id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| text
stringlengths 190
2.08k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01620v2 | MAGDi: Structured Distillation of Multi-Agent Interaction Graphs Improves Reasoning in Smaller Language Models | 2024-02-02T18:35:14 | 2024-06-07T18:13:16 | Justin Chih-Yao Chen, Swarnadeep Saha, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-agent interactions between Large Language Model (LLM) agents have shown
major improvements on diverse reasoning tasks. However, these involve long
generations from multiple models across several rounds, making them expensive.
Moreover, these multi-agent approaches fail to provide a final, single model
for efficient inference. To address this, we introduce MAGDi, a new method for
structured distillation of the reasoning interactions between multiple LLMs
into smaller LMs. MAGDi teaches smaller models by representing multi-agent
interactions as graphs, augmenting a base student model with a graph encoder,
and distilling knowledge using three objective functions: next-token
prediction, a contrastive loss between correct and incorrect reasoning, and a
graph-based objective to model the interaction structure. Experiments on seven
widely used commonsense and math reasoning benchmarks show that MAGDi improves
the reasoning capabilities of smaller models, outperforming several methods
that distill from a single teacher and multiple teachers. Moreover, MAGDi also
demonstrates an order of magnitude higher efficiency over its teachers. We
conduct extensive analyses to show that MAGDi (1) enhances the generalizability
to out-of-domain tasks, (2) scales positively with the size and strength of the
base student model, and (3) obtains larger improvements (via our multi-teacher
training) when applying self-consistency -- an inference technique that relies
on model diversity. | MAGDi: Structured Distillation of Multi-Agent Interaction Graphs Improves Reasoning in Smaller Language Models: Multi-agent interactions between Large Language Model (LLM) agents have shown
major improvements on diverse reasoning tasks. However, these involve long
generations from multiple models across several rounds, making them expensive.
Moreover, these multi-agent approaches fail to provide a final, single model
for efficient inference. To address this, we introduce MAGDi, a new method for
structured distillation of the reasoning interactions between multiple LLMs
into smaller LMs. MAGDi teaches smaller models by representing multi-agent
interactions as graphs, augmenting a base student model with a graph encoder,
and distilling knowledge using three objective functions: next-token
prediction, a contrastive loss between correct and incorrect reasoning, and a
graph-based objective to model the interaction structure. Experiments on seven
widely used commonsense and math reasoning benchmarks show that MAGDi improves
the reasoning capabilities of smaller models, outperforming several methods
that distill from a single teacher and multiple teachers. Moreover, MAGDi also
demonstrates an order of magnitude higher efficiency over its teachers. We
conduct extensive analyses to show that MAGDi (1) enhances the generalizability
to out-of-domain tasks, (2) scales positively with the size and strength of the
base student model, and (3) obtains larger improvements (via our multi-teacher
training) when applying self-consistency -- an inference technique that relies
on model diversity. | [
0.0226944853,
0.0312068034,
-0.0113660619,
0.0567800812,
-0.0329687633,
-0.0015925973,
0.0406379402,
-0.0314631723,
0.0289232153,
-0.0343291461,
-0.0116810743,
0.0057998518,
-0.0137578696,
0.000858457,
0.0302886404,
-0.0562180169,
0.0330669694,
-0.0520930775,
0.0018231131,
-0.0349331684,
-0.0151373334,
0.0043546637,
-0.0120037412,
0.0433342122,
-0.0123658273,
-0.0298302602,
-0.0356906019,
-0.0144800795,
0.0112844137,
-0.0107906405,
-0.0311278328,
0.0521667302,
0.0731891543,
0.0064186975,
0.0000021058,
-0.044839222,
-8.437e-7,
-0.0093071777,
-0.0449209176,
-0.0045642336,
0.0115638664,
-0.0036046531,
0.0330942348,
0.0031573712,
-0.0420298465,
-0.0249537993,
0.013873253,
0.0007100611,
0.076688908,
0.0649945736,
0.0134520316,
-0.0694579706,
0.0089217024,
-0.0025968351,
0.0106639974,
-0.0440089926,
0.0427692346,
0.073259078,
0.0223870948,
-0.017654324,
-0.0653111413,
0.0154673224,
0.0730708241,
-0.0190348439,
0.0033861154,
0.0494606569,
0.01326341,
-0.0084949471,
0.0119956648,
0.0877679512,
0.0116698416,
0.0071462719,
-0.0408510827,
0.0073436825,
0.0385143086,
0.0405396596,
-0.0629077852,
0.0066305296,
-0.0025804578,
0.0081535159,
-0.0008747256,
-0.0410614759,
0.0299999453,
0.0197959822,
-0.0451911725,
0.0763443932,
-0.0228078403,
-0.0117562125,
0.0262289979,
0.0125096729,
-0.036732778,
-0.0323453657,
0.0001173895,
0.0516114272,
-0.0218168348,
0.0242196545,
-0.0272739977,
-0.0037782353,
-0.0214994848,
-0.0107248612,
0.0128604965,
0.0290842541,
0.0227441825,
0.0524044931,
-0.0127156805,
0.0691000223,
0.0132635599,
0.0835964084,
-0.024842687,
-0.0119149145,
-0.0688747689,
0.0033652449,
-0.0280920584,
0.0828070268,
-0.001631818,
-0.0131204212,
-0.0298159048,
0.0165008679,
-0.0340155885,
0.0160194952,
0.0312427655,
0.016062377,
0.0002871405,
-0.029516479,
-0.034643352,
0.0840362012,
-0.0460614972,
0.0260143839,
0.0336874872,
-0.0453249142,
-0.0393199138,
-0.0008139693,
0.0133529846,
-0.0175235998,
-0.00183446,
0.0612296425,
-0.0284605157,
-0.0167364031,
-0.0215380862,
-0.0285896491,
0.0264588892,
-0.0847955197,
0.0079117306,
-0.0874862447,
0.0553821437,
-0.0019889048,
-0.0070393011,
-0.0709033161,
0.022385506,
-0.0332768746,
-0.0243847929,
0.0780809298,
0.0056412076,
0.0133666517,
-0.0003301712,
0.0148760583,
-0.0670400709,
0.0736647174,
0.0178425051,
-0.0105706528,
0.0185097009,
-0.0135943685,
-0.018348705,
0.0212644879,
0.0210134238,
0.0256069787,
0.0264724027,
0.000626167,
-0.031099949,
0.0474261977,
0.000156413,
0.038254492,
-0.0749276802,
-0.0285776556,
0.0470673703,
0.0533134937,
-0.002536098,
-0.0231979601,
0.0323572792,
0.0223480705,
0.0161802713,
0.0197711196,
-0.0819152743,
0.0240053572,
0.004524305,
0.005288898,
0.0036861023,
0.0125142727,
-0.0295545626,
-0.0371051691,
0.0072342595,
0.000471271,
0.0441952348,
0.0157662369,
0.0714170337,
-0.0006973681,
-0.03272653,
0.0426773988,
0.0480168313,
-0.0405635871,
0.0223117974,
-0.0530113839,
0.015174197,
0.0519992262,
0.0484971777,
0.0057217381,
-0.0457344949,
0.0005128295,
0.0175356809,
0.0227374528,
0.0193917044,
-0.0349625759,
0.010295419,
-0.061920397,
-0.0413041376,
-0.0197863914,
-0.010486492,
0.0219250564,
0.0284354575,
-0.0058935932,
0.0028983462,
-0.0629047155,
0.0175059605,
0.0112579847,
-0.0444904976,
-0.0119762924,
-0.0475681424,
0.0026812868,
0.0287507493,
0.0066369968,
0.0044890884,
-0.0045284471,
0.0095166508,
-0.0052712569,
-0.0151050519,
0.0046395841,
-0.0426685326,
-0.1132073477,
0.0409763008,
-0.0145354215,
-0.0336700082,
0.0091708964,
-0.0563130118,
-0.0317661427,
0.0610920824,
-0.012492395,
0.0424148738,
-0.0168343317,
-0.0020651938,
-0.0082624154,
-0.0248005483,
0.0273610465,
0.0796448961,
-0.0265806653,
-0.0352462903,
0.0035027023,
0.0477935709,
-0.0149662765,
-0.0309185125,
0.0286897775,
0.021382859,
-0.0007625044,
0.0240014791,
-0.0089145284,
0.0175770335,
-0.0491941981,
-0.0088275969,
-0.0368735194,
-0.0234483834,
-0.0075285812,
0.0184277762,
-0.0006465031,
-0.0123533597,
0.0293572322,
-0.0030180076,
-0.0185938794,
0.021625815,
-0.0017031898,
0.0278937705,
-0.0055202199,
0.0025520825,
-0.0425297543,
-0.0080309054,
-0.0380881391,
-0.0263011567,
0.0683465078,
0.0189744998,
0.0183006022,
-0.0292255487,
0.0123872319,
-0.0589009225,
0.0296690855,
-0.025624644,
-0.0222080443,
0.0450181589,
-0.0257608127,
0.0125688864,
0.1047217697,
-0.0367992744,
0.0785591304,
0.0428130478,
-0.03117905,
-0.0784584954,
0.0290241055,
-0.0233145356,
0.009088208,
-0.0717388988,
-0.0002586733,
-0.067923896,
0.028653523,
-0.010189414,
0.000142648,
-0.0666027367,
0.0054624761,
0.0232074298,
-0.0252326373,
-0.011041102,
-0.0236204285,
0.0057184217,
0.0012911411,
-0.0386093259,
0.0044360487,
0.0990761667,
0.0255809333,
-0.0173608027,
-0.0229509231,
0.0088644,
-0.0211122669,
0.0721486509,
-0.000119865,
-0.0043378551,
-0.0187539104,
-0.018546164,
-0.078836292,
-0.0355206132,
0.0621806979,
-0.0047998335,
0.0429395549,
-0.0616873503,
0.0062140008,
0.0068569691,
-0.0399714448,
-0.0252289977,
0.0157680344,
-0.0286571477,
0.04276428,
-0.0115801217,
-0.0212493371,
-0.0459822118,
-0.0195580404,
-0.0037726983,
-0.0183405317,
-0.0265574027,
-0.0010860054,
-0.0209921524,
0.0255604442,
0.0205575917,
0.0159769971,
0.0086888801,
-0.0932507887,
0.0568378344,
0.0629549399,
0.0452331863,
-0.0646826252,
-0.0105858278,
0.0115423333,
-0.0166667923,
0.0015966321,
0.0057163471,
0.0168918762,
0.0622897409,
-0.0726368055,
0.0007712447,
0.1070184857,
0.0024076868,
-0.0070644454,
-0.0012053406,
-0.029941773,
0.0629289523,
0.0101680122,
-0.0017788826,
-0.0530582853,
-0.056559708,
0.0114591494,
0.0004994139,
0.049562525,
-0.0584950298,
0.0159754138,
-0.110288009,
0.0090007782,
0.0478465036,
-0.0124545312,
-0.0128335422,
-0.0572055168,
-0.0063066171,
-0.0227269344,
0.0087987529,
0.020447677,
0.0185531285,
0.0062260656,
0.0053934399,
0.01427479,
-0.0382812805,
0.0303900223,
-0.0248642117,
0.0203675833,
-0.0031368292,
0.0043583186,
0.0105037326,
-0.0610461459,
0.0484432727,
0.0435284078,
0.0034566973,
-0.012675846,
0.047231175,
-0.0182429608,
0.011917091,
-0.0108145429,
0.0417950004,
-0.0411413088,
-0.0190773513,
0.0225148946,
0.0962254778,
0.0048139719,
-0.0533897728,
0.0059617823,
0.0013143158,
-0.0189688914,
0.0559939034,
0.0402879901,
0.0030411629,
-0.0626640841,
-0.0648314282,
-0.0398460776,
-0.0442149341,
-0.0229457822,
0.031985458,
0.014490271,
0.0075667868,
0.0045241555,
-0.0603516139,
0.058407221,
0.0307213124,
-0.0190117061,
-0.0046610306,
0.0506634414,
0.0236216113,
0.0016518728,
0.0154715125,
-0.0465385877,
0.0061909878,
0.0207195114,
0.0070993765,
-0.0021754613,
0.0006297023,
-0.0147017492,
0.0021594404,
-0.0862156078,
-0.0871210545,
-0.0314627141,
0.0441060849,
0.0206479002,
0.0852504075,
0.0131715508,
-0.0015287363,
0.0366184376,
-0.0201569144,
-0.015338202,
0.0038307784,
0.0445765555,
-0.0414223857,
0.0355725661,
0.0547473766,
-0.0417487547,
0.0093115335,
0.0047907187,
0.0640825555,
-0.0612791069,
-0.0098980591,
0.0082407873,
0.0220892299,
-0.0147920167,
0.0392976888,
-0.0039380994,
-0.0417316891,
0.0170356687,
-0.043086499,
-0.0188638587,
-0.036382053,
0.007295365,
0.0211070869,
-0.0067723175,
0.0464433841,
-0.0294557214,
0.01710294,
0.0211635325,
0.0294852573,
0.0215158369,
0.0053833127,
0.0013346015,
0.0535352156,
-0.0146517716,
-0.0254950039,
-0.0091233682,
0.0084399702,
0.0230838601,
-0.0004985733,
0.0476366207,
0.0445702486,
-0.0076643433,
-0.0007719831,
-0.026043931,
-0.0686315149,
-0.0529246703,
0.0009742263,
0.0227133874,
0.0260740798,
0.06346789,
0.0201641079,
-0.0374829322,
0.0074657523,
0.0079462975,
0.0605088733,
0.0064870138,
-0.0573088937,
0.050335262,
0.0298195165,
0.0238051042,
-0.0182090569,
0.0527085327,
-0.0032684833,
0.0428593531,
-0.0101961335,
0.0093239006,
-0.0361802951,
-0.0658917874,
-0.0118436543,
0.037185546,
0.0151162464,
0.0378289782,
-0.0545715243,
-0.0774018094,
-0.0443826951,
0.0206822176,
-0.014046602,
-0.0043892711,
0.0331877172,
0.0426229909,
-0.0180815775,
-0.0563197546,
-0.0024178736,
0.0315228142,
-0.0372877643,
-0.0248366799,
0.0057231099,
-6.149915345e-33,
-0.0370479673,
-0.0513991378,
0.0528110564,
-0.0033291746,
-0.0292671919,
-0.0225436054,
-0.053338889,
-0.0096756816,
-0.0637577027,
0.0380353034,
0.0165795479,
0.0295464173,
-0.0040052533,
0.0173478052,
0.0058125951,
-0.0143654747,
0.0281091575,
0.0172893405,
0.001346969,
0.0194576513,
0.0175429564,
0.0051578954,
0.0583422445,
-0.0475533232,
0.006492984,
-0.0022777412,
0.0052815177,
0.0447721817,
-0.0520261079,
0.0495861322,
0.0215687305,
0.0529338233,
0.008844926,
-0.0417727977,
-0.0164240301,
-0.0171191134,
-0.0721050948,
-0.0645035654,
0.028723998,
0.0231402591,
-0.0714088827,
-0.0353506878,
0.0289834682,
0.0214754753,
0.0048861876,
-0.0750966072,
0.0372964256,
-0.0038102744,
-0.0238314141,
0.0595484562,
-0.0313842371,
0.0109516634,
-0.0383001901,
-0.0224066637,
0.0039439863,
0.030867964,
-0.0047125411,
-0.0187368691,
-0.0492681041,
0.0266647432,
0.0251483694,
-0.0149355847,
0.0548471063,
0.0235734787,
0.0232364722,
0.0587446168,
0.0086962776,
-0.0039633163,
-0.0444161668,
-0.032583952,
0.0218253899,
0.0922697857,
0.0178756937,
0.0537950024,
-0.0166142229,
-0.0014013477,
-0.0893208161,
-0.0025969078,
0.0317127183,
0.0632286146,
-0.0079076812,
0.0017747273,
-0.0108853392,
-0.048949115,
-0.0380688272,
-0.0088269617,
-0.0101419929,
-0.0530336015,
0.0168989282,
-0.013459608,
-0.0104765706,
-0.008756944,
0.0194195155,
-0.0723788291,
-0.0344994329,
0.055566892,
-0.0184049867,
0.0118826982,
-0.0143660475,
0.0281440113,
-0.0502468012,
-0.0345507078,
0.0175503623,
-0.014987451,
0.0073849401,
0.0368967503,
0.0641118884,
0.0039547398,
-0.0129289161,
-0.0290686693,
-0.0476909056,
-0.0262560267,
0.0137544051,
-0.0019791166,
0.0381977223,
0.0436056145,
-0.021854559,
0.0328321643,
0.025469901,
-0.0173990056,
-0.0281505827,
0.0203459412,
-0.0153659591,
0.0049612965,
-0.0283354484,
-0.0041363169,
-0.0642354861,
-0.0117184464,
0.0392581038,
-0.0274442341,
-0.0247572809,
0.0184581447,
2.686e-7,
0.0304206349,
0.0379970297,
0.0135567151,
0.0133403363,
0.0065633738,
0.0594400875,
-0.0368378535,
-0.0056223711,
0.0356755704,
-0.0546149015,
0.018892793,
0.1010846943,
0.0220011361,
0.0408411399,
-0.0548805185,
0.0292399134,
-0.0436564684,
-0.0257136598,
-0.027071666,
-0.0087891696,
0.0455222391,
0.0501737446,
0.0590312667,
-0.0085112117,
-0.0180995408,
-0.0461567789,
0.053792946,
0.0069176652,
-0.0049479059,
0.0110189216,
-0.063352786,
-0.0351135693,
0.0254842024,
0.0543431155,
0.0295160189,
0.0092131915,
-0.032352712,
0.0490814261,
-0.0402699932,
-0.0176317859,
-0.0079402989,
-0.0226705186,
-0.0043409783,
-0.0389738567,
0.066296719,
-0.0658887401,
-0.0435230918,
0.0306478534,
-0.0256982781,
-0.0154285729,
-0.0031404756,
0.0071772244,
0.0035752982,
0.0110499132,
0.0011237555,
-0.0142093329,
0.0198262967,
-0.021015618,
0.0085021211,
-0.010123075,
-0.0428726897,
-0.0815418735,
-0.0000858963,
-0.0212245528,
0.0196907315,
-0.0212790612,
0.0012025727,
2.32555532e-34,
0.0356467366,
0.0008856529,
0.0361806899,
0.0462658331,
0.0494084544,
-0.047586631,
-0.0483631901,
0.009812938,
0.0467998497,
-0.077606611,
-0.0355416574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01619v1 | KB-Plugin: A Plug-and-play Framework for Large Language Models to Induce Programs over Low-resourced Knowledge Bases | 2024-02-02T18:32:24 | 2024-02-02T18:32:24 | Jiajie Zhang, Shulin Cao, Linmei Hu, Ling Feng, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Program induction (PI) has become a promising paradigm for using knowledge
bases (KBs) to help large language models (LLMs) answer complex
knowledge-intensive questions. Nonetheless, PI typically relies on a large
number of parallel question-program pairs to make the LLM aware of the schema
of the given KB, and is thus challenging for many low-resourced KBs that lack
annotated data. To this end, we propose KB-Plugin, a plug-and-play framework
that enables LLMs to induce programs over any low-resourced KB. Firstly,
KB-Plugin adopts self-supervised learning to encode the detailed schema
information of a given KB into a pluggable module, namely schema plugin.
Secondly, KB-Plugin utilizes abundant annotated data from a rich-resourced KB
to train another pluggable module, namely PI plugin, which can help the LLM
extract question-relevant schema information from the schema plugin of any KB
and utilize this information to induce programs over this KB. Experiments on
five heterogeneous KBQA datasets show that KB-Plugin achieves better or
comparable performance with 25$\times$ smaller backbone LLM compared to SoTA PI
methods for low-resourced KBs, and even approaches the performance of
supervised methods. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KB-Plugin. | KB-Plugin: A Plug-and-play Framework for Large Language Models to Induce Programs over Low-resourced Knowledge Bases: Program induction (PI) has become a promising paradigm for using knowledge
bases (KBs) to help large language models (LLMs) answer complex
knowledge-intensive questions. Nonetheless, PI typically relies on a large
number of parallel question-program pairs to make the LLM aware of the schema
of the given KB, and is thus challenging for many low-resourced KBs that lack
annotated data. To this end, we propose KB-Plugin, a plug-and-play framework
that enables LLMs to induce programs over any low-resourced KB. Firstly,
KB-Plugin adopts self-supervised learning to encode the detailed schema
information of a given KB into a pluggable module, namely schema plugin.
Secondly, KB-Plugin utilizes abundant annotated data from a rich-resourced KB
to train another pluggable module, namely PI plugin, which can help the LLM
extract question-relevant schema information from the schema plugin of any KB
and utilize this information to induce programs over this KB. Experiments on
five heterogeneous KBQA datasets show that KB-Plugin achieves better or
comparable performance with 25$\times$ smaller backbone LLM compared to SoTA PI
methods for low-resourced KBs, and even approaches the performance of
supervised methods. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KB-Plugin. | [
0.00706085,
0.0330496393,
-0.011866522,
0.0419889092,
-0.0071523734,
0.0393429436,
-0.0173680857,
-0.0199511535,
0.0453921258,
-0.0506235212,
-0.02311562,
0.0517476872,
-0.0298141334,
0.0419823937,
0.0294323135,
-0.0013613937,
0.0319158547,
-0.0463426411,
-0.014150071,
-0.0158812907,
-0.0087898625,
0.0271330737,
-0.005644171,
0.021166509,
-0.0074257511,
-0.0175935887,
-0.0217977017,
-0.0182912182,
-0.0433076285,
-0.0286661237,
0.0024571761,
0.0617456362,
0.0348556451,
0.0336190686,
0.0000020505,
-0.0624894463,
-0.0284614004,
0.0080379229,
-0.0663050935,
0.0306313783,
-0.012163789,
-0.02177318,
0.0121127414,
0.006484441,
-0.0599139221,
-0.0261295158,
0.0299882293,
0.02595984,
0.0681987852,
0.0548551045,
0.0038022664,
-0.0206382833,
0.0371288024,
-0.011849354,
0.020531727,
-0.0027306515,
0.0200472753,
0.034638755,
-0.0048038354,
0.0388978794,
0.0102641685,
0.0388686769,
0.0270157773,
-0.0231305435,
0.0260747038,
0.041041024,
-0.0642780066,
0.0010576213,
-0.0179787707,
0.0982179716,
-0.0352640375,
-0.0361320488,
0.0018805431,
-0.0091470135,
0.0138757378,
0.0234765075,
-0.0412586406,
0.0214568935,
0.0117053771,
-0.0017725676,
0.0581254698,
-0.0145654641,
0.0374407731,
-0.0225702319,
-0.0234318338,
0.0874842927,
0.0315188505,
-0.0594360754,
0.0233427212,
0.0049087256,
-0.0273988992,
-0.0373393111,
-0.0545679219,
0.0302925911,
-0.0096664075,
0.039355915,
0.0051872144,
-0.0095493523,
0.038482327,
-0.0336214118,
0.018637646,
0.0407022014,
-0.034922827,
0.0547495,
-0.0736634657,
0.0413456745,
0.0068245656,
0.0069060749,
-0.017486766,
0.0089793755,
-0.0671789423,
-0.0092341155,
-0.055073116,
0.0452614725,
-0.0004343203,
0.0070334226,
0.0023171201,
0.0799721777,
-0.0051907566,
0.0474294238,
0.0261520315,
-0.0139741218,
-0.0058779358,
-0.001953386,
-0.0240951385,
0.0426500887,
-0.0491785146,
-0.0112594524,
-0.0229797065,
-0.0106590781,
-0.0171056353,
0.0123215057,
0.0091265123,
-0.0134798605,
0.0090599684,
0.0222203769,
-0.0053344686,
-0.0167385936,
-0.0457978584,
-0.0312893093,
0.0042468561,
-0.0445393212,
-0.0232772473,
-0.1040100008,
0.0414750166,
0.0209975597,
-0.0135749662,
-0.0226295032,
0.019187415,
0.0076721883,
-0.0056009423,
0.0695504993,
-0.0443747528,
0.0108605539,
0.0208970122,
0.0124861328,
-0.0370287821,
0.0769465864,
-0.0171214901,
0.006941447,
0.0191819519,
-0.0238127634,
-0.01495759,
0.0393928699,
0.0533514321,
0.033129897,
0.0160154067,
0.0435681231,
0.0481198244,
0.0318319164,
-0.0078533385,
0.0167457163,
-0.006767944,
0.0309660584,
0.0138666937,
0.0610107817,
0.010997247,
0.0349624678,
0.076220192,
0.0303776879,
0.0391353965,
-0.0214293599,
-0.0761099681,
0.0421331786,
-0.0510820933,
0.0236228704,
0.0111725153,
0.0280236937,
-0.0312521458,
-0.0381040648,
-0.0015491289,
-0.0174329747,
-0.0376049839,
-0.0014782023,
0.0661748499,
0.053312704,
-0.011605273,
0.0622877143,
0.0337231867,
-0.0307857376,
-0.0087536983,
-0.0504038408,
0.0597561151,
0.0488531739,
0.0459396839,
-0.0747153014,
-0.0190222785,
-0.005623939,
0.0056900205,
0.0466721542,
0.0268720351,
-0.0494790561,
-0.0348168984,
-0.0188394319,
-0.0160760507,
-0.059307564,
0.0197316539,
0.0105886953,
0.0476274081,
-0.0124059319,
0.0261649955,
-0.0297938734,
0.0034960127,
0.045822978,
-0.0533645377,
-0.0190037396,
-0.0020920604,
0.022927722,
0.0136717856,
0.0063788267,
0.0052123587,
0.0110342391,
0.052158691,
-0.0417102054,
-0.0374066457,
-0.0275165122,
0.0027959775,
-0.0946940407,
0.0456771366,
0.0355026536,
0.0039950088,
-0.0242755935,
-0.0409646705,
-0.0442527682,
0.0318997093,
0.0093969656,
0.0644375607,
-0.0502884127,
0.0020602369,
0.024636317,
0.0002059484,
-0.0274122078,
0.0834401846,
0.0203663353,
0.0136119155,
0.0411050022,
-0.0050493497,
0.0161748677,
0.0039741807,
-0.0231008269,
-0.0003496833,
-0.020335624,
0.0199305974,
0.0083820047,
0.0018086807,
-0.0698166341,
-0.0126928166,
-0.1015423164,
0.0224740151,
-0.0055034258,
0.0173602886,
0.0003920691,
0.0178038217,
0.0045988807,
-0.0156895947,
-0.0531705841,
0.012283097,
0.0024443038,
0.0348682813,
0.01525041,
0.030402625,
-0.0126878731,
-0.0068255961,
-0.0099922847,
-0.0101584122,
0.0498195142,
-0.0044653835,
0.0249930248,
-0.0547350012,
0.0326805934,
-0.0282426588,
0.00992388,
-0.0090344558,
-0.036076434,
0.0164936297,
-0.0556495078,
0.0222140495,
0.0506860726,
-0.0319470316,
-0.0139204189,
0.0614909716,
0.0104289753,
-0.0891409889,
0.027466543,
0.0013632041,
-0.021207653,
-0.0238736514,
-0.0273636915,
0.0036460031,
0.0715102479,
-0.0260017999,
-0.0200043619,
-0.0353884473,
0.0290605202,
-0.0009431339,
-0.0094997529,
-0.0413403586,
0.0010497179,
0.0208643768,
0.0257450994,
-0.0174441114,
-0.0548365191,
0.080135107,
-0.0364054292,
-0.0243343841,
-0.0134876026,
0.0107544642,
-0.050347548,
0.0817960426,
0.0019721061,
0.008328083,
-0.0139347464,
0.0098174224,
-0.0459896028,
0.0298143122,
-0.0083527286,
-0.0189476851,
0.0772604123,
-0.0150621003,
0.0335857458,
0.009228061,
-0.0364828221,
-0.070309706,
-0.0153156053,
-0.0207393691,
0.0006930281,
0.0008840571,
-0.0060662678,
0.0464939922,
-0.0101341605,
0.0080115767,
0.0396786369,
0.0055302237,
-0.0172340553,
-0.0050675576,
0.0086273793,
0.032969512,
0.0012402624,
0.0013713879,
0.0192589629,
0.0713016838,
0.0302745346,
-0.0116297035,
-0.0248762965,
-0.012627542,
0.0208672471,
0.0008361568,
-0.0460261665,
-0.031807337,
0.0106641371,
0.0029155486,
-0.069960326,
-0.0272755567,
0.1205500215,
0.0499149114,
-0.0382335819,
-0.0162753034,
-0.0271315388,
0.0302301832,
0.0504086427,
0.0667514578,
-0.0958284289,
-0.0315159597,
-0.0289584659,
0.0286904834,
0.01017348,
-0.0197638571,
-0.0096881352,
-0.1500795782,
0.0233483613,
0.0089413654,
-0.0647476837,
-0.02736721,
-0.0620992221,
-0.0169165693,
0.0022615229,
-0.032109201,
0.0099024829,
-0.018360652,
0.0117840134,
-0.0019876645,
-0.0128336996,
-0.0458670966,
0.0310634188,
-0.011702437,
0.0840380639,
0.0429457054,
-0.0055994228,
-0.0067265453,
0.0017690711,
-0.0034063633,
-0.0131841907,
-0.0235799681,
-0.0172112565,
0.0301234182,
-0.0011022404,
-0.0172848292,
0.0235250518,
0.0458843447,
-0.0531629138,
-0.0083022248,
0.0391018353,
0.1089217514,
-0.0183140654,
-0.0215544775,
0.0097183883,
-0.0352055319,
0.0098772142,
0.0783718899,
0.0463583767,
-0.014659116,
0.0040130741,
-0.0357779413,
-0.0388711095,
-0.04093723,
-0.0299113281,
0.0332040936,
0.0026970243,
-0.0042590327,
-0.0874548927,
-0.0113083674,
0.0522683226,
0.0193207841,
0.0281631332,
0.0289871823,
-0.002396248,
0.0025490783,
-0.0620583743,
0.0336501077,
-0.0683346912,
-0.0358695313,
-0.0431896374,
-0.0669738725,
0.0259780958,
-0.0543523766,
-0.0171832033,
-0.0390633531,
-0.0872262046,
-0.0473958887,
-0.0103116194,
0.0882642716,
0.0082597118,
0.0557726063,
-0.0324649699,
-0.0137184272,
0.0454473235,
0.048404932,
-0.0726164058,
-0.0401825234,
0.0261717699,
-0.0039339331,
-0.0102130808,
0.0620672815,
-0.057788644,
0.0077137146,
-0.0018144876,
0.0477896184,
-0.0292530004,
-0.0234541371,
0.0331985727,
0.0277774427,
-0.0126679465,
-0.0008237672,
-0.0023493834,
-0.0381927863,
0.0014429596,
-0.0049749068,
-0.0380403474,
-0.0467132106,
0.022830395,
-0.0073818364,
-0.0266320854,
0.0381451435,
-0.0360717587,
-0.0294097625,
0.012539329,
0.0173790064,
0.0065655974,
0.0320708975,
0.0230255555,
0.0533857122,
0.006833558,
-0.0266540349,
0.0290070716,
0.0214079618,
0.0236496776,
-0.0437085517,
0.0450943597,
0.0040913313,
0.0068562967,
-0.0392723083,
0.0127328793,
-0.0201834384,
-0.0577270165,
-0.0011317525,
0.0300217494,
0.0651965216,
-0.0081122788,
0.0331454389,
-0.0377595685,
-0.0317015313,
0.0089557497,
-0.0004557998,
0.0215354208,
-0.0099726813,
0.0414648354,
0.0350768641,
-0.0234194584,
0.0011936272,
0.0855325833,
-0.0083290888,
0.0432591401,
0.0353381485,
0.0192749295,
-0.0532181598,
-0.0241960138,
0.0072570024,
0.0296518914,
-0.0486952029,
0.0256872568,
-0.0241169035,
-0.0851640105,
-0.0255084019,
-0.0124134058,
-0.0718924701,
0.0259812456,
0.0259395931,
0.0566435419,
0.0220665317,
-0.0124956602,
-0.0438374206,
0.0471644439,
-0.0421080738,
-0.0530110374,
0.0330883227,
-6.31938857e-33,
-0.0218053292,
-0.0179578084,
0.0234427284,
-0.0060050646,
0.0073927697,
0.0260636993,
-0.0481743962,
0.0168778971,
-0.0076403748,
0.0069250255,
-0.0137300417,
-0.0113691399,
-0.0110360105,
0.0100430073,
0.0323634446,
-0.0330130681,
0.00294312,
-0.0043973089,
-0.0133210327,
0.0332271755,
0.0147859594,
0.0147755258,
0.0108134495,
-0.0083269197,
0.03862831,
-0.0153358923,
0.0138343899,
0.0355193466,
-0.0419111922,
0.0647912025,
-0.0216979031,
0.0562739037,
0.0390566066,
-0.0384575315,
0.0072490033,
0.0114547936,
-0.0809532776,
-0.0426847562,
0.0368319601,
-0.0259729903,
-0.0270191859,
-0.0270475466,
0.0353207402,
-0.0127347829,
0.0429892205,
-0.0088961525,
0.0243493952,
-0.033868894,
-0.0052769687,
-0.0057339631,
-0.0579675809,
-0.0097281439,
0.002159979,
-0.0221935213,
0.0304494537,
-0.0065630735,
0.015090283,
0.0232781041,
-0.0250879694,
0.0268147383,
-0.0038380835,
0.0537131019,
0.05147947,
0.0027149217,
0.0219800733,
0.0100697139,
0.0042670635,
-0.0075691976,
-0.0163525697,
-0.0097774994,
0.0184604544,
0.0332714133,
0.0522688478,
0.0370597914,
0.0244196709,
0.0208427403,
-0.0516552366,
0.0125859296,
0.044432357,
0.0041229795,
-0.0098894173,
-0.0145883327,
-0.0283171535,
-0.0191706065,
-0.055552531,
0.0005636,
-0.0535701998,
-0.0470167696,
0.0239661448,
0.0019497909,
-0.0218767375,
-0.0119117657,
-0.0007481183,
-0.043915417,
0.0059790029,
0.0558242053,
0.0034656541,
0.0004852297,
-0.0110756606,
0.0605220981,
-0.0644828305,
-0.0219870452,
0.0327553302,
-0.0375415199,
0.0216977019,
0.0483677611,
0.0452656336,
0.0029960007,
-0.0650109649,
-0.0089414483,
-0.0676036179,
-0.0005310209,
-0.0055483654,
0.0256374553,
0.005166423,
0.0426447093,
0.0233977698,
0.0185448248,
0.0170473903,
-0.0071571041,
-0.0268529728,
-0.0237332731,
0.0034396243,
-0.000556528,
-0.0376393162,
0.017189661,
-0.0693365484,
0.0071211811,
-0.0310020167,
-0.049995698,
-0.0107826563,
-0.0170207713,
2.772e-7,
0.0613251999,
0.0391693115,
-0.0035434375,
0.0200922005,
0.0207554922,
0.0187995713,
-0.041517891,
0.0010355412,
0.0376013145,
-0.034806896,
0.0226185508,
0.0468880981,
0.0239746179,
0.0335612483,
-0.1187511757,
-0.0145649835,
-0.0212210771,
0.0188056193,
-0.0811388642,
-0.0199309587,
0.0576535724,
0.0833589658,
0.0292503368,
0.0029806425,
-0.0003998722,
-0.0332902595,
0.0378953218,
0.0060662795,
-0.0217703748,
0.0367603488,
-0.0321640298,
0.0701870248,
-0.0209888648,
0.0551033393,
-0.0321500935,
0.0279888622,
0.0025057979,
0.052734714,
0.0089859003,
-0.0161861125,
0.0054024952,
-0.0433409736,
0.0239113159,
-0.0665609762,
0.0919504017,
-0.0726963207,
0.0046223346,
0.0084867841,
-0.0004242484,
-0.0454466641,
-0.0117500676,
-0.0622698851,
-0.0062280884,
0.0073496415,
0.0303743556,
-0.0168014914,
-0.0177347139,
-0.0606517643,
-0.0244884584,
0.039163325,
-0.0072705257,
-0.0544108413,
-0.0542598963,
-0.0249514133,
-0.0182018969,
-0.0495600626,
0.0311194696,
3.000026658e-34,
0.0346036702,
-0.0157408696,
0.0329594724,
0.0300443806,
0.0206251591,
-0.0298565645,
-0.0126903001,
-0.0213665701,
0.0252325702,
-0.093470946,
0.014504469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01618v1 | Style Vectors for Steering Generative Large Language Model | 2024-02-02T18:31:15 | 2024-02-02T18:31:15 | Kai Konen, Sophie Jentzsch, Diaoulé Diallo, Peer Schütt, Oliver Bensch, Roxanne El Baff, Dominik Opitz, Tobias Hecking | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research explores strategies for steering the output of large language
models (LLMs) towards specific styles, such as sentiment, emotion, or writing
style, by adding style vectors to the activations of hidden layers during text
generation. We show that style vectors can be simply computed from recorded
layer activations for input texts in a specific style in contrast to more
complex training-based approaches. Through a series of experiments, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of activation engineering using such style
vectors to influence the style of generated text in a nuanced and
parameterisable way, distinguishing it from prompt engineering. The presented
research constitutes a significant step towards developing more adaptive and
effective AI-empowered interactive systems. | Style Vectors for Steering Generative Large Language Model: This research explores strategies for steering the output of large language
models (LLMs) towards specific styles, such as sentiment, emotion, or writing
style, by adding style vectors to the activations of hidden layers during text
generation. We show that style vectors can be simply computed from recorded
layer activations for input texts in a specific style in contrast to more
complex training-based approaches. Through a series of experiments, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of activation engineering using such style
vectors to influence the style of generated text in a nuanced and
parameterisable way, distinguishing it from prompt engineering. The presented
research constitutes a significant step towards developing more adaptive and
effective AI-empowered interactive systems. | [
0.0159442723,
0.0386417247,
-0.0120710991,
0.030667156,
-0.0128320009,
0.0128770815,
0.0211616736,
0.0134086646,
0.0140392529,
-0.0430889726,
-0.0556594133,
-0.0430174656,
-0.0219074376,
0.0441896431,
0.0207328908,
-0.0441030152,
-0.0240586735,
-0.0076008327,
0.0226140134,
-0.0002658905,
0.0387914218,
0.0344151407,
-0.0062476466,
0.048461888,
-0.0072738989,
-0.0321869813,
0.0000322213,
0.0453670658,
0.0140883271,
-0.013954483,
0.0357898027,
0.0362852179,
0.0078069745,
0.0369762294,
0.0000017724,
-0.0154268416,
0.0329627655,
-0.0365043469,
0.0481870361,
0.0256749541,
0.0757290795,
0.0127998926,
-0.0363404453,
0.003780382,
-0.0261749253,
-0.028499119,
0.0595316738,
0.0817941427,
0.0621521212,
0.0791578144,
-0.0155323148,
-0.0284593217,
-0.0012995776,
-0.0210702475,
0.0153210294,
0.0241074283,
0.0027269477,
-0.0213206243,
-0.0131884739,
0.0084286118,
0.01851671,
0.0365422778,
0.0193973016,
-0.0701049492,
0.0151534481,
0.0153445257,
-0.0127564827,
0.0021265347,
0.0045227003,
0.0823024064,
-0.0013996018,
-0.0102914264,
0.003525442,
-0.0264947377,
0.0183669459,
-0.0116347624,
-0.0402442291,
0.0077944682,
-0.0104519082,
0.0153863514,
-0.0109566245,
0.0187801402,
0.0214813408,
0.0300339982,
0.0253631398,
-0.0017565887,
0.0140591012,
-0.0103205368,
-0.0355286822,
0.0110885873,
0.0009123593,
-0.0493595637,
0.0299368575,
0.0130706038,
-0.026757665,
0.0155118499,
-0.0454988889,
-0.0156790838,
-0.0153469387,
-0.0724638849,
0.0802262053,
0.0138493013,
-0.000191607,
-0.0001635865,
-0.0236657653,
0.032334853,
-0.0550938956,
-0.0160088502,
-0.0195239857,
0.014552407,
-0.0236278307,
-0.0321863219,
-0.011563058,
-0.0057878429,
-0.0194048937,
-0.0366915949,
-0.0377441943,
0.0237206109,
-0.0149724958,
-0.0003316258,
-0.004992683,
0.0290856306,
-0.0125947883,
-0.0167556722,
-0.0001133846,
0.0079520736,
-0.0286052823,
0.0083249053,
0.0113038532,
-0.0083814571,
0.0073764618,
0.0360054113,
0.0213972218,
-0.0096331378,
-0.0308370013,
0.0103006903,
-0.038728483,
0.0130903032,
-0.0703120902,
-0.0249356925,
0.0068502398,
-0.0144311134,
0.0290611051,
-0.0470408127,
-0.007881253,
-0.0052326354,
-0.0126344562,
-0.0446668379,
0.0019660529,
0.0197396651,
-0.0107997051,
0.009673968,
0.0205320157,
-0.0175844859,
0.039330367,
-0.0035553903,
0.0269267019,
0.0470452532,
0.0531259626,
0.09601105,
0.0105013009,
-0.0108081847,
0.0592890009,
0.054755684,
0.0067967759,
0.0250026509,
-0.0715478361,
-0.0653143674,
-0.0070596063,
0.0514564551,
0.0406830572,
0.058969859,
-0.017182108,
0.0205473378,
0.1015913412,
-0.0078651356,
0.0279341526,
0.0490792207,
0.0570763163,
0.0140425665,
0.0150890248,
-0.0095940614,
0.0122019229,
0.0300978124,
-0.0158829205,
0.0217606165,
0.020671133,
0.0068193693,
-0.0428196751,
-0.0617710464,
-0.0032103853,
0.0089996727,
0.0034962327,
0.0103319576,
0.012099863,
0.0406736359,
-0.0395060703,
-0.0355025977,
0.0283326674,
-0.083360225,
0.016013978,
-0.0530784354,
0.0395070054,
0.1260631084,
0.0364661366,
0.005821201,
-0.0131670302,
0.0039645424,
0.0052362084,
0.0920827836,
0.0238679312,
-0.0248802155,
0.0127753187,
-0.0729625449,
0.0088362424,
-0.0191660132,
0.0118218204,
0.0160651542,
-0.0319969319,
0.0155244293,
0.0081316913,
-0.0052709756,
-0.0624583513,
0.0368397534,
-0.0256743487,
-0.082067959,
0.033325959,
0.0005511881,
-0.006590019,
0.0075050788,
-0.0564586595,
-0.0045614797,
-0.0310492087,
-0.0610704534,
-0.0498786122,
0.0398040302,
-0.0278491862,
-0.03078123,
-0.0289086085,
-0.0077505298,
-0.0052023791,
-0.0034052001,
-0.0368237458,
-0.0332962647,
0.0136728529,
-0.048972562,
0.0132088279,
-0.033482451,
-0.0108234566,
-0.0066399584,
0.0047127786,
-0.0347777642,
0.0236305725,
0.012516181,
-0.0432608388,
0.0223900247,
0.0342935659,
-0.0106340675,
0.0167707317,
-0.0220242459,
0.0045552738,
0.0447416529,
-0.002096724,
0.0338523537,
0.0137363533,
-0.0171068329,
-0.0561250784,
-0.078390114,
-0.0187369455,
-0.028117124,
-0.0028319927,
0.028967306,
0.017386876,
-0.0332580805,
0.0074268174,
-0.0604690872,
-0.0058236853,
-0.0172556471,
0.0005750922,
0.0298453979,
-0.0158491842,
-0.0087224953,
-0.0657912567,
-0.0047117458,
0.0060857655,
0.0342091657,
0.0469464883,
0.019290762,
-0.0539964661,
-0.0108822677,
-0.0185057446,
0.0000207494,
-0.0057434724,
-0.0678058341,
0.0217729677,
-0.0369670764,
0.0504341461,
0.0878807604,
0.0457144119,
0.0712261423,
0.0468715802,
0.0072706309,
-0.0532077514,
0.0204971954,
-0.0299154799,
0.0257852934,
-0.016841365,
-0.0200442392,
0.0280541666,
0.0491196625,
0.0370341912,
0.0194451548,
-0.0487984568,
0.019140698,
0.0248524267,
-0.0515707545,
0.0295885373,
-0.0257439632,
-0.0197585803,
0.0168182738,
-0.0004513163,
-0.0451382846,
0.0427407846,
-0.016835345,
-0.0190105531,
-0.0071558137,
-0.0069735148,
-0.0133955562,
0.058253061,
-0.0036884095,
0.0164988842,
-0.0059111305,
-0.0096065924,
-0.0272339303,
0.0045052408,
0.0222936757,
-0.0201918706,
0.0299987607,
-0.033550065,
-0.0186277516,
0.026279334,
-0.0465304479,
-0.0466056392,
-0.0252536237,
0.0021303783,
-0.0153310644,
0.0553442314,
-0.0644182041,
0.0206432231,
-0.0137824668,
0.0179087128,
0.0388377607,
-0.0429328009,
-0.0307364352,
-0.0018488785,
0.0261668786,
0.0547867231,
-0.0040633478,
-0.0247648675,
-0.0228159931,
0.0106356675,
0.0260856543,
-0.0020349284,
0.0162670203,
-0.0480484627,
-0.0072334302,
0.0503110848,
-0.0197317284,
-0.0331016518,
-0.0127769699,
0.0505655631,
-0.0610584617,
-0.0097781941,
0.1300036609,
0.0334420018,
-0.071246624,
-0.0138246343,
-0.0039958502,
0.060115695,
0.0073872451,
0.05627371,
-0.040111497,
-0.012436619,
-0.008962784,
0.0283271447,
-0.0132641522,
0.0166275725,
0.0125726722,
-0.1005313471,
0.0327414386,
0.013601453,
-0.0093179438,
-0.026675418,
0.0055651627,
0.0062467125,
0.0297337808,
-0.0182554275,
-0.0128006283,
0.003658013,
-0.0183694102,
0.0202330649,
-0.0206119474,
-0.0387934819,
-0.0409979634,
-0.0138113648,
0.0546130538,
0.0835184008,
0.0735525638,
0.007356598,
-0.0616198517,
0.0217365846,
-0.0000367093,
0.0312947072,
-0.0200265218,
0.0437764935,
0.0052305921,
-0.0086691491,
-0.049597472,
0.0455827154,
0.0261715092,
0.0236332025,
-0.0079178074,
0.0084551601,
-0.0532865189,
-0.0487627313,
-0.0440754481,
0.0066894726,
0.0374477431,
0.0289201792,
0.0527567901,
-0.0965628251,
-0.0547342971,
-0.0648866966,
0.0165755954,
-0.0840350613,
-0.0698486716,
-0.0215707105,
-0.0210546721,
-0.0257238913,
-0.109006092,
-0.0380652845,
-0.0054813009,
0.0575757138,
0.001643901,
-0.0395146124,
0.0146788107,
-0.0100843124,
-0.0070365495,
-0.0088536106,
0.0182079542,
0.0065406151,
-0.0157068502,
-0.0525618009,
0.0329518802,
-0.0865314081,
0.0112334844,
0.0127792433,
-0.0159666575,
-0.0645917505,
0.0291761905,
0.0477043316,
0.0068828696,
0.032928694,
-0.0098338295,
-0.1187497824,
0.0923301727,
0.0605327487,
0.0200959984,
0.0069080694,
0.0206628237,
0.049777966,
-0.0074124504,
0.0185751282,
-0.027832659,
0.0586438403,
0.0468133092,
0.0317684188,
-0.0050363243,
-0.0025616328,
-0.0127723683,
-0.0092500234,
0.0183297545,
-0.0398607627,
0.0011890667,
-0.0454130806,
-0.0133692268,
-0.027093295,
-0.031591583,
-0.0587998517,
-0.0078220787,
-0.0025140771,
0.0165194478,
-0.0501057059,
0.0089682471,
0.0239790175,
0.0202159379,
-0.0587061867,
0.0300193988,
0.014526397,
0.0525181927,
0.0129510146,
0.0349714942,
-0.0323350653,
0.0811842009,
-0.0203043092,
0.0166075751,
0.0052236388,
0.0530338883,
0.0321130641,
-0.00845215,
-0.0228283238,
0.0459124856,
-0.0406947881,
-0.0183066856,
-0.0213077161,
0.0223239623,
0.0385181382,
0.0000894924,
0.082353957,
-0.0355929881,
0.0098223202,
-0.0055819387,
0.0214961171,
0.0304527283,
-0.0444798656,
0.0004805279,
-0.0073179901,
-0.016619835,
-0.0408891067,
0.0529066212,
-0.0260187872,
0.0391792879,
-0.0079972399,
0.0083904359,
-0.0204067659,
-0.0089638121,
0.0622783415,
-0.00587,
0.0195935667,
0.014387995,
-0.0291659534,
-0.041240111,
0.0343590863,
0.0020125988,
0.0102923112,
-0.0293496083,
0.0382895768,
0.0437590405,
0.0015592801,
-0.0031726835,
-0.0510243177,
0.0134420265,
-0.063341774,
-0.0172152705,
-0.0302392747,
-5.713951306e-33,
-0.0226446819,
-0.0356358774,
-0.0160456207,
0.0573992431,
-0.0438620336,
-0.0119898729,
-0.0483316295,
0.0253582206,
0.0285370219,
0.0552227385,
-0.0321315899,
-0.0049826391,
-0.0019936967,
0.0487143621,
0.0220853593,
0.0146108503,
0.0625858828,
-0.0009500777,
-0.0363021642,
0.0505651012,
0.0481233187,
0.0006677347,
0.0244816691,
-0.084129028,
0.002237895,
-0.0313059799,
-0.0341830701,
0.0073999143,
0.0178368036,
0.0359999277,
-0.013870935,
0.0319274478,
0.0076459795,
-0.0399199501,
-0.0029534746,
0.0277245287,
0.002054027,
-0.0299803205,
-0.0159583464,
0.0201064162,
-0.0373572186,
-0.0527289249,
0.0494707711,
0.0132346721,
-0.0272182301,
0.0251722448,
0.0405025519,
0.003974861,
0.0010357475,
-0.1381399184,
-0.0849304497,
0.0241307449,
-0.0141768111,
-0.0310715064,
0.005043617,
-0.0041703847,
-0.0059475261,
0.0012493781,
-0.0699006543,
0.0057280371,
-0.0104386155,
0.0191968139,
0.0163593777,
0.0794515014,
0.0075510116,
0.0558695458,
0.0308798086,
0.0649861023,
-0.0917828158,
0.0300400313,
0.0404000655,
0.0082849367,
0.0059538856,
0.0507362373,
-0.0036682601,
-0.0134283826,
0.0142862406,
0.0252926033,
0.0550719909,
-0.0273309853,
0.0487854518,
0.0260351859,
-0.0108105047,
-0.004579369,
-0.0495130867,
-0.0236707926,
-0.0263206922,
-0.0090747215,
-0.0000629527,
0.0221672207,
-0.002865938,
-0.0413020998,
-0.0015422514,
0.0275300499,
-0.0263163801,
0.0114110187,
-0.0719765499,
0.074213624,
-0.0109097734,
-0.036598932,
-0.0049684714,
-0.0087801619,
0.0215884615,
0.0079619922,
0.0036602761,
0.0185210966,
0.0316440128,
0.0596410595,
-0.0667253286,
0.0033379823,
-0.0241806712,
0.0195397325,
0.0239206553,
-0.0260648429,
0.0095280902,
-0.0240040086,
-0.0349961668,
0.0272285528,
-0.0075045945,
0.0479051061,
0.0024066032,
-0.0395451076,
0.0022017916,
0.0097350739,
-0.0820191279,
-0.0037350978,
-0.0271917339,
0.0124359122,
-0.0002371461,
-0.0678015277,
-0.0155954249,
0.007036957,
2.494e-7,
-0.0055462406,
0.0585142262,
0.0028118,
0.0670713857,
0.0303935111,
0.0474737696,
0.0428462587,
0.0135700852,
0.0258519072,
0.0305097476,
0.0060185143,
0.0199065469,
0.0544607379,
-0.0056411084,
-0.1055639684,
-0.0080842823,
-0.0429526679,
0.0602377653,
-0.0320439599,
-0.0039110743,
0.0708665103,
0.0389364399,
0.0164844524,
-0.0076359096,
0.0539026968,
-0.0190334804,
0.0646503642,
-0.0090128584,
0.035767179,
0.0183885414,
0.0238971692,
-0.0313897394,
-0.0254833363,
-0.0293742064,
-0.0098279826,
-0.0289168339,
-0.019771859,
0.0635536835,
0.011722195,
-0.0128092412,
0.0069115036,
0.0218662824,
0.0242380612,
-0.0390839465,
0.0432284065,
-0.0001668239,
-0.0211542025,
-0.0544053428,
0.0243352596,
-0.0268078633,
0.0081149656,
-0.0566180535,
-0.0309996735,
0.0216584876,
0.0094888881,
-0.0187369641,
-0.0279278848,
-0.0769380927,
-0.0573227964,
-0.0355100855,
-0.0299055874,
-0.0203775875,
-0.0530003645,
0.051546175,
-0.0032512131,
-0.0066318503,
0.0136316093,
2.068267846e-34,
0.0246912222,
-0.0372521095,
-0.0065058027,
0.0359936208,
0.0445436724,
0.0428832881,
0.0210873056,
0.0092544649,
0.0533942841,
-0.1056307256,
-0.0102176368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01613v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01613v1 | Nomic Embed: Training a Reproducible Long Context Text Embedder | 2024-02-02T18:23:18 | 2024-02-02T18:23:18 | Zach Nussbaum, John X. Morris, Brandon Duderstadt, Andriy Mulyar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This technical report describes the training of nomic-embed-text-v1, the
first fully reproducible, open-source, open-weights, open-data, 8192 context
length English text embedding model that outperforms both OpenAI Ada-002 and
OpenAI text-embedding-3-small on short and long-context tasks. We release the
training code and model weights under an Apache 2 license. In contrast with
other open-source models, we release a training data loader with 235 million
curated text pairs that allows for the full replication of nomic-embed-text-v1.
You can find code and data to replicate the model at
https://github.com/nomic-ai/contrastors | Nomic Embed: Training a Reproducible Long Context Text Embedder: This technical report describes the training of nomic-embed-text-v1, the
first fully reproducible, open-source, open-weights, open-data, 8192 context
length English text embedding model that outperforms both OpenAI Ada-002 and
OpenAI text-embedding-3-small on short and long-context tasks. We release the
training code and model weights under an Apache 2 license. In contrast with
other open-source models, we release a training data loader with 235 million
curated text pairs that allows for the full replication of nomic-embed-text-v1.
You can find code and data to replicate the model at
https://github.com/nomic-ai/contrastors | [
-0.0287391413,
0.0207973514,
0.0171902087,
0.0802318379,
-0.0349175967,
-0.0157953501,
0.0354990028,
-0.0083404789,
0.0071267807,
-0.0168973673,
-0.0209429245,
-0.0096223168,
0.0227959212,
0.0165497363,
0.0477149263,
-0.0620042719,
0.0040856688,
-0.0039992318,
-0.0168455541,
0.0113050258,
0.0135878613,
-0.0051891198,
0.0206305664,
0.0266557168,
-0.0156869944,
-0.0302507579,
-0.0207844432,
-0.0052759899,
0.0582018681,
-0.048336722,
0.0131274816,
0.0162322111,
0.0565947033,
-0.0091269035,
0.0000017906,
-0.0187657122,
0.0047948742,
0.0211185589,
-0.0027559714,
-0.0172812827,
0.0598922223,
-0.0477060974,
-0.0004733804,
0.0362763666,
-0.0036957546,
0.0081161726,
0.0187924933,
0.0543395653,
0.0196734034,
0.0678324625,
-0.0072067222,
-0.0441131182,
0.0439369641,
-0.0676735491,
0.0116295675,
-0.00088265,
0.0208350811,
-0.0441850349,
0.0131078614,
0.0573401824,
-0.0551071726,
0.0139159858,
0.072874561,
0.0093373004,
0.0208989754,
0.0638132617,
-0.0371661745,
0.0357654765,
0.0075123534,
0.1268730015,
0.0278555714,
0.0201054588,
-0.0118050072,
0.0056993132,
-0.0298562404,
-0.0694515556,
-0.0073499526,
0.0206767973,
0.0084659401,
0.0535143167,
0.0269281138,
0.0295538586,
0.0255897325,
0.0022167938,
-0.0092755565,
-0.0122525003,
0.0027730539,
-0.0536440127,
-0.0193912946,
-0.023193635,
-0.0414699987,
-0.0056795725,
0.0344159454,
0.0226727873,
0.0104259448,
0.0225401334,
-0.0593016744,
-0.0792238414,
0.0423370786,
-0.0434173308,
-0.0139311589,
0.035614036,
-0.0513760112,
0.0567864627,
-0.0551103354,
0.0284946449,
-0.0240940079,
-0.0063837944,
-0.0244810712,
-0.0440502353,
-0.0120715043,
0.0129956668,
-0.0273045711,
-0.0029747083,
-0.0824515522,
-0.0704655796,
-0.0168102495,
0.0100802816,
-0.0061221034,
0.0394290909,
0.0246465039,
0.0217611976,
-0.0298925191,
-0.0005438769,
0.0093139736,
0.0100173792,
-0.0449713618,
0.0079590082,
-0.0168692525,
-0.0198142491,
-0.016699234,
0.0385840647,
0.0269723739,
-0.047335729,
-0.0132640395,
0.0374391302,
-0.0126068657,
-0.0564927235,
-0.0424161479,
0.000878731,
-0.0434569009,
-0.0213338528,
-0.0574337915,
-0.0626179576,
0.0071334513,
-0.0316151716,
0.012055343,
-0.0203832258,
0.0112292152,
0.0330987498,
-0.0252189394,
0.0784426033,
0.0062133074,
-0.0601551831,
0.0155439563,
0.0345353633,
0.0351984389,
0.0568730682,
0.0121255759,
-0.0077162329,
0.0473335683,
0.0308155864,
-0.0340670757,
-0.0046118414,
0.0224467013,
0.0073975502,
-0.0217401795,
0.028015459,
0.036067117,
0.0686173066,
0.0583931282,
0.0795296431,
-0.0131246159,
-0.0531882942,
0.0161972865,
0.0380826406,
0.0887786299,
0.0025565538,
0.0667340085,
0.0104754735,
-0.0400426909,
-0.0089802463,
-0.0181263778,
0.0004089059,
-0.0048184795,
0.0279500242,
0.0660662875,
0.0314446054,
-0.041224625,
-0.0092508616,
0.0020260639,
-0.0741142929,
0.0185900014,
-0.0235022027,
0.0400217734,
-0.012002958,
-0.0713432357,
-0.0186266843,
0.0143211894,
-0.0148081277,
0.0223147552,
0.0118479682,
0.0426994786,
0.0855445787,
0.027225025,
-0.0448770598,
0.0312865265,
-0.0363926217,
0.0169922952,
0.0596592315,
-0.0260542314,
-0.0198786613,
0.0503091328,
-0.0819664001,
-0.007110395,
-0.0239395201,
0.0120619778,
0.012386064,
0.0031327899,
0.0801870227,
0.0586497523,
0.0085634189,
0.0139386384,
0.0391008519,
-0.0466320626,
-0.0493061692,
0.0009935787,
0.0096033318,
0.0078787114,
0.0439686961,
-0.0121773193,
0.0101731587,
0.033211574,
-0.0804449767,
-0.0311290845,
-0.0150963543,
-0.0749655291,
-0.0778672025,
0.035877768,
-0.04306392,
0.0149055999,
0.0327337794,
-0.0369338915,
-0.0412865207,
-0.0066166311,
0.0233631358,
0.0239540674,
-0.0203623809,
-0.0310858525,
0.0144508136,
0.025789855,
-0.0060196612,
0.0653135553,
-0.0016142967,
-0.0003215901,
0.0399220288,
0.0534821749,
0.0101436758,
-0.0409990177,
-0.0314669013,
-0.0219561048,
0.0205799323,
-0.0009444107,
-0.0348385274,
-0.0105673354,
-0.0432524942,
-0.0154379271,
-0.1040510386,
0.014187173,
-0.018453503,
-0.0157031026,
0.0165188145,
0.0004576404,
0.0078527033,
0.002484994,
-0.0326001421,
0.0025146652,
-0.0287395045,
0.0056298506,
0.022417767,
0.003272759,
0.0144966822,
-0.04456985,
-0.0034827006,
-0.0167491473,
0.0504810922,
-0.0271066558,
0.0073240213,
-0.035776794,
0.0266360696,
0.0227924995,
0.0107504511,
-0.0242761839,
-0.0162222292,
-0.0163595527,
0.0046476205,
0.0744434744,
0.0545021519,
0.0279384442,
0.0115308948,
0.0067606606,
0.0252157655,
-0.0204912983,
0.0170141011,
0.01135231,
0.0401897989,
-0.0241102334,
0.0023747105,
-0.0233299378,
0.0510320254,
-0.0002570387,
-0.0111463256,
-0.0608864874,
-0.0297529064,
-0.0184840765,
0.0092532355,
-0.0066968487,
-0.0234640017,
-0.0378037691,
-0.0127318576,
-0.040139582,
-0.0121308807,
0.0541989431,
-0.037177071,
-0.0029066529,
-0.0470467694,
-0.0432654321,
-0.0693441108,
0.0307015106,
-0.0194541141,
0.0168931354,
0.0189194679,
0.0141627416,
-0.0030680744,
-0.0130304564,
-0.0186235122,
0.0018993746,
0.0535475053,
0.0131314881,
-0.0089129163,
-0.0144870318,
-0.0593607873,
-0.0272239055,
-0.0477050133,
-0.0438347124,
0.0390172377,
0.0364942215,
-0.0007837315,
0.0118194818,
-0.0308562219,
0.0093938969,
0.088248536,
-0.0030566629,
0.0031864317,
-0.0189345758,
0.0488364585,
0.0270181205,
0.0059516085,
-0.0259991866,
-0.0181778371,
0.0459351502,
0.0272069722,
0.0036236127,
-0.0250761397,
-0.0619552061,
-0.017522512,
-0.0309130941,
-0.0178876687,
-0.0084429104,
0.0063649397,
0.032503657,
-0.033379361,
-0.0022610994,
0.0991940051,
0.0130992867,
-0.0902282372,
0.0024338604,
-0.051473666,
0.017641753,
0.0011823298,
-0.0114695774,
-0.1040164158,
-0.0661316887,
-0.0139017459,
0.0100593176,
0.044571422,
-0.0184027441,
0.0062873475,
-0.0750172138,
-0.024973508,
0.0218251087,
-0.0410438105,
-0.0328923501,
-0.0534510575,
-0.0007088045,
-0.0311424825,
0.0097784251,
-0.0023518119,
-0.0098511931,
-0.0199143719,
-0.0112004327,
0.0200924259,
-0.0668309331,
0.0073255268,
-0.0620949082,
0.0531200171,
0.0321837366,
0.0256512426,
0.0073898663,
-0.0129374908,
0.0290464908,
-0.0647554845,
0.006687501,
-0.0264649168,
0.1036298275,
-0.0483220294,
0.0361406989,
-0.0278115701,
0.037463259,
-0.0400842577,
-0.0082458742,
0.0332040377,
0.0758874714,
0.0450394489,
0.0142906439,
-0.0421459973,
-0.0207806099,
0.0538314544,
0.0581034273,
0.0042245104,
-0.0299206581,
-0.0280315056,
-0.0214625299,
0.0183088016,
-0.037661545,
-0.0110366112,
-0.0400944538,
-0.0059826109,
0.0098857842,
-0.0543842763,
-0.0616236068,
0.0172484536,
0.0325283408,
0.0014726348,
0.0000627566,
-0.0562797114,
-0.0277671404,
-0.0389991328,
0.0043581463,
-0.0118934792,
0.0524364412,
-0.0454313383,
0.0391254947,
0.0527650565,
-0.0048203319,
0.0120388959,
-0.0069771204,
-0.0295491666,
-0.0445623733,
-0.0182346571,
0.0375954397,
0.0058570988,
0.0518229268,
-0.0068779415,
-0.0012585089,
0.0847663432,
-0.0001392236,
-0.0101163676,
0.0196002331,
0.0436417684,
0.0119994609,
0.0139180925,
0.0375204012,
-0.0291176755,
0.0006336334,
-0.0034813592,
-0.0056282072,
-0.0123075172,
-0.0018714835,
-0.0242666658,
-0.0766442344,
0.0064769057,
-0.001909987,
0.0080843335,
-0.0476386137,
0.033682242,
-0.0383442938,
-0.0030297956,
-0.0314187631,
0.0467306897,
0.0513405353,
-0.0119429072,
0.0090331314,
0.0224147215,
-0.0010688364,
0.0187975653,
-0.0201079734,
0.0613181069,
0.0489549935,
0.0293751303,
0.0071393582,
0.0302886777,
-0.0245717168,
-0.0243904591,
-0.0484151579,
0.0514336862,
-0.0147603871,
0.0333685912,
0.0158310495,
-0.0063466141,
-0.0017126689,
0.0291277468,
-0.0403899848,
0.0476638265,
-0.0218004435,
-0.0024872588,
0.0576692559,
-0.0152813839,
0.0221378393,
0.0022438038,
0.0013661996,
-0.0169502813,
0.03821145,
-0.0424521528,
-0.0246445201,
0.0114257466,
0.036213018,
-0.0001646788,
0.0267059691,
0.0928751156,
-0.0139672738,
0.0300573651,
0.0450001322,
0.0130726909,
-0.0363461263,
0.0164632741,
0.0328397341,
0.0721295998,
-0.0355380587,
-0.0041355295,
0.0072064796,
-0.0645106658,
0.0338879377,
-0.0188971087,
-0.0347084589,
0.0151910232,
0.0240015443,
0.0066518299,
0.0067297113,
-0.0094022239,
-0.0104754176,
0.0288363919,
-0.0242457986,
-0.060736306,
-0.0365435295,
-5.739131865e-33,
-0.002460188,
-0.0140153412,
0.0069063087,
-0.0635247603,
-0.0581492931,
0.0613775477,
-0.0416084118,
-0.0114928819,
-0.0236303583,
0.0151291341,
-0.0146923363,
0.0184229724,
-0.0051679909,
0.0585247427,
-0.0233163256,
-0.0210604277,
0.0307282675,
0.0145751117,
0.0138404854,
0.021841336,
0.0189871658,
0.0330503359,
-0.020050196,
-0.0563000105,
0.0364655852,
0.0143538481,
0.0143138617,
0.0123289376,
0.0358010493,
0.074542284,
-0.0430030152,
0.0442761034,
0.0242837407,
-0.0363214426,
-0.0250317547,
0.057589829,
-0.0903557912,
0.0038899251,
-0.033699479,
-0.040083915,
-0.0771853477,
-0.0622908995,
0.0195946321,
-0.0054547242,
0.0234692991,
-0.0288235378,
0.0596923232,
-0.0253090393,
-0.0241820794,
0.0229323413,
-0.0520363264,
0.039960295,
-0.0019281987,
0.0003451325,
0.0359232537,
-0.0058266521,
0.0523994863,
0.0530455485,
-0.0878925771,
-0.0218380261,
-0.0214892123,
0.0152557427,
0.0050363671,
0.0059917909,
0.0045374488,
0.0300826766,
-0.0191511046,
-0.0037617427,
-0.0322570652,
-0.0365084708,
-0.0083962977,
0.0088051073,
0.0467118397,
0.0607904196,
0.0479932167,
-0.0145254238,
-0.0488371514,
0.0143947266,
-0.0015903169,
0.0022065011,
0.0099718645,
0.0308047403,
-0.0356473364,
-0.0154885408,
0.0062685166,
-0.0478158519,
-0.0223782454,
-0.0556127727,
0.0164435785,
0.0476736315,
-0.0180096515,
-0.0071760016,
0.0288551003,
-0.0209990311,
0.0035182813,
0.0523897037,
0.0271514226,
0.0180134699,
0.0206295718,
0.0246402565,
-0.0644122064,
-0.0049370094,
0.0498109385,
0.0436376482,
0.0168330874,
-0.0113856401,
0.0578997396,
0.0228003766,
-0.0641535148,
-0.0062504252,
-0.018329462,
-0.0254826937,
-0.0162639245,
0.0430877469,
0.0113903247,
0.0018624521,
-0.004396305,
0.0671338886,
0.0187398158,
0.0032898139,
-0.0183774102,
-0.0495598428,
-0.0135810142,
0.0008177392,
-0.0156380571,
-0.0002126732,
-0.0257615056,
0.0537746921,
0.0503848195,
-0.0635199472,
-0.0017889766,
0.0112197353,
2.29e-7,
0.0033256488,
-0.0105091929,
0.054432407,
-0.0443101823,
0.028218111,
0.0310611855,
0.0091719646,
0.0738166124,
-0.0443704501,
0.0144821173,
0.0077010421,
0.029146336,
0.0229880493,
-0.0075289952,
-0.0882340744,
0.0240979902,
-0.0485898182,
0.0043757167,
-0.0417792238,
0.002388943,
0.0600436926,
0.121859543,
0.0134261055,
0.0326234661,
0.0160053745,
-0.0406677239,
0.0483186394,
-0.0132645098,
0.0418327078,
-0.030882284,
-0.047673054,
0.0254254546,
-0.0388356037,
-0.0447736867,
-0.0197798144,
0.0426395945,
-0.0207586326,
0.0737477094,
0.0222311709,
-0.0520898029,
0.0225913599,
0.010302959,
-0.0336654894,
-0.0233865026,
0.0716368109,
-0.039225556,
-0.0278188307,
-0.0026761089,
-0.0074869297,
-0.0116118034,
0.0303672329,
0.0210572239,
-0.0220862329,
-0.0081715994,
0.0073215719,
-0.0232180823,
-0.0028090817,
-0.1031137928,
-0.0298040882,
-0.0101316646,
-0.0621484742,
0.0206660517,
-0.0514777377,
0.0148205878,
0.0546021871,
-0.0486275144,
0.0347148292,
2.181355224e-34,
0.0262917783,
-0.0322066098,
-0.0105383089,
0.0363023467,
0.0187550653,
-0.0380798094,
-0.0112238778,
-0.0447751991,
0.0625484362,
-0.0650375634,
-0.0351265259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01828v1 | Retrieval Augmented End-to-End Spoken Dialog Models | 2024-02-02T18:23:09 | 2024-02-02T18:23:09 | Mingqiu Wang, Izhak Shafran, Hagen Soltau, Wei Han, Yuan Cao, Dian Yu, Laurent El Shafey | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | We recently developed SLM, a joint speech and language model, which fuses a
pretrained foundational speech model and a large language model (LLM), while
preserving the in-context learning capability intrinsic to the pretrained LLM.
In this paper, we apply SLM to speech dialog applications where the dialog
states are inferred directly from the audio signal.
Task-oriented dialogs often contain domain-specific entities, i.e.,
restaurants, hotels, train stations, and city names, which are difficult to
recognize, however, critical for the downstream applications. Inspired by the
RAG (retrieval-augmented generation) paradigm, we propose a retrieval augmented
SLM (ReSLM) that overcomes this weakness. We first train a speech retriever to
retrieve text entities mentioned in the audio. The retrieved entities are then
added as text inputs to the underlying SLM to bias model predictions. We
evaluated ReSLM on speech MultiWoz task (DSTC-11 challenge), and found that
this retrieval augmentation boosts model performance, achieving joint goal
accuracy (38.6% vs 32.7%), slot error rate (20.6% vs 24.8%) and ASR word error
rate (5.5% vs 6.7%). While demonstrated on dialog state tracking, our approach
is broadly applicable to other speech tasks requiring contextual information or
domain-specific entities, such as contextual ASR with biasing capability. | Retrieval Augmented End-to-End Spoken Dialog Models: We recently developed SLM, a joint speech and language model, which fuses a
pretrained foundational speech model and a large language model (LLM), while
preserving the in-context learning capability intrinsic to the pretrained LLM.
In this paper, we apply SLM to speech dialog applications where the dialog
states are inferred directly from the audio signal.
Task-oriented dialogs often contain domain-specific entities, i.e.,
restaurants, hotels, train stations, and city names, which are difficult to
recognize, however, critical for the downstream applications. Inspired by the
RAG (retrieval-augmented generation) paradigm, we propose a retrieval augmented
SLM (ReSLM) that overcomes this weakness. We first train a speech retriever to
retrieve text entities mentioned in the audio. The retrieved entities are then
added as text inputs to the underlying SLM to bias model predictions. We
evaluated ReSLM on speech MultiWoz task (DSTC-11 challenge), and found that
this retrieval augmentation boosts model performance, achieving joint goal
accuracy (38.6% vs 32.7%), slot error rate (20.6% vs 24.8%) and ASR word error
rate (5.5% vs 6.7%). While demonstrated on dialog state tracking, our approach
is broadly applicable to other speech tasks requiring contextual information or
domain-specific entities, such as contextual ASR with biasing capability. | [
0.0097549129,
0.0700295568,
0.0159913227,
0.0522064194,
0.0178400706,
-0.0235948451,
0.0150897605,
-0.0223145541,
0.0188360922,
-0.0673104823,
-0.0646580979,
-0.0460148677,
-0.0347727872,
0.0337720923,
0.0169574562,
-0.0315033644,
0.0497836657,
-0.0515900515,
0.0005919732,
0.0176496208,
0.0327080935,
0.0070226737,
-0.0222285688,
0.0382378772,
-0.0261196177,
0.0185229816,
-0.0240412056,
0.0374675058,
0.0114537096,
-0.033072181,
0.0223399494,
-0.0055560628,
0.0707647428,
0.0243572816,
0.0000018695,
-0.0544904061,
-0.0363880955,
0.0126503129,
-0.0691511258,
-0.0279169772,
-0.0022193876,
0.0169947259,
-0.0005749376,
0.0536271632,
0.0113184685,
-0.0255535021,
-0.0011560848,
0.0648274571,
0.0411664285,
0.0848931447,
-0.0036543733,
-0.0282138083,
0.0230863821,
-0.0420428403,
-0.0061552487,
-0.0578316003,
-0.0119991954,
-0.0252154525,
-0.0271587651,
0.047402177,
0.0312036127,
0.0375754125,
0.0039368235,
0.0035059135,
-0.011850277,
0.0010411055,
-0.0416258052,
-0.0004798582,
-0.0317037478,
0.0684586167,
0.0302059129,
-0.0063048615,
0.032133583,
0.0122741545,
-0.0176680852,
-0.0262987558,
-0.0426804237,
-0.0000879773,
-0.0013839965,
0.0178584047,
-0.0369515531,
0.0193612706,
0.0129253492,
0.0113713313,
-0.0380248651,
0.0314289145,
0.0143201584,
-0.0308706574,
-0.0105194421,
-0.0139757227,
-0.0022755223,
-0.0355655923,
0.0183230788,
0.019098958,
-0.0819579437,
0.0316938981,
-0.0172660314,
-0.003352907,
-0.0007941109,
-0.0108727422,
0.0151234688,
0.0294099338,
-0.0742897317,
0.0414342023,
0.0058818911,
0.0333906561,
-0.0173787978,
-0.0202837326,
-0.0322342068,
-0.0254647322,
-0.0167923886,
0.0070908028,
-0.0501859747,
0.0296450406,
-0.0693759024,
-0.0346860439,
-0.0046780668,
0.0115224896,
-0.0099418722,
0.0014657029,
-0.006582248,
0.041296199,
-0.0552511513,
-0.031269487,
-0.0087257354,
0.030791482,
0.0029891867,
0.0580281802,
0.0313837938,
-0.0238963272,
-0.0253913626,
0.0256422777,
0.0481828004,
-0.0162950922,
0.0069318642,
0.050798241,
-0.0316882469,
-0.0449319892,
-0.0365969315,
-0.0328345113,
-0.0275286064,
-0.0716077611,
-0.0151911993,
-0.0245030969,
0.0308520459,
-0.0187649727,
-0.0184282418,
-0.0250389818,
0.0288716275,
0.0039108675,
0.0175228771,
0.0333262607,
-0.0020700353,
0.0012262576,
0.0573447794,
0.007818914,
0.0024321193,
0.0462259799,
0.0238443781,
0.0345035978,
0.026463192,
0.007277057,
-0.0003339962,
0.0331339836,
0.0418216102,
0.0137331802,
-0.0120021338,
0.0278197154,
-0.0130940108,
-0.0047266707,
0.0176760703,
0.0608609989,
-0.043861758,
0.0120206112,
0.0441221595,
0.0449057594,
0.0649607405,
-0.0168413669,
-0.0010401248,
0.035317935,
-0.0270985737,
-0.0271064248,
-0.0195419379,
-0.0049012243,
-0.0238192379,
0.0210510399,
0.076025486,
0.0213963035,
-0.0179040115,
-0.0263291989,
0.0211427808,
-0.0107604852,
-0.0039060286,
0.0604972914,
0.0563286021,
0.0205407683,
-0.0856274366,
0.0430614874,
-0.0114887068,
-0.0617027767,
-0.001858265,
-0.0450639091,
0.0058222059,
0.0484628305,
0.0318361372,
-0.0293282308,
-0.0215514749,
-0.0391450524,
-0.0026031593,
0.0436343886,
0.0114035951,
0.0026768739,
0.0643811524,
-0.0628417507,
-0.0185355917,
0.034636803,
0.013995708,
0.0548507869,
0.0148352915,
0.0134385191,
0.0627145693,
0.017494956,
0.0261872131,
-0.0290140007,
0.0128057357,
-0.0252047088,
0.0132067278,
0.0039189188,
0.0413041413,
0.0490720607,
-0.0436080769,
-0.0072312118,
0.0489923805,
-0.0137245301,
-0.0039994223,
0.0341652818,
-0.0856767073,
-0.0375088751,
0.0198513865,
0.0496630594,
0.0314927213,
0.0118989451,
-0.0063305139,
-0.0863590986,
0.0180073306,
-0.0326597504,
0.052559495,
-0.0707221627,
0.0322932974,
0.0504502915,
0.0069626383,
-0.0255291834,
0.0183270816,
0.0358811356,
-0.0067472169,
0.0339797884,
0.0436531939,
0.0049900794,
-0.083787851,
-0.0131005654,
0.003621981,
-0.0130639924,
0.0489658825,
0.0360432342,
-0.0312338229,
-0.0442562923,
-0.0238072239,
-0.1070961654,
0.0196734443,
-0.0303282365,
-0.0042051305,
-0.0226634312,
0.0143103227,
-0.0060502486,
-0.0439157858,
-0.0094910562,
-0.0468732789,
0.0574139245,
-0.025603693,
-0.0380643122,
0.0524823852,
-0.0145271318,
-0.0645775124,
0.0365469791,
0.0256958418,
-0.0022980173,
-0.0294211563,
-0.0053886115,
-0.053488154,
0.0368157886,
-0.0082678702,
0.0477328114,
-0.0418327153,
-0.0084715122,
-0.0013661406,
-0.0090177422,
0.0074836616,
0.0419203229,
0.0261777043,
0.0040910398,
-0.0158818848,
-0.055696141,
-0.0942835882,
0.0493123494,
0.0034193066,
-0.0010537017,
-0.0263509341,
0.0431861356,
0.0277055632,
0.0240682792,
0.0103808744,
0.0223251618,
0.0070039644,
-0.0241548046,
0.0197480805,
-0.0343791582,
-0.0318333954,
-0.042791497,
-0.0607371926,
0.059905421,
-0.012168779,
-0.0287393536,
0.0202621482,
-0.0826734751,
-0.0271806121,
-0.0377461091,
-0.0406529382,
-0.0422280319,
0.0421120599,
-0.0320792645,
0.0163754765,
0.003594981,
-0.0557000265,
-0.0091045247,
0.0033179314,
-0.0107655181,
-0.0761768296,
0.0863624588,
0.0011696697,
0.0161875933,
0.001277949,
-0.0665296391,
-0.0612383485,
-0.0079187714,
-0.0189793762,
-0.0176219735,
-0.0156157361,
-0.0073587317,
-0.0388217978,
0.0077665444,
0.0220747273,
0.0477540344,
0.0125336517,
0.0081652403,
-0.0261231083,
0.0362157412,
0.0679504648,
0.0552693084,
-0.0367860459,
-0.0045917328,
0.0353205055,
0.0187469609,
0.0561258383,
-0.0286889616,
-0.026101714,
-0.0171588045,
0.0414260514,
0.0138600804,
-0.0144385425,
0.0314847454,
0.0390033908,
-0.0719040185,
-0.0253791101,
0.0950064212,
0.013156496,
-0.0074101547,
-0.0622185692,
0.000722467,
0.0067773168,
0.0321241207,
0.0207433105,
-0.0641620383,
-0.0549945012,
0.0570055619,
0.0343443528,
0.0138283633,
0.0263246298,
-0.0000041642,
-0.1073661596,
0.0458126925,
0.0208144952,
-0.0440961607,
-0.0410610847,
-0.024558248,
0.0001737859,
0.0265079308,
0.0435268581,
0.0381616391,
-0.0239099357,
-0.0229197312,
0.0346828178,
0.0005470216,
-0.015601892,
0.0081416443,
-0.034101665,
0.0702531114,
0.0730653927,
0.0217379183,
0.0211585686,
0.0019273501,
0.023771679,
-0.0029123719,
0.0155541366,
0.0134727499,
0.0393586047,
-0.0399067998,
-0.0166394599,
-0.0146746915,
0.0330077708,
0.0126473894,
-0.0117313834,
0.0154394656,
0.0079436908,
-0.0389544182,
0.0422051027,
-0.0106732482,
0.0027782656,
0.0252819005,
0.0428887755,
0.0072324108,
-0.0064504319,
-0.006861934,
-0.0022307425,
0.0124680912,
-0.0236675348,
0.0008170115,
-0.0038753918,
0.0040593026,
0.0110538546,
-0.0399756283,
-0.030825587,
-0.0183983203,
0.0390007235,
0.0137478933,
0.0185124408,
-0.0115878098,
0.0027541197,
-0.0426317006,
0.039483007,
-0.0450822301,
0.0269383676,
-0.0677710772,
0.0030700583,
0.0668228194,
-0.0764628723,
-0.0344558433,
0.0532758906,
-0.0613639019,
-0.0582161136,
-0.0261562094,
0.039635282,
0.0179447848,
0.0804868117,
-0.0058354987,
-0.021227086,
0.0394827686,
0.0024877477,
-0.0730022639,
-0.0035541886,
0.0551079102,
0.0303726867,
-0.0396051556,
0.0133141512,
-0.0868972838,
0.0509071127,
-0.0374696851,
0.036672309,
-0.028654512,
-0.0676304549,
-0.0203657597,
0.0083122794,
0.0713934079,
0.0233677533,
0.0042100032,
-0.0597588606,
0.0779898092,
0.000277951,
0.0119337551,
-0.0488364846,
0.0000170996,
0.0078893164,
-0.0218372717,
0.007037336,
-0.0074928799,
-0.0189989042,
0.0393300541,
-0.0224031042,
0.003459116,
0.0071367165,
-0.0080578998,
0.0147571182,
0.0054533766,
-0.0097244969,
0.054023508,
0.0420300663,
0.0464789905,
-0.0187600348,
0.0738568082,
-0.0067071095,
-0.0146366972,
-0.0025225151,
0.0060687931,
-0.0548457094,
-0.0402486734,
-0.0328199901,
0.0402861573,
0.0229532216,
-0.0093004163,
0.05430061,
0.0086217178,
0.0228845682,
-0.0411039367,
0.036239434,
-0.0110724764,
-0.0448967144,
0.0353069305,
0.0164131392,
-0.0164076295,
0.0432896018,
0.0305364709,
0.0223039947,
0.028206829,
-0.0167468302,
0.0122141307,
-0.0452791899,
-0.0608732067,
0.0084081162,
0.0471379198,
-0.0200494062,
-0.0150542464,
-0.0137774292,
-0.0700953454,
0.025167536,
-0.0066084662,
-0.0223423541,
-0.0330238305,
0.0213397536,
0.0258581527,
-0.0122646131,
-0.0078376103,
-0.0056080329,
-0.0408974588,
-0.0258261971,
-0.0142762959,
0.01139702,
-5.952675842e-33,
-0.0509423316,
-0.0113240592,
0.0464155562,
-0.0332785547,
-0.0441166312,
-0.0039015955,
-0.0388926491,
0.0098078968,
-0.00957976,
-0.0432382077,
-0.0124813644,
0.0221575908,
0.021718001,
0.0656038746,
-0.0378743298,
-0.0109600089,
0.0887171999,
0.0010310268,
0.0026926373,
0.0056427466,
0.0432523713,
0.0590247363,
0.0121627217,
-0.0636212975,
-0.0085468125,
-0.0213670097,
0.0059284437,
0.0015885236,
0.0114349294,
0.0437738076,
0.0050131842,
0.0357518904,
-0.0201225895,
-0.0486439876,
-0.0139107686,
0.0426319912,
-0.0743322968,
0.0055643641,
0.0111183412,
0.014460911,
0.0167699419,
0.0047110748,
0.0018022803,
-0.0024512738,
0.0148946419,
0.0171062909,
0.0052481261,
-0.0040928293,
-0.0232369211,
-0.012160968,
-0.0212518424,
0.0179889668,
0.0000150086,
-0.0516759865,
0.0300636645,
0.0511424392,
0.0478713512,
-0.0099602798,
-0.0444101542,
0.0022541499,
-0.0031240326,
0.0072053978,
0.0260949656,
0.0581800677,
-0.0184593014,
0.0654062852,
0.0374724753,
-0.0292204786,
-0.02900628,
-0.0738713592,
0.0140271131,
0.0618454702,
-0.0397115014,
0.0429731272,
0.0073463176,
-0.0191204157,
-0.0234277025,
0.0202140845,
0.0102574918,
0.030349141,
0.0156175904,
0.0294388812,
-0.0403740369,
0.007338251,
-0.0552702583,
0.0083110491,
-0.0341279879,
-0.0276535936,
0.0907152742,
0.0859324038,
0.0011750055,
0.0092070447,
0.0747412145,
0.0015030296,
-0.0003492796,
0.0269598458,
-0.0208350793,
-0.034806598,
-0.0497899577,
0.0588097721,
-0.0479876176,
-0.0350423343,
0.0797816515,
0.0278418195,
-0.0209038835,
-0.0276425239,
-0.0278602298,
0.0198589973,
-0.0705330968,
0.0380320735,
-0.0292326584,
0.057106398,
-0.0298909415,
0.0259130839,
0.0404234566,
-0.0062669637,
-0.0138984732,
0.085422948,
-0.0121980989,
0.0016902181,
-0.0462929085,
-0.0655728504,
0.0134986825,
0.0004431099,
-0.0347378589,
0.0392302163,
0.0260184221,
-0.0361651145,
0.0153741734,
-0.0219740346,
0.0082088718,
-0.0035378651,
2.71e-7,
-0.0252930801,
0.0033678249,
0.034733966,
-0.0046734679,
0.0009944083,
0.037748035,
-0.0161710139,
0.0087026535,
0.0439869016,
0.0084706433,
-0.0072789527,
0.0044424329,
0.0697436482,
0.0135717755,
-0.1069470048,
-0.0156777855,
-0.0618038774,
0.0197358932,
-0.0322597884,
-0.0403519124,
0.0252762325,
0.0925169811,
-0.0238223765,
-0.0202914719,
0.023928551,
-0.047408402,
0.0592823885,
-0.0259982347,
-0.0121315615,
-0.000648471,
-0.0018449114,
0.047361847,
-0.0301680472,
-0.0358625129,
-0.0196767524,
0.0611060038,
0.0038713522,
0.0690205693,
0.0100635476,
-0.0911520496,
-0.0134151932,
0.0493590608,
0.0070721102,
-0.0168416165,
0.0506288595,
-0.021741312,
0.0132173998,
-0.0445749573,
-0.0638102889,
-0.0306032468,
-0.0199857745,
0.0030919223,
0.0040873401,
-0.0020359454,
0.0047788611,
0.004823938,
0.0068201842,
-0.1331802011,
-0.0234061815,
-0.0054590683,
-0.0648761541,
-0.017876653,
-0.0486509316,
-0.0112258457,
-0.014483016,
-0.0308764912,
-0.0065756706,
2.163108429e-34,
0.0352606177,
-0.0078221951,
0.0057779839,
0.0503623113,
0.0398076735,
-0.0225605462,
-0.0352197178,
0.0074477624,
0.0159100611,
-0.0569690205,
-0.0219376143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01826v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Analyzing Blood Pressure Variations Across Biological Sex from Scientific Literature | 2024-02-02T18:15:51 | 2024-02-02T18:15:51 | Yuting Guo, Seyedeh Somayyeh Mousavi, Reza Sameni, Abeed Sarker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hypertension, defined as blood pressure (BP) that is above normal, holds
paramount significance in the realm of public health, as it serves as a
critical precursor to various cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) and significantly
contributes to elevated mortality rates worldwide. However, many existing BP
measurement technologies and standards might be biased because they do not
consider clinical outcomes, comorbidities, or demographic factors, making them
inconclusive for diagnostic purposes. There is limited data-driven research
focused on studying the variance in BP measurements across these variables. In
this work, we employed GPT-35-turbo, a large language model (LLM), to
automatically extract the mean and standard deviation values of BP for both
males and females from a dataset comprising 25 million abstracts sourced from
PubMed. 993 article abstracts met our predefined inclusion criteria (i.e.,
presence of references to blood pressure, units of blood pressure such as mmHg,
and mention of biological sex). Based on the automatically-extracted
information from these articles, we conducted an analysis of the variations of
BP values across biological sex. Our results showed the viability of utilizing
LLMs to study the BP variations across different demographic factors. | Leveraging Large Language Models for Analyzing Blood Pressure Variations Across Biological Sex from Scientific Literature: Hypertension, defined as blood pressure (BP) that is above normal, holds
paramount significance in the realm of public health, as it serves as a
critical precursor to various cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) and significantly
contributes to elevated mortality rates worldwide. However, many existing BP
measurement technologies and standards might be biased because they do not
consider clinical outcomes, comorbidities, or demographic factors, making them
inconclusive for diagnostic purposes. There is limited data-driven research
focused on studying the variance in BP measurements across these variables. In
this work, we employed GPT-35-turbo, a large language model (LLM), to
automatically extract the mean and standard deviation values of BP for both
males and females from a dataset comprising 25 million abstracts sourced from
PubMed. 993 article abstracts met our predefined inclusion criteria (i.e.,
presence of references to blood pressure, units of blood pressure such as mmHg,
and mention of biological sex). Based on the automatically-extracted
information from these articles, we conducted an analysis of the variations of
BP values across biological sex. Our results showed the viability of utilizing
LLMs to study the BP variations across different demographic factors. | [
0.0049384232,
0.0854228437,
0.0007384067,
0.0028861146,
0.0002329752,
0.0181041881,
0.0347655751,
0.0278634094,
-0.0061306562,
0.0003927294,
0.0239290576,
-0.0603706837,
0.0246534646,
0.0292100944,
-0.0071780477,
-0.0425423719,
-0.0227811672,
-0.0028696663,
0.1057922021,
-0.0222994853,
-0.0105170533,
-0.0092527661,
0.0101195062,
0.0353232548,
0.0516353287,
-0.0259250719,
0.0583971962,
-0.0315930881,
0.0188747086,
-0.0444002375,
-0.00919268,
0.0662951544,
-0.0020316187,
-0.0057013389,
0.0000018414,
-0.0832929239,
-0.0039375881,
0.0712630227,
0.023456702,
0.0096780751,
0.074693121,
-0.0513952263,
-0.0152819157,
0.0002157266,
-0.0225370582,
-0.068562232,
0.0385145806,
0.000442909,
-0.0051856148,
0.0127697922,
-0.0237517562,
0.0077311178,
-0.0256869756,
-0.0577025376,
0.0400914885,
-0.0576646961,
0.0728674531,
0.0171594843,
0.0248820521,
0.0332628712,
-0.0105818706,
0.0309420004,
-0.0373975076,
0.0417160727,
-0.0289030615,
0.0271852277,
-0.0347327739,
-0.0311307348,
0.0016981227,
0.0560842715,
-0.0195726082,
0.0191183332,
0.0591893829,
0.0095200837,
0.0024815793,
0.0084143709,
-0.0758729428,
0.0063606454,
-0.0332134292,
-0.0193677656,
-0.0063793706,
-0.0376105122,
0.0215167943,
-0.0276218504,
-0.0232507903,
0.0236519091,
0.0153381024,
-0.0153463846,
0.0259314124,
-0.0030535606,
-0.0399210677,
-0.0399847515,
0.0409927182,
-0.0229875371,
0.0041931071,
-0.0018528999,
0.0225670636,
-0.0519240946,
0.0794828162,
-0.0721313879,
0.0517060943,
0.0340511352,
0.0475135893,
0.0283075254,
-0.0075603547,
-0.0052408371,
-0.0455808453,
-0.0093444632,
-0.0485790819,
0.0132211214,
-0.0645989254,
-0.0097522289,
0.0068351687,
0.0006602523,
0.0140460292,
0.0216405876,
-0.1118842363,
-0.0212257914,
-0.0189815275,
-0.0248253196,
-0.0072489833,
0.0031357184,
0.0022839888,
0.0047498932,
0.0038294173,
0.048875019,
0.0024225547,
0.0247425605,
-0.0384193063,
-0.0206216462,
0.0283403415,
-0.0152250547,
0.0232201442,
0.0149803609,
0.0320400149,
0.0332024209,
0.0134922508,
0.0257755537,
0.0119085517,
-0.0154953618,
-0.0379182808,
-0.0051664542,
-0.0071028015,
-0.0937775001,
0.0680201128,
0.0303477552,
0.0168516953,
-0.0324185006,
-0.0002088717,
0.010880298,
-0.0353988819,
0.0309578404,
-0.0148236565,
0.0280301664,
0.0451731831,
-0.0040848753,
0.013692976,
0.0727744699,
0.0511971749,
-0.0554903187,
0.0166764781,
-0.0204160344,
-0.014378801,
0.0563588701,
0.024841575,
-0.0255741421,
-0.0355522372,
0.0095361983,
0.0324265845,
0.058431156,
0.0166579019,
0.032254152,
0.0205225423,
-0.0025679851,
0.0317041539,
0.0894271508,
0.0124210957,
0.0664162338,
0.0245084148,
-0.0434960537,
0.0110440319,
-0.0386108607,
-0.0108625628,
-0.0236340482,
-0.0067294016,
0.028747417,
-0.0312043037,
0.0176883359,
0.0091248024,
-0.0341611765,
-0.0546012446,
-0.0023812097,
-0.0145233525,
-0.0411475748,
0.0490463078,
-0.040908739,
0.014558265,
0.0346941054,
0.0181538146,
-0.0356714316,
-0.0000615123,
0.0091391252,
-0.0026528966,
0.0132048614,
-0.0111014564,
-0.0380535685,
0.0470712855,
-0.0207234267,
0.0247713942,
0.0102889445,
0.015971452,
0.0084511479,
0.0290272348,
-0.0316711552,
-0.0023396271,
0.0356863141,
0.0260069631,
-0.0048913262,
-0.0114486478,
0.0393285565,
0.0028003685,
-0.0398011543,
-0.0712843835,
0.0165669285,
-0.1002538353,
-0.007328352,
0.0335413702,
-0.0355216675,
0.0127965566,
-0.0252974089,
-0.0136891697,
0.0344593152,
-0.0180924255,
-0.046273116,
-0.0476947613,
-0.0260503087,
0.0497963168,
0.0318891369,
0.0353151783,
-0.0864492208,
-0.0158404876,
-0.0274136979,
-0.0383087024,
-0.0128222927,
-0.0173295718,
-0.028808536,
0.0112533728,
0.0115324315,
-0.0219767895,
0.0175881926,
0.0218401272,
-0.0223663896,
-0.0043984661,
0.0306005627,
-0.0023930813,
0.0318989493,
-0.0545936488,
0.007021836,
-0.0172891356,
-0.0164625347,
-0.0098260855,
0.0205638483,
0.0070399069,
0.0212377012,
-0.0068384823,
0.0000398941,
-0.0307342783,
-0.0752007291,
-0.0026221729,
0.0319246016,
0.0256339703,
0.0086912354,
0.0280588102,
-0.0340608917,
0.0061383029,
-0.0206626058,
-0.0059436485,
0.0187836792,
0.0530369356,
0.0509283356,
-0.0152210556,
0.0339198709,
-0.0304705016,
-0.0142693361,
-0.0579093955,
0.0362070985,
0.0346450992,
0.0113851922,
0.033067245,
0.0019420115,
-0.0479244292,
-0.0268203765,
0.0259843841,
-0.0438111909,
0.0056868321,
0.0141275246,
0.0730860308,
0.0465447232,
0.0065251184,
-0.043813888,
0.0458373353,
-0.010750182,
-0.0084140571,
-0.0014805656,
-0.0524554253,
0.0106536057,
0.0212171879,
-0.0548736453,
-0.0215240978,
0.057994578,
0.0097505748,
-0.0078772539,
0.0089930817,
0.0207689647,
-0.0350030027,
0.008086388,
-0.0928170085,
0.0175448079,
-0.0301253535,
0.0512880683,
0.0186064634,
-0.0283304919,
0.0465110652,
-0.0045967973,
0.0276962835,
-0.045671057,
0.0011421546,
-0.0446852297,
-0.0320976228,
-0.0301480256,
0.0095373495,
0.0310183018,
0.0050667012,
0.0070915469,
-0.0005226679,
0.0350328535,
-0.0541522242,
0.0641796142,
-0.057289511,
0.020872429,
0.0191360451,
-0.0323908888,
-0.0060147219,
-0.011710804,
-0.0424473695,
-0.0016853836,
0.0325759873,
-0.0329208337,
-0.0146912131,
0.0490955785,
0.0119970087,
0.0281061437,
-0.0231980756,
-0.0169670079,
0.0072912415,
-0.0310554951,
0.064976722,
-0.0391945355,
-0.0001683858,
-0.0327088311,
0.03053388,
0.0469506085,
-0.0172459725,
0.0327799842,
0.0036473272,
0.050041385,
-0.027310472,
-0.0260948297,
-0.0097900396,
-0.0249739829,
-0.0279586948,
-0.0293092281,
0.0159580465,
0.1210441962,
0.0291663669,
-0.0520376302,
-0.0237984844,
-0.063059479,
-0.0083713476,
-0.0166930296,
0.0019027462,
-0.0416280255,
0.0052726143,
0.008206646,
0.0412484035,
0.0017637978,
-0.029848,
-0.0270937961,
-0.0384735465,
0.0116457371,
0.0356065147,
-0.037377689,
0.0306811426,
-0.083969593,
0.0310976151,
-0.0582488477,
-0.0136987716,
-0.0320838913,
-0.0262153596,
0.0077501372,
0.0036635883,
-0.1004030108,
-0.078851752,
0.0591952503,
-0.0224879868,
0.0331119411,
0.0449221544,
0.0482050814,
-0.0216905493,
0.0098281465,
0.0400211029,
-0.026862165,
-0.0412102602,
-0.0446517691,
0.0558368899,
0.0587423071,
-0.0076095909,
-0.0711328611,
0.0912941322,
-0.0267561097,
0.0220899805,
0.0050754105,
0.0505475849,
0.0363264494,
-0.0453559831,
-0.0393875204,
0.0287307631,
0.0189768691,
0.0614567325,
-0.0106821936,
-0.0140585285,
-0.0119988639,
0.0004712737,
-0.0332898051,
0.0579901263,
-0.0693514869,
-0.0191933755,
-0.0388963521,
-0.0595861077,
-0.0065927249,
0.0058617848,
0.0654890463,
-0.0101434598,
0.0361636579,
0.0103143752,
0.0913448036,
-0.0191333424,
-0.0195508413,
0.0435174555,
0.0237763021,
0.0041803792,
-0.0074111251,
0.0039948332,
0.0659335703,
0.0488199703,
-0.0276290029,
0.0735206157,
-0.0550035648,
-0.0137339197,
-0.0127645917,
0.038615454,
0.0284770653,
0.0038410965,
0.0014413799,
-0.0154764429,
0.0248848815,
0.0188326258,
-0.0070256647,
-0.0049421461,
-0.0653113797,
0.0135839051,
0.0271984879,
-0.0072485902,
-0.003067127,
0.0455929637,
-0.025102431,
-0.0091599515,
0.0009911549,
-0.0353312641,
0.0319798253,
0.0477387682,
-0.0017908107,
-0.010319625,
-0.0280678794,
-0.0267032478,
-0.0056686038,
-0.0686598867,
0.0134547483,
-0.0248038135,
0.0372001491,
-0.0100403968,
0.0080164373,
-0.0252421219,
-0.0472451448,
-0.0470757298,
-0.0337619372,
-0.0756671727,
0.0691052526,
-0.0245168339,
0.0073555871,
0.0512223281,
-0.0305939224,
0.0132711791,
-0.0066806069,
-0.0158733148,
0.0374933928,
0.0006964497,
0.016949838,
-0.024383368,
0.0267708451,
-0.0392364301,
0.0062348084,
-0.0585023388,
0.0110385399,
-0.0007861963,
0.0636098385,
0.0066468315,
-0.0022212754,
0.0412201621,
-0.0180594493,
-0.0156202493,
-0.053769391,
0.0004925273,
-0.0210729595,
0.0701669604,
0.0602020025,
0.0023186824,
-0.0137481168,
-0.0430551618,
0.0841225237,
0.032532312,
-0.0022318137,
0.024583621,
-0.106807217,
-0.0002294068,
0.0184874833,
0.0109544815,
-0.0163914803,
-0.0895249918,
-0.0029651085,
-0.074848637,
-0.055474598,
0.0383158475,
0.021114463,
-0.0220012479,
0.0190832298,
-0.0769813731,
0.0752257705,
-0.0617663376,
-0.0371651649,
-0.0210408568,
0.0549781546,
-0.0535370894,
-0.0222032089,
0.0084264418,
-5.403398189e-33,
0.003429126,
-0.0228224546,
-0.0034184365,
-0.0258411113,
0.004262466,
0.0476620197,
-0.0354321674,
0.0124980323,
0.0394765772,
0.091260992,
-0.0275649577,
-0.0127846962,
0.0380922258,
0.0055446499,
0.0377784111,
-0.024713859,
0.0064275302,
-0.0036279273,
0.0293990802,
-0.0327456407,
0.0008280274,
0.0475599878,
0.0220888462,
-0.0634412318,
0.0396180786,
0.0308421254,
0.0070442837,
-0.0299105272,
0.0193887334,
0.0504927561,
-0.007358592,
0.079103075,
0.009203814,
-0.0080466615,
-0.0055048517,
0.012538203,
-0.0662766993,
-0.0341356993,
0.0407679714,
-0.056493748,
0.0346410014,
0.0197153687,
0.0649025738,
-0.0013773609,
-0.0189509392,
-0.0608090796,
0.0465672947,
-0.0797631368,
0.0021529512,
-0.0142550375,
-0.0186038669,
0.0183548816,
-0.0017861783,
0.0538165085,
0.0201314874,
0.0003784309,
-0.0742907003,
0.0191208143,
-0.0623526163,
-0.0139544802,
0.0609541088,
0.0268503781,
-0.0061034667,
-0.0165121313,
0.0502071083,
0.004274955,
-0.0070328107,
-0.0396038666,
0.001242705,
-0.0183503348,
-0.0207116231,
0.0106554022,
0.0438227542,
0.0416460931,
0.0134062786,
-0.042188514,
-0.101905182,
0.0406762958,
-0.0013522278,
-0.0243207179,
0.0035368542,
-0.0145827699,
-0.0028381099,
0.0006607279,
-0.0036450268,
-0.0211849045,
-0.0171889439,
-0.0483476147,
-0.0194547661,
-0.0130076231,
0.0020489569,
0.0100624971,
0.0311047845,
-0.0276069492,
-0.0651408434,
-0.0179152787,
0.0379235335,
-0.0391441472,
0.0210270621,
-0.0025761132,
-0.0146360742,
0.0071653384,
-0.0001956041,
0.0353143699,
0.0349418893,
-0.0124951061,
-0.01652628,
-0.0161623638,
-0.0489661396,
-0.0311926045,
-0.0164117776,
-0.003267962,
-0.016271662,
0.0459253713,
-0.0002054527,
-0.010392148,
0.0172840524,
0.0386607014,
0.0392924659,
0.0202348325,
-0.0127548939,
0.0480211154,
-0.0081231445,
0.0175740756,
-0.0237583164,
-0.0180564113,
0.0048222933,
0.0005823104,
0.0416921005,
-0.0150206704,
0.0041070557,
-0.038942717,
2.525e-7,
0.0718091205,
0.0511524417,
0.0131409848,
-0.0053386046,
0.0204466376,
-0.0039917924,
-0.0402005129,
0.0030845595,
0.0553651638,
-0.0228686184,
0.0274076127,
0.000141482,
0.022772016,
0.0412966944,
-0.0224667247,
-0.0116494671,
-0.0546624847,
-0.0370711647,
-0.0193815045,
-0.0290054753,
0.0251594093,
0.0630279109,
-0.0463000163,
-0.0214115977,
-0.0052276263,
0.0270793699,
0.0339258723,
-0.0497424826,
-0.0162847321,
0.0669484586,
-0.0126737263,
-0.0100500938,
0.0431455784,
0.051566001,
-0.0153407557,
-0.0173091926,
0.0340218209,
0.073936753,
-0.0232177526,
0.088164784,
0.0304998662,
-0.0116480496,
0.033192195,
-0.0814162269,
0.0482510999,
-0.05723463,
-0.0544911362,
-0.0757062584,
-0.0021746417,
-0.0305764489,
0.0774954185,
-0.0316178165,
0.0019203268,
0.0278693233,
-0.0018364906,
0.0366411917,
-0.0161988083,
0.0039062719,
-0.0002113647,
0.0198170766,
-0.0423112623,
-0.0271757226,
-0.0006160414,
0.0259176791,
-0.0155280093,
-0.0523760319,
0.0182122774,
2.129762731e-34,
0.0308202282,
0.0308853779,
-0.0316558369,
-0.0125481477,
0.0357555598,
-0.0134012904,
-0.0154062593,
0.0172355659,
-0.0218695402,
-0.0710123777,
0.003845199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01592v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01592v1 | Towards Sustainable Workplace Mental Health: A Novel Approach to Early Intervention and Support | 2024-02-02T17:35:49 | 2024-02-02T17:35:49 | David W. Vinson, Mihael Arcan, David-Paul Niland, Fionn Delahunty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Employee well-being is a critical concern in the contemporary workplace, as
highlighted by the American Psychological Association's 2021 report, indicating
that 71% of employees experience stress or tension. This stress contributes
significantly to workplace attrition and absenteeism, with 61% of attrition and
16% of sick days attributed to poor mental health. A major challenge for
employers is that employees often remain unaware of their mental health issues
until they reach a crisis point, resulting in limited utilization of corporate
well-being benefits. This research addresses this challenge by presenting a
groundbreaking stress detection algorithm that provides real-time support
preemptively. Leveraging automated chatbot technology, the algorithm
objectively measures mental health levels by analyzing chat conversations,
offering personalized treatment suggestions in real-time based on linguistic
biomarkers. The study explores the feasibility of integrating these innovations
into practical learning applications within real-world contexts and introduces
a chatbot-style system integrated into the broader employee experience
platform. This platform, encompassing various features, aims to enhance overall
employee well-being, detect stress in real time, and proactively engage with
individuals to improve support effectiveness, demonstrating a 22% increase when
assistance is provided early. Overall, the study emphasizes the importance of
fostering a supportive workplace environment for employees' mental health. | Towards Sustainable Workplace Mental Health: A Novel Approach to Early Intervention and Support: Employee well-being is a critical concern in the contemporary workplace, as
highlighted by the American Psychological Association's 2021 report, indicating
that 71% of employees experience stress or tension. This stress contributes
significantly to workplace attrition and absenteeism, with 61% of attrition and
16% of sick days attributed to poor mental health. A major challenge for
employers is that employees often remain unaware of their mental health issues
until they reach a crisis point, resulting in limited utilization of corporate
well-being benefits. This research addresses this challenge by presenting a
groundbreaking stress detection algorithm that provides real-time support
preemptively. Leveraging automated chatbot technology, the algorithm
objectively measures mental health levels by analyzing chat conversations,
offering personalized treatment suggestions in real-time based on linguistic
biomarkers. The study explores the feasibility of integrating these innovations
into practical learning applications within real-world contexts and introduces
a chatbot-style system integrated into the broader employee experience
platform. This platform, encompassing various features, aims to enhance overall
employee well-being, detect stress in real time, and proactively engage with
individuals to improve support effectiveness, demonstrating a 22% increase when
assistance is provided early. Overall, the study emphasizes the importance of
fostering a supportive workplace environment for employees' mental health. | [
0.0688396171,
0.0037695111,
-0.0499602892,
-0.0636318177,
-0.0275991373,
0.025360629,
0.0361022502,
0.061393287,
0.1383939385,
-0.0364434384,
0.0661256462,
0.0777152851,
-0.0116997482,
0.035217572,
0.003980278,
-0.0477738939,
-0.0260578096,
0.0461418219,
0.067093581,
0.0480531715,
0.0226978771,
0.0412156358,
-0.044920031,
0.0522646829,
-0.0539071187,
-0.0238497891,
0.0554428361,
0.0249291435,
0.0561080985,
-0.0051305825,
0.0043029664,
0.0313517898,
-0.0410535485,
0.0082481895,
0.0000025002,
-0.005288525,
-0.023719335,
0.0043557063,
-0.010849311,
-0.0838940889,
0.0473685712,
-0.0518195629,
-0.0268779788,
0.0519872606,
-0.0101792002,
0.0064376011,
0.0156524852,
0.0147790853,
0.0606556162,
0.0116971387,
-0.0460212752,
0.0488717146,
-0.0480373129,
0.0185141359,
-0.0255107526,
0.0129964286,
0.0355396792,
-0.0312228166,
0.0541293025,
-0.0945662558,
0.0179855693,
-0.0025606435,
-0.0520532839,
-0.0004844428,
-0.0419636853,
0.0048936317,
-0.0017392003,
-0.048634246,
-0.0025410191,
0.0539071485,
-0.0362759568,
0.0356581807,
0.0017556412,
-0.0423459709,
0.0779605582,
0.0007794135,
0.0049893749,
-0.0153036471,
-0.0373624638,
-0.0252373125,
0.0160427671,
0.0311347805,
-0.0123095084,
-0.0224144906,
0.0690705851,
-0.0013484539,
-0.0097712735,
-0.0348452739,
0.0270032883,
-0.005175849,
0.0024335091,
-0.0209535193,
0.0460288003,
0.0494394451,
-0.0310927164,
-0.0164137892,
-0.0224827193,
-0.0763055608,
-0.0016729459,
-0.036095418,
-0.0383963175,
0.0589454323,
-0.0375843979,
-0.0020618767,
0.0582891032,
0.0105396919,
0.0297413021,
-0.0726398677,
-0.0312907659,
0.0273944233,
-0.0348683447,
0.0205085222,
-0.0383972712,
-0.0148515701,
0.0120292306,
-0.02813676,
-0.0772707015,
0.0258325096,
-0.0313700773,
-0.0217317678,
-0.0055634622,
-0.0271157213,
0.0168111287,
0.0646332204,
0.0597422719,
-0.0032700978,
-0.0293920562,
-0.0215162467,
0.0197116844,
-0.0977018476,
0.0471263714,
0.0211948678,
0.0054373029,
0.0274860971,
0.0384666063,
0.0202097651,
0.0099449186,
-0.0658055171,
-0.0523826182,
-0.0279392265,
-0.0278352071,
-0.011893183,
0.0172289889,
-0.0336097702,
0.0467633232,
-0.0193783194,
-0.0167510472,
0.0303171314,
0.0390196592,
-0.0111731393,
-0.0144696971,
-0.0124530336,
-0.0793725103,
-0.0182377566,
0.0088321241,
0.0375962406,
-0.0000636443,
0.0108245006,
0.0005889704,
0.0185131971,
0.0469810925,
-0.0473461039,
0.0003206482,
0.0298348963,
-0.0264918525,
-0.0728241429,
0.0828912929,
-0.0301188435,
-0.0580414794,
0.029037552,
-0.0468938723,
-0.0130813112,
-0.0420830399,
0.0910919905,
0.0121375993,
0.063744776,
-0.0047423868,
0.0385556035,
-0.0388784856,
0.0535664037,
-0.0210091714,
-0.0562760122,
-0.0053848722,
0.0096381614,
-0.0261194631,
-0.0483866557,
0.0105096195,
0.0057985676,
-0.0325265117,
-0.081515789,
-0.0336495005,
-0.0249371529,
0.0200087521,
0.0176293887,
-0.0033598079,
-0.0378361493,
0.0086438647,
0.0248862617,
0.0315858983,
-0.0373198465,
-0.0383162163,
-0.0517678335,
0.018448336,
0.1133091748,
0.0154508613,
-0.0354068726,
-0.0123943938,
-0.0433704369,
-0.0065945289,
0.0134311868,
0.0273208041,
0.0158982202,
0.0211397968,
0.019120276,
0.0040403767,
0.0322162583,
0.0194198247,
-0.003437374,
-0.0095327692,
0.0415286422,
-0.0608669706,
0.0236226115,
-0.013156523,
0.032201346,
0.024795508,
-0.0408504382,
-0.0130191883,
0.0138940541,
0.0293747652,
0.0778191984,
0.0110652642,
0.0043788343,
-0.010861475,
-0.0357395671,
-0.0211843513,
0.0449899286,
0.0171371587,
-0.0041761063,
0.0191256851,
0.0226795599,
-0.0301739648,
0.0561203435,
-0.0150626572,
0.0243828278,
0.005300777,
-0.011469787,
0.0237164386,
0.002640574,
-0.0400384665,
-0.0376521125,
0.050873898,
-0.0229109004,
-0.0135503979,
0.0068131126,
0.0144467251,
-0.0638502985,
-0.0247801691,
-0.0292074159,
-0.0487488508,
0.0017639243,
-0.0111739626,
-0.006464527,
-0.012368124,
-0.0280355159,
0.0370414704,
-0.0392930768,
0.0105773266,
-0.1451461166,
-0.014030871,
-0.0020722593,
-0.0667921975,
0.010951967,
-0.0022346554,
-0.0263638645,
-0.0510366522,
-0.0117821125,
0.0531774759,
0.0505475402,
0.0277825575,
0.0011017948,
-0.0032724086,
-0.0109036835,
-0.0260823369,
-0.0056144977,
-0.0286605675,
-0.0324557312,
0.0735647827,
-0.0146437436,
-0.0598797686,
-0.0379064679,
-0.0334216841,
-0.0158118624,
-0.0023449219,
-0.0512322597,
0.0057258541,
-0.0116873309,
0.0460940041,
0.0562610663,
0.0141786402,
0.0496078506,
-0.0103805382,
0.0232195929,
0.0249804873,
-0.0030054119,
-0.0099629071,
0.0241600163,
-0.015674077,
-0.0430980437,
-0.0102512585,
-0.0013693252,
0.0224037971,
0.0131393708,
-0.0468643643,
0.029879434,
-0.0239093732,
0.0154707609,
-0.0370951071,
0.0227227807,
-0.0201034285,
-0.0018676284,
0.02715398,
-0.0044693961,
-0.0214482471,
0.0227545351,
0.0141278254,
-0.0718453452,
-0.0553142838,
-0.0129887871,
0.0227290746,
-0.0362301283,
0.0068265488,
0.0527960286,
-0.014736956,
0.0514872298,
-0.0246517472,
-0.0412145741,
-0.0628755242,
-0.0900113806,
-0.0372581743,
-0.0077790488,
0.0300984588,
0.0014784002,
-0.0462057516,
-0.0153075494,
-0.0853056833,
0.0160398725,
0.0352082178,
0.0158590786,
-0.0700391978,
-0.0432151668,
0.0349528715,
0.0286237784,
0.0380156375,
-0.0124456333,
0.0232248381,
-0.0302301273,
0.0275148135,
0.0172065422,
0.0448769368,
0.0193910208,
0.0565007217,
0.0665793121,
-0.0126310838,
0.0134223737,
0.0244750511,
-0.0309843831,
-0.0189503394,
0.0136346743,
0.0074438993,
-0.0138883032,
-0.0093040299,
0.0077882707,
-0.008370446,
0.0845366791,
-0.0158593934,
-0.0082562715,
0.0204748381,
-0.0454828404,
-0.0553159527,
0.0116237644,
0.0135725932,
0.0090369964,
-0.0141444895,
0.000419204,
0.0440317951,
-0.006510424,
-0.0321769454,
0.0318687037,
0.0063023902,
0.058967229,
-0.0233551227,
-0.0097169606,
-0.0061827493,
0.0144700147,
0.0204269569,
0.0057717627,
-0.0063966927,
-0.0499563888,
0.0181757268,
-0.0167330261,
-0.0027286769,
-0.0584952049,
-0.00670757,
0.0639026091,
-0.0056926664,
0.0022195037,
0.0438646078,
0.1014421508,
0.0179300327,
0.0122944918,
0.0143188545,
0.0610782653,
0.0199689995,
-0.0053515071,
0.0790601447,
-0.0102780787,
0.0149676977,
-0.0392501615,
0.0388316326,
-0.0720287785,
0.0405894816,
0.0245594028,
0.0335191712,
0.0293140654,
-0.0242609885,
-0.0192140713,
0.0717896,
0.0434102379,
0.0093896054,
-0.0045467229,
-0.0690120682,
0.0067249369,
0.0311512463,
0.0460949577,
0.0182331298,
-0.0280381013,
-0.0084249247,
-0.0485413559,
-0.0061524627,
-0.045384489,
-0.073884815,
0.0454527773,
-0.0239191297,
-0.0254087579,
-0.052395191,
-0.0120200627,
0.0476595834,
-0.0066262283,
-0.0077587729,
0.0215340294,
0.0798902214,
-0.0259797219,
-0.0092381993,
-0.0155727388,
0.0219813082,
0.0013435619,
0.0098346435,
-0.0380098261,
0.028269764,
0.0509506948,
0.0182203315,
0.0024472673,
-0.0563989803,
0.0106837684,
0.0173476674,
0.0257303063,
0.0030351698,
-0.0830212906,
0.0230940506,
0.015702622,
0.0671307296,
-0.0192776639,
-0.0053390572,
-0.028673457,
0.0293344017,
0.0102033513,
0.0090691606,
0.0392445065,
-0.0150376903,
-0.0003743278,
0.0394016877,
-0.0205097217,
0.0011438602,
-0.0445992388,
0.002285741,
-0.0137334289,
0.0110571133,
-0.0135232275,
-0.0163469054,
0.0029435935,
-0.0329558998,
0.0072107268,
0.024052009,
0.0211865176,
-0.0323622636,
-0.0108197797,
-0.017849315,
0.0235578232,
-0.0148970401,
0.0098122573,
-0.0312822275,
-0.0188784841,
0.014131072,
0.058956407,
-0.011689798,
0.0267106127,
0.0005470946,
0.0837574601,
-0.0296023395,
0.0006945916,
0.005098877,
0.0643971115,
-0.0354356579,
-0.0830758885,
0.0161628034,
0.0059506861,
0.0370120779,
0.0296607856,
0.0469481908,
-0.0064846817,
-0.03379713,
-0.0067282589,
-0.0158817619,
-0.0554556288,
0.0014100724,
-0.0196562018,
-0.0235743336,
-0.0276729409,
-0.0287023708,
-0.0099923275,
-0.0152873844,
0.0050362735,
0.0344522521,
0.0051227487,
-0.0197365507,
0.0216071587,
0.0253986493,
0.0340112038,
-0.0249352455,
0.007468279,
-0.0358149149,
-0.0352197513,
0.0495102853,
-0.0281503946,
-0.0265459791,
-0.0039289398,
0.0244195648,
0.0348286331,
0.0136948237,
-0.0180655904,
-0.0578127801,
0.0333941542,
-0.0247595385,
0.014627764,
-0.0103087341,
-5.762188452e-33,
0.017397888,
-0.0019037188,
-0.0139051564,
0.026828045,
0.034369085,
-0.0011415998,
0.0375577286,
0.0058271228,
-0.0047978787,
0.0068557458,
0.023631148,
0.1043004319,
-0.0282515977,
-0.0239444021,
-0.0122025795,
0.0023726358,
0.0206756517,
-0.0356701724,
-0.0053139916,
0.0213668123,
0.0131247658,
0.0770736784,
0.0475301482,
-0.0886000395,
0.0082706669,
0.0171882883,
-0.0039700759,
0.0029655595,
0.0510278307,
0.0060005137,
-0.0102445735,
0.0755877569,
0.0032551857,
0.0387095101,
0.0381760895,
0.0762866512,
-0.0232120734,
-0.0714237541,
-0.0323628671,
0.0170858521,
-0.0308581088,
-0.0118919453,
-0.0277109854,
-0.0158304684,
-0.0015924283,
-0.054145813,
0.0316282585,
-0.0604858436,
0.0457054786,
0.0036573461,
-0.0139921624,
-0.0054111569,
-0.0292660855,
0.0079286834,
-0.0298474878,
0.0862128139,
-0.0419238545,
-0.0094252722,
-0.0563265532,
-0.0147204939,
-0.0060118386,
-0.0405351408,
-0.0126944762,
-0.0460277386,
0.0119850794,
0.0119852722,
-0.0018410395,
0.0005766551,
0.0116800629,
0.0242897496,
0.0068674684,
0.020973172,
0.0696285814,
-0.0004239612,
0.019937329,
-0.0361066535,
-0.0335293189,
0.0086969575,
0.0780483633,
-0.0349401347,
0.0325130746,
0.0309654996,
-0.0291057248,
-0.0089614606,
0.0044114725,
0.0239237752,
-0.0193198845,
-0.0336410552,
0.0097786374,
0.0212608259,
-0.027239114,
-0.0705342442,
-0.0312211365,
-0.0322089009,
0.0573166944,
0.00852805,
0.0230144616,
-0.0170195475,
0.0104004517,
-0.0465691984,
-0.0521268398,
0.0036462212,
-0.0134222927,
0.0351043604,
0.0669183657,
-0.0379462913,
0.0275374092,
-0.0284307562,
0.0072790487,
-0.0108758742,
0.024705302,
0.1003259569,
0.0063874978,
-0.0116300546,
-0.0341357253,
0.0067735207,
0.0106112063,
0.0457191318,
0.0717758462,
0.0175028816,
-0.0526856743,
0.0298883561,
-0.0145383766,
-0.0252584238,
-0.0403171144,
-0.0563051812,
-0.0030709098,
0.0097773056,
0.033239238,
-0.0808565766,
-0.0020666679,
-0.0653621927,
3.046e-7,
-0.0059889895,
0.0440704077,
-0.0362106636,
-0.0236002579,
0.0234898049,
0.0092197582,
0.0168873593,
0.0069848667,
0.0239730906,
0.0157849994,
0.0098822657,
-0.01275157,
0.0371301919,
0.028579751,
0.0377117209,
-0.0865918398,
0.0007723006,
-0.0453718081,
-0.0182857681,
0.0160281975,
0.0861072317,
0.0466811471,
0.0241208486,
-0.0299542695,
-0.0057472354,
-0.0116832741,
0.0070098876,
-0.039039582,
0.0140262423,
0.0092783393,
0.0004945389,
0.0176857933,
-0.0238120407,
0.0105859712,
-0.0036988123,
0.0073136031,
0.0000351536,
0.0365030095,
-0.0355299562,
0.0197369717,
0.0300068371,
0.0137319611,
0.0081243692,
-0.0197005607,
0.0255470276,
-0.1124023125,
-0.0489879102,
-0.015091043,
-0.054285638,
-0.0477446094,
0.0234328732,
-0.0247900765,
-0.0415011458,
0.0426766723,
0.0135705415,
0.0142169381,
0.0087174252,
-0.0051974244,
-0.0055736569,
-0.0008244349,
-0.0554055162,
-0.0634532943,
0.0131179299,
-0.0045653847,
-0.0492966436,
-0.0169859212,
0.014089887,
2.213213876e-34,
-0.0079015559,
0.0705171898,
-0.0266123582,
0.0378938094,
0.00492342,
-0.001207443,
-0.0031010977,
0.0199427195,
0.0044772951,
-0.008125904,
-0.0149786863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01591v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01591v2 | BAT: Learning to Reason about Spatial Sounds with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T17:34:53 | 2024-05-25T17:05:11 | Zhisheng Zheng, Puyuan Peng, Ziyang Ma, Xie Chen, Eunsol Choi, David Harwath | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Spatial sound reasoning is a fundamental human skill, enabling us to navigate
and interpret our surroundings based on sound. In this paper we present BAT,
which combines the spatial sound perception ability of a binaural acoustic
scene analysis model with the natural language reasoning capabilities of a
large language model (LLM) to replicate this innate ability. To address the
lack of existing datasets of in-the-wild spatial sounds, we synthesized a
binaural audio dataset using AudioSet and SoundSpaces 2.0. Next, we developed
SpatialSoundQA, a spatial sound-based question-answering dataset, offering a
range of QA tasks that train BAT in various aspects of spatial sound perception
and reasoning. The acoustic front end encoder of BAT is a novel spatial audio
encoder named Spatial Audio Spectrogram Transformer, or Spatial-AST, which by
itself achieves strong performance across sound event detection, spatial
localization, and distance estimation. By integrating Spatial-AST with LLaMA-2
7B model, BAT transcends standard Sound Event Localization and Detection (SELD)
tasks, enabling the model to reason about the relationships between the sounds
in its environment. Our experiments demonstrate BAT's superior performance on
both spatial sound perception and reasoning, showcasing the immense potential
of LLMs in navigating and interpreting complex spatial audio environments. | BAT: Learning to Reason about Spatial Sounds with Large Language Models: Spatial sound reasoning is a fundamental human skill, enabling us to navigate
and interpret our surroundings based on sound. In this paper we present BAT,
which combines the spatial sound perception ability of a binaural acoustic
scene analysis model with the natural language reasoning capabilities of a
large language model (LLM) to replicate this innate ability. To address the
lack of existing datasets of in-the-wild spatial sounds, we synthesized a
binaural audio dataset using AudioSet and SoundSpaces 2.0. Next, we developed
SpatialSoundQA, a spatial sound-based question-answering dataset, offering a
range of QA tasks that train BAT in various aspects of spatial sound perception
and reasoning. The acoustic front end encoder of BAT is a novel spatial audio
encoder named Spatial Audio Spectrogram Transformer, or Spatial-AST, which by
itself achieves strong performance across sound event detection, spatial
localization, and distance estimation. By integrating Spatial-AST with LLaMA-2
7B model, BAT transcends standard Sound Event Localization and Detection (SELD)
tasks, enabling the model to reason about the relationships between the sounds
in its environment. Our experiments demonstrate BAT's superior performance on
both spatial sound perception and reasoning, showcasing the immense potential
of LLMs in navigating and interpreting complex spatial audio environments. | [
0.0116651785,
0.0466137826,
0.0075793071,
0.0520652831,
-0.0115584331,
-0.0086139608,
0.0483363755,
-0.048285272,
-0.0379369035,
-0.0098541882,
-0.0604433529,
0.0231987052,
0.0219505914,
0.0448601469,
0.0271410495,
-0.0617055371,
0.0241808891,
-0.0493218154,
0.0212348942,
-0.0201809239,
-0.0223566666,
0.0116292881,
-0.0736225247,
0.0674301386,
-0.0237035342,
-0.0022596018,
-0.0077913003,
0.0059148199,
0.0093410583,
-0.0452674776,
0.0090592718,
0.0091886921,
0.0823909938,
-0.0046771988,
0.0000016204,
-0.0361571498,
0.02477034,
-0.0050921184,
-0.0007892781,
-0.015295797,
-0.0694373623,
0.0074268929,
-0.008996875,
0.0370719507,
-0.0187286083,
-0.0316284932,
0.043742571,
-0.0086913751,
0.0312827677,
0.0181689896,
-0.0084479218,
-0.0997217968,
0.0039863056,
-0.0248034094,
0.0547972359,
-0.0052188262,
-0.0004910706,
-0.0115342019,
0.0300939269,
0.0540041104,
-0.0340604149,
0.0229834281,
0.0381109864,
0.0157469995,
0.0270524565,
0.0578766502,
-0.0132607836,
-0.0140787167,
-0.0320402719,
0.0864675716,
0.0406003408,
-0.0380340889,
-0.0067564715,
0.0546579584,
-0.0149998842,
-0.0326081887,
-0.0748088583,
0.0280158669,
-0.0100092329,
0.01355075,
-0.0593165681,
0.014848127,
0.018452907,
-0.0334612802,
0.0047762673,
0.0803077966,
0.0033789016,
-0.0176313911,
-0.0276985597,
-0.0331593342,
-0.008122134,
-0.0383206978,
0.0277997237,
0.0624936782,
-0.0326178856,
0.0059962319,
0.0228396282,
0.028274687,
-0.0178897157,
-0.024650136,
-0.0260615628,
0.0206796695,
-0.0601848103,
0.0884868875,
-0.0469039567,
0.0268924516,
-0.0165894367,
0.0183535349,
-0.0203247108,
-0.0415171608,
-0.0106728524,
-0.0252128672,
-0.0538306907,
-0.000348766,
-0.0513087399,
-0.0529284701,
0.0098744771,
-0.0185894538,
-0.0420380123,
0.0231862627,
0.0016366312,
0.0601332597,
0.0169867724,
-0.018480327,
0.0161577202,
0.0148157449,
-0.026481865,
0.0759504884,
-0.0431142934,
-0.0138327582,
-0.0278655645,
0.0292534996,
0.0473179333,
-0.0130790249,
-0.0003096265,
0.0765419155,
0.0045512435,
-0.0207664929,
-0.0097428476,
-0.0055005229,
-0.0367971957,
-0.0279572438,
-0.0009849606,
-0.0685170516,
0.0305460598,
-0.0084663201,
-0.0534895435,
-0.0116263162,
-0.0005228685,
0.0034451354,
0.0219414141,
0.0932508782,
-0.0144693926,
0.0464014187,
0.0819259211,
0.0109556988,
0.018051587,
0.016467968,
0.0814170092,
0.0076628607,
0.0123108719,
-0.0160274114,
-0.0231208149,
0.0289514381,
-0.0036817784,
-0.0138325728,
-0.0500885844,
0.014133554,
-0.0184163097,
0.0496872626,
0.0081163272,
0.0201509781,
-0.040298067,
-0.0339881331,
0.0372460634,
0.1044767946,
-0.0156357922,
-0.0004042304,
0.0418610573,
0.0012975131,
-0.028500814,
-0.0635623634,
-0.0308178719,
0.0669744834,
-0.0082036285,
-0.0136045292,
0.063571237,
0.0031638641,
-0.0338856243,
-0.0179808009,
-0.03631448,
0.0056873676,
-0.0001193118,
0.0535205267,
0.024827376,
0.0181972943,
-0.0263414197,
0.0759579837,
-0.0120738531,
-0.0387578756,
-0.0311293211,
-0.0152206933,
0.1061508805,
0.034968812,
0.0101567311,
-0.0466043167,
-0.028384421,
-0.0086440146,
0.0157611389,
0.0464992672,
0.030354755,
-0.0196988676,
0.0306071118,
-0.0179708768,
-0.0630458668,
-0.0049458607,
0.0052391156,
0.0218465161,
0.0409124345,
0.0285799131,
0.0033166134,
-0.0587615632,
0.0438796319,
-0.0035742216,
0.0252654552,
-0.0285861101,
-0.0236020964,
0.0145050995,
0.0212033913,
-0.0096973926,
0.0038523998,
0.012906272,
0.0389656387,
-0.0258354191,
-0.0018366013,
0.0446897335,
-0.0546208955,
-0.0507300496,
0.0381965004,
-0.0394633301,
0.0123489983,
0.0569172166,
-0.0256728008,
-0.0165711064,
0.0393029638,
-0.0504378416,
0.0061065755,
-0.0228338912,
-0.0214322954,
0.0228564125,
0.0206047837,
-0.0056148469,
0.0188897047,
0.0332063735,
0.006133738,
-0.0733568668,
0.0320674591,
0.0584916621,
-0.0118169468,
0.0347603895,
0.0126270419,
-0.015592928,
-0.0112730246,
-0.0338756815,
-0.0033533175,
-0.0367084444,
-0.0031605945,
-0.0735065416,
0.0041403915,
-0.0046584206,
-0.0030519008,
0.0180079099,
-0.0460356735,
-0.014286356,
-0.0488690175,
-0.0397031344,
-0.0270076245,
-0.0048433174,
0.0154742096,
-0.0058090216,
-0.0605613254,
-0.0472069606,
-0.0184382647,
-0.0108748907,
0.0001147094,
0.0116112623,
0.0088810781,
0.0107362112,
-0.0388455614,
-0.0203419998,
-0.0342990197,
0.0160197113,
0.0083656469,
-0.0114943478,
0.0452671386,
-0.0401318967,
-0.0098405126,
0.04283759,
-0.0199229307,
-0.0016778439,
0.0484522954,
-0.0022634191,
-0.0408392176,
0.0354851,
0.0138416542,
0.0409475118,
-0.0304739531,
-0.0030687142,
-0.0407863483,
0.0394445285,
0.0241252016,
-0.0037615208,
-0.0145500423,
-0.0007044196,
0.0061526541,
-0.0081048366,
-0.0720568076,
-0.0503262579,
-0.0016579368,
0.0647766665,
-0.0549801588,
-0.0149172014,
0.0240471177,
-0.066314809,
-0.0250937473,
-0.0724019036,
-0.0065881619,
-0.036338713,
0.0799755901,
-0.0183032081,
0.004825287,
-0.0215182137,
-0.0381365977,
0.0155722378,
-0.0335432552,
0.0005845934,
-0.0284771975,
0.0056927525,
-0.0301494785,
0.0192284137,
0.0002154317,
-0.0197956283,
-0.0417919345,
0.01111311,
-0.0732440203,
0.0068350057,
-0.0573627762,
-0.0268309265,
0.0041641816,
0.0348349996,
0.0453849174,
0.0644644052,
-0.0031924532,
-0.0042821742,
-0.0133033954,
0.0300064087,
0.0678218231,
0.1011071578,
-0.0220680386,
0.0012796054,
-0.0298110042,
0.0303912126,
-0.0159422718,
0.0006813519,
-0.0667453334,
0.0822853073,
0.0354312696,
0.0364722125,
-0.02719054,
0.0441042818,
0.0613439567,
-0.0539980046,
-0.0409599915,
0.0836298093,
0.0735772923,
0.0154133663,
0.0126277059,
-0.0241262428,
0.0044660899,
0.0349670127,
-0.0132016558,
-0.0192082003,
-0.061558038,
0.0251472238,
-0.0136053981,
0.0831686109,
0.0274439044,
0.0033330272,
-0.0727770776,
0.0704471916,
0.0045647407,
-0.114210546,
-0.06114107,
-0.012830032,
0.0040630456,
0.0019651535,
-0.0083941612,
-0.0013339418,
0.0041005351,
-0.0054801898,
0.0089285448,
-0.0154560786,
0.0164230149,
0.0372846834,
-0.0240833499,
0.0233741049,
0.049084153,
0.0465956256,
-0.0119740888,
-0.0549032316,
-0.018366253,
0.0276812874,
0.01955905,
0.0065036728,
0.0480625816,
0.0416340232,
-0.0217570458,
0.0201651193,
0.0384221114,
-0.0670417547,
-0.0300228633,
0.0321684554,
0.0741381794,
-0.0254403166,
0.0285961535,
-0.0331963375,
0.0695085004,
-0.0214177556,
0.0759951398,
0.039750237,
0.0380858891,
-0.042134691,
-0.0125673776,
-0.0680909082,
-0.0320620164,
-0.0069242753,
-0.0010369888,
0.0401451476,
0.0014705613,
-0.0508341491,
0.0033206958,
0.0364386886,
0.0381606184,
0.0044159093,
-0.0119395312,
0.0015254032,
0.0012814833,
-0.0589943901,
0.0515335798,
-0.0223034546,
0.0406071097,
0.0172833484,
0.0229400825,
0.0621081516,
-0.0654652491,
-0.0231506508,
0.0368388817,
-0.0504218154,
-0.0441786051,
-0.0258236565,
-0.0168920942,
0.0242550187,
0.0333693326,
-0.0356287919,
-0.0058562448,
0.0558941923,
-0.0090269772,
-0.0486344844,
0.0482038073,
0.0433103815,
0.0233564246,
0.0104441242,
0.0091419527,
-0.0505802333,
0.0256095938,
-0.0144128222,
0.0206070915,
0.0058669643,
-0.0023029698,
-0.0271058679,
-0.041271463,
0.064769797,
0.0187444687,
-0.0189404916,
-0.032600075,
0.0461531579,
-0.0114738401,
0.0520111136,
-0.038133584,
0.0229718331,
0.0150205335,
0.0272657555,
-0.0269097127,
-0.0075838598,
0.0203107353,
-0.0000893966,
0.000297143,
0.0324499905,
0.046179805,
-0.0548387654,
0.0030853862,
-0.0145729864,
0.0093705179,
0.000062429,
-0.0123036569,
0.0431541726,
0.0243695434,
0.026457645,
0.0074400022,
-0.0146783637,
-0.0377163291,
0.0260873251,
-0.0525058061,
-0.0742158964,
0.0347711258,
0.0424301289,
0.0548557565,
-0.01073658,
-0.0167840794,
0.0109736472,
0.007253834,
0.0189534165,
0.0128948782,
-0.0226188954,
-0.0142015656,
0.0731703714,
0.0355249606,
-0.0107193002,
-0.0168927442,
0.0376964062,
-0.0169792846,
0.0316672623,
-0.0211379398,
0.0330301523,
-0.0256196689,
-0.0299967397,
-0.0242040884,
0.0435430892,
-0.0065871873,
0.0237658415,
0.0203906242,
-0.0755315274,
-0.0139066344,
-0.0014285293,
-0.0154497921,
-0.004137022,
0.0549196117,
0.0299974307,
0.0136392778,
-0.031453371,
0.0411964394,
-0.0383637734,
-0.0021815023,
-0.0336444676,
0.0110177277,
-5.488308554e-33,
-0.0208075289,
-0.0490507297,
0.0526804626,
-0.01039341,
0.0076638232,
-0.0217772946,
-0.0629002601,
-0.0328861549,
-0.022006372,
0.0060585672,
0.0242776144,
0.0268707983,
0.006301654,
0.0192568619,
0.0364215001,
-0.011011757,
0.0145504298,
-0.011046242,
0.0192161072,
-0.0159944668,
0.0668302029,
0.007365908,
0.0306117591,
-0.050190255,
-0.0651179552,
0.0220699515,
-0.0010773522,
0.0154791735,
-0.0631302893,
0.0551424138,
-0.0277323667,
0.0161626097,
-0.0144541431,
-0.0338099785,
-0.0086773997,
0.0296660643,
-0.1028194278,
-0.0456595495,
-0.0043308642,
0.0264990367,
-0.0343972631,
-0.0157955065,
0.0463292412,
0.0104750982,
0.0036538974,
-0.0235780329,
0.0363684557,
-0.0291742682,
-0.0121715544,
-0.0110390857,
-0.0363414921,
-0.0016113564,
-0.0424184948,
-0.0561652891,
0.010825878,
0.0264244992,
0.006822098,
0.0211495757,
-0.0228513274,
0.0566763096,
0.003133798,
0.0170742758,
0.0393284336,
-0.0048542302,
-0.0103780283,
0.0452502593,
0.0769757554,
-0.0917901248,
-0.0205387976,
0.0033257115,
0.0272744503,
0.0373713337,
0.0471038856,
-0.0006631589,
0.0193832293,
0.0127714593,
-0.0507891439,
0.0080948286,
-0.0385879464,
0.0125004901,
0.0242655706,
0.0282580219,
-0.0203666929,
-0.0155435745,
-0.0337333716,
0.0186280627,
-0.0419202112,
0.0094026439,
0.0490182042,
0.0077626775,
0.0438282937,
0.002084143,
0.0197626967,
-0.0242315643,
0.0269710533,
0.0379993655,
-0.0218905285,
-0.0026085179,
0.0217858646,
0.0427492782,
-0.0298118312,
0.0345197655,
0.0797334611,
0.0161265098,
0.0174988881,
0.0016798968,
0.0112416316,
0.0540321022,
-0.0450713411,
-0.0105752824,
-0.0208500233,
-0.0287320837,
0.0041211573,
0.0184798054,
0.0240284763,
0.0158800296,
-0.0492904261,
0.0168509893,
-0.0572420694,
0.0141417114,
-0.0557372309,
-0.0273726601,
-0.0813588277,
0.0320569575,
-0.0162738878,
0.0036856183,
-0.0235874467,
-0.0671145171,
0.0028858522,
-0.0788565278,
-0.0260237493,
0.0189658273,
2.536e-7,
-0.0086991601,
0.0036399891,
0.0158570856,
-0.0045226389,
0.0430806205,
0.0153701743,
-0.0181411598,
0.0251990799,
0.0087301889,
-0.0156368148,
0.0019820714,
0.055283092,
0.0578665584,
0.0224933643,
-0.1000741944,
0.0401405469,
-0.0577827767,
0.0140815191,
-0.0557743646,
-0.0063543557,
0.0716144219,
0.0715066791,
-0.0085766669,
-0.0256239343,
0.0320356525,
-0.0325941965,
0.0095605208,
-0.0064473012,
0.0495504066,
-0.0424960367,
0.018468231,
-0.0346810594,
-0.0076144668,
-0.0124372728,
-0.0209730864,
-0.0093584061,
0.0123222442,
0.0418674536,
-0.0151536353,
-0.076054886,
-0.0122344438,
0.0411405228,
-0.0086903824,
-0.067036584,
0.1018823981,
-0.0294033345,
-0.0280956347,
0.0341596678,
-0.0186390579,
-0.0232473407,
-0.0150272343,
0.0127855344,
0.0317251682,
-0.0685020909,
0.0110980468,
-0.0219888352,
0.0030280298,
-0.1074199528,
-0.0210128818,
0.0363395698,
-0.0447720401,
0.0121405134,
-0.0095908819,
-0.0267007239,
0.0160846785,
-0.0083468072,
-0.0462775491,
1.633618593e-34,
0.0002108483,
-0.0089221429,
0.0273927413,
-0.0146529377,
-0.0107777892,
-0.013335485,
-0.0224721562,
-0.0230037272,
0.0269705951,
-0.0160070267,
-0.0101367095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01586v2 | TrustAgent: Towards Safe and Trustworthy LLM-based Agents through Agent Constitution | 2024-02-02T17:26:23 | 2024-02-18T04:11:55 | Wenyue Hua, Xianjun Yang, Zelong Li, Wei Cheng, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.MA | The emergence of LLM-based agents has garnered considerable attention, yet
their trustworthiness remains an under-explored area. As agents can directly
interact with the physical environment, their reliability and safety is
critical. This paper presents an Agent-Constitution-based agent framework,
TrustAgent, an initial investigation into improving the safety dimension of
trustworthiness in LLM-based agents. This framework consists of threefold
strategies: pre-planning strategy which injects safety knowledge to the model
prior to plan generation, in-planning strategy which bolsters safety during
plan generation, and post-planning strategy which ensures safety by
post-planning inspection. Through experimental analysis, we demonstrate how
these approaches can effectively elevate an LLM agent's safety by identifying
and preventing potential dangers. Furthermore, we explore the intricate
relationships between safety and helpfulness, and between the model's reasoning
ability and its efficacy as a safe agent. This paper underscores the imperative
of integrating safety awareness and trustworthiness into the design and
deployment of LLM-based agents, not only to enhance their performance but also
to ensure their responsible integration into human-centric environments. Data
and code are available at https://github.com/agiresearch/TrustAgent. | TrustAgent: Towards Safe and Trustworthy LLM-based Agents through Agent Constitution: The emergence of LLM-based agents has garnered considerable attention, yet
their trustworthiness remains an under-explored area. As agents can directly
interact with the physical environment, their reliability and safety is
critical. This paper presents an Agent-Constitution-based agent framework,
TrustAgent, an initial investigation into improving the safety dimension of
trustworthiness in LLM-based agents. This framework consists of threefold
strategies: pre-planning strategy which injects safety knowledge to the model
prior to plan generation, in-planning strategy which bolsters safety during
plan generation, and post-planning strategy which ensures safety by
post-planning inspection. Through experimental analysis, we demonstrate how
these approaches can effectively elevate an LLM agent's safety by identifying
and preventing potential dangers. Furthermore, we explore the intricate
relationships between safety and helpfulness, and between the model's reasoning
ability and its efficacy as a safe agent. This paper underscores the imperative
of integrating safety awareness and trustworthiness into the design and
deployment of LLM-based agents, not only to enhance their performance but also
to ensure their responsible integration into human-centric environments. Data
and code are available at https://github.com/agiresearch/TrustAgent. | [
-0.0127455546,
0.0219047125,
0.0164981838,
0.0305874702,
-0.0267628636,
-0.0235720035,
-0.0340472013,
-0.0241211355,
0.0378317349,
-0.0042167767,
-0.0000302174,
0.0287099909,
-0.0435232893,
0.007970619,
0.0093422579,
0.0116454456,
0.046774108,
-0.0496429466,
-0.0010838313,
0.0206371527,
-0.0080072964,
-0.0382721685,
-0.0127354879,
0.0088016558,
-0.0262427051,
-0.0036152184,
-0.0437341407,
0.0186889302,
0.0652584285,
-0.0405528806,
-0.0041409088,
-0.0083438549,
0.0454949476,
-0.005329249,
0.0000021198,
-0.0473873988,
-0.0116472645,
0.0013379885,
-0.0105127357,
-0.0834444016,
0.0179034304,
0.0210864339,
-0.0291922037,
0.0304288585,
-0.0407599472,
0.0593476668,
-0.0003288383,
0.0315552801,
0.0368270427,
0.0502948202,
0.0063941409,
0.0600577816,
0.0507507659,
0.0486680456,
0.0166346543,
-0.0663534403,
-0.0098364949,
-0.0201652888,
0.0329218879,
0.0113875475,
0.0086477175,
-0.0378350541,
0.019126961,
-0.011861193,
0.0102332756,
0.0104454681,
0.024998121,
-0.0591915175,
-0.0505253896,
0.0218028463,
0.0387633853,
0.0186767969,
0.0247050375,
0.0203381572,
-0.0048489734,
0.0292327963,
0.0142186983,
0.0101439506,
-0.006827388,
-0.0095513258,
-0.0234914552,
0.006814952,
0.0247897841,
0.0174626764,
0.0196492132,
0.1310978085,
-0.02204342,
0.0270761922,
0.0162214711,
-0.0141796507,
0.0596624389,
-0.0458276905,
-0.0079761837,
0.068164818,
-0.0587185472,
0.0186828002,
-0.0105236555,
0.0681485608,
0.033754088,
-0.0202826448,
-0.0230670515,
-0.0219421573,
0.0072681443,
0.00805985,
-0.000605388,
0.0298503563,
0.0087961927,
0.0552895367,
0.0028411238,
0.0110668708,
-0.005097542,
0.0233750548,
-0.0029720939,
0.0195862595,
0.0129494611,
0.0337825306,
0.0005688719,
0.0514143333,
-0.0336931907,
0.0529981777,
-0.0170601942,
0.0092694648,
0.0266686585,
-0.0052704033,
-0.072354272,
-0.0988084152,
-0.0332373232,
0.0058397376,
0.0005075136,
-0.0454840101,
0.0037947961,
-0.0043893415,
-0.0327602439,
-0.0097594755,
-0.0360462815,
0.1056250706,
0.0136493249,
-0.0535699129,
-0.0651896149,
-0.0424160436,
0.047409974,
-0.054175064,
0.0017320466,
-0.0306833554,
0.0013112017,
-0.0317413695,
-0.0400343128,
-0.0669809207,
0.0444298796,
-0.011264164,
0.0023247264,
0.0379352942,
-0.0586117171,
0.0109498594,
-0.0281337537,
0.0657878742,
-0.0631074011,
-0.00417784,
0.045744136,
0.0478044413,
0.0275203995,
0.0262239743,
0.0670796409,
0.0019663163,
-0.0362277701,
0.0119621633,
0.0774540678,
0.0033444713,
-0.0461805686,
0.017527448,
-0.0358058587,
-0.002231387,
-0.0118015567,
0.0311967023,
0.062711291,
0.0204524696,
-0.0160002559,
-0.0327370353,
-0.0159999356,
0.0509401672,
-0.0175977405,
-0.0432059802,
-0.0854512528,
0.0537050627,
-0.0556177236,
-0.0140184043,
-0.0994247273,
0.0505113006,
-0.0328809842,
-0.035116557,
-0.0086976429,
-0.0527725853,
0.0611537322,
-0.0027630345,
0.0016827119,
0.0040825098,
-0.0189036336,
0.0079516657,
-0.0150891142,
-0.0325441137,
-0.0423514061,
-0.0771138817,
0.0519715808,
0.0952119976,
0.0140812863,
-0.0085955402,
-0.0820166245,
-0.004893105,
-0.004928302,
-0.0211196262,
-0.0410384536,
-0.0092425384,
0.0444071107,
-0.0262341909,
-0.0628276765,
0.0036546763,
0.025827663,
0.0398518331,
0.0107814912,
0.0212539434,
-0.0154647827,
-0.011534607,
0.0024875188,
0.0476706326,
-0.0119950622,
-0.0061437231,
-0.0580798611,
0.0038087873,
0.0184031688,
0.0008113042,
0.0157138091,
-0.0074130846,
0.0693514571,
0.0411980487,
-0.0334704146,
0.0394744985,
0.008087662,
0.0550868995,
0.0098971641,
-0.0354669839,
0.012689339,
0.02551613,
-0.0088293348,
-0.0143452184,
-0.0351908207,
0.0017240063,
-0.011560142,
-0.033353474,
0.0194301624,
0.0009952682,
-0.0427068844,
-0.0042169266,
0.0079158591,
-0.0044195219,
-0.0826916844,
-0.0007337151,
0.0720550567,
0.0160309691,
-0.020906413,
0.0270998813,
-0.0079163006,
0.0102423867,
0.0444162264,
0.0068724095,
0.043808274,
-0.0125484066,
-0.0067944941,
0.0084467754,
-0.0134943686,
-0.0232912581,
-0.0027478507,
-0.0166642051,
-0.0506211184,
-0.0033645562,
0.0037490465,
0.0146211199,
0.0949007198,
-0.010802608,
-0.014142626,
0.0385834686,
-0.0169316251,
-0.0643751994,
-0.0091722924,
0.0429720543,
0.0024024392,
-0.0178475752,
0.0106109325,
-0.0205441117,
-0.0547020584,
0.0441333987,
-0.0409744978,
-0.0225305334,
-0.013759098,
-0.04402164,
0.0212045871,
0.0232675802,
-0.0650486872,
-0.0005259675,
-0.0094338953,
0.0164677091,
0.084024325,
-0.0290265158,
-0.0400356315,
0.0100539746,
-0.005089479,
-0.0126815932,
-0.021471994,
0.0210449658,
-0.0156351998,
0.0056213401,
-0.0577206239,
0.0253179856,
0.0162843745,
0.0025490508,
0.0431128666,
-0.0609372519,
0.063376449,
-0.0497985333,
-0.0256848969,
0.0840625614,
0.0060802856,
-0.0393968783,
0.0397490188,
-0.0152624603,
0.0091118412,
0.0302483812,
-0.0466951616,
-0.0223721061,
0.0490588173,
-0.0020168077,
-0.0185673907,
-0.0122710913,
0.0145251807,
-0.006237566,
-0.0526885837,
0.0053710714,
-0.0158721954,
0.0093359007,
-0.0608209819,
-0.0297051277,
0.0039018518,
-0.0440794118,
-0.0561335012,
-0.0019213564,
-0.0278965663,
0.0181678534,
-0.0869282559,
-0.0205914751,
-0.0217331164,
-0.0231254287,
0.0373429544,
-0.0303239264,
-0.00483817,
0.0024134933,
-0.0322968438,
-0.0478785299,
-0.0081733726,
0.0311737377,
0.0661854893,
0.0017255353,
0.0517428257,
0.0731095746,
-0.0098153939,
-0.05217994,
-0.0585580543,
-0.0159941278,
-0.0012913099,
0.0442858376,
0.0277310517,
0.0484403335,
0.0640108809,
0.004171961,
-0.017717896,
0.0155395763,
0.0004275141,
0.014277908,
0.0310432333,
-0.0516357794,
-0.0086529646,
0.0035109578,
0.0185117703,
-0.0105357794,
-0.0068609267,
0.0158176031,
0.0121193975,
-0.0191463679,
-0.044632718,
0.0274606105,
0.0011289476,
0.0917117223,
0.0002822061,
0.0061111767,
-0.0094440309,
-0.0429444052,
-0.0030594321,
-0.0106537743,
0.0279324744,
0.0309806429,
0.0295872074,
-0.0537579879,
0.0002560557,
-0.025963759,
-0.0133991055,
-0.0000719375,
-0.0694916621,
0.0278829075,
0.0774158239,
0.0067506474,
-0.033613611,
-0.0588987246,
-0.0206507239,
0.0506081581,
0.0630537048,
-0.0127821267,
-0.0185399894,
-0.0271507837,
0.0421960987,
0.0015085874,
0.0121124787,
-0.0290932897,
-0.0680846348,
0.049980849,
0.0655464977,
-0.0625236332,
-0.0257441532,
-0.0667020008,
0.0029484062,
0.0454100445,
0.0433913618,
-0.0340332501,
0.0277431495,
-0.0416953079,
-0.0071006049,
-0.0261137467,
0.010289629,
-0.005613972,
0.0245546885,
-0.0402054638,
-0.0202557538,
-0.0269102212,
-0.0463304818,
-0.0049130018,
-0.0004759337,
0.0048010885,
-0.0684524849,
0.008382557,
0.0525335595,
-0.0155123873,
-0.013093018,
0.0005568561,
0.0389313139,
0.0221205149,
0.0610396191,
0.0317606516,
-0.049785573,
0.024118755,
0.0155381449,
-0.0139680905,
-0.0173044857,
0.0250507034,
0.0853161886,
0.0339345522,
-0.0092175966,
-0.0424678177,
0.0081261657,
0.0633351132,
-0.0192327071,
-0.0673063397,
0.0091331601,
0.0308828838,
0.0008722874,
0.0222970154,
0.0135387713,
-0.0509956032,
-0.0001500659,
0.0236900318,
0.008007287,
-0.0617837571,
-0.0224511009,
0.0023034289,
0.036798615,
-0.0009808689,
0.0244398862,
0.0658901632,
-0.0001932899,
0.0437906496,
0.0054558869,
0.0290185045,
-0.0246098805,
0.0628300086,
-0.019089818,
-0.005112574,
0.0436422341,
-0.0408614762,
0.0114072198,
0.0117388051,
0.0405831821,
0.0469967313,
0.0040936498,
-0.0075835055,
0.0185548849,
0.0126910834,
-0.0031470493,
0.0324153602,
-0.0180902388,
0.004974789,
0.0465344153,
0.0065018088,
-0.0166639909,
-0.0061267619,
-0.0506002679,
0.026144892,
-0.0580192916,
-0.0639418587,
0.0336565934,
0.0650055632,
0.0233743023,
0.0796382353,
0.0025431924,
-0.0836071894,
0.0299692545,
-0.0172689781,
-0.004326785,
0.0233286731,
-0.0130864605,
0.0330672227,
0.0329808518,
-0.0128688328,
-0.0161798466,
0.0189702436,
-0.0122913364,
0.0317397155,
-0.0496727452,
-0.0621683747,
-0.0448031835,
-0.015050645,
0.014888363,
0.0208711643,
-0.022355359,
-0.0711171255,
-0.0654718652,
-0.0143344468,
0.0227620769,
0.0402312018,
-0.0114589687,
-0.0285643805,
0.0019141318,
-0.0068685352,
0.0256502237,
-0.0419582427,
-0.0043226257,
-0.0945906714,
-0.0044079507,
0.0248784814,
0.0121103432,
-5.41420392e-33,
0.0156492405,
-0.0594658926,
0.0518412888,
0.0451299921,
0.0135179237,
-0.0425216705,
-0.0153150856,
0.013465534,
0.0105247833,
-0.0025077539,
-0.021427935,
0.0155202756,
0.0276561268,
-0.0614317991,
0.0265975874,
-0.0171531998,
-0.0099785207,
0.000042151,
-0.0010102366,
-0.0300981719,
-0.0236369893,
0.023544427,
0.0143010113,
-0.0661893189,
0.0357567631,
-0.016837243,
-0.0447870865,
0.0373825245,
-0.0811082125,
0.0251783039,
0.0135053108,
-0.0142471446,
0.0064411135,
0.0275148172,
-0.0204031616,
0.0233372506,
-0.0127230026,
-0.0568932518,
-0.0187267642,
-0.0218792893,
-0.0942578763,
-0.0471094549,
0.0055606342,
-0.0054101273,
-0.0541686639,
0.0067872363,
0.0142390365,
-0.0140040787,
0.0133163156,
-0.0099468259,
-0.027851956,
0.0104375212,
0.0039417706,
-0.039554514,
0.0418455973,
-0.0019532233,
-0.0037751142,
-0.0341007859,
-0.0432848334,
0.0109220566,
-0.0256752558,
-0.0817002803,
0.0207061786,
-0.0230511054,
-0.0399598777,
0.0529188514,
0.0190759841,
0.0181705225,
-0.0291665476,
-0.0082221739,
-0.0288254637,
0.1249169782,
0.0062396699,
0.0698033869,
-0.0677867308,
-0.0107513508,
-0.0608375818,
0.0787531808,
0.0371414237,
0.0824726224,
0.0235263929,
-0.0009757301,
-0.0332957357,
0.0158405136,
0.0193628184,
0.0181771498,
-0.0042456854,
-0.0384030342,
-0.0021638563,
0.0214599725,
-0.0124279046,
-0.0325585864,
-0.0320222452,
0.0049984325,
0.0301453955,
0.0030881406,
0.030322846,
-0.0322179273,
-0.0128899552,
0.0244158655,
-0.0415098481,
-0.027611604,
-0.0396844037,
-0.0333859138,
0.0356721468,
0.0184974913,
-0.0007527563,
0.0711780488,
0.0165790711,
-0.00336793,
-0.0286201648,
0.0209796391,
0.0530403256,
-0.0611824505,
0.0128661627,
-0.0367185324,
0.0021220965,
0.0388713405,
-0.0159051195,
-0.0475365147,
0.0043088575,
0.0540747829,
-0.0217955709,
0.0110512925,
-0.0084267808,
-0.0242898725,
-0.0127171995,
0.0042730379,
0.0187660139,
-0.0299945995,
0.0171483569,
-0.0079341074,
2.928e-7,
-0.0563278422,
0.0184100885,
0.0066754115,
0.0143277962,
0.0279840622,
0.057536263,
-0.0492600463,
0.0580670498,
-0.0409261249,
-0.03699008,
0.068349652,
0.0248060245,
0.0172802061,
0.0565172471,
-0.003211621,
-0.009010626,
0.0418051742,
-0.0277975295,
-0.0168536473,
-0.0060519492,
0.0576037951,
-0.001656981,
0.0169740543,
-0.0379049554,
0.0255237985,
-0.0222221054,
0.0050458168,
-0.0781816989,
0.0098837567,
-0.0084602898,
0.0264252778,
0.0316549689,
0.0105269169,
0.0448400266,
0.0120488498,
-0.0055535594,
-0.0654090121,
0.093892321,
-0.0113551412,
-0.0338130556,
0.0053199017,
-0.0713621974,
0.0169545952,
0.0020245614,
0.0075725578,
0.0224936046,
0.0013100115,
0.0478212796,
-0.0428798832,
-0.0147537459,
-0.0331604108,
-0.0124473004,
0.0259967353,
-0.0279242732,
-0.0157395583,
-0.0041592559,
-0.0232890677,
-0.0051021688,
0.0388126411,
-0.0156272687,
0.0079420405,
-0.1112807095,
0.0266793314,
0.0524134487,
-0.0051714601,
-0.0517616682,
-0.0244242325,
2.147726443e-34,
-0.0430662371,
-0.0152537469,
-0.0374477096,
0.0419053994,
0.0527367964,
0.0441857278,
0.0056857523,
0.0000424435,
0.0356308259,
0.0190599449,
-0.0276323669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01582v1 | Automating Sound Change Prediction for Phylogenetic Inference: A Tukanoan Case Study | 2024-02-02T17:20:16 | 2024-02-02T17:20:16 | Kalvin Chang, Nathaniel R. Robinson, Anna Cai, Ting Chen, Annie Zhang, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe a set of new methods to partially automate linguistic
phylogenetic inference given (1) cognate sets with their respective protoforms
and sound laws, (2) a mapping from phones to their articulatory features and
(3) a typological database of sound changes. We train a neural network on these
sound change data to weight articulatory distances between phones and predict
intermediate sound change steps between historical protoforms and their modern
descendants, replacing a linguistic expert in part of a parsimony-based
phylogenetic inference algorithm. In our best experiments on Tukanoan
languages, this method produces trees with a Generalized Quartet Distance of
0.12 from a tree that used expert annotations, a significant improvement over
other semi-automated baselines. We discuss potential benefits and drawbacks to
our neural approach and parsimony-based tree prediction. We also experiment
with a minimal generalization learner for automatic sound law induction,
finding it comparably effective to sound laws from expert annotation. Our code
is publicly available at https://github.com/cmu-llab/aiscp. | Automating Sound Change Prediction for Phylogenetic Inference: A Tukanoan Case Study: We describe a set of new methods to partially automate linguistic
phylogenetic inference given (1) cognate sets with their respective protoforms
and sound laws, (2) a mapping from phones to their articulatory features and
(3) a typological database of sound changes. We train a neural network on these
sound change data to weight articulatory distances between phones and predict
intermediate sound change steps between historical protoforms and their modern
descendants, replacing a linguistic expert in part of a parsimony-based
phylogenetic inference algorithm. In our best experiments on Tukanoan
languages, this method produces trees with a Generalized Quartet Distance of
0.12 from a tree that used expert annotations, a significant improvement over
other semi-automated baselines. We discuss potential benefits and drawbacks to
our neural approach and parsimony-based tree prediction. We also experiment
with a minimal generalization learner for automatic sound law induction,
finding it comparably effective to sound laws from expert annotation. Our code
is publicly available at https://github.com/cmu-llab/aiscp. | [
-0.0105780102,
0.0839198977,
-0.0502472781,
-0.016765045,
-0.0256410427,
0.000283972,
-0.0063220984,
-0.0033268488,
-0.0661940649,
0.0017082058,
-0.0343760252,
-0.0413663499,
0.0884004012,
-0.0018646836,
0.0474803336,
-0.0206909645,
0.0159392711,
-0.0277619921,
0.041416686,
0.003504283,
-0.0356443077,
-0.0001506527,
-0.0406850539,
0.0339631289,
-0.0501862466,
-0.0268477369,
-0.0401989669,
-0.0127700716,
0.0220288262,
-0.0238400958,
-0.0193214733,
-0.0026220484,
-0.0061586364,
0.0805365741,
0.000001457,
-0.0477643125,
0.0492653102,
-0.0021327194,
-0.0409516469,
0.0257741213,
0.0045790961,
0.0760883465,
-0.008044526,
-0.024574155,
-0.0044798898,
0.0033458509,
0.0935668722,
-0.0800297931,
-0.0065316334,
0.0530766249,
-0.0023969198,
-0.0798958316,
0.058211755,
-0.0016043764,
0.0169729013,
0.0255951602,
0.0222200323,
-0.0115194982,
0.0163158588,
-0.0380878635,
0.0122958142,
0.0316862836,
-0.0047760531,
0.0069197915,
-0.0441173203,
-0.0146756712,
0.0190272406,
-0.084820956,
0.0136823216,
0.0105734905,
0.0360679179,
-0.0590774007,
-0.044103384,
0.0292174313,
-0.0355850868,
-0.0146694407,
0.0090102879,
0.0034480006,
-0.0380334891,
0.0043942807,
0.0622007251,
-0.0313186981,
0.0114727654,
-0.026633881,
-0.0077208788,
0.0363456607,
0.0490080751,
-0.0373549163,
0.0042886138,
-0.0272626095,
0.0298481714,
-0.0101449089,
0.0316449516,
0.0362080634,
-0.0288690366,
0.0018587963,
0.085768871,
-0.0149495499,
0.0237100236,
-0.0365324654,
0.0228301827,
0.0241601616,
-0.071962893,
-0.01801176,
-0.0508453213,
-0.0178460162,
0.0193502884,
-0.0713628381,
0.0215955712,
0.0027216191,
-0.0499682426,
-0.0443273969,
0.0112550538,
-0.0135876136,
-0.0181646757,
0.044550214,
0.0061572948,
-0.0348891802,
-0.0019900773,
-0.0222001858,
-0.0077337953,
-0.0407103635,
-0.0216391552,
0.0316141695,
0.0021271417,
-0.009732876,
-0.0349096693,
0.0613718964,
-0.0367689244,
-0.0820758417,
0.0149638448,
0.0102986125,
0.0100973388,
0.0490283966,
0.0170308258,
0.0471902452,
-0.0129842684,
-0.0048222481,
-0.007399796,
0.0046636174,
-0.0616227575,
0.0178886876,
-0.0458842777,
-0.0289844628,
0.0282634143,
-0.026263576,
-0.0330675468,
-0.0236166213,
-0.0495930463,
-0.0509621464,
-0.0002843318,
0.0269383453,
-0.0510784537,
0.0444085374,
0.0407544747,
-0.0069307019,
-0.0010551219,
-0.0088922679,
0.0426727943,
-0.0341676995,
0.0384440683,
-0.0403576978,
-0.0586614907,
0.0159283504,
-0.0201166477,
-0.0393148325,
-0.0052121724,
-0.0280740988,
-0.00244382,
0.0249631498,
-0.0062312786,
0.0193599612,
-0.008298967,
-0.0320516042,
0.0060455841,
0.0653180256,
0.0438778847,
0.0471150056,
0.0785749927,
-0.0507325493,
-0.0085171517,
0.0131996134,
0.0265223309,
-0.0390349105,
-0.0262792222,
-0.0121920258,
-0.0351421572,
0.0165617,
0.0070173796,
-0.0188272316,
0.0005163079,
-0.0312323309,
-0.036105331,
-0.0208135657,
0.0330255777,
0.0173293762,
0.0038876638,
0.0128128706,
0.0411625393,
-0.0120704239,
-0.0155268619,
-0.0125450063,
0.1070073768,
-0.0042664902,
-0.0460451581,
-0.0657505915,
0.0165947266,
0.045703847,
-0.0159381609,
0.0484184027,
0.0020792382,
-0.0519415885,
0.012610429,
-0.0099595832,
-0.009007562,
0.0417032912,
0.0477300882,
0.0673868358,
-0.0202550646,
0.0514193922,
0.0311386362,
-0.0311814882,
0.0051015629,
0.0198002513,
-0.033179149,
-0.0119788088,
-0.006844088,
0.0181764755,
0.0442665666,
0.0553507544,
-0.0112070451,
0.0232341327,
0.0210353378,
-0.00258649,
0.0283610746,
0.0319978148,
-0.0394549929,
0.0222318172,
0.0975090191,
0.0216068272,
0.0126525043,
-0.0325189121,
0.0266940538,
-0.0246127546,
0.0515042543,
-0.0419932827,
0.0683517754,
-0.0078483988,
0.0260805879,
-0.0614125878,
-0.0223798137,
0.0050648465,
0.0426585712,
0.0769914612,
0.0068614399,
-0.0051214406,
-0.0245208628,
0.0116686057,
-0.0326912478,
0.0173165537,
0.0232233666,
-0.017372014,
-0.0650062263,
0.0032167458,
-0.027680546,
-0.0145247215,
0.0222718194,
-0.0540063605,
-0.0367931947,
-0.0066776942,
0.0904065594,
-0.0161886755,
-0.0024237083,
-0.0020751012,
-0.0179347601,
0.0071228668,
0.0043471651,
-0.057312455,
0.0159878395,
0.002532677,
-0.034768194,
-0.0263460968,
-0.05002198,
-0.0276528466,
0.0040419959,
0.0510953255,
0.0175625868,
-0.0748655796,
-0.0336450972,
-0.0702854618,
-0.0813017413,
-0.0039427513,
0.0091047361,
0.001892342,
0.0208821222,
-0.0156900808,
0.008617931,
-0.0466454364,
-0.0351308919,
-0.0589177199,
0.0434578359,
-0.012418732,
-0.0167524163,
-0.0220094733,
-0.0153828328,
0.0116274161,
-0.0405972973,
-0.0079690255,
-0.0379850455,
0.0673025027,
-0.0042266157,
-0.0355141275,
-0.023271231,
-0.0195443071,
0.0164891854,
0.0153927431,
0.0443531722,
-0.067254439,
-0.0260577239,
0.0423867628,
-0.0379413851,
-0.0401302725,
0.0886608809,
-0.0274056531,
-0.017840296,
-0.007857224,
-0.0251565445,
-0.0569122471,
0.0911549777,
0.0173647683,
-0.0206868704,
0.0428795107,
-0.0279050563,
-0.0103660598,
0.0317124017,
0.0752085373,
0.0004726201,
-0.0083787721,
-0.0687764436,
0.0217593051,
-0.0149092581,
0.0115374606,
0.0096203322,
0.0610107705,
-0.0481399931,
0.0301801022,
-0.030477941,
-0.0144912265,
0.0439048186,
0.0257313643,
-0.0172792692,
0.0237410199,
0.0252781752,
0.0484673865,
0.0044196402,
0.0648832321,
-0.0167882871,
0.049703043,
-0.0139385005,
0.0409044288,
0.0855578333,
-0.0272455551,
-0.0107287923,
0.0269511864,
-0.0671601444,
0.0202616248,
-0.0057817642,
-0.0216491949,
-0.0411792882,
0.0004247678,
-0.0026962636,
0.0186570659,
0.0358777232,
0.0295832027,
0.0261562392,
0.0339358672,
0.0466415547,
0.0062177903,
0.0234527923,
0.0003512822,
-0.0303548407,
-0.0504141338,
0.0002107437,
0.0184935667,
0.0111681009,
0.0380371772,
-0.0425171331,
0.0225363355,
-0.0842507929,
-0.0158577207,
0.0305276196,
-0.0510166958,
0.0239439551,
-0.0451028459,
0.0147616314,
-0.002219042,
-0.0437959842,
0.0669901222,
0.0160267726,
0.007398589,
0.0349636786,
-0.0919240415,
-0.0149616851,
0.0040760264,
-0.0348951072,
-0.0095588639,
0.0489650629,
0.031418696,
-0.029624844,
-0.0285020154,
0.0870629847,
-0.0130293863,
0.014130502,
-0.0135285296,
-0.0112405913,
0.1066821069,
0.0311327688,
0.0387955494,
0.0107234754,
-0.0025679518,
0.0033354159,
0.0443028323,
0.0853626058,
0.0092047909,
-0.0618355013,
0.01430084,
0.0107185962,
-0.0492636338,
0.0014669455,
0.0287852995,
-0.0234331638,
-0.004428538,
-0.0106528345,
0.007172761,
0.0315998942,
0.0104527026,
0.0187405292,
0.0067312075,
-0.0858913064,
-0.1082845479,
0.0139265619,
0.0127368653,
0.0157096144,
0.0561563,
-0.0267137531,
-0.0122253839,
-0.0082975151,
-0.0380215496,
-0.0032293273,
0.0345067531,
0.0253232978,
0.0037460811,
0.004835302,
0.0761858299,
0.0062711495,
-0.0040614363,
-0.0041069645,
0.0121544134,
-0.0798859671,
-0.0044512944,
0.0062333373,
0.016459344,
0.0238640215,
0.0180261638,
-0.0499269888,
0.0147660142,
0.0267817229,
-0.0061675566,
0.0260007046,
0.0441535674,
-0.0471157506,
-0.0128829051,
0.0255516842,
-0.0491623245,
0.0200578794,
-0.0064489059,
0.013417148,
0.0020503819,
-0.0313303322,
0.0155377807,
0.0011676741,
0.0295151379,
-0.0388709866,
-0.0469013564,
-0.0045572254,
0.015806945,
0.0378897041,
0.0211557839,
-0.005324658,
0.0163396914,
-0.0123898732,
0.0715558454,
0.0024511453,
-0.038258303,
0.0293651186,
0.0346057601,
-0.0091064917,
0.0682263523,
0.0775173903,
0.0818450451,
-0.0248615742,
-0.0038174808,
-0.0194695164,
0.049197726,
-0.0658038333,
0.0357976072,
-0.0168015156,
-0.0331315249,
0.0047959895,
0.0174831767,
0.0030322385,
-0.0260622352,
0.0138549982,
-0.0105180517,
0.0069527114,
0.0145000238,
0.0494824313,
0.0043114559,
0.0248967744,
-0.0235879309,
-0.0210713502,
0.007892468,
0.0210663248,
-0.041788999,
-0.0290023182,
-0.0292962845,
0.0231718849,
-0.0348552838,
0.0367103592,
0.0037172458,
-0.0220691934,
0.0455890484,
-0.0270554572,
0.010528069,
0.012412739,
-0.0389256887,
-0.0385772772,
-0.0014348899,
-0.0383557007,
-0.0513093211,
-0.0235458557,
-0.0577363297,
-0.0019897541,
0.0200339798,
0.0102038505,
0.0249017142,
0.0476866215,
0.023808578,
0.0313575342,
0.0227887258,
0.0071381833,
-0.0238776598,
-0.008741051,
0.0298204925,
-0.0140620396,
-4.533887589e-33,
0.0048442031,
0.0022634317,
-0.0130657107,
0.0464914255,
-0.0070660901,
-0.0081740683,
-0.0393335335,
0.0039472049,
-0.0305677261,
0.0137478998,
0.0542987883,
-0.0096242661,
-0.0125950258,
-0.0457062721,
0.0448608771,
0.0429313593,
0.0267479829,
-0.0312941745,
0.036834728,
-0.0118954387,
0.0242095701,
0.0049970779,
0.0612584241,
-0.0411411859,
0.0233465377,
0.0650591031,
0.0058779656,
0.0062174085,
-0.0626266599,
-0.0033549792,
0.0059523289,
0.0231927261,
-0.0206991509,
0.0319062695,
0.0267693121,
-0.0423702002,
-0.0855232477,
-0.0292866714,
-0.0029422662,
0.0092305159,
0.0124303233,
0.0133464038,
0.0358613096,
0.0178146604,
-0.0257803891,
0.0180217717,
0.0242715459,
-0.0842688307,
-0.0023997265,
-0.0396666713,
-0.0460155308,
0.0495702438,
-0.0216144193,
-0.004440892,
0.0219013859,
0.0710750148,
-0.0215327106,
-0.0222679544,
-0.0312050506,
0.0885926336,
0.0270860009,
-0.0236561429,
0.0441197753,
0.0021830553,
-0.0374059789,
0.0081086149,
0.1108283326,
-0.0694368407,
0.0111505687,
0.0343453735,
0.0016624202,
0.0282007009,
0.0196280796,
-0.0306640081,
0.0334424712,
-0.0368318297,
-0.0282298401,
-0.0238899067,
0.0669459701,
-0.0066031953,
-0.0384753309,
0.0355448313,
-0.0196133107,
0.0008429234,
-0.0086693224,
-0.0591366403,
-0.0067268079,
-0.0254390985,
-0.0300028771,
-0.0486914515,
0.0415925905,
0.0385655165,
-0.0194978788,
-0.0082133422,
-0.0093472432,
-0.0344167128,
-0.0260906983,
0.0081451591,
0.0035837463,
0.022970438,
0.0230665971,
-0.002102705,
0.0348955765,
0.0067757573,
0.0286627375,
-0.0203874446,
-0.0134568401,
0.0555506758,
-0.0338959768,
-0.0012692609,
0.0141037107,
-0.0972989127,
0.0119475154,
0.0368036591,
0.0447395593,
0.018892888,
0.0209165327,
-0.0214826483,
0.0528339632,
0.0219968744,
-0.0163908694,
0.0286271032,
-0.0633163601,
-0.0121223247,
-0.0211624186,
0.0012536183,
0.0329366215,
0.0374997742,
-0.0325340889,
0.0012755835,
-0.00444277,
0.0367342271,
2.488e-7,
0.0207335819,
-0.0124932304,
0.0655082315,
-0.0114580616,
0.0346695781,
-0.0285227634,
-0.0487660877,
-0.0549960136,
0.0084571522,
-0.033825241,
0.0302883312,
-0.0287746377,
0.0709166974,
0.0571746752,
-0.0548558198,
-0.0205272511,
-0.1239747033,
-0.0113770477,
-0.0606073663,
-0.0129073905,
-0.0220222063,
0.0749799609,
-0.0209161472,
-0.076401554,
-0.0133043639,
0.019796798,
0.0106731234,
-0.0087705683,
0.0372907035,
-0.0359815508,
0.0135680595,
-0.09989959,
0.0099811936,
-0.0005475855,
-0.0467339121,
0.0247703847,
-0.0103982603,
-0.0328604728,
-0.001263147,
0.0186980981,
0.0343078487,
0.0348849595,
-0.0255045351,
-0.018911818,
0.0158706158,
0.0540241413,
-0.0027811958,
-0.0203539524,
-0.0351739936,
0.0198997669,
0.0051254919,
0.0052685346,
0.0464521609,
0.0041957893,
-0.0017912552,
-0.0117386561,
-0.0284972955,
-0.0182760041,
-0.0311844144,
0.0578911453,
-0.046570681,
-0.0394064486,
0.0056590466,
0.0006483882,
0.0099972859,
0.0142074665,
0.0245691892,
1.674546689e-34,
0.0011804424,
-0.0335387215,
0.0339708664,
0.0175738577,
-0.0257921852,
-0.0422667079,
0.0542261824,
0.0439414792,
0.0523653068,
-0.0075834938,
-0.0194200967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01579v1 | How Paralingual are Paralinguistic Representations? A Case Study in Speech Emotion Recognition | 2024-02-02T17:17:42 | 2024-02-02T17:17:42 | Orchid Chetia Phukan, Gautam Siddharth Kashyap, Arun Balaji Buduru, Rajesh Sharma | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Pre-trained Models (PTMs) have facilitated substantial progress in the field
of Speech Emotion Recognition (SER). SER is an area with applications ranging
from HumanComputer Interaction to Healthcare. Recent studies have leveraged
various PTM representations as input features for downstream models for SER.
PTM specifically pre-trained for paralinguistic tasks have obtained
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for SER. However, such PTM haven't been
evaluated for SER in multilingual settings and experimented only with English.
So, we fill this gap, by performing a comprehensive comparative study of five
PTMs (TRILLsson, wav2vec2, XLS-R, x-vector, Whisper) for assessing the
effectiveness of paralingual PTM (TRILLsson) for SER across multiple languages.
Representations from TRILLsson achieved the best performance among all the
PTMs. This demonstrates that TRILLsson is able to effectively capture the
various paralinguistic features from speech data for better SER. We also show
that downstream models using TRILLsson representations achieve SOTA performance
in terms of accuracy across various multi-lingual datasets. | How Paralingual are Paralinguistic Representations? A Case Study in Speech Emotion Recognition: Pre-trained Models (PTMs) have facilitated substantial progress in the field
of Speech Emotion Recognition (SER). SER is an area with applications ranging
from HumanComputer Interaction to Healthcare. Recent studies have leveraged
various PTM representations as input features for downstream models for SER.
PTM specifically pre-trained for paralinguistic tasks have obtained
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for SER. However, such PTM haven't been
evaluated for SER in multilingual settings and experimented only with English.
So, we fill this gap, by performing a comprehensive comparative study of five
PTMs (TRILLsson, wav2vec2, XLS-R, x-vector, Whisper) for assessing the
effectiveness of paralingual PTM (TRILLsson) for SER across multiple languages.
Representations from TRILLsson achieved the best performance among all the
PTMs. This demonstrates that TRILLsson is able to effectively capture the
various paralinguistic features from speech data for better SER. We also show
that downstream models using TRILLsson representations achieve SOTA performance
in terms of accuracy across various multi-lingual datasets. | [
-0.0125423633,
0.0260122642,
-0.001478228,
0.028922718,
0.0032057874,
0.0247347765,
0.0230450444,
-0.034025982,
-0.0357043222,
-0.041136235,
-0.1098840162,
-0.0042461152,
0.0017460128,
-0.0323228948,
-0.0068028462,
-0.0891902894,
0.053706985,
0.008529217,
0.0304777082,
-0.0228382926,
0.0114877075,
0.0173852071,
-0.0459849723,
0.0444826744,
0.0205380265,
0.0100630326,
-0.0303545184,
0.014339665,
0.0191279631,
-0.0145347426,
0.0044295043,
0.0221026428,
0.0325399451,
0.0189313069,
0.0000020274,
-0.0238552708,
0.0039207139,
-0.0152095212,
-0.0196235515,
0.0326647796,
0.0724798739,
0.0144540267,
-0.0275157075,
0.00819516,
-0.0213067196,
-0.0198558662,
0.0526827276,
0.0215942562,
0.0672783032,
0.0212977026,
-0.0254328903,
0.0101513909,
0.0112954043,
0.0056312722,
-0.006117173,
-0.0125707705,
-0.0216253325,
-0.034839116,
0.0204477403,
-0.0613909513,
-0.0252546091,
0.0489170216,
-0.007642501,
0.0373020209,
-0.038629923,
-0.0090390313,
-0.0186745469,
-0.0533698462,
-0.0356882848,
0.0499909185,
-0.0841152593,
0.000940131,
-0.053916581,
0.0013682815,
-0.0251070727,
-0.0308362264,
-0.0131426975,
-0.0227775685,
0.0345612541,
-0.0120089436,
0.0211744066,
0.0707693174,
-0.0113827484,
-0.0033107388,
0.0138980672,
0.0113515705,
-0.0037761584,
-0.033019267,
0.0518586971,
-0.0155366482,
0.0040458441,
0.0481835008,
0.0107644843,
-0.0387076586,
-0.0266750194,
-0.0019163386,
-0.006081976,
-0.0686013848,
-0.0182689149,
-0.0827206597,
0.0337560289,
0.0187827386,
-0.094481051,
-0.0039266017,
-0.0130579537,
0.0436938405,
-0.0074519855,
0.0129816644,
-0.0138576301,
-0.0064407303,
-0.0271304045,
0.0358546674,
-0.0107619464,
0.0354963765,
-0.0166259725,
-0.0058844467,
-0.0803157613,
-0.0023612112,
-0.0394074544,
-0.0009948049,
0.0204828661,
0.0084320223,
0.0115438281,
0.0151469791,
0.0073208571,
0.0423211008,
0.0080455011,
0.056808956,
-0.0548374541,
-0.1051121354,
0.0518352091,
-0.0041667246,
0.0263984613,
-0.0220062826,
0.0542699397,
0.0378821753,
0.0001799297,
-0.0584315248,
-0.031461481,
0.0239010472,
0.0059408359,
-0.0716127381,
0.0052798074,
-0.0129842116,
0.0604441538,
-0.0072459914,
0.0279935841,
-0.0348325633,
-0.0141542815,
-0.0335487872,
-0.0283873901,
0.0573670566,
0.0044848383,
0.0057376851,
-0.0033950573,
0.0047316179,
-0.0094915312,
0.035137184,
0.0144554088,
0.0295934994,
0.026420312,
-0.0680450127,
-0.0075196647,
0.0143005811,
0.003265382,
-0.0366952308,
-0.0247388855,
-0.009265027,
0.03697877,
-0.0024754221,
0.0610131174,
0.0154564446,
-0.0095490757,
-0.0451922305,
0.0670393109,
0.0585398823,
0.0005857421,
0.0182407666,
0.0498761088,
-0.0027074362,
0.0416627862,
-0.0234404877,
-0.0382145159,
-0.014227083,
-0.0255585425,
0.0057074763,
0.0066506821,
0.0130999433,
-0.0375168435,
-0.0425880812,
-0.0044877683,
-0.0424206629,
-0.0176677965,
0.0456223004,
0.0391194858,
-0.0367797315,
-0.0444824696,
0.0410680212,
0.0275026914,
-0.0788936242,
0.0204033181,
-0.0277946871,
-0.0048043705,
0.0609198101,
-0.0299898349,
-0.0257254243,
-0.0138525497,
-0.0381722525,
0.0089050634,
0.0057109133,
0.0151484674,
0.0234656874,
0.1172498614,
-0.0438345149,
0.0037096695,
-0.0028708472,
-0.0050698956,
0.0451241955,
-0.024969494,
0.059171807,
-0.0151642468,
0.001226784,
-0.0015677885,
-0.0140434438,
-0.0592924394,
-0.0500797741,
-0.0097837048,
-0.0011395544,
0.063688077,
0.0530509427,
-0.0401794016,
-0.0043082619,
0.0279203746,
-0.0325545855,
0.0483017787,
0.0645908564,
-0.0069615203,
-0.0193692744,
0.0269632302,
0.0183253419,
0.0214619525,
0.0695608705,
-0.019991694,
-0.0161725301,
0.0700783655,
-0.0026941947,
0.0668025687,
-0.0488342196,
0.0031368705,
-0.0451492481,
0.0581844412,
0.0596855134,
-0.036515411,
0.0159737915,
0.008642721,
-0.0263672397,
0.0118746981,
-0.0082005244,
-0.0285364259,
-0.0699115247,
0.0175052248,
-0.0071898247,
0.0294259526,
-0.0012985438,
-0.0274629146,
-0.0027707356,
-0.0347162858,
-0.092547901,
-0.0147831142,
-0.0022916528,
-0.0017111944,
-0.0254075788,
-0.0033912261,
-0.0381645598,
-0.0307694469,
-0.0399409942,
-0.0062351101,
0.0235220417,
0.0106599024,
-0.0245177373,
-0.0225149244,
-0.0102528287,
-0.0718362182,
0.0311999843,
0.0089409174,
0.0076098903,
-0.0298512261,
0.0002740909,
-0.0134948622,
0.0060503688,
-0.0234055966,
0.0266163833,
0.0145970974,
-0.0720373765,
-0.0174931753,
-0.021079272,
-0.0025899927,
-0.0015455491,
-0.0275857616,
0.0446572229,
0.0270508491,
-0.0194945484,
-0.0278426558,
0.0381853841,
-0.0113640968,
-0.0282607712,
-0.023098154,
-0.0002397866,
-0.0326263867,
0.0529705025,
0.0291420333,
0.0168547761,
-0.0486526266,
-0.0039139749,
0.0118822251,
-0.0267301779,
-0.0243475996,
-0.0192504879,
-0.0246548709,
0.0121408869,
0.0444205627,
-0.0430428945,
0.0132618481,
-0.0751890242,
-0.0608335659,
-0.0885160416,
-0.0226056967,
-0.0165267065,
0.0480820462,
-0.0587390549,
0.0076670572,
-0.0290379059,
-0.0053908387,
-0.0023105592,
-0.0075042499,
-0.0118478015,
-0.0702229291,
-0.0029569077,
0.0098908227,
-0.0430811755,
0.0305906516,
-0.0185634289,
-0.0126276957,
-0.046945639,
-0.0620219223,
0.0082582599,
-0.0350758061,
0.0135632912,
0.0034901383,
0.0023371056,
0.0287481397,
-0.0121410592,
0.0133281332,
-0.0014426868,
0.0004701586,
0.0050234972,
-0.0018680235,
0.0566698425,
0.0095392875,
0.024454318,
0.0283568408,
0.0023616247,
0.08554212,
-0.0134947691,
-0.039563369,
0.0585712455,
0.024951268,
0.0145480139,
-0.0091979727,
-0.0001745118,
-0.0192998368,
-0.0390959159,
0.0807887167,
0.1149859652,
-0.0025306297,
-0.041324053,
0.0025641434,
-0.0101302564,
-0.0141878258,
0.0142139392,
-0.0017692165,
-0.0007742757,
-0.0002801388,
0.0055397172,
0.0181813128,
0.007695002,
0.0066781868,
0.0040430888,
-0.0691522285,
0.0564360432,
0.021283228,
-0.0004818424,
-0.0386764817,
-0.0301003046,
-0.0133160884,
-0.0195739809,
0.0542613231,
-0.0498567149,
-0.0234824456,
-0.0385988951,
0.0412179902,
-0.0448882505,
-0.0425419286,
0.0567906611,
-0.038457647,
0.0043728156,
0.0022789035,
0.0546958297,
-0.0245272312,
-0.0843693838,
0.0114217177,
-0.0075526494,
-0.0050876145,
-0.0195201915,
0.0069659087,
0.0248913821,
-0.0219359826,
0.0070586051,
0.0081442455,
-0.0557696484,
0.0139794825,
-0.0226855706,
0.0829183087,
-0.037530534,
-0.0043026013,
0.0060921926,
0.0642920285,
0.0417820476,
0.046884995,
0.0272820108,
-0.0344910212,
-0.0366815962,
0.0278789531,
0.0325371884,
0.0470184609,
-0.0574016944,
0.0341046713,
-0.0141226947,
-0.0484264567,
-0.0286815297,
-0.070839718,
-0.013797855,
0.0447515883,
-0.0065882625,
0.0331856161,
-0.029857967,
0.0031573998,
-0.0474286675,
0.0392817482,
0.0672838166,
0.0163059831,
0.0001558774,
0.008593481,
0.0443137325,
-0.0127426656,
-0.0351237282,
-0.0284345113,
-0.0312996842,
-0.0586384311,
0.0530966036,
0.0303687789,
0.0094367415,
0.0207308251,
-0.0068763867,
-0.0247417688,
0.0735817626,
-0.0128972093,
-0.0587273613,
0.0255560651,
0.0986052454,
0.0230513886,
-0.0367048196,
0.0077662249,
-0.0141144833,
0.0311786272,
0.0106980288,
-0.016464524,
0.0326597728,
-0.0218683556,
-0.035954114,
0.0252782535,
0.0945682228,
0.0140889203,
-0.0003383172,
-0.0233874377,
0.0208496563,
-0.0214037895,
0.0790210813,
-0.0468742959,
-0.0610616617,
0.0022911397,
0.0127301421,
-0.0383245982,
-0.0256363899,
-0.0364021286,
-0.0209126305,
0.0144051295,
0.0766877607,
0.01539151,
0.0278394502,
-0.0076952684,
0.0599016249,
0.001070796,
0.0693937466,
-0.0132027036,
-0.0088171083,
-0.0273981392,
0.00831345,
-0.0159006175,
-0.003812369,
0.008043726,
0.0505537391,
-0.0140735479,
-0.0711788982,
-0.0089116422,
-0.0164211728,
0.047889404,
-0.0153947445,
0.0814615339,
-0.0242425576,
0.0401399992,
-0.003712324,
0.0133779738,
-0.069623597,
0.0118456408,
0.0175985601,
-0.035529986,
-0.0458194837,
-0.018204039,
0.0249278378,
0.0245144628,
0.049889259,
0.0062826467,
0.0093800221,
-0.0412115939,
-0.0333244652,
0.0387809128,
-0.0221748445,
-0.0286490899,
0.0261674877,
-0.0591234863,
-0.0554948375,
0.0263811275,
-0.0387934893,
-0.0382993482,
-0.0361361839,
0.0274423603,
0.0469745733,
-0.0119163087,
0.0290179513,
0.0044557233,
-0.0196096208,
-0.041202832,
-0.0275038164,
0.0547266528,
-6.242424546e-33,
0.0109141702,
0.039991349,
-0.0306752138,
0.0329567641,
-0.02566378,
0.0354660116,
-0.0247191563,
0.0242857467,
-0.0107667409,
0.0083438242,
0.0011595188,
-0.0210221279,
0.0237315353,
-0.0012656035,
0.013564501,
-0.0438455231,
0.0355652496,
-0.0313013121,
0.0602009557,
0.0015884117,
0.0299438648,
0.0479357354,
0.0917505771,
-0.0887114108,
0.0203773919,
0.0307678822,
-0.00073526,
-0.0257419273,
0.0619393401,
0.0348301493,
-0.0198752508,
0.0747433454,
-0.0107466178,
0.0164695345,
-0.0171288773,
0.0149060637,
-0.0443280749,
-0.033223141,
0.0235335361,
0.0518935584,
-0.0467326604,
-0.0065427101,
0.0050710612,
0.0299025606,
-0.0421808846,
-0.0084738936,
-0.0023960879,
-0.0256677661,
0.031181274,
-0.0474843644,
-0.0376564413,
0.0009333645,
-0.0086171562,
0.0127584441,
0.0842900723,
0.0847773254,
-0.0320665836,
0.0151458615,
-0.0519863218,
-0.0187792815,
-0.0184652414,
-0.0088875536,
0.0452907644,
-0.0464095958,
0.0118424119,
0.0559744313,
0.066521816,
-0.0215175021,
0.019816855,
0.060270641,
0.0490928665,
0.0669392198,
0.0374610685,
0.0373114049,
-0.0216617603,
-0.0012653937,
0.0072676595,
-0.0078970557,
0.0779443383,
-0.0027192372,
0.0348127522,
0.0124092018,
-0.0162106529,
-0.0046833451,
-0.0535254702,
-0.0362626091,
-0.0167981908,
-0.0677228644,
0.0651034564,
-0.0428401791,
0.0436527468,
0.0094581982,
0.049566403,
-0.0047731805,
0.0129966568,
0.0114914319,
-0.009699597,
0.0280828513,
0.0083880825,
0.0116195614,
-0.0153527642,
-0.0213659182,
0.001660466,
0.0047068996,
0.0851477981,
-0.0303212348,
-0.038429182,
0.0457974635,
-0.0277456976,
-0.0065588942,
-0.0063151899,
0.03798398,
0.0169803072,
0.0069525074,
0.0303130895,
0.0242117327,
-0.013885037,
0.0010250174,
-0.0200243946,
-0.014532824,
-0.0143623473,
-0.0035436554,
0.0143036591,
0.0596341118,
-0.0305624641,
-0.0036630493,
-0.0154602071,
-0.0123803383,
0.0406165458,
-0.0334656425,
0.0002158731,
-0.0097788256,
2.879e-7,
-0.007346882,
0.0247797072,
0.0300287642,
-0.0415425226,
-0.001463018,
0.0227082558,
-0.0295401886,
0.0277098417,
0.0183952786,
0.0045892466,
-0.001310386,
-0.0116961589,
0.090712294,
0.0509984791,
-0.0683324561,
-0.0580915436,
-0.0686381012,
0.0256698895,
-0.0226055328,
0.0340778716,
0.0664099827,
0.0970511287,
0.0213696938,
-0.0240722578,
0.0009591618,
0.0198849831,
0.0232984349,
-0.0627769828,
-0.0350766107,
-0.0024297333,
-0.0298212375,
-0.0572571494,
-0.0171046685,
0.0160439219,
-0.0180923436,
0.0511512123,
0.0125667676,
0.0409239791,
-0.0067239488,
-0.0878740251,
0.0212754477,
0.0342464596,
-0.0433860235,
-0.0741081908,
0.0440713726,
0.0009455445,
-0.0270000529,
0.0128149102,
-0.0193135738,
0.0191089083,
0.0596001334,
-0.0486945808,
-0.0053570666,
0.0359211713,
-0.0036785305,
-0.0355689339,
-0.0347390063,
-0.0360308886,
-0.0092037879,
0.0617932901,
-0.0464824438,
-0.0366504304,
-0.0210171491,
0.0102901738,
0.0649038628,
-0.0194837339,
0.0048380848,
2.038760183e-34,
0.0179323759,
-0.0441341177,
0.0372802727,
0.0317684449,
0.005322109,
-0.0057227719,
0.0603152178,
0.0169586055,
0.0452413633,
-0.0086844973,
0.0096969139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01577v1 | Deep Active Learning for Data Mining from Conflict Text Corpora | 2024-02-02T17:16:23 | 2024-02-02T17:16:23 | Mihai Croicu | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, stat.ML | High-resolution event data on armed conflict and related processes have
revolutionized the study of political contention with datasets like UCDP GED,
ACLED etc. However, most of these datasets limit themselves to collecting
spatio-temporal (high-resolution) and intensity data. Information on dynamics,
such as targets, tactics, purposes etc. are rarely collected owing to the
extreme workload of collecting data. However, most datasets rely on a rich
corpus of textual data allowing further mining of further information connected
to each event. This paper proposes one such approach that is inexpensive and
high performance, leveraging active learning - an iterative process of
improving a machine learning model based on sequential (guided) human input.
Active learning is employed to then step-wise train (fine-tuning) of a large,
encoder-only language model adapted for extracting sub-classes of events
relating to conflict dynamics. The approach shows performance similar to human
(gold-standard) coding while reducing the amount of required human annotation
by as much as 99%. | Deep Active Learning for Data Mining from Conflict Text Corpora: High-resolution event data on armed conflict and related processes have
revolutionized the study of political contention with datasets like UCDP GED,
ACLED etc. However, most of these datasets limit themselves to collecting
spatio-temporal (high-resolution) and intensity data. Information on dynamics,
such as targets, tactics, purposes etc. are rarely collected owing to the
extreme workload of collecting data. However, most datasets rely on a rich
corpus of textual data allowing further mining of further information connected
to each event. This paper proposes one such approach that is inexpensive and
high performance, leveraging active learning - an iterative process of
improving a machine learning model based on sequential (guided) human input.
Active learning is employed to then step-wise train (fine-tuning) of a large,
encoder-only language model adapted for extracting sub-classes of events
relating to conflict dynamics. The approach shows performance similar to human
(gold-standard) coding while reducing the amount of required human annotation
by as much as 99%. | [
0.012718414,
0.0518015027,
0.0028687483,
0.0068274057,
0.0077497223,
0.0383959673,
0.0215986427,
-0.0257779993,
0.0010689301,
-0.0323537365,
0.0591488332,
-0.0217339788,
-0.0227274839,
0.0738808513,
0.000513616,
-0.0553740337,
0.0416610613,
-0.017476961,
0.053716708,
0.007124153,
-0.0212819502,
-0.001902084,
-0.0465981364,
0.0160410516,
-0.0387298763,
0.0477224961,
-0.0641089603,
-0.0344642885,
0.0236132294,
-0.0094971145,
-0.0031155332,
0.0093904985,
0.0518899821,
0.0318118706,
0.0000020048,
-0.040219672,
-0.0094490079,
-0.0365008637,
-0.0357049331,
0.0073725875,
0.0203294251,
-0.0311308336,
-0.0036493021,
-0.0088527156,
-0.0501417182,
-0.0429288819,
0.0268156622,
0.01560893,
0.0690351427,
0.0717699602,
-0.019013932,
-0.0134184863,
0.0314062349,
-0.0129636442,
-0.0535713881,
-0.0283252262,
0.0168204978,
-0.0203792341,
-0.0370084569,
0.0384929255,
0.0281024296,
0.0262595769,
0.028169645,
0.0005384561,
-0.0272923857,
0.0259990245,
-0.0422969237,
0.0277804956,
0.0253012013,
0.0141998054,
0.0018890235,
-0.0112054637,
0.0130581539,
-0.029596325,
-0.01731373,
-0.013022163,
0.0006836642,
-0.0117043806,
-0.0190282706,
0.0326157585,
0.023684822,
-0.000530335,
0.0026098504,
0.0165932234,
-0.0155701637,
-0.006298949,
-0.0448184423,
-0.0228049047,
0.0349432305,
0.0121135078,
-0.0221630987,
-0.0208702795,
0.0196469352,
0.0352880433,
-0.0437097512,
-0.0163747706,
-0.0210784711,
-0.0192645267,
0.0138223069,
-0.1004735082,
-0.0258020647,
-0.0098031648,
-0.0225630179,
0.0765552819,
0.0215289705,
-0.0181361418,
0.0254128166,
0.0302036572,
0.0159865227,
-0.0212553386,
-0.0775792673,
0.0008692505,
-0.0145367514,
0.0323161073,
0.0077458108,
-0.0082175629,
-0.0639916509,
-0.0134237455,
-0.0037875588,
0.0109044965,
-0.0174964573,
0.0058173202,
-0.0503654219,
-0.0076755336,
-0.035831999,
-0.0178637579,
-0.0332038105,
0.0451862141,
-0.0367414728,
-0.0555986799,
0.0337165445,
-0.0113040237,
0.0131858392,
-0.00104226,
-0.0061840392,
0.0495316945,
-0.0417400338,
-0.0065239337,
-0.0697824731,
0.0249172673,
0.0492125005,
0.0165431648,
0.005563987,
-0.069825545,
0.035700798,
-0.0313231163,
0.0031114714,
-0.0658108294,
-0.0109255807,
-0.0060498794,
-0.0267068371,
0.067042686,
-0.0502155684,
0.0017478118,
0.0572198965,
-0.0100134229,
0.0340837836,
0.0844845846,
0.0671837553,
0.0348979309,
0.0670105964,
-0.0073822537,
0.009783892,
0.013559781,
-0.0284277219,
0.0210828874,
-0.0567081757,
0.0146038188,
-0.0699171647,
-0.0196259264,
-0.0296844468,
-0.0243717525,
-0.0101735257,
-0.0434969738,
0.061208263,
-0.0048809717,
-0.0512012839,
0.0105266795,
0.0206430107,
0.0472815298,
0.021693591,
-0.0185693633,
0.0371261314,
-0.0066252947,
-0.0195459854,
-0.0418623351,
0.0188476928,
0.0335407667,
-0.0249148477,
-0.0427408516,
-0.0016643803,
-0.0318775438,
0.014975246,
0.024132669,
0.0608004667,
-0.0133694932,
-0.0010864657,
0.0220361408,
0.0816202611,
-0.0296013746,
0.0061697508,
-0.0399589054,
-0.0354080945,
0.0072236937,
0.0167059489,
-0.0752805918,
-0.0776035413,
-0.0823571309,
0.0678142533,
-0.0054528397,
0.0223942138,
-0.0254432242,
0.0526147336,
-0.0550173372,
-0.0480444469,
0.0245596804,
0.0104575055,
-0.0012813543,
-0.0096147535,
0.0062400498,
-0.0184892509,
0.0226504933,
-0.0653640851,
0.0598803423,
0.0024106819,
-0.0433004126,
0.0271846745,
0.0419086926,
0.0596171878,
0.0272260047,
-0.0013345224,
-0.0388088413,
0.0389115736,
-0.0344794095,
-0.0048819911,
0.0065267948,
0.0585307032,
0.0853112042,
0.0037337013,
-0.009205414,
-0.0266558994,
0.0008847169,
-0.0296241362,
-0.0068008243,
0.0006606212,
-0.0186336115,
-0.0425654277,
-0.0118216285,
0.0142179355,
-0.0304610897,
-0.0005605925,
-0.0710969046,
0.0753246546,
-0.0072077322,
-0.0157191176,
0.0270722788,
-0.0309489165,
0.0591665991,
-0.0099374866,
0.0036595494,
0.0353932567,
-0.0092989402,
-0.0030213643,
0.0273816772,
-0.0246914197,
0.0169882327,
-0.027634548,
-0.0275957175,
-0.0107512306,
-0.0196039136,
-0.010778442,
0.051572226,
-0.0226866808,
-0.0244551208,
0.0118577471,
0.0164447092,
0.0100846393,
-0.0278176647,
0.0043156482,
0.0259758625,
0.0114595825,
0.0430736765,
-0.0413397476,
-0.0081480639,
-0.0164489541,
0.0566553846,
0.0322758108,
-0.046867311,
-0.0111735836,
0.0187197924,
-0.0204335544,
0.0535800718,
-0.0394415855,
-0.0773360282,
0.0570876412,
-0.0231049899,
-0.0390927643,
0.0331594981,
0.038773071,
0.1083377451,
0.0349942856,
-0.0264865197,
-0.0307111815,
0.0325515345,
-0.0717323869,
-0.0345295332,
-0.0667198747,
-0.0131583884,
-0.0205468405,
0.0264814477,
0.0285256859,
0.0363216102,
-0.0142236482,
-0.0173358526,
-0.0213338062,
-0.0135697192,
-0.0638048872,
0.0034671212,
0.0006386339,
0.0515338108,
-0.0117807761,
-0.0061469795,
0.0714182779,
0.0297083054,
0.0157780219,
-0.0430743322,
-0.0224330276,
-0.0271281004,
0.06134497,
0.0126794549,
0.0073799808,
-0.0074763242,
-0.0208640359,
-0.0336591899,
-0.0576524101,
0.026261976,
-0.041330304,
0.0079090353,
-0.0396206342,
-0.0011352567,
-0.0203635748,
0.0055296146,
-0.042559959,
-0.0424614809,
0.0133825177,
0.0366695225,
-0.0039147278,
0.0020185811,
-0.008408051,
0.0392741263,
0.0303446241,
0.0439570174,
0.0475520901,
-0.0302863438,
-0.0424654372,
0.0416239612,
0.031306915,
-0.0477224961,
-0.0251078699,
-0.0242112949,
-0.0431487635,
0.0204955712,
-0.0208142791,
-0.004974782,
-0.0479833744,
-0.0015379565,
0.0549535528,
-0.0434909984,
0.0271400828,
-0.0139949778,
0.0031648215,
-0.0525084622,
0.0263537429,
0.0879797041,
0.0636222363,
-0.0742002055,
0.0196384788,
0.0214371253,
-0.0147696184,
0.0058459877,
-0.0019493781,
-0.049654033,
0.0186292939,
0.0030848812,
0.0115354601,
-0.0209544916,
-0.0785476491,
0.0149836252,
-0.0723246932,
-0.0167571157,
-0.0065802867,
-0.0259479322,
-0.0417538993,
-0.0711167082,
0.0130476868,
-0.0466650724,
-0.0335988104,
-0.0199456625,
0.0207059179,
-0.0009522054,
0.047558967,
-0.0868350938,
-0.0686533749,
-0.0077220015,
-0.047571864,
0.0222011954,
0.0155010503,
0.0568892322,
-0.0148954205,
0.0638013259,
0.0580767989,
-0.0383137837,
-0.0300201233,
0.0131706372,
0.0800587758,
-0.0060873562,
-0.0414853096,
0.0128184417,
0.0291413795,
0.0153653864,
-0.0087373527,
0.01981722,
0.0383930765,
-0.0437025838,
0.0644566491,
0.0065918029,
-0.0186867453,
0.0555702932,
-0.0096373511,
-0.0107808625,
-0.0127456794,
0.0054009627,
-0.0048144832,
0.04972535,
-0.0395606384,
-0.0470788777,
0.0322787426,
-0.0169152785,
-0.0457074046,
-0.024356056,
-0.0783972219,
0.0631489381,
0.0665258393,
0.0041725296,
0.0124952365,
0.0430009998,
-0.0125604589,
-0.0391016454,
0.003556947,
0.0078070974,
0.00081425,
-0.0008515608,
-0.1001123488,
-0.0293905027,
0.0328073017,
-0.0196780004,
0.0544297919,
-0.0387389436,
-0.0305521972,
0.03275989,
-0.0067152716,
0.0190400817,
0.0258079004,
-0.0194370504,
-0.0439246111,
0.0118784839,
0.012786041,
0.0191165879,
-0.0336894579,
0.035153009,
-0.023833368,
0.0185421407,
0.0076106028,
-0.0072711129,
0.017195465,
0.0430876352,
-0.0537363477,
-0.1120995656,
-0.0819359943,
0.0138244359,
-0.0542402305,
0.0920859724,
-0.0044046696,
-0.0944098979,
-0.0567183793,
0.0162233897,
-0.0141776642,
0.0068506394,
0.012664197,
0.0266500786,
-0.0056723473,
0.0239329059,
-0.0274503659,
0.0616792962,
0.0152092315,
0.0324564427,
-0.0385271609,
0.0456165038,
-0.0010484381,
0.0501350872,
-0.0052347793,
0.0275194813,
-0.0050227041,
0.0446840934,
-0.0133914854,
0.0086141741,
-0.0114321299,
0.0270420015,
0.0325901993,
0.0609731004,
0.0319089592,
0.0142020416,
-0.0398837663,
-0.0279724766,
-0.0420774706,
0.0265055913,
0.0860362649,
-0.0366684943,
0.0139387362,
-0.0184037182,
-0.0157553889,
0.0127735091,
0.0062616598,
-0.0076413336,
-0.0280086752,
-0.019977184,
0.0545020401,
-0.0264987145,
0.0763668865,
0.0700515956,
0.0076876399,
0.0507479087,
0.0484585911,
-0.0319802836,
-0.0037652601,
-0.0225840453,
0.0457243808,
0.0395505093,
-0.0179334525,
0.0060890107,
-0.012296522,
-0.0381121002,
-0.0000524909,
-0.007675854,
-0.0114526041,
0.0035677594,
0.0336707123,
0.037007831,
0.0057513509,
0.0990789607,
-0.0654868558,
0.0322722048,
0.0204687547,
-0.0068212608,
0.032882981,
-5.865101145e-33,
-0.027843114,
-0.0167355835,
0.000537643,
-0.0161571819,
-0.0342573412,
0.0213790014,
-0.0444347225,
-0.0376077928,
-0.0196663681,
0.0280566923,
0.0042671063,
-0.0059849974,
0.0182921924,
0.0014030959,
0.0060374467,
-0.0191104785,
0.0288287662,
0.0125447875,
0.0029680554,
0.0147038456,
0.0897115394,
-0.0070197419,
0.0235466491,
-0.1191503629,
-0.0024214527,
0.0286803264,
0.0003221973,
0.0011655183,
0.072001107,
0.0562556908,
-0.0305069219,
0.0002021409,
0.0190721322,
-0.0368875861,
0.009818458,
-0.0389252268,
-0.0405034423,
0.0216570981,
-0.0317581259,
0.0319293737,
0.0192050375,
0.0125955502,
-0.0071941018,
0.0135023305,
0.006969553,
0.0077276435,
0.0621009953,
-0.0450660661,
-0.0063357963,
-0.064047806,
-0.047852356,
0.0408823453,
-0.0816572681,
0.0018953339,
-0.0019346119,
-0.0129000479,
0.0240836684,
0.0059912419,
-0.091578126,
0.0249002222,
-0.0105103897,
0.0466932133,
-0.0096408529,
-0.017165415,
0.0061158445,
0.0748169571,
-0.0051181843,
0.0121827889,
-0.0323018022,
0.0250578355,
0.0218899027,
0.0280972328,
0.0227356087,
0.0833198503,
0.0317994319,
-0.0360293612,
-0.1068930477,
0.014358921,
0.0744794011,
0.0196904764,
0.0097407047,
0.0189747866,
0.0007965469,
-0.0181500297,
0.0220902096,
-0.0136593776,
-0.0030844093,
-0.0164070409,
-0.0189583078,
-0.0300997011,
-0.0295597669,
0.0490999818,
0.0303017311,
0.0131247425,
0.0344271921,
0.0339418836,
0.0102956397,
0.0493259653,
-0.019231949,
-0.0003624854,
-0.026553778,
-0.0566542968,
0.0103560314,
-0.0118481787,
0.0436802022,
0.0141578084,
0.0187360048,
0.0268032588,
-0.0176752079,
0.0182393491,
0.0038140852,
0.0047872341,
-0.0102900295,
0.053103853,
0.0009535555,
-0.0222208109,
0.0096292682,
0.0352257565,
0.0363219902,
-0.0484537892,
0.0407815538,
-0.0052845483,
-0.0283094049,
-0.0014561651,
0.0096036596,
-0.0130555024,
-0.0353264622,
0.041722957,
-0.0059424215,
-0.0450531431,
-0.0068822992,
-0.0492026508,
2.641e-7,
0.0241114236,
0.0518388525,
0.0179154743,
-0.0103908572,
-0.0045407531,
0.0425707959,
-0.0005080174,
0.0383615643,
-0.0003125967,
-0.0120631736,
0.0446323119,
0.0449812375,
0.0343521535,
0.0667643324,
-0.0706479922,
-0.0535652936,
-0.0431377478,
0.0018871462,
-0.0850456133,
0.0100446111,
0.0365341306,
0.0404914878,
0.0596507937,
-0.0237243976,
-0.0227988288,
-0.0289929602,
0.0087420261,
0.0028708319,
-0.0531935692,
0.034347374,
0.0229398124,
-0.0207678284,
-0.0558289215,
0.0373682715,
-0.0219639,
-0.0119635928,
0.016671313,
0.0466648303,
-0.0134791834,
-0.0104656611,
-0.0181700774,
-0.0545174554,
-0.0171312969,
-0.0117293429,
0.0831959918,
-0.0335070193,
-0.0468125008,
0.0057349163,
-0.0369828008,
0.0024460286,
0.0301373918,
0.0139342491,
-0.0082989708,
0.0165324546,
-0.0178042818,
0.0130067291,
-0.003752785,
-0.047270041,
-0.0077876039,
-0.0073677772,
-0.042409312,
-0.0120822983,
0.0343736485,
0.0422225371,
0.0219804682,
0.0572701469,
0.0417803004,
2.315137501e-34,
0.0291863829,
0.059803661,
-0.0130799683,
0.0005552322,
0.0178866163,
0.0162530188,
-0.0160966348,
-0.0028953832,
0.0097103491,
-0.0071700998,
0.008582565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01825v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01825v2 | Fractal Patterns May Illuminate the Success of Next-Token Prediction | 2024-02-02T17:09:33 | 2024-05-22T16:19:13 | Ibrahim Alabdulmohsin, Vinh Q. Tran, Mostafa Dehghani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the fractal structure of language, aiming to provide a precise
formalism for quantifying properties that may have been previously suspected
but not formally shown. We establish that language is: (1) self-similar,
exhibiting complexities at all levels of granularity, with no particular
characteristic context length, and (2) long-range dependent (LRD), with a Hurst
parameter of approximately H=0.7. Based on these findings, we argue that
short-term patterns/dependencies in language, such as in paragraphs, mirror the
patterns/dependencies over larger scopes, like entire documents. This may shed
some light on how next-token prediction can capture the structure of text
across multiple levels of granularity, from words and clauses to broader
contexts and intents. In addition, we carry out an extensive analysis across
different domains and architectures, showing that fractal parameters are
robust. Finally, we demonstrate that the tiny variations in fractal parameters
seen across LLMs improve upon perplexity-based bits-per-byte (BPB) in
predicting their downstream performance. We hope these findings offer a fresh
perspective on language and the mechanisms underlying the success of LLMs. | Fractal Patterns May Illuminate the Success of Next-Token Prediction: We study the fractal structure of language, aiming to provide a precise
formalism for quantifying properties that may have been previously suspected
but not formally shown. We establish that language is: (1) self-similar,
exhibiting complexities at all levels of granularity, with no particular
characteristic context length, and (2) long-range dependent (LRD), with a Hurst
parameter of approximately H=0.7. Based on these findings, we argue that
short-term patterns/dependencies in language, such as in paragraphs, mirror the
patterns/dependencies over larger scopes, like entire documents. This may shed
some light on how next-token prediction can capture the structure of text
across multiple levels of granularity, from words and clauses to broader
contexts and intents. In addition, we carry out an extensive analysis across
different domains and architectures, showing that fractal parameters are
robust. Finally, we demonstrate that the tiny variations in fractal parameters
seen across LLMs improve upon perplexity-based bits-per-byte (BPB) in
predicting their downstream performance. We hope these findings offer a fresh
perspective on language and the mechanisms underlying the success of LLMs. | [
-0.0007373187,
-0.0051052407,
-0.0393622182,
0.0220813118,
-0.0868274793,
0.0049643945,
-0.0284229256,
0.0693240985,
-0.0567674115,
-0.0177856646,
0.0503833853,
-0.1222547591,
0.0075028422,
0.0592628308,
0.0293324888,
-0.043220818,
0.0335926637,
-0.0502976179,
0.0059616212,
0.0031308655,
0.0041114674,
-0.0497822613,
0.0343117602,
0.0070736418,
-0.0231768154,
-0.0204181056,
-0.0524100438,
0.0222610328,
-0.0092058377,
-0.0217058137,
-0.033323504,
0.029571509,
-0.0433431193,
0.0417426489,
0.0000018703,
-0.0805810615,
0.0039392067,
-0.0088476343,
0.0048820702,
0.0348870568,
0.0090096314,
0.0021293345,
-0.0332362391,
-0.0067607486,
-0.0092487903,
-0.0072480086,
0.0217878595,
0.0720003843,
0.0019911844,
0.0994209349,
-0.0303017274,
-0.047798451,
0.0337704122,
0.0105932327,
0.0408057086,
0.0281952191,
0.0223289877,
-0.0273004565,
0.0061387382,
0.0042756191,
-0.0273270253,
-0.0150471441,
0.0119622303,
0.0062144278,
-0.0250681862,
0.0445698984,
0.0227155592,
0.0007582413,
-0.0000781587,
0.0375524387,
-0.0089540444,
0.0093077123,
0.0370167159,
-0.002997373,
-0.0174032133,
0.0339345448,
-0.0477058589,
0.0016174888,
-0.032556653,
0.0206278767,
0.0358931683,
0.0049651805,
0.0258036256,
-0.0070260856,
-0.0510290675,
0.0660716817,
-0.0077877543,
-0.0382007025,
-0.050998006,
-0.057476379,
0.0481291115,
-0.0634153113,
-0.0219626743,
-0.0018540074,
0.0301613193,
-0.0018355228,
-0.0409127697,
0.0184042547,
0.0517938472,
-0.0193392783,
0.0293313526,
0.0228052568,
-0.0082205674,
0.0395484865,
-0.0135166934,
-0.0110704601,
-0.0567220524,
0.0399059244,
-0.0087283365,
0.0344989114,
0.0057571353,
0.010795719,
-0.007150373,
0.0661161542,
0.00870746,
-0.0249169562,
-0.0299068652,
0.0055843918,
0.0271183886,
-0.0121456459,
-0.0361105241,
-0.0270853955,
0.0344565548,
-0.0063829734,
-0.0456664823,
-0.0196755063,
-0.0486667044,
-0.0102615552,
-0.0050348113,
-0.0202411748,
-0.019853523,
0.0368116684,
-0.0030299709,
0.0014204175,
-0.0037263713,
0.0892443955,
0.0385164842,
-0.036607489,
-0.0383233726,
-0.0181741584,
-0.0128852474,
-0.0268810596,
0.0112349046,
-0.0556358732,
-0.0375968404,
0.0321063884,
-0.0364904068,
0.0225940477,
-0.0175649412,
0.0287028104,
-0.0171485469,
0.0863158181,
-0.025135098,
0.0027844419,
-0.0313495547,
0.0002922743,
-0.0130798612,
0.0605410039,
0.0372696593,
0.0491589494,
0.0489582904,
-0.0092260074,
-0.0077964906,
0.0255652145,
-0.0206994098,
0.005860969,
-0.0355570354,
-0.0024269435,
0.0193852633,
0.0102988193,
0.0357380398,
0.0652229711,
-0.024691904,
-0.0575825237,
0.0427801311,
0.1079499871,
0.0304200929,
0.0236629546,
0.0013627377,
0.0245863348,
0.0272352546,
0.0553096272,
-0.0182317439,
-0.0032312411,
0.0408402793,
0.027027199,
0.0768020377,
0.0420568325,
-0.0039727609,
-0.0572083257,
-0.0475809909,
-0.0326826982,
-0.010098259,
-0.0884206742,
0.0311251208,
-0.009324397,
-0.0487058051,
0.0415911004,
0.0186834335,
-0.0176777095,
-0.0347609557,
-0.0547815636,
0.027840361,
0.0888969377,
0.050088428,
-0.0417607017,
0.0137378266,
0.0115828868,
0.0114070736,
0.0160260685,
-0.0229745544,
0.0366935357,
0.0112948725,
-0.0549272262,
0.0010055258,
0.021874601,
-0.0123144267,
0.032412786,
-0.0033184395,
0.028484324,
-0.0164797958,
-0.0155310975,
0.0000535036,
0.0126925958,
0.0485916212,
0.0195412785,
0.0198723245,
-0.0014038467,
0.0491819344,
0.0089359144,
-0.0288353078,
0.0249243584,
0.0415327065,
-0.0386779867,
-0.0270813089,
-0.0190370437,
-0.062129885,
0.0008347179,
0.0109412577,
0.0127403541,
0.0315540098,
-0.0126112429,
0.0070796637,
-0.0144949388,
0.0240121651,
-0.0680722967,
0.079978548,
-0.0222369339,
0.0268094577,
0.003476856,
0.0515069291,
-0.0303282235,
0.0295423418,
-0.014512185,
0.04213164,
-0.0136797847,
0.0371572077,
0.0371788889,
0.021387279,
0.0123447254,
0.021826895,
-0.0250890609,
-0.0057015428,
0.0198667441,
-0.0252306964,
-0.0289335903,
-0.0517882295,
0.0064938054,
-0.0239393115,
-0.0143548883,
0.0314031765,
0.004264276,
0.0032085867,
-0.0442457199,
-0.0463243723,
-0.0127224578,
0.0235863887,
0.004690608,
-0.0063064741,
0.0708632991,
-0.0133523019,
-0.0604956336,
-0.0188550204,
-0.0235624202,
-0.0380472504,
0.0523932688,
-0.0080296742,
-0.0165135004,
-0.0581966005,
0.0399505235,
0.0015354321,
-0.0230718907,
-0.0428109355,
-0.0499427281,
0.018636208,
-0.0589214079,
0.056014441,
0.0318425111,
0.0315371938,
0.0199263301,
0.0111371558,
-0.004992669,
-0.0055153081,
-0.0179707631,
-0.026971247,
0.0898609534,
-0.0543546826,
-0.0332633592,
0.0245841872,
0.0720298812,
0.0031657019,
0.0092726788,
-0.011055463,
0.041435428,
0.0212400518,
0.0017779288,
0.0489370264,
0.011442068,
-0.0580106713,
0.0568561144,
-0.0133656608,
-0.1000115871,
0.0342599973,
-0.0150460079,
0.0005260542,
0.0092578251,
-0.0177009627,
-0.0449655689,
0.0912997648,
0.041556254,
-0.0023548407,
0.0183524434,
-0.0514743999,
-0.0278329346,
0.0055535003,
-0.0199650414,
-0.015679827,
0.0393087789,
0.0037347514,
0.0061085271,
-0.0006134123,
-0.0281080548,
-0.0131982882,
-0.0147104748,
0.0415367112,
-0.0208694302,
0.0422032364,
-0.0524516888,
-0.024784511,
0.0238617025,
-0.0074000396,
0.0180222187,
-0.0391290933,
-0.0308501814,
-0.0217048582,
0.0718719661,
0.0299645029,
0.0011250729,
0.0672129467,
0.0044791983,
0.0347308815,
0.05474139,
0.02801135,
0.0129581019,
0.0000104663,
-0.0120036872,
0.0108979279,
-0.0329498798,
-0.0512363873,
0.0708898976,
0.0638841167,
-0.0441419147,
0.0074029276,
0.1135173962,
-0.0082775401,
-0.0021222853,
0.0019459493,
-0.0291052628,
0.0633281991,
0.0120119872,
-0.0113278581,
-0.0672598332,
-0.0081620691,
0.0105658369,
0.0030072653,
-0.0065764491,
-0.0312440656,
0.0098700896,
-0.0495090708,
0.0239727497,
-0.0008611232,
0.0017455067,
0.0096460935,
-0.0588753521,
-0.0101882815,
0.0417266116,
-0.026069304,
0.0149217295,
-0.0213035103,
-0.0068506794,
0.0127770891,
-0.0661090016,
0.0316953957,
-0.0048137694,
-0.0269250758,
0.0195664261,
0.0092820739,
0.0234603062,
-0.0270213056,
0.0007188155,
-0.0238323584,
0.0316278636,
0.0262042992,
-0.0235236268,
0.080252327,
0.0490585566,
0.0057022129,
-0.0443373211,
-0.0405723751,
-0.0140071427,
-0.008344654,
-0.01257734,
0.0381625965,
-0.0387891196,
-0.0683339685,
-0.0664244592,
-0.0082060378,
-0.0541178249,
0.0829034671,
0.0188438073,
-0.0222512987,
-0.1190482974,
-0.0397256948,
0.042817995,
-0.0483844168,
0.0112506347,
-0.0041249883,
0.0190924015,
-0.035878446,
-0.0380998813,
-0.0216762535,
-0.0403682962,
0.0661038309,
-0.0043404358,
0.0338363275,
0.0301623773,
-0.0112726446,
-0.0695492178,
-0.0564013645,
0.0198280532,
0.012010199,
-0.0757464692,
-0.0020334111,
0.0073053059,
-0.0124492757,
-0.0096275359,
-0.00140372,
-0.0669604465,
-0.0556565374,
0.0260820724,
0.0061287233,
0.0193799529,
0.0103935832,
0.0404900983,
-0.0405111015,
0.0522098839,
0.0442033149,
-0.0588531978,
0.0253920704,
0.0173692964,
-0.0074389041,
0.009223382,
0.0342313014,
0.0036845796,
0.0031757408,
-0.0310556423,
0.0154846599,
-0.0193193033,
-0.0341397412,
0.011368243,
-0.0045034722,
0.0277113765,
0.002654277,
-0.0024639387,
0.0506040528,
0.028613437,
-0.0246410314,
0.0321491547,
-0.0133923143,
-0.0297133662,
-0.0081794793,
-0.007242871,
-0.0290543642,
0.000276119,
-0.015067176,
-0.0065505854,
0.03319465,
0.007262079,
-0.0503341705,
0.0124288332,
0.0467674211,
-0.0397538766,
0.0295695551,
-0.0080670938,
-0.0194022078,
0.0407090038,
-0.0215968974,
0.0261979755,
0.0159174688,
0.0075305491,
-0.0034415396,
0.0445355102,
-0.0890819877,
-0.0480578803,
0.0010898623,
-0.0158170145,
0.0110300956,
-0.0064812414,
0.0348882191,
-0.0518334694,
0.0298825093,
-0.0083051622,
0.0107742865,
-0.0108619714,
-0.0076950248,
0.0039807861,
0.0243839752,
-0.0530276485,
-0.0056330021,
0.0593470894,
0.0209684465,
0.0002461096,
0.0098720286,
-0.0190249905,
-0.0241836347,
-0.0290296841,
-0.0074739181,
0.0523901619,
0.009412243,
-0.0122866044,
-0.0697311834,
-0.0559951849,
0.0770904794,
0.0134982839,
0.0207877569,
-0.0257186331,
0.0277586542,
0.0709218755,
0.0083871307,
-0.04503005,
-0.0330120027,
0.0094976267,
0.0132791819,
-0.0019890494,
0.0077639045,
-5.764430707e-33,
0.0023514321,
-0.0362014845,
-0.0032124086,
0.0533689074,
0.0133384429,
0.0085523445,
-0.0057077035,
-0.0116606057,
0.0395744145,
-0.0081465142,
-0.0220647175,
0.0081120646,
0.0124410763,
0.0123761864,
0.032235384,
-0.0152624715,
0.0253512748,
-0.0277225673,
0.00924253,
0.0247215256,
0.0004398717,
0.0116341179,
0.027762454,
-0.018456541,
-0.0132272746,
-0.0005228697,
0.023686612,
-0.0142952194,
0.0172573328,
0.0290726405,
-0.0141303279,
0.0140145607,
0.0284957178,
-0.0238828063,
-0.0432699807,
0.0302548222,
-0.0460446924,
-0.0485373102,
0.0004888275,
0.0114726434,
0.0045397761,
-0.0444893613,
0.0627120137,
-0.0095268255,
-0.0530551784,
-0.0227270368,
0.027168896,
0.0247550253,
-0.0107313553,
-0.0362515189,
-0.022978697,
0.0459583849,
-0.0021595247,
0.020197833,
-0.0082551111,
-0.0197795853,
0.0279085655,
-0.011889088,
-0.0567289926,
0.0596917085,
-0.0131753189,
0.0726763681,
-0.0171610378,
0.0267520454,
0.0094644642,
0.0865156502,
0.1305291802,
0.0185998753,
-0.0009911624,
-0.0178061258,
0.0392064825,
-0.0044493848,
-0.0035562175,
0.007774184,
0.0741471499,
0.0207430888,
-0.067645371,
0.0250308998,
0.0250599459,
0.0332402363,
0.0044567608,
0.0058170911,
-0.0827059075,
-0.0247755721,
0.0098850876,
0.0635035634,
0.0046703597,
-0.0493951663,
0.0174252819,
-0.0379087254,
0.0585921891,
-0.0136338556,
-0.0023603528,
-0.0396576859,
-0.0367451608,
-0.0460204482,
-0.0272844154,
0.0295259766,
0.0042525264,
0.0129743433,
-0.0165716298,
-0.0443429649,
-0.0342002809,
-0.0139635019,
0.0167130064,
0.0095705697,
0.0045655593,
0.0109076137,
-0.1265535355,
-0.0119189639,
0.0297947582,
-0.0279821046,
0.0296460278,
-0.045250643,
0.0487655327,
-0.0054190811,
0.007906151,
0.0281602889,
0.0148832826,
-0.0032404535,
-0.0351577811,
-0.0428734832,
-0.0143034048,
0.0607933886,
-0.0489262268,
-0.0208674949,
-0.1006197855,
0.0378638878,
0.0063564978,
-0.0808451995,
-0.0302961338,
0.045493532,
2.708e-7,
0.0339917801,
0.0844952762,
0.0560821705,
0.0276841,
0.031761039,
0.0105102491,
-0.0140965907,
0.0059014987,
-0.0444934554,
-0.003195524,
-0.0075268201,
-0.0190972891,
0.0181479342,
0.0091480408,
-0.1354997903,
0.057269603,
-0.038373515,
-0.0129069015,
-0.050329484,
0.0499609374,
0.0205072202,
0.0649330765,
0.0014671629,
-0.001747349,
0.0013161299,
-0.0553181358,
0.0214609932,
-0.021177955,
0.016545523,
0.0208576974,
-0.0113785155,
-0.0448011346,
-0.0010384363,
0.0096980724,
0.019363476,
0.0082643507,
-0.0248073973,
0.016001733,
0.0080882674,
0.003224361,
0.0193562079,
-0.0466057286,
-0.0098819211,
-0.0405646861,
0.0526184551,
0.0254829004,
-0.0564927459,
-0.0043348572,
0.0173060242,
-0.0029458851,
0.0143414289,
0.0445528105,
-0.0227878001,
0.0219563488,
0.0028407117,
-0.0530724414,
0.0469276868,
-0.0371884778,
-0.0243115053,
0.0300838724,
-0.0228677448,
-0.0501270927,
-0.1099808887,
0.0293846726,
0.0456906632,
-0.0481675975,
-0.0200590417,
2.841390251e-34,
0.0578550734,
-0.0269870833,
0.0095129302,
0.0380321331,
-0.0036591664,
-0.0313223116,
0.0136117954,
0.0420675762,
0.0145934103,
-0.0498531349,
-0.0330046117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01822v2 | Building Guardrails for Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T16:35:00 | 2024-05-29T12:57:01 | Yi Dong, Ronghui Mu, Gaojie Jin, Yi Qi, Jinwei Hu, Xingyu Zhao, Jie Meng, Wenjie Ruan, Xiaowei Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become more integrated into our daily lives,
it is crucial to identify and mitigate their risks, especially when the risks
can have profound impacts on human users and societies. Guardrails, which
filter the inputs or outputs of LLMs, have emerged as a core safeguarding
technology. This position paper takes a deep look at current open-source
solutions (Llama Guard, Nvidia NeMo, Guardrails AI), and discusses the
challenges and the road towards building more complete solutions. Drawing on
robust evidence from previous research, we advocate for a systematic approach
to construct guardrails for LLMs, based on comprehensive consideration of
diverse contexts across various LLMs applications. We propose employing
socio-technical methods through collaboration with a multi-disciplinary team to
pinpoint precise technical requirements, exploring advanced neural-symbolic
implementations to embrace the complexity of the requirements, and developing
verification and testing to ensure the utmost quality of the final product. | Building Guardrails for Large Language Models: As Large Language Models (LLMs) become more integrated into our daily lives,
it is crucial to identify and mitigate their risks, especially when the risks
can have profound impacts on human users and societies. Guardrails, which
filter the inputs or outputs of LLMs, have emerged as a core safeguarding
technology. This position paper takes a deep look at current open-source
solutions (Llama Guard, Nvidia NeMo, Guardrails AI), and discusses the
challenges and the road towards building more complete solutions. Drawing on
robust evidence from previous research, we advocate for a systematic approach
to construct guardrails for LLMs, based on comprehensive consideration of
diverse contexts across various LLMs applications. We propose employing
socio-technical methods through collaboration with a multi-disciplinary team to
pinpoint precise technical requirements, exploring advanced neural-symbolic
implementations to embrace the complexity of the requirements, and developing
verification and testing to ensure the utmost quality of the final product. | [
0.0229296051,
0.1093415245,
-0.0501866825,
0.0632096753,
-0.0362375639,
-0.0334422886,
0.0076895114,
0.0242742524,
0.052227024,
-0.030023057,
0.0210824143,
-0.0299914572,
-0.0279089194,
0.049169641,
0.055513598,
-0.025706958,
0.0545484498,
-0.0676601157,
0.0072435346,
0.0040628905,
0.0163452774,
0.0174357332,
0.0393290929,
0.0392678566,
-0.0228685364,
-0.0170795191,
0.0063491245,
-0.0095786443,
0.0245955251,
-0.0180959068,
-0.0018659596,
0.0193461441,
0.0057777101,
0.0914692134,
0.0000022735,
-0.0593208559,
-0.0078331735,
0.012864545,
0.0017956846,
0.0028870306,
0.0271923561,
-0.0352229811,
-0.0478083454,
0.0268605221,
-0.0230528042,
0.0181390438,
0.0352500156,
0.0228239913,
0.0805794895,
0.059095107,
-0.0087387525,
-0.0114976242,
0.0345328525,
0.0016244067,
-0.064621903,
-0.0161173325,
0.0343110226,
-0.0228859037,
0.0034829066,
-0.002141742,
-0.0040399097,
0.0601419732,
0.0428870246,
-0.0300691761,
-0.0373627469,
0.006631881,
-0.0572694875,
-0.0293097738,
-0.03589895,
0.0658642203,
-0.0525157377,
-0.0334404111,
0.0303824022,
-0.0140959593,
0.0052996753,
-0.025662249,
-0.0179635193,
0.0421376862,
-0.0019072684,
0.025980629,
0.0209689066,
-0.0177638698,
0.0568745472,
0.0257559717,
-0.0043022824,
0.0825199708,
0.0246800743,
-0.0235340539,
0.0125321522,
-0.0154679017,
0.024450209,
-0.063778542,
0.0535432026,
0.0347698852,
-0.0332623944,
0.017467577,
-0.0526546501,
-0.0357384607,
0.0301383156,
-0.0847119093,
0.0267873239,
0.0295654684,
-0.0026202474,
0.0166056398,
-0.0044991923,
0.0395188704,
-0.0480297767,
0.0488859043,
0.0220200345,
0.0107432147,
-0.0054020695,
-0.0087345717,
-0.0255979523,
0.0294462666,
-0.0347370543,
0.0116975671,
0.0130958352,
0.0393803865,
-0.0576863922,
0.0472697429,
-0.0283306874,
0.0077503636,
0.0555936471,
-0.0250122957,
0.0046036886,
-0.014678238,
-0.0150724417,
0.0044980301,
-0.0242834687,
-0.0656152815,
0.0267472547,
0.0314610787,
-0.0462215617,
-0.0048954659,
0.0018526606,
0.1069914848,
0.039830815,
0.0019115987,
-0.0608157106,
-0.0562746115,
-0.0118701961,
-0.055583559,
0.0172944125,
-0.0543325394,
-0.0110446764,
-0.0278654732,
-0.0068341941,
-0.0973167568,
-0.003712635,
0.0250022914,
-0.0030154013,
0.0292730574,
-0.0033561385,
-0.0230214912,
0.0321477279,
0.0410510823,
0.0187988766,
0.0659563839,
0.062160559,
0.0107731745,
0.0592401624,
0.0043071336,
0.0122150816,
0.0624336749,
-0.0043462189,
0.0256459471,
-0.0795889348,
-0.0110067818,
0.0028234618,
0.0095418589,
-0.0099000707,
0.0997535959,
0.0060304645,
-0.0494812727,
0.0830736682,
0.0554670766,
-0.0347538926,
0.0141074555,
0.0298824813,
-0.0016816281,
-0.008790222,
-0.0271863788,
-0.0315982327,
-0.0091179516,
-0.0424556248,
-0.0250018481,
-0.0258923192,
0.0727784857,
-0.0119657246,
-0.0233240835,
-0.0218453426,
-0.0337176062,
0.0331756808,
0.0034022098,
0.0192712396,
-0.0307970047,
-0.0066176979,
0.0478168055,
0.0049206936,
-0.0317825004,
0.0158533081,
-0.077396065,
0.0309985299,
0.0688280016,
0.047532171,
-0.0278896801,
-0.0115183825,
-0.0293620173,
-0.0208153054,
0.0602321811,
0.0068340767,
-0.0037062678,
0.025474675,
-0.0545227826,
0.0141366478,
0.0255299006,
0.0197460633,
0.0143449334,
0.0106263412,
0.0442730524,
-0.0018934383,
0.0298083052,
-0.0792543963,
0.0397597887,
-0.0292823184,
-0.0372423939,
-0.0197460148,
0.0088409139,
-0.0057991394,
0.0259783752,
-0.007691958,
0.0084717693,
0.034970317,
-0.0229582768,
0.0022163123,
-0.0328708887,
-0.0473083816,
0.0548083633,
0.068881385,
-0.0263737142,
0.0012719556,
0.0584275648,
-0.0319411978,
-0.0133421943,
0.0614301078,
-0.0181334652,
0.0147544155,
-0.0288932826,
0.0052100732,
-0.0448820591,
0.0255053286,
-0.022483306,
0.011080455,
-0.0047899149,
-0.033156909,
0.0397667028,
-0.0339178666,
0.0347492024,
-0.0253466163,
-0.0723158419,
0.0178139452,
-0.0080026342,
0.0563688166,
0.0061445748,
0.0208331831,
-0.0174011309,
0.0046377638,
-0.0355289094,
-0.0152363926,
-0.018119663,
0.0213447716,
0.0008603525,
-0.0208975021,
-0.0270616449,
-0.0174517129,
0.013901935,
0.0021311108,
0.0001907282,
-0.008689886,
0.0213956293,
-0.0152818188,
-0.0737314746,
-0.0232519619,
-0.0136646181,
-0.0364893675,
0.044573158,
-0.0153353401,
-0.040800035,
-0.0676917061,
-0.0025382002,
-0.0279023293,
0.0533042476,
0.0094488431,
-0.0128612136,
0.0362252593,
0.0255279355,
0.0073366049,
0.0294917263,
-0.0128383795,
0.0066879019,
0.0831521899,
-0.0097287903,
-0.0444768965,
-0.0118021388,
0.0175974406,
-0.0017530145,
-0.0240124334,
0.0112483893,
0.0088803759,
0.0523888171,
-0.0128409006,
-0.0198637657,
-0.0550078601,
0.0495191105,
-0.0619842708,
-0.0210637022,
-0.0122472774,
-0.0819197297,
-0.0488253236,
0.049851492,
-0.0040760445,
-0.0380823016,
0.0874425545,
-0.0350742787,
0.0148878898,
-0.007667182,
-0.0375752449,
-0.046285063,
0.0534482934,
-0.0264792088,
0.0297530126,
0.0601847768,
-0.0124544688,
-0.0297166724,
-0.0143749239,
-0.0144738751,
-0.0142151406,
0.0315483473,
-0.0638634339,
-0.0058448398,
-0.0082281046,
-0.0392888151,
-0.028202761,
-0.0319512635,
-0.0609600917,
0.0284536853,
0.0152828638,
-0.0010754426,
0.0308658555,
0.0190198012,
-0.0062969513,
0.0097889137,
0.0010916564,
-0.0043114517,
-0.0356793888,
0.0003282598,
0.0293377247,
-0.0214977115,
0.0550310947,
-0.0115849124,
0.0137326038,
0.0440588854,
0.0211372748,
-0.0241499674,
-0.046818614,
-0.0168498177,
0.0528210811,
-0.0139892735,
-0.0089721633,
0.042958688,
0.0177181978,
-0.0689072385,
0.0008314997,
0.0696056634,
0.0117750103,
-0.0237203985,
0.0347442776,
-0.0433324277,
0.0385580361,
0.0227914657,
0.0407355651,
-0.0927337334,
-0.0006501769,
0.0320210792,
0.0063894941,
-0.0115361176,
-0.014833644,
-0.0294256695,
-0.071652703,
0.0438569486,
0.031774018,
-0.0552656502,
0.0062317504,
-0.0080820499,
-0.024374783,
-0.0013016192,
0.0341290459,
-0.0027238911,
-0.0093799653,
-0.0478913896,
0.0171212479,
-0.0598311722,
-0.0251787305,
0.0138267344,
-0.0583071969,
0.0426551774,
0.0386666358,
0.0193070769,
-0.018778393,
-0.0559157915,
0.0645037889,
-0.0062254006,
-0.0042009912,
-0.0056528817,
0.0144203501,
0.0237410069,
-0.0231382418,
-0.0227186959,
0.0123446612,
-0.0293339007,
-0.0397372432,
0.0185953435,
0.1072970778,
-0.0299944319,
-0.0258499142,
-0.0356941968,
-0.0144143617,
0.0155955683,
0.0433111116,
0.0096968962,
-0.0534710474,
-0.0383361615,
-0.0423288494,
-0.0146863088,
-0.0325857587,
-0.051568035,
-0.0061204745,
0.0047131861,
-0.0570528246,
-0.0355088562,
-0.0183834992,
-0.0240286849,
0.0066536437,
0.0500983186,
-0.0209201351,
0.0801161453,
-0.0362369046,
0.0147585645,
0.0140153058,
-0.0771291256,
0.0469809733,
-0.0369083025,
0.0732602701,
-0.0072146556,
0.0073560067,
0.0012299838,
0.0332169533,
-0.056890808,
-0.1061406285,
0.015326093,
0.0697770193,
0.0343789794,
-0.0054405048,
-0.0251152813,
-0.075422883,
0.0731285214,
0.0327253751,
-0.0279121045,
0.0098252082,
0.0349066965,
-0.0571045168,
0.0049189832,
0.0381045453,
-0.016866643,
-0.0335150212,
-0.0002381974,
-0.0015988798,
-0.0417024605,
-0.0284417178,
-0.0108799674,
0.0286439452,
-0.0133732473,
-0.0544014536,
0.0053860173,
-0.0481074303,
0.0111476099,
-0.0119444225,
-0.0006645506,
-0.0057537756,
0.0354891159,
0.0045361272,
-0.0131718172,
-0.0021346125,
-0.0191367418,
0.0014487555,
0.0414891616,
-0.0214717183,
0.0274372008,
0.0078021958,
0.0520059988,
0.033285521,
0.0036405609,
-0.0047860998,
0.0478876084,
-0.0304746367,
0.0469174981,
-0.0349185281,
0.0208726134,
0.0071843732,
0.0106287338,
-0.0286163893,
0.0401411578,
-0.0011816982,
-0.0700798929,
-0.0047747209,
0.0440792702,
0.0493409149,
0.0286729019,
0.0333864093,
-0.037474636,
0.0011664971,
-0.0311701782,
-0.0177817848,
-0.0098598637,
-0.0557999946,
0.0068403804,
0.0129678659,
-0.0205389131,
0.0065877633,
0.0410561524,
0.0014602474,
0.0441381522,
0.019362852,
-0.0262310915,
-0.0325981155,
-0.028128447,
0.0228174254,
0.0120527213,
-0.0777534992,
-0.0376497395,
-0.1120008901,
-0.0772297457,
-0.0029906945,
0.0406704023,
-0.0229059178,
-0.0139338514,
-0.0030525376,
0.0001373066,
0.037541192,
-0.0107843643,
-0.0306726322,
-0.0279122498,
-0.0211969297,
-0.0091293789,
0.0029960121,
-6.64329163e-33,
-0.0013919418,
-0.0273015033,
0.0339698195,
-0.0085347807,
0.0047551137,
-0.0071614818,
-0.0166182034,
-0.0013202149,
-0.0015083031,
-0.0054337634,
-0.0033348557,
-0.0062866095,
0.0125393951,
-0.0087906253,
0.0334414281,
-0.0120838145,
0.0184688531,
0.0033659723,
-0.0001371916,
0.0283053108,
0.0369057804,
-0.0140787279,
0.017912088,
-0.0913355798,
0.0625141561,
0.0115745151,
-0.0081186583,
0.0242836978,
-0.0653154999,
0.0670472533,
-0.0182762463,
0.0480418317,
0.0076841037,
-0.0415178016,
-0.009664434,
0.0351401195,
-0.0283020306,
-0.0363650732,
0.0198599566,
0.0331087224,
-0.0150739914,
-0.0704038963,
0.0654003471,
-0.0086935619,
-0.0309980605,
0.039570082,
0.0073063793,
-0.0131722381,
-0.0041512735,
-0.0264343247,
-0.0530231744,
0.0125586856,
-0.0144131472,
0.0201120041,
0.0146174254,
0.0128316619,
-0.0083645098,
-0.0124114752,
-0.0809785202,
0.0074459487,
0.0042842976,
-0.0069420123,
0.09006273,
0.0189106371,
-0.022300452,
0.0480010733,
-0.004793603,
-0.0217126012,
0.0042144707,
-0.0177229401,
0.0573106296,
0.0383548215,
0.0376315266,
0.0218796078,
0.0145194903,
-0.0477732345,
-0.0837703943,
0.0139568355,
-0.0058691869,
0.0693420842,
0.0287024938,
0.0290725753,
-0.0319387577,
-0.0337887555,
-0.0184871014,
-0.0495966114,
-0.0157174952,
-0.0058049471,
0.0246481113,
-0.003767781,
-0.0223978925,
0.0027187064,
0.0209224932,
-0.0654195771,
-0.0221039765,
0.0024990588,
0.0149401492,
-0.0229838304,
0.0266112369,
0.0456834845,
-0.0235296898,
-0.0157088395,
-0.0358345322,
-0.0281576961,
0.0546021834,
-0.0176732913,
0.027118694,
0.0655881092,
-0.0579335615,
0.0287059732,
-0.0364356115,
0.0448868535,
0.043826323,
0.0284769461,
0.0105716633,
-0.0239885598,
0.0207004305,
0.0135685392,
0.0619035847,
-0.0164905787,
0.0134830112,
0.0807533786,
0.0054645156,
0.0165913161,
-0.0108308708,
-0.0095830681,
-0.0311376154,
0.0783908218,
0.0789849535,
-0.0759272128,
-0.009653681,
-0.0216476694,
2.876e-7,
0.006091638,
0.0438520536,
0.039335914,
0.0047804858,
0.026862165,
0.0574631244,
-0.0134992786,
0.0374368913,
-0.0377791896,
0.0049043871,
-0.016542308,
0.0244710669,
0.0478016473,
0.0502350107,
-0.0741532668,
0.0052376497,
-0.0679342374,
0.0063872971,
-0.0751543939,
-0.0105136773,
0.0417937152,
0.0644063503,
0.024037566,
-0.0348316245,
-0.0214104522,
-0.0718102008,
0.0138099408,
-0.0080247149,
0.025681166,
0.0146488473,
0.048753906,
0.0335687324,
0.0047985855,
0.0002641167,
-0.0024260322,
0.0285267849,
-0.0495604761,
0.0710302815,
-0.00391078,
0.0045131482,
0.0113743059,
-0.0565807931,
-0.0268546939,
-0.0635678545,
0.0607445762,
0.029167885,
-0.0195364822,
-0.0487359352,
0.0239395052,
-0.0400727987,
0.0284751281,
-0.0241020359,
-0.0018940183,
-0.002038643,
0.0068476335,
-0.0244176686,
0.0059529734,
-0.0470214598,
-0.0369243659,
-0.0039976626,
-0.0185931809,
-0.029190341,
-0.020955326,
0.0444150008,
-0.0101705883,
-0.0452940725,
0.0255424455,
2.709047954e-34,
0.0074084536,
-0.0267149452,
0.0019925442,
0.0189181734,
0.0196038038,
0.0284826197,
-0.0473528244,
0.0056763543,
0.0030273141,
-0.0208506715,
-0.0218610279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01535v2 | An Empirical Analysis of Diversity in Argument Summarization | 2024-02-02T16:26:52 | 2024-02-14T10:51:08 | Michiel van der Meer, Piek Vossen, Catholijn M. Jonker, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Presenting high-level arguments is a crucial task for fostering participation
in online societal discussions. Current argument summarization approaches miss
an important facet of this task -- capturing diversity -- which is important
for accommodating multiple perspectives. We introduce three aspects of
diversity: those of opinions, annotators, and sources. We evaluate approaches
to a popular argument summarization task called Key Point Analysis, which shows
how these approaches struggle to (1) represent arguments shared by few people,
(2) deal with data from various sources, and (3) align with subjectivity in
human-provided annotations. We find that both general-purpose LLMs and
dedicated KPA models exhibit this behavior, but have complementary strengths.
Further, we observe that diversification of training data may ameliorate
generalization. Addressing diversity in argument summarization requires a mix
of strategies to deal with subjectivity. | An Empirical Analysis of Diversity in Argument Summarization: Presenting high-level arguments is a crucial task for fostering participation
in online societal discussions. Current argument summarization approaches miss
an important facet of this task -- capturing diversity -- which is important
for accommodating multiple perspectives. We introduce three aspects of
diversity: those of opinions, annotators, and sources. We evaluate approaches
to a popular argument summarization task called Key Point Analysis, which shows
how these approaches struggle to (1) represent arguments shared by few people,
(2) deal with data from various sources, and (3) align with subjectivity in
human-provided annotations. We find that both general-purpose LLMs and
dedicated KPA models exhibit this behavior, but have complementary strengths.
Further, we observe that diversification of training data may ameliorate
generalization. Addressing diversity in argument summarization requires a mix
of strategies to deal with subjectivity. | [
0.0421890095,
-0.0002275963,
0.039616365,
0.0234968141,
0.0053251018,
0.0221053436,
-0.0338071361,
-0.0372554064,
-0.0075020478,
-0.0756919309,
0.0077124252,
-0.0328449607,
0.0107171191,
-0.0124088703,
-0.0061540371,
-0.1078201532,
-0.007609115,
0.020665722,
0.0661180615,
-0.0275947545,
0.032169342,
-0.006082416,
-0.0326968394,
0.0568543375,
-0.0181349665,
-0.021300992,
-0.0058745295,
-0.0148261646,
0.0844316781,
-0.0121554714,
0.0072932113,
0.0359104797,
-0.0066462103,
-0.0083379596,
0.0000015089,
-0.0348142907,
0.0120360609,
-0.0169672593,
0.0003281396,
0.0319798961,
0.0306672659,
0.0269464795,
0.0297566336,
0.0246271268,
-0.0096108234,
0.0124560278,
0.0262953639,
0.1106157005,
0.0986927599,
0.0606025383,
0.0040576695,
-0.0428630076,
-0.0033386231,
-0.0238411501,
-0.0511139594,
-0.0064118202,
0.0037705936,
0.0152375242,
-0.0223224144,
0.0222885367,
0.0297854729,
0.0073250122,
-0.0239948221,
-0.0040000943,
0.027313672,
0.0117220115,
-0.0415486209,
-0.0160673205,
0.0191357005,
0.0701721534,
0.0275865532,
0.0086915875,
0.0506068803,
-0.0138752749,
0.0370830335,
0.0051597608,
-0.0790754259,
0.0779184625,
-0.0200069621,
0.0385202132,
0.0134612005,
0.0514368117,
-0.0013147752,
0.0032799505,
0.0368525125,
0.0121510234,
-0.0231890958,
-0.0138305658,
0.0073876628,
0.0359583236,
-0.0367738679,
-0.0427366346,
0.0047163968,
0.0286118276,
0.037426874,
0.0116834212,
-0.0019007593,
0.0118899848,
0.0555343218,
-0.1253924519,
0.0216423366,
-0.0499700308,
0.0128787272,
0.0632323995,
-0.0095282039,
-0.0388684347,
0.0056367461,
0.0128311682,
0.0112698283,
-0.0167588126,
-0.059463717,
-0.0001332614,
0.0251352675,
0.0521678105,
-0.0040995628,
-0.0039298935,
-0.0010764225,
-0.0044583767,
-0.036764022,
-0.0238056369,
-0.0015760197,
0.0313678682,
0.0477331281,
-0.0112285856,
-0.0294515472,
0.0550104529,
-0.0830873996,
-0.0051054414,
0.0124464883,
-0.0285843294,
-0.0028559649,
0.0510919467,
0.0145135131,
0.0175094269,
-0.0235529412,
-0.0097462405,
-0.0184341446,
0.005725184,
-0.0294965468,
-0.0348165892,
-0.0254846178,
-0.0190450661,
0.0189839955,
-0.0727158338,
0.0016078958,
-0.0059650932,
-0.0245637782,
-0.0291098244,
0.0102925003,
0.0297600161,
-0.0429388694,
0.0041404259,
0.0127340639,
0.0044389074,
0.0916142911,
0.0189829413,
-0.0413711704,
0.0563517138,
0.0120913722,
0.0212289318,
0.0434299186,
0.0264070109,
0.0076429318,
0.0026839415,
-0.006788841,
-0.0010463162,
0.0600636862,
-0.0095512848,
-0.056977693,
0.0033119535,
0.0205680821,
0.0555041805,
-0.0362125114,
-0.0187069904,
0.0290292539,
0.0868359283,
-0.0131903384,
-0.0078638904,
-0.0201514252,
0.0405550413,
0.0581151322,
0.0333317891,
0.0218438823,
0.0228284113,
-0.0258134678,
0.0038258622,
0.051678516,
0.0124354502,
-0.0182735864,
-0.0586120039,
-0.0428396985,
0.0029678391,
-0.02810774,
-0.0043727136,
-0.0156423301,
0.0016441442,
0.0223546252,
0.0567900054,
0.0100353854,
-0.0664030015,
-0.0336899497,
-0.0147231743,
0.0099236388,
-0.0052677779,
-0.0345093124,
-0.0249933396,
-0.0234061722,
-0.0466910414,
0.0528954007,
0.064505823,
0.0835497826,
-0.036126107,
-0.0353878476,
-0.0464111753,
-0.0369786024,
-0.0277221128,
0.0277547613,
0.0416609198,
0.0045841099,
-0.0504681766,
0.0406212434,
-0.0116309943,
-0.0194897428,
0.0132938875,
0.0144805685,
0.0204937756,
-0.0122955358,
-0.0002843218,
0.0285240319,
0.0838255882,
-0.0076605044,
0.0125657599,
0.0205416959,
-0.0309421383,
-0.0209796969,
0.0253784135,
-0.0227056891,
0.00226912,
0.0430978499,
-0.0838797912,
-0.0337862261,
-0.0061073983,
-0.0215124898,
-0.0383214802,
0.0325970687,
-0.0374657251,
-0.0398591347,
0.00673278,
-0.0279373787,
0.0054687685,
-0.0174293797,
-0.0597326458,
0.0788076892,
0.0090230256,
-0.0206121765,
-0.0007199968,
-0.0505321957,
0.0143598346,
-0.0677739605,
-0.0301418994,
-0.004047689,
0.0261666942,
0.0251067113,
0.0524950214,
-0.0476227887,
-0.021040434,
-0.0253810324,
-0.1120354682,
-0.0070831035,
-0.0216378756,
0.0107617127,
0.0382874049,
-0.028817188,
0.0091351522,
-0.0071406411,
-0.0712626353,
-0.0521365404,
-0.0206705499,
0.0390668586,
0.0485109687,
0.0190206189,
0.0687305257,
-0.0491577536,
-0.0142638898,
0.0012029711,
0.0637134537,
0.0218181256,
-0.0425418094,
-0.0096188812,
-0.0024450717,
-0.0339718461,
-0.0227475278,
-0.016629355,
0.0355096683,
0.0317689255,
0.0314858258,
0.0555761009,
0.046055913,
0.0303490367,
0.024304688,
0.013162286,
0.0299118832,
-0.0755904689,
-0.0303165223,
-0.0066905189,
0.0638207868,
0.0162496958,
-0.0339217931,
0.054622896,
0.075853996,
-0.0062618097,
0.0172018949,
-0.0837650225,
0.0325438492,
-0.0393496677,
-0.0251199473,
-0.0612545535,
-0.0295598824,
-0.0104748383,
-0.0026235655,
-0.0366355143,
0.0312969498,
0.0407169387,
-0.0042349021,
0.0577319004,
0.012713966,
-0.0140237762,
-0.0613420308,
0.0180414636,
-0.015593878,
0.0064708721,
-0.0075091869,
-0.0053781243,
-0.0138155287,
-0.0101426709,
0.0649917573,
-0.0344283134,
0.0946251005,
-0.0293914657,
-0.0052552116,
-0.0199212003,
-0.0115174064,
-0.0195096675,
-0.0253887698,
-0.0433199517,
-0.0037770614,
-0.0059519154,
0.0346961692,
0.0154836038,
0.0028191574,
0.0163148679,
-0.0147704566,
-0.0087017557,
0.004934628,
0.0214730036,
0.0371643268,
0.0378979817,
0.0278659295,
0.0620425567,
-0.022073226,
-0.0065178135,
0.0647114813,
0.0074995416,
-0.0382093489,
-0.0052487245,
-0.0476899482,
-0.0226504989,
-0.0754861236,
-0.0547321327,
-0.0334150679,
0.06557744,
-0.0142233344,
0.0676510781,
0.0706863031,
0.0213426352,
-0.0157318432,
-0.0133155547,
-0.043492157,
0.0107342191,
0.0009699489,
-0.011260245,
-0.0544731133,
0.0026874377,
-0.0534412898,
0.0368394703,
-0.0249293037,
-0.056807477,
0.0067581469,
-0.1024559885,
0.0133643374,
0.0000176788,
0.0071776463,
-0.0064494875,
-0.0506602563,
0.0151240556,
-0.0505277216,
-0.0225762278,
0.0083962642,
-0.0040796059,
0.0190044716,
0.0570811927,
-0.0815059468,
0.0142995967,
-0.017354453,
-0.0315062106,
0.0360596105,
0.0144687193,
0.0221189186,
-0.0115744667,
-0.000529443,
0.0483010598,
0.0116562592,
0.009934579,
0.0197363794,
0.032106217,
-0.0020976004,
0.0031940651,
-0.0131659182,
0.0268994663,
-0.0004379138,
-0.0430815481,
0.0127867516,
0.023829367,
0.0097824363,
-0.0134866685,
-0.0250705611,
0.0479839854,
-0.0400349274,
0.0656721517,
0.0446222089,
0.0187245756,
-0.0403381214,
-0.0557761528,
0.0028779425,
-0.0622357763,
-0.0380248316,
0.0055008596,
-0.0000133934,
0.0155594414,
-0.0863730386,
-0.0568778925,
-0.0165443793,
-0.0286131985,
-0.0194851458,
-0.0183599666,
0.0071308017,
0.0259848889,
0.0079484917,
0.0260875914,
-0.0088627972,
-0.0377457738,
-0.0101909256,
-0.0205682926,
0.0114675965,
-0.0086033158,
-0.0238033812,
0.0003932805,
-0.0376498029,
-0.0633070841,
0.0038887954,
0.0589771606,
0.0193020068,
0.0309494063,
0.037938375,
-0.0548770949,
0.038355846,
0.0190526228,
0.0635410771,
0.0071422923,
0.0415127724,
0.0497680046,
-0.0077013983,
-0.0054564695,
-0.0288093351,
0.0417135879,
-0.0227852501,
0.0243966859,
-0.0644977018,
-0.0216149725,
-0.0213350803,
0.0260715745,
0.0176080801,
0.0243435968,
-0.0565425158,
-0.0500403382,
-0.0376385376,
-0.0346223935,
-0.0039068586,
-0.0233494677,
0.0280360598,
-0.0435020663,
-0.0354275256,
-0.0133714266,
0.011497424,
0.0023446344,
0.062765412,
-0.0543861277,
0.016953012,
0.0301568024,
-0.0426824614,
-0.0483247265,
-0.0054244832,
-0.0678984672,
0.0510877408,
-0.0224865824,
0.0127309412,
0.0137469675,
-0.0111840796,
-0.0214751195,
-0.0090221688,
0.0383332781,
0.0145775098,
-0.0740840062,
-0.0314692035,
-0.0183508825,
0.0302689895,
0.0307491887,
-0.0061465772,
0.0728213042,
0.0012046717,
-0.013325097,
0.0077485316,
0.0173927546,
0.0158233624,
0.0072789378,
0.0078579579,
0.0254931003,
-0.0136917289,
-0.0056465692,
0.075693436,
-0.0744597092,
0.0303530172,
-0.0056814775,
-0.0144951027,
-0.0671120882,
-0.0353287309,
-0.0178947728,
0.0057639945,
0.0148346312,
-0.0141274687,
-0.0522513799,
0.014341414,
0.033773277,
-0.0025086752,
0.0393546894,
0.0073976954,
0.0218626745,
0.0283124335,
0.0024768612,
0.0316140726,
-0.0518743284,
-0.0048188041,
-0.0005019414,
0.0321885049,
0.005905035,
-5.783352493e-33,
-0.0166464634,
-0.0247706976,
-0.0417699106,
0.0593659766,
-0.0185126588,
0.0100630438,
-0.0266792383,
0.0632752031,
-0.0137997372,
0.0308723692,
0.0193427876,
0.0225493889,
0.0169520918,
0.0104452027,
0.0180179551,
-0.0193172414,
0.0253848247,
-0.0034386306,
-0.0388834178,
0.0228200592,
0.0154485907,
-0.0332658216,
0.0318943113,
-0.0467205197,
0.0804343522,
-0.0088206641,
-0.0192585196,
0.0053032162,
0.0217264928,
0.0426174551,
0.0042361859,
0.0507928468,
0.0522952154,
-0.0609977841,
-0.0185034685,
0.0249954239,
-0.0280976351,
-0.0354436971,
0.0319830216,
-0.0532632172,
-0.0286666565,
-0.0623686537,
0.0490678363,
0.0101540983,
0.0097339666,
-0.0579350702,
0.0595122166,
-0.0402412117,
-0.0163105745,
-0.0752694756,
-0.0115940254,
0.0608396754,
-0.0296666641,
0.0113402465,
-0.0112566659,
0.0291741807,
0.0176862758,
0.0330946259,
-0.0515457354,
0.0457135886,
0.0320734419,
0.0015085815,
0.0211443901,
-0.021846978,
-0.0008598399,
0.071754925,
-0.0206904896,
0.021151768,
-0.0544067919,
-0.0008122473,
-0.0483764373,
0.0187727436,
0.0623681843,
0.0842058435,
0.001568319,
0.0454238355,
-0.0515728891,
0.0203060135,
0.0281964019,
-0.0198103059,
0.0209171623,
-0.0169631988,
-0.0176156517,
0.0193074998,
-0.0372433402,
-0.0389567055,
-0.0056097675,
-0.0168507509,
-0.0402242504,
0.0123321284,
-0.0590941459,
0.0321177244,
-0.010269681,
-0.0240007117,
0.008095731,
-0.0041760271,
0.0082406281,
0.0259403829,
0.0256795771,
-0.0251904596,
-0.0390481874,
0.0337774791,
-0.0011216515,
-0.0121403448,
0.0428590849,
0.0024097811,
0.0418715365,
-0.0316356458,
-0.0410180166,
-0.012888724,
0.0130937863,
0.0415021479,
-0.032276962,
0.0339399055,
0.0058471337,
0.0180875212,
0.0016034232,
0.0548822284,
0.0071385261,
0.0364354812,
0.0114975385,
-0.0257828087,
-0.0108747063,
-0.0108446591,
-0.0159470551,
0.0127729457,
0.0467744097,
0.0111788623,
0.0231612287,
-0.0174841043,
-0.0161402225,
-0.0157028474,
2.124e-7,
0.0564576387,
0.0467962138,
0.0402477905,
-0.0385535322,
-0.0020255228,
0.0367703252,
0.0301298704,
0.0349898785,
0.0087296199,
-0.0665564016,
-0.0089411642,
0.0460886955,
0.0281441845,
0.0659635589,
-0.0863614529,
-0.0798952878,
-0.0691397339,
-0.0082078995,
-0.0060842414,
0.0054695765,
0.0721872747,
0.0327623226,
-0.0161852352,
0.0091432277,
-0.0453155413,
0.027455071,
0.0761045665,
-0.0319876634,
-0.0550667048,
0.0108261155,
0.0877213553,
-0.0630981922,
0.0189584941,
0.0019544517,
-0.0170589145,
-0.0117120547,
0.0491058268,
0.030962389,
0.0384034328,
-0.0721435398,
0.0135958884,
-0.0099765332,
0.0401667319,
-0.0261056852,
0.0518483557,
-0.0917273089,
-0.0484800413,
-0.0605700091,
-0.044194825,
0.012451794,
0.0264510214,
0.000654039,
-0.0057153879,
0.0073181591,
-0.0143029699,
-0.02755934,
0.0052674995,
-0.0795169398,
-0.080345951,
0.0014377383,
-0.0189538579,
-0.0289139301,
0.0116511406,
-0.0396312289,
0.0078424895,
-0.0148707004,
0.0009614863,
1.337896013e-34,
0.0517028384,
-0.0179033801,
-0.0147347981,
0.0028982176,
0.0179911349,
0.0164821688,
-0.0095120072,
-0.0241962634,
0.0137449699,
-0.0210322011,
0.0044719838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01528v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01528v2 | Decoding Speculative Decoding | 2024-02-02T16:15:24 | 2024-04-26T04:52:57 | Minghao Yan, Saurabh Agarwal, Shivaram Venkataraman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Speculative Decoding is a widely used technique to speed up inference for
Large Language Models (LLMs) without sacrificing quality. When performing
inference, speculative decoding uses a smaller draft model to generate
speculative tokens and then uses the target LLM to verify those draft tokens.
The speedup provided by speculative decoding heavily depends on the choice of
the draft model. In this work, we perform a detailed study comprising over 350
experiments with LLaMA-65B and OPT-66B using speculative decoding and delineate
the factors that affect the performance gain provided by speculative decoding.
Our experiments indicate that the performance of speculative decoding depends
heavily on the latency of the draft model, and the draft model's capability in
language modeling does not correlate strongly with its performance in
speculative decoding. Based on these insights we explore a new design space for
draft models and design hardware-efficient draft models for speculative
decoding. Our newly designed draft model for LLaMA-65B can provide 60% higher
throughput than existing draft models and can generalize further to the LLaMA-2
model family and supervised fine-tuned models. | Decoding Speculative Decoding: Speculative Decoding is a widely used technique to speed up inference for
Large Language Models (LLMs) without sacrificing quality. When performing
inference, speculative decoding uses a smaller draft model to generate
speculative tokens and then uses the target LLM to verify those draft tokens.
The speedup provided by speculative decoding heavily depends on the choice of
the draft model. In this work, we perform a detailed study comprising over 350
experiments with LLaMA-65B and OPT-66B using speculative decoding and delineate
the factors that affect the performance gain provided by speculative decoding.
Our experiments indicate that the performance of speculative decoding depends
heavily on the latency of the draft model, and the draft model's capability in
language modeling does not correlate strongly with its performance in
speculative decoding. Based on these insights we explore a new design space for
draft models and design hardware-efficient draft models for speculative
decoding. Our newly designed draft model for LLaMA-65B can provide 60% higher
throughput than existing draft models and can generalize further to the LLaMA-2
model family and supervised fine-tuned models. | [
0.0196587443,
0.0634133667,
0.0058515011,
0.02228285,
-0.0304487869,
0.0013357319,
0.0071259672,
0.0148209482,
-0.0519812033,
-0.0084563904,
0.0073919874,
-0.0698815882,
0.0144847734,
0.0152512686,
0.0127329007,
0.0144853853,
0.0341640227,
-0.0650136992,
0.0245167725,
-0.0308250207,
-0.032896556,
0.0249310564,
0.0233819131,
0.0263432357,
0.0322102755,
0.0109503986,
-0.0298579466,
0.0067061586,
-0.0463760346,
-0.0516204573,
-0.0094708465,
0.0298290681,
0.0069549284,
0.019760482,
0.0000020462,
-0.0013247743,
-0.0074335579,
0.0081947474,
-0.0517545491,
0.0859795213,
0.0767330453,
-0.0267864354,
-0.0519853868,
0.0208343342,
0.0127358288,
-0.0440570861,
0.0614318885,
-0.0165539999,
-0.0244241972,
0.050173495,
-0.0027302797,
-0.0401510261,
0.0388482846,
-0.0101313731,
-0.0632871836,
-0.0582403615,
0.0231735241,
-0.0085615003,
-0.0171611328,
0.0212547909,
-0.0051961592,
0.0263120644,
0.0402493849,
0.0106005184,
-0.0445376001,
0.0241512321,
0.0102207707,
-0.0228363499,
-0.0085240258,
0.0091010528,
-0.0256444942,
-0.0874086171,
-0.0035390388,
0.0043129683,
-0.0333569758,
-0.0327399634,
-0.0286596976,
0.0370918959,
-0.0499365814,
0.0173105411,
0.0963051394,
0.0192608349,
0.0536655113,
-0.0000955231,
-0.0496433899,
0.07542108,
0.0389401428,
0.0038397464,
-0.0398363955,
0.0049934466,
-0.0007934343,
-0.06848602,
0.0223066285,
-0.0013336083,
-0.0409667715,
0.0009746477,
-0.0689292997,
-0.0447647646,
0.0177572947,
-0.0574273132,
0.0321104899,
0.0888204277,
-0.0010898547,
-0.0042039859,
-0.034441907,
-0.027840307,
-0.0682079419,
0.0222828332,
-0.0460583009,
-0.0008936636,
0.0389304385,
-0.0222554859,
-0.0415751301,
0.0374976583,
-0.03695485,
-0.0360097364,
-0.0215829927,
-0.0015343989,
0.0439728014,
-0.005309239,
0.0272759609,
-0.0243368745,
-0.033799164,
-0.0186296925,
0.0291174222,
0.0143975448,
-0.0100165717,
0.0364246145,
-0.0230910648,
-0.0948948264,
-0.0105667608,
0.0173206422,
0.0064375624,
-0.0190360546,
0.0029584756,
0.0534693487,
-0.0126224076,
-0.0438856296,
-0.0233927239,
-0.0261822846,
0.0380175747,
-0.0512446463,
0.0171210188,
-0.056365557,
0.0306502488,
0.0239737295,
0.0100069661,
-0.0129449572,
-0.0237470455,
0.0153896231,
0.009961444,
0.0408024751,
-0.0242640786,
0.0036603764,
0.0128628621,
0.0013012799,
0.0061097629,
0.1244232953,
0.0152873853,
0.0390036479,
0.0157963857,
-0.0090100169,
-0.0387461819,
0.0690903813,
0.0454893671,
-0.0082475888,
-0.0253617093,
-0.0178450327,
0.0116915125,
-0.0019649372,
0.0324871466,
0.0575966723,
-0.0516150892,
-0.016340185,
0.0435835458,
0.0674848482,
0.0089066317,
-0.0108145745,
0.0154915312,
0.0203044731,
0.023507243,
-0.0019021247,
-0.0122648682,
0.0246347096,
-0.0182161685,
0.0214096233,
0.0551069453,
0.0574791841,
-0.0065944511,
0.0068847341,
-0.0299087651,
-0.0318679884,
-0.0194271076,
0.0175137855,
0.0708093122,
-0.0174244475,
-0.0537928194,
0.0464954413,
0.0269737802,
-0.0311738569,
-0.0436525419,
-0.0682960376,
0.0463042893,
0.0646258593,
0.0470930003,
0.0457358062,
0.0221485626,
0.0381472334,
-0.0305714943,
0.0259600561,
0.0247899592,
0.0116131771,
0.0119628031,
-0.0424141474,
-0.0052004894,
0.0573296919,
0.0401025899,
0.0523118712,
0.0654977188,
0.0055419807,
-0.0039628171,
-0.0099360058,
-0.0234936252,
0.0138911847,
0.012892901,
0.0327739604,
0.0063338084,
-0.0110201593,
0.0273025744,
-0.0137718609,
-0.0026693486,
0.0215289965,
0.04049192,
-0.0535164177,
0.0205835886,
-0.0022264461,
-0.0596504286,
-0.0114023518,
0.0150495162,
0.015639076,
0.0223945342,
0.0306472573,
0.008900417,
-0.0357108042,
0.0342022814,
-0.0338930823,
0.0694550425,
-0.0412732512,
0.0463595577,
-0.0106247207,
0.0429893248,
0.0112544065,
0.0393726639,
-0.045608826,
-0.0114987744,
0.0028196881,
0.000348741,
0.008698876,
-0.0160773378,
-0.0183703694,
0.0392536335,
-0.0027396407,
-0.0096838549,
-0.0416507535,
-0.0183533132,
0.0234211441,
-0.0045244396,
-0.0710815117,
-0.0071701333,
-0.0482992269,
0.0385903791,
0.0099551491,
-0.0008821339,
-0.0078850575,
-0.0107663954,
0.0034114423,
-0.0110077728,
-0.0055028489,
0.020588059,
-0.0323368609,
-0.0108190412,
-0.0573865101,
-0.0201126207,
-0.0390372723,
0.0211162809,
0.0639109313,
-0.0380763337,
-0.0403731056,
-0.0821188539,
0.0110244527,
0.0538578779,
0.0136880903,
-0.007649289,
-0.0340044796,
0.0222224444,
-0.0359143056,
-0.0129795391,
-0.0035807856,
-0.0295217093,
-0.0001977561,
0.0286002457,
0.0276843682,
-0.0418049693,
-0.010217295,
0.015070118,
-0.0144049609,
-0.0578835122,
-0.0588711202,
-0.0369891264,
0.0808542892,
-0.0071484302,
-0.0062477202,
-0.0487179495,
-0.0232522599,
-0.0019458904,
-0.0352925472,
-0.0102932062,
-0.033687517,
-0.0041847117,
0.0688512772,
-0.0203790478,
-0.0735555589,
0.0502114929,
-0.0657378063,
0.0017102169,
0.0015099576,
0.0141105857,
-0.0218603201,
0.0335118547,
-0.0210336689,
0.0234521702,
-0.0267577227,
-0.0359739624,
0.0265542176,
0.028327236,
0.0022079933,
-0.0464858636,
0.0391047001,
-0.051159732,
0.0377760157,
-0.0459719226,
-0.0175511371,
-0.0055643441,
-0.0049581849,
-0.0652331933,
-0.0028971264,
0.0627067611,
-0.0345730297,
0.0152797755,
0.0481361002,
-0.0863237232,
0.0468687713,
-0.0080137784,
0.0223512668,
-0.0208683219,
0.0046265805,
0.015760228,
-0.0268170889,
0.036746271,
-0.0445865132,
0.0089370357,
0.045153819,
0.0323452502,
0.0208194219,
-0.0766251907,
0.0061637145,
0.0584738851,
0.0167732034,
-0.0036919671,
0.0687738657,
0.0432520472,
-0.0454490781,
-0.0039020404,
0.0768723041,
0.0033691232,
-0.0482925288,
-0.0023883309,
0.015854843,
0.0508474298,
-0.0083904257,
0.018562546,
-0.0722184479,
-0.0251039267,
0.0546702072,
0.0123572852,
-0.0051633934,
0.023137413,
-0.0255659334,
-0.0915846825,
0.0502343364,
0.0213755034,
-0.0085696205,
0.0075683086,
-0.0418693498,
-0.054082714,
0.0463107303,
0.0501889139,
0.0418639667,
0.0399867669,
-0.0111382296,
0.0141439987,
-0.0200246666,
-0.0462016277,
0.0356171504,
0.0023364641,
0.0901679173,
0.0223717764,
-0.0348245017,
0.0193624403,
-0.0189651754,
0.0093830163,
-0.0154611673,
-0.0119814631,
-0.0097679021,
-0.0221498944,
-0.0064808046,
0.0033116655,
0.0042341645,
-0.00277185,
-0.0281610861,
0.0008123879,
-0.0523777828,
0.022708023,
-0.0215638597,
-0.032213591,
-0.0112180337,
-0.0231510568,
-0.0137675051,
0.0302410498,
0.0152526265,
-0.0072280834,
-0.0424553938,
-0.0474349335,
-0.0463832654,
-0.0896679759,
0.000316862,
0.0173821524,
0.0381752513,
-0.0493015163,
0.000652738,
0.0295046121,
0.0047984803,
0.0206855983,
0.0020431227,
0.0535187088,
0.0248500407,
-0.0336222947,
-0.0666529536,
0.00151094,
-0.0223776698,
0.0464760512,
-0.0576973818,
0.0145687526,
0.0295906514,
-0.0125000458,
-0.0152528463,
0.0366125889,
-0.1058337986,
-0.0657543242,
0.0036046233,
0.031390056,
0.033507362,
0.005145546,
-0.0392728262,
-0.0733121634,
0.0022369281,
0.0212534387,
-0.057670109,
0.0296660941,
0.0073782858,
-0.0413248874,
0.0196707044,
0.026190538,
-0.015992552,
0.0101085883,
-0.0094408114,
0.0025603638,
0.0126808919,
-0.0192706343,
0.0085059581,
0.0294294227,
0.009751413,
-0.0475372262,
-0.0277103726,
0.0333928242,
0.0839630663,
-0.0137999952,
0.0158980656,
0.008237279,
0.0019261605,
0.0143694188,
-0.0329079218,
-0.0046888669,
-0.0130627397,
0.0350868367,
0.0384550132,
0.0287041198,
0.0002180454,
-0.0235473868,
0.0258705206,
0.0512234122,
-0.0391428508,
-0.0102298334,
-0.0036133488,
0.0059748008,
0.0448479205,
-0.0528689921,
-0.0241043419,
-0.0038968904,
0.0144048501,
-0.0445821099,
0.0195457321,
-0.0212328155,
-0.0470930673,
-0.0389142372,
0.0268775914,
0.0425751098,
0.0288711376,
0.0313640758,
-0.003233155,
0.0079416391,
-0.0147938831,
0.010740092,
-0.0145911621,
-0.0206681881,
0.0689300969,
0.0081246216,
-0.0170532316,
0.0062936945,
0.0356097519,
0.0416795611,
0.0496376418,
-0.0025776136,
0.0115947388,
-0.0046619386,
-0.0555864759,
-0.0397125594,
0.033383064,
-0.0531902276,
-0.0213968065,
-0.0204427037,
-0.0437532663,
0.007625211,
0.0018505473,
0.0084196273,
-0.011596526,
-0.0076067392,
0.0704824775,
0.0112157129,
-0.0388539322,
-0.0088279527,
-0.0295730028,
0.0340238065,
-0.0148236053,
0.0200725123,
-6.692465497e-33,
-0.0135873603,
-0.0074574081,
0.0251271408,
-0.065012522,
-0.0013411042,
-0.0109569831,
-0.0318659246,
-0.0269777104,
-0.0213674679,
-0.0149784759,
-0.0325920135,
0.035423018,
0.046777565,
0.0204218086,
-0.011993831,
0.0171958655,
0.063580893,
-0.0152199492,
-0.0126985312,
-0.014957807,
0.0233526919,
0.0204720013,
0.0156821404,
0.0145394756,
-0.0192437544,
-0.0380432643,
-0.0049820859,
-0.0520924367,
-0.0241647959,
0.0567462221,
-0.0364269838,
0.0223767739,
0.0215292405,
-0.0037137808,
-0.0190145969,
0.0127092516,
-0.0886054263,
0.0464235879,
0.0474126935,
0.0496794805,
0.0231987704,
-0.0543831103,
-0.0345807374,
0.0625422895,
-0.0365092643,
0.015820533,
-0.0552475154,
-0.0033354501,
-0.0543203503,
-0.0290732309,
0.009612916,
0.0225081146,
0.0314353965,
0.0501715094,
0.0993643701,
-0.0064424048,
-0.0308034141,
0.0126325199,
-0.040995691,
0.0165271796,
-0.0045646634,
0.0618780069,
0.074028708,
0.0050259782,
-0.0297405589,
0.0198170356,
0.0244192313,
-0.0473826006,
-0.0514468923,
0.0126525629,
0.0473097861,
0.0069760862,
-0.0072574872,
0.0213979594,
0.0788079798,
-0.0569557063,
-0.0559029914,
-0.0058545084,
0.0395567417,
0.0248301029,
0.0832214653,
0.0396964289,
-0.0299032684,
-0.0505214408,
-0.0574896112,
-0.0428065509,
-0.052954793,
-0.0228835419,
0.021467125,
0.0486079752,
-0.0318627954,
-0.0158512089,
0.0529699773,
-0.0472231805,
-0.0078249341,
0.0095881568,
-0.0023075924,
0.0395179242,
-0.0268101133,
0.038558729,
-0.0050925817,
-0.048307199,
0.0355411284,
-0.0255587548,
0.0031703413,
-0.0204235818,
-0.0207222681,
0.0295812469,
-0.0780689493,
0.0035218636,
-0.0348931253,
0.0245964155,
0.0203201417,
0.0202396084,
0.0614187308,
0.0017469805,
0.0167294592,
0.0187758058,
-0.0417459011,
0.0451933481,
-0.0207348894,
0.0077928426,
0.0221134517,
0.0625204891,
-0.0031464144,
0.0221695658,
-0.054397583,
0.0103247864,
0.0344904847,
-0.0449579246,
-0.0360421725,
0.0597450547,
2.713e-7,
0.037763603,
0.0572138652,
0.0627138168,
0.0231167488,
0.0192424897,
0.002790953,
-0.0008409579,
0.0008229659,
0.0140812779,
-0.0122425407,
-0.0250646397,
0.0199345257,
0.0579066835,
0.012660658,
-0.0579812601,
-0.0110062584,
-0.0228444468,
0.025713481,
-0.0382700078,
-0.0634398758,
0.0039321864,
0.1177777573,
-0.0391894877,
-0.0275740698,
0.0448505059,
0.009237499,
-0.002180174,
0.0041810237,
-0.0317788757,
0.0118519431,
-0.0136798937,
0.0065036048,
-0.009116604,
0.0341281146,
0.0085484544,
-0.0132420231,
-0.0485145487,
0.0772399157,
0.004472347,
-0.0272971578,
0.0180938765,
-0.0293018464,
-0.0340004079,
-0.0217721667,
0.0538766086,
0.004595845,
-0.0161583144,
-0.0556622408,
-0.0190137327,
-0.025939934,
-0.0456162542,
-0.0116326241,
0.0557149388,
0.0561123826,
0.0304307267,
-0.0169530697,
0.0019625113,
-0.05922563,
-0.050813552,
-0.0254849214,
-0.0538563021,
-0.0476524681,
-0.0521171205,
0.0259462912,
0.0339030251,
-0.0518902838,
0.0274522528,
2.732570469e-34,
0.064003706,
0.0125203058,
-0.005031989,
0.1022951156,
-0.0108620394,
-0.0458047688,
0.0374292731,
0.0471358187,
-0.0204219222,
-0.0595923029,
-0.0216281805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01521v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01521v1 | K-Level Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T16:07:05 | 2024-02-02T16:07:05 | Yadong Zhang, Shaoguang Mao, Tao Ge, Xun Wang, Yan Xia, Man Lan, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their proficiency in
complex reasoning tasks, their performance in dynamic, interactive, and
competitive scenarios - such as business strategy and stock market analysis -
remains underexplored. To bridge this gap, we formally explore the dynamic
reasoning capabilities of LLMs for decision-making in rapidly evolving
environments. We introduce two game theory-based pilot challenges that mirror
the complexities of real-world dynamic decision-making. These challenges are
well-defined, enabling clear, controllable, and precise evaluation of LLMs'
dynamic reasoning abilities. Through extensive experiments, we find that
existing reasoning methods tend to falter in dynamic settings that require
k-level thinking - a key concept not tackled by previous works. To address
this, we propose a novel reasoning approach for LLMs, named "K-Level
Reasoning". This approach adopts the perspective of rivals to recursively
employ k-level thinking based on available historical information, which
significantly improves the prediction accuracy of rivals' subsequent moves and
informs more strategic decision-making. This research not only sets a robust
quantitative benchmark for the assessment of dynamic reasoning but also
markedly enhances the proficiency of LLMs in dynamic contexts. | K-Level Reasoning with Large Language Models: While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their proficiency in
complex reasoning tasks, their performance in dynamic, interactive, and
competitive scenarios - such as business strategy and stock market analysis -
remains underexplored. To bridge this gap, we formally explore the dynamic
reasoning capabilities of LLMs for decision-making in rapidly evolving
environments. We introduce two game theory-based pilot challenges that mirror
the complexities of real-world dynamic decision-making. These challenges are
well-defined, enabling clear, controllable, and precise evaluation of LLMs'
dynamic reasoning abilities. Through extensive experiments, we find that
existing reasoning methods tend to falter in dynamic settings that require
k-level thinking - a key concept not tackled by previous works. To address
this, we propose a novel reasoning approach for LLMs, named "K-Level
Reasoning". This approach adopts the perspective of rivals to recursively
employ k-level thinking based on available historical information, which
significantly improves the prediction accuracy of rivals' subsequent moves and
informs more strategic decision-making. This research not only sets a robust
quantitative benchmark for the assessment of dynamic reasoning but also
markedly enhances the proficiency of LLMs in dynamic contexts. | [
0.0430647247,
0.0389436483,
-0.0324204005,
0.0049967179,
-0.0585107319,
0.0193798412,
-0.002839556,
0.0323961265,
0.0076250327,
-0.035528522,
0.0273958109,
-0.0373802893,
0.0012719902,
0.0606897883,
0.0113838464,
-0.0250810906,
0.0060607577,
-0.082746543,
0.0399996415,
-0.0460653305,
-0.0262570735,
-0.0197695326,
-0.0215915516,
-0.0026788777,
0.0140723716,
-0.0148060536,
-0.0216199216,
-0.0341818929,
0.0248165391,
-0.0438595377,
-0.0320228003,
0.0109106582,
0.0274146274,
0.0030155841,
0.0000021456,
-0.0567941219,
-0.0180699993,
-0.0464153662,
-0.0749611333,
0.0069110263,
0.0008568735,
0.0158399083,
0.0145606985,
0.0086245853,
-0.0370678939,
0.0099777794,
-0.0090600969,
0.0080452682,
0.0599248745,
0.0460648537,
0.02780075,
-0.0397997499,
0.007964625,
-0.0290407874,
-0.0350497626,
-0.0908876657,
0.0259812586,
0.0135349901,
0.0080330186,
-0.0092364149,
0.0172364973,
0.0298355762,
0.0044032759,
-0.0026846097,
-0.0480902344,
0.0385864712,
0.0046572466,
0.0611959845,
-0.0018978977,
0.0267060306,
-0.0113906292,
0.0268316511,
0.0081681972,
-0.003732441,
-0.0193483122,
-0.0040272041,
-0.0278280564,
0.0438916832,
-0.0203802362,
-0.0012078939,
0.0117256809,
0.021107506,
0.0531585813,
0.0201686155,
-0.0374088176,
0.1248620152,
-0.0251662619,
-0.0292170998,
0.0197341926,
-0.0266620331,
0.0229817517,
-0.0762441531,
-0.0186835919,
0.0772358477,
-0.037970271,
0.0355823338,
0.0431223735,
0.0414674617,
-0.0221093278,
-0.066326648,
0.0097964434,
0.021165289,
0.0827723145,
0.0708957836,
-0.0215686932,
0.0402345546,
-0.0103419563,
-0.0042324071,
0.0179069135,
0.0101508582,
-0.0610349476,
-0.0342549607,
-0.0076477178,
0.0385027938,
-0.0054292278,
0.0189261958,
-0.0316417962,
0.0237326212,
-0.0547760539,
0.0575521328,
-0.0490688607,
0.0074483701,
0.0238933899,
-0.0559844635,
-0.0915092081,
-0.0183389895,
-0.0246859472,
0.0074760835,
-0.0048322468,
-0.028663855,
0.0163339078,
-0.0476943664,
-0.0296157096,
-0.0358118825,
0.0027651582,
0.0861369222,
-0.0037209198,
0.0384725444,
-0.0507647283,
-0.0436886027,
-0.0078608142,
-0.0895855874,
-0.025905773,
-0.0624925196,
0.0014838844,
0.0084412899,
-0.0223659929,
-0.020194754,
0.0116556734,
-0.0143392272,
-0.023999,
0.0791107565,
0.0490795225,
0.0247516707,
-0.0081299152,
0.0113030532,
0.0072085587,
0.0876818448,
0.0286165103,
0.0105573321,
0.0062938067,
0.0376080908,
-0.0144693935,
0.0237265136,
-0.0186309777,
-0.0166505035,
-0.0594541989,
0.0223610085,
0.0131394053,
0.0208042376,
-0.0478974581,
-0.0068621291,
-0.031823013,
-0.0041243793,
0.0690588132,
0.0172592569,
0.0393937938,
0.0436728783,
0.0239785612,
-0.0059007467,
-0.0400361232,
-0.0307257529,
0.000112044,
0.0107815731,
-0.0482716896,
0.0039511858,
-0.046073094,
0.0200790558,
-0.0011621696,
-0.0366988592,
-0.0251739714,
0.0215487164,
0.0142554771,
0.0243773311,
0.0564195625,
-0.0136213824,
-0.007827024,
0.0498699695,
0.0054464606,
0.0104443524,
-0.001715267,
-0.0418779589,
0.0176341012,
0.0907789916,
0.0569235198,
-0.0381979831,
-0.0366440415,
-0.0157575477,
-0.0208971091,
0.0273830872,
0.0552603528,
-0.0290927775,
-0.0321061239,
-0.0208872743,
-0.0342665054,
-0.0094017964,
0.0081544379,
0.0253816564,
-0.0045888736,
0.045298215,
-0.0064081261,
-0.0209751073,
0.0248117335,
-0.0146988025,
-0.0316004492,
-0.0385025777,
-0.0400624946,
0.0252526347,
0.0098535242,
-0.0030529206,
0.003178234,
0.0205805264,
-0.0062412452,
-0.0239639096,
-0.0295570325,
0.036823336,
0.0076650088,
-0.0098137911,
0.0244979039,
0.0123922387,
-0.0241683666,
-0.0270867739,
-0.0249230172,
0.0126260091,
0.076342009,
0.0037037411,
0.0293915439,
-0.0190569386,
-0.0071892077,
-0.036006175,
-0.0220519435,
-0.0169362314,
0.1166582182,
0.0294971913,
-0.0082985777,
0.0241078548,
-0.01678776,
-0.0043353476,
-0.0399888903,
0.0206178632,
0.0544336401,
-0.0072436021,
-0.0124159735,
0.0023917672,
-0.0430461206,
-0.0451542176,
-0.0028733355,
-0.0351856276,
0.0114283431,
0.0119234128,
0.0158471204,
-0.0066164006,
-0.0370802321,
0.0092838407,
0.0319275074,
-0.0123250317,
0.0112951389,
0.0457514413,
0.0336557887,
0.0482755899,
0.0291849058,
-0.0111247385,
0.0351710059,
-0.0116432663,
-0.0529564805,
0.0489285402,
0.015060341,
0.0278572179,
-0.0100443643,
-0.0092408443,
-0.0644814894,
0.0193383992,
-0.0215509851,
-0.0044307499,
0.0136276931,
-0.0537435114,
-0.0199792031,
0.0699614286,
0.0017435673,
0.0014036132,
0.044179149,
-0.0824032649,
-0.0534800291,
0.0396031477,
-0.0269233845,
-0.0052343248,
-0.0840509683,
-0.0089380033,
-0.019697303,
0.091767855,
-0.0152030298,
-0.000684155,
-0.047289744,
0.0259144008,
-0.0046051792,
0.0250363089,
-0.0817320272,
0.002554286,
0.021299623,
0.1041027158,
-0.0109052099,
0.015881503,
0.0963156894,
0.0308317244,
0.0103489328,
-0.0217829868,
0.028338667,
-0.0332307369,
0.077195324,
-0.0585136302,
-0.0060600759,
-0.0314457193,
-0.0048004431,
-0.047332067,
-0.0662418082,
0.056291718,
-0.0267986823,
0.0427664146,
-0.0765583366,
-0.0149660511,
0.0108476244,
-0.0335970558,
-0.0538811423,
0.000012925,
-0.0736292973,
0.0244099181,
-0.0094362944,
0.0028864273,
-0.0620153658,
0.0266639236,
0.0343909897,
-0.0443065353,
-0.0079583917,
-0.0294525046,
0.0027094537,
0.0047397395,
0.033000052,
0.0360154733,
0.0423617922,
-0.0263705868,
0.0736528412,
0.0369336605,
0.0540779196,
-0.0227660313,
-0.0051658568,
0.0351878144,
0.0070051225,
-0.0078187855,
-0.0031632159,
0.035369467,
-0.0325096473,
-0.0799444541,
0.0072693173,
0.055109933,
0.0281097032,
0.0477437638,
0.0019185968,
-0.0313030705,
0.0147799645,
0.0220428538,
0.0584193133,
-0.060992308,
-0.0448008366,
-0.004719344,
-0.0061114314,
-0.0024198457,
-0.0776283816,
-0.001985511,
-0.1518506557,
0.0208750349,
-0.000171487,
0.0140018221,
-0.0031041016,
0.0036097509,
0.0009252467,
-0.0384964235,
-0.0381020345,
0.0413455851,
0.0269042011,
-0.0139888953,
0.0176350772,
-0.0310983546,
-0.0205209684,
0.0611205548,
-0.0144640803,
-0.0090916799,
0.0278090984,
0.0397669636,
0.007036645,
-0.0376911908,
0.0025516024,
0.0035062518,
0.0259221606,
0.0196911264,
0.0102902604,
-0.0006269864,
-0.000600935,
0.0214126781,
-0.0128059713,
-0.0018480935,
-0.0129414639,
0.0300232377,
0.0819696635,
-0.0022071193,
-0.0361448489,
0.033524204,
0.0132587114,
-0.0203499347,
0.0416587591,
-0.023584934,
-0.0252969395,
-0.0485755093,
-0.0662607998,
-0.0247604549,
-0.0473465063,
-0.0231882911,
0.0133965649,
0.0080308923,
0.0011304414,
-0.0597346313,
-0.0190908611,
0.0365985781,
0.0427825898,
0.0051834648,
0.0093974955,
0.0164214429,
0.0375180952,
-0.0598120764,
-0.0114135286,
-0.0395631418,
0.0366638936,
0.0050007962,
0.0195228569,
-0.0151825948,
-0.0592019036,
-0.0390591137,
0.0076151048,
-0.061823085,
-0.0739098564,
0.0040871818,
0.0398934409,
0.0322905816,
0.0339551494,
-0.0218437109,
-0.0127161527,
0.0496670678,
-0.0263275877,
0.0055771749,
-0.0179491881,
0.0332684442,
0.0030861532,
0.0254315287,
0.0462234803,
-0.0417145304,
-0.0081060966,
0.0332337543,
0.0177922957,
-0.0467927828,
0.0205510203,
-0.0239758287,
-0.0159441177,
0.0125310505,
0.0415434912,
-0.0751474574,
0.0003769517,
0.0460539386,
0.0137919979,
-0.0589216799,
0.0108918333,
-0.004573903,
0.0264178142,
0.007038434,
0.0188606009,
0.0060565765,
0.0151657937,
-0.0234174449,
0.0088769132,
0.0147114424,
0.0479895771,
0.0385444127,
0.0625602975,
-0.0091253426,
0.0117901852,
0.0161108188,
-0.0076184338,
0.0663500726,
-0.0047087064,
0.03093886,
0.037398383,
-0.0485731922,
-0.0379572771,
-0.0406275839,
-0.049867183,
-0.0974832103,
0.0710206628,
0.0334784724,
0.0290085655,
-0.0015312668,
-0.0458532795,
-0.0717821121,
0.006484834,
0.0283060092,
-0.0318105295,
-0.0029742722,
-0.082858704,
0.0299562439,
0.0427606069,
-0.0252961013,
0.0174115207,
0.0498030782,
-0.0159885995,
0.0283718146,
-0.0479915328,
-0.0452784039,
0.0028783528,
-0.0245219506,
-0.0024085192,
0.063886337,
0.0123811951,
0.0385811515,
-0.0972780064,
-0.0514370501,
0.010335112,
0.0214607902,
-0.0084811822,
-0.0024106,
-0.000978251,
0.0485126153,
0.0506916344,
-0.0047374242,
-0.0428422131,
0.0388122201,
-0.0271051191,
0.0162151176,
-0.0032698517,
-6.251674218e-33,
0.0209869426,
-0.0150516015,
0.0444822684,
-0.0478508025,
-0.0245370287,
-0.0083593111,
-0.0409590937,
-0.0164624173,
-0.0131494422,
0.0178792365,
-0.023264626,
0.0074411826,
0.0028039888,
-0.0135059711,
0.0299749281,
-0.0320510566,
-0.020893028,
0.0177158117,
-0.0498971343,
0.0139538823,
0.0480489396,
0.0026684951,
0.0456266813,
-0.0235980377,
0.0013076422,
0.0131925587,
-0.0119076213,
0.0377972797,
-0.0690115541,
0.0355441235,
0.0023129496,
-0.0128977401,
0.0229718443,
-0.0854272246,
0.0175237451,
-0.0164601486,
-0.0178386439,
-0.0071578631,
-0.0023937188,
-0.0064514652,
0.0225479528,
0.0035591447,
-0.0103817033,
0.0364605859,
0.00869535,
-0.0198637694,
0.02624535,
-0.0732528865,
0.0038940534,
0.0128537044,
-0.0263980161,
0.0268483032,
-0.0581441671,
0.0383095816,
0.0384892486,
0.0224584024,
-0.0041773217,
0.0053959428,
-0.0437197611,
0.0810794532,
0.0326528214,
-0.0107756797,
0.0648828,
0.0134093873,
0.025726309,
0.0575622655,
-0.0208154283,
0.021210935,
-0.0374925211,
0.0048954859,
-0.0323277265,
0.0778173581,
0.0380060561,
0.0170988478,
0.0163203012,
-0.0046662353,
-0.0687814355,
-0.0045027607,
0.0557397678,
0.0501929894,
0.0305590034,
0.0140376082,
-0.0369901732,
-0.0518632755,
-0.0142221088,
0.0138040837,
-0.0415893719,
-0.0166075528,
0.0166358761,
0.0009463281,
-0.0110523766,
0.0281474646,
0.0058328439,
-0.0291503984,
-0.0443210453,
0.0055350247,
0.0214006621,
0.0186391808,
0.0048175612,
0.0163616985,
-0.0193265136,
-0.0090176808,
-0.0368340053,
-0.0176911745,
0.0034455776,
0.0035297989,
-0.0147840083,
0.0168168209,
-0.0092842802,
-0.0182950925,
-0.0390978381,
0.0271120071,
0.0296118855,
-0.0111900149,
0.041019246,
0.0111232605,
0.0218005218,
-0.0108605949,
0.0296908095,
-0.0275807921,
0.0114352424,
0.0435473248,
-0.0147152096,
0.0079348106,
0.0078524342,
-0.0170731619,
-0.0193886608,
0.0062174117,
-0.0183760356,
-0.0423917659,
-0.012272113,
0.0423937216,
2.836e-7,
-0.002818326,
0.0595558546,
-0.0197150484,
0.0123791248,
0.0163911264,
0.0665634871,
-0.0603437014,
-0.0418027118,
0.0145806177,
-0.018734986,
0.0282007381,
0.0532920547,
0.0593774915,
0.0567811169,
-0.0457156971,
-0.0125553608,
-0.0423634052,
-0.0102723949,
-0.0712032318,
-0.0205658302,
0.0314151086,
0.0172645934,
0.0353071764,
-0.0046651848,
0.0379422829,
-0.0860095546,
0.0469769165,
-0.0152619192,
0.0368610658,
0.0209033061,
0.0130827501,
-0.015547975,
-0.0150426235,
0.0398711637,
-0.003406472,
0.0369083099,
-0.0299229976,
0.0384170972,
0.0189906023,
-0.0280499086,
-0.0321085528,
-0.0504512936,
-0.0099775596,
-0.069930248,
0.1175867543,
-0.0639757067,
-0.0332362987,
0.002076711,
0.0382618941,
-0.0357660279,
-0.0154679539,
0.0083906492,
-0.0157805402,
0.0073120082,
-0.0232286379,
-0.0147969611,
0.0416191295,
-0.0707443208,
-0.0162687451,
0.0176590532,
-0.051509846,
-0.0129641416,
-0.0243279506,
0.0156017728,
0.0287430603,
0.0048676427,
0.0224207751,
2.557767112e-34,
0.0427635871,
0.0262012258,
-0.0288993791,
0.0000412879,
0.0774278045,
0.0105361203,
-0.0162882786,
0.0139452117,
0.0487467684,
-0.0853400752,
-0.0273214765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01513v1 | Multilingual Gradient Word-Order Typology from Universal Dependencies | 2024-02-02T15:54:19 | 2024-02-02T15:54:19 | Emi Baylor, Esther Ploeger, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CL | cs.CL | While information from the field of linguistic typology has the potential to
improve performance on NLP tasks, reliable typological data is a prerequisite.
Existing typological databases, including WALS and Grambank, suffer from
inconsistencies primarily caused by their categorical format. Furthermore,
typological categorisations by definition differ significantly from the
continuous nature of phenomena, as found in natural language corpora. In this
paper, we introduce a new seed dataset made up of continuous-valued data,
rather than categorical data, that can better reflect the variability of
language. While this initial dataset focuses on word-order typology, we also
present the methodology used to create the dataset, which can be easily adapted
to generate data for a broader set of features and languages. | Multilingual Gradient Word-Order Typology from Universal Dependencies: While information from the field of linguistic typology has the potential to
improve performance on NLP tasks, reliable typological data is a prerequisite.
Existing typological databases, including WALS and Grambank, suffer from
inconsistencies primarily caused by their categorical format. Furthermore,
typological categorisations by definition differ significantly from the
continuous nature of phenomena, as found in natural language corpora. In this
paper, we introduce a new seed dataset made up of continuous-valued data,
rather than categorical data, that can better reflect the variability of
language. While this initial dataset focuses on word-order typology, we also
present the methodology used to create the dataset, which can be easily adapted
to generate data for a broader set of features and languages. | [
0.0078679631,
0.1115000471,
-0.0317605212,
0.0416570939,
-0.0188312363,
0.0209222715,
0.0063544204,
0.0020781206,
-0.0023597004,
-0.0471155718,
0.012804199,
-0.0782622546,
0.0414588489,
0.0187914241,
0.0350072272,
-0.0718783215,
0.0168422032,
0.0092170797,
-0.006922747,
0.0055732881,
-0.0000051805,
0.021440601,
-0.008950063,
0.0288271178,
-0.0605183542,
-0.0250278506,
0.0286432635,
-0.0062019164,
0.0296985656,
-0.0243754257,
0.0578844473,
0.052252993,
0.0066549028,
-0.017361505,
0.000001785,
-0.0445645601,
-0.0304729715,
-0.0078283511,
0.0376794003,
-0.045945134,
-0.0012394151,
-0.0296653751,
-0.0399132594,
0.0270552021,
-0.0440388136,
-0.0282476172,
0.0464155301,
0.0048739119,
0.0183503665,
0.0249654595,
-0.0201765243,
-0.0878580511,
0.0310890973,
0.0122911297,
-0.0054461895,
0.0215250533,
0.0054690726,
-0.0050774473,
-0.0149003854,
0.0112735964,
-0.0249255095,
-0.0059337979,
0.0016280735,
0.0073975599,
-0.0232058614,
-0.0028580267,
-0.0128904497,
-0.0273311716,
-0.0111001255,
0.0705902353,
-0.0255904831,
-0.0156002175,
0.0131144598,
-0.0111099286,
-0.0118542491,
0.0115143666,
-0.000993008,
0.064588733,
-0.0183273144,
0.031939473,
0.0769352168,
0.028735308,
-0.0085814865,
0.0091737062,
-0.0662460178,
0.1109037474,
0.0156926662,
-0.0409880131,
-0.0025998249,
-0.0317865349,
-0.0195057988,
-0.0294529069,
0.0014615945,
-0.039876271,
0.0050331512,
0.0072259498,
-0.0152953602,
-0.028780194,
0.0226856973,
-0.0669298768,
0.0288226046,
-0.0274197031,
-0.0197634678,
0.0129011385,
0.0408376716,
0.0295151714,
0.0117580779,
-0.0348195396,
-0.0098205674,
-0.0169133693,
-0.0285019316,
-0.0030144793,
0.0197411627,
0.0111445943,
-0.0345171951,
0.0383269824,
-0.0637181178,
0.0009835332,
-0.0249012932,
-0.0123755382,
0.0224944912,
0.0089404713,
-0.0064374008,
-0.0079560149,
-0.0273881238,
0.0038848729,
-0.0172597226,
0.0169951506,
-0.03945392,
-0.0451788343,
0.0407847613,
0.0088916495,
0.020254571,
0.0130965915,
0.0087995883,
0.0416918583,
0.0499107763,
-0.0126384394,
-0.0365359522,
-0.0022733039,
-0.0198609773,
0.0020894471,
-0.013166381,
-0.090877004,
0.0201221202,
0.0306575783,
-0.0175814517,
-0.038070187,
0.0001542067,
0.0088849189,
-0.0624756366,
0.0711972937,
-0.0487679206,
-0.0157549456,
-0.0294882599,
-0.051100187,
0.00684459,
0.057624992,
0.0241194312,
-0.0434789434,
0.0983958095,
-0.0304896366,
-0.0192266777,
0.0250504073,
-0.0283500943,
0.0033220032,
-0.0436252207,
-0.010174891,
-0.0055444231,
0.0238066558,
0.0405528285,
0.029501671,
0.005375179,
-0.0333087668,
0.0388782248,
0.0617190935,
0.0497690439,
-0.0132375229,
0.0139653496,
0.0032946547,
-0.0093749557,
0.0297352616,
0.0228138734,
-0.0577421598,
0.0034456863,
-0.0158996228,
-0.0419557281,
0.0763816983,
0.000975436,
-0.0450588912,
-0.0425561592,
-0.0280386638,
0.0081509734,
-0.0413957052,
0.0346166454,
0.0077852155,
0.0097403927,
0.0208178833,
0.0574900806,
-0.0553371422,
-0.0357417129,
0.0395716168,
0.0095794955,
0.0754184723,
-0.0106064705,
-0.0373421051,
-0.022708701,
0.037557479,
-0.002753742,
0.0120408321,
-0.0086616687,
-0.0484638363,
0.0415436663,
-0.036182452,
0.0134921223,
0.0395864919,
0.0024172028,
0.0290208291,
-0.0142587265,
0.0460889265,
-0.021868255,
0.0127455313,
-0.0424979515,
0.0256705619,
-0.0339080989,
-0.0220606569,
0.0424334966,
-0.0022724508,
0.0350065567,
0.0479522161,
-0.0353499353,
0.0185873527,
0.0404442623,
-0.0527751483,
0.0048755822,
0.0456156284,
-0.028998306,
-0.0131781064,
0.0258666873,
-0.0155801848,
0.0048675551,
-0.0053294296,
-0.0268883035,
-0.0184330996,
0.0164173525,
0.0433500037,
0.0597777441,
-0.041040536,
0.0252300464,
0.0100228302,
0.0385270566,
-0.0441909321,
0.0298399143,
0.0010180025,
0.0740455985,
-0.0289989561,
-0.0290647242,
0.0119559374,
0.0405048952,
0.0408878438,
0.0655545592,
0.011360364,
0.0260484386,
0.0274524353,
0.0090559619,
-0.0108368602,
-0.0011032708,
-0.0963751078,
0.0162186064,
-0.0118333781,
0.0341448188,
0.0084962584,
0.0400567427,
-0.0125447856,
-0.0075207562,
-0.017617546,
0.0068233511,
0.0086309966,
0.0189911295,
0.0674587488,
-0.0387600623,
0.001567499,
-0.012321298,
-0.0259842332,
0.000676912,
0.0468393713,
-0.0585616715,
0.010287472,
-0.0189159364,
-0.0140271895,
-0.0129500795,
0.0517654642,
0.0033925693,
-0.059235815,
0.0090862401,
0.0193443391,
0.0462940335,
0.0116961394,
0.0379097499,
0.0281015001,
0.0218564551,
-0.0212876741,
-0.012467552,
-0.0383468904,
-0.019446278,
0.0618309043,
0.017805161,
-0.0306487512,
-0.0062654368,
0.0995765626,
0.019721875,
-0.0537473522,
0.0008087155,
0.0180007555,
-0.080322206,
-0.0106967576,
-0.050043799,
0.0234273896,
-0.0570279919,
0.0266529936,
0.0080704493,
-0.0298575014,
0.0146267898,
-0.0025911971,
0.0132038631,
-0.0548456572,
-0.029830087,
-0.0575830825,
0.0347182751,
-0.011844323,
-0.007921041,
-0.0006500379,
-0.0253218636,
-0.0441426635,
-0.018370593,
0.0190631486,
-0.0014660938,
0.0290966313,
-0.0619744509,
-0.0042457548,
-0.016223954,
-0.0733080059,
-0.021193698,
-0.0807561651,
0.0327036604,
-0.0135058919,
0.0548218861,
-0.0473985635,
0.0313237719,
-0.0016371902,
0.0159628447,
0.0499446169,
-0.0382091366,
-0.0012113265,
0.0095338244,
0.1023278758,
-0.0004726649,
0.0072469027,
0.0094042355,
0.0517651401,
-0.0119832326,
0.0299083162,
-0.0073221321,
0.0270422306,
-0.009826838,
0.0138698248,
0.0337020867,
-0.0267963614,
-0.0608920529,
-0.0225748867,
-0.0031314453,
-0.0122831576,
0.0258038528,
0.0996482447,
0.0471005775,
-0.0196442734,
0.0420938171,
0.0091122622,
0.0468596034,
0.0252583586,
0.0030515161,
-0.0448957495,
0.0213454831,
-0.0014221785,
0.000547628,
-0.0333419479,
-0.0271212813,
-0.0072053461,
-0.0693754405,
0.005775549,
-0.0104847252,
-0.0069964398,
0.0091113048,
-0.0270658098,
-0.0186413638,
-0.0097334003,
-0.0144378021,
-0.0038689366,
-0.0118925981,
0.0117613021,
0.0386729129,
-0.0676068962,
-0.0516114458,
0.0047836285,
-0.0314545035,
-0.0077712326,
0.0051530991,
0.047069978,
-0.0810812786,
-0.0161134936,
0.0316800661,
-0.031112019,
-0.0489272252,
-0.0042664222,
0.0225841235,
-0.0000149854,
-0.021279281,
-0.019705737,
0.0217274502,
-0.0599542707,
0.0061349045,
0.007745727,
0.0453957804,
-0.0075358097,
-0.0047356267,
-0.0433100648,
-0.0451369882,
0.0450008102,
0.0168219823,
-0.0159817617,
-0.0751638189,
0.0009010927,
-0.0428874604,
0.003468107,
-0.0325978994,
-0.0590894446,
0.0368350036,
-0.0002964961,
-0.0570687056,
-0.0922086686,
-0.0646567941,
-0.020273149,
0.0456538014,
0.0017319989,
-0.0147126364,
0.0184559021,
-0.0272420943,
-0.0549490489,
0.0187097266,
0.0709817782,
-0.0165149905,
-0.0458048582,
-0.0403977782,
0.0778208375,
0.0261321459,
-0.0401364639,
-0.0002708344,
0.0091888783,
-0.0527142771,
0.0618696921,
0.0055983006,
0.0152626755,
0.0136352582,
0.0110158743,
-0.0284571033,
0.0844794735,
0.0372576192,
0.008367192,
-0.0018939768,
0.0250721667,
-0.0137760239,
0.0079649426,
0.0241997428,
-0.0090787308,
0.0374271385,
-0.0342077389,
0.0088634137,
0.0073373131,
-0.0148218451,
0.0092513189,
-0.0445010848,
0.0196048077,
-0.022091601,
-0.0416775867,
-0.0703511387,
0.0088331988,
-0.0673801452,
-0.0392381288,
-0.0203189552,
0.042293787,
0.0151888533,
0.0113286413,
-0.0696450099,
-0.0231729951,
0.0019424198,
0.0182505753,
-0.0085527543,
0.0396425314,
0.080687739,
0.0178755857,
-0.0130166197,
-0.0067015504,
-0.0178142488,
0.0244397745,
-0.0756965801,
0.0466565229,
-0.0430672467,
-0.0134751061,
0.0015776632,
-0.0341389291,
-0.0363947675,
0.091672942,
-0.0088046668,
0.027903432,
-0.0052212416,
0.0029605941,
0.0728648156,
-0.0476530008,
0.0617393404,
-0.0230283272,
-0.0041666538,
0.005004589,
0.0245217122,
0.0320065022,
-0.0073341858,
-0.0164511725,
0.0093701109,
-0.0624126755,
0.0227497052,
0.1172210574,
0.0495085865,
-0.0281361602,
0.0339314118,
-0.0186149329,
-0.0095575303,
0.0362654403,
0.0274009164,
0.0007489596,
0.0125200255,
0.0324667096,
-0.0830163285,
-0.0488130413,
0.0420158654,
0.0145629086,
0.0047424692,
0.0307393372,
0.0261245128,
0.1089082137,
0.0298934747,
0.0315316617,
-0.0524787046,
-0.0097411647,
-0.0450678915,
-0.049442593,
0.0006149805,
-6.20732355e-33,
0.0036923529,
-0.0430424586,
-0.0619211756,
-0.0279489253,
0.0223170538,
0.0250059273,
0.04850813,
-0.0101719527,
0.00052385,
0.0149326446,
-0.0422656275,
0.0202841144,
0.0188110191,
0.0274052043,
0.0686258078,
0.0342028216,
-0.0351527892,
-0.0179154854,
0.0182278138,
-0.014157665,
0.0744543672,
0.0340390503,
0.1238751784,
-0.0641337857,
0.0494456366,
0.005257919,
0.0101496521,
-0.0083750328,
0.0408098362,
0.03426769,
-0.012149455,
0.0793243945,
0.0520683229,
-0.0205943007,
0.0071900692,
-0.0075612459,
-0.0183782689,
-0.0516715832,
0.0003631506,
0.0240441654,
-0.0422074273,
-0.0006766157,
0.0164797567,
-0.0202630367,
-0.0199342463,
0.0048997533,
0.0305589624,
-0.0186467804,
-0.0289219115,
-0.0210646465,
-0.0461363047,
0.0517331883,
0.011897428,
0.0240028314,
0.0155835012,
0.0116214231,
-0.0130849443,
-0.0043708491,
-0.0580611415,
0.0278317947,
-0.0130216926,
0.0702782571,
0.0017568436,
0.0017975388,
0.0063157734,
0.0389882624,
-0.0200927798,
0.0043491647,
0.0301968455,
0.0191830248,
0.0025916838,
0.015169384,
-0.0187960695,
0.0429985188,
0.0672626495,
-0.0493079014,
-0.0537858643,
0.0269187763,
0.0480451062,
-0.0328904726,
-0.0053304313,
-0.0234791245,
-0.0525390059,
-0.0405320749,
-0.0118625844,
-0.0496158116,
0.0163896084,
-0.0185762309,
0.0006843515,
-0.0459512398,
0.0223015137,
0.0166924465,
-0.0007565588,
-0.0261730757,
-0.101310052,
0.0427164547,
-0.0142134754,
0.0421418473,
0.0257923435,
0.0403819419,
-0.0473030433,
-0.0301043354,
-0.0276117306,
0.0462588891,
0.0531559177,
0.0158788431,
0.0179358032,
0.0216641631,
-0.0524125025,
-0.0106643774,
-0.0010647869,
-0.0024152298,
-0.0411057658,
0.0676860437,
0.0133415805,
0.004307834,
0.0026800241,
0.0521303937,
0.06854067,
0.0030784332,
-0.0212461315,
0.0108706756,
-0.0129914973,
0.0436636321,
-0.0247996096,
-0.0304027647,
-0.0070188059,
0.0410907492,
0.0254210792,
-0.0128142126,
-0.0029629422,
-0.0217028428,
2.674e-7,
0.0078513995,
0.0597672947,
0.0197632685,
0.030333288,
0.0381238796,
0.0126820514,
0.0041636485,
0.0330311768,
-0.0813711658,
-0.025935296,
0.0017829847,
-0.0497681685,
0.0264824685,
0.039153073,
-0.1178240031,
-0.0352056623,
-0.0244704522,
0.0079736663,
-0.0540236272,
-0.0176891964,
0.0479788408,
0.1373100132,
0.000707196,
0.0099617252,
-0.0332369618,
0.0230385922,
0.0318945311,
-0.0153731015,
-0.004022608,
-0.0248895083,
0.0371458307,
-0.0337213501,
0.0212937985,
-0.0122733023,
-0.02468789,
0.036191538,
-0.0085875895,
-0.0028482643,
-0.0240715537,
-0.0197966956,
0.0196246728,
-0.0265526585,
-0.0376578085,
-0.0924026817,
0.0622901171,
0.0282346737,
-0.0471408069,
-0.0209225416,
-0.0137611749,
0.0365397893,
0.0169828217,
-0.0417920724,
-0.0233579818,
0.0190154724,
0.0229553431,
-0.0470921397,
-0.0261439104,
-0.046234183,
-0.0284064822,
0.0240052622,
0.0085232127,
-0.0174661782,
0.0394120775,
0.0120953666,
0.0393716432,
-0.010758847,
0.014894776,
2.841603309e-34,
0.0329101086,
0.0019855385,
0.0285701677,
0.0141010797,
0.0233898554,
-0.0399859659,
0.0220186803,
0.0160085931,
-0.0082553048,
-0.0405723751,
-0.0142665002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01512v1 | Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions: A Survey of Methods, Datasets, and Evaluation | 2024-02-02T15:53:31 | 2024-02-02T15:53:31 | Elaf Alhazmi, Quan Z. Sheng, Wei Emma Zhang, Munazza Zaib, Ahoud Alhazmi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Distractors are important in learning evaluation. This paper surveys
distractor generation tasks using English multiple-choice question datasets for
textual and multimodal contexts. In particular, this paper presents a thorough
literature review of the recent studies on distractor generation tasks,
discusses multiple choice components and their characteristics, analyzes the
related datasets, and summarizes the evaluation metrics of distractor
generation. Our investigation reveals that more than half of datasets are
human-generated from educational sources in specific domains such as Science
and English, which are largely text-based, with a lack of open domain and
multimodal datasets. | Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions: A Survey of Methods, Datasets, and Evaluation: Distractors are important in learning evaluation. This paper surveys
distractor generation tasks using English multiple-choice question datasets for
textual and multimodal contexts. In particular, this paper presents a thorough
literature review of the recent studies on distractor generation tasks,
discusses multiple choice components and their characteristics, analyzes the
related datasets, and summarizes the evaluation metrics of distractor
generation. Our investigation reveals that more than half of datasets are
human-generated from educational sources in specific domains such as Science
and English, which are largely text-based, with a lack of open domain and
multimodal datasets. | [
-0.0039329431,
-0.019438874,
-0.0255731083,
0.0124780368,
-0.0156783741,
0.0076464899,
0.0812034309,
-0.0143917855,
0.0642423481,
-0.0328356661,
-0.0241038129,
-0.0177513231,
-0.0508018769,
-0.066625163,
0.0514299609,
-0.0861281827,
0.026348792,
-0.0286567211,
0.0148437349,
0.019852953,
-0.0203655884,
-0.0357038788,
-0.0329935141,
0.0035421117,
-0.0050090565,
-0.0581784882,
-0.0221810471,
-0.0096784774,
0.0358575359,
-0.0717051849,
0.0364729017,
0.0581060052,
-0.0129139591,
-0.0279015936,
0.0000020408,
-0.0437883846,
0.0007428146,
-0.026107071,
-0.0120774368,
-0.0066742008,
0.0295919199,
0.089621149,
0.0414304025,
-0.0036121076,
-0.0145684779,
0.010051812,
0.0383190401,
0.0206496641,
0.050648924,
0.0218596384,
0.0063689752,
0.0115226619,
0.0047510634,
0.0366216674,
0.0676421821,
0.0172310583,
-0.0403028801,
0.0119915847,
-0.0103286402,
0.0507935844,
-0.0531625487,
0.0075269942,
0.0048794318,
0.0372901075,
0.0129531398,
0.0241725352,
-0.0375688076,
-0.0567604788,
-0.0218091402,
0.1001563966,
0.0050154785,
0.0079414835,
-0.026520744,
-0.0217220951,
0.0222723112,
0.0708868504,
-0.0615882166,
0.0408727825,
-0.045715183,
-0.0237375535,
0.0169629529,
-0.0220862515,
-0.0283551347,
0.0010475612,
0.0242688637,
-0.0285755899,
0.0285959207,
-0.0300617032,
0.0388098471,
0.0034062574,
0.0065203113,
-0.051453907,
0.0198994409,
0.0151514299,
-0.0828375518,
0.0140054068,
-0.0483769104,
-0.094014369,
0.0350416042,
-0.0220529605,
0.0122546488,
0.031552922,
-0.0521934852,
0.0127398195,
-0.0006260384,
0.0434789173,
-0.0523860306,
0.0346488357,
-0.0008944526,
0.04250383,
-0.0144804874,
0.0148439547,
0.004179447,
0.0142821725,
-0.0378723405,
-0.023927182,
-0.0086803231,
0.0129602514,
-0.0088559762,
0.004792314,
-0.0083439276,
0.0230549052,
0.0069325212,
0.0170063097,
-0.0402443036,
0.0302096065,
-0.0315788388,
-0.0077449726,
-0.0085431002,
-0.0101279374,
0.0140890023,
0.0516295955,
0.0310023185,
-0.0627963468,
0.0031733979,
0.0715272501,
-0.0242521539,
-0.0268868431,
-0.0274185538,
-0.0220647398,
0.0251368657,
-0.0456679724,
0.0519459955,
-0.0075251595,
0.0003895471,
0.0086794868,
0.0067040785,
-0.0188531596,
0.0347764194,
0.0632912591,
0.0496762693,
0.0195152946,
-0.0128439227,
-0.0317391679,
0.0367643684,
-0.0105166305,
-0.0049153683,
0.0545781776,
0.0201272219,
0.01397302,
0.0646148995,
-0.0784165636,
0.0215803701,
0.0149171948,
-0.0331023969,
-0.0458745807,
0.0310542025,
0.0052497596,
0.0426948816,
0.0258605126,
-0.0057942374,
0.0505144671,
-0.0074951742,
0.0241673142,
0.0450263955,
0.0094858175,
0.0211408436,
-0.0111979991,
-0.0018026733,
0.0019156309,
0.0095951408,
0.0853734314,
-0.0094636744,
0.0246126521,
-0.0143155409,
0.0086019728,
0.0165223498,
0.0411179475,
-0.0021242031,
-0.0532060899,
-0.0200689286,
0.0399427302,
-0.0079475157,
0.0325686485,
0.0431101844,
-0.011132855,
-0.0717105865,
0.0299194828,
-0.000448627,
-0.0696065351,
0.0146697722,
0.0064199748,
0.0724732354,
0.0568309911,
0.0068242666,
-0.0571536571,
-0.0746680945,
-0.0079036169,
0.0648093671,
0.0292924978,
0.0138617791,
-0.0408071578,
0.0145113114,
-0.0702456981,
-0.0374519415,
-0.0377435759,
-0.018865509,
-0.0128584439,
0.0193761159,
-0.0073761991,
-0.0276696756,
-0.0051698852,
-0.0386188142,
0.0515928157,
-0.0147753097,
-0.0510107651,
-0.0069628558,
0.0146948518,
0.0233435221,
0.0055501522,
-0.0120909391,
-0.0024195868,
0.0145944273,
-0.000809686,
0.0508853123,
0.0053936057,
-0.0276421066,
0.002348314,
0.0408599637,
-0.0661470219,
-0.0199518427,
0.0237795487,
0.0156484172,
-0.0041634222,
0.009808558,
-0.050656464,
-0.0298392884,
0.0290486515,
0.0160933398,
0.0010394743,
0.0051477901,
-0.0259880181,
0.0897991881,
0.0214774292,
0.0601243824,
0.0526165999,
0.0500011295,
0.0242083054,
-0.0157705992,
0.0162769519,
-0.026329834,
-0.0235115066,
0.0211633705,
0.0064038909,
0.0133901462,
-0.1428515017,
0.0016037113,
-0.0114972703,
0.0331446417,
-0.0076532131,
0.0102543654,
0.0202876609,
-0.0494269393,
-0.0020668411,
0.0046574795,
-0.0226202756,
0.021943355,
-0.0179656558,
0.0133197065,
-0.0115531217,
-0.0576207116,
0.043781966,
-0.0204810239,
0.000697641,
-0.0205178466,
0.0465203077,
0.0451889746,
0.0070852228,
-0.0124559458,
0.0518973023,
0.0295793358,
-0.0153799923,
0.0328589901,
0.026236549,
0.0836118236,
-0.0100495685,
0.1067444235,
0.0397330634,
0.0399425626,
0.0296582337,
0.0360530913,
-0.0431981273,
-0.0519018359,
0.0185612366,
-0.0129407207,
0.0038386639,
0.0282234736,
-0.0621709973,
0.0320824571,
0.0112491464,
0.0417561978,
-0.0113136461,
-0.0099575724,
0.0333045945,
-0.0234830473,
-0.0507475957,
-0.0540812872,
0.0175622683,
-0.0643360838,
0.0459042378,
-0.0162762012,
-0.0196909774,
0.0357244052,
0.0089338897,
0.0214738976,
-0.0631266385,
0.0596440136,
0.0013128754,
-0.0008826599,
-0.0446601212,
-0.0027448186,
0.0561614633,
-0.0229075365,
-0.0250925664,
0.0035056937,
0.0267002657,
-0.0267105289,
0.0505247489,
-0.0616899356,
-0.0561254509,
0.0338596553,
0.0056486265,
-0.0503703095,
-0.019751763,
0.0329327099,
-0.057780847,
0.0071915393,
0.0227965228,
-0.0303042009,
-0.0488900542,
0.0633510575,
0.0101210568,
-0.0112205613,
-0.0223221965,
0.0060377666,
0.0840776041,
0.0315918364,
0.0712105334,
-0.009191839,
-0.0554322228,
-0.0071851355,
0.0520429909,
0.0425778553,
-0.0595124811,
0.0106897131,
0.035553176,
0.0344664454,
-0.0333383903,
0.005403982,
0.026189154,
0.0881806016,
-0.0397017226,
-0.0188503526,
0.0556528568,
0.0322059207,
-0.0109217195,
-0.0252704527,
-0.0387550145,
-0.0405888781,
0.0341039784,
-0.0354460925,
-0.0304640513,
-0.037021447,
-0.0432331488,
0.0158808175,
-0.0079183234,
-0.0102294087,
0.0105989082,
-0.0926873311,
0.0449026041,
-0.0133189252,
-0.0936679468,
0.0287347939,
-0.0301859565,
-0.0104568098,
-0.0000902131,
-0.013173297,
0.0032491859,
0.0215522014,
0.0257031843,
0.0500783287,
0.0222829096,
-0.0003775451,
-0.0528672673,
-0.0377549268,
-0.0307849478,
-0.0298087224,
0.005795761,
-0.0224937815,
-0.0754309073,
-0.004751707,
-0.072338298,
-0.0095976433,
0.0103766713,
0.0682626665,
0.0054388596,
-0.0016437516,
-0.0741358846,
0.0432850979,
-0.0050396537,
-0.0491507724,
0.091144219,
0.0593554117,
-0.0007400081,
-0.0174135622,
-0.0134980557,
0.0128504597,
0.0168377347,
0.0128304325,
0.0392637439,
-0.0747231618,
0.0295888353,
-0.0224301033,
0.0679482371,
-0.0806481317,
-0.001970489,
0.0102407634,
-0.0487397462,
-0.014270165,
-0.0413047336,
-0.0513985381,
0.0616074912,
0.0305560231,
0.0181735083,
0.0181938354,
0.0133468509,
0.0039199148,
-0.0149846366,
0.032143645,
0.0332283825,
-0.0193239171,
-0.0023255809,
-0.0734992772,
-0.0371000171,
0.0066412468,
0.009179214,
0.0668168813,
-0.02830703,
-0.0159864109,
0.0240563378,
0.0504490696,
0.0098662637,
-0.0533473305,
0.0671551228,
-0.0157349911,
-0.0551926903,
-0.0142026981,
-0.0139238434,
-0.0052985675,
-0.0379472561,
-0.0306821838,
-0.0013785558,
-0.0463773124,
0.0000894476,
-0.0168106016,
0.0325356722,
0.0160222389,
-0.0416248031,
0.0128689473,
0.0200796612,
0.0169739649,
0.0175148156,
-0.0675323904,
-0.0050776056,
-0.055241067,
0.0027692965,
-0.0048065642,
-0.0526734404,
0.0058445702,
-0.0071459548,
0.0137345931,
-0.0251452979,
0.0031578953,
-0.0176415909,
-0.0433806032,
-0.0120668793,
-0.0465309694,
0.0504451878,
0.0420376919,
0.019266732,
0.0203533079,
0.0125279175,
-0.0182514936,
-0.0139336959,
0.0286111813,
0.0487921834,
0.0448754951,
0.102280423,
0.0127408942,
-0.0298845731,
0.0322522447,
-0.0097227646,
-0.0031728654,
0.0138057116,
-0.0223278143,
0.0088650659,
0.016445078,
-0.0068204594,
0.0284806285,
0.0305637922,
-0.0136413323,
-0.0246180315,
0.0424738415,
0.007177541,
-0.0209973361,
0.0244746394,
0.010563883,
0.0263241213,
-0.0551144443,
0.0586110912,
-0.0290103722,
-0.001983501,
0.0150922025,
-0.0216188841,
-0.0875271857,
0.0026053402,
-0.0366917774,
0.0555655174,
0.0223583151,
0.0173571203,
-0.0577023812,
-0.0292767268,
0.0035842522,
0.0136657758,
0.0394505002,
-0.0088766767,
0.0394313522,
0.028058894,
-0.0365183614,
-0.0069560106,
0.0039284881,
0.0587169118,
-0.0742237791,
-0.0131070716,
-0.0474430174,
-5.735588851e-33,
-0.0306082312,
-0.0688582286,
0.0479004495,
-0.032818526,
-0.009928274,
-0.0166757386,
-0.051710669,
0.0399920233,
0.0061799325,
-0.0212031733,
0.0136233745,
-0.0371298976,
0.0033954221,
0.0586114898,
0.0298168268,
-0.0459278263,
-0.0102997376,
-0.0123245576,
-0.0258138888,
0.0208625048,
0.0636574551,
-0.0312539637,
0.0399875902,
-0.030966837,
0.034602277,
-0.0361022092,
0.0122238705,
-0.0477164946,
-0.0123310965,
0.045773197,
-0.0500546992,
0.093141444,
0.0113451378,
-0.0586931445,
-0.0229192805,
0.0500012003,
-0.0182811022,
-0.0801762715,
0.0045792782,
0.0086115906,
-0.0661174953,
-0.0610373057,
0.0448418185,
0.0211608913,
-0.0183004234,
-0.0184123628,
0.0574518032,
0.0110017229,
-0.0208674315,
0.0169394705,
-0.0952439383,
-0.0005873452,
-0.0498242751,
-0.0141892359,
0.0048491079,
0.0686642304,
-0.0138922557,
-0.0069828997,
-0.0371690802,
0.0782671571,
0.0162401851,
-0.0178007856,
0.0266475733,
0.01229198,
0.0027183089,
0.0531101227,
0.0492854193,
-0.0005407943,
0.0258529652,
-0.0228640437,
-0.0070690718,
0.0495537072,
0.0517575666,
0.0578052066,
0.0220540352,
-0.0040255194,
-0.0269872863,
0.0380479284,
-0.030286191,
0.0001109982,
0.0029577501,
-0.0533309951,
0.0171448607,
-0.0117996056,
-0.0087003708,
0.0112706413,
-0.0391953848,
0.0062696715,
0.0547029115,
-0.0673132241,
0.0148706809,
-0.0056732688,
0.0163541343,
0.0106066018,
0.0266200844,
0.0052706813,
-0.0028399273,
0.0592420101,
-0.0006808451,
-0.0489985868,
-0.0171460342,
-0.006238597,
0.0355380699,
0.0060887756,
0.0440876447,
0.0008762886,
-0.022754034,
-0.0216188468,
-0.0401422046,
0.0036640675,
-0.0488618799,
0.0115410378,
0.037839774,
0.000932521,
0.0395600758,
-0.0097483369,
-0.0397328325,
0.0090413764,
0.0094303638,
-0.0198738556,
-0.0251856465,
-0.0585449785,
-0.003696112,
0.0104291802,
0.002436341,
0.0082215378,
-0.0366952755,
-0.0166906156,
0.024462916,
-0.0702038184,
0.0099988496,
0.0027180081,
2.512e-7,
0.0247366354,
0.0518482327,
-0.0072062407,
0.0168806911,
0.0017497401,
0.0221597143,
0.0025663034,
-0.006498503,
0.023149725,
-0.0127756633,
-0.0434035175,
-0.0138730705,
-0.0205959119,
0.0149382772,
-0.0493837185,
-0.0594323911,
0.0543073379,
0.0148044461,
-0.0280020759,
0.0568631142,
0.0943306684,
-0.0196599141,
-0.0065206187,
-0.0220306255,
-0.0342367552,
0.0410991423,
-0.0051743239,
-0.0157685764,
-0.0102170091,
-0.0147736575,
0.0234339908,
-0.0006061265,
-0.0210253373,
0.0473331586,
-0.0223781131,
-0.07968501,
0.0355270244,
-0.0198705196,
0.0303282551,
-0.042547375,
-0.0006390553,
0.017786609,
-0.0064428924,
-0.0139239505,
0.0373821892,
-0.0082501918,
-0.0161459018,
0.0510623753,
-0.0473471321,
-0.0067576454,
0.0031347594,
-0.0179352798,
0.0049567902,
-0.0352741256,
-0.0118721221,
0.0211189948,
0.0023256689,
-0.00485407,
-0.0163081922,
0.0482913777,
-0.0249603596,
-0.0407809317,
-0.0153386006,
-0.0460979007,
0.0113055632,
-0.0101401284,
-0.0235783365,
1.294507529e-34,
-0.0173098296,
0.0218929518,
0.0496554561,
0.021215843,
-0.014928746,
-0.055267632,
0.0246301033,
-0.0095921513,
0.0325862244,
-0.0498836003,
-0.0092451433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01510v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01510v1 | A Hybrid Strategy for Chat Transcript Summarization | 2024-02-02T15:44:28 | 2024-02-02T15:44:28 | Pratik K. Biswas | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68, I.7 | Text summarization is the process of condensing a piece of text to fewer
sentences, while still preserving its content. Chat transcript, in this
context, is a textual copy of a digital or online conversation between a
customer (caller) and agent(s). This paper presents an indigenously (locally)
developed hybrid method that first combines extractive and abstractive
summarization techniques in compressing ill-punctuated or un-punctuated chat
transcripts to produce more readable punctuated summaries and then optimizes
the overall quality of summarization through reinforcement learning. Extensive
testing, evaluations, comparisons, and validation have demonstrated the
efficacy of this approach for large-scale deployment of chat transcript
summarization, in the absence of manually generated reference (annotated)
summaries. | A Hybrid Strategy for Chat Transcript Summarization: Text summarization is the process of condensing a piece of text to fewer
sentences, while still preserving its content. Chat transcript, in this
context, is a textual copy of a digital or online conversation between a
customer (caller) and agent(s). This paper presents an indigenously (locally)
developed hybrid method that first combines extractive and abstractive
summarization techniques in compressing ill-punctuated or un-punctuated chat
transcripts to produce more readable punctuated summaries and then optimizes
the overall quality of summarization through reinforcement learning. Extensive
testing, evaluations, comparisons, and validation have demonstrated the
efficacy of this approach for large-scale deployment of chat transcript
summarization, in the absence of manually generated reference (annotated)
summaries. | [
0.075571917,
-0.0046465448,
-0.0156048043,
-0.0300218426,
-0.0197632201,
0.0142100835,
-0.0391951315,
0.0063715028,
-0.0056363624,
-0.0172532704,
0.0035326304,
0.0024043061,
0.0284179915,
0.0163752306,
-0.0252179671,
-0.12411163,
0.0314885117,
-0.0042892043,
0.0297291502,
0.0268727094,
0.038608212,
0.0059106317,
0.0157499667,
0.0255394019,
0.0143938214,
0.000113976,
-0.0246805288,
0.013319362,
0.0295835286,
-0.0084828446,
0.0014563488,
-0.0106855594,
-0.0302086566,
0.0345498845,
0.000001695,
-0.0553486943,
-0.0530362241,
-0.0126574142,
0.0141163459,
0.0111465752,
0.0872972608,
-0.0015482694,
-0.0354961492,
0.0456977002,
-0.0144878533,
0.0064590052,
0.0402603336,
0.0697421804,
0.0734260604,
0.0826674327,
-0.0221280549,
-0.0139104696,
0.0192148052,
0.0105383154,
-0.0126215899,
-0.0157120246,
-0.0125617096,
0.0492750965,
0.0386152677,
-0.0326386653,
0.0182886403,
0.0357302241,
0.001219744,
-0.0389239378,
-0.0406387411,
0.0370255597,
-0.0581206009,
-0.0219797194,
-0.0261727087,
0.0350145288,
0.0137460539,
0.0173629373,
0.0410973541,
0.0188947339,
0.0079387212,
-0.027516434,
-0.0860557035,
0.0279044472,
-0.0240664836,
0.0284882579,
-0.0409997106,
0.042020198,
-0.0475945659,
0.0078143142,
-0.051397942,
-0.0500978194,
-0.0343041644,
-0.0293726027,
-0.0462154225,
0.0111675411,
0.0298741329,
-0.0419857576,
0.060711138,
0.0268393625,
-0.0307391509,
-0.0196582954,
-0.0153718563,
-0.0623251721,
0.0195934959,
-0.0366270952,
0.0021259205,
0.006291057,
0.0304176155,
0.0504901484,
-0.0118733952,
0.0053766961,
0.0512857772,
0.0030707621,
-0.0355907157,
0.006254096,
-0.0389150716,
-0.0171550512,
-0.032644853,
0.0542856008,
0.0003290471,
-0.0367952175,
-0.0620789565,
0.0406288207,
0.0309636053,
0.009520743,
0.010203151,
-0.0129544083,
-0.0420287251,
0.0351543091,
0.0167705938,
-0.0077713486,
-0.0347013809,
-0.0088850828,
0.0340312123,
-0.049426917,
0.0204353668,
0.0240128469,
0.048802238,
0.0200024415,
-0.0507588498,
0.0474010184,
-0.0431789123,
-0.0277878009,
0.00355398,
-0.038044218,
0.0011320936,
-0.0004162889,
-0.0375045203,
-0.037589632,
-0.007061631,
-0.0169320218,
-0.041619014,
0.048880782,
-0.0028373506,
0.0067957975,
-0.0249122716,
0.0191153791,
-0.0236957669,
0.0107581429,
0.0464245267,
0.001248489,
-0.0040922668,
0.0540401004,
0.055289913,
0.0662474111,
0.066574201,
0.0255764034,
0.0305881053,
0.0335346647,
-0.0076444321,
0.0052175033,
0.0112675894,
-0.0163776465,
-0.0211699773,
-0.0417317599,
0.0287804361,
0.0729533955,
-0.0454267189,
0.0565115958,
0.060742002,
0.07141985,
-0.0136688547,
0.007534158,
0.0191979073,
0.0802825168,
0.0236931015,
0.0715302899,
0.0016620115,
0.0294989664,
-0.0072364793,
0.0437584557,
0.1044270322,
0.0174766909,
-0.0156453997,
-0.0557791069,
0.0361012481,
-0.018382309,
0.0412149653,
0.0060391328,
0.0177806448,
-0.0004493919,
-0.035125345,
0.0029659111,
-0.0020218221,
-0.0468651503,
-0.0188830793,
-0.0382699408,
0.0109177446,
0.0609688126,
0.033774998,
-0.0339224972,
-0.0177151412,
-0.041592665,
-0.0393810682,
0.0328145027,
0.0255255606,
-0.0276122931,
-0.0208522286,
-0.0379239842,
-0.0287059937,
0.0360035449,
-0.0229962002,
-0.0088650659,
-0.0042406465,
0.0114537412,
0.0246184617,
0.0527094826,
-0.0529526509,
0.0099556297,
-0.0126422103,
-0.0082730623,
0.0016562,
-0.012484964,
0.0351070911,
0.0400915109,
-0.0141491191,
-0.005912568,
0.0021878905,
0.0203187298,
-0.0247989781,
0.0574346073,
-0.047051806,
-0.0418425985,
0.0155458627,
-0.0676582679,
0.0164636858,
0.0038720637,
-0.038924817,
-0.0511533953,
0.0086039063,
-0.0605365634,
0.0648939759,
-0.0407216698,
0.0200606938,
0.0050412826,
-0.0082097715,
-0.012757251,
0.009751183,
0.0019902675,
-0.0243323762,
0.0102113318,
-0.0776959881,
-0.0198900178,
-0.0398625657,
0.0455036126,
0.0185825359,
-0.0108222319,
0.0176681243,
0.068502374,
0.0286373887,
-0.0383087359,
-0.0337943584,
-0.1111610532,
-0.0054628416,
-0.0174034908,
0.0108480109,
0.0314978398,
0.0714401007,
-0.0333121382,
-0.044575002,
-0.0033669521,
-0.0393386558,
0.0445169881,
0.0097175278,
0.0339540802,
0.035069257,
0.0159612726,
-0.0647661388,
-0.0171931535,
0.0179845374,
0.0376923271,
0.0140456259,
-0.0525936298,
-0.0431631543,
-0.0132112084,
-0.0037953209,
-0.0299751647,
0.016804371,
-0.0426757149,
-0.0143806785,
-0.0037589322,
0.0411244854,
0.0312995166,
0.0510185212,
0.013758339,
-0.0097395778,
0.0183356665,
-0.0506738983,
0.0073167882,
-0.0330448933,
-0.0067227758,
0.0031307635,
-0.033429265,
0.0465146005,
0.0265435614,
-0.0015641761,
0.0263104662,
-0.018609805,
0.0090604983,
-0.0271061696,
-0.0315435082,
-0.0298900772,
-0.0135446321,
-0.0365772806,
0.0118307294,
-0.0334918909,
-0.0486083888,
0.076462768,
0.0368902571,
0.0073932158,
-0.0875707567,
-0.044590354,
-0.0381344706,
0.0280572288,
-0.0086330688,
0.0342637524,
-0.0106455591,
-0.0720955655,
-0.0399270579,
-0.0511423014,
0.0478589386,
-0.02140259,
0.0194577947,
0.0016967652,
-0.0090412796,
-0.0043433374,
-0.0334219635,
-0.0262100492,
-0.0390246175,
-0.0069519151,
0.0081033865,
0.0472019203,
-0.0064508962,
-0.066508688,
0.0548233688,
0.0451305546,
0.0450363196,
-0.0138520738,
-0.0308675002,
0.0031876592,
0.0490999743,
0.0309165251,
-0.0152550684,
0.0122421617,
-0.045031555,
0.0358928144,
0.0390398242,
0.0166233368,
-0.0344555229,
0.0459817573,
-0.0373305939,
-0.0078193704,
-0.0874373168,
-0.0002428917,
0.0016334222,
0.0430404916,
-0.0194446407,
0.0084281275,
0.0956838503,
0.0275268164,
-0.0443644933,
-0.0272327699,
-0.0395470299,
0.0296679549,
-0.0091051375,
0.0485058948,
-0.0742884278,
0.0079275873,
0.0018595685,
0.0456057079,
0.011499716,
-0.0168708805,
-0.0009530712,
-0.0849666595,
0.0269868989,
0.0196322389,
-0.0981981009,
0.0160736293,
-0.0224042423,
-0.0015487547,
-0.0116305742,
0.0211897735,
0.0098157022,
-0.0261290651,
0.0050965636,
0.0237901192,
-0.0927162841,
0.032268513,
-0.0747343674,
-0.0208406765,
0.0148778157,
0.0858011767,
0.0421753712,
0.0316564329,
0.0440214947,
0.0162026566,
-0.0066134864,
-0.0046878704,
-0.0008822439,
0.0700599253,
0.021913182,
0.016742425,
-0.0244892724,
0.0235723108,
0.06149593,
0.0132578341,
0.0282728542,
0.0048498577,
0.0266299136,
-0.0091802962,
-0.0427722037,
0.0425669998,
0.0270563718,
0.0333895348,
0.0268159881,
-0.0208102353,
-0.0712972954,
-0.0323904566,
-0.0233159475,
-0.0577326268,
-0.0144680589,
-0.0110246958,
-0.0551293194,
-0.0262495428,
-0.1096054018,
-0.0677737817,
-0.0058374228,
-0.0252036694,
-0.0206152573,
-0.0049342895,
0.026406724,
0.0443407446,
-0.0329286642,
-0.0649475902,
-0.0076193218,
-0.0061846767,
-0.0245891716,
0.0142218471,
0.0159708597,
-0.0523045808,
0.0097027263,
-0.0196130592,
-0.0275367629,
-0.0293971151,
-0.0107711526,
0.0325713083,
0.0141558107,
0.0734903216,
-0.0024932071,
0.0024474282,
0.0597864613,
0.033982113,
-0.0221761558,
-0.0086254319,
0.0320510231,
0.0760936961,
-0.0151221622,
0.0085270163,
-0.0718092024,
0.0427065007,
-0.0573549271,
0.0189415608,
-0.0510342754,
-0.0163129549,
-0.0005427343,
0.0275089592,
-0.0059230118,
-0.0079354653,
-0.0173919313,
0.0071740807,
0.0001736198,
-0.0202278551,
-0.0129760569,
-0.0083716055,
0.0400630794,
-0.0232954957,
0.0284238346,
0.0101248678,
0.0587484315,
-0.0181118157,
0.025725361,
-0.0276088677,
0.0106566176,
0.0160726532,
-0.0176094472,
-0.030764902,
0.0001634722,
-0.0271292124,
-0.0076133334,
0.0081609683,
0.0505603775,
-0.0135043971,
0.0190660059,
0.010664627,
-0.0178993642,
0.0219802596,
0.0357188098,
-0.077468954,
0.0358232409,
-0.0214040242,
0.0485686809,
0.0430046506,
-0.0247989148,
0.0613578744,
0.0102264509,
0.0153927039,
-0.0141327484,
0.0169864316,
0.0025966875,
-0.0255798958,
-0.0842612907,
0.013871369,
0.0034435978,
0.0113965748,
0.0525658652,
-0.0809405148,
0.0009655691,
-0.004574968,
-0.0521365851,
-0.0381094366,
-0.0202552453,
0.0074045863,
0.0397765152,
0.0137306955,
-0.0326269381,
-0.0190633535,
-0.0051532481,
0.0039717304,
0.0273568425,
0.0345632248,
-0.0033735659,
0.0358851664,
-0.0067242137,
0.0184259042,
0.0086516337,
-0.0542290919,
-0.0478803627,
-0.0244636033,
0.0108433142,
0.0124324886,
-5.531671071e-33,
-0.0134128798,
-0.0206766091,
-0.0165385064,
0.026922131,
-0.0651161522,
0.0038322443,
-0.032926783,
-0.0445622578,
0.0525799654,
-0.0173960235,
-0.0349922925,
0.0197398365,
0.0303989649,
0.0234607738,
-0.0055167791,
0.0417821035,
0.0528777279,
-0.0182818174,
-0.0234091133,
0.0628741533,
0.0268251467,
0.0301269256,
-0.0056722192,
-0.0550329499,
0.0170101188,
-0.0006634869,
-0.0108999936,
0.0070381486,
0.0802181885,
0.0452195592,
-0.0079701105,
-0.0261975005,
0.0085420981,
-0.0264471825,
-0.0506024472,
0.0304393787,
-0.0841978937,
-0.0294027589,
0.0126194675,
-0.000388966,
-0.0296486896,
-0.0115660531,
0.0394933596,
-0.0364769064,
0.0311723929,
-0.0099952323,
0.0442766808,
-0.0401920155,
-0.0356006473,
-0.0591471903,
-0.0336502716,
0.0339840949,
-0.0620050617,
0.0030022704,
0.024249021,
0.0720820129,
0.0114704734,
-0.0422874577,
-0.0198178571,
0.0532222427,
0.0246092118,
0.0147287091,
0.0279288888,
0.053163223,
0.0045838133,
0.0510174669,
0.0065171616,
-0.0053832242,
-0.0206329729,
-0.0026975798,
-0.019178031,
-0.0025402913,
-0.0126076881,
0.0200166181,
0.014354175,
0.0051656673,
-0.0286223944,
0.0778102949,
0.0394387618,
0.0047676894,
0.0334729478,
0.0373756289,
-0.0326786302,
0.0108987708,
0.0013927702,
0.0291712992,
0.016480295,
-0.0443065949,
-0.0149951009,
0.0283173434,
-0.069608897,
-0.0325353332,
0.0256931912,
-0.0486834459,
0.0162789859,
-0.0254851319,
-0.0334974304,
0.03453492,
-0.0276499595,
-0.0591494627,
-0.0096086385,
0.0028652051,
0.0346079431,
0.0147991301,
-0.0133013939,
0.01907265,
0.0469322801,
-0.0013252718,
-0.0466924272,
0.0211580358,
0.0555400066,
0.0520493574,
-0.0430676267,
-0.0070007574,
0.0126292212,
-0.0127964299,
0.0007210899,
0.0331421159,
0.004905628,
0.0009060304,
-0.0092544137,
-0.0106914658,
0.0039086035,
0.0099235708,
-0.0463761427,
0.0311386138,
-0.0242669322,
0.0346966088,
0.0089228731,
-0.0374449678,
-0.0135435462,
0.0138098551,
2.405e-7,
-0.0040008305,
0.0637842938,
0.0772509426,
-0.0309420768,
-0.004269131,
0.0130635519,
0.0165935252,
0.0104359733,
0.013486525,
0.0341476426,
0.0752913877,
0.0210178699,
0.0566148087,
0.0235842951,
-0.1591325253,
-0.0557938293,
-0.1043780595,
-0.0568864681,
-0.0375257544,
0.011093745,
0.0549138822,
0.0484053679,
-0.0020635219,
0.0129923765,
-0.0078919912,
-0.0003417249,
-0.0025933511,
-0.0086957142,
-0.0191215817,
0.0111257145,
0.0497347154,
0.0004444309,
-0.021019388,
-0.058934886,
0.0016576934,
-0.021026196,
0.0413313434,
0.0355512872,
0.0248330235,
0.0084018605,
0.0218334999,
-0.0131590087,
0.0399665572,
0.0133752748,
0.0224425606,
-0.0584384166,
-0.0239508282,
-0.025967326,
-0.0312180743,
-0.0348758548,
-0.0216386728,
-0.0014635457,
-0.0439648144,
0.0690938085,
-0.0229304116,
0.020849824,
0.0018685173,
-0.0811570957,
-0.0204690639,
0.0337358341,
0.0175935328,
-0.0370536447,
-0.018508669,
0.0258580539,
-0.0038093766,
-0.0426164083,
0.0266944245,
1.910644385e-34,
0.0514830239,
-0.0009772333,
-0.0287382938,
0.0123422425,
0.0248450469,
-0.0214834996,
0.0559511371,
0.0229056161,
0.0659610033,
-0.054851573,
-0.0090901563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01505v1 | Code-Switched Language Identification is Harder Than You Think | 2024-02-02T15:38:47 | 2024-02-02T15:38:47 | Laurie Burchell, Alexandra Birch, Robert P. Thompson, Kenneth Heafield | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code switching (CS) is a very common phenomenon in written and spoken
communication but one that is handled poorly by many natural language
processing applications. Looking to the application of building CS corpora, we
explore CS language identification (LID) for corpus building. We make the task
more realistic by scaling it to more languages and considering models with
simpler architectures for faster inference. We also reformulate the task as a
sentence-level multi-label tagging problem to make it more tractable. Having
defined the task, we investigate three reasonable models for this task and
define metrics which better reflect desired performance. We present empirical
evidence that no current approach is adequate and finally provide
recommendations for future work in this area. | Code-Switched Language Identification is Harder Than You Think: Code switching (CS) is a very common phenomenon in written and spoken
communication but one that is handled poorly by many natural language
processing applications. Looking to the application of building CS corpora, we
explore CS language identification (LID) for corpus building. We make the task
more realistic by scaling it to more languages and considering models with
simpler architectures for faster inference. We also reformulate the task as a
sentence-level multi-label tagging problem to make it more tractable. Having
defined the task, we investigate three reasonable models for this task and
define metrics which better reflect desired performance. We present empirical
evidence that no current approach is adequate and finally provide
recommendations for future work in this area. | [
0.0199300852,
0.0412724689,
-0.0212705713,
0.0395075791,
-0.0352547355,
0.0323593095,
0.0110873552,
0.0028098156,
0.0403632522,
-0.0409684554,
-0.0351133905,
0.0086029638,
0.0008330573,
0.0313372761,
0.0447353907,
0.0358197205,
0.0672831461,
-0.033038117,
0.0123573914,
0.0368810184,
0.0254327636,
0.0025595529,
0.0215246528,
0.025748536,
0.0019531229,
-0.0093945339,
0.0372354314,
0.0281559955,
-0.0072416463,
-0.0198548622,
0.0523199588,
0.0344548263,
-0.0281452127,
0.0593740344,
0.0000015046,
-0.0178174824,
-0.0795571059,
-0.0367894769,
-0.0297094267,
-0.0113827558,
0.0555974059,
-0.0447404683,
0.0006353439,
0.0345421284,
-0.0024864774,
-0.0458595045,
0.0833112523,
-0.0455983132,
0.0283681434,
0.0809044912,
-0.0161996372,
-0.0317079984,
-0.046686314,
0.0121187167,
-0.0182337947,
-0.063733682,
0.0124466587,
0.0029049788,
0.0248678047,
-0.0321737602,
0.0024160231,
0.0335445516,
-0.0435063727,
0.0081721041,
-0.0293808412,
-0.0198743343,
-0.0620310754,
0.0142542832,
-0.0081713945,
0.0074863187,
-0.0731137246,
-0.0654384941,
0.0393695608,
-0.0013633079,
-0.0308395829,
-0.0767789483,
0.0116040697,
0.0135002853,
-0.054387752,
0.0048563192,
0.0668071434,
0.0207498837,
0.0470035709,
0.0027050963,
-0.0406343043,
0.0597870015,
0.0203173645,
0.0225871764,
-0.0185298938,
-0.0010133946,
0.0176918563,
-0.0654256865,
0.0218748227,
-0.0035186841,
-0.0578666814,
0.0181251131,
-0.0357492156,
-0.0437315367,
-0.0291029494,
-0.0177553985,
0.0027549311,
0.0129155917,
-0.0333774909,
0.0386164002,
-0.0599773601,
0.0171383079,
0.0040256134,
-0.0218078103,
-0.0260216761,
-0.0349846259,
-0.0444999225,
0.011282282,
-0.0578580573,
-0.0156063,
0.0303753987,
0.0209706686,
-0.0128563857,
0.0116704209,
0.0179228261,
0.0124105755,
-0.0348771177,
-0.0908176675,
0.0097344201,
0.0221238844,
0.0808995888,
0.0075490358,
-0.0067091072,
-0.0209920462,
-0.022183137,
-0.0776342452,
-0.0261822827,
0.0647703484,
0.004902286,
-0.0135354446,
0.0282683,
0.0233265292,
-0.0080329683,
-0.0099142315,
-0.0760536864,
-0.0164124817,
-0.0291418079,
-0.0410373285,
-0.0173143856,
-0.0759176761,
-0.0028638442,
0.016884841,
0.0393586121,
-0.0776826814,
-0.0186235942,
-0.0271794312,
-0.000940404,
0.0786907896,
-0.0478716269,
-0.0131727234,
0.0168287978,
-0.0152825313,
-0.0092053879,
0.0736089945,
0.0414282568,
-0.0026972673,
0.0921765938,
-0.0327586271,
0.0390447117,
0.0860462487,
-0.0436290279,
0.0202092249,
0.0122731058,
-0.04514575,
0.0634773001,
-0.0378420986,
0.0084331101,
0.0259935651,
-0.007893282,
0.0094734784,
-0.0252479333,
0.0181695614,
-0.0185505655,
-0.0017938762,
0.0226988439,
0.0089081535,
-0.0123260617,
0.0161595363,
0.0249271356,
-0.0281416699,
-0.012946235,
-0.013574291,
-0.0008768851,
-0.0023744407,
-0.0170444585,
0.0169407297,
-0.041401498,
-0.0483386703,
0.0240611155,
-0.0356334895,
0.0436139926,
-0.0024882904,
0.0113954134,
0.0243014339,
0.02226514,
-0.0413579606,
0.0319822691,
-0.0482076108,
-0.0109056216,
0.0293220337,
0.0367635675,
-0.0365907624,
0.0120054716,
-0.0234172698,
0.0163374152,
0.0332677513,
0.0113905575,
-0.0380452611,
0.0377728418,
-0.0326514356,
0.0167247113,
0.0311729144,
0.0046232734,
0.0445678346,
0.01070878,
0.0004318017,
-0.0055662729,
-0.0308764465,
-0.0070947423,
0.0357186496,
-0.0265550427,
0.0016004214,
0.0623795912,
-0.0101544019,
0.0358500741,
-0.0119383382,
-0.0226913858,
0.0073285676,
-0.0401554853,
-0.0336654894,
0.0124443658,
0.0217256416,
0.0185921025,
-0.0411766432,
0.0407755375,
-0.0192083959,
-0.0240346007,
0.0327062309,
-0.0226293784,
-0.0635780692,
0.0590047613,
-0.0340913758,
0.0334399939,
-0.0118042137,
0.0507496372,
-0.0137807131,
-0.0041344501,
-0.0139254145,
0.0221976433,
0.0294335186,
0.048649393,
-0.0022327004,
-0.0126652578,
0.0634222776,
-0.0122416569,
-0.0311381612,
0.0188064855,
-0.0340925753,
-0.0226535108,
0.0273971539,
0.0065404545,
-0.0092612375,
-0.0088221412,
-0.0572733358,
-0.0018867759,
-0.0428781062,
0.0599304773,
0.0066295667,
0.0001974517,
-0.0264574531,
-0.029109275,
-0.0345800668,
-0.0033921518,
-0.0131698549,
0.0147323785,
0.0104134381,
-0.0126106832,
-0.0512471795,
-0.0627413094,
0.003847498,
-0.0256484039,
0.0554768257,
-0.0050860676,
-0.0999457911,
-0.1046399921,
0.009251927,
-0.0006085747,
0.0422664657,
0.0061859195,
-0.0354367234,
0.0025444122,
-0.012968841,
0.0455593318,
0.0281319842,
-0.0133024901,
-0.0382792801,
0.0567459874,
-0.0122901034,
-0.0267971605,
-0.0248994064,
0.0104361195,
-0.0387788452,
-0.0267378613,
-0.0607732497,
0.0558574758,
0.0794607326,
-0.0119635584,
-0.0086602541,
-0.0231634211,
-0.0632360056,
-0.0254096948,
-0.0005816293,
0.0207936782,
-0.0088113239,
-0.0119860983,
0.0498318635,
-0.0056784283,
-0.0505022816,
0.0313813202,
-0.0522737652,
-0.0108723855,
-0.0958757922,
-0.0164670553,
-0.0112202317,
0.0431936942,
0.0075856405,
0.0271991547,
0.0782952011,
-0.0568284616,
-0.0013393232,
0.0305514783,
0.0063102674,
-0.022785183,
-0.0057424493,
-0.0671903491,
0.0280681141,
-0.0028375245,
-0.0327950157,
-0.0208740979,
-0.0314944722,
-0.0586538948,
0.0072691357,
0.0625053644,
-0.015984904,
0.0002693562,
0.0249072798,
0.0191593356,
0.0845571831,
0.0213720351,
0.022617409,
-0.0083363382,
0.0398957729,
-0.00181929,
-0.0553985164,
0.0192223154,
-0.0033443864,
-0.0224882811,
0.0142588038,
0.0625340939,
0.0598307922,
-0.0290791057,
-0.0166182723,
0.0512763336,
-0.0384207927,
-0.0279055852,
-0.0022900095,
0.0167511906,
0.0052762679,
-0.0311466921,
0.100921303,
0.0437218882,
-0.0962242708,
-0.0258062426,
0.0264304858,
0.0309662465,
0.0309743993,
0.0086519886,
-0.0859899893,
-0.0545534417,
0.0382254049,
0.0225752685,
-0.0353651643,
-0.0283849668,
-0.0346282609,
-0.0583134778,
0.0085559562,
0.0102294544,
-0.0202126373,
-0.023331793,
-0.024372844,
0.0058437739,
-0.0051882593,
-0.0698668584,
-0.0179923233,
0.0052355509,
-0.0017913877,
0.031706959,
-0.0373784453,
-0.0127310706,
-0.005737816,
-0.0489146449,
0.0545762926,
0.0682809204,
-0.0064276489,
-0.02113837,
0.001340589,
0.0384330563,
-0.0361219235,
-0.0411816686,
-0.0300860852,
0.0315687358,
-0.0322126858,
-0.0323753431,
0.0632876903,
0.0068528634,
-0.0477890223,
-0.0070477175,
0.011382224,
-0.0005612079,
0.0075947153,
-0.0151952319,
0.0553763807,
-0.0019315928,
0.0374539681,
0.044503402,
0.0289509669,
-0.0533894859,
-0.000014556,
-0.0395404175,
0.0313965455,
-0.0305578653,
-0.011155759,
0.0074218428,
-0.0204208065,
-0.0722150654,
-0.0695042312,
0.0195445269,
0.0250104163,
0.0310326032,
0.0122169424,
0.0336294957,
0.013287697,
0.0118108029,
-0.0526870042,
-0.0208899602,
-0.0502475761,
0.0420309789,
-0.0733120665,
-0.0210902486,
0.0423632935,
-0.0127882101,
-0.0032941713,
0.0288043767,
-0.1334987432,
-0.0453031212,
0.0160346217,
-0.0260784235,
0.0145268561,
0.000733908,
-0.0474203005,
-0.0323787965,
-0.0749432296,
-0.0002346811,
-0.0312366262,
-0.0001411267,
0.0356153548,
0.0039022355,
-0.0223803949,
0.0205152631,
-0.0281250607,
0.0061407113,
0.0593419969,
-0.0057376246,
-0.0746801719,
0.0015194691,
0.0131239342,
0.0275746677,
0.0403045155,
-0.0534817241,
-0.0038475504,
-0.024124898,
-0.0145305637,
0.0449567549,
-0.0268073883,
-0.0101193227,
-0.0194916222,
0.0370488875,
-0.0127023002,
-0.0204021242,
0.0639908239,
-0.0223106463,
0.0261234045,
0.0161110107,
0.0414874703,
0.0454544462,
0.0682824031,
-0.013388956,
-0.0225655735,
-0.0083339149,
0.0457855612,
0.033811897,
0.0408589914,
-0.0270054899,
0.0208270587,
0.0243375469,
-0.0257613901,
0.0103957504,
0.0456218123,
-0.0262297988,
0.0251014344,
0.0165472105,
-0.0131605687,
0.0614300743,
0.008687471,
0.0934113041,
-0.0031308923,
0.0005713177,
-0.048557613,
0.0310749561,
0.0039869905,
-0.02776362,
-0.011755975,
-0.011225027,
-0.0468580462,
0.0064056111,
0.0836592987,
0.028156599,
0.0119010145,
-0.0020935708,
-0.0394051746,
-0.0075323372,
0.020309234,
-0.0164622702,
-0.0012266219,
-0.0032148946,
-0.002338907,
-0.0270346329,
-0.0436385088,
0.0347710326,
-0.0068346425,
0.0737807453,
0.0267517045,
0.0018387637,
0.0856759921,
0.0202614609,
0.0182627179,
-0.0544546656,
0.0033213883,
0.0671425015,
-0.0211033355,
-0.0123444917,
-5.101670829e-33,
0.0002042966,
-0.0164953861,
-0.0458893478,
0.0241727103,
0.0552774966,
-0.0205195099,
-0.058222454,
0.0267889015,
-0.0151186706,
-0.0563526899,
0.0090684975,
0.0209357049,
0.0332812443,
-0.0173908528,
0.0248697884,
0.0012816699,
0.0172439292,
0.0261397045,
-0.0419405587,
0.0007818226,
0.0372689255,
-0.0027321561,
0.0689619184,
-0.0555472821,
0.0185580794,
-0.0310225245,
-0.012179683,
-0.019090727,
0.0470602699,
0.0432110019,
-0.0008206884,
0.0175014101,
0.0361717381,
-0.000988623,
-0.0041021272,
0.0293654688,
-0.0254054349,
0.0105749546,
0.0131453872,
0.0587437153,
0.0339045748,
-0.0629862845,
-0.0060097049,
-0.0317403674,
0.0072279046,
0.0139890527,
0.0215002224,
-0.0219873507,
0.0152380932,
-0.0219254717,
-0.0672338828,
0.0733739957,
-0.0001558065,
0.0088677611,
0.0678309426,
0.0659733713,
-0.0149757108,
0.0504559502,
-0.0461969264,
0.0265505575,
-0.0184801109,
0.0559455976,
0.0265273731,
0.0467678122,
-0.0307502877,
0.0259983335,
0.0586245917,
-0.0106741888,
0.0249355622,
0.0111737875,
0.0382485315,
-0.038523715,
0.0622288287,
0.0508571751,
0.0292568188,
-0.0061094519,
-0.0511419177,
-0.0095234225,
0.0555901304,
-0.0380596407,
-0.0007816199,
0.0162910428,
-0.0303210039,
-0.0248223227,
-0.0213633124,
-0.0814954117,
-0.0327115431,
-0.0017327798,
0.0387083925,
-0.0182722844,
-0.0147018302,
0.0038859623,
0.0799052119,
-0.0250976346,
0.0062976875,
-0.0304175317,
0.0242073443,
0.0696671084,
0.0076596765,
0.0624841526,
-0.0603269115,
-0.0352379493,
0.0219110791,
0.008631113,
0.0598755255,
-0.0110787386,
0.0479029305,
0.0309907123,
-0.0563585274,
-0.0025761502,
0.0008323949,
0.0211589094,
-0.0459722877,
0.0453909822,
0.0032865356,
-0.0053767045,
0.029935563,
0.0065217922,
0.0305163469,
0.0044927085,
-0.0165895093,
-0.0566556379,
-0.0422207564,
0.0487102829,
-0.0312034804,
-0.0140974615,
-0.0044787782,
0.0652199313,
0.0097106555,
-0.017721111,
0.0344206803,
0.0190164223,
2.197e-7,
0.031959042,
0.0084784105,
0.0071311137,
0.0093362629,
0.0165419802,
0.0132437525,
-0.0234467927,
-0.0014994575,
0.0024451779,
-0.0160933323,
-0.0550799072,
-0.0341119356,
0.0914444551,
0.024192201,
-0.0842666551,
-0.0089418553,
0.0176732969,
0.0357882828,
-0.0215436798,
0.0075396928,
0.0322716348,
0.1099314764,
-0.0100341858,
0.0155883124,
-0.0095632123,
-0.0296911057,
-0.0100848638,
-0.0021187791,
0.013788606,
0.0407305658,
-0.0058365059,
0.0172819421,
-0.0118000917,
0.0139385369,
-0.0168399345,
-0.0088974033,
0.0211705603,
0.0294554308,
-0.0058592241,
0.0295387618,
-0.0178878829,
-0.0095014824,
-0.0130573595,
-0.0252701379,
0.0484619699,
0.0435007252,
0.028960418,
-0.0088237859,
0.0029584633,
-0.0003031332,
-0.0266404692,
0.0004135121,
-0.0713908225,
0.0700171739,
0.0197734926,
-0.0157630257,
-0.0205598287,
-0.0719494671,
-0.0221203975,
0.0027396216,
-0.0110069094,
-0.0193674397,
0.0221430268,
-0.0271597113,
0.037321046,
-0.0541488938,
0.0367849693,
1.829610006e-34,
0.0012156981,
-0.0187397581,
-0.0328198932,
0.0448432602,
0.0276397765,
-0.019748807,
-0.0681959912,
0.0444257632,
-0.0259801894,
-0.0173126515,
0.0165227447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01495v1 | A Comparative Analysis of Conversational Large Language Models in Knowledge-Based Text Generation | 2024-02-02T15:26:39 | 2024-02-02T15:26:39 | Phillip Schneider, Manuel Klettner, Elena Simperl, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating natural language text from graph-structured data is essential for
conversational information seeking. Semantic triples derived from knowledge
graphs can serve as a valuable source for grounding responses from
conversational agents by providing a factual basis for the information they
communicate. This is especially relevant in the context of large language
models, which offer great potential for conversational interaction but are
prone to hallucinating, omitting, or producing conflicting information. In this
study, we conduct an empirical analysis of conversational large language models
in generating natural language text from semantic triples. We compare four
large language models of varying sizes with different prompting techniques.
Through a series of benchmark experiments on the WebNLG dataset, we analyze the
models' performance and identify the most common issues in the generated
predictions. Our findings show that the capabilities of large language models
in triple verbalization can be significantly improved through few-shot
prompting, post-processing, and efficient fine-tuning techniques, particularly
for smaller models that exhibit lower zero-shot performance. | A Comparative Analysis of Conversational Large Language Models in Knowledge-Based Text Generation: Generating natural language text from graph-structured data is essential for
conversational information seeking. Semantic triples derived from knowledge
graphs can serve as a valuable source for grounding responses from
conversational agents by providing a factual basis for the information they
communicate. This is especially relevant in the context of large language
models, which offer great potential for conversational interaction but are
prone to hallucinating, omitting, or producing conflicting information. In this
study, we conduct an empirical analysis of conversational large language models
in generating natural language text from semantic triples. We compare four
large language models of varying sizes with different prompting techniques.
Through a series of benchmark experiments on the WebNLG dataset, we analyze the
models' performance and identify the most common issues in the generated
predictions. Our findings show that the capabilities of large language models
in triple verbalization can be significantly improved through few-shot
prompting, post-processing, and efficient fine-tuning techniques, particularly
for smaller models that exhibit lower zero-shot performance. | [
0.0734867677,
-0.0008997399,
0.0142087406,
0.0380366817,
-0.0426537134,
-0.0089468807,
0.0216158442,
0.002067653,
0.0218633711,
-0.0953990668,
0.0023495746,
-0.0331753008,
0.0093864799,
0.0446684584,
0.0235607233,
-0.0297199599,
0.0175447371,
-0.0416963212,
0.0188564379,
-0.0008109068,
0.0181321129,
0.0262211841,
0.0069631403,
0.0369970649,
-0.0173395462,
0.0091873137,
-0.0283275153,
0.0219317302,
-0.0287727714,
-0.0416248813,
-0.020233443,
0.0433131456,
0.0191450194,
0.0213030484,
0.0000018022,
-0.0548605509,
-0.0032015459,
-0.0070036068,
-0.0009240163,
0.0004899651,
0.0328371152,
-0.013349032,
0.0200801287,
0.0136779463,
-0.0591129586,
-0.0100476472,
0.0284416378,
0.060334526,
0.0392330885,
0.071296826,
-0.0230835211,
-0.0186169371,
-0.0099667981,
-0.0111724911,
0.0428956412,
-0.021754887,
0.0287016537,
0.0707768202,
0.0283083972,
0.0085369181,
0.0182609595,
0.0167273469,
-0.0218126569,
-0.0356541052,
0.0404288098,
0.0421705768,
-0.0274892729,
-0.0384203009,
-0.0092214812,
0.1045573503,
0.0263925008,
0.0035596576,
0.0003135006,
-0.0044745458,
0.0190754067,
-0.0056832936,
-0.0505261458,
0.0632680431,
-0.0161935464,
-0.0135154398,
-0.0234506968,
-0.0055067521,
0.0278556123,
0.0081293555,
-0.0282677431,
0.0656920001,
0.0172522329,
-0.0101014106,
-0.0095500993,
-0.0088164052,
-0.025360018,
-0.0964880064,
-0.0103908889,
0.0347106494,
-0.0483066775,
0.0257227477,
-0.0600166135,
0.0179142486,
0.0127632106,
-0.0120861391,
0.016182797,
0.0313226767,
0.0255506262,
0.0286398996,
-0.0145340953,
0.0408406034,
-0.0019231706,
-0.0213940199,
-0.0290728472,
-0.003785758,
-0.0280097462,
-0.0141016701,
-0.0401496738,
0.0690106377,
-0.0528544821,
-0.0654518753,
-0.0315069556,
0.0457587652,
0.0159606785,
0.0395936705,
0.0257630944,
0.0265785363,
-0.0235764738,
-0.0014070442,
-0.0187225901,
0.0226055048,
-0.0223727375,
0.0112006152,
0.0503187366,
-0.0690049604,
0.0251832921,
0.0234315079,
0.0451702923,
-0.0099997669,
-0.0156795066,
0.0694947839,
-0.0056049735,
-0.0339629315,
-0.0184298903,
-0.0750777796,
-0.0313932933,
-0.0773611069,
-0.0038667228,
-0.0597140267,
0.0543712825,
0.0267155934,
-0.0262216628,
-0.0240348708,
0.0405645445,
0.0141414823,
-0.0480371416,
0.0392855145,
-0.0634771436,
0.0085108057,
-0.0041787266,
-0.0001425693,
-0.0128512783,
0.0479462557,
0.0467764884,
0.038760718,
0.0550126284,
0.0049240435,
-0.0282270256,
0.0236227997,
0.0027716982,
0.0146778487,
-0.0066934386,
0.0084135504,
-0.004952882,
0.0686796978,
0.0022612624,
0.0856417343,
-0.0513839722,
0.0369434468,
0.0793520957,
0.0266639031,
0.0076690707,
0.0139282569,
0.0873993635,
0.0307973735,
0.0008482224,
0.0045627775,
-0.0291533396,
0.0028684414,
-0.0312239118,
0.0519137792,
0.0285194479,
0.0311739091,
-0.0183316879,
-0.032723289,
0.0094750663,
-0.0040698233,
0.0330047123,
-0.0168451611,
0.0354135595,
0.0272504222,
-0.0735429004,
0.0125540802,
0.0459688418,
-0.0682509318,
0.0158303957,
-0.0288645551,
0.0333444811,
0.1040528938,
0.0481996536,
0.0456623733,
-0.0351888165,
0.0110445069,
0.0270224772,
0.0368821993,
0.0436468832,
-0.0123630287,
-0.0141438693,
-0.045134455,
-0.0101533029,
-0.0301885717,
-0.0084570795,
0.0293901004,
0.0201749112,
-0.0024192806,
0.0377023555,
-0.0134488055,
-0.00678638,
-0.0022161433,
-0.0412979424,
0.0287205745,
0.0072874753,
-0.0194572136,
-0.0166013725,
0.0271573961,
-0.0223782305,
0.0289096721,
0.0139367646,
-0.008964465,
-0.0212326441,
0.0215967111,
-0.0292868279,
-0.0655043349,
0.0244400203,
0.0136009175,
0.0274486858,
-0.0451463833,
-0.0102092233,
-0.0533964001,
0.0016436465,
-0.0285990108,
0.0593065284,
-0.0112911705,
0.0149528701,
0.0578960665,
-0.0092649013,
-0.0144234225,
0.0650709048,
0.0206857286,
0.0016104796,
0.0344879888,
0.0201800447,
-0.0137766795,
-0.0494725704,
0.0159375928,
0.045907937,
0.0045623211,
-0.0046194158,
0.0315983146,
0.0122386236,
-0.0456743874,
-0.0245929305,
-0.1166732833,
0.02048425,
-0.0033063928,
-0.0055194553,
0.0163915213,
0.0252918173,
0.0108159371,
0.0202748161,
-0.0839176103,
0.0373959951,
0.0326869823,
0.0197611284,
0.0299901813,
0.0244690888,
-0.0353978574,
-0.0189021546,
0.0016009574,
-0.0011404516,
0.0838099793,
0.0532104857,
-0.0395430773,
-0.0372027494,
0.0709016845,
-0.0902126357,
0.0164235309,
-0.0111185238,
-0.0134141194,
0.0086341687,
-0.0250033438,
0.0512689129,
0.0345663466,
0.0190977622,
0.0374174342,
0.0265512094,
-0.0320355147,
-0.0406018794,
-0.0092052864,
-0.037765678,
0.0003760218,
-0.0375024974,
-0.0249011628,
-0.0077714999,
0.0149712712,
0.0377607942,
0.0188467093,
-0.0562526695,
0.0308831222,
0.023419654,
-0.0262779612,
-0.0199786704,
-0.0101754209,
-0.0073197284,
0.0376855731,
-0.0180539936,
-0.0046731727,
0.0380291492,
-0.0601224825,
-0.0085671283,
0.0152915725,
0.0133323697,
-0.0368875526,
0.0465500988,
0.0043696957,
0.048715543,
-0.0229511857,
-0.0129566379,
-0.0274549611,
-0.0228072796,
0.0331113562,
-0.0311742928,
0.0138477562,
-0.0394041575,
0.0228122491,
0.0139742289,
-0.0367801227,
-0.0302812122,
-0.0234533735,
-0.042744305,
0.023867324,
0.0444953442,
-0.0478156321,
-0.0143366521,
0.0181227773,
0.0265304931,
0.0306798909,
-0.0290381107,
-0.0309761018,
-0.0512025915,
0.0503129251,
0.0626503527,
-0.0038578804,
0.0100919874,
-0.0235848725,
0.0576932319,
0.0564657263,
0.0066968105,
0.0165266357,
-0.0315427147,
-0.0127443401,
-0.0004648473,
-0.0193517487,
-0.0352593809,
0.0344479159,
0.0348461457,
-0.0305101182,
0.0011929685,
0.1303432882,
0.0161953606,
-0.0079296129,
0.0120920381,
0.0154176475,
0.0465222262,
0.0108496211,
0.0077778581,
-0.1047562584,
-0.0304827504,
0.0038077072,
0.0012495406,
-0.0035037224,
-0.0578091443,
-0.0346170999,
-0.1382638812,
0.0272799581,
0.013529636,
0.0086885104,
-0.0253723282,
-0.0086232061,
-0.0204482879,
0.0245432574,
-0.014365253,
-0.0022766546,
-0.0265994798,
0.0080554765,
0.0077337227,
-0.0069122403,
-0.0521981381,
0.0241195299,
-0.0184997525,
0.0396213681,
0.0320433863,
0.0307779144,
0.020969145,
0.0103160255,
0.0198186934,
0.0422857068,
0.008534682,
-0.0113729946,
0.0147018926,
-0.0236341599,
0.0042758817,
-0.0457287095,
0.0274951309,
-0.0066087078,
-0.0100698993,
-0.0052503599,
0.0044402573,
-0.0379959196,
-0.0279295351,
0.0160762649,
0.0541793033,
0.0237458535,
0.0769805685,
0.0386872031,
-0.0269472674,
-0.0403426699,
-0.017385859,
-0.0074723042,
-0.0542052537,
-0.0141664408,
0.0379590318,
0.0077559398,
-0.0091064163,
-0.0723682493,
-0.0532273464,
0.0391415842,
0.0338496193,
0.0081712427,
0.0032543181,
0.0365316086,
0.0012884906,
-0.0003509639,
0.0001167271,
-0.0284218211,
0.0086043598,
-0.033286605,
-0.0005440583,
0.02612889,
-0.0585051961,
-0.0051608151,
0.0010786082,
-0.0856921747,
-0.0863416195,
-0.0368596204,
0.0391225554,
0.0274832398,
0.0577683635,
0.0037868856,
-0.0327316411,
0.004352231,
0.0566020049,
-0.0368997864,
0.0324463323,
-0.0214087237,
0.0524630621,
0.0058233081,
0.0445318036,
-0.0450140946,
0.0070286402,
-0.0319891758,
0.062676765,
-0.0269150604,
-0.0562905073,
0.0167324636,
0.0681844056,
-0.0299058799,
-0.0092649115,
0.0227123182,
-0.0255883727,
-0.0057291295,
-0.074912563,
-0.0364008546,
-0.0865108669,
-0.0037707367,
-0.0005703989,
-0.0099402713,
0.0127339959,
-0.0252447687,
-0.0171032492,
0.0294404589,
-0.0174606834,
-0.0387879424,
-0.0252959803,
-0.0326835364,
0.0765150264,
-0.0402047746,
-0.051612705,
0.051225923,
-0.0144152846,
0.0053206054,
-0.0242857616,
0.0617026873,
0.0180729199,
-0.0516357459,
-0.026442552,
0.0197194982,
-0.036846526,
-0.043343652,
-0.0124176051,
0.0187415369,
0.0417932421,
0.0286964811,
0.0822015777,
-0.0561962053,
0.0106319366,
-0.0250221286,
0.0692312196,
0.0153690251,
-0.0696023777,
0.0530932322,
-0.009463313,
-0.0282415841,
-0.0011411788,
0.0841256231,
0.0467124172,
0.0356971286,
0.0327967033,
-0.0282551739,
-0.0472541973,
-0.0381454565,
0.0000425272,
0.0230217092,
-0.0007238798,
-0.0064295488,
-0.0687704086,
-0.046573285,
-0.0187975653,
-0.0121244518,
-0.0126381936,
-0.009052949,
0.0449954718,
0.0648261756,
0.0115229618,
-0.0134726148,
-0.055787582,
0.0081188101,
-0.0541577786,
-0.0028192201,
-0.0223795325,
-6.301916316e-33,
-0.0331346765,
-0.0689505264,
0.0407079756,
-0.0105218338,
-0.0485150069,
-0.0139183011,
-0.0505243987,
0.0107220039,
-0.0132000446,
0.0106003573,
-0.0050272522,
0.0012771328,
0.0080211833,
0.0405970514,
-0.0370762013,
-0.009527198,
0.0454919226,
-0.0127449855,
-0.0379642397,
0.0558121391,
0.0608424731,
0.0176845584,
0.0188776888,
-0.0490534492,
0.0254638847,
-0.0460806303,
-0.031890966,
0.0162778217,
0.0181762595,
0.0381170027,
-0.0174512807,
0.0414497815,
0.0138024734,
-0.0026399042,
-0.0146701075,
0.0174618084,
-0.0363222845,
-0.0114325499,
0.0423755124,
-0.0010515209,
-0.0477085747,
-0.0302541275,
0.008919918,
-0.0239448734,
0.0043818047,
-0.0177895688,
0.0145911062,
-0.017451765,
-0.0677155182,
-0.0592742823,
-0.0510202572,
0.0285753198,
-0.0028207854,
-0.024868777,
-0.0082081985,
0.0456028283,
0.0012205086,
-0.0068722242,
-0.0318471044,
0.0611172654,
0.0061391122,
0.0030006794,
0.0405838974,
0.0256290808,
0.0126941679,
0.0725568458,
0.0125501119,
0.0360578634,
-0.0320990048,
0.0015833963,
-0.0144006191,
0.0723120272,
-0.0200511236,
0.0631575063,
-0.0263457317,
0.0112307183,
-0.0649992824,
-0.0233961977,
-0.0194450822,
-0.0061212778,
0.0226414558,
-0.0471236631,
-0.041524142,
-0.0378091559,
-0.0539595298,
0.0047146613,
-0.0360660404,
-0.0382416919,
0.0332567431,
0.0089938417,
0.0047920342,
-0.0060320566,
0.0361607261,
-0.0336008966,
-0.026460804,
0.0660898685,
-0.0543573685,
0.02955167,
-0.033061076,
0.0106823985,
-0.0510893613,
-0.0424084067,
0.023426624,
0.0013718603,
-0.0094675785,
0.0526384562,
-0.0072016227,
0.0033274046,
-0.0473135784,
-0.0030949579,
-0.0412510931,
0.0077566053,
-0.0157371517,
-0.02275162,
0.0318274796,
0.0025177491,
-0.0398913771,
0.0647084042,
0.0073187989,
-0.0008547797,
-0.0016777328,
-0.0328748748,
0.018396413,
0.0246505421,
-0.0268320162,
0.0149770966,
-0.0501529314,
-0.0114466343,
0.0608380549,
-0.0228549968,
-0.0149234822,
-0.0078917304,
2.678e-7,
0.0066113616,
0.0606857799,
0.0046585859,
0.0413663834,
0.012502973,
0.0356215835,
0.028038606,
0.0214553028,
0.0192397088,
-0.0227347929,
0.0088904798,
0.0290494841,
0.0122424709,
0.0098495726,
-0.0721526071,
-0.0023333237,
-0.0809831172,
-0.0386804901,
-0.0623718202,
-0.0188120082,
0.0748387948,
0.0491956249,
0.0063120546,
0.0058137188,
-0.0066775554,
-0.0755846873,
0.0705565065,
-0.0209248457,
-0.0448748544,
0.0488101169,
0.057362061,
-0.0023095603,
-0.0165885203,
0.0340499803,
0.0059704776,
-0.0098296562,
0.0026638242,
0.0560113117,
0.0129628228,
0.0178324226,
0.0239412896,
-0.0274685901,
-0.0094298543,
-0.0333408788,
0.0654750839,
-0.0702401176,
-0.0161515996,
0.0174764674,
-0.0032075578,
-0.0327099152,
-0.0342680514,
-0.0504242517,
0.0015247681,
0.0153805064,
0.0049546189,
0.0135006867,
0.0078501189,
-0.0247151125,
-0.0122270202,
-0.0109825619,
-0.0318026431,
-0.0806317031,
-0.0348438099,
-0.0265002009,
0.0241549164,
-0.0569879077,
0.0030423542,
2.615286668e-34,
0.0502677895,
-0.0040923632,
0.00988991,
-0.0137716467,
0.0586608723,
0.0007053483,
0.0419459194,
0.0049024723,
0.0231058747,
-0.1208257526,
-0.0174738709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01469v1 | AMOR: A Recipe for Building Adaptable Modular Knowledge Agents Through Process Feedback | 2024-02-02T14:56:48 | 2024-02-02T14:56:48 | Jian Guan, Wei Wu, Zujie Wen, Peng Xu, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The notable success of large language models (LLMs) has sparked an upsurge in
building language agents to complete various complex tasks. We present AMOR, an
agent framework based on open-source LLMs, which reasons with external
knowledge bases and adapts to specific domains through human supervision to the
reasoning process. AMOR builds reasoning logic over a finite state machine
(FSM) that solves problems through autonomous executions and transitions over
disentangled modules. This allows humans to provide direct feedback to the
individual modules, and thus naturally forms process supervision. Based on this
reasoning and feedback framework, we develop AMOR through two-stage
fine-tuning: warm-up and adaptation. The former fine-tunes the LLM with
examples automatically constructed from various public datasets and enables
AMOR to generalize across different knowledge environments, while the latter
tailors AMOR to specific domains using process feedback. Extensive experiments
across multiple domains demonstrate the advantage of AMOR to strong baselines,
thanks to its FSM-based reasoning and process feedback mechanism. | AMOR: A Recipe for Building Adaptable Modular Knowledge Agents Through Process Feedback: The notable success of large language models (LLMs) has sparked an upsurge in
building language agents to complete various complex tasks. We present AMOR, an
agent framework based on open-source LLMs, which reasons with external
knowledge bases and adapts to specific domains through human supervision to the
reasoning process. AMOR builds reasoning logic over a finite state machine
(FSM) that solves problems through autonomous executions and transitions over
disentangled modules. This allows humans to provide direct feedback to the
individual modules, and thus naturally forms process supervision. Based on this
reasoning and feedback framework, we develop AMOR through two-stage
fine-tuning: warm-up and adaptation. The former fine-tunes the LLM with
examples automatically constructed from various public datasets and enables
AMOR to generalize across different knowledge environments, while the latter
tailors AMOR to specific domains using process feedback. Extensive experiments
across multiple domains demonstrate the advantage of AMOR to strong baselines,
thanks to its FSM-based reasoning and process feedback mechanism. | [
0.0343669727,
0.0537111349,
-0.0318286568,
0.0240010973,
-0.0384437889,
0.0153870182,
-0.0055585378,
-0.0238521043,
0.0494167693,
-0.0080211451,
0.0056683365,
0.0082424851,
-0.0172004458,
0.0557499677,
-0.0051937965,
-0.0446358919,
0.0442266539,
-0.0690019652,
0.0074227857,
-0.023165442,
-0.0109778158,
-0.0035034975,
-0.018350631,
0.008925315,
0.0198637303,
0.0218881927,
-0.0523302667,
-0.0189348031,
0.014809127,
-0.0113669634,
-0.0230859239,
0.0208025593,
0.0476916283,
0.0195765328,
0.0000021943,
-0.0545130074,
0.0201379601,
0.0018912401,
-0.0316426717,
-0.0498818457,
-0.0211938117,
-0.0107889604,
-0.0032247438,
0.0276725683,
-0.0479301363,
-0.0039049096,
0.0273446981,
0.0205247272,
0.0783654451,
0.0784484744,
-0.0050017955,
-0.0370986313,
0.0136059597,
-0.0011350939,
-0.0008227737,
-0.0331705809,
0.0350407586,
0.0158323273,
0.0482582189,
-0.0184716582,
-0.0299019851,
0.0089421859,
0.040303003,
-0.0254639015,
-0.0274116173,
0.03557574,
0.0043344353,
-0.043135222,
-0.0065777348,
0.0808674321,
0.048954647,
-0.0123918727,
0.0172421858,
0.0037939672,
-0.0057042209,
0.0133081479,
-0.0442045927,
0.0432237945,
0.0064802798,
0.0213322211,
0.0322107524,
-0.0232188459,
0.0129734017,
0.0335970595,
-0.0643759295,
0.1142170578,
0.0078951847,
-0.0188292135,
-0.0045800931,
0.0093296766,
0.0136692524,
-0.0629633442,
0.0047755544,
0.0802052394,
-0.0509413853,
0.04983031,
-0.0364124067,
-0.0261937752,
-0.0251051653,
-0.0424250551,
-0.0061592972,
0.0560786128,
0.0237291567,
0.0730663314,
-0.0364313573,
0.0407511108,
0.0006888642,
0.0549520217,
-0.014400376,
-0.0447732136,
-0.1152695939,
0.0233047791,
-0.0026785254,
0.0401571207,
-0.0114694564,
0.0026081924,
0.0000681732,
0.0785359517,
-0.0369922966,
0.0747460946,
-0.0056209532,
-0.0094798403,
-0.0063551953,
-0.0372945704,
-0.0918075442,
0.0607616305,
-0.0487729087,
0.0178766884,
0.011932889,
-0.0052850167,
-0.0031145676,
0.0139394859,
-0.0031830522,
-0.0013802424,
0.0184620637,
0.1006566882,
-0.0070379619,
-0.0090824133,
-0.0165879931,
-0.044502493,
0.0330881961,
-0.0779570714,
-0.0036561023,
-0.0414614975,
0.0598893799,
0.0122050606,
-0.0244246274,
-0.0451799929,
0.010779609,
-0.0087786652,
-0.0314881355,
0.0630446076,
-0.0361660346,
0.0207407828,
-0.0140548898,
0.0206778776,
0.0127574299,
0.0695097074,
0.0322373658,
0.0328627378,
0.0228309892,
0.0175092295,
0.0170880668,
0.0115609756,
0.0055067302,
0.031955108,
-0.0113417739,
0.039079383,
-0.0327770673,
0.0339023136,
-0.0001573546,
0.0265815482,
0.000077973,
0.0305070281,
0.053833548,
0.0240892116,
-0.0002099319,
0.0236965939,
0.0131049193,
0.034029074,
-0.0143852476,
-0.0423284285,
-0.0467250571,
0.0697140619,
-0.0248736329,
0.0204225853,
-0.0411700979,
0.0254184939,
-0.0454393774,
-0.0394161493,
0.0087028779,
-0.0011645068,
0.0408920683,
0.0438142456,
0.0805069208,
0.017672874,
-0.0518256202,
0.0211288258,
0.0293912906,
-0.030326765,
0.0113880662,
-0.0796913579,
0.0615074784,
0.1090017334,
0.0547795221,
-0.028940497,
-0.0365881845,
-0.0024123599,
-0.0094928779,
0.0645279139,
0.0042392449,
-0.0139595252,
0.0041088141,
-0.0328815393,
-0.0470803566,
0.0029241401,
-0.0117404796,
0.0265944414,
0.0219375808,
-0.0063430839,
-0.0242467579,
0.0044296985,
0.0121546844,
0.0315818675,
-0.0462037139,
0.0124787306,
-0.0126839047,
0.0067993784,
0.0414299071,
0.0149375228,
0.0120125515,
-0.0055163219,
0.0401328132,
-0.0137112252,
-0.049869258,
0.0262361113,
0.0096864831,
-0.0161417462,
0.0303992666,
-0.0161481798,
0.0002745614,
-0.031078659,
-0.0537934266,
-0.0684076026,
0.0851314887,
-0.0077105779,
0.0302215926,
-0.0134948725,
-0.0113170044,
-0.0204604827,
-0.0060849548,
-0.0164212938,
0.0405235998,
0.0094553418,
-0.0502691492,
0.0100545436,
-0.0067017358,
0.0019970832,
0.0252155866,
0.0062784352,
0.0442670435,
0.0180275403,
0.0231005233,
0.0272178762,
0.0055370289,
-0.0422693603,
-0.057973478,
-0.0941186398,
-0.0187258162,
0.004738817,
-0.0062468648,
0.0166230649,
0.0054583238,
0.0030160961,
-0.0067652413,
0.005010549,
0.0274103973,
0.0158478096,
0.0195934456,
0.0224177651,
0.0256547723,
-0.0652204901,
-0.0291829538,
0.0051601394,
-0.0081630787,
-0.0084705902,
-0.0061920858,
0.0232281517,
-0.0942768902,
0.0136961956,
-0.0533211082,
0.0537191965,
-0.0161104687,
-0.0274885427,
0.0353514589,
-0.0311650299,
0.0106015084,
0.0494394638,
-0.0269904491,
0.0268119462,
0.0874772519,
-0.0329535939,
-0.0397569463,
0.0371008664,
-0.0386347622,
0.010885166,
-0.0561687164,
0.0021593133,
-0.000814632,
0.0775797591,
-0.0056917034,
0.0043062409,
-0.0719652101,
-0.0083764819,
0.01618471,
-0.0092863915,
-0.0009857243,
-0.0251941979,
-0.0013095295,
0.0488957837,
-0.0041004135,
-0.0082120514,
0.1096252725,
-0.0055952538,
-0.0117757972,
-0.0066058356,
-0.026111152,
-0.0346399806,
0.0934925973,
-0.0074819336,
-0.0164466221,
-0.0228830855,
0.0112343188,
-0.0463479795,
-0.03291291,
0.0460543893,
-0.004333633,
0.0420176014,
-0.0943553671,
0.0110828774,
0.0182050541,
0.0001919069,
-0.043988362,
0.0234727412,
-0.0605608784,
0.0240229238,
-0.0355465375,
-0.0298226383,
-0.0459932797,
-0.0099738576,
0.048823677,
0.0092371516,
0.0022361851,
-0.0081615262,
-0.0607221685,
-0.0559244752,
0.0239386056,
0.0236903504,
-0.0141085144,
-0.0594403483,
0.0699380189,
0.0157662407,
0.0193514563,
-0.0506798178,
-0.0373660959,
-0.0038337787,
0.0224879086,
-0.0221047718,
0.018047696,
0.0150020085,
0.0522301085,
-0.0669497401,
-0.0088872872,
0.119109273,
-0.0045468649,
-0.0244465601,
-0.0038715864,
-0.0213737004,
0.0229570121,
0.0434014499,
0.0685057715,
-0.0765493736,
-0.0262310263,
0.0200390555,
0.0135013964,
0.0128010781,
-0.0469511412,
0.0033164958,
-0.0912004337,
0.0304301865,
0.0042731422,
-0.0114008328,
-0.0643033162,
-0.0398083702,
0.0271705687,
-0.0041312496,
-0.0193715915,
0.0241743773,
0.0172291696,
-0.0193206295,
-0.0221975036,
0.0219145603,
-0.0390772372,
0.0307347178,
-0.0178340506,
0.0627412051,
0.0524390675,
0.0038353223,
0.0033960233,
-0.0611093119,
-0.0053416481,
-0.0200249702,
0.0004719243,
-0.0122250477,
-0.0059449696,
0.0197421126,
-0.0133798718,
-0.0256845094,
0.0275089256,
-0.0464646593,
-0.0294475984,
0.0147417868,
0.1137044057,
-0.0447422341,
-0.0383262634,
-0.0277955886,
-0.0266158171,
-0.0055410592,
0.0606765635,
-0.0159817748,
-0.0429948717,
-0.0397917815,
-0.016103534,
-0.0534790903,
-0.019027587,
-0.0174970031,
-0.0032463744,
-0.0342441164,
0.0042466903,
-0.0456630439,
-0.0082779052,
0.0698209628,
0.015139835,
0.0404182561,
-0.0199001543,
0.0598922595,
0.0153288255,
-0.01200746,
0.0020484091,
-0.0400757752,
0.0330781788,
-0.0209588166,
-0.0372723527,
-0.0013104404,
-0.0399258845,
0.0057147811,
-0.0065833516,
-0.0480328649,
-0.0651854649,
0.0023589968,
0.0452119187,
0.0274976306,
0.0563838296,
-0.025354879,
-0.0359635465,
0.0332813561,
-0.0249158032,
-0.063792944,
-0.022732025,
0.0190262124,
0.0167354643,
0.0036053478,
0.0413125493,
-0.0584111363,
0.0020234727,
-0.0076069408,
0.0302012097,
-0.0295247845,
-0.0176978018,
0.0142068285,
-0.004648827,
-0.0143757975,
-0.0137037635,
-0.0310814269,
-0.0372918472,
0.0252837054,
-0.0152278431,
-0.0029521117,
-0.0540584102,
0.0087704612,
-0.0114261396,
-0.0323366262,
0.0607762821,
-0.0050277445,
-0.0039458806,
0.0119526982,
0.0483708382,
0.0018542439,
-0.0356878564,
0.0544989854,
0.0233699605,
0.0263465401,
0.0001704248,
0.0422677025,
-0.0011937616,
0.0487171523,
-0.0269520022,
0.0619119368,
0.035895016,
-0.0023958741,
-0.0403014645,
0.0089995684,
-0.063190788,
-0.0688281655,
0.0277676787,
0.0469178818,
0.0510132909,
0.0447239056,
0.0397232622,
-0.0771518275,
0.022208767,
0.0326490402,
0.0747734532,
-0.0143055376,
-0.0330561176,
0.0026571029,
0.0405213386,
0.0118905464,
-0.0154682556,
0.0479043089,
-0.0112751843,
0.0402891897,
-0.0181129649,
-0.0011710782,
-0.0479831956,
-0.0436667763,
-0.012620097,
0.0129249617,
-0.0332298018,
0.0291671399,
-0.0503493287,
-0.0327344313,
-0.0728484541,
0.0102901356,
-0.0375834629,
-0.0170152988,
0.0476411991,
0.0082571972,
0.0189674105,
-0.0234910473,
-0.0288249236,
0.0047075879,
0.0042593568,
-0.0159773026,
0.003860147,
-6.364664939e-33,
-0.0566498898,
0.0021670377,
0.062699236,
0.0107960384,
-0.036201857,
-0.0623247996,
-0.0798095837,
0.0025084924,
-0.0004444595,
0.0198615603,
-0.0051092114,
0.0073028905,
0.001862802,
0.0068317195,
0.0323018469,
-0.0154835414,
0.0400915593,
-0.0026317504,
-0.0074611749,
0.0228925012,
0.0425085016,
-0.0074817897,
0.045978073,
-0.0593466163,
0.0193590205,
0.0136310393,
-0.0129579669,
0.0459944941,
-0.035577558,
0.0275778323,
0.0151848532,
0.0149290757,
0.0096564097,
0.0048800204,
-0.0179140642,
-0.0241876394,
-0.0572078452,
-0.0285554919,
0.0344940349,
0.0169525351,
-0.049784001,
-0.0191940255,
0.032955993,
-0.0156870428,
0.0187543985,
0.0177452974,
0.0422117375,
-0.0336532295,
-0.0018028114,
0.0221922379,
-0.0449865237,
-0.0021361921,
-0.0116693331,
-0.0247234795,
0.014722297,
0.0226032939,
0.0061482526,
-0.0527344011,
-0.025449181,
0.0365722701,
0.029047925,
-0.0053266785,
0.0636764541,
0.0084827011,
0.026305316,
0.0276431944,
0.0124933291,
0.0300163832,
-0.0407546721,
0.0100522321,
0.0248763692,
0.0813100338,
0.0395779274,
0.0094519239,
-0.0171333533,
0.0001820154,
-0.0550907627,
-0.0126870908,
0.0124524459,
0.1074174866,
0.0247688461,
0.0372653902,
-0.0149465147,
-0.0324185081,
-0.0516678281,
0.0197134633,
-0.0122589217,
-0.0380620956,
0.0067000124,
0.0217319634,
-0.0088199563,
-0.0765348375,
0.0154937236,
-0.0518810079,
0.0018596611,
0.0041403235,
-0.0220261924,
0.0187159628,
0.0099170525,
-0.0021686689,
-0.0523755997,
-0.0421307944,
0.014785829,
-0.0487034954,
0.0041812938,
0.0355754569,
-0.0321838669,
0.0540770777,
-0.0229790863,
-0.0098172147,
-0.0810001418,
0.0287486389,
-0.0010712545,
0.0040341388,
-0.0233133845,
0.0340677686,
-0.0292214639,
0.0295073986,
-0.0394843705,
-0.018448472,
-0.0134241544,
0.0305697899,
0.0216747671,
0.0336809047,
-0.0374395698,
-0.0394502729,
-0.0734223574,
-0.0218281262,
0.0284354519,
-0.0454192907,
-0.0036394198,
0.0090238713,
3.035e-7,
-0.0246350486,
0.0487336144,
-0.0112316115,
0.035136342,
0.0437222533,
0.049154412,
-0.056670256,
0.0011883893,
-0.0266472585,
-0.0278075207,
0.0123531371,
0.0524003953,
0.0358252302,
0.0327132493,
-0.0594543703,
-0.0108827353,
0.0287424065,
-0.0241613872,
-0.0502955541,
-0.0097086625,
0.0274534505,
0.0455800891,
0.0805343464,
-0.0014491447,
0.0306565519,
-0.0371389464,
0.0416223891,
-0.019266054,
0.0009204535,
0.0108897807,
-0.0094963387,
0.0360709317,
0.0052666715,
0.0375364907,
0.0299455822,
0.0163628738,
-0.0896594077,
0.0631481111,
0.0102361068,
-0.0143870236,
-0.0249257796,
-0.0230886564,
0.0079838112,
-0.0209083315,
0.0554025397,
-0.061410334,
-0.0328309275,
0.0096049206,
0.0079592057,
-0.0199630149,
-0.0661018789,
0.0048211319,
-0.0119166877,
-0.0116130188,
0.007156522,
-0.0236941446,
-0.0179928485,
-0.0490820818,
0.0038794307,
-0.0217215121,
-0.050743904,
-0.0393020362,
-0.0189411901,
-0.0155134248,
-0.0026279476,
-0.0348762907,
0.0146943014,
2.945018343e-34,
0.0275996458,
0.0132573629,
-0.0219461136,
0.0373680517,
0.0475635268,
-0.0124240341,
-0.0542208739,
0.013989538,
0.0537765399,
-0.0722673759,
-0.032203868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01453v1 | The Queen of England is not England's Queen: On the Lack of Factual Coherency in PLMs | 2024-02-02T14:42:09 | 2024-02-02T14:42:09 | Paul Youssef, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Factual knowledge encoded in Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) enriches
their representations and justifies their use as knowledge bases. Previous work
has focused on probing PLMs for factual knowledge by measuring how often they
can correctly predict an object entity given a subject and a relation, and
improving fact retrieval by optimizing the prompts used for querying PLMs. In
this work, we consider a complementary aspect, namely the coherency of factual
knowledge in PLMs, i.e., how often can PLMs predict the subject entity given
its initial prediction of the object entity. This goes beyond evaluating how
much PLMs know, and focuses on the internal state of knowledge inside them. Our
results indicate that PLMs have low coherency using manually written, optimized
and paraphrased prompts, but including an evidence paragraph leads to
substantial improvement. This shows that PLMs fail to model inverse relations
and need further enhancements to be able to handle retrieving facts from their
parameters in a coherent manner, and to be considered as knowledge bases. | The Queen of England is not England's Queen: On the Lack of Factual Coherency in PLMs: Factual knowledge encoded in Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) enriches
their representations and justifies their use as knowledge bases. Previous work
has focused on probing PLMs for factual knowledge by measuring how often they
can correctly predict an object entity given a subject and a relation, and
improving fact retrieval by optimizing the prompts used for querying PLMs. In
this work, we consider a complementary aspect, namely the coherency of factual
knowledge in PLMs, i.e., how often can PLMs predict the subject entity given
its initial prediction of the object entity. This goes beyond evaluating how
much PLMs know, and focuses on the internal state of knowledge inside them. Our
results indicate that PLMs have low coherency using manually written, optimized
and paraphrased prompts, but including an evidence paragraph leads to
substantial improvement. This shows that PLMs fail to model inverse relations
and need further enhancements to be able to handle retrieving facts from their
parameters in a coherent manner, and to be considered as knowledge bases. | [
0.0620701388,
-0.0028472876,
-0.0126864137,
0.0431064591,
-0.0483566038,
-0.0224329904,
-0.0258694887,
-0.0127832871,
-0.0012850598,
-0.0451853611,
-0.0151610738,
-0.0352880806,
-0.0089440355,
-0.0034039083,
0.0079634972,
-0.0479517691,
0.0875640586,
-0.019096829,
0.051662907,
-0.0086413492,
-0.0173486061,
-0.0004494639,
-0.014686049,
0.0126142995,
-0.0501746647,
-0.0175223406,
-0.0222275537,
-0.0039287154,
-0.012076213,
-0.0136435973,
-0.0164304301,
0.0385299474,
0.0187027864,
-0.0184552539,
0.0000020084,
-0.0678887069,
0.0166145954,
-0.036483936,
-0.0589872114,
0.0231477879,
-0.0005788745,
0.0117031075,
0.0255917925,
-0.0021910989,
-0.0362644643,
-0.0223556198,
0.005935817,
0.0662366897,
0.059478201,
0.0924401358,
0.0036426377,
0.0033013572,
-0.0009524035,
-0.0290602557,
-0.0091058332,
-0.0437103845,
0.019279968,
0.0074816602,
-0.0150990142,
0.0582446754,
-0.0022135461,
0.0621851124,
0.0019595046,
-0.0072660968,
-0.0075840289,
0.046378769,
-0.0168475285,
-0.0438438877,
0.0031522152,
0.0444670692,
0.0164867248,
-0.0043503819,
0.0022022843,
-0.0057900823,
0.018749088,
0.0341935605,
-0.0037342601,
0.0371524394,
-0.0143448813,
0.0266358536,
0.013738215,
0.0011074477,
0.0314858109,
0.0272408947,
-0.0360521786,
0.061636135,
-0.0032783411,
-0.0333233587,
0.00632125,
0.0192453302,
-0.0141574359,
-0.0461573005,
0.0096198432,
0.024412578,
-0.0132096075,
0.0321187563,
-0.04373594,
0.0125198662,
0.0182807352,
-0.0817516744,
0.0120784305,
0.0295082163,
-0.0820619166,
0.0683569089,
-0.0228193216,
0.0456487983,
0.0123033132,
0.046797283,
-0.0147667527,
-0.0206148885,
-0.0405812785,
-0.0121739497,
-0.0375886075,
0.0433323458,
0.0014682293,
-0.0118184257,
0.0151238488,
-0.0070003448,
0.0122644799,
0.0264161676,
-0.022404192,
0.020298982,
-0.0064764032,
-0.0190145653,
-0.0883413479,
0.0407663696,
-0.0119562503,
0.0043825652,
-0.0269219168,
-0.0702391863,
-0.0305599514,
-0.0087692123,
-0.0075818552,
-0.0091103958,
0.0112922424,
0.0082425699,
-0.0058786538,
-0.0566419959,
-0.0740859434,
-0.0414265506,
-0.0085031185,
-0.0942963362,
-0.0133479815,
-0.0211892296,
0.0253419131,
-0.0041831513,
-0.008661964,
-0.0433914959,
0.0253382139,
0.0428083353,
-0.0562113449,
0.0359183513,
-0.0277863108,
0.0363913216,
0.0224721376,
0.0300125238,
0.0114130145,
0.0682951957,
0.0062395763,
0.0144556696,
0.0440508574,
0.0114362258,
-0.0037903285,
-0.0023209266,
0.0474893041,
-0.0505823754,
0.0156565495,
0.0279027075,
-0.024607433,
0.0419368334,
0.0597624816,
0.0366954356,
0.0158713721,
-0.0279761646,
0.0843573809,
-0.0031013065,
0.007002343,
0.0113107124,
0.0781200528,
-0.0040638992,
0.0526371486,
0.0599099025,
-0.0874040499,
-0.0132717388,
-0.0207727849,
0.0432514325,
-0.0192589201,
0.0484644733,
-0.0371618681,
-0.0474234745,
-0.0076040849,
-0.0081188334,
-0.0590459406,
0.029836094,
0.0521133691,
0.0077156769,
-0.0470114276,
0.0685906038,
0.0250071231,
-0.0511258915,
0.0213500205,
-0.0118193673,
0.0393491536,
0.072206296,
0.0198750589,
-0.0409642942,
-0.0369950347,
0.0213807449,
0.0337416716,
0.0296830982,
0.0544349849,
0.0025072664,
0.0550184362,
0.0044309078,
0.0108549213,
-0.0093950406,
0.0308476202,
-0.0026532034,
0.0059180376,
-0.0010014855,
0.0343686454,
-0.0052282657,
0.0129459836,
0.0521483161,
-0.0304189194,
0.0063968198,
-0.0125561003,
0.0024916646,
-0.0001830477,
0.0448294394,
-0.0103936261,
0.0276599806,
0.070475325,
-0.0055602523,
0.0009366275,
0.0156420432,
-0.0570225976,
-0.0523734391,
0.0216736495,
-0.0201414619,
-0.0266273823,
-0.0135912644,
0.0011437691,
-0.0291848723,
0.0107961856,
-0.0062444145,
0.0750821009,
-0.0460923277,
0.0283917673,
-0.0031827099,
-0.0394642688,
-0.0226663761,
0.0783789381,
0.0012365212,
-0.0002745428,
0.0415286832,
-0.003373655,
-0.0026944347,
-0.0359316655,
-0.0300701335,
-0.0001521181,
0.0334248766,
-0.0149896489,
0.0177844875,
-0.0391813666,
-0.0396972373,
-0.0058000442,
-0.0953892693,
-0.0032611093,
-0.0177478306,
-0.0236646309,
0.007295317,
-0.026019711,
-0.0299460404,
-0.0355453901,
-0.0037492118,
-0.0126990881,
-0.0072483616,
0.0151082315,
0.0349927619,
0.0176435597,
0.0106657017,
-0.0356087275,
0.017291341,
-0.0096242521,
0.0256957654,
-0.0026307278,
0.0123057086,
-0.0465145186,
0.0816093683,
-0.0453475043,
-0.0068084449,
-0.030617075,
-0.0046851039,
-0.0019865828,
-0.0099886646,
0.0546905585,
0.0448880196,
0.0432947353,
0.0144116627,
0.0597783998,
-0.0371848047,
-0.0326578841,
0.0299439244,
-0.0525085479,
0.0053754691,
-0.0017815107,
-0.0002095851,
0.0196626876,
0.0165402126,
0.0256534107,
-0.018728707,
-0.0522451177,
0.0209371317,
-0.0004119901,
-0.0263103377,
-0.063312985,
-0.0289738048,
0.0119625609,
0.0548439175,
-0.021388853,
-0.0511842668,
0.0709903017,
-0.0638492033,
0.0180870127,
0.0018549666,
-0.0138722248,
-0.004014255,
0.0512728952,
0.0071595712,
0.0258633271,
-0.002651047,
-0.0135686044,
-0.0374649726,
-0.0062535657,
0.0189357996,
-0.03252884,
0.0477897935,
-0.0507085249,
0.0108519951,
0.0424562767,
-0.0382079817,
-0.0722730681,
-0.094300665,
-0.0301946159,
-0.0066436213,
-0.0283174589,
0.0128881857,
-0.0182340275,
0.0039402777,
0.0358149521,
0.0209772009,
-0.0031257614,
-0.0157999545,
-0.003162235,
-0.033383023,
0.0385070741,
0.0490815528,
0.0096567506,
-0.0171182882,
-0.0038990672,
0.0065116868,
-0.0294702202,
-0.0276218727,
0.0199370869,
-0.0013036472,
0.002948089,
-0.0428817123,
-0.0617118217,
0.0169392526,
0.0010035438,
-0.0652290508,
-0.0328360349,
0.148397103,
0.024006851,
0.0114221079,
-0.0283281207,
-0.0003729769,
-0.0005685084,
0.0210982598,
0.0111461263,
-0.0638671815,
-0.0128474189,
0.0073522725,
-0.0331033021,
-0.0101575172,
-0.0337364674,
-0.0622118227,
-0.1339486241,
0.016251687,
-0.0359249599,
0.0065210061,
-0.0627393201,
-0.0247639567,
-0.0133072529,
-0.0039679841,
0.0099670105,
0.0364462808,
-0.0280802473,
0.0179837346,
-0.0023987265,
-0.0376808904,
-0.0516056195,
-0.0084460676,
-0.0594125874,
0.0495157167,
0.0658477396,
0.0156073691,
-0.0000460408,
-0.0403805189,
-0.0270674527,
-0.0005692911,
0.0198480953,
-0.0031572159,
0.0646825433,
-0.029481044,
-0.0064732837,
-0.0236096755,
-0.0111374501,
0.0383796841,
-0.023881413,
0.0224066004,
0.032614328,
-0.04762052,
-0.0241720751,
0.006368245,
0.0472811535,
0.0116828838,
0.1421079934,
0.0383590497,
0.024203198,
-0.0045253607,
0.001554244,
0.0560786761,
0.0181297585,
-0.0429210514,
0.0178203173,
-0.0101840207,
0.0232743323,
-0.0678554624,
-0.0393010825,
0.0332473665,
0.0597327985,
0.0226568282,
0.0068546315,
0.0666297004,
-0.0225750413,
-0.0161788259,
0.0173341185,
-0.0351694077,
-0.034730494,
-0.0805954933,
-0.0093891453,
0.0343825258,
-0.0477119498,
-0.0064508212,
-0.0248019863,
-0.0193569679,
-0.0580618903,
0.0652275831,
0.0604590066,
0.0283175409,
0.0258412901,
-0.0199865121,
-0.0237844754,
0.035276778,
-0.0080331704,
-0.0683417693,
0.0469472855,
-0.0018998045,
-0.02013712,
-0.0152742798,
0.0467905924,
-0.0122754639,
0.0169989932,
-0.0188861974,
0.0246550962,
0.0069066244,
-0.0725751743,
0.0331010856,
0.0183186438,
0.0929179788,
-0.0013796737,
0.0118427044,
-0.0550975613,
0.0063774129,
-0.0522738621,
-0.0204201676,
-0.0174959246,
0.0117433723,
-0.0123194167,
-0.0031959976,
-0.0315442793,
-0.0246317834,
-0.0598004796,
0.0438491739,
0.0055747642,
-0.0473274216,
0.0137947677,
-0.0008186228,
0.0091980593,
-0.0195186175,
0.0062529566,
0.0463118516,
-0.017914217,
0.0371812992,
0.0021843661,
0.0475258827,
0.018329259,
-0.0105113098,
-0.0215195529,
-0.0009706799,
-0.0852387771,
-0.0234026834,
0.0194237828,
0.0447678901,
0.0620597452,
-0.0794691369,
0.0424846411,
-0.0326777957,
0.0086198682,
-0.0015702089,
0.0252118502,
0.0580187179,
-0.0318538658,
0.0408322923,
0.0064847227,
-0.0336735845,
0.0271723475,
0.096021533,
-0.0137325199,
0.0675609633,
0.0097350832,
-0.0419819392,
-0.0221376196,
-0.0321367532,
0.0018659187,
0.0016561245,
-0.0529052652,
0.016635634,
-0.0932394862,
-0.0411943644,
0.0333452187,
0.0024903892,
-0.015551107,
-0.0271421671,
0.02476044,
0.0899254456,
0.0284732506,
-0.0273297932,
-0.0340263769,
0.0305181965,
0.0081582135,
0.0063123265,
-0.0275040604,
-6.876364976e-33,
-0.0884204432,
-0.0124554504,
0.0334408395,
-0.0000785268,
-0.018804457,
0.0298188869,
-0.0374505296,
0.0256220121,
-0.0468916148,
0.0359967947,
-0.0179496985,
0.0335940644,
0.0167169813,
0.0019125614,
-0.0161117781,
-0.0417222939,
0.0429259203,
0.0233578365,
-0.0188485682,
-0.0162664019,
0.0600626916,
0.0507215373,
0.0422160849,
-0.0397756845,
0.0392386392,
-0.0023385512,
-0.0029512956,
0.0519869998,
-0.0140675642,
0.008954566,
0.0020966106,
0.0480242185,
0.0133939944,
-0.0372692496,
-0.0216814261,
0.0331976041,
-0.0897993073,
-0.0708735436,
0.0948225185,
-0.0199159123,
0.0146512371,
-0.0103826215,
0.0225966182,
-0.0104924198,
0.0144680347,
0.0152249867,
0.0371626504,
0.0022041649,
0.0210582018,
-0.006558849,
-0.0601604916,
0.0181839745,
-0.0039857891,
-0.006892391,
0.0150748463,
-0.0150042931,
0.0180733725,
-0.0190739464,
-0.0702356324,
0.0194523092,
-0.0006511887,
0.0464376211,
0.0291664023,
-0.0030889297,
0.0041582361,
0.0707893819,
-0.0058200536,
0.0159591008,
-0.0882801414,
0.0462373868,
0.0570556521,
0.0315591916,
0.025564976,
0.0649522692,
0.0111106448,
-0.0000253743,
-0.0682590306,
0.000838156,
-0.011013763,
0.0276216194,
0.004658706,
-0.032803677,
-0.0270176996,
-0.0417340659,
-0.0453038476,
0.0296113361,
-0.0192604791,
-0.0380125083,
0.0114223212,
0.0128662875,
0.0087586204,
-0.0193705279,
0.0160847027,
0.0174416583,
-0.0244608261,
0.0027781466,
-0.0226614475,
-0.0311509203,
-0.0052801953,
0.0438279584,
-0.069883883,
-0.0052202181,
0.0255147405,
0.014690442,
-0.0147550916,
0.0261812303,
0.0071015679,
0.0106901666,
-0.0463150367,
-0.0142341433,
-0.0128371781,
0.0145499203,
-0.0262090564,
-0.0463145971,
0.0314250402,
0.0423359126,
-0.0322791263,
0.0105017535,
0.0142249474,
-0.0040278551,
-0.0451350138,
-0.0198174678,
0.0084612118,
0.0246120207,
0.0094358064,
0.004711749,
-0.021158617,
-0.0007236484,
0.0202875435,
-0.0463087,
0.0013354575,
0.0217907038,
2.741e-7,
0.0586167499,
0.0448687077,
0.0316355862,
0.0256277695,
-0.0566962138,
0.0238930546,
-0.0422154106,
0.0042546066,
0.0230230317,
-0.0770638734,
-0.0019315217,
0.0516912676,
0.0069097909,
0.037525028,
-0.1089382768,
-0.0033625336,
-0.0577319972,
-0.0380677022,
-0.0539355949,
-0.0188279636,
0.0392749831,
0.0565259494,
0.0348705873,
-0.0131803378,
-0.0137660373,
-0.0197582375,
0.0439957976,
-0.0442707501,
-0.0459523723,
0.0076911221,
0.0834180564,
0.0099661713,
0.0067713084,
0.0433265083,
0.0034658227,
0.0286527593,
-0.0080546727,
0.0457788371,
0.0380846187,
0.0089545026,
-0.0258865897,
0.0007518397,
-0.0110063711,
-0.0227615163,
0.0804390907,
-0.0211221911,
-0.0156983268,
-0.0116865393,
-0.004598781,
0.0050225384,
0.0387956649,
0.0086892098,
-0.0379593782,
0.020939501,
0.018182056,
-0.0042928434,
0.0077026682,
-0.0693596527,
-0.0548289418,
0.0079798298,
-0.0275088418,
-0.0249589253,
-0.0146248806,
-0.014497349,
0.0347344466,
-0.0665552542,
0.0311743356,
2.364924738e-34,
0.0262120962,
-0.0033376112,
-0.0017572824,
0.0193513855,
0.0526522361,
0.006671268,
0.0050285347,
0.0050302399,
-0.012995895,
-0.0658827499,
0.0157296285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01427v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01427v2 | The effect of diversity on group decision-making | 2024-02-02T14:15:01 | 2024-05-20T15:46:42 | Georgi Karadzhov, Andreas Vlachos, Tom Stafford | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore different aspects of cognitive diversity and its effect on the
success of group deliberation. To evaluate this, we use 500 dialogues from
small, online groups discussing the Wason Card Selection task - the DeliData
corpus. Leveraging the corpus, we perform quantitative analysis evaluating
three different measures of cognitive diversity. First, we analyse the effect
of group size as a proxy measure for diversity. Second, we evaluate the effect
of the size of the initial idea pool. Finally, we look into the content of the
discussion by analysing discussed solutions, discussion patterns, and how
conversational probing can improve those characteristics. Despite the
reputation of groups for compounding bias, we show that small groups can,
through dialogue, overcome intuitive biases and improve individual
decision-making. Across a large sample and different operationalisations, we
consistently find that greater cognitive diversity is associated with more
successful group deliberation. Code and data used for the analysis are
available in the repository:
https://github.com/gkaradzhov/cognitive-diversity-groups-cogsci24. | The effect of diversity on group decision-making: We explore different aspects of cognitive diversity and its effect on the
success of group deliberation. To evaluate this, we use 500 dialogues from
small, online groups discussing the Wason Card Selection task - the DeliData
corpus. Leveraging the corpus, we perform quantitative analysis evaluating
three different measures of cognitive diversity. First, we analyse the effect
of group size as a proxy measure for diversity. Second, we evaluate the effect
of the size of the initial idea pool. Finally, we look into the content of the
discussion by analysing discussed solutions, discussion patterns, and how
conversational probing can improve those characteristics. Despite the
reputation of groups for compounding bias, we show that small groups can,
through dialogue, overcome intuitive biases and improve individual
decision-making. Across a large sample and different operationalisations, we
consistently find that greater cognitive diversity is associated with more
successful group deliberation. Code and data used for the analysis are
available in the repository:
https://github.com/gkaradzhov/cognitive-diversity-groups-cogsci24. | [
0.033924412,
0.04027538,
-0.0376387872,
-0.0188319813,
-0.051284112,
-0.0001997594,
0.0596818291,
-0.0153454281,
0.0025535468,
-0.0111411698,
-0.029328052,
-0.0280154385,
0.0472488441,
0.0022590938,
0.0091813691,
-0.0264288858,
0.0116187483,
-0.016253097,
0.0828635395,
-0.0344617628,
0.0189607609,
-0.0248415042,
-0.0414043441,
0.0554569326,
0.0241807196,
-0.012314165,
-0.0339734517,
-0.0333536454,
0.0534229949,
-0.0056226435,
0.0069260797,
0.069864504,
-0.0196904801,
0.0090580704,
0.0000022704,
-0.0157899447,
-0.024753537,
-0.0336196274,
0.0161810033,
-0.019808352,
0.002186887,
0.0937462375,
-0.0061623338,
0.0277823508,
-0.0318320058,
0.0275002085,
0.0163362902,
0.0051261531,
0.0046100393,
-0.0075371661,
0.0074587031,
0.0028824359,
-0.0655368343,
-0.0097438339,
-0.003731577,
0.0134742875,
-0.0097584464,
-0.0018932511,
0.0016283391,
-0.000048572,
0.0103115607,
-0.0306271836,
-0.0424703173,
-0.0254554562,
-0.0115849106,
0.0250927191,
-0.0363077521,
-0.0472600758,
0.025078835,
0.0460876264,
0.0566013195,
0.0475358889,
-0.0112797255,
-0.0128894532,
0.0522902496,
0.0242136009,
-0.0313429534,
0.0457565635,
-0.0258137062,
-0.0316830836,
-0.0250833388,
0.053803999,
-0.0276080519,
0.0104347216,
-0.0041190162,
0.0643422976,
-0.0205566417,
0.0131075969,
-0.0165366959,
0.0066523599,
-0.0210506022,
-0.0497602709,
-0.0180842858,
-0.008094511,
-0.0563434623,
-0.0091858935,
0.0906673968,
-0.0003466382,
0.0420556776,
-0.0237817373,
0.0316784605,
0.0155526083,
0.0444129519,
0.0267745126,
0.0845451802,
-0.0389411151,
-0.0036473572,
0.01572733,
0.0039895396,
-0.0044446001,
-0.0603193305,
0.0080113094,
-0.0009156448,
0.0494423248,
-0.0184071586,
-0.0007945249,
-0.0056202705,
-0.0066829878,
-0.0540340953,
-0.0130671719,
-0.037507683,
0.03042938,
0.0289689284,
0.0004335462,
-0.0601986721,
0.0358306766,
-0.0452422015,
0.011366968,
0.0037468616,
-0.0470789857,
0.0211257208,
0.0036633068,
-0.006142172,
-0.0284028258,
0.0026066848,
0.0018984098,
-0.033962518,
-0.0014097503,
0.0189408679,
0.0000397888,
-0.0051599499,
-0.0446213782,
0.0025186089,
-0.0549640283,
0.0067129955,
0.0190711692,
0.0179845653,
0.0020693205,
-0.0045672753,
-0.0195552111,
0.0044616139,
0.0376020484,
-0.0014781796,
0.0222301707,
0.1075905114,
0.0346313305,
-0.0398540273,
0.0589366555,
0.0222678222,
-0.0130917607,
0.0016971951,
0.0004734733,
0.0103911813,
-0.0027651377,
-0.0395152494,
-0.0086706979,
0.0426367484,
0.0224647261,
-0.0581167154,
-0.0196177475,
-0.0284546223,
0.0667736456,
-0.0529233292,
0.0391261131,
0.0433717333,
0.0875552148,
0.031545043,
0.0335863978,
-0.0803233981,
0.036827337,
-0.016037548,
-0.0412371494,
0.0317960717,
0.0561570674,
0.0417008586,
-0.0199840311,
0.0975241065,
0.0260056816,
-0.019221684,
-0.0194925312,
-0.0149957072,
0.0323603377,
0.0561769791,
0.0113952132,
-0.0339176841,
-0.0381383672,
0.0237773024,
0.0445216447,
0.0000586701,
-0.0174376089,
-0.0839928091,
-0.0278511941,
0.0733138695,
-0.006118631,
0.0271138027,
-0.0083175115,
-0.0340414196,
-0.0481965467,
-0.0219046008,
0.0256994348,
0.1027221233,
-0.007577328,
-0.0349067226,
-0.0529783815,
-0.0379053093,
0.034860231,
-0.0027041971,
0.0758705586,
0.0312878601,
0.0131972469,
-0.0453765802,
0.0630955771,
0.0106675662,
0.0023594769,
0.0379481465,
0.0546813756,
-0.0337596387,
0.0130729191,
0.0706479326,
0.0180889815,
-0.0353100002,
0.0132587738,
-0.02437043,
0.0050583854,
-0.0394000039,
0.0341984592,
-0.0473234653,
0.034745086,
0.0156600568,
-0.0849759653,
-0.0112811057,
-0.022239998,
0.0333893448,
0.0038983074,
0.0997891873,
-0.0055760951,
-0.0835071802,
0.0308742225,
-0.0206424501,
-0.0607406497,
-0.023962969,
-0.0238077771,
0.0586953126,
0.0030033407,
-0.0098418649,
0.006181302,
-0.0536987148,
0.0488080829,
-0.0606356114,
0.0125739062,
0.0361735858,
0.0407847799,
0.0012264735,
0.0338868722,
-0.0244162902,
-0.0217935219,
-0.0116835656,
-0.0894800127,
-0.0166512057,
-0.0012388428,
0.0084244842,
-0.0104709165,
-0.0206617471,
0.0047659674,
0.0227702223,
-0.0194338001,
0.008746976,
0.0104175396,
0.0451949127,
0.0185188223,
0.0182516612,
0.0186563693,
-0.0026819129,
-0.0037590973,
0.014867275,
0.0302228089,
0.0584811606,
-0.0753085017,
0.0005687447,
-0.031960655,
-0.0659636706,
-0.0240631718,
-0.010384894,
-0.0207994804,
0.077074036,
0.0197409261,
0.009213984,
-0.0094014052,
0.0498905331,
0.0026329083,
0.0239258669,
-0.0019205972,
-0.0503393784,
0.0041381195,
0.0133278547,
0.0730174184,
0.0196242407,
-0.0448817722,
0.0173642542,
0.050044626,
0.0088604819,
0.0155038731,
-0.0321347974,
0.0478004254,
-0.0354581699,
-0.0333770439,
-0.0527366176,
-0.0931667387,
-0.0040949457,
0.0399099551,
-0.0235583168,
0.007216203,
0.0239555798,
0.067360796,
0.0103445994,
-0.0612651035,
0.0100162691,
-0.0821235254,
0.0394325554,
-0.0589927956,
-0.0102362474,
0.0338482521,
-0.0175229292,
-0.0620591044,
-0.0456524901,
0.0585756339,
-0.0428399704,
0.0838924348,
-0.0178954415,
-0.013188201,
-0.0504809469,
-0.0258783083,
-0.0178714804,
0.0162710957,
-0.0206310004,
-0.0033266596,
0.1342477947,
-0.0094482834,
-0.0650281608,
0.0053402786,
0.053327512,
-0.006621053,
0.0345182158,
-0.0120123671,
0.0525918491,
-0.0330050588,
-0.0464655049,
0.0548564456,
0.0961645171,
-0.0599534251,
0.041387789,
0.0551777557,
0.0051523498,
-0.060702201,
-0.0161959697,
-0.0567114167,
0.0006745232,
0.0021881389,
-0.0132062063,
-0.0251124408,
0.054574877,
0.0184272025,
0.0242054164,
0.0338582061,
0.0209780149,
-0.0630850121,
-0.0234522074,
-0.0640809983,
0.0374911092,
0.0212963708,
-0.0135099571,
-0.060353823,
0.0146642132,
-0.0084343366,
-0.0091006197,
-0.0545618199,
-0.0633884594,
-0.0436018594,
-0.0691043809,
0.0317305028,
0.0049254266,
-0.0104785999,
0.0135114696,
0.0368803889,
0.03002817,
-0.0209008623,
0.0030945977,
0.0094529931,
0.0325272083,
0.0320794359,
0.031567622,
-0.1095129326,
0.0142956479,
-0.0018429809,
-0.0174066219,
-0.0008484625,
0.0290872734,
0.0461208187,
-0.0134416837,
-0.0416421033,
0.0612390153,
-0.0081317779,
-0.006548875,
0.0121671362,
0.0383706391,
0.0070399409,
0.0266063716,
-0.0029318088,
-0.0058709304,
0.0155462828,
-0.0298659038,
0.0248819515,
-0.007114728,
-0.0093388129,
-0.0161143802,
0.0097723724,
-0.0006323174,
0.0339298695,
0.0298617817,
0.0204486419,
-0.0199948605,
0.0024874634,
-0.0274506845,
0.0030548736,
-0.0331087708,
-0.0283805206,
-0.0150729567,
0.0814983994,
0.041326236,
-0.0181801654,
-0.0184451398,
0.0162074398,
-0.0050280676,
-0.0271244384,
0.0030527702,
-0.0246420968,
0.0530197471,
0.0206250697,
0.0147269936,
0.0378156193,
-0.0127723804,
-0.0369734652,
-0.0604633801,
-0.0809765682,
0.0146333911,
-0.0086349417,
0.0091217514,
-0.0427577011,
-0.0296262223,
0.0244368985,
0.0033835229,
0.0319896154,
-0.0401763953,
0.0168140177,
-0.0376433358,
0.0275900569,
0.0296815298,
0.0266154949,
-0.0127639705,
0.0011189563,
0.0604557618,
0.0026843981,
-0.0102071371,
0.0438017063,
0.0233149026,
0.024625944,
-0.0138862142,
-0.0295449179,
-0.0246419162,
0.0013921291,
-0.024241142,
-0.0253452286,
-0.0264974553,
0.001572358,
-0.0294499025,
-0.0286569949,
0.0165203139,
-0.012672117,
-0.0014853526,
-0.0779565573,
-0.0027642676,
-0.0676117763,
0.0141674094,
0.036808461,
0.0123007009,
0.0344187468,
-0.0371221043,
0.0863560736,
0.0374642797,
-0.0253440738,
0.003569457,
-0.0038316033,
0.0064692255,
0.0216183383,
-0.0444458611,
0.036360871,
0.0214716196,
0.0589800067,
-0.0146092437,
-0.0471241586,
0.0301988367,
0.020599708,
-0.050080996,
-0.1039339751,
0.0470900312,
0.02971703,
-0.0324872807,
0.0372745059,
-0.0303861536,
-0.0196849145,
-0.0030331328,
-0.012384654,
-0.0087751383,
-0.0395979919,
0.0165794343,
0.0014560772,
0.0339796282,
-0.0208317097,
-0.0230225399,
0.0515980944,
-0.0710379034,
-0.0450092144,
-0.050691314,
-0.0048225308,
-0.0590456687,
-0.0091428673,
-0.0112913614,
0.0314385742,
-0.0182363894,
0.0083715674,
-0.09752094,
0.0335239619,
0.0125418138,
0.0072905314,
0.063762337,
-0.0010807842,
0.0015948632,
0.0234742332,
-0.0024333536,
0.0134428516,
-0.011081839,
0.0264803655,
-0.0422079526,
0.021010438,
-0.0454897396,
-6.198538934e-33,
-0.0029346559,
-0.0635636151,
-0.0004926794,
-0.064464204,
0.0190629587,
-0.0541660935,
-0.0061818687,
0.0574360713,
-0.0077157407,
0.0177224651,
-0.0052222186,
0.0152628953,
0.0047078277,
-0.0194051005,
0.0400258154,
0.0039824615,
0.0311395098,
-0.0154845631,
-0.0400020294,
-0.0160594136,
0.0313106477,
-0.0196670275,
-0.0223819204,
-0.0002482078,
0.0022846907,
0.0331216268,
0.0200208016,
-0.0455030277,
0.019266028,
0.0414873138,
-0.0005435842,
-0.0195368156,
0.0256069209,
-0.0784073323,
-0.0363135301,
0.0562710054,
-0.0084154513,
-0.0279968679,
-0.0042027468,
-0.0281939507,
0.0155109586,
-0.0074735112,
-0.0349707752,
0.0238220468,
-0.031533204,
-0.044342123,
-0.002769439,
0.0017640778,
-0.00158142,
0.0163143277,
-0.0337054282,
0.0324185677,
-0.0400465429,
0.0340592228,
-0.0190240834,
0.0300881732,
-0.0092640771,
-0.0162966214,
-0.0630964115,
0.0634679273,
-0.0068310699,
-0.0332342871,
0.0028262162,
0.0059002452,
-0.0083961487,
0.0405957364,
0.0159537029,
0.072137624,
-0.0511467867,
-0.0407801792,
-0.0484737866,
0.057816837,
0.064588964,
0.0604002774,
0.0214505102,
-0.0122713158,
-0.0116716577,
0.0053465194,
-0.0015327212,
-0.0011951638,
0.0557493605,
0.0289096255,
-0.051531855,
-0.0110882111,
0.0169409402,
-0.0295124277,
-0.008231882,
0.0002841461,
-0.0095442152,
0.0170099437,
-0.0543718748,
-0.0145838866,
0.056028869,
-0.0254715905,
-0.0102766454,
0.017635351,
-0.0103113763,
0.0025134629,
0.0051804497,
-0.0575958677,
-0.0929867253,
0.0034273863,
-0.0158537868,
0.0611980408,
0.0418952554,
0.0046496531,
-0.0037118099,
-0.0086239474,
-0.042008765,
-0.0132000381,
-0.0011116235,
0.0537387468,
0.0126625001,
-0.0083424635,
0.0110119414,
0.0047217607,
0.009793872,
-0.0484998301,
0.0086613428,
-0.0218272042,
0.0078524984,
0.0000687425,
-0.0689766631,
-0.0189596247,
-0.0133504346,
-0.0236689411,
0.0070589716,
-0.0034579157,
0.0427789316,
0.0440281257,
-0.0151483612,
-0.0536437072,
2.847e-7,
0.0122959465,
0.0280951653,
-0.008032185,
-0.020348791,
0.0494892821,
0.0310686398,
0.0065499428,
0.0079297172,
0.0135581568,
-0.0383160859,
0.0225958116,
0.0386746414,
0.0225420985,
0.0710868835,
-0.0219774097,
-0.0732287243,
-0.0318180658,
0.0178472809,
-0.0097365957,
0.0285779852,
-0.0035208911,
-0.0033603206,
-0.0037811671,
0.0110133877,
-0.0605860762,
0.0302783567,
0.0255528074,
-0.0341622755,
-0.0126477303,
0.0455618501,
0.0643319115,
-0.074478887,
-0.0069127516,
0.0545213483,
0.0340602323,
-0.015152147,
-0.0346216597,
-0.0355689712,
0.0268565919,
0.0048168367,
-0.0006269711,
-0.0040992955,
0.0294545926,
-0.0152150532,
0.0220317002,
-0.0556072406,
-0.0408166833,
-0.0556944385,
-0.0080689443,
-0.0153144253,
0.0761797056,
0.0316180624,
0.0293949135,
-0.0008663139,
-0.0247983951,
-0.0147534469,
0.0345303789,
-0.0474829413,
-0.0291185044,
-0.0381956808,
-0.0550451316,
-0.0874290019,
-0.0002661978,
-0.0234975554,
-0.0068393429,
0.0281662811,
0.003674889,
1.908186408e-34,
0.0040322542,
0.0097018378,
-0.0300849341,
0.0400009006,
0.0424709991,
-0.0265380107,
-0.0011171408,
-0.0464700833,
0.0605057664,
0.016758129,
-0.0034843485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01423v1 | Different Tastes of Entities: Investigating Human Label Variation in Named Entity Annotations | 2024-02-02T14:08:34 | 2024-02-02T14:08:34 | Siyao Peng, Zihang Sun, Sebastian Loftus, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a key information extraction task with a
long-standing tradition. While recent studies address and aim to correct
annotation errors via re-labeling efforts, little is known about the sources of
human label variation, such as text ambiguity, annotation error, or guideline
divergence. This is especially the case for high-quality datasets and beyond
English CoNLL03. This paper studies disagreements in expert-annotated named
entity datasets for three languages: English, Danish, and Bavarian. We show
that text ambiguity and artificial guideline changes are dominant factors for
diverse annotations among high-quality revisions. We survey student annotations
on a subset of difficult entities and substantiate the feasibility and
necessity of manifold annotations for understanding named entity ambiguities
from a distributional perspective. | Different Tastes of Entities: Investigating Human Label Variation in Named Entity Annotations: Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a key information extraction task with a
long-standing tradition. While recent studies address and aim to correct
annotation errors via re-labeling efforts, little is known about the sources of
human label variation, such as text ambiguity, annotation error, or guideline
divergence. This is especially the case for high-quality datasets and beyond
English CoNLL03. This paper studies disagreements in expert-annotated named
entity datasets for three languages: English, Danish, and Bavarian. We show
that text ambiguity and artificial guideline changes are dominant factors for
diverse annotations among high-quality revisions. We survey student annotations
on a subset of difficult entities and substantiate the feasibility and
necessity of manifold annotations for understanding named entity ambiguities
from a distributional perspective. | [
0.080125995,
0.0155769996,
-0.0206776056,
0.0263556913,
0.0109564178,
0.0468082502,
0.009353688,
-0.0381201617,
0.0046391883,
-0.0312054679,
-0.0098505802,
-0.0179852471,
0.0365535133,
-0.0760436729,
0.0342538655,
-0.0620547347,
0.0344944075,
-0.0059863175,
0.0507192686,
-0.0021481153,
0.000809028,
-0.0164603908,
-0.0024448743,
0.0206303727,
-0.0101249591,
0.0147701567,
0.0027445434,
-0.0022417756,
0.0313152596,
-0.0281520169,
0.0200008769,
0.0837107226,
-0.0357668325,
0.0945529938,
0.0000015977,
-0.0463263579,
-0.0198995993,
0.0059666461,
-0.0283339377,
0.0092274817,
0.0056414646,
-0.0063753184,
-0.0243789088,
-0.0624706596,
-0.0034474407,
-0.0430517867,
0.0583763272,
0.0406500548,
0.0245959312,
0.0519094914,
0.0033451384,
-0.039253138,
-0.020006014,
-0.016710842,
-0.0008774974,
-0.0175506156,
0.0248885024,
0.0076670917,
-0.0259910505,
0.0341181047,
-0.0094460119,
0.0439848863,
-0.021927584,
0.0222448632,
0.0247577764,
0.041877687,
-0.0193258598,
-0.0230681449,
0.0263739787,
0.0549484678,
0.0318913199,
0.0208949298,
0.0312450863,
-0.0192746725,
0.011508679,
0.0345572121,
0.0144392392,
0.025263628,
-0.0698748305,
-0.0053630495,
0.0271799602,
-0.0318982974,
0.0129688578,
0.007389158,
-0.0062410859,
0.0633857474,
-0.0051268744,
-0.0472227298,
0.0511306748,
0.0465668701,
-0.0513406731,
-0.0555043966,
0.0231617521,
-0.0274138637,
0.0080348961,
0.0125315972,
-0.0359639227,
-0.0689311922,
0.0164491143,
-0.0503716506,
-0.0158411339,
-0.0069284597,
-0.0352209695,
0.0305248052,
0.022838708,
0.0120593989,
-0.001652882,
0.0396211296,
-0.007429102,
-0.011586519,
-0.0407995842,
-0.0040823724,
-0.0171629228,
0.0072922758,
-0.0074649942,
0.0355086848,
-0.0548355021,
-0.0188425295,
-0.0209987871,
0.0316430256,
-0.0140094254,
-0.031151263,
-0.0360695459,
0.0191008542,
-0.0642162338,
-0.0032230471,
-0.034655612,
0.0162931215,
-0.0351223163,
-0.0048513589,
0.0223874711,
-0.0059906985,
-0.0095782476,
-0.0404300243,
0.0015797331,
0.0282114614,
0.0072097955,
-0.0106890714,
-0.0237080511,
-0.0377086252,
-0.0249703191,
-0.020925723,
0.015741488,
-0.0515298657,
0.0313551649,
0.0168943014,
-0.0098092332,
-0.098926127,
0.0023782789,
-0.020574959,
-0.0858578831,
0.0683988556,
-0.0556332767,
0.0009352889,
0.054719504,
0.002747416,
-0.0152114592,
0.0204277579,
0.0099955099,
-0.0288810879,
0.0648301318,
0.0125606433,
-0.0011775896,
0.0179336164,
-0.002102369,
-0.0155483447,
0.033865355,
-0.0125858393,
-0.0124964779,
0.0531732664,
0.0588626526,
0.0464459769,
-0.0268630031,
-0.0519173853,
0.0172952618,
0.0493477061,
-0.0016596576,
-0.0332961492,
-0.0068061319,
-0.0019974932,
0.0414449722,
0.0354277864,
-0.0276072025,
-0.001735649,
0.0189284105,
0.0156186894,
-0.0013107824,
-0.0077195712,
0.0042564077,
-0.0232540183,
-0.0136216916,
0.0249376781,
-0.0107437922,
-0.0191263296,
0.0237321984,
-0.0061587715,
-0.0034034955,
0.0576611981,
0.0245020557,
-0.0356028527,
0.0284056179,
0.0451858491,
0.0123531381,
0.0543357544,
-0.0074503897,
-0.0146698626,
-0.0251786988,
-0.0102557363,
-0.0046584685,
0.0402185023,
0.0403758362,
-0.0529931895,
0.0174040869,
-0.0136787388,
-0.0156482905,
0.0061216136,
0.0266934447,
0.0118871387,
0.0026734404,
0.0059178886,
0.0023169741,
-0.0761687011,
-0.0676584616,
0.050157547,
-0.0185030419,
-0.0126371374,
-0.0275374223,
0.0379859395,
-0.0021229282,
0.043479193,
-0.0266455151,
-0.0002928117,
-0.0163129568,
-0.0105006425,
0.0147920614,
-0.0099678989,
0.0449428856,
-0.0060024601,
0.0260592289,
-0.0572098047,
-0.0560808294,
-0.0509488508,
-0.0282206163,
-0.0363910682,
-0.0620116033,
-0.0120408768,
0.0098551614,
0.0105972821,
0.0095738405,
0.0022376657,
-0.0179330558,
-0.0747389123,
0.0417199247,
-0.0080200648,
0.0462949798,
-0.0011287477,
-0.0125056654,
0.0041682743,
-0.0194972958,
-0.0557984821,
0.0459484644,
0.0408939123,
-0.0188336782,
0.0155652082,
-0.0367807485,
-0.0549390055,
-0.0261431895,
-0.0552243292,
-0.017911965,
-0.0218926854,
0.0551880822,
0.0058626644,
-0.0120641766,
-0.0166194923,
-0.0165978968,
0.0274838582,
-0.0572036691,
-0.0654852986,
0.0423877984,
0.0447939932,
0.0206385721,
0.0054100105,
-0.0181417279,
-0.0073361476,
-0.0334928781,
0.0102530895,
0.0415587351,
-0.0800326988,
-0.0815452412,
0.0365948156,
-0.0662308484,
-0.0083448607,
0.0151085667,
0.0266855583,
0.0158394016,
0.0580863245,
0.0816704929,
0.0427645892,
-0.0374976434,
0.0392236449,
0.0249982495,
-0.0342734829,
-0.0401930325,
-0.0016854495,
-0.0132642491,
-0.0073451791,
-0.026010761,
-0.0717915744,
0.028904289,
0.0444315001,
-0.024288509,
0.0032861691,
-0.0345410593,
0.0394794866,
-0.07950712,
-0.0088669714,
-0.0196311958,
0.0184414219,
-0.0027446754,
0.0775992051,
-0.0013683405,
0.0004195634,
0.0845245123,
-0.0034285239,
0.0110308481,
-0.0335268266,
0.0223631188,
-0.011218288,
0.0182947535,
-0.0112749673,
-0.000630843,
0.0452299342,
-0.0708856061,
-0.0329671539,
0.0637290254,
0.0619994886,
-0.0146426745,
0.0453703813,
-0.0321219005,
0.004986302,
-0.018426301,
-0.0080727953,
-0.0062867347,
-0.0219658464,
-0.0505695827,
-0.0024505428,
0.0291505978,
-0.0197075624,
0.0009962252,
0.016470151,
0.0036379427,
0.0153422309,
0.0037989696,
-0.008494637,
-0.0202587806,
-0.0172744598,
0.0204413235,
0.0562001429,
0.0343551673,
-0.0303292852,
-0.0387189984,
0.0276304688,
-0.014989553,
-0.0024813218,
0.0393860787,
-0.0260787643,
0.0305685233,
-0.0735909417,
-0.0660207719,
-0.0029666557,
0.0480721369,
-0.0489428751,
0.0078829704,
0.0713731647,
0.0202079564,
-0.011442055,
-0.0001622636,
-0.0031400037,
0.0127223972,
0.0054614111,
0.0092014056,
-0.0887294635,
0.0066084331,
0.0015220334,
0.0344841331,
-0.0343020819,
-0.0735007226,
0.0074195336,
-0.0785369352,
0.0183622763,
0.0084986566,
-0.1089468077,
0.0223301034,
-0.0462567136,
0.0162322484,
-0.036157243,
0.0134563781,
-0.0157786664,
0.0152772255,
0.050670851,
0.0456815176,
0.0025054838,
-0.0792676881,
-0.0101792188,
-0.0545480512,
0.0606352538,
0.0029163938,
0.0225297883,
-0.0372444801,
-0.0480606481,
0.015395592,
-0.0152477268,
-0.0134914294,
-0.0240086671,
0.086544849,
-0.0164991226,
-0.0106265256,
-0.0347314067,
-0.0057517067,
0.0035835425,
-0.0201116186,
-0.0051766555,
0.0337573588,
0.0056682271,
0.0123312101,
0.0078371065,
-0.0086730281,
0.0148426369,
0.0614697784,
0.028138604,
-0.0192034449,
-0.0096368082,
-0.0081810988,
0.0662091076,
0.0098357014,
-0.0079399645,
0.0564312786,
-0.0777268931,
-0.0861523896,
-0.0367295332,
-0.08421956,
0.0285609793,
0.0280652475,
0.05659426,
0.0068317326,
0.0516527593,
-0.005687234,
-0.0465013571,
0.0689354911,
0.0083193108,
0.0174318235,
-0.040349111,
-0.0543297976,
-0.0046212068,
0.0407955945,
-0.0364878662,
-0.0082717007,
-0.0403964147,
-0.0700756758,
0.0587509051,
-0.0018466915,
0.0210357886,
0.0515645444,
0.0080320537,
-0.0809317827,
-0.045302622,
0.0441012308,
0.017795505,
0.0165945794,
0.0177381039,
0.052845668,
-0.0120364949,
0.0180195831,
-0.0307508633,
0.0024131653,
0.0489461422,
0.0171012487,
-0.0243199617,
-0.0354628526,
-0.0126719931,
0.0449296646,
0.0527333692,
-0.0301522817,
-0.0019531429,
-0.0462987162,
-0.0072536897,
0.0232721996,
-0.014469916,
0.0195595659,
-0.0354513749,
-0.0111011118,
-0.0103347264,
-0.0494125262,
0.0823982507,
-0.0054672435,
0.0640615672,
-0.0777918547,
-0.0007966519,
0.0519758761,
0.0661657825,
0.0095946556,
-0.0027392919,
0.0114125405,
0.0291858651,
0.0481661707,
0.076808244,
0.0094751669,
0.0088071479,
0.0334541425,
0.0016993405,
-0.0340555757,
-0.0090325475,
-0.0603590943,
-0.0143608833,
-0.0133960433,
0.0238038395,
0.023890635,
-0.0015191076,
0.0768545717,
-0.0155490963,
-0.0129476404,
-0.0059649553,
0.0046865344,
0.0050142794,
0.0133338012,
0.0402294174,
-0.0044288142,
-0.0208562668,
-0.0085238237,
0.044443462,
0.007260168,
0.0247776993,
-0.0455009937,
-0.0308690164,
-0.0212433767,
0.0028590776,
-0.0175263304,
-0.0075386176,
-0.0119749224,
-0.012994566,
-0.0900810286,
-0.028325757,
0.0430068374,
-0.0141926482,
-0.0099752322,
0.0155673632,
-0.0049406383,
0.0373812094,
-0.0040993914,
-0.0523954704,
-0.0274478681,
0.0151952785,
0.0112106558,
-0.0420354754,
-0.0356843844,
-5.775762473e-33,
-0.0386193022,
-0.0311081093,
-0.0254206136,
-0.0160759613,
-0.0182994828,
0.0202793814,
-0.0029059255,
0.0186989848,
0.0051264307,
0.0083642127,
-0.0046874327,
0.0026329155,
0.0392323583,
-0.031367179,
0.0537135005,
-0.0456881076,
0.0509589128,
0.0388088897,
-0.0520634614,
-0.0186484177,
0.0497440509,
0.009712209,
0.1019576639,
-0.1129737794,
0.1262732595,
0.0162609834,
0.0236696638,
-0.0020379794,
0.0470499545,
0.0319350399,
-0.002663431,
0.0448644906,
0.0048619816,
-0.0354283378,
-0.0204684231,
-0.0470652506,
-0.1096697375,
-0.0321712755,
0.0061009545,
0.0717678517,
0.0093139242,
-0.0543992668,
0.0612809844,
0.0040850462,
-0.0317293741,
0.0363390744,
0.0676893145,
0.0165180657,
-0.0019672797,
-0.0111966161,
-0.0233106893,
0.0348876305,
0.0020379215,
0.0693496615,
0.0597856753,
-0.0198186822,
0.023828432,
-0.0128621012,
-0.0954575613,
0.0138730817,
0.017026227,
-0.0303927381,
0.0123692267,
0.0082935542,
-0.0075070751,
0.0262324251,
0.059273947,
0.0641415492,
-0.0250422917,
-0.0276685506,
0.0239604749,
-0.0053094905,
-0.023341747,
0.0499460362,
0.0175585598,
-0.037511915,
-0.0135947503,
0.0171438511,
-0.0361044034,
-0.0253668632,
-0.0365534164,
-0.0102399476,
-0.0797943771,
-0.0439335965,
-0.0283910558,
-0.055477567,
-0.0189860575,
0.02392531,
0.0021597408,
-0.049152866,
-0.0130191389,
0.0434126966,
-0.0146491416,
-0.0089087449,
-0.0745532662,
-0.0829333812,
0.0224118661,
0.0445834361,
-0.0095838318,
-0.001373554,
-0.0615321323,
-0.0109627675,
0.0207029507,
0.0320438556,
0.0495484956,
0.0095636426,
0.0442705564,
-0.0288523287,
-0.0516270697,
-0.0062093912,
0.0051636775,
-0.0124367876,
-0.0189590398,
-0.0229598656,
0.0454924367,
0.0054916581,
0.0007246008,
-0.0124756275,
0.0762679428,
0.0238441415,
-0.0181415118,
0.0351438113,
0.0251765922,
0.0125604337,
-0.003171853,
-0.0008510023,
0.0505097918,
-0.0095230006,
0.0175460242,
-0.0293804314,
0.0046484922,
-0.0218463223,
2.378e-7,
0.0604324825,
0.0603648201,
0.0155301448,
-0.0482579954,
-0.0077873636,
0.0052885078,
0.0138231181,
0.0062351115,
-0.010788261,
-0.0149294846,
-0.0065475181,
-0.0417711698,
0.0234399252,
0.0608596466,
-0.0479714163,
-0.0523462854,
-0.0014743687,
0.0447655134,
-0.0632003918,
0.0473197512,
0.0493364669,
0.0244047269,
0.0322479978,
0.0070448075,
-0.0475968421,
0.0046436014,
0.02721579,
-0.0072239987,
0.0581779703,
0.032260593,
0.0748544633,
0.0352289192,
0.0430594832,
0.0914223194,
0.0099174669,
-0.0200752933,
0.0640351102,
0.030814616,
-0.0031760368,
0.0414779969,
-0.0374067128,
-0.0171480346,
0.0146805793,
-0.0316524692,
0.003499537,
-0.041595839,
-0.0468817726,
0.01608143,
-0.0369371399,
0.0233985931,
0.0425030552,
0.0247842185,
-0.0037983949,
0.0361565277,
0.023597829,
0.0016925526,
-0.0157114826,
-0.0336302966,
0.0084677609,
0.0407106578,
0.00880842,
-0.0494871549,
0.0156044951,
-0.0168715473,
-0.0109744929,
-0.0625610799,
0.0034579877,
1.681594949e-34,
-0.0098533472,
0.0141916508,
0.0010745694,
0.0309464075,
0.0085756769,
-0.0019027621,
0.0117356526,
0.0026087642,
-0.0290187243,
-0.0013640175,
-0.0075878371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01416v1 | Sequence Shortening for Context-Aware Machine Translation | 2024-02-02T13:55:37 | 2024-02-02T13:55:37 | Paweł Mąka, Yusuf Can Semerci, Jan Scholtes, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Context-aware Machine Translation aims to improve translations of sentences
by incorporating surrounding sentences as context. Towards this task, two main
architectures have been applied, namely single-encoder (based on concatenation)
and multi-encoder models. In this study, we show that a special case of
multi-encoder architecture, where the latent representation of the source
sentence is cached and reused as the context in the next step, achieves higher
accuracy on the contrastive datasets (where the models have to rank the correct
translation among the provided sentences) and comparable BLEU and COMET scores
as the single- and multi-encoder approaches. Furthermore, we investigate the
application of Sequence Shortening to the cached representations. We test three
pooling-based shortening techniques and introduce two novel methods - Latent
Grouping and Latent Selecting, where the network learns to group tokens or
selects the tokens to be cached as context. Our experiments show that the two
methods achieve competitive BLEU and COMET scores and accuracies on the
contrastive datasets to the other tested methods while potentially allowing for
higher interpretability and reducing the growth of memory requirements with
increased context size. | Sequence Shortening for Context-Aware Machine Translation: Context-aware Machine Translation aims to improve translations of sentences
by incorporating surrounding sentences as context. Towards this task, two main
architectures have been applied, namely single-encoder (based on concatenation)
and multi-encoder models. In this study, we show that a special case of
multi-encoder architecture, where the latent representation of the source
sentence is cached and reused as the context in the next step, achieves higher
accuracy on the contrastive datasets (where the models have to rank the correct
translation among the provided sentences) and comparable BLEU and COMET scores
as the single- and multi-encoder approaches. Furthermore, we investigate the
application of Sequence Shortening to the cached representations. We test three
pooling-based shortening techniques and introduce two novel methods - Latent
Grouping and Latent Selecting, where the network learns to group tokens or
selects the tokens to be cached as context. Our experiments show that the two
methods achieve competitive BLEU and COMET scores and accuracies on the
contrastive datasets to the other tested methods while potentially allowing for
higher interpretability and reducing the growth of memory requirements with
increased context size. | [
0.0160385724,
0.027410442,
-0.0215498004,
0.0342556275,
-0.0590947419,
0.0162421931,
0.0444168411,
-0.0052500013,
-0.0674610659,
-0.0369937271,
-0.0004940767,
-0.058928553,
0.058026813,
-0.0153472777,
0.0509284399,
-0.0636065677,
0.0318068527,
0.0101466281,
0.0011009569,
0.0143229486,
-0.0071887774,
0.0086573716,
0.0240248851,
0.0335143134,
0.0109527661,
0.0183947235,
-0.0129281646,
0.0185142756,
0.038865149,
-0.0332110487,
0.0033164825,
0.0511240028,
0.0218024198,
0.0082782339,
0.0000023178,
-0.0209551286,
-0.0576348752,
-0.0239227582,
0.0061309254,
0.0042490968,
0.0599632449,
-0.0432152413,
-0.002644368,
0.0318425708,
0.0007157015,
-0.0014344405,
0.0381672904,
0.0146124158,
0.0462890118,
0.071716316,
-0.0258195344,
-0.0680977851,
-0.0188391581,
-0.0463803522,
-0.0143561391,
-0.0590367056,
-0.0051386789,
-0.0395088196,
-0.0386120155,
0.0123795532,
-0.0419914462,
0.0453861244,
0.0536059849,
0.0291020386,
-0.010107751,
0.0244708881,
-0.0356915742,
-0.0090902364,
-0.0131562604,
0.0608778968,
-0.0322356522,
-0.0177252684,
-0.0235083271,
-0.0036417851,
0.0004349073,
-0.0532202832,
-0.0541613922,
0.0038229621,
0.0163736306,
0.0112959398,
-0.0139751919,
0.0552808791,
0.0312556624,
0.0058231223,
-0.0521045402,
-0.0409720875,
0.0358458199,
-0.0175310019,
-0.0703337044,
0.0070349406,
-0.0164704118,
-0.0283405557,
0.036699187,
0.0114729526,
-0.0181660727,
0.020507304,
-0.032817468,
-0.053364031,
0.0032613671,
-0.0294765644,
-0.0124301771,
0.0629402399,
-0.0165321156,
0.0237000827,
-0.0406901985,
0.081804812,
0.001176005,
-0.0276513714,
-0.0846488029,
-0.0391131863,
-0.0342675671,
0.0208243709,
-0.0274776313,
0.0271907952,
-0.0599868372,
-0.0281822197,
-0.070158191,
0.0112900417,
0.0147785107,
-0.0181625001,
-0.0152799422,
0.0190812703,
-0.0451231711,
0.0309129264,
0.0006573871,
0.0348777436,
-0.0377301499,
-0.0028094945,
0.0345200114,
-0.0609516054,
-0.0388766415,
0.0139984395,
0.0340760686,
-0.0397410542,
-0.0173089802,
0.0745290592,
-0.0102736959,
-0.0476564541,
-0.0122040901,
-0.0304203462,
-0.0387517028,
-0.039370019,
-0.0006145827,
-0.0763035491,
0.0605420433,
-0.0039945338,
0.0176246539,
-0.0244284347,
-0.0075964378,
0.0075699328,
-0.0000714671,
0.0587845333,
0.0167305656,
-0.0649172813,
0.0041290005,
0.0201600119,
0.0208297968,
0.0432271473,
0.0646106154,
0.0543439873,
0.0344878025,
-0.0046804217,
-0.0104035875,
-0.0009581934,
0.0230429824,
0.0036702654,
-0.0022536085,
-0.017574789,
0.0000968888,
0.016365502,
0.0209116694,
0.0521318205,
-0.048938904,
-0.0064633847,
0.0278202929,
0.0381030329,
0.0275278799,
0.0392394625,
0.0564644039,
0.0025068927,
-0.0415028557,
0.0402739011,
-0.0101718446,
0.0501215234,
0.000857933,
0.003637475,
0.0751247704,
0.0427866764,
-0.0255415607,
-0.0204797667,
0.0040654992,
-0.0325045325,
0.0276818965,
-0.0330041125,
0.0276785139,
0.0126114395,
-0.0656437203,
0.0509653687,
-0.0151945101,
-0.0762528181,
-0.0042511919,
0.0001836562,
-0.04673177,
0.0798859969,
0.0302919168,
0.0224103797,
-0.0586996451,
-0.0191326141,
-0.0399556421,
-0.0037343397,
0.0188596416,
0.0084724389,
0.0416438617,
-0.0666619837,
-0.0169782601,
-0.0194187872,
-0.0148073621,
0.0282589886,
-0.0028225787,
0.0224875342,
0.0616542026,
0.0321510769,
0.0066861999,
0.0317510627,
0.0075163944,
-0.0339713953,
0.0296993945,
0.0378319547,
0.0501476005,
0.0280386619,
0.0221433993,
0.0034358301,
0.0485324413,
-0.0627697408,
-0.0284145381,
0.0304353666,
-0.1048262641,
-0.1234709918,
0.0015753644,
-0.0263374019,
0.0133884856,
0.0007102497,
-0.0721434206,
-0.0728404,
-0.0049201879,
-0.0389137827,
0.0315711312,
-0.0251771137,
0.0334225297,
0.0025329648,
0.0326310359,
-0.0193275511,
0.0766678974,
-0.041227486,
0.0034806132,
0.0220678411,
0.029551914,
0.0322460271,
-0.0485992394,
-0.0135670491,
0.0082351472,
0.0185601972,
0.0003966666,
0.0600531474,
0.0102240676,
-0.0381010175,
-0.0073111593,
-0.0879322812,
0.0158231724,
-0.0355188325,
0.0121417083,
0.0337038785,
0.0439760238,
0.0296114087,
-0.0073139481,
-0.0202236511,
0.0055044745,
-0.0105582988,
0.0331767797,
0.034244854,
0.0007701888,
-0.0321858339,
-0.0146301901,
-0.0188265443,
0.0155026019,
0.0770602301,
-0.0241633914,
-0.0424205214,
-0.0339944772,
0.0336741135,
-0.0304049794,
-0.0345037542,
-0.0035757283,
-0.0446449667,
0.0015618876,
-0.0025245578,
0.0402105413,
0.0401567407,
0.0257946551,
0.0498505235,
0.0174942724,
0.0093835844,
-0.0136889964,
-0.0105970958,
-0.0354738608,
-0.0071951472,
-0.0147954477,
-0.0205226615,
0.0018249496,
0.0329934098,
0.0225372184,
0.0205565356,
-0.0687396973,
-0.0129752103,
0.0269965921,
-0.0368224233,
-0.0446106456,
-0.0038402476,
-0.0121615594,
0.0221934896,
-0.0335922949,
-0.0314116478,
0.0624174438,
-0.0255434234,
-0.0040062792,
-0.0535197929,
-0.0085964203,
-0.0407826528,
0.0455351882,
0.0021322579,
0.0235315356,
-0.0692794248,
-0.0237438288,
-0.0360624343,
0.0007546283,
-0.0073525882,
-0.0167142842,
0.0192798022,
-0.0484961905,
-0.0227339044,
-0.0022003725,
-0.0272624418,
-0.0202118661,
0.0143143479,
0.0179552585,
0.0394645184,
0.0592443831,
0.0125934593,
-0.0619040206,
0.0105064344,
0.0163810253,
0.0837835521,
-0.0152083393,
0.0299122445,
-0.018977005,
0.0598865822,
0.0058952342,
0.0028243186,
0.0510346815,
-0.0525834821,
0.0438655391,
0.057643421,
0.0362959616,
-0.0312292892,
-0.0328663513,
-0.007378058,
0.0106055159,
-0.0023171464,
-0.0169567484,
0.012330058,
0.0504565686,
-0.0653454289,
-0.0220186412,
0.11510849,
0.0309201609,
-0.0652173087,
0.0168321598,
0.0270474385,
0.0122226244,
0.0077904086,
-0.0101707131,
-0.0661767721,
-0.0374502651,
-0.0005626241,
-0.0005983631,
0.0098828562,
0.0161002092,
-0.0339770615,
-0.0753337443,
0.0013350005,
0.0352269597,
-0.0842874423,
-0.0319274142,
-0.031002339,
-0.0209687464,
-0.0031937473,
0.048262015,
0.0134640252,
0.0287400428,
-0.0260194149,
0.0077439668,
0.0155355148,
-0.0788892359,
-0.021531051,
-0.0347278528,
-0.0049761166,
0.0643419623,
0.0313278437,
0.0285896044,
-0.0157079827,
0.0304275714,
-0.0566329919,
0.0363099687,
-0.0219223481,
0.0233336128,
-0.0158966649,
0.0130156148,
0.0229343213,
0.0019462146,
-0.0494281724,
-0.0206759777,
0.0108970022,
0.0374823511,
-0.0065714354,
0.0097232452,
0.0051583867,
-0.0324314609,
-0.0048849666,
0.0453543179,
0.0384385325,
-0.0216937605,
0.0033500437,
-0.0226214584,
-0.0294531081,
-0.0690363869,
0.0337631702,
-0.0318303183,
-0.0376581065,
-0.032888107,
-0.0972708687,
-0.0562284477,
0.0289921686,
0.0347163416,
-0.0164550077,
0.036003489,
0.001329304,
0.0078437002,
-0.0301482696,
-0.0009556267,
-0.0007951929,
0.0073169633,
-0.0224987306,
0.0172067322,
0.0294286571,
-0.011227496,
-0.0103302151,
0.0214047413,
-0.0987099633,
-0.0473361462,
-0.0166776888,
0.0474364124,
0.0115956469,
0.0566892028,
0.0042112116,
-0.0025825317,
0.0317838602,
0.0117597664,
-0.0533529632,
0.0272181518,
-0.0035117979,
0.0007595786,
-0.0109113082,
0.0207197126,
-0.0324018896,
0.0282943621,
0.0020955633,
0.0516629182,
-0.0182932075,
-0.04027652,
0.022075139,
-0.0141769685,
0.0399865955,
-0.0235475674,
-0.0332849845,
0.00422975,
0.0581127964,
-0.0095062871,
0.0034194123,
-0.0115966657,
0.0003224372,
-0.0043254551,
0.0203700513,
-0.0018142845,
0.0206439272,
0.0169476662,
-0.0531348474,
-0.0056421957,
0.0105873682,
0.0123489834,
0.0319293067,
-0.0181988254,
0.054185953,
-0.0329411589,
-0.0213886257,
-0.0174340736,
0.0088330125,
-0.068259038,
0.0103760939,
0.0265934877,
0.0331063084,
-0.0293103289,
0.0666406751,
-0.0674129203,
0.0440740474,
-0.0345445871,
-0.0116906632,
0.0691928938,
-0.0143888313,
0.0733098313,
0.0273391828,
-0.0111371158,
-0.0306825209,
0.0562598482,
-0.0062116454,
-0.0491264164,
-0.0197071377,
0.0056849327,
-0.0138840312,
0.0206005033,
0.0628062114,
-0.0442904979,
-0.0022176604,
-0.0047126301,
-0.0169984922,
-0.0342279412,
-0.0059056659,
-0.0166522395,
0.0320317633,
0.0099407118,
-0.006772059,
-0.0013665353,
-0.0429163463,
0.030849902,
-0.0080410419,
0.0243370403,
0.0123752505,
0.0675173923,
0.0823449194,
-0.0242341626,
-0.010282021,
-0.0149524184,
0.0071028266,
-0.0170047134,
-0.0197199453,
-0.0372386985,
-6.814982131e-33,
-0.0383662134,
-0.0438255593,
0.0073624421,
-0.0488817655,
-0.025085235,
0.0125760539,
-0.0689004809,
-0.0498243906,
0.0147419423,
-0.0212115888,
-0.0026133955,
-0.0085538756,
0.022338029,
0.0403800569,
0.0138518885,
-0.0045376844,
0.0933065861,
0.0305870585,
-0.0136486813,
0.0260306988,
0.0575842001,
0.0394201018,
0.0526697524,
-0.0402748063,
-0.0094856787,
-0.0036752825,
0.0020427797,
0.002444034,
0.0225463863,
0.0518237241,
0.0117337117,
0.0259108059,
0.0344406478,
-0.0346298479,
-0.0325929411,
-0.0011096218,
-0.1047616079,
-0.0273142718,
0.0143491719,
0.0101384781,
-0.0495324992,
-0.1067364588,
0.0567367673,
-0.0195628833,
0.0295801405,
0.0113470247,
0.0125844972,
-0.0320963562,
-0.0509611405,
-0.0375055932,
-0.0592930876,
0.0038019682,
-0.0115563106,
0.0235136077,
0.0111478893,
0.0561358966,
-0.0230074096,
0.0480242781,
-0.0871967524,
0.0115111126,
-0.0288804732,
0.0630522445,
0.0684003085,
0.0269610174,
-0.0001279748,
0.0199041143,
0.0110357841,
-0.0286471136,
-0.0097842496,
-0.0050473888,
0.0035470212,
0.0136826364,
0.0760161132,
0.0350084975,
0.0617263727,
-0.0397203229,
-0.0732907653,
0.0145352604,
-0.0073375828,
0.0166849215,
0.0337253697,
0.0487987287,
-0.0050928448,
-0.0226696078,
-0.0375558473,
-0.0036361502,
-0.0304851271,
-0.0340626985,
0.0200916715,
0.0366197415,
-0.0386290215,
0.0109590562,
0.0643843114,
-0.001748109,
0.0352499746,
0.0111616729,
-0.0137642762,
0.0086741112,
0.0107107898,
0.0340381488,
-0.027731685,
-0.0130809397,
0.0415196046,
-0.0099190725,
0.0112421717,
-0.0326367207,
0.0639632717,
0.0108910268,
-0.0448713675,
0.0100325635,
-0.0426290743,
-0.0264951494,
-0.0327023789,
-0.0150284674,
0.0006681998,
0.0372971594,
-0.0178729463,
0.0652853921,
-0.0034700676,
-0.0126434918,
-0.004428877,
-0.0134589672,
0.0154872546,
0.055228021,
-0.0545980074,
0.004569808,
-0.0134215569,
0.0431215949,
0.0851745903,
-0.0349595696,
-0.041616559,
0.0209461004,
3.02e-7,
0.0484123677,
0.0486317277,
0.0338987187,
-0.0390287265,
0.019135233,
0.0109327761,
0.0021405297,
0.0326573253,
-0.0043856627,
0.0614801385,
0.0452409349,
0.0294569023,
0.0442731529,
0.0288911201,
-0.0745386779,
0.016237447,
-0.041401457,
0.0021266199,
-0.0280068237,
0.0131908078,
0.0866266638,
0.1130360812,
0.0086724367,
0.0175011028,
-0.0087449662,
0.0011232251,
0.0444388092,
-0.0195621401,
-0.013281405,
-0.0159331057,
-0.0352880135,
0.0356450714,
-0.033172518,
-0.0129432883,
-0.0157202799,
0.0242276788,
0.0169334561,
0.0561239868,
-0.0045981822,
-0.0537840351,
0.0269879345,
0.0203262568,
-0.0195104219,
0.0129393144,
0.0659620166,
-0.0566534586,
-0.0168668386,
-0.0061204573,
-0.0029458199,
0.0450346768,
0.0270640496,
0.020549655,
-0.0297163595,
0.0207938757,
0.0337735526,
0.0133389896,
-0.0196964219,
-0.1049117744,
-0.0024657112,
0.0018316419,
-0.0162077397,
-0.0042320453,
-0.0470551178,
-0.0054408647,
0.0378093347,
-0.0204717312,
0.001710295,
2.925061342e-34,
0.0234924518,
-0.0212785993,
-0.0134358201,
0.0253640991,
0.0316186249,
-0.0557770655,
-0.0391915739,
0.0010854242,
0.0073608686,
-0.0538207367,
-0.0489013903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01404v1 | On Measuring Context Utilization in Document-Level MT Systems | 2024-02-02T13:37:07 | 2024-02-02T13:37:07 | Wafaa Mohammed, Vlad Niculae | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level translation models are usually evaluated using general metrics
such as BLEU, which are not informative about the benefits of context. Current
work on context-aware evaluation, such as contrastive methods, only measure
translation accuracy on words that need context for disambiguation. Such
measures cannot reveal whether the translation model uses the correct
supporting context. We propose to complement accuracy-based evaluation with
measures of context utilization. We find that perturbation-based analysis
(comparing models' performance when provided with correct versus random
context) is an effective measure of overall context utilization. For a
finer-grained phenomenon-specific evaluation, we propose to measure how much
the supporting context contributes to handling context-dependent discourse
phenomena. We show that automatically-annotated supporting context gives
similar conclusions to human-annotated context and can be used as alternative
for cases where human annotations are not available. Finally, we highlight the
importance of using discourse-rich datasets when assessing context utilization. | On Measuring Context Utilization in Document-Level MT Systems: Document-level translation models are usually evaluated using general metrics
such as BLEU, which are not informative about the benefits of context. Current
work on context-aware evaluation, such as contrastive methods, only measure
translation accuracy on words that need context for disambiguation. Such
measures cannot reveal whether the translation model uses the correct
supporting context. We propose to complement accuracy-based evaluation with
measures of context utilization. We find that perturbation-based analysis
(comparing models' performance when provided with correct versus random
context) is an effective measure of overall context utilization. For a
finer-grained phenomenon-specific evaluation, we propose to measure how much
the supporting context contributes to handling context-dependent discourse
phenomena. We show that automatically-annotated supporting context gives
similar conclusions to human-annotated context and can be used as alternative
for cases where human annotations are not available. Finally, we highlight the
importance of using discourse-rich datasets when assessing context utilization. | [
0.0269591492,
0.0038651701,
-0.0209790561,
0.0462119803,
-0.0454256907,
0.0136889582,
0.0462707318,
-0.0306905229,
-0.0777115226,
-0.0669681653,
-0.0462230369,
-0.0213614069,
0.0459090583,
-0.0468181409,
0.019043982,
-0.0665059835,
0.0402387269,
-0.0325515755,
-0.0237859339,
0.0181244295,
0.0100049032,
0.0041620452,
0.0058281478,
0.0090010464,
-0.0156798493,
-0.0224454794,
0.020027779,
0.0282286648,
0.0700713098,
-0.0099494392,
-0.023287151,
0.0597717054,
0.00807223,
0.0632835701,
0.0000019503,
-0.0546714552,
-0.0421931557,
0.0247137211,
-0.0133932661,
0.0379147939,
0.0823985189,
-0.0416174047,
-0.0086430879,
-0.0039984593,
-0.0305199884,
0.0114444932,
0.0186745524,
-0.0167627241,
0.018254796,
0.0064064125,
-0.0240244474,
-0.0082614804,
-0.0532668382,
0.0136698931,
0.0058832401,
-0.057923533,
-0.0289012715,
0.0357348099,
-0.0141290035,
0.0245067962,
0.0028412084,
0.0754285306,
0.0172635186,
-0.0143104382,
-0.0130673191,
-0.0002109275,
-0.0214438792,
0.0167191457,
-0.001407012,
0.0547912493,
0.1086530015,
-0.0068729133,
-0.0006341392,
0.0064274664,
-0.0098943645,
0.0359399728,
-0.0277788956,
-0.006792088,
-0.0170333702,
0.0107142515,
0.0595826358,
0.042626068,
0.0022230372,
0.0362229571,
-0.0386438295,
0.0133761438,
0.029398283,
-0.0000215431,
-0.0192201808,
0.0185181331,
-0.0651555359,
-0.0439654663,
0.043682646,
-0.0104595004,
-0.0329415798,
0.0345000774,
-0.0233612917,
-0.0813583285,
0.037737336,
-0.0922394022,
-0.0115527241,
0.0406950116,
-0.0280343387,
0.0460724682,
0.0257520899,
0.0327044725,
-0.013604261,
-0.0490049049,
-0.0358259566,
-0.0222672876,
-0.0230683386,
0.0343698934,
-0.0374472365,
-0.000740008,
-0.0761639252,
-0.0153441085,
-0.0463097468,
0.0385403745,
0.0254077204,
-0.0155181065,
0.0014003995,
-0.0313368924,
-0.0705781803,
0.0141706364,
0.0071013775,
0.0344549865,
-0.032430999,
-0.0152702862,
-0.018612057,
-0.0320655107,
-0.000169487,
0.029755557,
-0.0351055302,
-0.0407424718,
-0.0580896474,
0.0605115779,
0.0038284927,
-0.0315227062,
-0.000150606,
-0.0273523238,
-0.0518306084,
-0.0402082168,
-0.0218283329,
-0.0680739358,
-0.0125367865,
0.0291363448,
0.0133901024,
-0.0033972417,
0.0181154702,
-0.0110166706,
-0.0055245971,
0.0925877467,
0.0084885955,
-0.0059809983,
0.0460755043,
0.0058378242,
-0.0132960007,
0.0784441084,
0.0633356571,
-0.0278283805,
0.048215434,
0.0269511919,
-0.0396621004,
0.034503825,
-0.0222259015,
0.0134010194,
-0.0183549095,
-0.0016517271,
-0.0286547225,
0.0041973139,
0.0161871426,
0.0706711709,
-0.0378387719,
0.0188983027,
0.0356427431,
0.0305979196,
0.0102665517,
0.0068385843,
0.0553075336,
0.0048210276,
-0.015847113,
0.0453863516,
0.0093053831,
-0.0147738196,
-0.0178702809,
0.0043384382,
0.0244006086,
-0.0017272113,
-0.0189954676,
-0.0525449179,
-0.0199697074,
-0.0073499922,
0.0445393212,
-0.0335726067,
0.0782433674,
0.016866792,
-0.0042354558,
0.0392989181,
-0.0103107626,
-0.0440652445,
0.0110528264,
-0.0185924098,
-0.0426505953,
0.0768323317,
0.0689960718,
-0.0388480164,
-0.023296535,
0.0141614638,
0.0219938997,
0.0649498031,
0.0244077984,
-0.0057964628,
0.0265137702,
-0.0187414624,
-0.0190301649,
-0.0034695829,
0.0317946635,
0.0105134714,
0.0088412631,
0.0174716376,
0.0308671705,
-0.0583303869,
-0.0132146208,
0.0195262861,
-0.0352858081,
-0.0101666991,
-0.0078162793,
-0.0043231407,
0.0216080416,
0.0462643132,
-0.0310307555,
-0.006282663,
0.0071932827,
-0.0318675749,
0.0315924399,
0.0800335556,
-0.055647362,
-0.0510509908,
0.031142896,
-0.0303322598,
-0.019205492,
-0.0389339179,
0.0039568306,
-0.046574045,
0.0098079508,
-0.0533809364,
0.0326829106,
-0.0339814164,
0.0336089134,
-0.023691494,
-0.0303498786,
-0.045949731,
0.0528364107,
0.0059544854,
0.0065068081,
0.0599272735,
0.0167989507,
0.0536878519,
0.0011558838,
-0.0257395934,
0.0049849888,
0.0391084887,
-0.0048198788,
0.0529523082,
0.0166787282,
-0.031500645,
-0.0102602402,
-0.1319395006,
0.0043763686,
-0.0500044487,
0.044202961,
0.0688196421,
0.040354982,
0.0017636945,
0.0091081932,
0.0467876345,
-0.0366496406,
-0.0142877558,
0.0148484567,
0.0375294499,
0.0201139227,
0.0239119567,
-0.0661756694,
0.0032934684,
0.0036196513,
0.0445695259,
0.039932441,
-0.0591442585,
-0.0449067727,
0.0463031121,
-0.0340688862,
-0.0145831052,
0.010921225,
-0.0325542837,
0.0473486222,
0.0199846178,
0.0550332256,
0.0364829451,
0.0020095522,
0.0549068376,
0.0295802187,
-0.0386533774,
-0.0480125025,
-0.012471824,
0.0113242567,
-0.0054968232,
-0.0200403389,
-0.0367401503,
0.004631754,
0.0488184094,
0.0227571875,
0.0067928038,
-0.0326155461,
-0.0052096257,
-0.0697501078,
-0.0627507493,
0.0148960873,
0.0230623819,
-0.0156762712,
0.0718976408,
-0.0143640898,
-0.0244628005,
0.0760760903,
-0.0333643295,
-0.0002291144,
-0.0749069601,
0.0144163435,
-0.0258088838,
0.0335935019,
-0.0520312823,
-0.0050590062,
-0.0526329949,
-0.0542118736,
-0.0183273498,
-0.00293797,
0.0473787971,
-0.0331754759,
0.0527307093,
-0.1145503893,
0.0172495898,
-0.0136352619,
-0.0119720958,
-0.0308400281,
-0.0074416334,
-0.0033820488,
0.0242983438,
0.0374532677,
-0.0196936671,
-0.0006467685,
0.0461240113,
0.0490523539,
0.0641799271,
-0.0004389943,
-0.0249526557,
-0.023314137,
0.0341360383,
0.0024514564,
0.0019732169,
0.0499508269,
-0.02765649,
0.0483129099,
0.0376652852,
0.0035700125,
-0.0410781763,
-0.0283373035,
-0.0394229479,
0.0019537471,
-0.01675676,
-0.059521582,
-0.0152588272,
0.0922557414,
-0.0639895573,
-0.0515402593,
0.1365837306,
0.0407215916,
-0.0351269022,
-0.0313869193,
-0.0321015269,
0.0258488022,
-0.0224115588,
-0.013733252,
-0.0978492945,
-0.0150631312,
0.0064148903,
0.0167761445,
0.0236925967,
-0.0118037295,
0.0081194891,
-0.0349473618,
0.0213657822,
0.0152721154,
-0.04415543,
0.0106373737,
-0.0069004493,
0.0443091877,
-0.008477536,
0.0478974469,
-0.0266326033,
-0.003198894,
0.0013259136,
-0.0059676818,
0.0201103613,
-0.0646475777,
-0.0092392992,
-0.0401394479,
0.0219396185,
0.0462457612,
0.0204998553,
0.0186785832,
-0.0060723508,
0.0113512054,
-0.0539377369,
0.0156280566,
-0.043703109,
0.009001961,
0.0018039045,
0.0119890645,
-0.0381734669,
0.0006635114,
-0.0115841599,
-0.0137851229,
-0.0118395872,
0.0209643636,
-0.0342608355,
0.0389984138,
-0.0235471129,
0.0103618,
0.0265618395,
0.0628696829,
0.0404011831,
-0.0518701375,
-0.0285827331,
-0.0098688565,
0.0086644078,
-0.0317638442,
0.0320472755,
-0.0489419326,
-0.0494643934,
-0.0373827852,
-0.090281643,
-0.0650808364,
0.0050860299,
0.0249947347,
-0.0004291436,
0.0485858396,
0.0010239629,
-0.0006299664,
-0.0009887413,
0.0040189684,
-0.0159014352,
0.0149515308,
-0.0167270936,
-0.0176168662,
0.0257569235,
0.0127126416,
-0.0004725216,
0.0186550152,
-0.0403537527,
-0.0745586529,
0.007698088,
-0.0100894403,
0.0229579452,
0.0389968865,
-0.0192847252,
-0.027060682,
0.0160541758,
-0.0144652436,
-0.0077308631,
0.0398011208,
0.0542456433,
0.0425432809,
-0.0094901137,
0.0284277163,
-0.0187534895,
0.0124143958,
-0.0166017655,
0.0565205924,
-0.0610346012,
-0.0495105423,
-0.0059985612,
-0.0238193143,
0.0463561676,
-0.0473937094,
-0.013824556,
-0.0104519455,
-0.0081098266,
-0.0664492399,
-0.0009564589,
-0.0285841189,
0.0018614634,
0.0031313759,
-0.0091625443,
-0.0325573012,
0.0353531986,
-0.0577533655,
0.0228147004,
-0.0113570178,
0.0173803773,
0.0060079205,
-0.0009077301,
-0.048509568,
0.0245495904,
-0.0000189809,
-0.0247412082,
-0.0109117944,
0.0342204496,
-0.024746567,
0.0799347758,
0.0094489185,
-0.0178357009,
0.032672286,
0.057962507,
-0.0478164405,
0.0755263641,
0.0077247536,
0.0094445189,
0.0729139,
-0.0226864573,
0.1256814003,
-0.0220012758,
0.0079672467,
-0.0110709686,
0.0788160115,
0.0143592758,
0.0344270319,
-0.023162473,
0.0125124194,
0.0107650608,
0.0454345271,
0.0606344156,
-0.0345119685,
-0.0179262068,
-0.0092024384,
-0.0217932202,
-0.0206894986,
0.0003906531,
-0.0508681722,
0.0161358491,
-0.0230446626,
-0.0092155701,
-0.0764823481,
-0.0416463427,
0.0283214636,
0.0272006337,
-0.0215980411,
-0.0108304275,
0.0259656645,
0.0710196048,
-0.0173959918,
-0.0221594814,
-0.0569053628,
0.0025010705,
-0.0046447027,
-0.0073840758,
-0.0813538954,
-6.08914192e-33,
-0.08068946,
-0.050840281,
-0.0052239639,
0.0176511128,
-0.0031450547,
0.0251871403,
-0.0502907857,
0.0014739587,
0.014689059,
0.0284416582,
-0.0076175998,
0.0261903182,
0.0253098439,
-0.0133143207,
-0.0216966402,
-0.0094907405,
0.0477953069,
0.0121951113,
-0.0355585627,
0.0176971182,
0.0507082902,
-0.0201780256,
0.0718604326,
-0.0956207588,
0.0702356771,
-0.0089774625,
0.0187250674,
0.0091232182,
0.0309801493,
0.0507203229,
0.0023953724,
0.0278443396,
0.0324546918,
-0.0004211663,
-0.0316684544,
0.0316401087,
-0.0970441177,
-0.024021307,
0.0808823258,
0.0313351713,
-0.022088103,
-0.0373845287,
0.024892509,
-0.0077880495,
-0.0292234104,
0.0136638293,
0.0199424345,
-0.0284150634,
-0.0183843058,
-0.0278848577,
-0.0740796626,
0.0404104404,
-0.0036833528,
0.0056093591,
0.0377194434,
0.024838319,
-0.0076140845,
-0.0000085088,
-0.0769193992,
0.0047086803,
-0.0100001628,
-0.0009441869,
0.0650215968,
0.0203888882,
0.0158176292,
0.0180696175,
-0.0189439002,
0.002377708,
0.0268309638,
-0.0394063517,
0.0455620363,
-0.0113503598,
0.0404477306,
0.0578479283,
0.0198651217,
0.0281763356,
-0.0452027284,
0.0239318777,
-0.0260744318,
0.028428033,
0.029917093,
0.0167529471,
-0.0552196726,
-0.0151995886,
-0.0634855404,
-0.0010612935,
-0.0061567212,
-0.0263439547,
-0.0082705598,
-0.0325051956,
-0.0481837541,
-0.0193003286,
0.0709989071,
-0.009422374,
-0.0098117543,
-0.0023098914,
-0.0049589588,
0.0395003408,
0.0023014622,
0.024043208,
-0.0207046829,
-0.0032714901,
0.0158960149,
0.0520355217,
0.0177371576,
-0.0392177701,
0.0125261024,
0.0081091244,
-0.024260819,
0.0225793887,
-0.0178126954,
-0.0013105681,
-0.0510182828,
-0.0170831289,
0.0235714335,
0.0083345035,
0.0038385899,
0.0467679985,
0.0458885506,
0.0026264056,
-0.048216369,
-0.0004764569,
-0.0212332737,
0.0204361938,
-0.0430673026,
0.0171320606,
-0.0033215848,
0.0592313595,
0.0471084416,
-0.0128560774,
-0.0160061568,
0.0271863714,
2.566e-7,
0.0879524797,
0.065457195,
0.0083866892,
-0.0031261449,
0.0385458991,
-0.003542132,
-0.007426667,
-0.0065416759,
0.0122517394,
-0.0085299369,
0.0273379628,
0.0099184299,
0.068350926,
0.0464938581,
-0.0282129031,
-0.050995782,
-0.0317824446,
0.0014978762,
-0.0275414623,
0.0165649466,
0.0528387316,
0.0407836437,
-0.0222397521,
0.0239591673,
-0.0494776219,
-0.0478316732,
0.0668120012,
-0.0510397069,
-0.0144589441,
0.0220544264,
0.0263516326,
0.0276714098,
-0.0102659417,
-0.0144283492,
-0.0122022759,
0.008220355,
0.0202424806,
0.0593921281,
0.0149528505,
-0.0383389108,
-0.005880292,
-0.041105058,
0.0166386161,
-0.0214232728,
0.0241615046,
-0.0272575263,
0.0125222802,
-0.0192267466,
0.0033513054,
0.0001723154,
0.021263754,
0.0048120101,
-0.051582776,
0.0304854214,
0.0075402884,
-0.0032724193,
-0.0422906131,
-0.0472444296,
-0.0234847926,
0.0080627333,
-0.0188948903,
-0.0388280079,
0.0065105972,
-0.0594676994,
-0.0357206874,
-0.0261464659,
0.0078196097,
2.277948488e-34,
0.0656321496,
-0.0110753337,
0.0066945916,
0.0264645107,
0.0360005833,
-0.0128803095,
-0.02440813,
-0.006918198,
0.021696765,
-0.0679693148,
0.0128470603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01812v1 | Distilling LLMs' Decomposition Abilities into Compact Language Models | 2024-02-02T13:23:15 | 2024-02-02T13:23:15 | Denis Tarasov, Kumar Shridhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated proficiency in their reasoning
abilities, yet their large size presents scalability challenges and limits any
further customization. In contrast, compact models offer customized training
but often fall short in solving complex reasoning tasks. This study focuses on
distilling the LLMs' decomposition skills into compact models using offline
reinforcement learning. We leverage the advancements in the LLM`s capabilities
to provide feedback and generate a specialized task-specific dataset for
training compact models. The development of an AI-generated dataset and the
establishment of baselines constitute the primary contributions of our work,
underscoring the potential of compact models in replicating complex
problem-solving skills. | Distilling LLMs' Decomposition Abilities into Compact Language Models: Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated proficiency in their reasoning
abilities, yet their large size presents scalability challenges and limits any
further customization. In contrast, compact models offer customized training
but often fall short in solving complex reasoning tasks. This study focuses on
distilling the LLMs' decomposition skills into compact models using offline
reinforcement learning. We leverage the advancements in the LLM`s capabilities
to provide feedback and generate a specialized task-specific dataset for
training compact models. The development of an AI-generated dataset and the
establishment of baselines constitute the primary contributions of our work,
underscoring the potential of compact models in replicating complex
problem-solving skills. | [
0.0244825557,
0.0607212372,
-0.0301890559,
-0.0063131643,
-0.0495212004,
0.0301803164,
0.0243869051,
0.0178750046,
-0.0340247341,
-0.0035807514,
-0.0024887903,
0.0057175965,
-0.0067039924,
0.0292898118,
-0.0170032736,
-0.0165257007,
0.0282611102,
-0.0685492679,
0.002676931,
0.0043182722,
-0.0247362219,
0.0353204533,
-0.0260391086,
0.0633001029,
0.0284074415,
-0.0269890465,
-0.0440224446,
-0.0181894507,
-0.0158160757,
0.0105492845,
-0.0087323943,
0.024730375,
0.0724627674,
0.0311201792,
0.0000018498,
-0.037403021,
-0.0205434039,
-0.0325300023,
-0.0627296716,
-0.0180318188,
0.0143681876,
-0.0164511967,
0.0048736674,
0.0285124667,
-0.0529167987,
-0.0263693966,
0.0137734339,
0.0421084352,
0.0525904968,
0.090827018,
0.0175275523,
-0.011633629,
0.0182126537,
-0.0262072049,
0.0172215998,
-0.0323606431,
0.0036959765,
0.0603463873,
0.0279144086,
-0.0321408622,
-0.0066367537,
-0.0156914257,
0.0549708009,
0.0230835937,
-0.0390968807,
0.0346098766,
-0.0312647521,
-0.0213059206,
0.0010741914,
0.0368122943,
-0.0611678101,
-0.0178085249,
-0.0056326543,
-0.028659353,
0.0021830448,
0.0004540586,
-0.0476206988,
0.0596429557,
-0.0011129639,
0.052500084,
0.0122942561,
-0.0480539761,
0.0215542819,
0.0167586356,
-0.042142231,
0.0917902663,
-0.0180349462,
-0.0417454094,
-0.0007105845,
-0.0188353453,
-0.0556685627,
-0.0344725698,
-0.0093256487,
0.0650480688,
-0.056621667,
0.0283040628,
-0.0366084501,
-0.0173211657,
0.0003597009,
-0.0023791546,
0.0944786891,
0.0171049498,
0.0441968292,
0.0570829362,
-0.0200359393,
0.0744357482,
-0.0023258496,
0.023159055,
-0.0220648479,
-0.0020326299,
-0.0804968327,
-0.0195872337,
-0.0342567302,
0.0617405549,
-0.0309974384,
0.0078669116,
-0.0148337986,
0.0187115949,
-0.0154210124,
0.049538184,
0.0383006148,
0.0018278696,
-0.039737381,
-0.0203537196,
-0.0620422401,
0.0147177977,
-0.0387090854,
0.0550361685,
0.0106655629,
-0.0518822707,
0.0014134741,
-0.0138993179,
-0.0083867246,
-0.0287519842,
0.0340604521,
0.0729617029,
-0.0094678123,
-0.03930071,
-0.0266763922,
-0.0275706965,
0.0255433172,
-0.0812152326,
0.008471258,
-0.0827366859,
0.0470765494,
-0.0335836709,
-0.0167891122,
-0.0454200506,
0.0052679772,
0.0227921791,
0.0048435493,
0.0701870844,
0.041302748,
0.0303170774,
0.0178150833,
-0.0075411811,
-0.0038198098,
0.0879346132,
0.0180303734,
0.0115306349,
0.0113094952,
-0.0101458048,
0.0167610012,
0.0340636447,
0.0268244892,
0.0216834601,
-0.0611384138,
0.0119148996,
-0.0111149196,
0.0346965194,
0.0111771077,
0.0274409931,
-0.0382189117,
0.0272204094,
0.0552404039,
0.0613516346,
0.0393857807,
0.0296743475,
0.027228659,
0.0240423437,
-0.0110654868,
-0.0105562611,
-0.0500972681,
0.0196472928,
-0.0179007966,
0.0289024729,
-0.0367791094,
0.0272271745,
-0.0311929528,
-0.0545059443,
-0.0059278272,
0.0114058843,
0.0095895911,
0.0282879733,
0.0539271124,
0.017934354,
-0.0158504415,
0.0414064676,
0.0238328576,
-0.0382421464,
0.0023947551,
-0.0847781524,
0.0409172736,
0.0457856059,
0.0734774396,
-0.0241296962,
-0.0342083909,
-0.0165172927,
-0.0372522064,
0.0320333801,
-0.0076795956,
-0.0274417624,
0.0003727794,
-0.0508134328,
-0.0290918648,
-0.0276829787,
0.0250730105,
-0.0010818269,
0.0439992771,
-0.0040698876,
-0.0053099948,
-0.0256407689,
-0.0365987681,
0.0417380407,
-0.0554134138,
-0.0381436385,
0.0069626011,
0.0060031423,
0.0232559238,
-0.017236175,
-0.0014788511,
0.0056888498,
0.0332038328,
-0.0296294969,
-0.005797897,
-0.0204061344,
-0.0204396416,
-0.0588375032,
0.043164596,
-0.0339437388,
0.0196235385,
0.0598173663,
-0.0518029965,
-0.0241345689,
-0.0061988286,
-0.0210167579,
0.0189563408,
-0.0401487611,
-0.0025729055,
-0.0090889689,
-0.0025941911,
-0.004054883,
0.0765134692,
-0.0554402173,
0.0349822305,
0.0290007759,
-0.0326958634,
-0.0258215554,
-0.0622252785,
0.0149865868,
-0.0022961739,
-0.0081538958,
0.020068258,
-0.002630085,
0.0519084185,
-0.0162833575,
-0.0320711844,
-0.0385317318,
-0.0125244809,
-0.0105502103,
0.0139754657,
0.0454711504,
-0.009356495,
0.0021650754,
-0.0024277265,
-0.012011881,
-0.0065549063,
0.0526699387,
0.0055193971,
0.034353599,
0.0075826766,
-0.0295499377,
-0.0235247053,
-0.0385468788,
-0.0085362354,
0.0268468224,
-0.0558421426,
0.0254007634,
-0.0572846346,
0.0262885503,
-0.0245635714,
0.0487359464,
-0.0111091686,
-0.0463816822,
0.0190491118,
-0.0519495383,
0.0181108266,
0.1001805589,
0.0030882473,
0.0518709272,
0.1040504947,
0.006583794,
-0.0629649684,
0.0298229903,
-0.0278421454,
-0.0255195517,
-0.047376629,
-0.037488386,
-0.0015153275,
0.087680459,
-0.0209808666,
0.0146940993,
-0.0581535548,
0.0029930335,
0.0069823032,
-0.0365431979,
-0.0379108004,
0.0043529575,
-0.0219288338,
0.0543977506,
-0.0448132567,
-0.0515793227,
0.086487174,
0.0121047068,
-0.0153423203,
-0.0352613181,
-0.0418028906,
-0.0400832556,
0.0811734498,
-0.0025128115,
-0.0079511702,
-0.0154361501,
-0.0118669393,
-0.0827006176,
-0.0349813402,
0.026125297,
-0.0268784333,
0.0362138562,
-0.0436343998,
-0.0018292131,
0.000998826,
-0.0336066075,
-0.0474706925,
-0.0143111134,
-0.0290579945,
0.0195589382,
-0.0001366114,
-0.0016723482,
-0.0518058725,
0.0056279143,
0.0307477303,
0.0334876142,
0.0071160817,
-0.0014373179,
-0.028350452,
0.0163449459,
0.0653021038,
0.0581754297,
0.0191774294,
-0.0409196094,
0.0440524183,
0.0370245725,
0.057642024,
-0.0230621491,
-0.0036732429,
0.0438043922,
0.0239321087,
-0.0297802519,
0.0089092981,
0.0421241112,
0.0094653713,
-0.0761024356,
-0.0483661927,
0.1051916704,
0.0410056077,
-0.0368254744,
0.0141226724,
-0.0400238074,
0.0320793428,
0.024855217,
0.0489410087,
-0.0566198044,
-0.0213032365,
0.009227898,
0.0131828487,
0.0111082988,
-0.0222353879,
-0.0168709271,
-0.1325613707,
0.0146126607,
0.0227948651,
-0.0155692184,
-0.0072584124,
-0.0310560912,
-0.0222010445,
-0.0118825734,
0.0373948775,
0.0330936424,
-0.0090866657,
-0.0333543941,
0.0087270346,
-0.0080442177,
-0.0385706052,
0.0360165983,
-0.0018922826,
0.0660605207,
0.0434200913,
0.0222498327,
0.0060770325,
-0.0360354744,
0.0333931781,
0.020321304,
0.0147775961,
-0.0057744971,
0.0042314734,
-0.0069039511,
0.0120653156,
-0.0028034425,
0.0541109778,
-0.0375974104,
-0.0256565306,
0.022322759,
0.1119487137,
-0.0350554101,
-0.0124492077,
-0.0076647564,
-0.0290396363,
0.0021179926,
0.0633904785,
0.0333850756,
-0.0387542397,
-0.069151558,
-0.0013875365,
-0.0418312885,
-0.0401577801,
-0.0220800936,
-0.0016139313,
-0.0009015193,
0.0226390753,
-0.0275593661,
-0.0323689952,
0.0370335132,
0.0533844717,
-0.0180584043,
-0.0267593488,
0.0151318694,
0.0421960652,
-0.0461150855,
0.0207119994,
-0.0373274274,
0.0061374148,
-0.0320060924,
0.0144966953,
0.0058439318,
-0.0497797765,
-0.024871679,
-0.0367000364,
-0.0942754447,
-0.0532083623,
-0.0010901988,
0.0470472313,
0.0342141837,
0.0448615514,
-0.001966797,
-0.0613704287,
0.0371545404,
-0.0077987495,
-0.0737700313,
0.0230555944,
0.0402877405,
-0.0103461966,
0.0314038247,
0.0535234027,
-0.0311651379,
0.0232843459,
-0.0096219266,
0.0422658399,
-0.0277766772,
0.0199289322,
0.0303224158,
-0.0029059926,
-0.0238952246,
0.0085811615,
-0.0135717038,
-0.0296164155,
0.0608779006,
-0.0158522855,
-0.0111163659,
-0.0269129518,
0.0072093955,
0.0349860713,
0.010246533,
0.0224513449,
-0.0038535104,
0.0003596653,
0.0407257676,
-0.0098700719,
0.017770499,
0.0442876369,
0.0251272805,
0.0360908583,
0.0060631246,
-0.0113889379,
0.0082995845,
-0.0334708579,
0.0131087471,
0.0033275695,
0.0440465137,
0.0238045398,
0.019402368,
-0.0700236782,
0.011911042,
-0.0473224819,
-0.0614847615,
0.0177120306,
0.0093963519,
0.0543175898,
0.0202009995,
-0.0006438791,
-0.0232905578,
0.0003181419,
-0.0079394588,
-0.0138189951,
-0.0098898904,
-0.0084775155,
0.0320570469,
0.043689575,
0.0045293705,
-0.0194681659,
0.0932739452,
0.0155555299,
0.0519068018,
-0.0206960756,
0.051052589,
-0.0405368842,
-0.0144539755,
-0.0323495194,
0.0540539622,
-0.0247199163,
-0.0121797705,
-0.0325634815,
-0.075626947,
-0.0163201466,
0.0414923355,
-0.0096991463,
-0.008138679,
0.0265567824,
0.0431844071,
0.0091027124,
-0.010339288,
-0.0066473586,
0.0054536164,
-0.0095690424,
-0.0321727581,
-0.0336484984,
-5.908938269e-33,
-0.0101695554,
-0.0248349998,
0.0628966093,
-0.0453726463,
-0.024503218,
0.0105752964,
-0.0146275908,
0.0037468034,
-0.00934627,
-0.0009782814,
-0.0392454639,
0.0392076336,
-0.0048722127,
0.0399914198,
0.0132391267,
-0.0223129373,
0.0177623183,
-0.0341456421,
-0.0369672216,
0.018799603,
0.0339116678,
-0.0126001565,
0.0355681926,
0.0017834299,
-0.0384505913,
0.0021423453,
-0.0328942537,
0.0679775327,
-0.033820767,
0.0939143151,
-0.0234046336,
-0.0005471209,
0.0413162746,
-0.0429697931,
-0.0147664696,
0.0247377623,
-0.0795702487,
-0.0496510081,
0.0363010764,
-0.0221937615,
-0.0385954268,
-0.0241297819,
0.0189459864,
0.0042484975,
-0.0068497905,
-0.001432933,
0.003855818,
-0.0641498268,
-0.0218298659,
0.0005167268,
-0.0141073763,
-0.0244685803,
-0.0193191376,
-0.0152928885,
0.0432900116,
0.0200781152,
-0.039680697,
-0.0044296021,
0.0149953095,
0.0302683841,
0.0252968855,
0.0391730256,
0.0710484684,
0.0046194727,
0.003465367,
0.0381917171,
-0.01580102,
0.0069586844,
-0.0504417457,
-0.0233773515,
0.0568409003,
0.0845193714,
0.0152091375,
0.0040740441,
0.0172641706,
0.0003128477,
-0.0540075526,
0.0063492646,
0.0537785962,
0.0751030073,
0.0418416262,
0.0071311407,
-0.0240677856,
-0.0024422552,
-0.0460396186,
-0.0095126899,
-0.0351342112,
-0.0274484139,
0.0390746109,
0.0426534042,
-0.0243600551,
-0.069038868,
0.0292890165,
-0.047927808,
0.0078849094,
0.0411643609,
-0.0103222681,
0.0162484795,
0.0089138662,
-0.0126986969,
-0.0644442439,
-0.0568090081,
0.0027353598,
-0.0150128035,
-0.0021122985,
-0.0016717754,
-0.0044099772,
0.0427049398,
-0.0703146756,
-0.0098708346,
-0.0407389589,
0.0401055962,
0.0051282141,
0.0347001515,
0.0690106302,
-0.0008258764,
-0.0126025043,
0.0134104704,
-0.0132432487,
-0.0614334121,
-0.0212017223,
0.0236250535,
0.002873729,
0.0542443469,
-0.0178993046,
-0.0094360886,
-0.0603462309,
-0.0030559832,
0.0456663445,
-0.0209892578,
0.0028952244,
0.027475968,
2.495e-7,
-0.01896617,
0.0357949995,
0.015164909,
0.0320229009,
0.0318187512,
0.0160672609,
-0.0314905234,
-0.0251037292,
-0.0100942915,
-0.0157857426,
0.0426916704,
0.0570560768,
0.0443741791,
0.0270408541,
-0.0490212142,
0.0258387383,
-0.0461629964,
-0.016626168,
-0.0704205036,
-0.0268412698,
0.0011287038,
0.1072448418,
0.0330150314,
-0.0305134039,
-0.0233914368,
-0.0047207256,
0.0207190756,
-0.0313692875,
0.0018455789,
-0.0303465985,
0.015757788,
0.0348138213,
-0.012835877,
0.0048447535,
0.009517597,
0.0374511108,
-0.0379315838,
0.0933110863,
0.0136520676,
-0.0387419872,
-0.0211105961,
-0.0268761516,
-0.0045666532,
-0.0339502357,
0.0713009387,
-0.0631074756,
-0.0129450159,
-0.023585584,
0.0056526246,
-0.0167421885,
-0.0360993966,
-0.0258967504,
0.0205833185,
0.0229587704,
0.0085789571,
-0.0003224373,
0.0198671091,
-0.0901254788,
-0.0054765255,
0.0606004186,
-0.0286571868,
-0.0468778759,
-0.0485271849,
0.0076462473,
0.0408626087,
-0.0618475787,
-0.0202046912,
2.501854907e-34,
0.0118930144,
-0.0028347271,
0.0230191387,
0.069627963,
0.0015655798,
-0.0306787156,
-0.002691993,
0.016518699,
0.0424797498,
-0.0958246812,
-0.021754615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01391v2 | StepCoder: Improve Code Generation with Reinforcement Learning from Compiler Feedback | 2024-02-02T13:14:31 | 2024-02-05T13:28:23 | Shihan Dou, Yan Liu, Haoxiang Jia, Limao Xiong, Enyu Zhou, Wei Shen, Junjie Shan, Caishuang Huang, Xiao Wang, Xiaoran Fan, Zhiheng Xi, Yuhao Zhou, Tao Ji, Rui Zheng, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Tao Gui | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly propelled
the field of code generation. Previous work integrated reinforcement learning
(RL) with compiler feedback for exploring the output space of LLMs to enhance
code generation quality. However, the lengthy code generated by LLMs in
response to complex human requirements makes RL exploration a challenge. Also,
since the unit tests may not cover the complicated code, optimizing LLMs by
using these unexecuted code snippets is ineffective. To tackle these
challenges, we introduce StepCoder, a novel RL framework for code generation,
consisting of two main components: CCCS addresses the exploration challenge by
breaking the long sequences code generation task into a Curriculum of Code
Completion Subtasks, while FGO only optimizes the model by masking the
unexecuted code segments to provide Fine-Grained Optimization. In addition, we
furthermore construct the APPS+ dataset for RL training, which is manually
verified to ensure the correctness of unit tests. Experimental results show
that our method improves the ability to explore the output space and
outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in corresponding benchmarks. Our
dataset APPS+ and StepCoder are available online. | StepCoder: Improve Code Generation with Reinforcement Learning from Compiler Feedback: The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly propelled
the field of code generation. Previous work integrated reinforcement learning
(RL) with compiler feedback for exploring the output space of LLMs to enhance
code generation quality. However, the lengthy code generated by LLMs in
response to complex human requirements makes RL exploration a challenge. Also,
since the unit tests may not cover the complicated code, optimizing LLMs by
using these unexecuted code snippets is ineffective. To tackle these
challenges, we introduce StepCoder, a novel RL framework for code generation,
consisting of two main components: CCCS addresses the exploration challenge by
breaking the long sequences code generation task into a Curriculum of Code
Completion Subtasks, while FGO only optimizes the model by masking the
unexecuted code segments to provide Fine-Grained Optimization. In addition, we
furthermore construct the APPS+ dataset for RL training, which is manually
verified to ensure the correctness of unit tests. Experimental results show
that our method improves the ability to explore the output space and
outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in corresponding benchmarks. Our
dataset APPS+ and StepCoder are available online. | [
0.000011608,
0.075938046,
-0.0261998046,
-0.0070111277,
-0.0103936596,
0.0024879486,
-0.052993495,
0.0012006167,
-0.015146913,
0.0256645847,
0.0047209212,
0.0226513632,
0.0010767874,
0.0319671296,
0.0260479636,
-0.0180589743,
-0.0017836711,
-0.0460651554,
-0.0531873778,
0.0075900452,
-0.023644438,
0.0148723191,
0.0197991561,
0.0567800738,
0.0190886576,
-0.0240718927,
-0.0200387873,
0.0350110382,
-0.0127857067,
-0.0387424193,
0.0305238236,
0.0464752018,
0.0106464708,
0.0263774209,
0.0000024258,
-0.0384137109,
0.0060524601,
-0.0041611143,
0.0126105472,
0.0275178645,
-0.0053894408,
-0.0011044745,
-0.0062090531,
0.0317425281,
-0.0259366278,
-0.0395001136,
0.0298459828,
-0.0263704173,
0.053530965,
0.0813154206,
0.0325925685,
-0.0077703316,
-0.0085224649,
-0.0199935902,
0.0597263314,
0.0015968209,
-0.008809546,
0.0343350843,
0.0520024896,
-0.0324636176,
-0.0217589028,
-0.0166960005,
0.0580710024,
-0.0113483826,
-0.0375579782,
0.0740389228,
-0.0102504995,
-0.0150667783,
0.0021472625,
0.0251717865,
-0.090521276,
-0.0298913661,
0.0384171978,
-0.0139643066,
-0.0271097235,
-0.0363016874,
-0.0063040801,
0.0359985605,
-0.0334890969,
0.0025866549,
0.0079168808,
-0.0353124067,
0.0023056071,
0.0017419541,
-0.0336656235,
0.0294929799,
-0.0049391547,
-0.0280213971,
-0.0289564785,
0.0052160039,
0.0409879163,
-0.047891017,
-0.0514682159,
0.0416203141,
-0.0683825761,
-0.0007260714,
-0.0578690544,
-0.0047426964,
0.0184245463,
-0.0169581994,
0.0404784195,
0.0284818057,
-0.0038963433,
-0.0062336358,
-0.0745177045,
0.0522330664,
-0.0130271055,
-0.0175572243,
-0.0431648977,
0.0451801531,
-0.0350862704,
0.0253957696,
-0.030803185,
0.0484187081,
-0.0070289117,
0.0265545417,
-0.0626142323,
0.0332359001,
0.0117970714,
0.0970205367,
0.0057687117,
-0.013611964,
-0.0374524035,
0.0209701136,
0.0304764733,
-0.0200481489,
-0.0380173028,
-0.0699716806,
0.0193015467,
-0.0607768781,
-0.0050829863,
0.0184832029,
-0.0301634502,
-0.0301171429,
0.018714346,
0.0673956499,
-0.0025011047,
0.0075558079,
-0.0204071458,
-0.0423000082,
0.0189227778,
-0.062087018,
0.0006952843,
-0.1023580059,
-0.0401511788,
0.003406157,
-0.0334035009,
-0.0215393379,
0.0177264791,
0.0011825716,
0.0312230494,
0.0078954557,
-0.0213988498,
0.0107050072,
0.0049108202,
0.0118879694,
-0.0103790415,
0.0662083179,
0.0483315624,
0.0418811515,
-0.0200545974,
-0.0265439954,
0.0419201739,
0.040887218,
0.0123530384,
0.0123829516,
-0.0025241016,
0.0271395892,
0.0066392086,
0.0154709229,
0.0368362702,
0.0153465439,
-0.0179696828,
0.0215751901,
-0.0149627337,
0.0157146621,
0.0112921521,
0.0384265408,
0.0784678757,
0.0311515331,
-0.0143013271,
-0.0034046164,
-0.019358702,
0.0506109372,
0.0119814742,
0.038927123,
0.0026010084,
0.0662340224,
-0.0074792751,
-0.0605800673,
0.0206269957,
-0.0073735416,
0.0113205016,
0.0355680138,
0.0346689783,
0.0013561809,
-0.0778951347,
-0.0200196672,
0.0195841435,
-0.0725245848,
-0.0297732297,
-0.0526592545,
0.0864206553,
0.0376982987,
0.0403468683,
-0.0343833789,
-0.0128327552,
-0.0329493321,
-0.0055826749,
0.0046217199,
0.0217220765,
0.0020326439,
0.0051817195,
-0.0555616133,
-0.0235984642,
-0.0260059014,
-0.0086161327,
0.0669388399,
0.0685568303,
-0.0330769978,
0.0308109839,
0.0141452691,
-0.0912181512,
0.0334068313,
-0.0214610603,
-0.0053608394,
0.0498983003,
-0.0232045408,
0.0210959744,
-0.0456549861,
-0.04773679,
0.00340132,
0.0337256677,
-0.0185705256,
-0.0166277606,
-0.0347484984,
-0.049384214,
-0.0684528127,
-0.0066034221,
-0.0415563248,
-0.047599148,
0.0049104076,
-0.056460388,
-0.0043985904,
0.0301895179,
-0.0199443214,
0.025961617,
0.01379734,
0.0127536189,
-0.0138839893,
0.014567364,
-0.0182773918,
0.0466296859,
-0.0287322588,
0.0255369619,
-0.0104203941,
0.0635016188,
-0.0009924977,
0.0155787263,
0.0199186709,
0.0109542552,
-0.0357066579,
0.0265978724,
0.019333601,
0.0778333768,
-0.015914645,
-0.0529190712,
-0.0588454641,
0.0432346389,
-0.0227292776,
0.0226481836,
0.0046108402,
0.0475923531,
-0.0019304904,
-0.0003536798,
-0.0029825815,
-0.0115406718,
0.0350092202,
0.0010978107,
-0.0034885886,
-0.0226518251,
-0.0421922468,
-0.021151226,
-0.0132686179,
-0.01137345,
0.0338648781,
-0.0416524187,
0.0391809866,
-0.068678081,
0.0497474708,
0.0336228013,
0.0189914964,
-0.0245821644,
-0.045484338,
0.015115154,
-0.0582444668,
0.0570609234,
0.0516269989,
-0.0049696537,
0.0329478048,
0.0252145343,
-0.0012631782,
-0.0641337782,
0.0380280986,
0.0078467829,
-0.0569202304,
-0.0188964661,
-0.0321455225,
0.0557790734,
0.0659197569,
0.0004928794,
-0.0123773757,
-0.0601166077,
0.033980865,
0.0121894181,
-0.0133432476,
0.0375399739,
0.004099248,
-0.0236502737,
0.0477185547,
-0.0404736772,
-0.0836898908,
0.0638669133,
-0.0224413276,
-0.012492639,
-0.026447149,
-0.0286898483,
-0.0610872731,
0.009194958,
0.0197850894,
0.02875554,
-0.0190915149,
-0.0278242752,
-0.0075081876,
-0.0008668472,
-0.0169463698,
-0.0328763351,
0.0654814392,
-0.0184602868,
-0.0033991253,
0.0008668312,
-0.0349148586,
-0.0472094715,
0.0365388319,
0.0084989499,
-0.0158891696,
0.0191578194,
-0.0231359936,
0.0442951024,
-0.0086498559,
0.0121513773,
0.057871215,
-0.0027639107,
-0.040787261,
0.0005890593,
-0.0256481431,
-0.0054470254,
-0.0527552404,
-0.0012092931,
-0.0367436111,
-0.0083820252,
0.0053933584,
0.0670522377,
0.0635696948,
-0.0690141246,
0.0171371922,
0.0355129763,
-0.0176158566,
-0.0011079778,
0.0811860859,
0.0573656149,
-0.0713677481,
-0.0536492504,
0.0893492401,
0.0204023123,
-0.0457319617,
0.0099830553,
0.0007166112,
0.1009442732,
0.0667712614,
0.0682935193,
-0.0708172023,
-0.0109503567,
-0.0025356982,
0.0350713134,
-0.0192597583,
-0.0033858551,
-0.0179153979,
-0.1322353333,
0.0381954089,
0.0145054972,
-0.0195050463,
-0.0322396271,
-0.0206943974,
-0.0344025269,
0.0206909534,
-0.0438906364,
0.0574847981,
-0.010857041,
0.0276445523,
0.0056554847,
-0.0312261637,
-0.0115879811,
0.0250175688,
-0.0329991318,
0.0270710289,
0.1405014694,
-0.0016321017,
0.0036812851,
0.0114459246,
0.0170777161,
0.0120891146,
0.0058496157,
-0.0410578176,
0.0120751588,
0.0152870594,
-0.009100209,
0.0467961952,
0.0359362774,
-0.0366780981,
-0.0140368184,
0.0726320893,
0.0443770997,
0.0144250598,
-0.0400324985,
-0.0150068756,
-0.0090414295,
0.0086639067,
0.0239520483,
0.0302726235,
-0.0397045612,
-0.0556706935,
-0.0666364357,
-0.0257289596,
-0.076171793,
0.0135737518,
-0.0149169806,
-0.0016054404,
0.0175126288,
-0.0262723211,
0.001473038,
0.0068071885,
0.024203429,
0.003951571,
-0.0445231795,
0.0024279351,
-0.0156297497,
-0.0741841346,
-0.0002713759,
-0.0204704367,
0.018078845,
-0.0331168845,
-0.0073460992,
-0.0176275503,
-0.0354833603,
0.0125640547,
0.0257265307,
-0.0743795633,
-0.0655002072,
-0.0587024428,
0.0938617215,
0.0096772257,
0.0697405264,
-0.0312203579,
-0.037193954,
0.008541028,
-0.0189386457,
-0.0216575302,
0.0091654332,
0.0225040391,
0.0060817511,
0.0183989648,
-0.0186993647,
-0.0661403015,
0.0044798795,
0.0272298045,
-0.0045870845,
0.0152613902,
0.0121131539,
0.0362039432,
-0.037625283,
-0.0075472859,
-0.005380183,
-0.0117987944,
0.0120420773,
-0.0008082127,
0.0066336365,
-0.0209326874,
-0.0351521075,
0.0245832447,
0.0244733375,
-0.011465461,
0.0459140167,
-0.0095653497,
-0.0099545931,
0.0721888095,
-0.0151107162,
0.0612306036,
-0.0105422465,
0.0340526477,
0.1169488132,
-0.0053460714,
-0.0053970935,
0.034603104,
0.0099373646,
0.0225984361,
0.0146473898,
0.0684327781,
0.0248065274,
0.0549773462,
0.0406205356,
-0.012040318,
-0.0155306766,
-0.0463366508,
-0.0397545993,
0.0174136665,
0.0389043652,
0.0489173904,
0.0226935055,
-0.0256795343,
0.0278383121,
-0.0113194743,
0.0349843465,
-0.0452004373,
-0.0526078679,
0.0200768448,
0.0270693228,
-0.0077788313,
-0.0494321361,
0.1002105325,
0.0198780242,
0.0097828535,
-0.0074096718,
0.0159218777,
-0.0382127278,
-0.0049837376,
0.0402888544,
-0.0072190114,
0.0037290305,
-0.0118932854,
0.0001568423,
-0.0417889878,
-0.012256884,
0.0639909133,
0.0360862315,
0.0009155627,
0.0371471979,
0.0489509068,
-0.0129107824,
-0.0049158777,
-0.035019394,
-0.0140931681,
-0.0019418795,
-0.0694803521,
-0.0088031981,
-6.369952459e-33,
-0.0166645739,
-0.0196228363,
0.02377267,
0.0082798759,
-0.0155827142,
-0.0229323246,
-0.0517696515,
-0.0179398041,
0.0456605554,
-0.0371057279,
0.0292692054,
0.0155427968,
-0.0210245606,
0.018019937,
0.0480460972,
0.0280514788,
0.0683255717,
0.0205383375,
-0.0641482472,
0.0423548333,
-0.0732747465,
0.0356647745,
-0.0255844761,
-0.0249368567,
-0.0654247776,
0.0016024176,
0.0291338563,
0.0002994711,
-0.0071477825,
0.0382895134,
0.0267513897,
-0.002778884,
-0.0169643443,
-0.0488334857,
-0.0415442586,
0.0009595628,
-0.0437825434,
-0.0401573777,
-0.0014221665,
0.0113234334,
-0.0299104955,
-0.0739670619,
0.0532771721,
0.0064720409,
-0.011717231,
0.0007707638,
0.0057650236,
0.0162661336,
-0.0102039315,
-0.0466486961,
-0.0552805103,
0.0298394617,
-0.0278190095,
-0.0248190481,
-0.0065385047,
0.0378265344,
-0.026031835,
0.0127864005,
0.0339324847,
0.0076563722,
0.0308715738,
0.0716603994,
0.0668947101,
0.0403859541,
0.0256266426,
-0.01316131,
0.0411651246,
0.0055037006,
-0.0277979821,
0.0137513718,
0.0405034125,
0.032098338,
-0.0108644245,
0.0296711307,
0.0047581336,
-0.0089377528,
-0.0179792233,
-0.0004319022,
0.01025433,
0.0386494659,
0.048308976,
0.0081705302,
-0.0214345921,
-0.0163864121,
-0.0600021891,
-0.0024572031,
-0.0121671809,
-0.0560485572,
0.0549685173,
0.0271819085,
-0.0248853788,
-0.026516743,
0.0186914615,
-0.0148683917,
-0.0049076593,
0.0347529463,
-0.0763801485,
0.0211828202,
-0.0287446231,
-0.0013645778,
-0.0118002268,
-0.0396590605,
0.0210530777,
-0.0486422554,
0.0585928932,
0.0315501206,
0.0216729604,
0.0087795565,
-0.0678475052,
0.0190333128,
-0.0789606199,
0.0327629484,
-0.0120569058,
0.0283301733,
0.0108188633,
-0.0129698291,
-0.0046540969,
0.0503179431,
-0.0060381629,
-0.0394377634,
-0.0421424173,
-0.0122049963,
0.0153632984,
0.0260481648,
-0.0400679447,
-0.0222943109,
-0.0583136864,
0.0408789627,
0.0139757879,
-0.0498803258,
-0.0615385324,
0.0356405601,
3.031e-7,
-0.0548793077,
0.0451574139,
0.0122596715,
0.0544849448,
-0.0005186884,
0.036249876,
-0.0091806957,
-0.0014608243,
0.0203963686,
0.0050225556,
-0.0265006498,
0.0047878888,
0.0461248681,
0.0075867381,
-0.0497419313,
0.0263339821,
-0.0187040381,
0.0187435206,
-0.0715497658,
-0.0174831022,
-0.0067266389,
0.058711715,
-0.0001761619,
0.0155811058,
0.055441834,
0.0243645888,
0.009146492,
-0.0104437834,
-0.0050443043,
0.011464254,
-0.0818831176,
0.028751811,
-0.0135319866,
-0.034826722,
-0.0117336381,
-0.0061053499,
-0.0154620353,
0.054017812,
0.0229659956,
0.0423951596,
0.0779191479,
0.0069190557,
-0.0088137221,
-0.0587150902,
0.0358228572,
-0.0561226755,
0.0221877601,
-0.0384180248,
0.0028521502,
-0.0177584179,
-0.0210457221,
-0.0348071046,
0.0361403264,
-0.0146054458,
0.0019963854,
-0.0127873132,
-0.0380791612,
-0.0147603545,
-0.0448876768,
0.0264266487,
-0.0137042981,
-0.0199259184,
-0.0706120133,
0.0617707558,
-0.037863072,
-0.0378173478,
-0.0059546391,
3.109309291e-34,
0.0090277232,
-0.0437445268,
0.0100041367,
0.0077224458,
0.0434860252,
-0.0283067599,
-0.0348850973,
0.0547493696,
0.036358308,
0.0049050651,
-0.0446162857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01383v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01383v2 | LLM-based NLG Evaluation: Current Status and Challenges | 2024-02-02T13:06:35 | 2024-02-26T14:55:48 | Mingqi Gao, Xinyu Hu, Jie Ruan, Xiao Pu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating natural language generation (NLG) is a vital but challenging
problem in artificial intelligence. Traditional evaluation metrics mainly
capturing content (e.g. n-gram) overlap between system outputs and references
are far from satisfactory, and large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT
have demonstrated great potential in NLG evaluation in recent years. Various
automatic evaluation methods based on LLMs have been proposed, including
metrics derived from LLMs, prompting LLMs, and fine-tuning LLMs with labeled
evaluation data. In this survey, we first give a taxonomy of LLM-based NLG
evaluation methods, and discuss their pros and cons, respectively. We also
discuss human-LLM collaboration for NLG evaluation. Lastly, we discuss several
open problems in this area and point out future research directions. | LLM-based NLG Evaluation: Current Status and Challenges: Evaluating natural language generation (NLG) is a vital but challenging
problem in artificial intelligence. Traditional evaluation metrics mainly
capturing content (e.g. n-gram) overlap between system outputs and references
are far from satisfactory, and large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT
have demonstrated great potential in NLG evaluation in recent years. Various
automatic evaluation methods based on LLMs have been proposed, including
metrics derived from LLMs, prompting LLMs, and fine-tuning LLMs with labeled
evaluation data. In this survey, we first give a taxonomy of LLM-based NLG
evaluation methods, and discuss their pros and cons, respectively. We also
discuss human-LLM collaboration for NLG evaluation. Lastly, we discuss several
open problems in this area and point out future research directions. | [
0.0334375761,
0.0217239726,
0.0070879031,
0.0256338976,
-0.0640479773,
-0.0014772029,
-0.006828154,
0.0027227846,
0.0284797475,
-0.0742750689,
-0.0398850292,
-0.0496460013,
0.015200885,
0.0080924872,
0.0270865336,
-0.0069424259,
0.0112047782,
-0.0010469477,
0.0069096428,
0.0293043703,
-0.0096447011,
0.025245389,
0.0008211719,
0.0600895882,
-0.0023372262,
0.0105707683,
0.0161788333,
0.0160652008,
0.0276759993,
-0.0554202199,
-0.0103031257,
0.0212520659,
-0.0299208667,
0.0187432077,
0.0000018838,
-0.0681776851,
-0.0033172809,
-0.0041874344,
0.0063254721,
0.0397564769,
0.0762783065,
0.0209090617,
0.0034243285,
0.029851146,
-0.0460533872,
0.0207879022,
0.0005524835,
0.0317730419,
0.0688478574,
0.0651408061,
0.0149162626,
0.0134200267,
-0.0074075167,
-0.0168543272,
0.0167752672,
-0.0329098329,
-0.0039016134,
0.0395422578,
0.0199560523,
0.011038634,
0.0274387691,
0.0254605915,
-0.0001663761,
-0.0172733162,
0.0106119309,
0.0283029247,
-0.0487380885,
-0.0210082997,
-0.01629843,
0.0540459305,
-0.0087441579,
-0.0174712986,
0.0284499247,
-0.0173881873,
0.0238523819,
-0.0134949712,
-0.0309597608,
0.0421073474,
-0.0030389999,
0.030127896,
0.034974061,
0.0330221392,
0.0278482828,
0.0370499194,
0.0361527279,
0.0566646829,
0.0284680706,
-0.0041297222,
-0.0135129532,
0.0160841756,
-0.0028729432,
-0.0591942072,
-0.0039428789,
0.0304805692,
-0.0460333079,
0.0157311857,
-0.0398451686,
0.0110571124,
0.0577218048,
-0.0423444621,
0.0439418107,
0.0222023986,
0.0077442848,
0.0055167731,
-0.0354351886,
0.0584963188,
0.0137860784,
-0.0163202845,
-0.0605291575,
0.0305625424,
-0.0575349405,
-0.0120548978,
-0.0451047644,
0.0371009409,
-0.0326695293,
-0.0453502983,
-0.0709910542,
0.0143512553,
-0.0029130932,
-0.0192272626,
0.0193462782,
0.0087749073,
-0.0296750255,
0.0201558694,
-0.0316713266,
-0.0162974969,
-0.0076490282,
0.0117851449,
0.0353490114,
-0.0408669189,
0.0080053331,
0.0511589721,
-0.0061800219,
0.0046785148,
-0.0072191302,
0.1048588306,
0.0023199532,
-0.0144048855,
-0.0431671068,
-0.0624903627,
-0.0427456126,
-0.0619296953,
-0.0047310838,
-0.0676030815,
0.0108959042,
-0.0023609751,
-0.0201832354,
-0.0170243643,
0.0226188079,
0.0350217894,
0.0011389018,
0.020726312,
-0.001951314,
0.0140933478,
0.0419520512,
0.0116973855,
0.00985392,
0.0548721887,
0.0528403111,
0.0420739464,
0.0341599621,
0.0181151871,
0.0200867001,
0.0465250202,
-0.004675705,
-0.0150413951,
0.0199426021,
-0.0352548286,
-0.0275201872,
0.0380019546,
0.0248249508,
0.0857041925,
-0.0320393704,
0.0100494176,
0.0282718893,
0.0238091294,
0.0110404631,
0.0119744828,
0.1021503881,
0.0365394838,
0.0161921773,
0.0339952633,
0.0044740774,
0.0148367463,
-0.0488112196,
0.0210607983,
0.0551351607,
0.042999018,
0.0041698939,
-0.0675279796,
-0.0322393775,
0.0084784729,
0.0089956736,
-0.04472683,
0.008401922,
0.0209337976,
-0.0636240691,
0.061953485,
-0.0000812552,
-0.0625014901,
0.0363223925,
-0.058221899,
0.009080369,
0.0461916849,
0.0779150128,
0.0307682417,
-0.0350393578,
0.0198717061,
-0.0138229681,
0.0726522878,
0.0225358009,
0.0033974922,
-0.0097696818,
-0.0389763974,
-0.0057018618,
-0.0093220156,
0.021626357,
0.0086831553,
0.0110382102,
-0.0033890572,
0.0548555255,
-0.0278400127,
-0.0650654361,
0.0475542955,
-0.0257035065,
-0.0090978127,
0.0238238983,
-0.0384246521,
0.0460243598,
0.0182558727,
-0.0246806331,
0.0605208129,
0.0210116152,
-0.0255557615,
-0.029977493,
0.0258492138,
-0.0254855901,
-0.0445551351,
0.0262203515,
-0.0618618578,
0.0278882366,
-0.0172523074,
-0.0391996168,
-0.0422861092,
0.0009791137,
-0.0644792989,
0.0135387238,
-0.0597220957,
0.0382331274,
0.0454566777,
-0.0095927473,
-0.0568152927,
0.0577940568,
-0.0029282607,
0.0234763883,
0.0345774032,
0.0313959382,
0.0489452109,
-0.0361875743,
-0.0311780162,
0.0002013295,
-0.017828105,
0.0076269293,
0.0400041342,
0.0661005601,
-0.0667280406,
-0.0789269358,
-0.0881029516,
0.020114081,
-0.0085315779,
0.0494468622,
0.0232857764,
-0.0295177642,
-0.0097184023,
0.0240560379,
-0.0419530161,
-0.001569949,
0.0774050727,
-0.0178256724,
0.0501383021,
0.0056233113,
-0.0273674261,
-0.0380774103,
0.0323883705,
0.0170713738,
0.030893933,
0.0513136126,
-0.0072699431,
-0.07504078,
0.0377125591,
-0.06129333,
-0.0523811691,
0.0111682974,
-0.0647153035,
0.0249941237,
0.0275310986,
0.0314843841,
-0.0030559853,
0.0400943086,
0.0067503382,
0.0249154642,
-0.0071233874,
-0.0347242057,
-0.03064196,
-0.0338383242,
-0.0310997106,
0.0255273264,
-0.0338745117,
0.0326306038,
0.0519365147,
0.0137317227,
0.0032948242,
-0.0398004949,
0.0312509127,
-0.0442337245,
-0.0362268873,
-0.0303609353,
-0.020008821,
-0.0285680499,
0.0333403572,
-0.0182247255,
-0.0726101398,
0.0386978313,
-0.0795442536,
0.0146346958,
-0.0432261787,
-0.0044809282,
-0.0513005555,
0.0412448309,
0.0023464416,
0.0253773071,
-0.0112930313,
0.0001596854,
-0.0521696769,
0.0242269523,
-0.0057998467,
-0.0512199104,
0.0258512702,
-0.0681319237,
-0.0013317281,
0.0156465862,
0.0094654886,
-0.0618124679,
-0.0226713419,
-0.008660526,
0.0008545483,
0.0400261767,
0.0153318914,
-0.0119437128,
0.0188044086,
-0.0074008075,
-0.0243620034,
-0.0026466697,
-0.0107709495,
-0.0023767855,
0.0494528152,
0.0617813431,
0.0211568102,
0.0028426722,
0.0098684216,
-0.0022297564,
0.0307927057,
-0.0023715962,
0.0514211021,
-0.0062475684,
-0.0005349351,
0.0065362165,
-0.0199714135,
-0.0238590632,
0.0348459147,
0.0284634475,
-0.0406317785,
-0.0369087532,
0.1251871288,
0.0427841842,
0.0029060075,
0.0120495996,
-0.0211637784,
0.0593775846,
-0.013929449,
0.0163656287,
-0.0678226799,
-0.0236059744,
-0.0118703805,
0.0243511535,
-0.0218769535,
-0.000710091,
-0.0279224832,
-0.1272988617,
0.0357610993,
0.0388214327,
-0.0290674362,
0.0058508818,
-0.004772197,
-0.0374724083,
-0.0147602726,
-0.0151893236,
-0.0000232945,
-0.0277670212,
0.0325463191,
0.0277928058,
-0.0689688995,
-0.0588064715,
-0.0105602201,
-0.0268328302,
0.0731085762,
0.0487475656,
0.0352632105,
0.0303521473,
-0.0267028026,
0.050114207,
-0.0348130502,
0.0213776398,
-0.0198965445,
0.0110242367,
-0.0065843286,
0.009684938,
-0.0316667967,
0.0093670767,
-0.0209198371,
-0.0054814238,
0.0060376911,
0.0436357595,
-0.0309986155,
-0.0055336123,
-0.014616576,
0.0661953166,
0.0325549655,
0.1064546183,
0.0461212806,
-0.0333367959,
-0.027734993,
-0.0244501438,
0.0161699764,
-0.0520633087,
-0.0302292109,
0.021676546,
-0.0207901243,
0.0122034298,
-0.1218002737,
-0.0388443768,
-0.0220894627,
-0.0151034873,
0.0003382835,
0.0106590576,
-0.0156478174,
-0.0082134316,
-0.0124753146,
0.0171472672,
-0.0168442409,
-0.0102004074,
-0.0714792162,
-0.006062163,
0.027740268,
-0.0473005287,
-0.025494514,
0.0909026489,
-0.0804703832,
-0.0570842959,
-0.0188380983,
0.0266979635,
0.0260739904,
-0.0129216108,
-0.008855829,
-0.0194102433,
0.0240966994,
0.0832807124,
-0.014546819,
0.041157797,
-0.0146382758,
0.0373664536,
-0.023763489,
0.010795434,
-0.0483374745,
0.0166902561,
-0.0255881734,
0.0705945641,
0.00323243,
-0.0600760728,
0.0044214283,
0.0563383885,
0.0155573217,
-0.0864391103,
0.0025162098,
-0.0070916768,
-0.0556247793,
-0.0120363953,
-0.0212456472,
-0.0648288205,
-0.0072222915,
0.011450679,
-0.0009375205,
-0.0255828165,
-0.0075850673,
-0.0564081222,
0.0595704243,
0.0005942287,
-0.0127460444,
-0.0113366712,
-0.0027411531,
-0.0253711995,
-0.0144167859,
-0.0130641414,
-0.0078802928,
-0.0376099683,
0.0107737351,
-0.0190554671,
0.0551344417,
0.0093591819,
0.0204461962,
0.014341319,
0.0597594529,
-0.0227082577,
0.013828503,
-0.0597888678,
0.0436383747,
0.0774872676,
0.012451129,
0.1054469496,
-0.0453203134,
0.0106595717,
-0.0214220844,
0.0721214116,
0.0097750183,
-0.0374589674,
0.0114750937,
-0.0003443048,
-0.0431666821,
-0.0130155552,
0.0753174871,
0.0196138695,
0.0105177443,
-0.0016347861,
-0.0265176222,
-0.0509713218,
-0.0352890417,
-0.0350331441,
-0.0221533123,
0.0054953741,
0.0038269127,
-0.0780382454,
-0.0474413,
0.0073222346,
0.0519406386,
0.0310459603,
-0.0096367141,
0.0598636754,
0.0373252071,
-0.0300129373,
0.0290936437,
-0.0397633649,
-0.0223893691,
-0.047753945,
-0.0017248457,
-0.028458897,
-6.153564153e-33,
-0.0560345799,
-0.0870671272,
0.0319180079,
0.0084490171,
-0.0592695475,
0.0072048823,
-0.0353803411,
0.0220529921,
0.0480053909,
-0.0005705655,
0.0260005891,
-0.0430627242,
0.007326866,
0.009994572,
-0.0100147994,
-0.017740069,
0.0240005534,
-0.015602693,
-0.0585613735,
0.0168658383,
0.018226603,
0.000948631,
0.0093763694,
-0.0603500083,
0.0175635051,
-0.0163219832,
-0.0422348343,
-0.0187478736,
0.0232814513,
0.0715818703,
-0.0413020849,
0.0256782938,
0.031996198,
-0.0278556589,
-0.0096593928,
0.0032325685,
-0.0206988398,
-0.0345036574,
0.0116518494,
-0.0262349602,
-0.0179607011,
-0.0341157354,
0.0430877209,
-0.0170888267,
-0.0676308051,
0.0255595539,
0.0160356443,
-0.0362768881,
-0.0140385488,
-0.0254710726,
-0.0486587994,
0.0350118876,
0.0058240104,
-0.0247340798,
-0.0213971585,
0.0346140563,
-0.0351918265,
0.008910032,
-0.016129816,
0.0306748282,
0.0064494936,
0.0267276503,
0.0812157616,
-0.0015881188,
-0.0258057434,
0.0705570877,
-0.0234477893,
-0.0130419321,
-0.042912215,
-0.0218836721,
0.0000484886,
0.0452761091,
0.0558717549,
0.0521895364,
0.0161964539,
0.0246461518,
-0.046782665,
0.0820465237,
0.0055742203,
0.0110970186,
0.0086606313,
-0.0253789295,
-0.0120187923,
-0.0079492452,
-0.0418220051,
-0.0093205487,
-0.0137456749,
-0.0382388346,
0.0629659593,
0.0098785972,
-0.0245825332,
-0.0418216959,
0.0200239047,
-0.0042335303,
0.0138222957,
0.0213821698,
-0.0447885282,
0.0025215358,
-0.019908227,
-0.018639639,
-0.0393568054,
-0.0335441828,
0.0416478403,
0.0423578843,
0.0182714816,
-0.0362424366,
0.0138696032,
-0.0016383604,
-0.0355217382,
0.0523753762,
-0.0350443386,
0.0388119258,
-0.0062758462,
-0.0336410701,
0.0187056493,
-0.0435956791,
-0.0380640551,
0.0183116347,
0.0071182889,
0.0130302198,
0.0179353543,
-0.0223787464,
0.0020139783,
0.0065039867,
-0.0466847904,
0.0575068966,
0.0077354135,
0.0046569658,
0.0085839126,
-0.0007962153,
-0.0118368445,
0.0069416775,
2.578e-7,
0.0362676121,
0.0469166562,
0.0297913961,
0.0396954566,
-0.0028083986,
-0.0033242775,
-0.0072973138,
0.0073096794,
0.0054548318,
0.0070410473,
-0.0030903379,
-0.0031338029,
0.0722937584,
-0.0076576541,
-0.0607079603,
-0.009297777,
-0.0754720271,
0.0015628216,
-0.0274822079,
-0.021224428,
0.0753926709,
0.0369134992,
-0.0302351955,
-0.0112620899,
-0.0310022589,
-0.0767958164,
0.0719431937,
-0.0478463396,
-0.0386885703,
0.0267701447,
0.0973710045,
0.0269866772,
-0.0006661334,
-0.0074713095,
-0.0070506828,
-0.0112783732,
0.0404346921,
0.0518821515,
0.0480115265,
-0.0280247666,
0.0223994926,
0.0131700421,
0.0112271393,
-0.0440936312,
0.0429665707,
-0.0476381741,
-0.0061558485,
-0.0305672549,
-0.0129633406,
-0.014596872,
0.0081466883,
-0.0307828225,
-0.0383308902,
0.0322200507,
0.0191134401,
0.0035709068,
-0.0134579577,
-0.029460948,
-0.0402645506,
-0.0171058793,
-0.040731404,
-0.0361894108,
-0.0330069773,
0.0394446738,
0.005118357,
-0.066057235,
-0.0108870929,
2.263830617e-34,
0.0421141759,
-0.0385680795,
0.0169543847,
-0.0062147239,
0.0541784577,
0.0420808941,
-0.0211164504,
0.0170847941,
-0.0087846965,
-0.0816833526,
0.0145655731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01376v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01376v2 | LoTR: Low Tensor Rank Weight Adaptation | 2024-02-02T13:00:38 | 2024-02-05T12:42:52 | Daniel Bershatsky, Daria Cherniuk, Talgat Daulbaev, Aleksandr Mikhalev, Ivan Oseledets | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper we generalize and extend an idea of low-rank adaptation (LoRA)
of large language models (LLMs) based on Transformer architecture. Widely used
LoRA-like methods of fine-tuning LLMs are based on matrix factorization of
gradient update. We introduce LoTR, a novel approach for parameter-efficient
fine-tuning of LLMs which represents a gradient update to parameters in a form
of tensor decomposition. Low-rank adapter for each layer is constructed as a
product of three matrices, and tensor structure arises from sharing left and
right multipliers of this product among layers. Simultaneous compression of a
sequence of layers with low-rank tensor representation allows LoTR to archive
even better parameter efficiency then LoRA especially for deep models.
Moreover, the core tensor does not depend on original weight dimension and can
be made arbitrary small, which allows for extremely cheap and fast downstream
fine-tuning. | LoTR: Low Tensor Rank Weight Adaptation: In this paper we generalize and extend an idea of low-rank adaptation (LoRA)
of large language models (LLMs) based on Transformer architecture. Widely used
LoRA-like methods of fine-tuning LLMs are based on matrix factorization of
gradient update. We introduce LoTR, a novel approach for parameter-efficient
fine-tuning of LLMs which represents a gradient update to parameters in a form
of tensor decomposition. Low-rank adapter for each layer is constructed as a
product of three matrices, and tensor structure arises from sharing left and
right multipliers of this product among layers. Simultaneous compression of a
sequence of layers with low-rank tensor representation allows LoTR to archive
even better parameter efficiency then LoRA especially for deep models.
Moreover, the core tensor does not depend on original weight dimension and can
be made arbitrary small, which allows for extremely cheap and fast downstream
fine-tuning. | [
0.0135504007,
0.0581069402,
-0.0153174195,
0.056430947,
0.0266633928,
0.0431350358,
0.0141161513,
0.0223363414,
-0.0212311856,
-0.0297000129,
-0.0579737164,
-0.0312762596,
0.0186145194,
-0.0309404526,
0.0139351934,
-0.0361202694,
0.0051834704,
-0.0476406552,
-0.0227015764,
-0.0152715445,
-0.0257256944,
0.0240517594,
0.0076197446,
-0.003494181,
0.0644411966,
0.0095924605,
-0.0151361702,
0.0015349525,
0.0184956379,
0.0559696481,
0.0164411403,
0.0361198038,
0.0336481221,
0.0348025337,
0.0000019582,
0.0214574393,
-0.0145187443,
-0.0138126528,
0.0027641745,
0.0247497149,
0.0487671755,
-0.0247739814,
-0.0479867905,
0.0006672275,
-0.0175296105,
-0.0326873437,
0.050681591,
0.0195256118,
0.0688495934,
0.0702534169,
-0.0273986291,
-0.0430877991,
0.0092325071,
-0.0322567448,
-0.0562093593,
-0.0466691814,
0.0177486166,
-0.0283477865,
-0.0516325608,
-0.0129906274,
-0.0387725309,
0.005451086,
-0.000119712,
0.0065138503,
-0.0152665693,
-0.0001372483,
-0.044507876,
-0.0176809542,
0.0013842389,
0.0682266578,
-0.0669308752,
0.0052355989,
0.0082502486,
-0.0180266872,
0.0038335165,
-0.0549178645,
-0.0219977386,
0.0027409249,
0.0514174253,
0.0215212051,
0.008415021,
-0.0325719304,
0.0173871424,
0.0184064191,
-0.0574785136,
-0.0085715204,
0.0528949089,
0.0055733514,
-0.0680723861,
-0.0086677335,
0.0030737326,
0.0066048866,
0.0204013232,
0.0240838714,
-0.0265672691,
-0.014825982,
-0.0753224194,
-0.0910326317,
-0.0115051158,
-0.0536066443,
0.078570269,
0.0567129701,
-0.0183155816,
0.048856739,
-0.0799067467,
0.0559309721,
-0.0427727364,
-0.0092126448,
-0.0349069349,
-0.0216134209,
0.0307987183,
0.0303190481,
-0.0333572142,
0.0099828541,
-0.0574673787,
-0.0132780951,
-0.0226967186,
0.0488257483,
0.0012825404,
-0.0278191008,
0.0212850515,
0.0030788162,
-0.0263812803,
-0.049143441,
0.0050127548,
0.0637766123,
0.0213281084,
0.0226311404,
-0.0463268608,
-0.0238609947,
-0.0099285459,
0.0218294077,
0.0768941119,
-0.0066685705,
0.059126962,
0.0367143229,
-0.0381706618,
-0.043666739,
-0.0141283721,
0.0531499535,
0.0270501878,
-0.0428279079,
0.011719618,
-0.0208039209,
0.0387586653,
-0.0116632674,
0.0285006668,
-0.0336919092,
-0.0188463423,
0.0140076857,
-0.0744656324,
0.0302887801,
0.0224369876,
-0.01015017,
0.0262919664,
-0.0017647489,
0.0201483909,
0.0414519794,
0.0369217694,
0.0320745669,
-0.0110519584,
-0.0513737388,
-0.0368045978,
0.0436875597,
0.0014285466,
0.0402591005,
-0.0108436085,
-0.0214986559,
-0.0184175484,
0.0129919536,
0.0608979426,
0.074959524,
-0.0248987135,
-0.0070728497,
0.0541839264,
0.0323213637,
0.0759193823,
0.0749722943,
0.0045101857,
-0.0415702797,
-0.0210212953,
0.0084018344,
-0.0129002081,
0.0606928095,
-0.0076984852,
-0.0262148827,
0.0370784104,
0.083110556,
-0.0439587869,
0.0027996602,
-0.0011234534,
-0.0013704749,
0.0259568803,
0.00382023,
0.0342535675,
0.0073839109,
-0.050015673,
0.0664350837,
0.018284006,
-0.0429186374,
0.0116033023,
-0.0523470975,
-0.0055939378,
0.0370968655,
0.0209946614,
0.0084717562,
-0.0119844386,
-0.0048073446,
0.0131469164,
0.0031322953,
0.0197837725,
0.0186704099,
0.0524105206,
-0.0744837299,
0.0110995127,
0.0311808288,
-0.004574101,
0.006167334,
-0.0268468764,
0.017376557,
0.0220719017,
0.0088847633,
0.0136728063,
0.0238823295,
-0.0331044607,
-0.0120839272,
0.0566141307,
0.0008744044,
0.0121282125,
0.0022804129,
0.0190787315,
-0.0534321666,
0.0283213891,
-0.0525156856,
-0.0037971586,
-0.0525824539,
-0.0285891145,
0.0188520011,
0.0192349162,
0.0026372196,
0.0202058144,
0.0622665398,
-0.0382094383,
-0.0487747304,
0.0502814502,
-0.0262432322,
0.0200724546,
-0.0246579479,
0.0106796846,
-0.0182998106,
0.0734758973,
-0.0096197547,
0.0142940823,
-0.0133742522,
0.0037320121,
0.0685390383,
-0.0139763011,
-0.0075161462,
-0.0112260124,
-0.0579536371,
0.0300731268,
0.0048675947,
0.0433881134,
0.0181527268,
0.019146869,
0.0138706975,
-0.0462073982,
-0.0886602551,
0.0248997957,
-0.0466108397,
0.0185497329,
0.0453764237,
0.0528791063,
0.0300270002,
-0.0155122839,
-0.019189816,
0.0305282157,
-0.0320264846,
0.0075950976,
0.0042711841,
-0.0054434352,
0.0183473118,
-0.0260339323,
-0.0426992141,
0.0387373418,
0.0415469334,
-0.0396342985,
0.0128756193,
-0.0917528197,
-0.0320759229,
-0.0180259142,
0.0635064989,
-0.005999364,
-0.0640862733,
-0.028417334,
-0.0179545972,
0.0907886475,
0.0667181537,
0.0243348144,
0.0157409776,
0.0646510795,
0.0440935455,
0.0104925307,
0.0018163688,
-0.018905187,
-0.0441436023,
-0.0442111865,
-0.005936373,
-0.0330954976,
0.0408480577,
-0.0216656923,
0.0013543551,
-0.075319007,
-0.026499778,
-0.0068428903,
0.0156774055,
-0.0201318767,
0.0083705364,
-0.0299608763,
-0.0018014731,
0.0186015125,
0.0042045028,
0.0447071046,
-0.0282146912,
-0.0350130722,
-0.041157987,
-0.0491476357,
-0.0463190973,
0.0021841573,
0.0042363051,
0.0401165336,
-0.0635726601,
0.0049808915,
-0.0505604707,
0.0213629175,
0.0250603501,
-0.0419532508,
0.0222558044,
-0.0172557216,
-0.0103038251,
-0.0620838478,
-0.0395107642,
0.0131618511,
-0.0099004377,
-0.0104455231,
0.0241085868,
0.0348238908,
-0.0500427298,
-0.0215517804,
0.0114423661,
0.0194479842,
0.0775792375,
-0.0108488165,
0.0131220929,
-0.0381822325,
0.0509479195,
0.0621751733,
0.0467816927,
0.0220981315,
0.0047236015,
0.0270530246,
0.02462795,
0.0188710801,
0.0092834514,
-0.0735038444,
0.0244734641,
0.0756695196,
0.0323231518,
-0.0051372265,
-0.0141971866,
0.0002677019,
-0.0074534416,
0.0240041893,
0.0521400422,
-0.0229277499,
-0.0772530511,
0.0011692094,
-0.0037602687,
0.0417934582,
0.0139109837,
0.0264700018,
-0.0430575386,
-0.0116025191,
0.0139972707,
0.0088764727,
0.0272688828,
-0.0218080115,
0.006908007,
-0.0542422421,
0.0237049442,
0.0097045125,
0.0285190456,
-0.0387652144,
-0.0463754833,
0.0252069328,
0.0045932671,
0.0654591545,
0.0229637306,
-0.0043367469,
-0.059087038,
0.0178791154,
0.0048352573,
-0.058824867,
-0.0193257108,
0.0051070875,
0.0311328974,
-0.026671594,
0.0135435862,
-0.0046808356,
-0.0493959934,
0.02588352,
-0.0279741343,
-0.0096202325,
-0.0046974807,
-0.0272852797,
0.0244475622,
-0.0488491207,
0.0049833669,
0.0376370065,
-0.0355799906,
0.0173790883,
-0.0571147986,
0.0651030689,
-0.0008335211,
-0.0225457642,
-0.0103887292,
-0.0464067236,
-0.0334447324,
0.0315596424,
0.0157744288,
-0.0593535453,
0.0347938128,
0.0293383747,
-0.0073160189,
-0.0076729474,
-0.0427779481,
-0.015723262,
-0.016335573,
0.0037155913,
-0.0160708725,
0.0550455824,
0.0017255069,
0.0186589211,
-0.0243180748,
-0.0182574913,
0.0120833414,
0.009463571,
-0.0338068604,
0.0085388748,
-0.0234444048,
-0.0182249416,
-0.0309216529,
0.0121892877,
0.0736671388,
-0.0032037394,
-0.0060224668,
0.0049240477,
-0.0919693857,
-0.0429360121,
-0.0056955027,
0.0296856351,
0.0080383653,
-0.0032182427,
0.0193168316,
-0.0915136561,
0.061004512,
-0.0045986278,
-0.0163293239,
0.0833278075,
0.0038793138,
-0.0841648355,
-0.0337983742,
0.0332853273,
-0.0756238997,
0.0042727087,
0.0167824142,
0.0236350689,
0.0016377721,
-0.0289324708,
-0.0093276659,
-0.0128708091,
0.0164231379,
-0.0065830792,
-0.0057834545,
-0.0168185439,
0.0608980246,
-0.0055219014,
0.0119867986,
-0.034671355,
-0.0183015447,
0.0205296539,
-0.0007391842,
-0.0206521582,
0.0122372778,
0.0656200051,
0.0230492353,
-0.0139112743,
0.032774087,
-0.0207439512,
-0.0067517781,
0.0680127889,
0.0174935013,
-0.0276516248,
0.002282752,
0.0037031062,
0.020007316,
-0.0542126745,
-0.0141120516,
0.0193412639,
-0.0107633546,
-0.066575259,
0.0655998513,
-0.0299869683,
-0.1091452539,
-0.036245957,
-0.0046247346,
0.0498208925,
0.0378956385,
0.0562353171,
0.0101024834,
-0.0264125168,
-0.00344173,
-0.0206665583,
-0.0045710979,
0.0021604334,
0.0244710818,
0.0038863679,
0.0059669088,
0.0633523166,
0.0286596138,
0.0164839942,
0.0231283046,
-0.0228100065,
0.0083675887,
-0.0253732167,
-0.0207093544,
-0.024346035,
0.0431027748,
-0.0099161742,
-0.0083960071,
0.0369605869,
-0.0436099395,
-0.0420706458,
-0.0279489588,
0.0088029886,
-0.0689743459,
0.0083251949,
0.0379314572,
-0.0040036379,
0.022515174,
0.0046605053,
-0.0081750257,
-0.001300153,
-0.0268696602,
-0.0126634659,
-6.252623429e-33,
-0.0295519661,
0.0529185124,
0.0025110815,
0.0057882308,
-0.0112111205,
0.0154661108,
-0.0206666179,
0.0104224626,
-0.0193717089,
-0.006068347,
-0.0268544517,
-0.0130395135,
0.0037935164,
0.0167253148,
-0.0137657803,
0.0184021499,
0.0674165562,
-0.0130445771,
-0.0126568545,
0.0414204709,
0.0048057181,
0.0232805219,
0.0569243915,
-0.0171266645,
-0.0630805194,
0.0060475571,
-0.0275630336,
0.0031097552,
0.023072185,
0.0420026369,
-0.0576152839,
0.0300148409,
0.0198126435,
-0.0379505716,
-0.021947369,
0.0081967711,
-0.0938856825,
0.004548938,
0.0172767248,
0.0286788531,
-0.0405003466,
-0.0337966606,
0.0595029965,
0.0374838896,
-0.023531856,
-0.0254778787,
0.0131819369,
-0.0145508805,
-0.0317463391,
-0.0328280814,
-0.0292071626,
0.0082884301,
-0.000083352,
-0.0192513019,
0.0340314917,
0.0212935898,
-0.0194255542,
0.0482629389,
-0.0775324404,
-0.0248550903,
-0.031455297,
0.079889439,
0.0291836113,
0.0190298315,
-0.0339136124,
0.0223652124,
-0.0062229754,
0.0103111416,
0.0086838081,
-0.0437620915,
0.077022545,
0.0076030358,
0.0601908602,
0.025632672,
0.0076906784,
-0.0380615927,
-0.05289267,
-0.0431913882,
0.0254104529,
0.0179654863,
0.0574949905,
0.0553909466,
0.0228788126,
-0.0199065004,
-0.0512108542,
-0.0071993568,
-0.0497456901,
0.0093615586,
-0.0125015834,
0.0401134342,
-0.0485197529,
-0.031451229,
0.0518357567,
-0.0463731512,
0.0401551723,
0.0265172869,
-0.0284609925,
0.0272365212,
0.0237459876,
0.0145849613,
-0.011216497,
-0.0535341054,
0.0256021731,
-0.0373246744,
0.0009478116,
-0.0136280833,
0.0156856943,
0.0857179537,
-0.0601049252,
-0.0311098117,
0.0002963403,
-0.00327816,
0.0012412806,
0.0694083497,
-0.023695685,
0.0068266881,
0.006766988,
0.0477272496,
0.0079057943,
0.0562671423,
-0.0128808822,
-0.0051848143,
0.0494977236,
0.0262728073,
-0.0502232946,
-0.0067156786,
-0.0263728797,
0.0416345038,
0.0729469359,
-0.0648143813,
-0.0233493671,
0.0099249659,
2.717e-7,
-0.0051312675,
0.0341264047,
-0.0126435226,
-0.0479617938,
0.0395861715,
0.0318254493,
0.0220994316,
0.0555212945,
0.0475667343,
0.0260632373,
0.0266161468,
0.0108132912,
0.0012265777,
-0.0223012846,
-0.0534872897,
-0.0059884987,
-0.0875595063,
0.0252595376,
-0.0218454674,
-0.0394650884,
-0.0133955711,
0.1128410324,
0.0128267268,
-0.0465542078,
-0.0013577935,
0.0047884737,
0.0382680334,
-0.0331663899,
0.0197818037,
-0.0053062052,
0.0687194467,
0.0347036943,
-0.0429509692,
-0.0312087759,
-0.0015817994,
0.0619622134,
-0.0462773964,
0.0678392127,
-0.0324659199,
0.005609253,
0.0455803908,
0.0095285634,
-0.0206112433,
-0.0659565851,
0.0558815636,
-0.0177237242,
-0.0091386111,
-0.0905436426,
-0.0169538278,
-0.0110067278,
-0.0123655712,
-0.0355761014,
-0.0018655487,
0.0420947559,
0.0497310981,
0.0004965216,
-0.0247957408,
-0.1097611934,
0.0348204523,
-0.0001989022,
-0.0418871753,
-0.045067478,
-0.0421873555,
-0.0717285946,
0.0679487884,
-0.0321029872,
0.0298284497,
2.114106845e-34,
0.0257299654,
-0.0035483327,
0.0230905339,
0.0214638691,
0.0194264241,
-0.0387905315,
0.00098895,
0.0247988608,
0.0070437673,
-0.112066865,
-0.0393785238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01375v1 | Dive into the Chasm: Probing the Gap between In- and Cross-Topic Generalization | 2024-02-02T12:59:27 | 2024-02-02T12:59:27 | Andreas Waldis, Yufang Hou, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (LMs) perform well in In-Topic setups, where
training and testing data come from the same topics. However, they face
challenges in Cross-Topic scenarios where testing data is derived from distinct
topics -- such as Gun Control. This study analyzes various LMs with three
probing-based experiments to shed light on the reasons behind the In- vs.
Cross-Topic generalization gap. Thereby, we demonstrate, for the first time,
that generalization gaps and the robustness of the embedding space vary
significantly across LMs. Additionally, we assess larger LMs and underscore the
relevance of our analysis for recent models. Overall, diverse pre-training
objectives, architectural regularization, or data deduplication contribute to
more robust LMs and diminish generalization gaps. Our research contributes to a
deeper understanding and comparison of language models across different
generalization scenarios. | Dive into the Chasm: Probing the Gap between In- and Cross-Topic Generalization: Pre-trained language models (LMs) perform well in In-Topic setups, where
training and testing data come from the same topics. However, they face
challenges in Cross-Topic scenarios where testing data is derived from distinct
topics -- such as Gun Control. This study analyzes various LMs with three
probing-based experiments to shed light on the reasons behind the In- vs.
Cross-Topic generalization gap. Thereby, we demonstrate, for the first time,
that generalization gaps and the robustness of the embedding space vary
significantly across LMs. Additionally, we assess larger LMs and underscore the
relevance of our analysis for recent models. Overall, diverse pre-training
objectives, architectural regularization, or data deduplication contribute to
more robust LMs and diminish generalization gaps. Our research contributes to a
deeper understanding and comparison of language models across different
generalization scenarios. | [
0.0240215287,
0.0454439111,
-0.0167212095,
0.0416943803,
-0.0087597929,
0.0242278986,
0.0159617588,
0.0045047426,
-0.0506872684,
-0.0474520624,
-0.0410138592,
-0.0200530309,
-0.0225910265,
0.0120780757,
0.0386836529,
-0.0225687027,
0.0478618182,
-0.0120471381,
0.0070854006,
0.0022933388,
0.0058104252,
-0.0001844727,
0.0353523493,
0.0295435954,
0.008711841,
0.0207592957,
-0.0255302079,
-0.0200001746,
-0.0059196637,
-0.0303567927,
0.0171720851,
0.0364680663,
0.0781249627,
0.0204374865,
0.0000017338,
-0.0258850511,
-0.0006989607,
-0.0149310417,
0.0119901728,
0.0389573984,
0.0513927527,
-0.064252153,
0.0357408822,
0.0195763838,
-0.0168640427,
-0.0868749171,
0.0172889065,
0.0749109536,
0.0343738124,
0.0670365095,
-0.0183796417,
-0.0220267344,
0.0367926769,
-0.0575778745,
0.0144050997,
-0.0670403615,
0.0169351883,
0.0112820296,
0.008611856,
0.0540704578,
-0.0315901786,
0.009107722,
0.0189669933,
0.0453978963,
-0.0211718064,
0.0351790413,
-0.0311985556,
-0.0142428372,
-0.0078907665,
0.0901177004,
-0.0649057105,
-0.0268055256,
0.0069708172,
-0.0166146345,
-0.0132331382,
0.0058178399,
-0.0398664922,
-0.0050686989,
0.0405023359,
0.0255359281,
0.0354877673,
-0.0187021252,
0.053879939,
-0.0096580097,
-0.0337590054,
0.0538116172,
0.0282147657,
-0.0453954972,
-0.0085084336,
0.0199039076,
-0.0359214805,
-0.0353756659,
-0.0045213657,
0.003952567,
-0.0123232575,
0.0288831983,
-0.0645922273,
-0.023853289,
0.0316588283,
-0.0077155526,
0.0446846075,
0.0147113455,
-0.0421568789,
0.0629561767,
-0.0047442894,
0.0458913036,
-0.0266054478,
0.0476210453,
-0.0368031152,
0.0083648618,
-0.058446072,
-0.0149817327,
-0.02676416,
0.0081445919,
0.0387689881,
-0.0474654622,
0.0024967724,
0.0234766547,
-0.0143706864,
-0.0053641926,
-0.0437570438,
-0.0248415619,
-0.0365623645,
-0.0138159133,
0.026085645,
-0.0055584158,
-0.0511209369,
0.0610019751,
-0.0123826368,
-0.0143002979,
-0.0123164933,
-0.0018874506,
-0.0045700562,
-0.0077667362,
0.008514666,
0.0322139524,
-0.0066648242,
-0.0466332287,
-0.033854153,
0.0112195425,
-0.0107884668,
-0.0374760069,
0.0237090774,
-0.0393747203,
0.0476102531,
0.0004368736,
-0.0013520326,
-0.023137711,
-0.0122124748,
0.0022990555,
-0.0642803982,
0.0770794526,
0.0058930386,
0.0133900307,
0.0507840328,
0.0279196147,
0.033138454,
0.1019009128,
-0.013338943,
-0.0043621147,
0.0621176474,
0.0084042987,
0.0025138678,
0.0141559057,
0.0375938676,
0.0226846244,
-0.0307142157,
0.0200036038,
0.0336323492,
0.0239907615,
0.0451894775,
0.0262844805,
-0.0593398251,
-0.0351171903,
0.0374383442,
0.1085559428,
0.0215577334,
0.0142057203,
0.042577263,
0.0211365577,
-0.0084873652,
0.03388739,
-0.0352804698,
-0.0478628911,
-0.029704906,
-0.0080965227,
0.0382125489,
-0.0185134672,
-0.0624746867,
-0.0024567537,
-0.0340509973,
-0.047208067,
0.0059927371,
-0.0401079655,
0.0622619651,
0.0093187364,
-0.0167582948,
0.0256960541,
0.0369362347,
-0.0252492018,
0.0013467711,
-0.0236698855,
0.0308625475,
0.0191479456,
0.0349738598,
-0.0282200184,
-0.0322572738,
0.0067283828,
0.0542919412,
0.0190429501,
0.0667246357,
-0.0322840363,
0.0588487536,
-0.0237187017,
-0.0336885937,
-0.063012898,
0.0387804396,
0.0038723876,
0.0203312188,
0.0064718244,
0.029954616,
-0.0639239624,
0.0334254131,
0.0599728227,
-0.0522729829,
0.0035434845,
-0.0169206597,
-0.0101717496,
0.0166273154,
-0.0177706648,
-0.0281746127,
0.0102783144,
0.0231293067,
-0.0333106741,
0.001318834,
-0.0241671447,
-0.0383292139,
-0.0320814215,
0.0288114045,
-0.0470874719,
0.0241491925,
0.0233332757,
-0.047239583,
-0.0096116411,
0.0159326438,
0.009757936,
0.0631862134,
-0.0378135592,
0.0189010687,
-0.0642498881,
-0.0075927372,
-0.0278732274,
0.0269345883,
-0.0023179043,
0.0115312645,
-0.0241368786,
0.0091463868,
0.0495778844,
-0.0003163941,
-0.0537693202,
0.0112762628,
-0.0210685693,
0.0135017913,
0.0097830258,
-0.0224116258,
-0.0213519987,
-0.0041078576,
-0.1005587503,
0.0142023899,
-0.0325066335,
-0.02134992,
0.0233180467,
-0.0242549349,
-0.0093376394,
-0.0072038574,
-0.0195633564,
-0.0462136343,
0.0023556051,
0.0498484895,
0.0290951282,
-0.0063162111,
0.0226000678,
-0.0663234666,
-0.036923483,
-0.026509231,
0.0670652241,
-0.0514830463,
0.0411425978,
-0.0650229454,
0.0559912659,
-0.0329538621,
0.0083696833,
-0.0291248783,
-0.0215644501,
0.0177667998,
-0.0189158414,
0.0254036188,
0.0468726493,
-0.0132388566,
0.0138870897,
0.0793225467,
0.0133592701,
-0.0516864583,
-0.0291359127,
0.000370471,
-0.0118604712,
-0.032532122,
0.0086700162,
0.0058357082,
0.1027704328,
-0.0154361259,
-0.0042751054,
-0.0405151434,
-0.0056813504,
-0.0512328744,
-0.0014187581,
-0.0584434681,
-0.0243419781,
-0.0121415611,
0.0392054766,
-0.0349862762,
-0.0507331118,
0.0606568232,
-0.0229521133,
0.0074686948,
-0.0329574086,
-0.0050197579,
-0.0289979503,
0.0648711398,
0.0156240007,
-0.0093735093,
0.0007602868,
-0.0151823899,
-0.0531282611,
0.0006783441,
-0.0052100923,
-0.0226935074,
0.0590210967,
0.0032546804,
-0.007348639,
-0.0074134581,
-0.0273899063,
-0.0249617491,
-0.0826337188,
0.0002921705,
0.0014532114,
0.0124651622,
0.0134484237,
-0.0058095106,
0.0155294081,
-0.0163701698,
0.035211049,
0.0064859404,
-0.0036627273,
-0.0172435958,
0.0331896357,
0.051136326,
-0.0776821002,
-0.0321843959,
-0.0347179212,
-0.0017329825,
0.0102902548,
0.0369809978,
0.007204615,
-0.0470513143,
0.027225703,
0.0277795475,
-0.0154898874,
-0.0375913009,
0.0154142622,
0.0427292734,
-0.0171296,
-0.0025239571,
0.1024953648,
0.0366804078,
-0.0286475644,
0.0184255168,
0.0054980479,
0.0258483067,
0.0335645191,
0.0148076536,
-0.070752278,
-0.0032736843,
0.0054680589,
-0.0143777197,
0.0218080077,
-0.0034368162,
-0.0067819129,
-0.1109358743,
-0.0040752208,
0.0095209982,
-0.0345634185,
-0.0234796889,
-0.06623853,
0.0096215168,
-0.0025261007,
0.0493333377,
-0.0034913642,
-0.0243718717,
0.0030134164,
0.0050587081,
-0.0450555123,
-0.0746408924,
0.0052045262,
-0.0550325811,
0.0400756039,
0.0485926904,
0.004702826,
0.0119184051,
0.00389833,
0.0432822295,
0.0268371198,
-0.0120951757,
0.0048864591,
0.0462789983,
-0.0064635887,
-0.0030517005,
0.0273639318,
0.0041551664,
-0.0149510624,
-0.0249696318,
0.0027420945,
0.0681023747,
-0.0071079298,
-0.0334653519,
-0.026262505,
0.0015803217,
0.0099398484,
0.086810559,
0.0530799404,
-0.0522319451,
-0.0299013872,
-0.0087838927,
0.0079215262,
-0.0028348146,
-0.0286859963,
0.0108677531,
-0.0143558579,
-0.0284478571,
-0.0168208312,
-0.0503997505,
0.0275373608,
0.0130947949,
-0.0005811738,
-0.0109438039,
-0.0158121046,
-0.0341617055,
-0.0290297363,
0.0408925824,
-0.0329342335,
-0.0281604696,
-0.0165944882,
-0.0088689215,
0.0159494113,
0.0281195529,
-0.0344571397,
-0.0078362515,
-0.0999302119,
-0.0756699219,
0.0298910607,
0.000804698,
0.0138135087,
0.0236421861,
0.0003488899,
-0.0703294128,
0.0893407315,
-0.0267591588,
-0.0493993051,
0.0192548539,
0.0410093926,
-0.0432961248,
0.0258689392,
0.0160011109,
-0.0464199297,
0.035454873,
0.0433456227,
0.0007702864,
-0.0273412038,
0.022372501,
-0.015590474,
-0.0299469288,
0.0965766609,
0.0213972088,
-0.0193946678,
-0.0496069752,
-0.0131450361,
-0.0264713056,
0.0088760471,
-0.0302795004,
-0.0204073321,
0.0675871745,
-0.0010707183,
-0.0314512067,
-0.0107492106,
-0.02460053,
0.0972426683,
-0.0299500469,
0.0072115809,
0.0252514239,
0.0438156798,
0.0281195901,
0.0160846747,
-0.0186840389,
0.0398782752,
-0.0412192531,
0.0051229326,
-0.0371273868,
0.0133690927,
0.0034691729,
0.0417279974,
-0.0128066503,
0.0131698474,
-0.0830148011,
-0.0317387953,
-0.0041047903,
0.0174761117,
0.0384051912,
-0.0282959454,
0.0239437539,
0.0092576556,
-0.0212484952,
-0.0252457988,
0.0078996643,
-0.0366300717,
-0.044633545,
0.0442978926,
0.0151600651,
-0.0328261741,
0.0468263328,
0.0993614048,
0.0295201689,
0.0471315533,
0.0094327545,
0.0066944566,
-0.0321168117,
0.0315247737,
0.080108203,
0.0340012461,
-0.0423529856,
0.0124842823,
-0.0116520273,
-0.0471254736,
0.0162313171,
-0.0272157788,
-0.0363088027,
0.0464986265,
0.0039299852,
0.0972704664,
-0.013442928,
0.0311382171,
-0.0157630593,
-0.0313106626,
0.0185317267,
-0.0472420454,
-0.0372315161,
-6.197939432e-33,
-0.0232834592,
0.0286799949,
0.0011097915,
-0.0504727513,
0.0051487163,
0.0172375888,
-0.0236332808,
0.0415919088,
-0.0279633738,
0.001664169,
-0.0234918259,
0.0332838371,
-0.0013210307,
0.0174343307,
0.0061871582,
-0.0315930396,
0.036260616,
-0.0054758736,
-0.0050515076,
0.0251453128,
-0.0031737403,
0.0552057959,
0.0451676734,
-0.0465590209,
0.0276114121,
-0.0086966464,
0.0267435331,
-0.0123654529,
0.0550810695,
0.0632949993,
-0.0357036144,
0.0350616388,
0.0478226356,
-0.03545155,
-0.0389500856,
0.040679846,
-0.0385206677,
-0.0534528643,
0.0076760305,
-0.0272009484,
-0.0064853295,
-0.0175753422,
0.0244287625,
-0.0263517406,
0.008399901,
-0.0325059183,
0.0357577391,
0.0108244,
-0.0323745944,
-0.0046246983,
-0.0803817213,
0.0247719381,
-0.0039965287,
0.0182628781,
0.0182702933,
0.0202358104,
0.0181952603,
0.0399517417,
-0.0230428129,
0.0368456393,
0.0007061341,
0.0363409258,
0.0230934545,
-0.010677129,
-0.0106735872,
0.0690388083,
-0.0143529056,
0.0194055159,
0.0134394355,
-0.0350270122,
0.0807574615,
0.0408956222,
0.0139407245,
0.0343139358,
0.0581617169,
-0.0124369413,
-0.0765812621,
-0.0092582209,
0.0309746508,
-0.0093929004,
0.0264358055,
0.0570722446,
-0.0139208529,
-0.031380672,
-0.057538107,
-0.0211776998,
-0.0226863008,
-0.0561855063,
0.0367206819,
0.0344804265,
0.0069121453,
0.0170911197,
0.0407930128,
-0.052477356,
-0.0170693528,
0.039569445,
-0.0273874011,
-0.0123619707,
-0.0014515176,
0.0463475958,
-0.0853678957,
-0.0652305782,
0.01688236,
-0.0166188776,
0.0338182896,
-0.012627637,
0.0290848035,
-0.0123080872,
-0.0807989612,
-0.0260200538,
-0.0058408729,
-0.051843293,
0.0196356829,
0.0381736271,
0.0489069223,
0.0112656411,
0.0129407309,
0.033726003,
0.0474856794,
-0.0377261192,
-0.0207654312,
-0.0387530178,
-0.0198012274,
0.0297274031,
-0.0075770221,
-0.0193117894,
-0.0306525193,
-0.0049582855,
0.0696968064,
-0.0622935668,
-0.0290592816,
-0.0115189143,
2.415e-7,
0.0469839238,
0.0398200154,
-0.0183795393,
0.0095961988,
-0.0000818961,
0.0029687434,
-0.0295487214,
0.0516977981,
0.0051271282,
-0.006414135,
0.0132155092,
0.0375941955,
0.0336613879,
0.0383398645,
-0.0536993816,
0.0226929374,
-0.0770237595,
0.0430856645,
-0.0441484414,
-0.0007662816,
-0.0181024615,
0.1075430736,
0.0278866813,
0.0110363457,
-0.0324788168,
-0.0659090877,
0.0765039995,
-0.0631591082,
-0.024346577,
0.0376696736,
0.0233431626,
0.0753565282,
-0.0001990552,
0.0011251174,
-0.0145223197,
0.0511195362,
0.0096562076,
0.0488958843,
0.0119329328,
-0.0218825825,
-0.0270618331,
-0.0229042582,
-0.0357262604,
-0.0701530725,
0.0945822224,
-0.0684590414,
-0.0287928637,
-0.0891002491,
0.0130994683,
-0.0090387994,
0.0461454839,
-0.0188511331,
0.0074863569,
-0.0094307,
0.0285343919,
0.0095150117,
-0.0022931146,
-0.0822196975,
-0.0194240045,
0.0668006465,
-0.0494388603,
-0.0244651511,
-0.0295053087,
-0.0106093185,
0.0559511557,
-0.0349018238,
0.0309273731,
2.227931892e-34,
0.0451101884,
-0.0139309913,
0.0224911459,
-0.0031675999,
0.0237847194,
-0.0279676653,
-0.0229142085,
-0.0068107215,
0.0069488715,
-0.0562447831,
0.0258701574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01364v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01364v2 | Continual Learning for Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-02T12:34:09 | 2024-02-07T07:14:39 | Tongtong Wu, Linhao Luo, Yuan-Fang Li, Shirui Pan, Thuy-Trang Vu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are not amenable to frequent re-training, due to
high training costs arising from their massive scale. However, updates are
necessary to endow LLMs with new skills and keep them up-to-date with rapidly
evolving human knowledge. This paper surveys recent works on continual learning
for LLMs. Due to the unique nature of LLMs, we catalog continue learning
techniques in a novel multi-staged categorization scheme, involving continual
pretraining, instruction tuning, and alignment. We contrast continual learning
for LLMs with simpler adaptation methods used in smaller models, as well as
with other enhancement strategies like retrieval-augmented generation and model
editing. Moreover, informed by a discussion of benchmarks and evaluation, we
identify several challenges and future work directions for this crucial task. | Continual Learning for Large Language Models: A Survey: Large language models (LLMs) are not amenable to frequent re-training, due to
high training costs arising from their massive scale. However, updates are
necessary to endow LLMs with new skills and keep them up-to-date with rapidly
evolving human knowledge. This paper surveys recent works on continual learning
for LLMs. Due to the unique nature of LLMs, we catalog continue learning
techniques in a novel multi-staged categorization scheme, involving continual
pretraining, instruction tuning, and alignment. We contrast continual learning
for LLMs with simpler adaptation methods used in smaller models, as well as
with other enhancement strategies like retrieval-augmented generation and model
editing. Moreover, informed by a discussion of benchmarks and evaluation, we
identify several challenges and future work directions for this crucial task. | [
0.0449237712,
0.0818701833,
-0.0066690589,
0.0137032671,
-0.0005573806,
0.0370463319,
-0.00322394,
-0.0421951823,
0.0106978929,
-0.0699621364,
-0.0649378896,
-0.0360750072,
-0.0339140631,
-0.0092999851,
0.0262695365,
-0.0321605578,
0.0640041828,
-0.0174481198,
-0.0120390551,
-0.0062273098,
-0.0011554398,
0.0140146222,
-0.0134955058,
0.0187534727,
-0.0168750659,
-0.0099176299,
-0.0034757904,
-0.0360964872,
-0.0035541046,
-0.0216073282,
0.0328590795,
0.0482795723,
0.0445498042,
0.0557591841,
0.0000018038,
-0.0532530658,
-0.0378737599,
-0.0223937351,
-0.0439643748,
-0.0105040446,
0.0682971776,
-0.0021482329,
-0.0184083022,
0.0373074077,
-0.0297928136,
-0.0323850028,
0.086093314,
-0.0031805763,
0.0722865388,
0.0597344749,
0.0026885034,
-0.0497602783,
0.0587986782,
-0.0381720774,
-0.0255338587,
-0.0414566882,
0.0228223037,
0.010112837,
-0.0170380771,
0.0156953689,
0.0049197953,
0.0472159497,
0.0202819984,
-0.0205790363,
0.0185516533,
0.0471759737,
0.0004015724,
-0.0130407168,
-0.0046878969,
0.0385904834,
-0.0280858856,
-0.0476072207,
-0.0214984082,
0.0219343361,
-0.01009659,
-0.0088088298,
-0.0436296985,
0.0202480443,
0.0270040259,
0.030435944,
0.0553507991,
-0.040108528,
0.0214253366,
0.0279110558,
-0.0649386123,
-0.0067910375,
0.0361541621,
-0.0368551239,
-0.0169967227,
0.0169604309,
-0.0348427556,
-0.027078351,
0.0070329243,
0.0508380309,
-0.0531114452,
0.0240750089,
-0.0727728605,
0.0006731234,
-0.002294675,
-0.0646707118,
0.0513531566,
0.0331790559,
-0.0083405469,
0.0562690571,
-0.026314415,
0.0424852073,
0.0086426297,
0.0091819325,
-0.0612086281,
-0.0041613108,
-0.0860045478,
-0.0205668118,
-0.0494267642,
0.0227812454,
0.008874069,
-0.0082641477,
-0.0284128748,
0.0628426298,
0.0309926309,
0.0118064014,
-0.0067367218,
-0.0378427096,
-0.0732242092,
-0.010961283,
0.018601859,
0.0549787767,
0.0142962458,
0.016835494,
-0.0194726046,
-0.0086018378,
-0.0030646748,
0.0326999761,
-0.0140880188,
-0.0382996313,
0.0077724545,
0.0212987605,
-0.0603601113,
-0.0327434577,
-0.0535440557,
0.0216307323,
-0.0101112453,
-0.0359226502,
-0.0110028414,
-0.0236267783,
0.0237660613,
-0.0150129758,
0.0069499942,
-0.0558238067,
0.0016670736,
-0.025199173,
-0.0197209381,
0.0698195323,
0.0042517707,
0.0337201729,
0.0363384821,
-0.020590663,
0.0238163229,
0.0669484437,
0.0234798044,
-0.0293066036,
0.0356354378,
-0.0205493905,
0.0079143727,
0.0368902385,
0.0008049201,
0.0206881613,
-0.0476128235,
0.0123037826,
0.0336954035,
0.0291986372,
0.0394312963,
0.01310129,
-0.0135399187,
0.0095224641,
0.0444288366,
0.0032135649,
0.0554313213,
0.0551154912,
0.0527729876,
0.0009453819,
0.0086173369,
0.0026838903,
-0.04799385,
-0.0098649515,
-0.0339121707,
0.0120098982,
-0.0123289591,
0.0106959175,
-0.0506054088,
-0.0299202818,
0.0036714345,
0.0090373373,
-0.0190770905,
0.0258449055,
0.0609368607,
-0.0037063973,
-0.0153805567,
0.062536791,
0.0432689153,
-0.0319966003,
0.0149603449,
-0.0588050894,
0.0072882343,
0.0743730068,
0.0315654054,
-0.0480630882,
-0.0772014409,
0.0113188308,
0.0297924634,
0.0064994423,
0.0587372668,
-0.0486815907,
0.0126505084,
-0.0487928465,
-0.0037038962,
0.0079210093,
0.0292743091,
0.0056272834,
0.0281260349,
0.0210051071,
0.0179329664,
-0.0043742633,
-0.0373580828,
0.0586445779,
-0.0641388819,
-0.0218595769,
0.0005184801,
0.0043556504,
-0.0122274719,
-0.0009257657,
-0.0578467399,
-0.0013043841,
0.0394950397,
-0.046222236,
0.0340051539,
0.0213812981,
-0.0332384482,
-0.0286664851,
0.0761426464,
0.0736984834,
-0.0292505529,
-0.005810868,
-0.0374030806,
-0.0094596948,
0.0044042645,
-0.0024746021,
0.0549771488,
-0.0557872988,
0.0711531714,
-0.0274106991,
-0.0043716906,
-0.0637283027,
0.0388833992,
0.0121744741,
0.0024182342,
0.0214961693,
-0.0052698767,
-0.013949248,
-0.078723073,
-0.0059152776,
0.0342312716,
0.0109178778,
0.0357394032,
-0.0032119171,
0.028943941,
-0.0304730162,
-0.0615682118,
-0.098389186,
0.0218483694,
-0.0216642767,
0.0138222063,
0.0187918451,
0.0025932326,
-0.0121499654,
-0.0295220129,
-0.0075045265,
-0.0192501899,
-0.0075258831,
0.0290704202,
0.0007096523,
-0.0053205295,
-0.03556877,
-0.0401951484,
-0.0271547381,
0.0155092021,
0.0380215384,
-0.0294003896,
-0.0039690109,
-0.0816364959,
0.0022479016,
-0.0275437068,
0.0336865932,
0.0080969958,
-0.0152974408,
-0.0284518804,
-0.0225529764,
0.0181530695,
0.0449817814,
0.0324333794,
0.0452416874,
0.0521902293,
0.0025542364,
-0.0258635972,
0.0144530972,
-0.0309391394,
-0.0669841543,
-0.0390921049,
-0.0077751237,
0.003337173,
0.0739119798,
-0.0466259345,
-0.0200292654,
-0.0353655405,
-0.0081415381,
-0.054261256,
-0.0139967334,
-0.0589403324,
0.0047603347,
-0.0117381904,
-0.0211174712,
-0.0300140511,
-0.0575721487,
0.0575149506,
-0.0021119926,
-0.0069274069,
-0.0713114515,
-0.0403694101,
-0.0130009549,
0.0438514277,
-0.033238247,
0.0300864987,
0.0045006317,
-0.0313505903,
-0.0825863332,
-0.0035979343,
0.0245822277,
-0.0170509648,
0.0454590581,
-0.0371768922,
0.040346358,
-0.0180959217,
-0.0323970914,
-0.0650585443,
-0.0710070655,
-0.0052180784,
0.0044871285,
-0.0191121381,
0.003538043,
-0.0526264384,
0.0385046788,
0.0245308541,
0.055338677,
-0.0025898796,
-0.0057042795,
-0.0135030588,
0.0544699468,
0.0365775563,
0.0452734865,
-0.0217984095,
-0.0440345779,
0.016562229,
0.0244015604,
0.0327742361,
-0.0193828363,
-0.0155115854,
0.018749088,
0.05024039,
-0.0420680232,
0.0106569743,
-0.0222790428,
0.0113960458,
-0.0416245311,
-0.0250177234,
0.1281949878,
0.0415628217,
-0.0526650771,
0.001455978,
-0.0123629719,
0.0321929604,
0.0182160325,
0.0524400175,
-0.0398288704,
-0.0051225103,
0.0187962446,
0.0341558605,
0.0347050391,
0.0013500392,
-0.017284805,
-0.0952986628,
0.0200305339,
0.054710038,
-0.0366114788,
0.0003352293,
-0.0256988779,
-0.0041392446,
0.004895201,
0.003808453,
0.0421049297,
-0.0074958405,
-0.0224981271,
0.0254902598,
-0.0025808527,
-0.0427853577,
0.0048780194,
-0.030188987,
0.070124492,
0.0501362756,
0.0231809523,
0.0359930806,
-0.0155676957,
0.0993876681,
-0.0329826362,
-0.013400767,
-0.017093258,
0.0135031193,
-0.0181866903,
-0.0004714034,
0.036670249,
-0.009472616,
-0.0059094303,
-0.0102404198,
0.0223000292,
0.0667659789,
-0.0006348027,
0.0160212517,
0.0000415864,
-0.0524937063,
0.0139990691,
0.0398596525,
0.0032673487,
-0.0523719266,
-0.0069796965,
-0.0087828115,
0.0020748833,
-0.0108131375,
-0.0227822755,
0.0165769588,
-0.0770279318,
-0.0259867385,
-0.0522323363,
-0.0083847102,
0.014198266,
0.0328441933,
0.0237191375,
-0.0154958172,
-0.0002538924,
-0.0201879069,
-0.0568932407,
0.0217823032,
-0.0547630936,
-0.0037192763,
-0.0830628574,
-0.0440953411,
0.0541310273,
-0.0138486149,
-0.0073071592,
-0.0306415353,
-0.0509146526,
-0.0550099388,
-0.0038031146,
0.0339424387,
0.0169392806,
0.0821097121,
-0.0090526277,
-0.0675046518,
0.0384713598,
0.002567569,
-0.0371223502,
0.0369687304,
0.0143802902,
0.0004577794,
-0.0099884421,
0.0360317789,
-0.0455792956,
0.0208962318,
0.0139131211,
0.0644220039,
0.0007952193,
-0.0327747911,
0.0166704245,
-0.02263611,
0.0035423834,
-0.0214425176,
-0.0048311129,
-0.0665289238,
0.0190902222,
0.0073571685,
-0.0323490165,
-0.0242901556,
0.0106361983,
0.0490766279,
-0.0007727824,
-0.0005735701,
-0.0119101256,
0.0242480207,
0.043957755,
-0.0253157448,
-0.0120896408,
0.0037433228,
0.0101357428,
0.0184855014,
0.0239903573,
-0.030096285,
0.0157568306,
0.0003768816,
0.0392209552,
-0.042503316,
0.0275232755,
0.0054402626,
-0.003530639,
-0.0620346479,
0.0494406857,
-0.0286959112,
-0.0574454665,
-0.0609490313,
0.0345056467,
0.0942482725,
0.015687732,
0.0575624853,
-0.0003939516,
-0.0336318314,
-0.0325522386,
0.0074502314,
-0.007956625,
-0.0420358293,
-0.0127789602,
0.0238647629,
-0.0210954342,
0.0437824391,
0.0687464029,
0.0231490973,
0.0269905329,
-0.0239257123,
0.0027725636,
-0.0458449721,
-0.0001511364,
-0.017457515,
-0.009447623,
-0.027225161,
0.0384250246,
-0.0132979229,
-0.0709937438,
0.0339723676,
-0.0047830665,
-0.0289497916,
0.0001043048,
0.0113184527,
0.0419131182,
-0.0141393431,
0.0196544956,
-0.032118611,
0.0054194923,
0.0416093208,
-0.0343133174,
-0.022558134,
-6.185482131e-33,
-0.0429001153,
0.0405791923,
0.0510382243,
-0.0636457354,
-0.0743144527,
-0.0070598144,
-0.0499558151,
0.0278759971,
0.0146916937,
-0.0164819509,
0.002395449,
-0.0088572707,
0.0080712298,
0.0198740158,
0.0272505302,
-0.0114350235,
0.0539057553,
0.0036686535,
-0.0093599493,
0.0383179374,
0.0319881253,
0.0327231511,
0.0488192998,
-0.0548826903,
-0.0090314159,
0.0446604453,
0.008065124,
0.0645150393,
0.0483395085,
0.0814873949,
-0.0302792769,
0.01661193,
0.0224324558,
-0.0224428754,
-0.0199687444,
-0.0254824217,
-0.064478904,
-0.0161463432,
-0.0069325799,
0.020465849,
-0.0213958714,
-0.0426717736,
0.019845929,
-0.0101395547,
-0.0016613093,
0.0124222115,
0.0201000292,
-0.0372230858,
-0.0348935835,
0.0086817024,
-0.0734626874,
0.0134989368,
-0.0083024437,
-0.035321366,
0.0126386201,
0.0043020318,
0.0135624874,
-0.0121295452,
-0.0644020364,
0.0071855765,
0.0213670526,
0.0726702139,
0.0512110628,
0.044496201,
0.0208965521,
0.0195598956,
0.0095881065,
-0.0211379621,
0.017354805,
-0.0058981017,
0.0560265817,
-0.0075657493,
-0.0069528376,
0.0125740757,
0.0351740979,
-0.0370372646,
-0.0280316286,
-0.0129365148,
0.0226654857,
0.0430875048,
0.0299368668,
0.0239705872,
0.0080566788,
-0.023600081,
-0.0482816175,
0.0290310271,
-0.0465978161,
0.010985299,
0.0584772304,
0.0510712303,
-0.0304966588,
-0.0230063293,
0.063073203,
-0.0368172079,
-0.0403687358,
0.0201887134,
-0.0079332525,
0.0337161496,
0.0037380478,
0.0407967903,
-0.0330037326,
-0.0512073077,
-0.000521973,
-0.0409702025,
-0.0180832054,
-0.0080509316,
0.0328069516,
0.0605484061,
-0.0467371531,
0.0168329272,
0.0027662425,
-0.0024959797,
0.0236559398,
0.0530357584,
0.0181289185,
0.0274971705,
0.0212934818,
0.0457959026,
0.0678957924,
-0.0238940846,
-0.0253214296,
0.0430329964,
0.032071799,
0.0338906832,
-0.0143447146,
0.0248506479,
-0.0221167877,
0.0122679239,
-0.0135099264,
-0.0956638157,
-0.005235021,
-0.0196446553,
2.509e-7,
0.0316706598,
0.0290487092,
0.0002243618,
-0.0072578667,
0.0447153337,
0.012915344,
-0.0258581769,
-0.0005187708,
0.0471675433,
0.0554395281,
0.02558388,
0.0321659148,
0.0641201958,
0.0003848822,
-0.0631163269,
-0.0104543781,
-0.0297389291,
0.0700495169,
-0.0633051395,
-0.0038588068,
0.0249779113,
0.1251498759,
0.0098150223,
0.0012838417,
-0.02097564,
-0.0850375816,
0.0859321207,
0.0140054766,
0.0222773105,
0.0285349395,
-0.01385382,
0.0595014989,
-0.02130468,
-0.0183917582,
-0.0170691516,
0.0348027609,
-0.0236845296,
0.0581025071,
-0.0386292376,
-0.0145961018,
0.0281137619,
0.0130331507,
-0.0046627135,
-0.042691879,
0.0577702597,
-0.0846514553,
0.0033303131,
-0.0094262213,
-0.006191826,
-0.0039871861,
-0.0113976886,
-0.0162388515,
-0.0504278019,
0.0284099784,
0.0475230478,
0.0350174271,
-0.0336986855,
-0.0995030105,
-0.0287808087,
0.0173323508,
-0.0534417443,
-0.0400526673,
0.0004212075,
-0.0094344812,
0.0142132724,
-0.0486408211,
0.0392090976,
2.334144235e-34,
0.0211407617,
-0.0046890392,
0.017277658,
0.0757476911,
0.0081772022,
-0.0387669951,
0.0038889118,
0.0105234319,
0.0055837212,
-0.0919672698,
-0.0122310137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01360v1 | What Makes Medical Claims (Un)Verifiable? Analyzing Entity and Relation Properties for Fact Verification | 2024-02-02T12:27:58 | 2024-02-02T12:27:58 | Amelie Wührl, Yarik Menchaca Resendiz, Lara Grimminger, Roman Klinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical claim verification fails if no evidence can be discovered. In
these cases, the fact-checking verdict remains unknown and the claim is
unverifiable. To improve upon this, we have to understand if there are any
claim properties that impact its verifiability. In this work we assume that
entities and relations define the core variables in a biomedical claim's
anatomy and analyze if their properties help us to differentiate verifiable
from unverifiable claims. In a study with trained annotation experts we prompt
them to find evidence for biomedical claims, and observe how they refine search
queries for their evidence search. This leads to the first corpus for
scientific fact verification annotated with subject-relation-object triplets,
evidence documents, and fact-checking verdicts (the BEAR-Fact corpus). We find
(1) that discovering evidence for negated claims (e.g., X-does-not-cause-Y) is
particularly challenging. Further, we see that annotators process queries
mostly by adding constraints to the search and by normalizing entities to
canonical names. (2) We compare our in-house annotations with a small
crowdsourcing setting where we employ medical experts and laypeople. We find
that domain expertise does not have a substantial effect on the reliability of
annotations. Finally, (3), we demonstrate that it is possible to reliably
estimate the success of evidence retrieval purely from the claim text~(.82\F),
whereas identifying unverifiable claims proves more challenging (.27\F). The
dataset is available at http://www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/data/bioclaim. | What Makes Medical Claims (Un)Verifiable? Analyzing Entity and Relation Properties for Fact Verification: Biomedical claim verification fails if no evidence can be discovered. In
these cases, the fact-checking verdict remains unknown and the claim is
unverifiable. To improve upon this, we have to understand if there are any
claim properties that impact its verifiability. In this work we assume that
entities and relations define the core variables in a biomedical claim's
anatomy and analyze if their properties help us to differentiate verifiable
from unverifiable claims. In a study with trained annotation experts we prompt
them to find evidence for biomedical claims, and observe how they refine search
queries for their evidence search. This leads to the first corpus for
scientific fact verification annotated with subject-relation-object triplets,
evidence documents, and fact-checking verdicts (the BEAR-Fact corpus). We find
(1) that discovering evidence for negated claims (e.g., X-does-not-cause-Y) is
particularly challenging. Further, we see that annotators process queries
mostly by adding constraints to the search and by normalizing entities to
canonical names. (2) We compare our in-house annotations with a small
crowdsourcing setting where we employ medical experts and laypeople. We find
that domain expertise does not have a substantial effect on the reliability of
annotations. Finally, (3), we demonstrate that it is possible to reliably
estimate the success of evidence retrieval purely from the claim text~(.82\F),
whereas identifying unverifiable claims proves more challenging (.27\F). The
dataset is available at http://www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/data/bioclaim. | [
0.0652240738,
0.0414031893,
0.0207128264,
-0.0156509951,
-0.0084136967,
0.0060188081,
-0.0065547312,
0.0285206344,
0.0071219504,
-0.0219710451,
0.0360165723,
0.0100176437,
0.015256023,
-0.0204764809,
-0.0024239966,
-0.0220310241,
0.0206624214,
0.0456312932,
0.1103167757,
-0.0100061698,
-0.008164959,
0.0017815387,
-0.0508440696,
0.0386711098,
-0.0435430929,
0.0137949185,
0.0465210602,
-0.0145958345,
0.0147705814,
-0.0842375159,
-0.0016093478,
0.0512145646,
-0.033266589,
0.0405405574,
0.0000018551,
-0.0467154793,
-0.0249168258,
0.0622939989,
-0.0644885376,
-0.0091127558,
0.0027444933,
0.0164457094,
0.0031654809,
0.0130946888,
-0.0122493794,
-0.0437617302,
0.0489932895,
0.0524026975,
0.0258726832,
0.0872368813,
-0.0178968981,
-0.0010687704,
0.0122681428,
-0.013170871,
0.0236580409,
-0.0197977461,
0.0365163237,
0.0145046832,
0.0372398533,
0.0129066361,
0.0476895534,
0.0524875782,
-0.033622019,
-0.0013964731,
-0.0101070292,
0.0351367779,
-0.0472558104,
-0.0348197073,
0.0340160243,
0.0124579566,
0.0688524097,
-0.0316616222,
0.0272705834,
0.0122067593,
0.0094666779,
0.080977492,
0.002479523,
0.0379975885,
-0.0333597325,
-0.026692573,
0.0168888066,
0.0270888675,
0.0452549942,
-0.0000847654,
0.01948932,
0.0219388101,
-0.0267741773,
-0.0339953266,
0.0171671659,
0.0006332643,
0.0175762326,
-0.0883717164,
0.0363639481,
-0.0074197869,
-0.0120035401,
0.0167626385,
0.0195845682,
-0.0307288542,
0.1095708311,
-0.0549339205,
-0.0248593334,
-0.0317513533,
-0.0453892164,
0.054749392,
-0.0166049451,
-0.0532478727,
-0.0431116894,
0.0291897431,
0.0096545452,
0.0010010774,
-0.0481062233,
-0.0215340126,
-0.0202685054,
0.0156960152,
-0.001180323,
0.0430357195,
-0.0441543758,
-0.0593770333,
-0.023591375,
0.0297622681,
-0.0239409786,
0.0007154426,
-0.0218126904,
-0.0030033006,
-0.0556723922,
0.0163688753,
-0.006593233,
0.0293051712,
-0.0245205313,
-0.0393275023,
0.0231717937,
0.028609233,
0.0263052452,
0.0021731632,
0.0280670002,
0.005358886,
0.0476122387,
-0.0199264847,
-0.0089870896,
-0.0626993552,
-0.0129793249,
-0.0113278329,
0.0126437703,
-0.0298062097,
-0.0113711022,
0.0045564268,
-0.004623001,
-0.0535854772,
-0.0025420461,
0.0163158327,
-0.0430470258,
0.0491905101,
-0.0740988255,
-0.0159446765,
0.0254263654,
0.0158123206,
0.0058862003,
0.0025249184,
0.0281406529,
0.0032929019,
0.0425589196,
0.0150186354,
0.0201165043,
-0.033351168,
0.0604816638,
-0.0340754762,
0.0868394524,
0.0228065606,
-0.0023103605,
0.0493382402,
-0.0652842373,
0.044719968,
-0.0426494628,
-0.0389696509,
0.0193483531,
0.0393796749,
-0.011491172,
-0.0482368022,
-0.0111946976,
-0.0432486832,
0.0328641608,
-0.0085018743,
-0.0305091646,
-0.0008313521,
-0.018879829,
-0.0249291901,
0.0057426612,
-0.0199779905,
0.0168529246,
-0.0613101721,
-0.0521547869,
0.0238377899,
-0.0585759915,
-0.0300449692,
0.0202120189,
0.0095154755,
-0.000371423,
0.0325742401,
0.026925629,
-0.0331525318,
-0.0207736585,
-0.0311891194,
0.008598052,
-0.0268092919,
0.0353777409,
-0.0199811105,
-0.011935669,
-0.0024529831,
-0.0110437097,
0.0236053206,
0.0259976815,
-0.0325819999,
-0.0181860961,
0.0083690574,
-0.0253932532,
0.0079617025,
0.0305347871,
-0.0371511951,
0.0321037471,
0.0252701584,
-0.0130684217,
-0.0446739867,
-0.0347052403,
0.0265286285,
-0.0145742474,
0.0103027709,
-0.020245675,
0.0026218444,
0.0553817116,
0.0367146432,
0.0069390284,
0.0452399477,
0.0285209324,
-0.0191315301,
-0.0444646664,
0.024130404,
0.0807242617,
0.0297555327,
0.0030630399,
-0.0917240307,
-0.0340269841,
-0.0365943834,
0.0083281081,
-0.0073623355,
-0.071206525,
-0.0546142645,
0.0156058259,
-0.0182508901,
-0.0179208089,
0.016992528,
-0.0361190848,
-0.0290281661,
0.0424806438,
0.0109942518,
-0.0097507127,
-0.0453353859,
-0.0651822612,
0.0509162396,
-0.0407262109,
-0.0376493409,
-0.0006028633,
0.0297641642,
0.0050848546,
0.0332342386,
-0.0719188005,
-0.0262471847,
0.0250424352,
-0.0979166478,
-0.0070209848,
0.0154079124,
0.0314813405,
-0.0274341088,
-0.0247825291,
0.0176688917,
-0.0261130724,
-0.0163102001,
-0.0507505462,
-0.0040302011,
0.0288225673,
0.0503133647,
0.0252889264,
0.0097718043,
-0.0224805754,
-0.0044339299,
-0.0414437428,
0.0096275555,
0.0526394472,
-0.0500371158,
0.0021667711,
0.0066704997,
-0.0276302174,
0.0122453496,
0.0065887538,
0.0303282365,
0.0483888797,
0.0258498527,
-0.052387666,
0.0263819396,
0.0068266792,
0.0187606867,
0.0249268003,
0.0370265171,
-0.0150333755,
0.0014630515,
-0.0308206752,
0.0017361045,
0.0251245499,
-0.0453468263,
0.0582242347,
0.0301447082,
-0.0018387429,
-0.0283938702,
-0.0424051471,
0.0132807083,
-0.0343691893,
-0.0023520202,
0.011452863,
0.0112710297,
0.0094872136,
0.0742708445,
0.0014036488,
-0.0163878072,
0.0791491196,
-0.0228273645,
0.0324426368,
-0.0344123431,
0.0069333543,
0.0152855897,
0.0099002151,
0.0133198444,
0.013883641,
0.0606810227,
0.0117118405,
0.0458908565,
0.0035541232,
0.0830339789,
-0.0386620834,
-0.0238130223,
0.0044620978,
0.0631214306,
0.0105321137,
-0.0521501489,
-0.0136064468,
-0.0356356464,
-0.0239839461,
-0.0118446862,
-0.0284137521,
-0.0040999255,
-0.0811826587,
-0.0119037386,
0.0264789443,
0.0491552986,
0.0320758633,
-0.0124111176,
0.0038837001,
-0.0310023706,
-0.0094930325,
0.0268466529,
0.0240778066,
-0.0071845078,
-0.0634852871,
0.076593481,
-0.047146067,
0.0110332174,
-0.0086958017,
-0.0363030322,
-0.0353370719,
-0.0446244292,
0.0028508152,
-0.0256755017,
0.0127904583,
-0.0538468696,
0.0184834599,
0.0511519834,
0.0115684066,
0.0276314002,
0.0256186165,
0.0156792477,
-0.0583804995,
0.0060382225,
0.0093909521,
-0.1230851561,
0.0106587904,
-0.0258620996,
0.003265463,
-0.0488895029,
-0.0416880213,
0.0024161316,
-0.0362061821,
0.0701211989,
-0.0248944387,
0.0161238797,
-0.004721534,
-0.0884546041,
0.0071598422,
-0.045305945,
-0.030645702,
-0.0140629383,
0.0398466103,
0.0133069148,
0.0242486466,
-0.0103922943,
-0.0575421527,
0.0127043081,
-0.0256238393,
0.0301669631,
0.0336463079,
0.0285927001,
-0.0197020452,
-0.0550382212,
-0.0459937677,
0.0487614311,
-0.0229777396,
0.0082115717,
0.1056300104,
-0.0022040554,
0.0044534481,
-0.0561120138,
0.0090319384,
-0.0306032319,
-0.0309822224,
-0.0083666388,
0.0567853004,
-0.026147861,
-0.0264195781,
-0.0550048985,
-0.0201946981,
-0.0147315729,
0.0706967339,
-0.0025748869,
0.0442477129,
-0.0068941889,
0.009226406,
0.0363410711,
0.0192373209,
-0.0387989879,
0.071860835,
-0.0448013768,
-0.0532554574,
-0.0798690617,
0.001795055,
0.0143393027,
0.0447036177,
-0.0105020218,
0.0012225275,
0.0527307428,
0.0074932463,
-0.0640164241,
0.0881044194,
-0.0153357023,
0.0121019054,
-0.023365017,
-0.0097340131,
0.060636308,
0.0302363615,
-0.023047816,
0.005415,
0.0170483757,
-0.0131007889,
-0.0355956368,
-0.0043980205,
0.0273606237,
-0.0052695344,
-0.0147999628,
-0.0556931421,
-0.0267474186,
0.0798305646,
-0.0274448097,
-0.0248468928,
0.0082208207,
-0.0662715435,
-0.0222484004,
-0.0236818679,
-0.0087912483,
0.0443213731,
-0.01523533,
0.0194983445,
-0.0433698036,
-0.0073731435,
0.0656130761,
0.0853485912,
0.0914491117,
-0.0121450275,
0.0008090766,
-0.0105377659,
-0.0129614323,
0.0010091346,
-0.019279195,
-0.0190260708,
-0.0170403402,
-0.0105202068,
0.0017126868,
-0.0173317436,
0.0083172116,
-0.05016388,
0.0297801755,
-0.0206829943,
0.0303548537,
0.0106371325,
0.0238813534,
0.0245742444,
-0.0359283127,
-0.0005332759,
-0.0177427027,
-0.0111028226,
0.0622650422,
0.0004120011,
-0.0143615808,
0.0363597125,
0.0031990069,
0.0201537069,
-0.023568023,
-0.0592816509,
0.0063409745,
-0.0256970171,
0.0402529798,
-0.001261628,
0.0098794131,
0.023307059,
-0.0329399444,
-0.007845141,
-0.0091583626,
-0.0060784104,
0.000183062,
0.0278173238,
0.0433632173,
0.0114575597,
-0.0218746234,
-0.0162380934,
0.0572335906,
0.0199198294,
0.0642738268,
-0.055872228,
-0.060923405,
-0.0372699313,
-0.0700213835,
-0.0403015018,
0.0072036646,
-0.029144844,
-0.0173671097,
-0.0875494182,
-0.0283374004,
-0.0003588344,
0.0384976082,
0.007915427,
0.0146351978,
-0.0190816745,
0.0611814782,
0.0276772417,
-0.0654321909,
-0.0146080554,
0.0517586023,
-0.0334833078,
0.0126888501,
0.0263649747,
-6.120716065e-33,
-0.0046641668,
-0.0908825845,
-0.0088466853,
0.0081186295,
0.0463070422,
0.0510036349,
-0.0327438638,
-0.0096025094,
-0.0211875346,
0.0757729784,
0.0080775553,
0.0363482684,
0.0195167121,
-0.0263381228,
0.0243703723,
0.015592766,
0.0470417365,
0.0206163116,
-0.0458840318,
-0.0097945454,
0.0197473448,
-0.0219371598,
0.0257487074,
-0.1437121481,
0.0692746714,
0.016758794,
-0.006963193,
0.03633973,
-0.068443574,
0.0656347424,
0.0085045742,
0.0046640825,
0.0208847672,
-0.0168677531,
0.022505777,
-0.0497361794,
-0.0911562145,
0.016352253,
0.0317929685,
-0.0210589822,
-0.0563694127,
-0.0146046281,
0.0566208325,
-0.0021200876,
-0.0456981733,
0.0164616145,
0.0253232922,
-0.0305216368,
-0.0040688096,
-0.0673936605,
-0.0122974543,
0.0526871458,
0.0240084156,
0.0187898558,
-0.0021048423,
-0.0073850099,
-0.0068747597,
0.027932886,
-0.0305558387,
0.017973749,
-0.0232449342,
-0.0085998429,
-0.0156745818,
-0.0749649853,
-0.0321598984,
0.0609749779,
-0.0071118539,
0.0519695729,
-0.0101496056,
-0.0013339604,
-0.0420474634,
0.0552625842,
0.0627836138,
0.0860850364,
0.0446095765,
0.0225199349,
-0.0819440782,
0.0250530336,
-0.0300014168,
0.011939724,
0.0018759198,
-0.01641169,
-0.0564470477,
0.0039723832,
-0.0266257208,
-0.011191139,
-0.0179811623,
0.0356808975,
-0.0182343088,
0.016505884,
0.000108406,
0.0564337187,
-0.0269822273,
-0.0156075666,
0.0189762935,
-0.0310623366,
0.0487533323,
-0.0090831518,
-0.0278726146,
-0.0048585786,
-0.0476771966,
0.0264186878,
-0.007439625,
0.0179356821,
0.0422564596,
0.0258595701,
0.046359051,
-0.043849431,
-0.0393746048,
-0.0115282759,
0.0241995156,
0.0157902949,
-0.0213331748,
-0.0542800277,
0.0601720177,
0.0330186039,
0.0221682899,
0.0098932739,
0.010617286,
0.0394348577,
-0.0504059233,
0.0170762204,
-0.0106187118,
-0.015479981,
0.0018769912,
-0.024556838,
0.0156378318,
0.0145943714,
0.0069030453,
-0.0551131777,
0.0386275984,
-0.0019027637,
2.792e-7,
0.0681876764,
0.0537916794,
0.0349956714,
-0.0131311473,
0.0293670949,
0.039896898,
0.0079539884,
-0.0366923399,
0.0136477398,
-0.1007949784,
-0.0007910817,
-0.0182593204,
0.0107573736,
0.031052202,
-0.0715068206,
-0.0724117458,
-0.0231226273,
-0.0462866351,
-0.0115515944,
0.009462541,
0.0408239327,
-0.011816442,
0.0046744742,
-0.0060802456,
-0.0202059522,
-0.009081969,
0.0403257087,
-0.0078808358,
0.0119640864,
0.0204752143,
0.0835129768,
-0.0129378764,
0.0411260538,
0.0715293214,
-0.0363525413,
0.0127614103,
0.0028223391,
0.0639566705,
-0.0094771916,
0.030980913,
-0.0173702314,
-0.0451731905,
0.0425025895,
-0.0026886854,
0.0003056661,
-0.0165932197,
-0.052242022,
-0.0422582887,
-0.0176079739,
0.0113327373,
0.0406851694,
0.0422885902,
-0.0072464175,
-0.0033261315,
-0.0150175756,
0.0347839855,
-0.0165342223,
-0.0458812416,
-0.0071992511,
0.0296453498,
-0.0266562514,
-0.0534143783,
0.0386457667,
-0.022815872,
0.0089523401,
-0.0697019473,
-0.0080226986,
1.984250076e-34,
0.0206304826,
0.0110359723,
0.0107734678,
-0.0232329331,
0.0472987778,
0.0277537312,
-0.0031839886,
-0.0175663009,
0.0259405226,
-0.0122233285,
0.0067179264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01352v1 | Describing Images $\textit{Fast and Slow}$: Quantifying and Predicting the Variation in Human Signals during Visuo-Linguistic Processes | 2024-02-02T12:11:16 | 2024-02-02T12:11:16 | Ece Takmaz, Sandro Pezzelle, Raquel Fernández | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | There is an intricate relation between the properties of an image and how
humans behave while describing the image. This behavior shows ample variation,
as manifested in human signals such as eye movements and when humans start to
describe the image. Despite the value of such signals of visuo-linguistic
variation, they are virtually disregarded in the training of current pretrained
models, which motivates further investigation. Using a corpus of Dutch image
descriptions with concurrently collected eye-tracking data, we explore the
nature of the variation in visuo-linguistic signals, and find that they
correlate with each other. Given this result, we hypothesize that variation
stems partly from the properties of the images, and explore whether image
representations encoded by pretrained vision encoders can capture such
variation. Our results indicate that pretrained models do so to a
weak-to-moderate degree, suggesting that the models lack biases about what
makes a stimulus complex for humans and what leads to variations in human
outputs. | Describing Images $\textit{Fast and Slow}$: Quantifying and Predicting the Variation in Human Signals during Visuo-Linguistic Processes: There is an intricate relation between the properties of an image and how
humans behave while describing the image. This behavior shows ample variation,
as manifested in human signals such as eye movements and when humans start to
describe the image. Despite the value of such signals of visuo-linguistic
variation, they are virtually disregarded in the training of current pretrained
models, which motivates further investigation. Using a corpus of Dutch image
descriptions with concurrently collected eye-tracking data, we explore the
nature of the variation in visuo-linguistic signals, and find that they
correlate with each other. Given this result, we hypothesize that variation
stems partly from the properties of the images, and explore whether image
representations encoded by pretrained vision encoders can capture such
variation. Our results indicate that pretrained models do so to a
weak-to-moderate degree, suggesting that the models lack biases about what
makes a stimulus complex for humans and what leads to variations in human
outputs. | [
0.0097258538,
0.0380448103,
-0.0383378901,
0.0379962362,
0.0076137744,
0.0213009715,
-0.0232177749,
0.0067328573,
-0.0209701974,
-0.068534188,
-0.0546452291,
-0.0710793585,
0.0530774146,
0.0749512538,
0.0127097126,
-0.1259235293,
-0.0045931335,
-0.0136930197,
-0.0347826332,
-0.0032866045,
0.0337053016,
-0.0402131118,
0.0143698938,
0.0301806759,
0.0007335058,
0.0094412751,
-0.0436920971,
0.008981212,
0.006873521,
0.0040542553,
0.0116164759,
0.0678022653,
-0.0075494736,
-0.0398532376,
0.0000019736,
-0.0027293058,
0.0904394165,
-0.0588180982,
0.0276170671,
0.0419901982,
0.0085874684,
-0.0303433314,
-0.0037860989,
-0.0417622477,
-0.0218309183,
-0.0520408675,
0.0794032365,
0.0044828877,
0.0470255502,
0.0304878242,
-0.0058722789,
-0.0259840284,
-0.0240686424,
-0.0547470599,
0.0393858254,
0.0011342776,
0.006587483,
-0.025085222,
0.0081789605,
0.0050415662,
-0.102339007,
-0.0227201078,
0.0220739264,
0.0796269625,
0.0603126436,
0.0366877243,
-0.0077701523,
-0.0328095742,
-0.0280308817,
0.0829899311,
-0.0187232774,
-0.0340880379,
-0.0341296978,
-0.0095055476,
0.0023659372,
0.0154835451,
0.0115646571,
0.0263393614,
-0.0170074366,
-0.0001095586,
-0.064190872,
0.0416374914,
-0.0133749172,
-0.0092832297,
-0.0005622917,
-0.0374558717,
-0.0031288159,
-0.0056457273,
0.0115820169,
0.0301724877,
-0.0072757252,
-0.0486364774,
-0.0062903003,
-0.025612535,
0.0275883451,
-0.0577226169,
-0.050129097,
-0.0365068391,
-0.0049233497,
-0.0309479069,
0.0518603921,
-0.0041022017,
-0.0909345746,
0.0144222891,
0.0178064704,
0.1143298298,
-0.0613465086,
0.0121455844,
-0.0742489398,
0.0115705989,
-0.0617479086,
-0.0136984745,
-0.0078746676,
-0.0288611799,
0.0124906078,
-0.0322623588,
-0.0525749139,
0.0199683104,
-0.0308339372,
-0.0269275438,
-0.0503298901,
0.0546267182,
-0.0268972162,
0.0068885488,
-0.0703221262,
0.0085653523,
-0.0252562463,
0.0291365553,
-0.0390179791,
-0.0467932709,
-0.0044740355,
0.0581436493,
-0.0030457452,
-0.0037735139,
-0.0007389537,
0.0327349827,
-0.0087464545,
0.010769357,
0.0105947666,
0.001183402,
0.0007821444,
-0.0270113405,
0.0365448631,
-0.0238788724,
0.0276666395,
0.0073189782,
0.0162657313,
-0.0482883081,
-0.0236400459,
-0.0184813775,
-0.0089030089,
0.065349333,
-0.0563663729,
0.0024964071,
-0.0238785911,
-0.0055812974,
0.0205673538,
0.0315835103,
0.0313746743,
0.0180861354,
-0.0168832857,
-0.0409902483,
0.030477602,
0.026213102,
-0.0167346951,
0.0098276827,
-0.0269256253,
-0.0398375206,
0.0295315627,
0.0229681116,
0.0985054746,
0.0493788384,
-0.0428010225,
-0.0701665431,
0.0699001774,
0.0690446645,
0.0057841009,
0.000082319,
0.0602132045,
0.0054513146,
0.0382202156,
0.051329881,
-0.0162402224,
0.0467863791,
0.0633000955,
0.0177258141,
-0.0500481203,
0.0281478614,
-0.0588418804,
-0.0350621082,
-0.0034462092,
-0.0442290567,
0.0443683378,
-0.0068303952,
0.0173290893,
0.0079277195,
0.001302858,
0.0293296855,
0.0127557563,
0.0033135074,
-0.0025534695,
-0.0301021319,
-0.0026283583,
0.0883317143,
-0.0324261971,
0.0393654183,
0.0279809944,
-0.0031270119,
0.0120511027,
0.0156360939,
0.0227099825,
0.0233372208,
0.0430601649,
-0.0368980095,
-0.060004767,
-0.0586928055,
0.0086194556,
0.0168010611,
-0.0364209488,
-0.0242748689,
0.0035231533,
0.019391831,
-0.0249980353,
0.0297414958,
0.0379072204,
0.0152628087,
-0.0023092006,
0.0064960974,
0.0262021571,
-0.0282127876,
-0.0076113627,
0.0241871923,
0.0083682379,
0.0032867286,
0.0773744881,
0.071250245,
-0.0189393442,
0.0081448713,
0.0080857174,
-0.0644987896,
0.0019353526,
0.0219046045,
0.0162529424,
-0.0301733632,
0.0102768326,
-0.0683451444,
-0.0260616187,
-0.0055418103,
0.0156580247,
0.0201667659,
0.0394329727,
0.0259404667,
0.0323072933,
-0.0096654054,
-0.0020972535,
-0.0119736595,
0.0143455239,
0.0337228589,
-0.0317852907,
-0.0077854474,
0.0118803559,
-0.0057470952,
0.0037008803,
0.0000397222,
-0.0182915758,
-0.0439852327,
0.0319414586,
-0.0383876115,
-0.043961402,
-0.0241392441,
-0.0366867408,
0.0126353344,
-0.0086123561,
-0.0011072032,
-0.0383747667,
-0.0270408932,
0.0756568462,
-0.0226458441,
0.0081260037,
0.0100887269,
0.0076746773,
-0.0049791713,
-0.0211160742,
-0.0003846878,
0.0391896814,
0.0696953237,
0.0105330572,
-0.0223229751,
-0.0575022884,
0.0408696234,
-0.0042063296,
0.033078827,
0.0059627537,
-0.0430295616,
0.0392751954,
0.0096799703,
0.0065930677,
0.0938050821,
0.0477413796,
0.0585746802,
0.0582771748,
-0.0013404887,
-0.0191633049,
-0.0499523766,
-0.0183936954,
-0.0019586156,
-0.0208564103,
-0.0377646461,
0.0152409822,
0.0408417471,
0.0373575054,
0.0335387774,
-0.0967360139,
0.0041947635,
0.0138008194,
-0.0619108714,
-0.0239296407,
-0.0013479142,
-0.0199760888,
0.0570236854,
-0.0262528267,
-0.0723543093,
0.057550773,
0.0106598968,
-0.0210247692,
0.0191535056,
0.045107007,
0.0185175538,
0.0580932647,
0.024183318,
0.0064421464,
0.002597956,
0.0296450462,
-0.0430705585,
0.0183658618,
0.0418563485,
0.014985323,
0.0201694369,
-0.0344016589,
-0.0337071121,
-0.0123569397,
-0.0217016097,
-0.0262783784,
-0.014480467,
-0.038080506,
-0.0072460212,
-0.0052820356,
0.0228547435,
-0.0067854617,
0.0366822481,
0.0123400288,
-0.0022323418,
-0.0071226992,
-0.0337464288,
-0.0049090791,
0.0175859556,
0.0496016592,
0.0210477356,
-0.0414988175,
-0.0845933333,
-0.022136189,
0.0571636334,
-0.0148099735,
0.0585268587,
-0.0982146785,
0.0595630296,
-0.0079211779,
0.0072637424,
-0.0285412651,
0.0558869541,
0.0097474745,
-0.0138759725,
-0.0112795802,
0.0542823747,
0.0101998271,
-0.0316474847,
0.0367978513,
0.0311423223,
-0.002445753,
0.0169499535,
0.0115797929,
-0.0673943385,
-0.0206142236,
-0.0476807579,
-0.006348351,
0.0234935042,
0.0089194458,
0.0026026135,
-0.0387737602,
0.0306320451,
0.0627303347,
-0.0172077883,
-0.0478402227,
0.0086278124,
0.0040602144,
-0.0006777076,
-0.0072879069,
-0.0305457152,
-0.0000230262,
0.0420719124,
0.0356028713,
0.0136050163,
-0.0194571149,
0.0089007178,
-0.0438310243,
-0.0148138627,
0.0589527972,
-0.0420271307,
0.0026945579,
-0.0449361689,
-0.0192767121,
-0.0194332246,
0.0206180718,
0.0080720577,
0.0627399161,
-0.0256967321,
-0.0520052873,
-0.0299922824,
0.0115357609,
-0.0279330201,
-0.0316123962,
-0.0374222398,
-0.022206204,
-0.0555941053,
-0.010048301,
-0.0353097841,
-0.009256999,
-0.0144210206,
0.0146069461,
0.0070666308,
-0.0775675178,
-0.0059054527,
-0.0092281066,
0.0202660952,
-0.0294088144,
-0.078170687,
0.0267670639,
0.0309565719,
-0.0312470961,
-0.0454635061,
-0.0705898106,
-0.0494718626,
0.0203755517,
0.0121937785,
-0.0619056337,
0.0599230565,
-0.0289576203,
-0.0682493225,
0.0932697281,
0.0397880115,
-0.0060835821,
-0.0488706417,
-0.0788383335,
0.0347426608,
-0.0080133826,
-0.011003647,
-0.0059652147,
-0.0675223917,
-0.0251145121,
0.0210097879,
0.0360523909,
0.0140430117,
0.0533394329,
0.0214394592,
-0.0558355525,
-0.0153315365,
0.0037344918,
0.0202984214,
0.0572099648,
-0.0194323231,
-0.0208128504,
-0.0145858442,
-0.0172443613,
-0.0323392823,
0.013012263,
0.0194578469,
-0.0403572246,
-0.0166198965,
-0.0698339567,
0.0173976626,
-0.02434,
0.0665469021,
-0.0350664556,
0.0215783603,
-0.0012995134,
-0.019285962,
0.0431256592,
0.0129886447,
-0.042409867,
-0.0216338262,
0.050887838,
0.0371323116,
-0.0116460593,
0.0087101236,
-0.002083512,
-0.0185440537,
-0.0523291938,
-0.0137360012,
0.0019942739,
-0.0228435453,
-0.0522571951,
0.0477921292,
0.0278358273,
0.0432321019,
-0.009811772,
0.024950752,
0.0276883002,
0.0442224517,
0.0291910227,
0.0331709199,
-0.0111211706,
0.0041177529,
-0.0042091259,
-0.0285980962,
-0.0336789489,
-0.0216839314,
0.0091100037,
-0.0506881215,
0.0094877901,
-0.013565545,
0.0271679126,
-0.0508365892,
0.0351773612,
0.0046372991,
0.0046708989,
0.0237667225,
-0.0030540132,
-0.0039064963,
-0.0138473017,
0.0559140667,
-0.0056106402,
0.0102444347,
-0.0097545739,
-0.0141619481,
-0.0582886301,
-0.0016890801,
0.0389810838,
-0.0200585257,
-0.0078657204,
0.0425434411,
0.0001693218,
-0.0434350148,
0.0433772728,
-0.0052076112,
0.0657099485,
0.0326728821,
0.108490333,
0.0385337546,
-0.0359989256,
0.0150055904,
-0.0071521471,
-0.0539642386,
0.0119981486,
0.0143430578,
-0.019586198,
-5.633734837e-33,
-0.0038917309,
-0.0006322766,
-0.0178169943,
-0.0251724329,
0.0002159702,
-0.0157311335,
-0.0061811106,
0.0199242514,
0.0085514942,
0.0212161802,
0.060995806,
0.0093956208,
0.0125561031,
0.0071865721,
0.0361764506,
-0.0155244088,
0.0174137373,
-0.0166958403,
-0.0290246569,
-0.0266020745,
0.042406071,
-0.0204949938,
0.0471688546,
-0.0787350014,
0.0076997941,
0.009698363,
-0.0238970444,
-0.0305778515,
0.0593497157,
0.0641234368,
-0.0494928546,
0.0602396503,
0.0190107897,
0.0210636985,
-0.0281466637,
-0.0031925743,
-0.0254394934,
-0.0138536179,
0.0048426581,
0.0822331682,
-0.0638886541,
-0.011176154,
0.0756618157,
-0.0153364232,
-0.0423257463,
-0.0194758922,
0.060516119,
-0.0288864262,
0.0146502443,
-0.0157549754,
-0.0469157211,
-0.0268627256,
-0.0362144671,
-0.035892155,
0.0553027242,
0.0283502601,
-0.0333471373,
-0.0090912348,
-0.0338159613,
0.0412190482,
-0.0260125175,
0.010030848,
0.0234160889,
0.0396313891,
0.0587862469,
0.0444924794,
0.0731468201,
0.0199171491,
-0.0166738946,
-0.0148135535,
0.0527161472,
0.006564701,
0.0244871564,
0.0344596691,
0.0520065874,
-0.0044675078,
-0.0152349584,
0.0023103836,
-0.0494889766,
0.0717188939,
-0.0062511708,
0.0229062289,
-0.0296572614,
-0.0191219114,
-0.0036571149,
-0.0014209615,
-0.0178322867,
-0.0128158974,
0.0276898537,
-0.0079852277,
0.047286123,
0.003022443,
0.0569242015,
-0.0284978207,
0.0208692104,
-0.0562727526,
-0.0471705645,
0.0650868639,
0.0259568635,
-0.0203911252,
-0.0221791789,
-0.034975376,
0.0550037362,
0.0086802691,
0.0426066779,
0.0191296283,
-0.0119074862,
-0.0025837759,
-0.0157575142,
-0.028363714,
-0.0050052842,
-0.0350230075,
0.0258578733,
-0.0292847008,
0.0535484776,
0.0133270286,
-0.050633166,
0.0294156857,
-0.0714774132,
-0.0604404248,
-0.0360259265,
-0.0480342992,
0.0153312301,
0.0663792714,
-0.0151434261,
0.020010177,
-0.0597602762,
-0.0245635081,
0.0025547643,
-0.0247866493,
-0.0167624056,
0.0386427306,
2.704e-7,
0.0143982423,
0.0140962759,
0.0156059945,
0.0083756624,
0.0479696207,
0.0327229872,
-0.0103143733,
0.0208424795,
-0.0176773835,
-0.0752267465,
0.0239997134,
0.0573057234,
0.0301967673,
-0.0562123805,
-0.0075435424,
0.013460408,
-0.0103071127,
0.0319897719,
-0.0244429801,
0.003688731,
0.0467425585,
0.0348423123,
-0.0339089371,
0.0311279465,
0.0448163934,
-0.01512744,
0.1138074845,
-0.0273082517,
0.0280057117,
-0.0161229447,
0.0262103304,
-0.0007223479,
-0.0160214156,
0.0771668404,
-0.0158633832,
-0.0304614957,
0.0488852337,
-0.0230629481,
-0.0513205156,
-0.0165109113,
-0.0170358904,
0.0154847428,
0.0015454969,
-0.0218750276,
0.0452550836,
-0.043288812,
-0.0318008997,
0.0062601347,
-0.024227988,
0.0265934523,
0.0545391627,
-0.0166925658,
-0.0242087115,
0.0048369886,
0.039626725,
0.0149476053,
-0.0446341597,
-0.0581068471,
-0.0238804594,
0.0086760893,
-0.0678986758,
-0.0070204418,
-0.0525755137,
0.0167278126,
0.0824041739,
0.0348959491,
-0.0278887693,
1.330251167e-34,
0.0210594051,
0.0316255167,
0.0543597266,
0.0022826516,
-0.0077131218,
-0.0395676941,
-0.0221773386,
0.014265894,
0.024816988,
-0.0206148047,
-0.0180232283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01349v2 | Beyond the Answers: Reviewing the Rationality of Multiple Choice Question Answering for the Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T12:07:00 | 2024-05-30T01:57:14 | Haochun Wang, Sendong Zhao, Zewen Qiang, Nuwa Xi, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the field of natural language processing (NLP), Large Language Models
(LLMs) have precipitated a paradigm shift, markedly enhancing performance in
natural language generation tasks. Despite these advancements, the
comprehensive evaluation of LLMs remains an inevitable challenge for the
community. Recently, the utilization of Multiple Choice Question Answering
(MCQA) as a benchmark for LLMs has gained considerable traction. This study
first investigates the limitations of MCQA as an evaluation method for LLMs and
then analyzes the fundamental reason for the limitations of MCQA, that while
LLMs may select the correct answers, it is possible that they also recognize
other wrong options as correct. Finally, we propose a dataset augmenting method
for Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs), MCQA+, that can more accurately reflect
the performance of the model, which underscores the need for more robust
evaluation mechanisms in assessing the performance of LLMs. | Beyond the Answers: Reviewing the Rationality of Multiple Choice Question Answering for the Evaluation of Large Language Models: In the field of natural language processing (NLP), Large Language Models
(LLMs) have precipitated a paradigm shift, markedly enhancing performance in
natural language generation tasks. Despite these advancements, the
comprehensive evaluation of LLMs remains an inevitable challenge for the
community. Recently, the utilization of Multiple Choice Question Answering
(MCQA) as a benchmark for LLMs has gained considerable traction. This study
first investigates the limitations of MCQA as an evaluation method for LLMs and
then analyzes the fundamental reason for the limitations of MCQA, that while
LLMs may select the correct answers, it is possible that they also recognize
other wrong options as correct. Finally, we propose a dataset augmenting method
for Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs), MCQA+, that can more accurately reflect
the performance of the model, which underscores the need for more robust
evaluation mechanisms in assessing the performance of LLMs. | [
0.0597997829,
0.0576246753,
-0.0123515418,
0.035483364,
-0.0578241833,
0.0324513949,
0.0238813628,
-0.0044162134,
0.0265264101,
-0.0735643581,
0.0039602285,
-0.0402810611,
-0.0156724136,
-0.018540889,
0.0273778327,
0.0042252713,
0.0294223949,
-0.0391742513,
-0.0106345536,
0.0016110627,
0.0107889697,
0.0249736048,
0.023308564,
0.035786666,
0.0116393454,
-0.0038321298,
0.0061173895,
-0.0082140863,
0.005972221,
-0.0341868512,
-0.0014984544,
0.0621602535,
0.0120686963,
0.0318134278,
0.0000018384,
-0.0767294914,
0.0132297976,
-0.0090845032,
-0.0569565184,
0.0285360198,
0.0262263827,
0.0423534475,
0.0454493575,
0.0464654006,
-0.0131643722,
-0.0052379388,
0.027481176,
0.0255200006,
0.061284408,
0.0526708849,
0.0275176838,
-0.0321408883,
0.0150962574,
-0.0106910532,
0.005269303,
-0.0256502945,
0.0431711674,
0.0342002064,
0.0057359496,
0.0008761862,
0.0047612563,
0.0020693766,
0.0090725468,
0.0258763488,
-0.0059860172,
0.0239238646,
-0.0339201987,
-0.0269749947,
-0.0069422936,
0.0853827745,
0.007548186,
-0.0053465664,
-0.0174108576,
-0.0187240615,
-0.0079041338,
0.0330027193,
-0.0436375476,
0.0258576795,
-0.0127021652,
0.0121201314,
0.0156876277,
-0.0072055501,
0.007270237,
0.0508491397,
-0.0147444122,
0.0666585714,
0.0217069723,
-0.0209649503,
0.0263249204,
0.0238590352,
-0.0565101206,
-0.0529220961,
0.0230171103,
0.0391026363,
-0.0552234352,
0.024313163,
-0.0349616669,
-0.001766149,
0.057128638,
-0.0509410016,
0.0456503965,
0.013795726,
-0.0017220624,
0.0346293636,
-0.0307386648,
0.0707933083,
-0.0169631019,
0.0033456499,
-0.0810055137,
-0.0231385026,
-0.0261312909,
-0.0298960209,
-0.0168247838,
0.0558587797,
-0.0448675081,
-0.0258387905,
-0.0268282797,
0.0137669025,
0.021097403,
0.0002704369,
0.0134554645,
0.0428453609,
-0.0001909195,
0.0120564569,
-0.0758042634,
0.048716601,
-0.0338222086,
0.040789891,
0.0357938558,
-0.0698870718,
-0.0030164977,
0.0107986499,
0.031113375,
-0.0406800397,
0.0366215035,
0.0731851831,
0.002172766,
-0.0334960818,
-0.0296909437,
-0.0379532389,
-0.0315738991,
-0.0738089383,
-0.0078736134,
-0.0836567134,
0.025779739,
0.0466545075,
-0.0042513488,
-0.0042755036,
0.0326866321,
0.0580212548,
-0.0196523722,
0.0340204015,
0.0014583645,
0.0275312904,
0.0529564023,
-0.0051120613,
0.0229319409,
0.0653457791,
0.0349717736,
-0.000021959,
0.0519503206,
-0.0181545746,
0.0254755113,
0.0380333923,
-0.006733946,
0.0107289087,
-0.026020484,
0.0621104203,
-0.0143036833,
0.0353819653,
0.0075040604,
0.0693334416,
-0.0157675538,
-0.0347006284,
0.0484457612,
0.0579720959,
-0.0141856018,
-0.016782606,
0.0275339037,
-0.0065874909,
0.0209047869,
0.0063251215,
0.0091175195,
0.0024956763,
-0.0499653406,
0.0193085819,
0.0464623235,
0.0488282517,
-0.0134129161,
-0.0574416444,
-0.0526062101,
0.024248017,
0.0024765118,
0.0667024702,
0.0303805508,
-0.0072956174,
-0.0407998897,
0.0294357073,
-0.0071293507,
-0.0398803502,
0.0021447612,
-0.0616653785,
0.0672993287,
0.0425562076,
0.0754687786,
0.0122656915,
-0.0576655567,
-0.0156193646,
0.0052110935,
0.0426399745,
0.0466774702,
-0.0261703767,
0.0052196854,
-0.0297499765,
-0.0026849443,
-0.0099743679,
-0.0006792855,
0.0004118201,
0.0202790536,
-0.0088026915,
0.0151968226,
-0.0176214315,
-0.0514418855,
0.045041196,
-0.0164920036,
-0.0476150513,
0.0115630915,
-0.0260230787,
0.0291179754,
0.0082862778,
-0.025085289,
0.0356322862,
0.0331302546,
-0.017264463,
-0.0315654911,
-0.039025262,
-0.034266226,
-0.0518536679,
0.0421574973,
-0.0206129868,
-0.0113275871,
0.0502835587,
-0.0431361236,
-0.0449714176,
-0.0269216932,
-0.0476544835,
-0.0086851446,
-0.0338069834,
0.0052788719,
0.0122536775,
0.0163555052,
-0.0694020018,
0.0756618902,
-0.0086046802,
0.0753612071,
-0.0002590677,
0.0519013256,
0.0210362747,
-0.0165107157,
-0.0224744845,
0.0293394178,
0.0024095655,
0.0090537118,
0.0340423025,
0.0184934307,
-0.0787954926,
-0.0160424374,
-0.0756961778,
0.0310576186,
-0.0047508101,
0.0109497868,
0.0323377214,
-0.0024682705,
-0.0259799287,
-0.0069145979,
-0.0682456121,
-0.0245190505,
0.0685613751,
0.0203631464,
0.0314280167,
-0.0222043842,
0.0195969343,
-0.0483059958,
-0.001748092,
0.0043839724,
0.0651754811,
-0.0016076436,
0.0294462964,
-0.0419935547,
0.0182007924,
-0.0513404384,
-0.0268625319,
0.0250068493,
-0.0106868464,
0.0089676334,
0.0014170117,
0.0288622677,
0.0210509226,
0.0179912839,
0.0003778174,
0.0525243357,
0.0014869741,
-0.0291830022,
-0.0057811937,
-0.0285732914,
-0.0310928524,
-0.0045817546,
-0.0391279683,
-0.0221072324,
0.0589410141,
0.0263293106,
-0.0175466128,
0.0068196999,
0.0377329476,
-0.0191939808,
-0.0279095732,
-0.0737833008,
-0.0301730298,
-0.0018660299,
0.0619262867,
-0.0170626771,
-0.0451894552,
0.066397801,
-0.0536271296,
0.0040259548,
-0.0635409579,
-0.0025697418,
-0.0464601256,
0.0407401733,
0.011398661,
0.0049800901,
0.0026465484,
-0.0083314646,
-0.0354602858,
-0.0170193948,
-0.0160433259,
-0.0799159631,
0.0505323745,
-0.0623508655,
0.0039399187,
-0.0040492527,
-0.0115072187,
-0.0386294127,
-0.0474217497,
-0.0413090028,
-0.0014483397,
0.0323055238,
0.0122433724,
-0.0058518909,
0.0187999383,
0.0230843555,
-0.0039435239,
-0.0354478359,
-0.0103621371,
-0.0156157091,
0.1172963753,
0.0720631704,
0.062962018,
0.0588525496,
-0.0161280427,
0.0410651229,
0.041688662,
0.0427808762,
0.0246279798,
-0.020782901,
0.0103856483,
0.0228810385,
-0.0244288128,
-0.0037122536,
0.0159522742,
0.0597341917,
-0.0500131957,
-0.0421563387,
0.1088074967,
0.0670872182,
0.0155273424,
0.0026145992,
-0.0015582963,
0.0254934654,
0.0290337335,
0.0255720057,
-0.0603679791,
-0.0380270146,
-0.0107247084,
0.0223584399,
-0.0319087543,
-0.0297250487,
-0.0095238658,
-0.1364308745,
0.0276307166,
-0.000602095,
-0.0546389408,
0.0068098889,
-0.0594887584,
-0.0154146664,
-0.0125374207,
0.0228839573,
0.0041431338,
-0.0044670855,
0.0130273206,
0.0507456996,
-0.0118054273,
-0.0385789014,
0.0425184593,
-0.0354962833,
0.0404034965,
0.0561928563,
0.024293758,
-0.0026496081,
0.0044949348,
0.01584333,
-0.0620014109,
-0.0060087778,
-0.0167033877,
0.0191973727,
0.0230025798,
-0.0083597004,
-0.0490888208,
0.0209105592,
-0.0346236229,
-0.0050149956,
0.0363384336,
0.0622243062,
-0.0173776895,
0.0043402552,
-0.0204541739,
0.0170230661,
-0.0311109759,
0.077482067,
0.0223294459,
-0.0427990295,
-0.0387643427,
-0.0363251418,
-0.0042634206,
-0.0479692221,
-0.0365264378,
0.0304303151,
0.0072992621,
0.0408789255,
-0.0707687587,
-0.0369418524,
0.0636273697,
0.0055924519,
-0.0315009058,
0.0308614578,
-0.0007033788,
0.0223388821,
-0.0161478464,
0.0222254023,
-0.0159173794,
0.0128811747,
-0.0261198897,
0.0004444257,
0.0085058399,
-0.0230671111,
-0.018871922,
0.0360940322,
-0.1032984704,
-0.0537509322,
-0.0439576991,
0.0084291762,
0.0242545232,
-0.012934546,
-0.0117735052,
-0.0669973865,
0.023713002,
0.0218192134,
-0.0165814217,
0.0148991039,
-0.0440942235,
0.0213072058,
-0.0042838356,
0.0073403004,
-0.0212891363,
0.0040883208,
0.0022425109,
0.0670104623,
-0.0037914373,
-0.0338052586,
0.0594260953,
0.0439410582,
0.0108950483,
-0.0075233881,
0.0202074591,
-0.0166529361,
-0.0035410966,
-0.0220148712,
-0.0374877043,
-0.0213647112,
-0.0061714626,
0.0311406367,
-0.0363099277,
-0.0245229211,
-0.036580231,
-0.0291864723,
0.0610082783,
-0.0395041183,
0.00840961,
0.0418322496,
-0.0121452827,
0.0037444385,
-0.0154608879,
-0.0463270061,
-0.0156622641,
-0.0265507344,
0.0264803376,
0.0064862431,
0.0743481144,
-0.0260430276,
-0.0013360283,
0.0287679285,
-0.0070909816,
-0.0652837306,
-0.0533124134,
-0.0458857231,
0.0377464294,
0.0367180333,
-0.0099023161,
0.0417215712,
0.0078041628,
-0.0152976057,
-0.0506874733,
0.0060424297,
0.0008613174,
-0.0319021158,
0.0706152543,
0.0214615818,
-0.025982501,
0.0000593292,
0.0896347463,
0.0520088598,
0.0374538861,
0.0141399279,
-0.0395023748,
-0.0275414772,
-0.0416914001,
-0.0174973719,
0.0063948003,
-0.0035969391,
0.0170252416,
-0.050625138,
-0.0699896738,
-0.0034451012,
0.0216651615,
0.0430850312,
-0.0224130861,
0.0226251427,
0.0630328432,
0.0086597074,
-0.0265231133,
-0.0695323572,
0.0212014206,
-0.0655043274,
0.0100924233,
-0.0254050009,
-6.3513532e-33,
-0.0296569038,
-0.0399344042,
0.0472972617,
-0.0557835363,
-0.0173082706,
0.000228812,
-0.0230357926,
-0.0030551241,
-0.017375676,
-0.0254101939,
-0.0130152358,
-0.004405438,
-0.0089096371,
0.0520402491,
0.0177253168,
-0.0500384308,
0.0090582697,
-0.0276049059,
-0.0326467603,
0.0121396938,
0.0343465582,
-0.0000542121,
0.0296503082,
0.0132369548,
-0.010385178,
-0.0234793406,
-0.0100936536,
0.0029747752,
-0.0449124575,
0.0891934037,
-0.0354088768,
0.0590667278,
0.0291800424,
-0.0419578068,
0.003472982,
0.0474752188,
-0.0361270122,
-0.0341146104,
0.0286376625,
-0.0136164185,
-0.0217905268,
-0.0082276184,
0.0296564102,
0.00110407,
-0.0085712913,
0.014721592,
0.0128516592,
-0.0365078934,
-0.022355957,
-0.0148218432,
-0.028663028,
0.0207937844,
-0.022144286,
-0.010609773,
-0.0451048128,
0.0796204209,
-0.0466191731,
0.0486946963,
-0.0292082094,
0.0138873402,
0.0664087459,
0.0143310735,
0.0574769899,
0.0359529518,
-0.0068106945,
0.03905892,
0.0021272502,
-0.0362645499,
-0.0114150755,
-0.0036101551,
-0.0228957646,
0.0319191366,
0.0676340312,
0.0565863326,
0.0236470625,
0.0078371493,
-0.083900094,
0.0380449295,
-0.0048228195,
0.0092860823,
0.0411130451,
-0.0400205664,
-0.0156540517,
-0.031372916,
-0.085421294,
0.0213018805,
-0.0352271274,
-0.0059564975,
0.0629732013,
-0.0100085493,
-0.0102786729,
0.0078656739,
0.0419861935,
-0.0401745066,
-0.0305741839,
0.0093189888,
-0.0378927737,
0.0319483019,
0.0049143918,
0.0400939211,
-0.07478863,
0.0103804013,
0.0241281111,
-0.0302625485,
-0.0212886892,
-0.008273609,
-0.0019786656,
-0.004965852,
-0.0677366555,
0.0054700663,
-0.0589967109,
0.0078412956,
-0.0180042479,
-0.011472106,
0.0340511426,
-0.0033134145,
-0.0198239051,
0.0497621223,
-0.0098430291,
-0.0085122362,
-0.023647666,
-0.0401132032,
-0.0110320486,
0.0288693476,
-0.0228126775,
0.021752663,
-0.0289667882,
-0.0023469552,
0.0099162236,
-0.0311891418,
-0.0078537185,
0.0252157245,
2.5e-7,
0.0771961957,
0.0578108616,
-0.0121584339,
0.0277232248,
-0.0050698752,
0.0140149733,
-0.0274516456,
0.030985795,
0.0323133208,
-0.0046538976,
-0.0080584837,
0.0153913796,
0.0504235439,
0.0400444269,
-0.0276634414,
-0.017044656,
-0.0815503001,
0.0024400437,
-0.0593174584,
-0.0090987245,
0.0758654848,
0.0956418067,
-0.0111910971,
-0.0239174739,
-0.0340377614,
-0.0304645766,
0.065011695,
-0.0387094766,
-0.0218519047,
0.0095955823,
0.0387273729,
0.0370292552,
0.0288645029,
0.048014909,
0.0093166428,
0.0052483468,
0.0250286479,
0.0444180779,
0.0371292979,
-0.0458421633,
-0.0146745145,
-0.01615417,
0.01155697,
-0.0803665742,
0.099499397,
-0.0545417331,
-0.0232757218,
-0.0470046885,
-0.0211389344,
-0.0198602024,
0.0374491997,
-0.0407039933,
-0.0064958576,
0.0041003642,
0.0051927888,
-0.0037733265,
-0.0025174432,
-0.0366511829,
0.0090598892,
0.026608523,
-0.0484174192,
-0.0618804917,
-0.0483270884,
-0.0080600707,
-0.0006067698,
-0.0617724285,
-0.0170865096,
2.225575393e-34,
0.0204294436,
-0.0219267886,
0.0023480845,
0.0138382511,
0.0513998531,
-0.0178867802,
0.0009059617,
-0.0029376054,
-0.0229836479,
-0.1160947978,
0.0020211288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01345v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01345v6 | Skip \n: A Simple Method to Reduce Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-02T12:02:46 | 2024-05-08T02:15:45 | Zongbo Han, Zechen Bai, Haiyang Mei, Qianli Xu, Changqing Zhang, Mike Zheng Shou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large vision-language models (LVLMs) have demonstrated
impressive capability in visual information understanding with human language.
Despite these advances, LVLMs still face challenges with multimodal
hallucination, such as generating text descriptions of objects that are not
present in the visual information. However, the underlying fundamental reasons
of multimodal hallucinations remain poorly explored. In this paper, we propose
a new perspective, suggesting that the inherent biases in LVLMs might be a key
factor in hallucinations. Specifically, we systematically identify a semantic
shift bias related to paragraph breaks (\n\n), where the content before and
after '\n\n' in the training data frequently exhibit significant semantic
changes. This pattern leads the model to infer that the contents following
'\n\n' should be obviously different from the preceding contents with less
hallucinatory descriptions, thereby increasing the probability of hallucinatory
descriptions subsequent to the '\n\n'. We have validated this hypothesis on
multiple publicly available LVLMs. Besides, we find that deliberately inserting
'\n\n' at the generated description can induce more hallucinations. A simple
method is proposed to effectively mitigate the hallucination of LVLMs by
skipping the output of '\n'. | Skip \n: A Simple Method to Reduce Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models: Recent advancements in large vision-language models (LVLMs) have demonstrated
impressive capability in visual information understanding with human language.
Despite these advances, LVLMs still face challenges with multimodal
hallucination, such as generating text descriptions of objects that are not
present in the visual information. However, the underlying fundamental reasons
of multimodal hallucinations remain poorly explored. In this paper, we propose
a new perspective, suggesting that the inherent biases in LVLMs might be a key
factor in hallucinations. Specifically, we systematically identify a semantic
shift bias related to paragraph breaks (\n\n), where the content before and
after '\n\n' in the training data frequently exhibit significant semantic
changes. This pattern leads the model to infer that the contents following
'\n\n' should be obviously different from the preceding contents with less
hallucinatory descriptions, thereby increasing the probability of hallucinatory
descriptions subsequent to the '\n\n'. We have validated this hypothesis on
multiple publicly available LVLMs. Besides, we find that deliberately inserting
'\n\n' at the generated description can induce more hallucinations. A simple
method is proposed to effectively mitigate the hallucination of LVLMs by
skipping the output of '\n'. | [
-0.0104903765,
0.0476973057,
0.0109890681,
0.0607862733,
-0.0396360233,
0.0202308055,
-0.0218080785,
0.0132702375,
-0.0032703294,
-0.065973103,
-0.0069694757,
-0.066597335,
0.0512050502,
0.0250117201,
0.0556056164,
-0.0750311464,
0.036045108,
-0.0690040663,
-0.0490715988,
0.0118638799,
-0.0144548006,
-0.0301306155,
-0.0079755252,
0.0164676774,
-0.0172206517,
-0.0633868501,
-0.0112623097,
0.0156658776,
0.0125008598,
-0.0246403068,
-0.0659984425,
0.0211196616,
-0.0143063329,
0.023233626,
0.0000018795,
-0.0347677916,
0.0255433097,
0.0046683759,
0.0312999599,
0.0164958481,
0.0229331609,
-0.0555014126,
-0.0040919879,
-0.0199253671,
-0.0033269178,
-0.0336016677,
0.0656300411,
0.0799825415,
0.0220316947,
0.0628606975,
-0.01558364,
-0.0410333574,
0.005822659,
0.0122812223,
0.0762810633,
0.0182870142,
0.0570402555,
-0.006462222,
-0.0251793414,
-0.0385497734,
-0.0546419211,
0.0051876679,
0.0228303913,
0.0033924598,
0.0154857673,
0.0543220565,
-0.0580510087,
-0.0370895043,
-0.024632981,
0.0451158062,
-0.0626830161,
-0.0379054807,
0.0110065853,
0.0317584388,
0.0197768994,
-0.0330671296,
-0.0335027203,
0.0761635229,
-0.0321896151,
0.0144272959,
-0.0345920995,
-0.0205761883,
0.0268700197,
-0.0156488102,
-0.0553932376,
0.0371748507,
0.0099169435,
-0.0144393574,
0.0368007869,
0.0120595135,
-0.0304777734,
-0.0441512354,
-0.0105824945,
0.0031655682,
-0.028036071,
-0.0244126841,
-0.0597293712,
0.0131337661,
0.0001602516,
-0.0779987723,
0.0324560665,
-0.0175145697,
-0.0779633671,
0.0405481532,
-0.0577711761,
0.0397404321,
-0.0259887818,
0.0695304275,
-0.016677998,
0.0152836423,
-0.0020835055,
-0.0114070009,
-0.0239581186,
-0.0014777674,
-0.0280188844,
-0.0704483241,
-0.0087479977,
0.0037578344,
-0.0256509762,
0.0169154387,
-0.0449548922,
0.0176819544,
0.0159981679,
-0.0312741511,
0.0054006963,
0.0026432443,
0.0263015237,
-0.0211218111,
-0.0137184495,
-0.0693552047,
-0.0136209643,
0.0726632252,
-0.016588755,
0.0087368041,
-0.0459268391,
0.0904944763,
-0.0114647336,
-0.0044359723,
-0.0323304944,
0.0050593778,
-0.0424087681,
-0.0347362794,
0.0361827575,
-0.0380119123,
-0.0070268926,
-0.0136288395,
0.0073216115,
-0.0105279051,
0.0364702716,
0.0299026761,
-0.0445509255,
0.082046099,
-0.0567576997,
-0.0053922031,
0.0148118176,
0.0198177733,
0.02098516,
0.0489572436,
0.0304899234,
0.0424839258,
0.0164952613,
-0.021698324,
0.0429575332,
0.0218846519,
-0.0420399345,
-0.0070121307,
-0.0996156931,
-0.0391871221,
0.0354144387,
0.0322616883,
0.0590548888,
0.0841310993,
-0.0364347957,
-0.0534845367,
0.0667817667,
0.0281230584,
0.0166401695,
-0.0078063589,
0.0542494357,
0.012339741,
-0.010055732,
0.0522875786,
-0.0643730164,
0.0159809031,
-0.0017254255,
0.0146973096,
0.0137797799,
0.0152185988,
-0.0090438398,
-0.0225051399,
-0.0097284345,
-0.0027491029,
0.0164611954,
-0.0229140092,
0.0195398889,
0.0243609138,
-0.0568074398,
-0.0170164537,
0.0257967114,
0.0009402527,
0.0163229425,
-0.033012595,
0.0064836219,
0.075951755,
0.0394567922,
0.0075067533,
0.0287962332,
-0.0368564576,
0.0432327986,
0.0761425048,
0.006775097,
0.0161481388,
0.0263120327,
-0.0470979549,
-0.0087346276,
0.0077982093,
0.0198437274,
0.0048783179,
-0.051488582,
-0.0172777586,
0.0014267325,
-0.0216800123,
-0.0268374458,
0.0585174076,
0.0336172841,
-0.0031328008,
-0.0444550663,
0.0038868645,
-0.0156293791,
-0.0136077004,
-0.0242993422,
0.0368162803,
0.011356378,
-0.0417401344,
-0.003674434,
0.0149989054,
-0.0421946496,
-0.0175687969,
0.0163103603,
-0.0467224419,
0.0458108224,
-0.0057178708,
0.0217219647,
-0.0134287998,
0.0001135831,
-0.0341539383,
0.0366142206,
-0.0242383871,
0.0444963574,
0.0230624638,
0.0440322272,
-0.0248500351,
0.0569301955,
-0.0299659707,
-0.0023635873,
0.0084523782,
0.0202287976,
-0.0026505443,
-0.0110326614,
-0.0173085053,
0.0488170721,
-0.0027564012,
0.0229322612,
-0.0260216948,
-0.0330371074,
-0.0457375385,
-0.0115975542,
-0.0519164242,
-0.0144582251,
-0.0153046846,
-0.0396451652,
0.0101113832,
-0.0359962322,
-0.0040753931,
-0.0310399011,
-0.0073690983,
0.0417289361,
-0.0197903216,
0.0434502997,
0.0148382615,
-0.0051131854,
-0.0381187871,
0.0029895403,
-0.0079671638,
-0.0050035692,
0.0907841027,
-0.0055066138,
-0.0765131935,
-0.1069301441,
0.0333212912,
-0.0300234184,
0.0256855581,
-0.0082809031,
0.0052441978,
-0.0043962491,
-0.0041652634,
0.0579076856,
0.115393512,
0.0431277454,
0.044050891,
0.0714107975,
-0.0124501493,
0.0090763448,
-0.039052587,
0.0108051896,
-0.001696852,
-0.0170928054,
-0.0167122968,
0.0057894331,
0.0523750372,
0.0114134587,
0.0393118486,
-0.0669610798,
0.0251070727,
-0.0304770842,
-0.0693083629,
-0.0130688567,
-0.0216222648,
-0.0293701254,
0.0187015254,
-0.0396473482,
-0.0662062988,
0.0172852837,
-0.0272061676,
-0.0140779065,
0.0060928245,
0.0320835933,
-0.0011669522,
0.039706558,
0.0659143105,
0.03478631,
0.0096167242,
-0.0177775491,
-0.0572476424,
-0.0091554439,
-0.0535741188,
-0.0006067904,
0.0473225564,
-0.0464127287,
-0.0079859616,
-0.00544693,
-0.0011382326,
-0.0361304507,
-0.0265835989,
-0.0007320366,
-0.0436183959,
-0.0561828725,
0.0161102917,
-0.0383591577,
0.0353129208,
0.0242616925,
0.0172673371,
-0.0417150855,
-0.0180663317,
-0.0126551064,
0.0233887229,
0.0714367628,
-0.0229601078,
0.0377243944,
-0.0696977302,
0.0176274162,
0.0764313936,
0.0130940797,
0.0556335002,
-0.0379275046,
-0.0138769643,
-0.0067004221,
0.0068953284,
-0.0433792099,
0.0390092991,
0.0283724144,
-0.0802355781,
-0.0017730017,
0.0437144376,
0.0277122315,
-0.056491971,
0.0144363018,
-0.0088647362,
0.0734915435,
-0.0063629895,
-0.0176636111,
-0.0712146088,
-0.0209761839,
-0.0340167172,
-0.0295281578,
0.0156932622,
-0.0145697054,
-0.0345318951,
-0.0569699407,
0.055060219,
0.0460577421,
-0.0077012689,
-0.0341072716,
0.0319196284,
0.0062884679,
0.0301728323,
0.0191366728,
0.000926146,
-0.0255787,
-0.0183726735,
0.0308028255,
0.0002965053,
0.0097466242,
-0.0363370404,
-0.0392519422,
0.0170505252,
0.0779955164,
0.0087970737,
-0.014953291,
-0.0610368587,
0.050723996,
-0.0277690385,
0.0189725216,
0.0159091856,
0.0676121116,
-0.0163150001,
-0.0126612522,
0.0348380022,
0.006050461,
-0.0117277708,
-0.0443417765,
-0.0022858779,
-0.0017547489,
-0.0435063988,
-0.0890903324,
-0.0153811136,
0.0489288382,
-0.029945327,
0.062063504,
0.0391372815,
-0.0517200008,
-0.0650765598,
-0.0229625888,
0.0276431143,
-0.0200967118,
-0.0245164763,
0.0411749333,
0.063353464,
-0.0390159525,
-0.0664998293,
-0.0463782735,
0.0119672017,
0.0471331365,
0.0004636207,
0.0187932067,
-0.0166632999,
-0.0235201381,
-0.0252859537,
0.0340380929,
-0.0228075944,
0.0105625838,
-0.0435446352,
0.0117166499,
0.0258294214,
-0.0290397797,
0.0172551349,
0.0029943748,
-0.09871535,
-0.0457666479,
0.0263453256,
0.02984933,
0.0242401622,
0.0780458078,
0.0193849113,
-0.0455977172,
0.0513078272,
0.0336747095,
0.0439171009,
0.0637846366,
-0.0118999537,
0.0064435834,
0.0045635579,
0.0185160749,
0.0152079668,
-0.031052582,
0.0226916485,
-0.0104132295,
0.0178263765,
0.002181784,
0.0285751298,
-0.0402359329,
0.0274524409,
-0.020583367,
0.051295422,
0.0087924926,
-0.0094643151,
-0.0254713669,
-0.0100981407,
-0.0380626991,
0.0129285483,
0.0308832377,
0.0284316987,
0.0123526258,
-0.0210444424,
-0.0067884577,
-0.0082086604,
-0.0396146029,
-0.0421948954,
0.0007935564,
-0.0420068093,
0.0508184619,
0.012479526,
-0.0292141885,
0.0232316647,
-0.0297529679,
0.0382655151,
0.0111713903,
0.0787255466,
0.0336501338,
-0.0310324989,
-0.0422088914,
0.0329366624,
-0.0217914991,
-0.057496734,
-0.0276061054,
0.0365213417,
0.0369029604,
0.0055918377,
0.0605012886,
-0.0263659116,
0.0146333175,
-0.0407039784,
0.0280253179,
0.050392624,
-0.0502045602,
0.012480719,
0.0286439899,
-0.0563118346,
-0.0255535543,
0.0740395263,
0.02274937,
0.0119300205,
0.0205492545,
-0.0141923893,
-0.0459152311,
-0.0297971927,
0.0059206085,
-0.0101915142,
-0.0207699966,
-0.0071646208,
-0.0184937976,
-0.028989682,
-0.0003760322,
0.0082836458,
0.0511916019,
0.0143647296,
0.0214983691,
0.0497050099,
-0.0184295736,
-0.0397566073,
0.0016015898,
-0.0442533605,
0.0758698955,
-0.0001646334,
0.0202663746,
-5.436093829e-33,
-0.0105801309,
-0.003019819,
0.0220860057,
0.0017962629,
-0.0282761492,
-0.0222699903,
0.0015197524,
0.0228737202,
0.0294742994,
0.0276865736,
0.0338150822,
0.0158834793,
0.0234614927,
0.0175177716,
0.0007115925,
-0.0282498077,
0.0613057576,
-0.0015001667,
-0.0179299209,
-0.0091975126,
-0.0129849203,
0.0165067408,
0.0345371813,
-0.030381659,
0.0145452227,
0.0079725934,
-0.0443813726,
-0.0094440393,
0.0281146839,
0.0467857867,
-0.0566946194,
0.0129340095,
0.037443269,
0.0248623341,
-0.0511419475,
0.0492408611,
0.0048199571,
0.0372808725,
-0.0044729267,
0.0548739508,
-0.0810773671,
-0.0050916756,
0.0654265881,
-0.0235541705,
0.0143680871,
-0.0255951658,
0.0389584526,
-0.0510242581,
-0.0528883636,
0.0580968112,
-0.0647801831,
-0.0079344949,
0.0191085283,
-0.0146002434,
0.0397888161,
0.0012108493,
-0.0196292475,
-0.0030557476,
-0.0366658792,
0.014798834,
-0.0054389397,
0.0139169358,
0.0258827209,
0.0589880496,
0.0037830465,
0.0751013234,
0.1215006933,
-0.0146410214,
-0.0212428421,
-0.0308674611,
0.0257621706,
0.0068532815,
0.0095107621,
0.0183356088,
0.0652915761,
0.0182435438,
-0.0268585384,
-0.032816641,
-0.0890967473,
0.036322169,
0.0661656484,
0.0154570937,
-0.0310122278,
-0.0344702639,
0.0002461713,
-0.0050364765,
-0.0297236182,
-0.008559715,
0.0527278595,
0.0039817714,
0.000404897,
0.0306897406,
0.0449471697,
-0.0263673421,
-0.0011301538,
0.0016898464,
-0.0535181202,
0.0384202972,
-0.0101151848,
-0.0114330156,
-0.0131763453,
-0.0049562054,
0.0556004085,
-0.008449967,
0.0210132748,
0.0254125949,
0.0339012966,
-0.0024352511,
-0.0723504052,
-0.0107725495,
-0.0302895084,
-0.0341441184,
0.0403866135,
0.04040806,
0.0682392791,
-0.0168079566,
-0.0216775984,
0.0482608378,
0.0001332846,
-0.0298966188,
0.0171722397,
0.0223462172,
-0.0209503714,
0.0260244198,
-0.0083450638,
0.0000098759,
-0.0352163576,
-0.0386007838,
0.0514320843,
-0.0636342987,
-0.0173817463,
-0.0012627408,
2.556e-7,
-0.017165821,
0.0504555255,
0.0261561144,
0.0020310965,
0.0247972105,
0.0225694645,
0.0287704952,
0.0393424109,
0.000698304,
-0.0521413907,
-0.0294060968,
0.0291469432,
0.0500472561,
-0.011758172,
-0.0480743572,
0.0234634578,
-0.0070395521,
-0.0009029528,
-0.0817052871,
-0.042914398,
0.044420708,
0.0186206773,
-0.052463159,
-0.0083554406,
0.0592273362,
-0.0713584721,
0.0618253648,
-0.0107583581,
-0.0002493422,
0.0289176181,
0.0168917999,
0.0125347059,
-0.0080078999,
0.0774209201,
0.0003266154,
-0.0512781106,
0.0594452582,
0.0067034028,
-0.0446201377,
0.0120806638,
-0.0121884067,
0.0134165343,
-0.0132648246,
-0.0512982197,
0.0647193864,
-0.0292182229,
-0.0292999297,
0.0027242682,
-0.0167722758,
-0.0115431109,
0.0474923924,
-0.0308609623,
-0.0177639443,
0.0045446618,
0.0404582843,
0.0229494888,
-0.0313067511,
-0.0536795035,
-0.0169568732,
-0.0002767884,
-0.024809761,
0.0060315011,
-0.0474147722,
0.00618598,
0.0035549952,
-0.0813832134,
-0.0400957018,
2.49202208e-34,
0.0075274785,
-0.0166074391,
0.0501486436,
-0.0082166148,
0.0003070135,
-0.0205032341,
0.0465510227,
0.0108096916,
-0.0443421938,
-0.0437569246,
-0.0127004273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03469v2 | Rethinking the Role of Proxy Rewards in Language Model Alignment | 2024-02-02T11:58:08 | 2024-04-29T01:09:06 | Sungdong Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Learning from human feedback via proxy reward modeling has been studied to
align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human values. However, achieving
reliable training through that proxy reward model (RM) is not a trivial
problem, and its behavior remained as a black-box. In this paper, we study the
role of proxy rewards in the LLM alignment via `reverse reward engineering' by
composing interpretable features as a white-box reward function. We aim to
replicate the ground truth (gold) reward signal by achieving a monotonic
relationship between the proxy and gold reward signals after training the model
using the proxy reward in reinforcement learning (RL). Our findings indicate
that successfully emulating the gold reward requires generating responses that
are relevant with enough length to open-ended questions, while also ensuring
response consistency in closed-ended questions. Furthermore, resulting models
optimizing our devised white-box reward show competitive performances with
strong open-source RMs in alignment benchmarks. We highlight its potential
usage as a simple but strong reward baseline for the LLM alignment, not
requiring explicit human feedback dataset and RM training. Our code is
available at https://github.com/naver-ai/rethinking-proxy-reward. | Rethinking the Role of Proxy Rewards in Language Model Alignment: Learning from human feedback via proxy reward modeling has been studied to
align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human values. However, achieving
reliable training through that proxy reward model (RM) is not a trivial
problem, and its behavior remained as a black-box. In this paper, we study the
role of proxy rewards in the LLM alignment via `reverse reward engineering' by
composing interpretable features as a white-box reward function. We aim to
replicate the ground truth (gold) reward signal by achieving a monotonic
relationship between the proxy and gold reward signals after training the model
using the proxy reward in reinforcement learning (RL). Our findings indicate
that successfully emulating the gold reward requires generating responses that
are relevant with enough length to open-ended questions, while also ensuring
response consistency in closed-ended questions. Furthermore, resulting models
optimizing our devised white-box reward show competitive performances with
strong open-source RMs in alignment benchmarks. We highlight its potential
usage as a simple but strong reward baseline for the LLM alignment, not
requiring explicit human feedback dataset and RM training. Our code is
available at https://github.com/naver-ai/rethinking-proxy-reward. | [
0.036343839,
0.0770398751,
-0.0090013389,
0.0171791986,
-0.0507728569,
0.0067199753,
-0.0449613556,
-0.0056164507,
-0.0427806191,
-0.0015343154,
-0.0592492111,
-0.0176033899,
0.0055316156,
0.0092774397,
0.0192441791,
-0.0487418734,
0.0781891346,
-0.0300493333,
0.0158944875,
-0.0204158537,
0.0156804696,
0.0068267598,
-0.0000511098,
0.04589542,
-0.0095924903,
-0.0080665043,
-0.0280966852,
-0.0099294847,
0.0326803587,
0.0041465601,
0.0151362075,
0.034245763,
0.0190615673,
0.0799817517,
0.0000021041,
-0.0555272847,
-0.02091044,
-0.0051774504,
-0.0544058345,
-0.0288266465,
0.0124021769,
-0.0049673384,
-0.0101304511,
0.0173649639,
-0.0314512625,
0.0141472286,
0.0570609644,
0.0343418457,
0.0522233844,
0.0677222162,
0.0165117066,
-0.0332866162,
0.0424618721,
-0.0252589304,
0.0314546973,
-0.0339290984,
-0.0059587937,
0.022328848,
0.0050053755,
-0.0092401765,
-0.0219597835,
0.0254632737,
0.03151723,
-0.0034930874,
0.0020222915,
0.0395887159,
0.0214490276,
-0.0065421271,
-0.0085496791,
0.0623070411,
-0.019125307,
-0.0378970727,
-0.0227597728,
-0.0154809142,
0.0166866723,
-0.0085775135,
-0.009061167,
0.0148744918,
0.0355123319,
0.0437727086,
0.0701970458,
-0.0087415855,
0.0321218222,
-0.0040955544,
-0.0020861388,
0.0707833543,
0.0166385658,
-0.042116195,
-0.0145038236,
0.0212540124,
-0.025350878,
-0.0489004105,
-0.0261758175,
0.0169645268,
-0.0548881628,
0.0417452715,
-0.0527968369,
-0.0267469715,
0.0040873764,
0.0117851477,
0.0415048338,
0.0499515831,
-0.0210260786,
0.0517069846,
-0.0225706622,
0.0821686611,
-0.0505588055,
0.0792804211,
-0.0416452996,
-0.0157711785,
-0.0179965701,
-0.0323356874,
0.0155232884,
0.0230929442,
-0.000215357,
-0.0053643039,
-0.0483573042,
0.0202593319,
-0.0364242457,
0.0557450615,
0.0104977246,
0.0178576615,
-0.037340045,
-0.0229536165,
-0.0308037456,
0.041796349,
-0.0376513451,
0.02339972,
0.0242276508,
-0.0201405939,
-0.0159667674,
-0.001371099,
-0.0169669781,
-0.0341309346,
-0.0056728497,
0.0851254836,
-0.014739031,
-0.0112902038,
-0.0077278321,
-0.0270629358,
-0.0012074232,
-0.0480831079,
-0.0157050751,
-0.0641105995,
0.0321080945,
-0.0195261687,
-0.0316543467,
-0.0325978883,
0.0121658957,
-0.0029095556,
-0.0073002311,
0.0679181963,
0.0119069433,
0.0056502833,
-0.0018529483,
-0.0370383821,
-0.019869335,
0.0650336668,
0.0555994324,
0.0192279927,
0.0178313646,
-0.0112224342,
-0.0181866027,
0.0276541375,
0.0524612255,
0.0129237622,
-0.0298529267,
0.01495496,
0.0561399199,
0.0539051294,
0.0635192692,
0.0058872369,
0.0101998933,
-0.026399523,
0.0662453696,
0.0527236946,
-0.0131563889,
-0.0227507241,
0.0053372341,
-0.0003965603,
-0.0382546075,
0.0188608523,
-0.0777581409,
0.0337710716,
-0.0320384689,
0.0322505049,
-0.0040679136,
-0.002484024,
-0.0273554903,
-0.0397594683,
-0.0068417368,
-0.0227752551,
0.025172526,
0.0446855202,
0.0581835881,
-0.0157683659,
-0.0476205871,
0.0116792601,
0.0562776662,
-0.0210135188,
0.0325543955,
-0.0488186739,
0.0620298833,
0.0562253781,
0.0271107741,
-0.0267388094,
0.0042500445,
-0.0270524565,
-0.0324398428,
0.0647563189,
0.0443020612,
-0.0082618902,
-0.0109018926,
-0.0225387905,
-0.0332183242,
-0.0062826364,
0.0095838159,
0.0277094916,
0.0264879558,
-0.0299240239,
-0.0113771195,
-0.0070189307,
-0.0548428968,
0.0465984717,
-0.0214615557,
-0.0342505947,
-0.0131893381,
0.0255025513,
0.0239461567,
-0.0069611329,
0.0049881549,
0.0152138444,
0.0252464563,
-0.025203282,
-0.0061815917,
0.0209079776,
-0.0634966493,
-0.0135446545,
0.0329796113,
-0.0144430716,
-0.0221544076,
0.0946684778,
-0.0276215468,
-0.041961506,
0.0196209513,
-0.0267969221,
0.0588595048,
-0.0053810445,
0.0494185686,
-0.0359407999,
-0.0039830939,
-0.0707324669,
0.0279297084,
0.0011646692,
0.0247434303,
-0.0290299393,
-0.0358126238,
-0.002053234,
-0.052344773,
-0.0107722469,
0.020093957,
-0.004928818,
0.0328275301,
0.0459423214,
0.0028912562,
-0.050679151,
-0.0219524447,
-0.0168191362,
0.0046447511,
-0.029923737,
0.0397886895,
0.0562338196,
0.0002536984,
0.0064969929,
-0.0215857551,
-0.0836932957,
-0.0263692979,
0.0224913247,
-0.0035876827,
0.0521689951,
-0.009206471,
-0.0039070547,
-0.0671877563,
-0.0160985794,
-0.023285225,
0.0273293145,
-0.004709688,
0.0769989714,
-0.0752487183,
-0.0033380042,
-0.0260482039,
0.0176542494,
-0.00610602,
-0.0291271098,
0.0123752458,
0.0205836948,
0.002682507,
0.087699987,
0.0264996141,
0.0166506507,
0.0247778669,
0.0453789309,
-0.1066638678,
-0.0080759432,
-0.0474438816,
-0.0664336681,
-0.0503957719,
-0.0310943518,
0.0004780676,
0.0936094224,
0.0166273471,
0.011480188,
-0.0767953023,
0.0171795506,
-0.0030840861,
-0.0441805758,
-0.0500233471,
-0.0083230315,
-0.0479039066,
0.0322922319,
-0.0565692186,
-0.065582104,
0.097694546,
-0.0122818742,
-0.0037281378,
-0.0335624069,
-0.0201238617,
-0.0318787098,
0.0483652987,
-0.0217397641,
0.0281023141,
0.0034899348,
-0.0361475758,
-0.0808941573,
-0.0297258962,
0.0296302047,
-0.0496329926,
0.0337805599,
-0.0244720485,
0.0072035794,
-0.0096245725,
-0.0372908264,
-0.0784871727,
-0.0397255495,
-0.0193891432,
0.0179891009,
-0.0325675532,
-0.0002169846,
-0.017885888,
-0.0026654513,
0.0460906252,
0.0057356693,
-0.0184978284,
0.0174161904,
-0.0423201136,
0.0163109787,
0.0926940143,
0.0280806385,
0.0278727245,
-0.0397509262,
0.0150242308,
0.0226596538,
0.0572450459,
0.0371636935,
0.0093364073,
0.0056489026,
0.0550201051,
-0.0601243973,
0.0024344306,
0.0072903847,
0.0269790012,
-0.057871975,
-0.0155410208,
0.0961586684,
0.0454604737,
-0.044369258,
0.0219900813,
-0.027479982,
0.0614961386,
0.0110322973,
0.0197566748,
-0.0749193206,
-0.0152085023,
0.0183443837,
0.0134856375,
0.0037793601,
-0.0023527257,
0.0020151483,
-0.1328915656,
-0.0279813819,
0.0087243225,
-0.0627418011,
-0.0135455523,
-0.0121664265,
0.0053080614,
-0.0112790298,
0.0311055444,
0.0473898761,
0.027630128,
-0.0182755478,
0.014179267,
0.05317555,
-0.0103357434,
0.0320037641,
-0.0490718447,
0.0764404163,
0.117887035,
0.007826563,
-0.0100068068,
-0.0398887768,
-0.0148448348,
-0.0102349073,
-0.0331194997,
0.0383854881,
0.0254416019,
-0.0260361005,
-0.0290896818,
0.0106769949,
0.0530016087,
-0.0383268222,
0.01448764,
-0.0089897541,
0.0845531225,
0.0113636684,
-0.0023515141,
-0.0029053111,
-0.0191021524,
0.0137546714,
0.0837035179,
0.0100755822,
-0.0590093397,
-0.0276923496,
-0.0051642205,
-0.0152245862,
-0.0085334824,
-0.0527525991,
0.0226275921,
-0.0024108035,
0.0176582281,
-0.057883881,
-0.0609873421,
-0.0068381149,
0.0075512696,
0.0075797108,
-0.0124372942,
-0.0310716983,
-0.0440006964,
-0.0493122563,
0.0524128005,
-0.049226243,
0.0451085679,
-0.0604573339,
-0.0027895505,
-0.0194448717,
-0.0449866243,
-0.0366406515,
-0.0431087688,
-0.0542232767,
-0.0595402829,
-0.0119706616,
0.0338364653,
0.0165575277,
0.0738204494,
-0.0210277624,
-0.0012115669,
0.0167788826,
-0.0113469362,
-0.0437737852,
0.0154343201,
0.0230176654,
0.0092505664,
-0.0046894499,
0.0382289886,
-0.0605270714,
-0.0006150391,
0.0382085182,
0.0394602753,
0.0063296896,
-0.0053517637,
0.0679611489,
0.0088026384,
0.0388564952,
-0.01395051,
0.0016478089,
-0.0184735972,
0.0041789953,
-0.0212980397,
-0.0318920836,
-0.0038057899,
-0.0297588501,
0.0302703865,
-0.0089813713,
0.0173624307,
-0.043372456,
-0.0209548045,
0.0305157714,
-0.0271131676,
-0.0150248678,
-0.0230646618,
0.0279864259,
0.0043621529,
0.0319825783,
-0.0132790394,
0.0148105603,
0.0130607653,
0.0700374171,
0.0026798779,
0.0439438932,
0.0450688116,
0.0055512269,
-0.0055904957,
0.0173327941,
-0.0572470166,
-0.0249624513,
-0.0084449667,
0.0140230702,
0.0537450127,
0.0004547964,
0.0355105139,
0.0018537859,
-0.0156991072,
-0.0060301046,
0.0181301497,
-0.0334428474,
-0.0218985267,
0.0581803918,
0.0253247749,
-0.0132322656,
-0.0153493611,
0.0360778831,
0.0000238724,
0.0386153944,
-0.0487604998,
0.0322419256,
-0.0140396673,
-0.0165236071,
0.0249060392,
0.0060844496,
-0.0427317023,
0.0061967201,
-0.059471339,
-0.082314685,
-0.0529905483,
0.0692795068,
0.0049057025,
-0.0126322098,
0.0411077738,
0.032007698,
-0.0468503386,
-0.0033747097,
-0.0473376252,
-0.0051141889,
-0.0218643397,
-0.0294492468,
-0.0466548465,
-6.671419006e-33,
-0.038743414,
-0.0153669892,
0.0365609527,
-0.0085957898,
-0.0531346016,
0.0072977352,
-0.0212236885,
-0.0028315485,
-0.0228626207,
-0.012204282,
-0.0041901292,
-0.0204097871,
0.0022809252,
0.0125304544,
0.0152993752,
-0.0299283899,
0.0190720223,
-0.0053265924,
-0.0418607891,
-0.0125331823,
0.0395624265,
0.0052719666,
0.0826230496,
-0.0448657013,
0.0655865744,
0.0060902308,
-0.0312282518,
0.0384765677,
-0.008876102,
0.0489134341,
-0.0105590718,
0.0258018076,
0.0082954904,
-0.0389955826,
0.0070298333,
0.0174179617,
-0.0671122819,
-0.0130233299,
0.0517697521,
0.0243399367,
-0.0703926086,
-0.0343910865,
0.0519858934,
-0.0393609032,
-0.0234882254,
-0.0060137073,
0.032181032,
-0.0038387103,
-0.0125892051,
0.0542382412,
-0.0855252817,
-0.0096730236,
-0.018734565,
-0.0247261561,
0.0105470587,
0.0667619482,
0.009965119,
0.0452550761,
-0.0267937984,
0.0303034969,
0.010066702,
0.0361496285,
0.0984295085,
0.05116494,
0.0279205926,
0.0516265631,
0.0152087053,
-0.0208938923,
0.0061795339,
-0.0010045888,
0.0450289622,
-0.0093289157,
0.0512000062,
0.0406401716,
0.033961527,
-0.0107156448,
-0.0235681161,
0.002847166,
-0.0169138256,
0.0171625372,
0.0046980851,
0.03258029,
-0.0475821272,
-0.0127333906,
-0.0837780312,
-0.0070533655,
-0.0320315473,
-0.0594721735,
0.0380645394,
0.0066886353,
-0.0254834164,
-0.0310934,
0.0081148772,
-0.0489012599,
-0.009800721,
0.0151353311,
-0.0036089881,
0.0179129764,
-0.0093861334,
0.0194172282,
-0.0664948896,
-0.0052288175,
-0.0120814107,
-0.0110560823,
0.0241063423,
0.051907219,
0.0134069556,
0.0221214425,
-0.0463194363,
0.0217228066,
-0.0449351706,
0.0097059691,
-0.0098370761,
-0.0534558818,
0.0601375513,
-0.0029431949,
-0.0045114215,
0.0445114225,
0.0281818397,
-0.007194391,
-0.0426811501,
0.0026564097,
-0.0256000385,
0.0373986065,
-0.044574406,
0.0103353178,
-0.0124441963,
0.0221342482,
0.0332002044,
-0.0382813066,
-0.007552987,
-0.016045345,
2.771e-7,
0.0220878739,
0.0105651468,
0.0431079417,
0.0365668908,
-0.0013630238,
0.0739766881,
-0.0043800739,
0.0260637943,
0.0278815776,
-0.0045221504,
0.0074219373,
0.0063070082,
0.0608091876,
-0.0153341014,
-0.0684579015,
0.0268554818,
-0.0932459384,
0.018170571,
-0.0222006235,
0.0011844789,
0.0394177511,
0.0913908631,
0.0428947397,
-0.0015660431,
-0.0046319775,
0.030782396,
0.0552539639,
-0.0610923171,
-0.0337192975,
0.0117183458,
-0.0091080675,
-0.009208695,
0.009605634,
-0.0199878924,
0.0104040382,
0.0362604409,
-0.0222712103,
0.0421535149,
-0.0303594973,
-0.0392085835,
-0.067165859,
-0.0030636205,
0.0113110328,
-0.0742211789,
0.0351132341,
-0.0404274724,
-0.0387974828,
-0.0781566426,
-0.0149372136,
-0.0236952677,
0.0221347697,
-0.0084571624,
-0.0141313933,
0.0112030981,
0.0263874456,
0.0362703949,
-0.0049140286,
-0.0527787991,
-0.0525061786,
0.0354443602,
-0.0117940456,
-0.0222650934,
-0.0169732627,
0.0441736802,
-0.0139518604,
-0.0665806383,
-0.0110010421,
2.421149184e-34,
0.0054955105,
-0.0125841489,
0.0304712616,
0.047288008,
0.0128578311,
0.0118559161,
-0.0026433179,
0.006885401,
0.0745797232,
-0.0189353749,
-0.0270789228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01300v1 | Two Approaches to Diachronic Normalization of Polish Texts | 2024-02-02T10:42:06 | 2024-02-02T10:42:06 | Kacper Dudzic, Filip Graliński, Krzysztof Jassem, Marek Kubis, Piotr Wierzchoń | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper discusses two approaches to the diachronic normalization of Polish
texts: a rule-based solution that relies on a set of handcrafted patterns, and
a neural normalization model based on the text-to-text transfer transformer
architecture. The training and evaluation data prepared for the task are
discussed in detail, along with experiments conducted to compare the proposed
normalization solutions. A quantitative and qualitative analysis is made. It is
shown that at the current stage of inquiry into the problem, the rule-based
solution outperforms the neural one on 3 out of 4 variants of the prepared
dataset, although in practice both approaches have distinct advantages and
disadvantages. | Two Approaches to Diachronic Normalization of Polish Texts: This paper discusses two approaches to the diachronic normalization of Polish
texts: a rule-based solution that relies on a set of handcrafted patterns, and
a neural normalization model based on the text-to-text transfer transformer
architecture. The training and evaluation data prepared for the task are
discussed in detail, along with experiments conducted to compare the proposed
normalization solutions. A quantitative and qualitative analysis is made. It is
shown that at the current stage of inquiry into the problem, the rule-based
solution outperforms the neural one on 3 out of 4 variants of the prepared
dataset, although in practice both approaches have distinct advantages and
disadvantages. | [
-0.0023805203,
0.0429318212,
0.0078459373,
0.0363583192,
-0.0525395498,
0.013612601,
0.0225911606,
0.029707931,
-0.044736661,
0.0231335983,
0.0145927789,
0.0040545319,
0.0424991213,
0.0250874739,
-0.0063743661,
-0.0717780143,
0.0306464452,
-0.0004260208,
-0.0617734492,
0.0332514755,
0.0275232773,
-0.015722556,
0.0077872924,
0.0017922493,
-0.0555142611,
0.0179088302,
0.0065421876,
-0.0084128845,
0.0027770456,
0.0000852936,
-0.008638476,
0.0128268367,
0.0150965666,
0.0411243588,
0.0000017643,
-0.0381557345,
-0.0394446999,
-0.0318165049,
0.0500385091,
-0.0074399645,
0.0493489131,
-0.084722124,
-0.0420937091,
0.0032959485,
-0.0245625135,
-0.0340003036,
0.0764256865,
0.0996235609,
0.0300395377,
0.0766055882,
-0.0429100059,
-0.0871226341,
0.0480655879,
0.0092761666,
-0.058849372,
-0.0065238392,
0.0185634736,
0.0248663574,
-0.0263923518,
-0.0077038435,
0.0034972832,
0.0583383031,
0.0085258121,
-0.0586010218,
0.0224458035,
0.0096691195,
0.0535074845,
-0.0012819065,
-0.0285142343,
0.0069047417,
-0.0145535776,
-0.0222740229,
-0.017011242,
0.0115817385,
-0.0315979868,
0.0190027934,
-0.0425818749,
-0.0142672462,
-0.0133688953,
0.0322172306,
0.0317996144,
0.0412594974,
-0.0042513981,
-0.0184117816,
-0.0170752183,
0.0565696657,
0.0082641114,
-0.0513274558,
0.0196652655,
-0.0171003491,
0.0761732832,
0.0150995972,
0.1006159484,
0.0512853861,
0.0318190306,
0.0039386805,
-0.0277529657,
-0.0311465114,
-0.0343528017,
-0.0284466408,
-0.0007416297,
0.052116517,
-0.0055515491,
-0.003638705,
-0.0664980933,
0.056981612,
0.0044214958,
-0.0057080234,
-0.0861616284,
-0.0322193652,
-0.0587211885,
0.010458217,
-0.0739737824,
0.0145381447,
-0.0308215115,
0.0114639904,
-0.0417520702,
-0.0357642807,
0.0533776358,
-0.0180224832,
0.0443230979,
-0.0064125629,
-0.0438568629,
-0.0170288533,
-0.014290398,
0.0643086433,
-0.0670376793,
-0.0127689941,
-0.058609616,
-0.0323325396,
0.0233641472,
0.0208969302,
0.0344110988,
-0.0247342065,
0.0010929722,
0.0224123206,
-0.06382595,
0.0103867203,
-0.0787618905,
-0.0091505833,
-0.0296248756,
0.0103493575,
-0.0146563342,
-0.0511263087,
0.003873497,
-0.0019798535,
-0.002471989,
-0.0167243835,
-0.0235860199,
0.0156522021,
-0.0375126712,
0.0583168976,
-0.0335182473,
0.01908518,
0.0649244636,
-0.0333430357,
0.0144345434,
-0.001718628,
0.0552747883,
0.0197343994,
0.0022379074,
-0.0286655314,
-0.006586473,
0.0841751322,
-0.0166229159,
-0.0512951426,
-0.0660907775,
-0.0143517014,
-0.0030059707,
0.0050824923,
0.0783100128,
0.0795560777,
0.0099026645,
-0.0322150141,
0.0410143696,
0.0581732728,
0.0440122373,
0.036269851,
0.0457190983,
-0.0459555238,
0.0190925635,
0.0245539751,
0.0141523313,
-0.0142970299,
0.0017444037,
-0.0059441058,
-0.0761844963,
0.0237568077,
-0.0047993381,
-0.0084003722,
0.0385611877,
-0.0179801155,
0.0459518433,
-0.0720063671,
0.0421359874,
0.0159882568,
-0.0201744772,
0.0198572073,
-0.0033146353,
-0.0093012014,
0.026858598,
0.0405092761,
-0.0252142251,
0.0765027776,
0.0644382611,
-0.0296672489,
0.0054691955,
-0.0125574395,
-0.0179009885,
0.0456360839,
-0.0028901992,
-0.0292070154,
-0.0041995114,
-0.0763361901,
-0.0159489159,
0.0496260263,
-0.0295970775,
0.0287101232,
-0.0378216468,
0.0270402431,
0.0081261247,
0.0185950939,
-0.0533343107,
0.0479182787,
-0.0113519048,
-0.0247137696,
-0.0332792066,
0.0185869616,
-0.0129453121,
0.0552800894,
0.0181932021,
-0.0030841888,
0.0295446366,
-0.085418418,
0.0292434935,
0.0423328578,
-0.0938812569,
0.0002137827,
0.0381072238,
-0.0626948997,
-0.0085032396,
0.0108680455,
0.0027995212,
-0.0498973392,
-0.0016883496,
-0.0242582578,
-0.0034401203,
-0.0120356502,
0.0419567376,
-0.0181278251,
0.0149070509,
-0.0308477785,
0.0216155015,
-0.0019713759,
0.0025983304,
-0.0037388385,
-0.0444876961,
0.0318281204,
-0.0291231554,
-0.0042994851,
0.058048062,
-0.0373049378,
-0.0214314424,
0.0140162976,
0.005870332,
-0.0371454842,
-0.0117254956,
-0.023129411,
-0.0158449356,
-0.0050882483,
0.0546100251,
0.0300783031,
0.0261527505,
0.0308602136,
-0.0625780821,
-0.065165475,
-0.0022868933,
0.0170127451,
-0.0351924375,
0.0981575921,
0.0115360282,
-0.0133431237,
-0.0045219902,
-0.0125764078,
-0.0154995043,
-0.005929892,
0.0295072757,
-0.0637429729,
-0.0801012367,
0.0445700027,
0.0000954973,
0.0404933728,
-0.0044503892,
-0.0404770114,
0.0118307043,
0.0111805182,
0.0889558718,
0.022874115,
-0.0010154112,
-0.0546305515,
-0.0012420932,
-0.0407517478,
-0.0184234716,
-0.0167895518,
-0.020837944,
0.0738698021,
-0.0229583811,
-0.0554991849,
0.0025790995,
0.0515728705,
-0.0179972239,
0.0412143245,
-0.0180372428,
-0.0096690943,
-0.0674800649,
0.0130803678,
-0.0252704639,
-0.0122906435,
-0.0053808647,
0.0195512511,
-0.0038122716,
0.0142189041,
0.0367928185,
-0.0224505775,
-0.026225701,
-0.0483805798,
-0.039139647,
-0.0334504917,
0.0330587029,
0.0078517273,
0.0318152308,
-0.0115519855,
-0.0841608495,
-0.0305324327,
-0.0513624214,
0.0056757797,
-0.0110139167,
0.0489357971,
-0.0190704819,
0.0064923894,
-0.0638739318,
-0.0097787185,
-0.0138909416,
-0.0087125059,
0.0054753227,
0.033078514,
0.0011588268,
-0.0274319556,
-0.0398432761,
0.0491227955,
-0.003882057,
0.0678813756,
0.003856305,
-0.0032864159,
-0.0165518317,
0.0946944281,
-0.0005773024,
-0.0097170193,
-0.0353363007,
0.0133450096,
-0.0032604295,
0.0050059622,
0.0018485744,
-0.0290426686,
-0.055865068,
-0.0268950742,
-0.025023099,
-0.0143902898,
-0.0009330191,
-0.0338568576,
-0.0241864193,
-0.0485164002,
0.0033427717,
0.0759421363,
0.002062557,
-0.0409844406,
-0.0216962285,
-0.0122743733,
-0.0357228033,
-0.049561087,
-0.0128083732,
-0.0325238034,
0.0158678778,
-0.0139015177,
0.0156308226,
0.0301380213,
-0.0493295155,
0.0063258293,
-0.0460393354,
-0.0712533742,
0.0278812405,
-0.0622538552,
-0.0707311556,
-0.019612534,
-0.013691809,
-0.0107563846,
0.0307535976,
0.0230743531,
0.0039184894,
-0.0199563503,
0.0238544978,
-0.0594669618,
-0.041122485,
-0.0261843856,
-0.0158560332,
0.0554434657,
0.0333328992,
0.0465669632,
-0.0273796879,
-0.0119521879,
-0.020814728,
0.0193299036,
0.0307551753,
-0.0381964408,
0.0381764732,
0.0709849969,
-0.0155587047,
-0.0324099287,
0.0154359639,
0.0181135423,
0.0093685407,
0.0104597779,
0.0397398025,
0.0343382321,
-0.0183523931,
0.0152891316,
-0.019109847,
0.0104026524,
0.0321034193,
-0.0204200819,
0.0140434746,
-0.0325159393,
-0.023274269,
0.0225011893,
-0.1069793329,
-0.0458789244,
0.0171076357,
-0.0374268815,
-0.0410964638,
-0.0884302631,
-0.0516207367,
-0.0074112657,
0.0454301201,
0.0457420349,
-0.0293410886,
0.0510766953,
-0.0148867676,
-0.0375487544,
-0.0036158864,
-0.033779934,
0.0010972428,
-0.0784899145,
0.0253351051,
-0.0335872248,
-0.0238333102,
0.0205198117,
-0.0150680672,
-0.0067531094,
0.0052702818,
0.0492092781,
-0.0182006285,
0.0207443759,
-0.0019467379,
-0.0056866943,
-0.0378926098,
0.0284255072,
0.038635198,
-0.0078317523,
-0.0468791462,
-0.0090461448,
0.0126783848,
0.0052222922,
0.0146838846,
-0.0002390735,
0.0691790059,
-0.002462924,
-0.0027875132,
-0.0023837043,
-0.0255755205,
-0.0084286891,
0.0289161634,
0.0043151882,
0.0091640763,
0.0032035643,
-0.0129908202,
-0.0094937775,
-0.0616774745,
0.0194934644,
0.0154735558,
0.0279237665,
0.0375126377,
0.0414988883,
-0.0121323047,
-0.0021235051,
-0.0153714037,
-0.0454680249,
-0.0231938362,
-0.0011428362,
0.0295003485,
0.0634479821,
0.0048194584,
0.0111979153,
0.0144040454,
0.0044911755,
0.0128603848,
0.0255544018,
-0.011268924,
-0.0056317123,
0.0100394897,
0.0110436669,
-0.0436259508,
-0.007101424,
-0.0238463581,
0.0638765544,
-0.0106828734,
-0.0321969241,
0.0734626055,
0.0122207385,
0.0762923136,
-0.003178542,
0.0135711608,
0.0268037803,
-0.0027105315,
0.0356645212,
0.0521326847,
-0.0190210622,
-0.0094085569,
0.0170782376,
-0.0137585457,
0.0009324232,
-0.0590403415,
0.0112788985,
0.0096378587,
-0.0422614105,
-0.0354037993,
0.0180636365,
-0.0196780879,
-0.0760091245,
-0.0536585525,
-0.0491836965,
-0.0385563336,
-0.0035352868,
0.0070708161,
0.028149398,
-0.0046480554,
-0.0000888635,
0.0056105056,
-0.0434950255,
0.024810072,
0.0229135621,
0.0311659593,
0.0878570527,
0.0223979242,
-0.0592452399,
-0.0759644136,
-5.63050884e-33,
-0.0041413759,
-0.0187033508,
0.0260704532,
0.0090712402,
-0.0438049883,
-0.0098148566,
-0.0028155828,
-0.0357177928,
-0.0053451168,
0.0070107742,
-0.0381929316,
-0.0229244754,
0.0362134948,
-0.0101969941,
0.0463040285,
0.0297478028,
0.0487795919,
-0.0203568731,
-0.0058208029,
-0.0012453436,
0.067328997,
0.0360688008,
0.0940223336,
-0.0654525831,
0.0146133127,
0.0024385322,
-0.0211752001,
0.0194985438,
0.1028745249,
0.0044732406,
-0.0126619525,
0.0227508824,
0.0372386388,
-0.0054432969,
-0.0196483098,
0.0428448841,
-0.103434816,
-0.0353538394,
0.0009557184,
0.0824437365,
0.0342960879,
-0.0199668258,
0.0511909463,
-0.0432569273,
-0.0111525385,
0.0566900969,
0.0173057746,
-0.0430235825,
0.0222562142,
0.0075635794,
-0.0655069649,
0.0181544572,
0.0100791939,
0.0020295065,
0.0734344199,
0.0344137773,
-0.0025195125,
-0.0260519478,
-0.0652992725,
0.003865266,
0.0513771288,
0.0558970608,
0.0127254957,
0.0038961782,
-0.0266816821,
-0.0225905124,
0.0707300678,
-0.0280712191,
0.0027307197,
0.0357557759,
0.0546457991,
-0.0210759621,
0.0774298236,
0.0138772205,
0.0725997239,
0.0108355265,
-0.0233763102,
0.0362063609,
0.084579967,
0.0424428768,
-0.0124470908,
0.001841156,
-0.0195038877,
0.0006145794,
0.0392795242,
0.0103927962,
0.0037991907,
-0.0236371495,
0.0177143086,
-0.0084296688,
0.0045467587,
0.0267674085,
0.0117267603,
-0.0346459486,
-0.0287120976,
0.0061500538,
0.0045602196,
0.0299269222,
-0.0158471595,
-0.0070954375,
-0.0575760938,
-0.0856839642,
0.0474205986,
0.0371723771,
0.0100778267,
-0.0107264863,
-0.0051746885,
0.0347795002,
-0.0609728135,
0.0106750811,
0.0101420637,
-0.012657593,
0.0260217413,
0.0314818546,
0.007785683,
-0.0356869735,
0.0012987391,
-0.0239083692,
0.0650899485,
-0.0176301599,
0.0134250745,
-0.0265466217,
0.0882045329,
0.0188430399,
-0.0180730298,
0.0461984873,
-0.0127593903,
0.0292628687,
0.0260948334,
0.0401181951,
0.0024141385,
0.017047096,
2.467e-7,
0.0576649755,
0.0330558382,
0.085463874,
-0.0035640392,
0.0196838751,
-0.0314529054,
-0.0380856954,
0.0022009832,
-0.0138583053,
0.0752429739,
0.0390224829,
-0.0483466536,
0.0462864339,
0.039855063,
-0.0434353836,
-0.0651334897,
-0.036605984,
-0.0293251369,
-0.0330843367,
0.0572737567,
0.0457699969,
0.0390816368,
0.0020228697,
-0.0293466542,
-0.012422625,
-0.0318493582,
-0.0087242452,
0.019779345,
0.0101565011,
0.00814238,
0.0601155385,
-0.0020218659,
-0.0268983729,
0.0352694914,
0.0319875814,
0.0396808162,
0.0029755449,
0.0219493583,
-0.0168723632,
0.0546561107,
0.0055520847,
-0.0357157737,
-0.0311699025,
-0.0334591344,
0.0103603425,
-0.0143426182,
-0.0051140031,
0.036676079,
-0.0135870427,
0.0561469682,
-0.0109259859,
0.0054657748,
-0.0581703633,
0.0081465095,
0.0399669111,
0.0188418441,
-0.0235203058,
-0.0365213044,
-0.0028825793,
-0.0010719838,
0.0273814108,
-0.0207767952,
-0.038178578,
0.000110819,
-0.0099760266,
0.0222428348,
0.0234341137,
2.013575676e-34,
-0.0012975187,
-0.0188395362,
-0.0061781304,
-0.0044263005,
-0.0375836864,
-0.0208895914,
-0.0029555757,
0.0269756131,
-0.0242947247,
-0.055947721,
-0.0143813211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01293v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01293v2 | Can MLLMs Perform Text-to-Image In-Context Learning? | 2024-02-02T10:30:05 | 2024-04-15T21:30:10 | Yuchen Zeng, Wonjun Kang, Yicong Chen, Hyung Il Koo, Kangwook Lee | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The evolution from Large Language Models (LLMs) to Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) has spurred research into extending In-Context Learning (ICL) to
its multimodal counterpart. Existing such studies have primarily concentrated
on image-to-text ICL. However, the Text-to-Image ICL (T2I-ICL), with its unique
characteristics and potential applications, remains underexplored. To address
this gap, we formally define the task of T2I-ICL and present CoBSAT, the first
T2I-ICL benchmark dataset, encompassing ten tasks. Utilizing our dataset to
benchmark six state-of-the-art MLLMs, we uncover considerable difficulties
MLLMs encounter in solving T2I-ICL. We identify the primary challenges as the
inherent complexity of multimodality and image generation, and show that
strategies such as fine-tuning and Chain-of-Thought prompting help to mitigate
these difficulties, leading to notable improvements in performance. Our code
and dataset are available at https://github.com/UW-Madison-Lee-Lab/CoBSAT. | Can MLLMs Perform Text-to-Image In-Context Learning?: The evolution from Large Language Models (LLMs) to Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) has spurred research into extending In-Context Learning (ICL) to
its multimodal counterpart. Existing such studies have primarily concentrated
on image-to-text ICL. However, the Text-to-Image ICL (T2I-ICL), with its unique
characteristics and potential applications, remains underexplored. To address
this gap, we formally define the task of T2I-ICL and present CoBSAT, the first
T2I-ICL benchmark dataset, encompassing ten tasks. Utilizing our dataset to
benchmark six state-of-the-art MLLMs, we uncover considerable difficulties
MLLMs encounter in solving T2I-ICL. We identify the primary challenges as the
inherent complexity of multimodality and image generation, and show that
strategies such as fine-tuning and Chain-of-Thought prompting help to mitigate
these difficulties, leading to notable improvements in performance. Our code
and dataset are available at https://github.com/UW-Madison-Lee-Lab/CoBSAT. | [
0.0028312644,
0.070443444,
0.0264788419,
0.0955645069,
-0.0489239581,
0.0180584695,
0.0455006734,
-0.0130962925,
-0.0016384678,
-0.0694046691,
-0.0709452033,
-0.0393936485,
0.0292502642,
0.0194776859,
0.0528365895,
-0.0531517304,
-0.0135208741,
-0.0537137464,
-0.040228337,
-0.0040827552,
0.0233658236,
0.0356525667,
-0.0134190219,
0.0209374204,
-0.054308597,
-0.0327410065,
0.0146527747,
0.0536384769,
0.0193395596,
-0.01814791,
-0.0061800396,
0.0240292531,
0.0482753068,
0.0032681914,
0.0000018367,
-0.0287729893,
0.0121261347,
-0.0013058267,
0.0316479318,
-0.020808816,
0.0702396631,
-0.0568754934,
0.0060391715,
-0.0121687884,
-0.029696675,
0.0253089815,
0.0620431527,
0.0511101559,
0.0538843758,
0.0752047971,
-0.0277688764,
-0.02079162,
0.0062677059,
-0.029950235,
0.0217689518,
-0.0342970155,
0.0084280791,
0.0025124124,
0.0037768586,
-0.0136940507,
-0.0354949795,
0.0723629072,
0.0348963551,
-0.0143290795,
-0.0415130667,
0.0482303575,
0.0050044106,
-0.0368554071,
-0.0185402445,
0.0933922008,
-0.0356011949,
-0.0153314117,
-0.041021347,
0.0000808455,
-0.004099133,
-0.0111082429,
-0.0149647901,
0.0548281074,
-0.0185873806,
0.0300058126,
-0.0287421625,
-0.0087590814,
0.0247906316,
-0.0062002488,
-0.01736225,
0.0164331924,
0.0263317078,
-0.0002247653,
-0.0236427579,
0.0109496294,
-0.030850349,
-0.0323671363,
0.0001426602,
0.0326441303,
-0.0306453872,
0.0019472725,
-0.0676495656,
-0.0296256933,
-0.0193143375,
-0.0100154355,
0.0680415183,
-0.0085897474,
-0.0314887092,
0.0511560179,
-0.0059357556,
0.0065462706,
-0.0120868646,
0.0157304369,
-0.0408966504,
-0.0388859995,
0.0026278654,
0.0097952774,
-0.0394481272,
-0.0244306549,
-0.0373328887,
-0.0317261219,
-0.0092640556,
0.013452217,
-0.0136642251,
0.0048990222,
-0.0320126005,
-0.00154492,
-0.0448315293,
-0.0354888625,
0.0190648008,
0.0211379398,
0.0282975528,
0.028990522,
0.005920426,
-0.0291022845,
0.007436418,
0.0398681983,
0.0425133519,
-0.0366760679,
-0.0053633922,
0.0597914793,
-0.0497401468,
-0.0542746633,
-0.0296131782,
-0.0176351015,
-0.0408046246,
-0.0894417837,
0.0180849638,
-0.0651058778,
0.0345995277,
-0.0088386247,
0.0122038377,
-0.0211809855,
-0.0119364625,
0.0016251209,
-0.0017555878,
0.1090829447,
0.0025375802,
-0.012656875,
0.0379248224,
0.0066094766,
0.0042415727,
0.0798057243,
0.0303348191,
0.0491929315,
0.0269897766,
0.0290728938,
0.0051297233,
0.0951137021,
0.0120029943,
0.0353411436,
-0.0307997577,
-0.0085329199,
0.0117159616,
0.0474285334,
0.0436992496,
0.0699006766,
-0.0283934083,
-0.0049728435,
0.1072335243,
0.0179636609,
0.0440618321,
-0.0050764899,
0.0556198731,
0.0035974784,
-0.0008454528,
-0.0034896173,
-0.0553340055,
0.0293141436,
-0.0022519424,
0.0147203449,
0.0279137343,
0.0557284057,
-0.0335053094,
-0.0077416361,
0.0139812818,
-0.0454239622,
-0.0128163006,
0.0100379074,
0.0393094569,
0.034734156,
-0.0449562222,
-0.0119508477,
0.0275667328,
-0.0185242351,
0.0028319885,
-0.0327851586,
0.0188749917,
0.0494559817,
0.029740639,
-0.0005812977,
-0.0142952893,
-0.0103102988,
0.0544503704,
0.0860657021,
-0.0277856104,
-0.0110008698,
0.05392069,
-0.0572882667,
-0.0439761542,
0.0153403739,
-0.0106522199,
0.0093251476,
0.0020603815,
0.0223654509,
-0.0004663119,
0.0007347413,
0.0223673526,
0.0345406719,
-0.0050690128,
0.024465153,
-0.0136150355,
0.0277057234,
-0.0051997839,
-0.0255619567,
-0.0184723847,
-0.0134119699,
-0.0015960755,
-0.060391508,
-0.0052975202,
0.0172824059,
-0.0598993562,
-0.0613338798,
0.0175706167,
-0.0543038771,
-0.0251868311,
0.0118845748,
-0.0418487266,
-0.0103367344,
-0.0319200195,
-0.0083502885,
0.0029345292,
-0.0269775391,
-0.0265151262,
0.0378011726,
0.0169383213,
-0.0301666185,
0.0323563516,
-0.0217338745,
-0.02489274,
0.0247690715,
0.0179547723,
-0.0254168157,
-0.0070863827,
-0.0219353251,
0.008673883,
0.0081378603,
0.0297081787,
-0.0042152903,
0.065615803,
-0.0445578322,
-0.023849953,
-0.0973005444,
-0.0321941897,
-0.0326998942,
-0.0365272835,
0.0190393608,
0.0064453613,
0.0033828262,
-0.0232072007,
-0.032978002,
0.0215079281,
0.0089125205,
0.024439346,
0.025516592,
0.0079346346,
0.0261502061,
-0.0274712536,
-0.0067754663,
0.022919273,
0.0681949556,
-0.0145481694,
-0.0346186198,
-0.0407378227,
0.0010982781,
-0.0228506494,
0.0208822414,
-0.0210846625,
0.0227134135,
0.0225441232,
-0.0425240211,
0.0757497028,
0.0575091057,
0.0263966154,
0.0033340678,
0.0125980806,
-0.0066898684,
-0.0544064045,
-0.0103403898,
0.0189770106,
-0.032194864,
-0.0214719903,
-0.0243360754,
-0.0204037707,
0.0425893106,
-0.0014751066,
0.0184898656,
-0.0402791426,
0.0153062213,
-0.0069467705,
-0.0525941402,
-0.0689708665,
0.0303640626,
0.0014376978,
0.0189111661,
-0.0493053459,
-0.0743541569,
0.0182298888,
-0.049401138,
-0.0220816489,
-0.0023626778,
0.0051637422,
-0.0247045122,
0.0523295477,
0.0246390849,
0.0470847599,
-0.0112615125,
0.0164285991,
-0.0593838878,
0.0069814064,
0.0040683537,
0.0090475688,
0.0902163684,
-0.0385293998,
0.0214027558,
-0.0376911871,
-0.0439890511,
-0.0209106747,
-0.0273237694,
-0.0132377809,
-0.0177813787,
-0.0376502424,
-0.0191871207,
-0.0136878658,
0.0053291465,
0.0145363342,
0.0280883648,
-0.0050377557,
-0.03307366,
-0.0119432621,
0.0770389661,
0.0612850785,
0.0119122276,
-0.0202236082,
-0.0343600474,
0.0051421463,
0.0446225181,
0.0239143725,
-0.0046012453,
-0.0624708645,
0.0209131688,
0.0176032353,
0.0787711218,
0.0112296529,
0.0227424242,
0.0638104007,
-0.023489384,
-0.0287797432,
0.0686377957,
-0.0104823532,
-0.0746398345,
-0.0363443419,
0.0235105958,
0.0567447804,
0.0043653967,
-0.0082041407,
-0.076097928,
-0.0636122897,
-0.0179967415,
-0.0032395129,
0.033361502,
0.0093877222,
-0.0327066369,
-0.0693493187,
0.0544859655,
0.0047347993,
-0.0413262136,
-0.0374536328,
0.0093887998,
-0.005495023,
0.0259430856,
0.0198922716,
-0.0002639091,
-0.0144673288,
-0.0022032065,
-0.0002038061,
0.0236086212,
-0.0649705455,
0.0011897713,
-0.0364006869,
0.00619253,
0.0441575274,
0.0307133514,
0.0189627856,
-0.0132325906,
0.0799295828,
0.0172699597,
-0.0225416999,
-0.0292063318,
0.0485808849,
-0.0051385057,
-0.0157762878,
0.0085963756,
0.063223891,
-0.0215257704,
0.004770007,
-0.0025811724,
0.0300535411,
-0.0011652415,
-0.0122149484,
-0.0308264345,
0.0068516871,
0.03225803,
0.0481161289,
0.0303082094,
-0.0700046122,
-0.014808761,
-0.0199898127,
-0.0068384469,
-0.0355440974,
-0.0174673032,
-0.0019900051,
-0.0053463755,
0.0385860205,
-0.081875436,
-0.0404218063,
0.0115875648,
0.061690934,
-0.010877464,
-0.0058206683,
-0.0401096717,
-0.0067257835,
-0.0345991664,
0.0508657917,
-0.0436867438,
0.0429835767,
-0.0534676462,
-0.0044758702,
0.045270022,
-0.0581468605,
0.0070615909,
0.0447537936,
-0.1130040213,
-0.027315801,
-0.036914587,
0.0485262685,
0.0116398865,
0.0721317008,
0.0119586168,
-0.042672988,
0.0471382849,
0.0513831377,
0.0189733133,
0.0239855498,
-0.0031465092,
0.0418790504,
-0.0088421712,
0.0458317883,
-0.0428836234,
0.0214245319,
0.0266369972,
0.0165396128,
-0.0082222298,
-0.0353906304,
0.0060761021,
-0.0065928889,
0.0120837381,
-0.0601767749,
-0.0019699046,
-0.0385651812,
-0.0075133662,
-0.0199582409,
-0.033690583,
-0.096563302,
-0.0161190648,
0.030436974,
0.0197112449,
-0.0071970215,
-0.0047480236,
0.0550548211,
0.0530269071,
-0.0389977768,
0.010893099,
0.0373548679,
0.0167383589,
0.0234160051,
0.0267698523,
-0.0066026486,
0.0414841101,
-0.0292413738,
0.0365350395,
-0.019376358,
0.0781873986,
0.03665369,
-0.0325540341,
-0.0308271982,
0.0474561304,
-0.0091258092,
-0.0043086093,
-0.0632653385,
0.0402299017,
0.0723466054,
0.0252727624,
0.0694139525,
-0.0282103848,
-0.0240315832,
-0.0346044749,
0.0615398809,
0.0035043783,
-0.0481620692,
0.0551028475,
-0.0199890248,
0.0209460817,
0.0145869376,
0.0593513176,
0.0010421386,
0.0164949857,
0.0321890041,
0.0444693305,
-0.0377746895,
-0.0275465064,
0.0330120586,
-0.0160432216,
0.0117810117,
0.0210592374,
-0.0081242751,
-0.0590864532,
0.0073679537,
0.0265114568,
-0.0228178855,
0.0183612406,
0.036668919,
0.0573238917,
0.0215954222,
0.0079289386,
-0.0133500928,
-0.002371897,
0.0344558507,
-0.0312121473,
-0.0283046942,
-5.899515579e-33,
-0.0431568101,
-0.0437102504,
0.0463879779,
0.0064374045,
-0.007446798,
0.0207550507,
-0.0126391361,
0.0263436791,
-0.0140433349,
-0.0000334338,
-0.0061203702,
-0.0317131579,
0.0010693714,
0.0727805495,
-0.0285842307,
0.0005131823,
0.0162947141,
-0.0299501456,
-0.0118877338,
0.009238001,
-0.0013803768,
0.012703062,
0.0303474069,
-0.0440301374,
-0.0168455951,
-0.0163818784,
-0.0459954552,
0.0166369472,
-0.0118777333,
0.0330567807,
-0.0303269252,
0.0230357759,
0.0233221818,
0.0091319224,
-0.0423192382,
0.0225825403,
-0.0838542059,
0.0287018567,
-0.0213909689,
0.0183154643,
-0.0858466923,
0.013532876,
0.0467983447,
-0.0144460574,
0.0064469869,
-0.0579763837,
0.0385059528,
-0.0121124731,
-0.0193172283,
-0.0211065803,
-0.0584219694,
0.0065205065,
0.0001126943,
-0.0427897498,
0.0300514922,
0.0734912902,
0.0055269911,
0.0334993191,
-0.0672777891,
0.0160260256,
-0.0322532691,
0.0110838087,
0.0879273862,
0.0506786518,
-0.0125026377,
0.042507939,
0.0232806224,
-0.0089016976,
-0.0029398089,
0.0078114439,
0.0498272367,
0.0687687993,
0.0286640152,
0.0936249793,
-0.0105030378,
0.0462119095,
-0.0382317901,
0.0337387323,
-0.0295048468,
-0.0092541631,
0.035323564,
0.0070656505,
-0.0044504218,
0.0008944345,
-0.0486103147,
-0.0220355913,
-0.0429420769,
0.0075033451,
0.0492979176,
0.0254206881,
-0.0028300618,
-0.0063913446,
0.0836080164,
-0.0175058674,
-0.0488117822,
-0.0100653432,
-0.0263403822,
0.0514076874,
-0.0122230332,
0.0309309307,
-0.0389197767,
-0.0262942687,
0.0268358607,
0.0340760946,
0.0136161894,
0.0104892813,
0.080648087,
0.0219020639,
-0.0528374948,
-0.0067927428,
-0.0487079546,
0.0433409512,
-0.0173530076,
0.044755958,
0.026761869,
-0.0351872332,
-0.0530113578,
0.0297987182,
0.0000645416,
-0.0296105631,
-0.0011971479,
-0.0297134425,
-0.0258479882,
-0.0035825754,
-0.022729421,
0.0244209878,
-0.0458858497,
-0.0359091051,
0.0513692312,
-0.0544451475,
-0.0032795821,
0.0229098238,
2.341e-7,
0.0335322767,
0.0109732924,
0.0070614046,
0.0089489594,
0.0375897549,
0.0659548342,
-0.0499426238,
0.0219628196,
0.0159614533,
0.0005323234,
-0.0026066864,
0.0436778031,
0.0548838973,
-0.0096960571,
-0.0178491212,
0.0207236856,
-0.0319856107,
0.0330647901,
-0.0501633324,
-0.0185824241,
0.0350122005,
0.0785976946,
-0.0314985625,
-0.0567907803,
0.046709463,
-0.0578125678,
0.0932859629,
-0.0561837815,
-0.0098025193,
-0.0242141727,
-0.0054312567,
-0.002996017,
0.0018097319,
0.0042790971,
0.0127884289,
-0.0424494669,
0.0432113186,
0.0434938855,
-0.0075002415,
-0.0496038646,
0.0070729409,
0.0328930505,
-0.046963416,
-0.0566000305,
0.0702420473,
-0.052663777,
-0.0154130403,
-0.0396514684,
0.0143434228,
-0.0163617563,
0.0157531984,
-0.0438322723,
-0.0478077196,
0.0298323911,
0.0562964082,
-0.0158901569,
-0.0376543663,
-0.0792436302,
-0.0646727756,
-0.0206716489,
-0.0544903427,
-0.0092469528,
-0.0684615448,
0.0268776827,
0.0226051249,
-0.0370778143,
-0.040718589,
1.785276191e-34,
-0.0047644773,
-0.0218407959,
0.018285362,
0.0113052754,
0.0093119275,
-0.0092684245,
-0.0614871532,
-0.0044067437,
-0.0217044,
-0.0622620173,
-0.0064980779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01806v1 | HQA-Attack: Toward High Quality Black-Box Hard-Label Adversarial Attack on Text | 2024-02-02T10:06:43 | 2024-02-02T10:06:43 | Han Liu, Zhi Xu, Xiaotong Zhang, Feng Zhang, Fenglong Ma, Hongyang Chen, Hong Yu, Xianchao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Black-box hard-label adversarial attack on text is a practical and
challenging task, as the text data space is inherently discrete and
non-differentiable, and only the predicted label is accessible. Research on
this problem is still in the embryonic stage and only a few methods are
available. Nevertheless, existing methods rely on the complex heuristic
algorithm or unreliable gradient estimation strategy, which probably fall into
the local optimum and inevitably consume numerous queries, thus are difficult
to craft satisfactory adversarial examples with high semantic similarity and
low perturbation rate in a limited query budget. To alleviate above issues, we
propose a simple yet effective framework to generate high quality textual
adversarial examples under the black-box hard-label attack scenarios, named
HQA-Attack. Specifically, after initializing an adversarial example randomly,
HQA-attack first constantly substitutes original words back as many as
possible, thus shrinking the perturbation rate. Then it leverages the synonym
set of the remaining changed words to further optimize the adversarial example
with the direction which can improve the semantic similarity and satisfy the
adversarial condition simultaneously. In addition, during the optimizing
procedure, it searches a transition synonym word for each changed word, thus
avoiding traversing the whole synonym set and reducing the query number to some
extent. Extensive experimental results on five text classification datasets,
three natural language inference datasets and two real-world APIs have shown
that the proposed HQA-Attack method outperforms other strong baselines
significantly. | HQA-Attack: Toward High Quality Black-Box Hard-Label Adversarial Attack on Text: Black-box hard-label adversarial attack on text is a practical and
challenging task, as the text data space is inherently discrete and
non-differentiable, and only the predicted label is accessible. Research on
this problem is still in the embryonic stage and only a few methods are
available. Nevertheless, existing methods rely on the complex heuristic
algorithm or unreliable gradient estimation strategy, which probably fall into
the local optimum and inevitably consume numerous queries, thus are difficult
to craft satisfactory adversarial examples with high semantic similarity and
low perturbation rate in a limited query budget. To alleviate above issues, we
propose a simple yet effective framework to generate high quality textual
adversarial examples under the black-box hard-label attack scenarios, named
HQA-Attack. Specifically, after initializing an adversarial example randomly,
HQA-attack first constantly substitutes original words back as many as
possible, thus shrinking the perturbation rate. Then it leverages the synonym
set of the remaining changed words to further optimize the adversarial example
with the direction which can improve the semantic similarity and satisfy the
adversarial condition simultaneously. In addition, during the optimizing
procedure, it searches a transition synonym word for each changed word, thus
avoiding traversing the whole synonym set and reducing the query number to some
extent. Extensive experimental results on five text classification datasets,
three natural language inference datasets and two real-world APIs have shown
that the proposed HQA-Attack method outperforms other strong baselines
significantly. | [
0.0704244301,
0.0672181472,
-0.0124511607,
0.0111602657,
-0.0623153895,
0.0022995644,
0.0017680732,
0.0283385254,
0.0345332101,
-0.0446759909,
0.0036901198,
-0.0308294091,
0.012631041,
-0.0003530378,
0.0563261621,
-0.0055350428,
0.0507679433,
0.037742231,
-0.0485260896,
-0.0248016305,
-0.0044693039,
0.010448521,
-0.0069074868,
0.0036018707,
-0.0157106332,
-0.0145437559,
-0.0332572609,
0.0253191795,
0.0495433919,
-0.0229206812,
0.0601439551,
0.03983289,
-0.0110732252,
0.1045621708,
0.0000019485,
-0.0318985097,
-0.0557479076,
0.0251127165,
-0.012599458,
0.0116965054,
0.0567972884,
-0.0348217189,
-0.0025706731,
0.0077450955,
-0.0162960198,
-0.0203024056,
0.0153122814,
0.0550471023,
0.0851854533,
0.1125141382,
-0.0179762878,
-0.0621120892,
-0.0051629418,
-0.0649363697,
-0.0061176089,
-0.0813983232,
0.0588256456,
-0.0392669626,
-0.0264734216,
0.0125108035,
-0.0052495706,
0.0299933031,
0.0444984362,
0.0204782914,
0.0077614649,
0.0234129485,
-0.0114413537,
-0.0007969649,
0.02681024,
0.0937823877,
-0.0485278144,
-0.0208875239,
0.0152414311,
0.0005260819,
0.011937188,
-0.042994678,
0.0098244473,
-0.0304314978,
0.003857719,
0.0225047767,
0.0140158627,
-0.0040222933,
0.060002204,
0.0170992538,
0.019650802,
0.0002433427,
0.03426826,
-0.0354135595,
0.0268521383,
-0.0551346689,
-0.0044151857,
-0.0171963107,
0.0146004194,
0.0267881379,
0.0030536333,
0.0060968781,
-0.0871672705,
-0.0698063448,
0.0337524936,
-0.0701621175,
0.0310579389,
-0.0211876538,
-0.0221672654,
0.0405258872,
-0.0330958739,
-0.0093279779,
-0.0166932847,
0.0598850474,
-0.0144603653,
-0.0328812413,
-0.0156859476,
-0.0118874973,
-0.0576352514,
0.0354922451,
-0.0163721628,
-0.0032938106,
-0.045359049,
-0.0162481181,
-0.0295334626,
0.0352412499,
-0.0262782797,
0.0256825462,
-0.0360367596,
-0.0165773034,
0.0143003697,
-0.0765734389,
-0.0483130775,
0.0051135584,
-0.0209255088,
-0.0676447079,
-0.0241311081,
0.0186404977,
-0.0212827399,
-0.0280554965,
0.0024770049,
0.1140647754,
-0.0188325625,
-0.0337536074,
-0.0604540184,
-0.0240316931,
0.0032259012,
-0.0185177773,
-0.013718361,
-0.0239989217,
0.0108059682,
-0.0547262616,
-0.0207062997,
-0.0576313324,
0.0000727952,
0.0215690881,
0.0045955111,
0.0836958066,
-0.023777876,
-0.0519664884,
0.0389122739,
0.0371263027,
-0.0155840525,
0.0752916113,
-0.0379520655,
0.0604718812,
0.0379071198,
0.0208234359,
-0.0075247274,
0.0206701327,
0.0471089073,
0.0289251432,
-0.0408341177,
0.0074629406,
0.0007700265,
0.0379542895,
-0.0370413102,
0.0513708442,
-0.0297607798,
-0.0981426537,
0.0368810445,
-0.0226488709,
0.0003657562,
0.0544763431,
-0.0042372528,
0.0015688819,
-0.0277221091,
-0.0112884389,
-0.0232953392,
-0.0105639827,
-0.0427993611,
-0.0479112528,
0.0553272814,
0.0119706597,
-0.018158773,
-0.0380813256,
0.0118646286,
0.0009731278,
0.006370571,
-0.0513021015,
0.0196823925,
0.0762170851,
-0.015195515,
0.0476123951,
0.0353289507,
0.0054817637,
-0.0000204158,
-0.03915672,
-0.0080225002,
0.009329753,
0.0689062327,
-0.0303428378,
0.0347989351,
-0.0169177819,
-0.0007987936,
0.0041337125,
0.0266326852,
-0.0097109014,
-0.0065105888,
-0.0662631467,
-0.0127597274,
-0.0375412367,
0.0259097591,
0.0432437882,
0.0220490061,
0.0259886477,
0.0466659106,
-0.0047325697,
-0.0324005224,
0.0346752442,
0.0268838722,
-0.055293493,
0.0410027914,
0.0337919258,
0.0519808494,
-0.0079125986,
-0.0012087793,
0.007295392,
0.0300111547,
-0.0196704213,
-0.0778326988,
-0.0519131012,
0.0462059714,
-0.034046866,
0.0323854946,
-0.0455635674,
-0.0033548381,
0.0740492344,
-0.0605713166,
0.0030451962,
0.0205889661,
-0.0470297933,
0.010753734,
-0.0118021863,
-0.0322611704,
-0.0079844743,
0.0610119477,
-0.0225884914,
0.057284791,
-0.0136056384,
0.0010258189,
-0.0208696909,
0.0433530845,
0.0088464301,
0.0137127414,
-0.0514524914,
0.0023805548,
-0.0170849636,
0.0084386291,
-0.0041582161,
-0.0254913066,
-0.0270729065,
-0.0268450566,
-0.0026179082,
-0.0165632274,
-0.0388671234,
-0.0252831802,
0.0591039918,
-0.0095365457,
-0.0069688614,
-0.0312009212,
0.0039645601,
0.0334071778,
-0.068015404,
0.0428375117,
0.0494337492,
0.0275706444,
-0.0279972665,
-0.013096706,
-0.0056405133,
0.004395965,
0.0774526969,
0.0019231074,
0.0104255555,
-0.0078110397,
0.0017611576,
-0.0084920796,
0.0342333838,
-0.035357222,
-0.0341793448,
-0.0009991027,
0.0243722312,
0.000934768,
0.054220777,
0.0577202253,
0.0339708701,
0.027209634,
0.012990539,
-0.0121049695,
-0.0148530118,
-0.042705223,
0.0057258084,
-0.0499313176,
-0.0279406141,
0.0292960983,
0.0398941934,
0.0334575735,
-0.0020752903,
-0.0164250042,
0.0263825469,
0.0150561472,
-0.0370382071,
-0.0498447269,
0.0427503064,
-0.0383679084,
-0.0349588953,
-0.0162484366,
-0.0323365703,
0.0761261806,
-0.019181164,
0.0344019085,
-0.0297814924,
-0.0528701469,
0.0037151724,
0.0414676219,
-0.0184232686,
0.0213722289,
-0.0036000686,
0.0130225783,
-0.0129046803,
-0.0148269478,
0.0538306348,
-0.0029582209,
-0.0210976601,
0.0195460171,
0.0006748176,
-0.0023724257,
-0.010973026,
-0.0410189964,
-0.0667203441,
0.0012256148,
-0.0019603728,
0.0299719293,
-0.0091155348,
-0.0543073304,
-0.0253119711,
-0.0114411823,
0.0481890775,
-0.0259414352,
-0.0009589281,
-0.0314549617,
0.0242007021,
0.0935944691,
-0.0610309131,
-0.0165712647,
-0.0010136463,
0.0013966693,
0.0712218657,
0.0430173613,
0.0108427871,
-0.0084952535,
-0.0347542949,
-0.0072402479,
-0.0123816114,
0.0044954871,
-0.0045417305,
-0.0583611801,
-0.0057716989,
-0.010025844,
0.0541013591,
-0.0052705617,
-0.0160005819,
0.0346924029,
-0.0296632107,
0.033766482,
-0.0060515981,
-0.0065883016,
-0.0722385421,
-0.0377553813,
-0.0046906644,
0.031229442,
-0.037004672,
-0.0331689604,
0.0024878033,
-0.1079303399,
-0.0227565076,
0.0204060916,
-0.0044514793,
-0.011150633,
-0.0155633613,
0.0090128295,
-0.0153108574,
-0.0090260953,
-0.0029531245,
0.0628785864,
-0.0095520588,
0.0036421679,
0.029941611,
-0.0445841737,
0.0147489905,
-0.0002781847,
-0.0077548763,
0.0322460234,
0.0523007624,
-0.0116087981,
-0.015149883,
0.0625595599,
-0.0203205552,
-0.0353711024,
0.0209063813,
0.0632675812,
-0.030929707,
-0.0258649923,
0.0231870078,
0.0391788334,
0.0099268276,
0.0000746271,
0.0031152174,
0.0306661986,
0.0080087408,
-0.0134118944,
-0.0228277817,
-0.0044317977,
0.0363998525,
0.0323781893,
0.0200362857,
-0.061351154,
-0.0288209971,
-0.0003302592,
0.0316083357,
-0.0297992546,
-0.0157483984,
0.0273948479,
-0.0149402572,
-0.034127187,
-0.0520980284,
-0.0252077188,
-0.0449218862,
0.0551655702,
-0.0109809916,
0.0217732079,
-0.0320003815,
-0.0375241525,
-0.0168414228,
-0.033553943,
-0.0122222956,
0.0390862301,
-0.0095418412,
-0.0071168989,
0.0559203885,
0.0195286814,
-0.045011621,
0.0268099103,
-0.0276791044,
-0.072846204,
0.0166302454,
-0.0050245081,
0.0051466557,
0.0549941249,
-0.0517606698,
-0.0778538957,
0.0221976042,
0.0751959458,
0.0346193463,
0.0014268094,
0.0461505502,
-0.0434683524,
0.0345704183,
0.0756059512,
-0.0363057144,
0.0052350271,
0.0611202233,
0.0078061572,
-0.016240146,
0.0014627456,
-0.0088960743,
0.0088121546,
0.0491900481,
-0.0171950832,
0.0062887771,
0.031951353,
0.0660321489,
0.0083058877,
-0.0500918217,
0.0125578344,
0.0455105901,
0.001500319,
-0.0065621966,
-0.0038642297,
0.0027493951,
0.0073724771,
0.0257053692,
0.009694647,
-0.0105182789,
0.0176102892,
0.0734537765,
0.0367080308,
-0.0022011462,
-0.0073778136,
-0.0127537744,
0.0436591543,
0.0455258526,
-0.017728854,
0.0014273573,
0.0580702759,
-0.0118311653,
-0.0048024771,
0.0135130379,
-0.0296732672,
0.0230951402,
-0.056616582,
-0.0156624448,
0.0255195685,
0.0199417118,
-0.0422073565,
-0.0224854741,
-0.0347644091,
0.0055890153,
-0.0167341866,
-0.0387426205,
-0.0602474511,
-0.0110364407,
0.0056593912,
-0.007420585,
0.0618429184,
0.0446771421,
0.0297681727,
0.0635577291,
0.02104895,
-0.0169593785,
-0.0370657258,
-0.0034001675,
0.0361929722,
0.0041205049,
0.021044476,
-0.0296632145,
-0.033766713,
-0.0690826252,
0.0473788977,
-0.0289600343,
-0.0114350952,
0.0577666275,
0.0397062339,
0.0649781004,
0.0181231778,
0.0076523041,
-0.0476136953,
0.0405378379,
0.0055301194,
-0.0609361716,
0.0100865578,
-6.17621997e-33,
0.0017646697,
-0.0321547277,
-0.0351138785,
-0.1045028642,
0.0092760688,
-0.0007411671,
0.004260364,
-0.0675959736,
0.0126087805,
0.0224315953,
0.0137749668,
0.0041728737,
-0.0091606285,
0.0345283374,
-0.0571854822,
-0.0554673374,
0.0414005034,
0.0130667277,
-0.0517641492,
0.0155031411,
0.0396297164,
0.0366627574,
0.0269581042,
-0.0414401628,
-0.011993234,
-0.0087373415,
-0.0427537933,
-0.0182499532,
-0.0584118068,
0.0162241776,
0.0121762687,
0.0432198904,
0.0059171924,
-0.0092825443,
0.0235635713,
0.0016782013,
-0.0405957885,
-0.0118956445,
-0.024224421,
0.0120830052,
-0.014496984,
-0.0089160055,
0.0412293188,
0.0000638931,
-0.0021603946,
0.0043984102,
0.0004036913,
-0.0310137719,
-0.0232397672,
-0.0162064191,
-0.0207699779,
0.0385352597,
-0.0018747947,
0.025554806,
-0.0372669324,
0.0034431173,
0.0557712466,
0.0036715004,
-0.1191231608,
-0.0062308474,
0.0101758344,
0.0105386116,
0.0099037681,
0.0065554772,
0.0334642082,
0.04998767,
0.0482897498,
-0.0126100238,
-0.0094514731,
0.0131549696,
-0.0031777334,
0.0109861521,
0.0700793341,
0.1033524647,
0.0718811527,
-0.0532876439,
-0.0838102549,
-0.0050080027,
-0.023916766,
0.0010935148,
0.040039774,
0.01652015,
-0.0663467199,
0.0061835195,
-0.0273427051,
-0.0339002945,
-0.0191556327,
-0.0282839779,
0.0196962617,
0.0233168155,
-0.0468735918,
0.0329647213,
-0.0536044948,
-0.0213315524,
-0.0153476372,
0.0175751522,
-0.0333387107,
-0.0222259611,
0.0124236867,
0.01070954,
-0.0264421906,
-0.0375042558,
0.0324832089,
-0.0212672539,
0.0116900438,
-0.0208671633,
0.0334075727,
-0.0069822506,
-0.0839165002,
-0.0193970148,
0.0084874667,
0.0309833474,
-0.0048630936,
-0.0529004969,
-0.0024278727,
-0.0128231328,
-0.014921858,
0.0569733642,
0.0412191562,
0.0283590257,
0.006194483,
0.044164896,
-0.0225439835,
-0.0024097483,
-0.0069120168,
-0.0157482624,
0.018945558,
0.0072931116,
0.0650901124,
-0.0939998776,
0.0254517142,
-0.0341909267,
2.856e-7,
-0.0156954397,
0.0152242836,
0.0066102818,
-0.0330657326,
0.0209528711,
0.0695534796,
0.0304900147,
0.0645082146,
-0.0523351766,
-0.0229429249,
-0.0018575179,
-0.0185495019,
0.0347498581,
0.0171275176,
-0.0500160642,
0.0023843099,
-0.1217536926,
-0.0188589487,
-0.0579039678,
-0.0198908523,
0.0529094376,
0.1145720333,
0.0757958069,
-0.0283784922,
-0.0376565754,
-0.0421083495,
0.0392273702,
0.0279072933,
0.0091753528,
0.0184742231,
0.0316991508,
0.0053178589,
0.0376693681,
0.0049416707,
-0.0348758586,
0.0017714188,
0.0302242972,
0.0050828345,
-0.0139027266,
-0.0558165722,
-0.0134644611,
-0.0043927841,
-0.0045231371,
-0.0226834286,
0.10092327,
-0.0308076516,
-0.0220406707,
-0.0192926675,
-0.0285051353,
0.0357614607,
0.0517362356,
-0.0252105016,
-0.0173971932,
0.0128046824,
0.0096590118,
0.0478247106,
-0.0016716366,
-0.1100782454,
0.0374560617,
-0.0030846316,
-0.018878324,
0.0202169083,
-0.035502445,
0.0544104837,
0.0133039663,
-0.0190804396,
0.0290141739,
2.225663785e-34,
0.0031229113,
-0.0314358324,
-0.016480824,
-0.0042891623,
0.0356499068,
0.0094488459,
0.0337449387,
-0.0027251483,
0.0133836772,
-0.016690664,
-0.0223439727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01805v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01805v3 | Can LLMs perform structured graph reasoning? | 2024-02-02T09:45:33 | 2024-04-18T12:04:12 | Palaash Agrawal, Shavak Vasania, Cheston Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated various reasoning
capabilities through language-based prompts alone, particularly in unstructured
task settings (tasks purely based on language semantics). However, LLMs often
struggle with structured tasks, because of the inherent incompatibility of
input representation. Reducing structured tasks to uni-dimensional language
semantics often renders the problem trivial. Keeping the trade-off between LLM
compatibility and structure complexity in mind, we design various graph
reasoning tasks as a proxy to semi-structured tasks in this paper, in order to
test the ability to navigate through representations beyond plain text in
various LLMs. Particularly, we design 10 distinct problems of graph traversal,
each representing increasing levels of complexity, and benchmark 5 different
instruct-finetuned LLMs (GPT-4, GPT-3.5, Claude-2, Llama-2 and Palm-2) on the
aforementioned tasks. Further, we analyse the performance of models across
various settings such as varying sizes of graphs as well as different forms of
k-shot prompting. We highlight various limitations, biases and properties of
LLMs through this benchmarking process, such as an inverse relation to the
average degrees of freedom of traversal per node in graphs, the overall
negative impact of k-shot prompting on graph reasoning tasks, and a positive
response bias which prevents LLMs from identifying the absence of a valid
solution. Finally, we introduce a new prompting technique specially designed
for graph traversal tasks (PathCompare), which demonstrates a notable increase
in the performance of LLMs in comparison to standard prompting techniques such
as Chain-of-Thought (CoT). | Can LLMs perform structured graph reasoning?: Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated various reasoning
capabilities through language-based prompts alone, particularly in unstructured
task settings (tasks purely based on language semantics). However, LLMs often
struggle with structured tasks, because of the inherent incompatibility of
input representation. Reducing structured tasks to uni-dimensional language
semantics often renders the problem trivial. Keeping the trade-off between LLM
compatibility and structure complexity in mind, we design various graph
reasoning tasks as a proxy to semi-structured tasks in this paper, in order to
test the ability to navigate through representations beyond plain text in
various LLMs. Particularly, we design 10 distinct problems of graph traversal,
each representing increasing levels of complexity, and benchmark 5 different
instruct-finetuned LLMs (GPT-4, GPT-3.5, Claude-2, Llama-2 and Palm-2) on the
aforementioned tasks. Further, we analyse the performance of models across
various settings such as varying sizes of graphs as well as different forms of
k-shot prompting. We highlight various limitations, biases and properties of
LLMs through this benchmarking process, such as an inverse relation to the
average degrees of freedom of traversal per node in graphs, the overall
negative impact of k-shot prompting on graph reasoning tasks, and a positive
response bias which prevents LLMs from identifying the absence of a valid
solution. Finally, we introduce a new prompting technique specially designed
for graph traversal tasks (PathCompare), which demonstrates a notable increase
in the performance of LLMs in comparison to standard prompting techniques such
as Chain-of-Thought (CoT). | [
0.0204608738,
-0.0143781574,
-0.0113827558,
0.0299702249,
-0.0605017357,
0.0195846297,
0.0097906813,
-0.0122606913,
0.0709583163,
-0.0333542041,
-0.0082595153,
-0.0027182442,
-0.0206102487,
0.0292949528,
0.0066207633,
-0.0451612175,
0.0407061987,
-0.0633891672,
0.0034507301,
-0.0288846791,
-0.0286437888,
0.0096780034,
-0.0042530745,
0.0121780988,
-0.0021560383,
-0.0329443067,
-0.0516579933,
0.013627111,
-0.0197306909,
-0.0765336454,
-0.0332592651,
0.0322912224,
0.0353936702,
0.0279910788,
0.0000021877,
-0.0301377922,
0.0057087964,
-0.017174691,
-0.0749873593,
-0.0013655834,
-0.0063995789,
-0.0182890017,
0.0244460534,
-0.0069103441,
-0.0196576361,
-0.0438351147,
0.0300200582,
0.0351162739,
0.0612078272,
0.0779189765,
0.0008292864,
-0.0277824365,
-0.0009466527,
-0.0070052883,
0.0127003575,
-0.0477470122,
0.0300961025,
0.0254670326,
0.0469674766,
0.0233225971,
-0.0290776435,
0.0181931201,
0.0397225358,
-0.0062439158,
0.0192769077,
0.032098107,
-0.0023522649,
0.0056825895,
-0.0002077944,
0.1115732938,
0.0026153659,
-0.0086934008,
0.0002770977,
-0.0221483447,
-0.0173464771,
0.0107013052,
-0.0502035841,
0.0052363146,
-0.0135363732,
0.0023441769,
-0.0114165358,
-0.0175656006,
0.0604639202,
-0.0114577943,
-0.0449791327,
0.1178959161,
-0.0098626465,
-0.0253745001,
0.0590670183,
0.0053909076,
0.00671783,
-0.0670655966,
0.0095817717,
0.0700017139,
-0.0527547039,
0.0275104512,
-0.0080661569,
0.0126982136,
-0.0145030003,
0.0041360189,
0.0487899333,
0.0213451572,
-0.0060946434,
0.0671317354,
-0.0190450549,
0.045229353,
-0.0493405163,
0.0622863062,
-0.0344933644,
-0.0019622573,
-0.0438204147,
-0.0135943936,
-0.0573392324,
0.0330860764,
-0.021695042,
-0.0446790457,
-0.0059722699,
0.0621695034,
-0.0126517154,
0.0257560387,
0.0225580446,
-0.0007278604,
0.0407069251,
-0.0263970494,
-0.0467551649,
0.0124677401,
-0.0503148884,
-0.0069980486,
-0.0073633506,
0.0073036309,
-0.0113239465,
-0.0015848911,
0.0287505873,
-0.0562146492,
0.0298371464,
0.082614623,
0.0337360688,
-0.033565782,
-0.0313082747,
-0.0328851603,
-0.000494244,
-0.072988078,
0.0504691489,
-0.0817657858,
0.0503341407,
0.039586965,
-0.0131171783,
0.0006099783,
0.0116874315,
0.0029367041,
-0.0572464019,
0.0781710669,
0.0157482661,
0.0383045338,
-0.0035650693,
-0.0047993232,
-0.0317818299,
0.0223693904,
0.008504414,
0.0145736998,
0.0027952592,
0.0103717092,
-0.0071532144,
0.0322803296,
0.0076307179,
-0.0070355642,
0.0093300175,
0.0108549129,
-0.0338807441,
0.0352366753,
-0.0196416266,
0.0591412298,
-0.0378936343,
-0.0267145373,
0.0011440425,
0.0564632341,
0.003379544,
-0.048118908,
0.0623303205,
0.0056968504,
-0.005954125,
0.0316750631,
-0.0833943263,
0.0208506323,
-0.035631787,
0.0068559973,
-0.0062168255,
-0.0357569866,
-0.0100370673,
-0.0269969534,
-0.0156834312,
0.0156797152,
0.0542274863,
0.0220669936,
0.0699799284,
0.0160008967,
-0.037395902,
-0.0011465126,
0.026118828,
0.0044100354,
-0.029734889,
-0.0195876863,
-0.0001359283,
0.0827583522,
0.0651394054,
0.0007695976,
-0.0415955223,
0.0271880832,
0.0165163185,
0.0000480483,
0.0245876927,
-0.0225084946,
-0.0266574956,
-0.0405106209,
-0.0299151223,
-0.0354100242,
-0.018190885,
0.0338162817,
0.0075534773,
-0.0106905987,
0.0025102396,
-0.064690195,
-0.0054588732,
0.0106310882,
0.0266768988,
-0.0073505794,
-0.0109208878,
0.0167651772,
0.0016215614,
0.0205977112,
-0.0011436914,
0.0325930826,
0.0205564275,
-0.0031916478,
-0.0116859088,
-0.0217808709,
-0.0590746328,
-0.0812674686,
0.0240895543,
0.0000638412,
-0.0592630804,
-0.0045335814,
-0.0458023213,
-0.0404366925,
0.0376614295,
-0.0231978334,
0.0080624372,
0.002054869,
0.0230079684,
0.0343415141,
-0.043295797,
-0.0154581731,
0.087779507,
0.026519781,
0.018198844,
0.0346760377,
0.0258365124,
0.0036161449,
-0.0553345345,
-0.0123152537,
0.0422618911,
0.0211827196,
-0.0294930004,
0.0031738812,
-0.0009055449,
-0.0484430678,
0.0247291122,
-0.0894433036,
-0.0046233414,
-0.0023984248,
0.0151340477,
-0.0169414636,
-0.0128429141,
0.0086455755,
-0.0383516178,
-0.0626020283,
0.0489438809,
0.0406335704,
0.047192391,
0.019404687,
-0.0200817492,
-0.0124049885,
-0.0108969156,
-0.0533804335,
-0.0494392589,
0.0534082763,
0.0182978585,
-0.0346226096,
-0.0022514393,
0.051167421,
-0.038100142,
0.0324633159,
-0.017041469,
0.0331553072,
0.0342798978,
-0.0385982208,
0.0566794686,
0.0684801191,
-0.0527559295,
0.0164700933,
0.0545836017,
-0.0470748805,
-0.0355108641,
0.0257688425,
-0.0259581488,
-0.0219444837,
-0.0455693789,
-0.0106344996,
-0.0164731145,
0.0434353948,
-0.0035511479,
0.0102005079,
-0.0474856421,
-0.0202310383,
-0.0048632845,
0.0364809036,
-0.0279227421,
-0.0314589776,
0.0223390646,
0.0492054038,
-0.0299518351,
0.0060772495,
0.0997969136,
-0.0239432119,
-0.016777711,
0.0332329497,
-0.0137435663,
-0.0490632951,
0.1039873213,
0.0532907173,
0.0105153732,
-0.0092065074,
-0.0214211661,
-0.0432808399,
-0.0075929877,
0.0275315195,
-0.0010841249,
0.0132761318,
-0.0232023615,
0.0295511782,
0.0076985713,
-0.0331638232,
-0.0216929987,
0.0036613855,
-0.0491387919,
0.018439522,
-0.0100094983,
-0.0128588108,
0.0211660825,
0.0017223207,
-0.0005578679,
0.0166833084,
-0.0112945158,
0.0042642318,
-0.0478947945,
0.0225427859,
0.0226751529,
-0.0204215534,
0.0208103061,
-0.0445747636,
0.0489611886,
0.0360557772,
0.0146892909,
-0.0332551748,
-0.0245092548,
0.0455057733,
0.000104197,
-0.0058804075,
-0.0329784527,
-0.0025689173,
0.0408743396,
-0.0866541788,
-0.0060452316,
0.0879167989,
0.035406094,
-0.0256858896,
-0.0070119295,
-0.0184285119,
0.0109443869,
0.0390296727,
0.0363355353,
-0.1061252207,
-0.0288043451,
0.0150825093,
0.0003165232,
0.0014347841,
-0.0610428862,
-0.0026589537,
-0.1264254153,
0.0351919346,
0.0139515623,
0.00906255,
-0.0225525908,
-0.0347292237,
-0.0223820191,
0.0499414615,
-0.0215458274,
0.0037732152,
0.001526855,
-0.0100676725,
0.0001481772,
-0.0056615588,
0.0033981225,
0.0678784475,
0.0125121456,
0.0188042074,
0.0068396558,
-0.0004913015,
0.0352363698,
-0.0192116965,
0.0621971153,
0.0117233898,
0.0195553917,
-0.0299526826,
0.008480343,
0.0073307478,
-0.011946856,
-0.0376886465,
-0.0113095324,
-0.0243305247,
-0.0406738669,
-0.0017639836,
0.1235010475,
-0.0401308984,
-0.0450185947,
-0.0033695607,
-0.0076149059,
-0.0404312611,
0.0404969789,
0.0409717932,
0.0309271459,
-0.0823668763,
-0.0592803136,
-0.0160901416,
-0.031872049,
-0.0267519094,
0.0465772673,
-0.0144828623,
0.0443338193,
-0.0424515083,
-0.0393241048,
0.0699325874,
0.0366613381,
-0.0273190904,
-0.0217288174,
0.0349544436,
-0.0251272582,
-0.0483594127,
0.0247475374,
-0.0564347692,
0.0370451249,
-0.0372163579,
-0.0055240542,
-0.012378606,
-0.0068713389,
-0.0127389617,
-0.0071617668,
-0.0457640663,
-0.0774207264,
-0.0505462214,
0.017799614,
0.02219183,
0.0544380844,
-0.0205548387,
-0.0152948126,
0.0333871506,
-0.0078103696,
-0.0238572247,
-0.0004989593,
0.027438337,
0.0119533995,
-0.0203289501,
0.0308786388,
-0.0561170653,
0.0310468357,
0.016214624,
0.0474142618,
-0.0185104776,
-0.0373168401,
0.0217757989,
0.0636679679,
0.0301063266,
0.067084685,
0.0090952246,
-0.0183680113,
0.0071177324,
-0.041369956,
-0.0543639436,
-0.0227439515,
-0.0170804337,
0.0164471753,
-0.006316564,
0.0214154832,
-0.0542311706,
0.0001057304,
0.0493446514,
-0.0208956469,
-0.0188475437,
0.0189584959,
-0.0191897862,
0.0567603968,
0.0015085142,
-0.015912842,
0.0283525977,
0.0145061733,
0.0292153358,
-0.0033739947,
0.0682590008,
0.0405132584,
-0.0185129605,
-0.0719611049,
-0.0154209659,
-0.0785738379,
-0.0703749284,
0.049888026,
0.025741335,
0.0376687907,
0.0162912719,
-0.0044912775,
-0.033091221,
-0.0077028968,
-0.0059996513,
0.0116145974,
0.0417262018,
-0.0643203408,
0.0697150007,
0.0605520755,
0.0215952247,
-0.0018548791,
0.0339235254,
0.0431423262,
0.0314821415,
0.0285552572,
-0.0282880608,
-0.025563214,
-0.0474115871,
-0.0300889183,
0.0394173041,
-0.0017548072,
0.0291977972,
-0.0487628169,
-0.0919459313,
-0.0029033632,
0.0102991974,
-0.0158519223,
-0.0198315587,
0.040907681,
0.0297235046,
0.0583561547,
-0.0465060808,
-0.0148538845,
0.0369870849,
-0.0155441081,
-0.0183925666,
-0.0007443642,
-6.528633176e-33,
-0.0312387627,
-0.070166938,
0.0609975308,
0.0134958616,
-0.0304719154,
0.0022395018,
-0.0781379491,
0.0074362066,
-0.0251820385,
0.0224171821,
-0.017647855,
0.0060677943,
-0.0022176064,
0.014825589,
-0.0126629164,
-0.0171919595,
0.0145152211,
0.0238710847,
-0.0110389823,
0.0201906879,
0.0316210687,
-0.0060699726,
0.0165192503,
-0.0296767112,
0.0236296244,
-0.0231787656,
0.0201403908,
0.0417729206,
-0.040588405,
0.0335595831,
-0.0178758223,
0.0284014456,
0.0382373668,
0.0081758434,
-0.0061794817,
0.0455750935,
-0.0795350373,
-0.0496031605,
0.0247119516,
0.0123294862,
-0.0803910196,
-0.0217951164,
0.0250719488,
-0.0147452382,
0.0168307777,
-0.0228008889,
0.0104044629,
0.0116930949,
-0.0320023559,
0.0213225782,
-0.0329126865,
0.0196752585,
-0.0239907894,
-0.020982258,
0.0371802934,
0.0439873748,
-0.0017047583,
0.0060179713,
-0.0169723239,
0.0260706861,
-0.0135050369,
-0.0166934002,
0.0291486923,
0.0200119708,
0.0336589627,
0.0241625346,
0.007288273,
0.0010437219,
-0.0454669856,
0.0323421471,
-0.0142737133,
0.0713677108,
-0.004852281,
-0.0049227108,
-0.0165470019,
0.0328442417,
-0.0885346457,
-0.0278147291,
-0.0004637567,
0.0375055298,
-0.0045374078,
0.016653413,
-0.0335195363,
-0.0667518377,
-0.0434604622,
-0.0171206258,
-0.0405833311,
-0.0317448974,
0.0226063728,
-0.0227582306,
0.0067891954,
-0.0003182884,
0.0119289868,
-0.0187467728,
-0.0281311199,
0.0560236424,
-0.0148695298,
0.0447106548,
-0.0078144986,
0.0655665174,
-0.0292435344,
-0.0396319181,
0.0181928892,
-0.0348897837,
0.0164891463,
0.0357745774,
0.0275376756,
0.0143223694,
-0.0475922041,
-0.0209074169,
-0.0646564215,
-0.0074856034,
-0.0333543867,
-0.0015807425,
0.0778953806,
0.0525655746,
-0.0022162348,
0.0764672533,
0.0005520391,
-0.0144954957,
-0.0218877774,
0.0375506654,
-0.0199857913,
0.0294888299,
-0.0299436636,
-0.0096299462,
-0.0373285376,
0.0224458929,
0.0391973332,
-0.062623173,
-0.0039119339,
0.0313785188,
3e-7,
0.02811688,
0.0523444265,
0.0358013064,
0.0660878345,
0.0082826428,
0.0234673973,
-0.027970532,
-0.0031637717,
0.0047014062,
-0.0482137017,
0.0371329747,
0.0812377334,
-0.0173709076,
0.026178211,
-0.0553212911,
0.0495870635,
-0.040764872,
-0.0399610735,
-0.0685012564,
0.0225356184,
0.0724793747,
0.0300088413,
0.0100040864,
0.0045677549,
-0.0069887731,
-0.0731308684,
0.0455457121,
0.0046419357,
-0.0023481341,
-0.0357619449,
-0.0296355486,
-0.0164138377,
-0.0107998764,
0.0551048853,
0.0301777273,
0.0140297627,
0.0062235477,
0.0495787747,
-0.0017634928,
-0.0156878475,
-0.0005218839,
-0.0507653952,
0.0018104221,
-0.0236529093,
0.1062869728,
-0.0440664217,
-0.0600491799,
0.0074495934,
-0.0082977302,
-0.0461005345,
-0.001115569,
0.0093586855,
-0.0098045487,
0.0019347089,
0.0192569476,
-0.0143030025,
0.0260402076,
-0.0787308961,
0.0107607339,
0.0077234861,
-0.0039477581,
-0.0315451063,
-0.0346239395,
0.0333741643,
0.0374368727,
-0.0053306371,
-0.0147047061,
2.899615333e-34,
0.0449366868,
-0.0037090543,
0.0138852485,
-0.0235430617,
0.0327511244,
-0.0167359766,
-0.053235665,
0.0257560164,
0.0481214784,
-0.1249096468,
-0.0299935024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01267v1 | The Human and the Mechanical: logos, truthfulness, and ChatGPT | 2024-02-02T09:41:51 | 2024-02-02T09:41:51 | Anastasia Giannakidou, Alda Mari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The paper addresses the question of whether it is appropriate to talk about
`mechanical minds' at all, and whether ChatGPT models can indeed be thought of
as realizations of that. Our paper adds a semantic argument to the current
debate. The act of human assertion requires the formation of a veridicality
judgment. Modification of assertions with modals (John must be at home) and the
use of subjective elements (John is obviously at home) indicate that the
speaker is manipulating her judgments and, in a cooperative context, intends
her epistemic state to be transparent to the addressee. Veridicality judgments
are formed on the basis of two components: (i) evidence that relates to reality
(exogenous evidence) and (ii) endogenous evidence, such as preferences and
private beliefs. `Mechanical minds' lack these two components: (i) they do not
relate to reality and (ii) do not have endogenous evidence. Therefore they lack
the ability to form a belief about the world and a veridicality judgments
altogether. They can only mimic that judgment, but the output is not ground in
the very foundations for it. | The Human and the Mechanical: logos, truthfulness, and ChatGPT: The paper addresses the question of whether it is appropriate to talk about
`mechanical minds' at all, and whether ChatGPT models can indeed be thought of
as realizations of that. Our paper adds a semantic argument to the current
debate. The act of human assertion requires the formation of a veridicality
judgment. Modification of assertions with modals (John must be at home) and the
use of subjective elements (John is obviously at home) indicate that the
speaker is manipulating her judgments and, in a cooperative context, intends
her epistemic state to be transparent to the addressee. Veridicality judgments
are formed on the basis of two components: (i) evidence that relates to reality
(exogenous evidence) and (ii) endogenous evidence, such as preferences and
private beliefs. `Mechanical minds' lack these two components: (i) they do not
relate to reality and (ii) do not have endogenous evidence. Therefore they lack
the ability to form a belief about the world and a veridicality judgments
altogether. They can only mimic that judgment, but the output is not ground in
the very foundations for it. | [
0.0366125479,
0.01649867,
-0.048852507,
-0.0149072828,
-0.0570036434,
-0.0043312716,
-0.0610109605,
0.0013963956,
0.0012357878,
-0.0439315885,
-0.0195622109,
0.0115365488,
-0.0225312915,
-0.0476354659,
0.0803829283,
-0.0327940136,
0.0043321014,
0.015345009,
-0.0038817876,
0.0076222257,
0.0021352556,
0.0111138579,
0.0034738411,
0.0109079182,
-0.0020601943,
0.0203685146,
-0.0176781602,
-0.0258431658,
0.028262198,
-0.0075822813,
-0.042869661,
0.0179498363,
-0.0061311526,
0.0366076678,
0.0000023084,
-0.0006570898,
0.0609555058,
-0.017397197,
-0.0189753659,
-0.0019715892,
0.0071563595,
0.040598955,
0.0249541309,
-0.0132906474,
-0.0382543728,
-0.0038778984,
0.0003034759,
0.0334881842,
-0.0361532941,
0.0274070576,
-0.0000784511,
0.0369336382,
-0.0230405759,
-0.0073316009,
0.0279808845,
0.0415560491,
0.0259427428,
0.0211924035,
-0.010371618,
0.0045511769,
-0.0218619909,
0.004164129,
0.016641615,
0.0076310756,
-0.0268723406,
-0.014400389,
-0.0241671652,
-0.0377300978,
0.0165673643,
0.0290157851,
0.1383457035,
-0.0358844399,
0.0248841904,
0.0531407557,
0.0502654053,
0.0357592851,
0.0150412442,
0.0768085346,
-0.0221401006,
-0.012558993,
-0.0051457728,
0.0078579253,
-0.0198647846,
0.0050499686,
0.0026058611,
0.0231434256,
-0.0344577767,
0.0098213498,
0.00135551,
0.000932353,
-0.0000963715,
-0.0712791681,
-0.0788757056,
0.0053682718,
-0.0038578773,
-0.0060727936,
-0.0310421344,
0.0590546876,
-0.0108690979,
-0.0813928992,
-0.048456043,
0.0053099319,
0.0016696244,
0.0125074647,
0.0187724773,
-0.0112799881,
-0.0510353334,
0.1087487414,
-0.0576886348,
0.0543258116,
-0.0609563105,
-0.0267136283,
-0.0128059806,
0.0051856469,
0.0412088074,
0.0128298923,
-0.014522478,
-0.0038182901,
-0.0421968438,
-0.0201148055,
-0.1026041731,
0.0065702628,
-0.0199751537,
-0.0343581177,
-0.0413452834,
0.0166706517,
-0.0290679354,
0.0200475249,
-0.0295208674,
-0.0683938265,
0.0199385267,
-0.0110103637,
-0.0150568178,
0.0325202644,
-0.0047166157,
0.071494408,
0.0060617374,
-0.0009366276,
0.0391191654,
-0.0199819114,
-0.0112945177,
-0.0715329349,
-0.0120794512,
0.0176491141,
-0.0040606917,
-0.0005780798,
0.0122234281,
0.0065124063,
0.006302359,
-0.0032290919,
-0.0000105933,
0.0334077477,
0.0413911231,
-0.0115364082,
-0.044684235,
0.0185840428,
-0.032999672,
0.002035229,
-0.0102755837,
0.0373722576,
-0.0118627204,
0.0172032658,
0.0340332054,
-0.0147682466,
-0.0266536456,
-0.0298745465,
-0.0064317635,
0.0134772863,
0.0262514558,
0.0095972205,
-0.0178576689,
0.0449284725,
-0.038505882,
0.0463837087,
0.0290464163,
0.0135061583,
-0.0021121546,
-0.0021888774,
0.009330323,
0.0082396958,
0.0207644422,
0.0707372501,
-0.0373551287,
0.0110003492,
0.0071085133,
-0.0143871978,
-0.0630729869,
0.0064903195,
-0.0260062888,
-0.0190346986,
0.01022965,
0.0097524151,
0.0208315533,
0.0167162754,
0.011557485,
-0.0284998957,
0.0426113792,
-0.0412447527,
0.0256225783,
0.0073109795,
-0.0309175793,
-0.0805217251,
0.0573019087,
-0.0135522718,
0.0013477624,
0.057743419,
0.0141635947,
-0.0219761692,
-0.0264810938,
0.0529385693,
0.050123211,
0.0227203723,
-0.0599648617,
0.0056108986,
0.0126939965,
-0.0389514491,
-0.0158768017,
0.0499265976,
-0.1154161617,
0.0322526246,
0.0051232083,
0.0066462425,
0.0846835002,
-0.003157085,
0.067001,
-0.0016513665,
-0.084850654,
0.00464564,
0.0161166936,
-0.0321316421,
0.0049950234,
0.0196450911,
0.0167132206,
-0.0207873024,
-0.0301218089,
0.1077812165,
-0.0453547351,
0.0948748738,
-0.0116718644,
-0.1279382557,
0.0187072847,
-0.0279838219,
0.049895715,
0.0128573971,
-0.0094068451,
-0.0214593988,
0.037818525,
-0.0355195925,
-0.0054279999,
-0.0258332007,
-0.0182064064,
0.0002450735,
0.0013770212,
0.0151798669,
-0.0033028862,
-0.0494360514,
-0.0283724666,
0.0819800347,
0.0364537574,
-0.0178105198,
0.0502439551,
-0.0119991284,
0.0264581945,
0.0119928522,
-0.0040346258,
-0.0436865427,
-0.0217357576,
-0.0857849568,
-0.0536139868,
0.0201424249,
-0.0343931317,
-0.0113765085,
-0.040734686,
-0.0171466712,
0.0377653614,
0.0104655372,
0.0688746199,
0.0332744606,
0.0384226479,
0.0090375599,
-0.0158363059,
0.0062124757,
0.0414827876,
0.0351135358,
-0.0369905271,
-0.020773245,
0.0153083308,
-0.0334214643,
-0.0305020511,
-0.0275698062,
-0.0669113398,
-0.02466131,
-0.0177807957,
-0.0403671861,
0.0198284797,
0.029773172,
0.0228591263,
0.0086741848,
0.0157333557,
0.0366691239,
0.0033220588,
0.0115113799,
-0.006222086,
-0.0321580693,
0.013784104,
0.0028584658,
0.0001131694,
-0.0429105945,
0.0010931321,
0.0338453613,
0.0406740755,
0.0400178842,
-0.0543590225,
0.1171950474,
-0.0247386675,
-0.0316760689,
0.0053219916,
-0.0244694259,
-0.0108830957,
0.0445555337,
0.0079867244,
-0.0258414317,
0.0255468041,
0.0146109434,
0.0000862287,
0.0496496521,
0.0200057495,
0.0091658439,
0.0612765439,
0.0444188118,
0.0258306023,
0.1202600449,
-0.0094286082,
-0.0503114313,
-0.0170000661,
0.0296420753,
-0.0094557619,
-0.0303547308,
-0.017884206,
0.0392448157,
0.0127718523,
-0.0482774377,
-0.0107604135,
0.0098726479,
-0.0391275585,
0.0002712721,
0.0404823832,
0.0005847823,
-0.0125413984,
-0.011618671,
0.0428072847,
-0.0118103605,
0.0236015432,
-0.0064387484,
-0.0334538408,
-0.0644145012,
-0.0103822388,
0.0758830532,
0.0181250125,
0.029950479,
-0.0392468832,
0.0969434753,
0.0120323803,
-0.0007040191,
0.0140976505,
-0.0157175474,
-0.0159398597,
0.0474957079,
-0.0026190695,
-0.0046237851,
0.0140792802,
0.0084479218,
0.0022930384,
0.0066471309,
-0.0224128515,
0.0262394156,
0.0068272371,
-0.0299387183,
-0.0309542269,
-0.0015554782,
0.0034180933,
-0.1168459505,
0.0448560454,
-0.0126579339,
-0.0340689495,
-0.0773279145,
-0.0285252426,
-0.0095508033,
0.0061775367,
0.0469785891,
0.0296880566,
0.0176334847,
0.0070702741,
0.0505837612,
-0.0180357937,
-0.0139160026,
-0.023341937,
0.0085637728,
0.0132533759,
0.0295731239,
0.0121591575,
0.0156371519,
0.0309244189,
-0.0015929103,
0.0129154027,
0.0146885496,
-0.0125740776,
0.0310308523,
-0.0296400562,
-0.0821447521,
0.0021343071,
0.0162580721,
0.0123682935,
0.0153401252,
-0.0826081857,
-0.0286119655,
-0.0026982368,
-0.0747207031,
-0.0063137626,
0.0406168662,
0.0090782577,
0.0461896434,
0.0632168502,
-0.0258273799,
-0.0616730824,
0.0150683569,
-0.0113904858,
-0.0435520709,
0.0199619625,
0.0044023865,
0.0036057746,
0.0186204258,
-0.0288286805,
-0.0348668136,
0.1057378948,
-0.0956507996,
-0.0380628034,
0.019849157,
-0.0089325467,
-0.0382932425,
-0.05996757,
-0.0182961971,
0.0646702275,
0.0103262868,
-0.0615186021,
0.0517434143,
0.001505613,
-0.0185668264,
0.0241880286,
-0.0538673215,
-0.0391480923,
0.023867948,
0.0107082864,
-0.0060264398,
-0.0645688251,
-0.014316787,
-0.0544502549,
0.0528673083,
-0.0268626753,
0.0286210142,
0.0301700737,
0.042746339,
0.0072480952,
0.0017750296,
0.0651133433,
-0.021046875,
0.0091743926,
-0.0495588519,
0.080020383,
0.0011621417,
0.0482578538,
-0.0285233743,
-0.0096380292,
0.0477253795,
0.0117363548,
-0.0138554834,
-0.0472546034,
0.0059985924,
-0.0282964259,
0.0758240223,
0.0126203885,
-0.011970764,
0.0222683679,
0.027582122,
-0.007182424,
-0.0489377044,
0.0310222674,
-0.0235283896,
-0.0276135206,
-0.0027349046,
0.0358014628,
0.0059784004,
0.0039320751,
-0.036530029,
-0.0495995544,
0.0123517141,
0.0480276346,
0.0004826717,
0.0041388944,
0.0250431616,
0.0056642657,
0.0100153815,
0.0138641736,
0.0567099303,
-0.0132280793,
0.0597295724,
-0.0243983809,
0.0835436732,
0.0351978615,
-0.0383832529,
-0.007332643,
0.009790306,
-0.0489924587,
-0.1025174856,
0.0099189822,
0.0174928885,
-0.0337080359,
-0.0200443771,
-0.0379695483,
-0.0337736234,
0.0023611092,
0.0039932816,
0.0323206149,
0.0267754197,
0.0050591957,
-0.0192793552,
-0.0006941613,
-0.0218932498,
-0.0170847159,
-0.0033761398,
-0.088853173,
0.015205835,
-0.0149704581,
-0.000184453,
-0.0512439683,
-0.0403680131,
-0.0327671356,
-0.0399428681,
0.0498615429,
0.0359046347,
-0.0695101246,
-0.0092372457,
-0.023591537,
0.035423778,
0.0320871547,
-0.0334005691,
-0.0265894998,
0.0726262257,
0.015557901,
-0.0231401231,
-0.01699383,
0.0840584561,
0.0094016232,
0.0717491657,
-0.0205760989,
-6.284157535e-33,
-0.0282289926,
-0.0017419206,
0.015554795,
-0.0268808585,
-0.0743308291,
-0.017560238,
0.0150952265,
0.0161940623,
-0.034875989,
0.036205329,
-0.0073256865,
-0.0238086656,
0.011041658,
-0.0493519641,
0.0497450568,
-0.0453480706,
0.0112917153,
-0.0136962365,
0.0041060452,
-0.0372826532,
-0.0104510486,
-0.0400697105,
0.0448386893,
-0.0352311693,
0.0724744797,
-0.020911295,
-0.0398060791,
-0.02088557,
-0.0316643864,
-0.0387869403,
-0.0126717752,
0.009209401,
0.0200156774,
-0.0122905392,
0.0068592508,
0.0822858438,
0.0272615422,
-0.0155866873,
0.0582251959,
-0.0119804833,
-0.0087356651,
-0.0257513095,
-0.0633848906,
-0.0313237384,
-0.0425865538,
0.006898344,
0.0306501463,
0.0218239576,
0.0167245269,
0.0030133645,
-0.0492936745,
-0.036578849,
-0.0141555648,
-0.0320696719,
-0.0249135923,
0.0144486455,
-0.0300007258,
-0.0413017012,
-0.0664042383,
0.0231749173,
-0.0512997881,
-0.0141246608,
0.0044226856,
-0.0240687132,
0.0386089236,
0.0349991433,
0.0587226786,
0.0603419952,
-0.051329013,
0.0278729238,
0.006554598,
0.0581210516,
0.0281991567,
0.034086369,
-0.0314561613,
-0.0029695367,
0.0143553838,
-0.0564609654,
0.0446831845,
0.0286863707,
0.0318012163,
0.0093678674,
-0.0356784984,
-0.0078465687,
-0.0007758682,
-0.103055656,
-0.0309257098,
0.0124302413,
-0.0405172706,
0.0031113906,
0.0195860527,
-0.0486585014,
0.0044556218,
-0.0178558882,
0.0321737453,
-0.039283447,
0.0032432987,
0.0037687758,
-0.0153002208,
-0.0234514102,
0.0097283218,
0.0148120401,
-0.0096720727,
0.0556844212,
0.0200868044,
0.0251250621,
-0.0382857211,
-0.0122297136,
0.0175599568,
-0.0389106721,
-0.0110848872,
-0.0044884859,
-0.0030672366,
-0.0902882367,
0.0713340491,
0.0328208841,
-0.0080903489,
-0.0318630487,
-0.0026669172,
0.0130014522,
-0.0298349056,
0.0223287717,
-0.0176833719,
0.0278183669,
0.0087646395,
0.0291045643,
-0.0271192696,
0.0182163306,
0.0545813516,
-0.0451267026,
-0.0065907491,
-0.0386191756,
3.152e-7,
-0.0578103065,
-0.0150768673,
-0.0018092695,
-0.0343799591,
-0.0045313011,
0.0750046819,
0.0144253969,
0.0015653386,
0.056753926,
-0.0758504048,
0.0152907027,
-0.0172482878,
0.0236925948,
-0.0135073261,
0.0023295064,
0.0374442264,
-0.0094336169,
-0.0471147038,
0.0338784382,
0.0799761489,
0.0507404879,
-0.0223659296,
0.0303036179,
0.0095920479,
-0.0138726383,
0.0257808436,
0.0198422503,
-0.0168638993,
-0.0049100905,
-0.0045169452,
0.0659162253,
0.0022074075,
-0.0030531129,
0.0216303077,
0.0552731231,
-0.0296303518,
0.0021254867,
0.0149739068,
0.0063554654,
0.0196227916,
-0.020121865,
-0.0467803255,
-0.0086666998,
0.0128641613,
0.0454063155,
-0.1218980625,
-0.0135886595,
-0.0210935324,
-0.0042347512,
0.0140905827,
0.0216659568,
0.0185015667,
-0.0198839698,
0.0265254062,
0.0326758847,
-0.0045888624,
0.0207711514,
-0.0394154079,
0.0198507365,
0.0055322703,
-0.0379913859,
-0.0245327856,
0.0217357147,
0.0186234992,
0.0391456485,
-0.0555626415,
-0.0329848491,
2.260821397e-34,
0.0049928874,
0.020949455,
0.0377282836,
-0.021991495,
0.0521514826,
0.0380648524,
0.0415457711,
0.0158636887,
0.0244159084,
-0.0301700514,
-0.018229099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03370v1 | Detection of tortured phrases in scientific literature | 2024-02-02T08:15:43 | 2024-02-02T08:15:43 | Eléna Martel, Martin Lentschat, Cyril Labbé | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL | This paper presents various automatic detection methods to extract so called
tortured phrases from scientific papers. These tortured phrases, e.g. flag to
clamor instead of signal to noise, are the results of paraphrasing tools used
to escape plagiarism detection. We built a dataset and evaluated several
strategies to flag previously undocumented tortured phrases. The proposed and
tested methods are based on language models and either on embeddings
similarities or on predictions of masked token. We found that an approach using
token prediction and that propagates the scores to the chunk level gives the
best results. With a recall value of .87 and a precision value of .61, it could
retrieve new tortured phrases to be submitted to domain experts for validation. | Detection of tortured phrases in scientific literature: This paper presents various automatic detection methods to extract so called
tortured phrases from scientific papers. These tortured phrases, e.g. flag to
clamor instead of signal to noise, are the results of paraphrasing tools used
to escape plagiarism detection. We built a dataset and evaluated several
strategies to flag previously undocumented tortured phrases. The proposed and
tested methods are based on language models and either on embeddings
similarities or on predictions of masked token. We found that an approach using
token prediction and that propagates the scores to the chunk level gives the
best results. With a recall value of .87 and a precision value of .61, it could
retrieve new tortured phrases to be submitted to domain experts for validation. | [
0.0885094479,
0.0329068378,
-0.016090326,
0.0398413017,
-0.088777937,
-0.0066342126,
0.0007789428,
0.0278030504,
-0.004113696,
-0.0665043592,
-0.0089663249,
0.0579926409,
-0.0082713533,
0.0324087627,
0.0173690673,
-0.0327422395,
0.0476996973,
0.0122709004,
0.0433599837,
0.0135516999,
0.0051153549,
0.0008927508,
0.0374795049,
0.038647376,
0.0286707859,
-0.024790246,
0.0476791598,
0.0074673337,
0.0265337285,
-0.0395212285,
0.0194576606,
0.009707612,
-0.0179323982,
0.0799049512,
0.0000015757,
-0.0571742281,
-0.047751274,
0.0281034764,
0.0213711802,
0.0498148464,
0.0954557806,
-0.0208187681,
0.0204163138,
-0.0054204217,
-0.0174684338,
-0.0002936067,
0.0099401763,
0.0615482479,
0.0652549714,
0.0521154702,
-0.0242627095,
0.011978942,
0.0294069313,
0.0369623862,
-0.0195326172,
0.0191745684,
0.0777979195,
-0.0340963863,
0.042409651,
0.0615892,
0.0241000913,
0.0562365055,
-0.0325807855,
-0.0223718751,
-0.0421787985,
-0.0180285312,
-0.0742744282,
0.0146531565,
0.0237500258,
0.0217530634,
-0.0663923547,
-0.0689819232,
0.0510770716,
-0.0061588464,
0.0111678177,
0.0318639576,
-0.0362017415,
-0.0081036445,
-0.0036513745,
-0.0008936694,
0.021934256,
0.0084202746,
0.0035003636,
0.0118090687,
0.0181148369,
0.0237827729,
0.031150369,
-0.0754981115,
-0.0230554398,
-0.0623930879,
-0.0234870799,
-0.0148403235,
0.0498539247,
0.0090084998,
0.0550120659,
0.0162241366,
-0.063693203,
-0.1066947207,
0.0589148663,
-0.029215632,
-0.0028631405,
-0.002722983,
-0.0100073917,
0.0356029123,
-0.0614575259,
0.001157231,
-0.0321772769,
0.0468068868,
-0.011068996,
0.0131157609,
-0.0271506663,
-0.0515772961,
-0.030856695,
0.0348793194,
0.0117557496,
-0.0182106532,
-0.0192936584,
-0.0220888313,
0.0082967719,
0.0322863497,
-0.0696374923,
0.0163786504,
-0.0134626627,
0.0170004852,
0.0255295765,
-0.0298800915,
0.0170968212,
0.0143173095,
-0.0188284088,
-0.0262048896,
-0.0420694128,
0.0424135886,
0.0131812049,
-0.0189718176,
0.0299166758,
0.0026326198,
0.0366942659,
-0.0043474138,
0.0158454068,
-0.0545910932,
-0.0083273984,
0.0077421069,
0.0184068531,
-0.0230875406,
0.0207941923,
-0.0217560101,
-0.0107166423,
-0.0505732819,
-0.0051961122,
0.0456030369,
-0.0962279961,
0.036877282,
-0.0263313781,
-0.0555372387,
0.0144524751,
0.0126086352,
-0.0481114611,
-0.0196731705,
0.0426730737,
0.0413123481,
0.0629676878,
-0.0091893012,
0.0215243567,
-0.0046422156,
0.0225197319,
-0.0039091916,
0.0264285319,
0.0085173361,
0.0103853457,
0.0228354838,
-0.0134969996,
0.0627620667,
-0.0145649128,
-0.0475561135,
0.0109911365,
0.0884536877,
-0.0334382914,
0.0313020907,
0.0228081048,
0.0255508665,
0.0451832078,
0.0376752391,
-0.0216600168,
-0.0416543409,
-0.0193722248,
0.0199819971,
0.0043977415,
0.0294965543,
0.049275022,
-0.0229600463,
-0.0282596014,
0.0182679519,
-0.0324185789,
-0.0379156359,
0.0180955678,
0.0172847472,
-0.0383328237,
0.000232258,
0.0227595232,
-0.0145629123,
0.0064178086,
-0.0234387852,
0.001013012,
0.0107981497,
0.0955663025,
-0.0717012063,
0.0228509698,
-0.0393196791,
-0.021957526,
0.0178217459,
-0.0364604965,
0.0036135565,
-0.024872303,
-0.0271592382,
-0.0250660218,
-0.021475194,
0.0010278529,
-0.009850271,
-0.0184500422,
-0.0026068029,
0.0173189435,
-0.0133981314,
-0.0663517639,
0.070474498,
-0.0008973784,
-0.0238044765,
-0.0030104814,
-0.0257842634,
0.0561090149,
-0.002575425,
-0.0151243554,
0.0754070878,
0.042249836,
-0.0734965801,
-0.0342931822,
0.0196644049,
0.0030535827,
0.0060690157,
0.034018483,
-0.0649074018,
0.0183778107,
0.0140549503,
-0.0130585209,
0.0029022538,
0.0363823362,
-0.0297832396,
0.0096576698,
-0.0211058464,
0.0142695429,
-0.0446746573,
0.0447531827,
-0.0324237272,
0.0198911261,
0.0146989338,
0.0698346719,
0.0206684768,
-0.0489988141,
0.0317334905,
0.0151874106,
-0.0483237654,
-0.0206759311,
0.0032517742,
-0.0295858346,
0.0143267801,
-0.0264697168,
-0.0256513208,
-0.0497161634,
-0.025709305,
0.0111768357,
0.0156621486,
0.0163988639,
0.0321522616,
-0.0437526964,
-0.025562264,
-0.0010010439,
0.0246523917,
-0.0557049513,
0.0049707987,
-0.0005286434,
0.0296910908,
0.014395575,
-0.0198149811,
-0.0356399156,
0.0152134169,
-0.0623900294,
0.0613211095,
0.0134063587,
-0.0315448754,
-0.0612563044,
0.0322054774,
0.0240484457,
-0.0157914069,
-0.0131062409,
-0.013110213,
-0.008196285,
-0.0030988962,
0.0313993059,
0.0856905133,
0.0140671181,
0.0034230861,
0.0501767769,
0.0218263362,
-0.043135196,
-0.0351330899,
-0.0418109633,
0.0181759279,
0.0038743902,
-0.0172461011,
0.1108534485,
-0.0001505066,
0.0111830579,
-0.0180764627,
-0.0028600188,
0.0388478264,
-0.0182163678,
-0.0181906745,
0.0471578687,
-0.0422956124,
-0.0320264995,
0.0076204455,
0.0175105892,
-0.0181307159,
0.0633077621,
-0.0369660705,
-0.000820166,
-0.0755031407,
-0.00293484,
-0.0101327021,
0.0061252643,
-0.0181971844,
0.0311823245,
0.0852360874,
-0.0174567625,
0.0078221764,
-0.0038816761,
0.0068746563,
-0.0291291773,
-0.0386175327,
-0.0174777471,
-0.002086468,
0.0286383983,
0.021142615,
-0.02492694,
-0.0615150481,
0.0206621792,
0.0348104201,
0.0297638532,
-0.0079433555,
-0.0539005771,
-0.0109947221,
0.0260811057,
0.0205585361,
-0.0294384211,
0.0001813241,
-0.0395844541,
0.00635962,
0.0714099109,
-0.0590753034,
0.0446753837,
0.0032102098,
-0.0040686326,
0.0701621547,
-0.0011524763,
0.0331571922,
-0.0040085129,
-0.0180175714,
0.0036788841,
-0.0532406978,
0.0202586204,
-0.0199384149,
-0.0327129513,
-0.0485103056,
-0.0051998277,
0.0854178816,
0.0245544817,
-0.0162406377,
-0.0059068925,
-0.0599966608,
0.0211455282,
-0.0017318288,
0.0078403996,
-0.0530733801,
0.0262913834,
0.0089377472,
0.0038206188,
-0.0392570831,
-0.0459665172,
-0.0134293493,
-0.0391453281,
0.0249737352,
0.0085866647,
-0.0082162749,
-0.0389547013,
-0.0595928766,
-0.0026098297,
0.0416266769,
-0.0207193214,
-0.0231532939,
-0.0069401511,
-0.0030205159,
-0.0157826822,
-0.0461169109,
-0.0603947639,
-0.0114511689,
-0.0359609872,
0.0138405906,
0.0284717195,
0.0489190631,
-0.0114079453,
-0.0229512826,
-0.0066500735,
-0.0247934069,
-0.0653362125,
-0.0080436682,
0.0420790762,
0.0042004483,
0.01648633,
0.022695547,
0.066426903,
-0.0412278064,
-0.0186725259,
0.0403780267,
0.0764181465,
-0.0100392336,
-0.0222270433,
-0.0602950603,
0.0128736869,
-0.0075924192,
0.0779680163,
0.037272796,
0.0005860893,
-0.0640794784,
-0.0232855082,
0.0023468186,
-0.034785267,
-0.0341618285,
0.0012864834,
-0.0590346493,
0.0323557779,
-0.1152188778,
0.0064694849,
0.0229291599,
0.0351175219,
0.0499623977,
0.0440471359,
0.0124268839,
-0.016619429,
-0.052071061,
0.0033281487,
0.0066248993,
0.012965559,
-0.030261308,
0.0324772522,
0.0377709754,
0.055063311,
-0.0306073483,
-0.0070120222,
-0.0399049185,
-0.074980557,
0.008102905,
0.0188370086,
0.0145956716,
-0.0017370842,
-0.0054781353,
-0.0098995306,
0.0242176484,
0.0226526521,
-0.0194879733,
-0.0148013337,
0.0255497359,
-0.0403717197,
-0.0102641592,
0.0063952645,
-0.0105633093,
0.0027404532,
0.0324222371,
-0.0002865735,
-0.0688559711,
-0.0033718881,
0.0561369173,
0.0330608636,
0.0257268492,
-0.0311257783,
-0.0238338206,
0.0086968495,
-0.0011969549,
-0.0257539321,
-0.017972555,
-0.0289440434,
0.0379858427,
0.0218743719,
0.0162504632,
0.0022067823,
0.0325346999,
-0.0560338683,
0.0264306217,
0.0331487209,
0.0194343142,
-0.0173647776,
0.0422584489,
0.0297256149,
0.0128515745,
-0.0025891494,
-0.0139665585,
-0.036736723,
0.0290683359,
-0.0131041547,
0.003500808,
0.0447368883,
-0.0056635388,
-0.0112522384,
0.066737771,
-0.1076143384,
-0.0023044131,
-0.020343272,
-0.0319577977,
-0.0120062949,
-0.01918111,
0.0435816944,
-0.0283729993,
-0.0367044881,
-0.0020384395,
0.0241298396,
-0.0452672951,
0.0446651317,
0.0142888566,
0.0069492417,
-0.0404688157,
0.0255196951,
0.0431665666,
0.0206428897,
0.0402158387,
0.0308954958,
-0.0368297398,
-0.0122516472,
-0.0283170976,
0.0374782123,
0.035573937,
0.00353073,
-0.0200179983,
-0.0253317039,
-0.00214541,
0.0455455109,
0.0069388887,
0.0105122207,
-0.0157118756,
-0.0062837717,
0.0365107469,
-0.0099446652,
-0.0071535492,
-0.0571798384,
0.0802077055,
0.06752038,
-0.0984280109,
-0.033827506,
-5.336455622e-33,
0.0345174335,
-0.0374124311,
-0.0341206267,
0.0498120449,
0.0006825819,
0.010532205,
-0.0284163021,
-0.0593446009,
0.0073220246,
0.0344923474,
-0.0218245592,
-0.0374342687,
-0.0105305221,
-0.0242891926,
-0.0129457172,
0.0199953075,
0.0340999328,
0.0036845638,
-0.0194454417,
-0.0193518046,
0.0629214644,
0.0531483665,
0.029783437,
-0.09327095,
0.0550862923,
-0.0163487792,
-0.0293483716,
-0.0247862041,
0.0155262388,
0.0352967568,
-0.0212307777,
-0.0124320136,
0.0085979253,
0.0000354543,
-0.0282550752,
0.0097831367,
-0.0558337234,
0.0260744561,
0.0429099426,
-0.0193302091,
0.0020772468,
-0.0425352119,
0.0506018586,
-0.029213503,
-0.0085150823,
-0.00201843,
0.055213958,
-0.0362921134,
-0.0324533023,
-0.0706161782,
-0.059732493,
-0.0025067262,
-0.006881637,
0.0282228906,
0.0398778953,
0.0271152593,
0.0007028498,
0.123210758,
-0.050080765,
0.0122597674,
-0.0314225629,
0.0481615961,
-0.0211035609,
-0.0575132854,
0.0456178449,
0.0448484719,
-0.0146220177,
-0.0245472547,
0.0520725213,
0.0426212326,
0.0295730419,
0.0395766199,
0.0645303801,
0.0207931921,
0.0796747357,
0.0063954229,
-0.005277277,
0.0164149869,
-0.0009430905,
0.0328390002,
0.0017508627,
-0.0008558145,
-0.0143120224,
0.0034931924,
0.0085540563,
-0.0168111566,
-0.0087408656,
-0.038203299,
0.028823752,
-0.0160250515,
-0.0572598167,
0.0163775142,
-0.0088647138,
-0.0401009768,
-0.0116134929,
-0.0413102172,
0.0140353404,
0.0379068516,
0.0045177182,
0.0274477061,
-0.0251641814,
-0.0231754202,
0.0238413084,
-0.0279472452,
0.0598238595,
-0.0429223254,
0.0490524657,
-0.0126010105,
-0.077330403,
0.0137847997,
0.0319645815,
-0.0167653672,
0.0252994541,
0.0045443792,
-0.0278432686,
0.0312372949,
0.036617633,
-0.0242894366,
0.035061866,
0.0158345662,
-0.0204572566,
0.0553237312,
-0.0172355548,
0.0492374822,
-0.0095366668,
-0.0275251567,
-0.004984674,
0.0398278907,
0.0098092183,
-0.0747864768,
0.0217472371,
-0.0153783038,
2.456e-7,
0.0473421477,
0.0649273172,
0.0225338247,
-0.0555498004,
0.0117063951,
0.0466439761,
-0.0068982998,
0.0156515669,
-0.0009728295,
-0.0069843619,
-0.0134172756,
-0.0686472356,
0.0163451675,
-0.0084304102,
-0.1338928789,
0.0175372045,
-0.0646607578,
-0.0902284682,
-0.0503730327,
-0.0014212388,
0.0511530526,
0.0539111793,
-0.0012097236,
-0.0037551003,
-0.0297007598,
-0.0783020258,
0.0165581368,
-0.0167667959,
-0.033809457,
0.0590362996,
0.0472911745,
-0.0194765124,
0.0173274577,
0.0016373626,
-0.0322818756,
0.0120197088,
0.0257489402,
0.0303680655,
0.0278127473,
-0.0036604165,
-0.0209650211,
-0.041896712,
0.0243674498,
-0.044669576,
0.0240849499,
-0.0019355596,
-0.0083581097,
-0.0814183801,
-0.0192852132,
0.0053876401,
0.0273208097,
-0.0290017389,
-0.0306292716,
0.031372495,
-0.0082607074,
0.0410614945,
0.0182559211,
-0.0721660629,
0.0150215346,
-0.0079682758,
-0.0534525886,
-0.0048101824,
-0.0136673143,
0.0083673093,
0.0341101922,
-0.0534026548,
0.0066852001,
2.702308377e-34,
0.0619677864,
-0.0505571924,
0.0263631754,
0.086063236,
-0.0071195439,
0.0060803248,
0.0102035133,
0.0393474288,
-0.0205987766,
-0.0300862063,
0.0199158825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01801v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01801v3 | Large Language Models for Time Series: A Survey | 2024-02-02T07:24:35 | 2024-05-06T20:48:41 | Xiyuan Zhang, Ranak Roy Chowdhury, Rajesh K. Gupta, Jingbo Shang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen significant use in domains such as
natural language processing and computer vision. Going beyond text, image and
graphics, LLMs present a significant potential for analysis of time series
data, benefiting domains such as climate, IoT, healthcare, traffic, audio and
finance. This survey paper provides an in-depth exploration and a detailed
taxonomy of the various methodologies employed to harness the power of LLMs for
time series analysis. We address the inherent challenge of bridging the gap
between LLMs' original text data training and the numerical nature of time
series data, and explore strategies for transferring and distilling knowledge
from LLMs to numerical time series analysis. We detail various methodologies,
including (1) direct prompting of LLMs, (2) time series quantization, (3)
aligning techniques, (4) utilization of the vision modality as a bridging
mechanism, and (5) the combination of LLMs with tools. Additionally, this
survey offers a comprehensive overview of the existing multimodal time series
and text datasets and delves into the challenges and future opportunities of
this emerging field. We maintain an up-to-date Github repository which includes
all the papers and datasets discussed in the survey. | Large Language Models for Time Series: A Survey: Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen significant use in domains such as
natural language processing and computer vision. Going beyond text, image and
graphics, LLMs present a significant potential for analysis of time series
data, benefiting domains such as climate, IoT, healthcare, traffic, audio and
finance. This survey paper provides an in-depth exploration and a detailed
taxonomy of the various methodologies employed to harness the power of LLMs for
time series analysis. We address the inherent challenge of bridging the gap
between LLMs' original text data training and the numerical nature of time
series data, and explore strategies for transferring and distilling knowledge
from LLMs to numerical time series analysis. We detail various methodologies,
including (1) direct prompting of LLMs, (2) time series quantization, (3)
aligning techniques, (4) utilization of the vision modality as a bridging
mechanism, and (5) the combination of LLMs with tools. Additionally, this
survey offers a comprehensive overview of the existing multimodal time series
and text datasets and delves into the challenges and future opportunities of
this emerging field. We maintain an up-to-date Github repository which includes
all the papers and datasets discussed in the survey. | [
-0.0498676933,
0.1181633845,
-0.0008352305,
0.0312301386,
-0.0393963009,
0.0272926632,
0.0188987497,
0.007002655,
-0.0105505344,
-0.0277933702,
0.0082306638,
-0.0647758096,
0.0491421372,
0.0445346609,
0.0152548933,
-0.0922205076,
0.0303406473,
-0.0554608591,
-0.0046970504,
0.0273725986,
0.0205916949,
-0.0142778801,
0.0093440618,
0.0245575029,
-0.0508149043,
-0.0114342794,
-0.0306704305,
-0.0238670968,
0.0366594084,
-0.0483051278,
-0.0604073405,
0.0076022614,
0.0674734637,
0.0554633923,
0.0000020055,
-0.000134038,
-0.0042825714,
-0.0103472974,
0.0227804892,
0.0157625843,
0.0615300871,
-0.0586927421,
0.0181677174,
0.0006644375,
-0.0667065382,
-0.0111177769,
0.0805677399,
0.0113541894,
0.0670278817,
0.066148892,
-0.0177661087,
-0.0128453905,
0.0220921747,
-0.0250073187,
-0.0123022692,
-0.0145644443,
0.0209161751,
-0.0011625662,
0.0096192677,
0.0106479554,
-0.0432653688,
0.0521507524,
-0.0117747746,
-0.002664546,
-0.0010466713,
0.0649775192,
-0.0001316112,
0.0074202837,
-0.0374715589,
0.0497291535,
0.0090040304,
-0.0165943839,
0.0247940756,
0.021081863,
-0.0601849891,
0.0319255181,
-0.0661396086,
-0.0042944471,
0.038245257,
0.0591130406,
-0.0103050824,
-0.0116015878,
0.0353391208,
0.0288306549,
-0.0349751785,
0.0360978208,
-0.0005877542,
-0.0318528563,
-0.0372789949,
-0.0071786321,
-0.0150644127,
-0.0460228994,
-0.0230017267,
0.0393229574,
0.0214598328,
-0.0011511183,
-0.0311389882,
-0.0338216573,
-0.039781075,
-0.0307426248,
0.0566929318,
0.0231822971,
-0.0103840418,
0.0472791754,
0.0112521108,
0.0340873413,
-0.0237439293,
-0.0383093804,
-0.0186398253,
-0.0065342002,
-0.0513942204,
-0.0213552937,
-0.004101878,
-0.0580618121,
-0.0119744949,
-0.0039839549,
-0.0600898415,
-0.0000938504,
0.025253715,
-0.0166067705,
0.0158414077,
-0.0061965673,
-0.0046466016,
-0.0193512067,
-0.0098608239,
0.0442019179,
0.0280046314,
0.0310298745,
-0.0120026423,
-0.0448833592,
0.0106399041,
0.039008826,
0.0182647556,
-0.0052137082,
-0.0217763614,
0.0585694015,
0.0298361052,
0.0021004807,
-0.034858238,
-0.0056377593,
-0.0472885109,
-0.0234614182,
-0.0354683176,
-0.0557261929,
0.0095008444,
-0.0182370786,
0.0208703298,
0.0044811261,
0.0062573054,
-0.0034266675,
-0.0149230557,
0.0864998326,
-0.0343717001,
0.017848352,
0.0149751687,
-0.042424906,
0.0823456571,
0.0613762736,
0.0874192789,
-0.0073303385,
0.0235868003,
-0.0397090428,
-0.0228902306,
0.0557537526,
-0.0083534438,
0.0000872732,
-0.0755586773,
-0.021720849,
-0.0063494123,
0.0338015109,
0.039207153,
0.0438356996,
-0.0068671694,
-0.0206012838,
0.0793546885,
0.0583858676,
0.0253220294,
-0.0323027,
0.0204674639,
-0.0057209972,
0.0013002135,
-0.0320924185,
0.0197776873,
0.0361492708,
-0.0097794989,
0.0218233485,
0.0057922038,
0.0406314395,
-0.0183128212,
-0.0316905826,
-0.0239315312,
-0.0277084429,
0.0134442281,
-0.0173995029,
0.0723706037,
-0.0669156164,
0.0028805248,
0.0065492443,
0.0239961687,
-0.0152815646,
0.0128938621,
0.0014664846,
0.0062406356,
0.0677471906,
-0.0082444595,
-0.0041717463,
0.0411572829,
-0.0206407998,
0.0470597334,
0.0201738086,
-0.009239505,
0.0142832901,
-0.0066049127,
-0.0795210004,
-0.0472042933,
0.0369413979,
-0.0064967978,
-0.0026160162,
-0.040436253,
0.0368182249,
0.0192448143,
-0.019540647,
-0.0058548544,
0.0135655217,
-0.0127618685,
-0.0380883478,
-0.0100528514,
0.0059290677,
0.0397279449,
0.0114504248,
-0.019190602,
0.0091654519,
0.0313198268,
-0.0548232384,
0.0143070268,
0.0574200787,
-0.0248700678,
-0.009384728,
0.0190237835,
-0.0133464262,
0.0098943226,
0.0254259296,
-0.0489486344,
-0.0655716732,
0.0417187177,
-0.0363264047,
0.0487263203,
-0.0596775189,
-0.0139779635,
0.0097621819,
0.0313205346,
-0.0309018511,
0.0464000739,
-0.0208898913,
0.0017646882,
0.00186739,
0.0087562967,
-0.0062571764,
-0.0322082266,
0.0045021712,
0.019298844,
0.0293743573,
0.0170646608,
0.0046922853,
-0.0201519262,
0.0012276043,
-0.0001907934,
-0.1245724857,
-0.0478956923,
-0.0186543874,
0.0290128998,
-0.01145072,
-0.0064701969,
-0.0217360072,
-0.0046608588,
-0.0027858713,
0.0221461263,
0.0089821508,
0.0010670603,
0.0549539849,
-0.0189111177,
-0.0156006124,
-0.0242314804,
-0.0219851304,
-0.0412605964,
0.0750580207,
-0.0022125146,
-0.0568229891,
-0.0155605627,
-0.0100324573,
-0.0299749132,
0.0189324878,
-0.0117899738,
-0.0054335771,
0.021563841,
-0.0351645276,
0.0858949572,
-0.0032139609,
0.0472879224,
0.0143434228,
0.0121284435,
-0.0740730613,
-0.0307493825,
0.0161073711,
-0.0182784032,
0.0334922001,
-0.0505186915,
-0.0137782153,
-0.0030495161,
0.0983909816,
0.0066460664,
0.0250472687,
-0.014365335,
0.0281293709,
-0.0598603971,
0.0033869096,
-0.0687327608,
0.0276080109,
-0.057765875,
0.0254736133,
-0.0114085907,
-0.0939506367,
0.0140270833,
-0.047966484,
0.004021619,
0.0083037661,
-0.037821766,
-0.0692162663,
0.0658701882,
0.0090140784,
-0.0042638434,
0.0014596134,
-0.0058433921,
-0.0020222454,
-0.0217117462,
-0.0018237111,
-0.0287441202,
0.0126745822,
-0.0501666591,
0.0541694313,
-0.0032643476,
0.0135128899,
-0.0005709084,
-0.0521041751,
-0.0595281497,
-0.0147465738,
-0.0277550947,
-0.035776414,
-0.0145605262,
0.06658075,
-0.0074905641,
-0.0051865787,
0.0132942321,
0.0095721614,
-0.0050223279,
0.0691322014,
0.0741690248,
0.0205726828,
-0.0158161819,
-0.040935345,
0.0057650427,
-0.023128124,
0.0490471795,
0.0510684177,
-0.0922309384,
0.0093250601,
-0.0095277485,
-0.0061626919,
-0.0100765182,
0.011057674,
0.0208606794,
-0.0490797088,
0.0313482322,
0.0886572301,
0.00608582,
-0.0215684921,
0.0070916279,
0.0364189558,
0.0106292209,
-0.0155243436,
-0.0392572992,
-0.0782950893,
-0.0319460109,
0.0019525476,
-0.0090314923,
0.0016072596,
-0.0389710814,
-0.0171263926,
-0.0662266016,
0.0317666233,
0.0360686705,
-0.025753893,
-0.0104253395,
-0.0729790032,
0.0121461125,
-0.0407919101,
0.0087692114,
-0.0251234602,
-0.0293869339,
0.0252986141,
0.069363445,
-0.0527491458,
-0.0701224133,
-0.0223200582,
-0.0116332099,
0.015328805,
0.0371710025,
0.0412896127,
-0.0213522259,
-0.0276418291,
-0.0353838541,
0.0256304871,
0.0326588191,
-0.015737433,
-0.0099336533,
0.0007145993,
-0.0359569937,
-0.0251219496,
0.0604068711,
-0.0233501997,
0.0109327594,
0.016538769,
0.0665828139,
-0.0438882671,
0.004764535,
-0.0295996964,
0.0012336995,
0.0290288106,
0.0346300416,
0.007998337,
-0.0355969928,
-0.0325673372,
0.0055895704,
-0.006295071,
-0.0403269157,
-0.0794924945,
-0.0243619345,
-0.0060813096,
-0.0100843897,
-0.0392784737,
-0.0115291011,
0.0190538485,
0.0321440622,
-0.0025976296,
0.0473764539,
0.0616334155,
-0.0220479313,
-0.0597273111,
0.0442474373,
-0.0490608104,
0.0537207872,
-0.030638935,
0.0061763176,
0.0215762574,
-0.0151346913,
-0.0039203987,
0.0334472433,
-0.159693554,
-0.0580291115,
0.0200998783,
-0.008799647,
0.0158220176,
0.0087372717,
0.0499080792,
-0.0162837431,
0.0784962326,
0.0762575045,
0.002725441,
0.0245247968,
-0.0215722863,
0.0365353413,
0.0082038511,
0.0091309911,
-0.0015798103,
0.0279218014,
-0.0212389156,
0.0246395841,
-0.048079621,
-0.017233802,
-0.0029586332,
-0.0104460632,
0.0781889781,
0.004548864,
-0.0147804981,
-0.0216010157,
-0.0296473429,
-0.0037166232,
-0.0056735934,
-0.032922972,
-0.0006576252,
0.0173376054,
0.0218301434,
-0.0410198122,
0.0262104142,
0.0362827592,
-0.0205603298,
-0.047903236,
0.0689235926,
-0.0026351691,
0.002553683,
-0.0008649449,
0.0208681691,
0.0339088738,
0.0348243825,
-0.0312921219,
-0.0071696532,
0.0422863029,
0.0235939231,
-0.0076658758,
0.0189453457,
-0.0169377942,
0.0086208116,
-0.0479065292,
-0.0098734433,
-0.0009061035,
0.0183447599,
0.0600730181,
-0.0209428668,
0.0292952862,
-0.0520953573,
0.0203737859,
-0.0380546972,
0.0569884144,
0.0178837087,
0.0248022899,
0.0560072921,
-0.0064767818,
-0.0643050969,
0.0057992851,
0.0645675436,
0.0140228299,
0.0118982019,
0.0294169299,
-0.0217837617,
-0.0270121656,
-0.0081370221,
0.0169517845,
-0.0436528958,
-0.0166239925,
-0.0192028638,
-0.0500097871,
-0.0420969278,
0.0157779697,
-0.0331592895,
-0.0137772569,
-0.0103372866,
0.0102508478,
0.0353136286,
-0.0155490432,
0.0564868227,
-0.0230915658,
0.0161551647,
-0.0284405798,
-0.0625165626,
-0.0441479012,
-5.984453128e-33,
-0.011099861,
-0.0271699447,
0.0290269628,
-0.0252858978,
-0.0443737805,
0.0715844184,
0.0013689992,
0.0062945429,
0.022999743,
-0.0185971837,
0.024986878,
-0.0146810468,
0.018624194,
0.0061034705,
0.0385924838,
0.0199354347,
0.0483876169,
-0.0406361483,
0.026067812,
-0.007370933,
0.0560516566,
0.0321836248,
0.0562450364,
-0.0506368205,
-0.0017174779,
0.0302789938,
-0.0221055113,
-0.0030023281,
0.0608742759,
0.0427795686,
-0.0426600575,
0.0497232974,
0.0365564041,
0.0118525885,
-0.0526728369,
0.0565134399,
-0.0236108024,
0.0118951863,
0.0181801524,
0.0130790155,
-0.0355518162,
-0.0217511244,
0.0100356955,
-0.0162336826,
-0.0367958918,
0.0195524395,
0.0314206183,
-0.0408434458,
-0.0292724129,
-0.0303660315,
-0.0218066797,
0.0665768683,
-0.0302169695,
-0.0089019015,
0.0459376574,
0.0305000991,
-0.0029608908,
0.0482004769,
-0.0569630265,
0.0637164041,
0.0280278381,
0.0286993347,
0.0630851686,
0.045442082,
0.0525550805,
0.0594016127,
0.0027291153,
-0.0609613284,
-0.0324160047,
0.0468525626,
0.0457354188,
0.0315492861,
0.011935154,
0.0451144576,
0.0403018445,
-0.0314577706,
-0.0325318798,
0.0184015129,
0.0116565619,
0.030905053,
0.0295259543,
0.0399042405,
-0.0171169862,
0.0105803423,
-0.0197398793,
0.0109799365,
-0.0160609372,
-0.0037555438,
0.0126275346,
0.0142812505,
0.0214299895,
0.0224837549,
0.061676234,
-0.0345768929,
-0.03633577,
-0.0202022437,
0.0165097844,
0.0206953026,
0.017478358,
0.0107097467,
-0.0738503933,
-0.0675495043,
0.0275987722,
0.0329269394,
0.018410489,
-0.0642332286,
-0.01639615,
0.0489166491,
-0.0441082008,
-0.0125348996,
0.0006170479,
-0.0279140137,
-0.0037657802,
0.0209182967,
0.061243467,
-0.0501518063,
-0.013643641,
0.0503963009,
-0.0206989292,
-0.0044758827,
0.0193683114,
-0.0521216094,
-0.0177795123,
0.0253535975,
-0.0053088004,
0.0043429416,
-0.020281544,
-0.0386855789,
0.0456956811,
-0.0387411788,
-0.0126050375,
0.0309119206,
2.679e-7,
0.0250948537,
0.0647973195,
0.0309305266,
0.0105983987,
0.0371093415,
0.0046341731,
-0.0342761986,
0.0216909479,
-0.0360454433,
0.0147380214,
0.029108528,
0.0064306301,
0.0828524232,
0.0266340021,
-0.0237273406,
-0.0244547259,
-0.0918626636,
-0.0108419247,
-0.0880740955,
-0.0110719688,
0.0519188792,
0.1085923016,
0.0055678403,
0.0097100437,
0.0407613441,
-0.0501169972,
0.0882289708,
-0.0483672805,
-0.0481887497,
-0.0012628457,
0.0172865149,
-0.0024599871,
-0.0209200568,
-0.040624626,
0.0086885365,
-0.002866134,
0.0166146476,
0.0145873651,
-0.0021937611,
-0.0079937726,
-0.0122272018,
0.0196115021,
-0.0373733267,
-0.0430725515,
0.0474489368,
-0.0206800047,
-0.0394224562,
-0.0851843804,
-0.032147564,
0.0317160413,
0.0374598727,
0.0202009566,
-0.0069600833,
0.0312061273,
0.0213278048,
-0.0223436579,
-0.02353682,
-0.0369547568,
-0.0311496835,
0.0079502249,
-0.0361643992,
-0.0097334003,
-0.0579122044,
-0.0061558378,
0.0473905616,
-0.0309181642,
-0.0211432911,
2.249815372e-34,
0.0386019759,
-0.0241588261,
-0.0335236192,
0.003235803,
-0.0063903644,
-0.015990505,
-0.0280487165,
0.0388111435,
-0.0107624279,
-0.0999144763,
-0.0100591918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01183v1 | LINGO-Space: Language-Conditioned Incremental Grounding for Space | 2024-02-02T06:58:39 | 2024-02-02T06:58:39 | Dohyun Kim, Nayoung Oh, Deokmin Hwang, Daehyung Park | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We aim to solve the problem of spatially localizing composite instructions
referring to space: space grounding. Compared to current instance grounding,
space grounding is challenging due to the ill-posedness of identifying
locations referred to by discrete expressions and the compositional ambiguity
of referring expressions. Therefore, we propose a novel probabilistic
space-grounding methodology (LINGO-Space) that accurately identifies a
probabilistic distribution of space being referred to and incrementally updates
it, given subsequent referring expressions leveraging configurable polar
distributions. Our evaluations show that the estimation using polar
distributions enables a robot to ground locations successfully through $20$
table-top manipulation benchmark tests. We also show that updating the
distribution helps the grounding method accurately narrow the referring space.
We finally demonstrate the robustness of the space grounding with simulated
manipulation and real quadruped robot navigation tasks. Code and videos are
available at https://lingo-space.github.io. | LINGO-Space: Language-Conditioned Incremental Grounding for Space: We aim to solve the problem of spatially localizing composite instructions
referring to space: space grounding. Compared to current instance grounding,
space grounding is challenging due to the ill-posedness of identifying
locations referred to by discrete expressions and the compositional ambiguity
of referring expressions. Therefore, we propose a novel probabilistic
space-grounding methodology (LINGO-Space) that accurately identifies a
probabilistic distribution of space being referred to and incrementally updates
it, given subsequent referring expressions leveraging configurable polar
distributions. Our evaluations show that the estimation using polar
distributions enables a robot to ground locations successfully through $20$
table-top manipulation benchmark tests. We also show that updating the
distribution helps the grounding method accurately narrow the referring space.
We finally demonstrate the robustness of the space grounding with simulated
manipulation and real quadruped robot navigation tasks. Code and videos are
available at https://lingo-space.github.io. | [
0.0698803887,
0.0287929997,
0.0131395459,
-0.0569205247,
-0.0053932276,
-0.0036781286,
0.0084030684,
-0.0135976197,
-0.0471198857,
-0.0281323809,
-0.0430581495,
0.0061299521,
0.0283693243,
-0.009771985,
0.0124484245,
-0.0448766463,
0.0500333458,
-0.0269424338,
-0.0578249842,
-0.0042999727,
-0.0358988903,
-0.023043314,
-0.0524595492,
0.0343630575,
-0.0429365449,
0.0236033313,
-0.040179614,
0.0010525455,
0.0196965802,
-0.0568371788,
-0.0065696775,
0.0747036934,
0.038324222,
0.0547459275,
0.0000019712,
-0.0019981877,
-0.0126342401,
0.0039954172,
0.0152162071,
-0.0025322973,
0.0058639161,
-0.0055334005,
0.0068804184,
-0.0050545963,
-0.0076750894,
-0.0252499301,
0.0828058198,
0.025752116,
0.0329384692,
0.0099738725,
0.0120111145,
-0.0077779768,
-0.0412320867,
0.0166624598,
0.0570723824,
-0.0246465355,
0.0084097264,
0.0692182332,
0.0164336618,
0.0268052574,
-0.0502383411,
0.0345026553,
0.0289574191,
-0.0340094008,
0.0207243636,
0.0665884987,
-0.0413326919,
0.0106391832,
-0.0426744148,
0.0223977286,
-0.0368295535,
-0.055187203,
-0.001297719,
0.0080355946,
0.0144752432,
-0.0054294961,
-0.0309608728,
0.0393270515,
-0.0252362639,
-0.021588169,
-0.0681005716,
-0.0253114719,
-0.0111432495,
-0.0176111646,
-0.0487153381,
0.1607433259,
0.0267863553,
0.00748919,
0.0083355065,
-0.0083261104,
0.0020215078,
-0.0616848394,
0.0485535488,
0.002810512,
-0.041644115,
0.0270283073,
-0.0473130271,
0.0337043516,
-0.0148094343,
-0.0870150179,
-0.0032102058,
0.0541293398,
-0.0020693166,
0.0284983534,
-0.0104136486,
0.0374341905,
-0.0323730148,
0.0520767346,
-0.0039004113,
0.0361740924,
-0.0129138958,
0.0249695443,
-0.0496823266,
0.0301366244,
-0.0388784558,
-0.061149098,
0.0201781634,
0.0332306102,
-0.0266576763,
-0.018247677,
-0.0555956028,
0.0390727445,
-0.0328124464,
0.020564517,
0.0198475178,
-0.0336388946,
-0.029512791,
0.0381233804,
-0.0058659543,
-0.0003452579,
-0.0279273763,
0.0440292954,
-0.0213927757,
-0.0224284753,
-0.006745446,
0.0681444779,
0.0355026722,
-0.0182281695,
0.0046513472,
-0.0128752878,
-0.0233168602,
-0.0313479602,
0.0607589297,
-0.0550610945,
-0.0320081934,
0.0072359601,
-0.0203875694,
-0.0257443413,
0.0351770632,
0.0296943132,
-0.0045637116,
0.1260709316,
0.025311349,
0.0095119318,
0.0252152253,
-0.0036537976,
-0.0279222932,
0.0493526421,
0.0236313455,
0.0345388241,
0.0107405139,
0.0141955679,
0.0132743958,
0.0092682429,
-0.0219755601,
0.0165963769,
-0.0209708903,
-0.0327231549,
0.0207961965,
0.0145458141,
-0.0034575472,
0.0201393478,
-0.0121196266,
0.0226209648,
0.0076674116,
0.0409460999,
-0.0712812394,
-0.0321743414,
0.0423859395,
-0.0204610899,
-0.0551092736,
0.0158103667,
-0.0858113095,
0.0498279147,
-0.0595945679,
-0.0045027691,
-0.0006676029,
0.029958088,
-0.0129676973,
-0.0081364457,
-0.0143780094,
0.0149948988,
0.058719147,
-0.031094702,
0.0390938036,
0.0072407001,
-0.0397126861,
0.0808729231,
0.0385661051,
-0.0492537804,
-0.0264203977,
0.0089245392,
-0.0358120278,
-0.0076572387,
0.0006402188,
-0.0293977037,
-0.0630866289,
0.0020233185,
0.0429791249,
0.037847504,
-0.0263060723,
0.0244738273,
0.0216870494,
0.0195795894,
-0.0507497005,
0.0377741046,
0.0076472498,
0.0667393506,
0.0685558766,
0.0230057277,
-0.0037480684,
-0.0795396119,
0.0411736183,
0.0666450337,
0.0815568641,
0.0033552097,
0.0083958078,
0.0182424672,
0.0108129308,
0.020472873,
-0.0223316774,
0.0019606361,
0.0381086059,
0.0221478809,
0.0062686238,
0.0162027888,
-0.0155358957,
0.0163593981,
0.0521480031,
-0.0668806806,
-0.0203077123,
-0.0197947789,
-0.0037477233,
-0.0069161006,
0.0239749458,
-0.0099473437,
0.0226035826,
0.0439841263,
0.0235784575,
-0.0093369605,
-0.0005679562,
0.0052673011,
0.0028754915,
-0.0452260077,
0.0334243476,
0.0117416894,
0.0754486322,
0.0471560173,
-0.0274623111,
-0.0072294096,
-0.0281474832,
0.0121041704,
-0.0327517055,
0.0572165661,
0.0501397252,
-0.0121130738,
-0.048391331,
-0.0362139866,
-0.0368745327,
-0.0109709883,
-0.021143984,
0.032478001,
-0.0350230224,
-0.0190664884,
-0.0224958416,
0.0654509515,
-0.0154215796,
-0.0255585816,
0.0003569982,
0.0074834535,
-0.0005841129,
-0.0688267052,
-0.0247354712,
-0.0030770996,
-0.0196055919,
-0.0330948941,
0.0381386019,
-0.0501201935,
-0.0763667002,
0.019635329,
-0.0197144821,
0.0442140587,
0.0095105711,
-0.0271258596,
0.0323972106,
-0.0268748924,
0.0124593256,
0.0836259127,
-0.0554148443,
-0.016546255,
0.0914396122,
-0.0148624936,
-0.0054496182,
-0.0103119519,
-0.0181288458,
-0.0259920098,
0.0126469089,
-0.0031277025,
-0.0035997189,
-0.0046777707,
-0.0266066231,
-0.0115946233,
-0.0469176061,
-0.0053291344,
-0.0502209514,
-0.0476684235,
-0.0154505828,
0.0176202171,
-0.0475730598,
0.0203681011,
-0.0347984172,
-0.046681352,
0.0197514798,
-0.0287091788,
0.0083114346,
0.0082832202,
-0.012046041,
0.0376339555,
0.0481943414,
0.0049529942,
-0.0087501183,
-0.0013405427,
-0.0539866984,
0.0055132112,
0.0010483612,
-0.0283146761,
0.0337289385,
0.03188641,
-0.0882643387,
0.0412202924,
0.0240180269,
-0.0246235561,
-0.0446481779,
0.0378638245,
0.0058666151,
0.0178200081,
-0.0256829783,
-0.0872431323,
-0.0219333917,
0.0181754585,
0.0569490604,
0.0464589708,
-0.0363434367,
-0.0027555791,
-0.0328113623,
-0.0492272191,
0.0024641331,
0.0297073815,
-0.0434396043,
0.0239091665,
-0.1043470204,
0.0177485775,
0.0579346791,
-0.0260894857,
-0.0089247823,
0.0057165762,
0.0103775673,
0.0241480526,
0.005024978,
0.0337320603,
0.04204439,
0.0032320151,
-0.0776164457,
0.0714774206,
0.0415917747,
-0.0057164091,
0.0079870746,
-0.0128099024,
-0.0175539106,
0.0462179929,
-0.0016125015,
-0.0285413787,
-0.0099541536,
0.0217270311,
-0.0253804009,
0.0537412688,
0.0045782886,
0.0028630651,
-0.0981873348,
0.009898792,
0.0067143161,
-0.1089919806,
-0.1678911299,
-0.0004599673,
0.0073156133,
0.0060195229,
-0.0366948657,
0.0415435806,
0.0135748098,
0.0301959533,
0.0148355272,
-0.020180583,
-0.0045113997,
-0.017830167,
-0.0304702017,
-0.0130340634,
0.0274668373,
0.0055155004,
-0.0348534063,
-0.0421132855,
-0.0161465779,
0.0251068305,
-0.0051007639,
-0.0352634639,
-0.0209275857,
0.0323165394,
0.0152238552,
0.051594533,
0.0204295367,
-0.0242945291,
-0.0216941051,
-0.0150195817,
0.0234977137,
-0.0459212698,
0.0585878864,
-0.0161995385,
0.0288345888,
0.0533001609,
0.0311305188,
0.0260279085,
-0.011137669,
-0.0574095175,
-0.0441546477,
0.0357678905,
-0.0003357581,
0.008815744,
-0.0201967657,
-0.0313734636,
-0.0566139445,
-0.0593791492,
0.0107148709,
0.0581713021,
0.0732526854,
0.0251268037,
-0.0287042782,
-0.0168928951,
0.0195495989,
-0.0421344563,
-0.0069435555,
0.0088767502,
0.0171614867,
-0.0175509378,
0.0042377887,
0.0046286914,
-0.0066994377,
-0.0294691846,
0.0530062392,
0.0211263411,
-0.0495215692,
0.0645141751,
0.0671064481,
0.0233747661,
-0.0030560773,
-0.0080942959,
0.0411674008,
-0.006814389,
0.0215369295,
-0.0075080213,
0.0922817662,
0.0404663645,
0.0508671813,
0.0330086909,
0.0176665653,
-0.0626006722,
-0.0150464056,
-0.0107560614,
0.0256344229,
-0.0698574334,
-0.0168163143,
-0.00480321,
-0.0403079167,
0.0746214464,
-0.0206793863,
0.0235468373,
-0.0230082218,
-0.0022675737,
-0.0311421528,
-0.0096601555,
-0.0351592377,
0.0432653092,
-0.0227741711,
0.0101453625,
0.0433849134,
0.007067211,
-0.0035710288,
0.039652843,
0.0603445023,
-0.0408922583,
0.0425260067,
-0.0146382013,
0.0137785589,
0.0052989237,
0.0064601726,
-0.0148590505,
0.0125544984,
0.0449648201,
-0.0134959631,
0.0105907898,
0.050176546,
-0.0412570126,
-0.0497418866,
-0.0006645317,
-0.0555556081,
-0.051746659,
0.0228579324,
0.0386529155,
0.0868171379,
0.0225582328,
0.0058861319,
-0.0729752108,
-0.0248404816,
0.0103315273,
-0.0027071664,
0.0620144941,
0.0005346906,
0.005934468,
0.0172672588,
0.0006287903,
0.00446659,
0.0120090535,
-0.0200028736,
0.0597283244,
-0.013234159,
-0.0116817402,
-0.0335279927,
-0.0183216818,
-0.0210685655,
0.0522761568,
0.0021049755,
0.0389320962,
-0.0418026634,
-0.0435371511,
-0.0427528843,
0.0335527472,
-0.0307973567,
-0.0244645495,
0.0733216405,
0.0169238392,
-0.0008746121,
-0.0432431847,
-0.0043693366,
-0.0252438597,
0.035949707,
-0.0035419222,
-0.074449271,
-5.721939525e-33,
-0.0634809881,
-0.0845481232,
-0.0069893575,
-0.0057044765,
-0.0247482304,
-0.0013046518,
-0.0027483557,
0.0407376736,
-0.01739382,
0.0227895118,
0.0102127865,
0.0109293982,
0.020604426,
-0.0125237461,
0.0264721196,
0.0457333736,
0.0145283761,
0.0228904244,
-0.0432091504,
-0.0165761989,
0.0658842996,
0.0317521505,
0.0399749093,
-0.0865680575,
0.0012008676,
0.0392956845,
-0.0151608791,
0.0043166596,
-0.0332452767,
-0.0024245239,
-0.0101065421,
-0.0150160827,
-0.0502161533,
-0.0173151568,
-0.0173387248,
-0.0025523852,
-0.0754531696,
-0.0651987642,
-0.0132100442,
0.043145556,
0.0121600814,
0.0033359642,
0.0501878969,
-0.007279445,
-0.0439553894,
0.0162150934,
0.0119481301,
-0.0100618619,
-0.0143644689,
0.036104545,
-0.0332821161,
0.0079169469,
0.0327572301,
-0.0556223802,
-0.0106122317,
-0.0430172384,
0.0307345428,
-0.0379360728,
-0.0388898738,
0.0185660757,
0.015426632,
0.0271216873,
0.0303895324,
0.0150977112,
0.0729400218,
0.0810236186,
0.0241453387,
-0.0558278225,
0.0313356891,
-0.0531292558,
0.0103723798,
-0.0283198971,
-0.0128704868,
-0.0350036323,
0.0420946777,
0.0028333417,
-0.0317435898,
-0.0182594694,
-0.0017620861,
0.0657770783,
0.0010895043,
0.0106161376,
-0.0533441082,
0.0037669393,
0.0165638961,
-0.0339667201,
0.0482122153,
-0.0471976213,
0.0203833655,
0.0183110777,
-0.0071881395,
-0.0032072368,
0.0225305166,
0.0170344952,
-0.0187767819,
0.0253416561,
0.0188237783,
0.0342099741,
-0.004702202,
-0.018172916,
-0.0045539518,
-0.03268639,
-0.0008300362,
-0.0091759199,
0.0068443073,
0.0093449568,
-0.0519912057,
0.0542426482,
-0.0534039773,
0.0058941566,
-0.0008163516,
-0.0448648371,
0.0198746361,
0.017010387,
0.0785518363,
0.0086556906,
0.0080848178,
0.0674865991,
0.0298538264,
-0.0259067491,
0.0175175797,
-0.0369367898,
-0.0465129055,
0.0388034657,
-0.0659032837,
-0.0175401028,
-0.0402304418,
0.0094596725,
0.0067626005,
-0.0548586175,
-0.03904441,
0.014061966,
2.767e-7,
0.0497186556,
0.0280351732,
0.0493421666,
0.0010803816,
-0.0306267794,
0.0032313536,
0.0141278701,
0.0013106159,
-0.0240866486,
-0.040020857,
-0.0327571519,
0.0138189346,
-0.0547348559,
-0.0244671181,
-0.0669240654,
0.0330957547,
-0.0035027077,
-0.0164140072,
-0.0199750066,
0.0001393377,
0.0225153267,
0.0651883334,
0.0254108254,
0.0134321013,
0.0055727917,
-0.0541022606,
-0.0280772708,
-0.0078908158,
0.0716951638,
-0.0090553295,
-0.0229688343,
0.0159128178,
-0.0466977507,
-0.0018059242,
-0.0261263065,
0.0001563305,
0.0071895407,
0.0293386579,
-0.052377522,
0.0015387443,
-0.0063053113,
0.0044371178,
-0.0115391826,
-0.0245140325,
0.0489649847,
-0.051515881,
0.0370974392,
0.0083497101,
0.0353201553,
0.0141213574,
-0.0200894326,
0.0302446503,
-0.004282563,
-0.0572865196,
-0.021204643,
0.0530915894,
-0.0098344395,
-0.0629244968,
-0.0042367671,
0.044157885,
-0.0181974564,
-0.0338090882,
0.0534771569,
-0.0394187607,
-0.0157303046,
0.0237675793,
-0.0546086095,
2.524428531e-34,
0.017272111,
-0.0231958274,
0.0075501101,
0.0384516306,
0.01483142,
0.0243908986,
-0.0364220701,
0.0089448234,
0.043809291,
0.0176333357,
-0.0330987461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01182v1 | In-Context Learning for Few-Shot Nested Named Entity Recognition | 2024-02-02T06:57:53 | 2024-02-02T06:57:53 | Meishan Zhang, Bin Wang, Hao Fei, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In nested Named entity recognition (NER), entities are nested with each
other, and thus requiring more data annotations to address. This leads to the
development of few-shot nested NER, where the prevalence of pretrained language
models with in-context learning (ICL) offers promising solutions. In this work,
we introduce an effective and innovative ICL framework for the setting of
few-shot nested NER. We improve the ICL prompt by devising a novel example
demonstration selection mechanism, EnDe retriever. In EnDe retriever, we employ
contrastive learning to perform three types of representation learning, in
terms of semantic similarity, boundary similarity, and label similarity, to
generate high-quality demonstration examples. Extensive experiments over three
nested NER and four flat NER datasets demonstrate the efficacy of our system. | In-Context Learning for Few-Shot Nested Named Entity Recognition: In nested Named entity recognition (NER), entities are nested with each
other, and thus requiring more data annotations to address. This leads to the
development of few-shot nested NER, where the prevalence of pretrained language
models with in-context learning (ICL) offers promising solutions. In this work,
we introduce an effective and innovative ICL framework for the setting of
few-shot nested NER. We improve the ICL prompt by devising a novel example
demonstration selection mechanism, EnDe retriever. In EnDe retriever, we employ
contrastive learning to perform three types of representation learning, in
terms of semantic similarity, boundary similarity, and label similarity, to
generate high-quality demonstration examples. Extensive experiments over three
nested NER and four flat NER datasets demonstrate the efficacy of our system. | [
-0.0190641861,
0.0303453896,
0.0104272952,
0.0518747196,
-0.0288334414,
0.0641530082,
0.0602675006,
0.0116277942,
0.0228712223,
-0.0765183792,
-0.0526361205,
-0.02008087,
-0.0175625607,
-0.0157706942,
0.0332001373,
-0.0547071807,
0.0159598775,
-0.0206658915,
0.0177735463,
0.0195399821,
-0.0094150025,
0.0082697924,
-0.0227721762,
0.0107712019,
0.0028940791,
-0.0331019126,
-0.0074813887,
0.0217304826,
0.0435545743,
-0.1012383923,
0.0436155125,
0.0416628532,
0.0347269662,
0.0266357474,
0.0000019527,
-0.0504270159,
-0.0338839516,
0.0401220955,
-0.0383317024,
-0.0213729106,
0.0646977574,
-0.0178350452,
0.0108116595,
-0.0128659299,
-0.0055758618,
-0.0731884241,
0.0171436165,
0.0626278669,
0.0026896608,
0.0628615171,
-0.0180695187,
-0.0608303323,
0.0149440691,
0.0005116887,
-0.0140275368,
-0.0148016224,
0.0227223225,
-0.0195031688,
0.0271968003,
0.0142260296,
-0.0043298095,
0.0002867783,
0.0133949164,
0.0357302539,
-0.0198020246,
0.0516292788,
-0.0399942212,
0.0162244253,
-0.0105901696,
0.0893346891,
-0.0339188427,
-0.0144181727,
0.0113308104,
-0.0549683012,
-0.0321011059,
-0.0556974821,
-0.0310893599,
-0.0147652971,
-0.0297249667,
0.0315505415,
0.039936088,
0.0476363748,
0.0000699647,
-0.0224469695,
-0.0112329004,
-0.0236055199,
0.0216484517,
-0.0351425596,
-0.003506934,
0.0285256039,
0.0056262109,
-0.0401157029,
-0.0003790486,
-0.0105998348,
-0.0147774154,
0.0351439305,
-0.0582046658,
-0.058885362,
0.0064003374,
0.0086417515,
0.0434334502,
0.0209206771,
-0.029447021,
0.0659688041,
-0.0562403947,
-0.0106159635,
-0.016347114,
0.0190754309,
0.0170354638,
-0.0028173218,
-0.0554076694,
0.0302222464,
-0.047662314,
0.0390079878,
-0.0174811147,
-0.0149218533,
0.0055451877,
0.0086044809,
-0.0278196242,
0.0233955532,
-0.0241997167,
-0.0178574901,
-0.0213478934,
-0.0193340946,
0.0026886878,
0.0079196747,
-0.0390762463,
-0.0009797959,
-0.0006204891,
-0.053835392,
-0.0216792673,
-0.0120705729,
0.0477612764,
-0.0536489934,
0.0176575575,
0.0661727265,
0.0341080762,
-0.1172795445,
-0.073318392,
0.0208048727,
0.003854464,
-0.034624707,
0.0050531928,
-0.0419798978,
0.0479218327,
0.0045330501,
0.0015020916,
-0.0558990501,
0.0048575825,
0.0144389113,
-0.0303724594,
0.0905830711,
-0.054279428,
-0.0549876653,
-0.0219243225,
-0.0082416497,
0.0177644081,
0.0822683647,
0.0200215988,
-0.0251360834,
0.0271499213,
0.0351553448,
-0.0118124103,
0.0185141582,
0.0537986904,
0.0095023345,
-0.0265004486,
0.0333950557,
-0.0120459478,
0.0195157751,
0.0334793814,
0.0165136214,
-0.0107302852,
0.0145799136,
0.0299080107,
0.0454164483,
0.0145389652,
-0.0193482097,
0.0413299166,
0.0094804754,
-0.0158316381,
0.0188223906,
-0.0203530546,
0.031659849,
-0.0311784856,
0.0238006208,
0.0405437499,
0.0519991405,
-0.0316777676,
0.0142182996,
0.0111681623,
-0.0036196399,
-0.0319022983,
0.0065066759,
0.0538654327,
0.0474670157,
-0.0838645324,
0.037907932,
0.0619858243,
-0.0008872492,
-0.0021173139,
-0.0031589121,
0.0167765338,
0.0355733521,
0.0394693501,
-0.0397043377,
-0.034285523,
-0.0326192454,
-0.0032773709,
0.0469676107,
0.0224963967,
-0.0169296004,
0.0369672552,
-0.0279613249,
-0.0307898261,
-0.0308639985,
0.0185089931,
0.0050053685,
0.0070714015,
0.031413883,
0.0092813186,
-0.0408375785,
-0.0076810652,
0.0382515006,
-0.017350113,
-0.0279064476,
0.0260552745,
0.0408028364,
0.0208792817,
0.0360649489,
-0.0200186688,
-0.0202499982,
0.0169200022,
-0.0272385739,
0.0260288324,
-0.0270854272,
-0.0310325045,
-0.1312832683,
-0.0244985484,
-0.0129418019,
-0.0314873122,
-0.0312680416,
-0.0412719697,
-0.0207623541,
-0.0622066446,
0.0296270419,
0.0781870484,
-0.0316527151,
0.0108481776,
0.0211071931,
0.0045924406,
-0.0269823875,
0.0971427858,
0.0029820686,
0.0184115991,
0.0229250491,
-0.0039430819,
-0.0183863807,
-0.0177580249,
-0.0195326619,
-0.0197315309,
0.0047849552,
-0.0332942158,
-0.0187726542,
0.0355673805,
-0.0779494792,
0.0120869894,
-0.0565971173,
0.0042794896,
-0.030575024,
0.0339973532,
-0.0038930257,
0.0178658813,
-0.0252666119,
-0.039517805,
-0.0157798342,
-0.0124883847,
-0.0492355898,
0.0183283985,
0.0395165198,
0.0124213109,
-0.0090974318,
-0.0061334148,
0.0149291381,
-0.0338428728,
0.0604993924,
-0.0135504194,
-0.0167614371,
-0.0508295894,
0.0566048957,
0.0163024813,
0.003445724,
0.0251119528,
0.0618446171,
0.0019021938,
0.0384952836,
0.0087256292,
0.0572381094,
-0.011801417,
0.0505156033,
-0.0234747231,
-0.0132117011,
-0.0725468546,
0.0264073964,
-0.0099692391,
0.0481890924,
0.0131954253,
0.0256680064,
0.0244943891,
0.046107702,
-0.0167730357,
0.0240713228,
-0.0294171199,
0.051007662,
-0.0008832862,
-0.0075186295,
-0.0182468817,
0.0231095888,
0.0007043184,
0.0157562811,
-0.0192879178,
-0.0113899559,
0.0819803849,
-0.0424732119,
-0.0222014543,
-0.0232233517,
0.0198360346,
-0.0448282696,
0.0411481485,
-0.0105170691,
-0.0032474187,
0.0405083261,
-0.0576063022,
0.001595545,
0.0315063074,
-0.0212311987,
-0.0067420714,
0.0214263499,
0.0111596957,
0.0169263147,
-0.0145171368,
-0.0473356321,
-0.0252048746,
-0.0248162374,
-0.0445370711,
0.0259053893,
-0.0392427929,
0.0338638574,
-0.0009931852,
0.0252164099,
0.0059069288,
0.0580529869,
0.0128297163,
-0.0195073579,
-0.0300653093,
0.0575210862,
0.0353997536,
-0.0180131774,
0.0209078509,
-0.0119901914,
0.031515982,
0.0098460196,
0.0243215431,
0.0122631239,
-0.0046201837,
0.0077513331,
0.0062974528,
-0.0456799902,
0.0025130319,
-0.0013752433,
0.0425227955,
-0.0453344546,
-0.0150666684,
0.0846270025,
0.0012814826,
-0.042684976,
-0.0076039741,
0.0178622417,
0.0131289931,
0.022316277,
0.0231469087,
-0.1040340662,
-0.0403873026,
0.0057142484,
0.000930222,
0.0331710167,
-0.0601781122,
0.001079657,
-0.1487846076,
0.041735474,
-0.0017925376,
-0.0709453598,
-0.0059080631,
-0.0384769253,
0.0333741829,
-0.0004406076,
0.0285306238,
-0.0138214249,
-0.0414134003,
-0.0036094363,
-0.0034310876,
0.0347943008,
-0.0840423927,
0.0487610959,
-0.0637956411,
0.0330236666,
0.0121623483,
0.0079139834,
0.0171296764,
-0.0034643319,
-0.0246592779,
-0.0522287041,
-0.0144685032,
-0.0246892329,
0.0302567258,
-0.0578915663,
-0.0300410595,
-0.0151261352,
0.0135669038,
-0.0220667515,
-0.0326710306,
-0.0013357867,
0.0580774322,
0.0107950112,
0.0052230074,
-0.0243559349,
-0.038108848,
0.0746401697,
0.0821264759,
0.0484861322,
-0.0323078409,
-0.0118841631,
0.030486349,
0.0004192459,
-0.0312659852,
0.0102402521,
0.0210563261,
-0.0358699821,
0.0127304895,
-0.0361062102,
-0.0554357581,
0.0712749958,
0.062614046,
-0.0161965545,
-0.0014085164,
-0.0074177911,
-0.0030329167,
-0.0320783518,
0.0224835649,
-0.0352495573,
0.0229133144,
-0.0425554551,
-0.0109484354,
0.0385202505,
-0.0129289953,
-0.0613698736,
-0.0214491133,
-0.0534045734,
-0.0358786434,
-0.0167810377,
0.035187453,
-0.0016607678,
0.057484217,
-0.0076789837,
-0.0098820021,
0.0642550439,
0.0412255302,
-0.0321156569,
-0.036474105,
0.0236873776,
0.0204358995,
-0.0044989269,
0.0307189152,
-0.0480792783,
0.0406922363,
0.0365588404,
0.0498679169,
-0.0179376118,
-0.0119845523,
0.0101819122,
-0.0259750951,
0.0739970133,
-0.013090943,
-0.0235616416,
-0.047311306,
0.05011639,
-0.0137452167,
-0.0142233539,
-0.0267266054,
-0.0139308348,
-0.0374733545,
-0.0111324033,
-0.0359550342,
0.0269613769,
-0.0150449006,
0.0459283814,
-0.0286885872,
0.023801621,
0.0440892279,
0.0204154849,
-0.0027015023,
-0.0217910483,
-0.0333667099,
0.0379026905,
0.0067146048,
0.04817174,
-0.05567424,
0.0425559282,
0.0129089514,
0.0015601197,
-0.0432349145,
0.018350875,
0.0013810338,
0.0281304196,
-0.0563558079,
0.0173828173,
0.0499362648,
-0.0264650024,
0.0200424623,
0.0042088241,
-0.0056025488,
0.0024950725,
0.015447991,
-0.0258526858,
-0.0579261631,
0.0202539917,
0.0262530427,
-0.0088114385,
0.0052726967,
0.0543949753,
0.0019885821,
0.0429671779,
0.0314220265,
0.0494626872,
-0.0407546684,
0.0167770181,
0.0656461492,
0.0379348397,
0.0053156102,
0.0056669973,
-0.0503829718,
-0.0476916134,
0.0319432169,
-0.010900801,
-0.0532130599,
0.042452924,
0.0253556296,
0.0180974286,
0.0090416167,
-0.0498530939,
-0.0161706805,
-0.010064193,
0.0327494703,
-0.0529727675,
-0.027504459,
-6.485015724e-33,
-0.0468952581,
-0.0194732696,
0.0116768526,
-0.0291478019,
0.0232010726,
0.0202916265,
-0.0349046737,
-0.0389556959,
-0.0108547742,
-0.0144837033,
-0.0141307553,
-0.0353435166,
0.0267381277,
0.0314509459,
-0.010377612,
-0.0312201958,
0.0515444092,
0.0197297242,
-0.0127328504,
0.0153682735,
0.001902589,
0.0612967797,
0.0873283967,
-0.0908000171,
0.0175118279,
0.0041836728,
0.0104136989,
0.0053897835,
0.0549809225,
0.0620838031,
-0.0330297239,
-0.0074510598,
0.0196671728,
-0.0308168288,
-0.0089131603,
-0.0036288684,
-0.1353770792,
-0.0100199832,
-0.0365138948,
0.0102033122,
-0.0400978252,
-0.0105381552,
0.0152903199,
-0.0247815754,
0.0455629341,
-0.0228332672,
0.0163670834,
-0.0096052103,
0.0008486547,
-0.0330494791,
-0.086272873,
0.0468597524,
0.02155024,
0.0204193648,
0.0372803807,
-0.0070787081,
0.0362693071,
0.0317572989,
-0.0911489651,
-0.0187093876,
0.0129268654,
-0.0487533808,
0.039366819,
0.0123242149,
0.0072887577,
0.0865295082,
0.0270071011,
0.0024317922,
0.0047945725,
-0.0341763236,
0.04061139,
0.0440629832,
-0.0267784335,
0.0628469586,
0.0606752336,
0.0047254465,
-0.0573199242,
0.0121769393,
0.0093272403,
-0.0152817089,
-0.0055641597,
0.0014065077,
-0.0651796311,
-0.0066120368,
-0.005246629,
-0.0580568947,
-0.0460742712,
-0.0290806275,
0.0480248407,
0.0081389546,
-0.0559378564,
0.0418205559,
0.052540794,
-0.0014293661,
-0.0651539788,
0.0106387697,
0.0487254299,
0.0091008218,
-0.0109370314,
0.0033148094,
-0.042800419,
-0.0618089139,
0.0098790284,
0.0032948959,
0.0184898041,
-0.0021834867,
0.0920476094,
0.0003526467,
-0.0888873264,
0.0036227098,
0.0029748403,
-0.0056239539,
-0.0006649529,
-0.0149177462,
0.0410242602,
0.0156459138,
0.0001596832,
0.0450873338,
0.0738904178,
-0.0642533302,
-0.0339942425,
0.017299626,
-0.0250505041,
0.0372048952,
0.0234299526,
-0.0155804306,
0.00586621,
0.0031383832,
0.0289078355,
-0.0402820893,
0.0035631466,
0.0025055883,
2.658e-7,
0.0257658996,
0.0216446333,
0.0069045224,
-0.0078077703,
0.0132837398,
0.0206268709,
0.0213253181,
0.0551169068,
-0.0241883341,
-0.0011706627,
0.0155558856,
-0.0363578796,
0.0270127971,
0.0492162518,
-0.0899691582,
0.0088706454,
-0.0285144597,
0.0001058846,
-0.0755729079,
-0.0206905808,
0.082498163,
0.0627949089,
0.0279124826,
-0.0069618477,
-0.0140346084,
-0.0277949665,
0.0577768013,
0.0007036866,
0.0352249667,
0.0020307552,
-0.0585551374,
0.064747192,
0.0014661502,
0.0318330005,
-0.0162064191,
0.0524411537,
0.0046554804,
0.035283532,
0.0089887632,
-0.0141498884,
-0.0058735535,
-0.0251728855,
-0.0023308711,
-0.0452764258,
0.083375439,
-0.11216598,
0.0103047322,
-0.028524993,
-0.0318017229,
-0.0254406277,
0.0056799329,
0.0168662108,
-0.020152092,
0.0432038419,
0.0236245915,
-0.0103999805,
-0.0268253461,
-0.0784669742,
0.0272068158,
0.0390548296,
0.0028851724,
0.0268396921,
-0.0162230823,
-0.0174596012,
0.0320190974,
-0.039435178,
0.0021233389,
2.452947684e-34,
0.0010149825,
0.0004443253,
0.0003778453,
0.0674170628,
0.0090494705,
-0.0227231272,
-0.0177603252,
-0.0205582548,
0.0078538349,
-0.0633058473,
0.0202819295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01176v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01176v2 | CorpusLM: Towards a Unified Language Model on Corpus for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks | 2024-02-02T06:44:22 | 2024-04-21T08:33:32 | Xiaoxi Li, Zhicheng Dou, Yujia Zhou, Fangchao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have gained significant attention in various
fields but prone to hallucination, especially in knowledge-intensive (KI)
tasks. To address this, retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a
popular solution to enhance factual accuracy. However, traditional retrieval
modules often rely on large document index and disconnect with generative
tasks. With the advent of generative retrieval (GR), language models can
retrieve by directly generating document identifiers (DocIDs), offering
superior performance in retrieval tasks. However, the potential relationship
between GR and downstream tasks remains unexplored. In this paper, we propose
\textbf{CorpusLM}, a unified language model that leverages external corpus to
tackle various knowledge-intensive tasks by integrating generative retrieval,
closed-book generation, and RAG through a unified greedy decoding process. We
design the following mechanisms to facilitate effective retrieval and
generation, and improve the end-to-end effectiveness of KI tasks: (1) We
develop a ranking-oriented DocID list generation strategy, which refines GR by
directly learning from a DocID ranking list, to improve retrieval quality. (2)
We design a continuous DocIDs-References-Answer generation strategy, which
facilitates effective and efficient RAG. (3) We employ well-designed
unsupervised DocID understanding tasks, to comprehend DocID semantics and their
relevance to downstream tasks. We evaluate our approach on the widely used KILT
benchmark with two variants of backbone models, i.e., T5 and Llama2.
Experimental results demonstrate the superior performance of our models in both
retrieval and downstream tasks. | CorpusLM: Towards a Unified Language Model on Corpus for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks: Large language models (LLMs) have gained significant attention in various
fields but prone to hallucination, especially in knowledge-intensive (KI)
tasks. To address this, retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a
popular solution to enhance factual accuracy. However, traditional retrieval
modules often rely on large document index and disconnect with generative
tasks. With the advent of generative retrieval (GR), language models can
retrieve by directly generating document identifiers (DocIDs), offering
superior performance in retrieval tasks. However, the potential relationship
between GR and downstream tasks remains unexplored. In this paper, we propose
\textbf{CorpusLM}, a unified language model that leverages external corpus to
tackle various knowledge-intensive tasks by integrating generative retrieval,
closed-book generation, and RAG through a unified greedy decoding process. We
design the following mechanisms to facilitate effective retrieval and
generation, and improve the end-to-end effectiveness of KI tasks: (1) We
develop a ranking-oriented DocID list generation strategy, which refines GR by
directly learning from a DocID ranking list, to improve retrieval quality. (2)
We design a continuous DocIDs-References-Answer generation strategy, which
facilitates effective and efficient RAG. (3) We employ well-designed
unsupervised DocID understanding tasks, to comprehend DocID semantics and their
relevance to downstream tasks. We evaluate our approach on the widely used KILT
benchmark with two variants of backbone models, i.e., T5 and Llama2.
Experimental results demonstrate the superior performance of our models in both
retrieval and downstream tasks. | [
0.0832369924,
0.0287313983,
0.0099623892,
0.0070998454,
-0.0169845354,
0.0087513058,
-0.0047405162,
-0.0023284161,
0.0285688099,
-0.049925942,
-0.0134418672,
0.0002044609,
-0.0291637424,
-0.027260419,
0.0093090311,
-0.0167778954,
0.0522772148,
-0.0177600048,
0.0222034007,
-0.0260012355,
-0.0066399304,
0.0235464349,
0.0140826236,
0.0141170602,
-0.0081554018,
-0.0259170141,
0.0097709447,
-0.0052378792,
-0.0091046495,
0.0036543149,
0.0339288078,
0.0382553078,
0.0181595441,
0.0396873206,
0.0000020514,
-0.0482896529,
-0.0320031717,
0.0158264674,
-0.0087655205,
0.0035805455,
0.0354528986,
0.0030938478,
0.0261164885,
0.0116716996,
-0.0232973062,
0.0059219617,
0.0142508419,
0.057798285,
0.0422428474,
0.059670534,
0.0102023743,
-0.0474618822,
0.0512764193,
-0.0043532914,
0.0530113652,
-0.0174373742,
0.0091013452,
0.0417515673,
0.0373956151,
0.0588918738,
0.0078204051,
0.0549435169,
-0.0038953314,
-0.0339851305,
0.0670279339,
0.0362322666,
-0.0541898422,
-0.0072612851,
0.0273295157,
0.0417766869,
0.0102359559,
-0.058623217,
0.0284665339,
0.0255662762,
0.0051156962,
0.0239319336,
-0.0717121288,
0.037319731,
-0.0291309301,
0.0050742971,
0.0538165346,
0.0114744641,
0.0270013604,
0.0171121582,
0.0014931717,
0.0423857272,
0.0317193381,
-0.0269606058,
-0.036017105,
0.01557332,
-0.0218737964,
-0.0244850088,
0.0018778446,
0.0282129124,
-0.0292443801,
0.0232831612,
-0.001518375,
-0.0645920783,
0.0572486371,
-0.047176227,
-0.0094966125,
-0.0032652342,
-0.0041323635,
0.0567507073,
-0.0388827473,
0.0245871879,
-0.0075950921,
-0.007158102,
-0.0683892891,
-0.0258822236,
-0.0420666598,
-0.0362359695,
-0.0429872684,
0.0427405052,
-0.0463035963,
-0.021074621,
0.0101067731,
0.0241271406,
0.0226085559,
-0.0130087007,
0.0176979899,
0.0284951925,
-0.0611374639,
-0.0174661707,
-0.0358075537,
0.0085493466,
-0.0158684496,
-0.0194287356,
0.0176849309,
-0.0369949266,
-0.0003857888,
0.0065002544,
0.0097540608,
-0.0373244509,
-0.0066251624,
-0.0009382886,
-0.0248267092,
-0.0141782667,
-0.0189516228,
-0.0418826453,
-0.0109725492,
-0.0530813821,
0.0250221174,
-0.0839572027,
0.037395183,
0.0368693322,
-0.0214133617,
-0.0220243577,
0.0223532561,
0.0375308208,
-0.0355268344,
0.0225239526,
0.0164301991,
0.0022976648,
0.0520907976,
0.0117390128,
0.0241238698,
0.0398542508,
-0.0040946938,
0.0225047804,
0.067489922,
0.037083324,
0.0009424342,
-0.0071256845,
0.0227263831,
-0.0015645295,
0.0234247893,
0.0275675301,
0.004284197,
0.0234573763,
0.0345255695,
0.0416898057,
-0.0464191586,
-0.0073811985,
0.0548204519,
-0.0031727301,
0.0029129314,
0.0175853875,
0.0085880468,
0.0240318831,
0.0124568855,
0.0247606747,
0.010279173,
0.0171922203,
-0.0064227106,
0.0065202843,
0.0426147021,
0.0127934348,
-0.0272705946,
-0.0307913497,
-0.0084495516,
0.0007481915,
-0.0371534675,
0.0098170154,
0.03888027,
0.022430595,
-0.0350061432,
0.0719088316,
0.014334619,
-0.0867974758,
0.0302788429,
-0.0314188339,
0.0294080302,
0.0587412268,
0.1020041257,
-0.0151434252,
-0.0339320265,
0.0086015351,
-0.0160035156,
0.0568974689,
0.0310177729,
-0.0349734016,
-0.0403984338,
-0.0567353703,
-0.0148897516,
-0.0167220309,
0.0064899507,
0.013617605,
0.0039671049,
-0.0085735125,
0.0295649841,
-0.110402368,
-0.0442440324,
0.0213933513,
-0.0533201993,
-0.0437658094,
0.0138746882,
-0.0331465825,
-0.0236126557,
-0.0014389835,
-0.0186051112,
0.0347574428,
0.022811152,
-0.0440475009,
-0.0234873146,
-0.0066792271,
-0.0330179259,
-0.0380253866,
0.0346399248,
-0.0105469637,
0.0199067425,
0.0450045504,
-0.011533482,
-0.0375862904,
-0.0043117274,
-0.0279417653,
0.0228769667,
-0.0819906443,
-0.0182164051,
0.0383961499,
0.0003014238,
-0.0702835768,
0.0867819339,
-0.0013787749,
0.0401204079,
0.0233091284,
-0.0030971793,
0.0223330706,
-0.0529178493,
-0.0083843758,
0.0258877631,
-0.013687484,
0.019677978,
0.0600832738,
-0.0024676609,
-0.0242529586,
-0.0406861007,
-0.1060617119,
0.0025096775,
-0.0180373322,
-0.0244046263,
0.0205375105,
0.0190714616,
0.0022308321,
0.0038526463,
-0.0489868298,
0.0035045564,
0.0348880589,
0.0072626211,
0.0102858217,
0.009139522,
0.0269564725,
-0.0234352704,
-0.0096625313,
0.0171781126,
0.0394811407,
0.0137193911,
-0.0093522752,
-0.0352048539,
0.0174340364,
-0.0421741344,
0.0182560086,
-0.013228396,
0.019687254,
0.0156915914,
-0.0260748994,
0.0779297203,
0.0184753891,
0.0533850081,
0.0160003547,
0.013598646,
-0.0266161934,
-0.0995713696,
0.0243850797,
-0.0472572967,
-0.0202572625,
0.0045954101,
-0.0087721376,
0.0226306766,
0.0423886478,
0.0173555296,
-0.0315841623,
-0.0496865176,
0.0051914025,
0.0023209774,
-0.0427294374,
-0.0682330728,
0.0081250602,
0.0061125732,
0.0390754826,
-0.0350639261,
-0.0337436534,
0.0387681574,
-0.031097874,
0.0115640694,
-0.0783160552,
0.0379075408,
-0.0409235284,
0.0289357752,
0.0179382302,
0.0227963887,
-0.0007246612,
-0.0044415537,
-0.0261065736,
0.0606724322,
0.0302081089,
-0.0702036098,
-0.0040239003,
-0.0266967118,
0.0190717392,
-0.0146422647,
-0.0462518446,
-0.0666325167,
-0.004617922,
0.0340760797,
0.0081979185,
0.0204808433,
-0.0002303168,
-0.0237635951,
-0.0116213504,
0.0425247848,
0.0212775506,
-0.0385981426,
-0.0237626042,
-0.0111293513,
0.0642902553,
0.0886804312,
-0.0076660751,
0.0214955304,
0.0007361561,
-0.0036352242,
0.0661364868,
0.0270600971,
-0.0017228087,
0.0097331963,
-0.029597817,
0.0501680151,
-0.05916325,
-0.0218595024,
-0.0100907506,
0.0024898513,
-0.0304283183,
-0.0619721934,
0.1029082909,
0.0603654832,
-0.0418597311,
-0.0317161046,
-0.0555794574,
0.0431301706,
-0.002166451,
0.0509641767,
-0.0772622079,
0.0070055053,
0.0156806372,
0.0515857004,
0.0093924534,
-0.0242537856,
0.0042971345,
-0.1326654702,
0.0756923705,
-0.0010528381,
0.0432192124,
0.0030772081,
-0.0365623869,
-0.0296694431,
0.0386122391,
-0.0384664387,
0.0670203716,
0.0049264557,
0.0429152474,
0.0220099259,
0.0164289977,
-0.0340390131,
0.0024969045,
-0.033360973,
-0.0041362159,
0.072894074,
0.0396075062,
0.0269270316,
-0.0428332835,
0.00940968,
-0.0447808467,
-0.0181263108,
-0.0057850424,
0.0331873633,
-0.0178807452,
0.0164922755,
-0.0309330951,
0.0282146595,
-0.023329027,
-0.0092894034,
-0.0085445223,
0.0506077223,
-0.0333488919,
-0.0078877909,
-0.0680341423,
-0.0117807044,
0.0073263175,
0.1052099094,
0.0059182714,
-0.0219346266,
-0.0231172182,
-0.0204986092,
0.0590377264,
-0.0543145537,
-0.0285538342,
0.0167620555,
0.0256251767,
-0.0109426714,
-0.1257412434,
-0.051587794,
-0.0174012557,
0.0046660285,
-0.016554011,
0.0294543616,
-0.0270305965,
-0.0323989578,
-0.0519905239,
0.0124382768,
-0.0318041891,
-0.0376407318,
-0.0585827827,
-0.0221555345,
0.0646998137,
-0.0676459819,
-0.0229779854,
0.0282079596,
-0.0071648909,
-0.0383596011,
-0.0018812969,
0.035520412,
0.0187212154,
0.0538999848,
-0.0335732065,
-0.0193415806,
0.0287751015,
0.0744125471,
-0.067662552,
0.0228770468,
-0.0110162031,
-0.015106691,
-0.020817114,
0.0375033431,
-0.0962411091,
0.0301386006,
-0.0312441718,
0.0743723512,
0.0164496973,
-0.052353587,
0.0418653786,
0.0271904394,
0.0317295194,
-0.0199540798,
0.0178312808,
-0.0509779193,
0.0054847752,
-0.028128257,
-0.0362320766,
-0.0400511436,
0.0157435406,
0.0401840061,
-0.0034031372,
-0.0065275268,
0.0597488917,
0.0115645016,
0.0889585614,
-0.0190139581,
-0.040597517,
-0.0088774171,
0.0093021709,
-0.0137707284,
-0.0207604878,
-0.0399472713,
-0.0028509961,
-0.0213263482,
0.062659502,
-0.0293726884,
0.0332505107,
0.0102263372,
-0.0190841015,
0.0019097717,
0.0057307817,
-0.0698972791,
-0.0197293516,
-0.0465476885,
-0.0068832347,
0.0225274283,
-0.0063533448,
0.0565539524,
-0.0438273959,
-0.0216492862,
-0.0460004136,
0.0003503756,
0.0418062992,
-0.0212086663,
-0.0008723293,
0.0249455646,
-0.0124528948,
-0.0134862978,
0.0904721096,
0.0009946295,
0.0094847521,
-0.0082226181,
-0.0257941969,
-0.0429742336,
-0.0466493405,
-0.0311697777,
0.0107203517,
0.0023537546,
0.0085119102,
-0.0379090756,
-0.0318574049,
0.0176695623,
0.0172627233,
0.0064838841,
-0.0188062321,
0.0441621579,
0.0866043866,
-0.0224457365,
-0.0181115158,
-0.083149761,
0.0576749407,
-0.0535074398,
-0.0194269586,
-0.0205173232,
-6.532434431e-33,
-0.0277785957,
-0.0046630129,
0.0290492978,
-0.0053872252,
0.0047784862,
-0.0162352379,
-0.0401365869,
-0.0134899188,
0.0129397484,
0.0007971257,
-0.015692899,
-0.0075077447,
0.0026063146,
0.0466551632,
-0.0071304492,
0.0217611231,
0.0318424143,
-0.0083647417,
-0.0287951585,
0.0490818731,
0.0792639032,
0.0332098231,
0.0065776138,
-0.0551167876,
0.0213827137,
-0.0481717177,
0.0209333356,
0.000553426,
0.0055886423,
0.0586723164,
-0.0350761227,
0.0432168432,
0.0361562856,
-0.0309277605,
-0.0100048892,
0.0053122155,
-0.1308225989,
-0.0187357068,
-0.0006578869,
-0.0127877714,
-0.0426908694,
-0.0527798645,
0.03400914,
-0.0025062431,
0.0224631596,
-0.0184011534,
0.0444423668,
-0.0261722337,
-0.0339177065,
-0.0785268769,
-0.0470334589,
0.0211614147,
0.0180426501,
0.0056025698,
-0.0169274751,
0.0452516116,
0.0154349878,
0.0525371768,
-0.0567248203,
0.0124253705,
-0.0072698011,
0.0711926222,
0.0301132128,
-0.004150101,
-0.0072615636,
0.0451979339,
-0.0160907321,
-0.0252903514,
-0.023962345,
-0.000979474,
0.0191162191,
0.0356844626,
0.0338874832,
0.0682349727,
0.031252604,
0.0018360229,
-0.0557931885,
0.0873010978,
0.0073578698,
0.0260567199,
0.0217870828,
0.0011191793,
-0.0106712896,
-0.0185848717,
-0.0310036168,
0.0091151809,
-0.0313759036,
-0.0107791536,
0.0617808551,
0.026371412,
-0.0320998169,
-0.0355429836,
0.0481658168,
-0.0166977141,
-0.0210662708,
0.0690134093,
-0.0210096035,
0.0253824145,
-0.0089906035,
0.0294780787,
-0.0446891487,
0.0068053328,
0.0377956443,
-0.0030015016,
-0.0514540486,
0.0316989198,
0.0062342151,
0.0073268227,
-0.0252732579,
0.0144013986,
-0.0273860227,
0.0304617025,
-0.0226676986,
0.0076980912,
0.0064560384,
0.0158266462,
0.0038187758,
0.0320993587,
0.0087043829,
0.0132396547,
-0.0282501522,
-0.0372093543,
0.0112633388,
0.0001892426,
-0.0111203408,
0.0354609452,
-0.0246602688,
0.0418454856,
0.02980561,
-0.0540078878,
0.0071013174,
0.0391989499,
2.827e-7,
0.053183753,
0.0207569506,
0.0406907238,
0.0237117968,
0.0101610692,
0.0146279074,
0.0262364876,
0.0390169807,
0.0482716486,
-0.0304093715,
-0.0303372126,
0.0164868981,
0.0191372819,
0.0205682311,
-0.1049508303,
-0.0071140863,
-0.0388900116,
-0.0001318303,
-0.0292606615,
-0.0353146978,
0.0254741125,
0.0534506701,
-0.0273356996,
-0.0142960837,
-0.0071910643,
-0.0481639467,
0.0956192985,
0.0008470473,
-0.0328965597,
0.0299410392,
0.0877022222,
0.0199793652,
0.0266490169,
-0.0287261922,
-0.0134977521,
0.014055741,
0.0205825549,
0.0303953346,
0.0139769474,
-0.0501636788,
0.0184670668,
-0.0325734839,
0.0154359965,
-0.0633394122,
0.067395106,
-0.0293170512,
0.0301103946,
0.0129497787,
-0.058819361,
0.0123376232,
-0.042902641,
-0.0184670296,
-0.0371690355,
0.0456431285,
0.0114381621,
0.0139780398,
0.0048277904,
-0.0721715167,
-0.0318721123,
-0.0087852618,
-0.063890703,
-0.029754445,
-0.0206967443,
0.0116604315,
-0.0274952054,
-0.0510190353,
0.0166422036,
2.809905599e-34,
0.032581877,
0.0152151706,
-0.0321163796,
0.0044819191,
0.0279654153,
-0.0263361223,
-0.0388121642,
0.0480888709,
0.0099847876,
-0.0878241882,
-0.0220097378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01173v1 | Efficient Prompt Caching via Embedding Similarity | 2024-02-02T06:34:11 | 2024-02-02T06:34:11 | Hanlin Zhu, Banghua Zhu, Jiantao Jiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved huge success in numerous natural
language process (NLP) tasks. However, it faces the challenge of significant
resource consumption during inference. In this paper, we aim to improve the
inference efficiency of LLMs by prompt caching, i.e., if the current prompt can
be answered by the same response of a previous prompt, one can directly utilize
that previous response without calling the LLM. Specifically, we focus on the
prediction accuracy of prompt caching for single-round question-answering tasks
via embedding similarity. The existing embeddings of prompts mostly focus on
whether two prompts are semantically similar, which is not necessarily
equivalent to whether the same response can answer them. Therefore, we propose
a distillation-based method to fine-tune the existing embeddings for better
caching prediction. Theoretically, we provide finite-sample guarantees for the
convergence of our method under different types of loss functions. Empirically,
we carefully construct a hard dataset based on Kwiatkowski et al. (2019) where
the existing embedding model (Wang et al., 2022) only achieves an AUC of 0.51.
We then fine-tune the above embedding model, which significantly improves the
AUC of caching prediction from 0.51 to 0.81. We also conduct simulations
demonstrating that our trained models achieve better caching efficiency than
the previous embedding model. | Efficient Prompt Caching via Embedding Similarity: Large language models (LLMs) have achieved huge success in numerous natural
language process (NLP) tasks. However, it faces the challenge of significant
resource consumption during inference. In this paper, we aim to improve the
inference efficiency of LLMs by prompt caching, i.e., if the current prompt can
be answered by the same response of a previous prompt, one can directly utilize
that previous response without calling the LLM. Specifically, we focus on the
prediction accuracy of prompt caching for single-round question-answering tasks
via embedding similarity. The existing embeddings of prompts mostly focus on
whether two prompts are semantically similar, which is not necessarily
equivalent to whether the same response can answer them. Therefore, we propose
a distillation-based method to fine-tune the existing embeddings for better
caching prediction. Theoretically, we provide finite-sample guarantees for the
convergence of our method under different types of loss functions. Empirically,
we carefully construct a hard dataset based on Kwiatkowski et al. (2019) where
the existing embedding model (Wang et al., 2022) only achieves an AUC of 0.51.
We then fine-tune the above embedding model, which significantly improves the
AUC of caching prediction from 0.51 to 0.81. We also conduct simulations
demonstrating that our trained models achieve better caching efficiency than
the previous embedding model. | [
0.0172155146,
0.036869444,
-0.0022952373,
0.0343423001,
-0.0221224092,
0.0272920039,
0.0136131309,
-0.0168806463,
0.0220319144,
-0.0117250467,
-0.0155244367,
-0.041309379,
-0.0025924216,
-0.0006440836,
0.0120349266,
-0.0095052132,
0.0505703837,
-0.035726238,
0.0132881673,
-0.0151310479,
-0.0076711378,
-0.0043118186,
0.012041728,
0.0407936946,
0.0331983417,
-0.0167785268,
-0.0172396973,
-0.0134074604,
0.0155574484,
-0.0301166065,
0.0297793262,
0.0549947321,
0.0249039717,
0.0371466205,
0.0000020865,
-0.0503876545,
0.0266226809,
-0.0113144796,
-0.0830171108,
0.0186074357,
-0.0037693512,
0.0554483086,
0.0529333465,
0.0387570225,
0.0018418488,
-0.0403634124,
0.0349944271,
0.02773959,
0.0679068789,
0.0328962915,
0.0208949316,
-0.0237314478,
0.0234080963,
-0.0343357325,
0.0101634739,
-0.0443737209,
0.0115389302,
-0.0522642434,
-0.0126500912,
0.0237226058,
-0.0251824744,
0.0418019816,
0.0494830906,
0.0185926091,
-0.0316461846,
0.0562581718,
0.0051473696,
0.0069939326,
0.0055030249,
0.0598832555,
-0.0041437414,
-0.0238723606,
-0.012141183,
-0.0040835356,
0.0273939781,
0.0171917528,
-0.0585105568,
-0.0061807232,
0.0112691261,
0.0006234838,
0.0017907344,
0.0249760114,
-0.0013696498,
-0.0003545363,
-0.013925096,
0.0311271306,
0.0317238756,
-0.0339614674,
0.0038287805,
-0.0038160633,
-0.0136616062,
-0.0465484932,
-0.0109817358,
0.0253933426,
-0.0407175384,
0.0007092275,
-0.0312775783,
0.0254741404,
0.0256497487,
0.0064403694,
0.0603986047,
0.0308466498,
-0.0083399573,
0.0631859973,
-0.0400907472,
0.0638932884,
-0.0073115337,
0.0088842493,
-0.0470751412,
-0.0000235931,
-0.070716992,
-0.0220324378,
-0.0349894948,
0.0386071131,
0.0146871964,
-0.0137814721,
-0.0226488095,
0.0221828744,
-0.0116073806,
0.0384559929,
0.0319326967,
0.031795755,
-0.0094363168,
0.0113889966,
-0.0419600233,
0.0525120832,
-0.0852925405,
0.0164895039,
0.0130607616,
-0.0605160818,
-0.0546173602,
-0.018032901,
0.0357087143,
-0.0396604612,
0.0038377596,
0.0319854617,
-0.0090092625,
-0.0472570397,
-0.0270391908,
-0.0325441808,
0.0077719842,
-0.0675727949,
-0.0166959241,
-0.0534629114,
0.0700591579,
-0.0179786179,
0.0141179021,
-0.0016670007,
-0.0145106576,
0.0515831858,
-0.0105905943,
0.0736753047,
0.0423100293,
0.0103150411,
0.0090146046,
0.0078494297,
-0.0002021682,
0.027386589,
-0.0106180646,
0.0053272122,
0.0395119786,
-0.0322490297,
-0.0153205264,
0.0053053969,
0.0232536476,
0.0002630544,
0.0509622134,
0.0352200344,
0.0400496349,
0.0337346755,
0.0342940353,
0.0228312835,
-0.0290027745,
-0.0665050074,
0.0646436438,
0.0568678826,
-0.0228305738,
-0.0332487114,
0.0380448885,
0.0314272903,
-0.0139468461,
0.0390228927,
-0.0725664571,
0.0316327512,
-0.0006352293,
-0.0026471515,
0.0481728129,
-0.000876378,
-0.0794829577,
-0.0230192877,
0.0252145547,
-0.0127651533,
-0.0179747138,
0.0321720392,
-0.0156398322,
0.0105514415,
-0.0482713431,
0.056659054,
-0.0026093412,
-0.0240522791,
0.0044418187,
-0.028851347,
0.039740786,
0.0355585366,
0.0232635457,
-0.0164801329,
-0.0042423583,
-0.0451400094,
0.025838241,
-0.0194103271,
0.0533552989,
-0.0333875231,
0.0385922082,
-0.0434110649,
-0.0202539843,
-0.0220506527,
-0.0074880077,
0.002278259,
0.0142039694,
0.0244421549,
0.027235359,
-0.0017883439,
0.0170888174,
0.0079035321,
-0.0462775528,
-0.1012003943,
0.0278164726,
0.0161905047,
0.0160936285,
-0.0005312833,
-0.0022261648,
0.034055952,
0.0174333137,
-0.0594336241,
-0.0354614072,
-0.0063723521,
-0.079881534,
-0.0829751119,
0.0021888269,
0.0091246199,
-0.0008531073,
0.0382631645,
-0.0649340749,
-0.0572807007,
-0.0437491164,
-0.0259878021,
0.0410904698,
-0.0268039331,
0.0298654474,
0.011309525,
0.0123061519,
-0.0381015763,
0.0570815057,
-0.0483400822,
0.0612241216,
0.006345252,
0.0381684825,
0.0206711646,
-0.0282746516,
-0.0605650991,
0.0061202468,
-0.0137941809,
-0.0153550161,
0.050693471,
-0.0060966634,
-0.0417905562,
0.0049794633,
-0.0752974302,
0.0213806909,
-0.006594908,
0.0067306478,
0.0015706859,
0.0180602558,
0.0111253615,
-0.0404699668,
-0.0372738019,
-0.0298239142,
-0.0020607109,
0.0778674409,
0.0227576327,
0.0077700908,
-0.0164217483,
-0.0323274583,
-0.0330410898,
0.0172474422,
0.0467702597,
-0.0522351712,
0.03619764,
-0.0454003364,
0.0439376533,
-0.0005041529,
0.0166601557,
0.0096949963,
0.0063116369,
-0.0064967046,
0.0010815597,
0.0243806262,
0.0703787506,
0.0083580725,
-0.0257154852,
0.0153689981,
-0.002047362,
-0.0599980019,
0.0115384096,
-0.0363942198,
-0.0551193096,
0.0047513437,
-0.0299812425,
0.0141922738,
0.0885418355,
0.0349803269,
0.0038601062,
-0.0401273929,
-0.0076528522,
-0.0178798158,
-0.0090978276,
-0.0763881207,
0.0014025511,
-0.0241356846,
-0.0027718234,
-0.022494521,
-0.0558722578,
0.09438508,
-0.032537654,
0.0077126641,
-0.0235758536,
-0.0249778815,
-0.0186579376,
0.0658524409,
0.0217163637,
-0.0012689722,
0.0065856744,
-0.0210079532,
-0.0716203228,
0.0040546488,
0.0255601052,
-0.0424284525,
0.0205950066,
0.0049912464,
-0.0100630401,
-0.0191911273,
-0.0727242976,
-0.0722502694,
-0.0445021503,
-0.004261157,
0.0174568482,
-0.0337307453,
0.0028586951,
-0.0015407325,
-0.0065436154,
0.0005083649,
0.0301583,
-0.0265098494,
-0.011086612,
-0.0429918319,
0.0805483907,
0.0809081495,
0.0112529416,
0.0009100153,
0.0039796736,
0.0643605217,
0.0539756604,
0.0817344263,
0.032665886,
-0.0038113566,
-0.0086956583,
0.0387270972,
-0.036299862,
-0.0178578701,
0.0368539169,
0.0412019417,
-0.0481815077,
-0.0195644125,
0.1248283386,
0.0415781699,
-0.0378580131,
0.0003409537,
0.005565817,
0.0499744788,
0.0446763709,
-0.007420972,
-0.049910292,
-0.0457498729,
0.0211471822,
0.0187097192,
-0.0006238231,
-0.0407842509,
0.0004852249,
-0.1415765136,
-0.0066754958,
-0.0157276969,
0.0171324536,
-0.0449468568,
-0.0478061587,
-0.0037676906,
0.0101719182,
0.0202327706,
0.0045899637,
-0.0070841336,
-0.0147387488,
0.0160766076,
-0.018276725,
-0.0223507285,
0.0542800762,
-0.0399895348,
0.0287572443,
0.0325428173,
0.0199761316,
0.0240540877,
-0.0432784297,
0.0169547368,
-0.0698985755,
-0.0008745447,
0.0053454353,
0.0417002328,
0.0108545339,
0.0074087,
-0.020648919,
0.0421702079,
-0.0350257568,
-0.0136093283,
0.0232272577,
0.0807838589,
-0.0197199639,
-0.0357682481,
0.0064134113,
-0.0246806927,
-0.0008253552,
0.1055488363,
0.0304151587,
-0.0302682742,
-0.0469479226,
0.0006845381,
0.026436409,
-0.0031871272,
-0.0071016094,
0.0091701513,
0.0317371413,
0.0366545729,
-0.0307885297,
-0.0362783186,
0.0124073112,
0.0112596462,
-0.0321314447,
0.0218066256,
-0.0143485656,
-0.0081523024,
-0.038787242,
0.0315182433,
-0.0680758879,
0.0508180074,
-0.0297407806,
0.0126298936,
0.0366313569,
0.0361963734,
-0.0394728035,
0.0046812426,
-0.1291229129,
-0.0432915203,
-0.0279894974,
0.0491612814,
0.0080531007,
0.0400938988,
-0.0090051433,
-0.0615642369,
0.0607246123,
-0.0266466085,
-0.0510173775,
0.0162374172,
-0.0066159577,
0.0298077185,
-0.0127796093,
0.0407546684,
-0.0343005545,
-0.0133201759,
0.010664586,
0.0423455276,
-0.0169940609,
-0.0539062768,
0.0250477195,
0.0112805869,
0.0205944981,
0.0304118451,
0.0045291167,
-0.0307083223,
0.0477118157,
0.0441990495,
-0.0087239919,
-0.0060526486,
0.0044033118,
0.0409722626,
-0.0412918925,
0.0062847282,
-0.0189529676,
0.02290361,
0.043069873,
-0.0584142283,
-0.0327242725,
0.0236371867,
0.0040484611,
0.0248166397,
0.0143315112,
-0.0511482619,
0.0041442397,
0.0053589703,
0.0311612505,
-0.0290716253,
0.057440117,
0.00405723,
0.0308386311,
-0.0110051045,
0.0132018132,
-0.0776121691,
-0.061634656,
0.0004236968,
0.0141736837,
0.0250290371,
-0.0325678028,
-0.0289769433,
-0.0005080699,
0.001012523,
-0.0315903164,
-0.0062720473,
0.0144851804,
-0.0238509569,
0.058800023,
0.0419512279,
-0.0125027178,
-0.0017107876,
0.0848380923,
-0.0110113928,
0.05394255,
-0.02450235,
0.0002979547,
-0.0503979661,
-0.038898237,
-0.0145817399,
0.056026794,
0.005361537,
0.0181076117,
-0.0453663543,
-0.0708843842,
-0.024494255,
-0.0133763282,
-0.0188704915,
-0.0091998046,
0.0372193381,
0.0159097034,
-0.0033224653,
-0.0385420434,
-0.0161867235,
0.0235002525,
-0.0066061434,
-0.0454260744,
-0.0358015187,
-6.340223472e-33,
-0.017111646,
-0.0055130119,
0.0177613851,
-0.0293720383,
-0.0151114212,
0.0106389858,
-0.0188419633,
-0.0304227956,
-0.0450117253,
-0.0089858435,
-0.0381319188,
-0.0031551986,
0.0180762894,
0.0337088779,
-0.0058370186,
-0.0553182587,
0.0770043805,
-0.0133267185,
-0.0252240505,
0.0534364209,
0.0506406128,
0.0133083016,
-0.0051766895,
0.0116000641,
0.0032085429,
-0.0109992037,
0.0342923924,
0.0357345082,
-0.0169838909,
0.03152005,
-0.0299812704,
0.0663694814,
0.0408540219,
-0.0403892361,
-0.0143545279,
0.0615283959,
-0.0963136777,
-0.0750620365,
-0.0076962863,
-0.0300796852,
-0.0371033214,
-0.0151612572,
-0.0143051585,
-0.0184189938,
0.0167147964,
-0.0015804633,
-0.0028417315,
0.0160745028,
-0.030268129,
0.0152892629,
-0.0141870333,
-0.0030539613,
-0.011739675,
-0.0356516019,
-0.0081244027,
0.0738933384,
0.0354321636,
0.0208175518,
-0.0763250589,
-0.0096301604,
-0.0422010943,
0.0778197721,
0.028843591,
0.0085244523,
0.0135731315,
0.044486925,
0.0067141522,
-0.0183881857,
-0.0043110312,
0.0017949664,
0.0055725817,
0.0281941872,
0.0272422694,
-0.0022402976,
0.0503785722,
-0.0263840631,
-0.0139457723,
0.0309892315,
0.0315103233,
0.0743990615,
0.04769779,
-0.0039012467,
-0.0179789625,
-0.0546496995,
-0.0975402817,
0.0359605476,
-0.0297837183,
0.0220612455,
0.0686289519,
0.0475163646,
-0.0108611211,
-0.0299088843,
0.0620933026,
-0.0283534322,
0.0054207826,
0.0404006802,
0.0091868583,
0.0002698596,
0.0131532988,
0.0366307795,
-0.0446169898,
-0.0015669136,
0.0009753242,
-0.0423289202,
-0.0035486221,
0.012798477,
0.0157065876,
0.009151387,
-0.0948714614,
0.0018887818,
-0.049500607,
0.0258237645,
-0.0102883447,
-0.0071587982,
0.0420528427,
0.0200632866,
-0.0029697849,
0.0383479558,
-0.0022716473,
-0.0275333468,
-0.0037085165,
-0.0126603534,
0.0037680054,
0.0126836682,
0.002138169,
0.0091469064,
-0.0402550399,
0.0360087417,
0.0106718205,
-0.0419514775,
0.0051628975,
0.0237337351,
2.656e-7,
0.004052625,
-0.0272446647,
0.0146832289,
0.0385600626,
0.0117359683,
0.0366340093,
0.020292826,
0.0459378697,
0.0071130036,
-0.0408630185,
-0.0163935479,
0.0239310954,
0.0361832716,
0.0234406888,
-0.0982640162,
0.0069032693,
-0.100793235,
0.0182032231,
-0.0513524562,
-0.0414005406,
0.0422090739,
0.1126480997,
0.0178654641,
-0.0191671271,
0.0108142169,
-0.02308481,
0.040921092,
-0.0169834178,
-0.0057178801,
0.0102427239,
0.017801078,
-0.010758765,
0.0317902863,
0.0243813787,
-0.0256747268,
0.0171346851,
-0.0011921399,
0.0459440723,
0.0417870358,
-0.0533226207,
-0.0333150588,
-0.027019687,
-0.0057800109,
-0.0494553335,
0.1024660841,
-0.0506956205,
-0.0166284423,
-0.0644317865,
0.0177806448,
-0.0086906618,
0.0649349838,
0.0049348711,
-0.0289403666,
0.0235310905,
0.0178397894,
0.0119470395,
0.0026307963,
-0.0846844763,
-0.0111547764,
-0.0110695576,
-0.0571469367,
-0.0492949411,
-0.0558898896,
-0.0288848989,
0.0155170979,
-0.0463888235,
-0.0089557646,
2.605781464e-34,
0.0238229074,
0.0005961985,
0.0575034283,
0.0353951789,
0.0351913981,
-0.0222073663,
-0.000333524,
0.0183634441,
0.0454795472,
-0.100477457,
-0.0266227853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01172v1 | Streaming Sequence Transduction through Dynamic Compression | 2024-02-02T06:31:50 | 2024-02-02T06:31:50 | Weiting Tan, Yunmo Chen, Tongfei Chen, Guanghui Qin, Haoran Xu, Heidi C. Zhang, Benjamin Van Durme, Philipp Koehn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce STAR (Stream Transduction with Anchor Representations), a novel
Transformer-based model designed for efficient sequence-to-sequence
transduction over streams. STAR dynamically segments input streams to create
compressed anchor representations, achieving nearly lossless compression (12x)
in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) and outperforming existing methods.
Moreover, STAR demonstrates superior segmentation and latency-quality
trade-offs in simultaneous speech-to-text tasks, optimizing latency, memory
footprint, and quality. | Streaming Sequence Transduction through Dynamic Compression: We introduce STAR (Stream Transduction with Anchor Representations), a novel
Transformer-based model designed for efficient sequence-to-sequence
transduction over streams. STAR dynamically segments input streams to create
compressed anchor representations, achieving nearly lossless compression (12x)
in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) and outperforming existing methods.
Moreover, STAR demonstrates superior segmentation and latency-quality
trade-offs in simultaneous speech-to-text tasks, optimizing latency, memory
footprint, and quality. | [
-0.0478401072,
0.0253870822,
-0.0005783228,
-0.027182918,
-0.0218983293,
-0.0109532028,
0.0155307893,
-0.0076882681,
-0.0562526919,
0.0033001765,
-0.0024900171,
-0.0439474583,
0.0448593386,
0.0666727498,
0.0200953893,
-0.0726904869,
0.046039965,
-0.0240586754,
-0.0154756978,
0.0158290248,
0.0247474294,
0.0080030449,
0.000291594,
0.025981918,
0.0179129764,
0.0188715849,
-0.0375298783,
-0.0271863304,
0.025967842,
-0.0268317964,
-0.0468693748,
0.0107778208,
0.0591411702,
0.0157166645,
0.000001879,
0.0224521235,
-0.03600448,
-0.0008008227,
-0.0605967641,
0.0165054612,
-0.0150377546,
-0.0725311935,
-0.0311288796,
0.0412277579,
0.0219013859,
-0.0373962335,
0.0451430082,
0.006620002,
0.0441248827,
0.0380560718,
-0.0213952269,
-0.0534414947,
0.0703569576,
-0.0243619569,
-0.0267236494,
0.0093973642,
-0.0214346517,
-0.0140939197,
-0.02949683,
0.0057482794,
-0.0548756048,
0.0394240655,
0.0309171993,
-0.0180771351,
0.031436462,
-0.0011062485,
-0.0647065267,
-0.0408646166,
-0.0339565538,
0.0331600383,
-0.0603360906,
-0.0383880362,
0.0087889256,
-0.0027055163,
-0.0094638225,
-0.0678934678,
-0.0312182363,
0.0411663055,
0.001149006,
0.0159885865,
0.0094917063,
0.0086447848,
0.0198630989,
-0.0485786609,
-0.0128090633,
-0.0426908843,
-0.0012259213,
-0.0168061107,
-0.0454559028,
0.0021578609,
-0.0175668467,
0.0002214503,
0.0617950447,
-0.0084616514,
-0.0223879069,
0.0072748009,
-0.0544956326,
-0.0465553813,
-0.0278356206,
-0.0133094909,
0.0895596221,
0.0629659742,
0.0154540548,
-0.0070449552,
-0.0299826134,
0.0570043065,
-0.0071352734,
-0.0264921356,
-0.0235649887,
0.001379066,
-0.0182333943,
-0.0114984475,
-0.0340238698,
0.0394067392,
-0.0416407026,
-0.0397336297,
-0.0215543658,
0.0206694454,
0.0271460824,
-0.0330658667,
0.0128227053,
-0.0132710598,
-0.0409784503,
-0.003865547,
0.074769713,
0.0929790139,
-0.0047892346,
0.0151676051,
0.0338526145,
-0.0282478314,
-0.0266180225,
0.0217090882,
0.0239953008,
0.0003180045,
-0.0103425682,
-0.0229516737,
-0.0086934464,
-0.0415446311,
0.0000820273,
0.0019191748,
0.0130080916,
-0.0166984275,
0.0179230329,
-0.0375153683,
0.0398349278,
0.010114735,
-0.0101272557,
-0.0404812023,
0.0052811848,
0.0320003293,
0.0041688732,
0.0273843519,
0.0234663803,
-0.013068663,
0.0191181991,
0.0004644874,
0.0318001844,
0.0411515236,
0.0523921475,
-0.0075660772,
-0.0160550978,
-0.0416861214,
-0.0432533138,
0.0370580778,
0.0139614595,
-0.0240207817,
-0.0546455272,
-0.0164046083,
-0.0031732833,
0.020559147,
0.0597224571,
0.0662939772,
-0.0314487964,
-0.0391134918,
0.0445604622,
0.0932439566,
0.0525253415,
0.069097355,
0.0342822894,
0.0368174575,
-0.0218797866,
-0.0147406161,
0.0467960425,
0.0586286336,
0.0466421433,
0.0304616466,
0.0233365446,
0.0547055602,
-0.0179996621,
0.0100334454,
-0.0278008282,
-0.0159958769,
-0.0196595415,
-0.0115162246,
-0.0090139974,
0.0230166577,
-0.067028217,
0.0831073374,
-0.0627196655,
-0.0778056756,
0.0020591826,
-0.0242835712,
-0.0438914672,
0.018565556,
0.0090191653,
0.0068158838,
-0.0207567979,
-0.049586039,
0.0157661717,
-0.0060469257,
0.0068967291,
0.0179391298,
0.0274025854,
-0.0452497341,
0.0095665762,
0.0611301698,
0.0076649389,
0.0712892115,
0.0007769043,
0.0212834179,
0.0306412634,
0.0045085191,
0.0256924424,
-0.0103997895,
-0.0088037644,
-0.0208939295,
0.0324124247,
-0.0162495244,
0.0361863151,
0.0084780548,
-0.004179473,
0.0176952779,
0.0601768456,
-0.0388874374,
0.0134863649,
0.0557780154,
-0.0820114538,
-0.0132934637,
-0.0063942042,
-0.0396943986,
0.0284174979,
0.0737320483,
0.0277144741,
-0.0826202184,
0.0289931204,
-0.0442477725,
0.0336645953,
-0.032485541,
0.0302985217,
0.0473516211,
0.0377970785,
0.0410898216,
-0.0282777995,
-0.0072744391,
0.0067534372,
0.0011151045,
-0.0197703484,
-0.0465299189,
-0.0614238828,
0.0094138701,
0.0120231332,
-0.0193481408,
-0.0164005235,
0.0085811913,
-0.05079313,
0.0040651131,
-0.0050900267,
-0.005038748,
0.0021883373,
-0.0063890214,
0.0569581613,
-0.0205309782,
0.0575001314,
0.0260701664,
0.0315198265,
-0.0379387289,
-0.0394964777,
0.0184603501,
0.0119333882,
-0.0215769093,
-0.0101718577,
-0.0368018299,
0.0096916873,
-0.0371832065,
0.010235751,
0.0443752669,
-0.0224807728,
-0.0344322063,
-0.082397759,
-0.0502478071,
0.0801916495,
0.0074745924,
-0.0010575496,
-0.0136768892,
-0.0279575493,
0.0008621411,
0.0317964181,
0.029030785,
0.0010304844,
-0.0129988194,
-0.000895337,
-0.0064231525,
-0.0144391051,
-0.0082433149,
-0.0078661721,
0.0729973093,
0.0090546617,
0.022176601,
-0.0058510252,
0.0476080403,
-0.0058043948,
0.0118966056,
-0.0407496467,
-0.0679533333,
0.0251871608,
-0.0104633151,
-0.0125136478,
-0.0828298852,
-0.043671038,
0.0023170398,
-0.0057797339,
-0.0352723859,
0.0213751886,
-0.0543627217,
-0.0535900667,
-0.0069077159,
-0.0164759047,
-0.0433255695,
0.0378084294,
-0.0012367863,
-0.0069681322,
-0.0043965373,
-0.0413252302,
-0.0093900571,
0.0778449103,
-0.0305924416,
-0.0472397096,
0.0299557578,
-0.0052886591,
-0.0395990312,
-0.0269774385,
-0.0195138194,
-0.0136001827,
0.0116583593,
0.0063720415,
0.042780187,
0.0710439235,
-0.0373353399,
-0.063341476,
0.0584873855,
-0.0020622828,
0.0427599177,
0.0145262694,
0.0130066052,
-0.0233013835,
0.0456265695,
-0.0244354978,
0.0198261943,
0.0245127361,
0.0505840667,
0.036842078,
0.023973003,
0.102848433,
-0.0009680864,
-0.0092675621,
0.0211590398,
0.0503437817,
0.0025699579,
-0.0318986438,
0.0184009429,
0.0260176379,
-0.0785806924,
-0.0088046668,
0.0704864338,
0.0350988209,
-0.0102356784,
-0.0131691592,
0.0092843324,
0.0468874499,
-0.0097175399,
0.0130752502,
-0.0465499423,
-0.0214398,
0.0264543816,
0.0205529332,
0.0500003882,
0.0124607915,
-0.0187463481,
-0.0638626069,
0.0196586251,
0.0369143635,
0.0041015577,
-0.033095181,
-0.0626922622,
-0.0405751914,
0.0026233317,
0.0071042525,
0.019858649,
-0.0160335023,
-0.0210256986,
0.0257148854,
-0.0636924729,
-0.0239330307,
-0.0006734254,
-0.0000173,
0.0685299262,
0.0685698166,
0.0129478658,
0.0304402784,
-0.0188104734,
0.0202876199,
-0.0320933647,
-0.0083546592,
0.0051446487,
-0.0329612456,
-0.0009724904,
0.0040825116,
0.0418785103,
0.032476671,
-0.0258935262,
0.0135910371,
-0.0451261401,
0.0725456998,
0.0201289095,
0.0131425466,
-0.0089957826,
-0.0066271536,
-0.0340224542,
0.0509229004,
-0.0119983619,
0.0118830903,
-0.0320391059,
-0.0129991546,
0.0335206613,
-0.0160593186,
-0.0635852888,
-0.0032596856,
0.0344814546,
-0.1062252745,
-0.0338301919,
0.0258489884,
0.0012334518,
0.0170530453,
-0.0001327233,
0.0169678889,
0.0432318337,
0.0147255762,
-0.0586118922,
-0.0153228659,
-0.0035728544,
0.0170518197,
-0.0736117065,
0.0004175755,
0.0405186117,
-0.0225263648,
-0.0161898471,
0.0539245233,
-0.0941252857,
-0.0276627745,
0.0247718208,
-0.0083028255,
0.0138841039,
0.0370897874,
-0.0059676613,
0.0338784792,
-0.0041124434,
0.0366957448,
-0.0354418978,
0.0131200273,
0.0454522073,
-0.0563827418,
-0.0002359613,
0.0184971821,
-0.021540612,
-0.0005131701,
-0.0614315383,
0.0224382263,
-0.0224376712,
-0.0010009103,
0.0033550544,
0.0228332952,
0.0495436229,
0.0099483272,
0.0155194551,
0.0471615754,
0.0585125238,
-0.0017644482,
0.0808907747,
-0.0368466116,
0.0227787085,
0.0130139114,
0.015010044,
0.0041988576,
0.0355013683,
0.0213953834,
-0.0749062225,
-0.0126980226,
0.0458958112,
0.0222639255,
-0.0404675975,
0.003612238,
-0.0060601691,
-0.0141503867,
-0.0178436283,
0.0369831212,
0.0278213415,
-0.0673275441,
0.0019426323,
-0.0051956116,
0.0519569851,
0.0207032897,
0.0272416212,
-0.0435546413,
0.0416044332,
-0.0434826165,
0.037967898,
0.013563931,
0.0117596174,
0.0343842655,
-0.0263531841,
0.0368099548,
-0.0298122335,
0.0336386003,
-0.0546867736,
-0.0486295484,
-0.0151301362,
0.01279011,
-0.0114498669,
0.0027432949,
0.0361984894,
0.0078679621,
0.0185899921,
-0.0025483274,
-0.0131700207,
-0.01719792,
-0.0341096334,
-0.0728647634,
-0.0170592051,
-0.0096521527,
-0.0346881412,
-0.0118506933,
-0.0447471887,
0.0478338003,
-0.0336227044,
0.0668780357,
-0.0520004183,
-0.0013555392,
0.0107029695,
-0.0217018425,
0.0024927841,
0.0144078704,
-0.0308940355,
-0.0208369717,
-0.0240058377,
0.0165669192,
-6.001196943e-33,
0.0024845628,
0.0444223583,
-0.0014537575,
-0.0116190035,
-0.0385985896,
0.0354053788,
-0.0168850571,
-0.0033294316,
0.0200798828,
-0.0510812402,
-0.0279876348,
0.0260820258,
0.0305103473,
0.035566356,
0.0007611746,
-0.0063869371,
0.0902596414,
-0.0344564877,
0.0026719638,
0.0330887288,
0.0032901934,
0.0224633683,
-0.000559422,
0.0130890058,
-0.0597760826,
0.0040578507,
0.0200720876,
-0.0604816899,
0.0542444959,
0.0228927173,
0.0205410421,
0.020252794,
-0.0243446194,
-0.0881847292,
-0.0376847759,
0.0601837225,
-0.1133116186,
0.0226661935,
-0.0045043845,
0.0144112296,
0.0053300229,
-0.0198896695,
0.0078992052,
0.0059102215,
0.0047744066,
-0.0509242974,
-0.0340475552,
-0.0142361885,
-0.0532858074,
-0.075866282,
-0.0070987083,
0.0292941369,
-0.0388979465,
-0.0049867807,
0.0653337091,
0.0685288161,
-0.0305723418,
-0.0717873871,
-0.0532293916,
0.0570301563,
0.0286907423,
0.0752038881,
0.0242657512,
-0.0203783643,
0.016810514,
-0.0298179779,
0.0291400068,
-0.0814409181,
0.0051996298,
0.0813982785,
0.0227883626,
-0.0180026181,
0.0469927639,
-0.0297673997,
0.0684539825,
-0.0614883676,
-0.0200343635,
-0.0103326133,
0.0385402106,
0.0027479299,
0.0414932407,
0.0505256318,
-0.0130371647,
0.006185187,
-0.0174703114,
-0.0143257985,
-0.0075023803,
-0.0111092543,
0.0454291031,
0.0389787406,
-0.0009275289,
0.0549953468,
0.0908964574,
0.0028065604,
0.0333735459,
0.0057822256,
-0.0045174342,
0.0245837104,
-0.0076769707,
0.0119805289,
-0.0354825594,
-0.0109822182,
0.0647702962,
0.0234919377,
-0.002419099,
-0.013099459,
0.0150888469,
0.0721991211,
-0.0545818508,
-0.0254508201,
-0.0019476269,
0.0366606116,
-0.0190990381,
-0.0076597631,
0.0515345484,
-0.013220543,
0.0096558137,
0.0267259404,
-0.048683919,
0.0231543295,
-0.01128574,
0.0112503264,
-0.0150284115,
0.0603784621,
-0.0403872058,
0.0056467955,
-0.0339442305,
0.0213183183,
0.0550402552,
-0.0420997962,
-0.0330309682,
0.0385124981,
2.653e-7,
-0.0375946239,
0.0483828224,
0.0362013802,
-0.0432093069,
0.0173902586,
-0.0250692628,
0.0150512662,
0.0334262736,
0.0310678091,
0.0333634168,
-0.0099620149,
-0.0306719597,
0.0547389723,
0.0234598182,
-0.1337790638,
-0.0487635285,
-0.0651750416,
0.0343586802,
-0.0061989278,
-0.0014522929,
-0.00311505,
0.0894755721,
-0.057385847,
-0.0216643736,
0.0531513207,
-0.0071279258,
0.0075073605,
0.0297202673,
0.055785913,
-0.0591920018,
-0.0185416341,
-0.0152447866,
-0.0397220291,
-0.020252578,
-0.0389060751,
0.0056633279,
0.0113362633,
0.0545368344,
0.008091528,
-0.0696611777,
0.0074761827,
0.0358169377,
-0.0363849849,
0.0472420678,
0.044347018,
-0.0110636298,
-0.0036520574,
-0.0080628907,
-0.0516630039,
0.0273145176,
-0.0427736901,
0.0160225052,
0.0297694039,
0.020178657,
0.0119063593,
-0.005584856,
-0.0061125029,
-0.041376058,
-0.0093795201,
-0.0232896805,
-0.0372025892,
0.0024843982,
-0.069762215,
0.0058389124,
0.0219896063,
0.0040207207,
-0.0693870187,
2.716831013e-34,
0.0047295936,
-0.0234664585,
0.0070351013,
0.0269341748,
0.0030356543,
-0.0404160954,
0.0122690182,
0.0413994789,
-0.0203359928,
-0.0556383729,
-0.0793223828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01799v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01799v2 | Faster and Lighter LLMs: A Survey on Current Challenges and Way Forward | 2024-02-02T06:29:34 | 2024-04-24T04:58:46 | Arnav Chavan, Raghav Magazine, Shubham Kushwaha, Mérouane Debbah, Deepak Gupta | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the impressive performance of LLMs, their widespread adoption faces
challenges due to substantial computational and memory requirements during
inference. Recent advancements in model compression and system-level
optimization methods aim to enhance LLM inference. This survey offers an
overview of these methods, emphasizing recent developments. Through experiments
on LLaMA(/2)-7B, we evaluate various compression techniques, providing
practical insights for efficient LLM deployment in a unified setting. The
empirical analysis on LLaMA(/2)-7B highlights the effectiveness of these
methods. Drawing from survey insights, we identify current limitations and
discuss potential future directions to improve LLM inference efficiency. We
release the codebase to reproduce the results presented in this paper at
https://github.com/nyunAI/Faster-LLM-Survey | Faster and Lighter LLMs: A Survey on Current Challenges and Way Forward: Despite the impressive performance of LLMs, their widespread adoption faces
challenges due to substantial computational and memory requirements during
inference. Recent advancements in model compression and system-level
optimization methods aim to enhance LLM inference. This survey offers an
overview of these methods, emphasizing recent developments. Through experiments
on LLaMA(/2)-7B, we evaluate various compression techniques, providing
practical insights for efficient LLM deployment in a unified setting. The
empirical analysis on LLaMA(/2)-7B highlights the effectiveness of these
methods. Drawing from survey insights, we identify current limitations and
discuss potential future directions to improve LLM inference efficiency. We
release the codebase to reproduce the results presented in this paper at
https://github.com/nyunAI/Faster-LLM-Survey | [
-0.0542043522,
0.048993703,
-0.0052427533,
0.0578835569,
-0.0345442556,
-0.0229820255,
-0.0072522764,
0.0285519864,
-0.0062797708,
0.019763669,
-0.0008341146,
0.0168181378,
0.0136247575,
-0.0274963453,
0.031855505,
0.0358672328,
0.0221842956,
-0.0220442917,
-0.0516858958,
-0.0363561399,
-0.0424506739,
-0.0320151933,
0.0373888873,
-0.0031467483,
0.0288559571,
0.0155246612,
-0.0307891872,
0.0568311997,
0.0152552752,
-0.0186467785,
-0.0305472668,
0.028119158,
0.0331589617,
0.0077420408,
0.0000021155,
-0.0127178924,
0.0179084446,
0.039214205,
-0.0364161283,
0.0741017833,
0.0279385839,
0.0166643597,
-0.0079066539,
0.0194317866,
0.0474429727,
0.0090461411,
0.0599518903,
-0.0131782778,
-0.0222916584,
0.017005058,
0.0326240472,
0.0067319619,
0.0191397853,
-0.0286934692,
0.0077082333,
-0.018556755,
0.0109836012,
-0.0121260164,
0.018586142,
-0.0108506,
0.0022907997,
0.0022489675,
0.0295564681,
-0.0029229375,
-0.0197333153,
0.0098924702,
0.0274744984,
0.0001031689,
-0.0170910638,
0.031727843,
0.0082561383,
-0.0456886292,
-0.0046263812,
-0.0142206252,
-0.0449518263,
-0.0027420018,
-0.0405476242,
0.0320594162,
-0.0011940432,
0.0275052581,
0.0161309186,
0.0007682104,
0.0579231903,
-0.0126489447,
-0.0254937429,
0.0780450776,
0.049601011,
0.028411651,
-0.0153617812,
0.0043766471,
-0.0007500915,
-0.0549507588,
-0.0156779885,
0.0024526231,
0.0176139846,
-0.0187119134,
-0.0379364826,
0.0126160001,
0.0194710102,
-0.0272517707,
0.0945440531,
0.0583170727,
0.0056611202,
-0.0037877464,
-0.0556439497,
-0.0223752353,
-0.056747023,
0.0033615029,
-0.0218461603,
0.0164619368,
0.0483136475,
0.0213776324,
0.0188570935,
0.0504817702,
-0.0434271879,
0.0251545571,
-0.0421355441,
0.0132898502,
0.0178507082,
-0.0256496761,
0.0033196798,
-0.0058153812,
0.0020530657,
0.0087459972,
-0.0219978206,
-0.0070625371,
-0.0401829742,
0.0246194024,
-0.0057939701,
-0.0397905335,
-0.0499960333,
0.0282872152,
-0.0306657571,
-0.0098109096,
0.0550952144,
0.0703357756,
0.0148763442,
-0.0563470386,
-0.055281613,
-0.0121868905,
0.0276273582,
-0.0553501472,
0.0425471701,
-0.0697080046,
0.0470818393,
-0.0367736332,
-0.0002690054,
-0.0106338151,
0.0150330625,
-0.0149591686,
-0.0081477035,
0.0434221625,
-0.0082234982,
-0.0138701834,
-0.00687285,
0.0381816216,
0.006480502,
0.0969707519,
0.0164206438,
0.0539956987,
-0.010365963,
0.0036702706,
-0.0178891234,
0.039598994,
0.0662455484,
0.0133985253,
-0.0417680778,
-0.0217691492,
-0.032694377,
0.0106892558,
0.050210122,
0.0048134634,
-0.0236745141,
-0.0407407768,
-0.0053251311,
0.0471359938,
0.0262957755,
0.0267312974,
0.0002235576,
-0.0233590957,
0.0369227491,
-0.0090862457,
-0.0530888774,
0.0735879391,
-0.0742444545,
0.0117440708,
0.0511474237,
0.0652031675,
-0.0209126081,
-0.0473085754,
-0.061470069,
-0.0231668353,
-0.0353108644,
0.0051060612,
0.0111075146,
-0.0324954838,
-0.016051596,
0.106807299,
0.0535188168,
-0.0833115354,
-0.1040822864,
-0.1042086333,
0.0513570122,
-0.0102720791,
0.0237436984,
-0.0187972914,
-0.0500059351,
0.0562078916,
-0.0052914727,
-0.005189619,
-0.0174898766,
0.0297204349,
0.0444243439,
-0.0156699605,
-0.0072089778,
-0.0059284093,
0.0263866074,
0.0224388,
0.0481431186,
-0.0325156301,
0.0134893386,
-0.0566525534,
-0.0072060376,
0.0075843153,
-0.0146363629,
0.0094054379,
0.0544441603,
-0.0046725948,
0.0442277826,
-0.0224357042,
-0.0102121104,
-0.0345657729,
0.0776178539,
-0.0536446199,
0.0015179839,
-0.0477319509,
0.0001371514,
-0.0447895192,
0.0404598266,
-0.0278104879,
0.0337362476,
0.0142255044,
-0.0642637089,
-0.020824261,
0.0096138911,
-0.0298372135,
0.0117481779,
-0.0462392941,
-0.0029302319,
-0.0023439121,
0.0335537195,
0.0085282894,
0.0359107964,
-0.0640390366,
-0.0247177407,
0.0577327274,
0.0007760607,
0.0167212449,
0.0080932062,
0.0089640934,
-0.0071304352,
0.0152939707,
-0.0332262926,
-0.0363273397,
0.0045564966,
0.0422823504,
-0.0143257705,
-0.0276034772,
0.0470412076,
-0.0087945042,
0.040350534,
0.0222132783,
0.0184981171,
-0.003712547,
0.0426852405,
0.0298654381,
0.0358803645,
-0.0196734965,
-0.0137584247,
0.010999606,
-0.0295395367,
-0.0698065609,
-0.0180939808,
-0.0386756137,
0.0042161536,
0.0448331088,
-0.0664878264,
-0.0393730514,
-0.0307581425,
0.061256893,
-0.0109161921,
0.0005736029,
-0.0327734612,
-0.0171847735,
-0.0188127756,
-0.0239872076,
0.0028237163,
0.0706618279,
-0.0480808355,
0.0283758119,
0.0715819076,
0.0179739688,
-0.0399752818,
0.0205243025,
0.0124160666,
-0.0210330784,
0.0032479938,
-0.0542082973,
-0.0497520193,
0.072973147,
-0.0483609997,
-0.0211329795,
-0.0001285282,
-0.0388040133,
0.0511873811,
-0.0664801747,
0.0284007117,
0.027991401,
-0.0114430292,
0.0291846693,
0.0236908775,
-0.0610844865,
0.0265544765,
-0.0707841665,
0.0179190151,
0.0350493714,
-0.0540000647,
-0.0477306619,
0.017248854,
0.0030075936,
0.0353810452,
-0.0377012491,
0.0360270143,
0.0178431328,
0.0154472869,
0.0058595431,
-0.0198377185,
0.023669824,
-0.0110438112,
0.0117115211,
-0.0249880217,
-0.0289008319,
0.0332113132,
0.0476082116,
-0.0088381618,
0.0100938883,
-0.020253215,
-0.0307674035,
0.0077714934,
-0.0008408224,
0.0003338636,
-0.0279249214,
-0.024217315,
-0.0090374025,
-0.0288326759,
-0.004264643,
-0.0233721435,
0.0100086862,
0.0848317444,
-0.0182850789,
0.0098476913,
0.0339192338,
0.0013600304,
0.0345787331,
-0.0706197396,
-0.0277092271,
0.0626920164,
0.0140465563,
-0.0426002666,
0.0692508593,
0.0369360112,
-0.0462265275,
0.0021362365,
0.0280691814,
0.0084047923,
-0.0473521873,
0.0073914845,
-0.0255314764,
0.0691617206,
0.0227196831,
0.0596346259,
-0.0789372623,
-0.0464500114,
0.0510002188,
0.0297452621,
-0.0226942748,
0.012715051,
0.0032609454,
-0.0630432963,
0.0439831801,
0.0144937811,
0.0448338576,
-0.0132863652,
-0.0860729069,
-0.0081600659,
0.0093588922,
-0.0193971507,
0.0280236769,
-0.0072358069,
-0.0104598096,
-0.0118299192,
-0.0401431024,
-0.0063688681,
-0.0000872705,
0.022018237,
0.0102077918,
0.0089974161,
-0.0134664997,
-0.0263486318,
-0.0360628292,
0.0500883125,
0.0341341123,
0.007915671,
-0.0753993541,
-0.0091034267,
0.0496318154,
0.0172235575,
-0.0128288399,
0.0274389163,
0.0240028705,
-0.0100659933,
-0.036204651,
0.0587012656,
-0.0333608538,
-0.0231646486,
-0.0176727939,
-0.0168502722,
-0.0232188888,
0.0661028177,
0.0258138608,
0.0287607517,
-0.0614679419,
-0.0354500897,
-0.0504537784,
-0.0069624237,
0.0008261378,
-0.0135896523,
0.0041675665,
-0.0199975949,
0.0399785005,
0.0669018254,
-0.0300057102,
0.0115241557,
-0.0159920882,
-0.0343340077,
-0.0251203384,
-0.0395489037,
-0.0856460333,
-0.0091414899,
-0.0381797664,
0.0303313415,
-0.0338331088,
0.0339109637,
0.0410789251,
-0.0148925781,
0.0050528492,
0.0642894953,
-0.1389870495,
-0.0611313507,
-0.0506812669,
0.0713888407,
0.0228594635,
0.0573551096,
0.0330723077,
-0.0081730625,
0.0460962616,
0.0614908114,
0.0024236352,
0.0864930451,
0.0055480143,
-0.0073678647,
0.0182334688,
0.0085561546,
0.0054757996,
0.0091794254,
0.0166587215,
0.0218617208,
0.0087253815,
-0.0759266019,
-0.0553538688,
0.0683034137,
0.0165129956,
-0.0043943985,
-0.0365463495,
0.0303956941,
0.0723367855,
-0.0155505212,
0.0331019759,
-0.0341180786,
0.0090920394,
-0.0076838089,
-0.0330315419,
0.0069826124,
-0.0005097248,
0.0730878636,
0.0081698857,
0.0038057468,
0.0235917699,
-0.0253604855,
-0.042067036,
0.0275668036,
-0.0115435719,
0.004109995,
-0.0017654703,
0.0236689392,
0.0686169639,
-0.0314151756,
-0.0102064386,
-0.0179162733,
0.0487679206,
-0.0734723359,
0.0256680157,
-0.0094934907,
-0.0575217605,
-0.033944726,
0.0595591404,
0.0578873307,
0.0601194724,
0.0447545908,
-0.0238154568,
0.0023046283,
-0.0035372761,
0.0463757515,
-0.0059030363,
0.0417613946,
0.0542530157,
-0.0095539056,
-0.0174633488,
-0.0338174365,
0.0213728715,
0.0346477926,
0.0457238667,
-0.0323346406,
0.0239458494,
-0.0011324437,
-0.06190053,
0.004494349,
0.0050890199,
0.024899723,
-0.0710152015,
-0.0460115224,
-0.0151675567,
0.0414902121,
0.0237659365,
-0.0142533621,
-0.0315145217,
0.0051469896,
0.0416690074,
0.0426850095,
-0.037473686,
0.0404908434,
-0.0593498535,
0.0052309241,
-0.0161611401,
0.054944016,
-6.446826851e-33,
-0.0434296988,
0.0044670911,
0.0197833367,
0.016912736,
-0.0234272648,
-0.0297232084,
-0.0236083213,
-0.0206929371,
0.0211313814,
-0.0218652375,
-0.0102497237,
0.0034369528,
0.0136348903,
-0.0271079447,
-0.0329305381,
-0.0024590974,
0.023370618,
0.0098240506,
-0.0323039256,
0.0015362027,
-0.0132200373,
0.0148315942,
0.0065062186,
-0.0069783186,
-0.062446449,
0.0332837328,
0.0123713864,
-0.0139809726,
-0.0621274225,
0.0144032147,
-0.0269413982,
-0.0111521976,
-0.0401942097,
-0.0126026766,
0.0003836276,
-0.0280573573,
-0.0457623787,
-0.0198868159,
0.0506389365,
-0.0337670259,
0.0005579729,
-0.0960073397,
0.0281128436,
0.0901624039,
-0.0490408689,
-0.0648455843,
-0.0199798588,
-0.0152168078,
-0.0125729395,
-0.0554175824,
-0.0146929147,
0.0077352924,
0.0288621131,
0.0418155864,
0.0289976969,
-0.0212522838,
-0.0456209518,
0.0230658147,
-0.0082571562,
-0.0003941794,
0.0492313132,
0.0434930548,
0.1050013676,
0.0111695426,
0.016401764,
0.0141246384,
0.0004423531,
-0.0311202332,
-0.0543969683,
0.0090579493,
0.0132947015,
0.0624237582,
0.0123483082,
0.0204529092,
0.0343001671,
0.0141939027,
-0.1087733731,
0.0379816107,
0.0435468182,
0.0379652157,
0.0056638364,
0.0063987025,
0.0147956582,
-0.0209666006,
-0.005472912,
0.012498742,
-0.0120780189,
-0.0272832494,
-0.0207959041,
0.0027896247,
-0.0531039797,
-0.0364660956,
0.0273607466,
-0.0412917137,
0.0252599996,
-0.001714144,
0.0117399115,
-0.0139470911,
0.0380611159,
0.027248919,
-0.0209380873,
-0.0298140608,
-0.0334428176,
-0.0411158726,
0.0504364297,
-0.0175541248,
-0.0095092952,
0.0432951599,
-0.0506377518,
0.0056651141,
-0.0409560837,
-0.0380308889,
0.0202995222,
-0.0119020389,
0.0310184024,
-0.0096555538,
0.0178444535,
0.0030538717,
-0.0136435889,
0.0202919561,
0.0014040591,
0.0108240014,
0.031530261,
0.0551228933,
-0.0269905869,
0.0071919234,
-0.0428283326,
0.0015247409,
0.0046931184,
-0.0477206483,
-0.0555170476,
0.0543060303,
2.806e-7,
0.0283715222,
0.0130667202,
0.0044504097,
0.0620246008,
-0.0065875188,
-0.0042096428,
0.0002676439,
-0.0152298538,
0.0034271467,
-0.0408377163,
0.0231380332,
0.0334092006,
0.0467831828,
-0.0207583178,
0.0085494202,
0.0101715922,
0.0021527782,
0.0072577628,
-0.0197168961,
-0.0746593997,
-0.0066724042,
0.0641626567,
0.0015771706,
-0.0321400762,
0.0266160667,
-0.0008870581,
0.0273095854,
-0.0360223055,
0.0087354453,
0.0122002568,
-0.0009570193,
-0.0280050542,
-0.0409188569,
-0.0128652882,
0.0068922793,
0.0050588087,
-0.0678867698,
0.0788208768,
0.0394212641,
-0.0363769382,
0.0318732038,
-0.0237282887,
-0.0168273747,
0.0135298306,
0.0719127953,
0.0473625287,
-0.0124084139,
-0.0481884331,
0.0044730972,
-0.0477776006,
-0.0052613537,
-0.0183708034,
0.0949575603,
0.0164971408,
-0.03058034,
-0.018424714,
-0.0128042474,
-0.0328713022,
-0.0539165661,
0.0014874281,
-0.0332881883,
-0.0596808046,
-0.0387367383,
0.0352389291,
-0.0023968974,
-0.0558343977,
-0.0456791483,
3.223409844e-34,
0.0167511255,
-0.0156092038,
-0.0020806091,
0.1048395559,
-0.0194181725,
-0.0337367766,
-0.0514415726,
-0.0054677888,
-0.0442680828,
-0.0748832002,
-0.0137019018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01158v1 | LLM-Detector: Improving AI-Generated Chinese Text Detection with Open-Source LLM Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-02T05:54:12 | 2024-02-02T05:54:12 | Rongsheng Wang, Haoming Chen, Ruizhe Zhou, Han Ma, Yaofei Duan, Yanlan Kang, Songhua Yang, Baoyu Fan, Tao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT and other general large language models (LLMs) have achieved
remarkable success, but they have also raised concerns about the misuse of
AI-generated texts. Existing AI-generated text detection models, such as based
on BERT and RoBERTa, are prone to in-domain over-fitting, leading to poor
out-of-domain (OOD) detection performance. In this paper, we first collected
Chinese text responses generated by human experts and 9 types of LLMs, for
which to multiple domains questions, and further created a dataset that mixed
human-written sentences and sentences polished by LLMs. We then proposed
LLM-Detector, a novel method for both document-level and sentence-level text
detection through Instruction Tuning of LLMs. Our method leverages the wealth
of knowledge LLMs acquire during pre-training, enabling them to detect the text
they generate. Instruction tuning aligns the model's responses with the user's
expected text detection tasks. Experimental results show that previous methods
struggle with sentence-level AI-generated text detection and OOD detection. In
contrast, our proposed method not only significantly outperforms baseline
methods in both sentence-level and document-level text detection but also
demonstrates strong generalization capabilities. Furthermore, since
LLM-Detector is trained based on open-source LLMs, it is easy to customize for
deployment. | LLM-Detector: Improving AI-Generated Chinese Text Detection with Open-Source LLM Instruction Tuning: ChatGPT and other general large language models (LLMs) have achieved
remarkable success, but they have also raised concerns about the misuse of
AI-generated texts. Existing AI-generated text detection models, such as based
on BERT and RoBERTa, are prone to in-domain over-fitting, leading to poor
out-of-domain (OOD) detection performance. In this paper, we first collected
Chinese text responses generated by human experts and 9 types of LLMs, for
which to multiple domains questions, and further created a dataset that mixed
human-written sentences and sentences polished by LLMs. We then proposed
LLM-Detector, a novel method for both document-level and sentence-level text
detection through Instruction Tuning of LLMs. Our method leverages the wealth
of knowledge LLMs acquire during pre-training, enabling them to detect the text
they generate. Instruction tuning aligns the model's responses with the user's
expected text detection tasks. Experimental results show that previous methods
struggle with sentence-level AI-generated text detection and OOD detection. In
contrast, our proposed method not only significantly outperforms baseline
methods in both sentence-level and document-level text detection but also
demonstrates strong generalization capabilities. Furthermore, since
LLM-Detector is trained based on open-source LLMs, it is easy to customize for
deployment. | [
0.0227788668,
0.0111030517,
0.0159936305,
0.0717961788,
-0.0207956191,
0.0105359908,
-0.0193896759,
0.0405045971,
0.0549752265,
-0.030193422,
-0.0553553849,
-0.0254987981,
-0.028631568,
0.0191211347,
-0.007558973,
0.0095054917,
0.0236635692,
0.0000921764,
-0.0116840964,
0.0391940102,
0.0517133735,
-0.0006728867,
0.0114646703,
0.0231179595,
0.0053316439,
-0.0471071005,
-0.0024360833,
0.0541284606,
0.0532981716,
-0.0393995531,
0.047871504,
0.024500588,
0.0117326034,
0.0488463454,
0.0000018303,
-0.0412080698,
-0.0393988118,
-0.010031946,
-0.0149604166,
0.0382857732,
0.0523031652,
0.0001812307,
-0.0284945369,
0.048586823,
-0.0325786807,
0.01941319,
0.0017590383,
0.0973031148,
0.029824473,
0.1071598679,
-0.0189724546,
0.0290575121,
0.050453566,
0.0034880629,
0.0023881109,
-0.0482858419,
0.035373278,
-0.0025129889,
-0.0070125274,
-0.0013391095,
0.0021604542,
-0.0002583149,
0.0034477231,
-0.0139849195,
-0.0235236641,
0.0195117369,
-0.0280944388,
0.0067695091,
-0.0508535542,
0.0772879198,
-0.0380583256,
-0.0253879223,
0.0253162421,
-0.0145384539,
0.0228200946,
-0.0100822961,
-0.0087365108,
0.0267168079,
-0.0450084284,
0.0192594752,
-0.0069105946,
-0.0309051163,
0.0043616588,
0.0577163324,
-0.0221547596,
0.0255852323,
0.0116041573,
-0.0583871603,
-0.0050164056,
0.0017040257,
-0.049610436,
-0.0249135885,
0.0905721784,
0.032825876,
-0.0037110737,
-0.0039015443,
-0.0601495244,
-0.0380922854,
0.0063759899,
-0.0422955789,
0.0280500278,
0.0216729995,
-0.0576764792,
0.0318036638,
-0.0636816099,
0.0582822636,
-0.0544980615,
0.0148453834,
-0.0535107553,
0.0032337201,
-0.002082339,
-0.0188995972,
-0.0490454994,
0.013102958,
-0.0460759848,
-0.055125203,
-0.0216236338,
0.0250195432,
0.0328786485,
-0.0250538196,
-0.0034809103,
-0.0133908344,
-0.0232110322,
-0.0375377536,
0.0233850069,
0.0202983748,
-0.0098611303,
0.0285427291,
-0.0039633554,
-0.0492693819,
-0.0259354524,
0.0760331452,
0.0431221984,
0.0002634095,
0.0254886746,
0.0563899279,
-0.0200925376,
-0.0659988821,
-0.0312452,
-0.0032325608,
-0.0194252152,
-0.0266126245,
0.0247073174,
-0.047260344,
-0.0342072994,
-0.0182000883,
0.03476898,
-0.0000128656,
0.0185649469,
0.0384664573,
0.0058413609,
0.0271511804,
-0.0175795909,
-0.0046943258,
0.0183953494,
-0.0011962982,
0.0036641627,
0.0630978867,
0.0316140465,
0.0611636303,
0.0554585606,
0.0281418115,
0.0360221416,
0.0775490329,
-0.0265597459,
0.0141582154,
0.0159875285,
0.012426381,
-0.0147869298,
0.0025379488,
0.0400021933,
0.0184965171,
-0.0074167573,
0.0070026987,
0.0702776983,
0.0287046693,
-0.004093287,
-0.0024594713,
0.0154439434,
0.0705981478,
0.0041000182,
0.0472144596,
-0.0074605448,
-0.0158362091,
-0.0389597341,
-0.0004055112,
-0.002514051,
0.0323234685,
-0.0102818916,
-0.039452415,
-0.0283783432,
-0.0126213934,
-0.0253872126,
0.0095664337,
0.0499148183,
0.0107547622,
-0.0604380183,
-0.0101338578,
0.006054352,
-0.0352766104,
-0.0000592081,
-0.0510794483,
0.0327240452,
0.0602486432,
0.050097324,
-0.0310212187,
0.012045824,
-0.0052024196,
0.0328426473,
0.104967244,
0.0148512442,
0.0204116367,
-0.0158684123,
-0.0652711913,
-0.0305909179,
0.015608564,
0.0085402234,
0.0245652385,
0.0538169444,
0.0095417462,
0.0215415042,
-0.0511428304,
-0.042641744,
0.0762572661,
-0.0321449488,
-0.0263703801,
-0.0062771835,
0.0008998624,
0.000536525,
0.0090421038,
-0.0349756703,
0.0070833596,
0.0206169188,
-0.0461557284,
-0.0273881219,
-0.0285385549,
-0.0256654304,
-0.0541824698,
0.0134973926,
-0.0410308391,
-0.0318703838,
0.0328394137,
-0.0385551453,
-0.0134833083,
-0.0481566004,
-0.0237639323,
0.000072799,
-0.078793861,
0.0324809663,
-0.0034010215,
0.0359494984,
-0.015640039,
0.0519272014,
-0.0065224245,
-0.0181072708,
0.0283926614,
0.0082597956,
0.0440147296,
-0.0242705531,
-0.0263786837,
-0.0231313389,
-0.0331059024,
0.0311191436,
0.0285210889,
0.0620705746,
-0.0348113626,
-0.0278165955,
-0.0982368514,
0.048393257,
-0.0467883497,
0.0139766913,
0.0428925194,
-0.0011866781,
-0.0455555245,
-0.0205892846,
-0.0174043849,
-0.0212276783,
0.0024755998,
-0.0187738221,
0.0305522922,
-0.0566252097,
0.0164516866,
-0.0242839865,
0.0214437135,
-0.0254775099,
-0.0031064828,
0.0117360689,
-0.0583242141,
-0.0697667003,
0.0290890727,
0.0361230709,
0.0213396866,
0.0026721943,
-0.0687871724,
-0.0183496922,
-0.0132063022,
0.0494400188,
0.101255089,
0.0142807588,
-0.0124163898,
0.0213772394,
0.044810228,
-0.0313823782,
0.042211514,
0.0221843403,
-0.0051153577,
-0.0084443986,
-0.0215002708,
0.0531757586,
0.0626780763,
0.0079163425,
0.0086667202,
-0.0151655646,
-0.0457912497,
-0.0293558352,
-0.040693175,
-0.0232338011,
-0.0065776929,
-0.0585952178,
0.0081663812,
-0.0379360355,
-0.0479335599,
0.0364347063,
-0.0293648746,
-0.0133584011,
-0.0833453387,
-0.0100834109,
-0.045093894,
0.0026290696,
0.0077042715,
0.0150822233,
0.0067852638,
-0.0225042067,
-0.0374184772,
0.0161709152,
-0.0249807741,
-0.0241549909,
0.0382401459,
-0.0128033655,
0.0015430902,
-0.0228312537,
-0.0234730039,
-0.055395741,
-0.0436651297,
-0.0343135782,
-0.0114537552,
0.0111732241,
-0.0304003172,
-0.0026990906,
0.0105445962,
-0.0019158165,
0.079515256,
-0.0348328128,
0.0108569674,
-0.0377223752,
0.0748234615,
0.0534187928,
-0.0065024728,
0.0012420348,
-0.047488831,
0.0474448279,
0.0547953062,
0.0117284721,
-0.006012714,
0.0143509889,
-0.0135881929,
0.0189655311,
-0.0087104607,
0.0023430241,
0.0183033682,
0.0634754822,
-0.0627650619,
-0.0081790416,
0.1140012518,
0.0204322543,
-0.0267359056,
-0.0295209177,
-0.0125491945,
0.0091336202,
0.006311839,
-0.0026958275,
-0.0757848322,
-0.0733459145,
0.0175184254,
-0.0223987363,
0.0037840691,
0.0274426658,
0.001768111,
-0.1141003072,
0.025689261,
0.0085678026,
0.0052846237,
-0.0225110743,
0.02362228,
0.0307998639,
0.0244450904,
0.0056847078,
-0.018419208,
-0.0367812514,
-0.0185742825,
0.0006837402,
-0.0165208261,
-0.0193624608,
-0.0007229249,
-0.0529669672,
-0.0073479554,
0.0981509238,
0.0662252605,
0.0019192919,
-0.0072742426,
0.0638439208,
-0.0222286507,
0.0031331719,
0.0058495156,
0.0493314639,
-0.0163817331,
0.0004934338,
-0.0144928014,
0.0375417471,
-0.03975223,
0.0142079731,
0.0798932984,
0.0202530958,
0.0079802182,
-0.0496638417,
-0.0388393588,
0.0146434056,
-0.0098928437,
0.108455494,
0.022757804,
-0.0657274798,
-0.0580866486,
-0.0221474525,
-0.0160371456,
-0.0836663246,
-0.0047607771,
0.0333293006,
-0.049238462,
-0.0015745888,
-0.0887826532,
-0.015262126,
0.0087979939,
-0.012061025,
0.0110876886,
-0.003025084,
-0.0126451189,
0.0423701443,
-0.025621729,
0.0061378269,
-0.0398624726,
0.0154034067,
-0.0833875611,
0.0204855166,
0.0180961899,
-0.0584613308,
-0.0105003184,
0.0457160659,
-0.0697950125,
-0.0318605229,
-0.0042880811,
-0.0213151835,
0.0091867289,
0.0124034481,
-0.0343499072,
-0.0144050522,
0.0628509521,
0.0366460457,
-0.0323686749,
0.0026010678,
0.0240588859,
0.0039261649,
-0.0300872289,
0.0173624456,
-0.0272065327,
0.0336902253,
0.0283878036,
0.0019020353,
-0.0209468659,
-0.0127551537,
0.0162951741,
0.0029104489,
0.0302925799,
0.0025046528,
-0.0016837799,
-0.0531200916,
0.0123386038,
0.0173879694,
-0.0202053599,
-0.0544191785,
0.0195360798,
0.0551304333,
-0.0098569011,
-0.0212440155,
0.0630675703,
-0.0088360338,
0.0192202348,
-0.026387278,
0.0314027257,
0.0067287949,
0.0518878177,
0.0185490809,
-0.0241256934,
0.0017765788,
0.0336352699,
0.000179344,
0.0161034074,
0.020776391,
0.0814941823,
0.003755342,
-0.0336380638,
0.0259686913,
0.017759921,
-0.0427866206,
-0.0051831286,
-0.0565231517,
0.0648163036,
0.0694498196,
-0.0074071288,
0.0504305512,
-0.0403882675,
-0.0064145327,
-0.0401152074,
0.0082612243,
0.002427551,
-0.0097138975,
-0.0041960431,
-6.18e-7,
-0.0381727777,
-0.0578930862,
0.0841281414,
0.0422494859,
0.0526786968,
0.0328617394,
-0.0305515062,
-0.0534724519,
-0.0128925219,
0.0517067425,
0.0129688382,
-0.0118711591,
0.0494264662,
-0.0167770535,
-0.0299245622,
-0.0080870893,
-0.027592048,
-0.0193221662,
-0.0114570325,
-0.0010035502,
0.0455298871,
-0.0188409202,
-0.0180172753,
-0.0183378626,
-0.0037725857,
-0.0289251525,
-0.0166378934,
-0.0182901341,
-5.935415544e-33,
-0.0091119418,
-0.04965543,
-0.0121704172,
-0.0126262726,
0.008725862,
0.0251480453,
-0.0187098514,
-0.0325485952,
-0.0226648413,
0.0096210474,
-0.0254275594,
0.0427950397,
0.0314553976,
0.0311919618,
-0.0426783338,
-0.0160766058,
0.0610208921,
-0.0268034209,
-0.0242994837,
-0.0046190079,
0.0044909208,
0.0440789536,
0.043136891,
-0.0394764058,
-0.0135527933,
-0.0288899541,
-0.0293035842,
0.029642418,
0.0078820977,
0.0705476478,
-0.0286306925,
0.0413017534,
0.0513821878,
0.0169437211,
-0.0123209851,
0.0842345208,
-0.0824334398,
-0.0005151227,
-0.0166024771,
0.0198229086,
-0.0031881197,
-0.0448799655,
0.015746735,
-0.0221575182,
0.0208407212,
0.0064905505,
0.0684868395,
-0.0523802638,
0.014582023,
-0.0241645928,
-0.0576021522,
0.0404503122,
0.0128153972,
-0.0310403667,
0.0005115801,
0.0567932688,
-0.0022062825,
0.0236267336,
-0.0274272393,
0.0051244977,
0.032680396,
0.0397141874,
0.0002532473,
0.0382746644,
-0.0045167292,
0.0302981269,
0.0013565243,
0.0190185197,
-0.005381404,
-0.0562047139,
0.0199410673,
0.0137236333,
0.0249718316,
0.0612588525,
0.0378388837,
-0.0015963245,
-0.0632795617,
0.0367303304,
0.0262924246,
0.0045056324,
0.0388420857,
0.0074690948,
-0.074755013,
0.0067914561,
0.0188201498,
-0.0242354348,
-0.0434614941,
-0.0040957415,
0.0465526171,
0.051357206,
-0.0386041403,
-0.0261450745,
0.0308692418,
-0.0423921719,
0.0189043414,
0.0150024388,
-0.0125590926,
-0.0079202931,
-0.0056649307,
0.0307210162,
-0.0561122186,
-0.0469625667,
0.0156583413,
0.0092538241,
-0.0200857259,
-0.0105210207,
0.0478363037,
-0.0151300877,
-0.0792758018,
0.0227761474,
-0.0305603035,
-0.0113761974,
0.029119119,
0.0566321351,
0.0114767672,
-0.0271263197,
-0.0070735114,
0.0452929437,
0.026708696,
0.0092754886,
-0.0592648871,
-0.0427101701,
-0.04685954,
0.0159440544,
-0.0368290395,
0.0320396982,
-0.0182975922,
0.0051303525,
0.0233823899,
-0.0659419149,
0.0025940482,
-0.0093792183,
2.372e-7,
0.0389716923,
0.0126970848,
0.0389004014,
0.0371815152,
0.0010161742,
0.0505676344,
-0.0085439673,
0.0433076508,
0.0020794352,
0.0148126883,
0.0227709115,
0.0174289625,
0.0867713094,
-0.0313263088,
-0.1183006689,
0.0097506335,
-0.0213125404,
0.0029476974,
-0.0552033,
-0.0191272963,
0.0240805224,
0.0713851303,
-0.0276588555,
-0.0117266374,
0.0092454441,
-0.1026429087,
0.0469418429,
-0.0200679656,
0.0190414824,
0.0410443507,
0.031194672,
0.0448042601,
-0.0240097381,
0.0054299068,
-0.0079183048,
0.0352055319,
0.0589626655,
0.0847561881,
0.0242140479,
0.0075622057,
0.0072887815,
-0.003993398,
0.0101151941,
-0.0293760449,
0.0623833239,
-0.0208009891,
0.0005893529,
-0.0281204581,
0.0203915965,
-0.0721394196,
-0.0099848229,
-0.0362570956,
-0.022317918,
0.0333053209,
0.0271466635,
-0.0212582964,
-0.0226757433,
-0.0616948679,
-0.0559495576,
-0.03359304,
-0.0529691577,
-0.0272423662,
-0.0713246688,
0.01967787,
0.0133723598,
-0.0757245272,
0.0209363438,
2.102926103e-34,
0.0183536019,
-0.0302750953,
-0.0286182147,
0.0491431877,
0.0435485281,
-0.0108613782,
-0.0003943163,
-0.0238291044,
-0.0082042431,
-0.0648833066,
0.0130128274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01155v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01155v3 | CABINET: Content Relevance based Noise Reduction for Table Question Answering | 2024-02-02T05:48:39 | 2024-02-13T09:11:01 | Sohan Patnaik, Heril Changwal, Milan Aggarwal, Sumit Bhatia, Yaman Kumar, Balaji Krishnamurthy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table understanding capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has been
extensively studied through the task of question-answering (QA) over tables.
Typically, only a small part of the whole table is relevant to derive the
answer for a given question. The irrelevant parts act as noise and are
distracting information, resulting in sub-optimal performance due to the
vulnerability of LLMs to noise. To mitigate this, we propose CABINET (Content
RelevAnce-Based NoIse ReductioN for TablE QuesTion-Answering) - a framework to
enable LLMs to focus on relevant tabular data by suppressing extraneous
information. CABINET comprises an Unsupervised Relevance Scorer (URS), trained
differentially with the QA LLM, that weighs the table content based on its
relevance to the input question before feeding it to the question-answering LLM
(QA LLM). To further aid the relevance scorer, CABINET employs a weakly
supervised module that generates a parsing statement describing the criteria of
rows and columns relevant to the question and highlights the content of
corresponding table cells. CABINET significantly outperforms various tabular
LLM baselines, as well as GPT3-based in-context learning methods, is more
robust to noise, maintains outperformance on tables of varying sizes, and
establishes new SoTA performance on WikiTQ, FeTaQA, and WikiSQL datasets. We
release our code and datasets at https://github.com/Sohanpatnaik106/CABINET_QA. | CABINET: Content Relevance based Noise Reduction for Table Question Answering: Table understanding capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has been
extensively studied through the task of question-answering (QA) over tables.
Typically, only a small part of the whole table is relevant to derive the
answer for a given question. The irrelevant parts act as noise and are
distracting information, resulting in sub-optimal performance due to the
vulnerability of LLMs to noise. To mitigate this, we propose CABINET (Content
RelevAnce-Based NoIse ReductioN for TablE QuesTion-Answering) - a framework to
enable LLMs to focus on relevant tabular data by suppressing extraneous
information. CABINET comprises an Unsupervised Relevance Scorer (URS), trained
differentially with the QA LLM, that weighs the table content based on its
relevance to the input question before feeding it to the question-answering LLM
(QA LLM). To further aid the relevance scorer, CABINET employs a weakly
supervised module that generates a parsing statement describing the criteria of
rows and columns relevant to the question and highlights the content of
corresponding table cells. CABINET significantly outperforms various tabular
LLM baselines, as well as GPT3-based in-context learning methods, is more
robust to noise, maintains outperformance on tables of varying sizes, and
establishes new SoTA performance on WikiTQ, FeTaQA, and WikiSQL datasets. We
release our code and datasets at https://github.com/Sohanpatnaik106/CABINET_QA. | [
0.0335046351,
0.0733161345,
0.0127885696,
0.0324277543,
-0.0126621528,
0.0370534249,
-0.0386130773,
0.0141378595,
-0.013336896,
-0.0083941231,
-0.0565246344,
-0.0002563019,
-0.0274596773,
-0.0054872134,
0.0415666066,
0.0348047279,
0.0633894131,
0.0055669476,
-0.0305981133,
0.0088453405,
-0.0021330104,
-0.0168790035,
-0.009517218,
0.017693745,
-0.0149254883,
-0.0145234447,
-0.0184065141,
-0.0022782728,
-0.0434934758,
0.0125644505,
0.0369695835,
0.0926542878,
0.0105233425,
0.032304693,
0.0000019599,
0.00626677,
-0.0361059979,
-0.0114656221,
-0.0368273482,
-0.0057154829,
0.0130427061,
-0.0152663216,
0.0198292043,
-0.0040752632,
-0.0526197776,
-0.0072085466,
0.0109705692,
0.0442338884,
0.0494149178,
0.0327753015,
0.0276884846,
-0.0199719239,
0.0025523561,
-0.0069784201,
0.0811423138,
-0.0917041674,
0.0163819194,
0.0254068282,
-0.001557076,
-0.0028800927,
-0.0103066657,
0.0547713526,
0.0300911758,
-0.0195827298,
-0.0037525699,
0.0331615023,
-0.044311896,
0.0477794223,
0.0244856142,
0.1187399477,
0.0367343165,
-0.0312195718,
0.0011303235,
0.0251938924,
0.0407500304,
-0.0437146239,
-0.0556815229,
-0.0181433652,
0.0124201998,
-0.0112083172,
-0.0015112784,
-0.0128077073,
0.0050171423,
0.0073361988,
-0.01469763,
0.0737869889,
-0.0176620577,
-0.0452376083,
0.0130411275,
-0.0099304616,
-0.0218882747,
-0.0183347277,
0.0045060641,
0.067633912,
-0.0509938374,
0.0260162763,
0.0138220461,
-0.0325576849,
0.0185012445,
-0.0641025528,
-0.0194054861,
0.0370705016,
-0.0035247705,
0.0418198928,
-0.020647753,
0.0092961639,
-0.0210504383,
0.0218156483,
-0.0596565679,
-0.0510596894,
-0.0273116287,
-0.011269995,
-0.0540390164,
0.0430382304,
-0.0777910799,
-0.025129417,
0.0081393216,
-0.0030285974,
-0.0007701056,
0.013327105,
0.0212702751,
0.0506124943,
-0.0206728671,
0.0074962093,
-0.0119333407,
0.0221311226,
-0.0292974226,
0.0044313241,
-0.0322025679,
-0.063864395,
-0.0339270718,
-0.0188980401,
0.0138601307,
-0.0318721272,
0.0542454645,
0.0565687679,
-0.0337567776,
-0.0209788885,
-0.0208098236,
-0.0048083416,
-0.0222246163,
-0.0598304421,
-0.0248422623,
-0.0337683409,
0.0367203727,
0.0136109339,
0.017204646,
-0.0598400682,
0.0116614513,
0.0648999289,
-0.0091109313,
0.0613196343,
0.017405767,
0.0278571416,
0.0282471366,
0.0046251728,
-0.0209255498,
0.0851047188,
0.00976431,
-0.0073089343,
-0.0205793232,
-0.03117783,
-0.0335497409,
0.0306668431,
0.0599620566,
0.0002014661,
-0.0013412256,
0.0806246996,
0.0284134503,
0.0229802076,
0.0163976122,
0.0117635569,
-0.0055724294,
0.0159961917,
0.0325507969,
0.035194736,
-0.0050140168,
0.0708495826,
0.0025888137,
0.0157039203,
0.0245664604,
0.0299617331,
-0.0316231959,
0.0354152396,
-0.0121606477,
-0.0044757691,
0.0544203669,
-0.0164850838,
-0.0266303476,
-0.0482852235,
0.016968064,
0.0025050123,
-0.0276089646,
0.041700054,
0.0283772182,
0.027607223,
-0.0570355989,
0.0274396613,
0.0005163817,
-0.0433072373,
-0.0088642733,
-0.0294564087,
0.0541504547,
0.0472579151,
0.043179512,
-0.0711218566,
-0.0087628234,
0.0004736575,
0.0420937128,
0.0009778708,
-0.0094428891,
-0.0285298359,
0.0299516656,
0.0048118578,
-0.0268723462,
0.0246578492,
0.0283577237,
-0.0432936065,
0.0306019131,
-0.0044036382,
0.0018847618,
-0.0723581314,
-0.0096623553,
0.0183303654,
0.0601015128,
-0.0450106598,
0.0035542974,
0.0032367704,
0.0189916901,
0.0215452705,
0.0161049981,
0.0154218348,
0.0366890542,
-0.0101291947,
0.0445933416,
-0.0232051332,
-0.0273571722,
-0.0080342963,
0.0205161311,
0.0459836423,
-0.06664446,
0.0017915169,
-0.0415648073,
-0.0273764227,
0.0244247802,
-0.0463373363,
-0.0373177044,
-0.0431166366,
-0.0263736285,
0.0271683801,
0.0410819389,
-0.0227337368,
0.0790507048,
-0.0118279271,
0.0407197997,
0.0295003578,
-0.0607897937,
0.0226651989,
-0.0385518037,
0.0260400008,
-0.0454323329,
-0.0365526564,
0.0368398838,
0.0054594465,
0.0382487103,
-0.0639878809,
-0.0154811163,
-0.0874894485,
0.0300781354,
-0.0518102981,
0.0258821808,
0.0375952236,
0.0261781663,
-0.0119661354,
-0.0417117104,
-0.0446984172,
-0.0006923988,
0.0139454268,
-0.000882421,
0.0483721606,
0.0087057287,
0.0102323769,
-0.049475275,
-0.0309924185,
-0.0095180767,
0.032739073,
-0.0347975791,
-0.0266713295,
-0.0088561317,
-0.0240326263,
-0.0029546521,
0.029510919,
0.0236081667,
-0.0160372276,
-0.0204276647,
-0.0306571145,
0.0322034173,
0.0415082015,
-0.0415596291,
0.0175902098,
0.0091408379,
-0.0209331475,
-0.0553433262,
0.0403070636,
-0.0179359093,
0.0050541731,
-0.010830055,
-0.0470172316,
0.0530331768,
0.0250219107,
-0.0041485582,
-0.0083661927,
-0.0374965854,
0.0166007001,
0.0166824497,
-0.0084877741,
-0.1075479239,
0.0650621504,
-0.0014603921,
-0.0049309833,
-0.0235292558,
0.002047804,
0.010822311,
-0.0255969781,
0.0068781567,
-0.042010542,
0.0091069434,
-0.0556524917,
0.0578178316,
-0.0001299285,
-0.0053659338,
-0.0470272303,
-0.0429260321,
-0.0432437621,
-0.0389954038,
-0.0213740226,
-0.049151279,
0.0834744573,
-0.0477492549,
0.0320020877,
-0.0014860731,
-0.0125708021,
-0.0133347958,
-0.0414513759,
-0.0107358992,
0.0233849697,
0.0092036612,
0.0122952107,
-0.0289902464,
-0.0195019543,
0.0407775119,
0.0434605591,
-0.0143296663,
-0.01746496,
-0.0277624428,
0.0756026655,
0.0502604879,
0.0501267351,
-0.0298878346,
0.0188861806,
0.0381797515,
0.0492106415,
-0.0036919266,
-0.0424393415,
0.0021063455,
0.0271664914,
0.0423295312,
-0.0203639455,
-0.0059841005,
0.0337434895,
0.0019240252,
-0.0545161925,
-0.0386002772,
0.0810044929,
0.019696556,
0.0062648375,
-0.0145188188,
-0.0127055552,
0.018055195,
0.0136647141,
0.0646906868,
-0.0594646521,
-0.041529987,
-0.0024316807,
0.0092414645,
0.0319739133,
-0.0429502986,
-0.0289614797,
-0.0967211798,
0.0350915045,
-0.0519100539,
-0.0724935383,
-0.0915471241,
-0.0133674145,
0.0115876617,
-0.0336791836,
0.0488813706,
0.0646931455,
-0.0206030868,
0.0296487138,
0.0289260335,
-0.0259083156,
-0.0472613536,
-0.0240566283,
-0.0404922962,
0.0221990161,
0.0613454394,
0.0072568422,
-0.024281038,
-0.0086906878,
0.0070870374,
-0.0301023461,
-0.0028368977,
-0.0144698545,
0.0521731526,
0.0050930711,
-0.0102895871,
-0.0308992341,
0.003023501,
-0.0250997078,
0.0133531531,
0.0489354841,
0.0608691722,
-0.0368037447,
0.010020108,
0.027621448,
-0.0024342153,
0.006411117,
0.0895714536,
0.0657111034,
-0.0012676826,
-0.0330987163,
-0.0126657309,
-0.0554645471,
-0.0446489416,
0.0246220212,
0.0378811397,
0.0167137552,
0.0093840742,
-0.0506946854,
-0.0311468709,
0.0612369999,
-0.0046830978,
-0.0143695576,
0.0950025767,
-0.0839528814,
0.0079033626,
-0.0441164635,
-0.0102042332,
-0.0843200535,
-0.0101394653,
-0.02890536,
-0.0201358609,
0.0183256809,
-0.0566057488,
-0.030997416,
0.0264490619,
-0.0592423901,
0.0057328194,
-0.0152286533,
0.019146109,
0.0144044869,
0.0092558907,
-0.0062642326,
-0.0275882985,
-0.0187952369,
0.0117538432,
-0.0695436075,
-0.0076848455,
0.0048897085,
-0.047957249,
0.002856561,
0.0495667867,
-0.0446221828,
-0.0041065235,
0.0155197894,
0.0515046492,
-0.0040568886,
-0.0007306905,
0.0492628179,
-0.0049169143,
-0.0076755146,
0.0562082529,
-0.0538570881,
-0.0071509499,
0.0429843031,
-0.0167841502,
-0.0269458983,
-0.0033738902,
0.0002369577,
0.0246251468,
-0.024499476,
-0.0331899561,
0.0043956391,
0.0111575462,
0.0436918326,
-0.0376059264,
-0.002351464,
0.0288887229,
-0.0437685847,
-0.0019334715,
-0.0343591273,
-0.0097372392,
-0.0160793886,
0.0330249332,
0.0192357413,
-0.0112434998,
-0.0222166572,
0.0115641998,
-0.0537897721,
-0.0209239479,
0.0425574891,
-0.0634751916,
-0.0404226594,
-0.0299903844,
0.0284184422,
0.0251295753,
-0.0031406283,
0.0026582994,
-0.0101921419,
-0.0191841498,
0.0054195351,
0.0001639611,
0.035928607,
0.01192265,
0.0531617366,
0.011903869,
-0.0016564556,
-0.0109272357,
0.0860134065,
0.0536390506,
0.038828928,
0.0096885525,
-0.019497944,
-0.0636560321,
-0.0152056068,
-0.0120048122,
0.0187478364,
-0.0510733873,
0.0263198297,
0.0092805037,
-0.0320619009,
0.012543492,
0.0224343967,
-0.0566860586,
-0.0112472409,
0.0417251922,
0.0550227426,
0.0499186702,
-0.0343010537,
-0.0295557827,
0.0273257494,
-0.0074691353,
-0.0395801254,
-0.0167583916,
-6.524030381e-33,
-0.0398601033,
-0.021258967,
0.0142018432,
-0.0312389825,
0.018462982,
-0.0052897776,
-0.056156341,
-0.036612805,
-0.0288049728,
-0.0180405769,
-0.0422578976,
0.0695654675,
0.0161046255,
0.0113922078,
0.0002651602,
-0.0815051049,
0.0243163649,
-0.0084963711,
0.0180441346,
0.032961335,
-0.023564795,
0.0443820991,
0.0374043658,
-0.0090578161,
0.0414669551,
-0.0164356306,
-0.0191959292,
-0.0047912584,
-0.0131142531,
0.0411266312,
-0.0491746254,
0.0437107235,
0.0385446735,
-0.0416927077,
-0.0394466594,
0.014927743,
-0.1657098532,
-0.0138730658,
0.0153335109,
0.0166254696,
-0.0213010255,
-0.044092387,
0.0312910378,
-0.0016065167,
-0.0160279665,
-0.0084441947,
0.0278973356,
-0.0366458967,
0.0057097604,
0.0101298969,
-0.0136202062,
0.0058920006,
-0.028185131,
0.0006433352,
0.0254226178,
0.0417504944,
0.0095321024,
-0.0023403917,
-0.0481639765,
0.0027620897,
-0.0112154204,
0.0585703962,
0.0297161359,
-0.0349433236,
0.002460354,
-0.0109831104,
0.0104208998,
-0.0316810049,
-0.0201023053,
-0.0585211441,
-0.0530874319,
0.0378742702,
0.0857687816,
0.0379173905,
0.0579679497,
0.0185136665,
-0.0907522216,
0.073836036,
-0.024458481,
0.0369761251,
-0.0086052874,
-0.031463787,
-0.0232326388,
0.0030301777,
-0.0304307435,
0.0347612463,
-0.0421981327,
-0.0041204365,
0.0398265012,
-0.0204412658,
0.0179170221,
-0.0284318589,
0.0169833004,
-0.0182213746,
-0.0044337092,
0.0835803226,
0.0074669407,
-0.0184833053,
0.0354717337,
0.0116400039,
-0.00966556,
-0.0034780113,
0.0273377486,
-0.0376920328,
0.0160450079,
0.01689413,
0.0314888619,
0.0172100216,
-0.0488646105,
-0.0097137876,
-0.0295654442,
0.0729927793,
-0.020359939,
0.0266342685,
0.016442515,
-0.002147675,
0.0078188377,
0.0379829332,
0.0217756964,
0.0269537456,
-0.0016655917,
-0.0255604573,
-0.0086549418,
0.0021172748,
-0.0057943747,
0.0361644775,
-0.0227533244,
0.039430391,
-0.0207824335,
-0.0230380315,
0.0050189481,
0.028553674,
2.509e-7,
0.0998430327,
0.0075006355,
0.0446682759,
0.0355600677,
-0.0127213281,
-0.0110244006,
-0.0113918837,
0.0077599226,
-0.0152133722,
-0.0188414231,
0.0526575409,
0.0145907039,
0.0699244738,
0.0086917216,
-0.0359631442,
-0.0222354569,
-0.0801192001,
0.0060621235,
-0.0313970856,
0.0025298179,
0.0385390557,
0.1037571207,
-0.0661692247,
-0.0096473191,
-0.0270977318,
-0.051928889,
0.0323467627,
-0.0658598244,
0.0547967628,
0.0149697056,
0.0437021181,
-0.0334934071,
0.0316606164,
0.0299081281,
-0.0245727375,
0.0048822737,
0.0220382232,
0.0446816422,
0.0277687963,
0.0136026833,
-0.0097370362,
-0.0493819155,
0.0526350141,
-0.0751855969,
0.1276053041,
-0.0430095084,
-0.0046431255,
0.0663257465,
0.0048480574,
-0.0163353439,
0.0144934691,
0.0015460595,
-0.0134410281,
-0.008015045,
0.0368383713,
-0.0052988431,
0.0116925547,
-0.0506756045,
-0.0144487349,
0.0074453671,
-0.0361219049,
-0.0140874796,
-0.0172586776,
-0.0478030182,
-0.0284002852,
-0.0366748497,
-0.0116001982,
2.118011691e-34,
0.0401614569,
-0.0000952429,
0.045788832,
0.0497093648,
0.0368635468,
-0.010310811,
0.0031637752,
-0.0234536305,
0.0258310866,
-0.1044400185,
-0.0103016831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01152v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01152v2 | AccentFold: A Journey through African Accents for Zero-Shot ASR Adaptation to Target Accents | 2024-02-02T05:38:59 | 2024-02-05T05:45:59 | Abraham Toluwase Owodunni, Aditya Yadavalli, Chris Chinenye Emezue, Tobi Olatunji, Clinton C Mbataku | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Despite advancements in speech recognition, accented speech remains
challenging. While previous approaches have focused on modeling techniques or
creating accented speech datasets, gathering sufficient data for the multitude
of accents, particularly in the African context, remains impractical due to
their sheer diversity and associated budget constraints. To address these
challenges, we propose AccentFold, a method that exploits spatial relationships
between learned accent embeddings to improve downstream Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR). Our exploratory analysis of speech embeddings representing
100+ African accents reveals interesting spatial accent relationships
highlighting geographic and genealogical similarities, capturing consistent
phonological, and morphological regularities, all learned empirically from
speech. Furthermore, we discover accent relationships previously
uncharacterized by the Ethnologue. Through empirical evaluation, we demonstrate
the effectiveness of AccentFold by showing that, for out-of-distribution (OOD)
accents, sampling accent subsets for training based on AccentFold information
outperforms strong baselines a relative WER improvement of 4.6%. AccentFold
presents a promising approach for improving ASR performance on accented speech,
particularly in the context of African accents, where data scarcity and budget
constraints pose significant challenges. Our findings emphasize the potential
of leveraging linguistic relationships to improve zero-shot ASR adaptation to
target accents. | AccentFold: A Journey through African Accents for Zero-Shot ASR Adaptation to Target Accents: Despite advancements in speech recognition, accented speech remains
challenging. While previous approaches have focused on modeling techniques or
creating accented speech datasets, gathering sufficient data for the multitude
of accents, particularly in the African context, remains impractical due to
their sheer diversity and associated budget constraints. To address these
challenges, we propose AccentFold, a method that exploits spatial relationships
between learned accent embeddings to improve downstream Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR). Our exploratory analysis of speech embeddings representing
100+ African accents reveals interesting spatial accent relationships
highlighting geographic and genealogical similarities, capturing consistent
phonological, and morphological regularities, all learned empirically from
speech. Furthermore, we discover accent relationships previously
uncharacterized by the Ethnologue. Through empirical evaluation, we demonstrate
the effectiveness of AccentFold by showing that, for out-of-distribution (OOD)
accents, sampling accent subsets for training based on AccentFold information
outperforms strong baselines a relative WER improvement of 4.6%. AccentFold
presents a promising approach for improving ASR performance on accented speech,
particularly in the context of African accents, where data scarcity and budget
constraints pose significant challenges. Our findings emphasize the potential
of leveraging linguistic relationships to improve zero-shot ASR adaptation to
target accents. | [
-0.0269521773,
0.1150067896,
0.0126382895,
0.0136564132,
0.0165043045,
0.0173638165,
0.0561581478,
-0.0048922007,
-0.0383093357,
0.0132552087,
-0.0570255294,
-0.0577982068,
0.0690147951,
-0.0231400393,
0.0520673059,
-0.0486737788,
-0.0158640854,
-0.0399317183,
-0.0351368003,
-0.0330995843,
0.0197539218,
0.0371311679,
-0.0135324392,
0.0542457849,
-0.0137226721,
0.0453173853,
-0.0259488393,
0.0391634069,
0.0337410271,
0.0131815365,
-0.0506159402,
0.0049794014,
0.0069603394,
0.0060735354,
0.0000019382,
-0.0161961876,
-0.0215586573,
-0.0039416272,
-0.0895922631,
0.0505890772,
0.0302873403,
0.0160144195,
-0.0411011763,
0.0352448411,
0.0019476574,
-0.0316625573,
0.095653981,
-0.0165865496,
-0.0353976861,
0.0337641425,
-0.0124117788,
-0.0188833363,
0.0045416583,
-0.0393531583,
-0.0161043685,
0.0126352785,
-0.0091343289,
-0.0786398053,
-0.0223353114,
-0.0030991265,
-0.0241546389,
-0.0090122577,
-0.0007884204,
0.024405567,
0.002424493,
0.0303691365,
-0.0139223607,
-0.0104576237,
-0.0068867467,
0.035723187,
-0.0421624407,
-0.0133760292,
-0.0054299985,
0.0144206136,
-0.0189220905,
-0.0196787156,
-0.0216506999,
-0.0153426798,
0.0007338924,
0.0219341516,
-0.0217776541,
0.0580759719,
0.0386763997,
-0.0247376878,
-0.0505990498,
0.0198427215,
0.0124951545,
-0.0205591824,
-0.0071400148,
-0.0302077681,
0.001574774,
0.0092372298,
0.0245323367,
-0.0167380776,
0.037511345,
-0.0182142779,
0.0313979536,
0.0376941264,
0.030673163,
0.0416740291,
0.071620822,
0.0394368283,
-0.0697174743,
-0.026734665,
-0.0283857174,
0.0315336958,
-0.019658057,
-0.0131521337,
-0.0139978975,
-0.0010661969,
-0.0410768762,
-0.0159401465,
-0.0216653738,
-0.0180608965,
-0.0022637928,
0.0164713655,
-0.0032895587,
-0.0304233134,
-0.0363125429,
0.0131479427,
0.0142594017,
0.0052577448,
-0.0345731378,
-0.0601467676,
0.0792531073,
0.0527089536,
-0.0047431299,
0.035760019,
-0.0548193976,
-0.0751106068,
-0.0179639664,
-0.0022511918,
0.0536786802,
0.0489160605,
0.0199506115,
-0.0140065113,
0.0485580489,
-0.0328997411,
-0.0389055051,
0.0247373339,
-0.0611360222,
0.0112042716,
-0.0264185704,
-0.0496127866,
0.0051523806,
-0.0300436094,
0.0238343962,
-0.0308723282,
-0.0320383348,
-0.0346708409,
0.0404673815,
0.0563931502,
0.033923503,
-0.0136688799,
0.0674709901,
-0.0213806815,
0.0323515795,
0.0347685814,
-0.0006773851,
-0.0207620505,
-0.0197382271,
-0.0007502694,
-0.0334707983,
0.0570578277,
0.0449382812,
0.017991744,
-0.0069500678,
-0.0159844514,
-0.0066322279,
0.0091894278,
0.0568967424,
0.0072322991,
-0.0263174307,
-0.0469426028,
0.0043417555,
0.0696300492,
0.0209831614,
-0.0206129625,
0.0414733365,
-0.0037497531,
-0.0460608043,
-0.024194194,
0.0170874875,
-0.0165736303,
0.0222066902,
-0.0284579881,
0.0093112839,
0.0889052302,
-0.0685470477,
0.0012756612,
0.0049785757,
-0.0433208682,
-0.0215818379,
0.0165371653,
0.0171094611,
-0.0094616888,
-0.0133092199,
-0.0184811559,
0.0258900244,
-0.0238281079,
0.0066988417,
-0.0297714975,
-0.0178069901,
0.0042040101,
-0.0171136726,
0.0043559629,
-0.0266422164,
-0.0232249312,
0.021605134,
-0.0095597226,
-0.0194096696,
-0.0165036134,
0.0808544904,
-0.0840057135,
0.0172953438,
0.0370222814,
0.0141259665,
0.0727583393,
-0.031739518,
0.0541975796,
0.0047690389,
-0.0346541516,
0.0403565913,
-0.0151721667,
-0.0294804629,
-0.0126246968,
0.0416646637,
0.0410469882,
0.0328535289,
0.0381873883,
-0.0323646218,
-0.0146016367,
-0.0033418739,
-0.0619669855,
0.0251406748,
0.074978739,
-0.0635866597,
-0.0105507998,
0.0327619053,
-0.0406543761,
0.0511288084,
-0.0159545038,
0.0318977386,
-0.0720284507,
0.0668550283,
-0.0341223218,
0.0698720515,
-0.0254518948,
0.0232894421,
0.0098590944,
0.0289103594,
0.0010328479,
-0.0081326691,
0.0404382609,
-0.0389156304,
0.0016730165,
0.0397709049,
0.0481900163,
-0.0227660835,
0.0238053557,
0.0006070785,
-0.0027947892,
-0.0037582894,
-0.0261768121,
-0.0318453573,
0.01101074,
-0.0146418214,
-0.0881247967,
-0.0036510678,
-0.0186552275,
0.0291804783,
-0.0216446426,
0.046360109,
-0.0067147082,
-0.0219416823,
-0.0118763205,
-0.040678788,
-0.0345141478,
-0.0140765533,
-0.0378543325,
-0.0563566349,
-0.035220217,
0.0008956386,
-0.0112673128,
0.0116323363,
0.036640089,
-0.0351020321,
0.012262851,
-0.035297107,
-0.0836422741,
0.025019275,
-0.0030439999,
0.0026871411,
-0.0242867656,
-0.0388149954,
-0.0029391232,
-0.012067602,
0.003342835,
-0.0560076199,
-0.0159553792,
0.0063795168,
-0.0145388506,
-0.0294333044,
-0.0328177474,
0.013510813,
0.0601180084,
-0.0000393097,
0.0086621409,
-0.0508322418,
0.0143836942,
0.0210097227,
0.0175289139,
-0.0741571039,
-0.0121169901,
0.0193611477,
0.0059293816,
-0.0098259738,
-0.0243211295,
-0.0134991286,
-0.0066543487,
-0.0601142682,
-0.0417841785,
0.0399801135,
-0.0599841736,
-0.0395722166,
-0.0389807634,
-0.0239799488,
-0.0146759031,
-0.0193984471,
-0.0064288974,
0.0170519426,
0.0236467384,
-0.0359973498,
0.0234682634,
0.0327802785,
0.0113554327,
-0.0100682601,
0.0321258679,
0.0216988716,
-0.0260602627,
0.000835323,
-0.0521862805,
0.0244483743,
-0.0242839232,
-0.0563995652,
0.0260594152,
0.0246824641,
-0.0396325104,
0.0425478704,
0.0222484134,
0.0288417693,
0.0680095106,
0.0135535365,
0.0152014885,
0.0107578998,
0.0096987933,
0.0117754377,
0.0522843935,
-0.0484615862,
0.0115853073,
0.0492679626,
-0.0481417365,
0.0474377051,
0.0062265005,
-0.057800401,
0.0226002261,
0.0333014354,
0.004606639,
-0.0193206687,
-0.0059326077,
0.0317453668,
0.0235909838,
0.005601631,
0.0310780015,
0.0400412641,
0.0010880302,
0.027844891,
-0.0575685166,
0.0765291452,
-0.0007371034,
-0.0216854047,
-0.0720118806,
-0.0278214067,
0.0443474464,
0.0028841223,
0.0156297963,
0.0114243971,
0.0082530677,
-0.1169832051,
0.0462193377,
0.0458400585,
-0.0477260016,
-0.0154500362,
-0.063924484,
-0.0337915197,
-0.0214887913,
0.0142487576,
0.0053304848,
0.0173614379,
-0.0587559342,
0.0799948499,
-0.0751962438,
-0.0762037784,
0.0098929545,
-0.0597667098,
0.0932496265,
-0.0039916374,
-0.022316182,
0.0059692296,
-0.0312498361,
-0.0521724038,
-0.0245562494,
0.018023625,
-0.0599624142,
0.0374168716,
0.0633705184,
-0.0179820918,
0.0426974706,
0.0228662081,
-0.0220403578,
0.0022899865,
-0.0003985823,
0.0609926768,
-0.0315029509,
0.0484128036,
-0.0013123702,
-0.018104732,
-0.0020141872,
0.0260524433,
0.0284389164,
-0.0219321512,
-0.0082135322,
0.0044097658,
0.0428658873,
-0.0148108117,
0.0195252933,
0.0494190231,
0.033686962,
-0.0432270393,
-0.0489909574,
-0.003777293,
0.0146886492,
0.0513916574,
0.0255275127,
-0.0312009621,
-0.0252522025,
0.0008494317,
-0.0204251707,
0.0125818448,
-0.0333247334,
0.0528189875,
0.0280998908,
0.0280415732,
0.0426660366,
-0.0585500672,
0.0262575615,
-0.033559572,
-0.0192957353,
-0.050793305,
0.0316187218,
-0.0039707422,
0.0196456555,
0.0646717921,
-0.0120744715,
-0.0578293763,
0.0826905891,
-0.0354606137,
0.0426134653,
-0.0025238458,
0.0839836225,
-0.0112633435,
0.0253035612,
0.0130119873,
0.0070831482,
0.0610289611,
-0.0159972068,
-0.0372727588,
-0.0652220473,
-0.0077826176,
-0.0368036143,
-0.0136694517,
0.0280270912,
-0.0603545383,
-0.035366334,
-0.0309833884,
0.0304299723,
0.0118124774,
0.0901309624,
-0.0188029576,
-0.0478173196,
0.0527797677,
0.0300746001,
-0.0177479777,
0.0006874475,
-0.0171835106,
-0.017757073,
0.0082310783,
0.0661208853,
0.0366807431,
0.0273171067,
-0.0038319204,
0.0493558198,
-0.0122806774,
0.0453114659,
-0.0097604571,
0.0297616627,
-0.0425030589,
-0.0315285213,
-0.0146446573,
-0.0014330127,
-0.0263309199,
0.0385538824,
0.0009735781,
0.069960326,
-0.0134913204,
0.0124824382,
0.0723372996,
-0.0280347057,
0.0629883632,
0.0250405483,
0.0236285664,
-0.0020929563,
-0.0198687054,
-0.0577591546,
-0.008187688,
0.0442626961,
0.0110374652,
-0.0063690362,
0.0811851546,
0.0301679894,
-0.0044766543,
0.0397489294,
-0.0438717157,
0.0552594736,
-0.0121010598,
0.0006314687,
0.0254056714,
-0.0087995809,
-0.050150726,
-0.0142632416,
-0.0090212328,
-0.0775387958,
0.0340543427,
-0.0051467121,
0.0285487883,
-0.0062777614,
-0.001540178,
-0.0513158813,
-0.0329497196,
0.0129673565,
0.0203999132,
-0.0580089502,
-0.0024475674,
-0.0235756226,
0.049734544,
-6.161274294e-33,
0.0281640608,
0.0412136875,
-0.0026730355,
0.0273039248,
-0.0258761365,
0.0335201174,
-0.0102150468,
0.0168737546,
-0.0490364768,
-0.0289445426,
-0.0211355574,
-0.0203573778,
0.02123807,
0.0294552185,
0.0087320581,
0.0309906416,
0.0431357548,
-0.0015888485,
0.0090389233,
-0.0196691491,
0.0270230733,
0.0374295004,
0.0314775556,
-0.0414285883,
-0.0530080795,
0.008255125,
-0.0431425199,
-0.0040239738,
0.0171549208,
0.0541784726,
-0.0076013966,
0.0475791469,
-0.0061755786,
-0.0318152122,
-0.0065751211,
0.0044223848,
-0.0927930996,
-0.0115762278,
-0.02913207,
0.0359135121,
0.0076397718,
-0.0345978774,
0.0187995192,
0.0034179299,
-0.0097030262,
0.0087642036,
-0.0223854594,
-0.0494583584,
-0.0285205245,
0.0403284542,
-0.0367750451,
0.0765298605,
-0.0103062587,
0.0130814351,
0.081004113,
0.0269400179,
-0.0277071912,
-0.0257061124,
-0.0539860688,
-0.0124868127,
0.0348970555,
0.038214311,
0.0078178775,
0.0242489763,
-0.0331728272,
-0.0093995277,
0.0874310955,
-0.0975260437,
0.0036534227,
-0.0356288962,
0.0805228502,
-0.0163398087,
-0.0051793191,
0.0390619449,
0.0688156486,
-0.0572133102,
-0.0481530987,
0.0065768743,
0.0504544936,
-0.0040372745,
-0.0273692179,
0.0250604488,
-0.0068123201,
-0.0170787517,
-0.0203578994,
-0.0396945104,
-0.0221958756,
-0.0188505221,
0.040598914,
-0.0092152888,
0.0156469103,
0.0833953321,
0.0484847948,
0.0134853981,
-0.0275158938,
-0.0145865139,
0.0116228452,
0.018259421,
0.0258146655,
0.0309246797,
-0.045291841,
0.004815043,
0.0081229797,
0.0638008937,
0.0093753804,
-0.0176215656,
0.0709796995,
0.06021991,
-0.0729376897,
0.0004726179,
-0.0053796414,
-0.0208372641,
-0.0039913636,
0.0036624128,
0.0149234328,
-0.0167633407,
0.0341574289,
-0.0025479358,
0.0542945266,
-0.0029900852,
0.0293315575,
-0.0004458492,
-0.004598164,
0.0119132912,
-0.021720171,
0.0083721355,
0.0435135663,
-0.0459059626,
-0.0056466595,
-0.0367279463,
-0.0173861496,
0.0064195455,
2.669e-7,
-0.0422219299,
0.0154942712,
0.0512173697,
-0.0618827567,
0.0306039453,
-0.009393842,
-0.0322521366,
-0.0325393453,
-0.0147084501,
0.0171447862,
0.0384810157,
0.0059969327,
0.1093565747,
0.0339155011,
-0.0635244772,
0.0251767598,
-0.0326367989,
0.013854323,
-0.0279694535,
-0.0255795848,
-0.014369457,
0.1032727808,
-0.026181845,
-0.0562420264,
-0.0125985108,
-0.0035630914,
0.0175607949,
-0.0173329301,
0.0622394383,
-0.0568990782,
0.0287989285,
-0.0256616753,
-0.0157043561,
0.0237747468,
-0.0214786343,
0.0463744439,
-0.0149734821,
0.0054613729,
-0.062421333,
-0.026157897,
0.0122572882,
0.020508213,
-0.0711380988,
-0.0506400689,
0.0633385926,
0.0297648348,
-0.0261530336,
-0.0503198504,
-0.0734095275,
0.0268823821,
0.0165182203,
-0.0133932065,
0.0188730061,
0.0030116418,
0.0187093038,
-0.0402699113,
-0.0332340971,
-0.0368015058,
-0.0006632168,
0.052342765,
-0.0350681432,
0.0402687639,
0.0054267808,
0.0212778319,
0.0092003727,
-0.013439538,
0.0220735241,
2.266092755e-34,
0.011898322,
-0.0411779247,
0.0547179803,
0.0165069085,
-0.0247151162,
-0.038458582,
-0.0001492032,
0.0213722289,
0.0279246811,
-0.0325206928,
-0.0463522226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01796v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01796v2 | Speech foundation models in healthcare: Effect of layer selection on pathological speech feature prediction | 2024-02-02T05:09:42 | 2024-06-21T13:49:56 | Daniela A. Wiepert, Rene L. Utianski, Joseph R. Duffy, John L. Stricker, Leland R. Barnard, David T. Jones, Hugo Botha | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Accurately extracting clinical information from speech is critical to the
diagnosis and treatment of many neurological conditions. As such, there is
interest in leveraging AI for automatic, objective assessments of clinical
speech to facilitate diagnosis and treatment of speech disorders. We explore
transfer learning using foundation models, focusing on the impact of layer
selection for the downstream task of predicting pathological speech features.
We find that selecting an optimal layer can greatly improve performance (~15.8%
increase in balanced accuracy per feature as compared to worst layer, ~13.6%
increase as compared to final layer), though the best layer varies by predicted
feature and does not always generalize well to unseen data. A learned weighted
sum offers comparable performance to the average best layer in-distribution
(only ~1.2% lower) and had strong generalization for out-of-distribution data
(only 1.5% lower than the average best layer). | Speech foundation models in healthcare: Effect of layer selection on pathological speech feature prediction: Accurately extracting clinical information from speech is critical to the
diagnosis and treatment of many neurological conditions. As such, there is
interest in leveraging AI for automatic, objective assessments of clinical
speech to facilitate diagnosis and treatment of speech disorders. We explore
transfer learning using foundation models, focusing on the impact of layer
selection for the downstream task of predicting pathological speech features.
We find that selecting an optimal layer can greatly improve performance (~15.8%
increase in balanced accuracy per feature as compared to worst layer, ~13.6%
increase as compared to final layer), though the best layer varies by predicted
feature and does not always generalize well to unseen data. A learned weighted
sum offers comparable performance to the average best layer in-distribution
(only ~1.2% lower) and had strong generalization for out-of-distribution data
(only 1.5% lower than the average best layer). | [
-0.0161922202,
0.0810476542,
-0.0085060997,
-0.0190528221,
-0.0129701076,
-0.0028995941,
0.0193530694,
-0.0111928927,
-0.0566780232,
0.0353685655,
-0.0220706984,
-0.0518572517,
0.0364104956,
0.0495727248,
-0.0262564626,
-0.0450132824,
0.02687883,
-0.0262686368,
-0.0044912579,
-0.0162495803,
0.0108408974,
0.0152318096,
-0.049489364,
0.05959443,
-0.0132432515,
0.035444282,
0.0390582271,
-0.0155645935,
-0.0004226342,
-0.0210124105,
-0.0050565912,
0.0261299871,
-0.006088831,
-0.041307915,
0.0000019314,
-0.0429075025,
-0.0244816225,
0.0253428798,
-0.0372869596,
-0.0180689134,
0.0045752786,
0.0045745783,
-0.0104488572,
0.0393549539,
-0.0466087498,
-0.0390625186,
0.0219315048,
0.0465785898,
0.0560559258,
0.0422717296,
-0.0144143477,
-0.001508532,
0.0403341651,
-0.0173478872,
-0.0504735969,
-0.0446052141,
0.0358224027,
-0.0327930897,
-0.0466621369,
-0.1036376357,
-0.0015008438,
0.019540552,
-0.0112345787,
0.0308349561,
0.0554129072,
0.0260542631,
-0.0274701733,
-0.0496680401,
-0.0304379333,
0.0872251913,
-0.013695145,
0.01182546,
0.0188173894,
0.001110904,
-0.0149314506,
0.0026553371,
-0.0646654144,
0.0000602464,
0.0070412043,
0.0127922362,
0.0257419478,
0.0089583527,
0.0356298573,
-0.0127509618,
-0.0265067965,
0.0327486172,
-0.0085889427,
0.0151048116,
0.0514784753,
0.0164613426,
0.0090660378,
-0.0326806381,
0.0068620229,
0.0250220094,
-0.0417854972,
-0.0020945049,
-0.0187814273,
-0.0279305503,
0.0068873409,
-0.0146775404,
0.0078587206,
0.0050153257,
-0.0612855889,
0.0254393499,
-0.0399621651,
-0.0088916421,
-0.016069347,
0.0444953442,
-0.0156175671,
-0.0213969089,
-0.0352474861,
0.0266185813,
-0.0080075357,
0.0759289637,
0.0473937765,
-0.0207710247,
-0.0598225668,
-0.0358219557,
-0.0501686782,
-0.0290378686,
0.0494728088,
0.0319124795,
0.0014328894,
0.027149329,
0.0158086903,
0.0386094078,
0.0116968323,
0.0687180459,
-0.0025223461,
-0.0831590742,
-0.0060854005,
0.0211652238,
-0.0107181808,
0.0049892622,
0.0618150719,
0.0539783277,
0.0227653068,
0.0010347908,
-0.0062689735,
0.0182329994,
-0.0082110437,
-0.0271655507,
0.002683945,
-0.0511617772,
-0.004898448,
0.011502373,
0.0425974876,
-0.0573668331,
-0.0021805845,
-0.0215267371,
-0.0062968107,
0.0045119217,
-0.0099873878,
0.0357546546,
0.0617345199,
-0.0031115464,
-0.0650968477,
0.0114638992,
0.0487488434,
-0.0288577992,
-0.0173556283,
-0.0603982657,
-0.0103533575,
0.0543943793,
0.05896575,
-0.0194191188,
-0.0281003863,
-0.0255677234,
-0.0634280443,
0.0158658661,
0.0054729222,
0.0251845662,
0.0146755474,
-0.0306833908,
0.0176939536,
0.0767306909,
0.0593502223,
0.0430989824,
-0.011762578,
-0.0327238664,
0.0088533703,
-0.0152675947,
-0.0058877054,
0.0129966233,
-0.0216015,
-0.0297274087,
-0.0637814924,
0.0230430495,
-0.033386752,
-0.0275586583,
0.01104711,
-0.0369797312,
-0.0050245128,
0.0240718685,
0.0507909134,
0.0194262899,
-0.0236821491,
0.0560374297,
0.0462585278,
0.0058709229,
-0.0019027141,
-0.0656996071,
-0.0155801382,
0.0006893555,
-0.0245417673,
-0.0191614516,
-0.0338781774,
-0.0284278318,
-0.0036701676,
-0.0190252084,
-0.0252933409,
0.0160377752,
0.0770638138,
-0.0264119674,
0.0149331698,
0.0739283636,
0.0222029891,
0.0160780102,
-0.0402302891,
0.01352291,
-0.0206308644,
-0.0261516813,
-0.0202206876,
0.0428862721,
-0.0500329882,
-0.0000468743,
0.0228671506,
0.0066382918,
0.0479017086,
-0.0056325118,
-0.0339684449,
0.0033644834,
-0.0075588026,
-0.0398755819,
-0.0667722672,
0.0161481798,
-0.0727005154,
0.0184290726,
0.0061442964,
-0.0070408052,
0.0799733251,
0.0241302475,
-0.0066493829,
-0.0420462638,
0.0313073061,
-0.0527651049,
0.0170449633,
-0.0245927274,
0.010300626,
-0.0151921529,
0.0282748193,
0.0039683254,
-0.0122897606,
0.0017460289,
-0.0813645422,
0.0106498748,
-0.0664388761,
-0.0022690706,
-0.058715187,
-0.0059964452,
0.0116512384,
-0.0371880718,
0.0057580061,
-0.0281238277,
-0.0238854978,
0.0051725679,
0.0153314145,
-0.0767840818,
0.0055800518,
-0.0007416824,
-0.0101322643,
0.0145774735,
0.0332519561,
0.0023892217,
-0.0150823081,
-0.0508857481,
-0.0014534281,
0.0444927923,
-0.0170498639,
-0.0023127377,
0.0315474682,
-0.0318825133,
-0.0475355648,
0.0010280858,
-0.0257934742,
0.011250874,
-0.0214961674,
-0.0735520869,
0.028475767,
-0.0005071057,
-0.0024176689,
0.0021801675,
0.0212743878,
0.0028850283,
-0.0430472754,
-0.0382236689,
-0.1197324842,
0.0496850722,
-0.0109445341,
0.0407968871,
0.0189510398,
0.0029327353,
-0.0041440721,
0.0055957725,
-0.0173460711,
0.0416807085,
-0.0049607246,
-0.0059286444,
0.0045124651,
0.0768493116,
0.0679922998,
0.0327419005,
-0.058151111,
-0.0032617303,
-0.0173718203,
0.0264285002,
-0.0121550336,
-0.0196401123,
-0.0167329889,
0.0385587923,
-0.0132275634,
-0.0344588608,
0.0495051146,
-0.0433369093,
0.0239705052,
-0.0367562026,
-0.0613563843,
-0.0608990118,
-0.0342116058,
-0.0508009568,
0.0037503049,
-0.0129767405,
-0.0279214736,
-0.0200746283,
0.0023105566,
0.0279974025,
-0.0532292128,
0.0313490145,
-0.0343528017,
0.0115252454,
0.0198448636,
-0.0417101532,
-0.0390956551,
0.0094883973,
-0.0173858423,
0.0294092204,
-0.0488892868,
0.0206291825,
-0.021333525,
-0.0109289279,
-0.019221941,
0.09342134,
0.0168941319,
0.0339156128,
0.0204370581,
0.0305645261,
0.0132042104,
0.0554270521,
-0.0112324115,
-0.0139626153,
0.0719033033,
-0.0033675339,
0.0173657723,
0.0737704188,
-0.0342156515,
0.0177266747,
-0.0087167853,
0.0017164027,
-0.0252104104,
0.046099972,
0.0171291046,
-0.0276374407,
0.0121704424,
0.0802966282,
-0.0183256846,
-0.0158667434,
0.0146660814,
0.0150753669,
0.0013198138,
-0.0329240821,
-0.0107989945,
-0.01854074,
-0.032892216,
0.0447659679,
0.0525037497,
-0.0015425053,
-0.0305195935,
0.0261397436,
-0.0550381988,
0.0389870331,
-0.0009619078,
-0.0230280608,
0.0252637435,
-0.0508393981,
0.0457873978,
-0.0488522686,
0.000468028,
-0.0492692851,
0.0036501943,
-0.0298487637,
0.0593372062,
-0.1104155779,
-0.0710063353,
0.036603976,
-0.0107438993,
0.0370785184,
0.0760888234,
-0.0226676147,
-0.0293242093,
-0.0147418147,
0.0190571249,
0.0214933231,
0.0096933506,
-0.0240766276,
0.0764138699,
0.0508746617,
-0.0003785183,
-0.0122202216,
0.0722280964,
-0.0449621677,
0.0018504999,
0.0258806199,
0.0776666403,
-0.0068939882,
-0.0309075508,
-0.0292035062,
0.0406269543,
0.0319373719,
0.0545603819,
0.0011569661,
-0.0389099009,
-0.0071556945,
0.0326186456,
0.0298386216,
0.024754256,
-0.027573375,
0.0590822175,
0.022780478,
-0.0489273407,
-0.0610424727,
0.0324372984,
0.0110460641,
0.0403384306,
0.0527454689,
0.0307203904,
0.0188413132,
0.035419289,
-0.0067339633,
0.0339663513,
0.0638455898,
0.0433697291,
-0.0426186509,
-0.0039928979,
0.0436133035,
-0.0489686728,
-0.0524252877,
-0.0097673656,
-0.0161587987,
-0.0070791836,
0.0206113085,
0.0205321722,
0.0246656723,
0.0050505837,
-0.0516439453,
-0.000126233,
0.0689823553,
-0.0017294217,
-0.0615640543,
0.0319729336,
0.0571251884,
-0.1079806015,
-0.0072247093,
0.0405022092,
-0.0191697348,
0.0720664859,
0.0082220063,
0.0152750919,
-0.006659247,
-0.0175264794,
0.0082210088,
0.0447313897,
0.0680649057,
0.0319459327,
-0.0071981996,
-0.0193010569,
0.0556782745,
0.0271880981,
0.0511836708,
-0.0361653157,
-0.0121368384,
0.0457611158,
0.0287282243,
0.001800968,
-0.0090138875,
-0.0246564411,
-0.0085205287,
-0.0000034492,
0.0608116277,
0.0135713806,
0.0212790854,
0.0223034061,
-0.0013112646,
0.0057714269,
0.0031536992,
0.0515332408,
0.0162374917,
-0.0017076019,
0.0061764754,
0.0097361403,
0.0260788221,
0.0158013385,
-0.0096058631,
-0.0363876149,
-0.0986999795,
-0.052862972,
-0.0413498282,
-0.0061939014,
-0.0215167701,
0.0541380867,
0.0102686128,
0.032056734,
-0.0359126367,
0.0086839078,
-0.0642292872,
0.0526226833,
0.0185068212,
0.0008542197,
0.0123436823,
-0.0033760061,
0.0415273272,
0.0449890755,
0.0534023792,
-0.048135642,
0.0217606984,
-0.0249614548,
-0.0211338475,
0.0233973376,
0.0012719746,
-0.0301191658,
0.0415668301,
-0.0553011708,
-0.0427298956,
0.0789335072,
-0.0647343025,
0.0307773259,
-0.0384974107,
0.0406368002,
-0.005013959,
-0.022694055,
0.0103536611,
0.0094858781,
-0.0524626933,
-0.0341587737,
-0.0118210418,
0.0155795831,
-5.697574099e-33,
-0.0121632293,
0.0325691402,
0.0216531083,
0.0241635069,
-0.0150991119,
0.0460390784,
-0.0299463943,
0.0243816432,
-0.0243881606,
0.0168733317,
-0.0360336155,
-0.0062615974,
0.0235658977,
0.0494658612,
-0.0074430373,
-0.040251296,
0.0526422933,
0.0100448271,
-0.021570649,
0.0107668154,
-0.008601062,
0.0627192035,
0.0486502089,
-0.0788891315,
-0.1064933315,
0.0359741598,
-0.0277407859,
-0.0133266859,
-0.0062300926,
0.0266801436,
0.0124182198,
0.0406513624,
0.0251472946,
-0.0441032574,
0.0033489577,
-0.0033423717,
-0.068969354,
-0.0046418016,
0.0210416242,
0.0034875569,
0.0013032865,
0.0206920616,
0.0568524338,
-0.0092018452,
-0.0208171625,
-0.0314777121,
0.037315879,
-0.0790573806,
0.0013937659,
-0.0656372979,
-0.0151542351,
0.0266732965,
-0.0163648259,
-0.0063072741,
0.0111501003,
-0.0072019831,
-0.0747451633,
-0.0061343303,
-0.0099357357,
-0.0182242822,
0.0186768081,
0.0169420913,
0.0206258465,
0.0046796803,
-0.0461091138,
0.0496970005,
0.0652797073,
-0.0388205014,
-0.0147812478,
-0.0316925719,
-0.0120741343,
0.0973422304,
0.044384554,
0.0130196791,
0.0168696176,
-0.0396764949,
-0.1033627763,
0.007173039,
-0.0009602003,
0.036003124,
0.0003529963,
-0.0282957572,
-0.033913143,
-0.0120475274,
-0.0772601143,
0.0071318275,
0.0073661678,
0.0057367631,
0.0502454713,
0.002676758,
0.0151715139,
0.0009618117,
0.0231463239,
-0.0247468557,
0.0205031689,
0.0166649073,
-0.0016011873,
-0.0163907669,
-0.0024904644,
-0.003437998,
-0.0737277642,
-0.0348199792,
-0.0024271389,
0.0252616256,
0.0571773276,
-0.0056359852,
0.0218921155,
0.0219509173,
-0.0163122192,
-0.0190501194,
-0.0009488625,
0.0264322218,
0.0057227402,
0.0913152471,
0.0216678195,
0.0126184635,
-0.0204994958,
0.034333434,
-0.0752425268,
0.0474201068,
-0.0498596318,
-0.0130181294,
0.0334261321,
0.0303660389,
-0.0793640688,
-0.0305831656,
-0.013609333,
-0.0370471328,
0.0338323452,
-0.0666012466,
-0.0357012823,
-0.000482318,
2.777e-7,
0.0185247958,
0.0164826028,
-0.0064744782,
-0.0431636982,
0.0187684242,
0.0096613383,
-0.0497511327,
0.019677436,
0.0099386554,
-0.0100230007,
0.0189440828,
0.0343950316,
0.0829952434,
0.0255502444,
-0.0486451015,
-0.0338747837,
-0.0973848253,
0.000753855,
0.00852005,
-0.01605694,
-0.0300748963,
0.0578067861,
-0.0126352543,
-0.1019595116,
0.0496520698,
-0.0028579815,
0.0236256942,
-0.0268395692,
0.0351796076,
-0.0027656569,
0.0053046243,
0.0022484541,
0.0108166477,
0.0504001342,
-0.0304521564,
0.057022009,
0.0067981686,
0.0563768223,
-0.0533773862,
-0.0561705604,
0.0189655256,
0.0501698665,
0.0425734073,
0.013090916,
0.0598859042,
-0.0112658488,
-0.0268614851,
-0.0508689694,
-0.0515215583,
0.0018526666,
0.0278543364,
-0.0264297407,
0.0232534688,
-0.0015037038,
0.0117828827,
0.0250317045,
-0.0480907746,
-0.0154331969,
-0.022609679,
0.0499005653,
-0.0526933409,
-0.038491033,
0.0106807314,
-0.0206615236,
-0.0186017156,
-0.062291339,
0.035897959,
2.288032484e-34,
-0.0060987766,
-0.0038700458,
0.0199975464,
0.0170029216,
-0.0189932324,
-0.0055309916,
0.0482167751,
0.0291538704,
-0.0013431875,
-0.0308716763,
-0.0313432179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01135v1 | A Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System | 2024-02-02T04:20:13 | 2024-02-02T04:20:13 | Jiabao Fang, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Xiuying Chen, Suzan Verberne, Zhaochun Ren | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Due to strong capabilities in conducting fluent, multi-turn conversations
with users, Large Language Models (LLMs) have the potential to further improve
the performance of Conversational Recommender System (CRS). Unlike the aimless
chit-chat that LLM excels at, CRS has a clear target. So it is imperative to
control the dialogue flow in the LLM to successfully recommend appropriate
items to the users. Furthermore, user feedback in CRS can assist the system in
better modeling user preferences, which has been ignored by existing studies.
However, simply prompting LLM to conduct conversational recommendation cannot
address the above two key challenges.
In this paper, we propose Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System
(MACRS) which contains two essential modules. First, we design a multi-agent
act planning framework, which can control the dialogue flow based on four
LLM-based agents. This cooperative multi-agent framework will generate various
candidate responses based on different dialogue acts and then choose the most
appropriate response as the system response, which can help MACRS plan suitable
dialogue acts. Second, we propose a user feedback-aware reflection mechanism
which leverages user feedback to reason errors made in previous turns to adjust
the dialogue act planning, and higher-level user information from implicit
semantics. We conduct extensive experiments based on user simulator to
demonstrate the effectiveness of MACRS in recommendation and user preferences
collection. Experimental results illustrate that MACRS demonstrates an
improvement in user interaction experience compared to directly using LLMs. | A Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System: Due to strong capabilities in conducting fluent, multi-turn conversations
with users, Large Language Models (LLMs) have the potential to further improve
the performance of Conversational Recommender System (CRS). Unlike the aimless
chit-chat that LLM excels at, CRS has a clear target. So it is imperative to
control the dialogue flow in the LLM to successfully recommend appropriate
items to the users. Furthermore, user feedback in CRS can assist the system in
better modeling user preferences, which has been ignored by existing studies.
However, simply prompting LLM to conduct conversational recommendation cannot
address the above two key challenges.
In this paper, we propose Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System
(MACRS) which contains two essential modules. First, we design a multi-agent
act planning framework, which can control the dialogue flow based on four
LLM-based agents. This cooperative multi-agent framework will generate various
candidate responses based on different dialogue acts and then choose the most
appropriate response as the system response, which can help MACRS plan suitable
dialogue acts. Second, we propose a user feedback-aware reflection mechanism
which leverages user feedback to reason errors made in previous turns to adjust
the dialogue act planning, and higher-level user information from implicit
semantics. We conduct extensive experiments based on user simulator to
demonstrate the effectiveness of MACRS in recommendation and user preferences
collection. Experimental results illustrate that MACRS demonstrates an
improvement in user interaction experience compared to directly using LLMs. | [
0.0688124225,
0.0095862588,
-0.0181080215,
0.0203109439,
-0.0408611149,
-0.0318181962,
0.0402569734,
-0.0247140508,
0.0529830121,
-0.0329716094,
-0.0314012431,
0.0091005322,
-0.022025818,
0.0401003323,
-0.047675319,
-0.0489363,
0.0075062108,
-0.0577552766,
0.0083523942,
-0.0262256619,
0.0301907845,
0.00456576,
0.0026560589,
0.0389430895,
0.004240681,
-0.0134096388,
-0.0375674814,
-0.0212691836,
-0.0312632024,
-0.0059636012,
0.0329527855,
0.0225122087,
0.0232668668,
0.0008934078,
0.0000024117,
-0.0584805571,
-0.0085018128,
-0.0384530164,
-0.003880291,
0.0015080727,
0.045165237,
0.097281009,
0.0056799422,
0.0065209237,
-0.0359608792,
0.0364705138,
0.0194884762,
0.0572871044,
0.0625492334,
0.0204588547,
-0.017402228,
0.0055150199,
-0.0196372736,
0.0090621589,
0.0256706998,
-0.0278116278,
0.0030544298,
0.0132752378,
0.0473772921,
0.0204232968,
0.0072916443,
-0.0000120777,
-0.0196192451,
-0.0590014085,
-0.0143921645,
0.0195509624,
-0.0226471275,
-0.0519582555,
-0.0081838658,
0.0741931796,
0.0407110825,
-0.0045370511,
-0.0139082922,
0.009162507,
0.0072381459,
0.0140967816,
-0.0381398015,
-0.0163420066,
-0.0301041268,
-0.0119671309,
-0.0342634581,
-0.0026340089,
0.0216427948,
0.0139425294,
-0.0192583632,
0.0796324685,
0.0006074209,
-0.0297315381,
-0.0038816582,
-0.0079321954,
0.0426013209,
-0.0655190051,
0.0433979742,
0.0240987726,
-0.1275705844,
0.0030702904,
-0.003617336,
0.0616398379,
0.0071304413,
-0.0560627431,
0.0384845622,
0.0291239619,
0.0047917305,
0.0406179577,
0.020870747,
0.0197963789,
0.0113642914,
-0.0208496414,
-0.0429410301,
-0.0344134271,
-0.0133302938,
-0.0016341243,
-0.0206380319,
0.0476113781,
-0.0625417009,
-0.0290484093,
-0.0202687569,
0.0698146671,
-0.0189118423,
0.0500172675,
0.0063844793,
0.0454688892,
0.0163432769,
0.0009205191,
-0.1064055488,
0.017700851,
-0.0348847993,
0.0098196464,
0.0249508526,
-0.0336941592,
0.0469049811,
0.019792499,
0.013017253,
-0.0110942749,
-0.0190705564,
0.0435523801,
0.0121764941,
-0.0150321694,
0.026178984,
-0.0202435534,
-0.0012028022,
-0.0581579171,
-0.0699440539,
-0.0474991314,
0.0436092019,
0.046557337,
-0.0008010026,
-0.0087116295,
0.0390751064,
0.0320590623,
-0.0107438751,
0.0718927458,
0.0088169742,
0.0193746574,
0.0280478429,
0.0193902608,
-0.0602506623,
0.0065840622,
0.0249984581,
0.0724980906,
0.0537072122,
0.01772644,
0.0339119509,
-0.003497083,
-0.0293367021,
0.006647937,
0.0196916591,
0.0380823947,
-0.0511459112,
0.043035347,
-0.0048897821,
0.0690989122,
-0.055212412,
-0.0088815857,
0.0818501413,
0.0362123102,
0.0052150898,
0.0573711358,
0.0553881414,
0.0394059941,
-0.0272638984,
-0.0149844075,
-0.0007232943,
0.0578994602,
-0.0320202783,
-0.0404919907,
0.0379556939,
0.0112245083,
-0.0360338911,
-0.0388640985,
0.0473282449,
-0.0337433368,
0.0643523037,
0.0474951193,
0.0097836899,
-0.0409713313,
-0.0666832998,
0.0149362339,
0.034053456,
-0.0477449149,
-0.0246240329,
-0.0355607122,
0.08272589,
0.158382073,
0.0417576246,
0.0265998282,
-0.0229980238,
-0.0053724209,
-0.00473144,
-0.0139734671,
0.0637727231,
-0.0441394597,
-0.0078583527,
-0.0388672799,
-0.0262762271,
0.0406735577,
-0.049783323,
0.0533012562,
-0.0279303174,
-0.0206286963,
-0.0072993301,
0.0542344898,
-0.008850351,
-0.0382813849,
-0.0115078846,
0.0339929797,
0.0203462858,
0.0149172843,
0.0641761944,
-0.0012309058,
0.0263181329,
-0.0139271105,
0.0172836334,
0.0048358641,
-0.0416095145,
0.0333195664,
-0.0327392071,
-0.0399828553,
0.0044036233,
0.0167190544,
-0.0052776034,
0.0025104091,
0.0225713998,
-0.0358494222,
0.0149206128,
0.0029686317,
0.0348084643,
-0.0281589702,
0.026282208,
0.0218687635,
0.0022695805,
-0.0158395823,
0.0343242027,
0.0247581061,
-0.0061631282,
0.032253623,
0.0200905409,
-0.0059137642,
-0.0463971272,
-0.0095244786,
0.0266516097,
0.0369821936,
0.0306656696,
0.0335800573,
-0.0011417445,
-0.0155443205,
-0.0315605216,
-0.1022417992,
-0.0049200645,
0.011445879,
-0.0306509808,
-0.0418883748,
0.0632655695,
0.0155767482,
-0.0354365185,
-0.0427379087,
0.0434913114,
0.0167971086,
0.0204530824,
-0.01298285,
0.0227030441,
-0.0502444804,
-0.0467711426,
0.0317043699,
-0.0093807876,
-0.0033660149,
0.003518112,
0.0185821708,
-0.0497302376,
-0.0255777817,
-0.0433036722,
0.0060023284,
-0.0320006311,
-0.0074664075,
0.0122184316,
-0.0260696933,
0.0237679165,
0.0134198628,
0.0182758309,
0.0594778918,
0.0216754116,
-0.0457971059,
-0.0972234011,
0.0382518582,
-0.0277000312,
-0.0082090488,
-0.0556848645,
-0.0081084007,
0.030042978,
-0.0055954796,
0.001012734,
0.0235152524,
-0.0485889204,
0.0082148658,
0.0520868115,
0.0021603834,
-0.0131269963,
-0.0337774009,
-0.0367569439,
0.0638563111,
0.01111772,
0.0000523441,
0.0794710293,
-0.0204368494,
-0.0366658568,
-0.0382255614,
-0.0340550691,
-0.0411477871,
0.003091123,
0.0052371128,
0.0296071693,
-0.0335169919,
-0.0048115836,
-0.004163227,
-0.0323643796,
0.0444639549,
-0.0350917429,
0.0518902801,
-0.0388974771,
0.0094643468,
0.0132412482,
-0.0492846482,
-0.0220900085,
-0.0576812625,
-0.011060643,
-0.0123714916,
0.0036115216,
-0.0145191923,
-0.0573277548,
-0.0069020921,
0.0302517936,
0.0299421214,
0.0064921579,
-0.0314772017,
0.0086789662,
-0.0229939763,
0.0447787493,
-0.0022236621,
-0.0195596702,
0.0018985958,
0.0849590451,
0.025532281,
0.0064400802,
-0.0299289394,
-0.0334414504,
-0.0160435606,
0.053701438,
0.0114316912,
0.002676565,
0.0365756266,
0.0286492035,
0.0127491225,
0.0087309573,
0.1042610779,
0.0433886945,
-0.1098913103,
0.008469237,
-0.036799565,
0.0061200438,
0.0194718316,
0.0389741249,
-0.0192995276,
-0.0071406364,
0.0009978218,
0.010940644,
-0.0047208653,
-0.0332521535,
0.0075574443,
-0.0846616849,
0.0389204696,
-0.0281472132,
0.0024981231,
0.0306115542,
-0.0377519391,
0.0010131671,
-0.0012534156,
0.0450266302,
-0.0130558908,
0.0088540679,
-0.0283294655,
-0.0180624016,
0.0012486071,
-0.0033790527,
0.0626441985,
-0.0273344088,
0.0478243418,
0.071714662,
0.0454945378,
0.0237105023,
-0.0068065398,
-0.0028985259,
0.0245126896,
0.0019658024,
-0.0118803196,
0.0016593462,
-0.0087487744,
0.0169034172,
-0.0410236493,
-0.0009174817,
-0.0189920701,
-0.0163738895,
0.0276447255,
0.0313021056,
-0.066387549,
0.0121805035,
-0.0117594693,
0.0482306182,
0.0497682989,
0.0479264297,
-0.0005714285,
-0.0886488929,
-0.0112373764,
-0.0709017962,
-0.0493328273,
-0.0272859149,
-0.0258615371,
-0.0116465846,
0.0143256346,
0.0337868407,
-0.0510282032,
-0.054034695,
0.00861389,
-0.0139864283,
0.0045349221,
0.0286683384,
0.0120566282,
0.0061049107,
0.079565011,
-0.0110296831,
0.01022074,
0.0366855115,
-0.0278268997,
-0.0124359895,
0.0543220676,
-0.0591492094,
0.021702012,
-0.0245287176,
-0.0130822882,
-0.0362793729,
-0.0459037684,
0.0933479592,
0.0137121845,
0.0434405915,
-0.0411800332,
-0.0688927174,
-0.0181205682,
0.0051956736,
-0.0553006157,
-0.0336357281,
0.0086152824,
0.0902466699,
0.0056158388,
0.043944113,
-0.0474016927,
-0.0123186437,
-0.0414761156,
0.0112643139,
-0.0587737188,
-0.0859007984,
0.0145917907,
-0.0020986849,
-0.0029052072,
0.0225374028,
0.0439826809,
0.0303036626,
0.0320799947,
-0.0463827439,
-0.0506098159,
-0.0365023017,
-0.0024180196,
0.0008092981,
-0.0546681471,
0.0236097649,
-0.0254369155,
-0.0335797966,
0.0123363007,
0.0080493456,
0.0656248704,
0.0048872703,
-0.02888708,
0.0594878159,
0.0339904949,
-0.0099775009,
-0.0116779162,
0.037799444,
0.0353379734,
-0.0061084167,
0.0922509804,
-0.0072506471,
-0.0610758811,
0.0064416188,
0.020723613,
-0.0268828534,
-0.0545987561,
0.0449366234,
0.0406740718,
0.0117988968,
0.0037387051,
0.0276323613,
-0.0397729166,
0.0282564387,
-0.0463719368,
0.0123309763,
0.005028273,
-0.0369641669,
0.0319804065,
0.0298176073,
-0.0051696845,
0.0198858287,
0.0467582643,
-0.0403658524,
-0.0221279934,
-0.0034867038,
-0.0606843866,
-0.0533236824,
-0.0150924241,
-0.0089640133,
0.0300601814,
-0.0448189005,
-0.0145896832,
-0.0291140638,
-0.015062077,
-0.0160070676,
-0.0187808927,
0.0087377252,
-0.0655035302,
0.0148209231,
0.061107073,
0.0152392322,
-0.0019040186,
-0.0951236114,
0.0114142094,
-0.0543638356,
-0.006067066,
-0.0497256964,
-6.448184547e-33,
-0.0037284151,
-0.0241046641,
0.0516761392,
0.054961279,
0.0097126896,
-0.0777822435,
-0.0386696458,
0.0148157934,
0.0197776426,
0.0020480596,
-0.0315979384,
-0.0097429752,
0.0050793765,
0.0161123425,
0.0202323645,
-0.0029115737,
0.0603153892,
0.0277229771,
-0.025074631,
0.0156147014,
0.0414102599,
0.0043600607,
-0.0288373381,
-0.0782022774,
-0.001108508,
-0.0279571954,
-0.0063297129,
0.0073189824,
-0.0253273956,
0.0639217719,
-0.0032168252,
0.044389233,
-0.0019162571,
0.0017504292,
-0.0000602242,
-0.0102126962,
-0.0324235409,
0.0062543573,
0.0538605936,
0.0323226303,
0.0152850458,
-0.0164992157,
-0.0285440329,
-0.0008829184,
-0.0027585982,
0.0468527079,
0.0135358321,
-0.012092487,
-0.0766412839,
0.0215420946,
-0.0143995592,
-0.0078403056,
-0.0208329316,
-0.0438994132,
0.0087250713,
0.0506854951,
-0.0204633344,
0.0077593564,
-0.0393462516,
0.0380660295,
-0.0295512322,
-0.0126847317,
-0.0262777489,
0.0004482995,
-0.019683199,
0.0377888568,
0.0286661368,
0.0280947108,
0.005857517,
0.0010103586,
-0.0568875298,
0.0697257817,
-0.0152755445,
0.072786063,
-0.0428868458,
-0.0081554586,
0.0091060232,
0.0480751954,
0.0450833477,
0.0246729646,
0.0616082102,
0.0445719287,
-0.0345638469,
-0.0198294371,
-0.0259382259,
0.0166851971,
-0.0527096763,
-0.0784848556,
0.0292515364,
0.0434260406,
0.0253430773,
-0.010827071,
0.0243256092,
-0.0373106599,
-0.0473443121,
-0.005750271,
-0.025602337,
-0.0084830895,
-0.0109300539,
0.0021702952,
-0.0550356694,
-0.0166547336,
-0.0034920729,
-0.0274412297,
-0.0289202277,
0.0402099192,
-0.0044382336,
0.0235738754,
-0.0168839619,
-0.0059048282,
-0.0151908835,
-0.0366035439,
-0.0391446874,
0.0213405173,
0.0204622615,
0.0090417601,
-0.0521022044,
0.0518569574,
-0.0315912217,
-0.0203519426,
-0.0319234915,
-0.0973127782,
0.0112282597,
-0.006734224,
-0.041612532,
-0.0451790616,
-0.046388723,
-0.006491981,
0.0605154447,
-0.0236876719,
-0.0105103068,
-0.0223000534,
3.093e-7,
-0.0465949625,
0.0492186993,
-0.0447689034,
-0.0013255941,
0.017309472,
0.0610717498,
0.0000542356,
0.0282722972,
0.0464722514,
0.02828083,
0.0322776549,
0.0050777891,
0.0348118357,
0.0397542268,
-0.0844679475,
-0.0021345031,
-0.0232052896,
-0.0229343455,
-0.0533598475,
-0.0111974124,
0.0282149836,
0.0487904735,
0.0401237831,
0.015626967,
0.0060176472,
0.0112877022,
0.0459292755,
-0.0785298869,
-0.0696633235,
-0.0025417537,
0.0214663204,
-0.033025112,
-0.006946824,
0.0031497453,
0.0093414448,
0.007485582,
-0.0142950313,
0.0548045933,
-0.0130459853,
-0.0540829599,
-0.0122638885,
-0.0066944472,
0.0190791134,
-0.0186294988,
0.0381420404,
0.0073781307,
-0.0142594855,
-0.0024305976,
-0.0179483853,
-0.0085711516,
-0.0054949736,
-0.0377068706,
-0.0377432257,
0.0062008481,
-0.0166170001,
0.004493746,
-0.0080372784,
-0.0410387926,
0.0363115519,
-0.0195831805,
-0.037739709,
-0.0507582128,
-0.04383187,
0.0103274025,
0.0037300661,
-0.0272868723,
0.0495510697,
2.412659681e-34,
0.037368048,
0.0230312254,
-0.0030777571,
0.0274276286,
0.0614791773,
0.0230039824,
0.0066947024,
0.0222328659,
0.0615192428,
-0.0605892688,
-0.0368840136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01118v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01118v3 | PokeLLMon: A Human-Parity Agent for Pokemon Battles with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T03:22:12 | 2024-04-02T15:46:35 | Sihao Hu, Tiansheng Huang, Ling Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce PokeLLMon, the first LLM-embodied agent that achieves
human-parity performance in tactical battle games, as demonstrated in Pokemon
battles. The design of PokeLLMon incorporates three key strategies: (i)
In-context reinforcement learning that instantly consumes text-based feedback
derived from battles to iteratively refine the policy; (ii) Knowledge-augmented
generation that retrieves external knowledge to counteract hallucination and
enables the agent to act timely and properly; (iii) Consistent action
generation to mitigate the panic switching phenomenon when the agent faces a
powerful opponent and wants to elude the battle. We show that online battles
against human demonstrates PokeLLMon's human-like battle strategies and
just-in-time decision making, achieving 49% of win rate in the Ladder
competitions and 56% of win rate in the invited battles. Our implementation and
playable battle logs are available at: https://github.com/git-disl/PokeLLMon. | PokeLLMon: A Human-Parity Agent for Pokemon Battles with Large Language Models: We introduce PokeLLMon, the first LLM-embodied agent that achieves
human-parity performance in tactical battle games, as demonstrated in Pokemon
battles. The design of PokeLLMon incorporates three key strategies: (i)
In-context reinforcement learning that instantly consumes text-based feedback
derived from battles to iteratively refine the policy; (ii) Knowledge-augmented
generation that retrieves external knowledge to counteract hallucination and
enables the agent to act timely and properly; (iii) Consistent action
generation to mitigate the panic switching phenomenon when the agent faces a
powerful opponent and wants to elude the battle. We show that online battles
against human demonstrates PokeLLMon's human-like battle strategies and
just-in-time decision making, achieving 49% of win rate in the Ladder
competitions and 56% of win rate in the invited battles. Our implementation and
playable battle logs are available at: https://github.com/git-disl/PokeLLMon. | [
0.0239315964,
0.0038126404,
-0.009614734,
0.0440611653,
0.0260722823,
0.0070600184,
-0.0451859348,
0.0081634596,
-0.0470336527,
-0.0184837412,
-0.0531133786,
-0.013112478,
-0.0385350436,
0.0334790275,
0.0302092545,
-0.0537775606,
0.0069715925,
-0.0324861892,
0.0522140786,
-0.0142515032,
-0.0027951566,
-0.0467671528,
-0.0352746174,
0.036035832,
0.004973291,
-0.0049230871,
-0.0751736239,
0.0171819441,
0.0345334224,
-0.1070015728,
0.0224250257,
-0.0513494983,
0.0329048,
0.0040099635,
0.0000018319,
-0.0306525379,
0.0243290383,
-0.0354963206,
-0.0144608179,
-0.0398319475,
0.0087302933,
0.0050199865,
-0.0092206234,
0.0091786925,
-0.072190173,
0.0119934715,
0.0513010435,
0.0587205626,
0.0885351598,
0.0705550686,
0.0187599082,
-0.0173625462,
0.0270548854,
-0.0009354726,
0.0081617013,
-0.0270993114,
-0.022227617,
-0.0464162827,
0.0211849306,
-0.0136871198,
0.0017017071,
-0.0332999416,
0.0401170664,
0.0012403983,
-0.0340599529,
0.0463934839,
-0.0021843254,
0.0267165042,
-0.0225101933,
0.0313177481,
-0.0241014175,
-0.0129933329,
0.0257662404,
0.0098578203,
0.0340547003,
-0.016877491,
-0.0037853122,
0.0374320932,
-0.0191348642,
0.0254926253,
0.0148121966,
0.0119061796,
0.0234854762,
-0.002625233,
-0.0318178162,
0.0794029757,
-0.013669258,
-0.0541917682,
-0.0039986805,
0.0151636545,
0.0128919603,
-0.0288844462,
-0.0008057642,
0.0381208621,
-0.0539271533,
0.0001107421,
-0.0488908999,
-0.0326137543,
-0.0020586965,
-0.0935434923,
0.0102169281,
0.0014263882,
-0.0135465432,
0.0108901318,
0.0023608904,
0.0446317457,
0.012135732,
0.0409753956,
0.0058567687,
0.0278945807,
-0.0186591893,
0.0179298427,
-0.0520080291,
0.0359873362,
-0.0103091821,
-0.0256099943,
-0.0440928936,
0.0210055392,
-0.0375719331,
0.0393742658,
-0.0281915031,
0.0180578418,
0.0195156578,
0.0096852463,
-0.0496924296,
-0.0522410423,
-0.0351334251,
-0.0069586216,
0.0203124583,
-0.0344472863,
-0.0029250977,
-0.0050219405,
-0.0459857434,
-0.0200160928,
0.0261331014,
0.0826095045,
0.0039559738,
-0.0165202208,
-0.0013172709,
0.0229157694,
0.0303660184,
-0.0584792644,
-0.0110304989,
-0.0485222228,
0.022993736,
-0.044800438,
-0.0090461457,
-0.0213342104,
0.0296089482,
0.0015191317,
0.0477899387,
0.077852644,
-0.008514842,
0.0125537524,
0.0027923367,
-0.0071818219,
-0.0570438802,
0.0486814827,
0.0804260299,
0.0001531058,
-0.0170129091,
-0.0062811328,
0.0414105393,
0.0507219583,
-0.0041554929,
-0.0097995689,
0.0022347048,
-0.0272464398,
-0.012439616,
0.0739725158,
0.0244038682,
0.0136133879,
-0.0529616214,
-0.0194129329,
0.0869603679,
0.0582121871,
-0.0051503824,
0.0285344813,
0.0217679106,
0.0020140917,
0.0198473278,
-0.0121804317,
-0.0199430957,
0.0539731793,
-0.0107346186,
0.0017112913,
-0.0467374548,
0.0117638651,
-0.0016453482,
-0.0578644872,
0.0110636167,
0.0144549934,
0.0006200604,
0.0200670101,
0.0417212434,
0.011346329,
-0.0484670475,
0.0550438873,
0.0108680408,
-0.0370266661,
-0.0110893296,
-0.0572649352,
0.0357294641,
0.0984710753,
0.0102817081,
-0.0500154868,
-0.0291908048,
-0.005182066,
-0.0230165422,
0.0991289467,
-0.0258337762,
0.0017331546,
0.0062649189,
-0.0234591532,
-0.0259732865,
-0.0185385719,
-0.0050107408,
0.0440798365,
-0.014870584,
0.0297611859,
-0.0439488739,
0.0532977432,
-0.0143337995,
0.0478000119,
0.0035623009,
-0.0297964681,
-0.007398448,
-0.0063238707,
0.0452241078,
0.0327484347,
-0.0302665718,
-0.0076008015,
0.0387853347,
-0.0043470394,
-0.0150569221,
0.0515558496,
0.0222609919,
0.0187953841,
0.0631675869,
-0.0242404882,
0.0039113401,
0.0172780305,
0.01827785,
0.013072717,
-0.0012965762,
-0.0346375108,
0.0639215559,
-0.0137326233,
0.0251610503,
-0.0058683357,
-0.0153689897,
0.0182047114,
0.0158546511,
-0.0047948062,
-0.0468415692,
0.0184483211,
0.0071332497,
0.0293155275,
-0.0808937252,
-0.0190608185,
0.0536757335,
0.0202181339,
0.0121473856,
0.0135932481,
0.0204582494,
-0.0281933323,
-0.0078179631,
-0.0717548355,
-0.0093174782,
-0.0094720246,
0.0052029835,
0.0121662123,
-0.0504306667,
-0.0225125737,
-0.0153398998,
-0.0282652061,
0.0372103639,
-0.0019937195,
-0.0114755388,
0.0357253477,
0.0225919168,
0.0043726997,
-0.0314614587,
0.037369851,
0.0076415027,
0.0152681954,
-0.0286072381,
0.0149608022,
-0.034514647,
0.0412845537,
-0.0414308645,
0.0608329289,
-0.0232120249,
-0.0924353674,
0.0841789767,
-0.0438439175,
-0.009136837,
0.0319618694,
0.0312063359,
0.0201146603,
0.0941121429,
-0.0056918976,
-0.0486392714,
0.0450330228,
0.0144582018,
-0.0211941581,
-0.0464967676,
-0.0125672724,
0.0354464985,
0.0906785578,
-0.0445088148,
0.0369878933,
-0.0497026742,
0.0067547653,
0.0208398178,
-0.0727125183,
-0.0471974835,
0.015718421,
-0.0418763906,
-0.0227274857,
-0.0476394072,
-0.0140826004,
0.0836420953,
0.003846504,
0.0002942241,
-0.015261774,
-0.0278624687,
-0.0019180417,
0.0610796176,
-0.0129373772,
0.021318147,
-0.051176846,
-0.0017145155,
-0.0115083475,
-0.0381404273,
0.0180788115,
-0.0404231474,
0.0166970007,
-0.0479779914,
-0.0102098398,
0.0353704281,
-0.0373222306,
-0.0216480102,
0.0057362616,
-0.0491834842,
-0.0182640776,
-0.0394823514,
-0.0616137646,
-0.0439613312,
-0.0354183018,
0.031406492,
0.0104357852,
-0.013359529,
-0.0253601614,
-0.0109681142,
-0.0457545407,
0.0703829303,
0.0786401331,
0.0261205491,
-0.0400972068,
0.048249431,
0.0766129047,
0.0736977011,
-0.0650183186,
-0.0317363553,
0.0141399074,
-0.0078768954,
-0.0363447852,
-0.014124346,
0.0227552112,
0.0211401395,
-0.0836866498,
0.0067326063,
0.0787540451,
0.0149814915,
0.0107214535,
0.0036934428,
-0.0669237673,
-0.0016820983,
-0.0082770698,
0.0110755032,
-0.0370975323,
-0.0072150487,
-0.0217465926,
0.0606048852,
0.0167829711,
-0.0253197383,
0.023247635,
-0.0956455246,
-0.0052312277,
0.0231857635,
0.0169319734,
-0.0263417326,
0.0201579649,
-0.0188553296,
-0.0056347121,
-0.0083736219,
0.0280594751,
0.0198293962,
-0.0182437468,
0.0046695718,
-0.0049552238,
0.0749257058,
0.0010562838,
-0.0749960169,
0.0187580995,
0.0587522052,
0.0688850507,
-0.0352863111,
-0.0787249729,
-0.0489547513,
0.0382360816,
0.0346259922,
0.0018439362,
-0.0075560901,
-0.0168107525,
-0.0133165205,
0.0026868335,
0.0002295005,
-0.007551407,
-0.0305414721,
0.0610363334,
0.0488708764,
-0.0223924331,
-0.018501522,
-0.0225019008,
-0.0184956603,
0.0158331208,
0.037811365,
-0.0333960503,
-0.0632654727,
-0.0685073584,
-0.0270041153,
0.007568473,
-0.0360588245,
-0.0340209194,
-0.0010474243,
0.015381828,
0.0097291386,
-0.0891716704,
-0.06992127,
0.0191806629,
0.0568417311,
0.0123184882,
0.0082788141,
-0.056712497,
0.0011371931,
-0.0058590481,
-0.0167158935,
0.0137280347,
0.0194345545,
-0.0327500403,
-0.0429236032,
0.0005573264,
-0.0466286205,
0.0312814973,
0.0418370776,
0.0329404101,
-0.0145281516,
0.023699278,
0.0751793087,
0.0175025538,
0.0165007208,
0.0342041552,
-0.0222364571,
0.0778652132,
0.0174370818,
-0.0060762945,
0.0342082344,
0.0320227295,
0.0149681447,
0.0226426963,
0.0198893081,
-0.0570039004,
-0.0504329763,
0.0142224198,
0.0362120867,
-0.055713404,
-0.0301779769,
0.0044552544,
-0.0155576468,
0.0459061973,
-0.0386226177,
-0.0366577469,
0.0103711551,
-0.0005716673,
-0.023026254,
0.017888587,
-0.0506480746,
-0.0090237586,
0.0075070895,
0.0278003309,
0.0292862225,
0.0125498278,
-0.0052737887,
-0.0442614146,
-0.0150237065,
0.0541887395,
0.0597519688,
0.0263453256,
0.0078179305,
0.0279529709,
0.0366814062,
0.0428506359,
0.0114714,
0.0077460073,
0.0424007364,
0.0569559969,
0.0140922032,
-0.0339110494,
-0.0120284948,
0.0225934628,
-0.0407577008,
-0.0146376528,
0.0546474271,
0.022094382,
0.0712127537,
0.0694809258,
0.0274472106,
-0.0437238961,
0.0065041902,
0.0063698753,
0.0072010527,
-0.0148671707,
-0.0396658853,
0.0148409642,
0.0476017296,
-0.0229465906,
-0.0055623739,
0.0374632664,
0.0304961745,
0.093575187,
-0.01260438,
-0.0072409436,
-0.0241390262,
-0.0121696237,
0.0001105078,
0.0510813594,
-0.0056090136,
-0.0275789388,
-0.0656119958,
-0.0320479982,
0.0075380718,
0.1180754602,
0.0080569349,
-0.0513036512,
0.0195504818,
-0.0040205405,
-0.0043373071,
-0.0117823733,
-0.0370697565,
0.0163111649,
0.0038000562,
-0.0043012886,
-0.0112103131,
-4.74037162e-33,
-0.028670352,
-0.0606192611,
0.063402243,
-0.0088413218,
-0.0603084825,
-0.0163205024,
-0.0552265458,
0.0108589828,
0.0129747996,
0.01095179,
-0.0111267213,
0.0116065368,
-0.0121905208,
-0.0310204197,
0.0403971337,
-0.034552034,
0.0238939375,
0.0002961378,
-0.0193063151,
-0.0308865998,
0.0133172376,
0.0228961203,
-0.0062165549,
-0.0208360422,
0.0164093729,
0.0188799407,
-0.0190157052,
0.0248083249,
-0.0468014292,
0.0441989973,
0.0003639931,
-0.0105335237,
0.0024429492,
-0.00437201,
-0.016627796,
0.0040819589,
-0.0383318104,
-0.0354225971,
-0.0363531187,
-0.0006798701,
-0.0111722592,
-0.0068289535,
0.0311003495,
0.0242014825,
-0.0428610332,
0.0168331936,
0.0045317332,
-0.0328470767,
0.0142062372,
-0.007451701,
-0.0144600226,
0.008126393,
0.0116800219,
-0.0293798801,
0.0386263989,
-0.0196532998,
-0.0321404859,
-0.0412828773,
-0.0525245257,
0.0448492728,
-0.0002897694,
-0.0754305869,
0.0326162092,
0.0740040988,
0.0577196293,
0.0693931505,
0.0510174669,
-0.0117062451,
-0.0571889803,
-0.0222386234,
0.0322766006,
0.0576651618,
0.05916382,
0.0407184176,
0.026056109,
-0.0202658307,
-0.0239840727,
0.0542474203,
0.064777717,
0.0432961807,
0.0138147818,
0.0616799891,
-0.0511509292,
0.0063067074,
0.0277477223,
0.0030570091,
0.0032857321,
-0.0879123285,
-0.0019252212,
-0.0208070278,
0.0050528944,
-0.0596099645,
0.0266925879,
0.0090273432,
0.0075790677,
0.0152518256,
-0.029574737,
0.0199893788,
-0.0175318271,
-0.0431989543,
-0.0116660977,
-0.0297647882,
0.0007094028,
-0.0058711399,
0.0390906744,
0.0455012321,
-0.0076920711,
0.0357992463,
-0.0204654709,
-0.004073367,
-0.0163662229,
0.0209903251,
0.058082711,
-0.0141662508,
0.0582686365,
-0.0610530637,
-0.0050905673,
-0.0030910508,
-0.0355251133,
-0.0761675164,
-0.0315470956,
0.0518532842,
-0.021069441,
-0.005738189,
-0.0274695046,
0.0429314412,
-0.0439981483,
0.0810342282,
-0.0376803726,
-0.0578712225,
-0.0327069052,
-0.0103969527,
2.651e-7,
-0.0357546881,
0.0153339356,
-0.0017556879,
-0.0088197393,
-0.0051117926,
0.0822333321,
-0.0639717951,
0.0352743268,
-0.0137487892,
-0.0356683061,
0.0364083312,
0.0617785752,
0.0288922638,
0.0012665865,
-0.0855847299,
-0.0611341633,
-0.0551902615,
-0.0029692876,
-0.0191050656,
0.0005596053,
0.0352371633,
0.0035352237,
0.0401201062,
-0.0068468191,
0.0394593738,
-0.0038501208,
0.0002672702,
-0.0290002804,
0.0070504877,
-0.0482644178,
-0.0366855189,
0.0190724153,
-0.0568988807,
-0.0410672426,
-0.0024398232,
0.0315656587,
0.0208126456,
0.0283977091,
-0.0273919832,
-0.0132653508,
-0.0089878086,
0.0118144145,
-0.0206300169,
-0.0121984947,
0.0176062994,
0.0346156992,
-0.0046086754,
-0.0471984819,
-0.0240810923,
-0.0418745689,
-0.0733187422,
-0.0512462296,
-0.0333808996,
-0.0210678205,
-0.0343736298,
-0.0188138038,
0.0179316159,
-0.0566735864,
-0.0023353947,
0.023801472,
-0.0266572181,
-0.0543839,
-0.0753532201,
0.0693280622,
0.0096379118,
0.0067965896,
0.0071245143,
1.770558405e-34,
-0.029202858,
-0.0115249315,
-0.0146348448,
0.0138477869,
0.0310496558,
0.0458240807,
0.0297284834,
0.0027416139,
0.0736328512,
0.0191666707,
-0.0058858674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01117v1 | DTS-SQL: Decomposed Text-to-SQL with Small Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T03:21:00 | 2024-02-02T03:21:00 | Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.HC | Leading models for the text-to-SQL task heavily rely on proprietary Large
Language Models (LLMs), posing concerns over data privacy. Closing the
performance gap between small open-source models and large proprietary models
is crucial to mitigate this reliance. To this end, we introduce a novel
two-stage fine-tuning approach that decomposes the task into two simpler tasks.
Through comprehensive evaluation on two large cross-domain datasets and two
small LLMs, we show that this approach improves execution accuracy by 3 to 7
percent, effectively aligning the performance of open-source models with their
proprietary counterparts. | DTS-SQL: Decomposed Text-to-SQL with Small Large Language Models: Leading models for the text-to-SQL task heavily rely on proprietary Large
Language Models (LLMs), posing concerns over data privacy. Closing the
performance gap between small open-source models and large proprietary models
is crucial to mitigate this reliance. To this end, we introduce a novel
two-stage fine-tuning approach that decomposes the task into two simpler tasks.
Through comprehensive evaluation on two large cross-domain datasets and two
small LLMs, we show that this approach improves execution accuracy by 3 to 7
percent, effectively aligning the performance of open-source models with their
proprietary counterparts. | [
-0.006263298,
0.0937620476,
-0.015136783,
0.0430443063,
-0.0253399368,
0.0013681672,
0.0572394095,
0.0004264676,
0.0136666447,
-0.0324182808,
-0.0221036971,
0.0040458222,
0.0023994469,
0.0477208868,
0.0293500144,
0.004633415,
0.0210985392,
-0.0219952166,
-0.0559975095,
-0.000556912,
-0.0456898138,
0.0213780738,
0.0518257767,
-0.0280446224,
0.0257235207,
-0.0209165681,
-0.0011807146,
0.0034395456,
-0.0105807148,
0.0129861161,
-0.0109640788,
0.0455862209,
0.0350778289,
0.0544238612,
0.0000020354,
-0.0398980416,
-0.0530165508,
0.0567921326,
-0.0216942877,
0.0284038913,
0.0482796617,
-0.0411179103,
0.0490945019,
0.0367324986,
-0.0336260498,
-0.0121032922,
0.0101189343,
0.025021594,
0.0632482544,
0.0793086439,
-0.0109456452,
-0.0426351912,
-0.0377505906,
-0.0205178764,
0.0004598096,
-0.0394725911,
0.0170381032,
0.0107757971,
-0.0069455393,
0.0122192334,
0.0058340607,
0.0135960663,
-0.0448171273,
0.0212735403,
-0.0219218917,
-0.0467909835,
-0.0024367683,
0.0186312608,
0.0289091263,
0.010360905,
0.0282458644,
-0.0180222522,
0.0194358621,
0.0233359095,
0.0240684766,
-0.0157152917,
0.0104198875,
0.0075278785,
0.0056578587,
0.0146431094,
-0.0135146007,
-0.0231371149,
-0.0022644694,
-0.0020886315,
-0.0460484177,
0.0154628847,
-0.0103534227,
0.0007918656,
-0.0213893838,
-0.0328816921,
0.0071353852,
-0.0498373881,
0.0485600382,
-0.0209288187,
-0.034420263,
-0.0184325315,
-0.0619493909,
-0.0294156279,
0.0088516464,
-0.0441463217,
0.0292512104,
0.0310586877,
0.0425274856,
0.0440319963,
0.0141426651,
0.0123047857,
0.0199158434,
0.0000257644,
-0.0163425915,
-0.0359458663,
-0.0122584188,
0.0412805304,
0.0009244859,
0.0495168269,
-0.1265345663,
0.029209042,
-0.0185901187,
0.0388575271,
0.0087210145,
0.0373122394,
0.037621811,
0.002274022,
-0.0157341938,
-0.0312587097,
0.0022725654,
-0.035899058,
0.0107199848,
0.0402132347,
0.0119611714,
-0.0563895293,
-0.0057125925,
-0.0397150517,
0.0200708788,
-0.0393918492,
0.0173266865,
0.0327063911,
0.0021411346,
-0.0052674036,
-0.0871729329,
-0.069958441,
-0.0125426231,
-0.0212187227,
-0.0296774115,
-0.0290458817,
0.0523658842,
0.0039934618,
-0.017974684,
-0.1010143235,
-0.0458024181,
0.015690526,
-0.0343921967,
0.0557142645,
-0.0269714445,
0.0225018673,
0.0091304295,
-0.013628223,
0.0459497049,
0.067045182,
0.0192541685,
0.0565487444,
0.0210715719,
-0.0162043795,
-0.0345603637,
0.0135177663,
0.0197296254,
0.0491030812,
-0.0672592819,
0.0849670842,
-0.0082601709,
-0.0138684632,
0.0211783666,
0.0539530776,
0.0121906893,
-0.0255051553,
0.0744396299,
0.026890561,
0.0281585623,
0.0315040946,
-0.0386125483,
0.0668706596,
-0.0140517261,
-0.0444221906,
-0.0348431394,
-0.0293185841,
-0.0272549167,
-0.0105679501,
0.0202232655,
0.0325852595,
-0.0151743079,
-0.0183471758,
-0.0068020071,
-0.0490185134,
0.0202716552,
0.0424821712,
0.022999011,
0.0207813811,
0.0279006381,
0.0349583551,
-0.0141026424,
-0.0188521948,
-0.0073586782,
-0.0211265795,
-0.0400090627,
0.0713164285,
-0.0049684197,
-0.022329364,
0.0186997484,
-0.0358422883,
0.0431751348,
0.0018528169,
0.0061530843,
-0.002434755,
0.0341956541,
-0.0058078109,
-0.0485657603,
0.0424430743,
0.0435767099,
-0.0102191623,
0.0204657856,
0.0127011118,
0.0234371498,
-0.0388129205,
-0.0144651411,
0.0212430377,
-0.018286474,
-0.0320832916,
0.0473178737,
0.0076138852,
0.020184366,
0.0355171338,
-0.0167865641,
0.0014424172,
0.001390636,
0.0289505254,
-0.0220692661,
-0.0614963025,
0.0659100115,
0.0111303022,
0.0010478632,
-0.00119555,
0.0205253623,
0.0395852365,
-0.0497481041,
-0.0095626563,
0.0020609675,
0.0009699762,
-0.0014082676,
-0.0194917135,
0.01522722,
-0.0164468829,
0.0007948647,
-0.0417608991,
0.0112844184,
-0.0323691517,
0.016785007,
-0.0287057031,
-0.0748462677,
0.0299103465,
-0.0322832577,
0.043054726,
-0.0445651039,
-0.0166158453,
0.0508786961,
-0.0156552866,
-0.0048221466,
-0.0240296181,
-0.0314571671,
-0.0164185818,
0.0306308921,
0.0085205613,
0.0748629197,
-0.0065600821,
0.0394207351,
-0.0268772207,
0.0040656114,
-0.0531679019,
-0.0323017687,
-0.0179200638,
0.0052486411,
0.0315774456,
-0.0120959338,
-0.0250408519,
0.0169568136,
-0.0288783256,
-0.0059551694,
0.0437910631,
-0.0690058172,
-0.0321224704,
-0.0345637351,
0.0585488565,
-0.0161349364,
0.0428138748,
0.0110218683,
-0.0238923542,
-0.0495926104,
0.0046695499,
-0.0264240149,
0.0473144576,
-0.0125694582,
-0.0683667064,
-0.0135235069,
-0.0105069224,
-0.0473231822,
-0.0096352426,
-0.0220893137,
-0.0074510635,
-0.0209083334,
-0.0388788767,
0.0493169129,
0.0119987885,
0.0209461506,
-0.0389676914,
-0.0109061254,
0.0178147387,
0.0235646572,
0.0116336411,
-0.0172715764,
0.0321282037,
0.0075737746,
0.0315104388,
0.0097506624,
-0.0193148758,
0.0624645613,
-0.0403959341,
0.0353847593,
-0.0251704678,
-0.0107652498,
-0.0433548205,
0.0252438504,
-0.0125059681,
0.0472983792,
0.0148926433,
-0.0365414508,
-0.0257237628,
-0.0015491644,
0.0450372919,
-0.0614011697,
0.0912272036,
0.0243945904,
-0.0203770399,
-0.011707427,
-0.0373982526,
-0.0070723202,
-0.0514614135,
-0.0306692626,
0.0213890374,
0.0779274106,
-0.040504016,
-0.0379319377,
-0.0204124134,
0.004555827,
0.0345630385,
0.0108274082,
-0.0143673224,
-0.0071962327,
-0.0368459076,
-0.008963177,
-0.0329164155,
0.0079624802,
-0.0123022916,
-0.0003375344,
0.0518451147,
0.0254063644,
-0.0280637983,
0.0049593626,
-0.0294924993,
0.0079112956,
-0.0047249156,
-0.0178349465,
0.0294670835,
-0.002500341,
-0.03797267,
0.0127588296,
0.0749082267,
0.0051256195,
0.0115227792,
-0.0103708087,
0.0495455042,
0.0189090408,
0.0322063416,
0.0269580986,
-0.1450498104,
-0.0317805298,
0.0032563976,
0.0709948242,
0.0420127399,
-0.0505663417,
-0.0095868362,
-0.1068244651,
0.0301893465,
0.0032624642,
-0.0081583047,
-0.0106943622,
-0.0361872911,
-0.0158061478,
-0.0406805724,
-0.0002742801,
0.0101692267,
-0.0303128697,
-0.0126605574,
-0.0025470387,
-0.0035449441,
-0.0691746697,
-0.0203160308,
-0.0500738621,
0.0157063678,
0.0199130159,
0.0202594791,
0.0393970646,
-0.0067971703,
0.0027164335,
-0.002865762,
-0.0334799066,
-0.0075165727,
0.0592311136,
-0.0073646684,
0.0135030262,
0.0045273737,
0.0592289679,
-0.0362329632,
0.0355562977,
-0.0005940672,
0.0735696778,
-0.0197417829,
0.0246313829,
0.0236535165,
-0.0453418083,
0.0149832759,
0.0712184235,
-0.0131067475,
-0.0350439884,
-0.0142463921,
-0.0022965621,
-0.0150579959,
-0.0265390705,
-0.002246673,
0.0498023927,
-0.0504859202,
-0.0740766451,
-0.0362555757,
0.0062375255,
0.0200490542,
0.0022267285,
-0.0034960844,
0.0626145527,
0.0025093968,
-0.039000757,
-0.0606628545,
0.0107707139,
-0.0608404726,
0.0098754456,
-0.0346643291,
0.0507366583,
0.0078729894,
-0.0193381794,
-0.0397590697,
-0.0222664997,
-0.0748058408,
-0.0607616343,
0.0183564108,
-0.0003870282,
0.0118568745,
-0.0012550512,
0.0016822201,
-0.0913443416,
0.002708127,
0.0734023675,
-0.0365190879,
-0.0451489091,
0.0173729397,
-0.0162407495,
-0.0176355932,
0.048507154,
-0.032383848,
-0.0064326441,
0.033135362,
-0.0849826038,
0.014318998,
-0.0065658395,
0.0098402482,
0.0821415931,
0.0627735853,
0.0397878066,
0.0055126338,
-0.0256251171,
0.0569738932,
-0.053335771,
-0.0420300625,
-0.0415713638,
0.0096220747,
0.0371089317,
0.0043410412,
0.0063163629,
0.0106314924,
0.0321503021,
0.0265768357,
-0.0817394853,
0.034897238,
0.0142422868,
0.009293654,
0.0592680201,
-0.0522611402,
-0.0119538475,
0.067306675,
0.0364181139,
0.052937638,
-0.0295907706,
0.0203840062,
0.0084511051,
0.0468980744,
-0.0287460648,
0.0311086122,
0.0052936343,
-0.0352692977,
-0.0327765457,
-0.0333042666,
0.0169366039,
0.0243793,
0.0477952883,
-0.0092447214,
-0.0094690863,
-0.0269976649,
0.0208132956,
0.0247964654,
0.0175662208,
-0.0248096418,
-0.0248324051,
-0.0357391872,
0.0040744226,
0.0961486995,
0.0257438049,
0.0030218528,
-0.0305391382,
-0.0732006356,
-0.0393695459,
-0.0480243005,
-0.0013536684,
0.0034996397,
-0.0305584464,
-0.0535948947,
-0.0383040272,
-0.0250457525,
-0.0077229631,
-0.0009779799,
-0.0336248539,
-0.0123071549,
0.0226208996,
0.0391453989,
0.0306046586,
-0.0396595597,
-0.0604372174,
-0.0190934166,
0.0103289094,
-0.0681242943,
0.0111159924,
-6.308017866e-33,
0.0091777984,
0.0100609949,
-0.0100824581,
0.0122317355,
0.0190447252,
-0.0136977369,
0.0233808681,
-0.0086031947,
-0.0235916227,
0.0076917275,
-0.0526449047,
0.0257655531,
0.0374492034,
0.0462696142,
0.0137591604,
0.0107430117,
0.0472001955,
-0.0463043638,
-0.0253648721,
0.0165917557,
0.0645201132,
0.0198714305,
0.0187610146,
-0.0534032583,
0.0072379666,
-0.008913476,
-0.0533725023,
0.0236769207,
0.0106001282,
0.0099546667,
0.0154766003,
-0.0168260448,
0.013712273,
-0.0252906922,
-0.0277020764,
-0.0115257381,
-0.0577397123,
0.0289423931,
-0.0019285644,
0.0038254652,
0.0430283584,
-0.0374820605,
0.0628067032,
-0.0283815619,
-0.0425675362,
-0.0429527946,
-0.0476100706,
-0.0616812222,
-0.0159648862,
-0.0681041107,
0.0081344042,
0.0389670357,
0.0234041195,
0.0146546941,
0.0836253092,
0.0216334499,
-0.008504618,
-0.0133257667,
-0.023960812,
0.0172615647,
0.0604189523,
0.0411314443,
0.0454925187,
0.0137436949,
0.0069425241,
-0.010176261,
0.0327169038,
0.0134220095,
0.0221793801,
0.0376627743,
-0.0264747906,
0.0696224719,
0.0101579232,
0.0676869154,
-0.0232155472,
-0.0518485382,
-0.1023299173,
0.0472606681,
-0.090756394,
-0.03103281,
0.0502827987,
-0.0066511864,
-0.0885738954,
-0.0423792489,
-0.0442219973,
0.0401109643,
-0.0241006128,
0.0140290819,
0.0040519135,
0.0056907935,
-0.0204519574,
-0.0008310708,
0.047705967,
-0.0439219438,
-0.0312884487,
0.0145874703,
0.0010217285,
-0.0434486084,
-0.0178809315,
-0.0147736482,
-0.0487027243,
-0.0425725579,
-0.0171663053,
-0.0031105776,
0.0150705809,
0.0167457908,
0.0378303863,
-0.009874952,
-0.0838805437,
0.0214904044,
0.0014646649,
0.049137827,
-0.0084862215,
0.0538732596,
0.027437605,
-0.0284055974,
0.0388502814,
0.0495835058,
0.0251339767,
-0.0099081285,
-0.0002029721,
0.0166234933,
0.0402671918,
0.0029567797,
0.0535728522,
0.0136007946,
0.0186957996,
-0.0517304018,
0.0987300351,
0.0255007278,
-0.0108052287,
-0.0003928882,
2.735e-7,
0.0483001694,
0.039744962,
-0.0294965506,
0.0426315218,
0.0120983263,
0.0678953528,
0.0209879614,
0.0437624492,
0.009365852,
0.0278123636,
0.0069347383,
-0.0292941406,
0.0773030818,
0.0343217961,
-0.0577469543,
-0.0184374489,
0.023759773,
0.0108015761,
-0.0654943585,
-0.0097413668,
0.0204679295,
0.0746378228,
-0.0111833755,
-0.0121439938,
0.0196485966,
-0.0405452363,
0.0186830703,
-0.0654773042,
-0.0330334716,
0.0489398539,
0.0392810106,
0.0153048001,
-0.0000713174,
0.0086414721,
-0.0296605323,
0.049408216,
-0.0461121164,
0.1188706681,
0.0185769703,
0.0452326424,
0.0269741993,
-0.1091963947,
-0.0306273848,
-0.0106761707,
0.0738709494,
-0.0395711251,
-0.0284732562,
0.0342562124,
0.0127031207,
-0.0512491241,
0.0125850188,
0.0054283561,
0.0317314304,
-0.0342772715,
0.0354489572,
0.0336952955,
-0.0045918897,
-0.0366902538,
-0.0396393128,
0.0145120239,
-0.0337588638,
-0.0137635851,
0.0317646004,
0.0354187973,
-0.0134448875,
-0.004886549,
0.0335959308,
2.781607869e-34,
0.0098123718,
0.0047988193,
-0.0027398977,
-0.0289013088,
0.0582203679,
-0.0159423742,
0.0436638407,
-0.0168824065,
-0.0019844824,
-0.0841608495,
-0.008309301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01115v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01115v3 | Interpretation of Intracardiac Electrograms Through Textual Representations | 2024-02-02T03:15:13 | 2024-04-12T01:32:32 | William Jongwon Han, Diana Gomez, Avi Alok, Chaojing Duan, Michael A. Rosenberg, Douglas Weber, Emerson Liu, Ding Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.SP, I.2.7; J.3 | Understanding the irregular electrical activity of atrial fibrillation (AFib)
has been a key challenge in electrocardiography. For serious cases of AFib,
catheter ablations are performed to collect intracardiac electrograms (EGMs).
EGMs offer intricately detailed and localized electrical activity of the heart
and are an ideal modality for interpretable cardiac studies. Recent
advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) has allowed some works to utilize
deep learning frameworks to interpret EGMs during AFib. Additionally, language
models (LMs) have shown exceptional performance in being able to generalize to
unseen domains, especially in healthcare. In this study, we are the first to
leverage pretrained LMs for finetuning of EGM interpolation and AFib
classification via masked language modeling. We formulate the EGM as a textual
sequence and present competitive performances on AFib classification compared
against other representations. Lastly, we provide a comprehensive
interpretability study to provide a multi-perspective intuition of the model's
behavior, which could greatly benefit the clinical use. | Interpretation of Intracardiac Electrograms Through Textual Representations: Understanding the irregular electrical activity of atrial fibrillation (AFib)
has been a key challenge in electrocardiography. For serious cases of AFib,
catheter ablations are performed to collect intracardiac electrograms (EGMs).
EGMs offer intricately detailed and localized electrical activity of the heart
and are an ideal modality for interpretable cardiac studies. Recent
advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) has allowed some works to utilize
deep learning frameworks to interpret EGMs during AFib. Additionally, language
models (LMs) have shown exceptional performance in being able to generalize to
unseen domains, especially in healthcare. In this study, we are the first to
leverage pretrained LMs for finetuning of EGM interpolation and AFib
classification via masked language modeling. We formulate the EGM as a textual
sequence and present competitive performances on AFib classification compared
against other representations. Lastly, we provide a comprehensive
interpretability study to provide a multi-perspective intuition of the model's
behavior, which could greatly benefit the clinical use. | [
-0.0077070748,
0.0099003585,
0.00967116,
0.0436520614,
0.0104638319,
0.0306841861,
0.0235228892,
0.0213874988,
-0.0256347489,
0.0043135644,
-0.0044090473,
-0.083887279,
0.0253288895,
0.0895421058,
-0.0135241514,
-0.0618015788,
0.015186239,
0.0030576081,
0.0302417427,
0.0017177075,
0.0143198585,
0.0113313263,
-0.0119860573,
0.0579727069,
0.0177282579,
-0.0181705579,
-0.0101665333,
-0.0172448382,
0.0389768705,
-0.0405147448,
-0.020929629,
0.0217355564,
-0.0067763398,
0.0351387002,
0.0000021785,
-0.0196505189,
-0.0247485135,
0.0153315971,
-0.0570378937,
-0.0194208957,
0.0283588767,
-0.0537442863,
0.0349725746,
-0.0141136441,
-0.072678566,
-0.0017197452,
0.0450767539,
0.0368880481,
0.0745316446,
0.0373215377,
-0.0278652646,
-0.0296019204,
-0.0071839024,
-0.0335556716,
0.0236956328,
-0.0538752563,
0.0125718992,
-0.039799206,
0.0158886518,
0.0259853657,
-0.0312907584,
0.0406690836,
0.0421941802,
0.0617108122,
0.0513905548,
0.0321817435,
-0.0269988943,
-0.0303568635,
-0.0139289694,
0.0895137116,
-0.0425502434,
0.0057224995,
-0.0123743797,
-0.0029807014,
-0.0090039298,
0.0023386569,
-0.0414851233,
0.0064793783,
-0.0076968349,
0.0235907584,
0.0464106947,
0.0082819015,
0.0229254961,
-0.0033475291,
-0.0852534175,
-0.0079948921,
-0.0086018946,
0.0172981359,
0.0126368003,
0.0067524775,
-0.0607713759,
-0.0245382544,
0.0574865639,
0.0100065414,
0.0113507174,
0.0113875279,
-0.0628280416,
-0.0534819663,
0.0084333336,
-0.0312785544,
0.0109089501,
0.0254371017,
0.0034685631,
0.0417349823,
-0.0143224578,
-0.0149792302,
-0.0537598431,
0.0685286745,
-0.0151891885,
0.0302094892,
-0.0465610847,
-0.0279933717,
-0.0235687923,
0.0294792429,
-0.0238670353,
-0.0129802022,
-0.051467821,
-0.035458155,
-0.0267029889,
0.0001654479,
-0.0619593598,
0.0350096412,
-0.0180550329,
-0.0062576281,
-0.0074674557,
-0.0093403868,
-0.005469962,
0.0024889123,
-0.0194846597,
-0.0237696581,
-0.0101131573,
0.0009376159,
0.0235622656,
-0.0282649342,
0.0185256377,
0.0626284629,
0.0286329072,
-0.0076572453,
-0.0233735312,
-0.0546657741,
-0.0151351262,
0.0065115173,
0.0195308924,
-0.0493798368,
0.0349248163,
0.0010731478,
0.019116031,
-0.0551611856,
0.0170390997,
0.0209755227,
0.0034127536,
0.1009197012,
-0.0614825077,
-0.0332732834,
0.0119442632,
0.0400600769,
0.041626785,
0.0192237403,
0.0484380238,
-0.0116568748,
0.0081153959,
-0.0198587663,
0.0217123833,
0.023614563,
0.0200007148,
-0.0541840568,
-0.0247336924,
-0.0347533822,
0.0000782575,
0.0421480574,
0.0401470438,
0.0352825299,
0.0143926833,
-0.0519837439,
0.0204564147,
0.0437958017,
0.0044177077,
0.0672612935,
0.0487573706,
-0.0211739969,
-0.0048369938,
-0.0046783616,
0.0059816246,
0.0036232457,
0.0123138912,
-0.0089847893,
-0.0499689057,
-0.0495882481,
-0.0102416985,
-0.0547470972,
-0.0315554291,
-0.0215003807,
0.0069420235,
0.0022130061,
0.0619499572,
-0.0221759323,
-0.0562805869,
0.0367529392,
0.0150756799,
0.0102533158,
-0.0231415853,
-0.027780056,
-0.0094140023,
0.0668656975,
0.0174557902,
-0.0468573086,
0.021634154,
-0.0594171025,
0.0268349685,
0.0390554443,
0.0188916605,
0.0117460266,
0.0473411195,
-0.0577522516,
-0.0206387136,
0.0122967297,
-0.0121447248,
0.0141708953,
-0.0932045504,
0.0187396966,
-0.0079327291,
-0.0218435749,
-0.0439658612,
0.0415659882,
-0.0297745615,
-0.0557975918,
0.0055224071,
0.0493249111,
0.04265894,
0.0077006761,
-0.0192276146,
0.0064801103,
0.016388217,
-0.0698636845,
-0.0358206704,
-0.0164663903,
-0.0584945194,
-0.0120098311,
0.0258373544,
-0.0337670073,
-0.0117295943,
-0.0000164181,
-0.0454972051,
-0.0081100613,
-0.0286084209,
-0.0371889211,
0.0135009699,
0.0006883693,
0.017676821,
0.0090806996,
0.0526938327,
-0.0342495032,
0.0000353583,
0.0092156669,
0.009012213,
0.0273035355,
-0.0183530916,
0.0367998257,
-0.016189402,
-0.0426728912,
0.017964635,
0.0098193567,
-0.0148694208,
-0.0127723347,
0.0230721422,
-0.0146689555,
0.0294157472,
-0.0667886883,
-0.0055357302,
0.0147547247,
0.0181063786,
0.0219189916,
0.0105516193,
0.0067118155,
-0.0017801187,
-0.0082069887,
-0.0482062399,
0.0174227003,
0.0006350865,
0.0436100103,
0.0656422451,
0.000711201,
-0.0127049098,
-0.0110340491,
-0.0528830849,
0.0966039822,
0.0089951819,
-0.027441714,
-0.025120791,
-0.0066764103,
0.0091524189,
0.0245548356,
0.0028577982,
-0.0534423217,
-0.0036077099,
-0.0342976004,
-0.0209829397,
0.0578948595,
0.0034999265,
0.0808212236,
0.009328424,
0.0042814412,
-0.0050954446,
0.0135501018,
-0.0084746368,
0.0247958153,
-0.0163712371,
-0.0385087617,
0.0002733244,
0.1236135289,
0.0395452604,
0.0005262987,
-0.0294168349,
0.0104270028,
-0.0081275171,
-0.0247591361,
-0.075755477,
-0.0186724663,
-0.0095487535,
0.067955263,
0.0009420311,
-0.0218463913,
0.1027028635,
0.0001061073,
-0.002544391,
-0.0563919954,
-0.0360602103,
-0.0440814234,
0.043522872,
-0.0281485207,
0.0323031992,
-0.0015947662,
-0.0331120379,
-0.0106396368,
0.0300995503,
-0.0449252836,
-0.0505292192,
0.0640648007,
-0.0468657948,
-0.0132153034,
0.0157269295,
-0.000150526,
-0.0466552824,
-0.0399234965,
-0.0157032255,
0.0010979213,
0.0245122369,
0.0371297784,
-0.0405182578,
0.0727779493,
-0.0237420946,
0.0266245082,
0.0036188692,
-0.015200329,
-0.0180215258,
0.0469791107,
0.0027280236,
-0.0091032078,
0.0204515737,
-0.036245279,
0.031639073,
0.04104371,
-0.02167641,
0.032590583,
-0.0660933256,
0.0140372105,
-0.0283772461,
-0.0423893742,
-0.0307711866,
-0.0014289406,
-0.0002152893,
-0.0665818006,
-0.0092427144,
0.1353977025,
0.0264846142,
-0.0677688271,
0.0230740625,
0.0047569457,
0.0041418606,
-0.0151444301,
-0.0209659562,
-0.1160874963,
-0.0301072877,
-0.0016642234,
0.0077560702,
0.0091659222,
-0.0119618932,
0.0156610999,
-0.0239087958,
0.00757288,
0.0304182321,
-0.028635513,
-0.0699656531,
-0.057959009,
-0.0111506525,
-0.0144058689,
0.0018003049,
-0.0484712534,
-0.0196203999,
0.0112965256,
0.0053656586,
-0.0609087795,
-0.0626907945,
0.0161985327,
-0.0072798342,
0.0040042181,
0.0542892851,
0.0161184128,
-0.0511755832,
0.0213481374,
0.0034535357,
-0.0049413578,
-0.0235965289,
-0.0038905868,
0.0552489869,
0.0230993424,
-0.0286297016,
0.0286029335,
0.054234907,
-0.0648462921,
-0.0255405456,
-0.0138096176,
0.0570942424,
-0.0719591156,
-0.0308035035,
-0.043579638,
0.0281334743,
0.0400124118,
0.0503637008,
0.0277062897,
-0.0359955877,
-0.0183786694,
-0.0394658484,
0.0515604615,
-0.0059900652,
-0.043579977,
0.0354652442,
-0.0135218026,
-0.0274975225,
-0.0186713915,
-0.0645819157,
0.0303067453,
0.0103822509,
0.0473016948,
0.0105430223,
0.0693531334,
-0.0297985636,
-0.0433645919,
0.0714101121,
0.0219622348,
0.0599281192,
-0.0131837288,
-0.0440197289,
-0.0114087407,
-0.0070087686,
-0.065071173,
0.0647479445,
-0.0413559601,
0.0150345471,
0.0276576299,
0.031832628,
0.0293205529,
0.0247180145,
-0.0442217775,
-0.0256561283,
0.0176043026,
-0.0040383637,
-0.0071763652,
-0.0054136962,
0.0394437686,
0.0157022178,
-0.0303871632,
0.0063365302,
0.0113270059,
0.0143945469,
-0.0111869508,
0.0201806966,
-0.0196922999,
-0.0177702997,
0.0157948434,
0.0084455432,
0.0218361579,
-0.0052444432,
-0.0276436564,
-0.0181813799,
0.0259327237,
0.0129583143,
0.0195541009,
-0.0297468621,
-0.0054006903,
0.0120598534,
-0.0246574767,
-0.024397647,
-0.0447562337,
-0.0361843891,
-0.0744230524,
-0.0314215012,
0.0920030773,
-0.0131198009,
0.0135607878,
0.031241674,
0.0095329443,
-0.0023080762,
0.009859113,
0.001701926,
0.0015560744,
-0.000355371,
0.0307455882,
0.0158771258,
0.0455862433,
-0.029533485,
0.05408049,
-0.0239586681,
0.0332315825,
0.0012515445,
0.0034173322,
0.0265379976,
-0.0505112,
-0.0056304811,
-0.004501272,
0.0017757699,
-0.0048506474,
0.0405513793,
-0.0307810064,
0.0246762279,
0.0614372306,
0.0088596418,
0.0087432237,
0.0082746623,
0.0875573084,
0.0175997373,
0.0431621969,
0.0179898366,
-0.0737804696,
-0.0541586019,
-0.00440006,
0.0323080979,
0.0313914903,
-0.0316164456,
0.0064930618,
-0.0204278138,
-0.0569854639,
0.0798701718,
-0.0197441075,
-0.0145599488,
-0.0185300466,
0.0752528757,
0.0605091453,
-0.0264318995,
0.0230377559,
0.0260856654,
0.0297289323,
-0.0217962991,
-0.0383581407,
-0.0474202298,
-5.813595758e-33,
-0.0126910172,
-0.0182686914,
0.0136465859,
-0.0116067827,
-0.0185525734,
0.0349204578,
-0.0485273786,
-0.0038853991,
0.0150702251,
0.0435221829,
-0.0298603121,
0.0033789633,
0.0295846313,
0.0399622619,
-0.0184477735,
-0.0707883909,
0.0479712412,
0.0230035651,
0.018352678,
0.0139776515,
-0.022645466,
0.085882768,
0.0734379366,
-0.090743877,
0.0169892777,
0.0317250676,
-0.0007124814,
-0.0348796993,
0.0186719354,
0.0475723296,
-0.0631399974,
0.0602668524,
0.0334187783,
-0.0114158345,
-0.0201151278,
0.0198773108,
-0.0726579577,
0.0014906659,
0.0119557036,
0.0352732241,
-0.0244134273,
-0.0590187423,
0.0536294766,
-0.0068882816,
0.0333287865,
-0.0058680344,
0.0634999946,
-0.0619267896,
-0.0030375924,
-0.039894864,
-0.0035246729,
0.0354529321,
-0.0481059849,
-0.005625925,
0.0451737344,
-0.0247062389,
-0.0449149087,
0.0391686521,
-0.0608546399,
-0.0377067216,
0.0571710132,
0.0196600426,
0.0090154326,
-0.0203242581,
-0.0202419031,
0.0450518765,
0.0271760933,
-0.0193584263,
-0.0384590924,
0.0682091191,
0.0038450449,
0.065513365,
0.0496181287,
-0.0039694076,
0.0243793838,
-0.014809614,
-0.1025366485,
0.0291421842,
-0.0629278496,
0.0368914865,
0.0003856237,
-0.0140287876,
-0.0484697111,
-0.0126251318,
-0.0159471147,
-0.0258182064,
-0.0166648421,
-0.0150420945,
0.0249605849,
-0.0438488126,
0.0238300674,
0.0472981669,
0.0295658167,
-0.0498131402,
0.0173755717,
-0.0189372227,
0.0512329005,
-0.0003783037,
0.018865183,
-0.018129047,
0.0376415662,
-0.0371156745,
0.0239780676,
-0.0033190839,
0.0865473598,
-0.025984237,
0.0129461419,
0.0135787968,
-0.0358617269,
-0.0119714271,
-0.0013328802,
-0.0338076837,
0.000562384,
0.0516227148,
0.0218416303,
-0.0128031215,
0.000464859,
0.0784197897,
-0.0414143465,
0.0267153587,
-0.003576318,
-0.0278565753,
-0.0021644321,
0.0441619977,
-0.0684872195,
-0.0592251346,
-0.0235534497,
0.0271635707,
0.0206551161,
-0.0830132142,
-0.0341100506,
-0.007346971,
2.813e-7,
0.0711970031,
0.0237552989,
0.0285923425,
0.004327191,
-0.009184421,
0.0209068526,
-0.0130959041,
0.0106034111,
-0.0320628881,
-0.0102701485,
0.0291867238,
0.0330372341,
0.0351182856,
0.0138942683,
-0.0586703978,
-0.0258147772,
-0.0638632029,
0.0332719944,
-0.0232097153,
-0.0111914324,
0.0652280077,
0.0901620686,
-0.022725502,
-0.0328651108,
0.0458009429,
-0.004351201,
0.0404569991,
-0.0263526402,
0.0042772484,
0.0218544174,
-0.0240750853,
0.0214963797,
0.0173152853,
0.0319092423,
0.0030601008,
-0.0047093625,
0.0454416946,
0.0580982566,
-0.0588492304,
0.0017055789,
0.0038182242,
0.0184922125,
0.0313638486,
-0.0302739069,
0.0795778781,
-0.054728318,
-0.0554473251,
0.0011646412,
-0.0301149469,
-0.0456824489,
0.0551161729,
-0.0301584247,
-0.0215618387,
0.0198827516,
0.0356605724,
-0.0268834736,
-0.0334318727,
-0.0471199267,
-0.0001723829,
0.0252106693,
-0.0303499438,
0.0053797006,
-0.0049853818,
0.0028211898,
0.0507906303,
-0.0491117276,
-0.0171112008,
2.66545617e-34,
0.0100365914,
0.0072997264,
-0.0011271657,
0.0753110424,
0.028563492,
-0.0212099273,
0.0086496752,
-0.0029694526,
-0.0044848877,
-0.085225977,
-0.0199071821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03369v1 | Evaluation of Google's Voice Recognition and Sentence Classification for Health Care Applications | 2024-02-02T03:13:09 | 2024-02-02T03:13:09 | Majbah Uddin, Nathan Huynh, Jose M Vidal, Kevin M Taaffe, Lawrence D Fredendall, Joel S Greenstein | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This study examined the use of voice recognition technology in perioperative
services (Periop) to enable Periop staff to record workflow milestones using
mobile technology. The use of mobile technology to improve patient flow and
quality of care could be facilitated if such voice recognition technology could
be made robust. The goal of this experiment was to allow the Periop staff to
provide care without being interrupted with data entry and querying tasks.
However, the results are generalizable to other situations where an engineering
manager attempts to improve communication performance using mobile technology.
This study enhanced Google's voice recognition capability by using
post-processing classifiers (i.e., bag-of-sentences, support vector machine,
and maximum entropy). The experiments investigated three factors (original
phrasing, reduced phrasing, and personalized phrasing) at three levels (zero
training repetition, 5 training repetitions, and 10 training repetitions).
Results indicated that personal phrasing yielded the highest correctness and
that training the device to recognize an individual's voice improved
correctness as well. Although simplistic, the bag-of-sentences classifier
significantly improved voice recognition correctness. The classification
efficiency of the maximum entropy and support vector machine algorithms was
found to be nearly identical. These results suggest that engineering managers
could significantly enhance Google's voice recognition technology by using
post-processing techniques, which would facilitate its use in health care and
other applications. | Evaluation of Google's Voice Recognition and Sentence Classification for Health Care Applications: This study examined the use of voice recognition technology in perioperative
services (Periop) to enable Periop staff to record workflow milestones using
mobile technology. The use of mobile technology to improve patient flow and
quality of care could be facilitated if such voice recognition technology could
be made robust. The goal of this experiment was to allow the Periop staff to
provide care without being interrupted with data entry and querying tasks.
However, the results are generalizable to other situations where an engineering
manager attempts to improve communication performance using mobile technology.
This study enhanced Google's voice recognition capability by using
post-processing classifiers (i.e., bag-of-sentences, support vector machine,
and maximum entropy). The experiments investigated three factors (original
phrasing, reduced phrasing, and personalized phrasing) at three levels (zero
training repetition, 5 training repetitions, and 10 training repetitions).
Results indicated that personal phrasing yielded the highest correctness and
that training the device to recognize an individual's voice improved
correctness as well. Although simplistic, the bag-of-sentences classifier
significantly improved voice recognition correctness. The classification
efficiency of the maximum entropy and support vector machine algorithms was
found to be nearly identical. These results suggest that engineering managers
could significantly enhance Google's voice recognition technology by using
post-processing techniques, which would facilitate its use in health care and
other applications. | [
0.0648658052,
0.0055177482,
-0.049013406,
-0.03555049,
-0.024675712,
0.0007251253,
0.0457351096,
-0.0008694528,
0.0058876541,
-0.0822295398,
0.0358193815,
-0.0296366699,
0.0322692208,
-0.0010536993,
0.0151878484,
-0.065605998,
0.0207175892,
0.0222081076,
0.0274573471,
0.0241271649,
-0.0077576474,
0.0262546614,
-0.0237870794,
0.0546651818,
-0.0063671847,
0.0194161143,
0.0208327062,
0.0059915944,
0.0321696214,
-0.0661138073,
-0.0117768832,
0.0054001701,
-0.0316100083,
0.0082288682,
0.0000018365,
-0.0368532278,
-0.0105139194,
0.034771163,
-0.0659164935,
-0.0544965975,
0.0401479155,
0.0160194635,
-0.0304579064,
0.053423848,
-0.0122929104,
-0.0198891889,
0.0623293668,
0.0745170787,
0.0086831124,
0.0562138818,
-0.0401193462,
-0.0270109978,
0.0129513303,
0.0177487861,
0.0057246066,
-0.045603931,
0.0031118882,
-0.0193201788,
0.0341835171,
-0.0455191992,
0.0559612624,
0.0236716159,
-0.0177049879,
0.0331671461,
0.0105681485,
0.0450996794,
-0.0258936509,
0.0007212158,
-0.0294319987,
0.0068143853,
-0.006762235,
0.0099749714,
-0.0097106295,
-0.0046910965,
-0.0221229903,
-0.0206548609,
0.008120006,
-0.0413829908,
-0.0301563535,
-0.0140034435,
-0.0456439815,
0.0324171744,
-0.0017111914,
-0.0299073029,
0.0023293837,
-0.045773644,
-0.0151671479,
-0.0735352188,
0.03335445,
0.0234473888,
-0.0057384088,
0.0315175802,
0.0310707353,
0.0211637355,
-0.017719578,
0.0159062035,
-0.0143463481,
-0.0546383969,
0.0357791521,
-0.0877824649,
0.0212076921,
0.0086561637,
0.006027868,
0.00398847,
0.0021487107,
0.0123528987,
0.0033740462,
0.0139223021,
-0.0406998247,
0.04658705,
-0.0787023231,
-0.0094938129,
-0.0076601766,
0.041198466,
0.0344095007,
-0.0278459731,
-0.0814646482,
-0.0135611892,
0.025126135,
0.0042553432,
-0.0033469249,
0.0144280428,
-0.0003266929,
0.0371180587,
-0.0079310015,
-0.0194435976,
0.0105780717,
0.0724498034,
-0.0312260147,
-0.0528861471,
0.0594284907,
-0.0041830749,
0.0471711196,
0.0334702469,
0.0236572865,
-0.0067198123,
-0.0223755799,
-0.0383447483,
-0.0782124996,
-0.0256146938,
-0.0197961275,
-0.0162683781,
-0.008689126,
-0.012526487,
-0.0062984256,
0.020178929,
-0.0157883652,
0.0102679729,
0.0341938511,
0.0021314868,
-0.0235086977,
0.0242431704,
-0.0343845673,
0.0179459117,
0.067520082,
0.0099387709,
0.0300746616,
0.0124457926,
0.0209365021,
-0.0383001268,
0.0161760468,
-0.0609835647,
0.0010706942,
0.0242512375,
-0.0592607819,
-0.0783450231,
0.0236645713,
-0.0120158996,
-0.0088028312,
-0.0045385063,
-0.02437016,
0.0727083236,
0.0206855368,
0.0879048333,
0.0507446788,
0.0635238066,
0.0453483723,
0.0055067558,
-0.0241180696,
0.0179060772,
0.0037137528,
-0.0319777243,
0.0247170217,
-0.0623228438,
0.0028848117,
-0.0048595187,
-0.0046825381,
0.0044160658,
-0.0425016917,
-0.0366358459,
-0.0484803319,
-0.0368864685,
-0.0384409763,
0.0316792801,
0.0380053222,
-0.0256080776,
-0.0383118205,
0.0196070354,
-0.0138891907,
-0.0393451974,
-0.0486484692,
-0.0319779739,
-0.0207056552,
0.1184505969,
0.0417352132,
-0.0552394092,
0.0142226554,
-0.0711658895,
-0.0549166501,
-0.0016653612,
0.0058981655,
0.0061485381,
-0.0056753834,
-0.0365382321,
0.0079684863,
0.0581569411,
0.0057730014,
-0.0252422281,
-0.0155682871,
0.0648003891,
0.0241606999,
0.0265539829,
-0.0387391709,
0.0241499636,
0.0505753346,
-0.0555217862,
0.0190669242,
0.0096413251,
0.0413086154,
0.0697509572,
-0.0305537432,
-0.0074347691,
0.0264215898,
-0.0260773823,
-0.0095649604,
0.0471525565,
-0.0173101891,
0.0383053944,
-0.0059313914,
0.0144486213,
-0.0015296418,
0.0194234625,
-0.0047147619,
-0.0392542817,
-0.0423169658,
-0.067266874,
0.0371064842,
-0.0354913063,
0.0637053251,
0.0093474211,
0.0068540243,
-0.0415784307,
-0.0004454801,
0.0256725326,
0.0045630094,
-0.0469559692,
-0.0211250782,
0.038585905,
-0.0437166654,
-0.0081116296,
0.0463963486,
-0.0346923955,
0.0736426786,
-0.0096085034,
0.0100794267,
-0.0125504239,
-0.003365072,
-0.118760936,
-0.0437909476,
0.0012777013,
0.0066970186,
0.0213392228,
0.014812056,
0.0226334874,
-0.0392716601,
-0.0245159883,
-0.0235440545,
0.0041265981,
-0.0175715107,
0.0187286306,
-0.0068049096,
-0.0043132673,
0.0011509708,
-0.0042697843,
-0.03309194,
0.0299367141,
0.0344687104,
-0.0241273586,
-0.042854283,
-0.0069845892,
0.0185269043,
-0.0152385617,
0.0108488789,
-0.0125172818,
-0.0044156704,
0.0083967559,
0.0164013915,
0.0284420326,
0.0320435949,
-0.0153505132,
-0.0068438589,
0.0494832657,
0.0341236219,
-0.0027934294,
-0.0103339916,
0.0063986341,
-0.020133229,
-0.0333361775,
0.0014787713,
-0.0114004873,
0.0160911698,
0.0687234327,
0.0058937706,
-0.0250220355,
-0.0258326475,
-0.0105925426,
-0.0324322619,
0.0028556751,
-0.0610175133,
0.045039963,
0.0293936804,
-0.0289158262,
0.0298437923,
-0.0014794873,
0.0127956057,
-0.098914966,
-0.0600356236,
0.0072098933,
0.0449286103,
-0.0869383663,
0.0322136059,
0.0343507789,
-0.0587711185,
0.012835796,
-0.0036168857,
-0.0273596644,
-0.0628606975,
-0.0155122085,
0.0085401367,
0.0106747476,
0.00037675,
-0.0514751785,
-0.0511464924,
-0.0219224785,
-0.0497315563,
0.0079337517,
0.0469677225,
-0.0050429036,
-0.0306350105,
0.0782936588,
0.0044055777,
0.0584040284,
0.0381975621,
-0.0050113825,
0.0212301146,
0.0132671371,
-0.0006487324,
0.0474753864,
-0.0345081501,
0.0483999625,
0.0544849411,
0.0058419826,
0.0575599112,
-0.0081788134,
-0.0137588773,
-0.0393157527,
0.0023661277,
-0.0496476404,
-0.0324526094,
0.0444009714,
0.0432166979,
-0.0335733145,
0.0362576433,
0.0632224828,
0.0175045207,
-0.0614879429,
-0.0067100516,
0.0141627043,
-0.0883713216,
0.0039066738,
0.0359039791,
-0.0163060222,
0.0005843067,
-0.0029484662,
0.0527176224,
-0.0129880561,
0.0370292366,
0.007798085,
-0.0480144098,
0.0482145846,
0.0043735462,
-0.0367212705,
-0.0305139534,
-0.0267987773,
-0.0062410724,
0.0136366077,
-0.0025425898,
-0.0408319645,
-0.0401639566,
-0.0347447582,
0.0158040859,
-0.1150291115,
-0.0813989416,
0.0171343535,
0.0015905199,
-0.0000897468,
0.135465771,
0.0242103953,
-0.0250118095,
-0.0482570082,
0.0130393486,
-0.01007469,
0.0571199358,
-0.0089505883,
0.0620542616,
0.0012887728,
0.0146619305,
0.0241817646,
-0.0028406312,
-0.0322159119,
0.0149448141,
0.0488207154,
0.0635377243,
-0.0406570062,
-0.021258356,
-0.0209028441,
0.0450114273,
0.0230382215,
0.0044638263,
-0.0181783773,
-0.0260317903,
-0.0696232319,
0.0268326048,
0.0335092284,
0.0425310656,
0.0204221588,
0.0293698348,
-0.0082357842,
-0.0847275257,
-0.0278441831,
-0.0267792437,
0.0076559321,
0.0511458032,
0.0442158096,
0.0475482792,
0.0301633421,
0.090846613,
-0.0502586178,
-0.0530041717,
0.0428555571,
0.0565933213,
-0.0512778684,
-0.0253450666,
0.0114289848,
0.0127822077,
-0.0076121283,
-0.0552156866,
0.0365773924,
-0.0327199474,
0.0368616395,
0.0249889735,
0.0255865417,
-0.0041432772,
-0.0200414397,
-0.0590541139,
0.0279153474,
0.0475572012,
-0.0631193295,
0.0158147644,
0.0232566018,
0.0104806824,
-0.0207179282,
-0.0278479885,
0.0000790294,
0.0327297747,
-0.0094419559,
-0.0246872585,
-0.0474231467,
-0.0580979176,
-0.0009017527,
0.0312179383,
0.0237978473,
-0.003358328,
-0.0319304504,
-0.0053390698,
0.0396830253,
0.0298382249,
0.0304023158,
0.0003754291,
-0.0301698782,
-0.0235106573,
0.0262794755,
0.0217050668,
0.0131412214,
-0.0846399888,
-0.0527148619,
-0.0040633148,
0.044381775,
0.0100885723,
0.0553514957,
-0.0146267898,
0.0137064839,
-0.0239171609,
-0.0166126266,
0.0459582657,
0.0196520016,
0.0279478729,
0.0441090725,
-0.0305968467,
0.0231095981,
-0.0277418047,
0.0602846332,
-0.0559359491,
-0.0510980301,
-0.0065039471,
-0.0168711189,
0.0416343883,
0.003476525,
-0.03354479,
-0.0211906284,
0.0110102911,
-0.0477329008,
0.0247277562,
-0.0105627254,
0.0397035629,
0.0035485737,
0.0047097183,
-0.0439793877,
-0.0100741656,
0.0456507392,
-0.007953777,
-0.0070845638,
-0.0453808792,
-0.0273582898,
-0.0579468086,
-0.0122423125,
0.0399703979,
0.0676788539,
-0.0490970127,
-0.0224968288,
-0.0439566821,
-0.0129658906,
0.050156109,
-0.0687947869,
0.0468470305,
-0.0689806491,
0.0429403856,
0.0494071171,
0.0116459057,
-0.0020436402,
-0.0250291135,
-0.0283583924,
-0.0345177203,
0.043836765,
-0.0092864614,
-5.539709248e-33,
0.0244927946,
-0.0386984423,
-0.0163535327,
0.0435232632,
-0.0040617264,
0.0203548912,
0.0212430451,
0.0460782498,
0.01139371,
-0.0352962911,
-0.0395007133,
-0.002062666,
0.0245446749,
-0.0069547356,
0.0163713731,
-0.0170607101,
0.097667262,
-0.0116542056,
0.0035981301,
0.0213804003,
0.0112084299,
0.0749553218,
0.0459502041,
-0.1071044356,
-0.0017764556,
0.0282093473,
-0.0185505915,
-0.0499224104,
0.0643157884,
-0.0137192216,
0.0111135645,
0.0352746844,
0.0371915847,
-0.0230883062,
0.0182862021,
0.0818527192,
-0.0289680157,
0.0039811684,
0.0024282211,
0.0392397419,
-0.0104186144,
-0.0286765676,
0.0459653065,
-0.0293885246,
-0.0635691807,
0.0168073084,
0.0573245399,
-0.0152328992,
-0.0404456034,
-0.0598808676,
-0.0118519757,
0.0116543882,
-0.0003924932,
0.0018616802,
0.0051583238,
0.0462551974,
-0.0634548515,
-0.0028995248,
-0.0303802527,
0.0178601258,
0.0006619273,
-0.0187968947,
-0.0140729556,
0.0390406027,
-0.0121040549,
0.0283704139,
0.045796115,
-0.0219335929,
-0.0327650234,
-0.0147310691,
-0.0184429046,
0.0368040018,
0.0516188666,
0.0011595768,
0.0504090041,
-0.0730771869,
-0.0251238178,
0.0241423827,
-0.0126204323,
-0.0198983923,
0.0307879075,
-0.0039972709,
-0.0698726326,
-0.0156772286,
0.0035433671,
-0.0069385441,
-0.0107292784,
-0.0253944024,
0.0330324434,
-0.0019948129,
-0.0105900159,
0.0321650505,
0.007887939,
-0.0194283668,
0.0496776141,
-0.0652342513,
0.009085251,
0.0169094186,
-0.0258552656,
-0.0558488816,
-0.0833122358,
-0.0185075309,
0.0223116893,
0.0594189391,
0.0476162098,
-0.0186598618,
0.0230333395,
-0.0055689807,
-0.0573771968,
-0.0040548667,
0.0637029856,
0.0148639791,
-0.0097002462,
-0.0081987977,
0.0273006149,
-0.0045210309,
0.0165907498,
0.0433184318,
-0.015259169,
0.0108649544,
-0.0374123827,
-0.041869361,
-0.0062282621,
0.0086787688,
-0.0302769803,
-0.0010598464,
-0.0537272468,
0.02381997,
-0.0005570641,
0.0003487613,
-0.0001194771,
-0.0112406584,
2.646e-7,
0.037983004,
0.0337970741,
-0.0165685005,
-0.0170376357,
0.0410008654,
0.0158263482,
0.0452070124,
-0.0225769207,
-0.0091662062,
0.0478348024,
0.0605654083,
-0.0436038785,
0.0636042431,
0.011884965,
-0.0730933771,
-0.0662576184,
-0.0475147143,
0.0233968198,
-0.056201227,
0.0618275851,
0.0941296145,
0.064240858,
-0.0224065986,
-0.0470894463,
-0.0076213325,
-0.0171569698,
0.01233098,
-0.0201032013,
0.0662899688,
-0.028304534,
0.0466419086,
0.0370268114,
-0.0174920931,
0.0515634269,
-0.0194263849,
-0.0149296438,
0.0049058213,
0.0382229835,
-0.0610962771,
-0.0014190748,
0.0104947248,
0.0226368997,
0.0231768731,
-0.0171718001,
0.0313790664,
-0.0080914935,
-0.0451859795,
-0.0122054815,
-0.0161038395,
-0.0415566005,
0.0537901223,
0.0113446694,
-0.0069122445,
-0.0021351629,
-0.0081452094,
-0.0223444942,
-0.0378162339,
-0.0255222693,
0.0218436159,
0.0262117423,
-0.0043411292,
-0.0476793833,
0.0201873928,
-0.0080594933,
0.0226395056,
-0.0016284485,
0.0369325541,
1.892875824e-34,
0.0188224707,
-0.0047496636,
-0.0042797527,
0.0484727249,
0.0051425477,
0.0039608576,
0.0595440827,
0.0145423403,
0.0109322108,
-0.0303328391,
0.0001139255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01109v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01109v3 | Vaccine: Perturbation-aware Alignment for Large Language Model | 2024-02-02T02:56:50 | 2024-02-29T07:15:13 | Tiansheng Huang, Sihao Hu, Ling Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The new paradigm of finetuning-as-a-service introduces a new attack surface
for Large Language Models (LLMs): a few harmful data uploaded by users can
easily trick the finetuning to produce an alignment-broken model. We conduct an
empirical analysis and uncover a \textit{harmful embedding drift} phenomenon,
showing a probable cause of the alignment-broken effect. Inspired by our
findings, we propose Vaccine, a perturbation-aware alignment technique to
mitigate the security risk of users finetuning. The core idea of Vaccine is to
produce invariant hidden embeddings by progressively adding crafted
perturbation to them in the alignment phase. This enables the embeddings to
withstand harmful perturbation from un-sanitized user data in the finetuning
phase. Our results on open source mainstream LLMs (e.g., Llama2, Opt, Vicuna)
demonstrate that Vaccine can boost the robustness of alignment against harmful
prompts induced embedding drift while reserving reasoning ability towards
benign prompts. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/git-disl/Vaccine}. | Vaccine: Perturbation-aware Alignment for Large Language Model: The new paradigm of finetuning-as-a-service introduces a new attack surface
for Large Language Models (LLMs): a few harmful data uploaded by users can
easily trick the finetuning to produce an alignment-broken model. We conduct an
empirical analysis and uncover a \textit{harmful embedding drift} phenomenon,
showing a probable cause of the alignment-broken effect. Inspired by our
findings, we propose Vaccine, a perturbation-aware alignment technique to
mitigate the security risk of users finetuning. The core idea of Vaccine is to
produce invariant hidden embeddings by progressively adding crafted
perturbation to them in the alignment phase. This enables the embeddings to
withstand harmful perturbation from un-sanitized user data in the finetuning
phase. Our results on open source mainstream LLMs (e.g., Llama2, Opt, Vicuna)
demonstrate that Vaccine can boost the robustness of alignment against harmful
prompts induced embedding drift while reserving reasoning ability towards
benign prompts. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/git-disl/Vaccine}. | [
0.0011265796,
0.0646190271,
-0.0178641155,
0.0625250265,
-0.0194243528,
0.0062500639,
0.0235147979,
-0.0323814303,
0.0097585088,
0.0117626833,
0.0026131063,
-0.0085100252,
0.0016050393,
0.0091028698,
0.0591496006,
0.0220019035,
0.0806744844,
-0.0247444753,
-0.0188969355,
-0.016311856,
0.0216267053,
-0.0301653277,
0.0204282086,
-0.0065057892,
0.0203192402,
-0.0292446259,
-0.0347424224,
0.0281082131,
0.0385369137,
-0.0044852695,
-0.010356308,
0.0503280982,
-0.013336652,
0.1202104613,
0.0000019503,
-0.0392178111,
-0.060619209,
0.0544583835,
-0.0504048169,
0.0386775918,
0.0171237979,
-0.0248687863,
-0.0601089112,
0.0262663569,
-0.0268660579,
0.0241085943,
0.0856067613,
-0.0242412444,
0.1092037186,
0.078735657,
-0.002397507,
-0.0212939419,
0.0006899668,
-0.017366074,
-0.0357589461,
-0.0370365456,
0.0202045236,
-0.0250201598,
-0.0310867447,
0.0173238441,
-0.029637089,
0.0261718109,
-0.0133199031,
-0.047657866,
-0.014045639,
-0.0006847399,
-0.0560593344,
-0.0371920951,
0.0121603524,
0.0582491085,
-0.0275359508,
-0.0086947512,
0.009279999,
-0.003000648,
0.0207881834,
0.0166690238,
-0.0121497661,
0.000255947,
0.0444276147,
0.0214634892,
0.0242270753,
-0.0477291644,
0.0457024761,
-0.0224066842,
-0.002817913,
0.0397736765,
0.0398006067,
-0.0367090404,
-0.0563366674,
-0.0551230945,
-0.0159831587,
-0.0715800151,
-0.0111471154,
0.009596983,
-0.0195316542,
0.0225666538,
-0.0888425931,
-0.0658630654,
0.0452452563,
-0.0391458645,
0.0352375694,
0.0594487153,
-0.0113253025,
0.0310150441,
-0.0176963601,
0.0498086289,
-0.0291401148,
0.059704002,
0.0226140767,
0.0490442999,
0.0323281214,
0.0149659868,
-0.009846475,
0.0178911462,
-0.0144495303,
0.0100263683,
-0.0294258799,
0.066989176,
0.0057294657,
0.1012527347,
-0.0462617017,
-0.0273693167,
-0.0227806196,
0.0030726239,
0.0264546219,
-0.0069419281,
0.0015302331,
-0.0393657498,
-0.0019920997,
-0.0490574948,
-0.0371921472,
0.0037442001,
-0.0159324128,
-0.0309105087,
-0.0109452074,
0.061449986,
0.0305798575,
-0.0023207606,
-0.0076498273,
-0.0756418779,
-0.0177387781,
-0.0348875634,
-0.0171370506,
-0.0690045282,
-0.0034372704,
0.0041215988,
-0.0261047017,
-0.1121000424,
-0.0075826752,
0.0064800461,
-0.0481283702,
0.0646853074,
-0.0552524365,
-0.0005203054,
-0.030980058,
-0.0083733751,
0.0165672954,
0.0600301735,
0.0340595096,
0.0096078003,
0.0643343478,
-0.0272810366,
-0.0027251975,
0.0656122416,
0.0103864428,
0.046605099,
-0.0189298764,
0.0119568855,
0.0700223893,
0.0347295254,
0.0000425776,
0.0496954881,
0.0283466708,
-0.0434742086,
0.0688916519,
0.0618236326,
-0.0261449218,
0.01552423,
-0.0234883241,
0.0051906859,
-0.0192806609,
0.0418958217,
-0.0813371763,
-0.0026843878,
-0.0480993651,
0.0155266738,
0.0281582754,
0.0690317973,
0.016714517,
0.0212521534,
-0.013778233,
-0.0315942131,
-0.0058224327,
-0.0056015658,
0.0037555506,
-0.01175356,
-0.0021506373,
0.0643591136,
0.0249035228,
-0.0510455184,
-0.0071465871,
-0.0370768756,
-0.0054601412,
0.0430169739,
0.0670955628,
-0.0210601874,
-0.0737920552,
-0.0207900498,
-0.004330527,
0.0142223081,
0.0432524681,
0.0118982354,
-0.0006861688,
-0.0224345569,
-0.0236432869,
-0.000938441,
0.0072554215,
-0.0197337233,
0.007748398,
0.0050979611,
0.0100012813,
-0.0077454802,
-0.0164696164,
0.0264972448,
-0.0260641556,
-0.0321139954,
-0.0416542031,
0.0395990647,
0.0137981623,
0.0061533847,
-0.0272857863,
0.0170042031,
0.0500440113,
0.0234228913,
0.0546394177,
-0.0015918044,
0.0105448179,
0.0036081243,
0.076055795,
0.0098464638,
-0.0099626966,
0.0100795859,
-0.0602255054,
-0.015897803,
0.0277699232,
-0.0098566664,
0.0075827525,
0.0105359452,
0.0495956652,
-0.0318825841,
0.041277919,
-0.0410561413,
-0.0039671115,
-0.0120237358,
0.0388430469,
-0.0059508504,
0.0063915676,
0.0240209736,
-0.008419089,
-0.0766296312,
0.0248356424,
0.0034288706,
0.017333027,
-0.0130917626,
-0.0045101857,
-0.018434843,
-0.0330893882,
-0.0301316101,
0.0008699287,
0.0020429273,
0.0599507503,
0.0213884618,
0.0341915153,
-0.0303015318,
-0.0108982427,
-0.0096614389,
-0.0163573753,
-0.0067179427,
0.0336276367,
0.0408149883,
-0.0217613727,
-0.0625482574,
-0.038605094,
-0.0085643381,
-0.0211490467,
0.0328644365,
-0.0181981064,
-0.0053276694,
-0.0862469226,
-0.0237198621,
-0.0498658679,
0.0350587703,
0.0100089116,
-0.0710178092,
-0.0191116966,
0.0065286485,
0.0109773101,
0.0870601237,
-0.0201980192,
-0.0041144397,
0.0513324402,
0.0067448462,
-0.0163282342,
-0.0207586475,
0.0156117287,
-0.0480518676,
-0.0571777038,
0.0288356077,
-0.0105375247,
0.0339996703,
-0.0251388811,
-0.0309391767,
-0.040483743,
0.0579092801,
0.012994864,
0.0191031508,
0.0396940336,
-0.0083303656,
-0.0547212064,
0.0395135209,
-0.0049157855,
-0.078074351,
0.070750691,
-0.052526813,
-0.0043024463,
-0.006759583,
-0.0083708158,
-0.0157758482,
0.011423503,
-0.0061614416,
0.0380250737,
0.0227330364,
-0.0291992873,
-0.0625665113,
0.0032152107,
0.0613773763,
-0.0540747978,
0.0254845154,
0.0056787501,
-0.0104209557,
-0.041272793,
-0.0424697623,
-0.0184190702,
-0.0720831901,
-0.0294132382,
-0.032099735,
0.0256896615,
-0.0331271552,
0.0119268429,
-0.0104246968,
0.0166413467,
-0.000517902,
-0.0088624693,
0.0366024785,
-0.0495691225,
0.0019311304,
0.0209943596,
-0.0247896109,
0.0157944523,
-0.0288949106,
0.0127329547,
0.0573189221,
0.0205811672,
-0.012821909,
-0.0258025564,
-0.0141055444,
0.0509595051,
-0.0274097845,
-0.0152649675,
0.0197760388,
0.0338351093,
-0.0218906105,
-0.0024254676,
0.0680448711,
0.0142976372,
-0.0131432787,
0.0282288231,
-0.0311578121,
0.0746998042,
0.0220510513,
0.0414980017,
-0.1016278788,
-0.0090935584,
0.0524057038,
0.0425477028,
0.0077847615,
-0.0226360839,
-0.0313758776,
-0.0976349711,
0.0364499092,
0.0472233519,
0.0067014499,
-0.0334476046,
-0.0231622551,
0.0132454103,
0.0179610066,
0.0366769135,
0.0206312165,
-0.0045146313,
0.005431741,
0.010649805,
0.0073729912,
-0.0560492724,
-0.0359531604,
-0.0658430308,
0.0758221298,
0.0858605951,
-0.0089248046,
0.0054864809,
-0.0593076311,
0.0440522656,
0.0333973654,
-0.027789332,
0.0150582576,
0.0232754294,
0.0161048453,
-0.0345675088,
0.0221898351,
0.0154476026,
0.0117600411,
0.0011200408,
-0.017125573,
0.0689943284,
0.0009526326,
0.0386276767,
-0.0016813715,
-0.0456157923,
0.0004024595,
0.0409890823,
0.0252505559,
-0.0299176052,
-0.0122330729,
-0.0588021465,
0.010075598,
0.0305802748,
-0.0144490227,
0.0056239995,
-0.0236715619,
-0.0398066416,
-0.0337053649,
-0.0023558,
-0.0093250908,
0.0506163128,
0.0555017069,
0.0130568063,
0.0208733976,
-0.0205785781,
-0.0365924053,
-0.0032788482,
-0.0592265949,
0.0487370156,
-0.0523970947,
0.0348098166,
-0.0041438323,
0.0172414742,
-0.0157325156,
-0.0297657754,
-0.0977639407,
-0.1193162724,
0.0351888873,
0.0453936532,
0.0342696086,
0.0502561703,
-0.0248391703,
-0.0553040057,
0.0540523343,
0.0437506288,
-0.052135691,
0.011967402,
0.0286320336,
-0.0486857966,
0.0149674024,
0.048589915,
-0.0287111867,
-0.082798712,
0.0344418623,
-0.0195409413,
-0.0043557426,
-0.0249165967,
-0.0267991517,
0.0682089105,
0.0328869186,
-0.0296556074,
0.0145994779,
-0.0080429446,
0.048152402,
-0.011621247,
-0.029769225,
-0.0144540416,
-0.0100679779,
-0.0149135599,
-0.028681241,
0.0418461412,
0.0278790314,
0.0088093039,
0.0276701413,
-0.0112123275,
0.0271050651,
-0.0167231951,
0.0021372112,
0.0860557333,
0.0205575638,
-0.0010474733,
0.06100104,
-0.0051618973,
0.0433931835,
-0.0391771756,
0.0037988173,
0.0293621458,
0.0154380947,
-0.0310257841,
0.0587550849,
-0.020432001,
-0.0509744138,
-0.0188772716,
0.0055373018,
0.0293382332,
0.0179578848,
0.0565323867,
0.0198609438,
-0.0148331476,
-0.0294313356,
0.0115073724,
-0.0177740436,
-0.0371810794,
0.0236369148,
-0.0243970212,
-0.0216275994,
0.0393455327,
0.0671389028,
-0.0296017081,
0.031690795,
-0.0201312061,
-0.0329700559,
-0.0452457815,
0.0036327543,
0.0009659347,
0.0148889413,
-0.0496630706,
-0.0512538329,
-0.056715481,
-0.0983873159,
-0.0325965546,
0.0172197185,
-0.0161164794,
0.0101834675,
-0.0279733278,
0.0529161878,
0.0019856438,
0.0079598799,
-0.0383537896,
0.0094714817,
0.0091940844,
-0.058115337,
0.025621051,
-6.220005665e-33,
0.0041504395,
0.0008532731,
-0.0390707292,
0.0041173664,
-0.012944011,
-0.0121904751,
-0.0367515273,
0.0025603189,
-0.0074624843,
-0.0231868736,
-0.0301995277,
-0.00852706,
0.0131414654,
0.0044228882,
0.0025272926,
-0.0316239782,
0.0120152207,
0.0088683078,
-0.0476764515,
0.0062535922,
0.0150148403,
-0.0054640048,
0.0371056721,
-0.0566457659,
0.032208737,
-0.026630383,
-0.0156176332,
0.0233009197,
-0.0385359712,
0.0559666045,
0.0191819686,
-0.0313779116,
-0.0276311282,
0.0131894657,
-0.0225954615,
0.0097947801,
-0.0118752159,
-0.0139666004,
0.0223379154,
0.0345587395,
0.0095935445,
-0.0655671582,
0.0537397377,
-0.0294844322,
-0.0109370025,
0.0088088643,
-0.0062062563,
-0.0061429706,
-0.031425789,
0.0059562819,
-0.0353642963,
0.0192246623,
-0.0181665458,
0.0018013094,
0.0448156521,
-0.0374797508,
0.0516668558,
0.0188186243,
-0.0361216478,
0.0164549965,
0.0391348265,
0.0362754278,
0.0796438605,
0.0048455973,
-0.0023434979,
0.0438988246,
0.0038057026,
-0.0206961706,
0.0414747335,
0.0021261931,
0.0014838546,
0.0006897775,
-0.002587788,
0.0533919521,
0.0298907608,
-0.0189851765,
-0.023074856,
0.0148031274,
-0.0128049245,
0.01908792,
0.0243300889,
0.0179935955,
-0.0395588242,
-0.0034934364,
-0.0470832102,
-0.0419618599,
-0.0314492621,
-0.0299960617,
-0.0122320103,
-0.0183058046,
-0.0364956893,
-0.0030540565,
0.0249132738,
-0.0440589078,
-0.0281259865,
-0.0026635407,
-0.0174175985,
-0.011863376,
-0.0147712976,
0.0244887639,
0.0161841121,
-0.0169094149,
-0.0259683635,
-0.0651192144,
0.050377503,
0.0067367279,
0.0521982461,
0.0430208929,
-0.0922838002,
0.0208787881,
-0.033784043,
0.0264949854,
0.0121354861,
-0.0030997838,
0.060329169,
-0.034396749,
0.0192143582,
0.0189441349,
0.0748472139,
0.0474944897,
-0.0293548945,
0.0343598016,
0.0121121034,
0.0115143796,
-0.0056642299,
0.018564526,
0.0248678327,
0.0770435482,
0.0386806615,
-0.0463421047,
-0.0030764379,
-0.0349581093,
2.819e-7,
0.0386232026,
0.0634987354,
0.0425251648,
-0.0032560767,
0.0251081381,
0.074705556,
-0.0458025262,
0.0429944545,
-0.0065848152,
0.0150002064,
-0.0278745536,
-0.0201219358,
0.0526240803,
0.0230102967,
-0.0619167909,
0.0252059363,
-0.0612735599,
0.0410426222,
-0.0557059646,
-0.0234063659,
0.0217757858,
0.1100754589,
0.0336536244,
-0.0128790354,
-0.0054190583,
-0.0579110309,
0.0001814297,
0.022185361,
0.0001344136,
-0.00134503,
0.0175845306,
0.0190505981,
-0.0013126481,
-0.0170604885,
-0.0540619045,
0.0131386686,
-0.054447934,
0.0460650511,
-0.0047594928,
0.0244121235,
-0.0136157898,
-0.0674164519,
-0.0219519418,
-0.055979114,
0.0473187789,
0.0039630234,
-0.040999826,
-0.0579880178,
-0.0401099399,
-0.0354510918,
0.0279381443,
-0.009855614,
-0.0085577453,
0.0376418605,
0.0162494872,
-0.0240479931,
-0.0181891229,
-0.0639568791,
-0.0650078952,
-0.0138364444,
-0.0188335013,
-0.044706475,
0.0159963816,
0.0176667944,
0.0293008462,
-0.0302433558,
0.0183285773,
3.086569445e-34,
0.0159196947,
-0.0510169081,
0.0399669223,
0.0377045833,
0.0253127646,
-0.0364505127,
0.0410497934,
0.020092003,
0.0159378015,
-0.040062122,
-0.0429454781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01108v1 | Reasoning Capacity in Multi-Agent Systems: Limitations, Challenges and Human-Centered Solutions | 2024-02-02T02:53:11 | 2024-02-02T02:53:11 | Pouya Pezeshkpour, Eser Kandogan, Nikita Bhutani, Sajjadur Rahman, Tom Mitchell, Estevam Hruschka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) in a variety of tasks
brings forth many opportunities as well as challenges of utilizing them in
production settings. Towards practical adoption of LLMs, multi-agent systems
hold great promise to augment, integrate, and orchestrate LLMs in the larger
context of enterprise platforms that use existing proprietary data and models
to tackle complex real-world tasks. Despite the tremendous success of these
systems, current approaches rely on narrow, single-focus objectives for
optimization and evaluation, often overlooking potential constraints in
real-world scenarios, including restricted budgets, resources and time.
Furthermore, interpreting, analyzing, and debugging these systems requires
different components to be evaluated in relation to one another. This demand is
currently not feasible with existing methodologies. In this postion paper, we
introduce the concept of reasoning capacity as a unifying criterion to enable
integration of constraints during optimization and establish connections among
different components within the system, which also enable a more holistic and
comprehensive approach to evaluation. We present a formal definition of
reasoning capacity and illustrate its utility in identifying limitations within
each component of the system. We then argue how these limitations can be
addressed with a self-reflective process wherein human-feedback is used to
alleviate shortcomings in reasoning and enhance overall consistency of the
system. | Reasoning Capacity in Multi-Agent Systems: Limitations, Challenges and Human-Centered Solutions: Remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) in a variety of tasks
brings forth many opportunities as well as challenges of utilizing them in
production settings. Towards practical adoption of LLMs, multi-agent systems
hold great promise to augment, integrate, and orchestrate LLMs in the larger
context of enterprise platforms that use existing proprietary data and models
to tackle complex real-world tasks. Despite the tremendous success of these
systems, current approaches rely on narrow, single-focus objectives for
optimization and evaluation, often overlooking potential constraints in
real-world scenarios, including restricted budgets, resources and time.
Furthermore, interpreting, analyzing, and debugging these systems requires
different components to be evaluated in relation to one another. This demand is
currently not feasible with existing methodologies. In this postion paper, we
introduce the concept of reasoning capacity as a unifying criterion to enable
integration of constraints during optimization and establish connections among
different components within the system, which also enable a more holistic and
comprehensive approach to evaluation. We present a formal definition of
reasoning capacity and illustrate its utility in identifying limitations within
each component of the system. We then argue how these limitations can be
addressed with a self-reflective process wherein human-feedback is used to
alleviate shortcomings in reasoning and enhance overall consistency of the
system. | [
0.0469949916,
0.0153058069,
-0.0248940811,
0.0359101444,
-0.0497494787,
0.00591793,
0.001852348,
-0.0102212094,
0.0338141136,
-0.03263098,
-0.0217685848,
0.0006390685,
-0.0061119418,
0.023475185,
0.0081225364,
-0.010151227,
0.0034343593,
-0.0402021855,
0.0053761993,
-0.0084145293,
0.0048928675,
0.0019656285,
0.0117772305,
0.0456966385,
-0.0132881533,
-0.0078258459,
0.003851413,
-0.022117367,
0.0229903385,
0.001564341,
-0.0552281439,
0.0171979945,
0.0276117828,
-0.0010801813,
0.0000023756,
-0.0870426446,
-0.0305596795,
0.0183669552,
-0.0919440985,
0.0081991497,
0.0494430177,
0.0134499762,
-0.016522387,
0.0252103657,
-0.0401414931,
0.0395910554,
0.005067626,
-0.0209138207,
0.0633948371,
0.0443029851,
-0.0119528892,
0.0145371286,
-0.03762931,
0.0252172258,
-0.0383638591,
-0.088498801,
0.0165534671,
0.05740593,
0.0839031711,
-0.027849447,
0.0226120073,
0.030712124,
0.0382251143,
-0.0427382961,
-0.0294767749,
0.0198044889,
0.0162642654,
-0.0266775973,
-0.0212070476,
0.020050047,
0.0672702342,
0.0160396621,
-0.0066173221,
-0.0060358574,
-0.0036161719,
-0.0176223144,
-0.0136203803,
0.0334851258,
-0.0287303664,
-0.0031954413,
-0.028911896,
-0.0084065972,
0.0147699723,
0.0155266514,
-0.059205763,
0.1201673821,
-0.0309525654,
-0.0120447185,
-0.0047610668,
-0.0025107579,
0.0069632898,
-0.0481239147,
0.0023214954,
0.0880982578,
-0.0786634982,
0.0195816923,
0.0197841786,
0.0051410613,
0.0167626571,
-0.0682687908,
0.0191663392,
0.009844223,
0.0391984321,
0.0548591167,
0.0111901602,
0.0831122175,
-0.0237013567,
0.0318986103,
-0.0308545269,
-0.0287727527,
-0.102411896,
-0.02700831,
-0.0474267192,
0.021089131,
0.0109649766,
-0.0130740609,
-0.0074244607,
0.0506867543,
-0.026552774,
0.0514990427,
-0.0107407812,
-0.0326369479,
0.0023871986,
-0.0609046258,
-0.0661686286,
0.0143314293,
-0.0223187022,
0.0296838861,
-0.007680262,
-0.05738502,
0.0267740823,
0.0195727441,
-0.0500595197,
-0.0027363701,
-0.0113912206,
0.0733797178,
0.0235637054,
0.0157042257,
-0.0248096455,
-0.0608085804,
-0.0209739674,
-0.0957261547,
-0.0681848526,
-0.0432440341,
-0.0206085499,
0.0290524811,
-0.021721432,
-0.0348367132,
-0.0041449517,
-0.045239009,
-0.0204692166,
0.0567743741,
-0.0209851395,
0.0492530502,
0.0272433311,
0.0287363119,
-0.0075934506,
0.0868227854,
0.061570704,
0.033274319,
0.0345015004,
0.0430263132,
0.0263199061,
0.0140392734,
-0.0245678946,
0.0056857504,
-0.0230423473,
0.0490824692,
-0.0444371328,
0.0136398925,
-0.0332737267,
0.0455168784,
-0.0070774844,
0.0009032861,
0.0286541842,
0.0347882882,
-0.0046320045,
-0.0148526933,
0.0429356061,
0.0348318964,
-0.0153219271,
-0.0408528484,
0.009699652,
0.0167634115,
0.0178623218,
-0.0106495731,
0.002750983,
-0.0099247759,
-0.0233581569,
-0.0715496689,
-0.0358256735,
0.0074151801,
0.0134096043,
0.011232798,
0.060177613,
-0.0255366266,
-0.0164390858,
0.0131271631,
-0.0266965386,
-0.0244871825,
0.0044660047,
-0.0809571519,
0.0090739084,
0.1196614355,
0.0595598221,
-0.0304045919,
-0.0061855749,
0.0066120378,
0.0085692042,
0.0351781584,
0.0464537255,
-0.0148621369,
-0.0204389077,
-0.024528075,
-0.051636707,
0.0280944817,
-0.0011381726,
0.0262980573,
-0.0527527779,
-0.0013630041,
-0.0088875638,
0.0056411228,
-0.0309673399,
0.0087809497,
-0.0305215903,
0.0128828846,
-0.0617541485,
0.048265256,
0.0452138744,
0.0460603721,
-0.0238509905,
0.0371806212,
-0.0004725874,
-0.0238573756,
-0.0643984452,
0.0400385149,
0.028411096,
0.0593531765,
0.0023482973,
0.0118937269,
-0.004837954,
0.0122787179,
0.0190915801,
-0.0447666831,
0.060590826,
-0.0564350411,
0.005250691,
-0.021759158,
0.0307103992,
-0.061068356,
-0.034357965,
-0.0221858043,
0.0291937087,
0.005982318,
-0.0407506973,
0.003956839,
0.0321759693,
0.0465209745,
-0.0482572317,
0.0033457992,
0.057385046,
0.0365440287,
0.0229438208,
0.0366418399,
-0.0218640547,
-0.0159482658,
-0.0179006197,
-0.0740227476,
-0.0268844906,
-0.0052533029,
0.0187336076,
-0.0081082163,
-0.0279152524,
0.0059203445,
0.0137621723,
0.0109468028,
0.0371693298,
0.0303868819,
0.0238563716,
0.0160894599,
0.0536339171,
-0.0591536239,
0.0086734639,
0.0277935117,
-0.0212466344,
0.0258765239,
0.0460413024,
0.0046325317,
-0.0733825788,
0.0305571016,
-0.0413971916,
-0.0046987967,
0.0122006498,
-0.0299281999,
0.0509755537,
-0.0089953281,
-0.0088915266,
0.028288424,
-0.0423245095,
0.0426644087,
-0.001257654,
-0.0417321771,
-0.0568245798,
0.0020616797,
-0.0105579365,
-0.0029048861,
-0.0495405272,
-0.000581735,
-0.0076335212,
0.0313418582,
0.0061554476,
-0.017456919,
-0.0516117699,
0.0478489511,
-0.0541451648,
-0.029239215,
-0.036388889,
-0.0476154312,
0.0011750343,
0.0781852752,
-0.0037048054,
-0.0361936241,
0.0584496073,
-0.0036292565,
-0.002873769,
-0.0369445421,
-0.0388359688,
-0.0672615692,
0.0712438822,
-0.0340709314,
0.0069017084,
-0.0218729731,
-0.0071012531,
-0.0304210093,
-0.0433093309,
0.0373202823,
0.0010229249,
0.0318326578,
-0.0604104772,
0.0407310016,
-0.0007595701,
-0.0350568295,
0.0019403114,
0.0324624218,
-0.077453889,
0.0358218998,
-0.0054537938,
-0.0023385521,
-0.043488238,
0.0345396698,
0.0425861031,
-0.0013784068,
0.0283685494,
-0.0428394862,
-0.0042112772,
-0.0833962336,
-0.0178195722,
0.041907452,
0.0589482822,
-0.0253577922,
0.0730495602,
0.0211113133,
0.0518263504,
-0.03575176,
-0.02530385,
-0.0128114661,
-0.0225588288,
0.0002344111,
0.0241394565,
0.0155962277,
0.0308749974,
-0.0632119626,
-0.0033490921,
0.0559066832,
0.0149975559,
-0.0199493021,
0.0212666895,
-0.0446603969,
-0.0314397775,
0.0385052338,
0.0585053787,
-0.0244316291,
-0.0162613783,
0.0008927475,
0.0192325804,
-0.0070187766,
-0.0435084216,
-0.0232188702,
-0.0610366911,
0.057115674,
-0.0180847049,
-0.0022883245,
-0.0447955579,
-0.0126211643,
-0.0185232554,
-0.0369601175,
0.0166661907,
0.0265599266,
0.043981012,
-0.039360024,
0.027731467,
-0.0390102789,
-0.0331809893,
0.0359780528,
-0.0241117384,
0.0556928255,
0.0560313165,
0.0170129202,
0.0192414261,
-0.0495378226,
0.0078400793,
0.0322461873,
0.0380005576,
0.0013699197,
-0.014641053,
0.0268229935,
0.0014460089,
-0.0034819043,
-0.0299370345,
-0.031528905,
-0.025093874,
0.035244856,
0.0939124972,
-0.0155757545,
0.0065920856,
0.0002049849,
0.0059081418,
0.0048708357,
0.0592032708,
-0.0064147497,
-0.0343597941,
-0.0653080121,
0.000492308,
-0.0426264368,
-0.0534410551,
-0.0304765608,
0.0755762309,
0.004729114,
-0.0095194317,
-0.0255988427,
-0.069768697,
0.0166734681,
0.0331286155,
-0.0075844103,
-0.0034505944,
0.0314635746,
0.0156782512,
0.0114017772,
-0.0362248793,
-0.0267000832,
0.048471909,
-0.0163180958,
0.0265933219,
-0.0178541541,
-0.0211469289,
0.0075059608,
-0.0414875932,
-0.0409266129,
-0.0534578487,
0.0042348681,
0.0311760772,
0.0372479334,
-0.0055457586,
-0.0180189498,
-0.0841048658,
0.0292091109,
-0.0427623168,
-0.0620456487,
-0.0060372902,
0.0183657203,
0.028128311,
0.0041398937,
0.0525526851,
-0.0570896417,
0.0353910774,
-0.0036873342,
0.0287232958,
-0.0378381684,
-0.0467493348,
0.0040607825,
0.0268807933,
-0.0619185753,
0.0090090912,
-0.0191218685,
-0.0185831804,
0.0148302196,
-0.029378701,
-0.0171171259,
-0.0445529744,
0.00467521,
-0.0265455227,
-0.0279428996,
0.0544268712,
-0.0230484214,
-0.0099901566,
-0.0238835923,
0.0463227518,
0.037716791,
-0.0076749474,
0.0116573703,
0.0123601314,
0.0011025796,
-0.0058903592,
0.0083697801,
-0.0248945691,
0.0340200514,
0.0287553575,
0.0810996071,
0.0275473576,
-0.0312872455,
-0.0089281406,
0.0075394632,
-0.0403657109,
-0.0606244095,
0.0475361831,
0.0093989931,
0.0376536883,
0.0541922785,
0.0046293754,
-0.0542862788,
0.0288327727,
-0.0173180662,
0.0093338192,
0.0235428866,
-0.026038494,
-0.0173091795,
0.0480245501,
-0.0324889943,
0.0000562138,
0.0632012933,
-0.008833739,
0.0207329858,
-0.0606769882,
-0.0574504994,
-0.0610202998,
-0.0478927717,
-0.0287643205,
-0.0250627678,
-0.0308225695,
0.0197681561,
-0.1064544246,
-0.0399053022,
0.001670312,
0.0806083158,
0.0047209268,
-0.0101306196,
-0.0061232839,
0.0556636415,
0.0308696982,
-0.0227075405,
-0.038043458,
-0.0284820907,
-0.0640698224,
0.057955198,
0.0352716818,
-6.206687314e-33,
-0.0188766327,
-0.0569341518,
0.0920232981,
-0.0035795604,
-0.0070424317,
-0.0118472921,
-0.0405176021,
0.0101932809,
0.0030800421,
0.0324220844,
-0.0097810002,
0.0000237947,
0.0188688841,
-0.031022599,
0.0268838741,
0.0216538943,
0.0060761869,
0.0199700408,
-0.0273253415,
-0.0044896142,
0.0656411573,
-0.0166736823,
0.0204821881,
-0.0406999663,
0.0330426395,
-0.0009769213,
-0.0262750685,
0.064674817,
-0.0174911749,
0.0759017467,
0.0030139596,
0.0234356243,
0.0281024352,
-0.0673649311,
-0.0290851034,
0.0161461048,
0.0081953332,
-0.0212759487,
0.0033197445,
0.0313869007,
-0.004635632,
0.0002400919,
0.0027198128,
0.0046360432,
-0.0227640811,
0.0359139144,
0.0243060719,
-0.0365233533,
0.0135529432,
0.0219669677,
-0.0607223399,
0.0298798215,
-0.0408655703,
0.0192556158,
0.0380529501,
0.0350632668,
-0.0397688858,
-0.0255809519,
-0.0634921566,
0.0227665249,
-0.0168891344,
-0.0452014618,
0.0731867328,
0.0268085077,
-0.0026038287,
0.0400832035,
0.0066296374,
0.0337931402,
-0.0308808647,
-0.0248873737,
0.0022982208,
0.0623439662,
0.0402421877,
0.0656821877,
-0.0678959042,
0.0003551817,
-0.0563339256,
0.0281332862,
0.0053250529,
0.0630861744,
0.0776127353,
0.0273520518,
-0.0662505031,
-0.0316929482,
-0.0273064617,
0.0460760929,
-0.0426959358,
-0.0265108962,
0.0332797654,
0.0136631271,
-0.0523441993,
0.0150693031,
0.0501635931,
-0.0416222848,
-0.0260237828,
-0.0086050835,
0.0205122139,
-0.0048102723,
0.0160721745,
0.0172414351,
-0.052709084,
-0.0055584703,
-0.0188535042,
0.057194531,
0.0398273282,
-0.0086811259,
-0.0063684331,
0.023573339,
-0.0008785835,
-0.005108967,
-0.0491476543,
0.0262648128,
0.0076092831,
-0.0258279238,
0.0285653211,
-0.0034782495,
-0.0087286336,
0.0331258997,
-0.0022738031,
-0.043811433,
0.0106172413,
0.0389125086,
0.015855711,
-0.0209331326,
-0.0367096998,
-0.0076291109,
-0.0313347876,
0.0212750025,
0.0475116596,
0.0005068235,
-0.0067956625,
0.020213604,
3.086e-7,
0.0173372235,
0.0271473732,
0.0008309433,
-0.0062364913,
0.0207691062,
0.0701552704,
-0.0311366096,
-0.0221356712,
-0.0242116675,
-0.0229063667,
0.0464395918,
0.0520957559,
0.049654521,
0.0480750203,
-0.0131451637,
-0.0237153061,
-0.0103856744,
0.0016926226,
-0.0512334555,
-0.0018576513,
0.0801393539,
0.0041095819,
0.0289662648,
-0.0031978125,
-0.0139149874,
-0.0745211542,
0.0094811628,
-0.0372007303,
0.030755695,
0.0324287936,
0.0448687673,
0.0034584929,
0.0168722533,
0.0483669043,
0.0225499067,
0.0330561548,
-0.0281372815,
0.0702149197,
-0.0251480881,
-0.020958459,
0.0018403116,
-0.0669989735,
0.0145593109,
-0.0392512865,
0.0207681656,
-0.0649966598,
-0.0505927466,
-0.013504535,
0.0413074121,
-0.039398741,
-0.0173341874,
0.0042535146,
-0.0236449577,
0.0089913812,
-0.0055479086,
-0.0384718552,
0.032443773,
-0.0726025179,
0.0384394303,
-0.0171330515,
-0.0578159988,
-0.0389596,
-0.0262777228,
0.0006081411,
0.0265294556,
-0.0332570039,
0.0208679028,
2.527160178e-34,
0.0172686968,
0.0018338234,
0.0126761375,
0.0217839442,
0.0453445725,
0.0369267389,
-0.0465877391,
0.0209785923,
0.0320239291,
-0.0683242902,
-0.0163400136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01789v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01789v2 | The Political Preferences of LLMs | 2024-02-02T02:43:10 | 2024-06-02T04:48:36 | David Rozado | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | I report here a comprehensive analysis about the political preferences
embedded in Large Language Models (LLMs). Namely, I administer 11 political
orientation tests, designed to identify the political preferences of the test
taker, to 24 state-of-the-art conversational LLMs, both closed and open source.
When probed with questions/statements with political connotations, most
conversational LLMs tend to generate responses that are diagnosed by most
political test instruments as manifesting preferences for left-of-center
viewpoints. This does not appear to be the case for five additional base (i.e.
foundation) models upon which LLMs optimized for conversation with humans are
built. However, the weak performance of the base models at coherently answering
the tests' questions makes this subset of results inconclusive. Finally, I
demonstrate that LLMs can be steered towards specific locations in the
political spectrum through Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) with only modest
amounts of politically aligned data, suggesting SFT's potential to embed
political orientation in LLMs. With LLMs beginning to partially displace
traditional information sources like search engines and Wikipedia, the societal
implications of political biases embedded in LLMs are substantial. | The Political Preferences of LLMs: I report here a comprehensive analysis about the political preferences
embedded in Large Language Models (LLMs). Namely, I administer 11 political
orientation tests, designed to identify the political preferences of the test
taker, to 24 state-of-the-art conversational LLMs, both closed and open source.
When probed with questions/statements with political connotations, most
conversational LLMs tend to generate responses that are diagnosed by most
political test instruments as manifesting preferences for left-of-center
viewpoints. This does not appear to be the case for five additional base (i.e.
foundation) models upon which LLMs optimized for conversation with humans are
built. However, the weak performance of the base models at coherently answering
the tests' questions makes this subset of results inconclusive. Finally, I
demonstrate that LLMs can be steered towards specific locations in the
political spectrum through Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) with only modest
amounts of politically aligned data, suggesting SFT's potential to embed
political orientation in LLMs. With LLMs beginning to partially displace
traditional information sources like search engines and Wikipedia, the societal
implications of political biases embedded in LLMs are substantial. | [
0.058940459,
0.0679727867,
-0.025217738,
0.0174819659,
-0.0273496006,
0.0163027029,
0.0098989327,
-0.0102726491,
0.0188235659,
-0.0681791678,
-0.0187653396,
-0.0405806303,
-0.0182526801,
-0.004577931,
-0.0000065746,
-0.0748710632,
0.0508921742,
0.0259438939,
0.0606004409,
-0.0702388659,
0.0054570492,
0.0324598439,
-0.0123964408,
0.0328767709,
-0.0010685592,
0.0062164441,
-0.0173643176,
0.0029030764,
0.0383198634,
0.0258674286,
0.0271505211,
0.0595677905,
-0.0002284853,
-0.0108581288,
0.0000018738,
-0.0417793281,
0.0097401533,
-0.0597087108,
0.0297576524,
-0.0186668597,
0.0745474473,
0.0192806702,
-0.0085056163,
0.023849424,
-0.0453038923,
0.016128147,
0.0323609412,
0.0269059483,
0.0110059036,
0.0408420116,
0.0222339872,
-0.034307979,
-0.0146701932,
0.0051821889,
-0.0078302147,
-0.0318529457,
0.0511059947,
-0.0147932507,
-0.0417134725,
0.0349980816,
-0.0442570746,
-0.0000245954,
0.0091386912,
0.0070770308,
-0.023095509,
-0.0039775199,
-0.0140391923,
-0.0186553262,
0.0091351159,
0.0614276193,
0.0070012924,
-0.0150245633,
0.0186898597,
-0.0171999186,
0.0115079284,
0.0399338007,
-0.0444023088,
0.0444659367,
-0.0112098409,
0.0167930685,
0.0342694484,
-0.041265022,
-0.0006537381,
0.0736822113,
-0.0387175567,
0.1065403745,
-0.0268878657,
-0.0154802417,
0.0183886643,
-0.0016322989,
0.027070025,
-0.0423170626,
0.0215960685,
-0.0273999255,
-0.0023251206,
0.0269073527,
-0.024192756,
0.0637668222,
0.0375440009,
-0.0432924815,
-0.0006477396,
0.0429833941,
-0.0131334038,
0.0664483011,
0.0724622011,
-0.0180869363,
-0.0161391217,
0.0115562975,
0.0016700408,
-0.0261406414,
-0.0136143668,
0.0011898957,
0.033512339,
0.0022248465,
-0.0187087804,
0.0103618717,
-0.0162791517,
-0.0021973234,
-0.0161239505,
0.0127622252,
-0.0366963781,
0.0068221372,
-0.0048356443,
-0.0134937037,
-0.0811032206,
0.0559443608,
-0.0614227913,
0.0466380715,
-0.0148736816,
-0.0421367958,
0.0412962288,
0.0474054478,
-0.0275725164,
-0.0316335373,
0.0099552255,
-0.0033462357,
0.0129514355,
-0.0075493883,
0.020374123,
0.0039661182,
-0.0166578516,
-0.0510768257,
0.0314776488,
-0.046481099,
0.0441211089,
0.0281368047,
-0.0051953029,
-0.0521414727,
0.0092160776,
0.0387278013,
-0.0573493764,
0.0518673062,
0.0353125557,
0.0372329168,
0.0316837579,
0.0193276573,
0.0121719455,
0.0965889618,
-0.0013969259,
0.0149981482,
0.0375443697,
-0.060950648,
0.0063322424,
0.0287786182,
-0.0403655246,
0.0249953344,
-0.0445836112,
0.0423201732,
-0.0299555231,
-0.0180177502,
0.0641506389,
0.0473276898,
0.0136507796,
-0.0463823788,
0.0796149671,
0.0676470399,
-0.0125947185,
0.0246168748,
-0.0038386197,
0.0506875664,
0.0097929845,
0.0446915217,
-0.0401907116,
0.0169892851,
-0.0607586205,
-0.0398899987,
0.0088433512,
0.0578676313,
-0.0290201548,
-0.0301886816,
-0.017382415,
0.0084910942,
0.0516360998,
0.0444285199,
0.0428567119,
-0.0586385652,
-0.0057857442,
0.022845095,
0.041247271,
-0.0349421874,
-0.0152230402,
-0.0686074272,
0.0423967391,
0.0443234779,
-0.0086485874,
-0.0080460273,
-0.0088952016,
-0.0323428251,
0.0288456269,
0.100302659,
0.1171760708,
-0.0318636522,
-0.0231910236,
-0.0272914749,
-0.0120416526,
0.0030842875,
0.0108047957,
0.0488176681,
0.0271001514,
0.0174745005,
-0.0056964434,
-0.0153307691,
-0.0066872034,
0.013183848,
-0.0169177055,
0.0061235745,
-0.0079936953,
0.030221751,
0.0354643613,
0.0084293243,
0.0030446881,
-0.0260904357,
0.0187478364,
0.0148344282,
-0.0003904617,
-0.0109751932,
-0.0649412349,
0.029746037,
0.0083252825,
-0.0185692608,
-0.0163750052,
0.0432053283,
-0.0126797268,
0.0044670547,
0.0461150631,
-0.0027869323,
0.0224969387,
-0.014412934,
-0.0056343214,
-0.0615302287,
0.0013181921,
-0.0751089752,
0.0448427536,
-0.0082944063,
0.0149962455,
0.0224238392,
-0.0368464254,
0.0210583061,
-0.0149347587,
-0.0280293077,
0.0220607203,
0.0122033898,
0.0250343699,
0.0576993339,
-0.0380927697,
-0.0563852824,
-0.06571652,
-0.0434953682,
-0.001160849,
-0.025857605,
0.0258379653,
0.017831726,
-0.0265364219,
-0.0247529782,
0.0232145917,
-0.0470291078,
-0.001793602,
-0.017544806,
0.0281906947,
0.0169633608,
-0.0070298691,
-0.0264316425,
-0.0301852301,
0.0172384121,
-0.0246741734,
-0.0215938222,
-0.0000585287,
-0.0043506739,
-0.0109797148,
0.0278635137,
-0.0664330125,
-0.018641118,
-0.0389740765,
-0.0435435288,
0.0195013806,
0.0260714442,
0.0287653599,
0.0997113064,
0.0594771877,
0.0129207615,
0.04178451,
0.0119668711,
-0.0828136355,
-0.0222488344,
-0.0309793092,
-0.0006333556,
-0.0594710708,
-0.0476749204,
0.0036444936,
0.0669634268,
0.0124412421,
0.0088820318,
-0.045402348,
0.0636870041,
-0.0065105204,
-0.0320030898,
-0.0078276293,
0.0095952414,
-0.0147694517,
0.0499704555,
0.0094849896,
-0.0341285728,
0.0472203083,
0.0227385331,
0.0405656062,
-0.020485878,
-0.0148207294,
-0.0127222221,
0.0317260437,
-0.0136379423,
0.0007609696,
-0.0224280022,
-0.0048260633,
-0.0675578713,
-0.0417488702,
0.0318542495,
-0.0603589118,
0.0390583128,
-0.052463945,
-0.0123962164,
0.0054061506,
-0.0291754715,
-0.0552409627,
-0.0540242791,
-0.0267153624,
0.0068909712,
0.051889699,
-0.0325601771,
-0.0017565807,
0.0077142431,
0.0431096703,
-0.0550539233,
-0.0079906471,
0.01602103,
0.0130802486,
0.0012324331,
0.0283107832,
0.0288429093,
0.0354535878,
0.0059254779,
0.0124420505,
0.0103466604,
-0.00266898,
0.0322850011,
0.0085092969,
-0.0483874641,
0.0543323979,
-0.0149412062,
-0.0358466022,
0.0009609825,
0.0456100479,
-0.0199191477,
0.0240809638,
0.095857285,
0.0336466208,
-0.0622719452,
-0.0221986584,
-0.0259556379,
-0.0150018698,
0.0435622782,
0.0133442935,
-0.0809868574,
0.0228191372,
0.0100076655,
-0.0035901759,
-0.0494023338,
-0.010523296,
-0.0235074647,
-0.1251732856,
-0.0068822405,
-0.0118698142,
-0.0298958253,
-0.0157344062,
-0.0359927863,
0.0465307683,
-0.0038854999,
0.0161776189,
0.0076240306,
0.0085915383,
0.0018444734,
-0.0075393789,
-0.0572928078,
-0.0690582544,
0.0388519131,
0.013195103,
0.042766422,
0.0322428048,
0.0513665788,
-0.0037909381,
-0.0350487977,
0.0669987723,
-0.0138553688,
-0.0198435243,
-0.0249555986,
0.0052554077,
-0.0295281187,
0.0123426691,
-0.0209874921,
0.0439742915,
0.0236439034,
0.0001446126,
0.0032732254,
0.029423112,
-0.0394250304,
-0.0349713154,
0.0103197647,
0.0403018631,
0.0512236394,
0.0745513067,
0.0607521608,
-0.0765918046,
0.0257883538,
-0.0614522025,
-0.0062700561,
-0.0123234773,
-0.0493607782,
-0.0156014143,
-0.0174760818,
0.0081301993,
-0.0127631528,
-0.0658482313,
0.0177446883,
-0.0216417443,
-0.010404814,
-0.0208466034,
0.0322491638,
-0.0079561127,
0.0070874318,
0.0486810058,
-0.0252123084,
0.0069003524,
-0.0289286878,
-0.074706018,
0.0228232071,
-0.0474233739,
-0.0210468005,
-0.0157244243,
0.0019857963,
-0.0587140284,
0.0547157377,
0.0118692117,
0.017419355,
0.0122589003,
-0.0037930789,
-0.0550535917,
-0.004927373,
0.0564863347,
-0.0376609266,
0.0124966614,
0.0043530483,
0.0577207617,
0.0078129685,
0.0259482097,
-0.0069571664,
0.0416132994,
0.0537653752,
-0.0306664929,
-0.0628992319,
-0.0864866227,
0.0095166434,
0.0095144734,
0.067242004,
0.0230658595,
-0.0499293394,
-0.0244850256,
-0.0276814103,
-0.0078680841,
-0.0469289832,
0.0304730181,
-0.0443147607,
0.0327483453,
-0.0631077141,
-0.0204159562,
0.019003382,
-0.057558272,
0.0347366445,
-0.023247499,
0.036544092,
-0.0212604143,
0.0191888418,
0.0175658613,
0.0195776224,
-0.0164119583,
0.0462373756,
0.0152078215,
0.0543455482,
0.0249039773,
0.0778010115,
0.0105005195,
-0.0173744448,
0.0451482348,
-0.0269774795,
-0.0299779158,
-0.0764101371,
0.0118392035,
0.0423592068,
0.0172858853,
-0.0146284718,
0.0197802056,
-0.0059745968,
-0.0223608408,
-0.0242248513,
0.0151923718,
0.019658003,
-0.0361702368,
0.0698799044,
-0.0057583824,
-0.0556626096,
-0.0077814348,
0.0407823585,
-0.0077965632,
0.0215240065,
0.0260365903,
0.0022289304,
-0.0283640046,
-0.0099713011,
0.004605012,
-0.0046648905,
-0.0405556299,
-0.0091694193,
-0.0707140341,
-0.0365142971,
0.0092163496,
0.012340175,
-0.0105671547,
-0.0129918884,
0.0242927913,
0.0755270198,
-0.0392134078,
0.0197430979,
-0.0556733236,
0.0645065457,
-0.0584091768,
-0.014638138,
-0.0239463504,
-6.238360275e-33,
-0.0162882861,
-0.026399482,
0.0119111575,
-0.0213824995,
0.0060184118,
-0.0349566974,
-0.0083600208,
0.0692622587,
-0.0588278472,
0.0041287276,
-0.0030003339,
0.0261874404,
0.0217183139,
0.0017756879,
-0.016490519,
-0.0309669841,
0.0106244739,
-0.0065046572,
-0.0381716937,
0.0061520911,
0.0158137102,
-0.0029472949,
0.045221854,
-0.0729172751,
0.0027743136,
0.0074459752,
0.0166132115,
-0.0042207744,
-0.0306035876,
0.0174526051,
-0.0213785078,
0.0353668034,
0.0299664326,
-0.0002862666,
-0.0033349835,
0.0745417327,
-0.0032887505,
-0.0183084961,
0.0371109359,
0.0118314717,
0.015331015,
-0.0535181239,
0.0147022689,
-0.008711759,
-0.0594061799,
0.0062576248,
0.0400085486,
-0.0330782346,
0.0116462922,
0.0114508281,
-0.0230249707,
0.0124840122,
-0.0086114844,
-0.0232931394,
-0.0502867587,
0.063515,
0.0393784083,
0.0554536544,
-0.0314102024,
0.0682273954,
-0.0324748345,
-0.0009904107,
0.070503287,
-0.0202187337,
0.0261160862,
0.0724349618,
0.0331008956,
0.0523519963,
-0.0472639315,
-0.0709247515,
0.0574561022,
-0.0106779914,
0.028741112,
0.0589045025,
-0.0085177105,
-0.0637052134,
-0.0469624996,
-0.0172197912,
0.0668380111,
-0.0000264443,
0.0158748571,
-0.0191388614,
-0.0207433961,
-0.0370888375,
-0.0652816296,
-0.0471143872,
-0.0243030973,
-0.0175472554,
0.0111170597,
0.0138618685,
-0.0317967236,
-0.0206382591,
0.0503292009,
-0.0354473032,
-0.0128456913,
0.0306397267,
-0.040658325,
-0.0131039517,
-0.0024422293,
0.0138617186,
-0.0721749067,
-0.0137094958,
-0.0422202386,
-0.0227315836,
0.0028012022,
0.0009835961,
-0.0099807587,
-0.001570406,
-0.0595146157,
-0.0135482913,
-0.0172612183,
-0.0101065822,
0.0037918477,
0.0295156147,
0.0318361335,
0.051524248,
0.0160306133,
0.0478541031,
0.0303705819,
-0.0080536949,
-0.0155879557,
-0.069546327,
-0.0619813427,
0.0355616175,
-0.0426393226,
-0.0281256884,
-0.0335426331,
0.0439488664,
0.0045436835,
-0.0085891541,
-0.0231568068,
-0.0271756575,
2.458e-7,
0.0421902798,
0.1003488153,
-0.0391583778,
0.0201680698,
-0.0186532997,
0.0093256496,
0.0252230577,
0.0080251498,
-0.0020203658,
-0.0459690168,
-0.0434189811,
0.0062119705,
0.0610299669,
0.0182009172,
-0.0874487981,
0.0128479479,
-0.018695958,
0.0401767679,
-0.0458372161,
0.0324602462,
-0.0311870202,
0.0293021202,
0.0209616255,
0.0241512228,
-0.034315303,
0.0175994951,
0.05710743,
-0.0747406632,
-0.0514096208,
0.0331885628,
0.0129494974,
-0.0019664762,
0.0302429497,
0.0487874933,
0.0167708918,
0.0185797717,
-0.0410118476,
0.0955823287,
0.0112048034,
-0.0344136693,
-0.0252652112,
-0.0208038203,
0.0038427804,
-0.0401735306,
0.0644024462,
-0.0458720662,
-0.002182971,
-0.0367568657,
-0.0070542544,
-0.0082137669,
0.0478839129,
-0.0424732566,
-0.0278369337,
-0.0103449384,
0.0078785988,
-0.0053801783,
0.0067673977,
-0.0314477645,
-0.0097393245,
-0.0285951123,
-0.0487152413,
-0.0921303034,
0.008748888,
0.0023447454,
0.0251746178,
0.0038478593,
0.0064560906,
1.77132833e-34,
0.0295924284,
0.0145218093,
-0.0084415311,
-0.0499584377,
0.0538383424,
0.0160390809,
0.0117428843,
0.0027274608,
0.0292364471,
-0.0959713683,
0.0177149437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01788v1 | LitLLM: A Toolkit for Scientific Literature Review | 2024-02-02T02:41:28 | 2024-02-02T02:41:28 | Shubham Agarwal, Issam H. Laradji, Laurent Charlin, Christopher Pal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Conducting literature reviews for scientific papers is essential for
understanding research, its limitations, and building on existing work. It is a
tedious task which makes an automatic literature review generator appealing.
Unfortunately, many existing works that generate such reviews using Large
Language Models (LLMs) have significant limitations. They tend to
hallucinate-generate non-actual information-and ignore the latest research they
have not been trained on. To address these limitations, we propose a toolkit
that operates on Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) principles, specialized
prompting and instructing techniques with the help of LLMs. Our system first
initiates a web search to retrieve relevant papers by summarizing user-provided
abstracts into keywords using an off-the-shelf LLM. Authors can enhance the
search by supplementing it with relevant papers or keywords, contributing to a
tailored retrieval process. Second, the system re-ranks the retrieved papers
based on the user-provided abstract. Finally, the related work section is
generated based on the re-ranked results and the abstract. There is a
substantial reduction in time and effort for literature review compared to
traditional methods, establishing our toolkit as an efficient alternative. Our
open-source toolkit is accessible at https://github.com/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM
and Huggingface space (https://huggingface.co/spaces/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM)
with the video demo at https://youtu.be/E2ggOZBAFw0. | LitLLM: A Toolkit for Scientific Literature Review: Conducting literature reviews for scientific papers is essential for
understanding research, its limitations, and building on existing work. It is a
tedious task which makes an automatic literature review generator appealing.
Unfortunately, many existing works that generate such reviews using Large
Language Models (LLMs) have significant limitations. They tend to
hallucinate-generate non-actual information-and ignore the latest research they
have not been trained on. To address these limitations, we propose a toolkit
that operates on Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) principles, specialized
prompting and instructing techniques with the help of LLMs. Our system first
initiates a web search to retrieve relevant papers by summarizing user-provided
abstracts into keywords using an off-the-shelf LLM. Authors can enhance the
search by supplementing it with relevant papers or keywords, contributing to a
tailored retrieval process. Second, the system re-ranks the retrieved papers
based on the user-provided abstract. Finally, the related work section is
generated based on the re-ranked results and the abstract. There is a
substantial reduction in time and effort for literature review compared to
traditional methods, establishing our toolkit as an efficient alternative. Our
open-source toolkit is accessible at https://github.com/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM
and Huggingface space (https://huggingface.co/spaces/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM)
with the video demo at https://youtu.be/E2ggOZBAFw0. | [
0.0741975009,
-0.0101971272,
-0.0027261043,
-0.0238522161,
-0.0053264103,
-0.0261853598,
0.0263785236,
0.0013910505,
0.0020490901,
-0.0621657781,
-0.0563550629,
-0.0101877339,
-0.0061802729,
0.0391389914,
0.0396462083,
-0.0449735336,
0.0214512609,
-0.0086460738,
0.0230675843,
-0.0054163355,
-0.0106985234,
-0.0083372658,
0.0060225404,
0.0268013962,
0.0794492885,
-0.0096763643,
-0.0033856207,
-0.0102080116,
0.0269308612,
-0.0541723371,
0.0351397656,
0.0419179797,
0.0064891106,
0.0712846741,
0.0000021893,
-0.0693989545,
-0.0223471485,
0.02102286,
0.0500864647,
0.0261746496,
0.1148177087,
0.0077247946,
0.0013056666,
0.0020969035,
-0.0145375617,
-0.0211377833,
0.0146116391,
0.0274471045,
0.0142427199,
0.025924135,
0.0052450472,
-0.0265236665,
0.0092247212,
-0.0205613151,
0.0252911113,
0.024477493,
0.0068760356,
0.0346922986,
0.0914851278,
0.0903194845,
0.0477279052,
0.0426219255,
-0.0285686273,
-0.0681811124,
0.0693900809,
0.0246018618,
-0.0515966564,
-0.0286631994,
0.0140725635,
0.0546653159,
0.0223252829,
-0.0407413617,
0.0336716585,
-0.018619407,
-0.0254097302,
0.0812163278,
-0.0921851844,
0.0296875965,
0.0171879809,
-0.0294868145,
0.0060555423,
-0.0061686798,
0.0291174538,
0.0201042425,
0.0364581086,
0.0425614826,
0.0210365038,
-0.0309877247,
-0.0142315133,
-0.0097933868,
0.0337855145,
-0.0297214389,
-0.007811923,
0.0444352627,
-0.0148209529,
-0.0144771067,
0.0537263602,
-0.0656715855,
0.10565947,
-0.035612978,
0.0148234433,
-0.0302176978,
0.0098543279,
0.0193118975,
-0.0163397659,
-0.0422229506,
-0.0209050719,
-0.0518670902,
-0.0263609681,
0.0307792891,
-0.0243215859,
-0.0607702807,
0.0001075273,
0.0047597592,
-0.0359965488,
-0.0112337209,
-0.042658601,
0.0025895128,
-0.0185549892,
0.0007000859,
0.0051781214,
0.0297897737,
-0.0346046649,
0.0089430111,
-0.0144158499,
0.0329044051,
0.0183770265,
0.0238751881,
0.0008100022,
0.0090383571,
-0.0080202427,
0.0195754431,
0.0067615877,
-0.0012995001,
0.0341607518,
0.0011525766,
0.0211111773,
-0.0428103283,
0.0165825672,
-0.0534034781,
0.0003753085,
-0.0264076404,
0.0182759017,
-0.1006409377,
0.0217317212,
0.0131685426,
-0.0140944421,
0.0126960715,
0.0182931777,
0.0473105982,
-0.0197383165,
-0.0010386022,
-0.0715207383,
0.0092463167,
0.0486760251,
0.02314776,
0.0355544537,
0.0171699394,
-0.0279941745,
0.0184576176,
0.0357345603,
-0.0073287687,
0.0217817519,
0.0052137389,
-0.0025629657,
0.0078195035,
0.0154432245,
0.002222735,
-0.0386962146,
0.0265659057,
0.010191598,
0.0242806189,
-0.042293869,
0.042065423,
0.0126748905,
0.0674270466,
0.0239732321,
0.0327849463,
0.0082727419,
0.0226222221,
0.0335531384,
-0.017475199,
0.0082834698,
0.0403549224,
-0.0266695507,
0.0155933676,
0.0282446668,
0.0417283922,
0.0062662973,
-0.0294643939,
-0.0111874631,
0.0224819556,
-0.0066440273,
-0.0246666893,
0.0849565268,
0.0252443478,
-0.0139379883,
0.0072331829,
0.0297587719,
-0.0569038168,
0.0362948999,
-0.0140543273,
0.0435712375,
0.0593808964,
0.1121318042,
-0.0499910712,
-0.0046342476,
0.0099851778,
-0.0305290204,
0.0552022122,
0.0154799791,
-0.0089856265,
-0.0518314838,
-0.0261580143,
-0.036269445,
-0.035238456,
-0.0238618124,
-0.0003038808,
0.0138847176,
-0.00690025,
0.0289582498,
-0.0338488631,
-0.0787376314,
0.0136353038,
-0.0412068516,
-0.0188159235,
0.0016552344,
-0.0641823113,
0.027979847,
0.0283100978,
-0.0282498356,
0.0634199232,
0.0673921108,
-0.0197533518,
-0.044435814,
0.0035886606,
0.045009762,
0.0421057865,
0.017865954,
-0.0553242788,
0.0466583632,
0.0114355553,
-0.0024430151,
-0.0467348881,
0.0423403345,
0.0147552472,
0.0401245654,
-0.0120955212,
0.0125444736,
-0.0153176468,
-0.0193760358,
-0.0470954403,
0.0557318628,
0.03141056,
0.0618599169,
0.0414799824,
-0.0270349439,
-0.0016463252,
-0.0226195827,
-0.0222611297,
0.0174868088,
0.004898482,
0.00643055,
0.0737819746,
0.0173602272,
-0.0261813365,
-0.0235628746,
-0.0917915702,
-0.0022477845,
0.0269478709,
-0.0057068728,
0.0269746184,
0.0123578049,
-0.0075174882,
-0.0027080588,
0.0030589569,
-0.0044042678,
0.0391322225,
-0.0085728606,
0.0303771365,
0.0064473795,
0.0237761289,
-0.080139935,
-0.0320842043,
-0.0014001849,
0.0279584769,
0.0551983826,
0.0029261005,
-0.0606363229,
0.0572119951,
-0.0161777642,
-0.0137205319,
-0.0280760769,
0.0149175255,
0.0133473882,
-0.0217743851,
0.0235636812,
0.0336335897,
0.0208946075,
0.0028059329,
0.0884450227,
-0.0145843746,
-0.0669468343,
-0.0266130753,
-0.027137544,
-0.0148977777,
0.0347343795,
-0.034582302,
0.053795971,
-0.0063444758,
-0.0071175448,
-0.0152610857,
0.016214909,
-0.0134772966,
-0.0128836064,
-0.0134459948,
-0.0301541369,
-0.0321424529,
0.0038947358,
0.0305088349,
0.0274530519,
-0.0467542037,
0.0373710953,
-0.0401119776,
-0.0060511241,
-0.0877685398,
0.0163229294,
-0.0466021001,
0.0392979048,
0.0075585721,
0.011674501,
-0.0429700799,
0.0217741895,
-0.0147997895,
0.000356941,
0.0016212336,
-0.0456978418,
0.0075345356,
-0.0398362465,
0.0118697844,
-0.0208732225,
0.015636513,
-0.0044776355,
-0.0185033511,
-0.0085332422,
0.0113171022,
0.0287767462,
-0.0327198468,
-0.0227331799,
0.0175892096,
0.089121528,
0.0180695299,
-0.0419944339,
-0.0280202478,
-0.0072053466,
0.0136484373,
0.0736809671,
-0.0609685332,
0.0116848918,
0.0045090909,
0.0103265541,
0.0582803562,
0.0085587995,
0.0091547193,
-0.0219591111,
-0.0444032736,
0.0456571244,
-0.0509293899,
-0.0134507166,
-0.0165800359,
0.0060732686,
-0.0435093194,
0.0018242401,
0.0920033902,
0.0437706523,
-0.083083652,
-0.0307104699,
-0.0854364708,
0.0178073142,
0.0155011117,
0.0466899201,
-0.0471423231,
0.0388104096,
0.0012750018,
0.0625883713,
-0.0070643779,
0.0085357251,
0.0167220123,
-0.0725634545,
0.0596113279,
0.0239712112,
0.0123301484,
-0.0042335629,
-0.0705511197,
0.0131918201,
0.0106985681,
-0.0421716385,
0.0724284202,
-0.0575490221,
0.0086829476,
0.0092014996,
-0.0158267692,
-0.0457813591,
0.0071325954,
-0.0454123504,
0.0167391282,
0.0335253328,
0.0092943273,
-0.0217801593,
-0.0007602438,
0.0134597616,
-0.0393877551,
-0.0097078253,
-0.0281048659,
0.0112017719,
0.0294210613,
0.0302043576,
-0.0507445708,
0.0336836316,
-0.0095763747,
-0.0274726767,
0.0437715501,
0.0479522608,
-0.0436628759,
0.0081435479,
-0.0921440572,
0.0189804956,
-0.0109457178,
0.0546489321,
0.0034934296,
-0.023658989,
-0.0226092152,
0.0051930351,
0.0159421656,
0.0302117635,
-0.0531324521,
-0.0022215394,
-0.037669424,
-0.0086568138,
-0.0469764993,
-0.0093646338,
0.0004970477,
0.0137889087,
0.0361822098,
0.0541531928,
0.0162117593,
-0.0304254089,
-0.0431173518,
0.0278276112,
0.0197993368,
-0.007415507,
-0.0069891219,
-0.03360283,
0.108942695,
-0.0449418388,
0.0012412497,
0.0040095043,
0.0159966685,
-0.041023206,
-0.0382164121,
0.0423080027,
0.0288002212,
-0.0002229442,
-0.0200798474,
-0.0276275594,
0.0558997728,
0.0309271272,
-0.0116485655,
-0.0082253795,
-0.0345238671,
0.0090027256,
-0.017949434,
-0.0503573045,
-0.0834235325,
0.0101234736,
-0.0318958201,
0.0109686796,
-0.0192223992,
-0.0415072665,
0.0196287893,
0.0351342708,
0.0075546405,
-0.0596609935,
0.0265311431,
-0.0235943105,
-0.0010250459,
-0.0402693637,
-0.0186458733,
-0.0242675524,
0.0542480387,
-0.0031055936,
-0.0198198203,
0.0237512682,
0.036270801,
-0.0379720628,
0.0757602081,
-0.040303003,
0.0667267963,
-0.0363380425,
0.0119914124,
0.0358421244,
-0.0192508679,
-0.0342240147,
-0.0264033917,
-0.0805639476,
0.0251576994,
-0.0187250953,
0.0100855362,
0.014242433,
-0.0261501875,
-0.0205186084,
0.0443167724,
-0.1005320698,
-0.0454554372,
-0.0449472442,
-0.0208215471,
0.0240224246,
0.0157181658,
0.0796134695,
-0.050866127,
-0.0127540808,
-0.0282382388,
0.0240672305,
0.0015718555,
0.0084695769,
-0.0012878841,
0.0302249361,
-0.0170273576,
-0.0272356179,
0.0723262206,
-0.0068122931,
-0.0301389843,
0.0120991766,
-0.0460434891,
-0.017542474,
-0.0501450375,
0.0088628689,
0.0330002382,
-0.0252267607,
-0.054249689,
-0.029528195,
-0.0074816477,
0.005994048,
0.0209146552,
-0.0188432522,
-0.0424158499,
0.0199470036,
0.0823736414,
0.0042220219,
-0.0158901382,
-0.0446245037,
0.0573930405,
-0.0321877636,
-0.0505938269,
-0.0253051203,
-6.492626315e-33,
-0.0083858455,
-0.0578067973,
0.0261321887,
-0.0109530585,
-0.0279184692,
0.0115839727,
-0.057403218,
-0.0218390152,
0.0341250636,
0.0018031857,
-0.0190474968,
0.0058213025,
-0.0098880967,
0.0040066279,
0.0617253445,
0.0489463992,
0.0225253664,
0.0082184589,
-0.012425377,
0.0602212884,
0.0235267431,
0.0016635755,
-0.005782201,
-0.0424658619,
0.0563550331,
-0.0164001416,
0.0026024678,
-0.0244232193,
0.0007929922,
0.0532670915,
-0.0323068649,
0.031340912,
0.0107130138,
-0.0003307237,
-0.0112253027,
0.0073446915,
-0.0547566488,
0.0114087667,
0.0161848459,
-0.0353469215,
-0.0225642323,
-0.0111707533,
0.0511676185,
-0.0183839593,
-0.035373386,
0.0370106325,
0.0629484504,
-0.040096987,
-0.0529706664,
-0.0821938366,
-0.0490267463,
0.004378417,
-0.0006643743,
0.0346510857,
-0.010157859,
0.0863217339,
-0.0175493024,
0.0705303922,
-0.0420264266,
0.0538321957,
0.0036791244,
0.0497753024,
0.0357455239,
-0.0044729146,
0.0294561107,
0.0443751626,
-0.0519612767,
-0.0113654453,
0.0321079716,
-0.0336559191,
0.0162504241,
0.0161792748,
0.0207202248,
0.0121601075,
0.0196532831,
-0.0187463928,
-0.0432021022,
0.0612967983,
0.0121279918,
0.0423929133,
0.0710784644,
-0.0055897059,
0.0449287221,
-0.0221989695,
0.0084503898,
-0.0144038694,
-0.0077516674,
-0.0426538028,
-0.0053922869,
0.0082938755,
-0.0459276065,
-0.0587957986,
-0.0018907411,
-0.014204558,
-0.0073296102,
0.0481998399,
-0.0061807521,
0.0353872925,
-0.013790139,
-0.0171817243,
-0.0388795137,
-0.0210038163,
-0.0007282312,
0.0118578877,
-0.0231045298,
-0.0011341557,
-0.0036945061,
0.0136437137,
-0.0421520695,
0.005905617,
0.0036244651,
0.0136817843,
-0.0069941869,
0.0030085125,
-0.0250011943,
0.0167331975,
0.0255637877,
0.0166158937,
0.0199218988,
0.033924263,
-0.0062205717,
-0.0150283575,
-0.0118199941,
0.0305491071,
0.0134085231,
0.0439072587,
-0.0284038614,
0.039554663,
0.043524351,
-0.0422205776,
-0.0038210372,
-0.0071887905,
3.078e-7,
0.0522399954,
0.0531347804,
-0.0178402364,
0.0012169369,
0.0562108755,
-0.0111224269,
0.006600962,
0.0047645569,
0.037098188,
0.0349324867,
0.0177514218,
-0.0147134317,
-0.0035988844,
0.018120084,
-0.1001512483,
-0.0266806763,
-0.0909738094,
-0.0854946524,
-0.048723802,
-0.0186855476,
0.0158864688,
0.0049115038,
-0.0296505671,
-0.0041569215,
-0.045184534,
-0.05771612,
0.040094763,
-0.0257849637,
-0.0053166305,
0.0411123335,
0.0574890077,
-0.0066928286,
0.0114957709,
-0.0588766299,
-0.0245525856,
0.0089923209,
-0.0211655572,
-0.0096184025,
0.0131563349,
-0.0034946054,
0.0564087182,
-0.0306129698,
0.0492443107,
-0.0642151162,
0.0290698465,
-0.03389927,
-0.0060607535,
-0.0420758724,
-0.0633864403,
-0.0219966713,
0.0188318584,
-0.0463835634,
-0.0350223444,
0.0516798757,
-0.0325083695,
-0.0125196278,
-0.027736757,
-0.034579508,
-0.0143712573,
0.0580158345,
-0.0398650803,
-0.0672365651,
-0.0095346794,
-0.0414051153,
-0.0431679636,
-0.0512679815,
0.0116729205,
3.095872151e-34,
0.0956117734,
-0.0114958081,
-0.0164204538,
0.0146288164,
0.0252274554,
0.0057216878,
-0.0661886856,
0.0508514196,
0.0152353169,
-0.0913028568,
-0.0186719652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01097v1 | Let's Negotiate! A Survey of Negotiation Dialogue Systems | 2024-02-02T02:12:46 | 2024-02-02T02:12:46 | Haolan Zhan, Yufei Wang, Tao Feng, Yuncheng Hua, Suraj Sharma, Zhuang Li, Lizhen Qu, Zhaleh Semnani Azad, Ingrid Zukerman, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Negotiation is a crucial ability in human communication. Recently, there has
been a resurgent research interest in negotiation dialogue systems, whose goal
is to create intelligent agents that can assist people in resolving conflicts
or reaching agreements. Although there have been many explorations into
negotiation dialogue systems, a systematic review of this task has not been
performed to date. We aim to fill this gap by investigating recent studies in
the field of negotiation dialogue systems, and covering benchmarks, evaluations
and methodologies within the literature. We also discuss potential future
directions, including multi-modal, multi-party and cross-cultural negotiation
scenarios. Our goal is to provide the community with a systematic overview of
negotiation dialogue systems and to inspire future research. | Let's Negotiate! A Survey of Negotiation Dialogue Systems: Negotiation is a crucial ability in human communication. Recently, there has
been a resurgent research interest in negotiation dialogue systems, whose goal
is to create intelligent agents that can assist people in resolving conflicts
or reaching agreements. Although there have been many explorations into
negotiation dialogue systems, a systematic review of this task has not been
performed to date. We aim to fill this gap by investigating recent studies in
the field of negotiation dialogue systems, and covering benchmarks, evaluations
and methodologies within the literature. We also discuss potential future
directions, including multi-modal, multi-party and cross-cultural negotiation
scenarios. Our goal is to provide the community with a systematic overview of
negotiation dialogue systems and to inspire future research. | [
0.0893710032,
0.029815061,
-0.0300944801,
-0.0017689844,
-0.0412676819,
-0.0183041003,
0.0561509877,
0.018224081,
0.0096797878,
-0.0354786888,
-0.0269345883,
-0.0148911476,
0.0058863489,
0.0273430813,
0.0004389705,
-0.0568104461,
0.0401588641,
-0.0042124218,
0.0686253011,
-0.0157782994,
0.0310659893,
-0.0012941958,
-0.0421825089,
0.0635636672,
-0.0740353763,
-0.0072159581,
-0.0762924105,
-0.0038168612,
0.0496472828,
-0.0005244746,
-0.0343716405,
0.0477720685,
-0.0126475459,
0.0375744253,
0.0000016829,
-0.0706954598,
-0.0011651559,
-0.0222250987,
-0.0257546566,
-0.0267678108,
0.0717607588,
-0.0225345939,
-0.0148716755,
0.0372627452,
-0.0623643249,
-0.0103330323,
0.0359689258,
0.0831660256,
0.0664801896,
0.0633407161,
-0.0041155485,
0.0188819375,
-0.0128650488,
-0.0187924933,
-0.0385876372,
-0.070671998,
-0.0035403329,
-0.0234569106,
-0.0035367513,
-0.0022730471,
0.0048092064,
-0.0058593675,
0.00891174,
-0.0619098917,
-0.0981224477,
0.0231693275,
-0.0672956407,
-0.0292154029,
-0.0120307859,
0.075772129,
0.0504730679,
0.0192508157,
0.001728675,
-0.0019465429,
0.0153638581,
-0.0199874919,
-0.0244595725,
0.0264121871,
-0.0125896661,
-0.0164367985,
-0.0113878669,
0.003739794,
-0.0288560782,
-0.0122977505,
-0.0184287075,
0.0596300215,
-0.017081894,
-0.0157496948,
0.0100003602,
-0.0242547002,
0.0416756533,
-0.1103130803,
0.0009721701,
0.0325778276,
-0.0900494531,
0.0088961767,
-0.0100694001,
0.0061998153,
0.0287665576,
-0.0284695327,
-0.0016819895,
0.0257350486,
0.0151074361,
0.0422383361,
0.0755276904,
-0.015094894,
0.0129021313,
0.0173223559,
0.0043081585,
-0.017466642,
-0.0587916225,
-0.0150471609,
-0.0599135458,
0.0026301665,
-0.0385535732,
-0.0188764706,
-0.011953407,
0.0121613331,
-0.0474257693,
0.0350085162,
-0.0113993017,
0.0282492787,
-0.00366121,
0.0173833016,
-0.0549660772,
-0.0101793325,
-0.0665121824,
0.0168650337,
0.0205578823,
-0.0349859223,
0.0087608779,
0.0298884287,
-0.0140028596,
0.0274490453,
-0.0166367814,
0.058908049,
-0.0219715014,
0.0145523893,
0.0316523202,
-0.0233322699,
0.0139810601,
-0.079410173,
-0.0354818814,
-0.0350081027,
0.074187763,
-0.0198363066,
-0.0620303154,
-0.0418087468,
0.0321472026,
0.0180156995,
0.0043870569,
0.0476404205,
0.0156344119,
0.0173411667,
0.05017801,
0.0305368081,
-0.0609034412,
0.0251198504,
0.0747989863,
0.0116792005,
0.0450596884,
0.027618086,
0.0310523696,
0.0250154622,
-0.0119624687,
-0.0031065147,
0.057182081,
0.0232124776,
-0.0054730363,
0.0390536562,
-0.0600782633,
0.0565382354,
-0.0669239312,
-0.0683944002,
0.0702485368,
0.0837135017,
-0.0328309983,
0.044280827,
0.0043344069,
0.0571776889,
0.0334419794,
-0.0509116165,
-0.0279735737,
0.0328375809,
-0.003094089,
-0.0379236676,
0.0014942327,
0.0206864495,
-0.0377137698,
-0.0428170376,
0.0261086598,
-0.006421362,
0.0724982321,
0.0284777693,
0.012263827,
-0.0180338398,
-0.0333016925,
-0.024165066,
-0.0170369204,
-0.0126204779,
-0.0447061248,
-0.0226968806,
-0.0076688514,
0.0227505341,
0.046083767,
-0.0246973354,
-0.0246670097,
-0.0334529281,
-0.0228414461,
0.0589302033,
0.0720538646,
-0.0278403983,
0.0123063382,
-0.0546411276,
-0.0345708951,
0.0156275518,
-0.0214981474,
0.028283257,
-0.004554654,
-0.000422022,
-0.0190972164,
0.0364736579,
0.0569218397,
-0.0082263639,
0.0463994518,
0.0339031145,
0.0181108844,
0.0191912185,
0.0511991493,
0.0316985585,
-0.007583377,
-0.0141580012,
0.0246481523,
0.0163755901,
-0.0341483951,
0.0713118911,
-0.006198192,
-0.0330413692,
0.0170478541,
-0.0264976993,
-0.0328999311,
-0.011037061,
-0.0097979251,
-0.0413073897,
0.0405259393,
-0.0062506027,
-0.0080629056,
-0.0358440056,
0.0115255807,
0.0164278001,
-0.0109262858,
-0.0022478017,
0.0095453309,
0.0311952978,
-0.0558541454,
0.0229435582,
-0.0257950276,
0.0397198386,
-0.0546812713,
0.0194871761,
0.0425343625,
0.0075704874,
-0.0060650208,
0.0165718868,
0.0169251524,
-0.0366231985,
-0.0360239185,
-0.0952105224,
-0.0147750163,
0.0075969039,
-0.0132665578,
-0.0271990504,
-0.0197475143,
0.0145733645,
0.0028226853,
-0.0578603484,
0.0520209596,
0.0658408105,
-0.0165810585,
0.0377898626,
0.0087262699,
-0.0439976901,
-0.0080953073,
0.0160860922,
-0.0103018228,
0.0274023972,
-0.014949155,
-0.0097968848,
-0.0215251874,
-0.0067069461,
-0.0631862581,
0.0438961983,
-0.0115766628,
-0.0635867119,
0.0636908859,
0.0321516432,
-0.008216897,
0.0515674576,
0.0525678284,
0.0731151849,
-0.014602582,
-0.0420141108,
-0.0646525919,
0.041684512,
-0.0097713834,
0.0367943235,
-0.070007503,
-0.0270930566,
-0.0144941621,
0.0080021704,
0.0066319909,
0.0442956649,
-0.0224969313,
0.052866444,
0.0749612451,
-0.0520496964,
0.0153099075,
-0.0124807116,
-0.0245675705,
0.0861821249,
-0.0016804115,
0.0036006619,
0.0622359626,
-0.0066990801,
-0.0035268955,
0.0087508298,
-0.0008134908,
-0.0465099551,
0.0529554412,
-0.0475013219,
0.010181535,
0.042063769,
-0.0213593151,
-0.0243971758,
-0.0449494645,
0.0482047163,
-0.0376056693,
0.0058970628,
-0.0342382342,
-0.0216433797,
-0.0072401594,
-0.0291175041,
-0.0450181626,
-0.0187671874,
-0.0099892281,
0.0382918231,
0.0203471668,
0.0023912226,
-0.0719237775,
0.0177160054,
0.0073158164,
-0.001777018,
0.0772496536,
-0.0069533759,
-0.0193478558,
-0.0506078303,
0.0276005659,
0.055915609,
0.0101416958,
0.0109270085,
0.040920414,
0.0427861102,
0.0051689805,
-0.0089968564,
0.0080178296,
-0.0207799282,
0.0163775124,
-0.001781397,
0.0080878297,
-0.0181326848,
-0.0015868735,
-0.0200376082,
0.0285730381,
0.0438223071,
0.036082793,
-0.0023334776,
0.0065069455,
-0.0440245084,
-0.0001644296,
-0.0094023785,
0.021845147,
-0.0986567363,
0.002544157,
-0.0201824084,
0.0002085723,
-0.0609977618,
-0.0517447814,
0.0000920385,
-0.0644886643,
0.0276109613,
-0.0103366682,
-0.0128023829,
0.0273733512,
0.0328139998,
0.0056670629,
0.0008338358,
-0.0044175722,
-0.0271641724,
0.0716844797,
-0.0380889028,
-0.0328646787,
0.0045026313,
0.0212920606,
0.016115183,
-0.032034725,
0.0490399711,
0.032373827,
0.047549136,
0.0500489771,
0.0104345614,
0.0014189484,
0.0579131246,
-0.0332793407,
-0.0013563382,
0.000775583,
-0.0266250372,
0.0082180249,
-0.0240059793,
0.0299058519,
-0.0052174563,
-0.0431384258,
0.057951156,
0.0268542767,
-0.0554520376,
0.0131561812,
0.0081996536,
0.03225068,
0.0363005027,
0.0369638465,
0.0049675889,
-0.0362163484,
-0.0787449628,
-0.0251914933,
-0.0397825763,
-0.017289672,
-0.0317430496,
0.0144607946,
0.0258412156,
0.0136515526,
-0.0188739654,
-0.1150345057,
0.0284779537,
0.0328213833,
-0.0024722018,
-0.0192886554,
0.0507362373,
0.0259448122,
0.0385070294,
-0.0068411417,
-0.0003843363,
-0.0077271257,
-0.0087135229,
-0.0173808038,
-0.0222792029,
-0.0453144014,
-0.0011264976,
0.0064836019,
-0.0121062389,
-0.0272639394,
-0.0409027338,
0.0565925241,
0.0281434152,
-0.0011101075,
0.0039304141,
-0.0162982643,
-0.0517758206,
0.0011247399,
0.0198142771,
-0.0297804922,
0.0394847058,
0.0512484573,
-0.0006555294,
0.0381817967,
-0.015698513,
0.0297620147,
0.0090981396,
0.0250102151,
-0.0420224965,
-0.0733114555,
0.0177403446,
-0.0288898908,
-0.0544218607,
0.030320717,
-0.0542834997,
-0.0120625198,
0.0350463726,
-0.0547752194,
-0.0197269842,
-0.0387489945,
-0.024675183,
-0.0501267388,
-0.0200459417,
0.0428852178,
-0.0136117255,
-0.0441104583,
0.0260249823,
0.0373255648,
0.0403469428,
0.0028080945,
-0.0071281791,
-0.0066137421,
-0.0183302052,
0.0237669237,
0.0360973142,
-0.0068971631,
0.018894935,
0.0233701244,
0.0873906463,
0.0315661095,
-0.0566664711,
0.0068921521,
0.0300948955,
-0.0455712862,
-0.0634429157,
0.0688084066,
0.0500541218,
0.0267671645,
0.0440707281,
0.0057322206,
-0.041121006,
0.0205729418,
0.0104012433,
0.03962522,
0.0140934139,
-0.0468487293,
0.0174606461,
0.0267646667,
-0.0190043915,
0.0229111612,
-0.0086390879,
-0.0671232641,
-0.0053364993,
-0.0147940814,
-0.037872415,
-0.0587874427,
-0.0273025353,
-0.0391974375,
-0.0012988701,
-0.0150331324,
0.008709779,
-0.070996359,
0.005197702,
-0.0036097546,
0.0203176662,
0.004982613,
-0.0052787508,
0.0173023883,
0.0292176045,
0.0256061293,
-0.0160560384,
-0.0296359938,
0.0125472164,
-0.0537541434,
-0.0297225472,
-0.0369737707,
-4.987549062e-33,
0.0004216977,
-0.0499346741,
0.0394460708,
0.0536033288,
-0.0374659859,
-0.0758107901,
-0.0270476528,
-0.0010186264,
-0.016588835,
0.0380106308,
-0.0541132465,
0.006248855,
0.0310282335,
-0.0364272371,
-0.0021473621,
-0.0030343698,
0.0217414629,
-0.0216221549,
-0.0459147841,
-0.0034201122,
0.0223614033,
-0.0417902134,
0.0092888828,
-0.0940997973,
-0.0050252485,
-0.0182785373,
-0.0280328672,
0.0365612805,
-0.0170723405,
0.0689877793,
-0.003620042,
0.0042465422,
0.0034706888,
-0.0105365114,
0.0201743226,
0.0370877348,
-0.0469339304,
0.018519124,
0.0043427707,
-0.0132965809,
-0.0238989461,
-0.0102527253,
-0.0155186402,
0.0027581954,
-0.0166502949,
0.0115300333,
-0.0125754336,
-0.0112034446,
0.000589495,
0.0178564899,
-0.0544800498,
0.0202103946,
-0.0607461259,
-0.0373599865,
-0.0047161086,
0.0481804907,
0.0064379834,
-0.0539320745,
-0.0457367264,
0.0373523198,
-0.0153109403,
-0.0419292599,
0.0349406004,
-0.0358218998,
0.0193705373,
0.0401285104,
0.0566873401,
0.0686837435,
-0.0032312737,
-0.0729729757,
-0.0232401751,
0.0775177404,
0.0289152618,
0.0876122266,
-0.0621792302,
-0.0232437439,
-0.0360646918,
0.0029808283,
0.0778532326,
0.0535570756,
0.0096189007,
0.0071883099,
0.0240596998,
-0.0057666288,
-0.03912884,
-0.0357822999,
-0.0196204763,
-0.0525519364,
0.0443530455,
0.0445636548,
0.0313653648,
0.0053588063,
0.0426648259,
-0.0345217958,
0.0180782415,
0.0206485223,
0.0327446312,
0.042137403,
-0.0147304926,
-0.0292448383,
-0.0273661036,
-0.0171976425,
0.0204113573,
-0.0202216655,
0.0443547405,
0.0071605346,
-0.0030453112,
-0.0170190148,
-0.007934643,
0.0094076879,
0.0050151986,
0.0811859593,
-0.055125095,
-0.0158342663,
0.0047824401,
0.0073598488,
-0.0154393809,
-0.0103819165,
-0.00978358,
-0.0304968394,
-0.0609140061,
0.0047444296,
0.0236216076,
0.0123892436,
-0.0243565496,
0.0177174676,
-0.0043244073,
-0.0237466916,
0.002446779,
0.025133146,
-0.0096144145,
-0.0271076988,
2.28e-7,
-0.0335953832,
0.025322672,
0.0223644301,
0.0580819584,
0.0230794102,
0.066987507,
0.0052608885,
0.0477884859,
0.0143955098,
-0.022591887,
0.0342388749,
0.0177886952,
0.0539886393,
0.0600562021,
-0.0539936386,
-0.0129310004,
0.0001813272,
-0.0874563828,
-0.0477873795,
0.007771228,
0.1064219102,
0.0116121843,
0.0106007997,
0.0261877459,
-0.0345561616,
0.0180093218,
0.031665083,
-0.0596596003,
-0.0200870484,
0.0430944227,
0.0266895983,
-0.0963216573,
0.0192721486,
0.0142305633,
0.0222251341,
0.0289969947,
-0.0487271287,
0.0343355685,
-0.0167176649,
-0.061548546,
0.0025956545,
-0.0045329812,
0.0106577035,
-0.0305353906,
0.0007973618,
-0.0445009358,
-0.0393355489,
-0.0016938857,
0.0042934823,
-0.0256441962,
0.0141651137,
0.0036538632,
0.01303636,
-0.0041140504,
0.0081394371,
0.0078581301,
0.0668921545,
-0.0592987463,
0.007809557,
0.0109935189,
-0.0257453471,
-0.0157050919,
0.0248712245,
-0.0005307817,
0.0147973569,
-0.0014149527,
-0.0259556919,
1.190468014e-34,
0.0238456577,
-0.0110854469,
-0.0061073676,
0.0920787975,
0.0551125407,
0.0188360978,
0.0077985106,
0.0068983715,
0.0396200642,
-0.0556406677,
-0.0184292104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01093v1 | Specialized Language Models with Cheap Inference from Limited Domain Data | 2024-02-02T01:45:18 | 2024-02-02T01:45:18 | David Grangier, Angelos Katharopoulos, Pierre Ablin, Awni Hannun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models have emerged as a versatile tool but are challenging to
apply to tasks lacking large inference budgets and large in-domain training
sets. This work formalizes these constraints and distinguishes four important
variables: the pretraining budget (for training before the target domain is
known), the specialization budget (for training after the target domain is
known), the inference budget, and the in-domain training set size. Across these
settings, we compare different approaches from the machine learning literature.
Limited by inference cost, we find better alternatives to the standard practice
of training very large vanilla transformer models. In particular, we show that
hyper-networks and mixture of experts have better perplexity for large
pretraining budgets, while small models trained on importance sampled datasets
are attractive for large specialization budgets. | Specialized Language Models with Cheap Inference from Limited Domain Data: Large language models have emerged as a versatile tool but are challenging to
apply to tasks lacking large inference budgets and large in-domain training
sets. This work formalizes these constraints and distinguishes four important
variables: the pretraining budget (for training before the target domain is
known), the specialization budget (for training after the target domain is
known), the inference budget, and the in-domain training set size. Across these
settings, we compare different approaches from the machine learning literature.
Limited by inference cost, we find better alternatives to the standard practice
of training very large vanilla transformer models. In particular, we show that
hyper-networks and mixture of experts have better perplexity for large
pretraining budgets, while small models trained on importance sampled datasets
are attractive for large specialization budgets. | [
0.0311550982,
0.068064779,
0.0044500353,
0.0241870489,
-0.0194940809,
0.0086687431,
0.0122571103,
-0.007608193,
-0.0429445095,
-0.0188867021,
-0.045056656,
-0.0241079442,
-0.0084973397,
-0.0049649635,
0.007560004,
-0.0532794334,
0.0015296496,
-0.0213460345,
-0.0242277011,
-0.0117519405,
-0.0135173136,
0.0312511623,
-0.0085012484,
0.0356137492,
-0.0000261782,
0.0154729821,
-0.0222087093,
0.0144325551,
0.0002899971,
0.0042948849,
-0.0053684846,
0.0615360141,
0.0446926244,
0.0288058873,
0.0000018459,
-0.033496324,
-0.0483530089,
-0.0211710688,
-0.032043431,
-0.0156031372,
0.0343140773,
-0.063434951,
0.020318184,
0.016807517,
-0.0219510831,
-0.0674657598,
0.0809777752,
0.0573439039,
0.0312110875,
0.0844595656,
-0.0124247484,
-0.0272199549,
0.0148243504,
-0.0730405226,
-0.0329545178,
-0.0657140985,
-0.0001834315,
-0.0042833555,
-0.029424049,
0.0039525321,
-0.0165481605,
0.0145563018,
0.0420433953,
0.0386080667,
-0.0294723324,
0.0248346049,
-0.0368280225,
-0.0120201921,
0.0021071285,
0.0544885434,
-0.067139037,
-0.0188926738,
0.0024791837,
-0.0075230123,
-0.0058387625,
0.0305279195,
-0.0072919689,
0.0400638394,
0.0107474811,
0.0091534881,
0.0149507504,
0.0144732734,
0.0433820561,
0.0104555236,
-0.0793006271,
0.0162311532,
0.0158045255,
0.016826991,
-0.0143636977,
-0.0057928632,
-0.0840996802,
-0.0321583934,
-0.0328992195,
0.0208154749,
0.0146845253,
0.0052669635,
-0.0561433062,
-0.0538456105,
-0.0256536044,
0.0357765257,
0.0144987274,
0.0088431723,
0.0021694507,
0.0617356263,
-0.0004477025,
0.0113031808,
-0.0485193543,
0.0093319826,
-0.0260934923,
-0.0313566178,
-0.0269864909,
-0.0065589603,
-0.0758325011,
0.0209794007,
-0.0163554009,
-0.0091101304,
-0.012873061,
-0.0080821449,
0.0021687404,
-0.0081469519,
0.0188937839,
-0.0014276309,
-0.0766641945,
-0.0569429249,
0.0373627841,
0.0575209819,
-0.0015442489,
0.050099995,
-0.0071453997,
-0.0395330936,
-0.0219835602,
0.0492859557,
0.0198172592,
-0.0218204278,
0.0276184678,
0.0967281982,
-0.0121927923,
-0.0538945906,
-0.025848154,
0.0210395753,
-0.002276242,
-0.0778991282,
0.0102255028,
-0.0814772099,
0.0223385468,
0.0105550326,
0.0134697417,
-0.0411964655,
0.0062328079,
-0.0173168518,
-0.016211126,
0.0816977769,
-0.0020703392,
0.0247163493,
0.0065642814,
-0.0185100548,
-0.0265760552,
0.0763707235,
0.0113210771,
-0.0253721792,
0.0202195607,
-0.0203443449,
0.0249252617,
0.043058034,
0.0104744425,
0.0126727512,
-0.0247274563,
-0.017013846,
-0.0404366478,
-0.0111751296,
0.0182021353,
0.0369747728,
-0.036796283,
0.0039490722,
0.0495297089,
0.0446851514,
-0.0014283594,
0.009443976,
0.0500269718,
0.0272055082,
-0.0111624105,
-0.0141494526,
-0.0574480407,
-0.0119352546,
0.0048231711,
-0.0052616601,
-0.0139154689,
0.0216525514,
-0.0651282445,
-0.0358483903,
0.0261400323,
-0.0429715067,
0.0020163893,
0.0204109568,
0.1136653721,
0.0464915819,
-0.0193312597,
0.0963243395,
0.0344458185,
-0.0200797208,
0.0029862972,
-0.0400788561,
-0.0087562297,
0.0205279179,
0.0061329524,
-0.0454966091,
-0.009135806,
-0.0245019272,
0.0327641703,
0.0077615338,
0.0183908083,
0.0114516551,
0.0408705436,
-0.0558927134,
0.0120067159,
-0.0050535556,
0.0607766658,
0.0192709118,
0.0247621909,
-0.0075042313,
0.0367510207,
-0.0741211101,
0.0071455576,
0.0072349999,
-0.0366721302,
0.0105412006,
0.0090312408,
0.0380939096,
0.0242202152,
0.0001156349,
-0.0366430171,
0.0034289917,
0.0055442839,
-0.0448965579,
-0.0182790104,
-0.0075758537,
-0.0027201201,
-0.0484705083,
0.0213874672,
-0.073814556,
0.005639791,
0.0525422283,
-0.0489825532,
-0.0346059278,
0.0175788216,
-0.0325667076,
0.0632667318,
-0.0426373594,
0.0212362837,
-0.0015757908,
0.0243177954,
-0.0507021807,
0.0457413606,
-0.0048273569,
0.0293769315,
-0.0088342857,
-0.0190709401,
0.0220618267,
-0.0309781116,
-0.0542330295,
-0.009051159,
-0.0141018452,
0.0284226462,
-0.0156173976,
-0.0013151104,
0.0199702494,
-0.0402387902,
-0.0637065023,
-0.0328755081,
-0.0648834631,
-0.0062744254,
0.0102213556,
0.0409050956,
0.0078948149,
-0.0137227392,
-0.0134530151,
-0.0074143796,
0.00659345,
0.0039938688,
0.0061279307,
0.0070780022,
-0.0265008435,
-0.0132692987,
-0.0415492207,
0.0108444458,
0.0815636069,
-0.0033825266,
0.0023595893,
-0.0433734804,
0.0140345618,
-0.0055282502,
0.0555698052,
-0.0251818001,
-0.044956103,
-0.0188791305,
-0.0421062335,
0.0241299681,
0.0441025048,
-0.0079363883,
-0.0154658919,
0.0114960885,
0.0327360369,
-0.045887351,
-0.0008395515,
-0.0537160486,
-0.0335562937,
-0.0396765135,
0.0052752001,
-0.0003305425,
0.0647343621,
-0.0238337014,
-0.0314458422,
-0.0370533355,
0.0281441044,
0.0083973221,
-0.0087768342,
0.0334866904,
0.0282592755,
0.0352133177,
0.0551054627,
-0.0182253662,
-0.0375624448,
0.0749103129,
-0.0060773706,
0.0078748437,
-0.0593502037,
-0.0334963463,
-0.0531084575,
0.0457668304,
0.0079118712,
0.0179761816,
0.0325757153,
-0.0395831019,
-0.0596456081,
0.008049977,
0.0105646765,
-0.0019704404,
0.1019373462,
-0.0150105143,
0.0323059857,
-0.0152738625,
-0.048926957,
-0.0375248156,
-0.0628105104,
-0.0453897081,
0.0018557033,
0.0202933773,
-0.0254479032,
-0.0495950654,
0.0470048338,
-0.0121518411,
0.0891453251,
0.0023348723,
0.0177783873,
-0.022200549,
0.0423879921,
0.0216386132,
-0.0023774768,
0.0041156411,
-0.0382908881,
0.0173248611,
0.0148548288,
0.0111241769,
-0.003188127,
-0.0421699099,
-0.0054649934,
0.0257975385,
-0.0043439516,
-0.0149469469,
0.001134631,
0.03988396,
-0.0235997196,
-0.0180748943,
0.1160196066,
-0.0002456296,
-0.0576505698,
0.0086850962,
0.0335663892,
0.0194214284,
0.0172812678,
0.0265844632,
-0.080179669,
-0.0173694976,
0.0147916824,
0.0050477264,
0.0175090842,
-0.015483127,
0.0045040981,
-0.1237997934,
0.0236419551,
-0.002137163,
-0.0423434675,
-0.0454935431,
-0.0244332235,
0.0053931689,
-0.0261937995,
0.0018214581,
-0.0291482136,
0.009755509,
-0.0414914414,
0.0205311868,
0.0123175634,
-0.0783237293,
0.0122178299,
-0.0444279052,
0.0065238159,
0.0089732567,
-0.0173717979,
-0.0180321038,
-0.0249871481,
0.0367034264,
0.0255418774,
-0.0185235534,
0.0078062792,
0.0659370944,
0.0188961513,
-0.0412059575,
0.0380707048,
0.054611776,
-0.038948372,
0.0095876791,
-0.0023557593,
0.0523772277,
-0.0369223952,
-0.0036692289,
0.0211437549,
-0.0235288572,
0.0166518837,
0.0564641021,
0.0072323959,
-0.0632526278,
0.0166648086,
-0.0001831297,
-0.0005172427,
-0.0316628516,
-0.0047505172,
0.0204093717,
0.0278577544,
-0.0876871273,
-0.0367779173,
0.0060723932,
0.0210045539,
0.0573341697,
0.0114247575,
-0.0186422523,
0.0386568196,
0.0308966022,
-0.0645852834,
0.0704038516,
-0.0460149944,
0.0059964485,
-0.059198603,
0.002620236,
0.0670305863,
-0.0159769841,
-0.0269115008,
-0.0172441341,
-0.0610338189,
-0.0578065217,
-0.0310735703,
0.0406470634,
0.0294514578,
0.0406247266,
-0.0240290444,
-0.043301031,
-0.0105426377,
0.0246485751,
-0.0455673784,
-0.0110017881,
0.0659784004,
-0.0385055505,
-0.0043831333,
0.0579022951,
-0.0233715698,
0.0670972914,
0.0542863458,
-0.0037358017,
-0.0257167332,
-0.0125140613,
0.0170480274,
-0.0301526748,
0.0636202693,
0.0016933581,
0.0412445478,
-0.019490689,
0.0163160898,
-0.0056764423,
-0.025065342,
-0.0615944155,
-0.0184476841,
0.0482553467,
0.0379495956,
-0.0170770772,
-0.0173358116,
0.0107958214,
0.0500538461,
-0.0016318042,
0.0152645744,
-0.0094037671,
-0.0268591866,
0.0499471761,
-0.006266485,
-0.0212605353,
-0.0128264455,
0.0204063263,
0.0008382234,
-0.0091421297,
0.0277439225,
0.0179817844,
-0.0064288354,
-0.0770489126,
-0.0007344294,
-0.0525215864,
-0.0612231754,
-0.0063622198,
0.0004691967,
0.0640029609,
-0.0427677706,
0.0072496831,
-0.0034921088,
-0.0053697149,
-0.0323080644,
0.0348194391,
0.0171928126,
-0.0101452693,
0.0178701282,
0.0340531953,
-0.0146405818,
0.0500896983,
0.1039423719,
0.0287126843,
0.0400211252,
0.0137417391,
0.0109581398,
-0.0453152843,
-0.0032064233,
0.0048492812,
0.0400910713,
-0.0191016663,
0.0319552161,
-0.0303627476,
-0.0957635269,
0.0125625972,
-0.034766376,
-0.020132754,
0.006519414,
0.0314787291,
0.0498037226,
-0.0456739478,
-0.0112695843,
-0.0334896073,
0.0171280783,
0.0469590798,
-0.0141411684,
-0.0283042733,
-6.148502548e-33,
0.0300832093,
0.0084445318,
-0.0136711197,
-0.0176248848,
0.0141766006,
0.0101241814,
-0.0207564514,
0.0237959642,
-0.0355004296,
0.0111922473,
-0.0188830569,
0.0163649749,
0.0121316193,
0.0574254543,
-0.016407812,
0.0020795106,
0.0570862517,
0.0160348918,
-0.0098876329,
0.0020981634,
0.0040309518,
0.0184692685,
0.0834413692,
-0.0777383223,
-0.0532371476,
-0.0046293051,
-0.0127413115,
0.0525714979,
0.0183699783,
0.0245443135,
0.0208880305,
0.0341634117,
0.0257509649,
-0.0930782408,
-0.0058119851,
0.0053300178,
-0.0740179792,
-0.0031417301,
-0.0039925319,
0.0053987605,
0.018705897,
-0.0244388431,
0.0608436763,
0.0022866053,
0.0236582421,
-0.0174136087,
0.0237823706,
-0.0203899201,
0.0007401612,
-0.0111703584,
-0.0315767415,
0.0472865924,
0.0062562716,
-0.0165944714,
0.0118622547,
0.0423796512,
-0.0149609772,
0.0116444053,
-0.0207389016,
0.0159694254,
0.0403148793,
0.0318664797,
0.0320657939,
0.0424271896,
-0.0111145815,
0.0232300609,
0.0284849126,
0.0171914976,
0.0094530545,
0.0144725377,
0.0524360165,
0.0630119517,
0.0309077278,
0.0268542394,
0.0218448676,
-0.0010590209,
-0.0796160921,
-0.0355104282,
-0.0192106031,
0.0161926821,
0.0443358943,
-0.0072184275,
-0.0448563658,
-0.0196641758,
-0.0449792817,
-0.0029866786,
-0.0195201095,
-0.0077149635,
-0.0072977217,
0.0512553193,
-0.0332547277,
0.0140968896,
0.0426722541,
-0.0718989521,
-0.0269996542,
0.0281639416,
0.01749295,
0.0353786908,
-0.0258058086,
0.0079759443,
-0.0282215159,
-0.0352965891,
-0.0090480857,
0.0092325406,
-0.0088272607,
-0.0218544174,
0.0556018464,
0.00690324,
-0.0735001191,
-0.0325380005,
-0.0055154706,
0.0176902302,
0.0018364872,
0.1119986326,
0.0447250307,
0.0251846854,
-0.0207799617,
0.018440051,
0.0088499244,
-0.0435481891,
0.0040433221,
0.0521602333,
0.027071232,
0.0264793076,
-0.0190026034,
-0.0266360622,
-0.041713383,
-0.0395025909,
0.0353561528,
-0.060471382,
-0.0183016043,
0.0109611498,
2.6e-7,
0.0318769552,
0.0069779572,
0.0099682352,
-0.0129832933,
0.0318530761,
0.0134098828,
0.0249742158,
-0.0146987233,
-0.0185146648,
-0.0105855679,
0.0317969136,
0.0384984873,
0.0419255868,
0.0005274002,
-0.1146412417,
-0.0362123661,
0.0002836859,
0.0174779948,
-0.0190480594,
-0.0148016615,
0.0102584288,
0.1665715277,
0.0316052921,
-0.0055342787,
0.0001876637,
-0.0427894369,
0.0458563231,
-0.0137171373,
0.0193052441,
0.0532008111,
0.0167577136,
0.0719119385,
-0.0026285884,
0.0394444466,
0.0079886075,
0.0501617976,
0.0393030643,
0.0787680224,
-0.010348428,
-0.0114741502,
0.0113502722,
-0.0007684203,
-0.0323072076,
-0.0342268758,
0.0592869408,
-0.1359159499,
-0.0259815603,
-0.0223662648,
-0.0251784828,
-0.00362307,
-0.0122069083,
0.0010858412,
-0.0021609154,
0.0395017155,
0.0381465144,
-0.0148683898,
0.0101495069,
-0.0683672354,
0.0068823565,
0.020779334,
-0.0755773559,
-0.0215797536,
0.0031666148,
-0.0348058306,
0.0549951829,
-0.0190746486,
0.0401211679,
2.425168824e-34,
0.0610243753,
-0.021728497,
-0.011820511,
0.0161138475,
0.0043638228,
-0.0267084613,
-0.0260888897,
-0.016657697,
0.0139080463,
-0.1035872176,
0.0075218738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01091v1 | Reading Between the Tweets: Deciphering Ideological Stances of Interconnected Mixed-Ideology Communities | 2024-02-02T01:39:00 | 2024-02-02T01:39:00 | Zihao He, Ashwin Rao, Siyi Guo, Negar Mokhberian, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Recent advances in NLP have improved our ability to understand the nuanced
worldviews of online communities. Existing research focused on probing
ideological stances treats liberals and conservatives as separate groups.
However, this fails to account for the nuanced views of the organically formed
online communities and the connections between them. In this paper, we study
discussions of the 2020 U.S. election on Twitter to identify complex
interacting communities. Capitalizing on this interconnectedness, we introduce
a novel approach that harnesses message passing when finetuning language models
(LMs) to probe the nuanced ideologies of these communities. By comparing the
responses generated by LMs and real-world survey results, our method shows
higher alignment than existing baselines, highlighting the potential of using
LMs in revealing complex ideologies within and across interconnected
mixed-ideology communities. | Reading Between the Tweets: Deciphering Ideological Stances of Interconnected Mixed-Ideology Communities: Recent advances in NLP have improved our ability to understand the nuanced
worldviews of online communities. Existing research focused on probing
ideological stances treats liberals and conservatives as separate groups.
However, this fails to account for the nuanced views of the organically formed
online communities and the connections between them. In this paper, we study
discussions of the 2020 U.S. election on Twitter to identify complex
interacting communities. Capitalizing on this interconnectedness, we introduce
a novel approach that harnesses message passing when finetuning language models
(LMs) to probe the nuanced ideologies of these communities. By comparing the
responses generated by LMs and real-world survey results, our method shows
higher alignment than existing baselines, highlighting the potential of using
LMs in revealing complex ideologies within and across interconnected
mixed-ideology communities. | [
0.027249923,
0.0502380542,
-0.0080502043,
0.0533032082,
-0.0472298376,
0.0089585325,
-0.0366451219,
-0.0087475087,
0.006807331,
-0.0422234461,
0.0235186499,
-0.0174020622,
-0.0083269589,
-0.0023341661,
-0.0103199324,
-0.0571155846,
0.0325362906,
0.0302261543,
0.0441427566,
-0.0413766652,
0.0634705275,
0.0407794267,
0.0096511077,
0.0274269972,
-0.0028823751,
-0.0283084046,
0.0076614758,
0.020550942,
0.0588494428,
0.0331346504,
0.0439518876,
0.0336643644,
-0.028826585,
0.0618714988,
0.000001738,
-0.0024812203,
-0.0422227457,
-0.0431698821,
0.0443662107,
0.0000269072,
0.1022434831,
-0.0037702553,
0.021312708,
0.0182825308,
-0.0456998162,
0.0391369276,
0.0490483642,
0.0399580412,
0.0604273304,
0.0421242565,
-0.0123728067,
-0.0337070264,
-0.0163202584,
-0.0097420234,
-0.0468035713,
-0.0365092382,
0.0636425167,
-0.0355073325,
-0.0555256158,
0.0380485654,
-0.0154537167,
0.0448012687,
-0.0063105104,
0.0061373706,
-0.0268970691,
-0.0054839794,
0.0100138215,
-0.0108923586,
0.0206825733,
0.0639907271,
0.0008865933,
-0.0119400481,
0.05789667,
-0.0291704535,
-0.0468147211,
0.0471688323,
-0.0677024871,
-0.0239131358,
-0.0324295685,
0.0443896428,
0.0496185161,
-0.0009653439,
0.0239761733,
0.0490363613,
-0.0523395725,
0.0921018645,
-0.0149280168,
0.0051610218,
-0.026851112,
0.0288671609,
-0.0091633527,
0.0059949504,
0.0259796958,
-0.0255187899,
0.029674761,
0.0132886022,
-0.0394051112,
0.0211022291,
0.0074210134,
-0.0364317037,
-0.0048901346,
-0.0165342726,
0.009839992,
0.0653228462,
0.034010496,
-0.0607346706,
-0.0300587751,
0.0044151712,
0.019567417,
-0.0277604889,
-0.033306431,
-0.0165677909,
0.0067149526,
0.0121499728,
-0.0170100201,
-0.0063009071,
-0.0076180287,
-0.0139691103,
-0.0583896749,
-0.0280156005,
-0.0380367599,
-0.0197343659,
0.0314685367,
-0.031772688,
-0.0181932282,
0.0660719797,
-0.0640770197,
0.0209479611,
-0.0309915971,
-0.0300901663,
0.0190088209,
0.0409177057,
0.0179079734,
-0.0430100001,
-0.0286977552,
0.0085203424,
0.0169442389,
-0.0040146601,
0.0213395022,
-0.0366732851,
-0.0189845916,
-0.0257812012,
0.0230254382,
-0.0804748908,
0.0676853359,
0.0158904009,
0.0149232326,
-0.0537391491,
0.0018538651,
0.0420076996,
-0.0785055682,
0.0448251925,
0.0242934395,
0.030543562,
0.0222219024,
0.0127986129,
0.0471751094,
0.094744876,
-0.0054215128,
0.0176743884,
0.0437874645,
0.0060515385,
-0.0167755913,
0.0416538455,
-0.0000889751,
0.0165939759,
-0.0274007041,
0.0082292883,
-0.0323448479,
-0.0258886311,
-0.0034368848,
0.0843227133,
0.0130250724,
-0.028489178,
0.0352401286,
0.0537008755,
-0.0097191604,
-0.0166815016,
0.0288290605,
0.0391606577,
-0.00679196,
0.0326493941,
0.013410476,
-0.0069903927,
-0.0107571557,
-0.0508416928,
0.0730394647,
0.0444418117,
-0.0177093111,
-0.0107320733,
-0.0037988436,
0.0055788867,
0.0365132764,
-0.0366354808,
0.0228773747,
-0.0514696427,
-0.0085344967,
0.0237569902,
0.0497763529,
-0.0074499357,
0.0019177889,
-0.0374248065,
-0.0175422486,
0.0430246703,
0.0008747593,
0.0004130678,
0.0012775421,
-0.0194268934,
0.0888359994,
0.0477947034,
0.0541648827,
-0.021945972,
-0.046467986,
-0.0183722842,
0.0301316287,
0.0357352272,
0.0051699267,
0.0366287306,
0.0204796214,
0.0048687267,
-0.0166743286,
0.0266709272,
0.0199057255,
0.0100433677,
0.0111311777,
0.0302209966,
0.0005060389,
0.0126463156,
0.0094511369,
0.0353495963,
-0.0123076979,
-0.0273878295,
0.0181063637,
-0.0166013669,
-0.0530684702,
-0.0000067831,
-0.0416997634,
0.023060685,
0.0196673945,
-0.0421499871,
-0.0264130123,
0.026891252,
-0.005055469,
0.0061513027,
0.0779756904,
0.0054348027,
-0.0114380103,
-0.0015191978,
-0.014762491,
-0.0461617485,
-0.0153414207,
-0.0554401278,
0.056756191,
-0.0190040804,
0.0272210408,
-0.0067074383,
-0.0863184556,
0.0135308839,
0.0225716159,
-0.0140571306,
0.0139508881,
0.0018457263,
0.0089524258,
0.0386239514,
-0.0469925366,
-0.0207571331,
-0.0587593801,
-0.0293406937,
-0.015785072,
-0.0167834628,
0.0213565845,
0.0363476649,
-0.0117495703,
0.0192691498,
0.0579115786,
-0.0063589625,
-0.0069205789,
-0.0090772053,
0.0129422331,
0.0330704711,
0.0003666365,
-0.0043941233,
-0.0402990505,
-0.0258714054,
-0.0406621546,
0.0340224057,
0.0033659635,
-0.0770702213,
0.0032406405,
-0.0401260704,
-0.0450013764,
-0.0181502067,
-0.052463375,
-0.0343517773,
0.02000097,
-0.0216213893,
0.048052635,
0.0368758477,
0.0403935499,
0.0530217774,
-0.001234396,
0.0025618677,
-0.0340357199,
-0.0251490474,
-0.0490801595,
0.0155614503,
-0.041620072,
-0.0334543996,
0.0018537322,
0.1082172915,
0.0112815704,
-0.0074352561,
-0.063223362,
0.0562098995,
-0.0599962287,
-0.0102835158,
0.0219106916,
-0.0016328472,
0.0067696827,
0.0063522514,
-0.0086068101,
-0.0031783187,
0.0251685828,
0.0131424116,
0.0482394993,
-0.0001429238,
-0.0462019853,
-0.0128168371,
0.0111074531,
0.00030175,
0.005302188,
0.0126372697,
-0.0045009847,
-0.0158076044,
-0.0265656225,
0.0460753851,
-0.0441967361,
0.0450523719,
-0.0186188072,
0.0413291976,
0.0157302972,
0.0106308162,
-0.0006189161,
-0.0799623951,
-0.0467280485,
-0.0095847277,
0.0535220578,
-0.0246837437,
0.0043051504,
0.0428388119,
0.012692715,
-0.0778614432,
-0.006481376,
0.0091221053,
0.0030966268,
0.0405905209,
0.0166664794,
-0.0319778286,
0.0381482728,
-0.0129511189,
-0.0144620854,
0.0564155281,
0.0158963278,
0.0343582481,
-0.0061588991,
-0.0757210553,
0.0081315245,
-0.0200832542,
-0.0076987152,
-0.0378387161,
0.0804727003,
-0.0111685703,
0.0236657094,
0.0776331127,
0.0538663603,
-0.0113746375,
-0.0153826093,
0.0169678517,
0.0105053866,
0.0084865913,
-0.0031073429,
-0.0947353691,
0.0088606905,
0.0118853198,
0.0129285539,
-0.0410134494,
-0.0614565499,
-0.0008470256,
-0.071639657,
-0.0275468044,
0.011605625,
0.0189559888,
-0.0355278067,
-0.0472450852,
0.0515558012,
0.0020739369,
-0.0521602295,
-0.0277601276,
0.0066365739,
0.0223587342,
0.0009128844,
-0.0769698396,
-0.0489117391,
0.0185668934,
-0.0162011627,
0.0382858589,
-0.0084034931,
0.048873309,
0.0172360744,
0.0088504627,
0.0716255978,
-0.0765776113,
-0.0248217955,
-0.0465431735,
0.0351804346,
-0.0297879092,
-0.0103013236,
-0.0043103285,
0.0338453837,
-0.0053091971,
-0.0065772478,
-0.0353267416,
0.0461128727,
-0.0059215096,
-0.0597452931,
-0.0031167537,
0.0600561984,
0.0458624177,
0.0449146293,
0.0414106622,
-0.0245878715,
0.0049304538,
-0.0606392622,
0.0278600194,
-0.0173272323,
-0.0665506423,
-0.0498713441,
0.0051346598,
-0.0051766019,
-0.0450981855,
-0.0585606657,
0.0217214096,
-0.0013271533,
-0.0229996592,
-0.0075494773,
0.0445420854,
-0.0284434743,
-0.0205664039,
0.0173135363,
-0.0473010205,
0.0453601852,
0.003643488,
-0.0400144868,
-0.0015903633,
0.0277408995,
-0.0451406054,
0.0192086063,
-0.08616741,
-0.0852854773,
0.0365494713,
-0.0166813936,
0.023126265,
-0.001432022,
-0.0568604805,
-0.0370515771,
-0.0176580921,
0.0669508576,
-0.0341218933,
-0.0040416266,
0.0369252115,
0.0546051897,
0.0371696763,
0.0495632216,
0.0101169171,
0.0064490251,
0.0212501399,
-0.0248452425,
-0.0908293352,
-0.0624707527,
-0.0147563154,
-0.0050072279,
0.0471664108,
0.0584608577,
-0.0793817937,
-0.0441254936,
-0.053410247,
-0.0486553982,
-0.0452001095,
0.000235606,
-0.0220470391,
0.0267192684,
0.0058980538,
-0.0714089945,
0.0361141041,
-0.0132785225,
0.0492194593,
-0.0524170883,
0.033436574,
-0.0287524723,
0.0190633517,
0.0188580342,
-0.0029078741,
0.0089429356,
0.0181936324,
-0.0283578075,
0.027874032,
-0.0051612412,
0.0259705558,
0.0119368555,
-0.0149044627,
0.0270690303,
-0.0197294839,
-0.0471236184,
-0.0681613684,
-0.0047462373,
0.0437816307,
-0.0074835187,
0.0088292994,
0.0557802133,
0.0222052205,
-0.0261774343,
-0.0276198089,
0.0399337076,
0.0078200893,
-0.0273380894,
0.01331353,
0.0231812447,
-0.0423278399,
0.0056447969,
0.0571635813,
-0.0504653193,
0.0169817228,
0.0616366826,
-0.0002852755,
-0.0152821466,
-0.0117123164,
-0.0097571695,
0.0220211633,
0.0020689163,
0.0134381093,
-0.0396535769,
-0.0459558554,
0.0685417876,
-0.0331791788,
0.0075206147,
0.0220975336,
-0.0187704973,
0.0716715828,
0.0127392802,
0.0588818602,
-0.0657297075,
0.015710799,
-0.0353805833,
-0.0427031852,
-0.0015707377,
-6.70995318e-33,
0.0004660148,
-0.0350155681,
-0.0229486059,
-0.008919118,
-0.0272269882,
-0.0099514583,
-0.0165592376,
0.0530525185,
-0.0241720676,
0.0222670659,
0.0153952846,
0.0476213731,
0.0169103127,
0.0299165174,
-0.0099733341,
-0.0198809952,
-0.011057076,
0.0074121808,
0.0154504534,
0.0306752454,
0.020852115,
0.0049053067,
0.0151776578,
-0.0846979171,
0.0444413349,
-0.0117997276,
0.0074296128,
0.0098944679,
0.0256947502,
-0.0054508336,
-0.0394869447,
0.0131775131,
0.0526118204,
-0.0162795726,
0.0190868489,
0.0796159878,
-0.0273846574,
-0.0268415734,
0.0210988577,
-0.0199817363,
0.0016754707,
-0.0270831697,
0.0358758569,
0.0022474697,
0.0051051276,
-0.0106269214,
0.0496907867,
0.0100817522,
0.0404085778,
-0.0333807357,
-0.0453197137,
0.0558565035,
-0.0339373425,
-0.0008062145,
-0.0144294146,
0.0185229685,
0.0632001609,
0.0888655931,
-0.046143312,
0.0229691789,
-0.0566240288,
0.011577555,
-0.0022567674,
-0.0388960354,
-0.0058584479,
0.0640913472,
-0.0346872285,
0.0383486226,
-0.0418727249,
0.0103828721,
0.0302168187,
-0.017289741,
0.057095632,
0.0613885559,
-0.0218594614,
-0.0496935882,
-0.0472468324,
-0.015218067,
0.0569905043,
-0.0189747289,
0.0405338518,
-0.0123313004,
-0.0132844392,
-0.0155721055,
-0.0163461473,
-0.0760186389,
-0.0295581911,
-0.011433119,
-0.0460682474,
-0.0030909488,
-0.0605517216,
0.0197654031,
0.0365879126,
-0.0341226384,
-0.0619517863,
0.0326099433,
-0.0211795103,
0.0203299597,
0.0021182352,
0.0584034771,
-0.0471872576,
-0.013055115,
-0.0169155262,
-0.0070429007,
0.0202635899,
-0.0397566967,
0.0165559892,
-0.0003902107,
-0.0816664025,
-0.02664987,
-0.0191655438,
-0.0022581227,
-0.0401136503,
0.01636458,
0.0541947596,
0.0598839223,
0.0161212087,
0.0302271899,
0.0448886342,
0.0061083422,
0.0210727155,
-0.0048203431,
-0.0701174587,
0.0024363142,
-0.0313827433,
-0.0448544435,
-0.0349500738,
0.027695898,
0.0040742252,
-0.0428884849,
-0.0172739774,
-0.0177385397,
2.519e-7,
0.0721696168,
0.076487489,
-0.0054062791,
0.022710206,
0.0022513091,
0.0093431445,
0.0533202402,
0.0003952988,
-0.0445797034,
-0.0675586313,
-0.0345575809,
0.0650793985,
0.0430326648,
0.0034747636,
-0.0457052514,
0.0194345396,
-0.0158827193,
0.0157414824,
-0.0288799293,
-0.0011906201,
0.0065234099,
0.0356189832,
0.0476498976,
0.0383703336,
-0.0246669576,
-0.0132808881,
0.0655877963,
-0.0393159762,
-0.0425194204,
0.0349632055,
0.0142570306,
-0.0793551207,
0.018803671,
0.0334888771,
0.024507232,
-0.0034181757,
0.0110205933,
0.0586227216,
0.0329653136,
-0.0139460415,
-0.01365087,
-0.0228959229,
0.0016068399,
-0.0403860584,
0.0737867132,
-0.0989233106,
-0.0308465976,
-0.0830567181,
-0.0265895575,
-0.0040894109,
0.0208170954,
0.0018693166,
-0.0418366231,
0.0339367203,
-0.0149967847,
0.0027451145,
-0.007627768,
-0.0748786628,
0.0214406289,
-0.0080811735,
-0.0525324456,
-0.0387657322,
0.0025472455,
-0.0166222434,
0.0568996109,
0.0165436734,
0.0204704218,
1.859235219e-34,
0.0372105129,
-0.0175963975,
-0.026381338,
-0.0098899668,
0.0524273217,
0.010168843,
-0.0495293438,
0.0184705947,
0.0093231257,
-0.0596558377,
0.0005026775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01065v1 | Evaluation Methodology for Large Language Models for Multilingual Document Question and Answer | 2024-02-01T23:46:05 | 2024-02-01T23:46:05 | Adar Kahana, Jaya Susan Mathew, Said Bleik, Jeremy Reynolds, Oren Elisha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), in this paper
we investigate the multilingual capability of these models. Our preliminary
results show that, translating the native language context, question and answer
into a high resource language produced the best results. | Evaluation Methodology for Large Language Models for Multilingual Document Question and Answer: With the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), in this paper
we investigate the multilingual capability of these models. Our preliminary
results show that, translating the native language context, question and answer
into a high resource language produced the best results. | [
0.0494856872,
0.0018480358,
-0.0039560432,
0.0650831386,
-0.0469229408,
0.0264483523,
0.0355421752,
0.0006605303,
-0.0010371732,
-0.0584950298,
-0.0591947995,
-0.0472965576,
-0.036297746,
-0.0113794822,
0.0147299636,
-0.0333666131,
0.0083473306,
-0.0606536902,
-0.0032178357,
-0.0225877445,
0.0258316807,
0.03209389,
0.0329475403,
0.0033410259,
0.0079012159,
-0.0278478451,
0.0244542845,
0.0062173628,
-0.0005837365,
-0.0364860222,
-0.009124266,
0.0277203284,
-0.0010860999,
0.0270338133,
0.0000015601,
-0.0511039421,
-0.0028231211,
0.0333289318,
-0.0090024658,
0.0039116116,
0.0330819152,
0.0062560551,
0.0164213646,
0.0271610729,
-0.0298468247,
0.0074626678,
0.0132905329,
0.0318339095,
0.074178271,
0.034981288,
-0.0100803943,
-0.0580908172,
0.031733945,
-0.0008045905,
0.0236653481,
-0.0595858619,
0.0010601203,
0.0752420053,
0.052015081,
0.0134829609,
0.0236725993,
0.0393037163,
0.034161862,
-0.0474514626,
-0.0391276106,
-0.0257349424,
-0.0083856741,
0.011076428,
0.0111858165,
0.0631533936,
0.0151157696,
0.0126429098,
-0.0396529175,
0.0231605992,
0.0100078862,
0.037054427,
-0.0656237453,
0.0070916424,
0.0009514563,
-0.0204198826,
0.0625097305,
0.0073117856,
0.0155376438,
0.0129267508,
-0.023873046,
0.0653088018,
0.0341565982,
-0.0112858629,
-0.0051772073,
0.0040808027,
0.0169154909,
-0.0529455952,
0.0154466508,
0.0602755472,
-0.035169486,
0.0191334356,
0.0013236782,
-0.0379370674,
0.0539806522,
-0.0920733362,
0.0046113324,
-0.0007240599,
-0.0070553771,
0.1008951515,
-0.0316121913,
0.0494941771,
-0.0398785435,
-0.0198302642,
-0.0779484585,
-0.0727017522,
-0.0345951281,
-0.0062350607,
-0.0200243518,
0.04175945,
-0.0477204993,
-0.0064152521,
-0.0148237711,
0.0391102582,
0.0440678,
0.0092539247,
0.0214682054,
-0.0344561636,
-0.0104405582,
-0.0458775312,
-0.0244609602,
0.0547828414,
-0.0382233709,
-0.0067273453,
-0.0151648447,
-0.068830803,
0.0626200289,
0.0354365595,
-0.0038615679,
-0.045048479,
-0.0016171689,
0.0742903501,
0.0104155922,
0.0225934759,
-0.0195156913,
-0.0069633848,
0.0238602385,
-0.0404703878,
-0.0224440601,
-0.1027986929,
0.0213201884,
0.0230650436,
0.018144438,
0.0251721889,
0.0235763006,
0.0213140845,
-0.0140006458,
0.0125481188,
0.012243838,
0.0252602808,
0.0851860866,
-0.0114398161,
0.0356518403,
0.0819812045,
-0.014528444,
-0.011447873,
0.0640168265,
-0.0003911296,
-0.0054121139,
0.0576936603,
-0.0202947203,
0.0283308625,
-0.0007846353,
0.0943551287,
0.0167752691,
0.0011842033,
-0.0271469336,
0.0567560345,
-0.0104135973,
0.0032728345,
0.0243380442,
0.046363432,
0.0115067773,
0.0099051995,
0.0394019708,
-0.0125074591,
0.0092848549,
-0.0103928121,
0.0164146982,
0.0334295332,
-0.0204050727,
-0.0188354868,
0.0245512296,
0.0401382111,
-0.0493644364,
-0.0160084181,
-0.0308300313,
-0.0182182137,
-0.0234826859,
0.013534273,
0.0352908894,
-0.00517412,
0.010583546,
0.0427770838,
-0.0104407966,
-0.0127501478,
0.0213855952,
-0.0434162356,
0.0186444856,
0.0231670346,
0.0369985625,
-0.0248511862,
-0.0326992869,
-0.0198954288,
0.0054737632,
0.0311482437,
0.0706562325,
-0.0204955116,
-0.0148283383,
-0.0239085648,
-0.0024562853,
-0.0110905068,
-0.0218976289,
0.0271125473,
-0.0070102843,
0.038506873,
0.0089105517,
-0.0571637452,
-0.049527064,
-0.0074764267,
-0.0308221541,
-0.0115663083,
0.0120717073,
0.0040599117,
0.0002800641,
0.0491923057,
-0.0020501281,
0.023489926,
0.0144061567,
-0.0629132614,
-0.01072287,
-0.0007566179,
-0.0427021161,
-0.0289664306,
0.0421093702,
-0.0340981856,
-0.0101358118,
-0.0000099056,
-0.0035547686,
-0.0577021949,
-0.0418881476,
-0.0308202878,
0.0125438133,
-0.0539226122,
-0.0066160052,
-0.0089942096,
-0.00805429,
-0.0644963309,
0.0390575156,
0.0017121015,
0.0624554195,
0.027202975,
-0.0002793314,
0.0532943755,
-0.0306352358,
-0.0415540785,
0.0804129019,
-0.0013014784,
0.0084386021,
0.0318132304,
0.0335216485,
-0.0378110223,
-0.0411067605,
-0.0696685761,
-0.0167239755,
-0.0295339637,
0.0375956148,
0.0355521329,
0.0211564861,
0.0138961282,
-0.023520289,
-0.1019836441,
-0.0264206827,
0.0602261908,
0.0362122282,
0.0151278693,
0.0197677687,
0.0397869647,
-0.0271739494,
-0.0185260903,
0.0419589877,
0.0587485023,
0.0199296623,
-0.0035607796,
-0.0488346964,
0.0049661873,
-0.0469430014,
-0.0242955796,
0.0267811846,
-0.0356588811,
-0.0245980639,
-0.0395513289,
0.042669557,
0.0222682208,
-0.0188254565,
-0.0089455377,
0.010618262,
0.0104466174,
-0.0317299552,
-0.005570373,
0.0187555142,
-0.0437742472,
-0.050268773,
-0.0402130075,
0.012290623,
0.0231747869,
-0.0107084597,
-0.0081271436,
-0.0209004041,
-0.0029292512,
-0.0638107508,
-0.0121778361,
-0.076875031,
-0.0010662128,
0.0063023693,
0.053864304,
0.005938556,
0.0007852613,
0.0554267541,
-0.0334762894,
-0.0109633701,
-0.0764783993,
-0.01655728,
-0.0670158267,
0.045330286,
-0.035003446,
0.05081762,
-0.0790700018,
-0.0257568154,
-0.0238482151,
-0.0044257799,
0.0231976546,
-0.0307884961,
0.0262389388,
-0.0213709213,
-0.0016238493,
-0.0365587808,
-0.0240992084,
-0.0136723137,
-0.0268393625,
-0.0122900922,
0.0194770545,
-0.0051167882,
0.0047077471,
-0.0124560082,
0.0378985144,
0.0557849891,
0.0017401669,
-0.0378717817,
0.0006640599,
0.0202315375,
0.1174942777,
0.043761272,
0.0340063535,
0.0084988475,
-0.0246558413,
0.0614192858,
0.033275824,
0.0262614209,
-0.0133819189,
0.018346902,
-0.0260022171,
0.0484388359,
-0.0224053748,
-0.0480886437,
-0.0221108682,
0.0490233526,
-0.0588466488,
-0.0034194703,
0.0984610245,
0.0560915247,
-0.0545073859,
-0.0439211987,
-0.1025487036,
-0.0147450529,
0.0301985666,
0.0738477856,
-0.0673378855,
0.0164233353,
-0.0299558565,
-0.0303075947,
0.0253661983,
0.0123841567,
0.0237749331,
-0.0971463621,
0.0114968875,
-0.0299035776,
-0.0635950789,
-0.0138892783,
-0.0293074977,
-0.0286938921,
0.0192473847,
0.0046527563,
0.0151470304,
0.0074681812,
-0.0095728124,
0.0008165611,
-0.0134570114,
-0.0142663354,
0.0306061581,
-0.023490876,
-0.0028331184,
0.0759056956,
0.043831028,
-0.0352269076,
-0.0138146691,
0.028299205,
-0.0525729023,
0.0036771495,
0.0038084884,
-0.0195270963,
0.0205699746,
-0.0043709856,
-0.0183827523,
-0.008509594,
-0.0241832994,
0.0366002582,
0.0512802862,
0.0896545053,
-0.0198808312,
0.0205624942,
-0.0150639853,
-0.0187646169,
0.0077414485,
0.0611867346,
0.0072224466,
-0.0405634269,
-0.0199697465,
-0.0327834189,
-0.0438843779,
-0.0251258332,
0.0016336197,
0.0252817236,
0.0021051208,
0.0206082091,
-0.0817748755,
-0.0498199686,
0.0060064611,
0.0065705138,
0.0023920676,
0.033557307,
-0.0264104344,
-0.0148476986,
0.0332361497,
-0.0072486373,
-0.0377219394,
0.0479432195,
-0.0675467104,
0.0178140104,
0.0753269717,
-0.0081963567,
-0.0046345033,
-0.0193425808,
-0.0302040298,
-0.04313761,
-0.0453329273,
0.0274590421,
0.0174817406,
-0.0149496272,
-0.0581465662,
-0.056037508,
0.016972499,
-0.0342528224,
-0.0368623957,
-0.0067754872,
0.0099636428,
0.045049198,
-0.0194711685,
0.0527357087,
-0.0685640424,
0.0187791437,
-0.0003776865,
0.0397118591,
-0.0154524185,
-0.0697840303,
0.0033312219,
0.0715378895,
-0.0564680472,
0.0215123575,
-0.0021116792,
-0.0116302082,
0.0424088649,
-0.0544853099,
-0.0248073526,
-0.0248919018,
0.0300448369,
0.0495378114,
-0.0385024138,
0.0144780232,
0.0230525956,
0.0067303344,
0.0017238752,
-0.0154669257,
0.0473792329,
0.0449228249,
0.0017824991,
0.0008318709,
0.031445682,
-0.0472647436,
-0.018063046,
-0.0104306843,
0.0196906626,
-0.0166596361,
0.0809754953,
-0.0161518063,
-0.0354852639,
0.0253448058,
0.0176809877,
-0.0391208604,
-0.074571304,
0.0008571524,
0.0100616338,
0.067557916,
0.0169982314,
0.0465878509,
0.0061044595,
-0.0307206642,
-0.0255151279,
0.0295038819,
0.0527080223,
-0.0460337587,
0.0723536685,
0.0180300847,
-0.0077794977,
0.0085309753,
0.0667664707,
-0.0106091266,
-0.026150357,
0.0164653212,
-0.0017343266,
-0.0434987731,
0.0025981176,
0.0045280191,
-0.0014266617,
-0.0278088339,
0.0295009967,
-0.0269095134,
-0.0535454415,
-0.0088608228,
0.0200785901,
-0.0156162195,
0.0050408235,
0.0214133803,
0.0925712585,
0.0406935737,
0.0158577226,
-0.0829313025,
0.0393137187,
-0.0565444082,
-0.0055781151,
0.0091037052,
-5.567314631e-33,
-0.01558246,
-0.0193026178,
0.0232903846,
-0.0310564507,
0.0101910206,
0.0003750185,
-0.0190184917,
-0.0018027043,
-0.0364273041,
0.0044871978,
-0.0328695141,
-0.0046933857,
0.0082583549,
0.0229768567,
-0.010708754,
-0.0207972564,
0.0012454418,
-0.0009079247,
0.0084969858,
0.0356020667,
0.013854051,
0.0091650141,
0.0625665411,
-0.0458116792,
0.0554876477,
-0.0502688363,
0.0096088247,
0.0325725861,
0.004388981,
0.0863468125,
-0.0208263621,
0.0182294454,
0.0527365208,
-0.0579808243,
-0.0051799389,
0.0032368968,
-0.0312398151,
-0.0217502303,
0.0427370481,
0.0106818229,
-0.0412642285,
-0.0336383954,
-0.0094236862,
-0.0082138143,
0.0338450968,
0.0119522819,
0.0327501521,
-0.0383755341,
-0.0093115028,
-0.0116398595,
-0.0587606244,
0.0286007896,
0.0238879845,
0.0432349183,
-0.0101813963,
0.0671883076,
-0.0399441905,
0.0069295382,
-0.0237273034,
0.0010287329,
0.0067661526,
0.0298807342,
0.0494156145,
-0.0035065329,
-0.0153806666,
0.0034987261,
-0.031969402,
0.0179937948,
0.0260945503,
0.0059357681,
-0.0284265485,
0.0209698156,
0.07547196,
0.0807021037,
-0.0345546305,
0.0278134886,
-0.0745968074,
0.0619733296,
0.0112764416,
0.0381799899,
0.0190789346,
-0.0057169218,
0.0184385162,
0.00786791,
-0.060761556,
0.030455729,
-0.0528899804,
-0.0376786068,
0.0239240993,
-0.0406093784,
-0.0013753744,
0.0034395743,
0.0822196007,
-0.0304029062,
-0.0311911907,
0.0496384054,
0.0068153357,
0.0246082079,
0.0055208635,
0.0727562308,
-0.0369120352,
0.0141668217,
-0.0377356485,
-0.0298437923,
-0.0224843808,
0.0014804286,
0.0050483793,
-0.0224219896,
-0.0635079816,
0.0025012426,
-0.023595741,
-0.0080662919,
-0.0249841865,
0.0417886525,
-0.0122142425,
-0.0338894315,
0.0003013999,
0.0828406364,
0.0018791953,
-0.0228448622,
-0.0374138728,
-0.0451556183,
0.0195114464,
0.0104501154,
-0.0513494611,
0.0319300368,
-0.0356210433,
0.0329268239,
0.015383373,
-0.0162035208,
-0.0049498258,
0.0063374783,
2.247e-7,
0.0644853041,
0.0067247711,
-0.0222029909,
0.0187002905,
0.0422208942,
-0.0021719404,
-0.0157620758,
0.0235774964,
0.0388109088,
0.0319512524,
-0.0200298075,
0.0052408483,
0.0532683432,
0.050765492,
-0.0874197856,
-0.0154802427,
-0.0636145547,
-0.0001484814,
-0.0336719714,
0.0059807212,
0.0216545686,
0.0794349238,
-0.0401790552,
0.0067928773,
-0.0605657175,
-0.0665814653,
0.0503026098,
-0.0291416086,
-0.0493675917,
0.0327462405,
0.0379451178,
0.0214336999,
0.0245016906,
-0.0090974253,
-0.007303806,
-0.0003496837,
0.0622897707,
0.0539360158,
0.0035612669,
-0.0227716099,
0.020259833,
-0.0339177139,
0.0036232383,
-0.0858131945,
0.0715584084,
0.0042894916,
-0.032201048,
-0.0159946233,
-0.0046873223,
-0.0329791456,
0.0421087444,
-0.0584904328,
-0.0263937134,
0.0248045344,
0.021135943,
-0.0259826928,
0.0020664968,
-0.0154095516,
-0.0278189145,
0.0133543322,
-0.0137910787,
-0.0620967969,
-0.0175297093,
-0.0209052414,
-0.0275844149,
-0.0201132596,
0.0231815819,
1.456514642e-34,
0.0359169133,
-0.004095064,
0.018059833,
0.0400874354,
0.0238388125,
-0.0181362797,
-0.0173402354,
0.0098463334,
-0.0008890409,
-0.1134813428,
0.0016725146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01053v1 | Plan-Grounded Large Language Models for Dual Goal Conversational Settings | 2024-02-01T22:56:39 | 2024-02-01T22:56:39 | Diogo Glória-Silva, Rafael Ferreira, Diogo Tavares, David Semedo, João Magalhães | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training Large Language Models (LLMs) to follow user instructions has been
shown to supply the LLM with ample capacity to converse fluently while being
aligned with humans. Yet, it is not completely clear how an LLM can lead a
plan-grounded conversation in mixed-initiative settings where instructions flow
in both directions of the conversation, i.e. both the LLM and the user provide
instructions to one another. In this paper, we tackle a dual goal
mixed-initiative conversational setting where the LLM not only grounds the
conversation on an arbitrary plan but also seeks to satisfy both a procedural
plan and user instructions. The LLM is then responsible for guiding the user
through the plan and, at the same time, adapting to new circumstances,
answering questions, and activating safety guardrails when needed. We propose a
novel LLM that grounds the dialogue on a procedural plan, can take the dialogue
initiative, and enforces guardrails on the system's behavior, while also
improving the LLM's responses to unexpected user behavior. Experiments in
controlled settings and with real users show that the best-performing model,
which we call PlanLLM, achieves a 2.1x improvement over a strong baseline.
Moreover, experiments also show good generalization to unseen domains. | Plan-Grounded Large Language Models for Dual Goal Conversational Settings: Training Large Language Models (LLMs) to follow user instructions has been
shown to supply the LLM with ample capacity to converse fluently while being
aligned with humans. Yet, it is not completely clear how an LLM can lead a
plan-grounded conversation in mixed-initiative settings where instructions flow
in both directions of the conversation, i.e. both the LLM and the user provide
instructions to one another. In this paper, we tackle a dual goal
mixed-initiative conversational setting where the LLM not only grounds the
conversation on an arbitrary plan but also seeks to satisfy both a procedural
plan and user instructions. The LLM is then responsible for guiding the user
through the plan and, at the same time, adapting to new circumstances,
answering questions, and activating safety guardrails when needed. We propose a
novel LLM that grounds the dialogue on a procedural plan, can take the dialogue
initiative, and enforces guardrails on the system's behavior, while also
improving the LLM's responses to unexpected user behavior. Experiments in
controlled settings and with real users show that the best-performing model,
which we call PlanLLM, achieves a 2.1x improvement over a strong baseline.
Moreover, experiments also show good generalization to unseen domains. | [
0.0551729277,
0.0331221335,
-0.0187420007,
0.03303032,
-0.0080799768,
0.0084108096,
-0.0080046561,
-0.0310915206,
0.0047994773,
-0.0316726379,
-0.0212705787,
-0.038583152,
-0.0426787101,
0.0483023189,
0.0161951762,
-0.0422321968,
0.0363180339,
-0.0708286911,
0.0167211797,
-0.0067276028,
0.0090832245,
0.0057392474,
-0.0117546981,
0.0612849928,
0.0025889988,
-0.0014159955,
-0.0418826193,
0.0156809408,
0.0001041998,
-0.0417773686,
0.0250517279,
0.0206775591,
0.066408515,
0.0243226755,
0.0000020467,
-0.05930309,
0.014049843,
-0.0439293422,
-0.0170361046,
-0.0440025814,
-0.0378769189,
-0.0186366905,
-0.0132486215,
0.0291854609,
-0.0514228046,
0.0188937653,
0.0089842752,
0.1022804379,
0.0649916977,
0.0791352168,
-0.0009001665,
-0.0535914339,
0.0079900855,
-0.0191127099,
-0.0259294771,
-0.0800786242,
0.0057494631,
0.030188933,
-0.0070327944,
0.0284503829,
0.0132366521,
0.0018494128,
0.0144671844,
-0.0464793108,
-0.0244529881,
0.0367242321,
-0.0402626805,
-0.0340248756,
-0.0229464862,
0.1068523377,
-0.0046498962,
0.0045094187,
0.0354841612,
-0.0040600919,
-0.0054917941,
-0.020902684,
-0.0469951294,
0.0124668041,
0.0078692017,
0.0075828824,
-0.0094293971,
0.01305677,
0.0235737916,
0.0163960308,
-0.0487227291,
0.0769015029,
-0.0226907227,
-0.0379946008,
0.0201485027,
0.0034206768,
0.0078812903,
-0.0686776266,
0.0105118118,
0.0649306551,
-0.0946189091,
0.0438474566,
-0.0205994491,
0.0138801355,
0.0048346464,
-0.0282741357,
0.0207006261,
0.0393129699,
0.0130898068,
0.0535706505,
0.0127912862,
0.0494123325,
-0.0048311292,
0.0163968317,
-0.0083175162,
0.0192507058,
-0.0369088314,
0.0084902691,
-0.055380106,
0.0270512886,
-0.0579111278,
-0.0340538882,
-0.0018580466,
0.075641036,
-0.0174377635,
0.0525726601,
0.014584003,
-0.0130984755,
-0.0427491926,
-0.047776401,
-0.0498771071,
0.0140637252,
-0.0385752954,
0.0407207012,
0.0210308935,
-0.0307986978,
-0.0028925864,
0.017644383,
0.0000052504,
0.0062696356,
-0.0294412132,
0.0705935955,
-0.0063729966,
-0.0064413468,
-0.0345991664,
-0.0404907502,
-0.0142165152,
-0.0729085431,
-0.0053377473,
-0.0206913892,
0.0290480573,
0.0010303066,
-0.0090854345,
-0.0092532067,
0.0295069888,
0.0163543336,
-0.0090444768,
0.0428150557,
0.0185445752,
0.0213866103,
0.0106280129,
0.0225957185,
-0.0289381538,
0.0922281891,
0.0310424231,
0.0129439887,
-0.0026315469,
-0.0041718511,
0.0091059366,
0.0399106555,
0.0025103968,
0.0156983491,
0.0197946448,
0.0303455181,
0.0386642851,
0.0377302915,
0.0220526066,
0.0616915077,
-0.0215451494,
0.0261711571,
0.0706641451,
0.0630270541,
-0.0352555588,
0.0133664105,
0.0427861027,
0.0218348335,
-0.0273001958,
0.0190083534,
-0.0693433881,
0.0121312095,
-0.0232364889,
0.0015453576,
0.0022752839,
-0.0006643543,
-0.0429002829,
-0.0247865207,
0.0266071856,
-0.0132053476,
0.0251127724,
-0.0005784868,
0.0273375586,
0.0078759445,
-0.0889544785,
-0.0052027819,
-0.0038119368,
-0.007979176,
-0.0114184236,
-0.0162354615,
0.0231769513,
0.0922539234,
0.0228500552,
-0.0195371062,
-0.0342938937,
-0.0371006839,
0.0439715423,
0.0421120226,
0.0245836023,
-0.0232814997,
0.009678727,
-0.0609674603,
-0.0185210798,
-0.0194939543,
-0.0208356176,
0.0085983807,
0.0107014989,
-0.0051658577,
-0.0111655118,
0.0248493869,
-0.0205617975,
0.0089758504,
-0.0364887007,
0.006571841,
-0.006058157,
-0.0059893434,
0.0404915474,
0.0063236919,
0.009546143,
-0.0107285855,
0.0427063406,
-0.0240566246,
-0.0237050112,
0.0123862503,
-0.0815720335,
-0.020514762,
0.0251484234,
0.0080210567,
-0.0327861793,
-0.0186704695,
-0.0258154254,
-0.0500477739,
-0.0151138557,
-0.0099989688,
0.0333062783,
-0.0358993933,
0.0349757075,
0.0404431894,
-0.0355015546,
-0.0467079543,
0.0322803482,
0.0069501745,
-0.0243726783,
0.0383032858,
-0.0239787623,
-0.0186960381,
-0.0684563965,
0.004570296,
0.03748421,
-0.007421697,
-0.0019468617,
0.0206565354,
0.0322495885,
-0.0529678278,
-0.057351239,
-0.1148410216,
-0.0135874832,
-0.0424668901,
-0.0120026805,
-0.0012022493,
0.018888792,
-0.0016021858,
-0.0296082143,
-0.0354409032,
0.0216223989,
0.040458288,
-0.0181213971,
0.0284415949,
0.0456848815,
-0.0303857513,
-0.0402051136,
0.0497665145,
-0.0067452518,
-0.0113644013,
0.0044976836,
-0.031942267,
-0.0737754256,
0.0723096877,
-0.0030132981,
0.0496305078,
-0.0300985519,
-0.0202047043,
0.0041460162,
0.0032766149,
0.0568200648,
0.0696755871,
0.0065519246,
0.0309219547,
0.0268084761,
-0.0252862182,
-0.0831124187,
0.0524539351,
-0.0102889966,
-0.021966828,
-0.0747512579,
0.0179576837,
0.0300920885,
0.0492992066,
-0.007868357,
0.0468701683,
-0.055208873,
0.0127683301,
0.0120110502,
-0.0559915826,
-0.0156707,
-0.0229934286,
-0.0414206386,
0.0429940782,
-0.0092404438,
-0.0206533186,
0.0601500235,
-0.009363235,
-0.0271787159,
-0.0131537551,
-0.0221813861,
-0.0216570627,
0.0266580489,
-0.0138280522,
0.0206670053,
0.0126787527,
-0.031751927,
-0.0287921205,
-0.0113702193,
-0.0167096257,
-0.0236740038,
0.0743637457,
-0.0862979591,
0.0201265067,
0.0082411859,
-0.065327473,
-0.0683245957,
-0.0370185412,
-0.0539826639,
-0.001150573,
-0.0024278655,
-0.0161993913,
-0.0266669895,
-0.0017604308,
0.026500158,
0.0456190743,
0.0031442095,
-0.0053759795,
-0.0315997042,
-0.0393262058,
0.0639024004,
0.0427602455,
-0.0250061881,
-0.0200723168,
0.0863449872,
0.0139111653,
0.0368203633,
-0.0119932573,
-0.0242157318,
-0.0215906054,
0.0277805459,
0.0198475253,
-0.02116118,
0.0456917435,
0.0892196372,
-0.015224155,
-0.0268974807,
0.1251456887,
0.0079182545,
-0.0297481287,
-0.0015840735,
-0.0519914851,
0.0476551652,
0.0120764682,
0.0355180055,
-0.0488275178,
-0.0278829094,
0.005879736,
-0.0129729658,
0.0022858048,
-0.0279828683,
-0.0140324375,
-0.1123363525,
0.0110912239,
0.0056842137,
-0.0285204016,
0.0116665419,
-0.0026831685,
0.0095362617,
0.0189443007,
0.0587539636,
-0.0189541634,
-0.0012879239,
-0.0254805237,
0.0031909137,
-0.0162381213,
-0.035082072,
0.0098743066,
-0.0267077852,
0.0818547159,
0.101012744,
0.0364822857,
0.0175492521,
0.0118464744,
0.0570313819,
0.0394989476,
0.0200258307,
-0.0066899383,
-0.0136391874,
-0.0293448344,
0.0007383028,
-0.0031735974,
0.0637629256,
-0.0352204815,
-0.0192144271,
0.0526561812,
0.0604050457,
-0.0566566847,
0.0089602545,
0.0057698051,
0.0363751277,
0.0459399112,
0.059568651,
0.015689401,
-0.0624346286,
-0.0185819604,
-0.0227214526,
-0.0176204182,
-0.0616346225,
-0.0320648216,
-0.011751798,
-0.0073783649,
0.0534359217,
-0.0487452298,
-0.0601529814,
0.0453347303,
0.0413031243,
0.0363164395,
-0.0207653698,
0.0408588722,
0.0028430836,
0.0456814878,
-0.0006726364,
-0.0408983678,
0.042053096,
-0.089358218,
0.0005282565,
0.0225291867,
-0.0174217429,
0.006994301,
0.0370071381,
-0.0326887853,
-0.0655081272,
-0.0282693189,
0.0635837317,
0.0183185115,
0.0507497974,
-0.0037824006,
-0.0627744123,
-0.002813508,
-0.0222614594,
-0.0352800488,
0.0127213737,
0.0237811953,
0.0698554367,
-0.0122142471,
0.0554369986,
-0.0514178649,
-0.0079090009,
0.0011488312,
0.0517887548,
-0.0715041012,
-0.0628717989,
0.0176738705,
-0.0055947108,
0.0316930301,
0.0016940241,
-0.0038359526,
0.0023860598,
0.0378888585,
-0.0211379901,
-0.0258229729,
-0.0587514378,
0.0223606452,
0.0105414465,
-0.0325048827,
0.0353221521,
-0.0253140666,
-0.020564286,
0.0183295161,
0.0009059355,
-0.0291626174,
-0.0082447864,
0.0063102986,
0.0295731518,
0.0208096113,
-0.0184081439,
0.0476139039,
0.0511175767,
0.0354709588,
0.0287926849,
0.1027894765,
0.0306414664,
-0.0110301366,
-0.0105916457,
0.0088830711,
-0.0440129526,
-0.0704030693,
0.0408120491,
0.0357723236,
0.0416778028,
0.0301278792,
0.042320963,
-0.0382759534,
0.0256228559,
-0.0391789526,
0.0253999773,
0.0165193491,
-0.0457576439,
0.0580724478,
0.0155903371,
-0.0268530976,
0.0110853966,
0.0653088242,
0.0055817999,
0.0340940878,
-0.0302922688,
0.0410946459,
-0.0520001166,
-0.0257086977,
0.0050019133,
0.0482472293,
-0.0139820594,
0.0061195549,
-0.0426819958,
-0.0209333934,
-0.0323785096,
0.0062847165,
-0.0336816944,
-0.0461234674,
0.0333985835,
0.0305933934,
-0.0184191093,
-0.0349631198,
-0.0173667371,
-0.0254452508,
0.0043684081,
-0.0243328568,
-0.0744669065,
-5.767508298e-33,
-0.0452075228,
-0.0309452135,
0.0506397188,
-0.0032740894,
-0.0286837034,
-0.0220926851,
-0.0316981003,
0.0122901089,
-0.0220385138,
0.0161877219,
-0.0275311787,
0.0215872638,
0.0169581659,
0.0110053224,
-0.0106542017,
-0.0202024169,
0.0479212739,
0.0040486264,
-0.0247304346,
0.0384581685,
0.0389078334,
0.0163575001,
-0.0161765106,
-0.0940018073,
0.0137041416,
-0.0012665055,
-0.0171821713,
0.0581494868,
-0.001073637,
0.0452605747,
-0.016769534,
0.0055363006,
0.0075224251,
-0.021937862,
-0.0333556309,
0.07244201,
-0.0191081483,
-0.0144929253,
0.0587304458,
0.0000106936,
-0.0290280748,
-0.0548497476,
0.0083669024,
-0.0311608128,
-0.0196003653,
0.0083782449,
0.0138988933,
0.0042909542,
-0.0183492713,
0.0184241012,
-0.0721944645,
-0.0079615088,
-0.0228048488,
-0.0503312871,
-0.0073306523,
0.0258260611,
0.0032556891,
-0.0299374964,
0.0012966504,
0.0423528627,
-0.0484127216,
-0.0159877669,
0.0530441999,
0.0186189208,
-0.0033735689,
0.0710584745,
-0.0004806566,
0.0343034305,
-0.0263095871,
-0.0619987734,
-0.0173237678,
0.0423586927,
-0.0255023539,
0.0094393538,
-0.061066851,
0.0247082971,
-0.0493763871,
0.0151780583,
0.0180520918,
0.0516148396,
0.0214625653,
0.0338402838,
-0.0301135648,
-0.0168638714,
-0.0327376015,
0.0268691648,
-0.004626893,
-0.026000157,
0.051368136,
0.0326028205,
0.0299579296,
-0.0154597647,
0.0498686358,
-0.0409487523,
-0.0204595849,
0.0347065255,
-0.009474867,
-0.0011666499,
-0.0118610375,
0.0348116048,
-0.070938319,
-0.0361584648,
0.0362313986,
0.0054212529,
0.0154426061,
0.0267034303,
0.0057923854,
0.0109490957,
-0.0469429456,
-0.0072288634,
-0.0411524028,
0.0207449012,
-0.0245288312,
0.003799537,
0.0311683472,
-0.0074221813,
-0.022820456,
0.079580307,
0.0001659442,
-0.0758721381,
-0.0282181278,
-0.0713964179,
-0.0016418598,
0.0232988354,
-0.0401835591,
-0.0003673124,
-0.0052505927,
-0.0072877011,
0.0183097851,
-0.02916901,
-0.0111385062,
0.0073991185,
2.733e-7,
-0.0235927384,
0.0442312174,
0.0065827444,
0.0254180431,
0.0074565439,
0.0492286868,
-0.0316866525,
0.0396540761,
0.0067954464,
-0.019005321,
0.0153777059,
0.0392296426,
0.015841702,
-0.008885745,
-0.0940041468,
-0.0118857315,
-0.0456506722,
-0.022324698,
-0.0638975799,
-0.0172172599,
0.0605208464,
0.0511274524,
-0.0233685542,
0.0164144095,
0.0185220689,
-0.0391403325,
0.0646115467,
-0.0463986509,
-0.0285052415,
0.0100370971,
-0.0057477229,
0.0057164724,
-0.0093479594,
0.0177489575,
0.0051324163,
0.0459172055,
-0.0275439005,
0.1089503095,
-0.0044396976,
-0.0073112315,
-0.0048277313,
-0.0164603833,
0.0020770268,
-0.0293066278,
0.0350678042,
-0.0657558069,
-0.0208053105,
0.025982393,
0.0242350828,
-0.0501638576,
-0.0292283688,
-0.0037044222,
-0.013528889,
0.0059521878,
0.0245427135,
0.0046265656,
0.0063305502,
-0.0700745359,
0.0360101387,
-0.0011761172,
-0.0401859656,
-0.0615291558,
-0.0285744071,
0.0319790393,
-0.000556372,
-0.0363152809,
0.0071265195,
2.360508599e-34,
0.0122991642,
-0.0019290806,
0.0174755845,
0.0402912721,
0.0378131494,
0.0057243891,
-0.0040534185,
0.0270323921,
0.05816596,
-0.0925803557,
-0.0069885845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01051v1 | Generation, Distillation and Evaluation of Motivational Interviewing-Style Reflections with a Foundational Language Model | 2024-02-01T22:54:31 | 2024-02-01T22:54:31 | Andrew Brown, Jiading Zhu, Mohamed Abdelwahab, Alec Dong, Cindy Wang, Jonathan Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Foundational Language Models are capable of performing many tasks at a
high level but are difficult to deploy in many applications because of their
size and proprietary ownership. Many will be motivated to distill specific
capabilities of foundational models into smaller models that can be owned and
controlled. In the development of a therapeutic chatbot, we wish to distill a
capability known as reflective listening, in which a therapist produces
reflections of client speech. These reflections either restate what a client
has said, or connect what was said to a relevant observation, idea or guess
that encourages and guides the client to continue contemplation. In this paper,
we present a method for distilling the generation of reflections from a
Foundational Language Model (GPT-4) into smaller models. We first show that
GPT-4, using zero-shot prompting, can generate reflections at near 100% success
rate, superior to all previous methods. Using reflections generated by GPT-4,
we fine-tune different sizes of the GPT-2 family. The GPT-2-small model
achieves 83% success on a hold-out test set and the GPT-2 XL achieves 90%
success. We also show that GPT-4 can help in the labor-intensive task of
evaluating the quality of the distilled models, using it as a zero-shot
classifier. Using triple-human review as a guide, the classifier achieves a
Cohen-Kappa of 0.66, a substantial inter-rater reliability figure. | Generation, Distillation and Evaluation of Motivational Interviewing-Style Reflections with a Foundational Language Model: Large Foundational Language Models are capable of performing many tasks at a
high level but are difficult to deploy in many applications because of their
size and proprietary ownership. Many will be motivated to distill specific
capabilities of foundational models into smaller models that can be owned and
controlled. In the development of a therapeutic chatbot, we wish to distill a
capability known as reflective listening, in which a therapist produces
reflections of client speech. These reflections either restate what a client
has said, or connect what was said to a relevant observation, idea or guess
that encourages and guides the client to continue contemplation. In this paper,
we present a method for distilling the generation of reflections from a
Foundational Language Model (GPT-4) into smaller models. We first show that
GPT-4, using zero-shot prompting, can generate reflections at near 100% success
rate, superior to all previous methods. Using reflections generated by GPT-4,
we fine-tune different sizes of the GPT-2 family. The GPT-2-small model
achieves 83% success on a hold-out test set and the GPT-2 XL achieves 90%
success. We also show that GPT-4 can help in the labor-intensive task of
evaluating the quality of the distilled models, using it as a zero-shot
classifier. Using triple-human review as a guide, the classifier achieves a
Cohen-Kappa of 0.66, a substantial inter-rater reliability figure. | [
0.1002195403,
0.0361246727,
-0.0246075206,
-0.0298449509,
-0.0641693622,
-0.0107831964,
0.0187935084,
-0.0140017141,
-0.0109659052,
-0.0314320102,
-0.0210455041,
-0.0077205966,
0.0055990019,
0.0550892875,
-0.0303534996,
-0.0927999467,
0.0250275824,
0.0002273524,
0.0375214033,
-0.0014039262,
0.0180841479,
0.0303182993,
-0.0352297351,
0.0815206617,
0.0042824517,
-0.0243585091,
-0.0183532313,
0.0141836097,
-0.0153904976,
-0.0537321903,
-0.0283457711,
0.0469370671,
0.0073857512,
0.0025770681,
0.0000024265,
-0.0039021857,
0.0036148969,
-0.0051033329,
0.0027398868,
-0.0622045286,
0.0982244536,
-0.0098082507,
-0.0224230029,
0.0258833971,
-0.0224066246,
-0.0005346396,
0.013238485,
0.0544789359,
0.0914622843,
0.0524855517,
-0.0087573249,
0.0141378781,
-0.0149368672,
0.0176746361,
0.010238559,
0.0050095352,
-0.0283689555,
0.0222742204,
0.0392152034,
0.0250653569,
-0.0243144035,
0.0015386323,
0.0064785993,
-0.0035553207,
0.0100670103,
0.0342065506,
-0.0311849955,
-0.0549697839,
-0.0337328948,
0.0549738482,
0.0624974854,
0.0012277145,
-0.0110507142,
0.0037671279,
0.0408162586,
-0.0334497616,
-0.0349853151,
0.0112942904,
0.0121750394,
0.010712347,
-0.0224943012,
0.0150196701,
-0.0323681831,
-0.0200349893,
0.0550211295,
-0.017658079,
0.0054118014,
-0.0122139752,
0.0159248505,
0.0158858057,
0.0503848456,
-0.0669168681,
-0.0278426781,
0.0378237516,
-0.0417140834,
0.0158391781,
-0.044679869,
0.004739766,
-0.0048935995,
0.0291916821,
0.034480691,
0.0433765426,
-0.0403002501,
-0.0082381703,
0.0086984253,
0.0309035573,
0.0591974482,
0.0128735518,
-0.0398432501,
0.0085712811,
-0.0724645555,
-0.0047497582,
-0.0423448719,
0.0258480459,
0.0016863026,
-0.0515135862,
-0.0647912547,
0.0220221765,
-0.0154763926,
0.0019691391,
-0.0323783271,
-0.0040889634,
-0.0123027563,
0.0294392277,
-0.0108653223,
0.0245076977,
-0.0169609543,
0.0055766348,
0.0527384765,
-0.1182408705,
0.0288013462,
-0.0065621887,
-0.0098108137,
0.0227049999,
0.013219825,
0.0444203168,
0.0019690462,
-0.0549734049,
0.0322216153,
-0.0043446706,
-0.0434632152,
-0.0587859191,
0.0075186947,
-0.0391875803,
-0.008778763,
-0.0017778064,
0.0000880047,
-0.0309539959,
0.0358715542,
0.0034104004,
-0.0269835033,
0.0730467066,
-0.019613985,
0.0258813314,
0.0027876289,
0.0284096692,
-0.0284951329,
0.0393967144,
0.0107027842,
0.0115115279,
-0.0047880705,
-0.0596830882,
0.0373556353,
-0.0401628464,
-0.0083331848,
-0.0323179103,
-0.015973771,
-0.0209440254,
-0.0317885801,
0.0508047454,
-0.0422454961,
0.0427443124,
-0.0253920797,
0.046577394,
0.0699274167,
0.0572031289,
0.0037800753,
0.061101608,
0.0250788312,
0.0417317003,
0.0055821873,
-0.0181952026,
-0.0360470377,
0.0281738881,
-0.0019381305,
-0.0226527583,
-0.0086422907,
-0.0169845298,
-0.0308359731,
-0.0418937169,
0.0054658344,
-0.0113561377,
0.0018204591,
0.0233742092,
0.0133278295,
-0.0018259871,
-0.0344581641,
-0.0162552539,
0.026459394,
-0.066381827,
-0.0428787507,
-0.0764457807,
0.0222722758,
0.1043866947,
0.0537861623,
0.0154024204,
-0.0107521024,
-0.0145938154,
-0.0034004671,
0.0490503088,
0.0380376764,
0.0250581987,
-0.0154172648,
-0.0151985092,
-0.0036628782,
-0.0069380086,
0.0067465906,
0.0113525633,
-0.0515737012,
0.0274067093,
-0.0230219588,
0.0411107838,
-0.0191879123,
0.039118588,
0.0216293894,
-0.0054690987,
0.0087188864,
-0.0302986484,
0.0249179676,
0.0462352931,
-0.0131805781,
0.0217242874,
0.0349997617,
0.0014365435,
-0.0237425473,
0.0715271905,
-0.0294909906,
-0.043696776,
0.0094936499,
-0.0429049246,
0.0159064922,
0.0422522873,
0.0282279439,
-0.035339158,
0.038180504,
-0.0708026215,
0.0813362002,
-0.0217118841,
0.0282918997,
-0.0252620298,
0.0135525456,
-0.0048060319,
0.0008477019,
0.0139035108,
0.0164233781,
0.0035170396,
-0.0653726831,
-0.0221269112,
-0.0609247796,
-0.0162065178,
-0.0026832405,
-0.0256191362,
0.0098535344,
-0.0037197529,
0.0223543681,
-0.0605162568,
-0.0470066406,
-0.1061210111,
-0.0286296736,
-0.0006973288,
-0.0419066995,
0.0079504326,
-0.0286709573,
-0.0062164241,
-0.0230854079,
-0.0617204718,
0.0161813498,
0.0361176953,
0.0244927797,
-0.0110628009,
0.0075363107,
-0.0372733176,
-0.0213605575,
0.0160380192,
-0.0023026839,
0.0121690696,
0.010333118,
0.0437503271,
-0.0638618395,
0.0471075065,
-0.0201461241,
-0.0200527254,
-0.002691627,
-0.0619115978,
0.0679660961,
0.0050914208,
0.0261275936,
0.0307154898,
0.0316305384,
0.0333110131,
0.0210699774,
0.0036915266,
-0.0560133681,
-0.0124501381,
0.0104369912,
-0.0227075182,
0.007938196,
-0.0697974339,
0.0013372462,
0.0207073316,
0.0419463813,
0.0377255715,
-0.0790587664,
0.0230105035,
0.0017950754,
-0.0253373291,
0.0019514483,
-0.0184704717,
-0.0195759349,
0.0163214635,
0.0092635136,
-0.029403761,
0.0596684515,
-0.0164737217,
-0.0177795123,
-0.0320998356,
-0.0216627792,
0.0050930856,
0.0343832932,
-0.0424201116,
0.0100948913,
0.0405715965,
-0.0013543094,
0.0061586485,
-0.0389995053,
0.0000259524,
-0.0521323606,
-0.005394733,
-0.0387782976,
0.0054366961,
0.0201380812,
-0.0126852086,
-0.0702149644,
-0.0627873912,
-0.0451387279,
0.0042255153,
-0.0169852544,
0.0315882787,
-0.0177752934,
0.0050059967,
0.0320765898,
0.0523194149,
0.0124231102,
-0.0261215772,
-0.0008947001,
-0.0544884875,
0.0433791876,
-0.0112702707,
0.0413602404,
0.0044754236,
0.1071882993,
0.0280057769,
0.0638685003,
0.0511735119,
-0.0262491442,
-0.0259153396,
-0.0103146732,
0.0234502777,
0.0088450164,
0.0246435981,
0.0608002357,
-0.0131606776,
-0.0421151295,
0.1093927547,
0.0049536796,
-0.0867598057,
0.0127939293,
-0.0580474101,
-0.0127152139,
0.019541651,
-0.0007757624,
-0.0637521669,
-0.0324099101,
0.0198866501,
0.0480516553,
-0.0419265516,
-0.016643839,
-0.0080549652,
-0.0875189751,
0.0404469855,
-0.0097210631,
-0.0127932876,
-0.0056833704,
-0.0020038483,
-0.0032021357,
0.006440171,
-0.006424766,
-0.010606382,
-0.0153950024,
0.0148113482,
-0.010540178,
-0.0427848957,
-0.0302974451,
0.0743621513,
0.0107250791,
0.0998408794,
0.0578917786,
0.0566119701,
0.0261222497,
0.0078128548,
-0.0019882414,
0.0171624254,
0.0312442966,
0.024253536,
0.0335991867,
-0.0062866309,
0.0074208491,
-0.0389943905,
0.06036276,
-0.0507078394,
0.0034945884,
0.0375111066,
0.0418954417,
-0.0633948743,
0.0047440487,
-0.0141272899,
0.0610370375,
0.0321714021,
0.0726566464,
0.0607605763,
-0.0566144176,
0.0025826781,
0.0199802145,
0.0352439433,
0.0055582118,
-0.0863218904,
0.0077664549,
-0.0073122177,
0.0469355769,
-0.0925378427,
-0.0683175027,
0.0205519404,
0.0049843402,
-0.015074756,
-0.0178103726,
-0.0450296737,
0.044330094,
0.0102668516,
0.0249355305,
-0.0053207246,
0.012714182,
-0.0617822707,
-0.0164132304,
0.0426513329,
-0.0718296766,
0.0048330729,
-0.0048462101,
-0.0087180519,
-0.0156071223,
0.032246653,
0.0407256857,
0.0233202763,
-0.0047049709,
0.0012518422,
0.0217523891,
-0.0192176644,
-0.0129834404,
-0.0440394878,
0.0075651463,
0.0238962378,
0.0537167452,
0.0045342101,
0.0172339305,
-0.0196880922,
0.0463174917,
0.0185929071,
0.0207177531,
0.0093658585,
-0.050559368,
0.0461800955,
0.023358617,
0.0366660431,
-0.0212142821,
0.0179506503,
0.0202575624,
-0.0131898895,
-0.0555960424,
0.0012434507,
-0.0755795985,
-0.0050215321,
-0.0013065378,
0.0022321716,
0.0049921442,
-0.0323425271,
-0.1121441275,
0.0263111368,
-0.0442022607,
0.0113039371,
0.007142507,
-0.0105774188,
-0.0287356377,
-0.0065223733,
-0.0128719937,
0.0086229052,
-0.0206306204,
0.0186166354,
0.0027652108,
0.1136195362,
0.0072178445,
-0.0360211879,
0.0188662559,
0.0492908396,
-0.0593213812,
-0.0446067564,
0.0038226775,
0.056224592,
0.0263579246,
0.0735412017,
0.0222687032,
-0.0362994596,
0.0380113795,
0.0009436246,
0.0428503491,
-0.015898969,
-0.037076544,
-0.0200933479,
0.0161346737,
-0.0057870527,
-0.0348136947,
0.0215474404,
-0.0467694104,
0.0261621494,
-0.0050957003,
0.0058616493,
-0.0620869026,
0.0081243776,
-0.0029715977,
-0.0093084807,
-0.0110594062,
0.0187780783,
-0.0794396251,
-0.0364320762,
-0.032391049,
-0.010650984,
0.0058485474,
-0.0736989751,
0.0367390029,
0.0337213725,
-0.017217407,
-0.0267824568,
-0.0584364757,
0.0201528762,
-0.015046115,
0.0111063235,
-0.0230634622,
-6.225391633e-33,
-0.0095783956,
0.0101933032,
0.0138794845,
0.0298533943,
-0.0607524849,
0.005322149,
-0.0400233343,
0.0291663166,
-0.0144764902,
0.0082862973,
-0.0185199343,
0.029130578,
0.0094046313,
0.0023426204,
0.0332496539,
0.0326326527,
0.0391856804,
-0.0280006658,
-0.0517153107,
0.0166654605,
0.0035263784,
0.0351722278,
0.0432970896,
-0.0591866821,
0.015347654,
0.0165352467,
-0.0173339713,
0.0012598392,
0.0103181321,
0.0267026704,
-0.0141370809,
0.0392612219,
0.0313238539,
-0.0472560637,
-0.0085259397,
0.0101213921,
-0.0227566715,
-0.0342191011,
0.0154391322,
0.0070450236,
-0.060263548,
-0.0068317088,
-0.002255447,
-0.051923003,
-0.0368967019,
0.0224230234,
-0.0086127073,
-0.0370218307,
0.0044129174,
0.0554791801,
-0.0432584696,
-0.0244230125,
-0.0106476685,
-0.0995227993,
-0.0181078073,
0.0767557248,
-0.0515330769,
-0.0109837465,
-0.0189564265,
0.0473941788,
0.0252372939,
0.0050017694,
0.0172442757,
-0.0061800359,
-0.0022369786,
0.0605344735,
0.0367806442,
0.0188247524,
-0.0125737321,
-0.018031558,
0.0191327315,
0.0238091871,
0.078993924,
0.0475945286,
0.00247895,
-0.0057358854,
0.0041410998,
0.0002417083,
0.0484487787,
0.0045755859,
0.0620411597,
0.0067009353,
-0.0180823077,
0.009201711,
-0.058303684,
-0.0205454472,
-0.0087914877,
-0.0675818399,
0.0498575382,
0.0239972156,
-0.0403690077,
-0.040903911,
0.0218119938,
-0.0311964117,
0.0406100154,
0.0011739522,
-0.0451613963,
0.0387280732,
-0.0276909508,
-0.0353347771,
-0.0518401675,
0.0182513017,
0.0624820106,
0.025290506,
0.0417688489,
-0.0007513882,
-0.005466504,
0.0194253139,
-0.0270034373,
-0.0180595741,
-0.033008907,
0.0672235265,
-0.010875484,
-0.0019441734,
-0.0240099784,
0.0388350561,
-0.0389646031,
0.048283793,
0.0001608624,
0.0076555065,
-0.0595160201,
0.0091586933,
-0.0117285,
-0.0058958228,
-0.0542257167,
-0.0177258793,
-0.043523401,
-0.0144505166,
0.0457412899,
0.0140536707,
-0.0195661169,
-0.0068029887,
3.165e-7,
-0.0453716069,
0.0272093322,
0.0000448888,
0.0010590579,
0.0412560739,
0.0590273105,
0.0070978096,
0.0399813689,
0.0295038782,
-0.0613293163,
0.0015854265,
0.0218419675,
0.081908673,
0.0145419389,
-0.0629127547,
-0.020014558,
-0.0560345761,
-0.0521638133,
-0.0343427397,
0.0077047306,
0.0862712041,
0.053799402,
0.0076064854,
-0.0266556069,
0.0010753864,
0.0430589765,
0.0425478742,
-0.0474844873,
-0.031379465,
0.0083637536,
-0.0062700268,
-0.0220114496,
0.0014699092,
0.0031008914,
0.0307280645,
0.0013739071,
-0.025360886,
0.0530196913,
-0.0498628542,
-0.0508491956,
0.0334027298,
0.0581938587,
-0.0201229416,
-0.0094903484,
0.0311195683,
-0.0783298835,
-0.0377983376,
-0.0495605282,
-0.0335851796,
-0.0341341235,
0.0515392572,
-0.0274472479,
-0.0386882573,
0.0344578028,
-0.0133432737,
0.0028774205,
0.0017679716,
-0.0239079669,
0.0243030023,
-0.0304273441,
-0.0509994142,
-0.0178862009,
-0.0137564745,
-0.0424932912,
-0.0411670506,
-0.101911962,
0.0069310362,
2.463572591e-34,
0.0125971232,
0.0325557142,
0.0353843383,
0.0575882196,
0.0269768368,
0.0507841296,
0.0071441298,
0.024282461,
0.0397916101,
-0.034276884,
-0.0279064532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01786v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01786v2 | COA-GPT: Generative Pre-trained Transformers for Accelerated Course of Action Development in Military Operations | 2024-02-01T21:51:09 | 2024-03-28T15:22:42 | Vinicius G. Goecks, Nicholas Waytowich | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7 | The development of Courses of Action (COAs) in military operations is
traditionally a time-consuming and intricate process. Addressing this
challenge, this study introduces COA-GPT, a novel algorithm employing Large
Language Models (LLMs) for rapid and efficient generation of valid COAs.
COA-GPT incorporates military doctrine and domain expertise to LLMs through
in-context learning, allowing commanders to input mission information - in both
text and image formats - and receive strategically aligned COAs for review and
approval. Uniquely, COA-GPT not only accelerates COA development, producing
initial COAs within seconds, but also facilitates real-time refinement based on
commander feedback. This work evaluates COA-GPT in a military-relevant scenario
within a militarized version of the StarCraft II game, comparing its
performance against state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms. Our
results demonstrate COA-GPT's superiority in generating strategically sound
COAs more swiftly, with added benefits of enhanced adaptability and alignment
with commander intentions. COA-GPT's capability to rapidly adapt and update
COAs during missions presents a transformative potential for military planning,
particularly in addressing planning discrepancies and capitalizing on emergent
windows of opportunities. | COA-GPT: Generative Pre-trained Transformers for Accelerated Course of Action Development in Military Operations: The development of Courses of Action (COAs) in military operations is
traditionally a time-consuming and intricate process. Addressing this
challenge, this study introduces COA-GPT, a novel algorithm employing Large
Language Models (LLMs) for rapid and efficient generation of valid COAs.
COA-GPT incorporates military doctrine and domain expertise to LLMs through
in-context learning, allowing commanders to input mission information - in both
text and image formats - and receive strategically aligned COAs for review and
approval. Uniquely, COA-GPT not only accelerates COA development, producing
initial COAs within seconds, but also facilitates real-time refinement based on
commander feedback. This work evaluates COA-GPT in a military-relevant scenario
within a militarized version of the StarCraft II game, comparing its
performance against state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms. Our
results demonstrate COA-GPT's superiority in generating strategically sound
COAs more swiftly, with added benefits of enhanced adaptability and alignment
with commander intentions. COA-GPT's capability to rapidly adapt and update
COAs during missions presents a transformative potential for military planning,
particularly in addressing planning discrepancies and capitalizing on emergent
windows of opportunities. | [
0.0467906445,
0.0203074925,
0.0054622102,
-0.052788347,
-0.0170096457,
-0.0206342544,
-0.0315369293,
-0.0322076194,
-0.0545499921,
-0.0372944549,
-0.0169287641,
-0.0506405979,
-0.0255891569,
0.0595880747,
-0.0003272637,
0.0000406103,
0.0505113788,
-0.0521441661,
-0.005769453,
0.0299811661,
-0.0372745134,
-0.0104388976,
-0.0275410321,
0.0347351432,
0.0204246547,
-0.0077984533,
-0.0641541034,
-0.0120504973,
0.035691224,
-0.0709051415,
0.0007963414,
0.0186249781,
0.0554429255,
0.0032896975,
0.0000020111,
-0.0393921845,
-0.0239384919,
-0.0475361049,
-0.0168965682,
0.0224951692,
0.0354954153,
-0.0146674421,
-0.0411262363,
0.0395896398,
-0.0619435161,
0.0046251398,
0.0553479455,
0.0698278844,
0.0675801113,
0.0884934738,
0.0047336649,
-0.0298310667,
-0.0508124195,
-0.036100544,
-0.0428506583,
-0.0391952507,
0.0071388348,
0.0040598889,
-0.0082956534,
0.0281425379,
-0.0025559373,
-0.0184790939,
-0.0118247997,
0.0123753585,
-0.0250083189,
0.0705424473,
0.016458381,
0.018564973,
-0.0035445909,
0.0198987108,
-0.0077641411,
-0.0055333627,
0.0111754993,
-0.0118546458,
-0.0159092359,
0.0068995017,
-0.0249455404,
-0.0054088049,
-0.0062239026,
0.0079338886,
0.0216197986,
-0.0035981126,
0.0061321291,
-0.0068150614,
-0.0381373391,
0.0521056466,
-0.0151140131,
-0.0369886346,
-0.0069446429,
0.0098808995,
-0.0296528675,
-0.060398221,
-0.0336342677,
0.0677504316,
-0.1265224218,
0.0037848812,
-0.0181928333,
0.01837915,
0.0231305975,
-0.0028638383,
0.0906620622,
0.0214689933,
-0.0035386314,
0.0481275134,
-0.0166271906,
0.1027941331,
-0.0227932651,
0.0288334973,
-0.0356737934,
0.0350168534,
-0.08364214,
-0.030638421,
-0.036266841,
0.0425651707,
0.0037271255,
-0.061812941,
-0.0919617265,
0.0094831558,
-0.0316879228,
0.0442690812,
0.0233088098,
0.0245265923,
-0.0499837622,
0.010898849,
-0.0762559846,
-0.0211270694,
0.0139587745,
0.030554194,
0.0077222567,
0.0251268316,
0.028160736,
-0.0100023039,
-0.0380604267,
0.0005833931,
0.0010580658,
0.0988318697,
-0.0401182994,
-0.009442864,
-0.0253371727,
0.0100573581,
0.0055973441,
-0.0442106202,
0.0190784335,
-0.0761963353,
-0.0079740183,
-0.0156223159,
0.0011911412,
0.0061259009,
-0.0117248632,
0.0067838826,
0.0127349291,
0.0515809059,
0.0543794744,
0.0342865288,
-0.0006324704,
0.0086461343,
0.0075811786,
0.0602438301,
0.0464582071,
0.0622820668,
-0.0016193979,
0.0136035085,
0.0632344037,
0.0552097745,
-0.0441040993,
0.0271496028,
-0.0067583923,
-0.004803712,
-0.0096064638,
0.0560315065,
0.0230554845,
-0.0076035061,
-0.0162746739,
0.0121713681,
0.06614317,
0.0113307247,
0.0160279553,
0.0135354362,
0.1027511731,
0.0525181852,
-0.0106625343,
-0.0415705815,
-0.0213842746,
0.0266917627,
0.0165077578,
0.0014526075,
-0.0348007083,
0.0446385071,
-0.0171934906,
-0.0142043512,
0.0294126216,
-0.0137986345,
-0.0062730061,
-0.0322595574,
0.0200330466,
-0.0043530809,
-0.0642890781,
-0.0099756084,
0.0301340558,
-0.0165940616,
-0.0036888539,
-0.0286449324,
-0.0087801954,
0.084225975,
0.0471809171,
-0.0582389347,
-0.0956757888,
-0.0441889875,
-0.0252208896,
0.0359083079,
0.0309723001,
-0.0201872438,
0.0262295362,
-0.0169471931,
-0.0409501642,
-0.0214061979,
-0.0053620352,
0.0482431538,
-0.0033743577,
0.0244320929,
-0.0077376189,
0.0482077748,
-0.0220769849,
0.0343112536,
0.0484584086,
-0.0605962649,
0.0264267866,
0.0112514002,
0.056708768,
0.0206459649,
-0.0248950683,
0.0140134897,
-0.0101150377,
0.0011193554,
-0.0114986049,
-0.0122231059,
-0.0393217504,
0.0540821739,
0.0090505052,
-0.0266092084,
-0.0035170342,
0.0073049078,
-0.0360377915,
-0.0223384276,
0.0013302725,
-0.0311369896,
0.0209565107,
0.0066974196,
0.0115452018,
0.0032595303,
-0.0036860257,
-0.0559151657,
0.033642754,
-0.00044355,
-0.0617857389,
0.0314799584,
0.0049758754,
0.0076690428,
0.0078462949,
0.0191103294,
0.0491978452,
0.0143361576,
-0.0186137017,
0.0522965118,
0.0652724057,
-0.0074445205,
-0.0708889663,
-0.0487234257,
-0.0105222389,
-0.0090295374,
0.0009042993,
0.0163629036,
-0.0440350585,
-0.0127032576,
0.0390277915,
-0.0030793499,
0.0124560772,
0.0076370765,
-0.0126491291,
0.0244824551,
0.0371829644,
-0.0025552514,
-0.0147487838,
-0.0074575581,
0.0084091201,
0.0250865389,
0.0029780352,
0.0365742892,
-0.0655869097,
0.0383866876,
-0.0283279605,
0.0393912196,
-0.0247214548,
-0.1043505073,
0.0659373403,
-0.0541686676,
0.0515592434,
0.0098986216,
0.0284406766,
0.0375227407,
0.0842647478,
-0.0078538945,
-0.0153363626,
0.0060758665,
-0.0786970481,
-0.0913542211,
-0.0957227126,
0.0115215527,
0.0355271995,
0.046257969,
0.0002597338,
0.0274507739,
-0.0669020712,
-0.0358612798,
-0.0164449215,
-0.0158693604,
-0.0073498162,
-0.0146961482,
-0.0285656787,
0.0408981219,
-0.0214368924,
0.01093511,
0.055349458,
0.0238939393,
-0.011946301,
-0.0311197154,
0.0036493964,
-0.0179905444,
0.0365593284,
0.022700889,
0.0020324634,
0.0296677072,
-0.0381590798,
-0.0685105324,
-0.026111301,
0.015072355,
-0.0484430268,
0.0276328027,
-0.0203926452,
-0.018435033,
0.0094816973,
-0.012008395,
-0.019797897,
0.0096437447,
-0.0134184789,
0.023349965,
-0.0021512061,
-0.0487997048,
-0.0476846099,
-0.0236119628,
0.0768261626,
0.0441562273,
-0.0071055209,
-0.0465187095,
-0.0449645184,
-0.0165633429,
0.0622902252,
-0.0219273008,
-0.0016571095,
-0.0314334705,
-0.0190966595,
0.0240710247,
0.0061083045,
-0.0358595401,
-0.0652511418,
0.0222789738,
0.0174481869,
-0.0266932547,
0.0003545665,
0.0413259417,
0.0276344195,
-0.0454554521,
0.0066255145,
0.0781751424,
0.0277506243,
-0.0689317584,
0.0063921567,
0.0144489622,
0.01517299,
0.0291920286,
0.0369524807,
-0.0579483584,
0.0097604888,
-0.0322237238,
0.0049707009,
-0.0346565768,
-0.0316097215,
0.0080802515,
-0.1248607263,
0.0176409986,
-0.0135684796,
-0.0550771542,
-0.0351189487,
-0.0395018607,
0.0194526147,
-0.0127904639,
-0.0515044034,
0.0189587809,
0.0071421326,
-0.0014480312,
0.0305837132,
-0.0351900384,
-0.033578217,
0.0210194457,
-0.0514541306,
0.0309315976,
0.0697190091,
0.010044666,
-0.0117852073,
0.0031773443,
0.0220547356,
0.0249918699,
0.0152738933,
0.0041772989,
-0.0094774021,
-0.0087576415,
-0.0109573957,
0.0178230293,
0.0116641847,
0.0252341758,
-0.0416198596,
0.0034414206,
0.0695608333,
-0.0417073444,
0.0084948987,
0.0014279266,
0.0121908765,
0.0758133605,
-0.008081452,
-0.0310284607,
-0.0638401359,
-0.0480552502,
0.0127003174,
0.0192122385,
-0.0720939189,
-0.0798643157,
0.0032886434,
0.0395910554,
-0.013799889,
-0.0525764301,
-0.0349549837,
0.0102940723,
0.030914342,
0.0484179966,
-0.012331279,
-0.0011584761,
0.0238627493,
-0.0119427983,
-0.0111513212,
0.0003610251,
-0.0087742498,
-0.0814090148,
-0.0577003472,
-0.0043525863,
-0.0464626215,
-0.0245633423,
0.002881147,
-0.018652482,
-0.0373713002,
0.0482548587,
0.0688382387,
0.01679058,
-0.0221249815,
0.0203602184,
-0.0126575371,
0.046065107,
0.0347053893,
-0.0186556038,
0.0052106874,
0.0346552171,
0.041811794,
0.0185132995,
0.0051551126,
-0.0367347822,
0.0360308811,
0.0150074791,
-0.0142030707,
-0.0112699308,
-0.0156195201,
0.0290710442,
-0.0701625049,
0.0389127173,
-0.0738741606,
-0.0069806268,
0.0021429744,
0.0009771963,
-0.0185479671,
-0.0061112549,
0.0115969693,
0.0203768406,
0.0284758899,
0.0007422953,
0.0389364809,
-0.0029637555,
-0.0075915041,
-0.0100459196,
0.0045368024,
-0.0008249326,
0.0401646458,
0.0285429172,
0.0530349873,
0.0030978075,
0.0249843597,
0.0095805237,
-0.0121511966,
0.0057898937,
0.0210855268,
0.068798475,
0.0448242649,
-0.0003471949,
-0.0237161685,
0.0007393779,
-0.0454624034,
-0.0595657043,
0.0092374589,
0.0372303799,
0.0749137774,
0.0233342722,
0.010197591,
-0.0827868134,
0.0165513922,
0.0154820485,
-0.0051817303,
-0.0324928686,
-0.0091279512,
0.0265604407,
0.0387130342,
0.0164853539,
0.0602746084,
0.0554332361,
0.0001721616,
0.04285492,
-0.0069456147,
-0.0335842185,
-0.0284009129,
-0.0254542939,
-0.0191448722,
0.0368658528,
-0.0281731952,
0.0313506648,
-0.0671965852,
0.0039093113,
-0.0052864924,
0.0749235377,
0.0016178315,
-0.0356457867,
0.0077246823,
0.0447509736,
-0.0269778986,
0.0190756395,
-0.0556213036,
-0.0117460182,
0.0033570065,
-0.019873105,
-0.0295663867,
-5.632930726e-33,
0.0000491477,
-0.0166794248,
0.0997576863,
-0.0172439441,
-0.0739063844,
0.0070432811,
-0.0395083763,
0.0155395512,
0.0354213417,
0.0179886371,
-0.0127947805,
-0.0103663998,
-0.0031584394,
0.0309905093,
0.0378196612,
-0.0126874018,
0.0336987413,
-0.0069523919,
-0.04176303,
0.0466098152,
0.0469486676,
-0.0261204299,
0.0223025121,
-0.0858758762,
-0.048297286,
0.052422747,
-0.0264724158,
0.0005962956,
-0.0057868967,
0.0780958086,
-0.0066740965,
-0.0074853413,
-0.0098695392,
-0.0517630577,
0.0029975998,
0.0129751833,
-0.0151033206,
0.0022781109,
-0.0174368974,
-0.0092269843,
-0.016465852,
-0.0310565438,
-0.0350700766,
0.0185227506,
-0.0214632899,
0.0098038912,
0.0217317604,
0.0198761728,
0.0181360375,
-0.0207252465,
-0.0884063244,
0.0222708434,
-0.0215220582,
-0.0227754749,
-0.0076895817,
0.0446144007,
-0.0026932487,
-0.0023958129,
-0.0100447768,
0.0621205345,
0.0364891663,
0.0362830758,
0.0246973503,
0.0549568795,
0.0123872906,
0.0513851978,
-0.0405230485,
0.0305614341,
-0.0381560512,
-0.0269697849,
0.0015301658,
0.0657647625,
0.0152550275,
0.0477637015,
0.0229901783,
0.002528046,
-0.0484468676,
-0.0026550423,
-0.0188302286,
0.0729372129,
0.0623899102,
0.0076717692,
-0.0002599878,
0.016068479,
0.0020734225,
0.0056826668,
0.0059339348,
-0.0340189002,
0.0233977921,
0.018352231,
-0.0164365228,
0.0255751703,
0.0558614768,
0.0136089651,
0.0448636599,
0.0207148753,
-0.0547802821,
0.0625371188,
-0.0469797887,
-0.0351061709,
-0.0645176023,
-0.0519592278,
0.0597075261,
-0.0478523932,
0.0099448347,
0.0181211922,
-0.0139630632,
0.0375977233,
-0.0273506474,
0.0003000089,
-0.0134085063,
0.0275120661,
0.0059813624,
-0.0591704436,
0.0423259884,
-0.0291408543,
-0.0164834186,
-0.0214650799,
0.0121525256,
-0.1188081354,
0.0177335124,
-0.0135901803,
0.0171042699,
0.0212962348,
-0.0258785207,
0.0488511734,
-0.0616774336,
0.0573281348,
-0.0122239273,
-0.0445550121,
-0.0114063453,
0.0454602353,
2.786e-7,
0.0163156614,
0.0484691449,
0.0083259558,
-0.0015745917,
-0.0080097588,
0.0426201373,
-0.011002806,
0.0137149496,
0.0036533368,
-0.0147367585,
0.065178223,
0.0612525716,
-0.0061682886,
-0.0023814165,
-0.0343875252,
-0.0250478182,
-0.0259550009,
-0.0246852376,
-0.1007302478,
0.0028067608,
0.0710971132,
0.0395167693,
0.0201080292,
-0.0435535759,
0.0117080584,
0.0351070054,
0.0324589685,
0.0135520259,
0.0233373307,
0.0067178812,
0.0050384458,
-0.0024626949,
-0.0621927306,
0.0075724521,
-0.0155314356,
-0.017292222,
-0.0135014998,
0.0417505912,
0.0104868812,
-0.0106497668,
-0.0256177746,
-0.0036952258,
-0.0240625404,
-0.0538882501,
0.0506103747,
-0.1048455089,
-0.0116573134,
-0.0245855134,
-0.0310553964,
-0.0074581136,
-0.0287704077,
-0.0058927932,
-0.0074515096,
-0.0053699077,
-0.0167715549,
0.03470001,
0.0106444126,
-0.0563212521,
0.0417260155,
0.0638484806,
-0.0243549086,
-0.0183005445,
0.0063091526,
0.0038038162,
0.0233890396,
0.0273526441,
0.0067626331,
2.334961341e-34,
-0.0039944872,
-0.0122797079,
0.006686585,
-0.0230047833,
-0.0002084404,
0.025868468,
-0.0400016271,
0.028134549,
0.0256180037,
-0.031838458,
-0.0250799358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01035v2 | Getting the most out of your tokenizer for pre-training and domain adaptation | 2024-02-01T21:49:34 | 2024-02-07T10:51:11 | Gautier Dagan, Gabriel Synnaeve, Baptiste Rozière | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tokenization is an understudied and often neglected component of modern LLMs.
Most published works use a single tokenizer for all experiments, often borrowed
from another model, without performing ablations or analysis to optimize
tokenization. Moreover, the tokenizer is generally kept unchanged when
fine-tuning a base model. In this paper, we show that the size,
pre-tokenization regular expression, and training data of a tokenizer can
significantly impact the model's generation speed, effective context size,
memory usage, and downstream performance. We train specialized Byte-Pair
Encoding code tokenizers, and conduct extensive ablations on the impact of
tokenizer design on the performance of LLMs for code generation tasks such as
HumanEval and MBPP, and provide recommendations for tokenizer hyper-parameters
selection and switching the tokenizer in a pre-trained LLM. We perform our
experiments on models trained from scratch and from pre-trained models,
verifying their applicability to a wide range of use-cases. We find that when
fine-tuning on more than 50 billion tokens, we can specialize the tokenizer of
a pre-trained LLM to obtain large gains in generation speed and effective
context size. | Getting the most out of your tokenizer for pre-training and domain adaptation: Tokenization is an understudied and often neglected component of modern LLMs.
Most published works use a single tokenizer for all experiments, often borrowed
from another model, without performing ablations or analysis to optimize
tokenization. Moreover, the tokenizer is generally kept unchanged when
fine-tuning a base model. In this paper, we show that the size,
pre-tokenization regular expression, and training data of a tokenizer can
significantly impact the model's generation speed, effective context size,
memory usage, and downstream performance. We train specialized Byte-Pair
Encoding code tokenizers, and conduct extensive ablations on the impact of
tokenizer design on the performance of LLMs for code generation tasks such as
HumanEval and MBPP, and provide recommendations for tokenizer hyper-parameters
selection and switching the tokenizer in a pre-trained LLM. We perform our
experiments on models trained from scratch and from pre-trained models,
verifying their applicability to a wide range of use-cases. We find that when
fine-tuning on more than 50 billion tokens, we can specialize the tokenizer of
a pre-trained LLM to obtain large gains in generation speed and effective
context size. | [
0.0161132384,
0.0746295005,
0.0062264549,
-0.0015635518,
0.011285617,
0.0109303156,
0.011455995,
0.0242660344,
-0.0623396486,
-0.0701432154,
-0.0212147608,
-0.0019974397,
-0.0654143766,
0.0377111174,
0.0648325086,
0.0084513389,
0.0758742094,
-0.0153272673,
0.0046186545,
0.0116075333,
-0.0123993941,
-0.0034526798,
0.0244972967,
0.0734612569,
-0.0304257702,
0.0168375224,
-0.0205651969,
0.0584119484,
-0.0339706875,
-0.0416267663,
-0.0011682314,
0.0116525143,
0.0099157039,
-0.0033846595,
0.0000018633,
-0.0508915335,
-0.0401828475,
0.0145188356,
-0.0100978818,
0.0520666987,
0.0352218226,
-0.0134409498,
-0.0282888114,
0.0426045433,
-0.0237838421,
-0.0086485362,
0.0622989163,
0.0228258837,
0.050254982,
0.0883511677,
-0.0002489936,
0.0046895146,
0.0335782953,
0.0160333049,
0.013694576,
-0.0223258827,
0.0146643445,
-0.0233369954,
-0.0142050656,
-0.0243525691,
-0.0263836831,
-0.0301021934,
0.004399288,
0.001280764,
0.0031128118,
0.0138385557,
-0.0394233875,
0.0069468268,
-0.0330388062,
0.0059278766,
-0.0454650894,
-0.0254131015,
0.0183411594,
0.0102692824,
-0.0063350261,
-0.0534229353,
-0.0090762228,
0.0400491804,
0.013087661,
0.0361721851,
0.0146532003,
-0.0244820807,
0.0257211979,
-0.009739833,
-0.0498513579,
0.0605649687,
0.0318771005,
-0.006539647,
-0.0209814254,
-0.0089780996,
-0.0175484959,
-0.0838630199,
0.0109647075,
0.0373634771,
-0.0073036025,
0.0056734346,
-0.0852913037,
-0.0344957188,
0.0285327509,
-0.0007787434,
0.0273864344,
0.0657968894,
-0.0290597286,
-0.0327716544,
-0.0967017934,
0.0276844855,
-0.0122532733,
0.0415965021,
-0.0177241731,
-0.0005342721,
-0.0403098501,
-0.002348159,
-0.0596253537,
0.0816334859,
-0.0239224788,
0.0318490118,
-0.0380722359,
0.0536157601,
0.029381847,
0.008074983,
-0.0160110127,
-0.0246342532,
-0.0231288299,
0.0181131978,
-0.0097957077,
-0.0314235352,
-0.0399500653,
-0.0129150059,
0.0162246469,
-0.0884218886,
-0.0222557019,
0.0151090324,
-0.0166192427,
-0.0409848951,
0.0258919634,
0.1108825877,
-0.0003384278,
-0.0214298014,
-0.0758763999,
-0.0433127843,
0.0323049165,
-0.0042044506,
0.0000188,
-0.0568783022,
-0.0275111068,
-0.0041761645,
-0.0166339111,
-0.0509652533,
-0.0021578914,
-0.0232067071,
-0.0033071914,
0.038747821,
-0.0457800105,
-0.0340254754,
-0.0151457647,
-0.0157344285,
-0.0140034594,
0.0682974905,
0.0209545158,
0.0356714502,
0.0251787379,
-0.0244402718,
0.0077629643,
0.0439448617,
0.0086194836,
-0.0054358323,
-0.0141843269,
0.010573077,
0.047566928,
0.0057283482,
0.097814396,
0.0494817309,
-0.0514992364,
0.0044343546,
-0.0160737392,
0.0675515458,
0.0278491396,
0.0371403545,
0.0811927617,
-0.0056579611,
-0.0146110719,
-0.0241778661,
-0.0397165604,
0.0030669537,
-0.0015901569,
0.0058925003,
0.0167581253,
0.0721758232,
-0.0134419557,
-0.0518984981,
-0.0144647239,
-0.0178085789,
-0.0238403231,
-0.057564199,
0.0178377982,
0.0062314039,
-0.0657176897,
0.0914234817,
0.0128499344,
-0.0857359022,
-0.0212761592,
-0.0815800428,
-0.0028559475,
0.0600273497,
0.0552910082,
-0.0374462567,
-0.0414679535,
0.002059785,
-0.0033823063,
-0.0090160351,
0.0418006815,
0.0107326992,
0.0291779451,
-0.0664876252,
-0.0238263085,
-0.0514757261,
0.0192974694,
0.0416854322,
0.025817506,
-0.0084853014,
0.0285744928,
-0.0393315963,
-0.0040961243,
0.0726047531,
0.0221515689,
-0.0309848022,
0.0402355008,
-0.0053267665,
0.03549264,
-0.0068099382,
-0.0363949724,
0.0252111144,
0.0405415595,
-0.0180646218,
0.00549404,
0.001675653,
-0.0342015587,
0.0026449419,
0.0624273159,
-0.0114013646,
0.0167962629,
0.0024034993,
-0.0269121006,
-0.0391087793,
0.0246127322,
-0.0326028578,
0.0822510347,
-0.005946713,
0.0584440008,
-0.0143245738,
0.0105657894,
-0.0557698756,
-0.0043500387,
0.0114114927,
-0.0430869609,
-0.0319389701,
0.0447793603,
0.0383492149,
-0.0049751517,
-0.0176075138,
-0.0324901156,
-0.0350123718,
0.0073609329,
0.0081729637,
0.0423394702,
-0.0330953859,
-0.0345958993,
-0.0811710432,
0.0389577709,
-0.0284668151,
0.0431610085,
0.0091427043,
0.0338116772,
-0.0106162298,
-0.0037300317,
-0.0344158784,
-0.0116887856,
-0.0253848042,
0.007636616,
0.0225151349,
-0.0001690671,
-0.0599221326,
-0.0180676188,
-0.0066619781,
-0.0202436224,
0.0453310125,
-0.0345407687,
-0.0157789495,
-0.0530526042,
0.0588810556,
-0.0056734406,
0.0384463854,
0.0042347396,
-0.0471075326,
0.0336331241,
-0.0326365121,
0.0311361253,
0.0266219862,
0.0075381291,
0.0174991228,
0.050932847,
0.0241434928,
-0.0793642849,
0.0114425598,
0.0315445587,
-0.0518193915,
-0.0515403748,
-0.0046542636,
0.0692214593,
0.05546543,
-0.0342308208,
-0.0206489172,
-0.0227280948,
0.0073654093,
0.0331222899,
-0.0534344949,
0.0138190426,
-0.022951128,
0.0007302666,
0.052725438,
0.0037029928,
-0.0736688673,
0.0350237787,
-0.0394194648,
0.0071618413,
-0.0245344844,
0.0126861986,
-0.053399194,
0.0190460812,
-0.0212717932,
0.0197484158,
0.0068148812,
-0.0640469417,
-0.0211743973,
0.0037633381,
-0.0191328712,
-0.0107894372,
0.0345454104,
-0.0279180631,
0.004213552,
-0.0261543337,
-0.0476810858,
-0.0596211068,
0.0146656791,
-0.0133778015,
0.0036875694,
0.0604248568,
-0.0098726209,
-0.0201669931,
0.0196269806,
-0.0254221372,
0.0160028674,
0.0046091639,
-0.0330264829,
-0.0125304814,
-0.0054235486,
-0.0068698945,
-0.0039080828,
0.0217677653,
0.014502882,
-0.0111046536,
0.0511354543,
0.0384237692,
-0.0250569154,
-0.0527162142,
0.0317412317,
0.0506525822,
-0.0681493655,
-0.0063805478,
0.0370923877,
0.0873884559,
-0.0404864885,
-0.0271922164,
0.0972128958,
0.0333920047,
-0.034317784,
0.028148273,
-0.0140631367,
0.0249229092,
0.0358040705,
0.0393913724,
-0.0875260383,
-0.0236978605,
0.0279824734,
0.0247500781,
-0.0215806384,
-0.0112875011,
-0.0177852213,
-0.0904125497,
0.0137962457,
0.0305893663,
-0.0275600962,
0.0176522192,
-0.0330569893,
-0.041499,
0.0055264523,
0.0399433523,
0.02776918,
0.004052815,
0.0124636032,
0.0270927474,
-0.0007505573,
-0.0044894065,
-0.0135301454,
-0.0573417619,
0.0448962525,
0.0912831351,
-0.0295747519,
0.0054880115,
-0.0226354916,
0.0781417042,
0.048431538,
0.0370709971,
-0.0446769707,
0.010369434,
-0.015720509,
-0.0098206578,
0.0372088626,
0.006108054,
-0.0272946116,
-0.0264557395,
0.0244341176,
0.0126159238,
-0.0110708857,
0.0112866461,
-0.038536761,
-0.0352468863,
-0.0365566686,
0.042878028,
0.0492263287,
-0.0204064157,
-0.0584962592,
-0.0757856593,
-0.0379068404,
-0.0962398499,
0.0218351707,
-0.0320598483,
-0.021081632,
-0.0133428695,
-0.0539358072,
0.0375408866,
0.0291142575,
0.0663134977,
0.00314964,
-0.016589053,
-0.0320803858,
-0.0024600145,
-0.0757458806,
0.0255738311,
-0.0330490582,
0.0008028748,
-0.0843106955,
-0.0119977882,
0.0133863147,
-0.0115732439,
0.0004586675,
0.0021482995,
-0.0500100479,
-0.0717443004,
-0.0284346417,
0.0829629824,
0.0169938169,
0.0526434854,
-0.012150581,
-0.0487226546,
0.0118949255,
0.0481136441,
-0.0451677106,
0.0242083427,
0.0577115156,
0.0000955444,
0.0090099378,
-0.0226952713,
-0.0489073135,
0.0066217291,
0.0504100733,
0.0002434901,
0.0258774646,
0.0115395878,
0.0241567716,
0.0687036514,
0.0016800289,
-0.026777124,
0.0084408121,
0.0395547748,
0.0215175208,
-0.0184542816,
0.0150372256,
-0.0407099314,
0.0130347498,
-0.006269264,
0.0039420468,
0.0106601613,
-0.025088843,
-0.0377085581,
0.0603438616,
0.0224508271,
0.0373021327,
-0.0422750376,
0.0507832058,
0.0544546433,
-0.0093815355,
0.000925797,
-0.0115122395,
0.0244042575,
0.0196013991,
-0.04790603,
-0.0164949596,
0.0003599562,
0.0736563578,
-0.0462690257,
0.0483753048,
-0.0205536876,
-0.0308550335,
-0.0273243245,
0.01454446,
0.0467129573,
0.0294110868,
0.0166769251,
-0.0015934929,
0.0072606974,
-0.00583841,
0.0220013298,
-0.0095260879,
-0.0069937254,
0.027725067,
-0.0105069103,
-0.0426160581,
-0.0487489104,
0.0684348866,
0.0184327234,
0.0552621819,
-0.0119686937,
0.0059552751,
-0.0399429016,
0.0223194081,
0.0415465869,
0.03219188,
-0.0091251777,
-0.0437637679,
-0.0197365247,
-0.0546333157,
0.020193819,
0.0046707555,
0.024085924,
0.0301195551,
0.0302666947,
0.0704172403,
0.0069978451,
-0.0218475871,
-0.0127987713,
-0.0041949535,
0.041730728,
-0.040009737,
0.013269335,
-5.455918174e-33,
-0.0111627514,
-0.0052931439,
0.037684571,
-0.0149265463,
-0.0237879362,
-0.0169411357,
-0.0072474713,
-0.0165966824,
0.0208606273,
-0.0577386171,
-0.0016155363,
-0.0034652385,
0.0148271378,
0.0042029889,
0.0092098992,
0.0139858788,
0.0591024272,
-0.0045679412,
-0.0468428917,
-0.0150677022,
-0.0127830161,
0.0328332484,
0.0149053652,
-0.036057204,
-0.0564162657,
0.0271221008,
-0.0120251244,
-0.0275761429,
0.0282557253,
0.0590186939,
0.0085388422,
0.017068876,
-0.0013142055,
-0.0170838833,
-0.0414469205,
-0.0100212172,
-0.0610946119,
-0.0236612689,
0.0239214804,
0.0135008106,
0.0289586931,
-0.1304963529,
0.0674511492,
0.0234304257,
-0.0460387282,
0.023952039,
-0.0233652424,
-0.0036220846,
-0.0155787356,
-0.0614238977,
-0.0521252081,
0.0111993114,
-0.0213380493,
0.0346899107,
0.0194517784,
-0.0410346612,
-0.0012717484,
0.0408854708,
0.0079619735,
0.0271812156,
0.0249732658,
0.0278143231,
0.0684846044,
0.0168361887,
0.0176161826,
0.0385972783,
0.0461949483,
0.0139353015,
0.0128905466,
0.0281298254,
0.0521304533,
0.042678386,
0.0010975322,
0.0155247441,
0.0563609935,
-0.0422982462,
-0.0620769374,
0.0335680321,
0.0149367275,
0.0104974881,
0.007269308,
0.073940374,
0.0142894862,
0.008768267,
-0.0276650768,
0.0190629363,
-0.0144561222,
-0.0645487905,
0.0464872383,
-0.0029509801,
-0.0209188722,
-0.008631276,
0.0344516672,
-0.0335308611,
0.0125852199,
-0.0112077435,
-0.0110428771,
0.0021595925,
-0.0163863096,
-0.0057239151,
0.0006300525,
-0.064006187,
0.0436821021,
-0.0525133274,
0.0501091778,
-0.0217379853,
0.0259938613,
0.0012572957,
-0.0831870139,
-0.0004435391,
-0.0324233063,
0.0232592914,
0.043646574,
0.0386045538,
-0.0057979277,
-0.0132637108,
0.0094761821,
-0.0194520913,
-0.0169507079,
-0.0583536364,
-0.0328658558,
0.0219475776,
0.0336971991,
0.0517966338,
-0.0425340272,
0.0050491439,
-0.0366972573,
0.0428317189,
0.0303240716,
-0.0571903661,
-0.0600978695,
0.01154612,
2.638e-7,
0.0500532389,
0.0422791801,
0.0420850255,
-0.0128413364,
0.0021725392,
0.0087057408,
0.001768996,
0.0048596738,
-0.0107519673,
0.0340402909,
-0.020406248,
0.0194141082,
0.0163914096,
0.0087193325,
-0.0535896607,
0.0137532568,
0.0069148811,
0.0173046887,
-0.0528531298,
0.0086902902,
0.0187684614,
0.0989536718,
-0.0294138547,
-0.016465418,
0.0364270173,
-0.0301745739,
0.0125849452,
-0.0255940668,
-0.0016804879,
0.0296758339,
-0.0336387865,
0.0117395474,
0.0064721066,
-0.00689526,
-0.0183707587,
0.0049515357,
-0.0177726503,
0.0630453229,
-0.0017439768,
-0.017872192,
0.0399239436,
-0.0230444353,
0.0157259032,
-0.0159220397,
0.0541365184,
0.0148603562,
-0.0002436053,
-0.0436910726,
-0.037718825,
-0.0137410881,
-0.0473239869,
-0.0298040565,
0.0223162379,
0.0573927201,
0.0235783774,
-0.0078828996,
-0.0205276255,
-0.0706942454,
-0.025872143,
-0.0158329234,
-0.026321549,
-0.0668802336,
-0.0563430488,
0.0590486005,
0.0520762242,
-0.0316537693,
-0.0114738718,
2.887649627e-34,
0.0375298783,
-0.0604305044,
0.0256962515,
0.0850254148,
0.0313375182,
-0.0090392586,
-0.0144260311,
0.0398232229,
-0.0007013681,
-0.0215294864,
-0.0121217938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01032v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01032v2 | Repeat After Me: Transformers are Better than State Space Models at Copying | 2024-02-01T21:44:11 | 2024-06-03T22:22:15 | Samy Jelassi, David Brandfonbrener, Sham M. Kakade, Eran Malach | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Transformers are the dominant architecture for sequence modeling, but there
is growing interest in models that use a fixed-size latent state that does not
depend on the sequence length, which we refer to as "generalized state space
models" (GSSMs). In this paper we show that while GSSMs are promising in terms
of inference-time efficiency, they are limited compared to transformer models
on tasks that require copying from the input context. We start with a
theoretical analysis of the simple task of string copying and prove that a two
layer transformer can copy strings of exponential length while GSSMs are
fundamentally limited by their fixed-size latent state. Empirically, we find
that transformers outperform GSSMs in terms of efficiency and generalization on
synthetic tasks that require copying the context. Finally, we evaluate
pretrained large language models and find that transformer models dramatically
outperform state space models at copying and retrieving information from
context. Taken together, these results suggest a fundamental gap between
transformers and GSSMs on tasks of practical interest. | Repeat After Me: Transformers are Better than State Space Models at Copying: Transformers are the dominant architecture for sequence modeling, but there
is growing interest in models that use a fixed-size latent state that does not
depend on the sequence length, which we refer to as "generalized state space
models" (GSSMs). In this paper we show that while GSSMs are promising in terms
of inference-time efficiency, they are limited compared to transformer models
on tasks that require copying from the input context. We start with a
theoretical analysis of the simple task of string copying and prove that a two
layer transformer can copy strings of exponential length while GSSMs are
fundamentally limited by their fixed-size latent state. Empirically, we find
that transformers outperform GSSMs in terms of efficiency and generalization on
synthetic tasks that require copying the context. Finally, we evaluate
pretrained large language models and find that transformer models dramatically
outperform state space models at copying and retrieving information from
context. Taken together, these results suggest a fundamental gap between
transformers and GSSMs on tasks of practical interest. | [
0.0228232704,
0.0804753453,
-0.0093130423,
0.0174628142,
-0.0670726299,
0.0028901321,
0.0167699717,
-0.0000413182,
-0.0589296557,
-0.036595121,
-0.0034674464,
-0.076499626,
0.0277413297,
0.0224725679,
0.0362640396,
-0.0649292991,
0.0461344272,
-0.0344700739,
-0.0402353853,
0.0106461328,
-0.0124877365,
-0.0519452989,
0.0071099773,
0.0604416579,
0.0181839168,
0.0136999078,
-0.0410012342,
-0.0248545371,
0.0154988859,
-0.0051018004,
-0.0157871954,
0.0357289724,
0.0402696654,
0.0287299603,
0.0000017343,
-0.0045051291,
0.0147103621,
-0.0002689878,
-0.0096214572,
0.0117420992,
0.0075114197,
-0.0089118825,
-0.0037151913,
0.0310645998,
-0.0257674437,
-0.046273686,
0.060203068,
0.0391388088,
0.0482833348,
0.0989551321,
-0.0249097031,
-0.0306255817,
0.0228441563,
-0.0617200211,
0.0166522954,
-0.0265295394,
0.0405574739,
-0.0129853832,
0.0194118638,
0.0060536549,
-0.0478992686,
0.0469755642,
0.0201971456,
0.0176839959,
-0.0325662643,
0.0461638719,
0.0070374091,
-0.0287018195,
-0.0043086731,
0.0690007582,
-0.0489407219,
-0.0167487357,
0.0188317653,
-0.0017730265,
0.0049170069,
0.0293223895,
-0.0230265688,
0.0492439754,
-0.0061443867,
0.0289061926,
-0.0092990967,
-0.0095329825,
0.0426170528,
-0.0258089695,
-0.0579823256,
0.0229069032,
0.0225418303,
-0.0314713605,
-0.0494942181,
-0.0142053943,
0.0175925009,
-0.0856930315,
0.0328432694,
0.0638398007,
-0.008200394,
0.0157630723,
-0.054808896,
-0.0528849661,
-0.0298806131,
-0.000228315,
0.0395638309,
0.0438735299,
-0.015971357,
0.0276813339,
-0.0328858346,
0.0704501122,
-0.0588591509,
0.0485633612,
-0.0406875685,
-0.0013871291,
-0.040523883,
0.0042285994,
-0.0377605185,
0.0452660099,
-0.0035882145,
-0.0516970456,
-0.0301802661,
0.0246601123,
0.0135283712,
-0.0263885055,
0.0139120175,
0.010994412,
-0.0331192017,
0.0069848779,
0.0013684066,
0.0248748995,
0.0253856089,
0.0343289711,
0.0392868742,
-0.0297905263,
-0.0407645218,
0.0097032338,
0.0469594449,
-0.014606812,
-0.0082871309,
0.0707083046,
-0.0039080433,
-0.0786744505,
-0.0125649096,
0.0307899378,
0.0029427037,
-0.0494582504,
0.0227604508,
-0.0332272127,
0.0189018697,
0.0161067341,
-0.0012150292,
-0.0246303994,
0.0154319182,
0.0307572614,
-0.0078401817,
0.0635050535,
0.0380547307,
-0.0029648575,
-0.0148307076,
0.0082110707,
-0.0013490143,
-0.0206788313,
0.0427165478,
0.0422064848,
-0.0073064147,
-0.0149271749,
0.0433851108,
0.0484859385,
0.0076830792,
0.0057391017,
-0.0081201056,
-0.0477162786,
-0.0161301009,
0.0145557299,
0.0309611037,
0.0801687613,
-0.0463467799,
0.0120758172,
0.0828043893,
0.0506847054,
0.0553340651,
0.034610521,
0.0941092521,
0.0320363529,
-0.0045174663,
0.0017749051,
-0.0276520401,
0.042138502,
0.0219246075,
0.0222217478,
0.0034265558,
0.0261102803,
-0.0336518884,
-0.003582112,
-0.0124740629,
-0.0492770635,
-0.0063743661,
-0.0210059509,
0.067023553,
0.0264045298,
-0.0922308788,
0.0813498497,
-0.0211195517,
-0.057086587,
0.0049480191,
-0.0534263887,
0.0036602644,
0.0146116698,
0.0236570463,
-0.017560605,
-0.0349997468,
-0.0114746653,
-0.0184020642,
0.0185176395,
0.0085225524,
0.0132010197,
0.0125757111,
-0.0330139697,
-0.0449998342,
0.0188899338,
-0.006547031,
0.0079970974,
0.0400853641,
0.0241473522,
0.0480650179,
-0.0113817928,
0.0072338609,
0.0301169623,
-0.0302866716,
-0.0307516661,
-0.0124419592,
-0.0079439413,
0.0463506654,
-0.0175897628,
-0.0163580645,
0.0445071608,
0.0288619902,
-0.0389749072,
-0.0605602786,
0.0272124447,
-0.117847532,
-0.0401412547,
-0.0076154396,
-0.0201907903,
0.0525537208,
0.0776953772,
-0.052777335,
-0.0580221415,
0.0113108549,
-0.0601290278,
0.0314947404,
-0.0295211691,
0.015693225,
0.0426829979,
0.0393378474,
-0.0106489072,
0.0406859964,
-0.0394132547,
-0.0181683097,
0.030980764,
0.0272377059,
-0.0079080146,
-0.0024889449,
-0.0313756242,
-0.0100013018,
-0.0267927181,
-0.0046199234,
0.0177262481,
-0.0250457376,
0.0033675786,
-0.0188266989,
-0.0418412164,
-0.0171495136,
-0.0368592031,
0.0358823314,
0.0111781573,
0.0482233316,
0.0159714818,
0.0045018853,
-0.0399574041,
0.0071149208,
0.0098611135,
0.0120183825,
0.0327679329,
0.0203075316,
-0.0388019942,
-0.051447317,
-0.020159144,
0.0010932292,
0.0669004247,
-0.0479171015,
-0.0298770536,
-0.0651330873,
0.0065466091,
0.0116042979,
0.0381900929,
-0.0333017036,
-0.0176812001,
0.0045194449,
-0.0310080126,
0.0625597164,
0.0251235887,
0.0346491337,
0.0232617352,
0.008261295,
0.0073553589,
-0.0128334472,
0.0089197718,
-0.0706515983,
0.0120679252,
-0.0700605959,
-0.0006291115,
0.0407695584,
0.1027667746,
-0.0131809646,
-0.0040779924,
-0.0785655603,
-0.0341135524,
0.0008711335,
-0.0032904439,
0.009182875,
-0.0300878584,
-0.0661782697,
0.0060586603,
-0.0315610841,
-0.0208030585,
0.0417866781,
-0.0512586161,
-0.0018897275,
0.0198223125,
-0.0096224053,
-0.0339791402,
0.076024048,
0.0380350575,
-0.0017940676,
-0.021462163,
-0.0178696103,
-0.0328893177,
0.0268237665,
0.0270988569,
-0.0169383585,
0.0295137744,
-0.0475852825,
0.0277481973,
-0.0170082245,
-0.0471970439,
-0.0341954678,
-0.0027352325,
-0.0158500373,
0.0059110527,
0.0355374925,
-0.0344110392,
-0.0476472154,
0.0349736027,
0.0279729012,
0.1104861423,
-0.0062084091,
0.0053098747,
-0.020429017,
0.0640324578,
0.0336828195,
0.0011607582,
0.0115173515,
-0.0355892479,
0.0015240078,
0.0460878462,
0.0372984149,
0.0318801142,
-0.0365592875,
-0.0007601667,
0.0405997932,
-0.0353798568,
-0.0363765843,
0.0380356461,
0.0390233733,
-0.0404875763,
-0.0477380492,
0.0926680863,
0.0075380984,
-0.0423723087,
0.0253460649,
0.0158336181,
-0.009206038,
0.0124211004,
0.0033892002,
-0.0639639646,
-0.0347450636,
0.0116213262,
-0.0252744295,
-0.0009299275,
-0.0236862358,
-0.0146199875,
-0.0707385913,
-0.0196586307,
-0.0189049598,
-0.0732208863,
-0.0467765816,
-0.0430169366,
0.0083591156,
0.0041409847,
-0.0124976598,
0.0253760759,
-0.0247217286,
-0.0008538712,
0.0429721326,
-0.0141821494,
-0.052366592,
0.013411439,
-0.0058881165,
0.0236317459,
0.0703005418,
0.0040256223,
0.0054759798,
-0.0786116794,
0.0397704206,
0.0034837704,
0.0217251293,
0.0215994995,
0.0215383042,
-0.019246513,
-0.0158907566,
-0.0153525015,
0.0376927108,
-0.0347152613,
-0.0176315177,
-0.0249750242,
0.0348743014,
-0.0022667574,
-0.0482918583,
-0.0040756678,
-0.0377002358,
0.0056339647,
0.0628454536,
0.0449659601,
-0.0291730203,
-0.050108701,
0.0098944623,
-0.0192092843,
-0.0521012247,
-0.0355970785,
-0.0160742961,
0.0444030054,
-0.0509824753,
-0.0737496689,
-0.0363693424,
0.0169676375,
0.0281641986,
0.0051432373,
-0.0121513559,
0.0544199124,
0.0013354199,
-0.0432844907,
-0.0146618551,
-0.0288804676,
0.0272431821,
-0.0274428893,
-0.0059652748,
0.0260679033,
0.0070595094,
-0.061585445,
-0.0407156385,
-0.1350759268,
-0.0339655951,
0.0406056792,
0.0574786738,
0.0191684701,
0.00713077,
0.0146742873,
-0.0005445987,
0.0572496802,
0.0088393968,
-0.0095483344,
-0.0069537931,
0.0420501307,
-0.065549843,
0.0116376812,
0.032742314,
-0.0345724262,
0.0224856492,
0.0246418454,
0.0378885008,
-0.011611877,
-0.0308469404,
0.002475362,
-0.021832943,
0.0506616868,
0.0085856067,
0.0218169447,
0.0176748764,
0.0255849063,
0.0078800097,
0.0377955176,
-0.0616540872,
-0.0144828008,
0.0277020577,
0.0470326692,
0.0060063079,
0.0110224839,
0.030017674,
0.0084613152,
0.0094175749,
0.0000722269,
0.0044961404,
0.0094939899,
0.0546016693,
0.0031553488,
-0.0129385525,
0.0018430433,
0.0197951943,
0.0274131764,
-0.0375352278,
0.0439077094,
0.034645386,
0.0381031595,
-0.0105728172,
0.0251673032,
-0.1030034199,
-0.0222798195,
-0.03478783,
-0.0003872798,
0.0666977763,
-0.0097499546,
0.0264362656,
-0.0370416306,
0.0198036451,
-0.0095158145,
0.0669572949,
-0.0170363132,
-0.0293570925,
0.0256801751,
0.0138937822,
0.0137148146,
0.0150088184,
0.0948971733,
0.0323337056,
0.0590255,
-0.0285160486,
0.0082353614,
-0.0347492211,
-0.0308761243,
-0.0079740984,
-0.006041192,
-0.0087839467,
-0.0190287512,
-0.0386471599,
-0.0782465786,
0.0283168387,
0.0054635047,
0.0239213463,
-0.0319793336,
0.0517930537,
0.0563130043,
0.0009050332,
-0.0128969504,
-0.024068933,
-0.0135672865,
0.0303307157,
-0.0249573458,
-0.0064152945,
-5.659770568e-33,
-0.0062479791,
-0.00051762,
0.0470396169,
0.0044659269,
-0.0636824816,
0.000757166,
-0.0741673335,
-0.0078592636,
0.0151516004,
-0.0131896855,
-0.02360126,
0.0113085117,
0.0155334538,
0.061462339,
-0.0066980836,
-0.0225265156,
0.0646685809,
0.0148310307,
-0.0119098639,
0.0067296997,
0.0028383881,
0.0418679453,
0.0626454875,
-0.0002852124,
-0.015730273,
-0.013383409,
0.0308532864,
-0.0230200961,
-0.0230799839,
0.0089955898,
-0.0238535255,
0.0112916222,
0.0229154266,
-0.0748609975,
-0.0278032199,
0.0316381752,
-0.0502179153,
-0.0168944318,
-0.0053188875,
-0.0174235534,
-0.0454131402,
-0.0174346771,
0.0332605205,
0.0175836757,
0.0096607609,
0.0067139948,
0.0288117602,
0.0006752319,
-0.0410329811,
-0.0538479611,
-0.0611794144,
0.0077660517,
0.0254626535,
0.0000103571,
0.0261180773,
0.0664604381,
-0.0367360227,
0.0132087329,
-0.0363254286,
0.0122151645,
-0.001882406,
0.0649668276,
0.0493490994,
0.0461753085,
0.0135154286,
0.0120714232,
-0.0063373824,
-0.0462324284,
-0.066838868,
-0.0170567036,
0.0305714421,
0.0238479916,
0.0239412244,
-0.0119394613,
0.0208455771,
-0.0211019181,
-0.032204099,
0.0017376437,
-0.005965997,
0.0564039424,
0.0151283331,
0.007919034,
0.0041531995,
-0.0060076374,
-0.0412647761,
0.0234697629,
0.000101728,
-0.014330945,
0.0359689482,
0.0488499887,
0.0041334615,
0.0244079381,
0.0575275049,
-0.021827288,
-0.0146412784,
-0.0214935672,
-0.0056828512,
0.0174296256,
-0.0215508901,
-0.0159854107,
-0.0944696739,
-0.0395403244,
0.0168971717,
0.0438455492,
0.0139548834,
-0.0044518826,
0.0174210127,
0.0591708533,
-0.0678892657,
-0.0274585709,
-0.0563422218,
0.0206293855,
-0.0218443759,
0.0412921347,
0.0671224967,
0.0144020859,
-0.0226114374,
0.0190117378,
-0.0350761749,
-0.0342719629,
-0.0133592021,
0.0185688771,
0.0208379589,
0.0238596182,
-0.0378892794,
-0.021886345,
-0.0852570608,
0.0651768371,
0.0169704054,
-0.0681360736,
-0.0263911858,
0.0326631106,
2.467e-7,
0.0285137109,
-0.0027797034,
0.0604795925,
0.0079099946,
0.0191566236,
0.0251353737,
-0.0034467052,
0.0259177685,
-0.0014274776,
0.0374004506,
0.0312498473,
0.0268794149,
0.0330220386,
-0.0369883738,
-0.1053902507,
-0.0311674923,
-0.0875376314,
0.0088848202,
-0.0216647424,
-0.0026228214,
0.0346502885,
0.0916839167,
0.0194942486,
-0.0110081807,
0.0208451953,
-0.0099356556,
0.0668120831,
0.0088855503,
0.0483975485,
-0.0068829693,
0.0153162358,
0.0157111399,
-0.0049767862,
0.0032802005,
-0.0115761617,
-0.0109480098,
-0.0017647939,
0.0633430183,
0.0030255087,
-0.0367652215,
-0.0283092111,
0.0161757935,
-0.0198193137,
-0.0203034077,
0.0552322194,
-0.091383256,
-0.0066726189,
-0.021222936,
-0.0464483537,
0.033122167,
-0.0613887832,
0.0390950814,
0.0018553212,
0.0084202606,
0.0127172349,
0.0205854792,
0.0101729985,
-0.1027270406,
0.0075894799,
-0.0148385186,
-0.0505643226,
-0.01152445,
-0.0988917202,
-0.0088389162,
0.0530913174,
-0.0045357421,
-0.0503925607,
2.275657422e-34,
-0.0099787358,
-0.0213128664,
0.018385794,
0.0258426145,
-0.0347241499,
-0.0130047509,
0.0216246694,
0.0189876165,
-0.0190062523,
-0.0464868285,
-0.0636354163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01030v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01030v4 | Executable Code Actions Elicit Better LLM Agents | 2024-02-01T21:38:58 | 2024-06-07T01:53:07 | Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Lifan Yuan, Yizhe Zhang, Yunzhu Li, Hao Peng, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Model (LLM) agents, capable of performing a broad range of
actions, such as invoking tools and controlling robots, show great potential in
tackling real-world challenges. LLM agents are typically prompted to produce
actions by generating JSON or text in a pre-defined format, which is usually
limited by constrained action space (e.g., the scope of pre-defined tools) and
restricted flexibility (e.g., inability to compose multiple tools). This work
proposes to use executable Python code to consolidate LLM agents' actions into
a unified action space (CodeAct). Integrated with a Python interpreter, CodeAct
can execute code actions and dynamically revise prior actions or emit new
actions upon new observations through multi-turn interactions. Our extensive
analysis of 17 LLMs on API-Bank and a newly curated benchmark shows that
CodeAct outperforms widely used alternatives (up to 20% higher success rate).
The encouraging performance of CodeAct motivates us to build an open-source LLM
agent that interacts with environments by executing interpretable code and
collaborates with users using natural language. To this end, we collect an
instruction-tuning dataset CodeActInstruct that consists of 7k multi-turn
interactions using CodeAct. We show that it can be used with existing data to
improve models in agent-oriented tasks without compromising their general
capability. CodeActAgent, finetuned from Llama2 and Mistral, is integrated with
Python interpreter and uniquely tailored to perform sophisticated tasks (e.g.,
model training) using existing libraries and autonomously self-debug. | Executable Code Actions Elicit Better LLM Agents: Large Language Model (LLM) agents, capable of performing a broad range of
actions, such as invoking tools and controlling robots, show great potential in
tackling real-world challenges. LLM agents are typically prompted to produce
actions by generating JSON or text in a pre-defined format, which is usually
limited by constrained action space (e.g., the scope of pre-defined tools) and
restricted flexibility (e.g., inability to compose multiple tools). This work
proposes to use executable Python code to consolidate LLM agents' actions into
a unified action space (CodeAct). Integrated with a Python interpreter, CodeAct
can execute code actions and dynamically revise prior actions or emit new
actions upon new observations through multi-turn interactions. Our extensive
analysis of 17 LLMs on API-Bank and a newly curated benchmark shows that
CodeAct outperforms widely used alternatives (up to 20% higher success rate).
The encouraging performance of CodeAct motivates us to build an open-source LLM
agent that interacts with environments by executing interpretable code and
collaborates with users using natural language. To this end, we collect an
instruction-tuning dataset CodeActInstruct that consists of 7k multi-turn
interactions using CodeAct. We show that it can be used with existing data to
improve models in agent-oriented tasks without compromising their general
capability. CodeActAgent, finetuned from Llama2 and Mistral, is integrated with
Python interpreter and uniquely tailored to perform sophisticated tasks (e.g.,
model training) using existing libraries and autonomously self-debug. | [
0.014943731,
0.0604493544,
-0.0173248239,
0.0293273088,
-0.0170146227,
0.0256824531,
-0.0116490191,
-0.0222226232,
0.0428530276,
-0.0406153537,
-0.0311527904,
0.0353065096,
-0.0316151604,
0.0720818564,
0.0225038622,
-0.0387798473,
0.054419782,
-0.0474654548,
0.0079475809,
0.0141019123,
-0.0187169835,
0.0069511933,
-0.0383804962,
0.0809039772,
0.0222121049,
-0.0136608742,
-0.0437251106,
0.0117783723,
0.0070843762,
-0.0136360154,
0.0030146008,
0.0280205775,
0.0652401373,
0.0389130414,
0.0000020971,
-0.0508191176,
0.0139601072,
-0.0151906321,
-0.0345745832,
-0.0193388909,
0.0408809334,
-0.0136836432,
-0.0051008081,
0.02607584,
-0.069845356,
-0.0006730346,
0.0438113995,
-0.0210339818,
0.0763436109,
0.0705966577,
0.0137643525,
0.0322094932,
-0.0022687151,
0.0040359329,
-0.0209799856,
-0.0182314441,
-0.0013778902,
0.0061970991,
0.0397107378,
0.0031250017,
-0.0195381641,
0.0097195115,
0.0330701917,
-0.0274470598,
-0.0044286088,
0.0469494127,
-0.0403636545,
-0.0554407239,
-0.0451192483,
0.0641683191,
-0.0146474866,
-0.0159317721,
0.0178635884,
-0.0107381511,
0.0060891057,
-0.0182493366,
-0.0304251052,
0.0315572768,
0.0099828644,
0.0070909266,
0.0001776156,
-0.0489984713,
0.0226432215,
0.0009907905,
-0.0289109182,
0.0900358185,
-0.0093531776,
0.0103183025,
-0.0342592672,
-0.0205708519,
0.0325940065,
-0.0856060833,
-0.022171542,
0.0597118102,
-0.0740988031,
0.0235899147,
-0.0398035608,
0.0044722655,
0.0043107523,
0.0019035904,
0.0360422097,
0.042611748,
-0.0037066191,
0.0291925669,
-0.0025328055,
0.0553204976,
0.0013724198,
0.0501915812,
-0.0121313212,
0.0072338576,
-0.0569702163,
-0.0005898454,
-0.0157076754,
0.0262410529,
-0.0203516372,
-0.0173634738,
-0.0001640538,
0.0680713728,
-0.0205254015,
0.033770293,
-0.0139783565,
-0.0074144513,
-0.0253626909,
0.0131741567,
-0.030776253,
0.0132073993,
-0.0270465892,
0.0138938334,
0.0375231616,
-0.0703263059,
-0.0086437846,
0.0149165448,
0.0014603803,
-0.0126928585,
0.0230287295,
0.1092332229,
0.0121605424,
-0.026219707,
-0.006481681,
-0.0294786319,
0.0472009704,
-0.058595337,
-0.0145429168,
-0.0869977027,
0.0317795463,
0.0104877474,
-0.0219015349,
-0.0663590506,
0.0202463064,
-0.0087911552,
-0.0099966023,
0.0760086104,
-0.0182986688,
0.0220748968,
0.0161182918,
0.0024348663,
-0.0315026641,
0.0587245263,
0.052466657,
0.0423202254,
0.0238397755,
0.0027489229,
0.0377455167,
0.0400164314,
-0.0227530356,
0.0172155108,
0.0362674221,
0.0094264671,
0.0003869175,
0.0294011384,
0.0421488471,
0.0004188065,
-0.0235519968,
0.0080987895,
0.048896309,
0.050179597,
-0.0226152744,
-0.0340965651,
0.0571758747,
0.0269603748,
-0.0041783694,
-0.0373793915,
-0.0609221123,
0.0538897328,
-0.0002060721,
-0.0009035922,
-0.0212423615,
0.0384197198,
-0.0153948907,
-0.0569411032,
0.0046186661,
-0.0257829037,
0.0417532958,
0.023496259,
0.0389973521,
0.00309877,
-0.0564999022,
0.019266054,
0.0321802832,
-0.070067063,
-0.0241248067,
-0.0923519135,
0.0435301811,
0.074403733,
0.0495131724,
-0.042921152,
-0.0614721403,
-0.0145439124,
-0.0136607895,
0.0353248976,
0.0071851048,
-0.0174260456,
0.023211306,
-0.0193684548,
-0.0454736687,
-0.0538292266,
-0.0010520237,
0.0436318927,
0.0273389556,
-0.02618392,
-0.0227912199,
0.0011172735,
-0.0203204155,
0.0513842553,
-0.0223033912,
-0.0286664255,
-0.0221057367,
0.0000669244,
0.0568153337,
-0.0014924894,
-0.0171321165,
-0.0151477316,
0.0527145788,
-0.0049198954,
-0.0268896762,
0.0053810026,
0.0002503254,
-0.0094213849,
0.0376080908,
0.0046318946,
-0.0288125779,
0.0546367988,
-0.0415777415,
-0.030293664,
0.0318741351,
-0.0075636837,
0.0494918525,
0.0169602968,
0.0139400167,
-0.0180646572,
0.0112987095,
-0.0009425189,
0.019574808,
0.0082881004,
-0.0365001485,
0.024081884,
0.053505484,
0.0002401461,
-0.0010071305,
0.0027209669,
0.0211664345,
0.0153758833,
0.0237911399,
0.0422416553,
0.0321524478,
-0.0304683615,
-0.0337801948,
-0.0836229846,
0.0067534237,
-0.0338962562,
-0.0093349451,
0.0260669515,
0.020728007,
-0.0100230677,
-0.0018119233,
0.0078709293,
0.0139621515,
0.0054823849,
0.0299226195,
0.0197702553,
0.0065092472,
-0.0720215514,
-0.0576900952,
0.0069555165,
-0.0081110829,
0.011951346,
0.0213752966,
0.0065114647,
-0.0724493265,
0.0328110568,
-0.0184757132,
0.0241995584,
-0.0406580009,
-0.0774081945,
0.0629721805,
-0.0326685496,
0.003306601,
0.0969642475,
-0.035216745,
0.0388396196,
0.0971195325,
-0.0001188913,
-0.0820560455,
0.0162771754,
-0.0072994488,
-0.0321422927,
-0.0519061796,
-0.0079885842,
0.0218103956,
0.0816161036,
-0.0024859139,
0.0177208055,
-0.0341058485,
-0.0097996257,
0.0183742661,
-0.0583833419,
0.0116288681,
-0.0084433518,
-0.0436831638,
0.0636727586,
-0.0205428284,
-0.0906231403,
0.0718982741,
-0.0090236729,
-0.0391707942,
-0.0161960553,
-0.050143443,
-0.0315344408,
0.0923818126,
0.0365408026,
0.0068636024,
-0.0149797574,
-0.0358253494,
-0.0311802775,
-0.0012317224,
-0.00784731,
-0.0066214534,
0.0442967527,
-0.0718432069,
-0.0028251181,
0.0066298139,
-0.0295762327,
-0.0313287079,
0.0087817619,
-0.0442746058,
0.0157312676,
0.0066393488,
-0.0664075539,
-0.0216052122,
-0.0301681161,
0.0553368889,
0.0405861214,
0.0068069468,
-0.0275163613,
-0.0513578914,
-0.0532503277,
0.0232280977,
0.0220003612,
-0.0132788019,
-0.008150897,
0.0324250013,
0.0387406275,
0.0237702727,
-0.0220516957,
-0.0637180209,
0.0122559089,
0.0242895037,
-0.022680711,
0.0210198537,
0.0435429439,
0.0741505101,
-0.0697085708,
-0.0178818274,
0.1024900749,
0.0194399934,
-0.0253878925,
0.0209804382,
-0.0460570492,
0.0202265009,
0.0509857498,
0.0477579199,
-0.0496286601,
-0.0393103249,
0.001064298,
0.0464017093,
0.0052583436,
-0.022233557,
0.0026043833,
-0.1011878848,
0.0506750941,
-0.0084959306,
-0.0139971515,
-0.0293507278,
-0.0582145602,
0.0285689123,
-0.0306934621,
0.0079052635,
0.038776096,
0.0027272706,
-0.0000062206,
-0.01084542,
-0.01103104,
-0.0198676493,
0.0320339538,
-0.0385049134,
0.0582425483,
0.1018076017,
0.0130560054,
0.0081118643,
0.0028287678,
0.0026443137,
0.0274692811,
0.0282192696,
-0.0187631845,
0.0354369842,
0.0057605118,
-0.0244273655,
0.0181567445,
0.0541450083,
-0.074908413,
-0.0265386719,
0.0068445364,
0.057668943,
-0.0311883036,
0.0055750506,
-0.0144989509,
-0.0242059659,
0.0160023235,
0.0254420191,
0.0247934181,
-0.0241683368,
-0.0588843822,
-0.0578746386,
-0.0558886416,
-0.0283270162,
-0.0366583429,
-0.0134470565,
0.0021149206,
-0.0255219955,
-0.0571535714,
-0.0651914328,
0.0493640974,
-0.0021423937,
0.0250861049,
-0.0184816159,
0.0384776257,
0.02301687,
-0.0177820921,
0.0073440936,
-0.0314720571,
0.0341208689,
-0.0442568921,
-0.0669618249,
0.0394758359,
-0.0359758101,
-0.008312678,
0.0164795779,
-0.0634781867,
-0.0760596469,
0.0099116871,
0.0796780363,
0.0262727663,
0.045917362,
0.0032797726,
-0.0210805815,
-0.0216932781,
0.0340055451,
-0.0559698716,
0.029253222,
0.0322130919,
0.0486594178,
0.0056420038,
0.0279319771,
-0.0779440254,
-0.0088502467,
-0.0061696353,
0.0208209399,
-0.0745111033,
-0.0511501022,
0.0094307829,
-0.002870782,
-0.0044595096,
-0.0112460051,
-0.00910665,
-0.0267617013,
-0.0003150505,
-0.0065260413,
0.0135484263,
-0.0718725324,
0.0041168286,
-0.0206327513,
-0.0288754869,
0.0476777665,
0.0259651709,
-0.0230322871,
0.0176644232,
-0.0044837291,
0.0630674362,
0.0160291437,
0.0428311229,
0.0479657203,
0.0154226674,
-0.0138228675,
0.0160933044,
-0.0100632394,
0.0274442267,
0.0011974348,
0.0532843955,
0.0086810775,
0.0064752041,
-0.0129968161,
0.0382011421,
-0.0822324082,
-0.089276351,
0.0319545865,
0.0046127769,
0.046618104,
0.0272834506,
0.0646944344,
-0.0671216846,
0.0159091074,
-0.0047590118,
0.0400897712,
0.0005644636,
-0.0340757519,
0.0278060734,
0.0312447939,
-0.0073467963,
-0.0130557027,
0.0821064785,
-0.0338290781,
0.0850791484,
-0.0032781844,
-0.0011006384,
-0.0472471304,
-0.0486923568,
0.0428083092,
-0.0097342543,
-0.0069712782,
-0.012141387,
-0.0081177922,
-0.039479401,
-0.0412513018,
0.0386223234,
-0.0257407203,
-0.0481027737,
0.042924393,
0.0329916477,
0.0128678754,
-0.0125890104,
-0.0426626652,
-0.0000335636,
-0.0038450386,
-0.0364891626,
-0.0335426703,
-5.826059672e-33,
-0.0321664996,
-0.0430832729,
0.0536244512,
0.0201065335,
-0.0020293561,
-0.0194293,
-0.0679577366,
0.0001590358,
-0.027275268,
-0.0131702349,
0.0127487201,
0.022402158,
0.0022354901,
-0.0179311167,
0.042512428,
0.0021657455,
0.0252317861,
-0.0187481362,
-0.0328287072,
0.0402370207,
0.0286238715,
0.0038681894,
0.0176487919,
-0.0882537141,
0.0071676229,
0.0065300092,
-0.0047850655,
0.008876957,
-0.0408380814,
0.0528933555,
0.0042412719,
0.0253990088,
0.0076777413,
-0.0234430749,
-0.0306782667,
0.0024398426,
-0.0260235369,
-0.0284050927,
0.0008019703,
0.0162920374,
-0.0419189483,
-0.0553964823,
0.0416398086,
-0.0091501065,
-0.0319264792,
0.0042387359,
0.0363761894,
-0.0085282624,
-0.0142277032,
-0.0014601222,
-0.0719949007,
0.0086538028,
-0.0255661923,
-0.0579287708,
0.0029010095,
0.013895411,
-0.0023751089,
0.0204448272,
-0.034921091,
0.0222338848,
0.0188894067,
0.0101939291,
0.0821857974,
0.0127481725,
0.0295838211,
0.0488740429,
0.0383015573,
-0.0005478772,
-0.0011220351,
0.0223975405,
0.0226175319,
0.0667724982,
-0.0031733096,
0.033527337,
-0.0315138474,
0.0038611817,
-0.0260204319,
0.0184440911,
0.0238388199,
0.0549893416,
0.004814317,
0.0391904712,
-0.0236958321,
0.0047573787,
-0.0251633637,
0.0003495751,
-0.0123660294,
-0.0438445732,
0.0258601401,
0.0075182123,
0.0036054086,
-0.0582740903,
0.0257821567,
-0.0305706449,
-0.0110058775,
0.0290365461,
-0.0371419638,
0.0375934802,
0.0069983434,
0.0044705812,
-0.0306945052,
-0.0160404351,
0.0143557722,
-0.0117877461,
0.058233805,
0.0164599475,
-0.0144199952,
0.0649984926,
-0.0416767821,
0.0048580249,
-0.0768061802,
0.0035897819,
0.0086726472,
-0.0019218154,
0.0102237295,
-0.0146432333,
-0.0120430263,
0.0581023544,
-0.0304715242,
-0.0560601912,
-0.0424029455,
-0.0030413927,
-0.0046565807,
-0.0065925703,
-0.0723559782,
-0.0216459967,
-0.0855377764,
0.0516992696,
0.0196656305,
-0.0173544865,
-0.0193331707,
0.001590058,
2.785e-7,
0.0073367544,
0.0357195064,
0.0003544045,
0.0618399233,
0.0232365802,
0.059290804,
-0.0376303196,
0.027052667,
0.0080267005,
-0.0319417268,
-0.0039187642,
0.0410884693,
0.0367242023,
0.0227810387,
-0.05998962,
0.0156415198,
-0.0098559754,
-0.0141984206,
-0.0725527108,
-0.0087069599,
0.0526565984,
0.0824083462,
0.0242839437,
0.0021129972,
0.026269678,
-0.0290495325,
0.0033657607,
-0.0425784513,
0.0283301398,
0.0176113416,
-0.0541737378,
0.0269889757,
-0.0083681643,
-0.0108657628,
-0.007695335,
-0.0063337605,
-0.0584917478,
0.0932579935,
-0.0145502081,
-0.0235325359,
0.0238595996,
-0.0184419416,
0.0053090048,
-0.0555658676,
0.0396023393,
-0.0420318544,
-0.0178001374,
-0.0122015662,
0.0180895142,
0.0047649508,
-0.0330201574,
-0.0260410588,
0.0064004404,
0.0223909374,
-0.0180919375,
-0.0286052972,
-0.0211275872,
-0.0656275526,
-0.0136254514,
-0.0273864362,
-0.0470845029,
-0.0492351055,
-0.0430854522,
-0.0034983046,
-0.0002338593,
-0.0354751535,
-0.0006414867,
2.669465019e-34,
-0.0087938178,
-0.0199528281,
0.0160187483,
0.0717890486,
0.0492796265,
0.0087259216,
-0.017153902,
0.0311688352,
0.052504357,
-0.0531185009,
-0.0256252568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01025v1 | Graph-based Clustering for Detecting Semantic Change Across Time and Languages | 2024-02-01T21:27:19 | 2024-02-01T21:27:19 | Xianghe Ma, Michael Strube, Wei Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the predominance of contextualized embeddings in NLP, approaches to
detect semantic change relying on these embeddings and clustering methods
underperform simpler counterparts based on static word embeddings. This stems
from the poor quality of the clustering methods to produce sense clusters --
which struggle to capture word senses, especially those with low frequency.
This issue hinders the next step in examining how changes in word senses in one
language influence another. To address this issue, we propose a graph-based
clustering approach to capture nuanced changes in both high- and low-frequency
word senses across time and languages, including the acquisition and loss of
these senses over time. Our experimental results show that our approach
substantially surpasses previous approaches in the SemEval2020 binary
classification task across four languages. Moreover, we showcase the ability of
our approach as a versatile visualization tool to detect semantic changes in
both intra-language and inter-language setups. We make our code and data
publicly available. | Graph-based Clustering for Detecting Semantic Change Across Time and Languages: Despite the predominance of contextualized embeddings in NLP, approaches to
detect semantic change relying on these embeddings and clustering methods
underperform simpler counterparts based on static word embeddings. This stems
from the poor quality of the clustering methods to produce sense clusters --
which struggle to capture word senses, especially those with low frequency.
This issue hinders the next step in examining how changes in word senses in one
language influence another. To address this issue, we propose a graph-based
clustering approach to capture nuanced changes in both high- and low-frequency
word senses across time and languages, including the acquisition and loss of
these senses over time. Our experimental results show that our approach
substantially surpasses previous approaches in the SemEval2020 binary
classification task across four languages. Moreover, we showcase the ability of
our approach as a versatile visualization tool to detect semantic changes in
both intra-language and inter-language setups. We make our code and data
publicly available. | [
-0.0366795771,
0.0331198499,
-0.0418890007,
0.0341885425,
-0.0176152047,
-0.012071874,
-0.0337103792,
0.0456400327,
0.0250133835,
-0.0059570149,
0.0161850229,
-0.0024123662,
0.0350418277,
0.0225571003,
0.0285681598,
-0.0270882435,
0.0999894738,
0.0249376167,
-0.0459812507,
0.026407022,
0.0190557931,
-0.0113828294,
-0.0103593161,
0.0077513801,
-0.0337620154,
-0.0262257755,
-0.0271275602,
-0.053582374,
0.0135107934,
-0.0181759242,
-0.0541975647,
0.0591397993,
0.0644520596,
0.07895533,
0.0000016677,
-0.0495197438,
-0.0230473541,
-0.0447964557,
0.0009481958,
0.0334745422,
0.0766673386,
-0.0379431508,
0.0009633664,
-0.0399498157,
-0.0428360812,
-0.0512610488,
0.0318988375,
-0.0400284603,
0.0058300779,
0.014184827,
-0.0111292107,
-0.0000938175,
0.0014593117,
-0.0073831873,
0.0081627406,
0.0167567562,
-0.0094473204,
0.017367119,
-0.0263748262,
-0.0075120255,
-0.0910631344,
0.0060419491,
-0.0260896683,
-0.0162837729,
0.0366399027,
0.0453459248,
0.0072009927,
0.019916296,
0.0065890355,
0.0373755917,
-0.0091120629,
-0.0256329942,
-0.0183675513,
0.0239181966,
-0.0181262586,
-0.0095337909,
-0.0099451393,
-0.0442788377,
0.0256337803,
0.0281726886,
0.0400159582,
-0.0221206881,
0.0515820831,
0.0233550947,
-0.0075336783,
0.0671618506,
0.0296842586,
-0.0199157838,
0.0008939658,
0.0160226729,
0.0119927227,
0.0039681909,
0.0081433477,
0.0054173917,
-0.010221092,
0.0428722873,
0.0092453575,
0.0024009969,
0.0100889625,
-0.0379778109,
-0.0182270724,
-0.0141789392,
-0.0408474356,
0.0478007048,
-0.0362100601,
0.0113126952,
0.0208169874,
-0.0146952635,
-0.0307869986,
0.0061619836,
-0.0653563514,
0.0210081618,
-0.031500522,
0.0013583711,
-0.0304394234,
-0.0207385644,
-0.0393266007,
0.0358709432,
-0.0109711103,
-0.0155041097,
-0.0224485863,
0.0134655852,
-0.0090634087,
0.0569434054,
-0.0176313892,
0.031110324,
-0.050829161,
0.0129705239,
-0.0484639034,
-0.0168492831,
0.0136367353,
0.011749994,
0.0144474935,
-0.0062596183,
-0.0404433496,
0.0427464657,
-0.0087135751,
-0.0006462986,
-0.0615510978,
-0.0375178605,
-0.0425389931,
0.0111372797,
-0.0310076121,
-0.0640706569,
0.0205735471,
-0.0094190137,
0.0221166126,
-0.0471613556,
-0.0138548715,
-0.0401176251,
-0.0444492288,
0.0779232159,
-0.0504136011,
-0.0154301478,
-0.0121735176,
-0.0357042663,
0.0050126943,
0.066075258,
0.0279515013,
-0.0478724912,
0.0828658938,
-0.0051345597,
-0.0898545384,
0.0062805139,
-0.0032297238,
0.0558103286,
-0.0040078913,
-0.0711044595,
0.0120871607,
0.0488145128,
0.0240181126,
0.0067996909,
-0.0486404411,
-0.0566903837,
0.0048937327,
0.0585195348,
0.039565742,
-0.020184774,
0.006783722,
-0.0075390171,
-0.0419683456,
0.001544926,
0.012157294,
-0.0322272182,
-0.0173823442,
-0.0505397394,
-0.0022093754,
-0.010524556,
-0.0160831045,
0.0018984295,
0.0080179702,
0.0151451789,
0.0936374143,
-0.052450873,
0.0570916012,
0.0281690545,
0.0281249005,
0.0282033812,
0.0745415613,
-0.0407973193,
0.0512314066,
0.0126925083,
0.0206313841,
0.0526604839,
0.0272744857,
-0.0215998814,
0.0381856672,
0.0384307578,
-0.0016708525,
-0.0138757331,
0.0115450798,
-0.0416432545,
0.0320252329,
-0.0383241326,
-0.0006195065,
-0.0047591417,
0.0021371329,
0.0161297098,
-0.0016581219,
0.035328716,
-0.0120981475,
-0.1001865789,
0.0075722733,
0.032165572,
0.0204239599,
0.0283346046,
0.0063484856,
0.0220171362,
-0.0036398082,
0.0302656256,
0.0240655635,
-0.0101253036,
0.0196175575,
-0.0145422863,
0.0282361265,
0.0665590614,
-0.0116284275,
-0.0419164635,
0.0516988821,
0.0046962402,
-0.012733385,
-0.035126999,
-0.0478624143,
-0.0053832368,
0.0997163579,
-0.0502111427,
0.0821272209,
-0.0396162085,
0.0049137659,
-0.0423905216,
0.0201159846,
-0.0466923639,
0.0622812696,
-0.0109412726,
0.0113011207,
-0.0428166799,
0.0464745983,
0.0221716408,
-0.0088436445,
-0.0153198428,
0.0425288677,
0.0415378399,
-0.0136230458,
0.0128200026,
-0.0266304538,
-0.0613298081,
0.0658681914,
-0.1043039635,
-0.0298847053,
-0.024141198,
0.0013675673,
0.0469630472,
0.0056615961,
0.019957561,
-0.0346917175,
-0.0102414563,
0.0649182498,
-0.0059551108,
0.052471675,
0.0582267307,
-0.0329755917,
0.0181113463,
-0.037340682,
-0.0268066078,
-0.0369123295,
0.0680574104,
0.0208936483,
-0.0106154904,
-0.0316466205,
-0.0134658534,
-0.0597890802,
0.0200155545,
0.0159836486,
0.0307793468,
0.0141276894,
-0.0271348897,
0.0475737192,
0.0163922682,
0.0012330305,
0.0889093503,
0.0787238106,
-0.0538193397,
-0.0569025762,
-0.0373649821,
-0.0386543684,
0.0368543491,
-0.0414918475,
-0.007090372,
0.0196713954,
0.0144751491,
0.0522714145,
-0.0096319793,
-0.0366041064,
-0.0144373951,
-0.0773982257,
0.0124351354,
-0.0415654331,
0.0103594819,
-0.0223179702,
0.0197997279,
-0.0297263656,
-0.0293283556,
0.0503941029,
0.0222110301,
0.0421524271,
-0.0383539274,
-0.051751364,
-0.03694712,
0.0710940659,
-0.0033867455,
0.0206590686,
-0.032357607,
-0.0370519012,
-0.0623221099,
0.0116002029,
0.0639101118,
-0.0017169197,
0.0427234136,
-0.0729772076,
-0.0026392166,
0.0268837903,
0.0312434807,
0.00992727,
0.0190723594,
-0.0077957795,
0.0193752125,
0.0404276475,
-0.0100599695,
0.0238019787,
0.0197725296,
-0.0140361013,
0.0036572139,
0.0198374595,
-0.0186988059,
0.0038414493,
0.0378030539,
-0.0138844224,
-0.0136160776,
-0.0257126056,
-0.0193329193,
-0.0224350858,
0.0459708609,
-0.0038170402,
-0.0536122918,
-0.090889588,
0.0328067765,
0.0037365875,
-0.0294910539,
0.009163023,
-0.0582776926,
0.0216294825,
-0.0099844085,
-0.0103591383,
0.0404757746,
0.0405045375,
-0.0776138678,
0.054548189,
-0.0057899929,
0.0014927196,
0.0162759684,
-0.0391884968,
-0.0600975491,
-0.0330820046,
-0.0338296741,
0.0001192136,
0.0196915437,
-0.0696146637,
0.0194677804,
-0.0782955214,
-0.0166182499,
0.0228717569,
-0.0699039251,
0.0060205818,
-0.065446049,
0.043900162,
-0.0031403254,
-0.0246752258,
-0.030152617,
0.0203337669,
0.0033257892,
0.0180186182,
-0.0450078882,
-0.0095931841,
0.0212856121,
-0.0300359465,
0.015505285,
0.0200594123,
0.0657585189,
-0.0044999653,
-0.0431207567,
0.0401758887,
-0.012548889,
-0.0178570542,
-0.0461641476,
0.0411009379,
0.0398799255,
0.0096088424,
0.0204635002,
-0.0326838307,
0.0217492655,
-0.0246387217,
0.0268498063,
0.0700536892,
-0.0197324324,
-0.0420508571,
-0.0170802344,
0.004032271,
-0.0186302029,
-0.0174742509,
0.0185346995,
-0.0071047693,
0.0055936226,
0.0052474719,
0.0590822212,
0.0189836845,
-0.0227792636,
-0.051611606,
-0.0505462661,
0.0097587435,
-0.0871298462,
-0.0076053259,
0.0190043896,
-0.0097498279,
0.0316831283,
-0.0011185298,
0.0163811371,
-0.0448482968,
-0.1208460405,
-0.002489001,
-0.0315137357,
0.0281315483,
0.0002625654,
-0.0239909012,
0.0262040868,
0.0459986478,
0.0051656556,
-0.0007269467,
-0.0657768771,
-0.0451592393,
0.0073538767,
-0.0675061718,
0.0034231325,
0.0584497452,
-0.0314787365,
0.0035705834,
0.0550032705,
-0.017734006,
0.0096730851,
0.0222287308,
-0.0427879766,
-0.0004662608,
-0.0068247053,
0.0213566851,
-0.0261056814,
-0.0096486658,
-0.0179468263,
0.0316718444,
-0.0578095615,
-0.0042081964,
0.0093902443,
-0.0082710739,
0.0668367147,
0.0097759711,
-0.0438175574,
-0.048137635,
-0.0526076742,
-0.0029135672,
-0.0235538632,
0.056003198,
-0.0442813374,
0.0120062009,
0.0044392403,
-0.0331607163,
0.0411339104,
-0.0068808007,
0.0163833052,
0.0007160317,
-0.0047983034,
0.0723782852,
0.0213948563,
-0.0029892984,
0.0599190854,
0.0090389382,
-0.0081853187,
-0.0452541597,
-0.0009003799,
-0.0216035862,
0.0140115516,
0.0265833773,
-0.0331993997,
-0.0524642207,
0.0280321687,
-0.0273562819,
0.0348719545,
0.0374953151,
-0.0296994504,
0.032975588,
-0.013941424,
0.0652880669,
-0.0233154055,
-0.0116174547,
-0.0322825573,
0.0207708888,
0.0004127319,
-0.0416255891,
0.0427003726,
0.0084052719,
0.0094999829,
0.0565164909,
0.015739236,
-0.0639200285,
0.0405772887,
-0.0201494936,
-0.0482065156,
0.0002211954,
0.0098507246,
0.001058773,
0.0407400168,
-0.001617886,
0.0215781573,
-0.0545219183,
-0.0461076163,
0.0300785229,
-0.010925795,
0.0090675987,
0.0631824955,
0.0404276177,
0.025907591,
0.0446753278,
0.0416369587,
-0.0567946471,
0.0278808698,
-0.0021265745,
-0.0462207496,
-0.029865155,
-5.832856601e-33,
-0.0018484284,
-0.0414509624,
-0.0257230643,
-0.0081377123,
-0.0565217249,
0.0244726222,
-0.0272176061,
0.0282358676,
-0.0354750231,
0.0400994159,
0.0451605655,
0.0308656078,
-0.0009380548,
-0.0321949422,
0.0335199311,
-0.0018934456,
0.041466359,
0.0134795131,
-0.0006673028,
0.0146876266,
0.0914016515,
-0.0249401163,
0.0830607936,
-0.0151534872,
0.055543419,
0.0823122859,
0.0222869553,
0.0447005369,
0.0304564275,
0.0142862983,
-0.002313846,
0.1099020615,
0.014129662,
0.028838763,
-0.022970302,
-0.0502566397,
-0.0775843859,
-0.0804986209,
0.0147241587,
0.0303935166,
-0.0398306809,
-0.0252667014,
0.0129449302,
0.0024689382,
-0.0008009896,
0.0089300182,
0.061473418,
0.0107971057,
-0.064275369,
0.0069412645,
-0.0342792384,
0.0501224771,
-0.0236801524,
0.0365259759,
0.0004831798,
0.0030541844,
0.0292197186,
-0.0353089385,
-0.0943455845,
0.0736615285,
-0.0431546494,
-0.0139840376,
0.0195168592,
0.0019144509,
0.0033269776,
0.0514669903,
0.0228028223,
-0.0369685553,
0.011798935,
0.0452075563,
0.0857133195,
-0.009199894,
0.0034608054,
0.0337223411,
0.0116297463,
-0.0543652922,
-0.0106468033,
-0.0051318007,
0.0536946729,
0.0492233783,
-0.0070050498,
0.0407723635,
-0.0067894277,
-0.0347948633,
-0.0236365795,
-0.0396466665,
-0.0473456047,
-0.0410108604,
-0.0044920691,
-0.0403103456,
-0.0008834575,
-0.0030996504,
-0.0161657427,
-0.0290504489,
-0.0290964916,
0.015904732,
-0.0164468493,
0.025721848,
0.0316012539,
0.0104669575,
0.0203698985,
-0.0296761971,
0.0321825929,
-0.0045361142,
0.0313142017,
-0.0174324866,
0.0170748495,
-0.0408724509,
-0.0073254262,
0.0068967897,
0.0029730434,
-0.0880036727,
-0.0394604392,
-0.0452283323,
-0.0024459956,
-0.0001691139,
-0.0112858303,
0.0220156536,
0.1004014909,
0.0174603518,
-0.0058067269,
-0.0001045633,
-0.0085991202,
0.0337727778,
-0.0302638058,
-0.0180269349,
0.0006571973,
0.045468729,
0.044865571,
-0.0427800454,
-0.0270759538,
-0.0177897681,
2.57e-7,
0.0747569576,
0.0683428794,
0.0237748828,
0.0040805074,
0.0281642117,
-0.0121807856,
-0.0378827378,
0.0289793126,
-0.0231829938,
0.023673512,
-0.00248157,
0.0325505771,
0.0129486034,
0.0627931431,
-0.0012702174,
0.017942654,
-0.0035864105,
-0.0069420678,
-0.0605027713,
0.0102527672,
0.0492464192,
0.0361128226,
0.0309152361,
-0.0012824289,
-0.0268425159,
-0.027649818,
0.0321069732,
-0.0059967889,
0.0106669068,
-0.0459619239,
-0.0381405614,
0.0030035274,
0.0337636322,
0.0213372167,
-0.0272703934,
-0.0155621525,
0.0004653176,
-0.0444053784,
-0.0542217977,
0.0068716356,
-0.0131206298,
0.0193682648,
0.0262636356,
-0.0142115522,
0.0499820746,
-0.0081421286,
0.0013980527,
-0.0197150316,
-0.0259087626,
0.0409103036,
0.0541541688,
-0.0020867866,
-0.0915404484,
0.0350282006,
0.0130901504,
0.0370754078,
-0.0591382757,
-0.0577638745,
-0.0023688725,
0.0369309522,
0.0170974508,
-0.0508905128,
0.0309321936,
-0.01643591,
-0.0089857178,
0.0110023292,
0.034416426,
1.6185252e-34,
0.0105614131,
0.0454139002,
0.0117609408,
-0.0154086845,
0.0180489719,
-0.0576959029,
0.028218627,
-0.0085998466,
0.0283994805,
-0.0309528857,
-0.0120589947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01019v1 | Domain-Independent Deception: A New Taxonomy and Linguistic Analysis | 2024-02-01T21:13:04 | 2024-02-01T21:13:04 | Rakesh M. Verma, Nachum Dershowitz, Victor Zeng, Dainis Boumber, Xuting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY | Internet-based economies and societies are drowning in deceptive attacks.
These attacks take many forms, such as fake news, phishing, and job scams,
which we call ``domains of deception.'' Machine-learning and
natural-language-processing researchers have been attempting to ameliorate this
precarious situation by designing domain-specific detectors. Only a few recent
works have considered domain-independent deception. We collect these disparate
threads of research and investigate domain-independent deception. First, we
provide a new computational definition of deception and break down deception
into a new taxonomy. Then, we analyze the debate on linguistic cues for
deception and supply guidelines for systematic reviews. Finally, we investigate
common linguistic features and give evidence for knowledge transfer across
different forms of deception. | Domain-Independent Deception: A New Taxonomy and Linguistic Analysis: Internet-based economies and societies are drowning in deceptive attacks.
These attacks take many forms, such as fake news, phishing, and job scams,
which we call ``domains of deception.'' Machine-learning and
natural-language-processing researchers have been attempting to ameliorate this
precarious situation by designing domain-specific detectors. Only a few recent
works have considered domain-independent deception. We collect these disparate
threads of research and investigate domain-independent deception. First, we
provide a new computational definition of deception and break down deception
into a new taxonomy. Then, we analyze the debate on linguistic cues for
deception and supply guidelines for systematic reviews. Finally, we investigate
common linguistic features and give evidence for knowledge transfer across
different forms of deception. | [
0.0710611492,
0.039401073,
-0.0696734414,
0.0606088974,
-0.0732681304,
0.004124844,
0.0457280874,
0.0335257128,
0.0140959835,
-0.0367669016,
-0.0245578568,
-0.0174279828,
0.0601102002,
0.0477230959,
0.0560732782,
-0.0202919971,
0.0317091979,
0.0113411704,
0.0402120575,
-0.0053487369,
0.0223513432,
0.0236662515,
-0.0041211192,
0.0364160873,
-0.0233385488,
-0.029653132,
0.02458225,
-0.0281581059,
0.0257198159,
-0.0078649968,
0.0361925885,
0.0427789092,
0.0071534738,
0.0650515705,
0.0000019847,
-0.0612355992,
-0.000008667,
-0.0190486088,
-0.0708480924,
0.028326381,
0.0707672611,
-0.0398255885,
-0.0027606047,
0.0079791714,
-0.0248567667,
0.0005046186,
0.0366448648,
0.0877583027,
0.067878142,
0.0889112353,
-0.0077413758,
-0.0041125808,
0.008731666,
-0.0051566055,
-0.0167588554,
-0.0003933986,
0.0620403364,
-0.0640635639,
-0.0572873875,
0.0069715763,
-0.0092234891,
-0.0329029597,
-0.0457342379,
-0.0057938402,
-0.0468912609,
0.018536957,
-0.0305818934,
-0.0281258207,
-0.0044063451,
0.0096601089,
-0.0039295522,
-0.0135748517,
0.0076283198,
0.0098086968,
0.0233755726,
0.0474002622,
0.0297650322,
0.0456691049,
-0.0306508914,
-0.0344774239,
-0.0136785805,
0.0166602787,
0.043236088,
0.0361124389,
0.0255301371,
0.0280461386,
-0.0165557228,
-0.0314962417,
0.0195278097,
-0.0304625221,
0.0089697177,
-0.0686358139,
-0.018077964,
-0.0025670989,
-0.0193465278,
0.0053234394,
-0.0467401035,
-0.0034773543,
0.0460957699,
-0.0692504644,
0.0149037866,
-0.0103269517,
-0.0058755833,
0.002883886,
0.0256865919,
0.0383370481,
-0.0241197851,
0.0085524246,
-0.0397305153,
0.0144041851,
0.0039545819,
-0.0140932966,
0.0157117303,
0.0212884042,
0.0406617336,
0.0069370493,
-0.0998671278,
-0.0064315698,
-0.0810612068,
0.002832297,
-0.0364887938,
0.0166481808,
-0.0297674704,
-0.0198436715,
-0.0298276134,
0.0261833686,
0.0089205867,
0.0415548012,
-0.0260839052,
-0.0624520145,
0.0008637491,
0.0292903613,
-0.0343520716,
0.0043174471,
-0.0121399127,
0.039766252,
0.0388199203,
-0.023361126,
-0.0522055067,
-0.0406308956,
-0.0768091008,
-0.0415674224,
-0.0079728607,
-0.0391894616,
-0.0171590988,
-0.0232112147,
-0.0145810824,
-0.0554131046,
-0.0056942562,
0.0208201539,
-0.060702309,
0.0445547327,
-0.0359159149,
0.0013820765,
0.0547181629,
0.0045815371,
-0.0440848432,
0.0338056125,
-0.018121589,
0.0992264524,
0.0686637238,
0.0117366575,
0.046509631,
-0.0007970523,
0.0203881841,
-0.0005285261,
0.0549431406,
-0.0076070088,
0.0134979226,
-0.0244050138,
-0.0113857649,
-0.0063480446,
-0.0249568503,
-0.0221899971,
0.079729721,
0.0178404804,
-0.0214289483,
0.007656849,
0.0405078419,
0.0457544774,
-0.0069224699,
0.0087988107,
-0.0442499928,
-0.032340467,
-0.0787293315,
-0.0166074056,
-0.0426044539,
0.0182742123,
0.0251951478,
-0.0477718562,
-0.0282325614,
-0.0236438401,
-0.0012381267,
-0.0036889021,
0.0015296699,
0.0304647032,
-0.0144451139,
0.0014320677,
0.0415436476,
0.0175421312,
-0.0093214344,
-0.0422457978,
-0.0111145489,
0.0312100761,
-0.002575509,
0.0480958521,
0.0133364024,
-0.0566001832,
0.0025318523,
0.035461165,
0.0048449421,
0.008262529,
-0.0158490427,
0.0153083801,
-0.0215260237,
-0.0326602869,
-0.0034646522,
0.0104210535,
-0.0163098313,
0.029043179,
0.0259529222,
-0.016663257,
0.0428586192,
0.0264775567,
0.0186068192,
-0.0078427354,
-0.0074789915,
0.0452443771,
0.0515362024,
-0.0091648586,
0.0083351564,
-0.0072754878,
0.0339157395,
-0.0111175049,
-0.0496131815,
-0.0268204715,
0.0409195758,
0.0188812912,
-0.0035862839,
-0.0697308704,
-0.0163307842,
0.0139996381,
0.0035997648,
0.033178784,
0.0640802011,
-0.0407452621,
-0.0100762276,
-0.0230039787,
-0.0002045046,
-0.0333523527,
0.0532444194,
-0.0006397607,
0.0943672508,
-0.0308853183,
0.0048335451,
-0.0395250581,
-0.0481606573,
-0.0074332054,
0.0082613584,
0.0468890183,
-0.0401247665,
-0.0135425562,
-0.011139866,
0.045005016,
0.0060071042,
-0.0232213102,
-0.014862013,
-0.047162246,
-0.0642429963,
-0.0018624829,
-0.0093689458,
0.0097422944,
-0.0167942792,
-0.0056951428,
0.035503637,
-0.0077227009,
-0.00340098,
-0.0075522307,
-0.0011561826,
0.0262484141,
-0.0318211056,
-0.0331809409,
0.0275334995,
0.0277183317,
-0.0273581818,
0.0398823358,
0.0109757241,
-0.0551885217,
-0.0581537113,
-0.0217636395,
-0.0441344418,
0.0174988247,
-0.0140103465,
-0.0229176953,
-0.0281712078,
0.0308732521,
-0.0544977672,
0.0002453716,
0.0791611075,
0.0546800494,
-0.0000832277,
0.0397900864,
-0.0198112093,
-0.0304429159,
-0.0292787831,
0.0399757996,
-0.0207720716,
-0.0611456782,
0.0599956326,
0.0491974093,
0.0586712323,
0.0038912082,
-0.0028469956,
0.0594230108,
-0.0398722962,
-0.0577682406,
0.023634648,
-0.0655692369,
-0.012869739,
0.0452805758,
0.0161262471,
-0.0514249094,
0.1025350168,
-0.0253808163,
0.0281534605,
-0.013667102,
-0.0067252126,
0.0259855613,
-0.0130256992,
-0.0144254286,
0.0364444442,
0.1332314014,
-0.0263960827,
0.0171118379,
-0.0120976139,
0.060148783,
-0.0075812498,
0.004836685,
-0.0151494714,
0.0195422638,
0.0425254144,
-0.0424664728,
-0.0720643029,
-0.0811225995,
0.0069268807,
-0.0442291163,
-0.0041787522,
-0.0127940783,
-0.0772241428,
-0.0759966522,
-0.0211788788,
-0.0429329723,
-0.0014979407,
-0.0242751725,
-0.0081674373,
0.0059651122,
0.0197854005,
-0.0127553958,
0.0492543019,
-0.0181572139,
-0.0444083251,
0.0380622298,
-0.0462182723,
0.0074908584,
0.030989917,
-0.0012865989,
0.0279357322,
-0.0206556842,
0.023135541,
0.0093977125,
-0.0549032465,
0.0051364098,
0.007765179,
0.0581426956,
0.0083249416,
0.0049396032,
0.0160873234,
0.0034837967,
0.0017502112,
0.012262688,
-0.0289994348,
-0.0845704526,
-0.0059850635,
0.0035346779,
0.0077793864,
-0.0689768717,
-0.0039281226,
-0.0228563622,
-0.0822639093,
0.0461033247,
0.0113034109,
-0.0371330716,
-0.0376055725,
-0.0275607239,
-0.0359446071,
0.0352390446,
0.0369468629,
-0.0408474728,
-0.0114952717,
-0.0266653765,
-0.0122538637,
-0.0362124257,
-0.0455685481,
-0.0177228358,
0.0028231535,
0.0435004607,
0.0365347937,
0.0474240482,
-0.0109088235,
-0.0567151085,
-0.0198912453,
0.0052609863,
-0.0272094589,
-0.0108556086,
0.0958954021,
-0.026941197,
-0.0035055643,
-0.0044865115,
0.0147436485,
-0.0301974528,
-0.0081769191,
0.0097421193,
0.0534832478,
0.0042264867,
-0.0836688653,
0.004030006,
-0.0126797101,
0.0568801649,
0.0361253843,
-0.0391015373,
0.0237918776,
-0.0160851814,
-0.035137888,
0.0114422143,
0.0751478747,
-0.0578535236,
0.0683465302,
0.0207199641,
-0.0371587053,
-0.0524545871,
-0.0131346704,
-0.0237941984,
-0.022295313,
0.043618422,
-0.0186524168,
0.040176861,
0.0064323279,
-0.0703752488,
-0.0015093014,
-0.0426295772,
0.0666525513,
-0.0310222115,
0.0220428705,
0.0023656089,
-0.0601713993,
0.0354502648,
0.010702936,
-0.0256874971,
-0.0036629869,
0.0254663881,
0.0140697183,
0.015260363,
0.0381976739,
-0.0337751508,
0.0016825608,
0.0307302531,
0.0044871522,
-0.0602191873,
0.0093418993,
0.072070241,
-0.0070332414,
0.0066294046,
0.0169369746,
0.0007718506,
0.0517274775,
0.0283890571,
-0.0359723493,
-0.0195082035,
0.0052416278,
0.0728538781,
0.0007900392,
0.0683114082,
-0.0074490709,
0.0565532818,
0.0081914868,
-0.0199937895,
0.0021032507,
-0.0305319466,
-0.010417386,
-0.0478892922,
0.0386936702,
0.0524645112,
0.0212131608,
0.0130921695,
-0.0735060945,
-0.0330439024,
-0.0067011141,
-0.0090443306,
0.0379022025,
0.0554834418,
0.0060470114,
0.0000145118,
0.0171847995,
0.0412329212,
0.0103991134,
0.0430808999,
0.015882995,
0.0092236698,
0.0164463446,
-0.0225361008,
-0.0341045484,
-0.0182214342,
0.0046570208,
-0.0008189488,
0.005702029,
0.0048233876,
0.0097712958,
-0.0052653407,
0.0075915088,
0.0082164193,
0.0018769242,
0.0175774097,
-0.0156113999,
-0.0280247498,
-0.0569218062,
0.008372427,
-0.0100028384,
-0.038831614,
0.025281664,
0.0610874295,
-0.0145810815,
0.0174644757,
-0.0349680074,
-0.0600226745,
-0.0131161483,
-0.0481502004,
0.0118632969,
0.0368153118,
0.000922051,
-0.0178476349,
-0.1033626869,
-0.072847344,
0.0139620602,
-0.0519068763,
0.0517960675,
-0.0101545639,
-0.0109160151,
0.0865505636,
0.0088427439,
0.020352181,
-0.0790240616,
0.0303195622,
0.0072583808,
-0.0043981099,
-0.0132962773,
-6.13983695e-33,
0.0409571342,
-0.0767935365,
-0.0334876254,
0.0282407496,
0.01206306,
0.0381394587,
0.0258541424,
-0.0163652189,
-0.0037850568,
0.0626183823,
-0.011674487,
0.0235708021,
-0.0030976171,
0.0088559026,
-0.0463282131,
0.0132540008,
0.0235137232,
-0.0066619501,
-0.032421343,
-0.0169000924,
0.0399284028,
-0.007460102,
0.0577036403,
-0.0853748769,
0.0859833136,
0.0098065045,
-0.0598282441,
0.0290980525,
-0.0009253709,
0.0212479513,
-0.0105083343,
0.0531653576,
0.027555842,
-0.0349506959,
0.0139362579,
0.0317297317,
-0.0006708986,
-0.0295207892,
0.0617894679,
0.005311897,
0.0162665565,
-0.0154883927,
0.0306051802,
-0.0345218182,
-0.0556661747,
0.0237022638,
0.0280877519,
-0.009021054,
0.0058486369,
-0.0294332784,
-0.0662350506,
-0.0227582045,
-0.0093556596,
0.0110368952,
0.0037652415,
0.0949729159,
0.0066402392,
-0.0112041952,
-0.0916035026,
0.0529962443,
-0.0221348535,
-0.0194468852,
0.0253066383,
-0.0291504152,
-0.0304060299,
0.0752010643,
0.0298645161,
0.017253967,
-0.0106178513,
0.0342216231,
-0.0017772979,
0.0463177301,
0.0522417426,
0.0681047887,
-0.0101136994,
-0.0575994849,
-0.0405033417,
-0.0151038086,
0.0270988792,
-0.0194377135,
0.017544521,
-0.04042501,
-0.0436172932,
-0.0295272749,
-0.0118970368,
0.017556414,
-0.0487430692,
0.0175016802,
0.0246012062,
0.0019978581,
-0.0319519415,
0.0140484897,
-0.0064924061,
-0.0888383538,
-0.0105373273,
-0.0000474595,
0.0315624177,
-0.0152024738,
0.03607044,
0.001453713,
-0.0102177458,
-0.033939071,
-0.0007857839,
0.0053315777,
0.0479263216,
-0.0544331856,
0.0347472988,
-0.0153703047,
-0.0195313208,
-0.021356253,
0.0067429096,
0.0365404263,
0.0131765092,
-0.0032195593,
0.0376051441,
0.0119990874,
-0.0254097953,
-0.0352901556,
0.0410700962,
-0.0072585978,
-0.0326717198,
0.0687072277,
-0.0301195532,
0.0446081571,
-0.0565454103,
-0.0388402455,
-0.0277103819,
0.0220646504,
0.0294437874,
-0.0566167533,
-0.0327601358,
-0.050397303,
2.815e-7,
-0.0262960885,
0.0498203523,
-0.0640909821,
0.0290241763,
0.021688642,
0.0941316932,
0.0353340879,
0.0247498844,
0.025506271,
-0.052142866,
-0.0363910943,
-0.0174369887,
0.0203862805,
0.00307168,
-0.0669302642,
0.0232885517,
0.0226455964,
-0.0187626164,
-0.0257091448,
0.0083158119,
0.0203962047,
0.0619424917,
0.049704317,
-0.0641150996,
-0.0234879069,
0.0176596567,
-0.0073024994,
0.0090150395,
-0.0063126734,
0.02705447,
0.0101454323,
-0.0379328281,
-0.0015159622,
0.0548076592,
-0.0262727626,
0.0137919541,
-0.0305741541,
0.0273095462,
0.0067740264,
0.0278536621,
-0.0463386811,
-0.0496028513,
0.039034985,
-0.0477020033,
0.0245710667,
-0.0392873697,
-0.0462993383,
-0.0627442226,
-0.0295832418,
-0.0228702705,
0.0380865447,
0.0104030641,
-0.0436347015,
0.0546707623,
0.0266447235,
0.0392464995,
0.0198775064,
-0.0127549507,
0.0305788238,
0.0108884918,
0.001988553,
-0.0045578433,
0.029622063,
0.0359616876,
0.0654218867,
-0.033296112,
0.0396544077,
2.424240137e-34,
0.0056974641,
-0.0197788421,
0.016368879,
-0.0063898102,
0.0439810492,
0.0109763397,
0.0184406247,
0.0186721142,
-0.0071417452,
0.0209335107,
0.0098544015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01018v1 | HR-MultiWOZ: A Task Oriented Dialogue (TOD) Dataset for HR LLM Agent | 2024-02-01T21:10:44 | 2024-02-01T21:10:44 | Weijie Xu, Zicheng Huang, Wenxiang Hu, Xi Fang, Rajesh Kumar Cherukuri, Naumaan Nayyar, Lorenzo Malandri, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have been reshaping
Natural Language Processing (NLP) task in several domains. Their use in the
field of Human Resources (HR) has still room for expansions and could be
beneficial for several time consuming tasks. Examples such as time-off
submissions, medical claims filing, and access requests are noteworthy, but
they are by no means the sole instances. However, the aforementioned
developments must grapple with the pivotal challenge of constructing a
high-quality training dataset. On one hand, most conversation datasets are
solving problems for customers not employees. On the other hand, gathering
conversations with HR could raise privacy concerns. To solve it, we introduce
HR-Multiwoz, a fully-labeled dataset of 550 conversations spanning 10 HR
domains to evaluate LLM Agent. Our work has the following contributions: (1) It
is the first labeled open-sourced conversation dataset in the HR domain for NLP
research. (2) It provides a detailed recipe for the data generation procedure
along with data analysis and human evaluations. The data generation pipeline is
transferable and can be easily adapted for labeled conversation data generation
in other domains. (3) The proposed data-collection pipeline is mostly based on
LLMs with minimal human involvement for annotation, which is time and
cost-efficient. | HR-MultiWOZ: A Task Oriented Dialogue (TOD) Dataset for HR LLM Agent: Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have been reshaping
Natural Language Processing (NLP) task in several domains. Their use in the
field of Human Resources (HR) has still room for expansions and could be
beneficial for several time consuming tasks. Examples such as time-off
submissions, medical claims filing, and access requests are noteworthy, but
they are by no means the sole instances. However, the aforementioned
developments must grapple with the pivotal challenge of constructing a
high-quality training dataset. On one hand, most conversation datasets are
solving problems for customers not employees. On the other hand, gathering
conversations with HR could raise privacy concerns. To solve it, we introduce
HR-Multiwoz, a fully-labeled dataset of 550 conversations spanning 10 HR
domains to evaluate LLM Agent. Our work has the following contributions: (1) It
is the first labeled open-sourced conversation dataset in the HR domain for NLP
research. (2) It provides a detailed recipe for the data generation procedure
along with data analysis and human evaluations. The data generation pipeline is
transferable and can be easily adapted for labeled conversation data generation
in other domains. (3) The proposed data-collection pipeline is mostly based on
LLMs with minimal human involvement for annotation, which is time and
cost-efficient. | [
0.085756816,
0.0444417819,
-0.0121942125,
0.0079494519,
-0.052069854,
0.0192118194,
0.024360748,
-0.0191122014,
0.0483096279,
-0.0570917167,
-0.0464067049,
-0.0304775368,
-0.0124584176,
0.0039391434,
0.0125527633,
-0.0386088192,
0.0192349106,
0.0209591612,
0.0272957478,
0.0248051863,
0.0049397754,
0.039146848,
-0.0234328397,
0.0600359887,
-0.0084438324,
-0.0193926245,
-0.0050068959,
0.0036936025,
0.0299595967,
-0.0000671669,
0.0339739285,
0.055096399,
0.0374789573,
-0.0107934065,
0.0000017491,
-0.071971029,
0.0056032864,
0.0027001817,
-0.0522199012,
-0.0549566746,
0.04772361,
-0.0285585374,
-0.0042852056,
0.0368420146,
-0.041009333,
0.0089537287,
-0.0142645938,
0.0943050385,
0.0769114196,
0.0882036462,
-0.0138445655,
-0.0008358718,
-0.0084320679,
-0.0420124009,
0.0112048509,
-0.0725152269,
0.0357869603,
-0.003652849,
-0.0118914833,
0.0163582191,
0.0512129366,
-0.0176417548,
-0.0134998355,
-0.0365830436,
0.014438631,
-0.0028045611,
-0.025961332,
-0.0233871527,
-0.0188450925,
0.0929462612,
0.0365490951,
0.0324485563,
0.0084552877,
-0.0004740004,
0.038489785,
-0.0181992408,
-0.0268447027,
0.0468912162,
-0.0235005766,
-0.0086148055,
-0.0183977075,
0.0097134598,
-0.0193585884,
0.0098270522,
0.0361659154,
0.0325451791,
-0.0215417687,
-0.0354525074,
0.0305622257,
0.0108499937,
0.0433569849,
-0.0510583296,
0.0100070508,
0.015431379,
-0.0358012915,
0.0308390707,
-0.0444657467,
0.0182228182,
0.0525362454,
-0.0912118256,
0.0055063437,
0.0067995945,
0.0085306074,
0.0362216793,
0.0161838923,
0.0115938541,
0.0022708999,
-0.0102696056,
-0.0115064019,
-0.0362856798,
-0.075852409,
0.0054895012,
-0.0339535847,
0.02816239,
-0.0467741229,
-0.0042334418,
-0.0637172982,
0.0350773633,
-0.0269926954,
0.0172781423,
0.0123304175,
0.0059307911,
-0.0144448597,
0.0209454205,
-0.0696484372,
-0.0252779126,
-0.0096165566,
0.0401553437,
0.0069829877,
-0.068446584,
-0.0027318911,
0.0188656021,
0.0163534787,
-0.0073207067,
-0.0154668177,
0.0651981831,
0.0142301042,
-0.042744644,
-0.036059767,
-0.0400663689,
0.0013331193,
-0.0419092104,
-0.0106291063,
-0.0315106772,
0.0704356283,
-0.0370479487,
-0.0211215205,
-0.0404142067,
0.0409775972,
0.0666667446,
-0.0263698641,
0.0471534543,
-0.0303606521,
0.0155660016,
0.0388757139,
0.0192322023,
0.00172083,
0.0597863607,
0.0320861489,
0.0162371174,
0.0720099434,
-0.0092262393,
0.0074532507,
0.0303423237,
0.0119199185,
-0.0081778737,
0.0583268441,
0.0641651154,
-0.0039173025,
0.0566469878,
0.0131849926,
0.042956125,
-0.0440123305,
-0.006553276,
0.0219130702,
0.0575619079,
-0.0124530951,
0.0188020766,
0.0270011816,
0.0700361505,
-0.0132761374,
-0.0241678786,
-0.0348317288,
-0.0162433945,
-0.0226319134,
-0.043358162,
0.0107222572,
-0.0120058935,
-0.0556671135,
-0.0380233228,
-0.0023753254,
-0.0117379138,
0.0034857804,
-0.0025868618,
0.0225597229,
0.0427865013,
-0.0635201558,
0.0614377297,
0.0261223726,
-0.0446786769,
-0.0398292243,
-0.0395584889,
0.0063810311,
0.0793527737,
0.0469849482,
-0.0325896628,
-0.0214984026,
-0.0803698078,
0.020660378,
0.0682050884,
0.0564292558,
-0.0181008447,
0.0156172756,
-0.0512167066,
-0.0238432214,
-0.0140146958,
-0.0030210228,
-0.0190870017,
0.0179628208,
-0.0222376361,
0.0286663361,
0.0037638212,
-0.0623105802,
0.0346143506,
-0.015838135,
-0.0088043176,
0.0547423214,
0.0096264491,
0.0308548156,
0.0589220673,
0.0062896102,
0.0038412246,
0.0173797645,
-0.0213935785,
-0.0398609601,
0.005053319,
-0.0064583346,
-0.0461975373,
0.0290769506,
-0.0047292761,
-0.0314019993,
0.0408218093,
-0.0356371179,
-0.0210596547,
-0.0305848997,
-0.0254086237,
0.0045290221,
-0.0458675735,
0.0070189675,
0.0154204322,
0.0291520432,
-0.0257786158,
0.0595712066,
-0.0184057169,
0.0012259837,
-0.0147855971,
-0.0176407732,
0.0177945215,
-0.0736441016,
0.0105335591,
0.0073851901,
0.0107044708,
0.0054146349,
0.0197192952,
0.0091206646,
-0.0767805725,
-0.0282422099,
-0.099206157,
0.0085799424,
-0.0028748508,
0.0197300557,
-0.0075500184,
-0.0179480109,
-0.0020922543,
-0.0289481468,
-0.0453010388,
-0.0183932576,
0.0506946146,
0.0058325971,
0.0769331753,
0.004453091,
-0.021975223,
-0.0224031862,
-0.0116212815,
-0.0091016451,
0.0121378833,
0.0124943256,
-0.0127548175,
-0.0425739177,
0.0693077222,
-0.0343156196,
0.0202260036,
-0.0151541978,
-0.0022906314,
0.0157193113,
0.0340267159,
0.0217914488,
0.0304488894,
0.0332982056,
0.0314798877,
-0.0295092501,
-0.0013553678,
-0.0247555505,
0.0182967428,
-0.0291649234,
0.0050876248,
-0.0608152337,
-0.041316431,
0.0350195207,
0.016706828,
0.0084552607,
0.0111592617,
-0.0321403965,
-0.0031158822,
0.0069247507,
-0.013782097,
-0.0250112917,
-0.0049650888,
-0.0214494951,
0.0335000977,
0.002608336,
-0.0280331429,
0.046506051,
-0.0094036106,
0.019695295,
-0.052674979,
-0.0347948931,
-0.0682130009,
0.0781862661,
-0.0360299349,
0.0033189785,
0.0180910788,
-0.0426713191,
0.012502105,
-0.0212373491,
0.0145053128,
-0.0411968194,
0.0120994672,
-0.0201765578,
0.0062926156,
-0.0129325166,
-0.0503074639,
-0.0616547838,
-0.048647061,
-0.0224441849,
0.0097207669,
-0.0127742179,
0.015978571,
-0.072054252,
-0.0329601131,
-0.0139087951,
0.0171627104,
0.0266668275,
-0.0114342328,
-0.0165200382,
0.0262249541,
0.0435247496,
0.0398852453,
-0.0008374999,
0.0000929537,
0.0584614314,
0.0505346693,
0.0533397719,
-0.0063340752,
0.0318918861,
-0.0457876399,
0.006077237,
-0.0430058464,
0.015092358,
-0.0240670424,
0.0387825109,
-0.037498571,
0.012393998,
0.1003045887,
0.0140346019,
-0.0407453328,
-0.0080846408,
-0.0218652338,
-0.014964059,
0.0136719877,
0.0193098392,
-0.06272953,
-0.0371460393,
-0.0235192869,
0.0106602199,
-0.0549545288,
-0.0825243071,
0.0015499735,
-0.1190874353,
0.0366888382,
-0.0393883921,
0.022979416,
-0.011961001,
-0.0285911597,
-0.0068755285,
-0.0120141488,
0.0284284595,
-0.0326521061,
-0.0141402325,
-0.0404647402,
0.0214273855,
-0.0222093742,
-0.0476403795,
0.0692313164,
-0.033914011,
0.0407549515,
0.0417593829,
0.0610086359,
0.0206340812,
-0.0076153493,
0.0387088209,
0.0214445814,
-0.0017329896,
0.0141337989,
0.0709470883,
-0.0420589186,
-0.0057033836,
-0.0517246649,
0.0570261441,
-0.0614780746,
-0.000119449,
0.0338433571,
0.052129522,
-0.0493598022,
0.0330557078,
-0.002583904,
0.0287560225,
0.028623037,
0.0768168569,
-0.0039449437,
-0.05100495,
0.0011566926,
0.0047848863,
-0.0098058088,
-0.0232313424,
-0.0070886691,
0.0132503798,
-0.0178049076,
0.0278076772,
-0.0481503271,
-0.066232264,
0.0438718311,
-0.0044703903,
0.0094431741,
-0.0062919655,
0.0141394865,
0.0143276844,
-0.0412637107,
0.0282501876,
-0.0411892496,
0.0462646708,
-0.0413019396,
-0.0292647798,
0.0400629938,
-0.0062688263,
-0.0161254182,
0.0518676825,
-0.0839528814,
-0.0379172675,
-0.0550678037,
0.0200560018,
0.0170687586,
0.0491693281,
0.0114547685,
-0.0192923415,
-0.0173726622,
0.0231377333,
-0.0887905508,
-0.0062057422,
0.0148225175,
0.0698473081,
-0.0131951738,
0.0593116172,
-0.0381671749,
0.0108173629,
-0.0045939521,
0.0207808167,
-0.0172437392,
-0.0669883937,
-0.0064121746,
-0.0069217905,
0.0117336111,
0.0432205684,
-0.0025979332,
-0.0700638145,
0.023454668,
-0.0324445814,
-0.037504375,
-0.0498056263,
0.0227116905,
0.0013816562,
-0.0329835154,
0.0148970578,
0.012591267,
-0.0739473924,
0.0278878268,
-0.0420162082,
0.0288726892,
0.0093201213,
-0.0106385881,
-0.0220567901,
-0.0243056212,
-0.0307951868,
0.0180618782,
-0.0038613004,
0.0235269517,
0.0345151015,
0.0652399957,
0.0161168016,
0.0149639454,
0.0286362935,
0.0213219784,
-0.0316203162,
-0.0416884795,
0.0045935786,
-0.0021027699,
0.0104493657,
0.0247419085,
0.0559539869,
-0.022398835,
0.0055875541,
0.002249765,
0.0547521859,
-0.0298116561,
-0.0096136481,
0.0597389936,
0.0092000701,
-0.0456045456,
-0.0050907801,
0.0630422309,
0.0191202387,
0.0276174638,
-0.023686422,
-0.0214947164,
-0.074579522,
-0.0467701517,
0.0470781513,
0.0220806729,
0.0002861875,
-0.0133555979,
-0.0580896772,
-0.033239428,
-0.0054152631,
-0.0220706835,
-0.012585015,
-0.0097529162,
0.0418004543,
0.0454661548,
0.0072339601,
-0.0300436988,
-0.0769834444,
-0.0049844249,
-0.0063305618,
-0.005404334,
-0.006960528,
-5.251072855e-33,
-0.0124746654,
-0.0244417004,
0.0282698888,
0.0292733777,
-0.023991419,
-0.0049509848,
0.0222229585,
-0.013919414,
-0.0418486297,
-0.008256278,
-0.016368052,
0.0383498259,
0.0135157183,
0.0401512198,
-0.000084688,
-0.0049476242,
0.0488112494,
-0.0341413133,
-0.0027952979,
0.0437998027,
0.0242802631,
0.0384885073,
0.0607501417,
-0.0588238761,
0.0464656129,
-0.0135424584,
-0.0192778166,
0.063214004,
0.0273941718,
0.05533088,
-0.0428381935,
0.063373819,
0.0272990633,
-0.035873346,
0.0235554818,
0.0631322861,
-0.05745719,
-0.022756638,
0.0341428779,
0.0112175895,
-0.0169511419,
-0.0356279723,
0.0116178039,
-0.0047487337,
0.01160884,
0.0053029605,
0.0307071079,
-0.0361250639,
-0.0083562089,
-0.0028099066,
-0.046895504,
0.0424595997,
-0.0125564346,
-0.0459821597,
-0.0210571997,
0.0422168076,
-0.0206749476,
-0.0094835889,
-0.0826871991,
0.0209267214,
-0.0042498391,
-0.0424365103,
-0.0032429672,
-0.009590975,
0.0159369558,
0.0702439845,
0.0441859253,
0.0673292652,
-0.019513825,
0.0052505252,
-0.0452814065,
0.0659143925,
-0.0340753049,
0.0220951159,
-0.043237403,
-0.0185969044,
-0.0526580811,
0.0230428502,
0.0235650372,
0.0167822074,
0.0336179584,
-0.0215775575,
-0.0415188968,
-0.0060367426,
-0.0056499769,
0.0089606224,
-0.0007684338,
-0.0055465982,
0.0211469457,
0.0353512317,
0.0142715778,
0.0164174922,
-0.0069454354,
-0.044954285,
0.0071154516,
0.0238362923,
-0.0236527752,
-0.0328454748,
-0.0065863407,
-0.0487015955,
-0.0933840796,
-0.031785883,
0.0119263781,
0.0106042186,
0.0260102525,
0.0050523919,
0.0230221823,
-0.0299111847,
-0.0537144206,
-0.0018053496,
-0.0240664836,
0.0767041668,
-0.0532791689,
0.0563608706,
-0.0049683172,
0.011841069,
-0.0210150518,
0.1195071414,
0.0051476406,
-0.0057821199,
-0.0307255071,
0.0156132262,
0.0371533781,
0.0155887287,
-0.0052847443,
-0.0130607812,
0.0132603692,
0.0203098655,
0.0503048599,
-0.0069196331,
0.0137325637,
-0.0156623069,
2.454e-7,
0.0012021112,
0.0154884905,
0.0179281291,
0.019487638,
0.0332815014,
0.0531939454,
0.0057263062,
0.0563492402,
-0.006790447,
-0.0072411411,
0.0149670867,
-0.009045111,
0.0625593439,
0.0176391248,
-0.0801085606,
-0.0867239386,
0.0013565901,
-0.0611171946,
-0.0565206893,
0.0021671013,
0.0959580541,
0.0925351083,
0.0390032977,
-0.0235755946,
-0.0457118899,
-0.0223749559,
0.0791913345,
-0.0350217447,
-0.0633214265,
0.0377083346,
0.0380118005,
0.0164704714,
-0.0125178704,
0.0229901113,
-0.0170056205,
0.0490412116,
0.014257988,
0.0887969434,
-0.0098300595,
-0.0442648903,
0.0083225043,
-0.0356893167,
-0.0261397213,
-0.0024159593,
0.0368955992,
-0.0507914051,
-0.0789966881,
-0.0026663886,
0.0312420651,
-0.0188162904,
0.0336907431,
-0.0124228327,
0.0037368608,
0.0013732339,
0.0261981357,
-0.0105565647,
-0.0056455419,
-0.0651986301,
0.0354697965,
-0.0093119498,
-0.0790442154,
-0.0643471181,
0.0063636154,
-0.0140986973,
-0.0051075979,
-0.0204300992,
0.0339773037,
1.652826332e-34,
0.0295081828,
0.0130882738,
-0.0243139528,
0.0480055548,
0.040485356,
0.0036172075,
0.0097009409,
-0.0163668394,
0.0160846431,
-0.0698432103,
0.013714388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01783v1 | Hierarchical Multi-Label Classification of Online Vaccine Concerns | 2024-02-01T20:56:07 | 2024-02-01T20:56:07 | Chloe Qinyu Zhu, Rickard Stureborg, Bhuwan Dhingra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Vaccine concerns are an ever-evolving target, and can shift quickly as seen
during the COVID-19 pandemic. Identifying longitudinal trends in vaccine
concerns and misinformation might inform the healthcare space by helping public
health efforts strategically allocate resources or information campaigns. We
explore the task of detecting vaccine concerns in online discourse using large
language models (LLMs) in a zero-shot setting without the need for expensive
training datasets. Since real-time monitoring of online sources requires
large-scale inference, we explore cost-accuracy trade-offs of different
prompting strategies and offer concrete takeaways that may inform choices in
system designs for current applications. An analysis of different prompting
strategies reveals that classifying the concerns over multiple passes through
the LLM, each consisting a boolean question whether the text mentions a vaccine
concern or not, works the best. Our results indicate that GPT-4 can strongly
outperform crowdworker accuracy when compared to ground truth annotations
provided by experts on the recently introduced VaxConcerns dataset, achieving
an overall F1 score of 78.7%. | Hierarchical Multi-Label Classification of Online Vaccine Concerns: Vaccine concerns are an ever-evolving target, and can shift quickly as seen
during the COVID-19 pandemic. Identifying longitudinal trends in vaccine
concerns and misinformation might inform the healthcare space by helping public
health efforts strategically allocate resources or information campaigns. We
explore the task of detecting vaccine concerns in online discourse using large
language models (LLMs) in a zero-shot setting without the need for expensive
training datasets. Since real-time monitoring of online sources requires
large-scale inference, we explore cost-accuracy trade-offs of different
prompting strategies and offer concrete takeaways that may inform choices in
system designs for current applications. An analysis of different prompting
strategies reveals that classifying the concerns over multiple passes through
the LLM, each consisting a boolean question whether the text mentions a vaccine
concern or not, works the best. Our results indicate that GPT-4 can strongly
outperform crowdworker accuracy when compared to ground truth annotations
provided by experts on the recently introduced VaxConcerns dataset, achieving
an overall F1 score of 78.7%. | [
0.0547863729,
0.0868248045,
-0.0015373412,
-0.0100571224,
-0.0283869561,
0.0130225467,
0.0323434137,
-0.0108852098,
0.0164755192,
-0.0804095566,
0.0165654644,
-0.0268065929,
-0.0019938936,
0.0013528111,
-0.013841955,
-0.0461528786,
0.0382807292,
0.0156432204,
0.0829092339,
0.0167112332,
0.029685745,
0.0186558571,
-0.0495956689,
0.0583392568,
-0.0021606449,
-0.0100322301,
0.0055923918,
-0.0156295002,
0.0509944484,
-0.1289876103,
0.0659511834,
0.0440945141,
0.0312113091,
0.0541787595,
0.0000017274,
-0.0261856467,
-0.0234809518,
0.0100745168,
-0.0155871427,
-0.0083420901,
0.0591686592,
-0.0247814339,
0.0352825597,
0.0543183014,
-0.0378979407,
-0.0327266343,
0.0539613478,
0.0464820862,
0.0422224551,
0.0466833226,
-0.0178766977,
-0.0160373896,
0.0354946591,
0.0033941267,
-0.0002886295,
-0.0753738657,
0.0570963658,
-0.0431336202,
0.0038862361,
0.0628286824,
0.0367761292,
0.0367096178,
-0.0416290313,
-0.0088012312,
0.0194985159,
0.0309514441,
-0.03857987,
-0.0202225707,
-0.0220506955,
0.067630522,
0.0288291164,
-0.0078667626,
0.0196826961,
-0.0251157004,
0.0063062664,
0.0070540169,
-0.0249993801,
-0.004867834,
-0.0157192145,
0.0238472428,
0.0223232321,
0.0108665023,
0.0429114327,
0.0304277241,
0.0422172546,
0.0607685521,
-0.0267404933,
-0.0389359929,
0.006290501,
0.0110981576,
0.0151549689,
-0.0506586209,
0.0294635743,
0.0230598748,
-0.0376588255,
0.025052987,
0.0034589311,
-0.0418674015,
0.0460996367,
-0.0921530649,
-0.0303071644,
-0.0210929643,
0.0029473128,
0.0366278924,
0.0468298867,
-0.0141078401,
-0.0203960966,
-0.0090112826,
0.0462731719,
0.00489537,
-0.0831008404,
-0.0030452702,
-0.0505376048,
0.0314331464,
0.0161901359,
0.0325700566,
-0.0676945075,
-0.0141690327,
-0.0325100981,
-0.0206417441,
-0.0442037247,
0.0018267073,
0.0033000908,
-0.0002293874,
-0.0035757003,
0.0805386901,
-0.0406015068,
0.043683514,
-0.0079495721,
-0.043184109,
0.014708125,
-0.0014991489,
0.0154425725,
-0.0159454662,
-0.0122787142,
0.0157590788,
0.0186732057,
-0.0182885937,
-0.0239898637,
-0.0329767168,
-0.0504565276,
-0.0195043758,
-0.034227062,
-0.039901495,
0.0100665903,
0.0004693569,
0.001819712,
-0.0052076508,
0.0026341416,
0.0063973833,
-0.067873165,
0.0701641962,
-0.0182127636,
-0.0028905964,
0.0705338344,
0.014909219,
0.0171853695,
0.0369327366,
0.016198393,
0.004516209,
0.0326729827,
-0.0031278711,
0.0378249325,
0.0051391334,
0.0248250794,
0.0122012934,
0.040493533,
-0.0008415777,
0.0161557645,
0.023482915,
-0.0541676283,
0.0506100394,
-0.0129948827,
-0.0229601897,
0.0642241165,
0.0507000424,
-0.0892425627,
-0.084490709,
-0.0082888678,
0.0677584559,
-0.0197146703,
-0.0373897143,
-0.0022068324,
-0.0209671389,
-0.0490151793,
-0.0653036237,
0.0136516746,
-0.0190457888,
-0.0229843184,
-0.0262673944,
-0.0488382466,
0.0032139404,
0.003179132,
-0.0029255531,
0.0352373086,
-0.0290816277,
-0.0407455824,
0.0268344879,
0.047861442,
-0.0003608937,
-0.00558746,
-0.0696488321,
0.0192565843,
0.0273577366,
0.0211844072,
-0.019352017,
-0.0728987157,
-0.0579450354,
0.056948401,
0.0205997694,
0.0267703775,
-0.028996747,
-0.014809371,
-0.0233626291,
-0.0191084705,
0.0349385031,
0.0333850197,
0.0083283149,
0.0303617511,
-0.0040533305,
-0.0141137969,
0.0171398818,
-0.0171802081,
0.0425575078,
0.0171150472,
-0.0262707081,
0.0131124398,
0.027469011,
0.0840142071,
0.009601797,
0.0341935195,
0.0098586539,
0.0246572439,
-0.034821488,
-0.0216298159,
-0.040922571,
0.0057710321,
0.0047982903,
0.0247867666,
-0.0123025347,
-0.0222299434,
0.0049099149,
-0.0567663126,
0.0320165865,
-0.0023189532,
-0.0060417694,
0.0093637668,
-0.0176347233,
-0.0067727165,
-0.0157281142,
-0.0006598313,
-0.033306703,
0.0325381495,
-0.0198924802,
-0.0017295363,
0.004518291,
-0.0483606607,
-0.017731769,
-0.0324613079,
0.0138878478,
-0.0020238154,
0.0150495628,
-0.0015413858,
0.0181576982,
-0.0276678316,
-0.0290952642,
-0.0139334453,
-0.0989725068,
-0.0008943379,
0.0030843932,
0.0362281166,
0.0179427732,
-0.0167522058,
0.0259390827,
-0.0078744031,
-0.0324096903,
0.0054874485,
0.0067950212,
0.0603539683,
0.0599705279,
0.0116506638,
0.0204828698,
-0.0274504907,
0.002278215,
-0.0660452396,
0.0072651999,
0.0548821539,
-0.0572860502,
-0.0228172187,
-0.0668392405,
-0.0405318402,
0.0092480313,
-0.0096602645,
-0.0156608969,
0.0250621866,
0.0044310652,
-0.0105732176,
0.0164580233,
0.0349880382,
0.0364016108,
0.0522283018,
0.0243555382,
-0.0187890977,
0.0188330673,
-0.0450710095,
-0.0294253752,
-0.0233302303,
0.0060412544,
0.0182514787,
0.1128047109,
0.0186725687,
0.0069309976,
-0.0636230037,
0.0196738541,
-0.0511116832,
-0.003606006,
-0.0877162442,
-0.0186791196,
-0.0284545012,
0.0345206819,
-0.0252539683,
-0.0272785909,
0.0524590276,
0.0283699222,
0.0204482861,
-0.0498261936,
-0.0302750599,
-0.0258513447,
0.0012821796,
0.002855733,
0.0066359271,
0.0583671778,
-0.0095036449,
0.0081956303,
-0.0297249202,
0.0064426535,
-0.0476212576,
-0.056993816,
-0.0380119607,
0.0384156965,
-0.0077473526,
-0.0559290834,
-0.0518217236,
-0.0948256403,
-0.072491847,
-0.0306324568,
0.0099178571,
-0.0072574047,
-0.0558275767,
0.0195658803,
-0.0045463578,
0.0429012552,
0.0095666777,
-0.035177961,
0.024331633,
0.0510528125,
0.0297322664,
-0.033856038,
0.0090358527,
-0.030102253,
-0.0063794106,
0.0560232215,
0.0169895906,
0.0192915443,
-0.0054853247,
-0.0188330021,
0.0064821509,
-0.0129606975,
-0.0212898422,
0.0319337249,
0.0404606089,
-0.0600361563,
0.0281926058,
0.0954581201,
0.0333791971,
-0.014896391,
0.0036494653,
0.0048629208,
0.013515288,
-0.0070378175,
-0.0045356099,
-0.0635675788,
-0.0271428321,
-0.0042512193,
0.041961506,
-0.0423671938,
-0.0547289923,
-0.0081960214,
-0.0635864064,
0.0467963554,
-0.0114599811,
-0.0279498361,
0.0418643542,
-0.0579759665,
0.0119716097,
0.0048072999,
-0.0107630733,
-0.0219779331,
0.039605584,
-0.011664236,
0.0046490184,
-0.0710559413,
-0.0215713568,
0.0405058824,
0.0165123343,
0.0499085262,
0.0256706644,
0.0708715394,
-0.000458222,
-0.0687906146,
0.0382861756,
-0.0036010034,
-0.0581370406,
-0.0197973419,
0.0888716951,
-0.0303055346,
0.0036756475,
-0.0554240271,
0.031147873,
-0.040152546,
-0.0150519339,
0.0154285282,
0.091036655,
0.00184228,
-0.046461191,
-0.0351431817,
0.0299717952,
0.0229136776,
0.0566816181,
0.0092433486,
-0.0523402095,
-0.0083931675,
0.0053338772,
0.0314131528,
-0.0316159613,
-0.0099548548,
0.0028266208,
-0.0104253618,
-0.0576435365,
-0.054034505,
-0.0023175573,
0.0424768142,
-0.026856903,
-0.0255400054,
-0.0228748713,
0.052246958,
0.0310766958,
-0.027936589,
0.0233775862,
-0.0169744659,
0.0083691189,
-0.0548243597,
-0.0166744739,
0.0410623625,
0.0233451761,
-0.0300104152,
0.06025213,
-0.0679893643,
-0.0726281106,
-0.0158588607,
-0.00668213,
0.0195258111,
0.0072623729,
0.0032015103,
0.0091022784,
0.0499600433,
0.0595347621,
-0.0055265157,
-0.0395685211,
0.0180208329,
0.0275200866,
-0.0037171482,
0.0268572196,
0.0101128519,
0.0138489259,
-0.0098753236,
-0.0151902093,
-0.0768500268,
-0.0172151159,
-0.0018081012,
0.0051522702,
0.0767290294,
-0.0081858607,
-0.025028849,
-0.0486534685,
-0.0232330989,
0.0227651447,
-0.0339452513,
0.0026427617,
-0.015350149,
0.0122057721,
-0.0415235721,
-0.0503820963,
0.0317296349,
-0.0156341027,
0.0269598942,
-0.0190100726,
0.0025134608,
0.0142541965,
0.0622517541,
0.0439142734,
-0.0304325968,
-0.002694895,
0.0321480557,
0.0300018359,
0.0124791199,
-0.0062307846,
0.0133911036,
-0.008308202,
0.0222875681,
0.0272475071,
-0.0041106883,
-0.0462070666,
-0.0422100313,
-0.0208937954,
0.019990379,
-0.0042001191,
0.0245555621,
0.0412188284,
-0.0069380985,
-0.0544390492,
-0.0237024035,
0.0556750596,
-0.0217223708,
-0.0267806482,
0.0334498435,
0.0038824666,
-0.0570413023,
0.0104119303,
0.0544695891,
0.0229737684,
0.0878052562,
0.0370636247,
-0.0560230091,
-0.0445532762,
-0.0049263113,
-0.0150434067,
0.0532776713,
-0.0088918526,
0.0629952773,
-0.0676797181,
-0.0129255978,
0.0306440704,
-0.0396207161,
-0.0108342571,
0.0026148553,
0.0183233358,
-0.0057491334,
0.007016297,
-0.0125247529,
-0.0549495742,
0.0158769786,
0.0064657344,
-0.0348588899,
-0.0453267954,
-6.239429975e-33,
0.0090434374,
-0.0576708913,
-0.0191039518,
-0.0319140479,
0.0017230853,
0.050034292,
-0.017556686,
0.0230369996,
-0.0090686055,
0.0347955488,
0.0375304185,
0.0025012821,
-0.0078462204,
0.0304669514,
0.0181304645,
-0.0279483441,
0.0503453836,
-0.0278313365,
-0.0000336819,
0.049442444,
0.0314024985,
0.011141927,
0.0306786317,
-0.076633133,
0.0642205998,
-0.0141431801,
0.0040628193,
0.0481307022,
0.0018212388,
0.0437618382,
-0.0154205421,
0.048791565,
0.0560557097,
-0.0020017396,
0.0371273085,
0.0626373962,
-0.0534505807,
-0.0154963881,
-0.0420768559,
-0.0238182731,
-0.0495793074,
-0.0379186794,
0.0419551134,
0.0355070271,
-0.0099734738,
-0.0027923009,
0.0402489007,
-0.0133252535,
0.009752986,
-0.0367590152,
-0.0506923571,
0.0222462807,
-0.0267266966,
0.0017770635,
-0.0078796698,
0.0633481517,
-0.0239449237,
0.1195316687,
-0.028211711,
0.0336280353,
0.0161120687,
-0.0154956765,
-0.00161726,
0.0026792197,
0.0096389307,
0.026731912,
0.0032853629,
0.0059602256,
-0.0405251384,
-0.0099376068,
-0.0133116795,
-0.0016174527,
0.0417900234,
0.0479953215,
0.0576566719,
0.0077001648,
-0.0979785249,
0.0032255244,
-0.0277155936,
0.0234276392,
0.0203749128,
-0.0033998576,
-0.0307420492,
-0.0158415195,
-0.0170142297,
-0.0252000801,
-0.0204269309,
0.0223513599,
0.0198794249,
0.0052984837,
-0.0215508938,
-0.0014794989,
-0.0104580168,
0.0113568893,
-0.0573382415,
0.0152833825,
0.0409557745,
0.0004431221,
0.0125506483,
0.0375719629,
-0.0621938668,
0.0133930184,
-0.0016834874,
-0.0160549693,
0.0285745952,
-0.0103125125,
0.0405189134,
-0.0363792405,
-0.0895895958,
-0.0221866127,
0.0126568358,
0.0480178185,
-0.0336715356,
0.0716881528,
0.036768239,
0.0016294201,
0.0219814349,
0.0739164501,
0.0075915135,
0.0014300571,
0.0116058607,
-0.0207052473,
-0.0555038489,
-0.0044730809,
-0.0240792036,
-0.0152580217,
0.0016183219,
0.0423693694,
0.0025108343,
-0.0821851864,
-0.0063047241,
-0.0447240919,
2.531e-7,
0.0847447217,
0.0940363854,
-0.014402708,
-0.029480366,
0.0349513553,
0.0487983339,
-0.0157017987,
0.0052125067,
-0.0123555753,
-0.0455247089,
0.0207633674,
0.0100321975,
0.0344118476,
0.054842487,
-0.0609630495,
-0.0482845455,
-0.0736671761,
0.0338727869,
-0.0458586477,
0.0132085243,
0.082352221,
0.0517282635,
0.0280909166,
-0.0086788666,
-0.0119137559,
0.0299738962,
0.057273753,
0.0060903188,
-0.0148835005,
0.0244069491,
-0.008213453,
0.0175401419,
-0.0049288962,
0.0396973863,
-0.0365293697,
-0.0468982011,
-0.0379799791,
0.0605268739,
-0.0224180408,
-0.0129254777,
0.0081957867,
-0.0046557994,
-0.0254666433,
-0.0123628806,
0.0427887179,
-0.0712755844,
-0.0512681417,
-0.0277464278,
-0.0097478386,
-0.0054106228,
0.0387655646,
-0.0142233213,
-0.0326874703,
0.0022802139,
-0.0001880981,
-0.0010872093,
-0.0053867162,
-0.0584221892,
0.0272384882,
0.0066880565,
-0.0498672314,
-0.0665881261,
0.0220248252,
0.0047918172,
0.0124743972,
-0.0271237046,
0.067562744,
1.897682035e-34,
0.0327537768,
-0.0039847656,
-0.0146078961,
-0.0048582205,
0.0127076153,
0.0385576375,
-0.0350827388,
-0.0226186011,
0.039196346,
-0.030780917,
0.0338427499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00978v1 | An Information-Theoretic Approach to Analyze NLP Classification Tasks | 2024-02-01T19:49:44 | 2024-02-01T19:49:44 | Luran Wang, Mark Gales, Vatsal Raina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT | Understanding the importance of the inputs on the output is useful across
many tasks. This work provides an information-theoretic framework to analyse
the influence of inputs for text classification tasks. Natural language
processing (NLP) tasks take either a single element input or multiple element
inputs to predict an output variable, where an element is a block of text. Each
text element has two components: an associated semantic meaning and a
linguistic realization. Multiple-choice reading comprehension (MCRC) and
sentiment classification (SC) are selected to showcase the framework. For MCRC,
it is found that the context influence on the output compared to the question
influence reduces on more challenging datasets. In particular, more challenging
contexts allow a greater variation in complexity of questions. Hence, test
creators need to carefully consider the choice of the context when designing
multiple-choice questions for assessment. For SC, it is found the semantic
meaning of the input text dominates (above 80\% for all datasets considered)
compared to its linguistic realisation when determining the sentiment. The
framework is made available at:
https://github.com/WangLuran/nlp-element-influence | An Information-Theoretic Approach to Analyze NLP Classification Tasks: Understanding the importance of the inputs on the output is useful across
many tasks. This work provides an information-theoretic framework to analyse
the influence of inputs for text classification tasks. Natural language
processing (NLP) tasks take either a single element input or multiple element
inputs to predict an output variable, where an element is a block of text. Each
text element has two components: an associated semantic meaning and a
linguistic realization. Multiple-choice reading comprehension (MCRC) and
sentiment classification (SC) are selected to showcase the framework. For MCRC,
it is found that the context influence on the output compared to the question
influence reduces on more challenging datasets. In particular, more challenging
contexts allow a greater variation in complexity of questions. Hence, test
creators need to carefully consider the choice of the context when designing
multiple-choice questions for assessment. For SC, it is found the semantic
meaning of the input text dominates (above 80\% for all datasets considered)
compared to its linguistic realisation when determining the sentiment. The
framework is made available at:
https://github.com/WangLuran/nlp-element-influence | [
0.0213973597,
-0.0468060672,
-0.0237324759,
0.0243144389,
-0.072902061,
0.0480123498,
0.01464306,
0.0303570591,
0.042907849,
-0.0944327414,
0.0180308092,
0.0031798268,
0.002599651,
-0.0413689762,
-0.001526594,
-0.0505566709,
0.0354054384,
0.0080795605,
0.0005630259,
-0.0074768146,
0.0060923025,
-0.0050646546,
0.0006560853,
-0.0192482956,
0.0087488536,
-0.0155516984,
-0.0037091519,
-0.0269050654,
0.0117964754,
-0.0330634192,
0.0003195636,
0.0576972142,
-0.0114235524,
0.0136301517,
0.0000021454,
-0.055939313,
-0.0306798667,
-0.0035563121,
-0.0188981146,
-0.008984101,
0.0719170347,
0.0093276538,
0.037649218,
0.0174813084,
-0.0094363876,
-0.010484701,
0.0255138669,
0.0810695589,
0.0477023236,
0.0719216391,
0.0066874484,
-0.0215393081,
-0.0042853686,
0.056060873,
0.071155563,
-0.0073825633,
0.0193112977,
0.0234951023,
-0.0089805331,
0.0330674015,
0.002268733,
0.0226865578,
0.0107109733,
0.0449573733,
0.0157482233,
0.0034726728,
0.0229669027,
-0.016096117,
-0.0157630052,
0.0303340293,
0.0471522436,
-0.0324861631,
-0.0609855503,
-0.0268088281,
-0.0079382537,
0.0507797338,
-0.0088875676,
-0.0025764471,
-0.0221453272,
0.0068357061,
0.0351514705,
0.0216085576,
-0.0015351879,
0.0422277339,
-0.0082700346,
0.0601793081,
-0.0189788546,
-0.0587861277,
0.0412494168,
0.0430925637,
-0.0048332522,
0.0048898407,
0.0194360353,
0.0150142936,
0.0102644861,
0.0197331477,
0.0087892935,
-0.0610492229,
0.0523340441,
-0.0838350058,
-0.0032681525,
0.0268081632,
0.016266752,
0.0183947999,
0.0008402796,
0.0470483936,
0.023222141,
0.0008762204,
-0.0676610395,
0.018011352,
-0.0710786805,
-0.0131133506,
0.0159716699,
0.0527337007,
-0.0180890374,
-0.0047821016,
-0.024995584,
0.0058366437,
-0.0095558111,
-0.0147085646,
-0.0343672447,
0.000411374,
-0.0163828526,
0.0731988326,
-0.0572813451,
0.0198387355,
-0.0504640006,
0.0219898447,
-0.0350379199,
0.0049497844,
0.0359784961,
0.0313739516,
0.0100235483,
-0.0312371142,
0.0102171982,
0.0509455912,
0.000568323,
-0.0391553976,
-0.0283947736,
-0.0494425707,
-0.0059419866,
-0.0380135998,
-0.0016203044,
-0.0125082713,
-0.0108861821,
0.0254373625,
-0.0036600947,
-0.0004270367,
-0.0137137054,
0.0495715626,
0.0083550457,
0.0871106461,
0.0228534769,
-0.0337503515,
0.0303809643,
0.0166173689,
0.0387490205,
0.0528599024,
-0.0206559543,
-0.0080706077,
0.0554112531,
-0.0335059911,
-0.0006580368,
-0.0138845388,
-0.0174795594,
-0.0097611072,
0.0071941284,
0.0287161414,
-0.0154398009,
0.0016713128,
-0.0251853205,
0.0362531394,
-0.0101616466,
-0.01124328,
0.0300167818,
0.0216832068,
0.0431003608,
-0.0171764921,
0.0150343925,
0.0299598407,
0.0106298998,
0.0574987605,
-0.003869578,
-0.0107966987,
-0.0614887178,
0.007731678,
0.0014741264,
-0.0377292112,
0.0057017147,
-0.0789294764,
-0.0231187996,
0.0274969079,
0.0648203641,
0.0203224551,
0.0580466576,
0.001969235,
-0.0475476682,
-0.0376617201,
0.0169260297,
-0.0542849191,
0.0053898073,
-0.026422061,
0.0481894128,
0.0349002294,
0.0252731685,
-0.0476715602,
-0.0083652781,
-0.0018508176,
-0.0309449863,
0.0082744341,
0.031398274,
-0.0298085567,
-0.0104216654,
-0.0319349207,
-0.0003437896,
0.0223470367,
-0.013734349,
0.0060614399,
-0.0089175161,
-0.0057012928,
-0.0003599056,
0.014597672,
-0.0424965397,
0.0450025387,
0.0360263214,
-0.0748606399,
-0.0032698519,
0.0306677874,
0.0657917336,
0.0330883153,
-0.002433531,
-0.0171631519,
0.0109634176,
-0.0224380679,
-0.025782004,
-0.0149098029,
-0.0151694948,
-0.0559228361,
0.0046206284,
-0.0546646975,
0.0050720293,
0.0287742428,
-0.0119347181,
-0.0260465872,
-0.0053083617,
-0.0528750941,
-0.0027072073,
-0.0235860683,
-0.0217043944,
-0.052343294,
-0.0300970022,
-0.1067644656,
0.0578007735,
0.0103622312,
0.0893788785,
-0.0158662144,
0.0383602045,
0.0557725243,
0.0236287098,
-0.0479608811,
0.0088922977,
0.013695159,
0.0034065836,
0.0640765801,
0.0206119474,
-0.0504447259,
-0.0123249097,
-0.0848994404,
-0.0032928949,
0.0096520809,
0.026812559,
0.0304430462,
-0.0116069308,
0.0082100108,
0.0147078549,
-0.0123431971,
-0.0020973107,
-0.0268464442,
0.0285978038,
0.0390418395,
0.0123302527,
0.0341808014,
-0.0121821314,
-0.0054033427,
-0.0535906926,
0.0341194868,
0.0767918825,
-0.0172883291,
-0.0477639176,
0.0399338044,
-0.0086948285,
-0.0233911499,
0.0028744701,
-0.0158923566,
0.0275915395,
-0.0063942731,
0.0178090297,
0.0335264988,
0.0074069602,
0.0394846834,
0.0074958019,
0.0102175632,
-0.0435437821,
0.0220081452,
-0.0393160321,
0.0424852371,
-0.0164779034,
-0.0460408553,
0.0116239842,
0.0637906417,
0.0381276421,
-0.0490837917,
-0.0216157623,
0.0218104329,
-0.0911206901,
-0.0180087797,
-0.0833608806,
-0.0014642334,
-0.0063678212,
0.0575414486,
0.0022359444,
-0.0162997525,
0.0701393262,
-0.0201191362,
0.0107170567,
-0.1644206047,
-0.002899653,
-0.0415858142,
0.0642627999,
0.0216055866,
-0.0028210536,
0.0295201056,
-0.0144099537,
-0.023861317,
-0.0336276665,
0.0166197568,
-0.0255495235,
0.0414074101,
-0.0284690801,
-0.0225506555,
-0.0075273332,
-0.0185603369,
0.0163610838,
-0.0095362272,
0.0062744636,
-0.0405487604,
0.0440990366,
0.0155801084,
0.0100768255,
-0.0232525598,
0.0193042234,
-0.0257584602,
-0.0267258473,
-0.0320185423,
-0.0022548204,
0.0613719821,
-0.0112276962,
0.032169234,
0.030850336,
-0.0150057944,
0.0011203559,
0.0409553982,
-0.0002314369,
0.0323889963,
-0.0022173894,
0.0090617901,
0.0320124477,
-0.0617717505,
-0.0009953309,
-0.0170655698,
0.0448112674,
-0.0692595541,
-0.0131698055,
0.0839286149,
0.0542037487,
-0.029455753,
-0.0065476075,
-0.0089637944,
-0.0062884148,
0.0365474746,
0.0037716643,
-0.0327991061,
-0.0408367179,
-0.0153999692,
-0.0033620659,
-0.0666923672,
0.0038511483,
-0.0095629981,
-0.0668486431,
-0.0088141663,
-0.0267707948,
-0.0596309118,
-0.0425556824,
-0.0806767866,
-0.0115140565,
-0.0019914024,
0.0140047763,
-0.0205202065,
0.0068065976,
0.0271141604,
0.0279550329,
-0.0209311023,
0.0168389361,
0.0234939232,
0.0355627239,
0.0068362458,
0.0430575386,
0.042453289,
-0.0479510501,
0.0198116899,
0.0344757885,
-0.1090750173,
-0.0001574591,
-0.0470441505,
0.0667325407,
0.0251691714,
0.0187389906,
-0.0603895299,
0.0082850223,
-0.0193007607,
-0.0021437588,
0.0226753093,
0.0483470857,
-0.0076752249,
-0.0500915833,
-0.0460110903,
0.0244611297,
0.0157333221,
0.0861415043,
0.032861121,
-0.0891554132,
-0.0143002057,
-0.0402157605,
0.0234494805,
-0.0737768188,
-0.0356576145,
0.0304161664,
-0.0031595605,
-0.0199224409,
-0.0398518257,
-0.0895134658,
0.0345269926,
0.0107220644,
0.001912673,
0.0320591889,
0.0204173643,
-0.0175730009,
-0.026454147,
0.0010144557,
0.0314333178,
0.0103531042,
0.0257655978,
-0.0270673689,
0.0345757678,
-0.0211736895,
-0.0352676921,
0.0022615911,
-0.0339075774,
-0.0049524945,
-0.0027379922,
-0.0055879825,
0.0153203849,
0.0237157941,
0.0138676688,
-0.0495445132,
0.0709467381,
-0.0262638908,
-0.0251914132,
0.0040299585,
0.0134639163,
0.0449106954,
0.0270791687,
-0.0027613938,
0.0074812225,
0.0337347649,
0.0154426964,
-0.0209848192,
-0.0163601898,
-0.0136602707,
0.0233918,
0.0349625424,
0.0286444165,
0.0157569367,
-0.0190336034,
-0.0223193467,
-0.0145240724,
0.0109258909,
-0.0529704764,
0.0038275369,
-0.0192201808,
0.0121553903,
-0.0219621938,
-0.0716801509,
-0.0043756217,
-0.0276802555,
0.0272451062,
-0.0237250682,
0.0509248152,
0.0579716675,
0.0580016524,
-0.0079781767,
0.0117264194,
-0.0492541119,
-0.0261154212,
-0.030825058,
0.0077146152,
0.0275058784,
0.074109152,
0.0349948369,
-0.0068001719,
0.0011122557,
-0.0108595174,
-0.0573577508,
0.0830857754,
0.0141208721,
-0.0140340319,
-0.0453373939,
-0.0141176367,
-0.0050634802,
-0.0253781602,
0.0026544896,
-0.0183972418,
0.0306075476,
0.0101349885,
-0.0078875544,
0.0492558777,
0.0098621622,
-0.0027994029,
-0.0027376956,
0.0529022068,
-0.0341613404,
0.0023885469,
0.0214082208,
-0.0158326905,
-0.0649934933,
0.0002886596,
-0.006995922,
0.0694340169,
0.0092568081,
0.032047648,
-0.0572415069,
-0.0480746552,
0.031961035,
0.0118081216,
0.0527841337,
-0.0045757554,
0.027603846,
0.069432199,
-0.0082826819,
-0.010348279,
-0.0460728966,
-0.0002384483,
-0.0656011254,
-0.0279741678,
-0.0235329308,
-6.225642161e-33,
-0.0160911176,
-0.0311027337,
-0.0049667875,
0.0180527121,
0.0177565925,
0.0220249705,
0.0058540055,
-0.0055193105,
-0.0138334911,
0.0152857332,
-0.0004733319,
0.0105448393,
-0.018967703,
0.0560645349,
0.0028769274,
-0.0208311547,
0.0170866083,
-0.0062121293,
-0.0188609902,
0.0205569323,
0.0472430401,
-0.0125181777,
0.0299325511,
-0.0841812417,
0.0730015561,
-0.0119700683,
0.0006042676,
-0.0163409915,
-0.0102583067,
0.0155412201,
-0.0363562927,
0.0939601362,
0.0695954114,
-0.0711899027,
0.0247923527,
0.0785735771,
-0.040226832,
-0.1004986241,
0.0197655205,
0.046288915,
-0.0281045493,
-0.017802611,
0.0434723832,
-0.0205679815,
-0.0017297402,
-0.0275664665,
0.0702788979,
0.015198837,
-0.0130845336,
-0.0370546058,
-0.0739103928,
0.0174434669,
-0.0382624157,
0.0158595126,
0.0201733354,
0.0865320489,
-0.0175693613,
0.0302234124,
-0.0654897243,
0.0049966658,
-0.0106416224,
0.0110450145,
-0.0239533279,
0.0103805047,
-0.0018368035,
0.0482557677,
-0.0055827927,
-0.0312894918,
-0.0161077864,
-0.004825715,
0.0121365665,
-0.0338888317,
0.0365090184,
0.0719045848,
0.0549136922,
-0.0409656502,
-0.07175266,
0.0509801134,
0.0610779747,
-0.007325531,
0.0226562675,
-0.0264612343,
-0.0787851214,
-0.0377688818,
-0.0546765216,
-0.0229146779,
-0.0385200717,
-0.02755991,
0.0198028311,
-0.0577885509,
-0.0273224693,
-0.0073430566,
0.0034841783,
-0.0411404148,
-0.0048249508,
0.0009445864,
-0.0346495695,
0.0579977483,
-0.0004203971,
0.0039748619,
0.0010418646,
-0.0218002852,
-0.0315146372,
0.00749913,
0.0398163125,
-0.0147401216,
0.0401008464,
0.015691489,
-0.0496193394,
-0.0613259636,
-0.0143109029,
-0.0199151281,
0.0282285064,
0.0433365367,
-0.0070707053,
0.0467930213,
0.0003303129,
0.024182668,
0.0412271209,
0.0233901292,
-0.0016987697,
-0.0593105182,
-0.0267968159,
-0.0117682004,
-0.0315650888,
-0.0613870658,
0.006609492,
-0.0121577363,
0.0052562593,
-0.0542223416,
0.015787486,
0.0340396203,
2.83e-7,
0.0672280863,
0.0906108618,
-0.0415863581,
0.0147061972,
0.0095042158,
0.0503669828,
0.040125262,
0.0046922504,
0.0200243052,
-0.0162299573,
0.0032535165,
-0.0067506349,
-0.0139427288,
0.0178368445,
-0.1017615646,
-0.0481497832,
0.0337225497,
0.0368205495,
-0.0051259324,
0.0868249312,
0.1124305502,
0.0571519844,
0.0154632097,
-0.0041535343,
-0.0415255576,
-0.0088592898,
-0.0104021318,
-0.0508125685,
0.0223632753,
0.0476267226,
0.0015978712,
-0.0138071515,
0.0507068671,
0.0849142075,
-0.0067402408,
-0.0079343701,
0.0075492891,
-0.0000803078,
0.0233733729,
-0.0428857207,
-0.0000915617,
-0.0164340511,
0.0143880267,
-0.0404516868,
0.0789732561,
-0.0428855121,
-0.0613686554,
-0.0281016193,
-0.0053964676,
-0.0250747763,
0.0336876251,
0.0328144915,
-0.0234616473,
0.0103705917,
-0.0205428656,
-0.0334792808,
-0.0094229467,
-0.0504062735,
0.002629492,
0.0198211875,
-0.0110796923,
-0.02444157,
-0.0326735713,
-0.0070566679,
0.0651904419,
-0.0838080272,
-0.0068221628,
2.430719131e-34,
0.0100398874,
-0.0070965458,
0.0122257639,
-0.00148441,
0.0206654798,
0.0004363057,
-0.023398485,
-0.0005294132,
0.0394648649,
-0.078459464,
0.0231718868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00969v1 | SPARQL Generation with Entity Pre-trained GPT for KG Question Answering | 2024-02-01T19:38:32 | 2024-02-01T19:38:32 | Diego Bustamante, Hideaki Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, 68P20, 68T50, H.2.3; H.3.3; I.2.7 | Knowledge Graphs popularity has been rapidly growing in last years. All that
knowledge is available for people to query it through the many online databases
on the internet. Though, it would be a great achievement if non-programmer
users could access whatever information they want to know. There has been a lot
of effort oriented to solve this task using natural language processing tools
and creativity encouragement by way of many challenges. Our approach focuses on
assuming a correct entity linking on the natural language questions and
training a GPT model to create SPARQL queries from them. We managed to isolate
which property of the task can be the most difficult to solve at few or
zero-shot and we proposed pre-training on all entities (under CWA) to improve
the performance. We obtained a 62.703% accuracy of exact SPARQL matches on
testing at 3-shots, a F1 of 0.809 on the entity linking challenge and a F1 of
0.009 on the question answering challenge. | SPARQL Generation with Entity Pre-trained GPT for KG Question Answering: Knowledge Graphs popularity has been rapidly growing in last years. All that
knowledge is available for people to query it through the many online databases
on the internet. Though, it would be a great achievement if non-programmer
users could access whatever information they want to know. There has been a lot
of effort oriented to solve this task using natural language processing tools
and creativity encouragement by way of many challenges. Our approach focuses on
assuming a correct entity linking on the natural language questions and
training a GPT model to create SPARQL queries from them. We managed to isolate
which property of the task can be the most difficult to solve at few or
zero-shot and we proposed pre-training on all entities (under CWA) to improve
the performance. We obtained a 62.703% accuracy of exact SPARQL matches on
testing at 3-shots, a F1 of 0.809 on the entity linking challenge and a F1 of
0.009 on the question answering challenge. | [
0.0738215894,
0.0352768712,
0.0144542158,
0.0107837748,
-0.0103956023,
0.0302895792,
-0.0439535752,
-0.0036051462,
0.0431983359,
-0.0473703891,
0.008543903,
0.0182876028,
-0.0534593053,
0.0289198607,
0.0233764015,
-0.0308523811,
0.0156399198,
0.0337392688,
-0.0118258558,
-0.0049875034,
0.0100167785,
0.0728503019,
-0.0367439762,
0.0037243161,
-0.041028861,
-0.0110176606,
-0.0301624499,
0.0206237119,
-0.0108307134,
-0.0269492734,
0.0027791637,
0.0607978664,
0.0158537161,
0.0176408011,
0.0000018847,
-0.0677138418,
-0.0378251821,
0.0223679245,
-0.0553842261,
-0.0462078787,
-0.0492694192,
0.0042446726,
0.0405004025,
0.034874659,
-0.0628917366,
-0.0483803339,
0.0293559823,
0.0660328791,
0.049848713,
0.0685541332,
-0.0108705238,
-0.0497160479,
0.0078736031,
-0.0045524486,
0.053183198,
-0.0654457584,
-0.0017598406,
0.0068777292,
0.019982053,
-0.002560976,
-0.0090768589,
-0.0055233319,
0.0134664308,
0.040217571,
0.0051984079,
0.0052898107,
-0.0543026626,
0.0327066481,
0.0002931951,
0.0853620619,
0.01646691,
-0.0150321508,
0.0196523611,
0.0157113131,
-0.0251778439,
0.0073493635,
-0.0028228776,
-0.0271849632,
-0.0161548741,
-0.0017848331,
-0.0267322697,
-0.013570671,
-0.0095057162,
-0.0071827848,
-0.0286814198,
0.0745909065,
0.0325205773,
-0.0289883818,
0.0201815702,
0.0294963513,
-0.0263028629,
-0.0343477651,
0.001720436,
0.0263571441,
-0.018512439,
0.0387370698,
-0.0534488671,
0.0072824168,
0.0167255513,
0.0067147459,
-0.0213963147,
0.0281412769,
0.0631755143,
0.0465477109,
-0.0372318029,
0.0306823794,
-0.0013975854,
0.0106923385,
-0.0236454979,
-0.0502239391,
-0.098478511,
-0.0059857182,
-0.091012165,
0.0517318286,
-0.0286085363,
-0.0347530358,
-0.0299601164,
0.0366670191,
0.036695756,
-0.0005351791,
0.0505034029,
0.036593888,
-0.0143262176,
-0.0149301235,
-0.072271876,
0.0173812304,
-0.0461655185,
-0.0197049789,
-0.0356142409,
-0.0499897674,
-0.0065529593,
-0.007553421,
0.0340495408,
-0.0675563067,
0.0094657131,
0.0360118784,
0.0102691064,
-0.0241127443,
-0.0788449571,
-0.067213878,
0.0401464738,
-0.0444022119,
-0.0167769883,
-0.0349165797,
0.0519906357,
0.0020540098,
-0.0014045569,
-0.0456398502,
0.0176508892,
0.0290293042,
-0.0503564626,
0.067159839,
-0.0768091381,
0.0078121242,
0.0064323316,
-0.0040956689,
0.0237569921,
0.0791556016,
0.0005321211,
-0.0255929977,
0.0390488952,
0.0091170687,
-0.0418658815,
0.0081645977,
0.0551052392,
-0.0115210824,
0.0444022268,
0.0522993654,
-0.0349006504,
0.0283547174,
0.0097314864,
0.0476457141,
-0.0142889516,
-0.010758915,
0.005232065,
0.0490797125,
0.0081784064,
0.0320039243,
0.0390908718,
0.0320984535,
0.0033902624,
0.0068881018,
-0.0411228798,
0.0271061808,
-0.0305206254,
0.017384829,
0.0048725712,
0.0389113314,
-0.0346154794,
0.0079239113,
0.0085794423,
0.0351670906,
-0.0212762635,
0.0322353169,
0.0369737633,
0.0340771712,
-0.0582244024,
0.084533684,
-0.0014810668,
-0.0282920226,
0.00690705,
-0.0213703699,
0.0008273385,
0.0321041569,
0.0476719625,
0.0066143046,
-0.0727477446,
0.0040700315,
-0.0250799917,
0.0330922231,
0.0104220491,
-0.0036874523,
0.0001058203,
-0.0195637923,
-0.0457435213,
0.0141249523,
0.0051494879,
-0.0026377456,
0.0605157316,
0.0632814765,
0.0547357127,
-0.0327669419,
0.0510409735,
0.0300245769,
0.0001918774,
-0.0393726453,
-0.0045283181,
0.0087748645,
0.0119596384,
0.0440521389,
0.0007686301,
0.0194892958,
0.0064988593,
0.0026758106,
-0.0346602872,
-0.0008933821,
0.0344043933,
-0.0639209822,
0.034093231,
-0.0430648737,
-0.0077760355,
0.0052577048,
-0.0442724861,
-0.0484571271,
0.0043630023,
-0.0154595813,
0.0427959338,
-0.0437897369,
-0.0354512744,
0.061980322,
-0.0465578325,
-0.0281248987,
0.046083495,
0.0281795822,
0.030610837,
-0.0379087441,
0.0045737671,
0.0419411436,
-0.0700589418,
-0.0254206285,
-0.0192672443,
-0.003160469,
0.0152154276,
0.0010864375,
0.0141548719,
-0.1057891399,
0.013753172,
-0.0937892795,
0.0376164205,
-0.0101126274,
0.0382001922,
0.0267462339,
0.0077844574,
-0.0313399546,
-0.0244466495,
-0.0795128867,
0.005715956,
0.0197743867,
0.0199187398,
0.0210288279,
0.0169485379,
0.0218787249,
-0.0085221743,
-0.0017374107,
-0.028741559,
0.0157206282,
0.0323588178,
0.0196149666,
0.0028647529,
0.0389943346,
-0.0645583123,
0.0139484992,
0.0380391255,
-0.0023594548,
0.0050876308,
-0.0251876749,
0.0038227476,
0.0117572621,
-0.008494339,
-0.0003316066,
-0.0448933803,
-0.0265729874,
-0.041263748,
0.0370838419,
-0.0301849581,
-0.0023111198,
-0.0011299243,
0.0068320855,
0.0731820166,
0.0140604367,
0.006848624,
-0.0380474664,
-0.0678721145,
0.062315397,
0.0008306327,
0.0218182914,
-0.0470465869,
0.031769909,
0.0417204723,
0.0106552616,
-0.0127325989,
0.0114263492,
0.0571741797,
-0.0035871228,
0.0204612073,
-0.0442441069,
0.0190493688,
-0.0320170559,
0.0397654586,
0.0119061349,
0.0350524969,
-0.0213752016,
-0.0369846523,
-0.0381107144,
0.0120063862,
0.0254136194,
-0.0066785053,
0.001174476,
-0.0010285863,
0.0421715602,
0.0197818074,
-0.0038880613,
-0.0258413535,
0.0050850157,
-0.0204112958,
0.0081638955,
0.0244285073,
0.0165013038,
0.0165002197,
0.0205955971,
-0.0302608479,
-0.017241098,
-0.0074027199,
-0.0356692076,
-0.0068965601,
0.0614906214,
0.0997832119,
-0.0062426147,
-0.0309316535,
0.0330334865,
-0.0398109518,
0.0565084629,
0.0605260357,
-0.0501994342,
0.0222696569,
0.032953348,
0.0103021339,
-0.0957645029,
0.0012275438,
-0.013106836,
0.0091826357,
-0.0238819234,
0.0086403862,
0.1077614054,
0.0498047918,
0.0206205491,
-0.0287230406,
0.0293705333,
0.0282457732,
0.0208014846,
0.0576337762,
-0.1283174753,
-0.0461161137,
-0.0391490608,
0.0257906206,
-0.0070994133,
-0.0831908956,
-0.014346065,
-0.1371567249,
0.001344783,
-0.0303521138,
-0.0507665351,
-0.0331913792,
-0.0317102037,
-0.0373060331,
-0.0421090871,
-0.031960912,
0.0243495069,
-0.0160413515,
0.0424462482,
0.0190165099,
0.0208980646,
-0.0222257171,
0.0367904529,
-0.0706024021,
0.020311404,
0.0352528058,
0.0282061063,
0.0057165711,
-0.0127655901,
-0.0685811266,
-0.0231627338,
-0.0089208307,
-0.0179231279,
0.0646826029,
-0.0429744273,
-0.0185662042,
-0.0349387228,
-0.0011473808,
-0.055078242,
0.0246680528,
0.0041264063,
0.0689934492,
0.0058253417,
0.0087797036,
-0.0121019185,
-0.0202741679,
-0.005627417,
0.0606573224,
-0.0052219951,
0.0132054016,
-0.0760817602,
-0.0147047453,
0.0253869444,
-0.0418094732,
-0.0326429904,
0.0325404033,
-0.0172422919,
-0.0070770252,
-0.057966128,
-0.0614421666,
0.0772115514,
0.0738487765,
-0.0227245893,
0.008938292,
-0.0330136828,
0.0451777019,
-0.0528886952,
0.0344948694,
-0.0342958383,
-0.0063976683,
-0.060031455,
-0.0101406202,
0.0329015702,
-0.0050712046,
-0.0378100909,
0.0054066679,
-0.059665747,
-0.0419206321,
-0.0455134585,
0.0482924841,
0.0210358705,
0.0033259541,
-0.0307747703,
-0.0119560743,
0.0232499056,
0.0296383332,
-0.0668331459,
-0.0215759389,
-0.00951338,
-0.0022789331,
-0.0104935262,
0.0361992419,
-0.0568954013,
-0.0069067236,
-0.02341621,
0.084127821,
-0.022025127,
-0.0535615757,
0.0654931664,
0.0711469576,
-0.006244448,
0.0267345197,
0.0278479327,
-0.0251703504,
0.0117252497,
0.0035893887,
-0.0037566004,
-0.046144817,
0.0029311157,
0.0158270244,
-0.0086017484,
-0.0132732103,
-0.0289062001,
-0.0256066918,
0.0402877964,
-0.0187949389,
-0.0523060337,
0.0430209897,
-0.0214353241,
0.0363063253,
-0.0179609545,
-0.0147695364,
0.0062404633,
0.0320717134,
0.0285096187,
-0.0217594858,
0.0493653864,
0.0120538296,
0.0003421412,
-0.0139488531,
0.0009804921,
-0.0246430226,
-0.0596379973,
-0.0407091081,
-0.00227294,
0.0604815744,
-0.0057392661,
0.0215503611,
-0.0121588418,
-0.0101917228,
0.009502843,
0.0106267035,
0.003106338,
0.0143072,
0.0563075207,
0.0266783647,
-0.005367652,
-0.0271857847,
0.087699689,
0.0437477082,
0.0666114092,
0.0331318378,
-0.0654375553,
-0.0264484938,
-0.0366825275,
0.0300821532,
-0.0123921055,
0.0027189904,
0.020874979,
-0.0382237658,
-0.0880544186,
0.0007653175,
0.0001799225,
-0.011662866,
0.0173279326,
0.0853418484,
0.0548739098,
0.0303822383,
-0.0405377597,
-0.0162987672,
-0.0197005384,
-0.0320715345,
-0.0239252076,
0.0038693692,
-6.282753554e-33,
-0.0339604802,
-0.0357376225,
0.0380517766,
-0.0095069669,
-0.0111638457,
-0.0436317995,
0.010646021,
-0.0135588646,
-0.039879214,
0.0026665279,
-0.0065902518,
0.0085517466,
0.0045703053,
0.0156359784,
-0.0213945936,
-0.0283332095,
0.0098492512,
-0.0125304982,
0.0349895842,
0.0187700503,
0.0398071185,
0.0448499322,
0.0345146172,
0.0060376883,
-0.0048260288,
-0.0122441193,
0.0008870575,
0.0258980226,
0.0149427494,
0.0500258654,
-0.0137684466,
0.0210445225,
0.0212343168,
-0.0192756932,
0.0162733495,
-0.0513096936,
-0.1013448834,
-0.0724574924,
0.003694843,
0.012785349,
-0.0075337975,
-0.0007154209,
0.0291159861,
-0.0280570276,
0.0413210951,
-0.0197548717,
0.0349702276,
0.0265568495,
-0.0005414945,
-0.0867578015,
-0.035501983,
0.0193090271,
-0.0070241559,
0.0163313337,
-0.0229243748,
-0.021138519,
0.0073934007,
-0.0131088756,
-0.0427208804,
-0.0064034807,
0.0242748912,
0.0089930231,
0.0020967103,
-0.0392526537,
0.0196639299,
-0.0019727512,
-0.0180715378,
-0.0320746712,
-0.0197541881,
0.0455906093,
-0.0111854188,
0.0291194767,
0.0142481551,
0.0456594564,
0.0679160655,
0.0014971212,
-0.070492968,
0.0405574217,
-0.0248027798,
0.0331357792,
-0.0413814485,
-0.0221682042,
-0.0389876328,
-0.0198456291,
-0.0397094898,
0.0248003006,
-0.0458001532,
-0.0639101863,
0.0478765778,
-0.0136825647,
0.0027097519,
0.0140722943,
-0.0024051103,
-0.0234510917,
-0.0031152877,
0.0451729633,
0.0048381728,
-0.0313768908,
-0.0105203325,
0.0394958444,
-0.0624569319,
0.0062639466,
0.0243740696,
-0.0304567963,
-0.0196484439,
0.0089645851,
-0.0280855894,
-0.0014465146,
-0.0620558858,
0.0011033242,
-0.0069016288,
0.0383625291,
-0.0156312902,
0.0033595434,
0.0112350294,
0.0223776773,
0.0086278729,
0.0194944888,
0.0292416923,
-0.0222388823,
-0.0175479762,
0.017287096,
0.0390934199,
0.00184817,
0.0048827142,
0.0077765197,
-0.0171984341,
-0.0210610386,
-0.0250046607,
-0.0537516885,
-0.0198097415,
0.0010812314,
2.632e-7,
0.0427389741,
0.0044804998,
0.0331413709,
0.0700038299,
-0.033886455,
-0.0083658267,
0.0295856334,
0.0627396628,
0.0193939172,
-0.0000204492,
0.0156314019,
0.0210828204,
-0.0182222687,
0.0641092286,
-0.1046150997,
0.0072867894,
-0.0042015766,
-0.0393630192,
-0.0529579222,
-0.0171716455,
0.0805310607,
0.0321548879,
0.0162658058,
0.0066529172,
-0.0131920194,
-0.0523170158,
0.0472514071,
0.0311847813,
-0.0035146116,
0.0386244729,
0.0430567898,
0.0050763655,
-0.0079174405,
0.0490502864,
-0.0185137074,
0.0164164025,
0.0201690421,
0.0259374827,
-0.0260216892,
-0.0330279022,
0.0172938537,
-0.0587281473,
0.0182635784,
-0.0308925509,
0.1025783718,
-0.0445017591,
0.0064561376,
0.1019520611,
-0.0452060364,
-0.0446795337,
0.0052231564,
-0.0440170802,
-0.0160657298,
0.0102374321,
0.0480988957,
0.0093713766,
0.0197603591,
-0.0613437705,
0.0412585512,
0.0315566808,
-0.0079344865,
-0.0251491796,
0.0098862275,
-0.0215413906,
0.0127245896,
0.0012978552,
-0.0038870745,
2.340367927e-34,
0.0104088066,
0.0401314013,
0.0261848345,
0.0251795668,
0.058838442,
-0.0064892061,
0.0109512135,
-0.0107610272,
0.0341078788,
-0.0743324012,
-0.0066905031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00956v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00956v2 | Exploring Spatial Schema Intuitions in Large Language and Vision Models | 2024-02-01T19:25:50 | 2024-05-27T14:29:31 | Philipp Wicke, Lennart Wachowiak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the ubiquity of large language models (LLMs) in AI research, the
question of embodiment in LLMs remains underexplored, distinguishing them from
embodied systems in robotics where sensory perception directly informs physical
action. Our investigation navigates the intriguing terrain of whether LLMs,
despite their non-embodied nature, effectively capture implicit human
intuitions about fundamental, spatial building blocks of language. We employ
insights from spatial cognitive foundations developed through early
sensorimotor experiences, guiding our exploration through the reproduction of
three psycholinguistic experiments. Surprisingly, correlations between model
outputs and human responses emerge, revealing adaptability without a tangible
connection to embodied experiences. Notable distinctions include polarized
language model responses and reduced correlations in vision language models.
This research contributes to a nuanced understanding of the interplay between
language, spatial experiences, and the computations made by large language
models. More at https://cisnlp.github.io/Spatial_Schemas/ | Exploring Spatial Schema Intuitions in Large Language and Vision Models: Despite the ubiquity of large language models (LLMs) in AI research, the
question of embodiment in LLMs remains underexplored, distinguishing them from
embodied systems in robotics where sensory perception directly informs physical
action. Our investigation navigates the intriguing terrain of whether LLMs,
despite their non-embodied nature, effectively capture implicit human
intuitions about fundamental, spatial building blocks of language. We employ
insights from spatial cognitive foundations developed through early
sensorimotor experiences, guiding our exploration through the reproduction of
three psycholinguistic experiments. Surprisingly, correlations between model
outputs and human responses emerge, revealing adaptability without a tangible
connection to embodied experiences. Notable distinctions include polarized
language model responses and reduced correlations in vision language models.
This research contributes to a nuanced understanding of the interplay between
language, spatial experiences, and the computations made by large language
models. More at https://cisnlp.github.io/Spatial_Schemas/ | [
0.0233351272,
0.0329131186,
-0.0569436029,
0.025527101,
-0.0405641198,
0.0174511243,
-0.0155260991,
0.0030488546,
0.011330314,
-0.0666136891,
-0.0665311441,
-0.0227630232,
0.0595853403,
0.0193254594,
0.0380322859,
-0.0713060871,
-0.0061620874,
-0.056565512,
-0.0359436609,
0.0052871373,
-0.0445399918,
-0.0094108516,
-0.0152518349,
0.0413452499,
-0.0100521687,
0.0341749862,
-0.0240932647,
-0.0176264402,
-0.0278773513,
-0.0253660604,
-0.0563965626,
-0.0284708925,
0.059761975,
0.0106101101,
0.0000017585,
-0.0219038185,
0.0449659564,
0.0030433089,
0.0376507305,
-0.0004858971,
0.0282590818,
-0.0543666966,
0.0099843461,
-0.029131256,
-0.0403364226,
-0.0356905386,
0.0819657296,
-0.0042904485,
-0.0344970711,
0.010652326,
-0.0209770389,
-0.0433128625,
0.0030442371,
0.0050988882,
-0.0069721388,
0.0697340742,
0.013630731,
0.0121243019,
0.0286895819,
0.0383199453,
-0.0847392306,
0.0042971107,
0.0326932594,
0.0404606909,
-0.0314832181,
0.0613178164,
0.0011539058,
-0.0329516158,
0.0092327213,
0.0421966128,
0.0020339496,
-0.0392694846,
0.0131441476,
0.0087765483,
-0.007258506,
0.0077343723,
-0.0376518592,
0.0493922271,
0.023501087,
0.0428406149,
-0.0506524742,
-0.0209549703,
-0.0028868923,
-0.0079878895,
-0.0306328814,
0.0961675197,
0.014427661,
0.0131425876,
-0.0309829134,
0.0064263563,
0.0001596131,
-0.0586469136,
-0.0157586467,
0.0394637063,
0.0077311127,
0.0132208522,
0.0016439949,
0.0522712842,
-0.0164273772,
-0.0458987206,
0.0888453946,
0.0299805515,
-0.0117764492,
0.0210417956,
-0.0315134414,
0.0927577689,
-0.0300430413,
0.0779577941,
-0.0396582633,
0.0234678816,
-0.0108230542,
-0.0132184485,
-0.0092236074,
0.0297145955,
-0.0310661867,
-0.0463948101,
0.0169495735,
0.050265871,
0.0037560714,
0.0012626004,
-0.053282544,
0.030046409,
0.0216967221,
0.0009505755,
-0.0255963411,
-0.0084915385,
0.0109081548,
0.0593895949,
-0.0643692762,
-0.060194239,
0.0016280721,
0.056859415,
-0.0238232352,
-0.0282913893,
-0.0392379798,
0.0563534871,
0.0605172403,
-0.0288232509,
0.0284368265,
0.010405086,
-0.0221777838,
0.0008563131,
0.0472760722,
-0.0243220683,
-0.0157098286,
0.0248268005,
-0.0158862788,
-0.0730612278,
-0.008408851,
-0.0156717077,
-0.0168594625,
0.0602761172,
0.0143881775,
0.0277751964,
0.0197954532,
-0.0071749506,
0.027745625,
0.0344735906,
0.0725823715,
0.044579532,
-0.0148967318,
-0.001750198,
0.0291322973,
0.0084928712,
-0.021533167,
0.0184256583,
-0.0816591159,
-0.0112592205,
0.0209078193,
0.038512297,
0.026891401,
0.0628597736,
-0.0043708752,
-0.0022195159,
0.0677538887,
0.1067554355,
-0.0423573479,
-0.0205899067,
0.0419097766,
-0.0157815684,
-0.0118415728,
-0.0132868038,
-0.0440001823,
0.0218565706,
0.0345419385,
-0.004340637,
-0.0307055693,
0.0163703095,
-0.0284753181,
-0.015242056,
-0.0358034857,
0.0050441264,
0.0212414619,
0.0056052818,
0.0311623663,
0.0110424925,
0.0090666059,
-0.002005605,
0.000377323,
-0.0254936889,
-0.0204211753,
-0.0240411665,
0.0086105587,
-0.0052750353,
-0.0097537385,
-0.0043624402,
0.0149724577,
0.017749086,
0.029474495,
0.0642777756,
0.0545769595,
0.0148262298,
0.0012696014,
0.0173472762,
-0.0036791884,
0.0031212976,
0.0297905393,
0.0229452252,
-0.0126775969,
0.0053796316,
0.0020343882,
-0.0458680615,
-0.0292845201,
0.0427782275,
-0.0287366845,
0.0043073767,
-0.06042476,
0.0082411813,
-0.0144722229,
-0.0370459668,
-0.03119036,
0.0519540384,
0.0237321146,
-0.0305822622,
0.0197331421,
0.0930237845,
-0.0246811416,
0.0310899019,
0.0265059602,
-0.0192098599,
0.050747104,
0.0046910732,
0.0205940083,
-0.0087058563,
0.053398747,
-0.0619706586,
0.0700755268,
0.0004279265,
0.0027811485,
-0.026452478,
0.0015043685,
-0.0483527221,
0.0204552785,
-0.0028175996,
-0.0039398405,
-0.0101644993,
0.0072699166,
0.0413542762,
0.0007890427,
0.007788619,
0.0328953564,
0.0161126666,
0.012653104,
-0.0021006435,
-0.0360159837,
-0.0551772006,
-0.0257428102,
-0.0588972531,
-0.0393719114,
0.0163121577,
-0.0058849859,
0.0089483755,
-0.0691498592,
-0.0239436254,
-0.0197679382,
0.0053735753,
0.0016071623,
-0.0085511226,
0.0428489856,
0.0371408239,
-0.0269776173,
-0.0381457955,
-0.0281270053,
0.0003086655,
-0.0272526667,
0.0454951078,
0.0177611075,
-0.007915793,
-0.050933592,
0.0241204929,
-0.0249917191,
0.0140355667,
0.006219238,
-0.0162708536,
0.0660139322,
-0.0293763448,
-0.0088244053,
0.0668716654,
-0.0312081035,
0.0775792971,
0.0854857266,
-0.0369121395,
-0.0211347267,
-0.0527428053,
-0.0268497299,
0.0121396091,
-0.0169698242,
-0.0385828353,
-0.0134211024,
0.0689744651,
0.01103797,
-0.0040734857,
-0.0479782261,
0.0634450242,
-0.0580247454,
-0.0556214415,
-0.0143399192,
0.0010069187,
-0.0306095704,
0.0579077378,
-0.0526567288,
-0.0538405292,
-0.0024279652,
-0.0462457724,
0.0157408807,
0.0244153272,
0.0472566672,
-0.0020669301,
0.140071854,
0.0474877916,
0.003883118,
0.0024695816,
-0.0048986864,
-0.024176307,
-0.0324201211,
-0.0300655738,
-0.0163027421,
-0.0193463396,
-0.100257419,
0.0057959878,
-0.0050192103,
-0.0218840763,
-0.0160830114,
0.029874865,
-0.0475523248,
0.023488082,
-0.0218940321,
-0.0410917178,
0.0166581869,
0.0451812074,
0.0672247335,
0.0334292762,
-0.0132066784,
-0.0084938258,
-0.0328028984,
-0.0084732324,
0.0597263761,
0.0863461047,
-0.0058759269,
-0.0024842401,
-0.02969799,
0.014962038,
-0.0140399272,
0.0483406335,
-0.0566599779,
0.0487524197,
0.0457302853,
0.0306991786,
-0.0382566974,
0.0145002771,
0.0708246008,
-0.0276496727,
-0.0519597828,
0.046378158,
0.0434273109,
0.0010844291,
0.0304917973,
-0.0349217281,
0.0149390139,
0.0554664694,
-0.0039136661,
-0.0102942055,
0.0183167979,
0.0126476306,
-0.0593647175,
0.0056118448,
-0.0463898443,
0.0006502226,
-0.1196159199,
0.0274448954,
0.0016207214,
-0.1081639826,
-0.0649331063,
-0.0206782073,
0.0282559413,
0.0532136708,
-0.026825089,
-0.0003923947,
-0.0125789149,
0.0338420831,
0.0152682364,
-0.000273122,
0.0233442318,
-0.0185961351,
-0.0230614468,
0.0240157954,
0.0252971146,
0.0516477041,
-0.0181481373,
-0.0465118326,
0.0092377439,
0.0030769678,
0.0365569629,
0.0058721052,
-0.0105750691,
0.0466088168,
-0.0102348607,
0.0098016299,
-0.000357248,
-0.0539979115,
-0.0291588828,
-0.0335406475,
0.0361925848,
-0.0735961199,
-0.0046218084,
-0.0119326217,
0.0286677424,
-0.0263714269,
0.0227870941,
0.0560122468,
-0.0411488675,
-0.0456377156,
-0.0149283987,
-0.0038326208,
0.0549367964,
-0.0896700919,
0.0303446595,
0.0506172515,
0.0086367726,
-0.0563682057,
-0.023793878,
0.0238406006,
0.0423252247,
0.0499838926,
-0.0327991247,
-0.0158985928,
-0.0474571325,
-0.0430946834,
0.047119081,
-0.022178404,
0.0038194982,
0.0201516729,
0.0248902384,
0.0271192528,
-0.0778097063,
-0.0049829544,
-0.0016437332,
-0.0248378646,
-0.0586489476,
0.0281600785,
0.035396684,
0.0258789733,
0.0107266046,
0.020197792,
-0.0047125285,
0.0321646295,
0.0178773757,
0.0112957237,
0.106417045,
-0.0165219158,
0.0247167069,
0.0230503492,
0.0213682875,
0.0021547452,
-0.0049048481,
0.0346307009,
-0.0050501321,
0.0032471211,
-0.0055416245,
0.0104176709,
-0.0150497397,
0.0659483448,
-0.0029364489,
-0.0125842132,
-0.0051993947,
-0.0484573916,
-0.0306289978,
0.0121410796,
-0.0293457974,
-0.0180691108,
0.0294185504,
0.0443010814,
-0.0132635934,
-0.0065536737,
-0.0021420296,
0.0556049459,
0.0486696288,
-0.0210347697,
0.0138902115,
-0.0084789526,
0.0015676722,
0.0532655865,
0.0021617857,
0.0538459979,
-0.0919343904,
0.0438757837,
0.0235226993,
-0.0211863685,
0.0335557833,
-0.036702916,
-0.0451659188,
0.0297139082,
-0.0257922858,
-0.1053482443,
0.0189612806,
0.019765405,
0.0459955223,
-0.0585889518,
0.0309219081,
-0.0681521222,
0.0188269801,
-0.0025632903,
0.0022069167,
0.0301808789,
-0.0188515391,
0.0301116742,
0.013754,
-0.0283375196,
0.0022594382,
0.0176452361,
-0.0193268619,
0.0371761508,
0.0208210107,
-0.0112559041,
-0.0017823859,
-0.003468347,
0.0315370783,
-0.0161980167,
-0.0117696002,
0.0246268399,
-0.0540145114,
-0.0562712625,
0.0042613116,
0.0287718661,
-0.0046103424,
-0.0078321723,
0.0601194799,
0.0248890463,
0.0009942317,
0.0009511141,
-0.0188230854,
0.0060723205,
0.0039491672,
-0.0181488581,
0.0075505832,
-5.251507788e-33,
-0.0245107021,
-0.0554997548,
0.029347185,
-0.0096357726,
-0.0209480263,
0.0037324631,
-0.0511930324,
0.0325935744,
-0.040030539,
0.0101435333,
0.0226233248,
-0.0100371093,
-0.0035589777,
0.0115328254,
0.0495741814,
0.0298985224,
-0.0191079807,
-0.029683806,
-0.0140572051,
-0.0419865735,
0.0417783,
-0.0338062309,
0.0215578023,
-0.0669103563,
0.0003929069,
0.0609094501,
-0.00426149,
0.0144450516,
-0.0209136978,
0.0201319475,
-0.0634736121,
0.0244242344,
0.034163218,
0.0164783895,
-0.0131174764,
0.0308748297,
-0.0052618505,
-0.045439031,
0.0198019315,
0.0453253165,
-0.0532632805,
-0.0191623401,
0.0566363893,
-0.0432148762,
-0.0484382212,
0.0280441158,
0.0173872504,
-0.0385772176,
-0.0298502855,
0.05151207,
-0.0520079732,
-0.0188909248,
0.0187924057,
-0.0362580568,
0.0340110287,
-0.0268806256,
0.0065877098,
0.0430081524,
-0.0312170908,
0.0388661288,
-0.038147755,
0.0168166105,
0.0419047922,
0.0282866787,
0.065520823,
0.0878014788,
0.0845995918,
0.0129321553,
-0.0353030637,
-0.0373116881,
0.0904399082,
0.0030988995,
-0.0106260804,
0.0259294957,
-0.0319598056,
-0.0115867853,
-0.004656842,
-0.032170102,
-0.0476393327,
0.0263480581,
0.0330926403,
0.0023706413,
-0.0256738961,
-0.0121172061,
-0.0321492441,
-0.0640036166,
-0.0173822623,
0.0179393589,
0.0030620284,
-0.0320767909,
0.0597048961,
0.0019274381,
0.024551969,
-0.0520082153,
-0.0402880944,
-0.0401495658,
-0.0501383692,
0.0332811885,
0.0078764437,
0.0251179151,
0.0033063963,
-0.0301239416,
-0.0123459911,
0.0485357493,
-0.0029524809,
0.0298195276,
-0.0139316786,
0.0404251069,
-0.0104188621,
-0.0311505198,
-0.0284913536,
-0.0844713002,
0.0389201269,
-0.0252051707,
0.0411529504,
0.0205290876,
-0.0289152078,
0.0039311335,
-0.0063731535,
-0.0058770911,
-0.0096370829,
0.0061676446,
-0.082769312,
0.0223161653,
-0.0290076118,
-0.0271294881,
-0.0469047688,
0.0101777883,
0.0659256577,
-0.0419376828,
-0.0314366296,
-0.0419350713,
2.679e-7,
0.0357631445,
0.0569957197,
0.0257210862,
-0.0166233703,
0.049093198,
0.0132015226,
-0.0043474291,
0.0273528788,
-0.0292356052,
-0.0242851004,
-0.0011800734,
0.047150176,
0.0184425991,
-0.0287226737,
-0.0536833443,
0.0679832473,
-0.0090691419,
-0.0069946763,
-0.0416536219,
0.0388990343,
0.0087313214,
0.0205516126,
-0.0063370545,
-0.0087202732,
-0.0275795329,
-0.0019784623,
0.0306793544,
-0.0891862959,
0.070024237,
-0.040667776,
-0.0109939529,
-0.032820832,
-0.0059463587,
-0.0001372636,
0.028434515,
-0.0238013864,
0.0107814325,
0.0108890729,
-0.0298128091,
-0.0008462788,
-0.0013772025,
-0.0150747197,
-0.0316534676,
-0.0905707479,
0.0502693467,
-0.1017523855,
-0.0218620487,
0.0074775405,
0.025130868,
0.0012678133,
0.0224337541,
0.0136471419,
-0.00108431,
-0.0225299634,
0.0113596721,
-0.0087306295,
-0.0218416248,
-0.0292422958,
-0.0266062357,
0.0159669816,
-0.0529209301,
-0.0266735088,
-0.0322218575,
-0.0159809459,
0.0120251421,
-0.0481720418,
-0.0399000011,
1.978579923e-34,
-0.0013936608,
0.0289354585,
0.0191587713,
-0.0164310224,
0.0086464928,
-0.0193090551,
0.032316573,
0.0206929296,
0.0272323806,
-0.0462610722,
-0.0176386442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01781v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01781v2 | When Benchmarks are Targets: Revealing the Sensitivity of Large Language Model Leaderboards | 2024-02-01T19:12:25 | 2024-07-03T11:20:43 | Norah Alzahrani, Hisham Abdullah Alyahya, Yazeed Alnumay, Sultan Alrashed, Shaykhah Alsubaie, Yusef Almushaykeh, Faisal Mirza, Nouf Alotaibi, Nora Altwairesh, Areeb Alowisheq, M Saiful Bari, Haidar Khan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Model (LLM) leaderboards based on benchmark rankings are
regularly used to guide practitioners in model selection. Often, the published
leaderboard rankings are taken at face value - we show this is a (potentially
costly) mistake. Under existing leaderboards, the relative performance of LLMs
is highly sensitive to (often minute) details. We show that for popular
multiple-choice question benchmarks (e.g., MMLU), minor perturbations to the
benchmark, such as changing the order of choices or the method of answer
selection, result in changes in rankings up to 8 positions. We explain this
phenomenon by conducting systematic experiments over three broad categories of
benchmark perturbations and identifying the sources of this behavior. Our
analysis results in several best-practice recommendations, including the
advantage of a hybrid scoring method for answer selection. Our study highlights
the dangers of relying on simple benchmark evaluations and charts the path for
more robust evaluation schemes on the existing benchmarks. The code for this
paper is available at
https://github.com/National-Center-for-AI-Saudi-Arabia/lm-evaluation-harness. | When Benchmarks are Targets: Revealing the Sensitivity of Large Language Model Leaderboards: Large Language Model (LLM) leaderboards based on benchmark rankings are
regularly used to guide practitioners in model selection. Often, the published
leaderboard rankings are taken at face value - we show this is a (potentially
costly) mistake. Under existing leaderboards, the relative performance of LLMs
is highly sensitive to (often minute) details. We show that for popular
multiple-choice question benchmarks (e.g., MMLU), minor perturbations to the
benchmark, such as changing the order of choices or the method of answer
selection, result in changes in rankings up to 8 positions. We explain this
phenomenon by conducting systematic experiments over three broad categories of
benchmark perturbations and identifying the sources of this behavior. Our
analysis results in several best-practice recommendations, including the
advantage of a hybrid scoring method for answer selection. Our study highlights
the dangers of relying on simple benchmark evaluations and charts the path for
more robust evaluation schemes on the existing benchmarks. The code for this
paper is available at
https://github.com/National-Center-for-AI-Saudi-Arabia/lm-evaluation-harness. | [
0.0169463269,
0.0776604488,
-0.0172421262,
0.0556237623,
-0.0335127749,
0.0085482532,
0.012924945,
0.0150855714,
0.0189844836,
-0.0439954065,
-0.026181858,
-0.0266867448,
0.007896103,
-0.0192707554,
0.046973411,
-0.0095312148,
0.0422609895,
-0.0465841591,
0.0005373964,
-0.030150488,
-0.0388462283,
-0.019129049,
0.0013428257,
0.0124737294,
0.0483494923,
0.0061456091,
0.0197746195,
-0.013961901,
0.009414399,
-0.047829587,
-0.0296183415,
0.058404725,
-0.0199562069,
0.0198546369,
0.0000020952,
-0.062291339,
-0.0108202826,
-0.0132216727,
-0.0281580333,
0.0605701581,
-0.0232106186,
0.0527178384,
0.0009112457,
0.0073363227,
-0.0399363264,
0.0177855697,
0.0061908038,
-0.0273849368,
0.0432463884,
0.0325283259,
0.0201427042,
0.0071481434,
0.0192932319,
-0.0252435841,
-0.0000599912,
-0.0496543832,
0.0213298034,
0.0285866577,
0.0225583557,
0.0160658658,
-0.0494929589,
0.0116580138,
-0.0015678197,
0.0082500502,
0.0162031222,
0.0411213152,
-0.0550293028,
0.0107370345,
0.025183877,
0.0877154917,
-0.0468704551,
-0.0031291046,
-0.0008030618,
-0.0163621642,
0.007910653,
0.0112330085,
-0.0744591057,
0.0087724682,
0.0245774351,
-0.01442191,
0.0468063317,
0.0031167509,
0.0314922333,
0.0205246862,
-0.0519076474,
0.0964160413,
0.0326294899,
-0.0420405753,
0.0378066488,
-0.0011929558,
-0.0402067155,
-0.059853524,
0.0100369938,
0.0023349784,
-0.0525872484,
0.0258053597,
0.0141663896,
0.0155498693,
0.0277254432,
-0.0418662094,
0.0600089319,
0.0220644437,
0.0117500983,
0.0502853431,
-0.0249161422,
0.1111063585,
0.0099805109,
0.041995097,
-0.0630315617,
0.0268604364,
0.000407116,
-0.0023498291,
0.0472272225,
0.0282847509,
0.0003261691,
0.0066570835,
-0.0613066778,
-0.0033744895,
-0.0239539482,
0.0222959556,
0.0014962781,
-0.0093908235,
0.0185868759,
0.0381822214,
-0.0303310603,
0.0290469509,
-0.0378377065,
-0.0000246661,
0.0064426735,
-0.0606673062,
0.0094094211,
0.0026884528,
-0.019894015,
-0.0286952984,
0.0394191444,
0.0572808906,
-0.014748021,
-0.0071720402,
0.062624529,
0.0001055847,
-0.0175995864,
-0.0514526963,
0.0169647653,
-0.092357032,
0.0319580585,
0.0373355821,
0.0180154555,
-0.0076016607,
0.0192913003,
0.0362410508,
-0.0056237062,
0.0138958506,
0.0293886214,
-0.0030870379,
0.0165152475,
0.0122933835,
-0.0090096844,
0.0575866103,
0.0231936034,
0.0207861401,
0.0486280881,
-0.0548027419,
-0.0021671341,
0.0578063317,
0.0057656346,
0.0115145445,
-0.0102002248,
0.0652124509,
0.0123352092,
0.042597089,
-0.0269002505,
0.0406932831,
-0.0112453736,
-0.0262969863,
0.0714550614,
0.0743975267,
-0.0065794149,
-0.0136514949,
-0.0211403333,
-0.039692916,
0.0289846603,
0.012772142,
-0.0263726432,
0.0027668024,
-0.0183879938,
-0.0064930846,
0.0093560331,
0.0377765112,
-0.0006972883,
-0.0635760948,
-0.0137619292,
0.0280109439,
-0.0314658992,
0.051517047,
0.0410564765,
-0.0385754704,
-0.0168583654,
0.0474107191,
-0.012211022,
-0.0392265394,
0.0055429693,
-0.0581391491,
-0.0130236037,
0.0016703701,
0.0518328287,
-0.0238872562,
-0.040820837,
0.0022944936,
-0.0084682247,
0.0123049207,
0.059532214,
-0.02859997,
-0.01125398,
-0.0191513393,
0.0033701742,
-0.0024093499,
0.0042447201,
0.0018111479,
-0.0005041922,
-0.0020821949,
-0.0243959241,
-0.0550082214,
-0.0441768095,
0.0231523644,
-0.0099499589,
-0.0443397313,
0.0012340281,
-0.0391614176,
0.0417269282,
0.0023268729,
-0.0096045863,
0.0133355809,
0.0429508351,
-0.00913327,
-0.0149715208,
-0.0273203664,
-0.0445269495,
-0.0204075295,
0.0442913659,
-0.0182024222,
-0.0161387157,
0.0982472673,
-0.0433535129,
-0.0306711439,
-0.0106328512,
0.0011929136,
0.0024635103,
0.0191543326,
0.053107582,
-0.0353489183,
-0.0065358249,
-0.0774695054,
0.0745421872,
-0.0143355345,
0.0621946827,
0.0369636379,
0.0364812389,
0.0159303583,
-0.0181247965,
-0.0270128902,
0.0794355795,
-0.0243550017,
0.0180667192,
0.0269724168,
-0.0048986515,
-0.0795926079,
-0.0281746536,
-0.0886061713,
0.0042378176,
-0.0125653874,
0.0005931789,
0.017754063,
-0.0175538976,
-0.0042815832,
-0.0120046129,
-0.0370328352,
-0.0299748387,
0.0294046234,
0.0426765569,
0.0147695467,
-0.0029562882,
0.0028227025,
-0.0636340603,
-0.0486115701,
-0.0140570467,
0.0679389462,
-0.0043200972,
0.0381176956,
-0.0066524087,
0.0383101776,
-0.0789038613,
-0.0221728068,
-0.0188630223,
-0.0128937075,
0.0221235063,
-0.0213535205,
0.0161127616,
0.0745180324,
0.0111722481,
0.0186471064,
0.0713354945,
-0.005031975,
-0.0706162602,
-0.0133006899,
0.0128347734,
-0.0219295155,
-0.0451454297,
-0.055663608,
0.0181307495,
0.0439725555,
0.0037200644,
-0.0087798042,
0.0035436775,
0.0526032299,
-0.0804561973,
-0.0262409057,
-0.084732838,
0.0266646445,
-0.0274728313,
0.0632428676,
-0.0061949356,
-0.0555297807,
0.0359635279,
-0.0199301708,
0.0050600949,
-0.0595061071,
0.0084391758,
-0.0410257168,
0.0194628704,
0.0292840749,
0.0062560681,
-0.0545370206,
-0.000851111,
-0.0644215494,
-0.0300901067,
0.0118949283,
-0.060255453,
0.0515666232,
-0.0359191149,
0.0024990039,
-0.016633125,
-0.0604413599,
-0.0269187074,
-0.0318592861,
-0.0337302387,
0.0167698916,
0.0375555567,
-0.0114359437,
0.0095626861,
-0.0293163229,
0.0297375303,
0.0135397017,
-0.0409960635,
-0.0039891852,
-0.0019807043,
0.0623535141,
0.0532140955,
-0.0005220778,
0.0591448769,
-0.0496565588,
0.0490475297,
0.0567150861,
0.089762643,
0.0169123616,
0.0078938175,
0.0160019286,
0.0478682518,
-0.0575160868,
-0.0398449115,
0.0496713445,
0.0365408659,
-0.024424389,
-0.0014907693,
0.1048815772,
0.0412650891,
0.0035005703,
0.0236864127,
0.0060275048,
0.0323225595,
0.020314794,
0.0406554826,
-0.0426497683,
0.014543321,
0.0036473821,
0.0226732399,
-0.0274708848,
-0.0300118253,
0.0141451061,
-0.1242933497,
0.0229592659,
-0.0076399432,
-0.0526068285,
0.042035941,
-0.0572952665,
0.0009542294,
-0.014249837,
0.0103285071,
0.0401525609,
-0.0176956151,
0.0156785343,
0.0202615373,
-0.061771661,
-0.045160614,
0.0503142029,
-0.0167125221,
0.0392840207,
0.0176251121,
0.049780421,
-0.0522127412,
-0.0069503081,
0.0437475406,
-0.0394993946,
-0.0174414348,
-0.0402297825,
0.0329753906,
0.0307936054,
0.0036277436,
-0.0273538511,
-0.0184734091,
-0.0021802229,
0.0336071514,
0.0304732919,
0.0689330697,
0.01610245,
-0.0394941419,
0.0039014288,
-0.006058624,
-0.0427612513,
0.0535126999,
0.0172979347,
-0.0386085175,
-0.0189727191,
-0.0656332299,
-0.0068231709,
-0.0130952038,
-0.0672024712,
0.0010788627,
0.0116364919,
0.0224730484,
-0.0302694924,
-0.046107579,
0.0210229978,
0.0078743473,
-0.0066048945,
0.0492478833,
-0.0202698782,
-0.0002936809,
0.001332512,
0.009483221,
0.0077104778,
0.0156696569,
-0.0482566506,
0.0205760915,
0.0511923023,
0.0153511725,
-0.0398094915,
-0.0212359242,
-0.0654637292,
-0.0358384401,
0.0009436103,
0.0556993373,
0.0207105689,
-0.0176454093,
0.0260336027,
-0.0537619479,
-0.0006550744,
-0.0150039308,
0.0209397264,
0.0395991914,
-0.0079903351,
-0.0401167311,
-0.01759132,
0.0027500887,
-0.0367614441,
0.0123286936,
0.0647050738,
0.0458133444,
-0.0181788728,
-0.0183483269,
0.0244615749,
0.0580949076,
0.0135537712,
0.0002453991,
-0.0198078305,
0.0153313642,
0.0292787515,
-0.0329138972,
-0.0202286392,
0.0063266684,
-0.0358587056,
0.0310096219,
0.0078084571,
-0.0206151512,
0.0200227443,
0.0009559767,
0.0336932689,
-0.0809534043,
0.0323182382,
0.0197997745,
0.0095078703,
0.0285081677,
-0.0036532432,
-0.0508755296,
-0.0004731825,
0.0101865781,
0.0901608169,
-0.0055508837,
0.0266194306,
-0.0073722461,
-0.0264765937,
0.0324435718,
0.0409916043,
-0.0935454369,
-0.063312985,
-0.0208844692,
0.0141839003,
0.0678238422,
0.0021813693,
0.0564527884,
0.0208882447,
-0.0166920293,
-0.0405102521,
-0.0500959307,
0.0160570219,
-0.030751599,
0.0049276357,
0.0308168717,
0.0070809713,
0.0454833694,
0.0597341694,
0.0448399484,
-0.0030663041,
0.0354072154,
0.0117911492,
-0.0294638854,
-0.0115122516,
-0.0106005594,
0.0154076172,
-0.011932198,
-0.0208243523,
-0.0770645663,
-0.0765419602,
0.0086759143,
0.0285184886,
0.0306499302,
-0.0220485386,
0.011215318,
0.061971359,
-0.0124861859,
-0.0161862485,
-0.0599910133,
-0.0025857629,
-0.065264523,
-0.0250561181,
-0.0142404651,
-6.178663529e-33,
-0.0268286243,
-0.024430709,
0.0166083332,
-0.0412949547,
0.0070556793,
0.0054229083,
-0.0073774909,
0.0211989954,
-0.040199589,
-0.017412411,
-0.0564241111,
-0.0163299441,
0.0000317148,
0.0145268077,
0.0249005333,
-0.0374253131,
0.0127627887,
-0.0015172346,
-0.0559791401,
-0.0008118027,
-0.0013471834,
-0.0013969037,
0.0375969596,
-0.0433425941,
0.0135161187,
0.0009915081,
0.0106403902,
-0.0099721896,
-0.0560855083,
0.0651244074,
0.0090955542,
0.0569379404,
0.0280820001,
-0.0473600961,
-0.0089191934,
-0.021257665,
-0.0161903296,
-0.05090262,
0.0182831455,
0.0094939163,
-0.0029297904,
-0.0109253023,
0.0244216546,
0.0149604836,
-0.0635715574,
-0.0333291069,
0.0241658762,
-0.0317290388,
-0.0479715578,
-0.0039180177,
-0.0208192077,
0.0269836541,
-0.0287014786,
0.0476111397,
-0.0304973125,
0.0593070202,
-0.014531468,
0.0164159741,
-0.0177242234,
0.0205746237,
0.0578410439,
0.0538121872,
0.0872511044,
0.0298884418,
-0.0216382165,
0.056162376,
0.0339285359,
0.0329783633,
0.0554416366,
-0.0446832031,
0.0157077741,
0.021234164,
0.0886816531,
0.0295125879,
0.042952098,
0.0273425058,
-0.0930018649,
0.0311625469,
0.0378395878,
-0.0186343286,
0.0108749345,
0.0021936765,
-0.0518853627,
-0.03134045,
-0.078214936,
0.0316584595,
-0.0383538157,
-0.0264722556,
0.0637444407,
-0.0377216935,
-0.0224515684,
-0.0120196538,
0.0394936688,
-0.0306118503,
-0.0490778983,
0.0029244099,
-0.0002299767,
0.0427716784,
0.0086147534,
0.0390995257,
-0.0458271652,
0.021903418,
-0.0185255408,
0.0066691586,
0.0264210999,
0.0048495992,
-0.0363455191,
-0.0138013503,
-0.0369669497,
-0.0091929147,
-0.0271649547,
-0.0436775684,
0.0085101454,
-0.0094629535,
0.0205698404,
-0.0146436645,
0.0087976977,
0.0499329567,
0.0181450918,
-0.0092551522,
-0.0464421138,
0.0058995932,
-0.0058836848,
-0.0047762375,
-0.0089359265,
-0.0115695335,
-0.0394767337,
0.0555613302,
0.0196358338,
-0.0415724553,
-0.0198375881,
-0.0020946998,
2.696e-7,
0.0547090955,
0.084853217,
-0.0380197614,
0.0226936713,
0.0137316613,
0.0111126984,
-0.0383437425,
0.0098045906,
0.0702077746,
0.0396918356,
-0.0086843884,
-0.0041160416,
0.0384488851,
0.0494889729,
-0.0441124029,
-0.0393047966,
-0.0637901872,
0.0051436843,
-0.0706575513,
-0.0020060337,
0.0339758731,
0.052493155,
-0.0187743772,
-0.0062783388,
-0.0492516868,
-0.0210435055,
0.0407273285,
-0.0670941249,
-0.0052206554,
0.025959231,
0.0163582191,
0.0012749363,
0.0128742652,
0.0287978165,
-0.012083835,
-0.0079588126,
0.0538529456,
0.0481135435,
0.0093274908,
-0.013338075,
-0.0066782525,
-0.0064158011,
0.0124185234,
-0.0981271565,
0.0942500457,
-0.0348162353,
-0.0314629041,
-0.0427484401,
-0.0449346043,
-0.0332538299,
0.042181965,
-0.0174174998,
-0.0147185093,
0.0081368536,
-0.003041564,
0.0057244333,
-0.003657544,
-0.0139418347,
-0.0346420966,
0.0104165301,
-0.0258659832,
-0.1007635072,
-0.0368613563,
-0.0053492058,
-0.0353780538,
-0.0266480017,
-0.0238057151,
2.777597642e-34,
0.0056930957,
-0.0002215937,
0.0544382259,
0.0019937463,
0.0284940731,
-0.0039805127,
-0.0027156204,
0.0135237062,
0.0059914277,
-0.100649029,
-0.009542821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00861v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00861v2 | Evaluating Large Language Models for Generalization and Robustness via Data Compression | 2024-02-01T18:56:18 | 2024-02-04T01:16:25 | Yucheng Li, Yunhao Guo, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing methods for evaluating large language models face challenges such as
data contamination, sensitivity to prompts, and the high cost of benchmark
creation. To address this, we propose a lossless data compression based
evaluation approach that tests how models' predictive abilities generalize
after their training cutoff. Specifically, we collect comprehensive test data
spanning 83 months from 2017 to 2023 and split the data into training and
testing periods according to models' training data cutoff. We measure: 1) the
compression performance on the testing period as a measure of generalization on
unseen data; and 2) the performance gap between the training and testing period
as a measure of robustness. Our experiments test 14 representative large
language models with various sizes on sources including Wikipedia, news
articles, code, arXiv papers, and multi-modal data. We find that the
compression rate of many models reduces significantly after their cutoff date,
but models such as Mistral and Llama-2 demonstrate a good balance between
performance and robustness. Results also suggest that models struggle to
generalize on news and code data, but work especially well on arXiv papers. We
also find the context size and tokenization implementation have a big impact of
on the overall compression performance. | Evaluating Large Language Models for Generalization and Robustness via Data Compression: Existing methods for evaluating large language models face challenges such as
data contamination, sensitivity to prompts, and the high cost of benchmark
creation. To address this, we propose a lossless data compression based
evaluation approach that tests how models' predictive abilities generalize
after their training cutoff. Specifically, we collect comprehensive test data
spanning 83 months from 2017 to 2023 and split the data into training and
testing periods according to models' training data cutoff. We measure: 1) the
compression performance on the testing period as a measure of generalization on
unseen data; and 2) the performance gap between the training and testing period
as a measure of robustness. Our experiments test 14 representative large
language models with various sizes on sources including Wikipedia, news
articles, code, arXiv papers, and multi-modal data. We find that the
compression rate of many models reduces significantly after their cutoff date,
but models such as Mistral and Llama-2 demonstrate a good balance between
performance and robustness. Results also suggest that models struggle to
generalize on news and code data, but work especially well on arXiv papers. We
also find the context size and tokenization implementation have a big impact of
on the overall compression performance. | [
0.0198734421,
0.1124004051,
-0.0000662271,
0.0124112889,
-0.0212875474,
0.0022573033,
0.0105025806,
0.0643052012,
-0.0147027373,
-0.0218789764,
-0.0069479225,
-0.0279417112,
0.0064250557,
0.0352106281,
0.0247125719,
-0.0368987396,
0.0376625918,
-0.03483475,
0.014526573,
-0.0101647526,
0.0161661059,
-0.0261413213,
0.0674390569,
0.0491754189,
0.0294566359,
0.0061818333,
-0.0071606077,
-0.0092975898,
-0.0427216068,
-0.0175404754,
-0.012668442,
0.0732739717,
0.0392638147,
0.0617379174,
0.0000017352,
-0.0682694614,
-0.0089013595,
0.0310011711,
-0.0351925492,
0.0408525243,
0.0568961576,
-0.065086633,
0.005677409,
0.0025081339,
0.0003492976,
-0.0473990813,
0.0445249975,
0.034620028,
0.04044291,
0.0452207327,
0.0017989617,
-0.0113053154,
0.0573207028,
-0.0337326042,
-0.0091227908,
-0.0254445039,
0.0235895924,
0.0044829543,
-0.0105206501,
0.0262684431,
-0.0376683436,
0.028291814,
0.0237266663,
0.001821868,
-0.0186785012,
0.0302401111,
-0.0667853206,
-0.0342248715,
0.0035806422,
0.0416652523,
0.0039644102,
-0.0510556586,
0.0047203526,
0.0099999513,
-0.0061041936,
0.011490142,
-0.0703287646,
0.0192202628,
0.0181512814,
0.0003361787,
0.0160820205,
-0.0031995021,
0.0525697991,
0.0097450595,
-0.0185650792,
0.0538317822,
0.0174431354,
-0.0381993093,
0.0244459491,
-0.0044181054,
-0.0315783657,
-0.0472845212,
-0.019947717,
0.0131382504,
0.0014264485,
0.0119704502,
-0.0590801574,
-0.0449358448,
0.0592450686,
-0.0595232062,
0.0100097926,
0.0168749858,
-0.003345059,
0.0553670712,
-0.0441247597,
0.0408610553,
-0.0160284098,
0.0171086211,
0.0033523731,
-0.0228374284,
-0.0347635597,
-0.0022903101,
-0.0094492026,
0.052121602,
0.0066261655,
0.0001219747,
-0.0353382342,
0.0159024745,
0.0143261282,
0.0278537571,
0.0387993902,
-0.020932667,
-0.0352330916,
-0.0090028122,
0.0027327393,
0.0039487598,
-0.0398376584,
0.0167995766,
0.0041353637,
-0.0445430242,
-0.0046707164,
0.0188565794,
0.0108804265,
-0.0297454633,
0.0213391352,
0.0632457584,
0.02577498,
-0.0342206843,
-0.0257893037,
-0.0210732147,
-0.0022937546,
-0.0499655828,
-0.0163736735,
-0.0692873672,
0.0121643515,
0.023569854,
0.0070281499,
-0.0442640223,
-0.023897009,
-0.0010093803,
-0.0575288832,
0.0358071551,
-0.0133855408,
0.0028666961,
0.0111183189,
0.0021377217,
0.0135324467,
0.0917838737,
0.0252254512,
0.0077138846,
0.0587809198,
-0.0258636624,
-0.0078411903,
0.0339829959,
0.0690804571,
0.0327287577,
-0.0313470252,
0.0282078497,
0.0157069042,
0.0195271578,
0.0301485825,
0.0756059438,
-0.0400932841,
-0.0387647338,
0.043886859,
0.0449632518,
0.0331370756,
0.0322135985,
0.0312755518,
-0.0209862031,
0.0165059697,
-0.0054920153,
-0.0421536043,
-0.0179312099,
-0.0399046205,
0.0142704686,
0.0397721641,
0.0114004137,
-0.0264391154,
-0.0314353295,
-0.0342398286,
-0.021486653,
0.0456935614,
-0.029324919,
0.0630051866,
-0.0156318899,
-0.0256198104,
0.0517720282,
0.0323372595,
-0.0483861081,
0.006218038,
-0.0593079589,
0.0297579356,
0.0170978438,
0.0628199726,
-0.0063392762,
0.028982481,
-0.0270218793,
0.0231353175,
-0.016646659,
0.0305794198,
-0.0231461097,
0.0135699036,
-0.0427027866,
-0.0306551512,
0.0241302215,
0.0274277888,
-0.0108435852,
0.0483959503,
0.0262321904,
0.0126192598,
-0.0808249414,
-0.0495390631,
0.0401124358,
-0.0482984781,
-0.008240222,
-0.0116611207,
-0.0167239774,
0.0373569876,
-0.0146315377,
-0.0191772003,
-0.0042805774,
0.0609517209,
-0.0248312913,
-0.005911395,
-0.0205031373,
-0.0135074612,
-0.0118882498,
0.0344868042,
-0.0223732386,
0.0358923562,
0.0520595498,
-0.02546327,
-0.0326489247,
0.0228042565,
-0.0248289611,
0.0557081215,
-0.0304596052,
0.0035290776,
-0.0591198355,
0.0508380383,
-0.0149266878,
0.0358920433,
-0.0384449847,
0.0497416109,
0.0125050321,
-0.0131849954,
0.0166602973,
-0.0200456902,
-0.0752295107,
0.0358703621,
-0.0291658621,
0.0230673589,
0.0494269691,
-0.0062791896,
-0.0105724204,
-0.0116092153,
-0.1033419222,
-0.0073533254,
-0.0390992351,
0.0125627145,
0.0156219369,
-0.0035434722,
0.0012332681,
-0.0001739306,
-0.018660428,
-0.0125401095,
0.0105560282,
0.0312771797,
0.0277282763,
0.013652483,
-0.0202910863,
-0.0515567362,
-0.060442213,
-0.0121050868,
0.1102372482,
-0.0222135466,
-0.0136082638,
-0.0279668029,
0.0516091324,
-0.0257907044,
0.004679013,
-0.0189575553,
-0.0344012007,
-0.0076295533,
-0.027262412,
-0.0011705166,
0.0520341396,
0.0008722812,
0.0217177086,
0.0694099069,
0.0255029909,
-0.057787016,
-0.0108298715,
-0.0091591356,
-0.0232501328,
-0.0433092415,
-0.0471057668,
0.0036964065,
0.0750898048,
-0.0102904728,
-0.0049295346,
-0.0579728521,
-0.0294211172,
-0.0363349393,
-0.0130858831,
-0.031493213,
-0.0125514111,
0.00906213,
0.0631612316,
0.0148265976,
-0.0751260743,
0.0680867508,
-0.0279337857,
0.0148447379,
0.0034759718,
-0.0215432197,
-0.0521826036,
0.0626890585,
-0.0059737628,
0.0155512122,
0.0098689329,
0.00014138,
-0.0449685231,
0.0041658822,
0.0034387377,
-0.0351509601,
0.0306073651,
-0.0253193695,
0.0212358814,
-0.0133788772,
-0.0172446165,
0.0004199641,
-0.031490352,
0.0023761194,
0.0288267825,
0.0453665443,
-0.0245972034,
-0.021705674,
0.0318497457,
0.0017562212,
0.0611607023,
-0.0001883825,
-0.0237819534,
0.0228486061,
0.0190537479,
0.0406463072,
-0.0063953553,
0.0281435475,
-0.0229786392,
0.0194880459,
0.0270726532,
0.0469116233,
0.0328951031,
-0.0473937802,
-0.018782841,
0.0273048133,
-0.0257906038,
-0.0292370915,
0.0324691571,
0.0444326885,
-0.0544819869,
-0.0199184362,
0.1012912616,
0.0214017145,
-0.0397611968,
-0.0009765563,
0.0004762622,
0.0756636113,
0.0117807211,
0.0155658284,
-0.0696974844,
-0.0061747641,
0.0135057494,
0.0266135167,
0.0067383964,
-0.0461369567,
0.0044837128,
-0.0860825554,
0.0173182301,
-0.005525216,
-0.0219099093,
-0.0157206152,
-0.089539744,
0.0101530841,
-0.0463051461,
0.0332071967,
0.0098144757,
-0.0152165564,
0.0005336477,
0.0242084917,
-0.0567410737,
-0.0830150247,
0.0212834012,
0.0027075009,
0.039109122,
0.0322117321,
0.0147586055,
-0.0225274786,
0.0056387675,
0.0322748944,
0.0227362346,
-0.0301125888,
-0.0128655545,
0.0605640672,
0.0252200812,
0.0160495955,
0.0259764753,
0.0381774269,
-0.0141592938,
0.0122144092,
-0.0005683798,
0.0762537941,
0.0086092362,
-0.0447100922,
-0.0399631113,
-0.0456746072,
-0.0345935076,
0.0881221518,
0.0403912328,
-0.0253743101,
-0.035516534,
-0.0294410121,
-0.0033050575,
-0.0066158846,
-0.024285512,
-0.018438112,
-0.0016195156,
-0.0253941845,
-0.0708658993,
-0.0287371464,
0.0016153568,
0.0250070523,
-0.0050370004,
0.010559747,
-0.0136863468,
0.0140313711,
-0.0671040043,
-0.0033616282,
-0.012053878,
-0.0073467568,
-0.0779358521,
0.0371501371,
0.0140478183,
0.0090530831,
-0.0422384441,
0.019016305,
-0.1284223944,
-0.0675307587,
-0.0043961746,
0.0364913531,
0.0317641534,
0.0341489613,
-0.0026819406,
-0.0834198594,
0.0545391701,
0.0480733365,
-0.0228120461,
0.0221939106,
0.0473196022,
-0.0387447178,
0.0021458555,
0.0412606522,
-0.0590845309,
0.008015112,
-0.0245881863,
-0.0039204992,
-0.0235865619,
-0.0042314501,
0.0042823586,
0.038654048,
0.0247654524,
-0.018252695,
-0.0201508664,
0.0097244214,
-0.0014569841,
-0.010014317,
0.0157237481,
-0.0290782228,
0.038039472,
0.0420218445,
0.0037506011,
0.0011740348,
0.0335422046,
0.0161732174,
0.0224513635,
-0.0628730655,
0.0182083156,
-0.0064936881,
0.0189036187,
0.0597323626,
0.0078325868,
-0.0204098243,
-0.0405439921,
-0.015313861,
0.0237825271,
-0.0433714539,
0.0046288478,
0.0084401444,
0.0380138196,
0.0154438363,
0.021133123,
-0.0942095071,
-0.0271894187,
-0.0288554467,
0.0355058499,
0.0143521558,
0.0034988627,
0.0329313017,
-0.0382602774,
-0.0075242608,
-0.0331971832,
0.0078762136,
0.0246860757,
-0.0086342013,
0.0404256359,
0.0085701616,
-0.0431905054,
0.0181018729,
0.1153417826,
0.0367735326,
0.037510287,
-0.0251365285,
-0.0050996807,
-0.0427100509,
-0.0044892617,
-0.0078979088,
0.023874294,
-0.0306083672,
-0.0247280728,
-0.0201729089,
-0.0594393611,
-0.0038983943,
-0.0081849815,
0.0062404191,
-0.0175124146,
0.0022232721,
0.0865470096,
0.011574774,
0.0423686318,
-0.0257621258,
-0.0129356729,
0.0171040706,
-0.0269368347,
-0.0222177524,
-6.074432445e-33,
0.0160073843,
0.0269189235,
-0.0109772235,
-0.0552144237,
0.0076747844,
0.0368713662,
-0.0376023874,
-0.0158230569,
-0.0463192016,
-0.0127302632,
-0.0263460875,
0.0122980308,
-0.006018294,
0.0124379089,
0.0207549613,
-0.013401635,
0.0525159426,
-0.0049624755,
-0.0369715989,
0.0332392566,
0.0425831117,
0.0178173538,
0.0485367663,
-0.0628732741,
0.0506097078,
0.008253606,
-0.0214125495,
-0.0244049747,
0.0401357897,
0.0682820901,
-0.0325229056,
0.0253662392,
0.0107883187,
-0.059362907,
-0.0226692706,
0.0022331865,
-0.0670607015,
-0.0125005208,
0.0157963168,
-0.0242200047,
-0.0037375633,
-0.0326193757,
0.0595849268,
-0.0050210031,
-0.0151717588,
-0.021686757,
0.0212635845,
-0.0110530052,
-0.0543528125,
-0.0455375761,
-0.0205229428,
0.0211071968,
-0.0274527483,
0.0295852628,
0.029358644,
0.0535341352,
0.0013626333,
0.1000327617,
-0.0248208363,
0.0188962817,
0.0134051405,
0.052473668,
0.0565279052,
-0.036914032,
0.0010016075,
0.0441737287,
-0.0067641982,
0.0188828763,
0.0101989247,
0.0184562132,
0.0707045048,
0.0043520704,
0.0351722389,
0.0739951506,
0.066722393,
-0.0310886055,
-0.0873146653,
0.016242737,
0.0333880596,
0.0283925403,
0.0308119897,
0.0371762998,
-0.043505609,
-0.0193407536,
-0.0503594428,
-0.0371297672,
-0.0071987524,
-0.0468536541,
0.0112087857,
0.0194395483,
-0.0325784832,
0.002643266,
0.0294694584,
-0.08198338,
-0.079432413,
0.0639828742,
-0.0349693559,
0.033859279,
0.0180293489,
0.0225013066,
-0.0575150773,
-0.01919543,
0.0154220052,
-0.000620188,
0.0299324468,
-0.0305545665,
0.0408931673,
0.0367180929,
-0.0783630982,
-0.0097100548,
-0.0196528267,
-0.0139761232,
0.0055591199,
0.0004721026,
0.0491338298,
0.014258978,
0.0166214779,
0.0169850979,
0.0349702239,
0.025710104,
-0.0398847796,
-0.0277734268,
0.0137805622,
0.0309206117,
-0.0039426158,
-0.0560646132,
-0.0413233526,
0.0210979432,
0.0511381775,
-0.0420265384,
-0.0119097438,
0.022665007,
2.524e-7,
0.0428657793,
0.056611266,
-0.0086110504,
-0.0048187333,
0.0043370831,
0.0035484966,
-0.0189294294,
0.032855019,
-0.0192910433,
-0.0176214986,
-0.0105690798,
-0.0166407004,
0.0388612077,
0.0342852846,
-0.0935909003,
-0.0395518132,
-0.1168600023,
-0.0143109215,
-0.0643321127,
0.0111736134,
0.02711723,
0.1460368186,
0.0084305899,
-0.0093765976,
0.0049406881,
-0.0305574946,
0.0457517691,
-0.0467798263,
-0.0050543798,
0.0318028517,
0.0189866554,
0.0324064158,
0.0031050262,
-0.0072859302,
-0.0358472057,
0.0111011723,
-0.0034274373,
0.0692875385,
0.024446493,
0.0226764586,
0.0258510765,
-0.0442115255,
-0.0137850568,
-0.0649673864,
0.0816281959,
0.0017077301,
-0.0262541976,
-0.0427570455,
-0.0065618372,
-0.0188119002,
0.0569574572,
-0.0291448869,
0.0139425248,
0.0243627336,
-0.0228274204,
-0.0045828191,
0.0037392238,
-0.0674018189,
-0.029657485,
0.0052422271,
-0.0209658295,
-0.0575924292,
-0.0509043261,
-0.0208781902,
0.0310349278,
-0.0652338713,
0.031953454,
2.583413781e-34,
0.0657483488,
-0.0127659217,
-0.0121084759,
0.0120015219,
0.0129187601,
-0.0500331335,
0.0092177447,
0.0121344579,
-0.01319825,
-0.0797664821,
0.0051441947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00858v1 | Can Large Language Models Understand Context? | 2024-02-01T18:55:29 | 2024-02-01T18:55:29 | Yilun Zhu, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Shruti Bhargava, Jiarui Lu, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Site Li, Yuan Zhang, Hong Yu, Bo-Hsiang Tseng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding context is key to understanding human language, an ability
which Large Language Models (LLMs) have been increasingly seen to demonstrate
to an impressive extent. However, though the evaluation of LLMs encompasses
various domains within the realm of Natural Language Processing, limited
attention has been paid to probing their linguistic capability of understanding
contextual features. This paper introduces a context understanding benchmark by
adapting existing datasets to suit the evaluation of generative models. This
benchmark comprises of four distinct tasks and nine datasets, all featuring
prompts designed to assess the models' ability to understand context. First, we
evaluate the performance of LLMs under the in-context learning pretraining
scenario. Experimental results indicate that pre-trained dense models struggle
with understanding more nuanced contextual features when compared to
state-of-the-art fine-tuned models. Second, as LLM compression holds growing
significance in both research and real-world applications, we assess the
context understanding of quantized models under in-context-learning settings.
We find that 3-bit post-training quantization leads to varying degrees of
performance reduction on our benchmark. We conduct an extensive analysis of
these scenarios to substantiate our experimental results. | Can Large Language Models Understand Context?: Understanding context is key to understanding human language, an ability
which Large Language Models (LLMs) have been increasingly seen to demonstrate
to an impressive extent. However, though the evaluation of LLMs encompasses
various domains within the realm of Natural Language Processing, limited
attention has been paid to probing their linguistic capability of understanding
contextual features. This paper introduces a context understanding benchmark by
adapting existing datasets to suit the evaluation of generative models. This
benchmark comprises of four distinct tasks and nine datasets, all featuring
prompts designed to assess the models' ability to understand context. First, we
evaluate the performance of LLMs under the in-context learning pretraining
scenario. Experimental results indicate that pre-trained dense models struggle
with understanding more nuanced contextual features when compared to
state-of-the-art fine-tuned models. Second, as LLM compression holds growing
significance in both research and real-world applications, we assess the
context understanding of quantized models under in-context-learning settings.
We find that 3-bit post-training quantization leads to varying degrees of
performance reduction on our benchmark. We conduct an extensive analysis of
these scenarios to substantiate our experimental results. | [
-0.0094426991,
0.0601472445,
0.0007511431,
0.066660881,
-0.0078893993,
0.02884968,
0.0398651101,
0.00262744,
-0.0607965663,
-0.0626093745,
-0.0317620635,
-0.0577952042,
-0.0003459056,
0.0320737921,
0.0233575162,
-0.0286931992,
0.0381608829,
-0.010883051,
0.0029685074,
0.0041346974,
-0.02250457,
-0.0013148178,
0.0179334227,
0.0319016837,
-0.0152222477,
-0.0191765726,
-0.0092372065,
0.0373063385,
0.0217312165,
-0.0298252869,
0.0007772922,
0.0643685609,
0.0721410438,
0.0285020433,
0.0000019758,
-0.0408355407,
0.0008596777,
-0.0202673115,
-0.0800474733,
0.0160233267,
0.0274261627,
-0.0275957845,
-0.0340482183,
-0.0138588203,
-0.0446680933,
-0.0114749512,
0.0302928239,
0.0192380883,
0.0122720888,
0.0520697832,
-0.012344379,
-0.0287990756,
0.0070604822,
-0.0426235199,
0.0199540257,
-0.0552979633,
0.0139776533,
0.0320167355,
-0.0082803564,
0.008912188,
-0.0424632952,
0.0234065484,
0.038951546,
0.04296216,
-0.0105593763,
0.0455458276,
-0.0406355038,
0.0051796013,
-0.0244645402,
0.0737654492,
-0.0524372235,
-0.0126634911,
-0.0071209436,
-0.009580994,
-0.0145236617,
-0.075745739,
-0.0252749827,
0.0286898967,
0.0130022587,
0.0409414954,
-0.015557833,
0.0284886174,
0.0427405573,
0.024072431,
-0.0531569868,
0.0320986174,
-0.0015337697,
-0.0118308142,
-0.0104582794,
-0.0033541936,
-0.0712269098,
-0.043024119,
-0.0152784539,
0.0262286235,
-0.0218707081,
0.0195002817,
-0.0518318489,
0.0029580775,
0.0161261111,
-0.0158660747,
-0.0055384706,
0.0401136912,
-0.034617696,
0.0554660596,
-0.0082188752,
0.0513311289,
-0.0151226399,
0.0099191703,
-0.0309825968,
0.014068027,
-0.0226917751,
0.0053567691,
-0.0432488136,
-0.0000055825,
-0.0732035562,
-0.0352919959,
-0.0300307926,
0.0274236631,
0.0020393964,
0.000116864,
0.0083602956,
0.0230957996,
-0.0420896672,
-0.0018291253,
0.0164337475,
-0.0083223637,
-0.0274225269,
0.030841466,
0.0185721107,
-0.0738855675,
-0.0077921948,
0.0091139823,
0.0212074928,
-0.0388062596,
0.006972685,
0.0195943769,
0.0129530169,
-0.0646261424,
-0.0092833247,
-0.0142146936,
-0.0262430776,
-0.0816681683,
-0.045163881,
-0.0492787473,
-0.0009348186,
-0.0056214789,
0.0166395009,
-0.0342570432,
-0.0060214694,
-0.0115702618,
0.0093044788,
0.097796835,
-0.0068110386,
-0.0088337716,
0.0063101701,
0.0328362547,
0.0745250881,
0.0748776123,
0.0141921667,
0.0374478325,
0.0072833034,
0.0129644154,
-0.01956583,
0.0353124328,
0.0408948138,
-0.0042112027,
-0.0286966227,
0.0046452172,
-0.0069633201,
0.0587102063,
0.072077021,
0.0544290543,
-0.0533894524,
-0.0356358066,
0.0364702605,
0.0613670014,
0.0554701947,
0.0150180468,
0.046422109,
0.0188724324,
-0.0159196761,
-0.0050038411,
-0.0660415068,
-0.0062767048,
-0.0078083235,
0.0122338682,
0.0286288634,
0.0086953659,
-0.0281245112,
-0.0243374053,
-0.0155513566,
-0.0073081455,
0.0023088453,
0.0260308292,
0.0282563455,
0.0131467078,
-0.0346798599,
0.035657078,
0.02788602,
-0.04694416,
-0.0183412768,
-0.0595267974,
0.0261386167,
0.0730299428,
0.0412967168,
-0.0000620108,
0.0155168427,
-0.0091514653,
0.0160333645,
0.0091448696,
0.0031173541,
-0.0131223034,
0.0567713343,
-0.0352550372,
-0.0495439023,
-0.0317754187,
0.0120517947,
0.0363449231,
0.0280114058,
0.0041410248,
0.0213585217,
-0.0301646329,
0.0350111574,
0.0306618325,
-0.0202137157,
-0.0598612763,
0.0067979228,
0.0156655647,
0.0414157659,
0.0170962233,
-0.0235153772,
-0.0171618294,
0.0398207791,
-0.0497107543,
0.0373993441,
0.0072394442,
-0.1102535874,
-0.0798798278,
0.0078642778,
0.0176538825,
-0.0076802098,
-0.0143835424,
-0.0668817312,
-0.0226845201,
0.0031251782,
-0.0099211158,
0.0694114566,
-0.0614607632,
-0.0042946846,
0.0062168445,
0.0568564348,
-0.0432995148,
0.0824359357,
-0.0177881215,
0.0008969802,
0.0439565741,
0.0603744872,
0.01717305,
-0.0381958298,
-0.0245002769,
-0.0043937825,
-0.0147466892,
0.0039499751,
-0.008885473,
0.0058301846,
-0.0381751284,
0.0128898723,
-0.1243169308,
-0.0094080977,
-0.0527346097,
0.0116638597,
0.0377305225,
0.016054634,
-0.0182005856,
-0.0231680572,
-0.0384394675,
-0.0079196226,
0.0005733666,
0.0090432884,
0.0084806811,
0.0234802142,
-0.0088969572,
-0.0429921336,
-0.0147422897,
0.0106815379,
0.0527577922,
-0.0192838963,
0.0003731014,
-0.0471040718,
0.0436436795,
0.0153476074,
0.022764273,
-0.0210530572,
-0.0049631139,
0.0198496412,
-0.0379519351,
0.0455257222,
0.0917986035,
0.0148270708,
0.0631324202,
0.049606435,
-0.0040533203,
-0.0581608079,
0.0059565664,
-0.0073520201,
-0.0322372057,
-0.0517970696,
-0.0327019356,
-0.0110631725,
0.0753415823,
0.0109654469,
0.0113018705,
-0.0421166606,
0.0085285464,
-0.0110344132,
-0.0429137908,
-0.0846627355,
0.0010471826,
-0.0149286445,
0.0840869918,
-0.0296509005,
-0.0466006324,
0.0353320241,
-0.0398483351,
-0.0060895598,
-0.0078229522,
-0.0222816356,
-0.0348588489,
0.0907458365,
0.0030516062,
0.0215852279,
-0.0022784697,
-0.0309562627,
-0.0495684482,
-0.0055219536,
-0.0171635933,
-0.017520193,
0.0246831272,
-0.0451411568,
0.0214584731,
-0.0239613075,
-0.0354532972,
-0.0511146933,
-0.0488055795,
-0.0201801937,
0.0266867522,
0.0242943205,
0.004723696,
0.0285808351,
0.0277174301,
-0.0255303122,
0.051256787,
0.0155494325,
-0.0259255301,
-0.0152050424,
0.0551713631,
0.0377222337,
0.0129592326,
0.0262847189,
-0.0057322094,
0.0115788458,
0.040208187,
0.0248849634,
0.0147812935,
-0.0708047524,
0.0338621624,
0.0181471296,
0.0021067115,
-0.0105035724,
0.0397876948,
0.0564418137,
-0.0691840202,
-0.0348515585,
0.1172018126,
0.0239471607,
-0.0411552303,
0.0132647427,
0.0096289916,
0.0049571726,
0.0131919077,
-0.0058347993,
-0.1247162074,
-0.0471959524,
0.0048474162,
-0.0208245721,
0.0046703401,
-0.009397665,
-0.0220494494,
-0.080296725,
0.023985127,
-0.0030033707,
-0.0311524626,
-0.0168198645,
0.0046465346,
-0.0046519926,
-0.0150274402,
0.0676487237,
0.0000038528,
-0.0155938501,
-0.0131927915,
0.0142971538,
0.037474934,
-0.0857679546,
0.0599349402,
0.0012323589,
0.0637717247,
0.0826578587,
0.0239324328,
0.0354849733,
0.0076179001,
0.0149564231,
-0.0079361657,
0.0222268384,
-0.0064314683,
0.0265407171,
-0.0071210954,
0.0045324443,
0.031281516,
0.0093053821,
-0.0311516486,
-0.0387007333,
0.0049213069,
-0.0011831569,
-0.0134765999,
-0.0035313193,
-0.0142801208,
-0.0219057053,
0.0224917587,
0.0935643911,
0.0625888407,
-0.0097232619,
-0.0479113348,
-0.0219197143,
0.0227475278,
-0.0353607908,
-0.0123907942,
-0.0194097236,
0.0102027841,
-0.024106402,
-0.041298449,
-0.0200961567,
0.0188292898,
0.02983105,
-0.0096842414,
-0.0029449172,
-0.0160149876,
0.0167431291,
-0.0736338794,
0.027289262,
-0.0210381243,
0.0269329529,
-0.061269626,
0.0108774984,
0.0178381801,
-0.0338054225,
-0.0279413313,
0.0087928222,
-0.1218090951,
-0.0415764526,
0.0160435606,
0.001932119,
0.019315945,
0.0818486214,
-0.0026295462,
-0.062434189,
0.0610643476,
0.0272990745,
-0.0042611589,
0.0409475788,
0.0226908736,
0.0286172535,
0.0014680154,
0.0408509411,
-0.0373905562,
0.0604655743,
0.0185670108,
0.0282104164,
-0.0749430582,
-0.0377725922,
0.0103073902,
-0.0361466706,
0.0544861145,
-0.0300171226,
-0.0104305875,
0.0059482707,
0.0092371143,
-0.0164657924,
0.0288007818,
-0.0437815264,
-0.0444013886,
0.0409088023,
-0.0054296888,
-0.0105301095,
0.0184165854,
-0.0040925741,
0.0298204217,
-0.0273442287,
0.0154189663,
-0.0006817713,
0.017579047,
0.0365584008,
0.0163807534,
-0.0239060987,
0.0230770539,
-0.002450373,
0.0512204021,
-0.0240968782,
0.0496001653,
-0.0076114945,
0.0062455004,
-0.016831724,
0.0445989706,
-0.0764959157,
0.0011600857,
-0.0339869112,
0.0254119765,
0.0489385128,
-0.0207752362,
0.0255805198,
-0.0143006761,
-0.0004180008,
-0.0145901786,
0.017428996,
0.0110760089,
-0.0436769053,
0.0558713377,
0.0311828088,
-0.0231491234,
0.017007893,
0.077610217,
0.0364804976,
0.0255803745,
0.0030490721,
0.0152669903,
-0.0358630978,
-0.0068811621,
-0.0228913445,
0.0252227671,
0.001837225,
0.0483550169,
-0.024302749,
-0.0568052344,
-0.0140376268,
0.010587303,
0.0218663588,
-0.0119597251,
0.0369874462,
0.0371942669,
-0.0107873781,
-0.0266718101,
-0.0091535728,
-0.0000770578,
-0.0099158604,
-0.0049291337,
-0.0457295738,
-6.372238061e-33,
-0.0294566993,
-0.0125874747,
0.025928678,
-0.0594956465,
-0.0019584931,
0.0334323198,
-0.0442007482,
-0.0001469263,
-0.0302145034,
-0.0215379708,
-0.0262268167,
0.0285336766,
0.0213949047,
0.0507806279,
-0.0401217304,
-0.0090696299,
0.081866473,
-0.010958774,
-0.0004409843,
0.0189195462,
0.0087870425,
0.0184783358,
0.0285090003,
-0.0202267729,
0.0000863538,
-0.0120300585,
-0.0231514107,
0.00763408,
0.0045344834,
0.0384948291,
-0.0551052205,
0.0127433762,
0.0291326363,
-0.0111677712,
-0.0458389372,
0.0413023047,
-0.1050637662,
0.0028986072,
0.0186623484,
0.0191804245,
-0.0249120593,
-0.035362225,
0.0440032668,
-0.0201248564,
-0.0117874593,
-0.0167144369,
0.001166243,
-0.0341471694,
-0.0426298156,
-0.0955659524,
-0.047794193,
0.0228230432,
-0.013999138,
0.0014508611,
0.062566258,
0.007010174,
-0.0233341213,
0.018576337,
-0.0490251668,
0.011821989,
0.0137792947,
0.0457107536,
0.0652733073,
0.0385949463,
0.0095317038,
0.0453385711,
-0.0011904994,
-0.0321309268,
-0.0385968611,
0.0001819873,
0.036166124,
0.0473827757,
-0.0060333461,
0.0720534325,
0.0785522088,
-0.0073831128,
-0.068274796,
-0.0004588931,
-0.0045122853,
0.011326707,
0.0387049019,
0.0327443704,
-0.0289533064,
-0.0136423549,
-0.0494115092,
-0.0270954836,
-0.0337057076,
-0.028377315,
0.0411738195,
0.0143204723,
-0.0052089682,
-0.0235773977,
0.0368661582,
-0.0715015903,
-0.0096681565,
0.0365820788,
-0.0024924395,
-0.0092567205,
0.0209901687,
0.0451448038,
-0.0447705314,
-0.0201425627,
0.0400429592,
0.0381243862,
0.0135567328,
-0.024282163,
0.0494844802,
0.0065815612,
-0.0556257926,
-0.0157683343,
-0.0341964066,
0.0299935024,
-0.0317047052,
0.0295331255,
0.0461008474,
0.0199500937,
-0.0075252778,
0.0342724212,
-0.0115246391,
-0.018593166,
-0.0072549866,
-0.0034269707,
0.0032243943,
0.0447899066,
-0.0455016978,
-0.025007952,
-0.0288699493,
0.0098504946,
0.1078256741,
-0.0282543283,
-0.0219743084,
0.0444768891,
2.533e-7,
0.0399343334,
0.0159531422,
0.008597631,
-0.0329380184,
0.0237670634,
0.014302332,
-0.0033583494,
0.0087059876,
-0.0062869214,
-0.0161496755,
0.0304162335,
0.0505624525,
0.0312489569,
-0.0080364095,
-0.0608007014,
0.0338661224,
-0.0505237579,
0.0107010528,
-0.0432141237,
0.0010211177,
0.0538725294,
0.1229483932,
-0.030925516,
-0.0132985171,
0.0459440872,
-0.01644844,
0.0469068587,
-0.0580764897,
0.043670319,
0.0124116857,
-0.0170995705,
0.0478249379,
0.0021249084,
-0.0038930119,
0.007451694,
-0.0005824626,
-0.0367452204,
0.0990871862,
0.0046483502,
-0.0536742993,
-0.0188416634,
-0.0004710546,
-0.0029743894,
-0.0521044582,
0.0764086545,
-0.0683861375,
-0.0077146036,
-0.0657915324,
0.004458698,
-0.010057779,
0.0108128227,
0.0048737586,
0.0077125882,
-0.0004250573,
0.014735749,
-0.0367442369,
-0.0253044106,
-0.1280643195,
-0.031449616,
0.0085026212,
-0.037368305,
-0.0226357169,
-0.0479872227,
-0.0079362346,
0.05515128,
-0.0137764057,
0.0028773253,
2.121941331e-34,
0.026515346,
0.0090819839,
0.0231831186,
0.0091946023,
-0.0090449601,
0.0024653787,
-0.0234572105,
0.0051237731,
0.0061219358,
-0.0734737888,
0.006974271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00856v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00856v4 | Towards Efficient Exact Optimization of Language Model Alignment | 2024-02-01T18:51:54 | 2024-06-05T08:15:12 | Haozhe Ji, Cheng Lu, Yilin Niu, Pei Ke, Hongning Wang, Jun Zhu, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The alignment of language models with human preferences is vital for their
application in real-world tasks. The problem is formulated as optimizing the
model's policy to maximize the expected reward that reflects human preferences
with minimal deviation from the initial policy. While considered as a
straightforward solution, reinforcement learning (RL) suffers from high
variance in policy updates, which impedes efficient policy improvement.
Recently, direct preference optimization (DPO) was proposed to directly
optimize the policy from preference data. However, we show that DPO derived
based on the optimal solution of the problem leads to a compromised
mean-seeking approximation of the optimal solution in practice. In this paper,
we propose efficient exact optimization (EXO) of the alignment objective. EXO
is guaranteed to optimize in the same direction as RL algorithms asymptotically
for arbitrary policy parametrization. This leads to the same mode-seeking
solution, while enables efficient optimization by circumventing the
complexities of RL. We also compare our method to DPO with both theoretical and
empirical analyses, and further demonstrate the advantages of our method over
existing approaches on realistic human preference data. Code is available at
https://github.com/haozheji/exact-optimization. | Towards Efficient Exact Optimization of Language Model Alignment: The alignment of language models with human preferences is vital for their
application in real-world tasks. The problem is formulated as optimizing the
model's policy to maximize the expected reward that reflects human preferences
with minimal deviation from the initial policy. While considered as a
straightforward solution, reinforcement learning (RL) suffers from high
variance in policy updates, which impedes efficient policy improvement.
Recently, direct preference optimization (DPO) was proposed to directly
optimize the policy from preference data. However, we show that DPO derived
based on the optimal solution of the problem leads to a compromised
mean-seeking approximation of the optimal solution in practice. In this paper,
we propose efficient exact optimization (EXO) of the alignment objective. EXO
is guaranteed to optimize in the same direction as RL algorithms asymptotically
for arbitrary policy parametrization. This leads to the same mode-seeking
solution, while enables efficient optimization by circumventing the
complexities of RL. We also compare our method to DPO with both theoretical and
empirical analyses, and further demonstrate the advantages of our method over
existing approaches on realistic human preference data. Code is available at
https://github.com/haozheji/exact-optimization. | [
0.0341312923,
0.0663005561,
0.0020699247,
0.0309819859,
-0.0356167443,
0.0038347167,
-0.0634626895,
-0.0167579316,
-0.0425906181,
0.0076315026,
-0.0276715681,
-0.0388717167,
0.0202860814,
0.0040714825,
-0.0090694129,
-0.0503823981,
0.0608992204,
-0.0295747425,
0.0200321432,
-0.0133302016,
0.0483486727,
-0.0085942298,
-0.0150886206,
0.0235643927,
0.0336303525,
0.0076640514,
-0.0178502258,
0.0023090392,
0.0677433088,
0.0124744279,
0.0372498967,
0.022682406,
0.0077320905,
0.0497957058,
0.0000022349,
-0.0348901264,
-0.0368931182,
-0.0338081047,
0.0111416792,
-0.042846825,
0.058485914,
0.0252443086,
-0.0389843993,
0.030952448,
-0.0205220804,
0.0288466495,
0.1001721397,
0.0102990605,
0.0371144153,
0.0653492734,
0.0070577557,
0.0003198284,
-0.0367926806,
-0.0309846513,
-0.0001750532,
-0.0253118146,
0.0237254966,
-0.0316565111,
0.0027011065,
0.0009127906,
-0.0201965868,
0.0226918627,
-0.0290316585,
0.0099148713,
-0.0333256014,
0.0329881571,
0.0090635968,
-0.0176367667,
-0.0062604398,
0.0653022453,
-0.0363703258,
-0.0639567971,
0.0213720389,
-0.0301796161,
0.0003208079,
0.0303223561,
0.0183090065,
-0.017383201,
-0.0024669957,
0.0523367412,
0.0295408368,
-0.0290685333,
0.0296034571,
0.0158842988,
-0.0151904607,
0.0767324492,
0.0093739992,
-0.0333382785,
0.0116869863,
0.0019279426,
-0.0181336999,
-0.0445602946,
0.0144069027,
-0.0067812027,
-0.0691016465,
0.0328542553,
-0.0481891148,
-0.0206988063,
-0.0093984175,
-0.0510749109,
0.0417986959,
0.069926396,
0.0208208319,
0.0122853965,
0.0370333157,
0.0719867572,
-0.0286595337,
-0.0363615043,
-0.064297542,
0.0277751051,
-0.0220940243,
0.0056476067,
-0.0018930418,
-0.0020735105,
-0.0248087682,
-0.017349204,
-0.0604866557,
0.0404593758,
-0.0128487563,
0.0255708061,
-0.0022015402,
0.0054808767,
-0.066487655,
-0.0154867163,
-0.0420608819,
0.0236514099,
-0.0201090109,
0.0032964116,
0.008279724,
0.0313568786,
0.0273995213,
0.0074886451,
-0.0275216047,
-0.0224025231,
-0.0110561205,
0.0918641314,
-0.0243721548,
0.020622367,
0.0044547208,
-0.0025733612,
-0.0282925032,
-0.02650561,
-0.0512554832,
-0.0741792768,
0.0058931047,
-0.0206308886,
-0.0339437276,
-0.0598485209,
-0.0119715519,
-0.0049996227,
-0.0308528729,
0.0641137138,
0.0071579469,
0.0110913543,
0.032043267,
-0.0363082476,
-0.0050260909,
0.0742742345,
0.0353560708,
0.0306317247,
0.0095398529,
-0.0127046304,
-0.0118501522,
0.0699308068,
0.0087060072,
0.0139776086,
-0.0253542531,
0.0068217013,
0.0128872134,
0.0563743263,
0.0694830045,
0.0168682989,
-0.0086938385,
-0.0277981665,
0.0643685684,
0.0288296975,
0.0285994112,
-0.043802686,
-0.0085441004,
0.0415773802,
-0.0500969552,
-0.0138196517,
-0.0525360331,
0.028579412,
-0.0302580912,
0.0265692007,
0.0079217944,
0.0388511196,
0.0003315913,
-0.03508012,
0.0124055846,
-0.0165137667,
0.0203591771,
0.0450667292,
0.0146801118,
-0.035732165,
-0.0494803675,
-0.0062787635,
0.0464285128,
-0.003681941,
0.0020655906,
-0.0184721015,
0.0184301529,
0.0605951808,
0.0070289164,
-0.0184215736,
-0.0550267249,
-0.0032747958,
-0.0495464914,
0.0555643886,
0.0364716984,
-0.0289317407,
-0.0196585618,
-0.0601418018,
-0.0609065704,
0.0597995594,
-0.0129611371,
0.0289537683,
0.0318255536,
0.0062930812,
-0.0191765558,
-0.012596081,
-0.0592686944,
0.0238021947,
-0.010093336,
-0.0417620353,
0.0031393257,
0.0406094044,
0.0449454449,
-0.008831366,
0.0054700105,
0.0022800555,
-0.0136805093,
0.0167955905,
0.0132514164,
0.0105090924,
-0.0483295955,
-0.0017513941,
0.0661040023,
-0.0288876183,
-0.0384200104,
0.0558767207,
-0.0329018012,
-0.0474339612,
-0.0241122562,
-0.0215110146,
0.0384636261,
0.0084850444,
0.0415809192,
-0.0294731893,
-0.0220510326,
-0.0787299797,
0.0444992483,
-0.0095744375,
0.0124290744,
0.0107369348,
-0.0244653076,
-0.0108094001,
-0.0673743859,
-0.0375512019,
0.0399038978,
0.0015342956,
0.0558576882,
0.0829351768,
0.0288347211,
-0.0228922032,
-0.0268539581,
-0.0402039215,
0.0002977523,
-0.0108298706,
0.0277530309,
0.0449800156,
0.0239083935,
-0.0369073078,
-0.0297625214,
-0.042713996,
0.0096988259,
-0.0374458507,
-0.0043571535,
0.028941907,
0.0052648024,
-0.0263120532,
-0.0779177994,
-0.0020718137,
-0.0030941162,
-0.0301012378,
-0.0224622209,
0.0455782972,
-0.0473713875,
0.0350291394,
-0.0289173406,
0.0464406721,
-0.0121454364,
-0.0450249054,
0.0001312004,
-0.0112474896,
0.0320543945,
0.0950123668,
0.0549193285,
0.0167987924,
0.0607543215,
0.039226234,
-0.094031997,
0.0125533082,
-0.0796031505,
-0.0457585491,
-0.0475446731,
-0.0302385148,
0.0338927843,
0.1009573117,
-0.0089884717,
0.006387996,
-0.0656368881,
-0.0130469557,
-0.0000605494,
-0.0182549488,
-0.0128224343,
0.0462792926,
-0.0561481975,
0.0417179354,
-0.052132681,
-0.0816898718,
0.0984641612,
-0.0076938774,
0.0253241658,
-0.081480369,
-0.0326256864,
-0.0004749192,
-0.0307717081,
-0.0049701068,
0.0457812212,
-0.0245194416,
-0.0161575265,
-0.0765949041,
-0.0330086201,
0.0664099827,
-0.0398731902,
0.066590555,
-0.0158148408,
0.0307858977,
-0.0115901623,
-0.0707922652,
-0.0519792289,
-0.025360072,
-0.0164768249,
-0.0289974939,
0.004015035,
-0.0569038726,
-0.0187535994,
-0.0015622039,
0.0520941019,
0.0309425537,
0.0034891784,
-0.011768776,
-0.0190464221,
-0.0124724424,
0.1006203294,
-0.0115901101,
-0.0403128676,
-0.0023504149,
-0.0155104389,
0.0056988047,
0.0585680418,
0.0157834385,
-0.0353687704,
0.0166711267,
0.0677054673,
-0.0628920645,
-0.005043,
0.0596684515,
0.0186251905,
-0.0086702555,
-0.0033761128,
0.0856532902,
0.0322258957,
-0.0657529458,
0.0111565059,
-0.0157305524,
0.0592778437,
0.0044078343,
0.0435264744,
-0.0059229056,
-0.0147278057,
0.0133125335,
0.0757208765,
0.0135279419,
-0.0026121386,
0.007543656,
-0.1143104807,
-0.0470896997,
0.0173676107,
-0.0776137561,
-0.030762529,
-0.0176299084,
0.0328500755,
-0.0374334492,
0.0523585714,
0.020920556,
0.0171304364,
0.0094766393,
0.0237211175,
0.0413405038,
-0.0186797157,
0.0048990939,
-0.0382364839,
0.0543953441,
0.110693194,
0.0260445587,
0.0091417683,
-0.0051706517,
0.0073995902,
0.0456153341,
-0.0486177541,
-0.0011868301,
-0.041583024,
-0.025282653,
-0.009839586,
-0.0090041431,
0.0743646845,
-0.0167454537,
0.0189510584,
0.0097360555,
0.0406710207,
0.0055591459,
0.0241415557,
-0.0013355913,
-0.0104030222,
0.0484982803,
0.0387958251,
-0.0104356045,
-0.0797977448,
-0.006695929,
-0.0581060611,
-0.0279594455,
-0.0430018269,
-0.0480443873,
-0.0231866464,
-0.0054014088,
-0.0012513836,
-0.0602979474,
-0.0208167955,
-0.0242791381,
0.05324829,
0.0174173936,
0.0141795464,
0.0278071519,
-0.0328500234,
-0.0163072105,
-0.0007391353,
-0.0182775222,
0.0131690986,
-0.0899354219,
-0.013748657,
-0.0074478528,
-0.039448496,
-0.0332482569,
-0.0162834097,
-0.0059842337,
-0.1087083295,
-0.0002416498,
0.0432627089,
0.0122553147,
0.0904125273,
-0.0014508303,
-0.0377658978,
0.0324463323,
0.0281130336,
0.0020866254,
0.0110320095,
0.0199031197,
0.0264103506,
-0.0070592272,
0.031613946,
-0.0458633117,
-0.0132580651,
0.0216098204,
0.0282970779,
-0.0276738722,
-0.0403745323,
0.0424178988,
0.003703126,
0.028789524,
-0.0447609238,
-0.0274520703,
-0.0310830437,
-0.0170257576,
0.027089145,
-0.040572077,
0.0060381861,
-0.0164621342,
0.0335237272,
-0.0049694474,
0.0289457254,
-0.0060472842,
0.016225569,
-0.0029206707,
-0.000780659,
-0.0002121643,
0.0122234765,
0.0489482284,
0.0694140047,
0.0358098149,
0.0156702846,
0.0393272825,
0.0100866212,
0.0664678365,
-0.0061361403,
0.026352413,
0.0661581531,
0.022813471,
-0.0105088064,
-0.0027901644,
-0.0109208794,
-0.0646860003,
-0.0291291922,
-0.0116991373,
0.0615819506,
-0.0388953462,
0.0580341332,
-0.046612855,
0.0000631563,
-0.0307178609,
0.0185770988,
-0.0278082769,
-0.0046119075,
0.0241911821,
0.0225786939,
0.0043627648,
0.012637536,
0.065144226,
0.0110726701,
0.0311251264,
-0.0364860483,
0.0108689144,
-0.0361093171,
0.0047010933,
0.0128517775,
0.0132325795,
-0.0629383177,
-0.0260040984,
-0.0251050368,
-0.0633488297,
-0.0157562941,
0.0475362092,
0.0024871405,
0.0048461179,
0.0613702796,
0.0277005341,
-0.0410214067,
0.039066337,
-0.0566154122,
-0.0249284822,
-0.0115624564,
-0.0219996236,
-0.0453016199,
-6.401568114e-33,
-0.0254162848,
-0.0149747832,
0.0060879025,
-0.0045964592,
-0.0076754703,
-0.0478554331,
0.0114965653,
0.0241145417,
-0.0134520018,
-0.0265752487,
0.0028265542,
-0.0239910893,
0.0168795418,
-0.0132174883,
0.0260697678,
0.0263306126,
0.0022728951,
-0.0230291691,
-0.0676562116,
-0.0208060928,
0.0449908376,
0.0004303005,
0.0218140855,
-0.0565776899,
0.0269133467,
0.0320597626,
-0.0139783118,
0.0329030529,
0.0105801076,
0.0845888704,
0.0043185405,
0.0038796426,
-0.0139027955,
-0.024258567,
-0.0310251545,
-0.006532568,
-0.0214900468,
-0.0318820514,
0.024989916,
0.036416553,
-0.0186974388,
-0.0224569626,
0.0435224138,
-0.0029089833,
-0.059683539,
0.0192783736,
0.0213042535,
-0.0044154138,
-0.0249655358,
0.0424821638,
-0.05436318,
-0.001180205,
-0.0066531086,
-0.0114104953,
0.0604878739,
-0.0140180429,
0.0078588361,
0.01737074,
-0.0233251899,
0.0412434079,
-0.0222945306,
0.0632287189,
0.1183242723,
0.0715746209,
0.0123907141,
0.0299008768,
0.0304722153,
-0.0542729162,
0.0436593965,
-0.012769863,
0.0443198234,
-0.0145005807,
-0.0156043591,
0.0460940227,
0.024601344,
-0.0050166608,
0.0013061736,
0.035529051,
0.0099436836,
0.0085751917,
0.0318469703,
0.0481104292,
-0.0779942349,
-0.0117452247,
-0.0723545253,
0.0024503556,
-0.0394129679,
-0.0366231911,
0.0306461807,
0.0088855922,
-0.0139541393,
-0.0588867366,
0.013878868,
-0.0346325375,
-0.0078446222,
0.0020633216,
-0.0509617142,
-0.0104775643,
-0.0012160863,
0.0272033997,
-0.0558295101,
-0.0488513894,
-0.0516418107,
-0.0157845113,
-0.0108592901,
0.0294395369,
-0.0039149467,
0.0108042285,
-0.0429318585,
0.0361260884,
-0.0194238536,
-0.0190037712,
0.0109028947,
0.0123883579,
0.0678552911,
-0.039035093,
0.0020064751,
0.0446195267,
0.028364867,
-0.0362629592,
-0.0192432292,
-0.0184243955,
-0.0331824012,
0.0234988015,
-0.0209101699,
0.0364870317,
-0.024736939,
0.0207616296,
-0.0115904557,
-0.0228449665,
-0.0169729181,
0.0000946483,
2.819e-7,
0.0213107672,
0.0497289151,
0.0377962701,
0.0419831276,
-0.0459238812,
0.0678767711,
-0.0150734838,
0.0184084997,
-0.0007059054,
0.0149867078,
0.0320736431,
0.0068136728,
0.0172562879,
-0.0123548219,
-0.0838626847,
0.0116714556,
-0.0500291809,
0.0604232997,
-0.0237106699,
0.010730193,
-0.0076201963,
0.0639088824,
0.0193320196,
0.015400378,
0.0070237159,
0.0245705917,
0.0488921255,
-0.0605461188,
0.0201400053,
0.0111208912,
-0.0049004592,
-0.0035365424,
-0.0420967229,
-0.0444741249,
-0.0001399538,
0.0296039488,
-0.0212713871,
0.0612295344,
0.0087052472,
-0.02768787,
-0.0258037578,
0.0167270694,
-0.0049869348,
-0.0514168814,
0.0096810628,
-0.0368801467,
0.0022617946,
-0.0195596535,
-0.0121062063,
-0.0027121152,
-0.0015548087,
-0.0334495343,
-0.0145529779,
0.011905713,
0.0148787014,
0.0249031968,
-0.0124610113,
-0.0269587003,
-0.0163662415,
0.0313640162,
-0.041202195,
-0.0281014219,
-0.0195627529,
0.0780293643,
0.0213368274,
-0.0184371788,
-0.0095914211,
2.531534073e-34,
0.0016430212,
-0.0123880627,
0.0303128567,
0.0061643911,
-0.0132329781,
0.0177919306,
-0.003877556,
0.0398520865,
0.0480141938,
-0.052237235,
-0.0455564633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00841v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00841v2 | Tiny Titans: Can Smaller Large Language Models Punch Above Their Weight in the Real World for Meeting Summarization? | 2024-02-01T18:31:34 | 2024-04-15T17:56:58 | Xue-Yong Fu, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Elena Khasanova, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities to
solve a wide range of tasks without being explicitly fine-tuned on
task-specific datasets. However, deploying LLMs in the real world is not
trivial, as it requires substantial computing resources. In this paper, we
investigate whether smaller, compact LLMs are a good alternative to the
comparatively Larger LLMs2 to address significant costs associated with
utilizing LLMs in the real world. In this regard, we study the meeting
summarization task in a real-world industrial environment and conduct extensive
experiments by comparing the performance of fine-tuned compact LLMs (e.g.,
FLAN-T5, TinyLLaMA, LiteLLaMA) with zero-shot larger LLMs (e.g., LLaMA-2,
GPT-3.5, PaLM-2). We observe that most smaller LLMs, even after fine-tuning,
fail to outperform larger zero-shot LLMs in meeting summarization datasets.
However, a notable exception is FLAN-T5 (780M parameters), which performs on
par or even better than many zero-shot Larger LLMs (from 7B to above 70B
parameters), while being significantly smaller. This makes compact LLMs like
FLAN-T5 a suitable cost-efficient solution for real-world industrial
deployment. | Tiny Titans: Can Smaller Large Language Models Punch Above Their Weight in the Real World for Meeting Summarization?: Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities to
solve a wide range of tasks without being explicitly fine-tuned on
task-specific datasets. However, deploying LLMs in the real world is not
trivial, as it requires substantial computing resources. In this paper, we
investigate whether smaller, compact LLMs are a good alternative to the
comparatively Larger LLMs2 to address significant costs associated with
utilizing LLMs in the real world. In this regard, we study the meeting
summarization task in a real-world industrial environment and conduct extensive
experiments by comparing the performance of fine-tuned compact LLMs (e.g.,
FLAN-T5, TinyLLaMA, LiteLLaMA) with zero-shot larger LLMs (e.g., LLaMA-2,
GPT-3.5, PaLM-2). We observe that most smaller LLMs, even after fine-tuning,
fail to outperform larger zero-shot LLMs in meeting summarization datasets.
However, a notable exception is FLAN-T5 (780M parameters), which performs on
par or even better than many zero-shot Larger LLMs (from 7B to above 70B
parameters), while being significantly smaller. This makes compact LLMs like
FLAN-T5 a suitable cost-efficient solution for real-world industrial
deployment. | [
0.0317331143,
-0.0179038495,
0.0206128322,
0.0521008186,
-0.0181146972,
-0.0118932351,
0.0252281968,
-0.0079309652,
-0.0316879377,
-0.0420408472,
-0.0444614626,
-0.0466287285,
0.0336721428,
0.0314320624,
0.0138277635,
-0.0908507854,
0.0152801452,
-0.0404906012,
-0.0326511078,
-0.0153756617,
0.0172879472,
-0.0053503625,
0.0247558337,
0.0434258878,
0.0085791685,
0.0079536196,
-0.0119546428,
-0.0001618514,
0.0183969028,
0.0124574974,
-0.0210680868,
0.0070459326,
0.0387512222,
0.0421412997,
0.0000019719,
-0.0284519196,
0.0022518476,
-0.0187357478,
-0.012165904,
0.0528653711,
0.074485071,
-0.019536823,
-0.0058011673,
0.0463978648,
-0.0109727718,
-0.0053374651,
0.0214181561,
0.0412178598,
0.0383138657,
0.0561138839,
-0.0052494686,
-0.036037676,
-0.0045467061,
-0.0387406424,
-0.0349185802,
-0.0503026061,
0.0134124001,
0.0084582148,
0.0118666273,
-0.0147302588,
0.0247817282,
0.0520311296,
-0.0245917719,
-0.0251041446,
-0.0162034128,
0.0488491692,
-0.08077804,
0.0001522548,
-0.0093307644,
0.0635003746,
0.0036185337,
0.0062366552,
0.0259860735,
-0.0004161073,
-0.0174051654,
-0.0453028716,
-0.0893363208,
0.0194493905,
0.0066165039,
0.027827831,
-0.0074406834,
0.0211194083,
-0.009854964,
0.0034704879,
-0.0210489612,
0.0357463621,
-0.0036435407,
-0.0100833531,
-0.0567036979,
-0.0035090474,
-0.0074881543,
-0.0620315671,
0.0308403093,
0.0445727222,
-0.0028969445,
0.0233638845,
-0.0498085991,
-0.0213257,
0.0109901251,
-0.0504999645,
0.0413476117,
0.0263798088,
0.0400487594,
0.0626349673,
-0.0087447185,
0.0366513431,
0.0083588678,
0.0095441081,
-0.0741164908,
-0.0158734284,
0.0041001984,
0.023082545,
-0.0283359922,
0.0306484457,
-0.0718021914,
-0.052002266,
-0.0213788189,
0.0336807109,
0.0425579138,
0.0140441479,
0.0082776193,
0.0001118951,
-0.0063858293,
-0.0195779148,
0.0135644907,
0.0470595025,
-0.0094367368,
-0.0097200004,
0.0159606766,
-0.0570765994,
0.0040515526,
0.0198924392,
0.0161627103,
0.0290142633,
-0.0137088625,
0.0681374818,
-0.0172045305,
-0.0400203131,
-0.0092690485,
-0.0102431215,
-0.011222898,
-0.0640286282,
-0.0368959755,
-0.0703086257,
0.0188838523,
0.017357856,
-0.0072633051,
0.0078640468,
0.0014869332,
0.0040920824,
-0.0470250472,
0.0239273217,
-0.022374237,
0.053581316,
0.0452418141,
-0.0124057923,
0.0129710231,
0.0682605058,
0.0686247274,
0.0778445378,
0.0495158285,
0.0245132633,
-0.0003163406,
0.0631230697,
-0.012117085,
0.0239117835,
-0.0042576231,
-0.0134457182,
-0.0248830374,
0.0096754488,
0.0200941861,
0.0791446045,
-0.0230541993,
0.0244801678,
0.0895513892,
0.0775581524,
0.030200785,
-0.0068799648,
-0.0110998293,
0.0353695899,
0.0092270123,
0.0114149246,
0.0005269343,
0.0233171843,
-0.030281432,
0.0437047221,
0.1115079224,
0.0159402471,
-0.0411584042,
-0.027298985,
-0.0279182438,
-0.0020066698,
-0.0523510613,
-0.0056410707,
0.0302848425,
-0.0493078381,
-0.0694796816,
0.0737945884,
0.0237726104,
-0.0547387376,
-0.0250405185,
-0.0419797935,
0.0003435866,
0.0775860623,
0.0481275953,
-0.035377305,
-0.0239949487,
-0.0085074781,
-0.0030127056,
0.0551589169,
0.0857318938,
-0.0142128058,
0.0046142004,
-0.0640766099,
-0.0097183157,
0.0355055258,
-0.0103571294,
-0.0049336767,
0.0021131232,
-0.0019986315,
0.0375645421,
-0.0001443592,
-0.0599905103,
0.012293241,
0.0067724125,
-0.0043590348,
-0.0198496711,
-0.008182711,
0.0282848906,
0.0387186557,
-0.0077048405,
-0.0046834387,
0.0435689799,
-0.0339602716,
0.042229645,
-0.014148158,
-0.0381125994,
-0.0256130397,
0.0521276258,
-0.0018373899,
0.0342779756,
0.0323477685,
-0.062799491,
-0.0767738298,
0.012105817,
-0.0472343229,
0.011747703,
-0.0227103159,
0.0383507758,
-0.0034445496,
0.0020919347,
-0.0206493773,
0.0269466303,
-0.0062340568,
-0.0166736916,
0.0383080617,
-0.0043654321,
0.0054574851,
-0.0666956678,
-0.0315581225,
0.0288521908,
0.0287545491,
0.0199281015,
0.0186762866,
0.018416198,
-0.0192958713,
-0.0268235039,
-0.1029175147,
0.0080188671,
-0.0175673496,
0.0043217284,
0.0273543857,
0.0232330784,
-0.0035113122,
0.0108827334,
-0.0435436219,
0.002521215,
0.0403641239,
0.0139170866,
0.0257631931,
0.0312809311,
-0.0180262607,
-0.0875602812,
-0.0236868877,
0.0365930237,
0.0292713959,
-0.0040921122,
-0.058332596,
-0.0557414442,
0.0400067568,
-0.0245888121,
-0.0018370394,
0.0031728463,
-0.0347875468,
-0.0268238336,
-0.0234338474,
0.0508716814,
0.0434770882,
0.0174249262,
-0.0010674022,
0.0352840982,
0.0031064248,
-0.0472126044,
-0.0055988003,
-0.0144978985,
-0.0000959101,
-0.0106263123,
-0.0229681432,
0.0060301353,
0.0264923647,
-0.0084432513,
0.0305675212,
-0.0500181243,
0.0244744327,
0.0015835798,
-0.0013367042,
-0.0264380667,
-0.0099333525,
-0.0505778901,
0.0625176057,
-0.011016381,
-0.0337318815,
-0.0025683653,
-0.0548664145,
0.0016648675,
-0.0153419338,
-0.0252654497,
-0.0606711358,
0.0212152209,
-0.007101832,
0.0275426731,
-0.055230774,
-0.0259100795,
-0.0272718463,
-0.008843313,
-0.0082545886,
-0.0461999215,
0.081576921,
-0.037049111,
0.0351691581,
-0.0565596521,
-0.027917007,
-0.0108658215,
-0.001063233,
-0.0648716539,
0.0243197586,
0.0090876315,
0.0064246827,
-0.1092842817,
0.0779539645,
0.0263631195,
0.0668762922,
-0.0158282891,
0.0065386966,
-0.0189502034,
0.0516482852,
0.0367771536,
0.0337995142,
0.0490912534,
-0.0352516659,
0.017151773,
0.0293155238,
0.08490289,
-0.0203316081,
-0.0013799921,
-0.0488277301,
0.0304163788,
-0.0243233498,
-0.0099613899,
-0.0103992363,
0.0577881001,
-0.0368142612,
0.0213597715,
0.1019013152,
-0.0072262152,
-0.0419374034,
-0.0230345074,
0.0026277814,
0.0541319549,
-0.0035899598,
0.0182514228,
-0.0689558238,
-0.0233257711,
0.0251895338,
0.0441939794,
0.0034830614,
-0.0052986103,
-0.0402665623,
-0.1147160456,
0.0361535251,
0.0233293623,
-0.013189272,
-0.0271530375,
-0.0205095131,
0.0114104217,
-0.0257030353,
0.0443706736,
0.0371640474,
-0.0349009782,
-0.0387593023,
0.0274379905,
-0.0749913752,
-0.0398462974,
-0.0130021563,
-0.0094748614,
0.0417736396,
0.016132025,
0.0241594482,
0.0124216201,
0.0055935532,
0.0374789089,
-0.006485011,
0.0193649977,
-0.0153036881,
0.0485942997,
-0.0051964321,
-0.0071817203,
0.0109726209,
0.0073833982,
-0.0089784916,
0.0212464426,
0.0080549829,
0.015566959,
-0.0028029799,
0.0011774136,
-0.0158391763,
0.0461410061,
-0.0486662909,
0.075012967,
0.0354384184,
0.0072381231,
-0.0443670563,
-0.0225536395,
-0.021924248,
-0.026505949,
-0.0172205251,
-0.0237505399,
-0.0276992805,
-0.0329360068,
-0.0546941943,
-0.0463085808,
0.0551356263,
0.0153456135,
-0.0139355054,
0.008505363,
-0.0311337542,
0.0392174423,
-0.0350499004,
-0.0148351351,
-0.0649258941,
-0.0126748523,
-0.0940628275,
0.011103875,
0.0417141654,
-0.0016863459,
-0.0110325413,
0.0295854043,
-0.1135374829,
-0.0777354091,
-0.0164153706,
0.0442726128,
0.0343246236,
0.0425831154,
0.0308039207,
-0.0419449843,
0.0589085557,
0.0150313694,
0.0024981666,
0.0493358932,
-0.0057200301,
0.0005465184,
-0.0325288735,
0.0322515927,
-0.0636424199,
0.0313935466,
-0.0329676978,
0.0283067469,
-0.0343755409,
-0.084318772,
-0.0357288234,
0.0657550022,
-0.015200696,
-0.0064996378,
-0.0210424028,
-0.0142454356,
0.0140155647,
-0.0222146679,
0.0006446417,
-0.037295036,
0.0031136582,
-0.0481873639,
-0.0048668687,
-0.0006814927,
0.0206794795,
-0.0108224368,
0.0163528323,
-0.0348852761,
0.0084398258,
-0.0405470505,
-0.059381187,
0.0117753008,
-0.0105722314,
-0.0651611164,
-0.0002809514,
-0.0196060743,
0.0058877957,
-0.0181421209,
-0.011359971,
0.0137714632,
-0.0016154968,
-0.029626783,
0.0742563307,
-0.0671432316,
-0.0466102734,
-0.0479121506,
0.0575674996,
0.0554075167,
-0.0023657451,
0.0862885341,
-0.0239313487,
0.018484816,
-0.0615930073,
0.0119217765,
0.0154665532,
-0.0086103352,
-0.0068097897,
0.0234158896,
0.0032757598,
0.0389057957,
0.0930252522,
-0.0186793059,
0.0025687502,
0.0212512929,
-0.0016468671,
-0.0454944707,
-0.0090925246,
-0.0176257435,
0.043722406,
0.0095655797,
-0.0413947515,
-0.0605837181,
-0.0011481349,
0.0485767387,
-0.0173846688,
-0.0107012484,
-0.0746518075,
0.0425862521,
0.0260078367,
0.0558837131,
0.0311378893,
-0.0237096436,
-0.0408946238,
-0.0007355808,
0.0159009043,
0.0183914062,
-6.5043673e-33,
-0.0483125225,
-0.0199456196,
0.0098170126,
0.0399222001,
-0.0429005772,
0.0176123958,
-0.0505371094,
-0.0106990999,
-0.0099628642,
-0.0365811437,
-0.038676627,
0.0087885791,
0.0338296518,
0.0197673514,
-0.0147595946,
0.0194086228,
0.0665213615,
-0.0155825587,
-0.0270496272,
0.0471048951,
0.0322138146,
0.0177635718,
0.0092686368,
-0.032762412,
-0.0285300631,
-0.0317671448,
0.0020501669,
-0.0126008745,
0.0558631346,
0.0282146521,
-0.0366226844,
0.0529782362,
0.0253175963,
-0.0051724189,
-0.0475840569,
0.0216997527,
-0.0294482112,
0.0001262788,
0.0337983556,
0.0101885507,
0.0180587191,
-0.0220008269,
0.0280628242,
0.009011629,
-0.0194703266,
-0.035459891,
0.0168823507,
-0.0428456515,
-0.0650564954,
-0.0156941283,
-0.0064511192,
0.0374897346,
0.0160271917,
-0.0344017223,
0.0670309216,
0.0228628237,
0.0007468852,
-0.0027799825,
-0.0393840559,
0.0723882243,
0.0605444871,
0.0426008292,
0.0709915683,
0.0446820594,
0.0064080935,
0.0696512833,
0.0099251894,
0.0110299038,
0.0073052123,
-0.0289471149,
0.0019144439,
0.0349307135,
0.0144919977,
0.0173020028,
0.0127254175,
0.0104815997,
-0.0205873027,
0.0380968899,
0.0106575293,
-0.0026760255,
0.058586888,
0.018696025,
-0.0118623106,
-0.0174899139,
-0.0109150773,
0.0451260582,
-0.0294198878,
-0.0102815442,
0.0030259751,
0.0328353159,
-0.0311682038,
-0.0164332446,
0.052681081,
-0.0247772001,
0.0083782142,
0.0200124104,
-0.0092110429,
0.0212350171,
-0.0176777784,
-0.0129960207,
-0.0673689023,
-0.0033691181,
0.008701195,
0.0148026841,
-0.017093692,
0.0003947401,
-0.005443057,
0.0150378644,
-0.0410755724,
0.0174349211,
-0.0078484211,
0.0249215402,
-0.0413475893,
-0.0095828464,
0.0276579428,
-0.035441488,
0.0014313693,
0.0543395467,
-0.0266857948,
-0.0303993374,
0.0131675666,
-0.0119401533,
0.005563586,
0.0369189195,
-0.0693181008,
0.042143777,
-0.0489753224,
0.0281159561,
0.0735053644,
-0.0063104224,
-0.0298705082,
-0.0172247682,
2.648e-7,
0.0264070369,
0.0482562445,
0.0586101972,
0.0153028285,
0.0069999588,
0.0232324675,
-0.0075963857,
0.0183472149,
0.0283096768,
0.0334493145,
0.0315402336,
0.0215758719,
0.0653847978,
0.0158712752,
-0.0757592618,
0.0225901138,
-0.106279701,
-0.0138840741,
-0.0399067663,
-0.0080964519,
0.0121491235,
0.1120699197,
-0.0106551638,
-0.0199724417,
-0.0262841154,
-0.0489329696,
0.0451439582,
-0.0488171764,
-0.0367734358,
0.0062119318,
0.0300248377,
0.0465191975,
-0.0441936143,
-0.0166794956,
0.0202504545,
-0.0110643087,
0.0309821721,
0.0758037195,
-0.0029088762,
-0.0091826366,
0.0497264154,
-0.0198944081,
-0.0204362143,
-0.0000858015,
0.0492926724,
-0.042689357,
0.0015847198,
-0.00238894,
-0.0074159629,
-0.0171759091,
-0.046480231,
0.000282664,
-0.0252314173,
0.0280259158,
-0.0201744959,
-0.0352033004,
0.0046775434,
-0.0787133425,
-0.013351813,
0.0350213498,
-0.0266763046,
-0.0716269463,
-0.032538645,
-0.0383866392,
-0.0025539938,
-0.0229996145,
-0.018515775,
2.459415658e-34,
0.0530916192,
-0.0110342931,
-0.0396071486,
0.0552716888,
-0.0015563286,
-0.0233283155,
0.004141829,
-0.0060210936,
0.0150330951,
-0.1134790927,
-0.0051506259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00838v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00838v4 | OLMo: Accelerating the Science of Language Models | 2024-02-01T18:28:55 | 2024-06-07T21:59:52 | Dirk Groeneveld, Iz Beltagy, Pete Walsh, Akshita Bhagia, Rodney Kinney, Oyvind Tafjord, Ananya Harsh Jha, Hamish Ivison, Ian Magnusson, Yizhong Wang, Shane Arora, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Arman Cohan, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Yuling Gu, Jack Hessel, Tushar Khot, William Merrill, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Valentina Pyatkin, Abhilasha Ravichander, Dustin Schwenk, Saurabh Shah, Will Smith, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Mitchell Wortsman, Pradeep Dasigi, Nathan Lambert, Kyle Richardson, Luke Zettlemoyer, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo, Luca Soldaini, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have become ubiquitous in both NLP research and in
commercial product offerings. As their commercial importance has surged, the
most powerful models have become closed off, gated behind proprietary
interfaces, with important details of their training data, architectures, and
development undisclosed. Given the importance of these details in
scientifically studying these models, including their biases and potential
risks, we believe it is essential for the research community to have access to
powerful, truly open LMs. To this end, we have built OLMo, a competitive, truly
Open Language Model, to enable the scientific study of language models. Unlike
most prior efforts that have only released model weights and inference code, we
release OLMo alongside open training data and training and evaluation code. We
hope this release will empower the open research community and inspire a new
wave of innovation. | OLMo: Accelerating the Science of Language Models: Language models (LMs) have become ubiquitous in both NLP research and in
commercial product offerings. As their commercial importance has surged, the
most powerful models have become closed off, gated behind proprietary
interfaces, with important details of their training data, architectures, and
development undisclosed. Given the importance of these details in
scientifically studying these models, including their biases and potential
risks, we believe it is essential for the research community to have access to
powerful, truly open LMs. To this end, we have built OLMo, a competitive, truly
Open Language Model, to enable the scientific study of language models. Unlike
most prior efforts that have only released model weights and inference code, we
release OLMo alongside open training data and training and evaluation code. We
hope this release will empower the open research community and inspire a new
wave of innovation. | [
0.0362867638,
0.105918698,
-0.0129534611,
0.0552931391,
-0.0228223354,
-0.0065288497,
0.0054404368,
0.0170985777,
-0.0138259353,
-0.0379685611,
-0.0576814227,
-0.0289225969,
0.001408962,
0.0576569103,
0.0192445293,
-0.0202745255,
0.0347661078,
-0.0276184492,
0.0010852836,
0.0002001015,
0.0203756504,
0.0224962253,
0.0161427166,
0.0380040891,
0.0439382195,
-0.0184789859,
0.0207128618,
-0.0011127738,
-0.0344034694,
-0.027907582,
0.0150310341,
0.074209705,
0.0042267176,
0.0549657159,
0.0000018969,
-0.0525051914,
-0.01812464,
-0.0016967532,
-0.0398790538,
0.0296899136,
0.0719039813,
-0.0318085477,
0.0077424301,
0.0173326638,
-0.024725724,
-0.0377316102,
0.076293759,
0.0098527446,
0.0291984063,
0.0687943548,
-0.0014340752,
-0.0272201765,
0.0306166485,
-0.0528754592,
-0.0277572572,
-0.0042358669,
0.0321825519,
-0.0171992444,
-0.021436356,
0.0366941318,
-0.0162084717,
0.0292847771,
-0.0005617143,
0.0250292551,
0.0037191892,
0.0388742536,
-0.030108707,
-0.0517595746,
-0.012761713,
0.0803925171,
0.0057313992,
-0.0478004999,
0.00627671,
0.0066289306,
-0.045755066,
-0.0054330733,
-0.063839294,
0.0734839737,
0.0421679057,
0.0514481366,
0.0405567735,
-0.0000844561,
0.0470606387,
0.0318076685,
0.0066415886,
0.0784802139,
0.0383991636,
-0.006857316,
0.003234216,
-0.0203534495,
-0.0256221667,
-0.0557974353,
-0.0121543268,
-0.0035218569,
0.0262893215,
0.0247925669,
-0.0271741748,
-0.0264642332,
0.0481570177,
-0.0548444614,
0.0745345429,
0.019205194,
-0.0132130869,
0.0260973312,
0.001405976,
0.0181470122,
-0.0184127484,
0.0195959043,
-0.0138532137,
-0.0057600439,
-0.0258942451,
-0.0167684238,
-0.0063888193,
0.0189374853,
-0.0551416837,
-0.0325132385,
-0.0234644599,
0.0042775534,
0.0036000537,
-0.0297158193,
0.0366560109,
0.0147925233,
-0.0147509044,
-0.0099637117,
-0.0361820087,
0.0170558803,
-0.0029907636,
0.014399468,
-0.0168590136,
-0.0755530149,
-0.0174731072,
0.030372927,
-0.0175966583,
-0.0264187604,
0.0050846385,
0.0677018538,
0.0460855514,
-0.0326753147,
-0.008616901,
-0.0071958718,
-0.0234835111,
-0.0632959828,
-0.0083892802,
-0.078123346,
0.0179171078,
0.018465694,
0.0232174825,
-0.0567372255,
0.0205974691,
0.0188286174,
-0.0570156686,
0.0655861944,
-0.0620644949,
-0.0169371944,
-0.0122814337,
-0.0077704052,
0.0473242439,
0.0574845374,
0.0113825956,
-0.0314606242,
0.0654137656,
0.0042841495,
-0.0011452779,
0.0643365383,
0.009419376,
-0.0147588039,
-0.019518923,
0.0282636061,
0.0391045846,
0.0361653976,
0.0317706838,
0.0655710697,
-0.0147249978,
-0.0376473255,
0.0755773336,
0.0507767312,
0.0280467439,
0.022179123,
0.0128702531,
-0.0071349042,
0.000866349,
-0.0420870259,
-0.0314571895,
-0.0080332113,
-0.0298165642,
0.0091453465,
0.0288484227,
0.0407284684,
-0.0188167114,
-0.0205595754,
-0.064552635,
-0.0312905684,
-0.0040797056,
-0.0219859872,
0.0582868345,
0.0025987278,
0.016759932,
0.0683100522,
0.0774586573,
-0.0450343452,
0.0103393011,
-0.0574986525,
0.047650557,
0.0244659074,
0.0621866696,
-0.0016061811,
0.0166136678,
-0.0147051048,
-0.0034867397,
0.0695086047,
0.0640145466,
-0.0080719339,
0.0244992729,
-0.0373415574,
0.0067787259,
-0.0189093444,
0.0408910997,
0.0028556834,
0.0456186049,
-0.0153875286,
0.0150456773,
-0.0324465446,
-0.0524076559,
0.0551057272,
-0.0550006367,
-0.0221902374,
-0.0068561677,
-0.0459402166,
0.0302048922,
0.0105618872,
-0.0020157353,
0.0274874698,
0.0385248736,
-0.0281792879,
-0.004320947,
-0.0022016955,
0.0048451093,
-0.0194057412,
0.0456479415,
-0.0129860668,
0.0336254612,
0.047327131,
-0.0248756949,
-0.0226801354,
0.0515261255,
0.0122967716,
0.0608382337,
-0.0699031428,
0.0211834032,
-0.0139885107,
0.0306230746,
-0.0165305827,
0.0580336936,
-0.0213872306,
0.0503329933,
0.0260382742,
-0.0212867558,
0.0196162965,
-0.0411442891,
-0.0330500938,
0.0094765676,
-0.0149453422,
0.0102314912,
0.0044056699,
-0.005654953,
-0.0335587263,
-0.0174354631,
-0.0768203214,
0.0326310955,
-0.0207384862,
0.0181031879,
0.0252208784,
0.0120298825,
-0.0131174214,
0.0080419611,
0.0034155573,
-0.0173638519,
0.0105719091,
0.0089756809,
0.0378815942,
-0.0143384477,
-0.0172658227,
-0.0606169924,
-0.0508442707,
-0.0092934035,
0.0590024889,
-0.0274243709,
0.016075816,
-0.0276152492,
0.0048820893,
-0.0455991402,
0.0566605926,
-0.0120832929,
-0.0148145249,
0.0081879105,
-0.0383467153,
0.0219225753,
0.0461446345,
-0.0061454456,
0.0274981186,
0.063779287,
-0.0108163236,
-0.0320262052,
-0.0268696267,
-0.0337008201,
-0.023545118,
-0.0237375479,
-0.0243287627,
-0.0027767103,
0.0973172337,
-0.0080517363,
-0.0266231392,
-0.0203020182,
0.0026233857,
-0.0277888235,
-0.0074272188,
-0.000914422,
0.0093082963,
-0.0325327478,
0.035878595,
-0.0433314592,
-0.0743656531,
0.0469780192,
-0.0665842667,
0.008312895,
-0.0324148312,
-0.0068379249,
-0.0735322759,
0.0626690611,
-0.0032166762,
0.0058781505,
0.0401897579,
0.0004094124,
0.0000922545,
0.0181015283,
0.0023094516,
-0.0417690948,
0.0162714664,
-0.0507548973,
0.0193043146,
0.0050415606,
-0.0248978604,
0.000063188,
-0.0325899422,
-0.0466232449,
0.0318931043,
0.0159068443,
-0.0169174653,
-0.0381675437,
0.0187958553,
-0.0039968756,
0.0301107354,
-0.0176932532,
0.0230099224,
-0.0191026591,
0.0238815844,
0.0782113373,
-0.0095471973,
0.0152113494,
-0.0626315773,
-0.0109862555,
0.0417664945,
0.0426221229,
0.038050618,
-0.037204776,
0.0047694026,
0.0509534217,
-0.0257200897,
-0.0330896229,
-0.0008588443,
0.0222726241,
-0.0259281155,
-0.0092549538,
0.1276543885,
0.0219028089,
-0.0596260466,
0.0077963718,
-0.0140901618,
0.045436278,
0.0310709085,
0.0037519862,
-0.0783985406,
-0.0459344313,
0.0055575506,
0.0148650827,
0.0031735601,
-0.0194435939,
-0.0150072044,
-0.1059533879,
-0.0047111325,
-0.004662191,
-0.0346756168,
-0.0062794746,
-0.0574279763,
-0.0014105787,
-0.063979283,
0.0146124782,
0.01579028,
-0.0213712305,
0.0165598076,
0.0141881173,
-0.0213519465,
-0.0525551848,
0.0314375833,
-0.064629823,
0.0669117495,
0.0637016371,
-0.0057349564,
-0.0084153963,
-0.0387392975,
0.0383688584,
-0.0133400913,
-0.0173557922,
-0.0474699475,
0.047029011,
-0.0261017885,
-0.0065764459,
-0.0337017961,
0.0374632776,
-0.0529870987,
-0.0063365097,
-0.0334612168,
0.0700860545,
0.0341701284,
-0.0240363348,
-0.0249487069,
-0.0165967923,
-0.0176413525,
0.0801798105,
0.0064105638,
-0.0436414704,
-0.0278614704,
-0.0199370552,
0.0018085187,
0.0005785821,
-0.0349780433,
0.0106090177,
0.0229585133,
-0.0471514687,
-0.040862821,
-0.0054574073,
0.017094627,
-0.0029324652,
0.0183648374,
0.0086917067,
-0.0308772363,
-0.0340245292,
-0.043537464,
0.0581475385,
-0.0490020402,
0.0193598606,
-0.0613628589,
0.0043658977,
0.0592394844,
0.0003489318,
-0.0209951308,
0.029409498,
-0.0925985575,
-0.0839945003,
-0.0090306932,
0.0607803687,
0.0320506319,
-0.0045127319,
0.0004218328,
-0.0751992688,
0.0115426704,
-0.0028899538,
-0.0256097391,
0.0282778852,
0.0168650914,
-0.0271622613,
0.0335319564,
0.0448689833,
-0.0208603721,
-0.0033351011,
0.0164940543,
0.0406125896,
-0.0066484823,
-0.042466931,
0.0251448266,
-0.0189912822,
0.0617352314,
-0.0024658462,
-0.0203596614,
-0.0637977123,
-0.000465943,
-0.0175369196,
-0.0079754889,
-0.0566275306,
0.0127103571,
0.0545022637,
0.0220656674,
-0.0126640964,
0.0172179826,
-0.0272869579,
0.064406015,
-0.0525824651,
0.0232224073,
0.037776161,
-0.0040678354,
-0.0025953962,
0.0020817737,
-0.025837943,
0.0284247939,
-0.0768195316,
0.0310459416,
-0.0348667093,
0.0275004748,
-0.0037012098,
0.0032102535,
0.0200201347,
0.0237727482,
-0.0497532226,
-0.0052436125,
-0.027108904,
0.0323589891,
0.0344958231,
0.0047822325,
0.075893268,
-0.0217577741,
-0.0104495175,
-0.030530069,
0.0404725894,
-0.0083241565,
-0.0473840013,
0.0491884947,
0.0157126803,
-0.0325881243,
-0.0103708804,
0.0950509757,
0.051517237,
0.0263436846,
-0.020823678,
0.0052462374,
-0.0148368794,
0.0042196969,
0.0402137041,
0.0318069458,
-0.0446880683,
0.0163237117,
-0.0391093381,
-0.067312941,
-0.0004162992,
0.0214926116,
0.010806853,
-0.010038876,
0.0185980834,
0.078840524,
0.013146258,
-0.0469946004,
-0.0488416851,
-0.022356905,
-0.0233370177,
-0.0238108747,
-0.0173451938,
-6.706835181e-33,
-0.018379651,
0.0119759161,
-0.0090893004,
-0.0110368794,
-0.0325256437,
0.0076217838,
-0.0185395479,
0.0385939069,
-0.0451144837,
-0.0290595554,
0.0019045925,
0.0295864493,
-0.0031268117,
0.0427101739,
0.0199197084,
0.0238411482,
0.0199017748,
-0.0376095548,
-0.0077439616,
-0.0149851469,
0.0239142962,
0.0338152088,
0.0476977304,
-0.0152849844,
0.0652718022,
-0.0362147763,
-0.0134349838,
0.0325795561,
-0.0114546893,
0.0641066879,
-0.050108321,
0.0241651535,
0.0287859049,
-0.0323883146,
-0.008260794,
-0.0180195123,
-0.0684889778,
0.0093528451,
0.03800584,
-0.0215503313,
-0.0275706481,
-0.0084754545,
0.0335086882,
-0.0161398984,
-0.007426051,
-0.0231165886,
0.0177830365,
-0.0227834545,
-0.0309701469,
0.0345600508,
-0.0352764465,
0.0330301784,
0.0178110264,
0.0091529638,
0.0316071957,
-0.0073920768,
-0.0206964016,
0.0226104856,
-0.0186439231,
0.0167927723,
0.0315102674,
0.0566668734,
0.0571055412,
0.0505042113,
0.0175623242,
0.0535898022,
0.0060715619,
-0.0342108682,
-0.0325059406,
0.0150136054,
0.0516259931,
0.0612599961,
0.0536791347,
0.0140142217,
0.01789915,
0.0000993985,
-0.0685757697,
-0.019776497,
0.0369168967,
0.0200069677,
0.029108569,
0.0160752386,
-0.0091790222,
-0.027856607,
-0.0515907221,
-0.079565376,
-0.040547356,
-0.0137491729,
0.017018646,
0.0262705144,
-0.0209719855,
-0.0140371062,
0.0209663771,
-0.0631933659,
-0.0169474669,
-0.0056349155,
0.0266301874,
0.0204812344,
-0.0056621111,
0.0303630661,
-0.1055314243,
-0.0363458879,
-0.0172469839,
-0.0223308485,
-0.0028727567,
0.0047853165,
0.0066967988,
0.0063987621,
-0.0507160164,
0.0017136693,
-0.0374502167,
-0.0003891453,
0.0054609394,
0.0555681363,
0.0249781683,
0.0003663616,
-0.0006614993,
0.0468020216,
0.0392312109,
0.0335128047,
-0.0521084927,
-0.0078331754,
0.0050368658,
0.014785097,
-0.0218209419,
0.0017496352,
-0.0317674316,
0.0132175302,
0.0265327264,
-0.0298771095,
-0.0133809261,
0.0083413664,
2.503e-7,
0.073156625,
0.0193859152,
0.0063534472,
0.0417120084,
0.0205051601,
0.0144317942,
-0.0264567249,
0.0544075333,
0.0048024929,
-0.0162373967,
-0.0404197127,
0.0175404102,
0.0665570647,
-0.0093202377,
-0.0738014653,
-0.0105581321,
-0.0619828999,
-0.003462187,
-0.0528963394,
-0.0314083658,
0.0008918633,
0.1281647086,
0.0110765034,
0.0057063033,
-0.0309759211,
-0.036610052,
0.0872514695,
-0.047859624,
-0.0040649264,
0.0307099707,
0.0154057853,
0.0384732224,
-0.0154378619,
-0.0310251676,
-0.014520674,
0.0392539985,
-0.0056864326,
0.0646379888,
0.0043455814,
-0.0503100492,
0.0458716229,
-0.0422255769,
-0.0373422652,
-0.0681260601,
0.0902065337,
-0.0181332082,
-0.0413790494,
-0.0475614481,
0.0056435103,
0.0045796107,
0.0127452603,
-0.0547468662,
-0.0153316706,
0.0027938776,
0.013215105,
-0.0321225375,
-0.0295974091,
-0.0651678368,
-0.0646881312,
-0.0508959666,
-0.0364099108,
-0.0495038554,
-0.0132370787,
-0.0152943404,
-0.0022084927,
-0.0336811505,
0.0137841199,
2.608489923e-34,
0.0584463887,
-0.0112635009,
-0.0158047806,
0.0394023508,
0.0296027176,
-0.0364489108,
0.0337164737,
0.0163774583,
-0.0147486562,
-0.1251100153,
-0.0143562434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00835v1 | ALISON: Fast and Effective Stylometric Authorship Obfuscation | 2024-02-01T18:22:32 | 2024-02-01T18:22:32 | Eric Xing, Saranya Venkatraman, Thai Le, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.0 | Authorship Attribution (AA) and Authorship Obfuscation (AO) are two competing
tasks of increasing importance in privacy research. Modern AA leverages an
author's consistent writing style to match a text to its author using an AA
classifier. AO is the corresponding adversarial task, aiming to modify a text
in such a way that its semantics are preserved, yet an AA model cannot
correctly infer its authorship. To address privacy concerns raised by
state-of-the-art (SOTA) AA methods, new AO methods have been proposed but
remain largely impractical to use due to their prohibitively slow training and
obfuscation speed, often taking hours. To this challenge, we propose a
practical AO method, ALISON, that (1) dramatically reduces training/obfuscation
time, demonstrating more than 10x faster obfuscation than SOTA AO methods, (2)
achieves better obfuscation success through attacking three transformer-based
AA methods on two benchmark datasets, typically performing 15% better than
competing methods, (3) does not require direct signals from a target AA
classifier during obfuscation, and (4) utilizes unique stylometric features,
allowing sound model interpretation for explainable obfuscation. We also
demonstrate that ALISON can effectively prevent four SOTA AA methods from
accurately determining the authorship of ChatGPT-generated texts, all while
minimally changing the original text semantics. To ensure the reproducibility
of our findings, our code and data are available at:
https://github.com/EricX003/ALISON. | ALISON: Fast and Effective Stylometric Authorship Obfuscation: Authorship Attribution (AA) and Authorship Obfuscation (AO) are two competing
tasks of increasing importance in privacy research. Modern AA leverages an
author's consistent writing style to match a text to its author using an AA
classifier. AO is the corresponding adversarial task, aiming to modify a text
in such a way that its semantics are preserved, yet an AA model cannot
correctly infer its authorship. To address privacy concerns raised by
state-of-the-art (SOTA) AA methods, new AO methods have been proposed but
remain largely impractical to use due to their prohibitively slow training and
obfuscation speed, often taking hours. To this challenge, we propose a
practical AO method, ALISON, that (1) dramatically reduces training/obfuscation
time, demonstrating more than 10x faster obfuscation than SOTA AO methods, (2)
achieves better obfuscation success through attacking three transformer-based
AA methods on two benchmark datasets, typically performing 15% better than
competing methods, (3) does not require direct signals from a target AA
classifier during obfuscation, and (4) utilizes unique stylometric features,
allowing sound model interpretation for explainable obfuscation. We also
demonstrate that ALISON can effectively prevent four SOTA AA methods from
accurately determining the authorship of ChatGPT-generated texts, all while
minimally changing the original text semantics. To ensure the reproducibility
of our findings, our code and data are available at:
https://github.com/EricX003/ALISON. | [
0.0106004095,
0.1068911776,
-0.0321827866,
0.0633746237,
-0.068033278,
-0.0002673095,
0.0890969709,
0.0059057046,
-0.000261078,
0.0287859514,
-0.0207476299,
-0.0249851905,
0.0430014133,
0.0230260808,
0.0217398778,
0.0591879562,
-0.035121534,
0.0413170531,
0.0113014821,
-0.006679853,
-0.0195582267,
0.0214523301,
0.0267890934,
0.0313385278,
0.0339593813,
-0.0436090343,
0.0191319417,
-0.0033505708,
0.0359416157,
0.0323518887,
0.0056269434,
0.0401070043,
-0.0218126979,
0.1121439561,
0.0000019416,
-0.0239089299,
-0.0262721125,
0.0558774024,
-0.018263761,
0.0086228279,
0.069678694,
0.0136172147,
-0.0133657586,
0.0156427808,
-0.024010526,
0.0202863943,
0.0239577014,
0.0431634746,
0.0390173271,
0.0993603915,
-0.0257085562,
-0.0592808314,
0.0296171252,
-0.0340806246,
0.015377556,
-0.0084914481,
0.0083906464,
-0.0805582553,
-0.0413309187,
0.044661209,
-0.0007415784,
0.0777708441,
0.0040125116,
-0.006727322,
-0.0259813089,
0.0172567423,
0.0052754432,
0.022683518,
0.042565573,
0.0070124995,
-0.0028681753,
-0.0458154269,
0.0335731134,
0.0403754301,
0.0143870367,
0.0442433804,
0.014882734,
0.0334827602,
-0.053540796,
-0.0364854708,
-0.0223976821,
0.0044214115,
0.0298511889,
0.0084571103,
0.0237292424,
-0.0011604256,
0.0057164202,
-0.0039734798,
-0.0553132258,
-0.0500072986,
-0.0207009241,
-0.0542284921,
0.0742888972,
-0.0133863203,
0.0598117188,
-0.0072851316,
-0.0582069084,
-0.0773271173,
0.0024118572,
-0.0274557881,
0.0171406344,
-0.011183653,
0.0078736022,
0.0304569565,
-0.032278236,
0.057088051,
-0.0321031697,
0.0276890993,
-0.0033650291,
-0.0053716358,
-0.0286187027,
-0.0334285982,
-0.038156718,
0.0030949789,
-0.0188971385,
0.0023754535,
-0.0316037238,
0.0030282254,
0.0156664029,
0.0092145596,
-0.0415378734,
0.0103171254,
-0.0535043478,
0.0119557669,
0.0526909828,
-0.0227899347,
0.0127470549,
-0.0059135864,
-0.0047810455,
0.0062421248,
-0.0216736402,
0.0189331565,
0.0139630958,
-0.0138149913,
0.0242559426,
0.0493347421,
-0.0036064724,
-0.0110592982,
0.0210151635,
-0.0359921642,
-0.028092999,
-0.0223382823,
-0.0303972531,
-0.0065158959,
-0.0070445379,
0.0010156117,
-0.0192043148,
-0.0966187939,
-0.0303130541,
0.0203058124,
-0.0402259789,
0.0667288378,
0.0217792224,
-0.0357816778,
0.0546669438,
0.0274798144,
0.0055495496,
-0.0279470459,
0.0551628843,
0.091032207,
0.0370237306,
-0.0236960948,
0.0487097874,
0.0035279642,
0.0458525829,
0.0076457243,
0.0413790867,
-0.0106488606,
-0.0053117694,
-0.0216833651,
0.0032871244,
0.0175217185,
0.0152758611,
-0.0823354721,
0.0554919839,
0.0161398165,
-0.0023736665,
0.0671308935,
-0.0125655429,
0.0318388939,
-0.0012897042,
-0.0227997694,
-0.0189909283,
0.0101927612,
-0.098516129,
-0.0401569642,
-0.0527338423,
0.0243007243,
-0.0042714393,
-0.007899221,
0.0253923405,
-0.0207099672,
0.041546423,
0.0161375217,
0.0076560513,
0.0395010896,
-0.0373980924,
-0.0242265407,
-0.0207694788,
-0.0515688844,
-0.0255983062,
-0.059321858,
0.0030320466,
0.0139043014,
0.0775873736,
-0.0293801986,
0.0214927513,
-0.0594082512,
-0.0000604529,
0.0054474343,
-0.0251283348,
0.0181568824,
0.0683315322,
-0.0430616438,
-0.0255209971,
-0.0434084982,
-0.0056744823,
0.0746378824,
0.0338288732,
0.0029638079,
0.0383239314,
-0.0345360003,
0.0041235392,
0.0196584798,
-0.0264826026,
-0.0571825616,
0.0516652241,
0.0092038121,
0.0315956771,
-0.0044103041,
-0.0165298134,
0.0077467985,
-0.0042787283,
-0.0379288457,
-0.0311476942,
-0.0021658046,
0.0233841147,
-0.0331874713,
-0.0063444981,
-0.0082367612,
-0.0082138311,
0.0372196659,
-0.0277741756,
-0.0095102862,
0.012882269,
0.0019776148,
0.0076076351,
-0.0241889022,
0.0064078569,
-0.0120176729,
0.0559615865,
-0.0445657521,
0.0355846249,
0.0072484184,
0.0124006355,
-0.0582578555,
-0.0299301986,
0.0432220288,
-0.0036981571,
-0.0100525189,
-0.0353156514,
-0.0434511714,
0.0124161262,
0.0182549506,
0.0060294885,
0.0302165039,
-0.0869685635,
-0.0141905686,
0.0065038418,
-0.0023006245,
0.0246183369,
-0.0089032827,
-0.0030417547,
0.0012826165,
-0.0099992193,
-0.0439812243,
-0.0559842177,
-0.0687458441,
-0.0044561969,
0.0347220302,
0.0135859232,
-0.0426363051,
0.0099684736,
-0.0031329687,
-0.0137876561,
0.0237229988,
0.0248698015,
-0.0164901447,
-0.0298962723,
0.0203125626,
-0.0079120519,
-0.0032275401,
-0.0427914299,
-0.0274238195,
-0.0091136461,
0.0211842842,
-0.0241924431,
0.059699554,
0.0115694804,
0.0211153161,
-0.0165986642,
0.0231020153,
0.0138227651,
0.0079543684,
-0.015172217,
0.0263347477,
-0.0082005402,
-0.0567224473,
0.0333484001,
-0.006197344,
0.0177766904,
-0.0383099541,
-0.0409539081,
0.015454405,
0.0278791655,
-0.0302954186,
0.0211563725,
-0.0180781316,
0.0301723611,
-0.0403372906,
-0.0491680689,
-0.0308624282,
0.0494372584,
-0.0626377463,
-0.0101530114,
-0.0242352895,
-0.011099983,
-0.0303623695,
0.072510384,
0.017491959,
0.0412487425,
0.0631103814,
-0.0339180641,
-0.0050354721,
0.0304287504,
0.0821328536,
0.0015605439,
-0.0231764428,
0.023597246,
-0.0065699723,
0.0298358686,
-0.0376126468,
-0.0121088456,
-0.1183990315,
0.0238854084,
-0.0146302702,
0.0090221521,
-0.072280243,
-0.0510675758,
-0.053181082,
0.0515643172,
0.0170717929,
-0.0163547583,
-0.0157415476,
-0.0201000236,
0.0211057253,
-0.0207714401,
-0.0504206531,
-0.0286723152,
-0.0116028516,
-0.0180678666,
0.0510046966,
0.0035867733,
0.0129359495,
0.0326397642,
-0.0397096686,
-0.007232361,
-0.0140464893,
-0.0687106997,
0.0044388985,
0.0416500047,
-0.0393779576,
-0.002999106,
0.1028324738,
0.0014692602,
-0.0072485614,
-0.0201144125,
0.0228065886,
0.023181852,
-0.0154378545,
0.0012381551,
-0.0946442187,
-0.0037839056,
0.0061762389,
0.0356448181,
-0.0266950652,
-0.020282425,
-0.040450532,
-0.0365720578,
0.0077542397,
0.0016119912,
-0.0640715361,
0.0140471663,
-0.0333706662,
-0.0558558442,
-0.0103525342,
-0.0406802706,
-0.0440355353,
0.0162683222,
-0.0141875809,
-0.0392516069,
0.0035937072,
0.0384934582,
0.0052018072,
-0.0206199531,
-0.0022040003,
0.0609211214,
0.0838569403,
-0.0269980654,
-0.0284057781,
-0.029169742,
0.0253746435,
-0.0223866459,
-0.0135639729,
0.0957463086,
-0.0071045444,
0.0042462726,
-0.0226473603,
0.0883293897,
-0.0036742445,
-0.0141148176,
0.0251042657,
-0.0108342804,
-0.0061019626,
-0.0333318301,
0.0338170566,
-0.0230778195,
0.0243854728,
0.0519119911,
-0.029939279,
-0.0318139829,
-0.0532218888,
-0.0397205465,
0.0426905639,
-0.0137364184,
-0.0106614465,
0.0084007811,
-0.002770687,
-0.094670862,
-0.0312361382,
0.0193312224,
-0.0330576263,
-0.0117486669,
0.03075606,
0.0279647671,
-0.002051305,
-0.0157088228,
-0.0572440065,
-0.0268461667,
-0.048359111,
0.0577067807,
-0.0015891955,
0.0102088563,
-0.0028530057,
-0.0140629886,
0.008079771,
0.0285883043,
-0.0641651824,
-0.037037883,
0.0383259766,
-0.0181141086,
0.0082710432,
0.0536287278,
-0.062589176,
-0.0801756755,
0.0309894402,
0.052140031,
-0.0173497181,
0.0166339539,
0.0588722043,
-0.0479378812,
-0.0127156479,
0.0191376489,
0.004562004,
0.0218463801,
0.0721519962,
-0.0787709504,
-0.0414385088,
0.0171013065,
-0.0080584036,
0.0364788957,
0.0355391242,
-0.0338488594,
0.018582575,
0.0048644012,
0.0030626578,
-0.0137865106,
0.0114765894,
-0.0082026673,
-0.0198014583,
0.0431464054,
-0.0039194007,
0.0113812443,
0.0417619571,
0.0214612205,
0.024720883,
-0.0276723001,
0.0468676761,
-0.018031178,
0.0707090124,
-0.0052348864,
0.0205952246,
0.0158341937,
0.0420403443,
0.0417453721,
0.0570475832,
-0.0109361168,
0.0096107712,
0.0257986449,
0.0366668068,
-0.0269401502,
0.0562365688,
-0.0807250887,
0.0131827444,
-0.0434597805,
0.0578945763,
-0.0265353341,
0.0101970285,
0.0178738739,
-0.0303803906,
0.0050219013,
-0.0127197495,
0.051064603,
-0.0016184382,
-0.0138244601,
-0.0468002707,
-0.0270123761,
-0.0307337437,
0.0229902044,
0.07502345,
0.0421217941,
0.026806958,
0.0283181947,
-0.0608785003,
-0.0435060225,
-0.0459821746,
0.0222396385,
0.0094913431,
0.0305390321,
-0.0044491715,
-0.0444049649,
-0.0313476883,
0.0461301096,
-0.0149705103,
0.0376414359,
-0.0145173706,
-0.0279755853,
0.0432007425,
-0.0159887522,
-0.0317385308,
-0.0675891787,
0.0354337022,
0.0264054537,
-0.0620828234,
0.0425611325,
-4.979405458e-33,
0.0289269742,
-0.018138323,
-0.028025873,
0.0375018828,
0.0262739845,
0.0212742444,
-0.0038692032,
-0.0354190096,
-0.0179840978,
-0.011170391,
-0.0415098257,
0.0169319324,
-0.0158239007,
0.0321897827,
-0.0287613776,
0.0089394599,
0.0501779951,
0.0309337974,
-0.0325900689,
0.044530075,
0.0609934293,
-0.0017915751,
0.0353791825,
-0.0822958201,
0.0449375659,
-0.0361506864,
-0.0785523281,
-0.0208260436,
-0.05574302,
0.0259563513,
-0.0014408532,
-0.004721167,
0.0058863424,
0.0041358373,
-0.0023629421,
0.0205578785,
-0.0813214853,
-0.017416073,
-0.0088201156,
0.0186996255,
0.0309763011,
-0.0668108165,
0.0543378741,
-0.0379352272,
0.0101823779,
-0.0249787383,
0.0343039967,
0.0052625723,
-0.0184609126,
-0.0573634654,
-0.031415008,
0.0163467918,
-0.0387653746,
-0.0239787456,
0.040152289,
-0.0012406053,
0.009104399,
-0.027325131,
-0.0690944344,
-0.0234901011,
-0.0089237764,
-0.0236409716,
-0.0108517297,
0.0305407923,
0.0296619684,
-0.0073611103,
0.0330342986,
0.0298312381,
-0.0228363518,
0.0326416418,
0.035354197,
0.0341564864,
0.0754257962,
0.0804222003,
0.0370579213,
-0.0593471006,
-0.052877415,
0.0254732892,
0.0036432366,
-0.0304718651,
0.0324144214,
0.0131140091,
-0.0818032026,
-0.0320220105,
-0.0330825187,
-0.0553497933,
-0.0086068902,
0.0118139097,
-0.0180498622,
-0.0229823887,
-0.0453829691,
0.0080822203,
0.0009513422,
-0.066523537,
-0.0178331528,
0.0212894492,
-0.0183530767,
0.0492429845,
0.004897912,
0.0133682387,
-0.008277717,
-0.0091045517,
0.0313869938,
0.0015248735,
0.0244770218,
-0.01634451,
0.1222281009,
0.0179354828,
-0.0720966831,
-0.0317850895,
0.0052441712,
0.0636499003,
0.0524621271,
0.0067112697,
-0.0025920777,
0.0182420053,
0.0109613854,
-0.0154685387,
0.0243553016,
0.0177210011,
-0.0459463187,
0.0376178324,
0.0132152159,
-0.0259909052,
0.0037981493,
-0.0281639379,
0.0502773076,
-0.0378330648,
0.0485585555,
-0.042949561,
-0.0067829723,
-0.0359958448,
2.596e-7,
0.0653103217,
-0.0094405338,
0.0342514403,
-0.0165880248,
0.0145278564,
0.0610742532,
0.0480561666,
0.0426120982,
-0.0238356069,
0.0163349081,
-0.0019607837,
-0.0001269248,
0.0839018524,
0.0082492549,
-0.0581681915,
0.0055281366,
-0.0033044405,
0.0015374834,
-0.0547339842,
0.0298730917,
0.0118325306,
0.0487435535,
0.0664475709,
-0.038299188,
-0.0167675819,
-0.053785488,
0.0510547273,
-0.0134380041,
0.0191807225,
0.0354679748,
0.0083511192,
-0.0048242393,
0.0328612477,
-0.0326253325,
-0.0271699652,
-0.0054442445,
-0.0351511315,
0.080755949,
-0.0019623474,
0.0063329046,
0.0105119599,
-0.0402703546,
-0.008286343,
-0.0320423208,
0.0366805643,
0.0457185991,
-0.049926769,
0.0033790495,
0.0143530583,
-0.0244573727,
0.0309617575,
0.0090410309,
-0.0245139822,
0.0182519387,
0.0216310993,
-0.0365666971,
-0.0031914879,
-0.065421164,
-0.0277493577,
-0.020318795,
-0.0352880917,
0.0323058255,
0.0114813615,
0.0079426914,
0.0659819245,
-0.0523146763,
0.0432345346,
2.729922392e-34,
-0.0011320146,
0.0008978978,
-0.0269841626,
0.0099602053,
0.0447222367,
-0.0017194713,
0.0652450621,
0.0276405644,
0.002942302,
-0.0466781892,
-0.0018194666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01778v1 | Introduction to speech recognition | 2024-02-01T17:54:15 | 2024-02-01T17:54:15 | Gabriel Dauphin | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This document contains lectures and practical experimentations using Matlab
and implementing a system which is actually correctly classifying three words
(one, two and three) with the help of a very small database. To achieve this
performance, it uses speech modeling specificities, powerful computer
algorithms (dynamic time warping and Dijktra's algorithm) and machine learning
(nearest neighbor). This document introduces also some machine learning
evaluation metrics. | Introduction to speech recognition: This document contains lectures and practical experimentations using Matlab
and implementing a system which is actually correctly classifying three words
(one, two and three) with the help of a very small database. To achieve this
performance, it uses speech modeling specificities, powerful computer
algorithms (dynamic time warping and Dijktra's algorithm) and machine learning
(nearest neighbor). This document introduces also some machine learning
evaluation metrics. | [
0.0292417184,
-0.0229308121,
0.0035267384,
0.0085104806,
-0.0453116186,
0.0208095983,
0.0236227643,
0.0136552732,
-0.0065445988,
-0.0543685891,
-0.0124469567,
0.0237116236,
0.0914454237,
0.0049860203,
0.0002267579,
-0.0840996951,
0.0568361245,
-0.0269914027,
0.0305753592,
-0.0094281277,
0.01662568,
0.0162720587,
-0.0520660207,
0.0595768988,
-0.0360814445,
0.0439229496,
-0.0178873353,
-0.0493860953,
0.000334782,
-0.0219946783,
-0.0116057405,
0.0229285602,
0.0044462578,
0.0134395817,
0.0000017283,
-0.0463621616,
0.0051092166,
-0.029686654,
-0.0175229162,
-0.0482703112,
0.0275409874,
0.0207194444,
0.0028686803,
0.0299542006,
-0.0484036021,
-0.0180229582,
0.0580838025,
0.0136931026,
0.0355953872,
0.0859728307,
-0.0110542048,
-0.0466401353,
-0.0176959857,
0.0264594611,
0.0112083117,
-0.0162773803,
-0.0025353138,
0.0154445414,
0.0282060113,
-0.0534158014,
0.0089633726,
0.023058746,
-0.0687263012,
0.0148193985,
0.0506813973,
0.0181417242,
-0.0502550043,
-0.0571375154,
-0.0442521609,
0.0524165444,
-0.0183944553,
-0.0363078713,
0.0180463139,
0.0035980539,
-0.0410667993,
-0.0193541218,
0.0174302626,
-0.0625778139,
-0.0147068454,
-0.0276866686,
0.0213721115,
0.0517046899,
-0.0055630794,
0.0158142559,
-0.0097112199,
0.0190708954,
-0.0125758443,
-0.0234643016,
0.0018585031,
-0.056747999,
0.0551281609,
-0.0221480411,
0.0515740663,
0.0272382107,
0.0255883988,
-0.0187428854,
-0.0101829488,
-0.0529749282,
0.0102929939,
-0.0948385373,
-0.0026609944,
-0.0024117678,
-0.0113595733,
0.0375274532,
-0.0189450663,
0.0419298597,
0.0176272076,
-0.0198414735,
-0.03406699,
0.0227974206,
-0.0425468013,
0.0327017419,
-0.0342604853,
0.0322104804,
0.0208510421,
-0.0173664223,
-0.0792777464,
-0.0156026985,
0.0193328578,
-0.0093091289,
0.0390336625,
0.00864184,
0.0072253323,
0.0054139434,
0.0021031022,
-0.0200518258,
-0.0067938105,
0.044830393,
-0.0485884584,
-0.0847712681,
0.032046508,
0.0171106141,
0.0199861266,
0.0170796849,
0.0350403003,
0.0752868727,
-0.0044445796,
-0.0330444947,
-0.0350016952,
0.0141879814,
-0.0151393069,
-0.0402182154,
-0.0540676564,
-0.0589775071,
-0.0068538012,
0.0027816598,
0.0129211703,
0.026077766,
0.0081669437,
-0.0300267637,
0.0186063051,
0.0702485293,
0.020333875,
0.0232009422,
0.0926268771,
-0.0100693805,
0.0518516079,
0.0005437302,
0.0732899606,
-0.0298784487,
0.0105425557,
-0.0491045862,
0.0099437181,
0.0280048363,
-0.0487046577,
-0.0712535381,
-0.0322078653,
-0.004544965,
-0.0025782802,
0.0139977811,
-0.0025724731,
0.0391252786,
0.0047611985,
0.0298838727,
0.0369773582,
0.0872190446,
0.0343721882,
0.0072404132,
0.0179484431,
0.0135211032,
-0.0081104646,
-0.0750290379,
0.0221121851,
0.0040459279,
-0.0084137963,
-0.0057592462,
0.0180434473,
0.0504306145,
-0.0188551415,
-0.0203714781,
0.0067028068,
-0.0494497977,
0.0007018973,
-0.0218280926,
0.0661777407,
-0.0334798023,
-0.0384019576,
0.0054178983,
-0.0037667744,
0.0128678568,
-0.019763872,
-0.0411362797,
0.038190823,
0.0259115379,
0.0025644049,
-0.0219119042,
0.0164595339,
-0.0278179944,
-0.0060415608,
-0.0233038496,
0.0402536653,
-0.0060205893,
0.0063051707,
-0.0702335164,
-0.0003972254,
0.1206737012,
-0.0049423249,
0.0504447967,
-0.0298750699,
0.0452600494,
0.0415078402,
0.0075854468,
0.0336741917,
-0.0152801182,
0.0536085069,
-0.0278949365,
0.0072753956,
0.0383233838,
0.090272896,
0.0417360403,
0.0084570125,
0.0053315093,
0.0164539851,
0.0024814932,
0.0527211279,
0.0385489799,
0.0048257541,
-0.0194120593,
0.0498343371,
-0.0010110479,
0.0094202226,
0.0375132449,
0.0155109512,
-0.0932243913,
0.0438775308,
-0.0474661477,
0.0353470594,
-0.0380817875,
0.0645243526,
-0.0181473494,
0.0358701646,
-0.0077791261,
0.0187487882,
0.005992197,
0.017965015,
-0.0264975093,
-0.0339691006,
0.0294351839,
-0.0483814664,
-0.0205334499,
0.0315798037,
-0.0458650328,
-0.0098139448,
-0.0347564891,
-0.0016270566,
-0.0252240282,
0.0051455358,
-0.0070370729,
-0.0414145328,
0.0212900229,
0.0255640801,
-0.0559430122,
-0.0074964748,
-0.0095355399,
-0.0628189519,
-0.0103489337,
0.0269904472,
0.020910304,
-0.0666811094,
-0.0094033834,
-0.0197456945,
-0.0801900625,
-0.014608915,
0.0048968298,
-0.0196913127,
-0.0005650726,
0.0232344251,
-0.1039176285,
0.0017951264,
-0.0536155403,
-0.01362128,
0.0251452383,
0.0404544771,
-0.0279666763,
-0.0125114564,
0.0068925684,
0.0323829725,
-0.0214622244,
-0.0092366347,
-0.0096212169,
0.0155834416,
-0.0134641472,
-0.0415242091,
-0.0035630839,
-0.0148720238,
0.0566967316,
-0.0103553934,
-0.0085037695,
-0.0586911887,
0.0055914647,
0.0716294646,
0.0347061902,
-0.0054171062,
-0.0045647467,
-0.0114179282,
-0.0113551058,
-0.0262775831,
0.0001206788,
-0.0371445939,
0.0228209309,
0.0150211938,
-0.0350716673,
0.0559946559,
-0.0553148799,
-0.0211372878,
-0.0496397056,
-0.0846486688,
0.0199207533,
0.0164168291,
-0.0664103627,
0.009387223,
-0.0203814376,
-0.0692098364,
0.034570016,
-0.0194901489,
0.0457882173,
-0.0506592095,
-0.0270622056,
-0.0166059323,
0.0121881654,
-0.0073877238,
0.0103554782,
-0.0066298014,
-0.0142113948,
-0.0607739761,
-0.0246785022,
-0.0461675972,
0.0072534154,
-0.0162399523,
0.0606890656,
-0.0457216166,
0.0435162634,
0.0039407914,
0.0141657144,
-0.0232046619,
0.0621223673,
0.0027069666,
0.0372234918,
-0.0222472344,
0.0452282913,
0.0583862811,
-0.0162725747,
0.066996567,
0.0086389612,
-0.0637386143,
0.023226561,
0.0218434911,
-0.0250059515,
-0.0024972083,
0.0330802873,
-0.009344182,
-0.0261685159,
-0.0004360346,
0.0778707936,
0.0067917439,
-0.0174107105,
0.0027487248,
0.0214761887,
-0.0625156611,
-0.0130897444,
0.0114531415,
-0.0043474045,
-0.0034158572,
0.0155088836,
0.0386473313,
-0.0299985837,
0.0250416622,
0.0048747933,
-0.0640286058,
0.0159513205,
0.0306712296,
0.0010012588,
-0.0871203691,
-0.0523097478,
-0.0361916907,
-0.0081791235,
-0.0102798035,
-0.0141360452,
0.0308142472,
-0.0308125392,
0.0397670045,
-0.0426740646,
-0.0443707481,
0.0518674143,
0.0397068076,
0.080059886,
0.0193068795,
0.018303303,
-0.0495012105,
-0.058071699,
0.013289799,
0.0178896971,
0.0105255675,
-0.0436018221,
-0.0366905555,
0.0133247981,
-0.0141683398,
-0.0148831652,
0.0194272622,
-0.0089804186,
0.0282754358,
0.0261080135,
0.0525384061,
-0.0545717105,
-0.0029626326,
-0.0036170476,
0.0351400413,
0.0309792664,
0.0220498182,
0.0056267641,
-0.0189203545,
0.0036093395,
0.0496131852,
0.0166958999,
0.010319679,
0.0077021071,
-0.0065876613,
-0.0286635272,
-0.0523803458,
-0.0489067771,
0.0053305621,
-0.0181461275,
0.0371804051,
0.0512662567,
0.0383385643,
-0.0045730979,
0.067602776,
-0.0618179776,
0.0044709644,
0.0692088231,
0.0420535915,
-0.0604618937,
0.0008887983,
0.0676447973,
-0.0036598979,
-0.0510410592,
-0.0648749843,
-0.0621472895,
-0.0379335396,
0.0254440475,
0.0188710447,
0.0244917348,
0.0204581097,
-0.0508005619,
-0.0254095849,
0.0339389071,
-0.0215618014,
-0.0160391536,
-0.0268405899,
0.0372865349,
0.0123321451,
-0.0246639792,
-0.0088508204,
-0.0170097705,
0.0464216322,
-0.015319841,
-0.0697357133,
-0.0513312668,
-0.0299782641,
-0.0172227472,
0.02457105,
0.086106874,
0.0019176004,
0.0047838856,
-0.0439396426,
0.0095842723,
0.0649380088,
0.0379837081,
0.0022299525,
-0.0138145834,
0.0190043077,
0.0313414373,
-0.0301847383,
-0.0528534912,
-0.0175783709,
-0.1162519678,
0.0484960824,
0.0830019563,
0.0616947152,
0.0631116852,
-0.0377140567,
-0.0137065463,
-0.0089784972,
0.0590823181,
0.0268246289,
-0.0133242272,
-0.0024149208,
-0.003333369,
-0.0251002889,
0.0042197392,
0.0000548399,
0.021635564,
0.013568541,
0.0294790249,
-0.0387852341,
0.0177971162,
0.0219147503,
-0.0034881122,
0.003340404,
-0.0158703402,
0.0283648111,
-0.0136797931,
0.0452582128,
-0.0402595773,
0.0216402337,
0.007596571,
-0.0032247277,
-0.0271708667,
0.0349746086,
0.0138462046,
-0.0231602713,
0.0076379767,
0.0451442003,
-0.0208461583,
-0.0597078539,
0.0220486503,
-0.0042555435,
0.0106094973,
-0.0325415917,
0.0237815082,
-0.0146979485,
-0.0300493017,
0.0287284181,
0.0222829022,
0.0164460465,
0.0132970791,
0.0096532144,
-0.0142650176,
-0.0024487695,
0.0389538407,
0.0009446756,
-0.0481131487,
-0.0081636384,
-0.0021377595,
-0.0080184825,
-5.727186638e-33,
-0.0138357561,
-0.0549897738,
-0.0185914896,
-0.0196570475,
-0.0260641407,
-0.0122499075,
-0.0028976037,
0.016714897,
-0.0230548084,
-0.040770594,
0.0091387583,
0.0332919061,
0.0335403048,
-0.0379646532,
0.0270475149,
0.0053203981,
0.0142343016,
0.0005477516,
0.0100658983,
-0.0129422843,
0.0425793231,
0.0446435474,
0.0630332977,
-0.0768485367,
-0.0213251989,
0.02459893,
-0.0633620843,
-0.0046940707,
0.0234478768,
0.0096804984,
-0.0168525893,
0.0424286798,
-0.0066311732,
-0.0102442922,
-0.0022418115,
0.0236086752,
-0.0719093233,
-0.0297634173,
-0.0071867062,
0.1004948094,
0.0727965981,
-0.0040920614,
0.0127389515,
0.0081697199,
-0.0721359923,
0.0463797823,
0.0418064445,
-0.0481201671,
-0.023156615,
-0.0337740369,
-0.0153285954,
0.0526009388,
-0.0450993255,
-0.0329381935,
0.0874015689,
0.0289469361,
-0.0299781393,
-0.0781709254,
-0.0016241552,
0.0603324883,
0.0299356729,
0.011979443,
0.035912782,
0.0127603514,
-0.010598368,
0.0118994499,
0.0744786263,
-0.0844380558,
0.0593650155,
0.0063042878,
0.0215747133,
0.0466348678,
0.0240978189,
0.0096578933,
0.048499871,
-0.0774470046,
-0.0262199994,
0.0105994297,
0.0903766155,
0.0048183808,
-0.0157305934,
-0.0244121235,
-0.0539067648,
0.0328473225,
0.0081274221,
-0.0143282851,
-0.0157276634,
-0.016603943,
0.0482173078,
-0.008784188,
-0.0145903667,
0.0030971915,
-0.0001318146,
0.002713867,
0.03944299,
-0.0267843828,
0.0534980185,
-0.0128327999,
-0.0097781671,
-0.0058603222,
-0.0142140426,
-0.063399367,
-0.0011875303,
0.0238924716,
0.0636124536,
-0.032217335,
-0.0353003703,
0.03803844,
-0.0562529378,
-0.000472444,
0.0480332151,
-0.0350922011,
0.0006710407,
0.0267351829,
0.0409095362,
-0.0363852009,
0.0000059965,
-0.0065148058,
0.0143904518,
0.0069918102,
0.0241279304,
0.0079970174,
-0.0019181747,
0.0438811816,
-0.044998277,
-0.0038066038,
-0.0343864895,
-0.0109648071,
0.0024384668,
0.0238075946,
0.0003084323,
0.0154309738,
2.581e-7,
-0.0110464115,
0.0692689642,
0.01551772,
-0.0210640505,
-0.0162025727,
-0.0152198952,
-0.0391500592,
0.0096354913,
-0.0465239212,
0.0428445861,
0.0706775412,
-0.0611684173,
0.0671930239,
0.0114276195,
-0.0655234307,
-0.0316154473,
-0.0581624508,
0.0139660425,
-0.0670101345,
0.0684883669,
0.0065306639,
0.0879681632,
0.0200477149,
-0.0080820005,
-0.0263917148,
-0.0379718319,
-0.0363517068,
-0.0056840964,
0.044842571,
-0.0169236902,
0.0801729113,
0.0005637993,
-0.0016925471,
0.0150178019,
-0.0254825279,
0.0642963871,
0.0297796763,
0.0453826264,
-0.0441766456,
-0.0332259573,
0.0036713351,
0.041356761,
-0.0316664763,
0.0241582375,
0.0357221924,
0.0308339633,
-0.022606492,
-0.017937921,
-0.0019508315,
-0.0136397835,
0.0374692231,
0.0079990756,
-0.0023887164,
-0.0141454907,
0.007602857,
-0.0379137546,
-0.0172232948,
-0.0579326972,
0.011787083,
0.0280528236,
-0.049806755,
-0.0334981941,
0.0303101782,
0.0058158096,
0.0683682561,
0.0029581948,
-0.0134977521,
1.700439937e-34,
-0.0073752156,
-0.0516257212,
-0.0354000255,
0.045112025,
-0.0297127571,
-0.0260915533,
0.0321649946,
0.0076633678,
0.0301254261,
-0.0464187786,
-0.036957223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00798v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00798v3 | Formal-LLM: Integrating Formal Language and Natural Language for Controllable LLM-based Agents | 2024-02-01T17:30:50 | 2024-06-18T05:44:03 | Zelong Li, Wenyue Hua, Hao Wang, He Zhu, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL | Recent advancements on Large Language Models (LLMs) enable AI Agents to
automatically generate and execute multi-step plans to solve complex tasks.
However, since LLM's content generation process is hardly controllable, current
LLM-based agents frequently generate invalid or non-executable plans, which
jeopardizes the performance of the generated plans and corrupts users' trust in
LLM-based agents. In response, this paper proposes a novel ``Formal-LLM''
framework for LLM-based agents by integrating the expressiveness of natural
language and the precision of formal language. Specifically, the framework
allows human users to express their requirements or constraints for the
planning process as an automaton. A stack-based LLM plan generation process is
then conducted under the supervision of the automaton to ensure that the
generated plan satisfies the constraints, making the planning process
controllable. We conduct experiments on both benchmark tasks and practical
real-life tasks, and our framework achieves over 50% overall performance
increase, which validates the feasibility and effectiveness of employing
Formal-LLM to guide the plan generation of agents, preventing the agents from
generating invalid and unsuccessful plans. Further, more controllable LLM-based
agents can facilitate the broader utilization of LLM in application scenarios
where high validity of planning is essential. The work is open-sourced at
https://github.com/agiresearch/Formal-LLM. | Formal-LLM: Integrating Formal Language and Natural Language for Controllable LLM-based Agents: Recent advancements on Large Language Models (LLMs) enable AI Agents to
automatically generate and execute multi-step plans to solve complex tasks.
However, since LLM's content generation process is hardly controllable, current
LLM-based agents frequently generate invalid or non-executable plans, which
jeopardizes the performance of the generated plans and corrupts users' trust in
LLM-based agents. In response, this paper proposes a novel ``Formal-LLM''
framework for LLM-based agents by integrating the expressiveness of natural
language and the precision of formal language. Specifically, the framework
allows human users to express their requirements or constraints for the
planning process as an automaton. A stack-based LLM plan generation process is
then conducted under the supervision of the automaton to ensure that the
generated plan satisfies the constraints, making the planning process
controllable. We conduct experiments on both benchmark tasks and practical
real-life tasks, and our framework achieves over 50% overall performance
increase, which validates the feasibility and effectiveness of employing
Formal-LLM to guide the plan generation of agents, preventing the agents from
generating invalid and unsuccessful plans. Further, more controllable LLM-based
agents can facilitate the broader utilization of LLM in application scenarios
where high validity of planning is essential. The work is open-sourced at
https://github.com/agiresearch/Formal-LLM. | [
0.0474032871,
0.0528956242,
-0.0150533384,
0.0394999832,
-0.0472952947,
-0.041244451,
-0.0330485851,
-0.0229622703,
0.0359468162,
-0.0576245524,
0.0205887984,
0.0179895833,
-0.0262813214,
0.0927781612,
0.0071417741,
-0.0583621152,
0.0235982202,
-0.043422278,
0.0425542444,
0.0188060831,
0.00932144,
0.0002796726,
-0.0009194267,
0.0264816992,
-0.0040817847,
0.0179918874,
-0.0589638092,
-0.0045711542,
-0.005759235,
-0.044848904,
-0.0194541812,
0.0334684514,
0.0135181956,
-0.0001064375,
0.0000022804,
-0.0859565139,
-0.0030951358,
-0.0004147994,
-0.0436424576,
0.0036287727,
-0.0079525104,
-0.0031720053,
-0.0224601571,
0.0192940645,
-0.0520505905,
0.0533644557,
0.010943722,
0.0524691306,
0.0871664807,
0.0637280494,
-0.0118827708,
0.0028122715,
0.0248898473,
0.0192412622,
-0.0035436305,
-0.0624913611,
0.0145374881,
0.0093486821,
0.0675649941,
0.0338470899,
0.0161327869,
0.0005896412,
0.0132563272,
-0.0265124422,
-0.0373418778,
-0.0016090001,
-0.008939283,
-0.0554972664,
-0.0510808527,
0.0653714463,
0.0079902709,
-0.0154922102,
0.0677115768,
-0.0281560943,
0.0000392444,
0.0086628012,
-0.0406314954,
0.0510253049,
-0.0141964322,
0.0043596691,
-0.0216677971,
-0.0150835514,
0.029724801,
0.0189394094,
-0.0057411799,
0.0968084261,
-0.0009912959,
-0.0208182503,
0.0092095137,
-0.0261463393,
0.0336901955,
-0.104511179,
0.0453379117,
0.0820105374,
-0.0714239702,
0.0331644863,
-0.0379188061,
-0.0047734235,
0.0378294252,
-0.0421749726,
0.0243647527,
0.0430972241,
0.0148878284,
0.0229796544,
-0.0059357365,
0.0738093331,
-0.022041209,
0.0099853892,
-0.0278913993,
0.0090078674,
-0.0389320031,
-0.0082842978,
-0.0427163877,
0.0334420651,
-0.0442297086,
-0.0124652963,
-0.0360082313,
0.0613085888,
-0.048799593,
0.075871408,
-8.619e-7,
-0.0048379707,
-0.0178540573,
-0.0183530543,
-0.0826621428,
-0.0562499762,
-0.0554489605,
0.0033317218,
-0.0005320451,
-0.0168304704,
0.0303440113,
0.031612169,
0.0069089904,
0.0423924662,
-0.0102298912,
0.0838810205,
0.0041366084,
0.0116016865,
-0.0364453942,
-0.0706503913,
0.0161315445,
-0.0557629429,
-0.0103209354,
-0.0775860995,
0.0161820222,
-0.0075976332,
-0.0514757596,
-0.0301330723,
0.0264858734,
0.0371647701,
-0.0054719723,
0.0576871894,
-0.034860909,
0.0063104313,
0.0082590021,
0.016034184,
-0.0207649302,
0.0299729798,
0.0682027414,
0.0607247613,
0.0246324912,
0.0508335158,
0.0388557091,
0.0628992692,
-0.028830247,
-0.0196818002,
-0.0043244474,
0.0129324943,
-0.0202517938,
0.0316821374,
-0.0270135552,
0.0708905533,
0.0056041726,
0.0153147969,
0.0202354416,
0.0470583923,
0.0023368106,
-0.0031287253,
0.0675110891,
0.0590145178,
-0.0018959857,
-0.033875972,
-0.0386945568,
0.0260584112,
-0.0578204282,
0.0026917574,
-0.0265542194,
-0.0024722717,
0.0041047325,
-0.069977358,
-0.0168591365,
-0.0221014433,
0.0486336686,
0.0051231449,
0.0294381361,
0.0160200074,
-0.0593681447,
-0.0016134994,
-0.0230223387,
-0.0327739827,
-0.0210642684,
-0.0535478145,
0.0438045785,
0.0818950087,
0.0320357941,
-0.0310671497,
-0.0369795561,
0.0033151705,
-0.0306823868,
0.0532432087,
0.0252400767,
-0.0191351417,
-0.02896709,
-0.0265191998,
-0.0274728555,
-0.005450312,
-0.0010148663,
0.0089304978,
0.0220878609,
-0.0073213424,
-0.0003906665,
0.0130543085,
-0.025771698,
0.0486225709,
-0.0065586567,
-0.0300757177,
-0.0163162723,
-0.0195105579,
0.0508228391,
0.0172820296,
0.0105042243,
0.0295756105,
0.052768331,
-0.0027825418,
-0.0684365556,
-0.0128500545,
-0.0327776708,
0.0389231145,
0.0469004102,
-0.0131363235,
-0.0221892111,
-0.0067063188,
-0.024876805,
-0.0523046516,
0.0079032909,
-0.0220664497,
-0.0015333683,
-0.012871244,
0.0062720524,
0.036093168,
-0.0434988812,
-0.0289785489,
0.0532571077,
0.0173828807,
-0.0656683445,
0.0316427648,
0.0116462726,
0.0117004663,
-0.0143767521,
-0.0146453781,
0.0220801011,
0.0296121817,
0.0157572385,
0.0526379123,
0.0529492535,
-0.020355558,
-0.0233945251,
-0.0488482639,
0.0180366244,
-0.0190322511,
0.0008724054,
-0.0130798286,
-0.0119962711,
-0.0134419482,
-0.0078671873,
-0.0262062121,
0.0299548637,
0.0294359941,
-0.0240954757,
0.0390078351,
0.0317164548,
-0.0676649362,
-0.0499877073,
0.0159070473,
-0.0262127109,
-0.0384266563,
0.0379512943,
-0.0399464555,
-0.0609317161,
0.0471950024,
-0.0203405228,
0.025232017,
-0.0230475068,
-0.0046840822,
0.0269332528,
-0.0307279807,
-0.021093037,
0.0105579402,
-0.0275991783,
0.020305369,
0.0687293038,
-0.0267862324,
-0.061828766,
0.0252032541,
-0.0041913358,
-0.0071670003,
-0.0225259233,
-0.0209313463,
0.0442892462,
0.0405426957,
0.0002778583,
0.0345447585,
-0.0272730161,
-0.0087062493,
0.0204372462,
-0.0018223242,
0.0085045937,
-0.0695522502,
-0.039676901,
0.0865750611,
0.012431371,
-0.0435816832,
0.0576764233,
-0.0304150209,
-0.006034317,
0.016156394,
-0.022055937,
-0.0459798388,
0.0777660087,
0.0169448592,
0.0084905652,
0.0152890859,
0.0202652942,
-0.0099639157,
-0.0427672975,
0.0091851745,
-0.0076773744,
0.0479821488,
-0.0880831778,
0.0205032155,
0.0099512711,
-0.0296195466,
-0.0528069623,
-0.0133591285,
-0.0502665751,
0.0332950652,
-0.0080029005,
-0.0340445749,
-0.0136068482,
-0.040338546,
0.0196733233,
0.0435057692,
0.0156119606,
-0.0187624022,
-0.0432582758,
-0.0529804714,
0.0274071861,
0.0368448719,
-0.0144200819,
0.024045499,
0.0275977477,
0.0422418043,
0.0155149503,
0.0144637488,
-0.0461576618,
0.0048905881,
0.0135572106,
-0.0209902581,
-0.0069612274,
0.0739623159,
0.0324248634,
-0.0469741859,
-0.0109884189,
0.1016148925,
0.0382020287,
0.0151456436,
0.0229205992,
-0.0440562032,
0.005056798,
0.0317440815,
0.0602684692,
-0.0629085377,
-0.0149895567,
0.0090481304,
0.0024645629,
-0.010884027,
-0.0276212078,
-0.0331296884,
-0.1045869887,
0.0299153086,
-0.0072728582,
-0.0018559493,
0.0284299254,
-0.0496869646,
-0.0190779567,
0.0223254003,
0.0022657772,
-0.0024624942,
0.0263296962,
-0.034566544,
-0.0030195634,
-0.0523593239,
-0.0004919358,
0.0173071809,
-0.0326300152,
0.0541004315,
0.0806120634,
0.0410315432,
-0.005325404,
-0.0251460504,
0.0467010513,
0.0704885647,
0.0336722247,
-0.0281598419,
-0.0291592982,
0.0069519505,
0.0073901089,
-0.0254960135,
0.0481497273,
-0.061394155,
-0.0561817177,
0.041556716,
0.1018645242,
-0.017682977,
-0.0164044481,
-0.0547500364,
0.0035361233,
0.0318242125,
0.052439373,
-0.0225584712,
-0.0182394963,
-0.0672691688,
-0.0593664981,
-0.0440437496,
-0.0384884365,
-0.0321036503,
0.0057768673,
-0.0127705811,
0.0279199257,
-0.0709479302,
-0.0424088575,
0.0487266146,
0.0112716779,
0.0319768861,
-0.0365895927,
0.0698035359,
-0.0093651433,
0.0012235175,
-0.0010356751,
-0.0280243792,
0.0394962206,
-0.0309302602,
-0.0183591172,
0.0018124573,
-0.0186818652,
0.0016244077,
0.0309021361,
-0.0312069673,
-0.0608123578,
-0.0102684284,
0.0702680647,
0.0237868614,
-0.021552721,
0.0058059492,
-0.0388233662,
0.0167711619,
0.0115081752,
-0.0493487567,
0.0004907188,
0.0236942507,
0.050165277,
0.0178941432,
0.0314275883,
-0.0744573399,
0.0150169926,
-0.0238452554,
0.0585674122,
-0.0445885211,
-0.0251528304,
0.0261791218,
0.0548810139,
-0.0271303132,
-0.0279617365,
0.0008663871,
-0.0044053136,
-0.0114206048,
-0.0545552447,
-0.0441641361,
-0.0527182072,
0.0353603475,
-0.0393249057,
-0.0306178983,
0.0497696288,
-0.0304585863,
-0.0446162969,
-0.0195573922,
0.0256423429,
0.0137663335,
0.0073303017,
0.0188524295,
0.028496407,
-0.0088340882,
0.0055895215,
0.0573087521,
-0.01225382,
0.0307649691,
0.0216938965,
0.0267408472,
0.017097069,
0.0143137695,
-0.0639582276,
-0.02128876,
-0.0022030454,
-0.0761899427,
0.0470543243,
0.0525826216,
0.0427510515,
0.0318241715,
0.0178516004,
-0.092553243,
0.0298183821,
-0.0000384937,
-0.0103491936,
0.0104686441,
-0.0605541766,
0.0421437174,
0.0236132294,
-0.0132448506,
-0.0194305219,
0.0431214795,
0.0158001054,
0.0243957937,
-0.0196012314,
-0.0210904926,
-0.0793627203,
-0.0335418805,
-0.0066489219,
0.0197968911,
-0.0347004086,
-0.0319102854,
-0.0618458651,
-0.0466104224,
0.0197166558,
0.043304503,
0.0119176842,
-0.0335740484,
0.0386703201,
0.0032113616,
0.0228120778,
-0.0219191127,
-0.0298452806,
-0.017571291,
0.0159404222,
-0.0162315909,
-0.0276612099,
-5.939647691e-33,
-0.0201413874,
-0.0844367743,
0.062442176,
0.0147159379,
0.0287908334,
-0.0294381846,
-0.0540098511,
0.0248475466,
0.051662337,
0.0216514468,
-0.0215656478,
-0.0076427823,
0.0165653061,
-0.0084566223,
0.0171736013,
-0.0044761323,
0.0208195839,
-0.0188627802,
-0.0270702466,
-0.0319397897,
0.0329747684,
-0.0264745001,
-0.0050801379,
-0.0655183345,
0.0515365489,
0.0035877645,
-0.0349071734,
0.031255912,
-0.0176767409,
0.0459386185,
-0.0161594134,
0.0173579454,
0.0011213931,
0.0047125937,
-0.0503021702,
0.0638660491,
-0.0097409207,
-0.0577737689,
0.0271449201,
-0.0003215171,
-0.0537414961,
-0.0162614044,
0.0564743131,
-0.0143409483,
-0.0626474693,
0.0697557032,
0.0122273033,
0.0090324413,
0.0092838332,
-0.005737552,
-0.0851978883,
0.0188052654,
-0.0105856974,
-0.0117802406,
0.0133495387,
-0.0216759779,
-0.0076070107,
-0.0256373622,
-0.0136689311,
0.0004711903,
-0.0089703184,
-0.0326936953,
0.0728241503,
-0.0234265719,
-0.0042646076,
0.0573926717,
-0.0040417728,
0.0199377462,
-0.032791663,
-0.0062934691,
-0.0151715493,
0.0801603943,
0.008340654,
0.0372858606,
0.0059817065,
0.0203473158,
-0.0359429605,
0.0425410271,
-0.0116166221,
0.0772829279,
0.0409209244,
0.0307654161,
-0.0367281325,
-0.0029968524,
-0.0350176468,
0.0424265116,
-0.0200878289,
0.0055322354,
0.0333708227,
0.0209302027,
0.0172685571,
-0.0151375085,
-0.0116634723,
-0.0231828876,
-0.0043829354,
-0.0004732735,
-0.0231717285,
0.011157915,
-0.0159291942,
0.0307750963,
-0.034339793,
-0.0195585936,
-0.0136042507,
-0.0308600515,
0.034552101,
0.0438282415,
-0.0389737561,
0.0386867486,
-0.0406346545,
0.0104638701,
-0.0448610559,
-0.0056072292,
0.0079715792,
-0.0237577558,
0.0370947868,
-0.0192999169,
-0.0207556803,
0.0261241551,
-0.0236586612,
-0.0839930177,
-0.0200150944,
0.0324476026,
0.0226653386,
-0.0014098426,
-0.0340879709,
-0.0225388445,
-0.0386161879,
0.0038935877,
0.0373083279,
-0.0337496437,
0.0145846279,
0.0243445989,
2.997e-7,
-0.0177825,
0.0659464449,
0.0142020313,
0.068736583,
0.0109229973,
0.0421364382,
0.0032430105,
0.0080163404,
-0.0566982068,
-0.0298896413,
0.0231610686,
0.0240711421,
0.0130055984,
0.0458698794,
-0.0580748133,
0.0219910946,
0.002031758,
-0.0112986648,
-0.0829241499,
0.0202144999,
0.0770389736,
0.0290160459,
0.0339888036,
0.0141473301,
-0.0089769941,
-0.0492360443,
0.0202888492,
-0.0382241122,
0.0140932929,
0.0352802649,
0.01496334,
0.0225286018,
-0.0033832619,
0.025803756,
0.0215337928,
0.0111794444,
-0.030903751,
0.1110531613,
0.0011551821,
-0.0106104389,
-0.0149638411,
-0.0693098754,
0.0128785428,
-0.006793146,
0.0118632428,
-0.0101718595,
-0.0230677947,
-0.0214698166,
0.0186875202,
-0.0287701394,
-0.0445351936,
-0.0084666843,
0.0250598881,
0.0094839409,
-0.0081098909,
-0.0097824261,
-0.0048747286,
-0.0586624257,
0.005123077,
-0.0114414515,
-0.0436971895,
-0.0015203473,
-0.0511527024,
0.0322078839,
-0.0070594028,
-0.0173599031,
0.0146402931,
2.883219713e-34,
-0.0195969697,
-0.0049675568,
-0.0069216914,
0.0364696942,
0.0499895923,
0.0584216379,
-0.0387676768,
0.0563222803,
0.0503911376,
-0.0612153336,
-0.0445186198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00794v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00794v2 | ReAGent: A Model-agnostic Feature Attribution Method for Generative Language Models | 2024-02-01T17:25:51 | 2024-02-07T21:01:16 | Zhixue Zhao, Boxuan Shan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Feature attribution methods (FAs), such as gradients and attention, are
widely employed approaches to derive the importance of all input features to
the model predictions. Existing work in natural language processing has mostly
focused on developing and testing FAs for encoder-only language models (LMs) in
classification tasks. However, it is unknown if it is faithful to use these FAs
for decoder-only models on text generation, due to the inherent differences
between model architectures and task settings respectively. Moreover, previous
work has demonstrated that there is no `one-wins-all' FA across models and
tasks. This makes the selection of a FA computationally expensive for large LMs
since input importance derivation often requires multiple forward and backward
passes including gradient computations that might be prohibitive even with
access to large compute. To address these issues, we present a model-agnostic
FA for generative LMs called Recursive Attribution Generator (ReAGent). Our
method updates the token importance distribution in a recursive manner. For
each update, we compute the difference in the probability distribution over the
vocabulary for predicting the next token between using the original input and
using a modified version where a part of the input is replaced with RoBERTa
predictions. Our intuition is that replacing an important token in the context
should have resulted in a larger change in the model's confidence in predicting
the token than replacing an unimportant token. Our method can be universally
applied to any generative LM without accessing internal model weights or
additional training and fine-tuning, as most other FAs require. We extensively
compare the faithfulness of ReAGent with seven popular FAs across six
decoder-only LMs of various sizes. The results show that our method
consistently provides more faithful token importance distributions. | ReAGent: A Model-agnostic Feature Attribution Method for Generative Language Models: Feature attribution methods (FAs), such as gradients and attention, are
widely employed approaches to derive the importance of all input features to
the model predictions. Existing work in natural language processing has mostly
focused on developing and testing FAs for encoder-only language models (LMs) in
classification tasks. However, it is unknown if it is faithful to use these FAs
for decoder-only models on text generation, due to the inherent differences
between model architectures and task settings respectively. Moreover, previous
work has demonstrated that there is no `one-wins-all' FA across models and
tasks. This makes the selection of a FA computationally expensive for large LMs
since input importance derivation often requires multiple forward and backward
passes including gradient computations that might be prohibitive even with
access to large compute. To address these issues, we present a model-agnostic
FA for generative LMs called Recursive Attribution Generator (ReAGent). Our
method updates the token importance distribution in a recursive manner. For
each update, we compute the difference in the probability distribution over the
vocabulary for predicting the next token between using the original input and
using a modified version where a part of the input is replaced with RoBERTa
predictions. Our intuition is that replacing an important token in the context
should have resulted in a larger change in the model's confidence in predicting
the token than replacing an unimportant token. Our method can be universally
applied to any generative LM without accessing internal model weights or
additional training and fine-tuning, as most other FAs require. We extensively
compare the faithfulness of ReAGent with seven popular FAs across six
decoder-only LMs of various sizes. The results show that our method
consistently provides more faithful token importance distributions. | [
0.0355987102,
0.0746422485,
-0.0076412479,
0.0122499121,
-0.0303927865,
0.0131142531,
0.0229891986,
-0.0425209291,
-0.0423683077,
-0.0325537175,
0.020249486,
-0.0407331027,
0.039822232,
0.0501931459,
0.0445228219,
-0.0260246806,
-0.0134521518,
0.0015983375,
0.0277100019,
0.0066157696,
-0.0192893576,
-0.0032756261,
0.0272257943,
0.0686363503,
-0.0122032985,
0.0063992571,
0.0103917206,
0.0207040887,
0.0444944315,
-0.0024656595,
0.0197364073,
0.0417955369,
0.0088053532,
0.0133411195,
0.0000021023,
-0.0194991063,
-0.0078982161,
-0.00618889,
0.012189066,
-0.0009371386,
0.0423010327,
-0.0170770548,
-0.0108871674,
0.0267253947,
-0.028029684,
-0.0186978783,
0.069889687,
0.0198807586,
0.0062705614,
0.0590034574,
-0.0035540739,
-0.0233939309,
0.0236356668,
-0.0466150977,
0.0429447405,
-0.016958138,
0.000579424,
-0.0374683961,
-0.0692246929,
-0.0047349487,
-0.0450864024,
0.0560527854,
0.0443723537,
-0.0224141255,
0.0622674078,
0.0505462028,
0.0117056407,
0.0064809453,
-0.0143007888,
0.0620327741,
-0.0537922457,
-0.0369474292,
-0.0088964421,
-0.0064920303,
-0.0125230355,
-0.0045497539,
-0.0351440087,
0.0243771523,
0.0099608023,
0.0210435484,
0.047420729,
-0.0149399182,
0.0345610119,
0.0110763796,
0.0046185493,
0.0253942292,
0.036816597,
0.0122543117,
-0.0467310213,
0.0290549826,
-0.0536706522,
-0.084193334,
-0.002316704,
0.0175612066,
0.0202280283,
0.0164807513,
-0.0554435365,
-0.0307004414,
-0.0037044752,
-0.011689336,
0.0397376716,
0.0438116528,
-0.0014143074,
-0.0089345844,
-0.0580334216,
0.069041416,
0.0257819816,
0.0053090514,
-0.0263384115,
0.005613266,
-0.0268322527,
-0.0244022012,
-0.0238382686,
0.0225045923,
-0.0144894551,
-0.0246680379,
-0.0482753851,
0.0041534728,
-0.015799161,
-0.0592969358,
0.0425460897,
0.0666333511,
-0.0660280213,
0.0017058555,
0.0031269698,
0.0353724882,
-0.0328797176,
0.0306192134,
0.0292226411,
-0.0668988749,
-0.046157144,
0.0362047032,
0.0266194306,
-0.0181647763,
0.0009313017,
0.0638056621,
-0.0199002828,
-0.0397553854,
-0.0230845418,
-0.0381464548,
-0.0232957415,
-0.0565474108,
-0.0128076393,
-0.0560109392,
-0.0066941446,
0.0027433892,
-0.011700836,
-0.0673406422,
-0.0062051252,
0.0133262761,
0.0013271556,
0.0437472798,
0.0578942485,
0.0138531197,
0.0521808453,
-0.0230332483,
0.0111262444,
0.018980762,
0.0536124445,
0.0894848257,
-0.0182203148,
0.0191732775,
0.0166938975,
0.0106837079,
0.0119434642,
0.0057731252,
-0.026252402,
-0.0387934633,
-0.0113829151,
-0.0015995544,
0.0846037716,
0.0205623396,
-0.037829265,
0.0000777879,
0.0829823017,
0.002892989,
0.0111184008,
0.0422513895,
0.0796874762,
-0.0122883292,
-0.0268651713,
-0.0073507624,
-0.0390999056,
0.0714503005,
0.002882215,
-0.0029302198,
0.0419543125,
0.017995704,
-0.0177754778,
-0.0454396755,
0.0342717692,
-0.0079117026,
0.0000562538,
0.0048747482,
0.0464223586,
0.0446577594,
-0.0731709301,
0.0242699571,
-0.0079260264,
-0.0647664666,
0.0434574783,
-0.0585998707,
0.0030660927,
0.0905198529,
0.0606430322,
0.0173017029,
-0.0054446445,
0.0043916358,
0.0103928782,
0.0240615215,
0.0070743025,
0.0000469156,
0.0065823724,
-0.0523732975,
-0.0364834554,
-0.0242699124,
0.0354283564,
0.0707539171,
-0.0054080714,
0.0161490776,
0.0520997755,
-0.0447233394,
-0.0277410895,
0.0172530003,
-0.0038348327,
-0.0611087941,
0.0474663675,
-0.0189727731,
0.020212207,
-0.0160326511,
-0.0051068962,
0.0327467322,
0.0022304109,
-0.0498566777,
0.0007812452,
0.0228482988,
-0.0633809566,
-0.0700101703,
-0.0044245091,
-0.0388796665,
0.0474018678,
0.0388377234,
-0.04268815,
-0.0570068434,
0.0866888538,
-0.0663445741,
0.0370664969,
-0.0450392067,
0.0356671214,
0.0146753779,
0.0331908576,
-0.0085584894,
0.0540885516,
-0.0386261716,
-0.0048006801,
0.0179633852,
0.0118088918,
-0.0143811386,
-0.037320137,
0.0072466414,
-0.0367084555,
-0.0091817556,
0.0013332529,
0.0168936793,
0.0082826549,
0.0157536678,
-0.0345257372,
-0.0646267906,
0.00006586,
-0.0454985015,
0.0431862622,
0.0228332579,
0.0345363207,
0.0208288338,
-0.0201530922,
-0.0414324701,
-0.0214369968,
-0.0121891862,
-0.0032225868,
-0.0019847329,
-0.0196963921,
-0.0018925559,
-0.0237199925,
-0.0154070882,
0.0206652638,
0.0521208458,
0.0118153123,
0.0115529383,
-0.0495206825,
0.0048159207,
-0.0235992447,
-0.0170424655,
-0.0049802796,
-0.0487199239,
-0.0019534661,
0.0253288615,
0.0705651641,
0.0468897261,
0.0164160039,
0.0488290302,
0.0214308463,
0.0025660782,
-0.0539637804,
-0.0055286135,
-0.040863093,
0.0057122135,
-0.0140360063,
-0.0727354512,
-0.0047393129,
0.0796301439,
0.0225973316,
-0.0204911064,
-0.0722846016,
0.0369423479,
0.006539735,
-0.0570424758,
-0.0057609612,
-0.00931066,
-0.0298346356,
-0.0162005872,
-0.0411640145,
-0.0947657377,
0.0573552772,
-0.0548547395,
0.0192500744,
-0.0274550822,
0.0246710069,
-0.0468386821,
0.0310458187,
0.0222934056,
0.0081598861,
0.0139160445,
-0.0368302427,
-0.0163631644,
0.0461715721,
0.0373050794,
-0.0421668179,
0.0316938087,
-0.0600506552,
0.0051111295,
0.027557699,
0.0081851734,
-0.0369163528,
-0.006621304,
0.0081442054,
0.0306661632,
0.0068574366,
-0.0256986097,
-0.0150213884,
-0.0208370797,
0.0271959137,
0.0425435603,
-0.0150689585,
0.0144776003,
0.0001373695,
0.0273789167,
0.0519681536,
-0.0004483456,
0.00815445,
-0.032354027,
-0.0327442884,
0.0237418897,
0.027497815,
0.0131914616,
-0.0186692867,
0.022179639,
0.0072201053,
-0.0130376453,
-0.0125997784,
0.0368943214,
0.0647543967,
-0.0657229125,
-0.0392719172,
0.0976773575,
0.0142070772,
-0.0679814219,
0.0269843824,
0.0200534929,
0.0713378042,
0.020154221,
-0.0007185964,
-0.0377949141,
-0.0559367053,
0.0137244351,
0.0377986431,
-0.0232534036,
-0.025064161,
-0.0182919931,
-0.0982820243,
0.0414380468,
0.002877498,
-0.0606180914,
-0.0331351459,
-0.0353486314,
-0.0229146443,
-0.0131781111,
-0.022262292,
0.0063848901,
-0.0041211382,
0.0348337255,
0.0228894372,
-0.0155218225,
-0.0563369431,
-0.0126777636,
-0.0132633317,
0.0253507011,
0.1148013696,
0.0024408305,
0.0105651505,
-0.0100814942,
0.0060700015,
-0.0126370406,
0.0227986164,
-0.0184988696,
0.0452267379,
-0.030058587,
0.0128389783,
-0.0255828854,
0.0400779098,
-0.0448177643,
0.0005953205,
0.00668948,
0.0433927476,
0.0104480386,
-0.0470662564,
-0.0150973201,
-0.0405576304,
0.0493932739,
0.066648975,
0.0648655146,
-0.0314984731,
-0.0719854906,
-0.0549795702,
0.0228417739,
-0.0507094823,
-0.0078495918,
-0.0175756905,
0.0271998625,
-0.0842707753,
-0.1062628031,
-0.0236478895,
0.0165461935,
-0.0042746007,
-0.0062671234,
-0.0073580309,
-0.0348104723,
-0.0496162884,
-0.0559023656,
0.0067489715,
-0.0171153378,
0.0074086478,
-0.0311341956,
-0.0198683813,
0.0204459783,
-0.0578922667,
-0.015631482,
0.0040675895,
-0.086450316,
-0.0390789174,
-0.0117254686,
0.064380765,
0.0159154292,
0.0580175035,
0.0015898905,
-0.0686702877,
0.0958569348,
0.0077722091,
-0.0201862976,
0.0387800783,
0.0099110575,
-0.037763305,
-0.0122308489,
0.0349482447,
-0.0313099176,
0.0179181136,
0.0415242426,
0.0685980767,
0.032176584,
-0.0255064964,
0.0051333401,
-0.022996271,
0.0137049407,
-0.0365769155,
-0.0279132742,
-0.0315391906,
0.018804336,
0.0125656426,
0.0020511206,
-0.0640994534,
0.0274652354,
0.0298790354,
0.0444527902,
-0.0199401379,
-0.0066847997,
-0.0056976387,
0.022540316,
0.0027568466,
0.0130680129,
-0.0330728926,
0.0192899685,
0.0158686116,
0.0060992027,
0.0003070391,
-0.0073864814,
-0.0058328616,
0.0305670016,
-0.0113812052,
-0.0009749146,
0.007025654,
0.0105206575,
-0.028266158,
0.0106845833,
-0.0688038915,
0.0131331291,
-0.0938982889,
0.0095109008,
0.0322987288,
0.0212322492,
0.0927238241,
-0.0196806267,
0.0175384786,
-0.0337077342,
0.0416883677,
0.0079369796,
-0.0288912486,
-0.000956178,
0.0017933625,
-0.0175576136,
0.0000241788,
0.1029496565,
0.0529285483,
0.0325837359,
-0.0470264107,
-0.0163230915,
-0.0118107796,
-0.0397836417,
-0.004278305,
0.0062534683,
-0.0033595674,
0.0217243228,
-0.0255417563,
-0.0775059685,
0.009835396,
-0.0321715474,
0.0177996662,
-0.021439435,
0.0427976474,
0.0278696958,
-0.0434076488,
-0.0164094549,
-0.0651137233,
-0.0082738977,
-0.0279074199,
-0.0292867869,
-0.016380569,
-6.584300181e-33,
-0.0056484104,
-0.0299145896,
0.0016110325,
-0.014448707,
-0.0246490054,
0.0060731377,
-0.0756403804,
-0.0287815221,
0.033807192,
0.0343535915,
0.0068870354,
0.0079881996,
0.0108865956,
0.0515771396,
0.0145605085,
-0.0027698937,
0.0660705417,
0.0253008623,
-0.0451381132,
0.0639909878,
0.029492354,
0.0246791784,
0.0675264075,
0.013340476,
0.0144184083,
-0.0119735254,
-0.0075326269,
0.0048683332,
0.0014024766,
0.0415509753,
-0.0236722659,
0.0347711109,
0.0288999714,
-0.079707697,
-0.0572113916,
-0.0016541128,
-0.0597354285,
-0.0189895872,
-0.0227194522,
-0.010187489,
-0.0456065536,
-0.0761358142,
0.0588988774,
0.0259543564,
-0.010068953,
-0.0303294919,
0.0499540865,
-0.0145807443,
-0.0352061167,
-0.041349262,
-0.062404491,
0.0325466134,
-0.0084861517,
-0.0297811925,
0.0101429047,
0.0168042406,
-0.0084121898,
-0.0149342446,
-0.0291473959,
0.0203376859,
0.0196866337,
0.0293611027,
0.0642806143,
0.0351552032,
0.0115131503,
0.040438354,
0.0243444145,
-0.012512113,
-0.0477927923,
-0.0110917604,
0.0024697634,
0.0222801175,
0.0254563112,
0.0243689008,
0.0619673394,
0.0043095443,
-0.0657610521,
0.0354747698,
-0.009903538,
0.0408880599,
0.0667211711,
-0.0021507686,
-0.0025970417,
-0.0358486101,
-0.0412548035,
-0.0196518153,
-0.0270083714,
-0.0464423075,
0.0421113446,
0.0417250432,
-0.0347947069,
-0.0361447558,
0.0376697071,
-0.0480908826,
0.0123986378,
0.0492810532,
-0.014248495,
0.0352465808,
0.0163221247,
0.0203096252,
-0.0346192122,
0.0112385973,
0.060404744,
0.0078404937,
0.0077750725,
0.0005557894,
0.0303836595,
0.0359861106,
-0.0433577485,
0.0047734408,
-0.052631937,
0.0197174121,
-0.0036557799,
0.0523676015,
0.0029686182,
0.001501114,
-0.0346205309,
0.0193487201,
-0.0156382676,
0.0312825851,
-0.0369141512,
0.0052750753,
0.0162384044,
0.026639415,
-0.076415956,
0.003516664,
-0.0369112976,
0.0115853865,
0.0320225582,
-0.0079518156,
-0.041500017,
0.0240696892,
2.834e-7,
0.0394586027,
0.0050724996,
0.0367360301,
0.0000373891,
0.028112689,
0.0277353935,
0.0396062732,
0.0594842248,
0.0377290919,
-0.0034446106,
0.0210000649,
0.0334067754,
0.0782050565,
-0.0224748496,
-0.0854592472,
0.0346817262,
-0.0638854802,
0.0218710899,
0.0101316441,
-0.0500881597,
0.0013132526,
0.0714810491,
-0.0042703659,
-0.0257462375,
0.0099127889,
0.0228658207,
0.0652209818,
-0.0019655647,
-0.0001946389,
0.0176954698,
0.0482828729,
0.0125020118,
-0.0186121128,
-0.0058387802,
-0.0394398645,
-0.0288768299,
-0.0040927632,
0.0528775491,
-0.0179631226,
-0.0749029219,
-0.008877079,
0.0255205855,
0.036202807,
-0.0233492758,
0.0437560864,
-0.0449976437,
-0.0099595394,
-0.0085090976,
-0.0221839175,
0.0069899536,
0.008551118,
-0.0391643569,
-0.0092614386,
0.0470148399,
0.0140352957,
0.0185144488,
-0.0356442221,
-0.0687587261,
-0.0356691405,
-0.0238039158,
-0.0585633442,
-0.0321137086,
-0.0655611902,
-0.0125132883,
0.0301039182,
-0.0512032211,
0.0066630156,
2.458309729e-34,
0.0415030792,
0.0107274847,
0.0130941225,
0.0309328809,
0.0198172703,
-0.0047927848,
0.0132335648,
0.016246656,
0.0352899171,
-0.0805566609,
-0.0586769357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00786v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00786v4 | CroissantLLM: A Truly Bilingual French-English Language Model | 2024-02-01T17:17:55 | 2024-03-29T14:56:42 | Manuel Faysse, Patrick Fernandes, Nuno M. Guerreiro, António Loison, Duarte M. Alves, Caio Corro, Nicolas Boizard, João Alves, Ricardo Rei, Pedro H. Martins, Antoni Bigata Casademunt, François Yvon, André F. T. Martins, Gautier Viaud, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce CroissantLLM, a 1.3B language model pretrained on a set of 3T
English and French tokens, to bring to the research and industrial community a
high-performance, fully open-sourced bilingual model that runs swiftly on
consumer-grade local hardware. To that end, we pioneer the approach of training
an intrinsically bilingual model with a 1:1 English-to-French pretraining data
ratio, a custom tokenizer, and bilingual finetuning datasets. We release the
training dataset, notably containing a French split with manually curated,
high-quality, and varied data sources. To assess performance outside of
English, we craft a novel benchmark, FrenchBench, consisting of an array of
classification and generation tasks, covering various orthogonal aspects of
model performance in the French Language. Additionally, rooted in transparency
and to foster further Large Language Model research, we release codebases, and
dozens of checkpoints across various model sizes, training data distributions,
and training steps, as well as fine-tuned Chat models, and strong translation
models. We evaluate our model through the FMTI framework, and validate 81 % of
the transparency criteria, far beyond the scores of even most open initiatives.
This work enriches the NLP landscape, breaking away from previous
English-centric work in order to strengthen our understanding of
multilinguality in language models. | CroissantLLM: A Truly Bilingual French-English Language Model: We introduce CroissantLLM, a 1.3B language model pretrained on a set of 3T
English and French tokens, to bring to the research and industrial community a
high-performance, fully open-sourced bilingual model that runs swiftly on
consumer-grade local hardware. To that end, we pioneer the approach of training
an intrinsically bilingual model with a 1:1 English-to-French pretraining data
ratio, a custom tokenizer, and bilingual finetuning datasets. We release the
training dataset, notably containing a French split with manually curated,
high-quality, and varied data sources. To assess performance outside of
English, we craft a novel benchmark, FrenchBench, consisting of an array of
classification and generation tasks, covering various orthogonal aspects of
model performance in the French Language. Additionally, rooted in transparency
and to foster further Large Language Model research, we release codebases, and
dozens of checkpoints across various model sizes, training data distributions,
and training steps, as well as fine-tuned Chat models, and strong translation
models. We evaluate our model through the FMTI framework, and validate 81 % of
the transparency criteria, far beyond the scores of even most open initiatives.
This work enriches the NLP landscape, breaking away from previous
English-centric work in order to strengthen our understanding of
multilinguality in language models. | [
-0.0261002742,
0.0991822332,
0.002364933,
0.0733932257,
-0.0356368721,
-0.0040317588,
0.0259212293,
-0.037574973,
-0.0159642715,
-0.042673301,
-0.0573209189,
-0.0427905321,
-0.0315163694,
0.0201337319,
0.036259301,
-0.0188137144,
0.0657696575,
-0.0241801981,
-0.0188171696,
-0.014819121,
0.0189591534,
0.0337256826,
0.0197237339,
0.0600100309,
0.0061432733,
-0.0139293829,
0.0037614352,
0.030185489,
-0.0150859496,
0.0016886997,
0.0257236697,
0.0672843903,
0.0083080605,
0.0741143301,
0.0000020547,
-0.0282514077,
-0.010607806,
0.0031871232,
0.0089680254,
-0.0002008371,
0.0270157978,
-0.040225625,
-0.0065806992,
0.0298569165,
-0.0358151868,
-0.023160208,
0.0300621726,
0.0147765642,
0.031746164,
0.0764632225,
-0.0105367983,
-0.0169417653,
-0.0123245372,
-0.0570324697,
-0.0275607277,
-0.013321816,
-0.0139561174,
-0.0220418908,
-0.0257252026,
-0.0086084511,
-0.036689017,
0.0431388915,
0.0430535115,
0.0199865028,
-0.0143816052,
0.0200580526,
-0.0542929024,
-0.023424739,
-0.009944167,
0.0833148137,
-0.0499408431,
-0.0382524431,
-0.0070534418,
0.0244364627,
-0.0120282983,
-0.0781851336,
-0.0278933886,
-0.0052951118,
0.0237166826,
0.0310856327,
0.0304072946,
-0.0147669017,
0.0491889454,
-0.0121522481,
-0.0512573943,
0.0223660655,
0.0291607194,
-0.0089017479,
0.012258457,
0.0287568029,
0.0032089332,
-0.0450769514,
-0.0023011602,
-0.0108361281,
-0.0341682732,
-0.0068872548,
-0.0314961448,
-0.0006227487,
0.0252802838,
-0.05076617,
-0.0228231475,
0.0333894677,
-0.0284328125,
0.0491516888,
-0.0143629694,
0.016391607,
-0.0386923365,
0.0305480547,
-0.049973309,
-0.0236272961,
-0.0255881492,
0.0124869216,
-0.0407513231,
-0.0176573247,
-0.0492306128,
-0.0239006802,
-0.013294803,
-0.0225833133,
0.0095299827,
0.0013584524,
0.0706114992,
-0.0054413355,
-0.0351642035,
-0.005349867,
0.013170246,
0.0670890287,
-0.0442563295,
0.0011902346,
0.0134603297,
-0.1135945246,
-0.0157695804,
0.0065049659,
-0.0437036604,
-0.0516466089,
0.0084918095,
0.0900555104,
-0.0269667972,
-0.0269206297,
-0.0077640312,
-0.0248130672,
0.0038758353,
-0.0920024663,
-0.0147673758,
-0.1046811491,
0.0576017983,
0.0070618191,
0.0576810576,
-0.0353795215,
0.0120319175,
-0.0146287028,
-0.0174091402,
0.0676257238,
-0.0279500727,
-0.0154677304,
0.0109943636,
-0.0036622735,
0.0017574009,
0.1166533083,
0.0259163044,
-0.0256979186,
0.0532498844,
-0.011260042,
-0.0299346894,
0.0796143264,
0.0429084525,
0.0073126201,
-0.0222590268,
-0.0031820748,
0.026275849,
0.0383754373,
0.0574624166,
0.0594768897,
-0.0244107712,
-0.0106349625,
0.0375206843,
-0.0064282441,
0.0143000241,
0.0535776541,
0.0454635434,
0.0145076988,
0.0055111535,
-0.018458385,
-0.0275076106,
0.009088424,
0.0021586043,
-0.0127274897,
0.0363942757,
0.0493949503,
-0.0448105596,
-0.0158359502,
0.003806835,
-0.0165768787,
0.0390513279,
0.0031323151,
0.0442671701,
0.0240562093,
-0.0221867096,
0.0624520406,
0.0403869264,
-0.0333732739,
0.0222674552,
-0.0276132822,
-0.014997378,
0.0729556233,
0.0212161541,
0.010239413,
-0.0180283114,
-0.0324664004,
0.0129237818,
0.0316042528,
0.0664658323,
-0.0088829016,
0.0533199385,
-0.0585147478,
0.0020804661,
-0.0281574707,
0.0188466888,
0.0490514226,
0.0085513247,
0.0328283571,
-0.0103378054,
-0.0282941312,
-0.0333056934,
0.0322801694,
-0.0591337383,
0.003014548,
0.0022656459,
0.0007664054,
-0.0099474676,
0.0099255955,
-0.0234527607,
0.0013866082,
0.0272536203,
-0.0370639227,
0.0196355786,
0.0384318419,
-0.0211970545,
-0.041140195,
0.0394863151,
-0.0170770735,
-0.0119836712,
0.0228306875,
-0.0571798645,
-0.0277929045,
0.0348342918,
0.0117681222,
0.0403235853,
-0.0366865322,
0.0169586968,
0.0231396891,
0.0169681106,
0.0079915663,
0.0249114726,
-0.0152719393,
0.0382447876,
0.0116320197,
-0.0157877356,
0.0401661955,
-0.0350210182,
-0.0340131484,
0.0413223915,
-0.0131295957,
0.0355394855,
0.0277069584,
0.06194368,
-0.0118533839,
-0.0332012028,
-0.0803149194,
0.0018508894,
-0.0450010188,
0.010951519,
0.0128983492,
0.017829109,
-0.0128932176,
-0.0452168398,
-0.0362152755,
-0.0243228525,
-0.0009172804,
0.0182610881,
0.0024592003,
0.0035375308,
-0.0095695639,
-0.0233280379,
-0.0156629253,
0.032312613,
0.0505698025,
-0.0344424434,
0.0084752254,
-0.0187501144,
0.0022703423,
-0.0229696184,
0.0421833731,
-0.0159573928,
-0.0460369661,
-0.0061176247,
-0.0370859578,
0.016882604,
0.0404813662,
-0.0002999266,
0.0143951746,
0.0163736455,
-0.0102782743,
-0.0614696108,
0.0313245356,
-0.0098841889,
-0.0453266725,
-0.0565217808,
-0.0281613767,
-0.0048058629,
0.0773920715,
-0.0277952533,
-0.0211397968,
-0.0531224199,
-0.0003004328,
-0.0228051189,
-0.0391019322,
-0.0360250361,
0.0712239295,
0.0064724516,
0.0304444935,
-0.0301791392,
-0.0205819327,
0.0676015913,
-0.047283303,
0.0020730454,
-0.0318827741,
-0.0073345397,
-0.0200726595,
0.0448035188,
-0.0039230199,
0.0244253557,
0.0044594221,
-0.0168884192,
-0.0379808955,
0.01233528,
0.0127952034,
-0.0177102163,
0.0599750876,
-0.0202046297,
-0.0111160744,
0.0003698847,
-0.072941497,
-0.0138387056,
-0.0268466827,
-0.0296724346,
0.010407134,
0.0249308962,
-0.0184045583,
-0.0285670459,
0.0019430342,
0.0012206866,
0.0812831223,
-0.0140876314,
0.0159645453,
0.0001945713,
0.0080544511,
0.0309600942,
-0.0016706304,
0.0024314744,
-0.0691847131,
0.0126323635,
0.0249974262,
0.0318083316,
0.007027999,
-0.0270244125,
-0.015571611,
0.0373441316,
0.0037862239,
-0.0495813601,
-0.0330889784,
0.0592552237,
-0.0476635545,
-0.0619093478,
0.1001603976,
-0.0098346742,
-0.0552856885,
-0.0037615132,
0.0128239617,
0.0471121632,
0.0404656939,
0.0107465563,
-0.0807151347,
-0.0234248787,
0.0151564488,
0.0031056891,
0.043944519,
0.0238980651,
-0.0060033556,
-0.0891234726,
0.0047398848,
-0.0085545303,
-0.0827068239,
-0.0013383141,
-0.0231202301,
-0.0568575598,
-0.0534131825,
0.0548052862,
-0.0243932568,
0.0174642224,
-0.003469927,
0.00531663,
0.0029601317,
-0.0708770603,
0.0096709337,
-0.0680473447,
0.0410341099,
0.0457100645,
0.0230315402,
-0.0155180087,
-0.0289526917,
0.0496887192,
-0.0003666737,
-0.0056936615,
-0.0187373683,
0.0176364128,
-0.0080281179,
-0.0312691368,
0.0255144611,
-0.0228345096,
-0.0113403667,
0.0203905627,
0.0216844808,
0.0387037396,
0.0092708636,
0.0116712777,
-0.003027855,
-0.0125938868,
0.0025431137,
0.0620420165,
0.0236946847,
-0.0399141088,
-0.037840683,
-0.0461728014,
-0.0205889903,
-0.0857151896,
-0.0236423127,
0.0074722958,
-0.0165367592,
-0.0486043692,
-0.0429532602,
-0.0458555855,
0.0141699761,
0.0295772199,
0.0151957162,
0.0104131978,
-0.0215282161,
-0.006611859,
-0.0382555462,
0.0702976957,
-0.0242842883,
0.0053293188,
-0.0775364786,
-0.0047761649,
0.0179272406,
-0.0246632937,
-0.0272380412,
0.0243472401,
-0.0833857954,
-0.0722407922,
-0.0311171561,
0.0771755055,
0.0201797485,
0.0596135966,
-0.032117378,
-0.0469068289,
-0.0124267824,
0.0291334521,
-0.0263368171,
-0.0133643709,
0.0575261302,
-0.0373158008,
-0.0114296135,
0.0542068779,
-0.0271229912,
0.0210994016,
-0.0009859777,
0.0677901208,
0.019484235,
-0.0174058303,
0.0082495036,
-0.0098520694,
0.0572680943,
-0.0401352048,
0.0024974423,
-0.051498536,
0.0127487611,
-0.0320055075,
-0.0050966647,
-0.0294330567,
0.0150680756,
0.0494544022,
0.0045448556,
-0.0055151898,
-0.0181509219,
0.0440441631,
0.0185693037,
-0.0210994966,
-0.0282653049,
0.0097758556,
0.0139794964,
0.040710073,
0.019211391,
-0.0129022077,
0.0347594842,
-0.0041541778,
0.0285986811,
-0.0857487023,
0.0414651595,
0.0403933227,
0.0195884444,
-0.0121137341,
0.0299765039,
-0.0192009546,
-0.0388444252,
-0.0137998182,
0.0214354526,
0.0839151889,
0.0069613219,
0.1003278866,
-0.0084623815,
-0.041789569,
-0.0372514725,
0.0571035035,
-0.0026573723,
-0.0467385873,
0.0013973055,
-0.0083911726,
-0.0401891321,
-0.0271431636,
0.0817220509,
-0.0071645621,
0.011436753,
0.0225327294,
0.0266529098,
-0.0224667881,
-0.0000880614,
0.0217836667,
0.0072598513,
-0.0277227107,
-0.0173657555,
-0.0170570165,
-0.0599143356,
-0.005822727,
0.0333993211,
-0.0068456749,
0.0098158149,
0.0210492685,
0.0892428085,
0.0016268506,
-0.0050233612,
-0.0510366261,
0.0164086279,
0.0107604368,
-0.021647647,
-0.0034578582,
-6.416529219e-33,
0.0021684209,
0.0419697389,
-0.0008592546,
-0.0137570351,
-0.0177474152,
0.0105140172,
-0.0264665876,
0.00335606,
-0.0431390777,
0.0033267988,
-0.0014246391,
0.0128161032,
0.0173099674,
0.0553486273,
0.011023677,
-0.001966438,
0.0599776544,
0.0082324119,
-0.012012464,
0.0284308922,
0.0248377379,
0.0553434417,
0.0814985782,
-0.0244945586,
0.006617839,
-0.0332670324,
-0.0219741911,
0.0247798059,
-0.0263724476,
0.0733283609,
-0.0372107811,
0.0481605791,
0.0027879816,
-0.0228722058,
-0.0209549088,
-0.0350547247,
-0.1090833023,
-0.0161148831,
0.0060552475,
0.0542990416,
-0.0269038025,
-0.0120274406,
0.0362608954,
-0.0048428248,
-0.0249522496,
0.0126156826,
0.0099749323,
-0.0042729764,
-0.0023377871,
-0.0038413242,
-0.0667477176,
0.0109692179,
0.0318158902,
0.0029215629,
0.0408384278,
0.0692748353,
-0.000563144,
-0.0296869185,
-0.0689871535,
-0.0018041686,
-0.0252835378,
0.0430114493,
0.0764561594,
0.0338981189,
0.008868942,
0.056417156,
0.0536175556,
0.0066613234,
0.0031072814,
0.0342973247,
0.0795321167,
0.018475404,
0.0561631285,
0.075419113,
0.0225157719,
-0.0076452773,
-0.0730482712,
-0.0018499056,
0.0244946051,
-0.0131274424,
0.0128087783,
0.0098444205,
-0.00836452,
-0.0225178674,
-0.0577708371,
-0.0362557285,
-0.0206335206,
-0.0186508447,
0.0327863619,
0.0274920668,
0.0225406121,
-0.0277574547,
0.064551495,
-0.0102413362,
-0.0365476273,
0.0161442086,
0.0118766464,
-0.0089791948,
-0.0209583156,
0.0903746039,
-0.0501809418,
-0.0510875322,
-0.0130709829,
-0.0013167545,
0.0165931266,
0.0040187845,
0.0546516366,
0.011737315,
-0.047701925,
0.0075376458,
-0.0558577366,
0.0418752171,
-0.0100798747,
0.053096924,
0.0516974404,
-0.0120493798,
-0.0075214216,
0.0672068074,
0.019157378,
-0.0056765885,
-0.040382769,
-0.0295831226,
0.0185357984,
0.0484759696,
-0.0236420389,
0.0127990218,
-0.0608547181,
-0.0275095664,
0.0252468158,
-0.068691507,
-0.0400079302,
0.0159269478,
2.651e-7,
0.0482415445,
-0.0037920712,
0.027811652,
0.0248884298,
-0.0058361753,
0.0185762085,
-0.0559797809,
0.0380419083,
-0.0098447669,
0.0105440235,
-0.0413270369,
0.0333631895,
0.0796591863,
0.0358993709,
-0.084623307,
0.00227871,
-0.0498171523,
0.0226925593,
-0.0391381495,
-0.0128395688,
-0.0147505896,
0.1266647875,
0.0024445581,
0.015383143,
-0.0007949576,
-0.0241594128,
0.0620249249,
-0.0360035524,
-0.0138090067,
0.0118072247,
0.0075167948,
0.0542629026,
-0.0172774661,
-0.0220678672,
-0.0169415213,
-0.0187930632,
0.0191703141,
0.0584047958,
-0.0013202305,
-0.0083596492,
0.0309244152,
-0.042828694,
-0.038236659,
-0.0710602328,
0.0321372487,
-0.0243099052,
0.0106572956,
-0.0383751951,
-0.0110174986,
0.0007817911,
0.0676272139,
-0.054884728,
-0.0222911239,
0.0389360636,
0.0431138091,
0.0022672634,
-0.0290496685,
-0.0679805204,
-0.0558552891,
-0.0133551285,
-0.0348813795,
-0.0161741804,
0.005601509,
0.0245750472,
-0.0168456212,
-0.0341919251,
0.0238398965,
2.571491008e-34,
0.0480796136,
-0.001311159,
0.0051471819,
0.0172208641,
0.0489906147,
-0.0456663594,
-0.0115176868,
-0.0149225127,
-0.0359607339,
-0.0330592729,
-0.0202147011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00746v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00746v6 | Health-LLM: Personalized Retrieval-Augmented Disease Prediction System | 2024-02-01T16:40:32 | 2024-03-19T22:12:19 | Mingyu Jin, Qinkai Yu, Dong Shu, Chong Zhang, Lizhou Fan, Wenyue Hua, Suiyuan Zhu, Yanda Meng, Zhenting Wang, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), especially large
language models (LLMs), have significantly advanced healthcare applications and
demonstrated potentials in intelligent medical treatment. However, there are
conspicuous challenges such as vast data volumes and inconsistent symptom
characterization standards, preventing full integration of healthcare AI
systems with individual patients' needs. To promote professional and
personalized healthcare, we propose an innovative framework, Heath-LLM, which
combines large-scale feature extraction and medical knowledge trade-off
scoring. Compared to traditional health management applications, our system has
three main advantages: (1) It integrates health reports and medical knowledge
into a large model to ask relevant questions to large language model for
disease prediction; (2) It leverages a retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
mechanism to enhance feature extraction; (3) It incorporates a semi-automated
feature updating framework that can merge and delete features to improve
accuracy of disease prediction. We experiment on a large number of health
reports to assess the effectiveness of Health-LLM system. The results indicate
that the proposed system surpasses the existing ones and has the potential to
significantly advance disease prediction and personalized health management.
The code is available at https://github.com/jmyissb/HealthLLM. | Health-LLM: Personalized Retrieval-Augmented Disease Prediction System: Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), especially large
language models (LLMs), have significantly advanced healthcare applications and
demonstrated potentials in intelligent medical treatment. However, there are
conspicuous challenges such as vast data volumes and inconsistent symptom
characterization standards, preventing full integration of healthcare AI
systems with individual patients' needs. To promote professional and
personalized healthcare, we propose an innovative framework, Heath-LLM, which
combines large-scale feature extraction and medical knowledge trade-off
scoring. Compared to traditional health management applications, our system has
three main advantages: (1) It integrates health reports and medical knowledge
into a large model to ask relevant questions to large language model for
disease prediction; (2) It leverages a retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
mechanism to enhance feature extraction; (3) It incorporates a semi-automated
feature updating framework that can merge and delete features to improve
accuracy of disease prediction. We experiment on a large number of health
reports to assess the effectiveness of Health-LLM system. The results indicate
that the proposed system surpasses the existing ones and has the potential to
significantly advance disease prediction and personalized health management.
The code is available at https://github.com/jmyissb/HealthLLM. | [
0.0622438528,
0.060057912,
-0.0179050285,
-0.0307288375,
0.011773238,
-0.00147374,
-0.0003428992,
0.0415938012,
0.087533623,
-0.0027975235,
0.0047548097,
-0.0192328934,
-0.0190132596,
0.0792957544,
-0.0259897672,
-0.042562291,
0.0369715951,
0.0352208428,
0.0378150456,
0.0174262002,
-0.0113039035,
0.0091621382,
-0.002494456,
0.0651992485,
0.0092093702,
0.0078793429,
0.0281475168,
-0.0325850509,
0.0263274647,
-0.0609420575,
0.0016436555,
-0.0013823338,
-0.0338431112,
-0.0187483076,
0.0000020023,
-0.0575642847,
-0.0327303894,
0.0181305651,
0.0060846247,
-0.0744574368,
0.0410960875,
-0.0330891535,
0.0061988547,
0.0121474974,
-0.0519936942,
-0.0300505552,
0.0255466793,
0.054807689,
0.0548572466,
0.0602974296,
-0.0138010364,
-0.0161499735,
0.0112511553,
-0.0051726666,
0.0599486381,
-0.0351560526,
0.0501974188,
-0.0011482743,
0.0429615267,
-0.0436150096,
0.0262177866,
0.0548350401,
-0.0324920565,
0.0347455479,
0.0331865773,
0.0563788973,
-0.010358464,
-0.0346276723,
-0.014996035,
0.0344690904,
-0.0073602567,
0.0004306972,
0.0255450401,
0.0128891906,
0.0102836695,
0.0103508234,
-0.0235781595,
-0.0473571569,
-0.0298375748,
0.0169639289,
0.0173779372,
-0.0099596502,
0.0303056501,
0.0005637922,
-0.0159772746,
0.0358589664,
-0.0113648456,
-0.0220547114,
-0.0035538655,
-0.0249371752,
-0.0036539955,
-0.0311632287,
0.0349220149,
0.0623931549,
-0.0517639965,
-0.0116267493,
0.0128526734,
-0.058561556,
0.0959270075,
-0.0521165356,
0.0115933288,
-0.0008831046,
-0.0160472021,
0.0202771313,
0.0186717473,
0.0008467462,
-0.0094999531,
-0.016499294,
-0.0481608957,
0.009198321,
-0.0802899227,
-0.021010166,
-0.0102001606,
0.0498600416,
0.0315274261,
0.0136701837,
-0.080068551,
-0.0238956027,
-0.0377740525,
0.0204941984,
0.0406322405,
0.0749057233,
-0.0205505062,
0.0167103019,
-0.0336395241,
0.0201950967,
-0.0155180758,
0.0009986281,
-0.0060839015,
-0.0191926025,
0.0436802171,
-0.0173701718,
0.0182662364,
-0.0014501762,
0.0540939011,
0.0386863351,
0.0255538337,
-0.0377125069,
0.0097918827,
-0.0616777353,
-0.0230135769,
-0.0149580417,
-0.0302136242,
-0.0715884939,
0.0352752022,
-0.0050653368,
-0.0000253688,
-0.0477306433,
0.0186191015,
0.0132882027,
-0.0483680405,
0.022291759,
-0.0377609022,
0.0140585154,
0.0590928085,
0.0115756541,
0.0158079993,
-0.0029605965,
0.0073011946,
0.0208558999,
0.0132231936,
-0.004706753,
0.0272989888,
0.0119947577,
0.0196103118,
-0.0367678702,
0.0321341269,
0.0160512701,
-0.0018362736,
0.0488865264,
-0.0696374774,
0.0596993566,
0.0328929797,
0.0005409421,
0.0243918803,
0.0491377451,
0.0645866618,
0.0227403697,
0.0075549022,
-0.0078971516,
-0.0068600592,
-0.047206156,
0.024023179,
-0.0051707295,
-0.0629033148,
0.0013175693,
-0.0097531928,
0.0317629762,
-0.0251435265,
-0.0563011356,
-0.0375281759,
-0.0246355962,
-0.005160172,
0.0034069635,
0.0427655056,
-0.0273964107,
0.0036628612,
0.0492963269,
0.0448677465,
-0.0288528316,
-0.0245873854,
-0.0675170198,
0.0111278985,
0.0986724272,
0.0483851619,
-0.0589177981,
-0.0089055067,
0.0111290291,
-0.0431039557,
-0.0501688458,
0.0222696085,
-0.0206987876,
0.0036875827,
-0.0240654983,
0.0053833183,
0.0744137019,
0.0045175338,
-0.0351241864,
-0.011415679,
0.0389119759,
-0.0101645514,
0.0052097715,
-0.0343262777,
0.0200097691,
-0.0521965697,
-0.0171700008,
0.0115029896,
0.009797046,
0.0337965339,
0.0195930284,
0.0138923982,
0.038633883,
0.0445256382,
-0.0642926991,
-0.0522687845,
0.0034239672,
-0.0022607413,
-0.0136281746,
-0.0001175939,
0.0252118502,
0.0504208133,
-0.0243110247,
-0.0268797353,
-0.0238691196,
-0.0283824764,
-0.0472979844,
0.0187296122,
-0.0252108239,
0.0043658395,
0.0267545842,
-0.0015161181,
-0.0464030392,
0.0369419307,
-0.0153375175,
-0.0289863404,
-0.0251126215,
-0.0792952925,
-0.0096949758,
-0.044030644,
-0.0167576913,
0.0208773073,
-0.0002637377,
0.0155792236,
0.0165702011,
0.0021788457,
-0.0238793902,
-0.0084857317,
-0.1385587901,
0.0124860546,
0.0199513845,
-0.0143586639,
0.001915523,
0.0368030258,
-0.0112369228,
-0.0338042676,
-0.0640685484,
-0.0150266057,
0.0545537584,
0.0062286435,
0.037087936,
0.0707579404,
0.0008131007,
-0.0399221741,
0.0083200186,
-0.0375787318,
0.0287508704,
0.0076322658,
-0.0170260929,
-0.0058202217,
0.0069587049,
-0.0782666653,
0.0126813715,
0.027520068,
-0.012134538,
-0.0273035765,
-0.0608331524,
-0.0133781722,
0.0265366249,
-0.0019628711,
0.0171465501,
0.0683060139,
0.0117386859,
-0.0502248444,
0.0318708047,
-0.0630532131,
-0.0086197788,
0.0128606074,
-0.052036304,
0.015307812,
0.0302337445,
0.0392638966,
0.0088453395,
-0.0646556541,
0.0383784957,
-0.0039932332,
0.0321819335,
-0.0644483194,
0.0355567597,
-0.0246688463,
0.0345333368,
-0.0109366328,
-0.0512273572,
0.1016636342,
0.0015216703,
0.0516932756,
-0.088497974,
-0.0181219485,
-0.0425683521,
0.0206637662,
-0.0064071706,
0.0391372554,
-0.0020637093,
0.0102010602,
0.0141680492,
0.0204074346,
-0.0110480068,
-0.1033623442,
0.0249154642,
0.0000168708,
0.0273335185,
0.0473306924,
-0.0303029735,
-0.0380268358,
-0.0304411203,
-0.0330190919,
-0.011269032,
-0.0182389282,
0.0249967799,
-0.0589122847,
0.0165848825,
-0.0012801576,
0.0375748388,
0.0267477036,
-0.0152365314,
0.0415100008,
-0.0066809966,
0.0519882329,
0.0124652861,
-0.0335786641,
0.0062034451,
0.0173441488,
0.0562198311,
0.009335598,
0.0168813299,
0.0347443558,
0.0192386527,
0.0203864817,
-0.0418068692,
-0.0057121301,
0.0193282031,
-0.0047755302,
-0.0551969372,
0.0003132653,
0.0990534052,
0.0671603307,
-0.0614023358,
0.0175012294,
-0.0360243693,
-0.0143578257,
-0.0163283274,
0.0459353775,
-0.0566909425,
-0.0265830476,
-0.0111928685,
0.0455461107,
-0.0339439027,
-0.0258412361,
0.0198847428,
-0.0299297236,
0.0045969896,
-0.0015654205,
-0.0281855501,
-0.0616023391,
-0.0347106159,
0.004774204,
0.0019091858,
-0.0485379845,
-0.0116993906,
-0.0156871527,
-0.0050067799,
-0.0004471594,
-0.0594431572,
-0.0677271783,
0.0414880328,
-0.0125965355,
0.0073891319,
0.1274106503,
0.0511144102,
0.0144625735,
-0.040869873,
-0.0577660799,
0.0585859753,
0.038211789,
-0.0424918681,
0.0835851207,
0.0262119547,
0.0033728215,
-0.0635114461,
0.0116406968,
-0.0204728246,
-0.0174070057,
0.0177293699,
0.0966320112,
-0.0411656648,
-0.0287475456,
-0.0568780899,
0.0084659113,
0.0220123343,
0.0561555251,
-0.0231735818,
-0.0163580384,
-0.012677066,
0.0242692586,
0.021150697,
0.034218885,
-0.0449991636,
0.0490739197,
-0.0527331904,
-0.0203227513,
-0.0865880176,
-0.0253672805,
0.0348887742,
-0.0341294482,
0.0119628133,
0.0134887267,
-0.0005986909,
0.0119224247,
-0.0613046475,
0.0297161024,
0.0465020388,
0.0028542667,
-0.0418531448,
-0.0265835114,
0.0691719428,
-0.0315283127,
-0.012681297,
0.0078692334,
-0.0249499958,
-0.0058350889,
0.0190962143,
0.0384847559,
0.017691724,
0.0052090837,
-0.0049263905,
-0.013981916,
0.0804530233,
0.0576356687,
-0.0553107299,
-0.0259947628,
-0.0250397287,
-0.0305624902,
0.0028581282,
0.0293119662,
-0.0390996858,
0.0186550822,
-0.0154745579,
0.0274251774,
-0.0133560887,
-0.0209479798,
0.0155515084,
0.0596095063,
0.0415763333,
0.0082149943,
-0.0400563441,
-0.0281781144,
0.0182882361,
-0.0106314728,
-0.0044590463,
-0.022406159,
0.0088159982,
0.0083456999,
-0.0182701349,
0.004948034,
0.0490502045,
-0.0359631293,
-0.0269062482,
-0.0418873392,
0.0410208404,
-0.0200525485,
0.0167911071,
0.0656239316,
-0.0031890285,
0.0162693784,
0.0254709758,
0.0078801839,
0.0172693413,
-0.0259598587,
0.0363690071,
-0.0259046331,
0.0148495082,
-0.0299202036,
0.0524628349,
-0.0373170003,
-0.0544265732,
-0.0204463191,
0.0184400547,
0.0351378731,
-0.0022896999,
0.0421890505,
-0.0256104805,
-0.0139373206,
-0.0301199742,
-0.0168577693,
-0.0141426688,
0.0076282616,
0.0188428536,
-0.0043646311,
-0.0360271186,
-0.0378649943,
0.0743535161,
-0.0175381023,
0.0143048,
-0.0101856189,
-0.0754086748,
-0.0404477715,
0.0032582025,
0.041761443,
0.0251249745,
-0.0813820213,
-0.0165665466,
-0.0543521158,
-0.0299481153,
0.0587028526,
-0.0233961567,
-0.037219651,
-0.0071390891,
0.0534685589,
0.0541328155,
0.0015189034,
-0.0145785967,
-0.0410850048,
0.0336239785,
-0.0869332552,
-0.0274783671,
0.0126241585,
-5.892638203e-33,
-0.0003005145,
-0.0267614946,
0.037258856,
-0.0226581618,
0.0326033272,
0.0016693524,
-0.0034440556,
-0.0119746439,
0.0166341607,
0.0131018087,
-0.0031418633,
-0.0164470356,
-0.0044557173,
0.0132705094,
0.0102648679,
-0.0230731461,
0.03975695,
0.0181887969,
-0.0072591528,
0.0220885705,
0.0251746811,
0.085121423,
0.0082678832,
-0.0785016865,
-0.0045852452,
-0.0126777925,
0.0211023763,
0.0282195248,
-0.0056669149,
0.0576400571,
-0.0382675007,
0.0667531788,
0.0371601954,
0.0026918561,
0.0099175144,
-0.0117748706,
-0.0357228592,
-0.0276218615,
-0.031097047,
-0.0552211031,
-0.0151503319,
-0.0294054672,
0.0537854955,
-0.0138875172,
-0.0454096533,
0.0133515568,
0.0501058921,
-0.0563660413,
-0.0144376215,
-0.0567592047,
0.0019239406,
0.0242757034,
0.021158278,
0.019833114,
-0.0193859339,
0.0242930185,
-0.0174970981,
0.056928467,
-0.0145496773,
-0.0069949133,
0.0063330201,
0.0404891111,
0.0182705708,
-0.0182694066,
-0.0165269282,
0.0546307042,
0.0268353075,
-0.0184152201,
-0.0522066206,
0.0220274273,
-0.0380988419,
0.0378356092,
0.0319002941,
0.0182169192,
0.0193674527,
-0.0424731858,
-0.07598681,
0.0876339227,
-0.0602350384,
0.0329084024,
0.0087477025,
-0.0073713749,
-0.0297311507,
0.0107913557,
-0.0230483785,
0.0475387722,
-0.0498222373,
-0.0475314371,
0.0289981402,
0.0150716389,
0.0158495307,
0.0154981473,
-0.0287673119,
-0.0202605817,
0.009398994,
0.0100035574,
0.0114049083,
-0.020761909,
-0.0384363905,
0.0021575976,
-0.0280255359,
0.0091512715,
-0.001822402,
-0.0378917195,
0.0166857876,
0.02310903,
0.0218712222,
-0.0491549708,
-0.0386325829,
-0.0106474711,
0.0479435325,
0.0009639819,
-0.022877859,
0.0145710567,
0.0127401873,
0.038687665,
-0.005327052,
0.0789413378,
0.0329626277,
0.0344704352,
-0.0823512971,
-0.0419417247,
0.0367060117,
-0.0229584556,
-0.0304633062,
0.004870493,
-0.0598219782,
0.0470248014,
0.0425846279,
-0.0343405604,
0.0025664314,
0.007092671,
2.82e-7,
0.077145949,
0.0475999042,
-0.0182073209,
-0.0312822647,
0.0089004645,
0.0225961097,
0.0026203322,
-0.0002484883,
0.0142875686,
0.0414770953,
0.045442611,
0.0225006919,
0.0187639315,
0.0696741343,
-0.0661269799,
-0.0145180663,
-0.0699985549,
-0.0495902263,
-0.0534621961,
-0.0165721681,
0.0586061813,
0.0617455728,
-0.0216858052,
-0.0410177447,
0.0591423176,
-0.0090347519,
0.0270419139,
-0.0216368679,
-0.0360120721,
0.0254455749,
0.0246765874,
0.0147914505,
0.018341098,
-0.013117224,
-0.0303596184,
-0.0155754909,
-0.0063547306,
0.0586025566,
-0.0523903146,
-0.0155443689,
0.0153775206,
0.0272773709,
0.0264744535,
-0.0016452544,
0.0746823028,
-0.0136300484,
-0.033674553,
-0.0146512203,
0.0079816822,
-0.0123490514,
0.0372867323,
-0.0369667597,
-0.043496456,
0.0362148359,
0.0067137629,
0.025031101,
-0.0029385944,
-0.0612643138,
-0.0321221165,
0.0367756113,
-0.042435348,
-0.0484898016,
0.020985093,
-0.0089379791,
-0.0390444286,
-0.0883211121,
0.0322851315,
2.542490966e-34,
0.0136642344,
0.0412374996,
-0.0055952095,
-0.0118153654,
0.0400175788,
-0.0051993108,
-0.003084355,
0.0253869612,
0.0107743042,
-0.0750784054,
-0.019705398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00745v1 | Enhancing Ethical Explanations of Large Language Models through Iterative Symbolic Refinement | 2024-02-01T16:39:51 | 2024-02-01T16:39:51 | Xin Quan, Marco Valentino, Louise A. Dennis, André Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | An increasing amount of research in Natural Language Inference (NLI) focuses
on the application and evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
reasoning capabilities. Despite their success, however, LLMs are still prone to
factual errors and inconsistencies in their explanations, offering limited
control and interpretability for inference in complex domains. In this paper,
we focus on ethical NLI, investigating how hybrid neuro-symbolic techniques can
enhance the logical validity and alignment of ethical explanations produced by
LLMs. Specifically, we present an abductive-deductive framework named
Logic-Explainer, which integrates LLMs with an external backward-chaining
solver to refine step-wise natural language explanations and jointly verify
their correctness, reduce incompleteness and minimise redundancy. An extensive
empirical analysis demonstrates that Logic-Explainer can improve explanations
generated via in-context learning methods and Chain-of-Thought (CoT) on
challenging ethical NLI tasks, while, at the same time, producing formal proofs
describing and supporting models' reasoning. As ethical NLI requires
commonsense reasoning to identify underlying moral violations, our results
suggest the effectiveness of neuro-symbolic methods for multi-step NLI more
broadly, opening new opportunities to enhance the logical consistency,
reliability, and alignment of LLMs. | Enhancing Ethical Explanations of Large Language Models through Iterative Symbolic Refinement: An increasing amount of research in Natural Language Inference (NLI) focuses
on the application and evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
reasoning capabilities. Despite their success, however, LLMs are still prone to
factual errors and inconsistencies in their explanations, offering limited
control and interpretability for inference in complex domains. In this paper,
we focus on ethical NLI, investigating how hybrid neuro-symbolic techniques can
enhance the logical validity and alignment of ethical explanations produced by
LLMs. Specifically, we present an abductive-deductive framework named
Logic-Explainer, which integrates LLMs with an external backward-chaining
solver to refine step-wise natural language explanations and jointly verify
their correctness, reduce incompleteness and minimise redundancy. An extensive
empirical analysis demonstrates that Logic-Explainer can improve explanations
generated via in-context learning methods and Chain-of-Thought (CoT) on
challenging ethical NLI tasks, while, at the same time, producing formal proofs
describing and supporting models' reasoning. As ethical NLI requires
commonsense reasoning to identify underlying moral violations, our results
suggest the effectiveness of neuro-symbolic methods for multi-step NLI more
broadly, opening new opportunities to enhance the logical consistency,
reliability, and alignment of LLMs. | [
0.0486272722,
0.0966747478,
-0.0355758965,
0.0595077388,
-0.0737259388,
0.010569145,
0.0391711481,
-0.0279151388,
-0.0012345474,
-0.0212659687,
0.0208041053,
0.0201635156,
0.0206624735,
0.0043954155,
0.0289122947,
-0.0165866744,
0.0318811648,
-0.0014651694,
0.0376887508,
-0.0060281558,
-0.0011932568,
0.0694181025,
0.0373607837,
0.0120526208,
0.0028044807,
0.0053648874,
-0.0180825312,
-0.003890367,
0.0184680764,
-0.000618092,
-0.022996746,
0.0155068422,
0.0721672922,
0.0482119992,
0.0000020208,
-0.0499677956,
0.0057788878,
0.0466520339,
-0.0419670604,
0.0211530365,
0.0446550548,
-0.03356345,
0.0240890738,
0.0008557707,
0.0104914522,
0.0503055826,
0.0413007103,
0.0640155897,
0.0482552275,
0.0437819846,
0.0121257296,
-0.025690116,
0.0327705927,
-0.0124788033,
-0.048571486,
-0.0112213837,
0.0426446125,
0.0036022407,
-0.0209145602,
-0.0012874581,
-0.0043545798,
0.0280901343,
0.0813508481,
-0.0129866265,
-0.0592986904,
-0.0161287244,
-0.0082386564,
-0.0209165793,
-0.0080698254,
0.0300977603,
-0.0025065071,
-0.0459584817,
0.011039488,
0.0253537409,
0.0041752867,
0.0018676649,
-0.0219829567,
0.0799623951,
-0.0391067266,
0.0104069309,
0.0543602295,
-0.0061284914,
0.0626781136,
0.0721947551,
0.0219649673,
0.0242652595,
-0.0188712087,
-0.0215984751,
0.001075147,
-0.0131188063,
-0.0247658733,
-0.0288024507,
0.0299925953,
0.0419160686,
-0.034327358,
0.0533407591,
0.0152403945,
0.0111924624,
0.0345856212,
-0.0283101555,
0.0321650431,
0.0431724116,
0.0251368284,
0.0167803112,
-0.0194073282,
0.0061729383,
-0.0427189134,
0.0536193252,
-0.0245841388,
-0.0123951146,
-0.0263733789,
-0.0423583947,
-0.0102140782,
0.0181297604,
-0.036329601,
0.0282147694,
0.0245565381,
-0.0173787661,
-0.0451797098,
-0.0051850495,
-0.0198391993,
0.0364699289,
-0.0009986581,
-0.0262893252,
-0.0335992947,
0.0129084764,
-0.0498532057,
0.0425427034,
0.0291534457,
-0.0104143741,
-0.0228291545,
-0.0404924043,
-0.0412772819,
-0.0052145915,
0.0139918178,
0.089511402,
0.0166535061,
0.0265689585,
-0.0513773449,
-0.0450092554,
-0.0151467919,
-0.068317242,
-0.0224266816,
-0.051865302,
0.0313267447,
-0.0255118422,
-0.0405971482,
-0.0564642325,
0.0283972323,
0.0030777839,
-0.0333924443,
0.0697653368,
-0.0172535125,
-0.0049674115,
0.0203757752,
0.0353080519,
-0.0108480901,
0.0362465195,
0.0407636911,
0.0172602106,
0.0025559985,
0.0076867933,
-0.0030337053,
-0.013061258,
0.0318260416,
0.0144215329,
-0.0462595709,
-0.0118186772,
-0.0448996238,
0.0439536013,
0.0286507234,
0.0391465053,
-0.0163279939,
-0.0250583403,
0.0358267352,
0.0717788935,
-0.0020639999,
0.0144266132,
0.0515691116,
-0.0185027625,
-0.0116067845,
-0.0138625037,
-0.087827757,
0.0308736973,
-0.0136119099,
-0.0203438308,
-0.081439279,
0.0679505989,
0.0063693267,
-0.0631408691,
0.0273104049,
-0.0009193926,
0.0534665994,
0.0186524522,
0.0284887608,
0.0181442667,
0.0020769024,
0.0207330901,
0.0575675853,
-0.0545143969,
-0.002774548,
-0.0472115465,
0.0449715741,
0.0582448877,
0.0487507917,
0.0102780228,
-0.0075806314,
-0.0655179173,
-0.01833825,
0.0382755436,
-0.030159466,
-0.0108533595,
0.0235342495,
-0.0266273804,
-0.033528477,
-0.0464367867,
0.0231863037,
0.0098562045,
0.0191458538,
-0.0283693261,
0.0288642701,
-0.0396122113,
-0.0296060294,
0.0495976731,
-0.0331824981,
0.0180705748,
-0.0311889295,
0.0241563823,
0.0170198753,
0.0001454444,
0.0161924325,
-0.0178372972,
0.0052076192,
-0.004970232,
-0.0173036698,
0.0214836355,
-0.0382628702,
-0.0309845153,
0.0374619104,
-0.0530042388,
-0.0208213441,
0.038673684,
-0.0676319674,
0.0159059223,
0.0110221757,
-0.0511234812,
-0.0103485361,
-0.0670997798,
-0.0252610538,
-0.0613341182,
-0.0367713384,
-0.0109286038,
0.0737173185,
-0.0192018896,
-0.0222239979,
0.0031251123,
-0.0000844076,
0.0190189052,
-0.0149456933,
0.0207084361,
0.0139524015,
-0.0317979269,
-0.0042793071,
0.0046088351,
0.0204213075,
-0.0152198561,
-0.0048577562,
-0.0473265052,
0.0065649231,
0.0009244007,
-0.0162556767,
-0.0136725549,
-0.0175529122,
0.0176290758,
0.0077334833,
0.0139854355,
-0.0102763018,
-0.0072398772,
0.0027086223,
0.0203872547,
-0.0256044548,
-0.0647776648,
0.0111474935,
-0.0091779884,
-0.054315988,
0.0571981445,
0.0284542087,
0.0074603441,
-0.0405469462,
-0.0146877831,
-0.065292038,
0.008863884,
0.0033760222,
-0.0162160099,
0.0178740304,
0.0657765865,
-0.0454979092,
0.0726651847,
0.0187278874,
0.0420734249,
0.0386990532,
0.0367509127,
-0.0488288663,
0.0021192173,
-0.0012750729,
0.0178070869,
-0.0272208918,
-0.0450676605,
-0.0138697429,
0.0618987828,
-0.0057826666,
-0.008089371,
-0.0286121909,
0.0405988134,
-0.0395571105,
-0.0646708682,
-0.0213934127,
-0.0916337594,
0.0095664216,
0.0463085398,
-0.043212425,
-0.0642780513,
0.1139770746,
0.0199526697,
0.0317511223,
-0.0206099488,
-0.0223677848,
-0.040697854,
0.0783746466,
-0.0285941288,
0.049145069,
0.0310294125,
-0.0078201676,
-0.0136940349,
-0.0296675302,
0.0515095368,
-0.0110749248,
0.0587851033,
-0.0714612827,
-0.0053484342,
0.0307842847,
-0.0534540229,
-0.0340377949,
-0.0485029183,
-0.0353020988,
-0.0153506454,
-0.020610515,
0.0097375633,
0.008622651,
0.0011470198,
0.0369099528,
-0.0190193877,
0.0180488024,
0.0080223316,
-0.0287364889,
-0.0408724956,
0.013093926,
-0.0107820015,
0.0637703538,
0.0224235728,
0.0244707782,
0.0336872935,
-0.0044492874,
0.0155343106,
-0.024878988,
0.055754222,
-0.0203988813,
-0.0193317793,
0.0263107978,
0.0151653662,
0.0098986384,
-0.0656380579,
-0.0099701174,
0.0904853716,
0.0082855858,
-0.0256780591,
0.0355536155,
-0.0300758202,
-0.030757308,
0.0015734517,
0.0149514582,
-0.0970301926,
-0.0220604222,
0.0145559488,
-0.0105805527,
-0.0436913408,
-0.0446219333,
-0.0145823266,
-0.0973766148,
0.0252408832,
0.0218933094,
-0.0455319434,
0.0125351408,
-0.0684267431,
-0.0039967224,
-0.0161170997,
0.0180189349,
0.0144222463,
0.0087326728,
-0.0218157191,
-0.0032396305,
0.0226516016,
0.0098908078,
0.0519912951,
-0.0474530421,
0.0378338806,
0.0302908812,
0.033592198,
-0.0141827874,
-0.0271938965,
0.0201952402,
-0.0005000317,
0.0071076266,
-0.0054797996,
0.006628905,
-0.0104610361,
0.0077292258,
-0.062603943,
0.040679317,
-0.0106040118,
-0.0722346306,
-0.0076785111,
0.0847143456,
0.0133860819,
-0.0175340008,
-0.0041965377,
0.004695463,
-0.0033423509,
0.0717501268,
0.0225318465,
-0.0106907422,
-0.023234101,
-0.0350403748,
-0.061795231,
0.011849748,
-0.0141641451,
-0.0040685479,
0.0151029415,
-0.0032715132,
-0.0162511859,
-0.02000992,
0.0025717148,
0.0043581468,
0.0357153043,
-0.0207523927,
0.0271386653,
-0.0191032123,
-0.0150750075,
0.0319830775,
-0.0431907028,
0.0188591201,
0.0460643247,
0.0661732107,
-0.0326438732,
-0.0229480229,
-0.0057002753,
0.0401957221,
0.0062210066,
-0.0322828777,
-0.0098710842,
0.039309755,
0.0187506787,
0.0695685521,
-0.0307679102,
-0.004120369,
-0.0172819868,
0.0526982322,
-0.0240310933,
0.0039620162,
0.0409903042,
0.0058336523,
0.0208222251,
0.0315489247,
-0.0246587414,
-0.0142557025,
0.016720064,
0.0487165749,
-0.0423979275,
0.0008241945,
0.0606290027,
0.0262823012,
-0.0272315815,
-0.035781879,
-0.0225230753,
-0.0387865156,
-0.0139871798,
-0.0223851204,
-0.0472180247,
-0.02431974,
0.0396574549,
0.0478544496,
-0.0028963597,
-0.0261795241,
-0.0211116001,
-0.0004138688,
-0.0133659802,
-0.0010102422,
-0.0212835502,
0.0230504107,
0.0221376065,
-0.0263609085,
0.0074427528,
-0.036662478,
0.007617095,
-0.0247023683,
0.056395188,
-0.0240822472,
0.0702403039,
0.0624127723,
-0.0060955957,
-0.0539490841,
-0.0065159174,
-0.0467270128,
-0.020237362,
0.0258562025,
-0.0278738886,
-0.0074887048,
0.006395686,
0.0223814826,
0.0032983243,
-0.0065519502,
0.0396386832,
0.0402846411,
-0.0073894104,
-0.0618237741,
0.0206771903,
0.0116361855,
-0.0184577424,
-0.0017874925,
0.0242433771,
-0.0111309001,
0.0469395928,
0.014979166,
-0.0269416366,
0.004024507,
-0.0659072176,
0.001404649,
-0.0252049454,
-0.0144331129,
-0.0231074821,
-0.0723341703,
-0.0799066052,
-0.056627959,
0.0188209992,
0.0121392095,
-0.0229240078,
-0.0051341411,
0.0656720847,
0.0248515233,
-0.0739912987,
-0.0030327162,
0.0165253673,
-0.0084271245,
-0.0172639173,
-0.0499921739,
-5.44350826e-33,
-0.0158573445,
-0.0459448099,
0.0061584697,
-0.0079333745,
-0.0291804764,
-0.0168187078,
-0.0454818085,
-0.0318892486,
-0.0250580739,
0.0703429505,
0.0031794526,
0.0283634178,
0.0059543876,
-0.006811073,
-0.0081776856,
-0.0463915132,
-0.0015019329,
0.0389978625,
-0.0222859625,
0.0037414418,
0.0000646302,
-0.0055072773,
0.0370469242,
-0.0797507465,
0.0552909151,
0.0285796896,
-0.0154511128,
0.0528317466,
-0.0737137422,
0.0022359695,
0.0110427653,
0.0411769003,
0.0216783043,
-0.03208239,
0.0394245498,
0.0274879336,
-0.0484900773,
0.0099622365,
0.0935990587,
-0.0387331359,
-0.0549048968,
-0.062756218,
0.0522093065,
0.0116877379,
0.0006989953,
-0.0121797938,
0.0293183234,
-0.0298351031,
0.0101337684,
-0.022974018,
-0.0863720402,
-0.0245297626,
-0.0469496883,
-0.0201802421,
-0.0634004623,
0.0204154998,
-0.0393144153,
-0.0060635647,
-0.0198970605,
-0.0305222496,
0.0312365089,
-0.0751957148,
0.0819811076,
-0.0321874879,
0.0070666079,
0.0535017848,
-0.0174666084,
0.0088580064,
-0.0924474448,
-0.0014903203,
-0.0041742893,
0.0688321516,
0.0864730626,
0.0222523473,
0.0058641639,
0.0272403155,
-0.0666211098,
-0.022354804,
-0.0076300874,
0.0782535225,
0.0264965612,
-0.0086687272,
-0.0234520193,
-0.0332636163,
-0.0665284619,
-0.0342990607,
-0.0263993219,
-0.0336564295,
0.0200239457,
-0.0081450809,
-0.0492145009,
-0.0056677368,
-0.0123258345,
-0.0823208764,
0.0277442709,
0.0329656713,
0.0551994108,
-0.03278023,
0.0138177378,
0.0393346436,
-0.0227679107,
0.0104506044,
-0.0008036396,
0.0107552288,
0.0546860918,
-0.0293875076,
0.0641255453,
0.0142333219,
0.0227473937,
0.0278522,
-0.0687663332,
-0.0003342832,
0.0084364181,
-0.0136227543,
0.0318146907,
0.0436431579,
-0.0273173917,
-0.0182319582,
0.0401328877,
0.0129999761,
-0.0265804399,
0.0401950479,
-0.0266751684,
0.0159636177,
-0.0118818153,
-0.0012484565,
-0.0326329134,
0.018295655,
0.0524709299,
-0.0676861554,
-0.0148543082,
0.0365071073,
2.658e-7,
0.027692901,
0.0133486185,
0.0359361619,
-0.0046437508,
-0.0113774315,
0.0372723937,
0.0219738465,
0.0089476714,
0.0086982111,
-0.0727614909,
-0.0001643352,
0.0905787125,
0.0548259281,
0.0160483811,
0.0311668832,
-0.0127852419,
-0.0655361414,
-0.034743581,
-0.0659417734,
0.0361650735,
0.0255697761,
0.0418911725,
0.0650300682,
-0.0216900986,
-0.0011815907,
-0.034097787,
0.0606085211,
-0.0427352861,
0.0071008746,
-0.0141496677,
0.0091150999,
-0.0357466377,
0.0481244847,
-0.0089791454,
0.053193409,
-0.0030525078,
-0.0117477402,
0.0469196923,
-0.0357363001,
0.0052945996,
-0.0717429221,
-0.074044846,
0.0093705701,
-0.0775866359,
0.0593127273,
-0.0499025434,
-0.0273456201,
-0.0240109582,
0.0119728176,
-0.0362432227,
0.0093135154,
0.0212743953,
0.016818691,
0.0106633706,
-0.0036173239,
0.0074603651,
0.0136899147,
-0.0630611926,
-0.0575815216,
0.0043328679,
-0.0047074533,
0.0159880891,
0.0214877427,
0.0270467233,
0.0678630918,
-0.0810246319,
0.0224422831,
2.337048762e-34,
-0.0174764562,
-0.0232100058,
0.0348873846,
0.0362529568,
0.0697210282,
0.0537501313,
-0.0542074889,
0.0040452941,
0.0170565303,
-0.0260877162,
-0.0030360643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00744v1 | BATON: Aligning Text-to-Audio Model with Human Preference Feedback | 2024-02-01T16:39:47 | 2024-02-01T16:39:47 | Huan Liao, Haonan Han, Kai Yang, Tianjiao Du, Rui Yang, Zunnan Xu, Qinmei Xu, Jingquan Liu, Jiasheng Lu, Xiu Li | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | With the development of AI-Generated Content (AIGC), text-to-audio models are
gaining widespread attention. However, it is challenging for these models to
generate audio aligned with human preference due to the inherent information
density of natural language and limited model understanding ability. To
alleviate this issue, we formulate the BATON, a framework designed to enhance
the alignment between generated audio and text prompt using human preference
feedback. Our BATON comprises three key stages: Firstly, we curated a dataset
containing both prompts and the corresponding generated audio, which was then
annotated based on human feedback. Secondly, we introduced a reward model using
the constructed dataset, which can mimic human preference by assigning rewards
to input text-audio pairs. Finally, we employed the reward model to fine-tune
an off-the-shelf text-to-audio model. The experiment results demonstrate that
our BATON can significantly improve the generation quality of the original
text-to-audio models, concerning audio integrity, temporal relationship, and
alignment with human preference. | BATON: Aligning Text-to-Audio Model with Human Preference Feedback: With the development of AI-Generated Content (AIGC), text-to-audio models are
gaining widespread attention. However, it is challenging for these models to
generate audio aligned with human preference due to the inherent information
density of natural language and limited model understanding ability. To
alleviate this issue, we formulate the BATON, a framework designed to enhance
the alignment between generated audio and text prompt using human preference
feedback. Our BATON comprises three key stages: Firstly, we curated a dataset
containing both prompts and the corresponding generated audio, which was then
annotated based on human feedback. Secondly, we introduced a reward model using
the constructed dataset, which can mimic human preference by assigning rewards
to input text-audio pairs. Finally, we employed the reward model to fine-tune
an off-the-shelf text-to-audio model. The experiment results demonstrate that
our BATON can significantly improve the generation quality of the original
text-to-audio models, concerning audio integrity, temporal relationship, and
alignment with human preference. | [
0.0157685783,
-0.0056441003,
-0.0053438474,
-0.0143731991,
-0.020860523,
-0.0237833839,
-0.0049972525,
-0.027807124,
-0.0480917357,
0.0182872284,
-0.0677661151,
0.0129910214,
0.0214358997,
0.0402945988,
0.0027230105,
-0.1175362021,
0.0042964979,
-0.0468778051,
0.0178685356,
0.0204317421,
0.0141128134,
0.0309060756,
-0.0322696231,
0.0262941048,
-0.0390728489,
-0.0300927442,
-0.0161360968,
0.0460698269,
0.0253886245,
-0.0245567132,
-0.0461642034,
0.0509611666,
-0.0038513707,
0.011188875,
0.000001592,
-0.0415719785,
0.01692467,
0.0171985254,
-0.0132998545,
-0.0100941826,
0.0284379143,
0.0629008561,
-0.0605764948,
0.0269784294,
-0.0043558208,
0.0550826266,
0.0575341545,
0.0280956998,
0.0491924994,
0.0419542491,
-0.0118699102,
-0.0088305324,
-0.0012707581,
-0.0248982161,
0.0303216726,
0.0223732851,
-0.0350397415,
-0.0169275645,
0.0697663501,
0.0235671867,
0.0356732495,
0.0345482342,
0.02153695,
-0.0105521465,
0.0507315286,
0.0530143529,
-0.0180649851,
-0.0213058498,
-0.0374807045,
0.0754664838,
0.0268166568,
-0.0153370127,
-0.0173128024,
-0.0171406083,
0.0470371172,
-0.0123836808,
-0.0266047698,
-0.0114897303,
-0.0188890249,
0.0064112721,
-0.0514767244,
0.0337088667,
0.0336637422,
-0.0385741033,
0.0552033819,
-0.0030383952,
0.0311444234,
-0.035060443,
-0.0013088357,
-0.0058130021,
-0.0151073709,
-0.0526138321,
0.0564152226,
0.0101505686,
-0.0287861079,
-0.0302399378,
-0.0621703118,
-0.0054264218,
-0.0281603746,
-0.0077442382,
0.0608825982,
0.0401230976,
-0.0472412109,
0.0517592914,
-0.0053900294,
0.031843327,
-0.0184013732,
-0.0029476574,
-0.0237675607,
0.0201030802,
-0.0053052288,
-0.0235741939,
-0.0163332801,
-0.0089277271,
-0.0421700813,
-0.0409450196,
-0.0239986833,
-0.0134295514,
-0.044695437,
0.0603924729,
0.0270715449,
0.0482296646,
-0.0410912819,
0.0068417331,
-0.0275512766,
-0.0109191919,
-0.0324145779,
0.067538999,
0.0567916408,
0.0110442583,
0.0042002918,
-0.0025702079,
0.0175564457,
-0.0066266963,
0.0161150433,
0.0618220419,
-0.0172879081,
0.0091933245,
-0.0042731003,
-0.0310409907,
-0.0391658507,
0.0165740568,
-0.0678475797,
-0.0668566599,
0.0471878685,
-0.0190730281,
-0.0360145234,
-0.0196207166,
-0.0108592333,
0.0236862004,
0.0005350088,
0.0638270527,
-0.01191145,
0.0552981719,
0.0448759496,
-0.0079542529,
-0.025130799,
-0.0039320178,
0.0920167267,
0.0554346777,
0.0207856651,
-0.0010525279,
-0.0089100916,
0.0588534251,
-0.0027716055,
-0.0191585459,
-0.0302034859,
-0.011108065,
-0.0098232534,
0.072025843,
0.0403512456,
0.0539656132,
0.0016449369,
-0.0068063037,
0.1033102944,
0.030038964,
0.0160459634,
-0.0344334617,
0.0432335436,
0.0130630592,
-0.0128344307,
0.0258000176,
0.0184398033,
0.0495591052,
0.0100358641,
0.0447955392,
0.0521757342,
0.0159396399,
-0.0152193094,
-0.03950895,
-0.0018485596,
-0.0164870489,
-0.0055661574,
-0.0027216563,
-0.0057670348,
0.0341941603,
-0.0598610789,
-0.019368602,
-0.0143321035,
-0.0645405203,
0.037164744,
-0.0148630012,
0.0809118748,
0.1286528111,
0.0430936962,
-0.0271679014,
0.0529688969,
-0.0349664837,
-0.0158096626,
0.0702003911,
0.007607142,
-0.042139288,
-0.0188584495,
-0.0272090584,
-0.0281106513,
-0.0045753834,
-0.0340556428,
0.0272706579,
-0.0192957018,
0.0183516815,
0.0111075733,
0.0207313169,
0.0000305336,
0.0082121985,
-0.0028164068,
-0.0481036119,
0.001654105,
0.0278586969,
0.0438350849,
0.0557230897,
-0.0297835078,
0.0268833414,
0.0209869705,
0.0134331407,
0.0177786257,
0.046591673,
-0.0680672079,
0.0283942148,
0.0336788334,
-0.0478985012,
0.0326972902,
0.0173728168,
0.0234946422,
-0.0525357127,
-0.018500613,
-0.0076042176,
0.0305454098,
-0.0145994816,
0.037686877,
0.0204416122,
-0.0253786817,
-0.0037646249,
-0.002861066,
0.0274410527,
-0.0318928808,
0.0206636786,
0.0308609195,
-0.0047379318,
-0.0603374243,
-0.0015224698,
0.0484680496,
-0.0110984379,
0.0054183011,
0.0321413465,
-0.0246145539,
-0.0617585927,
-0.0454012044,
-0.0462856591,
-0.0102044484,
0.0163086895,
-0.0138042243,
0.0095315566,
-0.0006762731,
-0.0260262042,
-0.0139113395,
-0.0393516161,
-0.0658615977,
0.017361626,
-0.0114371385,
-0.0218829755,
-0.0098973438,
0.0115164034,
-0.0564808473,
0.0242677797,
0.0133592365,
-0.0330219232,
0.0093386574,
0.0103881089,
-0.0356031694,
0.0007254336,
-0.0134569984,
-0.0079198256,
0.031890437,
0.0150570031,
0.0390187427,
0.0267073698,
0.0999782607,
0.0595812351,
0.0115782591,
0.0217673536,
0.0342345759,
0.005881208,
-0.0660849512,
0.0188684314,
-0.0096312398,
0.0308695156,
-0.002197179,
0.0089868158,
0.0093689095,
0.0292406362,
0.0751020759,
0.0507115237,
-0.0482710078,
0.010372485,
-0.0126017742,
-0.01638937,
-0.0243571997,
-0.069565095,
-0.0522142164,
0.0478392541,
-0.0390079431,
-0.0526297577,
0.0630755648,
-0.068454653,
-0.0080111418,
-0.020436503,
-0.0197826177,
-0.0067469599,
0.0378655829,
-0.0515451431,
0.0129670324,
0.026575014,
-0.0020534028,
-0.0510467142,
0.0020480233,
0.054119233,
-0.0584337041,
-0.0081141219,
-0.0099162413,
-0.0181588642,
0.0109308772,
-0.0350750275,
-0.0278583616,
-0.0208127052,
-0.0127228722,
-0.0018817654,
0.0046294271,
-0.0183614846,
0.0060057174,
0.0176047068,
0.0262375809,
0.0296591576,
-0.0159897357,
-0.003798729,
-0.0336452983,
0.0543582588,
0.0503216498,
-0.0081789671,
-0.0459876657,
-0.0300615523,
0.016406266,
-0.0226491746,
0.0300047752,
-0.0032995711,
-0.0350424498,
-0.0053946399,
0.0254091714,
0.0049220761,
-0.0111600496,
0.0514924154,
0.0241949074,
-0.0320538953,
0.0136161232,
0.0972068682,
0.042652946,
-0.0088646431,
0.0059210104,
0.0061967978,
0.0460753925,
0.0035492121,
0.0075831977,
-0.0583938099,
-0.0170800779,
0.0431817137,
0.0655120835,
0.0362351425,
0.0423921682,
0.0096103149,
-0.0880117714,
0.0420761183,
0.0164219588,
-0.0065547898,
-0.0129872654,
-0.0213621743,
-0.0100942636,
0.0141489226,
-0.003828339,
0.0115373228,
-0.0078007895,
0.0112520279,
0.0448107198,
0.0092963735,
-0.0313055404,
-0.0082168039,
-0.029411925,
0.0952469856,
0.1301376522,
0.0589488335,
-0.004728741,
-0.0398934186,
-0.060660731,
0.0321639702,
0.0080655664,
0.0291787777,
0.0218851473,
0.0148971444,
0.0036296209,
-0.002802287,
0.0644363016,
0.0227437094,
-0.0179895591,
0.0383116007,
0.0298270825,
-0.0083475094,
0.010932371,
-0.0690360293,
0.0341094695,
0.0298470333,
0.058704704,
0.0266233478,
-0.0564846359,
0.0083047831,
-0.0273587145,
0.0051492271,
-0.0932426527,
-0.0127307046,
-0.0031236731,
-0.0020208871,
-0.0357914828,
-0.0739390105,
-0.0231418498,
-0.0227493551,
0.0194827728,
0.0423216783,
0.0001978512,
-0.026870247,
-0.0047895447,
-0.0574131757,
0.0280676857,
0.0135296732,
0.0579886734,
-0.060139928,
-0.048717726,
0.0042741871,
-0.091974996,
-0.0074535632,
0.0329792276,
-0.0227272492,
-0.0439530946,
-0.0191856548,
0.028183084,
0.0251744017,
0.0708937272,
-0.0085583217,
-0.0201037638,
0.0262177084,
0.0431777574,
-0.0563771389,
0.0063838619,
0.0127284974,
0.0344696902,
0.0039898469,
-0.0201680325,
-0.0620468594,
0.0201096572,
0.014022748,
0.0247556698,
0.0485079102,
-0.0681109577,
0.022452699,
-0.0080226762,
-0.0053971857,
-0.0473832935,
0.021206297,
-0.0497658662,
-0.0102851093,
-0.01066468,
-0.006307459,
-0.0409015678,
-0.0018999571,
0.0221088845,
0.0083118174,
-0.0340173915,
-0.0352090448,
-0.0242908932,
0.0069214297,
-0.068464525,
-0.0052212686,
0.0131508233,
0.004076764,
0.0270748362,
-0.0086811697,
0.0363947898,
0.0196663272,
-0.0094474936,
0.0284805857,
0.0327882692,
0.0362922736,
0.0164648257,
-0.0118521908,
0.0189015567,
0.053028699,
-0.0272809193,
0.0278619491,
-0.0472289883,
-0.0097705824,
0.0369598456,
-0.02874122,
0.0299790781,
0.0042827697,
0.0083266227,
-0.0047487887,
0.0266220327,
-0.0145404749,
-0.0386527851,
-0.0158682559,
0.0036673134,
-0.00117306,
-0.0180242155,
0.0239917524,
-0.0675971732,
-0.0073890472,
-0.0549965613,
-0.0109874997,
-0.0259437542,
-0.0103064412,
-0.0182701461,
0.0160024241,
-0.0252928361,
-0.0169306528,
-0.0421655066,
-0.06220356,
0.0223387722,
0.0359133407,
0.0187535305,
-0.0030389973,
0.0624189265,
0.0113770831,
-0.0443837494,
0.0297567639,
0.0200984553,
-0.0551224761,
-0.0502704531,
-0.0485011451,
-0.0441552848,
-4.638447076e-33,
-0.0519117713,
-0.026663864,
-0.0094700679,
0.0288943723,
-0.0203641113,
-0.0294386167,
-0.043292772,
-0.0050069392,
0.0413603336,
-0.0109031694,
-0.0104657728,
-0.0278622732,
0.0155160865,
0.0168029945,
0.0172267314,
0.0100268247,
0.0721216053,
-0.027939111,
-0.0645770505,
0.0319622718,
0.0410676375,
0.0064491522,
-0.0222652741,
-0.0897001028,
0.0115077738,
0.0007092726,
-0.0560504049,
-0.0323676132,
0.0071914983,
0.071540229,
0.0138130775,
0.0257692952,
-0.0351324975,
-0.0184212998,
0.0060666609,
0.0606356412,
-0.0469405018,
-0.0094141532,
0.0099192252,
0.0057817632,
-0.0171783566,
-0.045107659,
0.0121856378,
-0.0112486081,
-0.0415014774,
0.0192304943,
0.0631852299,
-0.0237259772,
0.0097895144,
-0.0500659011,
-0.0676552653,
-0.0052269367,
-0.0619095936,
-0.0733063221,
0.0208798088,
0.0648080334,
0.0012676016,
0.0149895465,
-0.0589802749,
0.0713394061,
0.0189954992,
0.0092936363,
0.0667298213,
0.0129494928,
-0.020227991,
0.0569713376,
0.0197950695,
-0.0576223508,
-0.0275566503,
0.0396808535,
-0.0189697836,
0.0361705013,
0.0312248394,
0.0140738245,
-0.0105127981,
-0.0338727348,
0.0367261842,
0.0775670335,
-0.016713053,
-0.0358648263,
0.0128198387,
0.0462992564,
-0.0556442216,
0.0240297839,
-0.058211308,
-0.0367169194,
-0.0342757441,
-0.0601080507,
0.0490611456,
-0.0210291948,
0.0082940459,
-0.0372184291,
-0.0052496716,
0.0093219094,
0.0209635496,
-0.022651732,
-0.0681816265,
0.045295734,
-0.0076500541,
-0.0314868949,
-0.011159692,
0.0103773698,
0.1083453223,
0.016004242,
0.0250732694,
0.02148984,
-0.0001751387,
0.0638932884,
-0.056868583,
0.0149466982,
0.0118900007,
0.0297499262,
0.0074117193,
-0.0250507742,
0.0188249685,
-0.000707854,
-0.0486780442,
0.0215448868,
-0.0176652297,
-0.0014324263,
-0.0366250314,
-0.0642818063,
-0.0372838341,
-0.0186657291,
-0.0256604347,
0.013794315,
-0.001345994,
-0.0157606397,
0.0100963488,
-0.0130087333,
-0.0315320157,
0.0120700505,
2.357e-7,
-0.029277347,
-0.0037534952,
0.0277677327,
0.0137296431,
0.0300034396,
0.0290071424,
-0.0290876366,
0.0060612061,
0.0182978809,
-0.0006346906,
0.0286890157,
-0.0221579093,
0.0834223181,
0.0008690834,
-0.1024439707,
0.0103602502,
-0.1018913239,
0.0326124243,
-0.0283284802,
0.0116748577,
0.0780562311,
0.0426751748,
0.0359568521,
-0.0147460401,
0.0155250812,
0.0351651721,
0.0092878975,
-0.0313483886,
0.0304769315,
-0.0558383167,
0.0173794311,
-0.0548320487,
-0.0532965586,
-0.0191586241,
-0.0431375429,
0.0078240978,
0.0578064173,
0.0388314128,
-0.0042119441,
-0.0515138879,
-0.0466399118,
0.0396928266,
0.0140493559,
-0.0350375958,
0.0340389684,
0.0120927896,
-0.0036453318,
-0.0348410979,
-0.0618379414,
-0.0125546288,
-0.0249066465,
-0.0340816006,
-0.012968529,
-0.0407148898,
0.0201025214,
0.047274109,
-0.0089390101,
-0.0163063593,
-0.022808427,
0.0056474516,
-0.0342243239,
-0.0218484979,
-0.0613212921,
0.0285577849,
-0.0238935333,
-0.0794889331,
-0.0065102219,
1.660954921e-34,
0.0080262935,
-0.0409522951,
0.028911164,
-0.0270646028,
0.0266480278,
0.0283209737,
0.0573649518,
0.0163758248,
0.0295999367,
-0.0274805799,
-0.0593850128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00743v2 | Theoretical Understanding of In-Context Learning in Shallow Transformers with Unstructured Data | 2024-02-01T16:39:45 | 2024-06-18T13:11:32 | Yue Xing, Xiaofeng Lin, Chenheng Xu, Namjoon Suh, Qifan Song, Guang Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Large language models (LLMs) are powerful models that can learn concepts at
the inference stage via in-context learning (ICL). While theoretical studies,
e.g., \cite{zhang2023trained}, attempt to explain the mechanism of ICL, they
assume the input $x_i$ and the output $y_i$ of each demonstration example are
in the same token (i.e., structured data). However, in real practice, the
examples are usually text input, and all words, regardless of their logic
relationship, are stored in different tokens (i.e., unstructured data
\cite{wibisono2023role}). To understand how LLMs learn from the unstructured
data in ICL, this paper studies the role of each component in the transformer
architecture and provides a theoretical understanding to explain the success of
the architecture. In particular, we consider a simple transformer with one/two
attention layers and linear regression tasks for the ICL prediction. We observe
that (1) a transformer with two layers of (self-)attentions with a look-ahead
attention mask can learn from the prompt in the unstructured data, and (2)
positional encoding can match the $x_i$ and $y_i$ tokens to achieve a better
ICL performance. | Theoretical Understanding of In-Context Learning in Shallow Transformers with Unstructured Data: Large language models (LLMs) are powerful models that can learn concepts at
the inference stage via in-context learning (ICL). While theoretical studies,
e.g., \cite{zhang2023trained}, attempt to explain the mechanism of ICL, they
assume the input $x_i$ and the output $y_i$ of each demonstration example are
in the same token (i.e., structured data). However, in real practice, the
examples are usually text input, and all words, regardless of their logic
relationship, are stored in different tokens (i.e., unstructured data
\cite{wibisono2023role}). To understand how LLMs learn from the unstructured
data in ICL, this paper studies the role of each component in the transformer
architecture and provides a theoretical understanding to explain the success of
the architecture. In particular, we consider a simple transformer with one/two
attention layers and linear regression tasks for the ICL prediction. We observe
that (1) a transformer with two layers of (self-)attentions with a look-ahead
attention mask can learn from the prompt in the unstructured data, and (2)
positional encoding can match the $x_i$ and $y_i$ tokens to achieve a better
ICL performance. | [
0.0126974564,
0.0302695297,
-0.009469769,
0.0434493236,
-0.0260804966,
0.0123852622,
0.0185880214,
-0.0082319453,
-0.0288999211,
-0.0637990013,
-0.0694711581,
-0.0228743888,
0.0342610553,
0.0113156177,
0.0434300415,
-0.024324201,
0.038275443,
-0.0486330539,
-0.0065551563,
0.0052705454,
-0.0219437778,
-0.0349338315,
0.0359612368,
0.0257010534,
-0.0124008069,
-0.0178156551,
-0.0248174313,
0.0026614098,
-0.0451773964,
-0.0160904173,
0.0065667122,
0.0252283644,
0.0241886806,
0.0506239682,
0.0000019704,
-0.0288833007,
-0.0233686082,
-0.0137941511,
-0.0295098945,
-0.0458195545,
0.0002963906,
-0.0640803054,
-0.0091113737,
-0.0043990351,
-0.0348200202,
-0.0337690972,
0.0640259609,
0.0938731208,
0.054109212,
0.090990074,
-0.0269100163,
-0.0428246073,
0.0273599494,
-0.040174529,
0.0019139101,
-0.0199546982,
0.0362966992,
-0.0653823614,
-0.0307926089,
0.0367625393,
-0.0485124104,
0.0475737974,
0.0269197784,
0.0353165977,
-0.0049185273,
0.0572247207,
-0.0558106117,
-0.0280285589,
-0.0295700803,
0.0322909988,
-0.0614865907,
-0.0309900995,
-0.0264784042,
0.0041750427,
0.0157755017,
-0.0315704681,
-0.0353227481,
0.045618806,
-0.0129589932,
0.0302632954,
0.0250560269,
0.0120234415,
0.0270709954,
-0.0162826423,
-0.0632800609,
0.0870967507,
-0.0038803637,
-0.0701671541,
-0.007932933,
-0.0019371992,
-0.0070136287,
-0.0541089699,
-0.0029352487,
0.0447209626,
-0.0421026349,
0.0406627432,
-0.046697557,
-0.037897151,
-0.0212543756,
-0.0318364538,
0.0321319811,
0.0329745747,
-0.0203475989,
0.043576818,
-0.0470659994,
0.0809574425,
-0.0419587158,
0.0575788803,
-0.0250322688,
-0.020111192,
0.0065346011,
-0.0224822424,
-0.0618949048,
0.03248927,
-0.0447526835,
-0.0128171248,
0.0081401737,
0.0508662723,
-0.0216762666,
0.0006563043,
0.0106557375,
-0.0044717416,
-0.0724365115,
-0.0025691856,
-0.0235548113,
0.0306991395,
0.0162153877,
0.0228025503,
0.011250928,
-0.065213941,
-0.0235000849,
0.0186837185,
0.0397107713,
-0.0327014662,
0.0023795476,
0.0774075314,
-0.0278671943,
-0.0482588783,
-0.0427921228,
-0.0009525867,
-0.0113779046,
-0.0542562343,
0.0421126671,
-0.0600152425,
0.0188475307,
0.0349629931,
-0.0028317154,
-0.0382344946,
-0.0055017178,
0.0556276441,
-0.0398140326,
0.0746311694,
0.0349769406,
-0.0129882451,
-0.0129465004,
-0.0082458789,
-0.0068209409,
0.0471356027,
-0.0053803525,
0.0248267725,
0.0021192087,
-0.0202695336,
0.0007061816,
0.0376332439,
0.0307160504,
-0.0018376034,
-0.0321015976,
0.021084277,
-0.0046519856,
0.0263542645,
0.0293617547,
0.0747892186,
-0.0094369277,
0.0007006066,
0.0688853934,
0.0545448661,
0.0442353375,
0.0488850847,
0.0202945583,
0.0008771957,
-0.0096150627,
0.0473097749,
-0.0691590905,
0.0136094997,
0.0007947225,
0.0037112064,
-0.0022264803,
-0.0086903367,
-0.05272891,
-0.0377998613,
-0.0050476426,
-0.0146599384,
-0.0019432311,
-0.0078809876,
0.0543220565,
0.0590478852,
-0.0754836351,
0.088913098,
0.0136840288,
0.0007968455,
-0.0063620973,
-0.0470847078,
0.0076048002,
-0.0134163322,
0.0051735095,
-0.0214148872,
-0.0281247627,
-0.0058004344,
-0.0018165827,
0.0428289473,
-0.0136383092,
-0.001886863,
-0.0194937978,
-0.0124668097,
-0.019430453,
-0.0030931951,
-0.0086678034,
0.0019544102,
0.0046301465,
-0.0311755575,
-0.0070273438,
-0.0079307565,
0.014982109,
0.0405971184,
-0.0209483616,
-0.0433215015,
-0.0107291956,
0.0210100207,
0.0456984229,
-0.0196997672,
0.0239577424,
0.0238206927,
0.0526454113,
-0.027940331,
-0.0072994046,
0.0028974507,
-0.1035549492,
-0.0397831872,
0.0095513733,
-0.0407319479,
-0.0128688235,
0.0365970582,
-0.0071539078,
-0.0402336977,
0.0045832694,
-0.0527837239,
0.0711211786,
-0.0059404843,
0.0142496666,
0.0138534922,
0.0329377204,
-0.0475181378,
0.0797711834,
-0.0085841669,
0.0159695875,
0.0278053731,
0.0252850428,
-0.0125540998,
-0.0096415449,
-0.0243521184,
-0.0147437155,
-0.0370948762,
-0.009478203,
-0.0142606795,
-0.0262146275,
-0.0367504545,
-0.0357902944,
-0.0495995767,
-0.0286570229,
-0.0359718055,
-0.0039866087,
0.0176541451,
0.004045492,
0.0152470479,
-0.0263363756,
-0.0339624062,
0.0040165884,
0.0220380016,
0.0249063522,
0.0357878394,
0.0138872294,
-0.003538212,
-0.0082511427,
-0.0218370762,
-0.0223591626,
0.0660025701,
-0.0014167078,
-0.0416273773,
-0.0867690518,
0.0290306453,
0.0433662981,
0.0569975674,
-0.0341326445,
-0.0172598194,
0.0105023906,
0.0008133792,
0.0764742196,
0.0890052319,
0.0087158075,
0.0345450118,
0.0259106513,
-0.0103712641,
-0.03999817,
0.025503708,
-0.037404675,
-0.0024893431,
-0.0789853856,
0.0210923087,
0.0377278738,
0.0879219323,
-0.003769869,
-0.0022159149,
-0.0393580347,
0.011003416,
0.0115827238,
-0.0257144272,
-0.0118951043,
-0.0251302905,
-0.0286701173,
0.0255425554,
-0.0109478952,
-0.0481273085,
0.0370967053,
-0.0422850326,
-0.0323171355,
-0.0412154719,
0.0068629058,
-0.03912092,
0.0281136222,
0.0177039392,
0.0066713528,
-0.0024543179,
-0.0363660119,
-0.0852917284,
0.0265614502,
-0.0299203526,
0.0044939164,
0.0847994983,
0.0142570324,
-0.0071166647,
-0.0209558494,
-0.025634272,
-0.0703076422,
-0.0305668749,
-0.0252433326,
0.0232665539,
0.0371631309,
-0.0017078249,
-0.0452355593,
0.0218139365,
0.0293253493,
0.0502407923,
-0.0136190401,
-0.024884142,
-0.0379634686,
0.0271779373,
0.0225946438,
0.0262458678,
0.0379221179,
-0.0189889986,
0.0042619566,
0.0573702008,
0.0408017114,
-0.0043051103,
-0.0203721654,
0.0122844074,
0.0549151823,
-0.0127780754,
-0.0064529702,
0.0273372401,
0.0320381783,
-0.0490774438,
-0.0540779941,
0.1091117486,
-0.0070697013,
-0.0707618445,
0.0020379839,
-0.0034782554,
-0.0001526827,
0.0330330022,
0.0209313743,
-0.0311210975,
-0.0188261271,
0.0121446261,
-0.0046400856,
0.0067766178,
-0.0046681543,
-0.0004407232,
-0.1087072715,
0.0157561246,
-0.0158923957,
-0.0624198392,
-0.0704604909,
-0.0372244231,
0.0055663292,
0.0226753987,
0.0411025658,
0.0184870809,
-0.0448119715,
-0.0417256579,
0.011635826,
-0.0003657844,
-0.0298237279,
0.0213442873,
-0.0229925942,
0.0122677442,
0.0576929599,
0.0150537128,
-0.0300875343,
-0.0664223582,
0.036495246,
0.0029534569,
0.0114162983,
-0.006221089,
0.0297274273,
-0.0256063621,
-0.0075311554,
0.0017426059,
0.0349126309,
-0.0383732207,
-0.0029553457,
-0.0408509746,
0.088236779,
-0.0121332742,
-0.0303122997,
-0.0033678161,
-0.0298800766,
-0.0071639512,
0.0723718926,
0.027101852,
-0.0282995403,
-0.0432815626,
-0.0061508846,
0.0273340251,
0.0069747437,
-0.0231491383,
0.0386645049,
-0.0030096513,
-0.027563408,
-0.0519830957,
-0.0221631359,
0.0142119806,
0.0455421358,
0.0031204922,
-0.0097917309,
0.0337558351,
-0.0006780622,
-0.0281244852,
0.027733,
-0.0188312586,
0.0085916808,
-0.0626046881,
-0.0006653928,
0.0279171672,
-0.0435189977,
-0.0255521424,
-0.0080088759,
-0.0855185241,
-0.0251881089,
0.0387865752,
0.0352323651,
0.0183482375,
0.0935161784,
-0.0104550505,
-0.0163298696,
0.0885516182,
0.0209464971,
-0.0224059131,
0.0178930834,
0.0494649448,
-0.0093232412,
0.0052063526,
0.0428523123,
-0.0384537578,
0.0194595139,
0.0503378734,
0.0118105663,
-0.0044658836,
-0.009147902,
0.0529019125,
-0.0212099999,
0.0957012698,
0.0098189367,
0.0432413667,
-0.0028122757,
0.0371144526,
0.0163758509,
-0.0129874405,
-0.0428399369,
-0.0414785296,
0.011854264,
0.0232641548,
0.006339604,
0.0122239087,
0.009086147,
0.0187437646,
-0.0043872073,
0.0183675475,
0.0346925557,
-0.0046997839,
0.0267801397,
0.0304006655,
-0.018998282,
-0.0083207171,
0.018745074,
0.0428478643,
-0.006485254,
0.0464938954,
0.0387171395,
0.0009659117,
-0.0527071394,
0.0161618944,
-0.0889868662,
0.0106902234,
-0.0134177981,
-0.019503111,
0.0155156748,
-0.0618390553,
-0.0025262975,
-0.0150119355,
-0.0079720868,
-0.0099970186,
0.0100417575,
-0.0121757733,
-0.0289039146,
0.0535809509,
0.0090987924,
-0.0052114143,
-0.0195793509,
0.0767106339,
0.0124344667,
0.0075079426,
0.0093453005,
0.0094086658,
-0.0298143905,
-0.0035630709,
0.0326258093,
0.0133827394,
-0.0075568599,
-0.0058531198,
-0.0222511999,
-0.0579691455,
0.0301116873,
-0.0119800046,
0.0124315256,
-0.0481733382,
0.0349407792,
0.0750638247,
0.0296013653,
-0.0020493474,
-0.0000469464,
0.0184681583,
0.0466529056,
-0.0080835391,
-0.0384003334,
-6.324038385e-33,
-0.0281213876,
-0.0233593155,
0.0191643946,
0.0181086678,
0.0003596052,
0.0237829462,
-0.0367139727,
-0.0184337199,
-0.0237745158,
-0.0047772364,
-0.049975846,
0.0056439023,
0.0112266997,
0.0520462543,
-0.0000466333,
-0.029836718,
0.0304230638,
0.0035609491,
-0.0100359721,
0.0045334511,
0.0226354003,
0.0126586175,
0.0760124847,
-0.0367446467,
-0.0045572775,
-0.0273257289,
0.0141802607,
0.0422861613,
-0.0199062023,
0.0609420761,
-0.0201700497,
0.0290976241,
0.0386160053,
-0.0666089132,
-0.0329963341,
0.0871572047,
-0.1030636132,
-0.0189879816,
0.0024684833,
0.0491212867,
-0.0469105057,
-0.0096594058,
0.0882170051,
0.0012895567,
-0.002549802,
-0.0347955339,
0.0256996863,
0.0008669269,
-0.0345247388,
-0.0165684652,
-0.0683007911,
-0.0014637234,
0.0351497792,
-0.012140953,
0.0288889799,
0.0610170551,
0.0106549831,
0.0414523296,
-0.0836062208,
0.0048582507,
-0.0233589374,
0.0562063493,
0.0431821719,
0.0434115008,
-0.0051798387,
0.0462137908,
0.0348251946,
0.0116815818,
-0.0239879377,
-0.0514821708,
0.049270466,
0.0440101698,
0.0127709582,
0.0001493399,
0.051326856,
0.0105045177,
-0.0495549329,
-0.0235559978,
-0.0249448996,
0.0651972592,
0.0395969674,
-0.00115562,
-0.0186804123,
-0.0368775092,
-0.0198108405,
-0.0145719321,
-0.0289705712,
-0.0004279672,
0.0254991371,
0.0287498981,
0.0057015554,
0.0081649031,
0.0440464206,
-0.0446643941,
-0.0062293774,
0.0105674649,
0.0125654973,
0.0117369285,
-0.0022893592,
0.0281915087,
-0.0743365288,
-0.0384924486,
-0.0082621239,
0.0155777847,
0.0092303995,
0.030936949,
0.074885942,
0.0452434011,
-0.0582531132,
-0.0486618504,
-0.0467685685,
-0.0066816788,
-0.0209050775,
0.0179256089,
0.0542225689,
0.0279925819,
-0.026767388,
0.0149951642,
0.0092413994,
-0.0100314515,
-0.0313836262,
0.0291508883,
-0.0139265954,
0.0065342044,
-0.0109505728,
-0.033727359,
-0.063691169,
0.0254096519,
0.0469111949,
-0.0654332712,
-0.0055072536,
0.0265199151,
2.758e-7,
0.0351094939,
0.0380545296,
0.0429650955,
0.0075262901,
0.0501409806,
0.0297835954,
-0.020739574,
0.0429098532,
0.0325804763,
0.0032864173,
0.0061812983,
-0.0032867556,
-0.0035601221,
0.0219150726,
-0.0969532058,
-0.0184125137,
-0.0567942448,
0.0283343848,
-0.0070796004,
0.0213190597,
0.019332204,
0.1260453314,
-0.0171839651,
-0.0203698259,
-0.0154565191,
-0.0118339844,
0.052953437,
-0.005076481,
0.0495671071,
0.0165812429,
-0.0164480191,
0.0032633755,
0.0148909362,
0.036485102,
0.0103745433,
0.0317646265,
-0.0056190798,
0.0334001817,
-0.00203825,
-0.0466255806,
0.0045396262,
0.000718259,
-0.0226255301,
-0.0713343695,
0.0512022674,
-0.1312265992,
-0.0425269604,
-0.0300650559,
-0.012449489,
0.0189553369,
-0.0498594269,
0.033771418,
-0.0149286883,
0.0015261,
0.0223950949,
-0.006447149,
-0.00335727,
-0.0813732892,
-0.0341121927,
0.0065807318,
-0.0598810092,
-0.0301648397,
-0.0646177977,
-0.0006918337,
0.064886108,
-0.0137432329,
-0.0068700048,
2.621272046e-34,
-0.0095775342,
-0.0006134453,
0.0197911859,
0.0388992317,
-0.0143435989,
-0.0520108156,
0.0162718631,
0.0421288647,
0.0354608074,
-0.0687978268,
-0.0148974936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00742v1 | Transforming and Combining Rewards for Aligning Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T16:39:28 | 2024-02-01T16:39:28 | Zihao Wang, Chirag Nagpal, Jonathan Berant, Jacob Eisenstein, Alex D'Amour, Sanmi Koyejo, Victor Veitch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2 | A common approach for aligning language models to human preferences is to
first learn a reward model from preference data, and then use this reward model
to update the language model. We study two closely related problems that arise
in this approach. First, any monotone transformation of the reward model
preserves preference ranking; is there a choice that is ``better'' than others?
Second, we often wish to align language models to multiple properties: how
should we combine multiple reward models? Using a probabilistic interpretation
of the alignment procedure, we identify a natural choice for transformation for
(the common case of) rewards learned from Bradley-Terry preference models. This
derived transformation has two important properties. First, it emphasizes
improving poorly-performing outputs, rather than outputs that already score
well. This mitigates both underfitting (where some prompts are not improved)
and reward hacking (where the model learns to exploit misspecification of the
reward model). Second, it enables principled aggregation of rewards by linking
summation to logical conjunction: the sum of transformed rewards corresponds to
the probability that the output is ``good'' in all measured properties, in a
sense we make precise. Experiments aligning language models to be both helpful
and harmless using RLHF show substantial improvements over the baseline
(non-transformed) approach. | Transforming and Combining Rewards for Aligning Large Language Models: A common approach for aligning language models to human preferences is to
first learn a reward model from preference data, and then use this reward model
to update the language model. We study two closely related problems that arise
in this approach. First, any monotone transformation of the reward model
preserves preference ranking; is there a choice that is ``better'' than others?
Second, we often wish to align language models to multiple properties: how
should we combine multiple reward models? Using a probabilistic interpretation
of the alignment procedure, we identify a natural choice for transformation for
(the common case of) rewards learned from Bradley-Terry preference models. This
derived transformation has two important properties. First, it emphasizes
improving poorly-performing outputs, rather than outputs that already score
well. This mitigates both underfitting (where some prompts are not improved)
and reward hacking (where the model learns to exploit misspecification of the
reward model). Second, it enables principled aggregation of rewards by linking
summation to logical conjunction: the sum of transformed rewards corresponds to
the probability that the output is ``good'' in all measured properties, in a
sense we make precise. Experiments aligning language models to be both helpful
and harmless using RLHF show substantial improvements over the baseline
(non-transformed) approach. | [
0.0451663397,
0.0755147785,
0.0009661389,
-0.0080218008,
-0.0514567792,
0.0113260951,
-0.032021109,
-0.0093150856,
-0.0649641082,
-0.0183343906,
-0.0598041825,
-0.0078734141,
0.0251433551,
0.0013505514,
-0.0050270027,
-0.095349133,
0.0545339361,
-0.0354372486,
0.0082278494,
-0.0256153811,
-0.0052092723,
-0.0288366601,
0.004408895,
0.0261799637,
0.0519717894,
0.0047267382,
0.0301109627,
-0.0250748675,
0.0556785725,
-0.0013505172,
-0.0144997193,
0.0438702442,
0.0036074338,
0.0243037958,
0.0000019599,
-0.0762152374,
-0.0191036537,
-0.0210284218,
-0.0090321079,
0.0054541905,
0.0539129078,
0.0410377681,
-0.0119906198,
0.0218910761,
-0.0161559042,
0.0140316458,
0.042363409,
0.0126925735,
0.0062001403,
0.0290682018,
0.0193035044,
-0.0097326636,
-0.0092197573,
-0.0483560339,
0.0257005468,
-0.0108399745,
0.0058101416,
-0.0207346417,
0.0144756911,
0.0031764917,
-0.0152320787,
-0.0011362268,
-0.0077386689,
-0.0003673004,
0.0582448244,
0.048143588,
0.0020210643,
0.0054239174,
-0.0078745186,
0.0172372609,
-0.0201062821,
0.0095455339,
-0.0213254169,
-0.0114587834,
0.0366646051,
0.0080096107,
-0.0161972158,
0.003802761,
0.0283888392,
0.0284475591,
0.0607349314,
0.0214539692,
0.0276689492,
0.0241042562,
-0.0084855417,
0.1099936813,
0.0180516783,
-0.0546975136,
0.0037337102,
0.0318102241,
-0.0241219234,
-0.040882811,
-0.020033082,
-0.0115534561,
-0.0272835065,
0.0256288238,
0.0130774183,
0.0588929616,
-0.0000951554,
-0.0172574949,
0.0532556325,
0.0382525288,
-0.0110971974,
0.0317742303,
-0.0223840922,
0.0815740973,
-0.0150235435,
0.0373753496,
-0.0602360442,
0.0482070558,
-0.0082126483,
-0.0133692753,
0.028245097,
0.0365104415,
0.0019848002,
-0.0018735406,
-0.0939688981,
0.0186399464,
-0.0382692814,
0.0371728204,
0.0201565605,
0.0220154244,
-0.0571804121,
0.0091579659,
-0.0755235553,
0.0394247137,
-0.0113368984,
0.0229793601,
0.036148604,
0.0348116681,
0.0223797392,
-0.0147924963,
-0.0202958602,
-0.0375196375,
0.0013579157,
0.0775827467,
0.0063630883,
-0.0092096422,
0.025683796,
0.0060084225,
-0.0418255851,
-0.0096001411,
-0.0127090272,
-0.0798319802,
0.0135178203,
-0.0110396408,
-0.0009245816,
-0.0181933343,
-0.005222911,
-0.0319957696,
-0.0461162366,
0.0511803068,
0.040252097,
0.0150843104,
-0.0019821129,
-0.015841227,
-0.0305163711,
0.0362916663,
0.0386909358,
0.0601751804,
0.0292916559,
-0.033990059,
-0.0088722361,
0.0381007865,
-0.0098446188,
0.0281423591,
-0.0195088368,
-0.0078868372,
0.0381642729,
0.0341447219,
0.0588693582,
0.0261220299,
-0.0178128853,
0.0178505518,
0.0858631581,
0.0224519633,
0.0297223907,
-0.04891048,
-0.0275641214,
-0.0378644839,
-0.031584207,
0.044799272,
-0.0514436401,
0.0237820931,
-0.0310301278,
0.0152202277,
0.0278946515,
0.00970932,
-0.003023765,
-0.0388235562,
0.0051676542,
-0.018594997,
0.0555889755,
0.045263432,
0.073080115,
-0.0189917237,
-0.027194513,
-0.027990194,
0.064380534,
-0.0444035381,
0.0329731889,
-0.0739562213,
0.0385086574,
0.0758681968,
0.02853873,
-0.020817589,
0.0262358431,
-0.0274999868,
-0.0829773769,
0.0363057293,
0.054017406,
-0.0268102102,
-0.0164609589,
-0.0023696148,
-0.0363251083,
0.0175408274,
0.0160586927,
0.0346438065,
-0.00889978,
-0.0523489155,
-0.0287348814,
0.0399844125,
-0.0379779004,
0.0142580112,
0.0280062426,
0.0047884961,
0.0199030079,
0.0155678969,
0.0518988073,
-0.0160351917,
0.0103407856,
0.0270135533,
-0.0006092764,
-0.0101994565,
-0.0107982345,
0.0345822759,
-0.0272198413,
-0.0050793295,
0.0199020971,
0.0071662925,
0.0194984153,
0.0602452569,
0.0016250038,
-0.0114339208,
0.0061919773,
-0.0217928719,
0.0539306141,
0.0355913714,
0.0630757809,
-0.0313445032,
-0.0608325787,
-0.0802766234,
0.0638046265,
-0.0151530067,
0.0391743891,
-0.0481701531,
-0.0544898883,
-0.0162787698,
-0.0790712014,
-0.0220722128,
0.0193238202,
0.0035593736,
0.0382543057,
0.0718067437,
0.0000688771,
-0.033961907,
-0.0476713553,
-0.0158346295,
-0.0010341888,
0.0100223916,
0.0118468879,
0.0312484913,
-0.0058672857,
0.0148022659,
0.0049536191,
-0.0604430214,
-0.0163767654,
0.0415257774,
0.0433581434,
0.0283931196,
0.0168621708,
-0.0246109813,
-0.0618481338,
-0.0398363955,
-0.0277178753,
0.0034132632,
0.0037897474,
0.0406370461,
-0.0529132672,
0.0435148217,
-0.0469038635,
-0.0107163265,
-0.0118212737,
-0.0177779328,
0.0243790001,
0.0161924697,
0.0315591842,
0.1014969647,
0.0366199464,
0.0291318782,
0.0752919242,
0.010683707,
-0.0813051537,
-0.0227612909,
-0.0593864545,
-0.0490812585,
-0.0193764977,
-0.0710714832,
-0.0035068053,
0.0588699542,
0.0200300682,
-0.0042936895,
-0.0569467433,
0.0188704319,
-0.0399863981,
-0.0459704585,
-0.05938356,
-0.0297491215,
-0.0317725725,
0.0580854341,
-0.0367765278,
-0.0733292624,
0.0579028018,
0.0056166695,
0.0357842147,
-0.0523350015,
-0.0059154341,
-0.0129217487,
0.0002114808,
0.0214457568,
0.0383286774,
-0.0163211618,
-0.0247994326,
-0.0757692903,
-0.0402907617,
0.0678731054,
-0.0407868065,
0.0544932187,
-0.0147808585,
-0.010305359,
-0.0236126352,
-0.0854958966,
-0.0408289433,
-0.0521742888,
0.0181125905,
-0.0044689253,
0.0206339471,
-0.0146314381,
-0.0343185626,
-0.0223051701,
0.0676171929,
-0.0195385497,
-0.0146319736,
-0.0096597802,
-0.0003592106,
-0.0018834096,
0.0757453963,
0.0029744715,
0.0233111735,
-0.0467477068,
-0.0389967784,
0.0212095995,
0.0319170728,
0.0283118933,
0.0189484004,
0.023630593,
0.0665802658,
-0.0485870093,
-0.030222062,
0.0292629525,
0.0092349052,
0.0021297135,
-0.0035796817,
0.0740025118,
0.0289113354,
-0.0428128392,
0.0259199832,
-0.020309737,
0.0313198864,
-0.0059255138,
0.0242829509,
-0.065926753,
0.0203072913,
0.007705315,
0.0356021151,
-0.0274777282,
-0.0058732214,
0.0445725359,
-0.1245660856,
-0.0225997511,
0.0146206217,
-0.0425167456,
0.0054213107,
-0.0344228633,
-0.0010792596,
-0.0353972837,
-0.0122614037,
0.0240528379,
0.0084406948,
0.0075123417,
0.0224622004,
0.0533851311,
-0.0126419188,
0.0059983465,
-0.0381474011,
0.0579553917,
0.1238534078,
0.0018370401,
-0.0379588231,
-0.0526438206,
-0.0378706455,
0.0426818095,
-0.0341431871,
0.022282552,
0.0009375489,
0.0018102526,
-0.0009867457,
-0.0346529782,
0.0219608471,
0.0248856936,
-0.0102311457,
-0.0131413946,
0.0352648459,
0.0281996112,
-0.0136730447,
-0.0157111213,
-0.0061266501,
-0.000440069,
0.0757143572,
-0.0127802445,
-0.0786293224,
0.0396614894,
-0.0398168005,
-0.0446372181,
-0.0013052617,
-0.0347425602,
0.014755344,
-0.0006011133,
-0.035054259,
-0.0812923685,
-0.0353603251,
-0.0226949919,
0.0253894068,
0.0247835685,
-0.0104701519,
-0.0235873181,
-0.0023320273,
-0.0065511297,
0.0344206393,
-0.0017312885,
0.0128510492,
-0.0868799612,
-0.0042957882,
0.0065168305,
-0.0513620265,
-0.0441093892,
-0.0644725263,
0.005698754,
-0.0683981255,
0.0129728308,
0.0697012544,
0.0343322717,
0.0222740583,
0.0127701685,
-0.0201074257,
-0.0100860428,
0.02587457,
-0.0158755872,
0.0204680655,
0.0178746562,
0.014720019,
-0.0084202476,
0.0005759771,
-0.0639762208,
0.0130457887,
0.0425807424,
0.0343216136,
-0.0003195964,
-0.0538241267,
0.0638775006,
0.0211632494,
0.0375816599,
-0.0350064263,
0.0009428153,
-0.0170258954,
-0.0194993354,
-0.0027868643,
-0.0453842022,
0.0072524287,
-0.0419032425,
0.0668458715,
0.021123223,
0.0099492297,
-0.0130055388,
0.0026608179,
0.0147106433,
-0.0463389345,
-0.0119280834,
0.015483994,
0.0144844502,
0.0277738795,
0.0330740102,
-0.0232708082,
-0.0114787119,
0.0130347665,
0.0539410301,
0.0158571005,
0.0422953926,
0.0287354123,
0.0071597141,
-0.0027003037,
0.0392749719,
-0.046048861,
-0.0292495061,
-0.0221332405,
-0.0316261128,
0.035466779,
-0.0153697422,
0.0667021126,
-0.0140596451,
-0.0197599437,
-0.0310106725,
-0.0079963608,
-0.0188011639,
-0.0176878348,
0.0372712761,
0.0240974296,
0.0091217831,
-0.0498116575,
0.0376544334,
-0.0316309482,
0.0095772976,
-0.041091416,
-0.0063222768,
-0.0095609063,
-0.0173456594,
0.007241738,
0.0345784873,
-0.0467363484,
-0.0056671933,
-0.0661785156,
-0.0435750149,
-0.0469644219,
0.0709224865,
0.0404577851,
-0.0207268111,
0.0172004793,
0.0297799092,
-0.0413296744,
0.0081764078,
-0.0578348078,
0.0011438561,
-0.0165266544,
-0.0049138237,
-0.0467821024,
-5.792527226e-33,
-0.0390954576,
0.0142652113,
0.0112298727,
0.0064324997,
-0.006807724,
-0.0367444828,
0.0159714315,
0.0536288172,
-0.0171902198,
-0.0084692277,
-0.0058697746,
-0.0629587993,
0.0037499347,
-0.0180654228,
0.0371027254,
-0.0006726031,
0.0366663635,
0.0115543827,
-0.0922333822,
-0.0179177262,
0.0464419201,
-0.0249814112,
0.0680591613,
-0.0456783287,
0.0430313237,
0.0537505113,
-0.0388500728,
0.022299774,
-0.0251079202,
0.0592333861,
0.0179324783,
0.0318899043,
0.0042517716,
-0.0530570075,
0.0032236108,
0.022944361,
-0.0277101677,
-0.0054160655,
0.0683400333,
-0.0057818838,
-0.0112085454,
-0.0414596573,
0.0361265242,
0.0034836323,
-0.0663935393,
0.0056911302,
0.0268246271,
-0.0328934938,
-0.0354523249,
0.0273264498,
-0.0661808476,
-0.0123307602,
0.0018654146,
-0.0178990234,
-0.0060298792,
0.036276374,
-0.0200501755,
0.0490521565,
-0.0342307873,
0.0912459493,
0.0275883246,
0.0443952084,
0.0776367784,
0.0186472144,
0.0013587587,
0.0391924977,
0.0197487641,
0.0077131726,
0.0240151919,
-0.0196792651,
0.0384036414,
0.0059703197,
0.0548680313,
0.0267869495,
0.0476150252,
-0.0233754907,
-0.0135662453,
0.0421798825,
0.0208967011,
-0.019535318,
0.0313445218,
0.0527848341,
-0.0522332378,
-0.0390012152,
-0.05282088,
-0.0081225233,
-0.0344568603,
-0.0582875237,
0.0429249592,
0.0100943185,
-0.0175811257,
-0.0219424665,
0.0221719779,
-0.0359641165,
-0.0577008389,
0.0061454433,
-0.0300990567,
0.0375028439,
-0.0256970208,
-0.0257400498,
-0.0732476488,
0.0011893492,
-0.0443604328,
0.0121183395,
-0.01599681,
0.052335754,
0.0297117662,
-0.0063308533,
-0.0372580253,
0.0197512414,
-0.0197825413,
-0.0118182078,
0.0277659558,
-0.0194908269,
0.038951803,
-0.0260243937,
0.0035300038,
0.0061520608,
0.0008549913,
-0.0549903214,
-0.0670092255,
0.0087898104,
-0.0021920879,
0.0189635977,
-0.0058098184,
-0.0117068896,
-0.0110222828,
0.0405193195,
0.0216947012,
0.0007989946,
-0.0252246205,
-0.0320576653,
2.644e-7,
0.0304977931,
0.0287775565,
-0.028129857,
0.0183085129,
-0.0251811426,
0.0655823052,
-0.0151628507,
0.0271816347,
0.0804786831,
0.0317130536,
-0.0060145841,
-0.0081166718,
-0.005551355,
-0.0044025658,
-0.0157523565,
-0.0435951576,
-0.0535375141,
0.0077252327,
0.0055441391,
-0.0004074966,
0.036459852,
0.0496179499,
0.0466386303,
0.0024396644,
-0.019553164,
0.0177463293,
0.0532533005,
-0.0832897946,
-0.0178643744,
0.0152579695,
-0.0153992381,
-0.0241036825,
-0.0197951328,
-0.0030251453,
0.0226914361,
-0.0025512218,
0.0182845127,
0.0432962067,
-0.0236451216,
-0.0226121061,
-0.037710987,
0.0006087875,
0.0114376657,
-0.0744990855,
0.0330734961,
-0.0614103489,
-0.0323965587,
-0.0244714264,
-0.0211410075,
-0.0004176177,
0.0189486332,
-0.0238127708,
-0.0259343181,
-0.0169623028,
0.0130096618,
0.0598683693,
-0.0005134235,
-0.0413940214,
-0.0364801139,
0.048912935,
-0.0205879398,
-0.0924902856,
-0.012314178,
0.0771049857,
-0.0380133688,
-0.0883255824,
-0.0156189622,
2.415360333e-34,
0.0097704791,
0.0259205438,
0.0414053127,
-0.0220411289,
0.021412624,
0.0094756,
-0.009158575,
0.004442119,
0.0573339611,
-0.0454139784,
-0.0279115848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00723v1 | Improving Semantic Control in Discrete Latent Spaces with Transformer Quantized Variational Autoencoders | 2024-02-01T16:14:35 | 2024-02-01T16:14:35 | Yingji Zhang, Danilo S. Carvalho, Marco Valentino, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Achieving precise semantic control over the latent spaces of Variational
AutoEncoders (VAEs) holds significant value for downstream tasks in NLP as the
underlying generative mechanisms could be better localised, explained and
improved upon. Recent research, however, has struggled to achieve consistent
results, primarily due to the inevitable loss of semantic information in the
variational bottleneck and limited control over the decoding mechanism. To
overcome these challenges, we investigate discrete latent spaces in Vector
Quantized Variational AutoEncoders (VQVAEs) to improve semantic control and
generation in Transformer-based VAEs. In particular, We propose T5VQVAE, a
novel model that leverages the controllability of VQVAEs to guide the
self-attention mechanism in T5 at the token-level, exploiting its full
generalization capabilities. Experimental results indicate that T5VQVAE
outperforms existing state-of-the-art VAE models, including Optimus, in terms
of controllability and preservation of semantic information across different
tasks such as auto-encoding of sentences and mathematical expressions, text
transfer, and inference. Moreover, T5VQVAE exhibits improved inference
capabilities, suggesting potential applications for downstream natural language
and symbolic reasoning tasks. | Improving Semantic Control in Discrete Latent Spaces with Transformer Quantized Variational Autoencoders: Achieving precise semantic control over the latent spaces of Variational
AutoEncoders (VAEs) holds significant value for downstream tasks in NLP as the
underlying generative mechanisms could be better localised, explained and
improved upon. Recent research, however, has struggled to achieve consistent
results, primarily due to the inevitable loss of semantic information in the
variational bottleneck and limited control over the decoding mechanism. To
overcome these challenges, we investigate discrete latent spaces in Vector
Quantized Variational AutoEncoders (VQVAEs) to improve semantic control and
generation in Transformer-based VAEs. In particular, We propose T5VQVAE, a
novel model that leverages the controllability of VQVAEs to guide the
self-attention mechanism in T5 at the token-level, exploiting its full
generalization capabilities. Experimental results indicate that T5VQVAE
outperforms existing state-of-the-art VAE models, including Optimus, in terms
of controllability and preservation of semantic information across different
tasks such as auto-encoding of sentences and mathematical expressions, text
transfer, and inference. Moreover, T5VQVAE exhibits improved inference
capabilities, suggesting potential applications for downstream natural language
and symbolic reasoning tasks. | [
0.021848077,
0.1191178337,
-0.0336612314,
0.0244558584,
-0.0151450094,
0.0055524562,
0.0348345265,
-0.0370918103,
-0.0483623035,
-0.0026466846,
0.0039884271,
-0.0187495667,
-0.0465337746,
0.0577908792,
0.0626603514,
-0.0484321974,
0.0500127375,
-0.0113457944,
-0.0165567528,
-0.0534899607,
-0.0054912958,
-0.0416673943,
0.0084214238,
0.0202640183,
-0.023037903,
-0.0053814664,
-0.0073733595,
-0.0432921164,
0.0130108064,
0.0241602305,
-0.0024317298,
0.050038211,
0.0526116826,
-0.0220011417,
0.0000021123,
0.0046402942,
-0.020139616,
-0.0255420879,
-0.0455729738,
-0.0281654242,
0.0178880207,
-0.0571403354,
-0.0078983745,
-0.0305623505,
-0.0036708522,
-0.0761160627,
0.072186023,
0.0434754528,
0.0557062477,
0.0330822654,
-0.0127848266,
-0.0281134155,
0.0287561361,
-0.0420486182,
0.0424279049,
-0.0729860663,
0.0259046387,
-0.009058686,
0.0000808536,
0.0339424089,
-0.0901969671,
0.0416075289,
0.0645012632,
-0.0217476841,
0.0111719305,
0.0376364179,
0.008383384,
-0.0415187702,
-0.0411075391,
0.0315124653,
-0.0241983794,
-0.0439017676,
-0.0277415384,
-0.0120640052,
-0.0295702126,
0.0174183194,
-0.0260599833,
0.0533904731,
0.0287798773,
-0.0042994209,
0.0224123057,
0.0427445732,
0.0188337546,
0.0072980155,
-0.039493937,
0.0111588724,
0.0375911109,
-0.0239076205,
-0.0036917876,
0.0097197676,
-0.1076287329,
-0.003658595,
0.014109889,
0.0037261343,
-0.0308552366,
-0.0060918727,
-0.0326858982,
-0.0678492486,
-0.0501099788,
0.0260878839,
0.0286260936,
0.0818757787,
0.0137626771,
0.0085943043,
-0.0270618722,
0.0836821496,
-0.0717022568,
0.0377281681,
-0.0416497029,
-0.0347478911,
0.0184685215,
-0.0184806753,
-0.0443006307,
0.0130930822,
-0.0288467407,
-0.0266284496,
-0.0122308582,
0.0418215245,
-0.0312003568,
-0.013069435,
-0.0004964478,
0.0691303611,
-0.055236049,
0.0097743515,
0.0221315399,
0.0161734559,
-0.0548447073,
0.0083652493,
0.0007461161,
-0.0245936811,
-0.036721386,
0.0166968033,
0.059886165,
-0.0621798635,
-0.0129470276,
0.0424611494,
-0.0059509971,
0.0049365233,
0.0020505672,
0.0127374465,
-0.0194322914,
-0.0306820646,
0.0323947072,
-0.0193655081,
0.0312307533,
0.0153957568,
-0.009295865,
-0.0141880214,
-0.0056160828,
-0.0059764269,
0.0054745488,
0.0771794617,
0.0542818084,
-0.025931837,
0.0240281224,
-0.0038687091,
0.0281714369,
0.0330657288,
0.006128693,
0.0402522869,
-0.0157879591,
0.0134029407,
-0.0114454757,
0.0203496441,
0.0515294224,
-0.0460376479,
-0.0385703929,
-0.0285867266,
-0.0206034277,
0.0390624776,
0.0877021849,
0.0505648553,
-0.0589865148,
-0.037131872,
0.020031495,
0.0342540294,
0.0576642565,
0.0181732439,
0.0456232466,
-0.0034577257,
-0.0283197127,
-0.019555416,
-0.0282450989,
0.0980247036,
0.0495350659,
0.0048406399,
0.0009646841,
-0.0006821773,
-0.0103922691,
-0.0382965393,
0.0116056474,
0.0141546605,
-0.0025781495,
-0.0124336258,
0.0343314558,
0.0550427027,
-0.0210168026,
0.0786293596,
0.0136927143,
-0.0117361844,
0.0252245404,
-0.0091866981,
0.0333952941,
0.0077791996,
0.0207022559,
0.0154452091,
0.0220184941,
-0.0083104419,
-0.0316067301,
0.0505750291,
0.0121852383,
-0.004505672,
-0.0328764208,
-0.0203536376,
-0.0708408356,
-0.073905766,
0.0095534809,
-0.004860518,
0.0192543268,
-0.0184782594,
-0.0177445021,
-0.0167838242,
0.0641226918,
0.0309013166,
-0.0137311164,
-0.0124051711,
0.0303408615,
0.0125223985,
0.0306042284,
-0.0063938256,
0.0073921094,
0.0255948734,
0.0064993468,
-0.0563923754,
-0.0340213552,
-0.0078514889,
-0.064040713,
-0.078343913,
0.0078497604,
-0.0367924869,
-0.005440271,
0.0304504838,
-0.0238514822,
-0.0139897577,
0.0753771737,
-0.0531932376,
-0.0188637376,
-0.0338714235,
-0.0478961058,
0.0355849601,
0.0397803076,
0.0011350038,
0.0668629482,
-0.0398012064,
0.0234413687,
0.033300627,
0.0787939355,
-0.0099306237,
0.007871272,
0.0162114073,
-0.0176849924,
0.018190762,
0.0038267719,
0.0293501467,
-0.0049305959,
-0.0041291383,
-0.0290146563,
-0.060186144,
-0.0102539426,
-0.0489212088,
-0.0149601195,
0.0186338425,
0.0521829911,
0.0219519008,
0.0206702258,
-0.000030823,
0.006216248,
-0.0064248187,
0.011179287,
0.0202138461,
-0.0244672019,
0.0417859033,
-0.016566705,
-0.0385595374,
-0.010870412,
0.0558362938,
-0.0075566433,
0.0085185273,
0.0126418844,
-0.0281562451,
-0.0003815682,
-0.0053095422,
-0.0209520999,
-0.0159745086,
-0.0035477397,
-0.0302913897,
0.0714719817,
0.0257555414,
0.0188067127,
0.061839886,
0.0365574397,
0.0092372103,
-0.0360407159,
0.0345172212,
-0.1009173989,
-0.0096398285,
-0.0055568274,
0.0354163721,
-0.0023782756,
0.0596819073,
0.0285880882,
-0.0012992254,
-0.0688159019,
0.067384012,
-0.0040908,
-0.0324227512,
0.0154943205,
0.0225730278,
-0.0362686813,
0.0456204005,
-0.0612809286,
0.0216796752,
0.0656642541,
0.0433363467,
-0.0005805634,
-0.019379098,
0.0453586653,
-0.0255690385,
0.0274022818,
0.0570382811,
0.0177619476,
-0.0221445058,
-0.0354580209,
-0.0295308605,
0.0367454141,
0.0056705163,
0.0230874643,
0.0297413915,
0.0078439554,
0.0110008484,
0.0254152846,
-0.0290751234,
-0.0494066961,
-0.003446704,
0.0317781344,
0.0454763882,
0.0593730472,
0.0058959718,
-0.0119548701,
-0.0213372465,
0.0210703295,
0.0447588861,
-0.0331636555,
-0.0186858289,
-0.0319132917,
0.0559188761,
0.0528945848,
0.0430770032,
0.0275677051,
-0.0246865395,
-0.066852279,
0.0366894975,
-0.0052405503,
-0.0001589115,
-0.0035832277,
0.0686158538,
0.0218740869,
-0.0147032607,
0.044677455,
-0.0178691465,
0.0280896835,
-0.0286110491,
-0.0591274984,
0.0521415919,
-0.016120648,
-0.0035450608,
0.0174832325,
-0.0555516705,
0.0114501277,
0.0105249528,
0.0116702244,
-0.0745894164,
-0.0237719417,
-0.0283940583,
-0.0009389831,
0.027567815,
0.000430715,
-0.0087176282,
-0.0393807217,
0.0248757731,
-0.0062862812,
-0.0119330715,
0.0033195307,
-0.0015188479,
0.0050645471,
-0.0426430292,
0.0545489751,
-0.0095912479,
0.0087871384,
0.0046524862,
0.016349148,
0.0670867041,
-0.0481769703,
-0.0029182727,
-0.0218312591,
0.0159288049,
0.0805415213,
0.0076873219,
-0.0132054156,
-0.0391754545,
-0.0034991114,
-0.0536197051,
-0.0021704407,
-0.008987817,
0.0415330008,
-0.0428195149,
-0.0183832049,
0.016185021,
0.034060318,
-0.0115567949,
-0.0330221914,
-0.0350960009,
0.0491657779,
0.0019469131,
-0.0490712523,
-0.0244445633,
-0.0173627939,
-0.0621210784,
0.0378563143,
0.0387015343,
-0.0223570205,
-0.0608257875,
-0.0148210712,
0.0283121169,
-0.0475262739,
-0.0587995909,
-0.0366595201,
0.0564100444,
-0.1235490814,
-0.0327164344,
-0.0238774884,
0.0052994466,
0.0107523585,
-0.0308778621,
-0.0345336162,
0.0421226099,
-0.0493930988,
-0.0606204197,
-0.0177748147,
0.0126626911,
0.0013312841,
0.0160875004,
-0.0037552647,
0.0030106576,
-0.0634463578,
-0.0299876258,
-0.031569276,
-0.09899728,
-0.0427267365,
0.0280566365,
0.0472832881,
0.0004139918,
0.0758747682,
-0.0103009669,
-0.0288441479,
0.0798718557,
0.0153730372,
-0.021121975,
0.0248458162,
0.0058581526,
0.0171921775,
0.0021662235,
0.0392712839,
-0.0215115286,
0.013233711,
0.0305301864,
0.0763262808,
-0.0112319812,
0.0022885888,
0.0281585399,
-0.0846560821,
0.0183685087,
-0.0004553661,
0.0082946932,
-0.0293756425,
-0.0046873172,
-0.0156963039,
-0.0165939182,
-0.0564602241,
0.0205885582,
0.0239528622,
0.0401075408,
-0.0256241206,
-0.007819565,
0.0487740785,
-0.0124735832,
-0.0016651114,
0.0117187081,
0.0183090158,
0.0152814798,
-0.0170745626,
0.0278203022,
-0.0056658075,
-0.0119919125,
0.0043220655,
0.0398979224,
-0.0198840145,
0.0477803983,
0.0599817745,
-0.013357888,
-0.0160890631,
0.0039530634,
-0.070901297,
-0.0335830338,
-0.0301995333,
-0.0308203679,
0.0037185163,
0.0202080607,
0.0199288726,
-0.033683341,
-0.0242902003,
0.0167198554,
-0.0089078061,
-0.0049675447,
-0.0500740744,
0.0442517363,
0.0023836691,
0.0338285901,
-0.0438389331,
0.0120261228,
-0.0052349637,
-0.001827903,
-0.0470988676,
0.0186008196,
-0.0435476862,
-0.0105308425,
-0.0297234301,
0.0068148663,
0.0091039296,
0.0218123291,
-0.0085805068,
-0.0368407965,
0.0250721928,
0.0101086749,
-0.0310165007,
-0.0038110709,
0.0326912999,
0.0499366783,
0.0002336577,
-0.0929984972,
-0.0181639791,
0.0266993083,
0.0344503969,
-0.0126095079,
-0.0538902022,
-7.071062106e-33,
-0.0395717435,
-0.039373748,
0.0132577745,
-0.0215994455,
-0.0307194963,
0.0038449124,
-0.0750369355,
-0.0424620509,
0.0091660703,
0.0295358002,
0.0109767523,
0.0238495022,
-0.0088908877,
0.0414621346,
0.0364426672,
-0.0527862161,
0.0566567034,
-0.0017977023,
-0.0074179294,
0.0270078816,
-0.0067718443,
0.0309920572,
0.0473106578,
-0.024093952,
0.0239680801,
0.0379279815,
0.0362035893,
0.0054803477,
0.0059368946,
0.0461656936,
-0.0411902256,
0.0069281314,
0.014580356,
-0.038718868,
-0.0271165632,
-0.0294211376,
-0.094994314,
-0.052768074,
-0.0238879099,
0.0171098746,
-0.0319822617,
-0.0388987474,
0.0866490453,
-0.0141606126,
0.002583568,
-0.0587844439,
0.011993641,
0.0128030824,
0.0035715445,
-0.1061893106,
-0.0514261611,
-0.0029604074,
0.0050040488,
0.0237274878,
0.0278856773,
-0.0393561982,
0.0028681739,
0.047271803,
-0.0447137319,
-0.0033219634,
-0.0213539973,
0.0218584705,
0.0581938289,
0.0003008434,
0.0236546174,
0.0004241304,
0.0462242849,
-0.0635448322,
-0.0646096542,
0.0108580356,
0.026520567,
0.0065162177,
0.0391873643,
-0.0050140717,
0.05593035,
0.0249853022,
0.0005821623,
-0.033483509,
-0.0657688528,
0.0817623138,
0.0180522427,
0.0367441587,
0.0042893612,
-0.0209852625,
-0.0094426712,
-0.0336490497,
-0.053698536,
-0.0175899193,
0.0143901333,
-0.0038496829,
-0.0313133225,
-0.0045130937,
0.0151433591,
-0.0480153561,
-0.0180449989,
0.0377999209,
0.0063399496,
0.0335996225,
0.005614317,
0.0285049286,
-0.067578733,
0.0373757258,
0.0337384902,
-0.0039076428,
-0.0148865227,
0.0158161242,
-0.0149090206,
0.060351342,
-0.0302514266,
-0.0304685142,
-0.0573498718,
-0.0288164634,
-0.0259372815,
0.0306647848,
0.0301272944,
0.051724311,
-0.017253926,
0.0270298608,
0.0213586204,
0.0221259892,
-0.0243141558,
0.0217875354,
0.0303991623,
0.0657646209,
-0.0441536829,
-0.0263169985,
-0.0459498689,
0.0619361475,
0.0287716165,
-0.0781419799,
-0.0031486491,
0.0437638275,
2.821e-7,
0.0665443391,
0.0173386727,
0.0262336079,
0.0061123762,
-0.0007578019,
0.0289810654,
0.0366698541,
0.0309728198,
0.008089371,
-0.0082122851,
0.0235668104,
0.0480658188,
-0.0204063524,
-0.0019006721,
-0.0080854408,
0.0372460186,
-0.00614799,
-0.0044047134,
-0.000199359,
-0.024165025,
0.0830580592,
0.1043610126,
-0.0006551254,
0.0122563727,
0.0276899636,
0.0416978188,
0.0639217943,
0.0376239009,
-0.0120832566,
0.0196915064,
0.0081877494,
-0.0394397303,
0.0186089166,
-0.0290644541,
-0.0079652471,
0.0259691272,
-0.0040040705,
0.0383763537,
0.0090778191,
-0.063168861,
-0.0576984622,
-0.0126997186,
-0.0046501514,
-0.0063769971,
0.0391881354,
-0.1265438646,
-0.0217799544,
0.0103297522,
-0.0344210453,
0.0525765307,
0.0079929428,
0.008167672,
-0.0290027596,
-0.0057790936,
0.0416909494,
0.0527640507,
-0.0204338338,
-0.0867554471,
0.0105773974,
0.0014062335,
-0.0456440523,
0.0315044671,
-0.044479914,
0.0032418231,
0.0338492766,
0.0044494434,
-0.0520743914,
2.534546966e-34,
-0.0037106283,
0.0169167705,
-0.0173573662,
0.0116629424,
0.0046365405,
-0.0418593027,
0.0089856442,
0.008049543,
0.0020288334,
-0.012004354,
-0.0527141169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00711v2 | Explaining Text Classifiers with Counterfactual Representations | 2024-02-01T16:06:35 | 2024-04-29T16:04:38 | Pirmin Lemberger, Antoine Saillenfest | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, 62Fxx | One well motivated explanation method for classifiers leverages
counterfactuals which are hypothetical events identical to real observations in
all aspects except for one categorical feature. Constructing such
counterfactual poses specific challenges for texts, however, as some attribute
values may not necessarily align with plausible real-world events. In this
paper we propose a simple method for generating counterfactuals by intervening
in the space of text representations which bypasses this limitation. We argue
that our interventions are minimally disruptive and that they are theoretically
sound as they align with counterfactuals as defined in Pearl's causal inference
framework. To validate our method, we conducted experiments first on a
synthetic dataset and then on a realistic dataset of counterfactuals. This
allows for a direct comparison between classifier predictions based on ground
truth counterfactuals - obtained through explicit text interventions - and our
counterfactuals, derived through interventions in the representation space.
Eventually, we study a real world scenario where our counterfactuals can be
leveraged both for explaining a classifier and for bias mitigation. | Explaining Text Classifiers with Counterfactual Representations: One well motivated explanation method for classifiers leverages
counterfactuals which are hypothetical events identical to real observations in
all aspects except for one categorical feature. Constructing such
counterfactual poses specific challenges for texts, however, as some attribute
values may not necessarily align with plausible real-world events. In this
paper we propose a simple method for generating counterfactuals by intervening
in the space of text representations which bypasses this limitation. We argue
that our interventions are minimally disruptive and that they are theoretically
sound as they align with counterfactuals as defined in Pearl's causal inference
framework. To validate our method, we conducted experiments first on a
synthetic dataset and then on a realistic dataset of counterfactuals. This
allows for a direct comparison between classifier predictions based on ground
truth counterfactuals - obtained through explicit text interventions - and our
counterfactuals, derived through interventions in the representation space.
Eventually, we study a real world scenario where our counterfactuals can be
leveraged both for explaining a classifier and for bias mitigation. | [
0.0246692058,
0.0596515425,
-0.0229620729,
0.0080101304,
-0.0452306904,
0.0453999527,
0.0455311388,
0.001611112,
0.017556794,
-0.0487518013,
0.0753780305,
0.0335880257,
-0.0176360421,
0.0301381834,
0.0205058921,
-0.0281206351,
0.0193596873,
-0.0002065542,
0.0252459887,
-0.0246149972,
-0.0007828816,
0.0210648868,
-0.0038002643,
0.0276707038,
-0.0074580316,
-0.0164015777,
-0.0156821553,
-0.0021946512,
0.0149532678,
-0.0050849216,
0.0103884619,
-0.0035473511,
0.0097155012,
0.0255316459,
0.0000021265,
-0.0226965137,
-0.0261839107,
0.0307559595,
-0.0494509339,
-0.0143497847,
-0.0106355827,
-0.0330997594,
0.0213228446,
-0.0027667461,
-0.0192803517,
0.0508630238,
0.0453946069,
0.0633772537,
-0.003285392,
0.0694192275,
-0.022526633,
-0.0515096448,
-0.0056106676,
0.0145666031,
0.0390346497,
-0.0054959939,
0.0100509301,
-0.0183900744,
-0.0372011364,
-0.0009366769,
-0.0124199865,
0.0054566297,
0.035319306,
0.010333864,
0.0285979267,
0.0402040854,
0.0193594471,
0.0071819089,
0.0185223147,
0.0020271137,
0.0494247489,
-0.0682948455,
0.0193921477,
-0.0403034054,
0.0532609075,
0.0520625971,
-0.0060259136,
-0.01989129,
-0.0125310961,
0.0088490918,
0.0428532548,
0.0493472479,
0.0637407154,
0.045569893,
-0.0038934692,
0.0433846973,
-0.0054722275,
-0.0020810629,
-0.0487555414,
0.0231741052,
0.0041243676,
-0.0289957244,
0.0076781148,
0.0034540698,
-0.0211408157,
-0.0036175563,
0.006593409,
-0.0318413004,
0.0130685251,
-0.100435555,
0.0140331583,
0.0299664009,
-0.0155714164,
0.0220110808,
-0.0096750306,
0.0251156148,
-0.022695506,
0.0200036131,
-0.0083766123,
-0.0027112372,
-0.0440244712,
-0.0428905711,
0.0020591191,
-0.0041775121,
-0.0357043184,
0.056287501,
0.0074417959,
0.005902777,
-0.0477481,
0.0102941496,
-0.0313206725,
0.0498299375,
-0.0313941687,
-0.0202717781,
-0.0390937366,
0.0084801605,
-0.044465486,
0.0302993972,
-0.0228792485,
-0.0252365042,
-0.0028483153,
0.0098499097,
0.0059064361,
-0.033467222,
0.004678546,
0.0786533579,
0.0357859544,
0.0216647219,
-0.0258654449,
-0.0540290214,
-0.0275502689,
-0.0483447611,
-0.0236066673,
-0.0247819256,
-0.0463570766,
0.0331570059,
0.0038519714,
-0.0293922219,
-0.0217554476,
-0.0283119008,
-0.0332013853,
0.0804623291,
-0.0053461432,
-0.0209713783,
0.0269048549,
-0.0013701151,
-0.0246415436,
0.0495386682,
0.034217447,
0.0008933679,
0.0411330611,
-0.0384234153,
0.0239933189,
-0.0348279402,
0.043945916,
-0.0229090415,
-0.0504306853,
0.005115476,
-0.0231104698,
-0.0172739271,
0.002392723,
-0.0504666902,
-0.0103785396,
-0.0220020693,
0.0491958372,
-0.03291272,
-0.0121773956,
0.0331357345,
0.0185608268,
-0.0096250325,
-0.055174619,
0.0599043556,
-0.0530208871,
0.0263715181,
-0.0822436288,
-0.0046212571,
-0.0283238608,
-0.0153328646,
-0.0359294936,
-0.0798198059,
-0.0069156052,
0.0002467266,
0.0196098667,
0.0242184456,
0.0552662723,
0.0146629354,
-0.0125051858,
-0.0225648526,
0.0273978487,
-0.0218469296,
0.0139494222,
-0.0361719094,
0.0062108412,
0.0977146626,
0.0371127315,
-0.080798693,
0.0254935529,
-0.0177635681,
-0.0018094671,
-0.0170436502,
0.0513573401,
-0.0185595267,
-0.0052588722,
-0.0187994055,
-0.0055518313,
-0.0398928896,
0.0557027012,
0.0080594979,
-0.0039824974,
-0.0190979205,
-0.0035419776,
0.0069026845,
-0.027993599,
0.0500395373,
0.0097854817,
-0.0288574677,
0.0129847014,
0.0226519704,
-0.0007062616,
0.0294001251,
0.0049696905,
-0.0067987046,
0.0207140893,
0.0113420915,
-0.0385445394,
0.033247482,
0.0014186695,
-0.0448538177,
-0.0080621541,
-0.0414375141,
-0.0450870544,
0.0422447808,
-0.0372236036,
-0.0099044768,
0.0295119546,
-0.0261787698,
0.072192356,
-0.0223580319,
0.0012704856,
-0.0089104678,
-0.0023982404,
-0.0149993384,
0.0607845411,
0.0093783624,
-0.0112228524,
-0.0359851941,
-0.0340935476,
0.0251359604,
-0.025624875,
0.0411864892,
-0.0008897053,
-0.0059404867,
-0.0121645555,
0.030444013,
-0.0439068042,
-0.0093142809,
0.0126629183,
-0.0258521233,
-0.027586475,
-0.0366091318,
-0.0209117774,
0.0077009117,
-0.018550111,
0.0105026588,
-0.0328355618,
-0.0163144451,
-0.0292474609,
-0.0041909795,
0.0281414352,
0.0458390042,
-0.0256931987,
0.0096495757,
0.0036515561,
0.0039325221,
-0.0546715669,
0.0942267552,
0.053419441,
-0.0131301796,
-0.0533057712,
-0.0463097505,
-0.0016886079,
-0.0230585691,
-0.022582192,
-0.0057332953,
-0.0020337412,
0.017465191,
-0.031595327,
0.0382223576,
0.0020275111,
0.0562600829,
0.039599482,
0.0300484467,
-0.046114061,
-0.0173201524,
-0.0447372794,
0.0371222086,
-0.0335550755,
-0.0611782484,
-0.0447337627,
0.0462986417,
-0.0070480611,
-0.0381005518,
-0.0779963136,
0.0291299038,
0.0075512049,
-0.0374882482,
-0.0213122182,
-0.0592088439,
0.0069532762,
0.0571842939,
-0.0084037576,
-0.065403834,
0.084012486,
0.0083784899,
0.0228901543,
-0.0417832993,
-0.0176226795,
-0.0030620187,
0.0557816923,
-0.0107553294,
-0.003638241,
0.0476930104,
0.0280193742,
0.006341185,
-0.00199613,
0.039584294,
0.0264401454,
-0.0117952526,
-0.0703057051,
0.0075446633,
0.0241999533,
-0.0322505236,
-0.0543487184,
-0.0975491479,
-0.0036406624,
-0.0041187988,
-0.0368405916,
-0.011592214,
-0.0493101142,
0.0074607362,
-0.0009143539,
0.0299391188,
-0.0152046327,
-0.0233887415,
0.0040773097,
-0.0226003956,
0.0033943269,
-0.0081633888,
0.0279450435,
-0.0301408675,
0.0152462143,
0.0149804614,
-0.0077629117,
-0.0309364311,
-0.0151067022,
0.0180826262,
-0.033550363,
-0.0220864881,
-0.0155765684,
0.0006538242,
0.0022584731,
-0.0387361385,
-0.003458187,
0.0691557154,
0.0467857309,
-0.0035566788,
0.0433656611,
0.0160137471,
0.0131264487,
0.0012684598,
-0.0325186327,
-0.0517220311,
-0.0106139956,
-0.0009817262,
-0.0012418681,
-0.042023018,
-0.0090486817,
0.0123351002,
-0.047775805,
0.0465508401,
0.0100850957,
-0.0064565944,
-0.0321393311,
-0.041600991,
-0.0478577912,
-0.0471298322,
-0.0614424124,
-0.0269083232,
0.0422931388,
0.0368000939,
0.0057384879,
-0.0124661997,
-0.0240956265,
-0.0166894067,
0.0172107089,
0.0017181491,
0.045816429,
0.0342704169,
0.0135540552,
0.0255230274,
-0.0207544118,
-0.0134096546,
0.0380091183,
0.0016527331,
0.1124841422,
0.009016348,
0.0008453077,
-0.0283697862,
0.0489528067,
-0.0061678141,
-0.0556522161,
0.0001213914,
0.0530673489,
-0.0327159241,
-0.0190427098,
-0.0115483264,
-0.0083076674,
0.012159735,
0.0795105323,
0.0075404849,
-0.035545934,
-0.0441157855,
-0.0542658791,
-0.003149973,
-0.0134568373,
-0.0108476002,
-0.0349007845,
0.0636144653,
-0.0544018075,
-0.0100290654,
-0.0613339469,
-0.0313211642,
-0.0050511379,
-0.0121479565,
-0.0119010145,
-0.0573176295,
-0.0087907752,
-0.049354393,
0.0312942713,
0.0021619555,
0.0339953676,
0.0719733834,
-0.049504403,
0.0208574235,
-0.0498969369,
-0.0310696904,
-0.0051320461,
-0.0083624311,
-0.0620201081,
0.0212454852,
0.0073124142,
0.030373618,
0.0789297894,
-0.0099106682,
-0.0745971948,
0.0358023383,
0.0690330341,
-0.0626722798,
0.0098219858,
0.0691176653,
-0.0123728886,
0.0117984777,
0.0254921168,
0.0046104505,
0.0090423189,
0.0188252274,
-0.0140162017,
-0.0524575636,
0.013809666,
0.0238558073,
-0.0327412933,
0.0553741753,
-0.0275930762,
-0.0289150737,
-0.0159757249,
0.029083414,
-0.0472842976,
-0.0311220419,
0.0105109746,
-0.0001313255,
0.0236661304,
0.0099357944,
-0.0318785645,
0.0153064644,
-0.0492508374,
0.0039275144,
-0.0222160202,
0.0566280968,
0.0603989139,
0.0541290939,
-0.0014282204,
0.0007881308,
-0.0094521223,
-0.0089054396,
0.0367854089,
0.0406696536,
-0.0107731549,
0.0264387392,
0.0297168903,
0.0231734291,
-0.0327336788,
-0.0501956493,
-0.1349329501,
0.0487014726,
-0.0164102651,
0.0411803313,
-0.0123192314,
-0.0385823064,
0.0138779953,
-0.0151309436,
-0.0298971366,
0.019302303,
0.0420133732,
0.0658895522,
-0.0312587731,
-0.006725092,
0.004483467,
-0.0532666072,
0.0054421797,
0.038801454,
0.0169770066,
0.0633177683,
-0.0288664754,
-0.0204457138,
-0.0181369726,
-0.0865184739,
0.0190504733,
0.0553568788,
0.0051388615,
-0.0137620522,
-0.1085462272,
-0.0411799848,
0.0283565391,
-0.0112639833,
0.0386112593,
-0.0295663867,
-0.0329118557,
0.0250484254,
-0.004745055,
-0.0292845499,
-0.0112750186,
0.0408589989,
-0.0024644258,
0.0304033682,
-0.0586523935,
-6.005070564e-33,
-0.0085039213,
-0.0883127749,
-0.0107865576,
-0.0270559881,
0.0456157401,
0.0072491621,
-0.0085494639,
-0.0472138785,
-0.0034475503,
0.0504525155,
0.0164484642,
0.045090761,
0.0188655164,
0.0109556615,
-0.0086311018,
-0.0306758806,
0.0421981998,
0.0147760846,
-0.0308101159,
0.0287165474,
0.0221361183,
0.005457757,
0.0420956686,
-0.1182096228,
0.0967542455,
-0.0204655882,
-0.0359214917,
-0.009298889,
-0.0651526079,
0.0308814105,
-0.0207859538,
0.0457558967,
0.0363643691,
-0.0122341998,
0.01467543,
-0.0086387498,
-0.033407636,
-0.0237176809,
0.0333342291,
0.0292322412,
0.0301968083,
-0.0505221821,
0.0199559089,
0.0156817157,
-0.0273541007,
-0.0079090381,
0.0669274554,
-0.0320247076,
0.0239117183,
0.0318807848,
-0.085790813,
0.0414818451,
-0.0611971542,
0.0127160074,
0.0358669534,
0.0584925339,
0.047587987,
0.0250227228,
-0.0183967333,
0.0395667925,
0.0364210606,
-0.0522600748,
0.0301896669,
0.006283097,
-0.0093383417,
0.0530725196,
0.0483809225,
0.0182793327,
-0.0613252968,
-0.012275192,
-0.0029287366,
0.0112517178,
0.0970454887,
0.1517470181,
0.0706856325,
-0.0184463412,
-0.0850689784,
0.0171603151,
-0.016439762,
-0.0704414621,
0.0308966804,
-0.0038910971,
-0.0734779388,
-0.0361273475,
-0.0297534075,
-0.0532597005,
-0.0181038417,
0.0234552044,
-0.0039963289,
-0.0098929442,
-0.0369584225,
0.0640318021,
-0.0098597184,
-0.0614669323,
-0.0033656342,
0.0384028181,
-0.000187611,
-0.0123972334,
0.0094789164,
-0.0272246096,
-0.0045210239,
0.0030625786,
0.0296519417,
0.0349339209,
0.053520035,
0.0133522879,
0.0831175447,
0.0113492645,
-0.0332527608,
-0.0001695497,
-0.0218993574,
-0.023223307,
-0.0015511654,
-0.0193181206,
0.0323116034,
0.0384644605,
-0.009213984,
0.0222253464,
0.017931655,
0.031480588,
-0.0101239961,
0.0008780771,
-0.0448585153,
0.011442394,
0.0022795461,
-0.0243871622,
0.0302547067,
-0.0257865414,
0.0284944642,
-0.0560071617,
-0.024140723,
-0.0230710618,
2.596e-7,
0.0596667677,
0.0215754677,
0.051645644,
-0.0137281511,
0.0353313014,
0.0674663484,
-0.0011730139,
0.0064378907,
0.0062559801,
0.005072773,
0.0597918145,
0.0166556463,
0.0334460661,
0.0154562397,
-0.0061969003,
0.0337916352,
-0.049347654,
-0.036520347,
-0.0358774699,
0.033940874,
0.093929179,
0.0435972996,
0.0574123859,
-0.0011088724,
0.0160164665,
0.0159411151,
0.0467951037,
-0.0491499528,
0.0295747966,
-0.0147798685,
-0.0216882564,
-0.0153770484,
-0.014926496,
0.0611494146,
-0.0300147515,
-0.0022730634,
-0.0509781092,
0.0235938188,
-0.0475891903,
-0.0166552234,
-0.0554358214,
-0.04198974,
0.0089813331,
-0.0504502803,
0.0672044232,
0.0140249394,
-0.0295124054,
-0.0035459318,
-0.0335085988,
0.0159438569,
0.0096187592,
0.0264179893,
-0.0235225055,
0.0137673216,
-0.0189098697,
0.011499133,
0.0015404727,
-0.072936967,
-0.0529067367,
0.006730231,
-0.0159453284,
-0.0164689533,
-0.0092066675,
0.0464508235,
0.0756079331,
-0.0754186586,
0.0278380066,
2.467952456e-34,
0.0414322615,
0.055989638,
-0.0270415451,
-0.0129190404,
0.0488135964,
0.008555891,
0.0353948176,
0.0207446348,
0.0840807706,
-0.0247692261,
-0.0038358935
] |
Subsets and Splits