Datasets:

giuliadc

/

arxiv-filtered-978rows

like 0

1407.3534

over the last more than three decades ferroelectric liquid crystals ( flcs ) have attracted considerable attention as promising chiral liquid crystal materials for applications in fast switching display devices ( a detailed description of flcs can be found , e.g. , in monographs @xcite ) . equilibrium orientational structures in flcs are represented by helical twisting patterns where flc molecules align on average along a local unit director @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the smectic tilt angle ; @xmath4 is the twisting axis normal to the smectic layers and @xmath5 is the @xmath6-director . the flc director lies on the smectic cone depicted in fig . [ subfig : director ] with the _ smectic tilt angle _ @xmath3 and rotates in a helical fashion about a uniform twisting axis @xmath4 forming the flc helix with the _ helix pitch _ , @xmath7 . this rotation is described by the azimuthal angle around the cone @xmath8 that specifies orientation of the @xmath6-director in the plane perpendicular to @xmath4 and depends on the dimensionless coordinate along the twisting axis @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the helix twist wave number . the important case of a uniform lying flc helix in the slab geometry with the smectic layers normal to the substrates and @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the electric field applied across the cell , is illustrated in fig . [ fig : geom ] . this is the geometry of surface stabilized flcs ( ssflcs ) pioneered by clark and lagerwall in @xcite . they studied electro - optic response of flc cells confined between two parallel plates subject to homogeneous boundary conditions and made thin enough to suppress the bulk flc helix . it was found that such cells exhibit high - speed , bistable electro - optical switching between orientational states stabilized by surface interactions . the response of flcs to an applied electric field @xmath12 is characterized by fast switching times due to linear coupling between the field and the _ spontaneous ferroelectric polarization _ @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the _ polarization unit vector_. there is also a threshold voltage necessary for switching to occur and the process of bistable switching is typically accompanied by a hysteresis . figure [ subfig : cell ] also describes the geometry of deformed helix flcs ( dhflcs ) as it was introduced in @xcite . this case will be of our primary concern . in dhflc cells , the flc helix is characterized by a short submicron _ helix pitch _ , @xmath15 @xmath16 m , and a relatively large _ tilt angle _ , @xmath17 deg . by contrast to ssflc cells , where the surface induced unwinding of the bulk helix requires the helix pitch of a flc mixture to be greater than the cell thickness , a dhflc helix pitch is 5 - 10 times smaller than the thickness . this allows the helix to be retained within the cell boundaries . electro - optical response of dhflc cells exhibits a number of peculiarities that make them useful for lc devices such as high speed spatial light modulators @xcite , colour - sequential liquid crystal display cells @xcite and optic fiber sensors @xcite . the effects caused by electric - field - induced distortions of the helical structure underline the mode of operation of such cells . in a typical experimental setup , these effects are probed by performing measurements of the transmittance of normally incident linearly polarized light through a cell placed between crossed polarizers . a more general case of oblique incidence has not received a fair amount of attention . theoretically , a powerful tool to deal with this case is the transfer matrix method which has been widely used in studies of both quantum mechanical and optical wave fields @xcite . in this work we apply the method for systematic treatment of the technologically important case of dhflcs with subwavelength pitch also known as the _ short - pitch dhflcs_. recently , the transfer matrix approach to polarization gratings was employed to define the effective dielectric tensor of short - pitch dhflcs @xcite that gives the principal values and orientation of the optical axes as a function of the applied electric field . biaxial anisotropy and rotation of the in - plane optical axes produced by the electric field can be interpreted as the _ orientational kerr effect _ @xcite . it can be expected that the electric field dependence of the effective dielectric tensor will also manifest itself as electric - field - induced transformations of the polarization - resolved angular ( conoscopic ) patterns in the observation plane after the dhflc cells illuminated by convergent light beam . these patterns are represented by the two - dimensional ( 2d ) fields of polarization ellipses describing the polarization structure behind the conoscopic images @xcite . as it was originally recognized by nye @xcite , the key elements characterizing geometry of such stokes parameter fields are the _ polarization singularities _ that play the fundamentally important role of structurally stable topological defects ( a recent review can be found in ref . in particular , the polarization singularities such as the _ c points _ ( the points where the light wave is circular polarized ) and the _ l lines _ ( the curves along which the polarization is linear ) frequently emerge as the characteristic feature of certain polarization state distributions . for nematic and cholescteric ( chiral nematic ) liquid crystals , the singularity structure of the polarization - resolved angular patterns is generally found to be sensitive to both the director configuration and the polarization characteristics of incident light @xcite . in this study , we consider the polarization - resolved angular patterns of dhflc cells as the stokes parameter fields giving detailed information on the incidence angles dependence of the polarization state of light transmitted through the cells . in particular , we explore how the polarization singularities transform under the action of the electric field . our analysis will utilize the transfer matrix approach in combination with the results for the effective dielectric tensor of biaxial flcs evaluated using an improved technique of averaging over distorted helical structures . we also emphasize the role of phase singularities of a different kind and discuss the electro - optic behavior of dhflcs near the exceptional point where the condition of zero - field isotropy is fulfilled . the layout of the paper is as follows . in sec . [ sec : theory ] we introduce our notations and describe the transfer matrix formalism rendered into the @xmath18 matrix form suitable for our purposes . this formalism is employed to deduce a number of the unitarity and symmetry relations with emphasis on the planar anisotropic structures that represent dhflc cells and posses two optical axes lying in the plane of substrates . in sec . [ sec : optics - dhf ] we evaluate the effective dielectric tensor of dhflc cells , discuss the orientational kerr effect and show that electro - optic response of dhflc cells is enhanced near the exceptional point determined by the condition of zero - field isotropy . geometry of the polarization - resolved angular patterns emerging after dhflc cells is considered in sec . [ sec : conoscopy ] . after providing necessary details on our computational approach and the polarization singularities , we present the numerical results describing how the singularity structure of polarization ellipse fields transforms under the action of the electric field . finally , in sec . [ sec : discussion ] we draw the results together and make some concluding remarks . details on some technical results are relegated to appendixes [ sec : op - evol][sec : flc - spiral ] . in order to describe both the electro - optical properties and the polarization - resolved angular patterns of deformed helix ferroelectric liquid crystal layers with subwavelength pitch we adapt a general theoretical approach which can be regarded as a modified version of the well - known transfer matrix method @xcite and was previously applied to study the polarization - resolved conoscopic patterns of nematic liquid crystal cells @xcite . this approach has also been extended to the case of polarization gratings and used to deduce the general expression for the effective dielectric tensor of dhflc cells @xcite . in this section , we present the transfer matrix approach as the starting point of our theoretical considerations , with emphasis on its general structure and the symmetry relations . the analytical results for uniformly anisotropic planar structures representing homogenized dhflc cells are given in appendix [ sec : planar ] . we deal with a harmonic electromagnetic field characterized by the free - space wave number @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is the frequency ( time - dependent factor is @xmath21 ) , and consider the slab geometry shown in fig . [ fig : geom_4rays ] . in this geometry , an optically anisotropic layer of thickness @xmath22 is sandwiched between the bounding surfaces ( substrates ) : @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( the @xmath25 axis is normal to the substrates ) and is characterized by the dielectric tensor @xmath26 and the magnetic permittivity @xmath16 further , we restrict ourselves to the case of stratified media and assume that the electromagnetic fields can be taken in the following factorized form @xmath27 where the vector @xmath28 represents the lateral component of the wave vector . then we write down the representation for the electric and magnetic fields , @xmath12 and @xmath29 , @xmath30 where the components directed along the normal to the bounding surface ( the @xmath25 axis ) are separated from the tangential ( lateral ) ones . in this representation , the vectors @xmath31 and @xmath32 are parallel to the substrates and give the lateral components of the electromagnetic field . substituting the relations into the maxwell equations and eliminating the @xmath25 components of the electric and magnetic fields gives equations for the tangential components of the electromagnetic field that can be written in the following @xmath18 matrix form @xcite : @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the _ differential propagation matrix _ and its @xmath35 block matrices @xmath36 are given by [ eq : mij ] @xmath37 general solution of the system @xmath38 can be conveniently expressed in terms of the _ evolution operator _ which is also known as the _ propagator _ and is defined as the matrix solution of the initial value problem [ eq : evol_problem ] @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the @xmath41 identity matrix . basic properties of the evolution operator are reviewed in appendix [ sec : op - evol ] . in the ambient medium with @xmath42 and @xmath43 , the general solution can be expressed in terms of plane waves propagating along the wave vectors with the tangential component . for such waves , the result is given by @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the eigenvector matrix for the ambient medium given by @xmath46 @xmath47 are the pauli matrices @xmath48 from eq . , the vector amplitudes @xmath49 and @xmath50 correspond to the forward and backward eigenwaves with @xmath51 and @xmath52 , respectively . figure [ fig : geom_4rays ] shows that , in the half space @xmath53 before the entrance face of the layer @xmath23 , these eigenwaves describe the _ incoming and outgoing waves _ @xmath54 whereas , in the half space @xmath55 after the exit face of the layer , these waves are given by @xmath56 in this geometry , there are two plane waves , @xmath57 and @xmath58 , incident on the bounding surfaces of the anisotropic layer , @xmath23 and @xmath24 , respectively . then the standard linear input - output relations @xmath59 linking the vector amplitudes of transmitted and reflected waves , @xmath60 and @xmath61 with the amplitude of the incident wave , @xmath62 through the transmission and reflection matrices , @xmath63 and @xmath64 , assume the following generalized form : @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the matrix the so - called _ scattering matrix _ that relates the outgoing and incoming waves ; @xmath67 ( @xmath68 ) is the transmission ( reflection ) matrix for the case when the incident wave is incoming from the half space @xmath53 bounded by the entrance face , whereas the mirror symmetric case where the incident wave is impinging onto the exit face of the sample is described by the transmission ( reflection ) matrix @xmath69 ( @xmath70 ) . so , we have @xmath71 it is our task now to relate these matrices and the evolution operator given by eq . . to this end , we use the boundary conditions requiring the tangential components of the electric and magnetic fields to be continuous at the boundary surfaces : @xmath72 and @xmath73 , and apply the relation to the anisotropic layer of the thickness @xmath22 to yield the following result @xmath74 on substituting eqs . into eq . we have @xmath75 where the matrix @xmath76 linking the electric field vector amplitudes of the waves in the half spaces @xmath77 and @xmath78 bounded by the faces of the layer will be referred to as the _ transfer ( linking ) matrix_. the expression for the transfer matrix is as follows @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the rotated operator of evolution . this operator is the solution of the initial value problem with @xmath81 replaced with @xmath82 . from eqs . and , the block structure of the transfer matrix can be expressed in terms of the transmission and reflection matrices as follows @xmath83 similarly , for inverse of the transfer matrix , @xmath84 we have @xmath85 in appendix [ sec : op - evol ] , it is shown that , for non - absorbing media with symmetric dielectric tensor , @xmath86 , the operator of evolution satisfies the unitarity relation . by using eq . in combination with the algebraic identity [ eq : vm_identity ] @xmath87 where @xmath88 , for the eigenvector matrix given in eq . , we can deduce the unitarity relation for the transfer matrix @xmath89 the unitarity relation for non - absorbing layers can now be used to derive the energy conservation laws [ eq : energy_laws ] @xmath90}^{\dagger } } { { { \mathbf{t}}}^{t}}_{\pm}+ { { [ { { { \mathbf{r}}}^{t}}_{\mp}]}^{\dagger } } { { { \mathbf{r}}}^{t}}_{\mp } = { \mathbf{i}}_2 , \ ] ] where a dagger and the superscript @xmath91 will denote hermitian conjugation and matrix transposition , respectively , along with the relations for the block matrices [ eq : w_ij_unit ] @xmath92}^{\dagger } } , \\ & \label{eq : w_12_unit } { \mathbf{w}}_{12}=-{\mathbf{t}}_{+}^{-1 } { \mathbf{r}}_{-}= { { [ { \mathbf{t}}_{-}^{-1 } { \mathbf{r}}_{+}]}^{\dagger } } , \\ & \label{eq : w_21_unit } { \mathbf{w}}_{21}={\mathbf{r}}_{+ } { \mathbf{t}}_{+}^{-1}= -{{[{\mathbf{r}}_{- } { \mathbf{t}}_{-}^{-1}]}^{\dagger}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that eqs . and can be conveniently rewritten in the following form [ eq : rel - w_12_21 ] @xmath93}^{\dagger } } { { { \mathbf{r}}}^{\dagger}}_{+},\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that multiplying these identities and using the energy conservation law gives the relations . in the translation invariant case of uniform anisotropy , the matrix @xmath34 is independent of @xmath94 and the operator of evolution is given by @xmath95 then , the unitarity condition @xcite @xmath96 can be combined with eq . to yield the additional symmetry relations for @xmath97 @xmath98 where an asterisk will indicate complex conjugation , that give the following algebraic identities for the transmission and reflection matrices : @xmath99 it can be readily seen that the relation for the transposed matrices can be derived by substituting eq . into the conservation law . for the important special case of uniformly anisotropic planar structures with @xmath100 , the algebraic structure of the transfer matrix is described in appendix [ sec : planar ] . equation shows that the symmetry relations remain valid even if the dielectric constants are complex - valued and the medium is absorbing . since identities are derived from eqs . and without recourse to the unitarity relations , they also hold for lossy materials . similar remark applies to the expression for inverse of the transfer matrix . from eq . , it follows that the relation between the transmission ( reflection ) matrix , @xmath67 ( @xmath68 ) , and its mirror symmetric counterpart @xmath69 ( @xmath70 ) can be further simplified and is given by @xmath101 from eqs . and , we have the relation for the transposed reflection matrices @xmath102 whereas the transmission matrices are symmetric . we now pass on to the electro - optical properties of dhflc cells and extend the results of ref . @xcite to the case of biaxial ferroelectric liquid crystals with subwavelength pitch . in addition , the theoretical treatment will be significantly improved by using an alternative fully consistent procedure to perform averaging over distorted flc helix that goes around the limitations of the first - order approximation . we consider a flc film of thickness @xmath22 with the @xmath25 axis which , as is indicated in fig . [ fig : geom ] , is normal to the bounding surfaces : @xmath23 and @xmath24 , and introduce the effective dielectric tensor , @xmath103 , describing a homogenized dhflc helical structure . for a biaxial flc , the components of the dielectric tensor , @xmath104 , are given by @xmath105 where @xmath106 , @xmath107 is the kronecker symbol ; @xmath108 ( @xmath109 ) is the @xmath110th component of the flc director ( unit polarization vector ) given by eq . ( eq . ) ; @xmath111 are the _ anisotropy parameters _ and @xmath112 ( @xmath113 ) is the _ anisotropy ( biaxiality ) ratio_. note that , in the case of uniaxial anisotropy with @xmath114 , the principal values of the dielectric tensor are : @xmath115 and @xmath116 , where @xmath117 ( @xmath118 ) is the ordinary ( extraordinary ) refractive index and the magnetic tensor of flc is assumed to be isotropic with the magnetic permittivity @xmath16 . as in sec . [ sec : theory ] ( see fig . [ fig : geom_4rays ] ) , the medium surrounding the layer is optically isotropic and is characterized by the dielectric constant @xmath119 , the magnetic permittivity @xmath120 and the refractive index @xmath121 . at @xmath122 , the ideal flc helix @xmath123 where @xmath124 is the free twist wave number and @xmath125 is the equilibrium helical pitch , is defined through the azimuthal angle around the smectic cone @xmath8 ( see fig . [ fig : geom ] and eq . ) and represents the undistorted structure . for sufficiently small electric fields , the standard perturbative technique applied to the euler - lagrange equation gives the first - order expression @xcite for the azimuthal angle of a weakly distorted helical structure @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the electric field parameter linearly proportional to the ratio of the applied and critical electric fields : @xmath128 , and @xmath129 . according to ref . @xcite , normally incident light feels effective in - plane anisotropy described by the averaged tensor , @xmath130 : @xmath131 where @xmath132 , and the effective dielectric tensor @xmath133 can be expressed in terms of the averages @xmath134^{-1}}\rangle } } , \label{eq : eta } \\ & \beta_{z\alpha}= { \ensuremath{\langle{\epsilon_{z\alpha}/\epsilon_{zz}}\rangle } } = \left\langle \frac{u_1 d_z d_\alpha+u_2 p_z p_\alpha}{1+u_1 d_z^2+u_2 p_z^2 } \right\rangle , \label{eq : beta } \end{aligned}\ ] ] as follows @xmath135 general formulas - give the zero - order approximation for homogeneous models describing the optical properties of short pitch dhflcs @xcite . assuming that the pitch - to - wavelength ratio @xmath136 is sufficiently small , these formulas can now be used to derive the effective dielectric tensor of homogenized short - pitch dhflc cell for both vertically and planar aligned flc helix . the results for vertically aligned dhflc cells were recently published in ref . @xcite and we concentrate on the geometry of planar aligned dhflc helix shown in fig . [ fig : geom ] . for this geometry , the parameters needed to compute the averages @xmath130 ( see eq . ) , @xmath137 ( see eq . ) and @xmath138 ( see eq . ) are given by @xmath139 formulas can now be inserted into eqs . to yield the explicit expressions for the elements of the dielectric tensor : [ eq : epsilon - ij - planar ] @xmath140 the simplest averaging procedure previously used in refs . @xcite involves substituting the formula for a weakly distorted flc helix into eqs . and performing integrals over @xmath141 . this procedure thus heavily relies on the first - order approximation where the director distortions are described by the term linearly proportional to the electric field ( the second term on the right hand side of eq . ) . quantitatively , the difficulty with this approach is that the linear approximation may not be suffice for accurate computing of the second - order contributions to the diagonal elements of the dielectric tensor . in this approximation , the second - order corrections describing the helix distortions that involve the change of the helix pitch have been neglected . in order to circumvent the problem , in this paper , we apply an alternative approach that allows to go beyond the first - order approximation without recourse to explicit formulas for the azimuthal angle . this method is detailed in appendix [ sec : flc - spiral ] . the analytical results substituted into eqs . give the effective dielectric tensor in the following form : @xmath142 the _ zero - field dielectric constants _ , @xmath143 and @xmath144 , that enter the tensor are defined in eqs . and , respectively , and can be conveniently rewritten as follows [ eq : epsilon_ph ] @xmath145 a similar result for the _ coupling coefficients _ @xmath146 , @xmath147 and @xmath148 ( see eq . ) reads [ eq : coupling - coeffs ] @xmath149 note that , following ref . @xcite , we have used the relation to introduce the electric field parameter @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the dielectric susceptibility of the goldstone mode @xcite . the above dielectric tensor is characterized by the three generally different principal values ( eigenvalues ) and the corresponding optical axes ( eigenvectors ) as follows @xmath152 ^ 2+[\gamma_{xy } \alpha_{e}]^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath153 the in - plane optical axes are given by @xmath154.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eq . , it is clear that , similar to the case of uniaxial flcs studied in ref . @xcite , the zero - field dielectric tensor is uniaxially anisotropic with the optical axis directed along the twisting axis @xmath155 . the applied electric field changes the principal values ( see eqs . and ) so that the electric - field - induced anisotropy is generally biaxial . in addition , the in - plane principal optical axes are rotated about the vector of electric field , @xmath156 , by the angle @xmath157 given in eq . . in the low electric field region , the electrically induced part of the principal values is typically dominated by the kerr - like nonlinear terms proportional to @xmath158 , whereas the electric field dependence of the angle @xmath157 is approximately linear : @xmath159 . this effect is caused by the electrically induced distortions of the helical structure and bears some resemblance to the electro - optic kerr effect . following refs . @xcite , it will be referred to as the _ orientational kerr effect_. it should be emphasized that this effect differs from the well - known kerr effect which is a quadratic electro - optic effect related to the electrically induced birefringence in optically isotropic ( and transparent ) materials and which is mainly caused by the electric - field - induced orientation of polar molecules @xcite . by contrast , in our case , similar to polymer stabilized blue phase liquid crystals @xcite , we deal with the effective dielectric tensor of a nanostructured chiral smectic liquid crystal . this tensor is defined through averaging over the flc orientational structure . typically , in experiments dealing with the electro - optic response of dhflc cells , the transmittance of normally incident light passing through crossed polarizers is measured as a function of the applied electric field . for normal incidence , the transmission and reflection matrices can be easily obtained from the results given in appendix [ sec : planar ] by substituting eq . into eqs . - . when the incident wave is linearly polarized along the @xmath160 axis ( the helix axis ) , the transmittance coefficient @xmath161 where @xmath162 is the thickness parameter , describes the intensity of the light passing through crossed polarizers . note that , under certain conditions such as @xmath163 , @xmath164 and the transmittance can be approximated by simpler formula @xmath165 where @xmath166 is the difference in optical path of the ordinary and extraordinary waves known as the _ phase retardation_. in ref . @xcite , the relation was used to fit the experimental data using the theory based on the linear approximation for the helix distortions ( see eq . ) . these results are reproduced in figure [ fig : expt_th ] along with the theoretical curve computed using the modified averaging technique . from fig . [ fig : expt_th ] , it is seen that , in the range of relatively high voltages , the averaging method described in appendix [ sec : flc - spiral ] improves agreement between the theory and the experiment , whereas , at small voltages , the difference between the fitting curves is negligibly small . given the anisotropy and biaxiality ratios , @xmath167 and @xmath168 , the zero - field dielectric constants and the coupling coefficients are determined by the smectic tilt angle , @xmath3 . figure [ fig : gamma_theta ] shows how the coupling coefficients depend on @xmath3 for both uniaxially and biaxially anisotropic flcs . as it can be seen in fig . [ subfig : gamma_uni ] , in the case of conventional flcs with @xmath169 , all the coefficients are positive and the difference of the coupling constants @xmath170 that define the electrically induced part of @xmath171 ( see eq . ) is negative at @xmath172 . from eqs . and , it follows that , at @xmath169 , the principal values of dielectric constants @xmath173 and @xmath174 are decreasing functions of the electric field parameter @xmath175 so that anisotropy of the effective dielectric tensor is weakly biaxial . in addition , for non - negative @xmath175 and @xmath176 , the azimuthal angle of in - plane optical axis , @xmath177 , given in eq . increases with @xmath175 from zero to @xmath178 . figure [ subfig : gamma_bia ] demonstrates that this is no longer the case for biaxial flcs . it is seen that , at @xmath179 , the coupling coefficient @xmath147 and the difference @xmath170 both change in sign when the tilt angle @xmath3 is sufficiently small . at such angles , the dielectric constant @xmath173 increases with @xmath175 and the electric field induced anisotropy of dhflc cell becomes strongly biaxial . when @xmath170 and @xmath175 are positive , electric field dependence of the azimuthal angle @xmath177 is non - monotonic and the angle decays to zero in the range of high voltages where @xmath180 . at @xmath122 , the zero - field anisotropy is uniaxial and is described by the dielectric constants , @xmath143 and @xmath181 , given in eq . . [ fig : eph_theta ] , these constants are plotted against the tilt angle . it is shown that , at small tilt angles , the anisotropy @xmath182 is positive . it decreases with @xmath3 and the zero - field state becomes isotropic when , at certain critical angle @xmath183 , the condition of zero - field isotropy @xmath184 is fulfilled and @xmath185 . so , the angle @xmath186 can be referred to as the _ isotropization angle_. in what follows we discuss peculiarities of the electro - optic response in the vicinity of the _ isotropization point _ where @xmath171 is proportional to @xmath158 ( see eq . ) and the kerr - like regime breaks down . mathematically , the isotropization point represents a square root branch - point singularity of the eigenvalues of the dielectric tensor which is known as the _ exceptional point _ @xcite . in the electric field dependence of the in - plane dielectric constants , @xmath187 and @xmath174 , this singularity reveals itself as a cusp where the derivatives of @xmath188 with respect to @xmath175 are discontinuous . more precisely , we have @xmath189 as is illustrated in fig . [ subfig : epsilon_c_uni ] , the cusp is related to the effect of reconnection of different branches representing solutions of an algebraic equation . since the azimuthal angle @xmath177 is undetermined at @xmath183 @xmath190 the isotropization point also represents a phase singularity . the electric field dependence of @xmath177 is thus discontinuous and the relation @xmath191 describes its jumplike behaviour at @xmath122 . this behaviour is demonstrated in fig . [ fig : psi_alp ] . we can now use eq . and write down the condition of zero - field isotropy in the following explicit form : @xmath192 the case of a uniaxially anisotropic flc with @xmath169 can be treated analytically . in this case , it is not difficult to check that @xmath193 gives the special solution of eq . that does not depend on the tilt angle and corresponds to an isotropic material with @xmath194 . another solution is given by the relation @xmath195 linking the isotropization angle @xmath186 and the anisotropy parameter , @xmath196 . in fig . [ fig : theta_r1 ] , this solution is represented by the solid line curve . the isotropization angle is shown to be a slowly decreasing function of the anisotropy ratio @xmath167 . from eq . , it starts from the maximal value of @xmath186 is @xmath197 and decays approaching @xmath198 . when the biaxiality ratio @xmath168 differs from unity , the solution of the isotropy condition can only be written in the parametrized form as follows @xmath199 where @xmath200 the @xmath186 versus @xmath167 curves computed from the representation are shown in fig . [ fig : theta_r1 ] . it can be seen that , by contrast to the case of uniaxial anisotropy [ @xmath169 ] , for biaxial flcs with @xmath202 , each curve has two branches separated by a gap . the isotropization angle vanishes , @xmath203 , at one of the endpoints of the gap , @xmath204 , whereas the angle @xmath186 equals @xmath178 at the other endpoint . thus , dependence of the isotropization angle on the anisotropy ratio @xmath167 being smooth and continuous for uniaxially anisotropic flcs is found to be splitted into two branches when the flc anisotropy is biaxial . from fig . [ fig : theta_r1 ] , one of the branches with @xmath205 is associated with the endpoint at @xmath204 and lies below of the solid line curve representing conventional flcs . for this branch , the angle @xmath186 decreases with the biaxiality ratio reaching zero at @xmath206 . we conclude this section with the remark on the electro - optic response of dhflc cells in the vicinity of the isotropization point . one of the important factors governing the electric field dependence of the transmittance is the phase retardation @xmath207 ( see eq . ) proportional the effective birefringence @xmath208 . the electrically dependent part of this birefringence is plotted as a function of the electric field parameter in fig . [ fig : dn_alp ] . it shown that , at @xmath183 , the kerr - like regime breaks down and the birefringence is dominated by the terms linearly dependent on the electric field . such a pockels - like behaviour manifests itself in the perfectly harmonic dependence of the transmittance , @xmath209 , on the electric field parameter depicted in fig . [ subfig : transm_c_uni ] . figure [ subfig : transm_c-2_uni ] illustrates the effect of small deviations from the isotropization angle . though the curve presented in fig . [ subfig : transm_c-2_uni ] and the ones for flc-576a ( see fig . [ fig : expt_th ] ) are quite similar in shape , it is clear that sensitivity to the electric field and the magnitude of transmission peaks are both considerably enhanced near the isotropization point . such behaviour comes as no surprise and derives from the above discussed fact that this point plays the role of a singularity ( an exceptional point ) ( see eqs . ) . we can now combine the general relations deduced in sec . [ sec : theory ] ( and in appendix [ sec : planar ] ) using the transfer matrix method with the results of sec . [ sec : optics - dhf ] to study the _ polarization - resolved angular ( conoscopic ) patterns _ describing the polarization structure behind the conoscopic images of short - pitch dhflc cells that are characterized by the effective dielectric tensor . this polarization structure is represented by a two - dimensional ( 2d ) distribution of polarization ellipses and results from the interference of eigenmodes excited in the dhflc cells by the plane waves with varying direction of incidence . geometrically , the important elements of the 2d stokes parameter fields are the polarization singularities such as @xmath1 points ( the points where the light wave is circular polarized ) and @xmath0 lines ( the curves along which the polarization is linear ) . in this section the focus of our attention will be on the singularity structure of the polarization - resolved angular patterns emerging after the dhflc cells . our starting point is the computational method used to evaluate the patterns as the polarization ellipse fields . we shall use the electric field vector amplitudes of incident , reflected and transmitted waves conveniently rewritten in the circular basis @xmath210 and the incidence angles , @xmath211 and @xmath212 , related to the lateral component of the wave vector as follows @xmath213 where @xmath211 ( @xmath212 ) is the _ polar ( azimuthal ) angle of incidence_. dependence of the polarization properties of the waves transmitted through the dhflc cell on the incidence angles , @xmath211 and @xmath212 , will be of our primary concern . the transmission matrix describing conoscopic patterns on the transverse plane of projection is given by @xcite @xmath214 where @xmath215 and @xmath216 are the polar coordinates in the observation plane ( @xmath217 and @xmath218 are the cartesian coordinates ) and @xmath219 is the aperture dependent scale factor . the transmission matrix of dhflc cells , @xmath220 , can be computed from general formulas given in appendix [ sec : planar ] ( see eq . ) . for this matrix , the parameters @xmath221 that enter the expression for the dielectric tensor of planar structures should be replaced with the characteristics @xmath222 of the effective dielectric tensor given in eqs . . in what follows the incident light is assumed to be linearly polarized @xmath223 where @xmath224 is the polarization azimuth of the incident wave , and the state of polarization of the transmitted wave @xmath225 is defined by the polarization ellipse characteristics . the orientation of the polarization ellipse is specified by the azimuthal angle of polarization ( _ polarization azimuth _ ) @xmath226}^{\ast } } e_{-}^{({\mathrm{trm}})},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath227 is the @xmath110th component of the stokes vector , and its eccentricity is described by the signed ellipticity parameter @xmath228 that will be referred to as the _ ellipticity_. the ellipse is considered to be right handed ( left handed ) if its helicity is positive ( negative ) , so that @xmath229 ( @xmath230 ) . + from eq . , the incidence angles and the points in the observation plane are in one - to - one correspondence . so , computing the polarization azimuth , @xmath231 , the ellipticity , @xmath232 , at each point of the projection plane yields the 2d field of polarization ellipses which is called the polarization - resolved angular ( conoscopic ) pattern . the point where @xmath233 and thus the transmitted wave is circularly polarized with @xmath234 will be referred to as the _ c@xmath235 point_. this is an example of the _ polarization singularity _ that can be viewed as the _ phase singularities _ of the complex scalar field @xmath236 where the phase @xmath237 ( see eq . ) become indeterminate . such singularities are characterized by the _ winding number _ which is the signed number of rotations of the two - component field @xmath238 around the circuit surrounding the singularity @xcite . the winding number also known as the _ signed strength of the dislocation _ is generically @xmath239 . since the polarization azimuth is defined modulo @xmath240 and @xmath241 , the dislocation strength is twice the index of the corresponding @xmath242 point , @xmath243 . for generic @xmath1 points , @xmath244 and the topological index can be computed as the closed - loop contour integral of the phase @xmath245 modulo @xmath246 @xmath247 where @xmath0 is the closed path around the singularity . in addition to the handedness and the index , the @xmath1 points are classified according to the number of streamlines , which are polarization lines whose tangent gives the polarization azimuth , terminating on the singularity . this is the so - called _ line classification _ that was initially studied in the context of umbilic points @xcite . mathematically , the straight streamlines that terminate on the singularity are of particular importance as they play the role of separatrices , separating regions of streamlines with differently signed curvature . as is illustrated in fig . [ fig : singul - types ] , for generic @xmath1 points , the number of the straight lines , @xmath248 , may either be 1 or 3 . this number is @xmath249 provided the index equals @xmath250 , @xmath251 , and such @xmath1 points are called _ stars_. at @xmath252 , there are two characteristic patterns of polarization ellipses around a @xmath1 point : ( a ) _ lemon _ with @xmath253 and ( b ) _ monstar _ with @xmath254 @xcite . different quantitative criteria to distinguish between the @xmath1 points of the lemon and the monstar types were deduced in refs . @xcite . from these criteria it can be inferred that a lemon becomes a monstar as it approaches a star and @xmath1 point annihilation occurs only between stars and monstars @xcite . the case of linearly polarized wave with @xmath255 provides another example of the polarization singularity where the handedness is undefined . the curves along which the polarization is linear are called the _ l lines_. from eq . the @xmath1 points are nodal points of the scalar complex function @xmath256 which can be found as intersection points of the stokes parameter nodal lines @xmath257 and @xmath258 . similarly , equation implies that nodes of the stokes parameter field @xmath259 provide the @xmath0 lines where @xmath260 and @xmath255 . now we present the theoretical results for the polarization - resolved patterns of the dhflc cells . these patterns are computed for the cell of thickness @xmath261 @xmath16 m filled with the flc mixture flc-576a which was studied in ref . @xcite and described at the end of sec . [ subsec : kerr - effect ] . our first remark is that the angular dependence of the elements of the transmission matrix is determined by the angle difference @xmath262 which is the angle between the in - plane optical axis @xmath263 ( see eq . ) and the lateral wave vector @xmath264 ( see eq . ) . then the vector amplitudes [ eq : tilde_e_phi ] @xmath265 where @xmath266 is the angle between the optical axis @xmath263 and the polarization plane of the linearly polarized incident wave ( see eq . ) , describing the incident and transmitted waves with polarization ellipses rotated by the angle @xmath267 are related by the transformed transmission matrix @xmath268\,{\mathbf{t}}_{c}(\rho,-\tilde{\phi})\ , \exp[i\tilde{\phi}{\boldsymbol{\sigma}}_3].\end{aligned}\ ] ] from relation it follows that , given the angle @xmath266 , the sole effect of changing the azimuthal angle of the optical axis : @xmath269 is the rotation of the polarization ellipse field by the angle @xmath270 . in dhflc cells , this effect manifests itself as the electric field induced rotation and can be clearly seen in fig . [ fig : pol - f-20 ] that shows the patterns emerging after the dhflc cell calculated at @xmath271 deg for two values of the electric filed parameter : @xmath272 ( see fig . [ subfig : pol-00 - 20 ] ) and @xmath273 ( see fig . [ subfig : pol-03 - 20 ] ) . figure [ fig : pol - f-20 ] also illustrates the case of angular patterns that do not contain @xmath1 points . the geometry of such patterns is completely characterized by the @xmath0 lines . interestingly , at @xmath274 deg , it turned out that the @xmath259 nodal lines can be evaluated using the simplified equation @xmath275 where @xmath207 is the phase retardation expressed in terms of the eigenvalues of the matrix for uniformly anisotropic planar layers ( see eqs . and ) , that thus gives a sufficiently accurate approximation for @xmath0 lines . the angle @xmath266 can be regarded as the governing parameter whose magnitude determines the formation of @xmath1 points . given the aperture , the latter occurs only if the magnitude of @xmath266 exceeds its critical value . the case where the angle @xmath266 is close to the critical value is illustrated in fig . [ subfig : pol-00 - 39_5 ] . it can be seen that , at @xmath276 deg , the singularity structure of the polarization ellipse fields becomes complicated and is characterized by the presence of symmetrically arranged star - monstar pairs of @xmath1 points . in addition to the above discussed electric - field - induced rotation , the electric field is shown to facilitate the formation of @xmath1 points . clearly , the field induced biaxial anisotropy is responsible for this effect . in fig . [ fig : pol - f-41 ] , we show how the singularity structure of the polarization resolved patterns develops when the angle @xmath266 further increases . this structure can be described as symmetrically arranged chains of star - monstar pairs of @xmath1 points . as is indicated in fig . [ subfig : pol-03 - 41 ] , these tightly packed chains of @xmath1 points are generally located in the vicinity of the lines @xmath277 that give a high accuracy approximation for the @xmath278 nodal lines where @xmath258 and , similar to eq . , are determined by the phase retardation @xmath279 . note that , since @xmath280}^{\ast } } e_{p}^{({\mathrm{trm}})}$ ] , applicability of approximate formulas and implies that the phase difference between the components of the transmitted waves , @xmath281 and @xmath282 , is close to the phase retardation : @xmath283}^{\ast } } e_{p}^{({\mathrm{trm}})}\}\approx \delta$ ] . in sec . [ subsec : kerr - effect ] , a similar approximation has been used to derive the expression for the transmittance given by eq . . as it was mentioned in the previous section , the loci of @xmath1 points on the projection plane are determined by intersections of the @xmath278 and @xmath284 nodal lines . in our case , the star - monstar pairs are produced as a result of small - scale oscillations of the nodal line around the smooth curve described by eq . . experimentally , it is a challenging task to resolve accurately the chains of @xmath1 points resulting from such ripplelike oscillations in polarimetry measurements . the 2d polarization - resolved patterns are centrally symmetric being invariant under inversion through the origin : @xmath285 . the reason is that optical properties of planar anisotropic structures are unchanged under a 180-degree rotation about the normal to the cell ( the @xmath25 axis ) . more specifically , we have the central symmetry relation @xmath286 which is an immediate consequence of the fact that the matrix @xmath34 given in eqs . and remains intact when the azimuthal angle of the in - plane optic axis is changed by @xmath240 . another symmetry relation @xmath287 describes the transformation of the transmission matrix under reflection in the mirror symmetry axis directed along @xmath263 : @xmath288 . this relation immediately follows from eq . deduced in appendix [ sec : planar ] . by using formula , it is not difficult to show that the polarization ellipse field @xmath289 transforms into its mirror symmetric counterpart @xmath290 when the polarization azimuth @xmath266 changes its sign : @xmath291 . in this paper , we have performed transfer matrix analysis of polarization - resolved angular patterns emerging after electrically controlled short - pitch dhflc cells . our formulation of the transfer matrix method , which is a suitably modified version of the approach developed in refs . @xcite , involves the following steps : ( a ) derivation of the system of equations for the tangential components of the wave field in the @xmath18 matrix form ( see eq . ) ; ( b ) introducing the evolution operator ( propagator ) and the scattering matrix ; ( c ) defining the transfer matrix through the propagator and , finally , ( d ) deducing formulas that link the transfer and scattering matrices . description of this method is augmented by discussion of a variety of unitarity and symmetry relations ( see sec . [ subsec : symmetry ] and appendix [ sec : planar ] ) , with an emphasis on the special case of anisotropic planar structures representing homogenized dhflc cells . interestingly , the relations given in eqs . , and are shown to be essentially independent of the assumption of lossless materials and thus can be used when the medium is absorbing . in general , we found that , owing to its mathematical structure , the transfer matrix approach provides the framework particularly useful for in - depth analysis of symmetry related properties ( recent examples of such analysis can be found , e.g. , in refs . @xcite ) . similarly , one of the important results of a rigorous analysis performed within such a framework in ref . @xcite is the expression for the effective dielectric tensor describing the electro - optical properties of uniform lying flc helical structures with subwavelengh pitch . in sec . [ sec : optics - dhf ] we have extended theoretical considerations of ref . @xcite to the case of biaxial flcs and have applied an alternative technique of averaging over distorted helix to evaluate the dielectric tensor . this technique is presented in appendix [ sec : flc - spiral ] and gets around the difficulties of the method that relies on the well - known first - order expression for a weakly distorted helix . the modified averaging procedure allows high - order corrections to the dielectric tensor to be accurately estimated and improves agreement between the theory and the experimental data in the high - field region ( see fig . [ fig : expt_th ] ) . the resulting electric field dependence of the effective dielectric tensor is linear ( quadratic ) for non - diagonal ( diagonal ) elements with the coupling coefficients given by eq . . these coupling coefficients along with the zero - field dielectric constants determine how the applied electric field @xmath292 changes the principal values of the effective dielectric tensor ( see eqs . and ) and the azimuthal angle of optical axis . generally , at @xmath122 , the dhflc cell is uniaxially anisotropic with the dielectric constants , @xmath144 and @xmath143 , and the optical axis directed along the helix axis . then there are two most important effects induced by the electric field : ( a ) producing biaxial anisotropy by changing the eigenvalues of the dielectric tensor ; and ( b ) rotation of in - plane optical axes by the field dependent angle @xmath157 defined in eq . at sufficiently low electric field @xmath292 and non - vanishing zero - field anisotropy , the kerr - like regime takes place so that the principal values depend on the electric field quadratically whereas the optical axis angle @xmath157 is approximately proportional to @xmath292 . this is the orientational kerr effect previously studied in refs . @xcite for different geometries . our results on dependence of the coupling coefficients and the zero - field dielectric constants on the smectic tilt angle @xmath3 described in sec . [ subsec : tilt ] indicate a number of differences between uniaxial and biaxial flcs . what is more important , they show that the zero - field anisotropy may vanish at certain value of @xmath3 which might be called the isotropization angle : @xmath183 ( see fig . [ fig : eph_theta ] ) . in sec . [ subsec : isotropy ] , the isotropization point determined by the condition of zero - field isotropy is found to represent a singularity known as the exceptional point @xcite . for analytic continuation of the dielectric tensor in the complex @xmath175 plane , the exceptional points occur at the zeros of the square root in eq . where @xmath293 ^ 2+[\gamma_{xy}\alpha_e]^2=0 $ ] . in general , there are two pairs of complex conjugate values of electric field parameter representing four exceptional ( branch ) points . when the difference @xmath294 vanishes , the two branch points coalesce on the real axis at the origin . in the case of conventional uniaxial flcs , the analytic solution of the condition of zero - field isotropy can be obtained in the closed form and is given by simple formula where the isotropization angle , @xmath186 , is found to be a decreasing function of the anisotropy parameter @xmath295 . for biaxial flcs with @xmath296 , the solution can only be written in the parametrized form . as it can be seen in fig . [ fig : theta_r1 ] , the corresponding @xmath186-@xmath167 curves are splitted into two branches separated by the gap . these results significantly differ from the relation @xmath297 that can be easily obtained @xcite for the dielectric tensor averaged over the flc helix : @xmath298{\mathbf{i}}_3 + [ u_1\cos^2\theta - ( u_1\sin^2\theta+u_2)/2]{\hat{\mathbf{x}}}\otimes{\hat{\mathbf{x}}}$ ] . the difference stems from the fact that , in our approach , the effective dielectric tensor @xmath299 is defined through the averaged differential propagation matrix @xmath300 and thus is not equal to the averaged dielectric tensor : @xmath301 at the exceptional point , the kerr - like regime breaks down and the electric field dependence of the birefringence becomes linear ( see fig . [ fig : dn_alp ] ) . this might be called the pockels - like regime which is characterized by the harmonic electric field dependence of the transmittance of light passing through crossed polarizers ( see fig . [ subfig : transm_c_uni ] ) . the curve shown in fig . [ subfig : transm_c-2_uni ] illustrates the electro - optical response of a dhflc cell near the exceptional point . it is seen that sensitivity to the electric field and the magnitude of the transmittance at peaks are both considerably enhanced as compared to the case studied in ref . @xcite ( see also fig . [ fig : expt_th ] ) . we now try to put these results in a more general physical context . in quantum physics , the exceptional points are known to produce a variety of interesting phenomena including level repulsion and crossing , bifurcation , chaos and quantum phase transitions @xcite . for optical wave fields , a recent example is unidirectional propagation ( reflection ) of light at the exceptional points in parity - time ( @xmath302 ) symmetric periodic structures and metamaterials that has been the subject of intense studies @xcite . to the best of our knowledge , the role of exceptional points in optics of liquid crystal systems has yet to be recognized . the main problem with conventional uniaxial flcs is that the isotropy condition requires large values of the smectic tilt angle that are typically well above @xmath303 deg . though there are no fundamental limitations preventing preparation of flc mixtures with large tilt angles , this task still remains a challenge to deal with in the future . biaxial flcs , where the isotropization tilt angle can be sufficiently small when @xmath304 is close to @xmath305 , also present a promising alternative approach for future work . in sec . [ sec : conoscopy ] , in order to gain further insight into the electro - optical properties of the dhflc cells , we have combined the transfer matrix approach and the results for the effective dielectric tensor to explore the polarization - resolved angular patterns which are the polarization ellipse fields representing the polarization structure of conoscopic images of dhflc cells . in the observation plane , such 2d patterns encode information on how the polarization state of transmitted light is changed with the incidence angles and exhibit singularities of a different kind , the polarization singularities such as @xmath0 lines ( lines of linear polarization ) and @xmath1 points ( points of circular polarization ) . note that , similar to the above discussed exceptional point at which the angle @xmath157 becomes undetermined , @xmath1 points can be regarded as phase singularities ( optical phase singularities are reviewed in ref . @xcite ) . since the differential propagation matrix of planar structures is invariant under rotation of in - plane optical axes by @xmath240 , the patterns are centrally symmetric [ see figs . [ fig : pol - f-20]- [ fig : pol - f-41 ] ] . it was shown that , at fixed the angle @xmath306 between the optical axis @xmath263 and the polarization plane of incident wave , the sole effect of the electric - field - induced rotation by the angle @xmath157 is rotation of the polarization ellipse field as a whole by the same angle . the symmetry axis of the @xmath259 nodal lines ( @xmath0 lines ) is found to be directed along @xmath263 . when the @xmath266 is not too small , they can be approximated by solving eq . and thus are mainly determined by the phase retardation @xmath207 . similar remark applies to the @xmath278 lines and approximate formula . it turned out that this is the angle @xmath266 that plays the role of the parameter governing formation of @xmath1 points . when the magnitude of @xmath266 exceeds its critical value which , in our case , is close to @xmath307 deg , @xmath1 points emerge as symmetrically arranged and densely packed chains of star - monstar pairs ( see figs . [ fig : pol - f-39_5]-[fig : pol - f-41 ] ) . so , in dhflc cells , rotation of polarization ellipse fields and formation of @xmath1 points are two most important effects describing electrically induced transformations of the polarization - resolved angular patterns . these predictions can be verified experimentally . this work is now in progress . this work is supported by the hkust grant itp/039/12np . we begin with the relation @xmath308 known as the _ composition law_. this result derives from the fact that the operator @xmath309 is the solution of the system that satisfies the initial condition with @xmath310 replaced by @xmath311 . from the composition law it immediately follow that the inverse of the evolution operator is given by @xmath312 and can be found by solving the initial value problem @xmath313 for non - absorbing media with symmetric dielectric tensor , the matrix @xmath34 is real - valued , @xmath314 , and meets the following symmetry identities @xcite : @xmath315 where an asterisk and the superscript @xmath91 indicate complex conjugation and matrix transposition , respectively . in this case , the evolution operator and its inverse are related as follows : @xmath316 where a dagger will denote hermitian conjugation . by using the relations , it is not difficult to verify that the operator on the right hand side of eq . is the solution of the cauchy problem . in this section we present the results for anisotropic planar structures characterized by the dielectric tensor of the following form : @xmath317 where the optical axes @xmath318 lie in the plane of substrates ( the @xmath160-@xmath319 plane ) . the operator of evolution can be expressed in terms of the eigenvalue and eigenvector matrices , @xmath320 and @xmath321 , as follows @xmath322 for the dielectric tensor , @xmath323 and @xmath324 ( see eq . ) . assuming that @xmath325 , we have @xmath326 where @xmath327 and @xmath328 are the principal refractive indices ; @xmath329 is the parameter of in - plane anisotropy . for the case where the diagonal block - matrices , @xmath330 and @xmath331 , vanish , it is not difficult to show that the eigenvector and eigenvalue matrices can be taken in the following form : @xmath332 in addition , the eigenvectors satisfy the orthogonality conditions ( a proof can be found , e.g. , in appendix a of ref . @xcite ) that , for the eigenvector matrix of the form , can be written as follows @xmath333 upon substituting eqs . - into eq . , some rather straightforward algebraic manipulations give the transfer matrix @xmath334 { \mathbf{n}}^{-1 } , \\ & \label{eq : a_pm - pln } { \mathbf{a}}_{\pm}={\mathbf{e}}_{{\mathrm{m } } } { \mathbf{h}}\pm{\mathbf{h}}_{{\mathrm{m } } } { \mathbf{e}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath335 . from eq . , the block @xmath35 matrices of @xmath336 are given by [ eq : tw_ij - pln ] @xmath337}^{t}}= \notag \\ & = { \mathbf{a}}_{- } { \mathbf{w}}_{- } { \mathbf{a}}_{+}^{t}-{\mathbf{a}}_{+ } { \mathbf{w}}_{+ } { { { \mathbf{a}}}^{t}}_{-}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , we can combine eq . and eq . with eq . to derive the expressions for the transmission and reflection matrices @xmath338 describing the case where the incident wave is impinging onto the entrance face of the layer , @xmath23 . as it can be seen from formulas , the symmetry relations are satisfied even if the dielectric constants @xmath339 , @xmath340 and @xmath173 are complex - valued . so , the applicability range of identities includes lossy ( absorbing ) anisotropic materials described by the dielectric tensor of the form given in eq . . interestingly , inverse of the transfer matrix , @xmath341 , can be obtained from formula by changing sign of the thickness parameter @xmath342 : @xmath343 . in formulas , this transformation interchanges the matrices @xmath344 and @xmath345 , so that @xmath346 and @xmath347 . so , from eq . , the block matrices of @xmath341 are given by [ eq : w_inv_pln ] @xmath348 from the other hand , eqs . and give the transfer matrix and its inverse , respectively , expressed in terms of the transmission and reflection matrices , @xmath349 and @xmath350 . these expressions can now be substituted into eq . to yield the relations @xmath351 linking the transmission ( reflection ) matrix , @xmath352 ( @xmath353 ) , and its mirror symmetric counterpart @xmath69 ( @xmath70 ) . in conclusion of this section , we consider how the transmission and reflection matrices transform under the reflection in the @xmath354 plane when the azimuthal angle @xmath355 changes its sign : @xmath356 . from eqs . and , we have @xmath357 by using eq . it is not difficult to deduce a similar relation for the transfer matrix @xmath358 that can be combined with eq . to yield the result for the transmission and reflection matrices in the final form : @xmath359 an important point is that , similar to identities , the assumption of lossless ( non - absorbing ) medium is not required to derive the symmetry relations and eq . . for the case of uniaxially anisotropic structure with @xmath360 , it is not difficult to find the expressions for the eigenvalues that enter the eigenvalue matrix @xmath361 where @xmath362 ( @xmath363 ) is the refractive index for ordinary ( extraordinary ) waves and @xmath329 is the anisotropy parameter . similarly , after computing the eigenvectors , we obtain the eigenvector matrix in the following form : @xmath364 & m_yq_o \\ m_y & -m_xq_o \end{pmatrix } , \quad { \mathbf{h}}= \begin{pmatrix } m_x q_e & m_y n_o^2 \\ m_y q_e & -m_x [ n_o^2-q_p^2 ] \end{pmatrix } , \\ & \label{eq : n_oe - pln - uni } n_{e}=\dfrac{2q_e\mu}{n_o^2}(n_o^2-q_p^2m_x^2 ) , \quad n_{o}=2q_o\mu ( n_o^2-q_p^2m_x^2).\end{aligned}\ ] ] equations - can now be substituted into the general expression for the transfer matrix defined by formulas - so as to obtain the transmission and reflection matrices . for the general case of biaxial anisotropy , the expressions for the eigenvalues are more complicated than those for uniaxially anisotropic layer ( see eq . ) . these can be written in the following form : @xmath365 ^ 2 - 4\det{\tilde{{\mathbf{m } } } } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the matrix @xmath366 is given by [ eq : tilde - m - pln ] @xmath367 \cdot{\mathbf{rt}}(\psi)= \begin{pmatrix } \tilde{m}_{11 } & \tilde{m}_{12}\\ \tilde{m}_{21 } & \tilde{m}_{22 } \end{pmatrix } , \\ & \label{eq : tilde - m-11 } \tilde{m}_{11}=n_{e}^2-(u_a+u_z[1+u_a])\,q_p^2 m_x^2 , \quad \tilde{m}_{12}=(u_a+u_z[1+u_a])\ , q_p^2 m_x m_y , \\ & \label{eq : tilde - m-22 } \tilde{m}_{22}=n_{o}^2-u_z q_p^2 m_y^2 , \quad \tilde{m}_{21}=u_z q_p^2 m_x m_y,\quad u_z=(\epsilon_{\perp}-\epsilon_z)/\epsilon_z.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it can be readily checked that the result for uniaxial anisotropy is recovered from eq . as the limiting case where the parameter of out - of - plane anisotropy @xmath368 is negligible and @xmath360 . for the eigenvector and normalization matrices , @xmath321 and @xmath369 , given in eq . and eq . , respectively , the results are @xmath370 these relations along with formulas give the transfer matrix for biaxially anisotropic films with two in - plane optical axes . before closing this section we briefly comment on the important special case of normal incidence that occurs at @xmath371 . in this case , the matrices @xmath372 defined in eq . can be written in the factorized form @xmath373 where @xmath374 is the matrix describing rotation about the @xmath25 axis by the angle @xmath216 . substituting eq . into eq . gives the block matrices @xmath375 expressed as a function of the director azimuthal angle @xmath355 . the result for the transmission and reflection matrices @xmath376 where the diagonal matrices @xmath377 and @xmath378 describe the case in which the director lies in the incidence plane , immediately follows from the relations and . in sec . [ subsec : diel - tensor - dhf ] , the effective dielectric tensor of a deformed helix flc cell is expressed in terms of the averages given in eqs . and . in this apppendix , we describe how to perform averaging over the helix pitch without recourse to explicit formulas for the azimuthal angle @xmath8 the flc director . we assume that the azimuthal angle is a function of @xmath160 , so that the free energy density can be written in the following form : @xmath379 where @xmath124 is the free twist wave number . then the free energy functional per unit volume can be written as the free energy density averaged over the helix pitch @xmath380/v={\ensuremath{\langle{f}\rangle}}_{x}\equiv \frac{1}{p}\int_0^p f { \mathrm{d}}x.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first integral of the stationary point ( euler - lagrange ) equation @xmath381 is given by @xmath382 ^ 2 + u_{e}\cos\phi = e.\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming that @xmath383 and @xmath384 is non - negative , equation can be recast into the differential form @xmath385 integrating eq . over the period yields the relation for the helix wave number @xmath386 where @xmath387 . this relation gives the helix pitch , @xmath7 , expressed in terms of the dimensionless parameter @xmath388 . we can now use equation to rewrite eq . in the following form @xmath389^{-1/2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] an important consequence of this equation is the relation @xmath390 that allows to perform averaging over the helix pitch by computing integrals over the azimuthal angle @xmath8 . in particular , with the help of eqs . and , it is not difficult to deduce the following expression for the free energy : @xmath391)= \notag \\ u_k\left [ 1-m^{-1}\bigl\ { 1 + 2 ( \sqrt{m}-{\ensuremath{\langle{r^{-1}}\rangle}}_{\phi})/{\ensuremath{\langle{r}\rangle}}_{\phi } \bigr\ } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the low voltage regime , the parameter @xmath392 is small and the left hand side of eq . can be expanded into the power series in @xmath392 . the expansion up to the second order terms is given by @xmath393 and can be used to average the @xmath25 component of the polarization vector @xmath394 defined in eq . . the result reads @xmath395 where @xmath151 is the dielectric susceptibility of the goldstone mode @xcite and @xmath396 . similarly , the averages that enter the formulas for the elements of the effective dielectric tensor can be expressed in terms of the electric field parameter @xmath175 as follows : [ eq : averages - planar ] @xmath397^{-1/2}(1 + 3 v\gamma_v^2\alpha_e^2 ) , \\ & { \ensuremath{\langle{v_{zz}^{-1}\cos^2\phi}\rangle}}_{\phi } \approx \gamma_v(1 + 3 [ 1+v]^{1/2}\gamma_v\alpha_e^2 ) , \\ & { \ensuremath{\langle{v_{zz}^{-1}\cos\phi}\rangle}}_{\phi } \approx 2 \gamma_v\alpha_{e } , \quad \gamma_v= [ \sqrt{1+v}+1]^{-1 } , \\ & { \ensuremath{\langle{v_{zz}^{-1}\sin\phi}\rangle}}_{\phi}= { \ensuremath{\langle{v_{zz}^{-1}\sin\phi\cos\phi}\rangle}}_{\phi}= 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting the relations into eqs . give the effective dielectric tensor which is expressed in terms of the zero - field dielectric constants @xmath398 , \\ & \label{eq : epsilon_p - v } \epsilon_p = \epsilon_2\sqrt{1+v } , \quad \gamma_v=[\sqrt{1+v}+1]^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the coupling coefficients @xmath399 , \\ & \gamma_{yy } =3 \epsilon_2 v \gamma_v^2\sqrt{1+v } , \quad \gamma_{xy } = 2 ( \epsilon_{1}-\epsilon_{\perp})\gamma_v\cos\theta\sin\theta.\end{aligned}\ ] ] 45ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _ ( , , ) p. @noop _ _ , the liquid crystals book series ( , , ) p. @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) p. @noop _ _ , ed . ( , , ) p. @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) p. @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , ed . , , vol . ( , , ) p. @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 94 - 007 - 1530 - 1 [ _ _ ] , ed . ( , , ) p. link:\doibase 10.1109/tap.2012.2220316 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.053902 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.85.064103 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.213901 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nmat3576 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.89.065801 [ * * , ( ) ]

in order to explore electric - field - induced transformations of polarization singularities in the polarization - resolved angular ( conoscopic ) patterns emerging after deformed helix ferroelectric liquid crystal ( dhflc ) cells with subwavelength helix pitch , we combine the transfer matrix formalism with the results for the effective dielectric tensor of biaxial flcs evaluated using an improved technique of averaging over distorted helical structures . within the framework of the transfer matrix method , we deduce a number of symmetry relations and show that the symmetry axis of @xmath0 lines ( curves of linear polarization ) is directed along the major in - plane optical axis which rotates under the action of the electric field . when the angle between this axis and the polarization plane of incident linearly polarized light is above its critical value , the @xmath1 points ( points of circular polarization ) appear in the form of symmetrically arranged chains of densely packed star - monstar pairs . we also emphasize the role of phase singularities of a different kind and discuss the enhanced electro - optic response of dhflcs near the exceptional point where the condition of zero - field isotropy is fulfilled .

nucl-ex0103002

among the physical methods of importance for archaeological applications , dating techniques occupy a special place . historians need a variety of information regarding their objects : structure , provenance , culture or authenticity@xmath1 . at the same time there is a great need of dating with precise and objective techniques of the historically valuable material . there are two categories of physical methods of dating , namely one in which the measured quantity decreases with time , and one in which the physical quantity accumulates in the sample with time . to the first category belong the methods in which the information on age is given by the disintegration rate of a radioactive nucleus , ranging from @xmath2k , th and u ( relatively abundant isotopes ) to more rare isotopes such as @xmath0c , @xmath3be , @xmath4al , @xmath5si , @xmath6cl , @xmath7ca , @xmath8mn , @xmath9pb . the second category includes the methods that are based on the measurement of the accumulated defects produced by radiation in the environment , using various techniques : thermoluminescence , electron paramagnetic resonance , fission traces in rocks . among dating methods , radiocarbon dating is the most frequently used . in recent decades accelerator mass spectrometry ( ams)@xmath10 , which constitutes a highly sensitive method for counting atoms , has been used for the detection of @xmath0c . the fact that ams counts atoms and not decays results in great advantages compared to radiometric techniques , requiring smaller samples and shorter measuring times . in the present work we have studied using the ams technique a fossil bone found in the course of the archaeological excavation of a workshop for the processing of flintstones at malu rosu , giurgiu , near the danube river , in romania . this archaeological assembly is believed to have an age of about 20,000 years , as based on an historical assessment . other specimens of fossil bones from malu rosu have earlier been analyzed by a relative chemical method . the age was estimated by determining the fluorine content@xmath11 using neutron activation analysis ( naa ) . _ pretreatment of the bone sample _ + the first step concerns the extraction of collagen from the bone structure . collagen is the native , biochemically intact triple - helical macromolecule . we will use collagen to refer to collagen that has undergone a degree of diagenesis . alterations during diagenesis are considered to include humification of parts of the molecule , attachment of exogenous humic materials , and hydrolysis with loss of some amino acids . we have essentially applied the longin method@xmath12 : + a dried bone specimen of about 1 g is powdered using a hard knife . the bone powder is put into a glass vessel with a rubber cork , which is then connected to a vacuum pump . about 70 - 80 ml of 2% hcl is added in drops to the bone powder to remove the carbonates . the co@xmath13 released is evacuated by pumping for 2 - 5 minutes . the bone is left in this solution for 15 - 24 h. collagen is then retrieved as a sediment in the vessel . the acid is poured off and the bone sample is washed with distilled water three times ( until the solution is neutral ) . the collagen is transferred to a 50 ml vessel . 20 - 30 ml of distilled water is added together with some drops of 2% hcl to obtain a ph in the range 2 - 3 . this solution is kept at a temperature of 90 @xmath14c overnight . the ph must remain in the range 2 - 3 for the whole period of heating , which ensures that the collagen is dissolved . + the collagen solution is filtered to remove all the impurities , and put in the oven at 110 @xmath14c until is completely evaporated . the collagen , in gelatin form is thus concentrated at the bottom of the test tube . + _ transformation to elemental carbon _ + the next step in the preparation of the bone sample is the transformation of the collagen into pure carbon in the experimental set - up , presented in detail in refs . 6 , 8 and 9 . the conversion to elemental carbon is done in two steps : the formation of co@xmath13 by the combustion of the collagen , and the reduction of co@xmath13 to carbon . + . about 200 mg of cuo as oxidation agent is added to the collagen sample in the test tube in order to attain a 100% combustion . the system is evacuated and the test tube containing the sample is heated with a flame . the water vapor that is released during the combustion is caught in a cold trap . + . about 10 mg of metallic iron is put into a double - legged test tube as catalyst for the reduction of the co@xmath13 to carbon . prior to the reduction process , the catalyst is heated under vacuum to 650 @xmath14c . with co@xmath13 transferred to and frozen in the cold trap of the reduction part of the apparatus , hydrogen gas is let into the system . it is suitable to have 3 times more hydrogen gas than carbon dioxide . the reduction process takes about 4 h. when the reduction is complete , the carbon sample is dried by pumping for about 20 minutes . the carbon sample and the iron catalyst are pressed into a copper holder with a stainless steel piston . the iron catalyst provides a good thermal conduction of the sample , which is important for the sputtering process into the ion source . the copper holder with the pure carbon sample is put into the ion source of the accelerator . the sample of bone , as pure carbon in the copper holder is arranged in a wheel with 20 positions in the following sequence : 2 standards of oxalic acid , 1 standard of anthracite , 15 carbon samples , with the other 2 positions being for a graphite and an optimizing sample . anthracite , being a very old coal is considered to contain no traces of @xmath0c traces and by its measurement the background for @xmath0c is obtained both of the accelerator and of the preparation procedure of the samples . oxalic acid is a standard srm prepared by the usa national bureau of standards , with an accurately known activity of @xmath0c . the oxalic acid is used to normalize the value of the @xmath0c/@xmath15c ratio of the sample . the wheel with samples and standards is put into the ion source of the accelerator . the central part of the lund ams system is a pelletron tandem accelerator , model 3udh , produced by nec , wisconsin usa , and is shown in fig . the accelerator is run at 2.4 mv during ams experiments , which is optimal for the c@xmath16 charge state when using 3 @xmath17g/@xmath18 carbon stripper foils . on the experimental beam line a magnetic quadrupole triplet , a velocity filter and a second analyzing magnet have been installed . the @xmath15c@xmath16 beam current is usually @xmath19 80 na . the particle identification and measuring system consists of a silicon surface barrier detector of @xmath20=25 mm . part of the accelerator system is operated and controlled by a pc - based system . the computer system analyses alternately the data of the @xmath15c current received from a current integrator and the @xmath0c counts arriving from the particle detector , to obtain , finally , the ratio @xmath0c/@xmath15c for each sample . this ratio is corrected for the background ( obtained from the anthracite and oxalic acid standards ) for every sample . each sample has been measured 7 times . the precision of the measurements is around 1 % . the age of the bone was determined in two steps : first the _ conventional radiocarbon age _ was calculated and then the age was converted to calendar years , taking into consideration the fluctuations of the @xmath0c concentration in the atmosphere over time . the conventional radiocarbon age was calculated by the equation @xmath21 : @xmath22}}{0.9558\,(^{14}c/^{13}c)_{ox[-19]}}\biggr)\ , { \rm years } \ , { \rm bp}\ ] ] where @xmath23}$ ] is the isotopic ratio for the sample , corrected for the background , normalized to @xmath24=-25 @xmath25 + and @xmath26}$ ] is the isotopic ratio for the oxalic acid standard , corrected for the background , normalized to @xmath24=-19 @xmath25 , + with @xmath24 being : @xmath27\,\times\,1000\,\,\%_0\ ] ] where @xmath28 is the @xmath15c/@xmath29c isotopic ratio for the sample and the oxalic acid , respectively , and @xmath30 is the @xmath15c/@xmath29c isotopic ratio of the @xmath31 standard . the conventional radiocarbon age of the bone is expressed in years bp , where present is defined to be ad 1950 . the conventional radiocarbon age for the analyzed bone from malu rosu has been determined to be : 4790@xmath3290 bp . the conversion into calendar years was done using the oxcal software @xmath15 ( see fig . 2 ) , using data from ref . 14 . from the processing of the data one obtained the age of the bone from malu rosu to be in the interval : [ [ comparison - of - the - radiocarbon - age - with - the - age - estimated - by - fluorine - content ] ] comparison of the radiocarbon age with the age estimated by fluorine content ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ the method of dating by measuring the fluorine content has been used since the end of the 19@xmath33 century . the increase of the fluorine content is the result of the contact of the fossil bone with underground water which contains fluorine@xmath34 . the main inorganic component of the bone , hydroxyapatite is slowly altered by the exchange of hydroxyl ions ( oh@xmath35 ) with ions f@xmath35 : the rate of accumulation of fluorine in bones depends on the environmental conditions of the burials , the temperature and the content of fluorine in underground waters . + some specimens of bones from malu rosu have been analyzed before by naa to determine their fluorine content@xmath11 . the irradiations were done at the vvr - s nuclear reactor at ifin bucharest , at a flux of 10@xmath29 neutrons/@xmath40s@xmath41 . samples of bones together with standards of pbf@xmath13 and caf@xmath13 were irradiated for a period of 4 s , for producing the isotope @xmath42f , with a half life of t@xmath43=11 s and the main @xmath44-ray of 1633.6 kev . the periods of decays and times of measurement for the sample were : t@xmath45=40 s , t@xmath46=20 s , and for the standard : t@xmath45=80 s , t@xmath46=20 s. for 8 specimens of bones from romanian regions , c1 , c2 , c4 , c5 , c6 , c8 and c9 , dated by radiocarbon at groeningen , the following correlation was established : fluorine concentration - age ( radiocarbon ) . for other bones : b1 ( cave bear ) , b2 ( cave bear ) , b3 ( cave bear ) , b4 ( mammoth ) and mr ( animal bone from malu rosu ) was evaluated the age , from the content of fluorine , determined by naa , using the calibration curve . in fig . 3 are presented the results of naa of analyzed bones . also represented are the fluorine concentrations and the ages for some bones from carribean zone@xmath15 . in this region the climate is warmer and therefore the rate of accumulation of fluorine in the structure of bones is higher than in bones with the same age , from romanian regions . from the diagram shown in fig . 3 one can estimate for the bone from malu rosu , sample mr , with a content of fluorine of 400 ppm , an age @xmath19 6000@xmath322000 years bp . for the bone b1 one could estimate an age around 11000@xmath322000 years bp . for the bear b2 and the mammoth b4 , and for the bear b3 , one could estimate an inferior limit of 35000 , respectively 37000 years bp , given by the calibration curve . taking into consideration a possible saturation of the curve , the bones b2 and b4 , and b3 could have an age of around 40000 , respectively 45000 years bp . + the age of the bone from malu rosu of 5510@xmath32200 bp , determined by @xmath0c measurements using ams in the present study is in agreement with the estimated value of the age of 5000@xmath321000 years bp , determined in other fossil bones from the malu rosu , by measuring their content of fluorine , using naa . the stratigraphy of the settlement is very complex , containing , besides the four cultural aurignacian levels ( workshops for processing flintstones have been found with some hearths in the central parts ) and cultural levels from the final middle neolithic ( boian culture ) , eneolithic ( gumelnia culture ) , la tne period , early middle age ( dridu culture , ix - xi centuries ) ( fig . 4 ) . due to the specific conditions , namely open areas , the vegetal deposit and the loessial deposit , which start at a depth of approximately one metre , are affected by rodent passages both contemporary and fossil , reaching in some cases a depth of 6 m. under these conditions some archaeological objects have been disturbed and moved from their initial position . furthermore , the neolithic , eneolithic and medieval archaeological complexes have sometimes affected the aurignacian cultural layers . the fragment of bone studied by ams in the present study originates from the superior part of an aurignacian layer i @xmath47 , surface iii/1995 , the workshop for the processing of flintstones nr . 1 , square d/11 , depth 1.98 m ( fig . the inferior part of this aurignacian layer , the oldest one in malu rosu , has been dated by ams , at groeningen , on the basis of charcoal fragments from hearths , to have an age of 21,140@xmath32120 bp ( gra-5094 ) and 22,790@xmath32130 bp ( gra-6037 ) . the value of 3560@xmath32200 bc for the age of the bone determined by ams in the present work associates the bone with the neolithic level of the malu rosu settlement , attributed by us to the final stage of evolution of the boian culture . in the layer mentioned one finds , at a depth of between 0.80 - 1.10 m , the archaeological remains of three houses belonging to the final stage of the boian culture . some radiocarbon datings for the boian culture can be quoted for some settlements from the danubian region : for the cascioarele settlement , with a layer dated at 4035@xmath32125 bc ( bin-800 ) and 3620@xmath32100 bc ( bin-796 ) and the settlement at radovanu , from the oldest layer ( transitional stage to eneolithic ) , dated to 3820@xmath32100 ( bin-1233)@xmath48 . thus the fossil bone analyzed in the present work , found in the palaeolithic layer of the malu rosu settlement is dated to have an age of 3560@xmath49 bc , and belongs in fact to the neolithic layer , situated above the palaeolithic one . this result can be explained by the existence of a dynamics of archaeological objects , by which they can be moved from their original places by an interference with the biosphere . * references * + 1 . j. w. michels , dating methods in archaeology , seminar press , 1973 + 2 . g. a. wagner , archaeometric dating , in lectures in isotope geology , + eds . e. jager and j. c. hunziker , springer , 1979 , p. 178 w. kutschera , _ accelerator mass spectrometry : counting atoms + rather than decays _ , nuclear physics news , vol . * 3 * , no . * 1 * ( 1993 ) 15 + 4 . c. tuniz , j. bird , d. fink , g. f. herzog , accelerator mass + spectrometry , ultrasensitive analysis for global science , crc press , + 1998 + 5 . c. besliu and a. olariu , i. popescu and t. badica , _ microelements in + fossil bones and the estimation of age _ , spie , * 2339 * ( 1995 ) 487 , and + 4th international conference on applications of nuclear techniques : + neutrons and their applications . , crete , greece , 12 - 18 june , 1994 + 6 . a. olariu , r. hellborg , k. stenstrm , g. skog , m. faarinen , + p. persson , b. erlandsson , i. v. popescu , e. alexandrescu , + , report 08/00 , + lundfd6/(nffr-3081)/1 - 30/(2000 ) , lund , 2000 + 7 . r. longin , _ new method of collagen extraction for radiocarbon dating _ , + nature , * v 230 * ( 1990 ) p. 241 - 242 j. s. vogel , j. r. southon , d. e. nelson and t. a. brown , nucl . instr . + and meth . * b5 * ( 1984 ) p. 289 k. stenstrm , g. skog , b. erlandsson , r. hellborg , a. jnis , a. + wiebert , _ a sample preparation system for production of elemental + carbon for ams analyses _ , report 02/94 , lundfd6/(nffr-3065)/ + 1 - 33/(1994 ) , lund 1994 \10 . r. gillespie , radiocarbon user s handbook , oxford university , + committee for archaeology , monograph number three , oxonian + rewley press , 1984 + 11 . d. j. donahue , t. w. linick and a. j. t. jull , _ isotope ratio and + background corrections for accelerator mass spectrometry radiocarbon + measurements _ , radiocarbon , vol . * 32 * , no . * 2 * ( 1990 ) p. 135 m. stuiver , h. polach , _ reporting of @xmath0c data _ , radiocarbon , + vol . * 19 * , no . * 3 * ( 1977 ) p. 333 - 363 + 13 . c. ramsey , from oxford radiocarbon accelerator unit , uk , oxcal + software , http://www.rlaha.ox.ac.uk/oxcal/oxcal_h.html + 14 . m. stuiver , radiocarbon , vol . * 40 * , no . * 3 * ( 1988 ) + 15 . z. goffer , archaeological chemistry , john wiley and sons . + n.y . , 1980 + 16 . r. p. parker and h. toots , _ minor elements in fossil bones _ , geological + society of american bulletin , vol . * 81 * ( 1970 ) 925 + 17 . e. alexandrescu , _ a hypothesis about the evolution of the aurignacian + cultural complex from romanian plane _ in time of history i , memory + and patrimonium , bucharest university , 1997 , p. 16 e. comsa , the neolithic on the romanian territory - considerations , + publishing house of academy , bucharest , romania , 1987 , p. 45 .

a fossil bone from the archaeological site malu rosu giurgiu , in romania has been analyzed by accelerator mass spectrometry to estimate its age by determining its @xmath0c content . the radiocarbon age of the bone is in agreement with the age obtained by the method for age determination , based on fluorine content . this is the first radiocarbon dating for the final neolithic period , for this archaeological settlement in the romanian region . + email : agata@ifin.nipne.ro + national institute for physics and nuclear engineering , + po box mg-6 , 76900 magurele , bucharest , romania + tel . 40 1 780 70 40

astro-ph0109394

the simplest view of a cluster is as a sphere of virial - temperature gas punctuated by old galaxies , with perhaps a cooling flow onto the cd galaxy . within this model , the gas cooling time is longer than a hubble time everywhere except near the center , and thus it is predicted that clusters should follow simple self - similar " scaling relations derived from the virial theorem combined with an assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium , namely : @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the total x - ray luminosity , @xmath10 is the gas temperature ( presumed to be the halo virial temperature ) , and @xmath11 is the velocity dispersion of cluster galaxies ( presumed to trace the system s total mass ) . while observations of the most massive clusters follow these relations , as one progresses to smaller systems , the self - similar model fails . the failure is most striking when one extends observations to poor groups , where helsdon & ponman ( 2000 ; hp ) found that the luminosity of their poorest groups declined much faster than expected ( @xmath12 ) , a fact also interpreted as an entropy floor " of @xmath13 kev @xmath14 ( ponman , cannon & navarro 1999 ) . one model that successfully accounts for these observations postulates that the gas is pre - heated " by some unknown physical process ( possibly supernovae or winds ) with an energy of @xmath15 kev / baryon . however , the success of this model relies on the assumption that groups are self - similarly scaled - down versions of large clusters . in these proceedings we present a preliminary test of whether self - similar scaling relations arise naturally in a cosmological hydrodynamic simulation of galaxy formation . we find that on group scales , the self - similar scaling relations are not followed , and that features can arise that quantitatively mimic a pre - heating model . the breaking of self - similarity from clusters to groups is due to an increased cooling efficiency in smaller systems , and does not imply additional heat or entropy input at early times ( see also bryan 2000 ) . our simulation is of a @xmath16 random volume in a @xmath1cdm universe with @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 . there are @xmath20 dark matter and @xmath20 sph particles . it includes cooling , star formation , and thermal feedback . we identify galaxies using skid , and halos using a spherical - overdensity criterion on friends - of - friends halos , as described in murali et al . our 64-particle galaxy mass resolution limit ( @xmath21 ) corresponds to @xmath22 . halos that contain three or more galaxies are identified as groups " ; we find 128 at @xmath23 . + figure 1 : @xmath3 relation , showing a break at @xmath24 kev . + figure 2 : @xmath25 ( left ) and @xmath26 ( right ) relations . the x - ray luminosity of a group is computed from all particles with @xmath27k that are members of that group . only bremmstrahlung emission is used ; metal emission is not included in this preliminary analysis to facilitate a straightforward comparison with the self - similar model , and also because intragroup gas metallicities are uncertain . in order to avoid the well - known problem of overestimation of x - ray luminosity due to sph oversmoothing , we recalculate gas densities using only hot particles , ignoring all particles with @xmath28k . this explicit decoupling of the hot and cold phases is shown to reproduce the correct x - ray luminosity in analytic cases ( croft et al . the x - ray temperature is given by the average luminosity - weighted temperature of group particles . figure 1 shows the @xmath3 relation for our simulated groups . the plot symbols indicate the number of group members . best fit power law relations above and below @xmath29 kev are shown in the upper left . the slope , for groups with @xmath30 kev , is steeper than predicted by the self - similar model , and steepens even more below @xmath5 kev ( the dashed line shows a continuation of the high - temperature slope ) . the latter slope is consistent with the hp data , and the former with results from clusters ( white , jones & forman 1997 ) . the break appears at a somewhat lower temperature than is suggested by hp , but more detailed modeling ( i.e. including metal emission and aperture effects ) may improve agreement . the crucial point is that a break occurs at all , when no physics has been input into the simulation that specifically picks out this temperature scale . this suggests that a straightforward extrapolation of cluster scaling relations ( i.e. self - similarity ) is an inappropriate model for poor groups . + figure 3 : @xmath31 ( left ) and @xmath32 ( right ) relations . figure 2 shows the @xmath25 ( left panel ) and @xmath33 relations ( right panel ) . the dark matter velocity dispersion faithfully traces the group mass . a break is seen in @xmath9 at @xmath34 km / s . the slopes above and below the break are consistent with a compilation of @xmath2 for clusters down to galaxies by mahdavi & geller ( 2001 ) . their break occurs at @xmath35 km / s , but given observational uncertainties it is roughly consistent with our prediction . the galaxy velocity dispersion does _ not _ trace the group mass when small numbers of galaxies are used . the right panel of figure 2 shows smaller groups shifted towards lower @xmath11 compared to the left panel , and the best - fit slope is altered significantly . thus we confirm zabludoff & mulchaey s ( 1998 ) result that a large number of galaxies ( @xmath36 ) must be used to accurately estimate group velocity dispersions . hp find a slope consistent with our @xmath25 , but claim that their @xmath37 is lowered due to misestimation from using small numbers of galaxies . however , zimer , zabludoff & mulchaey ( these proceedings ) find a similar slope using more than 20 galaxies per group . figure 3 shows the @xmath38 relation for @xmath39 ( left panel ) and @xmath11 ( right panel ) . interestingly , the @xmath31 relation shows no break at 200 km / s , indicating that the drop in @xmath9 is not due to an additional heat source such as shock heating on filaments . the slope is in reasonable agreement with the self - similar model , indicating that these systems are virialized . however , the misestimation of @xmath37 from using too few galaxies results in a steeper slope ( right panel ) , bringing it more into agreement with hp ; this can be misinterpreted as excess heat injection . since there is no excess heat , we conclude that the break in @xmath9 arises from a drop in the hot fraction due to an increase in efficiency of galaxy formation in smaller systems . the fraction of hot ( @xmath40 k ) gas for our simulated groups drops linearly from 50% at @xmath41 km / s to 20% at @xmath42 km / s . when placed on a logarithmic scale ( cf . the @xmath9 plots ) , the decline appears to steepen at lower @xmath37 ; hence the appearance of a break " . while the large cold gas + stellar fraction may appear to contradict baryon estimates in clusters , there are indications that the hot gas fraction decreases in smaller systems ( see bryan 2000 for summary ) . in any case , the trend for a rapid decline of the hot fraction in this mass regime seems to be a generic feature of cdm - based galaxy formation , arising in semi - analytic models as well ( bower , these proceedings ) . using a cosmological hydrodynamic simulation , we have shown that group x - ray scaling relations are not expected to follow simple extrapolations from clusters . for rich groups , the scaling relations for the x - ray luminosity are somewhat different than predicted by self - similarity arguments , while for poor groups the scaling relations deviate dramatically . the trends of our predictions are in agreement with observations . the location of the predicted break predicted is slightly different than that observed , but more careful modeling and better data may improve the agreement . we conclude that cooling is responsible for breaking self - similarity , and hence it is premature to use observed poor group scaling relations as evidence for an excess injection of heat or entropy into these systems . bryan , g. l. 2000 , , 544 , l1 croft , r. a. c. , et al . 2001 , , 557 , 61 helsdon , s. f. & ponman , t. j. 2000 , , 315 , 356 mahdavi , a. & geller , m. j. 2001 , , 554 , l129 murali , c. , et al . 2001 , , submitted , astro - ph/0106282 ponman , t. j. , cannon , d. b. , & navarro , j. f. 1999 , nature , 397 , 135 white , d. a. , jones , c. , & forman , w. 1997 , , 292 , 419 zabludoff , a. i. & mulchaey , j. s. 1998 , , 496 , 39

we investigate the x - ray vs. optical scaling relations of poor groups to small clusters ( @xmath0 km / s ) identified in a cosmological hydrodynamic simulation of a @xmath1cdm universe , with cooling and star formation but no pre - heating . we find that the scaling relations between x - ray luminosity , x - ray temperature , and velocity dispersion show significant departures from the relations predicted by simple hydrostatic equilibrium models or simulations without cooling , having steeper @xmath2 and @xmath3 slopes and a break " at @xmath4 km / s ( @xmath5 kev ) . these departures arise because the hot ( x - ray emitting ) gas fraction varies substantially with halo mass in this regime . our predictions roughly agree with observations . thus radiative cooling is a critical physical process in modeling galaxy groups , and may present an alternative to _ ad hoc _ models such as pre - heating or entropy floors for explaining x - ray group scaling relations . # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in

cond-mat0309568

population dynamics is a venerable and important subject that has been studied thoroughly for decades @xcite . understanding ecological systems is interesting in itself , as are applications of this understanding to a large variety of important practical problems such as , for example , the spread of a virus or other disease over a host population @xcite , and strategies for the elimination of pests or for the protection of endangered species @xcite . these examples point to the importance of the study of the extinction of populations and of the conditions that lead to extinction as well as those that protect against it . the oldest population models pose relatively simple rate equations for a total population , e.g. , those of the logistic variety , and typically take basic events such as births and deaths into account through appropriate rate processes . a generic example is the logistic form @xcite @xmath1 where @xmath2 is a measure of the size of a population and is therefore nonnegative . the parameter @xmath3 is the difference between birth and death rates of the population , and @xmath4 are its steady states . all that is required for survival is that @xmath5 . fairly early on , the possible role of fluctuations in these models was recognized and included by way of additional fluctuating terms . the sources of the fluctuations included in this way in the earliest models were associated with variations in the external environment in which the population evolves , and appeared as a fluctuation in the parameters of the equations . for example , a fluctuating birth and/or death rate in the logistic form might lead to the description @xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 is a zero - centered gaussian white noise . the role of `` internal fluctuations '' arising from the fact that the populations are finite and discrete was also recognized , and the stochastic contributions to the population equations were obtained from an appropriate expansion of a master equation @xcite . writing the logistic equation in appropriately rescaled form , one would have with @xmath8 and @xmath9 , @xmath10 the parameter @xmath11 is also determined by the rates that determine @xmath3 . other sources of stochasticity have also been recognized , namely , those arising from natural catastrophes and from changes in gene frequencies @xcite . the per capita growth rate of the population according to the deterministic logistic model is @xmath12 which clearly decreases to zero as @xmath2 approaches the steady state value @xmath3 but that has a maximum as @xmath13 . a point that was observed early on in the biological ecology literature is that this latter behavior is not descriptive of real populations in many cases , and that in fact the per capita growth rate also tends to decrease when the population becomes very small @xcite . various possible mechanisms have been discussed for this in the literature , but many of them are based on the recognition that not only the total population but also its _ density _ may play a crucial role in population dynamics , particularly in questions related to extinction . more recent population models have recognized the importance of describing not only the total populations but also its spatial distribution , thereby getting a handle on density - related issues . perhaps the easiest way of dealing with a spatial distribution is by way of reaction - diffusion equations , and indeed such studies in the biological / ecological context have a long history @xcite . reaction - diffusion equations describe deterministic continuous densities . therefore , whereas they do deal with some of the density - dependence issues of great importance in the assessment of extinction probabilities , they do not in general include the other feature discussed above that is also of great consequence in these problems , namely , the effect of fluctuations . these fluctuations can again arise from a variety of internal and external sources . herein we address the problem of _ internal _ fluctuations . populations are composed of discrete numbers of individuals . that populations are not continuous is particularly relevant at low densities and at low total populations . the importance of these effects have been recognized and analyzed in various ways in recent years , most prominently in works that deal with a master equation description of the population instead of a reaction - diffusion model @xcite . these master equations are typically solved numerically and provide important information on various measures for extinction . we take a different approach to the problem , our interest lying in an analytic formulation of the problem of internal fluctuations and their consequences . on the one hand , an analytic approach necessarily requires a more narrow focus on a particular question , and therefore requires some restriction as to the range of issues that we can address . on the other hand , analytic results may provide insights that are difficult to obtain in purely numerical work . our specific question arises from the following situation . suppose that a population lives in a one - dimensional bounded refuge with favorable conditions for life , while outside of the refuge the conditions are extremely harsh . a question that has been considered prominently in the mathematical literature is that of the critical size @xmath0 of such a refuge that will guarantee the survival of the population @xcite , that is , the critical size beyond which the extinction probability vanishes , @xmath14 . this problem , and many generalizations of it , have been solved , but to our knowledge existing analytic solutions are based on the assumption of a continuous population . we show that accounting for the discreteness and finiteness of the population profoundly modifies the known results and may reopen an array of questions for reconsideration . our starting point is a master equation to describe the following scenario . in a refuge of volume @xmath15 we have a population composed of a single stream of individuals called @xmath16 that diffuse with constant diffusion coefficient @xmath17 on a @xmath18-dimensional lattice ( later @xmath18 is set to unity ) with lattice spacing @xmath19 . we further suppose that the individuals reproduce by fission ( @xmath20 , as may be the case with bacteria ) with rate constant @xmath21 , they die ( @xmath22 ) with rate coefficient @xmath23 , and they compete according to the reaction @xmath24 with rate coefficient @xmath25 . we suppose that @xmath26 , because otherwise the population eventually becomes extinct with certainty . we also assume that the nutrients are homogeneously distributed so that the coefficients do not depend on the lattice site . the microscopic description of the system within the refuge is given by the master equation @xmath27 \nonumber\\ & & ~+\lambda\left[(n_i+1)n_ip(\ldots , n_i+1,\ldots;t)-n_i(n_i-1 ) p(\ldots , n_i,\ldots;t)\right ] \nonumber\\ & & ~+\sigma_1 \left[(n_i-1)p(\ldots , n_i-1,\ldots;t)-n_i p(\ldots , n_i,\ldots;t)\right ] \nonumber\\ & & ~+ \sigma_2 \left[(n_i+1)p(\ldots , n_i+1, ... ;t)-n_i p(\ldots , n_i,\ldots;t)\right ] \biggr\}. \label{master}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the occupation number @xmath28 is the number of bacteria at site @xmath29 and @xmath30 is the set of all occupation numbers . the index @xmath31 in the sum ranges over all lattice sites and @xmath32 denotes the set of nearest neighbors of @xmath31 . we choose a homogeneous initial condition given by an uncorrelated poisson distribution with average population @xmath33 at each site : @xmath34 outside of the refuge living conditions are assumed to be extremely harsh , represented by the addition of the process @xmath22 with a large rate coefficient @xmath35 . in the limit @xmath36 ( certain death outside of the refuge ) , we can implement this contribution by requiring that @xmath37 vanish whenever @xmath38 , where @xmath39 denotes any site just beyond the refuge boundary . thus , `` harshness '' is implemented as a set of boundary conditions . in sec . [ sec : model ] we discuss the derivation of a stochastic langevin equation whose moments can be related to those of the fluctuating population described by the master equation . in sec . [ sec : extinction ] we present criteria for survival or extinction . in this section we discuss whether a refuge can be made sufficiently large to make extinction unlikely . a summary of our results and some directions for future research are presented in sec . [ sec : conclusions ] . it is well known that the continuum ( mean field ) description of the local concentration @xmath40 is the fisher - kolmogorov - petrovsky - piscunov ( fkpp ) equation @xcite @xmath41 which has been the phenomenological starting point in a huge number of problems in physics , chemistry , and biology . in one dimension and with the refuge extending inside the interval @xmath42 $ ] , the equation is to be solved subject to the boundary conditions @xmath43 for small @xmath44 the only solution to this problem as @xmath45 is @xmath46 , that is , the population becomes extinct . there is a critical refuge size @xmath0 beyond which extinction does not occur and the population will be nonzero ( albeit small ) . since @xmath47 is small near @xmath0 , to find this critical value it is appropriate to linearize eq . around zero population density and solve the simpler equation @xcite @xmath48 subject to the boundary conditions ( [ boundary ] ) . the fourier decomposition of the solution is given by @xmath49 \sin \left [ \frac{n \pi}{l } \left(x + \frac{l}{2 } \right ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and the @xmath52 depend on the initial condition . thus , all fourier modes decrease to zero in time if and only if @xmath53 , leading to the conclusion that for these values of @xmath44 , @xmath54 when @xmath55 for any @xmath56 . we can therefore conclude that the critical length of the refuge is @xmath57 that is , the population becomes extinct with certainty if @xmath58 and it certainly does not become extinct if @xmath59 ( in fact , the fourier components grow without bound in this case , but the linearized equation is then no longer valid ) . this result , and extensions of it , have been known for more than fifty years @xcite , and has served as a background for the design and analysis of refuges . note that the linearization argument that leads to eq . is valid for any nonlinearity that can be neglected near extinction in eq . , and that therefore the resulting @xmath0 is obtained not only for this specific model @xcite . the above mean field analysis does not take into account the effect of the fluctuations associated with the fact that the population is really discrete and finite . to do this short of solving the full master equation , one must formulate a generalization of the fkpp model that takes the resulting fluctuations into account . such generalizations exist in the literature in other contexts . in particular , on the basis of a theory first proposed by doi @xcite , further elucidated by peliti @xcite , used for the study of critical phenomena associated with bulk transitions in reaction dynamics @xcite , explicitly applied to a reaction - diffusion front problem by pechekin and levine @xcite , and subsequently used in a number of other contexts related to fisher waves ( see e.g. @xcite ) , one arrives at a stochastic differential equation for a field whose moments can be related to those of the population in the original master equation . the connection comes about as follows . the master equation eq . can be projected onto a problem in quantum field theory by the construction of an adequate fock space . since this calculation has been performed many times in the literature we only indicate some of the main steps . a detailed review of the procedure can be found in @xcite . consider the following operator algebra : @xmath60=\delta_{ij},\qquad [ a_i , a_j]=0,\qquad [ a_i^+,a_j^+]=0,\ ] ] where @xmath61 , @xmath62 are destruction and creation operators and the square brackets denote the commutator @xcite . a state vector can be defined as @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the solution of the master equation , and the sum is performed over all possible configurations of the @xmath65 . the state vector obeys the imaginary time schrdinger equation @xmath66 whose formal solution is @xmath67 in our case the ( non - hermitian ) hamiltonian is @xmath68a_i^+a_i-\sigma_2(1-a_i^+)a_i\right].\ ] ] note that we recover eq . ( [ master ] ) by substituting eqs . ( [ state ] ) and ( [ hamiltonian ] ) into eq . ( [ schrodinger ] ) . one introduces the glauber state as the projection state @xmath69 the expected values of observables @xmath70 can then be written as @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the operator obtained by replacing every @xmath73 in the function @xmath70 by the number operator @xmath74 . the steps that we do not repeat @xcite show that this second - quantized theory can be expressed in terms of a path integral . furthermore , from this path integral one can derive a `` classical '' action from which one can in turn derive the mean field continuum equation eq . . if one concentrates on the path integral itself instead of moving on to the classical action , one can show an equivalence between the master equation and the following langevin equation @xcite : @xmath75 } \xi({\bm r},t ) , \label{stochastic}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath76 is gaussian white noise with mean and correlation given by @xcite : @xmath77 @xmath78 the multiplicative noise in eq . must be interpreted according to it@xmath79 . it is important to note that the noise in eq . can be imaginary , so the value of @xmath80 is in general complex . this makes it clear that the field is _ not _ to be interpreted as the population density . the field @xmath80 is the complex eigenvalue of the destruction operator , so one can relate its moments to the moments of the population density using the commutation relations eq . ( [ commutation ] ) and the property of the glauber state @xmath81 . for the first two moments we have : @xmath82 higher moments can also be calculated following this procedure . here the lattice site @xmath31 is associated with the volume @xmath83 around point @xmath84 and we have set @xmath85 for economy of notation . as a side note we point out that the so - called stochastic fkpp equation of the form @xmath86 } \xi(x , t)\ ] ] can not represent the population density either since it does not allow fluctuations around the equilibrium population density @xmath87 because the population is real , while these fluctuations do not vanish in the original discrete system . however , a connection between eq . and the original master equation eq . without the death process has recently been elaborated @xcite this connection is different from the one presented above involving the stochastic equation ( [ stochastic ] ) . the mean field model for the refuge population predicts certain extinction if the refuge size @xmath58 and certain survival if @xmath59 . in this section we show that the fluctuations destroy this certainty of survival , that is , that survival is in fact never guaranteed . in the biological literature one encounters the concept of a _ minimum viable population _ there are some variations in its definition , but one that seems to be widely accepted is that a minimum viable population is the smallest isolated population having a 99% chance of remaining extant for 1000 years despite the presence of foreseeable fluctuations . clearly one can vary the two numbers that appear in this criterion , but , in any case , it involves a _ probability of survival _ in a _ finite period of time_. we wish to make clear at the outset that our analytic theory is not yet developed to the point of being able to handle finite times , and we are therefore not able to implement a criterion of this sort . instead , the theory ( like the mean field prediction stated above ) deals only with steady state probabilities . near extinction one can show directly from the master equation that the competition term ( the term proportional to @xmath25 ) can be neglected . as a result , in this limit the contributions @xmath88 in the stochastic equation can also be neglected , and to find the critical refuge size one only needs to deal with the simpler langevin equation @xmath89 the mean value of @xmath80 obeys the equation @xmath90 which is the same equation , eq . , that we solved for the deterministic case . since @xmath91 , we have the same boundary conditions as in eq.([classic ] ) , which implies that the mean value of the population density is zero , that is , that extinction is certain , for @xmath58 . since @xmath92 for @xmath59 , this in turn implies that extinction is certain if and only if @xmath58 . this , however , does not tell us whether or not the extinction probability is zero for @xmath93 ( as predicted in mean field theory ) . indeed , we now show that the extinction probability is greater than zero for any finite length of the refuge . it is fairly obvious that @xmath94 does not vanish if one has a finite population and thus a nonzero probability ( albeit perhaps small ) of a total extinction event . we will place this statement on a more formal footing . however , an arbitrarily small extinction probability is not necessarily very important since in most design problems one deals with at least some uncertainties . it is therefore useful to establish a criterion as to what constitutes a non - negligible extinction probability and what the minimal size @xmath95 of the refuge must be to insure a probability smaller than this . clearly , @xmath96 . we will establish such a criterion and show that ( depending on parameter values ) the size @xmath95 may be much larger than @xmath0 and even infinite . first , to establish the obvious fact that fluctuations lead to a nonzero extinction probability even for @xmath59 , let us suppose that we begin with an infinite refuge and exclude death events @xmath97 altogether . the population inside an interval of length @xmath44 of this infinite refuge is then greater than or equal to the population inside our actual finite refuge of length @xmath44 . the population density inside the finite interval of the infinite refuge in the steady state is given by the poisson distribution @xmath98 so that the probability of an unbounded realization of the process is zero . since the integral of a bounded function over a bounded interval is bounded , we can conclude that the total population inside the interval is finite . therefore so is the total population inside the finite refuge . furthermore , with @xmath99-correlated gaussian fluctuations @xcite , even the most rare fluctuations occur in a _ finite _ mean time and therefore a rare fluctuation caused by the reaction @xmath22 could kill the entire population in a finite time . we thus conclude that the probability of extinction is greater than zero whenever @xmath100 . in the case of an unbounded refuge the mean value of the population density is @xmath101 and is homogeneously distributed , so a local fluctuation can not kill the population . we can summarize these conclusions as follows : @xmath102 we can furthermore state that since the number of individuals in the population increases as the length of the refuge increases , the probability of extinction decreases monotonically and continuously as @xmath44 increases continuously . thus , consideration of the internal fluctuations drastically changes the picture ; now there is no finite size of the refuge that can be considered absolutely safe for the population . however , we have not been able to derive the explicit functional dependence of @xmath94 on the size of the refuge . as an alternative to such an explicit full solution , we propose a criterion for deciding when a population is under substantial risk of extinction , and calculate the critical size @xmath95 of the refuge associated with this criterion . suppose that a population density @xmath103 in a refuge of length @xmath44 described according to mean field eq . has a maximum steady state density @xmath104 . clearly , @xmath105 . the maximum occurs at @xmath106 , in the middle of the refuge , that is , @xmath107 @xcite . now consider the description of this population that includes the fluctuations , and compare the average population density @xmath108 with the deterministic result @xmath103 . this average distribution also has a maximum at @xmath106 ( see below ) , @xmath109 . we define the critical size @xmath95 as the refuge length associated with two conditions : 1 . the deterministic and stochastically obtained maxima are equal , @xmath110 ; 2 . the standard deviation of the stochastic population density is equal to its mean at each @xmath111 . clearly , our idea is that a population density whose standard deviation everywhere equals its mean is in danger of extinction , and we call this a `` critical population . '' it is not clear _ a priori _ that these conditions can be simultaneously satisfied , but in fact it turns out that they can . the second condition above says that for the critical population @xmath112 or , equivalently , in terms of the field @xmath80 , one for which @xmath113 from eq . ( [ stochastic ] ) we obtain the following equation linking the first and second moments of @xmath80 : @xmath114 inserting eq . for the critical field then results in a closed equation for the first moment , @xmath115 note that the apparent irrelevance of the fluctuations in eq . other than their mean value in arriving at eq . is illusory since the relation and consequently eq . are intimately connected to the precise form of the fluctuations . in the steady state eq . reduces to the boundary value problem @xmath116 with boundary conditions as in eq.([classic ] ) . to find @xmath95 we multiply eq . by @xmath117 and rewrite the result as @xmath118=0,\ ] ] from which it follows that @xmath119 symmetry considerations show that the solution of this problem has only one maximum at @xmath106 @xcite , and since the first derivative of the solution should vanish at any maximum , we can explicitly write the constant as @xmath120 where @xmath121 is the maximum introduced earlier . since this maximum occurs at @xmath106 , we can integrate eq . ( [ firstintegral ] ) for @xmath122 to obtain @xmath123 taking into account that the population vanishes at the edge of the refuge we can obtain the value of the length @xmath44 of the refuge as a function of the maximum of the average population density : @xmath124 with the change of variables @xmath125 and setting @xmath126 we can rewrite this relation as @xmath127 the steady state deterministic equation obtained by setting the left hand side of eq . equal to zero is formally identical to the critical field equation eq . with modified parameters . since we are choosing @xmath95 as the value where the maximum of the critical average population density is equal to the maximum of the mean field population density , the mean field model provides us with a second relation between @xmath121 and @xmath44 : @xmath128 the simultaneous solution of eqs . and then leads to the value of @xmath95 ( and incidentally also of @xmath121 ) . the two equations reduce to the same equation if @xmath129 ( @xmath130 ) , and in this case @xmath131 and @xmath121 diverges . the reason for the equality is that when the nonlinearity is not present , the total steady state population is unbounded ( thermodynamic limit ) and there are no fluctuations . in general , the two simultaneous equations can only be solved numerically , and the results are shown in fig.[figura_1 ] . a number of important points should be noted about our results . first , @xmath132 is indeed greater than @xmath0 except for the single trivially coincident point when @xmath129 , that is , when there is no competition . thus , according to our criterion whereby the risk of extinction is substantial when the mean and standard deviation of the population density are equal , one must increase the size of the refuge considerably beyond the deterministic refuge size to avoid this risk . indeed , when @xmath133 the size @xmath132 diverges logarithmically and the population density becomes uniform at density @xmath134 . as @xmath25 grows beyond @xmath11 it is no longer possible to avoid considerable risk of extinction for any finite size of the refuge . the increase in @xmath121 with decreasing @xmath132 can be understood by moving from right to left in the figure : decreasing critical refuge size is associated with the requirement of a larger population ( and hence a larger maximum population density ) to insure against extinction . at @xmath0 the maximum @xmath121 diverges because no population , no matter how large , can be protected against extinction below this length . we can obtain an analytic expression for @xmath132 for small values of @xmath135 : @xmath136.\ ] ] we can also see analytically that @xmath132 must diverge when @xmath133 : at this point the two integrals for @xmath44 can only be equal if they both vanish ( which they do not ) or if they both diverge ( which they do when @xmath137 ) . the main point of this paper has been to assess the effects of the inevitable internal fluctuations on the prediction of the risk of extinction of a population in a refuge as a function of the size of the refuge . in the usual mean field deterministic model in one dimension , the population is treated as a continuum and one obtains a critical refuge length @xmath0 such that the population becomes extinct with certainty if the length of the refuge is below this critical value , @xmath58 , whereas survival is certain if @xmath59 . it is well known that , as predicted by the mean field approach , the smaller the area occupied by a population , the lower are its chances for survival @xcite . however , it is also known that a small size or low density of a population may also increase its chances of extinction , a feature that mean field theories do not capture @xcite . our approach deals with both of these features simultaneously through the interplay of discreteness and nonlinearity in a spatially distributed model . we have argued that the discreteness of the population and its finite size make fluctuations unavoidable , and have shown that whereas @xmath58 still guarantees extinction , @xmath59 by no means guarantees survival . while we have not been able to find an analytic expression for the survival probability as a function of @xmath44 , we have focused on a sensible risk criterion for which we have found explicit results up to quadrature . comparing deterministic and average stochastic population densities with a given maximum @xmath121 , we have chosen to define a new critical length @xmath132 as one for which the mean of the population density and its standard deviation are equal , reasoning that this variability implies considerable susceptibility of the population to extinction . we have shown that @xmath138 and , most importantly , that @xmath132 diverges when the competition rate coefficient grows beyond that of the net growth rate of the population . for some parameter values it is possible to protect ( albeit not with certainty ) a population from extinction by placing it in a sufficiently large refuge , one that is certainly larger than that predicted by the standard mean field model . for other parameter values ( in particular , when competition is too strong ) , it is not possible to evade the risk of extinction ( at least according to our criterion ) by enlarging the size of the refuge . clearly , these results have serious implications for the expectations in the design of refuges . many questions still remain to be answered . for instance , an exact result for the extinction probability would clarify many issues . so would the ability to obtain time dependent solutions so as to deal with a more realistic criterion of survival over a long but finite time interval . also , we have only considered the simplest most generic situation , whereas real systems ( particularly ones not designed in the laboratory ) are likely to be seriously affected by many complicating factors , some connected with the necessary extension to higher dimensions . examples include the presence of convection , different boundary conditions , and spatial inhomogeneities inside the refuge . similar questions can and should be posed when multiple species are present . in any case , in light of our results it would seem prudent to reconsider other critical size population problems to assess the effects of discreteness . as we have shown in the simple model considered here , the consequences can indeed be profound . the authors gratefully acknowledge input from j. l. cardy . c. escudero is grateful to the department of chemistry and biochemistry of the university of california , san diego for its hospitality . this work has been partially supported by the engineering research program of the office of basic energy sciences at the u. s. department of energy under grant no . de - fg03 - 86er13606 , the ministerio de educacin y cultura ( spain ) through grants no . ap2001 - 2598 and ex2001 - 02880680 , and by the ministerio de ciencia y tecnologa ( spain ) , project no . bfm2001 - 0291 .

we study a generic reaction - diffusion model for single - species population dynamics that includes reproduction , death , and competition . the population is assumed to be confined in a refuge beyond which conditions are so harsh that they lead to certain extinction . standard continuum mean field models in one dimension yield a critical refuge length @xmath0 such that a population in a refuge larger than this is assured survival . herein we extend the model to take into account the discreteness and finiteness of the population , which leads us to a stochastic description . we present a particular critical criterion for likely extinction , namely , that the standard deviation of the population be equal to the mean . according to this criterion , we find that while survival can no longer be guaranteed for any refuge size , for sufficiently weak competition one can make the refuge large enough ( certainly larger than @xmath0 ) to cause extinction to be unlikely . however , beyond a certain value of the competition rate parameter it is no longer possible to escape a likelihood of extinction even in an infinite refuge . these unavoidable fluctuations therefore have a severe impact on refuge design issues .

0907.5241

the study of networks has experienced enormous growth in recent years , providing foundational insights into numerous complex systems ranging from protein interaction networks in biology to online friendship networks in the social sciences @xcite . research on ecological and organizational networks has provided a general framework to study the mechanisms that mediate the cooperation and competition dynamics between individuals @xcite . in these networks , competitive interactions result from the indirect competition between members of different populations , who either compete for the same resources or are linked through consumer - resource relationships . however , data on mutually - antagonistic interactions i.e . , individuals who directly fight or compete against each other have been more difficult to collect @xcite . mutually - antagonistic interactions also occur frequently in different social contexts such as sports . in the present paper , we consider head - to - head matchups between major league baseball ( mlb ) pitchers and batters : pitchers benefit by defeating " batters , and vice versa . using data from retrosheet.org , we characterize the more than eight million mlb plate appearances from 1954 to 2008 , considering full careers by examining head - to - head matchups over a multi - season ( career " ) network and single - season performances by constructing networks for individual seasons . to compare the performance of players , mlb uses votes by professional journalists to recognize career achievement of players through induction into a hall of fame ( hof ) and single - season performance through awards such as most valuable player ( mvp ) and cy young ( for pitching performance ) @xcite . although the hof purports to recognize the best players of all time , the selection of players to it is widely criticized by fans and pundits each year because of the lack of consistency when , e.g. , comparing players from different eras , who play under fundamentally different conditions in different ballparks , facing different players , etc . such arguments come to the fore when attempting to draw comparisons between players elected to the hof and others who did not make it . for instance , how can one tell whether jim rice ( elected to the hof in 2009 ) had a better career than albert belle ( who dropped off the ballot because of low vote totals after only two years ? does bert blyleven , who appeared on 62.7% of the hof ballots in 2009short of the 75% required for election belong in the hof ? is sandy koufax , who played from 1955 - 1966 and is in the hof , better than pedro martinez , who was still active during the 2008 season and who will presumably eventually be elected to the hof ? to address such questions , it is insufficient to rely purely on raw statistics ; one must also consider quantitative mechanisms for comparison between athletes who played under different conditions . we take a first , simple step in this direction through the study of biased random walkers on these graphs @xcite , allowing us to not only construct a quantitative , systematic , and transparent ranking methodology across different eras , but also to investigate the interplay between these dynamics and the underlying graph structure and to reveal key properties of mutually - antagonistic interactions that can potentially also be applied in other settings . while water - cooler " discussions about the hof can often be fascinating , as indicated by the above paragraph , we stress that the primary goal of our paper is to investigate interesting features of the baseball _ networks _ and the impact that network structure can have on rankings rather than on the rankings themselves . while it is necessary to include some example rank orderings for the purpose of such a discussion , it is important to note that the rankings we show in the present paper must be taken with several grains of salt because our efforts at simplicity , which are crucial to highlighting the interplay between network structure and player rankings , require us to ignore essential contributing factors ( some of which we will briefly discuss ) that are necessary for any serious ranking of baseball players . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec2 ] , we define and characterize the mutually - antagonstic baseball networks and study the time evolution of various graph properties . in section [ sec3 ] , we provide a description of the biased random walker dynamics that we employ as a ranking methodology across eras and for single - season networks . in section [ sec4 ] , we study the interplay between the random walker dynamics and graph structure , paying special attention to the sensitivity of the player rankings . in section [ sec5 ] , we conclude the paper and discuss a number of potential applications of our work . we explain additional technical details in two appendices . we analyze baseball s mutually - antagonistic ecology by considering bipartite ( two - mode ) networks of head - to - head matchups between pitchers and batters . as shown in fig . [ fig1 ] , bipartite networks are formed using two disjoint sets of vertices , @xmath0 ( pitchers ) and @xmath1 ( batters ) , and the requirement that every edge connect a vertex in @xmath0 to one in @xmath1 @xcite ( keeping the pitching and batting performances of pitchers as two separate nodes ) . we consider such interactions in terms of three different bipartite representations ( with corresponding matrices ) : ( 1 ) the binary matchups @xmath2 in which the element @xmath3 equals @xmath4 if pitcher @xmath5 faced batter @xmath6 at any point and @xmath7 otherwise ; ( 2 ) the weighted matchups @xmath8 in which the element @xmath9 equals the number of times that @xmath5 faced @xmath6 ; and ( 3 ) the weighted outcomes @xmath10 in which the element @xmath11 equals a `` score '' or performance index , which in the case of picther - batter matchups is determined using what are known in baseball as sabermetric " statistics ( see the discussion below ) @xcite , characterizing the results of all matchups between @xmath5 and @xmath6 . for each of these bipartite pitcher batter networks , we also utilize corresponding square adjacency matrices : @xmath12 so that they are appropriately symmetric ( @xmath13 and @xmath14 ) and anti - symmetric ( @xmath15 ) . we construct and analyze each of these representations for the single - season networks and the aggregate ( career ) network that contains all pitcher batter interactions between 1954 and 2008 . to identify the changes in the organization of baseball networks , we examine the graph properties of single - season networks the number of distinct opponents per player , given by the distribution of player degree @xmath16 , follows an exponential distribution for a large range and then has an even faster decay in the tail ( see fig . [ figs1 ] ) . the mean values of the geodesic path length between nodes and of the bipartite clustering coefficient are only somewhat larger than what would be generated by random assemblages ( see appendix [ app1 ] ) . however , as with mutually - beneficial interactions in ecological networks @xcite , the mutually - antagonistic baseball matchup networks exhibit non - trivial relationships between player degree and player strength @xmath17 , which represents the total number of opponents of a player ( counting multiplicity ) @xcite . as shown in fig . [ fig2]a , the relation between strength and degree is closely approximated by a power law @xmath18 that starts in 1954 at @xmath19 for pitchers and @xmath20 for batters but approaches @xmath21 for each by 2008 . the six - decade trend of a decreasing power - law exponent indicates how real - life events such as the increase in the number of baseball teams through league expansion ( e.g. , in the 1960s , 1977 , 1993 , and 1998 ) , reorganization ( e.g. , in 1994 , to three divisions in each league instead of two ) , interleague play ( in 1997 ) , and unbalanced schedules ( in 2001 ) have modified the organization of the networks . an important property mediating the competition dynamics of mutualistic networks in ecology is _ nestedness _ @xcite . although the definition of nestedness may vary , a network is said to be nested when low - degree nodes interact with proper subsets of the interactions of high - degree nodes @xcite ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . to calculate the aggregate nestedness in the binary matchup network @xmath2 , we employed the nestedness metric based on overlap and decreasing fill ( nodf ) @xcite , which takes values between @xmath22 $ ] , where @xmath4 designates a perfectly - nested network ( see appendix [ app1 ] ) . figure [ fig2]b ( black circles ) shows that single - season baseball networks consistently have nestedness values of approximately @xmath23 . this value is slightly but consistently higher than those in randomized versions of the networks with similar distribution of interactions ( red squares ) @xcite , which we also observe to decrease slightly in time . in common with bipartite cooperative networks , this confirms that nestedness is a significant feature of these mutually - antagonistic networks . although nestedness is defined as a global characteristic of the network , we can also calculate the individual contribution of each node to the overall nestedness @xcite . comparing node degrees and individual nestedness ( see appendix [ app1 ] ) before 1973 , batters and pitchers collapse well onto separate curves ( see fig . [ fig2]c ) . starting in 1973 , however , each of these split into two curves ( see fig . [ fig2]d ) , corresponding to players in the two different leagues : the american league ( al ) and the national league ( nl ) . this structural change presumably resulted from the al s 1973 introduction of the designated hitter ( dh ) , a batter who never fields but bats in place of the team s pitchers ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) , apparently causing the al to become less nested due to the replacement of low - degree batting pitchers with higher - degree dhs . this suggests , as we discuss below , that the network position of a player might affect his own ranking ( while , of course , network position is strongly influenced by a player s longevity and , thus , by his performance ) . to compare the performance of players , we rank players by analyzing biased random walkers on the bipartite network @xmath10 encoding the outcomes of all mutually - antagonistic interactions between each player pair . our method generalizes the technique we previously used for ncaa football teams @xcite , allowing us to rank players in individual seasons and in the 19542008 career network , yielding a quantitative , conceptually - clear method for ranking baseball players that takes a rather different approach from other sabermetric methods used to project player performance such as diamondmind ( which uses monte carlo simulations ) , pecota ( which uses historical players as a benchmark ) , and chone ( which uses regression models ) @xcite . to describe the aggregate interaction @xmath11 between pitcher @xmath5 and batter @xmath6 , we need to quantify each possible individual pitcher batter outcome . for simplicity , we focus on the quantity _ runs to end of inning _ ( rue ) @xcite , which assigns a value to each possible plate appearance outcome ( single , home run , strikeout , etc . ) based on the expected number of runs that a team would obtain before the end of that inning , independent of the situational context ( see appendix [ app2 ] for specific values ) . higher numbers indicate larger degrees of success for the batting team . for each season , we add the rue from each plate appearance of pitcher @xmath5 versus batter @xmath6 to obtain a cumulative rue for the pair . note that any performance index that assigns a value to a specific mutually - antagonistic interaction can be used in place of rue without changing the rest of our ranking algorithm . we then define the single - season outcome element @xmath11 by the cumulative extent to which the batter s outcome is better ( @xmath24 ) or worse ( @xmath25 ) than the mean outcome over all pitcher batter matchups that season . when defining the career outcome element @xmath11 for 19542008 , we account for baseball s modern era offensive inflation @xcite by summing over individual seasons ( i.e. , relative to mean outcomes on a per season basis ) . we initiate our ranking methodology by considering independent random walkers who each cast a single vote for the player that they believe is the best . each walker occasionally changes its vote with a probability determined by considering the aggregate outcome of a single pitcher batter pairing , selected randomly from those involving their favorite player , and by a parameter quantifying the bias of the walker to move towards the winner of the accumulated outcome . a random walker that is considering the outcome described by this matchup is biased towards but not required to choose the pitcher ( batter ) as the better player if @xmath25 ( @xmath24 ) . the expected rate of change of the number of votes cast for each player in the random walk is quantified by a homogeneous system of linear differential equations @xmath26 , where @xmath27 the long - time average fraction of walkers @xmath28 residing at ( i.e. , voting for ) player @xmath6 is then found by solving the linear algebraic system @xmath29 , subject to an additional constraint that @xmath30 . if the bias parameter @xmath31 , successful players will on average be ranked more highly . for @xmath32 , the random walker votes will instead tend toward the `` loser '' of individual matchups . equation ( [ system ] ) gives a general one - parameter system for a biased walker with probabilities that are linear in rue , but the approach is easily generalized by using other functional forms to map observed plate appearance outcomes ( in @xmath10 ) into selection probabilities . by restricting our attention to a form that is linear in rue , the interpretation that the off - diagonal components of @xmath33 correspond to random walker rate coefficients requires that these components remain non - negative , a preferable state that leads to a number of beneficial properties in the resulting matrix . for example , this allows us to apply the perron - frobenius theorem , which guarantees the existence of an equilibrium @xmath34 with strictly positive entries ( and similarly guarantees the existence of positive solutions in algorithms such as pagerank ) @xcite . in practice , this requirement is equivalent in the baseball networks to @xmath35 , so that the result of a home run in a single plate - appearance matchup ( i.e. , the case in which a batter faces a pitcher exactly once and hits a home run in that appearance ) maintains a small but non - negative chance that a corresponding random walker will still select the pitcher . however , because the aggregate outcome of most pairings remains close to the mean , the bias in the random walk is small , and the rankings become essentially independent of the bias parameter . the linear expansion in bias @xmath36 thereby yields a ranking with no remaining parameters beyond the statistically - selected rue values , given by @xmath37 . generalizing the similar expansion described in detail in ref . @xcite , the zeroth - order term results in a constant number of votes per player , and the additional contribution at first order is given by the solution of a discrete poisson equation on the graph : @xmath38 subject to the neutral charge constraint @xmath39 . ( by analogy with electrostatics , we refer to @xmath40 as the rue ` charge ' of node @xmath6 . ) in equation ( [ firstorder ] ) , @xmath41 is the total number of players , @xmath42 is the graph laplacian , @xmath43 is the diagonal matrix with elements @xmath44 ( and @xmath45 for @xmath46 ) . accordingly , we restrict our attention to the first - order ranking specified by @xmath47 and obtained using the solution of equation . we tabulate this rank ordering separately for pitchers and batters , for individual seasons and the full career network . we compare the results of the random walker ranking to major baseball awards in table [ tables1 ] . we note that the rankings are highly correlated with the underlying rue per plate appearance of each player ( @xmath48 for 2008 and similar for other seasons ) , so that the top players in the rankings produced by our method have a strong but imperfect correlation with the lists produced by ranking players according to raw rue values . ( this similarly holds for any other sabermetric quantity that one might use in place of rue . ) that is , it matters which players one has faced , and that is codified by the network . we note , for example , that the differences between random walker rankings and raw rue rankings appear to appropriately capture the caliber of opponents ( for example , pitchers from teams with relatively anemic offenses such as the 2008 nationals , astros , and reds have a higher ranking in the random walker ranking , reflecting that they never had the good fortune of going up against their own teams batters ) . we also compared the rankings with a leading metric in baseball analysis , espn s mlb player ratings , which combines ratings from espn , elias , inside edge , and _ the baseball encyclopedia _ @xcite . of the top 99 players for 2008 who are listed in the player ratings , 12 did not meet our threshold for plate appearances . comparing the random walker results for the remaining 87 players with the player ratings yields a @xmath49 correlation . we thus proceed to study the random walker results for the full career ranking both with confidence that it correlates with methods currently used for single - season analysis and caution that the ranking details do not capture all effects according to current best practices in quantitative baseball analysis @xcite . the full career ranking allows credible comparisons between players from different eras . interestingly , considering the rankings restricted to individuals who played in at least 10 seasons during this time ( hof - eligible players ) , we find that barry bonds ( batter ) , pedro martinez ( pitcher ) , and mariano rivera ( relief pitcher ) are the best players ( in these categories ) from 1954 to 2008 . we show additional rankings in table [ table1 ] . we especially note that albert belle ( 29th among batters ) is ranked much higher than jim rice ( 115th ) , suggesting that belle s hitting performance perhaps merits hof membership more than that of rice . similarly , bert blyleven ranks higher not only than current hof competitors such as jack morris and tommy john but also higher than three hof pitchers with over 300 wins ( steve carlton , phil niekro , and don sutton ) , which is one traditional benchmark for selecting elite pitchers . direct comparison with other rank orderings of players across different eras would necessitate restriction to sufficiently similar time periods and is thus beyond the network - science focus of the present study . as previously suggested , the network architecture should have important effects on the performance of players . in particular , central players in the network might have a systematic advantage in the rankings relative to those who are not as well connected . such structurally - important players ( see table [ table1 ] for examples ) , who have high values for both betweenness centrality and nestedness , have had long and usually extremely successful careers , so it is of significant interest , yet difficult , to gauge the coupled effects on their rank ordering from statistical success versus structural role in the network . in fact , we found no correlation ( @xmath50 ) between a player s position i.e . , individual nestedness and betweenness and his success measured by the fraction of votes received . hence , we investigate this connection further via the correlation between the sensitivity of rankings to changes in outcomes in individual pitcher batter pairs , which is formulated using the moore - penrose pseudo - inverse of the graph laplacian . consider changing the outcome of the single edge that corresponds to the aggregate matchup between players @xmath5 and @xmath6 . if we increase the former s aggregate rue by a unit amount at the expense of the latter , then the total rms change in votes @xmath47 is proportional to the difference between the @xmath5th and @xmath6th columns of @xmath51 . this difference yields a node - centric measure of the sensitivities of rankings to individual performances : the constraint @xmath52 yields that @xmath53 ( the diagonal element of the graph laplacian pseudo - inverse ) , the direct control that player @xmath5 has over his own ranking , is equal and opposite to the total change his performance directly imposes on the rest of the network . additionally , as illustrated in fig . [ fig3]a , the quantity @xmath53 is closely related to the rms changes in votes across the network due to the performance of player @xmath5 . noting that the element @xmath53 is related to the mean of the commute times between nodes @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( averaging over all @xmath6 ) @xcite , specifically under our constraints , the sum of the commute times @xmath54 over @xmath6 yields a linear function of @xmath53 . consequently , @xmath53 provides a node - based measure of the average distance from node @xmath5 to the rest of the network . this definition of average commute time has similarities with the measures known as information centrality @xcite and random walk centrality @xcite ( though the results of applying the different measures can still be quite different ) . the negative relationship between @xmath53 and both betweenness centrality and nestedness , which we show in fig . [ figs2 ] , thus yields a corresponding negative relationship between the mean commute distance and the betweenness and nestedness of a player . a player who is highly embedded in the network ( i.e. , one with high individual nestedness ) has a small mean commute distance to the rest of the network , and the ranking of that player is not very sensitive to the outcome of a single matchup . in contrast , a player who is in the periphery of the network ( i.e. , one with low individual nestedness ) typically has a very large mean commute distance to other portions of the graph , and his place in the ranking - ordering is consequently much more sensitive to the results of his individual matchups . this would suggest that players in the al tend on average to be more prone to changes in their own rankings than players in the nl ( see fig . [ fig2]d ) . remarkably , we can make these general notions much more precise , as @xmath55 , where we recall that @xmath56 is the strength of node @xmath5 ( see fig . [ fig3]b ) . some similarities between these quantities is reasonably expected ( cf . the role of relaxation times in a similar relationship with random walk centrality in ref . @xcite , which can be quantified by an eigenvalue analysis ) . this simple relationship belies a stunning organizational principle of this network : the global quantity of average commute time of a node is well - approximated by its strength , a simple local quantity . that is , in the appropriate perturbation analysis to approximate the laplacian pseudo - inverse , the higher order terms essentially cancel out , contributing little beyond the ( zeroth - order ) local contribution . we also found a rougher relationship for nestedness and betweenness ( see fig . [ figs3 ] ) . these results have two interesting implications . first , they reveal that the success of well - connected players depends fundamentally on a strong aggregate performance rather than just on their position in the network . second , they imply that neophyte players would need to face well - connected players if they want to establish a stronger connection to the network and a ranking that is less vulnerable to single matchups . similarly , recent research on mutualistic networks in ecology has found that neophyte species experience lower competition pressures by linking to well - connected species @xcite . our findings on baseball - player rankings suggest the possibility of finding similar competition patterns in mutually - antagonistic interactions in ecological and social networks . drawing on ideas from network science and ecology , we have analyzed the structure and time - evolution of mutually - antagonistic interaction networks in baseball . we considered a simple ranking system based on biased random walks on the graphs and used it to compare player performance in individual seasons and across entire careers . we emphasize that our ranking methodology is overly simplistic , having noted several considerations that one might use to improve it ( see , e.g. , appendix b ) while maintaining a network framework that accounts for which players each player has faced . we also examined how the player rankings and their sensitivities depend on node - centric network characteristics . we expect that similar considerations might be useful for developing a better understanding of the interplay between structure and function in a broad class of competitive networks , such as those formed by antigen - antibody interactions , species competition for resources , and company competition for consumers . given the motivation from ecology , we are optimistic that this might lead to interesting ecological insights , compensating for the difficulty in collecting data on the regulatory dynamics of mutually - antagonistic networks in ecology such as the ones formed by parasites and free - living species @xcite or assessing the potential performance of invasive species from different environments @xcite . we thank eduardo altmann , jordi bascompte , mariano beguerisse daz , damian burch , justin howell , peter jensen , tom maccarone , ravi montenegro , cy morong , felix reed - tsochas , david smith , daniel stouffer , and tom tango for useful comments . ss did some of his work while a postdoctoral fellow at the oxford university corporate reputation centre and the cabdyn complexity centre . pjm , sp , and tm were funded by the nsf ( dms-0645369 ) and by start - up funds to pjm provided by the institute for advanced materials , nanoscience and technology and the department of mathematics at the university of north carolina at chapel hill . map acknowledges a research award ( # 220020177 ) from the james s. mcdonnell foundation . we obtained the baseball network data from retrosheet.org . the data was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by retrosheet ( 20 sunset rd . , newark , de 19711 ) . here , we review some important quantities for bipartite networks and discuss their values for the baseball matchup networks . a clustering coefficient for bipartite networks can be defined by @xcite @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the number of complete squares involving nodes @xmath5 , @xmath59 , and @xmath60 ; @xmath61 enforces the requirement in bipartite graphs that there are no links between nodes of the same population ; and we recall that @xmath62 is the degree of node @xmath5 . hence , the numerator in ( [ c4 ] ) gives the actual number of squares and the denominator gives the maximum possible number of possible squares . for the single - sason baseball networks , we calculate the ratio @xmath63 between the mean clustering coefficient @xmath64 summed over all nodes @xmath5 and the mean clustering coefficient @xmath65 generated by a randomization of the network that preserves the original degree distribution @xcite . we found that baseball networks have average clustering coefficients that are just above that of random networks . interestingly , the ratio @xmath66 decreases gradually ( and almost monotonically from one season to the next ) from @xmath67 in 1954 to @xmath68 in 2008 . the geodesic betweenness centrality of nodes over the unweighted network @xmath13 is defined by @xcite @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the number of shortest paths between players @xmath6 and @xmath71 that pass through player @xmath5 and @xmath72 is the total number of shortest paths between players @xmath6 and @xmath71 . for the single - season baseball networks , we calculate the ratio @xmath73 between the mean path length @xmath74 summed over all nodes @xmath5 and the mean path length @xmath75 generated by a randomization of the network that preserves the degree distribution @xcite . as with clustering coefficients , we found that the mean path lengths of baseball networks are only slightly larger than those of random networks , finding in particular that @xmath76 @xcite . nestedness is an important concept that has been applied to ecological communities , in which species present in sites with low biodiversity are also present in sites with high biodiversity @xcite . although the general notion of nestedness may vary , the concept has nonetheless been employed quite successfully in the analysis of ecological networks @xcite . in a nested network , interactions between two classes of nodes ( e.g. , plants and animals ) are arranged so that low - degree nodes interact with proper subsets of the interactions of high - degree nodes . a nested network contains not only a core of high - degree nodes that interact with each other but also an important set of asymmetric links ( i.e. , connections between high - degree and low - degree nodes ) . the importance of nestedness measures is twofold : ( 1 ) they give a sense of network organization ; and ( 2 ) they have significant implications for the stability and robustness of ecological networks @xcite . to avoid biases in nestedness based on network size ( i.e. , the number of nodes ) , degree distribution , and other structural properties , we employ the nestedness calculations introduced recently in ref . the aggregate nestedness is given by @xcite @xmath77 + [ b(b-1)/2])}\,.\ ] ] for every pair of pitchers ( @xmath5 and @xmath6 ) , the quantity @xmath78 is equal to @xmath7 if @xmath79 and is equal to the fraction of common opponents if @xmath80 . we also define a similar quantity for every pair of batters ( @xmath81 and @xmath59 ) . the nestedness metric takes values between @xmath22 $ ] , where @xmath4 designates a perfectly - nested network and @xmath7 indicates a network with no nestedness . the nodf nestedness also allows us to calculate the individual nestedness of each pitcher ( column ) or batter ( row ) using the equation @xmath82 where @xmath83 ( total number of columns ) for pitchers , @xmath84 ( total number of rows ) for batters and @xmath78 is calculated as above . in this way , the individual nestedness metric takes values between @xmath22 $ ] , where @xmath4 designates a perfectly - nested individual and @xmath7 indicates an individual with no nestedness . the null model used to compare the empirical nestedness is given by @xcite @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the occupation probability of a pairwise interaction between node @xmath5 and node @xmath6 , and we recall that @xmath1 and @xmath0 are , respectively , the total number of nodes @xmath6 ( batters ) and nodes @xmath5 ( pitchers ) in the network . in a bipartite network , @xmath6 and @xmath5 represent two different types of nodes , so @xmath86 is the mean of the occupation probabilities of the row and column . recent studies have shown that model - generated nestedness values extracted from this null model lower the probability of incorrectly determining an empirical nested structure to be significant @xcite . for baseball networks , we calculated the standard error given by @xmath87 , where @xmath88 corresponds to the nestedness values of the empirical networks and @xmath89 and @xmath90 are , respectively , the average and standard deviations of nestedness values of random replicates generated by the null model . for the baseball networks , we found that @xmath91 for all seasons ( see fig . [ fig2]b ) . to quantify the outcome of each plate appearance , we used the sabermetric quantity _ runs to end of inning _ ( rue ) @xcite , which assigns a value to each of the possible outcomes in a plate appearance based on the expected number of runs a team would obtain before the end of that inning following that event , independent of game context . ( rue can also be adjusted by subtracting the initial run state @xcite . ) higher numbers indicate larger degrees of success for the batting team . the batter events ( and their associated numerical rue values ) are generic out ( 0.240 ) , strikeout ( 0.207 ) , walk ( 0.845 ) , hit by pitch ( 0.969 ) , interference ( 1.132 ) , fielder s choice ( 0.240 ) , single ( 1.025 ) , double ( 1.311 ) , triple ( 1.616 ) , and home run ( 1.942 ) . note that we are ignoring events such as passed balls and stolen bases that can occur in addition to the above outcomes in a given plate appearance . this might lead to some undervaluing in the ranking for a small number of position players ( such as tim raines ) that rely on stolen bases . we also considered the metric known as weighted on base average ( woba ) @xcite , and note that any metric that assigns a value to a specific plate appearance can be used in place of rue without changing the rest of our ranking algorithm . this includes , in particular , popular sabermetric quantities such as win shares and value over replacement player ( vorp ) @xcite . one can also incorporate ideas like ballpark effects into the metric employed at this stage of the algorithm without changing any other part of the method . although it would make the methodology more complicated ( in contrast to our goals ) , it is also possible to generalize the algorithm to include more subtle effects such as estimates for when player performance peaks and how it declines over a long career . some of the active players in the data set have not yet entered a declining phase in their careers and might have higher rankings now than they will when their careers are over . we expect that the relatively high rankings of modern players versus ones who retired long ago might also result in part from the increased performance discrepancy between the top players and average players in the present era versus what used to be the case and in part from performing well against the larger number of relatively poor players occupying rosters because of expansion @xcite . finally , we note that batter pitcher matchups are not fully random but contain significant correlations ( e.g. , in a given baseball game , the entire lineup of one team has plate appearances against the other team s starting pitcher ) that can be incorporated to generalize the random walker process itself @xcite . to include the outcome of players who did not have many plate appearances without skewing their rankings via small samples , we separately accumulate the results for all pitchers and batters with fewer than some threshold number of plate appearances @xmath92 into a single `` replacement pitcher '' and `` replacement batter '' to represent these less prominent players . in the results presented in this paper , we used the threshold @xmath93 both for single seasons and for the collective outcome matrix . note that similar thresholds exist when determining single - season leadership in quantities such as batting average ( which requires 3.1 plate appearances per team game , yielding 502 in a 162-game season ) and earned run average ( 1 inning per team game ) .

we formulate the head - to - head matchups between major league baseball pitchers and batters from 1954 to 2008 as a bipartite network of mutually - antagonistic interactions . we consider both the full network and single - season networks , which exhibit interesting structural changes over time . we find interesting structure in the network and examine their sensitivity to baseball s rule changes . we then study a biased random walk on the matchup networks as a simple and transparent way to compare the performance of players who competed under different conditions and to include information about which particular players a given player has faced . we find that a player s position in the network does not correlate with his success in the random walker ranking but instead has a substantial effect on its sensitivity to changes in his own aggregate performance .

astro-ph0609338

over the last decade a concordance model has emerged in cosmology in which about two - thirds of the energy density of the universe today may be in the form of `` dark energy '' . this explains the observation that we reside in an accelerating universe @xcite . despite its importance to the formation and evolution of the universe there are no compelling theories that explain the energy density nor the properties of the dark energy . to address questions about the nature of dark energy a number of ambitious wide - field optical and infrared imaging surveys have been proposed . these range from space - based missions in the optical and infrared , such as the supernova acceleration probe ( snap , proposed as the space - based joint dark energy mission ( jdem ) ) , to ground - based surveys such as the panoramic survey telescope & rapid response system ( pan - starrs ) , the dark energy survey ( des ) , the large synoptic sky survey ( lsst ) and others . each of these missions approaches the study of dark energy using multiple , complementary observational probes : gravitational weak lensing ( wl ) to study the growth of structure and geometry , baryon oscillations to measure the angular diameter distance vs. redshift relation and type ia supernovae to measure the luminosity distance vs. redshift relation . in this paper we focus on one of these probes , weak lensing , and how the design of a survey might impact its scientific value for constraining dark energy . observations to date have succeeded in measuring the amplitude @xmath3 of the @xmath4 dark matter power spectrum to @xmath5 accuracy ( _ cf . _ @xcite and references therein ) by surveying @xmath6 deg@xmath7 of sky . to constrain the equation of state of dark energy requires that we improve the accuracy of these measures by close to an order of magnitude . to achieve this deep imaging surveys have been proposed that cover surveys of 1,000 - 20,000 square degrees in 5 - 6 filters . there is , however , a natural trade off in the design of these surveys ; depth vs number of filters vs area surveyed . to date the appropriate weighting of these components is not fully understood . for example , given the time and cost of a survey , does a large area , shallow survey in a small number of filters provide more scientific return than a deep survey in a large number of filters but sampling only a few hundred square degrees ? one of the primary requirements for any lensing application is the need for redshift information on the source galaxies . in the first studies of lensing only the statistical redshift distribution was available , but now surveys aim to get photometric redshifts ( connolly _ et al . _ 1995 ; hereafter photo - z s ) for individual galaxies . accurate photo - z information enables new qualitative and quantitative advances in lensing . conversely photo - z errors can be a limiting systematic in the use of lensing for precision cosmology . lensing tomography refers to the use of depth information in the source galaxies to get three - dimensional information on the lensing mass @xcite . by binning source galaxies in photo - z bins , the evolution of the lensing power spectrum can be measured . this greatly improves the sensitivity of lensing to dark energy in cosmological applications . the lensing power spectra measured from two redshift bins is shown in figure [ fig : cl ] . the two auto - spectra and the cross - spectrum , along with expected statistical errors , are shown . the relative shift in the amplitudes of the lensing spectra is sensitive to the properties of dark energy . it depends on both distances and the growth of structure , thus enabling tests of dark energy or modified gravity explanations for the cosmic acceleration . in figure [ fig : cl ] , the amplitude shifts of the three spectra ( for a given cosmological model ) depend on the mean redshifts and widths of the two photo - z bins ; clearly any errors in the bin redshifts will degrade the ability to discriminate cosmological models . thus the use of broadband multicolor photometry to estimate the distances of galaxies ( i.e.photometric redshifts ; henceforth abbreviated as photo - z s ) is critical to the use of lensing for dark energy studies . the capability of these surveys to meet their scientific goals will depend on our ability to characterize the uncertainties present within photometric redshift estimates , i.e. the scatter , bias and fraction of outliers . photometric redshifts must be calibrated with an appropriate sample of spectroscopic redshifts ( huterer _ et al . _ 2005 ; ma _ et al . _ this may be done more cheaply by using auto- and cross - correlations of photometric and spectroscopic redshifts samples @xcite , which can also be used to estimate the redshift distribution for a galaxy sample where the calibration data is incomplete ( see also zhan & knox 2006 ) . in this paper we study the possibility of doing lensing tomography from limited color information . imaging in five or more bands is needed for well - characterized photo - z s of galaxies extending beyond @xmath8 . we consider here whether lensing tomography can be carried out from a wide - area imaging survey in just two or three filters , along with a relatively small calibration sample that provides the statistical redshift distributions in all parts of the color space . these can be used to create a few sub - samples of the full galaxy sample that occupy distinct redshift bins , while discarding galaxies with colors that lead to badly defined redshift distributions . since lensing does not require redshift bins much narrower than @xmath9-@xmath10 in redshift , and does not need a full or fair sample of the galaxy population , there is reason to expect that limited color information may be sufficient for tomography . we use a mock catalog of galaxies with known redshifts to see how well one can make cosmological measurements with this approach , taking into account statistical errors in lensing measurements . in a future paper we will expand upon this analysis to include various sources of systematic errors in colors / photo - z s and in the lensing measurements . in section 2 we describe the formalism for computing lensing power spectra given the redshift distribution of a galaxy sample . in section 3 the mock catalog used for our study is described . section 4 contains the results on how well one can do with color cuts in making well separated redshift distributions for galaxy sub - samples . the errors on the power spectra and dark energy parameters are compared with the forecasts for idealized photo - z s . in section 5 we discuss the prospects for tomography with color cuts from imaging in a limited number of filters which we call color tomography . we will use the shear power spectrum as the lensing statistic for dark energy constraints . similar results can be obtained using two - point correlations and the mass aperture statistic . the key element in constraining dark energy is to use source galaxies in different redshift bins to probe the evolution of mass fluctuations and the geometric factors involved in lensing . we work in the context of spatially flat cold dark matter models for structure formation . the expansion history of the universe is given by the scale factor @xmath11 in a homogeneous and isotropic universe . the expansion rate , the hubble parameter , is given in terms of the matter density @xmath12 ( the cold dark matter plus the baryons ) and dark energy density @xmath13 at present ( in units of the critical density @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the hubble parameter at present ) by @xmath16\ ] ] where we have employed the normalization @xmath17 today and @xmath18 specifies the equation of state for dark energy as @xmath19 note that @xmath20 corresponds to a cosmological constant . the comoving distance @xmath21 from an observer at @xmath22 to a source at @xmath23 is expressed in terms of the hubble parameter as @xmath24 this gives the distance - redshift relation @xmath25 via the relation @xmath26 . next we need the growth of density perturbations . in linear theory , all fourier modes of the mass density perturbation , @xmath27 , grow at the same rate , the growth rate @xmath28 : @xmath29 . note that we use the primordial curvature power spectrum amplitude to normalize the linear 3d mass power spectrum , and therefore @xmath28 is normalized as @xmath30 in the deeply matter dominated regime ( e.g. , @xmath31 ; see equation ( 10 ) in takada 2006 for details ) . in the following , the tilde symbol is used to denote fourier components . the shear power spectrum is identical to that of the convergence , which is easier to work with as it is a scalar . in the context of cosmological gravitational lensing , the convergence field is expressed as a weighted projection of the three - dimensional density fluctuation field between source and observer ( e.g. , see bartelmann & schneider 2001 ; mellier 1999 for reviews ) : @xmath32 , \label{eqn : kappa}\ ] ] where @xmath33 is the angular position on the sky , @xmath34 is the comoving distance , and @xmath35 is the distance to the horizon . note that for a flat universe the comoving angular diameter distance is equivalent to the comoving distance . the lensing weight function @xmath36 is defined in equation [ eqn : weight ] below . photometric redshift information on source galaxies allows us to subdivide the galaxies into redshift bins . the average number density of galaxies in a redshift bin @xmath2 , defined to lie between the comoving distances @xmath37 and @xmath38 , is given by @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the redshift selection function of source galaxies . it is normalized as @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the average number density per unit steradian . note that @xmath43 determines the shot noise contamination due to the intrinsic ellipticities of galaxies for the power spectrum measurement in the @xmath2 bin ( see equation ( [ eqn : covps ] ) and discussion below ) . the convergence field for subsample @xmath2 is given by using in equation [ eqn : kappa ] the lensing weight function @xmath44 , given by @xmath45 where @xmath46 . how a dynamically evolving dark energy model changes the lensing weight function is shown in figure 3 in huterer ( 2002 ) . for example , increasing @xmath47 lowers @xmath44 similar to the dependence of the growth rate of mass clustering for cmb normalization . thus the dependence of lensing observables on the equation of state arises roughly equally from the two effects . to compute the convergence power spectrum , we employ the flat - sky , limber equation which is a good approximation over angular scales of interest ( kaiser 1992 ; hu 2000 ) . within this framework the lensing convergence field is decomposed into angular modes based on the two - dimensional fourier transform : @xmath48 . the angular power spectrum , @xmath49 , is defined as @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the dirac delta function , @xmath52 denotes ensemble averaging , and @xmath53 . for lensing tomography , we use all the auto- and cross - power spectra that are constructed from source galaxies divided into redshift bins . the angular power spectrum between redshift bins @xmath2 and @xmath54 , @xmath55 , is given by @xmath56 where the lensing weight function @xmath44 is given by equation ( [ eqn : weight ] ) and @xmath57 is the three - dimensional mass power spectrum . using @xmath58 redshift bins leads to @xmath59 cross and auto power spectra . the non - linear gravitational evolution of @xmath57 significantly enhances the amplitude of the lensing power spectrum on angular scales @xmath60 ( see figure [ fig : cl ] ) . therefore , we need an accurate model of @xmath57 , for which we employ the fitting formula proposed by smith et al . ( 2003 , hereafter smith03 ) . we assume that the smith03 formula can be applied to dark energy cosmologies , if we replace the growth factor in the formula with that for a given dark energy cosmology ( white & vale 2004 ; linder & white 2005 ) . the issue of how accurately the non - linear power spectrum needs to be calibrated to attain the full potential of lensing surveys is addressed in huterer & takada ( 2005 ) . measured shear correlations contain a shot - noise contribution from the intrinsic ellipticities of source galaxies . assuming that the ellipticity distribution is uncorrelated between different galaxies , the observed power spectrum between redshift bins @xmath2 and @xmath54 can be expressed as ( kaiser 1992 , 1998 ; hu 1999 ) @xmath61 where @xmath43 is the average number density of galaxies in redshift bin @xmath2 , as given by equation ( [ eqn : ni ] ) , and @xmath62 is the intrinsic shape noise of each galaxy . the kronecker delta function enforces the fact that the cross power spectrum with @xmath63 is not affected by shot noise ( hu 1999 ) . in this sense , the cross - power spectrum is an unbiased estimator of the cosmological signal . we have ignored other possible contaminations such as observational systematics and intrinsic ellipticity alignments . the power spectrum covariance is needed to understand statistical errors on the power spectrum measurement . the covariance between the power spectra @xmath64 and @xmath65 is @xmath66 & = & \frac{2\delta_{ll'}}{(2l+1)\delta l f_{\rm sky } } \left[c^{\rm obs}_{(im)}(l)c_{(jn)}^{\rm obs}(l ) + c^{\rm obs}_{(in)}(l)c_{(jm)}^{\rm obs}(l)\right ] \label{eqn : covps}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath67 is the fraction of sky covered and @xmath68 is the bin width centered at @xmath69 . we have used only the gaussian contribution to the covariance which does not lead to any correlation between the power spectra of different @xmath69 modes . we restrict our analysis to angular scales @xmath70 ; as discussed below , our conclusions are stronger with the inclusion of non - gaussian covariances or if a more conservative ( lower ) choice of the maximum @xmath69 is employed . figure [ fig : cl ] shows the lensing power spectra for two redshift bins , leading to 3 different power spectra as indicated . the solid curves are the results from the smith03 fitting formula . to estimate the errors on the measured power spectra , we parameterized a lensing survey by its survey area , @xmath71 degree@xmath7 , the galaxy number density @xmath72 and the rms of intrinsic ellipticities @xmath73 . the number density we have used would be achievable with a limiting magnitude @xmath74 imaging survey in excellent seeing conditions . the dashed line in figure [ fig : cl ] shows the contribution from intrinsic ellipticity shot noise to the power spectrum errors . for the power spectra shown , the shot noise contribution becomes smaller than the sample variance at wavenumbers @xmath69 smaller than the intersection of the power spectrum points with the shot noise line . the correlation coefficient between the power spectra of the redshift bins , @xmath75^{1/2}$ ] , quantifies how the power spectra are correlated . even with only two redshift bins , the power spectra are highly correlated ( @xmath76 ) . one thus gains little information from fine subdivisions of the redshift bins ( hu 1999 , 2002a , b ) . the box around each curve shows the expected measurement error at a given bin of @xmath69 , which includes sample variance and the error due to intrinsic ellipticities . the sample variance dominates the error over much of the angular scales that provide cosmological information . finally , to clarify the effect of non - linear gravitational clustering , the thin solid curve shows the prediction of @xmath77 from the linear mass power spectrum : non - linear evolution significantly enhances the amplitude for @xmath60 ( jain & seljak 1997 ) . a monte - carlo realization of @xmath78 galaxies was generated to approximate the redshift and colors distributions of galaxy samples obtained by the next generation of photometric surveys ( e.g. the lsst ) . galaxies were initially selected to match the observed number - magnitude relation for @xmath2-band selected galaxies of metcalfe _ et al . _ ( 2001 ) to a depth of @xmath2=27 . for each galaxy a redshift and spectral type was assigned . the redshifts were drawn from the magnitude - redshift distributions observed by the deep2 spectroscopic survey ( willmer _ et al . _ 2006 ) and the evolution of the distribution of spectral types of galaxies was based on the observations and models of franceschini _ et al . _ 2006 . colors were estimated , as a function of redshift and spectral type , using the @xmath79 filter response functions of the lsst ( see figure [ fig : filters ] ) . in total 10 spectral templates were used in this sample which were derived from the observed spectral properties of galaxies in the sdss ( including emission lines ) and supplemented with a young ( 50 myr ) star forming galaxy template drawn from the models of bruzual and charlot ( 2003 ) . photometric uncertainties are estimated based on the lsst exposure calculator assuming that each source has been observed approximately 400 times in each filter . the final catalog was limited to @xmath80 at which depth the galaxies have a signal - to - noise of approximately 15 for lsst s exposure times . thus the photometric errors in our catalog are smaller than would be expected in shallower surveys ; we leave a detailed modeling of this and other errors for future work . figure [ fig : colors ] shows the distribution of galaxies in color space . galaxies in three redshift intervals are shown to illustrate that , while they generally occupy different regions in color space , there is significant overlap , and moreover they can not be isolated by making simple color cuts . we use these properties to guide our algorithm for selecting regions in color space for tomography in the next section . having constructed our mock galaxy catalog , we used a set of heuristic criteria to cluster galaxies in color space . the goal is to construct 2 - 4 sub - samples with the `` cleanest '' possible redshift distributions . to achieve this we identify the redshift distribution of each region of color space , discard the regions with poorly behaved distributions , and group the rest into a set of sub - samples that would be useful for lensing tomography , i.e. have well separated and compact redshift distributions . we pixelized @xmath81 vs. @xmath82 space into 400 pixels , and used the redshift distribution of each pixel to rank pixels in order of increasing mean redshift . we also characterized the compactness of the distribution associated with each pixel by computing its low order moments . we then grouped pixels into sub - samples following a set of heuristic criteria : * the mean redshift associated with each pixel in a sub - sample fell within a well - defined redshift range . * the redshift distribution of each pixel retained was sufficiently compact ( had a small variance ) . * the joint distribution of pixels included a desired fraction of the total number of galaxies ( typically more than a quarter of the total ) . * the mean redshifts of the 3 or 4 sub - samples were useful for lensing tomography , i.e. were sufficiently well spread out over the range @xmath83 . this was iterated to arrive at the final selection and grouping of color pixels and thus the boundaries of the final redshift sub - samples . figure [ fig : dndz ] shows the results of making color cuts to isolate four redshift intervals with boundaries at @xmath84 . we can trade - off number of galaxies within a sample versus how `` clean '' the redshift intervals are : the left and right panels of the figure show the results of different trade - offs . in the right panel , about half of the galaxies are discarded so that the resulting redshift samples have almost no overlap . in the left panel , the overlap is at the @xmath85 level or smaller . this level of overlap provides a clean enough separation for wl tomography , but risks contamination of the lensing signal by intrinsic alignments . hence we use the more conservative choice in the right panel for dark energy forecasts below . we also note that for baryon oscillation measurements the widths in redshift of these sub - samples are too large ; one would need to focus on finding particular galaxy types that yield tighter redshift distributions . figure [ fig : dndz2 ] shows the results for a shallower sample with limiting magnitude @xmath86 . the basic result is similar , though with fewer galaxies at @xmath87 , it is more difficult to make four well separated sub - samples . we also explored the possibility of lensing tomography with just two - band imaging . we used cuts in @xmath82 color and @xmath2 band magnitude to create two or three different redshift distributions ( note that for the three - band case , we did not use the magnitudes to improve our redshift selection ) . while this is clearly an idealized exercise , in that it assumes a large calibration sample and does not include systematic errors or allow for variation in the spectral templates , the results in figure [ fig : dndz3 ] show that it is not a hopeless goal . tomography is possible in up to three bins if @xmath88 of the galaxies can be discarded ( left panel ) , though with significant overlap between the first two redshift samples . an alternative is to make just two samples ( right panel ) while losing fewer galaxies and having minimal overlap between the samples . we will quantify the consequences for cosmological parameter estimation below . figure [ fig : power ] shows the lensing power spectra with errors for a 2,000 square degree survey with three - band imaging , using the four redshift distributions of figure [ fig : dndz ] . next we compare the errors on the power spectra for two cases : ( a ) all galaxies within a redshift range were used to compute the power spectrum ( this represents the case of idealized photo - z s ) , and , ( b ) only galaxies selected using color cuts were used to compute the power spectrum ( with distributions shown in the left panel of figure [ fig : dndz ] ) . while the sample variance contribution is nearly the same as it depends on the amplitude of the power spectrum itself , the shot noise contribution is higher with the color cuts due to the loss in number density of galaxies . since the change in errors is undetectable on the power spectrum plot , we show the ratio of the errors for the two cases ( idealized photo - z s vs. color cuts ) in figure [ fig : power_ratio ] . the left and right panels correspond to the two sets of color cuts used in figure [ fig : dndz ] . the errors increase by a few percent to over 50% depending on the sample and the range of @xmath69 . at low wavenumber , @xmath89 , for all cases the increase in error is at the 10% level . thus color tomography does not degrade the errors at low wavenumber , since the errors are dominated by sample variance . at high wavenumber @xmath90 the degradation depends on the fraction of galaxies discarded in making the redshift sample ; for the right panel it is as high as 50% . the impact on dark energy parameters depends on the relative weights at low and high @xmath69 . note that we have underestimated the sample variance contribution to the errors by using only the gaussian terms . the degradation due to the shot noise contribution would be smaller if non - gaussian contributions to the sample variance were included ( these are significant at @xmath91 ) . cosmological parameters : lensing + l@ccc@ccc@ccc & & & + & 6 @xmath92-bins & & 4 @xmath92-bins & 4 @xmath92-bins@xmath93 & & 3 @xmath92-bins & 2 @xmath92-bins + @xmath94 & 0.019 & & 0.023 & 0.027 & & 0.048 & 0.1 + @xmath95 & 0.19 & & 0.22 & 0.25 & & 0.46 & 0.97 & + @xmath96 & 0.64 & & 0.72 & 0.86 & & 1.4 & 2.6 & + cosmological parameters : lensing+cmb + l@ccc@ccc@ccc & & & + & 6 @xmath92-bins & & 4 @xmath92-bins & 4 @xmath92-bins@xmath93 & & 3 @xmath92-bins & 2 @xmath92-bins + @xmath94 & 0.013 & & 0.014 & 0.016 & & 0.025 & 0.033 & + @xmath95 & 0.11 & & 0.13 & 0.15 & & 0.24 & 0.32 & + @xmath96 & 0.27 & & 0.30 & 0.36 & & 0.54 & 0.73 & + having computed the lensing power spectra and the errors on them for different redshift samples , we estimate the errors on dark energy parameters using the fisher matrix formalism . this formalism assesses how well given observables can distinguish the true ( `` fiducial '' ) cosmological model from other models . the parameter forecasts we obtain depend on the fiducial model and are also sensitive to the choice of free parameters . we include all the key parameters that may affect lensing observables within the cdm and dark energy cosmological framework : the density parameters are @xmath97 , @xmath98 , and @xmath99 ( note that we assume a flat universe ) ; the primordial power spectrum parameters are the spectral tilt , @xmath100 , the running index , @xmath101 , and the normalization parameter of primordial curvature perturbation , @xmath102 ( the values in the parentheses denote the fiducial model ) . we employ the transfer function of matter perturbations , @xmath103 , with baryon oscillations smoothed out ( eisenstein & hu 1999 ) . the dark energy equation of state parameters are @xmath104 , with fiducial values @xmath105 and @xmath106 . combining weak lensing with constraints from cmb temperature and polarization anisotropies can be a powerful way to lift parameter degeneracies ( e.g. hu & tegmark 1999 ; takada & jain 2004 ) . when computing the fisher matrix for the cmb , we employ 9 parameters : the 8 parameters above plus the thomson scattering optical depth to the last scattering surface , @xmath107 . the fisher matrix for the joint experiment is given by adding the cmb fisher matrix to the lensing fisher matrix as @xmath108 . we ignore the contribution to the cmb from the primordial gravitational waves . we use the publicly - available cmbfast code @xcite to compute the angular power spectra of temperature anisotropy , @xmath109 , @xmath110-mode polarization , @xmath111 , and their cross correlation , @xmath112 . specifically we consider the noise per pixel and the angular resolution of the planck experiment that were assumed in eisenstein et al . note that we use the cmb information in the range of multipole @xmath113 , and therefore we do not include the isw effect at low multipoles @xmath114 which might be affected by dark energy perturbations . we compare the fisher errors for lensing tomography with color cuts versus what is achievable with six redshift bins derived from an idealized set of photo - z s using the lsst filter set . in both cases we ignore the scatter of galaxies across bins due to photometric errors and inexact spectral templates for galaxies . for color cuts , we consider three and two band imaging , and in each case we use two sets of redshift distributions to represent a more and less conservative treatment . these correspond to the right ( more conservative ) and left panels of figures [ fig : dndz ] ( three band imaging ) and [ fig : dndz3 ] ( two band imaging ) . we consider constraints from lensing alone as well as from lensing with cmb priors . we focus on dark energy parameters @xmath115 and @xmath116 but also comment on the errors on the primordial power spectrum . figures [ fig : fisher1 ] and [ fig : fisher2 ] show the results for the dark energy parameters while tables [ tab : lens ] and [ tab : lens+cmb ] give the numerical values of the errors on @xmath117 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 . these are marginalized over all other parameters . table [ tab : lens ] shows the constraints from lensing , while table [ tab : lens+cmb ] includes the fisher errors expected from cmb data from the planck satellite . we have used only the lensing power spectrum ; adding information from the lensing bispectrum or lensing - galaxy cross - correlations would improve the parameter constraints . in tables [ tab : lens ] and [ tab : lens+cmb ] the errors in column 2 ( from 6 redshift bins with idealized photo - z s ) can be compared with columns 3 and 4 ( 4 @xmath92-bins using color cuts from three - band imaging data ) and columns 5 and 6 ( 3 and 2 @xmath92-bins from two - band imaging ) . columns 4 and 6 represent the conservative option for three and two - band imaging respectively , in that the redshift sub - samples have minimal overlap . for three - band imaging , even the conservative choice of column 4 shows that the degradation is modest : at the 30% level compared to the ideal case of 6-bin tomography . the loss of about half the galaxies does not prove very damaging as much of the cosmological information comes from the sample variance dominated regime . for two - band imaging , the degradation depends on whether one uses 3 or 2 @xmath92-bins . the last column shows that there is significant degradation with 2 @xmath92-bins . we found that even for this case , one parameter representing @xmath47 at the pivot redshift can be measured well . but constraints on @xmath115 and @xmath116 separately are severely compromised with just 2 @xmath92-bins . the parameter degradations are significantly reduced when cmb information is used , as shown in table [ tab : lens+cmb ] . this is due to the coarser requirements of lensing tomography once the high-@xmath92 information from the cmb is used . note that all these results depend on the lensing survey size , as the shot noise contribution affects parameter errors more for a smaller survey . and the results in table [ tab : lens+cmb ] are less impressive if the cmb priors are from wmap instead of planck . the constraints on the three dark energy parameters are shown in figures [ fig : fisher1 ] and [ fig : fisher2 ] . idealized photo - z tomography is compared with 4 @xmath92-bin tomography from three - band imaging , using the more conservative choice of redshift sub - samples . these confirm the information in the tables : the degradation in the dark energy parameters is modest , and is even smaller in the best determined combination of @xmath115 and @xmath116 , which is the value of @xmath47 at the pivot redshift for lensing . we also note that lensing primarily probes parameters that are more sensitive to the lensing power spectrum amplitude rather than its shape parameters ( see the discussion in takada & jain 2004 ) . for our case these parameters are @xmath117 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 and @xmath118 . adding redshift slices for tomography improves the errors on these parameters significantly up to 4 - 6 slices as it provides information on the redshift evolution of the amplitude of the lensing power spectrum . errors on the shape parameters , such as the logarithmic slope of the power spectrum @xmath58 , do not change appreciably . we have studied the prospects for lensing tomography with a wide area imaging survey that has limited color information . while it is never desirable to limit color information , it may be that a full complement of filters is not available at a survey telescope , that it is un - realistic to image the full survey area in all filters , or that additional science requirements for a survey dictate an observing strategy that is not optimal for lensing tomography . the questions we address in this study are whether lensing tomography is at all feasible with two or three band imaging data , and if so , what is the trade - off between filter choice and sky coverage . we use the fact that lensing tomography makes only statistical use of estimated redshifts and , given the width of the lensing kernel , the redshift bins can be quite broad ( though they must be known accurately ) . further , for planned wide - area surveys lensing measurements are not shot noise limited hence a significant fraction of galaxies can be discarded if their redshifts are ill - defined without severely degrading parameter accuracy . with these considerations in mind , we generate a mock catalog of galaxies extending to high redshift with known types , redshifts and colors . this provides an estimate of the redshift distributions for each part of @xmath81 and @xmath82 color space . from this we select regions in color space that produce sub - samples with redshift distributions well suited for tomography . errors on the power spectra in different redshift bins from this color tomography are then compared with what would be expected with idealized photo - z s . the resulting degradation in the accuracy of cosmological parameters is shown in tables [ tab : lens ] and [ tab : lens+cmb ] , and figures [ fig : fisher1 ] and [ fig : fisher2 ] for dark energy parameters from color tomography . with three - band imaging , the errors on dark energy parameters are only modestly degraded compared to idealized six - band photo - z s . even with two - band imaging , lensing tomography may be feasible for the case of high signal - to - noise data and an adequate calibration sample . this result may have implications for how to trade - off filter choice and sky coverage for large area surveys and how to optimize survey strategy to maximize the scientific returns in its initial stages . for example , imaging in three filters instead of six is more than twice as efficient in terms of survey time since the @xmath119 and @xmath120 filters ( on the blue and red end ) are substantially less efficient . thus , for a fixed survey duration , the survey area for a six band program would be less than half that of the three band survey , with all parameter errors scaling as @xmath121 . such trade - off studies must be carried out for the specific parameters and available choices in observing strategy for a given survey ; the fiducial parameters we have considered do not correspond to any real or planned survey known to us . for color tomography an adequate calibration sample is essential . the calibration will likely require a two - step approach : a sample of spectroscopic redshifts of over @xmath122 galaxies ( for a @xmath123 square degree survey ) , and a larger sample of multi - band imaging with a full set of optical and possibly infra - red filters . imaging to a depth equivalent to @xmath124 in say six bands over @xmath125-@xmath126 square degrees would provide a sample of well measured photo - z s for over @xmath127 million galaxies . this would enable us to map the redshift distributions over the desired color space : e.g. , it could provide photo - z s of over @xmath128 galaxies in each bin of @xmath129 magnitude in two - colors ( assumed to be available for the full survey area ) . it has been recognized that even with five or six band imaging data , photo - z s would need to be carefully calibrated with spectroscopic redshifts so that the means and widths of redshift bins are known to high accuracy ( bernstein & jain 2004 ; huterer _ et al . _ 2006 ; ma , hu and huterer 2006 ) , and proposals for calibration are being developed ( newman 2006 ) . for color tomography the calibration sample is even more important , as it forms the basis for grouping and discarding regions in color space . we leave for future work the detailed requirements and strategy for obtaining the calibration sample . our current study is based on estimates of statistical errors in the lensing power spectra in future work we will include systematic photometric uncertainties and other systematic errors that affect lensing . these will include a realistic modeling of photometric errors , filter design , and will address whether the spectral templates are adequate for describing high - redshift galaxies . the inclusion of these realistic errors is essential before one can make detailed trade - off studies of survey duration and filter choice . several caveats are in order until such a study is done : systematic errors may lower the signal - to - noise and this may depend on scale , testing for systematics is more difficult with coarser redshift bins , and marginalizing over intrinsic ellipticity contributions may be harder ( see below ) . finally , the inclusion of other statistics such as higher order correlations and cross - correlations with the galaxy distribution can alter the results on parameter accuracies . some of these issues can be tested on ongoing multicolor surveys , such as the cfht legacy survey . our results on the power spectrum errors in figure [ fig : power_ratio ] show that the degradation in errors is worse at high @xmath69 , because the shot noise term dominates on small scales . this raises the question : should one choose different galaxy samples at different @xmath69 : be more conservative at low @xmath69 , since number density matters less , to minimize redshift overlap and bias ? this merits a detailed study as it has the potential to impact different survey strategies . such a study must include non - gaussian contributions that increase the sample variance at high @xmath69 ; this in fact lowers the degradation for color tomography as the shot noise regime shifts to higher @xmath69 ( e.g. kilbinger & schneider 2005 ) . finally , intrinsic ellipticity alignments ( e.g. heymans _ et al . _ 2006 ) and ellipticity - shear alignments ( hirata & seljak 2004 ) must be considered . while we did choose as our fiducial sub - samples ones with well separated redshift distributions , it may be necessary to only use cross - spectra to eliminate intrinsic ellipticity contributions ( e.g. takada & white 2004 ) . this would increase the parameter errors from having a smaller number of redshift bins . similarly ellipticity - shear correlations may need to be measured from the data and marginalized over , which is easier to do with finer redshift binning . four redshift bins are the minimum needed to separately fit for both kinds of intrinsic ellipticity correlations , this may impose a minimal requirement on the needed color information . the impact of intrinsic alignments is likely to be the most important issue for future studies related to color tomography . we thank mike jarvis for stimulating discussions at all stages of this work and eric linder for valuable comments on an early draft . we thank gary bernstein , peter schneider , ravi sheth and fritz stabenau for helpful discussions . this work was supported in part by the coe program at tohoku university . mt acknowledges support from a grand - in - aid for scientific research ( 17740129 ) of the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology in japan . bj is supported in part by nasa grant nag5 - 10924 and by the research corporation . ajc is supported in part by an nsf itr award and nsf career award ast9984924 . ajc would like to thank google for their hospitality while completing this work . we acknowledge use of the publicly - available cmbfast code .

lensing tomography with multi - color imaging surveys can probe dark energy and the cosmological power spectrum . however accurate photometric redshifts for tomography out to high redshift require imaging in five or more bands , which is expensive to carry out over thousands of square degrees . since lensing makes coarse , statistical use of redshift information , we explore the prospects for tomography using limited color information from two or three band imaging . with an appropriate calibration sample , we find that it is feasible to create up to four redshift bins using imaging data in just the @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 bands . we construct such redshift sub - samples from mock catalogs by clustering galaxies in color space and discarding regions with poorly - defined redshift distributions . the loss of galaxy number density decreases the accuracy of lensing measurements , but even losing half or more of the galaxies is not a severe loss for large area surveys . we estimate the errors on lensing power spectra and dark energy parameters with color tomography and discuss trade - offs in survey area and filter choice . we discuss the systematic errors that may change our conclusions , especially the information needed to tackle intrinsic alignments .

math0108169

the motivation of this paper is the main theorem in pointwise asymptotic formulas on flat surfaces " of a. eskin and h. masur @xcite . they prove that on strata of quadratic differentials @xmath2 , parametrizing half translation surfaces , there exists almost everywhere a limit of the quadratic growth rate and it is constant ( with respect to a natural @xmath3 invariant liouville measure @xmath4 on @xmath2 see veech @xcite ) . the following questions arise : + 1 . does the quadratic growth rate associated to these constants majorize all other quadratic growth rates ? + 2 . how can one compute the constants ? are there ( sub ) spaces of quadratic differentials , where one can prove not only almost everywhere results but pointwise results ? + 3b . and if one has pointwise results , on which sets do the constants take different " values ? + our example the simplest one can find , but it has the advantage that one can compute things elementary . the above stated questions could all be answered in a precise way . + the paper contains results about the growth rates of cylinders of periodic trajectories or saddle connections on the two dimensional torus @xmath5 , @xmath6 with @xmath0 marked points . if the number of cylinders of periodic orbits ( po ) or saddle connections ( sc ) of length less than @xmath7 on @xmath8}$ ] is denoted by @xmath9},t)$ ] then the existence of the limits @xmath10},t)}{t^2}\ ] ] for every constellation of marked points i.e. for all @xmath11\in { { \mathbb{t}}^{2n}}$ ] is proved . , because this differs from the general marking only by a translation . all our counting results are invarinat under translations of the marking . ] remark : in the mathematical sense this is not the true parameterspace , because we would like to have all marked points different , but since we make either pointwise statements with respect to one marking or only measure theoretic statements with respect to the lebesgue measure on this space the difference to a well choosen parameter space plays no role . moreover all statements are true for any conformal class the tori might have . the existence of the limits is established by counting lattice points of certain lattices in the universal cover @xmath12 of @xmath13 . as a biproduct of this method we conclude that there is a subset @xmath14 ( which depends on what one counts : saddle connections or periodic families ) of measure one in the parameter space of all n markings ( contained in the set of all non rational n markings ) where the above limit takes a maximal value @xmath15 . moreover it is easy to see that if one approaches a point of the set @xmath16 the asymptotic constants of the sequence converge to @xmath15 . in other words the map @xmath17 \longmapsto \lim_{t\rightarrow \infty } \frac{n_{po / sc}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[x_0, ... ,x_{n-1}]},t)}{t^2}\ ] ] is continous at the points of the set @xmath18 . in the case of two marked points and only in this case the set @xmath19 does not depend on what is counted ( po s or sc s ) . without restrictions one can assume that the first marking is @xmath20 $ ] , then the set of points in general position consists exactly of all the non rational points @xmath21 . in this case the quadratic growth rate function for saddle connections , assuming @xmath22 , is given by : @xmath23 & \longmapsto & \frac{6}{\pi}\left ( 1 + \prod_{p| n\ prime}\left(1-\frac{1}{p^2}\right)^{-1 } \sum_{\gcd(i , n)=1}\left(\frac{1}{i^2}-\frac{1}{n^2 } \right)\right ) \quad \mbox{on } { \mathbb{q}}^2 \nonumber\\ \left[x , y \right ] & \longmapsto & \frac{6}{\pi}+\pi \quad \mbox{for } ( x , y ) \notin { \mathbb{q}}^2\end{aligned}\ ] ] the continuity at non rational points implies that the above formula approaches @xmath24 as @xmath25 approximates a non rational number . in contrast to the general for two marked points this continuity is calculated directly by an estimate . furthermore for the two marked torus we write down the veech and affine groups for rational markings . an argument shows that every veech surface coming from a rational marking is a @xmath1 deformation of one of the family @xmath26 } : \ n \in { \mathbb{n}}\}$ ] . therefore all the veech groups of rationally marked tori are isomorphic to one of the veech groups @xmath27}$ ] associated to the family of surfaces @xmath28 . finally the asymptotic formula of veech and the asymptotic counting of lattice points in the plane is used to compute the index @xmath29}]$ ] . with the help of the description of the veech groups for rational 2 markings we rediscover the index of some classical congruence subgroups of @xmath1 . it is now well known @xcite that one can also use ratners theorem to obtain pointwise results in modulispaces of torus coverings branched over n marked points . of course from the point of pure existence of the growth rates this is more general and in fact covers the examples described in the paper . on the other hand the results in this paper are explicit and the extremality , or more restrictive the maximality of the almost everywhere constants are proved for the above cases . in this direction one of the main objects of the paper was to see if there is something in between purely rational markings and markings in general position which has not an extremal growth rate . this question also could be answered with yes " ( see theorem [ tlimes ] and the preparatory lemma [ schnigi ] ) . unfortunately our elementary methods can not directly taken over to prove something on families of branched coverings of tori , but nevertheless with the more sophisticated approach in @xcite one can compute all the siegel veech constants for two marked torus coverings which are not veech . the results in @xcite show , that in this cases the siegel veech constants , as functions of the degree of the covering , behave monotonically , too . in the light of eskins and this results it would be of interest to compute and prove related statements for marked veech surfaces and their branched coverings . acknowledgements : + i have to thank for the hospitality of the cpt in marseille luminy in person of ricardo lima and his group during the jear 99 as well as alex eskin and pascal hubert for fruitful discussions . i owe thanks to eugene gutkin for pointing out an unprecise statement to me and the referee for finding a mistake . this paper is part of my thesis and i like to give many thanks to tyll krger and serge troubetzkoy for their continuous encouragement making this work possible . for @xmath30, ... ,[x_n]\in { \mathbb{r}}^2/ { \mathbb{z}}^2 $ ] let @xmath31 ) } $ ] be the translation torus @xmath32 marked at the points @xmath30,[x_1], ... ,[x_{n-1}]\in { \mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] . if we do not write down the zeroth entry @xmath30 $ ] in the index vector we assume @xmath30=0+{\mathbb{z}}^2 $ ] . our calculations are restricted to the torus which is isometric to @xmath33 with the induced euclidean metric . with respect to this choice the periodic directions ( of the geodesic flow ) are exactly the ones with rational slope . the results are not restricted to these special translation tori , they hold for all marked translation tori . in fact all the arguments are invariant under @xmath3 deformations of the marked tori and any marked translation torus is an @xmath3 deformation of the studied ones . the vector @xmath34 * associated * to a saddle connection @xmath35 ( or a prime periodic orbit ) is the unique vector @xmath34 in @xmath36 that maps isometrically to @xmath35 in @xmath37 under the natural projection map . recall that in the case of a periodic orbit @xmath35 the associated vector @xmath34 characterizes a whole cylinder of closed geodesics . a rational two vector like @xmath38 is always assumed to fulfill the condition @xmath39 . @xmath40 * two points @xmath41,[y]\in { \mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] are said to be * relatively rational * , if @xmath42 . * @xmath43 denotes the set of saddle connections between the points @xmath41\in{\mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] and @xmath44\in{\mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] . * @xmath45 is the length of a @xmath46 and finally if @xmath47,[z]\in s \in sc_{(x , y)}$ ] let @xmath48 be the distance between @xmath47 $ ] and @xmath49 $ ] * measured along @xmath35 . * relatively rational is obviously an equivalence relation . every marking splits up in classes of relatively rational points . each class defines a marking , eventually of lower order . by the results of veech @xcite or gutkin and judge @xcite @xmath8}$ ] is a covering of the one marked torus @xmath50}$ ] if and only if all marked points @xmath51 are pairwise relatively rational . thus @xmath8}$ ] is a veech surface if and only if for all markings are in one and the same marking class and from @xcite it follows : @xmath52}\right)\subset sl_2({\mathbb{q}})$ ] , where @xmath52}\right)$ ] denotes the veech group of @xmath8}$ ] . any affine diffeomorphism @xmath53 of the unmarked torus @xmath54 is given by an element @xmath55)\in sl_2({\mathbb{z}})\oplus { \mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] : @xmath56)=[az+v]$ ] . since every affine diffeomorphism of the marked torus defines one of the unmarked torus by forgetting marked points one obtains : @xmath57}\right)\subset sl_2({\mathbb{z}}).\ ] ] a * lattice * @xmath58 is a subset of @xmath12 of the form @xmath59 a * point distribution * is a finite union of lattices . the set of * visible points * @xmath60 of of a discrete subset @xmath61 consists of all points @xmath62 such there is no @xmath63 and a point @xmath64 with @xmath65 . in other words : there is no other point of @xmath58 on the line between the origin and the points @xmath66 . for the correct counting of periodic orbits and saddle connections we need further : if a point distribution @xmath58 is contained in another point distribution @xmath67 , then the visible points @xmath68 of @xmath67 with respect to @xmath58 are those @xmath69 for which there is a @xmath70 such that @xmath71 . @xmath72 is called @xmath73 * complete * if @xmath74 . + @xmath58 is called * closed * , if @xmath75 for any integer @xmath76 such that there exist two points @xmath77 with @xmath78 . let @xmath41,[y]\in { \mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] , again we put @xmath79 . then the set of saddle connections @xmath43 is described by the visible points of the lattice of associated vectors @xmath80 . + for a discrete subset @xmath61 ( in general point distributions ) we define for @xmath81 @xmath82 here @xmath83 is the ( closed ) disc of radius @xmath7 centered in the origin of @xmath12 . given a nonrational ( marked ) point @xmath44 $ ] on the marked torus @xmath84}^2 $ ] . take a saddle connection @xmath85 from the origin to @xmath44 $ ] . it might be represented in @xmath12 by @xmath86 with two fixed integers @xmath87 and an @xmath88 choosen from the set @xmath89 . assume we take a second point @xmath41\in { \mathbb{t}}_{[0]}^2 $ ] @xmath90 , different from @xmath44 $ ] so , that there is a saddle connection @xmath91 , which fulfills an equation @xmath92 this means after mark the point @xmath41 $ ] the saddle connection @xmath93 destroys @xmath94 and generates two new saddle connections , @xmath93 and one in the set @xmath95 . it is clear by equation ( [ relation ] ) , that if the factor @xmath96 is a rational number , say @xmath97 , all saddle connections represented by @xmath98 , @xmath99 are divided by the marking @xmath100 to give saddle connections in @xmath95 and @xmath101 . now assume @xmath41 $ ] rationally divides two saddle connections from @xmath102 with the equations : @xmath103 with integers @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 as above . subtract the two equations to obtain : @xmath107 since @xmath88 is non rational @xmath108 . assuming this we have : @xmath109 this equation has solutions if @xmath110 is ( componentwise ) divisible by @xmath111 . thus the saddle connections in the set @xmath112 dividing the ones from @xmath113 rationally , all have a common stretch factor @xmath114 . hence , if there is more than one rationally dividing saddle connection , then they are all given by the ( lattice ) set of vectors @xmath115 if @xmath44 $ ] , @xmath116 are fixed the different sets of rationally dividing saddle connections for the stretch factor @xmath114 are parameterized by @xmath117 . it is now clear that @xmath95 contains a lattice . = 7truecm to make shure there are not too much parallel saddle connections in @xmath101 and @xmath102 having non rational length ratio , consider the set @xmath118 of saddle connections that are represented by @xmath119 , where @xmath120 is non rational . [ countnrat ] @xmath121 . assume that the growth rate in question is of bigger than linear order , then there must be an integer @xmath122 where one can find two saddle connections @xmath123 represented by the points @xmath124 and @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 ( we assume @xmath128 ) . if that would be not the case , for each @xmath122 there could be at most one saddle connection of the form @xmath129 in @xmath130 , therefore @xmath131 contradicting our assumption . now by the strahlensatz of elementary geometry ( see figure 1 ) each intersection point of the saddle connections @xmath132 and @xmath133 as above , must divide the length in rational amounts contradicting the assumption . let @xmath43 and @xmath134 be two sets of saddle connections on the marked tori @xmath135}$ ] , @xmath136}$ ] and suppose @xmath49 $ ] is rationally divided by @xmath44 $ ] . then @xmath137 is the set of vectors associated to saddle connections @xmath95 on @xmath138}$ ] which are parallel to vectors associated to saddle connections in @xmath139 and shorter in length . + to summarize : [ schnigi ] let @xmath41,[y],[z]\in { \mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] be different points and @xmath140 . if @xmath44\in s \in sc_{(x , z)}$ ] , then @xmath141 contains a lattice , if and only if there is a rational number @xmath142 such that @xmath143 , moreover the number @xmath144 is unique in the sense that this equation holds for any saddle connection represented by elements of @xmath141 . these are just the statements above translated to the situaion @xmath41\neq [ 0]$ ] . the lemma is viewed as the generalisation of the following observation on the torus @xmath145 ( with the origin as a marked point ) : a point @xmath146 is rational if and only if it is in the intersection of saddle connections . if this is the case the saddle connections through @xmath146 give rise to a lattice ( by taking representatives in @xmath12 ) . the moral of the lemma is : when counting saddle connections for general markings , all markings which are lying on some saddle connection and dividing the length of it rationally will cause a lattice of intersection points . this is important as we will see later , this decreases the asymptotic constant of that marking . because of this observation we also have to take care about the definition of the set of markings in @xmath147 , where we assume the growth rates to be extremal . thus for saddle connections we define the set of markings ` in general position ' ( shortly : ` gp ' ) in @xmath147 inductively : @xmath148\in { \mathbb{t}}^{4 } : \ x_1-x_0 \notin { \mathbb{q}}^2 \}\\ \mbox { } \\ { \mathbb{t}}^{2(n+1)}_{gp(sc)}=\left\ { \begin{array}{l } [ x_0, ... ,x_n]\in { \mathbb{t}}^{2(n+1)}:[x_0, ... ,x_{n-1}]\in { \mathbb{t}}^{2n}_{gp(sc)},[x_n ] \in { \mathbb{t}}^2 \ \mbox{and } \\ \forall \ i \in \ { 0, ... ,n \ } \ x_i \mbox { does not divide any saddle connection}\\ \mbox{defined by the marking } [ x_0, ... ,x_{i-1},x_{i+1}, ... ,x_{n } ] \mbox { rationally } \end{array } \right\}. \end{array}\ ] ] thus the set of non extremal n markings is a set of full lebesque measure on @xmath147 ( see theorem [ tlimes ] ) . for periodic orbits the set of markings in general position is defined in the following way : @xmath149:\ x_j - x_i \notin { \mathbb{q}}\ \forall \ i , j \in \{0, ... ,n\ } \mbox { and } j \neq i \}.\ ] ] observe that for all @xmath150 @xmath151 . the sets are equal in the cases @xmath152 ( trivial ) and @xmath153 , for more marked points the inclusion is strict . it will turned out the markings in general position are exactely the sets of markings on which the growth rates are maximal . note that in the case of two marked points the set of markings in general position is the same as the set of non rational markings , always assuming one of the markings to be @xmath154 $ ] . it should be noted here , that the pure existence of the growth rate functions for any choice of marking could also be seen using the siegel veech formula together with ratners theorem for ergodic measures on homogeneous spaces ( see @xcite ) . the more elementary argumentation here and in the chapter on general markings shows , that even for complicated markings one has to count only simple lattice point distributions to obtain the quadratic growth constant . to compute quadratic growth rates we recall some preparatory lemmas . the first is quite well known and uses an argument going back to gauss . [ gauss ] . then @xmath156 to begin we treat the case @xmath157 . by drawing horizontal and vertical lines through the lattice points , we got a decomposition of the plane in rectangles with sidelengthes @xmath158 . every lattice point of @xmath58 can be viewed as the upper right vertice of one rectangle . so the number of points of @xmath58 in the concentric circle @xmath83 of radius @xmath7 is determined by the number of rectangles in that circle up to a certain correction term coming from the fact that a rectangle might be only partly inside the ball . but after increasing the radius of the ball by the length of the diagonal of the rectangles @xmath159 the estimate @xmath160 holds . and by decreasing the radius with the same amount we have : @xmath161 putting together these two estimates leds to : @xmath162 in the general case we have the estimate : @xmath163 the statement follows easily . before stating the next proposition let us make a general remark on our strategy of counting . if our interest is for example counting prime closed geodesics , we associate a certain point distribution in @xmath164 to all geodesics in question . this point distribution @xmath58 does not reflect a priory the prime geodesics , but it will be choosen in a way that its quadratic asymptotics as in the last lemma can be calculated easily . the points in @xmath58 which are associated to prime geodesics will be the visible points of @xmath58 with respect to @xmath165 . the price we have to pay is that we can not relate the distribution of visible points and all points of ( the completed and closed ) @xmath58 just by the factor @xmath166 . we have to choose our multiplicities with respect to @xmath58 : [ vielf ] let @xmath167 be a @xmath165 complete and closed lattice . let @xmath168 be the set of numbers @xmath169 such that @xmath170 . then the relation @xmath171 holds between the numbers of points of @xmath58 and the number of visible points @xmath60 of @xmath58 . for the lattice @xmath172 this implies : @xmath173 first let us check that there is no @xmath174 that is not an integer multiple of some @xmath175 . assume there is , then there exists a @xmath176 and a rational number @xmath177 with @xmath178 . so @xmath179 divides @xmath180 , a contradiction to the @xmath165 completeness of @xmath58 . since @xmath58 is closed and every element in @xmath58 is some @xmath181-multiple of an element in @xmath60 , thus : @xmath182 the lattice @xmath172 is obviously @xmath165 complete , closed and @xmath183 , thus @xmath184 counting only a certain percentage @xmath146 of the length of each line in a point distribution @xmath58 is equivalent to counting the length of vectors in the point distribution + @xmath185 . thus there is a relation : @xmath186 remark : as is seen above the relating factor between cylinders of geodesics and prime geodesics will be @xmath187 instead of @xmath166 because we do nt distinguish between the two directions a prime geodesic might have . our decision to do that is based on the point of view : count only ( the length of ) the geometric object . define the set of lattices parametrized by @xmath188 , with @xmath189 as : @xmath190 further for @xmath150 and a divisor @xmath191 of @xmath0 define @xmath192 to be the set of numbers which are relatively prime to @xmath193 @xmath194 ( if @xmath195 we write shortly @xmath196 instead of @xmath192 ) and the point distributions @xmath197 with this conventions [ pvert ] the point distributions @xmath198 are for all @xmath150 complete with respect to @xmath165 and closed . we have : @xmath199.\ ] ] as a consequence , for all prime numbers @xmath146 @xmath200 first one has to find all integers which map @xmath198 under elementwise multiplication to @xmath198 itself . for @xmath201 and @xmath202 we have @xmath203 , if and only if @xmath204 therefore @xmath169 has to be in @xmath205 . obviously the multiplication with a number from this set maps points of @xmath198 again to @xmath198 . so if the point distributions are complete with respect to @xmath165 they are also closed . to see the last statement take @xmath206 and choose @xmath207 with @xmath208 . this means @xmath209 with @xmath210 and @xmath211 . the equation in the first coordinate says that @xmath169 and @xmath212 are relatively prime to @xmath0 and from this it follows that @xmath213 has to be a multiple of @xmath0 . thus @xmath214 is already contained in @xmath198 and the completeness follows . using equation ( [ factor ] ) from proposition [ vielf ] gives the first part of the lemma . for the second part we simply observe that because @xmath146 is prime @xmath215 : @xmath216 remark : obviously the lattices @xmath217 are for @xmath218 never @xmath165 complete . before we compute the relating factor of equation ( [ vf ] ) in general , an observation is helpful : let @xmath219 be the principal character modulo @xmath0 , that is @xmath220 if @xmath221 and is equal to @xmath222 if not , then obviously : @xmath223 where @xmath224 is the @xmath225 series with respect to @xmath226 evaluated at @xmath227 . the following is well known ( see for example exercise ( 3.d ) page 166 in @xcite or serre @xcite ) [ sumform ] if @xmath35 is a complex number with real part bigger than @xmath228 then : @xmath229 the condition on the real part of @xmath35 guaranties absolute convergence of the series so that the following manipulations are justified . we start with the right hand side : @xmath230 we have used the well known mbius @xmath4 function , the formula @xmath231 and summation over @xmath232 to reorder the sum in a useful way . evaluating the above @xmath225 series for @xmath233 we find @xmath234 the left hand side of this equation is easy to compute with the help of lemma [ gauss ] and the definition of @xmath198 @xmath235 use eulers @xmath236 function to identify @xmath237 for later use we show [ completion ] + @xmath198 containes the @xmath165 completion of the lattice @xmath238@xmath239 . it is enough to show that a multiple of each point @xmath240 is in @xmath241 . that is we have to solve @xmath242 . but this is always possible since @xmath96 and @xmath169 are relatively prime with respect to @xmath0 . we now describe the affine group @xmath245 for a rational point @xmath246 . [ afftor ] assume @xmath247 . then @xmath248 if @xmath249 we have @xmath250 @xmath251 is a consequence of the discussion around equation ( [ sl2 ] ) in the preparation section . the only thing which is left to prove is the statement on the translation vector @xmath252 . it is defined only modulo @xmath165 , thus one can assume @xmath253 . the subgroup @xmath254 of pure translations is trivial if @xmath255 : + assume the lattice @xmath256 generated is by use of @xmath252 translated to @xmath165 and by the same translation @xmath165 is moved to @xmath257 , then @xmath258 must hold . thus either @xmath252 is trivial , or @xmath100 is one of the exceptions . in general the same problem comes up if the map should interchange the lattices @xmath165 and @xmath257 . the only possibility is : @xmath259 has to map @xmath257 to @xmath260 and @xmath252 translates this into @xmath165 . thus we obtain the conditions : @xmath261 for the three exceptions there is in fact only one condition , because in these cases @xmath262 , thus @xmath263 is automatically contained in these affine groups . moreover the translation @xmath264 is contained in the groups . [ kong]the veech group @xmath265 where @xmath266 $ ] * for @xmath267 is @xmath268 * for @xmath269 ( or @xmath270 analogously ) is @xmath271 * for @xmath272 is @xmath273 in the case @xmath274 that is @xmath275 we have to add the rotation : @xmath276 * for @xmath277 ( or equivalently @xmath278 ) is @xmath279 by the last proposition we have to evaluate the condition @xmath280 on the coefficents @xmath281 . if for example @xmath282 then we have @xmath283 it follows directly that @xmath284 , @xmath285 and @xmath286 is arbitrary . since the determinant of the matrix is always @xmath228 we have the condition @xmath287 . therefore @xmath288 , if @xmath289 . the other three cases are equally simple , we omit them . we prove now that all 2 marked tori are affine equivalent to one from a special family , if the marking is rational . [ reduction ] if @xmath290 $ ] ( @xmath22 ) , @xmath291 is affine isomorphic to @xmath292}$ ] . more precisely : there exists an affine diffeomorphism of @xmath13 represented by an element of @xmath1 which maps @xmath293 $ ] to @xmath294 $ ] ( and preserves @xmath20 $ ] ) . the veech group @xmath295 of the one marked torus is represented by @xmath1 . thus it is enough to show : given a point @xmath296\in{\mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] with @xmath39 , there is a linear map in @xmath1 that maps it to the point @xmath297\in{\mathbb{t}}^2 $ ] . let @xmath298 then the equation @xmath299 holds . we want the vector @xmath300 to become the second row of a matrix @xmath301 , thus the vector @xmath302 representing the first row has to fulfill @xmath303 . this equation has solutions @xmath304 because @xmath305 and @xmath306 are relatively prime . taking solutions @xmath307 defines an @xmath301 with @xmath308 with @xmath309 relatively prime to @xmath0 . hence the congruence @xmath310 has a solution @xmath311 and one can use the linear dehn twists @xmath312 and @xmath313 to obtain the result up to a rotation of 90 degrees . [ isom ] the veech groups @xmath314 for points @xmath315 $ ] with @xmath39 are all isomorphic . the isomorphism is given by conjugation with an element of @xmath1 . moreover the asymptiotic growth rates are the same , if the surfaces are affine isomorphic . the first two statements follow from the above proposition . veechs asymptotic formula depends only on the conjugacy class of the veech group in @xmath3 and on the areas of the cylinders of closed geodesics ( see for example vorobetz paper @xcite ) , which are invariant under affine isomorphisms . in other words the asymptotic constants depend only on the @xmath3 orbit of the given veech surface in the moduli space . but proposition ( [ reduction ] ) shows the marked surfaces in question are all on one @xmath3 orbit . since every rational number @xmath100 has a unique representation as above , one can restrict the considerations to families of markings defined by @xmath316\quad \mbox{or } \quad x_{(n , n)}:=\left[\frac{1}{n},\frac{1}{n}\right]\quad \mbox{where } \ 1\neq n \in { \mathbb{n}}\ ] ] and to the corresponding tori . we choose the family @xmath317 . to compute the index @xmath318})]$ ] , the first observation is that the only affine map @xmath319})$ ] ( @xmath39 ) which interchanges @xmath20 $ ] and @xmath320 $ ] is given by rotation of 180 degrees and a translation by the vector @xmath38 ( for @xmath321 ) . since @xmath53 maps @xmath320 $ ] to @xmath222 it is of no interest for the following discussion up to the subgroup of generated by the idempotent element @xmath53 , @xmath322})$ ] can be viewed as the isotropy subgroup @xmath323}({\mathbb{t}}^2)\subset a\mathit{ff}({\mathbb{t}}^2 ) $ ] . for a translation structure @xmath324 and @xmath325 one defines the isotropy group @xmath326 of @xmath100 and its associated veech group in the usual way : @xmath327 these are subgroups of @xmath328 , @xmath329 respectively . as a direct consequence from the definitions and elementary group theory one obtains : [ shindex ] let @xmath330 be a translation structure and @xmath331 the structure @xmath330 where the point @xmath100 is marked . then @xmath332= \operatorname{ord}(a\mathit{ff}(u)/ a\mathit{ff}_x(u))= [ v(u):v_x(u)]=\operatorname{ord}(v(u)/v_x(u))\ ] ] where @xmath333 is the orbit of @xmath100 under @xmath328 and @xmath334 denotes the set of right cosets @xmath335 of the subgroup @xmath336 . see for example chapter i 5 in s. langs book on algebra @xcite . lemma [ reduction ] above implies together with proposition [ shindex ] for @xmath321 @xmath337 the last equation on the cardinality of the set of pairs @xmath302 is well known . @xmath338 is normal in @xmath1 and therefore also in @xmath339})$ ] , thus @xmath340}({\mathbb{t}}^2)\cong v({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[\frac{p}{n},\frac{q}{n}]})/(-id).\ ] ] since @xmath263 generates a subgroup of order @xmath227 and the subgroup @xmath341 } ) \subset a\mathit{ff}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[\frac{p}{n},\frac{q}{n}]})$ ] of pure translations is trivial if @xmath342 we have @xmath343})]=\frac{n^2}{2}\prod_{p|n \ prime } \left(1-\frac{1}{p^2}\right)\ ] ] for @xmath153 the index is @xmath344 because @xmath263 is already an element in @xmath345}({\mathbb{t}}^2)$ ] . in contrast to this calculation there is a second way to compute the index of the veech groups using the asymptotic formula of veech and the results from the last section . to begin , the veech groups are presented as subgroups of @xmath1 , but since we do not want to count orbits in both directions we take the quotient modulo @xmath346 : @xmath347 . since both modulo @xmath263 equivalent elements are in @xmath348 we can do the same with the veech groups and loose no information when taking the preimage in @xmath3 . thus , denote by @xmath349 the image of @xmath348 in @xmath350 . the orbits @xmath351 ( @xmath352 is the number of different orbits ) of the vectors @xmath353 associated to a maximal cylinder @xmath354 of closed geodesics which fills the torus under @xmath355 give always the same asymptotic constant ( for the formula see proposition 6.3 in @xcite : @xmath356}{area({\mathcal{c}}_i ) } \ ] ] since each cylinder @xmath354 fills the torus we have @xmath357 and @xmath358=1 $ ] . here @xmath359 is the group generated by linear dehn twists around @xmath354 . thus we can write : @xmath360 \ vol\left({\mathbb{h}}/psl_2({\mathbb{z}})\right)= \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{\pi}{3}[sl_2({\mathbb{z}}):v({\mathbb{t}}^2_{x_{n}})].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the other side of veech s asymptotic formula is the quadratic growth rate of the lengths of the maximal cylinders that completely fill the torus . their directions are exactly the directions of lines in @xmath12 which begin at the origin and cross some point of the lattice @xmath361 . to get a set of integer points which represent ( eventually multiples of the length of ) the closed cylinders in question we simply multiply with @xmath0 and get the lattice @xmath362 studied earlier . since we are on the torus @xmath363 to count the length spectrum of the cylinders correctly one has to look for the visible points of the completion of @xmath364 with respect to @xmath165 . this completion , by proposition [ completion ] , is the point distribution @xmath198 , thus finally : @xmath365^{-1}\ ] ] what is left to calculate is @xmath352 : [ invariante ] @xmath366 observe that the ratio of the length of the two saddle connections connecting @xmath20 $ ] and @xmath367 $ ] and bounding the same cylinder of periodic orbits is an invariant under the operation of the veech group . furthermore modulo @xmath368 we can represent every periodic orbit or saddle connection by a point in @xmath369 . thus the directions with only one periodic family are represented by : @xmath370 the line from @xmath371 to @xmath372 intersects exactly one point of the set @xmath361 characterized by @xmath373 if @xmath374 runs through the numbers relatively prime to @xmath0 , then @xmath100 does this as well . thus the above regarded length ratio is in any case one of the numbers @xmath375 we see , exactly two relatively prime numbers modulo @xmath0 , namely @xmath100 and @xmath376 having the same invariant . if this invariant is complete , which will be shown in the next lemma , then the number of different one cylinder orbits under the operation of the veech group is given by @xmath377 the exceptional case @xmath153 is trivial , because there exists only one direction of one cylinder in @xmath378 . let @xmath291 be a rational marked torus . two directions @xmath379 with only one periodic cylinder are in the same orbit under the operation of the veech group , if they have the same ratio @xmath380 here @xmath381 are the two saddle connections which are on the boundary of the cylinder in direction @xmath382 . obviously the condition is necessary . all that is left is to show that it is sufficent . that is we have to find an element of the veech group that is a map between the two directions with the same invariant . forgetting for a moment the marked point @xmath100 we can map any periodic direction to any other by elements of @xmath1 . especially the saddle connections in question are mapped on one another . because the invariant is the same for both possible orientations of the saddle connections and @xmath383 we have found a map , which also transports one marked point to the other . now we can compute the index with the help of the counting formula again : let @xmath384 $ ] , @xmath321 , @xmath385 then @xmath386=\frac{n^2}{2}\prod_{p|n \ prime}\left(1-\frac{1}{p^2}\right)\ ] ] holds . in the case @xmath153 the index is @xmath344 . from equality ( [ kxn ] ) together with @xmath387 for @xmath321 it follows @xmath388=\frac{3}{2\pi } \varphi(n)\left[\lim_{t\rightarrow \infty } \frac{n(g^{v}_{i^n } , t)}{t^2 } \right]^{-1}.\ ] ] then put in the right hand side of equation ( [ vffinal ] ) to get the result . if @xmath153 then @xmath389 and we obtain @xmath344 . the two ways of computing the index of the veech groups of two marked tori might be used to obtain the asymptotic formula ( [ vffinal ] ) , counting the lattice points , without using the second section . one can take the first index computation and the veech formula together with the knowledge about the number of cusps @xmath390 ( see proposition [ invariante ] ) to compute @xmath391 backwards . nevertheless the first given way to compute the index of the veech groups seems to be a simple method to calculate for the index of the well known groups ( for example compare s.lang @xcite @xmath392 in @xmath1 . either the @xmath393 are subgroups of index two in @xmath348 if @xmath321 , or in the case @xmath153 @xmath394 and @xmath395 is isomorphic to @xmath396 . thus : @xmath397= \left\ { \begin{array}{cl } n^2\prod_{p|n \ prime}\left(1-\frac{1}{p^2}\right ) & \textrm { if } \ n>2 \\ 3 & \textrm { if } \ n=2 \end{array } \right.\ ] ] we begin with a general observation concerning the directions of periodic families on the torus . these directions are exactly all the rational " directions and this fact will not change how many points we will mark and wherever we will place them on the torus . the only thing that might change is the number of periodic families in a given rational direction , but in this case they are all of equal length . for the two marked torus @xmath291 there are always two families in any rational direction if @xmath100 is non rational . there are saddle connections connecting @xmath20 $ ] und @xmath41 $ ] but which bound no periodic family because they are not in a rational direction . for rational markings @xmath100 this can never happen . collecting things for rational @xmath100 : either there is a rational direction with two periodic families and the bounding saddle connections connecting the same marked point , or there is only one family but then the two bounding saddle connections will connect the marked points @xmath20 $ ] and @xmath41 $ ] . therefore counting the length @xmath398 of cylinders of periodic trajectories for extremal markings @xmath100 on @xmath291 is easy : @xmath399 to treat the rational case we have to subtract the directions where only one family is from the doubled number of periodic orbits of the one marked torus . let us denote the number of single cylinders on @xmath291 with length smaller than @xmath7 by @xmath400}({\mathbb{t}}^2_x , t)$ ] . thus we write : @xmath401}({\mathbb{t}}^2_x , t)+o(t^2)\ ] ] with the help of the discussion at the end of the last paragraph one computes for a rational point @xmath402 : @xmath403 to count saddle connections is less easy , but again using the last paragraph ( and the discussion before equation ( [ kxn ] ) we can write down the associated growth rates as follows : @xmath404 here ( [ vffinal ] ) and proposition [ invariante ] is used . the last term needs some explanation . we have seen that @xmath405 already counts the length of the simple periodic cylinders . it counts as well the length of their boundaries that is the sum of the length of the two bounding saddle connections . by proposition [ invariante ] there are @xmath406 different families of orbits of saddle connections labeled by their length ratios . equation ( [ kxn ] ) shows that these orbits under the veech group all have the same growth rate , namely @xmath407 . the relation of the length of a saddle connection bounding a family to the length of the family is more or less the invariant @xmath408 . anyway it is one of the numbers @xmath409 or @xmath410 where @xmath411 . with the help of equation ( [ scaling ] ) one finds the above expression . continuing the evaluation : @xmath412 the last equality follows with the help of equation ( [ in ] ) . for non rational markings one obtains : @xmath413 summarizing : the limits @xmath414 exist for all @xmath100 , moreover there are estimates @xmath415 and @xmath416 for @xmath88 non rational . the inequalities are strict if @xmath100 is rational . moreover for each sequence of rational points @xmath417 converging to a non rational point @xmath100 : @xmath418 this is the continuity of the quadratic constants at non rational points . the existence of the limits is proved in the equations ( [ ponr ] ) , ( [ po ] ) , ( [ rat ] ) and ( [ snrat ] ) , even more the computations give explicitly the values of the limits . in the case of saddle connections it is indeed not easy to see the continuity of the growth rate function from the expression ( [ rat ] ) directly ( in fact before the author found the esimate below he does not believe in the stated formula ) . by comparing equation ( [ snrat ] ) ( the limiting constant ) to the first line of ( [ rat ] ) one has to show : @xmath419 by using the equation ( [ sumform ] ) , which states @xmath420 and the estimates @xmath421 we have : @xmath422 clearly if @xmath423 the right and left hand side of the inequalities converge to @xmath424 . the continuity in the case of periodic orbits follows immediately from equation ( [ po ] ) . * let @xmath8}$ ] be a n marked translation torus . then the limits @xmath425},t)}{t^2}\ ] ] exist . * the set @xmath16 has full lebesque measure on @xmath426 and the inequalities @xmath427},t)}{t^2 } \leq \lim_{t \rightarrow \infty}\frac{n_{sc}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[y_0, ... ,y_{n-1}]},t)}{t^2}= \frac{n(n+1)}{2}\pi+\frac{3n}{\pi}\ ] ] and @xmath428},t)}{t^2 } \leq \lim_{t \rightarrow \infty}\frac{n_{po}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[y_0, ... ,y_{n-1}]},t)}{t^2}= \frac{3n}{\pi}\ ] ] hold for all @xmath429 . in both cases ( @xmath430 s and @xmath431 s ) the inequality is strict , if @xmath432 * + if @xmath433 is a sequence with + @xmath434 @xmath435 then @xmath436},t)}{t^2}\right)= \lim_{t \rightarrow \infty}\frac{n_{sc / po}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[y_0, ... ,y_{n}]},t)}{t^2}\ ] ] we prove the statements by induction over the number @xmath0 of marked points . the idea is to write down , modulo lower order terms , the numbers of saddle connections ( or po s ) for a given marking as sums over the numbers for an marking with one marked point less and the terms occuring when one marks the forgotten point . the results from the first section will imply the statements . to start for one point there is nothing to show , moreover we have already seen the proof for @xmath153 . so we assume the statements are true for all n markings @xmath437 of the torus . we add another marking @xmath438 . if the resulting marking is in general position , @xmath439 ( for saddle connections ) we obtain for saddle connections @xmath440},t)=n_{sc}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[x_0, ... ,x_{n-1}]},t)+ \sum^{n}_{i=0}n(sc_{(x_i , x_n)},t)\ ] ] furthermore by the definition of general position markings @xmath441 for all @xmath442 . for the case @xmath443 : saddle connections starting and ending in @xmath438 are bounding cylinders of periodic trajectories . we have to take care of multiplicities when counting these @xmath444 thus @xmath445},t)}{t^2}&= & \lim_{t \rightarrow \infty}\frac{n_{sc}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[x_0, ... ,x_{n-1}]},t)}{t^2}+ n\pi+\frac{3}{\pi}=\nonumber \\ & = & \frac{n(n+1)}{2}\pi+\frac{3n}{\pi}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we assume now that the marking is in general position with respect to periodic orbits . since a saddle connection starting and ending in @xmath438 bounds a cylinder of periodic trajectories , one has to add in each rational direction a new periodic family . thus the periodic orbit growth rates for markings in general position are : @xmath446},t)}{t^2}= \lim_{t \rightarrow \infty}\frac{n_{po}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{[x_0, ... ,x_{n-1}]},t)}{t^2}+ \frac{3}{\pi}=\frac{3n}{\pi}.\ ] ] if the marking @xmath447 is not in general position , it could be divided in classes of relatively rational points ( this is of course meaningful in any case , po s or sc s ) . the set of these classes is denoted by @xmath448}$ ] . for each class the veech theory holds ( see @xcite ) and guaranties that all the limits exist . for the inequalities between the limits one observes : if the marked points are rational there exists always a direction in which there are strictely less than the maximal number of @xmath0 cylinders of closed trajectories . the orbit of this direction under the operation of the veech group leads to a positive asymptotic growth constant ( proposition 6.1 in @xcite ) . but a lower ( than maximal possible ) number of closed cylinders in a given direction causes multiplicities " ( on has to count only visible points ) . hence the limit growth rates are in both cases ( po s and sc s ) smaller than the ones for markings in general position . this shows : if ther is one class in @xmath448}$ ] containing more than one point , then the growth rates have to be smaller than for markings in general position . to compute the growth rates in the cases of periodic orbits , we observe that each class @xmath449}$ ] defines a marked veech torus @xmath450 , by marking @xmath13 only with the points of that class . thus : @xmath451},t))=\sum_{m \in \mathcal{r}_{[x_0, ... ,x_n ] } } n_{po}({\mathbb{t}}^2_{m},t ) + o(t^2).\ ] ] here is used that by definition between points of different classes there are never saddle connections with rational slope ( or equivalently : with bound a closed trajectory ) . all remains is to count the saddle connections between points of different classes . to do this let @xmath51 be a marked point not rationally equivalent to @xmath438 and @xmath452 the set of saddle connections connecting @xmath51 and @xmath453 on the n marked torus @xmath454}$ ] . what we have to count are sets of saddle connections from a given set of saddle connections between two marked points ( for example the set @xmath452 ) which are parallel and shorter to another set of saddle connections ( for example @xmath455 ) . however by lemma ( [ schnigi ] ) and proposition ( [ countnrat ] ) sets of this kind are always lattices modulo a mistake of order @xmath456 , which does not count in the quadratic limit . + there are two different cases : first , there is a nonempty subset in @xmath455 consisting of saddle connections parallel to saddle connections in the set @xmath452 and shorter in length . the set of all indices @xmath457 of such @xmath453 are denoted with @xmath408 . second , a nonempty subset @xmath455 is parallel to one from @xmath452 , but the first are longer . as above denote the set of all indices of such @xmath453 with @xmath181 . moreover the sets of saddle are ( modulo sets of lower order growth rates ) given by some lattices @xmath458 or @xmath459 respectively . we can write : @xmath460 here @xmath461 denotes the lattices of saddle connections between @xmath51 and @xmath438 on the two marked tori @xmath462}$ ] . for all @xmath463 @xmath464 modulo terms of strictly lower order size the above expressions are all lattices , hence they have quadratic growth rate limits . after these steps for all markings @xmath465 $ ] the induction is complete . from the two equalities it follows immediately : + if intersections of the above kind have a nonzero quadratic growth rate ( so the marking is rational in the sense of our definition ) than the associated growth rates are smaller than for a non rational marking . the continuity follows from the fact that by approximating a marking in general position all the denominators of all the length ratios are growing over all bounds . because of the simplicity of our methods we are not able to conclude anything about ( families of ) branched coverings of tori , without using the existence of the growth rate limits by the method explained in @xcite . even the sets where the growth rate is the biggest is not seen as just the preimage of the non rational markings on the torus . for closed cylinders of geodesics at least it has to be contained in this set . this is because the geometry and combinatorics of the covering might cause new sets where the growth rates are different . geometrically the reason for this is that the length spectrum of the cylinders of periodic trajectories is connected in a way to the saddle connections bounding them , which depends on the covering and where the singular points are . if one makes the simplifying assumption that all inverse images of the marked points are itself marked ( such coverings are called ` balanced coverings ' by some people ) , then from theorem [ tlimes ] one can conclude : let @xmath466}$ ] a covering branched only over @xmath467 with the induced translation structure @xmath468 . further denote by @xmath469 the translation structure where each inverse image of a marked point is itself marked . then , after rescaling the volume of @xmath470 ( with respect to the induced flat metric ) to one : @xmath471},t)}{t^2}\ ] ] ( @xmath472 is the degree of @xmath473 ) . moreover , if some of the markings are artificial ( i.e. not singular points of the induced metric ) then the growth rates after unmark " any subset of these points will be smaller than the above one . thus @xmath474 remark : similarly one can write down the corresponding estimate for maximal periodic cylinders . + if one includes ratners theorem as done in @xcite then the @xmath475 in equation ( [ verh ] ) can be replaced by a limit . + the statement is a direct consequence of the fact that each saddle connection on the torus has exactly @xmath472 preimages on @xmath476 and theorem [ tlimes ] . the second part is clear , because by removing nonsingular markings , the directions in which there are saddle connections are not changed . but in any such direction the number of saddle connections could decrease and their length increase . remark : with the results of veech @xcite every translation surface can be approximated by torus coverings in spaces of abelian differentials @xmath477 . moreover torus coverings are equally distributed with respect to the liouville measure @xmath4 mentioned in the introduction . since periodic cylinders and saddle connections are locally stable with respect to deformations in this spaces we have some sort of control on their numbers by the corollary . but because of the increasing number of artifical markings while approximating a general translation surface or equivalently the increasing degree of the covering , the estimate above is to weak to predict for example quadratic bounds of the growth rates of po s or sc s in general . on the other hand the equidistribution of torus coverings in @xmath477 is used to compute the @xmath4 volume of these spaces of abelian differentials see @xcite . the knowledge of these volumes in turn is the main step to evaluate siegel veech formulas , compare @xcite . eskin , alex , counting problems and semisimple groups , doc . j. dmv , extra volume icm ii ( 1998 ) 539 - 552 . eskin , alex ; masur , howard . pointwise asymptotic formulas on flat surfaces , ergodic theory and dynamical systems ( 2001 ) 37 pages . eskin , alex ; masur , howard ; schmoll , martin . billiards with barriers , preprint ( 2001 ) 37 pages . eskin , alex ; masur , howard ; zorich , anton . the siegel veech constants , in preparation . eskin , alex ; okounkov , andrei . asymptotics of numbers of branched coverings of a torus and volumes of moduli spaces of holomorphic differentials . preprint ( 2000 ) 42 pages . to appear in inventiones math . . gutkin , e. ; judge , c. ; the geometry and arithmetic of translation surfaces with applications to polygonal billiards , math . lett.3 ( 1996 ) , 391 - 403 . gutkin , e. , judge , c. ; affine mappings of translation surfaces , geometry and arithmetic , duke journal ( 1999 ) . lang , serge ; algebra . second edition . addison - wesley publishing co. , reading , mass . , xv+714 pp . isbn : 0 - 201 - 05487 - 6 lang , serge ; introduction to modular forms , grundlehren der mathematischen wissenschaften 222 , springer verlag 1976 . masur , h. ; closed trajectories for quadratic differentials with an application to billiards , duke math . j. 53 ( 1986 ) 307 - 314 . masur , h. ; lower bounds for the number of saddle connections and closed trajectories of a quadratic differential , in holomorphic functions and moduli 1 , 215 - 228 , msri publ . 10 , springer verlag 1988 . masur , h. ; the growth rate of trajectories of a quadratic differential , ergodic theory and dynamical systems 10 ( 1990 ) , 151 - 176 . serre , j.p . ; cours darithmtique , le mathmaticien , presses universitaires de france,(1970 ) . tenenbaum , g. ; introduction la thorie analytique et probabiliste des nombres , cours spcialiss , socit mathmatique de france,(1995 ) . veech , w. ; the teichmller geodesic flow , annals of mathematics , 64 ( 1986),441 - 530 . veech , w. ; teichmller curves in moduli space , eisenstein series , and an application to triangular billiards , invent . 97 ( 1989 ) , 553 - 583 . veech , w. ; moduli spaces of quadratic differentials , journal danalyse mathmatique vol.55 ( 1990),341 - 379 . veech , w. ; the billiard in the regular polygon , geom . and funct . analysis 2 ( 1992),341 - 379 . veech , w. ; siegel measures . ann . of math . ( 2 ) 148 ( 1998 ) , no . 3 , 895 - 944 . vorobets , y. ; planar structures and billiards in rational polygons , russ . surveys 51 ( 1996 ) , 177 - 178 . vorobets , y. ; planar structures and billiards in rational polygons : the veech alternative , russ . surveys 51 ( 1996 ) , 779 - 817 . zemlyakov , a.n . , katok , a.b . ; topological transitivity of billiards in polygons . zametki 18(2)(1975 ) pp . 291 - 300 . english translation in math . notes 18(2 ) ( 1976 ) pp 760 - 764 .

asymptotic quadratic growth rates of saddle connections and families of periodic cylinders on translation tori with @xmath0 marked points are studied . for any marking the existence of limits of the quadratic growth rate is shown using elementary methods ( not ratners theorem ) . we study the growth rate limit as function of the marking . precise formulas for this function in the case of two marked points are given and the sets where the growth rate function is maximal and continuous are described . for rational two markings the index of the veech group in @xmath1 is calculated in two different ways .

0910.4288

quantum teleportation is the process where a quantum state is transferred from one system to another one at a different location . it relies on quantum entanglement , the most peculiar trait of quantum mechanics . in the protocol described by bennett _ et al.__@xcite the sender alice and the receiver bob share an entangled pair of particles . alice entangles her particle with a third one , namely the one whose state is to be teleported . then she performs a destructive joint - measurement on the two - particle system on her side . next , she communicates through a classic channel the outcome of the measure to bob . through this information he can reconstruct the original quantum state by simply applying local operations on his particle . clearly the scheme of teleportation relies on the prior establishment of quantum entanglement between the two parties . however , only classical communication is used after the particle to be teleported comes into play at alice side . while experimental realization of quantum teleportation protocols has been performed in nmr @xcite , optical @xcite , and atomic systems @xcite , no evidence of teleportation in semiconductor systems has been achieved so far . indeed , semiconductor technology represents a viable approach for the realization of quantum computing devices , and quantum teleportation would be a crucial validation of its potentiality . theoretical proposals for electron teleportation in solid - state systems are based on single @xcite and double @xcite quantum dots . teleportation protocols using edge channels in the quantum hall effect have also been advanced @xcite . however , quantum - wire systems have the advantage of intrinsically providing the qubit transmission between specified locations , as required by the divincenzo criteria @xcite . furthermore , they could be directly integrated in traditional electronic circuitry and allow in principle the implementation of a large number of quantum hardware units thus overcoming the scalability problem . in this frame , coherent electron transport in systems of couples of semiconductor quantum wires has been used to design qubits and to propose fundamental one- and two - qubit quantum gates @xcite . furthermore , the use of surface acoustic waves ( saws ) as a mean to inject and drive carriers along the wires presents some advantages with respect to the free propagation along quasi-1d channels since it prevents the spreading of the electron wavefunction , it reduces undesired reflection effects , and it makes the electron more immune to the decohering effects of the phonons @xcite . in this work we propose and simulate numerically a scheme to perform quantum deterministic teleportation of electrons in a device consisting of three couples of semiconductor quantum wires . the carriers are embedded in the minima of saws , propagating in the wires direction . the qubit - state is encoded through the localization of a single electron in one of two parallel quantum wires . in our scheme , the coulomb interaction between carriers is used first for the production of an einstein - podolsky - rosen ( epr ) pair of electrons , and then for the rotation of the bell states needed to perform a bell measurement@xcite . we note that the teleportation model described in the following could also be applied , without qualitative modifications , to edge channels in the quantum hall regime . in fact , the latter system has already successfully exposed the two - particle quantum interference via an electronic version of the hanbury brown twiss setup @xcite . the physical system used to implement our quantum teleportation scheme consists of three electrons injected by saw along three couples of gaas quantum wires . we assume that the device operates at low temperatures ( simulations are performed at zero temperature ) in order to have a negligible number of electrons in the conduction band and to minimize decoherence effects due to the interactions of electron with lattice vibrations . the use of saw for the injection and transport of electrons in the quantum wires @xcite allows a single carrier to be captured into a minimum of the sinusoidal piezoelectric wave propagating along the device and inhibits the natural spatial spreading of the wavepacket . in this way the particle is confined in a moving quantum dot @xcite and a so - called flying qubit is realized @xcite . in order to implement the quantum operations for the teleportation scheme we employ three elements : an electronic beam splitter @xmath0 , a phase shifter @xmath1 and a coulomb coupler @xmath2 @xcite . the former is realized through a coupling window between the two wires of a qubit , able to split an incoming wavefunction into two parts @xcite . in terms of qubit transformations it corresponds to @xmath3 and @xmath4 . the electronic phase shifter @xmath1 is realized by introducing a suitable potential barrier in the wire @xmath5(@xmath6 ) . it acts only on a single qubit state by adding a phase factor , namely @xmath7 and @xmath8 . similarly , @xmath9 and @xmath10 . the @xmath2 coulomb coupler is the only two - qubit gate . it consists of a region in which two electrons propagating along two different wires get close enough to each other to give rise to an effective interaction . a phase @xmath11 is added if and only if the two - qubit systems is in @xmath12 and the @xmath2 gate acts as follows : @xmath13 , leaving the other three two - qubit states unchanged . the above quantum gates have been numerically validated elsewhere @xcite . in fact , the phases @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath11 depend upon the physical and geometrical parameters of the system , e.g. the window length , the barrier height / length , the electron - electron coupling strength , the saw velocity . the proposed teleportation scheme ( with the exception of qubit 3 preparation ) employs only quantum gates with @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 and we tuned the device parameters accordingly . for brevity , in the following we will omit the indication of the above phases . ( color online ) sketch of the physical system used for the deterministic teleportation of electron 3 in electron 1 . the first two couples of quantum wires from the top represent the alice s system , while the bottom couple is bob s system . the bell - state preparation of qubits 1 and 2 consists of two beam splitters @xmath19 and @xmath20 followed by a coulomb coupler @xmath21 and a further splitting @xmath19 of qubit 1 . the gates in the dotted box labelled sp is needed to prepare the input state @xmath22 . this block applied to @xmath23 produces the general one qubit - state @xmath24 . the bell - measurement process in alice s system is realized in two sequential steps . first a complete rotation from bell states to separable states is performed by means of the beam splitter @xmath20 followed by a coulomb coupler @xmath25 and further inverse rotations of @xmath26 @xmath27 and @xmath28 . then the single - qubit states are measured by means of charge detectors ( green boxes ) . the outcome is communicated through a classical channel ( dashed lines ) to bob , which reconstructs in @xmath29 the original quantum state of qubit 3 by means of a network of one - qubit gates ( two beam splitters @xmath19 and two potential barriers ) . specifically , the potential barrier @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) is switched on if and only if the outcome of qubit 2(3 ) measurement is 0 ( see table [ tab1 ] ) . ] the quantum - wire network for our teleportation protocol is shown in figure [ fig1 ] . as a first step alice and bob must entangle qubits 2 and 1 . in particular , they start with an initial state @xmath32 @xcite , corresponding to one electron entering the upper wire of bob qubit 1 and another electron entering the upper wire of alice qubit 2 . the first block of quantum gates , namely two coupling windows @xmath33 ( acting on qubits 1 and 2 , respectively ) and a coulomb coupler @xmath34 ( acting on qubits 1 and 2 , together ) produces a maximally entangled state @xmath35 . now alice , wants to teleport , the quantum state of electron 3 @xmath36 , obtained from @xmath23 by means of the network of one - qubit gates reported in the state preparation ( sp ) box , into electron 1 at bob side . she performs a so - called bell measurement on qubits 3 and 2 . in fact , as suggested by brassard _ et al . _ @xcite , such a measurement can be realized in two steps : first the bell states of qubits 2 and 3 are rotated in the basis @xmath37 , then a projective measurement is performed in this latter basis . this approach permits to achieve deterministic quantum teleportation , since it makes possible a full bell measurement on alice s particles . in our scheme , the first step of the brassard approach is performed by means of the second block of quantum gates involving a coulomb coupler @xmath34 now acting on the qubits 2 and 3 and three @xmath33 gates ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . the three - qubit state obtained after this block takes the form : @xmath38 after this rotation alice can perform two single - particle measurements on qubits 2 and 3 . specifically , such measurements can be realized by means of single - electron transistors , acting as sensitive charge detectors . once the result is known , it can be transmitted as two classical bits of information to bob , that can choose the setup of proper unitary operations on his qubit 1 in order to completely recover the initial state @xmath39 . in fact , depending upon the outcome of the measurement on qubits 2 and 3 , suitable potential barriers acting as phase shifters @xmath40 are eventually introduced between the two coupling windows , according table [ tab1 ] . . the phase shifters ( potential barriers ) in the final stage of the bob qubit are applied according to the outcome of alice measurements in order to reconstruct the original state @xmath39 . note that the phase shifter @xmath41 is controlled only by the qubit 3 ( 2 ) , i.e. the potential barrier is introduced only when the electron is found in the lower wire of the corresponding qubit at alice side . [ tab1 ] [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the network of gates described in sec . [ phy ] has been simulated by solving numerically the time - dependent schrdinger equation for the three electrons injected in the device . gaas material parameters have been used . since a direct solution of the 3d - schrdinger equation for the whole three - particle wavefunction results too demanding in terms of computational resources , a semi-1d model has been adopted , as described in the following by referring to fig . the network is defined in the @xmath42-plane . in the @xmath43 direction the electrons are always supposed to be in the ground state of the quantum well defining the plane of the wires . the @xmath44 direction is explicitely included in the simulations through the @xmath45 variables , defining the position of the three carriers along the wires . specifically , in the computational approach adopted @xmath44 is discretized with a point - grid of resolution @xmath46 nm . for the @xmath47 direction , the @xmath48 variables can assume only the values 0 or 1 , identifying one of the two possible wires of a qubit , that is the qubit state . this allows us to move from a time dependent schrdinger equation for a seven - variable wavefunction @xmath49 to eight coupled schrdinger equations of the form @xmath50 the potential term appearing in the above equation is given by the sum of two contributions . the first stems from the saw time - dependent potential and reads @xmath51}\qquad \quad \qquad \forall \{x_1,x_2,x_3\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 indicates the amplitude of the potential , @xmath53 its wavelength , and @xmath54 the sound velocity . specifically , in the numerical investigations performed , @xmath52= 20 mev , @xmath53= 200 nm , and @xmath55 cm s@xmath56 the second term represents the screened coulomb interaction between carriers , computed from the geometry of the system and can be written in the form @xmath57 where @xmath58=@xmath59 with @xmath60 indicating the distance between the wires @xmath61 and @xmath62 at the positions @xmath63 and @xmath64 , respectively . this is a coulomb potential multiplied by an exponential damping term , corresponding to debye wave vector @xmath65 . in particular , in our calculations the latter has been taken equal to 0.2 nm@xmath66 : a value of the same of order of the ones given in the literature @xcite . due to the geometry of the system and to screening effects , the coulomb interaction can be considered negligible everywhere for not adjacent qubits , that is qubit 1 and 3 , and in the regions not involving the coulomb coupler for nearby qubits . each of the eight coupled schrdinger equations of eq . ( [ sch ] ) has been solved by means of simple - finite - difference relaxation method applied at each time step of the time evolution performed in a crank - nicholson scheme with @xmath67=0.01 fs @xcite . it is worth noting that in the simulation of the three - particle wave function dynamics , the only gate that presents a computational challenge due to its spatial extension and the two - particle potential involved , is the coulomb coupler @xmath34 . however , it is not always necessary to compute its effect on the whole wave function . in fact , when the first @xmath34 gate comes into action by entangling electrons 1 and 2 , electron 3 wave function remains factorizable . as a consequence , before the second @xmath34 gate , a two - particle simulation is sufficient . the numerical estimation of the second @xmath34 gate , between qubit 2 and 3 , requires more care since at this stage qubit 1 is already entangled with qubit 2 . this entanglement is not only related to the localization of electrons in one of their wires , but also to their positions @xmath68 and @xmath69 . as a consequence , the effect of the second coulomb coupler must be computed on the whole three - particle wave function . thanks to the superposition principle and to the fact that the interaction is just among electrons 2 and 3 , we performed different two - particle simulations for different values of @xmath68 and then computed the final state as the combination of the different evolutions . we found that , due to the sharp localization of the spatial wavepackets and to the small @xmath44-direction entanglement , the solution turns out to be practically independent from the choice of @xmath68 , as it will be shown by the numerical results reported in the next section . a number of numerical simulations have been performed in order to obtain the optimal geometry for the coulomb coupler @xmath34 . this is reached when the delay phase @xmath11 attains @xmath70 . as shown in other works @xcite , the latter mainly depends upon two geometrical parameters : the length of the coupling region and the distance between the coupled wires . from the optimization procedure , we find that the coulomb coupler is 150 nm long while the coupled wires are 5 nm distant from each other . this geometry allows a value of 0.88@xmath70 for the delay - phase @xmath11 , which is good enough for realizing both the initial maximally entangled state and the final rotation of the bell states at alice side . the experimental realization of the coulomb coupler @xmath34 is the most challenging part . specifically , the angle formed by a wire where it bends towards the other qubit must be small enough in order to make reflection phenomena negligible . in addition , no tunnelling between the two wires must be present to let the two wavefunctions only interact through coulomb coupling . obviously , within our semi 1d - model it is not possible to simulate directly the dynamics of the wave function splitting by a coupling window leading to the one - qubit transformation @xmath33 . in fact , we exploited the results of 2d simulations to validate the qubit transformations @xcite and include the beam splitters through their corresponding transformation matrix . we have performed our numerical simulations to teleport many test states prepared by tuning the phase @xmath71 and setting @xmath72 to @xmath26 for the phase shifters in the sp box of fig . [ fig1 ] . figure [ fig2 ] summarizes the three - qubit dynamics estimated numerically for the case of @xmath73 ( corresponding to @xmath74 ) , starting from the carrier - injection instant up to the single - particle measurements on alice s qubits . the square modulus of the eight components of the three - particle wavefunction @xmath75 is reported being the latter evaluated for the three electrons in the same @xmath76 position . we initialized the system in @xmath77 ( electrons injected in the upper wire of each couple ) . the first column of fig . [ fig2 ] shows the only non vanishing component of the wavefunction . the two @xmath33 gates located in the left part of the device split in the same way the electrons of qubits 1 and 2 ( third column of fig . [ fig2 ] ) . then , the coulomb coupler acting between qubits 1 and 2 induces a phase of 0.88@xmath70 in @xmath78 with respect to the other components . when the injected carriers reach the second coupling window between the wires of qubit 1 , the new rotation leads with good approximation to the three - qubit state @xmath79 , as shown in the fifth column . this corresponds to an epr pair of electrons 1 and 2 . however , we find that the component @xmath80 is small but not zero . this can be ascribed to the fact that the rotation performed by the simulated @xmath34 gate is not exactly @xmath70 . then the single - qubit gates of the sp block operate onto @xmath81 and the state @xmath82 is produced . from this stage , single and two - qubit operations act only onto electrons 2 and 3 , in order to perform the complete rotation of the bell state of qubits 2 and 3 into separable states . the components of the three - particle wavefunction displayed in the last column of fig . [ fig2 ] show the state @xmath83 on which the destructive measurements will be performed by alice . the state components depend on the coefficients of the spectral decomposition of the teleported state @xmath84 in terms of the single qubit - states @xmath85 and @xmath86 . in agreement with the theoretical prediction , we find that , for @xmath87 , the square modulus of the components @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath78 , and @xmath90 has the same form and value , which approximately is the triple of the one found for @xmath91,@xmath92 , @xmath93 , and @xmath77 , respectively . such a result shows the good efficiency reachable in the proposed teleportation scheme . ( color online ) the effect of the quantum gates of the network of fig . [ fig1 ] on a three - qubit state at different stages of the time evolution . the square modulus of the eight components of three - carrier wavefunction @xmath94 are reported as a function of @xmath76 at different time steps . here the teleported state is @xmath73 . thus the output state is @xmath83 of eq . ( [ outgoing ] ) with @xmath95 and @xmath96 . note that , to optimize the graphical represention , the curves are normalized to the ones corresponding to the states @xmath90 and @xmath97 in the second column . ] to better quantify the reliability of the teleportation , we also compare the square modulus of the coefficients @xmath98 and @xmath99 of the initial state @xmath100 with the coefficients @xmath101 and @xmath102 of the final state @xmath103 obtained by bob after the teleportation ( see fig . [ fig3 ] ) . the fidelity @xmath104 of the teleportation process , given by @xmath105 , is strictly related to the ratio @xmath106 : the closer to 1 the latter is , the larger values the fidelity attains . for the set of teleported states , obtained by varying the phase @xmath71 from 0 to @xmath70 , the above ratio ranges from @xmath107 @xmath108 to 1.02 @xmath109 and , for @xmath110 , it is almost equal to 1 @xmath111 . this implies that the state @xmath112 } |0\rangle + i\sin{\left[\left ( 3\pi/8\right)\right]}$ ] is teleported with the maximum efficiency . this proves an important point : the fidelity of the proposed teleportation scheme remains very high also for non ideal entangling gates and this can certainly be considered a plus in view of an experimental implementation . ( color online ) square modulus of the coefficients of the initial state @xmath113 and the final state @xmath114 as a function of @xmath71 . this graph illustrates the case with @xmath115 and @xmath116 . note that the phase @xmath71 is tuned by the barrier height in the @xmath117 gate of the sp box of fig . [ fig1 ] . ] in order to test the validity of the approach used in the numerical solution of the 3d - schrdinger equation for three - particle wavefunction , we have reported in fig . [ fig4 ] , the fidelity @xmath104 as a function of @xmath76 ( that is the point along the wires of qubit 3 where the carrier is assumed to be found in a measurement process ) . this is repeated for five teleported states corresponding to different values of the phase @xmath71 with @xmath72 set to @xmath26 . we find that @xmath104 is essentially constant . this implies that the efficiency of our quantum teleportation scheme does not basically depend upon the position variable along the wire direction of the three particles . this behavior , due to the confinement of the carriers in the saw minima leading to a sharp localization of the corresponding wavepackets , proves the validity of the two - particle approach adopted . ( color online ) fidelity of the teleportation process as a function of the difference between the wavepacket center @xmath118 and the point @xmath76 , for five teleported states corresponding to different values of the phase @xmath71 with @xmath119 : @xmath120 ( dotted line ) , @xmath121 ( dashed line ) , @xmath122 ( dot - dot - dashed line ) , @xmath123 ( dash - dash - dotted line ) , and @xmath124 ( solid line ) . the abscissa scale , ranging from -20 nm to 20 nm , covers the space region where the integral of the single - electron probability density ( shown for reference and represented by the gaussian - like thick solid line ) is equal to 0.92 . note that the estimated fidelities take values very close to 1 and that , for any teleported state , do not significantly depend upon position in the examined space interval . ] finally , the effect of the temperature deserves a few comments . as stated in sec . [ phy ] , numerical simulations of charge transport through quantum wires has been performed at zero temperature , that is fully coherent propagation of electrons has been assumed . such an approximation allows one to neglect the effects due to the piezoelectric coupling between charge carriers and acoustic phonon modes . in fact , the latter represents the main decoherence source of our physical system . experimental investigations about both saw assisted charge transport @xcite and low - dimensional devices suitable for quantum computing @xcite are usually carried out at temperatures in the range of mk . a realization of our device would require such low temperatures at which the stimulated absorption and emission processes of acoustic phonons are weak enough to be neglected . in fact , the mean occupation number of acoustic phonons with momentum energy @xmath125 5 mev ( of the order of the energy difference between the ground and the first excited bound state of the electrons ) can be evaluated from bose - einstein statistics and results to be practically zero at a temperature of 100 mk . thus it seems reasonable to take into account only spontaneous emission processes . these obviously affect the ideal fidelity of the gates implemented in the teleportation scheme . however such unavoidable effects can be minimized by inserting suitable quantum error correction codes in our scheme @xcite . this corresponds to use more two - qubit gates for the same computation . moreover , we expect that in an experimental setup the quantum teleportation process , would be repeated many times . in fact , the simulations performed in this work represent a `` single shot '' of the network in fig . [ fig1 ] , with three electrons in the same minimum of the saw . however , it is reasonable to think that in the experiment electrons also populate the other minima , as described in ref . . this corresponds to a multiple repetition of the teleportation scheme ( one each saw minimum ) . here we have proposed a device for the deterministic teleportation of electrons injected and driven by saws in a network of coupled quantum wires . it consists of a sequence of single - qubit ( beam splitter and phase shifter ) and two - qubit ( coulomb coupler ) gates which allows a high level of control over the state evolution . numerical simulations show that , with a suitable design of the nanostructure , the fidelity of the teleportation can reach values close to 1 , indicating a high - realibility of the process . furthermore , we also mention the possibility of using carrier transport in edge states for quantum hall effect regime , instead of saw - assisted electron transport in quantum wires . the experimental realization of the device proposed is challenging since it requires the use of frontier mesoscopic semiconductor technology . however , both the new developments in nanostructures fabrication permitting the control of the coupling between two modes of two 1d - channels @xcite , and the recent observation of single electron dynamics in experiments of saw assisted charge transport @xcite , seem to indicate the feasibility of an experimental setup of our device . its realization would undoubtedly represent a great step forward toward quantum - computing capable architectures scalable and integrable with traditional microelectronics .

we propose and numerically simulate a semiconductor device based on coupled quantum wires , suitable for deterministic quantum teleportation of electrons trapped in the minima of surface acoustic waves . we exploit a network of interacting semiconductor quantum wires able to provide the universal set of gates for quantum information processing , with the qubit defined by the localization of a single electron in one of two coupled channels . the numerical approach is based on a time - dependent solution of the three - particle schrdinger equation . first , a maximally entangled pair of electrons is obtained via coulomb interaction between carriers in different channels . then , a complete bell - state measurement involving one electron from this pair and a third electron is performed . finally , the teleported state is reconstructed by means of local one - qubit operations . the large estimated fidelity explicitely suggests that an efficient teleportation process could be reached in an experimental setup .

astro-ph9904082

it is now 45 years since cocconi @xcite drew attention to the broadening effects of the geomagnetic field on the lateral development of electron - photon cascades in the atmosphere . allen @xcite discussed the interaction of the geomagnetic field and the cascade electrons / positrons as the origin of the radio frequency emission produced by large cosmic ray showers . et al _ @xcite suggested that the geomagnetic separation of muons could be used to estimate the height of origin of showers . porter @xcite and browning and turver @xcite made calculations for the production of erenkov radiation by electron - photon cascades in the atmosphere , with allowance for the effects of the geomagnetic field . ground based gamma ray astronomy exploits the magnifying effects of the atmosphere to enable the detection of very low fluxes of gamma rays from a variety of sources @xcite . the cascade of electrons initiated by a primary gamma ray produces , at an altitude of about 10 km , erenkov light which reaches the ground in a pool @xmath0 m in diameter . it is possible to detect gamma rays of energy @xmath3 300 gev via this erenkov light produced in the atmosphere with an effective collection area , for our mark 6 telescope , of @xmath4 m@xmath5 . bowden _ et al _ @xcite discussed the effect of the geomagnetic field on the performance of ground based gamma ray telescopes . the interaction of the field and the cascade electrons produces a broadening of the atmospheric erenkov light image resulting in a reduction in the density of light sampled by the telescope ; so the energy threshold for the telescope increases . this is observed in the higher count rate for a telescope detecting showers propagating along the lines of the field ( with no spreading ) than when observing cascades developing perpendicular to the field lines ( and being spread ) , all other factors being the same . typical differences in measured count rate were about 20% in these extreme cases . the possibility was noted , on the basis of simulations , that an associated rotation of the direction of the erenkov light images may occur for cascades developing under high magnetic fields and in unfavourable directions . this could be of importance in ground - based gamma ray studies since the orientation of the image in gamma ray initiated cascades is the key to rejection of @xmath3 99% of the charged cosmic ray background @xcite . lang _ et al _ @xcite showed that the measurements of tev gamma rays from the crab nebula using the imaging erenkov technique were not significantly affected when the magnetic field was @xmath6 0.35 g. we report measurements made using a ground based gamma ray telescope of cascades developing under the influence of fields up to 0.55 g. observations with the mark 6 telescope operating in narrabri , australia which is discussed by armstrong _ et al _ @xcite are subject to such magnetic fields when observing objects to the south . the observational data demonstrate all the effects of the geomagnetic field on cascades which are predicted by simulations . the lateral distribution of electrons and positrons near the maximum of an electromagnetic shower in air is approximately axially symmetric . the presence of a transverse component of magnetic field will cause the electrons and positrons to separate and the lateral distribution to become wider along the radial direction perpendicular to the transverse field component . the order of magnitude of this effect may be estimated . a relativistic electron of energy @xmath7 ( mev ) will follow a circular path in a transverse magnetic field of strength @xmath8 ( g ) with a radius of curvature @xmath9 ( km ) of @xmath10 . the energy of the typical erenkov light - producing electron at shower maximum is @xmath11 100 mev ( the critical energy in air ) , which is at a height of @xmath11 10 km for a 250 gev primary gamma ray . the radius of curvature of these electrons for a maximum transverse magnetic field of 0.56 g is @xmath11 6 km . the typical length of such an electron s path in air at 10 km altitude is @xmath11 1 km , giving a lateral deflection of @xmath11 80 m. at a height of 10 km this corresponds to an angular deflection of @xmath12 , the same order as the coulomb scattering width . it should be possible to detect this as a broadening of the shower along one axis . the effect of the broadening will depend on the orientation of the image with respect to the direction of the magnetic field . the direction of the shower axis in the atmosphere is within @xmath111@xmath13 of the telescope - source line . the transverse magnetic field component therefore lies very close to the plane of the focal image of the shower . the parameters of an image which are used to discriminate between gamma rays and hadrons depend primarily on the second spatial moments . in a coordinate frame in which the x - axis is aligned with the projected field direction , these are @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 . the orientation angle of the long axis of the image is . those shower images whose major axes are aligned with the projected direction of the magnetic field have . the moment @xmath17 will be expected to be increased by the magnetic field and the images will be widened only . for images at other orientations , and the result of an increase in @xmath18 will be to rotate their minor axes towards the projected field direction . the main parameter used to discriminate gamma rays is _ alpha _ , the angle contained within the long axis of the image and the radius vector from the source position to the centroid of the image . any rotation of the image may affect _ alpha _ and hence the sensitivity for gamma ray detection . this is discussed further in section [ simulations ] . monte carlo simulations of gamma ray and hadron cascades have been made to investigate the strength of this geomagnetic effect . these simulations have been performed using a monte carlo code developed from that used in our earlier work @xcite which incorporates the responses of the university of durham telescopes . the results of the simulations have been validated against established simulation codes e.g. mocca @xcite . agreement has been found in all cases . the consequence of an increase in the lateral and angular spread of the shower electrons is a decrease in the density of erenkov light on the ground . this leads to a decrease in counting rate for fixed threshold , which was reported by us from measurements , using a non - imaging telescope , of counting rate against azimuth at fixed zenith angle @xcite . figure [ fig : simtotal ] shows the simulated reduction in the counting rate of a gamma ray telescope of the type used by us for hadron primaries , relative to the zero - field case , caused by a transverse magnetic field of 0.5 g. this is consistent with our earlier measurements a reduction of up to @xmath19 in count rate for gamma ray energies @xmath20 gev @xcite and , apparently , a greater reduction for @xmath21 gev cascades . in our earlier work @xcite we suggested that the distribution of recorded photons in an imaging camera may be distorted . we show in figure [ fig : simimage ] the pattern of photons in individual simulated 1 tev gamma ray cascades developing under the effects of 0 and 0.56 g geomagnetic fields . we also show the predicted responses of our camera after allowing for optical distortion , pixellation of the camera , measurement noise and passing through our standard data analysis package . the simulations for the pairs of cascades developing under the influence of a field and no field have been initiated using the same random number seed ; this ensures , as far as is possible , that the early development of the cascade ( which dominates the resulting image and is nearly independent of field ) is identical for the two simulations . the expected effects on the shape of the image ( widening or lengthening and rotation , depending on the orientation of the image with respect to the magnetic field direction ) was apparent , both in the distribution of photons hitting the detector and in the processed image . the predicted width of a shower image was investigated as a function of magnetic field strength and angle for gamma rays of energy 500 gev . results are shown in figure [ fig : simswid ] for transverse field strengths of 0.0 , 0.2 and 0.5 g. no allowance is made for the broadening effects of the defects in the mirror or the pixellation of the recording pmt camera . the effect of a 0.5 g field on the width ( minor axis ) of such undistorted gamma ray images is seen to be greatest when the image minor axis is perpendicular to the projected field direction , as expected . small transverse fields of 0.2 g have a limited effect on the image width . however , the effect on the pointing angle _ alpha _ become noticable and may vary both with the image s angle to the magnetic field and with its eccentricity ( defined as the ratio _ width_/_length _ ) . for example , an image with very low eccentricity may be widened only by a small amount but rotated through a large angle . histograms in _ alpha _ are shown in figure [ fig : simsalpha ] for the simulated gamma rays , for which widths were shown in figure [ fig : simswid ] , under the influence of fields of 0.0 , 0.2 and 0.5 g. the effects of mirror quality and camera pixellation of a typical telescope may reduce this change in width but may not mask the change in orientation of the image . we show in figure [ fig : tracks ] the celestial sphere , as viewed from the site of the mark 6 telescope in narrabri , australia , showing the loci of constant magnetic field strength . we indicate the tracks on the sky for the telescope during observations of a number of potential gamma ray sources which have been intensively studied . in fact , most of the sources studied at narrabri are in the azimuth range @xmath22 and in directions for which the magnetic field is @xmath3 0.35 g and in many cases @xmath3 0.5 g. the telescope sensitivity is therefore likely to be reduced by the broadening of the distribution of _ alpha _ for many of our observations , unless corrections are applied . all data reported here have been obtained with the mark 6 vhe gamma ray telescope which has been described in detail by armstrong _ et al _ @xcite . the telescope measures gamma rays in the energy range 300 gev 10 tev , with a 50% trigger probability at an energy of @xmath0 gev . it comprises an alt - azimuth mount with three 7 m diameter f/1.0 aluminium mirrors with an rms spread for a point source of @xmath23 . the pixel size for a @xmath24 diameter photomultiplier is @xmath25 . the focal plane of the central mirror contains a 109-pixel camera comprising a close - packed hexagonal array of 91 1-inch diameter photomultipliers surrounded by a ring of 18 2-inch diameter photomultipliers . the field of view of the imaging camera is @xmath26 wide . the mirrors on the left and right of the mount each contain a triggering detector of 19 2-inch photomultipliers in a close - packed hexagonal array . each photomultiplier is contained in a mumetal shell designed to give magnetic and electrostatic shielding . the effect of the geomagnetic field on the performance of the photomultipliers , with and without shielding , has been studied @xcite . for the 1-inch hamamatsu r1924 pmt the effect of a 0.5 g field on the gain was not measureable and less than 1% . for the 2-inch phillips xp3422 pmt the measured decrease in gain due to a 0.5 g field was 1% . shielded photomultipliers of both types show no measurable effects due to the magnetic field . the control of the attitude of the telescope is via dc servomotors driving onto gears mounted directly on the telescope structure . angles are sensed by absolute digital 14-bit shaft encoders with a resolution of @xmath27 . the calculated azimuth and zenith of a source is compared by a digital servomechanism ( employing 12-bit resolution ) with the shaft encoder outputs at 100 ms intervals . the error signals are passed via dacs to the dc motor amplifiers . these provide damping on acceleration and stabilise the movements of the telescope structure . thus although the telescope pointing is known to a resolution of @xmath28 , the source can be offset from the camera centre by up to @xmath29 by this mechanism . the attitude of the telescope is measured in two ways . the shaft encoder positions are recorded for each event to 14-bit accuracy . this gives a measurement of the pointing to @xmath30 within the telescope system . in addition , a coaxial optical ccd camera is mounted on the telescope . the output of this ccd camera is continuously monitored by microcomputer , which measures the position and brightness of a nominated guide star within the @xmath31 field . this information is integrated into the data stream on an event - by - event basis . guide stars of magnitude @xmath32 can be employed , providing absolute position sensing for the telescope to better than @xmath33 . false source analysis has been shown to be a useful method of demonstrating that @xmath34-ray like events originate from the source direction @xcite . conversely , such analyses may also be used to verify the steering performance of a telescope , if an established @xmath34-ray emitter is observed . however , we have only one data set for a gamma ray source containing data which are _ not _ subject to the effects of a strong geomagnetic field see section [ pks2155alpha ] . most of the data considered here were taken during routine observations of potential gamma ray sources during 1996 1998 . a small amount of data was taken in dedicated measurements at fixed values of azimuth and zenith , corresponding to a range of values of the geomagnetic field . the only restriction imposed on data was that events should lie within @xmath35 of the centre of the camera ( to avoid edge effects ) and were large enough ( 5 times the triggering threshold ) to ensure that their shape was well measured . the investigation of the sensitivity of the count rate to the magnetic field which established the effect with the mark 3 and mark 4 telescopes @xcite has been repeated for the mark 6 telescope . we find that the count rate observed with the mark 6 telescope for cascades developing under minimum and maximum values of the geomagnetic field at a constant zenith angle of @xmath36 differs by about 15% , as expected . the widths of images recorded by the mark 6 telescope in directions parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field have been investigated . for a large sample of cascades measured during observations of a range of sources the differences of the mean width in the parallel and perpendicular directions are shown in figure [ fig : distortion ] for a range of values of distorting field . the widths of images in directions perpendicular to the field are significantly greater than those in parallel directions for fields @xmath2 g. although the differences in widths are small , because of the effects of pixellation and noise which are common to all data , the measurements are free from systematic effects . this is because the orientation of images to the magnetic field depends on the orientation of the image in the camera . measurements of the width of the images parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field are derived from events distributed throughout the same observation . we have attempted to measure the differences in widths of images in cascades measured at fixed zenith angles of @xmath36 for values of fields less than and greater than 0.35 g. such measurements are difficult and require large exposures ( @xmath37 hr ) to give significant differences . for example , with exposures @xmath38 hr we find for @xmath39 g , the mean width is @xmath40 ( sd @xmath41 ) and for @xmath42 g the mean width is @xmath43 ( sd @xmath44 ) . the small difference in means , significant at the @xmath45 level , demonstrates the difficulty in making such a small measurement for which the standard deviation is approximately similar for all @xmath46 . in the absence of any magnetic field and detector triggering biases , the distribution of the orientation of the images in the camera of a telescope will be isotropic . if we define a coordinate system where the angle @xmath47 is the angle of the long axis of an image to the horizontal in the camera frame , then the distribution of @xmath47 should be flat between @xmath48 and @xmath49 . minor deviations from uniformity in angle might be expected near to threshold because of the increased effect of small changes in triggering probability and the six - fold symmetry of the hexagonal arrangement of close - packed detectors . we show in figure [ fig : aysmallh](a ) the distribution in the angle @xmath47 for background hadronic events which are subject to small values of the transverse magnetic field ( 0.15 g ) . we show in figure [ fig : aysmallh](b ) the distribution in @xmath47 for images due to hadron - induced cascades recorded in special observations at fixed azimuth and zenith angles which gave a transverse geomagnetic field of 0.52 g. all of these events were recorded in dedicated observations with the telescope at a fixed zenith angle ( @xmath36 ) . data at different values of the transverse magnetic field were obtained by varying the azimuth angle . all data presented here were recorded within a period of one hour , so potential variations due to changes in camera performance , atmospheric clarity , etc . were minimised . the data were processed following our normal procedures ( see e.g. @xcite ) . the requirement that images have a minimum brightness and fall within the camera ensures that the data are free of effects of variations in night sky brightness . the data for @xmath50 g show the expected distribution indicative of a near isotropic distribution of directions in the camera with a small peak . we note a strong anisotropy , with a peak containing twice the number of events resulting from the skewing or distortion of the image , for events subject to a @xmath51 g field . the maximum of the distortion occurs at @xmath52 , which is appropriate for those observations which were made at magnetic south . the magnitude of the anisotropy displayed in figure [ fig : aysmallh](b ) should depend on the strength of the magnetic field . in figure [ fig : ayampvh ] we plot the amplitude of the peak of the distortion in the @xmath47 distribution as a function of the magnetic field strength . each point corresponds to the result for a 15 minute segment of data . note that for values of transverse component of the geomagnetic field less than 0.35 g there is no great distortion of the @xmath47 distribution , as suggested by the work of lang _ et al _ @xcite , but for values of field in excess of 0.4 g substantial distortion occurs . the position of the peak in the @xmath47 distribution depends on the angle between the projected magnetic field and the vertical direction in the camera @xmath53 . we show in figure [ fig : aydirvh ] the correlation between @xmath53 and the position of the peak in @xmath47 . the data demonstrate the expected relation between these angles . again , each point is based on a 15 min sample of data taken during routine observations of a range of potential gamma ray sources . we have evidence that the geomagnetic field should , and does , influence the lateral development of atmospheric cascades . the observed effects on the threshold of a telescope and on the shape of the image and the magnitude and phase of the distortion of the pointing of images produced by background cosmic ray protons are as expected . a number of potential gamma ray sources has been observed using the mark 6 telescope at narrabri . in several cases there is evidence for gamma ray emission @xcite . the evidence comes mainly from a comparison of the _ alpha _ distributions for data selected on the basis of image shape for the on - source and off - source scans . the difference between the _ alpha _ distributions should show an excess of events the gamma ray candidates at low values of _ alpha_. if the data were taken in geomagnetically unfavourable directions , as is the case for most of our data , it might be expected that the _ alpha _ distribution of the excess events would be wider than that for data taken in more favourable geomagnetic directions . consideration of data recorded from a gamma ray source which are subject to @xmath54 g may provide the only true indication of the _ alpha_-distribution for our telescope . observations of this object were made with the cascades recorded over a range of transverse geomagnetic field strengths between 0.25 and 0.5 g. the total data set contained 41 hrs of observation , as reported @xcite . the _ alpha _ plot for the difference between the on - source and off - source data taken at zenith angles @xmath55 is shown in figure [ fig : alphaplot2](a ) . the significance of the excess at _ alpha _ @xmath56 is @xmath57 according to the maximum likelihood method @xcite . we are able to select a subset of data for which the strength of the projected field to which the cascades were exposed was @xmath6 0.35 g and for which minimal distorting effect would be expected . the _ alpha _ plot for this subset is shown in figure [ fig : alphaplot2](b ) . the excess events all have _ alpha _ @xmath58 ( significance @xmath59 ) . the distribution is narrower than that of the total dataset and is typical of that expected for a @xmath60 pixel camera . ( in the absence of any other data for gamma rays detected with our telescope and _ not _ subject to the effects of the magnetic field , we assume that this is reasonable . ) the _ alpha _ plot for the majority of the events for which the field is @xmath3 0.35 g , is shown in figure [ fig : alphaplot2](c ) . it is evident that the width of the peak is larger for these events recorded under the influence of higher transverse magnetic fields , with equal populations for values of _ alpha _ between @xmath61 @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) and @xmath62 @xmath64 ( @xmath65 ) . it should be noted that the peak at @xmath66 @xmath67 is superimposed on an _ alpha_-plot with increasing frequency for _ alpha _ approaching @xmath68 see @xcite . the significance of this peak is therefore @xmath69 ( before allowing for the number of bins in the _ alpha_-plots ) . on the basis of our only measurement of a gamma ray source not subject to the effects of the geomagnetic field , we have evidence that the excess events with @xmath70 _ alpha _ @xmath56 are confined to those measurements made with fields @xmath71 g. this conclusion is significant at the 2.5% level , on the basis of a @xmath72 contingency test of the populations of the @xmath73 bins in figures [ fig : alphaplot2](b ) and [ fig : alphaplot2](c ) . we have demonstrated that , on the basis of simulations and measurement , the erenkov images from gamma rays and cosmic rays are broadened and rotated by the geomagnetic field . the broadening results in an increase in the telescope threshold and a reduction in counting rate . the rotation of the images away from the projected direction of the magnetic field in the image plane broadens the _ alpha _ distribution . these results suggest that the geomagnetic field can have an important effect on the operation of atmospheric erenkov telescopes in some directions and that , for detected and candidate sources , our narrabri site is particularly susceptible . these effects may be removed using appropriate correction techniques ; unlike noise , geomagnetic effects do not reduce the information contained in the image . we are grateful to the uk particle physics and astronomy research council for support of the project and the university of sydney for the lease of the narrabri site . the mark 6 telescope was designed and constructed with the assistance of the staff of the physics department , university of durham . 99 gibson a i , harrison a b , kirkman i w , lotts a p , macrae j h , orford k j , turver k e and walmsley m 1982 , _ proc . int . workshop on very high energy gamma ray astronomy _ , ed p v ramana murthy and t c weekes , ( bombay : tata institute ) p 97

atmospheric erenkov telescopes are used to detect electromagnetic showers from primary gamma rays of energy @xmath0 gev @xmath1 tev and to discriminate these from cascades due to hadrons using the erenkov images . the geomagnetic field affects the development of showers and is shown to diffuse and distort the images . when the component of the field normal to the shower axis is sufficiently large ( @xmath2 g ) the performance of gamma ray telescopes may be affected , although corrections should be possible .

cond-mat0503161

two - band superconductivity was first proposed in the late 1950 s and further studied in the 1960 s and 1970 s as a possible explanation for understanding superconductivity in s- and d- band metals . however , it was not until the discovery of superconductivity at relatively high temperature in mgb@xmath5 in 2001 , that the most promising example of two - band superconductivity was found . after nearly four years of effort and the development of an extensive literature based on this material , it is now evident that this compound is an electron - phonon mediated superconductor , but with two distinct bands and hence two energy gaps . indeed , this is firmly established from detailed bandstructure calculations that provide the electron - phonon spectral densities which , when in turn are used in a two - band eliashberg formalism , give rise to predictions which are in accord with experiment . in fact , the picture that emerges is one of excellent agreement with the data , with the match being as good as is found between theory and experiment in conventional one - band superconductors@xcite . a detailed review and summary of the level of agreement found for the thermodynamic properties , bcs ratios , penetration depth and temperature - dependent energy gaps is found in ref . with such an extensive comparison between rigorous eliashberg theory and experiment completed , it is now appropriate to move on to the transport properties where less theoretical work has been done . in this paper , we consider the critical current which is of fundamental interest in the discussion of transport . while most technological applications focus on the bulk critical current density , which requires understanding of flux lattice pinning , etc . , here we are presenting the critical current in thin films . this geometry is more relevant to understanding issues associated with the fundamental superconducting state , rather than focussing on material details that lead to vortex pinning , etc . , and hence can be expected to provide further insight into the nature of multiband superconductivity in these materials . we note in passing , at this point , that some authors use the term depairing current for the critical current although , technically , the depairing current is the current at which the first cooper pair is broken and the gap decreases , and the critical current is the maximum current possible , which is greater than the depairing current . in simple one - band s - wave bcs theory the values are almost the same and hence there is the tendency to use the terms interchangeably . here , these two quantities can be quite different and so we will use the term critical current to refer to the global maximum obtainable in the current density . the full temperature - dependence of the critical current @xmath2 was first studied in conventional one - band s - wave bcs superconductors by rogers@xcite and bardeen@xcite . further work following on this was done by parameter@xcite for the clean limit , and by maki@xcite for the dirty limit , where the latter author introduced a description of the superfluid current density using the green s function formalism . a study of the effect of of a current on the quasiparticle states density of states of a superconductor was done by fulde@xcite . the most general work was that of kupriyanov and lukichev@xcite , who calculated the full temperature dependence of the critical current in bcs theory for arbitrary impurity scattering , which returned the usual ginzburg - landau results for the critical current near @xmath6@xcite . further considerations led to an initial attempt to include strong inelastic scattering@xcite followed by a full eliashberg calculation and study of strong coupling effects for conventional electron - phonon superconductors done by ourselves@xcite . thus , the formalism and basic one - band results have been well - established in both the weak - coupling bcs limit and strong - coupling eliashberg regime , at all temperatures and for arbitrary impurity scattering . more recently there has been a renewed theoretical effort on the critical current as applied to exotic gaps , which are anisotropic , such as d - wave@xcite and f - wave@xcite . the two - band case is , in some sense , a highly anisotropic system and hence the study of the critical current in this instance also complements these recent works . with regard to mgb@xmath5 , specifically , there has been some recent experimental work by kunchur@xcite , where the critical current has been measured in these systems . on the theoretical side , koshelev and golubov@xcite have gone beyond ginzburg - landau to use the usadel equations to study this system and find interesting effects such as a kink in the temperature - dependence of the c - axis critical current that reflects the underlying two - band nature . this type of feature is observed in other properties such as the penetration depth which also shows an inflection point in the temperature dependence , however , these effects may disappear with increased interband coupling . finally , a more recent work has been done on the topic of the non - linear term in the superfluid current in mgb@xmath5 and its effect on the nonlinear microwave response , which is relevant for device applications@xcite . in our work here , we use the general green s function formulation presented by maki@xcite where the cooper pairs are given a finite center of mass momentum @xmath1 . this @xmath1 leads to a boost in the quasiparticle energy ( sometimes called a doppler shift ) . the superfluid velocity @xmath7 is taken as uniform in the case of discussing currents in thin films or wires , unlike the doppler shift effect in the context of superfluid currents in the vortex state , where @xmath8 varies with spatial position . this latter topic has been the subject of a large number of papers in the recent literature relating to d - wave superconductors@xcite . a very fine physical description of the effect of this doppler shift on the quasiparticle density of states and the resulting effect on the superfluid density is presented in a paper by xu et al.@xcite , where they consider the non - linear meissner effect in d - wave superconductors from a starting point that discusses the basics of the superfluid current density . thus , with a body of literature developing on the topic of critical currents and superfluid currents , it is of interest to elucidate the features in the critical current due to two - band superconductivity , where unusual effects can occur due to a transfer from one band to the other of the dominant contribution to superfluid current and hence the critical current . our paper is structured in the following manner . in section ii , we introduce the basic theoretical equations which we have evaluated . we then examine , in section iii , results for renormalized bcs theory near @xmath6 and at @xmath9 and apply these results to mgb@xmath5 . in section iv , we present our eliashberg results for finite temperature and with impurities , evaluating the critical current for mgb@xmath5 and other model parameters . we also compare our results to the data for mgb@xmath5 . finally , we form our conclusions in section v. while various approaches have been used in the past for calculating the superfluid current , we will use the green s function method as presented by maki@xcite . thus the superfluid current density @xmath10 is given in terms of finite temperature green s functions as : @xmath11\quad , \label{eq : js1}\ ] ] where @xmath12 is the electron charge , @xmath13 , the electron mass , @xmath14 is the electron momentum , and @xmath15 is the temperature . the green s function is given in terms of the matsubara representation by @xmath16^{-1 } , \label{eq : greensfn}\ ] ] where @xmath17 , @xmath18 is the chemical potential , and the @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the pauli matrices for the particle - hole and spin spaces , respectively . the @xmath21 is the applied superfluid momentum and it results in a shift of the quasiparticle energies , given to first order in @xmath1 by @xmath22 . here , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the imaginary axis renormalized superconducting order parameter and renormalized matsubara frequencies , respectively , and are defined below . the integral over energy @xmath25 for the combined eqns . ( [ eq : js1 ] ) and ( [ eq : greensfn ] ) can be done and the result , generalized to two bands , is given in terms of a sum of two partial currents @xmath26 and @xmath27 , for the first and second band , respectively : @xmath28 with @xmath29 where @xmath30 , @xmath31 is the electron density and @xmath32 is the fermi velocity of the @xmath33th band ( @xmath34,2 ) . the nonlinear eliashberg equations for @xmath35 and @xmath36 have been generalized to two bands and with the inclusion of the effect of the @xmath1 , they are given as@xcite : @xmath37\nonumber\\ & \times&\int_{-1}^{1}\frac{dz}{2 } \frac{\tilde\delta_j(m)}{\sqrt{(\tilde\omega_j(m)-is_jz)^2+\tilde\delta_j^2(m)}}\nonumber\\ & + & \pi\sum_j(t^+_{ij}-t^-_{ij})\int_{-1}^{1}\frac{dz}{2 } \frac{\tilde\delta_j(n ) } { \sqrt{(\tilde\omega_j(n)-is_jz)^2+\tilde\delta_j^2(n)}}\nonumber\\ \label{eq : del}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath38 where @xmath39 and @xmath40 are the ordinary and paramagnetic impurity scattering rates , respectively , and the electron - phonon kernels @xmath41 with phonon energy @xmath42 enter through @xmath43 here , the @xmath44 indexes the @xmath44th matsubara frequency @xmath45 , with @xmath46 , where @xmath47 . the @xmath48 are coulomb repulsions , with a high energy cutoff @xmath49 usually taken to be about six to ten times the maximum phonon frequency . as written , eqns . ( [ eq : js2])-([eq : z ] ) are for three dimensions with isotropic fermi surface . for general anisotropic fermi surface , a fermi surface integral would remain , which would need to be done numerically@xcite . this goes beyond the scope of this paper , however , such details are not expected to change the qualitative features of our results but rather lead to quantitative changes only . in the following sections , we present both eliashberg results and renormalized bcs ( rbcs ) results , the latter of which can be quite successful at capturing the essential features of the eliashberg calculations without the full numerical complications of the more sophisticated calculations even for two - band models@xcite . to develop the rbcs results we use the two - square - well approximation or @xmath50 model written for two - bands ( for details see ref . @xcite ) , where now @xmath51\delta_j(t)}{\sqrt{(\omega_m - i\bar s_jz)^2+\delta_j^2}}. \label{eq : rbcsdel}\ ] ] in this expression , @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 with @xmath55 taken to represent either the debye frequency or some other characteristic energy scale representing the phonons in the system . likewise , the current from eq . ( [ eq : js2 ] ) can be reduced to @xmath56 equations ( [ eq : rbcsdel ] ) and ( [ eq : rbcsjs ] ) will be used in the next section to develop analytic results for comparison with full numerical calculation . in order to evaluate the critical current near @xmath6 , we need to know the effect of the current on the gap near @xmath6 . in this limit , both @xmath57 and @xmath1 will be small . after long but straightforward algebra , to first order in @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the reduced temperature , the gap equation of eq . ( [ eq : rbcsdel ] ) reduces to the form @xmath60 with a second equation obtained from eq . ( [ eq : bcs1 ] ) by switching indices @xmath61 . here @xmath62 and @xmath63 where @xmath64 and @xmath65 . for @xmath66 as @xmath67 and with no superfluid momentum @xmath68 , we recover the equation for the critical temperature ( symmetric in @xmath61)@xcite : @xmath69 with @xmath70 . throughout this paper , we will find it instructive to consider several simplifying limiting cases . the completely decoupled case corresponds to @xmath71 and the assumption that @xmath72 . in this case , the first channel determines the @xmath6 , which is given by @xmath73 . as an aside , we note that the small separable @xmath74 anisotropy model studied extensively in the older literature@xcite maps on to this model if @xmath75 , @xmath76 and @xmath77 , with the anisotropy @xmath74 assumed small . in this case , eq . ( [ eq : bcs3 ] ) simplifies greatly since @xmath78 so that @xmath79 = ( 1+\lambda)/[\lambda(1+a^2)]$ ] which gives @xmath80)$ ] . this is the well - known result that anisotropy increases the value of the critical temperature over its isotropic value ( @xmath81 ) . returning to eq . ( [ eq : bcs1 ] ) which gives the gap just below @xmath6 , we need to specify @xmath82 . it is given ( after more lengthy algebra ) as @xmath83 and an equivalent expression for @xmath84 is obtained from eq.([eq : bcs4 ] ) by switching indices @xmath61 . solving for @xmath85 , we find @xmath86 with @xmath87 \label{eq : bcs6}\ ] ] and @xmath88 . \label{eq : bcs7}\ ] ] likewise , the gap @xmath89 , is formed from the above three equations by exchanging @xmath61 . when @xmath90 , these equations properly reduce to those obtained previously by nicol and carbotte@xcite . in the limit of decoupled bands , @xmath91 and @xmath92 . some care is required when treating the equivalent equations for @xmath93 and @xmath94 because the combination @xmath95 is replaced by @xmath96 , which is zero . nevertheless , we can show @xmath97 , which is expected on physical grounds as the second band does not contribute near @xmath6 , where @xmath98 for @xmath99 , and @xmath100 $ ] , a well - known result . we can also recover other well - known results for the small separable anisotropy model defined previously . note first that when the fermi velocities are equal , @xmath101 in eq . ( [ eq : bcs7 ] ) reduces to @xmath102 , with @xmath103 given by eq . ( [ eq : bcs6 ] ) . further , @xmath104 and @xmath105 which leads to ( eq . ( [ eq : bcs5 ] ) ) @xmath106 \label{eq : bcs8}\ ] ] and an identical equation for the second gap with the first factor of @xmath107 replaced by @xmath108 . for @xmath90 , eq . ( [ eq : bcs8 ] ) reduces to the known result that the average gap @xmath109 with @xmath110 and @xmath111 . for the isotropic case ( equivalent to one band ) @xmath81 and eq . ( [ eq : bcs8 ] ) reduces to @xmath112 as is well known . the expression for the contribution to the current from the @xmath33th band is given in renormalized bcs by eq . ( [ eq : rbcsjs ] ) . expanding near @xmath113 for small @xmath1 and @xmath57 gives @xmath114 the total current is the sum over both bands and can be written as @xmath115 \frac{7\zeta(3)}{4(\pi t_c)^2 } eq_s , \label{eq : bcs13}\ ] ] where @xmath116 . substituting into eq . ( [ eq : bcs13 ] ) the new expression from eq . ( [ eq : bcs5 ] ) ( and equivalent for @xmath61 ) for @xmath85 , one obtains two terms . the first proportional to @xmath1 and the second to @xmath117 . this gives the total current @xmath0 as a function of @xmath1 . the critical current @xmath118 is obtained as the maximum of @xmath119 as a function of @xmath1 . after finding the extremum value of @xmath1 , we obtain for @xmath118 @xmath120^{3/2 } \biggl [ \frac{n_1}{m_1^*}\frac{1}{\chi_1^\prime}+\frac{n_2}{m_2^ * } \frac{1}{\chi_2^\prime}\biggr]^{-1/2}. \label{eq : bcs14}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we first note that the standard ginzburg - landau @xmath121 temperature dependence of the critical current remains unmodified in the two - band model . as a first check on our expression in eq . ( [ eq : bcs14 ] ) , we can recover the known one - band result when both bands are assumed to be identical by taking @xmath122 , @xmath123 , and the value of @xmath124 . here @xmath125 is the total electron density per unit volume equal to the sum @xmath126 . we obtain the standard ginzburg - landau result@xcite : @xmath127 note that all effective mass renormalization @xmath128 factors have cancelled in eq . ( [ eq : bcs15 ] ) . applying the separable gap anisotropy model to eq . ( [ eq : bcs14 ] ) leads to a modification of eq . ( [ eq : bcs15 ] ) by a multiplicative factor of @xmath129 . this gap anisotropy will decrease @xmath118 over its value for @xmath130 . decoupled bands give the usual expression of eq . ( [ eq : bcs15 ] ) since the second band makes no contribution near @xmath113 , but now @xmath44 , @xmath13 , and @xmath131 are those of the first band only . in the general case , we need to return to eq . ( [ eq : bcs14 ] ) which tells us how material parameters affect the slope of @xmath132 which varies linearly with @xmath58 near @xmath6 . if we normalize the current , as we will in the next section , to a slope of negative one near @xmath6 , this will mean that the current at @xmath9 will vary with material parameters in contrast to the one - band bcs curve for which it is a universal number for the clean limit case that we are discussing here . a well known result of ginzburg - landau theory is that near @xmath6 , @xmath133 , where @xmath134 is the thermodynamic critical field and @xmath135 is the london penetration depth , both for the case of zero current . in a previous paper@xcite , we have given expressions for @xmath134 and @xmath136 as @xmath99 . using these with eq . ( [ eq : bcs14 ] ) , we arrive at the expression relating the two - band @xmath4 , @xmath3 and @xmath2 : @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the velocity of light and @xmath139 is a complicated material - dependent parameter . it is given by @xmath140^{-1 } \label{eq : bcs18}\ ] ] where we have found it convenient to change from electron density @xmath31 , to density of states at the fermi surface @xmath141 . this modifies the usual ginzburg - landau relation by a constant factor . for the decoupled case where @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 , @xmath139 becomes equal to 1 . there is no change in the ginzburg - landau relation and this makes sense since near @xmath145 we are dealing with the single band ( the first one ) . for the isotropic gap case , where @xmath122 for any @xmath146 , from eqs . ( [ eq : bcs6 ] ) and ( [ eq : bcs7 ] ) we obtain @xmath147 and @xmath148 , the average of the squares of the fermi velocities in the two bands , which gives @xmath149 for identical bands , this expression gives 1 , as it must . this also holds if either the two fermi velocities are the same or the two density of states match , but not if both parameters for one band differ from those of the other band . we see that , in general , @xmath139 can be either greater or less than one and the ginzburg - landau relation ceases to hold . for identical bands but with gap anisotropy in the separable small anisotropy @xmath74 model , @xmath150 and @xmath151 , with @xmath104 and @xmath105 which gives @xmath152 to order @xmath74 . this result is expected since , as is well known , the @xmath74 anisotropy correction to @xmath134 and @xmath153 are both of the form @xmath154 which gives a factor of @xmath129 in the ratio @xmath155 . this agrees perfectly with the anisotropy factor we derived earlier for @xmath118 . thus , in this case , the ginzburg - landau relation will hold . we wish to comment on the use of the ginzburg - landau relation @xmath133 for comparison with data at all temperatures , which is done by substituting two - fluid model forms for @xmath134 and @xmath135 . the ginzburg - landau result should only hold near @xmath6 and indeed we find that when we form the ratio of @xmath155 using the @xmath134 and @xmath135 from the full eliashberg procedure , the resulting @xmath118 curve rapidly deviates from the eliashberg calculated @xmath118 . the results of using such a phenomenological procedure can give curves which are lower or higher than the true result , and will not even reproduce the qualitative feature of a kink in the @xmath118 that we have found in the two - band calculation . we conclude that the ginzburg - landau procedure should only be used near @xmath6 as is appropriate to its derivation and no reliable use can be made of it phenomenologically for lower temperatures . we now turn to low temperature and examine results of rbcs at @xmath9 . at zero temperature , the renormalized bcs gap equation ( [ eq : rbcsdel ] ) takes on the form @xmath156 where the barred quantities are renormalized by the factor of @xmath157 of eq . ( [ eq : rbcsz ] ) and @xmath158 ( 250,200 ) these equations need to be solved numerically . results are shown in the four lefthand panels of fig . the top frame is for @xmath159 , @xmath160 , @xmath161 ( nearly decoupled bands ) and @xmath123 . because @xmath162 is so small , the larger gap @xmath163 exhibits the known behavior as a function of @xmath164 of a one - band s - wave superconductor@xcite with a small modification . in one - band , the gap would be unchanged until @xmath165 at which point it would begin a sharp drop toward zero which is reached at @xmath166 . here , the same behavior occurs but there is a very slight drop from the @xmath90 value of @xmath57 at @xmath167 due to the coupling to the second band . the lower gap behaves differently . it retains its @xmath90 value until @xmath167 at which point it also begins a rapid drop but retains a small finite value until the point when @xmath168 . this small tail is due to the coupling @xmath169 which guarantees that the second gap is nonzero , although it can be very small , as long as the first gap is finite . in the second frame @xmath169 has been increased to 0.1 . this results in a considerable integration of the two gaps . at @xmath90 the lower gap ratio @xmath170 has increased from the 0.4 value of the top frame to 0.57 . more significantly for the present paper , as @xmath1 increases both gaps retain their @xmath90 value until @xmath171 , which is the point at which the second gap starts to decrease , but this drop is not as fast as in the top frame because of the large interband coupling . at the same point as the second gap starts to decrease , the first is also reduced but by much less . beyond @xmath165 both gaps drop sharply as expected and reach zero together at @xmath172 , a value which is smaller than the one band value of 1.35 . this shift in zero along the horizontal axis is also accompanied by a shift to the left , relative to the decoupled case , of the inflection points just described , but these shifts are small . these are signatures of the two - band nature of our system . in the third frame of fig . [ fig1 ] ( lefthand side ) , we have retained @xmath173 but now have increased the ratio @xmath174 to 2.0 instead of 1.0 . this has the effect of reducing the region of @xmath1 in which the second gap remains constant at its @xmath90 value and is due to the increase in @xmath175 . for the last frame , we have kept the parameters as in the first frame but have increased @xmath176 to a value of 0.7 . this has the effect of increasing the @xmath90 value of the second gap and also increasing the range over which it stays constant . additionally , the tail beyond @xmath167 is not as small as it is in the top frame due to less gap anisotropy . ( 250,200 ) in renormalized bcs , eq . ( [ eq : rbcsjs ] ) for the partial current can be evaluated analytically at zero temperature to obtain @xmath177^{3/2}\biggr],\nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad \qquad { \rm for } \frac{\bar s_i}{\delta_{i0}}>1\end{aligned}\ ] ] results for the current are presented in the righthand side frames of fig . [ fig1 ] for the four sets of parameters considered on the lefthand side . in all cases , the dotted lines give the results for the partial contribution to the current coming from the second band and the dashed for those from the first . the sum of the two partial contributions is the solid curve . a first feature to note is that for the three frames for which @xmath173 ( nearly decoupled ) , the dashed curves are essentially identical . the straight line segment has slope 0.5 in our units and the zero is very nearly at @xmath178 as in the one - band case . note that on the vertical axis , we have used the total electronic density of states @xmath179 with @xmath180 . if we had used only @xmath181 then the slope of the straight line segment would have been 1 which corresponds to what is expected in the one - band case . a second point to note is that increasing @xmath169 to 0.1 as in the second frame from the top has not had a large effect on the partial current from the first band except to reduce somewhat the value of @xmath1 at which the current goes to zero . this is accompanied by a small shift to the left in the position of the peak and a small reduction in its height . by contrast , the effect of the parameter changes are much more significant on the dotted curve ( the current in the second band ) . in the top frame , the slope of the straight line portion of the dotted curve is a little larger than 0.5 because of the renormalization factors on @xmath175 relative to @xmath182 . more significantly the partial current starts to deviate from linearity at @xmath183 at which point it drops rapidly towards zero but remains finite ( although small ) until the current in the first band has reached zero . this also applies to the third frame although in that case the current in the second band has been increased in value because of the increase in @xmath184 by a factor of two . in all cases the total current ( solid curve ) exhibits two peaks . the peak arising at lower values of @xmath1 has a significant contribution from both bands while the other peak at higher values of @xmath1 is due almost entirely to the partial current of the first band when @xmath169 is very small . on the other hand , when there is more integration of the two systems ( second frame from top ) both bands can make a significant contribution . in the top three frames , the first peak is lower than the second while in the fourth frame , the opposite holds . the height of the first peak can be made higher by increasing the value of @xmath184 as in the third frame compared with the first ( or equivalently , increasing @xmath185 as the density of states enters in combination with @xmath131 and so will have a similar effect , which is redundant to discuss here ) or by increasing @xmath176 as in the fourth , again compared with the first . it can also be increased by increasing the offdiagonal coupling as in the second frame . when this is done , however , the contribution of the second band to the total current in the second peak is also increased . finally we note that the peak heights in the two middle frames are only very slightly different and the lower @xmath1 peak could be made to be the highest through a small tuning of the parameters . as the highest peak determines the value of @xmath2 , this transfer from one peak to the other by varying parameters is very interesting and will produce nonstandard effects at finite temperature . before leaving our discussion of rbcs at @xmath9 , it is of interest to consider the specific case of mgb@xmath5 now well - established to be a two - band electron - phonon superconductor . microscopic parameters have been calculated from extensions of bandstructure calculations to obtain the electron - phonon spectral densities . the coulomb repulsion parameters that enter the gap equations ( [ eq : del ] ) and ( [ eq : z ] ) are also known . the parameters are @xmath186 , @xmath187 , @xmath188 , @xmath189 , @xmath190 , @xmath191 , @xmath192 , @xmath193 , with @xmath194 mev . the ratio of the two density of states @xmath195 and of the fermi velocities @xmath196 . to switch to our notation , @xmath197 . we start with rbcs results . in the top frame of fig . [ fig2 ] , we show the dependence of @xmath163 and @xmath198 normalized to @xmath199 as a function of @xmath164 . on comparison with some of the results of fig . [ fig1 ] , we note that mgb@xmath5 shows considerable integration of the two bands and also both gaps become zero at @xmath200 which is considerably reduced from the one - band bcs value . an interesting quantity that could be measured is the quasiparticle density of states @xmath201 in the presence of a current , which was first examined for one - band s - wave superconductors by fulde@xcite . such measurements have recently been reported for pb in ref . @xcite . for each band separately @xmath202\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath203 . in the bottom frame of fig . [ fig2 ] , we give results for @xmath204 as a function of @xmath205 for various values of @xmath1 as indicated in the figure . the solid curve is essentially the zero current limit and shows the expected superposition of two bcs quasiparticle density of states with square root singularities at the two gaps . as the current is increased in the linear region only ( cross - referencing with the upper frame of fig . [ fig3 ] which shows @xmath0 for mgb@xmath5 ) , the singular structure is smeared and the gap region fills as does the region between the two gaps . gapless behavior appears at a value of @xmath1 near the first peak in the total current due to the density of states in the small band going gapless . this is in contrast to what is found in a one - band s - wave superconductor@xcite where the gapless behavior occurs at the critical current . ( 250,200 ) the superfluid current @xmath0 versus @xmath1 for the rbcs calculation with mgb@xmath5 parameters is plotted in the upper frame of fig . the line types are defined in the same way as for the @xmath0 curves in fig . we note that this graph is very similar to that shown in the second frame ( righthand side ) of fig . [ fig1 ] , where it has been discussed in relation to other cases . as in that graph , the peak in the total current seen at low @xmath1 is lower than the one at higher @xmath1 , so that this second peak determines the critical current . it is of considerable interest to compare these renormalized bcs results with those from full eliashberg calculations based on the @xmath206 spectra given in ref . very similar values of the parameters can also be found in ref . such results are presented in the lower frame of fig . there are several differences that are worthy of note . the full eliashberg results are at @xmath207 and the rbcs are for @xmath9 . this difference in temperature is small and is not expected to lead to any significant differences . examination of the partial currents shows that the dashed curves are almost the same in both plots except that strong coupling effects have shifted the point of zero current to a slightly smaller value of @xmath1 . this is accompanied by a shift to the left of the position of the peak , a reduction in its height and an increase in the rounding , all small effects . these differences are seen to be slightly more prominent in the dotted curve . this shows that rbcs can be used with confidence as a first approximation . however , from this point on , we will consider only eliashberg results as we have available to us the electron - phonon spectral functions and we wish to consider the full effects of temperature and impurities . ( 250,200 ) at the end of the last section , we showed a comparison between rbcs and eliashberg theory ( fig . [ fig3 ] ) . given that the electron - phonon spectral functions for mgb@xmath5 are available , it is appropriate to work with the full theory for @xmath2 as a function of temperature and impurity scattering . we begin with a consideration of temperature effects . in the upper frame of fig . [ fig4 ] , we show the current @xmath208 normalized by @xmath209 as a function of @xmath164 for nine values of temperature from @xmath207 to 0.9 in steps of 0.1 . the parameters used are those appropriate to mgb@xmath5 with the upper curve reproduced from the bottom frame of fig . [ fig3 ] . as the temperature is increased , the peak with larger value of @xmath1 remains the highest and therefore determines the critical current given as the solid curve in the lower frame . here , @xmath2 has been normalized by @xmath210 so that the slope at @xmath145 is negative one by arrangement for the typical critical current plot of @xmath211 , which is designed to bring out the ginzburg - landau behavior near @xmath6 . we see a smooth ( concave downward ) increase in @xmath118 as @xmath212 is reduced . the value of the critical current at @xmath213 is @xmath214 . this is lower than the one - band bcs value of 0.72 . this reduction could reflect the two - band nature of mgb@xmath5 as well as strong coupling corrections@xcite due to our use of the full eliashberg equations ( [ eq : del ] ) and ( [ eq : z ] ) to calculate the current given by eq . ( [ eq : js2 ] ) . however , reference to the lower frame of fig . [ fig3 ] shows that the second band contributes only about 10% to the total critical current at @xmath9 and this remains true at @xmath6 . consequently , this curve is very nearly the single band result and deviates from the classical bcs curve almost entirely because of retardation effects . also shown is the data of kunchur@xcite , plotted as solid dots . there is good agreement between the data and the solid curve which is quite remarkable as the calculation has no free parameters , in principle , as they are all given in the literature . including impurity scattering has an effect on the temperature dependence of @xmath118 , as we will discuss later in relation to fig . unfortunately , information on the individual intraband scattering rates in these films for @xmath215 and @xmath216 bands , separately , is not available to us . including some impurity scattering in the @xmath215 band would futher improve the agreement with experiment . the other critical current curves in fig . [ fig4 ] are for different ratios of @xmath174 as indicated in the figure caption . in addition to allowing for some uncertainty in the reported @xmath131 values in the literature , this also mimics the possibility of currents associated with the c - axis where the @xmath216-band is known to have a much smaller @xmath131 than the @xmath215-band . likewise , we have not included the details of the full fermi surface average in the expression for the current , however , it is known that the @xmath216-band is quasi - two - dimensional as opposed to the more three - dimensional @xmath215-band . dahm and scalapino@xcite find significant geometrical corrections associated with such averaging which could also accentuate the difference between the two bands . this may also be approximately captured by our use of different @xmath131 ratios . all the curves are normalized to have a slope of negative one at @xmath145 . as @xmath184 is increased , the normalized critical current at zero temperature increases and can become considerably larger than its one - band bcs value . there is also a change in the temperature variation of the curves , the dashed curve shows a clear kink around @xmath217 while the long - dashed curve shows concave upward behavior at intermediate temperatures . this can be understood better when the pattern of behavior shown in fig . [ fig5 ] is considered . ( 250,200 ) the top frame gives the temperature evolution for the case @xmath218 and the bottom is for a ratio of 4 . the notation is as for the top frame of fig . [ fig4 ] and for the same nine reduced temperatures . in the top frame , it is the peak at lower @xmath1 which determines the critical current at @xmath213 while at higher @xmath212 , it is the peak with higher @xmath1 . this crossover occurs between @xmath219 and @xmath220 and leads to the kink seen in the dashed curve of fig . [ fig4 ] ( lower frame ) . if we look at the individual contributions from each band ( not shown here ) to the total current , we find that at @xmath9 it is the second band which makes the dominant contribution because of its large value of @xmath131 but near @xmath6 this contribution has decayed sufficiently that it only makes a 30% contribution to the total . in the lower frame of fig . [ fig5 ] , the peak at smaller value of @xmath1 has greatly increased in magnitude over its value in the top frame . it has also moved to a lower value of @xmath1 as expected from fig . 1 . however , now there is no crossover from smaller to larger @xmath1 peak and hence no kink . nevertheless , the dotted curve is very different from a one - band bcs variation . we can understand better how this can arise by once more looking at the partial contribution to the critical current from each band . at @xmath9 it is the second band which dominates while at @xmath6 it accounts only for 2/3 of the total with the remaining 1/3 contribution from band one . this difference in admixture of the two bands with temperature is seen to be enough to cause an upward curvature in the dotted curve at intermediate temperatures as well as to increase the value of the normalized critical current at @xmath9 to a value considerably larger than the bcs value of 0.72 . increasing @xmath184 further as in the long - dashed curve of the lower frame of fig . [ fig4 ] increases the @xmath9 value even further as the peak at lower @xmath1 value becomes even more prominent . details of the temperature variation of the critical current clearly depend on details of the microscopic parameters of the two bands involved , such as values of @xmath221 . for example , it is possible to shift the kink in @xmath118 to higher values of reduced temperature and to make it sharper by considering other parameter sets . ( 250,200 ) to illustrate this , in fig . [ fig6 ] we show results for a lorentzian @xmath222 spectrum defined in detail in our previous paper@xcite . in this model , @xmath159 and we take @xmath223 to decrease the gap anisotropy as compared with mgb@xmath5 . we have also taken @xmath173 ( nearly decoupled bands ) . the top frame gives the current @xmath224 for the case of @xmath218 , for the nine values of reduced temperature previously chosen . with this @xmath131 ratio , the peak with lower value of @xmath1 remains highest at small @xmath212 and the crossover of the maximum to the other peak occurs at a reduced temperature between 0.6 and 0.7 . this manifests itself as a sharp kink in the solid curve for @xmath2 ( bottom frame ) at this same temperature . also shown in this same frame are results for the critical current when @xmath225 ( dotted ) and @xmath226 ( dot - dashed ) . for the larger value of @xmath184 , the normalized current at @xmath9 is increased over the @xmath218 case as expected and for @xmath227 it is reduced but remains above bcs . in this latter case , the two peaks in the current versus @xmath1 are closer together than they are in the top frame of fig . [ fig6 ] and seem to almost merge before the crossover from lower to higher @xmath1 peak occurs , which means that the kink in the dotted curve can hardly be seen . it is clear that a rich pattern of behavior exists for the current versus @xmath1 at different reduced @xmath212 in a two - band model . this translates into quite distinct temperature dependence for @xmath118 as compared with the one - band bcs canonical behavior . some addition insight into this complicated behavior can be obtained from a consideration of simplified but analytic bcs results in the limiting case of two decoupled , well - separated bands , i.e. , for small values of the gap anisotropy @xmath228 . under this assumption , @xmath144 , @xmath229 , @xmath230 , and @xmath231 so that the critical current near @xmath6 given by formula ( [ eq : bcs14 ] ) reduces to @xmath232 and is determined entirely by band one , as previously commented upon . as the temperature is lowered , however , two possible circumstances can arise . the critical current can remain determined by the same band ( number one ) in which case we can write approximately @xmath233 a second possibility is that a crossover to the peak at lower @xmath1 value occurs and we have approximately @xmath234 for the first case , @xmath235 which is the one - band bcs result where we have normalized the critical current in such a way that @xmath211 has a slope of negative one at @xmath145 . this conforms with what we have done in the lower frames of figs . [ fig4 ] and [ fig6 ] . for the second case , by assumption , there is a crossover and @xmath236^{2/3}. \label{eq : bcse}\ ] ] this simplified approximate formula shows clearly that the anisotropy @xmath237 on its own reduces the value of @xmath238 below its universal bcs value of 0.72 while a large value of @xmath239 relative to @xmath240 or @xmath184 relative to @xmath241 increases it and that this reduced dimensionless quantity is no longer universal . it can depend on the band structure parameters as well as on the gap anisotropy . next we consider the effect of impurities on the current . it is instructive to begin by expanding eq . ( [ eq : js2 ] ) for @xmath224 to lowest order in @xmath1 . doing so leads to the well - known and physically expected result that for small superfluid velocity @xmath242 where @xmath243 is the superfluid density of the @xmath33th band given for a strong coupling superconductor by @xmath244^{3/2}}\biggr ] \label{eq : bcsg}\ ] ] in bcs at @xmath9 , this becomes @xmath245 and @xmath246 for band 1 and band 2 , respectively . the slope of @xmath247 as a function of @xmath8 gives @xmath248 with eq . ( [ eq : bcsg ] ) valid for any temperature and any impurity content . the impurities enter only through the eliashberg gap equations ( [ eq : del ] ) and ( [ eq : z ] ) . as the temperature is increased , the superfluid density is reduced and so the slope of @xmath224 seen in figs . [ fig4 ] to [ fig6 ] is correspondingly reduced . impurities also reduce the superfluid density . in bcs , the known result for each of the two bands separately , to lowest order , is @xmath249 with @xmath250 and @xmath251 , the coherence length and impurity mean free path in the @xmath33th band , respectively . this applies to intraband scattering which reduces the initial slope of the partial current coming from each band . ( 250,200 ) results are presented in fig . [ fig7 ] , where we also consider the interband case @xmath252 . in the top frame , we show @xmath0 versus @xmath1 for the reduced temperature @xmath253 in the lorentzian model used in fig . the solid curve applies to the pure case and is for comparison . we show only three cases , one where @xmath254 ( dotted curve ) , @xmath255 ( dashed curve ) , and @xmath256 , where @xmath257 is the @xmath6 without impurities ( in the case of @xmath258 and @xmath259 , @xmath6 will be unaffected , but not so for interband impurities ) . intraband impurities reduce only the partial contribution to the current coming from that band . it reduces its value on the vertical axis and extends the x - axis to higher values of @xmath1 leaving the second band largely unaffected . of course , since both bands contribute significantly to the total current in the region of the peak corresponding to the smaller value of @xmath1 , its magnitude is reduced even in the dotted curve . on the other hand , for the dashed curve , there is little change in the region of the second peak which is dominated by the first band . by contrast interband impurities modify both bands in a similar fashion . the corresponding critical current as a function of @xmath260 is shown in the lower frame . the solid line is the pure case of fig . as expected , a finite value of @xmath258 has reduced the critical current below its value in the pure case at all temperatures , however , when normalized to a slope of magnitude one near @xmath6 , the effect pushes the curve up at low @xmath15 . a kink remains and the crossover temperature is only slightly shifted toward higher values . for the dashed curve , the significant modifications arise only below the kink temperature . by contrast the main effect of the interband impurities is to wash out the kink structure leaving the rest of the curve largely unaffected ( of course the @xmath6 would show a small shift downwards relative to @xmath257 , not shown here ) . in conventional one - band s - wave superconductors , the energy gap @xmath57 remains unaffected by the flow of a supercurrent up to a critical value of the superfluid velocity @xmath7 ( ie . , @xmath261 ) at which point pairbreaking becomes possible . in this region , the current @xmath0 is linear in @xmath8 with proportionality constant equal to the superfluid density . beyond this critical value of @xmath8 , the rapid reduction in the gap in addition to a quasiparticle backflow current leads to @xmath262 at @xmath263 . for two nearly decoupled bands , we would expect that the total current to exhibit a two - peak structure as a function of @xmath8 . a first one near the critical value of the superfluid velocity for band two and the other near the larger critical value of @xmath8 corresponding to the first band alone . the first peak has in general a significant contribution from both bands ( unless @xmath264 ) while the second peak could be due mainly to the first band . the relative admixture depends on microscopic parameters such as density of states @xmath265 and fermi velocities @xmath32 , as well as gap anisotropy . when @xmath184 is made large as compared to @xmath241 , the first peak moves to lower values of @xmath8 and can also become larger than the second at low temperature . as the temperature is increased the superfluid density in each band is reduced but that in the second band is more strongly affected because of its smaller gap value . consequently , since the critical current is determined by the height of the highest peak , one can have a crossover from the first to second peak as @xmath15 is raised from @xmath266 to @xmath6 and this will reflect itself as a kink in the temperature dependence of the critical current . such a feature is also found in the dirty limit calculations presented in ref . @xcite for the critical current along the c - axis . when there is a significant interband coupling or the two gaps are close in value ( isotropic case ) the two peaks in the total current cease to be independent and a rich pattern of behavior emerges for the temperature and impurity dependence of the two peaks . in particular , as the temperature is raised , the first peak can remain the determining peak for @xmath2 up to @xmath6 or it can become the smaller of the two at a crossover temperature which can be increased or decreased through judicious choices of parameters . another possibility is that the two peaks merge into one or that the second peak is the dominant one at all temperatures . application to the specific case mgb@xmath5 , which involves no adjustable parameters , gives good agreement with the in - plane data of kunchur@xcite . if the resulting critical current @xmath211 is normalized to have slope of negative one as a function of @xmath58 near @xmath145 , the corresponding value of the critical current at @xmath9 will differ from its classic one - band bcs value of 0.72 . strong coupling effects resulting from our use of the full eliashberg equations , with appropriate electron - phonon spectral densities describing the electron - phonon interaction , are known@xcite to always reduce the normalized value of @xmath267 while two - band effects can reduce or increase it depending on the detailed values of the microscopic parameters involved . in particular , a large value of @xmath184 relative to @xmath241 can lead to values that can be even larger than one . this is expected for the case of current orientated along the c - axis for the specific parameters representative of mgb@xmath5 . in this case , because the @xmath216 band ( band one in our notation ) is nearly two - dimensional , the fermi velocity of the @xmath215 band in the c - direction will be much greater than that for the @xmath216 band . the superfluid density in each subband , which determines the initial slope of the linear in @xmath8 regime for the supercurrent , is reduced with the increase in intraband impurity scattering . this fact can be used to manipulate the position along the @xmath8 axis and size of the two peaks in the total current and consequently the temperature dependence of the resulting critical current . introducing impurities in the first band will reduce the critical current at all temperatures since this band always makes a contribution to the total current . on the other hand , if they are introduced only in the second band , this will leave the critical current largely unaltered around @xmath113 . interband impurity scattering affects both bands although not necessarily in exactly the same way and leads to the smoothing out of the kink in @xmath268 versus @xmath212 when it exists . in conclusion , we predict a complex pattern of behavior for the total current as a function of @xmath8 , temperature and impurity content which can be used to restrict further the values of the microscopic parameters involved in two - band superconductors , such as mgb@xmath5 . ejn acknowledges funding from nserc , the government of ontario ( prea ) , and the university of guelph . jpc acknowledges support from nserc and the ciar . this research was supported in part by the national science foundation under grant no . phy99 - 07949 .

using a green s function formulation of the superfluid current @xmath0 , where a momentum @xmath1 is applied to the cooper pair , we have calculated @xmath0 as a function of @xmath1 , temperature , and impurity scattering for a two - band superconductor . we consider both renormalized bcs and full strong - coupling eliashberg theory . there are two peaks in the current as a function of @xmath1 due to the two energy scales for the gaps and this can give rise to non - standard behavior for the critical current . the critical current @xmath2 , which is given as the maximum in @xmath0 , can exhibit a kink as a function of temperature as the maximum is transferred from one peak to other . other temperature variations are also possible and the universal bcs behavior is violated . the details depend on the material parameters of the system , such as the amount of coupling between the bands , the gap anisotropy , the fermi velocities , and the density of states of each band . the ginzburg - landau relation between @xmath2 , the penetration depth @xmath3 and thermodynamic critical field @xmath4 , is modified . using eliashberg theory with the electron - phonon spectral densities given from bandstructure calculations , we have applied our calculations for @xmath0 and @xmath2 to the case of mgb@xmath5 and find agreement with experiment .

1611.07431

the cms - totem precision proton spectrometer ( ct - pps ) @xcite is a joint project of the cms and totem collaborations aimed at measuring the surviving scattered protons during standard running conditions in regular `` high - luminosity '' fills . ct - pps adds precision tracking and timing detectors in the very forward region on both sides of the cms detector at about 210 meters from the interaction region to study central exclusive production ( cep ) in proton - proton collisions . cep provides a unique method to access a variety of physics topics , such as -among others- new physics searches via anomalous production of w and z boson pairs , high-@xmath1 jet production , and possibly the production of new resonances . the ct - pps detector consists of a silicon tracking system to measure the position and direction of the protons , and a set of timing counters to measure their arrival time . this allows the reconstruction of the mass and momentum as well as of the z coordinate of the primary vertex of the centrally produced system . the protons that have lost a small fraction of their momentum are bent outside the beam profile by the lhc magnets between the interaction point ( ip ) and the detector stations , and their trajectories can be measured in the ct - pps detector . the detector covers an area transverse to the beam of about 4 @xmath2 on each arm . it uses a total of 144 pixel readout chips and about 200 timing readout channels . several challenges are to be met for successfully carrying out the physics program . among those is the ability to operate the detectors close to the beam center , thus enhancing the sensitivity to lower invariant mass systems . a close approach is limited by the interference with the beam , as well as the detector damage caused by the high radiation levels . studies based on radiation monitors placed on the 220 m totem rp stations yield a total dose of about 100 gray and a fluence of the order of @xmath3@xmath4 per 100 fb@xmath5 of integrated luminosity @xcite . these are values at the location of front - end electronics in the rps . a proton flux of up to @xmath6@xmath4 is expected on the sensors themselves . furthermore , another challenge comes from the large background expected in the presence of multiple interactions ( pileup ) per bunch crossing . the number of pileup events was approximately @xmath7=20@xmath830 during 2016 , and may reach 50 or 100 in the next few years . figure [ figure1 ] shows an event with 78 reconstructed vertices collected by the cms experiment during the lhc run 1 . the dominant background results from inelastic events overlapping with two protons from single diffraction events occurring in the same bunch crossing . this pileup background can be reduced by using proton timing information to determine the z - position of the primary vertex . the expected increased pileup and large radiation doses represent some of the difficult challenges that need to be addressed with a focused upgrade program . upgrades to the tracking and timing detector systems and associated electronics are foreseen . these are needed in order to maintain the physics goals and be able to efficiently collect the large samples of data necessary to explore the rare processes that may hint at a new panorama in our current understanding of nature . silicon detectors are widely used in experiments in particle physics . the application of this detector technology is mostly suited for tracking detectors , i.e. detectors which measure the position of charged particles . the enormous progress in improving the resistance to radiation damage and the excellent spatial resolution make this technology well suited for ct - pps . tracking detectors are used to measure the position and direction of the outgoing protons . this will allow to reconstruct the mass and momentum of the centrally produced system . in the past few years there has been considerable progress in silicon sensor technology . at the lhc , both the cms and atlas collaborations have been pursuing improved pixel detector design for the high - luminosity upgrades of the lhc . these efforts culminated with the development of `` planar '' and `` 3d '' pixel sensor designs @xcite . both technologies can be used for the ct - pps detector due to their characteristics . these include : 1 ) efficient tracking close to the physical sensor edge providing single - hit resolution better than @xmath9 m , 2 ) improved radiation hardness to withstand @xmath10 protons/@xmath2 for an integrated luminosity of 100 fb@xmath5 . the 3d sensors consist of an array of columnar electrodes that penetrate through the silicon bulk perpendicularly to the surface . due to its structure , the inter - electrode distance is decoupled from the sensor substrate thickness allowing to reduce the drift path of the charge carriers . the close spacing between electrodes provides several advantages compared to the planar sensor design . among others , they are : 1 ) lower depletion voltage , 2 ) faster charge collection time , and 3 ) reduced charge trapping probability , thus reducing the effects of radiation damage . thanks to their better intrinsic characteristics , 3d sensors are the preferred choice for ct - pps . the ct - pps layout ( figure [ figure2 ] ) foresees two rp stations on each side of the ip to be equipped with tracking detectors . these are the horizontal rps located at @xmath0210 m. each station will contain six planes , where each plane contains a @xmath11 @xmath2 pixel sensor read out by six psi46dig readout chips ( rocs ) . the design of the front - end electronics and of the daq is based on that developed for the phase 1 " upgrade of the cms silicon pixel detectors . the resolution of the x - coordinate is determined by the charge sharing in the pixel clusters , which depends on the detector tilt angle in the x - z plane . test beam results with similar sensors indicate that for an angle of 20 degrees the two - pixel clusters give a resolution of the order of @xmath12 m . since there is no tilt in the y - z plane , the resolution of the y - coordinate is of the order of @xmath13 m . during the 2016 data - taking period , the totem silicon strip detectors were used . these detectors were not intended to sustain high radiation doses but were used during this preliminary phase to commission the detector and daq operations . about 15 fb@xmath5 of data were collected with ct - pps in `` physics '' mode at the safe operating position of @xmath14 from the beam . preparation of the sensors and detector packages , including the readout electronics and the associated mechanics , is ongoing . starting in 2017 , the 3d tracking detectors described above will be installed . upgrades for the high - luminosity lhc detectors are driving the efforts on several fronts , including r&d on timing detectors as an important tool to resolve multiple vertices in events with a large number of interactions . timing information can provide a powerful discrimination of signal and background events in the high - luminosity lhc era , by adding the `` event time '' to the `` event vertex '' information . in the case of ct - pps , timing detectors are used to measure the time of arrival of the outgoing protons at the rp detectors on both sides of the ip in order to determine the z - coordinate of the primary vertex . a time resolution of 10 ps corresponds to a vertex resolution of 2.1 mm . there are several technologies that can be used for a fast timing detector . considerable progress has been made on silicon detectors . solid state timing detectors have the advantage of being very thin and allow for a fine channel granularity . thin sensors make stacking of several layers possible , thus improving the overall time resolution . furthermore , small size pixels may allow a significant reduction of rate per channel . among key characteristics desired for good timing capabilities are large signals , fast drift , and low noise . an increased signal brings many benefits such as the possibility of developing thin detectors with large enough signals . thin sensors also have the advantage of collecting the electrons fast . furthermore , in order to improve the time resolution , large signal - to - noise ratio , small capacitance , and small leakage current are desirable . in general , the time resolution is proportional to @xmath15 , where s and n are signal amplitude and noise level . for a risetime of @xmath16@xmath172 ns , one needs s / n@xmath18100 to get into the 20 ps regime . however , this is only a first approximation as there are additional effects that may play a role in worsening this naive picture . nice reviews can be found in @xcite . good time resolution can be achieved with mono - crystalline * diamond detectors*. these devices are fast , low - noise , and radiation hard . this is the technology chosen for ct - pps . the choice is based on the combination of several ingredients . these include : 1 ) fine segmentation , thus reducing the occupancy of the individual channels , 2 ) thin sensors , thus reducing multiple scattering , 3 ) improved radiation tolerance , and 4 ) good time resolution . a mip signal produces a small signal and therefore low - noise readout electronics must be used . a single - hit time resolution of 80 - 100 ps was measured in beam tests @xcite . during 2016 , two rp stations -one on each side of the ip- were instrumented with diamond detectors . each detector package is composed of four layers of diamond sensors . other technologies are being studied and extensive r&d is pursued in parallel in order to achieve the ultimate goal of 10 ps resolution . extensive r&d is performed on avalanche photo diodes ( apds ) for their fast timing capabilities . in order to achieve good timing resolution they should be operated at a high gain , but they can also work at a lower gain provided that the signal - to - noise ratio is sufficiently large . for this purpose , studies are performed on silicon sensors by exploiting the charge amplification in the silicon itself , either working in `` geiger '' ( as in gas rpc ) or in `` linear '' ( as in low - gain avalanche detectors , lgads ) mode . the progress made on lgads has made possible to develop silicon detectors yielding large signals that are a factor of ten larger than those of traditional sensors . the so - called * ultra fast silicon detectors ( ufsds ) * @xcite are lgads optimized to achieve good timing resolution . they can reach a gain of 10 - 20 for voltages of 200 - 240v . they are n - on - p silicon sensors with an additional p@xmath19 implant under the n - implant . the additional p@xmath19 implant generates a large field used to generate the charge multiplication with a moderate internal gain of @xmath1810 . results of beam tests with a 180 gev pion beam at cern indicate that a timing resolution of 35ps can be achieved for a single layer with an active thickness of @xmath20 m . furthermore , tracking devices are small and not able to provide timing information accurately , while good timing detectors are too large for an accurate position measurement . ultimately , ufsds could provide precise tracking and accurate timing information at the same time . however , charge multiplication is affected by the radiation doses expected @xcite , and more tests are foreseen to further quantify the effects . one timing layer of ufsds for ct - pps is formed by 32 strips ; they are readout by four 8-channel amplifier - discriminator custom - made asics with low - power consumption . the readout chain is based on a time - over - threshold method to measure the timing information . finalization of ufsd sensor production and readout electronics is under way in order to install the first detectors already in 2017 . apds with large amplification are also being exploited for their good timing capabilities . these devices also known as * hyperfast silicon detectors ( hfsd ) * @xcite use a `` deep depleted '' technology and operate at gains of @xmath18500 in a depleted region deep inside the sensor . they require a large electric field with a voltage of @xmath181.8kv . this technology minimizes the drift region to a thin layer of a few @xmath7 m near the surface while the fast avalanche develops in the depleted region , thus improving the timing performance . it has a risetime of @xmath181ns ; sensors with an area of @xmath181@xmath211 cm can also be made . developed by rmd ( radiation monitoring devices inc . ) , this is a radiation - hard technology @xcite . tests are under way to further characterize the effects . a time resolution of less than 20 ps was measured in tests with a muon beam . the cms - totem precision proton spectrometer ( ct - pps ) was approved in 2014 to extend the coverage of the central detector to the region close to the beam at @xmath22 m from the interaction region . ct - pps will allow -for the first time- measurements of central exclusive processes at the electroweak scale , and it will enhance sensitivity to quartic gauge couplings and searches for rare exclusive processes . after an intense preparatory phase , ct - pps started taking `` physics '' data in 2016 during high - luminosity fills in proton - proton collisions . a program of detector upgrades is under way to prepare for the regular insertion of the detectors close to the beam during the next few years , with the goal of collecting 100 fb@xmath5 of data . the ability to withstand high radiation doses while retaining accurate tracking reconstruction and fast timing capabilities is the main challenge to meet . tracking and fast timing detector upgrades have been discussed , together with the r&d program that is actively being pursued for further detector improvements . to my totem and cms colleagues who strenuously contributed to the success of this difficult project becoming a reality , without forgetting that there are still hurdles ahead . to the rd51 colleagues for a stimulating environment where curiosity thrives , something that is often forgotten in our everyday life . to the organizers for an interesting meeting in a beautiful place , and for a kind and relaxed atmosphere . cms and totem collaborations , `` cms - totem precision proton spectrometer , '' cern - lhcc-2014 - 021 . f. ravotti [ totem collaboration ] , `` first radiation background studies for the totem roman pot and t2 detectors , '' doi:10.1109/nssmic.2011.6154586 ( 2011 ) .

the cms - totem precision proton spectrometer ( ct - pps ) is an approved project to add tracking and timing information at approximately @xmath0210 m from the interaction point around the cms detector . it is designed to operate at high luminosity with up to 50 interactions per 25 ns bunch crossing to perform measurements of e.g. the quartic gauge couplings and search for rare exclusive processes . during 2016 , ct - pps took data in normal high - luminosity proton - proton lhc collisions . in the coming years , high radiation doses and large multiple - vertex interactions will represent difficult challenges that resemble those of the high - luminosity lhc program . a coordinated effort of detector upgrades with the goal of reaching the physics goals while mitigating the degradation effects is under way . upgrades to the tracking and timing detectors are discussed .

cond-mat0505232

recently , a huge amount of research on complex networks has been achieved in interdisciplinary fields including mathematics , statistical physics , computer science , sociology , biology , etc . complex networks are ubiquitous in the real world , e.g. , there are technological networks such as the internet @xcite , biological networks such as protein interaction networks @xcite , and social networks such as scientific collaboration networks @xcite . various models to explain the observed properties of those real networks have been introduced and studied by both numerical and analytic approaches . relatively fewer works , however , have been done about possible error or bias in collecting data and identifying real networks in a practical sense , and most works deal exclusively with either social networks or the internet @xcite . for instance , a survey of relationships among participants has to be conducted to construct a social network , but the collected network data may be incomplete or erroneous since a survey usually targets only a partial sample of a whole population @xcite . the topology of the internet is inferred by aggregating paths or _ traceroutes _ @xcite , which also reveals only a part of the whole internet @xcite . in biology , protein - protein interaction networks are identified by seeking contextual or cellular functions mostly within specific functional modules @xcite . identification of such networks by experiments also has a fundamental limit naturally . thus , all these networks identified are _ sampled _ networks from complete structures . in addition , if the size of an entire network is too large to measure some quantities such as betweenness centrality @xcite due to time complexity , inevitably a sampling process is necessary . so far models of networks have been designed based on features observed in real networks , such as the small - world effect @xcite and the power - law degree distribution @xcite . but what if those _ observed _ characteristics from the _ sampled _ networks are considerably different from the original structures of the real networks ? it has been shown that the sampled networks based on the traceroute sampling method may have significantly different topological properties from the original network in some cases @xcite . effects of missing data in social networks are discussed in ref . @xcite , in which it was shown that some problems in conceiving social networks can cause incompleteness of data and lead to misestimation of quantities like mean node degree , clustering coefficient , assortativity , etc . at this point , bias in such quantities needs to be considered in a more general sense . in a statistical sense , inference from a sample provides fairly reasonable estimation of a whole population if a large number of objects are selected randomly enough to be representative in the population . this naive criterion , however , can not be applied directly to sampling networks , since there are two different elements , i.e. , nodes and links in a network . a degree distribution of nodes is , for example , a statistic of a network , but the degree is not an independent characteristic of each node . nodes are literally connected to one another , by the other kind of components called links from which a degree is defined . similarly , other properties of a network also heavily depend on the way that nodes and links are interwoven . there could be several different ways of sampling networks due to the two interrelated elements ( nodes and links ) , and each method may give distinctive features with respect to such properties . there has been a large amount of work on random breakdowns or intentional attack on complex networks , considered as the exact reverse process of sampling , in the physics community @xcite . the analytic methods in that work , therefore , can be also applied to the sampling problem . in this paper , we adopt three basic methods of sampling networks and investigate the effect of each method on measuring several well - known network quantities such as degree distribution , average path length , betweenness centrality distribution @xcite , assortativity @xcite , and clustering coefficient @xcite . observed bias of such quantities is explained , and we provide appropriate criteria for choosing sampling methods to measure the quantities more accurately . some typical real networks as well as the barabsi - albert model @xcite are sampled for this analysis . more general sampling processes used to identify real networks may consist of some combinations of methods presented here or variations of them , but we can infer by using the results from the basic methods . we introduce three kinds of sampling method called node sampling , link sampling , and snowball sampling . in node sampling , a certain number of nodes are randomly chosen and links among them are kept . the sampling fraction in this method is defined as the ratio of the number of chosen nodes ( including isolated nodes that will be removed later ) to that of all the nodes in the original network . as in fig . [ method](a ) , isolated nodes are neglected for convenience , although they are fully predictable , so the number of nodes in a sampled network is a little bit less than that of selected nodes . we observe the dependence of the number of chosen links on that of nodes , since it is related to the average degrees and average path length of sampled networks , discussed later on . suppose the fraction of number of selected nodes is @xmath0 and that of links among them is @xmath1 . then it is found that @xmath2 if we pick nodes randomly , since the maximum number of ( undirected ) links possible for @xmath3 selected nodes are @xmath4 @xcite . in link sampling , a certain number of links are randomly selected and nodes attached to them are kept , as in fig . [ method](b ) . in snowball sampling @xcite , we first choose a single node and all the nodes directly linked to it are picked . then all the nodes connected to those picked in the last step are selected , and this process is continued until the desired number of nodes are sampled . the set of nodes selected in the @xmath3th step is denoted as the @xmath3th layer , in the same sense of `` radius '' for ego - centered networks in ref . see fig . [ method ] ( c ) for illustration . to control the number of nodes in the sampled network , a necessary number of nodes are randomly chosen from the last layer . similar to the cluster - growing method used to calculate the fractal dimension of percolation clusters in ref . @xcite , the snowball sampling method tends to pick hubs ( nodes with many links ) in short step due to high connectivity of them . so whether the initial node is a hub or not does not make a noticeable difference in characterizing the sampled network . for numerical analysis of the sampled networks , we use barabsi - albert ( ba ) scale - free network as an example of model networks , which follows the power - law degree distribution @xmath5 , with @xmath6 nodes and @xmath7 @xcite . we also consider three real - world networks from various fields , including protein interaction network ( pin ) @xcite , the internet at the autonomous systems ( as ) level @xcite , and e - print archive coauthorship network ( arxiv.org ) @xcite . the numbers of nodes and links for each network are in table [ net_table ] . although results from other homogeneous networks are also discussed in sec . iv , most of networks considered in this work are undirected and scale - free networks following power - law degree distribution , @xmath8 , where @xmath9 . in this paper , we have studied the changes of well - known quantities in complex networks for randomly sampled networks . three kinds of sampling methods are applied , and three representative real - world networks , along with the ba model , are used as the original networks for numerical investigation . we have measured four typical quantities in sampled networks , which shows some characteristic patterns in changes of the quantities for each sampling method . based on properties of sampling methods , possible explanations for such changes as well as the mathematical analysis are provided . we have also analyzed other networks than the scale - free ones such as erds - rnyi random network @xcite and the growing network without the preferential attachment @xcite , and the results show that the form of the degree distribution is conserved for the node and link sampling in those cases , consistent with the previous work @xcite . table [ summary_table ] summarizes the results . to check the generality of the results , we also investigated the randomized version of each network in a similar fashion . the randomized networks were constructed by shuffling the links while conserving only the degree distribution @xcite . we found the same results with the original networks . the results in table [ summary_table ] , therefore , seem to hold for scale - free networks in general and provide criteria for sampling method when some specific quantity is supposed to be investigated by the sampling . from another viewpoint , bias of some quantities can be predicted if a specific sampling method used to identify a network is known . if we are interested in the assortativity of a network , for example , node or link sampling can give fairly accurate values . for a clustering coefficient , on the other hand , the link sampling method should be avoided . sampling problems should be taken into account for real network research , but not much work has been done so far . exploration of other characteristics of complex networks or using other sampling methods , rigorous analytic approaches , and establishing solid principles by more systematic investigation could all be important research topics for the future . we hope this work can make a contribution to this direction of research . we would like to thank kwang - il goh for providing useful information , and appreciate yong - yeol ahn for helping us with the link sampling formula . is grateful to kim bojeong basic science foundation and kaist for generous help . this work was supported by kosef through grant no . r14 - 2002 - 059 - 01002 - 0 ( p - j.k . ) and by r01 - 2005 - 000 - 1112 - 0 ( h.j . ) . the traceroute command sends data packets toward a certain destination on the internet , and one collects the traversed nodes and discovered paths during the process . using such processes repeatedly , the sampled networks of the whole internet are contructed at the as or routers level .

we study the statistical properties of the sampled scale - free networks , deeply related to the proper identification of various real - world networks . we exploit three methods of sampling and investigate the topological properties such as degree and betweenness centrality distribution , average path length , assortativity , and clustering coefficient of sampled networks compared with those of original networks . it is found that the quantities related to those properties in sampled networks appear to be estimated quite differently for each sampling method . we explain why such a biased estimation of quantities would emerge from the sampling procedure and give appropriate criteria for each sampling method to prevent the quantities from being overestimated or underestimated .

0807.4763

in this paper we detail the construction and characterize the performance of two cryogenic ion traps systems , designed for trapping @xmath0sr@xmath1 ions . ion traps operated at liquid helium temperature offer several advantages and pose some challenges compared with room temperature ultra high vacuum ( uhv ) systems . the cryogenic environment produces high vacuum and subsequently reduces the collision rate with the background gas.@xcite moreover the low temperatures reduce the electrical ( johnson ) noise and the anomalous heating of trapped ions.@xcite cryogenic systems also present some technical advantages compared with room temperature systems . the time necessary to reach uhv pressures can be 12 hours or less . since the cryogenic temperature suppresses outgassing , the range of materials that can be used for the trap construction is increased , as they do not have to be uhv compatible . however , some of the methods used in room temperature ion trap systems are not directly transferable to a cryogenic system , since careful attention must be paid in how the cryogenic system handles the thermal loads . one important problem with the standard high - temperature ion sources is that they are not compatible with the cryogenic environment due to the high heat load . we found that a compatible ion source can be obtained through a laser ablation method , which was demonstrated in earlier experiments.@xcite though care must be taken to provide appropriate thermal anchoring and isolation , it is possible to use all conventional ion sources , including photoionization and electron impact ionization of atoms produced by an oven . in this paper we focus on laser ablation because it is simple and able to load a variety of species . another problem is that the rf dissipation can locally heat the trap electrodes , which in the case of a cryogenic system requires a very good thermal contact to the cryostat baseplate in order dissipate the generated heat . to address this problem we used optical lithography techniques to fabricated a surface - electrode ion trap , since the planar aspect of this trap simplifies the anchoring to the helium baseplate . in addition , surface - electrode traps are easily integrable in multiplexed ion traps as a proposed scheme for the realization of a large - scale quantum computer.@xcite cryogenic ion traps allow for exploring new physics , such as the quantum interaction between superconductors and ions.@xcite proposals for a quantum information processor based on trapped ions require the ions to be cooled to the motional ground state , and decoherence rates in current ion traps may limit the fidelity of quantum operations.@xcite some of these decoherence sources can be minimized by the cryogenic environment . one source is the motional heating caused by electrical noise in the trap electrodes . studies of the dependence of the ion heating rates on the trap dimensions show that the main component of the heating is anomalous heating which dominates the johnson noise.@xcite previous experiments with the trap electrodes cooled to 150 k showed a reduction of the anomalous heating rate at least one order of magnitude compared with electrodes kept at room temperature.@xcite recent experiments with the ion trap electrodes cooled to 6 k showed an anomalous heating rate reduction of between seven and eight orders of magnitude.@xcite another cause for decoherence is collisions with the background gas molecules , which alter the internal quantum state of a trapped ion.@xcite elastic collisions increase the kinetic energy the trapped ion that may eject the ion from the ion trap . inelastic collisions such as chemical reactions and charge exchange can produce a different ion species or neutralize the trapped ion . several other cryogenic ion traps were successfully operated in previous experiments in order to take advantage of the very high vacuum and the superconducting properties of some materials offered by the cryogenic environments . a cryogenic linear rf ion trap for trapping @xmath2hg@xmath1 was built by the nist ion storage group @xcite and used as a frequency standard . a similar system was employed by okada _ et al . _ for studying the bohr - weisskopf effect in unstable be@xmath1 isotopes.@xcite cryogenic penning ion traps were used by gabrielse _ to trap antiprotons and carry out accurate measurements of the antiproton inertial mass.@xcite also , cryogenic systems were built for trapping neutral atoms . willems and libbrecht @xcite trapped cs atoms in cryogenic magneto - optical and magnetic traps , and more recently nirrengarten _ @xcite used a superconducting atom chip to trap rb atoms . this work is a continuation of d. berkeland s practice of building simple ion trap systems.@xcite we extend it to include ion traps operated in cryogenic environments . we build our cryogenic ion trap systems around two commercially available cryostats : a liquid helium bath cryostat and a low vibration closed cycled cryostat . depending on the experiment , each cryostat presents some benefits over the other . for example , the bath cryostat is naturally vibration free while the closed cycled cryostat does not require a constant supply of cryogens or long term supervision . in order to reduce the mechanical complexity of the setups we kept the total number of the components to a minimum . for this reason , for instance , we opted not to use a hermetically sealed pill - box , which is usually employed in cryogenic systems to improve the vacuum of the working chamber.@xcite we find that the trapped ions lifetime is not adversely affected by the choice of using a single vacuum space defined by the cryostat outer walls . the rest of the paper is organized in two main sections . in the following section ( section [ sec : csetup ] ) we make a detailed description of the components involved in the construction of the two cryogenic systems , along with their principles of operation . in the last section ( section [ sec : eval ] ) we finish with a performance evaluation of these two cryogenic systems built around the bath cryostat and closed cycle cryostat . a good cryogenic ion trapping system must present some of the same characteristics as a room temperature system such as high vacuum and an easy method for ion loading . a low temperature system also brings new benefits like the suppression of electrical noise and a faster turnaround time . on the other hand , the cryogenic systems present few challenges which are not present in the room temperature systems . the cryogenic systems have a limited thermal load capacity , thus special attention must be paid to reduce the heat loads from radiation , conduction and internal heat sources . specifically for the cryogenic ion traps connection wires with low thermal conductivity are required , and they have to be heat - sunk at each temperature stage of the cryostat . in the case of the surface - electrode ion trap due to the dielectric rf dissipation in the trap substrate , the trap must be carefully thermally anchored to the 4.2 k substrate . another problem which must be addressed in the closed cycle cryostats due to their principle of operation , is the damping of vibration . in this section , we describe two cryostat setups we have constructed and evaluated for @xmath34 k operation of surface - electrode ion traps . first , in section [ subsec : bath ] , we describe a bath type cryostat system , the workhorse for the majority of the experimental results presented in section [ sec : eval ] . we have also constructed and evaluated a closed cycle cryostat system , which has the advantage that it does not necessitate a constant supply of cryogens . this cryostat design is described in section [ subsec : ccycle ] . both systems employ similar optical and control electronics subsystems , as described in the block diagram shown in figure [ fig_1 ] . the bath cryostat system is built from a commercial liquid helium bath cryostat ( qmc instruments , model tk 1813 ) , depicted in figure [ fig_2 ] . the trap and related components are mounted on the 4.2 k baseplate of the cryostat ( figure [ fig_3 ] ) . the baseplate is heat sunk to the outside of a 1.75 liter liquid helium reservoir that is surrounded by a 77 k shield connected to a 1.4 liter liquid nitrogen tank . in this setup the 77 k inner chamber is open to the main vacuum chamber . the temperature of the helium baseplate is monitored with a ruthenium oxide sensor ( lakeshore , rx-103a - aa ) . the sensor is mounted in small block of ofhc copper , which is anchored to the baseplate . to enhance thermal contact between the components mounted on the 77 k heat shield or on the 4.2 k baseplate apiezon n high vacuum grease is used . .,width=2 ] for the bath cryostat system we constructed a surface - electrode ion trap , with five dc control electrodes and two rf electrode.@xcite compared with the traditional linear rf paul trap with 3d electrode geometry,@xcite the surface - electrode ion trap has all the electrodes in a single plane . also , the planar aspect of the trap offers the possibility to design complex electrode geometries . we fabricate the traps by evaporating a 2 @xmath4 m silver thin film on a sapphire crystal substrate , followed by a wet etch process in which the electrodes are developed . the width of the ground electrode is 200 @xmath4 m with a spacing between rf and ground electrodes of 10 @xmath4 m ( figure [ fig_5 ] ) . the ion traps are mounted in ceramic pin grid array ( cpga ) chip carriers ( global chip materials , p / n pga10047002 ) ( figure [ fig_6 ] ) to simplify the process of trap swapping . a cpga is a ceramic plate with metallic pads on one side , which are used to make electrical contacts to the chip , and with a corresponding number of pins on the other side such that the cpga can be plugged in a suitable socket or electrical board . moreover , the cpga s we use have over 100 usable pins which permits us to connect ion traps with a large number of electrodes . we attach the trap to the cpga using an epoxy resin ( varian , torr seal ) . the trap electrodes are connected to the cpga pads using gold wirebonds . the cpga is inserted into a socket that is thermally anchored to the helium baseplate through an ofhc copper pedestal ( figure [ fig_6 ] ) , through which electrical connections are made to the socket . to reduce the rf pickup on the dc electrodes , each dc electrode is connected to the ground through 1 nf ceramic capacitors soldered directly on the cpga . since the cpga ceramic is not a very good thermal conductor , in order to heat - sink the heat produced by the dielectric rf dissipation , we solder one end of a cooper wire mesh to the ion trap and the other end to the copper pedestal . the measured trap temperatures at various applied rf voltage amplitudes were as follows : 5.5 k at no applied voltage , 6.0 k at 200 v , 7.5 k at 400 v , and 8.5 k at 600 v. for applying dc bias potentials to the trap and reducing the heat transfer 36awg phosphorus - bronze wire ( lakeshore , wsl-36 - 500 ) is used . in order to lower the heat transfer from the vacuum shield to the helium baseplate , the wires are wrapped once around the nitrogen heat shield . before the dc wires reach the trap they go through a set of rc filters in order to reduce the electrical noise produced by the dc power supplies . the rc filters are thermally anchored to the helium baseplate with each filter having a time constant of 2 @xmath4s . as a fail safe and to check the electrical continuity of the wirebonds , every dc electrode is connected to the exterior through two wires . the rf voltage is applied to the trap through a helical resonator.@xcite the resonator is mounted on the 77 k heat shield ( figure [ fig_3 ] ) in order to reduce the capacitive load from the wire which connects the trap , and also to increase its step up . for the ion trap we used in the bath cryostat setup , the helical resonator was built such that it has a voltage step up of 20 , a loaded resonant frequency of 18.45 mhz , and a quality factor of 30 , as measured at room temperature . when the helical resonator is cooled at 77 k its voltage step up increases to 100 , and the quality factor improves to 67 . with later resonator designs we have obtained quality factors up to 300 . the quality factor can be increased further if the helical resonator is thermally anchored to the 4.2 k baseplate and it is built with superconducting wire.@xcite a helmholtz coil is attached to the exterior of the cryostat since we need to address the zeeman levels of the @xmath0sr@xmath1 ion for doppler cooling and resolved sideband cooling . the helmholtz coil provides 0.6 mt at an applied current of 3 a. the ultra high vacuum in cryogenic systems can be obtained of residual gas molecules on the cold surfaces , even in the presence of materials not compatible with room temperature uhv systems . to increase the cryosorption area , two activated charcoal getters are mounted in the cryostat , one at the top of the nitrogen shield and another on the helium baseplate . each getter contains about 5 g of activated charcoal enclosed in a copper container . to cool the cryostat , we first pump it down using a turbopump while regenerating the getters by applying 180 mw of heat through their heater coils . once the pressure reaches @xmath5 torr as measured at the turbopump inlet by a bayard - alpert pressure gauge , the cryostat is pre - cooled by filling both of its tanks with liquid nitrogen . when the pressure drops to @xmath6 torr , the helium tank is flushed using compressed helium and a liquid helium fill is performed . the final working pressure indicated by the pressure gauge is @xmath7 torr , although the pressure at the ion trap location is expected to be much lower due to the cryosorption and cryotrapping @xcite as it will be shown in section iii . experimentally we observe that the liquid helium hold time with the trap operating is 10 hours , and with no operation 18 hours . the hold time for nitrogen is around 12 hours regardless if the trap is operating or not . we calculated that the heat load on the liquid helium tank with the rf turned off is 23 mw . from the liquid helium hold time , we estimate that running with typical trap parameters the heat load from the rf dielectric dissipation is 33 mw . when there are no electrical connections to the cryostat and all the windows are blocked with metallic blanks the liquid helium has about 90 hours hold time . in order to run the ion trap three laser beams must be sent to the trapping location and a means for collecting the scattered photons by the trapped ions must be provided . laser access to the inner vacuum chamber , where the trap is mounted , is provided by three windows on the side of the cryostat ( figure [ fig_3 ] ) and a window at the bottom of the cryostat is used for ion imaging . each shield of the cryostat has a set of windows . there is an outer set mounted on the room temperature vacuum shield which holds the vacuum in the cryostat while allowing optical access , and an inner set on the 77k shield whose purpose is to absorb 300 k radiation and sink it into the nitrogen , increasing the helium hold time . for the outer set , we use 50 mm bk7 windows ( melles griot , 02wbk226 ) , and for the inner set 1 inch bk7 windows ( thorlabs , wg11050 ) . all the access windows used in the bath cryostat system have no anti - reflection coatings . for imaging the ions an aspheric lens is placed above the trap to collimate the fluorescence from the ions . the aspheric lens was chosen such that it had a good light collection and it can be positioned far enough from the trap so that the electrostatic charges on it do not affect the ions . we opted for an aspheric lens made by edmund optics ( nt47 - 730 ) with an efl of 25 mm and f/1 , which collects 5.3% of the light emitted by the trapped ions . the aspheric lens and a 200 mm plano - convex lens which focus the image outside the cryostat , are placed in a 1 inch cage mount from thorlabs . the entire ensemble can slide on four cage rods as shown in figure [ fig_6 ] . although there is a mismatch in the thermal expansion coefficients between the lenses and cage mount , the lenses have survived hundreds of cool down cycles . the final image is focused onto emccd camera ( princeton instruments , imax / photonmax 512 ) by two 100 mm plano - convex lenses placed outside the cryostat . the imaging system has 4@xmath8 magnification and an overall measured resolution of 6 @xmath4 m . the energy levels of @xmath0sr@xmath1 and the transitions used to conduct the experiments reported in this paper are shown in figure [ fig_7 ] . the s@xmath9p@xmath10 transition is used for doppler cooling the trapped ions and is driven by a 422 nm laser with 20 @xmath4w power focused to a 33 @xmath4 m spot size . the p@xmath10 state has a probability of 1 in 13 to decay to the metastable d@xmath11 level ( 435 ms lifetime ) . to avoid the depopulation of the doppler cooling transition , we use a 1091 nm repumping laser with 50 @xmath4w power focused to a 100 @xmath4 m spot size . the light necessary to drive these transitions is produced from two external cavity diode lasers with optical feedback for frequency stabilization . the details of the lasers used in this experiment are described elsewhere.@xcite this liquid helium bath cryostat system was used to cool a single trapped ion to the motional ground state with a 95@xmath12 fidelity.@xcite sr@xmath1 . the s@xmath9p@xmath10 transition is used for doppler cooling @xcite . the population decayed to the metastable d@xmath11 level is repumped back to p@xmath10 level by the 1091 nm laser.,width=2 ] the closed cycle cryostat system is constructed around a low vibration cryostat produced by advanced research systems ( model gmx-20b ) . the cryocooler head of the cryostat is mechanically decoupled from sample tip and vacuum chamber around it . the cryostat interface has two cooling stages , where the minimum temperature of the first stage is 40 k , and the minimum temperature of the second stage is 4.2 k. the cryostat interface comes with an 8 inch conflat ( cf ) flange and the uhv chamber is built by attaching a full cf nipple , a spherical octagon ( kimball physics , model mcf800-so2000800-a ) and an 8 inch glass viewport . the experiment chamber is made from an ofhc cooper tube attached to the 4.2 k cold tip . the cold tip and experiment chamber are surrounded by a custom made radiation shield attached to the 40 k stage of the cryostat ( figure [ fig_8 ] ) . only the room temperature outer chamber is vacuum sealed , with the inner chambers non - hermetically closed . the temperatures of the 4.2 k and 40 k stages are monitored with two silicon diodes ( lakeshore , dt-670a - sd ) . one concern due to the principle of operation of the closed cycle cryostats , is the vibration transmitted to the ion trap during experiments . since the cryocooler head is mechanically decoupled from the cryostat interface , it must be supported such that the vibration transfer to the cryostat interface is minimized . in our setup we chose to place the cryostat on an optical table with the cryocooler head supported independently by a holder anchored to the ceiling . the vibration amplitudes of the cold tip were measured with a michelson interferometer with the light provided by the 422 nm laser . during the operation of the cryocooler compressor we found that the maximum displacement of the cold tip was below 106 nm ( one quarter of an interference fringe ) . a typical vibration power spectrum of the cold tip is shown in figure [ fig_10 ] . the cryocooler head has a pumping repetition rate of 2 hz , which can be observed in figure [ fig_10 ] inset . . note : the ion trap employed in this setup is different from the one used in the bath cryostat system ( figure [ fig_5 ] ) . for a detailed description of this ion trap consult reference @xcite.,width=2 ] the ion trap used in this setup was built by patterning the copper electrodes on a printed circuit board.@xcite the ion trap and its cpga are installed on a pedestal which is identical with the one used in the bath cryostat setup . the pedestal is thermally anchored to the 4.2 k cold tip . we found that the temperatures of the ion trap as function of the applied rf voltage amplitude were : 7.2 k at no applied voltage , 8.8 k at 500 v , and 9.4 k at 650 v. dc bias potentials are applied to the trap through the same phosphorus - bronze wires used in the bath cryostat . the rf potential is delivered through a 20 awg copper wire , since for this setup the helical resonator is mounted outside the cryostat . to heatsink the heat conducted by the wires from exterior , the wires are wrapped around copper posts mounted on the 40 k cooling stage heatshield and on the 4.2 k baseplate . to attain the uhv environment the cryostat is first pumped with a turbomolecular pump to @xmath13 torr measured by an inverted magnetron pressure gauge attached at the pump inlet . in the second stage the cryostat vacuum chamber is isolated from the turbomolecular pump and the cool down process is started , while the pumping is continued by a small ion pump attached directly to the spherical octagon . the cooling of the cryostat takes 4 hours , with the cold stage reaching a final temperature of 5.2 k and the pressure at the ion pump getting to @xmath14 torr . the computed heat load from radiation and conduction to the cold tip is about 1 w , which agrees well with cryostat heat load map supplied by the manufacturer . the highest heat load ( 0.4 w ) is from the 300 k radiation absorbed by the exposed lenses assembly . in the future we plan to decouple the two lenses and mount the 75 mm lens on the first stage bottom plate . for comparison the thermally unloaded cold tip reaches 4.2 k after 2 hours of cooling . to allow for laser access to the trap , a set of three 2.75 inch viewports are attached on the side of the spherical octagon . the access through the 40 k and 4.2 k heat shields is provided by six 1 inch bk7 windows ( thorlabs , wg11050 ) , with three windows mounted on each shield . the imaging of the ions is done through the bottom 8 inch viewport . the light scattered by the trapped ions is collected and collimated by an aspheric lens ( edmund optics , nt49 - 100 , 22.50 mm efl , f/1.50 ) . the collimated light is focused outside the cryostat by a 75 mm plano - convex lens . both lenses are mounted in 1 inch thorlabs cage mount which can slide on four posts attached to the bottom plate of the cryostat second stage chamber ( figure [ fig_8 ] ) . two lenses , a 75 mm and a 150 mm achromatic doublet are installed outside the cryostat , to focus the final image on a ccd camera ( sbig , st-402me ) . the entire imaging system has a 7.5@xmath8 magnification and provides a theoretical resolution of 1.2 @xmath4 m . for this setup we use a laser system similar to the one used for the bath cryostat setup . in room temperature systems there are several methods for ion loading . in our systems we successfully tested the following methods : the neutral atoms produced by a resistively heated oven are ionized by impact with electrons emitted by an e - gun or through laser photoionization , and the ions are directly produced by laser ablation of a solid target or indirectly by photoionization of the neutrals inside the ablation plume . for our experiments , we chose the laser ablation loading method as it has some advantages compared with the other loading methods . during the ion loading from an oven , the heat production is of the order of hundreds of joules , but in comparison a single ablation pulse of 1.5 mj can load our trap . if the ion trap were operated in a cryostat which could reach temperatures in the milikelvin range , the system would likely not be able to handle the dissipated heat from an oven . another benefit of laser ablation is that it can produce ions from materials with very high melting temperature . surface - electrode traps tend to have a lower trap depth than a linear rf ion trap of comparable dimensions , and thus provide a stringent test for the laser ablation ion loading method.@xcite the mechanism of ion trapping from the ablation plume was described by hashimoto _ et al._.@xcite the fast electrons from the ablation plume arrive first to the trap and cancel the rf voltage applied to the trap , thus allowing the slower moving ions to enter the trapping region even if their kinetic energy is lower than the trap well depth . to produce the ablation plume , we use for both cryostat setups a q - switched nd : yag laser ( continuum electro - optics , minilite ii ) , which produces a maximum energy in its third harmonic ( 355 nm ) of 8 mj per pulse . the pulse duration is around 5 ns . the beam is focused onto the ablation target to spot size of 0.5 mm . because metallic @xmath0sr easily oxidizes in open atmosphere a single crystal of srtio@xmath15 ( mti crystal , stoa100505s1 ) placed 15 mm from the center of the trap ( figure [ fig_3 ] ) is used as ablation target . the yag beam is steered by a high - energy mirror ( cvi laser , y3 - 1025 - 45-p ) . the energy loss in optics is around 1 mj , thus the maximum energy delivered to the target is 7 mj as measured with a pyroelectric meter . in order to study the ion loading efficiency from the ablation plume in the bath cryostat setup , the energy of the nd : yag pulse on the target was varied from 1 mj to 7 mj ( 1 mw / mm@xmath16 to 7 mw / mm@xmath16 ) . the trap was operated at an applied rf voltage of 200 v at a frequency of 18.45 mhz , with a trap depth of 0.34 ev , and with the ions located at 200 @xmath4 m above the trap . the endcap dc electrodes were maintained at 7.5 v and the middle dc electrodes were maintained at -5 v ( figure [ fig_5 ] ) . the secular frequencies of the trap were as following : 550 khz , 1.52 mhz , and 1.87 mhz . during the experiment , the doppler cooling laser was detuned 30 mhz below the transition frequency . the maximum efficiency in ion loading was obtained at 6 mj laser pulse energy as shown in figure [ fig_11 ] . one of the primary reasons to choose a cryogenic systems is that the vapor pressure of most gasses is negligible allowing them to reach very high vacuum in a short time . most of the residual background gas in the bath cryostat comes from the 77 k heat shield and in the closed cycle cryostat from the 4 k shield . the residual gas species with an appreciable vapor pressure at 77 k are he , o@xmath17 , n@xmath17 , and h@xmath17 and at 4.2 k only he and h@xmath17.@xcite the ion lifetime is typically limited by collisions , charge exchange , or chemical reactions with residual background gas.@xcite the elastic collisions can not transfer enough kinetic energy to the doppler cooled trapped ion to eject it out of the trap , since the residual molecules have a kinetic energy no higher than 77 k and they are lighter then the @xmath0sr@xmath1 ion , which is trapped at 3500 k ( 0.3 ev ) depth in the bath cryostat or 4700 k ( 0.4 ev ) in the closed cycle cryostat . the ionization energies of the residual molecules and atoms ( he 24.58 ev , o@xmath17 12.30 ev , n@xmath17 15.60 ev , h@xmath17 15.20 ev @xcite ) from the background gas are higher then the ionization energy of the @xmath0sr atom ( 5.69 ev ) . even if it is assumed that the @xmath0sr@xmath18 ion is in the excited p@xmath10 state and the energy of the 422 nm photon ( 2.97 ev ) is transferred towards the ionization of the colliding atom or molecule the charge exchange reactions can not occur . chemical reactions between the ion and the background gas remain as the only possibility through which an doppler cooled ion held in a cryogenic trap can be lost . among all the possible chemical reactions between the @xmath0sr@xmath18 ion and the residual gas,@xcite in which the kinetic energy of the final @xmath0sr compound is comparable with the trapping potential depth , is : @xmath0sr@xmath19o@xmath20sro@xmath21o@xmath22 ev , where @xmath0sr@xmath23 is the ion in the p@xmath10 state . in the above reaction the sro@xmath1 has a kinetic energy of 0.3 ev which is enough to escape from the trap operated in the bath cryostat system . to determine the lifetime of a doppler cooled single ion trapped in the liquid helium bath cryostat setup , we observed the rate at which ions were lost from an initial chain of 10 ions . experimentally , we found a lifetime of 680 minutes for a single ion . during the experiment no ion became a non - resonant ion due to chemical reactions with the residual background gas ( figure [ fig_12 ] ) . the doppler cooling laser ( 422 nm ) and the repumping laser ( 1091 nm ) intensities were chosen such that the @xmath0sr@xmath18 ion spent approximately a third of the time in the p@xmath10 excited state . without doppler cooling we measured a single ion lifetime of 400 s. knowing the lifetime of a single atom trapped in the bath cryostat system and the collision rate between the trapped ions and residual molecules , an estimate of the o@xmath17 partial pressure at the trap location can be made . the collision rate can be found from the classical langevin theory of ion - molecule collisions:@xcite @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the density of the background gas molecules , @xmath26 is the polarizability of the molecules , and @xmath4 is the reduced mass of ion - molecule system . by assuming that the background gas has a temperature of 77 k and neglecting the kinetic energy of the trapped ions , we estimate an upper bound on o@xmath17 partial pressure of @xmath27 torr . m above the ion trap at a trapping potential depth of 0.40 ev.,width=2 ] if residual gas is not chemically reactive with the ion then , they can still interact via elastic collisions . collisions can heat or cool the ions depending on the mass and temperature of the buffer gas.@xcite injecting he buffer gas provides a means of cooling the ions to cryogenic temperatures that is insensitive to the ion state and does not require laser cooling . we characterized the ion lifetime without laser cooling in the presence of he buffer gas at a partial pressure of @xmath28 torr and at a temperature of 7 k using the closed cycle cryostat . after 12 hours we found there was no discernible drop in the ion cloud fluorescence intensity compared with its initial intensity . to characterize the ion lifetime in the absence of he buffer gas and with laser cooling in the closed cycle cryostat we employed the same method as for the bath cryostat . we observed an ion chain of four ions for a period of 12 hours in which none of the ions got lost or became non - fluorescent . this sets a lower bound for a single ion lifetime to 2500 minutes , which is in agreement with an unlimited ion lifetime obtained from a theoretical estimate similar to the one made for the bath cryostat system . we have shown that the cryogenic ion traps offer many advantages and we successfully managed some problems related to the operation of ion traps in cryogenic environments . the ion traps can be swapped very quickly and uhv pressures can be reached in less then 12 hours , which decreases the time necessary to implement new trap designs . also new materials which are not room temperature uhv compatible can be used in the design of these cryogenic systems . the pressures obtained inside these cryogenic systems permit for the doppler cooled ions to have a trapped lifetime of 680 minutes for the bath cryostat setup and over 2500 minutes for the closed cycled cryostat setup . to load the ion traps we employed an ion source based on laser ablation . by this method we can load surface - electrode ion traps with depths as low as 0.3 ev . in addition , the low temperature of these cryogenic systems offers the possibility of interacting the ions with superconducting systems .

we present two simple cryogenic rf ion trap systems in which cryogenic temperatures and ultra high vacuum pressures can be reached in as little as 12 hours . the ion traps are operated either in a liquid helium bath cryostat or in a low vibration closed cycle cryostat . the fast turn around time and availability of buffer gas cooling made the systems ideal for testing surface - electrode ion traps . the vibration amplitude of the closed cycled cryostat was found to be below 106 nm . we evaluated the systems by loading surface - electrode ion traps with @xmath0sr@xmath1 ions using laser ablation , which is compatible with the cryogenic environment . using doppler cooling we observed small ion crystals in which optically resolved ions have a trapped lifetime over 2500 minutes .

astro-ph0008050

deep surveys with the submillimetre common user bolometer array ( scuba : holland et al . 1998 ) in the fields of rich clusters @xcite and in blank fields ( e.g. , hughes et al . 1998 ; barger , cowie & sanders 1999 ; eales et al . 1999 ) have revealed a large population of luminous , star - forming galaxies at high - redshift . this population produces a substantial fraction of the diffuse infrared background @xcite , and , while the contribution of agn to its total luminosity is uncertain , accounts for at least as much star formation as has been inferred from uv / optical counts @xcite . besides their significance for the star - formation history of the universe , a subset of the submillimeter ( sub - mm ) source population may also host the obscured agn thought to be responsible for the diffuse x - ray background ( almaini , lawrence & boyle 1999 , hereafter alb99 ; hasinger 2000 ; fabian et al . 2000 ) . x - ray background models ( alb99 ; gunn & shanks 1999 ) and optical spectroscopy of sub - mm sources ( barger et al . 1999 , hereafter b99 ) both suggest that @xmath10% @xmath11% of scuba sources should contain an agn . deep x - ray observations with the chandra x - ray observatory can test this connection directly . we report here high - significance x - ray detections of bright sub - mm sources at high redshift , and the first x - ray spectral constraints on this population . the three sub - mm sources we discuss , , , and , are gravitationally magnified by abell 370 and are detected at greater than @xmath12 significance by scuba ( smail et al . 1997 ; b99 ) . we detect the first two of these , hereafter designated and , respectively . both x - ray - detected sources were previously identified with high - redshift ( @xmath1 and @xmath0 , respectively ) star - forming galaxies containing agn ( ivison et al . , 1998 , hereafter i98 ; soucail et al . , 1999 , hereafter s99 ) . we place an upper limit on the x - ray flux from the third , which has no optical counterpart to a limiting magnitude of @xmath13 ( smail et al . 1998 ; b99 ) . chandra observed abell 370 with the acis s3 detector @xcite in 1999 october for 93 ks . the net useful exposure time excluding periods of high background and bad aspect is 66.6 ks . events in asca grades 1 , 5 , and 7 were excluded , and unless otherwise noted , our analysis is restricted to the 0.37 kev spectral range . _ source detection and astrometry : _ we ran the chandra x - ray center s wavdetect wavelet source detection program on an @xmath14 field containing the cluster . we used wavelet kernel scales of 18 arcsec , and set the threshold detection significance parameter to 10@xmath15 . two of the 34 sources detected are positionally coincident with sub - mm sources described above to within 2.6 arcsec . table [ tab : srcpos ] lists the x - ray positions and compares them with the best available optical positions ( source l1 of i98 for ; s99 for ) for the identified sub - mm sources . formal random errors in the x - ray positions are of order 0.2@xmath16 in each axis . systematic errors of @xmath17 may affect the chandra aspect solution currently available for this observation . we compared the positions of other compact sources detected in the chandra image to various optical catalogs and found 4 stellar objects in the apm catalog with positions within 3@xmath18 of sources detected in the acis s3 field . the mean coordinate differences between the chandra and apm frames derived from these objects are listed in table [ tab : srcpos ] . the standard deviation of each of these mean differences is 0.5@xmath18 , and the external accuracy of the apm astrometry is claimed to be @xmath19 @xcite . we adopt the mean chandra@xmath20apm offset as the chandra boresight error , and find that the chandra and optical positions for both sources agree within 1@xmath16 . x - ray source positions ( from other acis detectors ) for four objects in the usno catalog , so corrected , have a mean radial error @xmath21 . we note that the 3 mm radio position of @xcite agrees with both the optical and x - ray positions to within 1@xmath16 . we note also that 14 x - ray sources at least as bright as are detected in the abell 370 field ; the probability of any of these fortuitously lying within 1.5 arcec of one of the sub - mm sources is less than @xmath22 . x - ray surface brightness contours from the gaussian - smoothed ( @xmath23 ) , boresight - corrected chandra image are overlayed on optical images in figure [ fig : xopt ] . _ photometry and spectroscopy : _ net source counts in @xmath24 apertures for detections , and 99% confidence upper limits in 2@xmath16 radius apertures , with corresponding background levels , are listed in table [ tab : srcpos ] . although the local cluster emission exceeds the particle background by a factor of @xmath25 at the source locations , the two ( hard - band ) detections are highly significant ( @xmath2 equivalent ) . upper limits were computed using the prescription of @xcite . the celestial coordinates of are taken to be @xmath26 , @xmath27 ( j2000 ) , derived from the finding chart of b99 . x - ray fluxes are derived from the hard - band counts assuming a power law spectrum with a photon index of @xmath28 . the 850@xmath29 m flux densities are from b99 . in spite of the small count totals , we can constrain the spectra of the detected sources . both sources are quite hard , as neither is detected above the cluster emission in the 0.31.5 kev band by wavdetect . we fit a series of simple xspec @xcite models to pulse - height spectra extracted from @xmath24 square apertures . we modelled the background as the sum of i ) a power law component and fluorescent lines , accounting for the particle background ; ii ) a cool thermal component , representing galactic emission ; and iii ) a hot thermal component representing the cluster . the relative amplitudes and shapes of the various background components were determined from suitable regions of the cluster image , and normalizations were determined locally for each source . the resulting fixed background model was added to the source model and the maximum likelihood statistic was minimized to identify the best - fit source parameters . optical and infrared data suggest that these objects contain agn ( see section [ sec : disc ] ) , so we fit power law models with absorbtion by the galaxy ( fixed at n@xmath30 @xmath5 ; stark et al . 1992 ) and by neutral material at the source . if the source absorbing column ( @xmath31 ) is fixed at zero , the best - fit power law index ( @xmath32 ) is consistent with zero , within wide limits , for both sources . in the case of this model systematically over - predicts the data at both low and high energies , suggesting that additional absorption is required . the fit is better if both @xmath31 and @xmath32 are varied , but @xmath32 is very poorly constrained . in the case of , an @xmath33-test shows that the addition of local absorption does not produce a statistically significant improvement in the fit . for both sources , the indeterminancy in @xmath32 is accompanied by a corresponding uncertainty in the absorbing column and in the intrinsic luminosity of the source . faced with this ambiguity , we fix the photon number index in our fits . the x - ray spectra of low - redshift agn generally exhibit ( unabsorbed ) continuum slopes in a restricted range ( @xmath34 ; e.g. , nandra et al . 1997 ; turner et al . 1997 ) . here we consider models with @xmath35 . any reflected component present is likely to be much harder , and , if the obscuring column is sufficiently high , will dominate the observed emission , at least at lower energies . results of fits are presented in table [ tab : spec ] , where values for fixed @xmath36 and @xmath3 are separated by slashes , and the 90% confidence envelope for these two cases is given in parentheses . to allow interpretation of the x - ray flux either as directly transmitted ( through an absorbing column ) or as reflected emission , we quote both `` unabsorbed '' and `` observed '' 210 kev luminosity in the source rest frame . all tabulated luminosities have been corrected for the estimated gravitational magnification as discussed in section [ sec : disc ] below . from the positional coincidences discussed above we may reasonably identify the chandra and sub - mm sources . here we discuss the role of the agn in the bolometric luminosity of these sources , and consider the implications of our results for the expected connection between the x - ray and sub - mm backgrounds . the role of agn in the energetics of ultraluminous infrared galaxies remains an open question , particularly in the case of the objects thought to comprise the high - redshift sub - mm source population . in the following discussion , we adopt a gravitational magnification of 2.5 for both sources . the uncertainty in this value is no more than a factor of 2 in the case of and about @xmath3710% in the case of ( kneib et al , 1993 ; i98 ; s99 ) . _ ( ): _ i98 presented comprehensive optical and infrared data which determined the redshift and showed emission from a narrow - line , dust - obscured agn . they report detection by iso at 15 @xmath29 m but were unable to determine the relative importance of star formation and the agn in producing the enormous bolometric luminosity of this object ( l@xmath38 , referred to our cosmology . ) frayer et al . ( 1998 ) detected co line emission in , implying a large mass of molecular gas ( 10@xmath39 ) and a relatively small ratio of far - infrared ( fir ) to co luminosity , indicating that star formation is important in this source . they conclude from the relatively low fir - to-4.85 ghz flux ratio that 50% @xmath37 25% of the infrared luminosity may be powered by the agn . we find that the ratio of x - ray to bolometric luminosity for this source exceeds 1.5% for @xmath40 . although this limit is rather low for radio - quiet quasars @xcite , we note that at least two luminous type 2 agn , iras 23060 + 0505 @xcite and iras 20460 + 1925 @xcite , have comparable or lower values of l@xmath41/l@xmath42 . adopting the median bolometric correction l@xmath41(1 - 10 kev)/l@xmath43 from @xcite , we find l@xmath44 erg s@xmath7 , about 40% of the fir luminosity . between 20% and 80% of the luminosity of is attributable to the obscured agn if @xmath35 . the large column density ( @xmath45 @xmath5 if @xmath46 ) inferred for suggests that the obscuring material may be compton - thick , in which case we must interpret the x - ray emission as predominantly reflected ( rather than obscured ) radiation from the central source . from the `` observed '' luminosity in table [ tab : spec ] , it follows that if the x - ray emission is due to reflection from cold gas with an albedo of 0.022 @xcite , then the nucleus in is of quasar luminosity . we can independently estimate the importance of the agn in by comparing its sub - mm - to - x - ray flux ratio with that of the ultraluminous infrared galaxy ngc 6240 , in which a highly - obscured , powerful agn dominates the bolometric luminosity @xcite . following fabian et al . ( 2000 ) , we characterize this ratio as an equivalent energy index @xmath47 , defined so that spectral flux density @xmath48 . taking @xmath49 at 850 @xmath29 m and 2 kev from table [ tab : srcpos ] , we find @xmath50 . this value is less than that expected of ngc6240 ( observed at @xmath51 ) by about a factor of 2 ( corresponding to @xmath52 ) ; see figure [ fig : andy ] . this might mean either that the fraction of scattered radiation is lower , or that the agn is relatively less luminous , in than in ngc 6240 . _ ( ): _ s99 identified the ring galaxy with , measured its redshift , reconstructed its intrinsic shape , and noted that the ring feature is indicative of interaction - induced star formation . the optical spectrum and the iso mid - ir colors led s99 to identify the source as a seyfert type 1 . from a keck lris spectrum , b99 classify it as a seyfert 1.5 . the x - ray luminosity and spectrum of this source confirm the presence of a powerful , obscured agn . applying a bolometric correction to the unabsorbed x - ray luminosity yields @xmath53 erg s@xmath7 which dominates the luminosity in the sub - mm ( b99 ) and the mid - ir @xcite . for , @xmath47 = 1.12 , which is quite comparable to the value expected if ngc6240 were observed at @xmath0 , allowing for the relatively smaller observed absorbing column in @xcite ; see figure [ fig : andy ] . two other searches with chandra for x - ray emission from sub - mm sources have yielded only upper limits or detections marginal in the sub - mm or the x - ray bands . fabian et al . ( 2000 ) report upper limits for six scuba sources in two cluster fields , with typical flux upper limits ( uncorrected for gravitational magnification ) in the deeper field of 45 @xmath54 erg s@xmath7 @xmath5 ( 27 kev ) . hornschemeier et al . ( 2000 ) report upper limits for 10 scuba sources from a very deep ( 166 ks ) chandra image containing the hubble deep field ( hdf ) , with typical upper limits 0.8 @xmath54 erg s@xmath7 @xmath5 ( 28 kev ) . given the cluster x - ray emission , we estimate our 99% confidence detection threshold for sources near the center of a370 to be about 1.5 @xmath54 erg s@xmath7 @xmath5 in the 1.57 kev band for sources with the spectrum ( @xmath3 , and no intrinsic absorption ) assumed by both groups . we must estimate the fraction of sub - mm sources that have detectable agn using a sample that has been observed to an explicit sub - mm - to - x - ray flux ratio ( i.e. , to a particular value of @xmath47 , as defined above ) . we adopt our lower limit for , viz . @xmath55 , ( as determined from the hard band flux ) . while none of the limits on @xmath47 from fabian et al . , and only one of the limits from hornschemeier et al . is this high , we note that both groups compute flux assuming @xmath3 _ and no absorption at the source_. we observe spectra much harder than this assumed model . accordingly , we recompute the previously published flux limits using a flat ( @xmath56 , unabsorbed ) spectrum , and find that the ( hardband ) x - ray flux density limits drop by about a factor of two . after making this adjustment , we find that 7 of the hdf limits are sufficiently stringent to have detected a source with @xmath57 . in this sample , then , 2 of 10 sub - mm sources ( @xmath9% where errors give the central 90 percent confidence interval for a binomial distribution ) have detectable x - ray emission . fisher s exact probability test @xcite shows that the probability of finding the observed detection rates , given the identical detection efficiency in abell 370 and the hdf , is modest ( 6.7% ) but not implausible . after this paper was submitted , severgnini et . al . ( 2000 ) reported that 1 of 9 sources detected with scuba in the hawaii sa13 field by @xcite was also detected in the chandra survey of sa13 by mushotzky et al . the detected source has @xmath58 , based on the hard - band flux , and the lower limits on @xmath47 for the other sources span @xmath59 . thus the sa13 data are not sensitive to as low an x - ray - to - sub - mm flux ratio as are ours . if we nevertheless pool these sources , together with all other chandra observations of sub - mm sources discussed above , without regard to sensitivity and including marginal detections , we find that 7 of 32 sub - mm sources have chandra counterparts . the x - ray - detected fractions in both samples are quite consistent with the predictions of alb99 , who model the ir emission of the agn which produce the diffuse x - ray background and find that 10% 20% of sources detected at 850@xmath29 m should be agn . similarly , the `` conservative '' models of gunn and shanks ( 1999 ) predict an agn fraction of 5% 15% , which is also consistent with our results . in summary , we have detected powerful , hard x - ray sources in two luminous , high - redshift sub - mm sources . both of these objects were previously known , from optical spectra , to contain agn , and in both the agn are probably responsible for a substantial fraction of the bolometric luminosity , though star formation is clearly important in . the proportion of sub - mm sources detected by chandra to date is consistent with models which synthesize the cosmic x - ray background from obscured agn at high redshift . we thank r. mushotzky for many helpful discussions , and l. cowie and a. barger for the keck image of . this work was supported by nasa under contracts nas-8 - 37716 , nas-8 - 38252 and 1797-mit - na - a-38252 . wnb acknowledges the support of nsf career grant ast-9983783 . 99 almaini , o. , lawrence , a. x. & boyle , b. j. , 1999 , , 305 , l59 ( alb99 ) arnaud , k. , 1996 , jacoby , g. & barnes , j. , eds . , astronomical data analysis software and systems v ; asp conference series , 101,17 apm website , http://www.ast.cam.ac.uk/`~`apmcat barger , a. j. , cowie , l.l . & sanders d. b. , 1999 , , 518 , l5 barger , a. j. , cowie , l.l , smail , i. , ivison , r.j . , blain , a. w. , & kneib , j .- , 1999 , , 117 , 2656 ( b99 ) blain , a. w. , smail , i. , ivison , r. j. , and kneib , j .- , 1999 , , 302 , 632 brandt , w.n . , fabian , a.c . , takahashi , k. , fujimoto , r. , yamashita , a. , inoue , h. & ogasaka , y. , 1997 , , 290 , 617 cowie , l. & barger , a. , 2000 , private communication dwek , e. , et al . , 1998 , , 508 , 106 eales , s. , lilly , s. , gear , w. , dunne , l. , bond , j. , hammer , f. , lefevre , o. & crampton , d. , 1999 , , 515 , 518 elvis , m. , wilkes , b. j. , mcdowell , j. c. , green , r. f. , bechtold , j. , willner , s.p . , oey , m.s . , polomski , e. , & cutri , r. , 1994 , , 95 , 1 fabian , a. c. , et al . 2000 , , ( submitted ) fixsen , d.j . et al . , 1998 , , 508 , 123 frayer , d.t . , ivison , r.j . , scoville , n.z . , yun , m. , evans , a.s . , smail , i. , blain , a.w . & kneib , j .- p . , 1998 , , 505 , l10 garmire , g.p . et al . , 2000 , in preparation . gunn , k. & shanks , t. , astroph/990989 hasinger , g. , astroph/0001360 hughes , d.h . et al . , 1998 , nature , 394 , 241 holland , w. s. et al . , 1999 , , 303 , 659 hornschemeier et al . , 2000 , , in press ( astroph/0004260 ) ivison , r. j. et al . , 1998 , , 298 , 583 ( i98 ) iwasawa , k. , fabian , a.c . matt , g. , 1997 , , 289 , 443 kneib , j .- mellier , y. , fort , b. & mathez , g. , 1993 , , 273 , 367 kraft , r. p. , burrows , d. n. & nousek , j. a. , 1991 , , 374 , 344 mushotzky , r. , cowie , l. , barger , a. & arnaud , k. , 2000 , nature , 404 , 459 nandra , k. , george , i. m. , mushotzky , r. f. , turner , t. j. , & yaqoob , t. , 1997 , , 477 , 602 ogasaka , y. , inoue , h. , brandt , w. n. , fabian , a. c. , kii , t. , nakagawa , t. , fujimoto , r. & otani , c. , 1997 , , 49 , 179 petrucelli , j. d. , nandram , b. & chen , m. , 1999 , _ applied statistics for engineers and scientists _ ( saddle river , nj : prentice hall ) p 682 . severgnini , p. , et al . , 2000 , , in press ; astroph/0006233 smail , i. , ivison , r.j . , blain , a.w . , 1997 , , 490 , l5 smail , i. , ivison , r.j . , blain , a.w . , & kneib , j.p . , 1998 , , 507 , l21 soucail , g. , kneib , j.p . , bezecourt , j. , metcalfe , l. , altieri , b. , & le borgne , j.f . , 1999 , , 343 , l70 ( s99 ) stark , a. a. , gammie c.p . , wilson r.w . , bally j. , linke r. , heiles c. & hurwitz m. , 1992 , , 79 , 77 turner , t.j . , george , i.m . , nandra , k. & mushotzky , r.f . , 1997 , , 113 , 23 vignali , c. , comastri , a. , cappi , m. , palumbo , g.g.c . , matsuoka , m. & kubo , h. , 1999 , , 516 , 582 vignati , p. , et al . , 1999 , , 349 , l57 l c c c c c c c smm i d & cxo name & @xmath60ra & @xmath60dec & & f@xmath61 & s@xmath62 + ( j2000 ) & ( j2000 ) & ( @xmath16 ) & ( @xmath16 ) & 1.57kev & 0.31.5kev & & + ( ) & 023951.9@xmath20013558 & 0.57 & @xmath63 & 25.1/5.9 & @xmath64/4.5 & 0.7 ( 0.4,0.9 ) & 25.3 + ( ) & 023956.6@xmath20013426 & 2.55 & @xmath65 & 115/8.1 & @xmath66/5.8 & 3.2 ( 2.7,3.7 ) & 11.0 + & & & & @xmath67 9.5/2.3 & @xmath67 7.2/3.9 & @xmath68 & 7.6 + & 1.6 & @xmath69 & & & +

we report the detection by chandra of and , two distant ( @xmath0 and @xmath1 , respectively ) submillimeter sources gravitationally magnified by the galaxy cluster abell 370 . these are high - significance ( @xmath2 ) x - ray detections of the high - redshift submillimeter source population . the x - ray positions are coincident with the optical positions to within one arcsecond . the x - ray spectra , while of low signal - to - noise ratio , are quite hard . absorbed power law models with fixed photon indices of @xmath3 imply local absorbing columns @xmath4 @xmath5 and unabsorbed luminosities @xmath6 erg s@xmath7 in both sources . these results imply that nuclear activity is responsible for the bulk of the luminosity in @xmath8 , and for at least 20% of the luminosity of , consistent with previous optical observations . we also place an upper limit on the x - ray flux of a third submillimeter source , . considered together with previously published chandra upper limits on x - ray flux from submillimeter sources , our results imply that @xmath9 % of submillimeter sources exhibit x - ray emission from agn ( 90% confidence ) , consistent with expectations of their contribution to the diffuse x - ray background .

hep-th0101156

the study of the infrared problem in quantum gravity goes mainly back to the work of weinberg @xcite who has investigated the infrared behaviour of virtual and real soft graviton emission processes . the transition amplitude for a process in which an emission of a single graviton occurs is logarithmically divergent . in the sum over an infinite number of soft gravitons emitted he claims that infrared divergencies in the transition amplitude cancel to every order of perturbation theory . in his treatment he considers virtual and real bremsstrahlung seperately . for the _ virtual _ ones he obtained in the sum over an infinte number of bremsstrahlungs processes a transition amplitude which is proportional to some power of the lower cutoff parameter @xmath0 . so this rate will vanish in the limit @xmath1 . for an infinite number of _ real _ processes he obtained a transition amplitude which is proportional to the same negative power in @xmath0 . so the cutoff disappears if virtual and real processes are combined . from our point of view we think that the problem can not be treated in this rather simple way for the following reasons . the structure of the problem is the same as in quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) . here it is well known that the infrared divergencies cancel in lowest order but in higher orders one has to deal with subdivergences in an arbitrary feynman diagram . the question of wheather or not these divergencies cancel to every order of perturbation theory is a topic which had long been investigated , see @xcite , but is still under discussion @xcite . as far as we know the cancellation of these divergencies is not at all clear . so we think that one has to investigate these processes carefully order by order . in this article we will reinvestigate the infrared problem in quantum gravity in the framework of causal perturbation theory . especially we consider the emission of a real soft graviton in two particle scattering . we use the method of adiabatic switching with a testfunction from the schwartz space which cuts off the interaction at large distances in spacetime . this makes all expressions well defined during the calculation and it turns out to be a natural infrared cutoff . we therefore avoid the introduction of a graviton mass . the latter , although widely used in the literature , is less satisfactory on physical grounds because it modifies the interaction at short distances , too . it is not at all clear that the different infrared regularizations give the same result for observable quantities . to study this question we want to calculate the differential cross section for bremsstrahlung from first principles . causal perturbation theory goes back to ideas of bogoliubov @xcite and was carefully developed by epstein and glaser @xcite in the seventies . later scharf @xcite applied it successfully to qed . the idea is to fix the first order interaction and then to construct higher orders of the scattering - matrix @xmath2 by induction using free fields only . since the free quantum fields as basic objects are operator valued distributions the scattering - matrix will be constructed as an operator valued functional on some testfunction space . the most important ingredient for the inductive construction is the causality requirement , which roughly states that the scattering - matrix of a sum of two testfunctions factorizes if the supports of the testfunctions can be separated in time . as testfunction space one considers for convenience the schwartz space of functions of rapid decrease , since this space is invariant under fourier transformation . then all expressions are well defined tempered distributions . in doing this we cut off the interaction at large but finite distances which is unphysical in most cases and has to be removed at the end . this is the so called adiabatic limit where we take the limit that the testfunction goes to a constant . in this way we investigate the long range behaviour of the theory . we consider a symmetric second rank tensor field @xmath3 , which is a solution to the wave equation , i.e. @xmath4 . all tensor indices are raised and lowered with the minkowski metric @xmath5 with components @xmath6 . we denote by @xmath7 the minkowski scalar product of two four vectors . throughout the paper equal indizes in one expression are always be properly contracted with the minkowski metric irrespective of their position . we quantize the graviton field @xmath3 by imposing the lorentz covariant commutation relations @xmath8=-ib^{{\alpha}{\beta}\mu\nu}d_0(x - y ) \label{hh}\ ] ] where the tensor @xmath9 is defined by @xmath10 and @xmath11 is the massless pauli - jordan distribution . we can write down the fourier - representation of the field @xmath12 . it is given by @xmath13 here @xmath14 and @xmath15 , @xmath16 are annihilation and creation operators on a bosonic fock - space . from ( [ hh ] ) we find that they have the following commutation relations @xmath17=b^{{\alpha}{\beta}\mu\nu}\delta^{(3)}(\vec{k}-\vec{k}^{\prime } ) \label{h - com}\ ] ] it should be emphasized that this quantization procedure is only formal in the sense that we do nt describe physical gravitons , since our @xmath12 contains too many degrees of freedom for a real gravitational field . there must be imposed further conditions like a specific gauge condition , etc . in order to obtain physical gravitons . this was done in @xcite . the massive scalar field @xmath18 obeys the klein - gordan equation @xmath19 . it has the following representation in terms of annihilation- and creation - operators : @xmath20 the energy @xmath21 is as usual given by @xmath22 . the operator @xmath23 annihilates a particle with momentum @xmath24 whereas @xmath25 creates an antiparticle with momentum @xmath24 . these operators obey the following commutation relations @xmath26 & = \delta^{(3)}(\vec{p}-\vec{p_{}}^{\prime } ) \\ \bigl[{\tilde{a}}(\vec{p}),{{\tilde{a}}(\vec{p_{}}^{\prime})}^{{\dagger}}\bigr ] & = \delta^{(3)}(\vec{p}-\vec{p_{}}^{\prime } ) \\ \end{split } \label{phi - com}\ ] ] and all the other commutators vanish . the energy - momentum tensor of @xmath18 is given by @xmath27 the interaction with the gravitational field will be described through the following first order coupling @xcite @xmath28 where @xmath29 with newton s constant @xmath30 . this leads to the following explicit form of the first order interaction @xmath31 \label{t1}\ ] ] where we have introduced the trace of the graviton field @xmath32 . for the calculation of the bremsstrahlung process we need to know the explicit form of the @xmath2-matrix up to third order in the coupling constant @xmath33 . this means that we have to construct the time - ordered product @xmath34 . according to the inductive construction of epstein and glaser we proceed by first calculating @xmath35 which will be done in the first subsection and after that we calculate the relevant terms , i.e. terms with four external scalar field operators and one graviton field operator , in the next subsection . for the construction of the time - ordered product @xmath35 we start with the first order term([t1 ] ) and apply the inductive construction due to epstein - glaser as in scharf s book @xcite . first of all we have to build the two distributions @xmath36 and @xmath37 since @xmath38 and @xmath39 are products of normally ordered field operators we apply wick s theorem to obtain a normally ordered expression . we are interested in scattering processes so we have to concentrate on terms with zero or one contraction only . the contraction of the free field operators are defined by @xmath40{.3pt}{.3em}\hrulefill \rule[-.27em]{.3pt}{.3em}\!\ , } } { \rule{0pt}{0.75em}h^{{\alpha}{\beta}}(x_1)h^{\mu\nu}}}(x_2 ) : = & -ib^{{\alpha}{\beta}\mu\nu}d^{(+)}_0(x_1-x_2)\\ { \overset{\makebox { \ , \rule[-.27em]{.3pt}{.3em}\hrulefill \rule[-.27em]{.3pt}{.3em}\!\ , } } { \rule{0pt}{0.75em}{\varphi}(x_1){\varphi}}}(x_2 ) : = & -id^{(+)}_m(x_1-x_2)\\ \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath41 is the positive frequency part of the massive pauli - jordan distribution . for the splitting operation we need the difference @xmath42 this distribution has causal support and it is given by @xmath43 \\ \end{split}\ ] ] to obtain the time - ordered product @xmath44 we have to split the numerical distribution in @xmath45 according to it s singular order ( see the appendix for the definition of the singular order ) . the singular order of the pauli - jordan distribution is @xmath46 , so the splitting is trivial and we can use the formula @xmath47 the retarded distribution @xmath48 is then given by @xmath49 if we replace all pauli - jordan distributions by the retarded ones @xmath50 . finally the time - ordered distribution @xmath35 is given by @xmath51 for later reference we give here the explicit expression @xmath52 \\ \end{split } \label{t2}\ ] ] this result will be needed in the next subsection for the calculation of @xmath53 . in the previous subsection we have calculated the distribution @xmath44([t2 ] ) from the given first order coupling @xmath54([t1 ] ) . now to obtain the time - ordered product to third order we proceed in much the same way as in the calculation of @xmath44 . we calculate the distributions @xmath55 and @xmath56 which are given by @xmath57 and @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 are defined by @xmath61 and @xmath62 it should be noticed that we only collect those terms which have two contractions involving all the spacetime points @xmath63 and @xmath64 , i.e. there is no product of contraction functions with the same argument . after we have built the causal difference @xmath65 we split the numerical part into @xmath66 with support in the backward light cone and @xmath67 with support in the forward light cone . the time - ordered distribution @xmath53 is then given by @xmath68 because the calculation is staightforward and not very enlightning we give only the result @xmath69\\ & \ \times b^{{\alpha}{\beta}{\gamma}{\varepsilon}}d^f_0(x_{\pi(2)}-x_{\pi(3)})\partial^{x_{\pi(3)}}_{{\beta}}\partial^{x_{\pi(1)}}_{{\rho}}d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\\ & \ + 4m^2\bigl[:h^{{\rho}{\sigma}}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\rho}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\alpha}}}:\\ & \ + : h^{{\rho}{\sigma}}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\rho}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\alpha}}}:\bigr]\\ & \ \times d^f_0(x_{\pi(2)}-x_{\pi(3)})\partial^{x_{\pi(3)}}_{{\alpha}}\partial^{x_{\pi(1)}}_{{\sigma}}d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\\ & \ + 4m^2\bigl[:h^{{\rho}{\sigma}}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\rho}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\varepsilon}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\varepsilon}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)}):\\ & \ + : h^{{\rho}{\sigma}}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\rho}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\varepsilon}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\varepsilon}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})^{{\dagger}}:\bigr]\\ & \ \times d^f_0(x_{\pi(3)}-x_{\pi(2)})\partial^{x_{\pi(1)}}_{{\sigma}}d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\\ & \ + 4m^2\bigl[:h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\gamma}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\varepsilon}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\beta}}}:\\ & \ + : h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\gamma}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\varepsilon}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\beta}}}:\bigr]\\ & \ \times b^{{\alpha}{\beta}{\gamma}{\varepsilon}}d^f_0(x_{\pi(3)}-x_{\pi(2)})\partial^{x_{\pi(3)}}_{{\alpha}}d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\\ & \ + 2m^4\bigl[:h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\gamma}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\gamma}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)}):\\ & \ + : h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\gamma}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\gamma}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})^{{\dagger}}:\bigr]\\ & \ \times d^f_0(x_{\pi(3)}-x_{\pi(2)})d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\\ & \ + 2m^4\bigl[:h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\beta}}}:\\ & \ + : h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\beta}}}:\bigr]\\ & \ \times d^f_0(x_{\pi(3)}-x_{\pi(2)})\partial^{x_{\pi(3)}}_{{\beta}}d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\\ & \ + 8m^4\bigl[:h^{{\rho}{\sigma}}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})^{{\dagger}}_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\rho}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)}):\\ & \ + : h^{{\rho}{\sigma}}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})_{{{^{\scriptstyle{,}}\!\rho}}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})^{{\dagger}}:\bigr]\\ & \ \times d^f_0(x_{\pi(3)}-x_{\pi(2)})\partial^{x_{\pi(1)}}_{{\sigma}}d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\\ & \ + 4m^6\bigl[:h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)}):\\ & \ + : h(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(1)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)})^{{\dagger}}{\varphi}(x_{\pi(2)}){\varphi}(x_{\pi(3)})^{{\dagger}}:\bigr]\\ & \ \times d^f_0(x_{\pi(3)}-x_{\pi(2)})d^f_m(x_{\pi(1)}-x_{\pi(3)})\biggr]\\ \end{split } \label{t3}\ ] ] due to the sum over all permutations of the indices this expression for @xmath53 is obviously symmetric in it s arguments as it is required by the definition of the time - ordered product . the third order @xmath2-matrix for the bremsstrahlungs processes is then given by @xmath70 in the preceeding section we have shown explicitly the construction of the time - ordered product to second and to third order . the @xmath2-matrix to third order was given by ( [ s - matrix ] ) . now we consider the scattering process of two massive scalar particles in which a bremsstrahlungs graviton is emited in the final state . that is we want to calculate the expectation value of @xmath71 between the following initial and final states @xmath72 these are wave packets in momentum space where @xmath73 are one particle wave functions from @xmath74 , @xmath75 is a two particle wave function from @xmath76 and @xmath77 is a tensor - valued square integrable wave function on @xmath78 . the vector @xmath79 is the vacuum vector in the asymptotic fock - hilbert space . we want to calculate the following @xmath2-matrix element : @xmath80 to show the details of the calculation we restrict ourself to the following term from the above computed @xmath53 ( [ t3 ] ) @xmath81 where the @xmath82 refers to this particular term of @xmath53 . the @xmath2-matrix element corresponding to this contribution is then given by @xmath83 then we have to compute the vacuum expectation value @xmath84 this can easily be evaluated by inserting the fourier representations of the free field operators ( [ h - field ] ) and ( [ phi - field ] ) and the use of the commutation relations in momentum space ( [ h - com]),([phi - com ] ) . the result is given by @xmath85\,p_1^{{\beta}}\,q_2^{{\rho}}\,p_2^{{\gamma}}\,q_1^{{\varepsilon } } \\ & + \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-q_1x_3+q_2x_1+p_2x_2-p_1x_2)\bigr]\,q_1^{{\beta}}\,q_2^{{\rho}}\,p_2^{{\gamma}}\,p_1^{{\varepsilon}}\\ & + \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-p_1x_3+p_2x_1+q_2x_2-q_1x_2)\bigr]\,p_1^{{\beta}}\,p_2^{{\rho}}\,q_2^{{\gamma}}\,q_1^{{\varepsilon}}\\ & + \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-q_1x_3+p_2x_1+q_2x_2-p_1x_2)\bigr]\,q_1^{{\beta}}\,p_2^{{\rho}}\,q_2^{{\gamma}}\,p_1^{{\varepsilon}}\bigr]\\ \end{split}\ ] ] the @xmath2-matrix element then reads @xmath86\,p_1^{{\beta}}\,q_2^{{\rho}}\,p_2^{{\gamma}}\,q_1^{{\varepsilon } } \\ & + \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-q_1x_3+q_2x_1+p_2x_2-p_1x_2)\bigr]\,q_1^{{\beta}}\,q_2^{{\rho}}\,p_2^{{\gamma}}\,p_1^{{\varepsilon}}\\ & + \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-p_1x_3+p_2x_1+q_2x_2-q_1x_2)\bigr]\,p_1^{{\beta}}\,p_2^{{\rho}}\,q_2^{{\gamma}}\,q_1^{{\varepsilon}}\\ & + \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-q_1x_3+p_2x_1+q_2x_2-p_1x_2)\bigr]\,q_1^{{\beta}}\,p_2^{{\rho}}\,q_2^{{\gamma}}\,p_1^{{\varepsilon}}\bigr]\\ \end{split } \label{sfi3}\ ] ] we introduce the abbreviations @xmath87 for the four parts of @xmath88 . then we consider the spatial integrations in @xmath89 . they can be carried out by inserting the fourier transforms of the testfunctions as well as the feynman propagators : @xmath90\\ = & \ ( 2\pi)^{-10}\int d^4x_1\ldots d^4x_3d^4l_1\ldots d^4l_5\hat{g}(l_1)\ldots\hat{g}(l_3)\exp\bigl[-i(l_1x_1+l_2x_2+l_3x_3)\bigr ] \\ & \ \hat{d}^f_0(l_4)\exp\bigl[-il_4(x_2-x_3)\bigr]\partial^{x_3}_{{\alpha}}\partial^{x_1}_{{\sigma}}\hat{d}^f_m(l_5)\exp\bigl[-il_5(x_1-x_3)\bigr ] \\ & \ \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-p_1x_3+q_2x_1+p_2x_2-q_1x_2)\bigr]\\ = & \ ( 2\pi)^{-10}\int d^4x_1\ldots d^4x_3d^4l_1\ldots d^4l_5\hat{g}(l_1)\ldots\hat{g}(l_3)\exp\bigl[-i(l_1x_1+l_2x_2+l_3x_3)\bigr ] \\ & \ \exp\bigl[-il_4(x_2-x_3)\bigr]l_5^{{\alpha}}l_5^{{\sigma}}\hat{d}^f_m(l_5)\exp\bigl[-il_5(x_1-x_3)\bigr ] \\ & \ \exp\bigl[+i(kx_1-p_1x_3+q_2x_1+p_2x_2-q_1x_2)\bigr]\\ = & \ ( 2\pi)^2\int d^4l_1\ldots d^4l_5\hat{g}(l_1)\ldots\hat{g}(l_3)\hat{d}^f_0(l_4)l_5^{{\alpha}}l_5^{{\sigma}}\hat{d}^f_m(l_5)\delta^{(4)}(l_1+l_5-k - q_2 ) \\ & \ \delta^{(4)}(l_2+l_4-p_2+q_1)\delta^{(4)}(l_3-l_4-l_5+p_1)\\ \end{split } \label{i1}\ ] ] we can do the integrations w.r.t . @xmath91 and @xmath92 immediately and get @xmath93[-l_1^{{\sigma}}-p_1^{{\sigma}}+k^{{\sigma}}+q_2^{{\sigma}}]\hat{d}^f_m(-l_1+k+q_2)\\ & \ \delta^{(4)}(l_1+l_2+l_3+p_1+q_1-q_2-p_2-k)\\ \end{split}\ ] ] then the first term of @xmath94 becomes @xmath95[-l_1^{{\sigma}}-p_1^{{\sigma}}+k^{{\sigma}}+q_2^{{\sigma}}]\hat{d}^f_m(-l_1+k+q_2)\\ & \ b^{\mu\nu{\rho}{\sigma}}p_1^{{\beta}}q_2^{{\rho}}p_2^{{\gamma}}q_1^{{\varepsilon}}\bigl(32\omega(\vec{k})\omega(\vec{p}_1)\omega(\vec{p}_2)\omega(\vec{q}_1 ) \omega(\vec{q_2})\bigr)^{-1/2}\\ & \ \delta^{(4)}(l_1+l_2+l_3+p_1+q_1-q_2-p_2-k)\\ = & \ ( 2\pi)^{-15/2}i\kappa^3\int d^3\vec{p}_1d^3\vec{q_1}d^3\vec{k}d^3\vec{p}_2d^3\vec{q}_2\hat{\psi}_1(\vec{p}_1)\hat{\psi}_2(\vec{q}_1 ) \hat{\psi}(\vec{p}_2,\vec{q}_2)\hat{\phi}^{\mu\nu}(\vec{k})\\ & \ \int d^4l_1\ldots d^4l_3\hat{g}(l_1)\ldots\hat{g}(l_3)b^{{\alpha}{\beta}{\gamma}{\varepsilon}}\frac{-l_1^{{\alpha}}-p_1^{{\alpha}}+k^{{\alpha}}+q_2^{{\alpha}}}{(l_1+l_3+p_1-k - q_2)^2+i0 } b^{\mu\nu{\rho}{\sigma}}\\ & \ \frac{-l_1^{{\sigma}}-p_1^{{\sigma}}+k^{{\sigma}}+q_2^{{\sigma}}}{m^2-(-l_1+k+q_2)^2-i0}p_1^{{\beta}}q_2^{{\rho}}p_2^{{\gamma}}q_1^{{\varepsilon}}\bigl(32\omega(\vec{k } ) \omega(\vec{p}_1)\omega(\vec{p}_2)\omega(\vec{q}_1)\omega(\vec{q_2})\bigr)^{-1/2}\\ & \ \delta^{(4)}(l_1+l_2+l_3+p_1+q_1-q_2-p_2-k)\\ \end{split } \label{sfi4}\ ] ] where we have inserted the propagators explicitely . in this expression we can carry out the adiabatic limit in the variable @xmath96 since it does nt appear in the argument of the propagators . we do this in the following way . first of all we choose a fixed testfunction @xmath97 with the property @xmath98 . then a new testfunction is defined by @xmath99 the adiabatic limit @xmath100 is then equivalent to the limit @xmath101 . the fourier transform of @xmath102 is given by @xmath103 then we have @xmath104 using this in ( [ sfi4 ] ) the integration w.r.t . @xmath96 gives just the factor @xmath105 . we are interested in the @xmath2-matrix element in the limit where only gravitons at low momenta ( soft gravitons ) are emited . so we omit all small quantities in the numerators , and we take only the leading singularities in the denominators . this is known as the eikonal approximation in the literature , see e.g. @xcite . with this approximation we obtain for the argument of the massless propagator @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the scaling parameter from the adiabatic limit . the argument of the massive propagator becomes @xmath108 since the momentum @xmath109 is on the mass shell . then the @xmath2-matrix element becomes @xmath110 now the adiabatic limit in @xmath111 can be done as above and we arrive at the result for the @xmath2-matrix element @xmath112 there remains to calculate the other three parts @xmath113 . the calculations are similiar to the one above so we only present the results @xmath114 now we are ready to consider the differential cross section . this will be done in detail in the next subsection . we have to calculate the absolute square of the @xmath2-matrix element @xmath94 . we do this again separately for the four parts @xmath116 . for the first part we start with ( [ sfi6 ] ) and write @xmath117 where a @xmath118 indicates complex conjugation . we use the completeness relations of the final states , i.e. @xmath119 where the sum is taken over all final states . then we have @xmath120 now we assume that the wavefunctions @xmath121 and @xmath122 are sharply concentrated around the initial momenta @xmath123 and @xmath124 , so that we can replace the momenta in the propagators by these initial momenta . then the expression can be simplified to @xmath125^{-1}\\ & \ \int d^3\vec{p}_1d^3\vec{q}_1d^3\vec{p_1}^{\prime}d^3\vec{q_1}^{\prime}\hat{\psi}_1(\vec{p}_1)\hat{\psi}_2(\vec{q_1 } ) \hat{\psi}_1(\vec{p_1}^{\prime})^{\ast}\hat{\psi}_2(\vec{q_1}^{\prime})^{\ast}\\ & \ \delta^{(4)}(l_1+p_1+q_1-q_2-p_2-k)\delta^{(4)}(l_2+p_1^{\prime}+q_1^{\prime}-q_2-p_2-k)\\ \end{split } \label{sigma3}\ ] ] we observe that the last integral herein depends on the initial state only . we denote it by @xmath126 , where we have introduced @xmath127 . we have @xmath128\exp\bigl[+i(l_2+p_1^{\prime}+q_1^{\prime}-p)y_2\bigr]\\ = & \ \int d^4y_1d^4y_2\psi_1(y_1)\psi_2(y_1)\psi_1(y_2)^{\ast}\psi_2(y_2)^{\ast}\exp[-il_1y_1]\exp[+il_2y_2]\\ & \ \exp\bigl[-i(y_1-y_2)p\bigr]\\ \end{split}\ ] ] the function @xmath129 is normalized according to @xmath130\ ] ] and it is concentrated around @xmath131 . in the limit of infintely sharp wave packets we may represent it by @xmath132\ ] ] this will be inserted in ( [ sigma3 ] ) and we obtain @xmath133^{-1}\\ & \ \delta^{(4)}(p_2+q_2+k - p_i - q_i)\int d^4y|\psi_1(y)|^2|\psi_2(y)|^2\exp\bigl[-i(l_1-l_2)y\bigr]\\ \end{split } \label{sigma4}\ ] ] for the definition of the cross section we follow sect . 3.4 of @xcite . we can set @xmath134 in the last integral because we neglect all contributions @xmath135 in the numerator , see the remarks after ( [ sfi4 ] ) . with the notation as in @xcite we define the cross section as @xmath136 where @xmath137 is the radius of the beam of incoming particles . then we restrict ourself again to ( [ t3term1 ] ) of @xmath53 and furthermore to the first integral @xmath89 ( [ i1 ] ) of @xmath138 . if we denote the integration variables @xmath139 and @xmath109 by @xmath140 and @xmath141 , respectively , then we obtain for the cross section @xmath142^{-1}\frac{\omega(\vec{p_i})\omega(\vec{q_i})}{\sqrt{\bigl((p_iq_i)^2-m^4\bigr)}}\int d^4l_1d^4l_2\hat{g}(l_1)\hat{g}(l_2)^{\ast}\\ & \ \int\frac{d^3\vec{k}}{2\omega(\vec{k})}\frac{d^3\vec{q_f}}{2\omega(\vec{q_f})}\frac{d^3\vec{p_f}}{2\omega(\vec{p_f})}b^{{\alpha}{\beta}{\gamma}{\varepsilon}}\frac{(q_f^{{\alpha}}- p_i^{{\alpha}})}{(q_f - p_i)^2}\frac{(q_f^{{\rho}}-p_i^{{\rho}})}{2q_f(l_1-k)}p_i^{{\beta}}q_f^{{\rho}}p_f^{{\gamma}}q_i^{{\varepsilon}}b^{{\alpha}^{\prime}{\beta}^{\prime}{\gamma}^{\prime}{\varepsilon}^{\prime}}\\ & \ \frac{(q_f^{{\alpha}^{\prime}}-p_i^{{\alpha}^{\prime}})}{(q_f - p_i)^2}\frac{(q_f^{{\rho}^{\prime}}-p_i^{{\rho}^{\prime}})}{2q_f(l_2-k)}p_i^{{\beta}^{\prime}}q_f^{{\rho}^{\prime } } p_f^{{\gamma}^{\prime}}q_i^{{\varepsilon}^{\prime}}\delta^{(3)}(\vec{p_f}+\vec{q_f}+\vec{k}-\vec{p_i}-\vec{q_i})\\ & \ \delta(\omega(\vec{p_f})+\omega(\vec{q_f})+\omega(\vec{k})-\omega(\vec{p_i})-\omega(\vec{q_i}))\\ \end{split}\ ] ] to carry out the remainig integrations we have to know the integrand explicitely . so at this point of the calculation the tensor structure of the integrand becomes important and we have to write down the various contractions between the four - vectors @xmath143 . with the tensor @xmath144 ( [ b - tensor ] ) we get for the cross section @xmath145\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f})^2 -\vec{q_f}^2\bigr)\\ & -\bigl[\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_f})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_f}\bigr)(p_iq_i)-\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i } ) { \omega}(\vec{p_f})-\vec{p_i}\vec{p_f}\bigr)\\ & + \bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})-\vec{p_f}\vec{q_i}\bigr)+\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{p_f})- \vec{p_i}\vec{p_f}\bigr)(p_iq_i)\\ & + ( p_iq_i)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{p_f})-\vec{p_i}\vec{p_f}\bigr)-p_i^2\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})-\vec{p_f}\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigr]\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f } ) { \omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\biggr]^2\\ & \ \frac{\delta^{(3)}(\vec{p_f}+\vec{q_f}+\vec{k}-\vec{p_i}-\vec{q_i})\delta(\omega(\vec{p_f})+\omega(\vec{q_f})+\omega(\vec{k})-\omega(\vec{p_i } ) -\omega(\vec{q_i}))}{(q_f - p_i)^22q_f(l_1-k)(q_f - p_i)^22q_f(l_2-k)}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] it is convenient to choose the center - of - mass system , defined by @xmath146 . we can easily do the integration w.r.t . @xmath147 : @xmath148\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f})^2-\vec{q_f}^2\bigr ) -\bigl[\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\\ & + \vec{q_f}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)(p_iq_i)-\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k } ) + \vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)\\ & + \bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})+(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\vec{q_i}\bigr)+\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i } ) { \omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\\ & + \vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)(p_iq_i)+(p_iq_i)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})+\vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)\\ & -p_i^2\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})+(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigr]\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\biggr]^2\\ & \ \frac{\delta({\omega}(\vec{q_f})+{\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})+{\omega}(\vec{k})-2{\omega}(\vec{p_i}))}{(q_f - p_i)^22q_f(l_1-k)(q_f - p_i)^22q_f(l_2-k)}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] now we are left with the integration w.r.t . @xmath149 . in order to be able to do this we have to rewrite the argument of the delta distribution showing the dependence on @xmath150 explicitely . we want to use the formula @xmath151 where the @xmath152 are simple zeros of the function @xmath153 . for that purpose we define @xmath154 where @xmath155 and we have used the notation @xmath156 . in order to simplify the notation in the following formulas we write @xmath157 . the zeros of the function @xmath153 are given by @xmath158 where we have introduced @xmath159 clearly these solutions are itself functions of the momentum @xmath160 and the angle @xmath161 . if we consider the limit of these functions ( [ zeros ] ) as @xmath160 goes to zero we obtain @xmath162 where @xmath163 . the derivative of @xmath153 with respect to @xmath164 is given by @xmath165 by inserting the two zeros of @xmath153 into ( [ fprime ] ) we observe that , by taking the limit @xmath166 , we get a finite result , namely @xmath167 now we can rewrite the cross section as @xmath168\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f})^2-\vec{q_f}^2\bigr ) -\bigl[\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\\ & + \vec{q_f}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)(p_iq_i)-\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k } ) + \vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)\\ & + \bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})+(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\vec{q_i}\bigr)+\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i } ) { \omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\\ & + \vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)(p_iq_i)+(p_iq_i)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})+\vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)\\ & -p_i^2\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})+(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigr]\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\biggr]^2\\ & \ \frac{1}{(q_f - p_i)^22q_f(l_1-k)(q_f - p_i)^22q_f(l_2-k)}\sum_{j=1}^{2}\frac{1}{\lvert f^{\prime}({\mathsf{q_f}})\rvert_{{\mathsf{q_f}}={\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)}}\rvert } \delta({\mathsf{q_f}}-{\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)})\\ \end{split}\ ] ] before we do the integration w.r.t . @xmath164 let us denote by @xmath169 the expression which comes from the tensor part in the numerator , i.e. @xmath170\\ & \ \bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f})^2-\vec{q_f}^2\bigr)-\bigl[\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})+\vec{q_f}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr ) \ ( p_iq_i)-\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f})\\ & \ { \omega}(\vec{q_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})+\vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr ) + \bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\\ & \ \bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k}){\omega}(\vec{q_i})+(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\vec{q_i}\bigr)+\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k } ) + \vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)\\ & \ ( p_iq_i)+(p_iq_i)\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\omega}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})+\vec{p_i}(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\bigr)-p_i^2\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f } + \vec{k})\\ & \ { \omega}(\vec{q_i})+(\vec{q_f}+\vec{k})\vec{q_i}\bigr)\bigr]\bigl({\omega}(\vec{q_f}){\omega}(\vec{p_i})-\vec{q_f}\vec{p_i}\bigr)\biggr]^2\\ \end{split}\ ] ] then the expression for the cross section is given by @xmath171 from this expression we can identify the differential cross section @xmath172 . we do the @xmath164-integration and obtain @xmath173}\\ & \ \frac{1}{2\bigl[\sqrt{({\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)})^2+m^2}l_2 ^ 0-{\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)}{\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}-\sqrt{({\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)})^2+m^2}{\mathsf{k}}+{\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j ) } { \mathsf{k}}\cos\theta\bigr]}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] where we have introduced @xmath174 in the next step we omit all small quantities in the numerator , and we set @xmath175 in the denominators if there occur no singularities . then the expression can be simplified to @xmath176}\\ & \ \frac{1}{2\bigl[{\omega}(\vec{p_i})l_2 ^ 0-{\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)}|_{{\mathsf{k}}=0}{\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}-{\omega}(\vec{p_i}){\mathsf{k}}+{\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)}|_{{\mathsf{k}}=0}{\mathsf{k } } \cos\theta\bigr]}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] now one observes that the function @xmath177 is independent of @xmath178 and depends only on the initial momenta @xmath123 and @xmath124 so we can take it outside the integral . then we get @xmath179}\\ & \ \frac{1}{2\bigl[{\omega}(\vec{p_i})(l_2 ^ 0-{\mathsf{k}})-{\mathsf{q_f}}^{(j)}|_{{\mathsf{k}}=0}({\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}-{\mathsf{k } } \cos\theta)\bigr]}\\ \end{split } \label{dsdo}\ ] ] where the function @xmath180 is given by @xmath181 if we use ( [ limitqf ] ) we can write the differential cross section in the form @xmath182\bigl[{\omega}(\vec{p_i})(l_2 ^ 0 -{\mathsf{k}})-{\mathsf{p_i}}({\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}-{\mathsf{k}}\cos\theta)\bigr]}\\ & + f_2(-{\mathsf{p_i}})\int\frac{d^3\vec{k}}{2{\omega}(\vec{k})}\\ & \ \frac{1}{\bigl[{\omega}(\vec{p_i})(l_1 ^ 0-{\mathsf{k}})+{\mathsf{p_i}}({\mathsf{l_1}}\cos{\beta}-{\mathsf{k}}\cos\theta)\bigr]\bigl[{\omega}(\vec{p_i})(l_2 ^ 0 -{\mathsf{k}})+{\mathsf{p_i}}({\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}-{\mathsf{k}}\cos\theta)\bigr]}\biggr]\\ \end{split } \label{diffcrosssec}\ ] ] in order to do the integration w.r.t . @xmath183 we use an identity due to feynman @xmath184 ^ 2},\ a , b\in \mathbb{c}\ ] ] we consider the first term in ( [ diffcrosssec ] ) . then we define the functions @xmath185 and @xmath186 by @xmath187 \\ \bigl[{\omega}(\vec{p_i})(l_2 ^ 0-{\mathsf{k}})-{\mathsf{p_i}}({\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}-{\mathsf{k}}\cos\theta)\bigr ] \\ \end{split } \label{ab}\ ] ] the integral becomes @xmath188 ^ 2}\\ = & \ \frac{2\pi}{2}\int{\mathsf{k}}d{\mathsf{k}}\int_0 ^ 1dx\int_{-1}^{+1}\frac{d\cos\theta}{\bigl[ax+b(1-x)\bigr]^2}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] we insert @xmath185 and @xmath186 and obtain @xmath189 ^ 2}\\ \end{split } \label{theta - int}\ ] ] we set @xmath190 and we observe that the integral w.r.t . @xmath191 is of the form @xmath192 see @xcite , where we ve set @xmath193 then we obtain for ( [ theta - int ] ) @xmath194 where @xmath195 and @xmath196 are given by @xmath197\\ b(l_1,l_2,x ) = & \ \bigl[\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i})l_1 ^ 0-{\mathsf{p_i}}{\mathsf{l_1}}\cos{\beta}\bigr)x+\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i})l_2 ^ 0-{\mathsf{p_i}}{\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}\bigr)(1-x)\bigr]^2\\ \end{split}\ ] ] then this integral w.r.t . @xmath160 is of the form @xmath198 where the constants @xmath199 are given by @xmath200 in our case the discriminant @xmath201 is given by @xmath202 ^ 2\\ & -4{\omega}(\vec{p_i})^2\bigl[\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i})l_1 ^ 0-{\mathsf{p_i}}{\mathsf{l_1}}\cos{\beta}\bigr)x+\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i})l_2 ^ 0-{\mathsf{p_i}}{\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}\bigr)(1-x)\bigr]^2\\ = & \ -4{\mathsf{p_i}}^2\bigl[\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i})l_1 ^ 0-{\mathsf{p_i}}{\mathsf{l_1}}\cos{\beta}\bigr)x+\bigl({\omega}(\vec{p_i})l_2 ^ 0-{\mathsf{p_i}}{\mathsf{l_2}}\cos{\gamma}\bigr)(1-x)\bigr]^2\\ \end{split}\ ] ] so we see that @xmath203 . then the integral ( [ bs44 ] ) is given by @xmath204\ ] ] here we consider gravitons up to an energy @xmath205 which is much smaller than the energy of the incident particles . since every real detector has a finite energy resolution below which he can not detect any particles we have to integrate over all these contributions up to the value @xmath205 . then the final result of the @xmath160-integration is given by the following expression @xmath206\\ \end{split}\ ] ] the second term in ( [ diffcrosssec ] ) can be treated in the same way . the only difference is the sign of @xmath207 in the definition of the functions @xmath185 and @xmath186 , see ( [ ab ] ) , which has no consequences for the calculation of the integrals ( [ bs1 ] ) and ( [ bs44 ] ) . in the preceeding subsection we ve found the differential cross section for bremsstrahlung in a scattering process of two massive scalar particles . now we want to discuss the adiabatic limit . for the differential cross section we ve found @xmath208\\ \end{split } \label{diffcrosssec1}\ ] ] where @xmath209 and @xmath210 . this expression , as it stands , is well defined and finite due to the presence of the testfunctions . to obtain a physically relevant result we have to remove this cutoff and therefore test the infrared behaviour of ( [ diffcrosssec1 ] ) . we will show below that part of this expression becomes singular in the adiabatic limit . in the adiabatic limit in momentum space we let the testfunctions tend to a delta distribution in it s argument . this will be done in the same way as in subsection 5.1 , see ( [ adia ] ) . we scale the argument of the testfunctions with a parameter @xmath107 in the integrals of ( [ diffcrosssec1 ] ) and consider the limit @xmath101 . the functions @xmath211 and @xmath212 are homogeneous of degree 2 in the variables @xmath213 and @xmath96 , i.e. @xmath214 while the function @xmath215 is homogeneous of degree 1 , i.e. @xmath216 . with this in mind let us now look at the various logarithms in ( [ diffcrosssec1 ] ) . the argument of the first logarithm contains the constant @xmath217 so it stays finite if @xmath107 goes to zero . the constant in front of the second and the fourth logarithm has equal powers of @xmath107 in the numerator as well as in the denominator so it tends to a constant . the argument of the second logarithm goes to one , so the logarithm itself goes to zero and the fourth goes to another constant . it remains to consider the third logarithm . this one becomes singular in the adiabatic limit . this can be seen as follows : @xmath218 ^ 2\biggr)\\ & + \text{finite terms}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] if we concentrate on the singular part only we obtain by inserting the scaled testfunctions @xmath219 where we ve introduced @xmath220 . so we get a logarithmic divergence if @xmath107 tends to zero . the origin of this singularity is the massless graviton propagator as can be clearly seen from the above calculation . since all the other terms in ( [ t3 ] ) have the same structure of propagators we would get the same logarihmic divergence as in our example . furthermore there can be no cancellation between these terms since they all have a positive sign . so we can omit the discussion of the other terms . this result is similar to the case of quantum electrodynamics @xcite where a logarithmic divergence in the differential cross section was obtained as well in the bremsstrahlung contribution to the scattering of an electron due to an external classical source . as is well known from qed , the infrared divergence in the bremsstrahlung must cancel against contributions from radiative corrections , otherwise scattering theory would break down . in this appendix we give the definition of the singular order @xmath221 of a numerical distribution @xmath222 . the singular order measures the singularity of the distribution @xmath223 at the origin @xcite . let @xmath222 be given . then the distribution @xmath223 has scaling degree @xmath224 at @xmath225 , if @xmath226 the singular order is then defined by @xmath227 - 4 $ ] , where @xmath228 $ ] is the greatest integer less or equal to @xmath224 . it s an easy excercise to see that differentiation increases the singular order of a distribution , i.e. @xmath229 where @xmath230 for every multi - index @xmath231 with @xmath232 .

in the framework of causal perturbation theory we consider a massive scalar field coupled to gravity . in the field theoretic approach to quantum gravity ( qg ) we start with a massless second rank tensor field . this tensor field is then quantized in a covariant way in minkowski space . this article deals with the adiabatic limit for graviton radiative corrections in a scattering process of two massive scalar particles . we compute the differential cross - section for bremsstrahlung processes in which one of the outgoing particles emits a graviton of low energy , a so called soft graviton . since the emited graviton will not be detected we have to integrate over all soft gravitons .

gr-qc0604034

in the past year there has been remarkable progress in the field of numerical relativity , particularly in the simulation of binary black hole systems . some of today s codes are capable of tracking the holes for many orbits before the merger and ringdown @xcite . since a primary goal of numerical relativity is the production of gravitational wave templates associated with the merger of black holes , it is important to simultaneously make progress with the tools which allow for their accurate generation and extraction . the schemes which have been able to push forward the binary black hole problem either use spatial compactification @xcite , which brings spatial infinity at a finite coordinate location , or mesh refinement @xcite , which allows the boundary to be placed further out by using lower resolution far away from the strong field region . a limitation of both methods is that the number of grid - points per wavelength gradually diminishes as the radiation propagates away from the sources and therefore the quality of the gravitational radiation progressively deteriorates , forcing the extraction to occur at a relatively small distance from the final hole extracted at @xmath1 and @xmath2 done by baker _ @xcite seems to indicate that the extraction at small distances leads to sufficiently accurate results . ] . the undesirable effect of a time - like boundary with a chronological future that intersects the region of interest ( where physical quantities are calculated ) , was highlighted in @xcite . to improve the quality of the outgoing radiation one should aim to keep the coordinate distance that the waves have to travel to a minimum , without making their speed go to zero . this can be achieved , for example , by employing asymptotically null slices @xcite , or by supplementing the cauchy evolution with a characteristic code @xcite , which extends all the way to infinity . see figures [ fig : conformal1 ] , [ fig : conformal2 ] , and [ fig : conformal3 ] . both methods resolve incoming waves poorly at very large distances , but these are not expected to be significant . the reason for not using a single characteristic evolution scheme , without a cauchy interior covering the strong field region , is that such a scheme tends to develop caustics , where neighbouring characteristics focus and the coordinate system breaks down . and @xmath3 ( the initial and final time ) , and a time - like artificial boundary @xmath4 . since it is not known how to specify local boundary conditions which do not introduce spurious radiation or reflect outgoing waves , the accuracy of the solution is limited to the future domain of dependence of @xmath5 ( green region ) . the solution in the grey region , which is causally connected to the boundary , is inaccurate . in this situation one is forced to extract gravitational radiation relatively close to the sources.,width=377 ] can be placed far away from the sources and is approximately null ( the incoming modes travel very slowly ) . gravitational radiation can be accurately extracted at much larger distances and with lower computational cost than with standard space - like slices . see table i of @xcite for a comparison of computational costs and errors with different slices.,width=377 ] ( future null infinity ) , where the radiation is unambiguously defined . initial data is specified at @xmath5 and @xmath6 and the two schemes are connected by a time - like interface @xmath7 . although in principle one could use the asymptotically null approach up to null infinity , experiments with the wave equation in spherical symmetry suggest that the scheme is less effective than that which uses a time - like boundary at very large distances @xcite.,width=377 ] in this work we describe a fourth order accurate algorithm for the axisymmetric massless klein - gordon scalar field around a schwarzschild black hole , which employs a cauchy evolution scheme , based on space - like slices , and a characteristic scheme , based on null slices . the outer boundary of the interior cauchy region is a time - like surface and coincides with the inner boundary of the characteristic region . communication between the two regions is done taking into account the propagation of the characteristic variables . at the discrete level the interface is implemented with touching grids . we find that when the slices are not simultaneous , this particular multi - grid approach is better suited than overlapping grids , as it avoids complications due to causality . the radial coordinate of the characteristic region is compactified in order to reach future null infinity . the paper is organised as follows . in section [ sec : continuum ] we describe the continuum scalar field initial - boundary value problem in the cauchy and characteristic regions and discuss the interface treatment . in section [ sec : discrete ] we provide details of the discretization method and in section [ sec : tests ] we describe the tests carried out to validate the code , including the simulation of the late - time tail decay . in this section we describe the continuum problem , giving the explicit form of the equations , and the interface treatment . the schwarzschild line element in kerr - schild coordinates takes the form @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the mass of the black hole and @xmath10 . the surface defined by @xmath11 is null and its normal , provided it belongs to the future null cone , points toward increasing values of @xmath12 . it is convenient to introduce the shorthand @xmath13 . using @xmath14 , in the cauchy region the wave equation on the schwarzschild background , @xmath15 , takes the form @xmath16 in bondi coordinates the schwarzschild line element is @xmath17 and it is related to ( [ eq : ks ] ) via the coordinate transformation @xmath18 which implies @xmath19 where there is no cause for confusion we will not distinguish between @xmath20 and @xmath21 . the klein - gordon equation in the characteristic region becomes @xmath22 note the lack of second partial derivatives @xmath23 , reflecting the fact that the @xmath24 surface is characteristic . we focus on axisymmetric solutions of the equations ( [ eq : wavecauchy ] ) and ( [ eq : wavechar ] ) , as we do not expect additional difficulties to arise in the general 3-dimensional case . this implies @xmath25 and regularity demands that , across the axis @xmath26 and @xmath27 , the scalar field is an even function of @xmath28 . since the discretization of second order systems tends to be more subtle than that of fully first order systems @xcite , we perform a reduction to first order and discretise the resulting system . in the cauchy region we introduce the auxiliary variables @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 . the reduced system is @xmath32 we also have the constraint @xmath33 , which propagates with zero speed and therefore does not introduce complications at the boundary . this system is symmetrizable hyperbolic provided that @xmath34 @xcite . it has non trivial characteristic speeds @xmath35 and @xmath36 in the radial direction and the corresponding characteristic variables are @xmath37 to reduce equation ( [ eq : wavechar ] ) to first order we introduce @xmath38 , @xmath39 and @xmath40 . the reason for this choice of auxiliary variables is that @xmath41 and @xmath42 are null vectors . we will refer to @xmath43 and @xmath44 as null variables . the reduced system is @xmath45 to reach @xmath46 we compactify the characteristic radial coordinate @xmath47 by introducing a new independent variable @xmath48 such that @xmath49 in the last equation @xmath50 and @xmath51 represent the location of the interface boundary in the cauchy and characteristic coordinate systems , respectively . the surface @xmath52 corresponds to future null infinity . effectively , this amounts to replacing in system ( [ eq : reduced1])([eq : reduced4 ] ) the partial derivatives with respect to @xmath47 with @xmath53 there are coefficients in equation ( [ eq : reduced1 ] ) that contain indetermined forms , which can be explicitly evaluated using the limit @xmath54 we typically use @xmath55 and @xmath56 . a necessary condition for well - posedness for the interior cauchy problem is that at the boundary and at the interface data is prescribed to the incoming characteristic variables . if no data is specified to these variables , then one can expect to lose uniqueness . the characteristic region can provide accurate data for the incoming mode by setting @xmath57 on the other hand , the characteristic problem requires data for the outgoing null variable @xmath44 . this is done by setting @xmath58_{r = r_i}.\label{eq : v}\ ] ] future null infinity corresponds to the boundary surface @xmath59 . here , as a result of the compactification , the speed of the incoming variable @xmath43 approaches zero , so there are no incoming modes ( the surface is null ) . no data is required at this boundary and its numerical treatment is particularly simple . see subsection [ sec : scri ] . stable finite difference approximations of the initial - boundary value problem for the wave equation in the cauchy region ( not coupled to the characteristic problem ) are available . for example , by approximating the spatial derivatives using finite difference operators that satisfy the summation by parts rule @xcite , it is possible to construct schemes which conserve a discrete energy @xcite , a positive definite quadratic form of the dependent variables . boundary conditions can then be imposed either using olsson s method @xcite or using penalty terms @xcite . it is possible to obtain energy estimates in the characteristic region @xcite , and in turn for the coupled cauchy - characteristic problem . ideally , one would like to achieve similar estimates at the discrete level . although we have been able to formally extend these estimates to the discrete case , the semi - discrete problem that we consider fails to admit solutions for generic initial data . formally , one can obtain discrete estimates for the semi - discrete system @xmath60 where @xmath61 , which is a shorthand for @xmath62 , is a vector - valued grid - function having the dynamical variables as components and the variables @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 are discretised with indices @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 . furthermore , @xmath69 is left continuous , @xmath64 and @xmath65 are periodic , the matrices are constant and symmetric and @xmath70 is singular . the operators @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 are discrete finite difference operators . the operators @xmath72 and @xmath73 are centered finite difference approximations of @xmath74 and @xmath75 . the operator @xmath71 approximates @xmath76 and satisfies the summation by parts rule . ] @xmath77 where @xmath78 are appropriate weights ( explicit examples of weights and operators can be found in @xcite ) and @xmath79 is the spatial mesh spacing . system ( [ eq : semidiscrete ] ) represents the semi - discrete approximation of ( [ eq : reduced1])([eq : reduced4 ] ) . without loss of generality we can assume that @xmath70 is diagonal and therefore at least one equation in system ( [ eq : semidiscrete ] ) does not contain derivatives with respect to @xmath69 . multiplying on the left by @xmath80 and using the fact that the matrices are constant and symmetric , we get @xmath81 summing over the indices corresponding to @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 and integrating in @xmath69 gives the equality @xmath82_{u = u_0}^{u = u_1 } + \int_{u = u_0}^{u = u_1 } \left[w_i^t a^x w_i \right]_{i=0}^{i = n } du = 0,\ ] ] where @xmath83_{u = u_0}^{u = u_1 } = f(u_1)-f(u_0)$ ] , @xmath84_{i=0}^{i = n } = f_n - f_0 $ ] , the index @xmath66 corresponds to the @xmath63 direction , and the indices corresponding to @xmath64 and @xmath65 are suppressed . despite the estimate , a solution of ( [ eq : semidiscrete ] ) does not exist . this can be seen by looking at the equation that does not involve derivatives in the @xmath69 direction . the system @xmath85 , for generic @xmath86 , is overdetermined because the operator @xmath71 is singular . since the summation by parts approach does not appear to work , our guiding principle will be to discretise the problem in a way consistent with the continuum problem , for which estimates do exist . numerical experiments will be crucial for establishing convergence of the resulting scheme . the discretization of the cauchy problem is done in a standard way : the derivatives are approximated with centered fourth order accurate finite difference operators @xmath87 where @xmath88 , @xmath89 , and @xmath90 . when applied to a grid - function @xmath91 , operator ( [ eq : fourth ] ) gives @xmath92 the boundaries , the interface and the axis of symmetry are implemented using ghost points . to eliminate the black hole singularity from the domain we use excision . at the boundary the ghost points are populated using extrapolation and by overwriting the incoming characteristic fields , if any are present , at the boundary point . see appendix b.2 of @xcite and @xcite . near the axis of symmetry these are populated using the regularity conditions , i.e. , using the fact that @xmath93 is an even function of @xmath28 across the axis . the interface boundary is treated as if it was an outer boundary , with the only exception that the incoming mode is provided by the characteristic evolution . we also add some artificial dissipation to the scheme of the form @xmath94 , explicitly @xmath95 with @xmath96 @xcite and use fourth order runge - kutta to integrate in time with a courant factor of @xmath97 . although we are investigating a linear problem , the partial differential equations have variable coefficients . a certain amount of artificial dissipation is desirable for stability and will most likely be necessary in the non - linear case . the discretization of the evolution part of the system , eqs . ( [ eq : reduced2])([eq : reduced4 ] ) , is done as in the cauchy case . equation ( [ eq : reduced1 ] ) treated as an ordinary differential equation in @xmath47 , the last two terms in the right hand side taking the role of forcing terms . it is advanced in the @xmath47 direction by using fourth order runge - kutta ( with a `` time '' step equal to the radial mesh spacing ) . this requires the evaluation of the coefficients and forcing terms of ( [ eq : reduced1 ] ) at intermediate time steps . the missing data is generated with fourth order interpolation @xmath98 note that to start the integration we need the fields at the grid - point @xmath99 . we use fourth order extrapolation to populate this point . the integration of @xmath44 along the @xmath47 direction is done at each intermediate time step of the global time integrator . artificial dissipation is added to the evolution in the @xmath69 direction . we use ghost points to treat the axis @xmath100 . the dynamical variables @xmath93 , @xmath4 , @xmath101 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 are even functions of @xmath28 along the axis , and @xmath102 and @xmath103 are odd functions . in particular , we impose that @xmath104 on the axis . data is communicated at the interface at each intermediate time step : the cauchy code requires the incoming variable @xmath105 , eq . ( [ eq : wp ] ) , and the characteristic code needs the outgoing null variable @xmath44 , eq . ( [ eq : v ] ) . the cauchy and characteristic grids are touching , rather than overlapping . this avoids complications with causality which would arise if the @xmath106 slice intersected the domain of dependence of the @xmath107 slice . at the interface boundary we implement condition ( [ eq : wp ] ) by solving for @xmath4 and @xmath101 the system of equations @xmath108 the only difficulty at the outer boundary of the characteristic grid is that some coefficients contain indetermined forms `` @xmath109 '' . we use the limit ( [ eq : indetermined ] ) to evaluate these . we populate the ghost points by extrapolating all fields . as there are no incoming modes no further action is taken . in this subsection we list the basic steps of our algorithm . 1 . give initial data to all fields in the cauchy grid ( @xmath93 and @xmath4 can be given arbitrarily , but @xmath101 and @xmath102 have to obey their definition constraints ) . give initial data to all fields on the characteristic grid ( @xmath93 can be given arbitrarily , @xmath43 and @xmath103 have to satisfy their definition constraints ) , with the exception of the null variable @xmath44 . 2 . impose regularity on the axis , impose interface boundary conditions ( [ eq : wp ] ) and ( [ eq : v ] ) . integrate eq . ( [ eq : reduced1 ] ) using fourth order runge - kutta ( use fourth order lagrange interpolation to populate the coefficients and forcing terms of the differential equation ) . extrapolate all fields in the radial direction to populate the ghost points . impose regularity again.[item:2 ] 3 . evaluate the right hand sides of the evolution equations ( because we use ghost points this can be done at every interior , and boundary / axis / interface point ) and calculate the solution at the next intermediate time step . repeat from point ( [ item:2 ] ) until a full fourth order runge - kutta time step is taken . repeat from point ( [ item:2 ] ) and take as many runge - kutta time steps are needed to reach the final time . to test for convergence we set @xmath110 , construct an exact solution by translating the spherically symmetric solution @xmath111 along the axis by an amount @xmath112 , @xmath113 where @xmath114 . the expressions for @xmath4 , @xmath101 , @xmath102 and @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath115 can be readily computed . we monitor how the @xmath116-norm of the error between the numerical and exact solution , @xmath117 scales with resolution . since the exact solution is known , we only need to use two resolutions ( coarse and fine ) to test for convergence . in the expression above @xmath118 and @xmath119 represent the mesh spacing and the sum is extended to all grid - points of the cauchy and charateristic grids . the coarse resolution is @xmath120 in each grid . the fine resolution is obtained by doubling the number of grid - points in each direction . the cauchy slices extend from @xmath121 , where an artificial boundary is introduced to avoid the @xmath122 coordinate singularity , to @xmath123 , the location of the spherical interface boundary . we use a time step @xmath124 for the coarse case and half it for the fine case . the test confirms that the scheme is indeed fourth order convergent . see figure [ fig : convtest ] . . the numerical errors left in the computational domain converge away at the correct rate . the inset shows the @xmath116-norms of the errors at the different resolutions.,width=453 ] having established that the scheme is fourth order accurate we want to determine whether it can accurately produce the late time tail decays @xcite . the field @xmath93 is expected to decay as @xmath125 ( along a time - like curve and assuming spherically symmetric initial data ) , because of the scattering of the field off the curvature of spacetime asymptotically far from the black hole . we set @xmath126 , give initial data to @xmath93 consisting of a spherically symmetric pulse with compact support , @xmath127 and set its time derivative equal to zero . we use @xmath128 and @xmath129 . we monitor the value of @xmath93 at three different locations : @xmath130 , @xmath131 ( @xmath132 ) and @xmath59 ( i.e. , at @xmath46 ) . using @xmath133 grid - points in the radial direction in both grids and very few in the angular direction , we obtain good agreement with the expected result . see figure [ fig : decay ] . the errors in the angular direction are of round - off order , i.e. , @xmath134 times smaller than the solution . , @xmath135 and at @xmath46 . whereas the first observer is in the cauchy region , the other two are in the characteristic region . note that the decay rate measured by the observer at infinity differs from that of the observers at a finite distance . at @xmath136 the ratio @xmath137 is @xmath138 , for the @xmath139 and @xmath135 observers , and @xmath140 , for the observer at @xmath46.,width=453 ] to study gravitational radiation at future null infinity , where it is unambiguously defined , numerical schemes have to evolve the fields up to that surface . an approach which would allow for this is cauchy - characteristic matching ( ccm ) , whereby cauchy and characteristic evolutions are matched across a time - like world - tube . this approach presents many advantages over other boundary conditions , such as maximally dissipative or absorbing boundary conditions . ccm makes it possible , for example , to compute accurate waveform and polarisation properties at infinity . it is a highly computationally efficient technique which can eliminate the undesirable reflections and inaccuracies that other boundary conditions would introduce @xcite . in this work we described a fourth order accurate algorithm for a cauchy - characteristic formulation of the wave equation written in first order form . by compactifying the radial coordinate in the characteristic region we can evolve all the way to @xmath46 . we carried out convergence tests showing that the scheme is fourth order convergent and were able to reproduce the expected tail decay rate . the interface was implemented using touching grids , which share a common smooth boundary , and by communicating the relevant characteristic / null variables . the success for the scalar field case is clearly only a necessary condition for the fully nonlinear case . the nonlinear extension of this work will require a careful choice of coordinate conditions and attention to the propagation of constraints @xcite . it will be crucial to establish how constraint violations propagate across the domain , so that the interface treatment can be done consistently . in three dimensions one would still require a smooth interface boundary implemented through either overlapping grids @xcite , which work well with simultaneous slices and can also allow for moving boundaries , or touching grids @xcite . 99 pretorius f 2005 _ phys . rev . lett . _ * 95 * 121101 kansagra a 2003 `` coordinate compactifications and hyperboloidal slices in numerical relativity '' ligo / caltech undergraduate project , unpublished . for an online abstract , see http://www.ligo.caltech.edu/ligo_web/students/ugprojects03.html

cauchy - characteristic matching ( ccm ) , the combination of a central @xmath0 cauchy code with an exterior characteristic code connected across a time - like interface , is a promising technique for the generation and extraction of gravitational waves . while it provides a tool for the exact specification of boundary conditions for the cauchy evolution , it also allows to follow gravitational radiation all the way to infinity , where it is unambiguously defined . we present a new fourth order accurate finite difference ccm scheme for a first order reduction of the wave equation around a schwarzschild black hole in axisymmetry . the matching at the interface between the cauchy and the characteristic regions is done by transfering appropriate characteristic / null variables . numerical experiments indicate that the algorithm is fourth order convergent . as an application we reproduce the expected late - time tail decay for the scalar field .

1611.09447

the driving mechanism of relativistic jets associated with active galactic nuclei , gamma - ray bursts , and galactic microquasars is one of the major problems in astrophysics . a widely discussed model is based on the blandford - znajek ( bz ) process , the energy extraction from a rotating black hole ( bh ) along magnetic field lines threading it ( ( * ? ? ? * blandford & znajek 1977 ) ) . this process produces poynting - dominated jets , in which the plasma particles can be accelerated to relativistic speeds ( e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * komissarov et al . 2009 ) , ( * ? ? ? * lyubarsky 2009 ) , ( * ? ? ? * toma & takahara 2013 ) ) . this theoretical picture is now being quantitatively compared with the recent observational results from the m87 jet ( e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * asada & nakamura 2012 ) , ( * ? ? ? * kino et al . 2015 ) , ( * ? ? ? * porth & komissarov 2015 ) , ( * ? ? ? * mertens et al . 2016 ) ) . the bz process was proposed in the pioneering paper of @xcite , in which were found steady , axisymmetric , force - free solutions of the kerr bh magnetosphere in the slow rotation limit where the poynting flux is nonzero along the field lines threading the event horizon . this was followed by demonstrations of numerical and approximate analytical solutions with finite speed of bh rotation ( e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * komissarov 2001 ) , ( * ? ? ? * koide et al . 2002 ) , ( * ? ? ? * mckinney & gammie 2004 ) , ( * ? ? ? * barkov & komissarov 2008 ) , ( * ? ? ? * tchekhovskoy et al . 2011 ) , ( * ? ? ? * ruiz et al . 2012 ) , ( * ? ? ? * contopoulos et al . 2013 ) , ( * ? ? ? * beskin & zheltoukhov 2013 ) ) . it is also generically proved that the steady , axisymmetric situation of no poynting flux can not be maintained for open field lines threading the ergosphere ( ( * ? ? ? * toma & takahara 2014 ) ) . however , the physical mechanism for the creation of the flux in the electromagnetically dominated plasma has not been clearly explained . the issue is where the steady electric current ( which produces the toroidal magnetic field ) is driven in the bz process . all the previous studies on this issue focused on the steady state condition , as far as we are aware , while we argue that this issue can not be solved without investigating the time - dependent state towards the steady state . then we suggest that the electric current is generally driven in the non - ideal magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) region in the time - dependent state , and such regions are hidden near ( or within ) the event horizon in the steady state . the steady current circuit is maintained without any current driving source , because the force - free plasma has no resistivity . in this article we explain the issue in more details and briefly summarize our argument . the bz process assumes that the poloidal magnetic field @xmath0 produced by the plasma filling the magnetosphere ( not by the bh itself ) threads the event horizon , as shown in figure [ fig1 ] . in the case of non - zero bh rotation , the steady axisymmetric state has the electric field @xmath1 perpendicular to @xmath0 ( with @xmath2 ) and the toroidal magnetic field @xmath3 , which form the outward poynting flux @xmath4 , where @xmath1 and @xmath5 are fields as measured in the coordinate basis . one should first note that @xmath3 is produced by the poloidal current @xmath6 , and not produced in vacuum just by the rotation of space - time ( ( * ? ? ? * wald 1974 ) ) . second , in contrast to the bz process , the origin of outward poynting flux of pulsar winds has been definitely identified : the rotation of the matter - dominated central star ( pulsar ) generates @xmath1 ( @xmath7 ) and drives @xmath6 via the unipolar induction process ( ( * ? ? ? * goldreich & julian 1969 ) ) . we can write @xmath8 , and the source term is positive in the star , where @xmath6 is driven to flow in the direction of @xmath9 . the bz process , working in the electromagnetically dominated plasma , does not include any matter - dominated region in which @xmath0 is anchored . the current can not cross the field lines , which means @xmath10 . then it is unclear where @xmath6 is driven . the membrane paradigm ( ( * ? ? * thorne et al . 1986 ) ) interprets the event horizon as a rotating conductor that generates @xmath1 and drives @xmath6 in an analogy with the unipolar induction of pulsar winds . however , the horizon does not actively affects its exterior , but just passively absorbs particles and waves ( ( * ? ? ? * punsly & coroniti 1989 ) ) . the flux production has to work outside the horizon . for such a causal flux production , some theorists proposed a scenario in which certain types of negative energies ( as measured in the coordinate basis ) created outside the horizon ( and within the ergosphere ) flow towards the horizon , resulting in the positive outward @xmath11 . this is an analogous to the mechanical penrose process . however , mhd simulations demonstrate that no regions of negative particle energy are seen in the steady state ( ( * ? ? ? * komissarov 2005 ) ) . the concept of negative electromagnetic energy inflow ( ( * ? ? ? * komissarov 2009 ) , ( * ? ? ? * lasota et al . 2014 ) , ( * ? ? ? * koide & baba 2014 ) ) is not physically essential , because the sign of electromagnetic energy density ( @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the lapse function of kerr metric ) depends on the coordinates ( ( * ? ? ? * toma & takahara 2016 ) ) . the total energy flux per unit mass flux treated in the analytical ideal mhd model can be negative even outside the ergosphere ( ( * ? ? ? * takahashi et al . 1990 ) ) . the inertial drift current in the ideal mhd model can cross the field lines , but it can not produce all of @xmath11 ( ( * ? ? ? * hirotani et al . 1992 ) ) . the current @xmath6 might be driven in the narrow non - ideal mhd region which steadily exists outside the horizon ( ( * ? ? ? * okamoto 2006 ) , ( * ? ? ? * blandford & znajek 1977 ) ) . this possibility may not be excluded . if this is the case , such a non - ideal mhd region may have electric field component parallel to the magnetic field , which accelerates the particles and produces characteristic electromagnetic radiation . thus the present issue appears to be not only theoretical but also related to observations . to help understanding the present issue , let us consider how the schwarzschild gravitational field is formed . its origin is definitely the mass inside the horizon . however , the information that the mass exists inside the horizon never comes out to the exterior . then how is the schwarzschild gravitational field formed ? this question can not be properly answered only by considering the static state . the answer is that this gravitational field has been produced by the mass before it falls across the horizon . this consideration suggests that the origin of steady electromagnetic field surrounding the horizon can not either be understood without investigating the time - dependent state towards the steady state . all the previous studies on the current driving mechanism ( as far as we are aware ) investigated only the steady state . although such a time - dependent state should be analyzed numerically , we use a toy model to qualitatively illustrate the process of building the poloidal current circuit ( ( * ? ? ? * toma & takahara 2016 ) ) . in order to find the essential physics , our analysis is performed in the boyer - lindquist ( singular at the horizon ) and kerr - schild ( regular at the horizon ) coordinate systems . as shown in figure [ fig2 ] ( left ) , we initially consider a vacuum in kerr space - time , and then begin the continuous injection of force - free plasma particles between the two light surfaces as a gedankenexperiment . the inflow ( outflow ) fills the vacuum near the horizon ( at infinity ) . then we can see a process building the poloidal current circuit . our toy model assumes that @xmath0 is fixed to be split - monopole in the whole region , that the two boundaries between the force - free region and the vacuum are geometrically thin and move radially , and that the force - free region and the vacuum have their steady - state structures , but the values of the physical quantities ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 , etc . ) keep being updated as determined by the varying conditions of the inner and outer boundaries . these assumptions enable us to integrate the @xmath16 maxwell equations . then we found that @xmath6 has to flow on the boundaries ( in the directions for making the circuit ) . more importantly , we found that the displacement current at the inner boundary also regulates @xmath6 in the force - free region , i.e. , @xmath17 , where the subscript and superscript ff " and vac " denote the force - free and vacuum regions , respectively , and @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 are the electric field as measured by the zero angular momentum observers , the velocity of inner boundary , the surface current on the inner boundary , and the determinant of spatial metric , respectively . the outward poynting flux in the force - free region is produced at the inner boundary as @xmath22 . this process takes place outside the horizon , which does not violate causality . figure [ fig2 ] ( right ) is the schematic space - time diagram of the two boundaries in the boyer - lindquist coordinates . when the inner boundary approaches the horizon , the outward signal from it propagates slower and slower and it can hardly affect the force - free region . this will lead to the steady state , and one has @xmath10 , i.e. , there is no driving source of @xmath6 in the steady state . since the force - free plasma is assumed to have no resistivity , the current can keep flowing steadily . in conclusion , the driving source of @xmath6 or the non - ideal mhd region exists outside the horizon in the time - dependent state , while it is not required in the steady state . see @xcite for more details . 2012 , _ apj _ , 745 , l28 2008 , _ mnras _ , 385 , l28 2013 , _ astron . _ , 39 , 215 1977 , _ mnras _ , 176 , 465 2013 , _ apj _ , 765 , 113 1969 , _ apj _ , 157 , 869 1992 , _ apj _ , 386 , 455 2015 , _ apj _ , 803 , 30 2014 , _ apj _ , 792 , 88 2002 , _ science _ , 295 , 1688 2001 , _ mnras _ , 326 , l41 2004 , _ mnras _ , 350 , 427 2005 , _ mnras _ , 359 , 801 2009 , _ j. korean phys . soc . _ , 54 , 2503 2009 , _ mnras _ , 394 , 1182 2014 , _ prd _ , 89 , 024041 2009 , _ apj _ , 698 , 1570 2004 , _ apj _ , 611 , 977 2016 , _ a & a _ , 595 , 54 2006 , _ pasj _ , 58 , 1047 2015 , _ mnras _ , 452 , 1089 , 1989 _ prd _ , 40 , 3834 2012 , _ mnras _ , 423 , 1300 1990 , _ apj _ , 363 , 206 2011 , _ mnras _ , 418 , l79 1986 , _ the membrane paradigm _ ( yale university press , new haven ) 2013 , _ ptep _ , 2013 , 3e02 2014 , _ mnras _ , 442 , 2855 2016 , _ ptep _ , 2016 , 3e01 1974 , _ prd _ , 10 , 1680

the blandford - znajek process , the steady electromagnetic energy extraction from a rotating black hole , is widely believed to work for driving relativistic jets , although it is still under debate where the electric current is driven . we address this issue analytically by investigating the time - dependent state in the boyer - lindquist and kerr - schild coordinate systems . this analysis suggests that a non - ideal magnetohydrodynamic region is required in the time - dependent state , while not in the steady state .

astro-ph9808329

an observation of a stellar cluster is an observation of a population of stars of the same age . x - ray observations of open clusters with various ages can thus be used to learn how the x - ray emission of stars changes as they evolve . it is found in young clusters that stars with spectral types later than f emit x - rays due to rapid rotation . as these stars age , their rotation slows down , and their x - ray emission decreases ( e.g. caillault 1996 , randich et al . 1996 and references therein ) . an observation of m@xmath067 with rosat discovered x - rays not only from the cataclysmic variable for which the observation was intended , but also from six other member stars ( belloni et al . 1993 , hereafter bvs ) . several of these other member stars are known to be binaries , and thus belloni et al . suggested that their x - ray emission is due to rapid rotation caused by tidal interaction , i.e. that these x - ray sources are similar to the rs cvn binaries , which are well known x - ray emitters ( e.g. dempsey et al . 1993 ) . in the strict definition , the rapidly rotating star in rs cvn binaries is a subgiant . if the hertzsprung russell diagram of a cluster shows a hertzsprung gap , i.e. if the turnoff mass is higher than about 2.2@xmath2 , it is less likely to contain such rs cvn systems , as the ( sub-)giants in these clusters live shorter . this has been confirmed with x - ray observations of such clusters as ngc@xmath0752 ( belloni & verbunt 1996 ) and ngc@xmath06940 ( belloni & tagliaferri 1997 ) . we use a less stringent definition of rs cvn binaries , which includes chromospherically active binaries consisting of two main - sequence stars , i.e. by draconis binaries . in this paper we continue our study of the x - ray emission of old open clusters . we describe the results of a second , longer , x - ray observation of m@xmath067 , and of an x - ray observation of another old galactic cluster , ngc@xmath0188 . we also reanalyse our first observation of m@xmath067 , and make use of new optical studies of the binaries in this cluster to determine the nature of the x - ray sources . m@xmath067 is an ideal target for rosat , due to its proximity at about 850@xmath0pc and the low interstellar absorption at @xmath3 ( twarog & anthony - twarog 1989 ) , which may be converted into a hydrogen column @xmath4 ( predehl & schmitt 1995 ) . ( note that these values differ from those used by bvs . ) its age is estimated to be about 4@xmath0gyr ( dinescu et al . ngc@xmath0188 is at a larger distance of about 2@xmath0kpc and is reddened more at @xmath5 ( von hippel & sarajedini 1998 ) , or @xmath6 . it is thought to be about 6@xmath0gyr old ( dinescu et al . we observed m@xmath067 with the rosat pspc between april 25 and may 9 1993 , for a total exposure of 15771 seconds ; the center of the field of view was at 8h51m24.0s , 11@xmath749@xmath848.0@xmath9 , the center of the cluster . our previous pspc observation , obtained between 15 and 19 november 1991 , had a total exposure of 10515 seconds , and was centered at 8h50m24.0s , 11@xmath749@xmath812.0@xmath9 , about 10@xmath8 offset from the center of the cluster ( belloni et al . the data were analyzed with the exsas package ( zimmermann et al . we also re - analyzed the previous pointing , both separately and merged with the new data . since the pspc point - spread function is not well known at large off - axis angles , we limited our analysis to the central 20@xmath8 of the instrument . we followed the standard exsas detection procedure ( see e.g. bvs ) , whose final step consists of a maximum likelihood detection ( cruddace et al . 1988 ) in three separate bands : total ( pha channels 11240 , 0.12.4 kev ) , soft ( ch . 1140 , 0.10.4 kev ) and hard ( ch . 41240 , 0.42.4 kev ) we ran the detection procedure on the single observations , with a maximum likelihood threshold of acceptance of 13 . this value is higher than the standard value of 10 , but has been chosen on the basis of a visual inspection of the image , which also allowed us to discard obvious spurious detections . the detected sources in the three bands were crosscorrelated and , in case of a coincidence , the values of the source with the higher likelihood value have been selected for further use . this procedure led to 45 sources in the new pointing and 22 in the old one . for each pointing separately , the x - ray sources were then crosscorrelated with the entries of the hst guide star catalog ( lasker et al . 1990 ) , to determine and correct for the systematic offset ( the so - called boresight correction ) between the rosat x - ray coordinates and the j2000 coordinate system . the two pointings are not coaligned , but are overlapping . thus , a lenticular region has been exposed in both observations . after having applied the boresight corrections to the single photons in the two observations , a merging was made and a new detection was performed on the lenticular region of overlap , with the same procedure described above . 26 sources have been detected in this way . the three lists of x - ray sources ( old , new and merged ) were then crosscorrelated to produce the final catalog , which contains 59 sources . when a source appeared in more than one list , the detection with the highest maximum likelihood value has been selected . positions and countrates of the sources can be found in table 1 . notice that the countrates in table 1 are , like the positions , those of the best detection . variability of the sources is discussed below . [ cols= " > , < , < , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , < " , ] with the exception of the two contact binaries and of the cataclysmic variable , all binaries referred to below are spectroscopic binaries . many of them are discussed in some detail in mathieu et al . we now proceed to discuss the sources according to category . source x@xmath016 is the cataclysmic variable eu cancri . this variable was discovered by gilliland et al . ( 1991 ) at a photometric period of 2.09@xmath0hr . it is of the am - her type , i.e. a binary in which a white dwarf with a strong magnetic field accretes from a low - mass main - sequence dwarf , and in which the rotation of the white dwarf is locked to the orbital revolution . eu cnc is detected with rosat only at soft energies ( channels 11 - 40 , corresponding roughly to 0.1 - 0.4@xmath0kev ) , at a countrate @xmath10cts / s . folding the x - ray data at the binary period , we obtain the lightcurve shown in fig . [ eucnc ] . the predominance of soft photons is typical for am - her type systems , as is the almost 100% modulation of the x - ray lightcurve ( due to occultation of the x - ray emission region by the rotating white dwarf ) . the ratio of @xmath11 to the optical flux also is in the range observed for am - her type systems ( see for example table 1 of verbunt et al . our observations thus confirm the suggestion by gilliand et al . ( 1991 ) that this object is an am - her type system . conversion of the observed countrate to flux suffers from our ignorance of the spectrum ; for an assumed blackbody spectrum with @xmath12ev we find a bolometric x - ray luminosity for eu cnc of @xmath13 at the distance and column of m@xmath067 . x@xmath023 is a very soft source , and has been identified with a white dwarf by pasquini et al . the effective temperature of this star is @xmath14 ( fleming et al . 1997 ) , which is hot enough to explain the x - ray emission . to compare its countrate with that of nearby field white dwarfs , we take the countrates found by fleming et al . ( 1996 ) in the rosat all sky survey , for white dwarfs whose absolute magnitudes are given in the spectroscopic studies of bergeron et al . ( 1992 ) and bragaglia et al . the values thus found are shown in fig . [ wd ] ; it is seen that the countrate we detect for the white dwarf in m@xmath067 is in the range seen for field white dwarfs at comparable magnitudes . the two contact binaries detected in m@xmath067 are ah cnc ( x@xmath040 , s@xmath01282 ) and s@xmath01036 ( x@xmath045 , no . iii-2 of gilliland et al . the countrates are at the limit of detection . contact binaries are thought to be x - ray emitters due to chromospheric activity , induced by the rapid rotation of the stars comprising the binary . the x - ray luminosities of these two contact binaries may be compared with those of contact binaries in the field , studied by mcgale et al . the countrates of ah cnc and s@xmath01036 are between those of e.g. v389 oph and ak her , converted to the distance of m@xmath067 . s@xmath01036 has an orbital period slightly longer than that of ak her , which has the longest orbital period of the systems discussed by mcgale et al . a third contact binary in m@xmath067 , iii-79 , was not detected ; it is much fainter in the optical than the other two , at @xmath15 . we detect three circular binaries at orbital periods @xmath16d . the circularity of the orbits indicates strong tidal interaction , and we expect that these systems are chromospherically active binaries ; optical spectroscopy is required to confirm this . s@xmath0999 and s@xmath01045 are double - lined spectroscopic binaries discussed by mathieu et al . s@xmath0999 @xmath17 x@xmath013 is a binary of a slightly evolved star , hence mass equal to the turnoff mass @xmath18 of m@xmath067 , and a @xmath19 main sequence companion . s@xmath01045 @xmath17 x@xmath041 is a binary of two main sequence stars of equal masses @xmath20 . s@xmath01070 @xmath17 x@xmath038 lies on the main - sequence in the hertzsprung russell diagram of m@xmath067 ; its orbital period @xmath21d and circular orbit suggest that it is an rs cvn binary . the larger star in rs cvn binaries is forced by the tidal interaction to corotate with the orbit , and this rapid rotation enhances the chromospheric activity , which explains the x - ray emission . the x - ray luminosities of the rs cvn systems in m@xmath067 is compared with those of rs cvn systems in the field in fig . [ rscvn ] . for the conversion of observed countrate to x - ray luminosity we use the two - temperature model described in sect . it is seen that the x - ray luminosities of the m@xmath067 systems are comparable to those of rs cvn systems in similar locations of the hertzsprung russell diagram . x@xmath053 is identified with s@xmath01234 . mathieu et al . ( 1990 ) observe that s@xmath01234 is a triple system in which the primary and tertiary have roughly equal light . the period of 4.36@xmath0d is then the orbital period of the inner binary . the visible stars would have masses close to @xmath20 ; no strong constraints exist for the mass of the companion in the inner binary . the x - ray emission of s@xmath01234 is probably due to chromospheric activity in the inner binary : the inner orbital period is short enough for tidal interaction to be efficient . four binaries with as yet unknown orbital solutions have also been detected in x - rays ( x@xmath049 @xmath17 s@xmath0760 , x@xmath017 @xmath17 s@xmath0972 , x@xmath011 @xmath17 s@xmath01019 , x@xmath07 @xmath17 s@xmath01077 ) . all but s@xmath0760 appear to have orbital periods of @xmath22 days ( for s@xmath01077 see mathieu et al . 1990 ) , suggesting that they too are rs cvn systems . x@xmath010 is identified with s@xmath01040 . s@xmath01040 was discovered to be a circular binary by mathieu et al . verbunt & phinney ( 1995 ) showed that the giant in this binary is too small to be responsible for the orbital circularization , and concluded that the companion to the giant must be a white dwarf , whose progenitor filled its roche lobe as a giant and circularized the orbit . the companion to the giant has been detected in the ultraviolet , and its ultraviolet spectrum shows that it is indeed a white dwarf , with a temperature @xmath23k ( landsman et al . 1997 ) . the white dwarf is too cool to be responsible for the x - ray luminosity , which therefore is presumably due to chromospheric activity of the giant ( belloni et al . such activity is evident from the mg@xmath0ii@xmath242800 doublet which is in emission ( landsman et al . 1997 ) , and also from ca h&k emission ( pasquini & belloni 1998 ) . we suggest that this chromospheric activity may be a remaining effect of the phase of mass transfer in the earlier evolution of this binary . x@xmath08 and x@xmath026 are identified with s@xmath01063 and s@xmath01113 respectively . this means that both stars located below the subgiant branch in the hertzsprung russell diagram of m@xmath067 have now been detected in x - rays . s@xmath01063 is an eccentric binary with an orbital period of 18.3@xmath0d ; s@xmath01113 is a circular binary with a period of 2.82@xmath0d ( latham et al . 1992 ; mathieu et al . 1998 , in preparation ) . the nature of these stars , why they are located below the subgiant branch , and why they emit x - rays , is a mystery . this is all the more remarkable , as these two stars belong to the brightest x - ray sources in m@xmath067 . model computations show that the larger star in s@xmath01063 could be synchronized with the orbital motion at periastron ( van den berg et al . 1998 , in preparation ) . for @xmath25 this corresponds to a rotation period which is 60% of the orbital period . the x - ray emission of s@xmath01063 ( x@xmath08 ) is variable : the countrate in november 1991 was @xmath26/ksec , that in april 1993 @xmath27/ksec . x@xmath050 has been identified with s@xmath01242 , an eccentric binary with an orbital period of almost 32@xmath0d . x@xmath037 and x@xmath052 have been identified with s@xmath01072 and s@xmath01237 , respectively , two long - period eccentric binaries , whose positions in the hertzsprung russell diagram could suggest that they contain evolved stars ( figs . [ xray ] ) . the colour and magnitude of s@xmath01237 can be produced by the combination of a giant branch star and a main - sequence star close to the turnoff ( janes & smith 1984 ) . no satisfactory solution has been suggested yet to explain the magnitude and colour of s@xmath01072 ( see e.g. mathieu et al . 1990 ) . it is not clear to us why these three eccentric binaries emit x - rays . we do nt think that the x - ray emission is due to hot white - dwarf companions , because the x - ray spectrum is not as soft as would be expected for a white dwarf . also , the progenitor of the white dwarf would likely have circularized the orbit in its giant stage : even an orbit of several thousand days can be circularized by a white dwarf progenitor , as witnessed by s@xmath01221 ( verbunt & phinney 1995 ) . a number of x - ray sources can be identified with stars for which there is no indication that they are binaries . it can not be excluded that these stars are chance coincidences . x@xmath043 @xmath17 s@xmath01270 and x@xmath044 @xmath17 s@xmath0775 have been observed by latham & mathieu ; no radial velocity variation was found , so these stars are not close binaries . x@xmath028 @xmath17 s@xmath01112 has not been measured by latham & mathieu . x@xmath035 is s@xmath0628 , located to the left of the main - sequence ; such a location can arise when a main - sequence star is accompanied by a hot white dwarf . the hardness of the x - ray spectrum argues against a hot non - accreting white dwarf . perhaps s@xmath0628 is a cataclysmic variable . it should be noted that its membership probability is only 69% ; if it is at larger distance than m@xmath067 ( to be at or above the main sequence it has to be @xmath28 times the distance of m@xmath067 ) , its x - ray luminosity is accordingly higher . x@xmath04 is the blue straggler s@xmath01082 . this has been suggested to be in a binary with a sdo companion on the basis of a large ultraviolet excess with respect to the spectrum derived from strmgren photometry ( landsman et al . . a binary period of approximately 1 day has been suggested from optical photometry ( goranskij et al . 1992 ) ; however , the large velocity variations implied by such a short period have not been found by mathieu et al . ( 1986 ) , even though they note that the dispersion in their velocities for this star is somewhat larger than normal . the larger dispersion may be due to the early spectral type . x@xmath019 is s@xmath0364 , close to the location of the mira variables in the hertzsprung russell diagram . no chromospheric emission is present in s@xmath0364 ( pasquini & belloni 1998 ) . x@xmath025 is identified with hd 75638 . this star is a triple star , with an inner orbit of 5.8@xmath0d and zero eccentricity ( nordstrm et al . the x - ray luminosity suggests that the inner binary is a rs cvn system . x@xmath042 shows a flare in the last 2800@xmath0s of our observations , during which the countrate was 0.03 cts / s , which is about ten times higher than the average countrate before . such a flare suggests that s@xmath01042 may be a late main - sequence star ; its colour and magnitude are compatible with a k dwarf at the distance of m@xmath067 . however , according to girard et al . ( 1989 ) s@xmath01042 is not a member . in fig . [ n188 ] we show the hertzsprung russell diagram of ngc@xmath0188 with the two detected member stars , x@xmath029 and x@xmath021 . x@xmath029 @xmath17 d@xmath0719 is one of the brightest giants in ngc@xmath0188 , and remarkable because of its relatively rapid rotation , at @xmath29km / s and ca h and k emission . the absence of radial - velocity variations suggest that it is a single , rapidly rotating giant , an fk comae - type star ( harris & mcclure 1985 ) . the x - ray luminosity of the star , @xmath30 , is in agreement with this suggestion . high - precision radial - velocity measurements obtained with the wiyn telescope show x@xmath021 @xmath17 d@xmath01335 to be both a short - period velocity variable and a rapid rotator ( mathieu & dolan 1998 , in preparation ) . thus the x - ray emission at @xmath31 is likely due to chromospheric activity . the star has been investigated for photometric variability by kaluzny & shara ( 1987 ) , who do not find it variable . x@xmath026 @xmath17 d@xmath01361 is variable v@xmath08 of kaluzny & shara ( 1987 ) , who find evidence for a 2.66@xmath0day periodicity in the @xmath32 magnitude , and suggest that the star is of the fk@xmath0comae type . the proper motion of this star suggests that it is not a member of ngc@xmath0188 ( dinescu et al . if it is a member , its x - ray luminosity is @xmath33erg / s . the increased sensitivity of the x - ray observation of m@xmath067 and the improved optical information have led to a true plethora of source types , as illustrated by table 3 . many of these are more or less expected source types , such as the cataclysmic variable , the hot white dwarf , the contact binaries , and the circular short - period binaries : for all of these the x - ray luminosity is in the range found for similar sources in the galactic disk . interestingly however , several sources have been detected for which we do not understand the mechanism of x - ray emission . these include several binaries with eccentric orbits , of which two are located in the hertzsprung russell diagram below the subgiant branch . unexpected also are the detection of a binary of a giant and a white dwarf in a circular orbit ; and of a blue straggler that appears to be a single star . further optical studies of these objects may help in elucidating the mechanism(s ) of x - ray emission . for example , chromospheric activity can be detected in the form of h@xmath34 or ca h and k emission ; and is probably caused by rapid rotation which may be detected through line broadening . if mass transfer is taking place in any of these binaries , broad balmer emission lines are expected . the number of x - ray sources detected in ngc@xmath0188 is much lower , due to the higher detection flux limit . one of the two detected members is a single , rapidly rotating giant star , an fk com type object which adds yet another source type . we predict that a more sensitive x - ray observation of ngc@xmath0188 will detect a few dozen x - ray sources , similar to those we have found in m@xmath067 . this work builds on the center for astrophysics m@xmath067 binary survey , for which we express our appreciation to dr . david latham . rdm was supported by a national science foundation grant ast-9731302 . in identifying our x - ray sources we have made use of the open cluster database of mermilliod ( 1996 ) .

we have observed the old open clusters m@xmath067 and ngc@xmath0188 with the rosat pspc . in m@xmath067 we detect a variety of x - ray sources . the x - ray emission by a cataclysmic variable , a single hot white dwarf , two contact binaries , and some rs cvn systems is as expected . the x - ray emission by two binaries located below the subgiant branch in the hertzsprung russell diagram of the cluster , by a circular binary with a cool white dwarf , and by two eccentric binaries with @xmath1d is puzzling . two members of ngc@xmath0188 are detected , including the fk@xmath0com type star d719 . another possible fk@xmath0com type star , probably not a member of ngc@xmath0188 , is also detected . = 0.0 mm

1407.7562

there is a qualitative transition in the sophistication of the mathematical tools required to describe mechanical systems of a few free bodies to those dominated by the behavior of continuous fields . second - order ordinary differential equations are indispensable in the study of point - system mechanics , particularly in a first year course , and many curricula are organized around first understanding the properties of these equations ( particularly in the case in which the equation of motion has the form @xmath0 ) . in a first course in electromagnetism , the fundamental quantities to understand are the distributed electromagnetic fields , @xmath1 , with dynamics given by maxwell s equations using the language of partial differential equations with appropriate boundary conditions . even very good companion works can give the impression to undergraduates that the ideas of `` divergence , gradient , and curl '' have their primary ( perhaps only ) role in describing electricity and magnetism . @xcite thus , beginning students get the impression that these mathematical tools are somehow wedded to the separate subjects of the physics canon , rather than being independent , widely applicable tools . my aim here is to present a mechanics problem which is usually dealt with in the algebra - based mechanics curriculum and recast it using the mathematical language students expect in electricity and magnetism . i have two aims . first , i will connect archimedes principle ( usually developed as a just - so " statement of how a buoyant force " works ) to real forces acting on real bodies . the ideas of buoyancy , density , and volume are known areas of difficulty for science teaching candidates , k-12 students , and even quite advanced students majoring in physics . @xcite as we shall see , the buoyant force is merely a consequence of the superposition of many forces acting on the outer edge of an object , and thus is no more mysterious than any other force in mechanics . secondly , i wish to give an undergraduate a context in which vector analysis has a definite application in the most familiar , concrete physics a student knows , namely mechanics . thus , the integration of these mathematical tools and the net forces " ideas in this nexus of problems and placing that integrated understanding firmly within the grasp of an intermediate - level student of physics is the goal . it is not my intention to merely display yet another derivation of the principle , although i will certainly do that . rather , it is my intention to integrate this basic idea into our curriculum in a fundamental way . if this work is used to merely guide a new set of derivations in a lecture hall , its purpose will be unfulfilled . there is a growing consensus across the academy that the value of integrating methods and content , and creating a unified , flexible intellectual framework supporting lifelong learning is the eventual goal of a baccalaureate course of study even in professional and stem fields , perhaps _ particularly so_. too often a university education can be experienced as a list of topics or courses logically disconnected from each other . the work of integrating the education into a seamless whole can be left to a student , and may or may not occur . @xcite physics is particularly blessed in this regard , in that our discipline celebrates the unification of disparate phenomena in a way that few disciplines have a history of doing . there are a number of excellent introductory texts that take this integrated point of view as opposed to a historical development . the right " ideas are developed at the beginning of study , and the special cases amenable to analysis ( exact or approximate ) are labeled as such.@xcite in the physics program at csu long beach where i am a faculty member , we have for a number of years been intentional with this very issue , stemming from our activity as a phystec supported site in 2010.@xcite one element of this program was to develop a learning assistant program on the colorado model , along with a course in physics pedagogy @xcite we use to train physics majors to teach in our lower - level laboratories as learning assistants . @xcite a part of that course , and the key to explaining to physics majors why this low - level material is so hard to learn ( and teach ) is discussing the excellent article by reddish on mental models in physics learning . @xcite one of the most striking features of this treatment is the realization that mental structures of physics in a student s head are incomplete , disorganized , and even for very well - trained students ( and faculty ) there exists `` holes '' in even very basic concepts . in taking this course , students are required to be present in a science tutoring center , and as is often the case , have duties to help students with courses they themselves had never taken . algebra - based mechanics and k-6 level physical sciences are never taken by physics students , and we assume that advanced students ( with advanced mathematical and physics tools ) should be able to handle the more elementary ideas in those `` precursor '' courses . it is a relatively simple problem that stumped my stable of learning assistants that prompted the development below a problem using archimedes principle . it is my experience that anything involving fluids is inordinately tricky to explain . the basic functioning of a centrifuge can be understood at an engineering level and qualitatively well enough for the devices to work correctly in the hands of research - caliber scientists and engineers . yet , the explanation in terms of hydrostatic equilibrium in a non - inertial frame is subtle with tendrils reaching up into very sophisticated mechanics.@xcite of the many treatments of the principle ( starting with a good exposition of archimedes words themselves @xcite and even quite interesting derivations centering on energy ideas @xcite ) not many cement the principle into the basic foundation of mechanics many students understand and can already use quite well . even in a static case , in which archimedes principle and buoyancy should be sufficient to solve many problems , my group of junior level physics students `` knew '' archimedes principle , but were unable to apply it . and , embarrassingly enough , likewise for myself . only when i had put the problem into the language of vector analysis did archimedes principle actually make sense to me ( in the sense that i had connected it to my own ideas of mechanics ) . the point of this paper is to elucidate the conditions that lead me to `` reconstruct '' a theorem of vector calculus archimedes himself must have discovered : @xcite @xmath2 which some will recognize as the three - dimensional version of the `` mean - value theorem , '' but which i will simply regard as archimedes theorem " a fitting companion to gauss law . i will first describe the elementary problem that revealed to us all that we had a buoyancy gap in our understanding . then i will describe hydrostatic equilibrium and the new vector identity , and in the discussion describe some applications and `` clicker '' style questions . the problem that send my physics major learning assistants off into a cycle of recursive algebra is a relatively straightforward problem encountered in the algebra - based mechanics sequence . here is a variation : _ a hot air balloon of volume @xmath3 is in equilibrium surrounded by air of density @xmath4 . at @xmath5 ballast of mass @xmath6 is released from the balloon , and it is observed to accelerate upwards with an acceleration @xmath7 . what is the final mass of the balloon ( in terms of @xmath8 ) ? _ these were students , by and large , who had just taken our junior - level course in mechanics , or had completed a course in introductory modern physics and differential equations , so there was no issue with their preparation . yet , they reported that they spent an inordinate amount of time circling around the problem without coming to a resolution , much to the consternation of the the first - year students who were hoping to get some help on the problem in our tutoring center . what my students knew , and what they had connected to the stock of problems they had personally solved , were two different things . it was only the presence of our master teacher in residence , ms . kathryn beck of bolsa grande high school that saved our collective bacon by remarking that the buoyant force is just @xmath9 both before the ballast had been dropped and after.@xcite given that this force is the same before and after leads immediately to the observation that @xmath10 in short , my students had `` heard '' of archimedes principle ( as i had myself ) , but in never having had to use it in a physical context ( this sort of problem has fallen out of our `` calculus''-based mechanics curriculum ) . they were quite confident in their use of free body diagrams , but the nature of the buoyant force was not connected from the beginning to the end of the problem . and , once i had the benefit of ms . beck s observation ( she was clearly very , very familiar with this sort of problem , having taught it many years in many guises and having charged generations of students to construct and predict the displacement of cardboard boats ) i was left with a conundrum . there is in reality no * buoyant * force , there is only the effect of the surrounding air pressure on the balloon . as i had drilled into my own mind in the course of working through my own ph.d . thesis @xcite , only gradients of the pressure field give forces . the presence of a pressure gradient is the * only * way the air can affect the balloon , not through an unsystematic `` watch me pull a rabbit out of a hat '' buoyant force . and , here is how i connect the buoyant force and the presence of a non - uniform pressure field . is subjected to an inward force on its upper face , an upward force on its lower face , and its weight . an abstract net force " or free body " diagram is at right . ] the air around the balloon is in hydrostatic equilibrium . thus , a small cube of air with edge lengths @xmath11 is in equilibrium when : @xmath12 here , the pressure on the top face of the box produces a downward force , and the pressure on the bottom face produces an upward force . rearranging a bit gives a differential equation for the pressure : @xmath13 with the familiar solution : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the pressure at @xmath16 . this treatment is elementary enough , certainly not worth writing a manuscript to share . so , now we know the pressure field around the balloon . what is the microscopic mechanism of transferring force to the balloon from this pressre field ? again , mirroring the constructions in ref . @xcite i consider an infinitesimal element of the surface area ( with normal directed outward ) of the ballon , @xmath17 . as in figure [ at_schematic ] , the air puts a force on this area element , @xmath18 . , our task is to add up all of the forces resulting from each infinitesimal directed area element , @xmath17 . also shown schematically is a `` box discretization '' of the sort used to motivate theorems in vector calculus.@xcite ] note that there is a pressure field inside the balloon as well , but if we are concerned with the balloon as the system , all such internal forces cancel in pairs a distinct advantage of the matter and interactions curriculum@xcite is the clear demarcation between system and surroundings in every phsyical situation . thus , the total force from the air is a sum over all of these small air forces : @xmath19 this looks suspiciously like the `` flux '' expression in gauss law , except @xmath20 is a vector quantity and not a scalar formed by the flux of a vector field through a closed surface . here is the clever bit , which generates a new ( to me ) theorem of vector calculus . let us dot bot sides of eq . [ fair ] with @xmath21 : @xmath22 the second equality follows form the divergence theorem applied to the vector field @xmath23 . thus , we have @xmath24 where the pressure gradient in eq . [ pgrad ] is used in the second equality . eureka . this gives just the @xmath25 component of the total force , and in this case , as the pressure has no gradients in either the @xmath26 nor @xmath27 directions , this is all the analysis can tell us , although if @xmath28 depends on each of @xmath29 nontrivially , we have derived the the full version of archimedes theorem , eq . [ at ] . the development of archimedes principle as a consequence of hydrostatic equilibrium , eq . [ hydro ] and a generalization of the divergence theorem , eq . [ at ] is clearly within the ability of an advanced undergraduate to use , and , in my opinion , relaxes the appearance of the archimedes principle from an _ ad hoc _ statement and grounds it solidly upon the development of general equilibrium , forces , and superposition of forces . it is altogether more clear to an advanced student _ why the principle is true _ which allows it to be used in different contexts . the design of numerous hand - made `` bob '' accelerometers is a case in point . here , an object less dense than water is submerged completely , yet tethered to the bottom of a clear , plastic bottle . the bob reacts quickly to an applied acceleration ... accelerate forward , and the bob immediately leans forward , and the magnitude of the acceleration can be measured by the angle ot the tilt . i have seen many students fumbling with * why * this should occur . there is some loose talk of `` water rushing backward , the bob getting out of the way , '' and yet this is clearly an unsystematic treatment . suppose the bottle is accelerated along the @xmath26-axis . a pressure field is immediately set up in the fluid ( on the timescale it would take a shockwave to traverse the bottle ) with a large pressure at the rear of the bottle , and a smaller pressure at the front . this component of the gradient of the pressure field has to match the hydrostatic equilibrium condition , eq . [ hydro ] , with an acceleration @xmath30 : @xmath31 then , an application of eq . [ at ] yields @xmath32 thus , for a quiescent bottle , there is a net pressure force in the direction opposite `` @xmath33 '' , but given the equivalence principle , we should be able to replace @xmath33 with an accelerating noninertial frame with acceleration equal to @xmath34 with no observable effects . and , if we moved the whole discussion off into the internationa space station , we would have @xmath35 , and to get the bob to point away form the bottom of the bottle , we would have to accelerate the bottle in the @xmath21 direction with the magnitude of the terrestrial @xmath36 to get the same behavior . a suitable probe for the reasonableness of this whole discussion is the following clicker "- style question . _ a helium - filled balloon is suspended from a thread one meter from the floor of an enclosed elevator . at the instant you cut the thread , the cable supporting the elevator is severed . while you are hurtling toward certain severe injury , you observe the balloon _ * \a ) rise toward the ceiling of the elevator . * \b ) remain one meter from the floor of the elevator . * \c ) fall toward the floor of the elevator . the correct answer is b ) , of course , for a very physical reason that is opaque in the usual reasoning of the principle . in the freely falling elevator , the pressure field is uniform , and hence the net force from the air on the helium balloon is zero . the balloon thus has only its weight force acting on it , and it freely falls along with the elevator . an unsophisticated reading of the problem will assume that the buoyant force is * always * acting , so the balloon will not only rise upward , it will rise upward faster and faster until it hits the roof of the elevator . a suitable demonstration ( in a very special case ) is found in dropping a water - filled container with a neutrally buoyant object floating in its midsection . if the buoyant force always acts , the ball will remain in equilibrium while the container falls , and he top of the container will fall toward the ball . yet , in the freely falling system , the water , ball , and container all should share the same acceleration . and further , we have a solid explanation in terms of real forces in an inertial frame for the functioning of a centrifuge . for , as the centrifuge spins , there is an acceleration field of the form @xmath37 . thus , the equivalent of the hydrostatic condition is ( in cylindrical coordinates ) @xmath38 with the analog of eq . [ at ] is then @xmath39 where @xmath40 radial position of the geometric center of the displaced volume . this is exactly the position of the center of mass of the fluid that would exists had the object not been submerged in the fluid . the dependence on @xmath40 on @xmath41 provides an enhancement of the density - discriminating effect , crucial for the operation of a gas - centrifuge . but again , this is solely a function of adding up the pressure on each surface of an object , and determining the net force . from there , we can connect to a student s early training in free body diagrams ( and the momentum principle , in the language of ref . @xcite . what is going on here is extremely clear from a computational point of view . as in figure [ at_schematic ] , we attempt to calculate the effect of the pressure forces on the finite elements in the entire body under consideration . as the pressures are all equal in the @xmath26 and @xmath27 directions , it is just the @xmath25 direction that i will concentrate upon here . each element of volume has two faces , and the pressures at neighboring surfaces give canceling forces . it is just the pressure at the top , and the pressure at the bottom of the overall column that is important , and this gradient is just adding up the increments in the weights of the fluid elements . what we have here is little more than @xmath42 with @xmath43 a student asked to * compute the effect of the pressure gradient * will find eq [ at ] as a trivial restatement of a massive internal cancellation of terms . exactly this sort of exercise is well within the capability of students completing a computation - enriched curriculum.@xcite here , i have related an episode revealing a `` hole '' in the preparation of undergraduate students in physics at csu long beach ( and perhaps in many more institutions beside ) , and proposed a solution . the solution brings the mathematics of vector analysis back into the physics curriculum between the hiatus in electrodynamics courses ( just when it would be very useful _ e.g. _ in an introduction to quantum mechanics ) . and , the argument provides a clear insight into how deeply archimedes himself understood the theorems of vector calculus.@xcite 99 harry moritz schey , _ div , grad , curl , and all that _ , 4th edition ( w. w. norton , 2005 ) . michael e. loverude1 , christian h. kautz1 and paula r. l. heron , am . * 71 * , 1178 ( 2003 ) . paula r. l. heron1 , michael e. loverude1 , p. s. shaffer1 and l. c. mcdermott , am . j. phys . * 71 * , 1188 ( 2003 ) ; george d. kuh , _ high - impact educational practices : what they are , who has access to them , and why they matter _ , ( aac and u , 2008 ) . ruth w. chabay , bruce a. sherwood , _ matter and interactions , vol . 1 _ , 3rd edition ( john wiley and sons , 2011 ) . david e. meltzer and peter s. shaffer , eds . _ teacher education in physics _ , ( american physical society , 2011 ) . phys 390 `` exploring physics teaching '' is taken by approximately 30 physics majors anually at csu long beach , and counts as upper - division elective credit in the physics major . v. otero , s. pollock , n. finkelstein , am . j. of phys . * 78 * , 1218 ( 20100 . edward f. reddish , am . j. phys . * 62*(9 ) , 796 ( 1994 ) . john robert taylor , _ classical mechanics _ , ( university science books , 2005 ) . herbert goldstein , charles p. poole jr . , john l. safko _ classical mechanics _ , 3rd edition ( pearson , 2001 ) . erlend h. graf , the phys . 42 * , 296 ( 2004 ) . v. m. rudiak phys . teach . * 2 * , 293 ( 1964 ) . while there is evidence that archimedes had developed ideas of infinitesimals in various geometric problems , he almost certainly had no concept of a vector field or vector calculus . it is a testament to his powers of insight that his principle has such deep roots in vector analysis . we have had four tir s at csu long beach : rod ziolkowski of whitney high school in cerritos , ca ; kathryn beck of bolsa grande high school in garden grove , ca ; kevin dwyer of cypress high school in cypress , ca ; and , meredith ashbran of da vinci high school in hawthorne , ca . interacting with these physicists has been extremely valuable for both our students and our faculty . generally , high school physicists have an enormous wealth of techniques and a depth of pedagogical experience that i , for one , envy . galen t. pickett , j. chem . phys . * 104 * , 1657 ( 1996 ) ;

the theorems of vector analysis ( divergence theorem , etc . ) are typically first applied in the undergraduate physics curriculum in the context of the electromagnetic field and the differential forms of maxwell s equations . however , these tools are analyzed in depth several courses later in the junior - senior level . i discuss here a bridge " problem , using the language of vector calculus in a mechanics setting to understand archimedes principle as a consequence of hydrostatic equilibrium and the superposition of the external forces . it is my hope that this treatment will help students better integrate and understand understand these and similar vector analysis results in contexts beyond electromagnetism .

cond-mat0404342

subdiffusion occurs in many physical systems such as amorphous semiconductors , porous media @xcite or gel solvents @xcite . the subdiffusion is defined by the relation @xmath0 with @xmath1 , where @xmath2 denotes the mean square displacement of the transported particle , @xmath3 is the time . the case of @xmath4 corresponds to the normal diffusion . to obtain the concentration profiles ( @xmath5 ) of transported substance in subdiffusive systems one uses the subdiffusion equation with fractional time derivative @xcite @xmath6 with the riemann - liouville fractional derivative defined as ( for @xmath7 ) @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the smallest integer larger than @xmath10 , @xmath11 is the subdiffusion coefficient measured in the units @xmath12 . while there is a huge literature about the normal diffusion in a variety of systems ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein ) , the subdiffusion is satisfactorily described in a few cases only . the procedure of solving the equation ( [ se ] ) appears to be rather complicated . below we present a practical method to calculate the solutions of the equations describing in a multi - part system where diffusion and subdiffusion occur . the starting point is the solution corresponding to the analogous multi - part system where only normal diffusion is present . till now homogeneous systems have been mostly studied . however , the multi - part systems discussed here , in particular the membrane systems , are important for several fields of technology and biophysics . we mention here as examples the membranes used as micro filters and the ( sub-)diffusion processes in living cells which are crucial for the cell physiology . there are a few attempts described in the literature to obtain solutions of eq . ( [ se ] ) from the ones corresponding to the normal diffusion . a powerful method seems to be mapping of the solutions of diffusion equation @xmath13 into the subdiffusive ones @xmath14 by means of the relation @xcite @xmath15 where the laplace transform of the function @xmath9 is @xmath16 ( throughout this paper the index @xmath10 is assigned to the functions corresponding to subdiffusion ; the index @xmath17 refers to the normal diffusion ) . another method is to ` rescale ' the time as @xmath18 @xcite . using the substitution one obtains the solutions of normal diffusion equation with diffusion coefficient depending on time . however , both procedures have been used to the homogeneous system only and it is unclear how to apply these approaches to a multi - part system , where the various kinds of diffusion occur ( e.g. a porous material , where subdiffusion proceeds , is adjoined to a normal diffusive medium ) . thus , a more general procedure is needed . in this paper we discuss a method of constructing solutions of the one - dimensional subdiffusive equation with given boundary conditions starting with those of normal diffusion , which can be obtained rather easily . our method gives the green s functions ( gf ) for subdiffusive equation in the form of series of the fox functions which is convenient for numerical calculations . the method splits into two step . in the first one the laplace transform of the subdiffusive green s function is obtained from the normal diffusion counterpart , and in the second one the laplace transform is inverted . in contrast to the previous papers @xcite , we include boundary conditions into considerations . as an illustration of our method , we find the solutions of eq . ( [ se ] ) for the system consisting of two parts where the normal diffusion and subdiffusion occur , respectively . we restrict our considerations to the case of boundary conditions which are given in the form of linear combination of concentrations and fluxes . we note that this is not a serious restriction as the linear boundary conditions often occur in normal diffusion problems ( and can be adapted for the subdiffusion cases ) . for example , for the system with fully reflecting , fully absorbing @xcite , and partially absorbing wall @xcite , respectively , the boundary conditions read : @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 , where @xmath22 denotes a position of the wall . for the partially permeable wall there have been used two different boundary conditions : @xmath23 @xcite or @xmath24 @xcite , which both should be supplemented by the continuity of the flux @xmath25 . since the green s function for normal diffusion is mapped onto the subdiffusion within the method presented below , we first discuss the connection between the equation of normal diffusion and the subdiffusive equation . we start with the normal diffusion equation @xmath26 and assume that each of the boundary condition involves a linear combination of fluxes and concentrations . when the system under consideration is divided into two parts by the membrane located at @xmath27 , the boundary condition ( bc ) at @xmath22 is assumed to be of the form @xmath28 where the flux @xmath29 is given as @xmath30 and @xmath31 ( @xmath32 ) are the parameters independent of @xmath3 . the solution of the equation ( [ ne ] ) can be found due to the following integral formula @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the initial concentration , and the green s function @xmath35 is defined as a solution of the equation ( [ ne ] ) with the initial concentration @xmath36 with the appropriate boundary conditions . since the diffusion equation is of the second order with respect to the space variable one needs two boundary conditions at the discontinuity of the system . when the system is infinite , the additional bc are needed at @xmath37 and they are usually of the form @xmath38 and @xmath39 , which can be treated as special cases of eq . ( [ bcn ] ) ( @xmath40 , @xmath41 for @xmath42 , and @xmath43 , @xmath44 for @xmath45 , respectively ) . one usually solves the normal diffusion equation by means of the laplace transform ( lt ) @xcite @xmath46 lt of the equation ( [ ne ] ) , boundary conditions ( [ bcn ] ) , and flux ( [ fn ] ) are , respectively , @xmath47 @xmath48 and @xmath49 the general solution of eq . ( [ ltne ] ) with the initial condition ( [ ic ] ) is @xcite @xmath50 where @xmath51 and @xmath52 are determined by the boundary conditions . the subdiffusive flux generated by the gradient of the concentration @xmath5 is given by the formula @xmath53 which combined with the continuity condition @xmath54 provides the subdiffusion equation ( [ se ] ) . the boundary condition at @xmath27 is assumed to be of the form fully analogical to that of the normal diffusion ( [ bcn ] ) i.e. @xmath55 the laplace transform of the subdiffusion equation , subdiffusive flux @xcite and boundary conditions are , respectively , @xmath56 @xmath57 @xmath58 the solution of eq . ( [ ltse ] ) for the initial condition @xmath59 , is computed as @xmath60 where the coefficients @xmath61 and @xmath62 are determined , as previously , by the boundary conditions ( [ ltsbc ] ) . let us note that substitution @xmath63 maps the laplace transforms of normal diffusion equation @xmath64 ( [ ltne ] ) , and flux @xmath65 ( [ ltfn ] ) onto the subdiffusion ones @xmath66 ( [ ltse ] ) and @xmath67 ( [ ltsf ] ) , respectively . assuming that the coefficients @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 are the same for the normal diffusion and for subdiffusion boundary conditions ( [ ltbc ] ) and ( [ ltsbc ] ) , the substitution ( [ sb ] ) transforms also the diffusion boundary condition @xmath72 ( [ ltbc ] ) into the subdiffusion one @xmath73 ( [ ltsbc ] ) . since the green s functions are uniquely determined by the subdiffusion equation , boundary conditions and initial condition ( which are assumed to be the same for normal diffusion and subdiffusion ) , it is clear that the substitution ( [ sb ] ) transforms the green s function for normal diffusion ( [ ltnfg ] ) into the green s function for subdiffusion ( [ ltsfg ] ) . comparing eq . ( [ ltnfg ] ) and eq . ( [ ltsfg ] ) we deduce that the coefficients @xmath61 and @xmath62 can be obtained from @xmath51 and @xmath52 by means of the replacement ( [ sb ] ) . as the green s function is given by eq . ( [ ltsfg ] ) , with the functions @xmath61 and @xmath62 of rather complicated structure ( as we will see in sec . 3.2 ) , the calculation of the inverse laplace transform is far not simple . therefore , we expand the function into the following series @xmath74 when the laplace transform is in such a form , the inverse transformation can be easily calculated , using the formula derived by means of the method based on the mellin transform @xcite ( for details of the derivation see the appendix ) @xmath75 where @xmath76 denotes the fox function , @xmath77 , and the parameter @xmath78 is not limited . due to the formula ( [ ge ] ) , we obtain the green s function as series of fox functions . as shown in the appendix , the function @xmath79 is given by the formula @xmath80\gamma \left ( 1+k\beta + \nu\right ) } { k!}\left ( -\frac{a}{t^{\beta}}\right ) ^{k}\;.\ ] ] the domain of applicability of eq . ( [ p ] ) appears to be limited @xcite . the fox function ( [ ge ] ) is analytical and has its series expansion ( [ p ] ) for every non - zero values of the variable @xmath81 when @xmath82 . otherwise , the additional restrictions should be imposed . for example , when @xmath83 , the equation ( [ p ] ) is still valid under the condition @xmath84 . in the following we consider the cases where @xmath85 , so we will not further discuss the domain of applicability of the formula ( [ p ] ) . to illustrate the considerations of the previous section , we find here the green s functions for the homogeneous system , which are well - known , and next we discuss a composite system containing two parts where , respectively , the normal diffusion and subdiffusion occur . as far as we know , such a system has not been considered yet . leaving the detailed analysis of this system to the next paper , we derive here the respective green s functions . since the subdiffusive homogeneous system has been already described in detail , we only show here that the procedure presented above gives the same results as that of the paper @xcite . for the homogeneous system of normal diffusion , the functions @xmath86 and @xmath87 from eq . ( [ ltnfg ] ) vanish . so , the laplace transform of gf is @xmath88 and the inverse laplace transform of ( [ ltfsr ] ) gives the gausian function @xmath89 the replacement ( [ sb ] ) transforms the gf for normal diffusion into the following function @xmath90 and due to eq . ( [ ge ] ) we obtain @xmath91 let us note that the fox function has several different representations equivalent to each other . using the formula @xcite @xmath92 & = & \frac{\alpha}{2}\frac{\mid x - x_{0}\mid}{\sqrt{d_{\alpha}t^{\alpha}}}h_{1\;1}^{1\;0}\bigg(\frac{\mid x - x_{0}\mid}{\sqrt{d_{\alpha}t^{\alpha}}}\mid^{\;\ ; 1-\frac{\alpha}{2}\;\;\;\;\frac{\alpha}{2}}_{\;\;\;\ ; 0\;\;\;\;\;\;\;1}\bigg)\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we transform the green s function ( [ ge1 ] ) to the one derived in @xcite . as a second example , we consider a system composed of two parts : @xmath93 ( @xmath94 ) where the normal diffusion occurs with the diffusion coefficient @xmath95 and @xmath96 ( @xmath97 ) where there is the subdiffusion with the subdiffusion coefficient @xmath98 . we assume the following boundary conditions at @xmath22 @xmath99 @xmath100 to use the procedure presented in the previous section , we temporarily assume that in the region @xmath96 the normal diffusion occurs with the diffusion coefficient @xmath101 . assuming that @xmath102 , the solutions of the diffusion equation with the boundary conditions ( [ bc1 ] ) and ( [ bc2 ] ) can be written in terms of the laplace transform as follows @xmath103 & + & \frac{1}{2\sqrt{d_{1l}s}}e^{-\mid x - x_{0}\mid \sqrt{s/ d_{1l}}}\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath94 , and @xmath104 for @xmath97 ( the index @xmath105 of green s function is assigned to the system where the normal diffusion occurs in both parts , the index @xmath106 corresponds to the system with normal diffusion and subdiffusion , the indices @xmath107 , @xmath108 refer to the signs of @xmath109 and @xmath110 , respectively ) . in the next step we pass from @xmath105 to @xmath106 functions . let us note that for the homogeneous system the substitution ( [ sb ] ) has been done for the whole system . however , for the composite one the substitution should be performed only with respect to the part where subdiffusion occurs . thus , @xmath111 whereas the coefficient @xmath95 remains unchanged . substituting ( [ sb1 ] ) in the functions ( [ ltnl ] ) and ( [ ltnr ] ) we obtain @xmath112 & + & \frac{1}{2\sqrt{d_{1l}s}}e^{-\mid x - x_{0}\mid \sqrt{s/ d_{1l}}}\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath113 it is easy to see that the functions ( [ ltsl ] ) and ( [ ltsr ] ) fulfil the laplace transforms of the boundary conditions ( [ bc1 ] ) and ( [ bc2 ] ) . expanding these functions into the series , we obtain @xmath114 + \frac{1}{\sqrt{d_{1l}}}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\left(-\sqrt{\frac{d_{\alpha r}}{d_{1l}}}\right)^{n+1}s^{\frac{(1-\alpha)n-\alpha}{2}}e^{- ( 2x_{m}-x - x_{0})\sqrt{s/ d_{1l}}}\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath115 & & \times s^{\frac{(1-\alpha)n+k-1}{2}}e^{-(x - x_{m})\sqrt{s^{\alpha}/ d_{\alpha r}}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] using the formula ( [ ge ] ) , we obtain from eqs . ( [ lts ] ) and ( [ lts+- ] ) the green s functions for the considered system @xmath116 + \frac{1}{\sqrt{d_{1l}}}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\left(-\sqrt{\frac{d_{\alpha r}}{d_{1l}}}\right)^{n+1}f_{\frac{(1-\alpha)n-\alpha}{2},\frac{1}{2}}\left(t;\frac{2x_{m}-x - x_{0}}{\sqrt{d_{1l}}}\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath117 & & \times f_{\frac{(1-\alpha)n+k-1}{2},\frac{\alpha}{2}}\left(t;\frac{x - x_{m}}{\sqrt{d_{1l}}}\right ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath118 the calculations are very similar to the ones presented above . in this case the green s functions are @xmath119 & & \times f_{\frac{(1-\alpha)n+\alpha k-1}{2},\frac{1}{2}}\left(t;\frac{x_{m}-x}{\sqrt{d_{1l}}}\right)\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath120\nonumber\\[2 mm ] & - & \frac{1}{\sqrt{d_{\alpha r}}}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\left(-\sqrt{\frac{d_{\alpha r}}{d_{1l}}}\right)^{n}f_{\frac{(1-\alpha)n+\alpha-1}{2},\frac{\alpha}{2}}\left(t;\frac{x+x_{0}-2x_{m}}{\sqrt{d_{\alpha}}}\right ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] to illustrate the above results we present two plots of the green s functions for several values of @xmath10 . in fig . 1 there are presented the green s functions ( [ sg ] ) and ( [ sg+- ] ) when the initial point @xmath121 is placed at the region @xmath93 ( with @xmath122 ) . 2 there are plots of the green s functions ( [ sg-+ ] ) and ( [ sg++ ] ) when the initial point is located at the region @xmath96 ( with @xmath123 ) ; here @xmath124 . we use the arbitrary units and the values of the parameters are : @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 , and @xmath128 . for the double series occurring in the functions ( [ sg+- ] ) and ( [ sg-+ ] ) , and for the function @xmath129 given by eq . ( [ p ] ) , there are taken first @xmath130 terms in each of the series . for the functions ( [ sg ] ) and ( [ sg++ ] ) given by the single series there are taken first @xmath131 terms and for the function @xmath79 we have taken first @xmath132 terms in the numerical calculations . we have checked that increasing these numbers does not change our results noticeably . let us briefly discuss the main qualitative differences between the green s functions for normal diffusion and the ones for @xmath133 . for the case of @xmath102 the inflection point of the green s functions is located at @xmath22 for @xmath134 whereas for the normal diffusion this point is placed in the region @xmath96 in a finite distance from the border between @xmath93 and @xmath96 . for the case of @xmath118 the differences between the considered green s functions are very similar to those between the green s function for a homogeneous diffusive and subdiffusive systems studied in @xcite . the procedure presented above allows one to solve the subdiffusion equations for the non - homogeneous systems such as a membrane system , layered system etc . the procedure uses the fact that the normal diffusion equation is simpler to solve than the subdiffusive one and the relation ( [ sb ] ) transforms the green s functions , diffusive equation and boundary conditions from the normal to the subdiffusive case . thus , knowing the laplace transform of @xmath135 one immediately obtains the laplace transform of @xmath136 . summarizing our considerations , the procedure to obtain the green s functions for the subdiffusive system with linear boundary conditions is presented as a do list : 1 . find the laplace transforms of the green s functions for the analogical system of the normal diffusion , 2 . obtain the laplace transform of the green s functions for subdiffusive system using the replacement ( [ sb ] ) ; when the system is divided into several parts , the replacement should be applied only to the part where the subdiffusion occurs , 3 . expand the laplace transform of green s function @xmath136 into the power series of @xmath137 multiplied by @xmath138 , 4 . use the formula ( [ ge ] ) to calculate the inverse laplace transform . the numerical calculations performed in sec . 3.2 , which give the green s functions presented in figs . 1 and 2 show usefulness of the method . it gives the explicitly analytic solutions of subdiffusive equations which are appropriate for numerical calculations . at the end we return to the method of mapping the green s function for normal diffusion to the subdiffusive one by the relation ( [ map ] ) which has been mentioned in the introduction . let us observe that substituting the expression ( [ sb2 ] ) in eq . ( [ map ] ) we obtain @xmath139 if we apply the replacement ( [ sb ] ) to the r.h.s . of eq . ( [ sb3 ] ) , we get the identity . so , the procedure presented in this paper is consistent with the procedure discussed in @xcite for the homogeneous system . the author wishes to express his thanks to stanisaw mrwczyski for fruitful discussions and critical comments on the manuscript . we derive here the relations ( [ ge ] ) and ( [ p ] ) . let us consider the laplace transform @xmath140\left ( s\right ) = s^{\nu}e^{-as^{\beta}}\\.\ ] ] the mellin transform @xmath141\left ( p\right)\equiv \int_{0}^{\infty}x^{p-1}f\left ( x\right ) dx\\,\ ] ] applied to the relation ( [ a1 ] ) gives @xmath142\left ( p\right ) = \frac{1}{\beta a^{\frac{p+\nu}{\beta}}}\gamma\left(\frac{p+\nu}{\beta}\right)\\.\ ] ] using the well - known formula @xmath143\left ( s\right)\right ] \left ( 1-p\right ) = \gamma\left ( 1-p\right ) m\left [ f\left ( t\right)\right]\left ( p\right)\\,\ ] ] we obtain @xmath144\left ( s\right)\right]\left ( 1-p\right)\right]\\.\ ] ] putting eq.([a2 ] ) in ( [ a3 ] ) and using the inverse mellin transform we get @xmath145 comparing above equation with the definition of the fox @xmath76-function @xmath146 where @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 , and the circle @xmath151 separates the poles of @xmath152 and @xmath153 , we obtain @xmath154 to get the poles of @xmath152 we take the relation @xmath155 , with @xmath156 , which gives @xmath157 using the relation @xmath158 we find @xmath159 where @xmath160 . so , we obtain @xmath161 additionally , we use the relation @xmath162 which gives @xmath163 from the above equation and the formulas ( [ a4 ] ) and ( [ a5 ] ) we get the relation ( [ p ] ) .

starting with the green s functions found for normal diffusion , we construct exact time - dependent green s functions for subdiffusive equation with fractional time derivatives . the green s functions satisfy the boundary conditions involving a linear combination of fluxes and concentrations . the method is particularly useful to calculate the concentration profiles in a multi - part system where different kinds of transport occurs in each part of it . as an example , we find the solution of subdiffusive equation for the system composed of two parts with normal diffusion and subdiffusion . = 8.5 in

0802.1683

a dilute solution of linear polymers in a gel provides the ideal case for reptation . the gel is a rigid network of obstacles which forces the polymer to find its way slithering through the maze . effectively the polymer moves inside a tube of pores which changes only by growing and shrinking at the ends of the tube . it is not a great step to replace the network of the gel by a regular lattice . the regularity of the lattice still keeps the motion of the polymer random , because the ends randomly leave or enter cells of the lattice . a big step is the reduction of the motion to a stochastic process of hopping units . it certainly can not be justified on the level of monomers , because neighboring monomers are strongly correlated in their motion . for this purpose the notion of reptons has been introduced : blobs of monomers of the size of the correlation length @xcite . seeing the polymer as a sequence of reptons , permits to consider the units of motion as uncorrelated , with the only proviso that they do not separate too far in order to preserve the integrity of the polymer . rubinstein @xcite designed an elementary model for reptation , as a chain of slack and taut links connecting the reptons . a slack link describes two successive reptons in the same cell and a taut link two in nearest neighbor cells . by allowing only these configurations of reptons and only moves between them , a simple model for reptation results . duke @xcite enriched the model by biasing the hopping of reptons by an external field , thus modeling the experimental situation of gel electrophoresis . of course the model misses important aspects of polymer dynamics , such as the hydrodynamic interactions and even more importantly the requirement of self - avoidance , which influences the universal properties @xcite . one can incorporate self - avoidance in the model , which makes however the analysis an order of magnitude more difficult . an excuse for leaving out this aspect is that mutual exclusion is for reptons less severe than for monomers , because the reptons are loosely packed blobs of monomers which can interpenetrate each other . the eternal dilemma is to choose between being realistic and keeping it simple . the chemical culture opts for being realistic and deals with specific properties , the physical culture leans towards simplicity and aims at generic properties . it was de gennes contribution to polymer physics to show that properties of long polymers do not depend on the specific composition , in particular the dependence on the length of the polymers is governed by universal exponents . in this sense the rubinstein - duke ( rd ) model has shown to catch the essential physics of reptation in spite of the crude approximations made . we will approach the problem from the physical perspective and deal with the universal properties of the rd model , but investigate a richer class of motions than treated sofar . in the standard rd model only interchange of slack and taut links is permitted . it means that the length stored in a slack link moves in the direction of a taut link , interchanging the slack and taut link . a move that would perfectly fit in the spirit of the rd model , is the change of two consecutive slack links into two taut links . it corresponds to three reptons in the same cell of which the middle one escapes to a neighboring cell . such a move does not cross a barrier . there was a practical reason to exclude this possibility , because it destroys the dimensional reduction , which was pointed out by duke . from a physical point of view , the formation of `` hernias '' does not seem to influence the universal properties and in this paper we investigate this issue . another optional move is the interchange of two taut links . as we will see this means the crossing of a barrier by the chain . if the barriers , posed by the obstacles were infinitely high , these processes would be strictly forbidden . but barriers are not perfect and therefore it is worthwile to investigate the influence of finite barriers . moreover we will see that barrier crossing in the rd model does not lead to much change , but the combination with hernia creation and annihilation has the drastic effect of crossing over from reptation to rouse dynamics . since the standard rd model already does not permit an exact solution , we have to rely on numerical methods to analyze the extended model . the most common method is simulation of the system but this is less suited for our goal , because the crossover between the two types of dynamics occurs for rather long chains which are hard to simulate accurately . we will employ the technique of finite size analysis , which requires very accurate data to be successful . in this paper we use a method , based on the analogy between the master equation and the schrodinger equation , by which the temporal evolution of the probability distribution of the chain configurations corresponds to the evolution of the wave function . the master operator corresponds to the hamiltonian of a one - dimensional spin chain , for which the very efficient density - matrix renormalization - group method ( dmrg ) has been designed by white @xcite . the model remains a one - dimensional quantum problem , irrespective the lattice in which it is embedded , because the chain itself is a linear structure . application of the dmrg method to the chain dynamics on the lattice is by now standard , but to perform successfully calculations in a @xmath0 embedding lattice requires an optimal use of the symmetries of the model in order to keep the basis set of states to a practical size . in the appendix we outline how we exploit the symmetries of the @xmath0 lattice . in the next section we describe the extension of the rd model and the corresponding master equation . we focus on two properties : the renewal time @xmath1 and the diffusion coefficient @xmath2 and determine them directly from the master operator . the renewal time is the time needed for the chain to assume a new configuration , which has no memory of the original one . it is found from the gap in the spectrum of the master operator . the master equation always has a trivial eigenvalue 0 , corresponding to the stationary state . any other initial state ultimately decays towards the stationary state and the slowest relaxation time ( the inverse of the gap ) is the renewal time . the gap decays with a negative power @xmath3 of the length @xmath4 of the chain , such that @xmath5 . the zero field diffusion coefficient @xmath2 is related to the drift velocity in a weak driving field and decays as a power @xmath6 . the approach to this asymptotic behavior is the main issue of this paper . due to the new types of hopping , the dimensionality @xmath7 of the embedding lattice plays a non - trivial role . we report , for the first time , on calculations in @xmath8 . they became possible through subtile use of the symmetries of the model , which are discussed in the appendix . the subsequent sections contain the results for the renewal exponent @xmath3 and the crossover functions , which describe the data for all lengths @xmath4 and strengths of the transition rates for barrier crossing and hernia creation / annihilation . the results for the diffusion coefficient @xmath2 and its exponent @xmath9 are calculated from a linearization of the master equation with respect to the driving field . the exponents @xmath3 and @xmath9 are linked through the mean square displacement of the wandering chains . in the discussion we comment on the results and explain why the crossover in gels is different from that in polymer melts . paessens and schtz @xcite have also extended the rd model by including `` constraint release '' in the hopping rates . in our language this is a mix of hernia creation / annihilation and barrier crossings . we comment their calculation in the discussion . earlier @xcite we have performed a similar investigation for the cage model ( in @xmath10 ) , with similar conclusions as the present study . investigation of the rd model elucidates in how far the crossover is model independent . the model consists of a chain of @xmath11 reptons located in the cells of a ( hyper)cubic lattice . they are connected by @xmath4 links , labeled by @xmath12 . the links take on the value @xmath13 ( slack ) or any of the @xmath14 vectors which connect a cell to its neighbors ( taut ) . the corners of the squares in @xmath10 or the edges of the cubes in @xmath8 are barriers for the chain . the reptons can move in three ways : 1 . the standard rd moves . a repton between a slack and taut link moves to the neighboring cell thereby interchanging the slack and taut link . for these moves no barriers have to be overcome . a move is illustrated in fig . [ rdmove ] . + the strength of the hopping rate for rd moves sets the time scale and is therefore put equal to 1 . 2 . the barrier crossings , of which an example is shown in fig . [ barrier ] . + this is an interchange of two taut links connected to the same repton that jumps over the barrier . the strength of the transition rate for such a move is taken to be @xmath15 . the creation of a hernia is the change from two consecutive slack links of which the middle repton jumps to a neighboring cell . the annihilation is the reverse process . an example is shown in fig . [ hernia ] . + hernia creation and annihilation go with the rate @xmath16 . the statistics of the model is governed by the master equation for the probability distribution @xmath17 , where @xmath18 stands for the complete configuration @xmath19 . it has the general form @xmath20 \equiv \sum_{\bf y ' } m({\bf y},{\bf y } ' ) p({\bf y}',t).\ ] ] the @xmath21 s are the transition rates of the possible motions that we have indicated in the above list . the matrix @xmath22 combines the gain terms ( in the off - diagonal elements ) and the loss terms ( on the diagonal ) . @xmath22 is the sum of matrices , for each repton one @xmath23 where the sum runs over the reptons starting with the tail repton @xmath24 to the head repton @xmath25 . the internal reptons induce transitions between two configurations which differ in two consecutive @xmath26 , the external ( head and tail ) repton change only @xmath27 viz . @xmath28 . if we view the links as `` bodies '' the problem is equivalent with a one - dimensional many body system with two body interactions between nearest neighbors . the matrix @xmath22 is asymmetric because the transition rates are biased by a factor @xmath29 for the moves in the direction of the field and by @xmath30 for the reverse process . @xmath31 is a dimensionless parameter representing the strength of the field . @xmath22 is a stochastic matrix since the sum over each column vanishes . therefore @xmath22 has an eigenvalue 0 and the corresponding right eigenvector is the probability density of the stationary state . all other eigenvalues are negative . the smallest in magnitude is the gap , giving the slowest decay to the stationary state and the inverse of the gap we take as the definition of the renewal time . the diffusion coefficient @xmath2 is calculated from an infinitesimal small driving field . the field induces a drift @xmath32 and via the einstein relation @xmath33 the diffusion coefficient results . it is determined by expansion of the master equation in powers of @xmath31 . @xmath34 which leads to the equations @xmath35 the first equation is trivially fulfilled by a constant @xmath36 , since the matrix @xmath37 is symmetric and the right eigenvector becomes equal to the trivial left eigenvector . the right hand side of the second equation is a known function of the configuration . thus it yields the linear perturbation @xmath38 . the drift velocity is an average over the distribution @xcite . the linear term in @xmath31 of the drift velocity involves the terms @xmath39 and @xmath38 . with these terms we can calculate the linear term in @xmath32 and find with ( [ a3 ] ) the diffusion coefficient @xmath2 . the easiest way to obtain the exponent of the relation @xmath40 is to make a log - log plot and determine the slope . in a previous publication @xcite it was shown that this is rather misleading for the present problem . a much more sensitive check is to compute local exponents @xmath41 according to @xmath42 which gives @xmath3 as a function of the chain length @xmath4 . the function @xmath41 is the basic ingredient for further analysis . first we check how accurate it can be obtained from a dmrg calculation of which the convergence is determined by the basis size @xmath43 . in fig . [ convhernia ] we show examples of poor and excellent convergence . poor convergence occurs for the combination @xmath44 , where we have no barrier crossings but substantial hernia creation / annihilation . for a length @xmath45 the size of the basis , even as large as m=160 , still has an influence and for longer chains this becomes stronger . thus it is difficult to deduce from these data the effective exponent for chains longer than @xmath45 . in the second combination @xmath46 the convergence is perfect for much smaller bases and for much longer chains , as the upper curve in the picture demonstrates . in fact the case with no barrier crossing at all is the only combination where convergence is a problem , as subsequent pictures will show . we blame the lack of convergence to the fact that hernia creation / annihilation without some barrier crossing leads to a large weight for configurations with many hernias and therefore to a short end - to - end distance of the chain . these are a - typical configurations and the dmrg procedure has difficulty to find an adequate basis to represent the gap state . some other noticeable points are : 1 . the curves have still not reached the asymptotic value for the values of @xmath4 of the order of 100 . thus a log - log plot would suggest a higher value than the reptation value 3 . this slow approach to the asymptotic value has been identified as the main reason for the discrepancy between the theoretical reptation exponent z=3 and the measured higher values @xcite . we get a better grip on the asymptotics when we discuss the crossover . 2 . the curves do not indicate a tendency towards the rouse exponent @xmath47 . this illustrates the point made in the introduction that the two mechanisms have to assist each other , before deviations from reptation occur . the next fig . [ lackbar ] shows a set of curves for @xmath48 and a set of values @xmath15 . note that the effective exponent is quite sensitive to the value of @xmath15 , but all curves do not show reptative behavior as was mentioned earlier for the @xmath4 dependence of a single point in parameter space . for larger values of @xmath15 , a maximum in the effective exponent @xmath41 seems to develop for larger and larger @xmath4 . as the maximum can easily be interpreted as a saturated asymptotic value in a log - log plot , these corrections to scaling , still present for very long chains , are very important for assessing the correct asymptotic behavior . this feature makes it neccesary to do a finite size analysis in order to get a grip on the region in @xmath4 where the behavior changes . the standard argument is that hernia creation / annihilation does not change the reptative character of the chain motion because they leave the backbone of the chain invariant , which is the collection of taut links after the chain has been successively stripped from its hernias . the backbone only changes by refreshment at the ends of the chain . also barrier crossing seems to be , as a single mechanism , ineffective . it changes the backbone , but not the number of taut links in a certain direction , since in a barrier crossing taut links are only interchanged in position along the chain . we may call the properties of the chain , which do not change by internal motion , `` quasi invariants '' . so one needs both a non - zero @xmath15 and a non - zero @xmath16 to remove these quasi invariants . the cooperation of hernia creation / annihilation and barrier crossing is a intricate mechanism . therefore we concentrate first on the situation that one of them has a finite strength and the other becomes small . the case where one of the two , @xmath15 or @xmath16 , is fixed at a finite value , gives a simple crossover from reptation to rouse dynamics when the chain grows with @xmath4 . as example consider first a fixed value @xmath49 and @xmath16 varying and small , for which the local exponent @xmath41 is given in fig . [ simcrossc1 ] . the reverse situation is plotted in fig . [ simcrossh1 ] with @xmath41 for @xmath50 and a set of values of @xmath15 . the two figures are strikingly similar . for small values of the parameter @xmath51 the chain seems to show reptative behavior but turns over towards the rouse exponent @xmath47 for longer chains . it is remarkable that even in fig . [ simcrossh1 ] the values for very small @xmath15 show this trend , while we know from the previous section that for @xmath52 the calculation is poorly convergent . anticipating the asymptotic values of the two regimes , the following representation is adequate for the renewal time ( for fixed @xmath16 ) . @xmath53 the idea is that all curves of e.g. fig . [ simcrossh1 ] are represented by a single curve @xmath54 . thus we have plotted in fig . [ scalingc5 ] the data for @xmath55 as function of @xmath56 for the fixed value @xmath57 and varying @xmath15 , with an assumed value @xmath58 this exponent is determined by trial and error to get the maximum collapse of the data on a single curve . the figure shows indeed a nice data collapse but it hides a subtlety which we can uncover using the properties of the crossover function @xmath54 . the function @xmath54 should be expandable for small arguments as @xmath59 and for large arguments as @xmath60 then @xmath1 goes as @xmath61 for vanishing @xmath15 and as @xmath62 for @xmath63 ( at non - zero @xmath15 ) . inserting the asymptotic behavior ( [ e4 ] ) into ( [ e1 ] ) we obtain @xmath64 where the dots refer to corrections of order @xmath65 . in fig . [ simtheta ] we have made a plot of the limit of @xmath66 vs @xmath67 . the values of the vertical axis are extrapolated to @xmath63 , which corresponds to the first two terms of ( [ e5 ] ) . we first check whether the basis of states is large enough , such that we have no systematic errors due to a too small basis . then we inspect whether @xmath68 has a well defined limiting value for @xmath63 . ( the values should approach the limiting point in a fairly linear way . ) if the curves in fig . [ simtheta ] had a straight slope , a well defined value of the crossover exponent @xmath69 follows . as one observes , there rather is a constant slope for small values of @xmath15 and another one for the larger values of @xmath15 . now crossover may only be expected in the limit of @xmath70 , which gives a slope in the neighborhood of @xmath71 . we could therefore discard the behavior for larger @xmath15 , as not being described by crossover , but this contrasts the findings for the cage model , where the crossover formula applies for practically the whole range of @xmath15 . we show the data also for larger values of @xmath15 because we find it intriguing that this region is also representable by a crossover function , albeit with a different crossover exponent . with one of the parameters @xmath16 or @xmath15 fixed it is the other parameter which controls the crossover . the real challenge is to find a representation where both mechanisms feature . we have not been able to find a simple expression which accurately accounts for arbitrary combinations of @xmath16 and @xmath15 . we gain some insight in the combined action of @xmath16 and @xmath15 by approaching the limit @xmath73 along a radial line @xmath72 . for fixed @xmath74 we have again a single parameter which , in combination with @xmath4 , provides a crossover scaling variable , such that we can use the scenario of the previous section to analyze the data . in fig . [ mixtheta ] we give the crossover exponent @xmath69 as a function of @xmath75 and for some values of the parameter ratio @xmath76 . for very small values of @xmath75 the slope of the line is compatible with the `` universal '' exponent @xmath77 . however for larger values another exponent seems to emerge of the order @xmath78 . note that the curves in fig . [ mixtheta ] run quite parallel , which means that @xmath74 only enters in the offset given by @xmath79 in ( [ e5 ] ) . to show this point in more detail we have plotted in fig . [ anotheta ] the lines for larger values of @xmath16 ( or @xmath15 ) . the window where the large exponent @xmath80 applies is more than an order of magnitude for a fixed ratio @xmath76 . the diffusion coefficient has been determined by the linearization ( [ a5 ] ) , which gives the linear response of the drift velocity with respect to the driving force . we do not repeat the analysis for the diffusion exponent @xmath9 , since diffusion and renewal time are closely related . if the center of the chain has drifted over a distance of the order of the end - to - end distance @xmath81 , the chain has renewed itself . the mean square displacement due to diffusion during a renewal time equals @xmath82 . so one has the connection @xmath83 this relation implies for the exponents @xmath84 . we have tested this relation and in fig . [ compexp ] we show the values of @xmath85 and @xmath86 for the same set of parameters , one for the small value @xmath87 , where the behavior is more reptative and one for the larger value @xmath88 , where the exponents tend to rouse dynamics . see also fig . [ compd2d3 ] which shows that the crossover exponent @xmath69 for renewal and for diffusion are practically the same in the domain where it could be calculated with reasonable accuracy . we have shown the results for embedding dimension @xmath8 . as mentioned the general expectation is that the embedding dimension has little influence on the universal properties . we are now in a position to verify this statement , since we have made extensive calculations both in @xmath10 and @xmath8 . indeed we come to the conclusion that the results agree qualitatively . to show an example we plot in fig . [ compd2d3 ] the @xmath8 and @xmath10 curves for @xmath69 for @xmath89 . the trends are the same , but the value of @xmath69 in the `` large '' parameter regime is definitely larger for @xmath8 than for @xmath10 . as a follow up of the study of crossover in the cage model , the extended rd model gives by and large the same picture : with growing length the chain crosses over from reptation to rouse dynamics . the story is here more complicated because the two extra types of hopping , barrier crossing and hernia creation / annihilation , have to assist each other in order to get rouse dynamics for long chains . this makes a comprehensive representation of the data in one scaling expression complicated . we have investigated the crossover behavior along lines in the @xmath90 plane . the underlying idea of crossover is that there are two competing time scales . one is the diffusive time scale @xmath91 , which is the time needed for a perturbation to diffuse along the chain inwards . we note that here not the overall diffusion @xmath2 but the curvilinear diffusion coefficient @xmath92 applies , which decays as @xmath93 . this timescale leads to a renewal time @xmath94 . the other time scale is the time needed to renew the chain by the combined action of hernia creation / annihilation and barrier crossing . if one of the parameters @xmath15 or @xmath16 is large enough , the other is the limiting factor . if @xmath15 is the smaller one , the timescale due to @xmath15 equals @xmath95 and if @xmath16 sets the rate , it is @xmath96 . the fastest of the two time scales sets the overall rate and therefore crossover occurs when they are equal i.e. when @xmath97 , or @xmath98 , whichever is the smaller parameter . this leads to a crossover exponent @xmath99 . we see this trend in the numerical data , but the fact that we have to go to really small values of @xmath15 ( or @xmath16 ) , and therefore to correspondingly large @xmath4 , prevents to see this `` universal '' crossover exponent in a clear way . on the other hand we observe for larger values of the parameters also crossover behavior , with different crossover exponents @xmath69 . this change in value could be a demonstration of corrections to scaling , just as the exponents @xmath41 or @xmath86 are rather far from their asymptotic values , also when crossover plays no role ( as e.g. fig . [ lackbar ] shows ) . clearly the renewal of the chain by sideways motion is still slow enough , even when @xmath15 and @xmath16 are of order unity , such that the competition with the diffusive renewal determines the character of the dynamics . as pointed out earlier for the cage model @xcite , the crossover differs from the common scenario for polymer melts , where the crossover is in the opposite direction : from rouse dynamics to reptation @xcite . in the melt reptation results for the longer chains because the restriction in motion of the polymer , due to the presence of others , becomes more severe the longer the polymer is . we have argued that such crossover in melts can be understood from sideways motion that have a rate depending on the length of the chain . if the renewal time is taken as indicative for the lifetime of a barrier , the sideways motion would have a rate @xmath100 in the melt . the combined scaling parameter @xmath101 then would shrink as @xmath4 grows . since we always find @xmath102 reptation prevails for long chains in the melt one would have to do a self consistent calculation , as carried out by paessens and schtz , to make this argument quantitative @xcite . paessens and schtz @xcite have also extended the rd model with rates that depend on the length of the chain . their aim is to see the influence of `` constraint release '' on finite chains . the constraint release that they allow is in our language a mix of hernia creation and annihilation and barrier crossing . but not all types of barrier crossing that we allow , are permitted in their model . so , it is a bit difficult to make a clear comparison between their findings and ours . the interesting point of their calculation is the requirement of selfconsistency : the rates determine the renewal time and the renewal time in turn influences the rates . to carry out this program accurately within the dmrg method is one of the challenges for further research . * acknowledgment * the authors have benefitted very much from many stimulating discussions with gerard barkema . thanks wroclaw centre for networking and computing for access for their computing facilities ( grant no . it is easy to set up a dmrg without paying attention to the symmetries of the problem . then in @xmath8 each link can be in @xmath103 states , leading to @xmath104 configurations for @xmath11 reptons . the possible symmetries in the problem will give an equal probability to many configurations . if the symmetries are not explicitely acknowledged , the symmetries get lost when the choice of basis states does not conserve the symmetry . this means that states , which are equivalent by symmetry , have to be chosen simultaneously . thus either one has to include a large number of states , which leads to impractical calculations , or one has to keep track of the symmetry in each step of the method , which requires a substantial extra amount of careful programming . however , since we want to extract the utmost out of the data , we have no choice and must optimize the symmetry . as we deal with the fieldless gap for the renewal time and with the fieldless equation ( [ a5 ] ) , we can employ , in principle , the full symmetry group of the cube , which has 48 elements . if we were to do an exact calculation , we could apply all the relevant symmetry operations to the wavefunction and so reduce the number of components . but that is not the way dmrg works . the configuration space is splitted into a tail and head part and the wavefunction is improved by an optimal choice of basis states in one part using the density matrix induced by the other part . in order to keep the symmetry in the wavefunction , the chosen states have to have the symmetry , which implies that the density matrix must have the symmetry . that in turn implies that , in each stage of the calculation , the wavefunction of the whole chain must have the desired symmetry . thus we have to know how to combine symmetry of the parts in order to get the symmetry of the whole . this is similar to combining angular momenta of particles in atomic physics to get the angular momentum of the total wavefunction . the `` good quantum numbers '' derive from a set of commuting symmetry operators . we can find at most 3 commuting operators within the cubic group , with some freedom of choice . the simplest would be to look to the reflection symmetry of the coordinate axes . for each of the 3 operations the wavefunction can be even or odd , giving 8 sectors labeled by the parities . the parities qualify as good quantum numbers . the groundstate ( stationary state ) is located in the sector which is even under all three reflections . each of the other sectors contains an excited state and the smallest ( in magnitude ) is the gap . the parities of the parts can be easily be combined to parities for the total since they simply multiply . we have implemented this scheme , but it does not lead to very accurate results , which we blame to the rather unbalanced occupation of the sectors , when the most probable states of the density matrix are chosen . the most successful use of the symmetry comes from another choice of commuting symmetry operations . we put the field in the direction of the body diagonal and consider rotations around this diagonal . we may rotate over the angles @xmath105 or @xmath106 , leaving the problem invariant . under a rotation the wavefunction is multiplied with a phase factor @xmath107 , which qualifies also as a good quantum number , leading to 3 sectors . rotations commute with simultaneous inversion of the coordinate axes , doubling each of the 3 rotation sectors . as first 3 sectors we take those which are invariant under inversion and the next 3 are odd under inversion . the groundstate is in the first and the gap is the fourth sector ( invariant under rotation and odd under inversion ) . the advantage of these good quantum numbers is that we can combine the quantum numbers of parts ( by simple multiplication ) to the same set of quantum numbers for the combination . for instance a part in sector 2 ( @xmath108 ) and one in sector 3 ( @xmath109 ) lead to a combination with @xmath110 , which is therefore in sector 1 . this use of symmetry gives good results , but it is not yet optimal . a refinement could be made by considering the interchange of the @xmath9 and the @xmath111 axis . this turns the first and fourth sector into itself and transforms sector 2 and 3 as well as 4 and 5 into each other . although there is no good quantum number associated with this operation , we could use this symmetry by splitting sector 1 and 4 into an even and odd part under the interchange . this leads to 8 `` channels '' , which partly coincide with the previous sectors . combining a part in sector ( channel ) 2 with a part in 3 does give an overall state in sector 1 , but one has to take even and odd combinations to get them in the even and odd channel corresponding to sector 1 . this gives a substantial amount of extra programming in order to keep properly track of the channels . but the effort is rewarded , as it improves the accuracy which is needed for the delicate cases of the parameter space . this choice of sectors ( channels ) is efficient because the states of the density matrix , which are chosen as having the largest eigenvalues , are more or less evenly distributed over the channels .

the competition between reptation and rouse dynamics is incorporated in the rubinstein - duke model for polymer motion by extending it with sideways motions , which cross barriers and create or annihilate hernias . using the density - matrix renormalization - group method as solver of the master equation , the renewal time and the diffusion coefficient are calculated as function of the length of the chain and the strength of the sideways motion . these new types of moves have a strong and delicate influence on the asymptotic behavior of long polymers . the effects are analyzed as function of the chain length in terms of effective exponents and crossover scaling functions . pacs 61.25.hk , 05.10.-a , 83.10.kn

1406.2072

graphene plasmonics has recently emerged as a promising platform for studying strong light - matter interactions.@xcite graphene is a novel two - dimensional ( 2d ) material @xcite with unique electronic and optical properties @xcite and a wide range of applications such as biosensors,@xcite ultrafast lasers , @xcite optical modulators , @xcite and photodetectors . @xcite clean graphene samples are characterized by long electron scattering times and much lower , compared to metals , ohmic losses due to relatively weak electron - phonon interaction . @xcite charge - doped graphene with fermi energy , @xmath0 , in the range 0.2 - 0.6 ev exhibits a stable in - plane plasmon in the infrared frequency range @xcite with gate - tunable wavelength , @xmath1 , well below radiation wavelength at the same frequency . @xcite a large local density of states ( ldos ) of graphene plasmons as compared to that of surface plasmon polaritons ( spp ) on metal surfaces ensures very efficient plasmon excitation by a local probe such as an excited dye molecule or an exciton in semiconductor quantum dot ( qd ) situated at a close distance to the graphene sheet . @xcite recent measurements @xcite of nonradiative energy transfer from a dye molecule to graphene pointed to a strong coulomb coupling between electronic excitations in these two systems with transfer rates exceeding the radiative decay rate by a factor of @xmath210@xmath3 . plasmons can also provide efficient coupling between several emitters situated near a graphene sheet , e.g. , by enhancing superradiance from two excited qds @xcite or facilitating long - distance energy transfer between a donor and an acceptor . @xcite these studies explored weak coupling regime between graphene plasmons and excitons , i.e. , the energy spectra of these excitations are not significantly altered by the optical interactions between them . here we demonstrate that a _ strong _ coupling between excitons and graphene plasmons can be realized in a hybrid graphene - semiconductor system giving rise to a propagating exciton - plasmon state with a mixed 2d dispersion ( hereafter referred to as exciton - plasmariton@xcite ) . strong exciton - plasmon coupling effects have been recently studied between surface plasmon - polaritons ( spp ) or localized surface plasmons in metal structures and excitons in dye j - aggregates , @xcite individual dye molecules , @xcite semiconductor quantum wells ( qw ) , @xcite or qds and nanoscrystals . @xcite in these systems , very large rabi splittings ( relative to vacuum rabi splitting @xcite ) were reported in the range of 100 - 200 mev for dispersion of spp coupled to molecular excitons @xcite and in the range of 200 - 450 mev for absorption / transmission spectra of excitons coupled to localized plasmons ( plexcitons ) , @xcite while relatively small splittings ( @xmath4 mev ) were observed for spp coupled to qw excitons.@xcite the optical excitation energies in the above experiments were in the range 1 - 3 ev to match those of plasmon resonances in metal nanostructures . in contrast , stable graphene plasmons have significantly lower energies ( below @xmath5 ev in highly doped samples ) and , to the best of our knowledge , strong coupling regime in graphene has not yet been explored . here we show that a strong exciton - graphene plasmon coupling can be achieved in a hybrid structure comprised of doped graphene monolayer separated by a thin spacer from a narrow gap semiconductor qw . the proposed structure is schematically shown in fig . [ fig : fig1](a ) . the tunneling barrier between qw and graphene , spacer i , prevents a photoinduced charge transfer from qw to graphene . in this case , quasiparticles in graphene ( plasmons ) and qw ( excitons ) interact with each other only via direct coulomb coupling . the qw rests on a dielectric substrate separated by spacer ii . as examples , we chose four narrow gap semiconductor qws : inas , insb , and hgcdte ( hct ) with two different cd concentrations corresponding to hct bulk bandgaps of @xmath6 ev and 0.3 ev . @xcite in fig . [ fig : fig1](b ) , the exciton dispersion relations for all qws are plotted together with the plasmon dispersion . in principle , both exciton and plasmon energies as well as the coulomb coupling between them are subject to complex dielectric screening determined by spacer layer widths @xmath7 and @xmath8 , qw width @xmath9 , and dielectric constants of all the materials involved . for example , by varying the parameters of the layered structure , the coulomb coupling strength can be tuned in a wide range . in this paper , we assume a simplified model of dielectric screening by introducing a single effective dielectric constant , @xmath10 , and using it as a free parameter . for example , fig . [ fig : fig1](b ) shows the graphene plasmon and qw exciton dispersions for effective dielectric constant of @xmath11 and the graphene charge - doping level of @xmath12 ev . at this doping level , graphene plasmon is landau damped at @xmath13 nm@xmath14 , the onset of damping marked by red cross in fig . [ fig : fig1](b ) . it can be seen that , for the chosen semiconductor qws , the plasmon and excitons dispersion curves intersect at @xmath15 well below the damping onset . at smaller @xmath10 , exciton energies decrease ( due to stronger electron - hole interaction ) and plasmon energies increase , resulting in the exciton - plasmon resonance at even smaller @xmath15 . for small separations between graphene and qw , we thus expect a mixed exciton - plasmon state to form due to strong coulomb coupling between its constituent excitations . we show that the dynamics of exciton - plasmaritons can be accurately described by a simple hamiltonian similar to exciton - polariton hamiltonian with exciton - plasmon coupling constant strongly affected by the system parameters . we explore the strong coupling regime by performing numerical calculations involving full graphene response functions and compare the results to our model . the calculated rabi splitting between the exciton - plasmariton upper and lower dispersion branches strongly depends on system parameters and can reach values @xmath250 - 100 mev for small graphene - qw separation @xmath7 . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec : hamiltonian ] we present our model for coupled qw exciton and graphene plasmon and derive the exciton - plasmariton hamiltonian and its energy spectrum within plasmon - pole approximation . in sec . [ sec : numerics ] we perform numerical calculations of exciton - plasmariton energy spectrum using graphene full response functions and compare the results to those of our model . technical details of calculations are described in appendices . ( a ) schematics of the device . ( b ) plasmon and exciton dispersion relations are shown by thick turquoise and thin lines , respectively . the bulk bandgap of hct is given in parentheses in the legend . the qw width and the fermi energy in graphene are @xmath16 nm and @xmath12 ev , respectively . plasmon - exciton resonances and the onset of landau damping are marked by black and red crosses , respectively . graphene electron - hole transition continua are shown in grey . , width=288 ] we consider a qw of width @xmath9 separated from a monolayer graphene by a sufficiently high potential barrier of thickness @xmath7 . the system hamiltonian is @xmath17 , where @xmath18 and @xmath19 are many - body hamiltonians for electronic excitations in qw and graphene , respectively , and @xmath20 describes the coulomb interaction between them . in the absence of free electron population in qw , the main contribution to @xmath21 comes from the interaction of interband polarization in qw with the electric field due to charge density fluctuations in graphene ( see appendix [ app : ham ] ) @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the dipole transition operator between conduction ( @xmath24 ) and valence ( @xmath25 ) bands and @xmath26 are bloch functions ( @xmath27).@xcite the electric field @xmath28 acting on exciton in qw is generated by density fluctuations in graphene @xmath29,\ ] ] where @xmath30 is 3d coordinate , @xmath31 and @xmath32 being in - plane and out - of - plane coordinates , respectively , and integration is carried over graphene plane @xmath33 . the in - plane fourier transform of the coulomb potential , @xmath34 , is given by @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the in - plane momentum and @xmath37 is the effective dielectric constant . electron density operator and the average electron density in graphene are denoted by @xmath38 and @xmath39 , respectively , . our goal is to derive effective exciton - plasmon hamiltonian . to this end , let us first recast @xmath21 in second - quantized electron - hole form . in a standard manner,@xcite the bloch function splits into envelope and periodic parts , @xmath40 , where the latter defines the interband dipole matrix element averaged over unit cell volume @xmath41 , @xmath42 , while the envelope functions @xmath43 describe `` free '' electrons in qw , where @xmath44 is the size - quantization wave function in qw and @xmath45 is the normalization area ( hereafter set to unity ) . performing 2d fourier transform , we obtain @xmath46 where @xmath47 , @xmath48 are electron ( annihilation ) and hole ( creation ) operators defined in a usual way through their conduction and valence band counterparts,@xcite and @xmath49 is the fourier transform of graphene density operator , @xmath50 being electron operator in graphene ( as usual , the point @xmath51 is excluded ) . the matrix element @xmath52 is evaluated as @xmath53u_{cv}(q),\ ] ] where ( for @xmath54 ) @xmath55 is overlap between gpaphene coulomb potential and qw excitations across the structure . we now introduce the exciton creation operator in a standard manner @xcite as @xmath56 where @xmath57 , @xmath58 ( @xmath59 ) are the relative electron and hole effective masses , and @xmath60 is the 2d fourier transform of eigenfunction @xmath61 of the wannier equation ( @xmath62 is the exciton center of mass momentum and @xmath63 is its quantum state ) . using the orthogonality relation @xmath64 , eq . ( [ eq : hint_eh ] ) takes the form @xmath65 where @xmath66 characterizes the strength of exciton coupling to charge density fluctuations in graphene , and @xmath67 and @xmath68 are , respectively , projections of @xmath69 onto @xmath32-axis and vector @xmath62 ( note that @xmath70 ) . other terms of the hamiltonian that contain qw electron and hole operators can be expressed in excitonic variables using standard projection technique . the free exciton hamiltonian has the usual form @xcite @xmath71 , where @xmath72 is exciton dispersion ( see below ) while higher - order terms including exciton - exciton scattering and exciton scattering by graphene density fluctuations are negligible for low exciton densities we consider ( see appendix [ app : ham ] ) . the hamiltonian of qw exciton interacting with graphene density fluctuations then takes the form @xmath73 the energy spectrum of exciton - plasmatiton can be obtained from exciton green function `` dressed '' due to the interactions with graphene density fluctuations . in the rotating wave approximation , the non - interacting exciton green function can be written as @xmath74 , where @xmath75 is free exciton damping . the interaction with graphene excitations results in the appearance of the exciton self - energy in the green function , @xmath76 where , in the lowest order in qw - graphene coupling , the spectrum is determined by the density - density correlation function in graphene , @xmath77 : @xmath78 . it is important to note here that even though the spectra of electronic excitations in graphene and qw are assumed isotropic by themselves , this is not necessarily the case for exciton - plasmaritons due to the possible anisotropy in the coupling constant , @xmath79 . this anisotropy originates from the directionality of @xmath69 and is , therefore , maximized when @xmath69 is parallel to the graphene plane [ see eq . ( [ eq : t_coupl ] ) ] . within the random phase approximation ( rpa ) , the density - density correlation function in graphene is given by @xmath80 $ ] , where @xmath81 is the polarization bubble in graphene and @xmath82 . in the following we restrict ourselves to the lowest @xmath83 excitonic state in a narrow qw ( @xmath84 ) characterized by wave function @xmath85 where @xmath86 is a 2d bohr radius . the exciton energy is @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is the excitation energy of the lowest qw exciton . here , @xmath89 is the bulk bandgap energy , @xmath90 is exciton reduced mass , @xmath91 is exciton binding energy , and the second term in the r.h.s . is correction to the bulk bandgap energy due to the quantum confinement in qw . for a symmetric qw , the transverse part of envelope functions of the lowest qw subband is @xmath92 . then the coulomb overlap @xmath93 can be explicitly evaluated as @xmath94 in the long - wave limit , the graphene polarization bubble has the form @xmath95 , so that @xmath77 is dominated by the plasmon pole @xmath96 where @xmath97 and @xmath98 are , respectively , plasmon energy dispersion and damping rate ( in energy units ) . combining eqs . ( [ eq : t_coupl ] ) and ( [ eq : pi_plpole ] ) , we obtain the exciton self - energy as @xmath99 where the exciton - plasmon coupling , @xmath100 , is given by @xmath101 with the above self - energy , the poles of eq . ( [ exciton - green ] ) determine two exciton - plasmariton energy branches , @xmath102,\ ] ] where @xmath103 and @xmath104 . to gain more insight , we note that eq . ( [ spectrum ] ) is the energy spectrum of a simple two - level hamiltonain where both the energies of the two levels , @xmath105 and @xmath106 , and the coupling between them , @xmath107 , are dependent on @xmath62 . this observation can be made precise by casting the graphene hamiltonian in terms of plasmon normal modes , @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is a plasmon creation operator . after expanding the graphene charge density operator in eq . ( [ ham - int ] ) over these normal modes , @xcite the hamiltonian ( [ ham2 ] ) of qw excitons interacting with graphene plasmons takes the form @xmath110\biggr ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where exciton - plasmon coupling @xmath111 is defined by eq . ( [ coupling ] ) . the imaginary part of @xmath105 and @xmath106 has to be interpreted in a usual manner as a decay constant of a metastable state . the corresponding lifetimes of an exciton and plasmon are given by @xmath112 and @xmath113 , respectively . the hamiltonian ( [ ham - final ] ) is similar to that describing exciton - polaritons and can be brought to canonical form by a standard bogolubov - hopfield transformation @xcite yielding , near the resonance , two dispersion branches eq . ( [ spectrum ] ) which , in general , are anisotropic in @xmath36-plane due to the dependence of exciton - plasmon coupling @xmath111 on the exciton polarization . note that if @xmath62 is parallel to the projection of @xmath69 onto the @xmath114-plane , then the coupling is maximized and @xmath115 , so that @xmath116 . this condition is assumed fulfilled hereafter . at resonance , @xmath117 , corresponding to momentum @xmath118 , the rabi frequency @xmath119 has the form @xmath120 and strongly depends on system parameters . all the analytical considerations above were based on the plasmon dispersion @xmath121 , eq . ( [ eq : pi_plpole ] ) . however , this simple dispersion relation becomes inaccurate in the high-@xmath10 dielectric environment due to non - local effects . it turns out that the dispersion relation could be analytically corrected to account for such effects ( see appendix [ app : high - k ] for detail ) . below we compare eq . ( [ spectrum ] ) , augmented by this corrected dispersion relation , to full numerical calculations of the energy spectrum of the system . numerical calculations were performed for four narrow - gap semiconductors , insb ( @xmath122 ev ) , @xcite inas ( @xmath123 ev ) , @xcite and hgcdte ( hct ) with two different cd concentrations corresponding to @xmath6 ev and @xmath124 ev . @xcite the electron and hole effective masses for these materials are taken from refs . . for each material , the dispersion of qw exciton intersects plasmon dispersion in graphene doped to @xmath125 ev before the landau damping onset ( see fig . [ fig : fig1 ] ) . unless otherwise noted , full rpa response functions for graphene were employed in numerical calculations ( see appendix [ app : polariz ] for detail ) and standard materials parameters were used . the interband matrix element @xmath126 was estimated as @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the kane energy , @xmath129 is the kane momentum matrix element and @xmath130 is the inter band transition momentum . for semiconductor materials considered in this work we have @xmath131 ev , @xmath132 ev and @xmath133 ev . @xcite surface plot of the logarithm of spectral function for the exciton - plasmariton , @xmath134 , for ( a ) hct with @xmath135 ev and ( b ) inas . the effective dielectric constant is set to @xmath136 ( panel a ) and @xmath137 ( panel b ) . other system parameters are set to @xmath12 ev , @xmath138 nm and @xmath139 nm . to make the excitonic `` ridge '' broader and more visible , we substituted @xmath140 ps in this figure . , width=288 ] figure [ fig : fig2 ] shows 3d log plot of exciton spectral function @xmath141 ( in arbitrary units ) as defined by eq . ( [ exciton - green ] ) for htc and inas qws of width @xmath16 nm , separated from the graphene by @xmath138 nm thickness spacer , and effective dielectric constants of the structure @xmath136 and @xmath137 , respectively . plasmon decays time is taken @xmath142 ps . @xcite exciton lifetime can vary in a wide range depending on specific parameters of the system , e.g. , qw thickness.@xcite here we assume a very conservative value of @xmath143 ps . since @xmath144 , the specific value for the exciton lifetime is largely irrelevant . with the chosen parameters , both exciton - plasmariton branches are seen to be well - separated in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] . in figs . [ fig : fig3 ] and [ fig : fig4 ] we show density plot of @xmath145 vs. momentum @xmath15 for inas and htc qws for two different effective dielectric constants . thin black lines , superimposed on top of the density plots , show the dispersion relations of exciton - plasmariton dispersion branches calculated from eq . ( [ spectrum ] ) . we see that with increasing @xmath10 , the splitting between exciton - plasmariton branches is strongly reduced while the resonance position is shifted towards higher @xmath15 . both effects can be traced to exciton - plasmon coupling which is directly affected by increase of dielectric constant , @xmath146 . at the same time , increasing @xmath10 reduces the exciton binding energy and hence shifts the resonance position to higher @xmath15 which , in turn , leads to a decrease of @xmath93 resulting in an even stronger reduction of @xmath147 . density plot of the spectral function for the exciton - plasmariton in inas . the effective dielectric constant is set to @xmath148 ( panel a ) and to @xmath137 ( panel b ) . other system parameters are set to @xmath12 ev , @xmath138 nm and @xmath139 nm . , width=288 ] density plot of the spectral function for the exciton - plasmariton in hct ( @xmath135 ev ) . the effective dielectric constant is set to @xmath149 ( panel a ) and to @xmath136 ( panel b ) . other system parameters are set to @xmath12 ev , @xmath138 nm and @xmath139 nm . , width=288 ] since the _ exciton _ spectral function is plotted , only the exciton - like branch is expected to be seen at vanishing exciton - plasmon coupling . indeed , the intensity of plasmon - like branches is seen to decrease for larger @xmath10 . as can be seen in all the panels , the analytical curves for the dispersion ( thin black lines ) agree reasonably well with the numerical results , seen as ridges in density plots . therefore , we will rely on analytical model in our further analysis . strength of exciton - plasmon coupling versus ( a ) effective dielectric constant , ( b ) fermi energy , ( c ) thickness of spacer i and ( d ) thickness of the quantum well . the system parameters are set to @xmath136 , @xmath12 ev , @xmath138 nm and @xmath16 nm except for that varied in each panel ( e.g. , @xmath10 in panel a ) . red crosses mark the onset of landau damping and dashed lines correspond to short - living plasmons that live within the electron - hole sector and , therefore , are subject to landau damping . , width=336 ] in fig . [ fig : fig5 ] we plot the rabi splitting @xmath150 given by eq . ( [ rabi ] ) as a function of various system parameters . panel ( a ) shows the dependence of rabi splitting on the effective dielectric constant of the structure , @xmath10 . in addition to aforementioned reduction of @xmath150 for larger @xmath10 , it has a maximum at @xmath151 followed by its sharp decrease for smaller @xmath10 . the latter is caused by the reduction of the _ total _ exciton energy @xmath152 as the exciton _ binding _ energy @xmath153 increases , which leads to a sharp drop of @xmath150 [ see eq . ( [ rabi ] ) ] . such a strong effect is caused by the cubic energy dependence of plasmon oscillator strength [ see eq . ( [ eq : pi_plpole ] ) ] . the rise of @xmath150 as a function of fermi energy , shown in panel ( b ) , is due to the resonance shift to smaller momenta ( @xmath154 ) which leads to increase of the coulomb overlap @xmath93 . it should be noted that behavior of @xmath155 is rather complicated and depends on qw width @xmath9 as well as separation between graphene and qw planes @xmath7 [ see eq . ( [ eq : ucv ] ) ] . it can be seen that for insb and htc qws with comparable @xmath156 the dependence is linear , while for inas ( larger @xmath156 ) and htc ( 0.2 ev ) ( smaller @xmath156 ) qws there are slight deviations from linearity . the overall magnitude is determined by the prefactor of @xmath157 originating from the graphene coulomb potential which suppresses plasmon - exciton coupling for small @xmath0 corresponding to large @xmath156 . the same prefactor determines the dependence of @xmath150 on spacer thickness @xmath7 in panel ( c ) . indeed , the exponential decay of plasmon - exciton coupling strength with spacer thickness causes @xmath150 to vanish for @xmath7 in the range from 7 nm to 24 nm for qws used , signaling the end of strong coupling regime . finally , panel ( d ) shows the dependence of @xmath150 on qw width @xmath9 . rabi splitting decreases as @xmath155 in eq . ( [ eq : ucv ] ) decreases for large @xmath9 . for smaller @xmath9 , however , the @xmath9-dependence of @xmath150 can become non - monotonic . the reason for this is that at small @xmath9 the exciton energy becomes higher due to the qw size - quantization , so the plasmon and exciton dispersion intersect at higher energies ( and momenta ) leading to a less efficient coupling . finally , for @xmath158 nm the plasmon dispersion enters the electron - hole excitation continuum before it meets the exciton dispersion . in this case , the graphene plasmon is short - lived and , therefore , the excition - plasmariton is no longer a stable excitation . in summary , we studied strong coupling between a graphene plasmon and a two - dimensional exciton in a narrow gap semiconductor quantum well separated from graphene by a potential barrier . we developed an analytical model based on hamiltonian similar to that for exciton - polaritons that accurately describes mixed exciton - plasmon states ( exciton - plasmaritons ) and calculated energy dispersion curves for several semiconductor materials . authors would like to thank g. khodaparast for a helpful discussion . work at lanl was performed under the nnsa of the u.s . doe at lanl under contract no . de ac52 - 06na25396 . work at jsu was supported by the nsf under grant no . the interaction hamiltonian between the qw and graphene is @xmath159 where @xmath160 is the electron field annihilation operator in qw . integral is evaluated over the volume of qw . the electrostatic potential due to charge density fluctuations in graphene is given by @xmath161 where the integral is evaluated over graphene . in the second quantization representation , electron field operators are expanded as @xmath162 where @xmath163 is the electron annihilation operator in band @xmath164 with ( quasi)momentum @xmath165 in the first brillouin zone and @xmath166 is the corresponding bloch function . substituting this definition of the field operator into eq . ( [ eq : hqwg ] ) , the hamiltonian takes the form @xmath167 where @xmath168 in turn , bloch functions can be expand into the basis of wannier functions , @xmath169 , as @xcite @xmath170 where @xmath171 is the total number of unit cells and the sum runs over lattice sites @xmath172 . wannier functions are normalized as @xmath173 . rewriting @xmath174 via wannier functions one obtains @xmath175 since the potential @xmath176 is smooth on atomic scale , we expand it within each unit cell as @xmath177 . the first term , after substituting into ( [ c2 ] ) yields @xmath178 where @xmath179 is the fourier transform of @xmath176 . to evaluate the second expansion term , we neglect the overlap of localized wannier wavefunctions at different lattice sites so that diagonal terms vanish . for non - diagonal terms we obtain @xmath180 where @xmath181 is the valence to conduction band transition dipole moment . using the definition of wannier functions , eq . ( [ eq : wannier ] ) , it can be rewritten in a more standard form @xmath182 where @xmath183 is the conduction ( valence ) bandedge bloch function , and the integration is assumed over the unit cell . substituting @xmath184 and @xmath185 into eq . ( [ h2 ] ) we obtain @xmath186 with @xmath187 the latter expression can be rewritten in a more intuitive form @xmath188 where @xmath189 is the transition dipole moment operator of the qw unit cell . the operator of electric field due to charge density fluctuations in graphene is @xmath190 . the hamiltonian @xmath191 describes interaction of _ interband _ qw excitations ( excitons ) with the electric field of graphene . it represents the starting point of this work . in contrast , @xmath192 describes interactions of _ intraband _ density fluctuations in qw with those in graphene . after recasting in exciton basis , this term describes qw exciton scattering on graphene plasmons . at low exciton densities and at low temperatures these processes are weak and not considered here . the bare density correlation function ( polarization bubble ) , is calculated within the dirac electrons approximation as @xcite @xmath193}{\sqrt{\omega^{2}-v_{f}^{2}q^{2}}}\nonumber \\ + \left.\frac{\left[g(\delta_{-})+i\pi\right]\theta\left[{\rm re}\left\ { \delta_{-}\right\ } + 1\right]-g(\delta_{+})}{\sqrt{\omega^{2}-v_{f}^{2}q^{2}}}\right],\label{eq : full_pop}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath194 and @xmath195 . the square roots are chosen to yield positive real parts and the imaginary part of the logarithm is taken in @xmath196 $ ] range . fermi velocity and fermi level ( the latter determines the extent of graphene charge - doping ) are denoted by @xmath197 and @xmath198 , respectively . within the dirac electrons approximation , the density correlation function is insensitive to the sign of the fermi level , so in all the expressions here and in the main text @xmath198 has to be understood as @xmath199 . the two important limiting forms of the density correlation function are ( i ) the long wavelength limit ( @xmath200 , @xmath201 ) , and ( ii ) the static limit ( @xmath202 , @xmath203 ) . the long wavelength limit is given by @xmath204 the static limit of the bare density correlation function is obtained as @xmath205 the naive substitution @xmath206 to account for in - graphene scattering losses in eq . ( [ eq : full_pop ] ) ( @xmath98 is the electron scattering rate in energy units ) is inaccurate in a general case ( especially if @xmath98 is not small ) , since it does not preserve the particle conservation requirement . to correct for this , the more accurate mermin procedure is adopted , yielding @xcite @xmath207 the full ( or dressed " ) density correlation function , which accounts for screening in graphene , is obtained within the random phase approximation as @xmath208 where @xmath209 is the two - dimensional fourier transform of the coulomb potential within the graphene s plane , @xmath210 . the effective dielectric constant of the environment @xmath10 is in general determined by the specific geometry of the graphene - based device and bulk dielectric constants of its material constituents . for example , in the simplest case of the interface between two homogeneous materials with dielectric constants @xmath211 and @xmath212 , the effective dielectric constant at the interface is given by @xmath213 . @xcite the plasmon dispersion relation , @xmath214 , is found by requiring the real part of the denominator of eq . ( [ eq : pop_rpa ] ) to vanish . the taylor expansion of the denominator around this point ( up to leading terms in both real and imaginary parts ) leads to the possibility of approximating the full density correlation function within the so called plasmon pole approximation as ( for @xmath215 ) @xmath216 where @xmath217 is the amplitude of plasmon pole , and @xmath218 is the plasmon energy - dissipation rate . the coefficients of the taylor expansion of the denominator of eq . ( [ eq : pop_rpa ] ) are @xmath219 \right|_{\omega=\omega_q},\nonumber \\ b_q&=-v_q{\rm im}\left[\pi_{\gamma}(q,\omega_q)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the low-@xmath15 limit ( i.e. , @xmath220 ) , the density correlation function in the plasmon pole approximation can be obtained purely analytically by ( i ) substituting eqs . ( [ eq : pop_lowq ] ) and ( [ eq : pop_stat ] ) into eq . ( [ eq : mermin ] ) , and ( ii ) using the so obtained @xmath221 to evaluate the taylor expansion coefficients @xmath222 and @xmath223 at @xmath224 , i.e. , where the real part of the denominator of eq . ( [ eq : pop_rpa ] ) vanishes . the first step produces @xmath225 the second step produces eq . ( [ eq : plpole ] ) with @xmath226 thus , resulting in the expected @xmath227 plasmon dispersion . @xcite it turns out that for the specific case considered here , i.e. , the plasmon pole approximation in the long wavelength limit , the same analytical expression for @xmath228 could have been obtained in the limit of small @xmath98 by using the substitution @xmath206 instead of the more general mermin s procedure . it has to be emphasized , however , that such an agreement is not general and hard to foresee . therefore , the more accurate mermin s procedure has to be favored over more approximate methods of introducing the finite scattering rate into the density correlation function.@xcite plasmon dispersion in graphene remains @xmath227 only at @xmath229 , and deviates from this simple relation at higher @xmath15 due to non - local effects originating from interaction of plasmons with intra - band electron - hole pair excitations . therefore , in high-@xmath37 environment , the dispersion of plasmons in graphene can deviate from @xmath230 at not very large @xmath15 . to correct for this , we have to find the position of a plasmon pole more accurately than that given by eq . ( [ eq : plpole_apprx ] ) . to this end , we expand the bare density correlation function of graphene at @xmath231 , which yields @xmath232.\ ] ] it is straightforward to check that at @xmath233 this expression reduces to eq . ( [ eq : pop_lowq ] ) . on the other hand , the limit @xmath202 yields eq . ( [ eq : pop_stat ] ) . the equation for the plasmon pole , @xmath234 is easily solved with respect to @xmath235 , yielding the corrected plasmon pole position as @xmath236 where @xmath237 . the amplitude of the plasmon pole becomes @xmath238 it turns out however that the correction to amplitude is rather small , so the original uncorrected amplitude , given in eq . ( [ eq : plpole_apprx ] ) can be used . 56ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.87.075447 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ , ( , , ) chap . @noop _ _ , ed . ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ , vol . , ( , , ) p. @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , ed . ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( )

we study strong coupling between plasmons in monolayer charge - doped graphene and excitons in a narrow gap semiconductor quantum well separated from graphene by a potential barrier . we show that the coulomb interaction between excitons and plasmons result in mixed states described by a hamiltonian similar to that for exciton - polaritons and derive the exciton - plasmon coupling constant that depends on system parameters . we calculate numerically the rabi splitting of exciton - plasmariton dispersion branches for several semiconductor materials and find that it can reach values of up to 50 - 100 mev .

1003.5095

the existence of massive neutrinos , the unknown origin of parity violation in the standard model ( sm ) and the hierarchy problem are some of the important motivations for physics beyond the sm . the most natural extension of the standard model that addresses these issues is the supersymmetric version of the left - right symmetric extension of the standard model , which will treat the left - handed and right - handed particles on equal footing , and the parity violation we observe at low energies would be due to the spontaneous breaking of the left - right symmetry at some high scale @xcite . another interesting feature of the left - right symmetric model is that the difference between the baryon number ( b ) and the lepton number ( l ) becomes a gauge symmetry , which leads to several interesting consequences . in spite of the several virtues of the minimal supersymmetric left - right symmetric models ( mslrm ) , we are yet to arrive at a fully consistent model , from which we can descend down to the mssm . one of the most important problems is the spontaneous breaking of left - right symmetry @xcite . there has been suggestions to solve this problem by introducing additional fields or higher dimensional operators or by going through a different symmetry breaking chain or breaking the left - right symmetry around the supersymmetry breaking scale @xcite . in some cases , this problem is cured through the introduction of a parity - odd singlet , but the soft susy breaking terms then lead to breaking of electromagnetic charge invariance . one interesting susylr model is the minimal susylr model , which has been studied extensively @xcite , and it has been found that global minimum of the higgs potential is either charge violating or @xmath2-parity violating . recently we proposed yet another solution to the problem , which resembles the non - supersymmetric solution , relating the vacuum expectation values ( vev s ) of the left - handed and right - handed triplet higgs scalars to the higgs bi - doublet vev through a seesaw relation . we achieved this by introducing a bi - triplet and singlet higgs scalars , and the vacuum that preserves both electric charge and r - parity can naturally be the global minimum of the full potential . in this article we are applying this idea of spontaneous left - right symmetry breaking at high scale in supersymmetric models with only doublet higgs scalars . we extend the model with one singlet higgs scalar , which breaks the left - right parity of the gauge groups at a high scale . the most attractive feature of the present model is that it does not allow any left - right symmetric solution to be a minimum of the potential . we also discuss the question of neutrino masses via type iii see - saw mechanism and leptogenesis in details . we then embed the model in a grand unified theory and study the gauge coupling unification to check the consistency of the mass scales required in this model . in this section , we shall review the left - right extension of the standard model , where the gauge group at higher energies is the left - right symmetric group @xmath3 and we assume that at energies above the tev scale , the theory is supersymmetric . in these supersymmetric left - right symmetric models , it is assumed that the mssm gauge group @xmath4 is enhanced at some higher energy , above which the left - handed and right - handed fermions are treated on equal footing . the minimal supersymmetric left - right ( susylr ) model starts with the left - right symmetric gauge group @xmath5 , which could emerge from a supersymmetric @xmath6 grand unified theory . the field content of this model is given by , @xmath7 where the numbers in the brackets denote the quantum numbers under @xmath5 . the higgs sector of this model consists of the bidoublet and triplet superfields , given by , @xmath8 under the left - right parity corresponding to the interchange of the gauge groups @xmath9 and @xmath10 , or the d - parity , the fields transform as @xmath11 the superpotential for this theory is given by @xmath12 one of the important problems with the supersymmetric left - right extension of the standard model is that the minimization of the potential does not allow spontaneous parity breaking , which was considered to be one of the major triumph of the non - supersymmetric lr models . several attempts were made to solve this problem in some variants of the model . some of these solutions involve modifying the higgs sector , adding higher dimensional operators or involving a different breaking scheme of the group theory @xcite . the simplest solution is to include a bi - triplet field @xcite and allow d - parity breaking at some high scale , which may then allow parity violation spontaneously , allowing the scale of @xmath10 breaking to be different from the @xmath9 breaking scale . we extend that argument to the models involving only doublets . in models with only doublet scalars , we require three singlet fermions to give masses to the neutrinos . the charged fermion masses originate from the vev of the bi - doublet scalar field . since there are no triplet scalar field that breaks the symmetry @xmath10 , and all the triplet scalars are replaced by the doublet scalars , the bi - doublet field required to give masses to the charged fermions can give rise to the coupling required to break the parity , when d - parity is broken . thus left - right symmetry breaking becomes more natural in these models with only doublet scalar fields . this model is also able to generate baryon asymmetry via leptogenesis and provide neutrino masses through both inverse see - saw mechanism and also using type - iii see - saw mechanism . we consider here a susylr model with only doublet higgs scalars , which is the simplest extension of the non - supersymmetric lr model . this includes the bi - doublet scalar field that is required to give masses to the charged fermions and also to break the @xmath9 symmetry after the left - right symmetry is broken . the doubling of the bidoublet higgs in previous models was to ensure a non - vanishing ckm matrix . for the sake of simplicity of our model we forgo this condition since it does nt have any bearing on parity breaking . however , extension of the present model via doubling of the bidoublet is fairly trivial . thus , the higgs sector of our model is given by , @xmath13 where , with usual custom the subscript @xmath14 and @xmath2 denotes the left and right handedness of the higgs particle . the higgs particles with bar " in the notation , helps in anomaly cancellation of the model . we have also included a singlet scalar field @xmath15 , which has the special property that it is even under the usual parity of the lorentz group , but it is odd under the parity that relates the gauge groups @xmath9 and @xmath10 . this field @xmath15 is thus a scalar and not a pseudo - scalar field , but under the d - parity transformation that interchanges @xmath9 with @xmath10 , it is odd . this kind of work is proposed in @xcite . although all the scalar fields are even under the parity of the lorentz group , under the d - parity the higgs sector transforms as , @xmath16 the superpotential of the model relevant in the context of parity breaking is given by , @xmath17 supersymmetry being unbroken , implies the @xmath18 and @xmath19 conditions are equal to zero . the @xmath18 flatness conditions for the various higgs fields are given by , @xmath20 similarly , the @xmath19 flatness conditions , are given by , @xmath21 in both the @xmath18 and @xmath19 flat conditions we have neglected the lepton fields , since they would have a zero vev . the vev s for the scalar fields are given by , @xmath22 here , for simplicity of the model , we have assumed @xmath23 and @xmath24 to have the same vev @xmath25 . similarly , for the right - handed fields @xmath26 and @xmath27 . minimization of @xmath19 flat conditions , leads to a number of holomorphic gauge invariants which corresponds to flat directions @xcite . here , however , in order to determine the vacuum structure of our model , we minimize the @xmath18 flat conditions and discuss about the relations that emerge from them . after the scalar fields have acquired their respective vevs , the @xmath18 flatness conditions are given by , @xmath28 solving the equations we get four relations among the vevs . the role of d - parity odd singlets @xmath15 is uni - important in left - right breaking . this can be understood from eqns . ( [ eq : chil_vev ] ) and ( [ eq : chir_vev ] ) as follows : @xmath30 if there is no @xmath15 field , then @xmath31 . this implies @xmath32 which is a left - right symmetric solution . also the f - term conditions ( [ eq : fchilvev])-([eq : fchirbvev ] ) are not consistent without the inclusion of the parity odd singlet @xmath15 in the model . hence , the parity odd singlet @xmath15 is necessary to account for the spontaneous left - right breaking and for the consistency of the model . we now try to interpret these results to get a working phenomenology . considering the last of the relations eqn ( [ eq : sigma_vev ] ) we see that @xmath33 is a trivial solution , and will put @xmath25 and @xmath34 on equal footing thus leading to unbroken parity . however , @xmath33 is a special solution of eqn ( [ eq : sigma_vev ] ) . for @xmath35 , we have @xmath36 and parity is violated spontaneously . we will choose @xmath37 , as it is usually assumed in model building for phenomenological reasons . choosing the mass ( @xmath38 ) and vev ( @xmath39 ) of @xmath40 to be of electroweak ( ew ) scale and considering the dimensionless coupling constant @xmath41 to be of order unity , we immediately come to the conclusion , from eqn ( [ eq : chir_vev ] ) , that @xmath42 . in order to avoid generic susy problems like over abundance of gravitino , we assume the mass scale of @xmath34 to be @xmath43 gev . this together with eqn ( [ eq : phi_vev ] ) gives the value of @xmath44 gev , where @xmath45 , another dimensionless quantity , without any fine - tuning is considered to be of order unity . this is also consistent with the assumption that @xmath37 . now using eqn ( [ eq : chil_vev ] ) and the above derived relation that @xmath42 we get @xmath46 gev . finally , from eqn ( [ eq : sigma_vev ] ) one derives the mass of @xmath15 ( @xmath47 ) to be of ew scale . .mass scales of the model [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] the couplings evolve according to their respective beta functions . the renormalization group equations(rges ) for this model cane be written as @xmath48\ ] ] where , @xmath49 . the indices @xmath50 refer to the gauge group @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 respectively . unlike the d - parity breaking case where the intermediate left - right gauge group has four different coupling constants as discussed in @xcite , in the present case @xmath54 has only three gauge couplings , @xmath55 , @xmath56 , and @xmath57 for @xmath58 . we now write down the rg evolution equation of gauge couplings upto one loop order which are given below @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the gut fine - structure constant and the beta function coefficients @xmath61 and @xmath62 are determined by the particle spectrum in the ranges from @xmath63 to @xmath64 , and from @xmath64 to @xmath65 , respectively . here we are using pdg values , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 @xcite . consider the case where @xmath68 breaks down to @xmath69 . in that case @xmath70 the normalized generators are @xmath71 and @xmath72 . using these , one can write @xmath73 which implies that the matching of the coupling constant at the scale where the left - right symmetry begins to manifest itself is given by @xmath74 1 . at scale @xmath75 , @xmath76 2 . at scale @xmath77 , @xmath78 this will change once we add contributions coming from extra particle added to the minimal supersymmetric model . once we fix the values of beta functions , we can achieve lower values of @xmath79 . there are discussion @xcite , where the unification is possible at the same energy scale around @xmath80 gev , but the scale of @xmath79 varies from @xmath81 - @xmath82 gev . let us summarize our results . we point out that the non - supersymmetric version of the standard model is ruled out by lep data . however , the supersymmetric extension of this scenario remains a viable alternative to conventional grand unified theories and is capable of predicting the precision values of couplings determined from lep and unification is possible within the error bar . there are model @xcite where one can achieve unification of all three fundamental interactions in which d - parity is broken at the gut level . we see from figure ( [ fig : susylr ] ) that the gauge couplings unify at a scale @xmath83 gev . also the right handed scale @xmath64 is found to be @xmath84 gev in our model . we studied the question of spontaneous parity breaking in the supersymmetric version of the left - right symmetric models , in which all symmetry breaking takes place with only doublet higgs scalars . we demonstrate that unlike the models with triplet higgs scalars , in these models the left - right symmetry could be broken at a different scale compared to the electroweak symmetry breaking scale , if we introduce a singlet higgs scalar @xmath15 , which breaks d - parity , that is the parity relating the gauge groups @xmath9 and @xmath10 but not relating to the parity of the lorentz group . the vev of the field @xmath15 breaks the d - parity , but does not break the lorentz parity . but when combined with the vevs of the other doublet scalars , it allows to break the group @xmath10 at a different scale than the @xmath9 breaking scale , which is in the range of @xmath85 gev , ( though we can have low @xmath34 which is allowed from minimization of the potential ) . we then demonstrated the consistency of the model in terms of the neutrino mass and the matter - antimatter asymmetry of the universe . we then consider embedding of the model and check the consistency of the mass scales involved for the gauge coupling unification . sudhanwa patra would like to thank santosh kumar singh for useful discussion . as would like to thank the hospitality of prl where most of this work was developed .

we studied the question of parity breaking in a supersymmetric left - right model , in which the left - right symmetry is broken with higgs doublets ( carrying @xmath0 ) . unlike the left - right symmetric models with triplet higgs scalars ( carrying @xmath1 ) , in this model it is possible to break parity spontaneously by adding a parity odd singlet . we then discussed how neutrino mass of type iii seesaw can be invoked in this model by adding extra fermion singlets . we considered simple forms of the mass matrices that are consistent with the unification scheme and demonstrate how they can reproduce the required neutrino mixing matrix . in this model , the baryon asymmetry of the universe is generated via leptogenesis . the required mass scales in the model is then found to be consistent with the gauge coupling unification .

0705.1974

in spring 2006 , the potential threat of bird flu dominated headlines in uk newspapers . on 26 march 2006 the sun has called it the day we all dreaded " , while the guardian says avian flu is almost certain to spread to wild birds across the uk " . the daily telegraph adds that the most likely human victims will be poultry farmers , who will be bankrupted . but the mirror calls for calm , saying people have a better chance of winning the lottery than catching the virus . interestingly , given a certain amount of clustering of wealth residents and correlation between wealth and readers preference , this would translate into a differently informed neighborhood . when the epidemic is over its peak or other news has just peaked or media has cried wolf " too many times over unfounded health scares , there is a quick drop in the attention to that disease ( something similar is reported nowadays for hiv ) . in other parts of the world , for example indonesia , a country with 18000 islands , people reacted differently to the bird flu epidemics . despite awareness campaigns in the media and even door - to - door visits in some of the islands , many indonesians remained oblivious to the dangers of being in contact with diseased birds , and aware of the need to inform the authorities and implement a cull . note that awareness campaigns , such as during the sars epidemics , are expensive and may result in culling , reductions in commerce , travels and tourism . the media hype over epidemics threat has a close similarity in how worried or fatalist , resilient , skeptical or cheeky may be friends and neighborhood . therefore , the individual perception of the risk of becoming infected is a key factor influencing the spreading of an epidemics and , toward realistic inference , epidemiological models should incorporate such parameter @xcite . in order to investigate the effect of risk perception in influencing the spreading of a disease , let us start from simple , yet meaningful models , such sis or sir ones . these models are defined on a network where individuals or groups of individuals corresponds to the nodes and links represent social contacts and relationships among them . most of classical studies used either a regular lattice , or a random one . both of those choices are characterized by a well defined value of the mean connectivity @xmath0 , and small variance @xmath1 . as shown by watts and strogatz @xcite , the simple rewiring of a small fraction of links in an otherwise regular lattice results in a sudden lowering of the diameter of the graph , without affecting the average connectivity or the degree of clustering . this _ small world _ effect manifests itself in a dramatic shortage of the distance between any two individuals , almost without affecting the local perception of the network of contacts . the consequences for epidemics spreading are important : just a few long - distance connections may promote the spreading of a disease in rural areas , whereby an epidemic would otherwise diffuse very slowly . however , the investigations of social networks have shown that they are quite different from regular and random graphs @xcite . the probability distribution of contacts often exhibits a power - law behavior ( @xmath2 ) , with an exponent @xmath3 between two and three @xcite . this distribution is characterized by a relatively large number of highly connected hubs , which are presumably responsible for epidemics spreading . moreover , such distributions have a diverging second moment @xmath4 for @xmath5 and a diverging average connectivity @xmath6 for @xmath7 . the influence of the connectivity on the spreading dynamics is well outlined by a simple mean - field analysis . let us consider for the moment a tree with fixed connectivity @xmath8 . in a sis model with immediate recovery dynamics , a single infected individual may infect up to @xmath8 neighbors @xcite , each one with probability @xmath9 . the temporal behavior of the mean fraction @xmath10 of infected individuals is given by @xmath11 where @xmath12 , @xmath13 and the sum runs over the number @xmath14 of infected individuals . the basic reproductive ratio @xmath15 @xcite is simply given by @xmath16 , so that the epidemic threshold @xmath17 corresponds to @xmath18 . this means that for a fixed connectivity , only diseases with an infectivity less than @xmath19 do not spread . in heterogeneous networks ( nodes with different connectivity ) the mean field analysis , reported in section [ meanfield ] , gives @xmath20 . in the case @xmath21 , @xmath22 is again equal to @xmath23 . in summary , the result is that on very non homogeneous networks , with diverging second moment @xmath4 ( and even worse on those with diverging average connectivity @xmath0 ) , a disease will always spread regardless of its intrinsic morbidity @xcite . this result can be modified by the assortativity degree of the network and by the presence of loops , not considered in tyhe mean - field analysis . in networks with assortative connections ( hubs are preferentially connected to other hubs ) , it may happen that epidemics spread for any finite infectivity even when the second moment is not diverging @xcite , while for disassortative networks the reverse is true , epidemics may be stopped by lowering the infectivity with random vaccination campaigns , even in the presence of a diverging second moment @xcite . this is particularly evident in networks lacking the small - world property ( consequence of high disassortativity ) @xcite . in small - world networks with diverging second moment , it is quite difficult to stop an epidemics . the most common recipes are vaccination campaigns ( removal of nodes ) or modification of the social structure ( removal of links ) , that mathematically corresponds to site and bond percolation problems . to be efficient , a vaccination camping must be targeted to hubs , either directly @xcite or implicitly , for instance by exploiting the fact that hubs are the most probable neighbors of many nodes @xcite . the modification of the social structure can be obtained by cohercitive methods ( quarantine , etc . ) or by rising alerts so to modify travelling and business patterns , but this option may be so expensive that the amount of money put into restoring the previous situation may exceed that used to cure ill people @xcite . however , epidemics in modern world are relatively uncommon , and most of them are stopped quite easily in spite of the presence of high network connectivity . the existence of an epidemic threshold on such networks has motivated the investigation of the effects of connectivity - dependent infectivity @xcite . in this latter case , most of investigations have been performed using mean - field techniques , thus disregarding the presence of loops . loops are irrelevant at and near the percolation threshold @xcite , and therefore one can threat the network as a tree in these conditions . however , for processes evolving on percolating networks , this assumption may not hold . at present , the basic models used do not take into consideration the _ knowledge _ that all human beings have nowadays about the mechanisms of diffusion of diseases . in fact , even in the absence of vaccination campaigns , a disease that manifests itself in a visible way induces modifications in the social network : lower frequency of contacts ( usage of mass transportation systems ) , higher level of personal hygiene , prevention measures ( masks ) , etc . indeed , recent works stress the importance of using a time - dependent bare infectivity to reproduce real patterns of epidemics @xcite . viruses with high mutation rates ( like computer viruses ) follow a dynamics which is more similar to sis than to sir @xcite , even in the presence of immunization . on the other hand , the origin of vaccination come from cross - immunization conferred by strains with lower pathogenicity . we shall study here a sis model in which the bare infectivity of the spreading agent is modulated by a term that tries to model the effects of the perception of the risk of being infected . we assume that this perception is just an increasing function of the fraction of ill people in the neighborhood , given that the illness presents visible symptoms . this assumption is modeled after the heuristic - systematic information - processing model @xcite , that simply states that attitudes are formed and modified as people gain information about a process . in the absence of explicit alarm or communication , the only way of gaining this information is though examination of people in the neighborhood . individuals can process information in two ways : either heuristically , using simple an semi - unconscious schemes , or carefully examining them in a rational way . investigations about the effects of advertisements , especially those exploiting fear , show that the first way is rather common and predictable , except in the limit of high level of fear , that may induce repulsion towards the brand , or very low level , that may trigger the reflexive mechanism and a more careful evaluation of the message . in this work we simply assume that the local information ( not enhanced by alarms ) about the incidence of the illness translates into a lowering of the infection probability , implementing only the `` linear part '' of the information - processing model . in principle , is possible to compare the effective susceptibility to infection for diseases that manifest themselves in a visible and in an invisible way and test experimentally this hypothesis . in our model , the infectivity is a dynamical quantity . although the idea of modulating the infectivity of the infection process is not new , it is generally studied ( mostly in the mean - field approximation ) as as a function of time @xcite , of connectivity @xcite and/or depending on the total infection level @xcite . in this latter approach , a nonlinear growing dependence of the infection rate on the total number of infected people may originate bifurcation and chaotic oscillations . as we shall show in the following , mean - field analysis may not capture the essential phenomena in highly connected networks . moreover , we study the case of decreasing infection rate with increasing local infection level , that might also induce chaotic oscillations at the mean - field level ( see ref . @xcite and section [ model ] ) . however , one should consider that chaotic oscillations on networks easily desynchronize , and the resulting `` microscopic chaos '' is quite different from the synchronous oscillations predicted by mean - field analysis @xcite , that may nevertheless be observed in lattice models the presence of long - range coupling @xcite . we explicitly describe the model in section [ model ] , analyze it using mean - field techniques in section [ meanfield ] and study numerically its behavior on different types of networks in section [ numerics ] . conclusions and perspectives are drawn in the last section . in this paper we study the dynamics of an infection spreading over a network of @xmath24 individuals . we use different kinds of networks : regular , with long - range rewiring @xcite , random and scale - free @xcite . the network structure is considered not to depend on the infection level . let us denote by @xmath25 the probability distribution of connectivity @xmath8 . we shall denote by @xmath26 the average connectivity ( first moment of the distribution ) , @xmath27 , and by @xmath28 the second moment , @xmath29 . in the case of regular lattice with eventual rewiring , @xmath30 and @xmath31 . the rewiring of the network is performed by starting from a regular lattice in one dimension , detaching a fraction @xmath32 of links from one end and attaching them to randomly chosen nodes . the regular case is studied numerically in one dimension . simulations on the rewired network are performed both in the quenched and in the annealed cases . for random graphs , studied only at the mean - field level , the probability distribution is assumed to be poissonian , @xmath33 corresponding to drawing @xmath34 links at random among the @xmath24 nodes ( @xmath35 ) . the scale - free network that we study numerically is asymmetric : each node @xmath36 has a certain number @xmath37 of input contacts and @xmath38 of output ones , and was grown using the following rule . we start with a ring of @xmath39 nodes , and we add the other @xmath40 nodes by choosing , for each of them , @xmath39 connected nodes @xmath41 , with probability @xmath42 ( preferential attachment ) . the node being attached is added to the _ inputs _ of the chosen nodes . we also choose another node at random and add it to the list of input nodes of the new node . this process simulates the growing of a social network in which a new node ( a family or an individual ) is born from another one ( the ones that is added as input of the newborn node ) and joins the society according with the popularity of nodes . distribution of input and output connections for the scale - free network used in simulations . ] our procedure allows to generate a network that has a power - law distribution of input contacts , @xmath43 , with @xmath44 ( see figure [ pk ] ) , while the distribution of output connections , @xmath45 , is found to be exponentially distributed . this is an interesting feature of the model as the input connections represent the total number of contacts to which an individual is exposed , while the output connections represent the actively pursued contacts , e.g. familiar ones . a customer , for instance , is exposed to a large number of obliged contacts , and may become infected with a large probability . these are considered `` input '' links . on the other hand , people in a public position is more monitored , and it is not plausible that they can infect a comparable large number of people . infection is limited to the private sphere , where contacts are more intense . these are the `` output '' links . we choose this algorithm in order to have a `` worst - case '' scenario , with an exponent corresponding to a diverging average of input connectivity we have not studied the case of dynamic dependence of the network on the infection level , however a high - level of infection of a severe disease may surely induce changes in the social network . it is reasonable to assume that , for mild diseases ( or diseases considered harmless , like most of computer viruses ) , the social network is not affected and only the level of prevention is increased . in the present paper we assume the effects of the infection to be immediately visible , with no latency nor `` hidden infectivity '' . we also assume as temporal unit the time required to recover from illness without immunization and thus we explore the case of a sis dynamics . mean field return map for fixed connectivity @xmath46 , parameters @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 and varying values of precaution level @xmath50 . the effect of risk perception ( @xmath50 ) is to lower the infectivity at high concentrations of infected individuals . ] an individual can be infected separately by each of his neighbors with a probability @xmath9 per unit of time ( see eq . ) . we model the effects of the perception of the risk of being infected replacing the bare infection probability @xmath9 with @xmath51 , @xmath52 \right\},\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the number of neighbors of a given site and @xmath14 is the number of them that are ill . we assume the perception of the risk of being infected to depend on the fraction of infected individuals among the neighbors , @xmath53 , on the level of precaution measures adopted , @xmath50 , and on the use of special prophylaxis , @xmath54 . the quantity @xmath55 models a global influence over the population , either alarm of broadcasting media news , in which case it could depend on the average level of the infection . its effect is that of reducing the bare infectivity @xmath9 , so in the following we only consider the case @xmath47 . for the moment , we consider @xmath48 ; the role of this parameter will be clear in the following . differently from ref @xcite , in our model the infectivity is not exclusively related to the connectivity . the mean - field return map ( for fixed connectivity @xmath56 ) is shown in figure [ campomedio ] . the effect of the introduction of risk perception is evident : for high concentrations of infected individuals the probability of being infected is diminished . therefore , while for @xmath57 and @xmath58 there is only one stable fixed point @xmath59 ( all individuals infected ) , by increasing @xmath50 one can have stable fixed points @xmath60 , limit cycles and even chaotic behavior @xcite . the simplest mean - field approximation of the evolution of disease on a network consists in neglecting correlations among variables . this is essentially equivalent in considering the evolution on a tree , i.e. , in assuming the absence of loops . let us denote with @xmath61 the probability of having an infected site of degree @xmath8 ( with @xmath8 connections ) at time @xmath62 , and with @xmath63 the probability at a subsequent time step . the mean evolution of the system is generically given by @xmath64 where @xmath65 indicates the local configuration ( degrees and healthy status ) at time @xmath62 around a site of degree @xmath8 . @xmath66 is the probability of occurrence of the healthy status of such configuration , @xmath67 is the probability that the local configuration is connected to the site under examination , and @xmath68 is the probability that the disease propagates in one time step from @xmath65 to the site . in our case , the local configuration is given by a set of @xmath8 nodes , of degree @xmath69 , and status @xmath70 ) , where @xmath71 ( 1 ) indicates that the site @xmath36 is healthy ( ill ) . thus @xmath72 and @xmath73 since we assume decorrelation among sites . @xmath67 depends on the assortativity of the network . let us define @xmath74 as the probability that a site of degree @xmath8 is attached to a link connected to a site of degree @xmath75 . @xmath74 is computed in an existing network as the number of links that connects sites of degree @xmath75 and @xmath8 , divided by the total number of links that are connected to sites of degree @xmath8 , and @xmath76 . the detailed balance condition gives @xmath77 . for non - assortative networks , @xmath78 , and summing over the detailed balance condition one gets @xmath79 , where @xmath56 is the average number of links per node , @xmath80 . assuming again a decorrelated network , we have @xmath81 for non - assortative networks . @xmath68 is the infection probability . in the case without risk perception , it is @xmath82 where @xmath83 . the risk perception is modeled by replacing @xmath9 with @xmath84 , which makes the equations hard to be managed analytically except in the limit of vanishing infection probability @xmath85 , for which only the case @xmath86 is relevant . we shall consider this point later . putting all together , one gets @xmath87 using the relation @xmath88 we obtain after some simplifications @xmath89 this expression could be obtained directly by noticing that @xmath90 is the probability of not being ill , which corresponds to the combined probability of not being infected by any of the @xmath8 neighbors . neglecting correlations , these are @xmath8 independent processes ( although they depend on @xmath8 ) . each of these process is 1 minus the probability of being infected , which is the sum , over all possible degree @xmath75 of the neighboring node , of the probability that it is ill ( @xmath91 ) times the probability that is is connected to the node under investigation , @xmath74 . let us denote by @xmath92 the asymptotic value of @xmath93 . assuming that the transition between the quiescent ( @xmath94 ) and active ( @xmath95 ) is continuous , its boundary is given by the values of parameters for which @xmath96 in the limit @xmath97 . in this limit @xmath98 and we can now consider the case with risk perception , with @xmath9 replaced by @xmath99 . in the case of non - assortative networks , @xmath100 calling @xmath101 ( that does not depend on @xmath8 ) , we have @xmath102 and thus @xmath103 the critical boundary is therefore given by @xmath104 from which one could obtain @xmath105 as a function of @xmath9 ( we replaced @xmath75 by @xmath8 for consistency with the rest of the paper ) . in the case @xmath57 ( no risk perception ) , the formula gives @xmath106 which is a well - known result @xcite . in the case of fixed connectivity , @xmath30 , and for @xmath48 @xmath107 in the absence of perception ( @xmath57 ) one has @xmath108 . the mean - field dependence of the critical value of precaution level @xmath105 with respect to the bare infectivity @xmath9 for poissonian networks , with average connectivity @xmath56 and @xmath48 ] for poissonian networks ( random graphs ) , @xmath110 numerical integration of eq . for @xmath48 gives the results shown in figure [ fig : poissonianjc ] . one can notice that for every value of @xmath9 and finite average connectivity @xmath56 , there is always a value of the precaution level @xmath105 that leads to the extinction of the epidemics . for non - assortative scale - free networks with exponent @xmath3 , @xmath111 , the sum in eq . diverges unless @xmath112 , irrespective of @xmath113 . this implies that at the mean - field level , any level of precaution is not sufficient to extinguish the epidemics . the mean - field approximation disregards the effects of ( correlated ) fluctuations in the real system . indeed , the effects of random and/or long - range connections may disrupt correlations . we found that the behavior of microscopic simulations with random rewiring , both in the quenched and annealed version , is well reproduced by mean field simulations with a white noise term , with amplitude proportional to @xmath114 . the noise term ( or the fluctuations in microscopic simulations ) may bring the infection to extinction if the average ( or mean - field ) oscillations come close to @xmath115 , as is often the case for a choice of @xmath50 for which chaotic behavior appears in the mean - field approximation . critical value @xmath105 of the precaution level as a function of the base infectivity @xmath9 average connectivity @xmath116 for the poissonian mean - field ( p ) , fixed connectivity mean field , eq . ( f ) , and numerically ( @xmath117 ) , for the annealed rewired @xmath118 ( w ) and regular one - dimensional ( r ) cases . ] for regular ( fraction of rewired links @xmath119 ) and rewired ( @xmath120 ) lattices , it is always possible to observe a continuous transition towards a critical level @xmath121 , such that the infection become extincted , for every value of the bare infectivity @xmath9 , as shown in figure [ fig : jc ] . for scale - free networks , we concentrated on the case illustrated in section [ model ] , which can be considered a worst - case scenario ( @xmath122 , diverging second and first moments of input distribution ) . simulations show that for @xmath48 ( eq . ) , there is no value of @xmath105 for which the infection may be stopped ( although not all population is always infected ) , for any value of @xmath9 , in agreement with the mean - field analysis . fraction of time spent ill ( @xmath123 ) in the scale - free case , as a function of @xmath8 for @xmath124 , @xmath125 . ] the investigation of nodes that are _ more responsible _ of the spreading of the infection reveals , as expected , that the nodes with higher input connectivity ( hubs ) stay ill most of time , figure [ hubs ] . notice that also nodes with high input connectivity have finite output connectivity , so the above relation is not trivially related to the infection level . dependence of the critical value of the perception , @xmath105 , as a function of the _ exposure - enhanced _ perception parameter @xmath113 , @xmath126 , @xmath49 , @xmath127 . ] in real life , however , public service workers who are exposed to many contacts ( like medical doctors , for instance ) use additional safety measures . in order to include this effect in the model , we use the parameter @xmath113 , eq . , that up to now have been set to one . the effect of this parameter is to increase the perception of the risk ( or the safety measures ) for nodes with higher connectivity . as shown in figure [ jalpha ] , as soon as @xmath128 , a finite critical value of @xmath105 appears . the transition from the active ( @xmath129 ) to the absorbing ( @xmath115 ) state occurs suddenly , due to fluctuations . essentially , nodes with high connectivity may fail to be infected due to their increased perception of the infection , and this stops efficiently the spreading . this effect is similar to targeted immunization , but is not captured by the mean - field analysis . it is a dynamical effect over a network far from the percolation threshold , and thus containing loops . the transition may be a finite - size effect , related to the unavoidable cut - off in the degree distribution for finite populations , although simulations with populations from @xmath130 up to @xmath131 do not show any systematic change in the transition point . in conclusion , we have studied the effects of risk perception in a simple sis model for epidemics spreading . these effects are modulated by two parameters , @xmath50 and @xmath113 , that reduce the infectivity of the disease as a function of the fraction of people in the neighborhood that are manifestly ill . the first parameter modulates the linear response , while the second models non - linear effects like the increasing of prevention due to a public exposed role . we found that for fixed or peaked connectivity there is always a finite value @xmath105 of perception that makes the epidemics go extinct . we studied the evolution of the disease in a `` worst case '' social networks , with scale - free input connectivity and an exponent @xmath132 , for which both the average input connectivity and fluctuations diverge . in this case a linear perception can not stop the disease , but we found that , as soon as the perception is increased in a non - linear way ( @xmath133 ) , the epidemics may get extincted by increasing the perception level . this latter transition is not continuous and is presumably induced by fluctuations in hubs . it may be due to the finiteness of population . the mechanism that we propose is somehow analogous to vaccination of hubs , except that is is a dynamics effect due to the local level of diffusion of the disease , and is not exclusively related to local connectivity . we think that a similar mechanism is at the basis of the robustness of human population with respect to epidemics , even in the absence of immunization procedures . one may speculate if , in consequence of such robustness , humans have been selected to exhibit visual signs of the most common diseases , which certainly does not favors the spreading of infective agents . another common symptom of an illness is the tendency to isolation , which again could be the result of selection . l.s . research is supported by the embo organization under the contract astf 12 - 2007 . authors acknowledge fruitful discussions with f. di patti and a. guazzini . eagly and s. chaiken , _ the psychology of attitudes _ ( harcourt , fort worth , tx 1993 ) . a.h . eagly and s. chaiken , _ attitude structure and function _ , in d. t. gilbert , s. t. fiske and g. lindzey ( eds ) , _ the handbook of social psychology _ , ( mcgraw - hill , new york 1998 ) vol . 269 - 322 . l. sguanci , p. li and f. bagnoli , _ the influence of risk perception in epidemics : a cellular agent model _ , in _ cellular automata _ , s. el yacoubi , b. chopard and s. bandini , editors ( lecture notes in computer science lncs 4173 , springer , berlin 2006 ) pp .

we investigate the effects of risk perception in a simple model of epidemic spreading . we assume that the perception of the risk of being infected depends on the fraction of neighbors that are ill . the effect of this factor is to decrease the infectivity , that therefore becomes a dynamical component of the model . we study the problem in the mean - field approximation and by numerical simulations for regular , random and scale - free networks . we show that for homogeneous and random networks , there is always a value of perception that stops the epidemics . in the `` worst - case '' scenario of a scale - free network with diverging input connectivity , a linear perception can not stop the epidemics ; however we show that a non - linear increase of the perception risk may lead to the extinction of the disease . this transition is discontinuous , and is not predicted by the mean - field analysis .

1604.02595

in previous works we compared the performances of an x - ray tes microcalorimeter under ac and dc bias by measuring the iv characteristic , the noise , the impedance and the x - ray response at perpendicular magnetic field @xmath1 . the tests were carried out both with an sron pixel and a gsfc pixel @xcite . with respect to the dc bias case , under ac bias we observe a smaller ( about @xmath2 ) current output at small voltage bias low in the transition , a low tes current and temperature sensitivity , a slightly worse integrated nep resolution and about a factor two x - ray resolution degradation . in order to better understand the reasons for the suboptimal performance of the tess under ac bias we thoroughly studied the effect of the perpendicular magnetic field and the voltage bias on the detector response . here we present the results obtained with a gsfc pixel read out both in the ac and dc configuration . a schematic drawings of the read - out circuit used for the ac measurements described here is shown in fig . [ acreadout2 ] . a superconducting flux transformer is used between the squid amplifier and the tes microcalorimeter to improve the impedance matching between the tes and squid amplifier . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] the tes microcalorimeter is tested using a superconducting transformer with inductances @xmath3 and @xmath4 , and estimated mutual inductance @xmath5 , @xmath6 coil turns ratio and with @xmath7 connected to the tes . the impedance of the lc circuit seen by the tes is then @xmath8 . the lc resonator consists of an hybrid filter with a lithographic nb - film coil with @xmath9 and commercial high - q np0 smd capacitors with @xmath10 . the circuit has an additive total stray inductance of about @xmath11 . the intrinsic resonator factor of the lc resonator is @xmath12 , limited by losses in the lumped elements circuit . as amplifiers we used a nist squid arrays consisting of a series of 100 dc - squid with input - feedback coil turns ratio of 3:1 , and input inductance @xmath13 . the input current noise is @xmath14 at @xmath15 . the squid amplifier is operated in a standard analogue flux - locked - loop ( fll ) mode using commercial magnicon electronics , which linearises the squid response . only at frequencies below @xmath16 the fll has enough loop gain to sufficiently linearise the signal response . for this reason our experiments are carried out at a resonant frequency of @xmath17 . the circuit resonant frequency is defined by the capacitor c and the total inductance @xmath18 , where the last term accounts for the screening effect of the superconducting transformer and @xmath19 is an inductance generated by the squid feedback loop . from the measured resonant frequency and the filter capacitance reported above we get @xmath20 . the effective inductance seen by the tes is @xmath21 . in the experiment described here we used an xray tes microcalorimeter from the gsfc . it is a @xmath22 pixel from a uniform @xmath23 array @xcite , where a tes is coupled to a micron - thick overhanging au / bi x - ray absorber . the sensor is a mo / au proximity - effect bilayer with a transition temperature of @xmath24 , and a normal state resistance of @xmath25 . when the gsfc pixel is dc biased good baseline and x - ray energy resolution is observed . the x - ray resolution is comparable to the baseline resolution and is generally of the order of 2.3 - 2.5ev . the pixel responsivity and noise strongly depends on the perpendicular magnetic field applied to the tes . in fig.[nep_acdcbias]*a*. we show the integrate nep ( @xmath26 ) as a function of the applied magnetic field @xmath27 and for different bias current . at this pixel we observed a remanent perpendicular field of @xmath28 . the pattern observed is due to the dependency of the detector critical current on the magnetic field as a result of the tes behaving as a weak - link @xcite . the shift of the josephson patterns along the applied magnetic field is due to the self magnetic field generated by the dc current flowing through the leads connecting the tes @xcite . and @xmath29 mgauss . the points in red up triangles are the results of measurements taken under identical experimental condition , but on a different day.[nep_acdcbias ] ] under ac bias we measured the @xmath26 as a function of the applied perpendicular magnetic field @xmath27 as well . at this pixel we observed a remanent perpendicular field of @xmath30 . the results are shown in fig . [ nep_acdcbias]*b*. from the plots we observe that , under ac bias : the fraunhofer - like oscillations are visible , but the pattern is more noisy and less reproducible than under dc bias ; the baseline resolution is slightly worse and strongly depends on the bias voltage . while the former effect is likely due to the self magnetic field , the latter has a less trivial explanation . in an attempt to clarify these results , we performed a fine scan of the detector i - v characteristic by measuring for every bias point the detector x - ray response and the noise . we repeated the scan for different magnetic fields . we discovered that the baseline energy resolution strongly depends on the detector bias point . a very small variation ( @xmath31 ) of the bias current could result in an energy resolution degradation of more than a factor three . the results of this measurement are shown in fig.[desivsibias ] , where the baseline resolution is plotted as a function of the bias voltage and for several value of the perpendicular magnetic field . signal amplitude ( i.e. @xmath32 tes current ) and integrated energy resolution as a function of the bias voltage of the ac biased pixel . the energy resolution shows an oscillating pattern as a function of the bias point . the pattern is partially modulated by the magnetic field . @xmath33mk . ] the energy resolution oscillates between values from 3.5 ev to 9 ev as a function of the bias point . the oscillating pattern is partially modulated by the magnetic field . as visible in the insert of fig.[desivsibias]*a . * , the sensor iv curve presents a staircase structure , modulated by the perpendicular magnetic field . the worst resolution is measured at the transition between two steps where the slope of the i - v curve is the highest . this is clearly seen in fig.[devsibiaszoom ] . integrated energy resolution as a function of the bias voltage . the energy resolution deteriorates at the bias point corresponding to the higher slope in the iv curve steps . @xmath34 mk.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in fig . [ sinoiseacdc ] we plot the nep , the responsivity and the noise spectra taken under ac and dc bias . for the ac bias case the spectra are taken respectively at the flat and at the rising part of the observed steps in fig . [ devsibiaszoom ] . the detector response bandwidth is not identical under ac and dc bias due to the different load impedance of the two circuits @xcite . one should refer to the nep plot when comparing the ac and dc cases . ] the nep is the lowest under dc bias . at low frequency ( @xmath35 ) the degradation in the nep observed in the ac bias case is probably due to a reduced responsivity . at high frequency ( @xmath36 ) excess noise is observed in the ac bias case . the excess noise is worse for the measurement taken at the rising part of the steps and has the signature of excess johnson noise . furthermore , the noise level at frequency @xmath36 in the spectra corresponding to the 3.5 ev integrated nep taken under ac bias , can not be explained by simply including the squid and the lc resonator thermal noise . an excess white noise of about @xmath37 is estimated from the model . under ac bias the responsivity is independent on the two bias points . in analogy with the analysis done for an rf - squid @xcite we calculate the characteristic parameters of a tes in a superconducting loop weakly coupled via a superconducting transformer to an lc resonant circuit . the tes is treated as a weak - link in accordance with the rsj model where @xmath38 is assumed to be tes normal resistance . for the detector described above we find the cut - off and the characteristic frequency to be respectively @xmath39 where a critical current of about @xmath40 is assumed . note that the tes critical current at a @xmath41 is generally larger than @xmath42 ( @xmath43 at 55mk @xcite ) . however in bias conditions the tes operating temperature is @xmath44 and the critical current drops . the screening parameter is @xmath45 . the rfsquid - like ac biased tes operates then in an adiabatic and hysteretic regime , since @xmath46 and @xmath47 . rf - squids have shown the highest noise in this working regime @xcite . the steps in the tes iv curves have a non zero slope ( fig.[desivsibias]*a . * ) . the tilting of the steps in the rf - squid i - v characteristic and the rounding of the step edges reflect directly the width of the quantum transitions distribution due to thermal fluctuations . kurkijrvi @xcite have shown that the ratio @xmath48 of the voltage rise along a step @xmath49 to the voltage difference @xmath50 between steps is directly proportional to the squid s instrinsic flux noise @xcite . their empirical formula gives @xmath51 in the same way we can estimate the flux noise in the tes superconducting ring . from the step observed in the iv curves we get an @xmath52 , which corresponds to a flux noise of @xmath53 . for a 17 nh inductance ring this is equivalent to a current noise of @xmath54 . this noise level is comparable with the excess noise observed in the ac bias detector , which limits the best measured integrated nep to @xmath55 . we observed excess noise and low reproducibility in the ac biased x - ray pixel . a strong dependency of the baseline noise on the bias voltage is at the origin of the non reproducible results obtained in the past . in the iv curve under ac bias a staircase structure is observed . a possible interpretation of this effect is given by comparing the detector and the ac read - out to an rf - squid . in this analogy the tes is seen as a weak - link in a superconducting ring weakly coupled to an lc resonator . should this interpretation be valid , the excess noise observed in the ac bias experiment could be due to flux noise generated by the uncertainties in the quantum transition . to validate this hypothesis the following tests should be performed in the future : measurements with large l and high bias frequency ( @xmath56 ) since in the rf - squid the flux noise decreases at higher rf tank frequencies and the detector operates in a non - adiabatic regime where rf - squid amplifiers show lower flux noise @xcite ; measurements of excess noise ( integrated nep ) as function of temperature since a weak dependency to @xmath57 is expected @xcite ; experiments with tess with different weak - link parameters ( @xmath58 and @xmath59 ) to achieve a non - hysteretic regime . j. kurkijrvi , _ phys.rev b _ * 6 * , 832 , 1972 , and j. kurkijrvi , _ j. appl . * 44 * , 3729 , 1973 . m. b. simmonds and w. h. parker , _ j. appl . phys . _ * 42 * , 38 , 1971 . a. h. silver and j. e. zimmerman , _ phys . _ * 157 * , 317 , 1966 . j. clarke and a.l . braginski , `` _ the squid handbook _ '' , wiley , 2004 .

at sron we are studying the performance of a goddard space flight center single pixel tes microcalorimeter operated in an ac bias configuration . for x - ray photons at 6 kev the pixel shows an x - ray energy resolution @xmath0ev , which is about a factor 2 worse than the energy resolution observed in an identical dc - biased pixel . in order to better understand the reasons for this discrepancy we characterised the detector as a function of temperature , bias working point and applied perpendicular magnetic field a strong periodic dependency of the detector noise on the tes ac bias voltage is measured . we discuss the results in the framework of the recently observed weak - link behaviour of a tes microcalorimeter . pacs numbers :

1312.2672

the dicke and tavis - cummings ( tc ) hamiltonian describe a system of @xmath2 two - level atoms interacting with a single monochromatic electromagnetic radiation mode within a cavity @xcite . one of the most representative feature of these hamiltonians is their second - order quantum phase transition ( qpt ) in the thermodynamic limit @xcite ( equivalent in the present models to the semi - classical limit ) . the ground state of the system goes from a normal to a superradiant state when the atom - field interaction reaches a critical value . in a companion paper @xcite , hereon referred to as ( i ) , it was shown that the semi - classical approximation to the density of states ( dos ) describes very well the averaged quantum density of states ( qdos ) . from the semi - classical description , the presence of two different excited - state quantum phase transitions ( esqpts ) was clearly established in these models . one esqpt , referred to as _ static _ , occurs for any coupling at an energy @xmath3 , where the whole phase space associated with the two - levels atoms ( the pseudo - spin sphere ) becomes available for the system . the second esqpt , referred to as _ dynamic _ , can take place only in the superradiant phase , at energies @xmath4 . this transition occurs when the top of the double well ( dicke ) or mexican hat ( tc ) potential that develops in the superradiant phase is attained . the previous results allow to study the properties of the quantum fluctuations using the semi - classical dos to separate the tendency or secular variation of the spectrum from its fluctuations . it is known that the tendency of the qdos depends completely on the particular system , but the properties of the fluctuations are universal @xcite . for quantum systems with a classical analogue integrable the fluctuations are common with those of the so - called gaussian diagonal ensemble ( gde ) , while for time - reversal - symmetric quantum systems with classical analogue hard chaotic , the fluctuations are those of the gaussian orthogonal ensemble ( goe ) . in ref . @xcite numerical evidence was presented that suggests a relationship between the normal to superradiant phase transition and the onset of chaos in the non - integrable dicke model . more recently @xcite this relationship was studied more closely and it was suggested that the onset of chaos is caused by the precursors of the _ dynamic _ esqpt occurring in the superradiant phase . in this contribution we go further in the study of this relationship between the onset of chaos and singular behavior of the dos ( esqpt ) and ground - state energy ( qpt ) . to this end we consider the non - integrable dicke model and its integrable approximation , the tavis - cummings model . we study these models as a function of both the coupling between atoms and field , and the excitation energy . the presence of chaos for different energies and coupling constants is exhibited , in the semi - classical limit , employing poincar sections . the role of the classical chaos in the dicke model has been recently studied in the context of the equilibration of unitary quantum dynamics @xcite . in the quantum case peres lattices are presented , which allow to characterize regular and chaotic regions qualitatively . a quantitative measure of the properties of the energy spectrum is also presented by means of testing if the nearest neighbor spacing distribution ( nnsd ) of the unfolded energies follows the wigner distribution of the goe . the results of the classical model are compared to the quantum ones . similar to the results of ref.@xcite , a clear correspondence between classical and quantum results are found for finite quantum system ranging from @xmath5 to @xmath6 . it is found that the onset of chaos in the dicke model can only take place in the energy region where the quadratic approximation of the hamiltonian , the one obtained by considering small oscillations around the global energy minimum , fails to describe semiclassical model dynamics . for any coupling there always exist a low energy interval above the ground state where only regular patterns are observed . in particular , for the very small coupling regime @xmath7 this energy interval extends to infinity . above these low energy region the quadratic approximation breaks down and room is left for the onset of chaos . even if an indirect connection between the esqpts and the onset of chaos can be identified through the unstable fixed points , the onset of chaos is a much richer phenomenon than the occurrence of non - analytic behavior in the density of states or the ground - state energy . the article is organized as follows : in section ii we present briefly the quantum dicke and tavis - cummings hamiltonians and their classical analogues , and summarize some of their properties . in section iii a qualitatively analysis of the spectrum is done via peres lattices and poincar sections , revealing a clear classical and quantum correspondence at the onset of chaos , both in the normal and superradiant phases . the properties of the energy fluctuations are studied by means of the anderson - darling test for the nnsd against the wigner distribution . section iv contains the conclusions . the dicke and tavis - cummings hamiltonians are made of three parts : one associated to the monochromatic quantized radiation field ( boson operators @xmath8 and @xmath9 ) , a second one to the atomic sector ( pseudo - spin operators @xmath10 and @xmath11 ) , and a last one which describes the interaction between them @xmath12 , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath13 and @xmath14 for the tc and dicke models , respectively . a quantum phase transition , from the normal to the so - called superradiant phase , takes place at a value of the coupling constant given by @xmath15 . we will focus on the subspace with largest pseudo - spin , where @xmath16 @xcite . the tc hamiltonian is integrable because it commutes with the @xmath17 operator , @xmath18 . its conserved eigenvalues @xmath19 define a set of subspaces where the tc hamiltonian can be diagonalized independently . the dicke hamiltonian is not integrable , but its hilbert space can be separated in two sectors depending on the eigenvalue ( @xmath20 ) of the parity operator @xmath21 . the classical version of the dicke and tc models can be obtained employing the _ naive _ substitution @xcite of the pseudospin variables by classical angular momentum ones ( @xmath22 ) , and the substitution of the boson variables by a classical harmonic oscillator ( variables @xmath23 and @xmath24 ) with @xmath25 . the pseudospin variables satisfy the poisson - bracket algebra @xmath26 . from there canonical variables @xmath27 can be obtained as @xmath28 and @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the azimuthal angle of the vector @xmath31 whose magnitude is constant @xmath32 . in terms of the canonical variables the classical dicke hamiltonian reads @xmath33.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] from here the equations of motion are @xmath34 \label{php}\nonumber\\ \frac{d j_z}{dt}&=&-\frac{\partial h_{cl}}{\partial \phi}=2\gamma\sqrt{j}\sqrt{1-\frac{j_z^2}{j^2}}\nonumber\\ & \times & \left[(1+\delta ) q\sin\phi + ( 1-\delta ) p\cos\phi\right].\label{jp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ cols="^,^ " , ] for couplings in the superradiant phase , a new energy region appears below the normal phase lowest energy . this new energy region corresponds , from a classical point of view , to the motion of the pseudospin variables in the double well energy surface where the parity symmetry is spontaneously broken . the top of this double well energy surface is given by the ground state energy of the normal phase ( @xmath4 ) , where the _ dynamical _ esqpt takes place . as a first example in this coupling regime , we consider a coupling near but above the critical one @xmath35 . the corresponding peres lattices are shown in fig.[fig14 ] , whereas the classical poincar sections are shown in fig.[fig15 ] . as it happened in the previous cases and as expected according to the fig.[figval ] , for the low energy regime a regular lattice is obtained and correspondingly only classical regular orbits appear in the poincar sections . in the case of a medium size quantum system ( @xmath36 top panel of fig.[fig14 ] ) , the regular lattice seems to extend until the energy of the _ dynamic _ esqpt ( @xmath4 ) , however a closer view of the same energy region using a larger system ( @xmath37 ) unveils a richer structure in the denser peres lattice : the regular lattice extends beyond the critical energy @xmath4 . for a small interval around @xmath4 , regular and irregular lattices coexist . for larger energies the lattice is completely irregular . these lattice characteristics are reflected by the respective a - d parameter ( bottom panel of fig.[fig14 ] ) which decrease drastically from large values at energies close to the minimum . at @xmath38 it attains values around @xmath39 , and finally at an energy @xmath40 it takes values smaller than @xmath41 . the classical results have a clear correspondence with the quantum ones , as can be verified in the poincar sections of fig . [ fig15 ] : regular orbits for low energies ( including the critical energy @xmath4 ) , mixed dynamics or soft chaos ( coexistence of regular and chaotic trajectories ) at energies near but above the critical energy @xmath4 , and hard chaos ( chaotic trajectories fulling the whole available phase space ) for energies @xmath42 . the precursors of the esqpts , both the _ dynamic _ and _ static _ , can be clearly seen in the peres lattice of the @xmath36 system ( top panel of fig.[fig14 ] ) , as a change in the slope of the tendency of the @xmath43 values as the energy is increased . the last case we present is one with a large coupling , deep in the superradiant phase ( @xmath44 ) . again , we have a regular region in the low energy sector and a hard chaotic region for higher energies . as in the previous cases the precursors of the two esqpts are clearly seen in the peres lattice shown in the top panel of fig.[fig16 ] . in the same panel the regular part of the lattice seems to be limited by the critical energy of the _ dynamic _ esqpt ( @xmath4 ) , however a closer view to that energy region for a larger system ( @xmath45 ) unveils a more involved relationship between the esqpt and the transition to chaos . differently to the case shown in the central panel of fig.[fig14 ] ( @xmath46 , for a system size @xmath37 ) , the regular part of the peres lattice in this case ( central panel of fig.[fig16 ] ) does not extend beyond @xmath4 , but it is upper limited by @xmath47 . for low energies the lattice is completely regular , whereas for energies around @xmath47 a coexistence of regular and irregular patterns is obtained . at the critical energy of the _ dynamic _ esqpt the lattice seems to be completely irregular , and the same is obtained for larger energies . the previous qualitative observations are quantitatively reflected by the a - d parameter ( bottom panel of fig.[fig16 ] ) which decrease abruptly in an energy interval around @xmath47 below the value @xmath41 . the classical poincar sections ( fig . [ fig17 ] ) present a very similar route to chaos . for @xmath48 only regular orbits are obtained , whereas for @xmath49 a mixed phase space with regular and chaotic trajectories appears . in a narrow energy interval the phase space properties change rapidly . for @xmath50 the chaotic trajectories fill the available phase space , excepting a small stability island , which disappears completely at larger energies . the peres lattices and the classical results which support and explain the different structures found in them , show that the change from a regular regime to a chaotic one in the dicke model is much more involved that the transitions linked to the dos ( esqpt ) or the ground - state properties ( qpt ) . while the esqpt and qpt are well defined transitions in the classical limit [ they are unambiguously indicated by non - analytic behavior of the ground - state energy and volume of the available phase space @xmath51 , the transition from a regular regime ( at low energies ) to a chaotic one ( large energies ) can not be unambiguously defined even in the classical limit . instead continuous changes in the phase space structures are obtained , which include a mixed or soft chaos regime where regular and chaotic patterns coexist , both in the classical and quantum results , and both in the normal and superradiant phases . nevertheless , an indirect connection between chaos and the esqpt can be obtained through the unstable fixed points of the classical version . they determine clearly the energies where changes in the available phase space take place , and consequently singular behavior in the classical approximation of the dos , on the other hand they are also involved in the breaking of the quadratic approximation which is a necessary ( but not sufficient ) condition for the presence of chaos in the classical model . finally , it is worth mentioning that the results presented above show that the peres lattices are a very useful tool to explore in a qualitative and quick way the presence of chaos in the quantum models . moreover , they are useful to give indications about the properties of the corresponding classical model . the peres lattices allow at a glance to visualize the system properties in the energy space , contrary to the traditional poincar sections which are defined only for a given energy . with the peres lattices it is easy to select individual states and identify if they are part of the regular or chaotic lattice part . in this sense they can be useful to perform more detailed studies about the classical and quantum correspondence such as the work of ref.@xcite , where the husimi functions of selected eigenstates are calculated and compared with the classical results . as in the present study , in that ref . a clear quantum - classical correspondence is obtained for systems with sizes of order @xmath52 . using both a semiclassical analysis and results of an efficient numerical procedure to diagonalize the quantum hamiltonians , we have studied the dicke and tc models in the space of coupling and energy . we focused on the onset of chaos in the non - integrable dicke model , one of the global properties of the energy - coupling space . we explore the properties of the quantum and classical models as a function of coupling and energy with regard to the onset of irregular patterns . poincar surface sections and peres lattices were used , respectively , for the classical and quantum versions . a clear classical and quantum global correspondence was obtained for system sizes ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath1 . through the unstable fixed points , an indirect connection between the esqpt s and the onset of chaos was identified , however , the latter is a much richer phenomenon than the occurrence of non - analytic behavior in the density of states or the ground - state energy . it was found that the onset of chaos is related with the breaking of the quadratic approximation of the hamiltonian that is obtained by considering small oscillations around the global energy minimum . it was confirmed in the quantum and classical versions , that chaos is present , both in the normal and superradiant phase , for large enough energies , except in the perturbative regime @xmath54 . conversely , for any coupling there always exist an energy interval above the energy minimum where only regular patterns are obtained . in particular for the very small coupling regime @xmath54 this energy interval extends to infinity . once the quadratic approximation is broken more energy is needed to produce chaotic patterns , something that can be clearly seen in the classical system with critical coupling , where one of the normal modes of the quadratic approximation is exactly zero , which implies that terms of order larger than two have to be considered . even so , the system presents regular patterns in the low energy regime , and irregular trajectories appears until larger energies . the peres lattices used to study the quantum versions were a very useful tool to identify qualitatively the chaotic and regular features of the spectrum , moreover they show clear signatures of the esqpts . the qualitative information provided by the peres lattices was quantitatively confirmed by analyzing the statistical properties of the quantum fluctuations . it was tested if the fluctuations of spectrum in different energy intervals follow the wigner distribution characteristic of the hard chaotic systems . the classical analysis performed in this contribution allows us to gain many insights about the results obtained in the quantum versions . for instance , it was shown that the two modes approximation obtained in @xcite by making a holstein - primakhof of the pseudospin variables in the quantum model , is valid in the thermodynamic ( equivalent here to the semi - classical ) limit , but only for an energy region immediately above the ground - state energy . moreover , the two modes approximation explains very well the regular patterns found in the low lying energy spectrum of the finite quantum dicke model . this global study may be useful as a navigation chart to more detailed studies that focus on the classical - quantum correspondence of single states , such as that performed in ref.@xcite . finally , the results presented here for optical models confirm results of previous studies , performed in the context of nuclear physics simple models @xcite , about the classical and quantum correspondence with regard to the onset of chaos in the extended energy and coupling space . we thank p. strnsky and p. cejnar for many useful and interesting conversations.this work was partially supported by conacyt- mxico , dgapa - unam and dgdaeia - uv through the `` 2013 internal call for strengthening academic groups '' ( uv - ca-320 ) . if small oscillations around the energy minimum are considered , a quadratic hamiltonian is obtained whose normal frequencies @xmath55 give the low lying energy spectrum of the quantum model with excitation energies @xmath56 , with @xmath57 . for couplings below the critical value the normal modes of the low energy regime can be obtained by expanding the classical hamiltonian ( [ diham ] ) around the global minimum @xmath58 . this expansion is easily obtained by transforming @xcite the angular momentum canonical variables ( @xmath59 and @xmath30 ) to @xmath60 , @xmath61 . in terms of these variables the classical hamiltonian ( [ diham ] ) of the dicke model ( @xmath62 ) , reads @xmath63 by expanding the square root in the previous hamiltonian , we obtain , to leading order , a quadratic hamiltonian @xmath64 with normal frequencies @xcite given by @xmath65 for couplings larger than the critical one , two degenerate minima emerge , and the expansion has to be taken around these new minima ( @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 ) given by eq.(12 ) in the companion paper ( i ) . the expansion until the quadratic leading terms is @xmath70\\ & + & \frac{j\omega_o}{2 } \left [ \left ( \frac{\gamma^2}{\gamma_c^2}-\frac{\gamma_c^2}{\gamma^2}\right)\phi^2 + \frac { ( \gamma/\gamma_c)^4}{\left ( \frac{\gamma^2}{\gamma_c^2}-\frac{\gamma_c^2}{\gamma^2}\right ) } \left(\frac{j_z - j_{zm}}{j}\right)^2\right]\nonumber\\ & + & \frac{\sqrt{\omega\omega_o j}}{\sqrt{\frac{\gamma^2}{\gamma_c^2}-\frac{\gamma_c^2}{\gamma^2 } } } ( q - q_m)\left(\frac{j_z - j_{zm}}{j}\right ) . \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] the normal modes of the previous quadratic hamiltonian can be obtained easily @xcite , they are @xmath71 the extended bosonic basis we used in ( i ) to diagonalize the dicke hamiltonian is given @xcite by the eigenstates of the dicke hamiltonian in the limit @xmath72 , which are @xmath73 where @xmath74 , @xmath75 are the eigenvalues of @xmath76 , and @xmath77 , with @xmath78 a boson coherent state and @xmath79 an eigenstate of the @xmath80 operator . the previous states are not eigenstates of the parity operator @xmath81 . in order to analyze the statistical properties of the dicke spectrum , we have to separate the energy eigenstates according to their parity ( @xmath20 ) . to this end , we construct a basis which is also an eigenbasis of the parity operator . it is easy to prove that @xmath82 this result shows that the states ( [ cohbas ] ) are proportional to @xmath83 . it can be shown ( see @xcite ) that the action of the rotation operator @xmath84 over @xmath79 gives @xmath85 therefore we have @xmath86 on the other hand , by using the properties of the coherent states , it is straightforward to show that @xmath87 . with the previous result we obtain @xmath88 by putting together eqs.([acrot ] ) and ( [ p3 ] ) we obtain @xmath89 then , the invariant subspaces of the the parity operator are generated by states ( [ cohbas ] ) with the same values @xmath90 and @xmath91 . it is straightforward to diagonalize the parity operator in these subspaces , and we obtain the eigenstates of the dicke hamiltonian in the limit @xmath72 , which are simultaneously eigenstates of the parity operator @xmath92 , @xmath93 using this basis we can separate from the beginning the two parity sectors of the dicke model and use the extended coherent basis , which has been shown @xcite to be very efficient to study large dicke systems . 99 r. h. dicke , _ phys . rev . _ * 93 * , 99 ( 1954 ) . k. hepp and e. h. lieb , _ ann . _ * 76 * , 360 ( 1973 ) . y. k. wang and f. t. hioe , _ phys . rev . a _ * 7 * , 831 ( 1973 ) . companion paper . f. haake , _ quantum signatures of chaos _ , springer . c. emary and t. brandes , _ phys . e _ * 67 * , 066203 ( 2003 ) ; phys . . lett . * 90 * , 044101 ( 2003 ) . p. prez - fernndez , a. relao , j. m. arias , p. cejnar , j. dukelsky , and j. e. garca - ramos , _ phys . e _ * 83 * , 046208 ( 2011 ) . a. altland and f. haake , _ phys . lett . _ * 108 * , 073601 ( 2012 ) ; _ new j. phys . _ * 14 * , 073011 ( 2012 ) . l. bakemeier , a. alvermann , and h. fehske , _ phys . rev . _ a * 88 * 043835 ( 2013 ) . e. nahmad - achar , o. castaos , r. lpez - pea , and j. g. hirsch , phys . * 87 * ( 2013 ) 038114 . de aguiar , k. furuya , c.h . lewenkopf , and m.c . nemes , _ annals of physics _ * 216 * , 291 ( 1992 ) . t. brandes , _ phys . e _ * 88 * , 032133 ( 2013 ) . a. peres , _ phys lett . _ * 53 * 1711 ( 1984 ) . p.strnsk , p. hruska , and p. cejnar , _ phys . * 79 * , 066201 ( 2009 ) . anderson and d.a . darling , _ ann . math . _ * 23 * 193 - 212 ( 1952 ) j. g. hirsch , o. castaos , e. nahmad - achar , and r. lpez - pea , phys . * 87 * ( 2013 ) 038106 . p. cejnar and p. strnsk , _ phys . . lett _ * 93 * 102502 ( 2004 ) p. strnsk , m. kurian , and p. cejnar , _ phys . _ c * 74 * 014306 ( 2006 ) h.goldstein , c. poole , and j. safko , _ classical mechanics _ , addison - wesley . q. h. chen , y. y. zhang , t. liu , and k. l. wang , _ phys . a _ * 78 * 051801 ( 2008 ) ; t. liu , y. y. zhang , q. h. chen , and k. l. wang , _ phys . rev . a _ * 80 * 023810 ( 2009 ) . m. a. bastarrachea - magnani and j. g. hirsch , _ rev . s _ * 57 * 0069 ( 2011 ) http://rmf.smf.mx/pdf/rmf-s/57/3/5730069.pdf . a. r. edmonds , _ angular momentum in quantum mechanics _ , princeton university press .

the non - integrable dicke model and its integrable approximation , the tavis - cummings ( tc ) model , are studied as functions of both the coupling constant and the excitation energy . the present contribution extends the analysis presented in the previous paper by focusing on the statistical properties of the quantum fluctuations in the energy spectrum and their relation with the excited state quantum phase transitions ( esqpt ) . these properties are compared with the dynamics observed in the semi - classical versions of the models . the presence of chaos for different energies and coupling constants is exhibited , employing poincar sections and peres lattices in the classical and quantum versions , respectively . a clear correspondence between the classical and quantum result is found for systems containing between @xmath0 to @xmath1 atoms . a measure of the wigner character of the energy spectrum for different couplings and energy intervals is also presented employing the statistical anderson - darling test . it is found that in the dicke model , for any coupling , a low energy regime with regular states is always present . the richness of the onset of chaos is discussed both for finite quantum systems and for the semi - classical limit , which is exact when the number of atoms in the system tends to infinite .

1405.1839

since the first planet outside the solar system was discovered orbiting the millisecond pulsar psr1257 + 12 ( @xcite ) , the study of extra - solar planets has rapidly become one of the key research areas in astronomy today . at the time of writing , 1782 exoplanets have been identified through many different techniques including radial velocity measurements , gravitational microlensing , transit surveys and many others . as of writing , 1133 are known to be transiting , mostly discovered by transit surveys such as superwasp ( @xcite ) , corot ( @xcite ) , the hatnet project ( @xcite ) and kepler ( @xcite ) . transiting systems provide a radius , and hence bulk density when coupled with the planetary mass determined from radial velocity follow - up , as well as characterising their atmospheres with techniques such as transmission spectroscopy ( @xcite , @xcite ) and secondary eclipse photometry ( @xcite , @xcite ) . the bulk density is an important parameter to determine , as this value is used in chemical composition models and atmospheric simulations . the bulk density is measured by determining the radius of the planet from the transit lightcurve , and assuming a spherical planet in order to work out the volume . since the volume and mass of the planet are then both known , a simple bulk density calculation can be applied . previous work on modelling exoplanet distortion has been carried out by @xcite , who demonstrated that tidal and rotational forces result in a systematic underestimation of the planetary radius . the tidal distortion is particularly relevant for short period planets with low masses and large radii , as these systems are subject to a significant amount of gravitational interaction with the host star . since the bulk of the distortion would lie along the axis connecting the star and planet , this effect would not be apparent during transit observations where the planet will appear largely spherical due to the observer being presented with a smaller cross - sectional area during transit . failing to account for this distortion would therefore result in a systematic overestimation of the measured densities of exoplanets , since the volume is calculated based on the planet being spherical . since a significant proportion ( @xmath030% ) of exoplanets so far discovered have orbital separations of @xmath10.1a.u . ( @xcite ) , this could potentially affect the measured bulk densities of a number of hot - jupiter systems . indeed , work by @xcite and @xcite show that distortion in wasp-12b is appreciable , and can potentially impact on mass - loss rates for short - period systems . naturally , if the tidal forces are weak , the distortion will be negligible , and the planet remains close to spherical . while @xcite are able to calculate the distorted shapes of exoplanets , which has important implications for our understanding of the internal dynamics of short period systems , their approach is limited in that the models are difficult to reconcile with observational parameters . for example , the work of @xcite requires detailed internal structure models , incorporating effects such as rotation and atmospheric structure . these parameters are obtained from models derived from measurements of jupiter and saturn . since our solar system s gas giants have markedly different rotation periods , orbital separations and incident fluxes to those of the short - period hot - jupiters , accurate determination of such internal parameters for hot - jupiters is fraught with uncertainty and potential error , as well as being beyond the expertise of the average observer . this is further demonstrated by the fact that , to the best of our knowledge , the important work by @xcite has never been applied to determine planetary density corrections in any observational exoplanet characterisation publication ( though it has been used to indicate the importance of tidal distortion effects e.g. @xcite , @xcite ) . the aim , therefore , was to outline a much simpler model to estimate planetary distortion , which would be easier to implement and would be comparable to the more detailed simulations of @xcite in order to make the models as applicable to observers as possible , the main focus of the modelling was to estimate the distortion using observed parameters gleaned from transit photometry and rv measurements . in this paper , we model the gravitational interaction between the parent star and planet using the roche approximation , and show that tidal distortion can be significant for hot - jupiters with orbital periods less than @xmath02 days . in section 2 , we outline the method of constructing a distorted hot - jupiter and measuring the volume in order to work out the change in bulk density , and use this model in section 3 to estimate the distortion of hot - saturn - like planets . in section 4 , we use the parameters of the shortest - period systems , derived from follow - up photometry and radial - velocity measurements , to calculate the tidal distortion of these exoplanets , and discuss the significance of these findings , comparing the results with the simulations by @xcite in order to model the exoplanets tidally distorted surface , we have assumed that it lies along a surface of constant gravitational potential . under the roche approximation ( @xcite ) , the total gravitational potential ( @xmath2 ) at any point within the system is given by ; @xmath3^{1/2}}\\ & -\frac{1}{2}\omega^2[(x-{\mu}a)^2+y^2 ] , \label{eqn : phi } \end{split}\ ] ] ( e.g. @xcite ) where @xmath4 is the mass of the primary component ( in this case the host star ) and @xmath5 is the mass of the secondary ( in this case the exoplanet ) . @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 are co - ordinates in which the surface is plotted with the origin at the centre - of - mass of the primary component , where @xmath6 is along the line - of - centre , @xmath7 is along the orbital plane and @xmath8 makes a right - handed set . @xmath9 is the orbital separation between the centres - of - mass of the two components . @xmath10 and @xmath11 ( the angular velocity of the system ) , where @xmath12 is the orbital period . the roche approximation has widely been used to model interacting binary systems , such as cataclysmic variables ( cvs ) . for example , roche tomography ( for a description , see e.g. @xcite , @xcite ) uses the roche approximation in order to reconstruct the surface features of secondaries for a number of cv systems from the velocity profiles ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . given the extreme tidal forces acting on some short period hot - jupiters , it was decided to model their shapes using the roche approximation . the main advantage of this approach is that it is possible to obtain the distortion solely from the observed system parameters as opposed to methods which use parameters derived from simulations , such as planetary rotation and internal structure . we note here that the roche approximation has previously been used by @xcite to estimate the reflection effect for tidally distorted planets , but density corrections were not calculated for these systems . in order to measure the distortion of the planet using the roche approximation , a number of assumptions have been made . first , we have assumed the planet is tidally locked with the star , so the orbital period is equal to the rotation period . we also assume the orbit has been circularised , so as to keep the distortion over the orbital period constant . this is a reasonable assumption , as it follows predictions of hot - jupiter formation and follow - up work ( e.g. @xcite ) . it is also a requirement of equation [ eqn : phi ] . we have also assumed that the mass of the planet is centrally condensed , again , required by equation [ eqn : phi ] . this was also an assumption made by @xcite and , for example , simulations by @xcite predict a centrally condensed wasp-12b given an orbital eccentricity of @xmath00 . in order to match the model to the observed radius , the value of @xmath2 in equation [ eqn : phi ] was adjusted such that the projected area of the model planet during transit matched those given by observations . this method gives the quantity ( @xmath13/@xmath14)@xmath15 , the ratio of the planetary occulting area to projected star area . since this is equivalent to the actual parameter derived from the transit light curve , this was determined to be the best method in which to set the value of @xmath13 , as opposed to just setting the value of @xmath2 to return the corresponding polar radius . the three - dimensional output is given in figure [ roche ] , along with the spherical case using the parameters of wasp-19 , a planetary system with one of the shortest known orbital periods ( 0.79 days ) . figure [ zerophase ] shows the sky - projected surface area of wasp-19b for both the spherical and distorted case at phase 0 . as can be seen from the projections , the polar radius at zero phase is almost identical this is due to the bulk of the distortion being projected away from the observer , towards the star , making the planet appear spherical in both cases . since the precise co - ordinates of the tiles were known , the volume of each ` slice ' of elements was determined by finding the area bounding the surface of the tile with the centre of the slice . the area was then multiplied by the depth of each slice , effectively modelling it as a tapered wedge . the number of tiles were set sufficiently high to make the gaps between sequential tile areas negligible , but also sufficiently low to avoid truncation issues when working out the projected area . to check there were no jumps in the projected area due to the tile projections , the density of the planet was calculated as a function of orbital period . figure [ track ] is an example of this process using the system parameters of wasp-19b . this allowed for the internal consistency of the code to be tested by setting the orbital period of the system to a value where one would expect the distortion to be negligible , and hence the planet to be spherical . at around 10 days , the difference between the volume given by the spherical case and the volume output from the simulations was @xmath00.001% for wasp-19b . once the accuracy and consistency of the code had been thoroughly established and tile truncation and placement errors had been minimised , the parameters of thirty - four short - period hot - jupiters were obtained in order to model the tidal distortion for each of these systems . we discuss the impact of this in section [ results ] . as a final demonstration , a number of cases of exoplanets with parameters similar to saturn have been modelled with the orbital period set to one day , the results of which are summarised in table [ tab : simulations of saturn - like planets ] . this was carried out in order to investigate the region of planetary parameters , primarily star - to - planet mass ratio , which are most susceptible to a severe ( i.e. @xmath1620% ) level of distortion . a 1@xmath17 model and 0.3 @xmath17 ( saturn - like ) model have been added as a comparison . we have also run the simulations over a range of orbital periods . the results from these simulations indicate that for saturn - mass planets , the density correction is significantly important for orbital periods of less than @xmath01.5 days . for a hot - saturn with an orbital period of 0.6 days , the density correction approaches 25% , sufficient to alter the position of the exoplanet on the mass - radius relation ( see figure [ fig : massrad ] ) . whilst there has yet to be a candidate discovered matching these orbital parameters , many systems are being identified with densities matching that of saturn with short orbital periods ( e.g @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . it can be seen that a density correction of @xmath05 - 10% is being approached for systems with more massive host stars , for orbital periods of 1 day . whist systems matching these exact parameters have yet to be discovered , hot - jupiters with orbital periods of less than one day are known to exist ( e.g. wasp-18b , wasp-19b , corot-7b , kepler-10b , kepler-70b ) . the parameters we have used for these simulations provide an initial , if somewhat speculative , investigation into planets which could potentially show extreme levels of distortion . in the case of gj163b a non - transiting exoplanet we have simply used the mass ratio of the system with a saturn - like radius , as the radius of the planet can not be constrained from radial velocity measurements . an especially interesting case is that of hd149026b . since its discovery in 2005 , the incredibly high density ( 1.17g@xmath18 ) has resulted in the prediction of an anomalously high core mass of 70 - 85@xmath19 ( @xcite ) . previous predictions of planetary formation using the core accretion model indicate a maximum core mass of 30@xmath19 before runaway gas accretion occurs ( @xcite ) . several explanations for the massive core of hd149026b have been proposed , including heavy element rain onto the core , accretion of planetesimals and collisions between planetary embryos ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . while the gravitational distortion of this planet with its current orbital period of 2.8 days is insufficient to lower its density in order to reduce the core mass to levels that agree with accretion theory , gravitational distortion could allow this for shorter period systems , should they be observed . for example , a saturn - mass planet in a 1 day orbit around a 1.1@xmath20 star would yield a radius of 0.7@xmath21 if sphericity was assumed , but would actually have a mean radius closer to 0.8@xmath21 due to gravitational distortion . using the evolutionary models of @xcite in addition to the core mass values calculated by @xcite with our new density value would allow a more accurate core mass to be estimated for such systems . for the case above , assuming a spherical planet ( i.e. a radius of 0.7@xmath21 ) , the core mass would be calculated to be 85@xmath19 assuming a core density of 5.5g@xmath18 , and a core mass of @xmath2274@xmath19 assuming a core density of 10.5g@xmath18 ( the core density of saturn ) . the value of our density correction , however , would result in a corrected estimate of the core mass of @xmath2274@xmath19 assuming a core density of 5.5g@xmath18 , and a core mass of @xmath2260@xmath19 assuming a core density of 10.5g@xmath18 for the distorted case . this reduction in the core mass of a planet analogous to hd149026b on a sufficiently short - period indicates that hot - saturns discovered to have a higher than expected core mass can be partially explained by the tidal distortion effect . additional mechanisms , such as accretion of planetesimals , can then be invoked to explain this much more easily with a reduced core mass . .output from simulations using the mass - ratios of three exoplanet systems , hd149026 , wasp-29 and gj163 , using a 1 day orbital period . also included as a comparison are the cases for a jupiter - mass planet and a saturn - mass planet orbiting a 1@xmath20 star with a period of 1 day . the density values have been indicated for both the spherical ( 6 ) and distorted cases ( 7 ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] these planets have an appreciable eccentricity , with hat - p-23 having @xmath23=0.106 , and gj436 having @xmath23=0.15 , and therefore do not strictly satisfy the condition of orbital circularisation assumed by equation [ eqn : phi ] . + [ 1 ] @xcite [ 2 ] @xcite [ 3 ] @xcite [ 4 ] @xcite [ 5 ] @xcite [ 6 ] @xcite [ 7 ] @xcite [ 8 ] @xcite [ 9 ] @xcite [ 10 ] @xcite [ 11 ] @xcite [ 12 ] @xcite [ 13 ] @xcite [ 14 ] @xcite [ 15 ] @xcite [ 16 ] @xcite [ 17 ] @xcite [ 18 ] @xcite [ 19 ] @xcite [ 20 ] @xcite [ 21 ] @xcite [ 22 ] @xcite [ 23 ] @xcite [ 24 ] @xcite [ 25 ] @xcite [ 26 ] @xcite [ 27 ] @xcite [ 28 ] @xcite +

the close proximity of short period hot - jupiters to their parent star means they are subject to extreme tidal forces . this has a profound effect on their structure and , as a result , density measurements that assume that the planet is spherical can be incorrect . we have simulated the tidally distorted surface for 34 known short period hot - jupiters , assuming surfaces of constant gravitational equipotential for the planet , and the resulting densities have been calculated based only on observed parameters of the exoplanet systems . comparing these results to the density values assuming the planets are spherical shows that there is an appreciable change in the measured density for planets with very short periods ( typically less than two days ) . for one of the shortest - period systems , wasp-19b , we determine a decrease in bulk density of 12% from the spherical case and , for the majority of systems in this study , this value is in the range of 1 - 5% . on the other - hand , we also find cases where the distortion is negligible ( relative to the measurement errors on the planetary parameters ) even in the cases of some very short period systems , depending on the mass ratio and planetary radius . for high - density gas - planets requiring apparently anomalously large core masses , density corrections due to tidal deformation could become important for the shortest - period systems .

cond-mat0512112

noise and fluctuation in general , are enhanced when the system size is reduced . in the case of equilibrium thermal fluctuation of a physical quantity , it is inversely proportional to the system size . in this paper , we would like to investigate the specific issue of electrical noise in metallic nanowires . this is an important issue not only as a basic question but also as an important parameter that should be considered for the use of nanowires as interconnects in nanoelectronics . the equilibrium white thermal noise ( the nyquist noise ) of a wire of resistance r at a temperature t can be estimated from the power spectral density @xmath6 @xcite where @xmath7 is the boltzmann constant . this component of the electrical noise depends only on the sample resistance r. the nyquist noise has no explicit dependence on of the size of the sample , the only size dependence in through the size dependence of r. however , in a current carrying nanowire a larger contribution to the electrical noise is expected to arise from the @xmath8excess noise `` or @xmath8conductance or resistance noise '' . this noise has a spectral power density of the type @xmath9 , where @xmath10 and is known as @xmath81/f noise . " we note that _ apriori _ there is no way of estimating the actual value of the 1/f noise because 1/f can arise from many different sources @xcite . as a result , an experimental measurement is an absolute necessity to make even an estimate of this noise component . for metallic films , past studies have shown that an estimate of the value of the 1/f noise can be made from the empirical hooge s formula given as : @xmath11 where n is the number of electrons in the sample , v is the bias used for measurements and @xmath12 is an empirical constant which for metallic films lie in the range @xmath13 . in this paper we address the issue of 1/f electrical noise in nanowires . we have measured the low - frequency resistance fluctuations ( 1 mhz@xmath0f@xmath010 hz ) in ag nanowires of diameter 15 nm @xmath1 d @xmath1 200 nm at room temperatures . the wires were electrochemically grown in templates of anodic alumina or polycarbonate . we observe that the noise indeed has a spectral power density @xmath9 and the magnitude of noise increases as the size is reduced . the observed noise in the metallic nanowires is larger ( @xmath14 ) than what one would expect from a simple extrapolation of hooge s relation to this domain . the exponent @xmath3 also deviates from @xmath15 as the diameter ( d ) of the nanowire is reduced . to our knowledge , this is the first report of the investigation of 1/f noise in nanowires in this range of diameters . the ag nanowires have been grown within polycarbonate ( pc ) templates ( etched track membranes ) or anodic alumina ( aa ) templates using electrochemical deposition from agno@xmath16 solution @xcite . the membranes have been procured from a standard commercial source @xcite . during the growth one side of the membrane was covered with an evaporated metal and was used as the anode . the other electrode was a micro - tip ( radius of curvature @xmath17 m ) that can be positioned by a micropositioner to a specific area on the other side of the membrane and the growth can thus be localized . the arrangement is shown as inset in figure 2 . the growth current used is approximately 10 ma . generally the growth occurs within the pore by filling it from end to end . as soon as a few wires grow and touch the electrodes , the electrochemical cell gets short circuited and the electrochemical deposition stops . the membrane containing the nanowire is then cleaned with deionized water and annealed at 400 k for 10 - 12 hours . during annealing a current 1 ma of is passed through the sample . the post deposition annealing is needed to stabilize the wire . the wires after growth can be retained within the membranes , as was done for the electrical measurements or can be freed from the membrane by etching the membrane off with a suitable etchant ( dichloromethane for pc and koh for aa ) . the wires after growth were characterized by x - ray , sem and tem . figure 1(a ) shows a sem image of the assembly of 100 nm wires ( after partially dissolving off the template ) . a tem image of a 15 nm wire ( taken after removing the membrane ) is shown in figure 1(b ) . from the tem data we find that the wires are single crystalline with occasional twinning . the selective area diffraction patterns showed that the wires have fcc structure . the diameter of the wire is close ( within @xmath18 ) to the nominal diameter of the pore of the membrane . this shows that the wires grow by filling the membranes . ( a)sem image of 100 nm wires taken after dissolving the template . ( b)tem image of a 15 nm ag wire.,title="fig:",width=226,height=188 ] ( a)sem image of 100 nm wires taken after dissolving the template . ( b)tem image of a 15 nm ag wire.,title="fig:",width=226,height=188 ] table 1 gives the diameter and lengths of different samples that have been used in the measurements . .[tab : table1]the radius and diameters of the various samples used in this work . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] in figure 2 we show the typical xrd data for a 20 nm wire . the xrd data on the nanowire matches nicely with the data taken on a bulk silver sample . the observed lines can all be indexed to a fcc ag . the xrd data for a 20 nm ag wire . the xrd data on the nanowire matches with the data taken on a bulk silver sample and the observed lines can all be indexed to a fcc ag . , width=377,height=302 ] we have measured resistance of the arrays of nanowires down to 4.2 k. this was done to check the residual resistivity ratio and the behavior of the resistance at low temperatures . the resistance noise measurements were done at room temperature using a digital signal processing ( dsp ) based a.c technique which allows simultaneous measurement of the background noise as well as the bias dependent noise from the sample @xcite . the sample is current biased and the resistance noise appears as a voltage fluctuation . the data are taken by stabilizing the temperature with @xmath19 . the measured background noise ( bias independent ) was white and was contributed by the 4k@xmath20tr nyquist noise . the apparatus can measure a spectral power down to @xmath21 v@xmath22hz@xmath23 . we have used a transformer preamplifier sr554 to couple the sample to the lock - in - amplifier . the basic electrical schematic is shown in the inset of figure 3 . the details of the data acquisition and the signal processing are given elsewhere @xcite . a single set of data are acquired typically for a time period of about fifty minutes or more at a sampling rate of 1024 points / sec . the time series of voltage fluctuations as a function of time consisting of nearly 3 million points was decimated to about 0.1 million points before the power spectral density s@xmath24(f ) is determined numerically . the frequency range probed by us ranges from 1 mhz to 10 hz . the frequency range is determined mostly by practical considerations . the lower frequency limit is determined by the quality of the temperature control . the sample resistance and the bridge output may also show a long time drift ( in general such a long time drift is subtracted out by a least square fit to the data ) . taking these factors into consideration the lower spectral limit in our experiment has been kept at 1 mhz . the high frequency limit of 10 hz is decided by the spectral window of the lock - in amplifier output filter which is operated at 24 db / octave with a time constant of 3 ms . the resistance and noise measurements were carried out by retaining the wires within the polymeric or alumina membranes . the sample , as stated before , consists of an array of nanowires . on each of the two sides of the membrane two electrical leads were attached using silver epoxy . though the measurements were made with the wires retained within the membrane , the system is an array of parallel nanowires where the individual wires are well separated by the insulating membrane . a very important issue in this measurement is the contribution of the contacts to the measurement . we have paid attention to this aspect and measured both resistance and noise by making the contact in different ways . we discuss this issue in more detail at a later stage when we discuss the data . we find that the contact contribution , if any , is negligibly small both in the measured resistance as well as the noise . the resistance measurements were done using the same electrodes which were used for noise measurements . in figure 3 we show the temperature dependence of the resistance of ag nanowire arrays of diameter 15 nm . the resistivity data for the wires of other diameters are qualitatively similar and are therefore not shown . the arrays contain different number of wires . it is possible to make a rough estimate of wires by a procedure described before @xcite to within a factor of 2 . due to the uncertainty in the number of wires in the arrays we can not fix the exact resistivities of the nanowires even if their diameter and the length are known to a reasonable degree of certainty . for all the samples the resistance has a fairly linear temperature dependence down to 75k and @xmath25 reaches a residual value below 30k . the residual resistivity ratio ( rrr)@xmath26 for all the wires lie between 3 and 6 . we find that the wires do not show any upturn in resistivity at low temperatures . this shows that the conduction of electrons in these wires are not controlled by disorder induced effects like localization @xcite . this ensures that the product @xmath27 is much larger than 1 . ( here @xmath28 is the fermi wavevector and @xmath29 is the elastic mean free path . ) the temperature coefficient of resistivity ( @xmath30 ) can be obtained from the resistance data for the nanowires . @xmath31 is in the range @xmath32 /k . this is smaller than but comparable to that of bulk silver which is @xmath33 /k . the temperature dependence of the resistivity thus shows predominantly metallic behaviour which is in agreement with the tem observation that the wires are single crystalline . for bulk silver at room temperature the mean free path is @xmath34 60 nm . for the wires with diameter @xmath0 50 nm , the mean free path will have significant contribution from the surface as well as from the grain boundaries within the wire @xcite this is an issue of considerable current interest due to diminishing size of the metallic interconnects in ic @xcite . given the scope of the paper we do not elaborate on this particular issue in detail but note that these factors which limit the electron mean free path can also contribute to the resistance noise . in figure 4 we show the typical low frequency power spectrum of the voltage noise arising from the resistance fluctuation in the current biased nanowires . the spectral power s@xmath24(f ) is @xmath35 to v@xmath36 where v is the bias voltage ( typically few tens of @xmath37 v ) and in figure 4 the spectral power is shown as s@xmath24(f)/v@xmath22 . the power spectra have a predominant 1/f@xmath38 nature . the observed noise appears to be independent on the nature of the membrane ( polymer or alumina ) as the observed noise data in wires of similar diameter are qualitatively the same . we note that contact can be a serious issue in noise measurements and we carried out a number of checks to rule out any predominant contribution of the contact to the measured noise . in addition to silver epoxy contacts we also used evaporated silver films and pb - sn solder to make contact . we find that they give similar results to within @xmath39 . in case of the pb - sn contact the change in r of the sample as we go below the superconducting transition temperature ( @xmath40 7 k ) of the solder is negligibly small ( @xmath41 ) implying a very small contribution of the contact to the total r measured . we have also measured the noise in different samples with varying numbers of wires in them . the resistance of the array , due to different number of wires in them vary . also such samples will have significantly different contact areas and hence different contact noise , if any . yet we find that the normalized noise @xmath42 in different arrays of the same diameter wire lie within @xmath39 . all these tests rule out any predominant contribution from the contacts . the normalized resistance fluctuation @xmath5 for a nanowire array of resistance r is obtained by integrating the power spectral density @xmath44 over the band width of our measurement . this equation , while giving correctly the relative resistance fluctuation of a single wire , is also applicable when there is more than one wire in parallel because of the following reasoning . if r the is resistance of * n * identical parallel wires each of resistance r@xmath45 , then @xmath46 . from this we get @xmath5 = @xmath47 thus implying that the measured noise is independent of the number of wires in parallel . we make the interesting observation that resistance fluctuation has a dependence on the diameter of the wire . for this purpose we separate the wires into two groups according to their length . group a contains wires grown in the pc membranes and have a length of 6 @xmath37 m. group b contains wires of length 60 @xmath37 m that were grown in alumina templates . thus a nanowire array belonging to a given group differ only in their diameters . the data are shown in figure 5 . one can clearly see that for nanowires of a given length ( group a or b ) there is an increase in the normalized noise as the diameter d is reduced . the exponent @xmath3 has an interesting dependence on the size of the wire as well . this is shown in the inset of figure 5 where @xmath3 is plotted as a function of 1/d . for wires with diameter d @xmath48 100 nm the exponent @xmath3 is @xmath34 1 . the value of the exponent is similar to what one finds in wires of larger diameter and in metallic films . this is generally expected to arise from activated defect dynamics as envisioned in the dutta - horn model @xcite . however , there is a perceptible increase in @xmath3 once the wire diameter reaches below 50 nm and it increases further when the diameter is reduced to 15 nm . such a change in @xmath3 is rather interesting and would indicate the presence of additional noise mechanism in the nanowires which are not present in wires of larger diameter . we are currently investigating the origin of such an extra component as well as the physical reason of the enhancement of the normalized noise on reducing the diameter d of the nanowire . to check that such a size dependence of the 1/f noise is indeed observed in other metallic nanowires we have also carried out noise measurements in cu nanowires of diameter 15 nm grown by similar electrochemical method in pc membranes . the spectral power density is shown in figure 6 . the behavior of the spectral power is rather similar to the ag nanowire of the same diameter and the magnitude of the resistance fluctuation @xmath49 at 300 k which is comparable to that seen in 15 nm ag nanowire . this strongly suggests that the observed behavior may be a general behavior of the metallic nanowires . it is tempting to express the observed results in the form of hooge relation ( equation [ hooge ] ) . however , due to the uncertainty in the exact numbers of wires in the arrays we can not estimate @xmath50 . also the hooge relation is valid for @xmath43 and any deviation of @xmath3 from 1 makes @xmath50 dependent on the exact frequency of measurement . to summarize , we find that in metallic ag ( and cu ) nanowires the low frequency resistance fluctuation is enhanced when the diameter is reduced . the power spectral density of the fluctuation has a 1/f@xmath38 character as seen in metallic films and wires of larger dimension . the fluctuation has a significant low - frequency component and @xmath3 increases from the usual 1 as the diameter d is reduced . the reduction of the diameter d also leads to an enhancement of the normalized fluctuation @xmath5 . our results shows that there are new features in the 1/f noise as the size is reduced and they become more prominent when the diameter of the wires fall to 15 nm . it will be important to investigate the origin of the new behavior . this is needed because 1/f noise will play an important role and may even become a limiting factor in use of such nanometer size metal wires as interconnects . the authors would like to thank dr . n. ravishankar ( mrc , iisc ) for the tem data . this work is supported by dst , govt . of india , csir , govt . of india and dit , govt . a. bid would like to thank csir for a fellowship and a.bora wants to thank ugc for a fellowship . 100 h.nyquist , phys . , * 32 * , 110 , ( 1928 ) . rev . of mod . phys.,*60 * , 537 , ( 1988 ) . p.dutta and p. m. horn , rev . * 53 * , 497 , ( 1981 ) . a.k.raychaudhuri , _ the chemistry of nanomaterials_(ed . c.n.r rao , a.muller and a.k.cheetham , wiley - vch , n.y 2004 ) vol 2 , 688 . http://www.whatman.com/products/?pageid=7.57.291.22 , http://www.whatman.com/products/?pageid=7.57.293 . j. h. scofield , rev . instr . , * 58 * , 985 , ( 1987 ) . a.ghosh , s.kar , a.bid and a.k.raychaudhuri arxiv : cond - mat/0402130 v1 4 feb 2004 . w.d.williams and n. giordano , phys . rev b , * 33 * , 8146 , ( 1986 ) . g. bergmann , physics reports , * 107 * , 1 ( 1984 ) . e. h. sondheimer , adv . phys . * 1 * , 1 ( 1952 ) . a. f. mayadas and m. shatzkes , phys . b * 1 * , 1382 , ( 1970 ) . c. durkan and m. e. welland , phys . rev b , * 61 * , 14 215 , ( 2000 ) . w. wu , s. h. brongersma , m. van hove , and k. maex , appl . letts , * 84 * , ( 2004 ) .

we have measured the low - frequency resistance fluctuations ( 1 mhz@xmath0f@xmath010 hz ) in ag nanowires of diameter 15 nm @xmath1 d @xmath1 200 nm at room temperatures . the power spectral density ( psd ) of the fluctuations has a @xmath2 character as seen in metallic films and wires of larger dimension . additionally , the psd has a significant low - frequency component and the value of @xmath3 increases from the usual 1 to @xmath4 as the diameter d is reduced . the value of the normalized fluctuation @xmath5 also increases as the diameter d is reduced . we observe that there are new features in the 1/f noise as the size of the wire is reduced and they become more prominent as the diameter of the wires approaches 15 nm . it is important to investigate the origin of the new behavior as 1/f noise may become a limiting factor in the use of metal wires of nanometer dimensions as interconnects .

1112.2159

graphene@xcite possesses a very long mean free path of the order of micrometers and a ballistic transport regime at low temperatures@xcite , which combined with a low spin - orbit coupling make it ideal for applications in spintronic devices . however , due to the intrinsic spin - unpolarized electronic structure of a pristine sheet , it is necessary to modify the electronic structure of graphene in such a way that the transport properties of the two spin channels become different . few ways that have been proposed to do this are ( i ) quantum confinement ( _ e . graphene nanoribbons@xcite , nanoflakes@xcite , hidrogenation@xcite , and interaction with substrates@xcite ) ; ii ) strain@xcite ; and iii ) adsorption of molecules or atoms@xcite , where the presence of a local magnetic moment leads to a spin - non - degenerated electronic structure . however , edge disorder is a limiting factor to use quantum confinement as a way to differentiate the spin channels , and for the application of strain , there is the drawback of a mechanically controllable device . therefore , doping large - area graphene with magnetic dopants seems more suitable for applications in spintronics . in the last few years , motivated by spintronic applications , many studies focused on understanding the doping properties of metallic adatoms on graphene . experimentally , it has been shown that both noble metals and transition metals tend to diffuse and clusterize in pristine graphene , unless they are trapped in lattice defects such as monovacancies ( mvs ) and divacancies ( dvs).@xcite moreover , all theoretical studies of metallic doping in large - area graphene have focused solely in investigating the emergence of local magnetic moments@xcite . however , conclusions about the possibility of using metallic doping to generate spin - polarized transport requires the investigation of spin - resolved currents , instead of merely local magnetic moments . ( color online ) ( a ) representation of devices considered in this work . ( b ) possible adsorption sites for atoms on pristine graphene . ( c ) geometry for @xmath9 , similar to all other atoms . ( d ) @xmath10 , similar to all other atoms . ( e ) @xmath11 ( similar to @xmath4:@xmath6:@xmath12 ) . ( f ) @xmath13 . ( g ) @xmath14 ( similar to @xmath15).,width=321 ] in this paper , we theoretically investigate spin - resolved currents flowing in large - area graphene , doped with single atoms of noble metals ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 ) and @xmath3-transition metals ( @xmath4,@xmath5,@xmath6 and @xmath7 ) . we study the adsorption both in pristine graphene as well as in monovacancies and divacancies , and we show that the current polarization is not monotonically correlated to the local magnetic moment . instead , it depends on the presence of localized levels near the fermi energy which strongly couple ( and thus hybridize ) to the graphene @xmath8 bands . we also show that a gate potential can be used to tune the energy of these localized levels , leading to an external way to control the degree of spin - polarized current without the application of a magnetic field . in fig . [ fig1 ] ( a ) we show the setup of the devices we considered in this work , and in panels ( b)-(g ) we show the representative geometries for the complexes of metals adsorbed in graphene , both pristine and with defects ( metal@defect ) . the paper is organized as follows : in the next section , we describe the methodology we used . in the subsequent section , we present our results , discussing the total energy calculations , the current polarization , the dependence on the doping concentration , and the effect of a gate potential . in the last section we present our conclusions . ( color online ) schematic representation of the unitary cell in the real ( a ) and reciprocal ( b ) spaces , where we define the symmetry points used to plot the energy bands.,width=321 ] in order to obtain the geometries and electronic structure , we employ total energy density functional theory@xcite ( dft ) calculations . all geometries were fully relaxed using a force criteria of @xmath16ev / with the siesta code@xcite . all calculations were carried out applying the generalized gradient approximation as parameterized by perdew , burke , and ernzerhof@xcite ( gga - pbe ) for the exchange correlation functional ( @xmath17 ) . we do not consider the spin - orbit coupling , because such interaction may locally open small band gaps@xcite , of the order of few milli electron volts , which will be a small effect when compared to the single - impurity scattering effects investigated in this paper . a localized double-@xmath18 polarized basis , an electronic temperature of @xmath19 , and @xmath20 for the grid cut - off were used . most of our results were obtained with a rectangular @xmath21 graphene supercell , as schematically shown in fig . [ fig2](a ) . the integration in the brillouin zone was done with the monkhorst - pack@xcite scheme corresponding to a @xmath22 sampling in the unitary cell . a vacuum of @xmath23 was used between the periodic images of graphene sheets to avoid undesirable interactions . the directions between the symmetry points defined in fig . [ fig2 ] ( b ) were used to plot the energy bands . once the relaxed geometries were obtained , we calculated the transport properties with the transampa code @xcite . this code makes use of the non equilibrium green s function techniques coupled to dft in a fully self - consistent way with the bttiker - landauer formalism@xcite within the non interacting approach of meir wingreen@xcite . within this formalism , the translational symmetry along the transport direction is broken . however , in the transversal direction , due to the periodicity of the infinite 2d - system , the bloch theorem is still usable . in order to take into account a truly 2d graphene sheet , we implement the transport equations with transversal periodicity , considering @xmath24-points perpendicular to the transport direction ( @xmath25 ) . in the transport calculations , the relaxed geometries were sandwiched between two buffer layers to guarantee that the scattering region has a pristine - like coupling with the leads . we used the same simulation parameters of the siesta calculations , with exception of the @xmath24-points sampling . here , for the electronic density , we used the equivalent of 48 @xmath25-points in the unitary cell , whereas for the transmittance , 5000 @xmath25-points are necessary for a smooth behavior . this number of @xmath24-points is sufficient to capture the true 2d - character of graphene . in each step of the self - consistent field cycle , we calculated the electronic density with an integral in the complex plane discretized in 60 energy points and 5 poles . when a bias potential was applied , the non equilibrium contribution for the electronic density was calculated with an integral discretized in 200 energy points . we also implement the effect of a gate potential with strength `` @xmath26 '' by adding to the hamiltonian a function @xmath27 that depends only on the @xmath28 coordinate , given by : @xmath29 \right\ } & , 0<z - z_{1}<\tau \\ v_{gate } & , z_{1}+\tau < z < z_{2}-\tau \\ \frac{v_{gate}}{2}\left\ { 1+cos\left [ \frac{\pi(z_2-\tau - z)}{\tau } \right ] \right\ } & , -\tau < z - z_2<0.\\ \end{array}\right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath28 is the transport direction , the above function affects only a region between @xmath30 and @xmath31 ( gated region ) and is continuous up to its first derivative . this region encloses the metal and the defect in our simulations , and we verified that the buffer - layer regions were not affected by this gate . the @xmath32 parameter controls the smoothness of the connections between the gated and non - gated regions , and we used @xmath33 for a smooth behavior . it is also important to mention that the gate effect is included in the whole self - consistent - field procedure , and the electronic density rearrangement creates a screening effect , in the sense that ( for example ) @xmath34 will not necessarily shift the energy levels by @xmath35 . this implementation is in the same spirit of refs . and . ccccc & m@pristine & m@mv & m@585 & m@555777 + [ cols="^",options="header " , ] + the relaxed geometries , local magnetic moments ( @xmath36 ) and binding energies ( @xmath37 ) are shown in table [ tab1 ] . our results compare well with previous calculations@xcite . this is also true for the adsorption of noble metals on pristine graphene , where van der waals interactions are important@xcite . however , in these cases , the energies obtained for the different configurations with our methodology are all very similar . thus , to select which adsorption site to use in the charge transport calculations [ b position in fig . [ fig1](b ) ] , we used the results of ref . . for atoms trapped in the mv , all relaxations lead to geometries similar to @xmath9 [ depicted in fig . [ fig1 ] ( c ) ] . however , the transition metals have a @xmath38 local symmetry , whereas for the noble metals this symmetry is destroyed by a structural distortion , breaking the spin degeneracies of localized states near the fermi level , leading to @xmath39 , as discussed in ref . . for adsorption on dvs , we considered two particular reconstructions studied in the literature@xcite , the 585 and 555777 . for atoms trapped in 585 dvs , we find a @xmath40 local symmetry in all cases , with the atoms displaced from the graphene plane , similar to @xmath10 , as shown in fig . [ fig1 ] ( d ) . all the @xmath3 transition metals adsorbed on the 555777 dv present a non - zero local magnetic moment , with the energetically most favorable position being above the central atom of this defect , as shown in fig . [ fig1 ] ( e ) . it is worth noting that ( i ) @xmath7 has a non zero local magnetic moment solely when trapped in this site and ( ii ) adsorption of adatoms has been experimentally observed in them@xcite . the noble metals , on the other hand , have a completely different behavior , presenting a zero local magnetic moment when adsorbed on the 555777 dv . the lowest energy configuration for @xmath13 is shown in fig . [ fig1 ] ( f ) , with the gold atom at the top of a carbon atom belonging to a pentagon . for @xmath0 and @xmath1 , the lowest energy position is above the center of a heptagon , as shown in fig . [ fig1 ] ( g ) . however , @xmath0 presents a @xmath41 local symmetry , whereas @xmath1 presents five different chemical bond lengths . ( color online ) current polarization with @xmath42 ( a ) for all studied cases , ( b ) as a function of the local magnetic moment , ( c ) as a function of the magnetic moment induced at the graphene carbon atoms . the solid lines guide the eye.,width=321 ] in fig . [ fig3 ] ( a ) we show the current polarization , cp=@xmath43 , for all studied cases , where the current for each spin channel ( @xmath44 ) is @xmath45de$ ] , with @xmath46 the transmittance for the spin @xmath47 , @xmath48 the fermi - dirac function , and @xmath49 the chemical potential for the left ( right ) electrodes . a bias potential of @xmath50 was used . clearly , @xmath6 and @xmath5 adsorbed on pristine graphene generate the higher cp in the systems we consider . however , the metal diffusion experimentally observed creates a drawback to build devices with adatoms over pristine graphene since in the most cases the atoms tend to clusterize . for the atoms trapped in defects , the higher values of cp ( in modulus ) occurs for the @xmath12 , followed by @xmath10 . the last one has a negative cp because localized levels above the fermi - energy scatter majority spins , generating a current with excess of minority spin electrons . one should note that , despite the high magnetization of all @xmath4 complexes , the absolute values of cp are not so remarkable in such systems . in particular , the @xmath51 has a negligible cp , even though it has @xmath52 . for the noble metals , an unusual local magnetic moment generated by the polarization of `` @xmath53 '' atomic orbitals leads to cp smaller than @xmath54 . these results indicate that the existence of a local magnetic moment is a necessary but not sufficient condition to have a large cp . this can be clearly seen in the fig . [ fig3 ] ( b ) , where we show the cp as a function of the local magnetic moment , showing that there is no correlation between the local magnetic moment and the current polarization . in fig . [ fig3 ] ( c ) we show the cp as a function of the magnetic moment induced only in the graphene carbon atoms . this magnetization occurs due to the hybridization between the graphene states and the adatom orbitals . however , this hybridization may occur ( i ) at deep levels , not affecting the cp , or ( ii ) near the fermi energy , affecting the transmission probability near the transport window . therefore we conclude that the cp behavior is not governed solely by the magnetic moment induced in graphene , but depends fundamentally on the energy window where the hybridization responsible for the appearance of such a magnetic moment occurs . ( color online ) band structure and spin - resolved transmittance for ( a ) and ( b ) @xmath55 , ( c ) and ( d ) @xmath6 over pristine graphene , ( e ) and ( f ) ni@555777 . the solid ( dashed ) lines correspond to the majority ( minority ) spin channels . for the sake of comparison , we also show the transmittance for pristine graphene . the smooth behavior of all curves indicates the convergence , regarding the @xmath25-points , to the true 2d - nature of graphene . in the energy bands , we also indicate the position of the dirac cone ( with a vertical dashed line ) , corresponding to the @xmath56 symmetry point in a hexagonal supercell . , width=321 ] in order to understand the ruling factors that govern the current polarization , we performed band structure calculations . from these results , we conclude that the degree of current spin polarization is governed by ( i ) the presence of localized levels , non degenerated in spin , nearby the fermi level and ( ii ) by their hybridization with graphene levels . to illustrate these conclusions we present in detail three representative cases shown in fig . [ fig4 ] . in panel ( a ) we plot the energy bands for the @xmath55 complex . in this situation , there is a flat band around @xmath57 below the fermi energy , with majority spin associated with au `` s '' atomic orbitals , which is responsible for the local magnetic moment of @xmath58 . this band does not modify the shape of the dirac cone because it has a weak coupling to the graphene @xmath8 bands . as a consequence , the transmission probability [ @xmath59 shown in fig . [ fig4 ] ( b ) is very similar to the pristine case around the fermi energy . this example shows that a magnetic moment and localized states near the fermi energy are a necessary , but not a sufficient , condition to generate spin - polarized currents in graphene , as discussed above . in fact , to generate current polarizations it is also necessary to have a high coupling between the localized levels and graphene @xmath8 bands , modifying in this way the transmission probability for only one or both spin channels . as an example of modifications in only one spin channel , we show the energy bands for the @xmath6 adsorbed on pristine graphene in fig . [ fig4 ] ( c ) . it is notable that a dirac cone is well defined only for the majority spin . for the minority spin , localized levels hybridize with the dirac cone states , and hence significantly modify the dispersion of these states . as a result , the transmittance [ shown in fig . [ fig4 ] ( d ) ] is very similar to the one in pristine graphene only for the majority spin , causing in this way a high current polarization . for the @xmath12 complex there are modifications in the band structure for both spin channels [ see fig . [ fig4 ] ( e ) ] . in this case , the local magnetic moment comes from localized states around the fermi energy with a high hybridization with the dirac cone . as a consequence , the transmittance for both spin channels , shown in fig . [ fig4 ] ( f ) , are not only distinct from the pristine case , but also very different between them . in this system we still observe a flat band at @xmath60 above the fermi energy . however , as there is a weak coupling with the dirac cone states , there is almost no change in @xmath61 . therefore , the examples shown in fig . [ fig4 ] elucidate the conditions to have spin - polarized currents in graphene generated by doping with magnetic impurities . in most calculations we performed the distance between the metallic adatom and its periodic image is @xmath62 . in order to understand the effect of the doping concentration we calculated the transmittance for @xmath51 also for supercells of @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 wide , as shown in fig . [ fig5 ] . the main characteristic of @xmath51 transmittance is a valley in the minority spin transmittance around @xmath66 above the fermi energy , and another valley for the majority spin transmittance around @xmath67 below the fermi energy . with the widening of the supercell , the valleys became more localized , as a reflect of the decrease in the energy dispersion of the defect levels . however , the main results obtained with the smaller supercell are unchanged . ( color online ) spin - resolved transmittance for @xmath51 . the distance between @xmath4 atoms are @xmath68 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 in ( a)-(d ) , respectively.,width=321 ] we also show that it is possible to control the current polarization via the effect of a gate potential . as an example , we show in fig . [ fig6 ] the transport properties for the @xmath51 complex , as a function of @xmath26 . in panel ( a ) we present the spin - resolved currents . without a gate potential the current polarization is negligible . however , with the inclusion of a negative gate the current has excess of majority spin electrons , whereas with a positive gate there are excess of minority spin electrons . this behavior occurs because the gate potential shifts the localized states that hybridize with the graphene @xmath8 bands , as shown in figs . [ fig6](b)-[fig6](f ) , allowing a tuning of the valleys in the transmittance ( indicated by vertical lines ) . in fig . [ fig6](g ) , we also present cp as a function of @xmath26 . it is remarkable that cp can be changed from @xmath69 to @xmath70 with the application of a gate . therefore , without any external magnetic perturbation , it is possible to control the degree of spin polarization in such systems . ( color online ) ( a ) spin - resolved current for the @xmath51 complex , were the circles ( squares ) represent the majority ( minority ) spin . ( b)-(f ) transmission probability for @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 , respectively . vertical lines indicate the position of the valleys in the transmittance . the fermi energy is fixed by the infinite graphene leads . ( g ) cp as a function of @xmath26.,width=321 ] in conclusion , via studies of adsorbed metal atoms in graphene with and without defects , we show that the presence of a local magnetic moment is a necessary but not sufficient condition to create a current polarization . essentially , a fundamental requirement to have a non - zero current polarization is the presence of spin - split localized levels near the fermi energy that strongly hybridize with the graphene dirac - cone states . we also show that with an external gate potential it is possible to control the degree of current polarization without any magnetic perturbation . the knowledge of such properties for isolated scatterers is a fundamental first step to design spintronic devices , where other important effects such as multiple scattering and disorder may even enhance the polarization signal@xcite . k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , y. zhang , s. v. dubonos , i. v. grigorieva and a. a. firsov , science * 306 * , 666 ( 2004 ) . a. h. castro neto , f. guinea , n. m. r. peres , k. s. novoselov and a. k. geim , rev . phys . * 81 * , 109 ( 2009 ) . k. i. bolotin , k. j. sikes , j. hone , h. l. stormer and p. kim , phys . rev . lett . * 101 * , 096802 ( 2008 ) . x. l. li , x. r. wang , l. zhang , s. w. lee and h. j. dai , science * 319 * 1229 ( 2008 ) l. jiao , l. zhang , x. wang , g. diankov and h. dai , nature * 458 * , 877 ( 2009 ) . m. p. lima , a. j. r. da silva and a. fazzio , phys . b * 81 * , 045430 ( 2010 ) . son , marvin l. cohen and s. g. louie , nature * 444 * , 347 ( 2006 ) . w. l. wang , s. meng , and e. kaxiras , nano lett . * 8 * , 241 ( 2008 ) . a. k. singh and b. i. yakobson , nano lett . * 9 * , 1540 ( 2009 ) . m. p. lima , a. r. rocha , a. j. r. da silva and a. fazzio , phys . b * 82 * , 153402 ( 2010 ) . s. y. zhou , g .- h . gweon , a. v. fedorov , p. n. first , w. a. de heer , d .- h . lee , f. guinea , a. h. castro neto and a. lanzara , nature mat . * 6 * , 770 ( 2007 ) . f. guinea , m. i. katsnelson and a. k. geim , nature physics * 6 * , 30 ( 2009 ) . j. berashevich and t. chakraborty , phys . b * 80 * , 033404 ( 2009 ) . i. zanella , s. guerini , s. b. fagan , j. mendes filho , and a. g. souza filho , phys . b * 77 * , 073404 ( 2008 ) . y. gan , l. sun and f. banhart , small * 4 * 587 ( 2008 ) . j. a. rodrguez - manzo , o. cretu and f. banhart , acs nano * 4 * , 3422 ( 2010 ) . o. cretu , a. v. krasheninnikov , j. a. rodrguez - manzo , l. sun , r. m. nieminen and f. banhart , phys . rev . lett . * 105 * , 196102 ( 2010 ) . r. zan , u. bangert , q. ramasse and k. s. novoselov , nano lett . * 11 * 1087 ( 2011 ) . a. v. krasheninnikov and r. m. nieminen , theor . acc . * 129 * , 625 ( 2011 ) . l. hu , x. hu , x. wu , c. du , y. dai and j. deng , physica b * 405 * 3337 ( 2010 ) . e. j. g. santos , a. ayuela and d. snchez - portal , new . j. phys . * 12 * , 053012 ( 2010 ) . c. cao , m. wu , j. jiang and h .- cheng , phys . b * 81 * , 205424 ( 2010 ) . e. j. g. santos , d. snchez - portal and a. ayuela , phys . b * 81 * , 125433 ( 2010 ) . h. valencia , a. gil and g. frapper , j. phys . c * 114 * , 14141 ( 2010 ) . a. v. krasheninnikov , p. o. lehtinen , a. s. foster , p. pyykk and r. m. nieminen , phys . 102 * , 126807 ( 2009 ) . r. singh and p. kroll , j. phys . matter * 21 * , 196002 ( 2009 ) . p. venezuela , r. b. muniz , a. t. costa , d. m. edwards , s. r. power and m. s. ferreira , phys . b * 80 * , 241413(r ) ( 2009 ) . k. t. chan , j. b. neaton and m. l. cohen , phys . b * 77 * , 235430 ( 2008 ) . i. zanella , s. b. fagan , r. mota and a. fazzio , j. phys . c * 112 * , 9163 ( 2008 ) . m. amft , s. lebgue , o. eriksson , n. v. skorodumova , j. phys . matter * 23 * , 395001 ( 2011 ) . y. g. zhou , x. t. zu , f. gao , h. y. xiao and h. f. lv , j. appl . phys . * 105 * , 104311 ( 2009 ) . p. hohenberg , w. kohn , phys . rev . * 136 * , b864 ( 1964 ) ; w. kohn and l.j . sham , phys . rev . * 140 * , a1133 ( 1965 ) ; e. artacho _ et al . . status solidi b * 215 * , 809 ( 1999 ) . j. p. perdew , k. burke and m. ernzerhof , phys . * 77 * , 3865 ( 1996 ) . z. qiao , s. a. yang , w. feng , w .- k . tse , j. ding , y. yao , j. wang and q. niu , phys . b * 82 * , 161414 ( 2010 ) . h. j. monkhorst and j. d. pack , phys . rev . b 13 , 5188 ( 1976 ) . f. d. novaes , a. j. r. da silva and a. fazzio , braz . * 36 * , 799 ( 2006 ) ; r. landauer , philos . mag . * 21 * , 863 ( 1970 ) ; m. bttiker , y. imry , r. landauer , and s. pinhas , phys . rev . b 31 , 6207 ( 1985 ) ; m. bttiker , phys . 57 , 1761 ( 1986 ) ; y. meir and n. s. wingreen , phys . 68 , 2512 ( 1992 ) . t. ozaki , k. nishio and h. kino , phys . b * 81 * 035116 ( 2010 ) . c. morari , i. rungger , a. r. rocha , s. sanvito , s. melinte and g rignanese , acs nano * 3 * , 4137 ( 2009 ) . r. g. amorim , a. fazzio , a. antonelli , f. d. novaes and a. j. r. da silva , nano lett . * 7 * , 2459 ( 2007 ) . a. r. rocha , m. rossi , a. fazzio , and a. j. r. da silva , phys . * 100 * , 176803 ( 2008 ) .

we theoretically investigate spin - resolved currents flowing in large - area graphene , with and without defects , doped with single atoms of noble metals ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 ) and @xmath3-transition metals ( @xmath4,@xmath5,@xmath6 and @xmath7 ) . we show that the presence of a local magnetic moment is a necessary but not sufficient condition to have a non zero current polarization . an essential requirement is the presence of spin - split localized levels near the fermi energy that strongly hybridize with the graphene @xmath8 bands . we also show that a gate potential can be used to tune the energy of these localized levels , leading to an external way to control the degree of spin - polarized current without the application of a magnetic field .

1612.07631

silicon photomultipliers ( sipms ) are constructed on a single substrate and consist of thousands of microcells operating in the geiger mode . the gain and quantum efficiency of the sipms are comparable to those of the photomultiplier tubes ( pmts ) . they are compact in size and insensitive to magnetic fields . with low - operating voltages , it simplifies the circuit design for electrical safety considerations . therefore , they are a good alternative to pmts @xcite . however , the conventional pmts are available in various sizes that are as large as a few tens of cm in diameter . in contrast , the largest single - chip sipm is less than 1 @xmath0 . for scintillation detectors , the efficiency of scintillation photon collection increases with the area of the photon sensor . moreover , a larger detector volume has a higher sensitivity for radiation detection . because of the small active area of the sipms , it is necessary to use multiple sipms to increase the efficiency of photon collection for a larger scintillator . in this work , scintillation detectors are constructed and tested with a custom 2x2 sipm array . the layout of the sipm array and the geometry of the scintillator were determined by performing geant4 simulations @xcite in which a point source is located 20 cm from the front of the scintillator . the @xmath2-rays are emitted uniformly random in a cone irradiating a circular area inscribed by the front surface . the surface finish of the scintillator is modeled using the `` groundteflonair '' option in the look - up - table ( lut ) @xcite . a thin layer of optical grease , 0.1 mm , is sandwiched between the scintillator and the sipms for transporting scintillation photons . the array has four 6x6 mm@xmath3 sipms arranged in a 2x2 configuration such that the electronics is less complicated . the goal of the simulations was to find the optimum geometry of the scintillator and the layout of the sipms for good @xmath2-ray energy resolution . it is found that the energy resolution of a detector is better for the scintillator with an area comparable to the active area of the sipm array . since the sipms are arranged as a square or rectangle in the array , scintillators with a square or rectangular cross section have a better energy resolution than those with a circular cross section . shown in fig . [ fg : resolgap](a ) is the photon distribution at the exit surface of an 18 mm cubic scintillator . the profile of photon distribution for a 6 mm horizontal strip across the middle of the exit surface is shown in fig . [ fg : resolgap](b ) . as can be seen , more scintillation photons are distributed near the center of the exit surface of the scintillator . for scintillators with a cross section larger than the active area of the sipms , leaving a gap between the sipms leads to a better energy resolution . in fig . [ fg : resolgap](c ) , the energy resolution for an 18 mm cubic scintillator as a function of the gap size between the active area of the sipms is shown . the best energy resolution is for the gap size between 1 and 2 mm . for larger gap sizes , the resolution gets worse slowly but a shoulder starts to develop on either side of the photopeak resulting in a poorer full - width - at - tenth - maximum . [ fg : spk18gap ] shows the simulated 662 kev @xmath2-ray spectra detected by the 18 mm cubic scintillator and sipm array with the gap size of 0.2 , 1.4 , and 4.0 mm . it can be seen that for the gap size of 4.0 mm a noticeable shoulder appears on the high - energy side of the photopeak and the trough between the photopeak and the compton edge is higher as well . furthermore , the photopeak position shifts to lower channels as the gap size increases . this is due to less photons distributed away from the center of the detection plane as shown in the profile of photon distribution in fig . [ fg : resolgap](b ) . in fig . [ fg : resolgap](d ) , the gap size between the sipms for cubic scintillators with dimensions between 16 and 24 mm to have an optimum resolution is shown . as can be seen , it is necessary to increase the gap size for larger scintillators in order to achieve a better energy resolution . -ray detected by an 18 mm cubic scintillator coupled to a 2x2 sipm array . the gap size between the sipms is ( a ) 0.2 , ( b ) 1.4 , and ( c ) 4.0 mm.,width=312 ] a sipm array with four 6x6 mm@xmath3 sipms @xcite has been constructed following the analysis of the geant4 simulations . three types of scintillators , nai , csi , and cs@xmath4liycl@xmath5:ce@xmath6(clyc ) , have been tested with this sipm array . the scintillator and sipm array were enclosed in a hermetically sealed aluminum container to keep out moisture and ambient light . all the tests were performed in a temperature controlled chamber . the three detectors were tested using a @xmath7cs source with the sipms biased at 27.5 v so that the detectors had the same nominal gain . the output of the preamp was recorded by a waveform digitizer ( struck sis3302 ) operating at 100 mhz . the response of the detectors to the 662 kev @xmath2-ray from @xmath7cs was compared by making a histogram of the integral of the digitized pulses . because the clyc pulse has a long - decay component , an integration time of 20 @xmath8s was used for all the scintillators in order to make an unbiased comparison . consequently , the counting rate was kept low to minimize pulse pileup . as the decay time for nai and csi is shorter , integrating these pulses for such a long time could introduce noise to the integrals . since the comparison was for the detector response , the influence of noise on energy resolution was ignored for the current test . a separate measurement using the proper integration time for each scintillator was carried out to compare the energy resolution . figure [ fg : lightout ] shows the normalized histogram of 10,000 pulse integrals for the three detectors . the nai detector has the largest output because the sipm response is optimized for the 420 nm scintillation photon . although csi has a larger yield of scintillation photons , the detector response is actually smaller than nai . this is due to the mismatch between the scintillation spectrum of csi and the response of the sipms . lastly , the light output for clyc is almost one half of that for nai . therefore , the pulse integral is the smallest . cs detected by the nai , csi , and clyc detectors . the histograms are obtained by integrating the pulses of the preamp output for 20 @xmath8s.,width=312 ] the breakdown voltage for the sipms varies individually due to the manufacturing processes . the breakdown voltage also increases with temperature which results in gain variation following temperature changes . in order to optimize the detector resolution , the gain for the sipms was adjusted to be the same within the array . furthermore , the gain for the entire sipm array was stabilized over the temperature range between 20 and 50 @xmath1c @xcite . to check the quality of temperature stabilization , @xmath2-ray sources , @xmath9eu , @xmath10co , @xmath7cs , and @xmath11th , were used . [ fg : det33msrc ] shows the spectra for these sources for the csi detector at 20 , 0 , 20 , and 50 @xmath1c . the centroid of the 662 kev photopeak for @xmath7cs was set to channel 220 for all the temperatures . as can be seen , the location of the photopeaks do not shift for different temperatures because of the stabilization performed for the detector . -rays from @xmath9eu , @xmath10co , @xmath7cs , and @xmath11th sources detected by the csi detector at 20 , 0 , 20 , and 50 @xmath1c.,width=312 ] to optimize the energy resolution , the preamp output was integrated for 1 , 4 , and 20 @xmath8s for nai , csi , and clyc , respectively . the best resolution obtained was 6.8% for nai , 6.4% for csi , and 7.8% for clyc . it has been reported that an energy resolution of 4% was observed for a 1 @xmath12 clyc scintillator coupled to a pmt . however , when the same clyc scintillator was coupled to sipms the energy resolution was between 6.2% and 8.3% @xcite . the @xmath7cs @xmath2-ray spectrum measured by the csi detector at 20 @xmath1c is shown in fig . [ fg : cs137 ] . the noise is sufficiently low such that the 32 kev peak is clearly visible without contamination . cs @xmath2-rays detected by the csi detector . the gain of the sipms in the array has been matched to achieve an optimum energy resolution of 6.4%.,width=312 ] the energy resolution of the 662 kev photopeak for csi and clyc measured between 20 and 50 @xmath1c is displayed in fig . [ fg : restemp ] . the variation in energy resolution for the csi detector is small . at high temperatures , the poorer resolution is likely due to noise in the sipms whereas at low temperatures the poorer resolution is attributed to a lower light yield of the scintillator . for the clyc detector , the energy resolution is much worse than that for csi , particularly well below and above room temperature . at 20 @xmath1c , the 662 kev photopeak is barely visible in the @xmath2-ray spectrum . a previous study using a smaller crystal , 1 @xmath13 , obtained mixed results for resolution as a function of temperature @xcite . in that study , sipms from different manufacturers were compared . for the sensl sipm , the variation of energy resolution with temperature is smaller as compared to the present work . for the hamamatsu sipm , resolution as poor as 14% was measured at 10 @xmath1c . since clyc crystals are known to be fragile , it is conceivable that fractures might have developed in the crystal that was used in this work . this makes the use of clyc for portable radiation detectors challenging because these instruments are required to operate between 20 and 50 @xmath1c . in addition to studying the three detectors , a large number of csi detectors have been tested which allow for examining the characteristics of the sipms . fig . [ fg : distr](a ) shows the distribution of the breakdown voltages for 300 sipms . the standard deviation of the distribution is 0.124 v which is consistent with the manufacturer s specification . [ fg : distr](b ) shows the distribution of the temperature coefficient for the csi detector . the centroid of the distribution is 15 mv/@xmath1c . in contrast , according to the manufacturer , the temperature coefficient for the sipm alone is 21.5 mv/@xmath1c . a @xmath14cf source was used for studying neutron detection by the clyc detector between 20 and 50 @xmath1c . according to the specification , the neutron is expected at 3.2 mev in the @xmath2-ray spectrum @xcite . since @xmath11th has a 2.6 mev @xmath2-peak , it was used along with @xmath14cf to test n-@xmath2 discrimination and as a reference for the energy spectrum . because the largest difference in the pulse shape occurs in the first 2 @xmath8s , a shorter integration time of 4.5 @xmath8s , instead of 20 @xmath8s , was used to speed up the data acquisition . [ fg : clyc1d ] shows the @xmath2-ray spectrum detected by the clyc detector . the photopeak for the @xmath11th 2.6 mev @xmath2-ray appears near channel 2600 and the neutron peak appears near channel 3200 . this agrees with the manufacturer s specification @xcite . as can be seen , the neutron distribution is fairly broad and overlaps with the high - energy tail of the 2.6 mev @xmath2-peak . for this reason , it is necessary to use pulse - shape discrimination ( psd ) to separate neutrons from @xmath2 s . -rays from @xmath11th and neutrons from @xmath14cf detected by the clyc detector.,width=312 ] the psd is performed by taking the ratio of the pulse integral in the delayed window to the sum of the pulse integral in the prompt and delayed windows , @xmath15 shown in fig . [ fg : cfthpsd20](a ) is the histogram for the psd ratio versus the integral of the preamp pulses . neutrons appears in the group of counts in the upper - right corner . the band of counts located across the center of the histogram are @xmath2-rays . the threshold for detection was set around 1.5 mev to reduce the counting rate . the group of events near the end of the @xmath2 band on the right - hand side is the 2.6 mev @xmath2 peak from @xmath11th . cf and @xmath11th , were present during the measurement . ( b ) histogram of projected psd ratio.,width=312 ] by projecting the the two - dimensional histogram on to the vertical axis , the histogram of the psd ratio is obtained , as shown in fig . [ fg : cfthpsd20](b ) . the figure - of - merit ( fom ) for psd is defined as the ratio of the difference between the centroid ( @xmath8 ) of the @xmath2 and neutron peaks to the sum of the full - width - at - half - maximum ( @xmath16 ) of the two peaks @xcite , @xmath17 the width for the prompt window and delayed window was varied to search for the best fom . at 20 @xmath1c , the best fom for n-@xmath2 discrimination is 1.9 for the width of the prompt and delayed window of 270 and 850 ns , respectively . the fom increases with decreasing temperature due to the change of pulse shape . at 50 @xmath1c the fom is 1.2 and at 20 @xmath1c the fom is 3.0 , as shown in fig . [ fg : fomtemp ] . although the resolution for clyc is poor at the extreme temperatures , the neutron identification by pulse - shape discrimination works well . the nai and csi scintillation detectors constructed with the custom sipm array have a good energy resolution for the 662 kev @xmath2-ray from @xmath7cs . they are suitable for deploying in a spectroscopic personal radiation detector ( sprd ) such as the flir identifinder r200 . using pulse - shape discrimination , neutrons can be identified without contamination from @xmath2-rays for the clyc detector . however , the resolution for @xmath2-ray detection is poor at extreme temperatures , 20 and 50 @xmath1c . further work is in progress to find solutions for neutron detection in hand - held radiation detection instruments . 99 p. eckert , h .- c . schultz - coulon , w. shen , r. stamen , and a. tadday , _ nucl . meth . a _ , vol . 620 , no . 2 - 3 , 217 - 226 , apr . 2010 . s. agostinelli _ et al . _ , _ nucl . instrum . meth . a _ , vol . 3 , pp . 250 - 303 , july 2003 . m. janecek and w.w . moses , _ ieee trans . nucl . 964 - 970 , 2010 . microfc-60035 , sensl technologies ltd . patent pending . rmdinc.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/clyc-properties-pdf.pdf k.e . mesick , l.c . stonehill , j.t . morrell , d.d.s . coupland , _ 2015 ieee nss / mic , san diego , ca , 2015 , pp . 1 - 4 . _

silicon photomultipliers ( sipms ) are a good alternative to photomultiplier tubes ( pmts ) because their gain and quantum efficiency are comparable to pmts . however , the largest single - chip sipm is still less than 1 @xmath0 . in order to use sipms with scintillators that have reasonable sensitivity , it is necessary to use multiple sipms . in this work , scintillation detectors are constructed and tested with a custom 2x2 sipm array . the layout of the sipms and the geometry of the scintillator were determined by performing geant4 simulations . cubic nai , csi , and clyc with 18 mm sides have been tested . the output of the scintillation detectors are stabilized over the temperature range between 20 and 50 @xmath1c by matching the gain of the sipms in the array . the energy resolution for these detectors has been measured as a function of temperature . furthermore , neutron detection for the clyc detector was studied in the same temperature range . using pulse - shape discrimination , neutrons can be cleanly identified without contribution from @xmath2-photons . as a result , these detectors are suitable for deploying in spectroscopic personal radiation detectors ( sprd ) . geant4 , silicon photomultiplier , nai , csi , clyc , pulse - shape discrimination , gain stabilization , temperature , spectroscopic personal radiation detector .

1308.6572

the standard - model extension ( sme ) provides a general field - theoretic framework for studying lorentz violation@xcite , including rotation - invariance violation . to highlight the basic ideas of lorentz - symmetry breaking , we consider rotation - invariance violation in newton s second law:@xcite @xmath0 here @xmath1 is a symmetric direction - dependent inertial mass ( we consider conventional gravitational mass ) . this yields a valid and more general form that newton himself could have chosen . our effective inertial mass can be generated as a low - energy limit of the sme:@xcite @xmath2 here @xmath3 is a coefficient for lorentz violation found in the fermion sector , taken as symmetric . it is depicted with background diamonds in fig . 1 . a similar construction can also be found associated with other sme coefficients for lorentz violation . @xcite using a block on an inclined plane , we show that observer rotation invariance holds , while a particle rotation changes the experiment s outcome , violating lorentz symmetry . examine a block on an inclined plane devoid of friction . the @xmath4-axis points down the plane while the @xmath5-axis is perpendicular to the surface as shown in the left - hand diagram of fig . 1 . let the block s effective inertial mass be diagonal : @xmath6 solving for the particle s acceleration under the constraint @xmath7 yields @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the acceleration down the ramp . the only difference here from the conventional problem is the presence of @xmath10 . qualitatively , the motion is down the plane with constant acceleration , as in the absence of lorentz violation . perform an observer rotation on the original experiment ; that is , consider the same problem in new coordinates as shown in the left - hand diagram of fig . 1 . here , @xmath11 is the mass in the new coordinates obtained via @xmath12 , @xmath13 being a rotation matrix . components are related by , for example , @xmath14 again solving , we find up to @xmath15 the components @xmath16 however , the acceleration is again along the ramp with the magnitude found in eq . ( [ eq1 ] ) , which is obtained from @xmath17 and @xmath18 by @xmath19 and a substitution for @xmath20 in terms of @xmath3 . hence , both observers agree on the outcome of the experiment . -40pt a particle rotation of the original system leaves the mass matrix as in eq . , but alters the direction of the gravitational field relative to the background as shown in the right - hand diagram of fig . 1 . this produces an observably different acceleration . solving for the motion of the particle subject to the constraint yields @xmath21 here the component along the ramp is @xmath22 which is different from the first cases , revealing observable lorentz violation .

a frequently confused point in studies of symmetry violation is the distinction between observer and particle transformations . in this work , we consider a model in which a coefficient in the standard - model extension leads to violations of rotation invariance in newton s second law . the model highlights the distinction between observer and particle transformations .

hep-lat0209030

the lattice realization of super yang - mills theory has been considered very difficult though highly desirable as a non - perturbative formulation@xcite . in our previous work and talk @xcite , we reported the presence of exact fermionic symmetries on the ` ichimatsu ' lattice , a novel lattice . if the symmetries survive in the continuum limit , they would be related to a supersymmetry if not to the brs symmetry . from the equation presented shortly , we know that the fermionic symmetries can not survive on the ordinary lattice . therefore it is of crucial importance to study the continuum limit on the ` ichimatsu ' lattice . plaquettes on the regular lattice gauge theory are decomposed into two sets : \(i ) plaquettes on cell + @xmath2 on @xmath3 ; \(ii ) plaquettes on pipe + @xmath2 on @xmath4 . one a @xmath5 plane , one finds an alternating or chequered pattern and it is called as an ` ichimatsu ' pattern @xcite . the fields of the ichimatsu lattice theory are link variables , @xmath6 , as the gauge field , and a real staggered fermion , @xmath7 , as the fermion field . the gauge action of our model ( cell+pipe ) is @xmath8 the fermionic symmetry transformation of the fermion field is written as @xmath9 where @xmath10 are grassman - odd parameters . it should be emphasized that on the usual regular lattice ( @xmath11 ) , the transformation goes down to @xmath12 . therefore it is important to study the dynamical properties on the two - couplings space ( @xmath0 ) . from now on , we switch off fermion effects in our model and concentrate on the vacuum structure of the gauge sector . we take a link variable @xmath13 as a mean field . this approximation is not gauge - invariant and it is useful only in the first view of the phase diagram . the results are ( 1 ) there exists an exact duality under @xmath14 , that is , the partition functions are invariant under the interchange of couplings ; @xmath15 \(2 ) in the cell model ( defined by putting @xmath16 ) and the pipe model ( @xmath17 ) , phase transitions occur . these results are independent of the spatial dimension and the gauge group . a rough sketch of the diagram is shown in fig . 1 . + fig . 1 . phase diagram of cell+pipe model in mean field approximation . 1 . regular lattice gauge theory ( @xmath18 ) when @xmath19 , our model becomes a usual regular lattice gauge theory . on the regular lattice , the 3d @xmath20 gauge theory has a phase transition point while the 4d su(2 ) gauge theory has a crossover point . 2 . four phase boundaries in order to understand the phase diagram , it is necessary to analyse the limiting cases , @xmath21 . we can obtain analytical results for these limiting cases . in the cell model , @xmath16 , the system is decomposed to a finite degrees of freedom and it is exactly solvable . the pipe model , @xmath17 , is equivalent to one plaquette model and is also exactly solvable . both cases have no phase transition contrary to the result of the mean field approximation . in @xmath22 , plaquettes on cell or pipe are strongly connected . the dynamics for these situations is not known and the numerical analysis is necessary . 3 . possibility of the continuum limit and its phase transition to take the continuum limit of our model , we must avoid the phase transition point or line . if we go across the singularity , then we miss the information on the vacuum , such as confinement . if one want to be consistent with confinement and asymptotic freedom , the phase diagram must be smoothly connected between the weak and strong coulping regions . the action is written as @xmath23 where @xmath24 is a link variable taking the values , @xmath25 . note the normalisation of the coupling constants differs from the su(2 ) case . for the regular lattice ( @xmath26 ) , it is found that there occurs the 2nd order phase transition at @xmath27 obtained by the analysis of the equivalent ising spin . we have simulated 3d z@xmath1 cell+pipe model for the size , @xmath28 and @xmath29 . + fig . 2 . 3d plot for ( @xmath30 , specific heat ) in 3d z@xmath1model . from fig . 2 , we can see that the phase transition point is extended to the connected pipe ( @xmath31 ) model and the connected cell ( @xmath32 ) model . the phase diagram for 3d z@xmath1 model is obtained in fig . + fig . phase diagram for 3d z@xmath1 model . for lattice size , @xmath33 , we calculated the internal energy and the specific heat . in fig . 4a , we show a crossover behaviour ( @xmath34 ) on a regular lattice and a sharp peak of the specific heat for the connected cell model in fig . 4b . + fig . 4a . a crossover in the regular lattice model . + fig a peak of specific heat at @xmath35 . our simulations are consistent with the following statements : 1 ) the peak in fig . 4b is that of the 2nd order phase transition ; 2 ) no peak is present in the connected cell model ; 3 ) a crossover line extends to @xmath36 . to consider exact fermionic symmetries on lattice , we decomposed all plaquettes into two sets , the cell and pipe . the vacuum structure of the gauge sector was investigated to study its continuum limit . phase diagrams of 3d z@xmath37 and 4d su(2 ) models were studied . we found a ` corridor ' ( singularity free region ) between strong coupling and weak coupling regions for 4d su(2 ) case ( fig . 5 ) ; the diagram is a single phase . the 3d z@xmath1 model has two phases . 9 g. curci and g. veneziano , nucl . b292 ( 1987 ) 555 . d. b. kaplan and m. schmaltz , chin . 38 ( 2000 ) 543 . k. itoh , m. kato , h. sawanaka , h. so and n. ukita , prog . ( 2002 ) 363 . k. itoh , m. kato , h. sawanaka , h. so and n. ukita , _ fermionic symmetry in ichimatsu - decomposed lattice models _ , in this volume . k. itoh , m. kato , m. murata , h. sawanaka and h. so , in preparation .

we proposed an ` ichimatsu'-decomposed lattice gauge theory with fermionic symmetries . the vacuum structures of the gauge sector with two coupling constants ( @xmath0 ) are investigated for 3-dimensional z@xmath1 and 4-dimensional su(2 ) cases using mean - field approximation and numerical simulation . we found two phases on the ( @xmath0 ) phase diagram for 3-dim . z@xmath1 case , while the diagram is a single phase for the latter .

astro-ph0506225

high mass stars , on account of their luminosities , temperatures and explosive ends , have a disproportionally large effect on the interstellar medium relative to their numbers . their influence appears to extend down to the scales of star - forming cores and even planet - forming disks . star formation may be triggered by supernovae shock waves in neighboring clouds ( elmegreen & lada 1977 ) but , at closer quarters , it may be stunted by photoionization and evaporation of molecular clumps within hii regions ( hester et al . 1996 ) . the dramatic _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ images of photoevaporating protoplanetary disks , or proplyds , in the orion nebula beginning with odell , wen & hu ( 1993 ) indicate that planet formation may , too , be inhibited . given that most low - mass stars are born in ob associations ( mckee & williams 1997 ) , it is important to study disk evolution in such harsh environments . the trapezium cluster in orion is the nearest young , massive star forming region and it is consequently the most intensively studied ( e.g. odell 2001 ) . approximately 1200 young stars with ages @xmath6 myr have been identified toward the central 1 pc diameter of the cluster core ( mccaughrean et al . a single star of spectral type o6ep , 1c , dominates the ultraviolet radiation field and ionizes the gas cocoons around nearby low - mass stars . the ionized gas is unbound and evaporates from the stars . mass loss rates averaging @xmath7 yrwere first inferred from centimeter wavelength observations by churchwell et al . the aforementioned hst data showed that many of the ionized knots are tadpole - shaped structures with a tail extending away from 1c ( odell et al . 1993 ) , and near - infrared imaging revealed low - mass stars at their centers ( mccaughrean & stauffer 1994 ) . the visibility of the central stars despite the inferred large mass of circumstellar material led all of these authors to suggest that the ionized gas originates from the surfaces of externally photoionized protoplanetary disks . as the integrated mass loss of a proplyd over the age of the cluster is larger than typical disk masses around t tauri stars , it was immediately apparent that their evolution was largely being dictated by their environment . the disk mass that remained , however , could not be determined from the observations . a lower limit can be obtained for the those objects that are seen in silhouette against the bright nebular background but are sufficiently far enough away from 1c that they are not strongly ionized and do not produce significant optical emission ( odell & wen 1994 ; mccaughrean & odell 1996 ; bally et al . 2000 ; smith et al . 2005 ) . based on its resolved size and a minimum column density to block the background light , mccaughrean et al . ( 1998 ) determined a lower limit to the mass of the giant proplyd 114 - 426 of @xmath8 . this is twenty times lower than the @xmath9 minimum formation mass of our solar system ( weidenschilling 1977 ) and thus this technique was not able to yield useful constraints on whether the proplyds are viable candidates for planet formation on scales of our own solar system . disk masses are best measured at longer wavelengths where the dust emission becomes optically thin . interferometry is essential to resolve the tightly clustered proplyds from each other and also to filter out the strong emission from the background molecular cloud . mundy , looney , & lada ( 1995 ) used the bima interferometer at @xmath10 mm to image a field around 1c containing 33 proplyds . several significant peaks were found , four coincident with proplyds , but the intensity was consistent with free - free emission from ionized gas and they were unable to measure masses . by analyzing the non - detections , however , they were able to place a statistical upper limit of @xmath11 on the average disk mass . the dust emission increases at shorter wavelengths and the free - free emission decreases . using the ovro array , bally et al . ( 1998a ) imaged two fields containing a total of six proplyds at @xmath12 mm , made a tentative detection of one object and placed upper limits of @xmath13 on the other objects . lada ( 1999 ) presented a mosaic of two fields at @xmath12 mm with the plateau de bure interferometer that claimed three detections . the implied masses were @xmath14 but these have not been analyzed in detail . the submillimeter array ( sma ; ho et al . 2004 ) is ideally suited to a renewed look at this issue . located on mauna kea , it can operate at shorter wavelengths than other interferometers and is therefore very sensitive to dust emission . furthermore , it has a relatively large field of view which allows many proplyds to be imaged simultaneously . in this paper , we present sma observations at @xmath15 m of a single @xmath16 full width half maximum ( fwhm ) field of view toward 23 proplyds around 1c . we detect five sources and measure the average flux for the rest . the observations are described in 2 , our results are presented in 3 , and we discuss the implications for planet formation in 4 . a single field containing 23 proplyds around 1c was imaged with the sma using six antennae in its compact configuration on november 13 and 14 , 2004 . the phase center of the observations was @xmath17 , @xmath18 , slightly south - west of 1cto maximize the number of proplyds in the field . the receivers were tuned in double sideband mode to place the co(32 ) line in the center of the upper sideband . each sideband provided the correlator with a 2 ghz spectral region separated from the central frequency of 340.7 ghz ( @xmath15 m ) by @xmath19 ghz . weather conditions were very good , and system temperatures varied from 300 to 700 k over different baselines as the field moved from @xmath20 to @xmath21 elevation . the amplitude and phase were monitored by alternately interleaving 5-minute integrations of the quasars j0423 - 013 and j0609 - 157 with each 20 minute observation on source . the stronger j0423 - 013 was used to perform the final calibration , and j0609 - 157 was imaged as a check on the system performance . the bandpass response and flux scaling were determined from a 30 minute observation of uranus toward the end of each track . the data for each night were calibrated with the mir software package . the atmosphere was very stable during both nights and the rms phase error after calibration was @xmath22 on short baselines increasing to @xmath23 on the longer baselines . the passband , gain , and flux calibrated data from each night were then combined during the imaging process in miriad . the total integration time on the 1c field was 9.6 hours . strong co emission was detected and the continuum data were extracted by summing over the line free channels . the shortest projected baseline was @xmath24 and the observations are therefore largely insensitive to features with angular scales greater than @xmath25 ( wilner & welch 1994 ) . this greatly reduces the potential confusion of extended emission from the background molecular cloud ( johnstone & bally 1999 ) . inversion of the continuum data to create a `` dirty map '' showed a strong source near the edge of the field of view at the @xmath26 gain of the primary beam , coincident with the proplyd 159350 using the nomenclature of odell & wen ( 1994 ) . this source produced artifacts in the southeast part of the map that proved difficult to clean , and we therefore removed a point source at its location from the visibilities before inverting and cleaning to analyze the other sources in the field . the cleanest map and lowest rms in the central region was obtained by removing a 45 mjy source but the source properties derived so far outside the primary beam half power point are highly uncertain . natural weighting of the @xmath27-data resulted in a beamsize of @xmath28 at position angle @xmath29 east of north and the cleaned map that is presented here was restored with a circular @xmath1 beam that has the same area as the naturally weighted beam . the rms noise noise level is @xmath30 mjy beam . contours of the continuum emission are shown in figure 1 . the lefthand image shows the location of the four trapezium o stars and optically identified proplyds relative to the data . the righthand image shows the contours overlaid on the hst image from bally et al . ( 1998b ) and shows the morphologies , brightness and colors of the proplyds . five proplyds were detected within the @xmath16 fwhm of the primary beam with a peak flux greater than @xmath31 mjy beamand are marked with a red cross in the lefthand image of figure 1 . the two brightest sources , 163 - 317 and 170 - 337 , were seen in subsets of the data , both lower and upper sidebands , and both the first and second day of observations . integrated fluxes for the five sources were measured by summing the pixels within the @xmath32 contour level and correcting for primary beam attenuation . the emission from 170 - 337 and 171 - 340 are merged and the flux for each one was estimated by cutting across the @xmath32 contour by eye . most of the proplyds in the field of view were detected at centimeter wavelengths with the vla ( churchwell et al . 1987 ; felli et al . 1993 ) and have spectral energy distributions that are consistent with thermal bremsstrahlung ( garay , moran , & reid 1987 ) . none of the sources that we have detected are variable at 3.6 cm ( zapata et al . 2004 ) , suggesting that any contribution from gyrosynchrotron emission is small and that we are not seeing a bright flare . thermal bremsstrahlung emission decreases gradually toward shorter wavelengths but dust emission sharply increases . spectral energy distributions ( seds ) for the five sma detections are plotted in figure 2 . a combination of bremsstrahlung and modified ( @xmath33 ) blackbody emission are overlaid . these fits are poorly constrained due to the small number of data points where the sed slopes are changing . nevertheless , they are adequate to show that the @xmath15 m flux is dominated by dust emission in all but one case , 167 - 317 , and to estimate the contribution from ionized gas emission in the other four . the measured sma fluxes , corrected for primary beam attenuation , the peak signal - to - noise ratio , and estimated contribution from bremsstrahlung emission are listed in table 1 . 167 - 317 ( @xmath2orig ) is the brightest proplyd at centimeter wavelengths and in the mundy et al . 3.4 mm map . the ionized gas emission is strong even at @xmath15 m and our sed fit shows that the dust emission contributes only 4.6 mjy to the measured flux . there is some scatter in the centimeter fluxes and a 20% uncertainty in the millimeter fluxes , however , so this number is uncertain . nevertheless , it does not appear to be a significant detection of dust emission . for the other four sources , however , there is a clear dust excess which allow us to measure the proplyd masses for the first time . masses were calculated from the dust excess flux at @xmath15 m in the standard way way using a distance to orion of 450 pc and the same hildebrand ( 1983 ) formulation for the grain opacity @xmath34 as in mundy et al . ( 1995 ) and bally et al . ( 1998a ) . implicit in this value is a gas - to - dust ratio of 100 and assumptions about the grain properties . these are discussed further in 4 . we assumed a lower temperature , 20 k , than previous work based on the average for disks in taurus - auriga ( andrews & williams 2005 ) and because the bulk of the disk dust mass lies in the midplane and is shielded from uv - heating even in the intense radiation field at the center of the trapezium cluster ( chiang & goldreich 1997 ) . masses would be lower by a factor of 3.3 if the dust temperature were 50 k. eighteen proplyds are undetected within the primary beam fwhm . as with the previous interferometer observations of the proplyds ( mundy et al . 1995 ; bally et al . 1998a ) , we can study the statistics of the non - detections to constrain their collective properties . the histogram of fluxes in beam - sized apertures around these 18 proplyds is compared to the background in figure 2 . for this comparison , a region around each of the five detections was blanked out . the flux distribution toward the proplyds is offset from that of the background and has a mean of 0.8 mjy beam . this is only a marginally significant result , however , as the map is oversampled . the expected noise in the combination of 18 positions is @xmath35 mjy beamand the histogram mean is only slightly greater than this . nevertheless , taken at face value and applying a correction for the mean gain , 0.73 , of the interferometer toward the 18 positions , the intrinsic mean flux of the non - detections is 1.1 mjy , which corresponds to a mass of @xmath36 . the integrated co map showed several resolved clumps of emission but they did not appear coherent in velocity or centered on any of the proplyds . the co line is optically thick and traces the gas temperature . the temperature probably varies more than the column density in the background cloud and the interferometer map is likely picking up hot spots in the molecular cloud - hii region interface rather than the proplyds themselves . these observations have proven more successful at measuring the masses of the orion proplyds than previous interferometer work because we were able to observe at shorter wavelengths and at higher sensitivity . our @xmath31 mjy beam detection limit corresponds to a mass limit of @xmath37 for individual sources . allowing for the different dust temperature assumptions , this is an order of magnitude more sensitive than bally et al . ( 1998a ) who were in turn an order of magnitude more sensitive than mundy et al . the iram plateau de bure map shown in lada ( 1999 ) covers many of the same objects and includes detections of 170 - 337 , 171 - 340 , and 158 - 327 , though the latter detection is not confirmed in our map . the 23 proplyds within the primary beam fwhm of our map are listed along with their morphological type , projected distance from 1c , associated stellar mass , and disk radius in table 2 . the morphology and association with a microjet are taken from the tables in bally et al . ( 1998b , 2000 ) . distances and disk radii are also measured from the hst images in bally et al . ( 1998b ) . stellar masses are estimated from k - band magnitudes and placement on 1 myr evolutionary tracks by mccaughrean & stauffer ( 1994 ) . the statistics are meager , but the four dust detections do not have a preferred morphological type and lie at a range of projected distances . the stellar masses are somewhat uncertain in absolute terms though probably good relative measures and suggest that the detected disks tend to be associated with the more massive ( @xmath38 ) stars . the conversion from submillimeter flux to disk mass contains many uncertainties in the grain properties and gas - to - dust ratio that are encapsulated in the parameter @xmath39 . the hildebrand ( 1983 ) formulation that we have used assumes an average grain size of @xmath40 m , appropriate to interstellar clouds and is normalized to a gas - to - dust ratio of 100 . throop et al . ( 2001 ) and shuping et al . ( 2003 ) show that the typical grain sizes in the outer parts of the giant silhouette proplyd , 114 - 426 , are @xmath41 m . if the grains are spherical , this does not greatly change the value of @xmath39 at 1 mm ( pollack et al . however , if the grains have aggregated in a fractal manner , the cross - section per unit grain mass may be as much as an order of magnitude higher ( wright 1987 ) and our proplyd mass estimate may be substantially overestimated . on the other hand , masses would be underestimated if there is dust settling to the disk midplane and grain growth to centimeter sizes and larger ( wilner et al . 2005 ) or if the inner disk is optically thick ( andrews & williams 2005 ) . the gas - to - dust ratio is also highly uncertain . dust settling to the disk midplane and photoevaporation of the upper disk envelope will tend to decrease the gas - to - dust ratio below the canonical ism value of 100 ( throop & bally 2005 ) leading to an overestimate of the mass using the hildebrand @xmath39 . we did not clearly detect co emission from any of the proplyds but future observations of other gas tracers that do not deplete and are abundant in the cold , dense disk midplane will help reveal the gas content and dynamics of the disks . given the uncertainty in the mass calculations , it is instructive to compare the submillimeter fluxes from the proplyds with isolated disks in taurus . after correcting for the greater distance to orion , the proplyd flux distribution is found to more closely match taurus class ii than class i objects ( andrews & williams 2005 ) . as proplyds lack outer envelopes , this is also their closest morphological match . in this sense , and only for the four dust detections , the trapezium cluster environment appears not to have had a substantial effect on these systems . the stars within the proplyds have ages @xmath6 myr ( hillenbrand 1997 ) but the evaporation timescales , equal to the disk masses measured here divided by the mass loss rates measured by churchwell et al . ( 1987 ) , are of order @xmath42 yr . note that if disks were originally more massive , they would have been larger in size and their mass loss rates consequently greater . thus , the present disk mass divided by the present mass loss rate is a good measure of the proplyd lifetime ( strzer & hollenbach 1999 ) . the resulting discrepancy in timescales may be due to a younger age , @xmath43 yr , for the ionizing source , 1c , than the rest of the cluster ( johnstone , hollenbach , & bally 1998 ) or a lower average mass loss rate if either the ionized gas recombines before leaving the system ( odell 1998 ) or if the proplyds move on radial , rather than circular , orbits through the cluster ( strzer & hollenbach 1999 ) . in this regard , it is intriguing to note that three of the four dust detections were at a signal - to - noise ratio greater than 7 , and one at a signal - to - noise ratio of 4 . a smooth distribution of disk masses with increasing numbers at smaller masses should have resulted in proportionally more detections at lower signal - to - noise . the number of detections is small but hints at an abrupt mass loss event such as might be expected for close encounters to 1c on plunging orbits through the cluster . observations of additional proplyds at a range of distances from 1c will show the disk mass distribution and the effect of environment more clearly . if a distance dependent effect is seen , it would suggest that most stars move on approximately circular orbits and the influence on 1c on planet formation is limited . if the detection rate does not increase with distance , however , it may be that the orbits are eccentric and that 1c would then influence large numbers of potential planetary systems as they pass through the center of the cluster . the effect may be purely destructive through almost complete photoevaporation of a disk but it may also promote the formation of planets via preferential removal of the gas which allows dust disk instabilities to develop ( throop & bally 2005 ) . the four dust detections have disk masses slightly greater than the @xmath9 minimum mass solar nebula ( weidenschilling 1977 ) . the mass loss is concentrated in the outer parts of the disks where the gravitational potential of the central star is weakest and photoevaporation is most effective ( hollenbach , yorke , & johnstone 2000 ) . the radius of the bound inner region depends on the stellar mass and whether the gas is ionized by euv photons or remains neutral and only heated by the fuv radiation field . the detected proplyds lie far enough away from 1c for the second condition to apply and the central @xmath44 au radius of the disks survive if the central stellar mass is @xmath45 ( johnstone et al . disk radii were measured to be roughly 40 au in 170337 and 171340 ( bally et al . thus , at most , the outer 50% of their disks will be lost and for a surface density @xmath46 , the surviving mass fraction is at least @xmath47% . the other two objects probably have smaller disk radii in which case even more of the mass will survive . we conclude that for these four proplyds , at least , the submillimeter emission indicates there is sufficient material bound to the stars to form solar system scale planetary systems . there are intriguing possibilities for the non - detections too . we found a statisically positive flux toward the 18 proplyds that lay below our @xmath32 detection limit . the corresponding ( gas + dust ) mass limit is @xmath36 and the dust - only mass limit is therefore @xmath48 . that is , even if all the gas were lost from these disks , there would still be enough material to form terrestrial - like planets . far more sensitive observations would be required to verify this on an individual basis , of course , and it would also be important to average the vla data in a similar way to measure the low level bremsstrahlung emission . we thank the referee , mark mccaughrean , for his thorough review which helped improve the paper , and the sma staff for carrying out the observations . we enjoyed interesting discussions with dave hollenbach , john bally , and michael liu , and provocative comments from frank shu and christine wilson concerning the collective properties of the non - detections . support for this work was provided by nsf grant ast-0324328 ( jpw ) and nasa origins of solar systems program grant nag5 - 11777 ( djw ) . = 1andrews , s. m. , & williams , j. p. 2005 , , submitted 3.3 in * figure 1 : * contours of @xmath15 m continuum emission toward the proplyds in the trapezium cluster . the lefthand image shows the locations of the proplyds ; red crosses for the 5 detections labeled with the odell & wen nomenclature and blue crosses for the 18 non - detections . the position of the four trapezium o stars are shown by the large star symbols and the center of the coordinate grid has been set to 1c . the @xmath1 synthesized beam and scale bar are shown in the lower left corner . the contour levels are @xmath49 where @xmath30 mjy beamis the rms noise level in the map . the righthand image shows the same contours overlaid on the hst image from bally et al . ( 1998b ) . in both images , the large dashed circle shows the fwhm of the primary beam , 3.4 in * figure 2 : * spectral energy distributions from 20 cm to @xmath15 m for the five sma detections . the fluxes shortward of 30 ghz are from vla observations by felli et al . ( 1993 ) , garay et al . ( 1987 ) and zapata et al . ( 1994 ) . in the case of multi - epoch observations , the error bar shows the range of measured values . the 86 ghz fluxes are from bima observations by mundy et al . and is estimated for 163 - 317 from the @xmath32 contour in their map . upper limits are shown by open symbols . the squares show the 341 ghz sma measurements . the uncertainties in the bima and sma measurementss are dominated by uncertainties in the flux scales , estimated to 20% . fits to the ionized gas and dust emission are overlaid . 3.7 in * figure 3 : * normalized histograms of the flux distribution toward the undetected proplyds ( line ) and the rest of the map within the primary beam fwhm ( grayscale ) . the five detected proplyds have not been included in either plot and the fluxes were not corrected for primary beam attenuation . the flux distribution toward the undetected proplyd positions is offset from the background flux distribution and has a mean value 0.8 mjy beam . lcccc + proplyd & @xmath50 & peak s / n & bremsstrahlung@xmath51 & @xmath52 + & ( mjy ) & & ( mjy ) & ( @xmath53 ) + + 163317 & 33.3 & 8.7 & 5.9 & 1.9 + 167317@xmath54 & 21.9 & 5.3 & 17.3 & + 170337 & 38.1 & 7.3 & 3.7 & 2.4 + 171334 & 24.6 & 7.5 & 2.1 & 1.6 + 171340 & 18.3 & 4.0 & 0 & 1.3 + + + + + lccccc + proplyd & dust excess ? & type@xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 + & & & ( @xmath59 cm ) & ( @xmath60 ) & ( au ) + + 163 - 317 & @xmath61 & & 4.7 & 1.8 & + 170 - 337 & @xmath61 & jet , od & 10.9 & 2.2 & 40 + 171 - 334 & @xmath61 & & 9.5 & @xmath62 & + 171 - 340 & @xmath61 & sd / e & 12.9 & & 40 + + 157 - 323 & @xmath63 & & 7.4 & 2.1 & + 158 - 323 & @xmath63 & & 6.3 & @xmath62 & + 158 - 326 & @xmath63 & sd / e & 6.5 & 0.7 & 40 + 158 - 327 & @xmath63 & sd / e & 7.2 & & 20 + 159 - 338 & @xmath63 & & 11.9 & 0.2 & @xmath64 + 160 - 328 & @xmath63 & od & 11.1 & & 45 + 161 - 314 & @xmath63 & & 5.1 & & + 161 - 322 & @xmath63 & & 4.1 & & + 161 - 324 & @xmath63 & & 4.2 & @xmath65 & + 161 - 328 & @xmath63 & sd / e & 5.1 & 0.1 & 40 + 163 - 322 & @xmath63 & & 2.0 & & + 163 - 323 & @xmath63 & & 1.4 & 0.2 & + 166 - 316 & @xmath63 & & 4.9 & 0.8 & @xmath64 + 167 - 317 & @xmath63 & jet & 5.2 & 2.4 & + 168 - 326 & @xmath63 & & 4.2 & 0.1 & + 168 - 328 & @xmath63 & & 4.5 & 0.7 & + 169 - 338 & @xmath63 & & 11.1 & & + 171 - 315 & @xmath63 & & 8.2 & & + 176 - 325 & @xmath63 & & 11.0 & 0.9 & + + +

we have imaged the 880 @xmath0 m continuum emission from the `` proplyds '' in the center of the trapezium cluster in orion using the submillimeter array with a beam size @xmath1 fwhm and an rms of 2.7 mjy . five sources are detected with fluxes in the range 18 to 38 mjy , which includes dust emission from four proplyds and ionized gas from @xmath2orig . the total masses of the detected proplyds derived from their dust emission range from 1.3 to @xmath3 assuming a dust temperature of 20 k and mass opacity of 0.03 @xmath4 g. the eighteen other proplyds within the field - of - view were not formally detected individually , but by combining the fluxes measured at their locations , an average flux of 1.1mjy was determined for them on a statistical basis , corresponding to a mass of @xmath5 . the four detected proplyds have sufficient disk mass bound to their central stars to form planetary systems on the scale of our solar system .

gr-qc0501034

sam is in the office and has just finished reading plato s _ meno _ @xcite in which socrates uses a self - discovery technique to teach a boy pythagoras theorem . sam is inspired by this dialog and is pondering its applicability to lecturing undergraduate physics when a tap on the door breaks that chain of thought . kim enters the room looking bleary eyed and pale . `` been out celebrating the last lecture of the year '' sam surmises , little knowing that other things have kept kim awake . * your lectures on special relativity fascinated me , and when i got home i wondered if i could construct a simple experiment to prove or disprove time dilation , the aspect of special relativity that interests me the most . while lying in bed before dozing off i realised that a clock placed at the equator should run slower than a clock placed at the pole . so i did a little calculation and found that special relativity predicts that a clock on the equator runs slower by about 100 nanoseconds per day with respect to a clock at the pole . while this effect is not large it is certainly measurable with modern atomic clocks so i went onto the internet to see if i could find any reference to such an experiment and to my surprise i could nt . + i was starting to get so frustrated that i could nt sleep . i glanced at the clock ( 3 am ) . i thought to myself `` how accurate is my clock ? i should check it against internet time . '' then it occurred to me that the world timing standard organisations must mention a latitude effect on local clock accuracies . so i got onto the internet again and checked _ _ the bureau international des poids et mesures ( bipm)__@xcite as they calculate the international atomic time ( tai ) . bipm calculate tai from atomic clocks located in more than 30 countries around the world . i was sure that i must find something about the latitude effect on their web site . after spending hours trawling through the site and then other sites on the web , i came up with nothing . there was a discussion of the relativistic effect of placing clocks at high altitudes , but nothing about latitude . in my despair i gave up and collapsed into a fitful sleep . + i came to see you today in the hope that you could cure my insomnia . * you are in good company in thinking that clocks at the equator and the pole should tick at different rates . einstein himself predicted as much in his famous 1905 paper on the special theory of relativity.@xcite luckily for physics the effect was not measurable with the instruments of the day as einstein s prediction would have failed to match experiment . let us return to your findings : 1 . according to the special theory of relativity a clock located at the equator should run slower than one at the pole 2 . all clocks located at sea - level on the earth s surface tick at the same rate , regardless of latitude + to help you understand how both apparently contradictory statements can be true i will ask you a question . + if the earth was a rotating perfect fluid and we could ignore the gravitational effects of the sun and the moon what shape would it be ? * well , i do nt see how this is relevant , but i would answer your question by drawing a free - body diagram . can i use your blackboard ? + [ fig : fbd ] + now let me see consider a test mass placed on the surface of the earth . we know that the forces acting on the test mass are the outward pointing force due to the difference in pressure and the inward pointing force due to gravity . if the test mass is in hydrostatic equilibrium then the pressure force must be perpendicular to the surface and the sum of the gravitational and pressure forces is the centripetal force , which is perpendicular to the axis of rotation.@xcite hmmm you would have a complicated integral equation to solve because the direction of the gravitational force vector would depend on the distribution of mass , furthermore the pressure gradient would be perpendicular to the surface we are trying to calculate . it seems to be a complicated problem and , to be honest , i am not sure that i could solve it . * it is a difficult problem and one whose solutions involve hyperbolic and elliptic functions . chandrasekhar has devoted a whole book to the subject.@xcite before we travel that arduous mathematical road let us see if we can use some physics to help us . taking our model of earth as a rotating perfect fluid , is the earth an equipotential surface ? * ( _ thinks _ ) yes . * why ? * because if it was nt the sea water would feel a force @xmath0 and would move until @xmath1 everywhere on the surface . * so if i told you what the earth s gravitational field is could you tell me the shape of the earth ? * yes , i think i could . * how ? * if you told me that the earth s gravitational field is @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the distance from the centre and @xmath4 is the colatitude @xcite then i could calculate the _ effective _ potential felt by an observer co - rotating with the earth by including the centripetal force : @xmath5 \\ \mbox{$\theta = 0 $ at the north pole , $ \pi/2 $ at equator and $ \pi$ at the south pole } \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath6 is the earth s rotation rate and @xmath3 is the distance from the centre to the earth s surface . the second term on the right hand side of eq . is the so called `` centrifugal potential '' . now we have already argued that a co - rotating observer on the surface of the earth feels no change in effective potential regardless of their latitude , i.e. , @xmath7 is constant . furthermore , you have told me that we know what the earth s gravitational field @xmath2 is , so all i need to do is rearrange equation eq . and _ voil _ we have an expression for the shape of the earth s surface . mind you , as @xmath8 may be a complicated function ; i am not sure that i can find an analytic expression for @xmath3 anyway . + all this is very interesting , but i do nt see how it answers my question about why clocks tick at the same rate on the earth s surface . * patience , we are coming to that . first let us investigate the discovery you have made , namely the shape of the earth . let me see , i know i have it in here somewhere + _ sam flicks through some notes in the filing cabinet _ + ah here it is . despite the earth s complicated shape with mountains and valleys its gravitational field can be modelled to a fractional accuracy of @xmath9 by:@xcite @xmath10 where * * @xmath11m@xmath12s@xmath13 is the product of the gravitational constant and the mass of the earth @xcite * * @xmath14 is a measure of the earth s equatorial bulge and is related to the legendre polynomials @xcite * * @xmath15 m is the earth s equatorial radius @xcite + to evaluate your equation for the earth s surface ( which incidentally is called the geoid ) you will need an accurate value of the earth s rotation rate . + _ sam shuffles through some files _ + yes here it is @xcite @xmath16 + now your geoid equation is going to be a bit tricky to solve analytically so instead of doing that let us see if we are on the right track . the easiest thing for us to do is to check that your equation for the earth s effective potential @xmath7 is the same at the equator and the pole . * * : the earth s mean polar radius is @xmath17 km @xcite @xmath18 * * : the earth s mean equatorial radius is @xmath19 km @xcite @xmath20 + look the two values for @xmath7 are the same ! + what have you shown ? * we have shown that the earth is indeed an equipotential surface with respect to an observer sitting on the surface . but sam , this has nothing to do with the question i originally asked you ! * does nt it ? what did you ask me again ? * i asked you why all clocks tick at the same rate on the surface of the earth when special relativity predicts that they should run slower at the equator than at the pole . * kim do you remember how we derived einstein s famous formula @xmath21 ? * yes , and to be honest i was a little disappointed with it . once we learnt that a constant speed of light lead to the lorentz transformations , the rest was just algebra . * remind me of the algebra . * we got to the point that we realised that the proper time interval , @xmath22 must be defined as @xmath23 with @xmath24 and @xmath25 the coordinate time and space interval respectively . then we simply multiplied equation eq . by @xmath26 to get @xmath27 so if @xmath28 , then @xmath29 , like i said , just algebra . * hmm , yes indeed . suppose you are floating in a room with no windows or doors . all of a sudden , you feel a force that throws you against the wall . if their were two possible forces , gravitational or centrifugal , are you able to determine which force you are feeling ? * i do nt see how . * and what would you ( sitting in this closed room ) say your time dilation was with respect to an observer who was not feeling the centrifugal or gravitation force ? * i think i see what you are getting at . i ca nt say whether the force is gravitational or centrifugal , so i must treat their effects as the same . if i knew the force was centrifugal , i would say that my time dilation with respect to a stationary observer depends only on my velocity @xmath30 , i.e. , @xmath31 . as i do nt know where the energy to thrust me against the wall has come from , to be consistent , i must say that the time dilation depends only on the effective potential , which is the sum of the gravitational and centripetal potentials . * excellent ! the idea that you ca nt know if the force is a uniform gravitational force , or a combination of uniform forces , is called the _ equivalence principle_. @xcite what does it tell you about clocks on the surface of the earth ? * yes , yes , of course . according to somebody standing anywhere on the surface of the earth , all their energy is effective potential energy @xmath7 . the rate at which their clock ticks depends only on this effective potential . we already showed that the effective potential over the surface of the earth is constant . so all clocks on the surface of the earth tick at the same rate . eureka , i can sleep again ! * yes , you can sleep well indeed because you have just discovered one of the fundamental arguments that led to the development of the general theory of relativity . before you go , let me clarify one point . to determine the time dilation , you used the effective potential which came from newtonian arguments about gravitational and centrifugal forces . according to general relativity the newtonian effective potential is an approximation to the relativistic effective potential . this does not change your conclusion in any way , the effective potential is still constant , it just means that in general relativity we have a slightly different version of @xmath7 ( _ see appendix [ app : clockgr ] _ ) . having said that , you should note that for the earth , the newtonian and relativistic effective potentials are almost identical . to learn precisely what the difference is , you will have to take my general relativity course , unless you continue to derive general relativity by yourself ! _ after exchanging pleasantries , kim leaves for the long cycle home . kim reflects that the thought experiment involving a person in a windowless room who did nt know if the force they felt was gravitational or centrifugal was very similar to the arguments about absolute and relative motion that they learnt in their special relativity course . _ _ sam contemplates this conversation with kim and wonders if it should be entered into next year s general relativity lecture notes . _ the author would like to thank two anonymous referees who provided insightful comments which improved the clarity of arguments presented in this paper . the author would also like to thank vivienne wheaton for proof reading the final version . 99 meno by plato translated with an introduction by benjamin jowett http://etext.library.adelaide.edu.au/p/p71mo/index.html the bureau international des poids et mesures ( bipm ) http://www.bipm.fr/ alex harvey and engelbert schucking , _ a small puzzle from 1905 _ , physics today , march 2005 dan bruton , _ the shape of rotating stars _ + http://observe.phy.sfasu.edu/downloads/starlight/word/starspin.pdf + william k. rose , _ astrophysics _ ( holt , rinehart and winston , new york , 1973 ) subrahmanyan chandrasekhar , _ ellipsoidal figures of equilibrium _ ( dover , new york , 1987 ) , 2d ed . colatitude is @xmath32 minus latitude . it is the coordinate of choice for most references on planetary gravitational potentials . this is the total mass of the earth including the atmosphere . as we are calculating the gravitational potential at sea level we should subtract the mass of the atmosphere but we do not need to do this as the mass of the atmosphere is roughly one millionth of the total mass of the earth . claude audoin and bernard guinot , _ the measurement of time _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2001 ) guy bomford , _ geodesy _ ( oxford university press , oxford , 1986 ) , 5th . ed . this value of @xmath33 is to fit the ellipsoidal earth model wgs84 see + http://earth-info.nga.mil/gandg/wgsegm/ + for more details . david lide , _ crc handbook of chemistry and physics _ ( crc press , new york , 1997 ) bernard f. schutz , _ a first course in general relativity _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1985 ) according to the general theory of relativity the proper time interval ( @xmath22 ) for a clock in a weak gravitational field ( such as the earth s ) is given by @xcite @xmath34 where @xmath35 is given by eq . and @xmath36 . for a clock sitting on the surface of the earth @xmath37 so the proper time interval is @xmath38 where @xmath7 is the newtonian gravitational potential ( see eq . ) . the time dilation effect is obtained by rearranging eq . : @xmath39 we have shown in this paper that the weak equivalence principle effectively states that time dilation can be calculated in terms of the effective potential only , i.e. , @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the relativistic effective potential . the relativistic effective potential can be determined in terms of the newtonian potential by expanding eq . and equating it with eq . ; @xmath42 comparing eq . with eq . , using the values for @xmath7 as calculated in eqs . and we see that the relativistic effective potential differs from the newtionian effective potential to a fractional accuracy of @xmath43 .

in this paper we show how the student can be led to an understanding of the connection between special relativity and general relativity by considering the time dilation effect of clocks placed on the surface of the earth . this paper is written as a socratic dialog between a lecturer sam and a student kim .

1509.03664

cataclysmic variables ( cvs ) are a diverse group of short - period binaries in which a late - type , roche - lobe filling secondary star transfers matter through an accretion disk onto a white dwarf primary . the standard paradigm for the formation of cvs postulates that they start out as wide binaries ( on the order of 1 au ) , of moderate orbital period ( @xmath5 1 yr ) . as the more massive component , the white dwarf progenitor , evolves off of the main sequence , the secondary star suddenly finds itself orbiting within the red giant photosphere . during this `` common envelope '' ( ce ) phase , much of the angular momentum of the binary is believed to be shed due to interactions of the secondary star with the atmosphere of the red giant . during this process , the binary period gets shortened , and the red giant envelope gets ejected . depending on the input parameters used in standard ce models , between 50 and 90% of all of these close binary stars merge ( c.f . , politano & weiler 2007 ) . after emerging from the ce phase , an epoch of angular momentum loss via magnetic braking ( verbunt & zwaan 1981 ) , lasting @xmath6 10@xmath7 yr ( warner 1995 ) , is then required that leads to the formation of a semi - detached binary , and the mass transfer phase that signals the birth of a cv . in this scenario , the vast majority of cv secondary stars should not show any signs of evolution , as there just has not been sufficient time for the low mass secondary stars ( m@xmath8 @xmath9 1 m@xmath10 ) in these systems to have begun to evolve off of the main sequence . thus , the composition of the secondary stars should be relatively normal unless they have accreted matter with an unusual composition during the ce phase , or perhaps during classical novae eruptions . in an infrared spectroscopic survey of cvs , harrison et al . ( 2004 , 2005 ) found that the co features of the secondary stars in a number of cvs were much weaker than expected for their spectral types . for u gem , the co features were extremely weak , yet the water vapor feature was normal for a spectral type of m4v . this suggested a deficit of carbon . hamilton et al . ( 2011 ) have tabulated the list of cvs with weaker than expected co features , and show that , when such data exists , analysis of uv spectra _ also _ find evidence for carbon deficiencies . one issue with the infrared spectroscopy surveys was that they were qualitative , and were derived from lower resolution ( r @xmath0 2000 ) spectroscopy . the line features in those spectra _ might _ be compromised due to veiling by a continuum source that arises from the accretion disk . we have obtained moderate , and lower resolution , @xmath1-band spectroscopy of three of the brightest cvs : ss cyg , ru peg , and gk per . previous near - infrared spectroscopy with spex ( harrison et al . 2004 , 2007 ) revealed that the secondary stars in these three systems had weaker than expected co features . in the following , we use a modified version of the moog spectral synthesis program to model moderate resolution @xmath1-band spectra to examine the atomic and molecular abundances in their secondary stars . as shown in hamilton et al . ( 2011 ) , higher resolution spectra dramatically reduce the effects of accretion disk veiling , allowing us to see secondary stars even in cv systems where the accretion luminosity totally dominates that of the secondary star . in the systems discussed here , however , the secondary star dominates the accretion disk flux in the @xmath1-band , and any veiling has to be quite small . we then compare the best fit model spectra derived from the higher resolution data to lower resolution data . in the next section we discuss the data to be modeled , in section 3 we discuss the spectral synthesis procedure , in section 4 we present the modeling of the data , discuss the results in section 5 and draw our conclusions in section 6 . ss cyg , ru peg , and gk per were observed using nirspec in high resolution mode on keck ii on 2004 august 28 . the 0.432 x 12 slit was used providing a resolving power of r @xmath0 25000 , or a velocity resolution of @xmath11 @xmath0 12 km s@xmath12 . we employed the two - nod script , and we used five minute exposure times for the three program cvs . to completely cover the @xmath1-band using nirspec requires two grating settings . due to time limitations , however , we only obtained data at a single grating position chosen to insure coverage of the first overtone bandhead of @xmath13co@xmath14 at 2.294 @xmath15 m . this grating setting also covers the @xmath13co@xmath16 bandhead at 2.383 @xmath15 m . in addition to the three program cvs , we also observed two late - type stars , @xmath17 eri ( k2v ) and @xmath18 psc ( g9iii ) , to provide templates for our synthetic spectral program given that the properties of those two objects are well known . to correct for telluric absorption , we observed bright a0v stars located close to the program objects so as to minimize their relative differences in airmass . these data were reduced using the idl routine `` @xmath19 '' , specially developed for nirspec package can be found here : http://www2.keck.hawaii.edu/inst/nirspec/redspec/index.html ] . in the @xmath1-band , the spectra of a0v stars are nearly featureless , except for the prominent h i brackett @xmath18 feature at 2.16 @xmath15 m . the @xmath19 package does not attempt to correct for this feature , but can interpolate across such lines to reduce their impact upon division into the program star spectrum . note that there is a weak telluric feature located very close to the brackett @xmath18 line , and thus the h i line profiles in spectra produced by the division of a `` patched '' a - star spectrum are slightly compromised . just prior to our observing run on keck , we observed the three program cvs using spex at the irtf on 2004 august 15 . spex was used in cross - dispersed mode generating spectra spanning the range from 0.8 to 2.45 @xmath15 m . in the @xmath1-band , the dispersion is 5.4 / pix . the raw data were reduced using spextool ( cushing et al . 2004 ) . a log of all of our observations is presented in table 1 , and includes the orbital phase at the mid - point of the observational sequence for each of the three cvs . the aavso light curve data base shows that ss cyg was in quiescence at the time of both the spex and nirspec observations , having reached visual maximum on 17 july . ru peg was in outburst on 23 july , but was in quiescence for both observing runs . at the time of the infrared observations , gk per had @xmath20 = 13.1 , its normal minimum light value . to calculate a synthetic spectrum , three basic building blocks are required : a stellar atmosphere model , a list of atomic and molecular lines , and a tool to calculate the corresponding flux at the stellar surface as a function of wavelength . a full description of the modified version of moog and the grid generation and spectral matching python code ( called `` _ kmoog _ '' ) used below is described in hamilton ( 2013 ) , here we highlight the most important aspects . there are several groups that provide precomputed atmosphere models , each with their own slightly different assumptions , simplifications , and basic input physics . most of the models in general circulation , however , have the same underlying assumptions : the atmosphere is either modeled as a series of plane - parallel slabs ( 1d ) , or as a series of concentric shells ( 2d ) . the 1d and 2d atmosphere models are calculated assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium ( lte ) conditions , in which one temperature can describe the particle velocity distribution as well as the population of atomic levels and ionization states around a given point in the stellar atmosphere . it is also assumed that the atmosphere is time invariant , with the effects of dynamical processes such as mixing and convection parameterized . bonifacio et al . ( 2012 ) provide an overview of the more detailed assumptions and differences between the available atmosphere computation methods and programs . full 3d ( radiation - hydrodynamic ) stellar atmosphere models have been calculated across parameter grids ( e.g. , ludwig et al . 2009 , hauschildt and baron 2010 , magic et al . 2013a , 2013b ) . for this program , however , we have only used the 1d and 2d models . the most commonly used atmosphere model codes are phoenix ( hauschildt et al . ( 1999 ) , allard et al . 2011 ) , marcs ( gustafsson et al . 1975 , 2008 ) , and atlas ( sbordone et al . 2004 ) . phoenix is perhaps the most computationally sophisticated , sampling 42 million atomic and 550 million molecular lines when calculating opacity . marcs model atmospheres are consistently updated through a web interface providing both 1d and 2d models . ultimately for this project , we chose to use marcs atmospheres . an important consideration for this choice was the existence of the interpolation code to create subgrid models , making it much simpler to construct a large grid of models quickly . very recently , mszros et al . ( 2012 ) presented a new grid of atmospheres based off of atlas and marcs codes with an updated h@xmath21o line list as well as finer grid spacings in temperature , gravity , metallicity , and c and @xmath22 abundances . given their recent availability , however , all analyses and spectra computed here use solely the original marcs grid . the next crucial step to constructing a synthetic spectrum is to assemble a list of atomic and molecular transitions for which you wish to calculate an opacity at the stellar surface . for our project we used the atlas line list with the addition of the co line list by goorvitch ( 1994 ) . each line list was converted into a common format before combining , and , in the case of the co line list , only lines with @xmath23 and 2.28 @xmath24 2.405 @xmath15 m were kept . the final list contains a total of 11,681 lines . for the purposes of this work , only computations involving diatomic molecules were considered . this eliminates lines of the important molecular species for the cooler m dwarfs commonly found in cvs , such as h@xmath21o . as described below , synthetic spectra for the sun and arcturus were generated and compared to observations to provide the initial validation of this line list . there are a number of codes that can readily make use of marcs and kurucz atmospheres . moogchris / moog.html ] ( sneden 1973 ) has one of the longest track records , and given its ubiquity , we chose it to compute the synthetic spectra for this work . when creating a spectrum , moog is internally limited to considering only 2500 lines in the line list . given the size of our line list , we modified moog ( see hamilton 2013 ) to allow for lists of 250,000 lines . two additional changes were made to the moog source code . first , a version was created to produce absolutely no output to the screen . this prevents unnecessary lag and slowdowns , as well as greatly enhances usability when running a large number of models simultaneously . second , and most importantly , a new binary output file type of moog was created . significant savings in storage size were realized by creating a true fits output type , reducing the file size of a successfully created model by a factor of five or more . the fits files created also have the benefit of being fully compliant and compatible with the standard cfitsio libraries , unlike the fits - like output already in the code . the fits output created also has the benefit of storing both a full resolution spectrum as well as one convolved to lower resolutions , useful for quickly comparing against observations from different telescopes and instruments . to validate our line list , we constructed synthetic spectra for the sun ( using the solar marcs model ) and arcturus ( using the parameters listed in table 2 , but with log@xmath25 = 3.0 ) to compare them to high resolution @xmath1-band spectra published by wallace et al . ( 1996 ) , and wallace & hinkle ( 1996 ) . we concentrated on the reproduction of only the strongest spectral features observed in these two objects . note that the arcturus comparison was only used to insure that we were not missing lines that become important at lower temperatures . we then altered the oscillator strengths of the most highly discrepant lines to insure that they would both fit the observations better , and not bias the automated fitting process . for example , there were a large number of sc i transitions that had oscillator strengths that were much too large . unfortunately , oscillator strengths for many of the transitions in the @xmath1-band do not appear in the nist atomic spectra database , and thus we used trial and error adjustment of the tabulated oscillator strength in the line list to better reproduce the observed spectral feature ( for a primer on the identification of the strongest spectral features found in the @xmath1-band for k - type stars , see fig . 5 in harrison et al . 2004 ) . to test our ability to reproduce observations , we have constructed synthetic spectra to compare to the nirspec observations of @xmath17 eri and @xmath18 psc , and to a sample lower resolution spectra of k dwarfs contained in the irtf spectral library ( cushing et al . we summarize the spectroscopically derived parameters for these objects in table 2 , averaging the data compiled in the pastel catalog ( soubiran et al . 2010 ) for each object , constrained to measures made after 1970 . the final column of table 2 denotes how many unique measurements went into the determination of each of the average properties for each star ( note that hd45977 only has a single measurement of its characteristics by sousa et al . as we will see , this sample more than spans the range in metallicity observed for our program cvs . note that the solar abundance pattern derived by grevesse et al . ( 2007 ) was used for all of the synthetic spectra , and only the abundance of carbon was altered for the investigation of the cvs . in preparation for comparison to the models , the spectra were continuum normalized using a third order polynomial fit in iraf . for the high resolution spectra , the process was quite trivial . for the full @xmath1-band spectra , however , we used an identical set of wavelength bins for identifying the continuum to be fit . the continua were then fitted over the range 2.08 to 2.29 @xmath15 m , with bins that avoided all of the strongest spectral features . the nirspec spectrum of @xmath17 eri is presented in fig . [ eps ] , where data for five of the seven spectral orders are shown ( the first order , spanning @xmath262.43 to 2.47 @xmath15 m , was too far red to obtain appreciable signal in our cv spectra , while the seventh order spectrum is dominated by the strong telluric feature at 2.05 @xmath15 m ) . as shown in table 2 , @xmath17 eri has a temperature near 5100 k , and a near - solar metallicity of [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.1 . in fig . [ eps ] , we overplot a synthetic spectrum with t = 5100 k , and [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.125 ( interpolated between the model atmospheres with [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.25 , and [ fe / h ] = 0.0 ) . the model fit to the strongest lines is excellent . note that we have inserted an h i br@xmath18 line into our line list . we do this to primarily show where this line is located . the profiles of this feature as found in the infrared spectra for each of the objects are unreliable due to the reduction technique . in addition , the profile of such a strong line can not be easily reproduced using moog . @xmath18 psc allows us to test our ability to reproduce a much lower gravity object with a very low metallicity . we used a marcs spherical , alpha - enhanced model atmosphere with log@xmath25 = 2.5 , and [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.5 to generate a synthetic spectrum for @xmath18 psc . as noted in alves - brito et al . ( 2010 ) , @xmath18 psc has a modest alpha - enhancement of @xmath0 @xmath270.2 , and thus many of the metal lines are stronger in @xmath18 psc than they would be in a model that has a solar abundance pattern . since @xmath28 does not yet have the capabilities to adjust the abundances of any other species besides carbon , we ran the moog binary used by @xmath28 in a stand - alone mode , increasing the abundances of o , al and mg as detailed in alves - brito et al . we overplot this model on the observed data in fig . [ gamma ] . the resulting synthetic spectrum is a reasonable match to the data . given that the majority of cvs are too faint for moderate resolution infrared spectroscopy , most of the existing @xmath1-band data have been obtained at a lower resolution . to examine how well we can model such data sets we have downloaded spex data for dwarf stars spanning the spectral types k0v to k7v . the spectral type range k0v to k3v is shown in fig . [ k0tok3 ] , while the range k4v to k7v is shown in fig . [ k4tok7 ] . we generated synthetic spectra for each of these stars using the parameters listed in table 2 . the published metallicities produced excellent fits over most of the spectral range for all of the stars except hd145675 ( k0v ) . we found that the best fitting model for hd145675 over the entire @xmath1-band required a lower metallicity , [ fe / h ] = @xmath270.25 , than tabulated for this object ( though within the observed error bars ) . close inspection of fig . [ k0tok3 ] shows that the synthetic spectra do not do a very good job of matching the strongest spectral features in the 2.10 to 2.15 @xmath15 m bandpass . the origin of this discrepancy is not obvious . the fit of the synthetic spectra over the rest of the @xmath1-band suggests the tabulated ( or derived ) metallicities are correct . this might be a problem with continuum subtraction . to investigate this , we reduced and plot the spex data for the g9v star hd161198 observed during the same run as our program cvs [ note that hd161198 is a spectroscopic binary with a cool secondary star ( duquennoy et al . 1996 ) , and it is not a useful spectral template ] . the model for hd145675 does a good job at fitting the spectrum of hd161198 in this range , indicating that continuum subtraction is not the issue . this suggests that the problem could be due to either the data reduction process , or some issue with the telluric standard and/or object spectra . the maximum amount of observed signal occurs in this bandpass , and the k0v , k1v , and k3v have @xmath1 @xmath9 4.7 ( hd3765 has @xmath1 = 5.16 , while hd145675 has @xmath1 = 5.55 ) , so perhaps it is a linearity issue . the discrepancy between the models and observed spectra in the 2.10 to 2.15 @xmath15 m bandpass is not as severe for the k4v to k7v templates ( even though the k7v template is 61 cyg b , with @xmath1 = 2.32 ) . clearly , however , our synthetic spectra do an excellent job at matching objects with known temperatures and metallicities . especially important for the current program is the match of the model spectra to the observed co features over a wide range of temperature and metallicity . in the preceding we have modeled the spectra of objects with known parameters . for modeling the cvs , where the temperatures and metallicities are poorly known , requires the generation of a large number of models , and a robust method to match the synthetic spectra to the observations . with the python wrapper we have constructed to the modified version of the moog program described above , we are able to generate a large grid of models covering a user - defined range of the following parameters : t@xmath29 , log @xmath25 , [ fe / h ] , and [ c / fe ] . microturbulence was fixed at 2 km s@xmath30 , and macroturbulence was not included since it is a small effect at the resolution of our observational data . in _ , if the synthetic spectra are designated to be stored as fits files , each model actually contains two synthetic spectra : one unsmoothed , full resolution model , and one model convolved with a rotationally broadened spectrum appropriate for the target at the observed spectral resolution ( which must be specified before the grid creation ) . a full grid covering the entire parameter space ( 3800 @xmath9 t@xmath29 @xmath9 5200 k , 3.0 @xmath9 log @xmath25 @xmath9 5.0 , @xmath31 @xmath9 [ fe / h ] @xmath9 @xmath271 , and @xmath31 @xmath9 [ c / fe ] @xmath9 @xmath271 ) requires about one day to create on a 32 core machine and occupies @xmath0 86 gbyte in fits output format . obviously , smaller grids can be generated much more rapidly if the input parameter space can be narrowed . with such large grids , it is easy to be overwhelmed by the quantity of data . given a suitable subset of parameters , a direct grid search is possible ; gather a list of valid models , and step through them one at a time comparing the model to observations . given the sometimes low s / n of the observational data , however , a @xmath32 statistic is not calculated across the entire observational range , but restricted to the areas of greatest impact . for example , including na i , ca i , mg i , al i , fe i lines , and the co bands . this restricted region has the advantage of avoiding areas prone to increased levels of noise , and generally improves the quality of the fits to the observations . another method of stepping through the parameter space involves the use of an evolutionary algorithm to find the best fit to the data . evolutionary algorithms are based off the ideas of biological evolution , the simple premise that in some given population only the `` fittest individuals '' ( combination of all parameters ) will `` breed '' and influence the next generation of that population . if we imagine representing our parameters as 1d binary strings , then the behavior and the manipulation of the binary strings over the course of the fit is not unlike that of dna during reproduction . sets of parameters can be mutated , introducing diversity into the population which helps to avoid getting stuck in a local maximum or minimum in the `` @xmath33 landscape '' . mutations take the form of bit flips or swaps , analogous to transcription errors in dna replication . we used a genetic algorithm framework called @xmath34 . the algorithm proceeds as follows : 1 . make an initial first guess at the parameters based on spectral shape 2 . choose an appropriate maximum number of generations to evolve through as well as the initial population size 3 . `` breed '' and `` mutate '' the `` fittest '' members in the population to create a new generation 4 . repeat # 3 until the population converges to the desired level in this manner , all parameters are varied continually as the population converges towards some minimum @xmath32 , at least a factor of four faster than the plain grid searching technique . using both grid search and genetic algorithm techniques , the grid created with moog can be readily compared with the appropriate subset of cv spectra to attempt to determine as many stellar parameters as possible . both methods are available in _ kmoog _ , though we find the brute force is sufficiently rapid and as reliable as the genetic algorithm technique . heat maps showing the best fitting models for any two parameters are then generated to allow the determination of the best fitting model(s ) . as we will find below , determining the exact value t@xmath29 or [ fe / h ] for an unconstrained object from a @xmath1-band spectrum is difficult . many of the relevant oscillator strengths for transitions in this bandpass are unknown , and we have had to estimate a number of them by comparison of models to observations . in addition , our line list is incomplete , and thus weaker spectra features can contribute in a negative fashion to the assessment of the fit of a model to the data . the issues of telluric correction and continuum subtraction , as noted above , can introduce additional uncertainties into the goal of finding the best fitting solution . thus , the @xmath32 analysis just described must be done carefully , focussing on the strongest spectral features , insuring that there is not a spectroscopic anomaly in that feature which can be attributed to random noise variation , or to the telluric correction process . it is extremely difficult to produce a fully automated best fit regimen that can blindly solve for the parameters of a previously unconstrained object in the @xmath1-band , even when focused on specific spectral lines . currently , we manually examine the @xmath32 analysis for each line / region to insure that it is reliable , and that no unexpected events have occurred that affect the line / region under analysis . one such anomaly will be encountered shortly when we discuss the al i line ( at 2.116 @xmath15 m ) in ss cyg . it has an unusual strength that defies obvious explanation . @xmath35 analysis of this line results in a super - solar abundance . we continue to work on the matching aspects of _ kmoog _ , but in its current state , a more interactive ( `` hands - on '' ) approach is required to insure the most robust results . given that we have some information on the spectral types of the secondary stars in our cvs , we decided to use smaller grid than can be generated with the default settings of _ kmoog_. for example , tests in hamilton ( 2013 ) show that even the moderate resolution @xmath1-band spectra are inadequate for assessing gravity . given the large rotational broadening of our targets , it will be impossible to constrain the surface gravity for the program cvs . thus we fixed log @xmath25 = 4.5 for modeling ss cyg and ru peg , and log @xmath25 = 4.0 for gk per ( see below ) , to reduce parameter space , and increase the efficiency of the grid searching process . we postpone the discussion of error bar estimation to section 4.4 . ss cyg is the prototype long period ( p@xmath36 = 6.603 hr ) dwarf nova with eruptions that recur on a monthly basis . harrison et al . ( 2004 ) estimate the spectral type of the secondary as k4/k5 , consistent with other published values . they noted , however , that the co features were very weak for this spectral classification . bitner et al . ( 2007 ) have used moderate resolution visual band spectroscopy to examine the masses of both components , and found that the secondary star is 10 to 50% larger than a star of its mass and temperature should be . they suggest that the secondary star in ss cyg is evolved , and may have a core that is depleted in hydrogen . they also measured a rotational velocity of @xmath37sin@xmath38 = 89 km s@xmath12 for the secondary star . the nirspec spectrum of ss cyg is presented in fig . [ sscyg ] . the large rotational broadening of the spectral features is apparent . our observations spanned @xmath39 = 0.05 . at the observed phase ( using the k@xmath8 = 162.5 km s@xmath12 value derived by bitner et al . ) , the total change in radial velocity over our set of observations would be @xmath11 = 11 km s@xmath12 , resulting in minimal `` orbital smearing . '' concentrating on the sixth order bandpass ( 2.095 to 2.128 @xmath15 m ) , we convolved solar metallicity models having t = 4700 k with rotational velocities ranging from 70 to 110 km s@xmath12 . the lowest @xmath33 values were for @xmath37sin@xmath38 = 90 @xmath40 10 km s@xmath12 . for the modeling below , we adopt the bitner et al . value of @xmath37sin@xmath38 = 89 km s@xmath12 for ss cyg . to attempt to reproduce the nirspec data , we generated a grid of models spanning 4200 k @xmath9 t@xmath29 @xmath9 4900 k , @xmath41 @xmath9 [ fe / h ] @xmath9 @xmath270.50 , and @xmath42 @xmath9 [ c / fe ] @xmath9 @xmath270.25 . the resulting heat map for the sixth order , based on @xmath33 fits to _ only _ the first two of the three strong lines in the wavelength interval 2.104 and 2.118 @xmath15 m is shown in fig . [ sshm02 ] . the best fit occurs for t = 4700 k , and [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.25 . the fourth order contains a number of metal lines from ti i and fe i , though this spectral region is noisier than the data at shorter wavelengths . the resulting heat map , fig . [ sshm04 ] , is consistent with the result for the sixth order , though the value of [ fe / h ] is less constrained . the results for the third order containing the @xmath13co@xmath14 bandhead is shown in fig . [ sshm05 ] , and suggests [ c / fe ] @xmath9 @xmath20.5 . the best fit synthetic spectrum is overplotted on the data in fig . [ sscyg ] has these values , and fits the data set quite well . there is only one apparent anomaly in the nirspec spectrum of ss cyg , and that is the al i line at 2.116 @xmath15 m . we overplot the derived best fit model spectrum on the irtf spex observation in fig . [ ssirtf ] . the fit is quite good , given the s / n of those data . the main differences between the model and the low resolution spectrum is again the al i line 2.116 @xmath15 m , and an mg i feature at 2.282 @xmath15 m . the al i line was perfectly reproduced for the solar spectrum and for @xmath17 eri , but does appear to be slightly under - predicted for the irtf spectral sequence ( though note our earlier discussion of the anomalous continuum in this bandpass ) . the line at 2.109 @xmath15 m is also due to al i , thus the abundance of aluminum is not unusual . it is odd that this line is perfectly reproduced for our other cvs . there is an he i line at this position that is often seen weakly in emission in the @xmath1-band spectra of other cvs with more prominent accretion disks , such as tt ari , see fig . [ ttari ] . this emission line might be the cause of the peaks in the continuum on either side of this line in fig . [ ssirtf ] , but the effect of any such emission line would be to lessen the depth of the feature , not increase its strength . the mg i line at 2.282 @xmath15 m is well reproduced by _ kmoog _ for all of the template star spectra . this line is very weak in the spex spectrum of ss cyg . since the mg i line at 2.106 @xmath15 m is at the appropriate strength in both the moderate and lower resolution data sets , we conclude that this is simply a s / n or telluric correction issue . the nirspec and spex data were obtained at quite different orbital phases , 0.20 and 0.40 , respectively . the @xmath1-band light curve of ss cyg presented in harrison et al . ( 2007a ) shows no evidence for irradiation at @xmath43 = 0.5 , and the @xmath1 magnitudes at these two phases in this light curve are nearly identical . thus , the fact that the same synthetic spectrum works for both epochs is not surprising . this does prove , however , that irradiation of the secondary star is not the source that weakens the co absorption features , as the amount of the irradiated hemisphere seen at the dramatically different orbital phases of our spectra has no influence on the strength of the co features . ru peg is a u gem type dwarf nova of very long period ( p@xmath36 = 8.99 hr ) , whose binary parameters were first examined by kraft ( 1962 ) , observing doubled ca ii lines at some points in the orbital phase and a spectrum broadly consistent with a g8 iv to k0 v. friend et al . ( 1990 ) observed the @xmath268190 na i doublet to measure radial velocity motion of ru peg , finding that the secondary star is cooler and less massive than expected , with the spectrum being consistent with a k3 dwarf . they also note that the secondary star must be somewhat evolved , as the temperature , and masses derived are inconsistent with a main sequence dwarf . harrison et al . ( 2004 ) presented irtf observations of ru peg , showing that the nir spectrum was consistent with a spectral type of k2 , but that ru peg must contain a subgiant since it would be over - luminous for a dwarf at the distance given by its parallax . dunford et al . ( 2012 ) recently presented spectra of ru peg analyzed with roche tomograms , deriving a much cooler spectral type of k5 . along with the estimation of a cooler spectral type than found previously , dunford et al . used moderate resolution visual band spectra to estimate @xmath37sin@xmath38 = 89 km s@xmath12 . as for ss cyg , we convolved a solar abundance model with t@xmath29 = 4700 k to make our own estimate of the rotation velocity and found a slightly higher value of @xmath37sin@xmath38 = 95 @xmath40 10 km s@xmath12 . we have used this value in generating the synthetic spectra that follow . using the same size grid as that for ss cyg , the @xmath44 analysis for the sixth order , shown in fig . [ ruhm04 ] , suggests solar metallicities , and 4600 @xmath9 t@xmath29 @xmath9 4700 k. the results for the fourth order ( fig . [ ruhm02 ] ) indicate slightly subsolar metallicities , and 4500 @xmath9 t@xmath29 @xmath9 4900 k. we conclude that the secondary star has t@xmath29 = 4700 k , and [ fe / h ] = 0.0 . analysis of the co features in the third spectral order ( fig . [ ruhm05 ] ) finds [ c / fe ] = @xmath20.75 . a synthetic spectrum with these values is overplotted on the nirspec data in fig . [ rupeg ] , and provides an excellent fit to the data in all of the spectral orders . the h i emission from the disk is lower than seen in ss cyg , and the underlying h i br@xmath18 absorption from the secondary star leaves its imprint on the emission line profile . note that the long period and orbital phase at which the observations occurred make for minimal orbital smearing for the duration of our data taking : @xmath11 = 20 km s@xmath12 . the final model derived for the nirspec spectrum is overplotted on the spex data in fig . [ rupegirtf ] . this model fits the lower resolution data very well , including all of the other strong @xmath13co bandheads in the red part of the @xmath1-band . sion et al . ( 2004 ) found that the carbon abundance in the photosphere of the white dwarf was 10% of solar . thus , the carbon deficit observed in the uv can be directly traced to the secondary star . sion et al . also found that silicon suffered a similar deficit as that of carbon . the most prominent si i lines in the wavelength range plotted in fig . [ rupegirtf ] are at 2.136 and 2.189 @xmath15 m , and while these lines are weak in our data , and the s / n not very high , they seem to be well represented by our solar abundance model . gk per is an old classical nova , having experienced an extremely luminous nova eruption in 1901 ( see harrison et al . it has since exhibited periodic dwarf nova outbursts every 2 - 3 years since 1966 , brightening by @xmath0 3 mag during these events . kraft ( 1964 ) detected the mass donor star in the optical , adopting a spectral type of k2 iv and noting that the spectrum was highly variable with an equivalent width of sr ii 4077 consistent with a giant at one point and a dwarf the next . more recently , morales - reuda et al . ( 2012 ) analyzed spectra of gk per , finding that the donor star appeared as k1 iv . their analysis consisted of an iterative template subtraction method , however , not direct detection of the secondary star . harrison et al . ( 2007b ) presented a @xmath1-band spectrum of the mass donor star in gk per , and found that it has extremely weak co features . the radial velocity study conducted by morales - reuda et al . found @xmath37sin@xmath38 = 61.5 @xmath40 11.8 km s@xmath12 , k@xmath8 = 120.5 @xmath40 0.7 km s@xmath12 , and a mass ratio of @xmath45 = 0.55 @xmath40 0.21 . given the luminosity of its classical nova eruption suggests a massive white dwarf . if this is true , the radial velocity solution implies a surface gravity for the secondary star of log @xmath25 @xmath9 4 . as noted above , it is not possible to constrain the surface gravity of the program objects given the limitations of our data set . thus , in contrast to ss cyg and ru peg , we set the surface gravity to log @xmath25 = 4.0 for our modeling of gk per ( though this produced identical results to models with log @xmath25 = 4.5 ) . as for the preceding two objects , we analyzed the rotational velocity apparent in our nirspec data and find @xmath37sin@xmath38 = 55 @xmath40 10 km s@xmath12 , slightly lower than that derived by morales - rueda et al . , but agreeing within the error bars of the two measurements . we use this value in all of our modeling . the nirspec data is plotted in fig . [ gkper ] . @xmath35 analysis of the model grid found these best fit values : t@xmath29 = 5100 k , [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.125 , and [ c / fe ] = @xmath21.0 . gk per is fainter than our other two targets so the co region is very noisy , and thus the measurement of [ c / fe ] for gk per is slightly less certain than found for the other two targets . it is interesting to note that the h i absorption of the underlying secondary star is sufficient to create the appearance of no h i br@xmath18 emission at the center of this feature . the spex spectrum of gk per , fig . [ gkperirtf ] , is even noisier than the nirspec data . clearly , however , the same model does an excellent job at fitting the observations . as demonstrated above , we are easily able to reproduce the spectra of objects with known parameters . our examination of k stars in the irtf spectral library shows that if we know the value of [ fe / h ] , we can derive values of t@xmath29 , or vice versa , that are correct to within the published error bars for that object . to examine how well we can determine t@xmath29 or [ fe / h ] if we do not know either value , we present a @xmath35 analysis for the irtf template hd36003 . the heat map for the spectral region 2.18 @xmath9 @xmath26 @xmath9 2.37 @xmath15 m of this star is shown in fig . [ k4vhm ] . while the models with parameters similar to the published values for both t@xmath29 ( 4615 @xmath40 29 k ) and [ fe / h ] ( @xmath20.14 @xmath40 0.08 ) do have low values of @xmath35 , there is a range of solutions with quantitatively similar fits to the data . as demonstrated in the plots shown in figs . [ k0tok3 ] and [ k4tok7 ] , for k dwarfs , the strong na i doublet ( at 2.209 @xmath15 m ) , the ca i triplet ( at 2.26 @xmath15 m ) , and the co features all slowly get stronger as we decrease temperature . thus , models can mimic the observed spectrum by either an enhanced abundance of [ fe / h ] and a hotter temperature , or a reduced value of [ fe / h ] and a lower temperature . our @xmath35 analysis over such a large span in wavelength is certainly also affected by missing transitions for weak lines , the s / n of the data , and for this lower resolution spectrum , the continuum subtraction process . the red end of the @xmath1-band is filled with strong telluric features , and even for high s / n data , small discrepancies can appear due to a slight mis - match of the telluric standard with the program object . this is especially clear for the co features , as some bandheads in a particular spectrum are well fitted by the models , while others are not . given these results , if we are able to constrain the limits on the temperature of the object , such as `` the secondary star in ss cyg has a spectral type near k5 '' , and not expect super - solar metallicities , we find that temperatures derived from these data are good to @xmath40 250 k , and [ fe / h ] is good to @xmath40 0.25 . moderate resolution data that covered either the na i doublet or ca i triplet would almost certainly lead to more precise values of both quantities . putting error bars on our values for [ c / fe ] is more difficult in that none of our templates are known to have unusual values for this parameter . it is clear that our models reproduce the co features in the template spectra over a large range in metallicity . thus , altering just the abundance of carbon should not introduce any significant issues , as it simply acts to reduce the strength of the co features to mimic those seen in lower metallicity stars . how a reduced carbon abundance affects the input stellar atmosphere is difficult to assess given the unknown evolutionary state of the cv secondary stars . the presence of more than one co bandhead in all of the spectra also allows us to have more confidence in a particular value of [ c / fe ] . for the higher s / n spectra , we expect that the precision of the values for [ c / fe ] are similar in scale to [ fe / h ] : @xmath40 0.25 . for gk per the data are quite poor compared to the other two cvs , and the derived value for [ c / fe ] is less certain . it is obvious , however , that the value of [ c / fe ] is lower in gk per than in the other two sources . this result will be amplified if the gravity of gk per is significantly lower than our input value of log @xmath25 = 4.0 . we have obtained moderate resolution @xmath1-band spectroscopy of three cvs that were previously noted to have weaker than expected co features : ss cyg , ru peg , and gk per . because those earlier data were obtained at lower resolution , r @xmath0 2,000 , questions were raised about the possibility of `` veiling '' of the co features to make them appear weaker . while we show below that this argument has no validity if realistic veiling scenarios are examined , it is the increased dispersion of the spectra obtained with nirspec that easily argues against such a scenario . the nirspec data have a dispersion of 0.32 / pix , nearly 1/17 that of the spex data . thus , the flux per pixel from any veiling component would be diminished by this factor . model spectra fitted to the two different sets of data would give different values for the strength of the co features if there was some type of veiling confined to the co region . to provide quantitative estimates of the relative carbon abundances for cvs we have altered moog to allow us to model the entire @xmath1-band , and developed a software package that constructs large grids of synthetic spectra , and then searches these grids to find the best fitting solution to the observed data . we specifically allowed for the abundance of carbon to be a separate input under the assumption that the @xmath13c abundance has been changed in the initial branches of the cno cycle , as argued in harrison et al . obviously , weak co features could be explained by a deficit of oxygen , but a process that could cause such a deficit is not obvious . with this software we derived values of t@xmath29 , [ fe / h ] , and [ c / fe ] from the nirspec spectra for the three program objects . we list these results in table 3 . except for the deficits of carbon , no other abundance anomalies are apparent , and the secondary stars of all three objects have solar , or slightly sub - solar abundances . the total @xmath13c abundance for ss cyg and ru peg are similar , @xmath0 25% of solar , while for gk per it is @xmath0 10% of solar . if these peculiar values are the result of the cno cycle ( c.f . , marks & sarna 1998 ) , than the abundance of @xmath46c should be enhanced , allowing for the detection of the bandheads of @xmath46co . the two strongest such bandheads with @xmath47 2.4 @xmath15 m are @xmath46co@xmath14 at 2.345 @xmath15 m , and @xmath46co@xmath48 at 2.374 @xmath15 m . the first of these is not covered by our nirspec data , but dhillon et al . ( 2002 ) present a @xmath1-band spectrum of ss cyg which appears to show a strong @xmath46co@xmath14 absorption feature . they attribute this feature to metal line absorption in star spots as indicated by anomalously strong na i absorption features ( at 2.3355 and 2.3386 @xmath15 m ) in their spectra . these two na i lines are not anomalous in our spex data , nor is there a @xmath46co@xmath14 feature of the strength observed by dhillon et al . the second of the @xmath46co features is covered by our nirspec observations , but there is a deep telluric feature at this wavelength that makes good correction quite difficult , and results in a noisy portion of the second order spectrum . even with this issue , there is certainly no sign of a strong absorption feature at this location in either ss cyg or ru peg . the spex data covers both features , and while there are hints of both of these bandheads in the data for ss cyg and ru peg , the spectra are simply too noisy to draw any firm conclusions . new , higher s / n moderate resolution spectroscopy will be required to properly investigate the @xmath13c/@xmath46c ratio . harrison et al . ( 2004 ) found that the @xmath1-band continua of many long period cvs were flatter than expected if the secondary star was the sole source of emission in that bandpass . to more closely examine the slope of the continuum of ss cyg , we compare the full @xmath1-band spectrum of ss cyg with that of the irtf template star that has the most similar temperature : hd45977 . in fig . [ sscygcomp ] , we subtract the spectrum of hd45977 from that of ss cyg , both spectra having been normalized at 2.2 @xmath15 m . the result is a residual spectrum that is fairly flat , with f@xmath49 @xmath50 @xmath51 . given the uncertainties in the temperatures of the two objects , and the differing sources of the data , such a flat spectrum is consistent with free - free emission . the continuum subtraction process step required to allow us to directly compare the spex data to the synthetic spectra easily removes a weak continuum source such as this , and this is why the results for the nirspec and spex are simultaneously consistent with the same model . we can also attempt to model the contribution of line emission sources that might preferentially veil the co features . there are only two possible sources that we can envision that might do this : the h i pfund continuum , and co emission . as shown in fig . [ sscygcomp ] , the h i br@xmath18 emission line in ss cyg is quite strong , so the pfund series of hydrogen will also be present . the pfund series limit is at @xmath262.279 @xmath15 m , and the transitions pf23 and higher , will fall in our modeling bandpass . the emissivities of these lines are very small ; hummer & storey ( 1987 ) list them as being @xmath9 1.7% that of br@xmath18 ( for `` case b '' conditions ) . fitting the br@xmath18 line with a gaussian profile gives fwhm = 73 . we will assume all of the h i lines have this profile . in fig . [ sscygpfcomp ] , we present spectra where we added a rotationally broadened spectrum of the pfund series ( up to pf100 ) to the k4v spectral template , and compare it to the spectrum of ss cyg . given their low emissivities , the effect of the h i lines is not detectable . we also artificially multiplied the emissivities of the pfund lines by factors 10 and 100 and added them to the k4v template . only at very large multiplicative factors can their presence be detected , and even then , they add a smooth continuum to the co region , leaving the absorption features relatively undisturbed , but producing a highly distorted continuum . even with this simplistic model , it is clear that h i pfund emission can not provide the veiling necessary to explain weak co features . the detection of co emission in wz sge ( howell et al . 2004 ) has led to the suggestion that co emission is the source of the veiling needed to produce weaker than expected co features seen in the program cvs . since the co emission must come from the accretion disk , a similar result as that for the pfund continuum emission attains . as discussed in scoville et al . ( 1980 ) , such emission is expected to be confined to regions where t @xmath52 3000 k , and where the densities are high , @xmath53 @xmath54 10@xmath55 @xmath56 . since ss cyg was in a minimum during our observations , presumably these conditions exist somewhere within its accretion disk . as shown in bik et al . ( 2006 ) , optically thin co emission features are essentially the inverse of the co absorption features seen in late type stars . this similarity allows us to construct crude models to investigate what co emission might look like if its origin was in a cv accretion disk . if we assign the co emission to the disk , then the broadening of any spectral feature located there will be much greater than that of the slower rotational broadening of the secondary star ( 89 km s@xmath12 in the case of ss cyg ) . for example , if the accretion disk extends to 75% of r@xmath57 ( the roche lobe radius of the white dwarf ) , using the stellar parameters for ss cyg in bitner et al . ( 2007 ) , the keplerian velocity at this radius will be @xmath0 400 km s@xmath12 . in fig . [ sscygcocomp ] , we add a rotationally broadened co spectrum to the best fitting synthetic spectrum for ss cyg using the value for the h i br@xmath18 line ( fwhm = 73 ) , and a co emission spectrum broadened by half that value . as could be expected , the result is a dramatic change in the profiles of the co features , with an emission peak preceding each bandhead , a subtle redward shift for the location of the strongest absorption , and a dramatic narrowing of the co bandhead profiles . obviously , the data for none of our objects resembles this result . more complicated scenarios for the emission profile could be constructed , but to truly diminish the co features without distorting the resulting spectrum _ requires _ the addition of co emission with a broadening profile that is very similar to that of the secondary star . there is no other location in a cv system besides the secondary star photosphere where such low velocities occur . we have modified the spectral synthesis program moog and have demonstrated that we are able to model moderate and lower resolution @xmath1-band spectra for stars hotter than t@xmath29 @xmath54 4000 k. we then used this program to investigate such spectra for three cvs : ss cyg , ru peg , and gk per . it is clear that all three cvs in this sample have subsolar carbon abundances . that synthetic spectra with identical parameters simultaneously model data with dramatically different dispersions for each of the objects , and realistic co veiling scenarios fail to reproduce the observed co features , proves that the carbon deficits are real . it is important to note that these results represent the first direct measurements of abundances in the photosphere of the mass donor stars in cvs . while our determinations of t@xmath58 , [ fe / h ] , and [ c / fe ] for these three objects are not overly precise , they have no parallel . there have not been many predictions for the behavior of the abundances in the atmospheres of cv donor stars as a function of age / evolutionary state . marks & sarna ( 1998 ) explored how the photospheric abundances of cno elements in cv secondaries might evolve with time , including the possibilities of pollution by the common envelope phase , or through the accretion of classical novae ejecta . they found that the latter two scenarios were inadequate in producing observable changes , and concluded that only pre - contact evolution could significantly alter the cno abundances and isotopic ratios in cv secondary star photospheres . schenker et al . ( 2002 ) examined how cvs might evolve from supersoft binaries and , if so , could show dramatic changes in cno species . in light of our results , it would be useful to revisit this research with newer generations of binary star evolution codes , such as starevol ( stancliffe & eldridge 2009 ) . it is also obvious that moderate resolution spectroscopy of the brightest cvs covering the _ entire _ @xmath1-band are required to achieve more robust measures of [ fe / h ] , as well as allow for the proper examination of the co bands . if the deficits of carbon arise from the cno cycle , than the isotopic abundances of carbon will be altered . moderate resolution @xmath1-band spectroscopy covering the main @xmath46co features will allow for the confirmation of this inference . both teh and rth were partially supported by a grant from the nsf ( ast-1209451 ) . we acknowledge with thanks the variable star observations from the aavso international database contributed by observers worldwide and used in this research . allard , f. , homeier , d. , & freytag , b. 2011 , aspc , 448 , 91 + alves - brito , a. , melendez , j. , asplund , m. , ramirez , i. , et al . 2010 , a&a , 513 , 35 + baron , e. , chen , b. , & hauschildt , p. h. 2009 , in aip conf . , vol . 1171 , american institute of physics conference series , ed . i. hubeny , j. m. stone , k. macgregor , & k. werner , 148160 + bitner , m. a. , robinson , e. l. , & behr , b. b. 2007 , apj , 662 , 564 + bonifacio , p. , caffau , e. , ludwig , h .- , & steffen , m. 2012 , iaus 282 , 213 + cushing , m. c. , rayner , j. t. , & vacca , w. d. 2005 , apj , 623 , 1115 + cushing , m. , vacca , w. d. , & rayner , j. t. 2004 , pasp , 116 , 362 + dhillon , v. s. , littlefair , s. p. , marsh , t. r. , sarna , m. j. , & boakes , e. h. 2002 , a&a , 393 , 611 + dunford , a. , watson , c. a. , & smith , r. c. 2012 , mnras , 422 , 3444 + duquennoy , a. , tokovinin , a. a. , leinert , ch . , glindemann , et al . 1996 , a&a , 314 , 846 + friend , m. t. , martin , j. s. , connon - smith , r. , & jones , d. h. p. 1990 , mnras , 246 , 654 + goorvitch , d. 1994 , apjs , 95 , 535 + gray , d. f. , the observation and analysis of stellar photospheres ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 374 + gray , r. o. , & corbally , c. j. 1994 , aj , 107 , 742 + grevesse , n. , asplund , m. , & sauval , a. j. 2007 , space sci . , 130 , 105 + gustafsson , b. , bell , r. a. , eriksson , k. , & nordlund , a. 1975 , a&a , 42 , 407 + gustafsson , b. , edvardsson , b. , eriksson , k. , j@xmath59rgensen , u. g. , nordlund , a. , & plez , b. 2008 , a&a , 486 , 951 + hamilton , r. t. 2013 , phd thesis , new mexico state university + hamilton , r. t. , harrison , t. e. tappert , c. , & howell , s. b. 2011 , apj , 728 , 16 + harrison , t. e. , bornak , j. , mcarthur , b. e. , & benedict , g. f. 2013 , apj , 767 , 7 + harrison , t. e. , howell , s. b. , szkody , p. , & cordova , f. a. 2007a , aj , 133 , 162 + harrison , t. e. , campbell , r. k. , howell , s. b. , cordova , f. a. , & schwope , a. d. 2007b , apj , 656 , 444 + harrison , t. e. , osborne , h. l. , & howell , s. b. 2005 , aj , 129 , 2400 + harrison , t. e. , osborne , h. l. , & howell , s. b. 2004 , aj , 127 , 3493 + hauschildt , p. h. , & baron , e. 2010 , a&a , 509 , 36 + hauschildt , p. h. , allard , f. , ferguson , j. , baron , e. , & alexander , d. r. 1999 , apj , 525 , 871 + howell , s. b. , harrison , t. e. , & szkody , p. 2004 , apj , 602 , l49 + hummer , d. g. , & storey , p. j. 1987 , mnras , 224 , 801 + kraft , r. r. 1964 , apj , 139 , 457 + kraft , r. p. 1962 , apj , 135 , 408 + ludwig , h. -g . , caffau , e. , steffen , m. , freytag , b. , et al . 2009 , mmsai , 80 , 711 + magic , z. , collett , r. , hayek , w. , & asplund , m. 2013 , a&a , 560 , 8 + magic , z. , collett , r. , asplund , m. , trampedach , r. , et al . 2013 , a&a , 557 , 26 + marks , p. b. , & sarna , m. j. 1998 , mnras , 301 , 699 + martnez - arniz , r. , maldonado , j. , montes , d. , eiroa , c. , & montesinos , b. 2010 , a&a , 520 , 79 + mszros , sz . , allende prieto , c. , edvardsson , b. , castelli , f. , et al . 2012 , aj , 144 , 120 + morales - reuda , l. , still , m. d. , roche , p. , wood , j. h. , & lockley , j. j. 2002 , mnras , 329 , 597 + politano , m. & weiler , k. p. 2007 , apj , 665 , 663 + reddy , r. r. , & viswanath , r. 1990 , journal of astrophysics and astronomy , 11 , 67 + sbordone , l. , bonifacio , p. , castelli , f. , & kurucz , r. l. 2004 , memorie della societa astronomica italiana supplementi , 5 , 93 + scoville , n. z. , krotkov , r. , & wang , d. 1980 , apj , 240 , 929 + schenker , k. , king , a. r. , kolb , u. , wynn , g. a. , & zhang , z. 2002 , mnras , 337 , 1105 + sion , e. m. , cheng , f. , godon , p. , urban , j. a. , & szkody , p. 2004a , aj , 128 , 1834 + sneden , c. a. 1973 , phd thesis , university of texas + soubiran , c. , le campion , j. -f . , cayrel de strobel , g. , & caillo , a. 2010 , a&a , 515 , 111 + sousa , s. g. , santos , n. c. , israelian , g. , mayor , m. , et al . 2011 , a&a , 533 , 141 + stancliffe , r. j. , & eldridge , j. j. 2009 , mnras , 396 , 1699 + verbunt , f. & zwaan , c. 1981 , a&a , 100 , 7 + wallace , k. , & hinkle , k. 1996 , apjs , 107 , 312 + wallace , k. , livingston , w. , hinkle , k. , & bernath , p. 1996 , apjs , 106 , 165 + warner , b. 1995 , cataclysmic variable stars ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press , 443 + lccccc ss cyg & nirspec & 2004 aug . 28 & 12:31:51 & 4 @xmath60 300 & 0.20 + ru peg & nirspec & `` & 13:17:12 & 4 @xmath60 300 & 0.87 + gk per & nirspec & '' & 14:20:24 & 6 @xmath60 300 & 0.46 + @xmath18 psc & nirspec & `` & 13:45:17 & 8 @xmath60 1 & + @xmath17 eri & nirspec & '' & 15:06:18 & 24 @xmath60 1 & + ss cyg & spex & 2004 aug . 15 & 08:55:17 & 8 @xmath60 180 & 0.40 + ru peg & spex & `` & 10:25:06 & 8 @xmath60 240 & 0.85 + gk per & spex & '' & 13:53:54 & 6 @xmath60 240 & 0.94 + lccccc sun & g2v & 5777 & 4.44 & 0.0 & + arcturus & k0iii & 4313 @xmath40 84 & 1.65 @xmath40 0.30 & @xmath20.54 @xmath40 0.10 & 34/31/31 + @xmath17 eri & k2v & 5088 @xmath40 72 & 4.54 @xmath40 0.16 & @xmath20.09 @xmath40 0.09 & 26/24/24 + @xmath18 psc & g9iii & 4853 @xmath40 45 & 2.59 @xmath40 0.26 & @xmath20.46 @xmath40 0.12 & 11/8/8 + hd145675 & k0v & 5320 @xmath40 114 & 4.45 @xmath40 0.07 & @xmath270.41 @xmath40 0.12 & 18/15/15 + hd10476 & k1v & 5189 @xmath40 53 & 4.46 @xmath40 0.12 & @xmath20.06 @xmath40 0.06 & 16/10/10 + hd3765 & k2v & 5023 @xmath40 66 & 4.53 @xmath40 0.16 & @xmath270.05 @xmath40 0.10 & 7/4/4 + hd219134 & k3v & 4837 @xmath40 138 & 4.51 @xmath40 0.13 & @xmath270.05 @xmath40 0.10 & 15/10/10 + hd45977 & k4v & 4689 @xmath40 174 & 4.30 @xmath40 0.39 & @xmath270.03 @xmath40 0.18 & 1/1/1 + hd36003 & k5v & 4615 @xmath40 29 & 4.35 @xmath40 0.06 & @xmath20.14 @xmath40 0.08 & 3/2/2 + hd201092 & k7v & 3964 @xmath40 175 & 4.50 @xmath40 0.18 & @xmath20.26 @xmath40 0.27 & 10/5/5 + lcccc ss cyg & 4700 @xmath40 250 & 4.50 & @xmath20.25 @xmath61 0.25 & @xmath20.50 @xmath40 0.25 + ru peg & 4700 @xmath40 250 & 4.50 & @xmath270.00 @xmath40 0.25 & @xmath20.75 @xmath61 0.25 + gk per & 5100 @xmath40 250 & 4.00 & @xmath20.125 @xmath40 0.25 & @xmath21.00 @xmath40 0.50 + eri ( black solid line ) . the synthetic model spectrum ( green , dashed line ) generated for this object is overplotted . for the purposes of this paper , the bottom panel will be defined as the second order , while the top panel will be labeled the sixth order . the synthetic spectrum has been rotationally broaded by 4 km s@xmath12 as measured by martinez - arnaiz et al . the s / n ratio ranged from 214 in the sixth order , to 95 in the second order.,title="fig:",width=566 ] m are not especially well matched by the models . the source of this discrepancy is hard to identify . in the top panel we also plot in red the spectrum of a g9v star ( hd161198 ) that we observed with spex during the 2004 august observing run , and the model spectrum generated for the k0v template fits the spectrum of hd161198 quite well.,title="fig:",width=566 ] heat map for the order 6 spectral region for the nirspec spectrum of ss cyg . in this , and all subsequent heat maps , blue denotes @xmath62 @xmath63 0.7 , green is 0.7 @xmath9 @xmath62 @xmath63 0.9 , yellow is 0.9 @xmath9 @xmath62 @xmath63 1.5 , magenta is 1.5 @xmath9 @xmath62 @xmath63 2.5 , and red is @xmath62 @xmath54 2.5 . , title="fig:",width=566 ] heat map for the order 3 spectral region for the nirspec spectrum of ss cyg . for this analysis , a grid of models with the metallicity fixed to [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.25 was constructed , while the carbon abundance was altered over the range @xmath21.0 @xmath9 [ c / fe ] @xmath9 @xmath270.25 . , title="fig:",width=566 ] heat map for the model grid fits to the third order spectrum of ru peg . like that for ss cyg , a grid of single metallicity models ( here with [ fe / h ] = 0.0 ) were generated with only the carbon abundance altered for this analysis.,title="fig:",width=566 ] analysis of the irtf spectral template hd36003 for a large grid of model spectra . the mean of the published values for this star , see table 2 , are t@xmath29 = 4550 k , and [ fe / h ] = @xmath20.17 . the grid has temperature intervals of 100 k , and [ fe / h ] stepped by @xmath400.125.,title="fig:",width=491 ] line of ss cyg . the spectrum below that has had the emissivities of the pfund lines increased by a factor of 10 . the bottom spectrum has the pfund line emissivity increased by a factor of 100.,title="fig:",width=491 ] line , added to the best fitting ( solar abundance ) synthetic spectrum . the bottom spectrum is the result of the identical process , except the velocity broadening was one half that of br @xmath18 profile . the co emission component was normalized so that when it was added to the model spectrum , the depth of the minima in the co features of ss cyg were reproduced . dashed vertical lines indicate the wavelengths of the @xmath13co@xmath65 ( left ) and @xmath13co@xmath66 ( right ) bandheads.,title="fig:",width=642 ]

we use a modified version of moog to generate large grids of synthetic spectra in an attempt to derive quantitative abundances for three cvs ( gk per , ru peg , and ss cyg ) by comparing the models to moderate resolution ( r @xmath0 25,000 ) @xmath1-band spectra obtained with nirspec on keck . for each of the three systems we find solar , or slightly sub - solar values for [ fe / h ] , but significant deficits of carbon : for ss cyg we find [ c / fe ] = @xmath20.50 , for ru peg [ c / fe ] = @xmath20.75 , and for gk per [ c / fe ] = @xmath21.00 . we show that it is possible to use lower resolution ( r @xmath0 2,000 ) spectra to quantify carbon deficits . we examine realistic veiling scenarios and find that emission from h i or co can not reproduce the observations . _ key words : _ infrared : stars stars : cataclysmic variables stars : individual ( ss cyg , ru peg , gk per ) stars : abundances @xmath3 visiting observer , w. m. keck observatory , which is operated as a scientific partnership among the california institute of technology , the university of california , and the national aeronautics and space administration . + @xmath4 visiting astronomer at the infrared telescope facility , which is operated by the university of hawaii under contract from nasa .

1304.2641

let @xmath1 be a simple undirected graph ( without loops ) with vertex set @xmath2 and edge set @xmath3 . a proper @xmath4-coloring @xmath5 of @xmath0 is a mapping @xmath6 such that @xmath7 . a legal or proper @xmath4-coloring can also be defined as a partition of @xmath8 into @xmath4 independent sets or stables @xmath9 such that @xmath10 @xmath11 . the classical graph coloring problem ( gcp ) aims at finding a proper @xmath4-coloring with @xmath4 minimum . this paper is dedicated to the np - hard minimum sum coloring problem ( mscp ) , which is closely related to gcp . the objective of mscp is to find a proper @xmath4-coloring which minimizes the sum of the colors assigned to the vertices . this minimum is the chromatic sum @xmath12 of @xmath0 : @xmath13 , with @xmath14 the set of all proper @xmath4-colorings of @xmath0 ( for all possible @xmath4 values ) and @xmath15 , or @xmath16 equivalently ( where @xmath17 is the cardinality of @xmath18 ) , the `` coloring sum '' of the proper @xmath4-coloring @xmath5 . mscp applications include vlsi design , scheduling , and resource allocation @xcite . considering the theoretical intractability of mscp , a number of heuristic algorithms have been proposed to find suboptimal solutions , such as a parallel genetic algorithm , two greedy heuristics , a tabu search metaheuristic , a hybrid algorithm ( ha ) , an effective heuristic algorithm ( exscol ) , a local search heuristic ( mds5 ) , and a breakout local search ( bls ) . to our knowledge , exscol , ha , mds5 , and bls are the state - of - the - art algorithms in the literature . exscol is based on extracting large disjoint independent sets and is particular effective for handling large graphs ( with at least 500 vertices ) . ha is a hybrid algorithm which combines a genetic algorithm with a surrogate constraint heuristic . mds5 is based on variable neighborhood search and iterated local search . bls combines local search with adaptive perturbation mechanisms to ensure the quality of solutions . this paper introduces a memetic algorithm for the minimum sum coloring problem ( masc ) , which relies on three key components . first , a double - neighborhood tabu search procedure is especially designed for mscp ( dnts ) . dnts is based on a token - ring application of two complementary neighborhoods to explore the search space and a perturbation strategy to escape from local optima . second , a multi - parent crossover operator is used for solution recombination . basically , it tries to transmit large color classes from the parents to the offspring . finally , a population updating mechanism is devised to determine how the offspring solution is inserted into the population . we evaluate the performance of masc on 77 well - known graphs from dimacs and color 2002 - 2004 graph coloring competitions ( 59 of them have been used previously for evaluating sum coloring algorithms ) . the computational results show that masc can frequently match the best known results in the literature for most of the 59 cases . in particular , it improves the previous best solution for 17 graphs for which an upper bound is known . for the additional 18 new graphs , we report computational results for the first time . the paper is organized as follows . next section describes the general framework and the components of our masc memetic algorithm , including the population initialization , the crossover operator and the double - neighborhood tabu search procedure . detailed computational results and comparisons with five state - of - the - art algorithms are presented in section [ sec_results ] . before concluding , section [ sec_analysis_masc ] investigates and analyzes two key issues of the proposed memetic algorithm a memetic algorithm is a population - based approach where the traditional mutation operator is replaced by a local search procedure . memetic algorithms are among the most powerful paradigms for solving np - hard combinatorial optimization problems . in particular , they have been successfully applied to the tightly related gcp . our masc algorithm is summarized in algorithm [ algo_masc ] . after population initialization , masc repeats a series of generations ( limited to @xmath19 ) to explore the search space which is defined by the set of all proper @xmath4-colorings ( @xmath4 is not a fixed value , section [ search space ] ) . at each generation , two or more parents are selected at random ( line 6 ) and used by the dedicated crossover operator to generate an offspring solution ( line 7 , section [ subsec_sol_crossover_operator ] ) . the offspring solution is then improved by a double neighborhood tabu search ( line 8 , section [ subsec_sol_ts ] ) . if the improved offspring has a better sum of colors , it is then used to update the current best solution found so far ( lines 9 - 10 ) . finally , the population updating criterion decides whether the improved offspring will replace one existing individual of the population or not ( line 12 , section [ subsec_sol_population_update ] ) . * input * : a graph @xmath0 * output * : the minimum sum coloring @xmath20 found and its objectif @xmath21 population_initialization(@xmath22 ) / * population @xmath23 has @xmath24 solutions , sect . [ subsec_sol_initial_population ] * / @xmath25 / * @xmath26 records the best objective value found so far * / @xmath27 / * select 2 or more parents at random for crossover * / @xmath28 / * crossover to get an offspring solution , sect . [ subsec_sol_crossover_operator ] * / @xmath29 / * improve @xmath30 with the dnts procedure , sect . [ subsec_sol_ts]*/ @xmath31 population_updating(@xmath32 ) / * sect . [ subsec_sol_population_update ] * / @xmath33 the search space explored by masc is the set @xmath14 of all _ proper _ @xmath4-colorings of @xmath0 ( @xmath4 is not fixed ) . for a given proper @xmath4-coloring @xmath5 , its quality is directly assessed by the sum of colors @xmath34 . our algorithm begins with a population @xmath23 of @xmath24 feasible colorings . this population can be obtained by any graph coloring algorithm that is able to generate different proper colorings for a graph . in our case , we employ the well - known tabucol , more precisely its improved version introduced in . for a given graph @xmath0 , tabucol tries to find a proper @xmath4-coloring with @xmath4 as small as possible . given the stochastic nature of tabucol , we run it multiple times to obtain different @xmath4-colorings ( @xmath4 may take different values ) . each resulting @xmath4-coloring is inserted into @xmath23 if it is not already present ( discarded otherwise ) . this process is repeated until @xmath23 is filled with @xmath24 different @xmath4-colorings . the crossover operator is an important component in a population - based algorithm . it is used to generate one or more new offspring individuals to discover new promising search areas . masc uses a multi - parent crossover operator , called mgpx , which is similar to the one introduced in as a variant of the well - known gpx crossover first proposed in for gcp ( restricted to two parents ) . mgpx generates only one offspring solution @xmath30 from @xmath35 parents randomly chosen from @xmath23 , where @xmath35 varies from 2 to 4 according to @xmath36 and the best @xmath4-coloring found for gcp ( see eq . [ eqnbparents ] ) . motivations for these @xmath35 values can be found in . @xmath37 * input * : a set @xmath38 of @xmath35 parents randomly chosen from @xmath23 * output * : an offspring @xmath30 @xmath39 / * counts the number of colored vertices in @xmath30 * / @xmath40 / * counts the number of colors used in @xmath30 * / @xmath41 / * to identify which parents are forbidden for color @xmath42 * / @xmath43 @xmath44 / * set of parents allowed for color @xmath42 * / let @xmath45 be a color class of maximum cardinality @xmath46 @xmath47 @xmath48 remove @xmath49 from @xmath50 @xmath51 / * forbid using @xmath52 for a few steps * / @xmath30 mgpx is summarized in algorithm [ algomgpx ] . it builds the color classes of the @xmath30 offspring one by one , transmitting as many vertices as possible from the parents at each step ( for quality purpose ) ( lines 7 - 14 ) . once a parent has been used for transmitting an entire color class to @xmath30 , the parent is not considered for a few steps with the purpose of varying the origins of the color classes of @xmath30 ( line 15 ) . this strategy avoids transmitting always from the same parent and introduces some diversity in @xmath30 . note that the offspring solution is always a proper @xmath4 coloring while the number of colors used by the offspring can be higher than those of the considered parents . local optimization is another important element within a memetic algorithm . in our case , its role is to improve as far as possible the quality ( i.e. , the sum of colors ) of a given solution returned by the mgpx crossover operator . this is achieved by a double - neighborhood tabu search ( dnts ) procedure specifically designed for mscp ( see algorithm [ algo_tabu ] ) . dnts uses two different and complementary neighborhoods @xmath53 and @xmath54 which are applied in a token - ring way @xcite to find good local optima ( intensification ) ( lines 2 - 14 ) . more precisely , we start our search with one neighborhood ( lines 6 - 9 ) and when the search ends with its best local optimum , we switch to the other neighborhood to continue the search while using the last local optimum as the starting point ( lines 10 - 13 ) . when this second search terminates , we switch again to the first neighborhood and so on . dnts continues the exploration of each neighborhood @xmath55 ( @xmath56 ) until @xmath57 ( @xmath56 ) consecutive iterations fail to update the best solution found . this neighborhood - based intensification phase terminates if the best local optimum is not updated for @xmath58 consecutive iterations ( line 14 ) . at this point , we enter into a diversification phase by triggering a perturbation to escape from the local optimum ( line 15 , section [ subsec_sol_perturbation_mechanism ] ) . the dnts procedure stops when a maximum number of iterations @xmath59 is met . we explain below the two neighborhoods , the tabu list management and the perturbation mechanism . * input * : graph @xmath0 , a @xmath4-coloring @xmath5 * output * : the best improved @xmath4-coloring @xmath60 @xmath5 @xmath61 ts(@xmath62 ) / * tabu search with neighborhood @xmath53 , sect . [ sectn2 ] * / @xmath63 @xmath5 @xmath61 ts(@xmath64 ) / * tabu search with neighborhood @xmath54 , sect . [ subsec_sol_one_move_tabu ] * / @xmath60 @xmath65 perturbation(@xmath20 ) / * search is stagnating , generate a new starting solution by perturbing the best @xmath4-coloring found so far , sect . [ subsec_sol_perturbation_mechanism ] * / the first neighborhood @xmath53 can be described by the operator @xmath66 . given a proper @xmath4-coloring @xmath67 , operator @xmath68 swaps some vertices of a color class @xmath69 against some connected vertices of another color class @xmath70 . formally , let @xmath71 be the set of all connected components of more than one vertex in the subgraph of @xmath0 induced by color classes @xmath69 and @xmath70 in a proper @xmath4-coloring @xmath5 . in figure [ fig_chain_swap ] ( left ) for instance , @xmath71 is composed of two graphs ( say @xmath72 and @xmath73 ) : @xmath72 is the subgraph induced by @xmath74 and @xmath73 is induced by @xmath75 . [ cols="^,^ " , ] in this paper , we presented a memetic algorithm ( masc ) to deal with the minimum sum coloring problem ( mscp ) . the proposed algorithm employs an effective tabu search procedure with a combination of two neighborhoods , a multi - parent crossover operator and a population updating mechanism to balance intensification and diversification . we assessed the performance of masc on 77 well - known graphs from the dimacs and color 2002 - 2004competitions . masc can improve 17 best known upper bounds including 11 large and very hard graphs with at least 500 vertices while equaling 30 previous best results . we also report upper bounds for the 18 remaining graphs for the first time . compared with five recent and effective algorithms which cover the best known results for the tested instances , our masc algorithm remains quite competitive . furthermore , we investigated two important components of the proposed algorithm . the experiments demonstrate the relevance of the multi - parent crossover operator and the combined neighborhood for the overall performance of masc . the work is partially supported by the radapop ( 2009 - 2013 ) and ligero projects ( 2009 - 2013 ) from the region of pays de la loire ( france ) . support for yan jin from the china scholarship council is also acknowledged . u. benlic , j .- k . hao , a study of breakout local search for the minimum sum coloring problem , in : l. bui , y. ong , n. hoai , h. ishibuchi , p. suganthan ( eds . ) , simulated evolution and learning , vol . 7673 of lecture notes in computer science , springer , berlin / heidelberg , germany , 2012 , pp . 128137 . hamiez , j .- k . hao , scatter search for graph coloring , in : p. collet , e. lutton , m. schoenauer , c. fonlupt , j .- k . hao ( eds . ) , artificial evolution , vol . 2310 of lecture notes in computer science , springer , berlin / heidelberg , germany , 2002 , pp . 168179 . a. helmar , m. chiarandini , a local search heuristic for chromatic sum , in : l. di gaspero , a. schaerf , t. sttzle ( eds . ) , proceedings of the 9th metaheuristics international conference , 2011 , pp . 161170 . z. kokosiski , k. kwarciany , on sum coloring of graphs with parallel genetic algorithms , in : b. beliczynski , a. dzielinski , m. iwanowski , b. ribeiro ( eds . ) , adaptive and natural computing algorithms , vol . 4431 of lecture notes in computer science , springer , berlin / heidelberg , germany , 2007 , pp . 211219 . p. moscato , c. cotta , a gentle introduction to memetic algorithms , in : f. glover , g. kochenberger ( eds . ) , handbook of metaheuristics , vol . 57 of international series in operations research and management science , chap . 5 , kluwer academic publishers , dordrecht , the nederlands , 2003 , pp . 105144 . d. porumbel , j .- k . hao , p. kuntz , an evolutionary approach with diversity guarantee and well - informed grouping recombination for graph coloring , computers & operations research 37 ( 10 ) ( 2010 ) 18221832 .

given an undirected graph @xmath0 , the minimum sum coloring problem ( mscp ) is to find a legal assignment of colors ( represented by natural numbers ) to each vertex of @xmath0 such that the total sum of the colors assigned to the vertices is minimized . this paper presents a memetic algorithm for mscp based on a tabu search procedure with two neighborhoods and a multi - parent crossover operator . experiments on a set of 77 well - known dimacs and color 2002 - 2004 benchmark instances show that the proposed algorithm achieves highly competitive results in comparison with five state - of - the - art algorithms . in particular , the proposed algorithm can improve the best known results for 17 instances . we also provide upper bounds for 18 additional instances for the first time . _ keywords _ : sum coloring , memetic algorithm , heuristics , combinatorial optimization , ,

astro-ph0001232

it is now clear that a classification of pne based on their morphology ( balick 1987 ; schwarz , corradi , & stanghellini 1993 ; manchado et al . 1996 ) also corresponds to a real physical classification of the nebulae and of their stellar progenitors . correlations between morphology and other properties of the nebulae / stars were recognized quite a long time ago ( cf . greig 1972 ; peimbert & torres - peimbert 1983 ; zuckerman & gatley 1988 ) , and confirmed recently by the analysis of extensive ( and thus statistically more robust ) , homogeneous , and high - quality image atlases ( balick 1987 ; schwarz , corradi , & melnick 1992 ; manchado et al . 1996 ; gorny et al . 1999 ) . one of the most extensive analyses is that of corradi & schwarz ( 1995 , hereafter cs95 ) , who considered 400 pne with high - quality optical images and studied in detail the correlation of the morphological properties with several other physical properties , giving particular emphasis to the comparison between the elliptical ( @xmath2 ) and bipolar ( @xmath0 ) pne . i stress once more the quite strict definition of according to the classification of schwarz et al . ( 1993 ) : these are elongated , axially symmetric pne distinguished by an `` equatorial '' waist from which two faint , extended lobes depart . cs95 found that have : + _ a ) _ a scale height on the galactic plane of 130 pc compared to the value of 320 pc for the @xmath2 objects and of 260 pc for the global sample of galactic disk pne ; + _ b ) _ smaller deviations than the other morphological types from pure circular galactic rotation ; + _ c ) _ the hottest central stars among pne ; + _ d ) _ chemical overabundances of helium and nitrogen ; + _ e ) _ outflow velocities up to an order of magnitude greater than the typical expansion velocities of pne ; + _ f ) _ giant dimensions ; + _ g ) _ different `` evolutionary '' tracks in the two - color iras diagram . the above properties especially _ a , b , c , d_indicate that are produced by more massive progenitors than the other morphological classes . these results were later confirmed by other authors ( e.g. gorny , stasinska , & tylenda 1997 ; see also manchado , this volume ) . in this contribution , i will add some comments to the discussion of those properties which appear to be most important for understanding the formation of the different morphological classes i then discuss whether these put real constraints on the models and present some other recent results on . as mentioned above , the conclusion that have more massive progenitors than is consistent with several properties of the nebulae and their central stars . but the only property which allows us quantitatively to derive mass limits for the progenitors of the different morphological classes is the distribution of the nebulae along the vertical ( @xmath4 ) direction of the galactic disk . the method is to compare the @xmath4-distribution of pne with that of main - sequence stars in the galaxy . to do this , an exponential - in-@xmath4 distribution function is usually assumed , @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the scale height . note that this distribution function has the convenient property that @xmath7@xmath8@xmath9@xmath10 , where , @xmath11 , and @xmath12@xmath9@xmath13 are the mean , the standard deviation and the median , respectively , so that one would be tempted to derive @xmath6 by simply measuring . the exponential function which a scale height independent from the galactocentric distance appears to be a good representation for the distribution of light ( star volume density ) in spiral galaxies ( wainscoat et al . 1992 ) . the @xmath4-distribution of 35 and 119 in cs95 is shown in figure 1 . the histograms are indeed fairly well fitted by exponential distributions , with @xmath6 = 130 pc and @xmath6 = 320 pc for the @xmath0 and @xmath2 types , respectively . cs95 also computed @xmath6 = 260 pc for the whole sample of galactic disk pne . these figures should be compared to the scale heights of main - sequence stars in the galaxy , which as shown in fig . 2 are basically divided into two regimes : @xmath6 around 100 pc for spectral types earlier than f5 , and around 300 pc for types later than f8 . the increase of @xmath6 with spectral type is thought to be an age effect , caused by the so - called `` dynamical heating '' of the disk ( wielen et al . 1984 ) , which would produce a continuous growth of the @xmath4-velocity dispersion of stars . from fig . 2 , it is clear that are associated with the low @xmath6 regime , while with the high @xmath6 one . this corresponds to limits of @xmath14 for the initial mass of the progenitors of , and @xmath15 for the . these figures are only slightly different from those quoted by cs95 , being slightly more conservative according to the discussion below of the uncertainties involved in their derivation . in deriving mass limits for the progenitors of the different morphological classes from the galactic @xmath4 distribution , one should consider the following points : * the main limitation in this kind of analysis is the uncertainty in the distances of individual pne . considering that are a very peculiar class of nebulae , it would not be surprising if their distances obtained via the usual statistical methods were affected by systematic errors . it would be sufficient that their distances were underestimated by a factor of two to raise serious doubts about the existence of a real difference in their galactic scale height with respect to the whole sample of pne . to remove this doubt , i have estimated _ kinematical _ distances for the sample of in cs95 . as is widely known , the method consists in assuming that the objects participate in the general circular rotation around the galactic center . their distances are then estimated by comparing their apparent radial velocities with those expected for circular orbits as a function of heliocentric distance and galactic longitude . errors in the distances provided by this method are large , but it remains the only method which , at present , can be applied to many , and which is free from risk of systematic errors . a comparison of the kinematical distances with those adopted by cs95 for 30 is plotted in figure 3 . apart from an obvious large dispersion of points , from this plot we can exclude the possibility that the distances of were underestimated by cs95 by a factor of two or more , since in that case they would preferentially lie close to the 2:1 relation ( dashed line ) , while most of them are instead found close to the 1:1 relation ( solid line ) . in fact , computing the scale height of the 30 using the kinematical distances , yields @xmath16150 pc . thus this exercise fully confirms the results of cs95 . * when determining the scale height of a class of objects , one has to be careful with the sample size . the number of objects should be large enough to check whether the exponential model distribution is a fair representation of the observed one , and that it is sufficiently well sampled . the derivation of @xmath6 directly from for small samples should also be avoided . * as discussed above , main - sequence stars in the galaxy are basically divided into `` early - type '' stars with @xmath16100 pc and `` late - type '' objects with @xmath16300 pc , the rapid transition to larger scale heights occurring between spectral classes f0 and g5 . considering the uncertainties involved in the derivation of the scale height for pne , and in particular the present poor knowledge of distances , it is therefore not possible to derive precise mass values for their progenitors . note also that the reference samples of stars are a mixture of main - sequence objects of different ages ( recently born or on the point of leaving the main sequence ) while the pne are clearly all very evolved objects . a population of pne is then expected to lie at higher @xmath4 than a ( younger ) random mixture of its main - sequence progenitors , provided that the main - sequence lifetime is sufficiently long to allow the dynamical heating of the disk to act . this introduces an additional uncertainty into the analysis . for these reasons , it is not advisable to derive more accurate masses for pn progenitors than those which result from dividing them in the above two scale height regimes . taking a mass value in the middle of the transition from low to high scale heights for main - sequence stars , say 1.3 corresponding to spectral types f5-f8 , the only robust conclusion is therefore that the progenitors of have initial masses greater than this value , while those of have smaller ones . although the difference in progenitor masses of @xmath0 and @xmath2 pne is a very important constraint that must be taken into account when explaining their formation , at present it does not appear to be able to discriminate as to whether these morphological classes are produced by single or binary systems , which is one of the main topics of this conference . the fact that have higher - mass progenitors is the basic starting point for _ single _ star theories . garca - segura et al . ( 1999 ) conjecture that , if the initial mass is larger than @xmath17 ( note that this limit coincides with that derived in the previous section for ) , stars might rotate on the agb with a velocity close to the critical one , causing a markedly aspherical mass deposition . this is because their cores would not have been spun down onto the main sequence ( as occurs for lower - mass stars ) , evolve decoupled from the envelope , and remain fast rotators until angular momentum is redistributed on the agb , spinning up the outer layers . rotation would force the envelope ejection in the equatorial plane of the agb star , providing the correct mass - loss geometry needed to form a bipolar pn . but _ binary _ models also have an explanation for the higher progenitor masses of . in fact , according to soker ( 1998 ) a low - mass star in a binary system would interact strongly with the companion already on the rgb ( the ratio of the stellar radii during the agb and the rgb , @xmath18/@xmath19 , is small for low - mass stars ) , causing an enhanced mass - loss which would leave a low - mass and small agb envelope . then the interaction with the companion on the agb would be weak preventing the formation of a @xmath0 pn . on the other hand , higher - mass stars , for which @xmath18@xmath20@xmath19 , would mainly interact on the agb , and because of this interaction would be able to produce a @xmath0 pn . in addition , it should be mentioned that mellema ( 1997 ) showed that in low - mass stars the post - agb evolution is slow enough for the ionization front to have time to smooth out the density contrast between the equatorial plane and the polar directions , preventing the formation of a bipolar pn even if the agb mass - loss geometry were the favorable one . in higher - mass stars , the post - agb evolution is so fast that the density distribution is unchanged . it should be calculated , however , whether this conclusion still holds for clumpy distributions of gas . the association of with the chemical type i , i.e. with he- and/or n - rich objects , has been known since peimbert s 1978 paper . cs95 discussed the amount of data available in the literature in 1995 , and more recently their results were refined by means of new observations . corradi et al . ( 1997b ) and perinotto & corradi ( 1998 ) made a detailed spatially resolved study of the abundances of a sample of 15 with the following main results : * within the errors , the nebulae are _ chemically homogeneous _ in he , o , n ; * ne , ar , and s abundances have systematic increases toward the outer regions of the nebulae . this might be due to errors inherent to the use of the standard _ icf _ method ( alexander & balick 1997 ) ; * it is confirmed that are overabundant in he and n ( type i ) with respect to elliptical pne , as indicated in table 1 . this is ascribed to efficient second and third dredge - up and burning at the base of the convective envelope in the most massive progenitors ; + lllll + & he / h & o / h@xmath21 & n / o & n / h@xmath21 + + & 0.15 ( 27 ) & 3.97 ( 27 ) & 1.24 ( 28 ) & 4.17 ( 27 ) + & 0.11 ( 66 ) & 5.03 ( 68 ) & 0.40 ( 61 ) & 2.10 ( 60 ) + sun & 0.10 & 8.51 & 0.12 & 1.02 + * the highest he overabundances displayed by some ( e.g. m 3 - 2 , he 2 - 111 , and ngc 6537 ) can not by reproduced by any current model of agb evolution ; * oxygen depletion is suggested for the nebulae with the highest n / o abundances , indicating that an efficient on cycle process has occurred in their progenitors . let s now turn our attention to `` massive '' stars . soker ( 1998 ) has argued that 3040% of massive stars ( m@xmath22 ) have companions in the right separation range to form bipolar ( @xmath0 ) pne . the other 6070% would form elliptical ( @xmath2 ) nebulae . if evolution in a binary system do not affect the chemical enrichment of the stars , then one expects to find , at any abundance interval in the range for massive pne progenitors , twice as many @xmath2 as @xmath0 pne ( assuming the same nebular life time ) . in our sample , after correcting for sample size effects , for large he and n abundances we have instead the reverse situation , with more @xmath0 than @xmath2 pne . this raises the question of where all the non - bipolar pne with large he and n abundances are ( the expected progeny of single massive stars ) ? an explanation within the binary scenario would require _ extra enrichment _ caused by the binary interaction . one hint in this sense is the fact that the highest he abundances of are not reproduced by any current model for single stars . there were some strong suggestions in the past that the symmetry axis of aspherical pne were not oriented randomly within the galaxy . in particular , melnick & harwit ( 1975 ) and recently phillips ( 1997 ) have claimed that axially symmetrical pne have their axes preferentially inclined at low angles to the galactic plane . such a property would put very interesting constraints on the mechanisms producing the asphericity in pne . in other classes of objects , as in sn remnants ( gaensler 1998 ) and nebulae ejected by massive stars ( hutsemekers 1999 ) , the nebular orientation , for instance , was found to be clearly related to the galactic magnetic field . based on a larger and more homogeneous sample , and on a more rigorous statistical analysis than in the previous studies , corradi et al . ( 1997a ) showed instead that there is no strong evidence for such an alignment , at least partially removing interest to the issue . finally , i conclude with a brief comment on the observations of binary stars in pne and their relation with . a review of very close binaries , with periods of a few hours to a few days , is presented by h. bond in this volume . these objects are expected to have undergone a common envelope phase during the agb evolution of the star which has now ejected its pn . although most pne with a close binary nucleus are aspherical , only a relatively small fraction of them ( some 25% ) has a truly bipolar nebula . in my opinion , the situation looks more promising for wider interacting binaries which avoid the common envelope phase , as also supported by soker ( 1997 ) . in this respect , known detached binaries like symbiotic stars give a practical demonstration of the ability of these systems to form bipolar nebulae , rings and jets . in symbiotic stars containing a mira , all nebulae are markedly aspherical , and about a half are bipolar / ring . this suggests that the kind of interactions occurring in these systems ( formation of collimating accretion / excretion disks , production of collimated fast winds from the hot components ) might provide the explanation of the collimation of the outflows in . a thorough discussion of the nebulae around symbiotic stars and of their similarities with can be found in the contributions of corradi et al . and mikolajewska ( this volume ) , as well as in corradi et al . ( 1999a , 1999b ) .

some of the correlations between morphological and other physical properties of planetary nebulae ( pne ) are reviewed . in particular , the finding that bipolar ( @xmath0 ) pne have more massive progenitors than the other morphological classes is discussed in detail . earlier results are confirmed ; including all the various sources of uncertainty , the galactic distribution of objects indicate that are formed by stars with initial masses @xmath1 while elliptical ( @xmath2 ) pne by progenitors with masses @xmath3 . recent results for the chemical abundances of @xmath0 and @xmath2 pne and their orientation within the galaxy are also presented . finally , the key role in the discussion of the formation of played by detached binary systems such as symbiotic stars is briefly discussed . # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in

hep-lat9608123

all production runs in full qcd use molecular dynamics based algorithms . for integer multiples of four staggered or two wilson fermions one has the exact hybrid monte carlo ( hmc ) , while for other multiples there is the very similar hybrid molecular dynamics algorithm . we examine here how effective the hmc is in decorrelating the topology for both full qcd with four staggered fermions and pure @xmath0 gauge theory . the latter we compare with an over - relaxed heat - bath algorithm . although the only hmc algorithm with four staggered fermions has been investigated , the conclusions drawn are valid for any algorithm based on molecular dynamics . an ensemble containing the correct topology is crucial for the @xmath1 mass , for example . it can also become relevant for other quantities , for example the proton mass , at some level of accuracy . one criterion that the ensemble must fulfill is that the global topological charge averages to zero ; we find that this is not so for a long run at our smallest quark mass . other simulations involving the topology in the presence of fermions have been presented in the literature @xcite , where the existence of long range correlations have been reported . we have a large set of configurations generated with the hmc , originally prepared with the aim of studying the spin of the proton @xcite . as the operator involves the topology , the longest topological auto - correlation length determines the number of independent configurations . this is the auto - correlation of the global topological charge on cooled @xcite configurations . the conclusions drawn here require only that our method sees the most slowly updated modes associated with the ` topological ' content of the lattice configurations . for this purpose any reasonable definition of the global topological charge that is not affected by noise is adequate ; we employed the field theoretic definition of @xmath2 , measured on cooled configurations . we use the @xmath3 algorithm of reference @xcite , with a @xmath4 lattice at a coupling @xmath5 for full qcd , and a @xmath6 lattice at @xmath7 for pure su(3 ) . the two relevant units for comparing the auto - correlations are then fictitious molecular dynamics time in units of @xmath8 , and wall clock time . let us begin with the results for quark mass @xmath9 . this yields a pion to rho mass ratio of @xmath10 @xcite , so we are still quite far from the physical value . the lattice spacing is @xmath11fm ( from @xmath12 ) , which gives a lattice volume of @xmath13 . we performed a rather long simulation , with a total length after thermalisation of @xmath14 in units of fictitious time . further details may be found in @xcite . [ fig1 ] shows the time history of the topological charge , where it is clear that the hmc is unable to change the global topological modes efficiently , leading to very long auto - correlations . the value of the topological charge got stuck at around @xmath15 , and its value averaged over all configurations generated so far is decidedly non - zero : @xmath16 . a very rough estimate of the integrated auto - correlation time @xmath17 from a blocking analysis of the data gives @xmath18 in units of molecular dynamics time . the simulations were performed on the 25 gflops ape tower , with around @xmath19 efficiency . on this machine @xmath20 corresponds to about three days of computer time , a considerable amount . notice that most simulations at comparable values of @xmath21 and @xmath22 presented in the literature have @xmath23 . to further investigate the behaviour of the hmc , we have performed simulations with larger quark masses , @xmath24 and @xmath25 , and in the quenched case , which represents the large quark mass limit of full qcd . quenched simulations were performed at @xmath26 , and here hmc has been compared with the over - relaxed heat - bath . one cycle of this algorithm consists of 5 microcanonical updates followed by a pseudo - heat - bath update . cccccc & & & & & + 5.35 & 0.010 & 0.3 & @xmath27 200 & @xmath27 72 & 1.2 + 5.35 & 0.035 & 0.3 & 15 & 2 & 2.5 + 5.35 & 0.05 & 0.3 & 6 & 0.3 & 2.2 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 0.3 & 320 & 0.9 & 1.7 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 0.6 & 140 & 0.4 & 1.7 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 0.16 & 312 & 0.67 & 2.8 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 0.32 & 180 & 0.34 & 1.9 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 0.64 & 72 & 0.12 & 2.4 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 0.96 & 43 & 0.08 & 4.1(27s ) + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 1.50 & 69 & 0.12 & 4.9 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & 2.00 & 83 & 0.15 & 5.6 + 6.00 & @xmath28 & & 5.7 & 0.0014 & 0.9(0.9s ) + in table [ tab : param ] we give the parameters used in our simulations and the estimates of the integrated auto - correlation time of the topological charge @xmath29 . the estimates should be regarded as a lower limit for @xmath9 , and with a possible uncertainty of 10 - 20% for all other values . there are three major results that have emerged from this work : 1 . in hmc simulations the integrated auto - correlation time of the global topological charge decreases as the length of the trajectory increases . if expressed in terms of computer time , then trajectories longer than one unit in molecular dynamics time seem to be slower . 2 . for pure gauge theory at @xmath26 the hmc algorithm is about two orders of magnitude slower in decorrelating @xmath2 than the local over - relaxed algorithm . for our ` best ' set of hmc parameters we find that the plaquette decorrelates about 30 times more slowly , which agrees with the results of @xcite . the plaquette auto - correlation time in units of @xmath8 is constant , though . however , @xmath2 decorrelates 60 times slower with the hmc than with the heat - bath over - relaxed for our ` best ' parameters . furthermore the auto - correlation of @xmath2 is far more sensitive to the choice of parameters than the plaquette . 3 . the auto - correlation time @xmath29 rapidly increases with decreasing quark mass , in terms of both cpu time and molecular dynamics time . the auto - correlation time for the plaquette , on the other hand , remains similar in units of @xmath8 . the time required appears to increase faster than the @xmath30 expected @xcite if one uses @xmath31 as the relevant physical quantity , a factor @xmath32 from the matrix inversion , and another @xmath33 from the change in step size and acceptance rate . note that in our rather long hmc simulation at @xmath9 ( @xmath34 ) the ensemble is not yet sufficient to determine the auto - correlation at all well ; we can not even estimate how long the run should have been to get @xmath35 . it may also be possible to improve the performance of the hmc algorithm at small masses via the use of simulated tempering @xcite . in simulated tempering , usually the coupling becomes a dynamical parameter in the simulation . we are currently investigating promoting the quark mass to a dynamical variable in the simulation . this helps in decorrelating the topological charge both because there are more fluctuations when the mass is large , and because the hmc algorithm itself is faster for larger masses . in simulated tempering one has an ordered set of masses , chosen such that the action histogram of adjacent masses has some overlap . the mass can then change to an adjacent mass if the configuration lies in this overlapping region , ie . , if the configuration is a representative member of the probability distribution for each of the masses . we are currently investigating simulations using masses between 0.01 and 0.035 . from these preliminary investigations we estimate that the improvements will more than compensate the additional overhead if the masses used range between @xmath36 and 0.02 . finally , we mention that algorithms that are not based on equations of motion , ( for example , lscher s @xcite multi - boson algorithm ) , may perform better with respect to the topological modes than the hmc algorithm . this is also being examined . in conclusion we have shown that the hmc algorithm has serious problems decorrelating global topogical modes , more serious than those associated with commonly studied quantities . for full qcd the algorithm appears to slow down much more rapidly than previously expected . we stress again that this warning must be seriously considered when simulating full qcd . it is especially important when studying quantities related to the topology , but may be less relevant in the calculation of the mass spectrum ( with the exception of , for example , the @xmath1 mass ) , since an effective decoupling from the topological modes is expected . note also that this slowing down is independent of both the number of fermions and type of fermion simulated , as the underlying dynamics of the algorithm are the same as the cases studied here .

we investigate the performance of the hybrid monte carlo algorithm in updating non - trivial global topological structures . we find that the hybrid monte carlo algorithm has serious problems decorrelating the global topological charge . this represents a warning which must be seriously considered when simulating full qcd , regardless of the number and type of fermions , with this or any similar algorithm . simulated tempering is examined as a means of accelerating the decorrelation .

0906.3411

+ there are three firmly established @xmath5gev emitting binaries ; psrb1259@xmath663 @xcite , ls5039 @xcite and lsi+61303 @xcite , all systems composed of a compact object and a high - mass star . ls5039 harbours an o6.5v type star in a 3.9 day orbit , the massive star in the other systems is of be type . psrb1259@xmath663 is the only one of these systems in which the nature of the compact companion ( a 48 ms period radio pulsar in a 3.4 year orbit around the star ) has been identified . all three systems display similarities in their radio to tev @xmath0-ray spectral energy distributions ( seds ) including a hard x - ray spectrum and a softer tev spectrum , radio emission above 1ghz and variability in all bands . there is also evidence for a single tev flare from the luminous x - ray binary cygnus x-1 @xcite , a system of a black hole and an o9.7 iab star in a 5.6 day circular orbit . the point - like tev source hessj0632 + 057 @xcite , has been suggested as a new member of this class of objects . this suggestion was based on associations with the massive star mwc148 ( hd259440 ) and the unidentified rosat and egret sources 1rxsj063258.3 + 054857 and 3egj0634 + 0521 , and would imply that mwc148 has a hidden compact companion . x - ray observations of this source with xmm - newton in 2007 revealed a point - like , hard spectrum ( @xmath7@xmath41.26 ) , x - ray source at the position of mwc148 @xcite . significant variability was detected on timescales of a few hours . the association of this x - ray source with the tev source ( and both sources with mwc148 ) seems highly likely and the spectral properties of the x - ray/@xmath0-ray source are consistent with the known @xmath0-ray binaries . very recently the veritas collaboration have published flux upper limits which imply variability in the tev emission of this object @xcite . historical studies of mwc148 have determined the star to be of spectral type b0pe @xcite . be stars are classified by the presence of balmer emission lines . mwc148 was rejected as a herbig aebe star due to a non - detection during the iras survey @xcite and thus is believed to represent one of the ` classical ' be stars . these stars are fast rotators , thought to be spinning at 50 - 90% of their critical velocity ( note @xcite give @xmath8sin@xmath9 of mwc148 to be 430kms@xmath10 ) with a large stellar wind and a high mass loss rate . the flattening of the circumstellar envelope produces a global polarisation of the envelope of a few percent . the most recent measured values of the polarisation of mwc148 are 3 - 4% @xcite . the star also exhibits a significant infrared excess ( see 2mass , * ? ? ? * ) consistent with the existence of an extended envelope . the source lies between the monoceros loop supernova remnant and the star forming regions of the rosetta nebula ( @xmath111.4kpc ) . a compatible distance estimate of @xmath41.5kpc is calculated using the apparent visual magnitude of mwc148 , @xmath12 = 9.1 @xcite , as described in @xcite . no variability was detected from the star during the asas-3 optical survey @xcite . bp stars are defined by their unusual surface abundances and strong ( up to kg , see e.g. * ? ? ? * ) surface magnetic fields @xcite . the confinement of the stellar wind in these strong fields is thought to lead to strong shock heating and variable x - ray emission . @xcite speculate that such a process may be capable of accelerating particles up to tev energies . all of the known binaries have been detected at radio wavelengths at flux levels of 10100mjy ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . the radio spectra of ls5039 and lsi+61303 have spectral indices close to @xmath2 = 0.5 ( where @xmath13 ) . * in lsi+61303 the radio flux is modulated with the orbital period , whereas in ls5039 , the radio emission ( unlike the x - ray and tev emission ) is not ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . * no targeted radio observations of mwc148 had previously been conducted . here we present new radio observations resulting in a detection of the system with both the vla and the gmrt . hessj0632 + 057 was observed for 6 hours at 5ghz with the very large array ( vla ) in d - configuration ( angular resolution @xmath414@xmath14 ) during july september 2008 ( program as944 ) . the time was divided into three 2hour observations separated by @xmath31 month . the data were calibrated using the nrao aips ( astronomical image processing system ; * ? ? ? * ) software package and then loaded into _ _ difmap__@xcite for additional editing and imaging . the flux density scale was set using a scan of 3c147 at the end of each observation and the phase was monitored with scans of the calibration source 0632 + 103 . the off - source rms in each observation ( 0.03 0.04mjy / beam ) was estimated from large sourceless boxes , far from the phase centre and was found to be close to the thermal noise limit for a 2 hour observation of @xmath40.03mjy / beam . five unresolved sources were found above 5@xmath15 within the 9@xmath16 primary beam radius of the best fit position of hessj0632 + 057 . * one of these sources ( hereafter source # 3 ) is located at 06@xmath1732@xmath1859.24@xmath19 @xmath20 0.3@xmath14 , + 05@xmath214800.8 @xmath20 0.3@xmath14 , consistent with the position of mwc148 . this position was derived from a two - dimensional gaussian fit to the brightest single vla observation . the error on this measurement is statistical only . * emission is detected from this source in all three observations and the measured flux varies significantly from observation to observation : from @xmath22mjy to @xmath23mjy ( @xmath24/dof for a constant fit = 19.4/2 , chance probability = 6.1@xmath2510@xmath26 ) , see fig . 3 . additionally , since each 2hour observation consisted of four 21minute scans of the region surrounding hessj0632 + 057 , we searched for shorter timescale ( intrahour ) variability . no evidence was found for short - term ( @xmath31hour ) variability of source # 3 in the scan - by - scan light - curves . source # 3 was modelled with an elliptical 2d gaussian in the map plane resulting in a size of 7@xmath14 by 4@xmath14 ( 1@xmath15 ) , consistent with an unresolved source . a further 3hour observation at 5 and 8.5ghz with the vla in the high resolution a - configuration ( program as967 ) was taken in october 2008 . however , source # 3 was not detected during this observation , presumably due to a low flux state of this object . a plausible alternative reason for the non - detection is that the source is extended on scales significantly larger than the @xmath27 beam ( but smaller than the 2@xmath14 1.28ghz gmrt beam ) , reducing the signal / noise achievable in this configuration . to circumvent this issue , the a configuration data were tapered to match the 2@xmath14 1.28ghz gmrt beam and rms point source limits at 5 and 8ghz were measured and plotted in fig . all four of the field sources detected during the d configuration observations were also present in the a configuration observations . * the next closest source to mwc148 ( source # 2 ) lies on the edge of the rms size limit of the tev emission , at 06@xmath1733@xmath1806.01@xmath19 @xmath20 0.3@xmath14 , @xmath105@xmath2147@xmath1649.63@xmath14@xmath20 0.3@xmath14 . the source displays a power - law spectrum with @xmath28 and has a flux density at 5ghz of 0.7 @xmath20 0.2mjy / beam . a multi - wavelength catalogue search resulted in no counterparts at this position . * one of the field sources ( source # 1 ) shows significant variability both on the @xmath3month separation timescale of these observations and on shorter ( @xmath3hour ) timescales . this source is located at 06h33m06.59s @xmath20 0.3@xmath14 , + 05d53@xmath1639@xmath1424 @xmath20 0.3@xmath14 , and is visible both in the nvss archive ( 1.4ghz , * ? ? ? * ) with a flux of @xmath315mjy ( cf @xmath312mjy in the gmrt 1.28ghz observations ) and in the xmm - newton image of this field . constant fluxes were recorded for all remaining field sources in all observations . we also observed the field of hessj0632 + 057 , using the giant metrewave radio telescope ( gmrt ) @xcite during june september 2008 . the gmrt array has 30 antennas , arranged in roughly a ` y ' configuration over 25 km area . the target field was observed for a total of 36 hours with 6 + 6 slots of 3 hours each at 1280 and 610/235 mhz . we observed simultaneously at 235 and 610 mhz , using synthesised bandwidths of 6 and 16 mhz , respectively . the 1280 mhz observation was carried out with a bandwidth of 16 mhz in each of the two available sidebands . each frequency channel is 125 khz in width , enabling the removal of narrow - band radio frequency interference ( rfi ) . the sources 3c147 and 3c48 were observed at the beginning and end of the observations and used as amplitude and bandpass calibrators to set the flux density scale . the sources 0632 + 103 and 0521 + 166 were used as phase calibrators at 1280 and 610/235 mhz respectively . all frequency channels affected by strong narrow - band rfi were flagged and removed from the entire data set using the aips software package . a faint , unresolved radio source is detected at the position of mwc148 ( see fig . 1 ) in five of the six 1280mhz observations , with an average flux of 0.68@xmath200.04mjy ( see fig . 3 ) . * the best fit position of this source from the full data set is 06@xmath1732@xmath1859.29@xmath19@xmath200.5@xmath14 , + 05@xmath214801.2@xmath200.5@xmath14*. there is no significant evidence for variability in these data over the week to month timescales of the observations . mwc148 was not detected above the 3@xmath15 level in the lower frequency observations . upper limits on the flux at 610mhz and 235mhz have been calculated and included on the sed shown in fig . the typical noise levels at 610 and 235 mhz were 0.74 and 1.82 mjy / beam respectively , the @xmath291ghz data were more strongly affected by rfi , resulting in a substantial increase in the rms noise . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the radio properties of source # 3 can be summarised as follows . the best fit positions of source # 3 measured with the vla and gmrt are consistent both with each other and with the position of mwc148 ( 06@xmath1732@xmath1859.236@xmath19 , + 05@xmath214801.04 ; * ? ? ? the new gmrt data provides the best constraint on the size of the radio emitting region in mwc148 . the upper limit on the source size ( along the short axis of the gmrt beam ) is 2@xmath14 . assuming a distance to the star of 1.5 kpc , this corresponds to an upper limit on the emission region of 3000au . significant variability was detected in the 5ghz emission from mwc148 at the 5@xmath15 level . variability at the same level may be present in the 1.28ghz data but not detectable above the noise . the non - detection during the vla a configuration observations further demonstrates the variable nature of the source . the variability timescale must be longer than the @xmath42hour scans and shorter than the @xmath3month timescale separation of the observations . an estimate of the spectral index , based on the average flux at 1.28ghz and 5ghz , was calculated for source # 3 to be @xmath30 = 0.6 @xmath20 0.2 . however , this value should be treated with caution due to the non - simultaneous nature of the 1.28ghz and 5ghz observations . the new radio source lies less than @xmath31@xmath14 from the centroid of the x - ray emission @xcite , and within the 1@xmath15 error box of hessj0632 + 057 * ( see fig . 2)*. thus we confidently identify this emission as the radio counterpart to mwc148 . it seems very likely that all these objects are associated and therefore we can create an sed as shown in fig . the recent publication of the fermi bright source list @xcite allows us to place constraints on the gev emission from hessj0632 + 057 . as no source was detected ( above 10@xmath15 in the first 3 months of operation ) at the position of hessj0632 + 057 , the egret source 3egj0634 + 0521 can be ruled out as a potential counterpart . limits for the gev emission after 3 months , and 1 year of fermi data have been added to the sed . the detection of tev emission implies particle acceleration is taking place in the source . the most natural explanation for the observed radio emission is then optically thin synchrotron emission from accelerated electrons . synchrotron radiation with a spectral index @xmath30.5 implies an underlying electron spectrum with @xmath31 . this can be interpreted as the injection spectrum . ic cooling in the thomson regime is hard to avoid for these electrons . if the observed spectrum is cooled , then this implies a very hard injection spectrum . this scenario was the one presented in @xcite , in which there is a low energy cut - off in the injection spectrum , resulting in an effectively mono - energetic injection for electrons below this cut - off energy . synchrotron cooling of such an injection will produce a time averaged electron spectral index of 2 and an emission spectrum with @xmath2=0.5 . the simple one - zone model presented in @xcite and adjusted to fit the x - ray and tev data , results in a radio spectrum remarkably similar to that observed . a better fit to the radio data can be achieved by adjusting the low - energy cut - off or a change in injection index from 2.0 to 1.9 ( see fig . 4 ) . assuming a one - zone model with the parameters described in @xcite , @xmath32 = 70 mg , @xmath33 = 1erg@xmath34 , the radio emission at 5ghz would be produced by @xmath390 mev electrons having a characteristic cooling time due to ic losses of @xmath42 days . similarly , 1.3ghz emission would be produced by 50mev electrons with a cooling time of @xmath34 days . the observed variability timescale , in common with that seen in x - rays , is comparable with the expected cooling times , even if the radio emission region is somewhat larger than the few au assumed . we note that if the emission region was considerably smaller than this both significant free - free absorption at 1ghz in the stellar wind and @xmath0-@xmath0 absorption at a few hundred gev on stellar photons would likely become apparent at some orbital phases . at this stage neither effect can be excluded . strictly simultaneous multi - frequency radio data would be required to check for radio absorption features . there are two main scenarios that could plausibly explain the observed emission from hessj0632 + 057 ; firstly that the star is isolated , with a magnetically confined wind region and secondly that the star is in a binary system with an unseen compact companion . although there are some interesting similarities between mwc148 and the archetypal isolated magnetic bp star @xmath15 ori e , including similar x - ray variability timescales @xcite , there are also significant differences . the x - ray emission from @xmath15 ori e can be well fit by a two - temperature _ apec _ model with a hot component of @xmath42.6kev whereas the x - ray emission from mwc148 can only be fit with such a model if the temperature of the hot component is well above 10kev , due to the substantial flux in the 510kev band . at radio wavelengths @xmath15 ori e displays a flat spectrum ( @xmath35 0)between 220ghz , whereas the emission from mwc148 appears to have a negative spectral index . the radio light - curve of @xmath15 ori e is strongly modulated with the orbital period . this may also be the case with mwc148 , but further observations are clearly needed to characterise its radio variability . as can be clearly seen in tab . 1 there is a strong resemblance between the known @xmath0-ray binaries and hessj0632 + 057 . although hessj0632 + 057 is a much weaker source in all wavelengths , the similar spectral properties make a convincing argument that this object does indeed represent a new @xmath0-ray emitting binary system . * the apparent variability in the tev emission of hessj0632 + 057 , as inferred by the veritas collaboration @xcite , is also consistent with the properties of the known @xmath0-ray binary systems . * all objects in tab . 1 exhibit a hard ( @xmath36 1 ) spectrum in the x - ray domain , with hessj0632 + 057 having a particularly hard spectrum . the tev spectral indices of all objects are consistent with each other and all considerably softer than the corresponding x - ray spectrum . all objects appear to have their peak energy output in the mev to gev range . note that gev emission has only been detected using fermi coincident with lsi+61303 and ls5039 @xcite . upper limits for the other sources have been estimated using detected sources close to the objects of interest to determine the local detection threshold . the @xmath0-ray binaries all display variable radio emission with a wide range of spectral properties including low energy spectral turnovers ( see e.g. * ? ? ? the clear outlier in this group is cygnusx-1 , for example , although the radio and vhe @xmath0-ray luminosities are similar , the x - ray luminosity of cygnusx-1 is orders of magnitude greater than the other objects . resolved radio emission has been detected in both lsi+61303 and ls5039 @xcite with emission regions of the order of @xmath310au . our current observations are unable to probe such small scales and more data is required in order to resolve or further constrain the size of the emitting region and move towards a better understanding of this source . whilst the detection of variable radio emission from mwc148 further strengthens the case that hessj0632 + 057 is indeed a tev binary , the scenario that this object is an ( extremely unusual ) isolated massive star remains an intriguing possibility . we thank the staff of the gmrt who made these observations possible . we thank dr . s. roy and prof . v. kulkarni of ncra , for the help provided during the gmrt observation and data transmission to the leiden observatory , h. e. wheelwright and j. j. stead for useful discussions and an anonymous referee for helpful comments . is supported by a uk science and technology facilities council ( stfc ) advanced fellowship . c. c. c. is supported by an appointment to the nasa postdoctoral program at goddard space flight center , administered by oak ridge associated universities through a contract with nasa . is supported by european community contract erc - stg-200911 .

the few known @xmath0-ray binary systems are all associated with variable radio and x - ray emission . the tev source hess j0632@xmath1057 , apparently associated with the be star mwc148 , is plausibly a new member of this class . following the identification of a variable x - ray counterpart to the tev source we conducted gmrt and vla observations in june - september 2008 to search for the radio counterpart of this object . a point - like radio source at the position of the star is detected in both 1280mhz gmrt and 5ghz vla observations , with an average spectral index , @xmath2 , of @xmath30.6 . in the vla data there is significant flux variability on @xmath3month timescales around the mean flux density of @xmath40.3 mjy . these radio properties ( and the overall spectral energy distribution ) are consistent with an interpretation of hess j0632@xmath1057 as a lower power analogue of the established @xmath0-ray binary systems . [ firstpage ] radio - continuum : stars , x - rays : binaries

physics0410014

in nature , complex nano - assemblies of functional units combine to perform required complicated tasks . one example is the assembly for harvesting light in photosynthesis @xcite . there is considerable practical interest in imitating and manipulating this sort of functionality on a nano - scale . in order to do so , theoretical and experimental understanding of the constituents is required . in this paper , we consider a functional component of a possible light harvesting assembly . one functional unit of a light harvesting assembly might be a self - assembled multilayer with the specific function of transferring holes away from light receptors . conjugated polymers may be good candidates for this purpose because of their semiconductor - like properties , plasticity , and potential low cost of fabrication @xcite . these materials have already found uses in a wide range of applications such as light - emitting diodes , lasers , sensors and molecular switches @xcite . to perform such functions , the molecule should be rigid in one dimension to provide required spatial conduits . moreover , the hole - electron separation and charge conduction processes require long conjugation lengths and flexible excited state structure to provide sufficient freedom to tune energetics synthetically . we consider oligomers of phenylene - acetylene , shown on the top panel of fig . [ fig : pa ] , which retain one - dimensional rigidity like molecular wires . however , this polymer can be easily twisted between benzene rings about the triple - bonded carbon links . this geometry change is expected to reduce the conjugation length and may adversely affect applications which rely on the de - localization of the charge carriers . in this article we examine phenylene - acetylene oligomers from both theoretical and experimental standpoints in order to analyze their excited state electronic structure and the effects of conformational rotations on effective conjugation and electronic de - localization lengths of these materials . in particular , we utilized the natural transition orbital decomposition @xcite to infer the extent of the underlying electronic localization . to calculate electronic structure we use a blend of quantum chemical methods including semi - empirical ( austin model 1 ( am1 ) ) approaches @xcite for ground and excited state @xcite geometry optimizations , and time - dependent density functional theory ( td - dft ) @xcite and zindo @xcite methods for excited state computations . there have been many theoretical calculations on conjugated polymers using various semi - empirical and first principle approaches . it is well understood that , in general , both semi - empirical ( such as am1 ) and dft methods provide reasonable geometries and zindo can deliver good uv - visible spectra for such molecular systems @xcite . even more accurate td - dft approaches are able to tackle complicated electronic features such as exciton binding energy @xcite and double excitations @xcite . furthermore , based on the results of the calculations , absorption an emission spectra can be modeled , for example , for polyenes , oligoarylenes , phenylenevinylenes , and polyfluorenes @xcite . existing theoretical studies of phenylene - acetylene include td - dft investigation of the excited states of the monomer @xcite and several studies of dendrimer with phenylene - acetylene being the basic unit @xcite . additionally , experimental absorption and fluorescence spectra have been reported for phenylene - acetylene monomers , dimers , and trimers linked to pt centers @xcite . details of our computational approach are presented in section [ sec.methods ] . in section [ sec.results ] we analyze computational results and compare them to experiment . finally , we discuss the trends that emerge and summarize our findings in section [ sec.conclusion ] . we focus on oligomers of two to ten phenylene - acetylene repeat - units ( top panel of fig . [ fig : pa ] ) . the two unit case is the small molecule limit and may be compared to more expensive _ ab initio _ calculations which are only possible for small systems . in such small molecules photo - excitations are confined by molecular ends and study of increasingly longer chains is necessary to understand the onset of de - localized excitations that polymers exhibit . the ten unit chain is a sufficiently long oligomer to reasonably approximate the infinite polymer limit @xcite . ground state optimal geometries of phenylene - acetylene oligomers have been obtained using the gaussian 98 @xcite software package . the molecular geometries in the gas phase are fully optimized using the semi - empirical am1 method . the am1 model has been parametrized to give accurate geometries for organic molecules and is expected to provide reliable geometries @xcite . to model the fluorescence spectra , the excited state geometries are needed . we used the excited - state molecular dynamics ( esmd ) computational package @xcite to optimize molecular geometries for the lowest excited state at time - dependent hartree - fock ( td - hf ) level and am1 model . this approach allows treatment of large molecular systems at modest numerical cost and previously resulted in reasonable fluorescence line - shapes of several conjugated molecular systems @xcite . in principle , it is also possible to use dft or hartree - fock _ ab initio _ approaches for ground state optimization purposes . however , such approaches may be problematic for the excited state optimization due to high numerical cost . instead , we treat molecular geometries within the same approach : hf / am1 and td - hf / am1 levels for the ground and excited states , respectively . additionally , by using the am1 , we eliminate any errors in the geometry that might come from using approximate functionals and limited basis sets in density functional theory . for example , it was found for polyacetylene that a fraction of exact - exchange must be mixed with a semi - local exchange - correlation functional for the theory to reproduce the bond - length alternation accurately @xcite . for obtained geometries , we next calculate the excited - state triplet and singlet manifolds using td - dft approach which is known to be a reliable but computationally affordable _ ab initio _ tool for excited state treatment . we perform all our calculations in the gas phase for simplicity , but we expect that the results will not change much when these oligomers are placed in non - polar solvents . we use the b3lyp functional combined with the 6 - 31 g basis set as implemented in the gaussian 98 package @xcite . the 6 - 31 g basis set is known to be an efficient blend of accuracy and manageable size for large conjugated molecules @xcite . we do not include diffuse functions as we expect the relevant excited states have support only along the backbone of the polymer for long chains . for ground - state properties , dft provides a formally exact scheme for solving the many - body problem @xcite , but , in practice , the functionals used are approximated in a manner convenient for calculations . the b3lyp functional @xcite combines semi - local exchange - correlation with non - local exact - exchange . by construction , this functional handles a fraction of long - range exchange exactly but fails to capture long - range correlation effects . time - dependent density functional theory is an extension of density functional theory in which many - body excitations are associated with the poles of the exact density response @xcite . td - dft using b3lyp inputs has been shown to be accurate for many molecular systems and is computationally affordable . in particular , ref . @xcite suggests that b3lyp is the optimal functional to use for excited - state calculations on ppv - type polymers . in order to characterize calculated excited states and to address the electronic localization , we performed a transition orbital analysis @xcite based on the computed transition densities from the td - dft calculations . this analysis offers the most compact representation of a given transition density in terms of its expansion in single - particle transitions . the transition orbital picture provides an important information on the multi - configurational nature of a given excited state , and gives a real - space orbital representation as to where the photo - excited hole and electron reside , which is useful to illustrate the excitonic localization phenomena . finally , we calculate the line - shapes of fluorescence spectra using the ground and excited state optimal geometries and vibrational normal modes of the ground state . this can be readily done within the condon approximation for displaced multidimensional harmonic oscillators @xcite . the vibrational overlap integrals @xmath1 , franck - condon factors , govern the probability of emission from transition between the vibrational level 0 in the lowest excited state and a vibrational level @xmath2 in the ground state . these quantities , in turn , depend on the dimensionless displacements @xmath3 of each normal mode with huang - rhys factors , @xmath4 . the fluorescence band shape as a function of the frequency @xmath5 is determined by the imaginary part of the polarizability @xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the electronic transition dipole moment between the excited and the ground - state , @xmath8 is the associated @xmath9 transition energy , the @xmath10 s are the vibrational frequencies , the @xmath11 s are the quanta of the participating normal modes , and @xmath12 is an empirical parameter setting the spectral line - widths . we choose the line - width to be either 0.2 ev or 0.02 ev . the former produces plots which agree well with the experimentally observed line widths , whereas the latter allows greater resolution and the analysis in terms of the contributing vibrational states . the chemical structure of phenylene - acetylene is shown on fig . ( [ fig : pa ] ) . our specimen is terminated at one end by a methyl group ( @xmath13 ) and at the other end by an amine group ( @xmath14 ) which may either be used for binding the molecule to to a substrate or for self - assembly into structures of interest at the air - water interface ( langmuir - blodgett method ) . oligomers with n=2,3 , and 4 repeat units have been synthesized and spectroscopically characterized . the phenylene - acetylene oligomers were synthesized by cross - coupling of the appropriate phenylacetylene compounds with 4-amino-1-iodobenzene using @xmath15/cui as catalyst . the molecular building block ( phenylene - acetylene ) is prepared by coupling 4-dodecane - ethynylbenzene with 4-(trimethylsilylethynyl ) iodobenzene . the solution uv - vis and fluorescence spectra were measured using methylene chloride as the solvent . we calculate the threshold for rotation about the triple bond is @xmath16 ev per triple bond , and we expect that at room temperature where @xmath17 ev , an ensemble of geometries will be allowed given the uncertainty of solvent effects and molecular packing . in order to estimate how these geometry changes will affect the spectrum , we sample two extreme geometries ( fig . [ fig : pa ] ) , the completely planar configuration where all benzene rings lie in the same plane , and an alternating configuration where adjacent benzene rings are at right angles to each other . both geometries are local minima within the am1 approach , the planar case being the global minimum . even though in total ground - state energies the two configurations do not differ drastically , their excited - states properties do . torsional potentials for another type of conjugated polymer have been calculated in detail @xcite . here we choose only to calculate the extreme limits and some intermediates arguing that the general behavior and trends will be thereby evident and the details of the torsional potential are not critical to the current study . in fig [ fig : pa ] , we plot the dependence of the energy of the uv - visible active singlet state as a function of chain length for absorption and fluorescence . absorption results are presented for a planar , a completely alternating , and an intermediate geometry where every other benzene is rotated about the triple bond by 45 degrees . the experimental results are the absorption and fluorescence maxima in a non - polar solvent , methylene chloride . except for in the alternating geometry , the lowest @xmath18 state has the largest oscillator strength . we see that the experiment lies between the intermediate and completely alternating results . the long chain limit is reached by approximately four to six repeat units for planar chain , which implies the extent of the conjugation length and the size of the photo - generated exciton . this value is a strong function of the exact orbital - dependent exchange ( fock - like exchange ) present in the functional @xcite . for example , the zindo ( 100% of exact - exchange ) curve saturates faster to the constant long - chain - limit than b3lyp ( 20% of exact - exchange ) results . since the alternating geometry breaks some of the conjugation , we observe several low - lying dark singlets energetically below the optically active _ band - gap _ state . in this case , the energy of the _ band - gap _ state has little size - dependence and is significantly blue - shifted compared to that for planar geometry . as expected , the intermediate geometry values lie between these two extremes and are accidentally very close to the zindo results . in order to estimate the effective bond angle ( within td - b3lyp/6 - 31 g approach ) , we gradually rotated the benzene rings about the triple bonds and calculated the singlet excited states for n=2 , 3 , and 4 unit oligomers . for most angles , the lowest singlet state can be directly associated with the lowest singlet state for the planar geometry . at some critical angle , this breaks down and the lowest singlet is no longer optically active . for 2-units , the singlet and experiment do not overlap for any angle . for 3-units , the overlap is at 43 degrees . the effective rotation angle for 4-unit chains is over 63 degrees . in the long chain limit , we expect the effective angle to increase but saturate . geometric effects are important for fluorescence as well . here the excited state geometries remain close to planar with a steep torsional potential as has been reported for other polymers @xcite . the bond - length alternation parameter reduces in the middle of the molecule which indicates an excitonic self - trapping process . because of the tendency of the excited state to planarize the molecule , the alternating geometry is unlikely , so we simulate what one might expect to become of the alternating geometry by taking the relaxed excited state geometry and rotating each benzene by 45 degrees about the triple bond while leaving two to three benzene rings in the center of the chain coplanar . we see that the fluorescence from the simulated alternating geometry differs only slightly from the planar geometry ( pointing to the short extent of the self - trapped exciton ) . the curve for the simulated case is not smooth because of the scheme we use to simulate the geometry . for even numbered chains we have two coplanar benzenes in the center of the chain , but for odd numbered chains , we have three coplanar benzenes and a slightly greater de - localization . therefore , the results for the first excited singlets of odd chain lengths are systematically slightly lower . using eq . ( [ eq : fluor ] ) it is possible to compare the experimental and theoretical fluorescence spectra directly ( see fig . [ fig : afplot ] ) . the top panel shows the experimental absorption spectra for 2 - 4 unit chains . the next panel is the experimental emission spectra . as expected , experimental absorption - fluorescence spectra are nearly mirror - image profiles ; this indicates the same nature of the absorbing and emitting electronic state . the last two panels are theoretical results calculated with broadening parameters of 0.2 ev and 0.02 ev , respectively . the larger broadening is able to model experimentally measured line shapes . indeed we observe good overall comparison between theory and experiment . in particular , the shoulder on the red - side of all spectra are well reproduced . the @xmath19 ev broadening gives spectra which show more detail than experiment and offer the possibility of identification and analysis of the dominant vibrational modes . in the theoretical absorption plots , three peaks can easily be resolved . they correspond , from left to right , to a 0 - 0 transition , a benzene bond alternating mode , and a fast triple bond length oscillation . in the ten unit chain , we can also resolve a peak from an alternate benzene bond mode . figure [ fig : modes ] shows schematically the dominant normal modes of phenylene - acetylene . the top shows the low - frequency stretching mode i of the entire molecule , which contribute for the most part to the width of vibronic peaks . its frequency and displacement @xmath20 depends on the molecular mass . these quantities decrease and increase for large oligomers , respectively . the other three nuclear modes ( ii - iv ) coupled to the electronic system are high - energy vibrations whose frequencies weakly depend on the chain length . the first two ( ii and iii ) are bond alternating modes within the benzene rings that only become resolved for the longer chain lengths . the last mode iv is the stretching of the triple - bond . relative displacements are shown for the individual modes . the left value is for the shortest chain and the right is for the ten unit chain . we see that the higher energy modes become less dominant as the polymer s length is increased . the strength of the low energy stretching mode nearly doubles in the long chain limit relative to the short chain limit , and the sub - dominant alternating modes such as the second benzene alternating mode become resolved in the longer chain length limit . figure [ fig : states ] shows the size - scaling of calculated low - lying excited states as a function of reciprocal conjugation length . the top panel displays a typical structure of singlet and triplet manifolds in conjugated polymers where the ladder of well - defined states is optically coupled . nearly linear scaling for all states allows extrapolation to the saturated values in the infinite chain limit . as expected , the singlet - excitation energies ( @xmath18 ) become lower with increasing polymer length . the long - chain limit is achieved approximately ( within 0.2 ev ) by six units . the optically inactive first triplet excited state ( @xmath21 ) has been calculated using two levels of theory : the td - dft approach for the lowest triplet excitation and change in the self - consistent field ( @xmath20scf ) method . the latter is the energy difference between the self - consistent ground states calculated with enforced singlet and triplet spin multiplicities . we observe negligible spin contamination in the unrestricted approach used to calculate the triplet ground state . in general , @xmath20scf is considered to be a stable and reliable approach for evaluating the first triplet state energy . in contrast , td - dft energies of triplet states strongly depend on the amount of the hf exchange present in the functional . even negative energies of triplet states may be observed in the td - hf limit ( so - called triplet instability ) . in our case ( b3lyp functional ) we found 2 and 2.4 ev saturation limits for the energy of the @xmath21 state of phenylene - acetylene in td - dft and @xmath20scf approaches , respectively . higher lying t@xmath22 and s@xmath22 states correspond to de - localized excitations where the electron become well separated from the hole upon absorption of a quantum of light @xcite . even though the spin state matters for small molecules , t@xmath22 and s@xmath22 correctly become degenerate in the long chain limit , saturating to 2.8 ev limit . in the alternating geometry case , the electron is expected to remain localized . all excitations for the alternating geometry are about 0.5 ev greater than for the planar geometry because of the more local nature of the excitation . in order to characterize the typical low - lying ( @xmath21 and @xmath18 ) excitations we further performed a transition orbital analysis @xcite . the top of fig . [ fig : ntos ] shows the transition orbitals for 2 , 4 , and 10 unit chains of planar phenylene - acetylene . as expected , all these states represent de - localized transitions which are mostly @xmath23 nature . note that for the longest ( ten unit ) chains , the triplets are more localized than the singlets . for the singlet state , one pair of orbitals dominates . both the hole and particle are de - localized along the backbone of the polymer ; however , the hole is more de - localized . triplet states adopt more of a multi - configurational character with increasing chain length , which reflects their smaller exciton size compared to that of singlet states . the bottom of fig . [ fig : ntos ] displays the transition orbitals for the alternating geometry . these plots clearly show the breakage of conjugation due to torsion . all excitations have multi - configurational character as a superposition of orbitals with an electron - hole pair residing on short chain segments ( e.g. , see @xmath21 for n=10 ) . ultimately such excitations in long chains can be well treated in the frenkel exciton limit . the extent of electronic de - localization and the existence of appropriate excited state energetics have serious implications for using conjugated polymers as a constituent in artificial functional nano - assemblies . our study confirms that torsional disorder of the molecular geometry caused by dielectric environment or thermal fluctuation is an important factor affecting the excited state structure of phenylene - acetylene . we find that dft can give quantitatively accurate results when compared to experiment . subsequently , the nature of calculated electronic states can be analyzed in the real - space using a transition orbital decomposition . the good agreement between the experimental and theoretical fluorescence spectral line - shapes indicate that we can use theory to understand the underlying molecular morphology and to identify and analyze franck - condon active vibrational modes . by comparing our theoretical calculations to the experimental results , we find an effective average geometry and argue that the conjugation length is drastically reduced by rotations about the triple - bonds . section [ sec.results ] contains only a fraction of the results we obtained using combination of different methods . overall , we observe two fundamental trends : i ) the bond - length alternation parameter reduces with decreasing a fraction of exact fock - like exchange in the dft functional in the course of the ground state geometry optimization . this results in the overall red - shift of the excitation energies . ii ) an increase of a fraction of exact exchange in the functional when computing td - dft excited states results in the blue ( red ) shift of singlet ( triplet ) state energies . consequently , any combination of physically justified methods and appropriate model chemistries will result in the same trends and conclusions with some variation of calculated spectroscopic variables . top : molecular structure of phenylene - acetylene and schematic structures of the planar and alternating geometries respectively . middle : scaling of the energy of the singlet excited state which dominates uv - visible absorption as a function of the number of polymer repeat units . theoretical values correspond to the vertical excitation and emission , and experimental values are taken for the absorption and emission maxima . bottom : same as above but for fluorescence.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] absorption and fluorescence line shapes for various length phenylene - acetylene oligomers ; experiment versus theory . the top two panels are the experimental absorption and fluorescence . the bottom two panels are the theoretical emission profiles calculated with broad ( 0.2 ev ) and narrow ( 0.02 ev ) spectral line width . frank - condon active vibrational normal modes ( ii - iv ) are shown in fig . [ fig : modes ] . , scaledwidth=90.0% ] the dominant normal modes contributing to the vibrational structure of the fluorescence spectrum for phenylene - acetylene . the top diagram is a low energy stretching mode contributing to the spectral broadening . the next two diagrams show vibrations contributing to the ii - iii peak , which becomes resolved as the polymer length increases ; these are oscillations in the length of the bonds within the benzene rings . the final mode is a high energy oscillation in the length of the triple bond , which contributes to the iv peak . , scaledwidth=90.0% ] top : typical electronic structure of optically active states in singlet and triplet manifolds for conjugated polymers . bottom : size - scaling of excitation energies as a function of the reciprocal conjugation length for phenylene - acetylene oligomers.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] selected transition orbitals for 2 , 4 , and 10-unit phenylene - acetylene chains in the planar and alternating ground - state geometries . these are calculated at the b3lyp/6 - 31 g level . the nh@xmath24 end is to the right.,scaledwidth=105.0% ]

the excited state electronic structure of @xmath0 conjugated phenylene - acetylene oligomers is calculated using time - dependent density functional theory ( td - dft ) approaches . the theoretical fluorescence spectra are analyzed in terms of frank - condon active nuclear normal modes and shown to compare well with experiment . theoretical and experimental results for the optical absorption and emission spectra of these molecules indicate that the conjugation length can be significantly reduced by conformational rotations about the triple - bonded carbon links . this has serious implications on the electronic functionalities of polyphenylene - acetylene based molecular wires and their possible use as charge / energy conduits in nano - assemblies .

hep-th0511059

the noncommutative chern - simons theory has been intensively studied during the last years . among the most important results obtained so far are the vanishing of the ultraviolet / infrared ( uv / ir ) infrared divergences for the pure chern - simons theory @xcite and the quantization of the chern - simons coefficient @xcite . there were also some indications that , in the axial gauge , the pure chern - simons theory is actually a free field theory @xcite . besides all these theoretical developments , a relation of noncommutative chern - simons theory to the fractional quantum hall effect has also been pointed @xcite . in our previous paper @xcite , we investigated various interactions of the noncommutative chern - simons field with the matter with special concern on the existence of dangerous uv / ir singularities . for the supersymmetric model , we found that the cancellation of uv / ir infrared divergences occurs even when matter is included , either in the adjoint or in the fundamental representation ( in the former case , this happens only in a particular gauge ) . in this paper , we continue our line of research by looking at two natural extensions of our previous results . first , we extend the investigations of @xcite to the non - abelian case . as we shall prove , similarly to other four- and three - dimensional noncommutative supersymmetric gauge theories @xcite , the cancellation of uv / ir singularities , generated in the nonplanar part of the quantum corrections , demands that the gauge group generators are in the fundamental representation of the @xmath0 group . we recall that this is the same requirement found for the consistency of noncommutative gauge models at the classical level @xcite . second , we will calculate the finite one - loop quantum corrections to the effective action of the supersymmetric theory ( see @xcite for a similar calculation in the non - supersymmetric case , as well as @xcite for an extensive study of the commutative theory ) . in particular , this will allow us to determine the finite changes in the coefficient of the chern - simons term and the structure of the effective action of the model . our work is organized as follows . in the next section we demonstrate the finiteness of the pure gauge sector if the generators are in the fundamental representation of @xmath1 . the effect of the inclusion of matter is considered in section [ sec2 ] where we prove that finiteness in the adjoint representation also requires the gauge superfield to be in a special gauge . the one loop calculation of the finite contributions to the quadratic part of the effective action is done in section [ sec3 ] . there , we prove that nonlocal maxwell and chern - simons terms are generated , and the later one induces a shift in the classical chern - simons coefficient . in the summary , section [ sec4 ] , we present our concluding remarks . the action of the three - dimensional noncommutative non - abelian chern - simons theory with an arbitrary gauge group is @xmath2 @xcite . here , @xmath3 is the classical action @xmath4 @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the gauge fixing and faddeev - popov actions @xmath7 and @xmath8\right)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9- \frac{1}{6 } [ a^\alpha , \{a_\alpha , a_\beta \}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] is the superfield strength constructed from the lie - algebra valued spinor superpotential @xmath10 , and the @xmath11 are the generators of the corresponding gauge group in a given representation . they satisfy the normalization condition @xmath12 . hereafter it is implicitly assumed that all commutators and anticommutators involve both algebraic and moyal ( anti)commutation . as usual , in this work we consider only space - space noncommutativity , to evade unitarity problems @xcite . the action ( [ 2n ] ) is invariant under the brst transformations @xmath13 ) , \\ \delta c & = & \epsilon c^2 , \quad \delta c^{\prime } \,=\ , \frac{\epsilon}\xi d_\alpha a^\alpha , \label{gt } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath14 is an infinitesimal grassmannian gauge parameter . the quadratic part of the action fixes the gauge propagator to be @xmath15\delta^5(z_1-z_2)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath16 is the second - rank antisymmetric levi - civit symbol defined with the normalization @xmath17 . the ghost fields are also lie - algebra valued and their propagator is given by @xmath18 the interaction part of the classical action in the pure gauge sector is @xmath19- \frac{1}{6}a^{\alpha } \ast [ a^\beta , \{a_\beta , a_\alpha \ } ] \nonumber\\ & + \frac{i}{6}\{a^{\alpha},a^{\beta}\ } \ast d_{\beta}a_{\alpha}+\frac{1}{12 } \{a^{\alpha},a^{\beta}\}*\{a_{\alpha},a_{\beta}\ } \big)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] from which we get the feynman supergraphs vertices @xmath20 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have introduced the notation @xmath21 the ghost - gauge field vertex has the following form , @xmath22 we are now in a position to study the divergences in the one - loop quantum corrections to the effective action . the non - abelian structure of the gauge group does not change the power counting we found for the abelian theory @xcite , so that the superficial degree of divergence for a supergraph with @xmath23 external field legs and @xmath24 covariant derivatives acting on those legs is @xmath25 . it follows that the linear uv divergences are possible only for supergraphs with two external gauge legs . as in @xcite , logarithmic divergences are absent due to symmetric integration on the loop momentum . therefore , the complete one - loop analysis of the divergences of the ( pure gauge ) model demands the evaluation of the diagrams depicted in fig . [ fig1 ] . for the sake of simplicity , we only give the details of the evaluation of the diagram [ fig1]@xmath26 . one starts by taking into account all contractions of two fields in the non - symmetric vertex @xmath27 in eq . ( [ val ] ) , that is to say , @xmath28\,.\label{g1b1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the six terms in eq . ( [ g1b1 ] ) are divided in two groups of similar contributions . after some manipulations one finds , for the first four terms in the square bracket of eq . ( [ g1b1 ] ) , @xmath29\times\nonumber\\ & \left(\xi d^{\alpha}d^{\beta}+d^{\beta}d^{\alpha}\right)\delta_{11}\ , a_{\alpha}^{\,a}\left(p,\theta\right)\ , a_{\beta}^{\,b}\left(-p,\theta\right)\,,\label{g1b2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] while , for the remaining two terms , @xmath30\times\nonumber\\ & \left(\xi d^{\alpha}d_{\alpha}+d_{\alpha}d^{\alpha}\right)\delta_{11}\ , a^{\beta\,a}\left(p,\theta\right)\ , a_{\beta}^{\ , b}\left(-p,\theta\right)\,.\label{g1b3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one readily realizes that the factor @xmath31 inside the square brackets of eq . ( [ g1b2 ] ) do not contribute for symmetry reasons . after @xmath32-algebra manipulations ( which are trivial in this case ) , one can cast the contribution to the two - point vertex function of the gauge superpotential corresponding to the diagram [ fig1]@xmath26 as @xmath33 a^{\alpha\ , a}\left(p,\theta\right)\ , a_{\alpha}^{\ , b}\left(-p,\theta\right)\,.\ ] ] as for the other diagrams in fig . [ fig1 ] , their complete evaluation follows along the same lines but is far more intricate . here , we just quote their divergent parts , [ g1ac ] @xmath34 \frac{1}{k^2}a^{\alpha\,a}(p,\theta)a^b_{\alpha}(-p,\theta),\\ \label{g1c } \gamma_{1c}(p)=&-\frac{1}{4\kappa^{2}}\int\frac{d^3k}{(2\pi)^3 } \ , d^2\theta \ , \left[a^{cad}a^{dbc}-a^{cad}a^{cbd}\cos(2k\wedge p)\right ] \frac{1}{k^2}a^{\alpha\,a}(p,\theta ) a^b_{\alpha}(-p,\theta)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] postponing the detailed discussion of their finite parts to the section [ sec3 ] . the planar part of @xmath35 , being proportional to @xmath36 , exactly vanishes within the framework of dimensional regularization , which we are implicitly assuming . as for the nonplanar part of @xmath37 , which would generate a linear uv / ir infrared divergence , its cancellation is secured by the condition involving traces of the gauge group generators , @xmath38 which is satisfied for the @xmath0 gauge group in the fundamental representation . equation ( [ cond ] ) is the same condition we found for the cancellation of dangerous uv / ir infrared singularities for the three- and four - dimensional noncommutative super - yang - mills theories @xcite . again , we see that the strong restriction imposed on the choice of the gauge group at the classical level @xcite also plays an outstanding role to enforce the absence of singularities in the quantum theory . as a final remark , by means of the substitution @xmath39 in eqs . ( [ g1b ] ) and ( [ g1ac ] ) , we correctly reobtain the results we have found for the abelian theory in @xcite . we will study now the consequences of the addition of matter in the theory . matter can interact with the chern - simons superfield in two different ways . it can be in the fundamental representation , @xmath40 or in the adjoint representation , @xmath41*d_{\alpha}\phi - d^{\alpha}\bar{\phi}\ast[a_{\alpha},\phi])\nonumber\\ & -\frac{1}{2}[\bar{\phi},a^{\alpha}]*[a_{\alpha},\phi]\big)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the presence of matter , the power counting for the supergraphs remains the same as before , but @xmath23 must be considered as the total number of external legs . therefore , only supergraphs with two external legs can generate nonintegrable ( linear ) uv / ir infrared divergences . the supergraphs with a matter internal loop and external gauge legs ( see fig . 2 ) are identical to the ones studied in @xcite , where their total contribution was proved to be free of nonintegrable uv / ir infrared divergences if and only if the condition ( [ cond ] ) was satisfied . we also note that all uv divergent terms in these diagrams cancel due to the relation @xmath42 which also happens to hold in the fundamental representation of @xmath1 . therefore we need to study only the graphs with external matter legs . first , we consider matter in the fundamental representation , as specified in eq . ( [ materfund ] ) . one can show that all the relevant diagrams are totally planar and therefore generate no uv / ir mixing . the cancellation of the uv divergences in these planar parts follows the same pattern as in the previous section . when matter is in the adjoint representation , we find the following divergent contributions from the supergraphs depicted in figs . [ fig3]@xmath43 and [ fig3]@xmath26 , @xmath44 \phi^a(-p,\theta)\bar{\phi}^b(p,\theta),\nonumber\\ & \gamma_{3b}(p)\,=\,\frac{i(1-\xi)\,g^2}{2m\kappa } \int\frac{d^3k}{(2\pi)^3}\,d^2\theta\ , \frac{1}{k^{2 } } \left[a^{abcc}-a^{acbc}\cos(2k\wedge p)\right ] \phi^a(-p,\theta)\bar{\phi}^b(p,\theta).\end{aligned}\ ] ] again , the planar parts of these contributions vanish within the framework of dimensional regularization . the nonplanar parts would generate dangerous uv / ir mixing , but they cancel if the relation @xmath45 is obeyed . the condition ( [ cond1 ] ) is satisfied only in the gauge @xmath46 where it reproduces eq . ( [ cond ] ) . therefore , as observed before , the cancellation only happens in the fundamental representation of @xmath1 . we remind the reader that the abelian theory is also free of nonintegrable uv / ir singularities in the gauge @xmath47 @xcite . for a different value of @xmath48 , the matter two - point function develops an uv / ir infrared divergence , even if the pure gauge sector is infrared safe , as we have shown in the previous section . after having demonstrated the one - loop finiteness of the model , in this section we determine the finite one - loop quantum corrections to the quadratic part of the effective action . a clear importance of this result is the possibility to verify whether in the quantum theory a shift in the chern - simons coefficient is produced . in the pure gauge sector , the two - point vertex function of the gauge superpotential receives finite contributions only from the diagrams @xmath43 and @xmath49 in fig . the more complicated diagram is [ fig1]@xmath43 , since there are 18 different ways to contract two pairs of superfields to form the internal lines . we classify these contributions according to the distribution of supercovariant derivatives , namely @xmath50 where , after simplifications of the moyal phase factors , @xmath51 \ , , \label{two1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath52 \ , , \label{two2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath53 \ , , \label{two3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath54 \ , . \label{two4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the moyal phase factor common to all these diagrams is given by @xmath55 and , in a slight abuse of notation , factors like @xmath56 in eqs . ( [ two1])-([two4 ] ) mean the gauge superpropagator in eq . ( [ gaugeprop ] ) without the @xmath57 , which has already been used to simplify the phase factor @xmath58 . finally , the graph in fig . [ fig1]@xmath49 yields the ghost contribution , @xmath59 \left[d^{2}d_{2}^{\beta}\delta^{2}\left(\theta_{1}-\theta_{2}\right)\right ] \ , . \label{mlett : c1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] only the contributions @xmath60 and @xmath61 have divergent parts , which were already discussed in section [ sec2 ] . for the remaining of this section , we restrict ourselves to the discussion of the finite parts of @xmath62 and @xmath61 . to evaluate them , one has to perform rather lengthy @xmath32-algebra manipulations , thus generating lots of terms . these were calculated independently by hand and also by means of a computer program designed for quantum superfield calculations @xcite . we do not quote all the details of the calculation , but we will describe the necessary steps using @xmath60 as a typical example of the contributions we have evaluated . first of all , using @xmath32-algebra manipulations , we can cast @xmath60 as follows , @xmath63,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the superscript @xmath64 is to stress that we are quoting only the finite part . next , we introduce the definition @xmath65 and verify that @xmath66 to write @xmath67\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the final form of @xmath68 and is obtained by means of the identities @xcite @xmath69,\nonumber\\ \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } \,d^2\theta\ , p_{\beta\gamma } d^2a^{\beta\,a}(p,\theta)a^{\gamma\,b}(-p,\theta ) & = \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } \,d^2\theta\ , \left[2\left(l_{maxw}\right)^{ab}+2\left(l_{mgf}\right)^{ab}\right]\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath70 are the maxwell ( `` linearized yang - mills '' ) and the gauge - fixing lagrangians of the three - dimensional sym theory , respectively . also , @xmath71 is the linear part of the superfield strength defined in ( [ sstr ] ) . using the steps just described , we obtained the finite parts of @xmath62 and @xmath61 as follows , @xmath72\big\}\,,\nonumber\\ \gamma_{aiii}^{fin}&=&-\frac{1}{36 } \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } \ , d^2\theta \ , i^{ab}(p ) \ , \big\{(1-\xi)\left[4 \xi \left(l_{maxw}\right)^{ab } + ( 1-\xi ) \left(l_{mgf}\right)^{ab}\right]\big\}\ , , \nonumber\\ \gamma_{aiv}^{fin}&=&-\frac{1}{9 } \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } \ , d^2\theta \ , i^{ab}(p ) \ , \big\ { ( 1-\xi)\left [ \xi \left(l_{maxw}\right)^{ab } + ( 1+\frac{1}{2}\xi)\left(l_{mgf}\right)^{ab}\right]\big\}\ , , \nonumber\\ \gamma_{c}^{fin}&=&\frac{1}{4 } \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } \ , d^2\theta \ , i^{ab}(p ) \ , \big\{\left(l_{maxw}\right)^{ab}-\left(l_{mgf}\right)^{ab}\big\}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a result , the total pure gauge contribution to the two - point gauge superpotential function is @xmath73.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , we find that both nonlocal maxwell and the gauge - fixing actions are generated by quantum corrections , and there is no gauge in which any of them vanish . note that the chern - simons term is not generated here . the only source for the chern - simons term as a quantum correction is the coupling to the matter ( see fig . [ fig2 ] ) in which case we obtained the following contribution to the two - point gauge superpotential function @xcite , @xmath74\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath75 } \left [ \begin{array}{c } a^{cad}a^{dbc } \\ 2 f_l^{ab}(k,\,p ) \end{array } \right ] \,.\ ] ] in eq . ( [ final ] ) , the upper ( lower ) row corresponds to the fundamental ( adjoint ) representation for the matter field . an equivalent form for @xmath76 is @xmath77,\ ] ] where @xmath78 we stress that the simplicity of eq . ( [ t2p1 ] ) depends on the relation ( [ relplanar ] ) , which enforces the cancellation of additional finite terms that would appear in eq . ( [ t2p1 ] ) if the generators @xmath11 were not in the fundamental representation of @xmath1 . the above results show explicitly the generation of nonlocal maxwell and chern - simons terms . from eq . ( [ t2p1 ] ) , we find that the radiative corrections to the original chern - simons coefficient @xmath79 turn out to be @xmath80\,.\ ] ] here , @xmath81 is the sign function . recalling the completeness relation satisfied by the generators of the @xmath0 group in the fundamental representation , @xmath82 , and that the value of @xmath83 in this representation is @xmath84 , one obtains @xmath85\,.\ ] ] for the matter in the fundamental representation , the above result is similar to the ones found in the literature for nonsupersymmetric theories @xcite , where a shift proportional to @xmath86 was also found . on the other hand , when matter is in the adjoint representation , the shift only appears for the non - abelian components of the gauge superpotential . this is consistent with the absence of this shift in the abelian theory , as can be seen from our calculations in @xcite . we studied the quantum dynamics of the noncommutative supersymmetric chern - simons theory with an arbitrary gauge group , in the one - loop approximation . our first result consists in the fact that the cancellation of the nonintegrable ( linear ) uv / ir infrared divergences occurs only if the generators of the gauge group are in the fundamental representation of @xmath0 . this condition is the same as the one found for the four - dimensional super - yang - mills @xcite and the three - dimensional super - yang - mills @xcite theories in spite of the radical difference between their superfield formulations . we have also calculated the finite one - loop corrections to the gauge superpotencial two - point function , and we verified that a nonlocal maxwell and the corresponding gauge fixing terms are generated from the pure gauge sector . we note that none of them vanish in any gauge . from the matter radiative corrections , besides the nonlocal maxwell , a chern - simons term is also induced . if the matter is in the fundamental representation , there is a shift in the classical chern - simons coefficient proportional to @xmath86 . interestingly enough , for the matter in the adjoint representation , the chern - simons coefficient receives quantum corrections only for the non - abelian components of the gauge superpotential . this work was partially supported by fundao de amparo pesquisa do estado de so paulo ( fapesp ) and conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ( cnpq ) . the work of a. f. f. was supported by fapesp , project 04/13314 - 4 . p. has been supported by cnpq - fapesq , dcr program ( cnpq project 350400/2005 - 9 ) .

in this work , we study the three - dimensional non - abelian noncommutative supersymmetric chern - simons model with the @xmath0 gauge group . using a superfield formulation , we prove that , for the pure gauge theory , the green functions are one - loop finite in any gauge , if the gauge superpotential belongs to the fundamental representation of @xmath1 ; this result also holds when matter in the fundamental representation is included . however , the cancellation of both ultraviolet and ultraviolet / infrared infrared divergences only happens in a special gauge if the coupling of the matter is in the adjoint representation . we also look into the finite one - loop quantum corrections to the effective action : in the pure gauge sector the maxwell together with its corresponding gauge fixing action are generated ; in the matter sector , the chern - simons term is generated , inducing a shift in the classical chern - simons coefficient .

cond-mat0509456

this paper reviews work done on atomistic modelling of martensitic phase transitions , and discusses the unresolved issues in linking various methods of modelling solid - solid phase transitions . in addition to discussing phase transitions in niti and zr , following the spirit of the meeting , i attempt to review and highlight what is not widely known or properly appreciated . my benchmark for `` what is known '' is primarily based on actual discussions with other scientists , regardless of whether it has appeared in the literature . the molecular dynamics method is in principle the most versatile way of describing solid - solid phase transitions . the crystal and interfacial structures arise automatically from the interatomic potential , as are the long range strain effects and there is no need for the implicit assumptions about microscopic detail and symmetry entailed in continuum methods . in particular , thermodynamics emerges from molecular dynamics rather than being an input , so all the fluctuations are incorporated properly . the downside of molecular dynamics is twofold - the models for interatomic forces are unreliable and the timestep is very short because it is set by the phonon vibrational frequencies which typically not relevant to nucleation and diffusive processes . it may appear that methods which access longer timescales and larger systems , such as kinetic monte carlo or phase fields are more useful , however this appearance is misleading . these methods have conspicuous success in certain systems where their assumptions are valid , but can not be applied in general . thus , molecular dynamics is an essential part of any attempt to model real materials . in this paper we discuss a number of issues and questions which have arisen from our work in molecular dynamics , but which tend to be ignored or glossed over in other techniques . along the way , i discuss a few points which appear to have been ignored in much of the literature , highlight some of the current unresolved issues and include the consensus of many discussions at the meeting in phoenix . throughout , we discuss only structural transitions , assuming the chemical composition to be constant . the transitions may then be driven either by stress or temperature . complete atomistic modelling of the shape memory effect has not yet been done . it has been delayed primarily by the lack of appropriate potentials for the interesting materials such as niti . it is likely that some information about the mechanisms could be obtained for parrinello - rahman dynamics with very simple potentials which describe the b2-b19 phase transition on cooling , however efforts to date has concentrated on the b2-b19 transition exhibited by real shape memory alloys , such as niti , and hcp - bcc in elements such as zr and ti , which do not exhibit the shape memory alloy .. the theory of the shape memory effect is straightforward : the material undergoes a martensitic transition on cooling to a lower symmetry structure , in which there is a one to one correspondence between atoms in each phase . the set of lower symmetry structures which preserve this unique relationship to the austenite is referred to as the eriksen - pitteri neighbourhood ( epn ) of the austenite . deformation of the martensite occurs by twin boundary motion , again preserving the epn . the standard theory for shape memory alloys required that at no point in the transformation or deformation of the structure do the atoms leave this epn . a minimum constraint here is that the transition is displacive , not diffusive@xcite there is also a two - way shape memory effect , in which the high - symmetry austenite phase stores a memory of the low - symmetry martensite phase . this effect is not usually so pronounced , and can not be explained in terms of epn - a high symmetry phase can not lie in the epn of the low symmetry one . avogadro s is one of the larger numbers , but it is nt always infinite thermodynamics is a continuum limit approximation to statistical mechanics . statistical mechanics is a probabilistic approximation to the chaotic dynamics of particles . at base , everything is made of atoms and electrons . gibbs free energy is thus an emergent property of particle dynamics . in bulk materials , it is an exceptionally good one - when averaging over say 1022 atoms the statistical errors are around 10 - 11 , so for any practical purpose we can treat thermodynamics as an exact theory for bulk phases at equilibrium . the notion of a driving force based on a differential of a free energy is less well motivated since the existence of a gradient means that the system is out of equilibrium . strictly speaking , the maxwell - boltzmann distribution underlying statistical mechanics then does not apply , and so nor does equilibrium thermodynamics . again , we are saved by a division of time and lengthscales . the entropic contribution in crystalline solids is contained in phonon vibrations , whose frequency is many orders of magnitude greater than the typical timescales of a phase transition . similarly , the typical lengthscales involved in microstructures are several orders of magnitude larger than interatomic spacings . thus we can usually regard local regions as being at equilibrium because a sufficiently large number of atoms are vibrating for a sufficiently long time for the approximations underlying thermodynamics to be valid . the movement of interfaces driven by a free energy difference is similarly ill - defined . one can envisage two limits , in one the interface moves freely back and forth on a timescale much faster than its net drift . this is a promising case for using free energy differences , since the system is sampling both phases efficiently . in other cases the interface is sessile - unable to move thermally , and tends to advance by a stick - slip process . in neither case , however , is the rate of motion of the interface given by the free energy gradient - one has to introduce some arbitrary timescale . in simple cases , where only a few types of interfaces are present , there may be only one timescale , so the dynamics of the transition can be captured correctly . in more complex cases where some boundaries are sessile and others mobile , the transition kinetics and resultant microstructure will be primarily determined by boundary mobility rather than bulk free energies . in continuum modelling of martensites , the interface sets an energy , and hence length , scale . in real materials the interfacial energy varies strongly with angle , and has cusps at special values ( so called low sigma boundaries ) . normally they are atomically sharp , which presents a further challenge thus methods based directly on thermodynamics will become a problem in very fast transitions ( e.g. shock waves on martensites ) or extremely fine microstructures ( the canonical example being a glass transition@xcite . the interfacial plane between two solid phases of the same composition , with one having transformed from the other , may be uniquely determined if the transition mechanism is known . where the transition mechanism is assumed to be purely displacive , the interfacial plane is purely determined by crystalline geometry - the invariant plane . this is defined by taking a slice through the unit cell of each crystal such that the two faces are identical in area and shape . the requirement for the transformation to occur on an invariant plane has some microstructural consequences : any volume change must be absorbed by contraction of the cell normal to the interface plane , this generates a strain energy around a nucleating region : hence growth in this direction is hindered and martensite typically grows as a plate . in general , the invariant plane is at an arbitrary angle to the crystallographic directions . the invariant plane should not be confused with the transformation mechanism . this determines how the atoms get from their positions in one crystal structure to their positions in the other . after the material is fully transformed , it is the transformation mechanism which determines the orientation of one grain to another . it is essential for analysis of the md that some we have some way of assigning individual atoms to particular twins or crystal structures . this process is rather arbitrary , but a good method is to use the distribution of cosines of angles to nearest neighbours to distinguish structures . this allows one to determine fcc , hcp and bcc regions of a crystal , and at the same time determine the orientation of the structures.@xcite atomistic simulation gives the possibility of studying martensitic phase transitions without any of the assumptions required in the continuum approaches . the interatomic potential used determines whether the simulation reflects any particular material , however the topological and geometric features arising will be generic . from a number of simulations carried out on zirconium , the detailed structure of the twin boundary emerges as the crucial feature for the dynamics . details of boundary structure is generally ignored in the continuum or phase field approaches , at best boundaries are assumed to have some constant energy or behaviour irrespective of orientation . however , for shape memory effect the boundary must be capable of moving without leaving the epn the austenite . this places constraints on the mechanism by which the boundary can move . in transitions from bcc via the nishiyama - wassermann mechanism the ( 110)@xmath0 planes convert to basal ( 0001)@xmath1 planes in hcp . different hcp variants arise from different original sets of ( 110)@xmath0 . this means that the variants must be rotated with respect to each other by 30 or 60 degrees . if one investigates the high temperature crystal structure of zr on cooling from the bcc phase prior to the transition , the structure is found to fluctuate@xcite , a snapshot being shown in fig[joneszr ] . in this figure we see the effects of stress - induced preferential nucleation . in the bcc - hcp transformation , the strain along the ( 111)@xmath0 direction ( a line of near neighbours ) is small ( perpendicular to the plane ) thus once the materials begins to transform to an hcp variant , and large stress filed is developed in the plane , which induces a transformation into the other two variants which share the particular ( 111)@xmath0 plane . thus the stress nucleates cp basal planes from the @xmath2 and @xmath3 planes . this rapid nucleation gives rise to a columnar microstructure fig[joneszr ] . however , these variants can not tile a plane with all interfaces being 60 degrees . in this nanostructured material , the large boundary energy of the 30 degree twin is sufficient to prevent a microstructure comprising only these three variants . what appears is a region of fcc , stabilised by the low energy of the interface between it and the adjacent hcp ( the interface is simply a basal stacking ) . the existence of metastable crystal phases close to the martensitic transition is reported in many systems , notably the r phase in niti . they are usually referred to as `` intermediate '' phases , often with the implication that they are thermodynamically stable over a small region . this simulations suggests another picture , the intermediate phases ( r in niti , fcc here ) actually are stabilised at the nanoscale both by the strain field of the precritical hcp phase nuclei and their very low interfacial energy . as the structure coarsens , they become metastable but their elimination may be kinetically hindered . the existence of such metastable phases could play a important role in compensating the strain field , and delaying the full transformation to martensite . .energy function and parameters for zirconium potential where @xmath4 is the heaviside step function , @xmath5 is the separation between atoms @xmath6 and @xmath7 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : coeff ] the angle between martensitic twins formed by cooling from an austenite is fully determined by crystal structure and transition mechanism . there is no reason for it to be a low energy boundary . in the case of zirconium it turns out that the 30 degree boundary is very high energy and is not seen in the simulations . this restricts the variants which can be observed . it is well established that the strain minimising microstructure is a laminate of twins , and the boundary energy difference means they are always 60 degree tilt this is clearly seen in the simulations . a @xmath8 tilt is close to the a @xmath9 symmetric tilt boundary of the @xmath10 twin , a cusp in the energy vs angle graph and with low boundary energy ( 0.58mjm@xmath11 according to this potential ) . for an isolated twin boundary , the discrepancy in angle is made up by twinning dislocations , however , when the twins are small these dissociate into partial twinning dislocations with a basal stacking fault extending through the twins@xcite . the structure is shown in figure[maytwin ] . the density of twin boundary partial dislocations is determined by crystal geometry ( in particular , the c / a ratio of hcp zirconium ) . thus to simulate a real material , using a potential which reproduces the lattice parameters accurately is crucial . as explained elsewhere in these proceedings@xcite a twin boundary dislocation is free to glide in the twin only if its burgers vector lies in the twin plane . this is not the case for the twin boundary partial dislocations in figure[maytwin ] . thus the twin boundary can not move in a diffusionless manner by motion of these twin boundary partial dislocations . the boundary does move , however , in response to external stress@xcite . the role of twin boundary partial dislocations is to act as stress concentrators which cause nucleation of other twin boundary dislocation which are mobile in the boundary . the mechanism is similar to that observed for the interaction of a crystal dislocation with a twin boundary @xcite . in the absence of the twin boundary partial dislocations , there is no source for mobile dislocations and so a perfect @xmath10 twin can not move@xcite niti is the canonical example of a shape memory alloy . ideally one would like to do calculations with a potential for niti , which described the high - t b2 phase , the low - t b19 phase and the metastable r phase . in this section we discuss the problems encountered in generating such a potential . the b2-b19 phase transition observed in niti can be simply understood in terms of the nishiyama - wassermann - type mechanism observed in zirconium ( see fig.[nitixtal ] . if one ignores the difference between ni and ti atoms , b2 is simply bcc , the different species do not disrupt the cubic symmetry . b19 has the same symmetry as hcp , except that the two species break hexagonal symmetry making the structure to tetragonal . b19 is a small distortion from b19 . we might thus hope that similar potentials to those used in zirconium would work for niti . experimental data for stress - free single crystal niti martensite is very hard to obtain . crystallography has been done on samples prepared by strain - induced transformation above the martensite start temperature , followed by quenching to ambient condition@xcite . it is unclear whether such crystals are strain - free . in the absence of detailed calorimetry for the phase transition energies , the standard way to proceed in making potentials is to generate a database of ab initio energies . there are many free parameters in the b19 structure , and great care has to be taken to ensure the true minimum is found@xcite . when this is done , it turns out that the dft minimum energy structure is different from that found in the experiment - the @xmath12 angle in b19 is 107@xcite rather than 98 degrees@xcite . moreover , 107 degrees is exactly the right angle to create a doubled unit cell with tetragonal symmetry - the b33 structure . this conflict between dft and experimental energetics makes it difficult to attempt to fit a potential to niti combining data from each . this explains why little progress has been made on the problem to date . one way to avoid the problem with lack of accurate potentials is to use ab initio molecular dynamics dft calculations for direct calculations of the microstructure . we have carried out density functional calculations based on pseudopotentials and plane waves using the vasp code , of up to 100 atoms in the b2 phase , cooling using a nose thermostat from 400 - 200k , then quenching to 0k for analysis . two supercell geometries were tried , in one the cell was orientated along ( 100 ) , ( 0@xmath131 ) , ( 011 ) requiring 64 atoms , while in the other ( 0@xmath131 ) , ( @xmath1311 ) ( 211 ) with 96 atoms was used . the classical work with zirconium indicated that this may prove too small , and certainly finite size effect will be significant , and the 96 atom cell attempted to ease that problem being only 5a thick in the z - direction on cooling the structures dropped out of the bcc phases . we used the angle based analysis@xcite to assign hcp , fcc or bcc crystal structures . for a displacive transition , these would pick up local b19 , l1@xmath14 or b2 alloy structures respectively . the 64 atom simulation ( figure.[dft ] ) remained almost entirely to a single phase strained bcc structure . the 96 atom cell , despite its high aspect ratio , was also too small to show any significant change from distorted bcc . the fully quenched structure has not gone back to b2 : there is some evidence of a transformation towards an l1@xmath15 or b19 structure in a few atoms , but the best description of the configuration is as distorted b2 . as with the metastable fcc phase in zirconium , the simulations of niti show that nanosized structures can impose stabilizing strains on the existing structure . moreover , the formation energy of its boundary may be high enough to to alter the stable crystal structure in microstructures aat a given lengthscale . in conclusion , we have shown that in going from the atomistic scale to the continuum in describing martensitic microstructures the following features are important : * the relative orientation of twins is defined by crystal symmetry , and will not normally coincide with a low energy twin boundary . the twin boundary might be a low - energy boundary with an array of geometrically necessary dislocations , but in general these dislocations will be sessile . * some geometrically - allowed boundaries between twins may not appear because of their high energy . * sessile twin - boundary dislocations may act as stress concentrators , and thence as sources for mobile dislocations which allow the boundary to advance . * nanoscale microstructures may stabilise different crystal structures from the thermodynamic limit , either inhibiting their appearance through the energy cost of twin boundaries , or allowing an altogether different phase with lower interface costs to nucleate . * twin boundary energy and mobility varies sharply depending on the boundary orientation . continuum models need to take this into account . the effects of nanostructure in stabilizing certain crystal structures outwith their thermodynamic stability ranges offers an resolution to a number of phenomena observed experimentally but ignored in phase - field and similar models . the nanostructure creates a variety of local environments subject to differing inhomogeneous stress whose minimisation calls for a variety of required interfaces . in particular metastable `` intermediate '' phases may be stabilised by particularly favourable local regions of stress and interface energies low energies . moreover , the relative stability of austenite and martensite varies in different regions of the crystal depending of the local stress environment . hence both can coexist at the same macroscopic ( i.e. average ) conditions of temperature and pressure . this explains at the microscopic level the existence of distinct `` martensite start '' and `` martensite finish '' temperatures . there remains a need to simulate a binary alloy undergoing a b2-b19 transition in order to understand the atomic level behaviour of the shape memory effect . there remains a discrepancy between the theoretical perfect crystal structures for niti martensite , and experimental measurement . this discrepancy is serious , in that the theoretical structure does not even lie in the epn of b2 . a resolution is offered that the theoretical structure is very soft in shear@xcite and so small internal stresses will recover the experimental value . this offers the possibility that the shape memory effect is in part due to microstructural stress , which offers a mechanism for the two - way effect . * acknowledgements : * the author would like to thank colleagues u.pinsook , k.rabe and x.huang for assistence with the simulations described here , and the organisers and other participants at ptm2005 for stimulation in writing this paper . this paper discusses issues across a wide range of methodologies , and author would like to apologise for his ignorance of some areas of the literature . 99 the entropy of a glass remains problematic . in particular , should one include the configurational entropy of all possible glass structures as in the liquid . the argument for doing so is that on glassification the system could choose any such structure - a large phase space volume , however once the glassification process is complete the system is frozen into one small region of phase space , and can not sample `` equivalent '' structures in the way statistical mechanics assumes . the zirconium potential used in this work gives far too low a stacking fault energy , so this dissociation may not occur in real zirconium . `` the theory of transformations in metals and alloys '' , j.w.chr istian ( pergamon oxford 1975 ) this defect is sometimes called a hexagonal translation twin : see _ theory of crystal dislocations _ frn nabarro p202 ( dover , 1987 ) k.bhattacharya _ microstructure of martensite _ ( oup , ox ford 2003 . ) g.j.ackland and a.jones , submitted ( 2005 ) g. j. ackland , s. j. wooding , and d. j. bacon , philos . mag . a 71 , 553 ( 1995 ) x. huang , km rabe and gj ackland nature materials 2 307 ( 2003 ) u.pinsook and g.j.ackland , phys.rev.b , 58 , 11252 ( 1998 ) u.pinsook and g.j.ackland phys . rev . b 59 , 13642 ( 1999 ) u.pinsook and g.j.ackland phys rev.b 62 5427 ( 2000 ) y.kudoh et al acta.metall.mater 33 , 2049 ( 1985 ) pond , rc , serra , a and bacon , dj , acta.materialia 47 1441 ( 1999 ) pond , rc , these proceedings there is some confusion as to the precise meaning of displacive and diffusive at the atomic level . here , i take displacive to mean that each atom in one structure can be mapped to a particular site in the other . this does not preclude transformations involving shuffles , or those proceeding by nucleation and growth .

this paper reviews the status of molecular dynamics as a method in describing solid - solid phase transitions , and its relationship to continuum approaches@xcite . simulation work done in niti and zr using first principles and semi - empirical potentials is presented . this shows failures of extending equilibrium thermodynamics to the nanoscale , and the crucial importance of system - specific details to the dynamics of martensite formation . the inconsistency between experimental and theoretical crystal structures in niti is described , together with its possible resolution in terms of nanoscale effects .

1412.3335

in part 1 of this lecture series we discuss two topics : * computational models based on the concept of the continuum * extended proof systems for more efficient certificates of optimality in the part 2 of this lecture series , we describe efficient evaluation methods for the effect of exponential number of constraints in the context of continuum based algorithms.we illustrate these ideas by considering concrete examples of finding maximum independent set in a graph and the satisfiability problem . objective function for these problems is treated by non - convex optimization methods covered in part 3 . a model of computation provides mathematical abstractions of basic data objects and operations on those objects , available as building blocks . this effectively decouples design of algorithms for complex tasks from lower level details of how the underlying hardware implements the basic primitives . the turing machine model uses strings of 0 s and 1 s and finite state machines . careful study of the work of early pioneers turing , von neumann and godel shows that they were acutely aware of the limitations of this model for comprehensive understanding of the fundamental aspects of computation . bss model(blum , shub , smale ) uses real or complex numbers as data objects and algebraic operations ( including comparisons in real case ) . this is more natural for many algorithms in numerical analysis , whereas turing machine model might seem more appropriate for discrete applications . * numerical simulation of natural phenomena or engineered systems based on differential equations * estimation of probabilities , assessing strength of association between various entities in social networks * interior point algorithms in optimization which are based on embedding discrete configurations in a multidimensional continuous space and constructing trajectories converging to the solution * standard digital computers * analog computers explored in the past e.g. shannon s differential analyzer * quantum computers * biological systems that appear to do information processing / computing * computers inspired by biological systems and partially mimicking some aspects of those systems + e.g. neural networks , neuromorphic computing , etc . * * alan turing * was interested in understanding the origin of intelligence in biological systems he believed it is due to some form of computing happening in these systems . however , there does nt seem to be anything similar to turing machines in these systems . many years after developing the discrete model of computation , turing started exploration of partial differential equations modelling biological functions these are clearly continuum based models of biological systems . * * von neumann * defined architecture of a digital computer using many ideas from turing machine model . however , he was particularly critical of the limitations imposed on the theory of automata by its foundations in formal logic , combinatorics . he articulated the need for a detailed , highly mathematical , and more specifically , analytical theory of computation based on mathematical analysis . * * shannon * worked on analog computer called differential analyzer . however , direct implementation of differentiation in analog system is highly error prone as it involves subtraction of two nearly equal continuous quantities . * * role of integration and integral transform * * * it s well known that for certain non - linear differential equations which are difficult to solve numerically , it helps to convert them into equivalent integral equations . * * biological systems seem to use integral transform . e.g. human ear essentially computes the magnitude of fourier transform of speech signal.the transform of the derivative is then obtained by scaling , a simpler algebraic operation than differentiation in analog setting . * * some optical computers are implementing fourier transform directly for computing differential operators required in computational fluid dynamic * * form of integration or convolution restricted to non - negative real functions is easier to provide in a physical system . * * robustness * * * in digial systems , the mapping from + + * physical states * / * quantities * @xmath0 * information states*/*quantities * + + is many to one , in fact , each information state has infinite pre images . * * this is to gain robustness in the face of small variations in physical states , due to noise , thermal effects , variations in manufacturing etc . * * however , this does not necessarily require information states to be discrete . e.g. an ideal low pass filter also provides infinity to one mapping but the output signal still belongs to the continuum . logical and physical processes underlying computation involves several levels of abstractions , both continuous and discrete . let us examine a specific application solution of a non - linear differential equation . * this application and algorithm used for solution are both based on continuous model . * real numbers in the continuous model are approximated by floating point arithmetic for mapping onto the discrete turing machine model . * the computer implementing discrete turing machine model is actually a network of transistors . as a circuit , it is modeled by a system of non - linear differential equations . restricted interpretation is applied to continuous quantities . e.g. continuous time is divided into clock cycles bigger than settling time of the transient solution to the differential equations , to create discrete time steps.voltage greater than certain threshold voltage represents logical one . in this way , the discrete logical model is supported by the underlying circuit - level continuous model . * this continuous circuit model is itself approximating underlying discrete phenomenon : * * continuous , fluid - like model of current flow , for approximating the statistical mechanics of large number of discrete particles ( electrons and holes in a semiconductor ) * * continuous energy bands ( valence and conduction bands ) representing large number of closely spaced quantized energy levels * the underlying quantum mechanical phenomenon is modelled mathematically by the concept of hilbert space which is based on the continuum concept . similarly , more recent and on - going model of physics is based on string theory , which again requires the concept of the continuum . [ [ given - this - intertwining - of - discrete - and - continuous - models - from - top - to - bottom - it - would - be - more - illuminating - to - take - a - broader - view - of - theory - of - computing .- in - addition - to - the - discrete - turing - machine - model - one - also - needs - to - explore - continuous - models - for - a - comprehensive - understanding - of - the - fundamental - aspects - of - computation .- bss - model - uses - real - or - complex - numbers - as - data - objects - and - algebraic - operations - including - comparisons - in - real - case-.-this - is - more - natural - for - many - algorithms - in - numerical - analysis . ] ] given this intertwining of discrete and continuous models from top to bottom , it would be more illuminating to take a broader view of theory of computing . in addition to the discrete turing machine model , one also needs to explore continuous models for a comprehensive understanding of the fundamental aspects of computation . bss model uses real or complex numbers as data objects and algebraic operations ( including comparisons in real case ) . this is more natural for many algorithms in numerical analysis . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + [ [ various - computing - models - can - be - organized - in - a - similar - way - as - cantor - had - organized - infinite - sets - by - cardinal - number - of - the - set - of - all - possible - machines - and - data - objects - in - the - model .- staying - within - the - same - cardinal - number - a - more - powerful - approach - is - to - use - further - extension - e.g - real - analytic - functions - or - algebraic - closure - of - meromorphic - functions - over - suitable - domains .- operations - include - algebraic - as - well - as - analytic - operations .- i.e .- integration - and - differentiation - regarded - as - binary - operations .- specification - of - the - contour - of - integration - is - one - of - the - input - operands ] ] various computing models can be organized in a similar way as cantor had organized infinite sets by cardinal number of the set of all possible machines and data objects in the model . staying within the same cardinal number , a more powerful approach is to use further extension , e.g real analytic functions or algebraic closure of meromorphic functions over suitable domains . operations include algebraic as well as analytic operations . i.e. integration and differentiation regarded as binary operations . ( specification of the contour of integration is one of the input operands ) + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + [ [ all-such-models-that-use-both-algebraic-and-analytical-operations-on-continuous-data-objects-are-collectively-referred-to-as-continuum-computing.our-research-program-is-aimed-at-exploration-of-what-a-continuum-view-of-computing-might-suggest-for-science-of-algorithms-relative-difficulty-of-various-computing-tasks-etc . ] ] all such models that use both algebraic and analytical operations on continuous data objects are collectively referred to as continuum computing.our research program is aimed at exploration of what a continuum view of computing might suggest for science of algorithms , relative difficulty of various computing tasks etc . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + [ [ abstract - continuum - computing - model - ac2m - or - cm - for - short ] ] * abstract continuum computing model @xmath1 or @xmath2 for short * ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ * * basic data objects * + algebraic closure of meromorphic functions ( over suitable domain ) * * basic unit operations * * * * field operations * : @xmath3 + and additionally for real quantities comparison @xmath4 * * * analytic operations * * * * * integration * : @xmath5 this is a binary operation , function @xmath6 and specification contour @xmath7 are the two operands * * * * differentiation * : @xmath8 is also a binary operation with inputs @xmath6 and @xmath9 . * computing models can be organized in the same way as cantor organized infinite sets i.e. according to the cardinal number + of set of all possible data objects and machines in the model . * at each cardinal number in the sequence @xmath11 , you have models of computation , and corresponding @xmath10 question @xmath12 * it appears that @xmath10 problem for tm is just the first member in a sequence of strict inclusions @xmath13 * an interesting question across adjacent level : + [ cols= " < , < " , ] * construct `` mobius completion matrix '' @xmath17 from special edges as follows : @xmath18 } \nonumber\\ m_c(z , \textbf{x})_{\bar{i } , i } & = & e^{z \left [ 1 + x_i \right ] } \nonumber\\ m_c(z , \textbf{x})_{i , j } & = & 0 ~~\text{if } j \neq \bar{i } ~~~~\{\text{note : } \bar{\bar{i } } = i\ } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] * define walk matrix @xmath19 as before , except that we include all walks ( odd and even ) upto length @xmath20 , where @xmath21 number of clauses . @xmath22 * for each walk , there is a `` mirror - image '' walk obtained by complementing all the nodes in t he walk , hence factor of 2 in the denominator * multiplication by @xmath23 also achieves the transition from implied to sharper inequalities . the combined effect is given by + @xmath24 * lengths of mobius cycles have expontential effect on resolution . in contrast , we are able to include the effect of mobius cycles of all lengths in polynomial number of operations . + the remaining part of computation is similar to the case of maximum independent set problem . 1 v. chvatal and e. szemeredi . many hard examples for resolution . journal of the acm , 35(4):759768 , oct 1988 . n. k. karmarkar . beyond convexity : new perspectives in computa- tional optimization . in proceedings of simulated evolution and learning ( seal ) - 8th international conference , kanpur , india , pages 123 , december 1 - 4 , 2010 . a. schrijver . combinatorial optimization : polyhedra and efficiency , volume 24 of algorithms and combinatorics . springer verlag , 2003 . karmarkar n. , riemannian geometry underlying interior point methods for lp , ams , contemporary mathematics 114,5175,summer research conference 1988 .

beginning with the projectively invariant method for linear programming , interior point methods have led to powerful algorithms for many difficult computing problems , in combinatorial optimization , logic , number theory and non - convex optimization . algorithms for convex optimization benefitted from many pre - established ideas from classical mathematics , but non - convex problems require new concepts . + + lecture series i am presenting at the conference on foundations of computational mathematics , 2014 , outlines some of these concepts computational models based on the concept of the continuum , algorithms invariant w.r.t . projective , bi - rational , and bi - holomorphic transformations on co - ordinate representation , extended proof systems for more efficient certificates of optimality , extensions of grassmann s extension theory , efficient evaluation methods for the effect of exponential number of constraints , theory of connected sets based on graded connectivity , theory of curved spaces adapted to the problem data , and concept of `` relatively '' algebraic sets in curved space . + + since this conference does not have a proceedings , the purpose of this article is to provide the material being presented at the conference in more widely accessible form .

0712.1858

short - period comets are originally composed of ices and dust that were present in the cold comet - formation region of the primordial solar nebula . when the comets leave the trans - neptunian region and approach the sun , volatile components of its nucleus begin to sublime . expanding volatile gases drag light dust having a large surface - to - volume ratio and leave preferentially heavy dust of a small surface - to - volume ratio on the surface of a comet to form a dust mantle ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * for a review ) . indeed , optical and infrared observations of cometary comae suggest that large compact aggregates of tens of micrometers or larger lie in a dust mantle with depleted volatile materials , while large fluffy aggregates are embedded with volatile materials below the dust mantle @xcite . dust mantle formation itself does not differentiate the composition of the aggregates , while chemical differentiation of a nucleus takes place owing to preferential sublimation losses of highly volatile materials in deeper parts of the nucleus . pristine amorphous water ices also crystallize to form a crystalline ice crust just below the dust mantle . in addition , impact cratering by interplanetary bodies affects the surface evolution of the nucleus ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . therefore , primordial materials in comet nuclei remain only in the deepest region far below the dust mantle . the above mentioned scenario for the evolution of a comet nucleus ( hereafter referred to as the standard model ) is applicable to comet 9p / tempel 1 ( hereafter , t1 ) , the target of nasa s deep impact ( di ) mission : numerical studies on thermal evolution of the t1 nucleus predict the formation of a dust mantle with a thickness of @xmath0 m and a crystalline ice crust with a thickness of @xmath2@xmath3 m below the mantle @xcite . observations of t1 during the di event gave us a good opportunity of examining the standard model for the t1 nucleus , because di excavated the t1 nucleus up to @xmath4@xmath5 m depth ( e.g. , * ? ? ? plenty of di observational results support the standard model : ( 1 ) the presence of a dust mantle on t1 is evidenced by a low thermal inertia of the nucleus estimated from its thermal maps @xcite ; ( 2 ) near - infrared spectroscopic observations of volatiles excavated by the di event revealed thermal processing of the layers below the dust mantle @xcite ; ( 3 ) the existence of large compact dust in the pre impact t1 coma has been reported by many researchers @xcite . the existence of such large dust in the pre impact t1 is consistent with the standard model , because the dust mantle formation depletes only fluffy aggregates . however , recent several researchers drew a peculiar picture of a comet nucleus from their observations of the ejecta plume produced by the di event ( hereafter , di ejecta plume ) . subaru telescope observation ( sto ) by @xcite showed that the outer part of the di ejecta plume ( high - velocity ejecta ) have a higher color temperature and lower infrared silicate - feature strengths than the inner part of the di ejecta plume ( low - velocity ejecta ) . they attributed the high - velocity ejecta to submicron - sized carbonaceous grains and the low - velocity ejecta to submicron - sized silicate grains . as a result , they proposed that the near - surface region of t1 is covered by a pristine crust of submicron - sized carbonaceous grains ( hereafter , pristine carbon crust ) , which were created by cosmic rays in the trans - neptunian region . in addition , they interpreted the existence of many craters observed by @xcite as evidence of a long surface retention age of the pristine carbon crust . this means that the nucleus of a comet does not form a dust mantle during its close approaches to the sun . they also claim that the pristine carbon crust is very thin ( several tens of cm ) based on the ejection velocity and their estimate of the amount of carbonaceous grains . finally , they concluded that even at a depth of only several tens of cm below the surface comet materials keep their primordial composition together with submicron - sized silicate grains . @xcite supported this interpretation by measuring slightly higher linear polarizations for the high - velocity ejecta compared to the low - velocity ejecta . @xcite also supported these interpretations from their infrared observations . these conclusions ( hereafter , kfh model ) completely contradict our conventional images of comet nuclei based on the standard model . note that the difference in the color temperature between high- and low - velocity ejecta may simply reflect the amount of volatile materials , because color temperatures depend on the volatile content @xcite . it is also worth noting that the silicate feature strength is not a good indicator of an amount of silicate grains nor their sizes @xcite ; large fluffy aggregates of tens of micrometers or larger show strong silicate features , while large compact aggregates of the same composition and mass show weaker silicate features @xcite . furthermore , the degree of linear polarization for aggregates may slightly vary with their porosity and/or volatile content @xcite . in this study , we examine how well the standard model can explain the available observational data of the di event by calculating color temperature , silicate feature strength , and polarization for aggregates in the framework of the standard model . we then discuss the advantage of the standard model over the kfh model even when comparing with the results of @xcite who analyzed the same sto data as @xcite ( hereafter , we refer @xcite and @xcite as to sto - k and sto - s , respectively ) . we also discuss the groundless interpretations of the long retention age of the t1 primordial surface and the thickness of its dust mantle based on comprehensive observational and theoretical considerations . we calculate the color temperature @xmath6 , the silicate feature strength @xmath7 , and the degree of linear polarization @xmath8 for the standard model as follows . in the standard model , large compact aggregates exist in a dust mantle and large fluffy aggregates are embedded with volatiles below the dust mantle @xcite . to describe large aggregates , we use fractal clusters of @xmath9 identical monomers with a radius of @xmath10 @xcite . each monomer is assumed to have a concentric structure of an organic refractory outer layer , a forsteritic inner layer , and an amorphous silicate core @xcite . the compact aggregates are assumed to have a fractal dimension @xmath11 , which corresponds to the value when the maximum compression of fluffy aggregates is attained @xcite . our calculation using the superposition t - matrix method ( tmm ) showed that the geometric albedo of the compact aggregates is @xmath12 at visible wavelengths ( see * ? ? ? * ) , and this value is identical to the albedo derived from an observation of the t1 surface ( ahearn et al . 2005 ) . we also calculate @xmath13 ( the ratio of solar radiation pressure to solar gravity ) for the compact aggregates , using mie theory with the optical constants deduced from the maxwell - garnett mixing rule ( mg ) ( see * ? ? ? * ) : this is also consistent with @xmath14 for high - velocity ejecta within the di ejecta plume ( e.g. , * ? ? ? . similarly , let large fluffy aggregates embedded with volatile materials below the dust mantle be presented by fractal clusters with @xmath15 @xcite . @xcite found the @xmath16 feature of solid h@xmath17o ice in their observations of the di ejecta plume . sublimation of volatiles within the ejecta seems to have lasted over the course of a few days @xcite . we thus consider ongoing sublimation of volatiles in the fluffy aggregates and assume that a few percent of volatiles in volume still remain on the surface of the aggregates . ( for a comparison , we also consider volatile free fluffy aggregates ) . we then derive the absorption cross sections @xmath18 for the compact and fluffy aggregates , using mie theory with the optical constants deduced from the mg ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the use of the mg for aggregates has been examined based on the discrete dipole approximation ( dda ) @xcite . from values of @xmath18 at wavelengths @xmath19 of @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 where sto - k observed , we calculate the color temperature as @xmath23 and the silicate - feature strength as @xmath24 . we also calculate @xmath8 at @xmath25 and at a phase angle of the di event for these aggregates . since @xmath8 does not strongly depend on the number of monomers , we perform numerical calculations with clusters of 256 monomers by using the dda and the tmm . all the results are listed in table 1 . we first interpret the observational data by sto - k . table 1 shows that the compact aggregate has higher @xmath6 and lower @xmath7 than the volatile coated fluffy aggregate . impact cratering mechanism indicates that high - velocity ejecta are thrown from near surface regions and low - velocity ejecta contain primarily materials excavated from deeper regions ( e.g. , * ? ? ? thus , a natural expectation in the standard model is that high - velocity ejecta in the di ejecta plume would have higher @xmath6 and lower @xmath7 than the low - velocity ejecta . this agrees with the observational data by sto - k that show the high - velocity ( @xmath26 m s@xmath27 ) ejecta to have higher @xmath6 and lower @xmath7 than the low - velocity ejecta ( @xmath28 m s@xmath27 ) . we next compare the polarimetric observation by @xcite with @xmath8 in table 1 . table 1 shows that the both aggregates have a positive polarization and that @xmath8 for the compact aggregates ( the high velocity ejecta ) is larger than that for the fluffy aggregates ( the low velocity ejecta ) . this is consistent with the observation by @xcite who showed that the high velocity ejecta have a slightly higher @xmath8 compared to the low velocity ejecta . the sto data at time @xmath29 hrs after the di event are shown by sto - s as infrared spectra at various radial distances . we also interpret the sto - s data by estimating the radial distributions of @xmath30 and @xmath31 from the data , where @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 being the sto intensity at a wavelength @xmath19 of @xmath20 , @xmath21 , or @xmath22 , respectively . figure [ f:1 ] shows that both @xmath30 and @xmath31 at @xmath29 hrs have the same peak position at @xmath35@xmath36 . we consider that the peaks represent low velocity , volatile free fluffy aggregates , because ( 1 ) the peak position is within the expected position ( @xmath37@xmath38 ) of the low - velocity ejecta at @xmath29 hrs ; ( 2 ) the peak position of the high - velocity ejecta at @xmath39 hrs is already @xmath1@xmath38 ( sto - k ) , so that the expected position at @xmath29 hrs is beyond @xmath40@xmath36 ; ( 3 ) the volatiles in the fluffy aggregates would sublime gradually through a few hours , resulting in higher @xmath6 ( see table 1 ) . thus , the sto data at @xmath29 hrs is well explained by the standard model . in summary , the optical properties of the compact and fluffy aggregates based on the standard model well account for the observational data used by sto - k , @xcite , and sto - s . in this section , we refute the following interpretations in the kfh model : ( 1 ) the presumption of the pristine carbon crust ; ( 2 ) the long retention age of the pristine carbon crust ; ( 3 ) the existence of cometary primordial materials at a depth of several tens of cm from the surface . in the kfh model , submicron sized ( @xmath41 radius ) carbonaceous grains are responsible to the @xmath30 peak within the high velocity ejecta ( @xmath26 m s@xmath27 ) . if this were correct , the carbonaceous grains in the high - velocity ejecta must have been decelerated significantly through @xmath42@xmath43 hrs , because the peak position of @xmath30 is @xmath44@xmath38 at @xmath42 hrs ( sto - k ) and proceeds to only @xmath35@xmath36 at @xmath29 hrs ( fig . [ f:1 ] ) , corresponding to an average velocity of @xmath45 m s@xmath27 . furthermore , sto - k claimed that the high - velocity ejecta ( @xmath46 m s@xmath27 ) were observed at @xmath47@xmath48 hrs by @xcite as highly polarized regions at @xmath49 . therefore , the kfh model suggests that the high - velocity ( @xmath26 m s@xmath27 ) carbonaceous grains were suddenly decelerated to @xmath50 m s@xmath27 during @xmath42@xmath43 hrs and then accelerated again to @xmath46 m s@xmath27 after @xmath29 hrs . we believe that no one could support such a dynamical behavior . a most likely explanation of the sto data is that the high - velocity ejecta expand with a nearly constant velocity over the first 20 hrs as observed by @xcite and that low - velocity ejecta is responsible to the @xmath30 peak at @xmath29 hrs . in addition , the observational constraint of @xmath13 in the high - velocity ejecta completely rules out the predominance of @xmath41 carbonaceous grains , which have @xmath51 @xcite . therefore , the pristine carbon crust is a false interpretation , unless the above contradictions are resolved . sto - k interpret the existence of craters with radii up to @xmath52 m @xcite as evidence for a long surface retention age of the pristine carbon crust , because they assumed that observable craters are produced when t1 was in the trans - neptunian region . however , @xcite himself estimated that a comet collides near - earth asteroids ( neas ) of 1 m every @xmath53 years during its approaches the sun , forming a @xmath53 m sized crater . short - period comets are also bombarded in the main asteroid belt with higher collisional probabilities than those of neas ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the model calculation by @xcite shows that the number of observable craters on t1 is around 10 for the steady state of collisional environment in the main asteroid belt and up to @xmath54 . even if we use a different parameter set with the asteroidal collision model by @xcite and @xcite , the number of @xmath52m - sized craters produced at each orbit is @xmath55 . thus , many craters with radii @xmath56 m can be formed during every approaches to the sun . furthermore , sublimation processes increase crater sizes with time @xcite , suggesting that the craters observed on t1 may have been produced by smaller impactors with more frequent impact rates . we thus conclude that the existence of craters on t1 can not be attributed to a long surface retention age . the standard model predicts the thickness of the dust mantle on t1 to be several meters or thinner @xcite . following sto - k , we could estimate the maximum depth of the region from which the compact aggregates are excavated , by using the @xmath57-model @xcite . this model allows us to estimate the maximum depth of an excavation flow ( maximum excavation depth ) for each ejecta with ejection velocity @xmath58 . as a result , we might arrive at the dust mantle thickness of several tens of cm as sto - k , but we find several problems in their assumptions . according to @xcite and @xcite , the center of an excavation flow ( flow center ) in the @xmath57model is at some depth below the surface , which may be comparable to a projectile diameter even for oblique impacts . however , sto - k assume that the flow center is at the surface . this is not correct : the actual excavation depth is the sum of the depth of flow center ( the projectile diameter , @xmath0 m ) and the maximum excavation depth . in addition , an acceleration of the ejecta due to the gas plume observed by sto - s was not taken into account . then , the value of @xmath58 used by sto - k is overestimated and the resulting thickness is underestimated . although sto - k claim that the thickness of several tens of cm is similar to that derived from the total mass of carbonaceous grains in the di ejecta plume , the presumption of the pristine carbon crust is a false interpretation , invalidating their estimate of the total mass of the carbonaceous grains . as a conservative estimate , the di results suggest that the thickness of the dust mantle is @xmath59@xmath1 m . this study was supported in part by t. yoda , a grant - in - aid for scientific research from japan society for the promotion of science , and a grant - in - aid for scientific research on priority areas from ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology , japan . ahearn , m.f . et al . 2005 , science , 310 , 258 . bar nun , a. , heifetz , e. , & prialnik , d. 1989 , , 79 , 116 britt , d.t . , et al . 2004 , , 167 , 45 . burns , j.a . , lamy , p.l . , & soter , s. 1979 , , 40 , 1 . croft , s.k . 1980 , proc . lunar planet . 11 , 2347 . de sanctis , m. c. , capria , m. t. , coradini , a. , & ammannito , e. 2007 , , 133 , 1836 . farnham , t.l . , et al . 2007 , , 187 , 26 . fern@xmath60ndez , j. a. 1981 , moon and planets , 25 , 507 furusho , r. , et al . 2007 , , 190 , 454 . hutton , r. 2000 , , 48 , 545 . gronkowski , p. 2007 , , 379 , 1049 . harker , d.e . , et al . 2007 , , 190 , 432 . hawkes , r.l . , & eaton , r.a . 2004 , earth . , moon , planets , 95 , 187 . kadono , t. 1999 , , 47 , 305 . kadono , t. et al . 2007 , 661 , l89 . kimura , h. , kolokolova , l. , and mann , i. 2003 , , 407 , l5 . kimura , h. , kolokolova , l. , & mann , i. 2006 , , 449 , 1243 . kolokolova , l. , kimura , h. , kiselev , n. , & rosenbush , v. 2007 , , 463 , 1189 . maxwell , d.e . 1977 , in impact and explosion cratering , ed . roddy , r.o . pepin , r.b . merrill ( new york : pergamon ) , 1003 . meech , k.j . 2005 , science , 310 , 265 . melosh , h.j . 1989 , in impact cratering ( new york : oxford univ . press ) . mukai , t. , & mukai , 1984 , adv . space res . , 4(9 ) , 207 . mukai , t. , ishimoto , h. , kozasa , t. , blum , j. , & greenberg , j. m. 1992 , , 262 , 315 . mumma , m.j . , et al . 2005 , science , 310 , 270 . okamoto , h. , mukai , t. , & kozasa , t. 1994 , , 42 , 643 prialnik , d. , benkhoff j. , & podolak m. 2004 , in comets ii , ed . festou , h.u . keller , & h.a . weaver ( univ . of arizona press ) , 359 . reach , w.t . , kelley , m.s . , & sykes , m.v . 2007 , , 191 , 298 . schleicher , d.g . , barnes , k.l . , & baugh , n.f . 2006 , , 131 , 1130 . sugita , s. , et al . 2005 , science , 310 , 274 . sunshine , j.m . , et al . 2007 , , 190 , 284 . sykes , m. v. , & walker , r. g. 1992 , , 95 , 180 . thomas , p.c . , et al . 2007 , , 187 , 4 . wada , k. , tanaka , h. , suyama , t. , kimura , h. , & yamamoto , t. 2007 , submitted to . yamamoto , t. , chigai , t. , & kimura , h. 2007 , submitted to . cccc & @xmath6 & @xmath7 & @xmath8 + compact aggregate & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 + volatile - coated fluffy aggregate & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 + volatile - free fluffy aggregate & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 +

according to our common understandings , the original surface of a short - period comet nucleus has been lost by sublimation processes during its close approaches to the sun . sublimation results in the formation of a dust mantle on the retreated surface and in chemical differentiation of ices over tens or hundreds of meters below the mantle . in the course of nasa s deep impact mission , optical and infrared imaging observations of the ejecta plume were conducted by several researchers , but their interpretations of the data came as a big surprise : ( 1 ) the nucleus of comet 9p / tempel 1 is free of a dust mantle , but maintains its pristine crust of submicron sized carbonaceous grains ; ( 2 ) primordial materials are accessible already at a depth of several tens of cm with abundant silicate grains of submicrometer sizes . in this study , we demonstrate that a standard model of cometary nuclei explains well available observational data : ( 1 ) a dust mantle with a thickness of @xmath0@xmath1 m builds up on the surface , where compact aggregates larger than tens of micrometers dominate ; ( 2 ) large fluffy aggregates are embedded in chemically differentiated layers as well as in the deepest part of the nucleus with primordial materials . we conclude that the deep impact results do not need any peculiar view of a comet nucleus .

1202.4028

quantum information promises extraordinary advances over classical means of both communication and computation . quantum communication offers the potential to securely transfer information over long distances @xcite , while quantum computation may enable processing tasks that are intractable using classical methods , such as efficient factorization and quantum simulations of many - body systems @xcite . the resources required for both of these tasks may be established by photon - mediated long - distance probabilistic entanglement between quantum memories . quantum memories allow photon - mediated entanglement protocols to circumvent the detrimental exponential scaling associated with direct transmission @xcite . while remote entanglement has been demonstrated between identical quantum memories @xcite , using distinguishable memories may be unavoidable when relying on fabricated devices such as optical cavities , solid - state qubits , and spectral filters . the entanglement of distinguishable quantum memories may also allow the favorable characteristics of disparate systems to be advantaged . for instance , solid - state quantum memories enable fast qubit operations and may be fabricated using standard methods that include integration of an optical cavity to increase photon collection efficiency and facilitate scaling a quantum network . on the other hand , atomic quantum memories provide long information storage times ( seconds or more ) @xcite that may be necessary for quantum information processing . thus far , remote entanglement of hybrid quantum memories has been achieved between a cavity - coupled atom and a bose - einstein condensate @xcite . there have also been recent proposals for the remote entanglement of a quantum dot and a trapped ion using single - photon interference @xcite , the local entanglement of ultracold degenerate gases with cantilevers @xcite , as well as remote entanglement between superconducting and atomic qubits @xcite . with the aim of hybrid entanglement , two - photon interference between single photons from a quantum dot and parametric down - conversion in a nonlinear crystal has been demonstrated @xcite . while each of these techniques has various applications in quantum information , it may be more beneficial to consider passively robust entanglement protocols between remote quantum memories . we analyze a generic protocol to establish remote entanglement between a pair of distinguishable quantum memories using a two - photon interference scheme . unlike single - photon entanglement protocols @xcite , two - photon interference schemes are not interferometrically sensitive to the optical pathlength @xcite , which may permit practical long - distance entanglement . although a trade - off exists between fidelity and efficiency for distinguishable sources , this two - photon - mediated entanglement protocol has the potential to reach high fidelity while maintaining an acceptable rate of entanglement . therefore , it might be possible to use remote entanglement operations between distinguishable quantum memories to establish a quantum repeater architecture @xcite for practical long - distance applications in quantum communication and quantum computation . in the following sections we overview the implementation of the remote entanglement operation between two distinguishable quantum memories , and characterize the fidelity of the protocol through a general analysis of the two - photon interference . we then apply this protocol to a few selected systems for the entanglement of accessible pairs of quantum memories : two spectrally filtered atomic qubits , two cavity - coupled solid - state qubits , and a single solid - state qubit and a single atomic qubit . these schemes may be implemented using previously demonstrated experimental techniques , and thus may be accessible by experiments in the near - term . and qubit 2 corresponding to a photon in spatial mode @xmath0 . photons from each quantum memory are collected through objective lenses , coupled into single - mode fibers , and directed toward the beamsplitter ( bs ) . the photons interfere at the bs , and then photomultiplier tubes ( pmts ) detect the photons in spatial modes 3 and 4 in a given window of time . the frequency filters are optional and are not part of the general analysis in secs . [ sec : initial - protocol ] and [ sec : photon - interference - analysis ] , but are used in analysis of selected systems in sec . [ sec : results ] . ] the envisioned basic setup for remote entanglement of distinguishable quantum memories is illustrated in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] , which closely resembles proven experimental implementations @xcite . here the quantum memories may be separated by an arbitrary distance , limited only by the attenuation length of photons transmitted through the optical fibers . after initialization and excitation of each quantum memory , the spontaneously emitted photons are coupled into the optical fibers and are directed to interfere at a 50:50 nonpolarizing beamsplitter ( bs ) . the interference and detection of these photons may be used to project the quantum memories into an entangled state . entanglement can be observed between photon and matter qubits through a sequential method of qubit initialization , excitation , spontaneous emission , and detection . initialization of each qubit ( for instance by optical pumping ) prepares the qubit in the @xmath1 state depicted in fig . [ fig : total - structure](a ) , where @xmath2 denotes the input spatial mode of a photon entering the bs corresponding to qubit @xmath2 . a laser pulse excites the quantum memory from @xmath1 to @xmath3 in fig . [ fig : total - structure](b ) . in fig . [ fig : total - structure](c ) , @xmath3 , with excited state lifetime @xmath4 , spontaneously decays into a superposition of qubit states @xmath5 and @xmath6 , while emitting a photon in a superposition of orthogonal states @xmath7 and @xmath8 ( e.g. polarizations or frequencies ) . the matter - photon entanglement between the quantum memory and its emitted photon may be described as @xmath9 . after the photons are emitted from each qubit in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] , a product state @xmath10 exists between the two matter - photon systems . as illustrated in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] , the photons interfere at the bs , and are then detected in a given window of time by the photomultiplier tubes ( pmts ) . a coincident detection at the pmts ideally signals the observation of the post - selected maximally entangled bell state @xmath11 of the photons . the detection of photons in the @xmath12 state heralds the probabilistic entanglement of the matter qubits . the state of the two quantum memories is then @xmath13 , which represents remote spin - spin entanglement between qubits 1 and 2 @xcite . after creating the @xmath14 entangled state , the states of the entangled qubits may be read out . the process to detect each qubit state is dependent upon the structure of each specific quantum memory and will be detailed for each selected system in sec [ sec : results ] . ground state for initialization of a qubit @xmath2 . ( b ) a laser resonant to the @xmath1 to @xmath15 transition excites the qubit . ( c ) the excited state @xmath15 will decay into a superposition of the ground spin states @xmath5 and @xmath16 while spontaneously emitting a photon in a superposition of orthogonal states @xmath17 and @xmath8 , establishing matter - photon entanglement . ] the fidelity of the above protocol depends critically on the quality of the interference between photons , as evaluated below . while the general interference analysis parallels to some extent the work in ref . @xcite , we have extended the analysis to characterize entanglement fidelity in the general case of two qubits distinguishable by both their frequency and temporal emission profiles . initially , a single , spontaneously emitted photon can be expressed by either a temporal or frequency mode profile @xcite . the overlap of these profiles in the temporal and frequency modes determines the quality of two - photon interference , and can be evaluated as the probability of coincident detection at the pmts depicted in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] . we use this probability of coincident detection to evaluate the fidelity of the matter qubit entanglement following joint detection of the interfered photons , as well as the detection efficiency . embedded in this analysis is the consideration of potential errors associated with the interference of photons from distinguishable quantum memories , including temporal and frequency offsets . temporal offsets can be either a difference in arrival time of each photon at the bs or a difference in excited state lifetimes , which determine the temporal profiles of each photon . we incorporate differences in excited state lifetimes in both the present and later sections . differences in arrival times can be optimized by simply changing the photon pathlength to the bs , which becomes important for analysis in secs . [ sec : barium ] and [ sec : hybrid ] . a frequency offset is a difference in the mean values of the photon frequency mode profiles . our analysis below demonstrates that a frequency offset may be tolerated to some extent and may be reduced by using either cavity - coupling or spectral filtering . to begin , we consider a single emitted photon from a quantum memory that may be described in the temporal mode by the electric field operator @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the mean frequency of a photon emitted from quantum memory @xmath2 , @xmath20 is the heaviside function , and @xmath21 is the usual photon annihilation operator . a temporal mode profile can be expressed for spontaneously emitted single photons as @xmath22 which is the time - dependent probability of spontaneous emission from quantum memory @xmath2 where @xmath23 . the interference of two photons is evaluated in terms of a joint detection probability ( jdp ) , which describes the likelihood of coincidentally detecting photons after interference at a bs . here we consider two cases of the jdp , which are then compared to evaluate the quality of the photon interference . first , the case that a time - dependent jdp considers noninterfering photons ( e.g. orthogonally polarized photons ) reduces to @xcite : @xmath24 where @xmath25 and @xmath26 denote orthogonal states with respect to each other , @xmath27 is a state containing two completely distinguishable photons ( each in a different spatial mode @xmath28 ) , and time delay @xmath29 is the interval of time between successive detection events at the pmts depicted in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] . the electric field operators in eq . [ eq : early - dist - jdp ] , written in terms of the output spatial modes @xmath30 and @xmath31 of the bs depicted in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] may be written in terms of the input modes as @xcite @xmath32 using the electric field operator defined by eq . [ eq : general - operator ] , then eq . [ eq : early - dist - jdp ] can be written as @xmath33 integrating this over all time @xmath34 yields the total jdp for the noninterfering case : @xmath35 which demonstrates that interference does not occur because @xmath36 for @xmath37 with no frequency dependence . because no interference occurs , each photon is transmitted or reflected at the bs with random 50% probability . second , the case that a time - dependent jdp considers interfering photons ( e.g. identically polarized photons emitted from the two quantum memories ) reduces to @xcite : @xmath38 where @xmath39 . the electric field operators can be related back to the spatial modes from which the photons were emitted using eq . [ eq : elec - operator - relations ] . with the electric field operators expressed in spatial modes 1 and 2 , @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the frequency mode mismatch between photons emitted from each quantum memory . the total interfering jdp considering identically polarized photons may be represented as @xmath42 which demonstrates that interference will always occur when @xmath29 is zero , and interference is still strong at all other values of @xmath29 with near - perfect frequency mode - matching ( @xmath43 ) . while we evaluate two - photon interference based on known photon states ( parallel or orthogonal ) , the entanglement protocol depends upon the interference of photons each defined by a superposition state representing matter - photon entanglement as described in sec . [ sec : initial - protocol ] . thus , the fidelity of the entanglement , or the overlap between the target quantum state and measured quantum state , is determined by the quality of the two - photon interference , since ideally a coincident detection only occurs when the photons are in the @xmath12 state . the detection of @xmath12 would then swap the entanglement of the photons to the quantum memories . the characteristics of this event are analyzed in terms of fidelity and detection efficiency below . fidelity may be derived from maximum and minimum correlated intensities ( @xmath44 and @xmath45 , respectively ) that accumulate in a window of time @xmath46 for which the pmts in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] are open for detection . the correlated intensities are combined to measure the interferometer visibility @xmath47 which characterizes the overall quality of the two - photon interference at the bs @xcite . first , the maximum correlated intensity @xmath44 corresponds to the case of noninterfering photons , and is defined as @xmath48 second , the minimum correlated intensity @xmath45 corresponds to the case of interfering photons , and is defined as @xmath49}{(\tau_1+\tau_2)\left(\tau_1 ^ 2\left(4\delta\omega^2\tau_2 ^ 2 + 1\right)+2\tau_1\tau_2+\tau_2 ^ 2\right ) } + \frac{i_{max}}{2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the fidelity may be represented in terms of visibility as @xcite @xmath50 where we assume negligible frequency differences between the two relevant transitions within each quantum memory . the fidelity for any probabilistic entanglement protocol is irrelevant without also evaluating efficiency . efficiency describes the success probability of the entanglement protocol , and therefore must be high enough for practical quantum communication and quantum computation . the efficiency of two - photon detection @xmath51 defines the probability of detection within a finite @xmath46 . while this generic detection efficiency assumes neither technical nor experimental losses , the analysis of selected systems below will consider both a net efficiency and an estimated rate of entanglement , which include probabilities of emission , transmission , and detection . both a temporal mode mismatch ( @xmath52 ) and a frequency mode mismatch ( @xmath53 ) will degrade two - photon interference and thus contribute to entanglement fidelity loss . although this loss in fidelity can be compensated for by reducing the detection window @xmath46 , this is only possible at the expense of reduced efficiency . in fig . [ fig : general_fidelity ] we show a three - dimensional solid region composed of coordinates @xmath54 in units of @xmath55 in which fidelities @xmath56% and two - photon detection efficiencies @xmath57% are possible . as is clearly illustrated , in principle , high fidelities are possible even when using emission sources that differ significantly in both frequency and time . , @xmath58 , and @xmath46 , in units of @xmath55 , that permit @xmath59% and @xmath60% for the entanglement of two distinguishable qubits . it is apparent that even with substantial photon mode - mismatches high fidelities and detection efficiencies are possible . ] in sec . [ sec : photon - interference - analysis ] we analyzed the general results and limitations of a two - photon - mediated entanglement protocol when offsets are present in the temporal and frequency modes . that analysis may be applied to the entanglement of several different specific systems of quantum memories that are nominally or experimentally distinguishable , or both . the following subsections describe entanglement protocols for three different selected systems of distinguishable quantum memories : two atomic qubits , two solid - state qubits , and hybrid qubits . extensions from the general protocol in each scenario are currently feasible with previously demonstrated experimental techniques , showing the current applicability of our analysis in various settings . the general techniques in sec . [ sec : initial - protocol ] may be used to analyze the entanglement between nominally identical remote atomic qubits , which become distinguishable with experimental fabrication of spectral modifiers . these spectral modifiers , specifically frequency filters , can be necessary to inhibit specific transitions when multiple hyperfine manifold decay channels are present .- polarization ) without the requirement of spectral filters , but it may prove beneficial to use @xmath61 transitions in order to take advantage of currently pursued collection techniques like parabolic mirror geometries @xcite , which also mitigate errors due to polarization mixing often encountered when utilizing high na collection optics @xcite . ] the advantage is that transitions to states with such decay channels often provide longer - wavelength emissions , maximizing the attenuation length in optical fiber . specifically , here we consider each quantum memory ( qubits 1 and 2 in fig . [ fig : entanglement - protocol ] ) to be a @xmath62ba@xmath63 atom confined in a linear radiofrequency ( rf ) paul trap @xcite . a spectral frequency filter is included along the path of photons emitted from each trapped @xmath62ba@xmath63 atom to inhibit the observation of unwanted frequencies.ba@xmath63 emission is micromotion caused by the rf trapping fields . however , we consider optimal trapping conditions where proper nulling of static offset fields minimizes micromotion . with standard low temperatures @xmath64 1 mk the absolute fluctuation in emission frequency due to the secular motion is extremely small @xcite . therefore , these frequency fluctuations of single emitted photons from @xmath62ba@xmath63 should have negligible effects and are omitted from the analysis . ] we have also outlined in fig . [ fig : barium - entanglement ] the processes of excitation , emission , and detection for establishing entanglement after initialization by optical pumping into the @xmath65 state . the requirements and effects of the above mentioned spectral modifiers are detailed below . in this protocol , spectral filtering @xcite of photons emitted from @xmath62ba@xmath63 is used to observe only the transition from @xmath66 to @xmath67 , suppressing the observation of photons from transitions to @xmath68 . this can be done with an external fabry - perot cavity resonant at the desired transition frequency . the @xmath69-@xmath70 transition was chosen as it provides a wavelength more practical than the @xmath69-@xmath71 transition for transmission over long - distances . this same technique could also be employed for other atomic ions such as sr@xmath72 or ca@xmath72 . in order to analyze the photon interference in the presence of the two relevant transitions in @xmath62ba@xmath63 , we define the electric field operator @xmath73,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath74 is the natural transition probability to observe the @xmath66 to @xmath67 transition , @xmath75 is the hyperfine frequency splitting between @xmath76 and @xmath77 , and operators @xmath21 and @xmath78 are used to represent the different ( distinguishable ) transitions . to obtain the frequency mode profile of an emitted photon from @xmath62ba@xmath63 , we first take the fourier transform of the electric field operator from eq . [ eq : barium_firstoperator ] @xmath79\notag,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath80 . then the normalized unfiltered frequency mode profile is @xmath81\notag,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath82 . using a filter resonant at @xmath19 , the filtered frequency mode profile becomes @xmath83 where @xmath84 @xcite is the frequency - dependent transmission of light through the filter and @xmath85 is the filter mode function where @xmath86 is the cavity decay rate of the spectral filter with speed of light @xmath87 , cavity finesse @xmath88 , and cavity length @xmath89 . value equal to 50 mhz can be established using a cavity with @xmath90 and @xmath91 cm . ] both the unfiltered and filtered frequency mode profiles are shown in fig . [ fig : frequency - filtering ] to exemplify the full effects of the filtering when including the relative strengths of the wanted and unwanted transitions . with filtering effects accounted for in the frequency mode , we transition back into the temporal mode for further analysis . after filtering , a single emitted photon in spatial mode @xmath2 from @xmath62ba@xmath63 may be described in the temporal mode by the electric field operator @xmath92\notag.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the likely situation that the photon mode profiles are nonidentical due to distinguishable filter cavities in each mode , quality of two - photon interference may benefit by imposing an intentional temporal offset in the arrival time of emitted photons at the bs . we thus incorporate a temporal mode - mismatch , @xmath93 , in the electric field operators for emitted photons in mode @xmath94 , so that @xmath95 . experimentally , this temporal offset may be manipulated by simply changing the pathlength of mode @xmath94 . utilizing the steps delineated in sec . [ sec : photon - interference - analysis ] , relevant temporal mode profiles and jdp cases may now be derived using @xmath96 and @xmath97 . further substituting the electric field operators of this subsection into the general analysis , we may determine the entanglement fidelity of this ion - ion system . fidelity is compared to a net efficiency @xmath98 , \label{eq : net_efficiency}\ ] ] where @xmath99 is the probability of detecting @xmath12 , @xmath100 is the two - photon detection efficiency for this system defined by eq . [ eq : detection ] , @xmath101 is the relative branching ratio of @xmath102-polarized emissions from @xmath62ba@xmath63 transitions into the @xmath103 and @xmath104 hyperfine levels depicted in fig . [ fig : total - structure]b @xcite , @xmath105 is the collection efficiency of @xmath62ba@xmath63 @xcite , @xmath106 is the quantum efficiency of each pmt , @xmath107 accounts for coupling and transmission efficiencies of necessary optical fibers , and @xmath108 is the transmission efficiency of necessary optics . the rate of entanglement generation is given by @xmath109 where we take @xmath110 mhz based on recently demonstrated methods of qubit state preparation @xcite . -polarized emission spectrum of @xmath62ba@xmath63 for the @xmath111 to @xmath112 transition before ( dashed line ) and after ( solid line ) frequency filtering . the transition probabilities are 3/8 to @xmath68 and 5/8 to @xmath67 @xcite . here the desired transition to @xmath67 is centered at @xmath113 , the other transition to @xmath68 is centered at @xmath114 ghz @xcite , and @xmath115 ghz . ] , @xmath116 , and @xmath93 that permit @xmath117 ns@xmath118% and @xmath119 ns@xmath120 hz for the entanglement of two @xmath62ba@xmath63 atoms . here @xmath121 ns is the natural excited state lifetime and @xmath122 ghz . it is clear that high fidelities and rates of entanglement can be achieved as long as @xmath123 ghz , @xmath124 ghz , and @xmath125 ns . ] figure [ fig : ion - fidelity ] shows a solid region composed of coordinates @xmath126 , which provide fidelities @xmath127% and rates of entanglement @xmath128 hz when detecting during a reasonable window @xmath129 ns . the remote entanglement therefore may maintain acceptable results even under unavoidable mode - mismatches caused by distinguishable filter cavities , especially when introducing experimentally optimal temporal offsets . in addition , the use of @xmath102-polarized photons may enable greater photon collection efficiencies , and thus greatly increases entanglement rates , in the near future @xcite . although we have specifically analyzed the @xmath62ba@xmath63 atom , the above procedure is generally applicable to any atomic ion with a low - lying @xmath70-state where transition wavelengths may be more practical for longer - distance transmission ( e.g. , sr@xmath72 or ca@xmath72 ) . in another extension of the generic protocol in sec . [ sec : initial - protocol ] we consider the remote entanglement of two low - temperature solid - state matter qubits . specifically , we apply our analysis to the entanglement of two nitrogen - vacancy ( nv ) centers through the interference of emitted photons at the zero - phonon line ( zpl ) near 637 nm . interference has recently been demonstrated between photons emitted by nv centers @xcite without cavity - coupling . due to a low emission probability at the zpl @xcite , we instead consider the fabrication of a cavity resonant at the zpl of each nv center for enhanced spontaneous emission and collection . given unavoidable distinguishability between fabricated cavities , our following analysis demonstrates the limits of entangling nv centers in terms of the quality factor of each cavity . following the recent experimental demonstration of entanglement between an nv center and a single photon @xcite , in fig.[fig : nvc - entanglement ] we review the processes of excitation , emission , and detection for achieving entanglement following initialization by optical pumping into the @xmath130 @xmath131 state . cavity - coupling of an nv center may be necessary to enhance the emission rate of photons characterized by the zpl wavelength @xmath132 nm . in order for this to be done with high efficiency , in this analysis we incorporate the fabrication of a photonic crystal cavity to the nv center corresponding to each mode @xmath2 , which has been successfully demonstrated with a single nv center in previous experiments @xcite . the general emission enhancement of each nv center caused by the cavity - coupling may be determined using the purcell factor @xmath133 assuming no spatial or resonance offsets exist between the cavity and the nv center , where @xmath134 is the quality factor , @xmath135 is the resonant wavelength , @xmath136 is the index of refraction , and @xmath137 is the effective cavity mode volume . following the assumption that a photonic crystal cavity may be fabricated with @xmath138 @xcite , the relevant purcell factor is @xmath139 the purcell factor in eq . [ eq : purcell - simplified ] may be utilized to compute the cavity - enhanced lifetime @xcite @xmath140 where @xmath141 @xcite is the natural branching ratio of photon emissions at the zpl . unlike the scenario in sec . [ sec : barium ] , a cavity - coupled nv center may be described in the temporal mode with an electric field operator that is analogous to that expressed in eq . [ eq : general - operator ] . however , a difference occurs due to the substitution of the righthand side of eq . [ eq : enhanced - nvc - lifetime ] in the place of @xmath4 , where distinguishability arises between each fabricated cavity - coupled nv center from the variability of @xmath134 . , @xmath142 , and @xmath46 that permit @xmath59% and @xmath143 hz for the entanglement of two nv centers . here we assume that @xmath144 ns is the natural excited state lifetime for both nv centers , and @xmath145 characterizes the lower quality cavity . the results for this system are most similar to those in sec . [ sec : photon - interference - analysis ] because we observe single - exponential decay profiles in both photons . thus , it is clear that high fidelities and rates of entanglement can be reached for @xmath146 ghz , @xmath147 , and @xmath148 ns . ] then , employing the steps outlined in sec . [ sec : photon - interference - analysis ] , the necessary temporal mode profiles and jdps may be derived for the calculation of entanglement fidelity and efficiency of entanglement . fidelity of the entanglement of two cavity - coupled nv centers is compared to a net efficiency @xmath149 , \label{eq : net_efficiency-2}\ ] ] where @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 , and @xmath153 are taken to be the same as in sec . [ sec : barium ] , @xmath154 is the two - photon detection efficiency of this system based on eq . [ eq : detection ] , @xmath155 is the cavity - enhanced branching ratio of the nv center emissions at the zpl @xcite , and @xmath156 is the fraction of photons emitted into the cavity mode in the weak - coupling regime , which we take as the effective collection efficiency @xcite . the entanglement rate for two cavity - coupled nv centers is then @xmath157 which follows the convention used in eq . [ eq : success - rate ] , where here we consider @xmath158 khz @xcite . in fig . [ fig : nvc - fidelity ] we illustrate a solid region composed of coordinates @xmath159 with @xmath145 , where the protocol achieves fidelities @xmath56% and rates of entanglement @xmath160 hz . thus , the remote entanglement of solid - state color centers has the ability to uphold exceptional results under distinguishability in cavity fabrication . for our final extension to the general protocol in sec . [ sec : initial - protocol ] we consider the hybrid entanglement of a low - temperature solid - state matter qubit and an atomic matter qubit . as aforementioned in sec . [ sec : introduction ] , a proposal exists to establish hybrid entanglement between a semiconductor inas quantum dot and a trapped @xmath161yb@xmath72 atom using a single - photon interference scheme @xcite . in the following analysis we evaluate the hybrid entanglement between the same two quantum memories using the two - photon interference scheme presented in the above sections . existing proposals for the remote entanglement of two charged quantum dots consider both single - photon interference @xcite and two - photon interference @xcite . for two - photon interference , ref . @xcite utilizes entanglement between emissions from trion decays and qubit spin states in the lowest levels . our extended entanglement protocol includes a similar convention . we assume initialization of the quantum dot may be done by creating a superposition @xmath162 between spin states using single - qubit rotation . the process of establishing matter - photon entanglement between an emitted photon and a quantum dot is described by fig . [ fig : hybrid - entanglement](a)-(c ) . we assume an excited state lifetime of the trion level @xmath163 ns @xcite ; the transition wavelength of interest is 935 nm , which is near the relevant @xmath161yb@xmath72 transition . the protocol for matter - photon entanglement with @xmath161yb@xmath72 employs the transition from @xmath164_{1/2}$ ] to @xmath112 with emission wavelength 935 nm and @xmath164_{1/2}$ ] excited state lifetime @xmath165 ns @xcite . the process for establishing matter - photon entanglement with @xmath161yb@xmath72 is detailed in fig . [ fig : hybrid - entanglement](d)-(f ) . as a result of the selection rules for both the selected quantum dot and @xmath161yb@xmath72 transitions , spectral filtering is not required to use the @xmath102-polarized transitions to the low - lying @xmath70 level as it was with @xmath62ba@xmath63 . however , we include a spectral filter only in the path of the quantum dot emissions to improve temporal mode - matching . ghz we assume error due to inhomogeneous broadening negligible . ] with the effects of filtering accounted for , the quantum dot emits photons in mode @xmath94 that may be described with electric field operators @xmath166 based on eq . [ eq : barium - elec - operator ] when @xmath167 and @xmath161yb@xmath72 emits photons in mode @xmath168 that may be described with electric field operators @xmath169 based on eq . [ eq : general - operator ] . due to the different types of electric field operators for each qubit emission , we incorporate a temporal offset @xmath93 in the quantum dot emission so that its electric field operators become @xmath95 , as is done in sec . [ sec : barium ] . as with the earlier selected systems , the derivations follow the step - by - step methods in sec . [ sec : photon - interference - analysis ] to determine fidelity and two - photon detection efficiency . , @xmath116 , and @xmath93 that permit @xmath170 ns@xmath118% and @xmath171 ns@xmath172 hz for the entanglement of a quantum dot and an @xmath161yb@xmath72 atom . here @xmath173 ns and @xmath174 ns are the natural excited state lifetimes of the quantum dot and @xmath161yb@xmath72 , respectively . despite the vast differences in the emissions of the two qubits , high entanglement fidelities can still be achieved at reasonable rates of entanglement as long as @xmath175 ghz , @xmath176 ghz , and @xmath177 ns . ] the net efficiency is @xmath178 , \label{eq : net_efficiency-3}\ ] ] where @xmath150 , @xmath152 , @xmath151 , and @xmath153 are taken to be the same as in sec . [ sec : barium ] , @xmath179 is the two - photon detection efficiency of this system based on eq . [ eq : detection ] , @xmath180 is the assumed branching ratio of the relevant quantum dot transition , @xmath181 is the branching ratio of the relevant @xmath161yb@xmath72 transition @xcite , @xmath182 is the collection efficiency of quantum dot emissions @xcite , and @xmath183 is the collection efficiency of @xmath161yb@xmath72 emissions @xcite . the entanglement rate between a quantum dot and a single @xmath161yb@xmath72 atom is then @xmath184 which follows the convention used in eq . [ eq : success - rate ] , where we take @xmath185 mhz @xcite . in fig . [ fig : hybrid - fidelity ] we illustrate a solid region composed of coordinates @xmath126 , where fidelities @xmath56% and rates of entanglement @xmath186 hz are possible when detecting during a reasonable window @xmath187 ns . thus , the remote entanglement of these hybrid qubits has the ability to uphold interesting results when appropriate experimental techniques are implemented . while we have analyzed the entanglement specifically between a quantum dot and @xmath161yb@xmath72 , a similar protocol may be utilized for the entanglement between a quantum dot and either @xmath188sr@xmath72 or @xmath189ca@xmath72 . each of these ions behave like @xmath62ba@xmath72 as in sec . [ sec : barium ] , and thus frequency filtering may be required for two - photon interference . the relevant transitions of @xmath188sr@xmath72 and @xmath189ca@xmath72 have much broader linewidths than @xmath161yb@xmath72 , which may allow for improved pairing of fidelity and rate of entanglement.sr@xmath72 or @xmath190ca@xmath72 by employing qubit shelving techniques previously demonstrated @xcite . here the atom - photon entanglement can be generated via the @xmath191 to @xmath192 decay , mapping one of the @xmath192 states back to @xmath193 , and performing fluorescence detection on the @xmath193 to @xmath194 ( and @xmath194 to @xmath112 ) transition . ] additionally , cavity - coupling techniques @xcite could be used to substantially increase the fidelity and efficiency of the system , at the cost of increased experimental complexity . finally , larger frequency differences between qubits may be mediated by the tunability of solid - state systems @xcite or through translation of photon frequencies @xcite . we have shown that a robust two - photon interference protocol can be used to entangle distinguishable quantum memories with high fidelities and rates . a general analysis demonstrates that entanglement fidelities @xmath56% and detection efficiencies @xmath57% are possible even with significant mismatches in the frequency and temporal characteristics of the photons . by applying this analysis to three relevant systems , we illustrate both the utility of the calculations and their applicability to current experimental efforts . moreover , the general analysis presented here can be easily extended to other pairs of quantum memories . overall , this evaluation elucidates the possibility of establishing remote entanglement between hybrid quantum memories that relies only on passive filtering and the passive stability inherent in the two - photon interference scheme . ultimately , this type of stalwart architecture may be crucial for the realization of long - distance quantum communication and distributed quantum computation . we thank dirk englund and dmitry budker for helpful discussions concerning the cavity - coupling of nv centers and james v. porto for useful comments on this manuscript . acknowledges the faculty at the loudoun county public schools academy of science . s.o . acknowledges support from the national research council ( nrc ) research associateship program . 62ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) _ _ , @noop ph.d . thesis , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) _ _ , @noop ph.d . thesis , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( )

we theoretically evaluate establishing remote entanglement between distinguishable matter qubits through interference and detection of two emitted photons . the fidelity of the entanglement operation is analyzed as a function of the temporal and frequency mode - matching between the photons emitted from each quantum memory . with a general analysis , we define limits on the absolute magnitudes of temporal and frequency mode - mismatches in order to maintain entanglement fidelities greater than 99% with two - photon detection efficiencies greater than 90% . we apply our analysis to several selected systems of quantum memories . results indicate that high fidelities may be achieved in each system using current experimental techniques , while maintaining acceptable rates of entanglement . thus , it might be possible to use two - photon - mediated entanglement operations between distinguishable quantum memories to establish a network for quantum communication and distributed quantum computation .

astro-ph0506618

in the past few years , pipelines providing astronomical data have been becoming increasingly important . the wide use of robotic telescopes has provided significant discoveries , and sky survey projects are now considered among the premier projects in the field astronomy . in this paper we will concentrate on the ground based missions , although future space based missions like kepler , snap and jwst will also create significant pipelines of astronomical data . pan - starrs @xcite , a 60 million dollar venture , is being built today and completion is expected by 2006 . pan - starrs will be composed of 4 large telescopes pointing simultaneously at the same region of the sky . with coverage of 6000 degrees@xmath0 per night , pan - starrs will look for transients that include supernovas , planetary eclipses , and asteroids that might pose a future threat to earth . similarly but on a larger scale , ground - based lsst @xcite is planned to use a powerful 8.4 meter robotic telescope that will cover the entire sky every 10 days . lsst will cost $ 200 m , be completed by 2012 , and produce 13 terabytes per night . in addition , many smaller scale robotic telescopes are being deployed and their number is growing rapidly . however , in the modern age of increasing bandwidth , human identifications are many times impracticably slow . therefore , efforts toward the automation of the analysis of astronomical pipelines have been gradually increasing . in this paper we present fuzzy logic based algorithms for two basic problems in astronomical pipeline processing which are rejecting cosmic ray hits and converting celestial coordinates to image coordinates . useful automatic pipeline processing of astronomical images depends on accurate algorithmic decision making . for previously identified objects , one of the first steps in computer - based analysis of astronomical pictures is an association of each object with a known catalog entry . this necessary step enables such science as automatically detected transients and automated photometry of stars . since computing the topocentric coordinates of a given known star at a given time is a simple task , transforming the celestial topocentric coordinates to image @xmath1 coordinates might provide the expected location of any star in the frame . however , in an imperfect world of non - linear wide - angle optics , imperfect optics , inaccurately pointed telescopes , and defect - ridden cameras , accurate transformation of celestial coordinates to image coordinates is not always a trivial first step . on a ccd image , pixel locations can be specified in either cartesian or polar coordinates . let @xmath2 be the @xmath3 coordinate ( in pixels ) of the zenith in the image , and @xmath4 be the @xmath5 coordinate of the zenith . in order to use polar coordinates , it is necessary to transform the topocentric celestial coordinates ( azimuth , altitude ) to a polar distance and angle from ( @xmath6 ) . the fuzzy logic model is built based on manually identified reference stars . each identified star contributes an azimuth and altitude ( by basic astronomy ) and also an angle and radial distance ( by measurement from the image ) . these provide the raw data for constructing a mapping between the two using the fuzzy logic model . in order to transform celestial coordinates into image coordinates , we need to transform the azimuth and altitude of a given location to polar angle in the image from ( @xmath6 ) and the radial distance ( in pixels ) from ( @xmath6 ) . in order to obtain the coordinates transformation , we build a fuzzy logic model based on the reference stars . the model has two antecedent variables which are _ altitude _ and _ azimuth_. the _ azimuth _ is fuzzified using pre - defined four fuzzy sets _ north_,_east _ , _ south _ and _ west _ , and each fuzzy set is associated with a gaussian membership function . altitude _ is fuzzified using fuzzy sets added to the model by the reference stars such that each fuzzy set is associated with a triangular membership function that reaches its maximum of unity at the reference value and intersects with the x - axis at the points of maximum of its neighboring reference stars . the fuzzy rules are defined such that the antecedent part of each rule has two fuzzy sets ( one for altitude and one for azimuth ) and the consequent part has one crisp value which is the distance ( in pixels ) from ( @xmath6 ) . the reasoning procedure is based on _ product _ inferencing and _ weighted average _ defuzzification , which is an efficient defuzzification method when the fuzzy logic model is built according to a set of singleton values @xcite . the algorithm has been implemented for the _ night sky live ! _ @xcite project , which deploys 10 all - sky ccd cameras called _ concam _ at some of the worlds premier observatories covering almost the entire night sky . the pictures are 1024 @xmath7 1024 fits images , which is a standard format in astronomical imaging . the algorithm allows practically 100 percent chance of accurate identification for nsl stars down to a magnitude of 5.6 . this accurate identification allows systematic and continuous monitoring of bright star , and photometry measurements are constantly being recorded and stored in a database . the automatic association of psfs to stars is also used for optical transient detection . the presence of cosmic ray hits in astronomical ccd frames is frequently considered as a disturbing effect . except from their annoying presence , cosmic ray hits might be mistakenly detected as true astronomical sources . algorithms that analyze astronomical frames must ignore the peaks caused by cosmic ray hits , yet without rejecting the peaks of the true astronomical sources . cosmic ray hits in astronomical exposures are usually noticeably different then point spread functions of true astronomical sources . cosmic ray hits are usually smaller than true psfs , and their edges are usually sharper . an observer trying to manually detect cosmic ray hits would probably examine the edges and the surface size each peak . since some of the cosmic ray hits have only one or two sharp edges , it is also necessary to examine the sharpest edge of the psf . for instance , if the surface size of the peak is very small , it has sharp edges and the sharpest edge is extremely sharp , it would be classified as a cosmic ray hit . if the surface size of the peak is large and its edges are not sharp , it would be probably classified as a psf of an astronomical source . in order to model the intuition described above , we defined 3 antecedent fuzzy variables : the surface size of the psf , the sharpness of the sharpest edge and the average sharpness of the edges . the consequent variable is the classification of the peak , and its domain is \{1,0}. since astronomical images typically contain 1 to 16 million pixels , the triangular membership functions are used for their low computational cost . the fuzzy rules are defined using the membership functions of the antecedent variables and the domain of the consequent variable ( \{0,1 } ) , and are based on the natural language rules of intuition . for instance , the rules of intuition described earlier in this section would be compiled into the fuzzy rules : @xmath8 _ sharp _ @xmath8 _ extreme _ @xmath9 1 @xmath8 _ low _ @xmath8 _ low _ @xmath9 0 the computation process is based on _ product _ inferencing and _ weighted average _ defuzzification @xcite , and the value of the consequent variable is handled such that value greater than @xmath10 is classified as a cosmic ray hits . otherwise , the value is classified as a non - cosmic ray hits . the fuzzy logic model is used in order to classify peaks in the frame as cosmic ray hits or non - cosmic ray hits . in the presented method , searching for peaks in a fits frame is performed by comparing the value of each pixel with the values of its 8 neighboring pixels . if the pixel is equal or brighter than _ all _ its neighboring pixels , it is considered as a center of a peak . after finding the peaks in the frame , the fuzzy logic model is applied to the peaks in order to classify them as cosmic ray hits or non - cosmic ray hits . measurements of the performance of the algorithm were taken using 24 _ night sky live _ exposures . each nsl frame contains an average of 6 noticeable cosmic ray hits brighter than 20@xmath11 , and around 1400 astronomical sources . out of 158 cosmic ray hits that were tested , the algorithm did not reject 4 , and mistakenly rejected 6 true astronomical sources out of a total of 31,251 psfs . these numbers are favorably comparable to previously reported cosmic ray hit rejection algorithms , and the presented algorithm also has a clear advantage in terms of computational complexity . the emerging field of robotic telescopes and autonomous sky surveys introduces a wide range of problems that require complex decision making . we presented solutions to two basic problems , which are star recognition and cosmic ray hit rejection . we showed that fuzzy logic modeling provides the infrastructure for complex decision making required for automatic analysis of astronomical frames , yet complies with the practical algorithmic complexity constraints introduced by the huge amounts of data generated by the astronomical pipelines . borucki , w. j. : kepler mission : a mission to find earth - size planets in the habitable zone . proc . of the conf . on towards other earths ( 2003 ) 6981 kaiser , n. , pan - starrs : a wide - field optical survey telescope array . proc . of the spie * 54 * ( 2004 ) 1122 nemiroff , r. j. , rafert , j. b. : toward a continuous record of the sky . pasp * 111 * ( 1999 ) 886897 salzberg , s. , chandar , r. , ford , h. , murphy , s. , k. , & white , r. , decision trees for automated identification of cosmic - ray hits in hubble space telescope images . pasp * 107 * ( 1995 ) 279 takagi , t. , sugeno , m. : fuzzy identification of systems and its applications to modeling and control . ieee trans . man & cybern . * 20 * ( 1985 ) 116132 tyson , j. a. , survey and other telescope technologies and discoveries . proc . of the spie , * 48 * ( 2002 ) 1020

fundamental astronomical questions on the composition of the universe , the abundance of earth - like planets , and the cause of the brightest explosions in the universe are being attacked by robotic telescopes costing billions of dollars and returning vast pipelines of data . the success of these programs depends on the accuracy of automated real time processing of the astronomical images . in this paper the needs of modern astronomical pipelines are discussed in the light of fuzzy - logic based decision - making . several specific fuzzy - logic algorithms have been develop for the first time for astronomical purposes , and tested with excellent results on data from the existing night sky live sky survey .

astro-ph0011002

disk galaxies that form in cosmological hydro simulations are surprisingly smaller and of lower spin than observed disks , posing an angular - momentum problem " ( e.g. navarro & steinmetz 1997 , 2000 ) . a key ingredient in the origin of galactic rotation , which can be studied in detail , is the distribution of angular momentum in the dark halo within which baryonic infall is assumed to form the disk . we describe here several advances in the investigation of the origin of halo angular momentum and its distribution , and preliminary implications on disk formation , based on high - resolution @xmath5-body simulations and analytic approximations . the universal @xmath4 profile ( 2 ) and the implied disk structure ( 3 ) are presented in bullock et al . ( 2000 , bdk+ ) . the issues of tidal - torque theory ( 4 ) are studied by porciani , dekel , & hoffman ( 2000 , pdh ) and the scaling relation is by porciani & dekel ( 2000 , pd ) . the @xmath4 profile due to mergers ( 5 ) is by dekel & burkert ( 2000 , db ) . the correlations with merger history ( 6 ) are to be described in wechsler et al . ( 2000 , wbd+ ) . we use a high - resolution @xmath5-body simulation of the @xmath6cdm cosmology ( @xmath7 ) inside a @xmath8 box , with particles of @xmath9 and force resolution of @xmath10 ( art code , kravtsov et al . spherical halos are identified around density maxima using an nfw density profile ; they contain a mass @xmath11 inside a virial radius @xmath12 , defined such that it encompasses a mean overdensity of 340 . we focus here on 500 isolated halos with @xmath13 . we find that the mass distribution of specific angular momentum @xmath4 is well fit by a _ universal _ profile : m(<j)= m j /(j_0 + j ) , > 1 . [ eq : prof ] this is roughly a power law for @xmath14 , which flattens off if @xmath15 . the _ shape _ parameter @xmath16 correlates with the fraction of mass in the power - law regime , which always contains more than half the mass . one can replace @xmath17 with a robust spin parameter @xmath18 , where @xmath19 . it coincides with the standard spin parameter @xmath1 for an isothermal sphere and for an nfw profile with concentration @xmath20 . the pairs @xmath21 and @xmath22 are related via j_0 b ( ) = v_c r , b ( ) - ( 1-^-1 ) -1 . [ eq : param ] either pair can fully characterize the @xmath4 profile . 1 shows a few examples . 2 ( left ) shows a certain correlation between @xmath16 and @xmath23 , with a correlation coefficient @xmath24 , meaning that high - spin halos tend to have power - law profiles . 5.5 cm we find that the direction of the angular - momentum vector tends to be aligned throughout the halo ; for more than half the mass , @xmath4 and @xmath25 typically differ by less than a factor of 2 . the spatial symmetry of @xmath4 tends to be more cylindrical than spherical ; in 80% of the halos , the mean value of @xmath4 ( over longitude ) decreases by less than a factor of 2 when moving away from the equatorial plane along lines parallel to the spin axis . a simple model can convert the halo @xmath26 into a disk density profile . assume that the gas initially traces the @xmath4 distribution of the halo , and that @xmath4 is conserved during the gas contraction into a rotation - supported disk of mass @xmath27 . then , using eq . 1 , the disk mass inside radius @xmath28 is @xmath29 $ ] . under the assumption of an isothermal halo with a flat rotation curve , one has @xmath30 , and then the disk surface - density profile is _ d = fm 2 r_d r ( r_d + r)^2 , r_d . [ eq : disk ] the characteristic length scale @xmath31 is based on eq . 2 . a more accurate numerical calculation using an nfw profile , that self - consistently solves for the disk circular velocity at @xmath28 and takes into account the adiabatic contraction of the halo in response to the baryonic infall , leads to the typical profile shown in fig . 2 ( right ) . compared to an exponential disk ( which is similar to the profile obtained from a uniform , solid - body rotating halo ) , our resultant profile has a core and tail excess , with somewhat higher densities both at small and large radii . since observed ( stellar ) disks are closer to exponential , this result may either indicate that @xmath4 is not exactly preserved during the collapse , or it may require some additional viscous processes ( e.g. lin & pringle 1987 ) . in some cases , the obtained slow - rotating core may be associated with a bulge . the extended disk , on the other hand , may be useful in explaining the damped lyman - alpha systems observed at high redshift ( maller et al . 2000 ) . our result for the limiting case of @xmath4 conservation clearly sharpens the big angular - momentum problem " , because @xmath4 transport from gas to dark matter and from inside out can only worsen any agreement with observed disks . it seems that one needs to appeal to some process of gas removal from subclumps before they merge into the halo center , and thus reduce @xmath4 transport . we find in the simulations that the halo @xmath4 profile in spherical shells is roughly a power law , @xmath2 , with @xmath32 distributed like a gaussian : @xmath33 ( see an early indication by barnes & efstathiou 1987 ) . here @xmath4 is the specific angular momentum in a shell of radius @xmath28 , and @xmath11 is the mass in the sphere encompassed by this shell . this profile can be related to the distribution @xmath26 under the assumptions of spherical symmetry for the density and cylindrical symmetry for @xmath4 . linear tidal - torque theory ( tt ) provides one hint for the origin of this power law , as follows . tt ( e.g. white 1984 ) implies that the @xmath4 gained by a halo at time @xmath34 before its turn - around is j_i(t ) = a(t)^2 d(t ) _ ijk t_jl i_lk , [ eq : ttt ] where the time growth is from some fiducial initial time @xmath35 , @xmath36 is the inertia tensor of the proto - halo at @xmath35 , and @xmath37 is the tidal tensor at the halo center , smoothed on the halo scale . this is based on assuming the zeldovich approximation for the velocities inside the proto - halo , and a 2@xmath38-order taylor expansion of the potential ( see pdh ) . we show elsewhere ( pd ) that the standard scaling relation of tt should be slightly modified ; it should read j t_c ( m ) m^2/3 , [ eq : scaling ] where @xmath39 is the turn - around time of the halo ( assuming that the relevant cosmology at @xmath39 is still eds ) and @xmath40 is the rms density fluctuation on scale @xmath11 at @xmath35 . to obtain the spin profile we apply eq . 5 shell by shell . the turn - around time of each shell is determined by @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the mean density inside @xmath11 . the densities within the different shells are correlated , such that , for a gaussian field , the typical density fluctuation profile about a random point scales like @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the linear two - point correlation function ( dekel 1981 ) . this is accurate to a few percent also around a high peak ( bardeen et al . 1986 , fig . thus , for a power - law power spectrum @xmath45 and a flat universe , we obtain for the @xmath4 profile within each halo j(m ) m^2/3 + ( 3+n)/3 . this implies @xmath46 for @xmath47 , the range appropriate for large galactic halos in a cdm spectrum , in pleasant agreement with our finding for the simulated halos . a similar analysis , using the accretion rate into halos based on the extended press - schechter approximation , also explains a weak anti - correlation detected in the simulations between @xmath32 and halo mass ( bdk+ ) . using simulated halos ( in gif simulations ) , pdh find that tt predicts an amplitude for the halo spin in the right ball - park . this confirms the relevance of tt to the @xmath4 distribution in halos . on the other hand , pdh find that the predicted spin direction is only weakly correlated with the true direction , with an average deviation of @xmath48 . this reflects large inaccuracies in the smoothing of the tidal tensor and the truncation of the taylor expansion of the potential . this relative failure of tt in predicting the spin direction should be born in mind when trying to use tt for the analysis of spin - spin correlations and weak - lensing phenomena . 5.5 cm a simple toy calculation for how @xmath4 is being deposited in the halo during a merger provides another hint for the origin of the @xmath4 profile . consider a fixed halo and an incoming satellite of mass profiles @xmath49 and @xmath50 respectively . assume that as it moves in , the satellite is losing mass outside a tidal radius @xmath51 , determined at @xmath28 by = _ t(r ) / r^3 , ( r)= [ 2m(r)- r m /r ] . [ eq : tidal ] for isothermal halos this implies @xmath52 . now assume that the satellite is spiraling in due to dynamical friction in circular orbits , and that the mass and @xmath4 are deposited locally . then @xmath53 is obtained by averaging over shells , 4r^2 ( r ) j(r ) = m(r)r + m(r ) r rv_c(r ) . [ eq : jdeposit ] the @xmath4 transfer is due to both the slowdown of the satellite by dynamical friction and the direct tidal stripping of mass . for an isothermal halo , we obtain j(m ) m . fig . 3 ( left ) shows the @xmath4 profile for an nfw halo swallowing a satellite that is loosing mass either according to the recipe @xmath54 or based on eq . 7 assuming that the satellite has an isothermal profile , compared to the case of no mass loss . the general shape of @xmath55 in the outer decade of mass , when realistic mass loss is considered , is reminiscent of the profiles detected in the cosmological simulation . full @xmath5-body simulations of mergers , spanning a range of halo and collision parameters , confirm the robust production of such power - law like profiles ( db ) . the resulting @xmath55 from a sequence of minor mergers would be a sum of similar contributions , each projected onto the direction of the total net angular momentum ( perhaps determined by the most major merger ) . since halo accretion histories typically reflect some combination of relatively quiescent mass accretion and more pronounced mergers , the @xmath4 profiles of individual halos may reflect a combination of the two processes explored above . we see that the profiles produced by each of the two processes are , in general , of similar shape to the profiles measured in the simulations . further investigations of halos in the art and gif simulations ( wbd+ ) reveal interesting correlations between halo spin and merger history . for example , halos that had a major merger in the last gyr tend to have higher spins , @xmath56 , in comparison with the average of 0.035 for all halos . this is hardly surprising because most of the orbits of merging halos are expected to be of large impact parameter and therefore to bring in much angular momentum . on the other hand , we find that major mergers also result in effective loss of @xmath4 , typically by a factor of @xmath57 of the original orbital @xmath4 . this spin loss is associated with mass loss of the weakly bound outer layers of the halos which are preferentially @xmath4-rich , eq . 1 . this spin loss somewhat weakens the tendency for high spin in merger products . these effects may be correlated with the fact that major mergers tend to be prograde , with the spins of the two merging halos oriented roughly parallel to each other and to the angular momentum of their mutual orbit . 3 ( right ) shows the average @xmath58 between the two spins and between the spin and orbit for pairs of halos at a given separation @xmath28 . there is a significant alignment at @xmath59 , growing as a power law towards smaller distances . prograde encounters indeed explain both the high spin and the high spin loss . being prograde they are more effective in transferring energy from the orbit to internal motions and thus making the typical impact parameter for mergers even larger . this , plus the coherency of progenitor spins and orbital @xmath4 , results in a high spin . but at the same time a prograde encounter causes effective stripping of @xmath4-rich mass . high spin due to major mergers seems not to go naturally with the common wisdom that such mergers produce low - spin bulges and elliptical galaxies . however , it is the halo properties at @xmath60 ( say ) rather than today that are likely to determine the @xmath4 content of the gas which later falls in to form the disk . then , it is the halo merger history prior to @xmath60 that is more relevant for the galactic spin , while later mergers govern the bulge - to - disk ratio . the high - spin halos at @xmath60 , those that were assembled and virialized not long before @xmath60 , may be the hosts of high - spin disks that are observed as low - surface - brightness galaxies ( dekel et al . 2001 ) . bardeen , j.m . , bond , j.r . , kaiser , n. , & szalay , a. s. 1986 , apj , 304 , 15 barnes , j. , & efstathiou , g. 1987 , apj , 319 , 575 bullock , j.s . , dekel , a . , kolatt , t.s . , kravtsov , a.v . , klypin , a.a . , porciani , c. , & primack , j.r . 2000 , apj , submitted , astro - ph/0011001 ( bdk+ ) kravtsov , a. , klypin , a. , & khokhlov , a.m. 1997 , apjs , 111 , 73 dekel , a. 1981 , a&a , 101 , 79 dekel , a. , & burkert , a. 2000 , in preparation ( db ) dekel , a. , et al . 2001 , in preparation lin , d.n.c . , & pringle , j.e 1987 , apjl , 320 , 87 maller , a.h . , prochaska , j.x . , somerville , r.s . , & primack , j.r . 2000 , mnras , submitted ( astro - ph/0002449 ) navarro , j.f . , & steinmetz , m. 1997 , apj , 478 , 13 navarro , j.f . , & steinmetz , m. 2000 , apj , 538 , 477 porciani , c. , & dekel , a. 2000 , submitted ( pd ) porciani , c. , dekel , a. , & hoffman , y. 2000 , submitted ( pdh ) wechsler , r.h . , bullock , j.s . , dekel , a. , primack , j.r . , kravtsov , a.v . , & klypin , a.a . 2000 , in preparation ( wbd+ ) white , s.d.m . 1984 , mnras , 286 , 38

we summarize recent developments in the study of the origin of halo spin profiles and preliminary implications on disk formation . the specific angular - momentum distributions within halos in n - body simulations match a universal shape , @xmath0 . it is characterized by a power law over most of the mass , and one shape parameter in addition to the spin parameter @xmath1 . the angular momentum tends to be aligned throughout the halo and of cylindrical symmetry . even if angular momentum is conserved during baryonic infall , the resultant disk density profile is predicted to deviate from exponential , with a denser core and an extended tail . a slightly corrected version of the scaling relation due to linear tidal - torque theory is used to explain the origin of a typical power - law profile in shells , @xmath2 with @xmath3 . while linear theory crudely predicts the amplitudes of halo spins , it is not a good predictor of their directions . independently , mergers of halos are found to produce a similar profile due to @xmath4 transfer from the orbit to the product halo via dynamical friction and tidal stripping . the halo spin is correlated with having a recent major merger , though this correlation is weakened by mass loss . these two effects are due to a correlation between the spins of neighboring halos and their orbit , leading to prograde mergers . # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in

1011.2621

the first accretion - powered millisecond pulsar , sax j1808.4 - 3658 , was discovered a decade ago @xcite . since then several other millisecond x - ray pulsars with spin periods between 1.7 and 5.4ms have been discovered ( e.g. xte j0929 - 314 , xte j1751 - 305 , xte 1807 - 294 and xte j1814 - 338 ; see @xcite for a review ) . these neutron stars have considerably weaker magnetic dipole moments , @xmath0tm@xmath1 , than the conventional x - ray pulsars . the accretion disc then extends much closer to the neutron star , where it reaches such a high temperature that the opacity is dominated by electron scattering and radiation pressure can grow stronger than the gas pressure . on the other hand the accretion rates in these systems can be so low that the alfvn radius might be located outside of the co - rotation radius of the neutron star . conventionally it has been thought that such systems will eject the mass that is transferred from the companion star through the propeller mechanism @xcite , though it has been pointed out by @xcite and @xcite that the velocity excess right outside the co - rotation radius is insufficient to eject all the matter . @xcite found that when the alfvn radius is only slightly larger than the co - rotation radius then the disc will cycle between one state in which the matter is accumulated outside the co - rotation radius and another state in which it is accreted onto the star . later @xcite constructed a steady accretion disc model , in which the entire disc is located outside of the co - rotation radius . the magnetic field of the neutron star is penetrating this disc and is mediating an exchange of angular momentum between the accretion disc and the neutron star as in the model by @xcite . since the entire accretion disc is rotating more slowly than the neutron star in this case , the disc brakes the rotation of the neutron star . the models of @xcite and @xcite have ignored the possibility of an internal dynamo in the accretion disc , and have considered only the magnetic field that is generated in the disc by the mismatch in the rotation of the neutron star and the disc . however the magnetic field due to a dynamo can strengthen the coupling between the accretion disc and the neutron star , and we @xcite have shown that the angular momentum exchange between the accretion disc and the neutron star can increase by more than an order of magnitude compared to the standard model by @xcite . furthermore the dynamo is insensitive to the rotation of the neutron star , and can therefore in principle provide a spin - up torque even at a low accretion rate . a complementary approach to study the magnetic interaction between an accretion disc and a star is represented by the numerical simulations by @xcite . in these simulations it is possible to study more complicated magnetic field geometries than are accessible to semi - analytic studies ( see for instance @xcite ) , but the resolution is so low that it is not possible to study the appearance of small - scale turbulence and the resulting turbulent transport and dynamo action in the simulation . thus these simulations do not really address the viability of a dynamo in the disc . however there are other things one can learn from these simulations . they show how the matter is streaming via funnel flows from the accretion disc onto the magnetic poles of the neutron star . furthermore they show that angular momentum is also lost from the accretion disc through the jets that are accelerated away from the disc . @xcite make a distinction between a conical jet that transport most of the mass , and a less dense axial jet inside the conical jet . the latter component can dominate the energetics if the star is in the propeller regime . it is also noteworthy that these simulations confirm that some matter might still be accreted when the star is in the propeller regime . the purpose of this paper is to extend our previous study ( paper i ) of an accretion disc with an internal dynamo around a magnetised star to the discs around millisecond pulsars . the difference is that due to the weak magnetic field the disc extends to much smaller radii , at which it becomes so hot that a significant part of the opacity is due to electron scattering , and radiation pressure might dominate over the gas pressure . therefore in the spirit of @xcite we divide the disc into an outer region with gas pressure and free - free opacity , a middle region with gas pressure and electron scattering opacity , and an inner region with radiation pressure and electron scattering . in sect . 2 we derive a single ordinary differential equation , which is generally applicable for the radial structure of the accretion disc independently of the equation of state and the form of the opacity . we then introduce the equations of state and the opacity prescriptions for the different regions of the disc in sect . 3 and present the numerical solutions in sect . the properties of these solutions and their application to the millisecond x - ray pulsars are discussed in sect . 5 , and we finally summarise our results in sect . our approach is an extension of the standard model for a thin accretion disc ( @xcite ) , and it follows closely the method that we introduced in paper i , though we will now consider a general opacity law and equation of state . for this reason we only summarise the steps leading up to eq . ( 21 ) of paper i , after which we deviate from the treatment in paper i. the surface density of the accretion disc is defined as @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the density , and @xmath5 the half thickness of the disc . we can then write the accretion rate as @xmath6 which is independent of the radial coordinate @xmath7 , and where @xmath8 is the radial velocity . a thin accretion disc is supported by the centrifugal force in the radial direction , so we get that @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the azimuthal velocity , @xmath11 the gravitational constant and @xmath12 is the mass of the accretor . this shows that the disc rotates in a keplerian fashion . the disc is in hydrostatic equilibrium in the vertical direction , which gives us that the pressure at the midplane of the disc is @xmath13 but the hydrostatic equilibrium can also be expressed as @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the isothermal speed of sound . this shows that the keplerian velocity is highly supersonic in a thin accretion disc . the conservation of angular momentum leads to the following height - integrated equation ( paper i ) @xmath16_{-h}^{h}r + \frac{1}{r}\frac{\mbox{d}}{\mbox{d } r}\left[r^{3}\nu\sigma \frac{\mbox{d}}{\mbox{d } r } \left(\frac{l}{r^{2}}\right)\right],\ ] ] where the specific angular momentum @xmath17 and @xmath18 is the viscosity . the magnetic term describes the exchange of angular momentum between the disc and the star via the magnetosphere . we assume that the vertical magnetic field is due to the dipolar field of the neutron star , so that its value in the equatorial plane is @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the magnetic dipole moment of the star . there are two sources for @xmath21 . the shear between the keplerian disc and the magnetosphere produces a field whose value in the upper half of the disc is @xmath22 where @xmath23 @xmath24 is the angular velocity of the star , and @xmath25 is a dimensionless parameter of the order of a few @xcite . the magnetohydrodynamical turbulence in the accretion disc is also generating a magnetic field , @xmath26 , through a dynamo action ( see for instance @xcite ) . in order to estimate the strength of this magnetic field we start by making the assumptions that the turbulence is not affected by @xmath27 , which is justified because in general @xmath28-component of the turbulent maxwell stress tensor , @xmath29 , that transports the angular momentum , and we couple this to the pressure in the disc through the @xcite @xmath30-prescription @xmath31 note that a negative maxwell stress means that the angular momentum is transported outwards and that numerical simulations suggest that @xmath32 @xcite . @xcite suggested that than @xmath33 that was used by @xcite . ] @xmath34 where @xmath35 based on the numerical simulations by @xcite . we now assume that due to an inverse cascade this turbulent filed contains a large - scale field , @xmath36 @xcite , and we express the ratio of the large - scale field to the rms - value of the turbulent field as @xmath37 thus we can express the large - scale magnetic field , that couples to the magnetic field of the neutron star , as @xmath38 where @xmath39 , and a negative value describes a magnetic field which is pointing in the negative @xmath40-direction at the upper disc surface . we will in general be conservative and assume that @xmath41 , but the simulations by @xcite suggest that @xmath42 can be significantly larger . we can now re - express eq . ( [ ang_mom ] ) as @xmath43.\end{aligned}\ ] ] which can be formulated as an ordinary differential equation in @xmath44 ( paper i ) . for a slow inflow of matter through an optically thick disc the local viscous dissipation @xmath45 is balanced by the radiative losses @xmath46 . this leads to the height - integrated equation @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the temperature at the midplane of the disc , @xmath49 the stefan - boltzmann constant , and the optical depth of the disc is given by : @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the sum of the electron scattering opacity @xmath52 and the free - free opacity , which is given by kramer s law @xmath53 with @xmath54 combining eqs . ( 14 ) and ( 15 ) , we get @xmath55 the total pressure is the sum of gas and radiation pressure @xmath56 where @xmath57 is boltzmann s constant , @xmath58 the mean molecular weight for a fully ionised gas , @xmath59 the mass of a proton , and @xmath60 the speed of light , but the pressure can also be expressed using eq . ( [ hydro - eq ] ) for hydrostatic equilibrium . we can thus express the scale height in terms of the total pressure @xmath61 the viscous stress tensor ( paper 1 , eq . 30 ) gives us @xmath62 but pressure and density are related according to eq . ( [ hydro - eq ] ) , so we can solve for the density of the gas @xmath63 combining eqs . ( [ hydro - eq ] ) , ( [ ang - mom1 ] ) and ( [ density ] ) and using @xmath64 we get @xmath65^{1/2}(gm)^{-1/4}r^{-3/2 } \nonumber\\ - \frac{4\mu^{2}\gamma}{3\mu_{0}\sqrt{gm } } r^{-9/2}\left[1 - \left(\frac{r}{r_{\rm c}}\right)^{3/2}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath66 is the co - rotation radius , at which the keplerian angular velocity is the same as the stellar angular velocity . here @xmath67 is the spin period of the star and @xmath68 . as @xmath69 @xmath70 which we use as the outer boundary condition . we now introduce the dimensionless variable @xmath71 through @xmath72 and a dimensionless radial coordinate through @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the alfvn radius , which is given by setting the magnetic pressure equal to the ram pressure ( e.g. @xcite ) @xmath75 where @xmath76 represents the mass transfer rate in units of @xmath77 , and @xmath78 is the stellar magnetic moment in units of @xmath79tm@xmath1 . the alfvn radius should not be taken as the location of the inner edge of our discs , since this is a quantity that comes out of our solutions , but merely as a convenient length unit . furthermore we introduce the fastness parameter @xmath80 we can now write eq . ( [ diff_eq ] ) as : @xmath81^{1/2 } ( gm)^{-1/4}r_{a}^{-5/4}r^{-9/4 } \nonumber\\ - \frac{4\mu^{2}\gamma}{3\mu_{0}\sqrt{gm}\dot{m } } r_{a}^{-7/2}r^{-9/2 } \left[1 - \omega_{\rm s}r^{3/2}\right ] , % \left[1 - \left(\frac{r}{r_{c}}\right)^{3/2}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to solve eq . ( [ diff_eq_2 ] ) numerically we need to determine @xmath5 for the different regions in the disc . with gas pressure and kramer s opacity we get @xmath82 and for the gas pressure and electron scattering opacity @xmath83 finally with radiation pressure and electron scattering the scale height is @xmath84 which is essentially independent of r. this comes from the fact that for radiation pressure @xmath85 we can now write down the self - similar structure of the different regions of the accretion disc in terms of the function @xmath86 . the toroidal magnetic field is given by the same expression @xmath87 everywhere in the disc , but for all other quantities we have to handle the different regions of the disc separately . in the outer disc where @xmath88 and @xmath89 we have that : @xmath90 @xmath91 @xmath92 @xmath93 @xmath94 @xmath95 @xmath96 @xmath97 the transition from the outer to the middle region occurs where @xmath98 . assuming that @xmath99 at this point we have that the transition radius is @xmath100 which is independent of @xmath101 in the middle disc , where @xmath88 and @xmath102 , we have that : @xmath103 @xmath104 @xmath105 @xmath106 @xmath107 @xmath108 @xmath109 @xmath110 the disc structure changes drastically in the inner disc where @xmath111 and @xmath112 , where we have that @xmath113 @xmath114 @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath117 @xmath118 @xmath119 @xmath120 it is of particular significance here that @xmath121 . the transition radius between the middle and the inner region is estimated by equating the gas and radiation pressures in the middle region and approximating @xmath71 with @xmath122 @xmath123 we then see that the accretion disc right outside of the alfvn radius is dominated by radiation pressure only if @xmath124 this condition is not fulfilled for a conventional x - ray pulsar with a magnetic dipole moment of @xmath125tm@xmath1 @xcite , though it can be fulfilled for a millisecond x - ray pulsar . for our fiducial model we take a neutron star of @xmath126 with a magnetic moment of @xmath127 and a spin period of 4.8ms . we set the dimensionless parameters @xmath25 and @xmath128 to 1 and 10 , respectively , while @xmath129 @xmath25 , @xmath128 , and @xmath30 appear only in combinations with other parameters , and thus their values do not carry any special significance , but the parameters @xmath130 and @xmath131 appear on their own in the equation , and therefore influence the solution in unique ways . in particular @xmath131 influences the fastness parameter and the transition radii between the regions of the accretion disc . in this paper we consider three different accretion rates , @xmath132 , 0.12 and 1.5 . we list the corresponding fastness parameters and transition radii in tab . [ params ] . lllll + @xmath133 & @xmath134 [ m ] & @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 + + 0.012 & @xmath138 & 0.98 & + 0.12 & @xmath139 & 0.37 & 8.5 & + 0.8 & @xmath140 & 0.31 & 52 & 6.0 + 1.5 & @xmath141 & 0.12 & 95 & 12 + + the accretion disc consists of only an outer region when @xmath143 , which corresponds to that @xmath144kgs@xmath145 for our fiducial model . assuming @xmath146 we get the solutions from the top to the bottom of fig . [ lambdafigout ] for @xmath147 and @xmath148 . we see here that @xmath149 at a finite @xmath150 for @xmath151,and@xmath152 , which we called case d in paper i , since @xmath153 at this radius ( fig . [ sigmafigout ] ) . in the other cases @xmath71 grows without a bound for decreasing @xmath150 , which we call case v in paper i , since then the viscous flux of angular momentum changes sign at a finite radius where @xmath154 ( fig . [ innerfigouter ] ) , which we take as the inner edge of the disc . inside of this radius the accretion flow is driven by the magnetic coupling to the neutron star . the disc has both an outer and a middle region when @xmath156 . we then use the analytical solution with @xmath157 for the outer region and solve eq . ( [ diff_eq_2 ] ) numerically for the middle region . for our calculations we take @xmath158kgs@xmath145 , which yields @xmath159 . the numerical solutions for the middle region are shown in fig . [ lambdafigmiddle ] for our fiducial neutron star with @xmath160 , and @xmath148 . we find a case d inner boundary for @xmath161 , while the other solutions have case v inner boundaries . the transition from case d to case v at the @xmath130 , that gives the smallest possible radius for the inner edge of the disc , which varies weakly with the accretion rate @xmath131 . the innermost region of the disc is dominated by radiation pressure and electron scattering when @xmath163 . we use two different accretion rates that fulfill this condition , @xmath164kgs@xmath145 and @xmath165kgs@xmath145 together with our fiducial neutron star in our calculations . we assume that @xmath157 in the outer and middle regions of the disc , and solve eq . ( [ diff_eq_2 ] ) for the inner region starting from @xmath166 our solutions for the inner disc region at the higher accretion rate and with @xmath167 , and @xmath168 are shown in fig . [ lambdafiginner ] . all these solutions have case v inner boundaries except the @xmath169 model . however because @xmath170 in this case we see that the density goes to infinity at the inner edge of the @xmath171 disc ( fig . [ sigmainn ] ) , at which point the flow stagnates ( fig . [ radialvelocityfiginn ] ) . in the case v solutions , on the other hand , we see that @xmath172 at a point which is inside the inner edge of the disc ( fig . [ innerfigin ] ) . in order for the neutron star to appear as an x - ray pulsar the accretion disc must be truncated by the stellar magnetic field ( tab . [ table1 ] ) at a radius @xmath173 outside of the neutron star . the inner edge of the disc can be either of type d ( @xmath174 ) or type v ( @xmath175 ) ( see paper i for an extensive discussion of these boundaries ) . in models without a dynamo ( for instance @xcite ) @xmath173 is comparable to or smaller than the alfvn radius , @xmath134 , but we find that the dynamo can make it significantly larger than @xmath134 . this opens up the possibility , as suggested by the referee , that a system can temporarily turn into an x - ray pulsar during the periods when the magnetic field generated by the dynamo is strong enough to make @xmath173 larger than the radius of the neutron star . sax j1748.9 - 2021 is such an intermittent millisecond x - ray pulsar @xcite , which is on for hundreds of seconds at a time . in case @xmath173 is located in the outer or middle region of our disc solution we find that a type d boundary coincides with the point at which @xmath153 and @xmath176 though the accretion rate is finite . however a type d boundary in the inner part of the accretion disc behaves in the opposite way ; @xmath177 and @xmath178 . neither one of these behaviours is entirely physical and one must keep in mind that we have ignored the importance of the radial pressure gradient and the inertial term in eq . ( [ 3 ] ) ( see for instance @xcite ) , and we have not attempted to model how the plasma is entering the stellar magnetic field lines to form a funnel flow onto the magnetic poles of the neutron star . one further problem with the inner region of the disc solution is that it is known to be viscously and thermally unstable @xcite . this instability persists if the accretion disc is threaded by a stellar magnetic field @xcite , but so far it has not been investigated what happens if the accretion disc is sustaining its own magnetic field through a dynamo . to understand the nature of the exchange of angular momentum between the accretion disc and the neutron star we multiply eq . ( [ ang - mom1 ] ) by @xmath179 and integrate it from @xmath173 , the inner radius of the disc , to a large radius @xmath180 . @xmath181 the left - hand - side is the difference between the angular momentum that is advected through the inner edge of the accretion disc and that which is fed into the disc at its outer edge and the right - hand - side describes the contribution of magnetic and viscous torques to the angular momentum balance . notice that the term @xmath182 describes the viscous tension at the outer edge of the disc , which will not be considered further in this paper . the material torque of the inner edge of the disc on the neutron star is @xmath183 it increases as the accretion rate increases ( tab.[table1 ] ) . then we have the magnetic torques on the neutron star , which we have divided into one part due to the shear @xmath184 \mbox{d}r \end{aligned}\ ] ] and a second part due to the dynamo @xmath185 we split up the latter integral into one integral for each of the three different regions of the disc @xmath186 @xmath187 and @xmath188 finally we have the boundary terms describing the viscous stresses on the inner and the outer edges of the accretion disc . the viscous stress at the outer edge of the disc is responsible for removing the angular momentum that is transported outwards through the accretion disc , and does not affect the angular momentum evolution of the neutron star . the viscous stress at the inner edge of the disc on the other hand can result in a torque that transports angular momentum away from the neutron star @xmath189 this term is usually neglected in accretion disc theory since the standard accretion disc solution has a case d inner boundary . but it can transport angular momentum from the neutron star to the disc when we have a case v inner boundary . we report on all the components and the total sum of the torques on our fiducial neutron star in tab.[table1 ] . the main factor determining the total torque is the accretion rate . in paper i we found that the dominant contributor to the torque is the internal disc dynamo . this torque is still strong , but now @xmath190 and @xmath191 are comparable in strength , though these make opposing contributions to the net torque , while the contribution from @xmath192 is still small . there is therefore no simple dependence of @xmath193 on @xmath130 , though the dynamo is indirectly affecting @xmath190 and @xmath191 by causing the inner disc edge to move outwards compared to the @xcite model . @xmath191 is also highly sensitive to the nature of the inner disc boundary , and in particular it vanishes for a d inner boundary , which occurs at a sufficiently negative @xmath130 , in which case the net torque is determined by the balance between @xmath194 and @xmath190 . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] the largest spin up rate recorded so far for a millisecond x - ray pulsar is @xmath195hzs@xmath145 during the december 2004 outburst of igr j00291 + 5934 @xcite , but one should keep in mind that there are large uncertainties in the spin variations that have been reported for the millisecond x - ray pulsars . for instance @xcite reported @xmath196s between @xmath197 and @xmath198hzs@xmath145 for sax j1808.4 - 3658 , but @xcite noted that the measurements of this source are plagued by large variations in the pulse shape , and put an upper limit of @xmath199hzs@xmath145 on the spin variations at any instant . some of the timing noise in the millisecond x - ray pulsars can be explained by the motion of the hot spot on the neutron star @xcite , and may thus not correspond to real changes in the spin period of the neutron star . the spin variation corresponds to a torque @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the moment of inertia of the neutron star measured in @xmath202kgm@xmath203 , and @xmath204 is the spin derivative in units of @xmath205hzs@xmath145 . in the @xcite model , the spin variation of igr j00291 + 5934 would imply then an accretion rate of at least @xmath206kgs@xmath145 , which is uncomfortably large , but our tab . [ table1 ] shows that it is possible to enhance the torque severalfold by coupling the stellar magnetic field to the magnetic field generated by an internal dynamo in the disc , and through the fact that the inner edge of the accretion disc is then located outside the alfvn radius , which increases the amount of angular momentum that is advected onto the neutron star . thus it is possible that a lower accretion rate can produce the necessary torque , though we have not attempted to fit our model to this system . a significant part of the luminosity is not generated in the accretion disc outside of @xmath173 , but rather it is released as the accreting matter falls onto the neutron star . we estimate that this luminosity is @xmath207 where we have assumed that both the potential energy difference between the inner edge of the accretion disc and the surface of the neutron star as well as the kinetic energy associated with the keplerian motion at the inner edge of the accretion disc is released at the surface of the neutron star . consequently @xmath208 . the neutron star can then contribute to the local heating in the accretion disc through its irradiation of the disc . assuming that the neutron star is a point source and the accretion disc is flaring , i.e. @xmath209 , the irradiation flux on the accretion disc is at most @xcite @xmath210 where @xmath211 is the disc albedo ( for a more complete treatment taking into account shadowing by the disc see @xcite ) . the local flux generated by the viscous heating in the accretion disc is on the other hand @xmath212 we thus find that @xmath213 and since @xmath214 we find that irradiation dominates for @xmath215 if @xmath216 . consequently irradiation dominates over viscous heating for @xmath217 km . thus the outer part of the accretion disc is hotter than is predicted by our model , which can be observed as an increased uv flux @xcite . thus we have underestimated the pressure in the outer disc , and since we have used the @xcite prescription @xmath218 to estimate @xmath26 , we have also underestimated @xmath26 and the torque from the outer disc on the neutron star . however , this torque is small in comparison to the total torque on the neutron star since @xmath219 is a rapidly decreasing function of @xmath7 , and thus the effect of the irradiation of the outer disc does not significantly change our results . irradiation is unlikely to significantly affect the inner disc , but , as pointed out above , other effects , such as radial advection and the transition from a disc flow to a funnel flow , that are not considered in this paper become important in the inner disc . we will investigate these effects in the future . the accretion rates that have been observed in millisecond x - ray pulsars cover several orders of magnitude , and the highest accretion rates are sufficient that the innermost part of the accretion disc is dominated by radiation pressure and electron scattering . for these reasons we have followed the approach by @xcite and divided our disc model in three regions , an outer region dominated by gas pressures and kramer s opacity , a middle region dominated by gas pressure and electron scattering , and an inner region dominated by radiation pressure and electron scattering . the large spin changes that have been observed in some of the accreting millisecond x - ray pulsars are difficult to explain in the model by @xcite , but the inclusion of a disc dynamo produces a significant enhancement of the torque between the accretion disc and the neutron star . this increase is not only due to the coupling between the magnetic fields of the neutron star and the accretion disc as such , but also to the fact that the accretion disc is truncated at a larger radius thus increasing the lever arm between the edge of the disc and the neutron star . sbt thanks the department of physics at the university of gothenburg for their hospitality and support during a part of this project . sbt is supported in part by the swedish institute ( si ) under their guest scholarship program . this research has made use of nasa s astrophysics data system . we thank an anonymous referee for comments that have improved the quality of the paper . we have also benefitted from discussions with dr . jonathan ferreira .

millisecond x - ray pulsars have weak magnetic dipole moments of @xmath0tm@xmath1 compared to ordinary x - ray pulsars with dipole moments of @xmath2tm@xmath1 . for this reason a surrounding accretion disc can extend closer to the neutron star , and thus reach a higher temperature , at which the opacity is dominated by electron scattering and radiation pressure is strong . we compute the self - similar structure of such a geometrically thin axisymmetric accretion disc with an internal dynamo . such models produce significantly stronger torques on the neutron star than models without dynamos , and can explain the strong spin variations in some millisecond x - ray pulsars . [ firstpage ] accretion , accretion discs magnetic fields mhd stars : magnetic fields stars : neutron x - rays : binaries pulsars : general

1502.04937

high luminosity experiments will play a key role for the future of particle and nuclear physics . in consequence , the next generation of detectors will feature increased complexity and require outstanding capabilities , e.g. high channel density setups will cope with extreme count rates . nowadays the development of custom - designed fee for specific applications has become very demanding in terms of costs and resources . the development of dedicated application - specific integrated circuits ( asics ) , for example , has seen a dramatic increase in complexity and functionality @xcite . these reasons favor a multi - purpose approach to the development of new fee . + the proposed fee was developed to meet the challenging requirements of an imaging cherenkov counter , the barrel dirc ( detection of internally reflected cherenkov light ) @xcite of the panda experiment @xcite . the detection of single photons will be of fundamental importance for this detector . in particular , the photodetector readout based on microchannel plate photomultipliers ( mcp - pmts ) will deliver fast ( @xmath0 ns ) and small ( @xmath1 mv ) signals , with an intrinsic resolution better than 40 ps after time walk correction @xcite . high precision timing on single photo - electron ( spe ) ( @xmath2 ps ) is needed for pattern reconstruction and background suppression . moreover , the continuos @xmath3 beam with a planned 20 mhz average interaction rate ( with peaks up to 50 mhz ) , sets a minimum requirement of 100 khz per channel . last but not the least , the panda daq scheme imposes the use of triggerless fee . + the third version of the tdc readout board ( trb3 ) , developed at gsi , has been chosen as data acquisition system ( daq ) @xcite . the trb3 offers fpga - based tdcs with multi - hit capability and up to 10 ps time precision on leading and trailing edge time measurements ( 20 ps on average ) . high hit rate ( 67 mhz ) capability and a unique flexibility further suit the panda barrel dirc requirements . + a design based on fast discriminators meets the required specifications and minimizes the information to digitize . a coarse but fast measurement of the deposited charge can be obtained through time - over - threshold ( @xmath4 ) . a modular design with a preamplifier add - on card allows the realization of versatile fee . different detectors can be readout , for example plastic scintillators which usually deliver large signals produced by the energy loss of charged particles . the highly segmented plastic scintillator array for the future neutron detector ( ndet ) of the a1 collaboration @xcite was chosen as test case . the ndet will be instrumented with multianode pmts ( mapmts ) , with a total of about 8000 readout channels . the future physics programme imposes high rate requirements ( several mhz per channel ) . under these conditions , a @xmath4 logic is a valid choice , also because of the large amount of data . particle identification to distinguish neutrons and minimum ionizing particles ( mip ) is an additional asset . the development of this fee was focused on the realization of a modular and versatile design . the main component is a discriminator card realized with a printed circuit board ( pcb ) 8 cm long and 6 cm wide . the layout of the discriminator card was designed to be as compact as possible and to fit the mcp - pmt connectors . a picture of the discriminator card is shown in fig . [ fee_discriminator ] . + the nino asic , developed by the laa project at cern , was selected as core component for the discriminator card @xcite . the nino chip features 8 channels and was chosen among other similar asics for its excellent timing performances , low noise and low power consumption @xcite . + the output of common pmts , including mcp - pmts , is usually single - ended , while the input of the nino chip is differential . however the chip can work in `` single - ended mode '' @xcite , where one channel input is connected to the pmt output while the other is left open . two nino chips per card ( one per layer ) are used for a total of 16 readout channels . three commercial digital to analog converter chips ( dac ) set the working parameters of the nino chips like common thresholds , hysteresis and pulse stretcher widths ( offset for the input tot ) . in particular , the dacs define voltage offsets ( from 0 to 3.3v ) which are added to the inputs of each nino channel . these connections allow the definition of individual thresholds for every nino channel , which by design only have one common threshold per chip . the communication with the dacs is via a serial peripheral interface ( spi ) connection . the nino provides lvds ( low voltage differential signal ) output , which is fed through a specific adapter to the trb3 daq . the board requires an operating voltage of + 5 v. the power consumption was measured to be about 70 mw / channel . furthermore , the card provides the facility to power add - on cards with @xmath5 v. a preamplifier add - on card was designed for the spe scenario . the card , 4 cm long and 6 cm wide , has 16 ch ( 8 ch per layer ) . a current feedback amplifier chip provides about 20 db gain , with 1.8 ghz unity - gain bandwidth . the schematic for one channel is shown in fig . [ fee_schematic ] . the amplification shifts the input charge into a region ( @xmath6 fc ) where the intrinsic charge - dependent jitter of the nino @xcite is small . the fee cards were characterized under controlled conditions to understand the basic properties , as well as to investigate the behaviour of the single - ended scheme with individual thresholds . the discriminator and the preamplifier cards were first tested separately , using a programmable fast pulse generator ( 2 gs / s and 250 mhz bandwidth ) . the readout was realized with a fast oscilloscope ( 10 gs / s and bandwidth of 2 ghz ) , so that the complete waveforms were available for offline analysis . subsequently the fee cards together with the trb3 daq , were tested under realistic conditions using a fast laser setup . the @xmath4 behaviour of the discriminator cards was analyzed choosing rectangular pulses with fixed amplitude and variable width as input . [ fee_nino_tot_response ] shows the @xmath4 of the nino output as function of the input width of the pulser signal . the response is perfectly linear up to almost 25 ns . at this value , corresponding to an input charge @xmath7 of 1.5 pc , the discriminator exhibits a saturation effect on the @xmath4 . the result qualitatively agrees with the 2 pc limit on the input charge reported for the nino asic @xcite . observations showed no limits for @xmath8 ns with @xmath9 pc . further tests revealed that the leading edge time at saturation can be used up to an input charge of about 300 pc , while higher charge values introduce after - pulse effects after the main output signal . the individual thresholds realized in the discriminator pcb were calibrated using short square pulses ( @xmath10 ) . the average amplitude at which the nino started producing output signals was recorded for various threshold settings . the result , shown in fig . [ fee_thr_calibration ] , is clearly nonlinear and is fit with the following exponential function : @xmath11 the equation allows the precise setting of the threshold levels to the desired input amplitude . the preamplifier cards are designed for use in a single photon environment . consequently , the characterization with fast and small signals is of particular interest . the typical shape of the mcp - pmt response to single photons was reproduced with the pulser , using two gaussian distributions matching in the peak position . the standard deviation of the first gaussian represented the rising part of the signal and was set to @xmath12 ns . the second distribution took into account the decay time of the signal , with a standard deviation set to @xmath13 ns . the data in fig . [ fee_preamp ] shows the amplitude response to different pulse heights . the trend is linear and returns a gain value @xmath14 . the result agrees with the design value of 20 db considering the 50 @xmath15 termination before the output ( see fig . [ fee_schematic ] ) . the operation of the discriminator card together with the preamplifier was verified under realistic conditions . the most challenging scenario of single photon detection was reproduced by illuminating an mcp - pmt with a fast laser pulser ( 35 ps fwhm , @xmath16 nm ) at a photon level of 0.3 @xmath17/pulse . the photodetector was equipped with 4 fee cards plus add - on cards , for a total of 64 readout channels . the laser beam was focused on a central pixel and set to a trigger rate of 1 khz . the setup was placed inside a light - tight box to shield the pmt from ambient light . two trb3 boards were used to readout the system . + the behaviour of the tot as function of the individual threshold ( fig . [ fee_tot_behaviour ] ) allows the definition of a proper working threshold at the end of the plateau ( @xmath18 v ) , as well as serving as a cross check between laser and test experiment ( see section [ sec_dirc ] ) data . the scatter plot in fig . [ tot_corr ] shows the arrival time relative to the laser trigger @xmath19 as function of the measured tot . the signals at @xmath20 ns belong to backscattered photo - electrons @xcite . the correlation between tot and @xmath19 can be considered in first approximation linear and is used for a walk correction as given below : @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the parametrisation of the distributions in fig . [ tot_corr ] . + defining the timing resolution @xmath23 as the standard deviation of @xmath24 , the walk correction returns @xmath25 ps , gaining an improvement of 40@xmath26 with respect to the raw timing resolution ( @xmath27 ps ) . this value represents the timing resolution for spe of the full readout , and is already well below the 100 ps required by the panda barrel dirc . the full electronics chain comprising mcp - pmts , fee and trb3 was extensively studied during a test experiment at the mami accelerator in mainz @xcite . the continuous wave beam provides electrons with an energy of 855 mev , a spot diameter of 1 mm and a negligible divergence @xcite . a small scale dirc prototype with a fused silica radiator bar and an expansion volume filled with mineral oil was instrumented with a matrix of 4 mcp - pmts , set to approximately @xmath28 gain . 16 fee cards ( with add - on cards ) were used with a total of 256 channels read out with trb3 boards ( more details in @xcite ) . incidence angle . monte carlo simulation is shown in grey . ] [ poster ] shows the result for a configuration for which the incidence angle between the radiator and the beam was @xmath29 . the image shows an overlay of 1 million events . the cherenkov pattern is clearly visible and was confirmed by varying the incidence angles . the results agree with a monte carlo simulation based on ray tracing @xcite ( shown in grey and used only to verify the correct position ) . the fee shows a good performance for single - photon detection under the anticipated working conditions . the fee contribution @xmath30 to the spe timing resolution was measured taking advantage of charge sharing between neighbouring pixels in the same mcp - pmt . the low number of detected photons per event ( 2 - 3 ) allows the identification of charge sharing as spe events . in this way the contribution of the mcp - pmt to the timing is minimised and the electronics determines the obtainable resolution . the results , shown in fig . [ time_res_same_mcp ] , can be fit with a sum of two gaussians taking into account the presence of back - scattered photo - electrons inside the mcp - pmt . the timing resolution @xmath30 is defined as the standard deviation of the narrow peak . the walk correction improves @xmath30 by about 70% , with an excellent value of @xmath31 ps . the different running conditions ( e.g. temperature and gain ) , between the laser characterization and the test experiment , require the optimisation for the coefficients of @xmath32 in eq . [ timewalk ] . in particular the slope @xmath33 of the time walk parametrisation ( see fig . [ tot_corr ] ) was tuned by varying its value found with the laser studies and looking for a minimum of the timing resolution @xmath30 . this simple algorithm further improves the timing resolution on average to @xmath34 ps . the result is interpreted as the intrinsic resolution of the whole electronics chain . + the timing resolution of the prototype @xmath35 was measured considering the time differences of pixels from different mcp - pmts in the horizontal plane ( @xmath36 ) , which refers to photons with a symmetric path from the radiator to the focal plane . the results , see fig . [ time_res ] , are obtained with the same fitting techniques exploited for @xmath30 . in this case the timing resolution corresponds to @xmath37 . the walk correction reduces the value of @xmath35 from about 141 ps down to 103 ps improving the performance by about 25% . + the monte carlo simulation used for the cherenkov pattern , estimates the timing contribution of the radiator bar as @xmath38 ps . the measured resolution @xmath39 can be obtained in first approximation by : @xmath40 where @xmath41 ps , @xmath34 ps and @xmath42 ps @xcite . the difference between simulation and measurement is mainly due to synchronisation precision between the fpgas of different trb3 boards , and can be estimated as @xmath43 in agreement with preliminary laboratory tests . a summary of the measured timing resolutions can be found in tab . [ time_res_resume ] . + .summary of the measured timing resolutions . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ table ] the timing performance , as established in fig . [ stability ] , was stable over an extended period of time . globally the excellent timing resolution on spe meets the requirement of the panda barrel dirc . over an extended period of data taking . ] scintillator arrays for neutron detection are usually characterized by a large amount of channels and high background conditions . the response of the fee to scintillator signals was investigated with a ndet prototype . the three spectrometer setup of the a1 collaboration @xcite at mami offered the possibility of coincidence measurements in pion photoproduction ( @xmath44 ) between the @xmath45 and the particles hitting the detector . the prototype of the ndet is composed of two layers of plastic scintillator bars ( 64 bars per layer ) , placed atop each other and parallelly aligned . each bar is read out by three wavelength shifting fibers ( wls ) which are connected via commercial optical connectors to three clear fibers ( on both sides ) . the clear fibers are then connected to multi - anode pmts . the prototype was instrumented with a total of 4 mapmt ( 2 per layer ) . the fee cards were connected to the mapmts with dedicated pcb adapters , and read out with 3 trb3 boards , for a total of 256 channels . the preamplifier add - on cards were not used in this experiment because of the expected large signals from the scintillators . the use of discriminators for such kind of detector is justified by the high rate per channel ( several mhz ) . prior experiments with a similar detector concept using an adc - based readout had difficulties due to pile - up effects @xcite . ns and [ -400,-300 ] ns belong to mips and neutrons respectively , while the band with @xmath46 ns is interpreted as noise signals . ] different particles species could be disentangled with simple cuts on the arrival time . the results in fig . [ neutron_scat ] show the @xmath4 spectrum as function of the arrival time ( relative to the a1 trigger at 0 ns ) . in the analysis a coincidence between left and right pmt channel is required , and all scintillator bars contribute to the plot . the structure between [ -500,-400 ] ns belongs to mips , which are mainly electrons from elastic scattering . the events inside [ -400,-300 ] ns refer to neutrons . the band with @xmath46 ns is due to noise signals . the @xmath4 spectra for mips , neutrons and noise were studied selecting the corresponding region of interest . the result in fig . [ neutron_tot ] shows an appreciable difference for the @xmath4 . in particular the response to neutrons is characterized by a larger @xmath4 average with respect to mips . normalizing both spectra and taking into account a cut around the crossing point ( @xmath4720 ns ) , the fraction of mips in the neutron sample amounts to 26@xmath26 . the @xmath4 spatial distribution was also expected to provide additional information to disentangle neutrons and mips . the results in fig . [ neutron_tot_bars ] show the @xmath4 spectra of incoming particles across the layers . the homogeneous band at @xmath48 ns is due to mips which propagate along the detectors . the neutrons cause an excess of events at higher @xmath4 ( 20 - 30 ns ) , which is observed between the 2@xmath49 and the 15@xmath50 bar . a dedicated geant simulation @xcite fully agrees with the observations , and predicted also the behaviour of the first bar not showing a @xmath4 excess for neutrons . the ndet requirements call for high count rates per channel on the order of mhz . the nino asic can sustain rates larger than 10 mhz @xcite . however , the single ended scheme adopted for the fee and the individual threshold had to be verified . a high beam current as used for a previous measurement of the neutron electric form factor at a1 @xcite was chosen for the studies . considering the trigger window of 1.2 @xmath51s set for the trb3 readout , and the number of hits per channel registered , the average rate could be reconstructed ( see fig . [ neutron_rate ] ) . a fit with a gaussian distribution gives a mean count rate of 2.8 mhz per channel with peaks up to 12 mhz . under these conditions no saturation effects or @xmath4 modifications were discovered , which confirm the high rate capability of the developed fee . the electronics meets the requirement of the a1 ndet . the versatile design of the discriminator cards offers a compact package and low power consumption . the single ended input and individual thresholds scheme were successfully implemented and verified under realistic conditions . the developed fee shows excellent results . + the response to single photon events , typical for imaging cherenkov detectors , was successfully investigated with a fast laser pulser . the results proved the feasibility of using tot to correct the time walk , with a timing resolution for the whole readout chain of 75 ps . during a test experiment with a small scale dirc prototype , the fee achieved an excellent intrinsic resolution of 40 ps and a detector timing resolution of @xmath52 ps . + the results of the a1 ndet studies proved the versatility of the fee design , which can be used to read out plastic scintillator arrays . the @xmath4 is able to deliver information about the deposited energy , fundamental for disentangling mips from neutrons . an additional tuning of the fee could improve the achievable resolution , which depends on the scintillator light yield . the fee meets the most demanding requirement of high count rates , with the possibility to reach an average of 2.8 mhz per channel without any signal degradations . + further improvements will focus on the finalisation of the fee design . in particular the availability of a 32 ch nino chip version opens the way to higher channel density designs . the optimisation of the power consumption is another goal of future developments . this work is partly supported by bmbf under contract no 05p12umfp4 and the helmholtz graduate school for hadron and ion research . the authors would like to express their gratitude to the trb3 collaboration for their outstanding support .

future experiments of nuclear and particle physics are moving towards the high luminosity regime , in order to access suppressed processes like rare b decays or exotic charmonium resonances . in this scenario , high rate capability is a key requirement for electronics instrumentation , together with excellent timing resolution for precise event reconstruction . the development of dedicated frontend electronics ( fee ) for detectors has become increasingly challenging . a current trend in r&d is towards multipurpose fee which can be easily adapted to a great variety of detectors , without impairing the required high performance . + we report on high - precision timing solutions which utilise high - bandwidth preamplifiers and fast discriminators providing time - over - threshold information , which can be used for charge measurements or walk corrections thus improving the obtainable timing resolution . the output signal are lvds and can be directly fed into a multi - hit tdc readout . the performance of the electronics was investigated for single photon signals , typical for imaging cherenkov detectors . the opposite condition of light signals arising from plastic scintillators , was also studied . high counting rates per channel of several mhz were achieved , and a timing resolution of better than 100 ps could be obtained in a test experiment using the full readout chain . fast timing , single photo - electron , frontend electronics , multipurpose , time - over - threshold , pid

1601.06582

liquid crystalline order is ubiquitous in biological materials @xcite and many properties of these systems can be analyzed in terms of the standard landau - de gennes approach @xcite , without particularly worrying about e.g. the polymer nature of the main - chain polymer nematogens . nevertheless , it was recognized a while ago , that the landau - de gennes approach needs to be modified specifically to take into account the polymer nature , i.e. the microscopic connectivity of the underlying mesogens @xcite . this connectivity leads to a coupling between the positional and orientational order of the polymer molecules . the ensuing continuity equation " derived to take into account this specificity of the polymer mesophase materials was shown to matter fundamentally for a consistent description of macroscopic properties of these systems @xcite . in addition , recently we showed that depending on the nature and the symmetry of the mesophase order , this continuity equation " might not be the only condition that the coarse grained description of polymer nematics needs to satisfy . in fact , its generalized form in terms of a vectorial conservation law @xcite suffices for polar nematic order , while in the more usual quadrupolar nematic order case a different , tensorial conservation law has to be included in the landau - de gennes description @xcite . discovering a new form of the conservation law , stemming from the microscopic connectivity of the constitutive nematogen molecules , naturally leads to questions , such as which form of the conservation law is the correct one , how are they related , when is the use of one preferred to the other one and how important is their implementation for the proper description of polymer nematics . in this note we address and resolve all these fundamental questions for future applications . in fact , we show that the two conservation laws are not equivalent , are irreducible and in general lead to different consequences specifically stemming from the presence of the backfolding configurations of the polymer chains , or in an extreme case , to the presence of localized hairpins and/or kinks which should be in particular relevant in the description of confined dna mesophases , where such local defects or elastic energy non - linearities have been implicated recently @xcite . in what follows , extending our previous analysis @xcite , we thus propose a new , generalized conservation law for the main - chain polymer nematics that _ consistently incorporates _ both the vectorial as well as the tensorial conservation laws . moreover , and in particular , this includes also a well - grounded interpretation of the recently derived tensorial conservation law that has been so far elusive . we also indicate to what extent and in which cases applying the vectorial constraint to nematic director of the main - chain polymer is invalidated , even in the case of perfectly rigid chains , and leads to fundamentally wrong conclusions . in addition we show that the two constituent conservation laws are manifest in the two extreme cases of flexible and inflexible chains , respectively . the present analysis is also relevant to ascertain the detectability of the two constraints , whether to pinpoint the observable differences between them or the novel features of their joint implementation , for which a detailed simulation approach , on which we recently embarked , seems at present to be our best guide @xcite . on the macroscopic level , the microscopic connectivity of monomers into the chain of a main - chain polymer nematic shows up as a constraint linking director deformations and density variations . since its formulation , the accepted form of this constraint has been @xcite @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the surface density of polymer chains perforating the plane perpendicular to the nematic director @xmath2 , while @xmath3 and @xmath4 are volume densities of the beginnings and endings of chains , respectively . this constraint has been used in connection with the nematic director , i.e. , the principal axis of the nematic order tensor @xmath5 , describing quadrupolar orientational ordering @xcite . including the modulus of the orientational ordering , it becomes apparent that the constraint eq . ( [ vectorial - n ] ) naturally augments to a vectorial law , i.e. , the conservation law for the polymer current density @xmath6 @xcite , @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the volume density of arbitrary polymer segments ( e.g. monomers ) of length @xmath9 and @xmath10 is the mesoscopic average of monomer tangents @xmath11 . in passing , by comparison of eqs . ( [ vectorial - n ] ) and ( [ vectorial ] ) we see that @xmath12 , which can be also straightforwardly inferred from geometry . a formal derivation @xcite of eq . ( [ vectorial ] ) leaves no doubt that this is indeed the exact conservation law for the polar orientational order @xmath13 of the chain tangents . however , recently we derived a different , tensorial conservation law @xcite for main - chain polymer nematics , of the form @xmath14 = \textstyle{3\over 2 } \partial_i \left(g_i^+ - g_i^-\right ) , \label{tensorial}\ ] ] where @xmath15 is the volume density of chain head / tail tangents . conforming to the quadrupolar symmetry , heads and tails are indistinguishable in @xmath16 , with the tangents always pointing away from the head / tail . this purely geometric ( kinematic ) continuity condition , just like the vectorial analogue eq . ( [ vectorial ] ) , is a consequence of the fact that in a system of unbreakable chains the orientation and the position of a monomer are not independent , and must be satisfied by any configuration @xmath17 . for a configuration @xmath17 , the requirement eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) is however not the complete story it is a necessary but , in general , not the only condition the tensorial configuration must satisfy . namely , since quadrupolar order is insensitive to chain backfolding , the tensorial constraint eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) is not at all affected by the flexibility of the chain . therefore , in order to describe the chain rigidity ( semi - flexibility ) , the tensorial constraint requires the backup of the tighter vectorial constraint eq . ( [ vectorial ] ) , as we will propose in what follows . indeed we will show that inflexible chains ( no chain backfolding ) should follow closely the vectorial conservation eq . ( [ vectorial ] ) for the nematic director ( which can be defined as a vector in this limit ) , and that flexible chains with strong backfolding , and therefore necessarily with a vanishing local mesoscopic polar order of chain tangents , should satisfy the tensorial conservation eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) . the aim here is thus to shed light on the connection between the vectorial and the tensorial conservation laws and to elaborate on the correct application of both conservation laws to the general case of semi - flexible chains , which should include the limits of inflexible and flexible chains as special cases . the vectorial conservation law has been standardly used for the nematic director , and vice versa , the constraint linking density variations and nematic director deformations has been implemented exclusively in terms of the vectorial conservation law . however , in principle , this is problematic . the vectorial conservation law is the continuity equation for the polymer current density , which is a vectorial quantity . as such , strictly speaking it can not be expressed in terms of a quantity with quadrupolar symmetry like the nematic director . in this section we present the underlying argument that nevertheless enables the use of the vectorial conservation law also for the nonpolar nematic director . the basis of this argument is the interpretation of chain hairpins ( point - like @xmath18 turns ) as effective chain ends . this viewpoint dates back to odijk @xcite and is also reflected in subsequent stat - mech results @xcite . here we articulate it for general backfoldings , in a way that rigorously connects with the macroscopic vectorial conservation law eq . ( [ vectorial ] ) . in a system of chains that does not exhibit macroscopic polar order ( the chains themselves can be either apolar or polar ) , one can not define a vectorial order parameter . if a polar orientational order is nevertheless defined in a local mesoscopic volume by an arbitrary convention of the chain directions ( e.g. such as to maximize the so - defined local polar order ) , it will decay away from this point with a finite characteristic length ( represented by the global persistence length @xcite ) depending on the density of hairpins or the extent of chain backfolding in general . this decay length is not necessarily small and may be comparable to other length scales in the system including the system size . it distinguishes between ensembles of stiff vs. flexible chains and is therefore a physical reality not in terms of orientational order ( which for apolar phases and , by definition , for apolar chains is insensitive to the extent of backfolding ) , but in terms of the chain backfolding configurational degrees of freedom . following the arguments presented by odijk , the density of top and bottom hairpins @xcite should enter the vectorial conservation law as a source term , similar to the density of chain heads and tails in eq . ( [ vectorial ] ) . but how can one consistently apply the vectorial conservation law if the polar orientational order can not be defined ? one can circumvent the inherent destruction of polar orientational order due to chain backfolding , by introducing virtual ( imaginary ) cuts in every chain as soon and each time it gets _ backfolded _ with respect to the nematic director , fig . [ fig : cutting ] . let us assign , arbitrarily but globally , an arrow to the director ( in this context we are not worried by the resulting branch cuts in the case when topological disclinations are present ) to get a _ nematic vector _ @xmath19 , fig . [ fig : cutting]a . the virtual cut is made whenever @xmath20 changes sign , fig . [ fig : cutting]b , which is also the definition of the chain backfolding ( one should not confuse it with the hairpin ) . every cut generates a @xmath21 chain sink and a @xmath22 chain source that coincide and thus add to zero . such cuts are therefore purely imaginary and have no observable effect . however , now one can , without any physical change , reverse all the segments between those virtual cuts that have @xmath23 , thereby also swapping the sources and sinks of these segments , fig . [ fig : cutting]c . instead of the previous coinciding sources and sinks we now generated @xmath24 sources and @xmath25 sinks , separated in the directions upstream and downstream with respect to @xmath19 , respectively , and in particular , we created a nonvanishing macroscopic polar order @xmath26 of chain tangents the _ recovered polar order _ , for which @xmath27 holds due to the head - tail symmetry of nematic ordering . note again that the system of chains was not modified physically in any way by this purely formal process . let us introduce a general source field @xmath28 in the vectorial conservation eq . ( [ vectorial ] ) , now reading @xmath29 for a uniform distribution of backfoldings that is expected in a nondeformed equilibrium configuration , the coarse - grained density of the new @xmath30 sources @xmath31 is still zero . what is different , however , is the susceptibility @xmath32 of the @xmath33 variations , given by the equilibrium densities of chain heads @xmath34 and tails @xmath35 in the noninteracting ideal gas model @xcite , @xmath36 . crucially , the recovered polar order _ does not _ depend on the density of backfoldings ( for a given shape of the monomer orientational distribution function , its value is rigidly connected to the degree of nematic quadrupolar order ) , whereas the densities @xmath34 and @xmath35 _ do _ they are equal to the densities of the corresponding backfoldings . this , however , has physical implications described by the vectorial conservation law eq . ( [ vectorial_rho_pms ] ) and the free energy of deviations of the source densities @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 from their equilibrium values @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath35 , @xmath34 , @xmath43 in other words , the introduction of the backfolding cuts @xmath35 and @xmath34 makes the @xmath33 variations cheaper , thereby weakening the vectorial constraint for the recovered polar order . let us reduce the unnecessary complexity of the sources and their free energy cost eq . ( [ f_pms_general ] ) and show this explicitly . the number of chain heads equals the number of chain tails and therefore @xmath44 the apolar symmetry of the nematic phase furthermore requires @xmath45 to simplify life further , in a model we may describe both types of sources , i.e. , chain ends @xmath46 and chain backfoldings @xmath47 , on an equal basis , writing @xmath48 and therefore also @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is a parameter of the system . hence , both types of sources can be expressed in terms of the total strength of sources @xmath51 as @xmath52 while the free energy cost of the sources eq . ( [ f_pms_general ] ) , @xmath53 is expressed as a single quadratic term , @xmath54 in the absence of the backfolding cuts , @xmath55 and nelson s result @xcite for the susceptibility @xmath32 is recovered . as soon as the density of backfoldings increases , however , @xmath32 is lowered and eventually vanishes in the strong backfolding limit @xmath56 . to recapitulate , the recovered polar order is insensitive to the degree of chain backfolding and is thus a well - defined quantity . the strength of the vectorial constraint for the recovered polar order , however decreases with increasing degree of chain backfolding . moreover , in the limit of strong backfolding , this constraint vanishes completely . the strength of the vectorial constraint for the recovered polar order thus depends on the density of backfoldings ( besides the density of chain heads / tails ) and vice versa , in the continuum description the semi - flexibility of the polymer chain is controlled exactly and exclusively by the strength of this constraint . in the light of this section , the vectorial conservation law can thus be , perfectly rigorously , applied also to apolar nematic ordering . however , this is the conservation law for the recovered polar order and not for the quadrupolar order . actually , this reasoning must have been more or less tacitly assumed every time the vectorial constraint was applied on the nematic director . at the end of section [ sec : s=1 ] it will become evident , why and when this simplistic standard application is incorrect . it is illuminating to study the tensorial conservation law in its integral form . being first order in gradients , the integrated constraint can be conveniently compared with the vectorial constraint . starting with the general tensorial conservation law eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) , we can integrate it once to obtain @xmath57 = \textstyle{3\over 2 } \left(g_i^+ - g_i^-\right ) + { \textstyle{3\over 2}}\epsilon_{ijk}\partial_j \psi_k , \label{curvature_mac}\ ] ] where the second term on the right - hand side is divergence - free . to recognize the meaning of the divergence - free component , along the lines of ref . @xcite we revert to the microscopic fields , writing @xmath58 + { \textstyle{3\over 2 } } \int_{{\bf x}(s ) } ds ~{d^2 x_i(s)\over ds^2 } \delta({\bf x } - { \bf x}(s ) ) , \label{curvature_mic}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the chain curvature @xmath59 besides nonsingular ( @xmath60 ) may have also singular contributions ( in general these may be singular kinks of any angle , but here we restrict ourselves to hairpins only ) ; a sum over all hairpins is omitted for brevity . we thus have @xmath61 from here it is already clear that point - like hairpins are analogous to chain beginnings / endings . we can rewrite eq . ( [ curvature_mac ] ) by coarse graining eq . ( [ curvature_mic_nice ] ) : @xmath62 = { \textstyle{3\over 2 } } \left(g_i^+ - g_i^- + 2 h_i + \rho\ell_0 k_i \right ) , \label{curvature_mac_nice}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is now the density of hairpin principal normals , while @xmath64 is the average nonsingular chain curvature field ; @xmath65 is the total length of the polymer within the coarse - graining volume @xmath66 centered at @xmath67 . hence , we learn that @xmath68 while the contribution of the curvature singularities ( point - like hairpins ) which is generally not divergence - free has been exempt from @xmath69 and added to the sources of the tensorial conservation law eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) , now reading @xmath70 . we note that in the context of the tensorial conservation law point - like hairpins are only a formal abstraction in reality they need not exist , i.e. , the chain tangent can be always regarded continuous , no matter how large the curvature ; therefore @xmath71 , and eq . ( [ curvature_mac_nice ] ) will serve merely to establish a link with the vectorial conservation ( see below ) . one might , however , have a specific physical reason to bring in also point - like hairpins and/or kinks : in some polymers such as dna discrete kinks of the polymer chain might be present as a chemical configurational entity alternative to large - scale loops of distributed curvature @xcite . in this case , eq . ( [ curvature_mac_nice ] ) tells us how to account for such kinks explicitly in the conservation law ( @xmath63 is then a new variable that enters also the energy functional ) . the presence of thermalized kinks or even better , their generation by the addition of certain dna binding proteins @xcite , might constitute an interesting new way to actually observe and control the role of the tensorial continuity constraint . to establish the connection with the nematic director @xmath72 ( which is a natural reduction towards the vectorial order parameter ) , in eq . ( [ curvature_mac_nice ] ) we use the uniaxial ansatz @xmath73 to get @xmath74n_i + \textstyle{3\over 2}\rho s\left[n_i\partial_j n_j + n_j\partial_j n_i\right ] + \textstyle{1\over 2}\partial_i\left[\rho(1-s)\right]\right\ } = \textstyle{3\over 2 } \left(g_i^+ - g_i^- + 2h_i + \rho\ell_0 k_i\right ) . \label{uniaxial_conservation}\ ] ] in the case of a perfect _ local _ orientational order , @xmath75 , the chain end tangents @xmath76 and the hairpin principal normals @xmath77 are aligned with the director , whereas @xmath78 is perpendicular . in this case we have @xmath79n_i + { \textstyle{3\over 2}}\rho\ , n_j\partial_j n_i \right\ } = \textstyle{3\over 2 } \left(g_i^+ - g_i^- + 2h_i + \rho\ell_0 k_i\right)\ ] ] and hence in the directions parallel and perpendicular to @xmath72 , respectively : @xmath80 thus , in the limit @xmath75 the vectorial conservation law is recovered exactly , with the hairpins acting as @xmath30 sources or sinks , while the macroscopic director bending field is equal to the local chain curvature . we also see that in case chain backfoldings are present ( due to @xmath75 these must be point - like hairpins ) , eq . ( [ parallel ] ) is exactly the vectorial conservation law eqs . ( [ vectorial_rho_pms ] ) and ( [ sources_total ] ) for the recovered ( ! ) polar order in the limit @xmath81 ( the statement holds also in the absence of hairpins , obviously ) . as soon as @xmath82 , on the other hand , the directions @xmath83 and @xmath84 are not decoupled in the conservation law eq . ( [ uniaxial_conservation ] ) , since @xmath85 $ ] , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , and @xmath88 all point in general directions . in this case the integrated conservation law eq . ( [ curvature_mac_nice ] ) is not useful and the original tensorial conservation law eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) must be used . since @xmath82 in all real systems , the tensorial conservation law eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) can not be in general reduced to the vectorial one and thus represents a new , distinct constraint . only in the limit of perfect orientational order , @xmath75 , the tensorial conservation law and the vectorial conservation law for the recovered polar order are indeed completely equivalent . hence , it is only in this limit that the use of the vectorial conservation law for the nematic director ( provided that the hairpins are included in the sources , of course ) is correct . the stronger the deviation from perfect orientational order , the more inaccurate the vectorial conservation law description becomes , invalidating the results obtained from the assumption of its general validity . in the context of no backfolding limit mentioned in sec . [ sec : intro ] , it is important to address the relation between the tensorial and the vectorial conservation laws for the general case @xmath82 . from what has been shown above , we understand that for @xmath82 the two conservation laws can not be equivalent . however , in the limit of weak chain backfolding , both tensorial and vectorial ( of the recovered polar order ) constraints are effective in principle ( the latter due to the small density of the backfolding cuts ) . therefore the compatibility of the two constraints must be inspected to ensure that they are not in an incurable conflict , in particular for long chains without backfoldings , when both constraints are rigid . this is certainly crucial for a consistent definition of a combined , generalized conservation law . retaining the uniaxial ansatz eq . ( [ uniaxial ] ) , for @xmath89 , @xmath90 , and in the absence of sources the tensorial constraint eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) reads @xmath91 which is incompatible with the no - splay requirement ( @xmath92 ) of the vectorial constraint , as in the second term it includes also the director bend deformation . in the following we show that this peculiarity of the bend deformation is connected with the arbitrarily imposed uniaxiality of the @xmath5-tensor . let us now allow a general form of the @xmath5-tensor , @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the biaxiality and @xmath95 is an orthonormal triad . with this ansatz , the tensorial constraint eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) in the absence of sources reads @xmath96n_i+{\textstyle{3\over 2}}\rho s(\partial_j n_j)\,n_i + { \textstyle{3\over 2}}\rho s\ , n_j(\partial_j n_i ) + { \textstyle{1\over 2}}\delta_{ij}^\perp\partial_j\left[\rho(1-s)\right]\right . + \label{biax1}\\ + \left.{\textstyle{1\over 2}}e_j^1\partial_j(\rho p)\,e_i^1-{\textstyle{1\over 2}}e_j^2\partial_j(\rho p)\,e_i^2 + { \textstyle{1\over 2}}\rho p\,\partial_j\left(e_i^1 e_j^1 - e_i^2 e_j^2\right ) \right\ } = 0 , \label{biax2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the gradients of @xmath97 and @xmath98 were split into longitudinal and transverse parts with respect to @xmath72 ; @xmath99 . consider a uniaxial configuration that undergoes a bend deformation at constant @xmath97 and @xmath98 , while at the same time the vectorial constraint rigidly requires @xmath100 and thus also @xmath101 . by inspecting the directions of the terms in eq . ( [ biax1])-([biax2 ] ) inside the @xmath102 bracket , one can verify that the bend term ( @xmath84 ) can be canceled by the first or second term in the line eq . ( [ biax2 ] ) , provided that the gradient of the biaxiality becomes nonzero and the biaxial director @xmath103 or @xmath104 is parallel to the principal normal defined by the bend deformation . that the bend deformation is connected with the biaxiality is not surprising already in low - molecular - weight nematics the bend deformation , by asymmetry , induces a slight biaxiality . if the configuration is already biaxial , then also the last term of eq . ( [ biax2 ] ) is nonzero . in general , all three directions are involved , also @xmath97 and @xmath98 are varying , of course , and only @xmath102 must vanish rather than the expression inside the bracket , such that all degrees of freedom take their share in accommodating the tensorial constraint . it is thus indeed possible to satisfy both constraints simultaneously , even if they are rigid . moreover , it is possible that the no - splay requirement does not affect the bend deformation , as in the case of the vectorial constraint alone . to what extent the tensorial constraint will be accommodated by variations of @xmath105 , @xmath98 , @xmath94 , @xmath103 , and @xmath97 is controlled by the relative free energy cost of these variations . the same holds for variations of @xmath13 and @xmath97 connected by the vectorial constraint . finally , it is important to recognize the following point . consider the case where the biaxiality is initially zero and the terms in the transverse directions vanish inside the @xmath102 bracket of eq . ( [ biax1])-([biax2 ] ) as before . the tensorial condition eq . ( [ biax1])-([biax2 ] ) is met if the longitudinal terms inside the bracket satisfy @xmath106+{\textstyle{3\over 2}}\rho s(\partial_j n_j ) = 0 $ ] . this requirement is very similar to the vectorial constraint @xmath107 , where @xmath108 , but not identical . even for @xmath109 , unless @xmath75 , the connection between splay and variations of the moduli is slightly different . this can not be lifted it is due to the inherent difference between polar and quadrupolar moments of orientational order . the reduction from the full @xmath5-tensor to the frequently used uniaxial director description is , in the context of the conservation laws , not an automatism as we have just seen . one can make various assumptions / models of how the omitted degrees of freedom entering the tensorial conservation behave when the reduction is made . for example , just using the uniaxial ansatz in eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) forbids any biaxiality and necessarily introduces the direct connection between splay and bend in eq . ( [ biax1 ] ) that is not present in the case of the vectorial conservation law . the quadrupolar order can be described as usually by the @xmath5-tensor and a corresponding landau - de gennes nematic free energy functional @xmath110 , which includes also the part that penalizes density variations . the conservation law is independent of the particular form of this functional , and we will hence not specify it further . the implementation of the full theory of the quadrupolar ordering thus assumes a concrete , non - universal form of this free energy functional and a universal implementation of the conservation law . we first write the tensorial conservation law eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) in terms of the @xmath5-tensor as , @xmath111 = \textstyle{3\over 2 } \partial_i g_i , \label{tensorial_conservation_1}\ ] ] where @xmath112 is the density of chain end tangents pointing away from the end towards the chain . in general , @xmath112 is an additional variable of the system (= 1 vector variable , since chain heads and tails are indistinguishable ) . moreover , at the same time the vectorial conservation law eq . ( [ vectorial_rho_pms ] ) holds for the recovered polar order @xmath13 , @xmath113 where @xmath33 is the total density of sources ( chain ends and backfoldings ) given in eq . ( [ sources_total ] ) . as discussed in sec . [ sec : recovered_polar ] , the recovered polar order @xmath114 is assumed to be parallel to the nematic vector @xmath19 , while its magnitude @xmath115 is connected with the modulus of the quadrupolar nematic order @xmath116 , @xmath117 where @xmath118 depends only on the orientational distribution function of the monomers and is assumed to be fixed . thus , the vectorial conservation eq . ( [ vectorial_conservation_1 ] ) for the recovered polar order is in fact an * additional constraint for the director principal axis * of the @xmath119-tensor . in the case when the density of chain backfoldings @xmath120 of eq . ( [ rho0pm2 ] ) is high ( small global persistence length ) , the free energy cost eq . ( [ f_pms ] ) of the variation @xmath33 is small . in this limit the vectorial constraint eq . ( [ vectorial_conservation_1 ] ) becomes ineffective and we are left with the tensorial conservation eq . ( [ tensorial_conservation_1 ] ) only . if , on the other hand , the density of the backfoldings is low , the additional constraint eq . ( [ vectorial_conservation_1 ] ) is strong and in this way implements the increased stiffness of the chains , which can not be controlled by the tensorial conservation . in general , the source fields @xmath121 , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 are additional variables of the apolar polymer nematic system besides the @xmath17-tensor and the polymer density @xmath124 , for which one should write down additional couplings in the free energy functional . in a first approach , they can be however treated in a minimal spirit as a result of non - uniform distributions of the ideal gasses of chain ends and backfoldings with equilibrium densities @xmath125 and @xmath120 , respectively . in this model , the free energy cost of the sources is purely entropic and is expressed in a form of eq . ( [ f_pms ] ) or alike . a similar free energy contribution can be set up also for @xmath126 . within this simple model of the sources , the source densities do not appear explicitly as additional variables , since their quadratic free energy contributions can be expressed directly via the conservation laws eqs . ( [ tensorial_conservation_1 ] ) and ( [ vectorial_conservation_1 ] ) which now take the form of penalty potentials , @xmath127 ^ 2 + { \textstyle{1\over 2 } } h \left\{\partial_i\partial_j\left[\rho\ell_0(q_{ij}+{\textstyle{1\over 2}}\delta_{ij})\right]\right\}^2 . \label{f_full}\ ] ] in this case the only additional parameters of the system are the equilibrium densities of chain ends @xmath125 and chain backfoldings @xmath120 , which define the strengths @xmath32 and @xmath128 of the penalty potentials . finally , the system of equations is closed with two additional conditions and corresponding lagrange - multiplier terms to be added to eq . ( [ f_full ] ) , keeping @xmath13 parallel to the director principal axis of @xmath5 and its magnitude @xmath129 connected with the nematic modulus @xmath98 according to eq . ( [ moduli ] ) . such conditions can be cumbersome if expressed analytically ( in particular the former ) , but can be treated quite naturally in numerical approaches . the vectorial and tensorial conservation laws for main - chain polymer nematogens are not in general equivalent nor are they interchangeable . in fact , using the vectorial conservation law for the usual quadrupolar nematic order as described in section [ sec : recovered_polar ] is incomplete and generally inaccurate , except in the limit of perfect orientational ordering . there exist in general two major reasons why the tensorial conservation law must be taken into account in addition to the vectorial conservation law for the recovered polar order : 1 . in the strong backfolding limit , the vectorial constraint for the recovered polar order vanishes as we have seen , thereby completely decoupling density variations and director deformations . due to the tensorial conservation law , however , another , although looser ( second order in the gradient ) constraint remains also in the strong backfolding limit ( vanishing global persistence length ) of ideally flexible chains . quadrupolar nematic order is described by the nematic @xmath5-tensor , i.e. , it is captured by averaging a tensorial quantity , not a vectorial one as in the case of the recovered polar order . the tensorial description comprises more degrees of freedom , which is reflected among others also in the fact that the sources of the tensorial conservation law ( the right - hand side of eq . ( [ tensorial ] ) ) besides the volume density of chain ends comprise also the direction of their tangents . as we have shown , only in the limit of perfect orientational order ( where the chains are perfectly aligned , all backfoldings are hairpins and there is no other directions involved ) both conservation laws are equivalent . we propose that the generalized conservation law for semiflexible main - chain polymer nematics with usual quadrupolar ( tensorial ) nematic ordering should build on both , the vectorial as well as the tensorial conservation laws , implemented in the effective free energy via the penalty potentials . if the ordered phase is also polar , then the vectorial conservation law directly holds for its polar order . if , however , the quadrupolar order of this polar phase is included in the modeling ( e.g. if a measurement probes the quadrupolar order of the polar phase rather than its polar order ) , the generalized conservation law for the quadrupolar order applies to it in principle , notwithstanding the concurrent existence of the polar order . since in this case the backfolding is weak , there is little difference whether the actual or the recovered polar order enters the generalized conservation law for the quadrupolar order , but in principle it _ should be _ the recovered polar order . the present analysis of the two continuity constraints , identifying the extent of polymer chain backfolding as the determinant of their relative importance , also suggests a possible method to detect and/or manipulate their strength . namely , in the case of dna , where sharp local kinks can be induced by the addition of certain dna binding proteins , an interesting new way to actually observe and control the role of the tensorial continuity constraint might be accessible by following the ordering of the chains in the solution and/or by monitoring the observable defects on adsorption of dna kinking proteins . this path is feasible and worth pursuing on the level of simulations as well as experiments . p. g. de gennes , mol . lett * 34 * , 177 ( 1977 ) . r. b. meyer , physica a * 176 * , 63 ( 1991 ) . j. v. selinger , r. f. bruinsma , phys . a * 43 * , 2910 ( 1991 ) . le doussal , d. r. nelson , europhys . lett . * 15 * , 161 ( 1991 ) . d. r. nelson , physica a * 177 * , 220 ( 1991 ) . j. v. selinger , r. f. bruinsma , j. phys . ii france * 2 * , 1215 ( 1992 ) . d. svenek , g. m. grason , r. podgornik , phys . e * 88 * , 052603 ( 2013 ) . d. svenek , g. veble , r. podgornik , phys . e * 82 * , 011708 ( 2010 ) . a factor of 3/2 is missing in ref . @xcite on the right - hand sides of eqs . ( 18 ) , ( 20 ) , ( 22 ) , ( 24 ) , ( 25 ) , ( 26 ) , and ( 27 ) . trinh x. hoang , hoa lan trinh , a. giacometti , r.podgornik , j. r. banavar , and a. maritan , phys . e * 92 * , 060701(r ) ( 2015 ) . d. svenek , r. podgornik , j. chem . 143 * , 114902 ( 2015 ) .

we explore the implications of the conservation law(s ) and the corresponding continuity equation(s ) " , resulting from the coupling between the positional and the orientational order in main - chain polymer nematics , by showing that the vectorial and tensorial forms of these equations are in general _ not equivalent _ and can not be reduced to one another , but neither are they disjoint alternatives . we analyze the relation between them and elucidate the fundamental role that the chain backfolding plays in the determination of their relative strength and importance . finally , we show that the correct penalty potential in the effective free energy , implementing these conservation laws , should actually connect both the tensorial and the vectorial constraints . we show that the consequences of the polymer chains connectivity for their consistent mesoscopic description are thus not only highly non - trivial but that its proper implementation is absolutely crucial for a consistent coarse grained description of the main - chain polymer nematics .

0706.1905

the dynamics of proteins involves high frequency vibrational modes that behave quantum mechanically even at room temperature ( @xmath0 k corresponds to @xmath1 @xmath2 ) . one such class of vibrations is the amide i mode , centered around 1650 @xmath2 and prominent in ir experiments due to its large oscillator strength . the amide i modes have been intensively studied by 2d - ir spectroscopy , which has provided new insights into their anharmonic couplings to the other vibrational modes and their intrinsic mode anharmonicities @xcite . theoretical studies have also been stimulated to characterize the details of the vibrational states @xcite , and to probe the origin of the inhomogeneous lineshape broadening of the amide i mode @xcite . in this study , we focus on the vibrational energy relaxation ( ver ) process of the amide i mode . recent pump - probe experiments @xcite have found that the ver of the amide i mode occurs on a a sub - picosecond timescale after its excitation . nguyen and stock @xcite have studied this phenomenon using molecular dynamics and instantaneous normal mode analysis . their results were found to be in qualitative agreement with the experimental results . nevertheless a more precise quantum mechanical description of the ver process is desirable . two of the authors @xcite have recently proposed a time - dependent perturbation theory to describe ver , and applied the formula to a small peptide - like molecule , n - methylacetamide ( nma ) , in heavy water using an empirical force field . they also observed ver on a time scale ( @xmath3 ps ) similar to that obtained experimentally , and further proposed a mechanism for the ver process . the present study explores the ver processes of nma _ more accurately _ by directly solving the schrdinger equation for molecular vibrations on _ ab initio _ potential energy surface ( pes ) . the nma molecule _ in vacuum _ is examined , excluding water molecules included in the previous studies @xcite . quantum dynamics calculations are carried out by the vibrational configuration - interaction ( vci ) method @xcite . 24 vibrational modes ( out of 30 ) are explicitly treated in the dynamics , excluding the 6 lowest - lying modes including the rotational motions of the two methyl groups . we note that while the multiconfiguration time - dependent hartree ( mctdh ) method @xcite provides a more flexible framework the vci method is sufficient for the present aim to investigate the vibrational motion of a semi - rigid molecule . the pes is approximated using a fourth - order taylor series expansion around the equilibrium geometry , which is called quartic force field ( qff ) , as @xmath4 where @xmath5 and @xmath6 denote the @xmath7th normal coordinate and the associated harmonic frequency . the coefficients , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , are the third- and fourth - order derivatives of the pes . the above qff can be recast in the form of the @xmath10-mode coupling representation ( @xmath10mr ) @xcite as @xmath11 it is known that 3mr - qff is enough to characterize the anharmonicity of molecules studied @xcite , we thus have neglected the fourth - order terms including @xmath9 with @xmath12 . in addition to the above 3mr - qff , we study two types of approximate qff : ( 1 ) 2mr - qff that neglects @xmath13 @xcite and ( 2 ) partial - qff that takes into account only the terms associated with the amide i mode , that is , @xmath14 and @xmath15 if the subscripts do not include the amide i mode . note that the previous perturbation calculation @xcite also employed partial - qff to calculate the reduced density matrix . by adding the normal mode kinetic energy @xmath16 , we have the full approximate vibrational hamiltonian @xmath17 for the system . the vibrational self - consistent field ( vscf ) calculation is first carried out for the vibrational ground state to obtain the basis functions for the vci calculations . the vscf wavefunction is expressed as a direct product of one - mode functions or _ modals _ as @xmath18 where * n * and @xmath19 denote the vibrational quantum numbers and the degrees of freedom , respectively . the modals are determined by @xmath20 \phi_{n_i}^{(i ) } = \epsilon_{n_i}^{(i ) } \phi_{n_i}^{(i)}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] this vscf equation is solved for the vibrational ground state ( * n=0 * ) , and the @xmath21 modals constitute the vscf configurations to be used in the vci calculations . the vci wavefunction is expressed as a linear combination of vscf configurations as @xmath22 the vci wavefunction and energy levels are obtained by diagonalization of the vci matrix @xmath23 in this study , the modals were expanded in terms of the harmonic oscillator ( ho ) wavefunction . the number of ho wavefunctions employed were 11 , 9 , 7 , and 5 for \{@xmath24 } , \{@xmath25- @xmath26 } , \{@xmath27-@xmath28 } , and \{@xmath29-@xmath30 } , respectively . the mode index is labeled in the increasing order of the frequency . see table [ tab : freq2 ] . the 6 lowest - lying modes were kept frozen . the vscf configurations were constructed by allowing the excitation up to 10 quantum numbers , and selected in the increasing order of the energy until the upper limit of the vci space , denoted @xmath31 , was achieved . the vscf / vci calculations were carried out using the sindo code @xcite for non - rotating molecules . . calculated harmonic ( h.o ) and anharmonic ( vci and pt2 ) frequencies of nma based on the b3lyp/6 - 31g+(d ) level of theory . the previous cc - vscf and vci results and the experimental results are also listed for comparison . units in @xmath2 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : pathway ] ) , ( b ) 9th ( 869 @xmath2 ) , and ( c ) 12th ( 1066 @xmath2 ) mode . ] table [ tab : pathway ] also shows that the dominant ver pathways are well characterized by the above parameters for the @xmath32 excitation . figure [ fig : frp ] shows that other minor pathways take on values of @xmath33 that are smaller than @xmath34 0.01 and that the frequency matching condition is important to predict the fermi resonance parameter . it is interesting to note that the dominant pathways ( fig . [ fig : resmode ] ) are similar to those suggested in @xcite . in the case of @xmath35 excitation ( fig . [ fig : label ] , right ) , it is difficult to assign such a parameter because the relaxation processes can accompany higher order processes , but the dominant pathways such as @xmath36 and @xmath37 are the frequency matching ones . we conclude that the fermi resonance parameter or frequency matching condition is very important to characterize the ver pathways , and its consequence is discussed below . . middle : the 3rd order coupling strength @xmath38 as a function of the mode index @xmath39 . bottom : the inverse of the frequency mismatch @xmath40 as a function of the mode index @xmath39 . ] from these observations , we conclude that a relatively small number of resonant bath modes plays an essential role in the quantum dynamics . simplification of the pes or a reduction in the number of modes , including the resonant bath modes , can result in an inaccurate estimate of the dynamics . this is illustrated in fig . [ fig : b3lypdynashort ] : the 3mr - qff and partial - qff results agree rather well up to 0.2 ( 0.5 ) ps for @xmath32 ( @xmath35 ) , while 2mr - qff results deviate from the other two at the initial stage . this is because the 2mr representation misses resonances mediated through the three mode interactions . it is interesting that the vibrational frequencies can be calculated accurately using 2mr - qff ; the fundamental ( first overtone ) of the amide i mode is obtained as 1713 ( 3414 ) , and 1716 ( 3421 ) @xmath2 by the 2mr- and 3mr - qff , respectively ( the difference is 0.2 % ) . however , the ver processes sensitively depend on the 3mr terms . ( left ) and @xmath35 ( right ) of the amide i mode , on 3mr - qff , 2mr - qff , and partial - qff , derived from b3lyp/6 - 31g+(d ) method . @xmath31 is set to 6000 . ] we showed that our pes is accurate enough ( sec . [ sec : accuracy ] ) , which is in accord with experiment @xcite and comparable to other theoretical methods @xcite . however , we note that the ver dynamics are much more sensitive to accuracy than the anharmonic frequency calculations . for example , gerber s group did not report any strong resonant interaction between the amide i mode and other modes using mp2/dzp level of theory @xcite . this is likely due to the level of theory for the pes ( mp2/dzp ) , but another possibility is due to the 2mr - pes in their calculations . as we showed above , 3mr - pes and 2mr - pes can provide similar anharmonic frequencies , but some resonance conditions should be missed in the latter , affecting the dynamics calculations . importantly , 2d - ir spectroscopy can directly detect anharmonic coupling in a molecule @xcite , and such data may be utilized to select an _ appropriate _ level of methods for a particular molecule . using the vci method , we investigated the quantum dynamics of deuterated n - methylacetamide in vacuum . we demonstrated the applicability of the method and were able to gain insight into the fundamental nature of ver in the molecule , relevant to the interpretation of ir and 2d - ir spectroscopy used as a probe of protein dynamics . the accuracy of the pes employed ( b3lyp/6 - 31+g(d ) ) was checked by the anharmonic frequency calculations and by comparing with experiment and other theoretical methods . we clarified the energy flow pathways from the @xmath32 and 2 excitations of the amide i mode , and interpreted our results using fermi resonance parameters , which represent the effective coupling strength betweem vibrational modes . this approach will be extended to condensed phase systems by invoking qm / mm methods @xcite or multiresolution methods @xcite to deal with dephasing problems and to simulate 2d - ir signals @xcite . we are grateful to e. geva , g. stock , d.m . leitner , j.m . bowman , and y. zhang for useful discussions . we also thank the national science foundation ( che-0316551 ) and boston university s center for computer science for generous support to our research . jes is grateful to montana state university for generous support and hospitality . m. gruebele , p.g . wolynes , acc . 37 ( 2004 ) 261 . m. cremeens , h. fujisaki , y. zhang , j. zimmermann , l.b . sagle , s. matsuda , p.e . dawson , j.e . straub , f.e.romesberg , j. am . 128 ( 2006 ) 6028 .

vibrational energy transfer of the amide i mode of n - methylacetamide ( nma ) is studied theoretically using the vibrational configuration interaction method . a quartic force field of nma is constructed at the b3lyp/6 - 31g+(d ) level of theory and its accuarcy is checked by comparing the resulting anharmonic frequencies with available theoretical and experimental values . quantum dynamics calculations for the amide i mode excitation clarify the dominant energy transfer pathways , which sensitively depend on the anharmonic couplings among vibrational modes . a ratio of the anharmonic coupling to the frequency mismatch is employed to predict and interpret the dominant energy flow pathways . , , , and vibrational configuration interaction ( vci ) method , vibrational energy relaxation ( ver ) , n - methylacetamide ( nma ) , quartic force field ( qff )

1504.03901

in recent years there has been a renewed interest@xcite in the problem of anderson localization on the cayley tree ( ct ) ( in the infinite limit known as a bethe lattice ) . this interest is mainly motivated by the connection between the many body localization phenomenon @xcite and the ct . many body localization may be viewed as a localization problem in fock space , where the coupling between states due to electron - electron interactions resembles the ct@xcite . in the context of the anderson localization on the ct@xcite , one can envisage that the entanglement entropy ( ee ) will play an important role in clarifying the ct localization properties . in this ee could join other methods such as level spacing statistics for the ct systems @xcite , and for many - body interacting systems believed to map on an effective ct in fock space @xcite . prior to addressing the challenging question of the ee on a disordered one must clarify the behavior of the ee for a clean ct . this is our main goal in this paper . the ee is a measure of the entanglement between two regions , a and b , of a system which is in some pure state . this measure is given by the von - neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix , @xmath0 , of region a : @xmath1 it has been shown that the ee is a very useful measure to locate and analyze quantum phase transitions @xcite . the ground state ee typically scales like the _ boundary area _ of the region @xcite . thus , for one dimensional systems , one would expect that the ee will be constant . this is correct for gaped systems , but for metallic systems there is a logarithmic correction , and ee grows like @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the size of the sub - system @xmath4 . for insulators the ee should not depend on the region s size . therefore for disordered systems the ee can give an indication for the localization length @xmath5 ; we expect the ee to grow logarithmically for @xmath6 , and to saturate for @xmath7@xcite . applying this picture to the ct is not straight forward . unlike the situation for regular @xmath8 dimensional systems , where for any regular simply connected area , the boundary area is proportional to @xmath9 , for the ct things are more complicated . one expects that a region which is connected to the rest of the graph only at one point ( a branch of the tree ) , will show a different ee than a region centered at the root of the tree where the boundary area grows as @xmath10 ( where @xmath11 is related to the coordination number of the tree ) . in this paper we aim to calculate the ee for a clean ct as a stepping stone towards investigating the ee in a disordered ct . we shall pay special attention to the different behavior for different regions and the physical meaning of these results . a ct is @xcite a simple connected undirected graph , with no closed loops . a ct of coordination number @xmath12 and @xmath13 generations is described as follows . there is a root vertex , which we denote @xmath14 . the root is linked to @xmath12 vertexes belonging to the @xmath15 generation , which we denote @xmath16 . each of those is linked to another @xmath17 vertexes on the @xmath18 generation , so that @xmath19 is related to @xmath20 , and so on . every vertex is linked to @xmath12 others , except those belonging to the last generation , which are linked to only one vertex each . unlike the _ bethe lattice _ , ct is finite , it s boundary being a non - negligible part of the entire tree : the total number of vertexes in the tree is @xmath21 , while the last generation contains @xmath22 vertexes . therefore , even for @xmath23 the boundary is important , as is well known in the context of localization on ct @xcite . and @xmath24 generations , title="fig:",width=151 ] + another noteworthy property of the ct is it s lack of dimension - since the number of vertexes grows exponentially with @xmath13 , we can not define the dimension of this system . on the other hand , any two vertexes are connected by a single path , what gives the ct a one - dimensional character . both of these features are reflected in the scaling of the ee we obtained . first we solve the tight - binding hamiltonian for a clean ct . the hamiltonian can be written , using the notation introduced previously , in the form @xmath25 where @xmath26 is an annihilation ( creation ) operator on vertex @xmath27 , and @xmath28 is the index of the first vertex of the @xmath29 s generation . it will be convenient to define a new basis , using the operators @xmath30 , defined as follows . we find an orthonormal basis in the @xmath15 generation , @xmath31 , and for each such operator we define it s successors in the following generations @xmath32 as a reflection of @xmath33 in the @xmath34 s generation . for example , if @xmath35 , then @xmath36 _ etc_. similarly we find a basis in every generation , composed of operators other than the successors of the previous generations , and define its successors in the next generations . we denote each such operator by @xmath37 , where @xmath34 is the generation in which this operator acts , @xmath38 is the generation in which it s first fore - father acts , and @xmath39 is it s fore - father s index inside the @xmath38 s generation . among these operators there is one important group that originates from the root , which we shall denote @xmath40 or @xmath41 , @xmath42 . they are symmetric in the sense that they treat each generation as one unit , @xmath43 @xmath44 using this representation , the hamiltonian becomes @xmath45\end{gathered}\ ] ] where the symmetric term @xmath46 thus all terms , except for @xmath47 , are a sum of independent one - dimensional lattices . one should note the exponentially increasing number of such lattices . the solution is given by the transformation @xmath48\hat b_j^{\gamma,\nu}\ ] ] so that @xmath49 and the spectrum is @xmath50 for the symmetric term ( [ h_sym ] ) a similar solution was obtained by chen _ _ et al.__@xcite , including the boundary condition for finite @xmath13 . in order to calculate the ee we use the relation @xcite @xmath51 where @xmath52 are the eigenvalues of the correlation matrix _ in region a_. for a one - particle state , the correlation can be written in the form @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is the eigenstate in region a. thus one eigenvector is @xmath54 , with corresponding eigenvalue @xmath55 . since @xmath56 is hermitian , any other eigenvector is orthogonal to @xmath54 , and its corresponding eigenvalue therefore vanishes , so that the ee is simply @xmath57 . we have calculated the ee for several representative one - particle states in a ct of @xmath58 . a typical state is : @xmath59\cdot\\ \cdot\left[\sum_{i = p_j}^{p_j+2^{j-2}-1}\hat c_i^{\dagger}- \sum_{l = p_j+2^{j-2}}^{p_j+2^{j-1}-1}\hat c_l^{\dagger}\right]\ket{\emptyset } \end{gathered}\ ] ] which resides on two of the branches . for this state , we let one branch be region a ( see fig . [ ct_as_1_branch ] ) , and obtain @xmath60 , and @xmath61 , regardless of the number of generations . , when we take one branch ( solid line ) or a part of it ( dashed ) to be the subsystem . ( color online),title="fig:",width=188 ] + another possible partition is to define region a as a part of one branch ( see in fig . [ ct_as_1_branch ] ) . the eigenvalue @xmath62 for this partition where region a is defined as the last @xmath63 generations of one branch is @xmath64}{\sin\left(\frac{\pi}{n}\right)}\right),\ ] ] which , in the appropriate limit , is proportional to the relative number of generations in region a. for the more challenging case of a many - particle state , the correlation matrix becomes more complicated , so we diagonalize it numerically . the many particle state can be written as @xmath65 where @xmath66 are the indicies of the occupied single particle states , leading to a correlation matrix @xmath67 let us first consider the ground state ee of a single branch of the ct ( see in fig . [ branchingpic ] ) for the half - filled case . since a branch is connected to the rest of the system only at one point , one would expect from the area law that the ee will be constant . nevertheless , since the ct has no gap , which is similar to the situation in metallic 1d system , a logarithmic correction is expected . indeed , we find a logarithmic dependence for the ct , but unlike the 1d system it does not depend on the size of the system , but rather on the number of generations @xmath13 in the ct ( or , equivalently , on the number of generations @xmath63 in the subsystem , where in this case @xmath68 ) . specifically , for @xmath58 , @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is a decaying alternating term typical to systems with open boundary conditions@xcite ( fig . [ ee_1_branch ] ) . the pre - factor @xmath71 of the logarithmic term is reminiscence of the behavior of an open boundary 1d system , where if one bisects a system of length @xmath72 in the middle the ee grows as @xmath73 @xcite . the fact that for the ee on a ct the number of generations @xmath13 plays the same role as the length @xmath72 for a 1d system stems from the structure of the eigenstates of the ct demonstrated in sec . [ ct_eigenstates ] . it is interesting to point out that for the ct the ratio of the sites on a branch to the overall number of sites is nearly constant ( @xmath74 ) for any generation @xmath13 larger than @xmath75 , again similar to the situation for the bisected 1d system . as function of @xmath63 the number of generations in the subsystem . h ere @xmath68 . the black squares represent an even number of generations and the red circles represent odd @xmath63 s , separated in order to emphasize the alternating term . the red lines correspond to @xmath76 for even @xmath63 s and @xmath77 for odd @xmath63 s . the blue line in between is @xmath78 , which corresponds to the asymptotic behavior of the ee . , title="fig:",width=264 ] + on the other hand , for an excited state we find an exponential growth of the ee ( fig . [ ee_1branch_excited ] ) , reflecting the growth in the number of sites per generation . this is expected since for an excited state the ee should obey a volume law . nevertheless , this is in stark difference to the one dimensional case for which excited states ee grows linearly . thus , for the ee of a branch of the ct there is a huge change between the ground state ee and the excited state ee not seen in more standard models . this may lead to a huge influence of localization on low - lying excitations @xcite . for a highly excited state represented by the black squares . the ee grows as @xmath79 ( red line ) since for an excited state the ee is proportional to the volume.,title="fig:",width=264 ] + a similar form of dissection is to define a site residing @xmath63 generations away from the boundary and all the sites connecting it to the boundary as region a , so that a is connected to the rest of the tree only at one point ( see in fig . [ branchingpic ] ) , just like in the previous case . as expected , we get the logarithmic dependence for this case also ( fig . [ branching ] ) . generations around the root to be region a ( solid circles ) or taking a branch ( big dashed circle ) or a sub - branch ( small dashed circle).,title="fig:",width=188 ] + generations , where the total number of generations in the tree is @xmath80 . the black squares represent even @xmath63 s , with the red line corresponding to @xmath81 , and the red circles are for odd @xmath63 s , with the line corresponding to @xmath82.,title="fig:",width=264 ] + a different obvious way to cut the ct into two different regions is to define the root and the sites belonging to the first @xmath63 generations as region a , and the rest of the sites belonging to the higher generations as region @xmath83 ( fig . [ branchingpic ] ) . in this case the area of contact between the two regions is proportional to @xmath84 for @xmath85 , and therefore according to the area law we expect the ground state ee to be exponentially dependent on @xmath63 . indeed , in this case the ee behaves as @xmath86 ( see fig . [ ee_generation ] ) . since for such a dissection the volume ( number of sites ) within region a is equal to @xmath87 , i.e. , grows exponentially with @xmath63 . also for a highly excited state we find the ee to follow @xmath88 , as expected . thus , for this form of dissection there is no qualitative difference between the ee of the ground state and the behavior of an excited state as function of @xmath63 . generations around the root ( including the root itself ) and the rest of the ct with @xmath58 for the ground state ( black squares ) and for a highly excited state ( red circles ) . in both cases the ee grows exponentially ( the lines , corresponding to @xmath89 and @xmath90 , respectively ) , since there is no qualitative difference in the growth as function of @xmath63 between the interface area and the volume.,title="fig:",width=264 ] + in this paper we calculated the ee for the ground state and excited states of a clean ct . utilizing an exact expression for the single - particle eigenfunctions of the ct developed in this paper in order to to obtain a correlation matrix from which the ee of a many - particle state can be calculated , it has been demonstrated that the ee may show dramatic differences depending on the way the ct is partitioned into two regions . if the ct is dissected into a branch connected in a single point to the ct , a logarithmic dependence on the number of generations in the branch is found , which reflects the one dimensional character of the states of the ct . on the other hand , excited states on the branch show a completely different ee behavior , namely an exponential dependence on the number of generations in the branch . this logarithmic to exponential change in the entanglement between the ground state and the excited state is unique to the entanglement on the ct . on the other hand , the ground state ee shows a completely different behavior for a different sort of partition - where the root and the first @xmath63 generations are considered as one region . in this case an exponential dependence on @xmath63 is found , which reflects the growth in the number of sites on the surface . in contrast to dissecting by branch , here the excited states ee ( which remains the volume law ) does not show a dramatic difference when compared to the ground state ee . thus , how one defines the separation into two regions has a crucial influence on the behavior of the ee . these large fluctuations in the ee could become even stronger for other types of complex ( random ) networks , such as small world graphs , erds - rnyi graphs and scale free networks @xcite . these behaviors predict a strong influence of disorder on the ee of a ct . it has been shown @xcite that the localization length in 1d may be inferred from the saturation of the ee on the length scale of the localization length . for the ct one expects that for a region around the root and the first @xmath63 generations where the increase in the ee is exponential this tool will be more sensitive than for the 1d system where the growth is logarithmic . it will be also very interesting to compare the effect of the localization on the ee of a branch . will it be similar to the 1d case ? another question is whether the non ergodic phase predicted for the ct @xcite may be detected in the behavior of the ee .

the properties of the entanglement entropy ( ee ) of a clean cayley tree ( ct ) are studied . the ee shows a completely different behaviour depending on the way the ct is partitioned into two regions and whether we consider the ground - state or highly excited many - particle wave function . the ground - state ee increases logarithmically as function of number of generation if a single branch is pruned off the tree , while it grows exponentially if the region around the root is trimmed . on the other hand , in both cases the highly excited states ee grows exponentially . implications of these results to general graphs and disordered systems are shortly discussed .

1605.08826

fault - tolerant quantum computing requires that the fidelities of elementary quantum logic gates exceed certain thresholds @xcite . these fidelity thresholds depend on the architecture . however , even for the most forgiving cases the threshold is high ; therefore , reaching and exceeding it is an extraordinarily difficult task . the implementation of high - fidelity quantum operations is also relevant , although to a lesser extent , in other quantum technologies , including quantum communication and sensing . qualitatively speaking , the fidelity of a gate depends on the ratio between the quantum coherence time and the gate time , implying two approaches to increase gate fidelities : increasing coherence times and reducing gate times . in most qubit architectures , single - qubit gates are implemented by applying an oscillating field that is resonant with the qubit transition frequency . most of the experiments and theoretical studies on such gates were performed with a driving strength that is significantly smaller than the qubit transition frequency . in this weak - driving regime , the qubit undergoes rabi oscillations between the two energy eigenstates at a rate that is proportional to the driving strength . this situation is described rather accurately using the rotating wave approximation @xcite ( rwa ) , which predicts sinusoidal oscillations between the energy eigenstates . with strong driving , the rwa breaks down and the dynamics becomes very complex . despite the increased complexity in controlling dynamics , the strong driving regime is interesting because it brings the opportunity to implement advanced quantum control @xcite and achieve faster quantum operations than in the weak driving regime . a two - level quantum system ( or a qubit ) driven by strong resonant pulses has been studied experimentally using nv centers in diamond @xcite , semiconductor quantum dots @xcite and superconducting circuits @xcite . in a few experiments @xcite , the qubit population exhibits complex dynamics containing a few frequency components , as the driving strength approaches or exceeds the qubit transition frequency , a signature of the breakdown of the rwa . therefore , for the proper design of quantum gates in this regime , different theoretical methods are required . floquet theory @xcite , which provides a general framework for treating periodically driven quantum systems with any driving strength , is the natural method for analyzing strong - driving dynamics . in ref . , the quasienergies and quasienergy states ( hereafter referred to as floquet states ) , as predicted by floquet theory , were observed in a strongly driven superconducting qubit . moreover , the observed dynamics pointed to the important role that the pulse shape plays in the qubit evolution , as determined by adiabaticity conditions in the floquet picture . in this paper , we perform a comprehensive theoretical analysis of qubit dynamics under strong resonant pulses using floquet theory . we derive approximate analytical expressions for the quasienergies and floquet states as functions of the driving amplitude for the practically important case where the qubit is biased at its symmetry point . we then analyze the qubit dynamics induced by a driving pulse , obtained by modulating the amplitude of a periodic signal . the quantum state of the qubit is naturally expressed as a superposition of floquet states . the occupation probabilities of the floquet states remain fixed as long as the driving strength is fixed , but they can change when the pulse envelope varies in time . we analyze the qubit dynamics using a representation of its state in the floquet picture @xcite . when the change in the driving strength is slow , the occupation probabilities of the floquet states remain almost constant , although the floquet states themselves change in accordance with the instantaneous driving strength . the quantum superposition of the floquet states acquires a phase that depends on the evolution of the quasienergies over time . this acquired phase corresponds to a qubit state rotation , generalizing the notion of rabi oscillations to the case of large driving amplitudes . however , a pulse with slowly varying amplitude corresponds to relatively slow quantum gates . we therefore analyze the dynamics with short pulses , when in general nonadiabatic transitions between floquet states can not be neglected . we find that with suitable pulse parameters the nonadiabatic transitions can be largely suppressed . this effect provides the basis of floquet interference efficient suppression of transitions in the adiabatic basis ( fiesta ) , a method to optimize quantum gates with strong driving . finally , we show that fiesta can be used to implement high - fidelity single - qubit operations in very short times , significantly alleviating the effect of decoherence . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : in sec . [ sec : floquet ] , we derive expressions for the quasienergies and floquet states of a qubit biased at the symmetry point under harmonic driving with arbitrary strength . in sec . [ sec : adiabatic_theory ] , we describe the adiabatic theory in the floquet picture and derive the adiabatic condition . in sec . [ sec : adiabatic ] , we use the adiabatic theory in the floquet picture to describe the quantum state evolution effected by pulses with slowly varying amplitude . in sec . [ sec : nonadiabatic ] , we present a quantitative analysis of the nonadiabatic transitions between the floquet states when the amplitude of the pulse changes rapidly . in sec . [ sec : gates ] , we calculate the fidelities of single - qubit gates optimized so as to suppress nonadiabatic transitions . in sec . [ sec : oqc ] , we discuss the connections between fiesta and other optimal quantum control methods . section [ sec : conclusion ] contains concluding remarks . in this section we discuss the quasienergies and floquet states of a qubit driven with a single - frequency tone . some of the results in this section have been presented in our previous paper @xcite and are included here for completeness . we start with a general model in which a qubit is driven by a harmonic field . the hamiltonian is given by @xmath0 with @xmath1 ( @xmath2 ) the pauli matrices . the ground ( @xmath3 ) and excited ( @xmath4 ) states are ordered such that @xmath5 and @xmath6 . the hamiltonian in eq . ( [ eq : hamstart ] ) is written under the standard convention where in the absence of driving the energy eigenstates are the ground and excited states @xmath3 and @xmath4 . in a frame rotating about the @xmath7 axis with frequency @xmath8 , the hamiltonian is : [ eq : hamrf ] h _ = & -_z + & + a ( t + ) ((t)_x + ( t)_y ) ) . in the weak driving limit ( @xmath9 ) , the terms in eq . oscillating at frequencies @xmath10 can be ignored under rwa . with this approximation the hamiltonian is given by [ eq : hrwa ] h _ = -_z + ( _ x + _ y ) . this is a well - known time - independent hamiltonian representing a spin-1/2 particle precessing in a magnetic field . in this paper , we will analyze the dynamics under the more general hamiltonian , eq . , for large driving amplitude . we will refer to eq . while connecting the general driven dynamics to the special cases in the well - known weak driving regime . for simplicity , we will treat eq . under @xmath11 in the remainder of this section . our derivation can be easily generalized to arbitrary @xmath12 . another alternative form of eq . , which is related to it by a @xmath13 rotation about the @xmath14 axis , is @xmath15 this form is convenient for our analytical derivations for the quasienergies and floquet states ( in which we will closely follow ref . ) , and we shall therefore use this form of the hamiltonian in the remainder of this section . according to floquet theory , for a periodic hamiltonian there exist solutions to the schrdinger equation of the form @xmath16 where @xmath17 are the quasienergies and @xmath18 , to which we shall refer as floquet modes , are periodic with the periodicity of the hamiltonian . because of the periodicity , we can write @xmath19 with @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the period of the hamiltonian , and the state fourier components @xmath22 are vectors in the hilbert space of the system . each fourier coefficient @xmath22 contains two complex numbers corresponding to the states @xmath3 and @xmath4 : @xmath23 . the index @xmath24 in eq . ( [ eq : generalfloquet ] ) takes a number of values equal to the dimension of the hilbert space . importantly , the floquet states form a complete basis , such that any quantum state can be expressed as a superposition of floquet states . with a fixed driving strength , the solution of the schrdinger equation is a superposition of floquet states with fixed coefficients . substituting eqs . and in the time - dependent schrdinger equation for a qubit with the hamiltonian given by eq . ( [ eq : hamrotated ] ) , we find the relation _ j |u_j , n = ( - _ x + n ) |u_j , n - _ z ( |u_j , n-1 + |u_j , n+1 ) . the above set of equations can be expressed as a single equation : @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the vector @xmath27 , and @xmath28 we now perform a basis transformation where the basis states after the transformation are related to those before the transformation by the formula @xmath29 in other words , when expressed in the original , time - domain representation , |_j , n,0 & = _ m=-^ e^imt j_m - n ( ) |0 , + by the fact that it diagonalizes the hamiltonian @xmath30 when @xmath31 . when considering strong driving , one can use the point @xmath31 as a starting point and treat @xmath32 as a small parameter . the hamiltonian in the new basis reads @xmath33 a sufficiently large truncated version of the matrix @xmath30 yields eigenvectors and eigenvalues that converge well . a size of @xmath34 for example is easily sufficient for reliable numerical calculations . as explained in ref . , truncating this hamiltonian to a @xmath35 matrix gives good results in the strong - driving limit , but it fails in the weak driving limit . as also explained in ref . , a truncation that allows an analytical solution while giving a good approximation for the quasienergies for both weak and strong driving is obtained by using the hamiltonian @xmath36 inspired by the symmetry in the above matrix , which is most easily seen in the limiting case @xmath37 , we now perform a basis transformation @xmath38 , with @xmath39 we obtain @xmath40 this matrix can be split into two @xmath35 decoupled blocks . the outer block gives quasienergies that are close to ( or even degenerate with ) quasienergies that were ignored when we truncated the infinite - dimensional matrix @xmath30 to a @xmath41 matrix . we can therefore expect that the quasienergies obtained from the outer block will not be accurate , and indeed they are not . we therefore focus on the inner block : @xmath42 the eigenvalues of this matrix ( i.e. the quasienergies ) are given by : _ 0 & = ( - - ) , + _ 1 & = ( - + ) . [ eq : quasienergiesanalytical ] the floquet modes are given by the corresponding eigenvectors of the floquet hamiltonian . in the basis of eq . , these eigenvectors are given by @xmath43 where @xmath44 we now note that we have made two transformations to go from the floquet hamiltonian @xmath30 in eq . ( [ eq : floquethamiltonian ] ) to @xmath45 , and we need to transform the eigenvectors back to the original basis . in the basis of eq . , the floquet modes are given by @xmath46 transforming further to the basis of eq . , we find the expressions c + + ) , + c + + ) . [ eq : periodicpartsoffloquetstatesoriginalbasis ] the rabi frequency is given by the difference between the two quasienergies ( see eq . ): @xmath47 ^ 2 + \delta^2 j_1 ^ 2\left(\frac{2a}{\omega}\right ) } . \label{eq : rabifrequencyanalyticalformula}\ ] ] in the case of exact resonance ( i.e. @xmath48 ) , we obtain the expression @xmath49 ^ 2 + j_1 ^ 2\left(\frac{2a}{\omega}\right ) } . \label{eq : rabifrequencyanalyticalformularesonantcase}\ ] ] this expression reduces to the well - known expressions in the weak- and strong - driving limits : when @xmath50 we obtain @xmath51 , and when @xmath52 we obtain @xmath53 , which upon shifting by @xmath8 gives @xmath54 ( and the minus sign here is physically insignificant because it is the absolute value of this expression that gives the meaningful frequency ) . it is worth noting that ref . has an expression for the rabi frequency that resembles eq . ( [ eq : rabifrequencyanalyticalformularesonantcase ] ) . the approach used there , however , is designed to extend the regime of validity from the weak - coupling limit to somewhat large driving strengths , and it breaks down in the strong - driving limit . in contrast , our results are most accurate in the weak- and strong - driving limits , with some deviation from the exact results at intermediate values of @xmath55 . furthermore , the approach of ref . relies on a numerical evaluation of one of the parameters in the argument of the bessel functions , while our approach is purely analytical . , as well as two additional ( and redundant ) quasienergies , as functions of driving amplitude @xmath55 . the solid lines are obtained from numerically solving the schrdinger equation and is essentially exact . the dashed lines are the approximate analytical expressions given by eq . . ( b ) the fidelity of the analytical expression for the floquet modes given by eq . with respect to the exact floquet states , which are evaluated by a numerical integration of the schrdinger equation , as a function of @xmath55 . away from the first two zeros of @xmath56 , and in particular for both the weak and the strong driving limits , the analytical formulae give good approximations for the quasienergies and the floquet modes . the vertical dotted line in ( b ) marks the point of maximum deviation between the analytical and the exact floquet modes.,width=302 ] in fig . [ fig : comparisonbetweenanalyticalformulaandexactresults ] , we plot the quasienergies obtained from eq . and compare them with those obtained from diagonalizing a @xmath57 truncated version of the hamiltonian in eq . . we also plot the fidelity @xmath58 of the floquet modes obtained from eq . with the exact floquet modes : @xmath59 where we have used the definition @xmath60 the analytical formula for the quasienergies agrees very well with the numerical ( and essentially exact ) results , except for small errors around the locations of the floquet - state degeneracy points . the floquet modes agree reasonably well with the exact results for most values of the driving strength . it should be noted here that a fidelity of 0.93 is not very high when dealing with qubit states : in the time - independent case , this value of the fidelity corresponds to an angle of 30 degrees in the bloch sphere representation . this difference in the quality of the approximation for the quasienergies and floquet modes can be understood by considering ( non - degenerate ) perturbation theory . perturbations that appear as off - diagonal matrix elements in the hamiltonian modify the quantum states at the first order but modify the energies only at the second order . in our case these perturbations are the matrix elements that we ignored when we truncated the floquet hamiltonian to a @xmath61 matrix . for example , taking into consideration the fact that @xmath62 has maxima of magnitude @xmath63 , we can estimate that an off - diagonal perturbation of magnitude @xmath64 coupling a quantum state to another one that is @xmath65 in energy away should give a fidelity between the perturbed and unperturbed states of about @xmath66 where @xmath67 , which agrees with the values plotted in fig . [ fig : comparisonbetweenanalyticalformulaandexactresults ] . as one can see in fig . [ fig : comparisonbetweenanalyticalformulaandexactresults ] , there are points where the quasienergies are degenerate , including the point @xmath37 . any superposition of two floquet states that have the same quasienergy is also a floquet state , meaning that at these degeneracy points there is ambiguity ( and freedom ) in how to define the floquet modes . since in this paper we are interested in the dynamics under the influence of short pulses with a varying amplitude @xmath55 , the natural definition of the floquet modes is obtained by considering the path that the pulse takes in parameter space approaching or moving away from any of the degeneracy points . in particular , for a resonant pulse ( i.e. with @xmath48 ) starting from @xmath37 the floquet states at the initial time should be defined by taking the limit @xmath68 . the degeneracy of floquet states at finite values of @xmath55 is a result of the symmetry @xmath69 in the sinusoidal driving waveform that we consider here @xcite . if we modify the waveform and the symmetry is lifted , the quasienergy crossings will turn into avoided crossings . before concluding this section , we address a rather surprising aspect in our analysis . obtaining the expression for the rabi frequency that is valid in the weak - driving limit was more difficult than obtaining the expression that is valid in the strong - driving limit , although the former limit is generally considered to be the simpler of the two limits . the reason is that we followed a derivation that is well suited for the strong - driving limit and modified it in order to extend its validity to the weak - driving limit . if we were interested in the weak - driving limit only , we could have started the derivation differently and written @xmath30 in eq . in the basis @xmath70 with @xmath71 and @xmath72 : @xmath73 near resonance ( i.e. when @xmath74 with @xmath75 ) one can obtain a good approximation of the quasienergies and floquet modes by truncating @xmath30 to the @xmath76 matrix @xmath77 which gives the well known expression for the rabi frequency @xmath78 . this derivation is indeed simpler than the one that we have followed above . it is not obvious , however , how one could modify this derivation and extend its validity to the strong - driving limit . we start this section by giving a derivation of the schrdinger equation in the floquet basis . before any manipulation , the equation reads @xmath79 inspired by the fact that when @xmath55 is independent of time the probability amplitudes of the floquet states are also time independent , we express the quantum state @xmath80 as a superposition in the instantaneous floquet basis : @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the floquet state with index @xmath24 taken at time @xmath83 and @xmath55 is assumed to implicitly depend on time . differentiating this expression with respect to time , we find an alternative expression for the derivative on the left - hand side of eq . ( [ eq : schroedingerequation ] ) : @xmath84 we now note that the partial derivative in the last term corresponds to the full derivative of the floquet states with respect to time assuming that @xmath55 remains constant in time . with this point in mind , we know that the floquet states are solutions of the schrdinger equation : @xmath85 the last term in eq . ( [ eq : expansionofpsidot ] ) therefore cancels the right - hand side in eq . ( [ eq : schroedingerequation ] ) , and the schrdinger equation in the floquet basis reduces to @xmath86 multiplying this equation on the left by @xmath87 , we find that @xmath88 which can alternatively be expressed as @xmath89 the two terms in the above equation have clear meanings . the first term describes the fact that as @xmath55 changes ( and @xmath90 changes with it ) the coefficients @xmath91 acquire phase shifts in order to correct for the difference between the actually accumulated phase ( from the initial time until time @xmath83 ) and the phase that would have accumulated assuming that the instantaneous quasienergy had been in effect from @xmath92 until time @xmath83 . the second term on the right - hand side of eq . ( [ eq : schroedingerequationinfloquetbasis ] ) describes geometric phase accumulation , as well as nonadiabatic transitions between floquet states . the first term in eq . has the undesirable property that its coefficient contains the factor @xmath83 , which grows without bounds , a feature that looks rather unnatural and could complicate calculations for long pulses . this term can be eliminated by defining the coefficients @xmath93 } c_k(t ) . \label{eq : c2ctilde}\ ] ] in terms of the coefficients @xmath94 , the quantum state in eq . takes the form |(t ) = _ j c_j(t ) a clear analogy with quantum state evolution in standard adiabatic theory : the floquet modes @xmath95 are the eigenstates of the instantaneous floquet hamiltonian , the dynamical phases @xmath96 are the time integrals of the quasienergies , and the evolution of the coefficients @xmath94 incorporates geometric phases and nonadiabatic transitions . with the definition of @xmath94 , eq . is transformed into = - _ j e^-i_0^t[_j(t)-_k(t)]dt | |u_j(a , t ) _ [ eq : schroedingerequationinfloquetbasiswithtildes ] note that although we have eliminated the indefinitely growing coefficient with this last transformation we now have a new undesirable feature in the equation of motion , namely the fact that the time derivative of the state now depends on the entire history of the system , as opposed to just the system parameters and state at time @xmath83 . is the schrdinger equation that describes the transition dynamics between the floquet modes . if the driving strength @xmath55 changes very slowly over time @xmath83 , we are in the adiabatic limit of the floquet picture . using eq . together with @xmath97 , we conclude that all the coefficient @xmath98 are constants . in this case , there is no population transition between the floquet modes . from eq . , we find that the state dynamics are fully described by applying a time - dependent dynamical phase @xmath99 to each of the two floquet modes @xmath95 . the constant coefficients @xmath100 can be obtained by decomposing the initial state @xmath101 in the floquet state basis at the initial time , e.g. the basis states @xmath102 if we are considering a pulse whose amplitude @xmath55 starts from zero at the initial time @xmath92 ( and we remind the reader here that setting @xmath37 in @xmath102 should be understood as taking the limit @xmath68 ) . ( upper panel ) and the quasienergy spectrum ( lower panel ) for the case of a qubit under resonant driving , @xmath103 . the quasienergies and floquet modes are calculated by numerically diagonalizing the floquet hamiltonian , eq . . the positions of the avoided crossings ( labeled with dashed lines in the lower panel ) align well with the local maxima of @xmath104.,width=302 ] if the driving strength @xmath55 varies fast over time , nonadiabatic transitions between the floquet modes can be excited . according to eq . , the nonadiabatic transition rate , given by the change of the coefficient @xmath105 , depends on the inner product @xmath106 . in the upper panel of fig . [ fig : innerproduct ] , we plot the amplitude of the inner product @xmath104 for the case of a qubit under resonant driving , @xmath103 . this quantity exhibits multiple local maxima at driving amplitudes which correspond to the positions of the avoided crossings of the quasienergies spectrum ( labeled with dashed lines in the lower panel of fig . [ fig : innerproduct ] ) . in a pulse where the driving strength changes and the system traverses such an avoided crossing , landau - zener transitions can occur between floquet states following the usual formula for landau - zener transitions , just modified from the language of energies to that of quasienergies . the time dependence of the floquet modes @xmath107 appears explicitly in eq . . it is possible to rewrite the equation using the fourier decomposition of these modes , similarly to what is done for example when transforming the time - dependent floquet hamiltonian into its time - independent infinite matrix form . as we shall see shortly , this change makes it possible to evaluate the necessary inner products directly from the eigenstates of the floquet hamiltonian in its time - independent large - matrix form . in order to perform this transformation , we take the inner product on the right - hand side of eq . and express it as a fourier series : @xmath108 where the double - bracket notation is defined in eq . , and we have also used the definition @xmath109 note that @xmath110 is different from @xmath111 , which was introduced in sec . [ sec : floquet ] and is the @xmath112-th fourier coefficient of @xmath95 . apart from the differentiation with respect to @xmath55 , the inner products in eq . can be evaluated by taking the simple inner products between two vectors that are obtained by diagonalizing the hamiltonian @xmath30 . because of the ambiguity in defining @xmath17 and @xmath18 ( more specifically the fact that one can freely move integer multiples of @xmath8 between the two ) , the above definition of @xmath113 naturally suggests the accompanying definition @xmath114 which leads to the relation @xmath115 for all values of @xmath112 . in other words , the different values of @xmath112 give identical copies of the floquet states , although the quasienergies and floquet modes for the different values of @xmath112 are different by integer multiples of @xmath8 and a factor of @xmath116 . equation now becomes @xmath117dt ' } e^{in\omega t } \langle\langle u_{k}(a , t ) | \frac{\partial}{\partial a } | u_{j}^{(n)}(a , t ) \rangle\rangle \tilde{c}_j(t ) \nonumber \\ & = & - \frac{da}{dt } \sum_j \sum_{n=-\infty}^{\infty } e^{-i\int_0^t[\epsilon_{j}^{(n)}(t')-\epsilon_k(t')]dt ' } \langle\langle u_{k}(a , t ) | \frac{\partial}{\partial a } | u_{j}^{(n)}(a , t ) \rangle\rangle \tilde{c}_j(t).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this equation is asymmetric in that it uses the quasienergies and floquet modes both with and without the additional index @xmath112 . it can be made symmetric by first rewriting it in the form @xmath118dt ' } \langle\langle u_{k}^{(0)}(a , t ) | \frac{\partial}{\partial a } | u_{j}^{(n)}(a , t ) \rangle\rangle \tilde{c}_{j}^{(0)}(t ) \label{eq : schroedingerequationinfloquetbasiswithtildesandspaceexpansionunsymmetrized}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and observing that the equation would still be valid if we replaced the index 0 by @xmath119 throughout the equation . we can therefore replace the single equation by an infinite number of equivalent and independent equations . because these equations are linear in the coefficients @xmath120 , one can distribute the two probability amplitudes @xmath121 at the initial time ( with complete freedom ) among the different identical copies of the floquet states ( and hence use the coefficients @xmath122 with @xmath123 ) and solve all the equations in order to find the probability amplitudes at the final time , keeping in mind that after obtaining the probability amplitudes at the final time all the coefficients with the same value of @xmath24 must be summed before calculating the occupation probabilities for the two floquet states , i.e. @xmath124 . noting once more the linearity in the schrdinger equations and the equivalence between the different copies of floquet state , we can rearrange the terms on the right - hand side among the different equations . one possible rearrangement gives the set of equations @xmath125dt ' } \langle\langle u_{k}^{(m)}(a , t ) | \frac{\partial}{\partial a } | u_{j}^{(n)}(a , t ) \rangle\rangle \tilde{c}_{j}^{(n)}(t ) . \label{eq : schroedingerequationinfloquetbasiswithtildesandspaceexpansion}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we remark that the above equation can also be derived using the ( @xmath126 ) formalism @xcite as described in ref . . in applications to quantum control of a single qubit , one often focuses on the qubit s final state at the end of a control pulse or pulse sequence , which is then followed by state readout . in this section , we discuss the final state of the qubit after a resonant pulse whose amplitude varies slowly . in this case , the adiabatic limit in the floquet picture applies . the pulse amplitude @xmath37 at the beginning and the end of the pulse . as a result , we would like to express the initial and final states of the qubit using floquet modes @xmath127 . from eqs . , and , we obtain the floquet modes expressions |u_0(0,t ) & = ( c 1 + e^it + ) , + c 1 + -e^it + ) in the original qubit basis using the bessel functions at value 0 , @xmath128 , and @xmath129 for @xmath103 and @xmath68 . we notice from the above equations that the floquet modes @xmath127 are the time - independent states @xmath130 and @xmath131 , if we define @xmath132 and @xmath133 as the qubit eigenstates in a rotating frame which rotates at an angular frequency @xmath8 . in this rotating frame , the floquet modes at the beginning and at the end of the pulse correspond to the same set of states . the state evolution from the beginning ( @xmath92 ) to the end ( @xmath134 ) of the pulse is simply described by the accumulation of a dynamical phase @xmath135 , where @xmath136 . in the bloch sphere , the above evolution can be seen as a rotation of the state vector by an angle @xmath137 around the x axis , which points towards @xmath138 . the rotation angle @xmath137 , which is the time integral of the quasienergy difference , does not depend on any other details of the pulse shape . considering the case where the rise and fall parts of the pulse are slow and we vary only the duration of the middle part of the pulse with fixed amplitude @xmath139 , the qubit state undergoes rabi oscillations as @xmath137 changes at a constant rate @xmath140 , i.e. the rabi frequency as discussed in sec . [ sec : floquet ] . in the equatorial plane . the direction of the fictitious field in the equatorial plane is determined by the phase @xmath12 of the driving and the amplitude of the fictitious field has an amplitude given by the quasienergy difference @xmath141.,width=302 ] it is worth noting here that although we have only discussed the case where the driving term of the qubit is @xmath142 above , we can easily generalize our results to the driving waveform @xmath143 with an arbitrary constant phase @xmath12 . in this more general case , we obtain the same form of the quasienergies of the system and floquet modes with a phase shift compared to the @xmath144 case . in particular , the floquet modes at @xmath68 are given by @xmath145 and @xmath146 . by choosing a specific value of @xmath12 in the driving signal , one can control the rotation axis of the rabi oscillation in the equatorial plane of the bloch sphere ( see figure [ fig : adaibaticpulseblochrepresentation ] ) . this point appears naturally in the rwa for weak driving , and our analysis shows that it holds for pulses with arbitrary driving amplitude , as long as the pulse amplitude varies slowly . in sec . [ sec : nonadiabatic ] , we will examine more closely the breakdown of the adiabatic approximation . when the driving strength changes rapidly , e.g. in a short pulse , nonadiabatic transitions between floquet states will be reflected in the evolution of the coefficients @xmath94 in eq . . this evolution can be calculated using eq . or equivalently eq . . these two equations are exact . to proceed further analytically , we will employ adiabatic perturbation theory ( apt ) @xcite and then we will compare the solutions given by apt with the exact numerical solutions . in the first order of apt @xcite , we solve eq . iteratively keeping terms up to first order in @xmath147 . this is equivalent to replacing @xmath148 on the right - hand side of eq . . this way we obtain the approximate expression _ k^(m)(t ) = _ k^(m)(0 ) - _ 0^t dt _ j _ n=-^ e^-i_0^t[_j^(n)(t)-_k^(m)(t)]dt u_k^(m)(a , t ) | | u_j^(n)(a , t ) _ j^(n)(0 ) . [ eq : schrodingerequation1storderapt ] setting @xmath149 at the initial time and summing the equation over @xmath119 , we obtain _ k(t ) = _ k(0 ) - _ 0^t dt _ j _ m=-^ e^-i_0^t[_j^(0)(t)-_k^(m)(t)]dt u_k^(m)(a , t ) | | u_j^(0)(a , t ) _ [ eq:1storderapt ] if we quantify the nonadiabatic transition as the change of each coefficient @xmath150 , we can see from the above equation that this quantity is proportional to n_jk(t ) = _ 0^t dt _ m=-^ e^-i_0^t[_j^(0)(t)-_k^(m)(t)]dt u_k^(m)(a , t ) @xmath151 , denotes the nonadiabatic transition matrix element from the @xmath24-th to the @xmath152-th floquet mode . it can be defined as the complex coefficient @xmath153 of the @xmath152-th floquet mode after a driven evolution with the initial state prepared in the @xmath24-th floquet mode , i.e. @xmath154 . @xmath155 is the sum of complex , oscillating terms that will occasionally give a very small value for the sum , as we shall see below . we also note that the coefficient @xmath153 can be calculated essentially exactly by numerically solving the time - dependent schrdinger equation . next , we calculate the nonadiabatic transition matrix elements for a representative pulse shape that has the simple form : a(t ) = ( 1-(t / t_r ) ) & t t_r + a_m & t_r < t t_r + t_p + ( 1 + ( ) ) & t_r + t_p < t t_r+t_p+t_f , [ eq : pulseshape ] where @xmath156 is the duration of the middle part of the pulse , @xmath157 ( @xmath158 ) is the rise ( fall ) time of the pulse , and @xmath159 is the maximum amplitude of the pulse . we choose to analyze pulses with the rising and falling edge being cosine functions because it is a pulse shape that requires a small bandwidth , minimizing required experimental resources . nonadiabatic transitions occur in both the rising and falling edges of the pulse . we will deal with these two cases separately in the remainder of this section . we will consider the case of resonant driving ( @xmath48 ) and @xmath144 here but our treatment can be generalized to arbitrary values of @xmath8 and @xmath12 . for the pulse shape given by eq . , the rising edge is in the time interval between 0 and @xmath160 . for performing the exact numerics to simulate the nonadiabatic transitions , we assume the initial state of the system to be @xmath161 which coincides with the floquet mode @xmath162 . thus @xmath163 and @xmath164 . we then use a numerical solver to determine the system evolution under the time - dependent hamiltonian in eq . with the specified pulse shape . the final state @xmath165 is written as a superposition of the floquet modes @xmath166 , yielding the floquet mode coefficients @xmath167 and @xmath168 . in this case , the quantity @xmath168 gives an measure of the nonadiabatic transitions during the rising edge of the pulse . in fig . [ fig : nonadiabatic](a ) , we show @xmath168 as a function of the maximum amplitude @xmath159 and the rise time @xmath157 . for comparison we also evaluate the nonadiabatic transition amplitudes using apt . for this purpose , we first numerically calculate all the instantaneous quasienergies and floquet modes for values of @xmath55 from @xmath92 to @xmath169 in small steps . we then numerically evaluate @xmath170 according to eq . , and we plot its absolute value in fig . [ fig : nonadiabatic](b ) . in fig . [ fig : nonadiabatic](c ) , we show the nonadiabatic transition amplitude calculated both by exact numerics and by apt as a function of @xmath157 for a few values of the strong - driving pulse amplitude @xmath159 . we find good agreement between the apt solution and the exact results . considering the physics of landau - zener transitions , and noting that the minimum gap in the first avoided crossing of quasienergies is @xmath65 , we find that for @xmath171 adiabaticity is determined by the product @xmath172 . as expected , for long rise times @xmath173 where the evolution should be adiabatic , we have @xmath174 . for short rise times @xmath175 , the nonadiabatic transition amplitude oscillates as a function of @xmath157 . this oscillatory behavior is a result of interference between different paths that correspond to the nonadiabatic transitions during the rise time . we notice that for the particular pulse shape analyzed here , @xmath176 has a local minimum around @xmath177 ( as well as at other higher points ) , which only weakly depends on the value of @xmath159 provided that @xmath178 . at this point , the net probability for a nonadiabatic transition to have occurred during the amplitude ramp is remarkably small . this suppression of nonadiabatic transitions can be understood as destructive interference of the transitions between the floquet states at different times during the amplitude ramp . the exact values of @xmath160 at which the minima occur depend on @xmath12 . for @xmath179 for example , the first minimum in the nonadiabatic transition probability occurs around @xmath180 . the nonadiabatic transitions in the falling edge of the pulse can be calculated in a similar way as for the rising edge . to simplify notations , we shift the times so that the beginning and end times are @xmath181 and @xmath158 ( e.g. by taking @xmath182 in eq . ) . we have = - ( (-1 ) ) . to exactly simulate the nonadiabatic transitions , we start with the initial state @xmath183 and express the final state @xmath184 in the basis of floquet modes @xmath185 . in fig . [ fig : nonadiabatic](d - f ) we show the amplitude of nonadiabatic transitions occurring during the falling edge of the pulse as a function of the maximum pulse amplitude @xmath159 and the fall time @xmath186 . in the adiabatic limit @xmath187 , we have @xmath174 as expected . we also notice a coherent suppression of nonadiabatic transitions at @xmath188 with only a weak dependence on the value of @xmath139 as long as @xmath178 . our results for the rising and falling edges agree in predicting that when @xmath189 , nonadiabatic transitions are negligible , which corresponds to the adiabatic limit in this driven system . the small differences between the two cases in the exact shapes of the oscillatory behavior of @xmath174 as a function of @xmath157 is not very surprising , given that there is an asymmetry between the two cases , both in the pulse shape and in the fact that in one case the pulse amplitude is minimum at the initial time while in the other the pulse amplitude is maximum at the initial time . remarkably , we find that the transitions between the floquet states during the rise and fall edges of the control pulses are reduced for specific values of the rise and fall times , respectively . this effect provides the basis for a quantum control protocol , which we name floquet interference efficient suppression of transitions in the adiabatic basis ( fiesta ) . in the next section we discuss the application of fiesta to optimization of single qubit gates . as we have discussed in secs . [ sec : adiabatic ] and [ sec : nonadiabatic ] , the absence of nonadiabatic transitions between floquet modes results in smooth and simple rabi oscillations between energy eigenstates of the qubit . this is a desirable property for implementing high - fidelity single - qubit gates . nonadiabatic transitions can be suppressed either by turning the pulse on and off adiabatically or by using the destructive interference of the nonadiabatic transitions discussed in sec . [ sec : nonadiabatic ] . in any realistic setup , the gate fidelity is further reduced by the decoherence that the qubit experiences during the implementation of the gate , and the reduction increases with increasing gate time . for an adiabatic pulse in the strong driving regime , we require @xmath190 , which means that the total pulse duration must satisfy @xmath191 . this condition is the same one obtained for the implementation of a typical single - qubit gate in the weak driving regime , because the pulse duration in that case is given by @xmath192 and @xmath193 . therefore , adiabatic pulses in the strong driving regime do not necessarily yield higher operation speeds than weak - driving pulses . however , with the coherent suppression of the nonadiabatic transitions , which requires careful control of the pulse shapes , one could realize high - fidelity single - qubit gates with gate times on the order of @xmath194 . in this section , we discuss the optimization of the fidelity of single - qubit operations by zeroing the nonadiabatic transitions between floquet modes in fast pulses . universal single - qubit operations require unitary operations corresponding to rotations around two axes in the bloch sphere with arbitrary angles . here , we consider implementing operations which are rotations around axes in the equatorial plane of the bloch sphere since these can be realized with the hamiltonian in eq . in the absence of nonadiabatic transitions between floquet modes . the rotation axis is controlled by the phase of the pulse @xmath12 and the rotation angle @xmath195 is determined by the time integral of the quasienergy difference , i.e. @xmath196 . following the discussions in the previous section , we consider the pulse shape defined in eq . . to achieve the above rotations , we choose the optimal rise time @xmath160 and fall time @xmath158 on the rising and falling edges respectively for the coherent suppression of nonadiabatic transitions and we choose the duration @xmath197 of the middle part of the pulse correspondingly according to the target rotation angle @xmath195 . for finding the optimal rise time @xmath160 for a given operation , we calculate and minimize the nonadiabatic transitions on the rising edge in its time interval between 0 and @xmath160 for pulses with a initial phase @xmath12 which sets the desirable rotation axis . this is essentially the same calculation we did in sec . [ sec : nonadiabatic ] . for operations @xmath198 and @xmath199 which are rotations around the @xmath200 and @xmath14 axes of the bloch sphere , the optimal rise times @xmath160 are approximately @xmath201 and @xmath202 respectively . for finding the optimal fall time @xmath158 , the procedure is more complicated as the nonadiabatic transitions on the falling edge depend on @xmath158 as well as the phase of the pulse at the beginning of the falling edge @xmath203 . this phase depends on the initial phase of the pulse as well as the pulse duration by @xmath204 . in fig . [ fig : pulsefidelity](a ) and ( b ) , we plot the nonadiabatic transition amplitude @xmath176 on the falling edge versus the fall time @xmath158 and the phase @xmath203 with the maximum amplitude @xmath205 . we find that the @xmath158 minimizing @xmath176 changes with @xmath203 periodically . next , we perform simulation on the qubit dynamics under pulses with different parameters and compute the their fidelities with respect to the ideal operations @xmath198 and @xmath199 . with the shape of the pulse in eq . , the pulse is fully determined by the parameters @xmath159 , @xmath12 , @xmath157 , @xmath186 , and @xmath156 . with energy relaxation time @xmath206 taken into account , we can express the resulting operation as a quantum process matrix @xmath207 characterized by quantum process tomography ( qpt ) @xcite . to obtain the process matrix corresponding to a given pulse , we simulate the final state after the pulse with respect to initial states @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath208 , and @xmath209 . the simulations are done by numerically solving the master equation in the lindblad form @xcite : ( t ) = -i[h(t ) , ( t)]+_n ( 2_n_n^- _ n^_n-_n^_n ) , [ eq : gates : mastereq ] where @xmath210 and @xmath211 are the lindblad operator and the decoherence rate for a certain decoherence source respectively . here we consider only one decoherence mechanism , energy relaxation thus we only have one term in eq . , with @xmath212 and @xmath213 . the actual values of the qubit parameters are chosen to be the same as those characterized in the experiments discussed in ref . , where @xmath214 ghz and @xmath215 @xmath216s . we note that the value of @xmath206 here is shorter than those obtained in other experiments with flux qubits , and therefore the fidelities we obtain are conservative estimates . once we have the final states with respect to the four initial states , we can reconstruct the process matrix @xmath217 using standard qpt . from the process matrix @xmath217 obtained by qpt and its ideal counterpart @xmath218 , we can directly calculate the process fidelity , defined as @xmath219 $ ] . the gate fidelity @xmath220 , defined as the state fidelity of the process output state with respect to the ideal output state averaged over all possible input states , can be related to the process fidelity @xmath221 by @xmath222 with @xmath223 the dimension of the system @xcite . we simulate the gate fidelity of operations @xmath198 and @xmath199 implemented by pulses with @xmath11 and @xmath224 at @xmath205 . in these simulations , we choose the rise times of the pulses @xmath225 and @xmath202 for @xmath198 and @xmath199 respectively for the maximum suppression of the nonadiabatic transitions on the rising edge . in fig . [ fig : pulsefidelity](c ) and ( d ) , we plot the gate fidelities versus the maximum amplitude duration @xmath197 with different fall times . for short fall times ( @xmath226 ) , the gate fidelity oscillates as a function of @xmath197 . this is a signature of coherent nonadiabatic transitions between the floquet modes . the highest - fidelities are attained when the combinations of @xmath197 and @xmath158 lead to small nonadiabatic transitions ( minima in fig . [ fig : pulsefidelity](a ) and ( b ) ) . for longer fall times ( @xmath227 ) , the ramping of the falling edge is approximately adiabatic thus the gate fidelity has suppressed oscillations and is limited by @xmath206 . versus the maximum amplitude duration @xmath197 ( a ) or the rotation angle @xmath195 given by @xmath196 ( b ) . the pulses are defined with @xmath11 , @xmath225 and @xmath228 and various values of @xmath197 and @xmath139 . while the optimal @xmath197 for the coherent suppression of nonadiabatic transitions is independent of @xmath139 , different pulses with the same @xmath160 , @xmath158 , and @xmath197 can have different rotation angles @xmath195 depending on @xmath139.,width=302 ] so far , we have shown that high - fidelity operations @xmath198 and @xmath199 can be achieved for some specific rotation angle @xmath195 which depends on the optimal combination of @xmath160 , @xmath197 , and @xmath158 . performing univeral quantum computation , however , requires engineering pulses that correspond to arbitrary rotation angles . this goal is easy to achieve in our optimization method . as discussed in sec . [ sec : nonadiabatic ] , the optimal @xmath160 and @xmath158 are almost independent of the maximum driving amplitude @xmath139 as long as @xmath229 . in fig . [ fig : fidelity_vs_a](a ) , we plot the gate fidelity of @xmath198 versus @xmath197 and @xmath139 with the optimal @xmath225 and a short @xmath228 . we show that the optimal @xmath197 , which minimizes nonadiabatic transitions and leads to high - fidelity operations , is also independent of @xmath139 . in fig . [ fig : fidelity_vs_a](b ) , we plot the gate fidelity of @xmath198 versus @xmath195 at several values of @xmath139 . we show that by fixing @xmath160 , @xmath197 , and @xmath158 to their the optimal values and sweeping @xmath139 , high - fidelity rotations for any rotation angles @xmath195 can be achieved . therefore , to fully optimize a pulse for a given rotation operation , one can first determine @xmath160 , @xmath197 , and @xmath158 based on the rotation axis and a rough range of @xmath139 and then fine - tune @xmath139 by targeting a precise rotation angle given by @xmath196 . as an example , we optimize pulses for the operations @xmath230 and @xmath231 in the single - qubit clifford group @xcite using qubit parameters detailed in ref . . for @xmath230 , the optimized pulse with @xmath225 , @xmath228 , @xmath232 , and @xmath233 has a gate fidelity of @xmath234 . for @xmath231 , the optimized pulse has a fidelity of @xmath235 with @xmath236 , @xmath228 , @xmath237 , and @xmath238 . the above fidelities are limited by @xmath206 , where we assumed @xmath239 ghz and @xmath215 @xmath240 . next , we consider optimization with an experimental limitation , as introduced by the time resolution and bandwidth of the ultrafast arbitrary waveform generator used in ref . . we perform pulse optimization while restricting the time resolution of the waveform to 40 ps and limiting the shortest @xmath157 and @xmath186 to 80 ps . we obtain a fidelity of @xmath241 for @xmath230 with the pulse parameters : @xmath242 ps , @xmath243 ps , @xmath244 ps , and @xmath245 ghz . for @xmath231 , we obtain a fidelity of @xmath246 with @xmath247 ps , @xmath243 ps , @xmath248 ps , and @xmath249 ghz . now the gate fidelities are additionally limited by the unsuppressed nonadiabatic transitions between floquet modes . these nonadiabatic transitions arise from waveform definition errors due to insufficient time - resolution . we note that , thanks to the cosine - function shape of the pulse envelope during the rising and falling edges , this pulse scheme requires a bandwidth of only @xmath10 . for superconducting qubits , which usually have a transition frequency of a few gigahertz , such pulses can be readily generated by a high - bandwidth arbitrary waveform generator . in this section , we discuss the connection between fiesta and other methods in optimal quantum control ( oqc ) . for an in depth discussion of quantum control , we refer the reader to the review articles @xcite . the objective in oqc is maximizing the fidelity of a quantum state or of a quantum operation , given a hamiltonian with controllable parameters . constraints on the parameters can be applied , including amplitude constraints and time - domain constraints . time - domain constraints are of two types : frequency bandwidth constraints or parametrization in terms of analytical functions . a research topic that is closely related to oqc is the quantum speed limit , addressing operations implemented with high fidelity in the minimum possible amount of time @xcite . gradient ascent pulse engineering ( grape ) @xcite and krotov @xcite optimal quantum control rely on assuming a piecewise - constant form of the control parameters . in these methods , an iterative algorithm is used to steadily increase the fidelity and eventually converge to optimal values of the control parameters in all the time intervals . with sufficient discretization , continuously varying control parameters can be approximated with good accuracy . other control methods , including chopped random - basis quantum optimization ( crab ) @xcite and gradient optimization of analytic controls ( goat ) @xcite assume the hamiltonian to be expressed in terms of analytic functions , with a set of parameters entering these functions to be optimized . derivative removal by adiabatic gate ( drag ) @xcite is concerned with the reduction of state leakage in a weakly anharmonic system , providing an approximate analytical solution to this problem . a problem discussed extensively in literature is the control of a qubit with a transverse driving term limited in absolute value . it was shown that the optimal solutions for single - qubit rotations consist of sudden switching of the control between its extreme values , and the optimal time is related to the inverse qubit transition frequency ( see ref . and references therein ) . in contrast to these approaches , closed - loop optimal control is a method in which control is optimized in a system with imperfect knowledge of the system hamiltonian or control transfer functions , based on feedback from a fidelity measurement performed on the physical system @xcite . fiesta is used to perform optimization of quantum gates with resonant driving and a simple pulse shape characterized by three times ( pulse rise , top , and fall ) and an amplitude ( the maximum pulse amplitude ) . this particular optimization problem has elements related to amplitude constraints and bandwidth constraints explored with other methods . one important characteristic of this pulse shape is that it is motivated by experimental implementation constraints , where using a frequency band around the qubit transition frequency can be conveniently implemented using analog quadrature modulation . optimization with amplitude constraints can be done using grape or analytically in some cases . bandwidth constraints can be implemented in goat @xcite or approximately , using filtered optimal pulses @xcite . our approach is physically motivated by the observation that even in the strong driving regime the dynamics can be simply described in terms of three unitaries , for the rise , central , and fall parts of the pulses . we showed that optimizing only the four involved parameters ( @xmath157 , @xmath156 , @xmath186 , and @xmath159 ) extremely high fidelities can be attained , with a total pulse duration of the order of @xmath250 , thus approaching the quantum speed limit @xcite . we expect that the optimization of these parameters is also suitable for a closed - loop approach , and that high fidelities can be attained with moderate levels of errors arising from the transfer function frequency dependence and qubit detuning . we note that bartels and mintert @xcite discussed a numerical optimization method for control with short pulses based on floquet theory . the discussion in ref . focuses on the implementation of single - qubit gates , the method is applicable straightforwardly to optimizing single - qubit gates . nevertheless , we expect in general that optimized pulses obtained using their method will have rather complicated envelopes , possibly complicating experimental implementations . we find that in the strong driving regime the optimal times for @xmath200 and @xmath14 rotations obtained with fiesta are different from each other , and these optimal times depend on the maximum amplitude @xmath159 . these results bear an interesting connection with the discussion presented in ref . ( see also references therein ) of optimized pulses with amplitude constraints and no bandwidth constraints . we finally comment on the relevance of our work for physical implementations of optimal quantum control . superconducting flux qubits , for which we have recently observed floquet dynamics @xcite , are an ideal two - level system to apply these results , because higher energy levels are well separated from the lowest two levels , even when driving field amplitudes are larger than @xmath32 . nv centers have also been used in strong driving time domain experiments by fuchs et al . @xcite . in a recent experiment scheuer et al . @xcite demonstrated the implementation of optimal control in the strong driving regime using optimization based on crab . we also expect our theoretical framework to be extendible to optimization of strong driving control for multi - level systems , with superconducting qubits being a case of particular interest . we have analyzed the dynamics of a two - level system under strong resonant pulses from the perspective of ( non)adiabatic evolutions in the floquet picture . we presented derivations of the approximate analytical expressions for the quasienergies and floquet states of the system under consideration . we analyzed the effects of pulse shaping using the adiabatic theory in the floquet picture . we shown that when the the driving amplitude of a pulse varies slowly , the system remains in its initial superposition of the floquet states and the dynamics are governed by a dynamic phase that depends on the evolution of the quasienergies over time . this phase corresponds to a qubit state rotation , generalizing the notion of rabi oscillations to the case of large driving amplitudes . we have also analyzed and quantified the nonadiabatic transitions between the floquet states by employing the adiabatic perturbation theory as well as exact numerical simulations . we found that the first order adiabatic perturbation theory agrees very well with the exact numerics when the driving amplitude is comparable with the qubit frequency and breaks down at very high driving amplitude . in addition , we found that with suitable pulse shaping the nonadiabatic transitions can be coherently suppressed . finally , we presented fiesta , an optimization scheme for the pulse shapes that minimize the nonadiabatic transitions . we shown that high - fidelity single - qubit operations can be achieved in very short times , significantly alleviating the effect of decoherence . furthermore , our optimized control scheme requires pulse specifications that can be achieved with presently available arbitrary - waveform generators and is therefore ready to be implemented in experiments using superconducting qubits . our method is an addition to the toolset of quantum control , providing a simple recipe for high fidelity control of a single qubit in the strong driving regime and a framework that can be generalized to other strongly driven systems . we thank frank wilhelm for useful discussions . we acknowledge support from nserc , canada foundation for innovation , ontario ministry of research and innovation , industry canada . during this work , al was supported by an early research award . 54ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _ ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.49.324 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.259.5101.1581 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1109/9.928587 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.63.032308 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.76.1037 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1181193 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/16/i=9/a=093022 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1183628 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys2149 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.86.121303 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.87.246601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature02831 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.037001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1119678 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.187002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.107001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.257003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.101.017003 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3093823 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.257003 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/17/i=4/a=043058 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.115.133601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjb / e2003 - 00343 - 8 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.75.063414 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2010.03.002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.138.b979 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s100530050236 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' in link:\doibase 10.1002/0471428027.ch3 [ _ _ ] ( , ) pp . link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.79.032301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.86.023831 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.67.165301 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.466058 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.78.052508 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/09500349708231894 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.78.390 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , vol . ( , ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0375-9601(02)01272-0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.78.405 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/12/i=7/a=075008 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjd / e2015 - 60464 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0953-8984/28/i=21/a=213001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.103.240501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.85.052327 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.260501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.jmr.2004.11.004 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0301-0104(93)80108-l [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.84.022326 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.103.110501 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.240503 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.88.052315 [ * * , ( ) ]

we consider the dynamics of a two - level system ( qubit ) driven by strong and short resonant pulses in the framework of floquet theory . first we derive analytical expressions for the quasienergies and floquet states of the driven system . if the pulse amplitude varies very slowly , the system adiabatically follows the instantaneous floquet states , which acquire dynamical phases that depend on the evolution of the quasienergies over time . the difference between the phases acquired by the two floquet states corresponds to a qubit state rotation , generalizing the notion of rabi oscillations to the case of large driving amplitudes . if the pulse amplitude changes very fast , the evolution is non - adiabatic , with transitions taking place between the floquet states . we quantify and analyze the nonadiabatic transitions during the pulse by employing adiabatic perturbation theory and exact numerical simulations . we find that , for certain combinations of pulse rise and fall times and maximum driving amplitude , a destructive interference effect leads to a remarkably strong suppression of transitions between the floquet states . this effect provides the basis of a quantum control protocol , which we name floquet interference efficient suppression of transitions in the adiabatic basis ( fiesta ) , that can be used to design ultra - fast high - fidelity single - qubit quantum gates .

1311.0269

the computing requirements for high energy physics ( hep ) projects like the large hadron collider ( lhc ) @xcite at the european laboratory for particle physics ( cern ) in geneva , switzerland are larger than can be met with resources deployed in a single computing center . this has led to the construction of a global distributed computing system known as the worldwide lhc computing grid ( wlcg ) @xcite , which brings together resources from nearly 160 computer centers in 35 countries . computing at this scale has been used , for example , by the cms @xcite and atlas @xcite experiments for the discovery of the higgs boson @xcite . to achieve this and other results the cms experiment , for example , typically used during 2012 a processing capacity between 80,000 and 100,000 x86 - 64 cores from the wlcg . further discoveries are possible in the next decade as the lhc moves to its design energy and increases the machine luminosity . however , increases in dataset sizes by 2 - 3 orders of magnitude ( and commensurate processing capacity ) will eventually be required to realize the full potential of this scientific instrument . the scale and longevity of the lhc computing require continual r&d into new technologies which may be relevant in the coming years . in this paper we report on our investigations into one such technology , low power arm processors , for scientific computing . the construction of the wlcg was greatly facilitated by the convergence around the year 2000 on commodity x86 hardware and the standardized use of linux as the operating system for scientific computing clusters . even if multiple generations of x86 hardware ( and hardware from both intel and amd ) are provided in the various computer centers , this was a far simpler situation than the typical mix of proprietary unix operating systems and processors . until around 2005 , a combination of increased instruction level parallelism and ( in particular ) processor clock frequency increases insured that performance gains expected from moore s law would be seen by single sequential applications running on a single processor . the combination of linux , commodity x86 processors and moore s law gains for sequential applications made for a simple software environment . since around 2005 , however , processors have hit scaling limits , largely driven by overall power consumption @xcite . the first large change in commercial processor products as a result of these limits was the introduction of `` multicore '' cpus , with more than one functional processor on a chip . at the same time clock frequencies ceased to increase with each processor generation and indeed were often reduced relative to the peak . the result of this was that one could no longer expect that single , sequential applications would run faster on newer processors . however in the first approximation , the individual cores in the multicore cpus appeared more or less like the single standalone processors used previously . most large scientific applications ( hpc / parallel or high throughput ) run in any case on clusters and the additional cores are often simply scheduled as if they were additional nodes in the cluster . this allows overall throughput to continue to scale even if that of a single application does not . it has several disadvantages , though , in that a number of things that would have been roughly constant over subsequent purchasing generations in a given cluster ( with a more or less fixed number of rack slots , say ) now grow with each generation of machines in the computer center . this includes the total memory required in each box , the number of open files and/or database connections , increasing number of independent ( and incoherent ) i / o streams , the number of jobs handled by batch schedulers , etc . the specifics vary from application to application , but potential difficulties in continually scaling these system parameters puts some pressure on applications to make code changes in response , for example by introducing thread - level parallelism where it did not previously exist . there is moreover a more general expectation that the limit of power consumption on future moore s law scaling will lead to more profound changes going forward . in particular , the power hungry x86 - 64 `` large '' cores of today will likely be replaced by simpler and less power hungry `` small '' cores with a greater emphasis on aggregate throughput performance per watt , rather than just raw performance . this has rekindled interest in solutions that would lead back to a more heterogeneous computing environment . a strong contender for this evolving low power ( high performance / watt ) server market is the arm processor @xcite due its nearly complete dominance in the low power mobile market for smartphones and tablets , which has also seen dramatic growth since around 2005 . the size of the mobile market , and its traditional focus on low power , has led to interest in using these processors also in a server environment . as such arm - based server products such as boston viridis @xcite are starting to appear . the arm processor has a long history @xcite dating back to acorn computers and the early days of personal computers . it is a risc processor and the current generation ( armv7 ) , used in most high - end mobile devices and the new server products , is a 32bit processor . we are interested in the `` a '' series of general purpose `` application '' processors . ( arm also produces `` r '' and `` m '' series designs for use in real - time and embedded microcontroller environments , respectively . ) a 64bit version of the arm processor ( armv8 ) has also been designed and is expected to appear in server products from fall 2013 or early 2014 . intel has also announced the development of products ( silvermont ) aimed at a low power market . however , much like the current mobile market , it is nt positioned to dominate the low power server market as it has dominated the commodity processor market in the past . as the arm processors are general purpose and run linux , only a standard port of the cms software is required , similar to what was done , for example , to port the cms software from 32bit ( ia32 ) to 64bit ( x86 - 64 ) . such a port is reasonably straightforward relative to the changes required to use other high performance per watt solutions ( e.g. gpgpu s , which require actual software rewrites ) , thus the effort required for these initial investigations was also relatively modest . for the tests described in this paper we used a low - cost development board , the odroid - u2 @xcite . the processor on the board is an exynos 4412 prime , a system - on - chip ( soc ) produced by samsung for use in mobile devices . it is a quad - core cortex a9 armv7 processor operating at 1.7ghz with 2 gb of lp - ddr2 memory . the processor also contains an arm mali-400 quad - core gpu accelerator , although that was not used for the work described in this paper . the board has emmc and microsd slots , two usb 2.0 ports and 10/100mbps ethernet with an rj-45 port . power is provided a 5v dc power adaptor . the cost of the board alone was $ 89 and with the relevant accessories ( cables , a cooling fan , a 64 gb emmc storage module , etc . ) the total cost was $ 233 . this extremely modest cost permitted us to do meaningful initial investigations without investing in a full - fledged server . all build tests were done using a 500 gb @xmath0 ata disk connected via usb . runtime tests were done with output written to the emmc storage . for the linux operating system on the board we used fedora 18 arm remix with kernel version 3.0.75 ( provided by hardkernel , the vendor for the odroid - u2 board ) due to its similarities to scientific linux cern ( slc ) . it is fully hard float capable and uses the floating point unit on the soc . the kernel was reconfigured to enable swap devices / files , which is required for cmssw compilation . a 4 gb swap file was used in our build environment . in order to compare results from the arm board we also used two typical x86 - 64 servers currently deployed at cern . the first is a dual quad - core intel xeon l5520 @xmath1 2.27 ghz ( nehalem ) with 24 gb of memory . the second is dual hexa - core intel xeon e5 - 2630 @xmath1 2.00ghz ( sandy bridge ) with 64 gb of memory . both machines were equipped with a large local disk for output and used software installed on an afs filesystem at cern . these machines were purchased about three years apart and very roughly represent the range of x86 - 64 hardware being operated at the time of our arm tests . the software written by the cms collaboration itself ( cmssw ) consists of approximately 3.6 m source lines of code ( sloc ) , as measured by the sloccount tool @xcite . the entire software stack includes also 125 `` external '' packages , including hep software packages like root @xcite ( @xmath21.7 m sloc ) , geant4 @xcite ( @xmath21.2 m sloc ) and many general open source packages : gcc , boost , qt , python , etc . for the compilation and linking of this large set of software we considered three options : compilation directly on the odroid - u2 board itself , cross compilation for the odroid - u2 board from an x86 - 64 host and compilation for the odroid - u2 board from an emulation environment such as qemu @xcite running on an x86 - 64 host our experience with arm emulation with qemu prior to purchasing the odroid - u2 led us to believe that it was not yet quite mature enough to provide a stable build environment sufficient for our needs . even though it was clear that the small odroid - u2 development board is much less powerful than most standard x86 - 64 servers , we decided to attempt compilation of the full stack directly on the arm board . this was motivated by the idea that should we eventually adopt arm as a standard production architecture , we would probably aim for direct compilation on arm servers . during the port to armv7 we had to resolve a number of issues in the software and build recipes : * oracle : * we did not have oracle libraries for the armv7 architecture . by construction , however , no standard grid - capable cms applications depend on oracle . thus this affected only a small number of cmssw packages used primarily for writing calibrations into the oracle database at cern . cms applications which read calibrations do not interact directly with oracle , but instead access the calibrations via the frontier web service @xcite , with no direct dependency on oracle . * configuration : * there were a number of minor configuration issues , for example : * the -m32 and -m64 options do not work . ( on x86 - 64 cms had made a complete transition to 64bit a couple of years prior to this work . ) * in a number of places there were x86-based assumptions leading to attempts to configure for x86 - 64 sse and avx * memory use : * compilation of some translation units ( primarily generated root dictionaries ) exhausted the virtual memory address space . here the solution was simply to refactor the dictionaries . * root cintex : * a patch was needed for the cintex trampoline in root to support the arm architecture . this was submitted to the root developers . * signedness : * x86 - 64 and arm treat the signedness of char / bit - fields differently , intel is signed and arm is unsigned by default . this was dealt with on arm by imposing the use of the compiler options -fsigned - char and -fsigned - bitfields , along with a few small code modifications to fix non - portable code . * dictionary generation and i / o : * there were several bugs in the root i / o infrastructure , as well as non cross - platform types ( that crept in after cms transitioned to 64bit on x86 - 64 and stopped regularly producing 32bit builds ) , that at time of these tests prevented us from properly reading and writing root files . with changes to the build recipes resulting from fixing these issues we were able to build all of the standard cmssw externals and 99% of the cmssw code . the cmssw code which did not build was the small subset requiring oracle . this demonstrates the advantages of relying primarily on open source software and , when closed source software can not be avoided , carefully restricting the code which can depend on the closed source libraries . after making the changes described above , we achieved the following results for the total build times directly on the odroid - u2 board : * @xmath24h - compilation of a `` bootstrap '' kit consisting of the gcc compiler ( version 4.8.0 ) and a small set of packages ( rpm , apt , zlib , ncurses , nspr , sqlite , etc . ) that we use for packaging and distributing the results of our builds * @xmath212h - compilation of all of the 125 external packages not included in the `` bootstrap '' kit * @xmath225.5h - compilation of the cmssw code itself as well as a set of generated root dictionaries these are quite reasonable results . taking into account that the externals do not change frequently , these results are already very close to consistent with an eventual `` nightly '' integration build where we compile the very latest versions of all of the cmssw code , but reuse pre - existing builds of the externals . for a run time test and benchmark we used an actual cms application from the build described above rather than a synthetic benchmark . this application performs a monte carlo simulation of 8 tev lhc minimum bias events using pythia8 @xcite ( event generation ) followed by simulation with geant4 @xcite . due to the problem mentioned above with generation of the dictionaries used for data input / output , output was turned off . the data output however has little effect on the total cpu time ( and thus these benchmarks ) as the cpu cost is heavily dominated by the geant4 simulation . the application itself is single - threaded ( sequential ) and thus ran on a single core at a time . to simplify testing we ran only a single job at a time on each machine with the aim of measuring the single core performance . multiple tests were performed of sufficient length to estimate properly an average per event time and dedicated tests were run to subtract off job startup times . a proper validation of the application output was complicated by the lack of an output file , but checks done by enabling printout indicated consistency between arm and x86 - 64 . the results for performance ( events simulated per minute per core ) are shown in table [ tab : results ] . [ tab : results ] .results of run time tests [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] in order to calculate values for the performance per watt , it would be a bit misleading to compare the total power used by real ( x86 - 64 ) servers with a small development board . to get a better estimate , which more directly compares the processors themselves , we used the `` thermal design power '' ( tdp ) numbers for the processors themselves . here tdp numbers for the two intel xeon x86 - 64 processors were taken from their website @xcite . for the odroid - u2 we were not able to find specific tdp numbers , but based on our own measurements we have estimated the tdp - equivalent fully loaded power at about 4w . using these values we have calculated an equivalent performance ( in events per minute ) per watt in the last column of table [ tab : results ] . a clear advantage in terms of performance per watt is seen for the arm processor . we have done a port of the entire cms software stack , including 3.6 m sloc of cms - written code in cmssw and 125 external support packages , to the armv7-based odroid - u2 development board . we chose to build directly on the development board itself and measured build times consistent with operating a `` nightly '' build of the cms software . we report performance and performance per ( tdp ) watt numbers both for the armv7 board and for two typical x86 - 64 servers at cern . on the basis of these results we conclude that arm - based low power servers , if they succeed in the market , show great potential for use with typical hep high throughput computing applications . this work was partially supported by the national science foundation , under cooperative agreement phy-1120138 , and by the u.s . department of energy . 9 evans l and bryant p 2008 lhc machine _ jinst _ * 3 * s08001 bird i 2011 computing for the large hadron collider _ annual review of nuclear and particle science _ * 61 * 99 - 118 chatrchyan s et al ( cms collaboration ) 2008 the cms experiment at the cern lhc _ jinst _ * 3 * s08004 aad g et al ( atlas collaboration ) 2008 the atlas experiment at the cern large hadron collider _ jinst _ * 3 * s08003 chatrchyan s et al ( cms collaboration ) 2012 observation of a new boson at a mass of 125 gev with the cms experiment at the lhc _ phys.lett . _ * b716 * 30 - 61 aad g et al ( atlas collaboration ) 2012 observation of a new particle in the search for the standard model higgs boson with the atlas detector at the lhc _ phys.lett . _ * b716 * 1 - 29 fuller s h and millet l i ( editors ) 2011 _ the future of computing performance : game over or next level ? _ the national academies press . puechased via the hardkernel website : http://www.hardkernel.com source code and documentation available at http://www.dwheeler.com/sloccount/ http://root.cern.ch agostinelli s et al 2003 geant4 - a simulation toolkit _ nuclear instruments and methods in physics research _ * a 506 * 250 - 303 http://ark.intel.com/products/40201/ and http://ark.intel.com/products/64586/ http://www.qemu.org blumenfeld b , dykstra d , lueking l and wicklund e 2008 cms conditions data access using frontier _ j. phys . . ser . _ * 119 * 072007 sjostrand t , mrenna s and skands p 2008 a brief introduction to pythia 8.1 _ comput . _ * 178 * 852 - 867

power efficiency is becoming an ever more important metric for both high performance and high throughput computing . over the course of next decade it is expected that flops / watt will be a major driver for the evolution of computer architecture . servers with large numbers of arm processors , already ubiquitous in mobile computing , are a promising alternative to traditional x86 - 64 computing . we present the results of our initial investigations into the use of arm processors for scientific computing applications . in particular we report the results from our work with a current generation armv7 development board to explore arm - specific issues regarding the software development environment , operating system , performance benchmarks and issues for porting high energy physics software .

quant-ph0108065

the physics of quantum computation and information [ 2 ] is one of the branch of quantum theory , which develops day by day very fast . a lot of proposals [ 2 ] have been proposed for the construction of quantum computer . most reliable , some of them [ 2 ] are optical quantum computer ( oqc ) , ion - trap , and solid - state quantum computer ( ssqc ) . the most prospective technique to construct quantum computer among them is ssqc . so , througuhout this paper , we will discuss the oqc and ssqc . our dream to see the power , possibilities and applications of quantum computer is still under process . the reason for comparing the oqc with ssqc is that the coherent optical computers [ 1,6,7 ] which come around 1960 were studied very extensively in usa for their millitary purposes . the coherent optical computers were constructed with the huge amount of optical instruments and were useful for very limited number of problems . after the invention of the maser , the requirement [ 1 ] for coherent optical computer starts increasing very fast with more requirements of linear and nonlinear optical instruments . moreover , the applications , possibilities of coherent optical computer were very limited as compare to the digital computer based on silicon . so , the coherent optical computers lost their interest [ 6 - 8 ] due to the huge amount of requirements and limited number of applications . in the begining of 1990 , oqc [ 2,3,5,9 ] were proposed . in this article , we are studying the main technical requirements to construct oqc and comparing with ssqc . moreover , firstly , we are proposing to construct oqc based on rds crystals [ 4 ] . the ssqc consists [ 2 ] of @xmath1 number of atoms in one molecule . why we are taking one molecule and why not two or three ? the reason for taking one molecule is that the interaction within the molecules are negligible as compare to interaction of atoms in each molecule . some of the atoms in each molecule have nuclear spins @xmath2 with slightly different resonance frequencies . to have an idea of ssqc , we will demonstrate the graphical representation of ssqc and how to perform logical operations on it . as an example we are taking one molecule having two atoms and each atom having nuclear spin @xmath2 and resonance frequencies @xmath3 and @xmath4 ( see fig.1 ) . the two spins are interacting with each other with hyperfine interaction @xmath5 . to start , the implementation of some quantum algorithm , firstly , we align the two nuclear spins of each molecule along the direction of constant magnetic field @xmath6 , which is applied along the @xmath7-axis . the hamiltonian of the system of two nuclear spins @xmath2 with hyperfine interaction @xmath5 [ 2 ] @xmath8 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 are the pauli matrices of nuclear spins @xmath11 and @xmath12 . the logical operations are performed by the time dependent unitary operator @xmath13 we can change the dyanamics and position of spins @xmath14 and @xmath15 by selecting different resonance frequency impulses [ 2 ] . recently , it is shown that for the implementation of quantum algorithms on quantum computer , only two quantum logical gates ( not and cnot ) [ 2 ] are needed . it means that the complex quantum algorithms can be executed on quantum computer with the combination of quantum logical gates not and cnot ( control - not ) . the true tables for quantum logical gates not and cnot are as follows truth tables for logic gates not and cnot : input & output & & input & input & output & output + @xmath16 & @xmath17 & & @xmath18 & @xmath19 & @xmath20 & @xmath21 + 0 & 0 & & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & 1 & & 0 & 1 & 0 & 1 + & & & 1 & 0 & 1 & 1 + & & & 1 & 1 & 1 & 0 + where bar over @xmath22 and sign @xmath23 denote the not operation and summation modulo @xmath24 . 1 . @xmath25-number of qubits ( quantum bits ) are required to operate and store data . 2 . to prepare the system ( qubits ) to its initial state i.e. , constant magnetic field is required to align the initial spin states along the magnetic field direction . 3 . to isolate the quantum computer ( qubits ) from the environment ( decoherence effect ) [ 10 ] , which is practically uncntrollable part of the quantum computer . 4 . unitary transformations to implement quantum algorithms i.e. , for the implementations of quantum algorithms . 5 . quantum measurements [ 10 ] , which are needed for measuring the final state of the implemented quantum algorithms . there are two proposals [ 2,3,5,9 ] to construct oqc on the basis of linear optics and nonlinear optics . the linear optics means that we need coherent laser beams , polarization beam splitters ( pbs ) , polarization rotating plates , optical mirrors , photo - detectors etc . for the case of nonlinear optics we need nonlinear crystals and all the components of the linear optics . the proposal to construct oqc based on linear optics was given by spreeuw [ 9 ] . to perform quantum computation on oqc for the general case , we need exponentially amount of linear optical components . for example to have @xmath26 qubits as in the case of ssqc , we need at least @xmath26 number of optical components to have properties like ssqc at least . the exponentially number of components can be reduced by using polarized states ( jones matrices ) of light . the oqc @xmath27 qubits can be represented by @xmath28 polarized light modes i.e. , @xmath29 jones matrices [ 9 ] . but in ssqc we need @xmath30 nuclear spins to have @xmath31 quantum states . pbs are required for separating horizontal and vertical polarization components of the laser mode . for performing the logical operations . for example , the logical operations not and cnot can be implemented by using the pbs . mathematically , linear optics logical gates can be constructed by using @xmath32 and @xmath33 algebra [ 3 ] . experimentally , it can be constructed by rotating the pbs ( see fig.2 ) . the proposal to construct logical gates based on nonlinear optics is given by milburn [ 6,2 ] . this oqc uses nonlinear crystal to get the squeezed states of light ( ssl ) . as we know the ssl has antibunching property i.e. , the photons are uniformally distrubuted as compared to the coherent state of light . by using the antibunching property of ssl , this computer can in the case of ssl , the role of qubits perform the photons of ssl i.e. , each photon of ssl represents , one optical qubit based on nonlinear optics . to operate on each photon qubit , we need photo - detectors with high quantum efficieny , which are our dream of future . moreover , in quantum mechanics , we detect the average number of physical quantities . it means , we do not have @xmath34 gurantee that we have detected the concrete photon , which we planned . again , we need the beam splitters to perform the logical operations , which are highly noisy . oqc can be constructed at least on one nonlinear crystal . it means that @xmath1 number of laser beams are propagating through one nonlinear crytal ( see fig . 2 ) . why we are using nonlinear crystal ? there are some advantages to use nonlinear crytals : 1 . logical gates ( not and cnot ) can be performed by using the rds ( regular domain structure ) crystals . 2 . we can use the property of squeezed states of light , i.e. , the quantum noise is less as compare to the coherent state of light . 3 . rds crystals are independent on heating [ 4 ] of the crystals . we can use this crystal without any cooling process , which will not delay our computation process . 4 . . there are two ways to perform the logical operations in rds crystals . 1 . by using the properties of bistable switches i.e. , the logical switch starts working when the intensity of the coherent laser beam ( fundamental mode ) propagating through the rds crystal starts producing the predefined intensity of harmonic generation for some concrete logical operation . 2 . since , the rds crystals can produce at a time multiple number of harmonic modes . we can predefine each harmonic for logic operations . for example , we can predefind second harmonic generation for not and third harmonic generation for cnot logical operations . if we will compare the properties of ssqc and oqc , we can conclude that the future of oqc is practically absent . due to the requirement of huge number of optical components ( linear and nonlinear ) , heating of the linear and nonlinear crystals and quantum noise is greater than the coherent state of light . the proposal which we have offered i.e. , the construction of oqc on rds crytals require less number of components as compare to linear and nonlinear ( ordinary ) crystals . moreover , we can construct the logical gates on one rds crytals with lesser quantum noise , because we are performing all the logic operations in it as compare to the linear and nonlinear crystals [ 2,3,5,9 ] . so , the oqc based on rds is more realistic as compare to other proposals to construct oqc . 99 _ n.g.basov el . _ , kvantovaya electronika , 5 , 526 ( 1978 ) _ d.bouwmeester , a.ekert,and a.zeilinger_ , the physics of quantum information , springer : berlin ( 2000 ) _ a.v.burlakov et . a , 60 , r4209 ( 1999 ) _ m.m.fejer et . al . _ , ieee j. of quantum electronics , 28 , 2631 ( 1992 ) _ g.j.milburn_ , phys . a , 62 , 2124 ( 1989 ) _ new physical principles of optical processing information _ , ed . s.a.akhmanov and m.a.vorontsov , moscow : nauka ( 1990 ) ( in russian ) _ k.preston_ , coherent optical computers , ny : mcgraw - hill ( 1972 ) _ proceedings of ieee _ , vol . 72 ( 1984 ) _ r.spreeuw_ , arxiv : quant - ph/0009066 _ m.b.mensky_ , quantum measurements and decoherence , north holland : kluwer academic publishers ( 2000 )

we have proposed the construction of optical quantum computer ( oqc ) on regular domain structure ( rds ) crystal . by using rds crystal , we can perform all the logical operations on one rds crystal . moreover , rds crystals are parctically independent to the heating effects [ 4 ] i.e. , can perform logic operations constantly without cooling the rds crystal [ 4 ] . also , we have proposed the quantum parallelsim i.e. , parallel coherent laser beams are injected at the input of the rds crystals . by using the rds crystal we can perform the reduce the requirements of the linear and nonlinear optical components . * optical quantum computer based on rds crystal + * z. sazonova + physics department , automobile @xmath0 road - construction institute ( technical university ) 64 , leningradskii prospect , moscow 125829 , russia + r. singh + wave research center at general physics institute of russian academy of sciences , 38 , vavilov street , moscow 117942 , russia tel./fax : ( + 7 095 ) 135 - 8234 email : ranjit@dataforce.net +

0805.2099

the existence of absolutely continuous invariant probability measures ( _ acip _ s ) for dynamical systems is a problem with a history going back more than 70 years , see for example pioneering papers by hopf @xcite and ulam and von neumann @xcite . notwithstanding an extensive amount of research in this direction in the last two or three decades , the problem is still not completely solved even in the one - dimensional setting which is the focus of this paper . quite general conditions are known which guarantee the existence of _ acip _ s for uniformly expanding maps in the smooth case or possibly admitting singularities , i.e. discontinuities with possibly unbounded derivatives ( see @xcite@xcite for additional remarks and references ) , and for smooth maps with a finite number of critical points ( see @xcite for first and strongest results including decay of correlations , and @xcite for the most recent and possibly the most general conditions for the existence of absolutely continuous invariant measures in this setting ) and even for smooth maps with a countable number of critical points @xcite . we are interested here in a general class of maps which contain critical points _ and _ singularities . a natural family of maps belonging to this class was introduced in @xcite and motivated by the study of the return map of the lorenz equations near classical parameter values , see figure 1 . it is clear from the arguments in these papers , that the presence of both critical points and singularities and their interaction can give rise to significant technical as well as fundamental issues . in particular , as we shall see in the present setting , it is not enough to have just some expansivity conditions in order to obtain the existence of an acip , as expansivity might occur due to the regions of unbounded derivative even when the deeper dynamical structure of the map is very pathological . moreover , it is possible that the interaction of critical points and singularities could give rise to new phenomena which are still unexplored . some general results for the existence of _ acip _ s and their properties in maps with critical points and singularities were obtained in @xcite under the assumption that _ lebesgue almost every point _ satisfy some exponential derivative growth and subexponential recurrence conditions . these conditions provide an interesting conceptual picture but may be hard to verify in practice . on the other hand , it was proved in @xcite @xcite that with positive probability in the parameter space of lorenz - like families , the orbits of the _ critical points _ satisfy such exponential derivative growth and subexponential recurrence conditions . in @xcite it was shown , within a more general setting of maps with multiple critical points and singularities , that these conditions are in fact sufficient to guarantee the existence of an ergodic _ acip _ ( from which it can in fact be proved that lebesgue almost every point also satisfies such conditions ) . our aim in this paper is to obtain the same conclusion but relax as much as possible the conditions on the orbit of the critical points , to include in particular cases in which the derivative growth may be subexponential and/or the recurrence of the critical points exponential . a crucial observation concerning the difference between the smooth case and the case with singularities discussed here is that in the smooth case , for which in particular the derivative is bounded , any condition on the growth of the derivative is also implicitly a condition on the recurrence to the critical set . indeed sufficiently strong recurrence to the critical set will always kill off any required derivative growth . on the other hand , this is not the case in our setting . derivative growth may be exponential but arise as a consequence of very strong recurrence to the singularities even if we have at the same time very strong recurrence to the critical set . strong recurrence to either the singular or the critical set brings its own deep structural problems and can be an intrinsic obstruction to the existence of an _ acip_. we shall formulate below a condition which simultaneously keeps track of the growth of the derivative along critical orbits and of the recurrence of such orbits to the critical set within a single summability condition . this optimizes the result to include a larger class of maps than would be possible by having to independent conditions both of which need to be satisfied . we conjecture that it is not possible to obtain a general result on the existence of acip s in the presence of both critical points and singularities by assuming only conditions on the derivative growth of critical points . we now give the precise statement of our result . we let @xmath0 denote the class of interval map satisfying the conditions formulated in sections [ c1 ] , [ c2 ] and [ c3 ] below . then we have the following [ th : physical ] every map @xmath1 admits a finite number of absolutely continuous invariant ( physical ) probability measures whose basins cover @xmath2 up to a set of measure 0 . let @xmath3 be an interval and @xmath4 be a piecewise @xmath5 map : by this we mean that there exists a finite set @xmath6 such that @xmath7 is @xmath8 and monotone on each connected component of @xmath9 and admits a continuous extension to the boundary so that @xmath10 exists . we denote by @xmath11 the set of all `` one - sided critical points '' @xmath12 and @xmath13 and define corresponding one - sided neighbourhoods @xmath14 for each @xmath15 . for simplicity , from now on we use @xmath16 to represent the generic element of @xmath11 and write @xmath17 for @xmath18 . we assume that each @xmath19 has a well - defined ( one - sided ) critical order @xmath20 in the sense that @xmath21 for all @xmath22 in some @xmath23 . note that we say that @xmath24 if the ratio @xmath25 is bounded above and below uniformly in the stated domain . if @xmath26 we say that @xmath27 is a _ singular _ point as this implies unbounded derivative near @xmath27 ; if @xmath28 we say that @xmath27 is a _ critical _ point as this implies that the derivative tends to @xmath29 near @xmath27 . we shall assume also that @xmath30 for every @xmath27 as this would be a degenerate case which is not hard to deal with but would require having to introduce special notation and special cases , whereas the other cases can all be dealt with in a unified formalism . for future reference we point out that this immediately implies @xmath31 for all @xmath32 , where @xmath33 denotes the distance of the point @xmath32 to the critical / singular set @xmath34 ( indeed this is the actual property of which we will make use ) . we suppose that @xmath35 is `` uniformly expanding away from the critical points '' , meaning that the following two conditions are satisfied : there exists a constant @xmath36 , independent of @xmath37 , such that for every point @xmath32 and every integer @xmath38 such that @xmath39 for all @xmath40 and @xmath41 we have @xmath42 and , for every @xmath15 there exist constants @xmath43 and @xmath44 such that latexmath:[\[\label{eq : ue } @xmath22 and @xmath46 such that @xmath39 for all @xmath40 . we remark that both these conditions are quite natural and are often satisfied for smooth maps without discontinuities . more specifically , the first one is satisfied if @xmath7 is @xmath47 , has negative schwarzian derivative and satisfies the property that the the derivative along all critical orbits tends to infinity , see theorem 1.3 in @xcite . the second is satisfied in even greater generality , namely when @xmath35 is @xmath48 and all periodic points are repelling @xcite . for each @xmath49 we write @xmath50 to denote the derivative along the orbit of @xmath27 and the distance of @xmath27 from the critical set respectively . we then assume that for every critical point @xmath27 with @xmath51 we have @xmath52 this condition plays off the derivative against the recurrence in such a way as to optimize to some extent the class of maps to which it applies . as mentioned in section [ sumcon ] above , we can not expect to obtain the conclusions of our main theorem in this setting using a condition which only takes into account the growth of the derivative . notice that condition ( @xmath53 ) is satisfied if the derivative is growing exponentially fast and the recurrence is not faster than exponential in the sense that @xmath54 here and in the rest of the paper , the symbol @xmath55 means that the inequality holds up to some multiplicative constant , i.e. there exists a constant @xmath56 independent of @xmath57 or any other constants , such that @xmath58 and @xmath59 . our strategy for the proof is to construct a countable partition @xmath60 of @xmath61 ( mod 0 ) into open intervals , define an inducing time function @xmath62 which is constant on elements of @xmath60 , and let @xmath63 denote the induced map defined by @xmath64 this induced map is uniformly expanding on each element of @xmath65 but does _ not _ have many desirable properties such as uniformly bounded distortion or long branches . nevertheless it has the two key properties we shall require which are summable inducing times and summable variation . we recall that the _ variation _ of a function @xmath66 over a subinterval @xmath67 $ ] of @xmath3 is defined by @xmath68 and all choices of points @xmath69 . for each @xmath70 we define the function @xmath71 by @xmath72 our main technical result in this paper is the following there exists a countable partition @xmath60 of @xmath61 ( mod 0 ) and an inducing time function @xmath62 , constant on elements of @xmath60 , such that the induced map @xmath73 is uniformly expanding and satisfies the the following properties . 1 . ( summable variation ) @xmath74 2 . ( summable inducing times ) @xmath75 theorem 1 implies the main theorem by known arguments . indeed , by a result of rychlik the summable variation property together with uniform expansion implies that @xmath76 admits a finite number of ergodic absolutely continuous invariant measure whose basins cover @xmath2 up to a set of measure zero @xcite . by standard arguments the summable inducing time property implies that these measures can be pulled back to a absolutely continuous invariant probability measure for the original map @xmath7 satisfying the same properties @xcite . the arguments used in @xcite also involve the construction of an induced map with summable return times , but in those papers the induced map has some very strong properties such as uniformly bounded distortion and the gibbs - markov property ( the image of each partition element maps diffeomorphically to the entire domain of definition of the induced map ) . to achieve these properties a quite complicated construction is required , involving the inductive definition of an infinite number of finer and finer partitions together with a combinatorial and probabilistic argument showing that the procedure eventually converges . besides the fact that we deal here with a significantly larger class of systems , a major difference is the construction of an induced map satisfying a different set of conditions as formalized in the summable variation property stated in the theorem . these induced maps do not necessarily have bounded distortion and there is no uniform lower bound for the size of the images . for this reason the construction of these induced maps is * much * simpler , and in fact can be fully achieved in less than two pages of text in the following section . the rest of the paper is just devoted to checking the required properties . the induced map @xmath77 can in fact be defined in complete generality with essentially no assumptions on the map @xmath7 . we will only require our assumptions to show that this induced map has the desired properties . for a point @xmath32 in the neighbourhood @xmath78 of one of the critical points @xmath27 , we let @xmath79 for an arbitrary interval @xmath2 we let @xmath80 denote the length of @xmath2 and @xmath81 denote it s distance to the critical set @xmath82 , i.e. the minimum distance of all point in @xmath2 to @xmath34 . for each critical point @xmath27 with @xmath83 , and every integer @xmath84 we let @xmath85 it follows immediately from the summability condition ( @xmath53 ) that @xmath86 given @xmath87,we define the _ binding period _ of a point @xmath88 as follows . if @xmath89 we just define the binding period as @xmath90 . otherwise we define the binding period as the _ smallest _ @xmath91 such that @xmath92 and @xmath93 , define @xmath94 to be the interval of points @xmath95 such that @xmath96 . observe that from the definition of binding it follows immediately that @xmath97 _ monotonically _ when @xmath98 . notice also that the interval @xmath94 may be empty and indeed that is the case , for instance , for all @xmath99 . using the monotonicity of @xmath101 we can fix at this moment and for the rest of the paper @xmath100 sufficiently small so that 1 . the critical neighbourhood of size @xmath100 of all critical / singular points are disjoint and the images of the critical / singular neighbourhoods are also disjoint from the critical / singular neighbourhoods themselves ; 2 . @xmath102 for all @xmath103 ; 3 . @xmath104 for all @xmath105 . the symbol @xmath106 here means that @xmath107 must be larger than some constant factor of @xmath108 for a constant which depends only on the map itself and which is determined in the course of the proof but which could in principle we specified explicitly at this point . we now fix an integer @xmath110 sufficiently large so that @xmath111 notice that the constants @xmath112 and @xmath113 come from the expansion outside the critical neighbourhoods given in section [ c2 ] . the choice of @xmath109 is motivated by the fact that any finite piece of orbit longer than @xmath109 iterations staying outside a @xmath100 neighbourhood of the critical points has an accumulated derivative of at least 2 . let @xmath114 so that @xmath115 denotes the set of points of @xmath61 which remain outside @xmath116 for the first @xmath117 iterations , and @xmath118 denotes those which enter @xmath119 at some time before @xmath120 . for @xmath121 let @xmath122 so that @xmath123 is the first time the orbit of @xmath32 enters @xmath119 and @xmath124 denotes the binding period corresponding to the point @xmath125 . then we define the inducing time by @xmath126 we define the induced map as @xmath127 and let @xmath128 denote the partition of @xmath3 into the maximal intervals restricted to which the induced map @xmath129 is smooth , and write @xmath130 and @xmath131 . this completes the definitions of the induced map . in this section we prove a general formula relating the variation , the distortion and the expansion . first of all we define the notion of _ generalized distortion_. this is a very natural notion which is no more difficult to compute than standard distortion and which appears in variation calculations . strangely it does not seem to us to have been defined before in the literature . for any interval @xmath2 and integer @xmath132 we let @xmath133 for @xmath134 and define the _ ( generalized ) distortion _ @xmath135 we remark here that we are taking the supremum over all choices of sequences @xmath136 . if these sequences are chosen so that @xmath137 for some @xmath138 then we recover the more standard notion of distortion . in particular , by choosing the sequence @xmath139 arbitrary and the sequence @xmath140 as the actual orbit of a point , we can compare the two products and , in this case , the definition given above of generalized distortion immediately implies @xmath141 for any @xmath142 . for future reference we remark also that by the mean value theorem , there exists some @xmath143 such that @xmath144 therefore we have @xmath145 we are now ready to state the main result of this section . [ le : varest ] for any interval @xmath146 and integer @xmath147 such that @xmath148 is a diffeomorphism , we have @xmath149 before starting the proof we recall a few elementary properties of functions with bounded variation which will be used here and later on . proofs can be found , for instance , in @xcite or @xcite . for any interval @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 , 1 . @xmath153 ; 2 . @xmath154 ; 3 . @xmath155 ; 4 . @xmath156 if @xmath157 is a homeomorphism ; 5 . if @xmath158 is of class @xmath159 then @xmath160 . 6 . for any interval @xmath161 , any bounded variation function @xmath158 , and any probability @xmath162 on @xmath161 , @xmath163 in particular , this holds when @xmath164 normalized lebesgue measure on @xmath161 . we start by writing @xmath165 = { \operatornamewithlimits{var}}_{i}\left[\left(\frac{1}{df}\circ f^{l-1 } \right ) \left(\prod_{j=0}^{l-2 } \frac{1}{df}\circ f^{j } \right)\right]\ ] ] thus , from ( v3 ) we have @xmath166 since the supremum of the product is clearly less than or equal to the product of the supremums this gives @xmath167 thus , multiplying and dividing through by both the first and last term of the right hand side of this expression , we get @xmath168\ ] ] we have used here the simplified notation @xmath169^{-1 } $ ] to denote @xmath170^{-1}\circ f^{j } $ ] . using this bound recursively we get @xmath171\ ] ] and therefore , substituting into we get @xmath172\ ] ] continuing in this way and and then using ( v4 ) we arrive at @xmath173 = \left(\prod_{j=0}^{l-1 } \sup_{i_{j } } \frac{1}{|df|}\right ) \left [ \sum_{j=0}^{l-1 } \frac{{\operatornamewithlimits{var}}_{i_{j}}\frac{1}{df } } { \sup_{i_{j } } \frac{1}{|df| } } \right]\ ] ] from the definition of generalized distortion , in particular , this gives @xmath174 \leq \frac{\mathcal d(f^{l } , i)}{\inf_{i}|df^{l}| } \left [ \sum_{j=0}^{l-1 } \frac{{\operatornamewithlimits{var}}_{i_{j}}\frac{1}{df } } { \sup_{i_{j } } \frac{1}{|df| } } \right].\ ] ] finally from ( v5 ) and we get @xmath175 [ le : distorcao ] for any @xmath176 , @xmath177 , the critical point closest to @xmath32 , @xmath178 , and any @xmath179 we have @xmath180 in particular there exists @xmath181 independent of @xmath32 such that for all @xmath182 we have @xmath183 and for all @xmath184 $ ] we have @xmath185 the definition of binding period is designed to guarantee that the length @xmath186 of the interval @xmath187 is small compared to its distance @xmath188 to the critical set . indeed , from the definition we have @xmath189 and therefore , for every @xmath190 we have @xmath191 in particular this also implies , from the order of the critical points , that @xmath192 and @xmath193 and therefore @xmath194 where @xmath195 means that the bound holds up to a multiplicative constant independent of @xmath196 or @xmath197 . now , from and we have @xmath198 the right hand side is uniformly bounded by the summability of the @xmath199 s . indeed , taking logs and using the inequality @xmath200 for all @xmath201 we get @xmath202 this proves the uniform bound on the distortion @xmath203 . the fact that @xmath204 then follows directly from the definition of @xmath205 and the fact that it is uniformly bounded . finally notice that @xmath206 and therefore the required bound follows from . the partition @xmath60 is defined quite abstractly and we do not have direct information about the sizes of the partition elements and in particular the relation between their sizes and their distances to the critical set . however , using the distortion bounds obtained above , we can prove the following [ distreturn ] let @xmath207 with @xmath208 and @xmath2 in the neighbourhood of a critical point with order @xmath209 . then @xmath210 in particular , letting @xmath211 denote the order of the critical / singular point closest to @xmath212 we have @xmath213 ^{\frac { 2(\ell - 1)}{2\ell-1 } } \lesssim d(c_{p-1})^ { \frac{2(\ell - 1)(\ell_{p-1}-1)}{2\ell-1 } } \ ] ] and @xmath214 ^{\frac { 2(\ell - 1)}{2\ell-1 } } \lesssim \log d(c_{p-1})^{-1}.\ ] ] we remark that the distortion not uniformly bounded in @xmath215 implying that the induced map does not have uniformly bounded distortion . notice also that for some values of @xmath215 it may happen that @xmath216 ; in this case the corresponding interval @xmath2 would necessarily be empty , i.e. there is no @xmath32 with binding period @xmath215 . from lemma [ le : distorcao ] and the definition of binding period we have , for any @xmath142 , @xmath217^{1/\ell } \geq [ d_{p-1}^{-1}\gamma_{p}d(c_{p})]^{1/\ell}\ ] ] and @xmath218^{1/\ell } \leq [ d_{p-2}^{-1}\gamma_{p-1 } d(c_{p-1})]^{1/\ell}\ ] ] by taking a sufficiently small @xmath100 we can assume that @xmath215 is sufficiently large so that @xmath219 and therefore , from the definition of the sequence @xmath220 we get @xmath221 thus , substituting into the expressions above gives @xmath222^{1/\ell } = [ d_{p-1 } d_{p-1}^{-1/(2\ell-1)}]^{1\ell } = [ d_{p-1}^{-2\ell/(2\ell-1)}]^{1/\ell } = d_{p-1}^{-2/(2\ell-1)}\ ] ] and , similarly , @xmath223 this gives the first set of inequalities . as a consequence we immediately get @xmath224 and therefore , @xmath225 ^{\frac { 2(\ell - 1)}{2\ell-1}}\ ] ] this gives the first inequality in . to get the second inequality we simply use the fact that @xmath226 . to get the last inequality we simply integrate @xmath227 over the interval @xmath228 to get @xmath229^{2/(2\ell-1)}\ ] ] and then argue as above . [ le : london1 ] for all @xmath87 , @xmath95 and @xmath230 , we have latexmath:[\[\label{eq1:london1 } choose @xmath100 small enough so that @xmath232 using the chain rule , bounded distortion in binding periods and lemma [ distreturn ] we have @xmath233 this gives . the inequality @xmath234 then just follows from the choice of @xmath235 in section [ fixdelta ] . [ le : supzero ] for every @xmath236 we have @xmath237 this follows immediately from the definition of the induced map and the expansion estimates during binding periods obtained in lemma [ le : london1 ] together with conditions [ kappa ] and [ eq : ue ] , the choice of @xmath100 and the corresponding choice of @xmath109 . we now study the distortion of the induced map @xmath77 on each of its branches . [ le : globaldist ] there exists a constant @xmath238 such that @xmath239 for all @xmath240 ( in which case @xmath241 ) and @xmath242 ( in which case @xmath243 ) respectively , where @xmath209 is the order of the critical point associated to @xmath244 . also , we have @xmath245 and @xmath246 respectively for @xmath240 and @xmath247 . for @xmath248 we have standard distortion estimates for uniformly expanding maps which give a uniform distortion bound @xmath249 depending on the size of @xmath119 . for @xmath250 on the other hand we write @xmath251 the first term consists of iterates for which @xmath252 lies always outside @xmath119 and therefore is bounded above by the same constant @xmath253 as above . the second and third term have already been estimated above in lemmas [ le : distorcao ] and [ distreturn ] . combining these estimates we complete the first set of estimates . for @xmath240 , using the uniform expansion outside @xmath119 we have @xmath254 for @xmath242 we again split the sum into three parts corresponding to the initial iterates outside @xmath119 , the first iterate in @xmath119 , and the following binding period . the fist part of the sum is bounded by the same constant @xmath249 as above . the second and third have already been estimated above . thus , from lemmas [ le : distorcao ] and [ distreturn ] and in particular we get the statement . we are now ready to prove the summable variation and the summable inducing time properties . from the definition of @xmath255 that we have @xmath256 for the supremum we have , from lemma [ le : supzero ] , @xmath257 and for the variation , we have , substituting the estimates in , and into the formula obtained in lemma [ le : varest ] , @xmath258 we can write @xmath259 and @xmath260 and so , substituting above , gives @xmath261 to prove the summability of the inducing time notice first of all that the number of intervals of a given inducing time is uniformly bounded . therefore it is sufficient to prove the summability with respect to the binding time . for this we give a basic upper bound for the size of each element @xmath263 using the mean value theorem and lemma [ le : supzero ] . this gives @xmath264 again , the summability follows directly from @xmath262 . this completes the proof of the theorem . notice that there is a significant gap between the first bound and the second bound in , particularly in the special case in which there are no singularities and where therefore @xmath265 for every critical point . in this case we get @xmath266 this leaves only an extremely mild condition on the recurrence of the critical points and therefore the summability conditions reduces almost to the condition @xmath267 assumed for smooth maps in @xcite . ideally we would therefore like to replace condition @xmath262 by the summability condition @xmath268 which would automatically reduce to the condition @xmath269 in the smooth case . this however gives rise to technical difficulties that we have not been able to overcome , mainly in the definition of the sequence @xmath270 , recall . condition @xmath271 does not imply the summability of the @xmath270 with the definition given in and on the other hand , changing the definition of @xmath270 to something more natural in terms of @xmath272 , such as for example @xmath273 gives rise to additional complications in the calculations and estimates related to the binding period in section [ s : binding ] . it is not clear to us whether these are superficial difficulties which can be overcome or whether they reflect deeper issues .

we prove that , under a mild summability condition on the growth of the derivative on critical orbits any piecewise monotone interval map possibly containing discontinuities and singularities with infinite derivative ( cusp map ) admits an ergodic invariant probability measures which is absolutely continuous with respect to lebesgue measure .

physics0612174

at large scale facilities for neutron and x - ray scattering , large quantities of experimental data are produced . for complex , nanoscale systems , understanding this data requires computer models . in the case of inelastic scattering , molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations @xcite are widely used to equilibrate structures and explore dynamics as a function of temperature and other experimental parameters . however md only gives a partial description of vibrational modes through the partial density of states and when knowledge about specific vibrational modes is required , normal mode analysis ( nma ) @xcite has to be performed . for physics and materials science problems , nma gives a description of the lattice dynamics via the dispersion ( k - vector dependence ) of the mode frequencies @xcite . for small systems ( @xmath0 200 atoms in the simulation box ) very accurate results can be obtained using density functional theory ( dft ) methods to determine interatomic force constants @xcite . by combining dft and software that constructs and diagonalises the dynamical matrix and calculates the experimental observables , experimentalists now have sophisticated tools to analyse their data . the phonon @xcite package is one of the best examples . phonon codes are traditionally limited to small systems for a number of reasons . for example , for small unit cells , the reciprocal lattice is big and stronger effects of dispersion are expected . if dft methods are used to determine force constants then these methods are themselves restricted to a few hundred atoms . however the development of nanoscale structures of ( partially ) crystalline materials stimulates a need for phonon codes to be extended to much larger systems . parameterised force fields @xcite can be used to determine the inter - atomic force constants and , as will be seen in the example presented here , strong dispersion effects are observed inspite of the small reciprocal lattice . in biomolecular systems , the need for nma has long been recognised and codes like charmm @xcite allow the gamma point normal modes to be calculated for moderately big systems . in addition , the neutron scattering quantities can be directly calculated from the simulations using the time - correlation function formalism @xcite , as implemented in the nmoldyn program @xcite . a combination of neuton scattering experiments and atomic detail computer simulations has proven to be a powerful technique for studying internal molecular vibrations @xcite . in this approach one can validate the applied numerical models , i.e. force field parametrizations , depending on the agreement between the experimental and calculated spectra . in this paper we present a software package that extends the functionality of codes like phonon @xcite and climax @xcite to arbitrarily large systems and extends the gamma point only analysis already available for larger systems to include k - vector dependence . the software reads a hessian matrix of force constants , constructs and diagonalises the dynamical matrix for any k - vector and calculates neutron and x - ray scattering observables . the computational bottleneck remains the diagonalisation of correspondingly large dynamical matrices and we comment on approximations that have to be used when the brillouin zone can not be sampled at a large number of points . in large systems , atomistic detail in the displacement vectors can be difficult to interpret due to the large number of degrees of freedom and we present two methods for simplifying this information . the first entails summing displacement vectors over atoms in user - defined beads , while the second involves a reduction of the degrees of freedom in the dynamical matrix by summing over force constants , which has the advantage of reducing the number of modes to be examined . the standard approach , also called a direct method @xcite , to the lattice vibration problem of crystals is based on the explicit knowledge of the interaction between all atom - pairs in the system . subsequently , one deduces the corresponding force constants , and constructs and diagonalizes the dynamical matrix for any k - vector in order to obtain the frequencies of the normal modes . a reasonable atomic detail description of interactions within large biomolecular systems are provided using empirical force fields . in the following we will briefly summarize the aspects of the classical theory of lattice vibrations @xcite and proceed to the description of the explicit phonon calculations . the individual atomic positions in the crystal can be assigned as @xmath1 where @xmath2 is unit cell lattice vector and @xmath3 is displacement of atom @xmath4 from its equilibrium positions @xmath5 . within the harmonic approximation we concentrate on expansion of the small differences of potential energy @xmath6 due to the small changes in atom positions : @xmath7 where the second derivative defines the force constant between the atoms @xmath4 and @xmath8 : @xmath9 as each unit cell is identical to every other unit cell in the crystal , the displacement pattern of a normal mode has to be identical to that in any other cell to within a phase difference @xmath10 . the representation of the atom displacement is chosen to be a plain wave ansatz of the form : @xmath11 ) , \label{le2}\ ] ] where @xmath12 is the polarization vector and @xmath13 is the mass of the atom @xmath4 . we omit writing cartesian component subscripts . solving the equation of motion with ansatz ( [ le2 ] ) is equivalent to the eigen - value problem @xmath14 where @xmath15 \label{le4}\ ] ] is the so called dynamical matrix . the form of the dynamical matrix ( [ le4 ] ) requires the atom pairs for which one atom belongs to a different unit cell , _ i.e. _ @xmath16 , to be identified . these terms contribute to the so called bloch - factor @xmath17 $ ] and make the dynamical matrix complex . but in case of applying periodic boundary conditions ( pbc ) as implemented in computer simulation programs , the potential energy of a crystal is given as an explicit function of only the atom positions in the primary unit cell . as a consequence , we obtain the second derivative matrix @xmath18 in which the contributions from the inter - cell atomic pairs are mapped and added to the corresponding image atom pairs in the primary unit cell : @xmath19\to{\bf h}_{\mu,\nu}= \frac{\partial^2 v^{pbc}}{\partial u_{\mu}\partial u_{\nu } } \label{le5}\ ] ] one can directly obtain @xmath20 by increasing the size of the unit cell by one or more layers of periodically arranged image cells and calculate force constants in the extended supercell . however , this approach is unfavourable when dealing with very large systems . a similar approach is to decompose the potential energy @xmath21 in equation ( [ le5 ] ) into individual contributions from the image cells , @xmath22 and evaluate the second derivative matrix for each term upon the same minimized structure . the situation is simpler if the interaction is truncated at some cutoff distance @xmath23 so that the `` minimum image convention '' ( mic ) is obeyed . the mic states that each atom interacts at most with one image of every other atom in the system ( which is repeated to fully enclose the primary unit cell with the periodic boundary conditions ) . this has the effect of limiting the interaction cutoff , for example , to no more than half the length of the minimum side when simulating the orthorhombic cell , @xmath24 . it should be noted that the size of nanoscale crystals usually far exceeds the spatial range of forces between atoms ( @xmath25 @xmath012 ) allowing physically reasonable cutoff radii to be introduced . ( hollow blue circle ) and @xmath4 ( full black circle ) is larger than the cut - off distance ( red circle around the atom @xmath4 ) , and if the force constant @xmath26 turns out to be nonzero , it means that the value of @xmath26 has to be related to the atom @xmath8 in the image cell @xmath27 ( full blue circle ) , with the position vector @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) , instead of to the atom @xmath30 in the primary cell @xmath31 . the corresponding lattice translation vector @xmath32 is thus determined for the element @xmath33.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] according to the mic we can conclude that there is always only one translation @xmath34 per atom pair @xmath35 giving rise to the minimum distance @xmath36 : @xmath37 where @xmath38 are lattice translation vectors , c.f . [ fg1 ] . in the case of a nonvanishing @xmath39 we get the following expression for a dynamical matrix element @xmath40 according to equation ( [ le3 ] ) the diagonalization of matrix @xmath41 yields the phonon frequencies @xmath42 and corresponding polarization vectors @xmath43 for a given phonon wave vector @xmath44 . a complete solution leads to the phonon dispersion relations . the subscript @xmath45 denotes a branch in the phonon dispersion . in a crystal of @xmath46 atoms , there are @xmath47 branches . 0.2 cm * inelastic scattering * 0.2 cm the dynamic structure factor @xmath48 contains information about the structure and dynamics of the sample . it can be split into a coherent part arising from the cross - correlations of atomic motions and an incoherent part describing self - correlations of single atom motions . according to the standard theory @xcite , which is based on the harmonic approximation , we obtain the following expressions for the coherent and incoherent dynamical structure factors : @xmath49 and @xmath50\delta(\omega-\omega_{\vec kj}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath51 is the scattering vector , @xmath52 is the corresponding atomic scattering length , @xmath53 refers to the phonon creation process ( absorption spectrum ) and @xmath54 is the mean number of phonons of frequency @xmath55 at temperature @xmath56 according to the bose - einstein statistics @xmath57 the factor @xmath58 $ ] is called the debye - waller factor : @xmath59 where @xmath60 is a @xmath61 symmetric tensor representing the thermodynamic mean square displacement of an atom @xmath4 , which can be expressed by the partial atomic phonon density of states @xmath62 : @xmath63 the partial atomic density of states is a weighted distribution of normal modes @xmath64 where @xmath31 is the number of sampling @xmath44-points in the first brillouin zone . the evaluation of the debye - waller @xmath65 factors using equation ( [ le6 ] ) requires extra attention due to the `` zero - phonon '' term resulting from the singularity caused by phonon ( acoustic ) branches where @xmath66 . the contributions of the 3 acoustic modes is treated separately by using the debye approximation for the density of states , _ i.e. _ @xmath67 , and normalization @xmath68 , where @xmath69 is the maximum frequency up to which the acoustic dispersion curve is linear @xmath70.\end{aligned}\ ] ] a new variable @xmath71 was introduced in the last equation . for systems containing thousands of atoms ( n ) the displacement vectors obtained by diagonalising the dynamical matrix can be difficult to understand , especially for low frequency modes which involve the displacement of many ( or all ) atoms . one simple solution to this problem is to sum over the displacements of atoms within beads , which represent logical coarse grains of the system , for example base molecules in the dna example below . this treatment allows different bead definitions to be applied to the calculated displacement vectors but has the disadvantage of not reducing the number of displacement vectors from 3n . a related approach is to reduce the atomic level hessian matrix to lower dimension by mapping the inter - atomic force constants on to inter - bead force constants @xcite . for n beads , the resulting dynamical matrices have dimension 3n and therefore result in 3n displacement vectors for any k - vector . we note that any reduction in the dimensionality of the system causes a loss in information , which is the rotational degrees of freedom of the beads ( rigid bodies ) . to verify the implemented formalism we have simulated a b - form dna molecule ( right - handed , 10 base - pairs per turn , pitch 33.6 ) using charmm @xcite . the full crystal environment was generated using periodic boundary conditions for an orthorhombic unit cell containing one helix of dna . the dimension of the unit cell is @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 , with @xmath75 parallel to the helical axis . the starting configuration was obtained by minimization of the potential energy of the crystal structure obtained as the time average over a 1ns md simulation at 100k . the hessian matrix of force constants was generated by displacing each atom in turn from equilibrium and calculating the forces induced on all other atoms . diagonalisation of the resulting dynamical matrices was performed using the the routine ` zcheev ` from the lapack library @xcite . is varied along the helical axis ( 0,0,1 ) . shown are @xmath76@xmath77.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] the typical coherent spectrum of dna , figure [ fg2 ] , obtained from equation [ eqn_coh ] , shows a well - defined brillouin peak at small @xmath55 which moves along the frequency dimension upon varying momentum transfer @xmath51 . fitting the spectral profile with a gaussian as a function of wave - vector gives the dispersion curve shown in figure [ fg3 ] , which compares well with the recent experimental results @xcite . figure [ fg3 ] also shows the result of the equivalent analysis of a 300k md simulation on the same model of b - dna using nmoldyn . in order to gain insight into the nature of low frequency dynamics we can analyse the displacement vectors at an atomic level ( see figure [ fg5](a ) for an acoustic mode ) . by summing over the displacement vectors in terms of beads , where base molecules , sugar molecules and phosphate groups are treated as single units , a simplified picture of the normal modes is obtained . figure [ fg5](b ) shows a high frequency mode which has a pronounced contribution from the phosphate groups . the new , user - friendly computational package ` nmscatt ` presented here enable an efficient atomic detail analysis of different types of inelastic scattering applied to arbitrarily large nanoscale systems . the ability to perform molecular dynamics and phonon calculations on large nano and bio - molecular materials means that one can efficiently pursue the investigation of some poorly understood structural and dynamical features of these systems . the authors are grateful to dr . stephane rols for helpful discussions at the start of this project . mj acknowledges a long - standing collaboration with prof . krzysztof parlinski . fm acknowledges a financial support from ill during his stay in grenoble and support from the ministry of higher education , science and technology of republic of slovenia under grant nos . p1 - 0002 , j1 - 6331 and j1 - 5115 . there are four main modules in the ` nmscatt ` program package _ phonon , coh , incoh _ and _ bead _ , and the overall ` nmscatt ` structure is given in figure [ fg6 ] . below are described the corresponding modules . * _ phonon _ : providing the full hessian matrix for a given energy - minimized atomic structure within the specified crystallographic unit cell this module constructs dynamical matrix and calculates its eigenvalues and eigenvectors at given wave vector @xmath44 . at input this module requires to specify the bravais lattice vectors that were previously used in the molecular mechanics / dynamics simulation package to satisfy the periodic boundary conditions while generating the minimized structure . the cut - off radius must be given at which the long range interactions are truncated while calculating the hessian matrix in the simulation . at output two separate files ` eig_val_`@xmath31 and ` eig_vec_`@xmath31 are written containing eigenvalues and eigenvectors , respectively , where @xmath31 assigns a consecutive number of the sampling @xmath78-point in the first brillouin zone . these files serve as an imput for other modules of ` nmscatt ` . the choice @xmath79 is assumed to be reserved for the @xmath80-point , @xmath81 . the lowest @xmath31 should sample the vicinity of the @xmath80-point . the @xmath78-points are to be specified in the fractional coordinates with respect to the reciprocal lattice vectors . the elements of the upper triangle of the hessian matrix should be provided in the binary ( default ) ` hessian_uf ` or alternatively in the ascii file ` hessian_f ` and the atomic coordinates in the file ` coord ` writen in the charmm coordinate format . * _ incoh _ : this module allows to calculate atomic debye - waller factors representing the mean square displacements and dynamical structure factor of incoherent one - phonon neutron scattering on monocrystals and from orientationally averaged powder . in the latter case we need to specify an absolute value of momentum transfer @xmath82 , range of the @xmath78-point index @xmath31 : @xmath83 for picking up the corresponding @xmath78-point eigenvalues- and eigenvectors - files generated by _ phonon _ , number of random orientations of @xmath82 vector to provide spherical averaging and absolute temperature . also , one has to define the @xmath78-point index @xmath84 , for which the @xmath78-point range @xmath85 corresponds to the linear regime of the acoustic - mode - dispersion curves . this is needed for the proper derivation of debye - waller factors using debye approximation . as a result , the function @xmath86 is given in the file ` s_q_w ` . optionally , one can also obtain density of states ( dos ) in this module . * _ coh _ : this module calculates dynamical structure factor of coherent one - phonon neutron or x - ray scattering on monocrystals . in addition to the input data required by _ incoh _ ( except for the spherical averaging ) , we need to define for module _ coh _ also the type of scattering neutron / x - ray , the number of higher brillouin zones included for sampling momentum transfer vector , and the range of the @xmath78-point index @xmath87 evaluated by module _ phonon _ and assigning the @xmath78-points in the first brillouin zone , which lie along the selected direction of the momentum transfer vector @xmath51 . as a result , the function @xmath86 is given in the file ` s_qw_coh ` . * _ bead _ : this module is used to enable visualization of selected vibrational modes obtained by running _ phonon _ for the @xmath80-point , such that atomic displacement vectors are projected on to the beads , which are defined as the center of mass of larger atomic groups of the system , for example residues . the output files are readable by the program ` xmakemol`@xcite which enables direct visualisation of the mode . to compile the program package makefile is provided . it is important to note that 64-bits processors are prerequisite for applying the ` nmscatt ` to analysis of the large systems ( containing more than 2000 atoms ) . one needs to install the lapack library on the computer beforehand , prior to ` nmscatt ` . the fortran compiling switches ` g77 -mcmodel = medium -funroll - all - loops -fno - f2c -o3 ` are recomended when installed on 64-bits processors running linux .

computational tools for normal mode analysis , which are widely used in physics and materials science problems , are designed here in a single package called ` nmscatt ` ( normal modes & scattering ) that allows arbitrarily large systems to be handled . the package allows inelastic neutron and x - ray scattering observables to be calculated , allowing comparison with experimental data produced at large scale facilities . various simplification schemes are presented for analysing displacement vectors , which are otherwise too complicated to understand in very large systems . , and vibrational analysis , phonons , atomic force - field simulations , inelastic neutron / x - ray scattering , dynamical structure factor 87.15.-v,87.15.aa,63.20.dj,61.10.dp

gr-qc9603025

among the results of the loop approach to non - perturbative quantum gravity there are several which tell us that the picture of geometry on scales small as compared with our usual scales ( on planckian scales ) looks quite differently from the habitual picture of riemannian geometry . the usual classical picture seems to arise only on coarse - graining . the fundamental excitations of the emerging quantum geometry are one - dimensional loop excitations and the whole quantum picture is of essentially discrete , combinatorial character . ( see , for instance , recent works @xcite , which also contain extensive references to the previous papers on the loop approach ) . let us assume now that we can formulate a reasonable approximation criteria , and for any classical geometry configuration find the set of approximating it quantum states . it is natural to expect that if the precision of approximation is chosen not too high , there will be a lot of quantum states corresponding to the same ` geometry ' . it is quite tempting to consider a usual riemannian geometry description as a macroscopical one and to regard all quantum states approximating a riemannian metric as micro - states corresponding to the same macro - state . this point of view brings up a lot of interesting possibilities . indeed , recall that with distinguishing between macro- and micro - states of a system the notion of entropy arises in statistical mechanics . entropy is a function which depends on a macroscopic state of the system . it can be thought of as a function which for each macroscopic state gives the ( logarithm of the ) number of different microscopic states corresponding to this macro - state . more precisely , the space of states of the system should be divided into compartments , where all micro - states belonging to the same compartment are macroscopically indistinguishable . then the entropy of a macro - state is given by the logarithm of the ` volume ' of the compartment corresponding to this macro - state . let us return to our quantum description of geometry . it is natural to introduce a coarse - graining of the space of quantum states in such a way that quantum states approximating different ` geometries ' belong to different compartments . having divided the space of states this way , it is natural to introduce the function which for any geometry configuration gives the logarithm of the ` volume ' of the corresponding compartment . this gives rise to the notion of _ geometrical entropy_. thus , geometrical entropy tells ` how many ' there are different quantum states which correspond to a given geometry configuration . to be more precise , in the cases when a compartment is itself a linear space the entropy is given by the logarithm of the dimension of the corresponding compartment . in this paper we try to implement the idea of geometrical entropy following a very simple choice of the ` ensemble ' of quantum states . although some of our results are surprising , the aim of this paper is not to argue a physical significance of the results obtained . rather , in order to understand if the general idea of geometrical entropy makes sense , we consider a particularly simple case , in which the analysis can be accomplished , and develop a technique that may prove to be useful for future developments . our choice of the ` ensemble ' of quantum states is as follows . first , we restrict our consideration to the gravitational degrees of freedom of an arbitrarily chosen in space 2-dimensional surface . namely , we consider lorentzian 3 + 1 general relativity in the framework of ( real ) ashtekar variables , and the quantization given by the loop quantum gravity . we restrict our consideration to the gravitational system induced by the full theory on some 2-surface @xmath5 embedded in the spatial manifold @xmath6 . thus , the degrees of freedom of our system are just the degrees of freedom of general relativity that live on a surface @xmath5 . second , we specify a macro - state of our system simply fixing the total area of the surface @xmath5 . in this case , as we shall see later , it is easy to pick up all quantum states which approximate a given macro - state , and the analysis becomes almost straightforward . thus , to illustrate the general idea of geometrical entropy we stick here to the case when a macro - state of our system is specified simply by the total area @xmath1 of the surface . let us note that such a statistical mechanical consideration of surface degrees of freedom is of a special interest because of its possible connection with the black hole thermodynamics . indeed , there is a common believe that it is the degrees of freedom living on the horizon surface of a black hole which account for the black hole entropy . to try to reveal the connection between quantum gravity and thermodynamics that is suggested by black hole physics is one the motivations for our investigation . the other , and maybe even more important motivation is that the loop quantum gravity itself is a new approach . in such a situation it is necessary to apply the formalism to simple problems , just in order to see if it gives a reasonable picture . the set of problems concerning statistical properties of the theory might serve as one of such tests . the paper is organized as follows . in the next section we remind briefly how the surface quantum states look like and discuss the issue of correspondence between macro- and micro - descriptions . in section [ sec:3 ] we calculate geometrical entropy of surface degrees of freedom considering the case of an open surface . section [ sec:4 ] contains a generalization of our result to the case of closed surfaces . we conclude with the discussion . let us recall the description of general relativity in terms of ( real ) ashtekar variables . in the hamiltonian framework general relativity can be formulated as a theory of @xmath7-connection over the spatial manifold . the connection field plays the role of a configurational variable ; the momentum variable is presented by the canonically conjugated field . the dynamics of the theory is determined by a set of constraint functionals . the degrees of freedom induced on an arbitrarily chosen surface @xmath5 are described by pull - backs of the connection and momentum fields into @xmath5 , which we shall denote by @xmath8 and @xmath9 respectively ( @xmath10 stands for two component spinor indices ) . the ` surface ' momentum field @xmath9 carries information about 2-metric on @xmath5 . let us describe the quantum theory . the loop quantization of 3 + 1 general relativity is described in details in @xcite . for our purposes it is sufficient to recall that there exists an orthogonal decomposition of the hilbert space of gauge invariant states of quantum general relativity into subspaces , which are labeled by the so - called spin network states . spin network states are labeled by closed graphs in @xmath6 with spins ( or , equivalently , with irreducible representations of the gauge group ) assigned to each edge and intertwining operators assigned to each vertex of graph . let us now specify the space of quantum surface states . given a 2-d ( not necessarily closed ) surface @xmath5 embedded into the spatial manifold @xmath6 and a 3-d spin network @xmath11 one can consider the intersection of this spin network with @xmath5 . let us call the intersection points vertices . generally , there can be vertices of any valence not less then two ( valence of a vertex is the number of edges of a spin network state which meet in this vertex ) . also , there can be edges lying entirely on the surface @xmath5 among the edges of @xmath11 ; we shall call such edges tangential ( see fig . [ fig:1 ] ) . the intersection of @xmath11 with the surface @xmath5 defines what we shall call a surface spin network on @xmath5 . a surface spin network is a graph lying entirely on the surface @xmath5 , with spins assigned to each edge , and intertwining operators assigned to each vertex . the intertwiners assigned to each vertex are just those of the corresponding 3-d spin network . this means that vertices of a 2-d surface spin network ` remember ' what were the spins of the edges incident at the surface ( see fig . [ fig:2 ] ) . note that our definition of a surface spin network is not the canonical one . a ` canonical ' surface spin network is defined as a graph lying on the surface , with spins assigned to each edge , and intertwiners assigned to each vertex . we use the term ` surface spin network ' simply to denote the intersection of a 3-d spin network with the surface @xmath5 , or , in other words , to denote the ` surface ' part of information carried by a 3-d spin network . to avoid confusion , we shall also use the term ` generalized surface spin network state ' . the simples non - trivial example of a surface spin network is that coming from a single edge intersecting the surface @xmath5 ( see fig . [ fig:3 ] ) . such a spin network is simply the point @xmath12 on @xmath5 , with the intertwining operator being the map from the one copy of the representation space @xmath13 ( @xmath14 here is the spin labeling the irreducible representation of @xmath7 ) to the other copy of @xmath13 . the intertwiner in this case is specified ( up to an overall constant ) simply by the spin @xmath14 attached to the vertex @xmath12 . we define the space @xmath15 of surface quantum states as the space spanned by all ( generalized ) surface spin network states . this definition means that the basis in @xmath15 is formed by surface spin network states , what gives us all that we need for our counting purposes . we can now recall that there exists a set of well defined operators @xmath16 , which ` measure ' quantum geometry of @xmath5 . these operators correspond to areas of various regions @xmath17 of the surface @xmath5 ( see @xcite ) . it turns out that 3-d spin network states are eigenstates of operators @xmath16 . the corresponding eigenvalues are given by @xmath18 note that we measure areas in the units of @xmath19 , which is convenient in the loop quantum gravity . here the sum is taken over all vertices @xmath12 lying in the region @xmath17 of the surface @xmath5 ; @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the total spins of edges lying up , down the surface and tangential to the surface ( see @xcite for details ) . although these operators are defined on 3-d quantum states , the eigenvalues ( [ qarea ] ) depend only on the ` surface ' part of the information carried by a 3-d spin network state . therefore , we can think of @xmath22 as operators defined on the ( generalized ) surface spin network states , with eigenvalues given by ( [ qarea ] ) . as we have said in the introduction , in this paper we are going to consider a geometrical entropy that corresponds to a macro - state specified simply by a total surface area @xmath1 . for this simple case , the approximation criterion between macro- and micro - descriptions is straightforward . namely , we can say that a quantum state ( micro - state ) approximates a given macro - state if the mean value of the operator @xmath23 in this quantum state is approximately equal to the fixed value @xmath1 . it is straightforward to see that quantum states approximating total surface area form a linear subspace in the space of all surface states . its dimension is equal to the number of different surface spin network states approximating @xmath1 . let us see now how many different quantum states approximate a given total area . it is easy to see that this number is infinite . indeed , loops on the surface , which are the simplest possible parts of a surface spin network state , do not give any contribution to the areas . therefore , one has an infinite number of spin networks which approximate one and the same total area of @xmath24 being different only in configurations of loops on the surface . one can argue , however , that this happens because , using terminology from statistical mechanics , a macro - state of our system is not completely specified when we fix only a total area of the surface . indeed , areas of regions on @xmath5 carry information only about degrees of freedom described by @xmath25 field . but there are also degrees of freedom described by the pull - back of the connection field on the surface which one should take care of when specifying a macro - state . our guess is that different configurations of loops on the surface from the above example correspond to different classical configurations of the connection field on @xmath5 . indeed , as we know , in classical theory loop quantities are constructed as traced holonomies of the connection , and , therefore , are just those objects which carry information about the connection field . therefore , since we want to forget about degrees of freedom described by the field @xmath26 when we specify a macro - state , to be consistent we have also to forget about those quantum states which , as we believe , contribute to @xmath26 and do not contribute to the area of @xmath5 . let us , therefore , consider only quantum states which contribute to the areas of regions on @xmath5 , but do not ` contribute ' to the connection field on the surface . these , according to our guess , are the states which contain no loops on the surface . we shall call the corresponding spin networks _ open _ spin networks . a ( generalized ) surface spin network is called open if the ( surface ) graph that labels it contains no closed paths ( or no loops ) . the simplest open spin network state is the spin network containing a single vertex ( see fig . [ fig:3 ] ) . now , to find the entropy which corresponds to a macro - state of a fixed total surface area @xmath1 we should calculate the number of quantum states which approximate @xmath1 , taking into account only open spin networks . however , let us first analyze the problem taking into account only some particularly simple spin network states , and then try to generalize the result obtained . let us consider spin networks whose vertices are bivilent , i.e. , those specified simply by sets of points ( vertices ) on the surface with spins assigned to these points ( see fig . [ fig:4 ] ) . points on the surface with spins assigned are sometimes called punctures ( see , for example , @xcite ) , and we shall use this name as well . so quantum states which we consider now are specified by sets of punctures on the surface . for these simple quantum states there exists a simplified version of the formula ( [ qarea ] ) . namely , a set @xmath27 of punctures gives the area of a region @xmath17 on @xmath5 @xmath28 here the sum is taken over all punctures which lie in the region @xmath17 and @xmath29 are the corresponding spins . to get the total area of the surface we just have to sum over all punctures @xmath30 . with these simple states the problem of calculating the entropy becomes almost straightforward . let us use the standard trick . instead of counting states which correspond to the same area we shall take a sum over _ all _ states but take them with different statistical weight . namely , let us consider the sum @xmath31 over all different states @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is a parameter . considering @xmath34 as a _ probability _ of our system to be found in a state @xmath11 , it is easy to see that the _ mean _ value of the area in such statistical state is @xmath35 the entropy of the system in this macro - state is given by the standard formula @xmath36 or , as it is easy to check , by @xmath37 we see that the mean value of the surface area depends on @xmath3 . if statistical ` ensemble ' of states is chosen properly , then one can adjust the value of @xmath3 in such a way that @xmath38 acquires any prescribed value . there is some particular value of @xmath5 which corresponds to the chosen value of @xmath1 . excluding @xmath3 in such a way we obtain the entropy as a function of the area @xmath39 . statistical mechanics tells us that when the density @xmath40 of states of our system grows sufficiently fast with @xmath1 it is of no difference which way of calculating @xmath0 to choose ; one can count the logarithm of the number of different states which give one and the same area or calculate the function @xmath0 as described - the results will not differ . let us note that @xmath0 calculated through ( [ sa ] ) will be meaningful only for large @xmath1 ( as compared with unity , i.e. with the planckian area ) . this is really what we need because only in this case the notion of approximation and , therefore , the notion of entropy acquires sense . let us now discuss whether all the sets of @xmath27 should be taken into account in ( [ statsum ] ) . first of all , let us recall that we have to count not the surface spin networks themselves but the diffeomorphism equivalence classes of spin networks . this means that two surface spin networks which can be transformed on into another by a diffeomorphism on the surface should be considered as a single state in ( [ statsum ] ) . thus , the continuous set of data @xmath41 ( @xmath42 runs all over the surface @xmath5 ) reduces simply to a set of spins @xmath43 when one identifies sets of punctures which can be mapped one into another by a diffeomorphism on the surface ( note , however , the discussion following the next paragraph ) . next , we note that , if the surface @xmath5 is a closed one , not every set @xmath41 can be obtained as a result of intersection with @xmath5 of some 3-d spin network in @xmath6 . namely , the sum @xmath44 , which is the total spin which ` enter ' the surface must be an integer for gauge invariant states . this corresponds to the fact that not all eigenvalues given by the formula ( [ qarea ] ) are eigenvalues of the area of a closed surface , as it was first pointed out in @xcite . let us consider in this section only a simpler case of an open surface @xmath5 ; we return to the case of a closed surface in sec . [ sec:4 ] . and , finally , let us consider the states specified by the following two set of punctures ( see fig . [ fig:5 ] ) @xmath45 these two states differ one from another only at two points @xmath46 ; they give the same total area of the boundary . should we distinguish these two states or consider them as a single physical state ? it turns out that this is the key question which determines the form of the dependence of the entropy @xmath0 on the area @xmath1 of the surface . let us now consider these states as _ different _ and postpone the discussion of such a choice to the last section . so let us denote by @xmath47 the number of states which correspond to one and the same area @xmath1 in the case when all the sets ( [ states ] ) are regarded as specifying different states . it is easy to see that @xmath47 is the number of _ ordered _ sets of punctures which approximate the total area @xmath1 . it is straightforward to compute @xmath47 using our method with the statistical sum . one can easily check that the fact that we regard the sets ( [ states ] ) as specifying different states ( or , equivalently , the fact that we count ordered sets of punctures ) means that we can sum over the spin of each puncture _ independently _ @xmath48 the first sum here denotes the sum over the number of possible punctures on @xmath5 and the subsequent ones denote the summation over the possible spins . it is easy to see that @xmath49 where @xmath50 is given by @xmath51 note that the sum here runs over all positive integers and half - integers . one can expect that @xmath52 will increase as @xmath3 gets smaller because in any case ( [ 1 ] ) diverges when @xmath3 goes to zero . however , we see that ( [ 2 ] ) diverges even for some finite value of @xmath53 such that @xmath54 ( we shall see in a minute to which value of @xmath3 this corresponds ) . when @xmath3 gets smaller and approaches @xmath53 , @xmath52 increases and diverges at the point @xmath53 . it can easily be checked that @xmath38 and @xmath55 also diverge when @xmath56 . this means that changing @xmath3 slightly we will obtain substantial differences in values of @xmath1 and @xmath5 . what we are interested in is the dependence @xmath0 for large values of @xmath1 . but we see that all large values of @xmath1 can be obtained by small changes in @xmath3 when @xmath56 . thus , from ( [ sa ] ) we conclude that for @xmath57 @xmath58 here we neglected the term @xmath59 which is small comparatively with the main term ( [ entropy ] ) . this result tells us that entropy grows precisely as the first power of area of the boundary . now let us see what @xmath53 amounts to . one can do this numerically but it is also straightforward to find an approximate value . note that @xmath50 can be rewritten as the sum over integers @xmath60 the term under the square root in the exponential can be given the form @xmath61 . because the sum starts from @xmath62 we can neglect the unity comparatively to a larger term . then @xmath50 can be easily computed @xmath63 this gives for the @xmath64 the value @xmath65 . an explicit numerical investigation of the equation @xmath54 gives a close value @xmath66 . so we have shown that for large values of @xmath1 the entropy depends on the area as @xmath67 as we have mentioned before , in the case of closed surfaces @xmath68 we have to take into account the fact that not all eigenvalues given by the formula ( [ qarea ] ) are eigenvalues of the operator @xmath69 , which measures the total area of the surface . namely , in the case of a closed surface @xmath68 gauge invariant quantum states are those which satisfy the condition that the sums @xmath70 and @xmath71 over all vertices lying on the surface are integers @xcite ( spins @xmath20 are those defined after the formula ( [ qarea ] ) . this condition means that for the case of a closed surface some spin network states should be excluded from the sum ( [ statsum ] ) . recall that our result essentially follows from the fact that the statistical sum @xmath52 diverges when @xmath3 approaches some _ finite _ value @xmath53 . because we have to drop some positive terms from the statistical sum corresponding to a closed @xmath68 , @xmath52 can prove to be convergent for all @xmath33 and as a result we would obtain some other ( non - linear ) dependence @xmath0 . ] . the aim of this section is to show that geometrical entropy @xmath0 of ( ordered ) sets of punctures , considered in the previous section , for a closed surface @xmath5 still depends linearly on the total surface area . so , again , our states are specified by ordered sets @xmath72 of punctures on the surface . however , in the case of a closed surface , not all sets of punctures correspond to gauge invariant physical states . namely , in our case gauge invariant states are those for which @xmath73 is an integer . to find the number of different states which approximate one and the same total area we can again apply our trick with the statistical sum . the statistical sum @xmath52 will be given by the expression ( [ 1 ] ) , where we have to take into account only the states satisfying the above condition . it is not hard to calculate the statistical sum @xmath52 for our case of a closed surface @xmath5 . let us divide the function @xmath50 given by ( [ z ] ) into two parts @xmath74 . function @xmath75 is the sum over all integer values @xmath76 of spin @xmath14 @xmath77 function @xmath78 is the sum over all half - integers @xmath79 @xmath80 let us rewrite the statistical sum @xmath52 over all sets of punctures in terms of the functions @xmath81 introduced @xmath82 a moment of reflection shows that in order to get the statistical sum corresponding to the case of a closed surface , we have to drop from ( [ q1 ] ) all terms which contain odd powers of @xmath83 . thus , we get @xmath84 here @xmath81 are functions of @xmath3 . recall now that our statistical mechanical system has a regime in which the entropy depends linearly on the area in the case when the statistical sum diverges for some finite value of @xmath3 . let us , therefore , investigate the behavior of @xmath85 when @xmath3 goes to zero . first , let us note that @xmath86 also , we note that @xmath87 , because the sum in @xmath78 starts from @xmath88 , whereas the sum in @xmath89 is taken over all integer values of spin and starts from @xmath90 . we see , therefore , that the statistical sum @xmath85 diverges for @xmath91 . but @xmath92 , so the value of @xmath53 here is the solution of equation @xmath54 obtained in the previous section . thus , we get that @xmath93 where @xmath53 is the same as in ( [ formula ] ) . thus , we have proved that , although the statistical sum @xmath94 for the case of a closed surface is different from @xmath52 corresponding to the case of an open @xmath5 , it implies the linear dependence @xmath95 of the entropy on the surface area , with the proportionality coefficient @xmath53 being the same as in the case of an open surface . one can say that , although we excluded some states from the statistical sum , there are still ` enough ' states to give the same linear dependence of the entropy on @xmath1 as in the case of an open surface . the result which we have obtained considering some particularly simple surface quantum states is that the entropy corresponding to a macro - state which is specified by a total area @xmath1 of the surface is proportional precisely to the area @xmath1 . it is important that we have obtained precisely the same dependence @xmath0 both for the case of open and closed surfaces @xmath5 . the entropy was defined as the logarithm of the number of different quantum states that approximate one and the same area of the surface . the states which we considered were specified simply by the sets of punctures on the surface . it is crucial that the states which are different only up to a permutation of spins ( see fig.[fig:5 ] ) were considered as different quantum states . one of the reasons why we postponed the discussion of the key point of distinguishing the states ( [ states ] ) was to emphasize the importance of this choice . this is this choice which implies the linear dependence of entropy @xmath0 on the surface area . as we show in the appendix , in the case when states ( [ states ] ) are considered as indistinguishable , the dependence of the entropy on the areas is different form the linear one ( in fact , the entropy turns out to be proportional to the square root of the area ) . before discussing this key point , let us note that our aim in this paper is not to give a physical motivation for some particular choice of the ensemble of quantum states . rather we wanted to show how the entropy arises naturally when one considers correspondence between classical and quantum pictures of geometry . we also wanted to illustrate this idea following some simple choice of the ensemble of quantum states , and to present a technique which turns out to be useful . having this in mind , let us discuss our choice of considering the states ( [ states ] ) as distinguishable ones . we were counting the number of different diffeomorphism equivalence classes of ( simple ) surface spin networks approximating one and the same total surface area . this means , that two surface spin networks which can be transformed one into another by a diffeomorphism on the surface should have been considered as specifying the same micro - state . let us now consider the two states ( [ states ] ) . it is easy to see , that there exists a diffeomorphism which maps one state into the other ; this diffeomorphism simply rearranges two points @xmath46 on the surface . therefore , on the first sight , the states ( [ states ] ) should have been considered as a single state . does this mean that the result obtained is physically meaningless and is simply an exercise in statistical mechanics ? . there are some reasons to believe that the result obtained is more than that . so let us give some possible motivations for our strange choice of considering states ( [ states ] ) as different quantum states . one possibility , which is argued by carlo rovelli @xcite , is that points on the surface are physically distinguishable , and so are the states ( [ states ] ) . this , in fact , happens in the case of some systems for which the surface @xmath5 play the role of the boundary . it might be the case that _ boundary conditions _ partly ( or even completely ) brake diffeomorphism invariance on the boundary . this would mean that some spin networks which are usually considered as specifying one and the same quantum state , should , in fact , be considered as different quantum states . this case of systems with boundaries is subtle and deserves a special attention . let us only note the possible connection of our result , viewed from this point , with the results of steven carlip @xcite . the other possibility , which has also been argued in @xcite , is that some other ( in fact , loop ) states on the surface make some of the states ( [ states ] ) belong to different diffeomorphism equivalence classes of spin networks . indeed , the surface loop states which we considered as giving no contribution to the areas , and , thus , forgot about , may affect largely the number of different diffeomorphism equivalence classes of states which approximate one and the same area of @xmath5 . to see this , let us introduce a loop configuration on the surface . this loop configuration divides the surface into regions . it is clear that some of the states ( [ states ] ) will belong to different equivalence classes , for there will no longer be a diffeomorphism ` connecting ' different regions . thus , the number of different diffeomorphism equivalence classes which approximate one and the same total area @xmath1 in this case is larger that in the case when there are no loops on the surface . so loops on the surface may allow one to distinguish states of the form ( [ states ] ) ( for more details see @xcite ) . of course , neither of these motivations gives a final physical justification of the result obtained . but let us repeat that this is not what we aimed at in this paper . we hope , however , that the above discussion shows at least that the issue deserves a further investigation . finally , let us discuss the possibility to generalize the result obtained considering arbitrary open surface spin network states . first , let us take into account surface spin networks which have no tangential edges , allowing , however , vertices of arbitrary valence . in this case we have to use a general formula ( [ qarea ] ) for eigenstates of area operators ( with all @xmath96 being equal to zero because of the fact that we consider spin networks with no tangential edges ) . we would like to generalize our result counting all ( open ) surface spin networks which approximate one and the same total surface area . however , we face the problem trying to consider all states . namely , eigenvalues given by the formula ( [ qarea ] ) are degenerate and we have to take this degeneracy into account when calculating the entropy . let us consider , for example , a simple state , which contains one vertex of valence two ( see fig . [ fig:7 ] ) . for this state we get @xmath97 , and , therefore , @xmath98 . a moment of consideration shows that there are , in fact , an infinite number of similar surface states that do not give any contribution to the area of @xmath5 . thus , we find that eigenvalue @xmath99 is infinitely degenerate . similarly , we find that _ all _ eigenvalues given by the formula ( [ qarea ] ) are infinitely degenerate . therefore , if we would like to take into account all different surface states we would get an infinite value for our geometrical entropy . let us note , however , that the states which we have just considered are rather pathological . namely , we observe that small deformations of the surface @xmath5 ( see fig . [ fig:7 ] ) ( with the spin network state being not deformed ) cause a change in the ` quantum area ' of @xmath5 . let us consider a one parameter family of surfaces @xmath100 $ ] such that @xmath101 when @xmath102 . for our example ( see fig . [ fig:7 ] ) , if surfaces @xmath103 approach the surface @xmath5 from below we have @xmath104 ( here by @xmath105 we denote an eigenvalue of the operator @xmath69 on the quantum state we consider ) . however , if we choose the family of surfaces approaching @xmath5 from above we have @xmath106 ( we measure areas in the units @xmath19 ) . thus , we see that states which cause the degeneracy are ` pathological ' when considered as surface states , for ` quantum area ' of @xmath5 in this states behaves non - continually under small deformations of @xmath5 . this observation , which the author learned from a.ashtekar , suggests that we have to exclude these states when we consider an ensemble of surface states . a natural way to do it would be to change the approximation criterion between macro- and micro - descriptions . namely , let us strengthen our criterion in the following way . we fix a value @xmath1 of the total area of @xmath5 , which defines our macro - state . we choose one parameter family @xmath103 of two - surfaces such that @xmath107 . let us now say that a spin network state @xmath11 approximates our macro - state if @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is the eigenvalue of operator @xmath110 corresponding to the eigenstate @xmath11 . the new approximation criterion states that we have to consider only ` good ' surface quantum states . by definition , ` quantum area ' of @xmath5 in ` good ' surface quantum states does not change under small deformations of the surface @xmath5 . it is easy to see , that ` good ' quantum states are those which have only bivilent vertices , i.e. precisely those states which we considered in this paper . thus , we conclude that the result obtained above gives the geometrical entropy @xmath0 of a macro - state of a fixed total area @xmath1 , the quantum states that account for this entropy being all states which approximate @xmath1 in the strong sense , i.e. , those for which ` quantum area ' does not change under small deformations of the surface @xmath5 . furthermore , the entropy @xmath0 is the same both for open and for closed surfaces . thus , the result obtained is general in the sense that we consider all quantum surface states which approximate @xmath1 in the strong sense . let us conclude saying that the notion of geometrical entropy is , presumably , valid not only in the form explored here ( when we fixed only one macroscopic parameter the surface area ) , but also in a more general context . for example , it is of interest to calculate the entropy @xmath111 which corresponds to a given 2-metric on the surface , which is a genuine geometrical entropy . i am grateful to yuri shtanov for the discussions in which the idea of geometrical entropy developed and for important comments on the first versions of the manuscript . i would like to thank a.ashtekar , a.coricci , r.borisov , s.major , c.rovelli , l.smolin and j.zapata for discussions , comments and criticism . i am grateful to a.ashtekar from whom i learned the idea of sequences of surfaces , which is used here to formulate the ` strong ' approximation criterion . i would also like to thank the banach center of polish academy of sciences for the hospitality during the period when this paper was started . this work was supported , in part by the international soros science education program ( issep ) through grant no . in this appendix we would like to show that the entropy @xmath0 in the case when one considers sets ( [ states ] ) as undistinguishable is proportional to the square root of the area . since we do not distinguish between sets ( [ states ] ) , all states @xmath11 which enter ( [ statsum ] ) are just unordered sets @xmath112 of spins . one can describe each such state by a set @xmath113 of numbers of spins @xmath114 in this state . it is convenient to imagine each state defined by a set @xmath112 as a collection of different particles . particles of a particular sort @xmath14 correspond to punctures carrying the spin @xmath14 . there can be many particles of the same sort in a state and we denote the corresponding number of such particles by @xmath115 . having this analogy in mind it is easy to see that our case the statistical sum @xmath52 is given by @xmath116 here by @xmath117 we denoted the contribution to the area from a single ` particle ' of the sort @xmath14 @xmath118 note that the sum over @xmath14 starts from @xmath88 and runs over all positive integers and half - integers . it is straightforward to take the sum over numbers @xmath115 of different ` particles ' in ( [ s2 ] ) ; this gives @xmath119 the area as a function of parameter @xmath3 is given by the formula ( [ a1 ] ) . in our case it gives @xmath120 to see what dependence of @xmath1 on @xmath3 this implies we replace the sum over spins @xmath14 by the sum over integers ( colors ) @xmath121 . then @xmath122 . for values of @xmath123 we have the following approximation @xmath124 let us now approximate the sum over @xmath14 in ( [ 3 ] ) by the following integral over @xmath76 @xmath125 it is easy to see that this integral is equal to @xmath126 recall now that we are interested in the dependence @xmath0 for large values of @xmath1 ( as compared with unity ) . we see from ( [ 4 ] ) that large values of @xmath1 correspond to small @xmath3 . in the limit @xmath127 the integral in ( [ 4 ] ) can easily be calculated @xmath128 so , finally , for large values of @xmath1 ( or , equivalently , for small @xmath3 ) , we have the following dependence @xmath129 this gives the dependence @xmath0 of the entropy on the area . namely , in the limit of large @xmath1 we can neglect the logarithmic term in ( [ sa ] ) as compared with the larger first term . thus , we get @xmath130 so , in the case when one considers unordered sets of punctures , the geometrical entropy @xmath0 is proportional to the square root of the area .

we adopt the point of view that ( riemannian ) classical and ( loop - based ) quantum descriptions of geometry are macro- and micro - descriptions in the usual statistical mechanical sense . this gives rise to the notion of geometrical entropy , which is defined as the logarithm of the number of different quantum states which correspond to one and the same classical geometry configuration ( macro - state ) . we apply this idea to gravitational degrees of freedom induced on an arbitrarily chosen in space 2-dimensional surface . considering an ` ensemble ' of particularly simple quantum states , we show that the geometrical entropy @xmath0 corresponding to a macro - state specified by a total area @xmath1 of the surface is proportional to the area @xmath2 , with @xmath3 being approximately equal to @xmath4 . the result holds both for case of open and closed surfaces . we discuss briefly physical motivations for our choice of the ensemble of quantum states .

astro-ph0411139

the tunka eas cerenkov array is located in tunka valley , at an altitude of 675 m a.s.l . , and was described in [ 1 ] . the new fitting function ( ldf ) for the eas cerenkov light lateral distribution , derived from corsika code simulation [ 2 ] , has been applied to tunka data . the primary energy @xmath0[@xmath1 has been obtained from the measured cherenkov light flux at a distance 175 m from the shower core @xmath2[@xmath3 with corsika sumulated relation : @xmath4 the absolute energy calibration is based on the results obtained with the quest experiment [ 3 ] . a monte carlo simulation of the experiment has shown that the energy resolution is better than 18% . the spectrum is derived from data taken in 300 hours , spread over 51 clear moonless nights , with a trigger rate of about 1.8 hz . to construct a spectrum with energy threshold @xmath5 ev , showers with zenith angles @xmath6 and a core position inside the geometrical area of the array have been selected . for the range from @xmath7 to @xmath5 ev , events with zenith angles @xmath8 falling inside a 5 times smaller area around the array center have been selected . lateral and time distributions of eas cherenkov light provide two independent methods to estimate the maximum depth . the simulation shows , that the ldf steepness @xmath9 is related to the linear distance ( in [ km ] ) from the array to the eas maximum position : @xmath10 . the cherenkov light pulse fwhm [ ns ] at distances larger than 200 m from the eas axis is related to the relative position of the eas maximum by @xmath11 [ g/@xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the total depth of the atmosphere and @xmath14 is the zenith angle of the shower . this relation depends only on the distance to the eas axis . for example , for distance of 250 m : @xmath15 . this method gives a better theoretical accuracy , than the first one . moreover , the @xmath16 estimate does not depend on assumptions about the primary nucleus . figure 2 presents the mean depth of the eas maximum , derived with the two methods described above , as a function of primary energy . it is seen that the threshold of the fwhm method is higher than that of the ldf steepness method , but the mean depths , obtained with the two different methods are in good agreement . the mean values of @xmath16 from fig.2 can be easily transformed to the mean logarithmic mass @xmath17 of primary particles . figure 3 represents the result . a slight correction , derived from mc simulations of the experiment ( assuming a 4-group mass composition , p : he : cno : fe = 0.3:0.3:0.2:0.2 ) has been applied . according to these data the mass composition has almost no energy dependence in the range from @xmath5 to @xmath18 ev and is compatible with the hypothetical composition with @xmath19 mentioned above . at energies above @xmath18 ev , however , a steep increase of the average mass is observed . a similar increase in average mass is observed in almost all experiments . points of the present work coincide with kascade data [ 4 ] at the energy of the knee . authors are thankful to professor gianni navarra and eas - top collaboration for the opportunity to carry out the calibration experiment quest at the eas - top array .

new results of 300 hours of operation of the tunka array are presented . an improved parametrization of the cherenkov light lateral distribution function ( ldf ) , based on corsika monte carlo simulations and the experiment quest , has been used for the reconstruction of eas parameters . the corrected energy spectrum in the knee region is obtained . the mean depth of the eas maximum has been derived both from the analysis of ldf steepness and the fwhm of cerenkov light pulse . the mean mass composition around the knee is estimated .

cond-mat0404103

by now , jump - diffusion processes and more general lvy processes or lvy driven processes are widely used in models of the stock dynamics and term structure models , under both historic and risk neutral measure . however , only discrete time series of empirical data are available , therefore the problem of identification of the jump and diffusion components is a non - trivial task . the problem of the identification of the diffusion component was considered in detail in ait - sahalia ( 2002 , 2003 ) ; in the present paper , the focus is on the jump component . clearly , the presence of jumps is most prominent in prices of contingent claims near expiry , especially for out - of - the money options , and therefore it is natural to extract information about the jump part of the process by using empirical data for out - of - the - money european options . carr and wu ( 2003 ) showed that in the presence of jumps , the prices of out - of - the - money european options near expiry are of order @xmath3 , where @xmath3 is the time to expiry , and use this observation to test for the presence of jumps . however , the results in carr and wu ( 2003 ) are qualitative rather than quantitative . the principal aim of the present paper is to derive simple analytical formulas which can be used for the identification of the jump part of a lvy process ( under a risk - neutral measure chosen by the market ) ; the straightforward generalizations to mean - reverting processes driven by lvy processes ( the ornstein - uhlenbeck type processes ) , stochastic volatility models with jumps and lvy - driven term structure models will be published elsewhere . the first group of results of the present paper are formulas for @xmath0 , or time decay , of out - of - the money european call and put options on a stock , at expiry . contrary to the gaussian case , @xmath0 for the former ( resp . , the latter ) is shown to be negative if there are positive ( resp . , negative ) jumps . in other words , we prove that near expiry , these prices are linear functions of time to expiry ( up to relatively small errors ) , and calculate the coefficients . the results are explicit analytical expressions in terms of the parameters which characterize the process . by using these formulas and empirical data for options near expiry as in carr and wu ( 2003 ) , it is possible to identify the jump part of a particular lvy model . after that , by using the data for options far from expiry , one can identify the first instantaneous moment of the process , and calculate the diffusion coefficient by subtracting the second instantaneous moment of the jump part of the process . this gives a new identification method for the diffusion component . by using the formulas for the @xmath0 s for the european put and call , we obtain approximations for the american put price and early exercise boundary near expiry . the pricing of american options in the gaussian case is well understood see e.g. musiela and rutkowski ( 1997 ) , karatzas and shreve ( 1998 ) , carr and faguet ( 1994 ) , carr ( 1998 ) , longstaff and schwartz ( 2001 ) , clment et al . ( 2002 ) , and the bibliography therein . in the infinite horizon case , explicit analytical formulas are obtained , and in the finite horizon case , a number of efficient numerical methods are developed . although explicit formulas are not available in the finite horizon case , several general results are proved for this case as well . consider the american put with the strike price @xmath4 and maturity @xmath5 , on a non - dividend paying stock ; the riskless rate @xmath6 is constant . let @xmath7 be the optimal exercise price of the american put . if the stock log - price @xmath8 follows the brownian motion , then the asymptotic behavior of @xmath9 is known both near expiry : @xmath10 as @xmath11 ( see , e.g. , barles _ ( 1995 ) and lamberton ( 1995 ) ; an asymptotic formula for the put price is also available ) , and for small values of @xmath12 : for any @xmath13 , @xmath14 ( see , e.g. musiela and rutkowski ( 1997 ) ; ( [ asymprgauss ] ) is formulated as follows : if the riskless interest rate is zero , then the early exercise of the american put is not optimal ) . notice that ( [ asbgauss ] ) implies that @xmath15 and that ( [ exlim ] ) and ( [ asymprgauss ] ) do not agree well when both the riskless interest rate and time to expiry vanish . in levendorski ( 2003 ) , a variant of carr s randomization method was developed for wide families of lvy processes , and as a by - product , it was shown that for many families of non - gaussian processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , the analogs of ( [ exlim ] ) and ( [ asymprgauss ] ) agree much better . namely , @xmath16 where @xmath17 depends on some of parameters which characterize the price process , and is _ smaller _ than the strike price , @xmath4 . moreover , it was proved that @xmath17 vanishes with @xmath12 , and therefore , @xmath18 notice that ( [ asymprlevy ] ) looks more natural than ( [ asymprgauss ] ) , and may be of some importance in today s almost deflationary world . further , if the difference @xmath19 is sizable , then any numerical procedure or parameters fitting procedure which does not take this fact into account , may produce significant errors near expiry and strike . hence , the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary has practical implications for the parameters fitting and development of accurate numerical methods . however , the proof in levendorski ( 2003 ) has three disadvantages , which stem from the use of the wiener - hopf method . first , the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary results from long calculations without clear intuition . next , the approximate formulas for the put price are expressed in terms of the factors in the wiener - hopf factorization formula , hence , they are complicated for practical use , and finally , the method in levendorski ( 2003 ) is not directly applicable to a popular class of variance gamma processes , which was used in carr et al ( 2002 ) , madan and hirsa ( 2003 ) , and carr and hirsa ( 2003 ) for pricing of american put . the generalization of the method for more general classes of processes seems impossible . here we prove ( [ exlimlevy ] ) and ( [ asymprlevy ] ) by using a much simpler argument . we obtain an efficient approximation for the put price near expiry , and formulate the result about the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary in a more meaningful form . also , we extend the result in levendorski ( 2003 ) to variance gamma processes , and in addition , we find a condition on a process which ensures that the behavior of the boundary is even more regular than in the gaussian case : there exists a negative constant @xmath20 s.t . @xmath21 we prove that the limit of the boundary at expiry is located where @xmath22 of the european call is equal to the riskless rate . ( if the @xmath22 of the european call at expiry is less than the riskless rate for all spot prices less than the strike , then the limit is the strike . ) when the corresponding equation is solved , one can use the formulas for @xmath0 s of the european call and put and obtain an efficient approximation to the put price near expiry . the formulas are fairly simple and can be used for parameters fitting purposes near expiry , both for the european options and american put . they also can be used to improve performance of numerical methods : when using the backward induction , one can start not at expiry , where the value function is most irregular but close to it , and use the analytical approximation as the basis for the backward induction . we demonstrate how large the deviations from the standard behavior of the early exercise boundary and put price can be by using the empirical data for the american put documented in carr et al . we found that the non - standard behavior should be observed for reasonable values of the riskless rate : typically , the margin between the strike and boundary is 10% or more , and for the spot price in the 5%interval around the strike , the jump premium " in the put price over the pay - off is @xmath23 or more , where @xmath3 is the time to expiry ( with the normalization @xmath24 for a business year ) . the last aim of the paper is to describe the restrictions on the log - price process under an emm , which should be satisfied if the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is observed . as ( [ exlim ] ) , ( [ exlimlevy ] ) and ( [ superregular ] ) imply , various types of the behavior of @xmath9 near expiry are possible however , for many families of processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , namely , hyperbolic processes , normal inverse gaussian processes ( nig ) , and truncated lvy processes of the extended koponen s family ( a.k.a . kobol processes , a.k.a . cgmy model ) of order @xmath25 , the behavior of the early exercise boundary is non - standard for all parameters values . this means that if in the empirical studies , the early exercise boundary for put options on a particular stock exhibits the standard behavior near expiry , then the use of any of the processes above to model the log - price dynamics under a risk - neutral measure chosen by the market is inconsistent with the data . normal inverse gaussian processes , hyperbolic processes and kobol processes of order greater than 1 are processes with sample paths of infinite variation . notice that the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is proved for much wider classes of infinite variation lvy processes as well . for processes with finite variation jump component , the prominent examples being variance gamma processes and kobol processes of order less than 1 , both the non - standard behavior ( [ exlimlevy ] ) and super - regular " behavior ( [ superregular ] ) of the early exercise boundary are possible , depending on parameters of the process ; there are also borderline cases , when we are able only to prove that ( [ exlim ] ) holds . according to a recent empirical study in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , finite variation processes fit empirical data better . even for a finite variation process , if we fix all the parameters of a process except for the drift @xmath26 , let @xmath27 and change @xmath26 accordingly so that the stock remains a martingale , then below a certain critical value of @xmath12 ( depending on the parameters of the process ) , the non - standard behavior is observed , and as @xmath12 decreases further , the optimal exercise price goes to zero uniformly over the interval @xmath2 . it is natural to ask how robust the result about the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is . in levendorski ( 2003 ) and the present paper , it is assumed that dynamics of log - prices @xmath8 follows a non - gaussian lvy process under a risk - neutral measure chosen by the market . this simplest choice of a non - gaussian risk - neutral measure for pricing of the american put was employed in carr et al ( 2002 ) , madan and hirsa ( 2003 ) , carr and hirsa ( 2003 ) , where parameters fitting and computational issues where addressed . better fit can be achieved with stochastic volatility models with jumps but the method in levendorski ( 2003 ) can not be generalized for stochastic volatility models . the method of the present paper can be applied to stochastic volatility models ( and term structure models ) , and under certain parameter restrictions , the margin between the early exercise boundary and strike can be derived . further , in levendorski ( 2003 ) and the present paper , the formulas for the margin are derived in two different approximate models , and in cases which were considered in the both papers , the formulas for the margin are the same . the identical results in two approximations allows one to hope that the margin in the continuous time model is the same . as a proven theorem , we can only claim that the margin in the approximate model is not less than in the continuous time model . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ levy ] , we recall the definition of lvy processes , and give examples of several families of lvy processes used in empirical studies of financial markets . in section [ europe ] , @xmath0 s of out - of - the - money european put and call options are calculated , and in section [ amerput ] , the approximate formulas for the american put price and early exercise boundary near expiry are derived . in section [ implications ] , we consider several families of lvy processes used ( and suggested for use ) in empirical studies of financial markets , and discuss the implications of non - standard behavior of prices and early exercise boundary for the choice of a family of processes , and parameters fitting in more detail . in section [ empirics ] , we derive properties of the early exercise boundary for kobol processes , for parameters values documented in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , and show that the margin between the strike price and early exercise boundary can be significant indeed : more than 10% . in the appendix , the technical proofs are given . recall that a lvy process is a process with stationary independent increments ( for general definitions , see e.g. sato ( 1999 ) ) . a lvy process may have a gaussian component and/or pure jump component . the latter is characterized by the density of jumps , which is called the lvy density . we denote it by @xmath28 . also , a lvy process can be completely specified by its characteristic exponent , @xmath29 , definable from the equality @xmath30=e^{-t\psi(\xi)}$ ] ( we confine ourselves to the one - dimensional case ) . if @xmath31 is a lvy process with finite variation jump component , then the characteristic exponent is given by @xmath32 where @xmath33 and @xmath26 are the variance and drift coefficient of the gaussian component , and @xmath34 satisfies @xmath35 equation ( [ psi1 ] ) is a special case of the lvy - khintchine formula ; for the general case , see e.g. sato ( 1999 ) . wide families of jump - diffusion processes used in the theoretical and empirical studies of financial markets are lvy processes with finite variation jump component . 0.1cm_example 2.1 . _ let @xmath36 be a lvy process with the lvy density @xmath37 where @xmath38 , and @xmath39 . then @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the variance and drift of the gaussian component . the @xmath43 is holomorphic in the strip @xmath44 . in order that @xmath45 $ ] be finite , we need to impose an additional condition @xmath46 . for the sake of brevity , we will consider below the exponential jump - diffusions with the characteristic exponent of the form ( [ jumpdif ] ) . the generalization to the case of lvy densities given by general exponential polynomials on positive and negative half - axis is straightforward . 0.1cm_example 2.2 . _ variance gamma processes ( vgp ) have been developed and used by madan and co - authors in a series of papers during 90th ( see madan et al . ( 1998 ) and the bibliography there ) . the characteristic exponent of a vgp without the diffusion component can be represented in the form @xmath47,\ ] ] where @xmath48 and @xmath49 . the condition @xmath45<+\infty$ ] imposes an additional restriction @xmath46 . 0.1cm_example 2.3 . _ truncated lvy processes ( tlp ) constructed by koponen ( 1995 ) were used for modeling in real financial markets in bouchaud and potters ( 1997 ) , cont et al . ( 1997 ) and matacz ( 2000 ) ; a generalization of this family was constructed in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 ) and called the extended koponen family of tlp processes . later , this generalization was used in carr et al . ( 2002 ) under the name cgmy - model . as a.n . shiryaev remarked , the name tlp was misleading , and so starting with boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002a-2002c ) , we use the name kobol processes . the characteristic exponent of a kobol process is of the form @xmath50,\ ] ] where @xmath51 , and @xmath42 . the condition @xmath45<+\infty$ ] imposes an additional restriction @xmath52 . ( in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002b ) , the reader can also find a formula for the kobol process of order @xmath53 ) . for @xmath54 , the equation ( [ kbl1d ] ) is obtained from ( [ psi1 ] ) with the lvy density given by @xmath55 and @xmath56 ( that is , there is no gaussian component ) . in the case @xmath57 , instead of ( [ psi1 ] ) , the general form of the lvy - khintchine formula is needed ( see sato ( 1999 ) and boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) ) . kobol processes of order @xmath58 are finite - variation processes , and the ones of order @xmath59 are infinite - variation processes . other examples of infinite variation processes are hyperbolic processes ( hp ) , normal inverse gaussian processes ( nig ) and normal tempered stable ( nts ) lvy processes of order @xmath60 ; in the general classification of boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002a-2002c ) , hp and nig are processes of order 1 . hyperbolic processes were constructed and used by eberlein and co - authors ( see e.g. eberlein and keller ( 1995 ) , eberlein et al . ( 1998 ) , eberlein and raible ( 1999 ) ) ; hyperbolic distributions were constructed in barndorff - nielsen ( 1977 ) . normal inverse gaussian processes ( nig ) were introduced in barndorff - nielsen ( 1998 ) and used to model german stocks in barndorff - nielsen and jiang ( 1998 ) ; generalization of the class nig , namely , the class of normal tempered stable ( nts ) lvy processes , was constructed in barndorff - nielsen and levendorski ( 2001 ) and barndorff - nielsen and shephard ( 2001 ) . as kobol processes , ntslp can be of any order between 0 and 2 . 0.1 cm _ example 2.4 . _ the characteristic exponent of an nts lvy process is of the form @xmath61,\ ] ] where @xmath62 @xmath63 , and @xmath64 . the condition @xmath45<+\infty$ ] imposes an additional restriction @xmath65 . with @xmath53 , we obtain the characteristic exponent of nig processes . 0.1cm_remark 2.1 . _ for the explicit calculations in the next two sections , it is important that the characteristic exponent of any of lvy processes considered above admit the analytic continuation into the complex plane with cuts @xmath66 , [ i{{\lambda_+ } } , + i\infty)$ ] , where @xmath52 and @xmath67 , and the analytic continuation is defined by the same formula ( in example 2.4 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 , and in example 2.1 , the characteristic exponent is analytic in the complex plane with two poles at @xmath70 and @xmath71 ) . this property is unnecessary if we want to obtain only qualitative results . for instance , the existence of a non - vanishing margin between the strike and early exercise boundary will be proved for more general class of lvy processes with the jump part of infinite variation . to simplify the presentation , we normalize the strike price to 1 . let @xmath31 be a lvy process of any class considered above . let @xmath72 and @xmath73 be the price of the european call and put option , respectively , at time @xmath74 , and the spot price @xmath75 . denote by @xmath76 , and @xmath77 , the opposite to the @xmath78 of the out - of - the - money european call and put options , respectively , at expiry ( the option s @xmath0 is the derivative of the option price with respect to time ) : for @xmath79 , @xmath80 and for @xmath81 , @xmath82 if the process is gaussian , then the prices of out - of - the - money european call , @xmath83 , and put , @xmath84 , vanish faster than any power of @xmath3 , as @xmath85 , hence the limits ( [ cc ] ) and ( [ cp ] ) equal 0 . the next theorem and lemma show that in the case of non - gaussian lvy processes which we consider , both @xmath86 and @xmath77 , exist and do not vanish . the intuition is that when the jumps are present , the value of waiting of a positive ( respectively , negative ) movement in the price is larger than in the gaussian case . [ margin1 ] let @xmath31 be any of lvy processes considered above . then 0.cm a ) for @xmath79 , the limit ( [ cc ] ) exists , and it is positive ; 0.cmb ) for @xmath81 , the limit ( [ cp ] ) exists , and it is positive ; 0.cmc ) the time decay at expiry , of out - of - the money european call , @xmath87 @xmath88 and put , @xmath77 , depends only on the positive and negative jump parts of the process , respectively , but not on the drift and gaussian component . notice that the intuition behind the independence of the time decay at expiry of the gaussian component is simple : the movements caused by the latter are of order @xmath89 , on average , and therefore the main contribution to the price of an out - of - the - money option , ( almost ) at expiry , can come from the jumps in the corresponding direction only ( for a rigorous proof , see the appendix ) . we start with the simplest case of a pure jump process ( example 2.1 with @xmath56 ) . let @xmath90 be the infinitesimal generator of @xmath36 . then the price @xmath91 of a contingent claim with the terminal pay - off @xmath92 can be represented in the form @xmath93g(x+\mu \tau).\ ] ] for the pure jump process , @xmath90 acts as follows : @xmath94 and since @xmath95 for processes in example 1.1 , we conclude that @xmath90 is a bounded operator in @xmath96 . hence , if @xmath97 is bounded ( the case of the put option : @xmath98 ) , we can write ( [ europclaim ] ) in the form @xmath99 if the put option is out - of - the - money , that is , @xmath81 , then for small @xmath3 , @xmath100 , hence the zero - order term in ( [ europclaim2 ] ) is zero , and @xmath101 by dividing by @xmath102 and passing to the limit , we obtain @xmath103 it remains to calculate @xmath104 at @xmath81 . we have @xmath105 and by calculating the integral , we obtain @xmath106 the case of the call option requires essentially the same calculations but @xmath90 should be regarded as a bounded operator in a space of continuous functions , which grow as @xmath107 as @xmath108 ( for details , see boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) ) , and the result is @xmath109 similarly , @xmath110 and @xmath111 for more general exponential jump - diffusions can be calculated . moreover , the proof above gives @xmath112 and @xmath113 provided @xmath114 and @xmath115 ( the latter condition is necessary for the stock to be priced ) . we conjecture that ( [ ccgen ] ) and ( [ cpgen ] ) are valid for any lvy process satisfying ( [ denspos1 ] ) . however , we were unable to prove ( [ cc])([cp ] ) in the full generality , and so in the proof of theorem [ margin1 ] for the other families of lvy processes listed above , we calculate the limits @xmath110 and @xmath111 directly , by using the formulas for the characteristic exponents . in the case of nts lvy processes and nig , set @xmath116 . now , for any @xmath31 of kobol , nts , and vgp classes , and for @xmath117 and @xmath118 , define @xmath119.\ ] ] [ gen ] let @xmath31 be a vgp , kobol , or nts lvy process . then for @xmath79 , @xmath120 and for @xmath81 , @xmath121 in the appendix . in the gaussian case , @xmath122 , and since @xmath123 depends linearly on @xmath29 , we conclude that @xmath123 depends on the jump component of the process only . hence , @xmath76 , and @xmath77 , depend on the jump component only . the fact that the former depends on the positive jumps only , and the latter on the negative ones , follows by inspection of the lvy - khintchine formula : for @xmath118 ( resp . , @xmath117 ) , @xmath124 is independent of the density of negative ( resp . , positive ) jumps . in the appendix , we will calculate @xmath124 for each family of processes , and derive from ( [ genc])([genp ] ) the following formulas : \1 ) for kobol processes of order @xmath125 : @xmath126 the integrals converge since @xmath127 and @xmath128 ; \2 ) for vgp : @xmath129 the integrals converge since @xmath130 ; \3 ) for nts lvy processes @xmath131^{\nu/2}}{z(z+1)}dz,\quad x<0;\\ \label{cpnts } { { \mathcal p}}(x)&=&\frac{{\delta}}{\pi}\sin\frac{\pi\nu}{2}\int^{+\infty}_{{\alpha}+{\beta } } \frac{e^{-xz}[(z-{\beta})^2-{\alpha}^2]^{\nu/2}}{z(z+1)}dz,\quad x>0;\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath53 , formulas for nig processes obtain . the integrals converge since @xmath132 , @xmath133 , and @xmath128 . by direct inspection of formulas ( [ cckbl])([cpnts ] ) , we conclude that with @xmath134 , the integrands decay as @xmath135 as @xmath136 for processes of order @xmath137 ; if @xmath31 is a vgp or exponential jump - diffusion , then the integrands decay faster than @xmath138 , for any @xmath139 . therefore , with @xmath134 , the integrals diverge if and only if the jump component of @xmath31 is a process of order @xmath140 . further , the integrands are positive monotone continuous functions of @xmath141 . by using the monotone convergence theorem , we deduce [ margin2 ] a ) for processes of order @xmath58 , vgp , and exponential jump - diffusion processes in example 2.1 , there exist finite limits @xmath142 \b ) for nig , and kobol and nts lvy processes of order @xmath143 , the limits @xmath144 and @xmath145 exist but are infinite . \c ) @xmath146 is an increasing continuous function , which maps @xmath147 onto @xmath148 , and @xmath149 is a decreasing continuous function , which maps @xmath150 onto @xmath151 . _ remark 3.1 . _ a ) it is possible to derive formulas for @xmath86 and @xmath77 , for the case of hyperbolic processes , and that part b ) of theorem [ margin2 ] holds in this case . b ) can be proved for more general classes of lvy processes . for instance , @xmath152 can be proved if in a neighborhood of 0 , the density of positive jumps , @xmath153 , admits a lower bound via @xmath154 , where @xmath155 . then there exists a density @xmath156 such that @xmath157 and @xmath158 where @xmath159 . clearly , @xmath110 can not increase if we replace @xmath153 with @xmath160 . the argument in the proof of theorem [ margin1 ] for the jump - diffusion case shows that the contribution of @xmath156 to @xmath110 is bounded uniformly in @xmath79 , and the proof for kobol processes shows that @xmath161 gives a contribution which is unbounded as @xmath162 . 0.1 cm to finish this section , we list approximate formulas for european call and put options near expiry , which follow from theorem [ margin1 ] and the put - call pairity . of course , these approximations are too inaccurate in a very small neighborhood of the strike if the process is of order @xmath163 . for @xmath81 : @xmath164 for @xmath79 : @xmath165 assume that @xmath144 and @xmath145 exist . they are measures of the influence of positive and negative jumps , respectively , and the emm condition is naturally formulated in terms of @xmath166 and @xmath144 and @xmath145 . as it was shown above , the limits ( finite or infinite ) exist for the families of processes in examples 2.12.4 . [ emm ] let @xmath31 be a lvy process with finite variation jump component . then @xmath167 is a local martingale if and only if @xmath168 since the gaussian component @xmath169 and jump component @xmath170 of a lvy process are independent , @xmath167 is a local martingale if and only if for any @xmath171 and @xmath172 , @xmath173e\left[e^{y_t}\right]\\ & = & e^{(\mu - r+{\sigma}^2/2)t+x_s}e\left[e^{y_t}\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] whereupon @xmath174,\ ] ] and @xmath175 - 1,\ ] ] which is @xmath176 ( here @xmath177 denotes the transition kernel of the semigroup @xmath178 , @xmath179=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}p_t(z)f(y+z)dz.\right)\ ] ] divide by @xmath180 : @xmath181 and pass to the limit @xmath182 ; the result is ( [ emm1 ] ) . we rewrite ( [ emm1 ] ) as @xmath183 for processes without the gaussian component , ( [ emm2 ] ) is simpler : @xmath184 the first theorem below shows that if negative jumps are present but their influence is not very large , and compensated by a positive drift ( which clearly decreases the value of waiting ) , then the early exercise boundary converges to the strike price . moreover , the convergence is more regular than in the gaussian case in the sense that ( [ superregular ] ) holds . let @xmath185 be the early exercise boundary . the continuous time model can be approximated by a discrete time model with small time steps @xmath186 . in the discrete time approximation , the option can be exercised at @xmath187 only . denote by @xmath188 the optimal exercise boundary at the last moment before the expiry , and set @xmath189 . one should expect that the behavior of @xmath190 for small @xmath191 is a good proxy for the behavior of the optimal exercise boundary near expiry . in particular , @xmath192 if the limit in the lhs exists . the proof of a simplified version @xmath193 is straightforward : as we make the class of admissible stopping times smaller , the price of the american put does not increase , therefore the early exercise boundary does not go down . we were unable to prove the equality ( [ just ] ) but the inequality ( [ just2 ] ) suffices to make the conclusion that if the early exercise boundary in the discrete time approximation exhibits the non - standard behavior in the limit @xmath194 , then the behavior of the early exercise boundary in the continuous time model is also non - standard . [ extrastan ] let @xmath31 be a vgp or kobol process of finite variation , without gaussian component , or an exponential jump process . let @xmath195 then @xmath196 in other words , _ if @xmath22 of the out - of - the - money european put , at the expiry and strike , is less than the drift , then the slope of the boundary near expiry equals the @xmath22 . _ at @xmath197 , a put owner must be indifferent between exercising and holding the put , therefore @xmath190 is the solution to the equation @xmath198 ( the lhs is the value of the put if it is exercised , and the rhs is the expected present value of the put if it is kept alive ) , equivalently , @xmath199 assume that for small @xmath200 , @xmath201 , then @xmath202 , hence @xmath203 . by using the taylor formula and dividing by @xmath191 , we obtain @xmath204 then we pass to the limit @xmath205 @xmath206 condition @xmath207 is necessary lest the assumption @xmath208 lead to a contradiction ; and the condition ( [ cneg ] ) suffices for the inequality @xmath208 to hold for small @xmath191 . now assume that ( [ cneg ] ) fails . this happens when either the drift is negative or the influence of negative jumps is too large . hence , the value of waiting should increase , and the optimal exercise boundary should be lower . as we will see , apart from the borderline case @xmath209 , the value of waiting becomes so large that @xmath190 remains bounded away from 0 , as @xmath205 . [ thm : finvar ] let @xmath31 be a vgp or kobol process of finite variation , without gaussian component , or an exponential jump process . then a ) if @xmath209 , then the limit @xmath210 exists , and it is equal to 0 ; \b ) if @xmath211 then the limit ( [ barh ] ) exists . it is negative , and can be found from the equation @xmath212 which has a unique solution . in other words , _ if @xmath22 of the out - of - the - money european put , at the expiry and strike , is bigger than the drift , then the limit of the early exercise boundary at expiry is less than the strike . it is located where @xmath22 of the out - of - the - money call , at expiry , is equal to the riskless rate . _ we start with part b ) . first of all , we notice that due to ( [ emm3 ] ) , ( [ cneg2 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath213 therefore on the strength of theorem [ margin2 ] , c ) , the solution @xmath214 to ( [ formpos1 ] ) exists and it is unique . secondly , the reader may be surprised that the answer is formulated in terms of the density of positive jumps , but the proof shows that this is a consequence of the put - call pairity ( for european options ) . since @xmath215 is a ( local ) martingale under the risk - neutral measure , we have @xmath216 hence , we can rewrite the rhs in ( [ exb1 ] ) as @xmath217 ( essentially , this is the put - call pairity ) , and therefore , ( [ exb1 ] ) can be written as @xmath218 we see that if @xmath219 is negative for small @xmath191 , then @xmath220 depends only on the upper tail of the probability density . by dividing by @xmath191 and passing to the limit , we obtain ( [ formpos1 ] ) . thus , part b ) has been proved . in part a ) , @xmath209 , hence from ( [ emm1 ] ) , @xmath221 , and if we assume that for some sequence @xmath222 , the sequence @xmath223 remains bounded away from 0 , then by dividing by @xmath224 in ( [ exb2 ] ) and passing to the limit , we obtain an inequality , contradiction . in the following theorem , we allow for a gaussian component . [ gauss ] let @xmath31 be a vgp or kobol of order @xmath58 , or exponential jump - diffusion process , with a gaussian component . then a ) if @xmath225 , then the limit @xmath214 exists . it is negative , and can be found from ( [ formpos1 ] ) ; \b ) if @xmath226 , then the limit @xmath214 exists , and it is equal to 0 . by repeating the proof of theorem [ thm : finvar ] , we obtain a ) , and similar arguments show that under condition @xmath226 , an assumption that the behavior of the boundary is non - standard , leads to contradiction . this gives b ) . we see that in the case @xmath226 , the result is weaker than in the pure jump case , where we can single out the case when the boundary is more regular than in the gaussian case . according to part b ) of theorem [ margin2 ] , now @xmath227 as @xmath228 . by using this observation , and repeating the proof of part a ) of theorem [ thm : finvar ] , we obtain [ thm : infvar ] let @xmath31 be a nig or kobol or ntsl process of infinite variation . then the limit @xmath229 exists . it is negative , and can be found from the equation ( [ formpos1 ] ) . _ remark 4.1 . _ if the density of positive jumps satisfies the conditions in remark 3.1 b ) , then @xmath152 , and repeating the proof of theorem [ thm : finvar ] , we obtain that @xmath214 is negative . let @xmath31 be a process from any of families in examples 2.12.4 . let @xmath230 but the lvy density and the diffusion coefficient of the gaussian component remain fixed . then the drift of the process changes with @xmath12 and converges to a finite value . by the direct inspection of ( [ formpos1 ] ) , we conclude that if the early exercise boundary exhibits the non - gaussian behavior ( [ exlimlevy ] ) near expiry , then the early exercise price near expiry vanishes with @xmath12 as well . the same argument as in the gaussian case shows that for any @xmath102 , @xmath231 as @xmath230 ( see ( [ asymprgauss ] ) ) , therefore we conclude that the optimal exercise price tends to zero uniformly on the interval @xmath2 . notice that if @xmath31 is a vgp or a kobol process of order @xmath232 , or exponential jump - diffusion ( as in example 2.1 ) , then for large @xmath12 , ( [ formpos1 ] ) has no solution , but for sufficiently small @xmath12 , equation ( [ formpos1 ] ) has a unique solution , and this solution tends to 0 together with @xmath12 . this means that for sufficiently low levels of the riskless rate , all the processes considered above should lead to the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary . by using the approximate formulas for the european put and call near expiry at the end of section 3 , we obtain approximate formulas for the american put price near expiry : @xmath233 notice that this approximation is too inaccurate very close to the strike , especially for infinite variation processes . the behavior of the early exercise boundary near expiry can be used to determine the type of a lvy process , which can be used to model the log - price dynamics under the risk - neutral measure . this choice of a risk - neutral measure was used in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , hirsa and madan ( 2003 ) and carr and hirsa ( 2003 ) . empirical studies of financial markets clearly indicate the presence of both downward and upward jumps ( under historic measure ) , therefore if the boundary exhibits the standard behavior , then one may not use simultaneously a process of order @xmath234 under the historic measure and lvy process under a risk - neutral measure ( chosen by the market ) . indeed , as it is shown in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , p.312 , the difference between the historic and risk - neutral lvy densities must be of finite variation , therefore a process of infinite ( finite ) variation under the historic measure must remain a process of infinite ( finite ) variation under an emm . processes of order @xmath235 can be used for modelling of log - price dynamics both under historic and risk - neutral measure but additional restrictions on the density of the upward jumps must be imposed . another possibility is to use one - sided kobol processes with densities of positive jumps of an order different from the one for positive jumps ( see boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002b ) ) . the characteristic exponents of these strongly asymmetric kobol processes are of the form @xmath236\\ & & \hskip1 cm + c_-\gamma(-\nu_-)[(-{{\lambda_-}})^{\nu_-}-(-{{\lambda_-}}-i\xi)^{\nu_-}],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath237 , @xmath238 , and @xmath239 ( for the formulas in the case @xmath240 , see boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002b ) ) . the analogs of ( [ cckbl ] ) and ( [ cpkbl ] ) are @xmath241 if a finite variation process is chosen for modelling of the american put on a particular stock , then the choice of parameters of the process is constrained by the observed behavior of the early exercise boundary : a. if the non - standard behavior ( [ exlimlevy ] ) is observed , then the constraint is @xmath242 ; b. if the super - regular " behavior ( [ superregular ] ) is observed , then the constraint is @xmath243 ( and probably , there is no gaussian component ) ; however , as empirical examples in the next section show , this possibility is unlikely to realize ; c. if @xmath244 but the super - regular " behavior ( [ superregular ] ) is not documented , then the constraint is @xmath245 , and the gaussian component is admissible . still another possibility is to assume that under an emm chosen by the market , the rate of decay of the density of positive jumps is very large ; then @xmath244 for processes of order @xmath235 , and @xmath214 is negative but very close to 0 for processes of order @xmath246 . for kobol , this means that the steepness parameter @xmath247 must be large in modulus . if under the historic measure , the @xmath247 is not large , this interpretation presumes that the agents in the market are very risk averse . the formulas for @xmath0 of out - of - the money european call and put options , at expiry , can also be used to infer the type of an appropriate family of processes , and parameters of the process . in particular , if @xmath0 at expiry quickly grows as the spot price approaches the strike price , then processes with infinite variation jump component must be used , otherwise the processes with finite variation jump component . the aim of this section is to demonstrate how large the margin between the strike and early exercise boundary and the jump premium " in the american option price over the payoff @xmath248 can be for realistic values of parameters . we use risk - neutral parameters values of the kobol processes with a diffusion component , which were obtained for several stocks in carr et al . ( 2002 ) ( table 3 on p.327 in op . cit . ) . 0.1 cm _ example 5.1 . _ only in one case : ibm1111 , the process is of order @xmath249 : the risk - neutral parameters are @xmath250 , and @xmath251 ( in carr et al . , these parameters are denoted @xmath252 , and @xmath253 ) . since @xmath249 , the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is guaranteed but the gap between the strike price and boundary is small unless the interest rate is very small indeed . it is seen from figure 1 , where we plot the graph of @xmath214 as a function of @xmath12 , that for @xmath254 , @xmath214 is about @xmath255 , and for @xmath256 , @xmath214 is close to 0.01 , so the gap is clearly seen . in figure 2 , we plot the graph of @xmath0 at expiry , for out - of - the - money european call and put ( graph of @xmath110 , for small @xmath79 near zero , and put , @xmath111 , for @xmath81 ) . both are unbounded in a neighborhood of @xmath257 . since the density of positive jumps decays very fast ( the steepness parameter @xmath258 is very large ) , the time decay of out - of - the - money puts is very small unless the spot price is very close to the strike . the density of positive jumps decays faster than the one of negative jumps ( @xmath259 ) , therefore the @xmath0 for the out - of - the - money call is smaller than the one for out - of - the - money put , for the same distance from the strike . 0.1 cm _ example 5.2 . _ for amzn1014 , the parameters are @xmath260 the fairly large @xmath261 indicates that the intensity of jumps is large , and relatively small values of @xmath262 and @xmath247 imply that there are many large jumps , especially negative ones ( recall that @xmath262 characterizes the rate of decay of the density of negative jumps ) . therefore , even not very close to expiry , the owner of an out - of - the - money european option can expect that with a non - negligible probability the option will become in - the - money . hence , the price of these out - of - the - money options is sizable , especially the one of the put . figure 3 demonstrates this effect . we plot graphs of @xmath146 and @xmath149 in a neighborhood of zero . further , @xmath263 , therefore for reasonable @xmath12 , we have @xmath242 , and the behavior of the early exercise boundary is non - standard . since the intensity of large negative jumps is significant , the value of waiting is very large , and the gap between the strike and optimal exercise boundary is also large . from ( [ amputapprox ] ) and figure 3 , we can conclude that even at 5% below the strike , the option value of waiting ( the difference between the american put price and the pay - off @xmath248 ) is of order @xmath23 ; @xmath24 is one year . in the next two figures 4 and 5 , we plot the graph of @xmath146 farther from the strike , and the graph of @xmath214 as the function of @xmath12 . in figure 6 , we plot both the early exercise boundary , at expiry , @xmath264 , as a function of @xmath12 , and that of the early exercise boundary far from expiry , @xmath265 ( the early exercise boundary in the infinite time horizon case ) . similar results are valid for the other stocks documented in carr et al . for several families of lvy processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , we have proved that the time decay of out - of - the - money european options at expiry is not negligible , and derived explicit formulas . these formulas can be used to make numerical calculations near expiry more accurate both for european options , and american ones . by using the same formulas , we proved that the optimal exercise boundary for the american put is separated from the strike price by a non - vanishing margin on the interval @xmath2 , and that as the riskless rate vanishes , the optimal exercise price goes to zero uniformly over the interval @xmath2 . the last result may be especially interesting since the current levels of interest rates are rather low . furthermore , we discussed the restrictions on the process under the risk - neutral measure which the non - gaussian behavior of the early exercise price near expiry imposes , and suggested a natural asymmetric extension of the kobol family ( a.k.a . cgmy model ) , which can be used for any type of the behavior of the boundary . we showed that for the risk - neutral parameters obtained for several stocks in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , the behavior should be non - standard , and the margin between the strike and the early exercise boundary be quite sizable : more than 10% , up to expiry . the jump premium over the payoff is shown to be sizable as well . further , we assume that @xmath46 ; the results for the case @xmath266 obtain by passing to the limit @xmath267 in the formulas for the case @xmath46 . for any @xmath268 , the price of the european call option is given by @xmath269 } { -i\xi(1-i\xi)}d\xi\ ] ] ( see e.g. boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2002b ) ) . clearly , the limit @xmath110 is independent of @xmath12 , therefore we may set @xmath270 . the characteristic exponent of a process without the gaussian component is of the form @xmath271 where @xmath272 grows as @xmath273 in the complex plane with the cuts @xmath66 $ ] and @xmath274 , for processes of order @xmath137 . in the complex plane outside two poles @xmath275 . for vgp , @xmath272 grows as @xmath276 , and for exponential jump processes , @xmath272 decays as @xmath277 . set @xmath278 , and write ( [ callprice ] ) as @xmath279 } { -i\xi(1-i\xi)}d\xi.\ ] ] let @xmath31 be a kobol or nts lvy process of order @xmath280 . then we can find @xmath281 s.t . since @xmath283 is bounded away from zero on the line @xmath284 , the integrand in ( [ callprice2 ] ) admits an upper bound via @xmath285 it follows that the integral over @xmath286 makes a contribution of order @xmath287 since @xmath288 , we have @xmath289 on the set @xmath290 the @xmath79 is fixed , therefore for sufficiently small @xmath102 , @xmath291 is negative and bounded away from zero , and therefore , @xmath292 is negative and bounded away from zero , uniformly in @xmath293 and @xmath294 in the half - plane @xmath295 . this means that we can use the cauchy theorem and push the line of the integration in ( [ au1 ] ) down : @xmath296 , and obtain that the integral in ( [ au1 ] ) is zero . hence , @xmath297 by using essentially the same argument as in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) , where a similar integral ( 5.33 ) was transformed to the integral over the banks of the cut @xmath298 $ ] in the complex plane , and after the change of variables @xmath299 and @xmath300 on the left and right banks , respectively , to an integral over @xmath301 ( equation ( 5.37 ) in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) ) , we obtain , for @xmath302 , @xmath303 as @xmath304 , @xmath305 , therefore by passing to the limit in ( [ genc2 ] ) , we obtain ( [ genc ] ) . recall that the calculations above were made for a kobol or nts lvy process of order @xmath306 . if @xmath31 is a vgp , then we make essentially the same argument by using any @xmath307 . if @xmath31 is a hyperbolic process , nig , or kobol or nts lvy process of order @xmath59 , then we start with the integration by part in ( [ callprice2 ] ) , by using @xmath308 after that we obtain an absolutely converging integral , and can repeat the constructions above with straightforward changes . in the end , we obtain @xmath309dz+o(1).\ ] ] by integrating by part back , and passing to the limit @xmath293 , we obtain ( [ genc ] ) . to finish the proof of ( [ genc ] ) , it remains to show that the result does not change when we add a gaussian component . let @xmath31 be any of the processes above , without a gaussian component , and let @xmath310 be a lvy process with the same drift " term and jump density as @xmath31 , and with the diffusion coefficient @xmath33 . let @xmath311 be the probability density of @xmath310 , and @xmath312 be the probability density of the brownian motion with the volatility @xmath33 . the @xmath312 is the convolution of @xmath177 and @xmath312 , therefore for @xmath81 , @xmath313 take @xmath314 . in the region @xmath315 , the gaussian density is @xmath316 , for any @xmath317 , therefore we may replace the outer integral with the integral over @xmath318 , and add @xmath319 . but then on the support of the integrand , for a fixed @xmath79 , @xmath320 is bounded away from zero , uniformly in @xmath3 . define @xmath321 as @xmath110 but assuming that the log - price follows the jump part of the process . then we can represent the inner integral in the form @xmath322 and therefore , @xmath323 now , define @xmath324 to be @xmath325 for all @xmath326 . then for small @xmath3 , the integral above does not change but now @xmath327 is a continuous bounded function on @xmath328 . by using the super - exponential decay of the gaussian density , we can restore the @xmath329 , and after that pass to the limit and obtain @xmath330 . this finishes the proof of ( [ genc ] ) . [ [ proof - of - cckblcpnts - and - cpjumpccjump - for - jump - processes - with - non - zero - drift ] ] proof of ( [ cckbl])([cpnts ] ) , and ( [ cpjump])([ccjump ] ) for jump processes with non - zero drift ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ let @xmath31 be a vgp . we have @xmath333.\ ] ] if @xmath118 , then the terms with @xmath247 cancel out , and @xmath334 hence , @xmath335 . if @xmath117 , then the terms with @xmath262 cancel out , and @xmath336 thus , @xmath337 . \2 . let @xmath31 be a kobol process . in the case @xmath118 , @xmath338\\ & = & ic\gamma(-\nu)[({{\lambda_+}}-z - i0)^\nu-({{\lambda_+}}-z+i0)^\nu]\\ & = & ic\gamma(-\nu)(z-{{\lambda_+}})^\nu i(e^{-i\pi\nu}-e^{i\pi\nu})\\ & = & 2c\gamma(-\nu)\sin(\pi\nu)(z-{{\lambda_+}})^\nu.\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , in the case @xmath117 , @xmath339 \3 . let @xmath31 be an nts lvy process . if @xmath340 , then @xmath341\\ & = & i{\delta}[({\alpha}^2-({\beta}-z+i0)^2)^{\nu/2}-({\alpha}^2-({\beta}-z - i0)^2)^{\nu/2}]\\ & = & i{\delta}({\alpha}-{\beta}+z)^{\nu/2}[({\alpha}+{\beta}-z+i0)^{\nu/2}-({\alpha}+{\beta}-z - i0)^{\nu/2}]\\ & = & i{\delta}({\alpha}-{\beta}+z)^{\nu/2}(z-{\alpha}-{\beta})^{\nu/2}(e^{i\pi\nu/2}-e^{-i\pi\nu/2})\\ & = & -2\sin\frac{\pi\nu}{2}((z-{\beta})^2-{\alpha}^2)^{\nu/2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath342 , then similarly , we obtain the same expression but without the minus sign . finally , if @xmath31 is an exponential jump - diffusion process , then the same proof as in lemma [ gen ] shows that for the call , it suffices to consider the pure jump process , and that in this case , ( [ callprice3 ] ) holds . since @xmath343 the integrand in ( [ callprice3 ] ) has the only pole @xmath344 in the plane @xmath345 . we push down the line of integration , and on crossing the pole , apply the residue theorem . the result is @xmath346 and by passing to the limit , we obtain ( [ ccjump ] ) . ( [ cpjump ] ) is proved similarly . cont , r. , potters , m. , and bouchaud , j .- p . : scaling in stock market data : stable laws and beyond " , in dubrulle , b. , f. graner , and d. sornette ( eds . ) . scale invariance and beyond ( proceedings of the cnrs workshop on scale invariance , les houches , march 1997 ) . berlin : springer 1997 \28 . lamberton , d. : critical price for an american option near maturity . in bolthausen , e. , m. dozzi , f. russo ( eds . ) seminar on stochastic analysis , random fields and applications . boston basel berlin : birkhaser 1995

we derive explicit formulas for time decay , @xmath0 , for the european call and put options at expiry , and use them to calculate analytical approximations to the price of the american put and early exercise boundary near expiry . we show that for many families of non - gaussian processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , the early exercise boundary for the american put without dividends is separated from the strike price by a non - vanishing margin on the interval @xmath1 . as the riskless rate vanishes and the drift decreases accordingly so that the stock remains a martingale , the optimal exercise price goes to zero uniformly over the interval @xmath2 . the implications for parameters fitting are discussed .

1210.8022

generation and characterization of multiphoton entangled states represent one of the prerogatives of modern quantum optics experiments . highly - entangled multiphoton states such as noon states @xcite and photon - number - correlated twin - beam states @xcite are promising resources for practical applications in quantum lithography @xcite , quantum metrology , @xcite and quantum cryptography @xcite . measurement of the degree of quantum correlations accurately is an essential task for characterizing states of these types . the recent emergence of photon - number - resolving detectors ( pnrds ) @xcite , such as visible - light photon counters ( vlpcs ) @xcite , transition - edge sensors ( tess ) @xcite , time - multiplexed detectors ( tmds ) @xcite and multipixel photon counters ( mppcs ) @xcite , makes the direct characterization of multiphoton states by photocounting possible . a measurement using a @xmath0-photon - resolving detector can be modeled by a positive - operator valued measure ( povm ) with @xmath1 outcomes : @xmath2 , satisfying completeness , @xmath3 , and positivity , @xmath4 , @xmath5 . the outcomes of the povm are diagonal in the fock - state basis and hence phase insensitive . the probability of detecting @xmath6 photons is @xmath7 , where the statistical operator @xmath8 describes the photon state , and knowledge of the @xmath9s enables us to reconstruct the photon statistics . for a perfect detector with no loss ( unit quantum efficiency ) and no saturation , @xmath10 . then the probabilities @xmath9 should reflect the true frequency of occurrence of @xmath6 photons received , @xmath11 , in the limit of a large number of detection trials . however , because of loss and noise in the detector the measurement is a proper povm rather than a von neumann measurement and the measured probability @xmath9 is a mixture of the actual photon statistics , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the conditional probability of detecting @xmath6 photons when @xmath14 photons impinged on the detector . the conditional probabilities model the measurement process in the detector ; in the povm picture , they are related to the outcomes by @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the ket of the fock state with @xmath14 photons . the set of @xmath13 has been used to quantify the capability of photon number discrimination of the pnrd @xcite , and the objective of detector tomography is to determine the conditional probabilities @xmath13 in a model - free way @xcite . however , detector tomography relies on the ability to prepare a tomographically complete set of states and complicated optimization techniques . therefore , parameter estimation for instrument calibration requires suitable models for the povm @xcite . highly entangled states can be produced in various nonlinear optical processes @xcite . at high intensities , the photodetector response becomes nonlinear due to saturation . for example , in a silicon multi - pixel photodetector consisting of a spatial array of avalanche photodiodes ( apd ) , saturation of individual apds in the silicon multi - pixel detector results in the saturation of the array . tes is another alternative for pnrd , which exploits bolometric methods for photon detection . tess operate at cryogenic temperatures ( below 100mk ) and have high quantum efficiency ( @xmath17 ) . their saturation at high intensities is due to the heating of the detectors beyond the superconducting state . hence , there is a clear need to understand the effects of saturation so that one can use these pnrds in experiments with intense non - classical states of light . in this paper , we assess the feasibility of using lossy pnrds for measuring quantum correlations under joint photodetection in the presence of saturation . the figure of merit that we use here is the variance of difference of photocounts ( vdp ) , which has been shown to be a good measure of entanglement @xcite . the dependence of the vdp on quantum efficiencies of photodetectors has been exploited in the method of absolute calibration of quantum efficiency using twin - beam light @xcite . the effects of saturation on this calibration protocol will be discussed here too . this paper is organized as follows : in section 2 , the joint detection setup is described . the povm modeling of losses and saturation are presented . the first and second moments of the photocounts of these povm for a state with poissonian statistics are derived . in section 3 , the vdp and its moment operators are described . the vdp of two pairs of two - mode states , one with classical and another with quantum correlations , are calculated . the difference of these vdp , @xmath18 , is introduced as a measure of distinguishability between quantum and classical correlations . a tractable analytic form is derived for @xmath18 . in section 4 , we introduce the noise reduction factor ( nrf ) , a normalized form of the vdp , and show how an absolute calibration of two detectors can be performed using the nrf in the linear regime of the detector response . the analytic form of the photocount calculated in section 2 gives a quantitative estimate for the range of mean photon numbers in which the detector remains linear . in section 5 , the results are summarized and the use and limitations of the measurement model are discussed . the joint measurement scheme is as follows : two modes of radiation with the mode creation operators , @xmath19 and @xmath20 , are incident on two pnrds . the resulting photocounts of the respective pnrds are analyzed . the joint detection of quantum correlations with lossy photodetectors has been looked into in @xcite . here we extend the theory to include the effects of saturation . for the purpose of the analysis , we use the twin - beam ( twb ) state defined as @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the fock state with @xmath23 photons in mode @xmath14 and @xmath24 is the probability amplitude of the state @xmath25 . it follows from the structure of eqn . ( [ twb ] ) that the two modes of the twb state are perfectly correlated in photon numbers . the twb state can be generated by spontaneous parametric downconversion ( spdc ) in a nonlinear crystal pumped by a pulsed laser . the two beams created by spdc comprise inherently of multiple frequency modes . in the limit of a large number of these modes , @xmath26 , where @xmath27 is the mean number of photons in either the signal or the idler mode @xcite . as a standard for comparison with classical states , we shall use the two - mode coherent ( tmc ) state @xmath28 where @xmath29 . without loss of generality , we can assume that there is no phase difference between the two modes in the tmc state because photocounting is a phase - insensitive measurement . the @xmath30th outcome of the povm of a lossy detector with quantum efficiency @xmath31 is given by @xcite , @xmath32 with @xmath33 for @xmath34 and @xmath35 was introduced in eqn . ( [ cond ] ) . for a pnrd , the measured number of photons , @xmath30 , which is an eigenvalue of the photocount , @xmath36 , has an upper bound at @xmath0 . when @xmath37 , then its povm is the same as in eqn . ( [ lossy ] ) , but because the pnrd is unable to resolve between @xmath0 and @xmath1 or more photons , we have @xmath38 for the @xmath0th outcome . @xmath0 is the maximum resolvable photocount . when @xmath0 or more photons are incident on the detector , at most @xmath0 photons will be registered . when @xmath39 , this povm reduces to that of the on / off photodetector : @xmath40 , where @xmath41 and @xmath42 . given the outcomes of a joint measurement of a two - mode state @xmath8 , the joint probability distribution is given by @xmath43 . moments of this distribution , @xmath44 can be calculated via the @xmath45-moment operator of the photocount , @xmath46 we note that since they are the operatorial moments of a povm , @xmath47 @xcite unless the outcomes @xmath48 are pairwise orthogonal which is not the case here . the first two moment operators are @xmath49 and @xmath50 where @xmath51 with @xmath52 and @xmath53 is gauss s hypergeometric function . without saturation , the first and second moment operators are @xmath54 and @xmath55 respectively . the variance of the photocounts is then @xmath56 . it is clear from eqs . ( [ first])-([last ] ) that the saturation adds extra summation terms into the moment operators . for a state with poissonian statistics we have @xmath57e^{-\eta \bar{n } } \ , \\ \label{sat_curve2 } \braket{\widehat{m^2}}_{\textsc{p } } & = & n^2 - \frac{(\eta\bar{n})^n(n+\eta \bar{n})e^{-\eta\bar{n}}}{\gamma(n)}+[(\eta\bar{n})^2+\eta\bar{n}-n^2]e^{-\eta \bar{n}}e_{n-1}(\eta\bar{n } ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the exponential sum function @xmath59 the dependence of the average photocount of a single detector on the average photon number of an impinging poissonian light is shown in figure [ sat_curves ] . with the average number of photons @xmath60 in the incident beam for the lossy detector with various maximum photocount of the detector , @xmath0 ( solid ) , and quantum efficiency , @xmath61 . quantum efficiency which is defined to be the ratio of the detected photocount to the incident photon number , i.e. the slope of the detected photon curve , tends to 0 at large @xmath27 . the response of a detector with just loss is also shown ( dotted ) for comparison.,width=384 ] when @xmath62 , the average number of photocounts tends to the saturation value @xmath0 with the following behavior : @xmath63 by contrast when @xmath64 , the saturation effect is negligible so the expected detected photons behave like that without saturation , @xmath65 when @xmath66 , then @xmath67 which identifies the linear regime of the detector . the povm in eqs . ( [ lossy])-([n ] ) describes the average photocount of a detector expected in the asymptotic limit of small and large average impinging photon number . given the two photocounts from the joint detection , their difference is @xmath68 with integer eigenvalues @xmath69 . the povm of the measurement of the difference photocount , @xmath70 , is @xmath71 \pi_{q}\otimes \pi_q \ & , \ d=0\\[1 ex ] \pi_{q}\otimes\pi_{q - d}\ & , \ d<0 \end{array } \right . \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath48 is the @xmath30th povm outcome of eqn . ( [ lossy ] ) . the moments of the difference photocount distribution are then @xmath72 the vdp for a given quantum state is @xmath73 . let us find the vdp for the tmc and the twb states . for the tmc state , we get @xmath74 where @xmath75 . for the twb state , the quantum correlations gives nonzero terms in the covariance of the joint photostatistics and this shows up in the vdp , @xmath76 where @xmath77 in figure [ vod ] , we show the effects of loss and saturation on measuring the vdp for the tmc and the twb states with different values of @xmath78 and @xmath79 . two observations can be made . first , the saturation causes the variance to decrease with increasing average photon number for both the tmc and the twb states and asymptotically approach zero . this means that the vdp can not provide a reliable discrimination of classical and quantum correlations at values of @xmath27 that are too large . second , loss degrades the measurement of the quantum correlation since with increasing loss , the vdp for the twb becomes closer to that for the tmc . , as a function of the mean photon number of the input signal for the tmc state ( blue solid line ) and the twb state ( red dashed line ) , where @xmath79 and @xmath78 with various values of @xmath0 and @xmath31 to illustrate the effects of saturation and loss.,width=576 ] however , there exists a range of @xmath27 for such a discrimination to be possible . let us define a quantity @xmath18 by means of @xmath80 @xmath18 is an indication of how good the discrimination between the classical and quantum correlations is . figure [ qplot ] shows the behavior of @xmath18 versus @xmath27 for the tmc and twb states . the optimal discrimination happens for the largest @xmath18 values for some @xmath81 that we can solve for if we know the quantum efficiencies , @xmath31 , and the maximum photocount of the detector , @xmath0 , of the detectors . the optimal discrimination does not always occur when @xmath82 due to saturation . when the mean photon number is high and saturation is likely to occur , having some loss in the detectors will help to set off the effect of saturation . however , loss will degrade the quality of the measurement of the vdp . as such , there is an interplay between loss and saturation . versus mean photon number , @xmath27 , and loss , @xmath31 , for a balanced joint detection where @xmath79 and @xmath83 . in this figure , the maximum @xmath18 value is clearly visible . the solid line shows the optimal @xmath27 for a given @xmath31 and the dashed line shows the optimal @xmath31 for a given @xmath27 . the higher the value of @xmath18 , the better the discrimination between quantum and classical correlations . note that for a fixed value of @xmath27 , the best discrimination does not always occur at @xmath82 ( zero loss ) . a higher loss is favored at higher mean photon numbers where saturation gets more prevalent to obtain a larger @xmath18 value . however , higher losses in the photocount will degrade the measurement of the vdp.,width=336 ] the analytic forms for the vdp for the tmc and twb states measured by a pnrd with saturation and loss in eqs . ( [ vodcoh])-([vodtwb ] ) are the main results of the paper . using these results , we analyzed the vdp for different values of @xmath31 and @xmath0 thus illustrating the significance of loss and saturation to the measurement of the vdp . thus , such an analytic analysis is helpful for interpreting experimental data . we will also show in the next section , how we can use the features of saturation in the analytic model in the absolute calibration of the pnrds . sometimes it is helpful to consider a related measure of quantum correlation the noise reduction factor ( nrf ) , @xmath84 for the tmc state , @xmath85 with any value of quantum efficiencies for the detectors . for the twb , @xmath86 with detectors of perfect quantum efficiencies and @xmath87 with lossy detectors , where @xmath88 and @xmath89 are their respective quantum efficiencies . this makes the nrf a useful measure of quantum correlations for two - mode states , as well as a calibration measure for the quantum efficiencies of detectors @xcite . first , we will describe the current experimental procedure for absolute calibration which is possible in the linear regime of a pnrd . then using the analytic form for the photocount , a range of values of average photon number for the linear regime can be derived . second , we will suggest the use of the analytic form in eqn . ( [ vodcoh])-([vodtwb ] ) for absolute calibration beyond the linear regime of the pnrd . for the first method , let us consider the scenario in which we are given two detectors with unknown quantum efficiencies and saturation characteristics . absolute calibration , for example , can be achieved if we have a twb state by measuring @xmath90 in the linear regime of the detectors . the calibration routine is as follows : 1 . measure the photocounts , @xmath91 and @xmath92 , of the two detectors with increasing @xmath27 . this can be done by increasing the pump power of the laser . from this data , the mean photocounts , vdp , and consequently the nrf , can be calculated . 2 . [ k]let us define the ratio of the two quantum efficiencies , @xmath93 . in the regime where the photocounts are approximately linear with respect to @xmath27 , then , @xmath94 . so @xmath95 can be found by calculating the ratios of the two photocounts . 3 . for this range of average photon number , @xmath96 . using the measured nrf and the value of @xmath95 found in step [ k ] above , @xmath88 can be calculated . last , we can calculate @xmath89 from the values of @xmath95 and @xmath88 found . thus , absolute calibration of the detector is possible in the linear regime of the detector . this is quantified by the range of @xmath27 in which the term linear in @xmath27 is much larger than the next order term in eqn . ( [ sat_curve ] ) , @xmath97 the higher the saturation point is , the broader the linear regime of the detector . although it is difficult to pinpoint exactly how small the value on the left - hand side of eqn . ( [ regime ] ) must be , current experiments suggest that values of @xmath98 are sufficient @xcite . the worst range of values of @xmath27 for the linear regime is given for @xmath39 , where we would require that @xmath99 . for an apd where @xmath39 , the quantum efficiency is typically of order @xmath100 @xcite , thus the linear regime is where @xmath101 . however , for a vlpc with a typical saturation value of @xmath102 and quantum efficiency @xmath103 @xcite , we have @xmath104 . so the linear regime of the vlpc is about 9 times that of the apd . this puts a quantitative estimate for the linear regime of a pnrd from its characteristics which are typical for that type of detector and can be taken from its manual . once an approximate linear regime is determined , a careful calibration can be done in this range of average photon numbers . in principle , using the analytic forms in eqs . ( [ sat_curve ] ) , ( [ vodcoh ] ) and ( [ vodtwb ] ) , we can achieve absolute calibration beyond the linear regime of the pnrd with just a tmc state using the following protocol : 1 . split a pulsed laser beam with a 50 - 50 non - polarizing beamsplitter into two parts with equal intensities to form a tmc state . one has to make sure that the laser produces a coherent state which is free of any additional classical noise , see @xcite . 2 . measure the photocounts of the beam in each arm with a detector where the detection intervals are triggered by the laser . then increase @xmath27 by increasing the pump power until there is no visible change in the mean photocount with increasing @xmath27 . in this limit , the detectors are saturated and we have @xmath105 $ ] and @xmath106 $ ] , where the subscript sat " indicates values at saturation and @xmath107 $ ] denotes the closest integer . 3 . calculate the difference of photocounts for each detection interval and then the variance of this difference for each @xmath27 value . using the found values of @xmath108 and @xmath109 we can generate an equation for the nrf of the tmc state as measured by the pnrd from eqs . ( [ sat_curves ] ) , ( [ vodcoh ] ) and ( [ vodtwb ] ) . a nonlinear fit of the experimental data of the vdp for the tmc state can then be done with the analytic form for the @xmath90 using a suitable numerical algorithm . this will yield fitted values of @xmath88 and @xmath89 thus completing the calibration of the pnrds . this absolute calibration procedure with the tmc state is possible owing to the features of the vdp in the presence of saturation . it would not be possible if detectors operating in the linear regime or detectors with just losses are used , because in those cases , the vdp would be insensitive to the quantum efficiencies of the detectors . the advantage of using this second method instead of the first is that we do not have to rely on a twb state which are harder to generate than a tmc state . the disadvantage is that we have to use a numerical nonlinear fit method for the calibration which might yield more than one reasonable fit and the errors in these fittings are generally larger than those for a linear regression fit required for the first method . a model of joint photodetection with lossy detectors considering saturation is presented . using this model , we have derived an analytic form for the vdp which is tractable for calculations . we then used this analytic form to study the effects of saturation on measurements of the vdp . it has been found that saturation diminishes this measure and the variance of photocounts of the tmc and twb states can not be distinguished at large mean photon numbers . loss in the pnrds degrades the quality of the measurement of the quantum correlation . on the other hand , loss can offset the effects of saturation at high average photon numbers . nonetheless , the vdp is still a good measure of quantum correlations as long as we are not far from the optimal @xmath18 . saturation also limits the range of @xmath27 in which data is useful for calibration . this has been known for some time experimentally , but here we have derived quantitatively what this range is in terms of relative values of quantum efficiency and saturation value . with the analytic forms for the measured photocounts and vdp , we will also be able to do an absolute calibration with a tmc state . the generation of a tmc state is far simpler than that of a twb state where the latter is required for absolute calibration . as the focus of this paper is on loss and saturation effects in pnrds , we have not looked at possible extensions of the measurement model . for example , apart from loss and saturation , pnrds can also suffer from dark counts and crosstalk effects , both of which add spurious counts to the data . in using the measurement model for accounting for noise in actual experiments , one would have to take these effects into account . this can be done by modifying eqn . ( [ lossy ] ) with the appropriate conditional probability matrices representing different noise types . another useful extension of the measurement model is that of a variable saturation value , @xmath0 . here , we have considered a fixed saturation value but in practice , a pnrd can have different saturation values at different intensities or wavelengths of incident light . a more robust measurement model can be obtained by taking this variability into account . we would like to thank hui khoon ng , matteo g.a . paris , bjrn hessmo and alexander ling for helpful discussions . we would also like to acknowledge the use of levelscheme in the preparation of the figures . this work was supported by the a - star investigatorship grant as well as the ministry of education and the national research foundation of singapore . boto , a.n . ; kok , p. ; abrams , d.s . ; braunstein , s.l . ; williams , c.p . ; et al . quantum interferometric optical lithography : exploiting entanglement to beat the diffraction limit . _ * 2000 * , _ 85 _ , 27332736 . agliati , a. ; bondani , m. ; andreoni , a. ; decillis , g. ; et al . quantum and classical correlations of intense beams of light investigated via joint photodetection . _ j. opt . b : quantum semiclass . opt . _ * 2005 * , _ 7 _ , s652s663 . agafonov , i.n . ; m.v.chekhova ; iskhakov , t.s . ; penin , a.n . ; et al . absolute calibration of photodetectors : photocurrent multiplication versus photocurrent subtraction . lett . _ * 2011 * , _ 36 _ , 1329 - 1331 . haderka , o. ; peina , j. , jr . ; m.hamar ; et al . direct measurement and reconstruction of nonclassical features of twin beams generated in spontaneous parametric down - conversion . a _ * 2005 * , _ 71 _ , 033815 .

the variance of difference of photocounts is an established measure of quantum correlations for quantum states of light . it enables us to discriminate between the classical correlation of a two - mode coherent state and the quantum correlation of a twin - beam state . we study the effect of loss and saturation of the photon - number - resolving detector on the measurement of the variance of difference of photocounts . an analytic function is derived for this variance , both for the coherent and the twin - beam states . it is found that the variance of difference of photocounts is no longer a reliable entanglement measure in the non - linear regime of the detector response but it remains useful in some range of values of average photon numbers of the incident light . we also quantify the linear regime of the detector with saturation which will be useful for calibration of the detector quantum efficiency . photon - number - resolving detectors ; quantum correlation ; saturation

0810.2517

in this paper , we present a multirate method that is suited for integrating systems of ordinary differential equations ( odes ) which arise from step models describing nanostructure evolution . the strength of our method , in comparison to other existing multirate schemes , is its order of accuracy : our method is fourth order provided solutions are sufficiently smooth . a multirate method is basically one that takes different step sizes for different components of the solution @xcite . when might such a need for different time steps arise ? one situation where multirate methods may be more efficient than single rate ones is when a few of the components contain time singularities or are _ locally stiff_. in this case , ( explicit ) single rate methods are likely to use small time steps for all the components , whereas a multirate one uses small time steps just for singular / locally stiff ones . we believe that this strategy significantly improves the efficiency of solution . integration by our multirate method occurs in two stages . we first use an `` outer '' integrator to handle the non - singular/ non - stiff components and then an `` inner '' integrator to handle the singular / stiff ones . to perform the second inner integration , a small number of components from the outer solution must be interpolated . the high order of accuracy of the multirate scheme relies on the interpolation being of a sufficiently high order . one of our key results in this paper is that for a multirate method to be @xmath0 order , the interpolation must be @xmath1 order . we demonstrate our method by using a fourth order runge - kutta method ( with error control ) for the inner and outer schemes and coupling them together with cubic interpolants . multirate schemes were first studied by gear and wells @xcite . further treatments can be found in @xcite , and the references therein . however , considering the wide variety of methods which researchers have used to improve the performance and accuracy of integration codes , it is surprising to learn that multirate schemes have received only modest attention . this is even more surprising , given that algorithms using somewhat similar concepts are well developed for the numerical solution of pdes e.g. adaptive mesh refinement ( amr ) in the field of hyperbolic pdes @xcite . the applications of multirate methods seem mostly confined to @xmath2-body problems @xcite , and equations arising from electrical networks @xcite . the work presented here is , as far as we are aware , the first instance of a multirate scheme applied to a problem in surface evolution . our method is fairly similar to the one described in @xcite , which is second order . for example : we first advance and interpolate the slow components , and then integrate the fast components this is the `` slowest first '' paradigm described in @xcite . we also automatically detect the fast components by looking at the error estimates produced using an embedded formula . the main differences are that : ( i ) our method is fourth order in time for sufficiently smooth solutions and ( ii ) our method is most effective when applied to the types of odes that commonly arise in models of step surface evolution . we will discuss ( ii ) in more detail later on in the paper , but for now we make the comment that a necessary but not sufficient condition for our method to work is that the ode system be locally coupled . the strengths of our method are that automatic step size selection is simple to implement , and that there is a lower overhead cost because we do not have to interpolate all the slow components of the solution this is one of the benefits of specializing to locally coupled systems . the outline of this paper is as follows : in section [ sec : physical_motivation ] , we discuss why step models are studied and explain the physics behind the equations . in section [ sec02:governing ] we present the step equations , and in section [ sec03:properties ] we describe features of the equations that require special attention . in section [ sec04:code ] we give the details of the numerical method and in particular , we discuss the important issue of interpolation in section [ interpolation ] . we validate our code and present our results in section [ sec05:implementation ] and summarize our findings with a conclusion in section [ sec61:discussion ] . the surface dynamics of crystal structures has received much recent attention @xcite because of its relevance to the fabrication of nano - scale electronic devices , such as quantum dots @xcite . of interest to us here is the behavior of _ vicinal _ surfaces below the roughening temperature @xmath3 . for any given material , a surface forming a small angle with a high symmetry plane of the crystal is called vicinal . the roughening temperature is the critical temperature below which steps become thermodynamically stable . thus , a microscope image of a surface below @xmath4 , with a slight miscut angle , appears as made from a series of terraces separated by steps of atomic height see figure [ fig : silicon ] for an example in silicon . as the surface evolves , the steps move and change their shape , but the steps are well defined and have a lifetime that is long enough to be directly observable . when the temperature is increased above @xmath4 , a _ kosterlitz - thouless _ phase transition occurs @xcite , and the surface becomes statistically rough as characterized by the divergence of the height height correlation function @xcite . for many physical applications ( such as epitaxy ) the operating temperatures are below @xmath3 , and this mesoscale description of a surface in terms of steps and their evolution is very useful . a step model can account for finite size effects occurring at the atomic scale , while remaining computationally simple simulations with step models can be done over much longer time periods than , for example , with atomistic models of the surfaces . the step s shape can , in general , be very complicated . thus , quantitative descriptions for how steps interact with one another can be very difficult to derive , and a complete description of an arbitrarily shaped nanostructure in terms of its steps is currently not available . as a result , theoretical studies have been restricted to simple nanostructure geometries and step shapes . the bcf model , proposed by burton , cabrera and frank @xcite in 1951 , deals with a monotonic step train consisting of an infinite number of parallel steps see figure [ fig : geombcf ] . in this model , the steps edges are separated by atomically smooth terraces , and each step position is uniquely described by a single scalar quantity @xmath5 where the index @xmath6 labels the step . using this model , burton , cabrera and frank were able to describe the evolution of a ( 1 dimensional ) stepped surface , under non - equilibrium conditions , in terms of its steps . in 1988 , rettori and villain @xcite considered a 2d array of circular mounds , and incorporated the effects of step line tension into the bcf model . the nanostructures that they studied consist of a finite number of concentric circular layers , in a `` wedding cake '' configuration see figure [ fig : wedcake ] . this step system can also be used to describe the `` healing '' of small circular pits @xcite produced by scanning tunneling microscopes . the radius of each layer @xmath7 is assumed to be a continuous function of time . physical considerations then lead to a set of locally coupled odes for the radii . similar sets of equations can be found in @xcite . there are two main competing physical processes that take place on a stepped surface , in the absence of evaporation and desorption . the first one is the diffusion of adsorbed atoms ( `` adatoms '' ) across terraces , which is characterized by a diffusivity @xmath8 . the second one is the attachment - detachment of adatoms at step edges , which is characterized by the kinetic coefficients @xmath9 and @xmath10 see figure [ fig : tranprostepsurf ] . experimental evidence @xcite suggests that , for some materials , attachment from the terrace above requires overcoming a higher activation energy barrier than attachment from the terrace below , so that @xmath11 . however , in this paper we consider only @xmath12 , and disregard this ( possible ) asymmetry in the step attachment - detachment known in the literature as an ehrlich - schwoebel ( es ) barrier @xcite . furthermore , we neglect the diffusion of adsorbed vacancies and the diffusion of adatoms along step edges @xcite . in this section , we present the ( non - dimensional ) evolution equations for a finite axisymmetric nanostructure with @xmath13 steps , relaxing in the absence of deposition and evaporation see figure [ fig : wedcake ] . derivations of these equations can be found in @xcite . every step in the structure is subject to two physical effects that drive its motion . the first is a _ step - line tension _ , arising from a gibbs - thomson mechanism @xcite . an isolated , circular step of radius @xmath14 , on top of an infinite substrate , initially devoid of adatoms , reduces its perimeter ( and hence its radius ) by emitting adatoms at a rate proportional to its curvature @xcite i.e. @xmath15 . the second effect is a _ repulsive interaction with neighboring steps _ , characterized by a potential function that is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the steps @xcite . steps in the bulk of the structure ( with a smaller curvature ) tend to be less affected by the step - line tension compared to steps near the top . let @xmath16 @xmath17 be the positions of the steps numbered starting from the top of the nanostructure . thus @xmath18 , with @xmath19 the radius of the innermost step and @xmath20 the radius of the outermost step . define @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 , by : @xmath24{4.6in}{{${\displaystyle \left . \begin{array}{lclcl } \lambda_1 & = & \lambda(\rho_{1 } , \rho_{2})\/,\\ \lambda_n & = & \lambda(\rho_{n-1 } , \rho_{n } ) + \lambda(\rho_{n } , \rho_{n+1})\/ , \quad \mbox{for } \;\ ; 2 \leq n \leq n-1\/,\\ \lambda_n & = & \lambda(\rho_{n-1 } , \rho_{n})\/ , \end{array } \ ; \right\}\/$}}}\ ] ] @xmath25{4.6in}{{${\displaystyle \hspace*{0.50 in } \mbox{where } \quad \lambda(\rho_i , \rho_j ) = \frac{2\,\rho_i}{\rho_i+\rho_j}\ , \frac{1}{(\rho_i-\rho_j)^3 } + \frac{1}{\rho_j}\ , \left(\frac{\rho_i}{\rho_i^2-\rho_j^2}\right)^2\,,}\/$}}\ ] ] @xmath26 @xmath27 where @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 ( as well as @xmath31 below ) are non - dimensional constants . then the step - flow equations are @xmath32 the non - dimensional constants are as follows : * the parameter @xmath33 measures the strength of the step - step interactions relative to the strength of the step line tension . it is given by @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the step - step interaction coefficient @xcite , @xmath36 is the step stiffness @xcite , @xmath37 is the height of a single step , and @xmath38 is a typical value for the radii for example , it could be the initial radius of the final step in the structure . _ we note that , in many experimental situations , @xmath39_. * the parameters @xmath40 are given by @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the adatom attachment - detachment coefficient at a step , and @xmath43 is the adatom terrace diffusivity . the ratio @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 is a typical terrace width , measures the competition between diffusion and attachment - detachment see equation ( [ eqn : sec20:deltan ] ) . * the dimensionless parameter @xmath31 is given by @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the atomic area , @xmath49 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath50 is the absolute temperature , @xmath51 is the equilibrium density of adatoms at a straight , isolated , step and @xmath52 is a typical bulk step velocity . we note that , of the physical parameters involved in the definitions of the non - dimensional constants above , some such as the terrace diffusivity @xmath43 , have been extensively tabulated @xcite , while others such as @xmath51 and @xmath52 , can be inferred from experiments @xcite . however , for the purposes of simulation , we can take @xmath53 without loss of generality , by an appropriate rescaling of the step radii and time . equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) constitute a pentadiagonal system , of the form @xmath54 where all the @xmath55 have the same functional form , with the exception of @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 which govern the behavior of the first and final two steps . notice that if @xmath60 denotes the common rate function for the bulk of the steps ( @xmath61 ) , then @xmath62 in this paper , we present a multirate method for integrating the equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) , when @xmath63 . however , we believe that the method presented here should be applicable to _ general sets _ of locally coupled odes , which are _ locally stiff _ ( see section [ local ] ) . in fact , our multirate method was designed to specifically tackle this problem . let us now turn our attention to the difficulties that arise when solving equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) numerically . the axisymmetric step - flow equations possess a number of peculiar properties which pose problems for standard integrators hence the need for a multirate algorithm . for example , the singular collapse of the innermost step and stiffness , localized to only a few of the components , are two ( different ) situations under which a standard integrator is forced to use small time steps . in these cases , a single rate method uses small time steps for all components . in contrast , a multirate method will use small time steps only when it has to , so that most of the components are integrated with a large time step . this strategy improves the efficiency of the integration . the singular collapse of the innermost step causes a loss in accuracy for most high order integrators near the point of collapse . hence , we implement a low - order simple euler routine for the innermost step and its neighbors . away from the singular step , we implement a fourth order multirate method with error control , which is able to efficiently integrate locally stiff components . equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) have the property that @xmath64 in a finite time . the top step always undergoes a monotonic collapse because its radius always decreases under the effect of step - line tension . as the top step shrinks , it emits adatoms , causing the radii of the second and subsequent steps to grow as these are absorbed . when the top step completely disappears , the number of layers in the structure is reduced by one . as a result of the sequential collapse of top steps , a macroscopically flat region called a facet forms and grows on the top of the structure . provided that the collapse of the top steps is tracked accurately , and the topmost @xmath65 is removed at each collapse , the growth of the facet is automatically accounted for . when the first collapse occurs , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 replace @xmath70 , @xmath68 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 in ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) , and ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) applies when @xmath73 . a similar replacement occurs for the second and subsequent collapses . in this way , a given index tracks always the same step throughout the integration . let @xmath74 be the collapse time for @xmath19 . then it can be shown @xcite that as @xmath75 , @xmath76 for some constants @xmath77 and @xmath78 . the square root behavior in ( [ square_root ] ) comes from the fact that the leading order behavior for @xmath79 in equation ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) stems from a line tension : @xmath80 . thus the derivatives of @xmath19 are divergent at the time of collapse . since ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) is a locally coupled set of equations , we also expect @xmath81 , for @xmath82 , to be singular but for the solutions to become more regular near @xmath83 as @xmath84 becomes larger . since the accuracy of high order integrators usually relies on the solution having enough bounded derivatives , this means that standard high order solvers will lose accuracy near the time of collapse . for example , consider a method with truncation error @xmath85 for smooth solutions @xmath86 , and time step @xmath87 . let @xmath88 be a time @xmath89 steps away from @xmath83 , so that @xmath90 . then , given the square root singularity in ( [ square_root ] ) , the error near @xmath83 will be increased to @xmath91 furthermore , consider the issue of automatic time step selection in an adaptive integration code . this is usually done by estimating the local truncation error , and updating the time step size with a formula for the truncation error that assumes a smooth solution . for example , consider a runge - kutta scheme using an embedded higher order formula to estimate the local truncation error . such an algorithm updates the time step size using a formula like @xcite @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the order of the integrator . equation ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) is invalid near a time singularity , because from ( [ eq100 ] ) , the error near @xmath83 does not scale as @xmath94 . the resulting behavior is somewhat unpredictable : an adaptive integrator may take a very large number of tiny steps rendering it very inefficient or it may simply abort , stating that the specified error tolerance is not achievable . the aim of this subsection is to attempt to quantify the classes of systems for which the approach in this paper is effective . before explaining what we mean by local stiffness , we first introduce some notation . for @xmath95 , let @xmath96 be the solution of the ode system for some initial condition @xmath97 . for some integer @xmath98 , let @xmath99 be the solution with initial condition @xmath100 , where @xmath101 is the kronecker delta , and @xmath102 is small . finally , let @xmath103 and @xmath104 . we say that the @xmath105 component of the ode system is _ strongly local _ if ( i ) the system is locally coupled and ( ii ) given any @xmath106 , for all @xmath107 , there exists an integer @xmath108 independent of @xmath107 such that for @xmath109 , @xmath110 . if every component is strongly local , we say that the ode _ system _ is strongly local . therefore , a system is strongly local if a small perturbation to any one of its components remains localized in component number . now we explain local stiffness . recall that an ode is stiff when the ratio of the slowest and fastest time scales is much greater than one . the simplest example of this is a situation where the solution of interest is strongly stable , so that small perturbations decay very rapidly , relative to the principal time scale of evolution . now consider again the perturbation described in the previous paragraph . we say that the @xmath105 component of an ode system is _ locally stiff _ if ( i ) it is strongly local and ( ii ) @xmath111 rapidly in time , relative to the principal time scale of evolution . hence , the @xmath105 component of the solution is locally stiff if a perturbation to it remains localized in component number _ and _ decays rapidly in time . if every component is locally stiff , the the solution is globally stiff . once strong locality has been established in an ode system , individual solution _ components _ can be designated as either being ( locally ) stiff or non - stiff . for the rest of this paper , when we refer to `` stiff components '' of the solution , we mean that the components are locally stiff . a `` non - stiff component '' is one that evolves on a time scale comparable to the principal time scale . with this in mind , we can design multirate strategies that handle stiff and non - stiff components separately . for example , we expect to be able to integrate all non - stiff components with large time steps using explicit solvers . if the number of stiff components is relatively small , we can use the same explicit method on the stiff components also , but with much smaller time steps because of stability constraints . if on the other hand the number of stiff components is fairly large , we should resort to a fully implicit stiff solver . at this point it is worth comparing our approach with other work in the literature dealing with problems involving disparate time scales . gear and kevrikidis @xcite propose their `` projective integration '' method to deal with situations where there is a _ gap _ in the spectrum of time scales : the main evolution of a ( stable ) solution occurs slowly , with perturbations decaying much more quickly . for a linear problem , this corresponds to a situation where the eigenvalues can be separated into two groups : one set of moderate sized eigenvalues , and another set with large negative real parts . projective integration requires two ode solvers : an `` inner '' and an `` outer '' integrator . the idea is to take many small steps using the inner solver so that the fast modes are damped out , followed by a large _ projective _ step with the outer integrator . the process is then repeated . this method ( which is not multirate ) is well - suited to handling problems where many , or all , of the solution components are rapidly attracted to a slowly varying manifold . note that there is no notion of `` locality '' in this approach : the fast modes can potentially be coupled with all the slow ones . our multirate method also involves an `` inner '' and an `` outer '' integrator . as discussed above , the property of local stiffness means that a certain subset of the solution components have much stronger stability than the others . these stiff components are handled by an `` inner '' integrator while the non - stiff ones are taken care of using an `` outer '' solver . however , in contrast to the work of gear and kevrikidis , our method is more suited to systems where a small fraction of the components is stiff at any time during the integration . in fact , in terms of the ode s evolution in time , one can think of projective integration as using the inner / outer integrators in `` series '' , whereas our multirate method uses them in `` parallel '' . we will now show that @xmath112 , the radius of a bulk step , in ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) is strongly local provided @xmath113 and hence , away from the facet and the substrate , any stiffness that arises is localized . for a bulk step , the physical origin of the rapid decay comes from the nature of step interactions in equation ( [ eqn : sec20:lambda ] ) . steps strongly repel each other when they get too close together . consider a configuration where some of the steps in the bulk are tightly bunched together , and most of the other steps are widely spaced apart . in this case , a step strictly ( two steps away , at least , from the edge ) inside a bunch is strongly stable , and hence stiff , because small perturbations in its trajectory are opposed by strong interactions from the neighboring steps . on the other hand , widely spaced steps do not experience such large forces , and respond to perturbations on much slower time scales . it turns out that these `` step bunching '' configurations are quite common in practice and are produced by the natural time evolution of the system . in fact , the step bunching instability @xcite is a well - studied phenomenon in epitaxial growth , with applications in quantum dot technology @xcite and nanolithography @xcite . to analyze the decay of solutions , the direct approach would be to compute the jacobian matrix and analyze its eigenspectrum . unfortunately , while the jacobian for the system in ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) can be computed analytically by linearizing at any fixed set of radii @xmath114 , the expressions involved are very complicated , and do not give much insight as to why the equations should be stiff . instead , we present below a less rigorous calculation , which allows us to relate the degree of local stiffness to the step spacing . our approach is based on the fact that the number of equations , @xmath2 , is generally rather large , and that the solutions of interest have a step spacing that is , piecewise , nearly constant . by this we mean that the step spacing @xmath115 changes slowly with @xmath116 , except for a few places where it may change abruptly the effect of these changes is much harder to analyze , and our method of attack ignores them since it is only valid far away from these rapid transition regions . however , the results of our numerical calculations indicate that their presence does not invalidate our analysis . we begin by considering a configuration of steps which has a nearly constant step spacing , and expand the solution in the form @xmath117 + @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is a constant , @xmath120 is the ( constant ) leading order step spacing and @xmath121 . substituting this expression into the step flow equations , and ignoring the equations for the boundary steps ( corresponding to @xmath122 and @xmath123 ) , results in the following leading order equation for the perturbation @xmath124 @xmath125 where @xmath126 is the discrete laplacian : @xmath127 . to show that equation ( [ conststepspacingpert ] ) has the property of strong locality , we consider the solution to the problem with the initial condition @xmath128 , given by @xmath129 with @xmath130 . when @xmath131 , @xmath132 exponentially because the integrand in ( [ conststepspacingiv ] ) is @xmath133-periodic . hence the delta function initial condition remains localized for all @xmath107 . also , note that equation ( [ conststepspacingpert ] ) has free normal modes given by @xmath134 and @xmath135 is the wave - number . it follows that the time scales behave like the fourth power of the step spacing . hence , widely spaced steps evolve on a slow time scale whereas step bunches , which consist of sets of tightly packed steps , give rise to fast time scales and local stiffness . the goal of our method is to efficiently solve a system of locally coupled odes where only a few of the components are stiff . a standard explicit integrator would take small time steps for all components of the solution . in contrast , our multirate method takes large steps for the non - stiff components , and small steps for the stiff ones . the algorithm starts by taking an explicit , global time step , say : from @xmath136 to @xmath137 . an embedded formula is then used to obtain an estimate of the local truncation error ( lte ) for each component of the solution . in general , some of the ltes will be unacceptably large ( because the associated solution components are stiff ) , while others will have acceptable sizes . the algorithm checks if the components with acceptable ltes satisfy the preset tolerance levels . if they do not , the step size is reduced and another global time step is attempted . if they do , a second round of integration is performed to correct the components with large ltes . hence , the algorithm is as follows : * take a step from @xmath138 to @xmath139 . * let @xmath140 be the lte for the @xmath141-th component , let @xmath142 be the @xmath143 percentile of all the ltes , and let @xmath144 be the required error tolerance for @xmath84-th component . for example , if @xmath145 , then @xmath146 of the errors are larger than @xmath147 . if @xmath148 , @xmath147 is the median . * for some real number @xmath42 , flag all the components whose ltes are greater than @xmath149 ( our code uses @xmath150 ) as being possibly stiff . * check if the unflagged solution components satisfy the tolerance requirements , i.e. @xmath151 where @xmath152 is taken over all unflagged components only . * * * if they do , the step is successful . the step size is increased using the formula ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) with @xmath153 as the ratio of errors . * * perform a second integration to correct the flagged components ( see figure [ fig4 ] ) . * * increase the step size according to formula ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) . increase @xmath154 and go back to step 1 . * * * if they do not , the step is not successful . reduce the step size according to ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) with @xmath155 as the ratio of errors . * * do not increase @xmath154 and go back to step 1 . [ algorithm2 ] the second integration is basically done only for the stiff components , and it involves many small sub - steps within the interval @xmath156}\/$ ] to ensure stability . although this second round of integration takes a large number of steps , it only needs to be done for a small subset of the solution components . to perform the second integration , values for the non - stiff components at all times @xmath157 along the boundaries of any stiff set of steps are needed see figure [ fig4 ] . for example , in the case of a pentadiagonal system , the values of two non - stiff components are needed on each side of a stiff region . one way to generate dense output from the non - stiff components , between @xmath158 and @xmath159 , is through interpolation . in this paper we use cubic interpolatants which are generated by using the intermediate stage function evaluations in a runge - kutta method . in section [ interpolation ] , we give more details on the construction of these interpolants and demonstrate that cubic interpolation is consistent with a multirate method that is globally fourth order . once solution components have been flagged as requiring re - integration , the local coupling means that some of the non - stiff components may also have to be re - integrated . because ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) is a pentadiagonal system of equations , if only @xmath160 and @xmath161 are stiff components with large ltes , then all three of the components @xmath162 and @xmath161 must be re - integrated as a set , using the dense output from @xmath163 , @xmath164 , @xmath165 and @xmath166 as ` boundary conditions ' . hence , the algorithm is slightly wasteful in that although @xmath167 was deemed accurate enough , it still had to be integrated for a second time . note that our algorithm uses the lte in a different way from conventional embedded rk methods : instead of immediately scaling the time step if the smallest lte is greater than the tolerance level , we make a note of _ which _ components had the largest ltes by analyzing their distribution : it might not be efficient to retake the time step for every component , if only a few of them are inaccurate . the largest ltes ( in the sense of being larger than @xmath168 in algorithm [ algorithm2 ] ) are discarded , and then the time step scaled according to the largest of the remaining errors . hence , we get a larger time step for a majority of the solution components , and the way that this time step is adjusted throughout the course of the integration is not affected by the presence of a few either rapidly varying or stiff components . for the rest of this paper , we will call the first time stepper @xmath169 ( used to generate the ltes in the first place ) , and the second time stepper @xmath170 ( used to re - integate stiff components with large ltes ) . in general , @xmath169 and @xmath170 do not have to be the same method , or of the same order , but @xmath169 has to be able to generate estimates of the local truncation error . in our code , @xmath169 is a cash - karp runge - kutta formula @xcite and @xmath170 depends on the solution component : if the re - integration involves the innermost step ( see section [ treatment ] ) , we take @xmath170 to be a simple - euler routine which adjusts its step size by step doubling ; otherwise @xmath171 . in other words , there are two possibilities which can arise when performing the re - integration with @xmath170 : 1 . the re - integration involves solution components which include the innermost step . in the following analysis , we will assume this is @xmath70 . [ case1 ] 2 . the re - integration does not involve the innermost step . [ case2 ] the reason to distinguish between these two cases is that ( [ case1 ] ) will involve integration of singular trajectories ( see equation ( [ square_root ] ) ) , but in general , ( [ case2 ] ) will not . using step doubling in ( [ case1 ] ) is a fairly crude way of adjusting the time step . however , resorting to an embedded formula is not possible when ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) breaks down , so using step doubling to monitor the quality of the solution is reasonable in this case . from equation ( [ square_root ] ) , we have seen that @xmath172 in a singular fashion , causing problems for standard high order integrators . our treatment uses a simple euler method whenever the re - integration of @xmath70 and neighboring singular components is involved : this is `` optimal '' in the sense that simple euler produces results that have the same accuracy as higher order methods ( due to the singular nature of @xmath70 ) but is computationally cheaper . furthermore , we are able to extract the time of collapse , @xmath173 , using linear interpolation , which is consistent with simple euler s order of accuracy . our method involves solving for @xmath174 instead of @xmath175 . note that from ( [ square_root ] ) , @xmath176 as @xmath75 ( the collapse time ) for some constants @xmath177 and @xmath178 , which means that @xmath179 has exactly one derivative at @xmath83 . our main reason for solving for @xmath179 , instead of @xmath70 , is not to improve accuracy , but rather to enable the algorithm to ` step through ' the singularity at @xmath180 , and use linear interpolation to obtain @xmath83 , the time of collapse of the innermost step . taking square roots to recover @xmath70 will will result in a drastic loss in accuracy near @xmath83 . at time @xmath107 close to @xmath83 , consider taking a time step of size @xmath181 with component @xmath179 using simple euler . let @xmath182 be the result of taking this time step using a ` perfect ' integrator , producing the exact solution at @xmath183 , given @xmath184 . then , since the truncation error in simple euler is @xmath185 from ( [ rho_sq ] ) , we have @xmath186 therefore , if @xmath187 ( @xmath107 sufficiently far away from the singularity ) then the lte for @xmath70 , @xmath188 , is @xmath189 . however , if @xmath190 ( @xmath107 is very close to @xmath173 ) , then the lte for @xmath70 is @xmath191 , which is not a big improvement over ( [ eq100 ] ) . note that these estimates for the lte are independent of the order of @xmath170 . when @xmath170 has ` overstepped ' @xmath83 resulting in @xmath192 and @xmath193 for times @xmath194 ( @xmath195 ) , we set @xmath196 as an approximation to the collapse time . once @xmath70 has collapsed at @xmath83 , it is removed from the system ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) , the number of equations drops by one , and @xmath197 replaces @xmath184 as the new top step . the key to making our multirate method high order lies in the ability to generate dense output from the non - stiff components with high accuracy . one way to generate dense output is to use interpolation and @xmath139 , the function that we derive does not actually pass through @xmath139 . hence strictly speaking , it is not an interpolant , though we will continue to refer to these approximating functions as `` interpolants '' for convenience . ] . for some integrators , such as backward differentiation formulae ( bdf ) , is it obvious how to derive an interpolant that is consistent in order with the underlying integrator bdf use extrapolation to advance the solution in time . for other integrators , such as runge - kutta schemes , constructing the interpolant is less obvious and this is the focus of the section . note that we need to generate interpolants _ during run time _ using only the function evaluations that have already been computed by the integrator within each time step . the extra constraint of generating the interpolants during run time adds a non - trivial complication to the `` traditional '' interpolation problem , which has been studied extensively @xcite . having successfully integrated the non - stiff components from @xmath138 to @xmath139 , we have the point values @xmath198 and the derivative @xmath199 at our disposal to construct the interpolant between @xmath138 and @xmath139 . we do _ not _ have information about the derivative @xmath200 . however , because we are constructing these interpolants during run time , we are at liberty to use the intermediate function evalulations inherent in the application of runge - kutta : this is valuable information that is not usually available in the traditional interpolation problem . we have seen that our method performs integration in two phases : first we integrate a large number of non - stiff components , then we integrate a small number of stiff ones . ideally , we would like the two integrations to have the same order . this is only possible if the interpolation of the non - stiff components is of a sufficiently high order otherwise large interpolation errors will contaminate the accuracy in the stiff components . in the following paragraphs , when we generate dense output between points @xmath107 and @xmath183 , we define an interpolant to be order @xmath201 when the interpolation error is @xmath202 . let us assume that our inner and outer solvers are both @xmath0 order . first of all , let us calculate @xmath201 in terms of @xmath154 if we want our method to be globally @xmath0 order . for simplicity , we assume in this calculation that the effects of round - off error are negligible . consider the ode system @xmath203 let us assume that we have taken a macro step of size @xmath181 and advanced the non - stiff components @xmath204 successfully from time @xmath107 to @xmath183 . also assume that we have taken @xmath2 micro steps of size @xmath205 , @xmath95 , for the stiff components @xmath206 so that @xmath207 . after taking these @xmath2 steps , the total error in @xmath206 will be @xmath208 the first term is the sum of the local truncation errors caused by taking @xmath2 steps each of size @xmath205 . the second term is the sum of the interpolation errors : note that to advance @xmath209 , an evaluation of @xmath210 in between @xmath107 and @xmath183 , in general , is required for the non - stiff neighbours of @xmath209 and this incurs an interpolation error of size @xmath202 . therefore the error in @xmath211 is also @xmath202 and the error in @xmath209 is @xmath212 . it is clear that ( [ toterr ] ) simplifies to @xmath213 and so for our multirate method to be globally @xmath0 order , we require @xmath214 that is , we can afford for the order of the interpolation to be one less than the order of the integrator . for example , if our integrator is fourth order ( @xmath215 ) , we need to be able to construct cubic interpolants during run time . if our integrator is second order , then linear interpolation should be sufficient as observed in @xcite . we will now illustrate how these interpolants are constructed by taking the classical 4th order ( non - adaptive ) runge - kutta formula as an example and applying it to the autonomous ode system @xmath216 : .coefficients in classical rk4 [ cols= " < , < , < , < , < " , ] we used our multirate code to solve the simple wave equation @xmath217 . by discretizing using the method of lines and one - sided ( `` upwind '' ) differences in space , we obtained @xmath2 coupled ordinary differential equations which were solved using the initial condition @xmath218 and periodic boundary conditions . unlike the axisymmetric step equations , this discretization of the wave equation does not have any time singularities and we expect fourth order convergence for every component . this is confirmed in figure [ fig : convergence ] . although @xmath181 and @xmath219 constantly change because our algorithm uses adaptive step size control , we take @xmath220 as a measure of the average step size where @xmath221 is the final integration time . for the single rate method , @xmath2 is the number of steps and for the multirate method , @xmath2 is the total number of micro - steps . in the multirate code , a maximum macro - stepsize @xmath222 was imposed , and all but the first and final macro - steps had size 1 . the exact solution comes from solving the linear system of odes exactly using an eigenfunction expansion . as the integration progresses , the fraction of components that has to be reintegrated increases gradually as the solution broadens and its amplitude decreases : see figure [ fig : wave ] . a matlab multirate code that produces the results in figure [ fig : wave ] is given in the appendix . figure [ fig5](a ) shows the results of an integration with @xmath223 . note that only those steps which are near the facet tend to pack closely together , but steps which are far away move relatively slowly and do not deviate significantly from their initial uniform configuration . this expanding front of closely packed steps represents the @xmath224 expansion of the facet radius @xcite . figure [ fig5](b ) illustrates the separation in time scales of the solution components and shows which components of the solution are integrated for a second time . as expected , our algorithm takes large time steps for components which are far away from the facet . near the facet and the collapsing top step , many relatively small steps are taken . for the rapidly varying components in this figure , only a representative sample of the meshpoints @xmath138 from the @xmath170 integration are shown . in contrast , when @xmath225 , steps can be closely packed even away from the facet . the plots in figure [ fig6 ] show that a step bunching instability arises when @xmath226 is sufficiently small and are qualitatively very different to those in figure [ fig5 ] . the instability originates from steps with smaller radii and gradually spreads outwards so that more and more steps bunch up . our multirate scheme performs a second integration when bunching and local stiffness arise : therefore , our algorithm gradually becomes less efficient over time . however , as long as the fraction of bunched steps is not too large , our algorithm remains competitive compared to a standard adaptive 4th/5th order runge - kutta code . when the fraction of bunched steps becomes close to unity , the optimal strategy is to have the algorithm detect this automatically , and then switch to a fully implicit , single - rate stiff solver . we leave this as future work , noting that inversion of the pentadiagonal jacobian only costs @xmath227 operations ( where @xmath2 is the total number of existing steps ) . in this paper , we present a multirate integration scheme that is designed to efficiently solve the systems of odes that arise in the relaxation of crystal mounds . these odes have two properties that call for a multirate strategy : the singular collapse of the innermost step and local stiffness . our method automatically detects singular / stiff components in the solution and disregards them when computing the size of the bulk ( macro ) time step . the result is that the bulk timestep can be much larger than in a single rate method . the trade - off is a re - integration of the stiff components which usually consists of a small fraction of the total number of equations in the ode system . our method is globally fourth order when applied to odes which have sufficiently smooth solutions for example , the step equations studied in @xcite and the wave equation discretized through the method of lines in section [ subsec : error - spread ] . however , the time singularities present in the axisymmetric step - flow equations mean that near times of collapse , the integration of steps near the facet suffers a loss in accuracy . to specifically deal with the singular inner trajectories , our method couples a simple euler routine to the bulk solver . given that the truncation error reduces to @xmath228 near the collapse time , independent of the method order , simple euler is the preferred method because it is computationally cheaper . furthermore , the use of linear interpolation to extract collapse times is consistent with the method s order . the high order accuracy of our algorithm ( when applied to bulk steps ) relies on the ability to generate high order interpolants during the run - time of a one - step integration method . our algorithm generates these interpolants by using the intermediate stage function evaluations of an embedded runge - kutta ( rk ) formula . specifically , our method computes @xmath229 order interpolants that are consistent with the @xmath230 order accuracy of the integrator . however , for general @xmath0 order rk formulae , we do not know if it is always possible to construct interpolants that have order @xmath231 . we see four main possible extensions to this work . the first is to generalize our multirate paradigm so that it can be used for ( i ) higher order runge - kutta formulae and ( ii ) multistep methods ( e.g. bdf , adams etc . ) we believe that it should be possible to make _ any _ method multirate the main obstacle in doing this is to derive interpolants of a suitably high order . the second is to explore in more detail the types of pdes that our multirate method can apply to . typically , large systems of odes result from discretizations of pdes and it is for large ode systems that our method becomes competitive with single rate methods . we think that a basic requirement of the discretization is that it should be strongly local . however , we have not fully explored which discretizations are strongly local and which are not . for example , a one - sided , upwind discretization @xmath232 of the advection equation @xmath233 is strongly local only when @xmath234 . for @xmath235 , a kronecker delta initial condition is unstable and does _ not _ remain localized . a discretization using centered differences @xmath236 yields a system of odes that is never strongly local for any @xmath237 . for nonlinear equations , our method seems to be efficient for step - flow like odes with repulsive dipolar step - step interactions . we were able to show that the linearized step flow odes are strongly local ; however , we do not know if linearizing an ode system is always sufficient to show strong locality . the third is to explore how the choice of parameters @xmath238 and @xmath239 in algorithm [ algorithm2 ] affect the efficiency of the integration and if there are optimal values of @xmath238 and @xmath239 . a `` good '' choice for @xmath238 and @xmath239 will result in small number of re - integrated components and a large macro - time step . if @xmath238 is too large and @xmath239 too small , the algorithm behaves like a single rate method . on the other hand , if @xmath238 is too small and @xmath239 is too large , many non - stiff components will be re - integrated along with the stiff ones , rendering the method inefficient . furthermore , our choice of @xmath147 as the @xmath143 percentile of the ltes is somewhat arbitrary ( but seems to generate reasonable results ) . another possibility is to take the mean this amounts to increasing the sensitivity of the bulk step size to the presence of one or two extremely stiff components . clearly , the performance of our multirate method is tied to the distribution of ltes , its moments , and identification of the `` largest errors '' . quantification of the `` largest errors '' and deciding which moments to use is work in progress . in summary , this work contributes to the currently growing body of research in multirate methods . we hope that the strategies adopted in this paper can be carried over to other physical problems and used to improve the efficiency and accuracy of future multirate algorithms . * acknowledgements * + we thank dionisios margetis for many helpful discussions and meetings . rrr was partially supported by nsf grant dms-0813648 . here we give the details of a matlab multirate code to solve a wave equation . % parameters for integrator desired_error = 1e-6 ; % desired error per step mr = 1 ; % set mr=1 for multirate mode , mr=0 for single rate t= 20 ; t = 0 ; dt = 0.1 ; dt_max = 1.0 ; k = -3 ; p = 30 ; % approx percentage of components to reintegrate safety = 0.95 ; while t < t [ unew , error , k ] = rk_onestep(t , u , dt,[1 n ] ) ; % % % % % start of multirate modification % % % if mr = = 1 % flag large errors flags = error > 10^k*percentile(error , p ) ; for i=1:length(flags ) if flags(i ) = = 1 r = i ; break ; end end for j = length(flags):-1:1 if flags(j ) = = 1 s = j ; break ; end end % just to be safe r = r - w ; s = s+w ; [ unew , num_micro_steps ] = micro_integrate(t , t+dt , u , unew , ... [ r s],k , desired_error*1e-3 ) ; end % % % end of multirate modification % % % max_error = max ( max(error(1:r-1 ) ) , max(error(s+1:end ) ) ) ; r = ( desired_error / max_error ) ^(1/5 ) ; if r<1 % step failed dt = dt*safety*max(0.1,r ) ; trynum = trynum+1 ; if trynum>10 sprintf('10 failed attempts ! ' ) return end elseif r>1 % step succeeded [ r s ( s - r ) ( s - r)/n ] t = t+dt ; u = unew ; trynum = 0 ; numsteps = numsteps+1 ; dt = dt*safety*min(5,r ) ; if t+dt > t dt = ( t - t ) ; end if dt > dt_max dt = dt_max ; end end if t > t1 & & plot_number = = 1 subplot(4,2,1 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t1 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,3 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) ; plot_number = 2 ; elseif t > t2 & & plot_number = = 2 subplot(4,2,2 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t2 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,4 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) ; plot_number=3 ; elseif t > t3 & & plot_number = = 3 subplot(4,2,5 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t3 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,7 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) ; plot_number=4 ; elseif t > t4 & & plot_number = = 4 subplot(4,2,6 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t4 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,8 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) end end y_current = y1 ; t = t1 ; trynum = 0 ; numsteps = 0 ; while t < t2 [ y_new , error ] = rk_onestep(t , y_current , dt,[r-2,s+2 ] ) ; r = ( desired_error / max(error(r : s ) ) ) ^(1/5 ) ; if r<1 % step failed dt = dt*max(0.1,r ) ; trynum = trynum+1 ; if trynum>10 sprintf('10 failed attempts ! ' ) return end elseif r>1 % step succeeded t = t+dt ; numsteps = numsteps+1 ; trynum = 0 ; y_new(r-2 ) = interpolate(t , y1(r-2),y2(r-2),t1,t2,k(r-2 , : ) ) ; y_new(r-1 ) = interpolate(t , y1(r-1),y2(r-1),t1,t2,k(r-1 , : ) ) ; y_new(s+1 ) = interpolate(t , y1(s+1),y2(s+1),t1,t2,k(s+1 , : ) ) ; y_new(s+2 ) = interpolate(t , y1(s+2),y2(s+2),t1,t2,k(s+2 , : ) ) ; y_current = y_new ; dt = dt*min(5,r ) ; if t+dt > t2 dt = ( t2-t ) ; end end end y2 = y_current ; a2 = 1/5 ; a3 = 3/10 ; a4 = 3/5 ; a5 = 1 ; a6 = 7/8 ; b21 = 1/5 ; b31 = 3/40 ; b32 = 9/40 ; b41 = 3/10 ; b42 = -9/10 ; b43 = 6/5 ; b51 = -11/54 ; b52 = 5/2 ; b53 = -70/27 ; b54 = 35/27 ; b61 = 1631/55296 ; b62 = 175/512 ; b63 = 575/13824 ; b64 = 44275/110592 ; b65 = 253/4096 ; k1 = dt*f(t , y , cpt ) ; k2 = dt*f(t+a2*dt , y+b21*k1,cpt ) ; k3 = dt*f(t+a3*dt , y+b31*k1+b32*k2,cpt ) ; k4 = dt*f(t+a4*dt , y+b41*k1+b42*k2+b43*k3,cpt ) ; k5 = dt*f(t+a5*dt , y+b51*k1+b52*k2+b53*k3+b54*k4,cpt ) ; k6 = dt*f(t+a6*dt , y+b61*k1+b62*k2+b63*k3+b64*k4+b65*k5,cpt ) ; k = [ k1 ' k2 ' k3 ' k4 ' k5 ' k6 ' ] ; m. kitamura , m. nishioka , j. oshinowo , y. arakawa , in - situ fabrication of self - aligned ingaas quantum dots on gaas multiatomic steps by metalorganic chemical vapor deposition , appl . 66 ( 26 ) ( 1995 ) 36633665 . j. g. mclean , b. krishnamachari , d. r. peale , e. chason , j. p. sethna , b. h. cooper , decay of isolated features driven by the gibbs - thomson effect in an analytic model and a simulation , phys . rev . b 55 ( 3 ) ( 1997 ) 1811 1823 . a. ichimiya , y. tanaka , k. ishiyama , quantitative measurements of thermal relaxation of isolated silicon hillocks and craters on the si(111)-(7x7 ) surface by scanning tunneling microscopy , phys . 76 ( 25 ) ( 1996 ) 4721 4724 .

we present a multirate method that is particularly suited for integrating the systems of ordinary differential equations ( odes ) that arise in step models of surface evolution . the surface of a crystal lattice , that is slightly miscut from a plane of symmetry , consists of a series of terraces separated by steps . under the assumption of axisymmetry , the step radii satisfy a system of odes that reflects the steps response to step line tension and step - step interactions . two main problems arise in the numerical solution of these equations . first , the trajectory of the innermost step can become singular , resulting in a divergent step velocity . second , when a step bunching instability arises , the motion of steps within a bunch becomes very strongly stable , resulting in `` local stiffness '' . the multirate method introduced in this paper ensures that small time steps are taken for singular and locally stiff components , while larger time steps are taken for the remaining ones . special consideration is given to the construction of high order interpolants during run time which ensures fourth order accuracy of scheme for components of the solution sufficiently far away from singular trajectories . multirate , runge kutta , interpolation , stiffness , step equations 65l05 , 65l06 , 82d25

astro-ph0001486

a major gap in our understanding of low - mass star formation concerns the origins of binary stars . about 30 to 50% of low - mass main - sequence stars have companions , and the frequency of young ttauri binary systems in nearby star - forming regions is nearly twice as high . binary systems have been observed in all pre - main - sequence stages of evolution and there is growing evidence for proto - binary systems , although the numbers are still very small ( e.g. , fuller et al . 1996 ; looney et al . 1997 ) . both theory and observations support the hypothesis that binary systems form during the gravitational collapse of molecular cloud cores . most scenarios propose bar formation and fragmentation in rotating and accreting protostellar cloud cores or circumstellar disks as a formation mechanism ( e.g. , burkert & bodenheimer 1996 ; boss & myhill 1995 ; bonnell et al . 1991 ; boss 1999 ) . to understand the formation process of binary stars , high angular resolution studies of the earliest stages of star formation are required . we have , therefore , started a program to search for multiplicity among low- and intermediate - mass protostars ( class0 and i ) using the owens valley radio observatory ( ovro ) millimeter array . our program aims at sub - arcsecond resolution corresponding to linear resolutions of 150 to 450au . later , with alma , we aim for 0.1 arcsec resolution , or 15 - 45 au , close to the peak of the pre - main sequence binary separation distribution . the mm continuum emission is used to trace the optically thin thermal dust emission . the molecular gas is traced by the c@xmath1o(1@xmath20 ) and n@xmath3h@xmath4(1@xmath20 ) lines at 110 and at 93ghz , respectively . n@xmath3h@xmath4(1@xmath20 ) comprises seven hyperfine components and , compared to other molecules , depletes later and more slowly onto grains ( bergin & langer 1997 ) . it is , thus , a very reliable gas tracer of the the morphology of protostellar cores . initial results presented here are based on observations conducted at ovro in september and october 1999 . the 1 mm and 3 mm continuum maps have 1@xmath5 rms sensitivities of 4mjy / beam for hpbw 2.0@xmath61.5 and 0.7mjy / beam for hpbw 5.2@xmath64.2 , respectively . the n@xmath3h@xmath4 images were obtained at low resolution only and have a velocity resolution of 0.2km / s and a 1@xmath5 sensitivity of 110mjy / beam for hpbw 13@xmath69.4 . the nir , submm , and 1.2 mm continuum observations were performed at the 3.5 m calar alto telescope ( magic ) , the 15 m jcmt ( scuba ) , and the iram 30 m telescope ( 19-channel bolometer array ) . we wish to thank th . henning , r. zylka , r. lenzen , d. ward - thompson , and j. kirk who are involved in these programs . cb230 is a bok globule located at a distance of @xmath0450pc . it contains a strong submm / mm continuum source ( launhardt & henning 1997 ; launhardt et al . 1998 , 2000 ) and a dense cs core which shows spectroscopic signature of mass infall ( launhardt et al . 1997 ) . the dense core is associated with two nir reflection nebulae separated by @xmath010 ( yun 1996 ; launhardt 1996 ) . the western nebula is bipolar with a bright northern lobe perfectly aligned with the blue lobe of a well - collimated co outflow ( yun & clemens 1994 ) . the much fainter southern ( red ) part of this bipolar nebula seems heavily obscured possibly by the infalling envelope . no star is visible and the nir morphology can be interpreted as light emerging from a deeply embedded yso and scattered outward through the outflow cone directed towards us . the eastern nir nebula is much fainter and redder and displays no bipolar structure . previous single - dish mm continuum and molecular line observations did not resolve the central part of the dense core . but they demonstrated that the mm emission has a core - envelope structure and peaks at the origin the western bipolar nir nebula ( fig . 1 , top row ) . the slight extension of the continuum emission to the south east suggests that the faint eastern nir source is also associated with circumstellar material . the new ovro continuum maps at 1 mm and 3 mm ( fig . 1 , bottom row ) show only one unresolved component clearly associated with the origin of the western bipolar nebula . the compactness and location of the 1 mm continuum source observed ( @xmath7400au e - w extent ) , together with the bipolar structure of the nir nebula , suggest the presence of a circumstellar disk . the compact source contains @xmath010% of the total 1 mm continuum flux in the iram map . a significant contribution by free - free emission can be ruled out since the bolometric luminosity of the entire cloud core of 11l@xmath8 points to a low - mass protostar with no capability to ionize its environment ( launhardt et al . . the eastern source may be too faint to detect ( @xmath9mjy at 3 mm and @xmath10mjy at 1 mm ) or no compact disk is associated with it . in contrast to the dust continuum emission , all seven hyperfine structure components of the n@xmath3h@xmath4(10 ) line are detected at both nir positions . the n@xmath3h@xmath4 data resolve the molecular cloud core into two separate components each of which is spatially coincident with one of the two nir nebulae ( fig . the projected separation of the two sources is @xmath05000au . the double core seems to rotate around an axis perpendicular to the connecting line and approximately parallel ( in projection ) to the outflow of the western source . a comparison of the kinetic , gravitational , and rotational energy of the double core system shows that the two cores are gravitationally bound . this is consistent with the assumption that the double core formed due to rotational fragmentation from a single cloud core and with the orientation of the assumed circumstellar accretion disk around the western protostar . the angular resolution is not yet high enough to derive the rotation curves of the individual cores , but planned observations should improve the resolution considerably . the projected separation of @xmath05000au is at the upper end of the pre - main - sequence binary separation distribution , nevertheless , these preliminary results suggest that the bok globule cb230 contains a `` true '' wide binary protostar system . bergin , e.a . , & langer , w.d . 1997 , , 486 , 316 bonnell , i. , martel , h. , bastien , p. , et al . 1991 , , 377 , 553 boss , a.p . , & myhill , e.a . 1995 , , 451 , 218 boss , a.p . 1999 , , 520 , 744 burkert , a. , & bodenheimer , p. 1996 , , 280 , 1190 fuller , g.a . , ladd , e.f . , & hodapp , k .- w . 1996 , , 463 , l97 launhardt , r. 1996 , phd thesis , university of jena launhardt , r. , & henning , th . 1997 , , 326 , 329 launhardt , r. , evans ii , n.j . , wang j. , et al . 1997 , , 119 , 59 launhardt , r. ward - thompson , d. , & henning th . 1998 , , 288 , l45 launhardt , r. , henning , th . , & zylka , r. 2000 , in preparation looney , l.w . , mundy , l.g . , & welch , w.j . 1997 , , 484 , l157 yun , j.l . & clemens , d.p . 1994 , , 92 , 145 yun , j.l . 1996 , , 111 , 930

in an effort to shed more light on the formation process of binary stars , we have started a program to study multiplicity among nearby low- and intermediate - mass protostars using the ovro millimeter array . here , we describe the project and present the first results on the protostellar core in the bok globule cb230 ( l1177 ) . at 10 resolution , the molecular core is resolved into two components separated by @xmath05000au . the morphology and kinematics of the double core suggest that it formed from a single cloud core due to rotational fragmentation . # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in

1408.5711

in the modern mathematical literature , catalan numbers are wonderfully ubiquitous . although they appear in a variety of disguises , we are so used to having them around , it is perhaps hard to imagine a time when they were either unknown or known but obscure and underappreciated . it may then come as a surprise that catalan numbers have a rich history of multiple rediscoveries until relatively recently . below we review over 200 years of history , from their first discovery to modern times . we break the history into short intervals of mathematical activity , each covered in a different section . we spend most of our effort on the early history , but do bring it to relatively recent developments . we should warn the reader that although this work is in the history of mathematics , we are not a mathematical historian . rather , this work is more of a historical survey with some added speculations based on our extensive reading of the even more extensive literature . due to the space limitations , this survey is very much incomplete , as we tend to emphasize first discoveries and papers of influence rather than describe subsequent developments . this paper in part is based on our earlier investigation reported in @xcite . many primary sources are assembled on the _ catalan numbers website _ @xcite , including scans of the original works and their english translations . ming antu , sometimes written mingantu ( c.1692c.1763 ) was a chinese scientist and mathematician , native of inner mongolia . in 1730s , he wrote a book _ quick methods for accurate values of circle segments _ which included a number of trigonometric identities and power series , some involving catalan numbers : @xmath0 the integrality of catalan numbers played no role in this work . ming antu s book was published only in 1839 , and the connection to catalan numbers was observed by luo jianjin in 1988 . we refer to @xcite for more on this work and further references . in 1751 , leonhard euler ( 17071783 ) introduced and found a closed formula for what we now call the _ catalan numbers_. the proof of this result had eluded him , until he was assisted by christian goldbach ( 16901764 ) , and more substantially by johann segner . by 1759 , a complete proof was obtained . this and the next section tell the story of how this happened . on september 4 , 1751 , euler wrote a letter to goldbach which among other things included his discovery of catalan numbers . euler was in berlin ( prussia ) at that time , while his friend and former mentor goldbach was in st . petersburg ( imperial russia ) . they first met when euler arrived to st . petersburg back in 1727 as a young man , and started a lifelong friendship , with 196 letters between them @xcite . euler defines catalan numbers @xmath1 as the number of triangulations of @xmath2-gon , and gives the values of @xmath1 for @xmath3 ( evidently , computed by hand ) . all these values , including @xmath4 are correct . euler then observes that successive ratios have a pattern and guesses the following formula for catalan numbers : @xmath5 for example , @xmath6 . he concludes with the formula for the catalan numbers g.f . : @xmath7 in his reply to euler dated october 16 , 1751 , goldbach notes that the g.f . @xmath8 satisfies quadratic equation @xmath9 he then suggests that this equation can be used to derive catalan numbers via an infinite family of equations on its coefficients . euler writes back to goldbach on december 4 , 1751 . there , he explains how one can obtain the product formula from the binomial formula : @xmath10 from the context of the letter , it seems that euler knew the exact form of before his investigation of the catalan numbers . thus , once he found the product formula , he was able to derive rather than simply guess it . we believe that euler did not include his derivation in the first letter as the g.f . formula appears at the very end of it , but once goldbach became interested he patiently explained all the steps , as well as other similar formulas . johann andreas von segner ( 17041777 ) was another frequent correspondent of euler . although segner was older , euler rose to prominence faster , and in 1755 crucially helped him to obtain a position at university of halle , see @xcite . it seems , there was a bit of competitive tension between them , which adversely affected the story . in the late 1750s , euler suggested to segner the problem of counting the number of triangulations of an @xmath11-gon . we speculate based on segner s later work , that euler told him only values up to @xmath12 , and neither the product formula nor the g.f . . segner accepted the challenge and in 1758 wrote a paper @xcite , whose main result is a recurrence relation which he finds and proves combinatorially : @xmath13 he then uses the formula to compute the values of @xmath1 , @xmath14 , but makes an arithmetic mistake in computing @xmath15 , which then invalidates all larger values . euler must have realized that equation is the last missing piece necessary to prove . he arranged for segner s paper to be published in the journal of st . petersburg academy of sciences , but with his own _ summary _ @xcite . in it , he states , gives segner a lavish compliment , then points out his numerical mistake , and correctly computes all @xmath1 for @xmath16 . it seems unlikely that given the simple product formula , segner would have computed @xmath17 incorrectly , so we assume that euler shared it only with his close friend goldbach , and kept segner in the dark until after the publication . in summary , a combination of results of euler and segner , combined with goldbach s observation gives a complete proof of the product formula . unfortunately , it took about 80 years until the first complete proof was published . semn kirillovich kotelnikow ( 17231806 ) was a russian mathematician of humble origin who lived in st . petersburg all his life . in 1766 , soon after the raid on berlin , euler returned to st . same year , kotelnikow writes a paper @xcite elaborating on catalan numbers . although he claimed to have another way to verify , larcombe notes that he `` does little more than play around with the formula '' @xcite . nicolas fuss ( 17551826 ) was a swiss born mathematician who moved to st . petersburg to become euler s assistant in 1773 . he married euler s granddaughter , became a well known mathematician in his own right , and remained in russia until death . in his 1795 paper @xcite , in response to pfaff s question on the number of subdivisions of an @xmath11-gon into @xmath18-gons , fuss introduced what is now know as the _ fuss catalan numbers _ ( see exercise a14 ) , and gave a generalization of segner s formula , but not the product formula . in 1836 , a young french mathematician joseph liouville ( 18091882 ) founded the _ journal de mathmatiques pures et appliques_. he was in the center of mathematical life in paris and maintained a large mailing list , which proved critical in this story . in 1838 , a jewish french mathematician and mathematical historian olry terquem ( 17821862 ) asked liouville if he knows a simple way to derive euler s formula from segner s recurrence . liouville in turn communicated this problem to `` various geometers '' . what followed is a remarkable sequence of papers giving foundation to `` catalan studies '' . first , gabriel lam ( 17951870 ) wrote a letter to liouville outlining the solution , a letter liouville promptly published in the _ journal _ and further popularized @xcite . lam s solution was to use an elegant double counting argument . let s count the number @xmath19 of triangulations of an @xmath2-gon with one of its @xmath20 diagonals oriented . on the one hand , @xmath21 . on the other hand , by summing over all possible directed diagonals we have @xmath22 combining these two formulas with easily implies . in 1738 , belgium born mathematician eugne charles catalan ( 18141894 ) was a student of liouville at cole polytechnique . inspired by the work of lam , he became interested in the problem . he was the first to obtain what are now standard formulas @xmath23 he then studied the problem of computing the number of different ( non - associative ) products of @xmath11 variables , equivalent to counting the number of bracket sequences @xcite . olinde rodrigues ( 17951851 ) was a descendant of a large sephardic jewish family from bordeaux . he received his doctorate in mathematics and had a career as a banker in paris , but continued his mathematical interests . in the same volume of the _ journal _ , he published two back - to - back short notes giving a more direct double counting proof of . the first note @xcite gives a variation on lam s argument , a beautiful idea often regarded a folklore . roughly , he counts in two ways the number @xmath24 of triangulations of @xmath2-gon where either an edge or a diagonal is oriented . on the one hand , @xmath25 . on the other hand , @xmath26 , since triangulations with an oriented diagonal are in bijection with triangulations of @xmath27-gon obtained by inserting a triangle in place of a diagonal , and such edge can be any edge except the first one . we omit the details . in @xcite , rodrigues gives a related , but even simpler argument for counting the bracket sequences . denote by @xmath28 the number of bracket sequences of labeled terms @xmath29 , e.g. @xmath30 . then , on the one hand @xmath31 . on the other hand , @xmath32 since variable @xmath33 can be inserted into every bracket sequence in exactly @xmath34 ways . to see this , place a bracket around every variable and the whole product , e.g. @xmath35 . now observe that a new variable is inserted immediately to the left of any of the @xmath36 left brackets , or immediately to the right of any of the @xmath36 right brackets , e.g. @xmath37 in 1839 , clearly unaware of euler s letters , a senior french mathematician jacques binet ( 17861856 ) wrote a paper @xcite with a complete g.f . proof of . across the border in germany , johann august grunert ( 17971872 ) became interested in the work of the frenchmen on the one hand , and of fuss on the other . a former student of pfaff , in a 1841 paper @xcite he found a product formula for the fuss catalan numbers . he employed g.f.s to reduce the problem to @xmath38 but seemed unable to finish the proof . the complete proof was given in 1843 by liouville @xcite using the _ lagrange inversion _ ( see @xcite ) . after a few more mostly analytic papers inspired by the problem , the attention of the french school turned elsewhere . catalan however returned to the problem on several occasions throughout his career . even fifty years later , in 1878 , he published _ sur les nombres de segner _ @xcite on divisibility of the catalan numbers . thomas kirkman ( 18061895 ) was a british ordained minister who had a strong interest in mathematics . in 1857 , unaware of the previous work but with cayley s support , he published a lengthy treatise @xcite . there , he introduced the _ kirkman cayley numbers _ , defined as the number of ways to divide an @xmath11-gon with @xmath18 non - intersecting diagonals ( see a41 ) , and states a general product formula , which he proves in a few special cases . in 1857 , arthur cayley ( 18211895 ) was a lawyer in london and extremely prolific mathematically . he was interested in a related counting of _ plane trees _ , and in 1859 published a short note @xcite , where ( among other things ) he gave a conventional g.f . proof of that the number of plane trees is the catalan number . like kirkman , he was evidently unaware of the previous work . his final formula is @xmath39 which he called `` a remarkably simple form '' . curiously , in the same paper he also discovered and computed the g.f . for the _ ordered bell numbers_. in 1860 , cayley won a professorship in cambridge and soon became a central figure in british mathematics . few years later , henry martyn taylor ( 18421927 ) became a student in cambridge , where he remained much of his life , working in geometry , mathematical education and politics . in 1882 , he and r. c. rowe published a paper @xcite where they carefully examined the literature of the french school , but gave an erroneous description of the euler segner story . they evidently missed later papers by grunert and liouville , and computed the fuss catalan numbers along similar lines , using the lagrange inversion , see @xcite . cayley continued exploring g.f . methods for a variety of enumerative problems , among over 900 papers he wrote . in 1891 , cayley used g.f . tour de force to completely resolve kirkman s problem @xcite . the _ ballot numbers _ were first defined by catalan in 1839 , disguised as the number of certain triangulations @xcite . we believe this contribution was largely forgotten since catalan gave a formula for the ballot numbers in terms of the catalan numbers , but neither gave a closed formula nor even a table of the first few values . the ballot sequences were first introduced in 1878 by william allen whitworth ( 18401905 ) , a british mathematician , a priest and a fellow at cambridge . he resolved the problem completely by an elegant counting argument and found interesting combinatorial applications @xcite . despite both geographical and mathematical proximity to cayley , he did not notice that the numbers @xmath40 he computed are the catalan numbers . in modern terminology , the _ ballot problem _ was introduced in 1887 by joseph bertrand ( 18221900 ) . in a half a page note @xcite , he defined the probability @xmath41 that in an election with @xmath42 voters , a candidate who gathered @xmath43 votes is always leading the candidate with @xmath11 votes . bertrand announced that one can use induction to show that @xmath44 he famously concludes by saying : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ il semble vraisemblable quun rsultat aussi simple pourrait se dmontrer dune manire plus directe . ( it seems probable that such a simple result could be shown in a more direct way . ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ within months , bertrand s protg joseph - mile barbier ( 18391889 ) announced a generalization of @xmath41 to larger proportions of leading votes @xcite , a probabilistic version of the formula for the fuss catalan numbers . dsir andr ( 18401918 ) was a well known french combinatorialist , a former student of bertrand . he published an elegant proof of bertrand s theorem @xcite in the same 1887 volume of _ comptes rendu _ as bertrand and barbier . although he is often credited with the _ reflection method _ , this attribution is incorrect , as andre s proof was essentially equivalent to that by whitworth ( cf . the reflection principle is in fact due to dmitry semionovitch mirimanoff ( 18611945 ) , a russian - swiss mathematician who discovered it in 1923 , in a short note @xcite . andre s original proof was clarified and extended to barbier s proposed generalization in @xcite . we should mention here takcs s thorough treatment of the history of the ballot problem in probabilistic context @xcite , humphreys s historical survey on general lattice paths and the reflection principle @xcite , and bru s historical explanation on how bertrand learned it from ampre @xcite . despite a large literature , for decades the catalan numbers remained largely unknown and unnamed in contrast with other celebrated sequences , such as the fibonacci and bernoulli numbers . yet the number of publications on catalan numbers was growing rapidly , so much that we can not attempt to cover even a fraction of them . here are few major appearances . the first monograph citing the catalan numbers is the _ thorie des nombres _ by douard lucas ( 18421891 ) , published in paris in 1891 . despite the title , the book had a large combinatorial content , including rodrigues s proof of catalan s combinatorial interpretation in terms of brackets and products @xcite . the next notable monograph is the _ lehrbuch der combinatorik _ by eugen netto ( 18481919 ) , published in leipzig in 1901 . this is one of the first combinatorics monographs ; it includes a lot of material on permutations and combinations , and it devotes several sections to the papers by catalan , rodrigues and some related work by schrder @xcite . we should mention that these monographs were more the exception than the rule . many classical combinatorial books do not mention catalan numbers at all , most notably percy macmahon , _ combinatorial analysis _ ( 1915/6 ) , john riordan , _ an introduction to combinatorial analysis _ ( 1958 ) , and h. j. ryser , _ combinatorial mathematics _ ( 1963 ) . a crucial contribution was made by william g. brown in 1965 , when he recognized and collected a large number of references on the `` euler segner problem '' and the `` pfaff fuss problem '' , as he called them @xcite . to denote the catalan numbers . ] from this point on , hundreds of papers involving catalan numbers have been published and all standard textbooks started to include it ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * @xmath453.2 ) and ( * ? ? ? * @xmath453 ) for an early adoption ) . some 465 references were assembled by henry w. gould in a remarkable bibliography @xcite , which first appeared in 1971 and revised in 2007 . at about that time , various lists of combinatorial interpretations of catalan numbers started to appear , see e.g. @xcite , appendix 1 and a very different kind of list in @xcite . because of their chaotic history , the catalan numbers have received this name relatively recently . in the old literature , they were sometimes called the _ segner numbers _ or the _ euler segner numbers _ , which is historically accurate as their articles were the first published work on the subject . perhaps surprisingly , we are able to tell exactly who named them _ catalan numbers _ and when . our investigation of this _ eponymy _ is informal , but we hope convincing ( cf . @xcite for an example of a proper historical investigation ) . first , let us discard two popular theories : that the name was introduced by netto in @xcite or by bell in @xcite . upon careful study of the text , it is clear that netto did single out catalan s work and in general was not particularly careful with the references , but never specifically mentioned `` catalan zahlen '' . similarly , eric temple bell ( 18831960 ) was a well known mathematical historian , and referred to `` catalan s numbers '' only in the context of catalan s work . in a footnote , he in fact referred to them as the `` euler segner sequence '' and clarifies the history of the problem . our investigation shows that the credit for naming catalan numbers is due to an american combinatorialist john riordan ( 19031988 ) . he tried this three times . the first two : _ math reviews _ mr0024411 ( 1948 ) and mr0164902 ( 1964 ) went unnoticed . even marshall hall s influential 1967 monograph @xcite does not have the name . but in 1968 , when riordan used `` catalan numbers '' in the monograph @xcite , he clearly struck a chord . although riordan s book is now viewed as somewhat disorganized and unnecessarily simplistic , back in the day it was quite popular . it was lauded as `` excellent and stimulating '' in p.r . stein s review , which continued to say `` combinatorial identities is , in fact , a book that must be read , from cover to cover , and several times . '' we are guessing it had a great influence on the field and cemented the terminology and some notation . we have further evidence of riordan s authorship of a different nature : the _ ngram chart _ for the words `` catalan numbers '' , which searches google books content for this sentence over the years . the search clearly shows that the name spread after 1968 and that riordan s monograph was the first book which contained it . there were three more events on the way to the wide adoption of the name `` catalan numbers '' . in 1971 , henry gould used it in the early version of @xcite , a bibliography of catalan numbers with 243 entries . then , in 1973 , neil sloane gave this name to the sequence entry in @xcite , with riordan s monograph and gould s bibliography being two of the only five references . but the real popularity ( as supported by the ngram chart ) , was achieved after the martin gardner s _ scientific american _ column in june 1976 , popularizing the subject : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ catalan numbers ] have [ .. ] delightful propensity for popping up unexpectedly , particularly in combinatorial problems . indeed , the catalan sequence is probably the most frequently encountered sequence that is still obscure enough to cause mathematicians lacking access to n.j.a . sloane s _ handbook of integer sequences _ to expend inordinate amounts of energy re - discovering formulas that were worked out long ago . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ now that we have covered over 200 years of the history of catalan numbers , it is worth pondering if the subject matter is worth the effort . here we defer to others , and include the following helpful quotes , in no particular order . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ it is not exaggerated to say that the catalan numbers are the most prominent sequence in combinatorics . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the catalan numbers are one of the most important sequences of combinatorial numbers , with a large range of occurrences in apparently different counting problems . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the catalan numbers are , next to the binomial coefficients , the best studied of all combinatorial counting numbers . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ catalan numbers are probably the most frequently occurring combinatorial numbers after the binomial coefficients . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ mathematicians are often amazed that certain mathematical objects ( numbers , sequences , etc . ) show up so often . for example , in enumerative combinatorics we encounter the fibonacci and catalan sequences in many problems that seem to have nothing to do with each other . [ .. ] the answer , once again , is our human predilection for triviality . [ .. ] the catalan sequence is the simplest sequence whose generating function is a ( genuine ) algebraic formal power series . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the catalan numbers are a favorite pastime of many amateur ( and professional ) mathematicians . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ catalan numbers are the subject of [ much ] interest ( sometimes known as _ catalan disease _ ) . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ catalan numbers are even more fascinating [ than the _ fibonacci numbers _ ] . like the north star in the evening sky , they are a beautiful and bright light in the mathematical heavens . they continue to provide a fertile ground for number theorists , especially , catalan enthusiasts and computer scientists . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ i d have to say my favorite number sequence is the catalan numbers . [ .. ] catalan numbers just come up so many times . it was well - known before me that they had many different combinatorial interpretations . [ .. ] when i started teaching enumerative combinatorics , of course i did the catalan numbers . when i started doing these very basic interpretations any enumerative course would have some of this i just liked collecting more and more of them and i decided to be systematic . before , it was just a typed up list . when i wrote the book , i threw everything i knew in the book . then i continued from there with a website , adding more and more problems . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ * acknowledgments : * . we are very grateful to richard stanley for the suggestion to write this note . we would also like to thank maria rybakova for her help with translation of @xcite , to xavier viennot for showing us the scans of euler s original letter to goldbach , and to peter larcombe for sending me his paper and help with other references . the author was partially supported by the nsf .

we give a brief history of catalan numbers , from their first discovery in the 18th century to modern times . this note will appear as an appendix in richard stanley s forthcoming book @xcite . department of mathematics , ucla , los angeles , ca , 90095 . .06 cm email : .06 cm ` pak@math.ucla.edu ` ] .9 cm

1306.2745

the first generation of stars , so - called population iii stars were formed at the end of the cosmic dark ages and their birth brought the first light into the cosmos . they emitted radiation and altered the dynamics of the universe by heating and ionizing the gas . they also polluted the universe with metals and injected mechanical energy through stellar winds and supernova explosions @xcite . consequently , they influenced the subsequent generation of structures through their feedback effects . to comprehend their formation is a matter of prime astrophysical interest . according to the present paradigm of structure formation , pop iii stars were assembled in minihaloes with masses of few times @xmath3 @xcite . the collapse in these halos is induced by molecular hydrogen whose rotational and vibrational modes can be excited to lower temperatures of about a few hundred k. previous studies showed that the first stars were massive with a mass range of about 30 - 300 m@xmath4 and lived solitary lives @xcite . however , a new picture has emerged during the past few years . recent simulations have shown that the protostellar disk fragments into multiple clumps which may lead to the formation of binary or multiple systems @xcite . most of the simulations described above have been carried out using smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) , and the studies by @xcite used the moving - mesh code arepo @xcite . all of these studies have thus been performed using lagrangian methods . @xcite , on the other hand , reported binary formation with a grid - based code , but as a result of two density peaks which happened to simultaneously collapse . with grid - based methods , on the other hand , and the piecewise - parabolic method ( ppm ) available in enzo , it is possible to study turbulent fragmentation much more accurately . in this context , previous numerical simulations demonstrated the requirement of a jeans resolution of at least 32 cells to obtain converged turbulent energies @xcite . the jeans resolution employed in the previous fragmentation studies was however systematically lower . we note in particular that sph simulations benefit from high resolution at the initial stage , but run out of resolution in the late stages of the collapse . @xcite reported the absence of a protostellar disk at high resolution per jeans length , a result potentially inhibiting fragmentation via disk instabilities . their study however explored only the formation of the first peak . it is thus essential to study fragmentation at high resolution per jeans length , which goes beyond the formation of the first peak . we further explore the impact of unresolved turbulence , which was found to have a strong impact on fragmentation in atomic cooling halos @xcite . such turbulence may efficiently amplify magnetic fields during primordial star formation . we carry out large - eddy cosmological simulations by tracking the evolution beyond the formation of the first clump in minihaloes where cooling is regulated by molecular hydrogen . this allows us to study fragmentation at high resolution with the grid code enzo after the formation of the first peak . we employ a fixed jeans resolution of 64 cells per jeans length throughout the evolution of the simulations and follow the collapse down to the scale of 0.1 au for 40 years using the adaptive mesh technique . these are the first large eddy simulations to investigate the impact of sgs turbulence . this study will enable us to assess the impact of resolved and subgrid turbulence in the formation of first stars . our approach is the following . in section 2 , we describe numerical methods and simulations setup . in section 3 , we present our results . we summarize our main findings and discuss further implications in section 4 . we present here simulations which are performed using a modified version of the adaptive mesh refinement code enzo @xcite including a subgrid - scale ( sgs ) model which takes into account unresolved turbulence @xcite . the simulations are commenced with cosmological initial conditions generated from gaussian random fields at @xmath5 with a grid resolution of @xmath6 cells . the size of comoving periodic box is 300 kpc @xmath7 and the most massive halo lies at its center . we subsequently employ two additional nested refinement levels , each with a grid resolution of @xmath6 cells . in all , we use 5767168 particles to simulate the dark matter dynamics . this provides us a dark matter resolution of 70 @xmath8 . the parameters used for generating the initial conditions are taken from the wmap seven years data @xcite . additional 26 dynamical refinement levels are employed in the central comoving 26.7 kpc of the halo during the evolution of the simulation , giving a resolution of sub au scales ( in physical units ) . the refinement criteria used in these simulations are the same as in @xcite . we mandated a resolution of 64 cells per jeans length during the entire course of evolution . when the highest refinement level is reached , the thermal evolution becomes adiabatic . this approach enables us to follow the formation of structures beyond the formation of the first peak until a peak density of @xmath9 is reached , which corresponds to 40 years . collapse in primordial minihaloes is triggered by @xmath10 cooling which can bring the gas temperature down to a few hundred k. to model the primordial non - equilibrium chemistry , the rate equations of @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath10 , @xmath18 are self - consistently solved in the cosmological simulations . we also include the effect of heating from the formation of molecular hydrogen via three - body reactions . this study was performed using the modified version of chemical solver developed by @xcite and @xcite ( see @xcite for details ) . to take into account the unresolved turbulence , large eddy simulations ( les ) were performed employing the sgs turbulence model of @xcite . the latter is a mathematical model for turbulence based on a scale separation approach where resolved and unresolved scales are connected via an eddy - viscosity closure to transfer energy non - linearly across the grid scales . the turbulent viscosity is calculated on the grid scale and the subgrid scale turbulence is computed from self - consistently defined sgs energy generation and dissipation terms . on other hand , implicit large eddy simulations ( iles ) use only the numerical dissipation coming from the discretization errors of the compressible fluid dynamics equations . the latter is the standard technique in computational astrophysics . our previous studies describe further details of les . our study consists of 3 distinct halos selected from different gaussian random seeds . the results from the les are compared with iles . in total , we run 6 simulations . we have performed 3 les and 3 equivalent iles runs for three distinct haloes named a , b and c. they have masses of @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 respectively . the collapse redshifts for these haloes are 21.7 , 18.1 and 22.0 . in the early phases of collapse gas falls in the dark matter potential , gets shock heated and leads to the nonlinear evolution . during the course of virialization , gravitational potential energy is continuously converted into kinetic energy of the gas and the dark matter . the properties of the halos at the maximum refinement level are shown in figure [ fig0 ] . the density profiles of different halos for les and iles runs agree very well and show @xmath22 behavior at scales larger than 100 au @xcite . the profile becomes flat in the center which is equivalent to the jeans length . this behavior is consistent with earlier studies . gas is initially heated up to its virial temperature and then subsequently cools by the rotational and vibrational modes of @xmath10 . at densities above @xmath23 , @xmath10 formation heating becomes effective and heats the gas to @xmath24 1000 k. the thermal evolution is the same for all halos at scales above 100 au . small temperature variations in the center may arise due to the differences in halo masses . the fraction of molecular hydrogen is low in the outskirts and close to one in the center which shows that the core of the halo becomes fully molecular . the amount of molecular hydrogen is slightly lower for massive halos and higher for the less massive halo . we attribute these differences to the self - regulation of molecular hydrogen due to the formation and collisional dissociation of @xmath10 molecules . furthermore , the formation of @xmath10 is very sensitive to the choice of three - body reactions ( for details see * ? ? ? the specific turbulent energy is about @xmath25 and the variations in turbulent energy are less than order of magnitude . the morphology of the haloes when simulations reach the maximum refinement level is shown in figure [ fig1 ] . at this stage of the collapse , the morphology is nearly - spherical for all haloes . there is no indication for the formation of a disk at this stage of collapse consistent with the results by @xcite . however , we see that in les runs the morphology is different from iles runs . overall , the gas clouds are more extended in les runs . this behavior is consistent with our previous study on more massive halos @xcite . in order to follow the evolution beyond the first peak , we switch off the cooling above densities of @xmath26 to obtain an adiabatic evolution at higher densities when reaching the highest refinement levels . this approach allows us to study fragmentation without using sink particles . turbulent accretion continues on the central clump and the final stage of the simulations is shown in figure [ fig2 ] . a disk is formed in the center of each halo for both les and iles runs . to further confirm the presence of a disk , we computed the eigenvalues of the inertia tensor and compared them with the state when the simulation reached the maximum refinement level . for halo a , the eigenvalues of the moments of inertia are almost equal ( i.e. , 1.74 , 1.46 , 1.39 ) when simulations reach the maximum refinement level . it indicates that the central clump is almost spherical at this stage and confirms our hypothesis that a disk is not formed yet . the eigenvalues of the moments of inertia after 40 years are 9.23 , 6.23 and 6.49 . the eigenvalues of two components of moments of inertia are equal while the value of the perpendicular component is about 1.6 times the values in disk plane . the expected values of the perpendicular component for a thin disk is twice the values in disk plane . we conclude that the disks formed here are thick in the vertical direction . very similar results are found for the other haloes . in our simulated sample , one halo fragments into 3 clumps which may lead to the formation of multiple system . no fragmentation is observed in iles runs . there are also indications for the formation of further clumps in the rest of the halos outside the disk . thus , we do not rule out the possibility of further fragmentation . radial profiles for the physical properties of the central disks are shown in figure [ fig3 ] . the typical rotational velocity is a few @xmath27 for all disks . it is low in the center , peaks around 10 au and then there is a decline at larger radii following the keplerian rotation . the radial velocity is a few @xmath27 which indicates the infall of gas to the central disk . the average gas accretion rates on the central disks are a few times @xmath28 which are typical for minihaloes . the mass radial profile increases sharply in the center , becomes flat and then linearly increases with radius . this behavior is observed for all runs . the masses of the central disks are about 10 m@xmath4 . the ratio of sgs turbulence production to dissipation shows they are in equilibrium in the center of the disk but production dominates in the surroundings excited by the gravitational instabilities . the subgrid scale energy is about comparable to thermal energy . it increases towards the center due to local production of turbulence during the gravitational collapse consistent with earlier studies @xcite . to quantify the role of turbulence , we followed the dynamics of gas compression employing a differential equation for the divergence of the velocity field @xmath29 @xcite : @xmath30 here , @xmath31 , @xmath32 is the overdensity relative to the mean density @xmath33 and @xmath34 represents the local support terms against gravitational compression . @xmath34 receives contributions from thermal pressure , resolved turbulence and the sgs turbulent pressure . the contribution of local support terms like thermal pressure , resolved and subgrid turbulence scaled by gravitational compression ( i.e. , @xmath35 ) are shown in figure [ fig4 ] . the compression by gravity dominates above 100 au while other supports terms remain sub - dominant . the impact of resolved and sgs turbulence becomes almost comparable to thermal pressure between 10 - 100 au . the overall contribution of the positive component of sgs turbulence support becomes almost equal to the thermal pressure which acts against gravity and helps in the formation of disk . the ratio of sgs - to - thermal support is about 30 % which is a factor of 4 lower than found in atomic cooling halos @xcite . we expect that positive support by sgs may become important at later stages of the collapse and particularly in the case of fragmentation on smaller scales . on the other hand , the negative component of resolved turbulence support aids the gravitational compression . in the very center of the halo , we have adiabatic core supported by thermal pressure . similar behavior is observed for all haloes . [ cols="^ " , ] c c & + & + & we present high resolution cosmological large - eddy simulations which track the evolution of high - density regions on scales of @xmath36 au beyond the formation of the first peak in minihalos , and also explore the effect of subgrid - scale turbulence . this is the first study to explore fragmentation with a grid code employing the highest resolution per jeans length in minihaloes which are predominantly cooled by molecular hydrogen . these simulations were performed for three distinct haloes . we compare the results of les and iles runs . in all , we carry out 6 simulations by following the collapse for 40 years beyond the first peak . our results show that self - gravitating disks are formed by turbulent accretion in all simulated haloes contrary to the previous study of @xcite . the masses of the disks are about @xmath37 at the final stage of our simulations and typical accretion rates are about @xmath38 . furthermore , fragmentation is observed in one out of 3 haloes which may lead to the formation of multiple systems . moreover , the formation of additional clumps proceeds at larger scales . no fragmentation is found in iles runs . the role of sgs turbulence becomes significant during the final stages of our simulation and may favor stable disks . our findings suggest the formation of a relatively massive central protostar of @xmath39 via turbulent accretion . we further expect the turbulent accretion to continue until the radiative feedback from the protostar becomes effective . the courant constraint limits the further evolution of simulations . we stopped our simulations after evolution of 40 years beyond the formation of the first peak when the simulations reached a peak density of @xmath40 . previous studies suggest large variation in the fragmentation time scales . it occurs on relatively short time scales of about 10 years in @xcite while in the simulations of @xcite the disk becomes unstable after the evolution of 60 - 90 years . fragmentation can thus still occur before the star reaches the main sequence . the time scale to reach main sequence is the kelvin - helmholtz time ( i. e. , @xmath41 years , * ? ? ? we also note that it would be desirable to explore fragmentation further on sub - au scales . subsequent fragmentation may still occur , as the star keeps accreting at later times . in spite of this , it seems likely that at least one high mass star will form . the accretion luminosity is expected to become important during the early stages of a protostar formation . this was explored in detail by @xcite finding that heating from accretion delays the fragmentation but does not completely prevent it . the protostar will continue to grow until the impact by uv feedback becomes significant , latter was examined by @xcite and @xcite . they found that once the mass of the star exceeds @xmath42 the kelvin - helmholtz ( kh ) time scale becomes shorter than the accretion time scale and the protostar passes through the so - called kh contraction phase . consequently , the stellar luminosity increases as well as the uv flux . when photo - heating and photo - ionization by uv radiation becomes significant , the hii region breaks out from the disk above @xmath43 , and further accretion will be suppressed . here , we presumed that the halo is metal free but the presence of trace amounts of dust can change the thermal evolution by boosting the formation of molecules and may induce further fragmentation . in such cases , where the disks are more unstable due to the enhanced cooling , the additional sgs pressure will be even more relevant . the simulations described in this work used the enzo code , developed by the laboratory for computational astrophysics at the university of california in san diego ( http://lca.ucsd.edu ) . we acknowledge research funding by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( dfg ) under grant sfb @xmath44 , project a12 and computing time from hlrn under project nip00029 . the simulation results are analyzed using the visualization toolkit for astrophysical data yt @xcite .

population iii stars forming in the infant universe at z=30 heralded the end of the cosmic dark ages . they are presumed to be assembled in so - called minihaloes with virial temperatures of a few thousand k where collapse is triggered by molecular hydrogen cooling . a central question concerns their final masses , and whether fragmentation occurs during their formation . while studies employing lagrangian codes suggest fragmentation via a self - gravitating disk , recent high resolution simulations indicated that disk formation is suppressed . here we report the first high - resolution large - eddy simulations performed with the eulerian grid - based code enzo following the evolution beyond the formation of the first peak , to investigate the accretion of the central massive clump and potential fragmentation . for a total of 3 halos , we see that a disk forms around the first clump . the central clump reaches @xmath0 solar masses after 40 years , while subsequent accretion is expected at a rate of @xmath1 solar masses per year . in one of these halos , additional clumps form as a result of fragmentation which proceeds at larger scales . we note that subgrid - scale turbulence yields relevant contributions to the stability of the protostellar disks . we conclude that the first protostar may reach masses up to @xmath2 , which are only limited by the effect of radiative feedback .

1501.05330

measurements of the masses and radii of neutron stars provide unique information on the equation of state of matter at densities above the nuclear saturation density . extremely accurate mass measurements in binary systems can be obtained through dynamical methods ( see , e.g. , stairs 2006 ; demorest et al . however , without independent determinations of the radii of these neutron stars , these measurements provide only limits for the equation of state . in contrast , an accurate measurement of the radius of even a single neutron star can provide strong constrains on the equation of state of neutron star matter ( lattimer & prakash 2001 ; zel & psaltis 2009 ; read et al . 2009 ) . thermonuclear x - ray bursts observed from low mass x - ray binaries have proven to be one of the most suitable events that can be used to measure both the radii and the masses of neutron stars ( see , e.g. , van paradijs 1978 , 1979 ; damen et al . 1990 ; lewin , van paradijs , & taam 1993 ; zel 2006 ) . using high signal - to - noise x - ray data and time - resolved spectroscopy allows a measurements of the apparent radius during the cooling segments of the bursts . in addition , time - resolved spectroscopy during a photospheric radius expansion burst enables a measurement of the eddington luminosity for each source . combining these two measurements leads to an uncorrelated determination of the neutron star mass and radius . thanks to the rossi x - ray timing explorer ( rxte ) , which provided more than 15 years of observations of bursts ( galloway et al . 2008 ) , it has now become possible to not only make neutron star mass and radius measurements using observations of specific systems ( see , e.g. , zel , gver , & psaltis 2009 ) but also to quantify the systematic uncertainties in these measurements . in paper i of these series ( gver , psaltis , & zel 2012a ) , we analyzed more than 13,000 x - ray spectra from 12 different sources and showed that the errors in the spectroscopic determination of neutron - star radii due to systematic effects in the cooling tails of x - ray bursts are in the range of @xmath23%@xmath08% . in paper ii ( gver , zel , & psaltis 2012b ) , we used all the archival photospheric radius expansion bursts and found that for sources from which a large number of bursts are observed , systematic uncertainties in the determination of the eddington flux are at the 5%@xmath010% level . in this paper , we focus on a third possible source of systematic uncertainty , which is the absolute flux calibration of the proportional counter array ( pca ) on board rxte . absolute flux uncertainties affect the normalization of the spectra obtained during bursts and therefore the measurement of both the apparent radii and of the eddington flux . determining the absolute flux calibration of an x - ray detector requires a major effort from any instrument team and all x - ray observatories put large amount of resources into in - flight calibrations of their detectors . however , these efforts are hindered by the fact that almost all x - ray sources in the sky that may be used as standard candles often show unpredicted variability over both long and short time scales ( see , e.g. , wilson - hodge et al . 2011 , and references therein for the recent activity of the crab nebula ) . additionally , complications due to significantly different responses of different detectors , both in terms of effective areas and the energy ranges that the detectors are sensitive to , become a major hurdle and restrict the inter - calibration efforts . furthermore , the often unknown intrinsic spectral shape of the astronomical objects being used for the calibration makes the problem even more complex . simultaneous observations of sources with well known intrinsic spectra by two or more x - ray detectors that have different energy responses allow us to better understand and quantify the systematic uncertainties in the absolute flux calibrations of individual detectors . in the early days of high energy astrophysics , the crab nebula was seen as the ideal stellar source for the calibration of various instruments . compiling a number of rocket , balloon , and satellite observations performed between 1964 and 1972 , toor & seward ( 1974 ) concluded that the diffuse x - ray emission should be steady at least for the time period they analyzed , since any variation in the pulsar emission larger than 10% at a few kev would have been detected . with these limits , they assumed that the crab is a steady source and provided a `` universal '' power - law amplitude and photon - index with their relevant uncertainties . in the following years , these values were often cited and used as a reference point to calibrate the performance of various instruments . norgaard - nielsen et al . ( 1994 ) even proposed a specific mission called _ excalibur _ to continuously monitor the crab nebula using two pinhole cameras one with a ccd and another with a proportional counter to measure the spectrum of the nebula with an accuracy @xmath32% over the energy range 0.8@xmath020 kev . such a mission could , in principle , be a reliable inter - calibration reference for subsequent detectors . using the crab as a standard source , kirsch et al . ( 2005 ) compared the xmm - newton / epic - pn measurements of the spectrum of crab with those from all the other modern x - ray satellites . in particular , they found that although the photon index inferred from xmm - newton / epic agrees within errors with the toor & seward ( 1974 ) value , the normalization derived from epic - pn is significantly lower than that from the rest of the instruments . they also noted that , with the new generation of instruments , crab is becoming a source that is too bright and too extended to be used as a standard calibration source . in a similar , later study , weisskopf et al . ( 2010 ) investigated possible departures from a single power - law of the intrinsic spectrum of crab for rosat / pspc , rxte / pca , and the xmm - newton / epic - pn , which would affect the instrument calibrations . using the high statistical quality of the rxte / pca data , these authors concluded that they would have been able to detect significant deviations from a simple power - law spectrum but they did not find any evidence for such a deviation . with the advancement of imaging detectors and considering the brightness of the crab for the onboard ccds , searches for new calibration sources and techniques started . in order to coordinate and improve the efforts on inter - calibration , a group of instrument teams formed the international astronomical consortium for high - energy calibration ( iachec , sembay et al . 2010 ) . one of the recent results of this group demonstrates that in the 2.0@xmath07.0 kev range , epic - pn measures systematically lower fluxes than the chandra acis , by 11.0@xmath10.5% ( nevalainen et al . 2010 ) , using a sample of 11 nearby clusters of galaxies . the difference is smaller yet still significant when acis is compared with epic mos1 and mos2 , with differences at 3.0@xmath10.5% and 6.0@xmath10.5% , respectively ( nevalainen et al . 2010 ) . the spectroscopic measurements of neutron star masses and radii have been predominantly performed with rxte . launched in 1995 and operated until 2012 , rxte / pca has always been calibrated against the crab nebula ( jahoda et al . 2006 ; shaposnikov et al . 2012 ) together with an onboard calibration source used mainly for channel - to - energy conversion . throughout the mission , any possible variations in the crab , as the one reported by wilson - hodge et al . ( 2011 ) , were assumed to be averaged out ( shaposnikov et al . 2012 ) ; this issue will be discussed further in section [ variable_source ] . because the pca was intrinsically calibrated against the crab and because it is a non - imaging instrument , inter - calibration of the pca has always been a challenge , especially as more and more sources such as clusters of galaxies or similarly soft and relatively dim objects ( i.e. , rx j1856.5@xmath03754 ) started to be used as standard candles . time resolved x - ray spectra extracted during thermonuclear x - ray bursts observed from low mass x - ray binaries offer a different opportunity in determining the systematic uncertainties caused by calibrations of different detectors . since the early studies of x - ray bursts , it has been shown that the burst x - ray spectra can statistically be modeled with blackbody functions ( see , e.g. , swank et al . 1977 ; lewin , van paradijs , & taam 1993 ; galloway et al . 2008 ) . in paper i , we analyzed more than 13,000 x - ray spectra extracted from the cooling tails of x - ray bursts observed from 12 different sources and showed that a planckian function can statistically fit the vast majority of the observations . the high count rates of rxte and the large number of bursts allowed us to show that any deviation from a planckian spectrum is limited to @xmath4 in the 2.5@xmath025.0 kev range . this almost unique characteristic of burst spectra make them ideal for testing our ability to convert countrate spectra to bolometric fluxes . furthermore , because the obtained spectral parameters are directly related to neutron star mass - radius measurements , results obtained from an analysis of x - ray burst data can be directly converted to uncertainties in the measurements of neutron star masses and radii . using simultaneous rxte , chandra x - ray observatory ( chandra ) , and xmm-_newton _ observations of x - ray bursts from gs 1826@xmath0238 , we quantify the differences in the measurements of the apparent surface area of the thermal emission when using different detectors with independent calibrations . we describe our method in section 2 , which is based on predicting the observed chandra and xmm-_newton _ countrates using time resolved spectral parameters obtained from rxte / pca . section 3 details the analysis of the data from different x - ray satellites . finally , in sections 4 and 5 we present our results and discuss their implications . the rapid evolution of the effective temperature during the cooling tails of thermonuclear x - ray bursts demands very short exposure time observations for direct comparison of spectral data that are obtained simultaneously . the short exposures require very high countrates and , hence , detectors with large photon collecting areas . this has been a unique property of rxte / pca but can not be achieved by the other instruments that we are going to compare its results against . therefore , we formulated an approach that does not rely on directly comparing the extracted spectra of x - ray bursts simultaneously observed with two ( or more ) x - ray satellites . instead , we first analyze the rxte data by performing time resolved x - ray spectroscopy . we extract spectra for short intervals ( 0.25@xmath02.0 s depending on the countrate ) and fit these data with blackbody functions . based on the obtained @xmath5 values , we then calculate the likelihood for a wide range of spectral parameters that cover the @xmath15@xmath6 range of the best fit values . we use this range of individual parameter pairs ( blackbody temperature and normalization ) to create simulations of chandra or xmm-_newton _ x - ray spectra and then to calculate the total rxte - predicted countrate in a given energy range . we calculate the uncertainty in these countrates by taking into account the posterior likelihoods of the rxte / pca parameters for each simulation . finally , we compare this predicted countrate with the countrate actually observed by chandra or xmm-_newton _ in the same energy range , taking into account all the associated uncertainties . assuming that there are no calibration uncertainties , the chandra and/or xmm-_newton _ count rates that were predicted by analysing the rxte observation should be in perfect agreement with the actual count rates observed with these satellites . a systematic offset on the other hand , would imply a discrepancy in the overall calibration of either or both detectors . it is evident that this method allows for the detection of a systematic uncertainty caused by the overall flux calibration of detectors and specifically in the determination of the normalization in a particular energy range . however , the method does not allow us to constrain any calibrational uncertainties in the determination of the spectral shape . we searched the archival rxte observations to find the best source that can be used for this purpose . an ideal source should be a frequent burster with a number of simultaneous observations and predictable burst properties . two low mass x - ray binaries in the archive conform to these conditions : the so - called clockwork burster gs 1826@xmath0238 and 4u 1636@xmath0536 . the problem with the latter source is that its bursts do not last long enough ( only about 20 s on average ) to obtain sufficient amount of data to infer any systematic trends during the cooling tails of x - ray bursts . on the other hand , with bursts that last on average 130 s , gs 1826@xmath0238 provides a significant amount of counts to be used for this purpose . gs 1826@xmath0238 was first discovered with the ginga satellite ( makino et al . 1988 ; tanaka 1989 ) . first conclusive detections of thermonuclear x - ray bursts from this source came from bepposax observations ( ubertini et al . 1997 ) , although x - ray bursts may have been observed from this source earlier by oso 7 ( markert et al . 1977 ) and oso 8 ( becker et al . 1976 ) . using 2.5 years of monitoring observations by bepposax , during which 70 x - ray bursts were detected , ubertini et al . ( 1999 ) reported that the x - ray bursts show a quasi - periodicity of 5.76 hr , a remarkable characteristic of this source . later , using 260 x - ray bursts observed with the wide field camera ( wfc ) on board bepposax over 6 years , cornelisse et al . ( 2003 ) showed that the burst recurrence time is indeed stable but decreases as the persistent flux increases . a total of 40 x - ray bursts were observed with the rxte between 1997 - 2003 ( galloway et al . 2008 ) . during this time interval , the persistent flux steadily increased as the burst recurrence time decreased ( galloway et al . another remarkable feature of the x - ray bursts observed from this source is their similarity . although the initial decay time - scale and the burst fluence show slight variations with persistent flux , the observed x - ray burst light curves are nearly identical and reproducible ( galloway et al . 2004 ) . the nearly identical light curves of individual bursts , predictable recurrence times , and , finally , already existing simultaneous observations with other x - ray satellites ( chandra and xmm- _ newton _ ) make gs 1826@xmath0238 an ideal target to understand and quantify the systematic uncertainties in the measurement of neutron - star masses and radii introduced by the uncertainties in the absolute flux calibration of rxte / pca . in this study , we use data from three different x - ray satellites . gs 1826@xmath0238 was observed simultaneously by chandra and rxte for the first time in 2002 , where three x - ray bursts were recorded . we present the analysis of these bursts below . furthermore , rxte observed the system in 2003 simultaneously with xmm-_newton_. during this observation , 7 x - ray bursts were detected with rxte . we analyze here 5 of these events because , during one of the remaining bursts , xmm-_newton _ was affected by high energy particle background ( burst # 28 ) while the other burst was only partially observed and did not have high time resolution data with rxte / pca ( burst # 29 ) . we present a log of these bursts in table [ bursts ] . cccc 22 & 52484.41775 & 70044 - 01 - 01 - 000 & chandra + 23 & 52484.56684 & 70044 - 01 - 01 - 00 & chandra + 24 & 52485.00672 & 70044 - 01 - 01 - 02 & chandra + 26 & 52736.53279 & 80048 - 01 - 01 - 00 & xmm-_newton _ + 27 & 52736.66488 & 80048 - 01 - 01 - 010 & xmm-_newton _ + 28 & 52736.80048 & 80048 - 01 - 01 - 010 & xmm-_newton _ + 29 & 52738.34118 & 80048 - 01 - 01 - 04 & xmm-_newton _ + 30 & 52738.47686 & 80048 - 01 - 01 - 04 & xmm-_newton _ + 31 & 52738.61013 & 80048 - 01 - 01 - 07 & xmm-_newton _ + 32 & 52738.74636 & 80048 - 01 - 01 - 07 & xmm-_newton _ [ bursts ] the rxte observations were analyzed following the method detailed in paper i. time resolved , 2.5@xmath025.0 kev x - ray spectra were extracted from science event mode data ( 125 @xmath7s time resolution and 64 energy channels ) using the ftool _ seextrct _ from all of the rxte / pca layers . for each burst , spectra were integrated over 0.25 , 0.5 , 1 or 2 s time intervals so that the total number of counts in each spectrum remain roughly the same while the countrate decreases during a burst . a 16 s x - ray spectrum was extracted from a time interval just prior to each burst , as the spectrum of the persistent emission , and subtracted from the x - ray burst spectra as background . we took the pca deadtime correction into account following the procedure described in paper i. response matrix files were created for each burst separately using the pcarsp version 11.7 , heasoft 6.7 and heasarc s remote calibration database . x - ray spectral analysis was performed using the interactive spectral interpretation system ( isis ) , version 1.4.9 - 55 ( houck & denicola 2000 ) and , for each fit , a systematic uncertainty of 0.5% was included as suggested by the rxte calibration team . we note that we also investigated the possibility of photon pile - up in the rxte / pca data following tomsick & kaaret ( 1998 ) and jahoda et al . ( 2006 ) . during the decay of the x - ray bursts investigated here , the observed count rates are @xmath81600 cts / s / pcu , which is far below the threshold of 10000 cts / s / pcu , where pile - up can become important according to those studies . we , therefore , conclude that photon pile - up in the pca does not affect our results . we fit each spectrum with a blackbody function using the _ bbodyrad _ model ( as defined in xspec , arnaud 1996 ) . pinto et al . ( 2010 ) reported an analysis of high resolution x - ray spectroscopy of the interstellar medium toward gs 1826@xmath0238 and found an equivalent hydrogen column density of n@xmath9 . in order to take into account the effect of the interstellar extinction in the x - ray spectra , we used this value with the _ phabs _ model in xspec . we set the elemental abundances to the protosolar abundances of lodders ( 2003 ) , following pinto et al . the resulting histogram of @xmath5/dof values obtained from the cooling tails of all the bursts and the spectral evolution during one of the bursts ( burst # 23 ) are given in figures [ chi_hist ] and [ rxte_burst23 ] . similar to the results we obtained for a number of sources in paper i , the blackbody model could adequately fit the data with a systematic uncertainty @xmath10 of only @xmath11 . chandra observed gs 1826@xmath0238 in 2002 for approximately 70 ks ( obsid 2739 ) . we analyzed the data using the _ chandra_repro _ tool with ciao version 4.3 and caldb 4.4.5 . chandra_repro _ script automates the data processing following the standard pipeline steps but applies the latest available calibrations . using the _ dmextract _ tool we created a 2.5@xmath08.0 kev range background - subtracted source lightcurve using only the data from the grating arms ( + /- 1st orders ) . the zeroth order data for this observation is saturated due to the high countrate of the source and the nominal frame time of 1.7 s. even for the grating arms , pile - up was significant during the peak of the bursts . in order to correctly carry out the comparison between the rxte and chandra observations , we opt to correct for pile - up the _ predicted _ chandra countrates based on the rxte spectra , as opposed to correcting the observed chandra countrates . because rxte observations have better statistics , this forward folding of the correction does not unnecessarily inflate the uncertainties . we applied a pile - up correction procedure that is described in the appendix , which was developed based on the understanding of the detector properties and calibrated against independent data . the evolution of the applied correction is shown in figure [ ch_pileup ] for burst # 23 . at the burst peak , photon pile - up causes a net loss of 25% of the flux , which can be recovered by the pile - up correction model that was developed independently of the present data ( see the appendix ) . nevertheless , the rise and the peak of each burst , which approximately correspond to the first 30 s , are most heavily affected by pile - up . furthermore , the rise and the peak are also the periods where the intrinsic spectrum may show some deviation from a planckian shape ; this is expected from theoretical model spectra and was discussed in paper i using rxte observations . because of these reasons , we exclude the first 30 s of all chandra bursts from our analysis such that in the time interval that we use , the pile - up fraction decreases to 2% . we used the _ mkgrmf _ and _ fullgarf _ tools to create observation specific response and auxiliary response files for the first orders of the high energy transmission grating ( hetg ) and used these when creating the simulations based on the spectral parameters determined from time resolved x - ray spectroscopy . xmm-_newton _ observed gs 1826@xmath0238 in 2003 for approximately 200 ks with two different back - to - back exposures that lasted 107,850 and 91,916 s ( obsids : 0150390101 , 0150390301 ) . the observation was performed with epic - pn in timing mode and the epic - mos detectors were turned off . we analyzed the epic - pn data using the sas version 11.0.0 ( xmmsas_20110223_1801 - 11.0.0 ) and the calibration files as of june 2011 . we calibrated the observation with the _ epproc _ tool . due to the high energy particle background we could only use the first 67 ks of the first observation and @xmath880 ks of the second . similar to the chandra observation , we extracted background subtracted source light curves in the 2.5 @xmath0 10.0 kev range using the sas tool _ epiclccorr_. the observatory guide gives a limit of 450 ct / s for telemetry of the epic - pn timing mode , which can be increased if some of the other instruments are turned off as in this case . in the burst lightcurves that were observed with xmm-_newton _ , two gaps that last approximately 10 s ( see figures [ comp_xmm1 ] and [ comp_xmm2 ] ) are seen . these are most likely due to this limit . while creating the simulations we calculated observation specific effective area and redistribution matrix files using the sas tools _ rmfgen _ and _ arfgen_. in order to explore the possibility of pile - up in the epic - pn data , we created two event lists : one including the full psf for the source and another where the central two pixels , which should be the most affected from pile - up , are excised . if pile - up were significant , the ratio of the countrates in the two event lists would evolve as the count rate changes during the burst because the two event lists would be subject to different amounts of pile - up . the ratio of the two lightcurves is shown in figure [ xmm_pileup ] for bursts # 30 , 31 , and 32 . as expected , a large fraction of counts are collected in the central two pixels , making this ratio approximately equal to two . however , as the burst eveolves , the ratio remains constant at the few percent level , implying that the pile - up effect will be at most of the same order . we consider this as strong evidence for the lack of any pile - up effect on the measured fluxes . nevertheless , in order to avoid any residual effects of photon pile - up and any possible deviations from a planckian shape , as with the chandra bursts , we exclude the first 30 s of each burst when determining the systematic offsets between the instruments . we show these time intervals in the plots for comparison and completeness . we followed the method outlined in section [ method ] for comparing all of the x - ray bursts observed simultaneously with rxte and chandra or with rxte and xmm-_newton_. briefly , our analysis steps are as follows : 1 . we first obtained the best fit values of the parameters for each burst spectrum observed with rxte / pca . we then calculated the two - dimensional confidence contours for the resulting color temperature and the blackbody normalization parameters covering a @xmath12 range from the best fit values . an example confidence contour is shown in figure [ example_conf ] for the spectrum obtained approximately 9.7 s after burst # 26 started . note that we show 68% and 95% confidence contours in the figure but use the entire likelihood in the calculations . 2 . for each pair of spectral parameters , we calculated the predicted countrates for the chandra gratings ( only the @xmath13 1st orders for heg and meg ) in the 2.5@xmath08.0 kev range and for xmm- _ newton_/epic - pn countrates in the 2.5@xmath010.0 kev range ( i.e. , the energy range that matches the rxte / pca sensitivity ) . for the case of the chandra simulations , we applied the pile - up correction , as described in the previous section . 3 . in order to take into account the uncertainties in the rxte / pca modeling , we used the posterior likelihoods over the parameters for each spectral fit to calculate the uncertainty in the total predicted countrates . 4 . finally , we compared the observed chandra hetg / acis - s or xmm-_newton_/epic - pn countrates to the countrates predicted using the rxte / pca spectral fits . for this comparison , we binned the countrates to match the time resolution of each data set and subtracted the persistent flux level of the source from the burst emission . during the chandra observation , the nominal frame time was 1.7 s. the time resolution of the epic - pn observation was much higher . we , therefore , binned the epic - pn data to match the varying exposure time of rxte spectra . in figures [ comp_ch ] , [ comp_xmm1 ] , and [ comp_xmm2 ] , we show the time evolution of the source countrate during each x - ray burst simultaneously observed with rxte and chandra in the 2.5@xmath08.0 kev range or with rxte and xmm-_newton _ in the 2.5@xmath010.0 kev range . in principle , all of the calculated ratios should be equal to unity within their formal uncertainties , if there are no systematic calibration differences . it is already evident from this figure that this is indeed the case between rxte and chandra but that there is a systematic calibration offset between rxte and xmm-_newton_. to explore in more detail the calibration differences between the three instruments and whether such differences evolve with countrate , we performed two analyses . first , for the xmm-_newton_/epic - pn data , for which we infer the largest systematic calibration offset , we created histograms of the ratios of the predicted and observed countrates with varying start times compared to the burst start times ( see figure [ phtest2 ] ) . if there were a significant countrate dependence of the calibration offset , we would have seen a significant change in the distribution of calculated ratios at later stages of these bursts . however , it is evident from figure [ phtest2 ] that there is no such time dependent change in the ratios . second , in order to quantify the level of offset between the three instruments , we followed the bayesian procedure described in papers i and ii and outlined below for completeness . we calculated the ratio @xmath14 between the observed and predicted countrates for each time bin in the 30@xmath0120 s interval after the start of every burst together with its formal uncertainty . we assume that the uncertainty in each measurement is described by a gaussian with a centroid @xmath15 and a dispersion @xmath16 i.e. , @xmath17\;,\ ] ] where @xmath18 is a set of normalization constants . we will also assume that the ensemble of these ratios for each burst is drawn from a gaussian distribution with a centroid at @xmath19 and a dispersion @xmath20 , i.e. , @xmath21\;,\ ] ] where @xmath22 is a proper normalization constant . this distribution is our model for the underlying systematic flux calibration offset between the instruments . if there are no calibration differences , the centroid should be equal to one , to within @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the number of measurements , and the dispersion should tend to zero . a significant offset in the flux calibration between two instruments will move @xmath25 away from unity , but keep the dispersion consistent with zero . on the other hand , a large dispersion can not be produced by an overall flux calibration offset . instead , it likely points to effects such as an inadequate modeling of the pile - up correction , of the energy response of the detector(s ) , or of the astrophysical properties of the source . our goal is to calculate the posterior likelihood for the parameters @xmath19 and @xmath20 , @xmath26data@xmath27 , given an ensemble of @xmath24 measurements . using bayes theorem , we can write @xmath28 here @xmath29 is a normalization constant , and @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the priors over the centroid and dispersion of the underlying gaussian distribution . we take these prior distributions to be flat in the range of parameters shown in figures [ res_ch ] , [ res_xmm1 ] , and [ res_xmm2 ] , which is large enough to incorporate any range of interest . the quantity @xmath32 measures the likelihood that we will make a particular set of measurements given the values of the parameters of the underlying gaussian distribution . because these measurements are uncorrelated , we write @xmath33 inserting equation ( [ eq : data ] ) into equation ( [ eq : bayes ] ) we obtain the posterior likelihood @xmath34 where @xmath29 is an overall normalization constant . we show two - dimensional contours of these likelihoods for each burst in figures [ res_ch ] , [ res_xmm1 ] , and [ res_xmm2 ] and display the most likely values of the parameters in table [ res_all ] . all figures show that the underlying distributions of offsets are extremely narrow and that the most likely values of their dispersions are consistent with being zero . this indicates that there are no systematic problems in the modeling of the energy response of the detectors and that the corrections described earlier adequately account for any pile - up effects . the most likely values of the centroids are consistent with unity for the comparison between rxte and chandra but as low as 0.86 for the comparison between rxte and xmm-_newton_. because the offsets are stable both throughout the cooling tails of individual bursts and from burst to burst , we combined all the measurements from all the bursts observed by each x - ray satellite to quantify the overall offset and its uncertainty . we computed the posterior likelihood for the offset @xmath25 given the two dimensional posterior likelihood of the centroid value @xmath19 and dispersion @xmath20 of the underlying gaussian distribution as @xmath35 using 5 bursts and 447 individual measurements and 3 three bursts and 170 individual measurements for comparison with xmm-_newton _ and chandra , respectively , we found that the ratio of the observed count - rate with the chandra and xmm-_newton _ compared to the predictions based on the rxte spectral analysis in the 2.5 @xmath0 8.0 kev and 2.5 @xmath0 10 kev range is 1.012@xmath36 and 0.857@xmath10.003 , respectively . in other words , the fluxes measured with chandra hetg / acis are in statistical agreement with the rxte / pca while the epic - pn measures one that is 14% less . in figure [ final_overplot ] , we show the combined likelihoods of the resulting ratios of countrates between the different instruments . lcc 22 & 1.01 & hetg - acis / pca + 23 & 1.01 & hetg - acis / pca + 24 & 0.97 & hetg - acis / pca + 26 & 0.86 & epic - pn / pca + 27 & 0.85 & epic - pn / pca + 30 & 0.86 & epic - pn / pca + 31 & 0.86 & epic - pn / pca + 32 & 0.86 & epic - pn / pca [ res_all ] in the previous section , we addressed the cross calibration between rxte and _ chandra _ as well as between rxte and xmm- _ newton _ , using observations of the burster gs 1826@xmath0238 . we obtained the most likely fractional offsets between the fluxes measured using the various instruments on simultaneous observations and showed that they are consistent with being constant throughout individual bursts as well as across different bursts . however , the offsets we inferred correspond to a single point in time for each comparison . if the efficiencies of the detectors were constant in time , the results of this comparison would be applicable to all the bursts observed thoughout the durations of the missions . however , the responses of the detectors evolve with time for a number of reasons ( e.g. , gas leakage , charge transfer inefficiency ) . this evolution is typically accounted for using smooth , time - dependent models of the response parameters of the detectors . these parameters are determined by fitting the models to regular observations of the cosmic sources with known brightness and spectral shape or using internal calibrations sources ( e.g. epic cameras ) . as an example , rxte / pca had been calibrated against the crab nebula ( shaposnikov et al . 2013 ) throughout the mission . the smooth models of the evolution of the detector response clearly can not reliably capture the true evolution , which is expected to have a stochastic component . this will , therefore , introduce an uncertainty in the measurements that will change in time . [ line - through]*t*his complication is exacerbated if the calibration source shows intrinsic variability , as is the case with the crab nebula , which showed variability at a level of @xmath8 7% ( wilson - hodge et al . it is , therefore , possible that were we to repeat our cross calibration procedure between rxte and chandra at different epochs , we would obtain different offsets . even though randomly catching an epoch of identical flux measurements between rxte and chandra might seem unlikely , we can not base our conclusions on such a posterior likelihood . for this reason , we now explore the possibility that there is a time - dependent systematic uncertainty in the calibration of the instruments and how this uncertainty would affect the scatter in the measured burst fluxes . if there were single - epoch measurements of the fluxes during the cooling tails of bursts , this potential systematic error would have to be added to the error budget of the measurements . however , for many of the sources we used for neutron - star radius measurements in papers i and ii , the burst flux measurements were carried over many epochs spanning the lifetime of rxte . in this case , as we will show below , this potential calibration uncertainty should not be treated as a separate source of systematic uncertainty as it is already inherently part of the measured scatter of observed fluxes . to demonstrate this point , we compute the mean and the variance of the ( burst ) flux measured by an instrument ( e.g. , rxte / pca ) . let the source flux for each burst be @xmath37 , with a mean of @xmath38 and an intrinsic dispersion @xmath39 . let the instrument have an inferred overall efficiency factor @xmath40 ( e.g. , as reported by a calibration team ) . if this efficiency factor has an unknown systematic bias , which may also be variable in time , then the observed countrate flux will be @xmath41 where we have denoted the mean bias in the calibration over the time span of the observations by @xmath42 and the potential time - variable part by @xmath43 . by definition , @xmath44 . when an observation is carried out and standard calibration procedures are applied , the observed source flux will be inferred to be equal to @xmath45 which will be related to the true source flux by @xmath46 clearly , the observations reproduce the true source flux if there is no bias in the calibration . the mean inferred flux of the source is equal to @xmath47 where we have used the fact that @xmath48 because the time evolution of the detector response and the variability of the source are uncorrelated . the variance in the inferred burst flux is @xmath49 and the mean of the square of the inferred fluxes is given by @xmath50 ^ 2 \right\rangle \nonumber \\ & = & \left(1+\frac{b}{r}\right)^2 \langle s_{i,\rm true}^2\rangle + \left\langle \left(\frac{v_i}{r}\right)^2 s_{i,\rm true}^2 \right\rangle + 2\left(1+\frac{b}{r}\right ) \left\langle \frac{v_i}{r } s_{i,\rm true}^2 \right\rangle.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath51 , we find that @xmath52 + \frac{1}{r^2}\left\langle v_i^2s_{i,\rm true}^2 \right\rangle \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the term in the square bracket is equal to the true variance of the source flux @xmath53 = \sigma_{\rm true}^2 $ ] . the average in the second term is @xmath54 , where we have used the definition of the variance of the time - variable bias @xmath55 as a result , @xmath56 or in terms of fractional errors , @xmath57\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] keeping only terms up to second order in the dispersions , the final result is @xmath58 this expression shows that the measured fractional variance in the burst fluxes is equal to the quadrature sum of the intrinsic fractional variance and the fractional variance of the calibration bias . in other words , the observed variance in the burst fluxes is an upper limit to the intrinsic scatter . if the statistical properties of the calibration uncertainties could be measured independently , this contribution could be subtracted from the dispersion of measured fluxes . in this paper , we quantified the systematic uncertainties that arise from the flux calibration of the x - ray instruments used in neutron star mass and radius measurements . we used simultaneous observations of the burster gs 1826@xmath0238 with rxte / pca and chandra hetg / acis - s as well as with rxte / pca and xmm-_newton_/epic - pn . we performed a bayesian statistical analysis to measure the level of offset in the flux calibration between these instruments . in the case of the comparison between chandra and rxte , we found no evidence for a significant offset between the measured fluxes and concluded that the most likely value of the flux ratio is @xmath59 . as we describe in the appendix , the effect of pileup is unlikely to change the value of this ratio in a statistically significant way . in contrast , we found a 14.0@xmath10.3% difference between the fluxes inferred using xmm-_newton_/epic - pn and rxte / pca . this discrepancy is persistent in all five analyzed bursts and is independent of the source spectrum or countrate . the flux discrepancy between xmm-_newton_/epic - pn and other detectors has been noted in earlier studies of different sources . nevalainen et al . ( 2010 ) reported a difference between flux measurements with the epic - pn , chandra acis ( zeroth - order data ) , and epic mos detectors at a level of 5@xmath010% . according to their results , acis flux measurements are significantly higher than epic - pn , by 11.0@xmath10.5% . similarly , the difference in the flux measurements between the epic - pn and mos detectors has been noticed earlier ( see e.g. , mateos et al . 2009 and xmm - newton calibration documents xmm - newton - soc - cal - tn-0018 and xmm - newton - soc - cal - tn-0052 ) ; mos yields fluxes that are approximately 7% higher than epic - pn ( see also read et al . 2014 ) . most recently , using 64 clusters of galaxies , schellenberger et al . ( 2014 ) showed that the effective area cross - calibration uncertainty between acis and epic - pn is energy dependent and in the 2@xmath07 kev range stabilizes at a 15% level a similar result is also presented by guainazzi et al . ( 2015 ) . given that the calibration errors of the detectors may be variable in time , it is possible that the excellent agreement between rxte and chandra is a coincidence . we showed , however , that even in this case , the spread of the measured burst fluxes reported in papers i and ii already accounts for this potential systematic uncertainty . we , therefore , conclude that , while an overall bias may still exist in the measurements , potential time - dependent flux calibration uncertainties do not increase the error budget of the radius measurements we reported in these earlier papers . one final consideration is whether the difference in the measured flux between xmm-_newton _ epic - pn and the other two instruments also affects the neutron star radii determined through the observations of quiescent low - mass x - ray binaries . the flux levels in question are very different in the observations of these dim sources : they are approximately six orders of magnitude below the peak burst fluxes and the crab nebula , and about three orders of magnitude below other typical calibration sources ( e.g. , clusters of galaxies ) . given the signal - to - noise ratio of the spectra that is achieved with even the longest observations of quiescent low - mass x - ray binaries , it is not possible to discern any measured flux differences between instruments , even if this difference persisted at the 14% level . this supports the lack of evidence for flux differences presented in the earlier studies ( catuneanu et al . 2013 ; heinke et al . 2014 ; guillot et al . 2013 ) , which compared neutron star radii derived from the quiescent sources using xmm-_newton _ and chandra data . to account for pileup in the chandra hetg / acis - s spectra , we used a correction that was developed independently by one of the co - authors , herman marshall , for mildly piled - up calibration data . the approach relies on the measurement of counts per pixel around the ir - m and si - k edges , at which the spectral response changes rapidly . denoting the observed counts per detector pixel per frame in wavelength bin @xmath60 as @xmath61 , we define the degradation of the effective area as the value of the parameter @xmath63 and the uncertainty associated with its determination was found using an observation of mk 421 ( observation i d 4148 ) performed on 26@xmath027 october 2002 with the letgs / acis - s for over 91 ks . the data were downloaded from _ tgcat _ ( huenemoerder et al . 2011 ) . the countrate spectra were rebinned by a factor of two so that each spectral bin corresponds closely to one acis pixel . the source was extremely bright so that there were of order 5000 counts per spectral bin in both the + 1 and -1 orders near 2 kev . the count spectrum was divided by the arf obtained from tgcat to generate spectra in photons/@xmath64/s / for both the @xmath65 and @xmath66 orders . when the two orders are compared ( see the top panel of figure [ final_overplot ] ) without being corrected for pileup , there are clear edges at ir - m ( 6.0 ) and si - k ( 6.74 ) in the effective - area - corrected spectra . these features arise from differential pileup , where @xmath61 may increase significantly over a few spectral resolution elements at an edge in the effective area of the instrument , causing increased pileup and a larger fractional loss of events with a corresponding decrease in apparent photon flux . we devised a model - independent method for estimating the parameter @xmath63 in equation ( [ eqa1 ] ) , which depends on the very smooth and slowly varying photon spectrum of mk 421 . using the ratio of fluxes in the 5.5 - 5.9 range to those in the 6.1 - 6.5 range ( straddling the ir - m edge ) , we compute the value of @xmath63 that matches the ratios based on the average @xmath40 values in the two narrow bands . we find @xmath67 for @xmath66 and @xmath68 for @xmath65 and , therefore , adopt @xmath69 and a range of acceptable values that are @xmath70 away from this value . figure [ final_overplot ] shows the sensitivity of the spectral inversion to @xmath63 ; for @xmath71 , the spectra still show edges , while , for @xmath72 , the data are over - corrected to form an excess over a smooth spectral model . ( a global spectral fit to a double power law indicates that the photon spectrum should drop monotonically by only 1% per through this wavelength range , so the assumption that the fluxes are equal should be good to 1% . ) using equation ( [ eqa1 ] ) , which is verified to @xmath73 cts / frame / pixel , a @xmath74% uncertainty in @xmath63 results in at most a @xmath75% uncertainty in @xmath76 , which is smaller than the expected calibration uncertainty in @xmath77 . this method required the hrma effective area correction implemented in 2005 , which corrected the ir - m edge caused by a thin contaminant layer on the hrma . note that , the correction given in equation ( [ eqa1 ] ) is valid for low to modest pileup , i.e. , @xmath78 cts / frame / pixel and the data used to compute the coefficient @xmath63 ranged up to about 0.10 cts / s / pixel . this yields a maximum correction of about 50% . in our comparison between rxte and chandra , we took into account the pileup losses in the predicted countrates rather than correcting the observed rates for pileup . if we denote by @xmath79 the number of photons per detector pixel per frame that should have been recorded in wavelength bin @xmath60 in the absence of pileup , we can then invert the above expression to obtain houck , j. c. , & denicola , l. a. 2000 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 216 , astronomical data analysis software and systems ix , ed . n. manset , c. veillet , & d. crabtree , 591+

many techniques for measuring neutron star radii rely on absolute flux measurements in the x - rays . as a result , one of the fundamental uncertainties in these spectroscopic measurements arises from the absolute flux calibrations of the detectors being used . using the stable x - ray burster , gs 1826@xmath0238 , and its simultaneous observations by chandra hetg / acis - s and rxte / pca as well as by xmm - newton epic - pn and rxte / pca , we quantify the degree of uncertainty in the flux calibration by assessing the differences between the measured fluxes during bursts . we find that the rxte / pca and the chandra gratings measurements agree with each other within their formal uncertainties , increasing our confidence in these flux measurements . in contrast , xmm - newton epic - pn measures 14.0@xmath10.3% less flux than the rxte / pca . this is consistent with the previously reported discrepancy with the flux measurements of epic - pn , compared to epic - mos1 , mos2 and acis - s detectors . we also show that any intrinsic time dependent systematic uncertainty that may exist in the calibration of the satellites has already been implicity taken into account in the neutron star radius measurements .

astro-ph9611139

although galaxies cover a wide range in properties , such as luminosity , hubble type and environment , their globular cluster systems are remarkably similar in many respects . in particular , all globular cluster luminosity functions ( gclf ) can be crudely represented by a gaussian with a peak located at m@xmath6 @xmath3 7.5 and a width of @xmath7 @xmath3 1.2 . the peak , or turnover magnitude , has been used with some success as an independent distance estimator to galaxies ( see jacoby 1992 ) . its usefulness relies on the assumption that the turnover magnitude is universal for all galaxies . it has been suggested that the gclf is not universal , but rather varies systematically with gc metallicity ( ashman , conti & zepf 1995 ) , the galaxy hubble type ( secker & harris 1993 ) or galaxy environment ( blakeslee & tonry 1996 ) . if any of these ` second parameter ' effects are confirmed , then accurate distance estimates using the gclf method will require an appropriate correction . in the case of gc metallicity , ashman ( 1995 ) have quantified the effects of metallicity on the turnover magnitude and show that once a metallicity correction ( @xmath3 0.1 mag ) is applied , the gclf gives distances in good agreement with other methods . to fully resolve these issues , a number of high quality gclfs are required covering a range of hubble types and environments . one approach is to study galaxies that belong to a nearby group . this has the benefit of allowing the gclf determined distances to be directly compared with other distance methods for galaxies in the same group . fleming ( 1995 ) aimed to use this approach on the nearby coma i cloud by examining the gclf in ngc 4494 ( e1 ) and ngc 4565 ( sb ) . their results will be discussed below . the coma i cloud is a small group of galaxies in the foreground of the well known coma cluster of galaxies ( a1656 ) . it is dominated by spiral galaxies but also includes a few ellipticals ( gregory & thompson 1977 ) . here we examine the gclfs of the two brightest ellipticals which may be members of the coma i cloud , namely ngc 4278 and ngc 4494 . both galaxies contain a kinematically distinct core which may have resulted from a merger . using _ hubble space telescope _ wide field and planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) data of forbes ( 1996 ) , we can probe the gclf in these galaxies to about 2 magnitudes beyond the turnover magnitude . the wfpc2 data have the additional advantages of very low background contamination with no blending of gcs in the central galaxy region . our method is similar to that applied to the gclf of ngc 4365 ( forbes 1996 ) . in particular , we use the maximum likelihood code of secker & harris ( 1993 ) to fit the gclf and the absolute turnover magnitude determination of sandage & tammann ( 1995 ) , i.e. m@xmath5 = 7.62 @xmath2 0.08 . we compare the gclf distance modulus with other methods and estimate the hubble constant . details of the wfpc2 data for the gcs in ngc 4278 and ngc 4494 are presented , along with 12 other ellipticals , in forbes ( 1996 ) . from the 2 @xmath8 500s f555w images , we use daophot ( stetson 1987 ) to detect gcs . detection is based on fairly conservative limits of flux threshold , shape , sharpness and size . and after checking against a list of hot pixels , the final contamination from cosmic rays , foreground stars , background galaxies and hot pixels is less than a few percent . we did not apply any color selection to the gc lists . the gc magnitudes have been converted into johnson v and corrected for galactic extinction . when examining the gclf of ngc 4365 ( forbes 1996 ) , we showed that the fraction of detected gcs with magnitude , once the threshold criterion is adjusted for a 0.3 mag sensitivity difference ( burrows 1993 ) , is similar for all four ccds . for ngc 4494 we were able to use all ccds , as the dust is confined to a small ( @xmath3 1@xmath9 ) ring which does nt appear to affect any gcs ( carollo 1996 ) . in the case of ngc 4278 , dust covers much of the pc ccd . we have therefore decided not to include gcs from the pc in this analysis . a full description of the modeling processes including completeness tests , photometric errors , background contamination and maximum likelihood fitting , are given in forbes ( 1996 ) . to summarize , we carried out simulations to test the ability of daophot to detect gcs on actual wfc images for both galaxies . these completeness tests , and the photometric error in measuring gc magnitudes , are given in figure 1 for ngc 4278 and figure 2 for ngc 4494 . both figures are similar to that found for ngc 4365 ( forbes 1996 ) . the 50% completeness level is v = 24.9 for ngc 4278 and v = 24.8 for ngc 4494 . we ignore gcs with magnitudes fainter than these to avoid large incompleteness corrections . a small correction is made for background contamination based on similar exposure wfpc2 images from the medium deep survey ( forbes 1994 ) . finally we fit the background corrected gclf using the maximum likelihood code of secker & harris ( 1993 ) which takes account of the completeness and photometric error variations with magnitude . we fit both gaussian and @xmath10 distributions to the gclf . we have detected 241 gcs in ngc 4278 and 148 in ngc 4494 to the 50% completeness level . the results of fitting the gclf of each galaxy , with the gaussian and a @xmath10 functions , are summarized in table 1 . in particular , the average turnover magnitudes are m@xmath11 = 23.23 @xmath2 0.11 for ngc 4278 and m@xmath11 = 23.07 @xmath2 0.13 for ngc 4494 . as these magnitudes are statistically within the combined errors , this would indicate that both galaxies are at the same distance . the probability contours output from the maximum likelihood code for the gaussian fit , over a range of 0.53 standard deviations , are shown in figures 3 and 4 . in figures 5 and 6 we show the binned gclf and our best fit gaussian superposed for each galaxy . note that the fitting procedure does not use binned data but rather treats each data point individually . these figures clearly show that the 50% completeness limit is almost 2 magnitudes fainter than the turnover magnitude , giving us additional confidence that the turnover is well determined . this makes our data among the most complete , in terms of sampling the luminosity function , of gclfs published to date . the number of ` missing ' gcs , i.e. those fainter than the limiting magnitude , is @xmath12 10% . fleming ( 1995 ) have recently investigated the gclf of ngc 4494 and the sb spiral ngc 4565 . the aim of their study was to derive a gclf distance for galaxies of different hubble types located in the same group . this would allow a direct test of whether or not the gclf turnover magnitude depends on hubble type . they used the same cfht @xmath31@xmath9 v band images used by simard & pritchet ( 1994 ) for a surface brightness fluctuation ( sbf ) study of these galaxies . the data consisted of two pointings for each galaxy . using daophot for gc detection and completeness tests , their 50% completeness limits for the two pointings were v = 23.2 , 24.0 for ngc 4494 and v = 24.5 , 24.3 for ngc 4565 . for a gaussian fit to their gclf data of ngc 4494 they quote @xmath1 = 23.6 @xmath2 0.4 with @xmath7 fixed at 1.4 . the results for ngc 4565 are @xmath1 = 22.63 @xmath2 0.2 , @xmath7 = 1.35 @xmath2 0.22 . in both cases there is considerable scatter in their faint magnitude bins ( see their figures 5 and 6 ) . they concluded that ngc 4565 was in the coma i cloud but that ngc 4494 lies in the background . we now consider whether their data , and hence inferred distances , are consistent with our dataset . we first note that all fleming magnitudes should be 0.05@xmath4 brighter after applying a galactic extinction correction . starting with ngc 4494 , for which their 50% completeness limit is comparable to their estimated turnover magnitude . for a gaussian fit our data gives @xmath13 = 23.05 @xmath2 0.13 which is _ not _ consistent with their result . however , an important distinction is that they fixed @xmath7 to be 1.4 ( their data did not warrant fits to both @xmath7 and @xmath1 ) . it has been shown that uncertainties in @xmath7 correspond to uncertainties in @xmath1 , so that a change from @xmath7 = 1.4 ( fleming ) to 1.1 ( us ) would translate into a brighter @xmath1 by about 0.5@xmath4 ( e.g. hanes 1977 ; secker & harris 1993 ) . thus the fleming gclf would have a turnover of @xmath1 @xmath3 23.05 . an alternative , and perhaps more straight forward , way to show this is given by figure 7 . this shows the fleming data for ngc 4494 and the best fit gaussian to our data for ngc 4494 . we include two gaussians arbitrarily scaled up and down by a factor of two vertically ( the turnover magnitude is held constant , but the dispersion is allowed to vary ) . this figure indicates that , within the error bars , the fleming data for ngc 4494 are consistent with a gaussian that has a turnover of @xmath1 = 23.05 . as a further test , we re fit their data but excluded the faintest bin and allowed the gaussian dispersion @xmath7 to be a free parameter ( along with the turnover magnitude and the normalization ) . this gave m@xmath11 = 23.27 @xmath2 0.4 ( after extinction correction ) and @xmath7 = 1.3 @xmath2 0.3 . we conclude that the ground based dataset of fleming ( 1995 ) for ngc 4494 and our wfpc2 data _ are _ consistent , albeit within some large scatter . next we consider ngc 4565 , in particular is it at the same distance as ngc 4494 ( and ngc 4278 ) ? figure 7 shows the fleming data for the spiral ngc 4565 . the data lie between the best fit gaussian to our ngc 4494 data and one scaled down by a factor of two . thus , as with ngc 4494 , the ground based data for ngc 4565 is consistent with a gaussian of @xmath1 = 23.05 . it is difficult to rule out the possibility that the turnover magnitude is brighter by @xmath3 0.5@xmath4 ( this difference is too large to be explained as metallicity effect ashman 1995 ) . we now calculate the distance modulus for our data from the apparent turnover magnitude . as noted in the introduction , ashman ( 1995 ) have advocated that a small correction be applied to the universal value based on gc metallicity . such a metallicity correction has been shown by them to improve gclf distance estimates . in the absence of spectroscopic measures , we can estimate the mean metallicity of a gc system assuming [ fe / h ] = 5.051 ( v i ) 6.096 ( couture 1990 ) . using the mean color from forbes ( 1996 ) , we derive [ fe / h ] = 0.79 for ngc 4278 and 0.84 for ngc 4494 , giving metallicity corrections of @xmath14m@xmath6 = 0.16 and 0.14 respectively . thus we make the universal value of m@xmath11 = 7.62 @xmath2 0.08 ( sandage & tammann 1995 ) fainter by 0.16 or 0.14 magnitudes . in table 2 we summarize distance determinations from other workers for galaxies in the coma i cloud . we include the gclf distance for ngc 4565 from fleming ( 1995 ) , after making a 0.05 galactic extinction correction and assuming m@xmath11 = 7.62 @xmath2 0.08 with no metallicity correction . from v band surface brightness fluctuations , simard & pritchet ( 1994 ) estimate ( m m ) = 30.88 @xmath2 0.3 for ngc 4494 , and 30.08 @xmath2 0.07 for ngc 4565 . using the planetary nebulae luminosity function ( pnlf ) method , jacoby , ciardullo & harris ( 1996 ) get 30.54 @xmath2 0.05 for ngc 4494 and 30.21 @xmath2 0.08 for ngc 4565 . from the a mass model of the virgo region and an _ assumption _ about the ` triple value ambiguity ' in velocity , tully & shaya ( 1984 ) give distances to ngc 4494 and ngc 4565 which correspond to 30.34 and 30.21 respectively . we will assume an error of @xmath2 0.3@xmath4 on these estimates . finally , aaronson & mould ( 1983 ) find ( m m ) = 30.42 @xmath2 0.32 for several spiral galaxies in the direction of the coma i cloud using the infrared tully fisher relation . the distance modulus for ngc 4494 ranges from ( m m ) = 30.34 ( mass models of tully & shaya 1984 ) to 30.88 ( sbf work of simard & pritchet 1994 ) with a weighted mean of 30.54 @xmath2 0.07 . our value for ngc 4278 ( 30.61 @xmath2 0.14 ) is consistent with the ngc 4494 mean . most recently , i band sbf measurements also indicate that ngc 4278 and ngc 4494 have essentially the same distance modulus , albeit at the upper range of values listed in table 2 ( tonry 1996 ) . for ngc 4565 the weighted mean distance modulus is 30.10 @xmath2 0.05 . this is 0.4@xmath4 or 2 mpc closer than ngc 4494 . this suggests that ngc 4565 lies in the foreground relative to ngc 4494 . it has been suggested that the coma i cloud may consist of two sub groups , one around ngc 4565 and the other associated with the s0 galaxy ngc 4274 and ngc 4278 ( de vaucouleurs 1976 ) . this claim was questioned by gregory & thompson ( 1977 ) who found no particular evidence that the coma i cloud formed two sub groups . however , they did note that the group formed a bar like structure of dimensions 0.9 @xmath8 2.5 mpc and that the galaxies with the _ lower _ velocities tend to be systematically fainter , i.e. located further from us . table 2 shows that in each case , other workers found ngc 4494 to be more distant than ngc 4565 for a given distance method . our preferred interpretation is that both ngc 4494 and ngc 4278 are at the same distance and are located at the far end of the coma i cloud , whereas ngc 4565 is located 2 mpc closer at the front end of the group . aaronson & mould ( 1983 ) caution that the redshifts for galaxies in the coma i cloud may not correlate well with distance , given the proximity of the group to the virgo cluster . nevertheless , we will attempt to estimate the hubble constant from our measurements . if we calculate the mean velocity of the eight galaxies associated with ngc 4274 sub group ( de vaucouleurs 1976 ) , and include ngc 4494 , we get 880 km s@xmath15 . the correction for motion with respect to the local group using solution number 2 of yahil , tammann & sandage ( 1977 ) is @xmath3 40 km s@xmath15 , giving 840 km s@xmath15 . the virgocentric infall component from tammann & sandage ( 1985 ) is @xmath3 200 km s@xmath15 , which gives a corrected recession velocity of 1020 km s@xmath15 . using a distance modulus of 30.54 and this corrected velocity we estimate a hubble constant of @xmath3 80 km s@xmath15 mpc@xmath15 . finally , we have derived the local ( within 100@xmath9 radius ) and total gc specific frequency ( @xmath16 ) for each galaxy following the method described in forbes ( 1996 ) . these give similar results of @xmath3 5 for ngc 4278 and @xmath3 2 for ngc 4494 . the richness of the gc system around ngc 4494 appears to lower than that of a typical elliptical ( @xmath16 @xmath3 5 ; van den bergh 1995 ) . using wfpc2 data of forbes ( 1996 ) we have fit the globular cluster luminosity function ( gclf ) of two ellipticals , ngc 4278 and ngc 4494 . the first of which is generally thought to lie in the coma i cloud , whereas the latter has been suggested to lie in the background . both the gaussian and @xmath10 profile fits give similar results , namely a turnover magnitude of m@xmath5 = 23.23 @xmath2 0.11 for ngc 4278 and m@xmath5 = 23.07 @xmath2 0.13 for ngc 4494 . the fitted dispersions ( @xmath7 @xmath3 1.1@xmath4 ) are somewhat smaller than typical values for other ellipticals . the limiting magnitude , as determined by completeness tests , is about 2 magnitudes fainter than these values . we derive distance modulii of 30.61 @xmath2 0.14 and 30.50 @xmath2 0.15 for ngc 4278 and ngc 4494 respectively , assuming an absolute turnover magnitude of m@xmath6 = 7.62 @xmath2 0.08 from sandage & tammann ( 1995 ) and a small metallicity correction based on the precepts of ashman ( 1995 ) . we compare our distance measure with the ground based gclf study of fleming ( 1995 ) and other distance determinations for galaxies in the coma i cloud . our distance modulii lie within the range of published values . we conclude that both ngc 4278 and ngc 4494 _ are _ members of the coma i cloud , and speculate that they lie at the far end of a bar structure ; the near end of which is associated with ngc 4565 . finally , we make a rough estimate of the hubble constant and globular cluster specific frequency from our data . * acknowledgments * + we are particularly grateful to j. secker for the use of his maximum likelihood code and useful suggestions . we also thank j. blakeslee , j. brodie and c. grillmair for helpful discussions . the referee is thanked for several suggestions that have improved the paper . this research was funded by the hst grant ar-05794.01 - 94a + * references * aaronson , m. , & mould , j. 1983 , apj , 265 , 1 + ashman , k. m. , conti , a. , & zepf , s. e. 1995 , aj , 110 , 1164 + blakeslee , j. p. , & tonry , j. l. 1996 , apj , in press + burrows , c. , 1993 , hubble space telescope wide field and planetary camera 2 instrument handbook , stsci + carollo , c. m. , franx , m. , illingworth , g. d. , & forbes , d. a. 1996 , apj , submitted + couture , j. , harris , w. e. , & allwright , j. w. b. , 1990 , apjs , 73 , 671 + de vaucouleurs , g. 1976 , stars and stellar systems , edited by a. sandage , m. sandage and j. kristian ( chicago : university of chicago press ) v9 , p557 + forbes , d. a. 1996 , aj , in press + forbes , d. a. , elson , r. a. w. , phillips , a. c. , illingworth , g. d. & koo , d. c. 1994 , apj , 437 , l17 + forbes , d. a. , franx , m. , illingworth , g. d. , & carollo , c. m. 1996 , apj , in press + fleming , d. e. b. , harris , w. e. , pritchet , c. j. , & hanes , d. a. 1995 , aj , 109 , 1044 + gregory , s. a. , & thompson , l. a. 1977 , apj , 213 , 345 + hanes , d. a. 1977 , mnras , 180 , 309 + jacoby , g. h. , 1992 , pasp , 104 , 599 + jacoby , g. h. , ciardullo , r. , & harris , w. e. 1996 , apj , 462 , 1 + sandage , a. , & tammann , g. a. 1995 , apj , 446 , 1 + secker , j. , & harris , w. e. 1993 , aj , 105 , 1358 + simard , l. , & pritchet , c. j. 1994 , aj , 107 , 503 + stetson , p. b. , 1987 , pasp , 99 , 191 + tammann , g. a. , & sandage , a. 1985 , apj , 294 , 81 + tonry , j. l. 1996 , the extragalactic distance scale workshop held at space telescope science institute + tully , r. b. , & shaya , e. j. 1984 , apj , 281 , 31 + van den bergh , s. 1995 , aj , 110 , 2700 + yahil , a. , tammann , g. a. , & sandage , a. 1977 , apj , 217 , 903 +

the membership of some galaxies in the nearby ( d @xmath0 mpc ) coma i cloud is uncertain . here we present globular cluster luminosity functions ( gclfs ) from the _ hubble space telescope _ for two bright ellipticals which may belong to this group . after fitting the gclf , we find a turnover magnitude of @xmath1 = 23.23 @xmath2 0.11 for ngc 4278 and @xmath1 = 23.07 @xmath2 0.13 for ngc 4494 . our limiting magnitude is about two magnitudes fainter than these values , making this data among the most complete gclfs published to date . the fitted gclf dispersions ( @xmath3 1.1@xmath4 ) are somewhat smaller than typical values for other ellipticals . assuming an absolute turnover magnitude of m@xmath5 = 7.62 , and after applying a small metallicity correction , we derive distance modulii of ( m m ) = 30.61 @xmath2 0.14 for ngc 4278 and 30.50 @xmath2 0.15 for ngc 4494 . these distance estimates are compared to other methods , and lie within the published range of values . we conclude that both galaxies lie at the same distance and are both members of the coma i cloud .

1605.08838

we consider bandit learning in personalized content recommendation with implicit pairwise comparisons . in our model , we offer pairs of items to a user and record implicit feedback on which offered item is preferred , seeking to learn the user s preferences over items quickly , while also ensuring that the fraction of time we fail to offer a high - quality item in our offered assortment is small . implicit pairwise comparisons avoid the inaccuracy of user ratings @xcite and the difficulty of engaging users in providing explicit feedback . we model items as related through covariates , and model regret as depending on the utility to the user of the best offered item . for example , consider a recommender system that delivers news articles to subscribers through push notifications . each news item is available through several different news sources , and so when we notify users of news , we may offer two different versions of the same news item from different sources , and record which one the user selects , so as to determine the user s favored news source . the problem that we study is a variant of the dueling bandit problem @xcite , in which a sequence of rounds are played , and in each round we forward two arms to the user and receive noisy feedback from the user telling us which arm is preferred , when an arm is preferred in a round , we say that arm wins the duel " in that round . previous work on dueling bandits has focused on choosing between ranking algorithms @xcite , where query results from two rankers are interleaved @xcite , and the ranking algorithm that provided the first result chosen by the user is declared the winner of the duel . perhaps because of their focus on the ranking setting , previous work has focused on models that are appropriate for few arms that do not model the dependence between arms , and where zero regret requires pulling the best arm twice . we study a formulation of the dueling bandits problem with two differences from the standard setting that make it more appropriate for online content recommendation . first , we model the dependence between arms by endowing arms with covariates which are then modeled as interacting through a known function ( for example , the inner product ) with some latent vector describing the user s preferences , providing the user s utility for that arm . for example , in our example above , covariates for a news source could be determined by fitting a topic model to the text in past news items from that source , and the user s preference vector could be interpreted as the user s preference for each topic . second , we model regret as the difference in utility between the best arm , and the best arm offered . we make this modeling choice because the user is able to choose between the items offered , and is expected to choose only one . our main contribution is that we develop an algorithm _ comparing the best _ ( ctb ) , which has excellent performance in terms of regret but whose computational demands grow with the number of arms , and a more computationally tractable variant _ scalable - ctb _ ( sctb ) for problems with many arms . we then prove that both algorithms have constant expected cumulative regret , and demonstrate through numerical experiments on simulated and real datasets that they significantly outperform existing algorithms . the paper is structured as follows . in section [ probform ] , we formulate our problem . in section [ methods ] , we introduce _ comparing the best _ ( ctb ) which works well for few arms and in section [ results ] , we prove ctb has constant expected cumulative regret . in section [ imple ] , we propose a scalable version of ctb that could work well in high dimension with a large number of arms , which is called _ scalable - ctb _ ( sctb ) . in section [ numerical ] , we compare ctb and sctb with three benchmarks using both simulated and real dataset . the numerical results suggest ctb and sctb outperform all benchmarks we considered . most work on dueling bandits focuses on the case that arms are independent , and zero regret occurs only when both of the pulled arms are optimal . under these assumptions , @xcite shows that the lower bound for the expected cumulative regret up to time t is @xmath0 . under the assumption that a condorcet winner ( an arm that has winning probability greater or equal to @xmath1 versus any other arms ) exists , algorithms were proposed that can reach the optimal regret bound under different conditions in the finite horizon setting , such as interleaved filter ( if ) @xcite and beat the mean ( btm ) @xcite . @xcite proposed relative uper confidence bound ( rucb ) , which is the first algorithm that can reach the optimal regret bound in the horizonless setting . recent research focuses on the case where a condorcet winner does not exist . @xcite proposed two algorithms , copeland confidence bound ( ccb ) and scalable copeland bandits ( scb ) , which have an optimal regret bound without the assumption that a condorcet winner exists . because they model arms as independent , these algorithms all require a large number of iterations before they can find the best arm , especially with many arms . in contrast , our paper focuses on the setting where arms are dependent and regret is only related to the best arm shown . as far as we know , no other previous work on dueling bandits studies this setting . outside of the dueling bandit literature , in the literature on active learning , @xcite considers an active learning problem that lacks the bandit objective based on cumulative regret but is otherwise similar . the primary purpose of @xcite is to sort the arms based on the user s preference . it proposes a novel algorithm , the query selection algorithm ( qsa ) , with the property that , when the number of arms n is sufficiently large , the expected number of operations to sort @xmath2 arms in the noiseless case is @xmath3 ( d is the dimension of the space ) instead of @xmath4 . they also show a high probability result in the noisy case . denote the user s latent preference vector as @xmath5 . there are n ( @xmath6 ) distinct arms lying in the d - dimensional space , denoted as @xmath7 . the user prefers @xmath8 over @xmath9 if and only if @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a known utility function . we assume that arms are ordered by the user s preferences , @xmath12 . throughout this paper , we use the terms `` arm @xmath8 '' and `` item @xmath8 '' interchangeably . at time t , the system chooses two items and forwards them to the user . we denote the index of these two arms at time t as @xmath13 and @xmath14 . suppose at time t , we forward item @xmath8 and @xmath9 to the user and the user prefers @xmath8 over @xmath9 . then the user chooses his / her favourite based on the following manner : the user chooses item @xmath8 with probability @xmath15 and item @xmath9 with probability @xmath16 . the system can observe the user s feedback @xmath17 , where @xmath18 means the user prefers @xmath19 and @xmath20 means the user prefers @xmath21 . here we denote @xmath22 , which is the lower bound of the probability that the user will choose his / her favourite item . based on its definition , we know p>0.5 . we briefly discuss two discrete choice models that can take advantage of our framework . the first model is logit model or bradley - terry model @xcite . in this case , the utility function is @xmath23 and the user will choose arm @xmath8 over @xmath9 with probability @xmath24 . another example is to model the user s choice with probit model @xcite . in this case , the utility function is still the inner product , but @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the cdf for a standard normal distribution given the difference between the two utilities follows a standard normal distribution . the regret r(t ) at time t is defined as @xmath27 , which is the difference in expected utility between the best arm overall and the best arm that the user can choose from those offered . since we think of the user as receiving the utility of the single arm chosen , we measure with respect to the best available arm , rather than some other function of the two offered arms . the cumulative regret up to time period t is defined as : @xmath28 . we measure the quality of an algorithm by its expected cumulative regret . now , we develop two algorithms ctb and sctb , and show they have constant expected cumulative regret . in this section , we propose an algorithm _ comparing the best _ ( ctb ) for this problem setting . each pair of arms @xmath8 and @xmath9 uniquely decides a _ winning space _ @xmath29 . based on the definition of winning space , we know when @xmath30 , the user with this @xmath31 will prefer item @xmath8 over @xmath9 . when the utility function is a linear function , this winning space is a half space . further @xmath32 and @xmath33 are two different winning spaces and their union is @xmath34 . throughout this paper , we use the phrases `` arm @xmath35 wins over arm @xmath36 in a duel '' , and `` winning space @xmath32 wins the duel '' interchangeably . each pair of arm determines two winning spaces and all winning spaces partition the space @xmath34 in to a number of cells . each cell can be written as intersection of winning spaces . to formally define a cell , we first denote @xmath37 when @xmath38 and @xmath39 when @xmath40 . then for a binary vector v , we denote the @xmath41 element of v as @xmath42 $ ] . finally , we define a cell as : the _ cell _ c corresponding to a @xmath43 length binary vector v is defined as @xmath44}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this definition , we use the @xmath45^{th}$ ] element of v to denote whether c belongs to @xmath32 or @xmath33 , for @xmath46 . in this paper , we use c(v ) to denote a cell that is defined by binary vector v. consider a sequence of binary vectors , all of length @xmath43 that are ordered lexicographically . denote @xmath47 the @xmath41 binary vector that corresponding to a non - empty cell . denote the number of non - empty cells as m , and denote the cells as @xmath48 where @xmath49 is corresponding to @xmath50 . with this definition , @xmath51 is the cell that corresponding to @xmath52 $ ] and thus @xmath53 . further we know @xmath51 is the cell that contains @xmath31 . this is because for any arm @xmath8 and @xmath9 with @xmath46 , since the user prefers @xmath8 over @xmath9 , we know @xmath54 , which means @xmath30 . denote @xmath55 , which is the collection of index of the winning spaces that contains @xmath56 . figure [ illustration ] is an illustration of winning spaces and cells . and @xmath57 ; @xmath58 and @xmath59 ; @xmath60 and @xmath61 ; @xmath62 and @xmath61 ; @xmath63 and @xmath64 ; @xmath65 and @xmath66 ; @xmath67 and @xmath68 . ] for each cell @xmath49 , denote the number of times that a winning space contains @xmath49 wins a duel before time t as @xmath69 . formally , @xmath70 each cell @xmath49 assigns a preference order to the arms . denote @xmath71 as the best arm suggested by cell i. formally , @xmath71 is the unique arm index j such that @xmath72 , @xmath73 . since @xmath51 is the cell that contains the true @xmath31 , we know @xmath74 . here we propose an algorithm _ comparing the best _ ( ctb ) , which selects two arms that are `` most likely '' to be the best arm and forwards them to the user . ctb stores a value for every cell , which can require an excessive amount of memory for problems with many arms . we introduce a scalable version of ctb in section [ imple ] , but we first prove that ctb has constant expected regret . in this section , we prove the expected cumulative regret of ctb is bounded by a constant . the main idea behind our proof is to show that for each cell @xmath49 with @xmath75 , @xmath76 $ ] is bounded by a constant . we show this in turn by showing @xmath77 can be modeled by a random walk with a larger probability of increasing than of decreasing . the following lemma , whose proof is in the supplement , allows us to bound the number of times this stochastic process takes negative values . [ basic ] for any @xmath78 , suppose z(t ) is a stochastic process with filtration @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 and @xmath82 , then we have @xmath83 \leq \frac{p}{(2p-1)^{2}}$ ] . we now proceed with the larger proof by defining @xmath84 which is the number of times that we forward @xmath8 and @xmath9 to the user and the user prefers @xmath8 over @xmath9 up to time t. then we can rewrite @xmath69 in terms of @xmath85 : @xmath86 based on the definition of @xmath51 , we know @xmath87 and @xmath88 . denote @xmath89 as the number of times that the system forwards arm @xmath8 and @xmath9 to the user . the next lemma shows @xmath90 $ ] is bounded by a constant for @xmath91 . [ mainlemma ] for @xmath91 , we have @xmath90\leq m\frac{p}{(2p-1)^{2}}$ ] , where m is the total number of non - empty cells . for @xmath91 , we can only pull arm @xmath9 when there is cell @xmath92 which believes @xmath9 is the best arm and its corresponding @xmath93 is greater or equal to @xmath94 . thus we have @xmath95\geq 0\ } , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last equation is because @xmath96 and thus @xmath97 . denote @xmath98 $ ] . then @xmath99 is very `` close '' to a random walk : * if we forward arm @xmath100 and @xmath101 to the user where @xmath102 and @xmath103 , then @xmath104 with probability @xmath105 and @xmath106 with probability @xmath107 , which is independent of previous history . further , since @xmath108 , every time we forward @xmath8 and @xmath9 to the user , @xmath99 will not remain the same . * if we forward arm @xmath100 and @xmath101 to the user where @xmath102 and @xmath109 , then @xmath110 . define @xmath111 , @xmath112 , for @xmath113 . because @xmath114 is a non - decreasing right continuous stopping time , we know it is a valid random change of time @xcite . define @xmath115 , which is the life time of the random change of time . here we consider a new stochastic process @xmath116 defined as @xmath117 for @xmath118 . for all sample path that @xmath119 , we define @xmath120 and @xmath121 for all @xmath122 . denote the filtration for w(t ) up to time t as @xmath79 . then : * for @xmath123 , we have @xmath124 . * for @xmath122 , based on its definition , we know @xmath125 . thus , we know @xmath116 is well defined and @xmath126 , @xmath127 and we know @xmath128 . since every time we forward arm @xmath8 and @xmath9 to the user , @xmath129 must hold , thus @xmath130 & \leq e\left[\sum_{b(s)=j}\sum_{k=1}^{t}\mathbbm{1}\{\sum_{(i^{'},j^{'})\in j_{s}\setminus j_{1}}[q_{i^{'},j^{'}}(k)-q_{j^{'},i^{'}}(k)]\geq 0\}\right ] , \nonumber \\ \leq & \sum_{s : b(s)=j}\left[e\left[\sum_{k=1}^{\infty}\mathbbm{1}\{w(k)\geq 0\}\right]\right ] \leq m \frac{p}{(2p-1)^{2}}.\nonumber \hspace{15mm}\qedhere \end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , denote @xmath131 . based on lemma [ mainlemma ] and a union bound , we obtain our main theorem , which is [ thm:1 ] the expected cumulative regret for ctb is bounded by @xmath132 . since each cell assigns a ranking for arms and different cells give us different rankings , we can bound m by @xmath133 , which is the number of all permutations . when the utility function is linear , then based on the results in @xcite , we know m is @xmath134 for sufficiently large n. ctb achieves a constant expected cumulative regret . however , it requires a great deal of memory to store @xmath69 for each cell , which makes it computationally infeasible for problems with many arms . instead of saving @xmath69 , equation [ reconstruct ] suggests that we can save @xmath85 and use @xmath85 to reconstruct @xmath69 . based on this idea , we propose a new algorithm , sctb that that has performance comparable to ctb , and that can work on much larger - scale problems . in sctb , we are going to set up step 1 and step 3 in ctb as a optimization problem in terms of @xmath85 . denote @xmath135 as a binary variable where @xmath136 means the cell is in @xmath32 and 0 otherwise , then based on equation [ reconstruct ] , maximizing @xmath69 is equivalent to maximizing @xmath137 subject to the constraint that the intersection of the winning spaces is not empty . in general , these constraints are not easy to describe in a way that admits optimization . instead , in sctb , we introduce imaginary cells that simplify the constraints . `` imaginary cells '' are cells that correspond to a valid collection of binary variables , and a valid intersection of winning spaces , but that are empty . cell c(v ) is an _ imaginary cell _ if @xmath138}=\emptyset$ ] . to find the best arm suggested by @xmath139 , in sctb , we first find @xmath140 for each arm @xmath141 after introducing the imaginary cells , which is the cell with largest @xmath69 such that this cell believes @xmath141 is the best . the @xmath41 problem is defined as follows : @xmath142 for the @xmath41 problem , there are three conditions in equation [ ip ] . the first condition says @xmath143 @xmath144 , which means cell @xmath145 that satisfies the first condition must lie in the winning space @xmath146 , @xmath144 . in other words , @xmath145 ranks arm @xmath141 better than any others and thus @xmath147 . the second and third condition together guarantees that cell @xmath145 either belongs to @xmath32 or @xmath33 . these three constraints will introduce some imaginary cells into the feasible solutions . however , this will not hurt our algorithm since @xmath31 lies in the cell @xmath51 and eventually @xmath94 will be the largest . though equation [ ip ] looks like an integer linear programming , it is in fact very easy to solve : the maximum value of this problem is reached when @xmath136 if @xmath148 for all @xmath149 , @xmath150 otherwise . denote the maximum value of the @xmath151 problem at time t as @xmath152 . after knowing @xmath153 , then finding the best arm with largest @xmath69 is equivalent to finding @xmath154 . now we are ready to introduce the _ scalable - ctb _ it is the same as ctb except we have introduced imaginary cells , simplifying the constraints in equation [ ip ] . the sctb algorithm is as follows . [ thm : imple ] the expected cumulative regret for sctb is bounded by @xmath155 . the proof is similar to theorem [ thm:1 ] , which is in the supplement . in this section , we compare ctb and sctb with three benchmarks : thompson sampling , relative upper confidence bound ( rucb ) and the query selection algorithm ( qsa ) @xcite . thompson sampling uses a posterior distribution over the cell containing theta , and this posterior is computed by beginning with a prior distribution on the location of @xmath31 , and updating this prior using bayes rule and knowledge of @xmath156 . at time t , we generate @xmath157 from the posterior distribution @xmath158 and forward the two arms that @xmath157 ranks the top two to the user and receives the user s feedback . in our implementation , we track the prior / posterior explicitly by storing a probability for each cell . an exact implementation of thompson sampling scales poorly with the number of cells and so we only compare against thompson sampling in the setting with fewer arms ( see section [ small ] , where the prior on theta is uniform over the unit sphere ) . it may also be possible to implement thompson sampling using gibbs sampling although this would be substantially more complicated than sctb . we also emphasized that thompson sampling as we consider it here requires knowledge of @xmath156 which is not typically not available . we choose rucb as our benchmark because it works well when a condorcet winner exists , and existence of a condorcet winner is a consequence of our modeling assumptions . though there are algorithms that claim to outperform rucb such as ccb and scb @xcite , they mainly work better in the case where a condorcet winner does not exist . throughout this section , we assume the utility function is @xmath23 . in the first two examples with simulated data , both the arms and the user s preference vector @xmath31 are uniformly generated from the unit sphere . also , we assume @xmath159 for all @xmath46 . in the yelp academic dataset , we use the probit model to model the user s choice . [ numerical ] in this section , we compare ctb and sctb with thompson sampling , rucb and qsa using 20 arms in 2-dimensional space . figure [ fig:1 ] shows that ctb is the best algorithm , which means that if we can store @xmath69 for all cells , then ctb typically beats thompson sampling . though sctb did not perform as well as ctb and thompson sampling , it outperforms qsa and rucb . sctb has an advantage over thompson sampling and ctb in that it can work on a much larger - scale problem . in this section , we compare sctb with rucb and qsa on a problem with 50 arms in 20-dimensional space . as can be seen from the figure [ fig : simulated_data ] , rucb almost has a linear regret when the time is short . this is in general true in the dueling bandits literature , which typically requires @xmath160 iterations before it starts to achieve @xmath161 cumulative regret for 50 arms . our algorithm finds the optimal arm after roughly 500 iterations and reaches constant expected cumulative regret . 0.5 0.5 in this section , we compare sctb with rucb and qsa using the yelp academic dataset @xcite . in this experiment , we choose 100 restaurants from las vegas as our arms . for each restaurant , we represent it by a 20-dim feature vector , calculated using doc2vec @xcite on its review . we select 49 users who have reviewed at least 20 of these 100 restaurants and calculate their preference vectors using linear regression . denote the estimated variance of the residuals from the linear regression as @xmath162 . since for each user , there are some restaurants that he / she hasnt reviewed , we rank the preference for restaurants based on the inner product between the user s preference vector and the restaurant s feature vector . for restaurant i and restaurant j with feature vector @xmath8 and @xmath9 , the user with preference vector @xmath31 will choose restaurant i with probability @xmath163 , where @xmath26 is the cdf for the normal distribution with mean 0 and variance @xmath164 . the result is summarized in figure [ fig : yelp_data ] . sctb outperforms both rucb and qsa significantly . rucb has a linear regret when the time is short . in this paper , we consider dueling bandits for online content recommendation . we formulate a new setting which differs from the traditional dueling bandits where arms are dependent , and regret depends only on the best arm shown . we propose two algorithms ctb and sctb which are proved to have constant expected cumulative regret . numerical experiments suggest our algorithms outperform all existing algorithms considered , in both simulated and real dataset . denote @xmath166 $ ] and @xmath167 , then we know @xmath165=1+(1-p)(a+e[\sum_{t=0}^{\infty}\mathbbm{1}\{z(t)\leq 0\}])+pb(e[\sum_{t=0}^{\infty}\mathbbm{1}\{z(t)\leq 0\ } ] ) . \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] now we need to calculate the expression for a and b respectively . based on the definition of a , we can rewrite a as @xmath168 $ ] . it is easy to show that @xmath169 is a martingale . here we define a stopping time @xmath170 as @xmath171 . then we know @xmath172 stops at @xmath170 is a martingale and thus @xmath173=e[z(\tau)]-(2p-1)e[\tau]=0 $ ] . thus @xmath174 . suppose w(t ) is a random walk and @xmath177 with probability p and @xmath178 with probability 1-p . based on the previous lemma , we just need to show @xmath165\leq e[\sum_{t=0}^{\infty}\mathbbm{1}\{w(t)\leq 0\ } ] . \label{bound}\end{aligned}\ ] ] because @xmath179=\sum_{t=0}^{\infty}p(w(t)\leq 0)$ ] and @xmath180 thus , we know equation [ bound ] holds true . based on the same proof , we can show that @xmath130&\leq\sum_{r}e\left[\sum_{k=1}^{t}\mathbbm{1}\{\sum_{(i_{0},j_{0})\in j_{j , r}\setminus j_{1}}[q_{i_{0},j_{0}}(k)-q_{j_{0},i_{0}}(k)]\geq 0\}\right ] \nonumber \\ & \leq 2^{\frac{n(n-1)}{2}}\frac{p}{(2p-1)^{2}}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we know our theorem holds true .

we consider online content recommendation with implicit feedback through pairwise comparisons . we study a new formulation of the dueling bandit problems in which arms are dependent and regret occurs when neither pulled arm is optimal . we propose a new algorithm , _ comparing the best _ ( ctb ) , with computational requirements appropriate for problems with few arms , and a variation of this algorithm whose computation scales to problems with many arms . we show both algorithms have constant expected cumulative regret . we demonstrate through numerical experiments on simulated and real dataset that these algorithms improve significantly over existing algorithms in the setting we study .

0805.0401

the left - right ( lr ) symmetric model @xcite , based on the gauge group @xmath3 , is an attractive extension of the standard model ( sm ) . the symmetry requires the introduction of right - handed partners for the observed gauge bosons and neutrinos , and a higgs sector containing one bi - doublet @xmath4 ( 2,2,0 ) , one left - handed triplet @xmath5 ( 3,1,2 ) and one right - handed triplet @xmath6 ( 1,3,2 ) . in such a minimal lr symmetric model , parity is an exact symmetry of the theory at high energy scale , and is broken spontaneously at low energy scale due to the asymmetric vacuum . also cp asymmetry can be realized as a consequence of spontaneous symmetry breaking , namely the spontaneous cp violation ( scpv ) @xcite . however , such a scenario suffers from nontrivial constraints from the vacuum minimization conditions . it is explicitly demonstrated that the scpv is not so easily realized if all the parameters in the higgs potential are real and endowed with natural values @xcite . the difficulty results from the facts that one of the neutral higgs bosons carries dangerous tree level flavor changing neutral currents ( fcnc ) effect , and that quark flavor mixing angles and cp violating phase are all calculable quantities due to the lr symmetry . therefore , many generalized cp violation scenarios beyond the scpv case have been analyzed extensively @xcite . in these literatures , the masses of right - handed gauge boson @xmath7 and the fcnc higgs boson are strongly constrained from low energy phenomenology . although the ckm matrix are more general not to be fully fixed than the scpv case , it is proved that there is only one physical complex phase in the yukawa couplings @xcite . hence the fcnc higgs boson s couplings ca nt be absolutely free . the fcnc higgs boson s mass still accepts strict bound . in terms of these observations , a generalized two higgs bi - doublets model is proposed @xcite . in this model , quark mass matrices become far more flexible and the fcnc higgs boson s yukawa couplings are now free parameters . thereby low energy bound on the right - handed scale is largely alleviated . as other generalized models , the two higgs bi - doublets version of lr model also has the advantage to realize the scpv without the fine - tuning problem . the lr symmetric model is also motivated to explain the very tiny neutrino masses . when the vacuum expectation value ( vev ) @xmath8 of the neutral component of @xmath6 is very huge , typically of order @xmath9 gev , the well - known seesaw mechanism provides a very natural explanation of the smallness of neutrino masses @xcite . however , the right - handed gauge bosons @xmath10 and @xmath7 are too heavy to be detected at the large hadron collider ( lhc ) and the future colliders . to allow for the possibility of an observable right - handed scale , many authors focus on the @xmath11 tev case . although the seesaw mechanism can work well , we have to face the so - called vev - seesaw puzzle . namely , @xmath12 is of order @xmath13 rather than the anticipant @xmath14 , where @xmath15 and @xmath16 are located in the higgs potential . one may introduce a discrete @xmath17 symmetry @xmath18 and @xmath19 to resolve this vev - seesaw problem @xcite . it is worthwhile to stress that neutrinos are the dirac particles in this scenario . if we preserve the majorana yukawa couplings , the corresponding model must lie beyond the lr symmetric model . the @xmath17 symmetry leads to the absence of both @xmath16-type terms and the majorana yukawa couplings , hence @xmath20 due to the minimization conditions . furthermore , we find that the neutral higgs bosons @xmath21 and @xmath22 are a pair of stable weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) . this is an important feature of our scenario which hasnt been indicated before . it is a natural idea that @xmath21 and @xmath22 may be the cold dark matter candidates @xcite . we firstly calculate the wimp - nucleon elastic scattering cross section which has been strongly constrained by the direct dark matter detection experiments , such as the cdms@xcite and xenon@xcite . however , our result is 3 - 5 orders of magnitude above the present bounds for @xmath23 gev @xcite . to avoid this puzzle , @xmath21 and @xmath22 ca nt dominate all the dark matter . we find that our scenario is consistent with the direct dark matter detection experiments only when @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is the total relic number density of @xmath21 and @xmath22 . this bound requires the dark matter annihilation cross sections must be very large . in this work , we examine whether our scenario can provide very large annihilation cross sections so as to derive the desired relic abundance . in this paper we try to give a comprehensive analysis on these lr models with general parameter setting . firstly , we perform a detailed investigation on the simplest lr model with one higgs bi - doublet , in which there are no any cp violation phases . then we generalize the simplest lr model to some other more complicated situations . it turns out that there s no significant differences among these one higgs bi - doublet versions of lr model because the gauge and higgs sectors are basically the same . whereas in the two higgs bi - doublet case , there would be more higgs bosons and the yukawa couplings might be quite different . hence more delicate analysis is needed . the remaining part of this paper is organized as follows . in section ii , we briefly describe the main features of the lr symmetric model and discuss the vev - seesaw problem . in section iii and iv , the direct dark matter detection experiments put very strong constraints on the relic number density and the annihilation cross sections . in section v , we analyze whether the simplest lr model can be consistent with the above constraints or not . then we generalize the simplest lr model to the two higgs bi - doublets case in sec vi . the summary and comments are given in section vii . the minimal lr symmetric model consists of one higgs bi - doublet @xmath4 ( 2,2,0 ) , one left - handed higgs triplet @xmath5 ( 3,1,2 ) and one right - handed higgs triplet @xmath6 ( 1,3,2 ) , which can be written as @xmath26 after the spontaneous symmetry breaking , the higgs multiplets can have the following vacuum expectation values @xmath27 where @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath8 are in general complex . without loss of generality , one can choose @xmath28 and @xmath8 to be real , while assign complex phases @xmath31 and @xmath32 for @xmath33 and @xmath30 , respectively . following the requirements of the lr symmetry , we can write down the most general form of the higgs potential @xcite @xmath34 \right ) - \mu_2 ^ 2\left({\rm tr } \left[\tilde{\phi}\phi^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr}\left[\tilde{\phi% } ^{\dagger } \phi \right ] \right ) -\mu_3 ^ 2 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \lambda_1 \left ( \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi \phi^{\dagger } \right ] \right)^2 \right)+ \lambda_2 \left ( \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi } \phi^{\dagger } \right ] \right)^2 + \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi}^{\dagger } \phi \right ] \right)^2 \right ) + \lambda_3 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi } \phi^{\dagger } \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi}^{\dagger } \phi \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \lambda_4 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi \phi^{\dagger } \right ] \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi } \phi^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi}^{\dagger } \phi \right ] \right ) \right ) + \rho_1 \left ( \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] \right)^2+\left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right)^2 \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \rho_2 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l^{\dagger } \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r \right]{\rm tr } \left [ \delta_r^{\dagger } \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) + \rho_3 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \rho_4 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r^{\dagger } \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l^{\dagger } \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \alpha_1 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi \phi^{\dagger } \right ] \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \alpha_2 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi \tilde{\phi}^{\dagger } \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r^{\dagger } \right]+ { \rm tr } \left [ \phi^{\dagger } \tilde{\phi } \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \alpha^\ast_2 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi^{\dagger } \tilde{\phi } \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_r \delta_r^{\dagger } \right]+ { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi}^{\dagger } \phi \right ] { \rm tr } \left [ \delta_l \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \alpha_3 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi \phi^{\dagger } \delta_l \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \phi^{\dagger } \phi \delta_r \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \beta_1 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi \delta_r \phi^{\dagger } \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \phi^{\dagger } \delta_l \phi \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) + \beta_2 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{\phi } \delta_r \phi^{\dagger } \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ { \tilde{\phi}}^{\dagger } \delta_l \phi \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \beta_3 \left ( { \rm tr } \left [ \phi \delta_r { \tilde{\phi}}^{\dagger } \delta_l^{\dagger } \right ] + { \rm tr } \left [ \phi^{\dagger } \delta_l \tilde{\phi } \delta_r^{\dagger } \right ] \right)\ ; , % ( 3)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath35 and all parameters @xmath36 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 and @xmath40 are real . only @xmath41 can be complex . the phases of @xmath29 and @xmath30 may lead to the scpv @xcite . it has been shown that the combing constraints from @xmath42 and @xmath43 system actually exclude the minimal lr symmetric model with the scpv in the decoupling limit @xcite . for our present purpose , we investigate here the simplest lr model , in which @xmath41 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 and the yukawa couplings are real . it is worthwhile to stress that our remaining analysis can be generalized to the other cp violation scenarios @xcite . in the minimal lr symmetric model , the lagrangian relevant for the neutrino masses reads @xcite : @xmath44 where @xmath45 . after the spontaneous symmetry breaking , one may obtain the effective ( light and left - handed ) neutrino mass matrix @xmath46 via the type ii seesaw mechanism : @xmath47 where @xmath48 gev represents the electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) scale and @xmath49 . the charged lepton mass matrix is given by @xmath50 . the electroweak precision test requires @xmath51 . barring extreme fine - tuning , the neutrino masses @xmath52 ev @xcite forces @xmath30 to be of order a few ev or less , thereby requiring @xmath53 gev for @xmath54 . in this case , the right - handed gauge bosons @xmath10 and @xmath7 are too heavy to be detected at the lhc and the future colliders . to allow for the possibility of an observable right - handed scale , many authors focus on the @xmath55 tev case . although the seesaw mechanism can work well , we need to resolve the so - called vev - seesaw puzzle @xcite , which is indicated by a simple vacuum minimization equation : @xmath56 without loss of generality , one can write eq.([vev see - saw ] ) in a compact form : @xmath57 in view of the naturalness , one expects @xmath58 . however , we find that @xmath59 as long as @xmath60 tev . this is the infamous vev - seesaw problem in the literatures @xcite . the neutrino mass matrix @xmath61 in eq . ( [ seesaw 1 ] ) can also be written as @xmath62 it is shown that the vev - seesaw relationship implies the unnaturalness for the auxiliary parameter @xmath63 if one wants to search for new physics at tev scale . to avoid the vev - seesaw puzzle , a smart way is to introduce some new symmetries to eliminate all @xmath16-type terms of the higgs potential . however this is not a easy task in the current model . one may guess there exists some additional global symmetries like @xmath64 acting on the higgs fields which can eliminate all @xmath16-type terms @xcite . however , such alternative always affects the fermion sector and fails to give correct fermion masses and mixing . if there is an approximate @xmath64 horizontal symmetry to suppress @xmath40 without eliminating them completely , then one may solve the vev - seesaw problem @xcite . unfortunately , this model yields a small mixing angle within the first two lepton generations . in ref.@xcite , the authors suggest a @xmath17 symmetry @xmath65 which can eliminate all @xmath16-type terms of the higgs potential . however , this discrete symmetry also eliminates the majorana yukawa couplings , which implies that neutrinos are dirac particles . at this moment , eq.([vev see - saw ] ) becomes @xmath66 one may immediately dismiss the possibility @xmath67 , which implies two massless left - handed higgs triplet bosons . thus the only left choice is @xmath20 . the @xmath17 symmetry leads to @xmath20 and the absence of both @xmath16-type terms and majorana yukawa couplings . furthermore , we find that the lightest particles among the members of left - handed higgs triplet @xmath5 , namely @xmath21 and @xmath22 , are two degenerate and stable particles . a natural idea is that @xmath21 and @xmath22 may be the cold dark matter candidates . in the following sections we shall discuss the possibility of @xmath21 and @xmath22 being the cold dark matter candidates by evaluating all relevant annihilation processes . the main features of the lr symmetric model with @xmath17 symmetry have been shown in ref.@xcite . here , we show the mass spectrum for the higgs bosons and gauged bosons at leading order in table . i , with approximations @xmath68 and @xmath69 mentioned in appendix a. gauge bosons @xmath70 and @xmath10 are defined by @xmath71 and @xmath72 , where the subscript @xmath73 denotes the weinberg angle @xmath74 . in addition , all the trilinear and quartic scalar interactions and scalar - gauge interactions are listed in appendix a for convenience . .the mass spectrum for the higgs bosons and the gauged bosons in the lr symmetric model with @xmath17 symmetry . here , we have neglected the terms in order of @xmath75 and @xmath76 . [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] the relevant scalar trilinear couplings and quartic couplings under the unitary gauge are shown in table [ triquarcpl ] . here we write out the scalar - gauge interactions : @xmath77+(-\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\delta_r^{--}w_r^+w_r^++h.c.)\right\}\nonumber\\ & + & g^2k\bigg\{\frac{1}{2}h_1^{-}(w_{3r}w_l^+-w_{3l}w_r^+)-\frac{1}{2}(h_1 ^ 0+ia_1 ^ 0)w_l^-w_r^++h.c.\nonumber\\ & + & \frac{1}{4}h^0[(w_{3l}-w_{3r})(w_{3l}-w_{3r})+2(w_l^+w_l^-+w_r^+w_r^-)]\bigg\}\label{hvv};\\ \mathcal{l}_{hhv}&=&\frac{ig}{2}h_1 ^ -\partial h_1^+(w_{3l}+w_{3r})-i\delta_r^{++}\partial\delta_r^{--}(gw_{3r}+g'b ) -ig(\delta_r^{--}\partial\delta_r^+-\delta_r^+\partial\delta_r^{--})w_r^+\nonumber\\ & + & \frac{ig}{2}\left[(h_1 ^ -\partial h_1 ^ 0-h_1 ^ 0\partial h_1 ^ -)w_l^++(h^0\partial h_1 ^ --h_1 ^ -\partial h^0)w_r^+\right]\nonumber\\ & + & \frac{g}{2}\left[(a_1 ^ 0\partial h_1 ^ --h_1 ^ -\partial a_1 ^ 0)w_r^++h.c.\right.\nonumber\\ & + & \left.(h_1 ^ 0\partial a_1 ^ 0-a_1 ^ 0\partial h_1 ^ 0)(w_{3l}-w_{3r})\right]\label{hhv},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the connection between weak eigenstates @xmath78 and physical states @xmath79 are demonstrated by the following orthogonal transformation at the leading order : @xmath80 the @xmath81 gauge coupling @xmath82 and @xmath83 coupling @xmath84 are related to @xmath85 gauge coupling @xmath86 : @xmath87 here our conventions are the same as those in ref . @xcite . p. minkowski , phys . lett . b * 67 * , 421 ( 1977 ) ; t. yanagida , in _ proceedings of the workshop on unified theory and the baryon number of the universe _ , edited by o. sawada and a. sugamoto ( kek , tsukuba , 1979 ) ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond , and r. slansky , in _ supergravity _ , edited by f. van nieuwenhuizen and d. freedman ( north holland , amsterdam , 1979 ) ; s.l . glashow , in _ quarks and leptons _ , edited by m. l@xmath88vy _ et al . _ ( plenum , new york , 1980 ) ; r.n mohapatra and g. senjanovic , phys . rev . lett . * 44 * , 912 ( 1980 ) . j. d. bekenstein , phys . d * 70 * , 083509 ( 2004 ) ; c. skordis , d. f. mota , p. g. ferreira and c. boehm , phys . lett . * 96 * , 011301 ( 2006 ) ; i. ferreras , m. sakellariadou and m. f. yusaf , phys . lett . * 100 * , 031302 ( 2008 ) ; x. f. wu , b. famaey , g. gentile , h. perets and h. s. zhao , arxiv:0803.0977 ; and references cited therein .

in the framework of left - right symmetric model , we investigate an interesting scenario , in which the so - called vev seesaw problem can be naturally solved with @xmath0@xmath1 symmetry . in such a scenario , we find a pair of stable weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) , which may be the cold dark matter candidates . however , the wimp - nucleon cross section is 3 - 5 orders of magnitude above the present upper bounds from the direct dark matter detection experiments for @xmath2 gev . as a result , the relic number density of two stable particles has to be strongly suppressed to a very small level . nevertheless , our analysis shows that this scenario ca nt provide very large annihilation cross sections so as to give the desired relic abundance except for the resonance case . only for the case if the rotation curves of disk galaxies are explained by the modified newtonian dynamics ( mond ) , the stable wimps could be as the candidates of cold dark matter .

1111.5074

maxwel introduced , in 1871 , a notorious being , known as maxwell s demon nowadays , to discuss the `` limitations of the second law of thermodynamics''@xcite . such a demon distinguishes the velocities of the gas particles and controls a tiny door on a partition of the gas container to create a temperature difference , which breaks the clausius statement of the second law of thermodynamics ( slot ) . to reveal the essence of the maxwell s demon , leo szilard proposed a single - particle heat engine @xcite , named as szilard heat engine ( she ) . the demon in she distinguishes the positions of the particles after the partition has been inserted . with the help of the demon , she can absorb heat from a single heat resource and convert it into work without apperant evoking other changes in the cycle . szilard pointed out that the slot was no longer violated if one considered the entropy increase during the measurement . brillouin generalized the szilard s argument and identified the thermodynamic entropy with the informational entropy firstly @xcite . however , the measurement could be carried out without any change in entropy @xcite . acutally , it was realized that a logically irreversible process must be `` accompanied by dissipative effects '' @xcite in the physical realization of the information processing , which is known as landauer s erasure principle . bennett used this point of view in the study of the maxwell s demon paradox and pointed out that the erasure of the demon s memory instead of the measurement was logically irreversible and thus must be accompanied by dissipative effects @xcite . with these observations , the conventional cycle presented by szilard is indeed not a thermodynamic cycle because the demon s memory has not been erased to complete the cycle . the slot will be saved if one considers the erasure process to finish the cycle of the demon . as people believe the essence of information should be discussed in the framework of quantum mechanics , various quantum versions of she have been proposed with different views about quantum measurements . one proposal is semi - classical @xcite . the working substance in this proposal is quantum mechanic while the demon is considered as a classical controller whose role is to extract information through measurement and control the system . the paradox of maxwell s demon was solved by arguing landauer s erasure principle . however , the final solution should include the md in the cycle and treat also the md in a quantum fasion@xcite . for she , it is also proved the existence of md will not violate the slot in ref . @xcite , where md is modeled as a two - level system . the focus of the study in both classical and quantum mechanical frameworks is the erasure process , which is crucial to solving the maxwell s demon paradox . in an odinary way , the demon and the working substance are in contact with the same heat bath . after erasing the demon by applying some work , one will find that she can not extract work in a cycle at all and the slot is not violated . however , a more general erasure should be done with a lower - temperature heat bath which is also called a heat sink . in this suituation , we turn the she into a thermal dynamic cycle , where the non - violation of slot can be proved by illustrating non - exceeding of carnot s efficiency . it is realized that the effective temperature of the md s initial state actually charasticrizes the error in the control of the heat engine@xcite . our previous work in ref . @xcite emphasized the functions of the demon with errors in the study of the single - particle she . but the erasure schemes in refs . @xcite are irreversible . therefore , the efficiencies of the heat engines in these papers can not reach the carnot cycle s efficiency . one purpose of the present paper is to establish an optimal scheme of the thermodynamic cycle with a reversible erasure process , assisted by demon . it is shown that the partition - removing process is not always reversible , which leads to the lower efficiency . we aso find the existence of the optimal expansion position to improve the efficiency of the single particle she to the carnot cycle s efficiency . the other purpose of this paper is to reveal the role of the quantum statistical properties of the working substance . we generalize our previous works about demon - assisted quantum heat engine by using a multi - particle working substance , which is the ideal bose or fermi gases , and find that the ratio of the work extracted to the working temperature has some discontinuous behavior , and that discontinuous behavior is closely related to the degenerate - ground - state phenomenon . the paper is organized as follows : in sec . [ sec2 ] we describe the model of quantum multi - particle she and the working scheme briefly . in sec . [ sec3 ] , we study in details the five steps of the working scheme : insertion , measurement , controlled expansion , removing and erasure separately and calculate the work applied and heat transferred in each step . in sec . [ sec4 ] , the efficiency of the engine is evaluated . it is found that our heat engine s efficiency can not exceed the carnot cycle s efficiency . for single - particle she , we optimize the scheme to make the efficiency of the engine reach the one of carnot s . in sec . [ sec5 ] , we discuss the behavior of the engine in low - temperature regime and show the ratio of the work extrated to the working temperature is closely related to the degenerate point ( whose definition can be seen in this section ) and the particles statistical properties . conclusions and remarks are given in sec . [ sec6 ] . ( color online ) modeling the chamber of gas by a one - dimensional infinite square well . ( a ) the chamber is modeled as a one - dimensional infinite square well with width @xmath0 where the particles are confined . the inner lines in the well represent the single - particle energy levels of the well . ( b ) after the insertion , the chamber is split into two chambers , which are modeled as two 1-d infinite square wells with widths @xmath1 and @xmath2 respectively . the inner lines represent the single - particle energy levels . , width=302 ] ( color online ) the states of the chamber and the demon ( a ) before and ( b ) after the expansion process . ( a ) after the measurement , the demon has revealed the number of the particles in the right compartment @xmath3 and recorded this information in its memory . if the demon is error - free , then its inner state ( or memory ) will be @xmath4 . however , when the demon contains some errors , there would be some mistakes in the demon s memory . for example , the sub - figure(2 ) shows a situation when @xmath5 and the demon is in state @xmath6 . thus , there are total @xmath7 situations after the measurement for a system with @xmath8 particles . here , the total @xmath9 situations are listed for @xmath10 . ( d ) after the measurement , the partition acts as a piston under the control of the demon . if the demon is in the state @xmath4 , the piston will move to a new position @xmath11 . such a movement is called controlled expansion . here the results of the expansion for all @xmath9 situations are listed for @xmath10.,width=302 ] the working substance is modeled as a collection of @xmath8 particles confined in a chamber , which is described as a one - dimensional infinitely deep square well with width @xmath0 illustrated in fig . [ chamber](a ) . generally , the particles can satisfy any distribution , bose distribution or fermi distribution . we calculate the canonical partition function @xmath12 as follows , where the subscript @xmath13 denotes the number of the particles in the well and @xmath1 represents the width of the well . its explicit expression is given in the appendix [ appendix1 ] . in the following calculations , we do not specify the concrete partition functions in most cases . the results obtained are valid for both bose and fermi distributions except for the case we claim specifically . in the model , maxwell s demon is described as a quantum system with @xmath14 energy levels to record the complete information about how many particles in each compartment after the insertion process . we may use a demon with number of energy levels less than @xmath14 , but it can only record partial information of the working substance , which decreases the work extract . we consider in the present paper only the demon with @xmath14 levels , with @xmath4 be its @xmath3-th eigen - state and @xmath15 be the energy of state @xmath4 . the energy of @xmath16 is set to be the zero point of energy , i.e. , @xmath17 . for a demon without errors , its initial state is a pure state , namely , @xmath18 . in this paper , we study the demon with errors generally , whose initial state can be written as @xmath19 when @xmath20 vanish for all @xmath21 , this demon returns to the one without errors , where@xmath16 is the standard state . for a demon with errors , a larger population @xmath22 in the state @xmath16 means a more efficient demon @xcite . the thermodynamic cycle consists the five steps . at the beginning , the working substance is in equilibrium with the heat resource at a higher temperature @xmath23 , and the demon is initially in the state @xmath24 ( see eq . ( [ ini_demon ] ) ) . in the first step , a partition is inserted at the position @xmath1 , which splits the initial well into two with widths being @xmath1 and @xmath2 respectively ( see fig . [ chamber](b ) ) . after the insertion , there are @xmath14 possible situations and one does not know which situation happens . suppose @xmath3 to be the number of the particles in the right compartment . then the @xmath14 situations correspond to @xmath25 . in the second step , the demon measures the working substance and records this information in its memory . for the error - free demon , it would be in the state @xmath4 for the @xmath3-th situation after the measurement . however , the demon with errors may record wrong information . for example , the working substance is in 0-th situation while the demon is in the state @xmath6 as illustrated in fig . [ expansion](a ) . in the third step , the partition acts as a piston and expands under the control of the demon . specifically , if the demon is in the state @xmath4 , it will move the piston to the position @xmath11 ( see fig . [ expansion](b ) ) . actually , one can optimize the expansion position @xmath11 to get the best efficiency . in the fourth step , the partition is removed and the working substance returns to its initial state . after these four steps , the working substance absorbs heat from the heat resource and converts it into work . it seems to violate the slot . however , the demon has not returned to its initial state to complete the cycle . thus , an additional step , step five , is needed to erase the memory of the demon . the effect of this step saves the slot as pointed out by landauer s erasure principle . in this section , we analyze in detail the thermodynamic cycle of the quantum multi - particle she . we calculate the heat absorbed and work applied in each step . in the first step , the partition is inserted isothermally , which means the working substance is in contact with a heat resource and the process is quasi - static . before the insertion , the state of working substance @xmath26 is @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the inverse temperature and the boltzmann constant is set to be unit , i.e. , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 represents the hamiltonian of @xmath8 particles confined in the infinite square well with width @xmath0 . @xmath31 is the corresponding partition function and its explicit expression is presented in appendix [ appendix1 ] . after the insertion , the chamber is split into two parts with widths @xmath1 and @xmath2 respectively and the substance is in an equilibrium state as @xmath32 here , @xmath33 describes an equilibrium state of the left chamber with similar meaning as those in @xmath34 . @xmath35 is the probability to find @xmath3 particles in the right chamber with insertion position being @xmath1 . as the process is isothermal , the work applied in this step is the difference of the free energies after and before the insertion , i.e. , @xmath36 and the heat absorbed is @xmath37 the free energy and the entropy are given in terms of the partition functions as @xmath38 and @xmath39 respectively . as shown in ref . @xcite , in quantum mechanics framework , the insertion work @xmath40 is no longer zero . moreover , it was proved in ref . @xcite that @xmath41 . in the second step , the total system is isolated from the heat bath . the demon finds out the number of the particles in the right compartment . this measurement process aims at establishing the correlation between the working substance and the demon . for the demon with no error , the state of the demon after the measurement is @xmath4 when there are @xmath3 particles in the right compartment . for the demon with errors , its initial state is a mixed state . thus , we should appoint the final states of the demon for all situations . let the final state be @xmath42 when the demon is initially in the state @xmath43 and the number of the particles in the right compartment is @xmath3 . mathematically , @xmath44 is a map from the set @xmath45 to itself . if the demon is error - free , the final state will be @xmath4 when there are @xmath3 particles in the right compartment , which leads the first constraint of @xmath46 , i.e. , @xmath47 . with this notation , the operator representing this measurement is @xmath48,\ ] ] where @xmath49 represents the @xmath11-th eigen - state of the working substance when there are @xmath3 particles in the right compartment . for a physical operation , @xmath50 should be unitary ( so that it is a quantum nondemolition pre - measurement ) , which leads to another constraint of @xmath51 . that is , for a fixed @xmath3 , when @xmath52 runs over from @xmath53 to @xmath8 , @xmath51 should also run over from @xmath53 to @xmath8 . thus , @xmath54 is a permutation of @xmath45 which satisfies @xmath47 . when @xmath55 , there is only one function of such kind and the corresponding operator @xmath50 represents a controlled - not operation . for @xmath56 , such function exists . one realization is @xmath57 . after the measurement , the state of the total system becomes @xmath58 , namely @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the inverse of the map @xmath46 . it follows from eq . ( [ state_aft_mea ] ) that there is a possibility that the demon is in the state @xmath4 while the number of particles in the right compartment is not @xmath3 . that is exactly what we mean ` error ' within the demon . due to the isolation from the heat bath , there is no heat transferred , @xmath61 , and the work applied is just the energy change during the measurement : @xmath62\delta_{j},\ ] ] which compensates for the energy difference between the initial state and the final state of the demon during the measurement . therefore , if all the energy levels of the demon are degenerate , one will not apply any work to perform the measurement . thus the work applied may not always be non - zero @xcite . in this step , the partition in the chamber acts as a piston and will be moved to the position according to the memory of the demon . specifically , if the state of the demon is @xmath4 , the finial position will be @xmath11 , which is called expansion position . this expansion process is slow enough and the working substance is in contact with the heat resource during the total expansion process . thus the state of the total system after the controlled expansion is @xmath63 however , the ` impenetrability ' of the piston does not make this process an isothermal process since the transition between two states with different numbers of the particles in the right compartment is forbidden . thus we should deal with this expansion process for each situation separately . for the situation when the demon is in state @xmath43 and there are @xmath3 particles in the right compartment , the work applied @xmath64 is @xmath65 and the heat absorbed @xmath66 is @xmath67 the probability of this situation is @xmath68 . thus , the total work applied and the total heat absorbed are : @xmath69 respectively . one can prove that even if the controlled expansion is not isothermal , the heat absorbed also satisfies the relationship @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is the entropy change of the total system . since the states with different numbers of the particles in the right compartment are orthogonal to each other , the entropies of the total system before and after the controlled expansion are @xmath72 respectively , where @xmath73 . thus , we have the following relationship @xmath74 ( color online ) the removing process . ( a ) before the removing , the state of the working substance may not be an equilibrium state because of the ` impenetrability ' of the partition ( see the sub - section [ expansion ] ) . ( b ) when the partition is lifted a little , it is no longer impenetrable and the particles can fly between the two sides of the chamber freely to reach the equilibrium state . ( c ) the partition keeps being lifted and finally be removed isothermally . , width=302 ] after the controlled expansion , the partition will be removed slowly while the working substance is in contact with the heat resource . because the state in eq . ( [ state_aft_exp ] ) before removing is not a thermal equilibrium state ( it is because the controlled expansion is not an isothermal process , see the last subsection ) , one should carefully deal with this step . once lifted a little , the partition is no longer ` impenetrable ' and the particles can fly between the two sides of the chamber freely to reach an equilibrium state . thus the removing process consists of two sub - steps . after the first sub - step finished , the partition has been lifted to create a small slit with width @xmath75 through which the particles can fly from one side to the other . whatever small the width @xmath75 of the slit is , the working substance can reach its equilibrium state . thus , we can let the width of the slit tend to zero , i.e. , @xmath76 , which makes this sub - step a thermalization process of the working substance while the partition remains still . thereafter the state of the system after the first sub - step becomes @xmath77 where @xmath78 . during this process , there is no work applied ( since @xmath76 ) and the heat absorbed is exactly the difference between the inner energies of the total system before and after the first sub - step , @xmath79\left[u(\rho_{n - i}^{l}(l_{j}))+u(\rho_{i}^{r}(l - l_{j}))\right].\ ] ] after the thermalization , the working substance is in a thermal equilibrium state , which makes the rest sub - step , the second sub - step , an isothermal process . after the removing , the working substance returns to its initial state and the correlation between the working substance and the demon no longer exists . during the second sub - step , the work applied and the heat absorbed are @xmath80 , \\ q_{\mathrm{rev } } & = & t_{1}\left[s(\rho_{s0})-\sum_{j=0}^{n}p_{j}^{(1)}s(\rho_{s , ins}(l_{j}))\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , and the state of the total system after the removing process is @xmath81 one can see that the state of the demon does not return to its initial state , which does not make the above four steps a thermodynamic cycle . thus , an addition step , erasure , is needed . ( color online ) erasing the memory of a three - energy - level demon reversibly . suppose that the populations of the three levels after the removing process the partition are @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 as in ( a ) and the initial state s populations of the three levels are @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 as in ( d ) . in step 1 ( a - b ) , the demon is isolated from the heat bath and the energy level spacings are adjusted from @xmath15 to @xmath88 for @xmath89 . during this process , the populations of the levels remain constant . the new level spacings are chosen so that the demon has an effective temperature @xmath90 after the adjusting , which implies @xmath91 and @xmath92 . in ( b ) , the minus sign in front of @xmath93 is due to the negative value of @xmath93 . in step 2 ( b - c ) , the demon is in contact with a real heat bath at temperature @xmath94 and the energies of the levels are adjusted . in this step , the populations of the levels change while its energy spacings change . the goal of this step is to let the populations of the levels return to be @xmath22 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 . thus the new level spacings are @xmath97 and @xmath98 . in step 3 ( c - d ) , the demon is isolated from the heat bath again and its level spacings are adjusted to return to its initial values . the isolation guarantees that the populations of the levels are not changed . thus the state of the demon has returned to its initial state . , width=302 ] in eq . ( [ state_aft_rev ] ) , the state of the demon after the removing process is @xmath99 which is different from the initial state of the demon . as part of the engine , the demon should be re - initialized to complete the cycle . because the entropy of @xmath100 is different from the entropy of @xmath24 , such a re - initialization process , or erasure process , can not be realized by a unitary evolution and must be a logical irreversibility process accompanied by dissipative effects @xcite . a natural way to complete the re - initialization process is to make use of a thermalization process . it can be shown that the heat bath used in the thermalization process is a heat sink instead of a heat resource . because the entropy of @xmath100 is larger than the entropy of @xmath24 , the heat must be transferred from the demon to the heat bath . it seems that after a series of complex tasks , the demon needs to be cooled down . according to thermodynamics , the best re - initialization process is a reversible one which does not cost additional dissipative work . before going into the general discussion , we first consider a three - level demon as an example to find out how to re - initialize or erase the demon reversibly . the three - level demon considered is shown in fig . [ fig_era ] , where the three states are @xmath16 , @xmath6 and @xmath101 respectively . the energy of the state @xmath16 is set to be zero and the energy of the state @xmath4 is @xmath15 for @xmath89 . for a demon in its initial state , the populations of the three levels are @xmath22 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 respectively ( see fig . [ fig_era](d ) ) . to be more concrete , we assume that @xmath85 while @xmath86 and @xmath87 . suppose that the populations become @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 respectively after the removing ( see fig . [ fig_era](a ) ) . in order to re - initialize it by using a reversible scheme by means of a heat bath with @xmath90 , we adjust the demon s energy level spacings adiabatically ( see fig . [ fig_era ] ( a)-(b ) ) . after being adjusted , the level spacings are changed from @xmath15 ( @xmath89 ) to @xmath88 ( see fig . [ fig_era](b ) ) . during this process , the population of each state remains unchanged . thus , the new level spacings satisfy the following relationship to ensure that the effective temperature of the demon is @xmath94 , i.e. , @xmath102 for @xmath89 , which implies @xmath91 and @xmath92 . next , the demon is kept in contact with the heat bath at temperature @xmath94 without any undesired irreversible heat transfer , and we adjust the energies of its levels isothermally ( see fig . [ fig_era ] ( b)-(c ) ) . in this process , the population of each level changes as the level spacings change and the final populations are adjusted to be @xmath22 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 respectively , which are the initial populations of the demon . therefore the new level spacings @xmath103 ( @xmath89 ) satisfy the relationship @xmath104 which implies @xmath97 and @xmath98 ( see fig . [ fig_era](c ) ) . after that , the population of each state has returned to its initial value while the level spacings do not . thus we need another adiabatical adjusting process as in the first step to re - initialize the level spacings ( see fig . [ fig_era ] ( c)-(d ) ) . these three sub - steps complete the re - initialization process and are all reversible , which makes the total re - initialization process reversible . the above example inspires us to construct the reversible re - initialization scheme in a more general case . in the following discussion , a detailed scheme of the re - initialization process is presented . in the first sub - step , we adjust the energy level of the state @xmath43 for @xmath105 adiabatically while the energy of @xmath16 is kept fixed . the corresponding new state is denoted as @xmath106 . during this sub - step , the demon is isolated from the heat sink . the target is to let the demon s effective temperature be @xmath94 , which is the temperature of the heat sink . thus , the new level spacing @xmath107 satisfies @xmath108 and the demon after the first sub - step is in the state @xmath109 it should be noticed that eq . ( [ new_energy ] ) always has a solution except for some extreme conditions , for example , @xmath110 or @xmath111 . if these extreme conditions happen , we will use some tricks to deal with it . in the case of @xmath111 , we will introduce a small positive quantity @xmath112 and let @xmath113 be @xmath114 . next we will use @xmath113 instead of @xmath94 to calculate the parameters of the scheme such as @xmath88 and @xmath103 . such a scheme is not reversible . however , if @xmath112 tends to zero , the scheme will tend to behave as a reversible scheme . in the following , we assume that eq . ( [ new_energy ] ) does have solution . in this sub - step , there is no heat transfer and the work applied is @xmath115 in the second sub - step , demon is in contact with the heat sink and the @xmath52-th level s energy is adjusted from @xmath107 to @xmath116 isothermally , where @xmath116 satisfies @xmath117 and @xmath118 is the inverse temperature of the heat sink . thus , the state of the demon after this sub - step is @xmath119 where @xmath120 represents the state corresponding to @xmath106 after the adjusting . the work applied and the heat transferred during this process are @xmath121,\\ q_{\mathrm{ini}}=t_{2}\left[h\left(\{p_{i}\}\right)-h\left(\left\ { \sum_{i=0}^{n}p_{i}(l)p_{f_{i}^{-1}(j)}\right\ } \right)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . here @xmath122 represents the shannon entropy of the probability distribution @xmath123 . in the last sub - step , the demon is isolated from the heat sink again and the energies of all of its levels are adjusted to its initial values . thus the final state of the demon is @xmath124 , which is indeed its initial state . during this sub - step , no heat transfers and the work applied is @xmath125 these three sub - steps together make up the re - initialization scheme . such a scheme involves adjusting the energies of the demon s levels , which is not easily realized . in a concrete experiment , if the quantum system that functions as the maxwell s demon has unchangeable energy levels , we will only use an irreversible scheme as in refs . as we know in thermodynamics , such an irreversible re - initialization scheme reduces the efficiency of the heat engine because of the dissipative effects . thus , when it comes to the maxwell s demon paradox , one needs a reversible re - initialization scheme without dissipative effects to get a good physical picture . combining the results obtained in the above section , one finally gets the total heat transferred and the work extracted in the thermodynamic cycle : \1 . the heat absorbed from the heat resource is @xmath126.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] \2 . the heat released to the heat sink is @xmath127.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] \3 . the work extracted is @xmath128 which can be checked to satisfy the first law of thermodynamics , i.e. , @xmath129 . firstly , it is emphasized that the result is general without referring to the statistical properties of the working substance , since @xmath130 has contained all the information of the distribution . thus eq . ( [ q1 ] ) , eq . ( [ q2 ] ) and eq . ( [ w ] ) are correct both for the bose system and the fermi system . secondly , one can optimize the expansion position @xmath131 to maximize the efficiency of she . consider a two - particle she as an example , in which the demon is of three - level . the function @xmath51 we choose is @xmath132 . thus the heat absorbed from the heat resource is @xmath133 thereafter , the optimized expansion position @xmath11 should satisfy @xmath134 working out the above equation , one will get the optimized expansion positions @xmath135 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 . thirdly , an upper limit of the heat absorbed from the heat resource @xmath138 in eq . ( [ q1 ] ) is estimated . use the method presented in the appendix [ appendix2 ] , one gets @xmath139\nonumber \\ & = & t_{1}\left[h\left(\{\sum_{i=0}^{n}p_{i}(l)p_{f_{i}^{-1}(j)}\}\right)-h\left(\{p_{i}\}\right)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore the efficiency of the she has the upper limit : @xmath140 thus , it is clear that the efficiency of the she can not exceed the carnot cycle s efficiency when the erasure process or re - initialization process is considered , which saves the slot . it can be seen more clearly when @xmath55 , which represents a single - particle she . for a single - particle she , there is only one realization of @xmath51 , and the corresponding measurement process is indeed a controlled - not operation as in ref . @xcite , i.e. , @xmath141 for @xmath142 while @xmath143 and @xmath144 . the formulas eq . ( [ q1 ] ) and eq . ( [ q2 ] ) are reduced to @xmath145,\eqno(\ref{q1}')\ ] ] and @xmath146\eqno(\ref{q2}')\ ] ] respectively . it is easy to maximize @xmath138 to find that @xmath135 and @xmath136 satisfy @xmath147 and the maximum of @xmath138 is @xmath148.\label{q1max}\ ] ] thus , it is found that @xmath149 is always positive whatever the insertion position is . combining eq . ( [ q1max ] ) and eq . ( [ q2 ] ) , one gets the best efficiency as @xmath150 then it is concluded that for a single - particle she , one can always choose a good expansion position to let the she reach the carnot cycle s efficiency even if the demon contains some errors . recall that in the step 4 of the thermodynamic cycle , the removing process , one needs to thermalization the working substance firstly . however , for a single - particle she , it is found that the expansion position can always be chosen that the thermalization process is not needed . thus , a single - particle she can always be a reversible heat engine with two heat baths , and its efficiency reaches the carnot cycle s efficiency . on the other hand , for a multi - particle she , the thermalization process is always needed in the removing process , which makes the heat engine irreversible . thus , a multi - particle she s efficiency can not always reach carnot cycle s efficiency . ( color online ) work extracted @xmath151 as the function of insertion position @xmath152 and the working temperature @xmath23 . ( 1 ) bose case with @xmath153 . ( 2 ) fermi case with @xmath153.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] ( color online ) work extracted @xmath151 as the function of insertion position @xmath152 and the working temperature @xmath23 . ( 1 ) bose case with @xmath153 . ( 2 ) fermi case with @xmath153.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] + \(1 ) bose case \(2 ) fermi case + at the end of this section , a concrete example is presented to show the difference between the bose system and the fermi system . in this example , a four - particle system is considered as the working substance . the demon we chosen is a five - level quantum system with some errors . its initial state is @xmath154 the temperature of the heat sink is fixed that @xmath90 . denote the higher temperature and the insertion position as @xmath23 and @xmath1 respectively . then the work extracted by the heat engine during a thermodynamic cycle can be numerically calculated for both the bose case and the fermi case . the results are shown in fig . [ bvf ] . as one can see , the patterns in fig . [ bvf ] for different distributions are quite different . in fact , in the next section , it is found that the difference between the bose case and the fermi case is most significant in low - temperature regime . in this section , the behavior of a multi - particle she when the working temperature @xmath23 is very low is studied . in sec . [ sec4 ] , a necessary condition for the heat engine to extract positive work is found that @xmath155 . thus , if @xmath23 considered is very small , the temperature of the heat sink will be @xmath111 . the demon in this case is free of errors because it is natural to get a pure initial state if the demon is re - initialized by a zero - temperature heat sink . the motivation to concern the demon without error is to see the difference between the bose system and fermi system more clearly without the effect of the demon s errors . as mentioned in the step 5 of sec . [ sec3 ] , it is less likely for one to re - initialize such a demon by using a reversible scheme ; however , one can use an asymptotic scheme to re - initialize the demon . ( color online ) asymptotic erasure scheme for @xmath111 . , width=302 ] now , we describe the asymptotic scheme in details firstly . similar to the re - initialization scheme in sec . [ sec3 ] , the asymptotic scheme also contains three sub - steps . the three sub - steps are illustrated in fig . [ fig_era1 ] . in the first sub - step , the energies of the levels @xmath4 for @xmath156 are adjusted from @xmath15 to a very small value @xmath157 adiabatically . during this sub - step , there is no heat transferred . in the second sub - step , the demon is in contact with the heat sink at temperature @xmath111 until it is in equilibrium with the heat sink . during this sub - step , there is no work applied and the finial state of the demon is a pure state for its temperature is zero when @xmath158 . in the third sub - step , the energies of the demon s levels are re - adjusted adiabatically to its initial value . thus , these three sub - steps complete the re - initialization process of the demon . if we use this scheme , @xmath138 in eq . ( [ q1 ] ) will not change and @xmath159 in eq . ( [ q2 ] ) will be revised to be the heat transferred in the second sub - step . due to the irreversibility of the second sub - step , this scheme is not reversible . nevertheless , if one lets @xmath160 tend to @xmath53 , @xmath159 will tend to @xmath53 , which makes the scheme reversible . thus , eq . ( [ q1 ] ) and eq . ( [ q2 ] ) will still hold if one uses this asymptotic scheme . in the following , this asymptotic scheme is used in which the relationships , @xmath161 and @xmath162 , hold . since the initial state of the demon is a pure state , which corresponds to the conditions @xmath111 and @xmath163 , the work extracted can be given by the relationship @xmath162 and ( [ q1 ] ) as @xmath164\nonumber \\ & = & t_{1}\sum_{i=0}^{n}p_{i}(l)\ln\left(\frac{p_{i}(l_{i})}{p_{i}(l)}\right).\label{w'}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is just the same as that in ref . @xcite and it can be calculated by a different way as in ref . then we will use eq . ( [ w ] ) to study the bose system and the fermi system separately . first of all , we study the behavior of @xmath165 when @xmath166 . according to eq . ( [ w ] ) , one gets @xmath167 here , the expansion position @xmath11 have been optimized as in sec . thus @xmath168 is always no less than @xmath130 . for a deterministic distribution , @xmath169 , @xmath165 in eq . ( [ a3_w / t ] ) becomes to be @xmath170 . due to the optimization of @xmath131 , we have @xmath171 , or , @xmath172 . thus , it is concluded that @xmath165 is always @xmath53 when @xmath173 is a deterministic distribution . in other words , the necessary condition for a non - zero @xmath165 is that the informational entropy @xmath174 of the distribution @xmath173 is non - zero . using the joint entropy theorem @xcite , one gets @xmath175 where @xmath176 is the entropy of the working substance after the insertion and @xmath177 represents the working substance s entropy in the condition that the number of the particles in the right compartment is @xmath3 . due to the non - negative property of entropy , one finds @xmath178 . therefore if the entropy of the working substance is zero , one will find that @xmath179 and @xmath180 . for a system with its ground state non - degenerate , its entropy always tends to zero when temperature tends to zero , which is referred to as the third law of thermodynamics . thus , it is found that , if the insertion position @xmath1 makes the ground state of the working substance non - degenerate , one will always have @xmath181 however , if the insertion position @xmath1 makes the ground state of the working substance degenerate , there will be a chance that @xmath165 tends to non - zero . such a position @xmath1 is called a degenerate point . thus , the relationship between the low - temperature behavior of @xmath165 and the degenerate point has been established . the similar result is found in ref . @xcite . then , we look for the degenerate points for both the ideal bose system and the ideal fermi system . for the ideal bose system , all particles condense in the ground state of the system when temperature is zero . thus the only chance for the ground state to be degenerate is that the energy of the left compartment s single - particle ground state is the same as that of the right compartment , which happens when the widths of the two compartments are equal to each other . thereafter it is found that there is only one degenerate point for the ideal bose system , i.e. , @xmath182 . ( color online ) degenerate ground states for a fermi gas . when the fermi surface contains more than one single - particle states , there is a chance that the ground state of the fermi gas is degenerate . for example , the states in ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) are two ground states of the system . , width=302 ] for a fermi system , the particles satisfy the pauli s exclusion principle . when temperature is zero , all the energy levels under the fermi surface are occupied . thus if the @xmath3-th single - particle energy level of the left compartment and the @xmath52-th single - particle energy level of the left compartment are both on the fermi surface , the ground state of the total gas may be degenerate , see fig . [ fermi_degen ] . the index @xmath3 and @xmath52 should satisfy the relationship that @xmath183 equals to the number of the particles @xmath8 . thus there are @xmath8 situations corresponding to @xmath184 . thereafter it is found that there are @xmath8 degenerate points for an ideal fermi system with @xmath8 particles . as the two compartments are modeled as two one - dimensional infinite square wells with widths @xmath1 and @xmath2 respectively , one can workout the spectrum of them as in eq . ( [ spectrum ] ) . thus the conditions of the degenerate points can be written as @xmath185 therefore the positions of the fermi system s degenerate points are @xmath186 so far we have revealed the qualitative difference of the work extracted by the engine between the bose type and the fermi type working substance at low temperature . that difference in the quantum statistical behavior between the bose and the fermi working substance will disappear as the temperature @xmath23 increase . the numerical simulation in fig . [ fig2 ] quantitively illustrates the statistical behavior at finite temperature . when @xmath23 tends to zero , the numerical calculations confirm the above results . similar result is also found in ref . in summary , the multi - particle she has been studied in a complete quantum framework , where the re - initialization process of the demon is discussed in detail . the errors are introduced in the demon so that one can use a finite - temperature heat sink to cool down the demon while the traditional demon must be cooled down by a zero - temperature heat sink . for a single - particle she , there is a scheme that the whole cycle of the she can be revisible . we illustrated that the efficiency of such a scheme is indeed the efficiency of carnot cycle s and other schemes have lower efficiency . and it is proved that she can not exceed the limit of the slot . on the other hand , the properties of the she with bose or fermi particles are studied . in the high - temperature regime , these two distributions make no difference . both of them reduce to the result of maxwell distribution . in contrast , the bose system and the fermi system differ from each other in the low - temperature regime . the origin of the difference is the difference of the degenerate points of these two distributions . the she whose insertion position is a degenerate point extracts more work in a cycle . if the temperature is absolute zero , the ratio of the work extracted to the working temperature will show some uncontinuous properties . this work was supported by nsfc through grants 10974209 and 10935010 and by the national 973 program ( grant no . 2006cb921205 ) . in this appendix , the explicit expressions of the multi - particle partition functions for the ideal bose gas and the ideal fermi gas are presented . let @xmath187 be the canonical partition function for @xmath13 particles , where @xmath188 represents the inverse temperature of the system and @xmath1 represents some parameters of the system , e.g. , in our paper @xmath1 means the width of the infinite square well . to present the explicit expression of @xmath187 , the explicit expression of the single - particle partition function @xmath189 is given firstly . then the relationship between the multi - particle partition function and the single - particle partition function is shown . the single - particle partition function does not depend on which distribution the particle satisfies . once one knows the single - particle spectrum of the system , one can write down its canonical partition function . for example , the single - particle spectrum in a one - dimensional infinite square well with width @xmath1 is @xmath190 where @xmath191 is the mass of the particle and @xmath3 is the index of the energy levels . then the single - particle partition function of this system is @xmath192 when it comes to multi - particle partition function , we first take the two - particle system as an example . in this condition , one gets @xmath193,\ ] ] where the indices @xmath188 and @xmath1 have been omitted for simplicity . here , the summation , @xmath194 , can be viewed as a single - particle partition function with spectrum @xmath195 . thus , it is found that @xmath196 can be decomposed into some single - particle partition functions . in general , all the partition functions of the ideal gas , @xmath197 , can be decomposed into some single - particle partition functions by this ways . the next task is to workout the coefficients in the decomposition . in the following discussion , the system considered has discrete spectrum and the index of the energy levels is denoted by @xmath198 . let @xmath199 be the number of the particles in the @xmath3-th level . to be convenient , we denote @xmath200 as @xmath201 for @xmath202 and the multi - particle partition function becomes to be @xmath203 here , the summation condition is that @xmath204 and @xmath205 for bose case or @xmath206 for fermi case . it is not difficult to show that @xmath207 in fact , if @xmath208 , one will find that @xmath209 and @xmath210 are nothing but the grand canonical partition functions for ideal bose case and ideal fermi case respectively . in mathematics , @xmath209 and @xmath210 are the generating functions for @xmath211 and @xmath212 respectively and they have the following simple relationship @xmath213 next , the single - particle partition function with spectrum @xmath214 , @xmath215 , is denoted as @xmath216 for @xmath217 . its generating function is @xmath218 thus , it is found that @xmath219 i.e. , @xmath220 by indefinite integration , one finds that @xmath221 where @xmath222 is the constant of integration and it is not difficult to find that @xmath223 . so , there is the following important relationship @xmath224 compare the coefficient of @xmath225 in both the two sides of eq.([h(t ) ] ) and one can find that @xmath226 where @xmath227 and the summation condition is @xmath228 which corresponds a summation for all the young diagrams with @xmath13 boxes . the @xmath229 is defined as @xmath230 and the @xmath231 is the product of some single - particle partition functions as @xmath232 thus we have decomposed the multi - particle partition function into some single - particle partition functions for bose case . for fermi case , using the relationship in eq.([h_e ] ) , one finds that @xmath233 also , compare the coefficient of @xmath225 in both the two sides of eq.([e(t ) ] ) and it is found that @xmath234 where the summation condition is the same as in the bose case . in this appendix , the upper limit of @xmath138 in eq . ( [ q1 ] ) is estimated . to this end , a two - particle she is used as an example firstly , in which the demon considered is of three - level . the function @xmath51 is chosen as @xmath132 . thus the heat absorbed from the heat resource is the one shown in eq . ( [ example_eff ] ) . to estimate the upper limit of @xmath138 , eq . ( [ example_eff ] ) should be re - written as where @xmath236 satisfy the constraints @xmath237 for all @xmath3 and @xmath52 . thus the original optimization problem becomes to be an optimization problem with constraints . this optimization problem with constraints has a maximum solution @xmath149 since @xmath138 in eq . ( [ b1 ] ) has an upper bound @xmath238 and the domain of @xmath239 is closed . substitute these constraints by the weaker constraints @xmath240 for all @xmath52 , then we get another optimization problem with constraints . after solving this problem we will get another maximum @xmath241 . because the constraints in the latter problem are weaker than the constraints in the former one , we have @xmath242 . thus @xmath241 is a upper limit of @xmath138 . the calculation of @xmath241 can be performed in terms of lagrange multipliers . namely , one only needs to solve an optimization problem without constraint in which the target function is @xmath243 where @xmath244 , @xmath245 and @xmath246 are three lagrange multipliers . solving this constraint - free optimization problem , one finds that the maximum solution @xmath241 is reached when @xmath236 satisfies the following relationships @xmath247 for a general situation , this trick can also be used to find an upper limit of the heat absorbed from the heat resource @xmath138 . to this end , one only needs to maximize @xmath138 under the constraints @xmath248 for all @xmath52 . thus the upper limit of @xmath138 is given as

we present a complete - quantum description of multi - particle szilard engine which consists of a working substance and a maxwell s demon . the demon is modeled as a multi - level quantum system with specific quantum control and the working substance consists of identical particles obeying bose - einstein or fermi - dirac statistics . in this description , a reversible scheme to erase the demon s memory by a lower temperature heat bath is used . we demonstrate that ( 1 ) the quantum control of the demon can be optimized for single - particle szilard engine so that the efficiency of the demon - assisted thermodynamic cycle could reach the carnot cycle s efficiency ; ( 2 ) the low - temperature behavior of the working substance is very sensitive to the quantum statistics of the particles and the insertion position of the partition .

astro-ph0108426

in astronomical data analysis , one develops models of physical processes in the spectral , spatial , and/or temporal domains , then fits these models to observed data . these data may be of arbitrary dimension , and/or they may have been collected using an arbitrary number of telescopes that observe in different wavelength bands . _ sherpa _ , the modeling and fitting application of the _ chandra interactive analysis of observations ( ciao ) _ software package,@xcite is designed to tackle such complex multi - dimensional , multi - wavelength analyses . free of hard - wired instrument details , _ sherpa _ is outfitted with a wide variety of models , fit statistics , and methods of optimization , model comparison , and parameter estimation , and it offers powerful embedded visualization , scripting , and data manipulation capabilities . it can thus be used to analyze energy- or wavelength - space data from , _ e.g. _ , ground - based telescopes , _ iso _ , _ hubble _ , _ xmm _ , and the _ chandra x - ray observatory _ , as well as from next - generation projects such as the virtual observatory . in this paper we present a basic overview of _ sherpa_. in [ sect : code ] , we describe the application itself , while in [ sect : func ] we describe _ sherpa _ s capabilities using a typical _ sherpa _ session as a framework , from reading in data to determining the 1@xmath0 errors on the best - fit model parameters . in [ sect : examples ] we provide brief examples of how one may use _ sherpa_. for more information , the reader may consult the on - line _ sherpa _ the authors have developed _ sherpa _ using the object - oriented c++ programming language.@xcite in object - oriented programming , objects encapsulate related data and functions ; thus , classes ( from which objects are instantiated ) can be written that more closely model the problem domain . for a modeling and fitting application , classes containing fitting methods , statistics , models , and data organize the code in a way that more intuitively mirrors the concepts underlying the fitting process . _ sherpa _ is an interactive application , using a lex / yacc - based parser to interpret commands . _ sherpa _ accepts input via the command - line interface or ascii script files . the _ ciao _ package also contains a number of other programs and libraries that enhance _ sherpa _ s capabilities . data i / o is provided by the _ ciao _ data model library.@xcite the data model gives a higher - level , abstract view of astronomical data files and provides transparent access to the most common astronomical file formats ( fits , _ iraf _ imh , _ iraf _ qpoe ) . the data model provides a uniform interface so that the application need no longer use i / o functions specific to particular file formats . the data model also has a sophisticated filtering and binning syntax that allows the extraction of selected portions of data contained in a file . for all visualization needs , _ sherpa _ uses _ chips _ , the _ chandra imaging and plotting system_.@xcite as the name indicates , _ chips _ provides an interface to plotting and imaging applications ( currently _ sm_,@xcite _ saods9_,@xcite and _ saotng_@xcite ) . _ chips _ is both a stand - alone , interactive application and a c++ library ( which is how it is used by _ sherpa_it passes commands and data to _ chips _ ) . _ sherpa _ can access _ chips _ functions through the _ chips _ api , but it is also possible for _ chips _ commands to be input directly at the _ sherpa _ command - line . as of _ ciao 2.1 _ , the s lang interpreted scripting language@xcite has been embedded in _ ciao_. its features include : * global and local interpreted variables , and multidimensional arrays ( up to seven dimensions ) ; * branching and looping , and programmability with user - defined functions ; * string and numeric data types , structures , and a limited form of pointers ; * built - in arithmetic and mathematical functions , which operate transparently on arrays ; and * extensibility the ability to create new functionality for _ ciao _ applications ( _ e.g. _ guide ; see [ sect : chgrating ] ) . s lang is accessed through a supplementary library layer , dubbed variables , math , and macros ( varmm),@xcite which gives the user additional capability to define structured variables directly from disk files , as well as enabling existing _ ciao _ applications to access s lang variables and other features with a bare minimum of new development effort . the capabilities of _ sherpa _ can be best described by following the steps of a typical analysis session . in such a session , the user would : * read in ( source and/or background ) data ( and set filters , _ etc . _ ) ; * build models that describe these data ( as well as the telescope / detector combination ) ; * choose a statistic that quantifies how well these models describe the data ; * fit the models to the data , determining the minimum value of the chosen statistic ; * compare best - fit results achieved with different models to select one best - fit model ; and * estimate the errors for each parameter of the best - fit model . below , we discuss each of these items in turn . we note that a typical session would also include _ chips _ visualization ( of the source data , or of the background fit , _ etc . _ ) ; while we do not discuss it specifically in this section , we provide examples of visualization in [ sect : examples ] . data input marks the beginning of a _ sherpa _ analysis session . the data may be input from either a file on disk or an interpreted s lang variable . in table [ tab : io ] , we list data types that may be input into _ sherpa _ , while in table [ tab : iotypes ] we list currently supported file formats . ( instrument characteristics , such as the point - spread function , or psf , may also be contained in files that are read in when an instrument model is specified ; see [ sect : inst ] . ) [ ht ] ' '' '' data & source data + ' '' '' back & background data + ' '' '' ( b)errors & source or background errors + ' '' '' ( b)errors system & source or background systematic errors + ' '' '' filter & specification of which bins of a given dataset are to be analyzed + ' '' '' weight & statistical weights for each datum + ' '' '' groups & specification of how data are to be binned + [ ht ] ' '' '' ascii & ascii data + ' '' '' fitsbin & fits binary table + ' '' '' fits & fits image + ' '' '' imh & _ iraf _ imh image + ' '' '' pha & type i & ii pha data + ' '' '' qp & _ iraf _ qpoe image + one only needs to read in source data to start an analysis session ; other data types ( such as background ) are not required . however , some types of data may be input automatically when source data are read ; for instance , a pha file can have columns that specify the statistical and systematic errors ( stat_err and sys_err , respectively ) and the data grouping ( grouping ) , and it can have a keyword ( backfile ) specifying the background dataset . also , one can specify statistical and systematic errors , filters , and statistical weights via the command - line interface . if statistical errors are not input or specified , they are estimated by _ sherpa _ during fitting ; see [ sect : stat ] . an arbitrary number of datasets may be input into _ sherpa _ , and arbitrary subsets of these data may be jointly analyzed . since current standard processing of _ chandra _ grating data includes the extraction of background spectra from regions on either side of the source extraction region , one may also specify up to two background datasets per source dataset . these data may be fit simultaneously with the source data ( see [ sect : srcback ] ) , or they may be subtracted from the source data on a channel - by - channel basis prior to a fit : @xmath1 \,.\ ] ] @xmath2 is the source datum in bin @xmath3 , @xmath4 is the background datum in bin @xmath3 of background set @xmath5 , @xmath6 is the observation time , and @xmath7 is the backscale " ( the backscal header keyword value in a pha file ) , typically defined as the ratio of data extraction area to total detector area . at any time during an analysis session , quantities like the background - subtracted data , convolved model amplitudes , or fit residuals may be output to files using the write command . ( the files may be saved in any of the formats listed in table [ tab : iotypes ] . ) a user may also save ( and later restore ) the state of a _ sherpa _ analysis session using a model descriptor list ( mdl ) . the mdl is a record of all information relevant to a sherpa fitting session : the names of all input data files and associated filters ; all defined source and instrument models , with model parameter settings ; the choices of optimization method and fit statistic ; and the fluxes and identification of emission / absorption lines that the user may have identified ( see [ sect : chgrating ] ) . the mdl may be either saved to disk or instantiated as an s lang variable . once source and/or background data are input , the next step is to create model expressions reflecting one s knowledge of the physical processes which gave rise to those data . ( the user can also build model expressions that represent the observing instruments . [ sect : inst ] . ) _ sherpa _ currently provides nearly 40 of its own one- and two - dimensional models and 90 one - dimensional _ xspec_@xcite models that may be arbitrarily combined to build complex composite models , as we show below . note that a user can also define a model and compile it into the libascfituser.so shared - object library , where it can be accessed by _ sherpa_. [ [ sherpa - model - language . ] ] sherpa model language . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the _ sherpa _ model language resolves ambiguity by allowing the user to give a unique name or alias to each instance of a model . for example , if two datasets are entered , and each is to be fit with a gaussian model , but with different parameters , one might type : .... sherpa > gauss1d[g1 ] sherpa > gauss1d[g2 ] sherpa > source 1 = g1 sherpa > source 2 = g2 .... whereas if each is to be fit with the same gaussian model , one might type : .... sherpa > gauss1d[g1 ] sherpa > source 1:2 = g1 .... [ [ linking - parameters - to - other - parameters - or - to - models . ] ] linking parameters to other parameters or to models . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + one can link an individual model parameter to another model parameter , so that their values are correlated . for instance , if a particular atomic line is observed by two different detectors , it could be modeled with two gaussian functions whose centroids are linked : .... sherpa > source 1 = gauss1d[g1 ] sherpa > source 2 = gauss1d[g2 ] sherpa > g1.pos = > g2.pos .... ( note that simple arithmetic relations are also possible , _ e.g. _ g1.ampl = > 2*g2.ampl . ) at this point , g1.pos is no longer a free parameter of the fit . it can be made free again with the command unlink g1.pos . one can also link an individual model parameter to a model , to describe how a parameter s value will vary as a function of position in parameter space . for instance , one can model emission from an accretion disk using a blackbody function whose temperature is a function of radius : .... sherpa > source = bb sherpa > temperature = poly sherpa > bb.kt = > temperature .... [ [ nesting - model - expressions . ] ] nesting model expressions . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + a model may be nested within another , _ i.e. _ one may specify a model expression of the form g(f(x ) ) . in this example , the input data axis is transformed to log - space using _ sherpa _ s log model , and a blackbody model is evaluated in that space : .... sherpa > logenergy = shlog sherpa > source = bb{logenergy } .... [ [ multi - dimensional - model - expressions . ] ] multi - dimensional model expressions . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + one can specify completely different models that are to be evaluated along different axes of a multi - dimensional dataset , as in this example , where two - dimensional spectral - radius data are modeled with a combination of lorentzian and power - law models : .... sherpa > lorentz[spatial ] sherpa > pow[spec ] sherpa > source = spatial{x1}*spec{x2 } .... x1 and x2 represent the first and second axes of the input image , respectively . instrument models are used to quantify characteristics , such as effective area , a detector s energy response , or a mirror s point - spread function . they provide a mapping from photon space ( where source and background models are evaluated ) to counts space ( where fit statistics are computed ) . the instrument model class is the key element which makes _ sherpa _ a mission - independent application , permitting analysis of data observed by any telescope , regardless of whether it is ground - based or space - based . currently , _ sherpa _ defines three instrument model classes : ( 1 ) rsp , in which an evaluated one - dimensional model is multiplied by an ancillary response ( arf , _ i.e. _ an effective area ) on a bin - by - bin basis , then folded through a response matrix ( rmf ) ; ( 2 ) psffromfile , in which the evaluated one- or two - dimensional model is convolved with a numeric kernel ; and ( 3 ) psffromtcd , in which the evaluated one- or two - dimensional model is convolved with an analytic kernel ( _ e.g. _ gaussian ) defined within _ ciao _ s transformation , convolution , and deconvolution ( tcd ) library . future versions of _ sherpa _ may include new classes to treat , _ e.g. _ , two - dimensional exposure maps . the @xmath8 statistic is appropriate for the analysis of gaussian - distributed data . it is defined as @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the ( source or background ) data in bin @xmath3 , @xmath11 is the ( convolved source or background ) model predicted amplitude in bin @xmath3 , and @xmath12 is the estimated error for the @xmath13 datum ( the square root of the variance of the distribution from which that datum had been sampled ) . as noted in [ sect : io ] , one may specify the errors via a file or the command - line ; if this is done , the @xmath8 statistic is used as shown above . otherwise , the data are assumed to be poisson - distributed , with the errors for each datum estimated during analysis . the large array of error estimators that _ sherpa _ provides is one of its key features ; these are listed in table [ tab : stat ] . note that the entries in this table are only correct if the background data have not been subtracted from the source data ; otherwise errors are propagated in the standard manner ( @xmath14 ) . also note that error estimates based on model amplitudes are inappropriate to use in the analysis of background - subtracted data , as they generally underestimate the true error . using a @xmath8-based statistic to analyze counts data is generally only valid in the gaussian ( high - counts ) limit ( @xmath15 5 counts in _ each _ bin ) . this is because the approximations that must be made to derive the @xmath8 statistic from poisson log - likelihood @xmath16 break down otherwise . the chi gehrels@xcite and chi primini@xcite statistics are designed to work with low - count data ; note that the former it is not generally sampled from the @xmath8 distribution and thus the derived best - fit statistic may appear to be too good " ( @xmath17 1 , where @xmath18 is the number of degrees of freedom in the fit ) , in the low - counts limit . the poisson likelihood function is @xmath19 _ sherpa _ features two statistics based on this function : cash and bayes . the version of the cash statistic@xcite used by _ sherpa _ is derived from @xmath20 by ( 1 ) taking its logarithm , ( 2 ) dropping the factorial term ( which remains constant during fits to given datasets ) , ( 3 ) multiplying by two , and ( 4 ) changing the sign ( so that the statistic may be minimized , like @xmath8 ) : @xmath21 \,,\ ] ] in the high - counts limit , @xmath22 , so that in principle one can use @xmath23 instead of @xmath24 in model comparison tests ( see [ sect : modcomp ] ) . [ ht ] ' '' '' statistic & variance @xmath25 + ' '' '' chi dvar & @xmath10 + ' '' '' chi gehrels ( _ sherpa _ default ) & @xmath26 ^ 2 $ ] + ' '' '' chi mvar & @xmath11 + ' '' '' chi parent & @xmath27 + ' '' '' chi primini & @xmath11 from previous best - fit + the bayes statistic@xcite is based on bayesian statistical methodology and is appropriate to use when a background is input and the rate of background accumulation may be taken as the same in both the background and source extraction regions . this statistic takes into account uncertainty in the ( implicitly defined ) background amplitudes via marginalization : @xmath28 where @xmath29 represents the set of source model parameters and @xmath30 is the background amplitude in the @xmath13 bin . ( note that the above equation has an analytic solution that we do not reproduce here . ) note that because the cash and bayes statistics are based on the likelihood function , they should not be applied to background - subtracted data . also , there is no goodness - of - fit " measure associated with cash and bayes , as there is of @xmath8-based statistics . such a measure can , in principle , be computed by performing monte carlo simulations : one would repeatedly sample new datasets from the best - fit model , fit them , and note where the observed statistic lies within the derived distribution of statistics . optimization is the act of minimizing @xmath8 or @xmath31 by varying the thawed parameters of the defined model . _ sherpa _ provides a number of optimization methods , which can be classified in two broad categories : those which find a local minimum of the statistical surface in parameter space by moving along the local gradient of that surface , and those which examine large ( hyper-)volumes of parameter space in a search for the global minimum ( see table [ tab : opt ] ) . below , we discuss the three optimization methods appropriate for finding local minima : powell , simplex , and levenberg - marquardt . users should be acquainted with the ( dis)advantages of each so as to make the best use of them . ( for more information about _ sherpa s _ other optimization methods , consult the _ sherpa _ manual@xcite and , _ e.g. _ , press _ et al . _ 1992@xcite . ) powell , a direction - set method in which the chosen statistic is minimized by varying each member of an ( initially orthogonal ) set of parameter - space vectors in turn , is _ sherpa s _ default optimizer . its advantages include the fact that no gradient calculations are required , and that it is a robust method , capable of finding minima even on complex statistical surfaces . ( also , unlike levenberg - marquardt , is can be used effectively with likelihood - based statistics . ) its primary disadvantage is that it is relatively slow . [ ht ] ' '' '' local minimum & powell , simplex , levenberg - marquardt + ' '' '' global minimum & grid(-powell ) , monte(-powell ) , simulated annealing + in simplex optimization , the fit statistic is calculated at the @xmath32 vertices of a simplex in a @xmath18-dimensional parameter space , with the vertices being moved until the local minimum is bracketed . its advantages include the fact that no gradient calculations are required , it can find minima of complex statistical surfaces , and it requires fewer model evaluations than powell . however , it is not as robust as powell . the simplex method is best - used when one starts the optimization close to the local minimum ; for instance , it is a good optimizer to use in parameter estimation ( see [ sect : parest ] ) . in levenberg - marquardt optimization , the local minimum is approached by taking steps in parameter space whose magnitudes @xmath33 are computed by solving the set of linear equations @xmath34 where @xmath35~~{\rm and}~~\beta_i~=~-\frac{1}{2}\frac{{\partial}\chi^2}{{\partial}x_i } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath36 is a matrix with non - zero diagonal elements whose magnitudes are inversely proportional to @xmath33 . the primary advantage of levenberg - marquardt optimization is speed , while its disadvantages include the fact that a gradient computation is required , that it is appropriate for use with @xmath8-based statistics only , and that it is less robust when applied to optimization on a complex statistical surface . ( to circumvent the third issue , we have introduced the option that the optimization method may be switched from levenberg - marquardt to simplex close to the minimum , where the disadvantages of levenberg - marquardt become more readily apparent . ) often , a user will fit more than one parametrized model to a given dataset , and will wish to compare the best - fit results of each . for instance , one may fit two continuum models to data , and need to decide whether the improvement in the fit statistic that is observed when using the more complex model is attributable to chance . to make this decision , one uses a model comparison test to yield either : ( 1 ) the frequentist test significance , @xmath37 , which is the probability of selecting the alternative ( more complex ) model @xmath38 when in fact the null hypothesis @xmath39 is correct ; or ( 2 ) the bayesian odds , the ratio of model posterior probabilities for @xmath38 and @xmath39 . if the prior probability distribution for a model s parameter values is constant , then its posterior probability is proportional to the integral of the likelihood function @xmath20 over parameter space . the model comparison test that is currently available to the _ sherpa _ user is the @xmath8 goodness - of - fit ( gof ) test , an alternative - free test . the next version of _ sherpa _ will also contain the maximum likelihood ratio ( mlr ) test and the @xmath40-test . methods of model comparison that may be included in future versions of _ sherpa _ include : using simulations to determine model comparison test statistics numerically when the conditions for using an analytic test are not fulfilled ; computing the bayesian odds using the laplace approximation@xcite ; and computing the bayesian odds via numerical integration . we note that these new techniques , in addition to assisting the comparison of models , would also be useful for parameter estimation . once one has selected a best - fit model , the next question is : what are the errors on the model parameters , _ i.e. _ what are the confidence intervals associated with each model parameter ? in general , a frequentist statistician can determine possible intervals by repeatedly simulating data from the best - fit model , fitting these data , and determining the distribution of best - fit values for each model parameter . the central 68% of each distribution can then be deemed the 1@xmath0 confidence interval . however , simulations are computationally expensive , and if : ( 1 ) the @xmath8 or @xmath16 surface is approximately shaped like a multi - dimensional paraboloid ( _ i.e. _ contours of constant @xmath8 or @xmath16 appear ellipsoidal in two - dimensional plots ) , and ( 2 ) the best - fit point is sufficiently far from parameter space boundaries , then confidence intervals may be estimated by examining the statistical surface itself . _ sherpa _ currently features three parameter estimation methods appropriate for use when the statistical surface is well - behaved " : uncertainty , projection , and covariance . ( in addition , one can make one- or two - dimensional plots showing the fit statistic value as a function of parameter value[s ] . ) with uncertainty , the error for a particular thawed parameter is estimated by varying its value ( while holding all other parameter values fixed to their best - fit values ) until the fit statistic increases by a preset amount from its minimum value ( _ e.g. _ @xmath24 = 1 for 1@xmath0 ) . projection is similar to uncertainty , except that the values of all other parameters are allowed to float to new best - fit values . with covariance , errors are estimated by calculating the covariance matrix , the inverse of the matrix of statistical surface second derivatives at the best - fit point . each of these methods has distinct ( dis)advantages : for example , uncertainty , while fast , will generally underestimate an interval s size if the parameter is correlated with other parameters ; and projection provides a means to visualize the surface and can be used even if the model parameters are correlated , but is in the strictest statistical sense no more accurate than the much faster covariance method ( which is itself not useful for visualization ) . in this section , we present four examples of _ sherpa _ analyses . we note that space limitations prevent us from showing all but a few commands that are used in these analyses ; for full scripts , plus scripts showing other analyses , please consult the _ sherpa _ analysis threads.@xcite in this example , we analyze flux data ( log@xmath41 $ ] ) of re j1034 + 396,@xcite a low - redshift , narrow - line seyfert 1 galaxy . the data were collected by the william herschel 4.2 m telescope , _ hst _ , and _ bepposax_. because the data are not sampled from a poisson distribution , the errors must be input or specified ; here , we assume that the error on the flux is 1% : we would like to thank mark birkinshaw , william joye , malin ljungberg , and michael noble for past and present contributions to _ sherpa _ s development . we would also like to thank holly jessop for her tireless work maintaining the _ sherpa _ manuals and threads . the _ sherpa _ project is supported by the _ chandra _ x - ray center under nasa contract nas8 - 39073 . s. doe , m. ljungberg , a. siemiginowska , & w. joye , fitting and modeling of axaf data with the asc fitting application , " in _ astronomical data analysis software and systems vii _ , r. albrecht , r. n. hook , & h. a. bushouse , ed . , pp . 157160 , asp , san francisco , 1998 . s. doe , m. noble , & r. smith , interactive analysis and scripting in ciao 2.0 , " in _ astronomical data analysis software and systems x _ , f. r. harnden , f. a. primini , & h. e. payne , ed . , _ in press _ , asp , san francisco , 2001 . k. kearns , f. primini , & d. alexander , `` bias - free parameter estimation with few counts , by iterative chi - squared minimization , '' in _ astronomical data analysis software and systems iv _ , r. a. shaw , h. e. payne , & j. j. e. hayes , ed . , pp . 331334 , asp , san francisco , 1995 . t. j. loredo & d. q. lamb , `` establishing the existence of lines in gamma - ray bursts , '' in _ gamma - ray bursts : observations , analyses , and theories _ , c. ho , r. epstein , & e. fenimore , ed . , pp . 414415 , cambridge university press , cambridge , 1992 . r. k. smith , n. s. brickhouse , d. a. liedahl , & j. c. raymond , `` collisional plasma models with apec / aped : emission line diagnostics of hydrogen - like and helium - like ions , '' _ ap . j. lett . _ , _ in press _ , 2001

the ever - increasing quality and complexity of astronomical data underscores the need for new and powerful data analysis applications . this need has led to the development of _ sherpa _ , a modeling and fitting program in the _ ciao _ software package that enables the analysis of multi - dimensional , multi - wavelength data . in this paper , we present an overview of _ sherpa _ s features , which include : support for a wide variety of input and output data formats , including the new model descriptor list ( mdl ) format ; a model language which permits the construction of arbitrarily complex model expressions , including ones representing instrument characteristics ; a wide variety of fit statistics and methods of optimization , model comparison , and parameter estimation ; multi - dimensional visualization , provided by _ chips _ ; and new interactive analysis capabilities provided by embedding the s lang interpreted scripting language . we conclude by showing example _ sherpa _ analysis sessions .

1011.2313

cognitive radio ( cr ) is a promising approach to efficiently utilize the scarce rf spectrum resource . in this paradigm , knowledge about spectrum occupancy in time , frequency , and space that is both accurate and timely is crucial in allowing cr networks to opportunistically use the spectrum , and avoid interference to a primary user ( pu ) . in particular , information about pu location will enable several key capabilities in cr networks including improved spatio - temporal sensing , intelligent location - aware routing , as well as aiding spectrum policy enforcement . the localization problem in cr networks is in general different from localization in other applications such as wireless sensor networks ( wsn ) and global positioning system ( gps ) , in which the target to be localized cooperates with the localization devices . in contrast , a pu does not communicate directly with the crs during the localization process . this scenario is referred to as non - cooperative localization and does not allow the use of conventional techniques such as time - of - arrival ( toa ) and time - delay - of - arrival ( tdoa ) ranging . several techniques have been proposed in the literature for estimating the position of active pus in a cr network . these schemes include both range - based @xcite and range - free @xcite algorithms . range - free positioning schemes , such as centroid localization @xcite , have attracted a lot of interest because of their simplicity and robustness to changes in wireless propagation properties such as path loss . this characteristic makes them suitable candidates for systems requiring coarse - grained , but reliable and cost - effective techniques . on the other hand , range - based techniques such as multi - lateration @xcite , offer better estimates , but require accurate information about the target s distance that can only be achieved either through cooperation with the target or a very precise knowledge of the path loss model . in this paper , we focus on analyzing the performance of a particular , low complexity , coarse - grained localization algorithm , referred to as weighted centroid localization ( wcl ) @xcite . in this technique , pu location is approximated as the weighted average of all secondary user positions within its transmission range . strictly speaking , wcl is not an entirely range - free technique because it requires additional information aside from simple connectivity , namely received signal strength ( rss ) measurements . wcl and wcl - like methods are suitable for pu localization because of their low computational complexity . they also do not require cooperation from the pu and only use the readily available rss information . in addition , wcl always converges to a solution , as opposed to some range - based techniques , and do not require estimation of the path loss exponent beforehand . recent papers on wcl have proposed improvements on the basic algorithm to enhance its performance for specific scenarios @xcite . all previous wcl studies reported in the literature have been analyzed either via simulation or field experiments @xcite . to the best of our knowledge , there has been no analysis of the probability distribution of the localization error for even the simplest version of wcl in the presence of shadowing in both wsn and cr literature . we present the first theoretical analysis of the error distribution of wcl in this paper . the presented analytical framework models varying levels of shadowing , including both independent and correlated shadowing environments , and also takes inaccuracy of sensor node positioning into consideration . using this analysis in conjunction with numerical simulations we observe and quantify the robustness of wcl to variable channel conditions and node placements . we also investigate variable node participation as a simple modification that can improve wcl performance . in the latter part of this paper we propose and investigate a distributed cluster - based implementation of wcl in the context of cr networks . previous work primarily assumes a centralized fusion node aggregating data from other nodes . in the context of wsn where wcl was first utilized @xcite , the primary motivation was node self - localization where a node applies wcl using measurements from beacon nodes in close proximity to it . this approach naturally dictates a centralized system where the node to be localized acts as the fusion center and only requires minimal interaction with the beacons . in the case of pu localization in cr networks , however , where the primary motivation is estimating the position of a non - cooperative node , there no longer exists any particular node that has all the requisite information to perform wcl . in this case a fusion node is arbitrarily chosen . this approach does not scale very well in terms of communication overhead and transmit power , which limits its application to low node densities or small network size . there is therefore a need to create distributed implementations of wcl for this technique to be practically applied in cr localization . a standard approach for distributing control in sensor networks is clustering . several algorithms exist in the literature for creating either disjoint @xcite or overlapping @xcite clusters . in @xcite , a distributed technique based on the concept of mean - shift @xcite . however , the technique requires repeatedly forming a virtual cluster until it converges to the target location . this introduces additional communication overhead and also requires several iterations to converge . we present an implementation which saves total transmit power needed for localization process communication , and investigate its accuracy as well as its effect on per node computational complexity and total transmit power consumption . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . the system model is introduced in section [ sec : systemmodel ] . the theoretical analysis of centralized wcl accuracy is presented in section [ sec : analysis ] , while a practical and distributed implementation of wcl is proposed and analyzed in section [ sec : distributed ] . numerical results for various scenarios used to evaluate performance of wcl algorithms are presented in section [ sec : evaluation ] . finally , the paper is concluded in section [ sec : conclusion ] . this section presents the general framework for our analysis . we first review the assumptions about the system setting and propagation model , and then present the basic wcl algorithm . we adopt the pu - centric model @xcite in which the pu transmitter is assumed to be at the center area of a circle . the rationale behind this choice is that in a practical scenario , sensor nodes that obtain enough received power ( i.e. above sensitivity threshold ) approximately form a circle around the primary transmitter . thus , sensors within this circle are used to jointly estimate the position of the pu . an implicit assumption in this model is that the pu is surrounded by enough nodes so that edge effects can be disregarded . assume @xmath0 sensor nodes in a circle of fixed radius @xmath1 . the number of sensors within the circle is jointly affected by several factors , such as transmit power of the pu ( which effectively determines @xmath1 ) , node density , node selection methodology , etc . @xmath0 is a design parameter for wcl deployment , the choice of which will have significant influence on the localization accuracy , as will be shown in our analysis . the pu located at the center has a coordinate defined as @xmath2^t=[0 , 0]^t$ ] . for the @xmath3th sensor node , we define its 2-dimensional location as @xmath4^t$ ] where @xmath5 . sensors are placed independently in both dimensions . we assume sensors obtain information about their own locations , which is modeled as imperfect . the measured location of the @xmath3th sensor is distributed as @xmath6 , where @xmath7 defines standard deviation of the error in sensor node self - localization . we further assume the self - localization errors are independent among sensors and are independent from received powers . we adopt the following channel model for received signal strength used in wcl . the received power of the @xmath3th node from the primary transmitter , @xmath8 , is given by @xmath9 in which the first two terms characterize path loss and the last term describes shadowing effect . the path loss is characterized by three constants : reference power @xmath10 , reference distance @xmath11 and path loss exponent @xmath12 . denote collection of shadowing variables as @xmath13 $ ] , then its distribution is characterized by @xmath14 . we consider the following shadowing cases _ = _ s^2 * i_n , & i.i.d case , + \{_}_ij = _ i-_j /x_c , & correlated case , [ shadowing ] * where @xmath15 is the correlation distance @xcite within which the shadowing effects of nodes are correlated , and @xmath16 is the identity matrix with dimension @xmath0 . the theoretical analysis presented in section [ sec : analysis ] is based on the centralized architecture , which will also give us an upper bound on the performance . in each localization period , all sensors involved in the wcl will send their rss measurements to the fusion center , where an estimate will be made about the coordinate of the primary transmitter . the considered algorithm is a modification of relative - span wcl proposed in @xcite . in this scheme , the weights are guaranteed to be non - negative in db scale . the 2-dimensional estimated location of pu is formed as @xmath17 the weight factor of node @xmath3 is defined as @xmath18 , @xmath19 where @xmath20 is a constant calculated from average received power of the node on the border with some margin , to guarantee the probability that receive power of all nodes in the area below @xmath20 is sufficiently small , say 1% . @xmath21 is the maximum received power among nodes , and @xmath22 is the span of received power . the localization error is then given by @xmath23^t$ ] , where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the 1-dimensional errors along the x and y - axis respectively . finally , the performance of the wcl scheme is evaluated by distance error , which is given by @xmath26 this section presents the analysis of wcl error using probability theory , ultimately leading to analytical expressions for the error distribution , first of wcl applied to 1-dimensional coordinates , and finally the 2-dimensional wcl error given by ( [ error - dist ] ) . first we derive the 1-dimensional localization error for the i.i.d . shadowing case . we define a constant @xmath27 for each node @xmath3 as @xmath28 one can verify that @xmath29 . the location estimation in one dimension , say , x - axis , is naturally given by @xmath30 based on our i.i.d assumption among all @xmath8 s , one can verify that @xmath31 for the statistical property of @xmath32 , since @xmath33 s are also i.i.d and are independent of @xmath8 s , the mean of @xmath32 is given by @xmath34 . the variance of the @xmath3th term of @xmath32 is given by rcl [ variance a ] [ ( p_i - p _ ) x_i ] & = & [ ( p_i - p_)^2 ] [ x_i^2 ] - [ p_i - p_]^2 [ x_i]^2 + & = & _ l^2 _ i^2 + _ s^2 _ i^2 + _ l^2 _ s^2 . thus the variance of @xmath32 is derived as @xmath35 . from central limit theorem , we approximate @xmath32 as a single gaussian variable , i.e. @xmath36 , which is verified by numerical simulations that are not presented here due to space limit . since @xmath32 and @xmath37 are correlated due to summation over the same set of variables , i.e. @xmath8 s , @xmath24 is a ratio of two correlated gaussian variables . in order to obtain statistical properties of @xmath24 , we first calculate correlation coefficient @xmath38 of @xmath32 and @xmath37 , which is given by @xmath39/(\sigma_a \sigma_b ) = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}\left [ \sum_{i=1}^{n } \sum_{j=1}^{n } x_i s_i s_j \right]/(\sigma_a \sigma_b ) . \label{correlation - coeff1}\ ] ] note that = _ i _ s^2 , & @xmath40 , + 0 , & @xmath41 , [ correlation ] thus the correlation coefficient is obtained as @xmath42 where @xmath43^t$ ] , and @xmath44 is the @xmath45th norm of the vector . from the previous analysis we know that @xmath24 is the ratio of two dependent gaussian random variables with non - zero means for which the closed - form pdf is available in ( * ? ? ? * eqn 7.14 ) . based on the pdf of @xmath24 , we calculate its mean @xmath46 and variance @xmath47 by numerical integration . alternatively , we also calculate @xmath46 and @xmath47 through approximation results of @xcite , which assume @xmath24 follows normal distribution . the approximation results are given by rcl m__p & & ( m_a / m_b ) + _ b^2 m_a / m_b^3 - _ ab _ a _ b /m_b^2 + _ _ p^2 & & _ b^2 m_a^2/m_b^4 + _ a^2/m_b^2 - 2 _ ab _ a _ b m_a /m_b^3 . [ approx ] the gaussian approximation ( [ approx ] ) is verified via numerical simulations . specifically , the mean and variance calculated from integration of the closed - form pdf are compared with the approximated mean and variance , for different node numbers . our results show that for @xmath48 , the approximation error for the means is essentially zero and less than 3% for the variances . up to this stage , we are able to calculate the mean and variance of the estimation error in the x - axis as @xmath49 , @xmath50 . the same analysis applies for calculating the mean and variance of the estimation error along the y - axis , namely , @xmath51 and @xmath52 . note that the estimation errors in x - axis and y - axis are correlated , therefore the statistical properties of the 2-dimensional error , @xmath53 , can not be obtained directly . in this case , since @xmath8 s in ( [ est x ] ) are correlated , thus the distribution of @xmath24 needs to be evaluated again . since @xmath37 in ( [ est x ] ) is the linear combination of correlated gaussian variables , it is still gaussian distributed @xcite , i.e. @xmath54 . thus , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 is given by @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the @xmath59th element of the covariance matrix of @xmath60^{t}$ ] , defined as @xmath61 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[s_i s_j ] = \sigma_s^2 \lambda_{ij } , \label{covariance_b}\ ] ] where @xmath62 . for the distribution of @xmath32 , it follows directly that @xmath63 . its variance is given by @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the @xmath59th element of the covariance matrix of @xmath66^{t}$ ] , which can be represented by @xmath67[(p_j - p_{min})x_j- x_j \mu_j]\ } \ieeenonumber \\ = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[x_i s_i x_j s_j ] , \label{covariance_a}\ ] ] where @xmath68 $ ] is given by = _ s^2 ( _ i^2 + _ l^2 ) , & @xmath40 , + _ i _ j _ s^2 _ ij , & @xmath41 . [ correlation ] based on central limit theorem , we approximate @xmath32 as a gaussian random variable , i.e. @xmath69 . the approximation is validated via simulations , and it applies for @xmath70 . the correlation coefficient @xmath38 is given by @xmath71/(\sigma_a \sigma_b ) = ( \sigma_s^2 \sum_{i=1}^{n } \sum_{j=1}^{n } \overline{x}_i \lambda_{ij } ) / ( \sigma_a \sigma_b ) . \label{correlation coeff}\ ] ] substituting the expressions for @xmath72 and @xmath73 into ( [ correlation coeff ] ) , after some simple manipulation , @xmath74 where @xmath75 and @xmath76 is a @xmath77 vector of all @xmath78 s . since the location estimate @xmath24 is formed by @xmath79 , we use the closed - form pdf given by ( * ? ? ? * eqn 7.14 ) to calculate @xmath46 and @xmath47 by numerical integration . gaussian approximation can also be used similarly to i.i.d shadowing case in sec . [ subsubsec : iidshadowing ] . in our previous analysis , we obtained the statistical properties of 1-dimensional location estimation error for both i.i.d . and correlated shadowing case . from gaussian approximation of 1-dimensional localization error ( [ approx ] ) , we know that @xmath80 , where @xmath81^t$ ] , @xmath82,\ ] ] and @xmath83 is the correlation coefficient between 1-dimensional errors , the calculation of which is presented in the appendix . the calculation of localization error @xmath53 involves computing 2-norm of @xmath84 . since the two variables in @xmath84 are dependent gaussian r.v.s with different variances , we perform the following transformations . first we form two independent gaussian variables from @xmath84 , by the standard technique of decorrelation @xcite , @xmath85^t$ ] , where @xmath86 is the orthogonal eigenvalue decomposition matrix of @xmath87 , which satisfies @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is a diagonal matrix . therefore , one can verify that ( * ? ? ? * eqn 2.1 - 159 ) @xmath90 . then by the orthogonal - invariant property of 2-norm @xcite , we know @xmath91 . in order to obtain the pdf of @xmath92 , let us first consider pdf of @xmath93 . @xmath94 and @xmath95 are two chi - square variables with one degree of freedom . then the pdf of @xmath96 is the convolution of these two chi - square pdfs , denoted as @xmath97 . the pdf of the localization error @xmath98 is given by @xmath99 . as a result , the closed - form pdf of @xmath53 , for given sensor node positions , is given by rcl p_e_l(x ) & = & ( - ) + & & _ i=0^ _ l=0^ , x 0 [ pdf_2d ] where @xmath100 , @xmath101 and @xmath102 , @xmath103 are means and variances of @xmath104 and @xmath105 , respectively , and @xmath106 and @xmath107 are gamma function and @xmath108th - order modified bessel function of the first kind , respectively . the mean and variance of @xmath53 , denoted as @xmath109 and @xmath110 , are calculated using their definitions , by numerical integration over the above pdf . note that the above calculations are based on a particular fixed node placement . if the nodes are randomly placed within the area according to some distribution , say uniform distribution , integrating @xmath111 times over all node coordinates gives the theoretical average performance . based on the theoretical analysis , wcl requires large number of nodes in order to achieve a high level of accuracy . this causes large communication overhead in terms of number of messages and transmit power consumption when implemented in a centralized manner . we now present a practical distributed implementation of wcl to address this problem in the context of cr networks . clustering is commonly used in implementation of distributed algorithms . the challenge in designing these algorithms is to reduce the amount of information exchanged among clusters . the proposed algorithm accomplishes this by splitting the task into two phases . first , the cluster with the highest average rss is selected . this cluster then acts as the coordinator for the second phase which performs the actual wcl algorithm . nodes , @xmath112 , in the cr network are assumed to be organized into clusters , @xmath113 , using the clustering algorithm presented in @xcite . this particular algorithm is based on geographic boundaries and generates clusters which have a predefined shape ( hexagonal in this case ) . the regularity in the shape of the cluster is beneficial for the first step of the distributed algorithm since wcl works best for a radially symmetric distribution of nodes . however , the proposed algorithm would work for any arbitrary clustering algorithm as long as nodes are clustered based on proximity . the pu is assumed to be randomly placed in the entire area and can thus be in any of these clusters . each cluster selects one node , @xmath114 , to be the cluster head . the cluster head maintains a table of all adjacent clusters , @xmath115 , and the location of its member nodes , @xmath116 . once a pu is detected by a node , using an existing pu detection method such as energy detection @xcite , it transmits its rss measurement to the corresponding cluster head which then participates in the distributed wcl algorithm outlined in the next section . using a predetermined fusion rule , such as a majority vote , the cluster head makes a decision on the presence of the pu . all clusters that decide that the pu is present , participate in the distributed wcl algorithm detailed in the next subsection . these clusters form a set defined as @xmath117 . if in addition , some prior knowledge of the pu transmit power is available , a situation typical of a cr network coexisting with a licensed incumbent network , then a predetermined threshold can be used to further reduce the number of clusters in @xmath117 . the threshold can be chosen based on the average node spacing to get a certain desired average number of nodes . we investigate the effect of this number on wcl accuracy in sec . [ subsec : variableparticipation ] . the first phase , which selects the head cluster , is shown in algorithm [ alg : selection ] . the objective is to select the cluster with the highest average rss , @xmath118 . this is done in a distributed manner by comparing the average rss between neighboring clusters . however , directly implementing this procedure would require a large amount of inter - cluster communication . to solve this issue , a cluster only communicates its average rss to the neighboring cluster , @xmath119 , in the direction of the pu relative to the cluster s centroid . although techniques for estimating the angle of arrival of a transmitter could be beneficial , these methods require cluster heads to have multiple antennas which increases complexity of sensors . in order to get an approximation of the pu direction , we propose a metric , @xmath120 , shown in line 5 of algorithm [ alg : selection ] . we get @xmath120 by subtracting the wcl result of all nodes within the same cluster from the geometric centroid of those nodes . this vector approximates the rss gradient within the cluster . it corresponds to an approximate direction of the pu since on average the rss in ( [ received power ] ) decreases as distance to pu increases . therefore , the negative of the gradient is directed towards the point with maximum rss . once the cluster with the highest average rss is selected , algorithm [ alg : mwcl ] is performed . in this step , the final wcl calculation is done using nodes within a given radius , @xmath121 , of the selected cluster s strongest node ( sn ) , @xmath122 . @xmath121 is adaptively chosen to be the minimum of the distance to the closest map edge , @xmath123 , and the cluster radius @xmath124 . this reduces the border effect , which is the tendency of the location estimate to be biased towards the center when the pu is close to the map border , by ensuring a radially symmetric node distribution even when the pu is close to the network edge . in order to improve the localization accuracy , additional nodes from adjacent clusters are also included in the wcl calculation . using the location of @xmath122 and @xmath121 , these adjacent clusters can reduce the amount of information exchanged by only transmitting the location and rss measurements of nodes that fall within this circle . in the case of large clusters , each cluster could also choose to calculate a weighted centroid using its own nodes and transmit the result of this calculation only . since wcl is essentially an averaging algorithm , this technique allows even algorithm [ alg : mwcl ] to be distributed . @xmath125 @xmath126 @xmath127 \mathbf{l}(n_j ) } { \sum_{n_j\in c_i}(\operatorname{p}(n_j ) - \min(\operatorname{p}(n_j))}$ ] @xmath128 @xmath129 select @xmath130 proceed to algorithm [ alg : mwcl ] @xmath131 @xmath132 @xmath133 @xmath134 \mathbf{l}(n_j ) } { \sum_{n_j \in c^*_{wcl}}\left[\operatorname{p}(n_j ) - \min(\operatorname{p}(n_j)\right]}$ ] * function * @xmath135 * return * @xmath136 , @xmath137 * end function * the power efficiency and computational complexity of this distributed approach could further be improved by taking into account a practical mobility model of the pu . there has been a lot of work such as @xcite , which discussed how to incorporate past observations of the target position and a mobility model to improve localization . however , applying these methods introduces complexity to wcl and defeats the purpose of such a low complexity scheme . intuitively , assuming the pu continuously transmits during successive wcl estimations , a pu would most likely be in the same cluster as it was in the previous wcl calculation , or it could move to an adjacent cluster . by considering this fact , algorithm [ alg : selection ] can further limit the clusters involved in choosing the head cluster , which is the most power consuming phase , by only taking the previous cluster head and its adjacent clusters as @xmath117 . we analyze the total transmit power and computational complexity of cwcl and the proposed dwcl algorithm . in order to do so , we first need to investigate the transmit power on a single link of length @xmath138 . the minimum transmit power is obtained from ( [ received power ] ) as @xmath139 , where @xmath140 is the minimum received power to correctly receive the message . for the computation complexity estimates , we assume the number of operations ( ops ) for addition , substraction and comparison is 1 ; for multiplication and division is 10 . in cwcl , the total number of messages is the sum of reporting messages from nodes to the fusion center , thus , @xmath0 . for the transmit power consumption , we assume the fusion center is roughly at the center of a circle area of radius @xmath1 , and nodes are placed according to a uniform distribution . in this case , one can verify that , @xmath141 , the distance from the @xmath3th node to the fusion center satisfies @xmath142 , where @xmath143 is the uniform distribution from @xmath32 to @xmath37 . thus the average total power consumption is expressed as @xmath144 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e } } [ p_{r,\min } \sum_{i=1}^{n } ( d_i^{\gamma}10^{-s_i/10 } ) ] \approx n p_{r,\min } \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[d_i^{\gamma } ] \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[10^{-s_i/10}],\ ] ] where we use statistical average to replace sum of realizations . note that @xmath145 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[{(d_i^2)}^{\gamma/2}]$ ] , which is the @xmath146th moment of an uniform variable . in order to calculate @xmath147 $ ] , we need the distribution of @xmath148 , which is a function of central gaussian variable @xmath149 . thus we can derive the desired pdf as @xcite @xmath150 finally , the average total power consumption is given by @xmath151 = n p_{r,\min } \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[d_i^{\gamma } ] \int_0^{\infty } x p(x ) d x.\ ] ] from the definition of wcl estimate , number of ops of cwcl is @xmath152 . assume that : @xmath153 is the average number of nodes in one cluster ; @xmath154 is the average number of clusters ; @xmath155 is the number of neighboring clusters for each cluster ; @xmath156 is the average percentage of clusters who decide they are the head cluster in step 7 of algorithm 1 ( clusters that have to perform step 8) . the total number of messages for algorithm 1 is @xmath157 . to calculate transmit power , in step 1 ) we use the same procedure as cwcl ( with a smaller radius ) ; step 2 ) and 3 ) are communication among cluster heads , we use the average distance between centers of two clusters as the estimate of the average distance among cluster heads . in algorithm 2 , the total number of messages is @xmath158 and the calculation of power consumption for this process is the same as step 2 ) of algorithm 1 . in terms of computational complexity , the number of ops for algorithm 1 is @xmath159 while the number of ops for algorithm 2 is @xmath160 . in this section , we evaluate the performance of cwcl algorithm and its proposed distributed implementation . for cwcl algorithm , using the theoretical framework presented in section [ sec : analysis ] , we consider impact of sensor node positioning error , different levels of shadowing @xmath161 and different correlation distances @xmath162 . the effect of node placement is investigated under random grid and uniform distribution . prior work on wcl uses mean localization error as the performance metric of interest . in @xcite , a slightly modified performance metric where the mean error is normalized by the transmission range @xmath1 of pu is adopted . simulations in these prior work have shown that the accuracy of wcl improves as the density of nodes is increased . this result is intuitive since the node spacing decreases as the density of nodes is increased . in this work , we introduce a novel performance metric where the mean localization error @xmath163 is normalized with respect to the average node spacing @xmath164 . the motivation for choosing this metric is to eliminate the effect of geometry scaling which intuitively improves accuracy . in order to isolate the effect of shadowing on wcl performance we consider a fixed grid placement of nodes with perfect positioning ( i.e. @xmath165 ) and fixed pu position . the normalized mean localization error for this scenario is shown in fig . [ fig : fixgridsquare_shadow_mean ] . for given shadowing variance , as the number of nodes increases , there is a slight improvement in the accuracy , which is a consequence of averaged shadowing over many nodes . note that this gain saturates at approximately 200 nodes or more . we also observe that wcl is quite robust to shadowing , since for an additional @xmath166 of shadowing from @xmath167 to @xmath168 , normalized error increases only 5% . therefore wcl is well suited for pu localization in severely shadowed environments . the results for mean localization error under correlated shadowing are shown in fig . [ fig : fixgridsquare_corr_mean ] . assuming fixed value of @xmath169 , and different levels of @xmath162 normalized to @xmath164 are presented . in highly correlated shadowing such as @xmath170 , increasing the number of nodes always worsens the error . for the high node density case , e.g. 400 nodes , the average error is as high as 47% of @xmath164 . we conclude that when all nodes are included in the wcl calculation , correlation has a degrading effect to accuracy . further investigation shows that the correlation distance resulting in the worst performance is proportional to the number of nodes involved . the impact of positioning accuracy of sensing nodes is presented in fig . [ fig : imperfect location knowledge ] with a fixed grid placement of nodes in an i.i.d . shadowing environment with @xmath171 . analysis shows that errors in sensor node positioning decrease the wcl accuracy but the impact is marginal . for example , @xmath7 of @xmath172 m increases the error for about @xmath78% . ) as a function of variance in the participating nodes positioning error , @xmath7 . for this scenario , nodes are placed on a grid with equal spacing ( fixed grid placement ) in an area with @xmath173 m . pu is at the center of the area . ] the previous subsections considered fixed node placement and pu location . realistically , node placement can be random and the pu also appears at random locations relative to the sensor nodes . next we consider two cases of random node placement : random grid and uniformly distributed placement . in the random grid scenario , the sensor nodes are still on a grid , but the pu can appear uniformly within the center box . a grid distribution of nodes can be practically implemented if nodes are explicitly deployed for the purpose of acting as a dedicated localization sensor network . evenly placed beacons have been shown to provide better accuracy for wcl in wsns @xcite . results for random grid placement in fig . [ fig : randomgridanduniformrandomplacement ] show approximately 10% performance loss compared to fixed pu location scenarios . the uniformly distributed placement has been used in @xcite to more accurately model scenarios where the sensor node positions are not predefined , such as in mobile ad - hoc networks . the results for uniformly distributed placement are also shown in fig . [ fig : randomgridanduniformrandomplacement ] . it is observed that randomness in the node placement can increase the error as much as three times compared to the fixed node placement . ) with varying correlation distance normalized to the node spacing . results of two placements , random grid ( rg ) and uniform random ( ur ) , are shown in an area with @xmath173 m . for both placements , @xmath174 . ] the results given so far assumed an ideal circular coverage area for the pu . works such as @xcite indicated that in practical scenarios , the circular model can not be guarranteed due to several non - idealities such as fading , shadowing , and interference in the system . intuitively , the degree - of - irregularity ( _ doi _ ) parameter determines how closely the coverage area can be approximated by a circle . _ = 0 means the transmission range is perfectly circular . the model used in our simulation is the _ model briefly described in @xcite where the transmission range is a correlated gaussian r.v . centered at @xmath175 with variance @xmath176 . in fig . [ fig : varydoi ] the effect of _ doi _ is investigated in the presence of uncorrelated medium level shadowing ( @xmath177 ) . the result shows that _ doi _ between 0% and 40% increases the error by 4% . _ doi _ is not a significant impairment for wcl because nodes closest to the pu , where the effect of irregularity is negligible , are weighted more than nodes closer to the edge of the coverage area . however , a slight increase in the normalized mean error can be observed as more nodes are used at high doi ( 30% or 40% ) . the denser the node distribution , the more nodes are included in wcl , but the more nodes there are , the more deviation from a perfect circular coverage coverage area , leading to lower accuracy . with varying degree - of - irregularity ( doi ) . for this scenario , nodes are uniformly and independently distributed ( uniform random placement ) in an area with average @xmath175 . ] from fig . [ fig : randomgridanduniformrandomplacement ] we observe that in correlated shadowing increasing the number of nodes also increases the error . one solution to this problem is to reduce the number of participating nodes used in wcl for this scenario . this could be achieved by ignoring nodes farther away from the pu to reduce the number of nodes resulting in less degradation . in fig . [ fig : varyingparticipation ] we investigate varying levels of node participation for a fixed average node spacing , @xmath164 . in this case the total number of nodes is 100 , and the density remains the same while the number of involving nodes is varied . to select which nodes are included in the wcl calculation , nodes are sorted according to their rss values . the nodes with high received power are included in wcl . as a result , increasing the participation for the uncorrelated case always improves the accuracy . thus , 100% participation is optimal . however , even with a little correlation , this number is greatly reduced and about 10% of the total number of nodes is optimal . another selection scheme was previously proposed in @xcite where only nodes whose rss is within 15% of the stronges node s rss are used . the localization accuracy of wcl is also compared to other techniques suitable for cr scenarios . this includes lateration , centroid and strongest node ( sn ) . lateration is a range - based technique that uses least - squares estimation using distance estimates to the target . the centroid algorithm , on the other hand , is a range - free technique which calculates the average of all node positions in range of the pu . finally , the sn technique simply selects the node with the highest rss and uses its location as an estimate of the pu position . results in fig . [ fig : comaprison with other techiques ] show that wcl performs better under higher @xmath161 compared to lateration . although this seems counter - intuitive at first , the result can be explained by taking note that range - based techniques require an accurate estimate of the distance to the target to provide accurate results . in the case of non - interactive localization , where the only available information is the rss from the pu , shadowing induces a very large error in the range estimates . under low shadowing ( @xmath178 db ) , the lateration method is more accurate than wcl . at 0 db shadowing ( not shown in the figure ) , the range - based technique will achieve perfect localization . this result supports the claim that wcl is a viable method in the context of non - interactive localization because of its robustness . the centroid algorithm performs slightly worse than wcl because it does not utilize rss information . however , the performance difference becomes smaller at higher level of shadowing . . for this scenario , nodes are uniformly and independently distributed ( uniform random placement ) in an area with @xmath175 ( uncorrelated shadowing ) . note that the centroid technique is unaffected by @xmath179 . ] [ fig : dwcl compare ] presents simulation results that compare normalized mean error of cwcl , sn and dwcl under different shadowing environments . sn is included in the comparison because it forms the basis of the head cluster selection for dwcl so it acts as an upperbound to the error . we observe that the proposed dwcl performance is between cwcl and sn algorithms . it is also interesting to note that the accuracy of dwcl degrades relative to cwcl and approaches the performance of sn when shadowing is high . the reason behind this is that for cluster head selection , dwcl is dependent on the sn algorithm . the accuracy of the sn degrades at large shadowing shown in fig . [ fig : comaprison with other techiques ] . [ fig : fixgrid_nodepower_theo ] compares the transmit power consumption for cwcl and dwcl with different number of clusters . in the simulation we set @xmath180 which is the mean received power at the border of the area of @xmath175 , assuming @xmath181 dbm , @xmath182 m and @xmath183 in ( [ received power ] ) . we observe that dwcl with 16 clusters consumes about @xmath184dbm less power for each node compared with cwcl . the analysis also shows that transmit power of each node is reduced as the number of node increases , since the average communication distance is getting smaller in dwcl . [ fig : fixgrid_cpu_theo ] compares computational complexity estimated in terms of number of ops . it shows that distributed algorithms require about three times more operations than cwcl , however total transmit power is reduced . in this paper we present the first analytical framework for the performance of wcl for localization of pu transmitters in cr networks . we derived the closed - form expression for the error distribution of wcl parameterized by node density , node placement , shadowing variance , correlation distance and errors in sensor nodes positions . using the theoretical results in conjunction with numerical simulations , the robustness of wcl against various physical conditions is investigated and quantified . based on the above analysis , we provide guidelines in terms of number of nodes and node placement required to achieve certain localization accuracy using wcl and propose variable node participation for improved wcl performance . to facilitate the deployment of wcl in an energy efficient context , a distributed cluster - based implementation of wcl is also proposed , which does not assume a fusion center that collects all rss information from nodes . the distributed method achieves comparable accuracy with its centralized counterpart , and greatly reduces total power consumption . for notational convenience we define @xmath186 and form the vector @xmath187^{t}$ ] , so that @xmath188 with @xmath189 . note that this definition includes both i.i.d and correlated shadowing case . the first term in ( [ dimensional correlation ] ) then becomes @xmath190 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{\mathbf{x}^{t } \mathbf{q } \mathbf{q}^{t } \mathbf{y}}{\mathbf{1}^{t } \mathbf{q } \mathbf{q}^{t } \mathbf{1}}\right].\ ] ] define three new variables @xmath191 , @xmath192 and @xmath193 , and their vector form @xmath194^{t}$ ] . now the first term in ( [ dimensional correlation ] ) becomes @xmath195 $ ] . as shown in sec . ii , @xmath196 , and @xmath197 . @xmath198 can be approximated as a single gaussian variable as shown in sec . [ subsubsec : iidshadowing ] since it is the same as @xmath32 in ( [ est x ] ) . we denote its distribution as @xmath199 , similarly @xmath200 . the distribution of @xmath201 is given as @xmath202 , where @xmath203 and @xmath204 . as a result @xmath205 , where @xmath206^t$ ] is the mean vector and @xmath207 is the covariance matrix . to derive @xmath207 we find @xmath208 as @xmath209 - m_1 m_2 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[(\sum_{i=1}^{n } x_i q_i)(\sum_{j=1}^{n } y_j q_j ) ] - m_1 m_2 = \overline{\textbf{x}}^{t } \mathbf{\omega } \overline{\textbf{y } } - m_1 m_2\ ] ] where in the last the equation we used the fact @xmath210 = \overline{x}_i \overline{y}_j \mathbf{\omega}_{ij}$ ] . similarly we calculate all entries of @xmath207 . in order to simplify the calculation of ( [ reform ] ) , we perform the following transformation to @xmath211 , @xmath212 , thus @xmath213 . clearly @xmath214 , where @xmath215 is the @xmath3th column of @xmath216 . then we have @xmath217 = \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}[\frac{(m_1 + \boldsymbol{\omega}_{1}^{t } \widetilde{\textbf{t}})(m_2 + \boldsymbol{\omega}_{2}^{t } \widetilde{\textbf{t}})}{(m_3 + \boldsymbol{\omega}_{3}^{t } \widetilde{\textbf{t}})^2}].\ ] ] since the expectation in ( [ results ] ) involves multiplication and division of three correlated random variables , the calculation can not be done directly . in order to reduce the number of variables involved , first we form @xmath218 $ ] , then perform qr factorization to reduce dimensionality , obtaining @xmath219 , in which @xmath86 is orthogonal and @xmath220 is upper triangular @xmath221.\ ] ] note that since @xmath225 , denominator of ( [ results ] ) can further be expressed as @xmath226 \widetilde{\textbf{t}}\right)^{2 } \doteq \left(m_3 + r_{11 } \widetilde{t}_{1}\right)^{2 } , \label{den2_new}\ ] ] where we use the fact that @xmath227 is the first column of @xmath220 ; and @xmath228^{t}$ ] . similarly , numerator of ( [ results ] ) can also be further expressed as therefore , the expectation in ( [ reform ] ) becomes @xmath229 = \frac { r_{12 } r_{13 } } { r_{11}^2 } \operatorname{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{\widetilde{t}_{1}^2 + \left(\frac{m_1}{r_{12 } } + \frac{m_2}{r_{13}}\right ) \widetilde{t}_{1 } + \left(\frac{m_1 m_2 + r_{22 } r_{23}}{r_{12 } r_{13}}\right)}{\left(\widetilde{t}_{1 } + \frac{m_3}{r_{11}}\right)^{2}}\right ] . \label{exp1_new}\ ] ] after factorization ( [ exp1_new ] ) becomes @xmath230 = \frac { r_{12 } r_{13 } } { r_{11}^2 } \!\!\left(\!\!1 + \frac{\left(\frac{m_1}{r_{12 } } + \frac{m_2}{r_{13}}\right)-2 \frac{m_3}{r_{11}}}{\frac{m_3}{r_{11 } } } + \frac{\left(\frac{m_1 m_2 + r_{22 } r_{23}}{r_{12 } r_{13}}\right)+\left({\frac{m_3}{r_{11}}}\right)^2-\left(\frac{m_1}{r_{12 } } + \frac{m_2}{r_{13}}\right ) \frac{m_3}{r_{11}}}{1+\left({\frac{m_3}{r_{11}}}\right)^2 } \right).\ ] ] substituting ( [ corr - coeff_new ] ) into ( [ dimensional correlation ] ) gives the result . j. wang , p. urriza , y. han , and d. abri , `` performance analysis of weighted centroid algorithm for primary user localization in cognitive radio networks , '' in _ proc . asilomar conference on signals , systems , and computers _ , pacific grove , ca , usa , nov . 710 , 2010 . h. chen , q. shi , r. tan , h. poor , and k. sezaki , `` mobile element assisted cooperative localization for wireless sensor networks with obstacles , '' _ ieee trans . wireless commun . _ , vol . 9 , no . 3 , pp . 956 963 , mar . 2010 s. liu , y. chen , w. trappe , and l. j. greenstein , `` non - interactive localization of cognitive radios based on dynamic signal strength mapping , '' in _ proc . conf . on wireless on - demand network systems and services _ , snowbird , ut , usa , feb . 24 , 2009 . r. behnke , j. salzmann , r. grossmann , d. lieckfeldt , d. timmermann , and k. thurow , `` strategies to overcome border area effects of coarse grained localization , '' in _ proc . 6th workshop on positioning , navigation and communication _ , hannover , germany , eu , mar . 19 , 2009 . q. zhou , x. li , and y. xu , `` mean shift based collaborative localization with dynamically clustering for wireless sensor networks , '' in _ proc . conf . on communications and mobile computing _ , vol . 2 , yunnan , china , jan . 68 , 2009 . m. k. simon , _ probability distributions involving gaussian random variables : a handbook for engineers , scientists and mathematicians_. 1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emnew york , ny , usa : springer - verlag , 2006 . r. chandra , j. padhye , a. wolman , and b. zill , `` a location - based management system for enterprise wireless lans , '' in _ proc . symposium on networked systems design and implementation _ , cambridge , ma , usa , apr . 1113 , 2007 .

information about primary transmitter location is crucial in enabling several key capabilities in cognitive radio networks , including improved spatio - temporal sensing , intelligent location - aware routing , as well as aiding spectrum policy enforcement . compared to other proposed non - interactive localization algorithms , the weighted centroid localization ( wcl ) scheme uses only the received signal strength information , which makes it simple to implement and robust to variations in the propagation environment . in this paper we present the first theoretical framework for wcl performance analysis in terms of its localization error distribution parameterized by node density , node placement , shadowing variance , correlation distance and inaccuracy of sensor node positioning . using this analysis , we quantify the robustness of wcl to various physical conditions and provide design guidelines , such as node placement and spacing , for the practical deployment of wcl . we also propose a power - efficient method for implementing wcl through a distributed cluster - based algorithm , that achieves comparable accuracy with its centralized counterpart .

1202.5814

within the last fifteen years or so , the dynamical mean field theory approach ( dmft)@xcite and its cluster generalizations@xcite have become some of the most powerful techniques to study strongly correlated electrons . in these approaches , a single - site hybridized to a bath or a cluster hybridized to a bath must be solved . the bath of non - interacting electrons is determined self - consistently . at the heart of the dmft approach then , one finds so - called impurity solvers . there are now very powerful impurity solvers , for example continuous time quantum monte carlo ( ctqmc ) methods@xcite . these methods are exact within statistical errors and , for the one - band hubbard model , certain versions@xcite at the single site level do not suffer from sign problem . yet , these approaches require sizeable computational resources and , in addition , real frequency information must be obtained through analytical continuation of data with statistical uncertainties , an ill - posed problem@xcite . it is thus still of great interest to work with approximate solvers that are reliable and do not suffer from statistical uncertainties . this facilitates the calculation of real - frequency quantities with pad approximants@xcite or directly in real - frequency and also enables one to quickly explore phase diagrams and pinpoint interesting regions of parameter space where state of the art solvers would be useful . among possible approximate solvers , one finds exact diagonalization , slave bosons , non - crossing approximation ( nca ) , numerical renormalization group ( nrg ) and others@xcite . they all have advantages and disadvantages . for example , exact diagonalization can consider only a limited number of bath sites , nca is limited to high temperatures and nrg to low energies . here we consider iterated perturbation theory ( ipt ) @xcite , an interpolation approach that generalizes the original@xcite ipt applicable only at half filling . this method has been , and still is , wildly used@xcite . the interpolation is constructed so that the self - energy recovers both the exact result in the atomic limit and the high - frequency limit of the hubbard model . there is one parameter however that can not be determined from these constraints . there have been several proposals to fix this parameter . at @xmath1 one can impose that luttinger s theorem be satisfied ( ipt-@xmath2 ) as was done in [ ] but when this condition is applied at finite temperature , the results are not satisfactory@xcite . another very popular approach for non - zero temperature fixes the occupation @xmath3 of the non - interacting part of the anderson impurity problem used in the perturbative calculation to be equal to the lattice occupation @xmath4 @xcite ( ipt-@xmath3 ) . this condition is arbitrary since there is no general principle relating these two numbers , but it turns out to be quite satisfactory in the case of correlated metal i.e. @xmath5@xcite . @xmath6 is the coupling for which the metal to insulator mott transition occurs at half - filling . despite this success , it is known@xcite that when @xmath7 is larger than the critical value for the mott transition at @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) , then ipt breaks down for @xmath10 at low @xmath11 when the condition @xmath4 is applied . this happens even if , in principle , ipt is constructed to respect the atomic limit @xmath12 . it has been proposed@xcite that preserving the third moment of the spectral weight improves the results . here we show that ipt-@xmath3 is unsatisfactory for @xmath13 close to half - filling for both @xmath10 and @xmath14 . we propose a way to circumvent this problem by using the fact that when @xmath7 is large enough , the double occupancy becomes almost temperature independent in the paramagnetic state with a value that is , to a high degree of accuracy , a simple function of the density . this provides us with a condition different from @xmath4 that allows one to close the ipt equations even for large coupling . this approach , ipt-@xmath0 , is applicable at all temperatures contrary to the approach that enforces luttinger s theorem . it can in principle be improved further by enforcing the third - moment sum rule@xcite . in sec . [ dmft ] we summarize the dmft approach , the solvers that we use and the manner in which fermi liquid parameters are extracted . [ breakdown ] demonstrates the failure of ipt at large coupling . in this section and throughout the text , numerical examples are obtained with the 3-dimensional fcc lattice . amongst lattice presenting electronic frustration , the fcc lattice is important because of its prevalence in nature . our main contribution appears in sec . [ sec : double ] where we show that double occupancy can be accurately determined from simple arguments at very strong coupling and then used to fix the remaining parameter in ipt . we call this approach ipt-@xmath0 . fermi liquid parameters , density of states , chemical potential , energy , and specific heat on the fcc lattice are calculated with both ipt-@xmath0 and ctqmc as benchmark examples . resistivity and optical conductivity obtained with ipt-@xmath0 are physically reasonable . appendix a contains details on the three dimensional adaptive integrator we developed for both ipt and ctqmc calculation . appendix b contains details of the implementation of ipt-@xmath0 . appendix c explains how to calculate the different non - interacting functions and appendix d gives details on the calculation of the optical conductivity . we study the one - band hubbard model , @xmath15where @xmath16 is the hopping matrix between sites @xmath17 and @xmath18 , @xmath7 the on - site coulomb repulsion , @xmath19 the creation ( annihilation ) operator for an electron of spin @xmath20 on site @xmath17 and @xmath21 is the number operator . the dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) provides a solution of the hubbard model that describes the mott transition in three dimensions and has predictive power for real materials@xcite . drawing from ideas on the solution of the hubbard model in infinite dimension@xcite , the self - energy in this approach depends only on frequency . one first solves the problem of a single site with the hubbard @xmath7 , hybridized with an infinite bath of non - interacting electrons , the so - called anderson model . one extracts the frequency - dependent self - energy of the anderson model , which is then taken as the self - energy in the lattice green s function . the bath is determined self - consistently by requiring that projection of the lattice green s function on a single site is identical to the single - site green s function of the anderson model . the anderson impurity problem can be solved numerically with a very high precision . dmft has been justified with a variety of approaches@xcite including a variational one@xcite . the single - site dmft is exact in infinite dimension@xcite . benchmarks against the bethe ansatz solution in one - dimension shows that dmft can be an accurate solution of the hubbard model also in lower dimensions @xcite . mathematically , the partition function for the anderson impurity problem is given by the imaginary - time grassmann path integral @xmath22\,\mathrm{e}^{-s_{0}-\int_{0}^{\beta } d\tau \int_{0}^{\beta } d\tau ^{\prime \dag } ( \tau ) \delta ( \tau , \tau ^{\prime } ) \psi ( \tau ^{\prime } ) } , \label{eq : z}\]]with @xmath23 @xmath24 the bath hybridization and @xmath25 the action of the impurity , which consists of a single site with repulsion @xmath7 . the self - consistency condition in matsubara frequency reads @xmath26 ^{-1}. \end{split } \label{eq : scc}\]]with @xmath27 the self - energy . on the fcc lattice the single - particle dispersion is given , with lattice spacing @xmath28 , by @xmath29 $ ] . in single - site dmft , the self - energy is local ( @xmath30 ) which enables one to transform the integrals over the brillouin zone entering the self - consistency relation into integrals over the non - interacting density of states @xmath31 . however , in the case of a 3d fcc lattice , there is no analytic form for @xmath31 and its accurate numerical calculation using a monte - carlo binning procedure is cumbersome and only produces a fixed finite numbers of points . on the other hand , if we used a lorentzian as an approximation for the delta function , the band - edges and the van - hove singularities would suffer from accuracy problems that could be transferred to the dmft calculation . we thus performed the calculation with the full @xmath32 space integration . we devised an adaptive 3d fifth order gaussian quadrature for a cube . this integration method is explained in appendix [ appen_integrate ] . for comparisons in calculation of transport properties , we have nevertheless calculated @xmath31 using monte carlo integration as explained in appendix [ mc_function ] . the resulting non - interacting density of state for the fcc lattice with nearest - neighbor hopping only is shown in fig . [ fig : dos_u0 ] . we have used two `` impurity solvers '' for the auxiliary anderson model . they are described in the following subsections . the first method is the numerically exact continuous time quantum monte carlo method ( ctqmc ) @xcite , a finite temperature approach that relies on the monte carlo summation of all diagrams obtained from the expansion of the partition function in powers of the hybridization @xmath33 . this method does not have a sign problem , and does not have errors associated with time discretization or bath parametrization . it is therefore exact within statistical errors but computationally expensive . we refer to the literature for an explanation of the approach@xcite . we describe the second approach , iterated perturbation theory ( ipt ) , in more details since it is the focus of this paper . ipt is an approximation method that relies on an interpolation from @xmath34 order perturbation theory for the anderson impurity problem @xcite . the interpolation preserves the correct high - frequency limit for the self - energy and is exact in both the non - interacting and the atomic limits . we only consider paramagnetic solutions . the self - energy in this approach is parametrized by @xmath35 where @xmath36 with @xmath37 and @xmath33 the hybridization function . the constants @xmath38 and @xmath39 @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 , are chosen such that one recovers the exact solution in the atomic limit as well as the exact result for arbitrary @xmath7 in the high - frequency limit . the green s function used to obtain the density @xmath43 is @xmath44 in eq . , @xmath45 is the chemical potential of the lattice that is determined by fixing the value of @xmath43 while @xmath46 is the chemical potential determined by the fictitious density @xmath3 . we need an additional equation to fix @xmath46 . this problem has been studied carefully in refs . setting @xmath47 is not a good option . indeed , as mentioned in the introduction , fixing luttinger s volume works only at very low temperature@xcite . a widely used approach @xcite consists in fixing @xmath4 . we call this approach ipt-@xmath3 . one can also modify the formula for the interpolated self - energy by requiring that the third moment , appearing in the high - frequency expansion of the green s function , be satisfied exactly . in this case , the deficiencies of ipt-@xmath3 at strong coupling are not as severe . we will see below that requiring that double - occupancy takes its exact value is an easier solution that does not modify the simplicity of the original scheme and gives accurate results . ipt can be implemented efficiently , as described in appendix . [ appen_ipt ] , so that the solution can be obtained in a very short time . in this section , we first define the physical parameters that will be used to demonstrate the breakdown of ipt-@xmath3 . then we take advantage of the existence of the exact ctqmc impurity solver to characterize the solution of the dmft equation . the last subsection demonstrates that for @xmath7 much larger than the bandwidth , ipt-@xmath3 fails to reproduce even qualitatively the exact solution . at low @xmath11 and finite doping , it is known that dmft predicts a fermi liquid regime no matter how strong the interaction@xcite . in other words , a quasiparticle peak always appears at @xmath48 at low @xmath11 except at half - filling when @xmath49 . we characterize the fermi liquid with three parameters namely the effective chemical potential , @xmath50 the quasiparticle weight , @xmath51 and the scattering rate @xmath52 , where real and imaginary parts are defined by @xmath53 . in the dmft treatment of the hubbard model , luttinger s theorem is satisfied at @xmath1 when @xmath54 takes the value of the non - interacting chemical potential that gives the same density . all of the above parameters are calculated with the self - energy on the real frequency axis and thus , in principle , one needs to perform an analytical continuation from the data in matsubara frequencies and then extrapolate to zero temperature . in practice , we calculate the values of the self - energy for a few very low temperatures and use them to extrapolate to zero frequency and zero temperature . for the retarded @xmath55 and @xmath52 we take @xmath56 at the smallest positive @xmath57 for three low temperatures and extrapolate to @xmath1 using the fact that @xmath58 . for @xmath59 , the spectral definitions of the self - energies @xmath60 allow one to prove @xmath61}{\omega_n}}\big|_{\omega_n\rightarrow 0 } = \int{\frac{d\omega'}{\pi}}{\frac{\sigma(\omega')}{\omega'^2 } } = { \frac{{\partial}\sigma'(\omega)}{{\partial}\omega}}\big|_{\omega = 0}\ ] ] which , for a linear dependence of @xmath62 $ ] on @xmath63 , also follows from the cauchy - riemann relation for holomorphic functions of a complex variable . this last equation with three low temperatures allows us to calculate @xmath64/\omega_{n=0}$ ] , extrapolate to @xmath1 and obtain @xmath59 . consider the one - band hubbard model on the fcc lattice , where the single particle dispersion is given by @xmath29 $ ] . we present the dmft results obtained with the ctqmc impurity solver for @xmath65 and @xmath66 , below and above @xmath6 for the mott transition at half - filling . the bandwidth is @xmath67 for the 3d fcc lattice . fig.[fig : fermi_ctqmc ] displays the fermi liquid parameters . in fig.[fig : fermi_ctqmc]-(a ) the red solid line shows the non - interacting chemical potential as a function of density . the effective chemical potential @xmath68 is shown with blue circles for @xmath65 and black points for @xmath66 . the dashed lines indicates the position of the band edges for the 3d fcc lattice . as expected , except at half - filling for @xmath66 , luttinger s theorem is satisfied . in fig.[fig : fermi_ctqmc]-(b ) , the extrapolated scattering rate @xmath69 is negligibly small , except for @xmath66 at @xmath8 . for @xmath65 , ( not shown ) it is of the order @xmath70 and has essentially no density dependance . the value of @xmath59 , shown in in fig.[fig : fermi_ctqmc]-(c ) , behaves as expected : for @xmath9 , @xmath59 vanishes when the occupation approaches half - filling while it is close to the non - interacting value @xmath71 when the lattice is almost empty or full . we can also see that even for coupling as large as @xmath66 , the absence of particle - hole symmetry in the dispersion relation still leads to a value of @xmath59 that is not symmetric with respect to half - filling . clearly , electronic frustration plays an important role in the doped mott insulator . the ipt equations eqs . - do not determine the value of @xmath3 . as mentioned previously , for @xmath1 the requirement that luttinger s theorem be satisfied ( ipt-@xmath2 ) provides an additional independent equation , except at half - filling for @xmath9 . however , luttinger s theorem is in general not satisfied at finite temperature and the method becomes inaccurate . the condition @xmath4 has thus been proposed@xcite ( ipt-@xmath3 ) . it gives satisfactory results for correlated metals ( not for the insulator at half - filling ) . the results for the low - temperature extrapolations of @xmath72 and @xmath59 for @xmath65 and @xmath66 are shown in fig . [ fig : fermi_ipt ] . below the mott transition , @xmath65 , the @xmath4 results ( brown ( @xmath73 ) ) are shown . one can detect only a very small difference with the solid red line . luttinger s theorem is thus essentially satisfied . on the other hand , ipt-@xmath3 for @xmath66 ( kaki ( @xmath74 ) ) gives non - physical results not only@xcite for @xmath10 but , quite generally , close to half - filling . not only is luttinger s theorem strongly violated , but for a large range of densities , @xmath10 , @xmath54 is outside the band . many properties of the fermi liquid are proportional to functions of the non - interacting system evaluated at @xmath54 . but these functions are zero outside the band and so if @xmath54 is outside the band we obtain zero . for example , this would predict an insulator away from half - filling . the situation is not better for @xmath59 , especially around half - filling where it vanishes for a finite range of densities when @xmath10 . this demonstrates that at low @xmath11 , when @xmath7 is large , ipt-@xmath3 in its simplest form can not be applied . we must thus search for a new condition to explore this region of parameter space imposing exact results such as sum - rules , whenever possible , is desirable for any physical theory . whereas the condition @xmath4 is not required by any fundamental principle , the self - energy must always obey @xmath75 where @xmath76 is double occupancy . enforcing this consistency condition between single - particle properties , such as @xmath77 and @xmath78 , and a two - particle property , @xmath0 , has been successful in other approaches , such as the two - particle - self - consistent theory.@xcite . in the regime of interest here , strong coupling , @xmath0 can be accurately estimated and is only very weakly dependent on temperature , as discussed in the following subsection . there , we assess the accuracy of the approach . for double occupancy @xmath79 plotted as a function of temperature . we define @xmath80 for fillings @xmath14 and @xmath81 for @xmath10 . the various densities are represented by different symbols : @xmath82 ( black ( @xmath83 ) ) , @xmath84 ( blue ( @xmath85 ) ) , @xmath86 ( red ( @xmath87 ) ) , @xmath88 ( green ( @xmath89 ) ) , @xmath90 ( yellow ( + ) ) , @xmath91 ( cyan ( @xmath92 ) ) , @xmath93 ( magenta ( @xmath94 ) ) , @xmath95 ( brown ( @xmath96 ) ) and @xmath97 ( kaki ( @xmath98 ) ) . the largest deviations from the naive value , occurring close to @xmath8 , are less than @xmath99 in absolute value . ] as a function of density obtained from ctqmc for @xmath66 for three temperatures : @xmath100 ( black ( @xmath87 ) ) , @xmath101 ( blue ( @xmath102 ) ) and @xmath103 ( red ( @xmath104 ) ) . on this scale , the naive value of @xmath0 is very accurate . the inset is a zoom for densities @xmath105 . ] for very large @xmath7 , it is easy to guess that @xmath0 should depend only very weakly on temperature . in addition , the value of @xmath0 can be estimated quite accurately . indeed if @xmath14 there are unoccupied sites in the lattice and since @xmath7 is large , @xmath0 should naively be zero . for @xmath10 , @xmath0 is necessarily non - zero . if we start from the half - filled , mott insulator , with one electron per site and add electrons , they must go to a site which is already occupied . thus @xmath0 should simply equal the excess number of electrons measured from half - filling , @xmath106 . these estimates are called @xmath107 . in reality for @xmath14 there are corrections of order @xmath108 to double occupancy , giving rise to exchange interaction , and @xmath0 is slightly larger than zero . for analogous reasons , @xmath0 for @xmath10 will always be a bit larger than @xmath109 i.e. @xmath110 . this is obvious for models with particle - hole symmetry , but it will be true as well , even in the absence of particle - hole symmetry . we can verify our estimates with the ctqmc results for @xmath66 . within ctqmc , @xmath0 is calculated directly on the impurity by the monte - carlo sampling . fig.[fig : d_occ ] displays @xmath79 as a function of temperature for different densities . we see that @xmath79 is small and that the @xmath11 dependence is on the third significant digits . so , for all practical purposes , we can assume @xmath0 to be independent of @xmath11 although it differs from @xmath107 . the values of @xmath0 obtained are very close to the naive expectation but always slightly larger . in fig.[fig : d_occ_n ] we show the double occupancy @xmath0 as a function of the density for three different temperature from @xmath111 to @xmath112 . this figure confirms again that even if we have some dependence on @xmath11 , it is quite small and the result is a fairly simple function of the density . very similar results have been obtained in ref . [ ] in the case of a 3d simple cubic lattice . we thus have a rather simple constraint that we can take into account in ipt to fix all parameters . we call this approach ipt-@xmath0 . in the next subsection , we will assess the accuracy of this approach and verify how the results are modified when the exact value of @xmath0 is used instead of the naive one . we first set @xmath0 to its naive values , i.e zero for @xmath113 and @xmath109 for @xmath10 . the results for @xmath54 and @xmath59 are shown in fig . [ fig : fermi_ipt ] as cyan stars . clearly , the value obtained for @xmath54 is in much better agreement with luttinger s theorem than in the case ipt - n@xmath114 , although it is still incorrect for densities near half - filling . the biggest improvement is that we avoid values of @xmath54 outside the band . furthermore , in the case of @xmath59 , ipt-@xmath0 is close to the ctmqc results while for ipt - n@xmath114 it is quite far@xcite from the correct result , leading in particular to an un - physical insulator over a finite range of densities for @xmath10 . as we now show , one can improve the results further by using an accurate value of @xmath0 . that value can be obtained from a number of methods , in particular ctqmc . it can be computed quite accurately and does not require a large number of matsubara frequencies . even if ctqmc is available , it may be desirable to use ipt-@xmath0 because the calculation can either be done directly in real frequency or analytically continued from matsubara frequencies using simple methods such as pad approximants@xcite , whereas with ctqmc , maximum entropy@xcite is necessary . in addition , since @xmath0 has negligible temperature dependence in strong coupling , only one value of @xmath0 may be sufficient with ipt-@xmath0 to compute other quantities for a wide range of temperatures . since @xmath0 is not completely @xmath11 independent , we use an average called @xmath115 calculated between @xmath116 and @xmath103 for the purpose of comparison with the naive approach . it is calculated from the arithmetic mean of the numerical values of @xmath117 . note that the values of @xmath117 for each @xmath43 are taken as the arithmetic mean of the last four dmft iterations . the results are shown in fig . [ fig : fermi_ipt ] as magenta lozenges . we see that the results for @xmath54 are in excellent agreement with luttinger s theorem except very close to half - filling where it deviates , but not too much . surprisingly , @xmath59 is not as accurate as that obtained from the naive estimate of @xmath0 . but if we look at the results for densities between 0.8 and 1.2 , the difference between @xmath118 and @xmath119 is small and constant and @xmath118 correctly extrapolates to zero at half - filling . a small difference in @xmath0 can have a quantitative impact on @xmath59 , without affecting qualitative trends . for example for @xmath120 , the @xmath0 given by ctqmc is @xmath121 instead of the naive @xmath122 , whereas for @xmath123 , ctqmc gives @xmath124 instead of @xmath125 . we could imagine that because these quantities are at low @xmath11 , it would be better to take a @xmath0 that is in the low temperature range . if we do this , we obtain a @xmath115 slightly larger . we then find that @xmath54 is not really affected while @xmath59 is a little bit worse than that obtained from the average @xmath0 over the larger @xmath11 range . some tuning of @xmath0 would allow us to get a best possible set of @xmath54 and @xmath59 , but that is clearly not the purpose of the exercise . finally , for @xmath52 fig . [ fig : fermi_ipt]-(b ) shows that ipt-@xmath0 is qualitatively correct while being always smaller than ctqmc . it is instructive to look at the density of states obtained from ipt with fixed @xmath0 and pad analytical continuation@xcite . we show @xmath126 and @xmath100 as typical values in fig.[fig : dos ] . we compare to the ctqmc values obtained from maximum entropy analytical continuation of @xmath127 . that green s function is an average over several converged dmft iterations . the maximum entropy implementation that was used here is somewhat crude and thus we must not really focus on the details . the ctqmc results have different errors at different scale , i.e very precise at low @xmath63 , fluctuating at intermediate @xmath63 while at large @xmath63 the results are analytical . hence , we choose the weight of the entropy term based on heuristic considerations , depending on the real - frequency range we are interested in . as was noted previously@xcite , in ipt there are states in the mott gap at finite frequency , but their weight is small compared to the states everywhere else , namely near zero frequency and in the lower and upper hubbard band . overall , ipt with fixed @xmath0 compares well with ctqmc , but , at low temperature , what really matters is the region near @xmath48 . we thus zoom on this region in fig . [ fig : dos]-(b ) . there , we see that in the vicinity of @xmath48 , when @xmath128 , we are quite close to the ctqmc values . when we use the naive @xmath0 , the quasi - particle peak is shifted a little bit to the right and so is this why the low @xmath11 results are different even if the shape and values of the peaks are similar . we also compare the results for an integrated quantity , @xmath129 , that is obtained in general by solving @xmath130 with @xmath131 the fermi function and @xmath132 the density of states . in our case , this is a byproduct of the dmft calculation . no analytical continuation is involved . in fig . [ fig : mu_t ] we show the results for three densities . in fig . [ fig : mu_t](a ) and ( b ) we note that the numerical values obtained with the different methods differ by at most about 10% . the best results are for ipt-@xmath115 since the curves are qualitatively very similar to the ctqmc ones with a derivative quantitatively quite close for all @xmath11 . the absolute difference between ipt-@xmath115 and ctqmc is almost doping and temperature independent . the derivative with respect to temperature for both ipt-@xmath3 and ipt-@xmath107 is not as good . at high enough temperature , all methods give similar results . [ fig : mu_t](c ) shows the result closer to half - filling , comparing ctqmc with ipt-@xmath115 , the best ipt method . as already discussed , ipt-@xmath3 gives un - physical results in the vicinity of half - filling . in this section we compare internal energy and specific heat in ipt-@xmath0 with ctqmc . within ctqmc , energy can be calculated quite accurately with a reasonable number of matsubara frequencies . indeed , it was shown by haule@xcite that the kinetic energy @xmath133 is proportional to the average perturbation order @xmath134 for a given set of parameters . as already discussed , the double occupancy is calculated directly by ctqmc and thus the total energy is given by @xmath135 in general , for a many - body system , the energy is given by the thermal average , in the grand - canonical ensemble , of the hamiltonian . for the hubbard model we may write @xmath136g_k(i\omega_n ) . \end{split}\ ] ] for ipt-@xmath0 , we use directly the imaginary time expression . since we generally compute green s functions only for positive imaginary time , we use the equivalent expression @xmath137 where we used that for the fcc lattice @xmath138 . once the energy is calculated , the specific heat @xmath139 is given by @xmath140 . to obtain values for all temperatures , we have considered the fixed @xmath0 as the one given by the average over @xmath141 of the ctqmc results . this is what we called ipt-@xmath115 previously . we use ipt-@xmath0 for brevity . we present the comparison in fig.[fig : energy ] for different densities . note the change in color code ( see the legend ) . in fig.[fig : energy]-(a ) we display results for densities @xmath113 while in fig.[fig : energy]-(b ) , the density is above half - filling @xmath142 . the energy scale for the latter case is shifted by a filling dependent quantity @xmath143 so that the various fillings can be displayed on the same scale . in fig.[fig : energy]-(c ) and ( d ) we zoom on @xmath144 and @xmath145 respectively without energy shift to emphasize the differences between ipt-@xmath0 and ctqmc . comparing those differences in fig.[fig : energy]-(c ) with those in fig.[fig : energy]-(d ) , we see that the further we are from half - filling , the better the agreement . in fig.[fig : cv ] we plot the specific heat as predicted by ipt-@xmath0 . once again we consider separately @xmath113 in fig.[fig : cv]-(a ) and @xmath142 in fig.[fig : cv]-(b ) . the closer we are to half - filling , the lower the temperature at which the peak that signals the appearance of the fermi liquid regime appears . despite the strong coupling , the particle - hole asymmetry is noticeable . in fig.[fig : cv]-(c ) we can compare the ipt-@xmath0 and the ctqmc results for three densities @xmath146 , @xmath147 and @xmath148 . the ctqmc results for the energy are not completely smooth especially at low @xmath11 because of statistical errors in the data . thus , if we were to calculate the specific heat @xmath139 for ctqmc , we would , for many of the values of @xmath43 , have to be very careful before calculating the derivative . here , we just performed a simple derivative on the raw ctqmc data to verify the trend . from the results for the energy , fig.[fig : energy]-(a ) we already knew that even if the change of curvature in the coherent - incoherent region exists also for ctqmc , it is much smoother than the one obtained from ipt . this is apparent indeed in @xmath139 . nevertheless , the transition temperature for the coherent - incoherent crossover given by the position of the maximum is quite similar for both methods even if , for ctqmc , its exact value is hard to really pinpoint due to the statistical errors in the raw data . we end this subsection by noting that the inadequacy of ipt-@xmath3 also shows when the energy is calculated . one finds an increase of the energy with decreasing @xmath11 at low @xmath11 , which is of course non physical since this corresponds to a negative specific heat . , as calculated in appendix [ mc_function ] . ] as calculated by ipt-@xmath0 for different values of density : @xmath82 ( black ( @xmath83 ) ) , @xmath84 ( blue ( @xmath85 ) ) , @xmath86 ( red ( @xmath87 ) ) , @xmath88 ( green ( @xmath89 ) ) , @xmath91 ( cyan ( @xmath92 ) ) , @xmath93 ( magenta ( @xmath94 ) ) , @xmath95 ( brown ( @xmath96 ) ) and @xmath97 ( kaki ( @xmath98 ) ) . the resistivity are largest close to half - filling where they exhibit low coherence temperatures . ] analytical continuation of response functions obtained with ctqmc is in general very difficult . with ipt , one can calculate response functions by first analytically continuing the self - energy with pad ? approximants and using the real - frequency expressions in terms of spectral weight . in this section , we obtain results for the electrical resistivity @xmath149 within ipt-@xmath0 to verify whether they are physically sensible at strong coupling . with ipt-@xmath3 they are not : one obtains an insulator at finite filling on the electron - doped side . since vertex corrections vanish in single - site dmft , the conductivity can be obtained from @xmath150 where @xmath151 and @xmath152 . we have restored the lattice spacing @xmath153 to exhibit the units . because the self - energy is local , we can also replace the triple sum over @xmath32 by a one dimensional integral over an energy variable . @xmath154 where the so called transport function that includes the effect of the lattice is @xmath155 . for a simple cubic lattice in any dimension , the calculation of this function can be brought in the form of a one - dimensional integral@xcite , but on the fcc lattice this is not possible . if one wishes to use the expression eq . instead of keeping the full three dimensional integrals in eq . , @xmath156 must be calculated numerically . we explain in appendix [ mc_function ] an efficient way to do this . the result for the fcc lattice is shown in fig . [ fig : x_func ] . we have tested both ways of obtaining @xmath157 , i.e. eq . and eq . and they give essentially the same answer . they can not give exactly the same number because @xmath158 is calculated for a fixed number of points and we must thus interpolate between these points when performing the integral over @xmath159 . this adds another source of numerical error not present in eq . . but , contrary to the non - interacting density of states ( fig . [ fig : dos_u0 ] ) , @xmath158 is a smooth function ( fig . [ fig : x_func ] ) and thus the process of interpolation will only induce a negligible error . when the integrals are performed in the order shown in eq . , i.e. integrate over @xmath160 first , the resulting integrand for the @xmath159 integration is smooth and @xmath158 need not be obtained with extreme accuracy . for these reasons , for the conductivity we preferred to use eq . . using eq . increases dramatically the calculation time here contrary to @xmath127 or @xmath161 discussed in the next section . at low temperature and finite doping , the conductivity is proportional to @xmath162 . thus , if @xmath54 is such that its value is outside the non - interacting band @xmath163 , @xmath164 and thus @xmath165 . in an exact implementation of single - site dmft , a null conductivity can only happen at half - filling for @xmath49 . at any finite doping , there is a quasi - particle peak and luttinger s theorem is respected ( fig.[fig : fermi_ctqmc]-(a ) ) . as ipt-@xmath3 fails with respect to luttinger s theorem ( fig.[fig : fermi_ipt]-(a ) ) in that case @xmath149 start diverging at low @xmath11 for the densities with @xmath54 outside the band while it should exhibit the @xmath166 behavior of a fermi liquid . we show in fig.[fig : resis ] the result for ipt-@xmath0 . we see that it has the correct @xmath166 behavior at low temperature . for clarity , we omitted values of densities between @xmath167 and @xmath168 . nothing very different happens there . we still have the low temperature @xmath166 behavior and , as is already obvious from the figure , the absolute values of @xmath149 obtained are larger and larger when we approach half - filling , the mott insulating state . note that close to half - filling , even though there is a tendency for the resistivity to saturate at very high temperature @xcite , this occurs at values of the resistivity much larger than the mott - ioffe - regel limit @xmath169 . this is characteristic of incoherent transport in strongly correlated systems . and @xmath167 , as calculated from ipt-@xmath0 for three different temperatures using two analytical continuation approaches for each temperature . the maximum entropy results are represented with solid lines and the pad analytical continuations with dashed lines . the broadest zero - frequency peak ( red ( @xmath170 ) ) is for the largest temperature , @xmath171 , and the narrowest one ( black ( @xmath102 ) ) for the lowest temperature , @xmath100 . the intermediate case , @xmath172 is in blue ( @xmath74 ) . the features in the optical conductivity can be identified with transitions between the fermi level and peaks in the single - particle density of states . ] we analyzed the performance of our new solver ipt-@xmath0 for fermi surface properties at @xmath173 ( @xmath59,@xmath174,@xmath175 ) , for integrated quantities like chemical potential @xmath45 , energy , specific heat , resistivity and frequency - dependent functions such as the density of states . to finish , we look at the optical conductivity . appendix . [ appen_opt_conduc ] explains how it is calculated using the susceptibility @xmath161 in bosonic matsubara frequency and analytical continuation . as a first check , which does not depend on analytical continuation , we verify the @xmath176-sum rule @xmath177 ( see for example ref . [ ] ) . in the case of nearest - neighbor hopping , this quantity can be related to the kinetic energy . for a fcc lattice one finds @xmath178 where @xmath179 is the average kinetic energy . for ctqmc the average kinetic energy is obtained from @xmath180 where , as already mentioned , @xmath134 is the average perturbation order obtained directly from the monte - carlo simulation . to calculate @xmath181 one needs the dressed green s function , or equivalently the self - energy ( @xmath182 ) . a very large number of numerical operations is necessary , as explained in appendix . [ appen_opt_conduc ] , but analytical continuation is unnecessary . for all the tests we did , the ratio @xmath183 agreed with @xmath184 up to the third digit . for example , for @xmath126 , @xmath185 and @xmath66 the ratio is 0.6668 , while for @xmath186 it is 0.6664 . analytical continuation of ctqmc is problematic , especially since we have a very wide frequency range given the large value of @xmath7 . hence we display only results obtained with analytical continuation of ipt-@xmath0 and check for consistency with what is expected from the density of states . results for density @xmath167 , interaction @xmath187 and three temperatures is shown in fig . [ fig : opt_conduc ] . solid and dashed lines correspond respectively to maximum entropy @xcite and pad analytical continuation . there is some quantitative disagreement but the qualitative information is the same . at low temperature ( @xmath185 black lines ) there is a clear peak around @xmath188 which corresponds to transitions between the lower hubbard band and the quasi - particle peak appearing in the density of state for a similar density in fig.[fig : dos ] . at larger temperature ( blue lines @xmath189 ) , the decrease of the peak near @xmath188 in @xmath190 corresponds to the disappearance of the quasi - particle peak and loss of coherence . that loss of coherence for @xmath186 is signaled by the maximum in @xmath139 observed in fig . [ fig : cv ] . at an even larger temperature , ( red lines @xmath191 ) the @xmath188 peak has disappeared since we are now in the incoherent regime . the peak for transition to the upper hubbard band around @xmath192 is always visible . in addition to being numerically inexpensive , ipt provides a method where analytically continued results can be reliably obtained directly in real frequencies or from pad approximants@xcite instead of maximum entropy methods required when quantum monte carlo is used as an impurity solver . however , for large interaction strengths in doped mott insulators , the popular condition for ipt where one imposes @xmath4 fails at low temperature for a broader regime than previously expected@xcite . as a solution , we propose that one should instead enforce the exact relation eq . between double occupancy and single particle quantities . further improvements are expected if one also enforces the third moment of the spectral weight@xcite . our new method , ipt-@xmath0 , can be used for any coupling if @xmath0 is known . double occupancy @xmath0 can be obtained quite accurately by a number of methods and is negligibly dependent on temperature for large coupling . for example , in the strong coupling regime one can use exact diagonalization of small clusters or slave bosons@xcite while , at weak coupling , methods such as two - particle - self - consistent theory ( tpsc)@xcite give good results . also , in both regimes , quantum monte - carlo methods can be used . in the very large @xmath7 limit , the naive estimate @xmath122 for @xmath14 and @xmath193 for @xmath10 leads to qualitatively correct results , except very close to half - filling . our approach has been benchmarked on the fcc lattice for a number of observables . the large - particle hole asymmetry of that lattice survives in observable quantities even for interaction strength equal to twice the bandwidth . the authors thank dominic bergeron for the maximum entropy codes that we used for analytical continuation of the ctqmc data and for discussions . this work was partially supported by nserc ( l .- f.a . and a .- m.s.t . ) , the tier i canada research chair program ( a .- m . s. t. ) , and universit de sherbrooke . a .- m.s.t is grateful to the harvard physics department for support and p. smon for hospitality during the writing of this work . partial support was also provided by the mit - harvard center for ultracold atoms . simulations were performed using a code based on the alps library @xcite on computers provided by cfi , mels , calcul qubec and compute canada . portions of the hybridization expansion impurity solver developed by p. smon were inspired by the code gracefully provided by e. gull and p. werner . as explained in the main text , for accuracy in the dmft iteration we need to perform integrals over a three dimensional brillouin zone . in this appendix we use symmetry and ideas from gaussian quadrature , adaptive methods , and statistics , to devise an accurate and fast integrator . we first obtain a quadrature of order five and then explain how we can make it adaptive . we need a normalized triple integral over a cube of length @xmath194 centered at a point @xmath195 $ ] . if we put the origin at this point , the integral takes the form @xmath196 we considered a normalized integral because the integrals we need to solve are over k - space and thus need normalization . we first show that fourteen appropriately chosen points and only two weights can give us an approximation of order five . usually when one develops a gaussian quadrature , only the order is specified and the points and weights are obtained . in 3d , this may be very cumbersome so we start with points symmetrically placed and we will show that they give a good approximation . take points on each axis and on the diagonals of the cube , @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 and @xmath200 as illustrated in fig . [ fig : cube ] . by symmetry , there are only two weights @xmath201 and @xmath202 . thus the integral is approximated by @xmath203\\ & + w_2f(\pm b , \pm b , \pm b ) . \end{split}\ ] ] to determine the numbers @xmath153 , @xmath204 , @xmath201 and @xmath202 we require that every polynomial of order five or less should be integrated exactly by this scheme . in 3d , this corresponds to many different polynomials but we have only four unknowns and apparently too many equations . this is where symmetry comes into play . first , since we integrate over a cube from @xmath205 to @xmath206 , all odd polynomials integrate to zero . also , for example , a polynomial of the form @xmath207 is equivalent to @xmath208 , or @xmath209 is equivalent to @xmath210 and @xmath211 and so on for every type of polynomials . thus we only have to consider four different polynomials i.e. @xmath212 , @xmath209 , @xmath213 and @xmath207 . + + taking @xmath214 , the integral gives one and thus we obtain the first equation @xmath215 taking @xmath216 , the integral gives @xmath217 and we obtain @xmath218 similarly , with @xmath219 , we have @xmath220 and we find @xmath221 finally , taking @xmath222 , @xmath223 and we obtain @xmath224 solving these equations , we obtain @xmath225 to make the method adaptive , we take our cube and split it in eight . if we take one of these cubes , and put the origin in its center we now have the integral over a cube from @xmath226 to @xmath227 centered at @xmath228 . we can thus use eq . but with @xmath229 and the points @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 and @xmath233 . we can do this for each of the eight cubes obtaining the new approximation for the integral @xmath234 . the process can be repeated . each of the eight cubes can be subdivided again with integrals from @xmath235 to @xmath236 . when one subdivision has converged , this part is stopped . the calculation has converged when all subdivisions have converged . the convergence criterion requires a detailed discussion . assume that we aim at a relative error @xmath237 . for an adaptive method , we need absolute error . indeed , with a simple 1d adaptive integration method where one subdivides the interval in half , if one wishes an absolute error @xmath238 one usually imposes absolute error @xmath239 on each of the two sub - intervals . to determine the absolute error in our case , we first estimate the value of the integral by performing three subdivisions , i.e. using @xmath240 cubes . let us call the resulting integral @xmath241 . then we take for the absolute error needed for the adaptive integration method @xmath242 . if we imagine launching the integrator from scratch , one would ask for @xmath243 accuracy in each of the @xmath244 sub - cubes when we do a division . this often leads to a final answer that is more accurate than desired . for heavy numerical calculations it is desirable to optimize the choice of the error in each subinterval to minimize the computation time while maintaining the final desired accuracy . in our case , we claim that it suffices to require the absolute error within each subinterval to be @xmath245 instead of @xmath246 , as we might have naively expected . indeed , if we consider each value on the sub - cube as a random variable @xmath247 and want an error @xmath238 on the original cube i.e. on the sum @xmath248 , an error @xmath245 for each sub - cube suffices is we assume that the errors on the @xmath247 s are independent and uniformly distributed ( iud ) . indeed , in that case @xmath249 and thus @xmath250 . this hypothesis of an iud is of course not rigorous , but we have extensively tested this choice for the error with many different integrands with known integrals . by taking advantage of the fact that statistical hypothesis on the errors become reasonable since the integral is high dimensional , our approach is faster . we also checked that our approach is more precise and faster than using three adaptive 1d integrators . additional speedup can be obtained by taking into account the symmetry of the integrand . , see text . ] in this section we detail how we implemented ipt-@xmath0 . ipt as an approximative solver is fast , but it needs to also be implemented in the fastest possible way . in ipt , we are solving a system of two nonlinear equations with two unknowns : @xmath46 and @xmath45 . the equations are @xmath251 and @xmath252 where @xmath43 and @xmath0 are fixed numbers for a particular set of parameters . the self - energy must be calculated using eqs . , . we show how to do this efficiently . we first start with guesses for the hybridization function @xmath253 , and the two chemical potentials @xmath46 and @xmath45 . then we calculate the impurity model loop as shown in fig . [ fig : loop_ipt ] . once the loop has been converged , we use the self - energy to calculate the lattice green s function @xmath254 . with it , the new hybridization function can be calculated @xmath255 and finally @xmath33 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 are fed back to the impurity model loop . this is repeated until global convergence is reached . it must be specified here that @xmath33 is a function of both @xmath45 and @xmath46 but in the present algorithm , once @xmath33 is fed to the impurity loop , it is considered to be independent while @xmath45 and @xmath46 are iterated until we obtain the correct @xmath43 and @xmath0 . however , once the system is close to convergence , the difference between @xmath33 in the inner loop and the correct @xmath256 becomes really small and once convergence is reached , it is indeed the same function . this is also the approach that was adopted originally in [ ] . this approach is much faster than fixing @xmath45 and @xmath46 , converging the entire dmft calculation , calculating the new @xmath43 and @xmath0 , updating @xmath45 and @xmath46 and converging again the dmft calculation until we obtain the correct @xmath43 and @xmath0 . we have tested and used the two methods and they give the same results . the fast method can , for some particular parameter set , become unstable and thus , in these cases , the long , more rigorous method , may be used . to perform this calculation , we see from fig . [ fig : loop_ipt ] that we must calculate fourier transforms from matsubara frequencies to imaginary time and back . this must be calculated numerically and we now explain how to do it efficiently . the first necessary step is to calculate @xmath257 . we can show that the function @xmath253 for a one band model with a dispersion relation @xmath258 behaves asymptotically like @xmath259 , similar to what was previously obtained@xcite . for the 3d fcc lattice with nearest - neighbor hopping @xmath260 . we can use this to define @xmath261 that gives the asymptotic high - frequency behavior of @xmath262 . we need it because the fourier transform necessary to get @xmath257 must be approximated by a finite sum and thus the function must be convergent at least as fast as @xmath263 , while @xmath264 . we thus consider the function @xmath265 instead and add the missing terms analytically . + + @xmath266 in the first sum , imaginary time has been discretized in @xmath267 bins so that @xmath268 . there is then a maximum and minimum matsubara frequency . in the second equality of eq . , fft stands for fast fourier transform . the last term , @xmath269 can be calculated analytically using complex analysis . we find , for @xmath270 , @xmath271 where @xmath272 is the fermi function and @xmath273 . hence , in terms of fft s , we obtain @xmath274 we must remember that fft does not give the value at @xmath275 . we will come back to that point later . we also need @xmath276 . this can be done using the antiperiodic property or by using a procedure similar to @xmath257 . in that case , we obtain ( again for @xmath270 ) @xmath277 where @xmath278 with these two green s function we can calculate the second order contribution to the aim self - energy that appears in ipt eq . . in this equation , we need to perform an integral . to obtain an asymptotic behavior in matsubara frequencies that decays instead of being periodic , we can not do a direct integration@xcite . the trick here is to perform a cubic spline interpolation of @xmath279 and then fourier transform that spline interpolation . to obtain the spline , one needs two conditions to solve the system of equations . in our case , it suffices to find the derivatives at @xmath280 and @xmath281 . we will show later that making the fourier transform of the spline is really accurate and introduces a minimum of numerical errors . up to now , we have only considered @xmath282 and thus what we need are the derivative at @xmath283 and at @xmath284 . if , for the moment , we consider a paramagnetic system we can write @xmath285 . the derivative is thus @xmath286 we calculate the derivative of the green s functions from their definition @xmath287 by defining @xmath288 and @xmath289 , we obtain @xmath290}{\frac{1}{\beta}}\text{fft}(f_1(i\omega_n))\\ & + { \frac{z_1 ^ 2}{z_1-z_2}}f(-z_1)\text{e}^{-z_1\tau } + { \frac{z_2 ^ 2}{z_2-z_1}}f(-z_2)\text{e}^{-z_2\tau } \\ { \frac{dg_0(-\tau)}{d\tau } } & = \text{e}^{-i\pi j[1/n - 1]}{\frac{1}{\beta}}\text{fft}(f_2(i\omega_n))\\ & + { \frac{z_1 ^ 2}{z_1-z_2}}f(z_1)\text{e}^{z_1\tau } + { \frac{z_2 ^ 2}{z_2-z_1}}f(z_2)\text{e}^{z_2\tau}. \end{split}\ ] ] with these two equations , we can get the derivatives at @xmath280 . to obtain the green s function and its derivative at @xmath281 , we use the spectral representation of the green s function to show that @xmath291 , @xmath292 and @xmath293 . we now have everything we need to calculate the derivative of eq . for @xmath280 and @xmath281 . knowing @xmath294 and @xmath295 we can calculate the coefficients of the spline . we need the matsubara - fourier transform of functions represented by that spline on the right - hand side of @xmath296 let us call @xmath297 the piecewise cubic spline for @xmath298 . the method is presented in details in appendix e of [ ] . integrating by parts , the result for fermionic frequencies is @xmath299 where ifft is the inverse fast fourier transform . this result is what we needed since it has the correct high - frequency behavior where in principle the first three terms are exact while the last one is obtained from a numerical inverse fourier transform . since the latter is the coefficient of @xmath300 , errors do not adversely affect the high - frequency behavior . even though for the dmft iterations we found that the way to obtain accurate results was to use the adaptive method described in appendix [ appen_integrate ] , we show here how to calculate @xmath301 , the non - interacting density of states and @xmath158 . the latter quantity appears in calculations of the conductivity and transport properties in general and it is in this context that we used the results presented here . both quantities have the general form @xmath302 . since our band structure is not simple , we can not perform the integral analytically . the question is thus , how do we treat the delta function in a numerical calculation ? + + a simple approach would be to replace the delta function by a lorentzian and perform the integral using an adaptive scheme . but , this approximation for the delta function gives tails at the edges of the band . a monte carlo scheme is preferable not only because the sharpness of the delta function is maintained without tails , but also because one does not need to do a triple integral for each value of @xmath159 : the complete function of @xmath159 is be obtained at once . + + we first choose for how many energy @xmath159 points we want to know the function . this number defines a number of bins , shown as dashed lines in fig . [ fig : mc_scheme ] . one then generates a random point @xmath303 , calculates @xmath258 and locates the bin where this number belongs . for example , in fig . [ fig : mc_scheme ] , the random @xmath258 belongs to the bin @xmath43 . we then add to this bin @xmath304 . this is equivalent to approximating the delta function by a rectangle of finite width . we continue this process @xmath305 times and divide , at the end , the numbers in the bins by @xmath305 . the function is thus given by the numbers in the bins , each bin corresponding to a particular energy @xmath159 . accuracy and smoothness can be improved by increasing the number of random points . for the optical conductivity , we need the current - current correlation function in bosonic matsubara frequencies . in dmft , vertex corrections vanish@xcite , hence we have @xmath306 where @xmath307 are bosonic matsubara frequencies while @xmath63 are fermionic . to compute this , we again use the convolution theorem and fft , as described for ipt in appendix [ appen_ipt ] . the above equation can be written as @xmath308 the only difference with eq . is that here we have bosonic frequencies . using again the cubic spline trick we obtain an expression similar to eq . . for @xmath309 @xmath310 while for @xmath311 @xmath312 . \end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath313 , @xmath314 , @xmath315 and @xmath316 the coefficients of the cubic spline . we also need to go from matsubara frequencies to imaginary time for @xmath317 and for @xmath318 in eq . . we proceed to obtain the analog of eq . . @xmath319 has a similar structure since the asymptotic behavior of the self - energy is @xmath320 . this time the poles are at @xmath321 where @xmath322 . + + once again , the values at @xmath323 are found using the spectral representation of @xmath324 . the expressions are @xmath325 @xmath326 @xmath327 @xmath328 we can thus calculate @xmath318 appearing in eq . and its first derivative at @xmath280 and @xmath281 to find the cubic spline interpolation . the sum over wave vectors @xmath32 requires some comments . like for the dmft calculation , we use the adaptive scheme in appendix [ appen_integrate ] . however , if we look at @xmath318 in eq . , in principle for each @xmath329 we need to perform the integral over @xmath32 independently , but the whole point of fft is to obtain all @xmath329 points at the same time . our solution is to launch the integrator for all @xmath329 at the same time and keep in memory the estimate of the integral for each @xmath329 while we refine the estimate . once the integrator converges for @xmath330 , we conclude that this @xmath32 grid is the one for all @xmath329 and stop the calculation . since we keep all values in memory , we have the function for all @xmath329 calculated for the grid in @xmath32 space appropriate for @xmath330 . we verified that by converging the calculation for other values of @xmath329 we obtain the same answer . we have also tried the other way around , where we interchange the integral over @xmath32 and the fourier transform in eq . . in this case , we converge the zero frequency and , once again , the results are essentially the same . once we have calculated @xmath331 , we need to obtain the real frequency representation since the optical conductivity is given by @xmath332 . in the case of ctqmc , we use the maxent analytical continuation scheme developed in bergeron _ [ ] for the conductivity . for ipt results we use both pad ? and maxent to find @xmath333 .

the dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) approach to the hubbard model requires a method to solve the problem of a quantum impurity in a bath of non - interacting electrons . iterated perturbation theory ( ipt ) has proven its effectiveness as a solver in many cases of interest . based on general principles and on comparisons with an essentially exact continuous - time quantum monte carlo ( ctqmc ) solver , here we show that the standard implementation of ipt fails away from half - filling when the interaction strength is much larger than the bandwidth . we propose a slight modification to the ipt algorithm that replaces one of the equations by the requirement that double occupancy calculated with ipt gives the correct value . we call this method ipt-@xmath0 . we recover the fermi liquid ground state away from half - filling . the fermi liquid parameters , density of states , chemical potential , energy and specific heat on the fcc lattice are calculated with both ipt-@xmath0 and ctqmc as benchmark examples . we also calculated the resistivity and the optical conductivity within ipt-@xmath0 . particle - hole asymmetry persists even at coupling twice the bandwidth . several algorithms that speed up the calculations are described in appendices .

astro-ph0108006

the ozpoz fibre positioner is being built by the australis consortium ( consisting of the anglo - australian observatory , the australian national university and the university of new south wales ) for the flames fibre - spectroscopy facility on the vlt ( http://www.eso.org/instruments/flames/ozpoz.html ) . ozpoz allows full access to the 25arcmin diameter ( 0.136deg@xmath0 ) field of view of the vlt nasmyth focus . it offers four field - plate positions , only two of which are used by giraffe and uves the other two positions are currently unused . up to 600 single - object fibres can be mounted on each field - plate , and the positioning robot is capable of configuring all 600 fibres in 50 minutes . as well , ozpoz handles multiple deployable fibre integral field units ( d - ifus ) , which can be as numerous as detector area allows . there are two main ways in which the capabilities of ozpoz could be fully exploited by new vlt instrumentation . one way is essentially an * upgrade * option for flames , leaving the existing feeds to giraffe and uves spectrographs in place and utilising the two free field plates to feed a new spectrograph . each of the two new field plates would hold 560 single 1 arcsec diameter fibres and also 1520 d - ifus each with 127 0.3 arcsec fibres giving a 4 arcsec diameter field . the other option is a full - fledged * second - generation instrument * for the vlt , and would use all four of ozpoz s field plates . in this case one would have more flexibility in the mix of single fibres and d - ifus . for example , one might chose to have two plates with 600 single 1 arcsec diameter fibres and two plates with 6080 d - ifus with 2 arcsec diameter fields ( @xmath1 arcsec ) ; many other arrangements ( particularly for the d - ifus ) are also possible . by the virgo consortium [ 2 ] , and the relative fields of view of various multi - object spectrographs . ] the scientific demand for multi - object spectrographs is so strong that every single 8-metre telescope ( not just every 8-metre observatory ) will have at least one : gemini north and south both have a gmos ( also flamingos - ii ) ; keck i+ii will have lris multislits , deimos and kirmos ; mmt will have hectospec ; subaru will have fmos . the four vlt unit telescopes will have flames , vimos and nirmos . the new deep , wide - field imaging surveys in the visible , uv , ir , x - ray and radio will only increase the demand for deep , wide - field , multi - object spectroscopy on 8-metre telescopes . spectroscopic follow - up of surveys carried out with vista will be particularly important to vlt users . with such a plethora of multi - object spectrographs , it is important for new instruments to have distinguishing advantages . maximus aims to provide vlt users with the maximum multiplex advantage allowed by the ozpoz fibre positioner , for both unresolved single - fibres and small , deployable integral fields . the science drivers are observations that require either : ( i ) the highest possible multiplex gain for unresolved single - object spectroscopy over the widest possible field of view , or ( ii ) high - multiplex resolved spectroscopy over a few square arcseconds with seeing - limited sampling over the widest possible field of view . an example of a galactic programme driven by a wide field and maximum multiplex is the attempt to recover the merger history of the galaxy s halo by mapping the tidal streams of the accreted stars . figure [ fig : spaghetti ] shows a simulation of these stellar streams in what has been aptly referred to as the spaghetti model for halo formation [ 1 ] . it is immediately apparent that only a densely - sampled wide - field survey of stellar velocities ( requiring a high - multiplex , wide - field spectrograph with good spectral resolution ) will be able to unravel the complex structure of the halo . similar instrumental requirements are demanded by surveys of the evolution of large - scale structure at high redshift . figure [ fig : highzlss ] shows the fields of view of multi - object spectrographs on 8-metre telescopes compared to a simulation of the large - scale structure in the galaxy distribution at a redshift of @xmath2 [ 2 ] . again , it is readily apparent that a high - multiplex , wide - field spectrograph will be essential for mapping these structures on the scales of interest . we propose two possible conceptual designs for maximus : design # 1 , shown in the top panel of figure [ fig : designs ] , has a curved fibre slit with a fish - tail design that sends the light from half the fibres to one side of the collimator and half to the other . the fibre apertures are approximately 1 arcsec . the two parallel collimated beams , each of diameter 150 mm are sent to two volume phase holographic ( vph ) gratings . two articulated cameras view the vph gratings in the littrow transmission configuration . each camera has an f/2.3 dioptic design and feeds an 8k@xmath38k ccd detector mosaic . each of the two spectrograph arms takes the light from 300 single fibres or 40 d - ifus . design # 2 , shown in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : designs ] , is generally similar , except that the two parallel collimated beams are each of diameter 300 mm and the camera has an f/1.4 catadioptic design . this allows the use of a smaller 4k@xmath34k ccd detector . each of the two spectrograph arms takes the light from 300 single fibres or 30 d - ifus . maximus extends the capabilities of giraffe by offering a wider range of spectral resolutions : @xmath430000 compared to giraffe s @xmath520000 . the lower resolutions in particular will make maximus much more useful for extragalactic observations . maximus has the same field area ( 0.136deg@xmath0 ) , but a 4.5@xmath3 higher multiplex for single fibres ( 600 vs 132 ) . maximus also offers 6080 deployable ifus each with a field of view of 2 arcsec diameter at 0.3 arcsec resolution , compared to giraffe s 15 deployable ifus each with a field of view of 3 arcsec@xmath32 arcsec at 0.6 arcsec resolution . by using volume phase holographic gratings , maximus should achieve 30% higher throughput than giraffe ( excluding detector differences ) . maximus complements the capabilities of vimos by offering 10@xmath3 the spectral resolution ( @xmath430000 vs @xmath62500 ) and 2.2@xmath3 the field area ( 0.136deg@xmath0 vs 0.062deg@xmath0 ) . maximus gives a similar multiplex to vimos at low resolution ( 600 vs 800 ) at lower surface density ( 1.0deg@xmath7 vs 3.6deg@xmath7 ) ; at high resolution it provides 3@xmath3 higher multiplex ( 600 vs 200 ) at comparable surface density ( 1.0deg@xmath7 vs 0.9deg@xmath7 ) . the ifu facilities offered are also complementary : for maximus , 6080 deployable ifus with field of view 2 arcsec diameter at 0.3 arcsec resolution vs the single large vimos ifu . a near - infrared version of maximus ( design # 3 ) can also be envisaged . this design is similar to design # 1 , using f/2.3 dioptic cameras with 4k@xmath34k hgcdte detectors that would be interchangeable with the optical cameras . the individual object apertures would again be about 1 arcsec in diameter , but in this design would consist of a 7-hex - format fibre bundle , allowing about 250 single objects or 20 deployable ifus to be accommodated in each spectrograph . this nir version of maximus would significantly extend the capabilities of nirmos . it would offer 3.2@xmath3 the spectral resolution ( @xmath8 vs @xmath9 ) , guaranteeing effective avoidance of the oh sky lines . it would also have a 2.2@xmath3 larger field area ( 0.136deg@xmath0 vs 0.062deg@xmath0 ) and 2.8@xmath3 the multiplex at moderate resolution ( 500 vs 180 ) . it would in addition offer 40 deployable ifus , each with a field of view of 2 arcsec diameter at 0.3 arcsec sampling . both maximus and nirmos would have the same long - wavelength limit of around 1.6@xmath10 m due to their non - cryogenic design .

we propose a new multi - object spectrograph for the vlt . maximus ( maximum multiplex spectrograph ) will fully exploit the multiplexing capabilities of the ozpoz fibre positioner in order to extend and complement flames and vimos in covering observational parameter space , and to meet the increasing demand for multi - object spectroscopy by eso users in the next decade .

astro-ph9801232

black hole binary systems give one of the most direct ways in which to study the physics of accretion disks . there is no surface boundary layer or strong central magnetic field to disrupt the flow , and the orbital parameters are often well studied so that the inclination , mass and distance of the system are tightly constrained . additionally , many of these systems ( the soft x ray transients , hereafter sxt ) show dramatic outbursts where the luminosity rises rapidly from a very faint quiescent state to one which is close to the eddington limit , and then declines again over a period of months , giving a clear sequence of spectra as a function of mass accretion rate . the usual pattern for such objects is for the outburst to be dominated by a soft component of temperature @xmath1 kev , with or without a ( rather steep ) power law tail , while the later stages of the decline show much harder power law spectra , extending out to 100200 kev ( see e.g. tanaka & shibazaki 1996 ) . the `` standard '' accretion disk model developed by shakura & sunyaev ( 1973 ; hereafter ss ) derives the accretion flow structure in the limit when the gravitational energy released is radiated locally in a geometrically thin disk . such models give temperatures of order 1 kev for sxt in outburst , but are unable to explain the presence of a ( hard or soft ) power law tail to high energies . either there are parts of the disk flow in a different configuration to that of ss , or there is some non disk structure such as a corona powered by magnetic reconnection ( e.g. haardt , maraschi & ghisellini 1994 ) . recently , another solution of the accretion flow was postulated to explain the hard x ray data . below a critical accretion rate , @xmath2 , a stable , hot , optically thin , geometrically thick solution can be found if radial energy transport ( advection ) is included ( see e.g. the review by narayan 1997 and the discussion by chen et al . 1995 of how all the accretion flow solutions fit together ) . in the absence of an optically thick disk the hot electrons can only cool via cyclotron / synchrotron emission ( on an internally generated magnetic field ) , bremsstrahlung , or compton scattering of the resultant spectra of these two processes . the lack of strong flux of soft photons in these models means that the x ray spectra are typically hard . such flows were proposed to explain the hard and very faint x ray spectra seen from black holes candidates ( bhc ) in quiescence ( narayan , mcclintock & yi 1996 ) . these models were then extended by esin , mcclintock & narayan ( 1997 ; hereafter emn ) to cover the whole range of luminosity seen in sxt . emn assume that accretion takes place via an ss disk for the incoming material beyond some ( large ) truncation radius of @xmath3 ( where @xmath4 ) , but that interior to this the flow _ always _ jumps to the advective solution if the latter exists . during the outburst the mass accretion rate goes above that at which an advective flow can be sustained , so they assume that the disk adopts the ss solution , forming a cool flow down to @xmath5 and hence producing soft spectra . during the decline the mass accretion rate falls below @xmath6 , producing an intermediate stage as the ss disk retreats . the transition radius between the advective and ss flow progressively increases , and the low state proper is defined to be where the ss disk is again restricted to beyond @xmath7 , although the spectrum is indistinguishable from this for transition radii @xmath8 . this change from an ss to advective disk solution takes place over a very small range in total luminosity , and is postulated to explain the soft hard transition seen in the sxt . emn tested their model on data of nova muscae 1991 , and found that it could indeed reproduce the overall spectral evolution of the source . this model predicts large changes in the accretion geometry as a function of mass accretion rate ( see figure 1 of emn ) which can be observationally tested by spectral studies of x ray reprocessing . x rays interact with optically thick material to produce a reflected continuum due to compton scattering and the iron @xmath9 line due to fluorescence / recombination . their normalizations determine the solid angle of the reprocessor as seen from the x ray source while the shape of the reflected continuum below 10 kev , the line energy and its equivalent width are functions of ionization state of the reprocessor . if the reflecting material is indeed a disk extending close to the black hole then the reprocessed spectrum is strongly smeared by the combination of high orbital velocities and strong gravity ( fabian et al . 1989 ; laor 1991 ; ross , fabian & brandt 1996 ) . in the emn model it is clear that as the source changes from high to low state then the amount of reflection should decrease , together with the amount of relativistic smearing , as the optically thick reflecting disk moves outwards . in this letter we present results of spectral analysis of data of soft x ray transient gs 1124 - 68 ( nova muscae 1991 ) with the emphasis on detailed modeling of the effects of x ray reprocessing . our results confirm the prediction of emn that the covering fraction of the reprocessing matter decreases as the source luminosity declines . however , the normalization of the reflected component and the amount of relativistic smearing are both significantly larger than the model predictions , indicating that the ss disk retreats outwards more slowly than predicted during the intermediate and low states . the hard ( low state ) spectra seen in the persistent bhc and sxt during decline are incompatible with the emn scenario of an optically thin accretion flow extending out to @xmath10 , and instead require that there is a transition from an optically thin to optically thick structure at @xmath0 . observations of nova muscae 1991 and various aspects of data modeling were described in detail by ebisawa et al . we re extracted the data from the archive in leicester and subtracted the background using a modified version ( ycki , done & smith 1997 ) of standard procedures ( hayashida et al . 1989 ) . for our analysis we have selected six data sets : january 11th , may 18th , june 13th , june 21st , july 23rd , and september 3rd . these are the only datasets in which the hard tail is sufficiently developed to search for reflection , and where the instrument is accurately pointed ( within @xmath11 ) at the source . our basic model of the x ray spectrum is a sum of a primary power law and the reprocessed component which is a sum of the compton reflected continuum and the iron @xmath9 line near @xmath12kev . the reflected continuum is computed using the angle dependent green functions of magdziarz & zdziarski ( 1995 ) , with the possibility of partial ionization ( parameterised by ionization parameter , @xmath13 ) as in done et al . ( 1992 ) , all as implemented in the `` pexriv '' model in xspec version 9.01 ( arnaud 1996 ) . this is a very basic ionization code , balancing the photo ionization from the power law irradiation with radiative recombination at a given fixed temperature , which we set to @xmath14 k. the self consistent iron @xmath9 line for this ionization state , computed using the monte carlo code described in ycki & czerny ( 1994 ) , is then added to the continuum . the relativistic effects expected from an accretion disk around a ( non rotating ) black hole are simulated by convolving this total ( line plus continuum ) spectrum with the xspec `` diskline '' model . this is parameterised by the inner and outer radius of the disk , @xmath15 and @xmath16 , its inclination and the irradiation emissivity , @xmath17 . the latter three are fixed at @xmath18 , @xmath19 ( orosz et al . 1996 ) and @xmath20 , respectively , while we fit for @xmath15 , the ionization state @xmath21 , and the amplitude of the reprocessed component expressed as a solid angle subtended by the reprocessor from the x ray source , @xmath22 , normalized to @xmath23 , i.e. @xmath24 ( see also ycki et al . 1997 ) . our code also allows the ionization to vary as a function of radius , @xmath25 , by splitting the disk into radial rings of constant ionization state . the relative covering fraction of each ring is determined by the emissivity and the relativistic corrections are given by the extent of each ring . during its decline phase nova muscae 1991 went through a sequence of distinct `` states '' ( ebisawa et al . 1994 ; emn ) . during and soon after the outburst the source was in the very high state ( vhs ; january 11th data ) , with both a strong soft component and a power law tail . two and a half months later that changed into high state ( hs ) , where the soft component dominates , and further one and a half months later , in mid - may , the intermediate state ( is ) began in which the soft component dramatically decreases while the power law tail hardens and increases in intensity . this is then followed two months later by the low state ( ls ; july 23rd and september 3rd data sets ) , where the hard power law dominates the luminosity output . an important point for the january ( vhs ) and may ( hs / is ) data is the description of the soft thermal component since it dominates the spectrum below @xmath26kev . we model this by optically thick comptonization of soft seed photons ( titarchuk 1994 ; as implemented in the `` comptt '' model in xspec ) , since simple blackbody and disk blackbody models ( with or without relativistic corrections ) can not give an adequate description of the observed spectral shape ( see also gierliski et al . 1997b ) . the results for the june and july data are not sensitive to a choice of the soft component so here we use the multi - temperature disk blackbody model ( mitsuda et al . 1984 ) . first , we have checked that the spectral features seen in the data at 58 kev , which we will attribute to x ray reprocessing , can not be accounted for by the effects of comptonization , even if a broad distribution of soft seed photons is assumed . to this end we have modelled the may 18th data using `` comptt '' for the soft component and we convolved it with the relativistic green functions of titarchuk ( 1994 ) to obtain the model for the hard component . such a two component model fails to account for the data ( @xmath27 ) and the residuals clearly indicate the presence of the reprocessed component . the situation is not improved if the soft component is modeled using the green functions of sunyaev & titarchuk ( 1980 ) convolved with a blackbody . we first model the reprocessed component assuming its uniform ionization ( @xmath28 ; table [ tab : inter ] ) . reflection is significantly detected in all but the september 3rd dataset , where the signal to noise is insufficient to obtain interesting constraints . even in the vhs , where the soft component is very strong , reflection is significantly detected and its amount is quite well determined . it is strongly ionized and relativistically smeared ( see gierliski et al . 1997b for a similar result for the soft state of cyg x1 ) . at the beginning of the is ( may 18th data set ) the reflector is still highly ionized , but as the importance of the soft component declines , the ionization state also drops ( to @xmath29 where iron is predominantly ionized only to fe vii ix ) , and the power law hardens by @xmath30 without a significant change in its total flux . relativistic smearing of the reflection spectrum is significant in all the datasets except for july 23rd and september 3rd . fit spectra for the may 18th and june 13th data sets are shown in figure [ fig : spectra ] . figure [ fig : cont ] shows the derived confidence contours for @xmath15 and @xmath31 during the is and ls . clearly the data require that the solid angle decreases as the source declines , and while there is no statistical _ requirement _ that the relativistic smearing decreases , the data are consistent with a monotonic increase in @xmath15 . to see how these results depend on any ionization structure , we repeated the fits for @xmath32 and @xmath33 , as expected from a gas and radiation pressure dominated ss disk , respectively ( with the assumed @xmath34 ) . only the contours for the may 18th dataset change , since this is the only one shown which has strong ionization . we include these results in figure [ fig : cont ] by the dashed and dotted lines for the gas and radiation pressure dominated cases , respectively . both allow much larger reflected fractions , since there is now a contribution from very highly ionized material at the inner disk edge which gives negligible spectral features . while this material is also strongly affected by the relativistic smearing , the lack of features means that there are no observational signatures until further out in the disk where the ionization drops , so allowing smaller values of @xmath15 . we have also checked that a different model for the soft component in the may data does not change the results concering the reprocessed component . using the solution of sunyaev & titarchuk ( 1980 ) convolved with a blackbody spectrum to model the soft component we re - derived the confidence contours in the @xmath31 vs. @xmath15 plane . the best fit and minimum values of @xmath31 and @xmath15 agree to within 10% with previous results ( solid curve in fig . [ fig : cont ] ) while the maximum values are larger by 20% when the sunyaev & titarchuk solution is used . we can use the results of our spectral fitting to derive the geometry , and then compare this with that proposed by emn in their scenario based on advective disk . our derived limits on the inner radius of the accretion disk from the amount of relativistic smearing are dependent on the illumination emissivity , for which we assumed @xmath34 . this should be a good approximation for a central quasi spherical source even if there is some overlap between the cold disk and hot source ( poutanen , krolik & ryde 1997 ) . thus it seems likely that the radii derived in the previous section are reasonable unless the disk flares substantially , and/or there are significant non local effects in the energy generation and/or relativistic corrections are important . in the vhs , hs and beginning of the is , where the spectrum contains a strong soft component , the emn model predicts that the disk extends down to the last stable orbit at @xmath35 . from the fits to the may ( hs / is ) data we see that indeed the reflector subtends a large solid angle with respect to the hard x ray source and the spectrum is strongly relativistically smeared , although the data prefer an inner radius of @xmath36 , and are formally inconsistent with @xmath37 . relativistic corrections to the illumination emissivity will be important at these small radii , although the results of reynolds & begelman ( 1997 ) suggest that this should lead to a steeper dependence , rather than the flatter one needed for the data to be consistent with @xmath38 . a more likely possibility to retrieve a disk down to the last stable orbit is that the strong ionization of the reflector seen in this state is not adequately modeled ( the ionization balance derived from done et al.1992 is rather approximate ) , and that this has distorted the fit . this strong ionization of the upper layers of the disk probably results from the intense gravitational energy release within the ss flow , and it may lead to comptonization of the emerging soft photons , producing the observed spectral shape of the thermal emission ( ross & fabian 1993 ; gierliski et al . 1997b ) . however , the next stage of evolution in the is does not seem to be properly described by the emn model . since the hard x ray flux was roughly constant between may and june the observed dramatic decrease of the ionization , from @xmath39 to @xmath40 , must be related to the disappearance of the soft component . consequently , the power law becomes harder , since the availability of seed photons for compton cooling is dramatically reduced . however , the dramatic spectral change was _ not _ accompanied by any significant change of @xmath15 , although the best fit value of @xmath31 decreases by @xmath41 . this could be produced by a small increase in @xmath15 , from @xmath42 to @xmath36 , depending on the emissivity , which is within the error contours of figure [ fig : cont ] . it is clearly incompatible with the prediction of emn that @xmath15 should be @xmath43 for the june data since this would produce no significant relativistic smearing of the iron spectral features and too small amplitude of reflection . similarly , the properties of the reprocessed component in the july data ( ls ) are incompatible with the emn computations . while the effect of smearing constrains @xmath15 to be @xmath44 , the amplitude of reflection , @xmath45 , requires @xmath15 to be @xmath46 for the emn geometry ( obtained using simple monte carlo code for photons propagation without further interactions after their generation ) . with @xmath47 , as postulated by emn , the amplitude @xmath31 would be negligible . the values of @xmath31 inferred by us are also in agreement with those for cyg x-1 and gx 339 - 4 in low states , from both simple fits to the data and detailed modeling of the continuum emission ( ueda , ebisawa & done 1994 ; ebisawa et al . 1996 ; gierliski et al . 1997a ; dove et al . 1997 ; poutanen et al . the amplitude @xmath48 seems thus to be a typical value for bhc in the low state , and shows that concept of accretion occurring in a optically thin flow from very large radii ( @xmath10 ) can not be sustained . thus , the observed transition from high ( soft ) to low ( hard ) state does seem to involve a retreat of the optically thick material , as in the emn model . however , the inner disk radius is much smaller than the values postulated by emn in their intermediate and low states . since their treatment of the transition radius marking the edge of the advective flow and the standard ss disk is assumed rather than calculated then this may not be an insurmountable problem . the major spectral change in their model occurs as @xmath15 changes from @xmath49 to @xmath50 , which corresponds well to the observed constraints during the high / low state transition , suggesting that it is indeed associated with the innermost regions of the accretion flow becoming optically thin . however , the sudden switching of _ all _ the accretion flow into an optically thin state over a very small range in @xmath51 is a major facet of their model , and is clearly inconsistent with the observed behavior of bhc in general and nova muscae in particular . this research made use of data obtained from the leicester database and archive service at the department of physics and astronomy , leicester university . acknowledges support from a pparc advanced fellowship . arnaud , k. a. 1996 , in astronomical data analysis software and systems v , eds . jacoby g. and barnes j. , asp conf . series volume 101 , p. 17 chen , x. , abramowicz , m. a. , lasota , j .- p . , narayan , r. , & yi , i. 1995 , , 443 , l61 done , c. , mulchaey , j. s. , mushotzky , r. f. , & arnaud , k. a. 1992 , , 395 , 275 dove , j. b. , wilms , j. , maisack , m. , & begelman , m. c. 1997 , , 487 , 759 ebisawa , k. et al . 1994 , , 46 , 375 ebisawa , k. , ueda , y. , inoue , h. , tanaka , y. , & white , n. e. 1996 , , 467 , 419 esin , a. a. , mcclintock , j. e. , & narayan , r. 1997 , , 489 , 865 fabian , a. c. , rees , m. j. , stella , l. , & white , n. e. 1989 , , 238 , 729 gierliski , m. , zdziarski , a. a. , done , c. , johnson , w. n. , ebisawa , k. , ueda , y. , & phlips , f. 1997a , , 288 , 958 gierliski , m. , zdziarski , a. a. , dotani , t. , ebisawa , k. , jahoda , k. , & johnson 1997b , in proceedings of 4th compton symposium , eds . c. d. dermer and j. d. kurfess , aip , in press haardt , f. , maraschi , l. , & ghisellini , g. 1994 , , 432 , l95 hayashida , k. , et al . 1989 , , 41 , 373 laor , a. , 1991 , , 376 , 90 magdziarz , p. , & zdziarski , a. a. 1995 , , 273 , 837 mitsuda , k. , et al . 1984 , , 36 , 741 narayan , r. 1997 , in proc . iau colloq . 163 on accretion phenomena & related outflows , asp conf . series , eds . d. t. wickramasinghe et al . , 75 narayan , r. , mcclintock , j. e. , & yi . , i. 1996 , , 457 , 821 orosz , j. a. , bailyn , c. d. , mcclintock , j. e. , & remillard , r. a. 1996 , , 468 , 380 poutanen , j. , krolik , j. h. , & ryde , f. 1997 , , 292 , 21 reynolds , c. , & begelman , m. c. 1997 , , 488 , 109 ross , r. r. , & fabian , a. c. 1993 , , 261 , 74 ross , r. r. , fabian , a. c. , & brandt , w. n. 1996 , , 278 , 1082 shakura , n. i. , & sunyaev , r. a. 1973 , , 24 , 337 sunyaev , r. a. & titarchuk , l. 1980 , , 86 , 121 tanaka , y. , & shibazaki , n. 1996 , , 34 , 607 titarchuk , l. 1994 , , 434 , 570 ueda , y. , ebisawa , k. , & done c. 1994 , , 46 , 107 ycki , p. t. , & czerny , b. 1994 , , 266 , 653 ycki , p. t. , done , c. , & smith , d. a. 1997 , , 488 , l113 lccccc jan 11 , vhs & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & 26.1/31 ( 40 ) may 18 , hs / is & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 ( 31 ) june 13 , is & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 ( 31 ) june 21 , is & @xmath66 & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 & @xmath70 ( 31 ) july 23 , ls & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 ( 31 ) sept 3 , ls & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & 0(f ) & & 26.9/26 ( 31 )

we identify the x ray reflected component in the spectra of nova muscae 1991 , a black hole transient system used as the prototype for the recent model of esin , mcclintock & narayan ( 1997 ) based on advection dominated disk solutions . we see that the reflected spectrum is generally significantly relativistically smeared , and use this , together with the amplitude of reflection , to track the innermost extent of the accretion disk . the optically thick disk switches from being highly ionized to nearly neutral during the transition from high to low state , and the inner radius of the disk moves outwards during the low state decline . qualitatively , this overall trend is compatible with esin et al.s model , but quantitatively , the retreat of the inner disk during the high to low state transition is much slower than predicted . the hard ( low state ) spectra are not produced solely by an optically thin accretion flow : optically thick material within @xmath0 is generally present .

1106.0857

consider a finite - parameter analytic family of analytic plane vector fields @xmath4 such that @xmath0 has a limit periodic set @xmath5 . the cyclicity of @xmath5 is , roughly speaking , the maximal number of limit cycles of @xmath1 which tend to @xmath5 as @xmath6 . the roussarie s finite cyclicity conjecture claims that _ every limit periodic set occurring in an analytic finite - parameter family of plane analytic vector fields , has a finite cyclicity _ if true , the conjecture would imply the finitness of the maximal number @xmath7 of the limit cycles , which a plane polynomial vector field of degree @xmath8 can have . therefore it plays a fundamental role in all questions related to the second part of the 16th hilbert problem and its ramifications . recall that a polycycle of the vector field @xmath0 is a topological polygon composed of separatrices and singular points . a @xmath9-saddle cycle of @xmath0 ( or a hyperbolic @xmath9-graphic ) denoted @xmath10 , is a polycycle composed of @xmath9 distinct saddle - type singular points @xmath11 , @xmath12 and separatrices ( heteroclinic orbits ) connecting @xmath13 to @xmath14 as on fig . [ dessin9 ] . @xmath9-saddle cycles , period orbits and weak foci or centers are the simplest limit periodic sets . the finite cyclicity of period orbits and weak foci is well known and follows from the gabrielov theorem @xcite . the finite cyclicity of one - saddle loops is due to roussarie @xcite . _ the purpose of the present paper is to prove the finite cyclicity of a two - saddle cycle , under finite - parameter analytic deformation _ , see theorem [ mainth ] . several special cases of this result were earlier proved , under different genericity assumptionss either on @xmath0 or on the family @xmath1 , by cherkas , mourtada , el morsalani , dumortier , roussarie , rousseau , jebrane , oadek , li , caubergh , luca and others @xcite , see also @xcite for survey of the results and references up to 1996 . the finite cyclicity of a k - saddle cycle ( any k ) , under finite - parameter analytic deformation was recently announced by mourtada @xcite . for _ generic families _ of vector fields the analitycity can be relaxed . as it is shown by ilyashenko and yakovenko @xcite , kaloshin @xcite _ any nontrivial elementary polycycle occurring in a generic @xmath9 - parameter family of @xmath15 vector fields has finite cyclicity_. in contrast to the aforementioned papers we shall not use the asymptotic expansions of the corresponding dulac maps . instead of this , we evaluate the number of the limit cycles near @xmath16 in a complex domain , by making use of a suitable version of the argument principle . this approach was initiated by the author in @xcite , where we studied cyclicity of hamiltonian two - loops . as it is well known , the limit cycles of planar systems close to hamiltonian are closely related to the zeros of associated abelian integrals depending on a parameter ( the so called weakened 16th hilbert problem ( * ? ? ? * arnold , p.313 ) ) . zeros of complete elliptic integrals were successfully studied by topological arguments in a complex domain ( the argument principle ) after the pioneering work by g. s. petrov @xcite , see also oadek @xcite for a description of the method . it has been used in a more general context in several papers , e.g. @xcite , and in @xcite the idea has been used to replace abelian integrals by the true poincar return map . in the present paper we shall find a relation between the fixed points of the poincar first return map and the fixed points of holonomies of the separatrices of the saddle points , which correspond to complex limit cycles . to count such fixed points is a question on the zeros of families of _ analytic functions _ which is easily solved . the main technical tool is lemma [ mainlemma ] in which we show that the connected components of the zero locus of the imaginary part of a dulac map are smooth semianalytic curves . this allows to estimate the variation of the argument of the displacement map along the border of an appropriate complex domain , and finally to apply the argument principle in order to evaluate its zeros in the domain . note that previously the relation between the monodromy and the dulac map was used by roussarie to compute the bautin ideal associated to the dulac map @xcite . this combined with @xcite also implies the finite cyclicity of one - saddle cycles . the paper is organized as follows . in section [ dulacsection ] we provide the necessary technical background , and prove the main technical lemma [ mainlemma ] . in section [ onesaddle ] , we give a new self - contained proof of roussarie s theorem about the finite cyclicity of one - saddle cycles . the origin of our method is then explained in section [ petrovtrick ] where we give a brief account of a local version of the so called `` petrov trick '' . the same method is then easily adapted in section [ mainsection ] to show that the cyclicity of @xmath16 is finite . consider an analytic family of plane real analytic foliations @xmath17 , @xmath18 , having a non - degenerate isolated saddle point . an appropriate translation analytically depending on @xmath3 will place the saddle point at the origin . the foliation @xmath17 has two analytic separatrices , transversally intersecting at the saddle point , and depending analytically on @xmath3 @xcite . therefore a further real bi - analitic change of the variables @xmath19,analytically depending on @xmath3 , will identify them to the axes @xmath20 and @xmath21 as on fig.[fig1a ] , so @xmath22 where the dots replace higher order terms in @xmath19 with coefficients depending on @xmath3 . the number @xmath23 is the hyperbolic ratio of the saddle point . from now on we shall suppose that the foliation ( [ foliation ] ) is analytic and depends analytically in @xmath3 in a neighborhood of the origin in @xmath24 . for @xmath25 sufficiently small , let @xmath26 , @xmath27 be open complex discs centered at @xmath28 and @xmath29 , parameterized by @xmath30 and @xmath31 respectively . the ( real ) dulac map is the germ of analytic map at @xmath32 @xmath33 defined as follows : if @xmath34 then @xmath35 is the intersection with @xmath36 of the orbit @xmath37 of ( [ foliation ] ) , passing through @xmath30 , see [ fig1a ] ( ii ) . this geometric definition of @xmath38 allows to control to a certain extent its analytic continuation in a complex domain . the dulac map allows an analytic continuation on some open subset of the universal covering space @xmath39 of @xmath40 , depending on @xmath3 . let us parameterize @xmath39 by polar coordinates @xmath41 , @xmath42 . the following result is well known ( e.g. ( * ? ? ? * appendix a ) ) [ continuation ] there exists @xmath43 and a continuous function @xmath44 such that the dulac map allows an analytic continuation in the domain @xmath45 the geometric content of theorem [ continuation ] is as follows . let @xmath46 be a continuous family of paths contained in the leaves of @xmath17 , and connecting @xmath47 to @xmath48 . for @xmath49 we suppose that @xmath50 is the real orbit of @xmath17 contained in the first quadrant @xmath51 , and connecting @xmath52 to @xmath48 , see fig.[fig1a ] ( ii ) . the above theorem claims that this family of orbits allows an extension to a continuous family of paths @xmath46 , contained in the leaves of @xmath17 , and connecting @xmath53 to @xmath54 . the family is defined for all @xmath55 which belong to the domain ( [ domain ] ) . each path starts at @xmath52 and terminates at a unique point on @xmath56 , denoted @xmath57 . although the paths @xmath46 are not unique , their relative homotopy classes are uniquely defined . to the axes @xmath58 parameterized by @xmath31 and @xmath30 , we associate holonomy maps @xmath59 defined by two closed paths contained in the axes @xmath60 and @xmath61 and based at @xmath28 , @xmath29 respectively . we shall make the convention , that each closed path makes one turn around the origin of the axe in which it is contained , in a positive direction ( recall that the axes are parameterized by @xmath31 and @xmath30 respectively ) . it is easily seen that in the case of a linear foliation of the form @xmath62 we have @xmath63 in the general case of a nonlinear foliation of the form ( [ foliation ] ) the dulac map @xmath38 is only asymptotic to @xmath64 , while the holonomy maps are analytic in @xmath65 and @xmath66 the dulac map @xmath38 is a transcendental multi - valued map . for @xmath67 let @xmath68 be the result of the analytic continuation of @xmath38 along an arc of radius @xmath30 and angle @xmath69 . similarly , for @xmath70 let @xmath71 be the result of the analytic continuation of @xmath38 along an arc of radius @xmath31 and angle @xmath69 . [ monodromy ] for every sufficiently small @xmath67 , @xmath70 , @xmath72 holds @xmath73 * proof . * consider , instead of @xmath38 the underlying path @xmath74 . the loop @xmath75 has the same origin as @xmath76 so they can be composed and the resulting loop @xmath77 starts at @xmath78 and terminates at @xmath79 . in the special linear case ( [ linear ] ) with @xmath80 the foliation is a fibration , the paths @xmath81 represent relative cycles in the fibers of @xmath82 , and the path @xmath77 is closed and represents a vanishing cycle . the claim of lemma [ monodromy ] is then the classical picard - lefschetz formula . in the general case the result follows `` by deformation '' . indeed , in the linear case ( [ linear ] ) with @xmath80 the family of closed paths @xmath83 is defined for all sufficiently small @xmath31 , and @xmath84 is a closed path which makes one turn around the origin in the axe @xmath21 in a positive direction . note that the paths @xmath85 are bounded away from the origin in @xmath86 . it follows that @xmath87 defines the holonomy @xmath88 of the separatrix @xmath21 , and this property holds true also for every sufficiently small deformation of ( [ linear ] ) . the homothety @xmath89 transforms ( [ foliation ] ) to a small deformation of ( [ linear ] ) which completes the proof of the first identity ( but see also @xcite ) . the second identity in lemma [ monodromy ] is proved in a similar way . @xmath90 consider the universal covering @xmath91 and the zero locus @xmath92 of the imaginary part of the dulac map @xmath38 corresponding to the domain ( [ domain ] ) @xmath93 in the case of a linear foliation ( [ linear ] ) the zero locus is therefore a union of half - lines : @xmath94 to describe @xmath95 in the case of a general foliation of the form ( [ foliation ] ) , with hyperbolic ratio @xmath96 , consider the germs of real analytic sets at the origin in @xmath97 @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the holonomy map associated to the separatrix @xmath20 . [ mainlemma ] the zero locus @xmath100 of the imaginary part of the dulac map in the domain ( [ domain ] ) is a union of connected components @xmath101 , indexed by @xmath102 . * each set @xmath103 , ( [ clk ] ) , is a germ of a real analytic curve of @xmath104 , which is smooth at the origin and tangent to the line @xmath105 there . * each connected component @xmath101 is projected on the plane @xmath106 under the map @xmath107 ( [ universal ] ) to the connected component of @xmath108 tangent to the half - line ( [ line ] ) , @xmath109 , at the origin . for a general bi - holomorphic map @xmath99 , vanishing at the origin , the set @xmath110 coincides with the origin itself . the above lemma shows , however , that for the monodromy map @xmath99 of a saddle point of a real - analytic plane vector field , the set @xmath103 , ( [ clk ] ) , is a germ of a real analytic curve of @xmath104 , which is smooth at the origin . the position of the connected components of @xmath108 tangent to the half - lines ( [ line ] ) , @xmath109 ( [ line ] ) , @xmath109 is shown on fig . [ dessin1 ] . the above lemma is the main technical result of the present paper . the analyticity of the zero locus @xmath95 is responsible for the algebraic - like behavior of the dulac map . + * proof of lemma [ mainlemma ] * let @xmath111 and suppose that for some @xmath112 , @xmath113 . as the dulac map is real along @xmath114 , then @xmath115 is complex conjugate to @xmath116 and hence @xmath117 if the point @xmath118 is seen as the inverse image of @xmath119 with respect to the dulac map @xmath120 , then the point @xmath121 is the result of the analytic continuation of the map @xmath120 along a suitable closed path of @xmath48 , starting and terminating at @xmath122 . if we put @xmath123 then @xmath124 are two values of the multivalued map @xmath125 and hence , by lemma [ monodromy ] , they differ by a power of the monodromy @xmath99 @xmath126 or equivalently @xmath127 clearly every such relation will correspond to a connected component @xmath101 of @xmath95 . as @xmath101 is an analytic set of real dimension one , then @xmath103 is an analytic set of dimension one too . it can be defined therefore by each of the following equivalent relations @xmath128= { \operatorname{re } } ( \bar{z } ) \}\ ] ] or @xmath129= { \operatorname{im}}(\bar{z } ) \}.\ ] ] as @xmath130 = -1 $ ] , then the linear part of the complex - analytic function @xmath131 can not be identically zero , and therefore @xmath132 is a real analytic curve , smooth at the origin . it follows from ( [ nonlinear ] ) that the projection of @xmath101 under @xmath107 on the plane @xmath106 is tangent to the half - line ( [ line ] ) , @xmath109 at the origin . @xmath90 let @xmath133 be a relatively compact domain , with piece - wise smooth boundary , and @xmath134 an analytic function which allows a continuation to the closure @xmath135 . denote by @xmath136 the number of the zeros of @xmath137 in @xmath138 , counted with multiplicity . if we assume that @xmath137 does not vanish along the border @xmath139 , then the increment of the argument @xmath140 of @xmath137 along @xmath141 oriented counter - clockwise is well defined . @xmath140 equals the winding number of the curve @xmath142 about the origin and the classical argument principle states that @xmath143 more generally , if @xmath137 has zeros on @xmath139 , isolated or not , the variation of the argument @xmath140 might be not well defined . we say that @xmath144 is a regular zero of @xmath137 if @xmath145 , and @xmath137 allows an analytic continuation in a neighborhood of @xmath52 in @xmath146 . if we assume that @xmath137 has only regular zeros in @xmath135 , then @xmath140 is well defined as a sum of the increments of the argument of @xmath147 between consecutive zeros of @xmath137 . indeed , the increments are finite , because the border @xmath148 is piece - wise smooth . the argument principle can be reformulated as follows [ argument ] let @xmath149 be a relatively compact domain with piece - wise smooth boundary . if @xmath150 is a continuous function , analytic in @xmath151 , and having only regular zeros in @xmath135 , then @xmath152 * proof . * there always exists a polynomial @xmath153 , such that @xmath154 has no zeros in @xmath135 , so we need to verify ( [ argument2 ] ) for polynomials only . the set @xmath151 is open , connected and oriented , with piece - wise smooth boundary , which therefore has no self - intersections and has an induced orientation . the inequality @xmath155 allows to `` remove '' the zeros along @xmath139 and hence formula ( [ argument1 ] ) implies ( [ argument2 ] ) . @xmath90 in the present paper the first inequality in ( [ argument2 ] ) will be used to bound the number of the zeros @xmath156 . for this we shall need estimates on the variation of the argument @xmath157 along any compact segment @xmath158 of a curve . more precisely , let @xmath159 be a compact segment of a smooth real analytic curve . let @xmath160 be an open set containing @xmath158 and @xmath161 , @xmath162 , be a germ of a family of complex - analytic functions in @xmath163 at @xmath164 . for every fixed @xmath3 such that the function @xmath165 is not identically zero , the variation of its argument @xmath166 is well defined . [ variation ] let @xmath158 be a compact segment of a real analytic curve and let @xmath167 be a family of functions analytic in a neighborhood of @xmath158 , and depending analytically in @xmath3 . there exists @xmath43 , such that @xmath168 the above result follows from the following theorem due to gabrielov @xcite let @xmath169 be real analytic varieties and consider the canonical projection @xmath170 . for every relatively compact semianalytic set @xmath171 , the number of the connected components of the pre - images @xmath172 is bounded from above uniformly over @xmath173 . * proof of theorem [ variation ] . * the number of the isolated zeros of @xmath165 along @xmath158 counted with multiplicity is uniformly bounded in @xmath3 at @xmath164 ( franoise - yomdin theorem @xcite ) . on an interval between two zeros of @xmath174 the variation of the argument divided by @xmath175 is bounded by the number of the zeros of the imaginary part of @xmath165 divided by two , plus the sum of the multiplicities of the zeros of @xmath165 at the end of the interval . the imaginary part of @xmath165 is a real analytic function in @xmath176 and the gabrielov theorem implies that the number of the connected components of @xmath177 is uniformly bounded in @xmath3 at @xmath164.@xmath90 let @xmath1 , @xmath2 be a germ of an analytic family of analytic plane vector fields , such that @xmath0 has a one - saddle cycle ( homoclinic saddle loop ) @xmath178 . the first - return map associated to @xmath178 is a composition of a dulac map @xmath179 and a transport map @xmath180 , see fig . [ dessin2 ] . we assume that the dulac map is in a normal form as in section [ scontinuation ] . the limit cycles of @xmath1 near @xmath178 correspond to the zeros of the displacement map @xmath181 near @xmath182 . an appropriate choice of the local coordinates on the croos - sections @xmath56 and @xmath48 brings the transport map to the form @xmath183 . alternatively , we could choose simply @xmath184 ( without supposing that the dulac map is in the normal form of section [ scontinuation ] ) . we shall bound the number of the zeros of @xmath165 in the domain @xmath185 delimited by the circle @xmath186 , and the connected components @xmath187 and @xmath188 of the zero locus of the imaginary part of the dulac map , as it is shown on fig . [ dessin4 ] . we shall suppose that @xmath189 is so small , that @xmath174 is analytic in @xmath190 for all @xmath191 , such that @xmath192 ( theorem [ continuation ] ) and it is analytic even on the closure of @xmath190 except of course at @xmath182 , where @xmath174 is only continuous . indeed , @xmath193 while @xmath180 is holomorphic at @xmath182 , so @xmath194 where @xmath195 is analytic and @xmath196 . if the family of functions @xmath165 is sufficiently general , then @xmath197 , and in the case when @xmath198 we may replace @xmath165 by the new family @xmath199 , @xmath200 , for which the limit at @xmath182 is the parameter @xmath201 . after this preparation , we may prove the finite cyclicity of the homoclinic loop @xmath178 . for this we apply proposition [ argument ] ( the argument principle ) to the family of functions @xmath165 in the domain @xmath190 . in the course of the computation , it will be supposed that @xmath189 is sufficiently small , @xmath202 is sufficiently small with respect to @xmath203 , and @xmath3 is such that @xmath204 . we may encode this choice of the parameters by the `` physical '' notation @xmath205 the hyperbolic ratio of the saddle point will be not bigger than one only in a suitable semi - analytic set in the parameter space , and will be bigger than one in another ( complementary ) semi - analytic set . after eventual exchanging of @xmath56 and @xmath48 , it will be also supposed that the hyperbolic ratio of the saddle point is not bigger than one for all parameter values . along the circle @xmath206 with angle close or strictly less than @xmath175 the variation of the argument of @xmath165 is uniformly bounded in @xmath3 ( theorem [ variation ] ) . along the curve @xmath207 the imaginary part of @xmath165 equals the imaginary part of the transport map @xmath208 . therefore the zeros of @xmath209 along @xmath207 are exactly the intersection points of @xmath207 and the segment @xmath210 . according to lemma [ mainlemma ] we have @xmath211 as @xmath212 is an analytic family of analytic functions , then by gabrielov s theorem , the number of such fixed points is uniformly bounded in @xmath3 on @xmath213 $ ] . to conclude , we have only to check that the family @xmath167 has regular zeros along the border of the domain @xmath190 . this is indeed the case , when @xmath214 , as @xmath215 . we conclude that the number of isolated zeros of the family of functions @xmath216 in the domain @xmath190 is uniformly bounded by some integer , say @xmath217 . finally , note that the condition @xmath218 can be removed . indeed , if for some @xmath219 , @xmath220 , @xmath221 , the function @xmath222 has at least @xmath223 zeros in @xmath190 , then it has at least @xmath223 zeros in @xmath190 in a sufficiently small neighborhood of @xmath219 , in contradiction with the preceding estimate . to resume , we proved the following classical result + * theorem ( roussarie@xcite ) * _ every homoclinic saddle loop ( a one - saddle cycle ) occurring in an analytic finite - parameter family of plane analytic vector fields , may generate no more than a finite number of limit cycles within the family . _ let us note that our method , exactly as the roussarie s theorem allows to compute more precisely the cyclicity of @xmath178 . we shall not enter into details here . just to illustrate this , note that if the hyperbolic ratio @xmath224 is strictly bigger than one , then the overall increase of the argument of the displacement map along the border of @xmath190 is strictly less than @xmath175 ( this computation is omitted ) and the cyclicity of @xmath178 is zero . the content of this section is not necessary for the proof of our main result theorem [ mainth ] , but it aims to shed some light on the origin of the method , used to bound the limit cycles near the saddle loop in the preceding section . with the same notations as in section [ onesaddle ] , consider the analytic family of analytic vector fields @xmath225 defining a holomorphic foliation @xmath17 of the form @xmath226 where @xmath227 is a function and @xmath228 is an analytic family of differential one - forms , both analytic in a neighborhood of the saddle loop @xmath178 . for definiteness , we put the saddle point at the origin in @xmath104 , so @xmath229 . we shall further suppose that the saddle loop @xmath178 is contained in the level set @xmath230 , and the interior of @xmath178 is filled up by a continuous family of periodic orbits @xmath231 , parameterized by @xmath232 , where @xmath233 is the restriction of @xmath227 on the cross - section @xmath56 . the displacement map is approximated by the usual poincar - pontryagin formula as follows @xmath234 where @xmath235 tends to zero as @xmath3 tends to zero , uniformly in @xmath236 in every compact interval in which the displacement map is defined . the zeros of @xmath174 correspond to limit cycles and , at least far from @xmath237 , they are approximated there by the zeros of the complete abelian integral @xmath238 we make the assumption ( actually justified by the roussarie s theorem @xcite ) , that this is so also in a neighborhood of @xmath239 ( corresponding to limit cycles close to the saddle loop @xmath178 ) . thus , it makes a sense to prove the finiteness of the maximal number of the zeros of the abelian integral @xmath240 , which tend to @xmath241 as @xmath242 tends to the origin in the parameter space . this follows of course from a well known general result of varchenko and khovansky . we shall use , however , a different idea due to g.s . petrov @xcite , who showed that the analogous global problem for complete elliptic integrals of second kind is of algebraic nature . this observation has been used in several papers by petrov to evaluate the precise number of zeros of complete elliptic integrals , and hence of limit cycles of perturbed hamiltonian vector fields , see for instance oadek @xcite . we are ready to describe the local version of the petrov method . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ consider the sector @xmath243 for a fixed sufficiently small @xmath189 and all sufficiently small @xmath244 the abelian integral @xmath245 allows an analytic continuation in @xmath246 . to bound the number of its zeros on @xmath246 ( and hence on @xmath247 ) we apply the argument principle to the domain @xmath246 . along the circle @xmath248 the increase of the argument of @xmath249 is bounded uniformly in @xmath3 ( due to gabrielov s theorem ) . along the segment @xmath213 $ ] the abelian integral allows two analytic continuations @xmath250 . as @xmath251 is real - analytic on @xmath247 then @xmath252 and by the picard - lefschetz formula @xmath253 where @xmath254 is a continuous family of cycles , vanishing at the origin as @xmath255 tends to zero . the imaginary part of @xmath240 on @xmath210 is therefore an analytic function , and by gabrielov s theorem again , its zeros are uniformly bounded in @xmath3 on the closed interval @xmath213 $ ] . this implies that the increase of the argument of @xmath240 on @xmath210 is also uniformly bounded in @xmath3 which combined to the argument principle shows the finiteness of the maximal number of zeros _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the proof of the finite cyclicity of the one - saddle loop from the preceding section , may be seen as a generalization of the petrov method . indeed , the picard - lefschetz formula corresponds to the claim of lemma 1 , and by lemma 2 the zeros the analytic abelian integral ( [ impart ] ) correspond to the fixed points ( complex limit cycles ) of the holonomy map @xmath99 of the separatrix . as it is well known , the holonomy map of a separatrix is analytic , which implies the finite cyclicity of the saddle loop @xmath178 . the main result of the paper is the following [ mainth ] every heteroclinic saddle loop ( a two - saddle cycle ) occurring in an analytic finite - parameter family of plane analytic vector fields , may generate no more than a finite number of limit cycles within the family . using the notations used in the preceding sections , suppose that the vector field @xmath0 has a two - saddle loop @xmath16 . consider the dulac maps @xmath256 associated to the corresponding foliation , as on fig.[fig4 ] . each map @xmath257 is a composition of a `` local '' dulac map ( as in section [ dulacsection ] ) and two real - analytic transport maps . from this it follows that lemma [ mainlemma ] applies to @xmath257 , @xmath258 , too . from now on we choose a real - analytic local variable @xmath52 on the cross - section @xmath56 thus identifying @xmath56 to an open disc centered at @xmath259 . we shall also suppose that @xmath260 . the functions @xmath261 , @xmath258 are multivalued on the cross - section @xmath56 and have critical points at @xmath262 , @xmath263 , respectively . the functions @xmath264 are real - analytic . the limit cycles of @xmath1 near @xmath16 correspond to the zeros of the displacement map @xmath265 near @xmath182 . let @xmath266 , @xmath258 be the hyperbolic ratios of the saddles . we shall suppose , upon exchanging eventually the roles of @xmath56 and @xmath48 , that @xmath267 . denote the zero loci of the imaginary parts of the dulac maps @xmath268 , @xmath269 by @xmath270 and @xmath271 respectively . we shall bound the number of the zeros of @xmath165 in the complex domain @xmath272 of the universal covering of @xmath273 defined as follows ( without loss of generality we assume that @xmath274 ) . * if @xmath275 , the domain @xmath272 is bounded by the circle @xmath276 and by @xmath277 as it is shown on fig.[dessin5 ] . * if @xmath278 then necessarily @xmath279 . the domain @xmath272 is bounded by the circle @xmath246 , by the interval @xmath280 $ ] , and by @xmath281 , as it is shown on fig.[dessin6 ] . in the course of the proof the parameters @xmath203 and @xmath3 will be chosen as in the one - saddle case : the constant @xmath203 will be sufficiently small , @xmath43 will be sufficiently small with respect to @xmath203 , and @xmath282 will be such that @xmath283 , see ( [ constants ] ) . like in section [ onesaddle ] we shall suppose , without loss of generality , that the analytic functions @xmath284 where @xmath285 are not identically zero . this will guarantee that for generic values of @xmath3 the displacement map will have only regular zeros in the closure of @xmath272 , so the argument principle ( proposition [ argument ] ) can be applied . * proof of theorem [ mainth ] . * it follows from the definition of the domain @xmath286 that the displacement map @xmath161 is analytic there . to count the zeros ( corresponding to real and complex limit cycles ) of the displacement map in @xmath287 we apply proposition 1 ( the argument principle ) to the family of functions @xmath165 . to evaluate the variation of the argument of the displacement map along the border of @xmath272 we repeat the arguments of section [ onesaddle ] . consider first the case @xmath275 , fig.[dessin5 ] . the connected component of the zero locus of the imaginary part of @xmath288 which is tangent to the line @xmath289 through @xmath290 intersects the circle @xmath246 transversally , and along this circle the variation of the argument of @xmath165 is uniformly bounded in @xmath3 ( theorem [ variation ] ) . the imaginary part of @xmath161 restricted to @xmath270 equals the imaginary part of @xmath291 and hence @xmath292 vanishes along @xmath293 exactly at the intersection points @xmath294 according to lemma [ mainlemma ] these intersection points are the solutions of the equation @xmath295 where @xmath296 are the holonomies of the separatrices intersecting @xmath56 and related to the saddle points @xmath297 and @xmath290 . by gabrielov s theorem , the number of such fixed points is uniformly bounded in the disc @xmath298 . consider now the second case @xmath278 , @xmath279 , see fig.[dessin6 ] . along this circle @xmath246 the variation of the argument of @xmath165 is uniformly bounded in @xmath3 ( theorem [ variation ] ) . along the interval @xmath280 $ ] the imaginary part of @xmath299 vanishes identically , and the imaginary part of @xmath161 restricted to this interval equals the imaginary part of @xmath291 . therefore the zeros of @xmath209 along @xmath280 $ ] are exactly the intersection points of @xmath300 and @xmath280 $ ] . by lemma [ mainlemma ] , and like in ( [ 1loop ] ) , these intersection points are the solution of the equation @xmath301 where @xmath302 is the holonomy of the separatrix intersecting @xmath56 and related to the saddle points @xmath290 . by gabrielov s theorem , the number of such fixed points is uniformly bounded . finally , the zeros of @xmath209 along @xmath303 and @xmath304 are evaluated as in the case @xmath275 . this completes the proof of theorem [ mainth].@xmath90 the identity ( [ 8loop ] ) which determines complex limit cycles `` responsible '' for the cyclicity of the double loop @xmath16 is the main new ingredient in the proof with respect to the one - saddle case . indeed , solutions of ( [ 8loop ] ) are fixed points of the holonomy @xmath305 which , for @xmath164 , is generated by a closed loop @xmath306 contained in the complexified separatrix of @xmath16 intersecting the cross - section @xmath56 . the topological type of this separatrix near @xmath16 is a disc with two punctures , corresponding to the two saddle points @xmath307 and @xmath308 . clearly @xmath306 makes one turn around each of them , but depending on the orientation we have two possibilities shown on fig . [ dessin8 ] ( i ) and ( ii ) . a simple computation on a model example shows that the loop @xmath306 associated to the holonomy @xmath305 is the figure eight - loop on fig . [ dessin8 ] ( i ) . the reader will recognize in the loop @xmath306 a key ingredient in the proof of the local boundedness of the number of zeros of pseudo - abelian integrals in @xcite . although the result of theorem [ mainth ] is existential , the proof we use leads to effective upper bounds on the number of the bifurcating limit cycles . this possibility is explored in @xcite , where we show that the cyclicity of a hamiltonian two - loop is bounded by the number of the zeros of _ a pair _ of associated abelian integrals , a phenomenon which also explains the appearance of alien limit cycles in @xcite .

we prove that the number of limit cycles , which bifurcate from a two - saddle loop of an analytic plane vector field @xmath0 , under an arbitrary finite - parameter analytic deformation @xmath1 , @xmath2 , is uniformly bounded with respect to @xmath3 . 2000 msc scheme numbers : 34c07 , 37g15 , 70k05

1506.04611

biological organisms have structure at many different levels of organization : from the scale of small molecules to genes , to chromosomes , subcellular organelles in eukaryotes , the arrangement and differentiation of individual cells in multicellular organisms , and the organisms themselves in the context of ecology @xcite . when constructing a theory for phenomena in such systems , there is a natural set of objects to use that separates out the parts that vary from the parts that are quite regular . in essence , these objects are the individuals of that theory and it is important to understand what drives the formation of new levels of individuality @xcite . especially in biological systems , that natural set of objects can vary from case to case ` species ' has a much clearer definition for multicellular organisms than for bacteria . these objects are not inherent aspects of the matter that biological systems are made of , or directly arising from the underlying physical laws , but instead are a consequence of biological processes and the information stored within the system that encodes them @xcite . this information is discovered and sustained by self - organization of the biological system , via the processes of evolutionary dynamics . this suggests that by understanding how biological systems create higher levels of organization a new set of individuals we can more generally understand the mechanisms behind the emergence of higher - level structures . this need to create robust higher - level organization appears in experimental attempts to reproduce facets of the origins of life , where a generalized understanding would help guide intuition about what could be used to enable the systems to sustain their own organization @xcite . in pursuit of artificial cells , researchers must deal with an analogue of this problem in the form of controlling the distribution of genetic material between the artificial cells . some cells may end up with multiple copies of the genetic material , or with none @xcite . in chemical origins of life scenarios , the distribution of compounds associated with complex autocatalytic networks plays a similar role @xcite . these are both cases in which the system has not yet managed to produce a robust , larger - scale individual , but in which the signatures of that larger scale can be observed for short times they are transitional systems . there are similar systems that occur much later in the evolutionary history of life , which can be used as inspiration for potential solutions to the problem of creating robust higher - level organization . for example , although bacteria are generally considered to be unicellular , many exhibit features such as biofilm , chain , or syncytium formation and the absence of individual growth that are more closely associated to multicellularity @xcite . the distinction between the unicellular and multicellular states of organisms is not precise @xcite . the transition from the unicellular to the multicellular state is most clearly indicated by germ - soma differentiation and the genetic assimilation of a developmental program that results in the reproduction of community - level morphological features @xcite . that is to say , the population - level structure becomes more precisely specified by the processes by which it is produced , usually in part through a very narrow replicative bottleneck of a single cell , followed by expansion into the new individual . the existence of a replicative bottleneck has consequences for the evolutionary dynamics in multiscale systems , and acts as a form of population - level repair mechanism . for example , in the case of protocells , using smaller vesicles tends to suppress the emergence of parasitic genetic material @xcite . other work has investigated the consequences of replicative bottlenecks , but historically much of the focus has been on the role of the bottleneck as a constraint on the stability of early forms of life in which the necessary genes for survival would not have been located on a single unified genome . for example , @xcite considers the maximum number of independent genes that can be sustained in a two - layer bag - of - genes model . there , each generation is produced through random sampling , which is used to generate a constraint on pre - biotic vesicularized genetic systems . similarly , the stochastic corrector model @xcite looks at sub - sampling of a population via division in two as a process which can import selection pressures from the group level in order to sustain genetic composition and to overcome the stringent constraints imposed by the error threshold associated with eigen s paradox @xcite in prebiotic systems . later , @xcite built on the artificial cells models to include multi - level selection and show that novel evolutionary directions could emerge from it . however , bag - of - genes models are examples of systems where the population structure necessary for survival can not change . in these cases the reproductive bottleneck helps sustain the population against mutational load , but does not act as an organizational driving force . this is because the organization is fixed and can not change . these systems can not do anything about the fact that their functions are all stored in separate places and must be collectively maintained . if , on the other hand , the population structure is allowed to vary on an additional level perhaps allowing for multiple functions on the same genetic molecule , but perhaps isolating them then we can ask questions about the transitions in which the number of levels of organization of the system changes . our subsequent step is to consider a three - layer system in which there are functions ( genes ) , cells ( collections of genes ) , and communities of cells ( ensembles of collections of genes ) . in this case , the reproductive bottleneck is not only preventing parasitism from emerging , but also provides a feedback between the way the lower - level population is organized and the higher - level replicative dynamics . because the cells ( which are the objects being transmitted through the bottleneck ) may have a variable genetic structure , the pressure produced by the bottleneck encourages gene - level organization . at the same time , if the bottleneck radius ( captured in what proceeds by the sporesize variable ) is capable of changing as well , then there is co - evolution between these factors . this co - evolution between individual- and community - level structure , in certain parameter ranges , can encourage the emergence of higher - level multicellular structures and retain them against fluctuations . developing such a bottleneck constrains the lower level of the system , and so during the formation we expect that there will be an evolutionary pressure resisting it . as recognized by previous works @xcite , this introduces a difficulty in evolving towards a multicellular organism , the individual cells must give up their replicative identity . during reproduction through a genetic bottleneck , mutations accumulated by somatic cells are not passed on to the offspring . in a transitional organism though , mutations which would encourage ` cheating ' that is , having an independent replicative identity would be beneficial at the level of the individual cells and might thus inhibit the formation of a multicellular organism . here we investigate a model that explicitly represents the competing interests that drive the evolution of multicellularity . on the one hand , organisms may require a relatively diverse collection of functions in order to survive in a particular environment . individual cells are thus considered to exist as part of independent communities ( biofilms ) that each require a certain collection of genes to be represented in order to be viable . pressure to retain those functions arises from survival or death on the scale of the biofilms themselves . on the other hand , once functions are being provided at the community level , selection pressures on individual cell lines to retain those functions are reduced and it becomes very likely for non - functional parasitic cells to emerge and dominate the population via an error catastrophe . in this section we provide a general presentation of the model and its analysis . the lowest - level elements of the model are @xmath0 genes representing functions required for the survival of the biofilm ( fig . [ fig : modelschema ] ) . an individual cell is comprised of a collection of these genes where , in this model , a cell may only possess at most one copy of each gene . because of this , the genotype of each cell may be represented by a string of @xmath0 bits , where a 1 indicates the presence of the gene for function and a 0 indicates the absence of that gene . the top level of the model is a population of isolated communities ( biofilms ) , each composed of a population of cells of fixed size @xmath1 , which in turn each have a collection of @xmath0 genes encoding functions . the biofilm - level population proceeds via cycles of replication . every iteration , the biofilms may each generate two propagules in order to attempt to produce viable offspring , where viability is determined by having at least one copy of each of the @xmath0 genes among its cell population . viable offspring are accumulated in a list which then becomes the biofilm - level population for the next iteration . to generate this list , parent biofilms are sampled randomly without replacement until either every biofilm has attempted two replications , or until the list has reached a maximum carrying capacity @xmath2 . this mechanism allows the biofilm population size to fluctuate and even to go extinct . the biofilms themselves reproduce by randomly selecting a subset of their cells ( with replacement ) to generate a propagule of a sporesize @xmath3 ( this does not remove the parent cells from the community ) . the propagule is then expanded through replication of its cells . the replication process is modelled by initializing the film with the propagule , then sampling randomly from all cells in the film with replacement to choose the parent of the next cell . this is repeated until the biofilm has grown to size @xmath1 . then , the biofilm is evaluated for viability : if the film contains all necessary functions , it is viable and replaces another random biofilm in the population . otherwise , it is discarded . the replication process of the individual cells involves two evolutionary operators : deleterious mutation and horizontal gene transfer . during a replication event , each @xmath4 in the bit string may be lost to mutation with rate @xmath5 ( changing the bit from a @xmath4 to a @xmath6 ) . in addition , with rate @xmath7 the value of that bit may be replaced with the corresponding value possessed by another cell randomly sampled from the same biofilm at that point in time . horizontal gene transfer in this model transmits both 0 and 1 values equally , based on their presence in the population . for much of the analysis of this model , we consider the sporesize @xmath3 to be fixed and directly investigate the survival rate and population structure at that sporesize . however , in order to investigate the evolutionary dynamics we must also specify where the information about the sporesize is stored within the biofilm . if we choose to have it be stored at the biofilm level , then there is a clear way for the biofilm - level individuals to assert top - down control over their components . as such , it seems better to associated the sporesize with individual cells instead . to do this , we also associate an integer , ss , to each cell which is its preferred sporesize , and which mutates via randomly increasing or decreasing with probability @xmath8 per replication . the first cell that is chosen to create a new propagule determines the size of that propagule based on its preference . this means that a parasite could improve its chance of survival by asking for a very large propagule . this increases the chance of including non - parasitic cells . because we are investigating the conditions that allow for the evolution of the multicellular state , we choose this mechanism to make the stability of the multicellular state as unlikely as possible . in this way , if the multicellular state still emerges , then this can be considered to be a more robust feature of the model . in actual biological systems , this constraint may be applied , if at all , in a less stringent manner . we refer to the version of our model where sporesize is allowed to fluctuate as dynamic . first we study the case in which the sporesize is fixed . we do this to determine the structure of the evolutionary landscape on which the dynamic version of the model will operate , to help guide our understanding of what is happening microscopically . the aim of this is to study the underlying structure induced by mutation and the replicative bottleneck , without regard to extra factors such as different replication rates among cells within the film due , for example , to the metabolic load deriving from the requirement of producing the macromolecules necessary to perform particular functions . these factors may be added in later , but would obscure the structure that arises purely from genetic drift combined with the replicative bottleneck . as a proxy for fitness , we measure the fraction of a biofilm s offspring that are viable . survivability in our model is generally determined by the ability of a community of cells to possess a collection of genes . in some cases , the community contains only one cell type , in which case that cell would be required to possess a copy of each gene . if the community contains multiple cell types , it is possible for the community to be composed of cells that collectively possess at least one copy of each gene . this quantity is not stationary , but in fact changes as mutations accumulate in the population over time . if we start with a biofilm in which every cell has all functions , the survival rate is initially very high but begins to decay as functions are lost , until it reaches a point where selection pressure at the biofilm level prevents it from decaying further . as such , the landscape actually experienced by a biofilm depends on the speed of its evolution . at short times , larger sporesize always corresponds to higher survivability . this is because as more cells are transferred , there is a much larger chance of capturing all necessary functions in the child film . the survival curve in this regime is very flat when the population is initially homogeneous and function - complete , as non - viable films require every cell in the spore to spontaneously develop the same deleterious mutation . as such , the death rate is exponentially suppressed as the sporesize grows , and a very large spore is not actually needed to ensure survival . as time passes , the population of cells within the biofilms begin to accumulate mutations . on the one hand , if the sporesize is equal to the biofilm size , mutations do not risk causing the death of the offspring until the biofilm approaches the point where each function is only present in approximately one of its cells . at that point , however , it is possible for a biofilm to give rise to a sterile offspring equal to the probability that any of the needed functions is lost to a deleterious mutation when the cells replicate . on the other hand , if the sporesize is 1 , then any cell with any deleterious mutation will give rise to a non - viable offspring if it is picked to be the spore . as such , in that limit the death rate is just the probability of a random cell in the film having at least one deleterious mutation . however , because of that , deleterious mutations can not be accumulated all cells that give rise to viable offspring are identical . the degree to which the single - cell spore has a lower death rate than the biofilm - sized spore is determined by the number of functions @xmath0 which must be retained . between the two extreme cases , simulations of the model ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , 5000 generations ) show that there is a sequence of collapses where the survivability decreases in steps ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) , but locally increases with increasing sporesize . this can be understood by thinking about the minimal number of cells needed to construct a viable spore . if only one cell is needed , then as the sporesize increases the probability of finding that cell also increases ( and so the survival rate increases ) . however , if the sporesize becomes too large , non - viable cells begin to be included . once this effect grows to the point that the minimal viable offspring requires two different cells from the parent ( e.g. no single cell in the film has all functions ) , the large spore becomes only half as effective at guaranteeing their inclusion . this proceeds in sequence as an increasing number of distinct cells are required to make a viable offspring . the discreteness of the apparent landscape is due to the discreteness of the number of required cells , and so as the number of required cells becomes larger the steps in the landscape become more blurred . , min_samples=1000 ) , averaged over 29 simulations . there are discrete jumps in the number of clusters with increasing sporesize as the population structure changes , corresponding to a division of necessary functions across multiple member species . ] we test this idea by preparing populations that are pre - configured to have two , three , and four required sub - populations for making a viable offspring . for example , the two - species case has half of the initial cells containing only the first @xmath14 functions with the other half having only the last @xmath14 functions , and so on . these are the marked lines plotted against the histogram data in fig . we note that the marked data points continuously join up with the different discrete segments of the histogram data , which supports the idea that the sporesize is controlling the strength of population - level repair . furthermore , we use the dbscan algorithm @xcite to cluster the population of individual cells in sequence space . this gives us an estimate of the number of distinct species of cell as a function of sporesize ( fig . [ fig2 ] ) . we see well - defined discrete steps in the number of discovered clusters for the lower - half of the range of possible spore sizes . these correspond to jumps in the death rate . if the only genetic mechanism in the system is deleterious mutation , there is no possibility to recover lost functions or to have internal repair of the population . in that case , the only repair mechanism available is selection , which for large spore sizes only becomes significant once the population has already suffered a build - up of harmful mutations . after this build - up leading to a damaged population the biofilm can no longer survive with a smaller sporesize . there is thus a ratchet effect which may lock a biofilm population into a particular large sporesize at long times . the local gradient of the fitness is always indicating a preference for larger sporesize , so the system can not easily detect the sudden jumps in survivability that would be obtained from smaller sporesize in order to find the fitness optimum . in addition , taking advantage of those jumps from the state of a less - structured population is impossible if the only genetic operators are deleterious mutation , as once there are no cells in the biofilm that have multiple functions a multi - function cell can no longer be recreated . this raises the question of accessibility of the survival rate landscape for an actual dynamical system . , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , 5000 generations ) . the presence of even a small amount of horizontal gene transfer allows the population structure of the biofilm to rebuild itself , smoothing out the cliffs in the survivability landscape . ] in the presence of a horizontal gene transfer mechanism the pool of available functions within a biofilm may be redistributed between its members . this means that mutational loss of population structure is not permanent in a given biofilm lineage , which causes the sharp transitions between population structures to become blurred ( fig . [ fig3 ] ) . as a result , a small amount of horizontal gene transfer may prevent the system from getting stuck and enable the system to transition to smaller sporesizes and towards multi - function cells . however , even though the optimum survivability is at a small sporesize , it remains to be seen whether or not the system will discover this optimum under its own evolutionary dynamics when starting far from it . , @xmath9,@xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath15 generations ) . at long times , there is a first order phase transition between the initial phase with sporesize comparable to the biofilm size and @xmath16 function per cell , and the multicellular phase with small sporesize and @xmath17 functions per cell . ] to test this , we initialize the system in a state where each cell only has one function , and allow the preferred sporesize of each cell to vary via a random walk whenever the cell replicates , with probability @xmath18 . we observe that in the case of non - zero horizontal gene transfer , there is a first order phase transition with respect to mutation rate @xmath5 @xcite . the transition occurs from the initial state , which is characterized by a sporesize comparable to the biofilm size and approximately one function per cell , to a state with @xmath19 sporesize and cells containing close to a full complement of functions ( fig . [ fig4 ] ) . the signature of the first order nature of the phase transition is an extended coexistence regime in which there is bistability between the two phases . the larger the horizontal gene transfer rate , the larger the mutation rate at which the phase transition occurs . , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , showing the dynamics of the average sporesize and average number of functions per cell . ] an example evolutionary trajectory from the bistable regime ( @xmath22 , @xmath20 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 ) is plotted in fig . the system does not progressively evolve towards the multicellular state , but rather spends most of its time fluctuating in distinct phases . the development of the multicellular state is rapid when it finally begins , but must be nucleated by a relatively rare event . an important feature of our study is that the global increase in survivability is associated with long - time , discontinuous changes in population structure . this makes the evolution of multicellularity particularly non - trivial . we have shown that horizontal gene transfer provides one mechanism for resolving this dilemma , as it is capable of smoothing the fitness landscape over sporesize thereby carving a favorable path from uni- to multicellularity . this kind of mechanism enables the population structure to better navigate the space of possible states . the mechanism of a replicative bottleneck gives rise to evolutionary forces which act to repair variations in population structure and to transfer selective pressure from the biofilm scale to the cell scale . this allows a system to create robust organization on a larger scale , in the form of a genetically homogeneous colony replicating through a single cell gamete : a multicellular individual . in a more general sense , the mathematics of this process can be mapped onto other systems in which evolutionary dynamics act on multiple scales for example , the genetic complement of a protocell and the unification of multiple shorter genes into a single chromosome . our study suggests that the natural methodology to think of this transition is that of the eigen error - threshold @xcite . there is some mutation rate which drives the population to forget the optimal structure ( e.g. , each cell having each function ) . as the population structure decays , the selection pressure resisting each further deleterious mutation begins to increase until it reaches some stable point which sits just at the error threshold . the smaller the sporesize , the more quickly the selection pressure increases with response to population decay , and so the closer to the ` complete ' population the system ends up being . because requiring @xmath23 cells versus requiring @xmath24 cells is a very large difference in survivability when @xmath23 is small , the system tends to cluster around the edges of those states as that is where the error threshold changes most rapidly . this observation may provide valuable insights into experiments . the model we have investigated here is intended to act as a baseline or ` minimal model ' for the phenomenon of the emergence of a higher level of organization . however , there are still certain elements of the model which admit variations that we have not investigated here . the reason for excluding these extra factors is that we want to focus on the costs and benefits specifically associated with the creation of a narrow replicative bottleneck . different versions of the dynamics , along with alterations to the survivability of the biofilm or the replication rates of the component cells can be easily added on top of this basic model in order to extend it or to calibrate it to specific experimental systems . for the same reason , we do not consider the effects of metabolic costs associated with encapsulating several functions within individual cells , which could lead to different replication rates among individuals . in the presence of multiscale selection and a variable information bottleneck , selection at the collective scale interacts with the bottleneck limiting information flow from the individual cell scale . when this bottleneck is very wide , the effect of selection is weak , but as the bottleneck shrinks this causes an amplification of selection pressure and in turn stabilizes the population at the small scale . the result is a feedback which causes the bottleneck to either expand to minimize the cost of selection and effectively reducing the impact of large - scale patterns , or to shrink as far as possible and so allowing selective forces operating on the collective scale to be transmitted to the cell level . this decision of whether to run off towards large bottlenecks or small bottlenecks is a phase transition in the evolutionary dynamics of the system . the new form of order corresponding to this phase transition is the emergence of a new unit of well - defined individual at the collective scale . we have characterized via a minimal model of a three - layer system that it is possible to observe , _ in silico _ , a transition possessing several of the most salient features of the evolutionary transition from unicellularity to multicellularity . two evolutionary forces co - exist to shape the structure of the population and stabilize the emergence of the higher - level structures associated with multicellularity . we have argued that this is due to the existence of a replicative bottleneck . the transition has to go through a series of population changes that locally reduce survivability and we have shown that mechanisms such as horizontal gene transfer help smooth these jumps and ease the process of global evolution towards multicellularity . further work will include more detailed formulation of potential experimental tests for these predictions and the study of chained transitions that may serve as a model analogous to the occurrence of more than one of the major transitions in evolution within the context of a single dynamical model @xcite . we would like to thank aaron dinner , christoph adami , nigel goldenfeld , and nicholas chia for useful discussions regarding the development of the model and connections to different types of biofilm behaviors , tetsuya yomo for useful discussions regarding the connection to evolutionary dynamics in protocells , raymond s. puzio for discussions regarding mathematical analysis of the model , and norman packard for suggestions towards improving the presentation of the manuscript . 39ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _ ( , ) p. link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.36.102403.114735 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1086/286012 [ `` , '' ] ( ) link:\doibase 10.1098/rspb.1996.0121 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1093/icb/43.1.64 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.0601080103 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/bies.201000039 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rspb.2011.1999 [ ( ) , 10.1098/rspb.2011.1999 ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s12038 - 014 - 9420 - 5 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1086/394109 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10539 - 009 - 9180-z [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1749 - 6632.2011.06422.x [ ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1478 - 3975/10/1/011001 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1038/nature11549 [ ( ) , 10.1038/nature11549 ] link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev.micro.52.1.81 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nrmicro3178 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.1115323109 [ * * ( ) , 10.1073/pnas.1115323109 ] link:\doibase 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003803 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms7102 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.devcel.2004.08.010 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.jtbi.2005.08.043 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01734356 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1098/rspb.1995.0172 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1006/jtbi.2002.3026 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000542 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.jtbi.2010.09.011 [ * * , ( ) ] in @noop _ _ , vol . ( ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) p. @noop _ _ ( , , )

we explain how hierarchical organization of biological systems emerges naturally during evolution , through a transition in the units of individuality . we will show how these transitions are the result of competing selective forces operating at different levels of organization , each level having different units of individuality . such a transition represents a singular point in the evolutionary process , which we will show corresponds to a phase transition in the way information is encoded , with the formation of self - reinforcing information bottlenecks . we present an abstract model for characterizing these transitions that is quite general , applicable to many different versions of such transitions . as a concrete example , we consider the transition to multicellularity . specifically , we study a stochastic model where isolated communities of interacting individuals ( e.g. cells ) undergo a transition to higher - order individuality ( e.g. multicellularity ) . this transition is indicated by the marked decrease in the number of cells utilized to generate new communities from pre - existing ones . in this sense , the community begins to reproduce as a whole via a decreasing number of cells . we show that the fitness barrier to this transition is strongly reduced by horizontal gene transfer . these features capture two of the most prominent aspects of the transition to multicellularity : the evolution of a developmental process and reproduction through a unicellular bottleneck .

astro-ph0504395

the giant radio galaxy m87 is located at a distance of @xmath2 ( @xmath3 ) in the virgo cluster of galaxies . the angle between the parsec scale plasma jet well studied at radio , optical and x - ray wavelengths and the observer s line of sight has been estimated to be in the order of @xmath4 . the mass of the black hole in the center of m87 is of the order of @xmath5 . m87 is discussed to be a powerful accelerator of high energy particles , possibly even up to the highest energies @xcite . this makes m87 an interesting candidate for tev @xmath1-ray emission . m87 was observed with the hegra stereoscopic telescope system in 1998/1999 for a total of @xmath6 ( after quality cuts ) above an energy threshold of @xmath7 . an excess of tev @xmath1-rays has been found with a significance of @xmath8 @xcite . the integral flux was calculated to be @xmath9 of the flux of the crab nebula . m87 is of particular interest for observations at tev energies : the large jet angle makes it different from the so far observed tev emitting active galactic nuclei ( agn ) which are of the blazar type , i.e. with their plasma jets pointing directly towards the observer . various models exist to describe emission of tev photons from m87 . leptonic models ( i.e. inverse compton scattering ) are discussed in @xcite , whereas @xcite consider the tev @xmath1-ray production in large scale plasma jets . from the experimental view , the tev @xmath1-ray production in large scale jets would be of particular interest since the extension of the m87 jet structure could be resolved at tev energies with the typical angular resolution of stereoscopic cherenkov telescope arrays of @xmath10 per event . hadronic models do also exist @xcite as well as tev @xmath1-ray production scenarios correlated with the cosmic ray population of the radio galaxy @xcite . finally , the hypothesis of annihilating exotic particles ( i.e. neutralinos ) has been discussed by @xcite . observations with the h.e.s.s . telescopes have been initiated to confirm the hegra result and to further clarify the origin of the tev @xmath1-ray emission , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) collaboration operates an array of four imaging atmospheric cherenkov telescopes optimized for an energy range between @xmath11 and @xmath12 . the telescopes are located in the khomas highlands in namibia ( @xmath13 , @xmath14 ) at a height of @xmath15 above sea level , see fig . [ fig : hess ] . each telescope has a @xmath16 tessellated mirror surface @xcite and is equipped with a 960 photomultiplier tube ( pmt ) camera with a field of view of @xmath17 @xcite . the full four telescope array is operational since december , 2003 . since july 2003 the telescopes are operated in a coincident mode @xcite assuring that at least two telescopes record images for each event which is important for an improved reconstruction of the shower geometry , and @xmath1-hadron separation . more information about h.e.s.s . can be found in @xcite . m87 has been observed with the h.e.s.s . cherenkov telescopes between march and may , 2003 and february to may , 2004 . the 2003 data were taken during the comissioning phase of the experiment with only two telescopes . the stereo events have been merged offline based on their individual gps time stamps . the 2004 data were taken with the full four telescope array with the hardware coincidence trigger . the sensitivity of the full setup increased by more than a factor of two compared to the sensitivity of the instrument during the 2003 observation campaign on m87 . the average zenith angle of the observations was @xmath18 for both years . due to technical reasons one of the four telescopes was excluded from the analysis in the february / march 2004 observation period affecting @xmath19 of the data by a slightly reduced sensitivity . standard cuts on the data quality ( stable weather and detector status ) have been applied leaving a dead - time corrected observation time of @xmath20 for the 2003 data and @xmath21 for the 2004 data . after data calibration @xcite and application of image cleaning tail - cuts hillas parameters @xcite are calculated for the individual recorded images . the geometric shower reconstruction ( direction , energy , etc . ) follows the standard h.e.s.s . analysis technique @xcite . cuts which were optimized on monte carlo simulated sources comprising @xmath22 of the flux of the crab nebula have been applied to the data including a tight angular cut of @xmath23 . although the _ _ s__oftware stereo telescope setup in 2003 would legitimate a separately optimized set of cuts , the same cuts as for the 2004 data were applied to the 2003 data . the distribution of excess events as a function of the squared angular distance @xmath24 between the reconstructed shower direction and the nominal position of m87 is shown in fig . [ fig : onoff ] for the combined data set . an excess of @xmath25 events is obtained from the direction of m87 corresponding to a significance of @xmath26 . the sky map of the combined data set is shown in fig . [ fig : skymap ] . the ring background model was used in which the background is determined from a ring region with a radius @xmath27 centred around the putative source position . the position of the tev excess as measured by h.e.s.s . is plotted in the radio map of m87 together with the tev position reported by hegra ( see fig . [ fig : radiotevmap ] ) . the tev excess is compatible with a point - source and its position was found to be compatible with the center of the extended structure of m87 as well as the position reported by the hegra collaboration within statistical errors . more observations are needed to reduce the statistical error on the derived position to further exclude regions within the extended structure of m87 . between the reconstructed shower direction and the nominal object position.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] sky region centered around the position of m87 . the number of events are integrated within the optimal point - source angular cut of @xmath28 for each of the correlated bins . the background is estimated using the ring background model . the event - by - event angular resolution is indicated by the circle ( beamsize).,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in order to calculate the integral flux above the energy threshold of the hegra measurement ( @xmath29 ) for the 2003 and 2004 h.e.s.s . observations a power - law spectrum @xmath30 with a photon index of @xmath31 ( as reported in @xcite ) was assumed . the integral flux points are shown in fig . [ fig : lightcurve ] together with the hegra measurement . note , that the 2004 flux of m87 is below the @xmath32 flux level of the crab nebula . although the h.e.s.s . fluxes of 2003 and 2004 seem still to be compatible taken the large statistical error of the 2003 measurement the comparison of the h.e.s.s . 2004 flux with the hegra measurement indicates variable tev @xmath1-ray emission from m87 on time - scales of years . the giant radio galaxy m87 has been observed with h.e.s.s . in 2003 during the comissioning phase and in 2004 with the full four telescope setup for a total of @xmath33 remaining after quality cuts . an excess of @xmath25 @xmath1-ray events has been measured from the direction of m87 with a significance of @xmath34 . this confirms the hegra measurement , although on a lower flux level . the tev excess is compatible with a point - source and within statistics its position is located at the center of the extended m87 structure . the measured flux was found to be on the sub @xmath35 level of the flux from the crab nebula in the 2004 data which indicates flux variability if compared to the @xmath36 flux level in 1998/99 reported by the hegra collaboration . to confirm the indications of variability of the tev @xmath1-ray emission from m87 more observations are needed . such a result would be very important since various models for the tev @xmath1-ray production in m87 could be ruled out . mechanisms correlated with cosmic rays @xcite , large scale jet structures @xcite and exotic dark matter particle annihilation @xcite could not explain variability in the tev @xmath1-ray emission on these time - scales . the measurement of an accurate energy spectrum could further help to reduce the amount of possible models as well as a more precise location of the emission region ; both goals require a measurement with higher event statistics as currently available by the h.e.s.s . 2003/2004 data set . m87 has been observed in a wide range of the electromagnetic spectrum . simultaneous observations at other wavelengths especially in x - rays , such as the chandra monitoring of the hst-1 knot in the inner jet region @xcite are of great importance since a correlation would further reveal the tev @xmath1-ray production mechanism of this agn which is the first one not belonging to the blazar class . the support of the namibian authorities and of the university of namibia in facilitating the construction and operation of h.e.s.s . is gratefully acknowledged , as is the support by the german ministry for education and research ( bmbf ) , the max planck society , the french ministry for research , the cnrs - in2p3 and the astroparticle interdisciplinary programme of the cnrs , the u.k . particle physics and astronomy research council ( pparc ) , the ipnp of the charles university , the south african department of science and technology and national research foundation , and by the university of namibia . we appreciate the excellent work of the technical support staff in berlin , durham , hamburg , heidelberg , palaiseau , paris , saclay , and in namibia in the construction and operation of the equipment .

the giant radio galaxy m87 was observed at tev energies with the cherenkov telescopes of the h.e.s.s . collaboration ( high energy stereoscopic system ) . the observations have been performed in the year 2003 during the comissioning phase and in 2004 with the full four telescope setup . the observations were motivated by the measurement of the hegra collaboration which reported a @xmath0 excess of tev @xmath1-rays from the direction of m87 . the results of the h.e.s.s . observations indicating a possible variability of tev @xmath1-ray emission from m87 ( compared to the hegra result ) are presented .