id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03321v1 | Planetarium: A Rigorous Benchmark for Translating Text to Structured Planning Languages | 2024-07-03T17:59:53 | 2024-07-03T17:59:53 | Max Zuo, Francisco Piedrahita Velez, Xiaochen Li, Michael L. Littman, Stephen H. Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Many recent works have explored using language models for planning problems.
One line of research focuses on translating natural language descriptions of
planning tasks into structured planning languages, such as the planning domain
definition language (PDDL). While this approach is promising, accurately
measuring the quality of generated PDDL code continues to pose significant
challenges. First, generated PDDL code is typically evaluated using planning
validators that check whether the problem can be solved with a planner. This
method is insufficient because a language model might generate valid PDDL code
that does not align with the natural language description of the task. Second,
existing evaluation sets often have natural language descriptions of the
planning task that closely resemble the ground truth PDDL, reducing the
challenge of the task. To bridge this gap, we introduce \benchmarkName, a
benchmark designed to evaluate language models' ability to generate PDDL code
from natural language descriptions of planning tasks. We begin by creating a
PDDL equivalence algorithm that rigorously evaluates the correctness of PDDL
code generated by language models by flexibly comparing it against a ground
truth PDDL. Then, we present a dataset of $132,037$ text-to-PDDL pairs across
13 different tasks, with varying levels of difficulty. Finally, we evaluate
several API-access and open-weight language models that reveal this task's
complexity. For example, $87.6\%$ of the PDDL problem descriptions generated by
GPT-4o are syntactically parseable, $82.2\%$ are valid, solve-able problems,
but only $35.1\%$ are semantically correct, highlighting the need for a more
rigorous benchmark for this problem. | [
-0.13740649819374084,
-0.4880061745643616,
0.7610636949539185,
0.5794728994369507,
-0.10278037935495377,
-0.15815088152885437,
-0.2889825403690338,
-0.1674370914697647,
-0.4048946797847748,
0.6825241446495056,
-0.5390274524688721,
-0.5791673064231873,
-0.4275631010532379,
0.24479207396507263,
-0.4655011296272278,
0.9961271286010742,
-0.6269278526306152,
-0.032275982201099396,
-0.31948328018188477,
-0.09188898652791977,
-0.15814682841300964,
-0.2656855583190918,
-0.02899753674864769,
-0.3797529935836792,
0.025284869596362114,
0.03955536335706711,
0.719872236251831,
0.6317833662033081,
0.8235626220703125,
0.2432962954044342,
-0.02122092992067337,
0.3407069444656372,
-0.4377953112125397,
-0.3166810870170593,
-0.26752907037734985,
0.03278123214840889,
-0.46364033222198486,
0.09621880203485489,
0.7572164535522461,
1.2692829370498657,
-0.3547745943069458,
0.31279686093330383,
0.009151100181043148,
0.7475038766860962,
-0.4649081230163574,
0.4158693552017212,
-0.3525334894657135,
0.08067923039197922,
-0.09525182098150253,
-0.28322309255599976,
-0.3696950078010559,
-0.5292491912841797,
0.23439401388168335,
-0.7183583378791809,
0.18347397446632385,
-0.01876325160264969,
1.0079940557479858,
0.4785483777523041,
-0.25018516182899475,
-0.5321334004402161,
-0.9755352139472961,
0.6925347447395325,
-0.5864483714103699,
0.3527075946331024,
0.4522072672843933,
0.35069572925567627,
-0.3572288751602173,
-0.7399351000785828,
-0.8210495710372925,
-0.39475974440574646,
0.08063214272260666,
0.022428950294852257,
-0.06000789627432823,
0.05706853047013283,
0.4534377157688141,
0.2566138505935669,
-0.9221388101577759,
-0.28788521885871887,
-0.396533340215683,
-0.051783718168735504,
0.48301586508750916,
0.16049516201019287,
0.20583581924438477,
-0.5456310510635376,
-0.4116448760032654,
-0.15450723469257355,
-0.6678014397621155,
-0.002997598610818386,
0.556769073009491,
0.09760534018278122,
-0.08534743636846542,
0.6549464464187622,
-0.37029001116752625,
0.7190887331962585,
-0.09145194292068481,
-0.3029654026031494,
0.12395205348730087,
-0.7627453804016113,
-0.41724854707717896,
-0.30620846152305603,
0.4491961896419525,
0.6541019082069397,
0.2453477382659912,
-0.48878949880599976,
-0.32386380434036255,
0.3524515628814697,
0.4650282561779022,
-0.8687180876731873,
-0.6436992883682251,
0.16163402795791626,
-0.22132553160190582,
-0.05302054062485695,
-0.1977781057357788,
-0.4718468487262726,
-0.11965595930814743,
-0.22637471556663513,
0.13503865897655487,
-0.5048791170120239,
-0.1471092402935028,
0.20098397135734558,
0.11964043229818344,
0.21593999862670898,
0.3337145745754242,
-0.6589621901512146,
0.5697006583213806,
0.7924997806549072,
0.6490928530693054,
-0.08431550860404968,
-0.3571220934391022,
-0.3678743839263916,
0.06854680925607681,
-0.7074979543685913,
0.9710944294929504,
-0.14514794945716858,
-0.5752156972885132,
-0.14324314892292023,
-0.07012417912483215,
0.003244568593800068,
-0.6000016927719116,
1.0167949199676514,
-0.18490082025527954,
0.3682892620563507,
-0.4091028571128845,
-0.5504646301269531,
0.05590621009469032,
0.4829941987991333,
-0.400386244058609,
1.001879096031189,
0.43729278445243835,
-0.4237090051174164,
0.830349326133728,
-0.40417417883872986,
-0.16310441493988037,
0.3260864317417145,
-0.33760008215904236,
-0.26120495796203613,
-0.20981740951538086,
0.05355888605117798,
0.16819392144680023,
-0.3457900881767273,
0.7828827500343323,
0.10148885101079941,
-0.09215182065963745,
0.07244738936424255,
-0.1919070929288864,
0.4701581597328186,
0.22253628075122833,
-0.29064151644706726,
0.2526424527168274,
-0.8310626149177551,
0.21091490983963013,
-0.08574151247739792,
-0.5715318322181702,
0.0378282256424427,
0.452389657497406,
0.32160669565200806,
0.08781824260950089,
0.39933133125305176,
-0.5151101350784302,
0.15892411768436432,
-0.5767392516136169,
0.13613946735858917,
0.73763507604599,
-0.287057101726532,
0.5318450331687927,
-0.33771270513534546,
0.4383890628814697,
-0.38053661584854126,
-0.04950239509344101,
0.10998880863189697,
-0.34608906507492065,
-0.39229103922843933,
0.07602256536483765,
0.14030903577804565,
0.382615327835083,
-0.9814980626106262,
0.4690222442150116,
-0.5167851448059082,
-0.7455450892448425,
-0.142356276512146,
0.11235310137271881,
0.6208621859550476,
0.6264539361000061,
0.2465682029724121,
-0.4206031262874603,
-0.38222625851631165,
-0.6898709535598755,
-0.16954584419727325,
-0.3685879409313202,
-0.044771235436201096,
0.624818742275238,
0.5184198617935181,
-0.12115798890590668,
0.9069136381149292,
-0.4127020239830017,
-0.18988683819770813,
-0.17261825501918793,
0.2227247953414917,
0.568362832069397,
0.4700033664703369,
0.5613378286361694,
-0.8068035244941711,
-0.5775136947631836,
0.10414889454841614,
-0.6741064786911011,
-0.3595331907272339,
-0.28678327798843384,
-0.006357788573950529,
0.10001721978187561,
-0.11349231004714966,
-0.6380382776260376,
0.37306416034698486,
0.6251761317253113,
-0.5220832228660583,
0.9546299576759338,
-0.5602278709411621,
0.19658204913139343,
-0.9021997451782227,
0.5917673707008362,
-0.005367239471524954,
-0.14319929480552673,
-0.6275700330734253,
0.3705958127975464,
0.2886691689491272,
-0.26557767391204834,
-0.25307101011276245,
0.4199330806732178,
-0.4123220145702362,
-0.4116284251213074,
-0.25685545802116394,
0.25487396121025085,
-0.06679622083902359,
0.33000633120536804,
0.1389964371919632,
0.9032886028289795,
0.5026343464851379,
-0.5851414799690247,
0.5603429675102234,
0.39648449420928955,
-0.7004133462905884,
0.6977299451828003,
-0.5303241014480591,
-0.016928108409047127,
-0.01012477558106184,
0.4016339182853699,
-0.8679298758506775,
-0.2383740246295929,
0.07960325479507446,
-0.12692363560199738,
-0.14589238166809082,
-0.15680505335330963,
-0.6641659140586853,
-0.5556700229644775,
0.016090024262666702,
0.28421980142593384,
0.37751010060310364,
-0.5015802383422852,
0.3279840350151062,
0.18770650029182434,
-0.20861029624938965,
-0.48167502880096436,
-0.36385565996170044,
0.2847096621990204,
0.16286449134349823,
-0.6148805022239685,
0.8025227189064026,
-0.18893498182296753,
-0.20487813651561737,
0.10770973563194275,
-0.43966421484947205,
-0.22109007835388184,
-0.05386824533343315,
0.1928001344203949,
0.302690714597702,
-0.07936109602451324,
-0.18477453291416168,
-0.23642490804195404,
-0.2794688045978546,
0.29616349935531616,
-0.3132411539554596,
0.7397803068161011,
0.10566755384206772,
-0.193523108959198,
-0.2811194062232971,
0.048609547317028046,
0.4773413836956024,
-0.15879662334918976,
0.47021567821502686,
0.2766060531139374,
-0.5318654179573059,
-0.3218165934085846,
-0.26647260785102844,
0.3364575207233429,
-0.42785897850990295,
0.3383282721042633,
-0.6986963152885437,
-0.07875045388936996,
0.2910030782222748,
-0.24360041320323944,
0.2200821042060852,
0.12337023764848709,
0.45175671577453613,
0.29982510209083557,
0.8147686123847961,
0.76288902759552,
0.2943539619445801,
-0.038148004561662674,
-0.22513534128665924,
0.2240859866142273,
-0.7357168197631836,
-0.19329914450645447,
-0.618751585483551,
-0.04986858367919922,
-0.42605671286582947,
-0.7560011744499207,
0.15951330959796906,
0.04345843195915222,
0.14613963663578033,
0.9153202176094055,
-0.6491556167602539,
0.4939773380756378,
0.100235216319561,
-0.3121514618396759,
0.265978068113327,
-0.3592208921909332,
-0.2047349065542221,
-0.2312370389699936,
-0.1969173699617386,
-1.0427430868148804,
1.1509466171264648,
0.07184027880430222,
0.6243860125541687,
0.21694828569889069,
0.5529540777206421,
0.11339861899614334,
0.251014769077301,
-0.2548660635948181,
0.6887413859367371,
-0.21030618250370026,
-0.4869304597377777,
-0.16030874848365784,
-0.6923307776451111,
-0.6491848230361938,
0.105418860912323,
-0.033102624118328094,
-0.6783342957496643,
0.17298275232315063,
-0.04709654301404953,
-0.1759336292743683,
0.13993337750434875,
-0.5552797317504883,
1.0918676853179932,
-0.3652055561542511,
-0.3244594633579254,
-0.3212718963623047,
-0.22613170742988586,
0.09514179825782776,
-0.2632499933242798,
0.16536912322044373,
-0.5047804713249207,
0.0457632839679718,
0.6893424391746521,
-0.29128146171569824,
0.21841424703598022,
-0.2139657437801361,
-0.18705108761787415,
-0.19712820649147034,
0.2685936391353607,
0.44152265787124634,
0.014583870768547058,
-0.2955273985862732,
-0.213211327791214,
0.3260142207145691,
-0.5727471113204956,
-0.25144529342651367,
0.7843101620674133,
-0.8741766810417175,
-0.17425274848937988,
-0.27737125754356384,
-0.7632411122322083,
-0.11003995686769485,
0.27257299423217773,
0.07204627990722656,
0.6131292581558228,
-0.6243090033531189,
-0.2610640227794647,
0.20665335655212402,
-0.4203321039676666,
0.2731874883174896,
0.5706119537353516,
-0.3252088725566864,
-0.12511199712753296,
0.8550838232040405,
0.11111393570899963,
0.3555901050567627,
0.33647483587265015,
-0.15525980293750763,
-0.4008396565914154,
-0.8369311094284058,
-0.6480942368507385,
0.04219057410955429,
-0.740053653717041,
0.04075883328914642,
-0.5152285099029541,
-0.10234514623880386,
-0.4472149908542633,
-0.32475563883781433,
-0.37148505449295044,
-0.31048455834388733,
0.028620673343539238,
0.031230514869093895,
-0.3078305721282959,
0.7948557734489441,
0.14131946861743927,
-0.038615383207798004,
-0.30511897802352905,
0.48032447695732117,
-0.016181619837880135,
0.45908164978027344,
-0.5730830430984497,
-0.11408299207687378,
0.03260413557291031,
-0.07934071123600006,
-0.45590803027153015,
-0.7430422306060791,
0.773784339427948,
0.11835034191608429,
0.5685290098190308,
0.28104355931282043,
0.23776035010814667,
0.8650376200675964,
-0.778222918510437,
0.7195058465003967,
0.039901748299598694,
-0.9703261256217957,
0.6341965794563293,
-0.24794840812683105,
0.16351760923862457,
0.5947384238243103,
0.3418545424938202,
-0.4441087543964386,
-0.24669305980205536,
-0.7180895805358887,
-0.6819290518760681,
0.6480671763420105,
0.4496496915817261,
-0.043666522949934006,
0.010258789174258709,
0.2861563563346863,
0.15776920318603516,
0.38152793049812317,
-0.8565870523452759,
-0.04037388414144516,
-0.15743331611156464,
-0.03895697742700577,
-0.3354624807834625,
-0.025740712881088257,
-0.19390055537223816,
0.042905934154987335,
0.3336385190486908,
-0.1803002804517746,
0.2527003884315491,
0.19287364184856415,
-0.15412425994873047,
-0.44638949632644653,
0.33974891901016235,
0.6126436591148376,
1.2928719520568848,
-0.5139182209968567,
0.2236853986978531,
0.03911766782402992,
-0.3388868570327759,
-0.07898522168397903,
0.6182696223258972,
-0.12307565659284592,
0.005535252392292023,
0.22913402318954468,
0.4382416903972626,
0.2016245573759079,
-1.034798502922058,
0.531139075756073,
0.034239381551742554,
-0.32453522086143494,
-0.33697831630706787,
-0.11736365407705307,
-0.0974586009979248,
-0.057464346289634705,
0.39066752791404724,
0.29678115248680115,
0.13558320701122284,
-0.5523289442062378,
0.2263600081205368,
0.3669593036174774,
-0.3081459403038025,
-0.4813591539859772,
0.7133070826530457,
0.4247138798236847,
-0.5040125846862793,
0.39853596687316895,
-0.5041373372077942,
-0.5484247207641602,
0.6305357217788696,
0.5906283259391785,
0.5421162843704224,
0.17739607393741608,
0.4631056785583496,
0.47315549850463867,
0.37823233008384705,
0.10568087548017502,
0.39151591062545776,
-0.34398987889289856,
-0.6762056350708008,
-0.5912748575210571,
-0.85711669921875,
-0.7335943579673767,
-0.40714403986930847,
-0.4627924859523773,
-0.023999202996492386,
-0.6201294660568237,
0.050499457865953445,
-0.04435437172651291,
0.43737366795539856,
-0.6226232647895813,
0.00782380998134613,
0.1450730860233307,
0.9713724851608276,
-0.7328999638557434,
0.9079692959785461,
0.8131222128868103,
-0.2408064603805542,
-0.8570217490196228,
0.01359231024980545,
-0.14419618248939514,
-0.585551381111145,
0.7659831047058105,
0.26570752263069153,
0.052242524921894073,
-0.06345227360725403,
-0.25280463695526123,
-0.6975524425506592,
1.1794861555099487,
0.10527093708515167,
-0.4095875918865204,
-0.20308858156204224,
0.3256497085094452,
0.6258280277252197,
-0.2565782964229584,
0.03153376281261444,
0.5515931844711304,
0.5635435581207275,
0.015377484261989594,
-1.494545578956604,
0.12733358144760132,
-0.2552170753479004,
-0.05643884092569351,
0.43342888355255127,
0.007485384587198496,
0.9313165545463562,
-0.15855762362480164,
-0.6659067273139954,
0.5723176598548889,
0.4269498586654663,
0.31838691234588623,
0.3450610637664795,
0.45345503091812134,
0.6018716096878052,
0.8385320901870728,
-0.438193142414093,
1.138645887374878,
-0.4858475923538208,
0.4946134388446808,
0.6748453974723816,
-0.8390491008758545,
0.9137740731239319,
0.44081899523735046,
-0.5405167937278748,
0.46508166193962097,
0.31965339183807373,
-0.04173336178064346,
0.7404628396034241,
0.20930339395999908,
-0.1771703064441681,
-0.03398876637220383,
-0.16669632494449615,
-0.23745158314704895,
0.16005703806877136,
0.2790790796279907,
-0.026921629905700684,
-0.5450981259346008,
-0.13644586503505707,
-0.2322963923215866,
0.5457016825675964,
0.07203062623739243,
0.5634248852729797,
-0.22451142966747284,
-0.9980308413505554,
0.4577568769454956,
0.194131538271904,
0.4043634235858917,
-0.4448803961277008,
0.02651377208530903,
0.019104214385151863,
0.42586296796798706,
-0.12855041027069092,
-0.9649932980537415,
0.495116651058197,
0.2116066962480545,
0.021463889628648758,
-0.6564888954162598,
0.2936684787273407,
-0.36670514941215515,
-0.43786099553108215,
0.11227284371852875,
0.4489731788635254,
0.227350115776062,
0.1107955202460289,
-0.6871153116226196,
-0.029316000640392303,
0.04934385046362877,
0.1817052662372589,
0.08655795454978943,
0.3617343008518219,
0.22347310185432434,
0.7624228596687317,
0.8056687116622925,
0.4306827783584595,
-0.05025877431035042,
-0.07513422518968582,
0.9186761379241943,
-0.5728853344917297,
-0.6946284174919128,
-0.40496009588241577,
0.25878357887268066,
-0.13453499972820282,
-0.5905306339263916,
0.6610800623893738,
0.6266596913337708,
0.8457688093185425,
-0.029058149084448814,
0.23184044659137726,
-0.39764848351478577,
0.4822930097579956,
-0.4948776960372925,
0.5063673257827759,
-0.17518797516822815,
0.43245673179626465,
-0.44818276166915894,
-1.0989941358566284,
-0.1296345442533493,
0.7943670749664307,
-0.7142277359962463,
-0.2552621364593506,
0.7862162590026855,
0.7927708029747009,
0.03731642663478851,
-0.24970266222953796,
0.35306501388549805,
-0.057856786996126175,
0.6349721550941467,
0.7742718458175659,
0.8419439792633057,
-0.34523805975914,
0.7922317981719971,
-0.5379622578620911,
-0.34487077593803406,
-0.0021512785460799932,
-0.9224809408187866,
-0.6661065220832825,
-0.6170859932899475,
-0.3937939405441284,
-0.31841692328453064,
0.17709003388881683,
0.7362266182899475,
0.8294575810432434,
-0.5674877762794495,
-0.46219775080680847,
-0.39689311385154724,
-0.03969116881489754,
-0.3319680690765381,
-0.2443617582321167,
0.4451304078102112,
-0.22265274822711945,
-0.7085738182067871,
0.4167807102203369,
0.37042370438575745,
-0.25579768419265747,
-0.3663254976272583,
-0.40579572319984436,
0.05114225670695305,
-0.12257305532693863,
0.2694350481033325,
0.2124495953321457,
-0.8960315585136414,
-0.31354278326034546,
-0.008650840260088444,
-0.3929922580718994,
-0.16377051174640656,
0.6020642518997192,
-0.8871313333511353,
0.5157268047332764,
0.33328351378440857,
0.3732297420501709,
0.49085181951522827,
0.10737057775259018,
0.7112850546836853,
-0.8650182485580444,
0.05456537753343582,
0.34325945377349854,
0.43294844031333923,
0.4222043752670288,
-0.018880605697631836,
0.6961710453033447,
0.12238314747810364,
-0.8550892472267151,
-0.9678489565849304,
0.3180091679096222,
-1.2496334314346313,
-0.13796710968017578,
0.8746219277381897,
-0.20769336819648743,
-0.13614341616630554,
-0.07750184834003448,
-0.2466600090265274,
-0.0887310802936554,
0.021638086065649986,
0.7933039665222168,
0.5569741725921631,
-0.04486135020852089,
-0.013915933668613434,
-0.6080877184867859,
0.6678199768066406,
0.24429549276828766,
-0.8715845346450806,
0.26049959659576416,
0.6031803488731384,
0.16879931092262268,
0.557253360748291,
0.7998042106628418,
-0.043904777616262436,
0.5578678250312805,
0.05829677730798721,
0.1307850033044815,
0.22034387290477753,
-0.19212551414966583,
0.21820572018623352,
0.2343195676803589,
0.28364479541778564,
0.1146339476108551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03320v1 | InternLM-XComposer-2.5: A Versatile Large Vision Language Model Supporting Long-Contextual Input and Output | 2024-07-03T17:59:21 | 2024-07-03T17:59:21 | Pan Zhang, Xiaoyi Dong, Yuhang Zang, Yuhang Cao, Rui Qian, Lin Chen, Qipeng Guo, Haodong Duan, Bin Wang, Linke Ouyang, Songyang Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Yining Li, Yang Gao, Peng Sun, Xinyue Zhang, Wei Li, Jingwen Li, Wenhai Wang, Hang Yan, Conghui He, Xingcheng Zhang, Kai Chen, Jifeng Dai, Yu Qiao, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We present InternLM-XComposer-2.5 (IXC-2.5), a versatile large-vision
language model that supports long-contextual input and output. IXC-2.5 excels
in various text-image comprehension and composition applications, achieving
GPT-4V level capabilities with merely 7B LLM backend. Trained with 24K
interleaved image-text contexts, it can seamlessly extend to 96K long contexts
via RoPE extrapolation. This long-context capability allows IXC-2.5 to excel in
tasks requiring extensive input and output contexts. Compared to its previous
2.0 version, InternLM-XComposer-2.5 features three major upgrades in
vision-language comprehension: (1) Ultra-High Resolution Understanding, (2)
Fine-Grained Video Understanding, and (3) Multi-Turn Multi-Image Dialogue. In
addition to comprehension, IXC-2.5 extends to two compelling applications using
extra LoRA parameters for text-image composition: (1) Crafting Webpages and (2)
Composing High-Quality Text-Image Articles. IXC-2.5 has been evaluated on 28
benchmarks, outperforming existing open-source state-of-the-art models on 16
benchmarks. It also surpasses or competes closely with GPT-4V and Gemini Pro on
16 key tasks. The InternLM-XComposer-2.5 is publicly available at
https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-XComposer. | [
-0.46688663959503174,
-0.31633588671684265,
0.5753116607666016,
0.41570544242858887,
-0.44970405101776123,
0.09976649284362793,
-0.25626739859580994,
-0.8836402297019958,
-0.28790321946144104,
0.5051370859146118,
-0.230923131108284,
-0.494945764541626,
-0.5116052031517029,
-0.09335286915302277,
-0.7582389116287231,
0.842079758644104,
-0.1784168928861618,
-0.03430904820561409,
-0.5035298466682434,
-0.3674704134464264,
-0.6324746608734131,
-0.41506969928741455,
-0.850623369216919,
-0.13980945944786072,
0.8153602480888367,
0.6346227526664734,
0.47081002593040466,
0.49538537859916687,
0.7452841401100159,
0.27467700839042664,
-0.04495352506637573,
0.07395779341459274,
-0.49363893270492554,
0.052142657339572906,
-0.30614474415779114,
-0.35893240571022034,
-0.520305871963501,
-0.21883603930473328,
0.8828015327453613,
0.3050703704357147,
0.11742007732391357,
0.08719678223133087,
0.1679629385471344,
0.7769609689712524,
-0.6063864827156067,
0.4471460282802582,
-0.751227855682373,
-0.18010690808296204,
-0.023791417479515076,
0.04304543510079384,
-0.42916420102119446,
0.3068988621234894,
0.23769895732402802,
-0.5627906918525696,
-0.29647141695022583,
0.22566822171211243,
0.6843276023864746,
0.4106694459915161,
-0.4701889753341675,
-0.11072732508182526,
-0.5605096220970154,
0.613220751285553,
-0.3864540159702301,
0.3355465531349182,
0.23709386587142944,
0.5706298351287842,
0.4355059564113617,
-1.337968111038208,
-0.7940505146980286,
-0.3453802168369293,
-0.0352616012096405,
0.3507239818572998,
-0.18878032267093658,
0.05201773717999458,
0.24399492144584656,
0.38623979687690735,
-0.5561224818229675,
0.1653863787651062,
-0.49589866399765015,
0.33021193742752075,
0.36555221676826477,
0.3267084062099457,
0.30784493684768677,
0.09695983678102493,
-0.4278141260147095,
-0.17364224791526794,
-0.8306451439857483,
0.19343842566013336,
-0.0006594404112547636,
-0.30122053623199463,
-0.3030930161476135,
0.5492070913314819,
-0.1505333036184311,
0.755981981754303,
-0.2745414674282074,
0.1317165642976761,
0.07748589664697647,
-0.4414299428462982,
-0.08223941177129745,
-0.10832557082176208,
0.5106304883956909,
0.6156234741210938,
-0.0832856297492981,
0.27316612005233765,
-0.38047733902931213,
0.09997742623090744,
0.28676164150238037,
-0.7628023624420166,
-0.15398681163787842,
0.022455906495451927,
-0.40858176350593567,
-0.30627164244651794,
-0.03903958946466446,
-0.4654005169868469,
-0.06408336758613586,
-0.5063061118125916,
0.43109285831451416,
-0.3781657814979553,
0.12273726612329483,
-0.04375244304537773,
-0.12563161551952362,
0.4921295940876007,
0.48998475074768066,
-0.7436838746070862,
0.4737936854362488,
0.6907545328140259,
1.0288166999816895,
-0.7254751324653625,
-0.28920453786849976,
-0.6186909675598145,
0.19441145658493042,
-0.3497326970100403,
0.7240933775901794,
-0.45622166991233826,
-0.23062492907047272,
0.05147617310285568,
-0.020804809406399727,
0.2139960527420044,
-0.4846683740615845,
0.546951413154602,
-0.5644877552986145,
0.21391837298870087,
0.08564376831054688,
-0.38672059774398804,
-0.12705634534358978,
0.5405188202857971,
-0.6001113057136536,
1.0745515823364258,
0.5146910548210144,
-0.8224883079528809,
0.150307297706604,
-0.8520345687866211,
-0.4324413537979126,
0.2300012856721878,
-0.3384951949119568,
-0.3435956537723541,
-0.07031633704900742,
-0.12314620614051819,
0.1469418704509735,
-0.5136096477508545,
0.07845805585384369,
-0.1064019501209259,
-0.5803999900817871,
0.3054743707180023,
-0.4031496047973633,
0.5187631249427795,
0.10288190096616745,
-0.4524250626564026,
0.3758903443813324,
-0.8871058225631714,
0.014845500700175762,
-0.07590416073799133,
-0.24834713339805603,
-0.23430053889751434,
0.11674187332391739,
0.3035030961036682,
0.6572407484054565,
0.2776571810245514,
-0.5860916972160339,
0.003652639454230666,
-0.28566616773605347,
0.6092696785926819,
0.6079215407371521,
-0.5712811946868896,
0.3177049160003662,
-0.14264094829559326,
0.5503165125846863,
0.1265963613986969,
0.22007183730602264,
-0.5765934586524963,
-0.43005213141441345,
-1.0751327276229858,
-0.393759548664093,
-0.056172121316194534,
0.6161191463470459,
-0.9504520893096924,
0.19687283039093018,
-0.5031349062919617,
-0.5082436800003052,
-0.022712640464305878,
-0.14295057952404022,
0.521392285823822,
0.7743116617202759,
0.44828876852989197,
-0.0638827458024025,
-0.5542560815811157,
-0.9304603338241577,
0.18860802054405212,
-0.2146265208721161,
0.05976385250687599,
0.424704372882843,
0.5774398446083069,
-0.27599847316741943,
1.002612590789795,
-0.6689226627349854,
-0.5390061736106873,
-0.45415571331977844,
-0.018469151109457016,
0.15762153267860413,
0.46003755927085876,
0.5719535946846008,
-0.9725913405418396,
-1.0723485946655273,
0.4661761224269867,
-0.6380306482315063,
0.052579138427972794,
-0.0007594453054480255,
0.0718548446893692,
0.508069634437561,
0.8148335218429565,
-0.599359393119812,
0.48935556411743164,
0.808799684047699,
-0.4043925404548645,
0.7356423735618591,
-0.3387046754360199,
-0.166009783744812,
-1.016696810722351,
0.2073592245578766,
-0.041426174342632294,
-0.560019314289093,
-0.48411500453948975,
0.20524270832538605,
0.3961091935634613,
-0.018347088247537613,
-0.7012710571289062,
0.9114089012145996,
-0.30355069041252136,
-0.0054140640422701836,
-0.5961349606513977,
0.006719542667269707,
0.09718196839094162,
0.4144468307495117,
0.18615825474262238,
0.938178539276123,
0.8151959776878357,
-0.28911176323890686,
0.376671701669693,
0.27194511890411377,
-0.7223773002624512,
0.4585161507129669,
-0.9633850455284119,
0.06421606242656708,
-0.13665889203548431,
0.3773271143436432,
-1.0116267204284668,
-0.25768110156059265,
0.3367985188961029,
-0.3125603199005127,
0.28891581296920776,
-0.03436758369207382,
-0.3782094717025757,
-0.4630168378353119,
-0.41310542821884155,
0.4120529592037201,
0.6473067998886108,
-0.7088022232055664,
0.6368954181671143,
0.15004587173461914,
-0.4514296054840088,
-0.4878075122833252,
-0.7968791127204895,
0.4713585376739502,
-0.03345327079296112,
-0.7598769068717957,
0.5794006586074829,
-0.27308934926986694,
-0.25220808386802673,
0.004946505650877953,
0.21591584384441376,
-0.002377578290179372,
-0.3572465181350708,
0.3564877212047577,
0.6484619379043579,
-0.17667722702026367,
-0.053125858306884766,
0.09999808669090271,
-0.37832188606262207,
0.024644531309604645,
-0.3284224271774292,
0.4063357412815094,
-0.17963732779026031,
-0.15569418668746948,
-0.09140632301568985,
0.7219076156616211,
0.7230585217475891,
-0.346236914396286,
0.5505155920982361,
0.5657181739807129,
-0.09210207313299179,
0.0394064225256443,
-0.4286996126174927,
0.12138140201568604,
-0.5094354748725891,
0.8102342486381531,
-0.4611804783344269,
-1.0406246185302734,
0.3411244750022888,
0.3389523923397064,
0.19170552492141724,
0.2097119688987732,
0.5573687553405762,
-0.25410160422325134,
1.27388596534729,
0.6574342846870422,
0.1630953997373581,
0.6063938736915588,
-0.38326916098594666,
0.2607099115848541,
-1.172059416770935,
-0.17860230803489685,
-0.18637581169605255,
-0.3768293559551239,
-0.25797462463378906,
-0.6211843490600586,
0.5500012040138245,
-0.4884651303291321,
-0.19508439302444458,
0.08305472880601883,
-0.3117583096027374,
0.5138360261917114,
0.7644666433334351,
-0.11874641478061676,
0.3443482518196106,
0.021580712869763374,
0.09741026908159256,
0.04179822653532028,
-0.4808954894542694,
-0.32809215784072876,
0.7456138730049133,
0.28909486532211304,
0.8611561059951782,
-0.0909014493227005,
0.04067583009600639,
-0.009007927030324936,
0.19431914389133453,
-0.8119800090789795,
0.6142249703407288,
-0.5700443983078003,
-0.518979012966156,
-0.2157122641801834,
0.054180342704057693,
-0.5552760362625122,
0.3454763889312744,
0.17799508571624756,
-0.7634610533714294,
0.20929694175720215,
0.31391215324401855,
-0.2528127431869507,
0.3018045127391815,
-0.5545390844345093,
0.8640868663787842,
-0.3307701647281647,
-0.5848367214202881,
-0.3362363278865814,
-0.9865849018096924,
0.24377894401550293,
-0.1409701555967331,
-0.2511369287967682,
-0.043683972209692,
-0.4024277925491333,
0.2639007568359375,
-0.28231722116470337,
0.7323529720306396,
0.1607355922460556,
-0.132163867354393,
0.3061918020248413,
-0.2915831506252289,
0.6357056498527527,
0.22679868340492249,
-0.1365538090467453,
0.1920432448387146,
0.05040815845131874,
0.012582870200276375,
-0.5496886372566223,
0.8896177411079407,
-0.7368646860122681,
-0.5730775594711304,
-0.5348978042602539,
-0.582719624042511,
0.010505307465791702,
0.21967941522598267,
0.5415076613426208,
0.6357770562171936,
-0.11275157332420349,
0.7007409334182739,
0.49383828043937683,
-0.16129443049430847,
0.5965444445610046,
0.41715168952941895,
-0.3800273537635803,
-0.5245126485824585,
1.0365464687347412,
0.04128394275903702,
0.39136451482772827,
0.596809983253479,
-0.10584329813718796,
-0.26294228434562683,
-0.6128126382827759,
-0.44452965259552,
-0.08231822401285172,
-0.926729679107666,
-0.251560777425766,
-0.8859624862670898,
-0.4230547845363617,
-0.1575980931520462,
-0.33284232020378113,
-0.4124689996242523,
-0.27027782797813416,
-0.4543743431568146,
0.1593114137649536,
0.058740172535181046,
0.31446751952171326,
0.0666787251830101,
0.4260851740837097,
-0.6945889592170715,
0.5250982046127319,
0.40452733635902405,
0.4402741491794586,
-0.2101612687110901,
-0.612531304359436,
-0.4798039495944977,
-0.1940811723470688,
-0.24824070930480957,
-0.3260821998119354,
0.3417748212814331,
0.34166350960731506,
0.12721635401248932,
0.4178020656108856,
-0.1735306829214096,
0.5275825262069702,
-0.5626003742218018,
0.8487902879714966,
0.44959133863449097,
-0.8825521469116211,
0.1301080286502838,
-0.31505823135375977,
0.7657754421234131,
0.5081838369369507,
0.1304737627506256,
-0.7963443398475647,
-0.2762542963027954,
-0.05113517865538597,
-0.9297066330909729,
0.9524745345115662,
0.264305979013443,
0.3153435289859772,
-0.02435016818344593,
0.25496038794517517,
0.20615938305854797,
-0.007200753781944513,
-0.8729892373085022,
-0.15349319577217102,
-0.43885165452957153,
-0.29152828454971313,
0.008161508478224277,
-0.6502523422241211,
0.09297666698694229,
-0.48920395970344543,
0.6988048553466797,
-0.48696228861808777,
0.14491119980812073,
0.26228126883506775,
-0.17529237270355225,
0.20281560719013214,
-0.01323283463716507,
0.5709306597709656,
0.9627349376678467,
0.11959122866392136,
0.263997346162796,
0.11166942119598389,
-0.5424266457557678,
0.10693735629320145,
0.17805494368076324,
-0.39921489357948303,
-0.16167838871479034,
0.2978619337081909,
1.1817116737365723,
0.13694341480731964,
-0.9676123857498169,
0.5914512872695923,
-0.2731599807739258,
-0.30206331610679626,
-0.7291076183319092,
0.16033118963241577,
0.10718634724617004,
0.12986990809440613,
0.265146940946579,
0.07190688699483871,
0.245320126414299,
-0.44079872965812683,
-0.023151632398366928,
0.3652089536190033,
-0.7431243062019348,
-0.33976617455482483,
0.7125194668769836,
0.1436910778284073,
0.11540258675813675,
0.7229393720626831,
-0.09998024255037308,
-0.4067741930484772,
0.612154483795166,
0.8036659955978394,
0.682299792766571,
0.16036130487918854,
0.1206463947892189,
0.37304380536079407,
0.07408656179904938,
0.17084920406341553,
0.4336645305156708,
-0.001239774632267654,
-0.5500638484954834,
-0.5755030512809753,
-0.30047667026519775,
-0.3501278758049011,
-0.06515691429376602,
-0.3711252510547638,
0.6334974765777588,
-0.16816996037960052,
0.11359892785549164,
-0.1300901174545288,
-0.23829713463783264,
-0.5022040009498596,
0.24923333525657654,
0.333450585603714,
1.175248146057129,
-0.208909273147583,
1.1851472854614258,
0.8293905854225159,
-0.1538471132516861,
-0.6123763918876648,
-0.37504786252975464,
-0.22053061425685883,
-0.6809211373329163,
0.8200215101242065,
0.3432672619819641,
-0.16863591969013214,
0.11004641652107239,
-0.695275068283081,
-0.8530188202857971,
1.240571141242981,
0.24330122768878937,
-0.7986261248588562,
-0.11327337473630905,
0.33067747950553894,
0.46135270595550537,
-0.4900144338607788,
0.18262091279029846,
0.4929206073284149,
0.5901735424995422,
0.3149295747280121,
-0.6432405710220337,
-0.1883869171142578,
-0.46044033765792847,
0.23709070682525635,
-0.002413383685052395,
-0.7715633511543274,
0.772728681564331,
-0.22112929821014404,
0.0345412977039814,
0.5532204508781433,
0.7862855792045593,
0.14156264066696167,
0.2936486303806305,
0.6025800704956055,
0.4197568893432617,
0.13701288402080536,
-0.05787273123860359,
1.119960904121399,
-0.3877238631248474,
-0.0022147763520479202,
1.6129599809646606,
-0.4908732771873474,
0.9234697818756104,
0.5934959650039673,
0.2114444524049759,
0.5228282809257507,
0.32783472537994385,
-0.020986715331673622,
0.5512613654136658,
-0.06951060891151428,
-0.5535584092140198,
-0.011401807889342308,
-0.09925829619169235,
-0.26929110288619995,
0.6027345061302185,
0.41572636365890503,
-0.3236532211303711,
0.1439415067434311,
0.2897546887397766,
-0.22853921353816986,
-0.31162136793136597,
-0.19651149213314056,
0.7632238268852234,
0.2655636966228485,
-1.030188798904419,
0.28919345140457153,
-0.034005749970674515,
0.537017285823822,
-0.8435783386230469,
-0.1984338015317917,
-0.16235844790935516,
0.4713050127029419,
-0.007585674989968538,
-1.303917407989502,
0.2878013253211975,
-0.03995795547962189,
-0.16550084948539734,
-0.09090020507574081,
1.0013200044631958,
-0.48548832535743713,
-0.5713172554969788,
0.3251408040523529,
-0.0016966693801805377,
-0.16722041368484497,
-0.468428373336792,
-0.4227578341960907,
0.3873552680015564,
-0.023645561188459396,
-0.03522523492574692,
0.22172091901302338,
0.15288150310516357,
-0.27762311697006226,
0.7429999113082886,
0.4583272337913513,
-0.17170703411102295,
0.02063741907477379,
0.04045144468545914,
1.0761847496032715,
-0.6027234792709351,
-0.5513271689414978,
-0.7081373929977417,
0.7133410573005676,
-0.28108155727386475,
-0.4364572763442993,
0.45508530735969543,
0.7450169920921326,
0.7902277112007141,
-0.24048687517642975,
0.8253285884857178,
-0.18776893615722656,
0.14542555809020996,
-0.3302724361419678,
0.5105366110801697,
-0.8093265295028687,
-0.10704485327005386,
0.03135126084089279,
-1.1129239797592163,
-0.5552663803100586,
0.286220520734787,
-0.10138820111751556,
-0.18331579864025116,
0.8827295899391174,
0.6806222200393677,
-0.17693106830120087,
-0.15025974810123444,
0.5766564011573792,
0.21888700127601624,
0.5995897650718689,
0.3627816140651703,
1.043287992477417,
-0.29162508249282837,
0.8809690475463867,
-0.19286921620368958,
-0.312603235244751,
-0.29806995391845703,
-0.7569808959960938,
-0.7948740720748901,
-0.7356924414634705,
-0.3212442696094513,
0.15813817083835602,
0.01497231051325798,
0.7277662754058838,
0.9323318600654602,
-0.43381813168525696,
-0.17035670578479767,
-0.08867839723825455,
-0.17512944340705872,
-0.159230574965477,
-0.1705566942691803,
0.1915852129459381,
-0.27443620562553406,
-0.9543177485466003,
0.25991687178611755,
0.9579007029533386,
-0.005125498399138451,
-0.4018315374851227,
-0.3084464967250824,
0.03543417900800705,
-0.028006743639707565,
1.208761215209961,
0.2573226988315582,
-0.6667653322219849,
-0.2644507884979248,
0.15019546449184418,
-0.19123174250125885,
0.4768826365470886,
0.7667484283447266,
-0.812537431716919,
0.36403077840805054,
0.6803691387176514,
0.3259926736354828,
0.6777401566505432,
-0.39948737621307373,
0.4800221025943756,
-0.4572668969631195,
0.22725513577461243,
0.1261015087366104,
0.5729446411132812,
0.31714463233947754,
-0.13031521439552307,
0.6071372032165527,
-0.2789001166820526,
-0.49836522340774536,
-0.4866868257522583,
0.15819264948368073,
-1.344963550567627,
-0.2722215950489044,
1.1675893068313599,
-0.1278398633003235,
-0.23119615018367767,
0.015468467958271503,
-0.828778088092804,
-0.053800832480192184,
-0.13715559244155884,
0.5964168310165405,
0.5476792454719543,
0.036146774888038635,
-0.4885260760784149,
-0.46769022941589355,
0.016870204359292984,
0.30643871426582336,
-1.0965746641159058,
-0.04512105509638786,
0.45540252327919006,
0.011282178573310375,
-0.041890569031238556,
0.6689116358757019,
-0.43515321612358093,
0.5917307734489441,
-0.2251979112625122,
0.006283238995820284,
-0.05459747463464737,
-0.5408540368080139,
-0.06773598492145538,
0.015698930248618126,
0.06850731372833252,
-0.09284554421901703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03314v1 | BACON: Supercharge Your VLM with Bag-of-Concept Graph to Mitigate Hallucinations | 2024-07-03T17:55:27 | 2024-07-03T17:55:27 | Zhantao Yang, Ruili Feng, Keyu Yan, Huangji Wang, Zhicai Wang, Shangwen Zhu, Han Zhang, Jie Xiao, Pingyu Wu, Kai Zhu, Jixuan Chen, Chen-Wei Xie, Chaojie Mao, Yue Yang, Hongyang Zhang, Yu Liu, Fan Cheng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.DB | This paper presents Bag-of-Concept Graph (BACON) to gift models with limited
linguistic abilities to taste the privilege of Vision Language Models (VLMs)
and boost downstream tasks such as detection, visual question answering (VQA),
and image generation. Since the visual scenes in physical worlds are structured
with complex relations between objects, BACON breaks down annotations into
basic minimum elements and presents them in a graph structure. Element-wise
style enables easy understanding, and structural composition liberates
difficult locating. Careful prompt design births the BACON captions with the
help of public-available VLMs and segmentation methods. In this way, we gather
a dataset with 100K annotated images, which endow VLMs with remarkable
capabilities, such as accurately generating BACON, transforming prompts into
BACON format, envisioning scenarios in the style of BACONr, and dynamically
modifying elements within BACON through interactive dialogue and more. Wide
representative experiments, including detection, VQA, and image generation
tasks, tell BACON as a lifeline to achieve previous out-of-reach tasks or excel
in their current cutting-edge solutions. | [
-0.5232805013656616,
-0.6351946592330933,
0.3282535672187805,
-0.21144193410873413,
-0.48630741238594055,
0.33747193217277527,
0.13061125576496124,
-0.8614577651023865,
0.5475852489471436,
0.8507404923439026,
-0.6537364721298218,
-0.1721276491880417,
-0.4019175171852112,
-0.15975242853164673,
-0.6345953345298767,
1.4236900806427002,
0.44973239302635193,
-0.24184882640838623,
-0.32914671301841736,
0.13893628120422363,
-0.2241683006286621,
-0.6238031983375549,
-0.322330504655838,
-0.16635659337043762,
0.8712572455406189,
0.1301809698343277,
0.6363685131072998,
0.4952453672885895,
0.39041054248809814,
0.2920275926589966,
-0.06021551042795181,
0.48160645365715027,
-0.7878085970878601,
0.21355170011520386,
-0.19740554690361023,
0.05093039199709892,
-0.3851945102214813,
-0.40977075695991516,
0.3240791857242584,
0.46758928894996643,
0.28756698966026306,
0.15424181520938873,
-0.10803649574518204,
0.4856724143028259,
-0.5615130066871643,
0.030994504690170288,
-1.0098023414611816,
-0.04091101512312889,
0.03746290132403374,
-0.27654340863227844,
-0.3447582721710205,
0.012654042802751064,
0.18558263778686523,
-0.8009580373764038,
0.14835508167743683,
0.2311907559633255,
1.2015585899353027,
0.3115527331829071,
0.0268513523042202,
-0.09484100341796875,
-0.7427836060523987,
0.6210702657699585,
-0.16605986654758453,
0.34455081820487976,
0.2509063482284546,
0.3226366341114044,
-0.04839400202035904,
-1.0390790700912476,
-0.7098115682601929,
-0.3590678572654724,
-0.3108038604259491,
0.04408169537782669,
0.00590283889323473,
-0.08822527527809143,
0.5026634335517883,
0.1113220602273941,
-0.5518798232078552,
-0.2952239513397217,
-0.5343536138534546,
-0.2391398847103119,
0.585943341255188,
0.1726294606924057,
0.5657695531845093,
-0.192289799451828,
-0.48655635118484497,
-0.10487491637468338,
-0.2911309599876404,
-0.1671660840511322,
0.1559254676103592,
0.19821174442768097,
0.33824434876441956,
0.5675647854804993,
-0.49547335505485535,
0.9250405430793762,
-0.4773789048194885,
-0.09846485406160355,
0.19736738502979279,
-0.3764447271823883,
-0.268703818321228,
-0.04805474355816841,
0.3924620449542999,
0.6869134902954102,
0.37266266345977783,
-0.2321416139602661,
-0.1791229546070099,
0.271814227104187,
0.5183137655258179,
-0.9148144125938416,
-0.5976073145866394,
0.11259547621011734,
-0.22921136021614075,
-0.23791055381298065,
0.13642150163650513,
-0.8413578867912292,
-0.5292388796806335,
-0.11223441362380981,
0.3757714331150055,
-0.3036511540412903,
-0.3358549177646637,
0.30492839217185974,
-0.5309421420097351,
0.343778133392334,
0.4297432005405426,
-0.6878345608711243,
0.3538084030151367,
0.4817546010017395,
0.880426287651062,
-0.05734813213348389,
-0.09797339141368866,
-0.6544752717018127,
0.25890013575553894,
-0.16767176985740662,
0.9783636927604675,
-0.7123996019363403,
-0.49928632378578186,
-0.06698144227266312,
0.1432608813047409,
0.2839168906211853,
-0.3501622974872589,
0.6694943308830261,
-0.27605777978897095,
-0.10260868817567825,
-0.609875500202179,
-0.2578924298286438,
-0.09474482387304306,
0.4190608561038971,
-0.6398305892944336,
1.0518226623535156,
0.041575394570827484,
-1.0033645629882812,
0.2232721447944641,
-0.8111695051193237,
-0.2954217493534088,
0.8148845434188843,
-0.3816593587398529,
-0.17946793138980865,
0.23078592121601105,
0.2336069494485855,
0.5849971175193787,
0.29682406783103943,
0.013995437882840633,
-0.2938939929008484,
-0.21110917627811432,
0.35637107491493225,
0.09733908623456955,
0.585932731628418,
0.3062003254890442,
-0.14404790103435516,
0.29375094175338745,
-0.7015318274497986,
0.27621328830718994,
0.2051982581615448,
0.29744046926498413,
-0.5922638177871704,
0.003168498631566763,
0.39429953694343567,
0.16964352130889893,
-0.025574317201972008,
-0.5575788021087646,
0.2824968993663788,
-0.3366239070892334,
0.7809231281280518,
0.6203598380088806,
-0.15032026171684265,
0.020389465615153313,
-0.3051047921180725,
0.18692971765995026,
-0.051229409873485565,
0.33640387654304504,
-0.25226303935050964,
-0.6671764254570007,
-0.7740981578826904,
-0.3430967926979065,
0.057899534702301025,
0.40931686758995056,
-1.2419278621673584,
0.2954312562942505,
-0.23078995943069458,
-0.42628079652786255,
-0.2170857936143875,
-0.19595938920974731,
0.35837623476982117,
0.7935119271278381,
0.3842734694480896,
-0.23959776759147644,
-0.4503130316734314,
-0.8813177347183228,
0.0831153392791748,
-0.15870098769664764,
-0.07014088332653046,
0.13690781593322754,
0.829435408115387,
-0.2447003722190857,
0.7359433770179749,
-0.690228283405304,
-0.2921087443828583,
-0.30403169989585876,
-0.24027754366397858,
-0.11095407605171204,
0.4486733376979828,
0.3927600085735321,
-1.1364039182662964,
-0.049393605440855026,
0.15116672217845917,
-0.49768149852752686,
0.010266132652759552,
-0.02598249353468418,
-0.4956378936767578,
0.15715306997299194,
0.2721981108188629,
-0.5662173628807068,
0.8137105703353882,
0.15757176280021667,
-0.622096061706543,
0.7774994969367981,
-0.10281731188297272,
-0.15741673111915588,
-0.7968674302101135,
0.02026177942752838,
-0.08849816769361496,
-0.2940227687358856,
-0.6434106826782227,
0.32844045758247375,
-0.23582184314727783,
-0.07927330583333969,
-0.6067785024642944,
0.7297572493553162,
-0.1864384561777115,
-0.08160174638032913,
-0.133113831281662,
0.10000529140233994,
0.3459061086177826,
0.3736386299133301,
0.34436580538749695,
0.34331250190734863,
0.7051191329956055,
-0.5206738114356995,
0.3642793297767639,
0.31676214933395386,
-0.23564757406711578,
0.4837161898612976,
-0.6766452789306641,
0.2522236108779907,
-0.13486522436141968,
0.11519482731819153,
-1.2403868436813354,
-0.1953759789466858,
0.49316659569740295,
-0.5168839693069458,
0.0686827003955841,
0.20417208969593048,
-0.31316396594047546,
-0.5296348929405212,
-0.47275224328041077,
0.18740922212600708,
0.4607977867126465,
-0.6069746017456055,
0.7279171347618103,
0.2167639285326004,
0.3057835102081299,
-0.4915950894355774,
-0.8220610618591309,
0.30315062403678894,
-0.19227565824985504,
-0.4118522107601166,
0.544110894203186,
-0.4059433937072754,
-0.14017705619335175,
0.2899637818336487,
-0.12979580461978912,
0.18251074850559235,
0.004564071539789438,
0.3625904619693756,
0.45989760756492615,
0.19374123215675354,
0.2442108392715454,
-0.3273172676563263,
-0.14411775767803192,
-0.04082878306508064,
-0.8227881789207458,
0.5680654644966125,
-0.16123445332050323,
-0.10855477303266525,
-0.1377410888671875,
0.5595602989196777,
0.6024368405342102,
-0.32919928431510925,
0.5037450790405273,
0.8629476428031921,
-0.6771664619445801,
-0.41854703426361084,
-0.42690905928611755,
-0.34631866216659546,
-0.4780367612838745,
0.48386290669441223,
-0.6166867613792419,
-0.712330162525177,
0.536266565322876,
0.16081516444683075,
-0.08807273954153061,
-0.013182644732296467,
0.5649222135543823,
-0.21677100658416748,
0.941973865032196,
0.7016031742095947,
0.3051661252975464,
0.6262311935424805,
-0.6920584440231323,
0.43687981367111206,
-0.9167397022247314,
-0.4957832992076874,
-0.3917143940925598,
-0.3708970248699188,
-0.5094416737556458,
-0.40338245034217834,
0.2905323803424835,
-0.0010171238100156188,
-0.08113706856966019,
-0.02009529061615467,
-1.1286685466766357,
0.770268976688385,
0.611639678478241,
0.3881068229675293,
0.14464810490608215,
0.33930397033691406,
-0.16898146271705627,
0.0029855547472834587,
-0.6443349719047546,
-0.5333915948867798,
0.7956518530845642,
0.16037428379058838,
0.6460665464401245,
-0.4519933760166168,
0.6537809371948242,
0.2822425663471222,
0.07205039262771606,
-1.0318371057510376,
0.7887864112854004,
-0.2416723519563675,
-0.34947437047958374,
-0.4049743115901947,
-0.1004774421453476,
-0.46088677644729614,
0.16185705363750458,
-0.21872368454933167,
-1.350516676902771,
0.10132775455713272,
0.1316758096218109,
-0.5362237691879272,
0.40370649099349976,
-0.6656414270401001,
0.7589664459228516,
-0.32639366388320923,
-0.6449314951896667,
0.288786917924881,
-0.5317484140396118,
0.3292241096496582,
0.25685015320777893,
0.01804637350142002,
0.24690262973308563,
-0.04413346201181412,
0.7353224754333496,
-0.4041270315647125,
0.8208836913108826,
-0.020454343408346176,
0.08169476687908173,
0.20614951848983765,
0.16131876409053802,
0.5184667706489563,
0.0970999151468277,
0.14122556149959564,
0.07829466462135315,
0.1913105994462967,
-0.38981083035469055,
-0.841996431350708,
0.6789959669113159,
-0.6706622838973999,
-0.5639917254447937,
-0.29917216300964355,
-0.6010691523551941,
-0.04281638190150261,
0.019143030047416687,
0.44803565740585327,
0.6205148696899414,
0.3398197293281555,
0.1520606428384781,
0.7244550585746765,
-0.2553512156009674,
0.37666863203048706,
-0.00914059765636921,
-0.7792603373527527,
-0.4674258530139923,
1.3025044202804565,
0.39711707830429077,
0.2232932299375534,
0.14185364544391632,
0.27131593227386475,
-0.517474353313446,
-0.6180961728096008,
-0.3735553026199341,
0.24589362740516663,
-0.7669392824172974,
-0.20004576444625854,
-1.2085148096084595,
-0.3761298954486847,
-0.32801905274391174,
-0.3374822437763214,
-0.054971400648355484,
-0.35148394107818604,
-0.2307080775499344,
-0.37490224838256836,
0.5366833209991455,
0.6757495403289795,
0.057979896664619446,
0.14155730605125427,
-0.3463614583015442,
0.6258471608161926,
0.5753878355026245,
0.21318325400352478,
-0.08262070268392563,
-0.21668478846549988,
-0.18509721755981445,
-0.07826008647680283,
-0.16197504103183746,
-0.6829176545143127,
0.5921579599380493,
0.16580204665660858,
0.4192381799221039,
0.260855495929718,
0.4028303325176239,
0.9819306135177612,
-0.23332218825817108,
1.0540608167648315,
0.33855167031288147,
-0.9642406105995178,
0.5838640332221985,
-0.1422644555568695,
0.0391133613884449,
0.0950731560587883,
0.24429963529109955,
-0.3921452462673187,
-0.573347806930542,
-0.6221593618392944,
-0.9673166275024414,
0.3161523938179016,
0.29077139496803284,
0.2612330913543701,
0.20854981243610382,
0.23222626745700836,
0.0541614405810833,
0.2502521872520447,
-0.8319013714790344,
0.04659844934940338,
-0.7024126648902893,
0.07335221022367477,
0.1481758952140808,
-0.32746002078056335,
-0.332281231880188,
-0.8372660875320435,
0.5501962304115295,
-0.3568403720855713,
0.31921154260635376,
0.5318976640701294,
0.37008920311927795,
0.08445398509502411,
-0.22622500360012054,
0.6484690308570862,
0.6711648106575012,
-0.18264909088611603,
0.4111981689929962,
-0.012015043757855892,
-0.5821057558059692,
-0.17698363959789276,
-0.2566659152507782,
-0.23122729361057281,
0.005833057686686516,
0.38644590973854065,
0.9590641260147095,
-0.2738822102546692,
-0.7449222207069397,
-0.03848698362708092,
-0.11665396392345428,
-0.26930731534957886,
-0.20461589097976685,
0.2752079963684082,
0.022086938843131065,
0.312622606754303,
0.4005119800567627,
-0.2534666359424591,
0.39955246448516846,
-0.586800754070282,
0.4550965428352356,
0.5463654398918152,
-0.3733203411102295,
-0.16698065400123596,
0.574165403842926,
0.08165232837200165,
-0.5230258107185364,
0.4316707253456116,
-0.6116852760314941,
-0.9192928075790405,
0.631719172000885,
0.6914154887199402,
0.9398705959320068,
0.22238057851791382,
0.6714993119239807,
0.11283804476261139,
0.5193488597869873,
0.18567894399166107,
0.4810183644294739,
-0.10650061815977097,
-0.9180206060409546,
-0.32623526453971863,
-0.8506892919540405,
-0.20283342897891998,
0.5593239665031433,
-0.47886449098587036,
0.2762371599674225,
-0.246137335896492,
-0.04974862188100815,
0.04222146049141884,
0.21567222476005554,
-0.6816040873527527,
0.3101695775985718,
0.39361265301704407,
0.748613715171814,
-0.6156224608421326,
1.1323152780532837,
0.799565851688385,
-0.26504969596862793,
-0.7952636480331421,
-0.08355097472667694,
-0.3979796767234802,
-0.7070212364196777,
0.8960763216018677,
0.3474067151546478,
-0.27656054496765137,
0.23170165717601776,
-0.8370047211647034,
-0.4441329836845398,
0.7025812864303589,
0.2907043993473053,
-0.7284281849861145,
-0.06033005565404892,
-0.08032814413309097,
0.5871332883834839,
-0.6561980247497559,
0.34950345754623413,
0.5569578409194946,
0.5072456002235413,
0.7328093647956848,
-0.5267377495765686,
0.03107486665248871,
-0.4709787666797638,
0.24570316076278687,
0.004256760235875845,
-0.2867486774921417,
0.8031638860702515,
-0.3807677626609802,
-0.3248177468776703,
-0.13746508955955505,
0.34805142879486084,
0.16700124740600586,
0.45328328013420105,
0.6542125344276428,
0.6439275145530701,
0.8094488382339478,
-0.1215294599533081,
0.922926664352417,
-0.14811347424983978,
0.1595928817987442,
1.1086158752441406,
-0.39615851640701294,
0.6983321905136108,
0.7109841704368591,
0.28995710611343384,
0.42199936509132385,
0.6069298386573792,
0.10760819911956787,
0.6377026438713074,
0.49044498801231384,
-0.03745820000767708,
-0.44429054856300354,
-0.6093941926956177,
-0.50858473777771,
0.2684706449508667,
0.5932002067565918,
-0.12838631868362427,
-0.15263451635837555,
0.40483275055885315,
-0.16871494054794312,
0.034536492079496384,
-0.2122664600610733,
0.7393231391906738,
-0.053212255239486694,
-0.11325454711914062,
0.8032488226890564,
-0.8318716883659363,
0.49479562044143677,
-0.5382451415061951,
-0.39960017800331116,
-0.16685350239276886,
-0.18951788544654846,
-0.2941778600215912,
-0.675750732421875,
0.40625494718551636,
0.005310297943651676,
-0.005584129597991705,
-0.2925102114677429,
1.09112548828125,
-0.25604143738746643,
-0.957230269908905,
0.5524846911430359,
0.4794892370700836,
0.35917893052101135,
-0.18315574526786804,
-0.6580639481544495,
0.710379958152771,
-0.07931284606456757,
-0.2815713584423065,
0.0869775339961052,
0.5425243973731995,
-0.10862941294908524,
0.7148371934890747,
0.6646407246589661,
0.30462732911109924,
0.015073748305439949,
-0.07285214215517044,
1.3645802736282349,
-0.7509692311286926,
-0.6832329034805298,
-0.940782904624939,
0.8254930377006531,
-0.4287135601043701,
-0.19660423696041107,
0.4690777361392975,
0.28421154618263245,
1.152486801147461,
-0.2603408098220825,
0.8338537812232971,
-0.1992693394422531,
-0.051450394093990326,
-0.5610772371292114,
0.6696540117263794,
-0.7719009518623352,
0.12088226526975632,
-0.4575658142566681,
-0.8216630220413208,
-0.306402325630188,
0.7096108794212341,
-0.24268245697021484,
-0.29012390971183777,
0.7574278712272644,
0.9740856289863586,
0.1390579342842102,
-0.030946973711252213,
0.8415770530700684,
0.1626535803079605,
0.43246063590049744,
0.6307557225227356,
1.1835623979568481,
-0.16793082654476166,
0.4068303406238556,
-0.33487987518310547,
-0.279744416475296,
-0.27740079164505005,
-1.092441439628601,
-1.000575304031372,
-0.9345102906227112,
-0.6391259431838989,
-0.33600160479545593,
0.02823949232697487,
0.6583268642425537,
1.107994556427002,
-0.6993449926376343,
-0.1031424030661583,
-0.046241216361522675,
0.359368234872818,
-0.29084452986717224,
-0.26159608364105225,
0.1448085755109787,
-0.3241370916366577,
-0.5463052988052368,
-0.10920072346925735,
0.5299202799797058,
0.07572595030069351,
-0.6176461577415466,
0.0060197897255420685,
0.07938633859157562,
0.11066564172506332,
0.9478906989097595,
-0.07919642329216003,
-0.9434332251548767,
-0.6204078793525696,
-0.052151571959257126,
0.22039318084716797,
-0.19469767808914185,
0.8565438985824585,
-1.1791629791259766,
0.7231380343437195,
0.410697340965271,
0.5898062586784363,
0.31858065724372864,
-0.1581908017396927,
0.013117916882038116,
-0.5284844636917114,
0.28511571884155273,
0.28883442282676697,
0.240130215883255,
0.13275977969169617,
-0.729049563407898,
0.555307924747467,
0.48964011669158936,
-0.23622922599315643,
-1.325348138809204,
0.5069359540939331,
-1.2748165130615234,
-0.40987566113471985,
0.9725470542907715,
-0.02854728326201439,
-0.6707655191421509,
-0.156865194439888,
-0.8000466823577881,
0.03640148416161537,
-0.31365349888801575,
0.8479467034339905,
0.649318516254425,
-0.19643913209438324,
-0.28043317794799805,
-0.6789815425872803,
0.7089260816574097,
0.04649917408823967,
-0.9491230249404907,
0.12923277914524078,
0.4641355872154236,
-0.11733710020780563,
0.5156440734863281,
0.45626580715179443,
0.21869060397148132,
-0.173256978392601,
-0.045358166098594666,
0.002179696224629879,
-0.43236932158470154,
-0.8134653568267822,
0.10359407216310501,
0.319396048784256,
-0.18680663406848907,
-0.5168917775154114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03302v1 | A Review of the Applications of Deep Learning-Based Emergent Communication | 2024-07-03T17:43:54 | 2024-07-03T17:43:54 | Brendon Boldt, David Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; I.6.m | Emergent communication, or emergent language, is the field of research which
studies how human language-like communication systems emerge de novo in deep
multi-agent reinforcement learning environments. The possibilities of
replicating the emergence of a complex behavior like language have strong
intuitive appeal, yet it is necessary to complement this with clear notions of
how such research can be applicable to other fields of science, technology, and
engineering. This paper comprehensively reviews the applications of emergent
communication research across machine learning, natural language processing,
linguistics, and cognitive science. Each application is illustrated with a
description of its scope, an explication of emergent communication's unique
role in addressing it, a summary of the extant literature working towards the
application, and brief recommendations for near-term research directions. | [
-0.3607915937900543,
-1.2271102666854858,
0.5139338970184326,
0.4643363356590271,
0.0669511929154396,
0.8316810131072998,
-0.24896056950092316,
-0.9190760850906372,
0.09368357062339783,
0.1776866614818573,
-0.3712477385997772,
-0.02000913955271244,
-0.2595458924770355,
-0.22653096914291382,
-0.6540617942810059,
0.4862513840198517,
0.23629064857959747,
-0.14659611880779266,
0.1656920313835144,
0.2325868308544159,
-0.262685090303421,
-0.34473326802253723,
-1.2896097898483276,
-0.770487368106842,
0.5328046679496765,
0.4139951467514038,
0.5573545694351196,
0.08710017800331116,
0.5561811327934265,
0.38129496574401855,
-0.2361067831516266,
0.10772747546434402,
-0.26001521944999695,
0.42318248748779297,
-0.19995619356632233,
-0.5591304302215576,
0.062113672494888306,
0.10983177274465561,
0.9810013771057129,
0.9182735681533813,
-0.10981909930706024,
-0.2541338801383972,
0.22836369276046753,
0.6685650944709778,
-0.39909735321998596,
0.023588629439473152,
-0.2327684462070465,
0.2452779859304428,
-0.11763843894004822,
-0.31077539920806885,
-0.4998622536659241,
-0.3286898732185364,
0.44471874833106995,
-0.255425363779068,
-0.0912235826253891,
-0.13875722885131836,
0.4798274338245392,
-0.07271628081798553,
-0.5606298446655273,
-0.5368674993515015,
-1.5560543537139893,
0.5926142334938049,
-0.5461024641990662,
0.34108272194862366,
-0.2526426315307617,
0.538030743598938,
-0.4441970884799957,
-0.7287603616714478,
-0.5465512871742249,
-0.16775600612163544,
0.23944580554962158,
0.25652191042900085,
-0.22866807878017426,
0.33397188782691956,
-0.3864334523677826,
0.4917728304862976,
-0.38806718587875366,
0.5353693962097168,
-0.20506499707698822,
0.19808439910411835,
0.34605783224105835,
0.14801891148090363,
0.3858441412448883,
0.40749481320381165,
-0.3578462600708008,
-0.0684683620929718,
-0.5609934329986572,
0.14882829785346985,
0.26983457803726196,
0.37010669708251953,
-0.06520967930555344,
0.2193799912929535,
-0.12688054144382477,
0.7435148358345032,
-0.049505509436130524,
0.3106173872947693,
0.17491666972637177,
-0.27964654564857483,
-0.12489301711320877,
-0.02411782369017601,
0.8564659357070923,
-0.06901665031909943,
0.024300426244735718,
-0.15495650470256805,
0.10002196580171585,
-0.12126447260379791,
0.2855392098426819,
-0.42062908411026,
-0.3391551673412323,
0.1488431841135025,
-0.5672977566719055,
-0.5885396003723145,
-0.13024118542671204,
-0.570918083190918,
-0.5369738936424255,
-0.14112588763237,
-0.012347470037639141,
-0.35893815755844116,
-0.9042866230010986,
-0.05727655813097954,
-0.17802922427654266,
0.3950076699256897,
0.18481990694999695,
-0.9496851563453674,
0.349275141954422,
0.6477519869804382,
0.7157300114631653,
0.041891910135746,
-0.5824952721595764,
-0.013739250600337982,
-0.05323520675301552,
-0.5542667508125305,
0.877030074596405,
-0.5530579686164856,
-0.1384260058403015,
0.10347669571638107,
-0.21455995738506317,
-0.09437374025583267,
-0.40663978457450867,
0.5515252351760864,
-0.7000244855880737,
-0.22969229519367218,
0.12080354243516922,
-0.3228636384010315,
-0.14917713403701782,
0.05638495087623596,
-0.6130181550979614,
0.643365740776062,
-0.08627885580062866,
-0.44569265842437744,
0.4451654851436615,
-1.0062475204467773,
-0.6833462119102478,
0.45035943388938904,
-0.06636969745159149,
-0.40125077962875366,
0.17330695688724518,
-0.1607198417186737,
0.49738526344299316,
-0.04973988980054855,
-0.0076718577183783054,
-0.061658814549446106,
-0.23539325594902039,
0.5108664631843567,
-0.4799143970012665,
0.778773844242096,
0.6884171366691589,
-0.6874143481254578,
0.06537216156721115,
-0.6353460550308228,
0.29531824588775635,
0.16116157174110413,
-0.5005108118057251,
-0.39245811104774475,
0.19702228903770447,
0.02076561562716961,
0.3172350525856018,
0.1734936386346817,
-0.5173591375350952,
-0.05788938328623772,
-0.645790696144104,
0.881607174873352,
0.436261922121048,
0.012711909599602222,
0.6594036817550659,
-0.03940807655453682,
0.16601873934268951,
0.28871262073516846,
0.06958501785993576,
-0.49144160747528076,
-0.3462506830692291,
-0.6718488335609436,
0.1002185121178627,
0.1734229177236557,
0.4994787275791168,
-0.8931175470352173,
0.21564921736717224,
0.16711151599884033,
-0.8293105363845825,
-0.9282023906707764,
-0.060277264565229416,
0.18980300426483154,
-0.16725467145442963,
0.11316405981779099,
0.02616337686777115,
-0.9843151569366455,
-0.7552397847175598,
-0.4502827227115631,
-0.2470368593931198,
0.3971101641654968,
0.33132675290107727,
0.12359422445297241,
-0.3833327889442444,
0.8228381872177124,
-0.15057280659675598,
0.15782058238983154,
-0.3263775408267975,
0.5869166851043701,
-0.005421231966465712,
0.524551272392273,
0.47231239080429077,
-0.8128368854522705,
-0.4723533093929291,
0.3172164261341095,
-0.8473943471908569,
0.5175048112869263,
-0.3206532597541809,
0.4655925929546356,
-0.017322031781077385,
0.7073396444320679,
-0.5553315877914429,
0.09266339987516403,
0.6640313863754272,
-0.15899160504341125,
0.4021897614002228,
-0.3287184238433838,
0.32492369413375854,
-0.985643208026886,
-0.1288975179195404,
-0.3118762969970703,
-0.07579600065946579,
-1.0028135776519775,
0.1519574075937271,
-0.27393588423728943,
-0.12697909772396088,
-0.49597999453544617,
0.27557921409606934,
-0.6762209534645081,
-0.12433700263500214,
-0.7794758677482605,
-0.12472237646579742,
-0.4830041229724884,
-0.09345273673534393,
0.2092435210943222,
0.608691930770874,
0.7215250730514526,
-0.8135650753974915,
0.4517481327056885,
0.021996285766363144,
-0.36959075927734375,
0.25337615609169006,
-0.552979588508606,
0.14475707709789276,
-0.003536802949383855,
0.21097366511821747,
-0.8758108615875244,
0.2059713900089264,
0.19646184146404266,
-0.6316443681716919,
0.08738771080970764,
0.0778847336769104,
-0.4796406030654907,
-0.67103511095047,
0.053533151745796204,
0.3569318652153015,
0.4201677739620209,
-0.44406285881996155,
0.0409349724650383,
0.5402197241783142,
-0.18166430294513702,
-0.40079265832901,
-0.7492467761039734,
0.5021367073059082,
-0.06215010955929756,
-0.2544171214103699,
0.024144360795617104,
-0.1743801087141037,
-0.29574641585350037,
-0.03110012412071228,
0.3636275827884674,
-0.10748211294412613,
0.6185907125473022,
0.17513519525527954,
-0.30501458048820496,
-0.44807398319244385,
0.042143821716308594,
0.036620669066905975,
0.036895282566547394,
0.33920949697494507,
-0.6320440769195557,
0.6160861253738403,
-0.6412785053253174,
-0.32613760232925415,
0.12113742530345917,
0.5725571513175964,
0.426900714635849,
-0.011987422592937946,
0.8903347253799438,
0.8483342528343201,
-0.23882897198200226,
-0.2293851673603058,
-0.33083829283714294,
-0.37385982275009155,
-0.4760361611843109,
0.2566635310649872,
-0.19291266798973083,
-1.0430412292480469,
0.25096189975738525,
-0.6570463180541992,
0.000504002848174423,
0.4216099977493286,
0.35112297534942627,
-0.3904496729373932,
0.774334728717804,
1.0630695819854736,
0.20027706027030945,
0.9424651861190796,
-0.28066486120224,
0.6530797481536865,
-0.8655678033828735,
-0.275617390871048,
-0.39427217841148376,
-0.14665821194648743,
-0.6774169206619263,
-0.15603862702846527,
0.009633522480726242,
0.047350894659757614,
-0.19238467514514923,
0.4730392396450043,
-0.3962714374065399,
0.3905731737613678,
0.48031511902809143,
-0.1935718059539795,
0.31806665658950806,
-0.16608794033527374,
-0.16557763516902924,
0.1573491245508194,
-0.8767235279083252,
-0.5995848178863525,
0.9812528491020203,
0.5035686492919922,
0.7251763343811035,
-0.01115882396697998,
0.7365214824676514,
0.5350759625434875,
0.22775140404701233,
-0.5841646790504456,
0.2959332764148712,
0.18874257802963257,
-0.5826820135116577,
-0.542428731918335,
-0.470636785030365,
-1.4798673391342163,
0.19729198515415192,
-0.29233673214912415,
-0.7478047609329224,
0.15020029246807098,
-0.13102255761623383,
-0.3380914628505707,
0.4474462568759918,
-0.7296570539474487,
0.40737974643707275,
-0.39490988850593567,
-0.03404219076037407,
-0.35005149245262146,
-0.7562853693962097,
0.2395661473274231,
0.19590164721012115,
0.2507062256336212,
0.1426311582326889,
0.18516458570957184,
0.7305805683135986,
0.41320499777793884,
1.0016634464263916,
0.12378180772066116,
-0.3070685863494873,
0.7687558531761169,
-0.21244336664676666,
0.2274150848388672,
0.018750101327896118,
0.24434985220432281,
0.07302694767713547,
-0.2415185123682022,
-0.18934319913387299,
-0.41296637058258057,
0.6412407159805298,
-0.7131999731063843,
-0.2149251401424408,
-0.5268368124961853,
-0.4117661416530609,
-0.20176322758197784,
0.540317952632904,
-0.06609293073415756,
-0.013696504756808281,
-0.7983635663986206,
0.13844521343708038,
0.9996547698974609,
-0.10970544070005417,
0.7281849384307861,
0.8187852501869202,
-0.18445834517478943,
-0.18619835376739502,
1.071892499923706,
-0.29214709997177124,
0.3857583999633789,
0.50020831823349,
0.07142895460128784,
0.0181338582187891,
-0.7945849299430847,
-0.273215651512146,
-0.14106182754039764,
-0.4644903838634491,
0.1721256673336029,
-0.829833447933197,
-0.7343422174453735,
-0.2950875759124756,
-0.1664130985736847,
-0.5050325989723206,
-0.08937010169029236,
-0.19583524763584137,
-0.1804085373878479,
0.04510379582643509,
1.1632792949676514,
-0.36090803146362305,
0.26867032051086426,
-0.6571420431137085,
-0.021715376526117325,
0.31423988938331604,
0.3876933455467224,
0.3191886842250824,
0.06199058145284653,
-0.49981704354286194,
0.41807904839515686,
-0.35501065850257874,
-0.6172878742218018,
0.15383629500865936,
0.25951912999153137,
0.8706574440002441,
0.3500383198261261,
-0.4037610590457916,
0.1735469102859497,
-0.41561949253082275,
0.7107346653938293,
0.26674991846084595,
-0.5171860456466675,
0.7236038446426392,
-0.43060818314552307,
0.2520538866519928,
0.23106636106967926,
0.40933138132095337,
-0.6881151795387268,
-0.47356274724006653,
-0.9396679997444153,
-0.909834623336792,
0.24027833342552185,
0.21607820689678192,
0.18202660977840424,
0.051214393228292465,
-0.08183524757623672,
-0.04406290501356125,
0.30042561888694763,
-0.3514833450317383,
-0.4136575162410736,
0.13288454711437225,
0.2195804864168167,
-0.45133864879608154,
-0.13200697302818298,
-0.26644566655158997,
-0.054845135658979416,
0.29275378584861755,
-0.1844576746225357,
0.4929315149784088,
0.1147979274392128,
-0.048554640263319016,
-0.15435083210468292,
0.7131808996200562,
0.7546966671943665,
0.35940882563591003,
0.04078959673643112,
0.25769516825675964,
-0.22224032878875732,
-0.5598593950271606,
0.33381175994873047,
0.03206169977784157,
-0.24202342331409454,
-0.11213551461696625,
0.1704016476869583,
0.4441092610359192,
0.28989896178245544,
-0.661835253238678,
0.0942348912358284,
-0.04586027190089226,
-0.08839601278305054,
-0.3260234594345093,
-0.19752644002437592,
0.4179333448410034,
0.48602667450904846,
0.5212868452072144,
0.4361090660095215,
0.3480227291584015,
-1.0383244752883911,
0.3697919249534607,
0.5203417539596558,
-0.7696259617805481,
-0.3011586666107178,
0.48740971088409424,
0.5828514099121094,
-0.37205833196640015,
0.5196305513381958,
-0.06597387045621872,
-0.2894324064254761,
0.5871354341506958,
0.7062397003173828,
0.9222907423973083,
-0.21767278015613556,
0.37102463841438293,
-0.09471427649259567,
0.5305447578430176,
0.20126241445541382,
0.3908914029598236,
-0.0778934508562088,
-0.7807047963142395,
-0.3221883773803711,
-0.3996068239212036,
-0.3523420989513397,
0.24294382333755493,
-0.03029950149357319,
-0.21931138634681702,
-0.4050118029117584,
-0.20178425312042236,
0.4096173346042633,
0.11203844100236893,
-0.6799039244651794,
-0.004508679267019033,
0.5640024542808533,
0.7846240997314453,
-0.9358522295951843,
0.4098806381225586,
0.974194347858429,
-0.36796706914901733,
-0.43562474846839905,
-0.24138420820236206,
-0.08403661847114563,
-0.5866138935089111,
0.6337930560112,
-0.15156808495521545,
-0.2268596589565277,
0.19960664212703705,
-0.5136210322380066,
-0.9903848171234131,
0.945429265499115,
-0.045678623020648956,
-0.23932766914367676,
0.18897704780101776,
0.10657268017530441,
0.7908377051353455,
-0.5742601752281189,
0.6456932425498962,
0.5345219969749451,
0.3555264174938202,
0.03214560076594353,
-0.9801661968231201,
-0.055114924907684326,
-0.30091843008995056,
-0.08136237412691116,
0.19072461128234863,
-0.8647202253341675,
0.5937442779541016,
-0.4655257761478424,
-0.32020696997642517,
0.13873539865016937,
1.0095477104187012,
-0.11148060858249664,
0.3806663453578949,
0.11465668678283691,
0.18259741365909576,
0.6135543584823608,
-0.0201142318546772,
0.5014578104019165,
-0.06724583357572556,
0.13410942256450653,
0.9699661135673523,
-0.11417843401432037,
0.5846872925758362,
0.2780279219150543,
-0.1097206100821495,
0.8053508996963501,
0.5674291253089905,
0.16549520194530487,
0.43221887946128845,
0.3112555146217346,
-0.3850135803222656,
0.21699048578739166,
-0.28777024149894714,
-0.272621750831604,
0.24059134721755981,
0.8818126916885376,
-0.26117974519729614,
-0.25440672039985657,
0.19496957957744598,
-0.29203885793685913,
-0.0022376382257789373,
-0.26566651463508606,
0.9235506057739258,
0.30448704957962036,
-0.39482027292251587,
0.2255164384841919,
-0.2948610186576843,
0.5439972877502441,
-0.3454500734806061,
-0.3686671853065491,
0.3102373778820038,
0.41052621603012085,
-0.25922891497612,
-1.1508303880691528,
0.27835822105407715,
-0.5975216031074524,
0.02051376923918724,
-0.4342878460884094,
1.0940757989883423,
-0.5104318857192993,
0.1413717120885849,
0.30407610535621643,
0.7602384686470032,
0.22501786053180695,
0.1122407540678978,
-1.0310605764389038,
-0.05130312219262123,
-0.5335601568222046,
-0.10475801676511765,
0.1129995584487915,
0.4890516698360443,
0.15383386611938477,
1.1366417407989502,
0.6726382970809937,
0.20853875577449799,
0.2807222902774811,
0.19835719466209412,
0.8831989169120789,
-0.7621667385101318,
-0.41813236474990845,
-0.6637575030326843,
0.38108301162719727,
-0.15178465843200684,
-0.3256721496582031,
0.8264431953430176,
0.44018641114234924,
0.6300135850906372,
0.04843515530228615,
1.0903971195220947,
-0.2555781304836273,
0.14664912223815918,
-0.2663223445415497,
0.7114901542663574,
0.19238241016864777,
0.012102661654353142,
-0.3079322576522827,
-0.6189231872558594,
0.10940607637166977,
0.060157410800457,
-0.08424699306488037,
0.18810327351093292,
0.7147163152694702,
0.046492114663124084,
0.0902966856956482,
0.12086603790521622,
0.23932835459709167,
0.23221558332443237,
0.39315903186798096,
0.5808500051498413,
1.3943618535995483,
-0.3483577370643616,
0.46053817868232727,
0.07449090480804443,
-0.2729966640472412,
-0.5001605153083801,
-0.63519287109375,
-0.8087142109870911,
-0.9042292237281799,
0.005299859214574099,
-0.14896726608276367,
0.2176050990819931,
0.6103747487068176,
0.8434200286865234,
-0.5769977569580078,
-0.2891003489494324,
-0.43090030550956726,
0.19147495925426483,
-0.9196969270706177,
-0.2817080020904541,
-0.09427700191736221,
-0.5513583421707153,
-0.42397505044937134,
0.7910184860229492,
0.3985709547996521,
0.40043389797210693,
-0.6844505071640015,
0.053642768412828445,
-0.5907097458839417,
-0.039856839925050735,
0.8139528036117554,
0.9034613370895386,
-0.31038206815719604,
-0.0013303504092618823,
0.012195467948913574,
-0.12262352555990219,
-0.0517023541033268,
1.2545466423034668,
-0.7859429121017456,
0.2892518937587738,
0.406475305557251,
0.8561763167381287,
0.38194969296455383,
-0.33900049328804016,
0.8095673322677612,
-0.45862898230552673,
0.004592006094753742,
0.5941249132156372,
-0.23459726572036743,
0.5641329884529114,
-0.47065502405166626,
0.2572547495365143,
0.1556299924850464,
-0.6525872349739075,
-0.6229988932609558,
0.6191194653511047,
-0.6224157214164734,
-0.34464070200920105,
0.9605733752250671,
0.0904761478304863,
-0.09682388603687286,
-0.6321786046028137,
0.03802429512143135,
0.28589895367622375,
-0.39641621708869934,
0.7131130695343018,
0.4911036789417267,
-0.07423704117536545,
-0.46844568848609924,
-0.6723846197128296,
0.6728094220161438,
0.2515811324119568,
-0.7657696008682251,
-0.16547457873821259,
-0.3112006187438965,
0.07923693209886551,
0.4415396749973297,
0.6840859651565552,
0.1845368891954422,
0.12417005747556686,
0.13266612589359283,
0.08259975165128708,
0.18083609640598297,
-0.45739349722862244,
-0.29322028160095215,
-0.10720930993556976,
0.28727078437805176,
-0.14742694795131683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03282v1 | LLM Internal States Reveal Hallucination Risk Faced With a Query | 2024-07-03T17:08:52 | 2024-07-03T17:08:52 | Ziwei Ji, Delong Chen, Etsuko Ishii, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Yejin Bang, Bryan Wilie, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | The hallucination problem of Large Language Models (LLMs) significantly
limits their reliability and trustworthiness. Humans have a self-awareness
process that allows us to recognize what we don't know when faced with queries.
Inspired by this, our paper investigates whether LLMs can estimate their own
hallucination risk before response generation. We analyze the internal
mechanisms of LLMs broadly both in terms of training data sources and across 15
diverse Natural Language Generation (NLG) tasks, spanning over 700 datasets.
Our empirical analysis reveals two key insights: (1) LLM internal states
indicate whether they have seen the query in training data or not; and (2) LLM
internal states show they are likely to hallucinate or not regarding the query.
Our study explores particular neurons, activation layers, and tokens that play
a crucial role in the LLM perception of uncertainty and hallucination risk. By
a probing estimator, we leverage LLM self-assessment, achieving an average
hallucination estimation accuracy of 84.32\% at run time. | [
-0.36135512590408325,
-0.5947229862213135,
0.8801424503326416,
-0.013494230806827545,
-0.009664085693657398,
-0.14090166985988617,
-0.2344546765089035,
-0.7192805409431458,
0.20297300815582275,
0.392234742641449,
-0.7738068699836731,
-0.2571786344051361,
-0.5203884840011597,
0.3508423864841461,
-0.36933016777038574,
0.5968111753463745,
0.21513304114341736,
0.06457417458295822,
-0.41979315876960754,
0.33960697054862976,
-0.517132580280304,
-0.7981675267219543,
-0.4961077570915222,
-0.34677237272262573,
0.423780232667923,
-0.007037240546196699,
0.3852858245372772,
0.1314316987991333,
0.3973889648914337,
0.29670974612236023,
0.011838930658996105,
0.08011306077241898,
-0.5994530916213989,
0.3898608386516571,
0.10063894838094711,
-0.8671916723251343,
-0.103465735912323,
-0.1056986078619957,
0.46144089102745056,
0.6602337956428528,
-0.11344343423843384,
0.04414256662130356,
0.21698229014873505,
0.8329896926879883,
-0.6294942498207092,
-0.12045606225728989,
-1.1791768074035645,
0.34453392028808594,
0.006543679162859917,
-0.4846676290035248,
-0.45498937368392944,
-0.324127733707428,
0.19181174039840698,
-0.0811576321721077,
0.29671987891197205,
0.09775149822235107,
0.565396785736084,
0.6960503458976746,
-0.31138402223587036,
-0.48645779490470886,
-0.6028746962547302,
0.3108254373073578,
-0.5091130137443542,
0.4748941957950592,
0.6978486180305481,
0.17510588467121124,
-0.6125983595848083,
-0.5256519317626953,
-0.5063928961753845,
-0.7168951034545898,
-0.25897136330604553,
-0.14420174062252045,
-0.035386089235544205,
0.15064336359500885,
0.2545246183872223,
0.43510690331459045,
-0.5380188226699829,
0.061767276376485825,
-0.4099128544330597,
-0.4644637405872345,
0.47280153632164,
0.18921595811843872,
0.2209814488887787,
-0.41140273213386536,
-0.4173407256603241,
0.14114651083946228,
-0.6728529334068298,
-0.11975443363189697,
0.5270914435386658,
0.2271091639995575,
0.23681534826755524,
0.8291789293289185,
0.016390077769756317,
0.4445689916610718,
0.17563678324222565,
0.1397768259048462,
0.06370402872562408,
-0.24473822116851807,
-0.39398136734962463,
0.5098443031311035,
0.9923522472381592,
0.1281740665435791,
0.26216360926628113,
-0.4977606534957886,
-0.3469635844230652,
0.025747831910848618,
0.8709067702293396,
-0.5595269203186035,
-0.0075759743340313435,
0.4890037477016449,
-0.0331193208694458,
-0.22696447372436523,
0.06091933697462082,
-0.5328530669212341,
-0.8623099327087402,
-0.13214346766471863,
0.6387218832969666,
-0.4158337712287903,
-0.26154688000679016,
0.05228547751903534,
0.2451501488685608,
0.2614068388938904,
0.1028270348906517,
-0.6694132685661316,
0.4234539270401001,
0.42578378319740295,
0.717193603515625,
-0.454106867313385,
-0.3376650810241699,
-0.37604841589927673,
-0.13747234642505646,
-0.5271512866020203,
0.8722977042198181,
0.0638691633939743,
-0.4672982394695282,
-0.13647936284542084,
0.1260886937379837,
-0.0979335829615593,
-0.6985660791397095,
0.37799015641212463,
-0.3969372808933258,
-0.15396687388420105,
-0.3347475528717041,
-0.691865861415863,
-0.24240420758724213,
0.2510661482810974,
-0.6369304060935974,
1.137238621711731,
-0.2636685073375702,
-0.9072873592376709,
0.5147165656089783,
-0.058859147131443024,
-0.2753627598285675,
-0.023841077461838722,
-0.49494239687919617,
-0.3046795725822449,
0.5934594869613647,
0.1513136625289917,
0.6050917506217957,
-0.048724669963121414,
0.18741443753242493,
-0.310153603553772,
-0.3388196527957916,
0.8408218622207642,
-0.45940694212913513,
0.5181849002838135,
-0.030642645433545113,
-0.4831184446811676,
0.34443023800849915,
-0.5451521873474121,
0.006331175100058317,
0.10989703238010406,
-0.05989975482225418,
-0.20275478065013885,
-0.008976493962109089,
-0.566461443901062,
0.25094321370124817,
0.1462884396314621,
-0.30824822187423706,
-0.04325629398226738,
-0.5502287745475769,
0.060072265565395355,
1.0497236251831055,
0.31250762939453125,
0.24061472713947296,
-0.1979026347398758,
0.44382408261299133,
0.02429906465113163,
-0.07451869547367096,
0.23471932113170624,
-0.4360968768596649,
-0.7885931730270386,
0.09529436379671097,
-0.18068429827690125,
0.3053041696548462,
-0.16999749839305878,
0.6426368951797485,
-0.030036525800824165,
-0.4047456979751587,
-0.5573928356170654,
0.0703626498579979,
0.23896850645542145,
0.4291965961456299,
0.2213842272758484,
0.0713621973991394,
-0.5175566077232361,
-0.9206539988517761,
-0.24068213999271393,
-0.29172053933143616,
-0.09070846438407898,
0.30032506585121155,
0.617647647857666,
-0.1939709186553955,
0.8095024824142456,
-0.3993408977985382,
-0.3808956444263458,
-0.15025198459625244,
0.0895053893327713,
0.0045782639645040035,
0.20092181861400604,
0.19148294627666473,
-0.3158411979675293,
-0.03962166607379913,
-0.23668713867664337,
-1.1205577850341797,
0.09941011667251587,
-0.41607940196990967,
-0.17350032925605774,
0.5196914672851562,
0.6708775758743286,
-0.664610743522644,
0.5734747648239136,
0.4700795114040375,
-0.18265296518802643,
0.6050795912742615,
-0.4309118986129761,
-0.05950260907411575,
-0.9036774635314941,
-0.24665413796901703,
-0.03953813388943672,
0.048712652176618576,
-0.45913219451904297,
-0.14068682491779327,
0.0914183035492897,
0.26776817440986633,
-0.27320390939712524,
0.5277490019798279,
-0.8034406900405884,
-0.49817386269569397,
-0.32457733154296875,
0.23991012573242188,
-0.3498627543449402,
0.36126670241355896,
0.019741129130125046,
0.8670488595962524,
0.7188466191291809,
-0.8999482989311218,
-0.02964823879301548,
-0.05758364126086235,
-0.7277784943580627,
0.21443802118301392,
-0.5177797079086304,
0.4239654242992401,
-0.20864282548427582,
0.10807527601718903,
-1.1938673257827759,
-0.34352532029151917,
0.37493079900741577,
-0.585198700428009,
0.2440701276063919,
0.19924317300319672,
-0.4358995854854584,
-0.40634849667549133,
-0.12842705845832825,
0.17057356238365173,
0.25186774134635925,
-0.5733842849731445,
0.5978320240974426,
0.4915749132633209,
0.20537805557250977,
-0.5255626440048218,
-0.8659058809280396,
0.21426646411418915,
-0.18295012414455414,
-0.49285390973091125,
0.04429933428764343,
-0.25944381952285767,
-0.3186798691749573,
-0.19412113726139069,
-0.4222885072231293,
0.0973169207572937,
0.2773702144622803,
0.8591578602790833,
0.07688284665346146,
0.09011085331439972,
0.29654961824417114,
-0.048511605709791183,
0.08440505713224411,
0.751957356929779,
-0.04059385135769844,
0.788992702960968,
-0.14880923926830292,
-0.6481571197509766,
-0.6080590486526489,
-0.011028530076146126,
0.22013255953788757,
0.03446085751056671,
0.8173009157180786,
0.32265761494636536,
-0.712945818901062,
-0.3203883469104767,
-0.6803768873214722,
-0.694955050945282,
-0.48230066895484924,
0.24640408158302307,
-0.5503915548324585,
-0.4776143729686737,
0.6037327647209167,
0.3960985839366913,
-0.39184293150901794,
0.40460410714149475,
0.7375239133834839,
-0.1688869595527649,
0.7013309597969055,
0.3296256959438324,
0.053515031933784485,
0.005799689330160618,
-0.06617069989442825,
0.21107694506645203,
-0.8443830609321594,
-0.5369517803192139,
-0.3963642418384552,
-0.2864862084388733,
-0.695665717124939,
-0.40615805983543396,
0.5426988005638123,
-0.06747755408287048,
0.04575004428625107,
0.040619369596242905,
-0.5625728964805603,
0.3157865107059479,
0.4398612082004547,
0.3843614161014557,
0.27841901779174805,
0.03294162452220917,
-0.09804791957139969,
-0.20592787861824036,
-0.2763635218143463,
-0.29274505376815796,
1.1715195178985596,
0.4196150004863739,
1.0507439374923706,
-0.00955125316977501,
0.9139795899391174,
0.12736776471138,
0.1682063639163971,
-0.9205191731452942,
0.6359459757804871,
0.6308416128158569,
-0.8304883241653442,
-0.577538013458252,
-0.45198309421539307,
-0.8729462027549744,
0.14060135185718536,
-0.3357076942920685,
-0.8871986865997314,
0.12796072661876678,
-0.054120536893606186,
-0.4508587121963501,
0.25838029384613037,
-0.40611931681632996,
0.33387860655784607,
-0.5316529273986816,
-0.3159787058830261,
-0.08075976371765137,
-0.5912178754806519,
0.6081118583679199,
-0.2524077594280243,
-0.1279771775007248,
-0.3250207006931305,
0.045848798006772995,
0.5805419683456421,
-0.003472493030130863,
1.0765351057052612,
0.06824474036693573,
-0.30514398217201233,
0.4564673900604248,
0.383312463760376,
0.6254855394363403,
0.15643693506717682,
-0.25545361638069153,
0.12931819260120392,
-0.5484305024147034,
0.17984749376773834,
-0.4567272961139679,
0.7252311110496521,
-0.6620703339576721,
-0.7702360153198242,
-0.7650662660598755,
-0.530516505241394,
-0.23524868488311768,
-0.10404976457357407,
0.6018021702766418,
-0.01994483359158039,
-0.18038560450077057,
0.1241173967719078,
0.6982679963111877,
-0.29499921202659607,
0.4100329279899597,
0.1155245378613472,
-0.3198680281639099,
-0.22146280109882355,
0.6289224624633789,
0.23626063764095306,
0.3034588396549225,
0.06821992248296738,
0.2573181092739105,
-0.6426501870155334,
-0.6707383990287781,
-0.07409167289733887,
0.3875080943107605,
-0.8227216005325317,
-0.19882887601852417,
-0.8953872323036194,
-0.5711331963539124,
-0.4161360561847687,
0.12445957213640213,
-0.35796821117401123,
-0.030056551098823547,
-0.4893445372581482,
-0.5889512300491333,
0.32666751742362976,
0.982344388961792,
-0.056682221591472626,
0.005352825857698917,
-0.4181036353111267,
0.28134140372276306,
0.5122070908546448,
0.28210824728012085,
-0.005491814576089382,
-0.6637250185012817,
0.04427717998623848,
-0.03642941266298294,
-0.007644063793122768,
-0.9628618955612183,
0.4593459963798523,
0.0082840071991086,
0.8777105212211609,
0.5081623196601868,
0.24124889075756073,
0.6012699007987976,
-0.4024503231048584,
0.8246740698814392,
0.034422531723976135,
-0.7051057815551758,
0.46100351214408875,
0.002381313592195511,
0.03547864407300949,
0.6013931035995483,
0.6477941870689392,
-0.2478492259979248,
-0.5778743624687195,
-0.3905831277370453,
-0.6455236077308655,
0.40025436878204346,
0.20183508098125458,
0.2268633395433426,
-0.38265734910964966,
0.5565115213394165,
0.19899040460586548,
0.10343561321496964,
-1.079109787940979,
-0.1812671273946762,
-0.10405908524990082,
0.2838553786277771,
0.060516249388456345,
-0.471037894487381,
-0.15210379660129547,
-0.2135041058063507,
0.4175690710544586,
-0.2187856286764145,
0.4978613555431366,
0.40330061316490173,
-0.31675317883491516,
-0.28069594502449036,
-0.006319175008684397,
0.8015685081481934,
0.5883080363273621,
-0.559444785118103,
0.3318212032318115,
0.2782902419567108,
-0.3099057972431183,
0.17889535427093506,
-0.3559741675853729,
0.12938550114631653,
-0.21095740795135498,
0.3276916444301605,
0.7818870544433594,
0.1826074719429016,
-0.6312160491943359,
0.32404014468193054,
-0.22529059648513794,
-0.2610619366168976,
-0.7748657464981079,
0.1524423360824585,
0.06237024813890457,
0.05351940542459488,
0.41006866097450256,
-0.1900026500225067,
0.1799430251121521,
-0.47828808426856995,
0.3844078481197357,
0.6893181800842285,
-0.5648606419563293,
-0.3216809034347534,
0.8314009308815002,
-0.172265887260437,
-0.31019672751426697,
0.6110514998435974,
-0.23953372240066528,
-0.41702473163604736,
0.5453940033912659,
0.7514508962631226,
1.3246313333511353,
-0.2602962851524353,
0.10976637154817581,
0.6776837110519409,
0.6761798858642578,
-0.09975480288267136,
0.2544909119606018,
0.3692863881587982,
-0.862949013710022,
-0.1738879680633545,
-0.8544635772705078,
-0.1968509554862976,
0.43191808462142944,
-0.6324669122695923,
-0.011827053502202034,
-0.27301594614982605,
-0.3866145610809326,
-0.4525046944618225,
-0.2020636647939682,
-0.5727002620697021,
0.2719278931617737,
0.42343583703041077,
0.5931726098060608,
-0.5811221599578857,
0.6917842030525208,
0.1311933845281601,
-0.2483980357646942,
-0.6287295818328857,
0.4350496828556061,
0.019177589565515518,
-0.9824632406234741,
0.7583361864089966,
0.4843841791152954,
-0.43020591139793396,
-0.21793733537197113,
-0.34688621759414673,
-0.9120863080024719,
0.8546813130378723,
0.35547730326652527,
-0.408801406621933,
-0.2695028483867645,
0.35502856969833374,
0.44985562562942505,
-0.2771594524383545,
0.06043645739555359,
0.5866182446479797,
0.33891192078590393,
0.08854542672634125,
-0.5489547848701477,
0.3532492220401764,
0.171349436044693,
-0.12946875393390656,
0.12241874635219574,
-0.1849028468132019,
0.8030270934104919,
-0.609128475189209,
-0.44209346175193787,
-0.13879147171974182,
0.8186926245689392,
0.2572591304779053,
-0.06195789575576782,
0.6451687812805176,
0.4141201078891754,
0.9446185231208801,
0.06302503496408463,
1.2014373540878296,
-0.49407824873924255,
-0.1259009838104248,
1.3592054843902588,
-0.2175762802362442,
0.8457069396972656,
0.6315814256668091,
-0.018834969028830528,
0.12056940048933029,
0.8513206243515015,
0.13375073671340942,
0.4018012583255768,
0.6152461767196655,
-0.2321474403142929,
-0.23275987803936005,
0.02088867872953415,
-0.3934021592140198,
0.531700849533081,
0.5925461053848267,
-0.3900527060031891,
0.11189944297075272,
-0.0721789002418518,
-0.13990521430969238,
-0.17181020975112915,
-0.1378023624420166,
0.9010300040245056,
0.25733110308647156,
-0.7900306582450867,
0.7020059823989868,
-0.6892871856689453,
0.5313062071800232,
-0.5053310394287109,
0.19887885451316833,
-0.3930983543395996,
-0.06047489866614342,
-0.20054061710834503,
-0.8019739389419556,
0.3051013648509979,
-0.3004712462425232,
0.18938428163528442,
0.10547464340925217,
0.6621737480163574,
-0.27362796664237976,
-0.5768151879310608,
0.6088221073150635,
0.562493622303009,
0.41162189841270447,
-0.6048095226287842,
-0.3197048306465149,
-0.027787059545516968,
-0.049519333988428116,
-0.5108763575553894,
0.5257043242454529,
0.5917393565177917,
0.1492765247821808,
0.9041025638580322,
0.47727373242378235,
0.23021671175956726,
0.5553812980651855,
-0.05878542736172676,
0.6792880892753601,
-0.7405745387077332,
-0.05692971870303154,
-0.8951847553253174,
0.3369070887565613,
0.016743693500757217,
-0.3199559450149536,
0.716567873954773,
0.3885507881641388,
0.7669962048530579,
0.0033149856608361006,
0.6694132685661316,
0.3736507296562195,
0.11994335800409317,
-0.7372704148292542,
0.9965782761573792,
-0.6490157246589661,
0.30997440218925476,
-0.03187141939997673,
-0.8735429048538208,
-0.09514167159795761,
0.6172348856925964,
-0.31299373507499695,
-0.05852360650897026,
0.808903694152832,
1.0075112581253052,
0.3553542196750641,
-0.0950491800904274,
0.5700958371162415,
0.29595106840133667,
0.08443044126033783,
0.32567599415779114,
0.9776760935783386,
-0.11525629460811615,
0.4328593909740448,
-0.5466309189796448,
0.2436441034078598,
-0.22658395767211914,
-0.8951380252838135,
-1.1100292205810547,
-0.684185802936554,
-0.03782602399587631,
-0.5350908637046814,
-0.3154292404651642,
0.8947890400886536,
0.38749006390571594,
-0.6751051545143127,
-0.4113924503326416,
-0.18309316039085388,
0.006874114274978638,
-0.026165233924984932,
-0.21220779418945312,
0.39298832416534424,
-0.632340669631958,
-0.43883979320526123,
0.6628165245056152,
0.16283677518367767,
0.30558231472969055,
-0.6077670454978943,
0.020185448229312897,
-0.13526593148708344,
0.24944323301315308,
0.37462282180786133,
-0.009605281986296177,
-1.0350316762924194,
-0.36163991689682007,
0.153489887714386,
-0.4198877513408661,
0.24900469183921814,
0.6332191228866577,
-0.7952438592910767,
0.47962167859077454,
0.29692256450653076,
0.6636284589767456,
0.4293772280216217,
-0.2742826044559479,
0.4977734088897705,
-0.7163788676261902,
0.058586668223142624,
0.2984204590320587,
0.31153276562690735,
0.26238277554512024,
-0.8084934949874878,
0.667235791683197,
-0.0321679450571537,
-0.6250166893005371,
-1.0155243873596191,
0.11748279631137848,
-0.8418553471565247,
-0.26191309094429016,
1.099524974822998,
0.27986711263656616,
-0.3504045605659485,
0.1335534155368805,
-0.026996783912181854,
0.20096859335899353,
-0.16563358902931213,
1.232020378112793,
0.71124267578125,
-0.3755103051662445,
-0.10819905996322632,
-0.9192894697189331,
0.8782216310501099,
0.18164779245853424,
-1.0506550073623657,
0.2283189445734024,
0.3746281862258911,
0.14490236341953278,
0.25244125723838806,
0.6604740619659424,
0.2282150387763977,
-0.009524769149720669,
0.09374231100082397,
0.24267879128456116,
0.22539108991622925,
-0.48387572169303894,
-0.2872595489025116,
0.1987803429365158,
0.050097979605197906,
-0.1879892349243164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03277v1 | Evaluating Automatic Metrics with Incremental Machine Translation Systems | 2024-07-03T17:04:17 | 2024-07-03T17:04:17 | Guojun Wu, Shay B. Cohen, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a dataset comprising commercial machine translations, gathered
weekly over six years across 12 translation directions. Since human A/B testing
is commonly used, we assume commercial systems improve over time, which enables
us to evaluate machine translation (MT) metrics based on their preference for
more recent translations. Our study confirms several previous findings in MT
metrics research and demonstrates the dataset's value as a testbed for metric
evaluation. We release our code at https://github.com/gjwubyron/Evo | [
-0.28500330448150635,
-0.49015143513679504,
0.47707870602607727,
0.553162693977356,
-0.2161683440208435,
0.07190559804439545,
-0.08679616451263428,
-0.5312692523002625,
-0.0867738425731659,
0.37158358097076416,
-0.7219110727310181,
-0.5468966960906982,
-0.6240294575691223,
0.7332702875137329,
-0.6059011220932007,
0.8666212558746338,
-0.42398807406425476,
0.23435603082180023,
-0.12854605913162231,
-0.6753054857254028,
-0.8942473530769348,
-0.23823854327201843,
-0.730162501335144,
-0.32519862055778503,
0.20120583474636078,
0.690062403678894,
0.7506460547447205,
0.8219135403633118,
1.0276494026184082,
0.2897513806819916,
0.3758849799633026,
0.12037258595228195,
0.013824700377881527,
0.17618735134601593,
0.02024361863732338,
-0.2832087576389313,
-0.4601781964302063,
0.11955104768276215,
0.9573988318443298,
0.6908010244369507,
-0.053417399525642395,
0.5912336111068726,
-0.2746948003768921,
0.7577884793281555,
-0.17640775442123413,
-0.0225863978266716,
-0.6848628520965576,
0.27941638231277466,
0.04581046849489212,
-0.4235285520553589,
-0.43035444617271423,
-0.6346556544303894,
0.15083079040050507,
-0.4623437523841858,
0.031925346702337265,
0.38425567746162415,
1.0383641719818115,
0.23973199725151062,
-0.5578128695487976,
-0.5073862075805664,
-0.6746644973754883,
0.9157155752182007,
-0.5424774885177612,
0.5469492673873901,
0.20373597741127014,
0.5628646612167358,
-0.1815062165260315,
-0.6271536946296692,
-0.45368725061416626,
-0.6197267174720764,
-0.03658323362469673,
0.34465938806533813,
-0.06722597032785416,
-0.36847156286239624,
0.1471995860338211,
0.6054035425186157,
-0.8084424734115601,
0.23153240978717804,
-0.4169916808605194,
-0.01751280203461647,
0.7396106123924255,
0.6652385592460632,
0.41945117712020874,
0.008005308918654919,
-0.5367630124092102,
-0.295549601316452,
-0.6960717439651489,
-0.1580761820077896,
0.39286327362060547,
-0.0769784227013588,
0.06688404083251953,
0.844711184501648,
-0.10445023328065872,
0.6778866052627563,
-0.08444461971521378,
0.21197769045829773,
0.6820886135101318,
-0.7944260239601135,
-0.42896324396133423,
-0.04120905324816704,
0.9635647535324097,
0.5565516948699951,
0.0005737126339226961,
-0.3113272488117218,
-0.47838836908340454,
0.14203199744224548,
0.5499847531318665,
-0.6180278062820435,
0.08712633699178696,
0.23685221374034882,
-0.41869261860847473,
-0.2532593905925751,
0.017832312732934952,
-0.5188265442848206,
-0.1865231692790985,
-0.5785754323005676,
0.537196695804596,
-0.5685858130455017,
0.14429837465286255,
0.061074528843164444,
-0.41201531887054443,
0.2735937535762787,
0.33991381525993347,
-0.32634249329566956,
0.30354440212249756,
0.4594232141971588,
0.9888041615486145,
-0.3911677300930023,
-0.5924050807952881,
-0.522810161113739,
-0.26215919852256775,
-0.6873753070831299,
0.7856596112251282,
-0.42529845237731934,
-0.4386793375015259,
-0.08835214376449585,
0.40265658497810364,
-0.12066246569156647,
-0.9443497657775879,
0.5886295437812805,
-0.43827345967292786,
0.39164289832115173,
0.11603458970785141,
-0.4015931487083435,
-0.24233759939670563,
0.42364558577537537,
-0.42652055621147156,
1.200084924697876,
0.3427457809448242,
-0.26757410168647766,
0.6760588884353638,
-1.0114688873291016,
-0.39639538526535034,
0.05981364846229553,
0.126020610332489,
-0.694084107875824,
0.08648642897605896,
0.09796787053346634,
0.15152907371520996,
-0.44054412841796875,
0.09162633121013641,
-0.209052175283432,
-0.3494971990585327,
0.3873155415058136,
-0.24534636735916138,
0.737438440322876,
0.6052182912826538,
-0.37343913316726685,
0.3799261152744293,
-0.7218227982521057,
-0.17650561034679413,
0.0969182476401329,
-0.3773766756057739,
-0.3120948374271393,
0.019345346838235855,
-0.06377360224723816,
0.153920978307724,
0.4211694002151489,
-0.57728111743927,
0.16740719974040985,
-0.38800498843193054,
0.47437307238578796,
0.6626094579696655,
0.008384332992136478,
0.418642520904541,
-0.2012767195701599,
0.777368426322937,
0.09738829731941223,
0.46223077178001404,
-0.39182066917419434,
-0.5411688685417175,
-0.8248578310012817,
-0.01362412516027689,
0.3211672902107239,
0.6944752931594849,
-0.5823133587837219,
0.9064099788665771,
-0.6469188928604126,
-0.2996135354042053,
-0.8218294382095337,
0.2726445496082306,
0.33464813232421875,
0.2330537587404251,
0.3877815008163452,
-0.8281997442245483,
-0.4203168749809265,
-1.1617130041122437,
-0.23688027262687683,
0.04081302881240845,
-0.248836949467659,
0.08809753507375717,
0.6395493745803833,
-0.3996078670024872,
0.581505537033081,
-0.14681825041770935,
-0.2904132604598999,
-0.1703120917081833,
0.35453081130981445,
0.23283323645591736,
0.4323868453502655,
0.5670530796051025,
-0.4101679027080536,
-0.6588374972343445,
0.3810521066188812,
-0.7216572761535645,
-0.046136800199747086,
-0.19782598316669464,
-0.2982803285121918,
0.07900579273700714,
0.2594960331916809,
-0.18574747443199158,
0.4362597167491913,
0.6925519108772278,
-0.4971809983253479,
0.3961622714996338,
-0.3996487259864807,
0.6481854915618896,
-0.8606964349746704,
0.2835788428783417,
0.05858386680483818,
-0.5029115676879883,
-0.07218585908412933,
0.12044352293014526,
0.13515429198741913,
-0.06106040999293327,
-0.3002384901046753,
0.32033902406692505,
-0.46222102642059326,
-0.45046401023864746,
-0.009071365930140018,
0.19248248636722565,
-0.017096497118473053,
0.03752439096570015,
-0.3780301809310913,
0.9162828326225281,
0.11343792825937271,
-0.730533242225647,
0.5123185515403748,
0.2527276873588562,
-0.6235954761505127,
0.7625946998596191,
-0.7221914529800415,
0.3411748707294464,
0.06684230268001556,
0.0976717472076416,
-1.2681161165237427,
-0.07869526743888855,
0.33636558055877686,
-0.7543551325798035,
0.24827389419078827,
0.03417373076081276,
-0.9045954942703247,
-0.7190396189689636,
-0.27375468611717224,
0.10944493860006332,
0.4104807376861572,
-0.43716827034950256,
0.11297184228897095,
0.47076335549354553,
-0.05229868367314339,
-0.2331172078847885,
-0.5243566036224365,
0.4164641499519348,
-0.4632347524166107,
-0.37378084659576416,
-0.06645376980304718,
-0.1528758704662323,
-0.21404492855072021,
0.02602871134877205,
0.006018529180437326,
-0.08001600950956345,
0.29726290702819824,
-0.0014905546559020877,
0.21312983334064484,
-0.052087608724832535,
0.0713558942079544,
0.16010183095932007,
-0.1778823733329773,
0.14930644631385803,
-0.6432211399078369,
0.4760842025279999,
-0.17097827792167664,
-0.1853615939617157,
-0.6242378950119019,
0.22777779400348663,
0.7306246757507324,
-0.17451603710651398,
0.6540961861610413,
0.4802538752555847,
-0.2364605963230133,
0.23678183555603027,
-0.45537710189819336,
0.24979270994663239,
-0.43682482838630676,
0.4710339605808258,
-0.5230032205581665,
-0.42273691296577454,
0.578399121761322,
0.003995267208665609,
0.35972487926483154,
0.8986349105834961,
0.6262552738189697,
-0.11035933345556259,
1.3422832489013672,
0.3912394940853119,
-0.08684790134429932,
0.5757733583450317,
-0.30994459986686707,
-0.10108082741498947,
-0.8683980107307434,
-0.17618639767169952,
-0.6458665132522583,
-0.5175103545188904,
-0.7221834063529968,
-0.16591933369636536,
0.4001275599002838,
-0.31824690103530884,
-0.4311932921409607,
0.7860782742500305,
-0.7069944739341736,
0.23005464673042297,
0.4563426673412323,
-0.01481893565505743,
0.5150557160377502,
-0.07609403878450394,
-0.22834175825119019,
-0.15600328147411346,
-0.4532323181629181,
-0.5742636919021606,
1.2181487083435059,
0.5392507910728455,
0.3783385157585144,
-0.09048163145780563,
0.27336207032203674,
0.6366831064224243,
0.9664593935012817,
-0.9711664319038391,
0.2766917645931244,
-0.22219431400299072,
-0.6643498539924622,
-0.3869665265083313,
-0.5770372152328491,
-1.205554723739624,
0.1544567197561264,
0.19688794016838074,
-0.30758389830589294,
0.00468380656093359,
0.1123141497373581,
0.04473324865102768,
-0.09355994313955307,
-0.8892369866371155,
1.0013154745101929,
-0.48579928278923035,
0.09019569307565689,
-0.3968914747238159,
-0.7172984480857849,
-0.052999481558799744,
-0.0461437813937664,
0.1925106942653656,
-0.13037674129009247,
-0.07624822109937668,
0.7062562108039856,
-0.2724693715572357,
0.3068596124649048,
-0.12700073421001434,
-0.028060246258974075,
0.19989460706710815,
0.12204308807849884,
0.3547217547893524,
-0.1599644273519516,
-0.20689992606639862,
0.23631396889686584,
-0.003608414903283119,
-0.37551969289779663,
-0.407166987657547,
0.688906192779541,
-0.6660506725311279,
-0.0859317034482956,
-0.40371236205101013,
-0.6349809169769287,
-0.012232224456965923,
0.18412615358829498,
0.18343880772590637,
0.22472836077213287,
-0.29943200945854187,
0.21784895658493042,
0.20924489200115204,
-0.40366294980049133,
0.1888662874698639,
0.7228218913078308,
-0.39124777913093567,
-0.8053684830665588,
0.7234207391738892,
0.14144183695316315,
0.32289251685142517,
0.4364418685436249,
0.1909409761428833,
-0.4755454957485199,
-0.5450432896614075,
-1.2184216976165771,
0.12218358367681503,
-0.566071629524231,
-0.18516573309898376,
-0.4066154360771179,
0.23357388377189636,
-0.34979090094566345,
-0.02739032357931137,
-0.5228016376495361,
-0.4494962692260742,
0.2340143769979477,
-0.11297497898340225,
0.3258923292160034,
1.025675654411316,
0.2209634631872177,
0.21344496309757233,
-0.9715367555618286,
-0.0033086868934333324,
-0.3110855221748352,
0.2584575414657593,
-0.3248943090438843,
-0.8692531585693359,
-0.6062542796134949,
0.03538409620523453,
-0.515587329864502,
-0.7318774461746216,
0.6891781091690063,
-0.08576797693967819,
0.5694469213485718,
0.08233053237199783,
-0.3920131027698517,
0.8517641425132751,
-0.8059533834457397,
0.824339747428894,
0.3270164728164673,
-1.0025599002838135,
0.7160232067108154,
-0.24009469151496887,
0.5564522743225098,
0.7864868640899658,
0.4624222218990326,
-0.6308149099349976,
-0.5552523136138916,
-0.5186563730239868,
-0.9921751022338867,
0.3745996356010437,
0.1885935366153717,
-0.028497133404016495,
0.13496899604797363,
0.4931641221046448,
0.4118310511112213,
0.4665725827217102,
-0.26824790239334106,
-0.353030264377594,
0.07357729226350784,
-0.3820017874240875,
-0.4324699938297272,
0.18970321118831635,
-0.15765123069286346,
-0.44715607166290283,
0.4734189510345459,
0.023451989516615868,
0.46730926632881165,
0.10944182425737381,
-0.3060489892959595,
-0.3005216717720032,
0.163038969039917,
0.5071892738342285,
0.9196805357933044,
-0.34103938937187195,
-0.18108303844928741,
0.3768823742866516,
-0.511566698551178,
0.34783756732940674,
0.021045085042715073,
-0.18735575675964355,
0.2887905538082123,
0.04993801563978195,
0.7866577506065369,
-0.08993791788816452,
-0.3535057306289673,
0.27675125002861023,
-0.005408830009400845,
-0.21974174678325653,
-0.6602469086647034,
-0.32102978229522705,
-0.28225454688072205,
-0.14330610632896423,
0.19832193851470947,
0.07459839433431625,
0.4160287380218506,
-0.6457439064979553,
0.31294527649879456,
0.1493663191795349,
-0.7718780636787415,
-0.5871168375015259,
0.6825333833694458,
0.31102055311203003,
-0.35680750012397766,
0.7188369631767273,
-0.34283018112182617,
-0.4713413715362549,
0.7420271039009094,
0.41399312019348145,
1.1675293445587158,
-0.37106087803840637,
-0.03485621139407158,
0.47427207231521606,
0.7307033538818359,
-0.1001797541975975,
0.18007856607437134,
0.08568006753921509,
-0.37429264187812805,
-0.4532139301300049,
-0.5927929878234863,
-0.5264734029769897,
0.11061909049749374,
-0.6521191000938416,
0.47342193126678467,
-0.1480293571949005,
-0.3381683826446533,
-0.21716202795505524,
0.16983404755592346,
-1.1478662490844727,
0.45225346088409424,
-0.18360444903373718,
0.9050028920173645,
-0.892593502998352,
0.7176869511604309,
1.237151861190796,
-0.44278639554977417,
-0.1588967889547348,
-0.246834397315979,
-0.10904961824417114,
-0.9281921982765198,
0.8144875764846802,
0.2715942859649658,
-0.2256079614162445,
0.1402500420808792,
-0.37146979570388794,
-0.6487035751342773,
1.3088736534118652,
0.0064880577847361565,
-0.5764706134796143,
0.39408189058303833,
0.18050284683704376,
0.7352445721626282,
-0.41264471411705017,
0.2586449682712555,
0.7297091484069824,
0.657355785369873,
-0.19199764728546143,
-1.2279926538467407,
-0.06996853649616241,
-0.3108038306236267,
0.04365339130163193,
0.4751354455947876,
-0.5383388996124268,
0.3222520053386688,
0.10260370373725891,
-0.34809181094169617,
0.16397377848625183,
0.47485801577568054,
-0.2539409399032593,
0.605082631111145,
0.6781312227249146,
0.8051198124885559,
0.5732617378234863,
-0.10492681711912155,
1.3614052534103394,
-0.33125919103622437,
0.377021461725235,
1.0807080268859863,
-0.0780835822224617,
0.7737640142440796,
0.4316866993904114,
-0.4743025600910187,
0.3734891712665558,
0.8284001350402832,
-0.14319729804992676,
0.46588030457496643,
0.24372662603855133,
0.1059010699391365,
-0.05439062789082527,
-0.002325605135411024,
-0.3731827735900879,
0.06200447678565979,
0.4717765152454376,
-0.5589187145233154,
0.02979610487818718,
-0.04225647822022438,
-0.03715904802083969,
-0.19435064494609833,
0.027868375182151794,
0.7025699615478516,
0.08683143556118011,
-0.7687039971351624,
0.4987451732158661,
0.03112703002989292,
0.33305445313453674,
-0.5887590050697327,
0.1172657161951065,
-0.30709108710289,
0.5036911964416504,
0.000028166345146019012,
-0.8329675197601318,
0.5974608659744263,
0.0066725644282996655,
0.08732280135154724,
-0.5169928073883057,
0.12471658736467361,
-0.2570716142654419,
-0.601857602596283,
0.29429924488067627,
0.3455604910850525,
0.29083532094955444,
0.17513367533683777,
-0.830558180809021,
0.023352261632680893,
-0.1335681527853012,
-0.2039986550807953,
0.27502986788749695,
0.6266369223594666,
-0.0706004723906517,
0.7910928726196289,
0.5491313934326172,
0.002247792901471257,
0.1734675019979477,
0.13336066901683807,
0.5755429267883301,
-0.7776694893836975,
-0.22089950740337372,
-0.7684091329574585,
0.48538830876350403,
-0.07150350511074066,
-0.6446883678436279,
1.2411478757858276,
0.9345923662185669,
0.9934640526771545,
-0.03409799933433533,
0.8537570238113403,
-0.0418487973511219,
0.465518981218338,
-0.28708943724632263,
0.3988838493824005,
-0.7369493842124939,
0.2304365634918213,
0.05153590813279152,
-0.9751005172729492,
-0.44434207677841187,
0.47617363929748535,
-0.34270045161247253,
-0.4684380888938904,
0.890553891658783,
0.4493354558944702,
0.09162914007902145,
-0.13953101634979248,
0.16009286046028137,
0.1616639494895935,
0.2787170112133026,
0.13820625841617584,
1.05624258518219,
-0.8089267611503601,
0.5651500225067139,
-0.07216952741146088,
-0.2734453082084656,
-0.22326421737670898,
-0.7767583131790161,
-0.503139078617096,
-0.3781231939792633,
-0.3846460282802582,
-0.48732173442840576,
0.22562649846076965,
0.9641610383987427,
0.27980488538742065,
-1.0367348194122314,
-0.6542341709136963,
-0.0900397077202797,
-0.0918140634894371,
-0.5398306250572205,
-0.27825459837913513,
0.11313624680042267,
-0.689815104007721,
-1.071974515914917,
0.37430888414382935,
0.5078610181808472,
-0.12032099813222885,
-0.406645804643631,
-0.05055847764015198,
-0.04647129774093628,
-0.08187196403741837,
0.6850665807723999,
-0.08180639147758484,
-0.26040390133857727,
-0.4442971348762512,
0.36311066150665283,
-0.15727779269218445,
0.38374805450439453,
0.8020723462104797,
-0.46592074632644653,
0.7136167287826538,
0.681763231754303,
0.5879183411598206,
0.3631364703178406,
0.037726424634456635,
1.0077776908874512,
-0.3794306516647339,
0.001984247239306569,
0.07627590745687485,
0.27794361114501953,
0.4645119905471802,
-0.1831851750612259,
0.810122549533844,
0.35277989506721497,
-0.8345336318016052,
-0.7301061749458313,
0.04332682117819786,
-0.6499264240264893,
0.2031169980764389,
0.9943732023239136,
-0.35389524698257446,
-0.152472585439682,
-0.16821065545082092,
0.0178730059415102,
0.14070384204387665,
-0.32457152009010315,
0.9266951084136963,
0.7332468032836914,
-0.05957036837935448,
0.3998812437057495,
-0.9896558523178101,
0.08070629835128784,
0.3004688620567322,
-0.9056459069252014,
-0.39497724175453186,
0.5128814578056335,
0.34495916962623596,
0.16751722991466522,
0.5278128385543823,
-0.5684065818786621,
0.10969603061676025,
-0.0019299741834402084,
0.13440459966659546,
0.31523823738098145,
-0.3967478573322296,
-0.3817582130432129,
-0.42005643248558044,
0.10054557770490646,
-0.634391725063324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03255v1 | How Similar Are Elected Politicians and Their Constituents? Quantitative Evidence From Online Social Network | 2024-07-03T16:36:26 | 2024-07-03T16:36:26 | Waleed Iqbal, Gareth Tyson, Ignacio Castro | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | How similar are politicians to those who vote for them? This is a critical
question at the heart of democratic representation and particularly relevant at
times when political dissatisfaction and populism are on the rise. To answer
this question we compare the online discourse of elected politicians and their
constituents. We collect a two and a half years (September 2020 - February
2023) constituency-level dataset for USA and UK that includes: (i) the Twitter
timelines (5.6 Million tweets) of elected political representatives (595 UK
Members of Parliament and 433 USA Representatives), (ii) the Nextdoor posts
(21.8 Million posts) of the constituency (98.4% USA and 91.5% UK
constituencies). We find that elected politicians tend to be equally similar to
their constituents in terms of content and style regardless of whether a
constituency elects a right or left-wing politician. The size of the electoral
victory and the level of income of a constituency shows a nuanced picture. The
narrower the electoral victory, the more similar the style and the more
dissimilar the content is. The lower the income of a constituency, the more
similar the content is. In terms of style, poorer constituencies tend to have a
more similar sentiment and more dissimilar psychological text traits (i.e.
measured with LIWC categories). | [
-0.6456020474433899,
-0.08866006135940552,
0.6980636119842529,
0.03601882606744766,
-0.3763067424297333,
0.4749225676059723,
-0.20233651995658875,
-0.3163868188858032,
0.7776467800140381,
0.4797731935977936,
-0.3080277144908905,
-0.2439192682504654,
-0.5807973742485046,
0.11904576420783997,
-0.19651931524276733,
0.5095033049583435,
0.6449043154716492,
0.26197463274002075,
-0.32005298137664795,
-0.21092510223388672,
0.07696934044361115,
-0.5983145236968994,
-0.34318169951438904,
-0.3622856140136719,
0.6559239625930786,
-0.009519274346530437,
0.6679510474205017,
0.3391416072845459,
0.3529132008552551,
0.35175052285194397,
0.13727083802223206,
-0.25152552127838135,
-1.1223671436309814,
-0.04865359887480736,
-0.4529728293418884,
-0.3674834966659546,
0.024879759177565575,
0.2526606619358063,
0.25804656744003296,
0.8004283308982849,
0.29597896337509155,
-0.06157783418893814,
0.42760562896728516,
0.8286029100418091,
-0.775050699710846,
0.23472939431667328,
-0.891188383102417,
-0.219528928399086,
-0.1307743638753891,
-0.45258828997612,
-0.26015010476112366,
-1.1875519752502441,
-0.11072510480880737,
-0.2621283531188965,
0.22047556936740875,
-0.1363312155008316,
0.9075102806091309,
-0.2682560682296753,
-0.6716828942298889,
-0.3166861832141876,
-0.31876569986343384,
0.45959481596946716,
-0.5995868444442749,
0.3092752695083618,
0.13375379145145416,
0.3856678605079651,
-0.05437801778316498,
-0.6305745840072632,
-0.4660147726535797,
-0.1948111653327942,
-0.1727120578289032,
0.39906084537506104,
-0.1839102804660797,
-0.04194983094930649,
-0.010473441332578659,
0.25954410433769226,
-0.5882189273834229,
-0.07276853173971176,
-0.37416309118270874,
-0.28339600563049316,
0.5124655961990356,
0.0004405031504575163,
0.0528164878487587,
-0.5645451545715332,
-0.5401706695556641,
-0.18606442213058472,
-0.7864381670951843,
0.2329254150390625,
0.8799696564674377,
0.6461440920829773,
-0.014635401777923107,
0.45032840967178345,
0.013990726321935654,
0.49692031741142273,
0.20256641507148743,
0.21653766930103302,
0.018284540623426437,
-0.414559543132782,
0.43815767765045166,
0.12008234858512878,
1.0401402711868286,
0.7039478421211243,
0.7222617864608765,
0.00046415621181949973,
0.01492287777364254,
0.20773974061012268,
0.09741460531949997,
-0.7607696056365967,
-0.06769086420536041,
0.12629860639572144,
-0.7277404069900513,
-0.0162454042583704,
0.7058151960372925,
-0.4276507794857025,
-0.8761157989501953,
-0.1992800384759903,
0.16237588226795197,
-0.05848776549100876,
-0.41932278871536255,
-0.5550760626792908,
-0.26751208305358887,
0.22500860691070557,
0.20000134408473969,
-0.7138208150863647,
0.1926601529121399,
1.2301779985427856,
0.9541366696357727,
-0.16470889747142792,
0.06903744488954544,
-0.39244091510772705,
-0.14242011308670044,
-0.6454775929450989,
0.8625850677490234,
-0.631624162197113,
-0.13599544763565063,
0.1790289729833603,
-0.0699719786643982,
0.007476411759853363,
-0.9174383878707886,
-0.2989172339439392,
-0.48726046085357666,
0.18926069140434265,
-0.6772440075874329,
-0.6987374424934387,
0.2683517634868622,
0.1845940351486206,
-0.8823081851005554,
0.4969824552536011,
0.2998042702674866,
-0.6918912529945374,
0.7101148962974548,
-0.30214598774909973,
0.056554507464170456,
-0.22370478510856628,
-0.3941691517829895,
-0.06029423326253891,
0.3126235902309418,
-0.13455785810947418,
0.7741772532463074,
0.08949065953493118,
0.06010473519563675,
-0.7990415096282959,
-0.39309990406036377,
0.6132444143295288,
-0.001117986161261797,
0.9585592150688171,
-0.008255019783973694,
-0.1535889059305191,
0.053295474499464035,
-0.6676850914955139,
-0.1770397573709488,
-0.36293596029281616,
0.18941758573055267,
-0.27294138073921204,
0.008303998969495296,
0.09562891721725464,
0.42963850498199463,
0.1722201257944107,
-0.9187743067741394,
0.12759847939014435,
-0.39928901195526123,
0.8787627220153809,
0.8973389863967896,
0.38934868574142456,
0.4584674537181854,
-0.562457799911499,
0.3151831030845642,
0.03014659322798252,
-0.046384844928979874,
0.2958783209323883,
-0.649965226650238,
-0.10597730427980423,
-0.11474976688623428,
0.6154911518096924,
0.28589221835136414,
-0.2149655818939209,
0.1829262375831604,
-0.6083791851997375,
-0.43033140897750854,
-0.41494429111480713,
-0.4621126353740692,
-0.22277383506298065,
0.007527738809585571,
-0.21513141691684723,
-0.34088134765625,
-0.2992934286594391,
-0.9731951355934143,
-0.8011401295661926,
-0.6520524024963379,
-0.24065692722797394,
0.4079015552997589,
0.6076868772506714,
0.22842995822429657,
1.0437320470809937,
-0.1389022171497345,
-0.048414260149002075,
0.09608190506696701,
0.16228334605693817,
0.07575124502182007,
0.13089841604232788,
0.548382043838501,
-0.6327641010284424,
-0.5715433359146118,
0.3341084122657776,
-0.26834923028945923,
-0.09236479550600052,
-0.06612692028284073,
0.05350901558995247,
-0.021989425644278526,
0.3012795150279999,
-0.17904381453990936,
0.380000501871109,
0.40371567010879517,
-0.43028321862220764,
-0.007289024069905281,
0.1810753047466278,
0.5067724585533142,
-1.3631213903427124,
0.054586756974458694,
-0.11598847061395645,
-0.5878042578697205,
-0.25661617517471313,
0.030286327004432678,
-0.12517161667346954,
-0.022688908502459526,
-0.34892597794532776,
0.3395250737667084,
-0.4286459982395172,
-0.5504178404808044,
0.02146189659833908,
0.2694712281227112,
-0.1509428769350052,
-0.05722683668136597,
-0.3481076657772064,
0.8141795992851257,
0.2800603210926056,
0.026387466117739677,
0.521757185459137,
-0.17837657034397125,
-0.793580949306488,
0.8277561664581299,
-0.535954475402832,
0.2354540228843689,
-0.15142756700515747,
0.22433502972126007,
-1.4656003713607788,
-0.440460205078125,
0.04766099154949188,
-0.5835373997688293,
-0.07686218619346619,
-0.08428540080785751,
-0.3333961069583893,
-0.360983669757843,
-0.3347759544849396,
-0.11478418856859207,
0.49266886711120605,
-0.2061551958322525,
0.565430760383606,
0.5813794732093811,
-0.3972349464893341,
-0.24045872688293457,
-0.6419814229011536,
0.16734318435192108,
-0.3248389959335327,
-0.5112397074699402,
0.3096809387207031,
0.5132877826690674,
-0.6654351949691772,
0.42171475291252136,
0.0996861532330513,
-0.2572267949581146,
-0.39159372448921204,
0.29229000210762024,
-0.3105418086051941,
-0.18964940309524536,
0.023310499265789986,
-0.463886559009552,
-0.027291791513562202,
0.04793925583362579,
0.022407924756407738,
0.5547825694084167,
0.052634794265031815,
-0.2611629068851471,
-0.47481101751327515,
0.577229380607605,
0.4696979820728302,
0.04380304366350174,
0.873179018497467,
0.39992555975914,
-0.1963520646095276,
0.15350624918937683,
-0.48299118876457214,
-0.4117024838924408,
-0.4424711763858795,
0.19807541370391846,
-0.34828123450279236,
-0.8429273366928101,
1.0605548620224,
0.21304258704185486,
0.33528101444244385,
0.6453084945678711,
0.5218270421028137,
-0.19696685671806335,
0.6872676014900208,
0.2053040862083435,
-0.008590987883508205,
0.3205074369907379,
-0.30921900272369385,
0.17106610536575317,
-0.12477343529462814,
-0.4061979353427887,
-0.7195912003517151,
-0.6301779747009277,
-1.0268803834915161,
-0.2592083513736725,
0.040623437613248825,
-0.10495877265930176,
-0.38801005482673645,
0.3635527789592743,
-0.6345334053039551,
0.3895314335823059,
0.46157029271125793,
0.1507285237312317,
-0.17581163346767426,
0.2615601420402527,
0.3959480822086334,
-0.38859567046165466,
-0.43761342763900757,
-0.38476213812828064,
0.9011971950531006,
-0.1337675154209137,
0.4600430727005005,
0.22713634371757507,
0.8512766361236572,
0.5368703603744507,
0.4215390086174011,
-0.5666453838348389,
0.42149272561073303,
-0.028384840115904808,
-0.5207578539848328,
-0.027550362050533295,
-0.7504379749298096,
-1.1631442308425903,
0.11738427728414536,
-0.23904523253440857,
-0.7294895648956299,
0.5857172012329102,
0.017877301201224327,
-0.2515527904033661,
0.73456871509552,
-0.21914958953857422,
0.6525187492370605,
0.06886053085327148,
-0.3776434361934662,
-0.27889183163642883,
-0.8897107243537903,
-0.13403421640396118,
0.19046053290367126,
0.212962344288826,
-0.29024094343185425,
-0.0734507218003273,
0.8842828869819641,
-0.5438680052757263,
0.49949702620506287,
-0.2586212456226349,
0.24833530187606812,
0.3667990565299988,
-0.3087945878505707,
0.2706223130226135,
-0.34945061802864075,
-0.23569878935813904,
0.10141848772764206,
0.36758124828338623,
-0.5922629833221436,
-0.749756932258606,
0.9099224209785461,
-1.0363823175430298,
-0.46333304047584534,
-0.6020971536636353,
-0.15532828867435455,
0.06412101536989212,
-0.03537869453430176,
0.463990718126297,
0.7861169576644897,
-0.5947651267051697,
0.7091132402420044,
-0.06312363594770432,
0.45383575558662415,
0.5815458297729492,
-0.233497753739357,
-0.1513657122850418,
-0.6588153839111328,
1.0166704654693604,
0.599092423915863,
0.36082351207733154,
0.5945079922676086,
0.38450273871421814,
-0.625993013381958,
0.028363119810819626,
-0.12760889530181885,
0.12725897133350372,
-0.44498226046562195,
-0.09489826112985611,
-0.5456423163414001,
-0.028871575370430946,
-0.4468914866447449,
-0.2278965264558792,
-0.3356590270996094,
-0.582979142665863,
-0.3508763015270233,
0.2132255584001541,
0.24670985341072083,
1.3368970155715942,
-0.18658801913261414,
0.21898439526557922,
-0.15986308455467224,
0.027063103392720222,
0.6396431922912598,
0.2980952858924866,
-0.13913992047309875,
-0.373855322599411,
0.1662030816078186,
0.17584547400474548,
-0.46455249190330505,
-1.5399668216705322,
-0.23363755643367767,
0.456380695104599,
0.274042010307312,
1.0497759580612183,
0.32356420159339905,
0.709575891494751,
-0.19780422747135162,
1.1278355121612549,
0.27588891983032227,
-0.5203381776809692,
0.06051212549209595,
-0.3776599168777466,
-0.030759433284401894,
0.9460907578468323,
0.5429111123085022,
-0.2401479184627533,
-0.4111289083957672,
-0.7192884087562561,
-0.5037004351615906,
0.24196362495422363,
0.37044450640678406,
0.3211025297641754,
0.006241948343813419,
0.2125435769557953,
0.21862681210041046,
0.3342941105365753,
-0.5886236429214478,
-0.22197368741035461,
-0.4510324001312256,
-0.03575941175222397,
-0.047722358256578445,
-0.10597606003284454,
0.06579135358333588,
-0.014314509928226471,
0.03763962909579277,
-0.07826855778694153,
0.44133609533309937,
0.05063038691878319,
0.5834071636199951,
-0.07455653697252274,
0.26557594537734985,
0.2586180567741394,
1.2560945749282837,
-0.4524771571159363,
0.17469806969165802,
-0.21502375602722168,
-0.2221994698047638,
0.2670935094356537,
-0.2927090525627136,
0.15971457958221436,
0.2615717053413391,
0.7323064208030701,
0.5266426205635071,
-0.1022452637553215,
-0.08070852607488632,
0.7476863861083984,
0.037941720336675644,
-0.35383516550064087,
-0.20463669300079346,
-0.22050821781158447,
0.581637978553772,
-0.033704567700624466,
0.5647506713867188,
0.2395235151052475,
0.0062489998526871204,
-1.3809224367141724,
0.14522458612918854,
0.7129186391830444,
-0.720220685005188,
-0.5614018440246582,
0.4645933508872986,
0.4353178143501282,
-0.8867435455322266,
0.07990050315856934,
-0.31275662779808044,
-0.5876330733299255,
0.6848998665809631,
0.3427172005176544,
0.5414189696311951,
-0.14484697580337524,
0.24078048765659332,
0.25974079966545105,
0.10809571295976639,
0.32102444767951965,
0.32009050250053406,
0.2447035014629364,
-0.41195350885391235,
0.06325334310531616,
-0.3454735577106476,
-0.2773556709289551,
0.15124908089637756,
-0.8778392672538757,
-0.03491942584514618,
-0.5238474607467651,
-0.6770865321159363,
0.12176626920700073,
0.5169587135314941,
-0.5447171330451965,
0.05802415683865547,
-0.3298761248588562,
0.5261706113815308,
-1.1180428266525269,
0.02281424216926098,
0.6333895325660706,
-0.0007871914422139525,
-0.8180102705955505,
0.3015514314174652,
-0.11077762395143509,
-0.45694026350975037,
0.07907029986381531,
0.4356014132499695,
0.13665728271007538,
-0.25645971298217773,
-0.2132432758808136,
-0.3495914340019226,
0.6711139678955078,
0.7079362273216248,
-0.8205094337463379,
-0.10650304704904556,
0.45003268122673035,
0.449494332075119,
-0.6470130085945129,
0.6227997541427612,
0.12419654428958893,
0.36211177706718445,
0.03497453033924103,
-0.6256715059280396,
-0.1256542205810547,
0.008990947157144547,
-0.07955090701580048,
0.289748877286911,
-0.9450095891952515,
0.8519061207771301,
0.15684787929058075,
-0.4450106620788574,
-0.1109044998884201,
0.6220479607582092,
0.06254911422729492,
0.41209590435028076,
0.6946314573287964,
0.1771276891231537,
0.581908106803894,
-0.21749460697174072,
0.999129056930542,
-0.7740015387535095,
0.1830885112285614,
0.6890265941619873,
-0.3137056827545166,
0.8762566447257996,
0.5908237099647522,
-0.46890783309936523,
0.6830624938011169,
0.7368608117103577,
0.25558343529701233,
0.6552858352661133,
0.3445223271846771,
-0.01763816736638546,
-0.3309079706668854,
-0.29279080033302307,
-0.5775485634803772,
0.42412492632865906,
-0.004914243705570698,
-0.2628440856933594,
-0.09790206700563431,
-0.15143446624279022,
-0.21931304037570953,
0.6817154884338379,
-0.3418358564376831,
0.932889997959137,
0.3171365559101105,
-0.5490034818649292,
0.07913849502801895,
-0.6781196594238281,
0.04344889521598816,
-0.28664135932922363,
0.0013040780322626233,
-0.20014998316764832,
-0.08636268228292465,
-0.14741003513336182,
-1.2407844066619873,
0.3019002377986908,
-0.11155260354280472,
0.0048210350796580315,
-0.10771104693412781,
0.38066914677619934,
-0.17736178636550903,
-0.48599153757095337,
0.5275222659111023,
0.6709043979644775,
0.3133699595928192,
-0.24208073318004608,
-0.6565744876861572,
0.16001355648040771,
0.03607947751879692,
-0.3471701145172119,
0.06517358124256134,
0.39220747351646423,
0.2025061398744583,
0.5062447190284729,
0.3636762499809265,
0.6881347894668579,
-0.026272350922226906,
0.1848994642496109,
0.9670541286468506,
-0.36370551586151123,
-0.6077653169631958,
-0.6651010513305664,
0.2815019488334656,
-0.6609349250793457,
-0.6683417558670044,
0.6749005913734436,
0.8006247878074646,
0.8651931285858154,
0.08820084482431412,
0.5328536629676819,
-0.20610614120960236,
0.649469792842865,
-0.14609672129154205,
0.941020667552948,
-0.6667073369026184,
-0.2018103152513504,
-0.09414641559123993,
-1.3889403343200684,
0.20156079530715942,
0.7027462720870972,
-0.45809635519981384,
0.2651817500591278,
0.41675108671188354,
1.0214312076568604,
-0.5078098177909851,
-0.1290341466665268,
0.32446327805519104,
0.07018478959798813,
-0.07919148355722427,
0.21635708212852478,
1.127643346786499,
-0.026214690878987312,
0.44167566299438477,
-0.09042631834745407,
0.18006576597690582,
-0.25494125485420227,
-0.5343464612960815,
-1.0659793615341187,
-0.8407496213912964,
-0.2635915279388428,
-0.5309420228004456,
0.29515761137008667,
1.0459657907485962,
0.8645484447479248,
-0.9024691581726074,
-0.2908640205860138,
0.11919380724430084,
-0.09006939828395844,
0.05228592827916145,
-0.28647714853286743,
0.40263429284095764,
0.4526931047439575,
-0.592953622341156,
-0.31777456402778625,
0.2457849532365799,
-0.45509347319602966,
-0.37094712257385254,
0.1711435317993164,
0.07587207108736038,
0.2934628129005432,
0.307526558637619,
-0.07630161941051483,
-1.0955215692520142,
-0.6022982597351074,
-0.14020788669586182,
-0.5264424681663513,
0.3343141973018646,
0.8919641375541687,
-0.7182292342185974,
0.4265997111797333,
0.9702739119529724,
0.0729115828871727,
0.3106823265552521,
0.6203104853630066,
0.3686561584472656,
-0.5209230780601501,
-0.018477587029337883,
0.3588718771934509,
0.015412825159728527,
0.67240971326828,
-0.0702584907412529,
0.4729810655117035,
0.260547012090683,
-0.5890040397644043,
-0.6806554198265076,
0.3926355540752411,
-1.0594745874404907,
-0.08102373033761978,
0.8090435266494751,
-0.2160366177558899,
0.013307887129485607,
-0.06992022693157196,
-0.027206681668758392,
0.23986394703388214,
-0.6055777072906494,
0.648522675037384,
0.40880826115608215,
0.012004435993731022,
-0.3327420651912689,
-0.2363739013671875,
0.24697022140026093,
-0.1583675742149353,
-0.5972815155982971,
-0.1762617528438568,
0.07341877371072769,
0.17490698397159576,
0.2402947098016739,
0.7054660320281982,
0.25726038217544556,
0.10948407649993896,
0.3151800334453583,
-0.5413033366203308,
0.19826574623584747,
-0.3195746839046478,
-0.0013474002480506897,
0.6015052199363708,
-0.3636336028575897,
-0.04827059805393219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03253v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03253v1 | STF: Sentence Transformer Fine-Tuning For Topic Categorization With Limited Data | 2024-07-03T16:34:56 | 2024-07-03T16:34:56 | Kheir Eddine Daouadi, Yaakoub Boualleg, Oussama Guehairia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nowadays, topic classification from tweets attracts considerable research
attention. Different classification systems have been suggested thanks to these
research efforts. Nevertheless, they face major challenges owing to low
performance metrics due to the limited amount of labeled data. We propose
Sentence Transformers Fine-tuning (STF), a topic detection system that
leverages pretrained Sentence Transformers models and fine-tuning to classify
topics from tweets accurately. Moreover, extensive parameter sensitivity
analyses were conducted to finetune STF parameters for our topic classification
task to achieve the best performance results. Experiments on two benchmark
datasets demonstrated that (1) the proposed STF can be effectively used for
classifying tweet topics and outperforms the latest state-of-the-art
approaches, and (2) the proposed STF does not require a huge amount of labeled
tweets to achieve good accuracy, which is a limitation of many state-of-the-art
approaches. Our main contribution is the achievement of promising results in
tweet topic classification by applying pretrained sentence transformers
language models. | [
-0.6572138667106628,
-0.9692801237106323,
0.31943854689598083,
0.3296205401420593,
-0.6156795620918274,
0.172478586435318,
-0.4535619020462036,
-0.05700189247727394,
0.29671239852905273,
0.5681685209274292,
-0.7545048594474792,
-0.3828320801258087,
-0.9313422441482544,
0.02186185121536255,
-0.5763371586799622,
1.2262765169143677,
-0.10261662304401398,
-0.33547839522361755,
0.10564034432172775,
0.059888847172260284,
-0.6365662217140198,
-0.011413922533392906,
-0.5692377090454102,
-0.09644230455160141,
0.4264187812805176,
0.8978399634361267,
0.5616581439971924,
0.5132930874824524,
0.6987881660461426,
0.24131949245929718,
0.05746056139469147,
0.21325166523456573,
-0.6232462525367737,
0.07765451073646545,
-0.3257489800453186,
-0.2237793505191803,
-0.07907360792160034,
-0.08458174020051956,
0.46497616171836853,
0.463612824678421,
-0.12380078434944153,
0.1837722808122635,
-0.03278617560863495,
0.29581305384635925,
-0.3722682595252991,
-0.019078588113188744,
-0.7268761396408081,
0.13115613162517548,
-0.2863158881664276,
-0.6361382007598877,
-0.26401495933532715,
-0.2756763696670532,
0.17765551805496216,
-0.2485744208097458,
0.7197754979133606,
0.12370381504297256,
1.2884324789047241,
0.47035667300224304,
-0.5016336441040039,
-0.04478767141699791,
-0.7247259020805359,
0.6651633977890015,
-0.2991168797016144,
0.22885581851005554,
0.2294319123029709,
0.3592219054698944,
0.053547441959381104,
-0.9646159410476685,
-0.46246397495269775,
0.07294147461652756,
-0.15302380919456482,
-0.03233194723725319,
-0.4050971269607544,
0.06095872074365616,
0.2436646819114685,
0.36343419551849365,
-0.6901560425758362,
0.17064641416072845,
-0.3083646893501282,
-0.09536567330360413,
0.47949838638305664,
0.1291528195142746,
0.08066384494304657,
-0.2963707447052002,
-0.13282546401023865,
0.13376063108444214,
-0.19373689591884613,
-0.1478562206029892,
0.098362997174263,
0.5586315393447876,
-0.041676491498947144,
0.4488545358181,
-0.44167953729629517,
0.3948879837989807,
0.225569948554039,
0.2804716229438782,
0.09265312552452087,
-0.21209140121936798,
-0.1794719099998474,
-0.06841720640659332,
0.873020589351654,
0.3971858024597168,
0.4027208089828491,
-0.2521969676017761,
-0.19579006731510162,
0.1698470562696457,
0.5587943196296692,
-1.219555377960205,
-0.3371117115020752,
-0.011912313289940357,
-0.5656958818435669,
-0.4663636386394501,
0.2592253088951111,
-0.6420018672943115,
-0.20883768796920776,
-0.16417822241783142,
0.4948456585407257,
-0.3082815110683441,
-0.18209947645664215,
0.156497061252594,
-0.08644416183233261,
-0.26795694231987,
0.3064521551132202,
-1.0087521076202393,
0.03270580992102623,
0.7528435587882996,
0.7799373865127563,
-0.2181287705898285,
-0.1940830498933792,
-0.7052883505821228,
-0.14973768591880798,
-0.2739742398262024,
1.146614670753479,
-0.6863895058631897,
-0.13457739353179932,
0.06213843822479248,
0.055659569799900055,
-0.031822167336940765,
-0.32920655608177185,
0.9235320687294006,
-0.42959460616111755,
0.0759439691901207,
0.055612172931432724,
-0.6424709558486938,
0.547924280166626,
0.03866666927933693,
-0.3910042643547058,
0.8314384818077087,
0.010933531448245049,
-1.012068748474121,
0.6851091980934143,
-0.7361790537834167,
-0.7364174723625183,
0.03242524340748787,
0.1234176754951477,
-0.42226743698120117,
0.31746819615364075,
0.3208140432834625,
0.8125101327896118,
-0.315311074256897,
0.7844224572181702,
-0.12109824270009995,
-0.5682749152183533,
0.006808247417211533,
-0.46322202682495117,
0.1912936270236969,
0.4943714439868927,
-0.05107159912586212,
0.5377903580665588,
-0.47007882595062256,
-0.13590946793556213,
-0.045454926788806915,
-0.06501475721597672,
-0.03250863775610924,
0.03513293340802193,
0.255166232585907,
0.10338352620601654,
0.06955058872699738,
-0.4855008125305176,
0.18467994034290314,
-0.3969416916370392,
0.8512171506881714,
0.48569542169570923,
0.2126292586326599,
0.6360846161842346,
-0.28964558243751526,
0.3260948956012726,
0.07515381276607513,
0.15067850053310394,
-0.12715034186840057,
-0.3316500782966614,
-0.9531580209732056,
0.0211982149630785,
0.483408123254776,
0.37676289677619934,
-0.7907817959785461,
0.8986849784851074,
-0.4155098497867584,
-0.6480770111083984,
-0.453986257314682,
-0.13383182883262634,
-0.18868067860603333,
0.37437108159065247,
0.43524429202079773,
0.15555085241794586,
-0.495983362197876,
-0.9725929498672485,
-0.3579806685447693,
-0.03686856850981712,
-0.2908203601837158,
0.04431331157684326,
0.4470428228378296,
-0.17301051318645477,
0.8961707353591919,
-0.7746184468269348,
-0.4089116156101227,
-0.30382660031318665,
0.6053473949432373,
0.08053453266620636,
0.41111838817596436,
0.3725915551185608,
-0.971223771572113,
-0.3556908965110779,
-0.19893692433834076,
-0.16961750388145447,
-0.2693205177783966,
-0.05373299494385719,
-0.17663882672786713,
-0.10014385730028152,
0.6948019862174988,
-0.6761574149131775,
0.45290306210517883,
0.09851989895105362,
-0.39592716097831726,
0.16781488060951233,
0.02164280042052269,
0.04219699651002884,
-1.2377873659133911,
-0.2863098382949829,
0.24014294147491455,
-0.3166334629058838,
-0.8045498132705688,
-0.25779587030410767,
0.33605602383613586,
-0.2278374284505844,
-0.3521463871002197,
0.29468095302581787,
0.3351857662200928,
0.494469553232193,
-0.7503445148468018,
-0.09702124446630478,
-0.23894178867340088,
0.243453249335289,
0.14137451350688934,
0.6292017698287964,
0.4305369257926941,
-0.5954378843307495,
0.2544393539428711,
0.3799435496330261,
-0.3235442340373993,
0.24402931332588196,
-0.5050293207168579,
-0.002273479476571083,
-0.13541993498802185,
0.19664856791496277,
-0.997676432132721,
-0.259240984916687,
0.22171975672245026,
-0.43810614943504333,
0.27916523814201355,
0.03948744758963585,
-0.773215115070343,
-0.47903427481651306,
-0.10046960413455963,
-0.0962410420179367,
0.4002675712108612,
-0.43187060952186584,
0.31607192754745483,
0.24097804725170135,
-0.18352505564689636,
-0.24340344965457916,
-0.5184119939804077,
0.03569462150335312,
-0.3396746814250946,
-0.5577145218849182,
0.5562077164649963,
0.17203348875045776,
0.31855762004852295,
0.06964416056871414,
-0.3480447828769684,
-0.1615246832370758,
0.12394774705171585,
0.11546221375465393,
-0.13601042330265045,
-0.21378257870674133,
0.722526490688324,
0.28424039483070374,
-0.3846215605735779,
-0.3720960021018982,
-0.26535701751708984,
0.6766425967216492,
-0.2461746484041214,
0.12587381899356842,
-0.5493265986442566,
0.19978347420692444,
0.2625841796398163,
-0.4784901440143585,
0.6430572867393494,
1.0858469009399414,
-0.4873824119567871,
-0.5211890935897827,
-0.5069643259048462,
-0.3943581283092499,
-0.5027652978897095,
0.4275331497192383,
-0.3654937148094177,
-1.3909379243850708,
0.13561348617076874,
-0.22620204091072083,
-0.19879962503910065,
0.6529891490936279,
0.20453467965126038,
-0.2232879251241684,
0.614674985408783,
0.9622645378112793,
-0.11780732870101929,
0.6915952563285828,
-0.1348210573196411,
0.45251598954200745,
-0.20952443778514862,
0.24088463187217712,
-0.7991105318069458,
-0.47025224566459656,
-0.8446909189224243,
-0.23157504200935364,
-0.17773936688899994,
0.1531199961900711,
-0.4257391095161438,
0.5710858702659607,
-0.7574552297592163,
0.5075893402099609,
0.5440806746482849,
0.21792547404766083,
0.04138480871915817,
0.0011666682548820972,
0.575925350189209,
-0.17311625182628632,
-0.5004200339317322,
-0.6828400492668152,
0.6583839654922485,
0.47897154092788696,
0.6934874653816223,
-0.2380339354276657,
0.474060595035553,
0.3425869941711426,
0.33142220973968506,
-0.7322314381599426,
0.5145370364189148,
-0.769626259803772,
-0.43764975666999817,
-0.5652549266815186,
-0.4679550230503082,
-0.6412619948387146,
-0.032556094229221344,
-0.3195511996746063,
-0.7619709968566895,
0.05826856568455696,
-0.11623965203762054,
-0.3201982378959656,
0.3064453601837158,
-0.7916635870933533,
1.18722403049469,
-0.046788111329078674,
0.014980029314756393,
-0.2169741690158844,
-0.5442216396331787,
-0.03780633583664894,
-0.27671900391578674,
-0.3426820635795593,
-0.5301096439361572,
0.007943387143313885,
0.899618923664093,
-0.1755659431219101,
0.6048770546913147,
-0.35003167390823364,
0.054153427481651306,
0.014601627364754677,
-0.30102208256721497,
0.382575124502182,
0.3465135097503662,
-0.07117494195699692,
-0.04243179038167,
-0.06771396100521088,
-0.30808523297309875,
-0.47807857394218445,
0.5793007016181946,
-0.566902756690979,
-0.776586651802063,
-0.19281363487243652,
-0.4200265109539032,
-0.42707663774490356,
0.40513354539871216,
0.6294755935668945,
0.07139710336923599,
-0.24583938717842102,
0.5953863859176636,
0.4892626702785492,
-0.11365640163421631,
0.5194599032402039,
0.31560784578323364,
0.1124950721859932,
-0.05238078534603119,
0.8896286487579346,
0.0418643020093441,
-0.20369957387447357,
0.7997180819511414,
0.1970232129096985,
-0.17669560015201569,
-0.8331409692764282,
-0.10751087218523026,
-0.10496149212121964,
-0.39766040444374084,
-0.5445400476455688,
-0.8236385583877563,
-0.383280873298645,
-0.36959052085876465,
-0.06473357230424881,
-0.4347255229949951,
-0.2920325994491577,
-0.7885164618492126,
-0.2657095193862915,
0.43067631125450134,
0.344132661819458,
0.32930296659469604,
0.7617461085319519,
-0.7814760804176331,
0.7718586921691895,
0.09825234115123749,
0.6812698245048523,
-0.4214872717857361,
-0.7742459774017334,
-0.09938815981149673,
-0.08759316802024841,
-0.5750424265861511,
-0.5787994265556335,
0.2253345251083374,
0.4259284734725952,
0.20543256402015686,
0.6117266416549683,
0.6488726735115051,
0.7498697638511658,
-0.48712027072906494,
0.4922717213630676,
0.07028059661388397,
-1.0283563137054443,
1.0118463039398193,
-0.4163344204425812,
0.2227810025215149,
0.7566596865653992,
0.13007402420043945,
-0.5017179250717163,
-0.565521776676178,
-0.4685364067554474,
-0.704234778881073,
1.0442270040512085,
0.463510125875473,
0.5722352862358093,
0.049638375639915466,
0.3780398666858673,
0.30629992485046387,
0.36069753766059875,
-0.21151500940322876,
-0.04680369794368744,
-0.4067458212375641,
-0.35541418194770813,
-0.3779272139072418,
-0.23084139823913574,
0.2659133970737457,
-0.25826552510261536,
0.2927626967430115,
-0.15352201461791992,
0.4166204631328583,
-0.1070355474948883,
-0.16437236964702606,
-0.48785194754600525,
0.4149364233016968,
0.5321231484413147,
0.491075336933136,
-0.3700050115585327,
0.1349029690027237,
0.20919722318649292,
-0.33791425824165344,
0.09922784566879272,
0.4480154812335968,
-0.13361048698425293,
0.04134372994303703,
0.27108055353164673,
1.0620222091674805,
0.12114983052015305,
-0.4025561511516571,
0.5262043476104736,
-0.2672794759273529,
-0.31551995873451233,
-0.11419554054737091,
0.36055105924606323,
0.1355603188276291,
0.29994523525238037,
0.5394569635391235,
0.4140591025352478,
0.0088322963565588,
-0.2298702448606491,
0.616388201713562,
-0.0017705484060570598,
-0.4817136526107788,
-0.15910767018795013,
0.6170356273651123,
0.2613285481929779,
-0.43327781558036804,
0.4473794996738434,
-0.2522979974746704,
-0.5278759002685547,
0.6374463438987732,
0.2850893437862396,
1.0044960975646973,
-0.13718654215335846,
0.4954928159713745,
0.11556791514158249,
0.3707300126552582,
-0.1915448009967804,
0.09675492346286774,
-0.11568772792816162,
-0.8874228596687317,
-0.36913350224494934,
-0.7808719277381897,
-0.26257243752479553,
0.3450426459312439,
-0.5458999276161194,
0.6079944372177124,
-0.44957494735717773,
-0.3058803975582123,
0.5154671669006348,
0.1822403520345688,
-0.5785316228866577,
0.3772241175174713,
-0.10337257385253906,
1.1061769723892212,
-0.8960247039794922,
0.878785252571106,
0.7627419233322144,
-0.10792676359415054,
-0.5138679146766663,
0.5962247252464294,
-0.6240372657775879,
-0.1808401197195053,
0.6254643201828003,
0.38939303159713745,
0.1782233864068985,
0.12555214762687683,
-0.4920019507408142,
-0.44699591398239136,
0.7873813509941101,
0.46538788080215454,
-0.4382838010787964,
0.045427847653627396,
0.28240227699279785,
0.6807940602302551,
-0.4128565192222595,
-0.029659848660230637,
0.5075849294662476,
0.4463736414909363,
0.11536354571580887,
-1.0466591119766235,
-0.0013262048596516252,
-0.2611069679260254,
0.05832548439502716,
0.41336917877197266,
-0.7411196827888489,
0.4746286869049072,
0.09680461138486862,
-0.21632421016693115,
0.006188512779772282,
0.8624598979949951,
-0.1475229114294052,
0.6510438323020935,
0.47503334283828735,
0.3468523323535919,
0.643231213092804,
-0.6542332768440247,
0.659184992313385,
-0.07691720128059387,
0.6438894271850586,
0.8134365081787109,
-0.09441187232732773,
0.7775150537490845,
0.31429144740104675,
-0.06452775001525879,
-0.19467423856258392,
0.9432955980300903,
-0.3078276515007019,
0.7635645866394043,
0.23902082443237305,
0.2082822620868683,
-0.4795384407043457,
-0.34261101484298706,
-0.2198200523853302,
0.32311639189720154,
0.4470924139022827,
-0.14213304221630096,
-0.24423933029174805,
0.5361329317092896,
-0.3120296895503998,
0.03098740428686142,
-0.23792795836925507,
0.6541895270347595,
0.020550154149532318,
-0.5591411590576172,
0.3769633173942566,
0.1844390630722046,
1.036505103111267,
-0.3092825412750244,
0.2953490912914276,
-0.18212850391864777,
0.27270859479904175,
-0.18094801902770996,
-0.8257685899734497,
0.5262961387634277,
0.1287234127521515,
-0.14851370453834534,
-0.5363086462020874,
1.2495673894882202,
-0.27936771512031555,
-0.3651103675365448,
0.16267408430576324,
0.24337522685527802,
-0.24292635917663574,
-0.3944912850856781,
-0.38711637258529663,
-0.026017459109425545,
0.013785932213068008,
-0.28681063652038574,
-0.07169350236654282,
0.7181978225708008,
0.08267665654420853,
0.7003352046012878,
0.2905327081680298,
-0.21164695918560028,
-0.2557191252708435,
0.13093626499176025,
0.7628605961799622,
-0.8449172973632812,
-0.704664945602417,
-0.6393576264381409,
0.264684796333313,
-0.03465854376554489,
-0.620269775390625,
0.3657422363758087,
0.4146089553833008,
0.8104934692382812,
-0.28593361377716064,
0.714508056640625,
0.02139345183968544,
0.7796190977096558,
-0.3424000144004822,
0.8246996402740479,
-0.6672266721725464,
0.21422414481639862,
-0.13776610791683197,
-0.8349043130874634,
-0.5582320690155029,
0.5153515338897705,
-0.42523929476737976,
0.05881325900554657,
0.7701597809791565,
0.5802969336509705,
-0.3526560366153717,
0.5667557120323181,
0.29251450300216675,
0.01044425182044506,
0.3922955095767975,
0.3946128785610199,
1.0580124855041504,
-0.405569463968277,
0.7805588841438293,
-0.45029160380363464,
0.14706729352474213,
-0.6202558279037476,
-0.5832332968711853,
-1.1927636861801147,
-0.6935002207756042,
-0.47617730498313904,
0.03582923859357834,
0.06193871796131134,
0.7849127650260925,
0.7862377166748047,
-1.042064905166626,
0.22629201412200928,
-0.49115049839019775,
-0.030898436903953552,
0.2066512405872345,
-0.2718106508255005,
0.575600266456604,
-0.4832373857498169,
-0.632855236530304,
0.050215765833854675,
0.09520143270492554,
-0.027819626033306122,
0.2904178500175476,
0.18122859299182892,
-0.0981694683432579,
-0.17321591079235077,
0.5107482075691223,
-0.07784507423639297,
-0.5551998615264893,
-0.6025975346565247,
0.11163900792598724,
-0.1976405531167984,
-0.023662444204092026,
1.0023200511932373,
-0.43431851267814636,
-0.05057657137513161,
0.6090794801712036,
0.6137758493423462,
0.7607563138008118,
0.10167618095874786,
0.22559183835983276,
-0.9745064377784729,
0.05792874097824097,
0.38759711384773254,
0.18979492783546448,
0.07844607532024384,
-0.3083106279373169,
0.37491098046302795,
-0.009455226361751556,
-0.4212144911289215,
-0.8497689962387085,
0.18300245702266693,
-0.9138795137405396,
-0.35021165013313293,
0.9401468634605408,
0.36471983790397644,
0.2519078254699707,
-0.12107057124376297,
-0.2574785351753235,
0.6303482055664062,
-0.6179468631744385,
0.8417690396308899,
0.6804550290107727,
0.047001078724861145,
-0.4616905152797699,
-0.6046038866043091,
0.5092493295669556,
0.34254130721092224,
-0.819703221321106,
0.013920538127422333,
-0.005837467964738607,
0.06661952286958694,
0.21186651289463043,
0.46655941009521484,
0.4346565902233124,
0.20834535360336304,
-0.42271456122398376,
-0.32247617840766907,
-0.015859229490160942,
-0.4954299032688141,
-0.18164773285388947,
0.5012884140014648,
-0.2035772204399109,
-0.4082501530647278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03236v1 | CATT: Character-based Arabic Tashkeel Transformer | 2024-07-03T16:05:20 | 2024-07-03T16:05:20 | Faris Alasmary, Orjuwan Zaafarani, Ahmad Ghannam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tashkeel, or Arabic Text Diacritization (ATD), greatly enhances the
comprehension of Arabic text by removing ambiguity and minimizing the risk of
misinterpretations caused by its absence. It plays a crucial role in improving
Arabic text processing, particularly in applications such as text-to-speech and
machine translation. This paper introduces a new approach to training ATD
models. First, we finetuned two transformers, encoder-only and encoder-decoder,
that were initialized from a pretrained character-based BERT. Then, we applied
the Noisy-Student approach to boost the performance of the best model. We
evaluated our models alongside 11 commercial and open-source models using two
manually labeled benchmark datasets: WikiNews and our CATT dataset. Our
findings show that our top model surpasses all evaluated models by relative
Diacritic Error Rates (DERs) of 30.83\% and 35.21\% on WikiNews and CATT,
respectively, achieving state-of-the-art in ATD. In addition, we show that our
model outperforms GPT-4-turbo on CATT dataset by a relative DER of 9.36\%. We
open-source our CATT models and benchmark dataset for the research
community\footnote{https://github.com/abjadai/catt}. | [
-0.2488679140806198,
-0.7159469127655029,
0.18892979621887207,
-0.05443689599633217,
-0.6737226247787476,
0.6458413600921631,
-0.0008429067092947662,
-0.4635220170021057,
-0.08178512006998062,
0.5574678182601929,
-0.3646877408027649,
-0.734819233417511,
-0.587028443813324,
0.2444325089454651,
-0.5568023920059204,
1.237667202949524,
-0.3155486583709717,
0.12508529424667358,
0.7110810279846191,
0.0367112010717392,
-0.2566087245941162,
-0.6161767840385437,
-0.5580585598945618,
-0.15963076055049896,
0.1965266913175583,
0.44456496834754944,
0.8449985384941101,
0.7183307409286499,
0.7604922652244568,
0.20468154549598694,
-0.07362758368253708,
0.10961037874221802,
0.026063190773129463,
0.1908837854862213,
0.1861381232738495,
-0.18919670581817627,
-0.33597809076309204,
-0.3144673705101013,
0.7065612077713013,
0.38585713505744934,
-0.23523226380348206,
0.09244387596845627,
0.010900062508881092,
0.4698067605495453,
-0.47024795413017273,
0.00034821598092094064,
-0.5987182855606079,
0.1679435819387436,
-0.44491490721702576,
0.08664993196725845,
-0.5717800855636597,
-0.759693443775177,
0.017407886683940887,
-0.45682138204574585,
0.35722923278808594,
-0.026536526158452034,
0.9378958344459534,
0.4168259799480438,
-0.6697736382484436,
-0.04871055483818054,
-0.767723023891449,
0.8489024639129639,
-0.5994976758956909,
0.8094668984413147,
0.40580466389656067,
0.407947301864624,
0.1841896027326584,
-0.8583109974861145,
-0.5237208008766174,
-0.2087036818265915,
0.17260608077049255,
0.2620968222618103,
-0.0022566160187125206,
0.3443191945552826,
0.1864282786846161,
0.541519045829773,
-0.5840294361114502,
-0.09599658846855164,
-0.2211056351661682,
-0.08071425557136536,
0.27623096108436584,
0.06135149300098419,
0.3192989230155945,
-0.15414546430110931,
-0.5464971661567688,
-0.3866325318813324,
-0.45319709181785583,
0.2094581425189972,
0.1033523753285408,
0.30842670798301697,
-0.15553924441337585,
0.47823601961135864,
-0.06407712399959564,
0.16830556094646454,
0.2644125521183014,
0.10956209897994995,
0.13632838428020477,
-0.33019018173217773,
-0.21198727190494537,
0.1312538981437683,
0.6598913669586182,
-0.20881812274456024,
0.5278018712997437,
-0.21320976316928864,
-0.39334118366241455,
-0.04493565857410431,
0.45838335156440735,
-1.1740041971206665,
-0.42293575406074524,
-0.09858732670545578,
-0.6110503673553467,
-0.6202576160430908,
-0.00510885426774621,
-0.46950408816337585,
-0.18700969219207764,
-0.07388756424188614,
0.36411383748054504,
-0.6428688764572144,
-0.26957419514656067,
0.18352541327476501,
0.14404010772705078,
0.03855901584029198,
0.17378577589988708,
-0.9668557643890381,
0.55797278881073,
0.21245411038398743,
0.9807389974594116,
-0.34224995970726013,
0.012278378009796143,
-0.19681446254253387,
0.1352962702512741,
-0.4562843441963196,
0.7923060059547424,
-0.6093661189079285,
-0.5563440918922424,
0.0627240538597107,
-0.3155466318130493,
-0.07636594027280807,
-0.2734748423099518,
0.8620634078979492,
-0.7653819918632507,
-0.07894932478666306,
-0.17014488577842712,
-0.18582366406917572,
-0.3567824065685272,
0.14358071982860565,
-1.0554373264312744,
1.1518996953964233,
0.1729329377412796,
-1.0030128955841064,
0.38310298323631287,
-1.2219370603561401,
-0.38880085945129395,
0.12324011325836182,
0.26456642150878906,
-0.9816148281097412,
0.04800320416688919,
0.612133264541626,
0.20430758595466614,
-0.20315325260162354,
0.3216121792793274,
-0.021123237907886505,
-0.5117678642272949,
0.34947603940963745,
-0.676393985748291,
0.9307341575622559,
0.44538095593452454,
-0.15502013266086578,
-0.013586525805294514,
-0.7774366736412048,
0.22575144469738007,
-0.038241129368543625,
-0.5262715220451355,
-0.20447249710559845,
-0.10286153107881546,
0.5476410388946533,
0.0439089760184288,
0.06071161851286888,
-0.7299505472183228,
0.16439034044742584,
-0.524638295173645,
0.5209302306175232,
0.5944163799285889,
0.1490190178155899,
0.039145488291978836,
-0.3218337595462799,
0.7705551981925964,
0.11872357130050659,
0.31330710649490356,
-0.06486307084560394,
-0.33687034249305725,
-0.7947076559066772,
-0.397346556186676,
0.5927770137786865,
0.35963302850723267,
-1.1599254608154297,
0.07059343159198761,
-0.3431517481803894,
-0.5230159163475037,
-0.6399149894714355,
-0.33058491349220276,
0.5902440547943115,
0.3122979700565338,
0.635326087474823,
-0.5283352136611938,
-0.5972513556480408,
-0.8070980906486511,
-0.2655223309993744,
-0.529772162437439,
0.1892032027244568,
-0.275760293006897,
0.48715922236442566,
-0.08737695962190628,
0.9693921208381653,
-0.11395887285470963,
-0.08298054337501526,
-0.30465269088745117,
0.33118996024131775,
-0.01797126978635788,
0.4522501826286316,
0.32133427262306213,
-0.8218931555747986,
-1.100112795829773,
0.18421345949172974,
-0.1433885544538498,
-0.19006678462028503,
0.18975959718227386,
-0.030156105756759644,
0.13937073945999146,
0.17348439991474152,
-0.4605671465396881,
0.8877572417259216,
0.32408973574638367,
-0.2541596293449402,
0.898994505405426,
0.212846577167511,
0.5398842692375183,
-1.340478539466858,
0.08812592923641205,
-0.17913974821567535,
-0.44174501299858093,
-0.9442628622055054,
0.15610195696353912,
0.2758180499076843,
-0.3120952546596527,
-0.48156940937042236,
0.3212246596813202,
-0.23856188356876373,
0.18179261684417725,
-0.28141558170318604,
-0.6525861620903015,
-0.0711558610200882,
0.6844916343688965,
0.24161814153194427,
1.3301458358764648,
0.08965175598859787,
-0.4199979305267334,
0.12028253078460693,
0.6230599880218506,
-0.47495728731155396,
0.06964966654777527,
-0.6989455819129944,
0.1326669454574585,
0.335918128490448,
0.3251454830169678,
-0.991966962814331,
0.04508126899600029,
0.19110150635242462,
-0.4450826048851013,
0.24700285494327545,
-0.0005851578898727894,
-0.6911155581474304,
-0.48487961292266846,
-0.4347928762435913,
0.9387303590774536,
0.6085048913955688,
-0.6213420629501343,
0.5955851674079895,
0.024393999949097633,
-0.05973779037594795,
-0.5357526540756226,
-0.7926135659217834,
-0.05782345309853554,
-0.3277363181114197,
-0.39794212579727173,
0.6163699626922607,
-0.04729356989264488,
0.06433293968439102,
-0.3213876485824585,
-0.09857600182294846,
-0.734413743019104,
0.19614142179489136,
0.12591663002967834,
0.08350736647844315,
-0.27237433195114136,
0.18049879372119904,
0.032243985682725906,
-0.18366624414920807,
-0.09251415729522705,
-0.21858157217502594,
0.5469657182693481,
0.014687132090330124,
-0.5388972759246826,
-1.0151695013046265,
0.25030699372291565,
0.4759025275707245,
-0.6056525111198425,
0.5101664066314697,
0.8183096051216125,
-0.29849275946617126,
-0.07447192817926407,
-0.4014078974723816,
-0.41632363200187683,
-0.5189942121505737,
0.7404100894927979,
-0.5280688405036926,
-0.5394050478935242,
0.5278796553611755,
0.15989327430725098,
0.32025739550590515,
0.3023998439311981,
0.6329406499862671,
0.12393108755350113,
1.3214523792266846,
0.9987624287605286,
-0.12515868246555328,
0.7294701933860779,
0.05169733613729477,
0.34482458233833313,
-0.626272976398468,
0.0736858993768692,
-0.6761481165885925,
0.005060138180851936,
-0.6029390096664429,
-0.21322111785411835,
0.42153775691986084,
-0.136631578207016,
-0.6925368309020996,
0.39340126514434814,
-0.5825161337852478,
0.5484594106674194,
0.3569163978099823,
0.301016628742218,
0.495670884847641,
0.41082707047462463,
-0.20995865762233734,
-0.3407520651817322,
-0.4938511550426483,
-0.704194962978363,
1.4042370319366455,
0.5195794701576233,
0.7749762535095215,
0.28957825899124146,
0.5701680183410645,
0.6957921981811523,
0.33127519488334656,
-0.7163515686988831,
0.20322096347808838,
-0.2975008487701416,
-0.5986074209213257,
-0.2741979956626892,
0.029421884566545486,
-0.67336106300354,
0.05555497109889984,
0.07336173951625824,
-0.6948682069778442,
0.009187771007418633,
0.07324483245611191,
-0.4849429428577423,
0.6143248081207275,
-0.686403751373291,
0.4531523287296295,
0.19974365830421448,
-0.11505606025457382,
-0.047009002417325974,
-0.4451935589313507,
0.5030959844589233,
-0.4964216351509094,
-0.07679601013660431,
0.3511678874492645,
0.10622261464595795,
1.0113093852996826,
-0.704705536365509,
0.7210391163825989,
-0.10311425477266312,
-0.1864151805639267,
0.37562426924705505,
0.1657402217388153,
0.5243781805038452,
-0.08284474164247513,
-0.35443830490112305,
0.18825429677963257,
0.08267563581466675,
-0.2260138988494873,
-0.45783478021621704,
0.08783511072397232,
-1.0873527526855469,
-0.48011261224746704,
-0.399592787027359,
-0.48813650012016296,
-0.1466485559940338,
-0.02744438499212265,
0.19201263785362244,
0.6355199217796326,
-0.12745341658592224,
0.1513138711452484,
0.7518453001976013,
0.032969214022159576,
0.5494836568832397,
0.46710893511772156,
-0.21523436903953552,
-0.4360523819923401,
0.6934188008308411,
-0.08804262429475784,
0.3770025968551636,
0.45903193950653076,
-0.10296973586082458,
-0.4993886947631836,
-0.5837398767471313,
-0.5612849593162537,
0.006810457445681095,
-0.798811674118042,
-0.4134851098060608,
-0.6716390252113342,
-0.7294830679893494,
-0.04917339235544205,
0.010919846594333649,
-0.593592643737793,
-0.49508097767829895,
-0.1921122521162033,
0.10465606302022934,
0.5461816787719727,
0.7195614576339722,
0.3831493854522705,
0.740135133266449,
-0.7123061418533325,
0.20019829273223877,
0.05002577230334282,
0.2507263123989105,
0.2636217772960663,
-0.9364043474197388,
-0.6681170463562012,
0.05526614189147949,
-0.8398765921592712,
-0.8959773182868958,
0.4483594000339508,
0.22491388022899628,
-0.050216253846883774,
0.36197230219841003,
0.19884760677814484,
0.7410314083099365,
-0.6473605036735535,
0.8256546258926392,
0.12505348026752472,
-1.1157574653625488,
0.2505541443824768,
-0.1904900223016739,
0.36093658208847046,
0.5042707324028015,
0.24876312911510468,
-0.6157968044281006,
-0.4381488561630249,
-0.3362395465373993,
-0.33966532349586487,
0.8046897053718567,
0.5858039855957031,
-0.10676708072423935,
0.052077241241931915,
0.2288527935743332,
0.282428503036499,
-0.026007303968071938,
-0.8356090188026428,
-0.06645377725362778,
-0.440629243850708,
-0.6019057035446167,
0.4093504846096039,
-0.4023206830024719,
0.4811772108078003,
-0.35201382637023926,
0.9566190242767334,
0.07821742445230484,
0.39407405257225037,
0.10423633456230164,
-0.3512631952762604,
-0.09173645079135895,
0.2603013217449188,
0.3248552083969116,
0.20227739214897156,
-0.22382758557796478,
0.028172273188829422,
0.3066096007823944,
-1.205544114112854,
0.4009237587451935,
0.042083851993083954,
-0.12940135598182678,
0.19292977452278137,
0.35208970308303833,
0.704818069934845,
0.045938923954963684,
-0.33925652503967285,
0.522667646408081,
-0.17562520503997803,
-0.2772548794746399,
-0.18889574706554413,
-0.10548246651887894,
-0.4703052341938019,
0.22521260380744934,
0.4345068633556366,
-0.023294895887374878,
0.26471298933029175,
-0.08461589366197586,
0.2821463346481323,
0.3386725187301636,
-0.44634220004081726,
-0.5760068297386169,
0.8412994742393494,
0.25518858432769775,
-0.38642603158950806,
0.6640970706939697,
0.1938105821609497,
-1.0754412412643433,
0.5265032052993774,
0.6771515607833862,
1.0553255081176758,
-0.5785033702850342,
0.18045121431350708,
0.28321409225463867,
0.25450584292411804,
0.19859960675239563,
0.2944692373275757,
-0.3396410048007965,
-0.5996131896972656,
-0.449271023273468,
-0.7325947880744934,
-0.3802018165588379,
0.09989158809185028,
-0.5827410221099854,
0.528177797794342,
-0.459589421749115,
-0.34116506576538086,
-0.015277376398444176,
0.525062084197998,
-0.6024056077003479,
0.2669218182563782,
-0.16346555948257446,
0.7372216582298279,
-0.8425154089927673,
1.2426797151565552,
0.6930673122406006,
-0.5037315487861633,
-0.7880945801734924,
0.23290525376796722,
-0.28131526708602905,
-0.8354005813598633,
0.7506409883499146,
0.1774016171693802,
-0.04593357443809509,
0.5611718893051147,
-0.3616780638694763,
-1.0126044750213623,
0.8944573998451233,
0.014097752049565315,
-0.48639923334121704,
-0.050773561000823975,
0.5304669141769409,
0.3821159303188324,
-0.11511854082345963,
0.8169644474983215,
0.5180800557136536,
0.45775359869003296,
-0.17629826068878174,
-1.0859062671661377,
-0.03891853243112564,
-0.28099989891052246,
0.3932993412017822,
0.3103858530521393,
-0.6200141906738281,
0.9907597899436951,
-0.052964579313993454,
-0.5078526735305786,
0.4034542143344879,
0.5408201217651367,
0.10090094804763794,
-0.3050977289676666,
0.34643280506134033,
0.33165109157562256,
0.4834533929824829,
-0.016767432913184166,
0.7597082257270813,
-0.3449246287345886,
0.2732371389865875,
0.6376523971557617,
-0.07340597361326218,
0.658043384552002,
0.3521662950515747,
-0.2836158275604248,
0.6495955586433411,
0.951856255531311,
-0.01905815489590168,
0.8058795928955078,
-0.07363859564065933,
-0.39198148250579834,
-0.34828436374664307,
-0.2485848367214203,
-0.4352593719959259,
0.42747271060943604,
-0.02534995786845684,
-0.4043633043766022,
-0.40572264790534973,
0.24993768334388733,
-0.2702489197254181,
0.3140637278556824,
-0.04392523318529129,
0.7240389585494995,
-0.1638181358575821,
-0.10030584782361984,
0.9873702526092529,
0.4341850280761719,
0.5802007913589478,
-0.4999825358390808,
-0.02274579368531704,
-0.252769410610199,
0.08639802783727646,
0.01567835733294487,
-0.48779571056365967,
0.23484686017036438,
0.3341464400291443,
-0.42764797806739807,
-0.14612723886966705,
0.5983863472938538,
-0.38022857904434204,
-0.5544803142547607,
-0.32890838384628296,
0.30806276202201843,
0.2796497046947479,
-0.06046915054321289,
-0.6537985801696777,
0.16540205478668213,
0.3312681317329407,
-0.28622278571128845,
-0.1892600804567337,
0.4576909840106964,
-0.7047789096832275,
0.6597302556037903,
0.5202420353889465,
-0.11719045788049698,
-0.09914799779653549,
0.2328035682439804,
0.8239099383354187,
-0.7318713068962097,
-0.689494252204895,
-1.015598177909851,
0.5496464967727661,
0.1793588399887085,
-0.2877257764339447,
0.5031805634498596,
0.5493025779724121,
0.4711810052394867,
-0.07759251445531845,
0.8154196739196777,
0.4368163049221039,
0.5920579433441162,
-0.5483701825141907,
1.1164400577545166,
-0.36088910698890686,
0.09638568758964539,
-0.24273720383644104,
-1.0477479696273804,
-0.37477344274520874,
0.5143201351165771,
-0.11735616624355316,
0.2554285228252411,
0.9800927042961121,
0.6035439968109131,
-0.237298384308815,
0.5120353102684021,
0.29707205295562744,
-0.01628906838595867,
0.7010213136672974,
0.6605691313743591,
0.772295355796814,
-0.7572475671768188,
0.5512989163398743,
-0.16338567435741425,
-0.01245365384966135,
-0.20402929186820984,
-0.5553205013275146,
-1.2622770071029663,
-0.8134567141532898,
-0.253557413816452,
-0.010915569961071014,
0.3610399663448334,
1.049637794494629,
0.7856018543243408,
-0.7410915493965149,
-0.07816817611455917,
-0.27590590715408325,
-0.18021893501281738,
-0.15653012692928314,
-0.1524960994720459,
0.7500448822975159,
-0.31994152069091797,
-0.8014117479324341,
-0.056252188980579376,
-0.1585085242986679,
0.4993835687637329,
-0.12737934291362762,
-0.07090666890144348,
-0.01167585700750351,
0.14109431207180023,
0.3385965824127197,
-0.053929008543491364,
-0.8612819910049438,
-0.2464047223329544,
-0.3177240490913391,
-0.21131174266338348,
0.30902165174484253,
0.5868616700172424,
-0.8899549841880798,
0.4362266957759857,
-0.11022084951400757,
0.7768761515617371,
0.5850678086280823,
0.33908697962760925,
0.372929185628891,
-0.710551917552948,
0.2108447253704071,
0.22806833684444427,
-0.1520409882068634,
0.3122105896472931,
-0.244512677192688,
0.33761051297187805,
0.018096590414643288,
-0.4579041302204132,
-0.9207804799079895,
0.18169516324996948,
-0.5479286909103394,
0.09822243452072144,
0.8356184363365173,
-0.043320003896951675,
-0.1819850355386734,
-0.3353898525238037,
-0.28067097067832947,
0.728930652141571,
-0.5740718245506287,
1.0973116159439087,
0.8439934849739075,
0.47724857926368713,
-0.16093586385250092,
-0.5718206763267517,
0.7778055667877197,
0.5079459547996521,
-0.535737156867981,
0.14797882735729218,
-0.08790063858032227,
0.14230069518089294,
-0.15640754997730255,
0.4143434762954712,
-0.09037016332149506,
0.3755752742290497,
-0.1514638364315033,
0.48628345131874084,
-0.264834463596344,
-0.2436242401599884,
-0.14828266203403473,
-0.19080129265785217,
0.16606073081493378,
-0.38330206274986267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03234v1 | Self-Evaluation as a Defense Against Adversarial Attacks on LLMs | 2024-07-03T16:03:42 | 2024-07-03T16:03:42 | Hannah Brown, Leon Lin, Kenji Kawaguchi, Michael Shieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | When LLMs are deployed in sensitive, human-facing settings, it is crucial
that they do not output unsafe, biased, or privacy-violating outputs. For this
reason, models are both trained and instructed to refuse to answer unsafe
prompts such as "Tell me how to build a bomb." We find that, despite these
safeguards, it is possible to break model defenses simply by appending a space
to the end of a model's input. In a study of eight open-source models, we
demonstrate that this acts as a strong enough attack to cause the majority of
models to generate harmful outputs with very high success rates. We examine the
causes of this behavior, finding that the contexts in which single spaces occur
in tokenized training data encourage models to generate lists when prompted,
overriding training signals to refuse to answer unsafe requests. Our findings
underscore the fragile state of current model alignment and promote the
importance of developing more robust alignment methods. Code and data will be
made available at https://github.com/Linlt-leon/Adversarial-Alignments. | [
-0.3383043110370636,
-0.7022056579589844,
0.4474857747554779,
-0.2400185763835907,
0.18485423922538757,
0.055251751095056534,
0.21367280185222626,
-0.20439565181732178,
-0.1950380504131317,
0.38785073161125183,
-0.5807384848594666,
-0.32425376772880554,
-0.6071264743804932,
-0.12784706056118011,
-0.8072537183761597,
1.2343792915344238,
0.021306488662958145,
0.09758547693490982,
-0.31122395396232605,
-0.08625957369804382,
-0.42999014258384705,
-0.7563775777816772,
-0.30040398240089417,
0.15072080492973328,
0.616481363773346,
-0.050116416066884995,
1.0734370946884155,
0.907575249671936,
0.7532391548156738,
0.30328214168548584,
0.08117078244686127,
-0.10832877457141876,
-0.408980131149292,
0.2936868369579315,
-0.2721003592014313,
-0.2984255850315094,
-0.5199184417724609,
0.31216955184936523,
0.5412914752960205,
0.4520804286003113,
0.08935214579105377,
0.2181430459022522,
0.16228175163269043,
0.6142482161521912,
-0.7668939828872681,
-0.558647096157074,
-0.7340763807296753,
0.14994190633296967,
-0.3665332794189453,
0.09734183549880981,
-0.43345174193382263,
-0.3113301992416382,
-0.06486845016479492,
-0.3325890302658081,
0.03831634670495987,
-0.031012674793601036,
0.7681544423103333,
0.4127417504787445,
-0.36241742968559265,
-0.45082196593284607,
-0.4993073046207428,
0.5060165524482727,
-0.6076111793518066,
0.07633949816226959,
0.12757094204425812,
0.34102296829223633,
-0.40253204107284546,
-0.4586831033229828,
-0.2122398167848587,
-0.3096392750740051,
-0.04925918206572533,
0.01057032123208046,
-0.5644395351409912,
0.14631438255310059,
0.26190704107284546,
0.1434159129858017,
-0.7353932857513428,
0.3015156686306,
-0.6574475169181824,
-0.1974293440580368,
0.7054968476295471,
0.1636754870414734,
0.6561761498451233,
-0.1494234949350357,
-0.7670249938964844,
-0.12055762112140656,
-1.0162489414215088,
-0.043950680643320084,
0.968013346195221,
0.2687308192253113,
0.0924592912197113,
0.8823954463005066,
0.18574076890945435,
0.6086017489433289,
0.10664894431829453,
0.47115185856819153,
-0.3301345705986023,
-0.2577574849128723,
-0.27199795842170715,
-0.11202823370695114,
1.0938889980316162,
0.2995868921279907,
0.22614260017871857,
-0.2775503993034363,
-0.28162404894828796,
0.296783447265625,
0.8896192908287048,
-0.6252631545066833,
-0.09232965856790543,
0.36997345089912415,
-0.30130478739738464,
-0.9057268500328064,
0.12377781420946121,
-0.4671541452407837,
-0.691561222076416,
0.21531794965267181,
0.5660035014152527,
-0.22801747918128967,
0.20136785507202148,
-0.011808442883193493,
-0.09986141324043274,
-0.11354628950357437,
0.05018811672925949,
-0.61263108253479,
0.4457884430885315,
0.5916315317153931,
0.6940070986747742,
-0.07596094906330109,
-0.4389679431915283,
-0.5387357473373413,
-0.09378104656934738,
-0.6039698719978333,
0.4849788546562195,
0.04466496780514717,
-0.5602555274963379,
-0.2529986798763275,
-0.21667495369911194,
0.07352299243211746,
-0.5546155571937561,
0.39182978868484497,
-0.5344920754432678,
0.3522743582725525,
-0.1943010538816452,
-0.5047009587287903,
0.04871870204806328,
0.2740800976753235,
-0.4951237440109253,
0.7699530124664307,
-0.08228490501642227,
-0.8328378200531006,
0.14306819438934326,
-0.651665449142456,
-0.272073358297348,
-0.2947351038455963,
-0.3197302520275116,
-0.5366939902305603,
0.15831269323825836,
0.20124416053295135,
0.4984906017780304,
0.04099230095744133,
0.18662714958190918,
-0.90268874168396,
-0.13331694900989532,
0.7679858803749084,
-0.5799858570098877,
0.8432711362838745,
0.5809465050697327,
-0.39309147000312805,
0.48434582352638245,
-0.6490411758422852,
0.07713774591684341,
0.4402388036251068,
-0.1627500057220459,
-0.3459025025367737,
-0.05782545730471611,
-0.5567808151245117,
0.274921715259552,
0.34169167280197144,
-0.29841047525405884,
0.34701189398765564,
-0.5362489223480225,
0.24453766644001007,
1.1257084608078003,
-0.01928708516061306,
0.4950096905231476,
-0.43785661458969116,
0.6604968905448914,
-0.12502427399158478,
0.3629268705844879,
-0.05192803218960762,
-0.25327226519584656,
-0.44785916805267334,
-0.02699640393257141,
0.26189297437667847,
0.33415764570236206,
-0.25905877351760864,
0.3329750597476959,
0.03585219010710716,
-0.5431293249130249,
-0.6164511442184448,
0.46311312913894653,
0.5818396806716919,
0.3746095895767212,
0.11095454543828964,
-0.21385252475738525,
-0.5870206952095032,
-0.9455071091651917,
-0.46207424998283386,
-0.20742365717887878,
0.13166485726833344,
0.10201779007911682,
0.5968625545501709,
-0.08448696881532669,
0.6497341394424438,
-0.29590293765068054,
-0.0006051219534128904,
0.19028925895690918,
-0.22126467525959015,
-0.09143584221601486,
0.4987647831439972,
0.652806282043457,
-0.5314867496490479,
-0.12175925076007843,
-0.40100762248039246,
-1.061008334159851,
0.05261938273906708,
-0.15072718262672424,
-0.3918949365615845,
-0.3256363868713379,
0.3318021893501282,
-0.4641033709049225,
0.4715377390384674,
0.43590566515922546,
-0.48370492458343506,
0.5193031430244446,
-0.017295733094215393,
-0.10122621059417725,
-1.0031332969665527,
-0.06879545003175735,
-0.15935882925987244,
-0.16742712259292603,
-0.6549587249755859,
0.44285452365875244,
0.04824412241578102,
-0.2816821038722992,
-0.5899389982223511,
0.5474878549575806,
-0.37541669607162476,
-0.18626531958580017,
-0.30184879899024963,
0.14085489511489868,
0.13891805708408356,
0.09698554873466492,
-0.45994386076927185,
0.922356128692627,
0.4374319612979889,
-0.5437608957290649,
0.15282894670963287,
0.2533451020717621,
-0.22638121247291565,
0.4378684163093567,
-0.700924813747406,
0.3949926793575287,
0.15857882797718048,
0.018061138689517975,
-1.0132992267608643,
-0.2164067178964615,
0.448253870010376,
-0.6074299812316895,
0.37617966532707214,
-0.11880607157945633,
-0.13627159595489502,
-0.38935545086860657,
-0.5994254350662231,
0.3521822392940521,
0.2210487276315689,
-0.7553790211677551,
0.17431814968585968,
0.4569604694843292,
0.2889522314071655,
-0.993855357170105,
-0.7125135660171509,
0.1085009053349495,
-0.5566272735595703,
-0.8025220036506653,
0.038534168154001236,
-0.29879510402679443,
-0.41706448793411255,
-0.016399020329117775,
-0.08804841339588165,
0.13947135210037231,
0.8642716407775879,
0.48140305280685425,
0.40044617652893066,
-0.02915998362004757,
-0.1371987760066986,
-0.42532843351364136,
0.05972806364297867,
0.4048507511615753,
-0.21988633275032043,
0.23561711609363556,
-0.13182108104228973,
-0.8331200480461121,
-0.23596759140491486,
0.3063295781612396,
0.6055914163589478,
-0.04265758767724037,
0.6430462002754211,
0.3289370536804199,
-0.45714420080184937,
-0.14314639568328857,
-0.26662424206733704,
-0.10061699151992798,
-0.5260229706764221,
0.40312400460243225,
-0.20572884380817413,
-0.7567634582519531,
0.35432398319244385,
0.18117165565490723,
0.22538240253925323,
0.5538608431816101,
0.6247259974479675,
-0.3556986451148987,
1.2153462171554565,
0.3508155345916748,
-0.151360884308815,
0.1818232536315918,
-0.2172831892967224,
0.17139950394630432,
-0.9139891862869263,
-0.026431063190102577,
-0.37855929136276245,
-0.32642146944999695,
-0.37751466035842896,
-0.30786946415901184,
0.3407275676727295,
0.15731169283390045,
-0.3955047130584717,
0.4028717577457428,
-0.8258040547370911,
0.29540005326271057,
0.4600899815559387,
0.008384143002331257,
-0.1307862401008606,
-0.18814584612846375,
-0.03384922444820404,
-0.08569321781396866,
-0.6952826976776123,
-0.6639784574508667,
1.3278924226760864,
0.7561710476875305,
1.2206591367721558,
0.34108394384384155,
0.8780041933059692,
0.5261346697807312,
0.3972269296646118,
-0.6796342134475708,
0.41378816962242126,
0.009862679988145828,
-0.9206628799438477,
-0.20749197900295258,
-0.29151371121406555,
-1.0210387706756592,
0.1963389366865158,
-0.001313814427703619,
-0.6425347328186035,
0.1368338167667389,
0.21294739842414856,
-0.6101050972938538,
0.37220752239227295,
-0.6564972996711731,
0.8683053851127625,
-0.833828330039978,
-0.35589784383773804,
0.20647384226322174,
-0.44027790427207947,
0.6257938742637634,
-0.11986945569515228,
0.32705000042915344,
-0.08829012513160706,
0.07838722318410873,
0.8114891052246094,
-0.5980384945869446,
1.1044727563858032,
-0.17284494638442993,
-0.213182732462883,
0.4987788796424866,
0.5143771171569824,
0.531834602355957,
-0.20851965248584747,
0.10441499203443527,
0.008490216918289661,
-0.1336483508348465,
-0.19056710600852966,
-0.6587146520614624,
0.6714490652084351,
-0.9691570401191711,
-0.9194848537445068,
-0.4290524423122406,
-0.46456193923950195,
0.13706767559051514,
0.14712072908878326,
0.4562072455883026,
0.16009867191314697,
-0.4104808270931244,
0.13626731932163239,
0.4914551377296448,
-0.1522454172372818,
0.17941869795322418,
0.26217254996299744,
-0.20208273828029633,
-0.5136197209358215,
0.7629414200782776,
0.2695283889770508,
0.5329508781433105,
-0.19893211126327515,
0.08488388359546661,
-0.3287293016910553,
-0.5825135111808777,
-0.4951149523258209,
-0.14129182696342468,
-0.8725032210350037,
-0.4165797233581543,
-0.5209693312644958,
-0.3857828974723816,
-0.5726361870765686,
-0.264168918132782,
-0.529508650302887,
-0.5177028179168701,
-0.2592337727546692,
-0.2965013086795807,
-0.15021079778671265,
1.1515134572982788,
-0.03523207828402519,
0.24093158543109894,
-0.5514898300170898,
-0.047547146677970886,
0.28636088967323303,
0.05040237680077553,
-0.11510604619979858,
-0.6138836145401001,
-0.2243141382932663,
-0.113364577293396,
-0.6530218124389648,
-1.0179202556610107,
0.25092244148254395,
-0.19979509711265564,
0.5960788726806641,
0.42424649000167847,
0.11404263973236084,
0.5191941261291504,
-0.39422833919525146,
0.7005198001861572,
0.18470099568367004,
-0.8095760345458984,
0.7074781656265259,
-0.40892118215560913,
0.048310209065675735,
0.2584584951400757,
0.35645240545272827,
-0.09367584437131882,
-0.39867839217185974,
-0.7839656472206116,
-0.5963060259819031,
0.4273070991039276,
0.2669826149940491,
0.19915872812271118,
-0.07280943542718887,
0.3866235911846161,
-0.17388205230236053,
0.10010753571987152,
-1.012772798538208,
-0.2848791182041168,
-0.2770559787750244,
-0.1553322970867157,
0.3211463391780853,
-0.49154233932495117,
-0.6752575039863586,
0.33082661032676697,
0.7255859971046448,
-0.12032168358564377,
0.1644744575023651,
0.19500432908535004,
-0.07590591162443161,
-0.21971286833286285,
0.45956748723983765,
0.4858320355415344,
0.25265610218048096,
-0.0396387092769146,
0.23975121974945068,
0.19985446333885193,
0.032714344561100006,
0.5886670351028442,
-0.05983817204833031,
-0.14772666990756989,
-0.5496151447296143,
0.2875942587852478,
0.4456433355808258,
0.154249906539917,
-0.3235381543636322,
0.7666665315628052,
-0.1642269790172577,
-0.18105588853359222,
-0.26362714171409607,
0.3241763412952423,
-0.15907974541187286,
0.20354941487312317,
-0.027693727985024452,
0.25743427872657776,
0.2733561396598816,
-0.4269191026687622,
0.2837306559085846,
0.9406840205192566,
-0.44446516036987305,
-0.36870285868644714,
0.9364376068115234,
-0.09683609753847122,
-0.24491563439369202,
0.33889836072921753,
-0.04500410333275795,
-0.5557948350906372,
0.5898111462593079,
0.5326132774353027,
0.9994469285011292,
-0.2669554054737091,
-0.024329306557774544,
0.20831866562366486,
0.6274783611297607,
0.15424342453479767,
0.07939402759075165,
0.023008674383163452,
-0.7688015699386597,
0.09570538997650146,
-0.38873299956321716,
-0.3940434157848358,
0.19140155613422394,
-0.7019234895706177,
0.15270568430423737,
-0.9674643278121948,
-0.3481091558933258,
-0.24197688698768616,
-0.31654050946235657,
-0.5044562816619873,
0.20258712768554688,
0.4631178379058838,
0.7059165239334106,
-0.67844158411026,
0.4465952217578888,
0.49467429518699646,
-0.32756325602531433,
-0.6339124441146851,
-0.19493602216243744,
0.4752027988433838,
-0.800875186920166,
0.5525898337364197,
0.13466446101665497,
-0.10477814078330994,
-0.5371242761611938,
-0.6504673957824707,
-1.1135228872299194,
0.7752665281295776,
0.5000221133232117,
-0.38886746764183044,
-0.2438320815563202,
-0.07253126800060272,
0.3588085472583771,
-0.3651371896266937,
0.04520151764154434,
0.16449660062789917,
0.3150365650653839,
-0.3917236328125,
-0.4629044532775879,
0.29450443387031555,
-0.33698251843452454,
-0.0984656885266304,
0.11048377305269241,
-0.7711559534072876,
0.8170406222343445,
-0.351155549287796,
-0.324181467294693,
0.3399282991886139,
0.6905205249786377,
0.2837957739830017,
0.08354146033525467,
0.4479140639305115,
0.5777598023414612,
0.7638909816741943,
0.0001223296858370304,
1.205042839050293,
-0.37593555450439453,
0.04564865306019783,
1.3191946744918823,
-0.18370090425014496,
0.617699921131134,
0.1737721711397171,
-0.15943890810012817,
0.27008095383644104,
0.6048563718795776,
-0.4692089557647705,
0.4138381779193878,
0.31425878405570984,
0.05413171648979187,
0.018835054710507393,
0.19862695038318634,
-0.32913267612457275,
0.5440335869789124,
0.2744807302951813,
-0.517951488494873,
-0.22110383212566376,
-0.22561629116535187,
0.09421780705451965,
0.10233627259731293,
0.09851724654436111,
0.6640382409095764,
0.0767204761505127,
-0.6000666618347168,
0.48458707332611084,
-0.11080630868673325,
0.5203140377998352,
-0.6975885033607483,
0.24401696026325226,
0.1871313899755478,
0.22303570806980133,
-0.4226229190826416,
-0.6712549328804016,
0.3318808674812317,
0.2525556683540344,
-0.06954729557037354,
-0.10484953969717026,
0.8986225128173828,
0.11406749486923218,
-0.30111825466156006,
0.5133574604988098,
0.5488011240959167,
0.08135517686605453,
0.13638056814670563,
-1.028353214263916,
-0.09034905582666397,
0.054985929280519485,
-0.5656396746635437,
0.6889063119888306,
0.09324714541435242,
-0.007964334450662136,
0.7070473432540894,
0.8116782903671265,
0.0021174107678234577,
0.1904294341802597,
0.023251879960298538,
0.8386428356170654,
-0.5114706158638,
-0.25946205854415894,
-1.2352256774902344,
0.599987804889679,
0.015979865565896034,
-0.18928281962871552,
1.0653096437454224,
0.5788787007331848,
0.903784453868866,
0.2717173993587494,
1.021340012550354,
0.2032880187034607,
0.27097615599632263,
-0.3896006643772125,
0.8220260143280029,
-0.5543786883354187,
0.558495044708252,
-0.160924032330513,
-0.4661223590373993,
-0.13149869441986084,
0.4006076157093048,
-0.3431503176689148,
0.15529955923557281,
0.32986682653427124,
0.773999035358429,
0.030503371730446815,
-0.3458445072174072,
0.5223209857940674,
0.2743023633956909,
0.6240573525428772,
0.24180375039577484,
1.3161715269088745,
-0.5441057085990906,
0.7013434767723083,
-0.42913392186164856,
-0.09975837171077728,
0.13600584864616394,
-0.7909428477287292,
-0.9338352680206299,
-0.33202221989631653,
-0.2536782920360565,
-0.8521959185600281,
0.13017861545085907,
0.7332857847213745,
0.6859304904937744,
-0.6993821859359741,
-0.22649811208248138,
0.15286192297935486,
0.1130564957857132,
0.20019865036010742,
-0.19859857857227325,
0.23259808123111725,
-0.4280283749103546,
-0.33051764965057373,
0.9201825261116028,
0.2659853994846344,
0.40899139642715454,
-0.7533189654350281,
-0.032159171998500824,
-0.08210448920726776,
0.2412749081850052,
-0.15400442481040955,
0.3384084105491638,
-0.823970377445221,
-0.29648223519325256,
0.021056702360510826,
-0.4401756823062897,
0.08571906387805939,
0.4673215448856354,
-0.5073327422142029,
0.6090219616889954,
0.13923461735248566,
0.8172293901443481,
-0.2897023558616638,
0.08645607531070709,
0.8729754090309143,
-0.7752622961997986,
-0.24955755472183228,
0.059821728616952896,
0.6861122250556946,
0.5017048120498657,
-1.025801420211792,
0.6808288097381592,
-0.013624404557049274,
-0.7253662347793579,
-1.0238839387893677,
0.18821869790554047,
-0.3242053687572479,
-0.37981465458869934,
0.7647346258163452,
-0.32143378257751465,
-0.48251038789749146,
0.3379233181476593,
-0.15506033599376678,
0.24270379543304443,
-0.10245180130004883,
0.9859699606895447,
0.827777087688446,
-0.1053193211555481,
0.5090884566307068,
-0.4198426306247711,
0.4530980885028839,
0.5554690361022949,
-0.6891596913337708,
0.09987242519855499,
0.3380934000015259,
0.4433378279209137,
0.21057821810245514,
0.3918020725250244,
-0.24289238452911377,
0.46409347653388977,
0.02617369219660759,
-0.004576738458126783,
-0.21309229731559753,
-0.39123156666755676,
-0.7806206345558167,
0.35302168130874634,
0.307431697845459,
-0.31363409757614136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03232v1 | Single Character Perturbations Break LLM Alignment | 2024-07-03T16:03:10 | 2024-07-03T16:03:10 | Leon Lin, Hannah Brown, Kenji Kawaguchi, Michael Shieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | When LLMs are deployed in sensitive, human-facing settings, it is crucial
that they do not output unsafe, biased, or privacy-violating outputs. For this
reason, models are both trained and instructed to refuse to answer unsafe
prompts such as "Tell me how to build a bomb." We find that, despite these
safeguards, it is possible to break model defenses simply by appending a space
to the end of a model's input. In a study of eight open-source models, we
demonstrate that this acts as a strong enough attack to cause the majority of
models to generate harmful outputs with very high success rates. We examine the
causes of this behavior, finding that the contexts in which single spaces occur
in tokenized training data encourage models to generate lists when prompted,
overriding training signals to refuse to answer unsafe requests. Our findings
underscore the fragile state of current model alignment and promote the
importance of developing more robust alignment methods. Code and data will be
available at https://github.com/hannah-aught/space_attack. | [
-0.2229541391134262,
-0.805617094039917,
0.5288962721824646,
-0.1808474361896515,
-0.050249166786670685,
0.09790168702602386,
0.24740023910999298,
-0.22462868690490723,
-0.0736900344491005,
0.8394988179206848,
-0.7517545819282532,
-0.5765874981880188,
-0.5452743768692017,
-0.04041299223899841,
-0.6000978946685791,
1.0689952373504639,
0.012862902134656906,
0.07987362891435623,
-0.3466866612434387,
-0.12644076347351074,
-0.6415551900863647,
-0.9650160670280457,
-0.2851375937461853,
0.3424411118030548,
0.8324463963508606,
0.38874146342277527,
1.1894117593765259,
0.8702808618545532,
0.9167261719703674,
0.23833821713924408,
-0.11321964859962463,
0.006929382216185331,
-0.5373193621635437,
0.38590794801712036,
0.17519879341125488,
-0.4181665778160095,
-0.5306658148765564,
0.01936817355453968,
0.8341017961502075,
0.7344750761985779,
0.12509068846702576,
0.053180623799562454,
0.02363445796072483,
0.4765874147415161,
-0.5086604952812195,
-0.5308268070220947,
-0.6777037978172302,
0.033183515071868896,
-0.5322849750518799,
0.04933079332113266,
-0.5311509370803833,
-0.20640316605567932,
-0.3741280734539032,
-0.6601517200469971,
0.04951510205864906,
0.06843654066324234,
0.9261699318885803,
0.5526736974716187,
-0.34095948934555054,
-0.2733883261680603,
-0.5925891995429993,
0.6225694417953491,
-0.8113587498664856,
0.14951999485492706,
0.18158398568630219,
0.10354897379875183,
-0.5664965510368347,
-0.474871426820755,
-0.4667949974536896,
-0.18231798708438873,
-0.04578632861375809,
-0.2089347541332245,
-0.26777422428131104,
0.3244556784629822,
0.6197585463523865,
-0.033957209438085556,
-0.5006235837936401,
0.5046584606170654,
-0.6136417388916016,
-0.11094281077384949,
0.6101406216621399,
0.267061322927475,
0.7606104016304016,
-0.1270686537027359,
-0.7300659418106079,
-0.216205433011055,
-1.2257421016693115,
0.039559412747621536,
1.1571406126022339,
0.5752083659172058,
-0.051167748868465424,
1.0343600511550903,
0.4939418435096741,
0.49921196699142456,
0.09165559709072113,
0.41869014501571655,
-0.43826568126678467,
-0.39555421471595764,
-0.03779037296772003,
0.05425505340099335,
1.039809226989746,
0.21712306141853333,
0.10355428606271744,
-0.06413213163614273,
-0.023234348744153976,
0.19662374258041382,
0.6366097331047058,
-0.6157518625259399,
0.03176186978816986,
0.39170023798942566,
-0.025822307914495468,
-0.5780330896377563,
0.3102790415287018,
-0.511711835861206,
-0.8523518443107605,
0.18255053460597992,
0.16625484824180603,
-0.43085339665412903,
0.1490512490272522,
0.25433358550071716,
-0.09710150957107544,
-0.017518650740385056,
0.08130235224962234,
-0.742523729801178,
0.3432391583919525,
0.6358327269554138,
0.6170699596405029,
0.053842224180698395,
-0.3452785313129425,
-0.45810770988464355,
-0.10208389908075333,
-0.449063241481781,
0.7208719849586487,
-0.217888742685318,
-0.7250962257385254,
-0.20272746682167053,
-0.3342476487159729,
0.1148739904165268,
-0.4904760718345642,
0.4813034236431122,
-0.42157524824142456,
0.16820742189884186,
-0.4540160894393921,
-0.48792341351509094,
0.11600968986749649,
0.006092721596360207,
-0.6944087743759155,
0.5407166481018066,
-0.23499523103237152,
-0.9234461188316345,
0.32518619298934937,
-0.5181944966316223,
-0.26220014691352844,
-0.2337506264448166,
-0.3839249610900879,
-0.5160655975341797,
0.23471926152706146,
0.17174625396728516,
0.3145059049129486,
0.18058212101459503,
-0.08782418072223663,
-0.8207652568817139,
-0.35852673649787903,
0.754060685634613,
-0.39285218715667725,
0.8524672985076904,
0.21678951382637024,
0.10819994658231735,
0.517469048500061,
-0.76004558801651,
-0.017475107684731483,
0.36958372592926025,
-0.3193967938423157,
-0.3102826178073883,
0.1541319489479065,
-0.24045413732528687,
0.17852263152599335,
0.09969399124383926,
-0.5180762410163879,
0.6107094883918762,
-0.4037395715713501,
0.29639768600463867,
0.8911066055297852,
0.23074232041835785,
0.4893121123313904,
-0.438603937625885,
0.6453977227210999,
-0.0743277445435524,
0.06536431610584259,
-0.37812021374702454,
-0.36036255955696106,
-0.2995598316192627,
-0.3884642422199249,
0.15455825626850128,
0.31529664993286133,
-0.2449958622455597,
0.2135166972875595,
-0.03618554770946503,
-0.3650255799293518,
-0.7104092836380005,
0.180419921875,
0.45057833194732666,
0.436439573764801,
0.1901210993528366,
-0.17969495058059692,
-0.6913117170333862,
-0.659691572189331,
-0.6155216693878174,
-0.3062003254890442,
0.07218056917190552,
-0.030163712799549103,
0.33121973276138306,
-0.12413474917411804,
0.7820700407028198,
-0.2508818507194519,
-0.09928399324417114,
0.12987957894802094,
-0.17429675161838531,
0.18128755688667297,
0.6390522718429565,
0.4057503342628479,
-0.6203498244285583,
-0.1710629016160965,
-0.4419777989387512,
-0.820845365524292,
0.04515448957681656,
-0.2751682996749878,
-0.2007099688053131,
-0.018166013062000275,
0.41456881165504456,
-0.616814911365509,
0.5833991169929504,
0.3757224380970001,
-0.7870872020721436,
0.7145323157310486,
0.04101366549730301,
-0.04261265695095062,
-1.0565667152404785,
-0.0861675813794136,
-0.12190230190753937,
-0.12842021882534027,
-0.7242299914360046,
0.4396721422672272,
-0.03861220180988312,
-0.30725497007369995,
-0.7362797260284424,
0.46135613322257996,
-0.31094905734062195,
-0.09385921061038971,
-0.10920155793428421,
-0.03078576736152172,
-0.05662386491894722,
0.22705425322055817,
-0.35465267300605774,
0.6819333434104919,
0.2897217571735382,
-0.4214627742767334,
-0.016959307715296745,
0.6809574365615845,
-0.10553833097219467,
0.30010855197906494,
-0.6426390409469604,
0.5564789175987244,
0.011297570541501045,
0.13469113409519196,
-1.3244142532348633,
-0.43766170740127563,
0.28719910979270935,
-0.6483042240142822,
0.5885922908782959,
-0.2136610895395279,
-0.5175423622131348,
-0.22242625057697296,
-0.48901861906051636,
0.39557939767837524,
0.22408466041088104,
-0.5492239594459534,
0.09082658588886261,
0.37047868967056274,
0.2149067223072052,
-0.9078693389892578,
-0.8649936318397522,
0.04675326123833656,
-0.44056200981140137,
-0.8987070918083191,
0.04211282357573509,
-0.3334067761898041,
-0.38019001483917236,
-0.06534014642238617,
-0.394859254360199,
0.09156041592359543,
0.6612066030502319,
0.5897398591041565,
0.5143575668334961,
-0.08024012297391891,
-0.35042518377304077,
-0.13227014243602753,
0.0782947763800621,
0.1434498280286789,
-0.06531374901533127,
0.3919389545917511,
0.11672095209360123,
-0.899720311164856,
-0.5967667102813721,
0.36219656467437744,
0.9577953219413757,
-0.006509896367788315,
0.8194310069084167,
0.1368972510099411,
-0.4390389919281006,
-0.023617492988705635,
-0.20476512610912323,
-0.23086953163146973,
-0.5346722602844238,
0.5521894693374634,
-0.24734538793563843,
-0.9994996786117554,
0.5213703513145447,
0.2637328505516052,
0.4005560576915741,
0.3551535904407501,
0.2836351990699768,
-0.4584992527961731,
1.3030235767364502,
0.5133084654808044,
0.026037704199552536,
0.2960006892681122,
0.08774422109127045,
0.22626379132270813,
-0.7514925599098206,
-0.0791369155049324,
-0.6401310563087463,
-0.40318384766578674,
-0.5162465572357178,
-0.42551764845848083,
0.395608514547348,
0.3220295310020447,
-0.4865053594112396,
0.42055660486221313,
-0.6477259993553162,
0.45536285638809204,
0.1988174021244049,
-0.06463627517223358,
0.09737872332334518,
0.141757071018219,
-0.203593447804451,
-0.17925521731376648,
-0.7493972182273865,
-0.7566284537315369,
1.1711910963058472,
0.7148285508155823,
1.2521262168884277,
0.27674028277397156,
0.8403370380401611,
0.2390543520450592,
0.07512082904577255,
-0.6166963577270508,
0.501071572303772,
-0.13132134079933167,
-0.7941744327545166,
-0.2794850468635559,
-0.3260263204574585,
-0.856103241443634,
0.06892312318086624,
-0.1877821832895279,
-0.850496768951416,
0.18906719982624054,
0.19117552042007446,
-0.697864294052124,
0.5576823353767395,
-0.5906067490577698,
0.8032113313674927,
-0.5260519981384277,
-0.4223755896091461,
0.23331144452095032,
-0.5400533080101013,
0.5556064248085022,
-0.09851694852113724,
0.31601420044898987,
-0.11776912212371826,
-0.07678168267011642,
0.6523191928863525,
-0.521462619304657,
1.1767679452896118,
-0.13254915177822113,
-0.28661349415779114,
0.2708979845046997,
0.39405086636543274,
0.503683865070343,
-0.05894545465707779,
0.010405546054244041,
0.21511249244213104,
-0.09765661507844925,
-0.4599882960319519,
-0.41355904936790466,
0.5700172781944275,
-0.9213435053825378,
-0.7722792625427246,
-0.2472071647644043,
-0.6446746587753296,
-0.07901260256767273,
0.1442549079656601,
0.65537029504776,
0.1108064204454422,
-0.2509916424751282,
0.14075502753257751,
0.7068758010864258,
-0.3919183313846588,
0.18647003173828125,
0.2622174620628357,
-0.33654487133026123,
-0.3716638386249542,
0.5319291353225708,
0.24790093302726746,
0.4714781939983368,
0.03927057608962059,
-0.2032339870929718,
-0.1516162008047104,
-0.5043774843215942,
-0.2597085237503052,
0.18603502213954926,
-0.7659410238265991,
-0.24172133207321167,
-0.471194326877594,
-0.25616690516471863,
-0.5539928078651428,
-0.29851865768432617,
-0.504108726978302,
-0.6557042598724365,
-0.40261465311050415,
-0.2585276961326599,
-0.22494037449359894,
1.0172244310379028,
0.2640323340892792,
0.3874777853488922,
-0.9109436273574829,
-0.11925869435071945,
-0.07208272069692612,
0.18106813728809357,
-0.3759293258190155,
-0.6716014742851257,
-0.14244073629379272,
-0.1476672738790512,
-0.536176323890686,
-1.1446285247802734,
0.13608340919017792,
-0.29060059785842896,
0.34885716438293457,
0.42550572752952576,
0.0153156453743577,
0.6281785368919373,
-0.5628852844238281,
0.8047821521759033,
0.295667827129364,
-0.8172656297683716,
0.418362021446228,
-0.5667963624000549,
0.3832474946975708,
0.3107651174068451,
0.3170537054538727,
-0.4132184088230133,
-0.5607978701591492,
-0.5838829278945923,
-0.7932019233703613,
0.6819703578948975,
0.03410919010639191,
0.3074798882007599,
0.050850190222263336,
0.6204509735107422,
0.09016217291355133,
0.0944775640964508,
-0.7730035781860352,
-0.30474695563316345,
-0.014069486409425735,
-0.232255220413208,
0.3744446635246277,
-0.5833690762519836,
-0.24772366881370544,
0.22366879880428314,
0.6192640066146851,
-0.04899700731039047,
0.3087768256664276,
0.12392456084489822,
-0.02373863011598587,
-0.47008126974105835,
0.30578652024269104,
0.7148287296295166,
0.2072944939136505,
-0.014280329458415508,
0.13462689518928528,
-0.032802797853946686,
-0.22315819561481476,
0.34250450134277344,
-0.0001823215716285631,
-0.1130569577217102,
-0.34971559047698975,
0.41435033082962036,
0.7291049957275391,
0.350750595331192,
-0.4912460148334503,
0.37853217124938965,
-0.2114633023738861,
-0.20591942965984344,
-0.13100886344909668,
0.25428444147109985,
-0.12719246745109558,
0.10369817912578583,
0.09254783391952515,
0.28152021765708923,
-0.3246440887451172,
-0.33525052666664124,
0.22600078582763672,
0.7828378677368164,
-0.4661960303783417,
-0.6036286950111389,
0.936848521232605,
-0.1721639484167099,
-0.340882271528244,
0.6091168522834778,
0.24724803864955902,
-0.45417165756225586,
0.6278870701789856,
0.5974380970001221,
0.6988373398780823,
-0.35438844561576843,
-0.10697653889656067,
0.37624701857566833,
0.7151206135749817,
0.03776096552610397,
0.243625670671463,
0.22506654262542725,
-0.9289644360542297,
-0.1805693656206131,
-0.41698119044303894,
-0.5195239782333374,
0.18525446951389313,
-0.5078361630439758,
0.4645334482192993,
-1.0909374952316284,
-0.28397977352142334,
-0.2561408281326294,
-0.2733888328075409,
-0.44049081206321716,
-0.13893187046051025,
0.6959031820297241,
0.708703875541687,
-0.6245693564414978,
0.5160221457481384,
0.9085019826889038,
-0.5790785551071167,
-0.7807264924049377,
-0.03566867485642433,
0.5220796465873718,
-0.5473635196685791,
0.3113616108894348,
0.11126600950956345,
0.13204419612884521,
-0.33989661931991577,
-0.9564791321754456,
-1.2199219465255737,
0.6477457880973816,
0.6957033276557922,
-0.6411511898040771,
-0.39632242918014526,
0.25583529472351074,
0.2714005410671234,
-0.16168613731861115,
-0.19160978496074677,
0.1628945767879486,
0.5035936236381531,
-0.3161444365978241,
-0.5084519386291504,
0.27875998616218567,
-0.09574659913778305,
-0.2806899845600128,
0.28632885217666626,
-0.6906260251998901,
0.9063378572463989,
-0.4434100389480591,
-0.547021746635437,
0.4541180431842804,
0.7045640349388123,
0.568455159664154,
0.040715523064136505,
0.25452354550361633,
0.6623744964599609,
0.9085260629653931,
-0.058166440576314926,
1.1831285953521729,
-0.1469249129295349,
0.09059306234121323,
1.2751553058624268,
-0.47681334614753723,
0.6833590269088745,
0.5468548536300659,
-0.15112698078155518,
0.3780286908149719,
0.4703504741191864,
-0.26219961047172546,
0.17185208201408386,
0.2470485419034958,
0.053391117602586746,
-0.02099556103348732,
0.23221470415592194,
-0.08321408182382584,
0.430156946182251,
0.3453090786933899,
-0.15451239049434662,
-0.07708404958248138,
-0.07655061036348343,
0.28916677832603455,
0.1790384203195572,
0.06896816939115524,
0.5507712960243225,
0.10370048880577087,
-0.50260990858078,
0.4529309570789337,
-0.07839201390743256,
0.5815263986587524,
-0.8248224258422852,
0.11309526860713959,
-0.032207366079092026,
0.14174148440361023,
-0.5248099565505981,
-0.5540399551391602,
0.280814528465271,
0.33445170521736145,
-0.23601171374320984,
-0.189986452460289,
0.8902937173843384,
-0.13953278958797455,
-0.2495187669992447,
0.20413511991500854,
0.34983912110328674,
0.014185922220349312,
0.038451243191957474,
-0.549233078956604,
0.21078012883663177,
0.10939048230648041,
-0.45571115612983704,
0.663517415523529,
0.046160988509655,
-0.008137938566505909,
0.3683440089225769,
0.8345026969909668,
-0.0228349007666111,
0.3684861361980438,
-0.2510415017604828,
0.7928513884544373,
-0.5718206167221069,
-0.22366300225257874,
-1.0953800678253174,
0.8652509450912476,
0.12793271243572235,
-0.1687031090259552,
1.0732619762420654,
0.4820244610309601,
0.9375343322753906,
0.27142927050590515,
0.8768180012702942,
0.22519689798355103,
0.22093673050403595,
-0.47440147399902344,
0.9344188570976257,
-0.4521137475967407,
0.8032993078231812,
-0.14193812012672424,
-0.7541684508323669,
-0.4771389365196228,
0.1562017798423767,
-0.14421550929546356,
-0.07801727205514908,
0.6274853944778442,
0.7174763679504395,
0.0819784551858902,
-0.1959354281425476,
0.584851861000061,
0.3600218892097473,
0.6370282769203186,
0.21434785425662994,
1.2232633829116821,
-0.4321506917476654,
0.476782888174057,
-0.0804765596985817,
0.0968373715877533,
0.16750960052013397,
-0.8031429052352905,
-0.7965327501296997,
-0.3495977818965912,
-0.3514598309993744,
-0.7547352313995361,
-0.008954550139605999,
0.8366473913192749,
0.5976855158805847,
-0.677139937877655,
-0.19190698862075806,
0.02969512715935707,
0.166448175907135,
0.14501646161079407,
-0.18234996497631073,
0.2044989913702011,
-0.4693220853805542,
-0.4056784212589264,
0.9483614563941956,
0.21360896527767181,
0.20540399849414825,
-0.3396289348602295,
0.03910702094435692,
-0.18463794887065887,
0.3758368492126465,
-0.2624627351760864,
0.5072352886199951,
-0.7550551891326904,
-0.2598634958267212,
0.08013676106929779,
-0.3729074001312256,
0.16280747950077057,
0.7581776976585388,
-0.4815399646759033,
0.3969382047653198,
0.15395338833332062,
0.785891592502594,
-0.1470194160938263,
0.06615739315748215,
0.6227013468742371,
-1.114923357963562,
0.0014768998371437192,
0.2021591067314148,
0.5794616937637329,
0.45084109902381897,
-1.0091545581817627,
0.37187597155570984,
0.190227672457695,
-0.6366510987281799,
-1.2008377313613892,
0.2508414685726166,
-0.5211499333381653,
-0.49820178747177124,
1.0250253677368164,
-0.1650969535112381,
-0.47973161935806274,
0.3714728355407715,
-0.2789103090763092,
0.3427608609199524,
-0.28087103366851807,
0.6371186971664429,
0.9137750864028931,
-0.12844090163707733,
0.4453376531600952,
-0.3201228678226471,
0.3660149872303009,
0.6673535108566284,
-0.5842632055282593,
0.19737470149993896,
0.6176066398620605,
0.3242560625076294,
0.27842578291893005,
0.34206607937812805,
-0.3041076362133026,
0.35674598813056946,
0.025619283318519592,
0.1365050971508026,
-0.35592296719551086,
-0.3751998245716095,
-0.8827227354049683,
0.514907956123352,
0.3086315393447876,
-0.18838390707969666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03227v1 | Improving Retrieval-augmented Text-to-SQL with AST-based Ranking and Schema Pruning | 2024-07-03T15:55:14 | 2024-07-03T15:55:14 | Zhili Shen, Pavlos Vougiouklis, Chenxin Diao, Kaustubh Vyas, Yuanyi Ji, Jeff Z. Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | We focus on Text-to-SQL semantic parsing from the perspective of Large
Language Models. Motivated by challenges related to the size of commercial
database schemata and the deployability of business intelligence solutions, we
propose an approach that dynamically retrieves input database information and
uses abstract syntax trees to select few-shot examples for in-context learning.
Furthermore, we investigate the extent to which an in-parallel semantic
parser can be leveraged for generating $\textit{approximated}$ versions of the
expected SQL queries, to support our retrieval. We take this approach to the
extreme--we adapt a model consisting of less than $500$M parameters, to act as
an extremely efficient approximator, enhancing it with the ability to process
schemata in a parallelised manner. We apply our approach to monolingual and
cross-lingual benchmarks for semantic parsing, showing improvements over
state-of-the-art baselines. Comprehensive experiments highlight the
contribution of modules involved in this retrieval-augmented generation
setting, revealing interesting directions for future work. | [
-0.10147680342197418,
-0.8430166840553284,
0.6562016010284424,
0.1856762319803238,
-0.4413840174674988,
0.0569937564432621,
-0.4522266685962677,
-0.5219485759735107,
0.2595025300979614,
0.6012468934059143,
-0.5702193975448608,
-0.5145930051803589,
-0.5071428418159485,
0.24302314221858978,
-0.578538715839386,
0.6377001404762268,
0.3138050138950348,
0.03823217377066612,
-0.3250633180141449,
-0.15733738243579865,
-0.5154503583908081,
-0.6131775975227356,
-0.3259916305541992,
0.039730772376060486,
0.2087714970111847,
0.6068317890167236,
0.5838494896888733,
0.8379038572311401,
0.5566080212593079,
0.2513257563114166,
-0.22654087841510773,
0.0003748940071091056,
-0.4483679234981537,
0.43538981676101685,
-0.6701043248176575,
-0.2909548878669739,
-0.22731809318065643,
-0.36304691433906555,
0.8694596290588379,
1.183505654335022,
-0.36607626080513,
0.12972617149353027,
-0.11324465274810791,
0.6220816373825073,
-0.48758575320243835,
0.21354612708091736,
-1.114916205406189,
-0.2973652184009552,
-0.27835696935653687,
-0.048379674553871155,
-0.6844188570976257,
-0.062971331179142,
0.1392006278038025,
-0.6088370084762573,
0.1670956164598465,
0.35357052087783813,
1.0098241567611694,
-0.024569958448410034,
-0.5662142634391785,
-0.3563215434551239,
-0.33630743622779846,
0.9004882574081421,
-0.4567221999168396,
0.5208718776702881,
0.09964028000831604,
0.4726409912109375,
-0.19066153466701508,
-1.0642049312591553,
-0.14150309562683105,
-0.3641453683376312,
-0.2302011251449585,
-0.10067187994718552,
0.2895755171775818,
0.08146259933710098,
0.4488525986671448,
0.43856000900268555,
-0.3765736520290375,
-0.16764160990715027,
-0.14158041775226593,
0.09308711439371109,
0.6586117744445801,
0.1692773401737213,
0.20864467322826385,
-0.24936842918395996,
-0.3032359778881073,
-0.07554931938648224,
-0.8817751407623291,
-0.21189777553081512,
0.10885772109031677,
0.6528992056846619,
0.7713598012924194,
0.7988572120666504,
-0.5742455720901489,
0.9928716421127319,
-0.21511681377887726,
0.37040093541145325,
-0.040103696286678314,
-0.6961194276809692,
-0.21705009043216705,
0.02738717943429947,
0.4866175949573517,
0.23904021084308624,
-0.052783504128456116,
-0.4912397563457489,
-0.3227042853832245,
0.23393844068050385,
0.23234106600284576,
-0.7883375883102417,
-0.29133516550064087,
-0.03566897660493851,
-0.28593072295188904,
-0.021875588223338127,
-0.05624524503946304,
-0.8496050238609314,
-0.19496890902519226,
-0.4373476207256317,
0.5171371102333069,
-0.7110738158226013,
-0.020975328981876373,
0.07559492439031601,
-0.2523501515388489,
0.25684067606925964,
0.32034701108932495,
-0.8067636489868164,
0.7106688022613525,
0.693748414516449,
0.4703052043914795,
-0.12647078931331635,
-0.26805204153060913,
-0.494269460439682,
0.6019125580787659,
-0.2817835211753845,
0.9300393462181091,
-0.6590723991394043,
-0.4392799735069275,
-0.11659747362136841,
-0.10112297534942627,
-0.04804639145731926,
-0.8242281079292297,
0.6522458791732788,
-0.5361530780792236,
-0.06037420406937599,
-0.593825101852417,
-0.7636319994926453,
0.17378585040569305,
0.259111613035202,
-0.4607080817222595,
1.1428134441375732,
0.06377946585416794,
-0.6045008897781372,
0.5782831907272339,
-0.5489030480384827,
-0.5710800886154175,
0.14033243060112,
-0.32454007863998413,
-0.017027469351887703,
0.23189525306224823,
0.209395632147789,
0.09485124051570892,
-0.595543384552002,
0.23264454305171967,
0.02793223224580288,
-0.318868488073349,
-0.37495413422584534,
-0.034029047936201096,
0.7668763995170593,
0.10533201694488525,
-0.12502802908420563,
0.19497735798358917,
-0.8742180466651917,
0.207483172416687,
0.33150243759155273,
-0.2951643466949463,
-0.4941560626029968,
0.20453399419784546,
0.06740810722112656,
0.22120894491672516,
0.3424144387245178,
-0.7853875160217285,
0.16386599838733673,
-0.823384165763855,
0.44476160407066345,
0.36661672592163086,
0.04066401720046997,
0.4982251524925232,
0.16727012395858765,
0.051383767277002335,
-0.059137601405382156,
0.03060970827937126,
-0.24546249210834503,
-0.21991652250289917,
-0.7756645083427429,
-0.44364336133003235,
0.4060908257961273,
0.45206794142723083,
-0.9089800715446472,
0.3310728967189789,
-0.679152250289917,
-0.36385300755500793,
-0.37950238585472107,
0.050543852150440216,
0.30095773935317993,
0.4617696702480316,
0.537496030330658,
-0.29746338725090027,
-0.31461113691329956,
-0.9341525435447693,
-1.0083826780319214,
-0.09969565272331238,
-0.25119781494140625,
0.3624285161495209,
0.2541462481021881,
0.2111494541168213,
1.2729859352111816,
-0.585879385471344,
-0.34620824456214905,
-0.24377942085266113,
-0.1553417295217514,
0.13576313853263855,
0.3955894708633423,
0.29866930842399597,
-0.8791462182998657,
-0.6740582585334778,
0.1562626212835312,
-0.6468901038169861,
0.07175469398498535,
0.3543640375137329,
-0.1771879941225052,
0.08948150277137756,
0.7253250479698181,
-0.909331202507019,
0.2854520082473755,
-0.29535120725631714,
-0.6108940839767456,
0.3565400242805481,
-0.10368470102548599,
-0.05669334530830383,
-0.8787383437156677,
-0.014508962631225586,
-0.15203794836997986,
-0.4651236832141876,
-0.44989752769470215,
0.483004093170166,
0.27855122089385986,
-0.45871973037719727,
-0.3770518898963928,
0.31858038902282715,
-0.505467414855957,
-0.3297252357006073,
0.050527218729257584,
0.19821740686893463,
0.19231317937374115,
0.2589918375015259,
0.15220482647418976,
0.7764819860458374,
0.30327239632606506,
-0.2510678768157959,
0.2862018942832947,
0.30140116810798645,
-0.5036831498146057,
0.5054908394813538,
-0.5248783230781555,
-0.07373946905136108,
-0.1008029356598854,
0.2663801908493042,
-0.741494357585907,
-0.1959369033575058,
-0.23672708868980408,
-0.3140276074409485,
0.39448073506355286,
-0.30758553743362427,
-0.9351915717124939,
-0.04845046624541283,
-0.24428591132164001,
0.2348385453224182,
0.3425302505493164,
-0.718172013759613,
0.719471275806427,
0.3662758767604828,
-0.2689090371131897,
-0.42793717980384827,
-0.5654762983322144,
0.2787386476993561,
-0.15636014938354492,
-0.6868898272514343,
0.5699750185012817,
0.35046038031578064,
-0.3138219714164734,
0.07017529755830765,
-0.11128692328929901,
-0.003650022204965353,
-0.03549432381987572,
-0.256962388753891,
0.127794086933136,
-0.2809383273124695,
0.15455569326877594,
0.12504450976848602,
-0.046214647591114044,
0.11997336149215698,
-0.35341688990592957,
0.4475163221359253,
-0.2246839702129364,
-0.30330896377563477,
-0.08677252382040024,
0.6389507055282593,
0.17789703607559204,
-0.5098847150802612,
0.8668946623802185,
-0.03955690562725067,
-0.4200073778629303,
-0.25167810916900635,
-0.4470538794994354,
-0.3433168828487396,
-0.4704805612564087,
0.44921162724494934,
-0.5802218914031982,
-0.6088597178459167,
0.33927640318870544,
-0.2517957389354706,
0.08475857228040695,
0.6597625017166138,
0.2260400503873825,
-0.03932672366499901,
0.9895128607749939,
0.48011064529418945,
0.28912946581840515,
0.49104994535446167,
-0.05741710215806961,
0.2927526533603668,
-0.3808411955833435,
-0.10877276957035065,
-0.6468758583068848,
0.15414413809776306,
-0.4308681786060333,
-0.3953009247779846,
0.0833786353468895,
0.08273470401763916,
-0.29398900270462036,
0.5383796095848083,
-0.4879092276096344,
0.7140543460845947,
0.442450612783432,
0.19913406670093536,
0.6106152534484863,
0.1716824769973755,
-0.06623627245426178,
-0.1684686541557312,
-0.7643693089485168,
-0.156744122505188,
0.7878443598747253,
0.0948643907904625,
0.3749704360961914,
0.2938486635684967,
0.5675331950187683,
-0.06764225661754608,
0.17573431134223938,
-0.7631657123565674,
0.7367333173751831,
-0.31369489431381226,
-0.5900854468345642,
-0.3910808265209198,
-0.4820825755596161,
-0.6465040445327759,
0.4770573079586029,
-0.09612338244915009,
-0.6989037990570068,
0.175521582365036,
-0.026536501944065094,
-0.007540086284279823,
-0.1104716882109642,
-1.0640110969543457,
1.0358302593231201,
0.15861670672893524,
-0.5632800459861755,
-0.35657942295074463,
-0.8663714528083801,
0.10734166949987411,
0.12287936359643936,
0.02025465853512287,
-0.11873867362737656,
-0.15307149291038513,
0.5001239776611328,
-0.752349853515625,
0.3749732971191406,
-0.33540675044059753,
0.3302260637283325,
0.2307354211807251,
0.020507654175162315,
0.6197955012321472,
-0.07837454229593277,
-0.37088721990585327,
-0.11588552594184875,
0.2664504051208496,
-0.7559864521026611,
-0.780819296836853,
0.7963383197784424,
-0.2367478609085083,
-0.7017418146133423,
-0.3500445783138275,
-0.5855591297149658,
-0.5127785205841064,
0.290131539106369,
0.10858350992202759,
0.47917675971984863,
-0.029116645455360413,
0.37940219044685364,
0.5868366360664368,
-0.08807231485843658,
0.23357374966144562,
0.31971752643585205,
-0.21847841143608093,
-0.17564783990383148,
1.0106148719787598,
0.48329660296440125,
0.3136111795902252,
0.4066757559776306,
-0.011274251155555248,
-0.47570905089378357,
-0.536668062210083,
-0.6425966620445251,
0.38007068634033203,
-0.8882248997688293,
-0.33998605608940125,
-0.7331980466842651,
-0.05166170373558998,
-0.3759620785713196,
-0.05424691364169121,
-0.41571933031082153,
-0.7748987674713135,
0.00786882545799017,
-0.09784147143363953,
0.5521758794784546,
0.45058855414390564,
0.6596693396568298,
0.2916289269924164,
-0.5086824893951416,
-0.041841618716716766,
-0.030753664672374725,
0.5498350858688354,
-0.1517396867275238,
-0.24269288778305054,
-0.1747666895389557,
-0.3038731813430786,
-0.1342979073524475,
-0.7956393957138062,
0.29268282651901245,
0.39990508556365967,
0.38938748836517334,
-0.1963244527578354,
0.1414533108472824,
0.901692807674408,
-0.7889696955680847,
0.8374400734901428,
-0.17772680521011353,
-0.930336058139801,
0.7187554240226746,
-0.4951471984386444,
0.08359932899475098,
1.06479811668396,
0.18448489904403687,
-0.1270013153553009,
-0.07014672458171844,
-0.6872701048851013,
-1.2941924333572388,
0.908146321773529,
0.32861313223838806,
0.0047267465852200985,
-0.24531321227550507,
0.4599081873893738,
-0.09079792350530624,
0.3085207939147949,
-0.4001512825489044,
-0.1738445907831192,
-0.06910422444343567,
-0.4332669973373413,
0.0840277299284935,
-0.43140020966529846,
0.15211081504821777,
-0.42967283725738525,
0.6368424892425537,
-0.10951311141252518,
0.06095036864280701,
0.017226271331310272,
-0.4696761965751648,
0.31938788294792175,
0.07652325183153152,
-0.06706905364990234,
0.843992292881012,
-0.23515307903289795,
-0.04974228888750076,
0.27872586250305176,
-0.23178255558013916,
-0.2446412593126297,
0.3310905694961548,
-0.022663110867142677,
0.2743036150932312,
-0.08968570828437805,
0.45522284507751465,
0.3069392144680023,
-1.0762182474136353,
0.7228417992591858,
-0.08794913440942764,
0.18282786011695862,
-0.17148323357105255,
-0.2752191424369812,
0.002095030155032873,
-0.05361632630228996,
0.38340961933135986,
-0.21899953484535217,
0.4880824089050293,
-0.6691707968711853,
0.4417104423046112,
0.5416538715362549,
-0.3180686831474304,
0.049115922302007675,
0.5783102512359619,
0.12804624438285828,
-0.2580598294734955,
0.7516041398048401,
0.010377002879977226,
-0.3415556848049164,
0.4610625207424164,
0.7006766200065613,
0.3183003067970276,
-0.20423007011413574,
-0.28162631392478943,
0.2066044807434082,
0.15217997133731842,
-0.12193313241004944,
0.2923928201198578,
-0.35874199867248535,
-0.3111770451068878,
-0.4547211229801178,
-0.7358342409133911,
-0.3798762857913971,
-0.5798307657241821,
-0.7006073594093323,
0.7226523756980896,
-0.3181587755680084,
0.17000681161880493,
0.14048048853874207,
0.200650155544281,
-0.36153218150138855,
0.20545262098312378,
-0.4430128335952759,
1.419959306716919,
-0.6738636493682861,
1.053073525428772,
0.8129938840866089,
-0.5770196914672852,
-0.6889621615409851,
-0.01986577734351158,
-0.4950639307498932,
-0.3707273304462433,
0.31360819935798645,
0.052159033715724945,
0.1092342957854271,
0.34217527508735657,
-0.15932542085647583,
-0.8899326920509338,
0.9560645222663879,
0.7148332595825195,
-0.22222590446472168,
-0.3528311848640442,
0.23056741058826447,
0.595415472984314,
-0.2364259958267212,
0.279855340719223,
0.9403529167175293,
0.10362127423286438,
0.16819553077220917,
-0.8395559191703796,
-0.06566935032606125,
-0.11984442919492722,
0.14877229928970337,
0.5084151029586792,
-0.4196975529193878,
0.6328924298286438,
0.307852566242218,
-0.24118433892726898,
0.10853587090969086,
0.8465095162391663,
0.349860817193985,
0.2557496726512909,
0.38878947496414185,
0.4848374128341675,
0.4397372901439667,
-0.025090353563427925,
1.257110834121704,
-0.3778987228870392,
0.3936854302883148,
1.2795658111572266,
-0.35898321866989136,
1.1781888008117676,
0.7196041345596313,
-0.12866955995559692,
0.38068708777427673,
0.5415403246879578,
0.35966625809669495,
0.529259979724884,
0.042104288935661316,
-0.2929549217224121,
-0.1627510040998459,
-0.41516241431236267,
-0.15106303989887238,
0.24343015253543854,
0.7429875731468201,
-0.41268423199653625,
-0.5468116998672485,
-0.04156586900353432,
-0.18136154115200043,
0.4547770917415619,
-0.2571984827518463,
0.9429568648338318,
0.05541171878576279,
-0.4622049629688263,
0.4408881664276123,
0.08519262075424194,
0.3207654654979706,
-0.5859565138816833,
-0.012157237157225609,
-0.03638840466737747,
0.09127151221036911,
-0.09473025053739548,
-0.7271701693534851,
0.651739239692688,
-0.1348082423210144,
-0.1303207129240036,
-0.3319418430328369,
0.8838086724281311,
-0.5251333713531494,
-0.537346601486206,
0.40108129382133484,
0.3336449861526489,
0.15204977989196777,
-0.30651795864105225,
-0.4779021739959717,
0.00844813697040081,
-0.16840383410453796,
-0.2464568018913269,
0.6086174249649048,
0.6252216696739197,
-0.3187565505504608,
0.399033784866333,
0.34606581926345825,
-0.060999125242233276,
0.21768537163734436,
-0.04540858417749405,
1.1459612846374512,
-0.8029707670211792,
-0.5518027544021606,
-0.7176592946052551,
0.316148966550827,
-0.4409243166446686,
0.14601488411426544,
0.7462672591209412,
0.8823234438896179,
0.9052168726921082,
0.09305792301893234,
0.306730717420578,
-0.11212748289108276,
0.9091818332672119,
-0.34618493914604187,
0.6031308174133301,
-0.6279012560844421,
0.5395235419273376,
-0.24712969362735748,
-1.2273519039154053,
-0.3336896300315857,
0.32394149899482727,
-0.4175747036933899,
-0.22793640196323395,
0.700063943862915,
0.791598916053772,
-0.13180206716060638,
0.16867122054100037,
0.3659651279449463,
0.19930344820022583,
0.1288156509399414,
0.1837839037179947,
0.6874789595603943,
-0.5552070736885071,
0.5966641306877136,
-0.28646907210350037,
-0.10525273531675339,
-0.05737360939383507,
-0.5934250950813293,
-0.3954284191131592,
-0.5173198580741882,
-0.08546357601881027,
-0.4380437731742859,
0.40241116285324097,
1.2118561267852783,
0.39449670910835266,
-0.6544642448425293,
-0.2571834325790405,
-0.2011801302433014,
-0.024528509005904198,
-0.0949421301484108,
-0.1986721009016037,
0.48048722743988037,
-0.6032794713973999,
-0.7306912541389465,
0.5661991238594055,
0.3325425088405609,
-0.5195695757865906,
0.16429093480110168,
0.4723135530948639,
-0.5242351293563843,
0.12688599526882172,
0.9780491590499878,
-0.004510748200118542,
-0.5509108304977417,
-0.27240651845932007,
-0.014247922226786613,
-0.06223367527127266,
0.10320944339036942,
0.7130491733551025,
-1.0601375102996826,
0.2695996165275574,
0.5085197687149048,
0.9701324105262756,
0.5593622326850891,
0.33504417538642883,
0.5352702736854553,
-0.9614668488502502,
0.19521278142929077,
0.46047118306159973,
0.18894439935684204,
0.4115113615989685,
-0.3268466889858246,
0.582068145275116,
0.42158544063568115,
-0.40406110882759094,
-1.040440320968628,
0.27294522523880005,
-0.7118072509765625,
-0.36696919798851013,
1.03740394115448,
-0.01741001009941101,
-0.5301864743232727,
-0.22820018231868744,
-0.20172013342380524,
-0.07802749425172806,
-0.3888953626155853,
0.3890495002269745,
0.572069525718689,
-0.1261785477399826,
0.0401664637029171,
-0.40053853392601013,
0.6029571294784546,
0.7862589359283447,
-0.6363862156867981,
0.4994983375072479,
0.5264877676963806,
0.20131756365299225,
-0.10684580355882645,
0.5001820921897888,
-0.34591326117515564,
0.1577599048614502,
0.05000060051679611,
-0.2401067018508911,
0.344683438539505,
-0.27511686086654663,
-0.30415406823158264,
0.3260330855846405,
0.36007705330848694,
0.058923084288835526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03211v1 | How Does Quantization Affect Multilingual LLMs? | 2024-07-03T15:39:40 | 2024-07-03T15:39:40 | Kelly Marchisio, Saurabh Dash, Hongyu Chen, Dennis Aumiller, Ahmet Üstün, Sara Hooker, Sebastian Ruder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Quantization techniques are widely used to improve inference speed and
deployment of large language models. While a wide body of work examines the
impact of quantized LLMs on English tasks, none have examined the effect of
quantization across languages. We conduct a thorough analysis of quantized
multilingual LLMs, focusing on their performance across languages and at
varying scales. We use automatic benchmarks, LLM-as-a-Judge methods, and human
evaluation, finding that (1) harmful effects of quantization are apparent in
human evaluation, and automatic metrics severely underestimate the detriment: a
1.7% average drop in Japanese across automatic tasks corresponds to a 16.0%
drop reported by human evaluators on realistic prompts; (2) languages are
disparately affected by quantization, with non-Latin script languages impacted
worst; and (3) challenging tasks such as mathematical reasoning degrade
fastest. As the ability to serve low-compute models is critical for wide global
adoption of NLP technologies, our results urge consideration of multilingual
performance as a key evaluation criterion for efficient models. | [
-0.12173888832330704,
-0.6402503252029419,
0.5247802138328552,
0.5447519421577454,
-0.23606817424297333,
0.06010812520980835,
-0.17723484337329865,
-0.6703781485557556,
-0.1198883131146431,
0.32070815563201904,
-0.14773812890052795,
-0.4292457699775696,
-0.6534702777862549,
0.384372740983963,
-0.15629035234451294,
0.8337662220001221,
0.06294523179531097,
0.41571494936943054,
-0.5989505052566528,
-0.3168211281299591,
-0.2730638086795807,
-1.0145868062973022,
-0.7363706231117249,
-0.3396352231502533,
0.593539297580719,
0.1557581126689911,
0.8995794653892517,
0.39515694975852966,
0.6510457992553711,
0.4018382132053375,
-0.20815084874629974,
-0.1952432245016098,
-0.10229898244142532,
0.15129943192005157,
0.20176608860492706,
-1.143054485321045,
-0.5334678888320923,
-0.002294701524078846,
0.9526349902153015,
0.8023711442947388,
-0.21088217198848724,
0.2706059217453003,
0.09191636741161346,
0.7391462922096252,
-0.7978010177612305,
-0.03776928037405014,
-0.2382209151983261,
0.10519791394472122,
-0.2668016850948334,
-0.11361031979322433,
-0.2502194046974182,
-0.271203875541687,
-0.08588097989559174,
-0.5700526237487793,
-0.09638615697622299,
-0.07651469856500626,
0.3947053849697113,
0.41212472319602966,
-0.7819606065750122,
-0.2919301390647888,
-0.7327332496643066,
1.0062220096588135,
-0.4564138352870941,
0.49071934819221497,
0.4565534293651581,
0.006066601257771254,
0.22706958651542664,
-0.539106011390686,
-0.08806797862052917,
-0.26174843311309814,
-0.057147689163684845,
0.06944124400615692,
-0.3211098313331604,
0.2501554787158966,
0.638124942779541,
0.5696467161178589,
-0.5393902659416199,
0.227848082780838,
-0.2909674346446991,
-0.23268994688987732,
0.5445111393928528,
0.27208489179611206,
0.27836906909942627,
-0.2781088054180145,
-0.15741786360740662,
0.03168630599975586,
-0.6670423150062561,
0.059084922075271606,
0.5702941417694092,
0.05066737160086632,
-0.0030479386914521456,
0.5795550346374512,
-0.27467411756515503,
0.5751141905784607,
-0.43393996357917786,
-0.25824806094169617,
0.0016257636016234756,
-0.6668752431869507,
-0.1703091412782669,
-0.22705481946468353,
0.8603987693786621,
0.264839768409729,
0.3874392509460449,
-0.15244841575622559,
-0.1715918779373169,
0.22162207961082458,
-0.008934052661061287,
-0.8476293683052063,
-0.030907945707440376,
0.0019737756811082363,
-0.20626655220985413,
0.06889871507883072,
-0.3240421414375305,
-0.38802650570869446,
-0.2940082848072052,
-0.10353793203830719,
0.28012874722480774,
-0.32154953479766846,
-0.0318591333925724,
0.26264330744743347,
-0.06744454056024551,
-0.0342436283826828,
0.15428176522254944,
-0.6832461357116699,
0.296408474445343,
0.5171738862991333,
0.7372663617134094,
0.008029493503272533,
-0.18360000848770142,
-0.37875643372535706,
-0.017242765054106712,
-0.304177463054657,
0.7752586603164673,
-0.2006351351737976,
-0.5410881638526917,
-0.1822109818458557,
-0.11508756130933762,
0.04930483549833298,
-0.7084670066833496,
0.40048474073410034,
-0.4247265160083771,
0.1650930494070053,
-0.1862412840127945,
-0.46711644530296326,
-0.015994291752576828,
-0.07404767721891403,
-0.878462553024292,
0.6009728312492371,
-0.2084931880235672,
-0.49184998869895935,
0.4931895136833191,
-0.3667610287666321,
-0.6351279616355896,
0.06916695088148117,
0.1493222713470459,
-0.3746192455291748,
0.27030032873153687,
0.13066081702709198,
0.2852024435997009,
-0.2831743061542511,
0.3067731559276581,
-0.27979984879493713,
-0.5168043971061707,
0.49951523542404175,
-0.9606254696846008,
0.8084825277328491,
0.17819207906723022,
-0.17251873016357422,
-0.08254830539226532,
-0.747124195098877,
0.24008065462112427,
-0.08283600211143494,
-0.48889055848121643,
-0.5321998596191406,
-0.041759129613637924,
0.004184218589216471,
0.1656935214996338,
0.07642226666212082,
-0.20154789090156555,
0.0776977613568306,
-0.5381563305854797,
0.39336302876472473,
0.5127829313278198,
0.16414877772331238,
0.4583975076675415,
-0.2629874050617218,
0.9800313711166382,
-0.15919119119644165,
0.35294485092163086,
-0.21326635777950287,
-0.5740545988082886,
-0.6737037301063538,
-0.3296269476413727,
0.5028348565101624,
0.5944947600364685,
-0.7033690810203552,
-0.10987682640552521,
-0.16607765853405,
-0.2283279299736023,
-0.7070165872573853,
0.07529112696647644,
0.6818570494651794,
-0.2706248164176941,
-0.011586555279791355,
-0.18957597017288208,
-0.13259859383106232,
-1.0073301792144775,
-0.6285030841827393,
-0.005729658994823694,
-0.20757347345352173,
-0.210381418466568,
0.47757649421691895,
-0.021987086161971092,
0.6239679455757141,
-0.38450172543525696,
-0.1596342772245407,
0.08432888239622116,
0.3073047399520874,
0.002921886509284377,
0.24531657993793488,
0.30304884910583496,
-0.6925438642501831,
-0.48025527596473694,
-0.16079722344875336,
-0.5222799777984619,
-0.1973496526479721,
-0.06811802089214325,
0.06369521468877792,
0.46652644872665405,
0.3212985098361969,
-0.5909572243690491,
0.39485883712768555,
0.5882207751274109,
-0.2561415731906891,
0.619233250617981,
-0.2587839365005493,
0.41755473613739014,
-0.834318220615387,
-0.10699883103370667,
0.3848688304424286,
-0.34595730900764465,
-0.42880555987358093,
0.2844541370868683,
0.28924760222435,
-0.01969030313193798,
-0.7743355631828308,
0.5346145629882812,
-0.3327806293964386,
-0.3840828537940979,
-0.05385693162679672,
0.17248579859733582,
0.385515421628952,
0.2527003884315491,
-0.1790654957294464,
1.0183638334274292,
0.27566391229629517,
-0.6519121527671814,
0.3308607339859009,
-0.23788844048976898,
-0.48093241453170776,
0.696157693862915,
-0.5888441205024719,
-0.0974401906132698,
0.04272130876779556,
-0.05510425195097923,
-0.774636447429657,
0.16157187521457672,
0.048059236258268356,
-0.43130019307136536,
0.21772097051143646,
-0.07278376072645187,
-0.9639328718185425,
-0.04660239815711975,
-0.44117361307144165,
0.5687201023101807,
0.21530814468860626,
-0.20984524488449097,
0.2407144159078598,
0.2924179136753082,
0.09923674166202545,
-0.38247692584991455,
-0.853757917881012,
0.14977213740348816,
-0.5297216773033142,
-0.5503337383270264,
0.12157666683197021,
-0.18180344998836517,
-0.743098795413971,
-0.16269047558307648,
-0.26825061440467834,
-0.25875216722488403,
0.5922309160232544,
0.057913120836019516,
-0.05848519131541252,
0.05379682779312134,
0.27689847350120544,
0.007531426846981049,
-0.2636910676956177,
0.30272015929222107,
-0.12635073065757751,
0.2674209773540497,
-0.3167271316051483,
-0.3257071077823639,
-0.5287884473800659,
0.28849780559539795,
0.44623124599456787,
-0.3381701707839966,
0.7377464771270752,
0.6709374785423279,
-0.3309014141559601,
0.16627074778079987,
-0.38328924775123596,
-0.03959253057837486,
-0.47084301710128784,
0.6296230554580688,
-0.6557860970497131,
-0.8727500438690186,
0.5238757133483887,
-0.05213286355137825,
-0.3414272665977478,
0.4553689658641815,
0.5400881171226501,
-0.35427117347717285,
1.3165969848632812,
0.5037893652915955,
-0.004669535905122757,
0.3893716335296631,
-0.3068319261074066,
0.07755803316831589,
-0.7621587514877319,
0.07501770555973053,
-0.6082752346992493,
-0.02512826770544052,
-0.9892602562904358,
-0.40876853466033936,
0.6170436143875122,
0.3461250960826874,
0.13530363142490387,
-0.0043188598938286304,
-0.10392870754003525,
0.545976996421814,
0.4805523157119751,
-0.05606163293123245,
0.6460546851158142,
-0.12196141481399536,
0.15511345863342285,
-0.32984477281570435,
-0.8070523738861084,
-0.5669782161712646,
1.2165194749832153,
0.2785343527793884,
0.80772864818573,
0.32681965827941895,
0.6010302901268005,
0.3956657350063324,
0.2243576943874359,
-0.9379957914352417,
0.37197431921958923,
-0.24229948222637177,
-0.5745126605033875,
-0.4962390959262848,
-0.6685506105422974,
-1.199065089225769,
0.5804394483566284,
-0.08251753449440002,
-0.45228880643844604,
-0.19148088991641998,
0.007708665914833546,
-0.5321642756462097,
-0.03977305814623833,
-0.7829263210296631,
0.9124749898910522,
-0.4841059744358063,
-0.3411487936973572,
-0.5829975008964539,
-0.4394301474094391,
0.5637801289558411,
-0.3367767632007599,
0.691321611404419,
-0.19902877509593964,
-0.2810814082622528,
0.7790172696113586,
-0.07914954423904419,
0.8529959321022034,
0.043700095266103745,
-0.49363774061203003,
0.07161710411310196,
0.0019287209725007415,
0.18199796974658966,
0.38704293966293335,
-0.16306155920028687,
0.5843114852905273,
0.4031584858894348,
-0.4964212477207184,
-0.6665460467338562,
0.5999236106872559,
-0.7255998253822327,
-0.6464738249778748,
-0.46600431203842163,
-0.6185168623924255,
-0.24105586111545563,
-0.15804001688957214,
0.30256766080856323,
0.36290502548217773,
-0.10882414132356644,
-0.13662737607955933,
0.4735596776008606,
-0.4201718270778656,
0.47550010681152344,
0.6555513739585876,
-0.07973892986774445,
-0.6396728754043579,
0.9695388674736023,
0.4067927598953247,
0.7357310652732849,
0.4996923804283142,
0.17902573943138123,
-0.36583036184310913,
-0.2404220551252365,
-0.40070632100105286,
0.3819809854030609,
-0.927265465259552,
-0.09657786041498184,
-0.3087881803512573,
0.27087652683258057,
-0.4493202567100525,
0.18493780493736267,
-0.2332114279270172,
-0.680637001991272,
-0.3746260106563568,
0.15064354240894318,
0.05193135887384415,
0.5650664567947388,
0.04618564993143082,
0.45415303111076355,
-0.9152310490608215,
0.42418214678764343,
0.32947587966918945,
0.3580482304096222,
-0.2405611276626587,
-0.47243303060531616,
-0.7861421704292297,
0.0946168377995491,
-0.23804768919944763,
-0.6353023052215576,
0.17827466130256653,
0.3939829170703888,
0.4227357506752014,
0.2395646870136261,
-0.08021973073482513,
0.8418188691139221,
-0.4122390151023865,
0.6460745930671692,
0.1238308995962143,
-1.1769253015518188,
0.3158802092075348,
-0.023647554218769073,
0.7139076590538025,
0.3261927366256714,
0.5574721097946167,
-0.9072452783584595,
-0.6556460857391357,
-0.3544456660747528,
-0.8189911842346191,
0.6624436974525452,
-0.08445606380701065,
0.1359613537788391,
-0.20287692546844482,
0.326265424489975,
-0.025270098820328712,
0.46533364057540894,
-1.0026719570159912,
-0.4175984859466553,
0.3697192668914795,
0.1775834858417511,
-0.26421624422073364,
-0.44291993975639343,
0.2089841067790985,
-0.2615583539009094,
0.3798767030239105,
-0.05889015272259712,
0.07061521708965302,
-0.12657767534255981,
-0.4744516611099243,
-0.18682798743247986,
0.3212504982948303,
0.6492381691932678,
0.6209374666213989,
0.1421922743320465,
0.07777164876461029,
0.19956329464912415,
-0.11719158291816711,
0.3962588906288147,
-0.14478707313537598,
-0.13722342252731323,
0.030906161293387413,
0.6256395578384399,
0.775353729724884,
0.5598475933074951,
-0.5752706527709961,
0.36775150895118713,
-0.08234990388154984,
-0.10687378793954849,
-0.2830403745174408,
-0.11665112525224686,
0.010449892841279507,
0.2434716820716858,
0.18192748725414276,
0.00027969235088676214,
0.2494402825832367,
-0.5872425436973572,
0.03738115727901459,
0.6795011162757874,
-0.04425138235092163,
-0.3919864594936371,
0.6519327163696289,
0.08458004146814346,
-0.3460724651813507,
0.4594363868236542,
-0.2745973467826843,
-0.5080718398094177,
0.7118985652923584,
0.35104700922966003,
0.713866114616394,
-0.5155521035194397,
0.08679912984371185,
0.18683964014053345,
0.5323606729507446,
0.0012101971078664064,
0.26370665431022644,
-0.09803203493356705,
-0.564852774143219,
-0.9573110938072205,
-0.6118735671043396,
-0.3737257122993469,
-0.19577544927597046,
-0.7498590350151062,
0.08111900836229324,
-0.037198256701231,
-0.5877026915550232,
-0.13700130581855774,
0.11312124878168106,
-0.5819606184959412,
0.2041338086128235,
0.4728125333786011,
0.2857687771320343,
-0.912979245185852,
0.7830027937889099,
0.6740354895591736,
-0.10062891244888306,
-0.3300107717514038,
0.04674885794520378,
-0.14190258085727692,
-0.7284284234046936,
0.7241801023483276,
0.03923216462135315,
0.000729472900275141,
0.2358051836490631,
0.11217360198497772,
-1.0967791080474854,
0.7305997610092163,
0.5726408958435059,
-0.5175769329071045,
0.24469910562038422,
0.7151728272438049,
0.818749725818634,
0.3341897428035736,
0.5464624166488647,
0.6230069398880005,
0.5660271048545837,
-0.3836257755756378,
-1.148297905921936,
-0.274192214012146,
0.0933392196893692,
0.21993999183177948,
0.5323789715766907,
-0.7377912998199463,
0.653008222579956,
-0.27010831236839294,
-0.5057166218757629,
-0.040838588029146194,
0.26913124322891235,
0.09474901109933853,
0.29382577538490295,
0.3148829936981201,
0.6146606802940369,
0.6809483766555786,
-0.04386085644364357,
1.3680411577224731,
-0.43034034967422485,
0.3114337921142578,
0.6374881267547607,
-0.2714238464832306,
0.6796007752418518,
0.5552078485488892,
-0.7921585440635681,
0.04077655449509621,
0.6684626340866089,
0.2164316475391388,
0.369918555021286,
0.5835530757904053,
-0.4206427335739136,
-0.15079668164253235,
-0.16078947484493256,
0.03008905239403248,
0.42078274488449097,
0.29128897190093994,
0.15830382704734802,
-0.0014111143536865711,
0.5862023234367371,
0.011122100055217743,
0.08251655101776123,
-0.4332394003868103,
0.6937894821166992,
0.2973634898662567,
-0.5177258253097534,
0.7902399301528931,
0.3725440502166748,
0.8309620022773743,
-0.3869461417198181,
0.1893974095582962,
-0.4115206003189087,
-0.04321859031915665,
-0.1776934713125229,
-0.48201900720596313,
0.5017259120941162,
0.04465332627296448,
-0.13982707262039185,
-0.4354139566421509,
0.2662493884563446,
-0.42189347743988037,
-0.6316674947738647,
0.40521135926246643,
0.8361611366271973,
0.30987057089805603,
-0.455599844455719,
-0.5748605132102966,
0.0741536095738411,
-0.08195358514785767,
-0.43366652727127075,
0.6120448708534241,
0.5099811553955078,
-0.4135717749595642,
0.811747670173645,
0.41062355041503906,
0.088278628885746,
0.15489155054092407,
0.3342462480068207,
0.3028155565261841,
-0.7961860299110413,
-0.10270387679338455,
-1.093781590461731,
0.3818734884262085,
0.4673716425895691,
-0.15570007264614105,
0.9618443846702576,
0.7302576899528503,
0.9914585947990417,
0.06965818256139755,
0.4226950407028198,
0.43377596139907837,
-0.02799031138420105,
-0.6433614492416382,
0.598294198513031,
-0.7877848148345947,
0.4978843927383423,
-0.13641168177127838,
-0.9197383522987366,
-0.4917190372943878,
0.28996744751930237,
-0.2292792648077011,
0.09573183208703995,
0.9781410098075867,
0.3062286674976349,
0.5000481009483337,
-0.3410610854625702,
0.7700066566467285,
0.016885099932551384,
0.09188100695610046,
0.42685428261756897,
1.119905710220337,
-0.4922121465206146,
0.534723162651062,
-0.6838952302932739,
0.02876795269548893,
0.08972011506557465,
-0.6220273971557617,
-0.5676906108856201,
-0.36459869146347046,
-0.6422322392463684,
0.15315194427967072,
0.08382181078195572,
0.44870051741600037,
0.46845006942749023,
-0.5108509659767151,
-0.570197582244873,
0.2420649230480194,
0.44082406163215637,
-0.16970732808113098,
-0.2931050956249237,
0.1729329228401184,
-0.5030726790428162,
-1.0598993301391602,
0.2256360799074173,
0.3547419607639313,
-0.0921153724193573,
-0.37472474575042725,
0.046445608139038086,
0.07752646505832672,
-0.2171463668346405,
0.8155637383460999,
-0.27970296144485474,
-0.9162773489952087,
0.07044906914234161,
0.10846441239118576,
-0.36188361048698425,
0.07410255819559097,
0.7521027326583862,
-0.7638193368911743,
0.31291714310646057,
0.13429397344589233,
0.1859392374753952,
0.32814139127731323,
-0.049493491649627686,
0.49969181418418884,
-0.9052125215530396,
0.29347431659698486,
0.24979141354560852,
0.31145140528678894,
0.21565677225589752,
-0.4231014549732208,
0.45590806007385254,
0.4128446877002716,
-0.5898846387863159,
-0.8480862975120544,
0.09461520612239838,
-0.3102824091911316,
-0.40466514229774475,
1.0963239669799805,
-0.15435484051704407,
-0.1480880230665207,
0.004187007900327444,
0.16070768237113953,
0.27699825167655945,
-0.09964397549629211,
0.5392153859138489,
0.8883482217788696,
-0.053250137716531754,
-0.22770026326179504,
-0.8263331651687622,
0.3202425241470337,
0.6565752625465393,
-0.6921409964561462,
0.011083254590630531,
0.5288151502609253,
0.12723909318447113,
-0.07370667904615402,
0.5976983308792114,
0.08923253417015076,
0.31663137674331665,
-0.14139407873153687,
0.40141043066978455,
0.28749266266822815,
-0.06999418884515762,
-0.9543726444244385,
-0.03764963895082474,
0.4343564212322235,
0.006127974949777126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03192v1 | CiteAssist: A System for Automated Preprint Citation and BibTeX Generation | 2024-07-03T15:18:29 | 2024-07-03T15:18:29 | Lars Benedikt Kaesberg, Terry Ruas, Jan Philip Wahle, Bela Gipp | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL | We present CiteAssist, a system to automate the generation of BibTeX entries
for preprints, streamlining the process of bibliographic annotation. Our system
extracts metadata, such as author names, titles, publication dates, and
keywords, to create standardized annotations within the document. CiteAssist
automatically attaches the BibTeX citation to the end of a PDF and links it on
the first page of the document so other researchers gain immediate access to
the correct citation of the article. This method promotes platform flexibility
by ensuring that annotations remain accessible regardless of the repository
used to publish or access the preprint. The annotations remain available even
if the preprint is viewed externally to CiteAssist. Additionally, the system
adds relevant related papers based on extracted keywords to the preprint,
providing researchers with additional publications besides those in related
work for further reading. Researchers can enhance their preprints organization
and reference management workflows through a free and publicly available web
interface. | [
-0.47464168071746826,
0.06691376864910126,
0.6050800681114197,
0.4118729531764984,
-0.42864134907722473,
0.3159382939338684,
0.36818236112594604,
-0.5667464733123779,
0.45957866311073303,
0.19018232822418213,
-0.2778880298137665,
-0.2869272232055664,
-0.3939407467842102,
0.3823363184928894,
-0.22543452680110931,
1.0441749095916748,
-0.027908416464924812,
0.14031168818473816,
-0.012284278869628906,
0.11475489288568497,
-0.26027214527130127,
-0.2121133953332901,
-0.37860599160194397,
-0.4389464557170868,
0.9449033141136169,
0.17206135392189026,
0.6993362307548523,
0.5641176700592041,
0.7636458277702332,
0.17328643798828125,
0.41661444306373596,
-0.019398095086216927,
0.05983132869005203,
0.5366894602775574,
-0.9905351996421814,
-0.09045381098985672,
-0.33987584710121155,
-0.08883742988109589,
0.40924862027168274,
0.5757525563240051,
0.5434995889663696,
0.5385726690292358,
-0.16226550936698914,
0.33923691511154175,
-0.8687273263931274,
-0.18464651703834534,
-0.42867663502693176,
-0.46212175488471985,
-0.3815985321998596,
-0.7091901898384094,
-0.3626757562160492,
-0.9423008561134338,
0.010512731969356537,
-0.6235466003417969,
0.2853015065193176,
0.35367122292518616,
0.9495212435722351,
0.18296495079994202,
-0.22422026097774506,
-0.2736395299434662,
-0.5131903290748596,
0.4126879572868347,
-0.12115904688835144,
0.16556592285633087,
0.23813895881175995,
0.2381516695022583,
-0.31978902220726013,
-1.136124849319458,
-0.3993113934993744,
0.04873950406908989,
-0.527306318283081,
-0.03562578931450844,
-0.0346827507019043,
-0.05904928594827652,
-0.0412818044424057,
0.05658654868602753,
-0.7521588802337646,
-0.29131460189819336,
-0.41897594928741455,
-0.25390931963920593,
0.5886840224266052,
-0.36762169003486633,
0.45400163531303406,
-0.5223348736763,
-0.4811922311782837,
-0.1018201932311058,
-0.6544317007064819,
-0.45591965317726135,
0.6010217070579529,
0.29546281695365906,
0.43342503905296326,
0.5046152472496033,
-0.001947513548657298,
0.0530262254178524,
-0.1465926468372345,
0.42245543003082275,
0.304831326007843,
-0.1373804658651352,
-0.009449920617043972,
0.49902164936065674,
0.8098279237747192,
0.048317138105630875,
-0.007575635798275471,
-0.3482338786125183,
-0.027273740619421005,
-0.3086966276168823,
0.1481311321258545,
-0.8443644046783447,
-0.9559190273284912,
0.594029426574707,
-0.23636318743228912,
-0.3691764771938324,
0.27298811078071594,
-0.6709273457527161,
-0.5914739370346069,
-0.4520382881164551,
0.6598663926124573,
-0.6477490663528442,
-0.20319052040576935,
-0.7747114896774292,
-0.7220990061759949,
-0.08050289750099182,
0.4249183237552643,
-0.5069310665130615,
0.1789359152317047,
0.4084790349006653,
1.0924488306045532,
-0.24021072685718536,
-0.29908278584480286,
-0.4979902505874634,
0.8458398580551147,
-0.292314350605011,
1.277536392211914,
-0.4702393412590027,
-0.48720815777778625,
-0.06769133359193802,
0.11328605562448502,
0.11839619278907776,
-0.2671954035758972,
0.4669317603111267,
-0.7992438673973083,
-0.2548605799674988,
-0.44151079654693604,
-0.424848735332489,
-0.04952540248632431,
0.128311887383461,
-0.8163506388664246,
0.9901562333106995,
0.04971563443541527,
-0.9145205020904541,
0.3729594349861145,
-1.144132137298584,
-0.19684068858623505,
0.6898995637893677,
0.00974400993436575,
0.12096333503723145,
0.02488330379128456,
-0.04356097802519798,
0.1303226500749588,
-0.10136348754167557,
0.2153000682592392,
-0.3058786988258362,
-0.11850238591432571,
0.2128155529499054,
0.22955168783664703,
0.9886184930801392,
0.6232120394706726,
-0.04496021196246147,
0.24890942871570587,
-0.7291650772094727,
0.16488151252269745,
0.23906302452087402,
-0.17444826662540436,
-0.7995243072509766,
-0.0800972655415535,
0.5586698651313782,
-0.15111258625984192,
0.4784820079803467,
-0.7183659076690674,
0.38806861639022827,
-0.09416353702545166,
0.03161758556962013,
0.9581681489944458,
0.5627589225769043,
0.003322822507470846,
-0.12100176513195038,
0.3479774296283722,
-0.3655661344528198,
-0.07804451137781143,
-0.5091859698295593,
-0.14228548109531403,
-0.3100777566432953,
-0.560215950012207,
0.8364510536193848,
0.5016670227050781,
-0.38218632340431213,
0.3772425949573517,
-0.5854222178459167,
-0.6292741894721985,
-0.050321608781814575,
0.28411760926246643,
0.12434569001197815,
0.013663080520927906,
0.416301429271698,
-0.2847672700881958,
-0.6964142918586731,
-0.719685971736908,
-0.4602012038230896,
-0.268009215593338,
-0.33343425393104553,
-0.33136504888534546,
0.7430058717727661,
-0.261420339345932,
1.1389551162719727,
-0.5215010643005371,
-0.13837771117687225,
0.17824403941631317,
0.7216348052024841,
-0.22031643986701965,
0.8374229073524475,
0.6531461477279663,
-1.1060664653778076,
-0.5769376754760742,
-0.07395122200250626,
-0.6292876601219177,
-0.56490558385849,
-0.019436949864029884,
-0.6622484922409058,
0.002487731399014592,
0.5697124600410461,
-0.3189651370048523,
0.4960293769836426,
-0.046556130051612854,
-0.1224585473537445,
0.6254408955574036,
-0.03731752559542656,
0.09093854576349258,
-1.2481690645217896,
0.7772462964057922,
-0.4862309694290161,
-0.1463472843170166,
-0.22265906631946564,
-0.04404400289058685,
-0.004431193228811026,
-0.33789560198783875,
-0.029303602874279022,
0.659396767616272,
-0.5643044114112854,
-0.15278016030788422,
-0.332753449678421,
0.178207665681839,
0.15879544615745544,
0.16008128225803375,
0.16495651006698608,
0.6168341636657715,
0.06264890730381012,
-0.4168199896812439,
0.25358742475509644,
0.3111054301261902,
0.11550432443618774,
0.7334879636764526,
-0.7015896439552307,
0.10244156420230865,
0.0006370440241880715,
0.31000933051109314,
-1.1604005098342896,
-0.676908552646637,
0.47269463539123535,
-0.5904322266578674,
0.18411926925182343,
-0.257693886756897,
-0.9962301850318909,
-0.03606181591749191,
-0.360228955745697,
0.27052146196365356,
-0.10493908077478409,
-0.5979394912719727,
0.6890923976898193,
0.14983969926834106,
-0.8088430166244507,
-0.3422204554080963,
-0.2023410052061081,
0.24616645276546478,
0.19116878509521484,
-0.15626879036426544,
0.48158201575279236,
-0.19530753791332245,
-0.33399614691734314,
0.28802457451820374,
0.05320923030376434,
0.025092901661992073,
-0.15580682456493378,
0.5069791674613953,
0.30647265911102295,
0.37693533301353455,
0.5859954953193665,
0.40256354212760925,
-0.23932397365570068,
0.05752571299672127,
-0.42583534121513367,
0.5712666511535645,
0.006047180853784084,
-0.49043357372283936,
-0.28893136978149414,
0.6744219660758972,
0.3031424582004547,
-0.3387746214866638,
0.19284628331661224,
0.4898514151573181,
-0.37613770365715027,
0.28013408184051514,
-0.38355088233947754,
0.012556083500385284,
-0.4595935046672821,
-0.17381952702999115,
-0.4547506272792816,
-0.06229294836521149,
0.5277581810951233,
-0.5408084392547607,
0.5372132658958435,
0.5256733298301697,
0.22533869743347168,
-0.15287888050079346,
0.48153167963027954,
0.4565475285053253,
0.40517204999923706,
0.580168604850769,
0.06119957193732262,
0.11345671862363815,
-0.8088515400886536,
-0.2636846899986267,
-0.8562555909156799,
-0.4876331090927124,
-0.2655464708805084,
-0.011631953530013561,
0.02197030372917652,
0.23198482394218445,
-0.6587795615196228,
0.4978146255016327,
-0.9708722233772278,
0.38022297620773315,
0.880093514919281,
-0.2470361590385437,
0.14789670705795288,
0.15805263817310333,
-0.19553394615650177,
0.13206583261489868,
-0.07298688590526581,
-0.8270803689956665,
1.1098726987838745,
-0.0967022180557251,
0.5120094418525696,
0.46676602959632874,
1.2812269926071167,
0.7981561422348022,
0.8974806070327759,
-0.42182016372680664,
0.5056146383285522,
0.7594497799873352,
-1.1703728437423706,
-0.03726853057742119,
0.06382652372121811,
-0.9320018887519836,
0.0983312800526619,
0.003901719581335783,
-0.9706897735595703,
0.7354069948196411,
0.16357630491256714,
-0.2299867421388626,
0.05524618923664093,
-0.6435341835021973,
0.6078805923461914,
-0.30337145924568176,
-0.6404469609260559,
0.09556692093610764,
-0.8401660323143005,
-0.0350969061255455,
-0.3322797417640686,
0.06945061683654785,
-0.10617843270301819,
-0.2568810284137726,
0.829772412776947,
-0.6998311281204224,
0.404747873544693,
-0.33627817034721375,
0.36057254672050476,
0.30002784729003906,
0.4465562105178833,
0.5125765800476074,
0.05724720284342766,
-0.05200639367103577,
0.09095150977373123,
0.4714515805244446,
-0.6631931066513062,
-0.36214202642440796,
0.783173143863678,
-0.630761444568634,
-0.17703770101070404,
-0.9342926740646362,
-0.3980199098587036,
-0.06286171078681946,
0.8080886602401733,
0.34798815846443176,
0.1609940230846405,
-0.13801456987857819,
0.02386489510536194,
0.4928012788295746,
0.16830487549304962,
0.5413675904273987,
0.27877309918403625,
-0.2569595277309418,
-0.946378767490387,
0.9548449516296387,
0.28785914182662964,
-0.011486644856631756,
0.5335683226585388,
0.05794193968176842,
-0.3480972349643707,
-0.6918884515762329,
-0.4470653831958771,
0.2511332035064697,
-0.9416483640670776,
-0.33306819200515747,
-0.7474048137664795,
0.17787675559520721,
-0.870877206325531,
-0.40633437037467957,
-0.0011145094176754355,
-0.4824577867984772,
-0.16724202036857605,
-0.13417339324951172,
0.5327703952789307,
0.5016560554504395,
-0.42375484108924866,
0.46886879205703735,
-0.7225042581558228,
0.345075786113739,
0.052806124091148376,
0.27637243270874023,
-0.27399569749832153,
-0.11577723920345306,
-0.3030983805656433,
-0.49276959896087646,
-0.5533409714698792,
-1.3234070539474487,
0.25801852345466614,
0.120235875248909,
0.493100106716156,
0.4927526116371155,
0.44349002838134766,
0.4982587695121765,
-0.4265102446079254,
0.6995941996574402,
0.2923007607460022,
-0.7721024751663208,
0.8547818660736084,
-0.6178916692733765,
0.12040090560913086,
0.969404935836792,
0.909264862537384,
0.14554256200790405,
-0.040179889649152756,
-0.7084611058235168,
-1.2387810945510864,
0.33132097125053406,
0.21249890327453613,
-0.3451707065105438,
0.05712981894612312,
0.17640772461891174,
0.14788207411766052,
0.2334212213754654,
-0.6685924530029297,
-0.1545301079750061,
-0.5637527704238892,
-0.42511460185050964,
0.24032573401927948,
-0.20596536993980408,
-0.4698098599910736,
-0.021679844707250595,
1.108782410621643,
-0.20601852238178253,
0.15759208798408508,
0.5933020114898682,
-0.25391489267349243,
-0.053876686841249466,
0.16253115236759186,
0.3163889944553375,
0.9342917799949646,
-0.6902987360954285,
0.3870382308959961,
-0.3805592656135559,
-0.6674204468727112,
0.08453147858381271,
0.6045297384262085,
-0.32384511828422546,
0.49004197120666504,
0.17173980176448822,
-0.011675049550831318,
0.155146524310112,
-0.6361427307128906,
0.20577242970466614,
0.21114550530910492,
0.03189178928732872,
-0.8813477754592896,
-0.29986801743507385,
-0.04211145639419556,
0.1517695188522339,
0.9517443776130676,
0.2532409429550171,
0.3851534128189087,
-0.31470194458961487,
0.12519460916519165,
0.06621675938367844,
-0.2783116400241852,
-0.48185399174690247,
0.7832595705986023,
0.18620242178440094,
-0.4078436493873596,
-0.16630509495735168,
-0.24985139071941376,
-0.29912251234054565,
0.05365890637040138,
0.2848283648490906,
1.1125308275222778,
-0.22637760639190674,
-0.01064744871109724,
0.3373980224132538,
0.40294408798217773,
0.26860812306404114,
0.15653595328330994,
-0.318136990070343,
-0.15853151679039001,
-0.005788592621684074,
-0.9380029439926147,
-0.6201833486557007,
-0.14405573904514313,
-0.4677763283252716,
0.1746833175420761,
-0.7201685309410095,
-0.3094926178455353,
0.5211061239242554,
0.2087584286928177,
-0.49105745553970337,
0.1672278791666031,
-0.09402502328157425,
0.9506170153617859,
-0.6345624923706055,
0.7342575192451477,
1.0483157634735107,
-0.9663482308387756,
-0.5083815455436707,
0.07003366947174072,
-0.04729589819908142,
-0.11811144649982452,
1.056460976600647,
-0.04220682382583618,
-0.4149135947227478,
0.11584629863500595,
-0.6637712121009827,
-0.8570366501808167,
1.1134623289108276,
0.3578186333179474,
0.09593146294355392,
0.11001722514629364,
-0.15863938629627228,
0.3665560483932495,
-0.2101747989654541,
0.4091942608356476,
-0.01517656072974205,
0.8062356114387512,
0.20980998873710632,
-0.46879616379737854,
0.32052546739578247,
-0.7553486227989197,
-0.01335042342543602,
0.1847616285085678,
-0.254011869430542,
0.5571935772895813,
0.07452162355184555,
-0.20067346096038818,
0.17882607877254486,
0.763298511505127,
0.3427228033542633,
0.5782666802406311,
0.3580232858657837,
0.17462986707687378,
0.8194122314453125,
-0.013367414474487305,
0.7100022435188293,
-0.34222328662872314,
-0.06316272169351578,
1.3227344751358032,
-0.3210253417491913,
0.8688607215881348,
0.882445752620697,
-0.09967425465583801,
0.9817754030227661,
0.8713055849075317,
-0.17432397603988647,
0.40393388271331787,
0.02061430737376213,
-0.293203204870224,
-0.15573935210704803,
-0.21948105096817017,
-0.4318271279335022,
-0.24191007018089294,
0.31527769565582275,
-0.6264709234237671,
-0.17401954531669617,
0.03213520720601082,
0.16939005255699158,
0.014510510489344597,
-0.1838371306657791,
0.6128352284431458,
-0.16403117775917053,
-0.604681670665741,
0.06831793487071991,
-0.2656187415122986,
0.2030145674943924,
-0.743042528629303,
0.056457459926605225,
0.2115689218044281,
0.0063521647825837135,
-0.5624117851257324,
-0.40726426243782043,
0.27958670258522034,
-0.02375468797981739,
-0.3322209417819977,
-0.0823402926325798,
0.923588752746582,
0.040342189371585846,
-0.36080485582351685,
0.14201949536800385,
0.19789725542068481,
0.5453874468803406,
-0.01525146048516035,
-0.4609737694263458,
-0.025876304134726524,
-0.37126463651657104,
-0.43595993518829346,
0.27560773491859436,
0.37443777918815613,
-0.14736491441726685,
0.49866771697998047,
1.1289498805999756,
0.23637785017490387,
0.19596441090106964,
-0.1946713924407959,
0.7789610028266907,
-0.5167070627212524,
-0.5135395526885986,
-0.4637140929698944,
0.29515013098716736,
-0.693158745765686,
-0.23661597073078156,
0.7074421644210815,
0.8650481104850769,
0.5235608220100403,
-0.12642183899879456,
1.286978006362915,
-0.49974408745765686,
0.8112170100212097,
0.29353776574134827,
0.8034583330154419,
-0.5477627515792847,
0.010312301106750965,
-0.5701574683189392,
-0.94444340467453,
-0.4363921582698822,
0.1620398312807083,
-0.5887365937232971,
-0.09115884453058243,
0.5935484170913696,
0.5512211322784424,
-0.08467692881822586,
-0.10530982911586761,
-0.1734224408864975,
-0.44722509384155273,
0.5498526096343994,
-0.3034350275993347,
0.27920860052108765,
-0.47905394434928894,
0.6904038786888123,
-0.08077969402074814,
-0.12462880462408066,
-0.5333564877510071,
-0.9019604325294495,
-0.5365749597549438,
-0.5143366456031799,
-0.4330284893512726,
-0.22709667682647705,
0.015173295512795448,
1.0776668787002563,
0.3383278250694275,
-0.9421644806861877,
0.05259758234024048,
-0.1580476611852646,
0.04388369247317314,
-0.11453408002853394,
-0.34985730051994324,
0.8103631734848022,
-0.4972669184207916,
-0.8354256749153137,
0.0422709584236145,
0.26236236095428467,
0.03975231572985649,
-0.20826338231563568,
0.06746026128530502,
-0.6663529276847839,
0.3799115717411041,
0.14721359312534332,
0.6951625347137451,
-0.2696274220943451,
-0.24386747181415558,
-0.30677542090415955,
-0.1529303640127182,
-0.28981757164001465,
0.9117454290390015,
-0.5719033479690552,
0.536475658416748,
0.862939715385437,
0.43818193674087524,
0.12172853946685791,
0.24794843792915344,
0.3697715401649475,
-0.4343835413455963,
0.03980393335223198,
0.23260003328323364,
0.34364375472068787,
0.33604127168655396,
-0.14407792687416077,
0.6691176891326904,
0.44274377822875977,
-0.6790433526039124,
-1.2923179864883423,
0.15293671190738678,
-0.9992714524269104,
-0.33057883381843567,
0.5713568329811096,
-0.2843569219112396,
-0.30644533038139343,
-0.43901488184928894,
-0.24832558631896973,
0.3522730767726898,
-0.43352949619293213,
0.5052289366722107,
0.3615422248840332,
-0.09967000782489777,
0.06342878937721252,
-0.34289926290512085,
0.4631415009498596,
0.04329676553606987,
-0.836705207824707,
-0.05311141908168793,
0.4768531620502472,
0.4190961420536041,
1.0241680145263672,
0.5217602252960205,
-0.11002598702907562,
0.39598339796066284,
0.1976267695426941,
0.6915242671966553,
-0.23321674764156342,
-0.18705889582633972,
0.37609949707984924,
0.6405960321426392,
0.031028077006340027,
-0.29943200945854187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03181v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03181v1 | Fine-Tuning with Divergent Chains of Thought Boosts Reasoning Through Self-Correction in Language Models | 2024-07-03T15:01:18 | 2024-07-03T15:01:18 | Haritz Puerto, Tilek Chubakov, Xiaodan Zhu, Harish Tayyar Madabushi, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Requiring a Large Language Model to generate intermediary reasoning steps has
been shown to be an effective way of boosting performance. In fact, it has been
found that instruction tuning on these intermediary reasoning steps improves
model performance. In this work, we present a novel method of further improving
performance by requiring models to compare multiple reasoning chains before
generating a solution in a single inference step. We call this method Divergent
CoT (DCoT). We find that instruction tuning on DCoT datasets boosts the
performance of even smaller, and therefore more accessible, LLMs. Through a
rigorous set of experiments spanning a wide range of tasks that require various
reasoning types, we show that fine-tuning on DCoT consistently improves
performance over the CoT baseline across model families and scales (1.3B to
70B). Through a combination of empirical and manual evaluation, we additionally
show that these performance gains stem from models generating multiple
divergent reasoning chains in a single inference step, indicative of the
enabling of self-correction in language models. Our code and data are publicly
available at https://github.com/UKPLab/arxiv2024-divergent-cot. | [
-0.43158432841300964,
-0.7390444278717041,
0.5408033132553101,
-0.06767323613166809,
-0.3224759101867676,
0.25350695848464966,
-0.40928444266319275,
-0.2936159372329712,
-0.1544497162103653,
0.5530328750610352,
-0.846889853477478,
-0.6048761010169983,
-0.4558172821998596,
0.097775898873806,
-0.25174760818481445,
0.9786076545715332,
-0.0028894857969135046,
-0.008418851532042027,
-0.1469765156507492,
-0.006006404757499695,
-0.5053533911705017,
-0.18691417574882507,
-0.7710745334625244,
-0.24345232546329498,
0.5443286299705505,
0.7108317613601685,
0.6604336500167847,
0.7550458312034607,
0.5577472448348999,
0.2935774624347687,
-0.15701787173748016,
0.832078754901886,
-0.532036542892456,
0.22238324582576752,
-0.5633682012557983,
-0.7747687697410583,
-0.5164589285850525,
-0.18240848183631897,
0.5026179552078247,
0.5067939162254333,
-0.15580222010612488,
0.09487618505954742,
-0.008516530506312847,
1.0734609365463257,
-0.8064020872116089,
-0.16396217048168182,
-0.781406581401825,
-0.13845294713974,
0.01229088194668293,
-0.3612377941608429,
-0.4836573004722595,
-0.36631515622138977,
-0.005288644228130579,
-0.2608102858066559,
0.6322004795074463,
-0.06690783053636551,
0.3954845666885376,
0.5375909209251404,
-0.418523907661438,
-0.34124955534935,
-0.7741288542747498,
0.7266108989715576,
-0.8981004357337952,
0.36371153593063354,
0.14817573130130768,
0.03836287185549736,
-0.24092285335063934,
-0.5522053241729736,
-0.41278567910194397,
0.03004477731883526,
-0.02830219455063343,
-0.015298644080758095,
-0.045237455517053604,
0.35215431451797485,
0.39109498262405396,
0.5020396113395691,
-0.12549588084220886,
0.3209612965583801,
-0.3723917007446289,
-0.052426066249608994,
0.8012170791625977,
0.34211692214012146,
-0.00034614387550391257,
0.17699532210826874,
-0.2232503592967987,
-0.24237588047981262,
-0.8254146575927734,
-0.14829279482364655,
0.507339596748352,
0.6276212334632874,
-0.24977032840251923,
0.4743629992008209,
-0.45366883277893066,
0.7019097208976746,
0.34816455841064453,
-0.05501611903309822,
-0.010043860413134098,
-0.4236341416835785,
-0.12067927420139313,
0.13571271300315857,
0.3743627965450287,
0.2097095102071762,
0.40992939472198486,
0.08013509213924408,
-0.3106846213340759,
0.011459768749773502,
0.19191280007362366,
-0.8457236886024475,
-0.6358553767204285,
0.15033367276191711,
-0.03552376851439476,
-0.09450608491897583,
-0.27940404415130615,
-0.4346567690372467,
-0.2983769178390503,
-0.6249799728393555,
0.11967599391937256,
-0.352266401052475,
-0.29392755031585693,
0.3778866231441498,
-0.06814362853765488,
0.047808703035116196,
0.5761246681213379,
-0.9565820097923279,
0.34025341272354126,
0.6994885802268982,
0.8190686702728271,
-0.25348010659217834,
-0.25380656123161316,
-0.5905941128730774,
-0.0020462777465581894,
-0.7014163732528687,
1.0773557424545288,
-0.5785472393035889,
-0.16058625280857086,
-0.21441034972667694,
-0.2377701848745346,
-0.09718611091375351,
-0.521162748336792,
0.4807400405406952,
-0.5879223346710205,
-0.03516083210706711,
-0.5679001808166504,
-0.8269206285476685,
-0.00010210377513431013,
0.25367435812950134,
-0.6673585176467896,
0.9075455665588379,
-0.18056035041809082,
-0.7701014876365662,
0.311513751745224,
-0.4442208707332611,
-0.4688616991043091,
-0.16229508817195892,
-0.22939027845859528,
-0.36336976289749146,
0.26876750588417053,
0.43344104290008545,
0.2983618378639221,
-0.243550643324852,
-0.08103350549936295,
-0.29129114747047424,
-0.4223482310771942,
-0.09943085163831711,
-0.6086079478263855,
0.6130722165107727,
0.13352160155773163,
-0.36483272910118103,
0.14606015384197235,
-0.6819283366203308,
0.303737610578537,
-0.20118655264377594,
-0.37612223625183105,
-0.3139244019985199,
0.034598078578710556,
-0.7619518637657166,
0.1685611456632614,
-0.020540447905659676,
-0.21670983731746674,
0.47813042998313904,
-0.4786754548549652,
0.2928520739078522,
0.9764477610588074,
0.007348045241087675,
0.2899155616760254,
-0.1759204864501953,
0.4617955982685089,
0.3246292471885681,
-0.019636040553450584,
-0.11320289224386215,
-0.3417697548866272,
-1.0628224611282349,
-0.49669209122657776,
0.4387550354003906,
0.17791979014873505,
-0.5161343812942505,
0.33744847774505615,
0.037496525794267654,
-0.3559968173503876,
-0.7875169515609741,
0.1574849933385849,
0.38302233815193176,
0.3942890763282776,
0.662510097026825,
-0.15757840871810913,
-0.3784341514110565,
-0.7156314253807068,
-0.43480294942855835,
-0.08429120481014252,
0.21037328243255615,
0.398527592420578,
0.33653610944747925,
-0.27640554308891296,
0.7049556970596313,
-0.49879738688468933,
0.12880900502204895,
-0.08753408491611481,
0.2579382359981537,
0.18007852137088776,
0.5578901171684265,
0.1294001042842865,
-0.27080491185188293,
-0.3153042793273926,
0.014685375615954399,
-0.38479360938072205,
0.01022789254784584,
-0.1918138712644577,
-0.4461275339126587,
0.3230774402618408,
0.5557018518447876,
-0.5171002149581909,
0.2870185673236847,
0.38303282856941223,
-0.3172128200531006,
0.7711606025695801,
-0.4552781283855438,
0.13900715112686157,
-0.6375385522842407,
-0.4632073640823364,
-0.36165285110473633,
-0.41104695200920105,
-0.32872018218040466,
0.14917223155498505,
0.35708898305892944,
0.6108633279800415,
-0.29234686493873596,
0.30794504284858704,
-0.6171995401382446,
0.1027887761592865,
-0.44420188665390015,
0.3399296998977661,
0.08996784687042236,
0.30403435230255127,
-0.14475122094154358,
0.9673142433166504,
0.6483114361763,
-0.9855118989944458,
0.17906694114208221,
0.017538607120513916,
-0.24807380139827728,
0.33825206756591797,
-0.510267972946167,
0.3488071858882904,
-0.03690705448389053,
0.09527024626731873,
-0.9322918057441711,
0.02568245306611061,
-0.1613813042640686,
0.06299252808094025,
0.35321322083473206,
-0.16476504504680634,
-0.5637458562850952,
-0.4429180920124054,
-0.2367497682571411,
0.4970676004886627,
0.24037493765354156,
-0.972781777381897,
0.28846174478530884,
-0.0407416895031929,
0.10777460038661957,
-0.6898229122161865,
-0.6113045811653137,
-0.27831754088401794,
-0.01302885077893734,
-0.3931507170200348,
0.2589183449745178,
-0.20615826547145844,
-0.13732920587062836,
-0.1612713783979416,
-0.5236222743988037,
0.2507569193840027,
0.1345222443342209,
-0.24406610429286957,
0.20264549553394318,
-0.2549471855163574,
0.6768578886985779,
0.6794993281364441,
0.0654580295085907,
0.05318419635295868,
-0.4534508287906647,
0.53116375207901,
-0.44911742210388184,
-0.4331711530685425,
-0.309266060590744,
-0.05267992988228798,
0.2945384085178375,
-0.25587984919548035,
0.6284283995628357,
0.3649653494358063,
-0.04979078844189644,
-0.7077010869979858,
-0.6035823225975037,
-0.4327743351459503,
-0.5324072241783142,
0.033720020204782486,
-0.5861285924911499,
-0.9266955852508545,
0.39055943489074707,
-0.5497598052024841,
-0.06479014456272125,
0.5329437851905823,
0.7482219934463501,
0.07753800600767136,
1.0353820323944092,
0.7297067642211914,
0.26149627566337585,
0.35713502764701843,
-0.4962204098701477,
0.33116111159324646,
-0.9073781967163086,
-0.06120140850543976,
-0.2987421154975891,
-0.31520748138427734,
-1.0378047227859497,
-0.7666164040565491,
0.09909643232822418,
0.45847561955451965,
-0.38138729333877563,
0.1660098135471344,
-0.6302476525306702,
1.0185688734054565,
0.5720203518867493,
0.2222316712141037,
0.6773397326469421,
-0.12888386845588684,
-0.6267954707145691,
0.3221326172351837,
-0.9050816893577576,
-0.5262951254844666,
1.002580165863037,
0.14848443865776062,
1.121863603591919,
0.07482761889696121,
0.9389702677726746,
0.2343108206987381,
0.13493070006370544,
-0.5935829877853394,
0.3991207778453827,
-0.28477743268013,
-0.5692975521087646,
-0.24916256964206696,
-0.5705901384353638,
-0.7289111614227295,
0.3563247323036194,
0.032167449593544006,
-0.5707510709762573,
0.4403942823410034,
0.272378534078598,
-0.5034434795379639,
0.4139341115951538,
-0.8810600638389587,
0.6205942630767822,
-0.3557673692703247,
-0.6107025146484375,
-0.6733444929122925,
-0.46789124608039856,
0.4347245395183563,
0.11384037137031555,
-0.13519641757011414,
-0.42466071248054504,
-0.02307416871190071,
0.3498208820819855,
-0.3482702970504761,
0.8176897764205933,
0.1529826819896698,
-0.3572908043861389,
0.4014575481414795,
0.33705922961235046,
0.664482057094574,
0.3964686095714569,
-0.17545564472675323,
0.2359856218099594,
0.07674235105514526,
-0.46998026967048645,
-0.5992512106895447,
0.979861855506897,
-0.809430718421936,
-0.9337857961654663,
-0.24701090157032013,
-0.8156211972236633,
-0.26685014367103577,
0.3231948912143707,
-0.0041531845927238464,
0.2980000972747803,
0.09694869071245193,
-0.09360203891992569,
0.7906489968299866,
0.03732125461101532,
0.4416376054286957,
0.4426122307777405,
-0.013404754921793938,
-0.2503007650375366,
0.43862593173980713,
-0.02640017494559288,
0.7108252048492432,
0.3643273413181305,
0.21500065922737122,
-0.3785640001296997,
-0.3910384774208069,
-0.4403633773326874,
0.32075974345207214,
-0.9243946671485901,
-0.5354722738265991,
-0.47276729345321655,
-0.2161540985107422,
-0.20045027136802673,
-0.05837869271636009,
-0.8438581228256226,
-0.7383534908294678,
-0.2152867168188095,
-0.25775209069252014,
0.5790653228759766,
0.7617073059082031,
-0.2803647518157959,
0.09100868552923203,
-0.4196525514125824,
0.28510764241218567,
0.4320775270462036,
0.649374783039093,
0.12048403173685074,
-0.41832664608955383,
-0.30961060523986816,
0.3384174108505249,
-0.4630878269672394,
-0.35516437888145447,
-0.004511524923145771,
0.14506064355373383,
0.43345215916633606,
0.31907376646995544,
0.2594026029109955,
1.1047946214675903,
-0.49784985184669495,
0.3890312910079956,
-0.011233193799853325,
-1.0926870107650757,
0.7610758543014526,
-0.17811715602874756,
0.5083498358726501,
0.582780122756958,
0.2816427946090698,
-0.13026177883148193,
-0.5387870669364929,
-0.5458201766014099,
-0.769382119178772,
0.7097935676574707,
0.20818719267845154,
0.04386014863848686,
-0.28050321340560913,
0.5417740941047668,
0.16542039811611176,
0.17731723189353943,
-0.31837978959083557,
-0.25116243958473206,
0.17949344217777252,
-0.14080575108528137,
0.054300419986248016,
-0.049006395041942596,
-0.3021980822086334,
-0.5543510913848877,
0.6448507308959961,
-0.44640082120895386,
0.03523862361907959,
0.4211016893386841,
0.040059417486190796,
-0.3823108673095703,
0.1670568734407425,
0.4998001754283905,
0.7572878003120422,
-0.12032942473888397,
0.4118109941482544,
0.4376946985721588,
-0.15665815770626068,
0.06613298505544662,
-0.15604902803897858,
-0.03878180310130119,
-0.2636878192424774,
0.4296354651451111,
0.8180579543113708,
-0.015189267694950104,
-0.5305494070053101,
0.14996717870235443,
-0.3364851772785187,
0.0035607446916401386,
0.20414160192012787,
0.5732315182685852,
0.10756167769432068,
0.6101969480514526,
-0.10976403951644897,
0.38979944586753845,
0.16617539525032043,
-0.3904173970222473,
0.13377952575683594,
0.41945868730545044,
-0.06651754677295685,
-0.03559485450387001,
0.4358694553375244,
0.20215362310409546,
-0.25136467814445496,
0.8214195966720581,
-0.20255905389785767,
-0.3131795823574066,
0.6297318339347839,
0.6310948729515076,
0.9434060454368591,
-0.13650576770305634,
0.2289295196533203,
0.540199339389801,
0.3894125819206238,
-0.2786860167980194,
0.2251092493534088,
-0.37967029213905334,
-0.7387668490409851,
-0.5766633152961731,
-0.6016279458999634,
-0.5164914727210999,
-0.2520320415496826,
-0.6109206080436707,
0.3472857177257538,
-0.40874719619750977,
-0.021863535046577454,
-0.11528494209051132,
0.07632923871278763,
-0.83089280128479,
0.2985503673553467,
0.258091539144516,
0.8764029741287231,
-0.4470122158527374,
0.8913396000862122,
0.30344220995903015,
-0.22928401827812195,
-0.8408469557762146,
0.40579551458358765,
-0.37405017018318176,
-0.5924493074417114,
0.3234834671020508,
0.22443103790283203,
-0.6867726445198059,
0.05760330706834793,
-0.44478172063827515,
-1.1188790798187256,
0.9888454079627991,
0.6166690587997437,
-1.1588516235351562,
0.13157552480697632,
-0.015650326386094093,
0.7681823372840881,
-0.5733375549316406,
0.3802405297756195,
0.9513472318649292,
0.04951167106628418,
0.0076369186863303185,
-0.6236432790756226,
0.20437371730804443,
0.08878869563341141,
0.0550655797123909,
0.27944648265838623,
-0.7880121469497681,
0.9515528678894043,
-0.8183492422103882,
-0.2951678931713104,
-0.11733680963516235,
0.6604814529418945,
0.5068832039833069,
0.0133619774132967,
0.45611897110939026,
0.5422875285148621,
1.2615454196929932,
0.04451729729771614,
1.0062650442123413,
-0.5002062916755676,
0.6312383413314819,
1.490325927734375,
-0.080685555934906,
0.7792877554893494,
0.35480061173439026,
-0.1489086151123047,
0.9652934074401855,
0.6283308267593384,
0.21721623837947845,
0.6073742508888245,
0.2715759575366974,
-0.1874665915966034,
-0.6628363728523254,
0.24764364957809448,
-0.33247798681259155,
0.3013208210468292,
0.3386397957801819,
-0.22067275643348694,
-0.17063920199871063,
-0.32406875491142273,
-0.17753826081752777,
0.13789916038513184,
-0.49484387040138245,
0.7440634369850159,
0.09779047966003418,
-0.8750931620597839,
0.9598041772842407,
-0.04693344980478287,
0.36226150393486023,
-0.17137888073921204,
-0.11550650000572205,
-0.42343053221702576,
0.6658908724784851,
-0.21822911500930786,
-0.7476139068603516,
0.2609459459781647,
0.03137018531560898,
-0.21448646485805511,
0.11127747595310211,
0.6181900501251221,
-0.48022446036338806,
-0.6966087222099304,
0.4873431622982025,
0.56568843126297,
-0.0632954016327858,
0.17163027822971344,
-0.6330041885375977,
-0.06878901273012161,
-0.1393360048532486,
-0.1817927360534668,
-0.09190891683101654,
0.8167014718055725,
-0.09489789605140686,
0.7544598579406738,
0.5062859058380127,
0.04444481059908867,
0.21557331085205078,
0.4945164620876312,
1.169121265411377,
-0.7579666972160339,
-0.3937024176120758,
-1.1157746315002441,
0.40935012698173523,
-0.11763041466474533,
-0.3535619378089905,
0.7672863006591797,
0.6452538371086121,
1.2589643001556396,
0.07445746660232544,
0.6565627455711365,
0.23935024440288544,
0.36123040318489075,
-0.6141380071640015,
0.24588371813297272,
-0.453185498714447,
0.6701327562332153,
-0.08638481050729752,
-0.4972653090953827,
-0.19298778474330902,
0.5223410725593567,
-0.5966305732727051,
0.14204390347003937,
0.8970397710800171,
0.946143388748169,
-0.13889089226722717,
0.09746115654706955,
0.20624738931655884,
0.41748976707458496,
0.3082578182220459,
0.34904083609580994,
0.8129501938819885,
-0.48380550742149353,
0.22272750735282898,
-0.5300235748291016,
-0.10699404031038284,
-0.05860278755426407,
-0.7297391891479492,
-1.2400797605514526,
-0.05437255650758743,
-0.483167439699173,
-0.24667057394981384,
0.3685321509838104,
0.9572551250457764,
0.7407414317131042,
-0.9423664808273315,
-0.23444080352783203,
-0.7164492011070251,
0.5848863124847412,
-0.5595605969429016,
-0.16550180315971375,
0.29786908626556396,
-0.9324780702590942,
-0.6507818698883057,
0.3915656507015228,
0.38208043575286865,
-0.2507665157318115,
-0.2125738561153412,
-0.04905286058783531,
-0.41438356041908264,
0.595295250415802,
0.609390914440155,
-0.2383032888174057,
-0.8940624594688416,
-0.3134000301361084,
-0.2465950846672058,
-0.01850816234946251,
0.18520121276378632,
0.9050984382629395,
-0.7803995609283447,
0.7061865329742432,
0.47192785143852234,
0.4019400477409363,
0.7459628582000732,
0.10014866292476654,
0.5397249460220337,
-0.9212781190872192,
-0.08121275901794434,
0.2181190401315689,
0.19916793704032898,
0.3359271287918091,
-0.6526858806610107,
0.5587502717971802,
0.05403054505586624,
-0.6316165924072266,
-0.7921783924102783,
0.41324010491371155,
-0.7013428807258606,
-0.36994150280952454,
0.9504278898239136,
-0.00870972964912653,
-0.09289509803056717,
0.22562457621097565,
-0.24908530712127686,
0.38387632369995117,
-0.314308226108551,
1.0906667709350586,
0.5194612741470337,
-0.3841334283351898,
-0.2015749216079712,
-0.15692082047462463,
0.5732489824295044,
0.5255225300788879,
-0.8029760122299194,
0.4489903450012207,
0.1812657117843628,
0.34588396549224854,
-0.13970597088336945,
0.3910207748413086,
0.1132943332195282,
0.34520360827445984,
0.09519094973802567,
-0.09500294923782349,
0.20299971103668213,
-0.6217822432518005,
-0.23436623811721802,
-0.23241619765758514,
0.19990022480487823,
0.025467736646533012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03169v1 | Investigating Decoder-only Large Language Models for Speech-to-text Translation | 2024-07-03T14:42:49 | 2024-07-03T14:42:49 | Chao-Wei Huang, Hui Lu, Hongyu Gong, Hirofumi Inaguma, Ilia Kulikov, Ruslan Mavlyutov, Sravya Popuri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large language models (LLMs), known for their exceptional reasoning
capabilities, generalizability, and fluency across diverse domains, present a
promising avenue for enhancing speech-related tasks. In this paper, we focus on
integrating decoder-only LLMs to the task of speech-to-text translation (S2TT).
We propose a decoder-only architecture that enables the LLM to directly consume
the encoded speech representation and generate the text translation.
Additionally, we investigate the effects of different parameter-efficient
fine-tuning techniques and task formulation. Our model achieves
state-of-the-art performance on CoVoST 2 and FLEURS among models trained
without proprietary data. We also conduct analyses to validate the design
choices of our proposed model and bring insights to the integration of LLMs to
S2TT. | [
-0.00799825880676508,
-0.5385002493858337,
0.7604174613952637,
0.1501087248325348,
-0.6418058276176453,
-0.2322624772787094,
-0.3789440393447876,
-0.5164245367050171,
-0.07497338950634003,
0.8720627427101135,
-0.36500075459480286,
-0.35230305790901184,
-0.9982865452766418,
0.12798863649368286,
-0.5533992648124695,
0.9475833177566528,
0.07526127249002457,
0.03053242713212967,
-0.008198357187211514,
0.3072411119937897,
-0.3898196518421173,
-0.42917153239250183,
-0.5031017065048218,
-0.29529526829719543,
0.31188687682151794,
0.32461684942245483,
0.4484384059906006,
0.7925137281417847,
0.31901800632476807,
0.1197289526462555,
-0.3533622920513153,
0.3601423501968384,
-0.6385973691940308,
0.15137217938899994,
-0.4508819580078125,
-0.41297367215156555,
-0.5475239753723145,
-0.38129502534866333,
0.702063262462616,
0.34480348229408264,
-0.03913186863064766,
0.1154046356678009,
0.16996203362941742,
0.17278127372264862,
-0.46778905391693115,
0.29994574189186096,
-0.7581372261047363,
-0.14190159738063812,
-0.13710764050483704,
-0.30691447854042053,
-0.8103722929954529,
0.0011207078350707889,
0.03499957546591759,
-0.17270879447460175,
-0.1937672346830368,
-0.13568371534347534,
0.3990938365459442,
0.5242757201194763,
-0.7187390327453613,
-0.2922934889793396,
-0.8000069856643677,
0.6508694291114807,
-0.6492826342582703,
0.6525506377220154,
0.23772796988487244,
0.1169225350022316,
-0.13199783861637115,
-0.5930985808372498,
-0.29773420095443726,
-0.082000233232975,
0.04352277144789696,
0.00884995050728321,
-0.4088098406791687,
0.04495013505220413,
-0.04330115392804146,
0.12012328952550888,
-0.6481459140777588,
0.2585698068141937,
-0.17033451795578003,
0.055758289992809296,
0.42902106046676636,
0.07890408486127853,
0.23243802785873413,
-0.16966861486434937,
-0.37964779138565063,
0.27358630299568176,
-0.5270521640777588,
-0.1735507696866989,
-0.1845892071723938,
0.6353381872177124,
-0.378767192363739,
0.880370020866394,
0.04268265143036842,
0.5435577630996704,
0.07809678465127945,
0.08954405039548874,
-0.08474048227071762,
-0.38198456168174744,
-0.3371805250644684,
0.14141394197940826,
0.8285254240036011,
-0.10719224065542221,
0.19134576618671417,
-0.6498277187347412,
-0.39962124824523926,
-0.05808044970035553,
0.044091857969760895,
-0.9495674967765808,
0.16203272342681885,
0.16389605402946472,
-0.14871789515018463,
-0.2819960415363312,
-0.5152584314346313,
-0.4031250476837158,
-0.29202303290367126,
-0.1374656707048416,
0.39192846417427063,
-0.14901678264141083,
-0.4649556279182434,
0.3828222453594208,
0.002640231978148222,
0.2754088044166565,
0.2123715728521347,
-0.9726478457450867,
0.34604525566101074,
0.8140609860420227,
0.8011292219161987,
-0.3235076665878296,
-0.022008297964930534,
-0.8407490253448486,
0.5841543078422546,
-0.4800102412700653,
0.7862654328346252,
-0.4384775161743164,
-0.3837296664714813,
0.10424106568098068,
-0.1188414990901947,
0.03786814212799072,
-0.3392563760280609,
0.7242268919944763,
-0.7297090888023376,
-0.40968236327171326,
-0.24551686644554138,
-0.6264766454696655,
0.06374957412481308,
0.04839363694190979,
-0.46495959162712097,
0.6897034049034119,
-0.03569803014397621,
-0.6322081089019775,
-0.21429665386676788,
-0.5765666365623474,
-0.6718267202377319,
0.138722762465477,
-0.2634362578392029,
-0.14063531160354614,
0.3033161461353302,
0.2125929594039917,
0.5491330623626709,
-0.5765965580940247,
0.40057530999183655,
0.13008607923984528,
-0.4583503007888794,
0.19313624501228333,
-0.39597275853157043,
0.49100083112716675,
0.24773354828357697,
-0.18238899111747742,
0.11195169389247894,
-0.3669208884239197,
0.013767706230282784,
0.33111435174942017,
-0.5187233090400696,
0.009108838625252247,
0.09479274600744247,
0.38296476006507874,
0.07172371447086334,
0.41712331771850586,
-0.441013902425766,
0.2843705117702484,
-0.47789591550827026,
0.7947389483451843,
0.46102702617645264,
-0.22594501078128815,
0.6234222650527954,
-0.10029008239507675,
0.29591676592826843,
-0.09263124316930771,
-0.3963523805141449,
-0.1688930094242096,
-0.2984698414802551,
-0.6027703285217285,
-0.49892857670783997,
0.3297432065010071,
0.6641286611557007,
-0.6403188705444336,
0.32697567343711853,
-0.7127211093902588,
-0.38263317942619324,
-0.415921688079834,
0.06519360840320587,
0.347606360912323,
0.25880274176597595,
0.4027126729488373,
0.2819083034992218,
-0.4172583818435669,
-0.784367024898529,
-0.28901636600494385,
0.26939937472343445,
-0.1473674327135086,
0.026628810912370682,
0.4826264977455139,
-0.4856679141521454,
0.6273488402366638,
-0.14463084936141968,
-0.32857492566108704,
-0.663159191608429,
-0.24077317118644714,
-0.05362981930375099,
0.44506803154945374,
0.1448526680469513,
-0.5078964233398438,
-0.3072206377983093,
0.3222551643848419,
-0.5831437110900879,
-0.0682644322514534,
-0.04542643204331398,
0.0030011048074811697,
0.1792457401752472,
0.5955228805541992,
-0.7312167882919312,
0.26592469215393066,
0.8306014537811279,
-0.1890813410282135,
0.3371365964412689,
-0.41431644558906555,
-0.06155404821038246,
-1.1973519325256348,
0.11996839195489883,
-0.051274918019771576,
-0.5323569774627686,
-0.8982776403427124,
0.14271420240402222,
0.25840461254119873,
-0.358273446559906,
-0.49234044551849365,
0.5787615180015564,
-0.2776375710964203,
-0.32766059041023254,
-0.4287671446800232,
0.3054136633872986,
0.02780659683048725,
0.48947715759277344,
0.229364275932312,
1.0524792671203613,
0.4319605529308319,
-0.45767101645469666,
0.054677482694387436,
0.5574719309806824,
-0.49388110637664795,
0.12850040197372437,
-0.7603063583374023,
0.5144132971763611,
-0.07547438144683838,
0.3585332930088043,
-0.9269123673439026,
-0.2735338509082794,
0.2532607316970825,
-0.363921582698822,
0.2737514078617096,
-0.19602495431900024,
-0.7538900971412659,
0.21081377565860748,
0.06483816355466843,
0.46185821294784546,
0.48844605684280396,
-0.6040653586387634,
0.6678590774536133,
0.2121913582086563,
-0.4076263904571533,
-0.14174950122833252,
-1.1316653490066528,
0.38962021470069885,
0.19826088845729828,
-0.7247024774551392,
0.5406138300895691,
0.12177176773548126,
0.073386050760746,
-0.2286350280046463,
-0.20030415058135986,
-0.03571160137653351,
-0.2670852541923523,
-0.07835724949836731,
-0.04791027680039406,
-0.2414632886648178,
0.08121092617511749,
0.568943977355957,
-0.16162173449993134,
-0.21916919946670532,
-0.41413986682891846,
0.5275507569313049,
0.08955676108598709,
-0.12999743223190308,
-0.870621383190155,
0.7671751379966736,
0.8099174499511719,
-0.7214787006378174,
0.5796422362327576,
0.2175242006778717,
-0.15212422609329224,
-0.3044604957103729,
-0.4790893495082855,
-0.04306574538350105,
-0.4588213264942169,
0.789694607257843,
-0.6641629934310913,
-1.0437370538711548,
0.23426559567451477,
-0.20678932964801788,
0.03783944621682167,
0.13041538000106812,
0.5888267159461975,
-0.04570205882191658,
1.1716185808181763,
0.4573327898979187,
0.11310531198978424,
0.42537155747413635,
-0.24306868016719818,
0.281196653842926,
-1.075027346611023,
-0.1972072720527649,
-0.5286694169044495,
-0.005598941817879677,
-0.4561752676963806,
-0.7630223631858826,
0.20536324381828308,
-0.12046565860509872,
-0.30004051327705383,
0.32567495107650757,
-0.3431968688964844,
0.2685810327529907,
0.13380342721939087,
0.12124846130609512,
0.3345501124858856,
0.2711988389492035,
0.3029272258281708,
0.12454777210950851,
-0.746002197265625,
-0.576729416847229,
0.8254718780517578,
0.4769655466079712,
0.5955148935317993,
0.24762874841690063,
0.6236465573310852,
0.21004842221736908,
-0.16516724228858948,
-0.9984042644500732,
0.6516629457473755,
-0.7405164837837219,
-0.3327222168445587,
-0.1974940150976181,
-0.44360166788101196,
-0.7447614669799805,
0.3988683819770813,
-0.05171167105436325,
-0.5810398459434509,
0.01695168763399124,
-0.08500911295413971,
-0.08179584890604019,
0.2191571444272995,
-0.43993818759918213,
0.7269796133041382,
-0.37371590733528137,
-0.33552464842796326,
-0.2736327052116394,
-0.2551725208759308,
0.19360965490341187,
-0.13872191309928894,
0.3701748847961426,
0.026832330971956253,
-0.2428840845823288,
0.527299702167511,
0.010906706564128399,
0.7258409857749939,
0.04613947495818138,
-0.5474686622619629,
0.13963812589645386,
0.2804276645183563,
0.9648259282112122,
-0.11807653307914734,
-0.35479238629341125,
0.30180543661117554,
0.1869868040084839,
-0.35525843501091003,
-0.4549975097179413,
0.6277075409889221,
-0.7895213961601257,
-0.6146732568740845,
-0.2128116488456726,
-0.7807555198669434,
-0.2830989956855774,
0.2995418608188629,
0.14711721241474152,
0.5509948134422302,
-0.01619303785264492,
0.23961320519447327,
0.8570816516876221,
-0.07285233587026596,
0.07428848743438721,
0.46150925755500793,
-0.17514708638191223,
-0.4194270670413971,
0.8137962818145752,
-0.022689754143357277,
0.5129354000091553,
0.6754570603370667,
0.16981001198291779,
-0.5413155555725098,
-0.8385273814201355,
-0.6262618899345398,
0.3845081925392151,
-0.7567121386528015,
-0.02901659719645977,
-0.7095109224319458,
-0.16257977485656738,
-0.5279253721237183,
-0.059717752039432526,
-0.5053356885910034,
-0.10441046208143234,
-0.5598077774047852,
-0.06516800075769424,
0.15511290729045868,
0.6371526122093201,
0.07223939895629883,
0.4211951196193695,
-0.7827833294868469,
0.4839092493057251,
0.28740960359573364,
0.22017882764339447,
-0.14227937161922455,
-0.8549438714981079,
-0.2994432747364044,
0.2051236778497696,
0.04348401352763176,
-0.7378924489021301,
0.20833903551101685,
0.13612911105155945,
0.1939263790845871,
0.160005584359169,
-0.0014968975447118282,
0.5520634651184082,
-0.7685052752494812,
0.6757587194442749,
0.14404289424419403,
-1.094712495803833,
0.4485628306865692,
-0.6282709240913391,
0.35013142228126526,
0.15952031314373016,
-0.20437537133693695,
-0.4248107075691223,
-0.2738639712333679,
0.15099626779556274,
-0.48524579405784607,
0.8965526819229126,
0.2759247124195099,
0.48972418904304504,
-0.044979870319366455,
0.5951471924781799,
-0.12322238087654114,
-0.03813880309462547,
-0.47717541456222534,
0.1534523069858551,
-0.08295714110136032,
-0.3516083061695099,
-0.21906480193138123,
-0.6194756031036377,
0.17175047099590302,
0.00004860968329012394,
0.4089621901512146,
0.09266829490661621,
0.2900834381580353,
-0.028964633122086525,
-0.27675798535346985,
-0.12309170514345169,
0.5782983899116516,
0.7827907800674438,
0.23236273229122162,
-0.10338837653398514,
0.2595970928668976,
0.1933787316083908,
-0.20468246936798096,
0.09578519314527512,
-0.026704352349042892,
-0.16695241630077362,
-0.1370038390159607,
0.27131223678588867,
0.9020528197288513,
0.5501442551612854,
-0.6713636517524719,
0.49130019545555115,
0.10113077610731125,
-0.28631114959716797,
-0.018459482118487358,
-0.028231894597411156,
0.40373024344444275,
0.5129379630088806,
0.1535879671573639,
0.1109820306301117,
-0.0028184091206640005,
-0.3967611491680145,
0.06611214578151703,
0.39421239495277405,
-0.3142926096916199,
-0.33697208762168884,
0.7632952928543091,
0.37668171525001526,
-0.48115965723991394,
0.340666264295578,
-0.022380458191037178,
-0.29472970962524414,
0.24638061225414276,
0.8691955804824829,
0.8586268424987793,
-0.24774880707263947,
-0.0607016384601593,
0.01707911305129528,
0.31035611033439636,
-0.31113532185554504,
0.24891528487205505,
-0.15743444859981537,
-0.4342791438102722,
-0.6884605884552002,
-0.5891761779785156,
-0.18837936222553253,
0.21335864067077637,
-0.606498658657074,
0.31648483872413635,
-0.027593443170189857,
-0.04657387733459473,
-0.2622826099395752,
-0.23313456773757935,
-0.47505950927734375,
0.22933363914489746,
0.3604578375816345,
1.0456866025924683,
-0.49052783846855164,
1.2321088314056396,
0.38434290885925293,
-0.21982382237911224,
-0.6986218690872192,
0.08491912484169006,
-0.4051913022994995,
-0.7958377599716187,
0.5721978545188904,
-0.11344030499458313,
-0.6474640965461731,
0.3931734263896942,
-0.2808060348033905,
-0.7786418795585632,
0.8698070645332336,
0.904872477054596,
-0.8506680130958557,
-0.2993159592151642,
0.5219767093658447,
0.2977624833583832,
-0.24562668800354004,
-0.13105206191539764,
0.595123291015625,
0.29240942001342773,
0.3329654335975647,
-0.9908267259597778,
0.009879584424197674,
-0.04153497517108917,
0.36460041999816895,
0.10691956430673599,
-0.4949951171875,
0.5266969203948975,
-0.24150139093399048,
-0.1850186139345169,
0.36612668633461,
0.6021727919578552,
0.023165857419371605,
-0.11667313426733017,
0.14767704904079437,
0.20932818949222565,
0.4820925295352936,
0.1716860979795456,
1.0900037288665771,
-0.20613276958465576,
0.26750075817108154,
1.2314668893814087,
-0.2529555857181549,
1.2241697311401367,
0.5917012095451355,
0.14539073407649994,
0.03840993717312813,
0.2954288721084595,
0.1709047108888626,
0.8916335701942444,
0.09742645919322968,
-0.3105502128601074,
-0.5187361836433411,
-0.18428996205329895,
-0.36788079142570496,
0.7218328714370728,
0.3744686245918274,
-0.31184813380241394,
-0.2516017258167267,
-0.012144370004534721,
-0.059755027294158936,
0.10878860950469971,
-0.35781100392341614,
0.8749067783355713,
0.24221141636371613,
-0.4198218584060669,
0.7593005895614624,
0.3631029725074768,
0.6892476081848145,
-0.6426854729652405,
0.18313749134540558,
-0.021422410383820534,
0.1437317430973053,
-0.2212873101234436,
-0.5138735771179199,
0.38444122672080994,
0.33508479595184326,
-0.2585974633693695,
-0.36182114481925964,
0.4786660671234131,
-0.7115282416343689,
-0.4685046970844269,
0.3440113663673401,
0.41566261649131775,
0.1556827872991562,
-0.2703487277030945,
-0.24953003227710724,
0.6228623390197754,
0.034719813615083694,
-0.1720387488603592,
0.3481810688972473,
0.40317514538764954,
0.27423733472824097,
0.47300127148628235,
0.43165886402130127,
0.10715490579605103,
-0.033280737698078156,
-0.0543447807431221,
0.5355870723724365,
-0.5050467252731323,
-0.5853556394577026,
-0.8629375696182251,
0.5704891681671143,
0.4456881582736969,
0.2134697586297989,
0.4206303060054779,
0.6501303911209106,
0.39112389087677,
-0.13166148960590363,
1.073731780052185,
0.3579804003238678,
0.37501418590545654,
-0.5393525958061218,
0.7524983882904053,
-0.6973391175270081,
0.2393941730260849,
0.08807692676782608,
-0.5470187067985535,
-0.1279221475124359,
0.4985349476337433,
-0.4728568494319916,
-0.3129678964614868,
0.3359880745410919,
0.7143640518188477,
-0.19800207018852234,
0.14993339776992798,
0.5107114315032959,
0.22819072008132935,
0.5996067523956299,
0.6411796808242798,
0.6277238726615906,
-0.5669726133346558,
0.8421454429626465,
0.39614999294281006,
-0.13448761403560638,
-0.39607948064804077,
-0.7255004644393921,
-0.9203701615333557,
-0.4044215977191925,
-0.2848903238773346,
-0.24721302092075348,
0.18869270384311676,
0.841052770614624,
0.5248203873634338,
-0.620637059211731,
-0.3720007538795471,
-0.23556889593601227,
-0.13957731425762177,
0.08293523639440536,
-0.01816052943468094,
0.38676753640174866,
-0.30222728848457336,
-0.8501572608947754,
0.7127215266227722,
0.40321972966194153,
-0.013773072510957718,
-0.019562460482120514,
-0.18119458854198456,
0.1865788698196411,
0.4263681471347809,
0.8371710777282715,
-0.14111709594726562,
-0.9952747225761414,
-0.22143636643886566,
0.1327916979789734,
-0.26477575302124023,
0.11631708592176437,
0.6689751744270325,
-0.32103097438812256,
0.4044070243835449,
0.34808051586151123,
0.9727504253387451,
0.7728695273399353,
-0.32469791173934937,
0.4374178946018219,
-0.5395179986953735,
0.18051958084106445,
0.2146426886320114,
0.1671365201473236,
0.21263790130615234,
-0.2045631855726242,
-0.02580941654741764,
-0.27020543813705444,
-0.38433837890625,
-1.001949667930603,
0.4902990460395813,
-1.0342154502868652,
-0.1683875471353531,
1.4333240985870361,
-0.02304227091372013,
0.03307965770363808,
0.13955843448638916,
-0.2593696713447571,
0.49955233931541443,
-0.42702290415763855,
0.3782583177089691,
0.38348519802093506,
0.0778057649731636,
-0.47276124358177185,
-0.6132083535194397,
0.25750532746315,
0.3013457953929901,
-0.6330491900444031,
0.4705616235733032,
0.18471716344356537,
0.4813401401042938,
-0.302188903093338,
0.5726264119148254,
0.00030788761796429753,
0.17862474918365479,
-0.13881228864192963,
-0.18804994225502014,
-0.3494482934474945,
-0.11008738726377487,
-0.3224160373210907,
0.10818025469779968,
0.05193976312875748,
-0.13380959630012512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03160v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03160v1 | SOS! Soft Prompt Attack Against Open-Source Large Language Models | 2024-07-03T14:35:16 | 2024-07-03T14:35:16 | Ziqing Yang, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang, Ahmed Salem | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Open-source large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly popular
among both the general public and industry, as they can be customized,
fine-tuned, and freely used. However, some open-source LLMs require approval
before usage, which has led to third parties publishing their own easily
accessible versions. Similarly, third parties have been publishing fine-tuned
or quantized variants of these LLMs. These versions are particularly appealing
to users because of their ease of access and reduced computational resource
demands. This trend has increased the risk of training time attacks,
compromising the integrity and security of LLMs. In this work, we present a new
training time attack, SOS, which is designed to be low in computational demand
and does not require clean data or modification of the model weights, thereby
maintaining the model's utility intact. The attack addresses security issues in
various scenarios, including the backdoor attack, jailbreak attack, and prompt
stealing attack. Our experimental findings demonstrate that the proposed attack
is effective across all evaluated targets. Furthermore, we present the other
side of our SOS technique, namely the copyright token -- a novel technique that
enables users to mark their copyrighted content and prevent models from using
it. | [
-0.06288032233715057,
-0.7022196054458618,
0.3211163878440857,
0.3505951166152954,
-0.4433809220790863,
-0.07100863009691238,
-0.17981499433517456,
-0.13538230955600739,
0.004835393745452166,
0.7233059406280518,
-0.49324920773506165,
-0.4426889419555664,
-0.6076071858406067,
0.2549571394920349,
-0.5405418872833252,
0.9742196798324585,
0.23926514387130737,
0.31238123774528503,
0.1149105578660965,
-0.26289406418800354,
-0.2545894980430603,
-0.6203973889350891,
-0.8056344985961914,
0.3491669297218323,
0.5720651149749756,
0.1784071922302246,
0.6099351644515991,
0.5178123712539673,
0.35285988450050354,
0.2725038528442383,
-0.27963846921920776,
-0.5727516412734985,
-0.462654709815979,
0.405319482088089,
-0.19494417309761047,
-0.4116412401199341,
-0.47104552388191223,
-0.24343498051166534,
0.6561613082885742,
0.24812956154346466,
-0.03785700723528862,
0.37933945655822754,
-0.006544269621372223,
0.6254672408103943,
-0.7972314357757568,
-0.17721761763095856,
-0.7324464917182922,
0.03599301725625992,
-0.6503148674964905,
0.04365475848317146,
-0.5467717051506042,
-0.3906387984752655,
-0.21446038782596588,
-0.4509536623954773,
-0.039674948900938034,
-0.00898338109254837,
0.5253008008003235,
0.08180135488510132,
0.017368676140904427,
-0.1814602017402649,
-0.27418309450149536,
0.836480975151062,
-0.8402690887451172,
0.24469350278377533,
0.07650516927242279,
0.43327096104621887,
-0.3928389251232147,
-0.6003971695899963,
-0.6064265966415405,
-0.30275964736938477,
0.315300852060318,
-0.17292703688144684,
-0.3976231515407562,
-0.04159415513277054,
0.6195386648178101,
0.1458708792924881,
-0.5303827524185181,
0.5337968468666077,
-0.35099509358406067,
-0.2430868148803711,
0.5226483345031738,
0.0694400817155838,
0.529406726360321,
-0.258138507604599,
-0.790005624294281,
0.2533127963542938,
-1.2106809616088867,
0.044759247452020645,
0.4600047469139099,
0.6513374447822571,
-0.2130862921476364,
0.7298852205276489,
-0.03580041974782944,
0.5217665433883667,
-0.19115298986434937,
0.058209266513586044,
-0.02384086512029171,
-0.06103866547346115,
-0.16587987542152405,
0.08951786905527115,
1.1515027284622192,
0.031179098412394524,
0.2523852586746216,
-0.08851264417171478,
-0.39786696434020996,
-0.18350201845169067,
-0.21787148714065552,
-0.863672137260437,
0.3975377380847931,
0.3091965913772583,
-0.422661691904068,
-0.4749084711074829,
-0.015679029747843742,
-0.8117796182632446,
-0.6855258941650391,
0.1321466714143753,
0.2508600354194641,
-0.3595274090766907,
-0.21344690024852753,
0.021895382553339005,
-0.07540247589349747,
0.10245826095342636,
0.1819498986005783,
-0.8797577023506165,
0.06615463644266129,
0.7267439365386963,
0.9499310255050659,
0.06298454850912094,
-0.2150179147720337,
-1.007678747177124,
0.3416841924190521,
-0.29362788796424866,
0.4429827332496643,
-0.37592265009880066,
-0.5928869843482971,
-0.010868060402572155,
-0.1481757014989853,
0.30562493205070496,
-0.25684258341789246,
0.122597336769104,
-0.9744666218757629,
-0.04112083837389946,
-0.2572273015975952,
-0.3478868007659912,
0.43932288885116577,
0.31709766387939453,
-0.9516083598136902,
0.8477437496185303,
0.0290322657674551,
-0.8739412426948547,
-0.00754450261592865,
-0.5682160258293152,
-0.4517277479171753,
0.20205315947532654,
-0.4437168836593628,
-0.2068929821252823,
0.20676672458648682,
0.003732680808752775,
0.4847903251647949,
-0.21769005060195923,
-0.006817950401455164,
-0.45697200298309326,
-0.2604057192802429,
0.5675370693206787,
-0.3502028286457062,
1.050925850868225,
0.5738738179206848,
-0.26561209559440613,
0.1673925518989563,
-0.7550384402275085,
-0.16724272072315216,
0.532167375087738,
-0.33308953046798706,
-0.4309951066970825,
-0.15836764872074127,
-0.14993490278720856,
0.1197807714343071,
0.5755850076675415,
-0.6348153352737427,
0.4797497093677521,
-0.4332346022129059,
0.6371213793754578,
1.0033974647521973,
-0.09055086970329285,
0.414276659488678,
0.07522737979888916,
0.7108601331710815,
-0.3074797987937927,
0.528985321521759,
-0.3223114609718323,
-0.3111336827278137,
-0.14721812307834625,
-0.6179642081260681,
0.4201301038265228,
0.457861065864563,
-0.7029514908790588,
0.20758745074272156,
-0.12402666360139847,
-0.6012322306632996,
-0.2759983539581299,
0.1940428912639618,
0.5400941967964172,
0.028154149651527405,
0.1948556751012802,
-0.19330960512161255,
-0.3465425670146942,
-0.38611194491386414,
-0.6670961380004883,
0.003926260396838188,
-0.36429083347320557,
0.20283420383930206,
0.346924364566803,
-0.022201834246516228,
0.9860849380493164,
-0.44893181324005127,
-0.3651272654533386,
-0.3726367652416229,
-0.062278423458337784,
0.11519598215818405,
0.525743305683136,
0.6974521279335022,
-0.467923104763031,
-0.47153857350349426,
-0.4478732645511627,
-0.6752323508262634,
-0.2652071714401245,
0.0441393181681633,
0.25375863909721375,
0.36255785822868347,
0.9387208819389343,
-0.6491255760192871,
0.35062187910079956,
0.4615822732448578,
-0.47120386362075806,
0.7801310420036316,
-0.04160735383629799,
-0.16657483577728271,
-0.9286292791366577,
0.014504236169159412,
-0.23077304661273956,
-0.025837372988462448,
-0.46475496888160706,
0.4142422676086426,
-0.05250705033540726,
-0.5772715210914612,
-1.0485785007476807,
0.7517064809799194,
-0.1628098487854004,
-0.00914721842855215,
0.13902191817760468,
0.1988823115825653,
-0.10077112913131714,
0.1262875646352768,
-0.294792503118515,
0.7711190581321716,
0.6622259020805359,
-0.3322424292564392,
0.18513567745685577,
0.08908738940954208,
-0.2625190019607544,
0.6000886559486389,
-0.8047549724578857,
0.523514449596405,
0.03783362731337547,
0.2342730015516281,
-0.7043147087097168,
0.07731921225786209,
0.38837534189224243,
-0.5319600105285645,
0.4293102025985718,
-0.3088315725326538,
-0.676313579082489,
0.026727555319666862,
-0.5008213520050049,
0.1309799700975418,
0.28848519921302795,
-0.41479459404945374,
0.6238828301429749,
0.1816374659538269,
-0.43454092741012573,
-0.7663883566856384,
-0.6940796375274658,
0.3259339928627014,
-0.1163647398352623,
-0.5778934955596924,
0.09141630679368973,
-0.1556074172258377,
-0.2892332971096039,
-0.10044553875923157,
-0.11429033428430557,
0.07040183991193771,
0.5355760455131531,
0.10646441578865051,
0.34919020533561707,
-0.23390282690525055,
-0.29123958945274353,
-0.18921935558319092,
-0.30624204874038696,
0.0412047915160656,
-0.4709473252296448,
0.5550631284713745,
-0.06678401678800583,
-0.5027791261672974,
-0.5687677264213562,
0.5649784207344055,
0.8946822881698608,
-0.2863942086696625,
0.7958470582962036,
0.2880636751651764,
-0.3481454849243164,
-0.2003544569015503,
-0.3966294527053833,
-0.27388715744018555,
-0.5310049057006836,
0.3804606795310974,
-0.26462599635124207,
-1.0937973260879517,
0.275433212518692,
-0.03643275797367096,
0.3227798044681549,
0.1892586499452591,
0.3710362911224365,
-0.11868499964475632,
1.1469248533248901,
0.3450305461883545,
-0.24880218505859375,
0.7253247499465942,
-0.2027062624692917,
0.12446866929531097,
-0.3916308879852295,
-0.3427615463733673,
-0.9159043431282043,
-0.14149083197116852,
-0.2876300513744354,
-0.05798555165529251,
0.1349087804555893,
0.18829751014709473,
-0.4079577922821045,
0.2727438509464264,
-0.21708941459655762,
0.6426488161087036,
0.5630893111228943,
-0.1735408902168274,
0.25805819034576416,
0.011288351379334927,
-0.06427963823080063,
-0.01869964599609375,
-0.6718982458114624,
-0.6167120933532715,
1.1486921310424805,
0.41459786891937256,
0.9970348477363586,
0.15871109068393707,
0.7570833563804626,
0.504753828048706,
-0.02088947221636772,
-0.4615701138973236,
0.9302902817726135,
-0.3340969681739807,
-0.6176332831382751,
-0.43723544478416443,
-0.4482812285423279,
-0.9415793418884277,
-0.09134513884782791,
-0.10223700106143951,
-0.7111120820045471,
-0.18099793791770935,
0.08478499948978424,
-0.6412244439125061,
0.4895978271961212,
-0.5722765326499939,
0.8588557243347168,
-0.35896849632263184,
-0.2651410400867462,
-0.1912122517824173,
-0.7003924250602722,
0.10081546008586884,
-0.1686076670885086,
0.6146994829177856,
-0.1573020964860916,
-0.025203149765729904,
0.8972523808479309,
-0.73213130235672,
0.9609938263893127,
-0.445981502532959,
-0.015384341590106487,
0.3517845571041107,
0.4533824622631073,
0.7314226627349854,
0.06132033094763756,
-0.010491007938981056,
0.5503944158554077,
-0.0069888439029455185,
-0.5316813588142395,
-0.5546888709068298,
0.580036997795105,
-0.6093997955322266,
-0.7119910717010498,
-0.4869903326034546,
-0.06632299721240997,
0.12538844347000122,
0.34276509284973145,
0.3201049864292145,
0.4684884250164032,
-0.01460035890340805,
0.20417147874832153,
0.5669707655906677,
-0.26956942677497864,
0.40630975365638733,
0.6879041194915771,
-0.13812927901744843,
-0.49377351999282837,
1.1195974349975586,
0.11170019209384918,
0.5491930246353149,
-0.0003321202821098268,
0.47214093804359436,
-0.14763501286506653,
-0.7240185737609863,
-0.47477883100509644,
0.28128954768180847,
-0.6310042142868042,
-0.34264862537384033,
-0.4341880977153778,
-0.22784578800201416,
-0.6986211538314819,
-0.27064669132232666,
-0.4498944580554962,
-0.5966765284538269,
-0.480741024017334,
0.1482415646314621,
0.35189083218574524,
0.7809476852416992,
0.21787132322788239,
0.49327796697616577,
-1.1396958827972412,
0.13461188971996307,
0.37551149725914,
0.41507625579833984,
-0.17691300809383392,
-0.4963438808917999,
-0.18247871100902557,
-0.2981868088245392,
-0.33590325713157654,
-0.9626439809799194,
0.07076626271009445,
-0.10817334800958633,
0.40683192014694214,
0.5918947458267212,
0.25096166133880615,
0.043105144053697586,
-0.5891059637069702,
1.0975134372711182,
0.5257118940353394,
-1.162862777709961,
0.5241165161132812,
-0.20434634387493134,
0.15314064919948578,
0.5300513505935669,
0.29262250661849976,
-0.3653261959552765,
-0.506248950958252,
-0.6713935732841492,
-0.8013118505477905,
0.7576302289962769,
0.04595310986042023,
0.31882691383361816,
0.018906116485595703,
0.1842171549797058,
0.12450718879699707,
0.40588364005088806,
-0.6544851064682007,
-0.16293199360370636,
-0.24278783798217773,
-0.23902465403079987,
0.4256571829319,
-0.47039830684661865,
0.0027443093713372946,
0.34444302320480347,
0.6905074119567871,
0.04672161862254143,
-0.20050595700740814,
-0.1219562441110611,
-0.049718569964170456,
0.034488603472709656,
0.6438950896263123,
0.32610514760017395,
0.12975706160068512,
0.1625097543001175,
0.15690672397613525,
0.2777162194252014,
-0.5795015096664429,
0.10640113055706024,
0.020196301862597466,
-0.40061092376708984,
-0.04272424802184105,
0.12070949375629425,
0.5365332365036011,
0.3541066646575928,
-0.8869714140892029,
0.9726462960243225,
-0.11127804219722748,
0.06415492296218872,
-0.18100082874298096,
0.07833388447761536,
-0.06549620628356934,
0.5055103302001953,
0.201398566365242,
0.11395859718322754,
-0.23373886942863464,
-0.25896161794662476,
-0.161488875746727,
0.5990108251571655,
-0.47043246030807495,
-0.5036460757255554,
0.5564890503883362,
0.17772258818149567,
-0.5730853080749512,
0.39228883385658264,
-0.15621547400951385,
-0.6795279383659363,
0.4130110740661621,
0.6250678300857544,
0.8185172080993652,
-0.5501565337181091,
-0.17456473410129547,
-0.05746889486908913,
0.4062429666519165,
-0.10174636542797089,
0.5710744857788086,
0.0071161286905407906,
-0.3185701370239258,
-0.2335750162601471,
-0.5666893720626831,
-0.47408345341682434,
0.4013752043247223,
-0.4828468859195709,
0.7383666634559631,
-1.0560048818588257,
-0.22037985920906067,
-0.396919310092926,
-0.3598734438419342,
-0.27411386370658875,
0.053311385214328766,
0.3042524755001068,
1.2242687940597534,
-0.690116286277771,
0.5969299077987671,
0.2984766364097595,
-0.23434410989284515,
-0.6296215057373047,
-0.18339413404464722,
0.1459907591342926,
-0.6475459933280945,
0.7263117432594299,
0.09197339415550232,
-0.07036454975605011,
0.16807787120342255,
-0.8377933502197266,
-0.8519418239593506,
0.7332166433334351,
0.8398303985595703,
-0.68871009349823,
-0.17210069298744202,
0.13552969694137573,
0.0017729818355292082,
0.0869697779417038,
-0.17508715391159058,
0.518358051776886,
0.3187209665775299,
0.04916776344180107,
-0.48180121183395386,
0.24486495554447174,
-0.09458316117525101,
-0.31706666946411133,
0.09084086865186691,
-0.632740318775177,
0.8239283561706543,
-0.2797583043575287,
-0.4660632610321045,
0.10530299693346024,
0.7070410847663879,
0.7017145156860352,
0.2640112042427063,
0.837938666343689,
0.3364138901233673,
0.5687339901924133,
0.06093895062804222,
0.7885294556617737,
-0.28663456439971924,
0.03714624047279358,
1.0013619661331177,
-0.4398460388183594,
0.9672531485557556,
0.6436784267425537,
-0.2097664624452591,
0.3450539708137512,
0.27147191762924194,
-0.13949954509735107,
0.4753427803516388,
0.45342516899108887,
-0.2767549753189087,
-0.0032048106659203768,
-0.09403319656848907,
-0.6793306469917297,
0.15915867686271667,
0.33286914229393005,
-0.13897158205509186,
-0.07358615845441818,
0.17611360549926758,
0.49075356125831604,
-0.006324195768684149,
-0.34656545519828796,
0.6915842890739441,
0.38454389572143555,
-0.25038012862205505,
0.3736826479434967,
0.11647772043943405,
0.5911040902137756,
-1.0427334308624268,
0.39204251766204834,
0.03165511041879654,
-0.029155008494853973,
-0.24946165084838867,
-0.45706117153167725,
0.020127050578594208,
0.46105802059173584,
0.08125458657741547,
-0.1744132786989212,
0.6034319400787354,
-0.12177900969982147,
-0.14110645651817322,
0.23699696362018585,
0.05106547102332115,
0.04261958226561546,
-0.19025656580924988,
-0.7060614824295044,
0.47112295031547546,
-0.2595229744911194,
-0.5959175229072571,
0.5529530048370361,
0.24141329526901245,
-0.18676041066646576,
0.5857344269752502,
0.8481733798980713,
0.4564145505428314,
0.10013002902269363,
0.2656194269657135,
0.9009761810302734,
-0.6025761961936951,
-0.9380784034729004,
-1.2166134119033813,
0.2650558352470398,
-0.07386593520641327,
-0.04057200625538826,
0.9810794591903687,
0.5097565054893494,
0.7148013114929199,
-0.008921978995203972,
1.0130730867385864,
0.2023703157901764,
0.29362329840660095,
-0.8013774752616882,
0.9343689680099487,
-0.5087059140205383,
0.6036837697029114,
-0.40268173813819885,
-0.5169613361358643,
-0.42398256063461304,
0.007254583295434713,
-0.28422611951828003,
-0.08437419682741165,
0.6114292144775391,
0.7144652009010315,
0.33744969964027405,
0.30557239055633545,
0.07042849063873291,
0.2634454667568207,
0.616364598274231,
0.17885276675224304,
1.1646945476531982,
0.03157608583569527,
0.7625632286071777,
0.1872837245464325,
-0.45633137226104736,
-0.3736300766468048,
-1.0839910507202148,
-1.0738904476165771,
-0.12533175945281982,
-0.22313420474529266,
-0.6836296916007996,
0.0269910991191864,
1.1076918840408325,
0.43289700150489807,
-0.9276549220085144,
-0.15582461655139923,
0.09799224883317947,
-0.08406687527894974,
-0.0792967677116394,
-0.12523706257343292,
0.47035765647888184,
-0.3296980559825897,
-0.4123423099517822,
0.6377469301223755,
0.30704614520072937,
0.22075830399990082,
-0.5291664600372314,
0.03242188319563866,
0.05616376921534538,
0.2873896062374115,
0.18541209399700165,
0.4702841341495514,
-0.6043366193771362,
-0.04498961567878723,
0.32410451769828796,
-0.4039575457572937,
-0.2586525082588196,
1.0588223934173584,
-0.4993308484554291,
0.3076528012752533,
0.585457980632782,
0.6641954779624939,
0.08631539344787598,
-0.4124413728713989,
0.3427015542984009,
-0.8933519124984741,
0.24644628167152405,
0.2916494905948639,
0.4790511727333069,
0.43775704503059387,
-0.4040919840335846,
0.03255614638328552,
0.605638861656189,
-0.21767306327819824,
-1.1887491941452026,
0.28602156043052673,
-0.6453028917312622,
-0.5397242307662964,
1.0681204795837402,
-0.3936750590801239,
-0.5570979714393616,
-0.16259188950061798,
-0.2452383041381836,
0.17724783718585968,
-0.48479151725769043,
0.6263646483421326,
0.2839307188987732,
0.5808346271514893,
0.5668940544128418,
-0.43867385387420654,
0.3201276957988739,
0.3998929262161255,
-0.5720729827880859,
0.2428463250398636,
0.1361086070537567,
0.3446941375732422,
0.07422105222940445,
0.5659207105636597,
-0.4067740738391876,
0.2902498245239258,
-0.19933071732521057,
-0.01041129045188427,
-0.48811936378479004,
-0.44027286767959595,
-0.732335090637207,
0.443671852350235,
0.11069875210523605,
-0.20583704113960266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03157v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03157v1 | Let the Code LLM Edit Itself When You Edit the Code | 2024-07-03T14:34:03 | 2024-07-03T14:34:03 | Zhenyu He, Jun Zhang, Shengjie Luo, Jingjing Xu, Zhi Zhang, Di He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | In this work, we investigate a typical scenario in code generation where a
developer edits existing code in real time and requests a code assistant, e.g.,
a large language model, to re-predict the next token or next line on the fly.
Naively, the LLM needs to re-encode the entire KV cache to provide an accurate
prediction. However, this process is computationally expensive, especially when
the sequence length is long. Simply encoding the edited subsequence and
integrating it to the original KV cache meets the temporal confusion problem,
leading to significantly worse performance. We address this efficiency and
accuracy trade-off by introducing \underline{\textbf{Positional
\textbf{I}ntegrity \textbf{E}ncoding} (PIE). Building upon the rotary
positional encoding, PIE first removes the rotary matrices in the Key cache
that introduce temporal confusion and then reapplies the correct rotary
matrices. This process ensures that positional relationships between tokens are
correct and requires only a single round of matrix multiplication. We validate
the effectiveness of PIE through extensive experiments on the RepoBench-C-8k
dataset, utilizing DeepSeek-Coder models with 1.3B, 6.7B, and 33B parameters.
Our evaluation includes three real-world coding tasks: code insertion, code
deletion, and multi-place code editing. Results demonstrate that PIE reduces
computational overhead by over 85% compared to the standard full recomputation
approach across all model sizes and tasks while well approximating the model
performance. | [
-0.11367622017860413,
-0.5884666442871094,
0.4037027359008789,
0.4770444929599762,
-0.4604807198047638,
0.2949928045272827,
-0.18517984449863434,
-0.5850117206573486,
0.2763015031814575,
0.5742638111114502,
-0.5134972333908081,
-0.4391111135482788,
-0.29788538813591003,
-0.005573131609708071,
-0.42540863156318665,
0.4208624064922333,
-0.1944400817155838,
-0.00999631267040968,
-0.15179072320461273,
0.15201205015182495,
-0.6692349910736084,
-0.6272518634796143,
-0.2826242744922638,
-0.00639392901211977,
0.24482765793800354,
0.6219228506088257,
0.697733998298645,
0.8747900128364563,
0.4854627549648285,
0.30258265137672424,
-0.007943597622215748,
0.27634263038635254,
-0.4013991355895996,
0.3344464600086212,
-0.02713804505765438,
-0.7062094211578369,
-0.7034051418304443,
-0.24618250131607056,
0.4056435227394104,
0.23884643614292145,
-0.13472819328308105,
0.08087035268545151,
-0.31523945927619934,
0.9396990537643433,
-0.856340229511261,
0.10231826454401016,
-0.7665338516235352,
0.23680076003074646,
-0.17339099943637848,
-0.27125638723373413,
-0.7104189991950989,
-0.3657582700252533,
-0.4819425642490387,
-0.553794801235199,
0.21557173132896423,
-0.24713388085365295,
0.5001075863838196,
0.5844634175300598,
0.1131855770945549,
-0.2580036222934723,
-0.8660832643508911,
0.46698421239852905,
-0.6682453751564026,
0.6242658495903015,
0.2812831699848175,
0.1336764097213745,
-0.22454938292503357,
-0.7452057003974915,
-0.6523457169532776,
-0.1416957825422287,
0.12810489535331726,
0.23353244364261627,
-0.25613436102867126,
0.13443133234977722,
0.2752726972103119,
0.22168630361557007,
-0.2848847210407257,
0.32700932025909424,
-0.486488938331604,
-0.19540581107139587,
0.5353401899337769,
0.3396987020969391,
0.2194209098815918,
-0.17727793753147125,
-0.019787855446338654,
-0.020433194935321808,
-0.9505329728126526,
0.04027256742119789,
0.3064975142478943,
0.006785323843359947,
-0.015780702233314514,
0.8459886908531189,
-0.15667089819908142,
0.5464403629302979,
0.6164491176605225,
0.12035743147134781,
0.10586067289113998,
-0.39044928550720215,
-0.5446938276290894,
0.2967456579208374,
0.42976948618888855,
0.40619972348213196,
0.1891220211982727,
-0.17547571659088135,
-0.07921791821718216,
0.15680474042892456,
0.7506301403045654,
-0.6888328194618225,
-0.4872179329395294,
0.3316269516944885,
-0.15218360722064972,
-0.2759566903114319,
0.024554936215281487,
-0.5498360395431519,
-0.2149529606103897,
-0.4866034984588623,
-0.0750337541103363,
-0.2808857262134552,
0.13545912504196167,
0.240340918302536,
0.2679276764392853,
0.10054457187652588,
0.3866058886051178,
-0.6076282262802124,
-0.17059727013111115,
0.6975837349891663,
0.599686861038208,
0.12593360245227814,
-0.29731273651123047,
-0.6150721907615662,
0.12451138347387314,
-0.628197431564331,
0.4754621088504791,
-0.6501655578613281,
-0.6105406880378723,
-0.3812117278575897,
-0.08200879395008087,
0.06644368916749954,
-0.445691853761673,
0.06570060551166534,
-0.9363145232200623,
-0.18233706057071686,
-0.23536568880081177,
-0.4205787777900696,
0.22600142657756805,
-0.12885607779026031,
-0.7266682982444763,
1.00531804561615,
0.12415337562561035,
-0.5970341563224792,
0.5971407890319824,
-0.4117110073566437,
-0.3573448956012726,
-0.39064106345176697,
-0.1165921613574028,
-0.667007327079773,
0.3917456567287445,
0.6041582822799683,
0.31389838457107544,
0.052681077271699905,
0.2003779262304306,
-0.19247747957706451,
-0.5788338780403137,
0.3138308525085449,
-0.2752019762992859,
0.5204648971557617,
0.3438619077205658,
-0.2812667489051819,
0.027473822236061096,
-0.5530970692634583,
-0.025019317865371704,
-0.22184902429580688,
-0.6691427826881409,
0.0617235004901886,
-0.19827473163604736,
-0.35848450660705566,
0.36138081550598145,
0.12856434285640717,
-0.610473096370697,
0.7052865028381348,
-0.5213675498962402,
0.2925049364566803,
0.9580193758010864,
0.04252903163433075,
0.6646725535392761,
-0.11368661373853683,
0.8804494738578796,
0.15446297824382782,
0.3383949398994446,
-0.25568389892578125,
-0.26322686672210693,
-0.9620285630226135,
-0.22418181598186493,
0.5273333191871643,
0.5603143572807312,
-0.8205515146255493,
0.16205193102359772,
-0.41748571395874023,
-0.5175555944442749,
-0.7818707227706909,
0.305778831243515,
0.5996807813644409,
0.19586984813213348,
0.4420742392539978,
-0.39873915910720825,
-0.8559410572052002,
-0.6224433183670044,
-0.22811412811279297,
-0.15030312538146973,
0.1830325573682785,
0.12069988995790482,
0.14371679723262787,
-0.2672078013420105,
1.0268853902816772,
-0.3206559717655182,
0.2724705934524536,
-0.11444392055273056,
0.06633607298135757,
0.153080016374588,
0.7202601432800293,
0.14313052594661713,
-0.4014531970024109,
-0.5439881086349487,
-0.010033546946942806,
-0.6361691355705261,
-0.2661992013454437,
-0.4751782715320587,
-0.25101619958877563,
0.6260056495666504,
0.8112278580665588,
-0.69868403673172,
0.8519290685653687,
0.3774709701538086,
0.02474251575767994,
0.6941668391227722,
-0.48930999636650085,
0.2688125967979431,
-0.7566813826560974,
-0.02737542800605297,
-0.6020030379295349,
-0.2107943743467331,
-0.3103882074356079,
0.28610163927078247,
0.48357391357421875,
0.029178449884057045,
-0.6310880780220032,
0.2825549840927124,
-0.6952133178710938,
-0.32662203907966614,
-0.17043739557266235,
-0.11299446225166321,
0.027023591101169586,
0.5768055319786072,
-0.1563158929347992,
1.0827220678329468,
0.07893039286136627,
-0.602158784866333,
0.17353574931621552,
-0.0017691674875095487,
-0.43212294578552246,
0.22750809788703918,
-0.510065495967865,
0.4532022774219513,
-0.2163408100605011,
0.288517028093338,
-0.688554048538208,
0.03833550214767456,
0.11109551787376404,
-0.5711520314216614,
0.5398052930831909,
-0.41678041219711304,
-0.5417008399963379,
-0.277732789516449,
-0.1521037220954895,
0.5379871726036072,
0.3576509654521942,
-0.5813412070274353,
0.5220237970352173,
0.1945890337228775,
0.05538816750049591,
-0.9276250600814819,
-0.8146792054176331,
0.24257290363311768,
0.030510907992720604,
-0.6004955768585205,
0.40031903982162476,
0.07477354258298874,
-0.16001485288143158,
-0.038804832845926285,
-0.4237205386161804,
0.0317167229950428,
0.041440218687057495,
0.4002302587032318,
0.2090621143579483,
-0.1227046474814415,
0.20029619336128235,
0.27647584676742554,
-0.5484716296195984,
-0.2199450433254242,
-0.19245076179504395,
0.48985064029693604,
0.21940787136554718,
-0.6753643155097961,
-0.5348348021507263,
0.11404822766780853,
0.823564350605011,
-0.2605271339416504,
0.39902007579803467,
0.3477480709552765,
-0.14425387978553772,
-0.031734928488731384,
-0.6590678095817566,
0.15305006504058838,
-0.4791220426559448,
0.3947819769382477,
-0.5160751342773438,
-0.7402440309524536,
0.4924231469631195,
0.13221599161624908,
0.12806691229343414,
0.2921164631843567,
0.5025052428245544,
-0.24133756756782532,
0.6860333681106567,
0.7285218834877014,
-0.28494054079055786,
0.5151579976081848,
-0.35763511061668396,
0.34694090485572815,
-0.8440714478492737,
-0.22221916913986206,
-0.4417352080345154,
-0.37074726819992065,
-0.5688753128051758,
-1.006500482559204,
0.15991802513599396,
0.5138825178146362,
-0.2377246469259262,
0.5931833982467651,
-0.5372946262359619,
0.7294076681137085,
0.3877895772457123,
0.17031922936439514,
0.28506624698638916,
-0.1710466891527176,
-0.2659773826599121,
-0.273073673248291,
-0.8600367903709412,
-0.23844119906425476,
1.091948390007019,
0.10530851781368256,
1.08909273147583,
0.04630367085337639,
0.7483605146408081,
0.3892858028411865,
0.27960339188575745,
-0.37239211797714233,
0.41751131415367126,
-0.12081919610500336,
-0.3192109763622284,
-0.08449723571538925,
-0.2039276659488678,
-0.7626397609710693,
-0.0019053382566198707,
0.04725164920091629,
-0.5291834473609924,
0.5224688649177551,
0.5528791546821594,
-0.4458976686000824,
0.4799755811691284,
-0.8132752180099487,
0.6247056126594543,
-0.13110344111919403,
-0.39407533407211304,
-0.3530236780643463,
-0.46370580792427063,
0.17462585866451263,
-0.22045385837554932,
-0.005771202500909567,
0.2409093976020813,
-0.018654637038707733,
0.31958895921707153,
-0.755753755569458,
0.9982427358627319,
-0.13106781244277954,
0.0758325457572937,
0.3565509021282196,
0.6014711260795593,
0.8908236622810364,
0.1945730745792389,
-0.19466815888881683,
0.08006961643695831,
-0.3374726474285126,
-0.4059731364250183,
-0.6919180154800415,
0.7804358005523682,
-0.7058221697807312,
-0.5662160515785217,
-0.11953070759773254,
-0.2338649183511734,
0.03808539733290672,
-0.016099194064736366,
0.3312768340110779,
0.46282029151916504,
0.02228458598256111,
0.18489542603492737,
0.38373810052871704,
-0.46057918667793274,
0.5517309308052063,
0.3083382248878479,
-0.17196796834468842,
-0.20584657788276672,
0.574591875076294,
0.017346054315567017,
0.4219188392162323,
0.6997804045677185,
-0.13313202559947968,
-0.1906353235244751,
-0.46096768975257874,
-0.6230248212814331,
0.12295252084732056,
-0.8190715909004211,
-0.3360169231891632,
-0.7987082004547119,
-0.06718085706233978,
-0.2644045352935791,
-0.7731314301490784,
-0.8418647050857544,
-0.6752438545227051,
-0.21504753828048706,
-0.30373141169548035,
0.3636334240436554,
0.6387503147125244,
-0.27549517154693604,
0.4028553366661072,
-0.9160504937171936,
0.14781416952610016,
0.13998600840568542,
0.317558616399765,
0.06087726354598999,
-0.3578946590423584,
-0.5531492829322815,
0.10462822765111923,
-0.1660711020231247,
-0.6780744791030884,
0.38753896951675415,
-0.09889595955610275,
0.3806725740432739,
-0.11662662774324417,
-0.09282400459051132,
1.28365957736969,
-0.4738166034221649,
0.7698473334312439,
0.08486288785934448,
-1.2634923458099365,
0.4439893960952759,
0.0699332058429718,
0.6059565544128418,
0.5618037581443787,
-0.19715890288352966,
-0.6590138077735901,
-0.5005456209182739,
-0.45084208250045776,
-0.9077702760696411,
0.6543386578559875,
0.2157755345106125,
-0.044487278908491135,
-0.06669094413518906,
0.5721583962440491,
-0.030572760850191116,
0.17001475393772125,
-0.48762449622154236,
-0.09453333914279938,
-0.24953593313694,
0.02038080058991909,
0.12961238622665405,
-0.4686039984226227,
0.4538567066192627,
-0.20697353780269623,
0.47051411867141724,
0.05828395113348961,
0.6837947964668274,
0.39298495650291443,
-0.5758066773414612,
-0.38520270586013794,
0.24757114052772522,
0.742163896560669,
1.032928466796875,
0.011235863901674747,
0.017945418134331703,
0.3201303482055664,
-0.518913745880127,
0.06792785227298737,
-0.4462262988090515,
0.11508765816688538,
-0.02629469707608223,
0.561954140663147,
0.4256696403026581,
0.49492374062538147,
-0.5456026196479797,
0.24856825172901154,
0.08799805492162704,
0.2033861130475998,
-0.2503143846988678,
0.08305837213993073,
0.1591591238975525,
0.2740478515625,
-0.01878601685166359,
0.22458495199680328,
-0.24632292985916138,
-0.20812112092971802,
0.4069743752479553,
-0.0015984075143933296,
-0.24224862456321716,
-0.30909183621406555,
0.6603303551673889,
0.10064473748207092,
-0.4585821330547333,
0.9822103381156921,
-0.09396820515394211,
-0.5688885450363159,
0.8284382224082947,
0.24051538109779358,
1.064036250114441,
-0.24253885447978973,
-0.09918925911188126,
0.5007340312004089,
0.4595632255077362,
0.31685489416122437,
0.22083769738674164,
-0.12743178009986877,
-0.6006746292114258,
-0.8466760516166687,
-0.47742050886154175,
-0.15518637001514435,
-0.34955406188964844,
-0.48838281631469727,
0.31278496980667114,
-0.6529141068458557,
-0.02648383192718029,
-0.16043323278427124,
-0.2678307890892029,
-0.8569298982620239,
0.013557584024965763,
-0.1909717172384262,
0.9028262495994568,
-0.39812418818473816,
1.1618624925613403,
0.32596078515052795,
-0.2471204698085785,
-0.6024507880210876,
-0.2289687842130661,
0.02110491506755352,
-1.0370595455169678,
0.6994224786758423,
-0.023020386695861816,
-0.23517140746116638,
-0.3467470407485962,
-0.485365092754364,
-0.78391432762146,
1.021892786026001,
0.2306525707244873,
-0.9614913463592529,
-0.12115371227264404,
-0.030785977840423584,
0.4610927999019623,
-0.30163130164146423,
0.00897237379103899,
0.4393301010131836,
0.2664574980735779,
0.046048879623413086,
-0.9388057589530945,
-0.09823772311210632,
-0.25327441096305847,
0.07639464735984802,
0.549307644367218,
-0.43106576800346375,
0.793603777885437,
-0.5086951851844788,
-0.22629380226135254,
0.06939633935689926,
0.4945969581604004,
0.0992298349738121,
-0.07412567734718323,
0.27477219700813293,
0.5817586779594421,
0.5878521203994751,
0.1411380171775818,
1.0735993385314941,
-0.5957919359207153,
0.18946677446365356,
1.4368666410446167,
0.0650390163064003,
0.6499679088592529,
0.6040229797363281,
-0.2504331171512604,
0.3384750187397003,
0.6091006994247437,
0.25723931193351746,
0.4208109974861145,
0.17470037937164307,
0.07095492631196976,
-0.3891262114048004,
0.576667308807373,
-0.5240226984024048,
0.5413526296615601,
0.25844836235046387,
-0.39238661527633667,
0.02517627738416195,
-0.37566033005714417,
0.1703316569328308,
-0.047916311770677567,
-0.05837860330939293,
0.5273643136024475,
0.012848232872784138,
-0.5774747133255005,
0.4360102713108063,
0.24531036615371704,
0.5061991214752197,
-0.2656998932361603,
-0.10121332854032516,
-0.4302457869052887,
0.19361232221126556,
-0.12175945937633514,
-0.6217830777168274,
0.6548634767532349,
-0.011974554508924484,
-0.2623687982559204,
-0.17409013211727142,
0.4911448359489441,
-0.21385657787322998,
-0.619686484336853,
0.05642220005393028,
0.28646886348724365,
-0.05142834782600403,
0.08063974976539612,
-0.6926499009132385,
0.34141913056373596,
0.2491961568593979,
-0.04235489293932915,
0.14040344953536987,
0.37664297223091125,
-0.03171767666935921,
0.7906580567359924,
0.8467450737953186,
0.03982379287481308,
0.33539626002311707,
-0.05445947125554085,
0.9601982235908508,
-0.8657994270324707,
-0.8147075772285461,
-0.8546798229217529,
0.597164511680603,
0.1696130931377411,
-0.28954729437828064,
0.6752251386642456,
0.5464481115341187,
0.9374822974205017,
-0.10015332698822021,
0.4254285395145416,
0.11430567502975464,
-0.01412863377481699,
-0.8836559653282166,
0.3908374607563019,
-0.26426124572753906,
0.6631876230239868,
-0.5591279864311218,
-0.8243688941001892,
-0.3577392101287842,
0.5665984749794006,
-0.4421233534812927,
-0.036367107182741165,
0.5079869031906128,
0.9893399477005005,
-0.028933826833963394,
-0.005989473778754473,
0.2135552018880844,
0.3067796230316162,
0.4480530917644501,
0.6874659657478333,
0.7451308369636536,
-0.2729562222957611,
0.27902448177337646,
-0.5410575866699219,
0.16795705258846283,
-0.40210309624671936,
-0.9169843196868896,
-0.4264477491378784,
-0.27747517824172974,
-0.2786121368408203,
-0.3475761115550995,
0.24736636877059937,
0.9688283801078796,
0.7276573181152344,
-0.564276933670044,
-0.14184969663619995,
-0.12544430792331696,
0.25029563903808594,
-0.3170212507247925,
-0.1851886510848999,
0.3766973614692688,
-0.1693572700023651,
-0.4997507929801941,
0.41909483075141907,
0.487907737493515,
-0.12259365618228912,
-0.19407685101032257,
-0.18325890600681305,
0.03731141239404678,
-0.01724577695131302,
0.5582429766654968,
0.28340330719947815,
-0.8207370638847351,
-0.29231852293014526,
0.22680138051509857,
-0.06237950921058655,
0.34157681465148926,
1.1584715843200684,
-0.7472477555274963,
1.0881239175796509,
0.3853435516357422,
0.7949446439743042,
0.7341289520263672,
0.08519342541694641,
0.7084326148033142,
-0.7010770440101624,
0.13760854303836823,
0.14953601360321045,
0.2867404818534851,
0.16500195860862732,
-0.8292067646980286,
0.458114355802536,
0.06528854370117188,
-0.5361435413360596,
-0.606316089630127,
0.23996831476688385,
-0.8667058944702148,
-0.2802644670009613,
0.7249356508255005,
-0.06952584534883499,
-0.27357256412506104,
-0.23460084199905396,
-0.15256530046463013,
0.21282733976840973,
-0.4579874873161316,
0.8506781458854675,
0.483997106552124,
-0.2803087532520294,
-0.24474988877773285,
-0.2547472417354584,
0.4087197184562683,
0.2551712095737457,
-0.39654025435447693,
0.2207520604133606,
0.5164419412612915,
0.19052010774612427,
-0.013059399090707302,
0.7610156536102295,
-0.28891298174858093,
0.725813090801239,
0.10752048343420029,
0.4152681231498718,
-0.4464740753173828,
-0.5065195560455322,
-0.42125359177589417,
-0.06732632219791412,
0.04709254205226898,
-0.2273685485124588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03145v1 | Enhancing Translation Accuracy of Large Language Models through Continual Pre-Training on Parallel Data | 2024-07-03T14:23:36 | 2024-07-03T14:23:36 | Minato Kondo, Takehito Utsuro, Masaaki Nagata | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a two-phase training approach where pre-trained
large language models are continually pre-trained on parallel data and then
supervised fine-tuned with a small amount of high-quality parallel data. To
investigate the effectiveness of our proposed approach, we conducted continual
pre-training with a 3.8B-parameter model and parallel data across eight
different formats. We evaluate these methods on thirteen test sets for
Japanese-to-English and English-to-Japanese translation. The results
demonstrate that when utilizing parallel data in continual pre-training, it is
essential to alternate between source and target sentences. Additionally, we
demonstrated that the translation accuracy improves only for translation
directions where the order of source and target sentences aligns between
continual pre-training data and inference. In addition, we demonstrate that the
LLM-based translation model is more robust in translating spoken language and
achieves higher accuracy with less training data compared to supervised
encoder-decoder models. We also show that the highest accuracy is achieved when
the data for continual pre-training consists of interleaved source and target
sentences and when tags are added to the source sentences. | [
-0.15800657868385315,
-0.6991794109344482,
0.7857961058616638,
0.5170477628707886,
-0.5448798537254333,
-0.03775070980191231,
-0.5719203948974609,
-0.21796107292175293,
-0.05449583753943443,
0.536429226398468,
-0.3548178970813751,
-0.5159032940864563,
-0.8784531950950623,
0.3217945396900177,
-0.4505264163017273,
0.6898590922355652,
-0.5501285195350647,
0.5693719387054443,
-0.2687458395957947,
-0.06742570549249649,
-0.5449116826057434,
-0.49258843064308167,
-0.6372824907302856,
-0.28277137875556946,
0.5428922176361084,
0.4922849237918854,
0.6861172318458557,
0.7962384223937988,
0.47752809524536133,
0.1891942322254181,
0.33154353499412537,
0.22388248145580292,
-0.6541033983230591,
0.007730328012257814,
-0.05979108437895775,
-0.7189844846725464,
-0.394076943397522,
0.06873886287212372,
1.0655360221862793,
0.8012928366661072,
-0.0001326057390542701,
0.14121845364570618,
0.43897494673728943,
0.5006208419799805,
-0.30257073044776917,
0.5155175924301147,
-0.49247851967811584,
-0.170678973197937,
-0.6209059357643127,
-0.1884365975856781,
-0.5346855521202087,
-0.32293105125427246,
-0.27943167090415955,
-0.7108607292175293,
0.07305896282196045,
0.20721882581710815,
0.867618203163147,
0.3611655831336975,
-0.32828211784362793,
-0.033226966857910156,
-0.8226471543312073,
0.7762267589569092,
-0.9195806384086609,
0.6036834120750427,
0.48629030585289,
0.062195178121328354,
-0.2466403841972351,
-0.6659830808639526,
-0.6041771173477173,
-0.3126794397830963,
-0.04535999894142151,
0.22320035099983215,
0.33152124285697937,
0.0005133745726197958,
0.26510104537010193,
0.0822376012802124,
-0.6581224203109741,
0.3241922855377197,
-0.07253577560186386,
0.09539912641048431,
0.5556178092956543,
0.21039508283138275,
0.3030165433883667,
0.2442677915096283,
-0.1506035476922989,
-0.20584410429000854,
-0.9512707591056824,
-0.10930047184228897,
0.27731621265411377,
0.36493104696273804,
-0.14759494364261627,
0.5257375836372375,
-0.24367403984069824,
0.6987583637237549,
0.07442024350166321,
-0.29149138927459717,
0.35936060547828674,
-0.7649434804916382,
0.1682053655385971,
-0.16416701674461365,
0.927317202091217,
0.20384778082370758,
0.5422642827033997,
-0.34135758876800537,
-0.1839292049407959,
-0.051601096987724304,
0.17149537801742554,
-0.7246832251548767,
0.012513763271272182,
0.06769726425409317,
-0.2863568365573883,
-0.037793729454278946,
-0.03158801794052124,
-0.44525307416915894,
0.3290281891822815,
-0.6774815917015076,
0.4476069211959839,
-0.19891051948070526,
-0.050337646156549454,
0.2072368562221527,
0.4044343829154968,
0.08627922087907791,
0.1899813413619995,
-0.6427924036979675,
0.38055115938186646,
0.5427706837654114,
0.9024221897125244,
-0.30997517704963684,
-0.8409870266914368,
-0.5547837615013123,
0.44628751277923584,
-0.6583552956581116,
0.5542823076248169,
-0.4166932702064514,
-0.14895682036876678,
-0.07058887183666229,
0.08902601152658463,
-0.2460978627204895,
-0.5219579339027405,
0.2831089198589325,
-0.334841787815094,
0.024180753156542778,
-0.2319173663854599,
-0.5669116377830505,
0.08798053860664368,
0.08795955777168274,
-0.3814549446105957,
0.7881830930709839,
-0.09365575015544891,
-0.5397288203239441,
0.2460096925497055,
-0.17256677150726318,
-0.570388674736023,
-0.07114002853631973,
-0.09031214565038681,
-0.49464935064315796,
0.15402807295322418,
0.49979332089424133,
0.5809476375579834,
-0.3906506896018982,
0.5734425187110901,
-0.3843275010585785,
-0.3079689145088196,
0.11593285948038101,
-0.3619988262653351,
0.2752421796321869,
-0.02065630443394184,
-0.27093246579170227,
-0.03709666058421135,
-0.3353755474090576,
-0.18374399840831757,
0.3681276738643646,
-0.3019941449165344,
-0.13430525362491608,
0.04758097231388092,
-0.07220160961151123,
0.23723700642585754,
0.4331989586353302,
-0.5138285756111145,
0.08922751247882843,
-0.39794737100601196,
0.0509965643286705,
0.5261216163635254,
-0.17610491812229156,
0.3453570604324341,
-0.30493369698524475,
0.47089314460754395,
0.1922435611486435,
0.14767037332057953,
-0.25041839480400085,
-0.34016579389572144,
-0.9058159589767456,
0.05076666548848152,
0.4203547239303589,
0.7280091643333435,
-0.757348358631134,
0.5082094669342041,
-0.7125489115715027,
-0.30828186869621277,
-0.4456561803817749,
0.3041686713695526,
0.4896197021007538,
0.6412720084190369,
0.5957705974578857,
-0.47239458560943604,
-0.3060152530670166,
-0.6401722431182861,
-0.14657016098499298,
0.060252148658037186,
0.08524902164936066,
-0.0917401984333992,
0.3713354766368866,
-0.13377487659454346,
0.5567057728767395,
-0.36512789130210876,
-0.054853636771440506,
-0.3666892349720001,
0.285099059343338,
0.23032240569591522,
0.7357494831085205,
0.24278073012828827,
-0.6106412410736084,
-0.7904822826385498,
0.12575387954711914,
-0.8284336924552917,
-0.18768973648548126,
-0.22002503275871277,
-0.2265876680612564,
-0.06921922415494919,
0.6801232099533081,
-0.6774001717567444,
0.2783268392086029,
0.5793637037277222,
0.289251446723938,
0.489160418510437,
-0.39110267162323,
0.2750477194786072,
-1.2935607433319092,
0.07865145802497864,
-0.10878156870603561,
-0.5445155501365662,
-0.793300211429596,
0.09881913661956787,
0.21071840822696686,
-0.02563900500535965,
-0.3135491907596588,
0.433229923248291,
-0.4634357690811157,
-0.004161520395427942,
-0.37723976373672485,
-0.0004189502797089517,
-0.08425792306661606,
0.29617270827293396,
0.1342228651046753,
0.9512834548950195,
0.36690542101860046,
-0.4385412931442261,
0.20671582221984863,
0.26760414242744446,
-0.5078760385513306,
0.2972184121608734,
-0.6459670066833496,
0.38811489939689636,
-0.2329464554786682,
0.41287150979042053,
-0.7281650304794312,
-0.3124578595161438,
0.3108537495136261,
-0.18892864882946014,
0.6995861530303955,
-0.0191997978836298,
-0.8479132056236267,
-0.2947986125946045,
0.24287572503089905,
0.4025045931339264,
0.5635995268821716,
-0.4401669502258301,
0.20527128875255585,
0.040137503296136856,
-0.615268886089325,
-0.46089544892311096,
-0.6663868427276611,
-0.03320759907364845,
-0.026362344622612,
-0.3899131119251251,
0.18515105545520782,
-0.08408364653587341,
0.15147057175636292,
-0.09930513054132462,
-0.11739835888147354,
-0.05100834369659424,
-0.05797204002737999,
0.04697278141975403,
0.14825241267681122,
-0.1655438393354416,
-0.0685979425907135,
0.19036920368671417,
-0.27922436594963074,
-0.04863390326499939,
-0.5389140844345093,
0.740953266620636,
0.14322182536125183,
-0.3145253360271454,
-0.6527214050292969,
0.4595221281051636,
0.440789133310318,
-0.3655993938446045,
0.8711154460906982,
0.3307840824127197,
-0.23255109786987305,
0.11061618477106094,
-0.6788867712020874,
0.023658841848373413,
-0.3642469644546509,
0.47109532356262207,
-0.6477740406990051,
-0.6505821943283081,
0.2754521369934082,
-0.11621951311826706,
0.04666045308113098,
0.19638784229755402,
0.4239847660064697,
-0.4219984710216522,
1.28319251537323,
0.4755915701389313,
-0.29057776927948,
0.3795364201068878,
0.03417577967047691,
0.11993588507175446,
-0.5525081753730774,
-0.1298007369041443,
-0.47272226214408875,
-0.12605717778205872,
-0.21973860263824463,
-0.5964927077293396,
0.22262504696846008,
0.6641064882278442,
-0.19173957407474518,
0.4629935324192047,
0.17032963037490845,
0.38382071256637573,
0.29637980461120605,
0.40426722168922424,
0.27852919697761536,
0.044409941881895065,
0.10836012661457062,
-0.13425414264202118,
-0.6184452176094055,
-0.3458611071109772,
1.3157765865325928,
0.4268123209476471,
0.6112973690032959,
-0.13433554768562317,
0.72153639793396,
-0.3410966396331787,
0.39308449625968933,
-0.44618961215019226,
0.3187367618083954,
-0.4221472144126892,
-0.23474250733852386,
-0.2783750891685486,
-0.5651266574859619,
-0.7875762581825256,
0.10566090047359467,
0.030072268098592758,
-0.22629006206989288,
-0.02997692860662937,
0.32905685901641846,
0.022410806268453598,
0.0184488445520401,
-0.603823184967041,
0.940798819065094,
-0.588862419128418,
-0.2740502953529358,
-0.43068432807922363,
-0.6848582029342651,
0.1290779560804367,
-0.5990070700645447,
0.20913845300674438,
-0.15352082252502441,
-0.03212054446339607,
0.5595494508743286,
-0.3787769079208374,
0.6292264461517334,
-0.05812534689903259,
0.10465098917484283,
-0.07272186130285263,
-0.2115197330713272,
0.8754780888557434,
0.04125872254371643,
0.13299451768398285,
0.5807682275772095,
-0.18226969242095947,
-0.8376006484031677,
-0.612787127494812,
0.3520331382751465,
-0.7434547543525696,
-0.7146978974342346,
-0.21986059844493866,
-0.9573020339012146,
-0.5321171879768372,
0.3205714523792267,
0.33652904629707336,
0.2960752248764038,
0.009152086451649666,
0.27229738235473633,
0.5383104681968689,
-0.03533463180065155,
0.12599609792232513,
0.49813327193260193,
-0.20247149467468262,
-0.4047934412956238,
0.737606942653656,
0.158694326877594,
0.5929517149925232,
0.5281040668487549,
0.12973693013191223,
-0.3892265558242798,
-1.0770622491836548,
-0.4802955985069275,
0.5624208450317383,
-0.39334607124328613,
0.017450343817472458,
-0.6217489242553711,
0.0003722785331774503,
-0.6493089199066162,
0.00704960199072957,
-0.566605806350708,
0.06634339690208435,
-0.21756277978420258,
0.11095952242612839,
0.025620661675930023,
0.5193948149681091,
-0.0005785863613709807,
0.6037495732307434,
-0.982643723487854,
0.29447582364082336,
0.011652032844722271,
0.03545983508229256,
-0.4410354197025299,
-0.7919477820396423,
-0.5083357095718384,
0.2140786200761795,
0.19668757915496826,
-0.817836582660675,
0.5005583167076111,
0.10536917299032211,
0.5180956125259399,
0.027949534356594086,
-0.4329321086406708,
0.9983659386634827,
-0.9181612133979797,
0.4420299828052521,
0.31006109714508057,
-0.867246150970459,
0.5619184970855713,
-0.4945339262485504,
0.6541376113891602,
0.8163352608680725,
0.730992317199707,
-0.21273992955684662,
-0.5018035769462585,
-0.16076694428920746,
-0.5328725576400757,
0.7038266062736511,
0.15877759456634521,
0.10737860202789307,
0.16450323164463043,
0.5831021666526794,
0.08974096179008484,
0.28204891085624695,
-0.5884058475494385,
-0.14014331996440887,
-0.18595798313617706,
-0.5277567505836487,
-0.7617329955101013,
-0.26905903220176697,
0.10687830299139023,
-0.2898467481136322,
0.6189728379249573,
-0.15829791128635406,
-0.1641186624765396,
-0.14863699674606323,
-0.34688448905944824,
0.09915438294410706,
0.12115370482206345,
0.43085312843322754,
0.7824516296386719,
-0.1983467936515808,
-0.2091083973646164,
0.2289355993270874,
-0.6188637018203735,
0.38038399815559387,
0.3283306658267975,
-0.33248797059059143,
0.051336389034986496,
0.301158607006073,
0.8446395397186279,
0.2499667853116989,
-0.2761824131011963,
0.4987131655216217,
0.2066524475812912,
0.05264587327837944,
-0.28213736414909363,
-0.33639228343963623,
0.1343105435371399,
0.13810336589813232,
-0.11201433837413788,
0.005992666352540255,
-0.295971155166626,
-0.33501219749450684,
0.23985621333122253,
-0.030970143154263496,
-0.00444197840988636,
-0.36961081624031067,
0.6745540499687195,
0.13567985594272614,
0.06719401478767395,
0.7366998791694641,
-0.040565814822912216,
-0.273518830537796,
0.3063768744468689,
0.903236985206604,
0.6270896196365356,
-0.4982045292854309,
0.009714650921523571,
0.5069200396537781,
0.42716094851493835,
-0.90934157371521,
0.17085790634155273,
-0.006297856569290161,
-0.7538397312164307,
-0.8647688627243042,
-0.7063010931015015,
-0.3416669964790344,
0.1817212551832199,
-0.8502216935157776,
0.24204130470752716,
-0.28760379552841187,
0.06855162233114243,
-0.4142586886882782,
-0.23952500522136688,
-0.7134004235267639,
0.1946025788784027,
0.09684783220291138,
0.6499189734458923,
-0.8976418972015381,
1.4694734811782837,
0.4326665699481964,
-0.5499745607376099,
-0.9506897926330566,
0.2588720917701721,
-0.3328302800655365,
-0.6548369526863098,
0.7237745523452759,
0.21120001375675201,
-0.023576518520712852,
0.4359423518180847,
-0.455651193857193,
-1.214278221130371,
0.8832736015319824,
0.6799891591072083,
-1.2073254585266113,
0.00033907240140251815,
0.41994553804397583,
0.3603403568267822,
-0.3718426823616028,
-0.04768195003271103,
0.6570935249328613,
0.3332849144935608,
-0.16081549227237701,
-1.0659066438674927,
-0.18414728343486786,
-0.1284772753715515,
0.24301405251026154,
0.23263463377952576,
-0.3980233669281006,
0.6549682021141052,
0.21664035320281982,
-0.14059577882289886,
0.1740482747554779,
0.9006274342536926,
0.2705899477005005,
0.1518114060163498,
0.5527551770210266,
0.6341506838798523,
0.49008893966674805,
-0.19253283739089966,
1.1154931783676147,
-0.32423511147499084,
0.22823385894298553,
1.5224628448486328,
-0.38053804636001587,
1.1211210489273071,
0.36154431104660034,
-0.16725385189056396,
0.2562546133995056,
0.4609655737876892,
0.052720099687576294,
0.5069935917854309,
-0.0932781994342804,
-0.16600623726844788,
-0.37651360034942627,
-0.021178865805268288,
-0.35773080587387085,
0.18659386038780212,
0.3984813690185547,
-0.15197986364364624,
0.01414342038333416,
0.4060448408126831,
0.20522168278694153,
0.2244194895029068,
-0.2109455168247223,
0.43025341629981995,
0.32777342200279236,
-0.8230001926422119,
0.5854867100715637,
-0.0823839008808136,
0.5238620638847351,
-0.7190290093421936,
0.2733222246170044,
-0.4006853699684143,
0.14386625587940216,
0.07698575407266617,
-0.5799254179000854,
0.23619334399700165,
0.13234560191631317,
-0.16454510390758514,
-0.521747350692749,
0.25452208518981934,
-0.7465406060218811,
-0.5685330629348755,
0.20602799952030182,
0.3609367609024048,
0.4781850278377533,
-0.16042351722717285,
-0.6585538387298584,
0.09962774068117142,
-0.16836589574813843,
-0.16497333347797394,
0.38900288939476013,
0.023470168933272362,
0.11859604716300964,
0.3512248396873474,
0.7766318321228027,
0.4426983594894409,
0.32543113827705383,
0.26238635182380676,
0.5901963710784912,
-0.52303546667099,
-0.36245620250701904,
-0.6269944310188293,
0.2985493540763855,
-0.008688315749168396,
-0.13344039022922516,
0.8036505579948425,
0.44872480630874634,
1.342712640762329,
-0.033553652465343475,
0.6240813732147217,
0.34553205966949463,
0.5391728281974792,
-0.8912380933761597,
0.43137145042419434,
-0.5282713770866394,
0.03904547914862633,
0.10807271301746368,
-1.1561484336853027,
-0.35729947686195374,
0.36435386538505554,
-0.43291130661964417,
-0.003677403088659048,
0.9062674045562744,
0.963279128074646,
-0.09149346500635147,
-0.36737948656082153,
0.34068623185157776,
0.40066248178482056,
0.21788068115711212,
0.5979386568069458,
0.7031712532043457,
-0.5191708207130432,
0.4171757698059082,
-0.39212071895599365,
-0.08141469955444336,
0.15367989242076874,
-0.4661012291908264,
-0.8055059313774109,
-0.3560235798358917,
-0.20256343483924866,
-0.2932053208351135,
0.2004561871290207,
0.751323938369751,
0.6777635216712952,
-0.9451518654823303,
-0.4060039222240448,
-0.3841669261455536,
-0.5077810883522034,
-0.16340050101280212,
-0.036481987684965134,
0.1389133483171463,
-0.7681549191474915,
-1.0398653745651245,
0.8178905248641968,
0.285839706659317,
0.1225886195898056,
-0.1428440809249878,
-0.24532413482666016,
-0.23756514489650726,
-0.10480821877717972,
0.4748845398426056,
0.19120949506759644,
-0.7835990190505981,
-0.26413846015930176,
-0.15839898586273193,
-0.276836097240448,
0.057194653898477554,
0.6244410276412964,
-0.3064669668674469,
0.5617148876190186,
0.546231210231781,
0.8302956819534302,
0.944824755191803,
0.2873373329639435,
0.9962348341941833,
-0.5702452063560486,
0.4389568865299225,
-0.03234495222568512,
0.2986851632595062,
0.3790670931339264,
-0.24171556532382965,
0.34098368883132935,
0.28296321630477905,
-0.5583038330078125,
-0.6328291893005371,
0.19921275973320007,
-0.8337950110435486,
-0.14378014206886292,
1.0846246480941772,
-0.5952601432800293,
-0.04100637510418892,
-0.09169670939445496,
0.1590908169746399,
0.5347031354904175,
0.05886184424161911,
0.32163718342781067,
0.6845470666885376,
0.11564461141824722,
-0.2855130136013031,
-0.8203216195106506,
0.1620098203420639,
0.7568209171295166,
-1.0273445844650269,
-0.23116222023963928,
0.3025458753108978,
0.3498222827911377,
-0.10352268815040588,
0.6472964882850647,
-0.2699294984340668,
0.0657866969704628,
0.010781005024909973,
-0.0904756486415863,
0.005399493500590324,
-0.5508060455322266,
-0.528738796710968,
-0.11815670132637024,
0.2367316037416458,
-0.23896770179271698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03132v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03132v1 | Speaker- and Text-Independent Estimation of Articulatory Movements and Phoneme Alignments from Speech | 2024-07-03T14:13:04 | 2024-07-03T14:13:04 | Tobias Weise, Philipp Klumpp, Kubilay Can Demir, Paula Andrea Pérez-Toro, Maria Schuster, Elmar Noeth, Bjoern Heismann, Andreas Maier, Seung Hee Yang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | This paper introduces a novel combination of two tasks, previously treated
separately: acoustic-to-articulatory speech inversion (AAI) and
phoneme-to-articulatory (PTA) motion estimation. We refer to this joint task as
acoustic phoneme-to-articulatory speech inversion (APTAI) and explore two
different approaches, both working speaker- and text-independently during
inference. We use a multi-task learning setup, with the end-to-end goal of
taking raw speech as input and estimating the corresponding articulatory
movements, phoneme sequence, and phoneme alignment. While both proposed
approaches share these same requirements, they differ in their way of achieving
phoneme-related predictions: one is based on frame classification, the other on
a two-staged training procedure and forced alignment. We reach competitive
performance of 0.73 mean correlation for the AAI task and achieve up to
approximately 87% frame overlap compared to a state-of-the-art text-dependent
phoneme force aligner. | [
0.014907325617969036,
-0.6642261147499084,
0.4305359721183777,
-0.291890949010849,
-0.35751184821128845,
-0.11177516728639603,
0.07478730380535126,
-0.4657890200614929,
0.6249033808708191,
0.213458850979805,
-0.5884837508201599,
-0.2232501208782196,
-0.5052972435951233,
-0.08683641999959946,
-0.3295866549015045,
0.5574384331703186,
0.24592846632003784,
0.3453609347343445,
0.11098784953355789,
-0.3290575444698334,
-0.8009421825408936,
-0.10977262258529663,
-0.41859838366508484,
-0.3651179075241089,
0.22686366736888885,
0.3727607727050781,
0.7879396080970764,
0.839905321598053,
0.325373113155365,
0.33678552508354187,
0.1711096465587616,
-0.08848226070404053,
0.3277978301048279,
0.04877282679080963,
0.03241801634430885,
-0.39535021781921387,
-0.5833855271339417,
0.24326297640800476,
0.6138622760772705,
0.7457187175750732,
-0.28047215938568115,
0.02464648336172104,
-0.253606915473938,
0.6990994215011597,
-0.8549099564552307,
0.07046639919281006,
-0.25554159283638,
0.0069794440641999245,
-0.2419244349002838,
-0.14133262634277344,
-0.15111859142780304,
-0.01856088638305664,
0.26029494404792786,
-0.6609000563621521,
-0.29828494787216187,
-0.30270981788635254,
0.5661398768424988,
0.5349708795547485,
-0.5494574308395386,
-0.32737499475479126,
-0.5713209509849548,
0.6878625750541687,
-0.5753730535507202,
0.7595534324645996,
0.25601422786712646,
0.14818307757377625,
-0.04432644322514534,
-0.34326764941215515,
-0.6151130199432373,
0.16248147189617157,
0.16263729333877563,
0.4122752845287323,
-0.20988991856575012,
0.1297817826271057,
-0.14078205823898315,
0.11529868841171265,
-0.6834633350372314,
0.23275434970855713,
-0.08537541329860687,
-0.006986857391893864,
0.7096285820007324,
-0.3345596194267273,
0.3894396126270294,
-0.16035650670528412,
-0.49605000019073486,
-0.40567919611930847,
-0.3484916687011719,
0.31243735551834106,
0.47136056423187256,
0.3180907368659973,
-0.4002712666988373,
0.5090399384498596,
0.19006793200969696,
0.659430980682373,
0.36381134390830994,
-0.37580376863479614,
0.5215489268302917,
-0.35314562916755676,
-0.3326481580734253,
0.5546954274177551,
1.042675495147705,
-0.09101717919111252,
-0.030396871268749237,
-0.4449739158153534,
0.06314393132925034,
0.17935794591903687,
-0.05340397730469704,
-0.2306821495294571,
-0.11574903875589371,
0.3374817371368408,
-0.2731606364250183,
-0.06641090661287308,
0.20384584367275238,
-0.7392846941947937,
-0.44010767340660095,
-0.6195248961448669,
0.7424117922782898,
-0.3302749991416931,
-0.5487654805183411,
-0.2952319383621216,
-0.06482846289873123,
0.47368621826171875,
0.04505690932273865,
-1.0213185548782349,
0.2058727890253067,
0.7184700965881348,
0.8257807493209839,
-0.2512792646884918,
-0.5910718441009521,
-0.9302428960800171,
0.2610979974269867,
-0.5128865242004395,
0.7493544220924377,
-0.6004729866981506,
-0.21200843155384064,
-0.28487473726272583,
0.04051674157381058,
-0.7222996354103088,
-0.14963257312774658,
0.6560577750205994,
-0.24820053577423096,
0.46643441915512085,
0.22818882763385773,
-0.44505757093429565,
-0.24295532703399658,
-0.3123999834060669,
-0.7127417922019958,
0.7529115676879883,
-0.24006636440753937,
-0.7655177712440491,
0.16993752121925354,
-0.36500799655914307,
-0.40091434121131897,
-0.3901088535785675,
-0.35210859775543213,
-0.4186513125896454,
0.15121285617351532,
0.13450966775417328,
0.2549319267272949,
-0.015472657047212124,
0.17074120044708252,
-0.3449249267578125,
-0.43484073877334595,
0.270916223526001,
-0.525414764881134,
0.9056752920150757,
0.11795321851968765,
-0.48456519842147827,
0.17058558762073517,
-0.9757815003395081,
-0.054628144949674606,
-0.3740914762020111,
-0.1784203201532364,
-0.49748289585113525,
0.0433494970202446,
-0.4485795795917511,
0.06595426797866821,
0.11105243861675262,
-0.554057240486145,
0.050449274480342865,
-0.8277862668037415,
0.2866550385951996,
0.4094654619693756,
-0.28507933020591736,
0.7850068807601929,
-0.2577582001686096,
0.41264697909355164,
-0.07961452752351761,
-0.14259560406208038,
-0.0455697663128376,
-0.7336937785148621,
-0.06982777267694473,
-0.22346478700637817,
0.4205268323421478,
0.9044815301895142,
-0.5659199953079224,
0.3493543267250061,
-0.5019834637641907,
-0.5220992565155029,
-0.7386664748191833,
-0.07849747687578201,
0.4338873326778412,
0.5202588438987732,
0.08715885132551193,
-0.5520495772361755,
-0.5804230570793152,
-0.43783536553382874,
-0.3577038645744324,
-0.7382268905639648,
-0.038543425500392914,
-0.004388561472296715,
-0.06031663715839386,
0.20690058171749115,
0.8811623454093933,
0.07764708250761032,
-0.24990513920783997,
0.07830128073692322,
0.4724663496017456,
0.08932113647460938,
0.5740529298782349,
0.4420385956764221,
-0.7370133996009827,
-0.20674435794353485,
-0.028726425021886826,
-0.3713890612125397,
-0.2586844861507416,
-0.13332107663154602,
-0.18947197496891022,
0.13615116477012634,
0.22766520082950592,
-0.846514880657196,
0.494344025850296,
0.8169377446174622,
-0.34143370389938354,
0.34429195523262024,
-0.10336187481880188,
0.32828402519226074,
-1.220902442932129,
0.21326857805252075,
0.12852482497692108,
-0.1434505581855774,
-1.217801570892334,
-0.16031302511692047,
0.1379144787788391,
-0.19322888553142548,
-0.3670281767845154,
0.40383848547935486,
-0.7453054189682007,
-0.5045991539955139,
-0.5321211218833923,
0.4554681181907654,
-0.004318429157137871,
0.6068597435951233,
0.3060547113418579,
0.9461560249328613,
0.8367339968681335,
-0.4044687747955322,
0.04874287545681,
0.413298636674881,
-0.14059652388095856,
0.45264890789985657,
-0.4465084969997406,
0.4467236399650574,
-0.05222655087709427,
0.01605507731437683,
-1.2207732200622559,
-0.10827909409999847,
0.4460236132144928,
-0.6721035838127136,
0.47205957770347595,
-0.12844453752040863,
0.25615277886390686,
-0.04682203009724617,
-0.13666623830795288,
0.6381896734237671,
0.3795689642429352,
-0.4028611481189728,
1.1239168643951416,
0.7504807114601135,
-0.20347705483436584,
-0.9601747989654541,
-0.6426928043365479,
0.14260290563106537,
-0.49918317794799805,
-0.2906048893928528,
0.24781262874603271,
0.2134981006383896,
-0.32449519634246826,
-0.3937321603298187,
-0.24907945096492767,
-0.49413561820983887,
-0.05262671411037445,
0.6364675164222717,
0.13137270510196686,
-0.13920989632606506,
0.14373666048049927,
0.09151417016983032,
-0.055200062692165375,
0.06114662438631058,
-0.11398078501224518,
0.11395826935768127,
0.2625168263912201,
-0.5449069142341614,
-1.178602695465088,
0.48036864399909973,
0.6307311058044434,
-0.37562692165374756,
0.03895176947116852,
0.5979508757591248,
-0.09800302982330322,
0.727429211139679,
-0.5695162415504456,
0.029953887686133385,
-0.3506774306297302,
0.2654789388179779,
-0.28678393363952637,
-0.1401458978652954,
0.22009475529193878,
0.031165601685643196,
0.12114925682544708,
0.2912755310535431,
0.23884397745132446,
-0.08408574759960175,
1.3061693906784058,
0.6660599708557129,
-0.25347697734832764,
0.6227092146873474,
-0.11010271310806274,
0.15831074118614197,
-0.6768792867660522,
-0.0378715917468071,
-0.7903788089752197,
-0.42971271276474,
-0.39384377002716064,
-0.26640424132347107,
0.3312666118144989,
0.1657448410987854,
0.003549171146005392,
0.46932560205459595,
-0.192886084318161,
-0.0296073816716671,
0.6368296146392822,
0.15060220658779144,
0.22716814279556274,
0.09300640225410461,
0.13323384523391724,
0.28670212626457214,
-0.5038460493087769,
-0.3897121846675873,
0.9441618919372559,
0.27532246708869934,
0.2851458787918091,
0.23407407104969025,
0.7397263646125793,
-0.09505634754896164,
0.01170715969055891,
-1.0303345918655396,
0.46354639530181885,
-0.22494271397590637,
-0.2587054371833801,
-0.6026751399040222,
-0.2792109549045563,
-0.9950025677680969,
0.30044180154800415,
0.09406651556491852,
-0.9237500429153442,
0.6917063593864441,
0.16039955615997314,
-0.38122332096099854,
0.2650282382965088,
-1.0260083675384521,
0.735541820526123,
-0.17777563631534576,
-0.05304091423749924,
-0.3444945216178894,
-0.9688935875892639,
0.15507934987545013,
-0.055489685386419296,
0.5953987240791321,
-0.4331721365451813,
-0.2815260887145996,
0.7220942378044128,
-0.1940249353647232,
0.9683645963668823,
-0.469860315322876,
-0.2617189586162567,
0.5284323692321777,
-0.29806604981422424,
0.40897050499916077,
-0.3145577311515808,
-0.264726847410202,
0.3409993052482605,
0.17924068868160248,
-0.17680351436138153,
-0.5219417810440063,
0.540783166885376,
-0.7164673209190369,
-0.5012881755828857,
-0.29032102227211,
-0.6576545834541321,
-0.35552656650543213,
0.03645242378115654,
-0.06471727788448334,
0.5847098231315613,
-0.3745953440666199,
-0.1252838522195816,
0.26825979351997375,
0.3530207574367523,
1.089341640472412,
0.44436657428741455,
0.4235891103744507,
-0.740738034248352,
0.8430272936820984,
-0.11464541405439377,
0.14765268564224243,
0.6991753578186035,
0.3175819218158722,
-0.4324202239513397,
-0.5516653060913086,
-0.681297242641449,
0.2924656271934509,
-0.21150538325309753,
0.07176139950752258,
-0.36453917622566223,
0.3699610233306885,
-0.7371096014976501,
0.45648759603500366,
-0.3876873552799225,
-0.9716319441795349,
-0.4647907316684723,
0.2378356158733368,
-0.1445021778345108,
0.24769635498523712,
-0.2896950840950012,
0.5255117416381836,
-0.8035723567008972,
0.2410772144794464,
0.5229085087776184,
-0.02273757942020893,
-0.33830925822257996,
-0.7158340215682983,
-0.08572674542665482,
0.4773072600364685,
-0.3801003396511078,
-1.2818690538406372,
0.3656649887561798,
0.6929240226745605,
0.4345739185810089,
0.5982380509376526,
0.06877891719341278,
1.0315114259719849,
-0.5041041374206543,
0.8024842739105225,
0.606495201587677,
-1.0031794309616089,
0.5586576461791992,
0.00328263477422297,
0.4054657220840454,
0.4897608757019043,
0.21090400218963623,
-0.23038335144519806,
-0.22714142501354218,
-0.4808903634548187,
-0.7127830982208252,
0.6628174781799316,
0.32680559158325195,
-0.09331906586885452,
0.22358188033103943,
0.3756389617919922,
0.22935396432876587,
0.2392292469739914,
-0.5101723074913025,
-0.18845407664775848,
-0.3288458287715912,
-0.5519248247146606,
-0.10333423316478729,
0.11108018457889557,
-0.35711100697517395,
-0.14748379588127136,
0.9052296280860901,
-0.3469350039958954,
0.5665486454963684,
0.29022276401519775,
-0.08240464329719543,
-0.41348129510879517,
0.32490116357803345,
0.5939386487007141,
0.7329634428024292,
0.18359678983688354,
0.08436432480812073,
0.044469982385635376,
-0.6229865550994873,
0.2958308160305023,
0.46403220295906067,
0.06080332770943642,
0.3945937156677246,
0.3405274748802185,
1.2108362913131714,
0.23089423775672913,
-0.6451097726821899,
0.7912279963493347,
-0.053543832153081894,
-0.23744389414787292,
-0.39968809485435486,
-0.13766077160835266,
-0.24163755774497986,
0.49022093415260315,
0.4394654333591461,
0.12575958669185638,
0.11572329699993134,
-0.4183005690574646,
0.21010492742061615,
0.5343008041381836,
-0.5893068313598633,
-0.7314736843109131,
0.8943448066711426,
0.08445841073989868,
-0.549444854259491,
-0.037911556661129,
0.19794440269470215,
0.23676779866218567,
0.5933653712272644,
0.11558374762535095,
1.3437411785125732,
-0.8314999938011169,
0.1368248611688614,
0.1922653764486313,
-0.32025498151779175,
0.027322929352521896,
0.427978515625,
-0.4061991274356842,
-0.7114803791046143,
-0.6993851065635681,
-0.1618102490901947,
-0.3751296401023865,
-0.17375199496746063,
-0.789485514163971,
0.2219056487083435,
0.35299789905548096,
-0.30119258165359497,
0.23660393059253693,
-0.1271836906671524,
-0.11510055512189865,
0.09790016710758209,
0.10731953382492065,
0.6492025852203369,
-1.0121876001358032,
1.037010669708252,
1.0410566329956055,
-0.04659213498234749,
-0.9205335974693298,
0.3208424746990204,
0.11467572301626205,
-0.7882528901100159,
0.2837958335876465,
0.20620089769363403,
-0.26918619871139526,
0.0019292121287435293,
-0.16275912523269653,
-0.952278733253479,
1.06529700756073,
0.45723676681518555,
-0.6799535751342773,
-0.35158294439315796,
0.1389354169368744,
0.1386513113975525,
-0.23905397951602936,
0.4556666910648346,
0.5500175952911377,
0.3514133095741272,
0.014802344143390656,
-1.262356162071228,
-0.37956979870796204,
-0.1318233460187912,
-0.25631555914878845,
0.39425206184387207,
-0.6771522164344788,
0.25683507323265076,
-0.009905991144478321,
-0.34858956933021545,
0.4801627993583679,
0.7896769642829895,
0.2840178310871124,
0.590921938419342,
0.9522911310195923,
0.6350011825561523,
0.6481048464775085,
-0.07571207731962204,
0.45962050557136536,
-0.6766236424446106,
-0.08009308576583862,
1.2055150270462036,
-0.022544454783201218,
0.8824346661567688,
0.8425073623657227,
0.044876258820295334,
0.3801785707473755,
0.4544736444950104,
0.4438914358615875,
0.7325650453567505,
-0.5389139652252197,
-0.3306291103363037,
-0.21363164484500885,
0.10299349576234818,
-0.15073396265506744,
1.0481743812561035,
0.16157393157482147,
-0.1341448277235031,
-0.041821304708719254,
0.2431257665157318,
-0.2921440005302429,
-0.20234699547290802,
-0.24379391968250275,
1.0139098167419434,
-0.147299662232399,
-0.9722123742103577,
0.5716151595115662,
-0.370754212141037,
0.2240607738494873,
-0.48500993847846985,
0.07490146160125732,
0.06244867667555809,
-0.0488579086959362,
0.07421178370714188,
-0.38897383213043213,
0.2442217916250229,
-0.3998263478279114,
0.13275234401226044,
-0.19848406314849854,
0.49230408668518066,
-0.7145476937294006,
-0.09390546381473541,
-0.015091577544808388,
0.502162516117096,
0.5726590752601624,
0.18983031809329987,
-0.8113275766372681,
-0.15279537439346313,
-0.015037166886031628,
-0.2821185886859894,
0.3040577173233032,
0.45802026987075806,
0.15962153673171997,
0.39585253596305847,
0.06920772045850754,
0.12979532778263092,
0.1231139749288559,
0.13522440195083618,
0.3761161267757416,
-0.17147862911224365,
-0.5843559503555298,
-0.5096638202667236,
0.3852875232696533,
0.15416797995567322,
-0.42048075795173645,
0.4682381749153137,
0.4259554445743561,
0.40004193782806396,
0.17405906319618225,
0.5314078330993652,
0.0007073874003253877,
0.6365627646446228,
-0.66098552942276,
0.09087598323822021,
-0.5158731937408447,
0.07645756006240845,
-0.5462633967399597,
-0.7331742644309998,
0.010388903319835663,
0.5427880883216858,
-0.15911723673343658,
-0.03670252114534378,
0.6138258576393127,
0.6686875820159912,
-0.03855697810649872,
0.3562352657318115,
0.14812590181827545,
-0.05916183814406395,
0.042056888341903687,
0.4008506238460541,
0.3865882158279419,
-0.7396796345710754,
0.7014005184173584,
-0.5556437373161316,
-0.36119571328163147,
0.3012688457965851,
-0.8098202347755432,
-0.38461023569107056,
-0.6949707269668579,
-0.7908081412315369,
0.11899815499782562,
0.17315222322940826,
0.7863486409187317,
0.9036484956741333,
-0.9481859803199768,
-0.7059196829795837,
-0.2923915982246399,
-0.041737549006938934,
-0.9172407984733582,
-0.12348870933055878,
0.71811443567276,
-0.08540184795856476,
-1.187546968460083,
1.0508723258972168,
0.07970935851335526,
0.37405839562416077,
0.13483358919620514,
-0.058165427297353745,
-0.2859663963317871,
-0.10394247621297836,
0.12488242983818054,
0.6934238076210022,
-0.747960090637207,
-0.40514862537384033,
-0.1907193660736084,
0.2632991075515747,
0.2873625159263611,
0.8793978095054626,
-0.8135319948196411,
0.5308548808097839,
0.41001880168914795,
0.5216505527496338,
-0.022671779617667198,
0.39310094714164734,
0.6752901077270508,
-0.8018162846565247,
0.4541512131690979,
-0.0648709237575531,
0.2562333643436432,
0.12156037241220474,
-0.18289916217327118,
0.4002021551132202,
0.3213516175746918,
-0.657207190990448,
-0.754082441329956,
0.25115513801574707,
-1.1157667636871338,
-0.239421546459198,
0.9038624167442322,
0.1627476066350937,
-0.35956329107284546,
-0.13723409175872803,
-0.10103015601634979,
0.8047274351119995,
-0.35476845502853394,
0.7333769798278809,
0.410674512386322,
-0.44971737265586853,
-0.3894745409488678,
-0.48446184396743774,
0.35023367404937744,
0.684779703617096,
-0.46131664514541626,
-0.11338265240192413,
0.5471252202987671,
-0.1442464143037796,
0.3824306130409241,
0.41601794958114624,
-0.027406057342886925,
0.2887073755264282,
-0.32454365491867065,
0.18227115273475647,
0.22733424603939056,
-0.318136602640152,
-0.6057355999946594,
0.30315056443214417,
-0.25005003809928894,
-0.9302102327346802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03129v1 | Social Bias Evaluation for Large Language Models Requires Prompt Variations | 2024-07-03T14:12:04 | 2024-07-03T14:12:04 | Rem Hida, Masahiro Kaneko, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Warning: This paper contains examples of stereotypes and biases. Large
Language Models (LLMs) exhibit considerable social biases, and various studies
have tried to evaluate and mitigate these biases accurately. Previous studies
use downstream tasks as prompts to examine the degree of social biases for
evaluation and mitigation. While LLMs' output highly depends on prompts,
previous studies evaluating and mitigating bias have often relied on a limited
variety of prompts. In this paper, we investigate the sensitivity of LLMs when
changing prompt variations (task instruction and prompt, few-shot examples,
debias-prompt) by analyzing task performance and social bias of LLMs. Our
experimental results reveal that LLMs are highly sensitive to prompts to the
extent that the ranking of LLMs fluctuates when comparing models for task
performance and social bias. Additionally, we show that LLMs have tradeoffs
between performance and social bias caused by the prompts. Less bias from
prompt setting may result in reduced performance. Moreover, the ambiguity of
instances is one of the reasons for this sensitivity to prompts in advanced
LLMs, leading to various outputs. We recommend using diverse prompts, as in
this study, to compare the effects of prompts on social bias in LLMs. | [
-0.17159311473369598,
-1.0104726552963257,
0.6908056735992432,
0.36092376708984375,
-0.08261831104755402,
0.14116054773330688,
-0.44953471422195435,
-0.1756308525800705,
0.14375001192092896,
0.2737606167793274,
-0.7168365120887756,
-0.4274681508541107,
-1.0848771333694458,
0.31238457560539246,
0.1008218377828598,
0.908235490322113,
0.1365085393190384,
0.2564186453819275,
-0.06328380852937698,
-0.048921871930360794,
-0.7401991486549377,
-0.49423590302467346,
-0.79103022813797,
-0.35053038597106934,
0.8085598945617676,
0.3821353614330292,
0.6773865222930908,
0.23060940206050873,
0.23893019556999207,
0.2697620093822479,
-0.43362122774124146,
-0.02350355125963688,
-0.7686783671379089,
0.46128273010253906,
-0.21202455461025238,
-0.3880613446235657,
-0.05967537313699722,
-0.13516183197498322,
0.7159541249275208,
0.7234591841697693,
0.4980536103248596,
0.42879268527030945,
0.4360333979129791,
0.6345176696777344,
-0.6746789216995239,
0.25109609961509705,
-0.6368033289909363,
-0.1932973861694336,
-0.35447007417678833,
-0.13341493904590607,
-0.46160513162612915,
-0.45354241132736206,
0.11203109472990036,
-0.19834502041339874,
0.1991603821516037,
-0.04148993641138077,
0.44889065623283386,
0.20279277861118317,
-0.5134146213531494,
-0.18314357101917267,
-0.5938595533370972,
0.8921294212341309,
-0.7491194009780884,
0.043999552726745605,
0.12104739248752594,
0.34655484557151794,
-0.2059229016304016,
-0.10100241750478745,
-0.12070537358522415,
-0.4568312466144562,
0.22622522711753845,
-0.25777843594551086,
-0.04898430407047272,
0.014965910464525223,
0.7256360650062561,
-0.12882111966609955,
-0.2352408915758133,
0.35733741521835327,
-0.23931178450584412,
-0.2330789566040039,
0.5739247798919678,
0.5101180672645569,
0.2534729242324829,
-0.19603386521339417,
-0.013943963684141636,
-0.0497245155274868,
-0.9333426356315613,
0.41187992691993713,
0.7517407536506653,
0.5397108197212219,
-0.2842313051223755,
0.5475916266441345,
-0.38602590560913086,
0.6432377696037292,
0.2651429772377014,
-0.14787331223487854,
0.2035418152809143,
-0.08054386079311371,
0.08543200045824051,
-0.015669871121644974,
0.6026860475540161,
0.7681728005409241,
0.48660561442375183,
0.15497331321239471,
-0.2763286232948303,
0.22843514382839203,
-0.08256939053535461,
-0.672003448009491,
0.3295750617980957,
-0.11453016102313995,
-0.5225335955619812,
-0.29147103428840637,
-0.3886280953884125,
-0.7695271372795105,
-0.9508920311927795,
-0.3239961564540863,
0.1299149990081787,
0.012476670555770397,
0.04584395885467529,
-0.03318944573402405,
-0.1581430286169052,
0.059957023710012436,
0.5154651403427124,
-0.8658648729324341,
0.27695849537849426,
0.5949720144271851,
0.9108582139015198,
-0.48133963346481323,
-0.2924446761608124,
-0.9183719754219055,
-0.11858326941728592,
-0.18720154464244843,
0.443680077791214,
-0.8988062739372253,
-0.5152833461761475,
0.21338558197021484,
0.0021861328277736902,
-0.10573124140501022,
-0.4122718572616577,
0.4938312768936157,
-0.3164181411266327,
-0.047025974839925766,
-0.9460557699203491,
-0.40274861454963684,
0.1743045300245285,
-0.08082912117242813,
-0.5970638990402222,
0.9168708920478821,
-0.048691537231206894,
-0.9344565868377686,
0.41167375445365906,
-0.4176463186740875,
-0.5461561679840088,
-0.03960651531815529,
-0.4045324921607971,
0.11171922087669373,
0.22833511233329773,
0.1490243673324585,
0.45356911420822144,
-0.4735007882118225,
0.47204142808914185,
-0.5261119604110718,
-0.6891798377037048,
0.3205347955226898,
-0.509425699710846,
0.95042884349823,
0.03978428244590759,
-0.6750604510307312,
0.32107943296432495,
-0.49145105481147766,
-0.5018846988677979,
0.009014786221086979,
-0.3487064242362976,
-0.6067992448806763,
0.028492184355854988,
-0.29369211196899414,
0.15730679035186768,
0.17259855568408966,
-0.5984400510787964,
0.15623843669891357,
-0.21456100046634674,
0.2686351239681244,
1.302301287651062,
-0.01761147566139698,
0.40866079926490784,
-0.4805549383163452,
0.7196076512336731,
-0.10900071263313293,
0.24160173535346985,
0.15614405274391174,
-0.6476002335548401,
-0.5480105876922607,
-0.17029857635498047,
-0.04728992283344269,
0.39673206210136414,
-0.6886982321739197,
0.10524827986955643,
-0.1151607483625412,
-0.48644837737083435,
-0.37318727374076843,
0.19009606540203094,
0.2669103443622589,
0.22036650776863098,
-0.12007702142000198,
-0.07020317018032074,
-0.2690158486366272,
-0.9561957716941833,
-0.6732487082481384,
0.08744310587644577,
0.04314076155424118,
0.5108309984207153,
0.4061889052391052,
-0.051268577575683594,
0.7644227743148804,
-0.4769262373447418,
0.14720363914966583,
-0.3812442123889923,
0.04408905655145645,
0.36633020639419556,
0.16804856061935425,
0.5747714638710022,
-0.3327464163303375,
-0.4411871135234833,
-0.5370883941650391,
-0.223506361246109,
-0.5598313808441162,
-0.10964705795049667,
-0.06828833371400833,
0.3106258809566498,
0.4399462640285492,
-0.6309205889701843,
0.23416884243488312,
0.5546894669532776,
-0.45315632224082947,
0.67006915807724,
0.1716165542602539,
0.2077910602092743,
-0.7661689519882202,
-0.1922701597213745,
0.2975350618362427,
0.0480184331536293,
-0.40508851408958435,
-0.23761475086212158,
-0.15807002782821655,
0.18622976541519165,
-0.46945732831954956,
0.7728012800216675,
-0.4352930784225464,
-0.2010856419801712,
-0.11391439288854599,
0.22355352342128754,
-0.02718113735318184,
0.2592732012271881,
-0.1302040070295334,
0.6889849305152893,
0.643930971622467,
-0.6871792674064636,
0.37142214179039,
-0.1431090384721756,
-0.5348814129829407,
0.2940431237220764,
-0.9734693765640259,
0.26841962337493896,
-0.3142726421356201,
0.2785395383834839,
-1.2401248216629028,
-0.05340466648340225,
0.34933432936668396,
-0.23653773963451385,
0.19345036149024963,
-0.0387815497815609,
-0.3751375079154968,
-0.24583101272583008,
-0.6406352519989014,
0.2886561155319214,
0.3948412537574768,
-0.24616798758506775,
0.1874653846025467,
0.15993863344192505,
-0.4612728953361511,
-0.7003312110900879,
-0.33579349517822266,
-0.12941651046276093,
-0.36138835549354553,
-0.6548871994018555,
-0.0027832279447466135,
-0.23107333481311798,
-0.5342467427253723,
-0.34725695848464966,
-0.028278762474656105,
0.5178689360618591,
0.2161305695772171,
0.4349058270454407,
0.31375622749328613,
0.000021024103261879645,
0.15357168018817902,
0.23879733681678772,
0.26332810521125793,
0.3405727446079254,
0.25823771953582764,
0.7958959341049194,
0.21145661175251007,
-0.3270719349384308,
0.014138370752334595,
0.29528898000717163,
0.5147790312767029,
-0.010484175756573677,
0.7090997695922852,
0.3142089247703552,
-0.21377556025981903,
-0.04763596132397652,
-0.7578774690628052,
-0.4005778431892395,
-0.5171626806259155,
0.3396809697151184,
-0.28449368476867676,
-1.1890360116958618,
0.673754870891571,
0.09646163880825043,
0.11891607940196991,
0.2994785010814667,
0.8472514748573303,
0.3612968325614929,
1.0922064781188965,
0.2893162965774536,
-0.11958060413599014,
0.6249340176582336,
0.32156112790107727,
0.029521236196160316,
-0.8977169394493103,
-0.028461968526244164,
-0.8341963887214661,
-0.32891029119491577,
-0.6970746517181396,
-0.36831629276275635,
0.17789188027381897,
-0.3554515242576599,
-0.3387828469276428,
-0.11869049072265625,
-0.24727044999599457,
0.45700278878211975,
0.47023269534111023,
0.09030165523290634,
0.11015664786100388,
-0.03885042667388916,
-0.0789029523730278,
-0.08340952545404434,
-0.5940121412277222,
-0.8163329362869263,
1.0200697183609009,
0.46588656306266785,
1.0570720434188843,
0.05733203515410423,
0.4852559268474579,
0.6026058197021484,
0.1368817389011383,
-0.5207483768463135,
0.6406729817390442,
-0.028884362429380417,
-0.747404932975769,
-0.43408769369125366,
-0.3555563986301422,
-0.8372862935066223,
0.15038368105888367,
-0.13899390399456024,
-0.9271047115325928,
0.2867392897605896,
0.08368438482284546,
-0.5299252271652222,
-0.026125486940145493,
-0.7116011381149292,
0.6165447235107422,
-0.0015604601940140128,
-0.6486269235610962,
0.028507422655820847,
-0.5739437341690063,
0.15413326025009155,
-0.0208792332559824,
0.2361055165529251,
-0.39055007696151733,
0.10804428160190582,
0.6603286862373352,
-0.060093436390161514,
1.517903208732605,
-0.32194334268569946,
-0.29405996203422546,
0.08668114989995956,
0.11616221070289612,
0.8714660406112671,
0.09467761963605881,
-0.4051215946674347,
0.10102742165327072,
-0.1913144290447235,
-0.33537858724594116,
-0.45439592003822327,
0.9399670362472534,
-0.8593618273735046,
-1.0642709732055664,
-0.25906336307525635,
-0.7753413319587708,
-0.2413255125284195,
-0.10083223134279251,
0.48646098375320435,
0.49529600143432617,
-0.15722399950027466,
0.011467263102531433,
0.5627201795578003,
-0.6272221207618713,
0.2771386206150055,
0.4423825144767761,
-0.12287439405918121,
0.14508861303329468,
0.28628525137901306,
0.3390226364135742,
0.6031914353370667,
0.029905153438448906,
0.36784932017326355,
-0.2427666038274765,
-0.26548758149147034,
-0.535426676273346,
0.17724643647670746,
-0.8878139853477478,
0.0181993767619133,
-0.5870777368545532,
0.24038198590278625,
-0.8935914039611816,
-0.2352050542831421,
0.029889332130551338,
-0.2801876962184906,
-0.32439085841178894,
-0.21205094456672668,
0.45451951026916504,
0.8950631618499756,
0.13118745386600494,
0.21401961147785187,
-0.49408280849456787,
0.04477290064096451,
0.2096949964761734,
0.08309992402791977,
0.13748382031917572,
-0.7577846050262451,
0.007804307155311108,
0.020532280206680298,
-0.12438487261533737,
-1.1339974403381348,
0.00720776105299592,
-0.2017054408788681,
0.6505898237228394,
0.25572144985198975,
0.26556459069252014,
0.18524488806724548,
-0.46307504177093506,
0.9689501523971558,
0.05928187072277069,
-1.0522743463516235,
0.47879689931869507,
-0.5546679496765137,
0.4779149889945984,
0.43607836961746216,
0.32477110624313354,
-0.5551376342773438,
-0.6237860321998596,
-0.2342311441898346,
-0.8338377475738525,
0.7864335179328918,
-0.15433795750141144,
0.4158870279788971,
-0.21388450264930725,
0.28178027272224426,
0.3339110314846039,
0.23873692750930786,
-0.723925769329071,
-0.5011855363845825,
0.15436629951000214,
0.0796227678656578,
-0.11704535782337189,
-0.7035838961601257,
-0.12316615134477615,
-0.1643591672182083,
0.463754266500473,
0.02406357415020466,
-0.1261727213859558,
0.03412800654768944,
-0.04234631732106209,
-0.26849886775016785,
0.4972124993801117,
0.6690245866775513,
0.6835851669311523,
0.011037240736186504,
0.15612682700157166,
0.39548999071121216,
-0.24672986567020416,
0.23835361003875732,
-0.1821983903646469,
-0.5720196962356567,
0.18978171050548553,
0.3587205111980438,
1.2247060537338257,
0.07259541004896164,
-0.4640047550201416,
0.44773173332214355,
0.13557328283786774,
0.16570496559143066,
0.028988990932703018,
0.2393580675125122,
0.09092654287815094,
0.393286794424057,
0.2097233235836029,
-0.09040055423974991,
0.37062060832977295,
-0.6175107359886169,
-0.38672223687171936,
0.48531821370124817,
-0.25190722942352295,
-0.13988523185253143,
0.47264939546585083,
0.38927730917930603,
-0.42629504203796387,
0.17057159543037415,
-0.25541600584983826,
-0.414629191160202,
0.8028370141983032,
0.6104949712753296,
0.7649818658828735,
-0.46241214871406555,
0.35805246233940125,
0.17950783669948578,
0.5121392607688904,
0.11342012882232666,
0.3260839581489563,
0.23856070637702942,
-0.5982776284217834,
-0.6190748810768127,
-0.4044186770915985,
-0.3728334605693817,
0.14706933498382568,
-0.5700321793556213,
0.4055899381637573,
-0.3095892667770386,
-0.49532267451286316,
-0.022917047142982483,
-0.20087507367134094,
-0.7521418929100037,
-0.15710626542568207,
0.15605783462524414,
0.7411364912986755,
-1.065862774848938,
0.4079078137874603,
0.8733131289482117,
-0.006582064088433981,
-0.6157501339912415,
0.05690950155258179,
0.16940587759017944,
-0.7262269854545593,
1.000675916671753,
0.26865074038505554,
-0.2422405630350113,
-0.31490829586982727,
-0.47482481598854065,
-0.8116183280944824,
0.5998533964157104,
0.7600281834602356,
-0.8277495503425598,
0.04147641360759735,
0.30147117376327515,
0.4938111901283264,
-0.4986281096935272,
0.44804441928863525,
0.5107352137565613,
0.5412415862083435,
-0.1432468593120575,
-0.7941415309906006,
0.5024056434631348,
0.030209900811314583,
0.33957439661026,
-0.16619493067264557,
-0.6468427181243896,
1.0411453247070312,
-0.27064886689186096,
-0.17396126687526703,
-0.29339247941970825,
0.13086552917957306,
0.5483580827713013,
0.429425448179245,
0.6279122829437256,
-0.2778254449367523,
0.5562465190887451,
-0.05933146923780441,
1.032910943031311,
-0.20144878327846527,
0.09561367332935333,
1.153043270111084,
-0.7818690538406372,
0.212185800075531,
0.5723558068275452,
-0.12738913297653198,
0.37409070134162903,
0.6971105337142944,
0.22046948969364166,
0.26845765113830566,
0.7400122880935669,
-0.2656209170818329,
-0.26730769872665405,
-0.40076684951782227,
-0.3250974714756012,
0.10380374640226364,
0.15527571737766266,
-0.41516026854515076,
-0.07837115228176117,
0.02907649055123329,
0.28694531321525574,
-0.0022659089881926775,
-0.36391982436180115,
0.4091089963912964,
0.1151013970375061,
-0.8308704495429993,
0.5040839910507202,
-0.1430674046278,
0.9285897016525269,
-0.4777376055717468,
0.08816933631896973,
-0.3244816064834595,
-0.04728877171874046,
-0.17136380076408386,
-0.5177298784255981,
-0.0664839893579483,
0.13001613318920135,
-0.3146403431892395,
0.006068318150937557,
0.9071170091629028,
-0.11843160539865494,
-0.4023500680923462,
0.49395114183425903,
0.45114848017692566,
0.06032668054103851,
-0.17017154395580292,
-0.49238449335098267,
0.5311040878295898,
0.15858560800552368,
-0.5738208293914795,
0.3222595453262329,
0.5355716943740845,
-0.18419882655143738,
0.5330663323402405,
0.5061607360839844,
0.15394370257854462,
0.24414314329624176,
0.445549339056015,
0.9571738839149475,
-0.37158048152923584,
-0.2489800900220871,
-1.1572597026824951,
0.24501264095306396,
-0.17723865807056427,
-0.4102400541305542,
0.9374933838844299,
0.2968332767486572,
0.5896198153495789,
-0.1784789264202118,
0.8762996792793274,
0.16389338672161102,
0.5252787470817566,
-0.42799684405326843,
0.4203248918056488,
-0.3230091631412506,
0.46527236700057983,
-0.6920236349105835,
-0.9880064725875854,
0.12368031591176987,
0.3622570037841797,
-0.7368178963661194,
0.24214519560337067,
0.5005382299423218,
0.8310694098472595,
0.3913356363773346,
-0.07764989137649536,
0.40077993273735046,
0.22995798289775848,
0.18294650316238403,
0.38608986139297485,
1.0250027179718018,
0.16968725621700287,
0.20065762102603912,
-0.031688325107097626,
-0.3220691680908203,
-0.38629990816116333,
-0.9186353087425232,
-1.0917820930480957,
-0.34129399061203003,
-0.3340860903263092,
-0.4679894745349884,
0.4544376730918884,
1.1255862712860107,
0.2866347134113312,
-0.622882604598999,
-0.33665430545806885,
0.36943069100379944,
0.3633049726486206,
-0.005248594097793102,
-0.27084770798683167,
0.24000303447246552,
-0.39092785120010376,
-0.8884914517402649,
0.13134746253490448,
0.06931669265031815,
-0.15664216876029968,
-0.3310796022415161,
-0.06998785585165024,
-0.01812678761780262,
0.26630541682243347,
0.7320979237556458,
-0.18506202101707458,
-0.6843053698539734,
-0.5619053244590759,
0.24664318561553955,
-0.2573835551738739,
-0.22145716845989227,
0.7456286549568176,
-0.38522395491600037,
0.13417480885982513,
0.7234822511672974,
0.37876591086387634,
0.03361725062131882,
-0.19240084290504456,
0.656971275806427,
-0.7394434213638306,
-0.013436295092105865,
0.030416792258620262,
0.4885546565055847,
0.4215537905693054,
-0.6288119554519653,
0.22920960187911987,
0.11142928153276443,
-0.7010858654975891,
-0.7059159874916077,
0.39094898104667664,
-0.7333968281745911,
-0.2530565559864044,
1.961603045463562,
-0.09274626523256302,
0.014668434858322144,
-0.1207001581788063,
-0.5567942261695862,
0.3583124279975891,
-0.8564716577529907,
0.9260457754135132,
1.1305694580078125,
0.13796459138393402,
0.037365853786468506,
-0.6207225322723389,
0.44911989569664,
0.6335135102272034,
-0.48881933093070984,
0.2980421483516693,
0.8141598701477051,
0.3885689079761505,
-0.10358680039644241,
0.7013730406761169,
0.028136683627963066,
0.036822978407144547,
-0.32537567615509033,
-0.0710684210062027,
0.2639484703540802,
-0.11851876229047775,
-0.533545196056366,
-0.12232000380754471,
0.4016284942626953,
0.07042928040027618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03104v1 | KeyVideoLLM: Towards Large-scale Video Keyframe Selection | 2024-07-03T13:41:44 | 2024-07-03T13:41:44 | Hao Liang, Jiapeng Li, Tianyi Bai, Chong Chen, Conghui He, Bin Cui, Wentao Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | Recently, with the rise of web videos, managing and understanding large-scale
video datasets has become increasingly important. Video Large Language Models
(VideoLLMs) have emerged in recent years due to their strong video
understanding capabilities. However, training and inference processes for
VideoLLMs demand vast amounts of data, presenting significant challenges to
data management, particularly regarding efficiency, robustness, and
effectiveness. In this work, we present KeyVideoLLM, a text-video frame
similarity-based keyframe selection method designed to manage VideoLLM data
efficiently, robustly, and effectively. Specifically, KeyVideoLLM achieves a
remarkable data compression rate of up to 60.9 times, substantially lowering
disk space requirements, which proves its high efficiency. Additionally, it
maintains a 100% selection success rate across all video formats and scales,
enhances processing speed by up to 200 times compared to existing keyframe
selection methods, and does not require hyperparameter tuning. Beyond its
outstanding efficiency and robustness, KeyVideoLLM further improves model
performance in video question-answering tasks during both training and
inference stages. Notably, it consistently achieved the state-of-the-art (SoTA)
experimental results on diverse datasets. | [
-0.49838095903396606,
-0.768807590007782,
0.3195318877696991,
0.14139114320278168,
-0.6622067093849182,
0.001120055909268558,
-0.45691147446632385,
0.12259922921657562,
-0.12933292984962463,
0.500199556350708,
-0.3996107876300812,
-0.6827844381332397,
-0.7899294495582581,
-0.16044718027114868,
-0.5757901668548584,
0.5472591519355774,
-0.049695923924446106,
0.11048991978168488,
-0.4366789758205414,
-0.28874897956848145,
-0.3073008060455322,
-0.23281753063201904,
-0.4002550542354584,
-0.006289155222475529,
-0.12021990120410919,
0.41331085562705994,
1.016839623451233,
0.9874926805496216,
0.8772162795066833,
0.2899388074874878,
-0.32887107133865356,
0.12380081415176392,
-0.5095361471176147,
0.3514363467693329,
-0.019551124423742294,
-0.36918312311172485,
-0.22542381286621094,
-0.24564984440803528,
0.7939432859420776,
0.22426556050777435,
0.15383689105510712,
0.6468510031700134,
-0.06444299966096878,
0.5807182788848877,
-0.8229445219039917,
0.3080970048904419,
-0.8131428956985474,
0.37207433581352234,
0.05360238999128342,
-0.18524594604969025,
-0.08125517517328262,
-0.4646838307380676,
0.07312986999750137,
-0.47768890857696533,
0.44454482197761536,
0.14581571519374847,
0.695988118648529,
0.5161896347999573,
-0.04518336430191994,
0.2044602334499359,
-0.5116606950759888,
0.4317459464073181,
-0.5990033149719238,
0.7214862704277039,
0.5631458163261414,
0.3681631088256836,
0.175729438662529,
-0.5423781275749207,
-0.5184694528579712,
0.12043469399213791,
0.5547146201133728,
-0.17730970680713654,
0.0427003838121891,
0.223989799618721,
0.4925968647003174,
0.38850143551826477,
-1.129628300666809,
0.15115371346473694,
-0.29111409187316895,
-0.13801172375679016,
0.2860240042209625,
0.23390933871269226,
0.26373645663261414,
-0.3148699104785919,
-0.1476050317287445,
-0.5504310131072998,
-0.5866819620132446,
-0.1266869604587555,
0.2142663598060608,
0.02948521263897419,
0.14758802950382233,
0.5035277009010315,
-0.22325745224952698,
0.7804932594299316,
-0.22204938530921936,
-0.4260205924510956,
0.17696602642536163,
0.007423590403050184,
-0.8062555193901062,
0.008266311138868332,
0.679761528968811,
0.9036152958869934,
0.19322024285793304,
-0.09111864119768143,
0.39752933382987976,
0.21054977178573608,
0.09697200357913971,
-1.341127634048462,
-0.2156960368156433,
0.23211334645748138,
-0.7455458641052246,
-0.028652213513851166,
0.23825064301490784,
-1.034177541732788,
-0.2253013402223587,
0.03942866250872612,
0.47000813484191895,
-0.4123779833316803,
-0.21163572371006012,
0.03272482380270958,
-0.23450104892253876,
0.48797520995140076,
0.3510154187679291,
-0.8073326349258423,
0.1662587672472,
0.6527504920959473,
0.844830334186554,
-0.43951642513275146,
-0.17400255799293518,
-1.0193184614181519,
0.09885181486606598,
-0.45013993978500366,
0.2421884685754776,
-0.743753969669342,
-0.13345058262348175,
0.21494144201278687,
-0.1597331464290619,
0.026538176462054253,
-0.7975504994392395,
0.1816347986459732,
-0.9011417627334595,
-0.09904073923826218,
0.17011433839797974,
-0.6776672005653381,
-0.2672504484653473,
0.4666878283023834,
-0.8150749802589417,
0.9493096470832825,
-0.289561927318573,
-0.4871467351913452,
0.5498442649841309,
-0.021125461906194687,
-0.26296332478523254,
0.006607688032090664,
-0.24549782276153564,
-0.8035513162612915,
0.0067727230489254,
0.30534228682518005,
0.7483973503112793,
-0.45456016063690186,
0.3073539435863495,
-0.649164080619812,
-0.2573029696941376,
0.18563640117645264,
-0.647278368473053,
-0.0639481246471405,
0.32896217703819275,
-0.2071038782596588,
-0.11028766632080078,
-0.6399189829826355,
0.16784247756004333,
-0.3114398717880249,
-0.05375662446022034,
-0.27583304047584534,
-0.20009014010429382,
0.30098897218704224,
0.16487297415733337,
-0.08806777000427246,
-0.29921555519104004,
-0.01796732284128666,
0.03134393319487572,
0.7784433364868164,
0.4891296923160553,
-0.17727379500865936,
0.44557660818099976,
0.00975433737039566,
0.8454928398132324,
-0.2418358027935028,
0.24913093447685242,
-0.349681556224823,
-0.21675309538841248,
-0.1539916694164276,
-0.11759265512228012,
0.20392733812332153,
0.2905426621437073,
-0.6295129656791687,
0.07638682425022125,
-0.34143292903900146,
-0.12403988093137741,
-0.2741144597530365,
0.46681517362594604,
0.3776928782463074,
0.2174835056066513,
0.322953462600708,
-0.2163698822259903,
-0.3305739462375641,
-0.5040018558502197,
0.0027976250275969505,
-0.2832748293876648,
-0.08109249919652939,
0.3302846848964691,
0.2604704201221466,
0.016521217301487923,
0.9296024441719055,
-0.8953250646591187,
-0.3074837625026703,
-0.17964424192905426,
0.09292201697826385,
0.0525582954287529,
0.3171582818031311,
0.3561095893383026,
-1.3492050170898438,
-0.5406213998794556,
-0.18219584226608276,
-0.7047643065452576,
0.2819308042526245,
-0.19963854551315308,
0.08208998292684555,
-0.3686276972293854,
0.8874490261077881,
-0.6343691349029541,
0.3210708796977997,
0.4755076467990875,
-0.15415720641613007,
0.31851524114608765,
-0.15515466034412384,
0.404705673456192,
-1.0949985980987549,
-0.05681087449193001,
-0.09150712937116623,
-0.5041061639785767,
-0.11564739793539047,
0.15348204970359802,
0.16099922358989716,
-0.2833418846130371,
-0.7781534790992737,
0.41540855169296265,
-0.28344109654426575,
-0.30514100193977356,
-0.0493861548602581,
0.1651647537946701,
-0.18314331769943237,
0.4898608922958374,
0.33913490176200867,
0.8308523893356323,
0.7811527848243713,
-0.5604691505432129,
0.4598581790924072,
0.5794766545295715,
-0.4117372930049896,
0.5003504753112793,
-0.4009891152381897,
-0.04967908188700676,
-0.44424933195114136,
-0.2014581710100174,
-1.1411579847335815,
-0.38165873289108276,
-0.3362483084201813,
-0.38890886306762695,
0.2774859070777893,
-0.2984485924243927,
-0.24040614068508148,
-0.30778247117996216,
-0.5332738757133484,
0.4037419557571411,
0.5081413984298706,
-0.5500664114952087,
0.4297625422477722,
0.48166143894195557,
-0.32984262704849243,
-0.436789870262146,
-0.3562781512737274,
0.23779989778995514,
-0.6155436038970947,
-0.5136305689811707,
0.39595597982406616,
-0.13665445148944855,
-0.02675042673945427,
0.05458700284361839,
-0.5960701107978821,
-0.423896849155426,
-0.09186331182718277,
0.48763707280158997,
0.289002925157547,
-0.22325584292411804,
0.2073981612920761,
0.018943453207612038,
0.0895889401435852,
0.026683518663048744,
-0.1576807200908661,
0.33739525079727173,
0.08866177499294281,
0.006678666919469833,
-0.07306981086730957,
0.15814273059368134,
0.7471407651901245,
-0.3330792486667633,
0.3825192153453827,
0.8172430992126465,
-0.24968430399894714,
-0.3113866150379181,
-0.708118736743927,
-0.17770883440971375,
-0.42138010263442993,
0.8224654793739319,
-0.2224985510110855,
-1.2154837846755981,
0.2209496647119522,
-0.11704542487859726,
-0.11904357373714447,
-0.13355058431625366,
0.4767889082431793,
-0.05397208407521248,
0.8245972990989685,
0.2660463750362396,
-0.23840078711509705,
0.7776796817779541,
-0.5226150155067444,
-0.24075466394424438,
-0.5939851403236389,
-0.06754627078771591,
-0.2582435607910156,
-0.1931566298007965,
-0.21394257247447968,
-0.9023314118385315,
0.473908007144928,
0.13147874176502228,
-0.28396520018577576,
0.5296245813369751,
0.02321700192987919,
0.8600698113441467,
0.051238156855106354,
0.16384808719158173,
0.28865519165992737,
0.05908088758587837,
0.11757581681013107,
-0.1859845221042633,
-0.6372359395027161,
-0.3965121805667877,
1.296520471572876,
0.30339139699935913,
1.0996243953704834,
0.21261785924434662,
0.12776760756969452,
0.3737863600254059,
-0.23392003774642944,
-0.6754446625709534,
0.7155558466911316,
-0.44000834226608276,
-0.29732781648635864,
-0.4727419912815094,
-0.2951514720916748,
-0.7668346166610718,
0.26699528098106384,
-0.2058304399251938,
-0.6100262999534607,
-0.4410511255264282,
0.14250683784484863,
-0.7028623223304749,
0.32699334621429443,
-0.24043139815330505,
1.081830620765686,
0.023525385186076164,
-0.619878351688385,
-0.5329134464263916,
-0.8551678657531738,
0.25179800391197205,
0.0405237190425396,
0.06323916465044022,
-0.12383944541215897,
0.10646385699510574,
0.7906991839408875,
-0.545798122882843,
0.29693034291267395,
0.07209929078817368,
0.38866204023361206,
0.38582202792167664,
0.16370542347431183,
0.2318064123392105,
0.5105695128440857,
0.3465082049369812,
-0.2374575287103653,
-0.003538825549185276,
0.11238083243370056,
-0.7763532400131226,
0.5812166333198547,
-0.5299409031867981,
-0.603216826915741,
-0.1293066143989563,
-0.3728891909122467,
-0.3313429057598114,
0.07980222254991531,
0.037295326590538025,
0.6685935258865356,
-0.3133578896522522,
0.9066718220710754,
1.1878560781478882,
-0.3234456777572632,
0.7257541418075562,
0.2289399355649948,
-0.328449010848999,
-0.618777871131897,
0.7526547908782959,
-0.33380380272865295,
0.40379488468170166,
0.7397929430007935,
-0.14268384873867035,
-0.5359105467796326,
-0.5733606219291687,
-0.4774892330169678,
-0.13292847573757172,
-0.4958633780479431,
-0.57783043384552,
-0.6239573955535889,
-0.18264338374137878,
-0.37248721718788147,
0.13617350161075592,
-0.42566660046577454,
-0.2658921480178833,
-0.23458342254161835,
-0.5288796424865723,
0.6225495934486389,
-0.14559026062488556,
0.24627211689949036,
0.36549079418182373,
-0.9689669609069824,
0.8946750164031982,
0.8490526676177979,
0.3242773115634918,
-0.18749676644802094,
-0.6027824282646179,
-0.22359898686408997,
-0.4306735098361969,
-0.3803969621658325,
-0.7111577391624451,
0.4596215784549713,
0.7147849202156067,
0.3391285538673401,
0.5780434012413025,
-0.13650241494178772,
0.9165472984313965,
-0.4931831359863281,
0.7574387192726135,
0.205002099275589,
-0.6969537138938904,
0.4148879051208496,
-0.06373973190784454,
0.34375715255737305,
0.6820816397666931,
0.4128437340259552,
-0.5447731018066406,
-0.32815220952033997,
-0.3042827546596527,
-0.8021015524864197,
0.40078404545783997,
0.3419547975063324,
0.2045878916978836,
0.17676743865013123,
0.0891127809882164,
0.1006566658616066,
0.3996928930282593,
-0.2671862840652466,
-0.0322255939245224,
-0.24094338715076447,
-0.10366696864366531,
-0.04378509894013405,
0.16054411232471466,
0.2698670029640198,
0.008966803550720215,
0.3788028657436371,
-0.5142102241516113,
-0.029670588672161102,
0.21908436715602875,
-0.696850061416626,
-0.19113823771476746,
0.30655738711357117,
0.20993198454380035,
0.6062830090522766,
-0.473256915807724,
0.16169187426567078,
0.1604028046131134,
-0.8552718162536621,
0.29124462604522705,
-0.05907884240150452,
-0.12459184229373932,
0.14067576825618744,
0.2707138657569885,
1.1392322778701782,
0.3379025459289551,
-1.1246241331100464,
0.7714268565177917,
-0.07090289890766144,
-0.2351256012916565,
-0.1065790206193924,
0.2624402344226837,
-0.24071817100048065,
0.5149513483047485,
0.46528831124305725,
-0.140284925699234,
0.19230151176452637,
-0.6421582102775574,
0.43830016255378723,
0.6766396164894104,
-0.17752660810947418,
-0.16516923904418945,
1.1683470010757446,
-0.03855627402663231,
-0.2687653601169586,
0.6887168884277344,
0.017809109762310982,
-0.47755324840545654,
0.7701866626739502,
0.004464279860258102,
0.9248327016830444,
-0.05124777927994728,
0.609675943851471,
0.34290140867233276,
-0.035789765417575836,
-0.5346694588661194,
0.30412086844444275,
-0.2892785370349884,
-0.5805468559265137,
-0.6579824686050415,
-0.7905341386795044,
-0.4618311822414398,
0.43750396370887756,
-0.9331002831459045,
0.3361574113368988,
-0.39216065406799316,
-0.31618374586105347,
-0.20288024842739105,
-0.23162955045700073,
-0.8539315462112427,
0.45806723833084106,
0.4929918646812439,
1.2193992137908936,
-0.9294217824935913,
0.9105801582336426,
0.42637231945991516,
-0.1913226693868637,
-0.6713686585426331,
-0.19520540535449982,
-0.09863895177841187,
-0.5790853500366211,
0.5782920122146606,
0.18358878791332245,
0.3468630015850067,
-0.11559710651636124,
-0.2337280958890915,
-0.8254477977752686,
1.1806141138076782,
0.3618358373641968,
-0.6002557873725891,
-0.3682868480682373,
0.4572071433067322,
0.2970316410064697,
-0.1795322597026825,
0.3458886444568634,
0.5304924845695496,
0.18047362565994263,
0.5311329960823059,
-0.8282292485237122,
-0.2112867534160614,
0.04185691103339195,
0.4184870421886444,
0.26714053750038147,
-0.7342276573181152,
0.45326220989227295,
-0.16842332482337952,
0.26312145590782166,
0.06397272646427155,
0.8434253931045532,
0.14959999918937683,
0.24634571373462677,
0.4829971492290497,
0.5872960090637207,
0.2741783559322357,
0.2673720121383667,
0.1771702766418457,
-0.2870238423347473,
0.4325871169567108,
1.19107186794281,
-0.1913575530052185,
0.9816188216209412,
0.6730204224586487,
-0.37069204449653625,
-0.014371839351952076,
0.6254884004592896,
-0.23886297643184662,
0.669791042804718,
-0.09977111965417862,
0.09244567900896072,
-0.6003692746162415,
0.2901150584220886,
-0.3257693946361542,
0.6346330642700195,
0.18171286582946777,
-0.44195556640625,
-0.27265703678131104,
0.3830556571483612,
-0.1734507977962494,
0.05217453092336655,
-0.8118962645530701,
0.7424533367156982,
0.05990105867385864,
-0.60416179895401,
0.3628027141094208,
-0.31165021657943726,
0.4835992157459259,
-0.6208882331848145,
0.023682456463575363,
-0.23529529571533203,
0.03266502544283867,
-0.15446680784225464,
-0.7563913464546204,
0.28195884823799133,
0.3700951039791107,
-0.1034027487039566,
-0.334817111492157,
0.5316652655601501,
-0.7448278665542603,
-0.24847574532032013,
-0.1944284737110138,
0.2128814309835434,
0.08834974467754364,
-0.39564165472984314,
-0.459803968667984,
0.4504058063030243,
-0.3013840317726135,
-0.05580686405301094,
0.5103496313095093,
0.05869743227958679,
-0.08495518565177917,
0.6456961035728455,
0.4082440435886383,
0.12587159872055054,
0.053646545857191086,
-0.19349417090415955,
0.6645442843437195,
-0.6032633781433105,
-0.6718257069587708,
-1.0189076662063599,
0.05557485297322273,
-0.10316935926675797,
-0.22490474581718445,
0.8108347058296204,
0.9196779131889343,
0.8347733616828918,
-0.275088369846344,
0.6466076970100403,
-0.02874908037483692,
0.07715978473424911,
-0.8662673830986023,
0.27234160900115967,
-0.28114214539527893,
-0.033185575157403946,
-0.6128580570220947,
-1.2041175365447998,
-0.34668049216270447,
0.5735459327697754,
-0.16156211495399475,
-0.3945029079914093,
0.6786479353904724,
0.9476838707923889,
-0.2623743414878845,
0.1155712753534317,
0.4556678533554077,
0.16147373616695404,
0.1537494957447052,
0.6611994504928589,
0.5925173759460449,
-0.571280300617218,
0.9984486103057861,
0.1946607083082199,
0.08551779389381409,
-0.3043668270111084,
-0.9729068875312805,
-1.0033893585205078,
-0.5512987971305847,
-0.7097373604774475,
-0.11489348113536835,
0.14037883281707764,
1.1830488443374634,
0.9914695024490356,
-0.6501785516738892,
-0.2625287175178528,
0.09020167589187622,
0.17750714719295502,
-0.34474971890449524,
-0.17009933292865753,
0.3611591160297394,
0.16546645760536194,
-0.6565372943878174,
0.12529020011425018,
0.5330617427825928,
-0.18194854259490967,
-0.23181214928627014,
-0.21761713922023773,
0.27430659532546997,
-0.20492295920848846,
0.6546284556388855,
0.3581724166870117,
-0.3815456032752991,
-0.08561229705810547,
0.23922258615493774,
0.1525413990020752,
0.2899264991283417,
0.9670321941375732,
-0.7076532244682312,
0.5070610046386719,
0.7016328573226929,
0.9317523837089539,
1.1880931854248047,
0.051068250089883804,
0.3065985143184662,
-0.4664461612701416,
0.23552340269088745,
0.16359253227710724,
0.22610005736351013,
0.29091960191726685,
-0.12108580768108368,
0.33530479669570923,
0.037445008754730225,
-0.38249441981315613,
-0.902265191078186,
-0.007407463621348143,
-0.9557057619094849,
-0.3579353392124176,
1.4088985919952393,
-0.14829887449741364,
-0.25086793303489685,
0.21306318044662476,
-0.29578033089637756,
0.1344088912010193,
-0.2846029996871948,
0.7316993474960327,
0.6359220147132874,
0.27120575308799744,
-0.5669015645980835,
-0.5010823011398315,
0.6908098459243774,
0.38532692193984985,
-0.6028892993927002,
0.0951324850320816,
0.3510577380657196,
0.3366008698940277,
-0.457208514213562,
0.26602375507354736,
0.10448647290468216,
0.5274025797843933,
-0.3692993223667145,
-0.3850424587726593,
-0.11211758852005005,
-0.45144903659820557,
-0.4363750219345093,
0.7158715128898621,
-0.08989271521568298,
-0.44723886251449585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03103v1 | Cactus: Towards Psychological Counseling Conversations using Cognitive Behavioral Theory | 2024-07-03T13:41:31 | 2024-07-03T13:41:31 | Suyeon Lee, Sunghwan Kim, Minju Kim, Dongjin Kang, Dongil Yang, Harim Kim, Minseok Kang, Dayi Jung, Min Hee Kim, Seungbeen Lee, Kyoung-Mee Chung, Youngjae Yu, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, the demand for psychological counseling has significantly increased
as more individuals express concerns about their mental health. This surge has
accelerated efforts to improve the accessibility of counseling by using large
language models (LLMs) as counselors. To ensure client privacy, training
open-source LLMs faces a key challenge: the absence of realistic counseling
datasets. To address this, we introduce Cactus, a multi-turn dialogue dataset
that emulates real-life interactions using the goal-oriented and structured
approach of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). We create a diverse and
realistic dataset by designing clients with varied, specific personas, and
having counselors systematically apply CBT techniques in their interactions. To
assess the quality of our data, we benchmark against established psychological
criteria used to evaluate real counseling sessions, ensuring alignment with
expert evaluations. Experimental results demonstrate that Camel, a model
trained with Cactus, outperforms other models in counseling skills,
highlighting its effectiveness and potential as a counseling agent. We make our
data, model, and code publicly available. | [
-0.2571331858634949,
-0.806289792060852,
0.5563749074935913,
0.7901142239570618,
-0.018790939822793007,
0.11264999955892563,
-0.6501752138137817,
-0.4514188766479492,
0.0754271075129509,
0.3674600422382355,
-1.1496483087539673,
-0.7832490801811218,
-0.3691302239894867,
-0.12006489187479019,
-0.24389706552028656,
1.1214890480041504,
0.24137413501739502,
0.3649761378765106,
-0.004350137431174517,
-0.02249975875020027,
-0.7877679467201233,
-0.32000619173049927,
-0.6854588389396667,
-0.1851644217967987,
0.4694881737232208,
0.32618284225463867,
1.0614780187606812,
0.4066080152988434,
0.1586146503686905,
0.180693581700325,
0.11429426819086075,
-0.013543650507926941,
-0.7438956499099731,
-0.06898392736911774,
-0.09322214126586914,
-0.40305033326148987,
-0.3770025372505188,
0.23689977824687958,
0.34654173254966736,
0.741806149482727,
-0.6450607180595398,
-0.03454514220356941,
-0.035541635006666183,
0.23540468513965607,
-0.5593039393424988,
0.36252614855766296,
-0.7749109268188477,
0.2972088158130646,
0.036727480590343475,
0.07649289816617966,
-0.6446398496627808,
-0.658983051776886,
0.36772897839546204,
-0.9062302708625793,
0.2937745451927185,
-0.15718425810337067,
0.4654926359653473,
0.3314022421836853,
-0.4666782021522522,
-0.25751811265945435,
-0.9768927693367004,
0.7239856123924255,
-0.5725888013839722,
0.46401455998420715,
0.704224169254303,
0.254470556974411,
-0.6309551000595093,
-0.5417154431343079,
-0.4673177897930145,
-0.41031986474990845,
-0.07152865082025528,
0.2349381297826767,
-0.07410447299480438,
0.096866175532341,
0.1952005922794342,
0.30290335416793823,
-0.23208923637866974,
-0.17167825996875763,
-0.18415771424770355,
-0.2151295244693756,
0.5721824765205383,
0.530489981174469,
0.15719948709011078,
0.42810696363449097,
-0.12835942208766937,
-0.023686686530709267,
-0.47145482897758484,
0.3950989544391632,
0.24636881053447723,
0.29514816403388977,
-0.048222336918115616,
0.39898744225502014,
0.1386530101299286,
0.5838567614555359,
-0.12376715242862701,
-0.3817528784275055,
-0.38142839074134827,
-0.024081047624349594,
-0.08456047624349594,
0.21363219618797302,
0.8730362057685852,
0.40684786438941956,
0.1980886608362198,
-0.264701247215271,
0.4204337000846863,
0.30638623237609863,
0.6670565605163574,
-0.7155333161354065,
-0.38985031843185425,
0.3013831079006195,
-0.3184719979763031,
-0.23003073036670685,
-0.1768198013305664,
-0.6137564778327942,
-0.4955067038536072,
-0.46038660407066345,
-0.36324337124824524,
-0.6789232492446899,
-0.30641692876815796,
0.09545303136110306,
0.09460722655057907,
0.36230751872062683,
0.4015060067176819,
-0.6717825531959534,
0.8031112551689148,
0.8810588717460632,
0.8014315962791443,
-0.17735496163368225,
-0.32252755761146545,
-0.4600699841976166,
0.40038490295410156,
-0.46634921431541443,
0.6580474972724915,
-0.8627243638038635,
-0.7454283833503723,
0.21143698692321777,
0.03769572824239731,
0.08495680242776871,
-0.11259102821350098,
0.5033950805664062,
0.03809947147965431,
0.21500413119792938,
-0.47576746344566345,
-0.33187171816825867,
0.27306845784187317,
0.5728830695152283,
-0.24364687502384186,
0.8801146745681763,
0.209678053855896,
-0.7734140753746033,
0.4381113648414612,
-0.7659627795219421,
-0.3013926148414612,
0.008424928411841393,
-0.33571720123291016,
-0.3494377136230469,
-0.2049437314271927,
0.127567857503891,
0.06273823231458664,
-0.35211366415023804,
0.20523229241371155,
-0.6907511353492737,
-0.4686513841152191,
0.7338553667068481,
-0.3688237965106964,
0.6174377799034119,
0.30548375844955444,
0.018407432362437248,
0.1400873363018036,
-0.7697046399116516,
0.14897391200065613,
0.04419141635298729,
-0.4280757009983063,
-0.29446738958358765,
0.03761691972613335,
-0.03866559639573097,
-0.05613366514444351,
-0.06365793198347092,
-1.0980111360549927,
0.40118423104286194,
-0.4223807156085968,
0.5495489835739136,
0.5548616647720337,
-0.01476194616407156,
-0.016953106969594955,
-0.21357719600200653,
0.45065417885780334,
0.03318461403250694,
0.5536881685256958,
0.04962458461523056,
-0.5946015119552612,
-0.442229688167572,
-0.417259156703949,
-0.276614248752594,
0.40010198950767517,
-0.4232717454433441,
0.28747203946113586,
0.06571377068758011,
-0.8960126042366028,
-0.5947014093399048,
0.09308023005723953,
0.5038787722587585,
0.4141012132167816,
0.2956252992153168,
-0.5640735626220703,
-0.017424728721380234,
-0.6125831604003906,
-0.3401651680469513,
-0.1599452644586563,
0.11571762710809708,
0.4408871829509735,
-0.009001112543046474,
-0.12273309379816055,
1.4277293682098389,
-0.9577211141586304,
-0.3748612701892853,
-0.11750873178243637,
0.21077248454093933,
0.11142108589410782,
0.59534752368927,
0.4562825560569763,
-0.37158897519111633,
-0.3969418704509735,
-0.23505692183971405,
-0.6218889355659485,
0.12676255404949188,
-0.14505577087402344,
-0.35024359822273254,
-0.2346557080745697,
0.052521321922540665,
-0.5623407959938049,
0.7704700231552124,
0.22892829775810242,
-0.2444695681333542,
0.6140857934951782,
-0.42482781410217285,
-0.11491384357213974,
-0.7463040351867676,
-0.21149811148643494,
0.13375696539878845,
-0.05439639836549759,
-0.6441106200218201,
-0.31977587938308716,
0.024346379563212395,
-0.48440274596214294,
-0.6094873547554016,
-0.010663867928087711,
-0.2376871109008789,
-0.19831503927707672,
-0.19553551077842712,
-0.11680202931165695,
-0.34713631868362427,
0.8959723114967346,
0.3903551697731018,
0.8669443130493164,
0.48044949769973755,
-0.48812317848205566,
0.5373042821884155,
0.7855079770088196,
-0.07572115957736969,
0.9908046126365662,
-0.5955447554588318,
0.34006088972091675,
-0.01923503167927265,
0.7610719799995422,
-0.755754292011261,
-0.03540439158678055,
0.4162333011627197,
-0.043371714651584625,
-0.06607351452112198,
-0.12713979184627533,
-0.17992925643920898,
-0.3515929579734802,
-0.4109334945678711,
0.5174299478530884,
0.11572134494781494,
-0.47440508008003235,
0.12668922543525696,
0.1729089915752411,
-0.24223604798316956,
-0.6766987442970276,
-0.453753262758255,
0.27771085500717163,
-0.10088743269443512,
-0.4606902301311493,
0.2750755250453949,
-0.4077889621257782,
-0.06589345633983612,
-0.09824611991643906,
0.25196373462677,
-0.10777322202920914,
-0.0476326160132885,
0.5212510228157043,
0.22252576053142548,
0.059108760207891464,
0.29088321328163147,
0.21573300659656525,
-0.3048243224620819,
0.23398447036743164,
-0.32967591285705566,
0.6005863547325134,
-0.47863954305648804,
-0.6952086091041565,
-0.5447729229927063,
0.22224412858486176,
0.2709156274795532,
-0.5123564600944519,
0.893307626247406,
0.6751760244369507,
-0.35299423336982727,
-0.0686943307518959,
-0.4885062873363495,
0.057317912578582764,
-0.4476436972618103,
-0.0202903151512146,
-0.18633662164211273,
-0.5368973612785339,
0.22677375376224518,
-0.05432017892599106,
0.39936813712120056,
-0.3497290313243866,
0.6317859888076782,
0.08531282097101212,
1.1754802465438843,
0.71825110912323,
0.03936776891350746,
0.679718554019928,
-0.23865771293640137,
0.2761114239692688,
-0.7501609921455383,
-0.24832037091255188,
-0.3047800660133362,
-0.12355400621891022,
-0.34211763739585876,
-0.03595318645238876,
0.37763386964797974,
-0.2518068552017212,
-0.4283978343009949,
0.4631378948688507,
-0.8176546096801758,
0.32265836000442505,
0.45038333535194397,
0.3870089054107666,
0.5157982707023621,
-0.3668866455554962,
-0.10194920003414154,
-0.433689683675766,
-0.2985713481903076,
-0.5435723066329956,
0.8207664489746094,
0.39610153436660767,
0.915265679359436,
0.2060452401638031,
0.3072860836982727,
0.16268466413021088,
0.7782341241836548,
-0.9919532537460327,
0.4831450879573822,
0.36831238865852356,
-0.622641921043396,
-0.29749852418899536,
-0.0858747810125351,
-1.1453288793563843,
0.25242072343826294,
-0.30195382237434387,
-1.0204908847808838,
0.1993604451417923,
-0.06087071821093559,
-0.2361842393875122,
0.003030212828889489,
-0.3058851361274719,
0.8312121033668518,
-0.16535139083862305,
-0.4845098853111267,
-0.456137090921402,
-0.6820570230484009,
0.614533007144928,
-0.07262023538351059,
0.25813284516334534,
-0.3611742854118347,
0.2194305658340454,
0.5302837491035461,
-0.9330693483352661,
0.9885438680648804,
-0.1015898734331131,
-0.2764192521572113,
0.3881743252277374,
0.3416980803012848,
0.32526254653930664,
0.3253796398639679,
-0.02826644666492939,
-0.19691292941570282,
0.734926700592041,
-0.517997682094574,
-0.5503259897232056,
0.6615480780601501,
-1.1516187191009521,
-0.4497066140174866,
-0.39744114875793457,
-0.7581263780593872,
-0.6087444424629211,
0.01694582588970661,
-0.011195742525160313,
0.35071882605552673,
-0.7182968258857727,
-0.08513735979795456,
0.2355789840221405,
-0.49556735157966614,
0.043715525418519974,
0.8093425035476685,
-0.1605636328458786,
-0.4257805347442627,
0.8906639814376831,
-0.08524594455957413,
0.1649683564901352,
-0.37574297189712524,
0.28198498487472534,
-0.09758684784173965,
-0.10279526561498642,
-0.05775431916117668,
0.40495243668556213,
-0.8331027626991272,
0.07597693055868149,
-0.5931158065795898,
0.019820425659418106,
-0.5622376799583435,
-0.0786806270480156,
-0.4604642689228058,
-0.11234873533248901,
-0.19299446046352386,
-0.18686817586421967,
0.5723317861557007,
0.8106748461723328,
0.14794203639030457,
0.726805567741394,
-0.7814995646476746,
0.11122023314237595,
0.2136504203081131,
0.49535760283470154,
0.1191190853714943,
0.18988542258739471,
-0.1166558712720871,
0.35964125394821167,
-0.8494186997413635,
-1.0745998620986938,
0.4775448739528656,
0.053084902465343475,
0.4387405812740326,
0.5664674639701843,
0.27457395195961,
1.0393162965774536,
-0.1602151244878769,
0.8607887625694275,
0.24935521185398102,
-0.9257245659828186,
0.7590388059616089,
-0.5105669498443604,
-0.17807208001613617,
0.6642203330993652,
0.256041556596756,
-0.7943086624145508,
-0.6470680832862854,
-0.6320376396179199,
-0.36738792061805725,
1.0630788803100586,
0.318964421749115,
0.12025158852338791,
-0.2124156653881073,
0.5235673785209656,
0.23060889542102814,
0.32618483901023865,
-0.7053585052490234,
0.0710359737277031,
-0.5838914513587952,
-0.43380671739578247,
0.1771373748779297,
0.23962752521038055,
-0.4434294104576111,
-0.22489620745182037,
0.6768659353256226,
-0.2561492323875427,
0.37952330708503723,
0.2891945540904999,
0.1761493682861328,
-0.30898234248161316,
0.2211889773607254,
0.26984843611717224,
0.5011443495750427,
-0.12935149669647217,
-0.08280891925096512,
0.4729314148426056,
-0.5494587421417236,
0.08765267580747604,
-0.2445463091135025,
0.40285196900367737,
-0.34543904662132263,
0.09289256483316422,
0.31373387575149536,
0.2275829315185547,
-0.6195031404495239,
0.6865891814231873,
-0.6125825643539429,
-0.019352121278643608,
-0.6957540512084961,
0.35719403624534607,
0.13230441510677338,
0.08719328790903091,
-0.23862643539905548,
-0.2931234538555145,
0.03956912085413933,
-0.8359377980232239,
-0.1771078109741211,
0.5187444090843201,
-0.9893956184387207,
-0.26560741662979126,
0.5635189414024353,
0.031193578615784645,
-0.6524218916893005,
1.0182766914367676,
0.3229510188102722,
-0.028131309896707535,
0.47091102600097656,
0.7454641461372375,
0.3775959610939026,
0.0851425901055336,
0.28345391154289246,
0.026457270607352257,
-0.05019368603825569,
-0.13369345664978027,
0.09693120419979095,
-0.49853992462158203,
-0.6259703636169434,
-0.16762517392635345,
-0.26031967997550964,
-1.0467801094055176,
0.00462994072586298,
-1.042470097541809,
0.3692856729030609,
-0.7902236580848694,
-0.3096761405467987,
-0.26108965277671814,
-0.05973625183105469,
-0.7384313344955444,
0.02273695357143879,
0.016922837123274803,
0.9744758605957031,
-0.6480855941772461,
1.0850895643234253,
0.5089325308799744,
-0.5331289768218994,
-0.8132039308547974,
-0.15688499808311462,
0.15164707601070404,
-0.9389477968215942,
0.09798033535480499,
0.17751918733119965,
-0.26551908254623413,
-0.0761350765824318,
-0.9667986035346985,
-0.5625754594802856,
1.3060520887374878,
0.5610889196395874,
-0.17562353610992432,
0.06771951913833618,
0.4336090683937073,
0.798514187335968,
-0.47643330693244934,
0.5089557766914368,
0.9091728925704956,
0.46265724301338196,
0.3350800573825836,
-0.6839548945426941,
0.04326409846544266,
-0.24751223623752594,
0.042000625282526016,
-0.07641991227865219,
-0.9359422326087952,
0.5293941497802734,
-0.19394981861114502,
-0.17845067381858826,
0.3634759485721588,
0.6719023585319519,
0.3303441107273102,
0.2682226896286011,
0.5489796996116638,
0.16347309947013855,
1.0111509561538696,
-0.02115459553897381,
0.9701966047286987,
-0.5364847183227539,
0.28848913311958313,
1.159764289855957,
-0.5365133881568909,
0.5270732641220093,
0.20755311846733093,
-0.2575684189796448,
0.5231643915176392,
0.8129572868347168,
-0.10012061148881912,
0.3044421076774597,
0.29832619428634644,
-0.2945144474506378,
-0.38637474179267883,
-0.6443114876747131,
-0.3522462844848633,
0.2169668823480606,
0.7648282051086426,
-0.00890381820499897,
0.06859331578016281,
0.038007140159606934,
0.08366286009550095,
0.15211106836795807,
0.08080390840768814,
0.8680923581123352,
0.3186553120613098,
-0.8063558340072632,
0.24735604226589203,
-0.0874210000038147,
0.27763310074806213,
-0.6966990232467651,
-0.10837201774120331,
-0.08192060142755508,
0.3735836446285248,
-0.40060216188430786,
-0.8574374914169312,
0.2651587426662445,
0.12817229330539703,
0.40459585189819336,
-0.2644595801830292,
0.6918197870254517,
-0.39021629095077515,
-0.5312632322311401,
0.28072306513786316,
0.32995662093162537,
0.4577997326850891,
0.023847637698054314,
-0.6571530103683472,
-0.07839576154947281,
-0.4958983361721039,
-0.11369527876377106,
0.2711004912853241,
0.40053051710128784,
-0.11656484752893448,
0.9010130763053894,
1.0134838819503784,
0.09662686288356781,
-0.26551303267478943,
0.11732266843318939,
1.0607826709747314,
-0.832191526889801,
-0.7761272192001343,
-0.6646651029586792,
0.06357715278863907,
-0.04362713545560837,
-0.4890918731689453,
0.47495266795158386,
0.22894872725009918,
0.41638806462287903,
0.30365562438964844,
0.6199788451194763,
0.3236307203769684,
0.4274155795574188,
-0.10568823665380478,
0.3830876052379608,
-0.023787062615156174,
0.4044642746448517,
-0.3933146297931671,
-0.9762635827064514,
-0.12958869338035583,
0.7232978940010071,
-0.6077921986579895,
-0.2344249188899994,
0.5263423323631287,
0.7521761655807495,
-0.06373666971921921,
0.7698927521705627,
0.1271919459104538,
0.27243322134017944,
0.9676631093025208,
0.6696656942367554,
1.36382257938385,
0.11456362903118134,
0.8238030076026917,
-0.30279117822647095,
-0.26239919662475586,
0.15164627134799957,
-0.7860186696052551,
-0.8224726319313049,
-0.14260968565940857,
-0.17659978568553925,
-0.3249044716358185,
-0.1919698864221573,
1.3321712017059326,
0.630467414855957,
-0.4106302559375763,
-0.3234539031982422,
-0.22768108546733856,
-0.2117987424135208,
-0.3766222894191742,
-0.16924236714839935,
0.029697218909859657,
-0.23587572574615479,
-0.30539193749427795,
0.44243356585502625,
0.1807064265012741,
-0.09256859868764877,
-0.4755907356739044,
-0.25704050064086914,
0.2818721830844879,
0.20973511040210724,
0.2850624620914459,
0.22134089469909668,
-0.6800668835639954,
-0.3255629539489746,
-0.22624769806861877,
-0.12118572741746902,
0.40196922421455383,
1.1814731359481812,
-0.8763406872749329,
0.2731378376483917,
-0.2671281397342682,
0.37959760427474976,
0.8893831968307495,
0.07110821455717087,
0.8439780473709106,
-0.56070876121521,
0.2396378368139267,
-0.03100275620818138,
0.25885066390037537,
0.2484634667634964,
-0.6581516265869141,
0.5993465781211853,
-0.022297026589512825,
-0.3397141098976135,
-0.6375080943107605,
0.2983371317386627,
-1.084257960319519,
-0.28931504487991333,
0.8835257887840271,
-0.5929392576217651,
-0.22015619277954102,
-0.5893092155456543,
-0.8773470520973206,
0.4737124443054199,
-0.576431393623352,
0.8508009910583496,
0.7517316937446594,
-0.4450036585330963,
0.14603480696678162,
-0.21768519282341003,
0.47859641909599304,
0.3239413797855377,
-0.8206349015235901,
0.406246155500412,
0.32978978753089905,
0.4169791340827942,
0.12332583218812943,
0.9044913649559021,
-0.07219564914703369,
0.14545120298862457,
-0.12622417509555817,
-0.06418825685977936,
-0.22701461613178253,
-0.06850634515285492,
0.02739434875547886,
0.001435373560525477,
0.24442823231220245,
0.1321244239807129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03076v1 | A Case Study on Context-Aware Neural Machine Translation with Multi-Task Learning | 2024-07-03T12:50:49 | 2024-07-03T12:50:49 | Ramakrishna Appicharla, Baban Gain, Santanu Pal, Asif Ekbal, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | In document-level neural machine translation (DocNMT), multi-encoder
approaches are common in encoding context and source sentences. Recent studies
\cite{li-etal-2020-multi-encoder} have shown that the context encoder generates
noise and makes the model robust to the choice of context. This paper further
investigates this observation by explicitly modelling context encoding through
multi-task learning (MTL) to make the model sensitive to the choice of context.
We conduct experiments on cascade MTL architecture, which consists of one
encoder and two decoders. Generation of the source from the context is
considered an auxiliary task, and generation of the target from the source is
the main task. We experimented with German--English language pairs on News,
TED, and Europarl corpora. Evaluation results show that the proposed MTL
approach performs better than concatenation-based and multi-encoder DocNMT
models in low-resource settings and is sensitive to the choice of context.
However, we observe that the MTL models are failing to generate the source from
the context. These observations align with the previous studies, and this might
suggest that the available document-level parallel corpora are not
context-aware, and a robust sentence-level model can outperform the
context-aware models. | [
-0.1699220836162567,
-0.8300498723983765,
0.5171170234680176,
0.09914162009954453,
-0.26515430212020874,
-0.3437482714653015,
-0.3737733066082001,
-0.1913587749004364,
-0.41752558946609497,
0.3211902379989624,
-0.6298328638076782,
-0.29045069217681885,
-0.8130291700363159,
0.35280096530914307,
-0.4259931743144989,
0.9363980889320374,
-0.2233092188835144,
0.20502665638923645,
-0.27888670563697815,
-0.2776372730731964,
-0.8343483805656433,
-0.8198713660240173,
-0.8888439536094666,
-0.21405498683452606,
0.5943291187286377,
0.08409754931926727,
0.22563961148262024,
0.429330050945282,
0.3375236690044403,
0.23018012940883636,
-0.07406150549650192,
0.4145169258117676,
-0.18079937994480133,
0.3345077335834503,
0.07265631854534149,
-0.4039035141468048,
-0.3147584795951843,
-0.08652130514383316,
0.4325471520423889,
0.6557593941688538,
-0.01021161861717701,
-0.010394166223704815,
0.36393409967422485,
0.24533796310424805,
-0.48863843083381653,
0.10082440823316574,
-0.7877605557441711,
0.048006847500801086,
-0.09138980507850647,
-0.32969579100608826,
-0.717115581035614,
0.467369943857193,
-0.015292025171220303,
-0.3973996639251709,
0.27259838581085205,
0.1823599636554718,
0.5299380421638489,
0.5444892048835754,
-0.9580175876617432,
-0.4498794972896576,
-0.562954306602478,
0.6838493943214417,
-0.622285008430481,
0.4445595145225525,
0.25752460956573486,
0.17772790789604187,
-0.005508947651833296,
-0.6047406792640686,
-0.3777991235256195,
-0.08710981905460358,
-0.2612519860267639,
0.30429911613464355,
0.03419818356633186,
-0.2888641953468323,
0.2308064103126526,
0.05640921741724014,
-0.4556107521057129,
-0.12289939075708389,
-0.39761611819267273,
-0.050359126180410385,
-0.23095524311065674,
0.1184784471988678,
0.058152228593826294,
-0.44693413376808167,
-0.5851879119873047,
0.05660809949040413,
-0.6125580668449402,
0.08954611420631409,
-0.009154588915407658,
0.49559447169303894,
-0.1226549744606018,
0.4387178421020508,
0.2191244512796402,
0.8590719699859619,
0.24770890176296234,
-0.06120229884982109,
0.279952734708786,
-0.5916041731834412,
-0.24083150923252106,
0.027329251170158386,
0.6783586740493774,
0.18144692480564117,
-0.16318978369235992,
-0.4170815646648407,
-0.402997225522995,
-0.005398956127464771,
0.6253327131271362,
-0.7052962183952332,
0.4304317831993103,
0.356975793838501,
-0.3727957606315613,
0.005902575794607401,
-0.305686891078949,
-0.07626866549253464,
0.0026418406050652266,
-0.47886988520622253,
0.4199570119380951,
-0.7199357748031616,
-0.11334507912397385,
-0.07319477945566177,
-0.13797533512115479,
-0.08961006999015808,
0.13414016366004944,
-0.6091353893280029,
0.136698380112648,
0.4709691107273102,
0.8303564786911011,
-0.19945791363716125,
-0.7139036059379578,
-0.6547363996505737,
0.3761867880821228,
-0.26679956912994385,
0.44766294956207275,
-0.2096894085407257,
-0.11760679632425308,
-0.030002975836396217,
0.12298290431499481,
-0.5290859937667847,
-0.3865346312522888,
0.6979584693908691,
-0.43870043754577637,
0.24144282937049866,
-0.32028210163116455,
-0.2430523931980133,
-0.08925545960664749,
0.46342334151268005,
-0.5234948992729187,
0.8282914757728577,
0.20808157324790955,
-0.852419376373291,
0.42960649728775024,
-0.8661808371543884,
-0.7785953879356384,
-0.30812886357307434,
0.018022874370217323,
-0.19515325129032135,
0.29921209812164307,
0.31274908781051636,
0.615846574306488,
-0.09844514727592468,
0.7433419227600098,
0.18192097544670105,
-0.17391309142112732,
0.29912322759628296,
-0.659795343875885,
0.6714736819267273,
0.37001290917396545,
-0.34166333079338074,
0.2504994869232178,
-0.39779552817344666,
-0.4042727053165436,
-0.015578392893075943,
-0.5954073071479797,
-0.5016943216323853,
0.009432832710444927,
0.3686828315258026,
0.8332549929618835,
0.18022207915782928,
-0.47323039174079895,
-0.09239421039819717,
-0.14365381002426147,
0.7699341177940369,
0.43746501207351685,
-0.1665482074022293,
0.44970351457595825,
-0.3342169523239136,
0.1683148443698883,
0.5480386018753052,
-0.05657739192247391,
-0.2972094416618347,
-0.2537388503551483,
-0.5647428631782532,
-0.116168312728405,
0.2944734990596771,
0.4369058609008789,
-0.8799293041229248,
0.1245669424533844,
-0.3267747163772583,
0.07805316895246506,
-0.6113988161087036,
-0.005656053777784109,
0.4546257257461548,
0.9637429118156433,
0.5081483721733093,
-0.2018226534128189,
-0.4182836413383484,
-0.8285147547721863,
-0.20219121873378754,
0.42774975299835205,
0.0404420830309391,
0.42221200466156006,
0.5651726126670837,
-0.24369947612285614,
0.6952537894248962,
0.06278397887945175,
-0.33509722352027893,
-0.1559273898601532,
0.3248141407966614,
-0.014202154241502285,
0.603150486946106,
0.506981372833252,
-0.9871906042098999,
-0.38304945826530457,
0.02317233756184578,
-0.9360043406486511,
0.2579423189163208,
-0.16406609117984772,
-0.039571814239025116,
0.3487280607223511,
0.4745805561542511,
-0.7772494554519653,
0.008339913561940193,
0.6821950674057007,
-0.1204417422413826,
0.16835887730121613,
-0.6214106678962708,
0.19183868169784546,
-1.6639024019241333,
0.23901963233947754,
-0.06213422119617462,
-0.2753390371799469,
-0.8562987446784973,
0.2520163953304291,
0.49034810066223145,
-0.21297003328800201,
-0.5677616000175476,
0.1954033374786377,
-0.553068995475769,
-0.10167703032493591,
-0.4327693581581116,
0.02401278167963028,
0.02306574396789074,
0.6109423637390137,
0.1863163709640503,
0.7761658430099487,
0.48072704672813416,
-0.5822489261627197,
-0.2100149393081665,
0.07472044974565506,
-0.03681136295199394,
0.8940189480781555,
-0.38546350598335266,
0.21749813854694366,
-0.28640344738960266,
0.47376707196235657,
-0.6914302110671997,
-0.20438575744628906,
0.25806909799575806,
-0.26837193965911865,
0.48456135392189026,
0.013980223797261715,
-0.6389141082763672,
-0.2357824742794037,
0.22065125405788422,
0.3994653820991516,
0.12156195938587189,
-0.3748690187931061,
0.5163326263427734,
0.1370832622051239,
0.07465913146734238,
-0.6758077144622803,
-0.9615657329559326,
0.29374316334724426,
-0.3774070739746094,
-0.47528183460235596,
0.5064919590950012,
-0.10063432157039642,
0.23568709194660187,
0.11355358362197876,
-0.2881198823451996,
-0.2144673466682434,
0.28340357542037964,
0.37095990777015686,
0.07382703572511673,
-0.19734789431095123,
0.039040785282850266,
0.14120012521743774,
-0.011814490891993046,
0.0034697495866566896,
-0.6699573397636414,
0.4671221375465393,
-0.10758339613676071,
-0.3153741657733917,
-0.1318293809890747,
0.7170060873031616,
0.692497730255127,
-0.3966692388057709,
0.9686179161071777,
0.8841860294342041,
-0.5389153361320496,
-0.1753588318824768,
-0.22125941514968872,
-0.20017696917057037,
-0.3728478252887726,
0.39215099811553955,
-0.7895163893699646,
-0.7675333619117737,
0.2881059944629669,
-0.13818852603435516,
0.059324961155653,
0.5607014298439026,
0.5979713797569275,
-0.05510256066918373,
0.8925327062606812,
0.5136489868164062,
0.11420145630836487,
0.29399749636650085,
-0.19334082305431366,
0.10211063921451569,
-1.2395579814910889,
-0.034674495458602905,
-0.4123004972934723,
-0.3202205002307892,
-0.25241732597351074,
-0.3975311517715454,
0.4227081537246704,
-0.014063860289752483,
-0.091562919318676,
0.7611711621284485,
-0.49692606925964355,
0.0738510861992836,
0.8098759055137634,
0.10259494930505753,
0.2721017003059387,
-0.04691311717033386,
-0.37620672583580017,
0.12050845474004745,
-0.970463752746582,
-0.4502306282520294,
1.0941814184188843,
-0.09161361306905746,
0.11158072203397751,
0.013267114758491516,
0.5258795022964478,
0.011469804681837559,
0.28006091713905334,
-0.38065090775489807,
0.13598932325839996,
-0.2804622948169708,
-0.7653369903564453,
-0.1318964660167694,
-0.5349684953689575,
-1.0294859409332275,
0.5058975219726562,
0.004996136296540499,
-0.3519013226032257,
0.0016893659485504031,
-0.03847237303853035,
-0.20714420080184937,
0.1111651137471199,
-0.5937804579734802,
1.147202730178833,
-0.2880016565322876,
-0.20987297594547272,
-0.15415063500404358,
-0.7975549101829529,
0.3343275785446167,
-0.3326146602630615,
0.4833182096481323,
0.24404598772525787,
-0.055222101509571075,
0.39401769638061523,
-0.024127960205078125,
0.8880262970924377,
-0.061431434005498886,
-0.10901731997728348,
0.07250912487506866,
0.00857291929423809,
0.45515111088752747,
-0.10172013938426971,
-0.14342914521694183,
0.05613352358341217,
-0.12977929413318634,
-0.302877813577652,
-0.19109134376049042,
0.8149378299713135,
-0.6939617395401001,
-0.5396223664283752,
-0.23718471825122833,
-1.0952824354171753,
-0.18494965136051178,
0.2926885485649109,
0.6254580020904541,
0.738707959651947,
-0.017201397567987442,
0.20904338359832764,
0.3935222923755646,
0.05591290816664696,
0.7049157619476318,
0.5049459934234619,
0.42474690079689026,
-0.19947481155395508,
0.6592441201210022,
0.32721763849258423,
0.263438880443573,
0.4961342513561249,
-0.07085695117712021,
-0.10734683275222778,
-0.5053955316543579,
-0.74779212474823,
-0.25972771644592285,
-0.756186306476593,
-0.02766881138086319,
-0.85944664478302,
-0.15566618740558624,
-0.2925451993942261,
-0.1973482221364975,
-0.198032945394516,
-0.1562887579202652,
-0.11675377935171127,
0.08757640421390533,
-0.2649378180503845,
0.5020053386688232,
0.1166478842496872,
0.2696383595466614,
-0.6171140074729919,
0.43485718965530396,
0.07630749046802521,
0.007536346558481455,
-0.0797789990901947,
-0.405188649892807,
-0.4078652262687683,
0.11336993426084518,
-0.28730902075767517,
-0.9194127321243286,
0.5123218894004822,
0.0306574497371912,
0.6202215552330017,
0.07788796722888947,
0.12183224409818649,
0.35995516180992126,
-0.8367966413497925,
0.6440555453300476,
0.10369368642568588,
-0.8295729160308838,
0.3993951380252838,
-0.39630839228630066,
0.6157900094985962,
0.4065849184989929,
0.2746252417564392,
-0.6636612415313721,
-0.6134203672409058,
-0.4389615058898926,
-0.6624260544776917,
0.8102961182594299,
0.14719723165035248,
0.28904908895492554,
-0.23754069209098816,
0.1060563176870346,
0.36458832025527954,
0.48730671405792236,
-0.8197387456893921,
-0.2315330058336258,
-0.3742290139198303,
-0.2797354757785797,
-0.3095345199108124,
-0.09524472057819366,
-0.20688994228839874,
0.07482805848121643,
0.29481199383735657,
-0.15760044753551483,
0.29773780703544617,
0.2496057152748108,
-0.5178555846214294,
-0.03015943244099617,
0.5123178958892822,
0.9181842803955078,
0.5546831488609314,
-0.2992294132709503,
0.5254524350166321,
0.12738043069839478,
-0.10331130027770996,
0.031176796182990074,
0.24327880144119263,
-0.309017539024353,
0.18316301703453064,
0.24647298455238342,
0.9896757006645203,
0.46905750036239624,
-0.29430726170539856,
0.4851491153240204,
0.051728010177612305,
-0.32941487431526184,
0.014451423659920692,
-0.41609275341033936,
0.39983412623405457,
0.11599516123533249,
0.48024439811706543,
0.7513768076896667,
0.09712634980678558,
-0.5171335339546204,
0.12316779047250748,
0.3338600695133209,
-0.49667486548423767,
-0.3218355178833008,
1.040970802307129,
0.20141585171222687,
-0.26176878809928894,
0.4147719740867615,
-0.24327413737773895,
-0.5251132845878601,
0.6303039193153381,
0.9086005687713623,
0.7464158535003662,
-0.008070140145719051,
-0.08300262689590454,
0.2690916061401367,
0.5237024426460266,
-0.13694055378437042,
-0.03501282259821892,
-0.13154928386211395,
-0.5609182715415955,
-0.508571445941925,
-0.36970749497413635,
-0.2018967866897583,
0.05873040854930878,
-0.48396119475364685,
-0.09299325942993164,
0.16632558405399323,
-0.314300537109375,
-0.10556874424219131,
-0.4563421607017517,
-0.8910367488861084,
0.03261500224471092,
0.07273104041814804,
0.6777163147926331,
-0.6966997981071472,
1.1102491617202759,
0.7208111882209778,
-0.277625173330307,
-0.4706989824771881,
0.10610630363225937,
-0.09057674556970596,
-0.4371045231819153,
0.7315024137496948,
0.45678451657295227,
0.09102349728345871,
0.08252965658903122,
-0.03521789610385895,
-0.5978595018386841,
1.2252285480499268,
0.510357677936554,
-0.359250545501709,
-0.15124711394309998,
0.1134871244430542,
0.3332979679107666,
-0.6818626523017883,
-0.057367123663425446,
-0.015097285620868206,
0.3293963670730591,
-0.21799245476722717,
-0.94110107421875,
0.287454217672348,
-0.16408224403858185,
0.08066228777170181,
0.10282900184392929,
-0.5079675316810608,
1.1833864450454712,
0.03833979740738869,
-0.24165527522563934,
-0.2782829999923706,
0.32116270065307617,
-0.01167217642068863,
0.3840121626853943,
0.4546632170677185,
0.3792574405670166,
0.5812518000602722,
0.0054704598151147366,
1.284597635269165,
-0.6695092916488647,
0.09371846914291382,
1.2430909872055054,
-0.22754134237766266,
0.8918052315711975,
0.6872723698616028,
0.4287455081939697,
0.11367101222276688,
0.5527223944664001,
0.23506677150726318,
0.8149623274803162,
-0.12114711850881577,
-0.14031891524791718,
-0.1766238510608673,
-0.2138361632823944,
-0.33251625299453735,
0.23535247147083282,
0.1631487011909485,
-0.43353408575057983,
-0.27238261699676514,
0.4394407868385315,
-0.08747108280658722,
-0.15505337715148926,
-0.2174936681985855,
0.5635210275650024,
0.35509559512138367,
-0.9253988862037659,
0.6045780181884766,
0.3765239119529724,
0.7699536085128784,
-0.43545225262641907,
0.3369063436985016,
-0.11042336374521255,
0.12115740031003952,
0.16544409096240997,
-0.28486981987953186,
0.5626270771026611,
-0.08763168752193451,
-0.3935718536376953,
-0.6025263667106628,
0.7187854051589966,
-0.6877274513244629,
-0.3405839204788208,
0.3059004247188568,
0.9320289492607117,
-0.14172935485839844,
-0.2836219370365143,
-0.4904792606830597,
-0.19989049434661865,
-0.413255900144577,
-0.17503489553928375,
0.5503203868865967,
0.6130176782608032,
0.025446273386478424,
0.32571345567703247,
0.5907328724861145,
-0.30838048458099365,
0.24386847019195557,
-0.04573814198374748,
0.47728002071380615,
-0.3926393389701843,
-0.38716110587120056,
-0.7463579773902893,
0.49839043617248535,
0.010390017181634903,
-0.3793444335460663,
0.7942863702774048,
0.531367301940918,
0.825353741645813,
-0.3704488277435303,
0.7017583847045898,
-0.08211329579353333,
0.041142430156469345,
-0.4670673906803131,
0.6080178022384644,
-0.6640580296516418,
0.011351286433637142,
0.11338646709918976,
-0.7129203081130981,
-0.05114195495843887,
0.14856117963790894,
-0.14086942374706268,
-0.20281419157981873,
1.1563233137130737,
0.5194277763366699,
-0.33878639340400696,
-0.20057277381420135,
0.4277316927909851,
-0.07816758751869202,
-0.21280540525913239,
0.8914498686790466,
0.6895718574523926,
-0.5489637851715088,
0.7116279006004333,
-0.16570833325386047,
0.15518204867839813,
-0.07718673348426819,
-0.8279772400856018,
-0.8830271363258362,
-0.8337224721908569,
-0.14713530242443085,
-0.18090355396270752,
0.19721943140029907,
0.6146671772003174,
0.9099006056785583,
-0.6496559381484985,
-0.0639265850186348,
-0.21746771037578583,
0.02975296787917614,
-0.7499884366989136,
-0.11095290631055832,
0.3347463011741638,
-0.6983909010887146,
-0.9231484532356262,
0.7393973469734192,
0.1204429417848587,
-0.24684353172779083,
0.04630545526742935,
-0.20680220425128937,
-0.23129096627235413,
-0.05421516299247742,
0.6311653256416321,
-0.2615495026111603,
-0.8648049235343933,
-0.1897941678762436,
0.09138854593038559,
-0.6514283418655396,
0.23436841368675232,
0.7663541436195374,
-0.456277459859848,
0.1878347396850586,
0.24382805824279785,
0.765123188495636,
0.5809949636459351,
-0.18643134832382202,
0.6669757962226868,
-1.087112545967102,
0.04996557533740997,
-0.2784121632575989,
0.539596438407898,
0.4191332161426544,
-0.3734075725078583,
0.46239590644836426,
0.1613907665014267,
-0.30486640334129333,
-0.5752867460250854,
0.08662869036197662,
-0.9302389621734619,
-0.5962794423103333,
0.9986846446990967,
-0.1662929356098175,
-0.1784093677997589,
-0.05032326281070709,
-0.1548488885164261,
0.5117816925048828,
-0.23164595663547516,
0.514141321182251,
0.7742263674736023,
0.24249610304832458,
-0.1950509399175644,
-1.1253612041473389,
0.19470563530921936,
0.49064791202545166,
-0.5245360136032104,
-0.09585677832365036,
0.39542990922927856,
0.25465837121009827,
0.2935697138309479,
0.3772284686565399,
0.19132797420024872,
0.21645177900791168,
0.15400345623493195,
-0.20353420078754425,
-0.5205861330032349,
-0.2784661650657654,
-0.3610815107822418,
0.6162012815475464,
-0.10510627925395966,
-0.34660619497299194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03061v1 | ALTER: Augmentation for Large-Table-Based Reasoning | 2024-07-03T12:34:45 | 2024-07-03T12:34:45 | Han Zhang, Yuheng Ma, Hanfang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While extensive research has explored the use of large language models (LLMs)
for table-based reasoning, most approaches struggle with scalability when
applied to large tables. To maintain the superior comprehension abilities of
LLMs in these scenarios, we introduce ALTER(Augmentation for Large-Table-Based
Reasoning)-a framework designed to harness the latent augmentation potential in
both free-form natural language (NL) questions, via the query augmentor, and
semi-structured tabular data, through the table augmentor. By utilizing only a
small subset of relevant data from the table and supplementing it with
pre-augmented schema, semantic, and literal information, ALTER achieves
outstanding performance on table-based reasoning benchmarks. We also provide a
detailed analysis of large-table scenarios, comparing different methods and
various partitioning principles. In these scenarios, our method outperforms all
other approaches and exhibits robustness and efficiency against perturbations. | [
-0.3542473614215851,
-1.2564958333969116,
0.6038106083869934,
0.11802856624126434,
-0.2040274292230606,
0.10799399018287659,
-0.17742836475372314,
-0.6432366371154785,
0.24310632050037384,
0.8238036632537842,
-0.479211688041687,
-0.13898928463459015,
-0.17318293452262878,
0.09342890977859497,
-0.34336626529693604,
0.7781710624694824,
-0.03974274545907974,
0.004302592948079109,
-0.36252644658088684,
-0.21038562059402466,
-0.5090558528900146,
-0.3371819257736206,
-0.3809396028518677,
-0.2418619841337204,
0.6905450224876404,
0.6770552396774292,
1.089672565460205,
0.7041978240013123,
0.5851914882659912,
0.28773412108421326,
-0.1820136457681656,
0.3840577006340027,
-0.3567829430103302,
0.39892351627349854,
-0.4373241662979126,
-0.7411081194877625,
-0.5523766875267029,
-0.3791457712650299,
0.7813401222229004,
1.0021188259124756,
0.05301499739289284,
-0.1574147790670395,
-0.2613951861858368,
0.7209996581077576,
-0.6288219094276428,
0.16754764318466187,
-1.1447237730026245,
-0.01171043235808611,
-0.21250030398368835,
-0.0335715152323246,
-0.5269308090209961,
-0.24294672906398773,
-0.05122979357838631,
-0.6921955943107605,
-0.011369636282324791,
0.27259957790374756,
0.4547842741012573,
0.4849356412887573,
-0.3556218445301056,
0.2327403724193573,
-0.8913817405700684,
0.43917012214660645,
-0.662766695022583,
0.7987355589866638,
0.16469021141529083,
0.35778510570526123,
-0.44441428780555725,
-0.890522837638855,
-0.9403194785118103,
-0.4416014552116394,
-0.40250763297080994,
-0.24549823999404907,
-0.08222785592079163,
0.2216894030570984,
0.7538086175918579,
0.7186989188194275,
-0.5761635899543762,
0.177231565117836,
-0.15539361536502838,
-0.18795163929462433,
0.5037185549736023,
0.27578499913215637,
0.3991278409957886,
0.05379459261894226,
0.08974813669919968,
-0.12239070981740952,
-0.9594654440879822,
-0.1421886831521988,
0.08757814764976501,
0.3207942843437195,
0.3697788715362549,
1.0261763334274292,
-0.4140668511390686,
1.228585958480835,
0.06157388538122177,
0.06309203803539276,
0.08848210424184799,
-0.40361273288726807,
-0.34793925285339355,
0.04362760856747627,
0.2721607983112335,
0.2497043013572693,
-0.4241653382778168,
-0.29065826535224915,
-0.268545001745224,
0.16111800074577332,
0.033003948628902435,
-0.7020553350448608,
-0.194548100233078,
0.2391781061887741,
-0.04661155119538307,
-0.031067268922924995,
-0.04826262220740318,
-0.7616384625434875,
-0.6087912321090698,
-0.5291956067085266,
0.7208113670349121,
-0.3622109591960907,
0.20393812656402588,
-0.07090561091899872,
-0.006084019318223,
0.42421209812164307,
0.6928396224975586,
-0.885267436504364,
0.16326655447483063,
0.7648626565933228,
0.5406048893928528,
-0.36791715025901794,
-0.21241778135299683,
-0.7616028785705566,
0.4798922836780548,
-0.5938765406608582,
0.7742913365364075,
-0.8691463470458984,
-0.34403276443481445,
-0.08500003069639206,
0.12596814334392548,
0.3117051124572754,
-0.621802031993866,
0.757737398147583,
-0.67194002866745,
0.16990086436271667,
-0.5068252682685852,
-0.4835936725139618,
-0.03118119202554226,
0.4117215573787689,
-0.96527498960495,
0.8829962015151978,
0.24837179481983185,
-0.5838190913200378,
0.5487494468688965,
-0.9648411273956299,
-0.6045322418212891,
0.06295471638441086,
0.07376115769147873,
-0.29176825284957886,
0.1627352386713028,
0.6240589618682861,
-0.04799524322152138,
-0.25863075256347656,
0.10225365310907364,
-0.268844872713089,
-0.22214272618293762,
0.44645750522613525,
-0.5002079010009766,
0.4810168445110321,
-0.011253123171627522,
0.005684603471308947,
0.4668032228946686,
-0.9083465337753296,
-0.06071893125772476,
-0.04975009337067604,
-0.3423573076725006,
-0.20012903213500977,
0.030481526628136635,
-0.21505770087242126,
0.09794517606496811,
0.1865013986825943,
-0.6309294104576111,
0.5288842916488647,
-0.8130970597267151,
0.4747666120529175,
0.48578527569770813,
0.2772679030895233,
0.8384439945220947,
-0.2705332934856415,
0.20304226875305176,
0.06008783355355263,
0.08465981483459473,
-0.14044398069381714,
0.00946787092834711,
-0.8940670490264893,
-0.053291257470846176,
0.4335465431213379,
0.5063895583152771,
-1.2500455379486084,
0.32398638129234314,
-0.23155495524406433,
-0.46750694513320923,
-0.38736510276794434,
-0.15721137821674347,
-0.07239886373281479,
0.7524545788764954,
0.7789050340652466,
0.16589045524597168,
-0.6796875596046448,
-0.9392176866531372,
-0.5634647011756897,
-0.09245266020298004,
-0.10703857988119125,
0.09530665725469589,
0.36260151863098145,
-0.35835549235343933,
0.8915433883666992,
-0.5465830564498901,
0.013908256776630878,
-0.29285892844200134,
-0.053977906703948975,
0.2615639567375183,
0.5037295818328857,
0.1274799406528473,
-0.6507912874221802,
-0.3525865077972412,
0.09097228944301605,
-0.2748642861843109,
-0.20361129939556122,
-0.3824535310268402,
-0.2993229925632477,
0.2865801453590393,
0.602492094039917,
-0.6721251010894775,
0.5462358593940735,
0.030722027644515038,
-0.3005855977535248,
0.702985405921936,
-0.13279473781585693,
0.13610315322875977,
-0.7220475673675537,
-0.227061465382576,
-0.416442334651947,
-0.08662739396095276,
-0.656559407711029,
0.129921555519104,
0.10537932068109512,
-0.04015108197927475,
-0.2136741280555725,
0.6096762418746948,
-0.5797496438026428,
-0.25067323446273804,
-0.10646089166402817,
-0.20028136670589447,
0.25689396262168884,
0.13629040122032166,
-0.06754901260137558,
1.120787501335144,
0.1878688484430313,
-0.477939635515213,
0.3932316303253174,
0.5209084153175354,
-0.35585683584213257,
0.6491172909736633,
-0.6968061923980713,
0.1842232346534729,
-0.09684330224990845,
0.42230960726737976,
-0.935616135597229,
-0.40804073214530945,
0.22467322647571564,
-0.15461209416389465,
0.35868239402770996,
0.017286717891693115,
-0.4691857695579529,
-0.3991505205631256,
-0.21582750976085663,
0.08866657316684723,
0.10457149147987366,
-0.8812626600265503,
0.9665188193321228,
0.25224724411964417,
-0.13644608855247498,
-0.7517625093460083,
-0.9130577445030212,
0.3809339702129364,
-0.11804161220788956,
-0.679540753364563,
0.8545461297035217,
-0.15188908576965332,
-0.6241517663002014,
-0.052931103855371475,
-0.2738128900527954,
-0.058803096413612366,
-0.24854551255702972,
0.11789532750844955,
0.3352845013141632,
-0.17413121461868286,
0.2852628529071808,
0.4500701129436493,
-0.08350050449371338,
-0.04330409690737724,
-0.23908479511737823,
0.49690112471580505,
-0.15881049633026123,
-0.4483085572719574,
-0.11114684492349625,
0.1780707985162735,
0.5453467965126038,
-0.47376301884651184,
0.8407794237136841,
0.35570648312568665,
-0.38610729575157166,
-0.20481111109256744,
-0.8104326725006104,
-0.38347139954566956,
-0.4798179268836975,
0.5018458366394043,
-0.5124050974845886,
-1.126317024230957,
0.7060949206352234,
0.13969223201274872,
0.2945532500743866,
0.5461053848266602,
0.4925633668899536,
0.14529992640018463,
0.7755060195922852,
-0.013771823607385159,
0.15253083407878876,
0.4765145480632782,
0.012886812910437584,
0.16011594235897064,
-0.8528378009796143,
-0.1675826907157898,
-0.6736729145050049,
-0.28000688552856445,
-0.35920584201812744,
-0.7773302793502808,
0.4311380982398987,
-0.2523118555545807,
-0.38117995858192444,
0.05436461791396141,
-0.450872540473938,
0.6351719498634338,
0.30815237760543823,
0.25716179609298706,
0.5220656991004944,
-0.02909442037343979,
0.18582458794116974,
-0.1081489771604538,
-0.35100257396698,
-0.12663047015666962,
0.9236406683921814,
0.12789517641067505,
0.8501262068748474,
0.2146352380514145,
0.2830527424812317,
0.2533860206604004,
0.29212769865989685,
-0.7653719186782837,
0.683489978313446,
0.17684906721115112,
-0.7716596126556396,
-0.7217963933944702,
-0.589975893497467,
-0.8630988001823425,
0.46841490268707275,
-0.4713134169578552,
-0.6948312520980835,
0.2048512101173401,
0.11607859283685684,
-0.04354238137602806,
0.37077054381370544,
-0.7147865891456604,
0.6892372965812683,
-0.3906627595424652,
-0.8081440329551697,
-0.06921546161174774,
-0.6365349292755127,
0.25838300585746765,
-0.11494092643260956,
-0.07169678807258606,
0.24066902697086334,
-0.31826913356781006,
0.47321072220802307,
-0.9002893567085266,
0.4039415121078491,
-0.3150756359100342,
0.02492675557732582,
0.30538979172706604,
0.261918306350708,
0.8255811333656311,
0.33754631876945496,
-0.3353109359741211,
-0.14922809600830078,
-0.1004197895526886,
-0.15688207745552063,
-1.1358847618103027,
0.6142366528511047,
-0.4259207248687744,
-0.9174069166183472,
-0.22157835960388184,
-0.9527906179428101,
-0.785658597946167,
0.11882977932691574,
-0.1491825133562088,
0.3138953745365143,
-0.132502481341362,
0.4720076024532318,
0.5273059606552124,
-0.2756803035736084,
0.3522680997848511,
0.47807180881500244,
-0.3899519741535187,
-0.5531359910964966,
0.517267644405365,
0.32474902272224426,
0.2542627453804016,
0.7527332305908203,
0.2343522012233734,
-0.8397318720817566,
-0.6911550760269165,
-0.5617920756340027,
0.0257873572409153,
-0.5799373984336853,
-0.2126678079366684,
-0.5974596738815308,
-0.07608753442764282,
-0.16619873046875,
-0.15211792290210724,
-0.02960224449634552,
-0.7679479122161865,
-0.10690677911043167,
-0.4187995493412018,
0.4633573293685913,
0.23872825503349304,
-0.15541276335716248,
0.38341739773750305,
-0.7367514371871948,
0.3039023280143738,
0.5603418946266174,
0.3790128529071808,
-0.16070032119750977,
-0.7446790933609009,
0.18513137102127075,
-0.04115917533636093,
0.020076492801308632,
-1.1455265283584595,
0.16450618207454681,
0.1458425670862198,
0.6173818707466125,
0.2214735895395279,
0.06815019994974136,
0.8088498115539551,
-0.4333511292934418,
0.6943746209144592,
0.0676606148481369,
-0.9907235503196716,
0.46631669998168945,
-0.3985755443572998,
0.2839595377445221,
0.8578538298606873,
0.021556295454502106,
-0.3122616112232208,
0.012620650231838226,
-0.4933352768421173,
-0.962627112865448,
0.4811951816082001,
-0.051787119358778,
0.029584186151623726,
0.3250364065170288,
0.5580064058303833,
0.2597740590572357,
0.12228117138147354,
-0.9300781488418579,
0.0715094730257988,
0.06724298000335693,
0.16280536353588104,
0.18860623240470886,
-0.3716762363910675,
0.13933894038200378,
-0.7425859570503235,
0.7138705253601074,
-0.035241276025772095,
0.1643471121788025,
0.18427808582782745,
-0.3188515305519104,
-0.13809850811958313,
0.5689705014228821,
0.506513774394989,
1.0315381288528442,
-0.07052000612020493,
0.13626983761787415,
0.6884358525276184,
-0.23068282008171082,
0.010453877970576286,
0.31630560755729675,
-0.2902767062187195,
-0.10970911383628845,
0.1833401471376419,
0.9140494465827942,
0.07534298300743103,
-0.49924036860466003,
0.035247791558504105,
0.10523141920566559,
-0.10849881917238235,
0.02113395370543003,
0.14141647517681122,
0.10213524848222733,
0.20387062430381775,
0.3612939417362213,
-0.27294057607650757,
0.17988984286785126,
-0.61480712890625,
0.3197244107723236,
0.47415098547935486,
-0.3226437270641327,
-0.00783936120569706,
0.607201874256134,
-0.12469515949487686,
-0.3730686604976654,
0.5404028296470642,
-0.18095795810222626,
-0.37873440980911255,
0.24357885122299194,
0.7329354286193848,
0.32900702953338623,
-0.39705678820610046,
0.11671750992536545,
0.30967116355895996,
0.504507303237915,
0.15396566689014435,
0.4116986095905304,
0.030630700290203094,
-0.7374044060707092,
-0.8868411183357239,
-0.5890828967094421,
-0.6885074377059937,
0.3089510202407837,
-0.28316599130630493,
0.09158728271722794,
-0.3956703245639801,
0.1871328204870224,
0.3334002196788788,
-0.1093018651008606,
-0.33846816420555115,
0.18162895739078522,
-0.3577050566673279,
0.917773425579071,
-0.6175113320350647,
0.5278404951095581,
0.8062012195587158,
-0.45746931433677673,
-1.0390750169754028,
-0.10647844523191452,
-0.3791387677192688,
-0.570874810218811,
0.14156807959079742,
-0.18175986409187317,
0.333746999502182,
-0.1507960706949234,
-0.6994616389274597,
-0.7049643993377686,
0.6910035014152527,
0.4744131863117218,
-0.6728929877281189,
-0.007379151880741119,
0.5959375500679016,
0.5588093400001526,
-0.10270292311906815,
0.2865017056465149,
0.9160275459289551,
0.957260012626648,
0.472123384475708,
-0.6487060785293579,
0.06185238063335419,
0.11829335242509842,
-0.1465582251548767,
0.5545111298561096,
-0.036011356860399246,
0.683017909526825,
-0.14323295652866364,
0.24516744911670685,
-0.20793992280960083,
0.9430034160614014,
0.12341528385877609,
0.33615604043006897,
0.6930841207504272,
0.8097823858261108,
0.8818670511245728,
-0.4786720871925354,
0.8130555152893066,
0.028417028486728668,
-0.19554269313812256,
1.2995200157165527,
-0.32646259665489197,
0.7860772013664246,
0.5615154504776001,
-0.47335147857666016,
0.5016891360282898,
0.5093548893928528,
0.0495222769677639,
0.12259326875209808,
0.2286507785320282,
-0.29439663887023926,
-0.17557093501091003,
-0.03866596519947052,
-0.4679424464702606,
0.6807793974876404,
0.8013976216316223,
-0.12003356218338013,
-0.23027636110782623,
-0.06337150186300278,
0.03821774944663048,
0.0148185845464468,
-0.644938051700592,
0.950373649597168,
-0.27185121178627014,
-0.6817315816879272,
0.4340287446975708,
-0.048387713730335236,
0.10018961876630783,
-0.34397587180137634,
-0.2463546246290207,
-0.13008707761764526,
-0.09320896863937378,
-0.4610046148300171,
-0.8631433248519897,
0.7362192273139954,
-0.3396855294704437,
-0.041190050542354584,
0.01549562718719244,
0.9766259789466858,
-0.3925429880619049,
-0.5017837882041931,
-0.2512819170951843,
0.7196158766746521,
-0.1811399757862091,
-0.32084786891937256,
-0.5905805230140686,
0.1183067262172699,
0.047844354063272476,
-0.10086669772863388,
0.2370050698518753,
0.5131416916847229,
-0.2264404147863388,
0.33017468452453613,
1.004228949546814,
0.09307393431663513,
-0.09915562719106674,
0.13511265814304352,
1.2108451128005981,
-0.6025504469871521,
-0.5322685837745667,
-0.8307616710662842,
0.6032676100730896,
-0.3576800525188446,
0.09671825170516968,
0.5110982060432434,
0.7818377614021301,
0.42761483788490295,
-0.08509333431720734,
0.4892086684703827,
-0.019356299191713333,
0.5764449834823608,
-0.5522074699401855,
0.488549143075943,
-0.5415732860565186,
0.3435068726539612,
-0.3936566412448883,
-1.384572148323059,
-0.6622018218040466,
0.5308638215065002,
-0.849766731262207,
-0.1961452066898346,
0.573687732219696,
0.9865438342094421,
0.1485489308834076,
0.28002020716667175,
0.26288866996765137,
0.524563193321228,
0.3687328100204468,
0.22094111144542694,
1.082983374595642,
-0.048555273562669754,
0.4608885645866394,
-0.0033866739831864834,
-0.2407287061214447,
-0.12641555070877075,
-0.7989693284034729,
-0.6139392852783203,
-0.4999726116657257,
-0.0676729753613472,
-0.4329427182674408,
0.11190132796764374,
0.892389714717865,
0.23114998638629913,
-0.6918649673461914,
0.23668238520622253,
-0.2510312795639038,
0.36679190397262573,
0.0365406833589077,
-0.2742822468280792,
0.4585346281528473,
-0.1764231026172638,
-0.5461866855621338,
0.6877362728118896,
0.4583868086338043,
-0.17905449867248535,
-0.23973217606544495,
0.30974069237709045,
-0.20064985752105713,
0.07495486736297607,
0.8311220407485962,
0.32740291953086853,
-0.6243874430656433,
-0.5863650441169739,
0.0026189337950199842,
0.3064582943916321,
0.37102246284484863,
0.6886292695999146,
-0.7924402952194214,
0.4369380474090576,
0.7322954535484314,
1.1042053699493408,
0.6489797234535217,
0.3094339668750763,
0.30972981452941895,
-0.5873002409934998,
0.17595931887626648,
0.5186800956726074,
0.4750981032848358,
0.4188377857208252,
-0.3324436843395233,
0.5856943726539612,
-0.07325507700443268,
-0.6698655486106873,
-0.9531823992729187,
0.3908786177635193,
-1.2144098281860352,
-0.2819335460662842,
1.1680587530136108,
0.45145183801651,
-0.36156049370765686,
-0.2422114461660385,
-0.4531043767929077,
0.09155910462141037,
-0.27533087134361267,
0.6634332537651062,
0.4669816493988037,
-0.33364397287368774,
-0.4449176490306854,
-0.23606041073799133,
0.41875261068344116,
0.48465096950531006,
-1.276753306388855,
0.16335028409957886,
1.1110599040985107,
-0.09699372202157974,
0.16231825947761536,
0.3174954652786255,
-0.3248124122619629,
0.12914644181728363,
0.005928439553827047,
-0.08320392668247223,
-0.24315029382705688,
-0.26537102460861206,
-0.0789770558476448,
0.3623153567314148,
0.24167108535766602,
0.27001968026161194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03051v1 | Improving Conversational Abilities of Quantized Large Language Models via Direct Preference Alignment | 2024-07-03T12:19:06 | 2024-07-03T12:19:06 | Janghwan Lee, Seongmin Park, Sukjin Hong, Minsoo Kim, Du-Seong Chang, Jungwook Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has facilitated their
transformation into conversational chatbots that can grasp contextual nuances
and generate pertinent sentences, closely mirroring human values through
advanced techniques such as instruction tuning and reinforcement learning from
human feedback (RLHF). However, the computational efficiency required for LLMs,
achieved through techniques like post-training quantization (PTQ), presents
challenges such as token-flipping that can impair chatbot performance. In
response, we propose a novel preference alignment approach, quantization-aware
direct preference optimization (QDPO), that aligns quantized LLMs with their
full-precision counterparts, improving conversational abilities. Evaluated on
two instruction-tuned LLMs in various languages, QDPO demonstrated superior
performance in improving conversational abilities compared to established PTQ
and knowledge-distillation fine-tuning techniques, marking a significant step
forward in the development of efficient and effective conversational LLMs. | [
0.058947596698999405,
-0.7626194357872009,
0.5621359348297119,
0.010283051989972591,
-0.3815467953681946,
0.34133413434028625,
-0.5507271885871887,
0.06854584813117981,
-0.020727744325995445,
0.6240660548210144,
-0.3269483745098114,
-0.4759513735771179,
-0.5775816440582275,
-0.18037788569927216,
0.02492471970617771,
0.9205017685890198,
0.3015969693660736,
0.06759308278560638,
-0.31930309534072876,
0.045019861310720444,
-0.5002233982086182,
-0.616119921207428,
-0.8210650682449341,
-0.07458628714084625,
0.39750710129737854,
0.45692744851112366,
1.16054368019104,
0.7353853583335876,
0.45396703481674194,
0.362140417098999,
-0.010102175176143646,
0.2531963288784027,
-0.5283253192901611,
0.1161981001496315,
0.09701362997293472,
-0.6071285605430603,
-0.9846493601799011,
-0.22201253473758698,
0.6050079464912415,
0.6588088274002075,
-0.33146074414253235,
-0.14063158631324768,
0.13075749576091766,
0.8636997938156128,
-0.551285445690155,
0.1687091737985611,
-0.8232556581497192,
-0.005286186933517456,
0.05983826890587807,
-0.4113147258758545,
-0.4280683994293213,
-0.7013888955116272,
0.37312737107276917,
-0.83021479845047,
-0.08406434208154678,
-0.12872344255447388,
0.718325674533844,
0.5586427450180054,
-0.6016478538513184,
0.09618455916643143,
-0.5697817206382751,
0.8873443007469177,
-0.7384483218193054,
0.4922630488872528,
0.2790857255458832,
0.1867111325263977,
-0.18845024704933167,
-0.2284342497587204,
-0.4513586461544037,
-0.06602662801742554,
0.23622505366802216,
-0.09096404165029526,
-0.16374042630195618,
0.47997719049453735,
0.18348510563373566,
0.26521036028862,
-0.5548911094665527,
0.31243249773979187,
0.1782212108373642,
-0.1738390326499939,
0.5502203702926636,
0.1483636498451233,
0.002612839685752988,
0.06787439435720444,
-0.06960534304380417,
-0.35183626413345337,
-0.6065402030944824,
0.30287396907806396,
0.46267983317375183,
0.34231260418891907,
-0.0903024822473526,
0.5482357740402222,
-0.47090795636177063,
0.8073959946632385,
0.5058197975158691,
-0.15885350108146667,
0.18971826136112213,
-0.27453333139419556,
-0.2375081181526184,
0.13945944607257843,
0.8491411805152893,
0.43434545397758484,
0.45722195506095886,
-0.12058001756668091,
0.05657874047756195,
-0.15672901272773743,
0.15583795309066772,
-0.9619380831718445,
-0.2972024381160736,
0.41646841168403625,
-0.0704527273774147,
-0.48435133695602417,
-0.2718620300292969,
-0.47535625100135803,
-0.4619390666484833,
-0.48448511958122253,
0.3872818052768707,
-0.4335625171661377,
-0.2482176572084427,
0.34436866641044617,
0.03681771084666252,
0.16453374922275543,
0.4396498501300812,
-1.209604024887085,
-0.06314879655838013,
1.0682576894760132,
0.5537116527557373,
-0.014729690738022327,
0.1435239464044571,
-0.7071755528450012,
0.20679731667041779,
-0.3857991397380829,
0.5362061262130737,
-0.7307149171829224,
-0.48000457882881165,
-0.006705064792186022,
-0.28250300884246826,
0.15398730337619781,
-0.5144134163856506,
0.5422765612602234,
-0.6317824721336365,
0.1814458966255188,
-0.03595319762825966,
-0.49416422843933105,
0.21825560927391052,
0.1850309669971466,
-0.28679022192955017,
0.6617123484611511,
-0.08581032603979111,
-0.5571001768112183,
0.25333184003829956,
-0.3780573606491089,
-0.25078338384628296,
-0.05910232290625572,
-0.07063755393028259,
-0.42145246267318726,
0.12269605696201324,
0.3030768036842346,
0.4268764853477478,
-0.1218988224864006,
0.6147139072418213,
-0.32965314388275146,
-0.314039409160614,
0.6127230525016785,
-0.5465235710144043,
0.5350671410560608,
-0.21249622106552124,
-0.20367050170898438,
0.6655761003494263,
-0.6219107508659363,
0.30455735325813293,
-0.059260718524456024,
-0.2907184958457947,
-0.3418523073196411,
0.11825007945299149,
-0.5314282178878784,
-0.02856840193271637,
0.6828696727752686,
-0.2327929586172104,
0.5141034722328186,
-0.6992629170417786,
0.5987595319747925,
1.0440224409103394,
-0.37467893958091736,
0.9275851845741272,
-0.05741545930504799,
0.4372912645339966,
-0.04436931014060974,
0.37019577622413635,
0.015085914172232151,
-0.18769945204257965,
-0.9238967299461365,
-0.35192012786865234,
0.49992886185646057,
0.450053334236145,
-0.7167772650718689,
0.880109429359436,
-0.7633848786354065,
-0.24669043719768524,
-0.6438568830490112,
0.044991634786129,
0.4891548156738281,
0.48052477836608887,
0.015528819523751736,
-0.25864166021347046,
-0.40193694829940796,
-1.0634697675704956,
-0.11981110274791718,
-0.17368441820144653,
-0.12312626838684082,
0.400848925113678,
-0.2548321485519409,
-0.09026447683572769,
1.0180929899215698,
-0.5882811546325684,
0.09885385632514954,
0.1769951581954956,
-0.09066018462181091,
0.19972893595695496,
0.4797455072402954,
0.027570931240916252,
-0.7762564420700073,
-0.7298448085784912,
0.19667308032512665,
-0.30681100487709045,
-0.07354194670915604,
0.22941887378692627,
-0.5645648837089539,
0.363786518573761,
0.1847631186246872,
-0.5760350227355957,
0.10002732276916504,
0.6386730670928955,
-0.19743850827217102,
0.3109622597694397,
-0.14082542061805725,
0.2083897590637207,
-0.9910189509391785,
-0.15706346929073334,
-0.22021366655826569,
-0.263905793428421,
-0.5915201902389526,
-0.4110757112503052,
0.2382754385471344,
-0.21169641613960266,
-0.24560268223285675,
0.5439189672470093,
-0.14960193634033203,
0.09723686426877975,
-0.30199798941612244,
0.19699622690677643,
0.025260604918003082,
0.5935443639755249,
0.3165849447250366,
0.9296332001686096,
0.5578535795211792,
-0.5858045816421509,
0.17357556521892548,
0.35446903109550476,
-0.03830559551715851,
0.6576657891273499,
-0.6305364966392517,
0.43520089983940125,
0.07707656174898148,
0.2103952020406723,
-1.0320311784744263,
-0.06668085604906082,
0.13123343884944916,
-0.46492525935173035,
0.42154833674430847,
-0.28540071845054626,
-0.2780974805355072,
0.008811638690531254,
-0.310494065284729,
0.5803924202919006,
0.6189465522766113,
-0.3682548701763153,
0.4362472891807556,
0.22920821607112885,
-0.22108490765094757,
-0.7494855523109436,
0.13459867238998413,
-0.055050112307071686,
-0.3573322594165802,
-0.5858328938484192,
0.3861597180366516,
-0.059096649289131165,
-0.17286711931228638,
-0.5356575846672058,
-0.14737150073051453,
0.08013149350881577,
0.13271139562129974,
0.19482189416885376,
0.3612392544746399,
0.0065020848996937275,
0.22046011686325073,
0.1362086683511734,
-0.2722388505935669,
-0.2265128195285797,
-0.3207419812679291,
0.9108218550682068,
-0.05929899960756302,
0.016362052410840988,
-0.6121573448181152,
-0.03501564636826515,
0.389741450548172,
-0.32034778594970703,
0.5109142661094666,
0.2478092759847641,
0.15279051661491394,
0.16537417471408844,
-0.547532320022583,
-0.2880820631980896,
-0.5309474468231201,
0.46282073855400085,
-0.49104100465774536,
-1.1818392276763916,
0.021081848070025444,
-0.0908643901348114,
-0.02846657484769821,
-0.010637420229613781,
0.3915890157222748,
-0.11117161810398102,
1.4006576538085938,
0.6068125367164612,
-0.15510405600070953,
0.7966120839118958,
0.053862739354372025,
0.42629167437553406,
-0.8203650712966919,
0.12692584097385406,
-0.41082271933555603,
-0.21587306261062622,
-0.7152514457702637,
-0.47509971261024475,
0.43674251437187195,
0.23254801332950592,
-0.5481938123703003,
0.30610066652297974,
-0.48315006494522095,
0.3672361969947815,
0.6748350858688354,
0.28449875116348267,
0.28949296474456787,
-0.033672720193862915,
0.3316766619682312,
-0.15611010789871216,
-0.5563229322433472,
-0.5798238515853882,
1.4107180833816528,
0.2453315109014511,
0.4800482988357544,
0.045717302709817886,
0.6499665379524231,
-0.02135320007801056,
-0.04913053289055824,
-0.9655440449714661,
0.5725100040435791,
-0.21651239693164825,
-0.140964537858963,
-0.6268803477287292,
-0.5605807304382324,
-0.8541073799133301,
0.1991354376077652,
-0.24479462206363678,
-0.6247873902320862,
-0.055443163961172104,
0.3205747604370117,
-0.5033437013626099,
-0.13939295709133148,
-0.7412823438644409,
0.9628770351409912,
-0.5615406036376953,
-0.4178237318992615,
-0.4902184307575226,
-0.5720592737197876,
0.283888578414917,
0.019856354221701622,
-0.052460622042417526,
-0.3848547041416168,
-0.1624416559934616,
0.5069026350975037,
-0.219837948679924,
0.7848396301269531,
-0.1502622365951538,
-0.5678954720497131,
-0.1416836380958557,
0.12029680609703064,
0.5067427754402161,
0.045923300087451935,
-0.06323651969432831,
0.2595376670360565,
0.04925913363695145,
-0.4732946455478668,
-0.8722870945930481,
0.5403053164482117,
-0.9076468348503113,
-0.9423993229866028,
-0.04716021567583084,
-0.6112154722213745,
-0.6007293462753296,
-0.0865069255232811,
-0.10888344794511795,
0.23381845653057098,
-0.3424277901649475,
0.169555202126503,
0.8026595115661621,
-0.2926742136478424,
0.2563828229904175,
0.6008036732673645,
-0.09821929037570953,
-0.7356715798377991,
0.8824569582939148,
-0.23773811757564545,
0.4787612557411194,
0.9094910621643066,
0.2846011817455292,
-0.3487986922264099,
-0.4452095329761505,
-0.3636617064476013,
0.14023691415786743,
-0.20248550176620483,
-0.29997381567955017,
-0.5595304369926453,
0.032025013118982315,
-0.6273012757301331,
-0.17606402933597565,
-0.4174371361732483,
-0.5742234587669373,
-0.32140830159187317,
0.07959610968828201,
0.3214496970176697,
-0.13961605727672577,
0.16980546712875366,
0.5333058834075928,
-0.8583695888519287,
0.18400326371192932,
0.6570229530334473,
0.30844002962112427,
-0.15384887158870697,
-0.7523781061172485,
-0.17959879338741302,
0.49117177724838257,
-0.4119151830673218,
-0.444157212972641,
0.31932559609413147,
0.1550004780292511,
0.14819307625293732,
0.7192332744598389,
0.07164904475212097,
0.9394634366035461,
-0.5042364597320557,
0.43252113461494446,
0.2536398470401764,
-1.1811878681182861,
0.7216973900794983,
-0.5240821242332458,
0.20886223018169403,
0.5521872043609619,
0.26217201352119446,
-0.5527355074882507,
0.09605561196804047,
-0.4404524266719818,
-0.6988295316696167,
0.6727864742279053,
0.09667276591062546,
0.476458877325058,
0.021881135180592537,
0.2418285608291626,
0.0212592463940382,
0.527520477771759,
-0.4614865481853485,
0.057667236775159836,
-0.05905965343117714,
-0.34401336312294006,
-0.19173592329025269,
-0.36119920015335083,
-0.29140612483024597,
-0.24664844572544098,
0.6714615225791931,
-0.48558351397514343,
0.18262478709220886,
-0.29030826687812805,
0.20709209144115448,
-0.10304280370473862,
0.33787915110588074,
0.5070903301239014,
0.5247896909713745,
-0.29546913504600525,
-0.10333207249641418,
-0.20648275315761566,
-0.036690983921289444,
0.22989390790462494,
0.0069746472872793674,
0.05283602699637413,
-0.5528557300567627,
-0.14260824024677277,
0.952504575252533,
0.46228718757629395,
-0.9075546860694885,
0.6506949663162231,
-0.11443132907152176,
0.062291357666254044,
-0.06478586047887802,
0.38557904958724976,
0.031255654990673065,
0.37370485067367554,
0.1751197874546051,
-0.3249921500682831,
0.051715072244405746,
-0.4867922067642212,
-0.11793132871389389,
0.93166184425354,
-0.3616703748703003,
-0.26928284764289856,
0.4559656083583832,
0.5029215812683105,
-0.5764822363853455,
0.6056898832321167,
0.05029335618019104,
-0.47112828493118286,
0.4926885962486267,
0.45656058192253113,
0.9028187394142151,
-0.17685401439666748,
0.2903549373149872,
0.2760147154331207,
-0.3163335621356964,
0.015432876534759998,
-0.11095897108316422,
-0.5519288182258606,
-1.099700927734375,
-0.43082064390182495,
-0.5777751207351685,
-0.5760225057601929,
-0.318464070558548,
-0.632557213306427,
0.3153430223464966,
-0.33962440490722656,
-0.33027535676956177,
-0.10431341826915741,
0.02167782559990883,
-0.3603174686431885,
-0.021002020686864853,
0.12529511749744415,
0.24803926050662994,
-0.3142303228378296,
1.0465893745422363,
0.49001622200012207,
0.02982415445148945,
-0.5704712271690369,
-0.053228333592414856,
-0.4317528009414673,
-0.9963613152503967,
0.73809814453125,
-0.03526178374886513,
0.024214109405875206,
0.3786284029483795,
-0.5113987326622009,
-0.9349465370178223,
1.0378142595291138,
0.48653122782707214,
-1.059121012687683,
-0.060457494109869,
0.3231680691242218,
0.5124845504760742,
-0.07726608961820602,
0.37128013372421265,
0.686505913734436,
0.2221149504184723,
0.08332376182079315,
-1.2250994443893433,
-0.11838053166866302,
-0.052650146186351776,
0.1772717386484146,
0.5824947953224182,
-0.927782416343689,
0.3311345875263214,
-0.05270994454622269,
-0.15807007253170013,
0.10709080845117569,
0.6685382723808289,
0.3524160385131836,
0.007632726803421974,
0.46083715558052063,
0.690388560295105,
0.8054320216178894,
-0.24430780112743378,
0.7242169976234436,
-0.4476078152656555,
-0.04480788856744766,
1.0486729145050049,
-0.5088027119636536,
0.9644666314125061,
0.5719343423843384,
-0.4118069112300873,
0.1780664175748825,
0.49094071984291077,
0.4298818111419678,
0.5687954425811768,
0.1249341070652008,
-0.39830753207206726,
-0.4869215786457062,
-0.04031123220920563,
-0.20285378396511078,
0.6146016716957092,
0.24158604443073273,
-0.08725475519895554,
0.3300507962703705,
-0.12685634195804596,
-0.021233903244137764,
0.13684946298599243,
-0.20602060854434967,
1.0843561887741089,
-0.16009758412837982,
-0.7806202173233032,
0.9220852851867676,
-0.15279348194599152,
0.958092212677002,
-0.48626789450645447,
0.05261222645640373,
-0.2364654541015625,
0.1316056102514267,
0.03129158541560173,
-0.5451852083206177,
-0.06425762176513672,
-0.15650713443756104,
-0.17924128472805023,
-0.2869170010089874,
0.25178611278533936,
-0.5446118116378784,
-0.14639143645763397,
-0.11715976148843765,
0.3386354446411133,
-0.11256232857704163,
-0.3625444769859314,
-0.5048615336418152,
-0.008304483257234097,
0.24929296970367432,
0.057093795388936996,
0.63175368309021,
0.5291329622268677,
-0.07784117013216019,
0.5969591736793518,
0.6603344678878784,
-0.11955834180116653,
-0.1669466644525528,
0.06432601064443588,
0.6691020727157593,
-0.6630573868751526,
-0.2927815318107605,
-0.9097447991371155,
0.4373883605003357,
-0.12230897694826126,
-0.3096756637096405,
0.6292378902435303,
0.667208731174469,
0.7514505982398987,
0.020958255976438522,
0.6081339716911316,
0.27340492606163025,
0.23255789279937744,
-0.625466525554657,
0.37091729044914246,
-0.18360042572021484,
0.12964612245559692,
-0.14388231933116913,
-1.0202597379684448,
-0.10398048907518387,
0.6031266450881958,
-0.6252996921539307,
-0.1983426958322525,
0.31788182258605957,
0.913470983505249,
0.2591492533683777,
-0.26098254323005676,
0.5577229857444763,
0.011314322240650654,
0.4286530017852783,
0.7358014583587646,
0.8890281319618225,
-0.2892390787601471,
0.5156053900718689,
-0.36584123969078064,
-0.2530355453491211,
-0.26458361744880676,
-0.8160073757171631,
-0.8231815695762634,
-0.5607981085777283,
-0.5727751851081848,
-0.23189109563827515,
0.15612123906612396,
0.9175781011581421,
0.7518207430839539,
-0.5732482671737671,
-0.31387513875961304,
-0.16571499407291412,
0.05869290605187416,
0.04136946052312851,
-0.3013293445110321,
0.3659008741378784,
-0.39152607321739197,
-1.1644818782806396,
0.1757466346025467,
0.47524529695510864,
0.22156238555908203,
0.027367034927010536,
-0.15814779698848724,
0.2883579134941101,
0.04164138436317444,
0.7638879418373108,
0.13214556872844696,
-0.7710736393928528,
-0.23999756574630737,
0.1622394621372223,
-0.280513197183609,
0.38529661297798157,
0.8301812410354614,
-0.6801368594169617,
0.4826180040836334,
0.32764923572540283,
0.6447169780731201,
0.22439567744731903,
0.3784908354282379,
0.806496798992157,
-0.6728947162628174,
0.24970632791519165,
0.345689982175827,
0.023510796949267387,
0.2936900556087494,
-0.4371897876262665,
0.28382202982902527,
-0.1898399293422699,
-0.8078675866127014,
-0.7917762398719788,
0.18816375732421875,
-1.2111033201217651,
-0.11727865785360336,
1.2184218168258667,
0.14479482173919678,
-0.08228820562362671,
0.3142800033092499,
-0.605697512626648,
0.4071262776851654,
-0.7376733422279358,
0.981364369392395,
0.47167280316352844,
-0.18399593234062195,
-0.16022402048110962,
-0.078209787607193,
0.7364901900291443,
0.7409645915031433,
-0.6864273548126221,
0.2681736350059509,
0.6382856965065002,
0.08742214739322662,
-0.17871811985969543,
0.765594482421875,
-0.0631561130285263,
0.12742480635643005,
-0.5156886577606201,
0.2792964279651642,
0.13384202122688293,
-0.0670955702662468,
-0.528978168964386,
-0.1607571542263031,
0.3708338439464569,
-0.27909716963768005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03045v1 | JailbreakHunter: A Visual Analytics Approach for Jailbreak Prompts Discovery from Large-Scale Human-LLM Conversational Datasets | 2024-07-03T12:10:41 | 2024-07-03T12:10:41 | Zhihua Jin, Shiyi Liu, Haotian Li, Xun Zhao, Huamin Qu | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained significant attention but also
raised concerns due to the risk of misuse. Jailbreak prompts, a popular type of
adversarial attack towards LLMs, have appeared and constantly evolved to breach
the safety protocols of LLMs. To address this issue, LLMs are regularly updated
with safety patches based on reported jailbreak prompts. However, malicious
users often keep their successful jailbreak prompts private to exploit LLMs. To
uncover these private jailbreak prompts, extensive analysis of large-scale
conversational datasets is necessary to identify prompts that still manage to
bypass the system's defenses. This task is highly challenging due to the
immense volume of conversation data, diverse characteristics of jailbreak
prompts, and their presence in complex multi-turn conversations. To tackle
these challenges, we introduce JailbreakHunter, a visual analytics approach for
identifying jailbreak prompts in large-scale human-LLM conversational datasets.
We have designed a workflow with three analysis levels: group-level,
conversation-level, and turn-level. Group-level analysis enables users to grasp
the distribution of conversations and identify suspicious conversations using
multiple criteria, such as similarity with reported jailbreak prompts in
previous research and attack success rates. Conversation-level analysis
facilitates the understanding of the progress of conversations and helps
discover jailbreak prompts within their conversation contexts. Turn-level
analysis allows users to explore the semantic similarity and token overlap
between a singleturn prompt and the reported jailbreak prompts, aiding in the
identification of new jailbreak strategies. The effectiveness and usability of
the system were verified through multiple case studies and expert interviews. | [
-0.26509031653404236,
-1.0520081520080566,
0.5310864448547363,
0.4359452724456787,
-0.1099863052368164,
0.5203588604927063,
-0.12710082530975342,
-0.19891506433486938,
0.4791678190231323,
0.7193828225135803,
-0.8264228105545044,
-0.9172882437705994,
-0.5302320718765259,
-0.04155241325497627,
-0.35116705298423767,
0.74092698097229,
0.12425783276557922,
-0.19331170618534088,
-0.12541402876377106,
-0.06108703464269638,
-1.0841847658157349,
-0.5311694741249084,
-0.5119020342826843,
0.2671363353729248,
0.5160148739814758,
0.6466791033744812,
0.3872377276420593,
0.4267585277557373,
0.47784286737442017,
0.3657953441143036,
-0.2004346400499344,
0.14166806638240814,
-0.7317814826965332,
0.5904223918914795,
0.14613085985183716,
-0.34659531712532043,
-0.2897002100944519,
-0.15651355683803558,
-0.031397756189107895,
0.29126089811325073,
-0.3836368918418884,
0.11708317697048187,
-0.16169103980064392,
0.6745356917381287,
-0.5869451761245728,
0.1316062957048416,
-0.6919567584991455,
0.023773636668920517,
-0.5292845368385315,
-0.22197453677654266,
-0.44597554206848145,
-0.3903518319129944,
0.1475607454776764,
-0.21300823986530304,
0.13867567479610443,
0.1102856993675232,
0.39391690492630005,
0.067863829433918,
-0.14080719649791718,
-0.11063037067651749,
-0.40375083684921265,
0.4055688977241516,
-0.6892852187156677,
-0.12465687096118927,
0.1668185591697693,
0.5592334866523743,
-0.658754289150238,
-0.3509753346443176,
-0.26313334703445435,
-0.3120989501476288,
-0.09970230609178543,
-0.18335580825805664,
-0.5933114886283875,
0.017375122755765915,
0.24819283187389374,
-0.006051278673112392,
-0.6994223594665527,
0.29742690920829773,
-0.40120258927345276,
-0.3085787296295166,
0.6467391848564148,
0.6240493655204773,
0.5658628344535828,
-0.23990577459335327,
-0.25664380192756653,
-0.006162367295473814,
-0.750794529914856,
0.14354956150054932,
0.47406694293022156,
0.35947927832603455,
-0.3918725848197937,
0.43776047229766846,
-0.29981449246406555,
0.8539344072341919,
-0.18330299854278564,
-0.162552148103714,
0.16412541270256042,
-0.3101239800453186,
0.05251053720712662,
0.13523322343826294,
1.1477153301239014,
0.5244387984275818,
0.4476115107536316,
-0.11555920541286469,
0.14965705573558807,
-0.23839589953422546,
0.2866981029510498,
-0.9083256721496582,
-0.3737015128135681,
0.30471503734588623,
-0.4116629362106323,
-0.7404570579528809,
0.0711776539683342,
-1.1815154552459717,
-1.4013947248458862,
0.17322233319282532,
-0.040277931839227676,
-0.1951298713684082,
-0.15339767932891846,
-0.20610792934894562,
-0.22369152307510376,
0.1399882584810257,
0.31578391790390015,
-0.66232830286026,
0.06005680561065674,
0.6059458255767822,
1.0164649486541748,
-0.2806057631969452,
-0.2539646625518799,
-0.7666774392127991,
-0.10144895315170288,
-0.2536942660808563,
0.7222043871879578,
-0.4755542576313019,
-0.40592026710510254,
-0.07480289787054062,
-0.0881027951836586,
0.02085472270846367,
-0.6622805595397949,
0.23028676211833954,
-0.43382126092910767,
-0.22972716391086578,
-0.11303386837244034,
-0.22063277661800385,
-0.11382126808166504,
0.4355354309082031,
-0.6107253432273865,
0.535359263420105,
-0.2546347975730896,
-0.830572783946991,
0.2791662812232971,
-0.6321592926979065,
-0.3508031964302063,
0.09719535708427429,
-0.20518659055233002,
-0.527169942855835,
0.012827671132981777,
0.47095659375190735,
0.7212982773780823,
-0.2792641520500183,
0.4881252348423004,
-0.667466402053833,
-0.3001750707626343,
0.31471630930900574,
-0.27719345688819885,
0.8067280054092407,
0.1746886521577835,
-0.4265922009944916,
0.4653346836566925,
-0.6848339438438416,
-0.3994061052799225,
0.37831929326057434,
0.09394881874322891,
-0.379486083984375,
0.20148000121116638,
-0.21914979815483093,
-0.10154363512992859,
0.08703901618719101,
-0.681281566619873,
0.48045814037323,
-0.14496473968029022,
0.4881930947303772,
0.6549105644226074,
0.30792000889778137,
0.003979732282459736,
0.21359194815158844,
0.7364071011543274,
0.2554447054862976,
0.2531742453575134,
-0.5938417315483093,
-0.5312892198562622,
-0.3322964906692505,
-0.33664047718048096,
-0.12382423132658005,
1.0128319263458252,
-0.38640978932380676,
0.26503998041152954,
-0.07900961488485336,
-0.6630029082298279,
-0.4628477394580841,
0.34448108077049255,
0.3498886823654175,
0.48469486832618713,
0.18750496208667755,
-0.13250629603862762,
-0.6383939981460571,
-0.8930899500846863,
-0.6696248650550842,
-0.18784396350383759,
0.14330947399139404,
0.26518574357032776,
0.23417901992797852,
-0.37983885407447815,
0.9254158139228821,
-0.7067012190818787,
-0.18279600143432617,
-0.5756276249885559,
0.29077744483947754,
0.34560319781303406,
0.28067198395729065,
0.5540993809700012,
-0.422321081161499,
-0.30485987663269043,
-0.1539541780948639,
-0.9597486257553101,
-0.4597816467285156,
-0.29041674733161926,
0.07923825085163116,
-0.27462613582611084,
0.8327310085296631,
-0.3652370572090149,
0.667441725730896,
0.43883252143859863,
-0.7591850161552429,
0.6539263129234314,
0.19603173434734344,
0.1767081767320633,
-0.9036784172058105,
-0.2629528343677521,
0.14312466979026794,
-0.2087927758693695,
-0.751059353351593,
-0.24710538983345032,
-0.10276181995868683,
-0.3583191931247711,
-0.31157809495925903,
0.4425399899482727,
-0.43766841292381287,
-0.09081050753593445,
-0.033461328595876694,
0.30851373076438904,
-0.2540091574192047,
0.36498475074768066,
-0.2981348931789398,
0.8629274964332581,
0.5892089009284973,
0.06355271488428116,
0.7798436880111694,
0.27191561460494995,
-0.3554155230522156,
0.34184056520462036,
-0.6762534379959106,
0.20627322793006897,
-0.23882749676704407,
-0.014384234324097633,
-1.2580809593200684,
-0.2644466459751129,
0.2541380822658539,
-0.4077902138233185,
0.0169813334941864,
-0.5357848405838013,
-0.37903741002082825,
-0.16965334117412567,
-0.5154514908790588,
-0.01002705842256546,
0.11038675159215927,
-0.5721897482872009,
0.5494404435157776,
0.4945066273212433,
-0.5457242727279663,
-0.401569128036499,
-0.3062994182109833,
0.652174174785614,
-0.6556525826454163,
-1.0559844970703125,
-0.1293705850839615,
0.06309791654348373,
-0.6090171933174133,
-0.5216971039772034,
0.1272909790277481,
0.12572240829467773,
0.4149663746356964,
0.6386209726333618,
0.672731339931488,
0.10489530861377716,
-0.5263916254043579,
-0.20116198062896729,
0.0033572912216186523,
0.40571796894073486,
0.1059427484869957,
0.5857424139976501,
-0.2458781749010086,
0.03135412558913231,
-0.6038370132446289,
0.19233238697052002,
0.7665479779243469,
-0.16385839879512787,
0.7271376252174377,
0.4441494345664978,
0.14524821937084198,
-0.08247580379247665,
-0.6486445069313049,
0.04816924035549164,
-0.4908437728881836,
0.2002040445804596,
-0.2575945556163788,
-0.857479453086853,
0.632442831993103,
-0.11734774708747864,
0.025855934247374535,
-0.16454041004180908,
0.4909716546535492,
-0.004353787750005722,
1.1722209453582764,
0.4975700378417969,
-0.5168147683143616,
0.658871591091156,
-0.11143747717142105,
0.10653959959745407,
-0.5307604074478149,
-0.4922310411930084,
-0.3287813365459442,
-0.25871190428733826,
-0.497849702835083,
-0.0844104215502739,
0.37966370582580566,
0.0840640515089035,
-0.057816196233034134,
0.4034135937690735,
-0.2613511383533478,
0.5793681740760803,
0.3167281746864319,
-0.017064906656742096,
0.36079132556915283,
-0.15926195681095123,
0.03683099150657654,
-0.030010005459189415,
-0.26772040128707886,
-0.2876303195953369,
0.9888136386871338,
0.3941788077354431,
1.0008429288864136,
0.20689454674720764,
0.7902541756629944,
0.553388237953186,
0.20395438373088837,
-0.8253799676895142,
0.6535457372665405,
0.24098047614097595,
-0.2944238781929016,
-0.2240566611289978,
-0.5411474108695984,
-1.0897915363311768,
0.33730316162109375,
-0.12942177057266235,
-1.183730959892273,
-0.04671869054436684,
0.18367989361286163,
-0.2605679929256439,
0.15878795087337494,
-0.8865243792533875,
1.188852310180664,
-0.35172921419143677,
-0.20417940616607666,
-0.046936869621276855,
-0.7205109000205994,
0.6699371933937073,
0.1175009235739708,
0.43223699927330017,
-0.149529367685318,
0.39856064319610596,
0.8061851859092712,
-0.690951943397522,
1.133315920829773,
-0.6207684874534607,
0.0313076488673687,
0.4096604287624359,
0.39181214570999146,
0.9156413078308105,
0.2745586037635803,
0.37461209297180176,
0.027745526283979416,
-0.17121721804141998,
-0.11848277598619461,
-0.532121479511261,
0.6439895033836365,
-0.4576450288295746,
-0.7258550524711609,
-0.2893586754798889,
-0.36387506127357483,
-0.3037654161453247,
0.08418519794940948,
0.20042318105697632,
0.3089708983898163,
-0.18225623667240143,
0.0012077559949830174,
0.4978460371494293,
-0.4654957354068756,
0.29079583287239075,
0.27326634526252747,
-0.40533173084259033,
-0.3846745789051056,
0.7830930948257446,
-0.3203893303871155,
-0.14852885901927948,
-0.0424003042280674,
0.2885476350784302,
0.04017641767859459,
-0.9129621982574463,
-0.5182457566261292,
0.12047892063856125,
-0.4137490689754486,
-0.26954221725463867,
-0.38074618577957153,
0.11973442137241364,
-0.23819653689861298,
-0.016638953238725662,
-0.07744012027978897,
-0.026347456499934196,
-0.1637762039899826,
-0.22511187195777893,
0.8005494475364685,
0.5840524435043335,
0.2024337500333786,
0.5023940801620483,
-0.8808236122131348,
0.3588954210281372,
0.22829793393611908,
0.09386371821165085,
-0.04831118509173393,
-0.23395341634750366,
-0.029524242505431175,
-0.20218418538570404,
-0.24877013266086578,
-1.300203561782837,
0.5014885663986206,
-0.22534233331680298,
0.4137353003025055,
0.422368586063385,
-0.11732932925224304,
0.7312365770339966,
-0.3642718195915222,
0.6544846892356873,
0.33238714933395386,
-0.7992189526557922,
0.8571707010269165,
-0.6584831476211548,
-0.006803755648434162,
0.8048405647277832,
-0.07039103657007217,
-0.6307146549224854,
-0.4503430128097534,
-0.38147005438804626,
-1.0283808708190918,
0.5953036546707153,
0.08871038258075714,
-0.0711553692817688,
0.14228928089141846,
0.07365553081035614,
-0.11437291651964188,
0.2733455002307892,
-0.4253195822238922,
-0.30118295550346375,
-0.09585335850715637,
-0.1531480848789215,
0.11414268612861633,
-0.030618930235505104,
-0.17238344252109528,
-0.17038469016551971,
0.1571492999792099,
-0.01928156428039074,
-0.1556318998336792,
-0.18365229666233063,
-0.2563975155353546,
0.3611026406288147,
0.4589601457118988,
0.31103333830833435,
0.646623432636261,
-0.3026452362537384,
-0.062031641602516174,
0.060091253370046616,
-0.6438117623329163,
0.08632316440343857,
-0.006001374218612909,
0.1240808516740799,
-0.08748690783977509,
0.45085272192955017,
0.9015527963638306,
-0.10406756401062012,
-1.1500777006149292,
0.9138455390930176,
-0.2713946998119354,
0.11645331233739853,
-0.4040428698062897,
0.16068224608898163,
0.03759773448109627,
0.4974514842033386,
0.29902324080467224,
-0.09237520396709442,
0.32882773876190186,
-0.5883841514587402,
-0.06445932388305664,
0.48696956038475037,
-0.41376709938049316,
-0.26216891407966614,
0.4421820342540741,
0.30285605788230896,
-0.2926971912384033,
0.8455146551132202,
-0.009327608160674572,
-0.5091869235038757,
0.6424587368965149,
0.2907293438911438,
1.0883506536483765,
-0.03022422455251217,
0.28883007168769836,
0.04604533314704895,
0.3147512376308441,
0.14704854786396027,
0.25710731744766235,
0.012959563173353672,
-0.5746253728866577,
-0.4482695460319519,
-0.24488188326358795,
-0.2818467319011688,
0.26221930980682373,
-0.7211939692497253,
0.2811149060726166,
-0.5405692458152771,
-0.05100029334425926,
0.09860443323850632,
-0.5361777544021606,
-0.4438566267490387,
-0.2253449261188507,
0.27816295623779297,
0.9668858647346497,
-0.7716863751411438,
0.48206284642219543,
0.3434434235095978,
-0.08228018134832382,
-0.5395967960357666,
-0.32685261964797974,
0.6926948428153992,
-0.7423792481422424,
0.5051225423812866,
0.39069437980651855,
-0.12510240077972412,
-0.3484475612640381,
-0.911903440952301,
-0.4352032244205475,
1.0242482423782349,
0.30954259634017944,
-0.7984703779220581,
0.07423148304224014,
-0.15954381227493286,
0.34773972630500793,
-0.3947750926017761,
-0.03106022998690605,
1.1337136030197144,
0.4675154983997345,
0.10509796440601349,
-0.611489474773407,
0.18670733273029327,
-0.3597542345523834,
-0.08740490674972534,
0.5792316794395447,
-0.32446298003196716,
0.3916310966014862,
-0.6461549997329712,
-0.00028587845736183226,
0.008089864626526833,
0.39911049604415894,
0.6489959359169006,
0.4480009377002716,
0.4958662688732147,
0.36092719435691833,
0.6601128578186035,
-0.13869056105613708,
0.7298210263252258,
-0.020112499594688416,
0.09808564931154251,
1.0878914594650269,
-0.15756931900978088,
0.5498332977294922,
0.557106614112854,
0.013324343599379063,
0.6876768469810486,
0.5275580883026123,
-0.3957231044769287,
0.47148406505584717,
0.5388036966323853,
-0.08797433972358704,
-0.1940942406654358,
0.20637889206409454,
-0.09196963161230087,
0.456341952085495,
0.4918707609176636,
-0.17065195739269257,
-0.11243913322687149,
0.36901339888572693,
0.5694838762283325,
-0.14567741751670837,
-0.3322165608406067,
1.0963026285171509,
-0.17154140770435333,
-0.38144248723983765,
0.5663014054298401,
-0.06306999176740646,
0.7270516157150269,
-0.4800822138786316,
0.0024391827173531055,
-0.38528624176979065,
-0.03156135976314545,
-0.32124024629592896,
-0.716382622718811,
0.0745723694562912,
0.519257664680481,
0.08955893665552139,
-0.018459811806678772,
0.6708828210830688,
-0.11950086802244186,
-0.09103923290967941,
0.37887826561927795,
0.420867919921875,
0.22361035645008087,
-0.33685365319252014,
-0.5906098484992981,
0.38648730516433716,
0.14056554436683655,
-0.39311617612838745,
0.26974254846572876,
0.21213552355766296,
-0.1291821449995041,
0.8850222229957581,
0.6764228940010071,
0.1649492233991623,
0.1271824985742569,
0.2022702544927597,
0.9985819458961487,
-0.9899328351020813,
-0.5221489667892456,
-1.2680375576019287,
0.6811574101448059,
-0.4759255349636078,
-0.28472796082496643,
0.9086595773696899,
0.4607246220111847,
0.2433159053325653,
0.12310491502285004,
0.8895473480224609,
-0.03760512173175812,
0.42558732628822327,
-0.5806254744529724,
0.5698888301849365,
-0.09259006381034851,
0.8708758354187012,
-0.5423356890678406,
-0.565650463104248,
-0.15302927792072296,
0.2623492181301117,
-0.5274075269699097,
-0.35531434416770935,
0.24648529291152954,
0.8855732083320618,
0.1634264588356018,
0.14447949826717377,
-0.02795100398361683,
0.27310070395469666,
0.5394117832183838,
0.2976953387260437,
1.201755404472351,
0.051885295659303665,
0.8526254892349243,
0.1619102507829666,
-0.4978000521659851,
-0.31683507561683655,
-0.7793048620223999,
-1.2227396965026855,
-0.20638063549995422,
-0.1668785661458969,
-0.4522530436515808,
0.08149801939725876,
0.735556423664093,
0.5815339088439941,
-0.7518618106842041,
-0.43656113743782043,
-0.1321599930524826,
0.09810417890548706,
0.018538963049650192,
-0.29810449481010437,
-0.01155219879001379,
-0.20637750625610352,
-0.17964495718479156,
1.0035946369171143,
0.40040525794029236,
-0.10395579040050507,
-0.2901822030544281,
0.20804056525230408,
0.1800817996263504,
-0.11118461936712265,
0.6448521018028259,
0.4245864152908325,
-0.4841143488883972,
0.09222263842821121,
-0.10240273177623749,
0.10445211082696915,
0.1158609688282013,
1.1324739456176758,
-0.8224441409111023,
0.5845121741294861,
0.5179371237754822,
0.5990229249000549,
0.7625356912612915,
0.1831149458885193,
0.6367923021316528,
-0.9402027726173401,
0.20525768399238586,
-0.017322534695267677,
0.37985238432884216,
0.3624557554721832,
-0.41403019428253174,
0.34355247020721436,
0.14370517432689667,
-0.3111535310745239,
-0.8992669582366943,
0.1605297327041626,
-0.8611471652984619,
-0.5096065402030945,
1.0159269571304321,
-0.1871548295021057,
-0.16363497078418732,
-0.33892500400543213,
-0.5072034597396851,
-0.3159139156341553,
-0.7067261338233948,
0.8081414699554443,
0.5906942486763,
-0.35300391912460327,
-0.15240010619163513,
-0.637651264667511,
0.39820292592048645,
-0.23727989196777344,
-1.1400625705718994,
0.6007444858551025,
0.5965554714202881,
0.28546270728111267,
0.23538866639137268,
0.22989846765995026,
-0.17057406902313232,
0.012182063423097134,
-0.20606966316699982,
-0.20614659786224365,
-0.39759624004364014,
-0.49036723375320435,
-0.4257241189479828,
0.23416535556316376,
-0.11633633822202682,
-0.17041732370853424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03040v1 | Raw Text is All you Need: Knowledge-intensive Multi-turn Instruction Tuning for Large Language Model | 2024-07-03T12:04:10 | 2024-07-03T12:04:10 | Xia Hou, Qifeng Li, Jian Yang, Tongliang Li, Linzheng Chai, Xianjie Wu, Hangyuan Ji, Zhoujun Li, Jixuan Nie, Jingbo Dun, Wenfeng Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Instruction tuning as an effective technique aligns the outputs of large
language models (LLMs) with human preference. But how to generate the seasonal
multi-turn dialogues from raw documents for instruction tuning still requires
further exploration. In this paper, we present a novel framework named R2S that
leverages the CoD-Chain of Dialogue logic to guide large language models (LLMs)
in generating knowledge-intensive multi-turn dialogues for instruction tuning.
By integrating raw documents from both open-source datasets and domain-specific
web-crawled documents into a benchmark K-BENCH, we cover diverse areas such as
Wikipedia (English), Science (Chinese), and Artifacts (Chinese). Our approach
first decides the logic flow of the current dialogue and then prompts LLMs to
produce key phrases for sourcing relevant response content. This methodology
enables the creation of the G I NSTRUCT instruction dataset, retaining raw
document knowledge within dialoguestyle interactions. Utilizing this dataset,
we fine-tune GLLM, a model designed to transform raw documents into structured
multi-turn dialogues, thereby injecting comprehensive domain knowledge into the
SFT model for enhanced instruction tuning. This work signifies a stride towards
refining the adaptability and effectiveness of LLMs in processing and
generating more accurate, contextually nuanced responses across various fields. | [
-0.0013787547359243035,
-0.6531882882118225,
0.5433682203292847,
-0.1738872230052948,
-0.24206508696079254,
0.050089478492736816,
-0.558039128780365,
-0.1558683216571808,
-0.1952504962682724,
0.7560945153236389,
-0.9205948710441589,
-0.6739431023597717,
-0.29740574955940247,
-0.11091956496238708,
-0.1357019543647766,
1.2286659479141235,
0.2667303681373596,
0.1491829752922058,
-0.11196374893188477,
-0.05870554968714714,
-0.20872969925403595,
-0.1732439249753952,
-0.4932962656021118,
-0.26130321621894836,
0.4777660369873047,
0.7149380445480347,
0.5817053914070129,
0.7641880512237549,
0.13780967891216278,
0.23885954916477203,
0.33560752868652344,
0.701688826084137,
-0.6142487525939941,
0.29149651527404785,
-0.27988260984420776,
-0.496513694524765,
-0.3928070068359375,
0.0652230978012085,
0.5721627473831177,
0.1496640294790268,
-0.3168482780456543,
0.24751155078411102,
-0.017555177211761475,
0.6275012493133545,
-0.39254310727119446,
0.1784936636686325,
-1.0292258262634277,
-0.21860770881175995,
-0.04430372267961502,
-0.5262713432312012,
-0.9068943858146667,
-0.3468765914440155,
-0.147596538066864,
-0.7278178334236145,
0.5284587740898132,
0.053518012166023254,
0.8399986028671265,
0.22783449292182922,
-0.35150110721588135,
-0.3717654347419739,
-0.6080148220062256,
0.8687087297439575,
-0.8948267698287964,
0.3798447847366333,
0.24155569076538086,
0.10831611603498459,
-0.2388984113931656,
-0.6177510619163513,
-0.46490949392318726,
0.0941881537437439,
-0.08424932509660721,
0.19277270138263702,
0.3843996226787567,
0.12863129377365112,
0.0975770428776741,
0.2993972897529602,
-0.4302729368209839,
0.1277519315481186,
-0.2243860363960266,
-0.10013750940561295,
0.5969927906990051,
0.2772372364997864,
0.33457618951797485,
0.053480032831430435,
-0.374397337436676,
-0.19094032049179077,
-0.7627530694007874,
-0.08437559008598328,
0.630222499370575,
0.46881014108657837,
-0.170355886220932,
0.5932095050811768,
-0.015320930629968643,
0.8077095150947571,
-0.0020191173534840345,
-0.4776078760623932,
-0.18105517327785492,
-0.49705350399017334,
0.048733070492744446,
-0.056932006031274796,
0.7596235275268555,
0.5475990772247314,
0.40377160906791687,
-0.2601650357246399,
-0.17635470628738403,
-0.15963391959667206,
0.5480626821517944,
-1.0988259315490723,
-0.26702943444252014,
0.00079119618749246,
-0.21220260858535767,
-0.12921656668186188,
0.019151605665683746,
-0.8952655792236328,
-0.3299020528793335,
-0.7473008036613464,
-0.021144114434719086,
-0.5215342044830322,
-0.21774286031723022,
-0.05344304069876671,
0.012128588743507862,
0.44709837436676025,
0.243350088596344,
-1.1199287176132202,
0.1761574000120163,
0.8107374310493469,
0.7264252305030823,
-0.0842600017786026,
-0.1192648708820343,
-0.8047552108764648,
0.34033191204071045,
-0.38836824893951416,
0.8422906994819641,
-0.8520073294639587,
-0.2390604019165039,
0.22446128726005554,
0.05356498807668686,
-0.3507017493247986,
-0.38285839557647705,
0.5118329524993896,
-0.7244184017181396,
0.1449694037437439,
0.06096477806568146,
-0.5094264149665833,
-0.01947176456451416,
0.09037195891141891,
-0.4919900894165039,
1.0117487907409668,
0.14770221710205078,
-0.5354986786842346,
0.0566418319940567,
-0.4981271028518677,
-0.756600558757782,
-0.08975163847208023,
-0.21668654680252075,
-0.35997268557548523,
0.0879785344004631,
0.2899687886238098,
0.24892190098762512,
-0.4670295715332031,
0.22009120881557465,
-0.009748131036758423,
-0.25885632634162903,
0.26278871297836304,
-0.5067722201347351,
0.32335609197616577,
0.059417709708213806,
-0.17747773230075836,
0.2941463887691498,
-0.8448299169540405,
0.4869857430458069,
-0.11590797454118729,
-0.617624044418335,
-0.12688328325748444,
0.313106894493103,
-0.02994322031736374,
0.05263126641511917,
0.1396811455488205,
-0.3461625576019287,
0.46817508339881897,
-0.48144811391830444,
0.6673839092254639,
0.7398382425308228,
0.0213607344776392,
0.4490825831890106,
-0.021331366151571274,
0.46276336908340454,
-0.06182049214839935,
0.049757108092308044,
-0.6175724267959595,
-0.4270963966846466,
-0.9042249321937561,
-0.22616301476955414,
0.11298888176679611,
0.6750814914703369,
-0.6855615973472595,
0.3445066213607788,
-0.26659178733825684,
-0.2109324038028717,
-0.9125814437866211,
0.4422718286514282,
0.5408533215522766,
0.44801151752471924,
0.5097843408584595,
0.1873004138469696,
-0.47813165187835693,
-0.8285319805145264,
-0.21874704957008362,
0.12168946862220764,
-0.17594443261623383,
0.4334518015384674,
0.023870239034295082,
-0.17555229365825653,
0.7952283620834351,
-0.6991532444953918,
-0.24991485476493835,
-0.15075072646141052,
0.3339228630065918,
0.07342256605625153,
0.20287960767745972,
-0.0384475439786911,
-0.6103500723838806,
-0.4420757293701172,
0.1565360575914383,
-0.5471693277359009,
0.05364900827407837,
-0.12665899097919464,
-0.38011714816093445,
0.5707941055297852,
0.6306689381599426,
-0.40936458110809326,
0.08741286396980286,
0.45588457584381104,
-0.0710459053516388,
0.38960501551628113,
-0.2745208740234375,
0.10549503564834595,
-1.2455956935882568,
-0.044449225068092346,
0.018574902787804604,
0.009029663167893887,
-0.39809730648994446,
0.2702253460884094,
0.193058043718338,
-0.08696088194847107,
-0.15590524673461914,
0.35780036449432373,
-0.5277184844017029,
0.025619447231292725,
-0.27622029185295105,
0.3168792724609375,
0.17340949177742004,
0.6889111995697021,
0.19020231068134308,
1.1249033212661743,
-0.025694165378808975,
-0.6127180457115173,
0.2869901955127716,
0.2433166801929474,
-0.5342231392860413,
0.3502151072025299,
-0.5401439070701599,
0.42391085624694824,
0.1098814308643341,
0.305399090051651,
-0.7576690912246704,
-0.21070753037929535,
0.11295191198587418,
-0.2299412339925766,
0.5794268846511841,
-0.48101943731307983,
-0.4516969323158264,
-0.09853119403123856,
-0.18283364176750183,
0.08979886770248413,
0.4022327661514282,
-0.4890507161617279,
0.7364224791526794,
0.1390853226184845,
-0.39747655391693115,
-0.4785131812095642,
-0.25665974617004395,
-0.0020899076480418444,
0.11587762832641602,
-0.7069732546806335,
0.3398212194442749,
-0.20897091925144196,
0.05486021935939789,
-0.15032805502414703,
-0.1346481442451477,
0.050762634724378586,
-0.16110295057296753,
0.07566939294338226,
0.4415501356124878,
-0.48579856753349304,
0.11069810390472412,
0.3420833945274353,
-0.10934512317180634,
0.06309153139591217,
-0.531236469745636,
0.4928079843521118,
0.06914842873811722,
-0.30238813161849976,
-0.27624189853668213,
0.35874277353286743,
0.6183118224143982,
-0.3651116192340851,
0.566715657711029,
0.7516503930091858,
0.160507470369339,
-0.5782871246337891,
-0.6276610493659973,
-0.4438387155532837,
-0.4636957347393036,
0.42349639534950256,
-0.29646822810173035,
-0.8741259574890137,
0.10657159239053726,
-0.2629449963569641,
0.46952641010284424,
0.23255284130573273,
0.6328713297843933,
0.07266620546579361,
1.1433213949203491,
0.5052182674407959,
0.10115547478199005,
0.3375748097896576,
-0.1932048499584198,
0.44188305735588074,
-1.1360660791397095,
-0.3661949634552002,
-0.5933613181114197,
-0.10079798102378845,
-0.5510557293891907,
-0.6703332662582397,
0.46366065740585327,
0.020767997950315475,
-0.25572386384010315,
0.02703016996383667,
-0.5021589398384094,
0.6453230977058411,
0.5798137187957764,
0.1511320024728775,
0.31879958510398865,
0.1957908272743225,
-0.16474305093288422,
-0.10891915112733841,
-0.7821484804153442,
-0.721081554889679,
1.0593152046203613,
0.11879216134548187,
0.8770908713340759,
-0.01976347528398037,
0.32566192746162415,
0.12520739436149597,
0.25840112566947937,
-0.9516244530677795,
0.4612496793270111,
-0.29974907636642456,
-0.43727678060531616,
-0.3656676113605499,
-0.36676928400993347,
-0.6303372979164124,
0.12119780480861664,
-0.1356872022151947,
-0.5044938921928406,
-0.47923123836517334,
0.04876837134361267,
-0.21278755366802216,
0.22812002897262573,
-0.864293098449707,
0.6746370792388916,
-0.2873804569244385,
-0.7260493636131287,
-0.37395986914634705,
-0.6919235587120056,
0.44719186425209045,
0.23484468460083008,
0.3841453194618225,
-0.00461813248693943,
0.05398084223270416,
0.5647069811820984,
-0.37176692485809326,
1.0707546472549438,
-0.07612370699644089,
-0.5455358028411865,
0.43894919753074646,
-0.005541927646845579,
0.5908839702606201,
0.310457319021225,
-0.1423601508140564,
-0.15579994022846222,
-0.11172168701887131,
-0.2432042956352234,
-0.634380578994751,
0.9007415771484375,
-1.0171884298324585,
-0.7145068645477295,
-0.13591565191745758,
-0.571533203125,
-0.39358726143836975,
0.1637611985206604,
0.16552767157554626,
0.6071900725364685,
-0.18043769896030426,
0.019216978922486305,
1.0444025993347168,
-0.22691985964775085,
0.13231109082698822,
0.8719635009765625,
0.06342440843582153,
-0.426821768283844,
1.1748396158218384,
-0.20695942640304565,
0.3543781042098999,
0.6205356121063232,
0.12498651444911957,
-0.365925669670105,
-0.19030791521072388,
-0.9841210246086121,
0.15739355981349945,
-0.6251205801963806,
-0.4422791004180908,
-0.5795297026634216,
-0.4005071818828583,
-0.5271608233451843,
-0.03271661698818207,
-0.29018083214759827,
-0.0860811397433281,
-0.37982723116874695,
-0.07230734080076218,
0.6093254089355469,
0.8208113312721252,
0.2246406078338623,
0.1101851761341095,
-1.0212833881378174,
0.5559161305427551,
0.37555205821990967,
0.48907721042633057,
0.08802558481693268,
-0.7202510833740234,
-0.478473037481308,
0.4517923593521118,
-0.39237794280052185,
-0.5300943851470947,
0.16197176277637482,
0.4928222894668579,
0.41665560007095337,
0.46826282143592834,
0.15129369497299194,
0.5132473707199097,
-0.9365641474723816,
0.7221894860267639,
0.007148534990847111,
-0.7704038619995117,
0.5332054495811462,
-0.3662552833557129,
0.2492685317993164,
0.44321486353874207,
0.20540851354599,
-0.4461807608604431,
-0.2184806615114212,
-0.23192816972732544,
-1.0729902982711792,
1.0993285179138184,
-0.28695929050445557,
0.28786832094192505,
0.006547348573803902,
0.2772771120071411,
0.25297245383262634,
0.18058472871780396,
-0.2947458326816559,
-0.024778224527835846,
-0.3252333402633667,
-0.37274059653282166,
-0.007080707233399153,
-0.2621103525161743,
-0.37864863872528076,
-0.141310453414917,
0.93800288438797,
-0.5397399663925171,
0.03280722722411156,
-0.1914677619934082,
-0.05879456549882889,
-0.24838076531887054,
0.4615207314491272,
0.6769340634346008,
0.45726287364959717,
-0.09642500430345535,
-0.003910927567631006,
-0.13676875829696655,
-0.4617016613483429,
0.03691708296537399,
-0.20309175550937653,
-0.30534565448760986,
-0.25420376658439636,
0.42842113971710205,
0.9839823246002197,
0.5372025370597839,
-0.6337250471115112,
0.22379152476787567,
0.06928572803735733,
-0.12137246131896973,
-0.10420762747526169,
0.4401005506515503,
0.3944280445575714,
0.025227444246411324,
0.24953317642211914,
-0.08980810642242432,
-0.15288613736629486,
-0.6219332218170166,
0.05132821202278137,
0.3842972218990326,
-0.12606914341449738,
-0.18699638545513153,
0.34414196014404297,
0.5700215697288513,
-0.3585556745529175,
1.0736498832702637,
-0.009328044019639492,
-0.5075270533561707,
0.4208363890647888,
0.686915934085846,
0.6676819324493408,
-0.041952308267354965,
0.3717271089553833,
0.5604906678199768,
0.27771738171577454,
0.05220623314380646,
0.02685811184346676,
-0.12564808130264282,
-0.6149433851242065,
-0.6764131784439087,
-0.8579772114753723,
-0.49294090270996094,
0.33404719829559326,
-0.8631408214569092,
0.22927337884902954,
-0.392952561378479,
0.19909021258354187,
-0.18143121898174286,
-0.11512985825538635,
-0.4630548059940338,
0.15716984868049622,
-0.030109472572803497,
0.8109316825866699,
-0.674475371837616,
0.8940966129302979,
0.5926826000213623,
-0.20543475449085236,
-0.8552136421203613,
0.08921042829751968,
-0.09609643369913101,
-1.0394502878189087,
0.3705008625984192,
0.07437825947999954,
-0.4370060861110687,
0.14408531785011292,
-0.7494654655456543,
-0.5470983982086182,
0.9379911422729492,
0.21210139989852905,
-0.7861710786819458,
-0.11523367464542389,
0.15097346901893616,
0.45916080474853516,
-0.4639473557472229,
0.3720551133155823,
0.6745424270629883,
0.5472632646560669,
0.38782885670661926,
-0.35433486104011536,
-0.08575769513845444,
-0.3171687126159668,
-0.018476685509085655,
0.2888818383216858,
-0.8285157680511475,
0.4414753019809723,
-0.405948281288147,
-0.3787350058555603,
0.07279211282730103,
0.5937556624412537,
0.12026241421699524,
0.19843554496765137,
0.16531282663345337,
0.5520763993263245,
0.6725150346755981,
-0.08654528856277466,
0.8329366445541382,
-0.5868341326713562,
-0.11501763761043549,
1.3836519718170166,
-0.46681129932403564,
0.9013745784759521,
0.2614032030105591,
-0.036072734743356705,
0.6868889927864075,
0.32268714904785156,
-0.010502275079488754,
0.4812602996826172,
0.20793086290359497,
-0.3049018383026123,
-0.5208061337471008,
-0.1123906746506691,
-0.42196765542030334,
0.3037019670009613,
0.6627484560012817,
-0.12838749587535858,
-0.06702879071235657,
-0.2725931704044342,
0.12128366529941559,
0.403229296207428,
-0.08246216177940369,
1.1823015213012695,
0.0027237667236477137,
-1.0485597848892212,
0.609863817691803,
0.3946828246116638,
0.515868067741394,
-0.8665224313735962,
-0.25939586758613586,
-0.2661494016647339,
0.23296231031417847,
-0.18283511698246002,
-0.6236370801925659,
0.0457623116672039,
0.23462316393852234,
-0.6177589297294617,
-0.24695801734924316,
0.49137699604034424,
-0.7106320858001709,
-0.5668914318084717,
0.15069159865379333,
0.22235716879367828,
-0.1400323361158371,
0.2166060209274292,
-0.45836612582206726,
0.17048437893390656,
0.1520441621541977,
-0.32746702432632446,
0.5802343487739563,
0.7290303707122803,
0.08293909579515457,
0.43206655979156494,
0.81444251537323,
-0.050596341490745544,
0.04020649194717407,
0.25508129596710205,
0.923090934753418,
-0.44273295998573303,
-0.20675918459892273,
-0.5367085337638855,
0.49628961086273193,
-0.045555707067251205,
-0.3794858753681183,
0.46748998761177063,
0.6792941689491272,
0.8013808131217957,
-0.13862085342407227,
0.9606297612190247,
0.18802399933338165,
0.5567010045051575,
-1.003425121307373,
0.592543363571167,
-0.41860759258270264,
0.16034682095050812,
0.19258159399032593,
-0.8501348495483398,
0.34282875061035156,
0.5792403221130371,
-0.057183876633644104,
-0.0623956061899662,
0.6610465049743652,
1.062320351600647,
-0.12853270769119263,
0.24405087530612946,
0.04969915375113487,
0.2585486173629761,
0.171713724732399,
0.36886608600616455,
0.48920169472694397,
-0.3952800929546356,
0.5934211015701294,
0.1812765896320343,
-0.25278937816619873,
-0.2666948437690735,
-0.900450587272644,
-0.9704235792160034,
-0.5355437994003296,
-0.1772705763578415,
-0.3649989366531372,
0.1940692812204361,
0.9156687259674072,
0.6827475428581238,
-0.8253448009490967,
-0.29342496395111084,
0.056740131229162216,
0.1182841956615448,
-0.1800057590007782,
-0.30321910977363586,
0.23292014002799988,
-0.8234151601791382,
-0.7592402696609497,
0.7479444146156311,
0.3310447037220001,
-0.3954521119594574,
-0.20644161105155945,
-0.19863533973693848,
-0.21340666711330414,
0.3588449954986572,
0.6671904921531677,
0.10069714486598969,
-0.633568286895752,
-0.053897663950920105,
0.15420763194561005,
-0.19301486015319824,
-0.06671582907438278,
1.2438329458236694,
-0.47046566009521484,
0.4101610779762268,
0.14715030789375305,
0.5939834713935852,
0.476396769285202,
0.01564197801053524,
0.7116820216178894,
-0.8693482279777527,
-0.0017484232084825635,
0.1054898351430893,
-0.08140556514263153,
0.4257456362247467,
-0.35497766733169556,
0.4346146583557129,
0.07024797052145004,
-0.4760678708553314,
-0.54282546043396,
0.4442741870880127,
-0.7971189022064209,
-0.29730162024497986,
1.4256799221038818,
-0.1612086296081543,
-0.07955650240182877,
0.10419028997421265,
-0.36386239528656006,
0.4501938819885254,
-0.5731818079948425,
0.7493868470191956,
0.7394583821296692,
0.1765233725309372,
-0.1565714180469513,
-0.5027546286582947,
0.5025689005851746,
0.18209831416606903,
-0.800506591796875,
0.46317610144615173,
0.6206780076026917,
0.1673613339662552,
0.0030191210098564625,
0.2876341938972473,
-0.029763847589492798,
-0.0354677215218544,
-0.09116765856742859,
0.04978153482079506,
-0.2467554658651352,
-0.5783298015594482,
0.2330787479877472,
0.02652374841272831,
0.13050678372383118,
0.16098763048648834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03038v1 | On the Client Preference of LLM Fine-tuning in Federated Learning | 2024-07-03T12:02:24 | 2024-07-03T12:02:24 | Feijie Wu, Xiaoze Liu, Haoyu Wang, Xingchen Wang, Jing Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.LG | Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) fine-tunes a pretrained
large language model (LLM) using preference datasets, enabling the LLM to
generate outputs that align with human preferences. Given the sensitive nature
of these preference datasets held by various clients, there is a need to
implement RLHF within a federated learning (FL) framework, where clients are
reluctant to share their data due to privacy concerns. To address this, we
introduce a feasible framework in which clients collaboratively train a binary
selector with their preference datasets using our proposed FedBis. With a
well-trained selector, we can further enhance the LLM that generates
human-preferred completions. Meanwhile, we propose a novel algorithm,
FedBiscuit, that trains multiple selectors by organizing clients into balanced
and disjoint clusters based on their preferences. Compared to the FedBis,
FedBiscuit demonstrates superior performance in simulating human preferences
for pairwise completions. Our extensive experiments on federated human
preference datasets -- marking the first benchmark to address heterogeneous
data partitioning among clients -- demonstrate that FedBiscuit outperforms
FedBis and even surpasses traditional centralized training. | [
-0.7443808913230896,
-0.31206485629081726,
0.16343317925930023,
0.4735102951526642,
0.14903679490089417,
0.22152066230773926,
-0.5649427771568298,
-0.5151196122169495,
0.2907795310020447,
0.5231895446777344,
-0.9670161008834839,
-0.5134873390197754,
-0.15254081785678864,
0.2248542755842209,
0.12080461531877518,
1.111846685409546,
0.02462276630103588,
0.09272705018520355,
-0.44632092118263245,
-0.379786878824234,
-0.12980736792087555,
-0.38052210211753845,
-0.3109036982059479,
-0.9430394768714905,
0.7239422798156738,
0.7778795957565308,
0.7226975560188293,
0.47446298599243164,
0.4302300810813904,
0.2538064420223236,
0.38674965500831604,
0.3686160445213318,
-0.738490104675293,
0.16101276874542236,
-0.352788507938385,
-0.572580873966217,
-0.3702619969844818,
0.2764543890953064,
0.49073413014411926,
0.9161052107810974,
-0.4664594829082489,
0.11706704646348953,
-0.26847192645072937,
0.9552536010742188,
-0.6114461421966553,
0.3479938209056854,
-0.33167314529418945,
0.5629708766937256,
-0.09373784065246582,
-0.3169673979282379,
-0.6847005486488342,
-0.4908035695552826,
0.3623608946800232,
-0.6074736714363098,
0.3316844403743744,
0.5078020691871643,
0.7699587345123291,
0.19729383289813995,
-0.050324421375989914,
0.14608438313007355,
-0.5749003291130066,
0.7688468098640442,
-0.3832782506942749,
0.5636124610900879,
0.6030967831611633,
0.2912085950374603,
-0.30879083275794983,
-0.48155075311660767,
-0.11320547014474869,
-0.09690437465906143,
-0.32696759700775146,
-0.019652795046567917,
0.05004378780722618,
0.3955170214176178,
0.07853371649980545,
0.4628795385360718,
-0.403717577457428,
0.4698909819126129,
-0.006365245673805475,
-0.3392557203769684,
0.7181296348571777,
0.17874351143836975,
0.05560087040066719,
0.21015803515911102,
-0.3606753945350647,
-0.1790701150894165,
-0.6249721050262451,
0.3605656623840332,
0.4967135190963745,
0.6091817617416382,
0.06381023675203323,
0.11420454829931259,
-0.793592095375061,
0.7238409519195557,
0.591840386390686,
-0.18225660920143127,
0.5543345808982849,
0.09197241812944412,
-0.32132279872894287,
0.10660434514284134,
0.7994814515113831,
0.33349403738975525,
-0.02922719158232212,
-0.7112002968788147,
-0.4787067472934723,
-0.09979648143053055,
0.15644529461860657,
-0.8938230872154236,
-0.3872753381729126,
0.21915680170059204,
-0.2963254451751709,
-0.36229977011680603,
0.1308600902557373,
-0.3464535176753998,
-0.17619754374027252,
-0.3917556405067444,
-0.03352804109454155,
-0.17406892776489258,
-0.24782413244247437,
0.15856365859508514,
0.06590601801872253,
0.13501302897930145,
0.28781330585479736,
-1.579932451248169,
0.5473893284797668,
0.9546833634376526,
0.3569825291633606,
-0.06560518592596054,
-0.6991041898727417,
-0.9895936250686646,
-0.037226442247629166,
-0.08411437273025513,
0.7815513014793396,
-0.5844053030014038,
-0.2665770947933197,
0.046179693192243576,
-0.06879501044750214,
0.22324799001216888,
-0.566307008266449,
0.11862707883119583,
-0.6736752390861511,
0.3323606848716736,
-0.7012229561805725,
-0.6539254188537598,
0.02605442702770233,
0.2610577642917633,
-0.40769168734550476,
0.40347641706466675,
0.23049865663051605,
-0.7503141760826111,
0.7499552965164185,
-0.49704334139823914,
-0.474913626909256,
0.23031118512153625,
-0.42823436856269836,
-0.6215775012969971,
-0.19182458519935608,
0.27943897247314453,
0.6365431547164917,
0.0008307891548611224,
0.2781311869621277,
-0.8780139088630676,
-0.5318446755409241,
0.163407102227211,
0.10547628253698349,
0.48924484848976135,
0.08728150278329849,
-0.14273463189601898,
0.2658842206001282,
-0.4413529932498932,
0.21654793620109558,
-0.060115162283182144,
-0.6265015006065369,
-0.13949993252754211,
-0.06922192871570587,
0.10540034621953964,
-0.044335026293992996,
0.27353668212890625,
-0.6363677382469177,
0.341193825006485,
-0.6051044464111328,
0.4374202787876129,
0.8909832239151001,
-0.1316007822751999,
0.837975025177002,
-0.6489989757537842,
0.4152255952358246,
-0.1891290843486786,
0.26559188961982727,
0.3690932095050812,
-0.041344039142131805,
-0.4165005385875702,
-0.2997351884841919,
0.30079594254493713,
0.0025560783687978983,
-0.37766021490097046,
0.4097168743610382,
-0.2447090595960617,
-0.26119735836982727,
-0.5139921307563782,
0.30230939388275146,
0.568164050579071,
0.2919526696205139,
0.06792458146810532,
-0.4638286232948303,
-0.4270209074020386,
-0.8665412068367004,
0.22287267446517944,
-0.13171887397766113,
0.12430699914693832,
0.7104776501655579,
-0.036949656903743744,
-0.47136446833610535,
1.2922005653381348,
-0.41423478722572327,
-0.3940994441509247,
-0.14428377151489258,
0.22066137194633484,
-0.027759350836277008,
0.4016168713569641,
0.689355194568634,
-0.6932937502861023,
-0.500652015209198,
-0.005253414623439312,
-0.42619308829307556,
-0.11494710296392441,
0.14386175572872162,
-0.17329920828342438,
0.29297390580177307,
0.017872963100671768,
-0.10135969519615173,
0.02334802970290184,
0.5203595757484436,
-0.16836252808570862,
0.6176595091819763,
-0.3363056778907776,
0.13959720730781555,
-0.6802859902381897,
-0.14806868135929108,
-0.2799069881439209,
-0.5536243319511414,
-0.24417154490947723,
0.13670530915260315,
-0.021825119853019714,
0.0866430252790451,
-0.31661614775657654,
0.26728808879852295,
-0.37531760334968567,
-0.598598301410675,
-0.2012077122926712,
-0.00597754493355751,
-0.1281483769416809,
0.8136236071586609,
0.12413571774959564,
0.8098404407501221,
0.3418918251991272,
-0.36543840169906616,
0.6078554391860962,
0.6030426025390625,
0.03810443356633186,
0.6782277226448059,
-0.32901471853256226,
0.03234592452645302,
0.04879684001207352,
0.5228685736656189,
-0.6341976523399353,
-0.5877885818481445,
0.17290572822093964,
-0.33214879035949707,
0.23894581198692322,
0.00391097366809845,
-0.47439539432525635,
-0.19706083834171295,
-0.24611620604991913,
0.26425987482070923,
0.1714457869529724,
-0.9131889939308167,
0.27768847346305847,
0.28256136178970337,
0.2446517050266266,
-0.9047273397445679,
-0.720924437046051,
-0.32015886902809143,
0.1553623378276825,
-0.5985997319221497,
0.2658444941043854,
-0.13354240357875824,
0.07311800867319107,
-0.03651408106088638,
-0.04145011678338051,
0.048735614866018295,
0.193422332406044,
0.7422139048576355,
0.11852961033582687,
-0.0275361780077219,
0.058512747287750244,
0.05144306272268295,
-0.1777191162109375,
0.04845379665493965,
-0.21265581250190735,
0.5544248819351196,
-0.6803331971168518,
-0.39873647689819336,
-0.2625580430030823,
0.13435642421245575,
0.18354862928390503,
-0.37589916586875916,
0.54240882396698,
0.790363609790802,
0.07537112385034561,
-0.577864408493042,
-0.544867753982544,
-0.464993953704834,
-0.4570474624633789,
0.0741235688328743,
-0.23179571330547333,
-1.3215192556381226,
0.4808468520641327,
0.0327322892844677,
0.34601056575775146,
-0.25199487805366516,
0.47536084055900574,
-0.025193054229021072,
0.7182912826538086,
0.7263023853302002,
-0.5616772770881653,
0.7146399021148682,
-0.1375844031572342,
-0.05453440546989441,
-0.518537163734436,
-0.11076220870018005,
-0.2403474748134613,
-0.539896547794342,
-0.6920974850654602,
0.15501166880130768,
0.033464618027210236,
-0.15627682209014893,
-0.23343224823474884,
0.19986194372177124,
-0.3937782049179077,
0.6624072790145874,
0.7479837536811829,
0.5329123735427856,
0.2430991381406784,
0.12122690677642822,
-0.47864070534706116,
0.16063754260540009,
-0.6315491199493408,
0.11503097414970398,
0.9675537347793579,
0.29624125361442566,
0.8160913586616516,
0.02983279712498188,
1.3372751474380493,
0.3000922203063965,
0.5517773032188416,
-0.6769404411315918,
0.392612487077713,
0.08056679368019104,
-0.5332231521606445,
-0.3561207354068756,
-0.586901843547821,
-0.7296943068504333,
0.18812711536884308,
-0.4563247859477997,
-0.6055834889411926,
0.24137361347675323,
0.3244952857494354,
-0.6741786599159241,
0.16068190336227417,
-0.5860546231269836,
0.6506907343864441,
-0.04159536585211754,
-0.7380897998809814,
-0.42722827196121216,
-0.8208078145980835,
0.458496630191803,
0.33204084634780884,
-0.14380350708961487,
-0.11046344041824341,
0.3229740560054779,
0.6169351935386658,
-0.5922107696533203,
0.8038655519485474,
-0.27251601219177246,
0.26570072770118713,
-0.2751326858997345,
-0.03262512385845184,
0.33454304933547974,
0.41407492756843567,
0.059883248060941696,
-0.08397815376520157,
-0.13197985291481018,
-0.6138278245925903,
-0.3636796474456787,
0.8486339449882507,
-1.1908023357391357,
-0.5129336714744568,
-0.3938983678817749,
-0.6008614301681519,
-0.6784665584564209,
0.3014564514160156,
-0.03466395288705826,
0.48321333527565,
-0.22675207257270813,
0.1572839766740799,
0.7237645983695984,
-0.031743139028549194,
0.24266909062862396,
0.8062885999679565,
-0.6191843152046204,
-0.5384719967842102,
0.8539422154426575,
-0.34303849935531616,
0.2993001639842987,
0.4942246377468109,
0.04409496486186981,
-0.16593025624752045,
-0.4862241744995117,
-0.22466813027858734,
0.3787265717983246,
-0.5690451264381409,
-0.15462027490139008,
-0.42464351654052734,
-0.09489760547876358,
-0.2094115912914276,
-0.44422677159309387,
-0.49469444155693054,
0.05655830353498459,
-0.37464553117752075,
-0.2959541380405426,
0.1753707379102707,
0.3699427545070648,
-0.3525804877281189,
0.3229040801525116,
-0.6910721063613892,
0.006041083950549364,
0.5144597887992859,
0.8482332825660706,
-0.10841371864080429,
-0.0009755445062182844,
-0.3372885286808014,
0.0757664293050766,
-0.043563362210989,
-0.20635700225830078,
0.15861037373542786,
-0.058778874576091766,
0.5369124412536621,
0.7478152513504028,
0.3196054995059967,
0.6558114290237427,
-0.2600547671318054,
0.24525488913059235,
0.2442316859960556,
-0.4539298713207245,
0.23387831449508667,
-0.4217662811279297,
0.003460772568359971,
1.085986614227295,
0.1513543426990509,
-0.47054392099380493,
-0.22722211480140686,
-0.6064571142196655,
-0.3730299472808838,
1.161974549293518,
-0.21983598172664642,
-0.32259467244148254,
0.23055388033390045,
0.2875395119190216,
0.35926932096481323,
0.3605727255344391,
-0.44808658957481384,
-0.3348098397254944,
-0.0067313737235963345,
0.1179332360625267,
-0.07162842154502869,
-0.06401988863945007,
-0.35097649693489075,
-0.16803450882434845,
0.6308525204658508,
-0.12889966368675232,
0.17172925174236298,
-0.012553622014820576,
-0.0174066424369812,
-0.6122153401374817,
0.292805552482605,
0.36431509256362915,
0.5553028583526611,
-0.7506168484687805,
-0.20887063443660736,
-0.20979149639606476,
-0.1716861128807068,
0.16966480016708374,
0.2831103205680847,
-0.3133257329463959,
-0.34944990277290344,
0.13698649406433105,
0.9228489995002747,
0.3922445774078369,
-0.5162291526794434,
0.5866438150405884,
-0.4624589681625366,
-0.6221727728843689,
-0.08454296737909317,
0.34503182768821716,
0.03530735522508621,
0.3258931636810303,
0.08333611488342285,
0.40114885568618774,
-0.012371711432933807,
-0.43804219365119934,
0.47619250416755676,
0.5075548887252808,
-0.4631350338459015,
-0.3280971944332123,
0.3318203091621399,
0.4468468427658081,
-0.08263882994651794,
0.6480373740196228,
-0.27416300773620605,
-0.4595222473144531,
0.0725543275475502,
0.2929859757423401,
0.7554748058319092,
0.02623780630528927,
0.5884864926338196,
-0.011285260319709778,
-0.09889564663171768,
-0.3205326199531555,
-0.03501962125301361,
-0.6987174153327942,
-0.9301359057426453,
-0.12236259877681732,
-0.793512225151062,
-0.7865385413169861,
-0.2145220786333084,
-0.9652439951896667,
-0.06379890441894531,
-0.8986436128616333,
-0.011253073811531067,
-0.09657669812440872,
0.5563740134239197,
-0.7370812892913818,
-0.07834023982286453,
0.21268215775489807,
0.653410017490387,
-0.8203560709953308,
1.0203689336776733,
0.6987366080284119,
-0.49622833728790283,
-0.9504591822624207,
-0.09712614864110947,
-0.13405267894268036,
-0.765927255153656,
0.5076316595077515,
0.18191774189472198,
-0.008420812897384167,
-0.08387778699398041,
-0.49234163761138916,
-0.4995421767234802,
1.2360037565231323,
0.23650230467319489,
-0.7149816155433655,
-0.11034765839576721,
0.21951143443584442,
0.5059058666229248,
-0.4585128724575043,
0.24127629399299622,
0.6311972141265869,
0.3169097602367401,
0.06765104830265045,
-0.9001328945159912,
-0.12506912648677826,
0.15022145211696625,
-0.09307683259248734,
0.23336483538150787,
-1.0672398805618286,
0.5818391442298889,
-0.24356026947498322,
-0.028454890474677086,
-0.31568264961242676,
0.8405934572219849,
0.242230623960495,
0.2866666316986084,
0.6494731903076172,
0.6102210879325867,
0.9285979866981506,
-0.003364129923284054,
0.6415326595306396,
-0.110452800989151,
0.5897807478904724,
1.4138202667236328,
-0.4965209364891052,
0.7175279259681702,
0.41471201181411743,
-0.3092690706253052,
0.3383225202560425,
0.7850648164749146,
0.08322823792695999,
0.8347097635269165,
0.05161307007074356,
-0.20745287835597992,
-0.49193525314331055,
-0.11616720259189606,
-0.29315268993377686,
0.328195720911026,
0.18330883979797363,
-0.15182869136333466,
-0.39660122990608215,
0.05991411954164505,
-0.21380479633808136,
0.17489737272262573,
-0.1814986765384674,
0.9555509686470032,
-0.07091040164232254,
-0.7254104614257812,
0.6269236207008362,
0.03856126219034195,
0.8863250017166138,
-0.5510073900222778,
0.356092631816864,
-0.5520128011703491,
0.3654112219810486,
-0.5616171956062317,
-0.4546341598033905,
0.07356109470129013,
-0.39106687903404236,
-0.4425739049911499,
-0.42836442589759827,
0.40996527671813965,
-0.5600615739822388,
0.09293007850646973,
0.40622642636299133,
0.2018110603094101,
-0.2768784761428833,
0.19314149022102356,
-0.71099853515625,
-0.020840831100940704,
0.16686956584453583,
-0.1467607170343399,
0.7668246626853943,
0.17708997428417206,
0.27699851989746094,
0.770709216594696,
0.5713377594947815,
0.11332040280103683,
-0.21633964776992798,
0.224714457988739,
0.9925709962844849,
-0.3368014693260193,
-0.8139208555221558,
-0.4229108691215515,
-0.17790967226028442,
0.052474070340394974,
-0.019808588549494743,
0.604806661605835,
0.354783833026886,
1.271672010421753,
-0.02609684318304062,
0.7149056792259216,
0.08154703676700592,
0.45795539021492004,
-0.20994237065315247,
0.7728907465934753,
-0.31748461723327637,
0.27447161078453064,
-0.04290064051747322,
-0.612041175365448,
-0.12512412667274475,
0.46435487270355225,
-0.5513961911201477,
-0.3229944407939911,
0.35723698139190674,
0.9276651740074158,
-0.26020297408103943,
0.3320659399032593,
0.3130764663219452,
-0.12711136043071747,
0.3874485492706299,
0.8167627453804016,
0.49622946977615356,
-0.023300664499402046,
0.22418160736560822,
-0.7195172309875488,
-0.28150808811187744,
-0.6104047298431396,
-0.5667803883552551,
-1.0872613191604614,
-0.4589431881904602,
-0.13782024383544922,
-0.14870516955852509,
0.07119964063167572,
1.5835908651351929,
0.8634046912193298,
-0.9138710498809814,
-0.20302020013332367,
-0.10285478085279465,
0.14406612515449524,
-0.3257473409175873,
-0.22869253158569336,
-0.04358387365937233,
-0.5692992806434631,
-0.38860687613487244,
0.17133505642414093,
0.2528616189956665,
-0.2257775366306305,
-0.5700094103813171,
-0.5289048552513123,
-0.1610662043094635,
-0.4774562418460846,
0.19850648939609528,
0.4160214066505432,
-0.7390997409820557,
-0.3596162497997284,
-0.2555871307849884,
-0.3872758448123932,
0.1573702096939087,
0.756987988948822,
-0.7886543273925781,
0.4340617060661316,
0.43971922993659973,
0.9352089762687683,
0.5092582106590271,
0.20280534029006958,
0.5955126881599426,
-0.9801020622253418,
0.289686918258667,
0.11330636590719223,
0.36021310091018677,
0.3326491415500641,
-0.456240713596344,
0.2590494155883789,
0.25801774859428406,
-0.8219408392906189,
-0.6601414680480957,
0.14234806597232819,
-0.988210141658783,
-0.11872132122516632,
0.8553090691566467,
-0.44057372212409973,
-0.40362492203712463,
0.2252873331308365,
0.008151817135512829,
-0.05970678851008415,
-0.918546199798584,
0.7083433866500854,
0.5542195439338684,
-0.17528456449508667,
-0.03275437280535698,
0.025952477008104324,
0.7949630618095398,
0.4494972229003906,
-0.580461323261261,
0.2991577982902527,
0.8317832350730896,
0.40214574337005615,
-0.11717484891414642,
0.8645933866500854,
0.3067435920238495,
0.42631494998931885,
-0.32545676827430725,
0.04845470190048218,
-0.5459678769111633,
-0.3894120454788208,
-0.17908631265163422,
0.24940502643585205,
0.2765241861343384,
-0.11932011693716049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03032v1 | Strategies for Arabic Readability Modeling | 2024-07-03T11:54:11 | 2024-07-03T11:54:11 | Juan Piñeros Liberato, Bashar Alhafni, Muhamed Al Khalil, Nizar Habash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic readability assessment is relevant to building NLP applications for
education, content analysis, and accessibility. However, Arabic readability
assessment is a challenging task due to Arabic's morphological richness and
limited readability resources. In this paper, we present a set of experimental
results on Arabic readability assessment using a diverse range of approaches,
from rule-based methods to Arabic pretrained language models. We report our
results on a newly created corpus at different textual granularity levels
(words and sentence fragments). Our results show that combining different
techniques yields the best results, achieving an overall macro F1 score of 86.7
at the word level and 87.9 at the fragment level on a blind test set. We make
our code, data, and pretrained models publicly available. | [
-0.43778303265571594,
-0.9364708065986633,
0.18940259516239166,
0.3048781454563141,
-0.4518013596534729,
0.11311089992523193,
0.046816386282444,
-0.7851842045783997,
-0.13931319117546082,
0.2163214087486267,
-0.27398818731307983,
-0.9050564169883728,
-0.817644476890564,
0.3133237361907959,
-0.7619041800498962,
0.8715408444404602,
-0.448417603969574,
-0.3329874277114868,
0.059029195457696915,
-0.26865407824516296,
-0.44013550877571106,
-0.41327545046806335,
-0.1990511119365692,
-0.03603213280439377,
0.4413113594055176,
0.450309157371521,
1.2794049978256226,
0.6881545186042786,
0.5124000906944275,
0.24246373772621155,
-0.32997986674308777,
0.07236658781766891,
0.09129630774259567,
-0.26739615201950073,
-0.05886705964803696,
-0.042163994163274765,
-0.5817893147468567,
-0.04281485825777054,
0.3968755900859833,
0.6709203720092773,
-0.01684451289474964,
-0.01379976887255907,
-0.05096881464123726,
0.5607082843780518,
-0.7812264561653137,
-0.16947917640209198,
-0.1405903548002243,
0.20384961366653442,
-0.16562698781490326,
0.105403371155262,
-0.36733555793762207,
-0.38763129711151123,
0.4677131772041321,
-0.28811410069465637,
0.061961956322193146,
0.1312723606824875,
0.6944201588630676,
0.061465393751859665,
-0.6983023285865784,
-0.8224432468414307,
-0.6880987286567688,
0.6833780407905579,
-1.0020883083343506,
0.5093972682952881,
0.8098905682563782,
0.13625724613666534,
0.3836078643798828,
-0.5695289373397827,
-0.569174587726593,
-0.615524172782898,
-0.14807899296283722,
-0.1850154548883438,
-0.12860538065433502,
-0.05272562801837921,
-0.034983739256858826,
0.43694642186164856,
-0.48735105991363525,
-0.1376817375421524,
-0.017485452815890312,
-0.33111563324928284,
0.6681128740310669,
-0.09586135298013687,
0.7193048000335693,
-0.2359643280506134,
-0.12941744923591614,
-0.10283714532852173,
-0.4430716931819916,
-0.09810485690832138,
0.43266761302948,
0.18675139546394348,
-0.21529290080070496,
0.6962593197822571,
-0.19556263089179993,
0.6710063219070435,
-0.3351946175098419,
-0.14984647929668427,
0.2615944445133209,
-0.6923458576202393,
-0.12746262550354004,
-0.16004396975040436,
0.3677304983139038,
-0.05890607461333275,
0.327923983335495,
-0.21080654859542847,
-0.4889395833015442,
-0.45705848932266235,
0.5836074352264404,
-0.9905025362968445,
-0.11067134886980057,
0.3009612262248993,
-0.7245817184448242,
-0.15852810442447662,
-0.016438692808151245,
-0.686154842376709,
-0.3171599507331848,
-0.3420478105545044,
0.89317387342453,
-0.7833682298660278,
-0.17280825972557068,
0.17978577315807343,
0.23063819110393524,
0.37740635871887207,
0.5550132393836975,
-0.8372739553451538,
0.40381577610969543,
0.3646475076675415,
1.0704818964004517,
-0.23132552206516266,
-0.030820749700069427,
-0.1258327215909958,
-0.14128825068473816,
-0.23230893909931183,
0.6223630905151367,
-0.44861045479774475,
-0.5005562901496887,
0.19614072144031525,
-0.543480396270752,
-0.3868209421634674,
-0.5858529210090637,
0.6126039028167725,
-0.6860581040382385,
-0.3219560980796814,
0.2517743706703186,
-0.5921995639801025,
-0.6028719544410706,
0.3033176362514496,
-0.7538665533065796,
0.6567360162734985,
0.31022411584854126,
-0.7674512267112732,
0.4037492573261261,
-0.7386137247085571,
-0.7006703019142151,
-0.12144295126199722,
0.2919257581233978,
-0.3565281629562378,
0.1130160242319107,
0.295919805765152,
0.214623361825943,
0.32900282740592957,
-0.07782689481973648,
0.013298851437866688,
-0.40174436569213867,
0.17450293898582458,
-0.6590684652328491,
0.4109609127044678,
0.2783161699771881,
-0.652566134929657,
0.2521525025367737,
-0.8682477474212646,
0.4145268499851227,
-0.400581419467926,
-0.3926059901714325,
-0.06408947706222534,
0.179586723446846,
0.5816035270690918,
0.19478513300418854,
0.04755640774965286,
-0.14281857013702393,
0.061568524688482285,
-0.464102178812027,
0.07021956890821457,
0.32654398679733276,
-0.320453941822052,
0.20987045764923096,
-0.46900761127471924,
0.6989287734031677,
0.1864648014307022,
0.07795882970094681,
-0.017377793788909912,
-0.1580536812543869,
-0.7657727003097534,
-0.6121953725814819,
0.6898984313011169,
0.689746081829071,
-0.45805710554122925,
0.5365809798240662,
0.2646317481994629,
-0.942586362361908,
-0.4775742292404175,
0.17495094239711761,
0.5938901305198669,
0.06271851062774658,
0.41776594519615173,
-0.37318122386932373,
-0.010015903040766716,
-0.5799562335014343,
-0.5376704335212708,
-0.15913301706314087,
0.12759141623973846,
0.5206348896026611,
1.0280072689056396,
-0.7159373760223389,
0.6381649971008301,
-0.30643653869628906,
0.025094132870435715,
-0.386281281709671,
0.3157130777835846,
0.10747849941253662,
0.455281138420105,
0.5601682662963867,
-0.7793489694595337,
-0.5834147930145264,
0.14962132275104523,
-0.3492060899734497,
-0.044841356575489044,
0.37136584520339966,
0.05127517506480217,
0.17739371955394745,
0.4374805986881256,
-0.09290525317192078,
1.0094562768936157,
0.530647337436676,
-0.7215895056724548,
0.7050778865814209,
-0.24732697010040283,
0.19823713600635529,
-0.7238421440124512,
0.15297479927539825,
-0.1430080235004425,
-0.6064308881759644,
-0.6505877375602722,
0.47429320216178894,
0.06883356720209122,
-0.03481246531009674,
-0.716176450252533,
0.6267561316490173,
-0.433793306350708,
-0.06376384943723679,
-0.37137913703918457,
-0.3031744062900543,
-0.1504490226507187,
-0.018162723630666733,
0.00017059920355677605,
1.073163390159607,
0.3516584634780884,
-0.7070732116699219,
-0.1860039234161377,
0.4121644198894501,
-0.8341816663742065,
0.0746893584728241,
-1.0879439115524292,
0.12455138564109802,
-0.0663616955280304,
-0.08130498230457306,
-0.9597193598747253,
-0.17386874556541443,
0.2066737711429596,
0.018211379647254944,
0.1994057446718216,
0.3444085121154785,
-0.5057008266448975,
0.3418540358543396,
0.038597412407398224,
0.8824504017829895,
0.3554447591304779,
-0.4307252764701843,
1.0200974941253662,
0.1828504502773285,
-0.473070353269577,
-0.551493763923645,
-0.13656902313232422,
-0.23090271651744843,
-0.09492072463035583,
-0.714038074016571,
0.39229893684387207,
-0.2338070422410965,
-0.4060247838497162,
-0.272611141204834,
-0.11970342695713043,
-0.5758255124092102,
0.3137931227684021,
0.4806693196296692,
-0.006352668162435293,
-0.17636409401893616,
-0.022206593304872513,
-0.117666095495224,
0.16755536198616028,
-0.1315542459487915,
0.13391785323619843,
0.6150648593902588,
-0.40898269414901733,
-0.21332696080207825,
-0.4850198030471802,
0.47512364387512207,
0.37590718269348145,
-0.48827531933784485,
1.006888747215271,
0.7400973439216614,
-0.3582666218280792,
-0.19935697317123413,
-0.14346760511398315,
0.2520163655281067,
-0.46371063590049744,
0.4838249981403351,
-0.4273618459701538,
-0.5753569602966309,
0.391274094581604,
-0.15809845924377441,
0.1779964119195938,
0.3405715227127075,
0.7063542604446411,
-0.09164224565029144,
1.0501316785812378,
1.01649010181427,
-0.025223540142178535,
0.3761942386627197,
-0.1252976357936859,
0.1920064389705658,
-0.21925778687000275,
-0.15400397777557373,
-0.783454418182373,
-0.19999335706233978,
-0.37880682945251465,
-0.5984725952148438,
0.3331533372402191,
0.3943566083908081,
-0.08384046703577042,
0.12597930431365967,
0.17426271736621857,
0.5669538974761963,
0.41685792803764343,
0.22796951234340668,
0.5869928598403931,
-0.09091859310865402,
-0.6503814458847046,
0.11744006723165512,
-0.3924383819103241,
-0.919413149356842,
0.9578189253807068,
0.33151775598526,
0.4847603142261505,
0.525040328502655,
0.5481046438217163,
0.6233616471290588,
0.526298999786377,
-0.9179850816726685,
0.31934136152267456,
-0.024361304938793182,
-0.6389473676681519,
-0.34447357058525085,
-0.3214505910873413,
-0.6961631774902344,
0.2854132652282715,
-0.34691858291625977,
-0.5129579305648804,
-0.13046646118164062,
0.07165643572807312,
-0.28135865926742554,
-0.11487390100955963,
-0.691999077796936,
1.1052310466766357,
-0.06050586700439453,
0.09717579185962677,
-0.13413028419017792,
-0.6727170944213867,
0.023314233869314194,
-0.3826657235622406,
0.4795653223991394,
-0.011104404926300049,
-0.2647462487220764,
0.7452096343040466,
-0.573680579662323,
0.6809439063072205,
0.19581106305122375,
-0.14674480259418488,
0.38281500339508057,
0.22057577967643738,
0.17051005363464355,
0.18236884474754333,
-0.25715312361717224,
0.2519700229167938,
0.4360184371471405,
-0.7218039035797119,
-0.5629868507385254,
0.06188279017806053,
-1.2438372373580933,
-0.28356149792671204,
-0.6728320717811584,
-0.7375032305717468,
-0.2817501127719879,
0.40138208866119385,
0.017733311280608177,
0.6232307553291321,
-0.5879318118095398,
-0.18037180602550507,
0.35558706521987915,
-0.21319665014743805,
0.5091770887374878,
0.79529869556427,
-0.34691059589385986,
-0.2676740884780884,
0.6345291137695312,
0.0019303044537082314,
0.16630837321281433,
0.204960897564888,
-0.0015356645453721285,
-0.4212377965450287,
-0.9989994168281555,
-0.3926366865634918,
0.08648234605789185,
-0.45996925234794617,
0.23766061663627625,
-0.3042365610599518,
-0.3823741376399994,
-0.2770337164402008,
-0.09360399842262268,
-0.09153061360120773,
-0.23537157475948334,
-0.3164352476596832,
0.014491135254502296,
-0.04745367169380188,
0.8555192947387695,
0.04895854368805885,
0.539527177810669,
-0.9458878636360168,
0.21064908802509308,
0.07813791185617447,
0.3073982298374176,
-0.09192579984664917,
-0.9172061681747437,
-0.3797772228717804,
-0.1062760129570961,
-0.3716394007205963,
-0.8903698921203613,
0.5250006318092346,
0.19611993432044983,
-0.07705952227115631,
0.5410114526748657,
-0.013321088626980782,
0.5209812521934509,
-0.8275169134140015,
0.35439997911453247,
-0.3013027012348175,
-1.3530570268630981,
0.49214521050453186,
-0.20901596546173096,
0.3958618640899658,
0.8778557777404785,
0.7331874370574951,
-0.334523469209671,
-0.24606439471244812,
-0.3550432324409485,
-0.8127477765083313,
0.2249555140733719,
0.4565211832523346,
0.25545239448547363,
0.1663377285003662,
0.5596174597740173,
0.354064404964447,
0.1653490513563156,
-0.4020363390445709,
-0.05752183124423027,
-0.09298452734947205,
-0.4781559109687805,
-0.3287495970726013,
-0.41322842240333557,
0.13936592638492584,
-0.22556060552597046,
0.5636032223701477,
0.1053699254989624,
-0.06540002673864365,
0.07299556583166122,
-0.5105939507484436,
0.2881447672843933,
0.370596706867218,
0.6199754476547241,
1.2062336206436157,
-0.42318880558013916,
0.16603057086467743,
-0.06609459221363068,
-1.019339680671692,
0.42036548256874084,
0.23713333904743195,
-0.48771995306015015,
0.16003476083278656,
0.807392418384552,
0.4654681384563446,
-0.04783298447728157,
-1.014377236366272,
0.5459132194519043,
-0.19255396723747253,
-0.14837609231472015,
-0.25358846783638,
0.20066305994987488,
-0.09345471113920212,
0.1713564246892929,
-0.01873066835105419,
0.026413366198539734,
0.15072935819625854,
-0.5458667874336243,
0.3122287690639496,
0.13413842022418976,
-0.46155667304992676,
-0.2013566493988037,
0.3028852641582489,
0.3078995645046234,
-0.29853376746177673,
0.7203149795532227,
-0.031417571008205414,
-0.20919980108737946,
0.6105250716209412,
0.5567708611488342,
0.3913748264312744,
-0.31499770283699036,
0.5792555809020996,
0.1197456568479538,
0.3769199252128601,
0.1409672200679779,
0.4903194308280945,
0.017056910321116447,
-0.9032413959503174,
-0.25477686524391174,
-0.7860116362571716,
-0.6537808179855347,
-0.18992464244365692,
-0.6231723427772522,
-0.1342470943927765,
-0.3916451334953308,
-0.05218188464641571,
0.18172432482242584,
0.46091794967651367,
-0.6910243034362793,
0.6572859287261963,
-0.3422045111656189,
1.1343817710876465,
-0.8543661832809448,
0.43672284483909607,
0.6009945273399353,
-0.5537853240966797,
-0.7799533605575562,
0.22166655957698822,
-0.12742969393730164,
-0.7274591326713562,
0.4622885286808014,
0.462236225605011,
0.1097458153963089,
0.04537191614508629,
-0.22574791312217712,
-0.8929427862167358,
0.832419216632843,
0.06271708011627197,
-0.44096338748931885,
-0.10988527536392212,
0.07405803352594376,
0.4108272194862366,
-0.05730138346552849,
0.7489515542984009,
0.774627685546875,
0.5437259674072266,
-0.057715728878974915,
-0.8772386312484741,
-0.07513342052698135,
-0.3009524643421173,
-0.1967633217573166,
0.131662979722023,
-0.26029714941978455,
0.7261238098144531,
-0.24635867774486542,
-0.07914046943187714,
0.3478863835334778,
1.0396314859390259,
-0.013844032771885395,
0.5510393977165222,
0.7092217803001404,
0.5710713267326355,
0.8166606426239014,
0.29829323291778564,
1.0872405767440796,
-0.31495457887649536,
0.11591056734323502,
0.7524386644363403,
-0.2156648486852646,
1.1767216920852661,
0.10708238929510117,
-0.23985590040683746,
0.6377823948860168,
0.5758653283119202,
0.3078652620315552,
0.4916781485080719,
0.3701997995376587,
-0.5775916576385498,
-0.047699250280857086,
-0.2219775766134262,
-0.249864861369133,
0.6923841834068298,
0.008817196823656559,
-0.4620416462421417,
-0.18206144869327545,
0.09040823578834534,
0.22196951508522034,
0.11476606130599976,
-0.4482230842113495,
0.5503891706466675,
0.031887151300907135,
-0.30630430579185486,
0.436554878950119,
0.5198280811309814,
0.3271547555923462,
-0.3603024184703827,
0.017142262309789658,
-0.19253462553024292,
0.22749435901641846,
-0.17586512863636017,
-0.46636584401130676,
0.5975641012191772,
0.3713279068470001,
-0.3123973309993744,
0.10062754154205322,
0.699336051940918,
-0.22794602811336517,
-0.7166436314582825,
0.03517487645149231,
0.9481654167175293,
0.4436860680580139,
-0.059218693524599075,
-0.5772978663444519,
0.048905257135629654,
-0.19747589528560638,
-0.20723514258861542,
0.33529722690582275,
0.26080644130706787,
0.14962545037269592,
0.5267383456230164,
0.3792949616909027,
-0.00001768910624377895,
0.03978288918733597,
0.06841081380844116,
0.5898624062538147,
-0.8196225762367249,
-0.3486679792404175,
-0.8683710098266602,
0.23556342720985413,
0.35220515727996826,
-0.6306731104850769,
0.7577527165412903,
0.3859313130378723,
0.582587480545044,
0.04218678176403046,
0.6690384745597839,
0.10554178059101105,
0.3255988359451294,
-0.5172980427742004,
0.9052737951278687,
-0.47576233744621277,
-0.13366277515888214,
-0.3802565038204193,
-0.8341352939605713,
-0.413665235042572,
0.8708553910255432,
-0.21325920522212982,
0.5385558605194092,
0.7914295196533203,
0.6144042611122131,
-0.012014726176857948,
0.1862916350364685,
0.24113400280475616,
0.20813396573066711,
0.06546036899089813,
0.4169214069843292,
0.7177209854125977,
-0.2687827944755554,
0.393543541431427,
0.0051824189722537994,
-0.34734562039375305,
-0.29472190141677856,
-0.9355370998382568,
-1.1407427787780762,
-0.25859883427619934,
-0.38811150193214417,
-0.5287760496139526,
0.25715172290802,
0.757768988609314,
0.7171326875686646,
-0.7768218517303467,
-0.22025813162326813,
-0.08212829381227493,
-0.021673349663615227,
-0.29600000381469727,
-0.1532030552625656,
0.6758694648742676,
-0.07494643330574036,
-0.565588653087616,
0.11223653703927994,
-0.0660838931798935,
0.3142833113670349,
-0.06397999078035355,
0.1655690222978592,
-0.25750502943992615,
0.4254961609840393,
0.5783986449241638,
0.2515714764595032,
-0.37632617354393005,
-0.26857614517211914,
-0.22039666771888733,
-0.2476545125246048,
-0.19441668689250946,
0.3893063962459564,
-0.7004856467247009,
0.2530936002731323,
0.46548959612846375,
0.9094270467758179,
0.31765297055244446,
0.26410141587257385,
0.47734513878822327,
-0.3800666630268097,
0.02617708034813404,
0.44377923011779785,
0.100565604865551,
0.1145034059882164,
0.022007504478096962,
0.5539779663085938,
-0.2619388997554779,
-0.5969874858856201,
-0.5335491895675659,
0.2831003665924072,
-0.847484827041626,
-0.09535130113363266,
0.87444007396698,
-0.5205581784248352,
-0.32011792063713074,
-0.26388075947761536,
-0.41450217366218567,
0.18595701456069946,
0.012601185590028763,
0.9427890181541443,
0.976557731628418,
0.020639734342694283,
0.009227062575519085,
-0.5954064726829529,
0.47097548842430115,
0.732825517654419,
-1.0810872316360474,
-0.4328886568546295,
0.31132039427757263,
0.3455139696598053,
-0.00010229870531475171,
0.659288227558136,
0.03824682533740997,
0.36242982745170593,
-0.02665332332253456,
-0.1281270533800125,
-0.006532995495945215,
-0.6597838997840881,
-0.37910977005958557,
0.11606012284755707,
0.20447716116905212,
0.18261639773845673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03020v1 | Exploiting Dialect Identification in Automatic Dialectal Text Normalization | 2024-07-03T11:30:03 | 2024-07-03T11:30:03 | Bashar Alhafni, Sarah Al-Towaity, Ziyad Fawzy, Fatema Nassar, Fadhl Eryani, Houda Bouamor, Nizar Habash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialectal Arabic is the primary spoken language used by native Arabic
speakers in daily communication. The rise of social media platforms has notably
expanded its use as a written language. However, Arabic dialects do not have
standard orthographies. This, combined with the inherent noise in
user-generated content on social media, presents a major challenge to NLP
applications dealing with Dialectal Arabic. In this paper, we explore and
report on the task of CODAfication, which aims to normalize Dialectal Arabic
into the Conventional Orthography for Dialectal Arabic (CODA). We work with a
unique parallel corpus of multiple Arabic dialects focusing on five major city
dialects. We benchmark newly developed pretrained sequence-to-sequence models
on the task of CODAfication. We further show that using dialect identification
information improves the performance across all dialects. We make our code,
data, and pretrained models publicly available. | [
-0.5291833281517029,
-0.6109441518783569,
0.37273040413856506,
0.2589184641838074,
-0.5364416837692261,
-0.048255279660224915,
-0.5131682753562927,
-0.543513298034668,
0.5030565857887268,
0.644183874130249,
-0.18791788816452026,
-1.0439331531524658,
-0.678806483745575,
0.3562389016151428,
-0.5145472884178162,
0.8954015374183655,
0.19103801250457764,
-0.16066791117191315,
0.2623905837535858,
-0.4338609278202057,
-0.4117010235786438,
-0.8602524399757385,
-0.6495723128318787,
0.09799961000680923,
0.38765251636505127,
0.4897884726524353,
0.9350545406341553,
0.6414173245429993,
0.18266825377941132,
0.3894255459308624,
-0.09922297298908234,
0.06562475860118866,
-0.48684749007225037,
-0.0635560154914856,
0.05344431474804878,
-0.2554057240486145,
-0.33865079283714294,
-0.43154269456863403,
0.6955922842025757,
0.9651519656181335,
-0.07455288618803024,
0.3175552785396576,
-0.13915877044200897,
0.9351134300231934,
-0.65859055519104,
0.28454136848449707,
-0.7012432813644409,
-0.2867577075958252,
-0.5505290031433105,
0.3857440650463104,
-0.013767835684120655,
-0.7546820640563965,
0.10666397958993912,
-0.24786710739135742,
0.3118360638618469,
-0.34066513180732727,
0.9322877526283264,
-0.24427461624145508,
-0.7348001599311829,
-0.32564976811408997,
-0.7180531024932861,
0.566473662853241,
-0.9689924716949463,
0.25105324387550354,
0.34063857793807983,
0.2864070236682892,
0.2735978066921234,
-0.65960693359375,
-0.5846477746963501,
0.05226792022585869,
-0.13565915822982788,
-0.19570940732955933,
0.06179049611091614,
0.15418091416358948,
0.05827467143535614,
0.2054942548274994,
-0.41044723987579346,
-0.15494072437286377,
-0.4431585669517517,
-0.1140766590833664,
0.7426155805587769,
-0.059347353875637054,
0.2792007625102997,
-0.10949253290891647,
-0.1991582065820694,
0.04050939157605171,
-0.47021105885505676,
0.11525338888168335,
0.44608965516090393,
0.6259377002716064,
-0.23859089612960815,
0.18427325785160065,
-0.41451185941696167,
0.6780160665512085,
-0.08119950443506241,
0.10968101769685745,
0.6086425185203552,
-0.30447375774383545,
-0.22845716774463654,
0.09849782288074493,
0.6561384797096252,
0.29514187574386597,
0.8190710544586182,
-0.007229097653180361,
-0.3838600516319275,
-0.29158690571784973,
0.4156794846057892,
-0.6478742361068726,
-0.12806296348571777,
0.11140093952417374,
-0.4219568371772766,
-0.265247106552124,
0.3501819670200348,
-0.7906025648117065,
-0.2971218228340149,
-0.22864490747451782,
0.20438630878925323,
-0.4991825819015503,
-0.31863072514533997,
0.07523803412914276,
-0.043746620416641235,
0.17948077619075775,
0.13611844182014465,
-1.1679694652557373,
0.48783019185066223,
0.5758088827133179,
0.7654144167900085,
-0.06039508804678917,
-0.2455011010169983,
0.12292418628931046,
0.17880849540233612,
-0.5891522765159607,
0.5403252840042114,
-0.48996254801750183,
-0.4085223376750946,
0.5071393847465515,
-0.1530476063489914,
-0.14312952756881714,
-0.888821005821228,
0.5851224660873413,
-0.7619616985321045,
-0.35664206743240356,
-0.22749623656272888,
-0.12705861032009125,
-0.5168970823287964,
-0.037163618952035904,
-0.9224806427955627,
0.8673321008682251,
0.07657156139612198,
-0.4269372522830963,
0.17676496505737305,
-0.4004853069782257,
-0.7550913095474243,
-0.08534224331378937,
0.01841045543551445,
-0.5060245394706726,
0.22958941757678986,
0.41190382838249207,
0.3235853910446167,
-0.056439176201820374,
0.3958136737346649,
-0.017171790823340416,
-0.35187575221061707,
-0.005941113457083702,
-0.22639842331409454,
0.8575753569602966,
0.24046117067337036,
-0.2411622852087021,
0.09666267037391663,
-0.8921455144882202,
0.04774589091539383,
0.05598685145378113,
-0.12112122774124146,
-0.39906612038612366,
0.03974359855055809,
0.40788233280181885,
-0.12184622883796692,
0.30286890268325806,
-0.3524603545665741,
0.003962917253375053,
-0.6889642477035522,
0.17623239755630493,
0.5531600713729858,
0.07588057965040207,
0.4103906750679016,
-0.5605506300926208,
0.3864509165287018,
-0.03369835764169693,
-0.1668257713317871,
-0.04499948397278786,
-0.6235501170158386,
-0.7843503355979919,
-0.4820433557033539,
0.5582211017608643,
0.3699128031730652,
-0.2517137825489044,
0.4225959777832031,
-0.3898047208786011,
-0.49316978454589844,
-0.4585859179496765,
0.22889943420886993,
0.20712432265281677,
0.17186929285526276,
0.4181067645549774,
-0.6508540511131287,
-0.7090127468109131,
-0.916579008102417,
-0.32191190123558044,
-0.09688975661993027,
-0.020054077729582787,
0.07343123108148575,
0.06277231127023697,
-0.448855996131897,
0.9904196262359619,
-0.21624352037906647,
-0.34882664680480957,
-0.45887064933776855,
0.5318787097930908,
0.26868271827697754,
0.21598495543003082,
0.7902017831802368,
-0.6782863140106201,
-0.6405653953552246,
-0.056393057107925415,
-0.38794955611228943,
-0.6561200618743896,
-0.23722977936267853,
0.05689164623618126,
0.28861895203590393,
0.45926138758659363,
-0.11341091990470886,
0.4654040038585663,
0.6178964972496033,
-0.08403614908456802,
0.494736909866333,
0.08174502104520798,
0.18316389620304108,
-1.0270566940307617,
0.0680861845612526,
-0.23436862230300903,
-0.3855419456958771,
-0.8498871326446533,
0.16890476644039154,
-0.03136368840932846,
-0.21494339406490326,
-0.1308896392583847,
0.41709235310554504,
-0.47604939341545105,
0.11917348951101303,
-0.24432286620140076,
-0.07203076779842377,
-0.18032482266426086,
0.32002368569374084,
0.2530066967010498,
0.602228045463562,
0.33680686354637146,
-0.285165935754776,
0.11476635932922363,
0.10952882468700409,
-0.3193480968475342,
0.025600047782063484,
-0.5453201532363892,
0.4228592813014984,
-0.21130870282649994,
0.10940039902925491,
-1.2163296937942505,
-0.16468894481658936,
0.05394758656620979,
-0.22152242064476013,
-0.1586078405380249,
-0.19119195640087128,
-0.2850092947483063,
0.22849541902542114,
-0.22052864730358124,
0.7040560841560364,
0.462929368019104,
-0.4120856821537018,
0.7512444853782654,
0.35986950993537903,
-0.5093646049499512,
-0.3166430592536926,
-0.2888382375240326,
0.1806289702653885,
-0.18958958983421326,
-0.6495763659477234,
0.30068108439445496,
0.3693462610244751,
-0.42296120524406433,
-0.32877448201179504,
-0.004328868817538023,
-0.5399240851402283,
0.02212458662688732,
0.4941670894622803,
0.09712579846382141,
-0.37822720408439636,
0.1064973920583725,
0.1413269191980362,
0.09410274773836136,
0.08997399359941483,
0.006150645203888416,
0.697109043598175,
-0.12471994757652283,
-0.29147547483444214,
-0.6220289468765259,
0.7805549502372742,
0.3987228274345398,
-0.3329545855522156,
0.6912274360656738,
0.6116998195648193,
-0.23186275362968445,
-0.23298190534114838,
-0.776563286781311,
-0.08502945303916931,
-0.5220221877098083,
0.28217601776123047,
-0.4396042227745056,
-0.5357362627983093,
0.526355504989624,
-0.28636765480041504,
-0.21852901577949524,
0.32391494512557983,
0.49495768547058105,
0.05215379223227501,
0.5170137286186218,
0.6353901028633118,
-0.6307365894317627,
0.42987769842147827,
0.021240539848804474,
0.18098336458206177,
0.03460482507944107,
0.18152275681495667,
-0.6586508750915527,
-0.3772859573364258,
-0.3969954550266266,
-0.4489883780479431,
0.5199645757675171,
0.02830972708761692,
-0.1755875200033188,
0.35206112265586853,
0.0241668913513422,
0.4638301134109497,
0.6374528408050537,
0.11403272300958633,
0.437917560338974,
0.10116727650165558,
0.06497831642627716,
0.06965958327054977,
-0.39467811584472656,
-0.6876239776611328,
1.275912880897522,
0.027449266985058784,
0.39485955238342285,
0.3370043933391571,
1.1857807636260986,
0.4658122956752777,
0.27470558881759644,
-0.6291492581367493,
0.5211968421936035,
-0.15722019970417023,
-0.4397217035293579,
-0.26226356625556946,
-0.11604423820972443,
-0.9452651739120483,
-0.03770959749817848,
-0.16717970371246338,
-0.6898365020751953,
0.3412613570690155,
-0.03316507488489151,
-0.40971848368644714,
-0.11534930020570755,
-0.6881856322288513,
0.8168326616287231,
0.14890344440937042,
0.2727026641368866,
-0.3628157675266266,
-0.8586940765380859,
0.032143063843250275,
-0.36387091875076294,
0.5712619423866272,
0.04875319451093674,
-0.014629554003477097,
0.5928901433944702,
-0.5460570454597473,
1.0625700950622559,
0.07154791057109833,
0.04676571860909462,
0.26188036799430847,
-0.07683654129505157,
0.32722577452659607,
0.0009742647525854409,
-0.2869769334793091,
0.6881468296051025,
0.2958049774169922,
-0.6466416716575623,
-0.45465171337127686,
0.47465938329696655,
-0.8723167181015015,
-0.5808678269386292,
-0.3020871877670288,
-0.2557107210159302,
-0.4397066831588745,
0.32518166303634644,
0.041600801050662994,
0.6093930602073669,
-0.580528199672699,
-0.06824961304664612,
0.2035181224346161,
0.11971449106931686,
0.465226411819458,
0.40285030007362366,
-0.1498165726661682,
-0.4005446135997772,
0.7541475892066956,
0.0012894278625026345,
0.3654572367668152,
0.06922736018896103,
0.056827716529369354,
-0.06541994959115982,
-0.8311900496482849,
-0.49778902530670166,
0.2075844556093216,
-0.7421570420265198,
0.08465710282325745,
-0.3268466889858246,
-0.27626460790634155,
-0.7805767059326172,
-0.3419080674648285,
-0.25090041756629944,
-0.4825689196586609,
-0.011137678287923336,
-0.05533363297581673,
-0.0380253791809082,
0.8812691569328308,
-0.15113385021686554,
0.2534266710281372,
-0.9459590911865234,
0.524300217628479,
0.32014966011047363,
-0.13022302091121674,
-0.16262613236904144,
-0.4321884512901306,
-0.29760417342185974,
0.00915355235338211,
0.06831420212984085,
-1.3250221014022827,
0.4266645312309265,
0.5413433313369751,
0.16600120067596436,
0.6958109140396118,
0.21989640593528748,
0.5916111469268799,
-0.6336201429367065,
0.6890326142311096,
-0.22864598035812378,
-1.1726740598678589,
0.2279234379529953,
-0.27433571219444275,
0.4133449196815491,
0.9334257245063782,
0.536949872970581,
-0.7801591753959656,
-0.44787275791168213,
-0.3076925575733185,
-1.1527307033538818,
0.3342840075492859,
0.13295990228652954,
0.5591993927955627,
-0.21971160173416138,
0.20271652936935425,
0.07121454179286957,
0.38619768619537354,
-0.46910181641578674,
-0.10479314625263214,
-0.2009543776512146,
-0.4093291461467743,
-0.17554672062397003,
-0.5327504277229309,
-0.3841642141342163,
-0.2454792559146881,
0.44206929206848145,
-0.12739181518554688,
0.11172144114971161,
0.16906671226024628,
-0.3506380021572113,
0.11525461077690125,
0.20206555724143982,
0.29708483815193176,
0.6578390002250671,
-0.21755066514015198,
0.10597410053014755,
0.0982331857085228,
-0.5046437978744507,
0.03173555061221123,
0.11395378410816193,
-0.197229266166687,
0.4750674366950989,
0.6576564908027649,
0.3958422541618347,
0.03629472851753235,
-0.7041292786598206,
0.5902405381202698,
0.3046468496322632,
0.011996563524007797,
-0.44406241178512573,
-0.22041074931621552,
0.028370995074510574,
0.1523357480764389,
0.31955111026763916,
0.07532818615436554,
0.287638396024704,
-0.6231327652931213,
0.17138759791851044,
0.3632839322090149,
-0.24570506811141968,
-0.2359403669834137,
0.30006465315818787,
0.36324378848075867,
-0.4021230936050415,
0.4636754095554352,
0.02004777267575264,
-0.6301785707473755,
0.8267244100570679,
0.4126085042953491,
0.9603457450866699,
-0.17458465695381165,
0.2836765944957733,
0.32743823528289795,
0.2698074281215668,
0.28345465660095215,
0.40520885586738586,
-0.3235000967979431,
-1.0256474018096924,
-0.05318405106663704,
-0.7126086354255676,
-0.32841917872428894,
-0.2419540286064148,
-0.7648204565048218,
0.2457161396741867,
-0.6251897811889648,
-0.19274267554283142,
0.13315808773040771,
-0.36338701844215393,
-0.46127021312713623,
0.2730090618133545,
0.4929155111312866,
0.7537330389022827,
-1.1370012760162354,
1.0824105739593506,
0.6495754718780518,
-0.17089171707630157,
-0.8598306775093079,
0.4898582696914673,
0.30882981419563293,
-0.6764964461326599,
0.7052980065345764,
0.1869780421257019,
-0.409298300743103,
0.12354881316423416,
-0.2815450131893158,
-0.6171461939811707,
0.5552166700363159,
0.16256973147392273,
-0.25203096866607666,
0.10263536125421524,
0.5699023008346558,
0.6124480962753296,
-0.381102055311203,
0.2542579472064972,
0.5625398755073547,
0.542137622833252,
-0.18860113620758057,
-0.9070524573326111,
0.17005044221878052,
-0.25822171568870544,
0.32765427231788635,
-0.003992845304310322,
-0.5605998039245605,
0.7223608493804932,
0.018619714304804802,
-0.2815418243408203,
0.3340064585208893,
0.6806145310401917,
-0.32403767108917236,
0.21201921999454498,
0.5766621828079224,
0.3624594509601593,
0.571865975856781,
-0.0033843195997178555,
0.6170337200164795,
-0.5102314949035645,
0.11923754960298538,
1.0009106397628784,
-0.3474389314651489,
0.9243543744087219,
0.45886924862861633,
-0.06491934508085251,
0.7803156971931458,
0.397054523229599,
0.39235246181488037,
0.5327236652374268,
0.18858185410499573,
-0.6907918453216553,
-0.03496081009507179,
0.10435274988412857,
-0.4301941692829132,
0.5744339227676392,
0.17764556407928467,
-0.40926629304885864,
-0.290995717048645,
-0.2227979153394699,
0.1709904670715332,
0.5256969332695007,
-0.13426996767520905,
1.0193824768066406,
-0.2715493440628052,
-0.43316203355789185,
1.1291826963424683,
0.33840927481651306,
0.4128383696079254,
-0.7417535185813904,
0.09838537871837616,
-0.358806312084198,
-0.0009002733277156949,
-0.17022022604942322,
-0.007823994383215904,
0.654692530632019,
-0.2014615386724472,
-0.06434906274080276,
-0.18972069025039673,
0.5178993344306946,
-0.6556578874588013,
-0.4303221106529236,
0.22117303311824799,
0.36478835344314575,
0.0005978489061817527,
-0.3467727303504944,
-0.23187018930912018,
0.11823664605617523,
-0.04140138626098633,
-0.01804737001657486,
0.19677072763442993,
0.43928268551826477,
-0.08348428457975388,
0.16845542192459106,
0.49404147267341614,
0.24661001563072205,
0.19240105152130127,
0.23943215608596802,
0.8587531447410583,
-0.7182846069335938,
-0.29279249906539917,
-0.8598349094390869,
0.1213957667350769,
-0.09664849191904068,
-0.40827012062072754,
0.8111274242401123,
0.5737699866294861,
0.7885797023773193,
-0.3670370578765869,
0.8465259075164795,
0.012620825320482254,
0.5045731067657471,
-0.466898649930954,
0.8348824381828308,
-0.3677283227443695,
0.20029596984386444,
-0.3147227466106415,
-0.7037871479988098,
-0.32955172657966614,
0.48385247588157654,
-0.3321598172187805,
-0.2166733741760254,
0.7000781893730164,
0.9923231601715088,
-0.09760437160730362,
0.27823111414909363,
0.2959539294242859,
0.25174787640571594,
-0.0893939957022667,
0.3207615613937378,
0.33124640583992004,
-0.07355023175477982,
0.2864910662174225,
-0.37674805521965027,
-0.21074000000953674,
-0.25503572821617126,
-0.7056097984313965,
-1.0095142126083374,
-0.5811356902122498,
0.020443474873900414,
-0.37521401047706604,
0.5871124863624573,
1.1260873079299927,
0.7057340145111084,
-1.2578681707382202,
-0.8663040995597839,
0.11526373028755188,
0.06085490062832832,
-0.511368989944458,
-0.14822229743003845,
0.16526764631271362,
-0.5194111466407776,
-0.9434462785720825,
0.40352386236190796,
0.004891594871878624,
-0.22303611040115356,
0.10789641737937927,
0.4216880798339844,
-0.3422755002975464,
0.30144572257995605,
0.35930466651916504,
0.4221767783164978,
-0.40818721055984497,
-0.2963462769985199,
-0.5919374227523804,
-0.2602037489414215,
0.23279182612895966,
0.8912132382392883,
-0.6592297554016113,
0.5053157210350037,
0.3767949938774109,
0.7549823522567749,
0.4300359785556793,
0.4487892985343933,
0.86383455991745,
-0.8920976519584656,
0.4310063123703003,
0.2737235724925995,
0.2117711305618286,
0.21052682399749756,
-0.005675877444446087,
0.3981679081916809,
0.3680596649646759,
-0.28115618228912354,
-0.33075499534606934,
0.2895672619342804,
-0.9184504747390747,
-0.13604141771793365,
1.1583999395370483,
-0.2078498899936676,
-0.06377188861370087,
-0.5029967427253723,
-0.45000624656677246,
0.09121080487966537,
-0.4740145206451416,
0.9773493409156799,
0.7543996572494507,
0.4442349970340729,
0.14009112119674683,
-0.4112667739391327,
0.6995912790298462,
0.5990986227989197,
-0.5724665522575378,
-0.20467662811279297,
0.3654301166534424,
0.2909221947193146,
-0.005896309390664101,
0.9616592526435852,
0.15043547749519348,
0.041024401783943176,
-0.23868213593959808,
0.03791484981775284,
0.13490714132785797,
-0.32271748781204224,
-0.5597042441368103,
0.4166814386844635,
0.12386965751647949,
-0.20645427703857422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03007v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03007v1 | What Affects the Stability of Tool Learning? An Empirical Study on the Robustness of Tool Learning Frameworks | 2024-07-03T11:06:05 | 2024-07-03T11:06:05 | Chengrui Huang, Zhengliang Shi, Yuntao Wen, Xiuying Chen, Peng Han, Shen Gao, Shuo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tool learning methods have enhanced the ability of large language models
(LLMs) to interact with real-world applications. Many existing works fine-tune
LLMs or design prompts to enable LLMs to select appropriate tools and correctly
invoke them to meet user requirements. However, it is observed in previous
works that the performance of tool learning varies from tasks, datasets,
training settings, and algorithms. Without understanding the impact of these
factors, it can lead to inconsistent results, inefficient model deployment, and
suboptimal tool utilization, ultimately hindering the practical integration and
scalability of LLMs in real-world scenarios. Therefore, in this paper, we
explore the impact of both internal and external factors on the performance of
tool learning frameworks. Through extensive experiments on two benchmark
datasets, we find several insightful conclusions for future work, including the
observation that LLMs can benefit significantly from increased trial and
exploration. We believe our empirical study provides a new perspective for
future tool learning research. | [
-0.3043345808982849,
-0.693723738193512,
0.5134313106536865,
-0.1188197210431099,
-0.2656865119934082,
0.2717529237270355,
-0.3412882685661316,
-0.5923258066177368,
-0.4353046119213104,
0.0017158970003947616,
-0.30931946635246277,
-0.40243831276893616,
-0.7398677468299866,
0.10714273154735565,
-0.41982540488243103,
0.7333847284317017,
0.03812473267316818,
0.30634692311286926,
-0.5479919910430908,
-0.47118350863456726,
-0.5472286343574524,
-0.6392796635627747,
-0.704620897769928,
-0.4847411811351776,
0.5980603694915771,
0.5610475540161133,
0.7473878264427185,
0.8042295575141907,
0.5433279871940613,
0.2548992335796356,
-0.176768958568573,
-0.2311776727437973,
-0.715901255607605,
0.4641624689102173,
-0.14884603023529053,
-0.9444649815559387,
-0.022515811026096344,
-0.007298015523701906,
0.6313278079032898,
0.8235356211662292,
-0.11490844190120697,
0.0876728743314743,
0.4499901235103607,
0.19899824261665344,
-0.5392810106277466,
0.020235583186149597,
-0.6740506291389465,
-0.18076416850090027,
-0.26271939277648926,
0.1392858922481537,
-0.39361217617988586,
-0.27466148138046265,
0.3262855112552643,
-0.4887929856777191,
0.25619566440582275,
-0.12413075566291809,
0.6268377304077148,
0.24006737768650055,
-0.34030741453170776,
-0.359186053276062,
-0.7826518416404724,
0.8284581899642944,
-0.6668803095817566,
0.7607376575469971,
0.2328118532896042,
0.3589220345020294,
-0.5251121520996094,
-0.6441974639892578,
-0.06640748679637909,
-0.11422399431467056,
0.16017653048038483,
-0.201396182179451,
0.4305441379547119,
-0.19881671667099,
0.5333949327468872,
0.27054762840270996,
-0.1389632225036621,
0.7721840143203735,
-0.44580647349357605,
-0.25199049711227417,
0.40988534688949585,
0.2697540819644928,
0.010884925723075867,
0.35346925258636475,
-0.14731265604496002,
-0.5219425559043884,
-1.0785136222839355,
0.5180795788764954,
0.4618608355522156,
0.5091455578804016,
-0.20434726774692535,
0.37053394317626953,
0.3015877306461334,
0.42980700731277466,
-0.030085906386375427,
-0.7454407215118408,
0.346340149641037,
-0.1602238565683365,
-0.0920146107673645,
-0.20593960583209991,
0.5714924931526184,
0.23180651664733887,
0.05621772259473801,
-0.41303467750549316,
-0.32655972242355347,
-0.12163639813661575,
0.3408854305744171,
-0.885172963142395,
-0.03756468743085861,
0.14998343586921692,
-0.33537790179252625,
-0.39154693484306335,
0.10377179831266403,
-0.4940233528614044,
-0.6710733771324158,
-0.2499455064535141,
0.2750721871852875,
-0.17098645865917206,
-0.4554315209388733,
-0.21589729189872742,
-0.1303136795759201,
0.19590511918067932,
0.4331892728805542,
-0.5759725570678711,
0.31929251551628113,
0.6010265350341797,
0.9892081022262573,
-0.5210534334182739,
-0.2747180461883545,
-0.8714694976806641,
-0.2390620857477188,
-0.4917960464954376,
0.38651829957962036,
-0.5252566933631897,
-0.79139643907547,
0.10659094154834747,
0.211587592959404,
0.09237048774957657,
-0.7362310886383057,
0.29511648416519165,
-0.553005576133728,
0.06830132007598877,
-0.642126739025116,
-0.39072614908218384,
-0.2545563280582428,
0.05239485576748848,
-0.6731931567192078,
1.2551164627075195,
0.00020674259576480836,
-0.7631835341453552,
0.9866495728492737,
-0.27686846256256104,
-0.4732222557067871,
-0.27707794308662415,
-0.34632444381713867,
-0.664631187915802,
0.4408405125141144,
-0.16284461319446564,
0.5522443652153015,
-0.32557666301727295,
0.21797360479831696,
-0.9604086875915527,
-0.5452013611793518,
0.38282090425491333,
-0.29778844118118286,
0.7200899720191956,
0.0450262725353241,
-0.4184127151966095,
0.2584315836429596,
-0.7187317609786987,
-0.3483397662639618,
0.08940631151199341,
-0.40905123949050903,
-0.1278776377439499,
0.2717713415622711,
-0.06402546167373657,
0.5731818079948425,
-0.2395002841949463,
-0.6519730091094971,
0.0848676860332489,
-0.5905706882476807,
0.1988651156425476,
0.9328306913375854,
0.007454026956111193,
0.41119247674942017,
-0.15633070468902588,
0.8230897188186646,
0.26937776803970337,
-0.11511283367872238,
-0.10280425101518631,
-0.06532502919435501,
-0.5406421422958374,
0.17719636857509613,
0.5804944634437561,
0.34487849473953247,
-0.5216056704521179,
-0.15979017317295074,
-0.1022316962480545,
-0.5547103881835938,
-0.23550735414028168,
0.6733899712562561,
0.21514655649662018,
0.3798334300518036,
-0.03755709156394005,
-0.49566540122032166,
-0.2718054950237274,
-0.6120742559432983,
-0.08614982664585114,
-0.2369006723165512,
0.006813880987465382,
0.15030500292778015,
0.47476303577423096,
0.10595861822366714,
0.9016430377960205,
0.07938741892576218,
-0.1149812638759613,
-0.37503930926322937,
-0.03561105579137802,
0.06648422032594681,
0.37451741099357605,
0.8007763028144836,
-0.6661680340766907,
-0.40357068181037903,
-0.03828181326389313,
-0.5774893164634705,
0.052482523024082184,
-0.12117429822683334,
0.1311863660812378,
0.23191215097904205,
0.724592387676239,
-0.3143024742603302,
0.48464450240135193,
0.4117427468299866,
0.015980053693056107,
0.525869607925415,
-0.0409969761967659,
-0.3561660051345825,
-0.9288988709449768,
0.08439627289772034,
0.23408450186252594,
-0.2540351152420044,
-0.20918485522270203,
-0.14456240832805634,
0.17434707283973694,
0.15817545354366302,
-0.6913125514984131,
0.48123690485954285,
-0.42036107182502747,
-0.2228042036294937,
-0.2932698130607605,
0.2744934856891632,
-0.2088218629360199,
0.1540970653295517,
-0.29591304063796997,
1.184124231338501,
0.7952365279197693,
-0.6895892024040222,
-0.020720602944493294,
-0.11462405323982239,
-0.25073400139808655,
0.5161310434341431,
-0.796970784664154,
-0.018794246017932892,
0.1490563005208969,
-0.12789399921894073,
-0.659960925579071,
-0.11474807560443878,
0.01420802716165781,
-0.21197618544101715,
0.6154255867004395,
-0.13844534754753113,
-0.8899846076965332,
-0.03221387788653374,
-0.3007753789424896,
-0.07210025936365128,
0.3558066785335541,
-0.5166376829147339,
0.6522445678710938,
0.320057213306427,
0.050622764974832535,
-0.7170515060424805,
-0.29311949014663696,
-0.16646748781204224,
-0.5336503982543945,
-0.2681259512901306,
-0.27743399143218994,
-0.03659621626138687,
-0.4269484877586365,
-0.2876422107219696,
-0.555537760257721,
0.2792219817638397,
0.7429893016815186,
0.6152320504188538,
0.03375199809670448,
-0.11915337294340134,
0.48115211725234985,
-0.022654810920357704,
-0.04818085953593254,
0.34162428975105286,
0.0221230648458004,
0.2520143687725067,
-0.13652542233467102,
-0.63652503490448,
0.07258687168359756,
-0.1402958184480667,
0.8377293348312378,
-0.11604548990726471,
1.0439566373825073,
0.7178866863250732,
-0.1422269642353058,
-0.30920109152793884,
-0.5119423270225525,
-0.3330509662628174,
-0.5492411255836487,
0.40116965770721436,
-0.36711278557777405,
-0.8117366433143616,
0.7428637742996216,
-0.49166491627693176,
0.5451452732086182,
0.19011501967906952,
0.5902559161186218,
-0.21028244495391846,
1.202075719833374,
1.0055303573608398,
-0.17267107963562012,
0.6117380261421204,
-0.1997409164905548,
-0.15367981791496277,
-0.7970561981201172,
-0.11453644186258316,
-0.5148727297782898,
-0.313977986574173,
-0.4498966336250305,
-0.04779301956295967,
0.3561389148235321,
0.29150912165641785,
-0.0873030424118042,
0.011990990489721298,
-0.03333615884184837,
0.383198082447052,
0.37181976437568665,
-0.08533278852701187,
0.16901911795139313,
-0.04849335178732872,
-0.6285821199417114,
-0.031736038625240326,
-0.8365155458450317,
-0.6197621822357178,
1.3593757152557373,
0.6435592174530029,
0.8722706437110901,
0.1304119974374771,
0.39836791157722473,
0.011748149059712887,
0.2569250166416168,
-0.7313043475151062,
0.36563971638679504,
0.2880757451057434,
-0.4388831555843353,
-0.11137735843658447,
-0.16731113195419312,
-0.9898943901062012,
0.3099130690097809,
-0.3212384879589081,
-0.8006268739700317,
0.3355224132537842,
0.12674009799957275,
0.009151560254395008,
0.28261682391166687,
-0.7525069713592529,
0.7957790493965149,
-0.6026816964149475,
-0.9983373880386353,
-0.04015138000249863,
-0.6882050037384033,
-0.06540443748235703,
-0.32950112223625183,
0.38207271695137024,
-0.15601256489753723,
-0.06670977920293808,
0.6609155535697937,
-0.07895991206169128,
1.1605195999145508,
-0.28984227776527405,
-0.3514792025089264,
0.005242503248155117,
0.25835472345352173,
0.5411536693572998,
0.23707208037376404,
-0.36359578371047974,
0.008778041228652,
0.07415024936199188,
-0.1422317773103714,
-0.6067831516265869,
0.7109525203704834,
-0.7190033793449402,
-0.7722926139831543,
-0.38808053731918335,
-0.4003725051879883,
-0.476560115814209,
0.4175597131252289,
0.10317941755056381,
0.6971226334571838,
-0.0967617779970169,
0.717172384262085,
0.7230532169342041,
-0.008569750003516674,
0.523243248462677,
0.32798901200294495,
-0.4876892566680908,
-0.07463692873716354,
0.7003820538520813,
0.3940557837486267,
0.6597310900688171,
-0.2431696504354477,
0.022283626720309258,
-0.16540391743183136,
-0.9413312077522278,
-0.5001280307769775,
0.16051171720027924,
-0.9716709852218628,
-0.1774379462003708,
-0.22388535737991333,
0.1636473685503006,
0.12266085296869278,
-0.2329919934272766,
-0.36733484268188477,
-0.13717800378799438,
-0.4870745837688446,
-0.44428253173828125,
0.2862968146800995,
0.9170092940330505,
0.06589089334011078,
0.37037336826324463,
-0.5695065855979919,
-0.3200497031211853,
-0.08882937580347061,
0.741574227809906,
-0.02444414608180523,
-0.19602619111537933,
-0.630806028842926,
0.019762849435210228,
-0.3965967893600464,
-0.6737085580825806,
-0.22806832194328308,
0.27950069308280945,
0.9454442858695984,
0.5980160236358643,
0.09635095298290253,
0.4994714856147766,
-0.07168367505073547,
0.6795712113380432,
-0.16985920071601868,
-0.6207993030548096,
0.2520163953304291,
-0.37636598944664,
0.4416629374027252,
0.765483021736145,
0.3446400463581085,
-0.0894886702299118,
-0.5679444670677185,
-0.41433629393577576,
-0.7396783828735352,
0.7349017858505249,
-0.02173752523958683,
0.025612615048885345,
0.4573977291584015,
0.5340480804443359,
0.48090067505836487,
0.17349094152450562,
-0.604988157749176,
-0.1186431497335434,
0.005758455488830805,
0.0261637382209301,
-0.12801991403102875,
-0.15715238451957703,
-0.10934428125619888,
-0.218928262591362,
0.6338858604431152,
-0.26636895537376404,
-0.1552266627550125,
-0.40432074666023254,
-0.30663564801216125,
-0.19420206546783447,
0.026751382276415825,
0.36431440711021423,
1.079254388809204,
-0.1614200323820114,
0.08215094357728958,
0.5537670850753784,
-0.5641703009605408,
0.15170623362064362,
-0.29391881823539734,
-0.053581684827804565,
-0.2506651282310486,
0.35547304153442383,
0.7718965411186218,
0.45123958587646484,
-0.8524631261825562,
0.344281941652298,
-0.10411533713340759,
-0.08362283557653427,
-0.2752220630645752,
0.4573950171470642,
0.15902994573116302,
0.26434820890426636,
0.23818640410900116,
0.06418436020612717,
-0.14794790744781494,
-0.4185950458049774,
0.030331073328852654,
0.548552930355072,
-0.49556490778923035,
-0.3694508969783783,
0.5743947625160217,
0.19852787256240845,
-0.270099401473999,
0.47552451491355896,
0.040721211582422256,
-0.4157966375350952,
0.4577256441116333,
0.5174053907394409,
0.649360716342926,
0.021892480552196503,
-0.10902963578701019,
0.14378589391708374,
0.5017820000648499,
-0.1528448611497879,
-0.08512556552886963,
-0.04990321397781372,
-0.495103120803833,
-0.38333600759506226,
-0.538412868976593,
-0.49414438009262085,
0.013514203950762749,
-0.6290754675865173,
0.376765638589859,
-0.5144870281219482,
-0.5310521721839905,
-0.6714065670967102,
-0.05588841065764427,
-0.8355711698532104,
0.1362483948469162,
-0.17728114128112793,
0.9785891175270081,
-0.7955704927444458,
0.942138671875,
0.7750082015991211,
-0.20873935520648956,
-0.7403641939163208,
-0.0581858791410923,
0.3877258896827698,
-0.3827891945838928,
0.46950528025627136,
0.3225831687450409,
-0.5851993560791016,
-0.1735047996044159,
-0.3952191174030304,
-1.2054009437561035,
1.0155593156814575,
0.610031247138977,
-0.26905959844589233,
-0.011229685507714748,
0.06261299550533295,
0.5713230967521667,
-0.18809327483177185,
0.05703864246606827,
0.4303715229034424,
0.0775524228811264,
0.16785866022109985,
-1.2349505424499512,
-0.07657323777675629,
-0.26333341002464294,
-0.04271555319428444,
0.19306913018226624,
-0.3270322382450104,
0.37285855412483215,
-0.27348968386650085,
-0.5206827521324158,
-0.28547921776771545,
0.41575512290000916,
0.25249823927879333,
0.03188115730881691,
0.5481838583946228,
0.41323360800743103,
0.5095322728157043,
-0.17847183346748352,
0.9292600154876709,
-0.31574535369873047,
0.19874700903892517,
0.9512447714805603,
-0.2627438008785248,
0.943680465221405,
0.5689363479614258,
-0.17649959027767181,
0.5395658612251282,
0.8665229082107544,
-0.060552388429641724,
0.2599727213382721,
-0.019000543281435966,
0.2035885453224182,
-0.305766761302948,
0.11436166614294052,
-0.4027279019355774,
0.4719058871269226,
0.48226234316825867,
-0.4116644263267517,
-0.07245004922151566,
0.18339748680591583,
0.03392985090613365,
-0.18317413330078125,
-0.00903259590268135,
0.815139889717102,
0.12708258628845215,
-0.3338526785373688,
0.32116031646728516,
-0.2808345556259155,
0.5775832533836365,
-0.7250970602035522,
0.005721827037632465,
0.23258230090141296,
0.45739299058914185,
-0.18962827324867249,
-0.5179396867752075,
0.23009048402309418,
-0.3070950508117676,
0.10767266154289246,
-0.023151762783527374,
0.6997928023338318,
0.10199680179357529,
-0.49855443835258484,
0.4461357593536377,
0.7906176447868347,
-0.18802614510059357,
0.44255444407463074,
-0.6073641777038574,
0.5335555076599121,
-0.44692057371139526,
-0.4034639298915863,
0.8108674883842468,
0.4179840385913849,
0.10275325924158096,
0.9172099232673645,
0.6313462853431702,
-0.08851193636655807,
0.04861718416213989,
-0.2554171085357666,
0.8865129947662354,
-0.10165908932685852,
-0.31996071338653564,
-0.706530749797821,
0.7163625955581665,
-0.1705847978591919,
-0.29519936442375183,
1.310059905052185,
0.48281756043434143,
1.2086284160614014,
0.3052743673324585,
0.6532379388809204,
0.09554758667945862,
0.535973310470581,
-0.4483391046524048,
0.7008084058761597,
-0.6492288708686829,
0.7290024757385254,
-0.21158553659915924,
-0.8410585522651672,
-0.2494153082370758,
0.5105878710746765,
-0.5300282835960388,
0.2991417348384857,
0.4581228494644165,
0.5635992884635925,
-0.14283359050750732,
-0.18890787661075592,
0.15571030974388123,
-0.02902752347290516,
0.5186715126037598,
-0.1493045538663864,
0.5889076590538025,
0.007039850112050772,
0.47243714332580566,
-0.5941559076309204,
0.21689154207706451,
-0.29515397548675537,
-0.9175698757171631,
-1.0679906606674194,
-0.5546533465385437,
-0.1759674847126007,
-0.37988603115081787,
-0.03172365576028824,
0.9631829857826233,
0.673723578453064,
-0.7129092216491699,
-0.43788811564445496,
-0.03531700745224953,
0.3218100965023041,
-0.2577310800552368,
-0.19635796546936035,
0.3143934905529022,
-0.4185047745704651,
-0.47073128819465637,
0.31895124912261963,
0.08755259215831757,
0.06435282528400421,
-0.44904080033302307,
-0.15131066739559174,
0.08389844000339508,
-0.19226554036140442,
0.470049649477005,
0.40311846137046814,
-0.771885335445404,
-0.35548266768455505,
0.13135263323783875,
0.1504705250263214,
0.23113590478897095,
0.8290068507194519,
-0.9722475409507751,
0.6733275651931763,
0.08290793746709824,
0.7104379534721375,
0.3205423057079315,
-0.2001352459192276,
0.895172119140625,
-0.6824679374694824,
0.14546360075473785,
-0.17054326832294464,
0.44276291131973267,
0.3774384558200836,
-0.17246221005916595,
0.4731803238391876,
0.06573252379894257,
-0.5781691074371338,
-1.2721086740493774,
0.16496972739696503,
-0.3725590705871582,
-0.10226262360811234,
1.0128775835037231,
-0.14309340715408325,
0.04144144803285599,
-0.6284658312797546,
-0.18652471899986267,
0.10029421746730804,
-0.28763341903686523,
0.6795566082000732,
0.7738831639289856,
-0.17710760235786438,
-0.3319332003593445,
-0.726860523223877,
0.4320765435695648,
0.301323264837265,
-0.45047372579574585,
0.16930614411830902,
0.4017520546913147,
0.6208478212356567,
0.027038104832172394,
-0.07261376827955246,
0.06779064983129501,
0.332606703042984,
-0.020856376737356186,
-0.38085731863975525,
-0.3229784369468689,
-0.4419763386249542,
-0.4481579661369324,
0.43111681938171387,
0.7798669934272766,
0.21222040057182312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03005v1 | Human-like Linguistic Biases in Neural Speech Models: Phonetic Categorization and Phonotactic Constraints in Wav2Vec2.0 | 2024-07-03T11:04:31 | 2024-07-03T11:04:31 | Marianne de Heer Kloots, Willem Zuidema | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | What do deep neural speech models know about phonology? Existing work has
examined the encoding of individual linguistic units such as phonemes in these
models. Here we investigate interactions between units. Inspired by classic
experiments on human speech perception, we study how Wav2Vec2 resolves
phonotactic constraints. We synthesize sounds on an acoustic continuum between
/l/ and /r/ and embed them in controlled contexts where only /l/, only /r/, or
neither occur in English. Like humans, Wav2Vec2 models show a bias towards the
phonotactically admissable category in processing such ambiguous sounds. Using
simple measures to analyze model internals on the level of individual stimuli,
we find that this bias emerges in early layers of the model's Transformer
module. This effect is amplified by ASR finetuning but also present in fully
self-supervised models. Our approach demonstrates how controlled stimulus
designs can help localize specific linguistic knowledge in neural speech
models. | [
-0.1793741136789322,
-0.41004273295402527,
0.20957106351852417,
0.09560170769691467,
0.07430871576070786,
-0.27964091300964355,
-0.2554011344909668,
-0.614964485168457,
0.06245328485965729,
0.6823257207870483,
-0.5544080138206482,
-0.12137866020202637,
-0.14243584871292114,
-0.13762499392032623,
-0.022677870467305183,
0.5981501936912537,
0.3708897531032562,
0.3719284236431122,
-0.025961875915527344,
-0.2071039229631424,
-0.5324645638465881,
-0.8851481676101685,
-0.3697812259197235,
-0.7975860238075256,
0.45386621356010437,
0.32787302136421204,
0.6603341698646545,
0.5459693074226379,
0.22076356410980225,
0.18440590798854828,
-0.32307785749435425,
-0.11562206596136093,
-0.05841526761651039,
0.19878430664539337,
-0.23198099434375763,
-0.5170749425888062,
-0.1958301067352295,
-0.0433255136013031,
0.4505951702594757,
0.812186062335968,
-0.3431743383407593,
-0.052128180861473083,
0.21303321421146393,
0.3272949457168579,
-0.3353769779205322,
-0.06655621528625488,
-0.6417620182037354,
0.28714466094970703,
-0.25588491559028625,
-0.07721596956253052,
-0.3517338037490845,
0.07932765781879425,
0.2953571379184723,
-0.4987321197986603,
0.4431757628917694,
-0.2462245523929596,
0.5993754267692566,
0.5713562369346619,
-0.5141689777374268,
-0.18144582211971283,
-0.8556933999061584,
0.661404013633728,
-0.438253253698349,
0.8323930501937866,
0.5855631232261658,
-0.017131881788372993,
-0.11501889675855637,
-0.5084977149963379,
-0.3731943368911743,
-0.15504364669322968,
-0.1492283195257187,
0.030306784436106682,
-0.23331253230571747,
0.33118611574172974,
0.06895267218351364,
0.13678085803985596,
-0.6378721594810486,
0.5284337997436523,
-0.4658060669898987,
-0.5740867257118225,
0.3977424204349518,
-0.13108502328395844,
0.15631629526615143,
-0.4095083475112915,
-0.2675427496433258,
-0.10328315198421478,
-0.5437793135643005,
0.2653592526912689,
0.5600525736808777,
0.2166363000869751,
-0.025844858959317207,
0.6794241070747375,
0.11793111264705658,
0.46968045830726624,
0.1376579850912094,
0.097279854118824,
0.23945294320583344,
-0.0636691078543663,
0.0004028431139886379,
0.2782934606075287,
0.6788631677627563,
0.14716413617134094,
0.4188181161880493,
-0.07020562142133713,
-0.23333632946014404,
0.21625378727912903,
0.17297852039337158,
-0.39640599489212036,
-0.32324036955833435,
0.07502884417772293,
-0.44057944416999817,
-0.1731242686510086,
-0.16653263568878174,
-0.37433579564094543,
-0.6605761647224426,
-0.42452001571655273,
0.3414382040500641,
-0.16053253412246704,
-0.45624810457229614,
0.06432509422302246,
-0.1896536499261856,
0.10658620297908783,
-0.18776440620422363,
-1.2196462154388428,
0.5250529050827026,
0.5170601010322571,
0.2720138430595398,
0.016169432550668716,
-0.34593456983566284,
-0.40573835372924805,
-0.14341114461421967,
-0.24573318660259247,
0.6148589253425598,
-0.4725549817085266,
-0.4763939082622528,
0.03376239165663719,
-0.03274049982428551,
0.32258984446525574,
-0.9159347414970398,
0.49412262439727783,
-0.39761796593666077,
0.03705991804599762,
-0.3538443446159363,
-0.3598661422729492,
0.07586026191711426,
-0.3527365028858185,
-0.5555817484855652,
0.8052364587783813,
0.011470439843833447,
-0.5112326145172119,
0.32967257499694824,
-0.20731216669082642,
-0.6221238374710083,
-0.18182657659053802,
-0.5222164988517761,
-0.22591960430145264,
0.30165696144104004,
-0.09698889404535294,
0.09836193919181824,
-0.16308018565177917,
0.14666900038719177,
-0.06734287738800049,
-0.10419389605522156,
0.5879387855529785,
-0.437742680311203,
0.7760531902313232,
0.31080561876296997,
-0.2506295442581177,
0.24428708851337433,
-0.8761877417564392,
-0.02097366936504841,
0.015190106816589832,
-0.4200023114681244,
-0.4004356265068054,
0.11927732080221176,
0.14651939272880554,
0.1510985642671585,
0.09614062309265137,
-0.4654238522052765,
0.11900746077299118,
-0.4073234498500824,
0.8923369646072388,
0.3613935708999634,
0.14285677671432495,
0.8893538117408752,
-0.01081422995775938,
0.22295387089252472,
0.05164366587996483,
0.12120392918586731,
0.07092370092868805,
-0.463186651468277,
-0.758910059928894,
0.2260836958885193,
0.25329893827438354,
0.5295530557632446,
-0.07353745400905609,
0.37322449684143066,
0.24653828144073486,
-0.03125683590769768,
-0.8389907479286194,
0.06763357669115067,
0.4082772731781006,
0.45968353748321533,
0.39653265476226807,
-0.487516313791275,
-0.6344999670982361,
-1.2980400323867798,
-0.1143568605184555,
-0.1758527308702469,
-0.5792853236198425,
0.36610808968544006,
-0.04757951945066452,
-0.09041175246238708,
0.943295955657959,
-0.14352969825267792,
-0.6077467203140259,
0.0696275532245636,
0.08437156677246094,
-0.12921088933944702,
0.6222352981567383,
0.20985783636569977,
-0.7774217128753662,
0.21819840371608734,
-0.10271900147199631,
-0.44262662529945374,
-0.3078916668891907,
-0.025685394182801247,
0.18375560641288757,
0.14950217306613922,
0.5556411147117615,
-0.5792039036750793,
0.30319079756736755,
0.2312128245830536,
-0.38391801714897156,
0.29046350717544556,
-0.19123686850070953,
-0.3400059640407562,
-0.5662635564804077,
-0.28328537940979004,
0.1681659072637558,
-0.06328127533197403,
-0.8176719546318054,
-0.25292903184890747,
0.08365684747695923,
-0.04672486335039139,
-0.2714408338069916,
0.401169091463089,
-0.4949273467063904,
-0.37205246090888977,
-0.22064326703548431,
0.07919632643461227,
0.07690387219190598,
0.5821054577827454,
0.4977880120277405,
0.290970116853714,
0.3657192587852478,
-0.5771968364715576,
0.13718894124031067,
0.2320868819952011,
-0.1993895173072815,
0.18513041734695435,
-0.7634310126304626,
0.48139581084251404,
-0.006906506139785051,
0.3751651346683502,
-0.8903673887252808,
-0.11723583936691284,
0.24674181640148163,
-0.7719324827194214,
0.3195555508136749,
-0.38734689354896545,
-0.13450174033641815,
-0.2204207330942154,
0.1931556612253189,
0.7504340410232544,
0.8221721053123474,
-0.4958030581474304,
0.4011291563510895,
0.7477114796638489,
0.19389505684375763,
-0.275071918964386,
-1.2177625894546509,
-0.12341123074293137,
-0.09731093049049377,
-0.3398270905017853,
0.24551993608474731,
0.056627146899700165,
-0.5345027446746826,
-0.016189977526664734,
-0.2590895891189575,
-0.2900497317314148,
-0.09471555054187775,
0.38960036635398865,
-0.09601162374019623,
-0.29059988260269165,
0.017436472699046135,
-0.010392524302005768,
-0.07591186463832855,
0.22157800197601318,
-0.7956576943397522,
0.5251273512840271,
0.24223323166370392,
-0.14368779957294464,
-0.8463908433914185,
0.16295894980430603,
0.367914080619812,
-0.4877183437347412,
0.11662738770246506,
0.4605460464954376,
-0.48912379145622253,
-0.24198099970817566,
-0.6410039663314819,
-0.545376181602478,
-0.42393994331359863,
0.5045576095581055,
-0.6484177112579346,
-0.8280065059661865,
0.5083982348442078,
0.47013261914253235,
-0.3637652099132538,
0.2101822942495346,
0.7663053870201111,
-0.05889178439974785,
0.9483452439308167,
0.15398135781288147,
0.008373400196433067,
0.30957433581352234,
-0.11308631300926208,
-0.11145266890525818,
-0.8986071348190308,
-0.4762546420097351,
-0.5168411135673523,
-0.1984369158744812,
-0.7567691802978516,
-0.3099139332771301,
-0.021786537021398544,
-0.05619698762893677,
-0.09858979284763336,
0.19532661139965057,
-0.7944027781486511,
0.5911459922790527,
0.6183936595916748,
0.06903063505887985,
-0.0667237639427185,
-0.021159280091524124,
-0.16020143032073975,
-0.33589044213294983,
-0.7460740804672241,
-0.06142272800207138,
0.7254565358161926,
0.6934365630149841,
0.5541983842849731,
0.048860013484954834,
0.3721591830253601,
0.252902090549469,
-0.46538323163986206,
-0.9647569060325623,
0.23773403465747833,
-0.13901279866695404,
-0.6191393136978149,
-0.2658795714378357,
-0.17345331609249115,
-0.8931677937507629,
0.26076993346214294,
-0.19821617007255554,
-0.8919203877449036,
0.6237396597862244,
0.2928802967071533,
-0.5588942170143127,
0.0693836659193039,
-0.6164858937263489,
0.6400542855262756,
-0.1458686888217926,
-0.31718194484710693,
-0.3271767497062683,
-0.813727617263794,
0.11151210963726044,
0.22456948459148407,
0.22164879739284515,
-0.03275764361023903,
0.03584869205951691,
0.5911754965782166,
-0.26862484216690063,
0.888253390789032,
-0.3182111084461212,
-0.24396690726280212,
0.43056216835975647,
0.5188064575195312,
0.18147630989551544,
-0.040339261293411255,
0.05295099690556526,
0.2795029580593109,
-0.23584318161010742,
-0.31878721714019775,
-0.3477689325809479,
0.6833805441856384,
-0.9701610803604126,
-0.5121933817863464,
-0.1590028703212738,
-0.5722850561141968,
-0.30298423767089844,
0.08275862783193588,
0.5494924783706665,
0.614197313785553,
-0.10271880030632019,
0.007996351458132267,
0.8155056834220886,
-0.116461381316185,
0.1644543707370758,
0.3496217727661133,
-0.10024932026863098,
-0.15393206477165222,
0.8098742365837097,
0.3288498818874359,
0.2729145884513855,
0.42235997319221497,
0.3727702796459198,
-0.4533044099807739,
-0.5525731444358826,
-0.23808632791042328,
0.09182003885507584,
-0.6195294857025146,
0.18320852518081665,
-0.4015263319015503,
-0.2844971716403961,
-0.4434492886066437,
0.20112769305706024,
-0.49658602476119995,
-0.6330349445343018,
-0.4353735148906708,
-0.08834635466337204,
-0.050911132246255875,
1.2193491458892822,
-0.31788739562034607,
0.17829133570194244,
-0.3573596775531769,
0.372514933347702,
0.5880323052406311,
0.2778603732585907,
0.11060145497322083,
-0.789852499961853,
-0.10572704672813416,
0.08546017855405807,
0.12943732738494873,
-0.8281684517860413,
0.12201319634914398,
0.015119265764951706,
0.28137505054473877,
0.38081440329551697,
-0.18934743106365204,
0.15548019111156464,
-0.6493239998817444,
0.8517342805862427,
0.12300192564725876,
-0.8533394932746887,
0.42212289571762085,
-0.4827747046947479,
0.35145214200019836,
0.21216343343257904,
-0.12910312414169312,
-0.64666348695755,
-0.3489476144313812,
-0.5553833246231079,
-0.7610751986503601,
0.7067803144454956,
0.24593369662761688,
0.13250675797462463,
0.02543451450765133,
0.5612914562225342,
0.02645035833120346,
-0.07494041323661804,
-0.5970245003700256,
-0.36625850200653076,
-0.3618611991405487,
0.09011289477348328,
0.09593136608600616,
-0.5890896916389465,
0.002797158667817712,
-0.2590053677558899,
0.39694344997406006,
0.349357008934021,
0.06589967012405396,
0.4859214723110199,
-0.22927063703536987,
-0.15515859425067902,
0.1708502620458603,
0.7677165865898132,
0.39034685492515564,
-0.0954887643456459,
0.5327247381210327,
0.10103251039981842,
-0.3575264811515808,
0.2609316408634186,
-0.043071676045656204,
-0.0690658688545227,
-0.0031313770450651646,
0.28448984026908875,
0.9088060259819031,
0.25745803117752075,
-0.21329589188098907,
0.17091797292232513,
-0.10172419250011444,
-0.1613428294658661,
-0.48932796716690063,
0.14127713441848755,
0.13976427912712097,
0.46946191787719727,
0.37210482358932495,
0.31599506735801697,
0.17973437905311584,
-0.40194329619407654,
0.3098992705345154,
0.1733384132385254,
-0.6421855092048645,
-0.598637580871582,
1.1245023012161255,
0.2535105049610138,
-0.7418932914733887,
0.6046090126037598,
-0.10234476625919342,
-0.530828595161438,
0.6865156292915344,
0.5451480746269226,
0.8673631548881531,
-0.5654692053794861,
-0.2654169201850891,
0.418038010597229,
0.23477429151535034,
0.05181411653757095,
0.002454529283568263,
-0.27271512150764465,
-0.9995089769363403,
-0.1723332554101944,
-0.4792482554912567,
-0.1267879158258438,
0.38932299613952637,
-0.8733724355697632,
0.285369873046875,
-0.5109602808952332,
-0.16004806756973267,
0.5147315859794617,
-0.34306854009628296,
-0.558784544467926,
0.1701626181602478,
0.6578302979469299,
0.5917629599571228,
-0.7086278796195984,
1.1472047567367554,
0.5270081758499146,
-0.29151102900505066,
-0.9014758467674255,
0.09542576223611832,
0.3106033504009247,
-0.7880344986915588,
0.5816380381584167,
-0.06990093737840652,
-0.23518313467502594,
0.057191360741853714,
-0.2313518226146698,
-0.5825446248054504,
0.519860565662384,
0.08817043155431747,
-0.7195456027984619,
0.06323633342981339,
0.3655130863189697,
0.559279203414917,
-0.17941544950008392,
0.011527947150170803,
0.9018787741661072,
0.41512855887413025,
-0.07206035405397415,
-1.0351943969726562,
-0.2281312346458435,
-0.1533564329147339,
-0.04435382038354874,
0.14643613994121552,
-0.6154083013534546,
0.7699048519134521,
-0.16187210381031036,
0.011132501997053623,
0.00018320573144592345,
0.657199501991272,
-0.04425959661602974,
0.06602640450000763,
0.645905613899231,
0.4082084894180298,
0.7636216878890991,
0.05713878571987152,
0.9066309332847595,
0.0596601665019989,
0.20903030037879944,
1.2793004512786865,
-0.21182338893413544,
0.6177739500999451,
0.4319141209125519,
-0.19315984845161438,
0.12991352379322052,
0.7970613837242126,
-0.000840537715703249,
0.5172836184501648,
0.4492420256137848,
-0.14120779931545258,
-0.179247185587883,
-0.5354591012001038,
-0.23503045737743378,
0.7838729023933411,
0.32051801681518555,
0.007364959456026554,
0.31189867854118347,
0.07615819573402405,
0.042061880230903625,
0.16856183111667633,
-0.3101915121078491,
0.8006933927536011,
0.19896197319030762,
-0.7228689193725586,
0.5095077753067017,
-0.13883532583713531,
0.5542521476745605,
-0.5512470006942749,
0.17958444356918335,
-0.21467941999435425,
0.21222755312919617,
-0.41983965039253235,
-0.7491567730903625,
0.17968302965164185,
-0.28256145119667053,
-0.5054567456245422,
-0.11325208097696304,
0.6989812254905701,
-0.816781759262085,
-0.0847863256931305,
0.43962788581848145,
0.21106746792793274,
0.09345121681690216,
-0.017633330076932907,
-0.42258498072624207,
0.013332042843103409,
0.2151620090007782,
-0.3733413815498352,
0.2841430604457855,
0.29647964239120483,
-0.15116067230701447,
0.33073434233665466,
0.41998833417892456,
0.3248252272605896,
0.1552651822566986,
0.6531844139099121,
0.3135899603366852,
-0.43219324946403503,
-0.58431476354599,
-0.7511966824531555,
0.2776981294155121,
0.4211325943470001,
-0.28783339262008667,
0.3867555558681488,
0.5084539651870728,
0.8852202892303467,
0.035189080983400345,
0.6306604743003845,
0.1724981665611267,
0.336376816034317,
-0.5311761498451233,
0.8226578831672668,
-0.4852631390094757,
0.18376706540584564,
0.2318490892648697,
-0.84294593334198,
-0.33680468797683716,
0.6332475543022156,
-0.09701894223690033,
-0.21429288387298584,
0.48185181617736816,
0.7572492361068726,
-0.018904510885477066,
-0.050101011991500854,
0.38678550720214844,
0.46136367321014404,
-0.05620269477367401,
0.3841756582260132,
1.0318012237548828,
-0.009366261772811413,
0.36055871844291687,
-0.5216425657272339,
0.03508143126964569,
0.05062151700258255,
-0.26859456300735474,
-0.7194928526878357,
-0.9067519903182983,
-0.16830001771450043,
-0.49954846501350403,
-0.11447342485189438,
1.1302834749221802,
0.8349611163139343,
-0.9281269907951355,
-0.5302562117576599,
-0.15840882062911987,
0.16528873145580292,
0.1432247906923294,
-0.23771779239177704,
0.24400919675827026,
-0.11772558838129044,
-0.5884857177734375,
0.6303143501281738,
-0.0038110853638499975,
0.19227054715156555,
-0.44185054302215576,
-0.12551862001419067,
0.2500114142894745,
0.05650606378912926,
0.2669356167316437,
0.444347083568573,
-0.9461966156959534,
-0.3156490921974182,
0.027906574308872223,
-0.09329269826412201,
0.2860562205314636,
1.1342178583145142,
-0.7697018384933472,
0.47206035256385803,
0.3657713234424591,
0.22153589129447937,
0.46845608949661255,
-0.1903483122587204,
0.5756485462188721,
-0.9631827473640442,
0.7115305662155151,
0.4580032229423523,
0.23307204246520996,
0.36709651350975037,
-0.38374537229537964,
0.2814125120639801,
0.22279225289821625,
-0.6622606515884399,
-0.7887383699417114,
0.45788946747779846,
-0.9221997857093811,
-0.39121919870376587,
1.3431698083877563,
0.41366812586784363,
-0.03750422224402428,
-0.009763947688043118,
-0.18770131468772888,
0.4367425739765167,
-0.3104581832885742,
0.45712214708328247,
0.5810400247573853,
-0.172054722905159,
-0.05995110422372818,
-0.6075014472007751,
0.7839170694351196,
0.4958035349845886,
-0.0024454782251268625,
0.18593336641788483,
0.5094850063323975,
0.32221078872680664,
0.06342443823814392,
0.4503522217273712,
0.1816793531179428,
0.280882328748703,
0.12082290649414062,
0.4537298381328583,
-0.011621305719017982,
-0.4041067361831665,
-0.8206542730331421,
-0.03263142332434654,
0.28958427906036377,
-0.2748173177242279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03004v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03004v1 | SemioLLM: Assessing Large Language Models for Semiological Analysis in Epilepsy Research | 2024-07-03T11:02:12 | 2024-07-03T11:02:12 | Meghal Dani, Muthu Jeyanthi Prakash, Zeynep Akata, Stefanie Liebe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models have shown promising results in their ability to encode
general medical knowledge in standard medical question-answering datasets.
However, their potential application in clinical practice requires evaluation
in domain-specific tasks, where benchmarks are largely missing. In this study
semioLLM, we test the ability of state-of-the-art LLMs (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Mixtral
8x7B, and Qwen-72chat) to leverage their internal knowledge and reasoning for
epilepsy diagnosis. Specifically, we obtain likelihood estimates linking
unstructured text descriptions of seizures to seizure-generating brain regions,
using an annotated clinical database containing 1269 entries. We evaluate the
LLM's performance, confidence, reasoning, and citation abilities in comparison
to clinical evaluation. Models achieve above-chance classification performance
with prompt engineering significantly improving their outcome, with some models
achieving close-to-clinical performance and reasoning. However, our analyses
also reveal significant pitfalls with several models being overly confident
while showing poor performance, as well as exhibiting citation errors and
hallucinations. In summary, our work provides the first extensive benchmark
comparing current SOTA LLMs in the medical domain of epilepsy and highlights
their ability to leverage unstructured texts from patients' medical history to
aid diagnostic processes in health care. | [
-0.25677740573883057,
-0.9415584206581116,
1.0766878128051758,
0.167856827378273,
-0.2109968513250351,
-0.11330610513687134,
-0.3835769295692444,
-0.7238804697990417,
0.20316945016384125,
0.4067682921886444,
0.01308961771428585,
-0.48826488852500916,
-0.5587316751480103,
0.28494396805763245,
-0.6958067417144775,
0.42270684242248535,
-0.24093063175678253,
0.2737719416618347,
-0.2892681360244751,
0.04405861347913742,
-0.07905235886573792,
-0.798019528388977,
-0.535808265209198,
-0.19385859370231628,
0.0031267611775547266,
-0.037659142166376114,
0.3746106028556824,
0.11693708598613739,
0.3882218301296234,
0.14815662801265717,
-0.4529981315135956,
0.16449326276779175,
-0.2424473613500595,
0.11019904911518097,
-0.02139294520020485,
-0.08360686153173447,
-0.42002812027931213,
-0.3067535161972046,
0.7169666290283203,
0.9570913314819336,
-0.3717593550682068,
-0.016382165253162384,
0.05718134716153145,
0.17865458130836487,
-0.3744969964027405,
-0.1588379144668579,
-0.26312410831451416,
0.2576419711112976,
-0.035149332135915756,
-0.36403319239616394,
-0.48895522952079773,
-0.35575559735298157,
0.37858325242996216,
-0.41385000944137573,
0.18284450471401215,
0.18328285217285156,
0.8075346350669861,
0.05336707457900047,
-0.5050958395004272,
-0.2738054096698761,
-0.6834911704063416,
0.44312992691993713,
-0.6580396294593811,
0.6543310284614563,
0.5350106954574585,
0.2005237191915512,
-0.22950556874275208,
-1.1237099170684814,
-0.43508338928222656,
-0.4846630394458771,
0.06389141082763672,
-0.028107834979891777,
-0.227422297000885,
0.19751474261283875,
0.3883495032787323,
0.22225990891456604,
-0.5459246039390564,
0.2282145917415619,
-0.4435799717903137,
-0.5888978838920593,
0.2932702600955963,
0.22155524790287018,
0.46370574831962585,
-0.10765141248703003,
-0.6295963525772095,
0.46161311864852905,
-0.7591821551322937,
-0.23325501382350922,
-0.0022169819567352533,
0.009005784057080746,
-0.005926314275711775,
0.6386467218399048,
0.1221853643655777,
0.608422577381134,
-0.03622406721115112,
0.11185456812381744,
0.10865999758243561,
-0.3708869218826294,
-0.19731684029102325,
0.3036615550518036,
0.6447452306747437,
0.6493327021598816,
0.13621939718723297,
-0.5082140564918518,
-0.12450399994850159,
-0.1906757652759552,
0.30619460344314575,
-0.9237159490585327,
-0.23804539442062378,
0.4514111280441284,
-0.5483449697494507,
-0.01309644803404808,
-0.46761950850486755,
-0.8044909238815308,
-0.807259202003479,
-0.1597469598054886,
0.5594031810760498,
-0.5498262643814087,
-0.15662434697151184,
0.4466211497783661,
-0.09746404737234116,
0.04126078635454178,
0.3781352937221527,
-0.6108399629592896,
0.49865278601646423,
0.2541033923625946,
0.8075947761535645,
-0.3057674467563629,
-0.11954015493392944,
-0.25863346457481384,
0.01524338684976101,
-0.24885642528533936,
0.9517397284507751,
-0.326275497674942,
-0.39484739303588867,
0.15037798881530762,
0.09646779298782349,
-0.3990550935268402,
-0.7212397456169128,
0.8645219802856445,
-0.4017379879951477,
-0.07480103522539139,
-0.2598055601119995,
-0.8874833583831787,
-0.17018923163414001,
0.07126064598560333,
-0.40907007455825806,
0.772622287273407,
-0.03724135458469391,
-0.658128023147583,
0.5025061964988708,
-0.2553640305995941,
-0.4856158494949341,
0.2205827534198761,
-0.3036858141422272,
-0.2890552580356598,
0.24787327647209167,
0.0803273394703865,
0.6694304943084717,
-0.6604793667793274,
0.40480634570121765,
-0.24658195674419403,
-0.1553676575422287,
0.37579038739204407,
-0.15671409666538239,
0.6358160376548767,
0.14943569898605347,
0.015465564094483852,
-0.13835321366786957,
-0.7386687994003296,
-0.01561659574508667,
0.2260752022266388,
-0.06490436941385269,
-0.5108203291893005,
0.002887558192014694,
0.09013479202985764,
-0.054276853799819946,
0.36059415340423584,
-0.5921527743339539,
-0.08784051239490509,
-0.32573917508125305,
0.4720381796360016,
0.3094927668571472,
0.3144891858100891,
-0.02572050876915455,
-0.23504066467285156,
0.42771968245506287,
0.03638116270303726,
0.1692197322845459,
-0.03525562211871147,
-0.5761560201644897,
-0.4024029076099396,
-0.4059430658817291,
0.5983210206031799,
0.19640158116817474,
-0.359356552362442,
0.3372270166873932,
-0.1559671312570572,
-0.1864870935678482,
-0.27027955651283264,
-0.3021166920661926,
0.08781450986862183,
0.6490693092346191,
0.5250712037086487,
-0.19836805760860443,
-0.46163326501846313,
-1.027207612991333,
-0.26573604345321655,
0.0036904625594615936,
-0.14133982360363007,
0.08906129747629166,
0.4938928782939911,
-0.12097925692796707,
0.489608496427536,
-0.19157211482524872,
-0.10717498511075974,
-0.24195879697799683,
0.08236974477767944,
0.0010612263577058911,
0.005823085084557533,
0.36240968108177185,
-0.5934421420097351,
-0.20255520939826965,
0.1836722046136856,
-1.004683256149292,
-0.10165867209434509,
0.1010906770825386,
0.32972317934036255,
-0.08613156527280807,
0.28696200251579285,
-0.5861555933952332,
0.298240065574646,
0.17523619532585144,
-0.6882908344268799,
0.5464431643486023,
-0.5689937472343445,
0.43116089701652527,
-0.9296179413795471,
-0.014891844242811203,
0.263651967048645,
-0.40164875984191895,
-0.703353226184845,
-0.07933096587657928,
0.31477606296539307,
0.0940779596567154,
-0.23796868324279785,
0.4391082227230072,
-0.37091296911239624,
-0.05466118082404137,
0.040050674229860306,
0.18481028079986572,
-0.19022339582443237,
0.08714508265256882,
-0.05696038901805878,
0.7231858968734741,
0.5364901423454285,
-0.5869008898735046,
-0.02972666546702385,
0.20772551000118256,
-0.46847525238990784,
0.2538406550884247,
-0.7789638042449951,
0.08458493649959564,
0.17419831454753876,
-0.20653745532035828,
-0.907660186290741,
-0.2757314443588257,
-0.4061492383480072,
-0.30655619502067566,
0.4008382260799408,
-0.21626892685890198,
-0.8551275134086609,
-0.09616755694150925,
-0.26073312759399414,
0.22849516570568085,
0.6679092049598694,
-0.4288012385368347,
0.6055259108543396,
0.6683380603790283,
-0.27628853917121887,
0.014231368899345398,
-0.47231945395469666,
0.2036363035440445,
-0.15837854146957397,
-0.6159235835075378,
0.43216416239738464,
0.31786859035491943,
-0.24978114664554596,
-0.17805692553520203,
-0.24283069372177124,
-0.07706093043088913,
0.19168439507484436,
-0.12493424862623215,
0.25805407762527466,
-0.11742857098579407,
0.12341761589050293,
0.2737487256526947,
0.1584569811820984,
0.26593127846717834,
-0.20129665732383728,
0.5308915972709656,
0.03234046697616577,
-0.32460156083106995,
-0.34161368012428284,
0.0842103660106659,
0.45610010623931885,
0.0796046108007431,
0.6796709299087524,
0.003897895570844412,
-0.8369323015213013,
-0.4278738498687744,
-0.4635302424430847,
-0.1697663962841034,
-0.3212009370326996,
0.33361703157424927,
-0.399882435798645,
-1.0357311964035034,
0.608224093914032,
-0.3823254108428955,
-0.3069536089897156,
0.36138561367988586,
0.7842938899993896,
-0.2048085331916809,
1.0143580436706543,
0.3357982039451599,
0.5928077697753906,
-0.08106138557195663,
-0.08691758662462234,
0.39898252487182617,
-0.8845182657241821,
-0.29647207260131836,
-0.5678067803382874,
0.1282361000776291,
-0.4322318732738495,
-0.3261697292327881,
0.6823990345001221,
0.11863002926111221,
-0.08621445298194885,
0.08214550465345383,
-0.40719708800315857,
0.19705204665660858,
-0.1600411832332611,
0.121970035135746,
0.413533091545105,
0.2714241147041321,
-0.5846786499023438,
-0.09199552237987518,
-0.532766580581665,
-0.8742097616195679,
1.390720248222351,
0.438327819108963,
0.7313941717147827,
-0.00019917065219487995,
0.34879809617996216,
0.550035297870636,
-0.12056466937065125,
-0.691096842288971,
0.6948874592781067,
-0.16517190635204315,
-0.47711578011512756,
-0.054264191538095474,
-0.25488579273223877,
-0.7850537300109863,
0.3256252110004425,
-0.039857346564531326,
-1.2038514614105225,
0.2780756950378418,
-0.1653570681810379,
-0.6489912867546082,
0.16881100833415985,
-0.7834791541099548,
0.8202329277992249,
-0.2237498015165329,
-0.35093697905540466,
-0.18039044737815857,
-0.3601132035255432,
0.3582887053489685,
-0.38869306445121765,
-0.11099279671907425,
0.10820602625608444,
-0.20252157747745514,
1.14520263671875,
-0.2594436705112457,
0.7363522052764893,
-0.14921823143959045,
-0.14456193149089813,
0.1894216239452362,
0.1676253080368042,
0.3560384511947632,
0.02766941860318184,
-0.03908857703208923,
0.46527621150016785,
0.5154317617416382,
-0.10364586114883423,
-0.4300704896450043,
0.7159883379936218,
-0.64631187915802,
-0.3362807333469391,
-0.5747814774513245,
-0.16341955959796906,
-0.7308935523033142,
0.13721607625484467,
0.16838262975215912,
0.7024767994880676,
-0.19487878680229187,
0.1187146008014679,
1.0614290237426758,
-0.111798956990242,
-0.027531463652849197,
0.5400477647781372,
-0.37896284461021423,
-0.26537588238716125,
0.5292415022850037,
0.26498955488204956,
0.117413230240345,
0.24509362876415253,
0.2171928584575653,
-0.6035493016242981,
-1.188001275062561,
-0.4273262321949005,
0.21413928270339966,
-0.8055863380432129,
0.1312149167060852,
-0.7505565881729126,
-0.2321246713399887,
-0.19501392543315887,
0.2565208077430725,
-0.19858525693416595,
-0.5834150314331055,
0.05244822055101395,
-0.20995193719863892,
0.1714930683374405,
0.593840479850769,
0.3880150318145752,
-0.09590209275484085,
-0.7787990570068359,
0.2651238441467285,
-0.05515521019697189,
0.11736839264631271,
-0.038304753601551056,
-0.8023951649665833,
-0.2613365650177002,
-0.10046672075986862,
-0.08047936111688614,
-1.0042743682861328,
0.11645025759935379,
-0.017058532685041428,
0.6288086771965027,
0.24712510406970978,
0.02515757642686367,
0.44350478053092957,
-0.43015241622924805,
0.787279486656189,
0.19763483107089996,
-0.5924956798553467,
0.3851046562194824,
-0.16290287673473358,
-0.36043211817741394,
0.41614654660224915,
0.6680608987808228,
-0.16970473527908325,
-0.1622219979763031,
-0.56879723072052,
-0.6894545555114746,
0.4249196946620941,
0.3531131148338318,
-0.3903125822544098,
-0.027805041521787643,
0.4568321704864502,
0.1939290314912796,
0.013739559799432755,
-0.06766262650489807,
-0.13803920149803162,
0.2434512972831726,
-0.32605162262916565,
0.021540198475122452,
-0.4496268332004547,
-0.3550591766834259,
-0.4118783175945282,
0.3648850917816162,
-0.1753454953432083,
0.64906907081604,
0.5039505958557129,
-0.21328236162662506,
-0.06210070103406906,
0.2693159878253937,
0.5063595771789551,
0.9752684831619263,
-0.14161211252212524,
0.381041556596756,
0.4888969659805298,
-0.6934025883674622,
0.15387675166130066,
0.4374677240848541,
-0.29812294244766235,
-0.032020021229982376,
0.4338413178920746,
0.541589617729187,
0.08519820123910904,
-0.8302201628684998,
0.5105646848678589,
-0.23665902018547058,
-0.17762158811092377,
-0.3220164179801941,
-0.2128143310546875,
0.17095519602298737,
0.23055580258369446,
0.401753306388855,
-0.0021740589290857315,
0.3590018153190613,
-0.34064722061157227,
0.12418508529663086,
0.33290818333625793,
-0.1886720508337021,
-0.7477541565895081,
0.7013798952102661,
0.021623332053422928,
-0.05527730658650398,
0.3221778869628906,
-0.22506223618984222,
-0.5312986969947815,
0.5539369583129883,
0.7676157355308533,
0.9107716083526611,
0.13634516298770905,
-0.0470261424779892,
0.2525423467159271,
0.45001450181007385,
-0.21291875839233398,
0.5467249751091003,
0.07912550866603851,
-0.7822391986846924,
-0.38552600145339966,
-0.7894818782806396,
-0.25998300313949585,
0.3363339304924011,
-0.48043718934059143,
0.2493334263563156,
-0.48776379227638245,
-0.4254860579967499,
0.1598990112543106,
-0.09963192045688629,
-0.45862191915512085,
0.23757028579711914,
0.07138649374246597,
0.9616625308990479,
-0.5935350060462952,
0.5902334451675415,
1.1771260499954224,
-0.3983595371246338,
-0.5681062936782837,
0.29258590936660767,
-0.2996019124984741,
-0.7153840661048889,
0.31725001335144043,
-0.11277267336845398,
-0.06480992585420609,
0.015019455924630165,
-0.44915053248405457,
-0.37658414244651794,
0.883968710899353,
0.3311588764190674,
-0.5480943918228149,
-0.08570560067892075,
0.030008895322680473,
0.7822139859199524,
-0.23341397941112518,
0.3847403824329376,
0.6360365152359009,
0.29734209179878235,
-0.07933012396097183,
-1.110783338546753,
0.37053847312927246,
-0.023396305739879608,
-0.09364914894104004,
0.33230704069137573,
-0.3677883446216583,
0.49982261657714844,
-0.19786055386066437,
-0.39052021503448486,
0.008388780988752842,
0.4395201504230499,
0.26741015911102295,
0.4667811989784241,
0.20676492154598236,
0.6054865717887878,
1.0224844217300415,
-0.08405368030071259,
1.2101842164993286,
-0.5174797773361206,
0.46033036708831787,
0.7400214672088623,
-0.7193307876586914,
0.7812443375587463,
0.5585747957229614,
-0.4911438226699829,
0.030792757868766785,
0.7442657947540283,
0.271601140499115,
0.4988926649093628,
0.019395917654037476,
-0.33591428399086,
-0.6346821188926697,
-0.26671546697616577,
-0.3770714998245239,
-0.012813313864171505,
0.3715967535972595,
-0.40505361557006836,
-0.222059965133667,
0.060736436396837234,
-0.1149917021393776,
-0.031725767999887466,
-0.11369327455759048,
0.6015488505363464,
0.35301652550697327,
-0.21158339083194733,
0.6313026547431946,
0.09413222223520279,
0.2095397263765335,
-0.546464204788208,
-0.0059830909594893456,
-0.0865442156791687,
0.18739371001720428,
-0.13766182959079742,
-0.7145853638648987,
0.06909675896167755,
0.30665266513824463,
0.17762978374958038,
0.0902121290564537,
0.8796863555908203,
0.010244861245155334,
-0.4053206741809845,
0.43672889471054077,
0.5189693570137024,
0.3200136423110962,
0.12197855114936829,
-0.2577076554298401,
-0.05051323398947716,
-0.178467258810997,
-0.27936843037605286,
0.541948676109314,
0.5453751683235168,
-0.27886560559272766,
0.5944870710372925,
0.2887085974216461,
0.39014947414398193,
0.1578078716993332,
0.30624252557754517,
0.743848443031311,
-0.6223916411399841,
-0.1915009319782257,
-0.7609290480613708,
0.1776963770389557,
-0.19545245170593262,
-0.4031231701374054,
0.7168179154396057,
0.6477526426315308,
0.6673120260238647,
0.11049214750528336,
0.903830349445343,
-0.09041397273540497,
0.5199544429779053,
-0.6649706363677979,
0.7031021118164062,
-0.5814851522445679,
0.2522433400154114,
0.34148943424224854,
-0.56815505027771,
-0.24878619611263275,
0.48003509640693665,
-0.33595219254493713,
0.19249552488327026,
1.1699919700622559,
0.5753301978111267,
-0.13680604100227356,
0.43655839562416077,
0.5687501430511475,
0.6133933067321777,
0.10912377387285233,
0.4229491651058197,
1.2345596551895142,
-0.31800514459609985,
-0.0534302182495594,
-0.06323209404945374,
-0.2205759584903717,
-0.15337474644184113,
-0.5833024978637695,
-1.1055324077606201,
-0.5263711810112,
-0.3252795338630676,
-0.34325897693634033,
0.3475049138069153,
0.9563192129135132,
0.41076356172561646,
-0.8257253766059875,
0.051786839962005615,
0.21877992153167725,
-0.15633931756019592,
-0.2306959629058838,
-0.09039819240570068,
0.5285003185272217,
-0.1888056844472885,
-0.32885730266571045,
0.5829604268074036,
0.3951040208339691,
-0.03246832638978958,
-0.27841290831565857,
0.07921391725540161,
-0.01350085437297821,
-0.0010576362255960703,
0.6631115674972534,
-0.12359458953142166,
-0.6261386871337891,
-0.17387422919273376,
0.038059052079916,
-0.09868486225605011,
-0.18656165897846222,
0.7829747200012207,
-0.5658593773841858,
0.467819482088089,
0.5111214518547058,
0.7274147272109985,
0.5064453482627869,
-0.12311746925115585,
0.3506945073604584,
-0.020126014947891235,
-0.3476593792438507,
0.4458763003349304,
0.7014404535293579,
0.2213984876871109,
-0.2891559302806854,
0.40531203150749207,
0.24895688891410828,
-0.5913041830062866,
-0.9587311744689941,
-0.24901525676250458,
-0.8640709519386292,
-0.13685809075832367,
1.13766610622406,
-0.20509210228919983,
-0.30898386240005493,
-0.4695360064506531,
-0.1139717847108841,
0.021624522283673286,
-0.19984769821166992,
0.762451171875,
0.7303106784820557,
-0.302161306142807,
0.17636439204216003,
-0.9554412364959717,
0.4393449127674103,
0.337756872177124,
-0.7023244500160217,
-0.06991750001907349,
0.3939058780670166,
0.36113154888153076,
-0.03699411451816559,
0.6615145802497864,
-0.29935207962989807,
0.32880082726478577,
-0.09179577976465225,
0.13092954456806183,
-0.022582652047276497,
-0.3477132022380829,
-0.5702283978462219,
0.3855031132698059,
0.279815137386322,
0.002575177699327469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03000v1 | VIVA: A Benchmark for Vision-Grounded Decision-Making with Human Values | 2024-07-03T10:59:06 | 2024-07-03T10:59:06 | Zhe Hu, Yixiao Ren, Jing Li, Yu Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper introduces VIVA, a benchmark for VIsion-grounded decision-making
driven by human VAlues. While most large vision-language models (VLMs) focus on
physical-level skills, our work is the first to examine their multimodal
capabilities in leveraging human values to make decisions under a
vision-depicted situation. VIVA contains 1,062 images depicting diverse
real-world situations and the manually annotated decisions grounded in them.
Given an image there, the model should select the most appropriate action to
address the situation and provide the relevant human values and reason
underlying the decision. Extensive experiments based on VIVA show the
limitation of VLMs in using human values to make multimodal decisions. Further
analyses indicate the potential benefits of exploiting action consequences and
predicted human values. | [
-0.4538736343383789,
-0.28201213479042053,
0.6815069913864136,
0.2275591492652893,
-0.23513451218605042,
0.01773841306567192,
0.11750616878271103,
-0.5275126099586487,
0.21828098595142365,
0.4597543478012085,
-0.4819059371948242,
-0.2989921271800995,
-0.18603567779064178,
-0.24072474241256714,
-0.2832881212234497,
0.36743107438087463,
0.4427984952926636,
0.05008507892489433,
-0.39144229888916016,
-0.4063531756401062,
-0.7193117737770081,
-0.39376145601272583,
-0.25442537665367126,
-0.12384741008281708,
0.8436164855957031,
0.4117946922779083,
0.6754273772239685,
0.41460496187210083,
0.2875080406665802,
0.23431095480918884,
-0.10269665718078613,
0.1997266709804535,
-0.4024038314819336,
-0.1123860627412796,
-0.3476957082748413,
-0.3011285662651062,
-0.5708558559417725,
0.26095151901245117,
0.6056840419769287,
0.5099689960479736,
0.08331573009490967,
0.5764634609222412,
-0.27354198694229126,
0.6955864429473877,
-0.9367337822914124,
0.2119312733411789,
-0.5739357471466064,
0.07536815851926804,
-0.0921802744269371,
-0.0850997194647789,
-0.36037546396255493,
-0.7162532210350037,
0.1221853718161583,
-0.5012614130973816,
-0.15629443526268005,
-0.029590224847197533,
1.4224276542663574,
0.5548193454742432,
-0.6969037055969238,
0.5362065434455872,
-0.8291172385215759,
0.7311035394668579,
-0.12418878823518753,
0.5982705950737,
0.3464919328689575,
0.7470579743385315,
0.22854183614253998,
-0.6742342710494995,
-0.5530083179473877,
0.15898799896240234,
0.29230567812919617,
0.3355093002319336,
0.12521050870418549,
0.10330832004547119,
0.3478020429611206,
-0.12853775918483734,
-0.0023997181560844183,
-0.06784874945878983,
-0.748168408870697,
-0.030905282124876976,
0.6816049218177795,
0.4222697913646698,
-0.04628954827785492,
-0.23756560683250427,
-0.7152816653251648,
-0.6538102030754089,
-0.8554523587226868,
0.728297770023346,
0.06864280253648758,
0.0008077837992459536,
0.3552102744579315,
0.6473391056060791,
-0.6235333681106567,
0.8423938155174255,
-0.3871397078037262,
-0.43866196274757385,
0.2965444326400757,
-0.35354846715927124,
-0.3426467478275299,
-0.10968790203332901,
0.12019845843315125,
1.138973355293274,
0.5466370582580566,
0.23197196424007416,
-0.05057121440768242,
0.3823661506175995,
0.5498532056808472,
-0.7496539950370789,
0.14615997672080994,
-0.1650567203760147,
-0.633542001247406,
-0.43052539229393005,
0.1335606575012207,
-1.2399636507034302,
-0.5425264239311218,
-0.6265869736671448,
0.7048627138137817,
-0.38200101256370544,
-0.03223777934908867,
0.2101009339094162,
-0.32278433442115784,
0.8712007403373718,
0.7167203426361084,
-0.47441747784614563,
0.21084575355052948,
0.397452712059021,
0.4189169704914093,
0.07718482613563538,
-0.546220064163208,
-0.6508426070213318,
-0.1898512989282608,
-0.5743554830551147,
1.0150038003921509,
-0.538533091545105,
-0.34032249450683594,
-0.11526531726121902,
-0.277917742729187,
-0.009373664855957031,
-0.50502610206604,
0.9723770618438721,
-0.3650769293308258,
-0.28475210070610046,
-0.946510910987854,
-0.12758928537368774,
-0.6507993340492249,
0.19571012258529663,
-0.6079384684562683,
1.0554652214050293,
0.17139483988285065,
-0.3234907388687134,
1.4361763000488281,
-0.48071107268333435,
-0.24243289232254028,
0.299989253282547,
-0.3986544609069824,
-0.4407692849636078,
0.2716650664806366,
-0.21946310997009277,
0.3288014829158783,
-0.3283999264240265,
0.24883824586868286,
-0.3763050138950348,
-0.3129802644252777,
0.3687112629413605,
-0.6357510089874268,
0.4652057886123657,
0.0893026739358902,
-0.3163191080093384,
0.4310297667980194,
-0.8594855666160583,
0.3533923327922821,
-0.1135980635881424,
-0.48764246702194214,
-0.36912068724632263,
0.5141187310218811,
0.21885663270950317,
0.8697750568389893,
-0.04329528659582138,
-0.4353032112121582,
0.011037793010473251,
0.09752470999956131,
-0.025852734223008156,
0.6999010443687439,
-0.28718823194503784,
-0.11441388726234436,
-0.2246384620666504,
0.33581048250198364,
-0.086191825568676,
0.5192630887031555,
-0.262175053358078,
-0.754916787147522,
-0.9000345468521118,
-0.5024009943008423,
0.21220260858535767,
0.5377499461174011,
-0.5549485683441162,
0.031062185764312744,
-0.34875407814979553,
-0.3442361354827881,
-0.8124504089355469,
-0.15473943948745728,
0.3499441146850586,
0.8085294961929321,
0.43090182542800903,
-0.10539540648460388,
-0.5048564672470093,
-1.214121699333191,
-0.10702549666166306,
-0.2682962715625763,
0.19649964570999146,
0.5649797916412354,
0.5997478365898132,
-0.2655538320541382,
1.3824020624160767,
-0.5027048587799072,
-0.2608613967895508,
0.13237793743610382,
0.3291328251361847,
-0.12512236833572388,
-0.047422491014003754,
0.7588409781455994,
-1.3715240955352783,
-0.20943139493465424,
-0.06635106354951859,
-0.7590377330780029,
-0.045948222279548645,
-0.11567043513059616,
0.004024100489914417,
0.01956680417060852,
0.17342832684516907,
-0.2707569897174835,
1.2278833389282227,
0.159112349152565,
-0.8855545520782471,
0.7083043456077576,
-0.39684295654296875,
0.6341356635093689,
-0.5795458555221558,
0.3793885111808777,
-0.0264657661318779,
-0.4197999835014343,
-0.5428749322891235,
-0.18901008367538452,
0.4222187101840973,
-0.15352290868759155,
-0.8742443323135376,
0.6955433487892151,
-0.04920071363449097,
-0.6653968691825867,
-0.17335285246372223,
-0.367931067943573,
0.20401272177696228,
0.21454282104969025,
0.5117552876472473,
0.8380773067474365,
0.35819879174232483,
-0.8453052043914795,
0.4808415472507477,
0.28096863627433777,
-0.45499399304389954,
1.291288137435913,
-0.6195949912071228,
-0.3993954360485077,
-0.3119828999042511,
-0.16684985160827637,
-0.7348167896270752,
-0.2996984124183655,
-0.3175082206726074,
-0.30996978282928467,
-0.4205312430858612,
-0.1288847178220749,
-0.3683938980102539,
-0.5949582457542419,
-0.3114062547683716,
0.35212621092796326,
0.651346743106842,
-0.43634289503097534,
0.8807293176651001,
0.4344351887702942,
0.20373573899269104,
-0.5030778050422668,
-0.4201040267944336,
0.3896160125732422,
-0.6100688576698303,
-0.7733686566352844,
0.25251004099845886,
-0.13486482203006744,
-0.5013976693153381,
-0.12228432297706604,
0.21129554510116577,
-0.11613442748785019,
0.11448149383068085,
0.7293050289154053,
0.4043484628200531,
0.020280957221984863,
-0.17476767301559448,
-0.1199379712343216,
-0.4066116511821747,
-0.09736084192991257,
-0.08653772622346878,
0.21914605796337128,
-0.6311324834823608,
-0.46653100848197937,
-0.31684115529060364,
0.2808523178100586,
1.0759191513061523,
-0.4680236876010895,
0.5624254941940308,
0.5205584168434143,
-0.3906709849834442,
0.11763570457696915,
-0.7672056555747986,
0.014206569641828537,
-0.458208829164505,
0.0448957234621048,
-0.4449402987957001,
-0.29837843775749207,
0.47580721974372864,
-0.23311328887939453,
-0.1347850114107132,
0.26607465744018555,
0.6261861324310303,
-0.3306502401828766,
0.8534982204437256,
0.5302425026893616,
0.33473876118659973,
0.3171073794364929,
0.012289530597627163,
-0.19610300660133362,
-0.6732760071754456,
-0.6318371295928955,
-0.2522679269313812,
-0.49776485562324524,
-0.11021732538938522,
-0.6848256587982178,
0.8011820316314697,
-0.21284352242946625,
-0.1295989751815796,
0.09539530426263809,
-0.25040704011917114,
0.3066360056400299,
0.8713464736938477,
0.1882925182580948,
0.08065689355134964,
-0.4790767729282379,
-0.28460001945495605,
-0.20543289184570312,
-0.3787486255168915,
-0.47195225954055786,
0.8273282647132874,
0.2021026760339737,
0.5922727584838867,
-0.18315306305885315,
0.29145458340644836,
0.32873570919036865,
0.15365976095199585,
-0.7266448140144348,
0.7639980316162109,
0.28047069907188416,
-0.7170290350914001,
-0.07416966557502747,
-0.10286235809326172,
-1.0406612157821655,
0.599216639995575,
-0.6223794221878052,
-0.5958256125450134,
0.5906933546066284,
0.07302739471197128,
-0.7911972403526306,
0.23517538607120514,
-0.6672316789627075,
1.0469346046447754,
-0.6470018029212952,
-0.738457441329956,
-0.4644187092781067,
-0.746515691280365,
0.19154296815395355,
0.15840238332748413,
0.25201860070228577,
-0.19625569880008698,
-0.034913115203380585,
0.5128836035728455,
-0.047096773982048035,
0.8339712023735046,
-0.2742235064506531,
0.3913210928440094,
0.3771090805530548,
-0.028368987143039703,
0.06039430946111679,
-0.04020444303750992,
0.021818554028868675,
-0.1570148915052414,
0.12171756476163864,
-0.24804185330867767,
-0.08041395992040634,
0.26070675253868103,
-0.5518890023231506,
-0.12736639380455017,
-0.6268136501312256,
-0.15823538601398468,
-0.19214285910129547,
0.30840378999710083,
0.06607670336961746,
0.4334748089313507,
-0.6415029168128967,
0.3962517976760864,
0.725316047668457,
-0.4897324740886688,
0.643937349319458,
0.5232318043708801,
-0.5905242562294006,
-0.5650307536125183,
0.8706861734390259,
0.16042505204677582,
0.2640036940574646,
0.03967452421784401,
0.2667256295681,
-0.39379099011421204,
-0.22976256906986237,
-0.4405380189418793,
-0.10046874731779099,
-0.8123297095298767,
-0.1806156486272812,
-0.2449050396680832,
0.05108553543686867,
0.04153395816683769,
-0.31469881534576416,
-0.6355478763580322,
-0.0036032984498888254,
-0.035848814994096756,
-0.25889843702316284,
0.2592475712299347,
0.5760671496391296,
-0.07991129904985428,
-0.2921654284000397,
-0.6813293099403381,
0.6641046404838562,
0.9882040023803711,
0.5111286044120789,
-0.43030089139938354,
-0.020315470173954964,
-0.19921660423278809,
0.05751523748040199,
-0.12914210557937622,
-0.7960795760154724,
0.5175135135650635,
0.010291874408721924,
0.7152095437049866,
0.6640444993972778,
0.046719443053007126,
0.9171451926231384,
-0.43185746669769287,
0.6050376296043396,
0.05166977643966675,
-0.8714343905448914,
0.7811970114707947,
-0.4409253001213074,
0.0664307251572609,
0.9892272353172302,
-0.05270565673708916,
-0.46428486704826355,
0.5370733141899109,
-0.6027973294258118,
-0.7380695343017578,
0.4777994155883789,
0.007471855264157057,
-0.19307877123355865,
0.13183443248271942,
0.17153804004192352,
-0.00818641483783722,
0.46643006801605225,
-0.6251184940338135,
0.09324224293231964,
-0.378864586353302,
0.2979668378829956,
0.07947228103876114,
-0.2826880216598511,
-0.1607733964920044,
-0.696674108505249,
-0.06780090928077698,
-0.3966156840324402,
0.08747386187314987,
0.2611096203327179,
-0.07354962080717087,
-0.06411904841661453,
0.10555722564458847,
0.8464391231536865,
0.8142853379249573,
-0.40013808012008667,
0.17591789364814758,
0.5062142610549927,
-0.13419021666049957,
0.044355422258377075,
-0.23191501200199127,
-0.22731536626815796,
-0.4222905933856964,
-0.0815616175532341,
0.8416788578033447,
0.4508506655693054,
-1.1454875469207764,
0.6749802231788635,
0.0585792176425457,
-0.11880269646644592,
-0.3581450879573822,
0.0833970457315445,
-0.15698395669460297,
0.36065295338630676,
0.3788323700428009,
0.3688898980617523,
0.1614593118429184,
-0.6676766872406006,
0.34995347261428833,
0.2885717451572418,
-0.62654048204422,
-0.46338140964508057,
0.918275773525238,
0.36387622356414795,
-0.13821031153202057,
0.514706552028656,
-0.1865738034248352,
-0.6293884515762329,
0.4524439573287964,
0.01334353443235159,
0.828195333480835,
-0.04200281202793121,
0.48684069514274597,
0.32043716311454773,
0.21130765974521637,
-0.21185988187789917,
0.707942545413971,
-0.0267653688788414,
-0.7204293012619019,
-0.2640571594238281,
-0.5901215076446533,
-0.637928307056427,
-0.3762856721878052,
-0.8223249912261963,
0.5190913677215576,
-0.4641629457473755,
-0.26676738262176514,
-0.13728958368301392,
-0.13791118562221527,
-0.9752827286720276,
0.7110190391540527,
0.599020779132843,
0.8193013668060303,
-0.9860547780990601,
1.0233362913131714,
0.5719910264015198,
-0.5239236354827881,
-0.3203094005584717,
-0.3411426246166229,
0.14142511785030365,
-0.6727762818336487,
1.1981250047683716,
0.21403950452804565,
-0.508805513381958,
-0.28968170285224915,
-0.3126886188983917,
-0.6953601241111755,
1.3751381635665894,
0.3893095850944519,
0.08757302165031433,
0.0795711949467659,
0.10330159217119217,
0.4657284915447235,
-0.25341570377349854,
0.16422376036643982,
0.6059888005256653,
0.9042873382568359,
0.29480287432670593,
-1.0522490739822388,
-0.44647666811943054,
-0.16407565772533417,
-0.03183895722031593,
-0.007500065956264734,
-0.7860256433486938,
1.0440727472305298,
-0.26484131813049316,
-0.11102070659399033,
-0.25951793789863586,
0.529398500919342,
0.23811553418636322,
0.468527615070343,
0.6571505069732666,
0.6514468789100647,
0.8130207061767578,
-0.20382104814052582,
1.121227502822876,
0.10065317153930664,
0.06238501891493797,
0.5804229378700256,
-0.6163305640220642,
1.0279200077056885,
0.29566332697868347,
-0.12125983834266663,
0.4440634548664093,
0.44243404269218445,
0.006711397785693407,
0.6337310671806335,
-0.3071863353252411,
-0.14512623846530914,
-0.7703857421875,
-0.17121686041355133,
-0.20141248404979706,
1.0066883563995361,
0.5051378607749939,
-0.039260383695364,
-0.14952407777309418,
0.07131163030862808,
-0.13775333762168884,
0.1176946833729744,
-0.3687857687473297,
0.6784659624099731,
-0.2347480207681656,
-0.8238834142684937,
0.406917542219162,
-0.10710751265287399,
0.3054458498954773,
-0.4959811270236969,
-0.15583311021327972,
0.3320954442024231,
0.33745720982551575,
-0.034805718809366226,
-1.2011185884475708,
0.3890793025493622,
-0.15108835697174072,
-0.1828024536371231,
-0.7079275846481323,
0.8830198645591736,
0.06824975460767746,
-0.45250919461250305,
0.48563870787620544,
0.31619971990585327,
-0.1192348301410675,
-0.352047324180603,
-0.43665188550949097,
0.07087577134370804,
-0.3701942563056946,
-0.10036103427410126,
0.3066878020763397,
0.40970200300216675,
-0.31090202927589417,
0.9545481204986572,
0.6092438101768494,
-0.0744587704539299,
0.2752944827079773,
-0.1316968947649002,
0.8392314910888672,
-1.1807188987731934,
-0.568800151348114,
-0.7052948474884033,
0.8340673446655273,
-0.32712075114250183,
-0.6594802737236023,
0.5758532881736755,
0.627968430519104,
0.3317822515964508,
0.00018700618238653988,
0.6737760901451111,
-0.01702573522925377,
0.33419856429100037,
-0.5004671812057495,
0.47386541962623596,
-0.6812034845352173,
-0.10868628323078156,
-0.2942812740802765,
-0.6258985996246338,
-0.2791321277618408,
0.8471353054046631,
-0.2717718780040741,
-0.05536820739507675,
0.2751183807849884,
0.38911810517311096,
0.10578090697526932,
-0.2470804750919342,
0.7665829062461853,
-0.3011426627635956,
0.22251318395137787,
0.4562414884567261,
0.9953779578208923,
-0.1689833700656891,
0.2732507288455963,
-0.05108996853232384,
-0.37639570236206055,
-0.6963374614715576,
-1.081748366355896,
-0.9271433353424072,
-0.7726455926895142,
-0.09690997004508972,
-0.32305458188056946,
-0.08194515854120255,
1.0319876670837402,
1.1300240755081177,
-0.38170555233955383,
-0.1560644507408142,
0.354594349861145,
0.13959945738315582,
-0.7148444652557373,
-0.10820826888084412,
0.08541315048933029,
-0.034864816814661026,
-0.3871834874153137,
0.5710429549217224,
0.6957823634147644,
-0.050453148782253265,
-0.2759624719619751,
-0.15108896791934967,
-0.2676295042037964,
0.36631450057029724,
0.8988155126571655,
0.5632963180541992,
-0.7917519211769104,
-0.5631808042526245,
0.10718759894371033,
-0.00045156004489399493,
0.34544122219085693,
0.698754072189331,
-1.3957628011703491,
0.7195898294448853,
0.513759195804596,
0.3553685247898102,
0.6694046854972839,
0.22728973627090454,
0.48466065526008606,
-0.3813615143299103,
0.1820959895849228,
0.3408769369125366,
0.5471308827400208,
0.17126621305942535,
0.20904801785945892,
0.46316948533058167,
0.40412089228630066,
-0.33993300795555115,
-0.6804521083831787,
0.22273726761341095,
-1.3357384204864502,
-0.08628878742456436,
1.1879122257232666,
0.08265972882509232,
-0.32214120030403137,
-0.04411991685628891,
-0.5816164612770081,
-0.3272201120853424,
-0.10936171561479568,
0.7623204588890076,
0.4654841423034668,
0.06019685044884682,
-0.34987014532089233,
-0.7256755232810974,
0.5107722282409668,
0.2135997712612152,
-1.0840001106262207,
-0.018751081079244614,
0.7979982495307922,
0.011219244450330734,
0.050927162170410156,
0.28249189257621765,
0.0008918446837924421,
0.6409556865692139,
0.24143853783607483,
0.2765028774738312,
-0.020482137799263,
-0.8952777981758118,
-0.14542454481124878,
0.3632485866546631,
0.1615370661020279,
-0.30364009737968445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02996v1 | Are Large Language Models Consistent over Value-laden Questions? | 2024-07-03T10:53:54 | 2024-07-03T10:53:54 | Jared Moore, Tanvi Deshpande, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) appear to bias their survey answers toward
certain values. Nonetheless, some argue that LLMs are too inconsistent to
simulate particular values. Are they? To answer, we first define value
consistency as the similarity of answers across (1) paraphrases of one
question, (2) related questions under one topic, (3) multiple-choice and
open-ended use-cases of one question, and (4) multilingual translations of a
question to English, Chinese, German, and Japanese. We apply these measures to
a few large ($>=34b$), open LLMs including llama-3, as well as gpt-4o, using
eight thousand questions spanning more than 300 topics. Unlike prior work, we
find that models are relatively consistent across paraphrases, use-cases,
translations, and within a topic. Still, some inconsistencies remain. Models
are more consistent on uncontroversial topics (e.g., in the U.S.,
"Thanksgiving") than on controversial ones ("euthanasia"). Base models are both
more consistent compared to fine-tuned models and are uniform in their
consistency across topics, while fine-tuned models are more inconsistent about
some topics ("euthanasia") than others ("women's rights") like our human
subjects (n=165). | [
-0.1214296966791153,
-0.8399001955986023,
0.8422325253486633,
0.1917991042137146,
-0.1741250902414322,
-0.22987577319145203,
-0.30171698331832886,
-0.6562113761901855,
0.2417072206735611,
0.6586331725120544,
-0.19551977515220642,
-0.08269831538200378,
-0.7192477583885193,
0.18386420607566833,
-0.4351215064525604,
1.0823040008544922,
-0.19185347855091095,
0.24133987724781036,
-0.23349718749523163,
-0.49907466769218445,
-0.17971786856651306,
-0.7344592809677124,
-0.3608679175376892,
-0.34589487314224243,
0.6223214268684387,
0.07359166443347931,
0.9888748526573181,
0.6568713784217834,
0.474037230014801,
0.20245736837387085,
-0.410185843706131,
0.061970304697752,
-0.5933129787445068,
0.21625664830207825,
-0.2706722617149353,
-0.4538504481315613,
-0.4252278506755829,
0.23648573458194733,
0.626101553440094,
1.009521245956421,
-0.20507729053497314,
0.11436411738395691,
0.11430720239877701,
0.35636019706726074,
-0.5421951413154602,
-0.05828261747956276,
-0.8913353681564331,
-0.297146737575531,
-0.013861254788935184,
0.18086053431034088,
-0.2671908140182495,
-0.5955731868743896,
-0.012324140407145023,
-0.40063953399658203,
-0.23207269608974457,
-0.16831804811954498,
1.237923502922058,
0.1817777454853058,
-0.5904790163040161,
-0.33092260360717773,
-0.7507347464561462,
1.050689697265625,
-0.9713982343673706,
0.26924532651901245,
0.54725182056427,
0.01776852458715439,
-0.24073472619056702,
-0.39880993962287903,
-0.6373574733734131,
-0.39351218938827515,
0.1487424224615097,
0.03321100026369095,
-0.2420935481786728,
-0.012127197347581387,
0.46197864413261414,
0.46328064799308777,
-0.4073352813720703,
0.2927634119987488,
-0.17633090913295746,
-0.04559573903679848,
0.7304427027702332,
0.4217100143432617,
0.3431814908981323,
-0.2282545566558838,
-0.32222670316696167,
0.04172191396355629,
-0.9283502101898193,
0.2125883549451828,
0.3885052800178528,
0.27205729484558105,
-0.005429365206509829,
0.893356442451477,
-0.17360174655914307,
0.6891053318977356,
0.12684020400047302,
-0.4608900547027588,
0.14570041000843048,
-0.5330327153205872,
-0.15948998928070068,
-0.29038992524147034,
0.7968385219573975,
0.5546749234199524,
0.7771357297897339,
0.0055165826342999935,
-0.2809499502182007,
-0.06043567880988121,
0.20595431327819824,
-0.7176346778869629,
0.002712012967094779,
0.36350905895233154,
-0.3252691924571991,
-0.0848076120018959,
-0.06106788292527199,
-0.26987406611442566,
-0.20246411859989166,
-0.3396843373775482,
0.447282999753952,
-0.08171391487121582,
-0.3320234715938568,
0.2336748093366623,
0.25806504487991333,
0.29605016112327576,
0.458465576171875,
-1.0480331182479858,
0.1820688545703888,
0.6876847743988037,
0.6347604990005493,
-0.5270465016365051,
-0.36121851205825806,
-0.28226181864738464,
0.05602177977561951,
-0.5728659629821777,
0.7505782246589661,
-0.6286605596542358,
-0.4462808668613434,
0.023001939058303833,
0.08597899228334427,
0.08526883274316788,
-0.6741465926170349,
0.16756077110767365,
-0.5968788862228394,
0.08483312278985977,
-0.8688107132911682,
-0.7489561438560486,
0.15026365220546722,
0.765672504901886,
-0.663631021976471,
0.9446485638618469,
0.06575300544500351,
-0.6795657277107239,
0.3587695062160492,
-0.09841035306453705,
-0.08825217932462692,
-0.3091057240962982,
-0.45864757895469666,
-0.3264768123626709,
0.04962410777807236,
-0.2152232974767685,
0.3470861315727234,
-0.4785093069076538,
0.5259027481079102,
-0.5990330576896667,
-0.505707323551178,
0.5571017265319824,
-0.6725299954414368,
0.730719268321991,
0.19256332516670227,
-0.22604835033416748,
-0.1097240298986435,
-0.5635069012641907,
0.1967213749885559,
0.10570723563432693,
-0.3717469871044159,
-0.35178202390670776,
-0.14443857967853546,
0.009761032648384571,
0.3352721929550171,
0.3416810929775238,
-0.5834069848060608,
0.36358535289764404,
-0.1279124766588211,
0.3429989516735077,
0.7518475651741028,
0.0798550546169281,
0.3246089518070221,
-0.6484346389770508,
0.5512131452560425,
0.11636185646057129,
-0.08124197274446487,
-0.0025333205703645945,
-0.637694239616394,
-0.4567950963973999,
-0.0915212407708168,
0.18358124792575836,
0.42002758383750916,
-0.09723997116088867,
0.16480040550231934,
-0.3719103932380676,
-0.45494726300239563,
-0.25176745653152466,
-0.05496225878596306,
0.20737537741661072,
0.3941969573497772,
0.3786638081073761,
-0.035379793494939804,
-0.16464604437351227,
-0.9422741532325745,
-0.2712620496749878,
-0.4645787477493286,
-0.06039746478199959,
0.22190025448799133,
0.6005758047103882,
-0.14927279949188232,
0.7646388411521912,
-0.37041324377059937,
0.269048810005188,
-0.11030091345310211,
0.05532042309641838,
0.2827979028224945,
0.356378972530365,
0.39310789108276367,
-0.8011362552642822,
-0.6848835945129395,
-0.02700633928179741,
-0.6774882078170776,
-0.24122194945812225,
0.09045762568712234,
0.062418654561042786,
0.2262107878923416,
0.23894405364990234,
-0.5606661438941956,
0.07965102046728134,
0.7473204731941223,
-0.12876306474208832,
0.40805378556251526,
-0.19626076519489288,
0.2690589725971222,
-1.3738212585449219,
0.11741039156913757,
-0.10684815794229507,
-0.04168148711323738,
-0.7066114544868469,
-0.114232636988163,
0.1975460648536682,
0.43067872524261475,
-0.48195624351501465,
0.7145894765853882,
-0.10668536275625229,
0.01468636468052864,
-0.4846765995025635,
-0.045980650931596756,
0.19909100234508514,
0.04658842459321022,
-0.026170071214437485,
0.9169741272926331,
0.263624906539917,
-0.6003551483154297,
0.37299665808677673,
0.10480623692274094,
-0.20562076568603516,
0.8102942109107971,
-0.9306141138076782,
0.10132617503404617,
-0.10106097161769867,
0.3213573694229126,
-0.8387767672538757,
-0.231571227312088,
0.08223765343427658,
-0.1384650617837906,
-0.07935545593500137,
-0.06334462016820908,
-0.4252789318561554,
0.16013024747371674,
-0.17552177608013153,
0.5444452166557312,
0.7568959593772888,
-0.30830249190330505,
0.5174636840820312,
0.42601636052131653,
-0.23203030228614807,
-0.7530134320259094,
-0.5235494375228882,
-0.12888793647289276,
-0.19623565673828125,
-0.522520124912262,
0.06566432118415833,
-0.3236643671989441,
-0.6942561268806458,
0.06827294081449509,
-0.18587718904018402,
-0.32136616110801697,
0.028582746163010597,
0.14089438319206238,
0.2574503421783447,
-0.2365725189447403,
0.212978333234787,
-0.2817280888557434,
0.28225699067115784,
-0.036383286118507385,
-0.22741499543190002,
0.5360352993011475,
-0.14305579662322998,
-0.6831762790679932,
-0.015967564657330513,
0.44189634919166565,
0.8734103441238403,
-0.1655808687210083,
0.670200765132904,
0.15030455589294434,
-0.43950092792510986,
0.18786022067070007,
-0.8544626832008362,
-0.06357543170452118,
-0.42004233598709106,
0.23875199258327484,
-0.6430748701095581,
-1.2789908647537231,
1.0684428215026855,
0.4379616677761078,
0.241117462515831,
0.6108055710792542,
0.7504450082778931,
-0.2343372255563736,
1.1879686117172241,
0.5293797254562378,
-0.11712737381458282,
0.13098572194576263,
0.11089684814214706,
-0.03713907301425934,
-0.6565247774124146,
-0.21953827142715454,
-0.5990015268325806,
-0.1881398856639862,
-0.8409366011619568,
-0.2580529749393463,
0.3484332263469696,
0.12854251265525818,
-0.5500034689903259,
0.001683250186033547,
-0.08737646788358688,
0.4642280042171478,
0.339616984128952,
-0.18175597488880157,
0.40830808877944946,
-0.11157077550888062,
0.02318291924893856,
-0.2467518448829651,
-0.5851439237594604,
-0.7151299118995667,
1.2599973678588867,
0.29844245314598083,
1.0610673427581787,
0.008332350291311741,
0.5305044651031494,
-0.16820028424263,
0.5182274580001831,
-0.5545164942741394,
0.25322216749191284,
-0.00011732088751159608,
-0.8008905053138733,
-0.5228156447410583,
-0.5927549600601196,
-1.1167597770690918,
0.33297106623649597,
-0.0794912576675415,
-0.6505452990531921,
0.02834988944232464,
0.10238707810640335,
-0.2616880536079407,
0.5188942551612854,
-0.18276697397232056,
0.7994964122772217,
-0.4691624939441681,
-0.41560009121894836,
0.11323539912700653,
-0.5202664732933044,
0.42542555928230286,
-0.2628171443939209,
0.08973246067762375,
-0.3844537138938904,
0.033642105758190155,
0.6269629001617432,
-0.2916547656059265,
0.6812279224395752,
0.2574194669723511,
-0.5053436756134033,
0.33066001534461975,
-0.04295085743069649,
0.5313796401023865,
0.05105254054069519,
-0.17475828528404236,
0.3105037808418274,
0.40446197986602783,
-0.766533374786377,
-0.6767971515655518,
0.6503961682319641,
-0.913444995880127,
-0.8698095083236694,
-0.5330421328544617,
-0.828424870967865,
-0.17162048816680908,
0.12452797591686249,
0.11219518631696701,
0.15863165259361267,
-0.10871122777462006,
0.34050315618515015,
1.00840425491333,
-0.09312249720096588,
0.06857090443372726,
0.641694962978363,
-0.15409521758556366,
-0.2218015491962433,
0.4913424551486969,
0.36012551188468933,
0.7741398811340332,
0.2918362319469452,
0.3079800605773926,
-0.26564833521842957,
-0.3887035846710205,
-0.6245841383934021,
0.38150614500045776,
-0.6538993120193481,
-0.004709826782345772,
-0.8186450600624084,
-0.24748735129833221,
-0.2567935585975647,
-0.11249149590730667,
-0.6274511814117432,
-0.07500853389501572,
-0.21361319720745087,
-0.043575577437877655,
0.38613036274909973,
0.8313027620315552,
0.24243545532226562,
-0.16864512860774994,
-0.9492805004119873,
0.4081902503967285,
0.35401633381843567,
0.35477349162101746,
-0.19660456478595734,
-0.9063295125961304,
-0.12261232733726501,
0.38184162974357605,
-0.04362030699849129,
-0.9883552193641663,
0.0006730540771968663,
-0.2630535960197449,
0.630273699760437,
0.4381934106349945,
0.08808460086584091,
0.7246100902557373,
-0.5942633152008057,
1.066124677658081,
0.09422948211431503,
-0.8940436840057373,
0.07666659355163574,
-0.46993395686149597,
0.4050336480140686,
0.6688873767852783,
0.6733472943305969,
-0.8944180607795715,
-0.6232209801673889,
-0.7601282596588135,
-0.5781764984130859,
0.33954083919525146,
-0.15500496327877045,
0.689902126789093,
-0.2081131637096405,
0.46387025713920593,
0.0744512602686882,
0.3085736632347107,
-1.045197606086731,
-0.006658768747001886,
-0.08373121172189713,
-0.22107045352458954,
-0.023930571973323822,
-0.3959089517593384,
-0.2176317572593689,
0.03062537871301174,
0.3113624155521393,
-0.15102295577526093,
-0.19828933477401733,
-0.10727386176586151,
0.24455294013023376,
-0.40757498145103455,
0.40617236495018005,
0.9062600135803223,
1.0402882099151611,
-0.20806379616260529,
0.31596797704696655,
0.48048824071884155,
-0.4501282274723053,
0.5033145546913147,
-0.19370339810848236,
-0.3236596882343292,
-0.1266566962003708,
0.2842218577861786,
0.5326982140541077,
0.19131538271903992,
-0.8556573390960693,
0.6572272777557373,
0.14051367342472076,
-0.1897132247686386,
-0.3779411017894745,
-0.043409913778305054,
0.2477961629629135,
0.14621248841285706,
0.07799265533685684,
-0.28236332535743713,
-0.2516334056854248,
-0.8811967968940735,
0.039327941834926605,
0.7486065626144409,
-0.2600098252296448,
-0.2495548129081726,
0.7689834237098694,
-0.14945285022258759,
-0.006703679915517569,
0.5609259009361267,
-0.03255138546228409,
-0.5567626357078552,
0.6810754537582397,
0.47115251421928406,
0.5758339166641235,
-0.33003559708595276,
-0.06386275589466095,
0.2220471054315567,
0.5206151008605957,
-0.7220860123634338,
0.6256840229034424,
0.33106961846351624,
-0.9668628573417664,
-0.5103245377540588,
-0.6066473722457886,
-0.8585233092308044,
0.4826967716217041,
-0.7732148766517639,
0.0534098744392395,
-0.04051266983151436,
0.08653315156698227,
-0.3576037287712097,
-0.07564618438482285,
-0.3905949890613556,
0.39266136288642883,
-0.06314663589000702,
0.6885705590248108,
-1.0570712089538574,
0.9986023306846619,
0.6982918977737427,
-0.7131730318069458,
-1.1378196477890015,
0.07145129144191742,
-0.29070818424224854,
-0.6328333616256714,
0.5822728276252747,
-0.18542344868183136,
0.011578081175684929,
-0.3358703553676605,
-0.49670541286468506,
-1.2695075273513794,
0.9394105672836304,
0.3555484116077423,
-0.37452828884124756,
0.061247844249010086,
0.4281512200832367,
0.7575377225875854,
-0.35621583461761475,
0.37601378560066223,
0.3520263433456421,
0.548620343208313,
0.16128449141979218,
-1.309288740158081,
-0.0886925682425499,
-0.09182927757501602,
0.07949415594339371,
0.06973446160554886,
-0.688636839389801,
1.1721997261047363,
-0.1125621646642685,
0.196881964802742,
0.003141987370327115,
0.5975732207298279,
0.6076164245605469,
0.2658182978630066,
0.423684686422348,
0.5377455353736877,
0.7855849862098694,
-0.11736880987882614,
1.0955623388290405,
-0.40947821736335754,
0.3933682441711426,
0.8423586487770081,
-0.6763225793838501,
0.9630815982818604,
0.6119086146354675,
-0.30857980251312256,
0.02640090510249138,
0.7079018354415894,
-0.027582455426454544,
0.1718842089176178,
0.2977396547794342,
-0.039858195930719376,
-0.36718642711639404,
-0.1244523897767067,
-0.5375341176986694,
0.4234234392642975,
0.05812031775712967,
-0.3259657919406891,
-0.0649673119187355,
-0.17846152186393738,
0.3875311315059662,
0.12197475880384445,
-0.09923847019672394,
0.6357244253158569,
0.1896478235721588,
-0.853460431098938,
0.8880434632301331,
0.14672768115997314,
0.46941861510276794,
-0.7482718825340271,
0.06721411645412445,
-0.48798808455467224,
-0.0734233632683754,
0.010124954394996166,
-0.9366933107376099,
0.22556722164154053,
0.2446741759777069,
-0.4091361463069916,
-0.286029577255249,
0.2654905319213867,
-0.6760653853416443,
-0.38339170813560486,
-0.013598076067864895,
0.8679926991462708,
0.27350401878356934,
0.0005545924068428576,
-0.45680201053619385,
0.32281824946403503,
-0.02642124705016613,
-0.37039315700531006,
0.5126201510429382,
0.37839725613594055,
-0.23552870750427246,
0.6481683254241943,
0.47965437173843384,
0.28424394130706787,
0.20392639935016632,
-0.06782469898462296,
0.5969433784484863,
-0.5650490522384644,
-0.30981162190437317,
-0.969569206237793,
0.4389544427394867,
0.012743595987558365,
-0.49984267354011536,
0.8623957633972168,
0.5039783120155334,
1.060593605041504,
0.14623098075389862,
0.7363615036010742,
0.3399801254272461,
0.38317328691482544,
-0.6211383938789368,
0.4577394723892212,
-0.7377983331680298,
0.26016274094581604,
-0.2970258593559265,
-1.1881920099258423,
-0.10687696933746338,
0.5977857708930969,
-0.4341781437397003,
0.36200761795043945,
0.6595726013183594,
0.5882940292358398,
-0.15983112156391144,
-0.1176978200674057,
0.6627453565597534,
0.07683669030666351,
0.31019076704978943,
0.5596222281455994,
1.114597201347351,
-0.24603408575057983,
0.45271700620651245,
0.10210875421762466,
0.02740464359521866,
-0.18675391376018524,
-0.8007002472877502,
-0.5761401057243347,
-0.3302721083164215,
-0.26533257961273193,
-0.5392570495605469,
-0.005107462871819735,
1.1007757186889648,
0.4321102499961853,
-0.9220528602600098,
-0.5607832670211792,
0.10130582749843597,
0.0029056493658572435,
-0.12904919683933258,
-0.12951788306236267,
0.2691371440887451,
-0.14471055567264557,
-0.9269863963127136,
-0.10355402529239655,
0.30994606018066406,
0.047569986432790756,
-0.3617611527442932,
0.004479477647691965,
-0.08315800130367279,
0.5026662349700928,
0.3694359362125397,
0.25318098068237305,
-1.125579833984375,
-0.6330319046974182,
0.3360722064971924,
-0.6987446546554565,
0.1579006016254425,
0.5275893807411194,
-0.19527927041053772,
0.3264525830745697,
0.4967312812805176,
0.809371292591095,
0.21483862400054932,
0.20599551498889923,
0.36869120597839355,
-0.27623385190963745,
-0.15013836324214935,
0.28843435645103455,
0.5483765602111816,
0.2859739065170288,
-0.10323547571897507,
0.17718791961669922,
0.0892525240778923,
-0.7329176664352417,
-0.8458511233329773,
0.7040931582450867,
-1.0192928314208984,
-0.18884895741939545,
1.5618047714233398,
-0.3171485662460327,
0.1522236168384552,
0.0730641633272171,
0.08959245681762695,
-0.009828213602304459,
-0.024150939658284187,
0.8949483036994934,
1.0948402881622314,
-0.2201114445924759,
-0.14901795983314514,
-0.7920643091201782,
0.2581814229488373,
0.6219236850738525,
-0.8246667385101318,
0.0693870335817337,
0.6304196119308472,
0.556219220161438,
0.13485653698444366,
0.7412405610084534,
-0.16338716447353363,
0.2210756540298462,
-0.2137959748506546,
-0.08375369012355804,
0.34978485107421875,
-0.081345334649086,
-0.32375219464302063,
0.197118878364563,
0.41801533102989197,
0.1939215213060379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02987v1 | LoRA-Guard: Parameter-Efficient Guardrail Adaptation for Content Moderation of Large Language Models | 2024-07-03T10:38:40 | 2024-07-03T10:38:40 | Hayder Elesedy, Pedro M. Esperança, Silviu Vlad Oprea, Mete Ozay | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Guardrails have emerged as an alternative to safety alignment for content
moderation of large language models (LLMs). Existing model-based guardrails
have not been designed for resource-constrained computational portable devices,
such as mobile phones, more and more of which are running LLM-based
applications locally. We introduce LoRA-Guard, a parameter-efficient guardrail
adaptation method that relies on knowledge sharing between LLMs and guardrail
models. LoRA-Guard extracts language features from the LLMs and adapts them for
the content moderation task using low-rank adapters, while a dual-path design
prevents any performance degradation on the generative task. We show that
LoRA-Guard outperforms existing approaches with 100-1000x lower parameter
overhead while maintaining accuracy, enabling on-device content moderation. | [
-0.5131706595420837,
-0.7646386027336121,
0.5788228511810303,
0.14759871363639832,
-0.550725519657135,
0.1448717713356018,
-0.052556149661540985,
-0.13002236187458038,
0.4644034802913666,
0.8729019165039062,
-0.21399392187595367,
-0.6021807789802551,
-0.6349233388900757,
-0.3982209265232086,
-0.31056687235832214,
0.8202629685401917,
-0.3317740857601166,
-0.2520216107368469,
0.07346783578395844,
-0.18812289834022522,
-0.37323394417762756,
-0.42872604727745056,
-0.808493435382843,
-0.13319788873195648,
0.9286202788352966,
0.3031681776046753,
0.4571392238140106,
0.687993049621582,
0.6593431234359741,
0.14464978873729706,
-0.14191186428070068,
0.35475581884384155,
-0.4788128435611725,
0.3394326865673065,
-0.5460864901542664,
-0.2423194795846939,
-0.7142223715782166,
-0.37830355763435364,
0.4219568073749542,
0.3614301085472107,
-0.22325016558170319,
-0.03417156636714935,
0.18971753120422363,
0.7329518795013428,
-0.8996783494949341,
-0.07668300718069077,
-0.7467606067657471,
-0.09985759109258652,
-0.2440633326768875,
-0.40095359086990356,
-0.45296570658683777,
-0.4282369017601013,
-0.19027079641819,
-0.5640262365341187,
-0.3309907615184784,
0.15407222509384155,
0.6107026934623718,
0.3839888572692871,
-0.6345729827880859,
-0.010335647501051426,
-0.8654441833496094,
0.7113698720932007,
-0.3186459541320801,
0.24620680510997772,
0.6128686666488647,
0.3911338448524475,
-0.20527856051921844,
-0.5464069843292236,
-0.3249748647212982,
0.22359074652194977,
0.306174099445343,
0.030697844922542572,
-0.2676675617694855,
0.010530994273722172,
0.0027196877636015415,
-0.10116630792617798,
-0.22720138728618622,
0.4082024395465851,
-0.24052603542804718,
-0.10213778167963028,
0.5385292172431946,
0.0940973088145256,
0.12112235277891159,
-0.12894469499588013,
-0.4504869878292084,
-0.10210168361663818,
-1.1945157051086426,
0.10655619204044342,
0.29787054657936096,
0.35434040427207947,
-0.25786712765693665,
0.3032880425453186,
-0.2321828007698059,
0.6441841125488281,
0.159567192196846,
-0.3585571050643921,
-0.2030237317085266,
-0.1601605862379074,
0.03431160748004913,
0.3009011149406433,
0.8542925119400024,
0.47319453954696655,
-0.1647852212190628,
-0.06621088087558746,
-0.16844351589679718,
-0.09509794414043427,
0.3822838068008423,
-0.9833733439445496,
-0.14146670699119568,
-0.11535335332155228,
-0.3922765254974365,
-0.29827937483787537,
-0.06329023838043213,
-1.0134564638137817,
-0.9736407399177551,
0.09875687956809998,
0.5911064743995667,
-0.09070896357297897,
0.005692862439900637,
0.3919025957584381,
0.11519484966993332,
0.45548900961875916,
0.5590633749961853,
-1.1181089878082275,
0.42120611667633057,
0.7200194001197815,
1.1358345746994019,
-0.4311273992061615,
-0.07971847802400589,
-0.8892939686775208,
0.547873854637146,
-0.1390523910522461,
0.954963207244873,
-0.37872743606567383,
-0.4793185293674469,
-0.05043376609683037,
0.001999163767322898,
-0.2788703441619873,
-0.24112360179424286,
0.9702195525169373,
-1.0665366649627686,
-0.042009755969047546,
-0.20749424397945404,
-0.15945065021514893,
-0.18247468769550323,
0.017078783363103867,
-0.7696515321731567,
0.5973966121673584,
0.11803679913282394,
-0.7753803730010986,
0.2547622323036194,
-0.7047385573387146,
-0.5785665512084961,
-0.18973492085933685,
-0.03802725672721863,
-0.42012226581573486,
-0.10417848825454712,
0.29831406474113464,
0.21117764711380005,
-0.32982003688812256,
-0.02474510483443737,
-0.4016069173812866,
-0.2997458577156067,
0.011890443973243237,
-0.482638418674469,
0.6244969964027405,
0.4255506694316864,
-0.10495220124721527,
0.23969076573848724,
-0.22645080089569092,
-0.08464404940605164,
-0.08492564409971237,
-0.6464095711708069,
-0.4280594289302826,
0.5360738635063171,
-0.07079634070396423,
0.14320960640907288,
0.2918238043785095,
-0.38991281390190125,
0.1739722490310669,
-0.10691853612661362,
0.4598563313484192,
1.0032955408096313,
0.15957029163837433,
0.45275014638900757,
-0.5482942461967468,
0.6744062304496765,
-0.18981540203094482,
0.30122604966163635,
0.21665526926517487,
-0.3213512897491455,
-0.8227005004882812,
-0.40789467096328735,
0.4122489094734192,
0.4103631377220154,
-0.7929406762123108,
0.6412860751152039,
-0.5782897472381592,
-0.8643267750740051,
-0.17110638320446014,
0.5017456412315369,
0.28912898898124695,
0.16119739413261414,
0.10283973067998886,
-0.656093418598175,
-0.49509644508361816,
-0.41651400923728943,
-0.06307385861873627,
-0.3031253218650818,
0.304017037153244,
-0.10648705065250397,
0.32524940371513367,
-0.04989946261048317,
0.8934741020202637,
-0.45500585436820984,
-0.42731061577796936,
-0.38310161232948303,
-0.21437868475914001,
0.19164377450942993,
0.390563040971756,
0.6552791595458984,
-0.5097612142562866,
-0.7839688062667847,
0.2451133131980896,
-0.5175278186798096,
-0.11837580054998398,
0.12072473019361496,
-0.4454655349254608,
0.0017028134316205978,
0.6683973073959351,
-0.4869861304759979,
0.19266368448734283,
0.9756186604499817,
-0.46506747603416443,
0.2567448019981384,
-0.18866486847400665,
-0.03191123157739639,
-1.2965282201766968,
-0.06302279233932495,
-0.1907506287097931,
-0.5086396336555481,
-0.6341283917427063,
-0.056243617087602615,
-0.05995361506938934,
0.15392975509166718,
-0.3846772313117981,
0.784770131111145,
-0.1158081442117691,
-0.011052337475121021,
-0.44188979268074036,
0.5233474969863892,
0.333842933177948,
0.2627556025981903,
0.10641779005527496,
0.6195420026779175,
0.6120657324790955,
-0.6924449801445007,
0.4608824849128723,
0.3644879162311554,
-0.5617647767066956,
0.7332391142845154,
-0.3756834864616394,
0.1904742419719696,
0.07200755178928375,
0.40159872174263,
-0.3843751549720764,
-0.3588215708732605,
0.24851687252521515,
0.18179993331432343,
-0.16420617699623108,
-0.7792925834655762,
-0.3895970582962036,
0.059308357536792755,
-0.609049379825592,
0.2018873691558838,
0.6547910571098328,
-0.7101519703865051,
0.7958930730819702,
0.8027924299240112,
-0.30569976568222046,
-0.2953897714614868,
-0.44621890783309937,
0.13529619574546814,
-0.7612074017524719,
-0.5611923933029175,
0.5713703036308289,
-0.1683764010667801,
-0.29487544298171997,
-0.3085789382457733,
-0.211243137717247,
-0.14335604012012482,
0.3918425738811493,
0.31324660778045654,
0.0321054607629776,
-0.3278060555458069,
-0.0014991778880357742,
0.19946156442165375,
0.13316607475280762,
0.011901347897946835,
-0.019135240465402603,
0.8540440797805786,
0.22539664804935455,
-0.6590068340301514,
-0.32533952593803406,
0.28267303109169006,
0.6103741526603699,
-0.28744980692863464,
1.001960039138794,
0.3017629384994507,
-0.1432446986436844,
-0.434756875038147,
-0.2882460951805115,
-0.004988717380911112,
-0.5898606181144714,
0.1932510882616043,
-0.23633228242397308,
-0.891950249671936,
0.47614583373069763,
-0.005792052950710058,
0.15948525071144104,
0.15257525444030762,
0.20332351326942444,
-0.0999840795993805,
1.0364831686019897,
0.6736756563186646,
-0.2622094750404358,
0.9655027389526367,
0.25604745745658875,
0.25465676188468933,
-0.8403478860855103,
-0.06161414459347725,
-0.5430746674537659,
-0.34353357553482056,
-0.594572126865387,
-0.36583247780799866,
0.6133615970611572,
0.313956618309021,
-0.4347577691078186,
0.47491219639778137,
-0.11690237373113632,
0.3712613880634308,
0.4856211543083191,
0.29671594500541687,
0.6075358390808105,
0.23187603056430817,
0.37456750869750977,
0.161088228225708,
-0.6206670999526978,
-0.6330990791320801,
1.012104868888855,
0.35267695784568787,
1.3361179828643799,
0.655278205871582,
0.5778441429138184,
0.5714953541755676,
0.18457086384296417,
-0.7232514023780823,
0.6788042783737183,
-0.5539666414260864,
-0.35552743077278137,
-0.06016742065548897,
-0.3888716995716095,
-0.8621141910552979,
0.26795780658721924,
-0.17504559457302094,
-0.8692251443862915,
0.16059048473834991,
0.1964859813451767,
-0.6622606515884399,
0.6349124908447266,
-0.7097930312156677,
0.6973854899406433,
-0.4826420247554779,
-0.5106519460678101,
-0.3057565987110138,
-0.09098829329013824,
0.2242291420698166,
-0.578346848487854,
0.09827522188425064,
-0.06636428087949753,
-0.13891080021858215,
1.0332392454147339,
-0.36349955201148987,
0.9096729755401611,
-0.3990517556667328,
-0.44697871804237366,
0.3275813162326813,
0.28113412857055664,
0.7687183022499084,
0.007932848297059536,
-0.21676327288150787,
-0.32554325461387634,
0.0664365217089653,
-0.13283413648605347,
-0.7286223769187927,
0.8200036883354187,
-0.7764305472373962,
-0.837123692035675,
-0.26173466444015503,
-0.24464932084083557,
-0.3996642827987671,
0.2259080708026886,
-0.15790191292762756,
0.27188801765441895,
-0.18300725519657135,
0.5224445462226868,
0.9365087747573853,
-0.09650995582342148,
0.43355289101600647,
0.47324931621551514,
-0.6385318636894226,
-0.25763368606567383,
0.7671459913253784,
-0.15090906620025635,
0.3817225396633148,
0.3361847400665283,
0.1300247311592102,
-0.22897228598594666,
-0.7430695295333862,
-0.5963934063911438,
-0.044241439551115036,
-0.8190756440162659,
-0.10151916742324829,
-0.535133421421051,
-0.5369314551353455,
-0.1116555780172348,
-0.41298821568489075,
-0.3690403401851654,
-0.5353222489356995,
-0.12957389652729034,
-0.009893459267914295,
0.9524825215339661,
0.5188773274421692,
0.06724204123020172,
0.9781472086906433,
-0.55699223279953,
0.3741617798805237,
0.45915356278419495,
0.4009504020214081,
-0.5159400105476379,
-1.0675235986709595,
-0.17662665247917175,
-0.23870635032653809,
-0.3291688561439514,
-0.5391628742218018,
0.10083748400211334,
0.162204772233963,
0.4112667739391327,
0.6799697875976562,
0.2854226231575012,
0.4700060188770294,
-0.21639609336853027,
0.5506843328475952,
0.02578182891011238,
-0.7897094488143921,
0.3229351341724396,
-0.5343140363693237,
0.06566431373357773,
0.604570209980011,
0.01106502115726471,
-0.6410777568817139,
0.2279469519853592,
0.05244988575577736,
-0.5888906717300415,
0.6609450578689575,
-0.09544692933559418,
0.43129080533981323,
0.4640437066555023,
0.024928908795118332,
-0.12369903922080994,
-0.18109603226184845,
-0.872651994228363,
0.2608807384967804,
-0.2826204001903534,
-0.30661389231681824,
0.13359245657920837,
-0.20638181269168854,
-0.4317328631877899,
0.1378490924835205,
0.7435232996940613,
-0.3121018409729004,
0.0806669294834137,
-0.1607855260372162,
-0.18672756850719452,
-0.054208558052778244,
0.5313413739204407,
0.5129508376121521,
0.4459719657897949,
-0.17828695476055145,
0.558531641960144,
0.3313065469264984,
-0.5445812940597534,
0.1343054324388504,
-0.05732947215437889,
-0.5025635361671448,
-0.2995186746120453,
0.15950317680835724,
0.9060819745063782,
-0.030341483652591705,
-0.5892012715339661,
0.4988863170146942,
-0.07008418440818787,
0.046462491154670715,
-0.14044207334518433,
0.5256319642066956,
0.062489721924066544,
0.09715594351291656,
-0.2573118805885315,
-0.007284756749868393,
-0.42506691813468933,
-0.42227041721343994,
-0.01742292009294033,
0.5238357186317444,
-0.620884895324707,
-0.24512818455696106,
0.5876474380493164,
0.5051577091217041,
-0.17899982631206512,
-0.12086247652769089,
0.046801988035440445,
-0.28952863812446594,
0.19058509171009064,
0.4749874472618103,
0.7427332401275635,
-0.2814856469631195,
0.30471453070640564,
0.08927386999130249,
0.24984298646450043,
-0.1888105571269989,
0.3138141334056854,
0.04521261900663376,
-0.780920147895813,
-0.2816990911960602,
-0.7539388537406921,
-0.4355137050151825,
-0.0022580078803002834,
-0.38118982315063477,
0.333109587430954,
-0.8955994248390198,
-0.28385859727859497,
-0.35028567910194397,
-0.29459473490715027,
-0.08540622889995575,
-0.22313812375068665,
-0.07947988063097,
1.117533802986145,
-0.7370973229408264,
1.0975160598754883,
0.38125139474868774,
-0.20317772030830383,
-0.6119558215141296,
0.042061205953359604,
-0.15625733137130737,
-0.6032339930534363,
0.24830006062984467,
-0.24555185437202454,
-0.7115604877471924,
-0.006267531309276819,
-0.17297779023647308,
-0.8882529735565186,
1.063062310218811,
0.3773927092552185,
-0.2508713901042938,
-0.14256298542022705,
0.334170937538147,
0.4648416340351105,
-0.23703497648239136,
-0.17006272077560425,
0.3934796452522278,
0.5136030316352844,
-0.26741766929626465,
-0.7855436205863953,
0.07650502026081085,
0.07749916613101959,
-0.1138211041688919,
0.08938181400299072,
-0.9168969988822937,
0.504770815372467,
0.3696163594722748,
-0.10324932634830475,
0.1740792840719223,
0.3498503863811493,
0.35794055461883545,
-0.01665036752820015,
0.7097954154014587,
0.23860947787761688,
0.5201348066329956,
0.046994078904390335,
0.7052360773086548,
-0.34922125935554504,
-0.022047189995646477,
1.181767463684082,
-0.5627482533454895,
1.0978394746780396,
0.6362303495407104,
0.01752692647278309,
0.7694247364997864,
0.3615858554840088,
0.254958838224411,
0.8429762125015259,
-0.14873313903808594,
-0.8126426339149475,
-0.265259712934494,
-0.4699694812297821,
-0.15515579283237457,
0.6017556190490723,
0.31021401286125183,
-0.470179945230484,
-0.2321600615978241,
-0.22116844356060028,
0.4931414723396301,
0.0768582746386528,
-0.6232449412345886,
0.6886621713638306,
0.15127407014369965,
-0.7651582360267639,
0.5110737681388855,
0.38562560081481934,
0.5650630593299866,
-0.9148411154747009,
0.3392582833766937,
-0.28300878405570984,
0.2195279747247696,
-0.17961007356643677,
-0.8200381398200989,
0.19544051587581635,
0.4517837166786194,
-0.004050221759825945,
-0.5358248949050903,
0.6365329027175903,
-0.06346097588539124,
-0.2335118055343628,
0.47245699167251587,
0.48889225721359253,
-0.2055026888847351,
-0.012970422394573689,
-0.32979482412338257,
0.3113164007663727,
-0.16137976944446564,
-0.21756549179553986,
0.500442624092102,
0.05166146159172058,
-0.4719642400741577,
0.751379132270813,
0.4971204400062561,
0.1282830685377121,
0.2360670566558838,
0.043718140572309494,
1.0166113376617432,
-0.43970099091529846,
-0.5170095562934875,
-0.7494282126426697,
0.24411895871162415,
-0.0476180836558342,
-0.05993664637207985,
0.6927621960639954,
0.46876436471939087,
0.5538895130157471,
0.136561781167984,
1.0513017177581787,
-0.3103499710559845,
0.3037303388118744,
-0.950127363204956,
0.990757942199707,
-0.3792770802974701,
0.518598198890686,
-0.16325294971466064,
-0.9477178454399109,
-0.2846028208732605,
0.41512882709503174,
-0.4866695702075958,
-0.0743931382894516,
0.5501701831817627,
1.1434329748153687,
-0.47273972630500793,
-0.26985979080200195,
0.26291120052337646,
-0.0671052560210228,
0.4659349024295807,
0.5566588640213013,
0.8563490509986877,
-0.1873999387025833,
0.7734402418136597,
-0.15773886442184448,
0.04379050433635712,
-0.19205203652381897,
-1.0116639137268066,
-0.987718403339386,
-0.3614913821220398,
-0.10765417665243149,
-0.3398970663547516,
0.24522891640663147,
0.8286029100418091,
0.9599975347518921,
-0.8152568936347961,
-0.22348062694072723,
0.06980769336223602,
0.3234836757183075,
0.02334929257631302,
-0.09816677868366241,
0.565732479095459,
0.37435972690582275,
-0.4045102000236511,
0.6685310006141663,
0.17911876738071442,
-0.2027817964553833,
-0.3885282278060913,
-0.3357737362384796,
0.1413455754518509,
0.2926817238330841,
0.49992087483406067,
0.4764489531517029,
-0.5206116437911987,
-0.571955144405365,
-0.3203061521053314,
-0.22247135639190674,
0.19766713678836823,
0.6052008867263794,
-0.35217371582984924,
0.1973702311515808,
0.5425117611885071,
0.6999102830886841,
0.4217338562011719,
0.1768573671579361,
0.3840467035770416,
-0.5563547015190125,
0.07248673588037491,
-0.3074151575565338,
0.6332964897155762,
0.2534359395503998,
0.11599381268024445,
0.3300422132015228,
-0.03198762983083725,
-0.4405168890953064,
-0.6849803328514099,
0.6162243485450745,
-1.3173199892044067,
-0.0009306304855272174,
1.3262341022491455,
-0.20988120138645172,
-0.23973043262958527,
-0.3479369878768921,
-0.4739775061607361,
-0.03553206846117973,
-0.3215982913970947,
1.0008193254470825,
0.29310184717178345,
0.08984474092721939,
-0.3584958016872406,
-0.5347797274589539,
0.5788524150848389,
0.23462267220020294,
-1.30339777469635,
0.21142113208770752,
0.25176388025283813,
0.3957427442073822,
0.07530642300844193,
0.5070255398750305,
-0.09289510548114777,
0.16832619905471802,
-0.29888641834259033,
-0.04379944130778313,
0.21892186999320984,
-0.2227107733488083,
-0.31373995542526245,
0.17029957473278046,
0.6765233278274536,
0.13202157616615295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02978v1 | Mast Kalandar at SemEval-2024 Task 8: On the Trail of Textual Origins: RoBERTa-BiLSTM Approach to Detect AI-Generated Text | 2024-07-03T10:22:23 | 2024-07-03T10:22:23 | Jainit Sushil Bafna, Hardik Mittal, Suyash Sethia, Manish Shrivastava, Radhika Mamidi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased impressive abilities in
generating fluent responses to diverse user queries. However, concerns
regarding the potential misuse of such texts in journalism, educational, and
academic contexts have surfaced. SemEval 2024 introduces the task of
Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Black-Box Machine-Generated Text
Detection, aiming to develop automated systems for identifying
machine-generated text and detecting potential misuse. In this paper, we i)
propose a RoBERTa-BiLSTM based classifier designed to classify text into two
categories: AI-generated or human ii) conduct a comparative study of our model
with baseline approaches to evaluate its effectiveness. This paper contributes
to the advancement of automatic text detection systems in addressing the
challenges posed by machine-generated text misuse. Our architecture ranked 46th
on the official leaderboard with an accuracy of 80.83 among 125. | [
-0.19996093213558197,
-0.9305769205093384,
0.43675413727760315,
0.08114159852266312,
-0.21843436360359192,
0.16544897854328156,
-0.1541997641324997,
-0.6715303063392639,
-0.35249897837638855,
0.5249713063240051,
-0.23894020915031433,
-0.4030582904815674,
-0.9212851524353027,
0.5466804504394531,
-0.5702356100082397,
1.1623754501342773,
0.02811777964234352,
-0.11253030598163605,
-0.14315655827522278,
-0.2022450566291809,
-0.5078113675117493,
-0.7320631742477417,
-0.510161280632019,
-0.2352437525987625,
0.4138040840625763,
0.24592378735542297,
0.2041364461183548,
0.15965622663497925,
0.4631299376487732,
0.37371471524238586,
0.014637414366006851,
0.4811941087245941,
-0.1916911005973816,
0.33343303203582764,
-0.20249409973621368,
-0.18893380463123322,
-0.29433751106262207,
-0.006165496073663235,
0.5199984908103943,
0.02105058915913105,
-0.05485447496175766,
0.34209680557250977,
0.10423576086759567,
0.3008612096309662,
-0.5127344727516174,
-0.05963518097996712,
-0.6815157532691956,
-0.2517700791358948,
-0.527405858039856,
-0.6020013689994812,
-0.6669550538063049,
-0.17474773526191711,
0.11675752699375153,
-0.13717542588710785,
0.24055610597133636,
0.19406569004058838,
0.8637014031410217,
0.23540621995925903,
-0.7296533584594727,
-0.7695866823196411,
-0.7270179986953735,
0.7699415683746338,
-0.4869607388973236,
0.30810272693634033,
0.4463035762310028,
0.4208960235118866,
0.023214178159832954,
-0.6058270931243896,
-0.5796908736228943,
0.1367303729057312,
0.12866227328777313,
0.12073614448308945,
-0.1892896443605423,
-0.41458162665367126,
-0.01783520169556141,
0.14652906358242035,
-0.9453868269920349,
0.03319207951426506,
-0.5870600938796997,
-0.2507834732532501,
0.6025183796882629,
0.18000638484954834,
0.547960102558136,
-0.4161560833454132,
-0.3723304271697998,
0.29445767402648926,
-0.6768600940704346,
-0.1547214686870575,
0.38815873861312866,
0.3210832476615906,
-0.025601841509342194,
0.6891763806343079,
0.09489750862121582,
0.5971769690513611,
-0.11353529989719391,
-0.14609278738498688,
0.28836724162101746,
-0.5358361601829529,
-0.2103133350610733,
0.15887722373008728,
0.8429028391838074,
0.0038954783231019974,
0.41286003589630127,
-0.09486989676952362,
-0.17816025018692017,
0.2265445739030838,
0.47598427534103394,
-0.6667892336845398,
-0.18939930200576782,
-0.15521454811096191,
-0.46462008357048035,
-0.5303237438201904,
0.0336008220911026,
-0.6952797770500183,
-0.4727162718772888,
-0.04533567652106285,
0.435142457485199,
-0.4182627201080322,
0.023324843496084213,
-0.09584914892911911,
0.003547832602635026,
0.24429704248905182,
0.49295374751091003,
-0.5403647422790527,
-0.10417332500219345,
0.45197594165802,
0.5477285385131836,
-0.3778128921985626,
-0.1651957780122757,
-0.49502113461494446,
0.2568644881248474,
-0.05403641238808632,
1.0219414234161377,
-0.48798778653144836,
-0.31583985686302185,
-0.041863128542900085,
0.14511366188526154,
0.2096288949251175,
-0.4404849112033844,
0.8360314965248108,
-0.6592754125595093,
0.5796484351158142,
0.18149156868457794,
-0.44893214106559753,
-0.3656917214393616,
0.3926084339618683,
-0.47281283140182495,
1.2261420488357544,
0.019503694027662277,
-0.790650486946106,
0.3734704852104187,
-0.6022013425827026,
-0.6296095848083496,
0.3682343661785126,
-0.039797063916921616,
-0.859382152557373,
-0.15907180309295654,
0.11292635649442673,
0.3536633849143982,
-0.40715542435646057,
0.5134303569793701,
0.06934545934200287,
-0.3258458971977234,
0.2682899534702301,
-0.8634063005447388,
0.8931185007095337,
0.2740102708339691,
-0.5177725553512573,
0.06764420121908188,
-0.9003848433494568,
-0.13721829652786255,
0.11538472771644592,
-0.6786564588546753,
-0.5567218661308289,
-0.09747029095888138,
0.28633543848991394,
0.224386066198349,
0.2611856162548065,
-0.43109676241874695,
-0.16949710249900818,
-0.24638348817825317,
0.17827732861042023,
0.818673849105835,
0.19968053698539734,
0.3286130130290985,
-0.2819741368293762,
0.5829004645347595,
-0.0039952583611011505,
-0.18689656257629395,
-0.47927093505859375,
-0.6975565552711487,
-0.7632559537887573,
-0.22105112671852112,
0.3750169575214386,
0.643913984298706,
-0.6539381146430969,
0.4652290642261505,
0.14418937265872955,
-0.5111401081085205,
-0.248525932431221,
0.13712039589881897,
0.41455715894699097,
0.2796482443809509,
0.4346752166748047,
0.06338858604431152,
-0.6847600340843201,
-0.7214140295982361,
-0.34861668944358826,
-0.013692272827029228,
0.2065875083208084,
0.19665206968784332,
0.7100924253463745,
-0.43029239773750305,
0.534417450428009,
-0.05442271754145622,
-0.06743456423282623,
-0.18936261534690857,
0.4525177776813507,
-0.22942198812961578,
0.40884411334991455,
0.44577693939208984,
-0.979418933391571,
-0.6195991039276123,
-0.08885523676872253,
-0.9331021904945374,
-0.48192381858825684,
-0.03526044636964798,
-0.1377834677696228,
0.6647456288337708,
0.38763341307640076,
-0.4603799879550934,
0.701783299446106,
0.41759371757507324,
-0.4693075120449066,
0.5663933753967285,
-0.13268080353736877,
0.2927318215370178,
-1.2555854320526123,
0.15571819245815277,
-0.06980367749929428,
-0.389163613319397,
-0.6191781163215637,
-0.060085296630859375,
0.23183365166187286,
-0.23298299312591553,
-0.211152121424675,
0.3919678032398224,
-0.4587627947330475,
0.028155410662293434,
-0.42224252223968506,
0.09710875898599625,
0.12206517904996872,
0.14119477570056915,
-0.21330595016479492,
0.9927091002464294,
-0.007298407144844532,
-0.6249951720237732,
0.12607114017009735,
0.2774609923362732,
-0.2170577347278595,
0.7980318665504456,
-0.6046745777130127,
0.1186215877532959,
-0.22343894839286804,
0.19144363701343536,
-1.030924677848816,
-0.04220651090145111,
0.3870372474193573,
-0.6838424801826477,
0.2857174575328827,
-0.02411673590540886,
-0.6450921893119812,
-0.3253611624240875,
-0.13080421090126038,
0.4111599922180176,
0.3386433720588684,
-0.38764214515686035,
0.46408140659332275,
0.4438096880912781,
-0.4591532349586487,
-0.4860437512397766,
-0.6501017212867737,
0.42211437225341797,
-0.33541008830070496,
-0.45410704612731934,
0.10116910934448242,
-0.19618730247020721,
-0.18220274150371552,
-0.03089638240635395,
0.12734144926071167,
-0.020923594012856483,
0.27310898900032043,
0.2867504358291626,
0.490303635597229,
-0.25639641284942627,
0.16779610514640808,
0.14633387327194214,
-0.257732629776001,
-0.012002786621451378,
-0.15660890936851501,
0.7115721702575684,
0.06947240233421326,
-0.28386184573173523,
-0.584262490272522,
0.4102301597595215,
0.6955231428146362,
-0.5709394216537476,
0.5271129012107849,
0.7246900796890259,
-0.2750563621520996,
-0.2779255211353302,
-0.47036781907081604,
0.18254578113555908,
-0.44412893056869507,
0.16456148028373718,
-0.20637278258800507,
-0.8573397397994995,
0.025002282112836838,
0.024561122059822083,
-0.17478841543197632,
0.6130006909370422,
0.8654186725616455,
-0.038881566375494,
1.0352296829223633,
0.6341538429260254,
0.11877703666687012,
0.2675597071647644,
-0.13140854239463806,
0.2819857895374298,
-0.7334073185920715,
-0.2986716628074646,
-0.9596074819564819,
-0.09189193695783615,
-0.641959547996521,
-0.34740376472473145,
0.2523142993450165,
-0.3134095370769501,
-0.3403748571872711,
0.44063305854797363,
-0.6796627044677734,
0.27261975407600403,
0.5538076162338257,
-0.25998544692993164,
0.4429786503314972,
-0.08076754212379456,
0.08842594921588898,
0.092223159968853,
-0.33254632353782654,
-0.8367520570755005,
1.2204121351242065,
0.10059725493192673,
0.4929940700531006,
0.30965012311935425,
0.7594330906867981,
0.6621642708778381,
0.4086120128631592,
-0.42652636766433716,
0.3588132858276367,
-0.08815566450357437,
-0.8228042721748352,
-0.09663088619709015,
-0.22289298474788666,
-1.0649075508117676,
0.26427558064460754,
-0.2113688886165619,
-0.5005401968955994,
-0.07016733288764954,
-0.2393835335969925,
-0.05220529064536095,
0.040768496692180634,
-0.4106006622314453,
0.7877352237701416,
-0.4812440574169159,
-0.18018661439418793,
-0.047276224941015244,
-0.5561215281486511,
0.3403934836387634,
-0.3683234453201294,
0.41369181871414185,
-0.12855346500873566,
-0.04717826098203659,
0.5708951950073242,
-0.14473627507686615,
0.616744875907898,
-0.11230986565351486,
-0.13027100265026093,
0.4374348521232605,
0.11175747960805893,
0.4295780062675476,
-0.12182239443063736,
-0.1694447249174118,
0.024282431229948997,
-0.19887222349643707,
-0.2733161747455597,
-0.08410320430994034,
0.42868223786354065,
-0.7693237662315369,
-0.29304710030555725,
-0.7716830968856812,
-0.38241052627563477,
0.03248009830713272,
0.47011837363243103,
0.46390610933303833,
0.6350520849227905,
-0.13579893112182617,
0.34429600834846497,
0.42942148447036743,
-0.4959980547428131,
0.4522116780281067,
0.627994179725647,
-0.21208317577838898,
-0.405958354473114,
0.9265055060386658,
-0.0251438207924366,
-0.15539981424808502,
0.24124203622341156,
0.14502854645252228,
-0.25934040546417236,
-0.7831186652183533,
-0.7700523138046265,
-0.042706266045570374,
-0.4852076470851898,
-0.5168107151985168,
-0.7537285089492798,
-0.33201736211776733,
-0.3495329022407532,
-0.18073770403862,
0.14742955565452576,
-0.21644918620586395,
-0.5136476159095764,
0.06787068396806717,
-0.016598036512732506,
0.8676636219024658,
0.40973934531211853,
0.21472807228565216,
-0.8727427124977112,
0.23026081919670105,
0.037364114075899124,
-0.1219044104218483,
-0.18246079981327057,
-0.7211186289787292,
-0.12432745844125748,
-0.02017574943602085,
-0.5413916707038879,
-0.7858003973960876,
0.6315073370933533,
0.10654585808515549,
0.5840293169021606,
0.17525739967823029,
0.040935929864645004,
0.34552687406539917,
-0.45307523012161255,
0.804086446762085,
-0.10750257223844528,
-0.760040283203125,
0.698600709438324,
-0.345366895198822,
0.35390961170196533,
0.3992193639278412,
0.39332330226898193,
-0.32586613297462463,
-0.6394902467727661,
-0.5260581970214844,
-0.5921357870101929,
0.6576454639434814,
0.2782035768032074,
0.16857756674289703,
-0.006000634282827377,
0.1166035383939743,
0.3375696837902069,
0.3291625380516052,
-0.7399470806121826,
-0.02540683001279831,
-0.07222993671894073,
-0.5386289954185486,
-0.1384551078081131,
-0.38173145055770874,
0.3098424971103668,
0.1594722419977188,
0.8336623311042786,
0.1412072628736496,
0.137746661901474,
-0.04054529592394829,
-0.5573206543922424,
-0.02229766547679901,
0.4111366868019104,
0.7145994901657104,
0.38203150033950806,
0.20277845859527588,
0.3142314553260803,
0.06835377216339111,
-0.4092049300670624,
0.19517302513122559,
0.14087483286857605,
-0.6602141857147217,
0.010151336900889874,
0.27473726868629456,
0.4770149290561676,
0.15009483695030212,
-0.7755087614059448,
0.4970555901527405,
0.039450403302907944,
0.02194257080554962,
-0.5850818753242493,
-0.04667506366968155,
-0.10551028698682785,
0.2472500205039978,
0.5206512212753296,
0.2884860336780548,
0.43230125308036804,
-0.64027339220047,
0.36424294114112854,
0.47205615043640137,
-0.23553279042243958,
-0.4359508156776428,
0.7183418273925781,
0.2979614734649658,
-0.6839900612831116,
0.29066136479377747,
-0.4064904749393463,
-1.0043457746505737,
0.5768684148788452,
0.8294782638549805,
0.7257809042930603,
-0.3022511899471283,
0.16873247921466827,
0.26164427399635315,
0.1876642107963562,
0.3024792969226837,
0.17082658410072327,
-0.1393919289112091,
-0.6889029145240784,
-0.15937913954257965,
-0.7865599989891052,
-0.04635244980454445,
0.08111068606376648,
-0.22996528446674347,
0.5258665084838867,
-0.25947192311286926,
-0.10179470479488373,
0.288147896528244,
0.1249857097864151,
-0.5044004321098328,
0.0826876312494278,
0.23235943913459778,
0.6205742955207825,
-0.602753758430481,
0.6555959582328796,
0.8553239107131958,
-0.48638713359832764,
-0.4576173722743988,
0.012200766243040562,
0.45676401257514954,
-0.6126041412353516,
0.7760513424873352,
0.4042694568634033,
-0.21526512503623962,
0.05041707679629326,
-0.3794274628162384,
-0.6157170534133911,
1.0702266693115234,
-0.3471387028694153,
-0.17896924912929535,
0.06911925226449966,
0.09646669030189514,
0.5700280666351318,
-0.17420227825641632,
0.07874657958745956,
0.24590878188610077,
0.5873751640319824,
-0.1610007882118225,
-0.8561045527458191,
-0.22656936943531036,
-0.4525325298309326,
-0.07828434556722641,
0.3971728980541229,
-0.5029061436653137,
0.9865037202835083,
0.22208215296268463,
-0.30679842829704285,
0.4611942768096924,
0.2973417043685913,
0.2066350132226944,
0.690170407295227,
0.22318044304847717,
0.5583363771438599,
0.7279909253120422,
0.04170067608356476,
0.7687690258026123,
-0.1946970820426941,
0.30595913529396057,
0.9704227447509766,
-0.44890275597572327,
0.6731926798820496,
0.01469544880092144,
-0.19581590592861176,
0.7419636249542236,
0.4081433117389679,
-0.17756536602973938,
0.35165679454803467,
0.05020797252655029,
-0.43713119626045227,
0.05499386414885521,
-0.05190194398164749,
-0.15276271104812622,
0.8749639987945557,
0.41669973731040955,
-0.4271513521671295,
-0.2981553375720978,
0.3049899637699127,
0.04870409891009331,
0.2768527865409851,
-0.11828385293483734,
0.9215243458747864,
-0.15616782009601593,
-0.7256423234939575,
0.22077862918376923,
0.43193623423576355,
0.8049110174179077,
-0.3730565011501312,
-0.016138937324285507,
0.1253335177898407,
0.32701176404953003,
-0.03102022595703602,
-0.6326529383659363,
0.3522070050239563,
0.3599248230457306,
-0.20312625169754028,
-0.20777542889118195,
1.2610387802124023,
-0.5766757726669312,
-0.535000741481781,
0.08966393768787384,
0.6411170959472656,
0.14249086380004883,
-0.01192410197108984,
-0.5594220757484436,
0.2872239351272583,
-0.1742323637008667,
-0.08404823392629623,
0.16993820667266846,
0.7147096991539001,
-0.3084450364112854,
0.545078694820404,
0.7581117749214172,
-0.15546506643295288,
0.1604415327310562,
-0.06718476861715317,
0.3647492825984955,
-0.5040744543075562,
-0.47112709283828735,
-0.9165180325508118,
0.2669588029384613,
-0.13956132531166077,
-0.2528449594974518,
0.9593690037727356,
0.7499670386314392,
0.5664160847663879,
0.007700471207499504,
1.0296119451522827,
-0.18045002222061157,
0.7248631715774536,
-0.2661326229572296,
0.7790212035179138,
-0.6320174336433411,
0.21229101717472076,
-0.3189948797225952,
-0.8948603868484497,
-0.2443845421075821,
0.6647683382034302,
-0.11257901042699814,
0.06820275634527206,
0.5852782726287842,
0.6102952361106873,
0.06989514082670212,
0.23796942830085754,
0.16486583650112152,
-0.01937391795217991,
0.32541194558143616,
0.34700438380241394,
1.0332006216049194,
-0.4863457977771759,
0.6506320238113403,
0.10674367845058441,
-0.16397997736930847,
-0.5413177609443665,
-0.6329833269119263,
-0.9649364352226257,
-0.7278702259063721,
-0.04881182312965393,
-0.25295233726501465,
0.17557145655155182,
0.7261046767234802,
0.4717179834842682,
-0.9634281396865845,
-0.00848021823912859,
0.03037288971245289,
0.02113921009004116,
0.2729140818119049,
-0.23563718795776367,
0.19349320232868195,
-0.37098395824432373,
-0.8313499689102173,
0.21653296053409576,
0.5700811147689819,
0.13530847430229187,
-0.39917537569999695,
-0.120320163667202,
-0.6595985889434814,
0.18837712705135345,
0.9154658317565918,
-0.05634280666708946,
-0.6110565662384033,
-0.6443052291870117,
0.00359197030775249,
-0.42350611090660095,
-0.0781359151005745,
0.7721547484397888,
-0.6676914095878601,
0.3986157476902008,
0.6288811564445496,
0.797211229801178,
0.4560515582561493,
0.24523110687732697,
0.3143047094345093,
-0.5098031759262085,
0.025198280811309814,
0.3616469204425812,
0.192489355802536,
0.4638076424598694,
-0.3797508180141449,
0.5895596146583557,
0.4815509021282196,
-0.815187931060791,
-0.9579530954360962,
0.10718907415866852,
-0.8080947995185852,
-0.40755030512809753,
0.9489467144012451,
0.059442803263664246,
-0.1816895455121994,
-0.5430994629859924,
-0.43529829382896423,
0.37130582332611084,
-0.25209930539131165,
0.7411075234413147,
0.7164983153343201,
0.058249007910490036,
-0.3305761218070984,
-0.6115880012512207,
0.232131689786911,
0.1836034208536148,
-1.0075037479400635,
-0.11087959259748459,
0.6464707255363464,
0.23183713853359222,
0.27316173911094666,
0.6575047969818115,
-0.323565810918808,
0.3406693637371063,
-0.1491275280714035,
-0.029010483995079994,
-0.07405377179384232,
-0.5734062194824219,
-0.19075024127960205,
0.24671122431755066,
-0.10634946823120117,
-0.027945637702941895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02977v1 | Large Language Models as Evaluators for Scientific Synthesis | 2024-07-03T10:21:27 | 2024-07-03T10:21:27 | Julia Evans, Jennifer D'Souza, Sören Auer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT | Our study explores how well the state-of-the-art Large Language Models
(LLMs), like GPT-4 and Mistral, can assess the quality of scientific summaries
or, more fittingly, scientific syntheses, comparing their evaluations to those
of human annotators. We used a dataset of 100 research questions and their
syntheses made by GPT-4 from abstracts of five related papers, checked against
human quality ratings. The study evaluates both the closed-source GPT-4 and the
open-source Mistral model's ability to rate these summaries and provide reasons
for their judgments. Preliminary results show that LLMs can offer logical
explanations that somewhat match the quality ratings, yet a deeper statistical
analysis shows a weak correlation between LLM and human ratings, suggesting the
potential and current limitations of LLMs in scientific synthesis evaluation. | [
-0.49592334032058716,
-0.370195597410202,
0.8786965012550354,
0.21185041964054108,
-0.1608319878578186,
0.10733798891305923,
-0.39077553153038025,
-0.6421821713447571,
0.11380025744438171,
0.25466957688331604,
0.005344127304852009,
-0.38746771216392517,
-0.43522608280181885,
0.7182840704917908,
-0.7759978175163269,
1.2050710916519165,
-0.20420512557029724,
0.2731735408306122,
-0.33872681856155396,
0.2284822314977646,
0.11166516691446304,
-0.6460882425308228,
-0.48182401061058044,
-0.3828255832195282,
0.6320229172706604,
-0.24747292697429657,
0.72292560338974,
0.3765023350715637,
0.6416953206062317,
0.35971933603286743,
-0.2061036229133606,
0.017797483131289482,
-0.4338993728160858,
0.2738901376724243,
-0.2511039972305298,
-0.26207831501960754,
-0.6309689879417419,
0.29698097705841064,
0.7116544842720032,
0.6239053010940552,
0.11028924584388733,
0.2538563013076782,
-0.003887868020683527,
0.6000747084617615,
-0.1949615627527237,
0.2262871414422989,
-0.5593045949935913,
-0.03663197159767151,
0.03162660449743271,
-0.1202775239944458,
-0.2448582500219345,
-0.6552150249481201,
0.30110159516334534,
-0.40191441774368286,
0.5779293179512024,
-0.023802217096090317,
0.7026841640472412,
0.09422638267278671,
-0.024525867775082588,
-0.31391310691833496,
-0.7092248797416687,
0.7169359922409058,
-1.2074306011199951,
0.42541494965553284,
0.276687890291214,
0.2606780529022217,
-0.351441353559494,
-0.8806986212730408,
-0.7511733174324036,
-0.586267352104187,
0.07109824568033218,
0.21679897606372833,
-0.2562048137187958,
0.052336327731609344,
0.24636611342430115,
0.44098222255706787,
-0.6311152577400208,
-0.09310627728700638,
-0.8051007986068726,
-0.24921150505542755,
0.7312259674072266,
0.2673827111721039,
0.24533677101135254,
-0.19586186110973358,
-0.13289210200309753,
0.11436109989881516,
-0.816011905670166,
-0.29366710782051086,
0.29226797819137573,
0.09985761344432831,
0.24309873580932617,
0.7523156404495239,
-0.06027206778526306,
0.7248387336730957,
-0.2171216607093811,
-0.10956931859254837,
-0.009832930751144886,
-0.8218082785606384,
-0.16934876143932343,
-0.08105577528476715,
1.2164742946624756,
0.5697559714317322,
0.1735159456729889,
0.010391464456915855,
-0.4631161391735077,
0.17957474291324615,
0.02494223229587078,
-1.0122648477554321,
-0.26291516423225403,
0.13947829604148865,
-0.3528543710708618,
-0.4048333466053009,
0.10309764742851257,
-0.49384137988090515,
-0.2204006463289261,
-0.378675252199173,
0.2897356450557709,
-0.08000621199607849,
-0.2675834894180298,
0.06486985832452774,
-0.3396137058734894,
-0.16539938747882843,
0.5567371845245361,
-0.7425057888031006,
0.3946393132209778,
0.6482784748077393,
1.013920545578003,
-0.32490861415863037,
-0.4925699830055237,
-0.16553805768489838,
-0.08279815316200256,
-0.6564463376998901,
0.833283543586731,
-0.3462236821651459,
-0.5265732407569885,
-0.3586653769016266,
-0.2929631173610687,
0.19797730445861816,
-0.5190144777297974,
0.389324426651001,
-0.431633323431015,
0.5116584897041321,
-0.5120446681976318,
-0.4249299168586731,
-0.22828273475170135,
0.032554592937231064,
-0.7772436738014221,
0.7749329209327698,
0.25935471057891846,
-0.761231005191803,
0.3638559579849243,
-0.6415923833847046,
-0.2579500377178192,
0.08081404119729996,
-0.14572450518608093,
-0.08236941695213318,
0.2708331048488617,
0.12060107290744781,
0.35658174753189087,
-0.7112705707550049,
0.48750388622283936,
-0.2161218374967575,
-0.21377621591091156,
0.7541990876197815,
-0.4880853295326233,
0.2787841260433197,
0.45487910509109497,
-0.15204530954360962,
0.24872294068336487,
-0.49530845880508423,
-0.09346441924571991,
-0.0906476378440857,
-0.44163188338279724,
-0.285594642162323,
-0.0485658161342144,
0.13635221123695374,
0.23079802095890045,
0.16380418837070465,
-0.4620571434497833,
0.13421601057052612,
-0.3672894835472107,
0.8220827579498291,
0.5318354964256287,
0.2642766535282135,
0.11489287763834,
-0.29036808013916016,
0.5832149982452393,
-0.43570950627326965,
-0.05530689284205437,
-0.12048587948083878,
-0.5640124082565308,
-0.45003101229667664,
-0.30306145548820496,
0.4526160657405853,
-0.08064335584640503,
-0.42899563908576965,
0.2636899948120117,
-0.24242205917835236,
-0.7073294520378113,
-0.5336307883262634,
0.01593879424035549,
0.29770731925964355,
0.31901246309280396,
0.06334179639816284,
-0.25177693367004395,
-0.5383217334747314,
-0.8132783770561218,
-0.31553635001182556,
-0.42806893587112427,
-0.21765169501304626,
-0.13805797696113586,
0.8532688617706299,
-0.12939660251140594,
1.0006567239761353,
-0.2985368072986603,
0.17441003024578094,
-0.14680401980876923,
0.14209629595279694,
0.3671785891056061,
0.025118129327893257,
0.4873593747615814,
-0.5650675296783447,
-0.4234369695186615,
0.0651068463921547,
-0.73272705078125,
-0.4079527258872986,
0.1496966928243637,
0.25206565856933594,
0.08598168194293976,
0.44168901443481445,
-0.9225586652755737,
0.109990693628788,
0.669109582901001,
-0.15499183535575867,
1.0017000436782837,
-0.17619504034519196,
0.5511853694915771,
-0.8548943996429443,
0.25255298614501953,
0.018507923930883408,
-0.09175985306501389,
-0.7264919877052307,
-0.07420223951339722,
-0.25302690267562866,
-0.15354220569133759,
-0.30872228741645813,
0.6360531449317932,
-0.4866534471511841,
-0.2350282371044159,
-0.3969029486179352,
0.23226256668567657,
0.155082568526268,
-0.12528790533542633,
0.13341563940048218,
0.8941692113876343,
0.2663594186306,
-0.4731350243091583,
0.2966100871562958,
0.1407248079776764,
-0.5937706232070923,
0.12037485092878342,
-1.1375412940979004,
-0.16199563443660736,
-0.08954767137765884,
0.5216546058654785,
-1.0430212020874023,
-0.6623863577842712,
-0.0793377086520195,
-0.4827876091003418,
0.05781300365924835,
-0.00809059850871563,
-0.5208132266998291,
-0.5264967083930969,
-0.39941200613975525,
0.31993886828422546,
0.47804638743400574,
-0.3170721232891083,
0.3805356025695801,
0.18858741223812103,
-0.6818854808807373,
-0.08311473578214645,
-0.6929885745048523,
0.24242760241031647,
-0.14256161451339722,
-0.5500873923301697,
0.11034485697746277,
-0.25963324308395386,
-0.5882242918014526,
0.12079641222953796,
-0.2565118968486786,
-0.030155880376696587,
-0.06296234577894211,
0.29751330614089966,
0.3626583218574524,
-0.24720174074172974,
-0.12373007833957672,
0.0469486378133297,
-0.05700330808758736,
0.24548473954200745,
0.047562237828969955,
0.2270490676164627,
-0.12201432883739471,
-0.44050225615501404,
-0.30444884300231934,
-0.005220428109169006,
0.950279951095581,
-0.19514478743076324,
0.33012112975120544,
0.3152468204498291,
-0.19109436869621277,
-0.01661617122590542,
-0.645010232925415,
-0.2999662160873413,
-0.4042188823223114,
0.41851624846458435,
-0.25172826647758484,
-1.0683467388153076,
0.5076554417610168,
0.1467886120080948,
0.14113427698612213,
0.6423495411872864,
0.894885241985321,
0.21296945214271545,
1.126799464225769,
-0.06713639944791794,
0.04557402804493904,
0.2510238289833069,
-0.011285211890935898,
0.22145825624465942,
-0.9160866737365723,
0.027959253638982773,
-0.6296045184135437,
0.09313367307186127,
-0.44206908345222473,
-0.42315372824668884,
0.7284654378890991,
0.12856879830360413,
-0.286896675825119,
0.0058738430961966515,
-0.6257248520851135,
0.49458935856819153,
0.19405104219913483,
-0.32415497303009033,
0.38847652077674866,
0.07114540040493011,
0.10968581587076187,
0.10997848212718964,
-0.41102832555770874,
-0.8724298477172852,
1.0602467060089111,
0.6037079095840454,
0.8523232936859131,
0.09281782805919647,
0.589381992816925,
0.11672529578208923,
0.7505320310592651,
-0.6490575075149536,
0.4700812101364136,
0.16974835097789764,
-0.7544890642166138,
-0.37747034430503845,
-0.6853008270263672,
-0.7209983468055725,
0.6683488488197327,
-0.10395295917987823,
-0.41751113533973694,
-0.20200392603874207,
-0.10319680720567703,
-0.26251545548439026,
-0.010915442369878292,
-0.6592001914978027,
0.5348260998725891,
-0.2755741775035858,
-0.09521619230508804,
-0.030643107369542122,
-0.3637053966522217,
0.8187071681022644,
-0.5297178030014038,
0.40332263708114624,
-0.23785749077796936,
0.047687824815511703,
0.9647783637046814,
-0.36400261521339417,
0.6613314747810364,
0.02268344536423683,
-0.15804237127304077,
0.4074416756629944,
0.2997627556324005,
0.0970032662153244,
0.10475717484951019,
-0.2822108268737793,
0.367328405380249,
0.20535804331302643,
0.03731808811426163,
-0.5360517501831055,
0.9145187139511108,
-0.8470371961593628,
-0.8138318657875061,
-0.6184037923812866,
-0.560275673866272,
-0.01508256047964096,
0.24904736876487732,
0.3246791958808899,
0.2506111264228821,
-0.3698183596134186,
0.05225382372736931,
0.12061954289674759,
-0.2056955099105835,
0.24628470838069916,
0.5725815892219543,
-0.4689212143421173,
-0.717923641204834,
0.6211640238761902,
0.02184455096721649,
0.481256902217865,
0.1038077101111412,
0.4694924056529999,
-0.20409353077411652,
-0.8249905109405518,
-0.34564799070358276,
0.5120119452476501,
-0.7225428819656372,
-0.10098524391651154,
-0.5436921715736389,
-0.31532344222068787,
-0.29638129472732544,
0.0832502469420433,
-0.2979710102081299,
-0.6026031374931335,
-0.1888953149318695,
-0.24574868381023407,
0.22417519986629486,
1.2615445852279663,
0.06574362516403198,
-0.07968433201313019,
-0.7516154050827026,
0.2178642302751541,
0.2494603991508484,
0.13767801225185394,
0.14011290669441223,
-0.5778341889381409,
-0.12703333795070648,
0.043233875185251236,
-0.2661550045013428,
-0.7601218223571777,
0.46045514941215515,
-0.045781731605529785,
0.4694409966468811,
0.2476881593465805,
-0.31446152925491333,
0.43553322553634644,
-0.6579317450523376,
1.3518487215042114,
0.4260443449020386,
-0.9785144329071045,
0.22552472352981567,
-0.4012920558452606,
0.23160597681999207,
0.3103986978530884,
0.5438400506973267,
-0.22368332743644714,
-0.7543501853942871,
-0.25124913454055786,
-0.6526705026626587,
0.3705682158470154,
0.3707572817802429,
-0.09579242020845413,
-0.11598217487335205,
0.2723627984523773,
0.3195701539516449,
0.21829354763031006,
-0.6713454127311707,
0.11583138257265091,
-0.2980966567993164,
-0.0718027651309967,
-0.2904681861400604,
-0.2836768329143524,
-0.2247544527053833,
-0.17163394391536713,
0.5648245811462402,
0.06866933405399323,
0.06571082770824432,
0.2983899712562561,
0.21347977221012115,
-0.33479729294776917,
0.4182751774787903,
0.8892936110496521,
1.1655170917510986,
-0.2606325149536133,
0.2677842676639557,
-0.06946815550327301,
-0.4032975137233734,
0.16409988701343536,
0.07399390637874603,
-0.20091769099235535,
0.18422889709472656,
0.6995670795440674,
0.6163832545280457,
0.032076645642519,
-0.5856045484542847,
0.47657299041748047,
-0.1940060406923294,
-0.4086115062236786,
-0.10701718926429749,
0.08808083832263947,
0.1884397566318512,
0.09036486595869064,
0.3819398880004883,
0.06658172607421875,
0.2736336290836334,
-0.4551967680454254,
-0.117918960750103,
0.4182073175907135,
-0.03725074231624603,
-0.881634533405304,
0.7971788644790649,
0.027804860845208168,
0.011087771505117416,
0.2574489116668701,
0.05235530436038971,
-0.6443610191345215,
0.3025219738483429,
0.5624159574508667,
0.7521274089813232,
-0.40879878401756287,
0.14298713207244873,
0.39377260208129883,
0.36218351125717163,
-0.46961724758148193,
0.30495813488960266,
0.15782727301120758,
-0.3930515944957733,
-0.8043992519378662,
-0.8551996350288391,
-0.6029825210571289,
0.1828373521566391,
-0.4352007806301117,
0.06887686997652054,
-0.19820022583007812,
-0.4615761637687683,
0.5110181570053101,
-0.4361152648925781,
-0.5153268575668335,
-0.09606019407510757,
-0.11792778223752975,
0.6371460556983948,
-0.9934216141700745,
0.523087739944458,
0.6280102133750916,
-0.7601290941238403,
-0.8200358152389526,
-0.2811843752861023,
-0.05647832900285721,
-0.18015161156654358,
0.9013988375663757,
-0.21580477058887482,
0.017007630318403244,
-0.2572876513004303,
-0.5063391327857971,
-1.0148444175720215,
0.8950433731079102,
0.41587504744529724,
-0.5132943391799927,
-0.10194183140993118,
0.003688122145831585,
1.0287144184112549,
-0.20764358341693878,
0.5573935508728027,
0.5728779435157776,
0.7207819819450378,
0.08840419352054596,
-1.3874311447143555,
0.13979870080947876,
-0.21265394985675812,
0.03815197944641113,
0.16003437340259552,
-0.3737740218639374,
1.029634952545166,
-0.22977156937122345,
-0.17025108635425568,
0.3850027024745941,
0.5854600071907043,
0.48572102189064026,
0.33389824628829956,
0.06394080817699432,
0.14459992945194244,
0.5498137474060059,
-0.08329512923955917,
1.289237380027771,
-0.22996416687965393,
0.34157276153564453,
0.7991455793380737,
-0.4964371919631958,
0.8227162957191467,
0.5933650732040405,
-0.5042301416397095,
0.3335984945297241,
0.508701503276825,
-0.11267590522766113,
0.3819223940372467,
0.45954203605651855,
-0.24375662207603455,
-0.006968265864998102,
0.024736672639846802,
-0.440299391746521,
0.23351271450519562,
0.37918806076049805,
-0.6005105972290039,
-0.15070800483226776,
-0.17012754082679749,
-0.02036837674677372,
-0.17826925218105316,
-0.14233867824077606,
0.7320774793624878,
0.3451922833919525,
-0.8144853115081787,
0.9064589738845825,
-0.01757858507335186,
0.23471523821353912,
-0.6234824061393738,
-0.16102944314479828,
-0.08011896163225174,
-0.18962103128433228,
-0.4527789354324341,
-0.9014200568199158,
0.019069787114858627,
0.2269144505262375,
-0.21083472669124603,
0.12162430584430695,
0.3545423448085785,
-0.43137797713279724,
-0.3615943491458893,
-0.17941589653491974,
0.5275471210479736,
0.5848503708839417,
-0.00258045457303524,
-0.33310505747795105,
0.21619728207588196,
0.010841323994100094,
-0.5306974053382874,
0.23072433471679688,
0.45564523339271545,
-0.3115856647491455,
0.6100651621818542,
0.960181474685669,
0.5478734374046326,
-0.171439990401268,
0.19878190755844116,
0.8712717890739441,
-0.6997142434120178,
-0.23082594573497772,
-0.9803316593170166,
0.22252105176448822,
0.21754242479801178,
-0.15603597462177277,
1.0047578811645508,
0.5750108957290649,
0.5165542364120483,
-0.2992911636829376,
1.158744215965271,
0.14511427283287048,
0.3526453971862793,
-0.4704629182815552,
0.84670090675354,
-0.1044175997376442,
0.3477734923362732,
-0.5096781849861145,
-1.2859902381896973,
-0.28877490758895874,
0.4462830424308777,
-0.27696582674980164,
0.2590090334415436,
0.8975430130958557,
0.6311086416244507,
-0.03868811950087547,
0.2091895192861557,
0.37420326471328735,
0.5253397226333618,
0.7840398550033569,
0.2177094966173172,
1.1979364156723022,
0.004644820466637611,
0.17872688174247742,
0.2803243398666382,
-0.35260242223739624,
-0.006325278896838427,
-0.9644709825515747,
-1.0393885374069214,
-0.6272620558738708,
-0.09821260720491409,
-0.27374744415283203,
-0.22811359167099,
0.9021844267845154,
0.3677624464035034,
-0.7611148953437805,
-0.23083895444869995,
0.005085034295916557,
-0.07164213061332703,
0.050028178840875626,
-0.2217724472284317,
0.5822399258613586,
-0.025166373699903488,
-0.5826027989387512,
0.5663626194000244,
0.32094600796699524,
0.09026792645454407,
-0.7036238312721252,
-0.12182600051164627,
0.41266873478889465,
0.2520833909511566,
0.8199523687362671,
-0.026697028428316116,
-1.215409278869629,
-0.19318553805351257,
-0.1327420473098755,
-0.0637526735663414,
-0.39037129282951355,
0.7802660465240479,
-0.4625839293003082,
0.5201351642608643,
0.7473493814468384,
0.39063262939453125,
0.4243527948856354,
0.11731341481208801,
0.7477121353149414,
-0.23486697673797607,
-0.34718066453933716,
0.25285452604293823,
0.45499464869499207,
0.5562644004821777,
0.039117876440286636,
0.49755868315696716,
0.01422359049320221,
-0.8988133668899536,
-1.039226770401001,
-0.007131111808121204,
-0.9118978381156921,
-0.11544840782880783,
1.3916529417037964,
-0.06051356717944145,
-0.21170730888843536,
0.05096045136451721,
-0.3927270472049713,
-0.07134531438350677,
-0.43117210268974304,
0.8270404934883118,
0.8607223629951477,
-0.33021441102027893,
0.16985534131526947,
-0.7171728014945984,
0.5332599878311157,
-0.04422542080283165,
-0.8476119041442871,
0.1306053102016449,
0.790385901927948,
0.5914281606674194,
0.4059188961982727,
0.5600182414054871,
-0.3775271773338318,
0.4411596953868866,
-0.12744775414466858,
0.22014190256595612,
-0.3257727324962616,
-0.0024406735319644213,
-0.22174793481826782,
0.04895278066396713,
0.5297379493713379,
0.5855842232704163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02964v1 | FSM: A Finite State Machine Based Zero-Shot Prompting Paradigm for Multi-Hop Question Answering | 2024-07-03T10:01:01 | 2024-07-03T10:01:01 | Xiaochen Wang, Junqing He, Zhe yang, Yiru Wang, Xiangdi Meng, Kunhao Pan, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) with chain-of-thought (COT) prompting have
demonstrated impressive abilities on simple nature language inference tasks.
However, they tend to perform poorly on Multi-hop Question Answering (MHQA)
tasks due to several challenges, including hallucination, error propagation and
limited context length. We propose a prompting method, Finite State Machine
(FSM) to enhance the reasoning capabilities of LLM for complex tasks in
addition to improved effectiveness and trustworthiness. Different from COT
methods, FSM addresses MHQA by iteratively decomposing a question into
multi-turn sub-questions, and self-correcting in time, improving the accuracy
of answers in each step. Specifically, FSM addresses one sub-question at a time
and decides on the next step based on its current result and state, in an
automaton-like format. Experiments on benchmarks show the effectiveness of our
method. Although our method performs on par with the baseline on relatively
simpler datasets, it excels on challenging datasets like Musique. Moreover,
this approach mitigates the hallucination phenomenon, wherein the correct final
answer can be recovered despite errors in intermediate reasoning. Furthermore,
our method improves LLMs' ability to follow specified output format
requirements, significantly reducing the difficulty of answer interpretation
and the need for reformatting. | [
-0.3732976019382477,
-1.250349760055542,
0.9587568044662476,
0.04564916342496872,
-0.2795998156070709,
0.09402944892644882,
0.000068928740802221,
-0.25837162137031555,
0.1538812220096588,
0.21568159759044647,
-0.9605996608734131,
-0.25112786889076233,
-0.17051245272159576,
0.5663725137710571,
-0.20903508365154266,
0.584437906742096,
-0.19241076707839966,
-0.1531202793121338,
-0.15741239488124847,
0.1895865648984909,
-0.6051741242408752,
-0.37467604875564575,
-0.7234628796577454,
-0.5001464486122131,
0.6379914283752441,
0.32633087038993835,
0.5898669362068176,
0.4884423017501831,
-0.1914365291595459,
0.342629611492157,
-0.05297554284334183,
0.5047975182533264,
-0.19235515594482422,
0.5936934947967529,
-0.24511221051216125,
-0.711165189743042,
-0.23797166347503662,
-0.21962271630764008,
0.6871031522750854,
0.4750005304813385,
0.08680499345064163,
0.15934492647647858,
-0.21723994612693787,
0.516033947467804,
-0.6808977127075195,
0.13159024715423584,
-0.8935373425483704,
0.130415678024292,
0.11663006246089935,
-0.6447775959968567,
-0.632114589214325,
-0.2798519432544708,
-0.06248890236020088,
-0.453624427318573,
-0.0831608697772026,
0.10358192026615143,
0.4784172773361206,
0.6061838269233704,
-0.3107844889163971,
-0.00806199200451374,
-0.6730254888534546,
0.6631048917770386,
-0.5357035994529724,
0.455677330493927,
0.21371468901634216,
0.3260134756565094,
-0.40360933542251587,
-0.12569056451320648,
-0.9003710150718689,
-0.17510655522346497,
0.24640662968158722,
-0.06305022537708282,
-0.09630633145570755,
0.13713933527469635,
0.49967533349990845,
0.31664469838142395,
-0.5347588658332825,
-0.328614205121994,
-0.07952579110860825,
-0.4426935017108917,
0.42509138584136963,
0.31943169236183167,
0.22913432121276855,
-0.1747221201658249,
-0.28492116928100586,
-0.262962281703949,
-0.6675809621810913,
0.30464255809783936,
0.05303020775318146,
0.573935329914093,
0.19224590063095093,
0.5814701914787292,
-0.5369040966033936,
0.9714251160621643,
0.1354963779449463,
-0.21368689835071564,
0.1799779087305069,
-0.07167704403400421,
-0.37589865922927856,
0.029562631621956825,
0.6478617191314697,
0.09262597560882568,
0.2883467972278595,
-0.047114450484514236,
-0.12468188256025314,
-0.05511017143726349,
0.17422181367874146,
-0.5901044011116028,
-0.03900214284658432,
0.6880567073822021,
-0.0691194012761116,
0.050912607461214066,
-0.027760261669754982,
-0.7141771912574768,
-0.2140028029680252,
-0.3969857394695282,
0.9288365244865417,
-0.6883841753005981,
-0.27790606021881104,
0.23719869554042816,
-0.06154001131653786,
0.4838836193084717,
0.55681973695755,
-0.6834446787834167,
-0.08035256713628769,
0.6164919137954712,
0.9375432729721069,
0.07911384850740433,
-0.4469134211540222,
-0.9180452227592468,
0.01926114223897457,
-0.5724026560783386,
0.786348819732666,
-0.44358325004577637,
-0.2597840428352356,
-0.13640236854553223,
0.0408843457698822,
-0.393178254365921,
-0.2896173894405365,
0.11974693089723587,
-0.6468278765678406,
-0.03383057191967964,
-0.46100151538848877,
-0.5317894220352173,
-0.3586898148059845,
0.5736509561538696,
-0.5026861429214478,
0.9784275889396667,
-0.00476058479398489,
-0.5465806722640991,
0.04840531572699547,
-0.7512908577919006,
-0.3483867645263672,
-0.15271179378032684,
-0.3546159565448761,
0.06680293381214142,
0.037285126745700836,
0.5306758284568787,
0.5772213935852051,
0.009868119843304157,
0.17673006653785706,
-0.21124905347824097,
-0.5003207325935364,
0.27368202805519104,
-0.5801411271095276,
0.6356668472290039,
0.24208591878414154,
-0.36189424991607666,
0.16741645336151123,
-0.4356076121330261,
0.357703298330307,
0.27534016966819763,
-0.2020409107208252,
-0.11566685140132904,
-0.25512418150901794,
-0.6799865365028381,
0.4077833890914917,
-0.008065937086939812,
-0.6128044128417969,
0.25887611508369446,
-0.5588991045951843,
0.27935343980789185,
0.7965359687805176,
0.3277396559715271,
0.2678694725036621,
-0.6184163689613342,
0.7395063638687134,
0.02443198300898075,
-0.0032901400700211525,
-0.7199287414550781,
-0.5600775480270386,
-0.629044234752655,
-0.15791459381580353,
-0.02870359644293785,
0.7902944684028625,
-1.115954875946045,
0.34027352929115295,
0.15613900125026703,
-0.3300629258155823,
-0.6444499492645264,
-0.15633244812488556,
0.3884585499763489,
0.5586404204368591,
0.6144227981567383,
0.33680909872055054,
-0.2993584871292114,
-0.3880072832107544,
-0.17218844592571259,
-0.10188817232847214,
-0.009380796924233437,
0.14588843286037445,
0.44200316071510315,
-0.12734976410865784,
1.0892467498779297,
-0.4236195981502533,
0.12497716397047043,
-0.09240599721670151,
0.18532060086727142,
0.32825860381126404,
0.3230147957801819,
0.08406571298837662,
-0.4307863712310791,
-0.06614356487989426,
-0.3712088465690613,
-0.7287624478340149,
0.09049765765666962,
-0.292849063873291,
-0.20171613991260529,
0.27647271752357483,
0.2856449484825134,
-0.7381590008735657,
0.11985199898481369,
0.3360411524772644,
-0.2596137225627899,
0.7358000874519348,
-0.04592977836728096,
0.5735589265823364,
-0.9775017499923706,
0.056187547743320465,
-0.3555193841457367,
-0.13542771339416504,
-0.6163620352745056,
0.0993989109992981,
-0.010799826122820377,
-0.11657324433326721,
-0.49400922656059265,
0.5835495591163635,
-0.3415088653564453,
0.04899680241942406,
-0.265174001455307,
-0.013593589887022972,
0.06917160004377365,
0.5013101696968079,
0.017351264134049416,
0.9205839037895203,
0.5740845203399658,
-0.8836438059806824,
0.3648982048034668,
0.2913535237312317,
0.01839067041873932,
0.43006110191345215,
-0.43501394987106323,
0.4762899577617645,
-0.4203217327594757,
0.4551561772823334,
-1.1623491048812866,
-0.1935194730758667,
0.2630299925804138,
-0.6462580561637878,
0.13942958414554596,
0.035647064447402954,
-0.45039623975753784,
-0.6009953618049622,
-0.32044926285743713,
0.25278615951538086,
0.13627417385578156,
-0.44098982214927673,
0.557421863079071,
-0.13322438299655914,
-0.0373811312019825,
-0.6886752247810364,
-0.5314463973045349,
-0.08307043462991714,
0.08612660318613052,
-0.4844343960285187,
-0.01951632648706436,
-0.407408744096756,
-0.12538647651672363,
-0.3399296700954437,
-0.5121332406997681,
-0.0639081597328186,
0.0330999493598938,
0.06099461764097214,
0.402863085269928,
-0.30211228132247925,
0.3132731020450592,
0.46436429023742676,
-0.24955318868160248,
0.23184552788734436,
-0.4087146818637848,
0.7648387551307678,
-0.2563197612762451,
-0.41457608342170715,
-0.8543390035629272,
0.39984774589538574,
0.6906118988990784,
-0.20259588956832886,
0.4379168450832367,
0.17040669918060303,
-0.3874399960041046,
-0.3173788785934448,
-0.3237679600715637,
-0.6233195662498474,
-0.4664508104324341,
-0.2464209347963333,
-0.8549527525901794,
-1.30357825756073,
0.1260640025138855,
-0.2103186547756195,
0.4225385785102844,
0.2594362497329712,
0.503470778465271,
-0.03981245681643486,
0.9885002374649048,
0.16206693649291992,
-0.01246530283242464,
0.1064322292804718,
-0.19504746794700623,
0.2617042064666748,
-0.5441233515739441,
-0.35559576749801636,
-0.6629918813705444,
-0.0641181617975235,
-0.004680715501308441,
-0.7939899563789368,
0.35494235157966614,
0.08457012474536896,
-0.37938204407691956,
0.09308703243732452,
-0.5480817556381226,
0.47277894616127014,
0.32681915163993835,
0.14177986979484558,
0.43421003222465515,
0.04297679290175438,
-0.6526384353637695,
0.14833477139472961,
-0.7244917750358582,
-0.41370341181755066,
0.6764687299728394,
0.23422609269618988,
0.855448305606842,
-0.08930757641792297,
0.9329582452774048,
0.19371171295642853,
-0.05880596861243248,
-1.1241852045059204,
0.5310423374176025,
0.41876181960105896,
-0.7502458691596985,
-0.7546418905258179,
-0.39979299902915955,
-0.6644381284713745,
0.4541536867618561,
-0.38215357065200806,
-0.847386360168457,
-0.1661374866962433,
0.4695688784122467,
-0.8983560800552368,
0.39590662717819214,
-0.25363826751708984,
0.4537692666053772,
-0.029400136321783066,
-0.1451680213212967,
-0.06025795638561249,
-0.5949010848999023,
0.3993074893951416,
-0.034384310245513916,
0.13013912737369537,
-0.3611833155155182,
-0.03956614434719086,
0.42019614577293396,
-0.4198455810546875,
0.5499269366264343,
-0.3344246745109558,
-0.3403879404067993,
0.4614422917366028,
0.5235796570777893,
0.5330763459205627,
-0.053791891783475876,
-0.39875394105911255,
-0.06437744945287704,
0.24655918776988983,
-0.11857576668262482,
-0.8332579135894775,
0.5517699122428894,
-0.4731397330760956,
-0.7510858774185181,
-0.3411397635936737,
-0.7838247418403625,
-0.6274376511573792,
0.1456993669271469,
0.11691094934940338,
0.4384964108467102,
0.33053216338157654,
0.08341144025325775,
0.9491043090820312,
-0.1664150357246399,
0.4981253743171692,
0.38991668820381165,
-0.32359132170677185,
-0.5576314330101013,
0.6218963265419006,
-0.1583346575498581,
0.33183524012565613,
0.5928069949150085,
0.45987212657928467,
-0.808671236038208,
-0.09661120176315308,
-0.9576601386070251,
0.20908592641353607,
-0.5823737382888794,
-0.35899218916893005,
-1.0099788904190063,
-0.19920462369918823,
-0.372555136680603,
-0.3306775987148285,
-0.20401477813720703,
-0.28143802285194397,
0.08585119992494583,
-0.06445755809545517,
0.6648699045181274,
0.3758891522884369,
0.07096223533153534,
0.1566726267337799,
-0.981074333190918,
0.5692431330680847,
0.4592340290546417,
0.2791009843349457,
0.26522570848464966,
-0.4781736433506012,
0.31910380721092224,
0.11419843882322311,
-0.11035685986280441,
-1.078544020652771,
-0.24036307632923126,
0.04737843573093414,
0.5782889723777771,
0.43646883964538574,
0.3722628653049469,
0.9406875371932983,
-0.5412291884422302,
0.7346152067184448,
0.2720593810081482,
-1.1916142702102661,
0.7984723448753357,
-0.41959473490715027,
0.5560469627380371,
0.6274332404136658,
0.5465565919876099,
-0.5841509103775024,
-0.5440266728401184,
-0.4023721516132355,
-0.5691800713539124,
0.6775333285331726,
0.05798814818263054,
0.22284531593322754,
-0.17118322849273682,
0.5390245318412781,
0.11157048493623734,
0.17359349131584167,
-0.4782486855983734,
-0.3022141456604004,
-0.12520870566368103,
0.04356083646416664,
0.24422235786914825,
0.00607736362144351,
0.03295484930276871,
-0.38396573066711426,
0.8345115184783936,
-0.5317977070808411,
0.4308333694934845,
0.584383487701416,
-0.11330296844244003,
-0.35661134123802185,
0.5677344799041748,
0.523457944393158,
0.6266558766365051,
0.08111021667718887,
0.16781732439994812,
0.5095488429069519,
0.009832234121859074,
0.5834997296333313,
-0.31004828214645386,
-0.3891882002353668,
0.05370752885937691,
0.07237322628498077,
0.5491207838058472,
0.05300438031554222,
-0.5535032153129578,
0.27672916650772095,
0.126587375998497,
-0.5439019799232483,
0.0377689003944397,
0.48915326595306396,
0.024233324453234673,
0.3431021571159363,
0.5595356822013855,
-0.26621246337890625,
0.011368970386683941,
-0.4128408432006836,
0.4404070973396301,
0.2943422496318817,
-0.3513808250427246,
0.07296182215213776,
0.6527351140975952,
-0.03370371460914612,
-0.35018646717071533,
0.5673852562904358,
-0.054959218949079514,
-0.4291899800300598,
0.37731289863586426,
0.8422636389732361,
0.6558873653411865,
-0.5775030255317688,
0.42117488384246826,
0.637637734413147,
0.4113987386226654,
-0.1365041583776474,
0.824062168598175,
-0.3517337143421173,
-0.7234276533126831,
-0.7839027643203735,
-0.7935882806777954,
-0.603506863117218,
0.2818467617034912,
-0.38604480028152466,
-0.01760992407798767,
-0.7477672696113586,
0.032580144703388214,
-0.10686107724905014,
-0.028776761144399643,
-0.12905865907669067,
0.3947303891181946,
0.26341870427131653,
1.1992058753967285,
-0.7750996947288513,
0.7044194936752319,
0.6040998697280884,
-0.25297197699546814,
-1.2307108640670776,
0.20752200484275818,
0.34117382764816284,
-0.5957168340682983,
-0.03151603788137436,
0.4823315739631653,
-0.7225932478904724,
0.20298825204372406,
-0.5727605223655701,
-0.7812885642051697,
1.0036629438400269,
0.3644135594367981,
-0.4996176064014435,
0.2304464876651764,
0.051304880529642105,
0.17809909582138062,
-0.2832699716091156,
0.0545707568526268,
0.5303601026535034,
0.6074609160423279,
0.5958468317985535,
-0.6083860397338867,
0.45871347188949585,
-0.05998442694544792,
-0.11919664591550827,
0.2713935375213623,
-0.45078518986701965,
0.7741794586181641,
-0.5552175045013428,
-0.1291562169790268,
0.17585179209709167,
0.6811462044715881,
0.9462687373161316,
0.3975655138492584,
0.9561723470687866,
0.1712970733642578,
1.2033283710479736,
-0.053486112505197525,
0.5810336470603943,
-0.17746634781360626,
0.09428268671035767,
1.1126176118850708,
-0.34742704033851624,
0.9410005807876587,
0.5686157941818237,
-0.12031088769435883,
0.6769213080406189,
0.7055222988128662,
0.22397245466709137,
0.0928334966301918,
0.33918580412864685,
-0.3966115117073059,
-0.6145047545433044,
0.16466082632541656,
-0.30450668931007385,
0.5352162718772888,
0.25471511483192444,
0.04510645568370819,
-0.3970046043395996,
0.04445774108171463,
0.26036399602890015,
-0.039691537618637085,
-0.2905586063861847,
0.577218770980835,
0.15906506776809692,
-0.9550706744194031,
0.7049151062965393,
-0.18092069029808044,
0.4458433985710144,
-0.6169190406799316,
-0.21356835961341858,
-0.16587688028812408,
-0.17591328918933868,
-0.18467068672180176,
-0.7295415997505188,
0.4427024722099304,
0.10837648808956146,
-0.3266221880912781,
-0.1584777534008026,
0.5642780065536499,
-0.3916257619857788,
-0.11210699379444122,
0.2887648940086365,
0.7308141589164734,
0.39994746446609497,
-0.30764666199684143,
-0.9171846508979797,
0.019126707687973976,
-0.12593741714954376,
-0.08500798046588898,
-0.16015943884849548,
0.45466944575309753,
-0.1816924512386322,
0.7618642449378967,
0.9046106338500977,
-0.22939635813236237,
0.03185570612549782,
0.150694340467453,
0.7141379117965698,
-0.8128763437271118,
-0.6306518316268921,
-0.9007421731948853,
0.5169618725776672,
0.13560539484024048,
0.015066520310938358,
0.6337398290634155,
0.31370630860328674,
0.49592137336730957,
-0.08944883942604065,
0.6780391335487366,
-0.09524411708116531,
0.44150304794311523,
-0.6677423715591431,
0.5878749489784241,
-0.6381592154502869,
-0.1111266165971756,
-0.3631979525089264,
-0.8082420825958252,
-0.3277299404144287,
0.6520727276802063,
-0.09122773259878159,
-0.0456569530069828,
0.868068277835846,
0.9713089466094971,
0.27839669585227966,
0.2642931044101715,
0.6046693921089172,
0.09541201591491699,
0.08465151488780975,
0.5629245638847351,
1.0922157764434814,
-0.1931714564561844,
0.5325636863708496,
-0.06736554205417633,
-0.34311044216156006,
-0.10960818827152252,
-0.7753629088401794,
-0.7823851704597473,
-0.5101592540740967,
-0.172481507062912,
-0.35694003105163574,
-0.058663878589868546,
1.3080676794052124,
0.6767038106918335,
-0.931064784526825,
0.010712992399930954,
0.06798610091209412,
0.32996657490730286,
-0.44012996554374695,
-0.22146087884902954,
0.03243740648031235,
-0.6694996953010559,
-0.5555120706558228,
0.832770586013794,
0.5435479879379272,
-0.06126927211880684,
-0.26570889353752136,
-0.08983571082353592,
-0.4042064845561981,
0.3806406855583191,
0.8046227693557739,
0.2719048261642456,
-0.9263732433319092,
-0.4077438712120056,
0.3790823519229889,
0.24712873995304108,
0.039508361369371414,
0.8784921765327454,
-0.7302513718605042,
0.5965442657470703,
0.48779231309890747,
0.8602278232574463,
0.17923270165920258,
0.025937458500266075,
0.46122515201568604,
-0.4847323000431061,
-0.08856866508722305,
0.14471383392810822,
0.21133381128311157,
0.15080806612968445,
-0.5990609526634216,
0.196414515376091,
0.15619494020938873,
-0.31385648250579834,
-0.4615652859210968,
0.2545227110385895,
-0.7966635227203369,
-0.474632203578949,
1.063523530960083,
-0.13541822135448456,
-0.4097060263156891,
-0.4063309133052826,
-0.2957812249660492,
0.32335272431373596,
-0.48751768469810486,
0.6040025949478149,
0.538261890411377,
-0.37793660163879395,
-0.26267096400260925,
-0.469472736120224,
0.3983766436576843,
0.4442327320575714,
-0.9409165382385254,
0.06476473063230515,
0.6309164762496948,
0.36788392066955566,
0.09667687863111496,
0.8562215566635132,
-0.12774726748466492,
0.41848111152648926,
-0.07858777046203613,
-0.14367884397506714,
-0.161764457821846,
-0.8599419593811035,
-0.6059625744819641,
0.265320748090744,
0.015430076979100704,
-0.2810078263282776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02960v1 | ObfuscaTune: Obfuscated Offsite Fine-tuning and Inference of Proprietary LLMs on Private Datasets | 2024-07-03T09:54:08 | 2024-07-03T09:54:08 | Ahmed Frikha, Nassim Walha, Ricardo Mendes, Krishna Kanth Nakka, Xue Jiang, Xuebing Zhou | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This work addresses the timely yet underexplored problem of performing
inference and finetuning of a proprietary LLM owned by a model provider entity
on the confidential/private data of another data owner entity, in a way that
ensures the confidentiality of both the model and the data. Hereby, the
finetuning is conducted offsite, i.e., on the computation infrastructure of a
third-party cloud provider. We tackle this problem by proposing ObfuscaTune, a
novel, efficient and fully utility-preserving approach that combines a simple
yet effective obfuscation technique with an efficient usage of confidential
computing (only 5% of the model parameters are placed on TEE). We empirically
demonstrate the effectiveness of ObfuscaTune by validating it on GPT-2 models
with different sizes on four NLP benchmark datasets. Finally, we compare to a
na\"ive version of our approach to highlight the necessity of using random
matrices with low condition numbers in our approach to reduce errors induced by
the obfuscation. | [
-0.32087042927742004,
-0.9886348247528076,
0.45429036021232605,
-0.1521807461977005,
-0.441446989774704,
-0.003887993050739169,
-0.17940326035022736,
-0.4124163091182709,
-0.04420126602053642,
1.0133521556854248,
-0.5864672660827637,
-0.5449174046516418,
-0.33522385358810425,
-0.3918827772140503,
-0.432497501373291,
1.1013574600219727,
0.308912456035614,
-0.07869460433721542,
-0.10442173480987549,
-0.0908336341381073,
-0.12253696471452713,
-0.5390975475311279,
-0.4498744308948517,
-0.11895029991865158,
0.017775775864720345,
0.47764822840690613,
1.0612636804580688,
0.9110392928123474,
0.6105305552482605,
0.24498696625232697,
0.0221120435744524,
0.5623543858528137,
-0.9435731172561646,
0.013998029753565788,
-0.45244860649108887,
-0.6706720590591431,
-0.34606635570526123,
-0.2075958102941513,
0.3257785737514496,
0.5383098125457764,
-0.41504591703414917,
0.5218296051025391,
0.43280094861984253,
0.5242593288421631,
-1.1598985195159912,
-0.23090919852256775,
-0.9707826972007751,
0.18634271621704102,
-0.20875506103038788,
-0.16920685768127441,
-0.38596200942993164,
-0.6017136573791504,
-0.23789860308170319,
-0.697594940662384,
0.4094422161579132,
0.3157183527946472,
0.9142066240310669,
0.7746332883834839,
0.04741470143198967,
0.3057561218738556,
-0.9195990562438965,
0.9756089448928833,
-0.5372560620307922,
0.15424367785453796,
0.7460476160049438,
0.2990184426307678,
-0.14825475215911865,
-0.7476413249969482,
-0.05686000734567642,
0.046336829662323,
0.012161764316260815,
0.07970917224884033,
-0.22378340363502502,
0.10550130903720856,
0.0986333116889,
0.6956053972244263,
-0.23758161067962646,
0.41505932807922363,
-0.22445635497570038,
0.040419332683086395,
0.673264741897583,
0.0708770602941513,
-0.17183543741703033,
0.20240670442581177,
-0.4964885711669922,
0.20113135874271393,
-1.0623321533203125,
-0.15816453099250793,
0.6709255576133728,
0.020841216668486595,
0.10063953697681427,
0.7359452247619629,
-0.2162753939628601,
0.4064866900444031,
0.14043669402599335,
0.08078379184007645,
-0.19543978571891785,
-0.12917210161685944,
-0.7756359577178955,
0.1373748779296875,
0.6260785460472107,
0.3321152925491333,
-0.07430819422006607,
-0.6968410611152649,
-0.07085847109556198,
-0.27659305930137634,
0.23513074219226837,
-0.7297499775886536,
-0.4821634292602539,
0.4769864082336426,
-0.4062657654285431,
-0.4923347532749176,
0.14875061810016632,
-0.8359781503677368,
-0.807705283164978,
-0.3124450445175171,
0.5533738136291504,
-0.09466226398944855,
-0.04571233317255974,
0.1376895010471344,
-0.027458183467388153,
-0.08904211968183517,
0.28745484352111816,
-0.6680788397789001,
0.5267970561981201,
0.9427816867828369,
0.88387531042099,
-0.13788019120693207,
0.01877567172050476,
-0.590342104434967,
0.47115400433540344,
-0.12449924647808075,
0.42715445160865784,
-0.13759396970272064,
-0.5232056379318237,
-0.34022608399391174,
0.09623757004737854,
0.338271826505661,
-0.505247175693512,
0.6095682382583618,
-0.3081177771091461,
-0.09247040748596191,
-0.011277232319116592,
-0.5074367523193359,
-0.28885990381240845,
-0.057637084275484085,
-0.721255362033844,
0.9525336027145386,
-0.13799580931663513,
-0.5001400709152222,
0.08546506613492966,
-0.42230409383773804,
0.1804879605770111,
0.06599652767181396,
-0.022022433578968048,
-0.9844691157341003,
0.44013452529907227,
0.3595566749572754,
0.36599138379096985,
-0.45735520124435425,
0.36866459250450134,
-0.7724080085754395,
-0.41159355640411377,
0.18193480372428894,
-0.2433672845363617,
0.9973252415657043,
0.18898361921310425,
-0.36132368445396423,
-0.1451285481452942,
-0.6434493660926819,
0.3705156445503235,
0.2797803282737732,
0.30174607038497925,
-0.7403944134712219,
-0.033988263458013535,
-0.11622340977191925,
-0.2848111391067505,
0.3362423777580261,
-0.6568937301635742,
0.28346654772758484,
-0.5491155385971069,
0.6385502219200134,
0.7302116751670837,
0.12876936793327332,
0.5484248995780945,
-0.5163109302520752,
0.3940214216709137,
-0.324006050825119,
0.6159957051277161,
0.21752510964870453,
-0.5540132522583008,
-0.554518461227417,
-0.6449488997459412,
0.3676477074623108,
0.5124019980430603,
-0.4850773513317108,
0.23196941614151,
-0.14160670340061188,
-0.7643504738807678,
-0.8627228736877441,
0.1984143853187561,
0.6557831764221191,
0.3301054835319519,
0.44896140694618225,
0.04651322215795517,
-0.41395479440689087,
-1.1262069940567017,
-0.4778082072734833,
0.550439178943634,
-0.07933586090803146,
0.37243223190307617,
0.3048517405986786,
0.03576526790857315,
1.051892876625061,
-0.557625412940979,
-0.6632691025733948,
0.006438604090362787,
-0.02671424113214016,
0.058029357343912125,
0.8058915138244629,
0.5682623982429504,
-0.6281785368919373,
-0.14632754027843475,
0.02741059847176075,
-0.6273056268692017,
-0.16737905144691467,
0.06410078704357147,
-0.2488323450088501,
0.0023394168820232153,
0.6155717372894287,
-0.2961427867412567,
0.5388316512107849,
0.7182610630989075,
-0.07265409827232361,
0.2607742249965668,
-0.4950701594352722,
-0.026465343311429024,
-0.8171584606170654,
0.09799809008836746,
-0.47243499755859375,
-0.5409320592880249,
-0.4734290540218353,
0.39686229825019836,
-0.09505906701087952,
-0.11245448142290115,
-0.5272975564002991,
0.34816858172416687,
-0.6131059527397156,
-0.04253866896033287,
-0.22126157581806183,
0.048196665942668915,
0.2084825038909912,
0.4371717572212219,
-0.10809426009654999,
0.5633153319358826,
0.2824925482273102,
-0.4654994010925293,
-0.09265080094337463,
0.38794979453086853,
-0.2737409174442291,
0.32656341791152954,
-0.6860244274139404,
0.3712316155433655,
0.046649955213069916,
-0.13443374633789062,
-0.6166661381721497,
-0.08540897071361542,
0.34823739528656006,
-0.06697866320610046,
0.07761496305465698,
-0.5241508483886719,
-0.7808620929718018,
0.1816377490758896,
-0.32903021574020386,
0.2206297516822815,
0.6633008718490601,
-0.6979986429214478,
0.5225531458854675,
0.5958560109138489,
0.23096433281898499,
-0.5005613565444946,
-1.1396170854568481,
-0.19271446764469147,
-0.5131363272666931,
-0.30824998021125793,
0.5542254447937012,
0.08008166402578354,
-0.3053625822067261,
0.08813612908124924,
-0.033190105110406876,
-0.4628070890903473,
0.4493766725063324,
0.7666019797325134,
0.08735667169094086,
-0.2113913893699646,
-0.21603715419769287,
0.45045334100723267,
-0.08038043230772018,
-0.057082124054431915,
-0.2565689980983734,
0.15288245677947998,
-0.05127023532986641,
-0.5503920912742615,
-0.4966631531715393,
0.20316016674041748,
-0.1558855026960373,
-0.16043592989444733,
0.8348895311355591,
0.38968464732170105,
-0.44614869356155396,
-0.48256611824035645,
-0.5812807083129883,
-0.3616468906402588,
-0.5327200889587402,
-0.025705086067318916,
-0.15222488343715668,
-0.591947078704834,
0.5040037035942078,
-0.15389584004878998,
0.19021712243556976,
0.12896424531936646,
0.2938866913318634,
0.1774623543024063,
0.7187020182609558,
0.6186997890472412,
0.12114852666854858,
0.26975423097610474,
-0.4346667230129242,
0.19424046576023102,
-0.6873123049736023,
-0.07682742178440094,
-0.5046104192733765,
-0.32785946130752563,
-0.6629288196563721,
-0.38052552938461304,
0.2922419011592865,
0.5670517086982727,
-0.18108074367046356,
0.36918264627456665,
-0.7097910046577454,
0.8189892768859863,
0.667397141456604,
0.6934660077095032,
0.809592604637146,
0.09764046967029572,
0.20251856744289398,
-0.0478646419942379,
-0.5975039005279541,
-0.44021570682525635,
1.1613178253173828,
0.2649291157722473,
0.6387166976928711,
0.27566495537757874,
0.7738390564918518,
0.10769465565681458,
0.3946709930896759,
-0.4587537348270416,
0.3463897705078125,
-0.28940820693969727,
-0.8167980909347534,
-0.2676450312137604,
-0.3425920009613037,
-0.8984043598175049,
0.3379955291748047,
-0.2490328699350357,
-1.1280031204223633,
0.36971792578697205,
0.6102232336997986,
-0.4830200672149658,
0.5232333540916443,
-0.7508379817008972,
0.6056811213493347,
0.0424220934510231,
-0.870815634727478,
-0.03703657165169716,
-0.5295114517211914,
0.7343155145645142,
-0.32569247484207153,
0.2556339502334595,
-0.20858806371688843,
-0.29867294430732727,
0.25184792280197144,
-0.8214430809020996,
0.7911415100097656,
-0.19778487086296082,
0.06659875810146332,
0.19700582325458527,
0.3666854500770569,
0.7097706198692322,
0.40848875045776367,
-0.23778179287910461,
0.6738584041595459,
0.20397740602493286,
-0.14051039516925812,
-0.6159405708312988,
0.8019317388534546,
-0.6894863247871399,
-0.6225771307945251,
-0.21998439729213715,
-0.3663496673107147,
-0.2903621792793274,
0.30176040530204773,
0.40202996134757996,
0.20028717815876007,
-0.09934867918491364,
0.612220823764801,
0.6794540286064148,
-0.15529249608516693,
0.32033926248550415,
0.6184380054473877,
-0.03718823194503784,
-0.45963606238365173,
0.7999280095100403,
-0.005483738612383604,
0.44381773471832275,
0.36422979831695557,
0.4781317114830017,
-0.26979953050613403,
-0.7765201926231384,
-0.25396135449409485,
0.09715106338262558,
-0.6064611673355103,
-0.41613122820854187,
-0.5079212784767151,
-0.06778337806463242,
0.13743522763252258,
-0.18552114069461823,
-0.7225675582885742,
-0.6558103561401367,
-0.4018423557281494,
0.21320797502994537,
0.5535418391227722,
0.36635711789131165,
-0.15721669793128967,
0.6771510243415833,
-0.5962825417518616,
0.34121155738830566,
-0.3047780990600586,
0.3780572712421417,
-0.2805856168270111,
-0.36433929204940796,
-0.042855154722929,
0.4044918119907379,
-0.48163652420043945,
-0.5032944083213806,
0.3769671618938446,
0.47459954023361206,
0.5357019901275635,
0.5211522579193115,
0.5611749291419983,
0.7610980272293091,
-0.23285743594169617,
0.650433361530304,
-0.21423877775669098,
-1.1043506860733032,
0.40753206610679626,
-0.26696693897247314,
0.056612830609083176,
0.8232885003089905,
0.19268536567687988,
0.22765430808067322,
-0.7886092662811279,
-0.776964008808136,
-0.906984806060791,
0.8251758217811584,
0.6654207110404968,
-0.28831812739372253,
0.53538578748703,
0.4032842516899109,
0.3572835922241211,
0.5716322064399719,
-0.5425953269004822,
-0.4685972332954407,
-0.3141961395740509,
-0.0681995302438736,
-0.21867050230503082,
-0.055693142116069794,
-0.3401951193809509,
0.08449174463748932,
0.7184521555900574,
0.05123216286301613,
0.1409280151128769,
0.10686678439378738,
-0.18532316386699677,
0.28290754556655884,
-0.024470187723636627,
0.35663068294525146,
0.44492393732070923,
-0.3715287446975708,
0.04536806046962738,
0.19733519852161407,
-0.6558554172515869,
-0.21186690032482147,
0.2272283136844635,
-0.372094064950943,
-0.07302732020616531,
-0.2062101811170578,
0.3836307227611542,
0.29497721791267395,
-0.4582374095916748,
0.4810038208961487,
-0.0032496850471943617,
-0.15726880729198456,
-0.296212762594223,
0.26840436458587646,
-0.18300804495811462,
0.21457263827323914,
-0.007355698850005865,
0.046258822083473206,
0.5704817771911621,
-0.04442448914051056,
-0.1338130682706833,
0.5744650363922119,
-0.2866981625556946,
0.0017668347572907805,
0.9962011575698853,
-0.14310428500175476,
0.0762152299284935,
0.4141353666782379,
-0.12134484946727753,
0.11189301311969757,
0.5891550779342651,
0.2396053820848465,
0.9295222759246826,
-0.19756723940372467,
-0.16196253895759583,
-0.008065000176429749,
0.5801771879196167,
-0.2888125777244568,
0.2668750286102295,
-0.23612365126609802,
-0.38553640246391296,
-0.25021806359291077,
-0.4859919250011444,
-0.548900306224823,
0.44909176230430603,
-0.8169265389442444,
0.4031018316745758,
-0.703127920627594,
-0.11937177181243896,
0.021280938759446144,
-0.32566511631011963,
-0.5635616183280945,
-0.027849417179822922,
-0.17591379582881927,
0.5918156504631042,
-0.34449702501296997,
0.8576524257659912,
0.20775078237056732,
-0.15054075419902802,
-0.5506209135055542,
-0.38308772444725037,
0.0723293125629425,
-0.7926878333091736,
0.12683598697185516,
-0.10632863640785217,
-0.2227105051279068,
0.29293587803840637,
-0.5767141580581665,
-0.8050717115402222,
1.0448435544967651,
0.6972266435623169,
-0.7586992383003235,
0.19009195268154144,
0.2870156168937683,
0.30949413776397705,
0.20443607866764069,
0.25263354182243347,
0.36207637190818787,
0.4049374461174011,
-0.37124672532081604,
-0.8856093287467957,
0.2364090532064438,
0.19172577559947968,
0.019672218710184097,
0.4222623109817505,
-0.5365957021713257,
0.44861286878585815,
-0.18087290227413177,
-0.24484634399414062,
0.4937065541744232,
0.3155602812767029,
0.13579188287258148,
0.34568366408348083,
0.29189467430114746,
0.5452843904495239,
0.70973140001297,
-0.1508449763059616,
0.8430429100990295,
-0.4337977468967438,
0.699062705039978,
1.613673210144043,
-0.07699541002511978,
0.5848991274833679,
0.4219651520252228,
0.11942126601934433,
-0.15221938490867615,
0.4618270695209503,
-0.30535393953323364,
0.8929412961006165,
0.11118169128894806,
0.006495197769254446,
-0.2365068942308426,
-0.04231115058064461,
-0.4602257311344147,
0.45549657940864563,
0.23051267862319946,
-0.48401370644569397,
-0.3624267876148224,
0.03162204846739769,
0.21595078706741333,
-0.07222235947847366,
-0.5413876175880432,
0.7095033526420593,
0.22251860797405243,
-0.33784711360931396,
0.621082603931427,
0.12466016411781311,
0.17820113897323608,
-0.39528778195381165,
0.16359926760196686,
0.04277653619647026,
0.6167305707931519,
-0.5194101929664612,
-0.520811140537262,
0.6418746709823608,
-0.26227813959121704,
0.15058666467666626,
-0.3168044984340668,
0.4896099865436554,
-0.13964241743087769,
-0.21433410048484802,
-0.032201994210481644,
0.2501903772354126,
0.2428005486726761,
-0.4527303874492645,
-0.5809409618377686,
-0.11045359820127487,
-0.19916392862796783,
-0.2156394124031067,
0.2617107927799225,
0.3031121492385864,
-0.10421432554721832,
0.5937179327011108,
0.742581307888031,
-0.07217789441347122,
-0.10508593171834946,
-0.17367646098136902,
0.7940019369125366,
-0.19981814920902252,
-0.6599684953689575,
-0.9858933091163635,
0.3466424345970154,
-0.1498490273952484,
-0.5009846091270447,
0.9506422877311707,
0.8411740064620972,
0.5497447848320007,
-0.18792465329170227,
0.6314157247543335,
0.4011838138103485,
0.4187591075897217,
-0.7029750347137451,
0.9133250117301941,
-0.529251217842102,
0.33516204357147217,
-0.08928792178630829,
-0.7310518026351929,
-0.2701828181743622,
0.21427077054977417,
-0.32548895478248596,
-0.3395985960960388,
0.5547543168067932,
0.95526123046875,
-0.432097464799881,
0.4004800021648407,
0.3248289227485657,
0.17277799546718597,
0.09214413911104202,
0.4498893618583679,
0.6433332562446594,
-0.3919956088066101,
0.5691179633140564,
-0.8113358020782471,
-0.24511905014514923,
-0.22873567044734955,
-1.0971746444702148,
-0.9977173209190369,
-0.17698821425437927,
-0.454106867313385,
-0.2557598054409027,
0.2941206097602844,
0.49141064286231995,
0.7556814551353455,
-0.7129518389701843,
0.17193567752838135,
-0.5632691383361816,
0.089316226541996,
-0.4714588522911072,
-0.16438987851142883,
0.2963789403438568,
0.27718043327331543,
-0.7535426616668701,
0.3130459785461426,
0.119386687874794,
0.11482586711645126,
-0.4996233284473419,
0.42797794938087463,
0.4116164743900299,
0.1040937751531601,
0.11726804077625275,
0.27619922161102295,
-0.7929360866546631,
0.06792506575584412,
-0.25360310077667236,
0.09192000329494476,
-0.13148075342178345,
0.7602781653404236,
-0.5822018980979919,
0.2583116888999939,
0.1874365508556366,
0.6932839751243591,
0.7218934297561646,
0.2861984968185425,
0.4075123369693756,
-0.7498829364776611,
0.4401172995567322,
0.271015465259552,
0.24395635724067688,
0.15742263197898865,
-0.7797521352767944,
0.5275611281394958,
-0.07090887427330017,
-0.772972822189331,
-1.1286993026733398,
0.18669666349887848,
-0.9481651186943054,
-0.31756332516670227,
1.1156187057495117,
-0.37947991490364075,
-0.38147661089897156,
-0.30637556314468384,
-0.19923081994056702,
-0.025417132303118706,
-0.41307955980300903,
0.8276475071907043,
0.098384790122509,
0.021826835349202156,
-0.0847240686416626,
-0.7294824123382568,
0.724362850189209,
0.1837874948978424,
-0.8607205152511597,
0.09046726673841476,
0.1745157241821289,
0.21657100319862366,
-0.1770983636379242,
0.10287509858608246,
-0.05012122914195061,
0.07316047698259354,
-0.12803694605827332,
-0.07140085846185684,
-0.7242279052734375,
-0.055177051573991776,
-0.286128968000412,
0.2699038088321686,
-0.16858021914958954,
-0.428870290517807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02956v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02956v1 | IncogniText: Privacy-enhancing Conditional Text Anonymization via LLM-based Private Attribute Randomization | 2024-07-03T09:49:03 | 2024-07-03T09:49:03 | Ahmed Frikha, Nassim Walha, Krishna Kanth Nakka, Ricardo Mendes, Xue Jiang, Xuebing Zhou | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we address the problem of text anonymization where the goal is
to prevent adversaries from correctly inferring private attributes of the
author, while keeping the text utility, i.e., meaning and semantics. We propose
IncogniText, a technique that anonymizes the text to mislead a potential
adversary into predicting a wrong private attribute value. Our empirical
evaluation shows a reduction of private attribute leakage by more than 90%.
Finally, we demonstrate the maturity of IncogniText for real-world applications
by distilling its anonymization capability into a set of LoRA parameters
associated with an on-device model. | [
0.2637820243835449,
-0.8872888088226318,
0.6547297835350037,
0.26581642031669617,
-0.0762803927063942,
0.27493929862976074,
0.09318891167640686,
-0.8677686452865601,
0.15092159807682037,
0.824009120464325,
-0.7880265712738037,
-0.6616373062133789,
-0.5336015224456787,
-0.05278711020946503,
-0.650768518447876,
1.3071990013122559,
0.10395246744155884,
-0.16641834378242493,
-0.32105955481529236,
-0.16862528026103973,
-0.07546599209308624,
-0.6255269646644592,
-0.5990754961967468,
-0.034280914813280106,
0.5400240421295166,
0.588458776473999,
0.7596402168273926,
0.8192488551139832,
0.8328173756599426,
0.2962808907032013,
-0.12403740733861923,
0.02745230682194233,
-0.6462693214416504,
0.3896018862724304,
-0.15747332572937012,
-0.6073378324508667,
-0.35344198346138,
0.19375883042812347,
0.5981501340866089,
0.02900317870080471,
-0.0003181223582942039,
0.2593522071838379,
-0.09262505918741226,
0.3369663655757904,
-0.8748229146003723,
-0.25148048996925354,
-0.6784617900848389,
0.32697176933288574,
-0.23648422956466675,
-0.3614630699157715,
-0.2752649784088135,
-0.512451171875,
0.25459688901901245,
-0.6429722309112549,
0.20231293141841888,
0.5420462489128113,
0.8624423742294312,
0.2881048321723938,
-0.20326712727546692,
-0.09888960421085358,
-0.8165473937988281,
0.9191256165504456,
-0.6406480073928833,
0.004748768638819456,
0.8012730479240417,
-0.010666152462363243,
0.18460382521152496,
-0.8062875270843506,
-0.5552663803100586,
-0.3818323016166687,
-0.42485329508781433,
0.09931667894124985,
0.11416230350732803,
0.09395904093980789,
0.18428446352481842,
0.5958395600318909,
-0.33817774057388306,
0.18649575114250183,
-0.13139177858829498,
-0.4819004237651825,
0.9139741063117981,
0.18365053832530975,
0.364404559135437,
0.024814270436763763,
-0.6753231883049011,
0.06665543466806412,
-0.6521980166435242,
0.12995484471321106,
0.8606441617012024,
-0.2672719359397888,
-0.1643085777759552,
0.811997652053833,
-0.4258742034435272,
0.3098204433917999,
0.1712646186351776,
-0.6529974937438965,
-0.05555233731865883,
-0.5811600685119629,
-0.2652152478694916,
0.3831341564655304,
0.7167790532112122,
-0.034839529544115067,
-0.18085794150829315,
-0.5501102209091187,
0.11989621073007584,
-0.21313928067684174,
-0.15426667034626007,
-0.9845504760742188,
-0.34671932458877563,
0.40419429540634155,
-0.5397270321846008,
-0.7184430360794067,
-0.0517592653632164,
-0.7057830095291138,
-0.9494203925132751,
0.08616600930690765,
0.5457125902175903,
-0.38923346996307373,
0.23709678649902344,
-0.13488776981830597,
-0.019039493054151535,
-0.11166075617074966,
0.3112165033817291,
-0.9361450672149658,
0.5382345914840698,
0.4765797555446625,
0.5256032347679138,
-0.2862914800643921,
-0.2088334560394287,
-0.3425752520561218,
0.5652889013290405,
0.24542273581027985,
0.6357014775276184,
-0.6485567688941956,
-0.3182680904865265,
-0.3972046971321106,
-0.1812732219696045,
0.23352614045143127,
-0.06569336354732513,
0.23759478330612183,
-0.3289657533168793,
0.47575843334198,
0.23098815977573395,
-0.5069714188575745,
-0.28518128395080566,
0.17725436389446259,
-0.7212924957275391,
0.8268486857414246,
-0.2367241531610489,
-0.8913590312004089,
0.1802932620048523,
-0.48779138922691345,
-0.3232276737689972,
0.041035834699869156,
-0.14066343009471893,
-0.731091320514679,
0.17599226534366608,
0.08964551985263824,
0.29422029852867126,
-0.08514922112226486,
0.023904940113425255,
-0.2705496549606323,
-0.13124361634254456,
0.6746984124183655,
-0.5838643312454224,
0.8198817372322083,
0.2598951756954193,
-0.23789243400096893,
-0.05876867473125458,
-0.894773542881012,
0.14656955003738403,
-0.11303742229938507,
-0.07779821008443832,
-0.5916509628295898,
0.017883682623505592,
-0.2717551290988922,
-0.13954836130142212,
0.9995936751365662,
-0.9095569849014282,
-0.11890121549367905,
-0.45235320925712585,
0.23650310933589935,
0.7996438145637512,
0.12912620604038239,
0.8645288348197937,
-0.20805998146533966,
0.46606695652008057,
-0.20464469492435455,
0.3091448247432709,
-0.3107541799545288,
-0.5533981323242188,
-0.5378068089485168,
-0.7441118955612183,
0.3948342502117157,
0.8912191390991211,
-0.24878427386283875,
-0.1553533524274826,
0.14141012728214264,
-0.24894307553768158,
-0.560466468334198,
0.36823171377182007,
0.8683851957321167,
0.45595982670783997,
0.061389729380607605,
-0.10717464238405228,
-0.48462653160095215,
-0.9807697534561157,
-0.6679777503013611,
-0.09264997392892838,
0.006912126671522856,
0.5712743401527405,
-0.027964137494564056,
-0.009837483055889606,
0.9407212138175964,
-0.5500127673149109,
-0.6361798644065857,
-0.13774031400680542,
0.09141148626804352,
-0.18326109647750854,
0.5407727956771851,
0.2787839472293854,
-0.9376141428947449,
-0.5828137993812561,
0.08787167072296143,
-0.8008295297622681,
-0.18016986548900604,
-0.07516919821500778,
-0.15024538338184357,
0.08355075865983963,
0.4965175986289978,
-0.4913402199745178,
0.8506191372871399,
0.8733608722686768,
-0.7140683531761169,
0.1319712996482849,
-0.46415096521377563,
0.16691476106643677,
-0.8935509920120239,
-0.06097446009516716,
-0.07442054152488708,
-0.5604685544967651,
-0.5572025179862976,
0.1488633155822754,
-0.04246145859360695,
-0.3090198040008545,
-0.5631710290908813,
0.8326441049575806,
-0.5486348271369934,
0.30738428235054016,
-0.15329870581626892,
0.035727035254240036,
0.13844233751296997,
0.3509901463985443,
0.0032266261987388134,
0.7723143696784973,
0.018662139773368835,
-0.401706337928772,
0.11267548054456711,
0.34293168783187866,
-0.11071501672267914,
0.5772708058357239,
-0.3167319893836975,
0.32196322083473206,
-0.18243254721164703,
-0.07945194840431213,
-0.8984895944595337,
-0.43619510531425476,
0.34458988904953003,
-0.49421942234039307,
0.15725785493850708,
0.11295003443956375,
-0.7763258814811707,
0.3132215142250061,
-0.5829072594642639,
0.42115336656570435,
0.21897025406360626,
-0.4482487142086029,
0.6976688504219055,
0.5462932586669922,
-0.30431467294692993,
-0.5252436399459839,
-0.7861185669898987,
0.43857941031455994,
-0.3189273178577423,
-0.7225340604782104,
0.7277916669845581,
-0.3064594864845276,
-0.34038931131362915,
0.3980085849761963,
-0.09158118069171906,
-0.6375475525856018,
0.24628306925296783,
0.4095393717288971,
0.23045232892036438,
0.23167507350444794,
0.1142713874578476,
0.12984606623649597,
-0.27078208327293396,
-0.16091440618038177,
-0.03567597642540932,
-0.11533018201589584,
0.2131243646144867,
0.11314064264297485,
-0.9157396554946899,
0.568282425403595,
-0.41802331805229187,
-0.106949083507061,
1.085585117340088,
0.2916904389858246,
-0.22415052354335785,
-0.24765801429748535,
-0.6471749544143677,
-0.2528698146343231,
-0.5353167653083801,
0.1269335001707077,
-0.15027788281440735,
-1.1213468313217163,
0.4429750144481659,
0.25021934509277344,
-0.07758282124996185,
-0.13974425196647644,
0.2822687029838562,
-0.22648189961910248,
0.8492390513420105,
1.1459897756576538,
-0.14928916096687317,
0.5022148489952087,
0.11301714181900024,
0.5111936330795288,
-0.42614254355430603,
-0.32896506786346436,
-0.32986006140708923,
-0.3767157793045044,
-0.9631050825119019,
0.06664260476827621,
0.08580887317657471,
-0.33222177624702454,
-0.06784282624721527,
0.26034340262413025,
-0.6443914771080017,
0.7373128533363342,
0.8048689961433411,
0.5067307949066162,
0.727379560470581,
0.0794144794344902,
0.39495769143104553,
-0.26427459716796875,
-0.2914537489414215,
-0.3617483377456665,
1.0898969173431396,
0.295261412858963,
1.024436116218567,
0.11843739449977875,
0.8455830812454224,
0.4951556622982025,
0.6764479279518127,
-0.3104550838470459,
0.6607285737991333,
-0.2182292491197586,
-0.954147219657898,
-0.4569535553455353,
-0.44548657536506653,
-0.5391188859939575,
0.15517747402191162,
-0.23801405727863312,
-1.3884423971176147,
0.21202178299427032,
0.470853328704834,
-0.3786527216434479,
0.28704214096069336,
-0.746500551700592,
0.6255225539207458,
-0.17953579127788544,
-0.5919301509857178,
0.06463949382305145,
-0.6081481575965881,
0.6340183615684509,
-0.17538507282733917,
0.10315528512001038,
-0.28672659397125244,
-0.52107173204422,
0.5798060297966003,
-0.6454459428787231,
0.8613072633743286,
0.10483767092227936,
-0.06353152543306351,
0.1644992232322693,
0.11926580220460892,
0.8852654695510864,
0.34191808104515076,
0.0030920659191906452,
0.18743713200092316,
-0.00882057473063469,
-0.10202111303806305,
-0.6036143898963928,
0.8182799816131592,
-0.3101649582386017,
-0.6238114237785339,
-0.45649296045303345,
-0.6016427278518677,
-0.1755780279636383,
0.21996991336345673,
0.5536385178565979,
0.06478250026702881,
0.0028805050533264875,
0.44432350993156433,
1.0483909845352173,
-0.3682520389556885,
0.5177585482597351,
0.5078946948051453,
0.05520612373948097,
-0.5490115880966187,
1.0089430809020996,
-0.06150078773498535,
0.17696934938430786,
0.7707576751708984,
0.2346835881471634,
-0.23221591114997864,
-0.47524458169937134,
-0.045620568096637726,
0.2384486347436905,
-0.6064374446868896,
-0.4108034074306488,
-0.7667619585990906,
-0.35832786560058594,
-0.09508922696113586,
-0.15321877598762512,
-0.046953584998846054,
-0.7713680267333984,
-0.4740837812423706,
-0.27055153250694275,
0.7112751007080078,
0.40262022614479065,
0.024111591279506683,
0.5519456267356873,
-0.4537043571472168,
0.4441986680030823,
0.1645711064338684,
0.2943771481513977,
-0.4360494315624237,
-0.3735401928424835,
-0.200541153550148,
-0.11802910268306732,
-0.1799287348985672,
-0.7814476490020752,
0.509131908416748,
0.3109666109085083,
0.22148919105529785,
0.18210071325302124,
0.2243938148021698,
0.41732704639434814,
-0.5043641924858093,
0.6506290435791016,
0.21729415655136108,
-0.8601568341255188,
0.41615527868270874,
-0.12178811430931091,
0.052275557070970535,
0.7271257042884827,
-0.21472017467021942,
-0.1467490941286087,
-1.0214412212371826,
-0.7278725504875183,
-0.9742055535316467,
0.6828659772872925,
0.5751466751098633,
0.45789834856987,
0.5841982364654541,
0.33453667163848877,
0.2202487736940384,
0.569726824760437,
-1.1558314561843872,
-0.5385977029800415,
-0.13146230578422546,
-0.49741312861442566,
0.08828690648078918,
-0.835763156414032,
-0.14067213237285614,
0.0347282811999321,
0.49954888224601746,
0.37084269523620605,
0.2696693241596222,
0.18314671516418457,
-0.13331358134746552,
0.33237436413764954,
0.26971590518951416,
0.5889614224433899,
0.40600576996803284,
-0.2303914576768875,
0.18308165669441223,
0.13134238123893738,
-0.9124004244804382,
0.4204557538032532,
0.2070760279893875,
-0.613697350025177,
0.027968905866146088,
0.059137191623449326,
0.4877297878265381,
0.13561022281646729,
-0.38949060440063477,
0.6278782486915588,
-0.20647385716438293,
-0.0641721710562706,
-0.43645864725112915,
0.26013028621673584,
-0.23278506100177765,
0.03868722915649414,
0.3692106008529663,
-0.35053837299346924,
0.47748732566833496,
-0.26294249296188354,
-0.024396026507019997,
0.40562954545021057,
-0.37916767597198486,
-0.30401912331581116,
0.9779725670814514,
0.14364197850227356,
-0.47582462430000305,
-0.1315205991268158,
-0.09064372628927231,
-0.023915985599160194,
0.5325626134872437,
0.5263444781303406,
1.1763273477554321,
-0.5049538612365723,
0.1138930469751358,
-0.15002191066741943,
0.5553687810897827,
0.17361406981945038,
0.25626906752586365,
-0.2865763306617737,
-0.427920937538147,
-0.11532583832740784,
-0.3591165542602539,
-0.6485147476196289,
0.3633810877799988,
-0.2665324807167053,
-0.062128946185112,
-0.8278480172157288,
-0.13792204856872559,
-0.06148920953273773,
-0.04256981611251831,
-0.5588053464889526,
0.49658510088920593,
-0.151368647813797,
0.56486576795578,
-0.17944768071174622,
0.7312898635864258,
0.3666955828666687,
-0.14223721623420715,
-0.5571492910385132,
0.11644023656845093,
0.16789610683918,
-0.4187367260456085,
0.6384087800979614,
0.10518534481525421,
-0.23576638102531433,
-0.0034022745676338673,
-0.8879061341285706,
-1.0492852926254272,
1.1848866939544678,
0.45854485034942627,
-0.35037437081336975,
-0.01033587846904993,
0.28462305665016174,
0.42587485909461975,
-0.28864535689353943,
-0.18393884599208832,
0.18365983664989471,
0.450074166059494,
-0.46480801701545715,
-0.5347383618354797,
0.31008970737457275,
-0.0989084467291832,
0.18087877333164215,
-0.0023728185333311558,
-0.6277545094490051,
0.8181653022766113,
-0.06760795414447784,
-0.4213986396789551,
0.5264834761619568,
0.830376386642456,
-0.1410970389842987,
0.599615216255188,
-0.005358540453016758,
0.448585569858551,
0.7010470032691956,
0.22903898358345032,
1.1468321084976196,
-0.2553946375846863,
0.2503245174884796,
1.3953982591629028,
-0.21650998294353485,
0.528762698173523,
0.31685373187065125,
0.13803668320178986,
0.5729420185089111,
0.29886728525161743,
0.19633986055850983,
0.9264199137687683,
0.05871943011879921,
-1.0116509199142456,
0.09663320332765579,
-0.0628385916352272,
-0.12326986342668533,
0.36462271213531494,
0.19747410714626312,
-0.6006566286087036,
0.027212608605623245,
0.11068098992109299,
0.504923403263092,
0.2513009011745453,
-0.27293771505355835,
0.8507555723190308,
0.1361326277256012,
-0.260099858045578,
-0.20740969479084015,
0.24418877065181732,
0.5568578839302063,
-0.6288362145423889,
0.06318461894989014,
-0.3092283010482788,
0.41773074865341187,
-0.3608604669570923,
-0.5040580034255981,
0.08952730894088745,
0.16098837554454803,
-0.30348899960517883,
-0.40946322679519653,
1.013169765472412,
-0.3594849109649658,
-0.539010226726532,
-0.04304356500506401,
0.02254217304289341,
-0.0547817163169384,
0.20828600227832794,
-0.47371193766593933,
-0.20290955901145935,
-0.14077438414096832,
-0.3131915032863617,
0.4884277880191803,
0.5177079439163208,
0.15771269798278809,
1.0164411067962646,
0.6042248606681824,
-0.09835411608219147,
-0.02415575459599495,
-0.5035375356674194,
0.6252190470695496,
-0.7701868414878845,
-0.8129568099975586,
-1.1329349279403687,
0.43126827478408813,
-0.452679842710495,
-0.3236914277076721,
1.451931118965149,
0.5962221026420593,
0.5835726857185364,
0.20598137378692627,
0.8623262643814087,
0.09032994508743286,
0.744002103805542,
-0.7539956569671631,
0.9063639044761658,
-0.3210090398788452,
0.6312829256057739,
-0.11856580525636673,
-0.6299360990524292,
-0.21797268092632294,
0.29389843344688416,
-0.20256349444389343,
-0.19709298014640808,
0.794647216796875,
0.7823798060417175,
0.02664872817695141,
-0.06646078079938889,
0.32115718722343445,
-0.018381519243121147,
-0.022416479885578156,
0.31473875045776367,
0.7044580578804016,
-0.3104621469974518,
0.6847531199455261,
-0.5020531415939331,
-0.29591819643974304,
-0.04646668583154678,
-1.181963324546814,
-0.9167650938034058,
-0.10403645038604736,
-0.40531623363494873,
-0.4967513680458069,
0.33850061893463135,
0.029340071603655815,
0.6369479298591614,
-0.6075940132141113,
-0.07642542570829391,
0.0006431944202631712,
0.41476672887802124,
0.08063861727714539,
-0.1922091692686081,
0.12725841999053955,
0.07216358929872513,
-0.523200511932373,
0.17925338447093964,
0.5397636890411377,
0.1914750635623932,
-0.5279508233070374,
0.12200172990560532,
0.10140136629343033,
0.5860483646392822,
0.4072072505950928,
0.5440413951873779,
-0.4648592472076416,
-0.35150524973869324,
-0.10086134076118469,
-0.29329806566238403,
0.018001116812229156,
0.7204858064651489,
-0.7135891318321228,
0.35642603039741516,
0.37890374660491943,
0.48891115188598633,
0.517514169216156,
0.2978439927101135,
0.36057424545288086,
-0.9985561966896057,
0.5483956933021545,
0.14950062334537506,
-0.0674075037240982,
0.2920236587524414,
-1.001006007194519,
0.3339725732803345,
0.035549696534872055,
-0.40088075399398804,
-1.0047308206558228,
0.25105714797973633,
-0.621109127998352,
-0.21704834699630737,
1.0736438035964966,
-0.33160433173179626,
-0.4423407018184662,
-0.12093174457550049,
-0.2519564628601074,
-0.37530797719955444,
-0.5439699292182922,
0.9839819669723511,
0.4054130017757416,
0.02493010275065899,
-0.354096382856369,
-0.47383591532707214,
0.9192979335784912,
0.10804371535778046,
-1.0808706283569336,
-0.37627583742141724,
0.24317066371440887,
0.2876797318458557,
-0.11120670288801193,
0.9915540814399719,
-0.024204228073358536,
0.26635053753852844,
-0.2064959555864334,
-0.2733166217803955,
-0.12797978520393372,
-0.27248460054397583,
-0.07361265271902084,
0.18237534165382385,
-0.21364432573318481,
-0.29423588514328003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02943v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02943v1 | PII-Compass: Guiding LLM training data extraction prompts towards the target PII via grounding | 2024-07-03T09:20:04 | 2024-07-03T09:20:04 | Krishna Kanth Nakka, Ahmed Frikha, Ricardo Mendes, Xue Jiang, Xuebing Zhou | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The latest and most impactful advances in large models stem from their
increased size. Unfortunately, this translates into an improved memorization
capacity, raising data privacy concerns. Specifically, it has been shown that
models can output personal identifiable information (PII) contained in their
training data. However, reported PIII extraction performance varies widely, and
there is no consensus on the optimal methodology to evaluate this risk,
resulting in underestimating realistic adversaries. In this work, we
empirically demonstrate that it is possible to improve the extractability of
PII by over ten-fold by grounding the prefix of the manually constructed
extraction prompt with in-domain data. Our approach, PII-Compass, achieves
phone number extraction rates of 0.92%, 3.9%, and 6.86% with 1, 128, and 2308
queries, respectively, i.e., the phone number of 1 person in 15 is extractable. | [
-0.4487364590167999,
-0.32120639085769653,
0.5347780585289001,
0.1694760024547577,
-0.21885761618614197,
-0.05626097321510315,
-0.11265257000923157,
-0.29586878418922424,
-0.20786026120185852,
0.29609981179237366,
-0.5737327337265015,
-0.7030717134475708,
-0.5223809480667114,
0.1170172393321991,
-0.06605473160743713,
0.8906824588775635,
0.6160992383956909,
0.3996010422706604,
0.07085620611906052,
0.1411823332309723,
-0.6111668348312378,
-0.8935326933860779,
-0.4503471553325653,
-0.40198037028312683,
0.4192202091217041,
0.9539133906364441,
0.4384477138519287,
0.7590553164482117,
0.6921104192733765,
0.16135545074939728,
-0.09297098219394684,
0.06186921149492264,
-0.6033037304878235,
-0.03751698136329651,
-0.3171117603778839,
-0.5036207437515259,
-0.614149808883667,
0.49253523349761963,
0.6292843222618103,
0.6787050366401672,
0.2740668058395386,
0.1865447610616684,
-0.2038734406232834,
0.8833243250846863,
-0.588261604309082,
-0.0014091826742514968,
-0.9189764857292175,
-0.023319510743021965,
-0.21470868587493896,
-0.4482036232948303,
-0.5942209362983704,
-0.11096883565187454,
0.2910946011543274,
-0.519420862197876,
0.2650451958179474,
0.24682050943374634,
1.0087931156158447,
-0.03064533695578575,
-0.11760008335113525,
-0.3516530692577362,
-0.5532084107398987,
0.7418041825294495,
-0.3611384928226471,
0.29240846633911133,
0.723452091217041,
0.43616026639938354,
-0.08093363791704178,
-0.3560279607772827,
-0.09964491426944733,
-0.04242987185716629,
0.09327671676874161,
0.1535608023405075,
0.22133272886276245,
-0.16082239151000977,
0.8375905752182007,
0.49704739451408386,
-0.0526900589466095,
0.1072402149438858,
-0.5765363574028015,
0.16141065955162048,
0.9033031463623047,
0.08395969122648239,
0.24411624670028687,
0.04311491549015045,
-0.1747273951768875,
0.05053501948714256,
-1.247227668762207,
0.23813527822494507,
0.3694070875644684,
0.47356078028678894,
0.005356340203434229,
0.6363023519515991,
-0.3851219415664673,
0.4651917517185211,
0.7217464447021484,
-0.22673100233078003,
0.2512546181678772,
-0.031097188591957092,
-0.10108786076307297,
0.2880569398403168,
0.6632047891616821,
0.4927939772605896,
0.33996620774269104,
-0.6994515061378479,
-0.022501537576317787,
-0.34654900431632996,
0.1768958866596222,
-0.9699242115020752,
-0.2622031569480896,
0.2694917619228363,
-0.3019822835922241,
-0.5725745558738708,
0.837722897529602,
-0.8913514018058777,
-0.613090455532074,
-0.2789520025253296,
-0.1324462592601776,
-0.5818914175033569,
-0.3176293671131134,
-0.08053341507911682,
-0.10681962221860886,
0.6689582467079163,
0.3783920407295227,
-0.9010598659515381,
0.25242915749549866,
0.9400352835655212,
0.8695457577705383,
-0.7371802926063538,
0.15611425042152405,
-0.9255292415618896,
-0.02866222895681858,
-0.2184811383485794,
0.4377526342868805,
-0.5215086936950684,
-0.7776961326599121,
-0.37197044491767883,
0.1557600349187851,
-0.20346054434776306,
-0.9354318380355835,
0.3264559805393219,
-0.6737890839576721,
0.2480252981185913,
-0.49356305599212646,
-0.48481136560440063,
-0.03862563893198967,
0.11885502934455872,
-0.47894376516342163,
1.0276949405670166,
0.007933646440505981,
-0.7166261672973633,
0.22054442763328552,
-0.588770866394043,
-0.23870661854743958,
0.03861425817012787,
-0.20896777510643005,
-0.7472267746925354,
0.27057743072509766,
0.3022076189517975,
0.7366183996200562,
-0.6560772657394409,
0.43966594338417053,
-0.3699128329753876,
-0.5653021335601807,
0.4216528832912445,
-0.2585070729255676,
0.9267491698265076,
0.4244999587535858,
-0.6562544107437134,
-0.3840886056423187,
-1.1766059398651123,
0.15233977138996124,
-0.0421382337808609,
-0.31458035111427307,
-0.37940067052841187,
-0.44536635279655457,
-0.6973389387130737,
0.21535085141658783,
-0.031018394976854324,
-0.5395493507385254,
0.05385424569249153,
-0.4570823609828949,
0.11684852093458176,
0.5489498376846313,
0.24504204094409943,
0.8674298524856567,
-0.3435044288635254,
0.27480843663215637,
0.14215809106826782,
-0.3249024748802185,
-0.40894392132759094,
-0.5230808258056641,
-0.5930554866790771,
-0.7311580777168274,
0.20859357714653015,
0.5947390794754028,
-0.33489173650741577,
0.7307957410812378,
-0.6674245595932007,
-0.6150863170623779,
-0.10640580952167511,
0.05343717709183693,
0.5035158395767212,
0.700563371181488,
0.04460251331329346,
-0.1436491310596466,
-0.27393704652786255,
-0.5861318707466125,
-0.6129761934280396,
-0.017171122133731842,
-0.1424255073070526,
0.5363390445709229,
0.1277628093957901,
0.11559020727872849,
1.3986430168151855,
-0.39659976959228516,
-0.09202072769403458,
-0.2265474498271942,
0.010093067772686481,
0.6275724172592163,
0.7115411162376404,
0.2152022421360016,
-1.168812870979309,
-0.6718906760215759,
0.06103892996907234,
-0.9710983037948608,
-0.3569319546222687,
-0.452311635017395,
-0.425062894821167,
-0.5472980737686157,
0.05698152631521225,
-0.6294336915016174,
0.7558043003082275,
-0.18922628462314606,
-0.26967912912368774,
0.2213590294122696,
0.06885340809822083,
-0.06505947560071945,
-0.8890511989593506,
0.1911293864250183,
0.1890009641647339,
-0.22886577248573303,
-0.8548464775085449,
-0.18698996305465698,
0.3473086953163147,
-0.4195258617401123,
-0.5905777812004089,
0.2922055721282959,
-0.8994795083999634,
-0.4088227152824402,
-0.12353658676147461,
-0.07593715935945511,
-0.07570569217205048,
0.4468331038951874,
0.016787396743893623,
1.2613123655319214,
0.5753186345100403,
-0.904219388961792,
0.05416826531291008,
0.12107715010643005,
0.051006730645895004,
0.5815890431404114,
-0.4492751955986023,
0.5348529815673828,
-0.05199947953224182,
-0.22682097554206848,
-0.8385161757469177,
-0.3027646839618683,
0.5381752848625183,
-0.4383639395236969,
0.38994279503822327,
-0.4172501564025879,
-0.004933077376335859,
0.0655817911028862,
-0.32974332571029663,
0.25385817885398865,
0.5539107918739319,
-0.8736107349395752,
0.7024394273757935,
0.5009146332740784,
-0.09275709837675095,
-0.20973363518714905,
-0.16120946407318115,
-0.03006197325885296,
-0.8056723475456238,
-0.38511383533477783,
0.29617902636528015,
0.09541808813810349,
-0.43817153573036194,
-0.6696836948394775,
-0.16912363469600677,
-0.283450186252594,
0.3914356529712677,
0.9015536904335022,
0.36318501830101013,
0.05617216229438782,
0.05971459671854973,
-0.2239864021539688,
-0.47978001832962036,
0.3713591694831848,
-0.14830540120601654,
0.45152318477630615,
-0.2728540599346161,
-0.3489826023578644,
-0.8814197778701782,
0.41328734159469604,
0.6545567512512207,
-0.24747727811336517,
0.49473288655281067,
0.12788046896457672,
-0.38509833812713623,
0.18558254837989807,
-0.6347041726112366,
-0.10782891511917114,
-0.5124832987785339,
-0.033790793269872665,
-0.7937740087509155,
-0.1738237738609314,
0.3249816596508026,
-0.8578330278396606,
-0.05781381577253342,
0.3226052224636078,
0.3246861696243286,
0.04897769168019295,
0.9299495816230774,
0.6706718802452087,
-0.32139673829078674,
0.6214967370033264,
-0.5291873216629028,
0.1402149498462677,
-1.0098857879638672,
-0.40685856342315674,
-0.3674866557121277,
0.24515490233898163,
-0.06481429934501648,
0.0039200251922011375,
0.5332788228988647,
0.3504873216152191,
-0.1745777279138565,
0.22365282475948334,
-0.5755876898765564,
0.5755723714828491,
0.609389066696167,
0.38903069496154785,
0.3382504880428314,
0.43268442153930664,
0.24854835867881775,
-0.36148107051849365,
-0.4016723930835724,
-0.685364842414856,
1.329050898551941,
0.547866940498352,
0.5951701402664185,
-0.018979735672473907,
0.8545063734054565,
0.09118470549583435,
0.6330280303955078,
-0.8225901126861572,
0.4207666218280792,
0.21501141786575317,
-0.5230459570884705,
-0.17778833210468292,
-0.36715978384017944,
-0.6457173228263855,
0.4454432427883148,
-0.24396692216396332,
-0.7963156700134277,
0.5055692195892334,
-0.01866818778216839,
-0.55824214220047,
0.11386185884475708,
-0.8140303492546082,
0.32648807764053345,
-0.41384848952293396,
-0.578130304813385,
0.3462923765182495,
-0.6780871152877808,
0.27689996361732483,
-0.2701226472854614,
0.21488843858242035,
-0.4574908912181854,
0.1573570966720581,
0.6786478161811829,
-0.6105048656463623,
0.9215787649154663,
-0.44862887263298035,
-0.010534013621509075,
0.3793316185474396,
-0.24090027809143066,
0.7392619252204895,
0.19252867996692657,
-0.474417120218277,
0.4237574636936188,
-0.42782357335090637,
-0.08391090482473373,
-0.5919472575187683,
0.3908258378505707,
-0.7401710748672485,
-0.6495556235313416,
-0.33795779943466187,
-0.24451440572738647,
-0.2642768621444702,
0.2722826898097992,
0.6705215573310852,
0.3879113495349884,
-0.09413162618875504,
0.11624918133020401,
0.9038029313087463,
-0.008963964879512787,
0.3351728916168213,
0.3914497196674347,
0.32124289870262146,
-0.6276773810386658,
1.0988082885742188,
0.05809716880321503,
0.08436683565378189,
0.015429171733558178,
0.2571987509727478,
-0.14416883885860443,
-0.4736318588256836,
-0.37785395979881287,
0.49541953206062317,
-0.6739088892936707,
-0.3283374607563019,
-0.533595085144043,
-0.12264218181371689,
-0.37899050116539,
-0.18723087012767792,
-0.3990594148635864,
-0.3789156675338745,
-0.8413815498352051,
-0.11019930243492126,
0.1657484471797943,
0.5268186926841736,
0.1277010291814804,
0.78115314245224,
-0.7712028622627258,
0.16337206959724426,
0.021102234721183777,
-0.13516630232334137,
-0.31072965264320374,
-0.6181135773658752,
-0.15448813140392303,
0.10722608119249344,
-0.19707408547401428,
-0.9137505888938904,
0.5722706317901611,
0.28261154890060425,
0.2991938889026642,
0.5994572043418884,
0.3168877065181732,
1.2086600065231323,
-0.5469207763671875,
0.5621641874313354,
0.5030366778373718,
-0.8750739097595215,
0.5913954377174377,
-0.2313971370458603,
-0.07500136643648148,
0.7357978224754333,
0.5371052026748657,
-0.16594906151294708,
0.12464120239019394,
-0.7810559868812561,
-0.7161505222320557,
0.6677792072296143,
-0.003509089583531022,
-0.1929357498884201,
0.11371783167123795,
0.8764851689338684,
0.054562635719776154,
0.09433314204216003,
-0.4957265555858612,
-0.2060175985097885,
0.07379889488220215,
-0.2665426731109619,
0.2319316267967224,
-0.464866042137146,
-0.20400641858577728,
-0.24239157140254974,
0.5506913065910339,
-0.1378544718027115,
0.4113140404224396,
0.46838614344596863,
-0.3248956501483917,
0.09789350628852844,
-0.02837260067462921,
0.22260737419128418,
0.6830430626869202,
-0.12219587713479996,
0.10489662736654282,
0.2940724790096283,
-0.6279637813568115,
0.21770255267620087,
-0.22878165543079376,
-0.25835341215133667,
-0.08193033188581467,
0.25888949632644653,
0.3073723018169403,
0.045333731919527054,
-0.5265613198280334,
0.9666624665260315,
-0.17285193502902985,
-0.11619027704000473,
-0.7580295205116272,
0.2670328617095947,
-0.5464722514152527,
0.06646817922592163,
0.7335996627807617,
-0.18602149188518524,
0.16583426296710968,
-0.15270651876926422,
0.409475713968277,
0.6060840487480164,
-0.26012271642684937,
-0.4708702862262726,
0.5666579604148865,
0.22446638345718384,
-0.48831045627593994,
0.672235906124115,
0.004775424487888813,
-0.49620646238327026,
0.4787457585334778,
0.6251137852668762,
0.7345762252807617,
-0.09271195530891418,
-0.14077644050121307,
0.5381580591201782,
-0.18084381520748138,
-0.20225019752979279,
0.17260409891605377,
-0.17801672220230103,
-0.517620861530304,
0.2119828760623932,
0.1449410766363144,
-0.42970699071884155,
-0.1903921663761139,
-1.1468936204910278,
0.5182281732559204,
-0.8586655855178833,
-0.21887819468975067,
-0.1247573122382164,
0.22743798792362213,
-0.6238069534301758,
0.36590030789375305,
0.27147775888442993,
0.8225902915000916,
-0.6326472759246826,
0.8776497840881348,
0.3864411413669586,
0.02931550331413746,
-0.8750672340393066,
-0.1517125815153122,
0.07537629455327988,
-0.7604497075080872,
1.026358962059021,
0.6966232657432556,
-0.319498747587204,
0.13195504248142242,
-0.8448382019996643,
-1.0438494682312012,
1.3310774564743042,
0.20687457919120789,
-0.5145459771156311,
-0.036991775035858154,
0.29052454233169556,
0.03644001483917236,
-1.0074294805526733,
0.279043585062027,
0.7127202749252319,
0.16344590485095978,
0.22338594496250153,
-0.4058607518672943,
0.022334560751914978,
-0.3051922023296356,
-0.03954378142952919,
-0.37692174315452576,
-0.4646565318107605,
0.7961509823799133,
-0.24242551624774933,
-0.7482042908668518,
0.122711680829525,
0.5767298340797424,
0.2559202313423157,
0.5761386752128601,
0.4956565797328949,
0.3363029956817627,
1.2861735820770264,
-0.16148197650909424,
0.8877860307693481,
-0.43532949686050415,
0.11826831847429276,
1.0301313400268555,
-0.3631337583065033,
0.5133757591247559,
0.4948958158493042,
0.21646219491958618,
0.0447603240609169,
0.7858290672302246,
-0.025340693071484566,
0.7839503884315491,
0.12567396461963654,
-0.3070284426212311,
-0.16830287873744965,
0.21684211492538452,
-0.2661135196685791,
0.30651047825813293,
0.5188814997673035,
-0.503336489200592,
-0.0873662531375885,
0.012736758217215538,
0.239012211561203,
-0.22672484815120697,
-0.25510698556900024,
1.011173129081726,
0.019478417932987213,
-0.5942055583000183,
0.7686561942100525,
0.0014537251554429531,
0.48417556285858154,
-0.23501771688461304,
-0.22140927612781525,
-0.18995538353919983,
0.14981524646282196,
-0.34461578726768494,
0.03424743562936783,
0.04827088490128517,
0.2673477232456207,
-0.18420113623142242,
-0.38239026069641113,
0.7255063056945801,
-0.2752801477909088,
-0.2884559631347656,
-0.2629709243774414,
0.48616066575050354,
0.6217167377471924,
-0.4952026307582855,
-0.6397921442985535,
0.08109258860349655,
0.13156750798225403,
-0.15527702867984772,
0.37415561079978943,
0.5118526220321655,
0.029561322182416916,
0.7633348107337952,
1.0011074542999268,
0.1606721431016922,
0.2569360136985779,
-0.3880179524421692,
1.2794253826141357,
-0.9854654669761658,
-0.4345930814743042,
-1.0927772521972656,
0.5430068373680115,
-0.7001357674598694,
-0.3779660165309906,
0.9487490653991699,
0.69361811876297,
0.4833797514438629,
0.11721450090408325,
0.7188456058502197,
0.1936948001384735,
0.7951513528823853,
-0.45259973406791687,
0.42418989539146423,
0.120250403881073,
0.8095992803573608,
-0.04963793605566025,
-0.6616556644439697,
-0.39869171380996704,
0.7906970381736755,
-0.7229917049407959,
-0.4609552025794983,
0.43512266874313354,
0.8751021027565002,
0.027640236541628838,
0.15323211252689362,
0.3249916136264801,
-0.339204341173172,
0.5735580921173096,
0.39220115542411804,
0.887948751449585,
-0.701621413230896,
0.09743451327085495,
-0.4509875178337097,
-0.5349622964859009,
0.00011112634820165113,
-0.861586332321167,
-1.2442901134490967,
0.048367682844400406,
-0.30554667115211487,
-0.3324546217918396,
-0.07231488823890686,
0.8467847108840942,
0.9973936080932617,
-0.777656078338623,
-0.209411159157753,
-0.11679019778966904,
0.19710689783096313,
0.05527034029364586,
-0.17936238646507263,
0.389723002910614,
-0.32657310366630554,
-0.7619162797927856,
0.6421427726745605,
0.04044002294540405,
0.2628885507583618,
0.2181512862443924,
-0.1270095556974411,
0.2603655457496643,
-0.5259695649147034,
0.26271703839302063,
0.43645018339157104,
-0.43918630480766296,
-0.09273044019937515,
0.08615117520093918,
-0.14532621204853058,
0.3629680573940277,
1.1547346115112305,
-0.6682576537132263,
0.2238491326570511,
-0.07695914059877396,
0.9400519728660583,
0.2554710805416107,
0.8304322957992554,
0.8199961185455322,
-0.5559471845626831,
0.3102421164512634,
0.03209485486149788,
0.10407862067222595,
0.3169771432876587,
-1.060680866241455,
0.7411133646965027,
0.4509158134460449,
-0.26227831840515137,
-0.7395257949829102,
-0.03791790083050728,
-0.6667791604995728,
0.0988030657172203,
1.3231306076049805,
-0.640530526638031,
-0.43218451738357544,
-0.2275438755750656,
-0.3469945788383484,
-0.10252338647842407,
-0.3759576976299286,
0.645048975944519,
0.5354431867599487,
-0.12588118016719818,
-0.09390705823898315,
-0.09939397871494293,
0.415465772151947,
0.26533907651901245,
-0.6480221152305603,
0.17266526818275452,
0.44966402649879456,
0.4114351272583008,
0.23280124366283417,
0.6971971988677979,
-0.4411405920982361,
0.13904105126857758,
-0.2869167625904083,
-0.2432442009449005,
-0.2951849699020386,
-0.6248195767402649,
-0.7691591382026672,
0.3338487446308136,
-0.15020723640918732,
-0.42556673288345337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02937v1 | Probing the Feasibility of Multilingual Speaker Anonymization | 2024-07-03T09:12:53 | 2024-07-03T09:12:53 | Sarina Meyer, Florian Lux, Ngoc Thang Vu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In speaker anonymization, speech recordings are modified in a way that the
identity of the speaker remains hidden. While this technology could help to
protect the privacy of individuals around the globe, current research restricts
this by focusing almost exclusively on English data. In this study, we extend a
state-of-the-art anonymization system to nine languages by transforming
language-dependent components to their multilingual counterparts. Experiments
testing the robustness of the anonymized speech against privacy attacks and
speech deterioration show an overall success of this system for all languages.
The results suggest that speaker embeddings trained on English data can be
applied across languages, and that the anonymization performance for a language
is mainly affected by the quality of the speech synthesis component used for
it. | [
-0.27576515078544617,
-0.7858365178108215,
0.2392554134130478,
0.2007930874824524,
0.08236941695213318,
0.2713480293750763,
-0.4595435857772827,
-0.8064942359924316,
0.41869059205055237,
0.4102729260921478,
-0.22709792852401733,
-0.3910630941390991,
-0.4946783483028412,
0.3247236907482147,
-0.48879382014274597,
0.612458348274231,
0.4022250771522522,
0.3880365788936615,
0.1794952005147934,
-0.33342400193214417,
-0.3623780310153961,
-0.8755197525024414,
-0.42909467220306396,
-0.12726189196109772,
0.35240331292152405,
0.2565460801124573,
0.8708036541938782,
0.7606638073921204,
0.11853349953889847,
0.36654332280158997,
-0.00797202903777361,
0.12992727756500244,
-0.33224576711654663,
0.20828962326049805,
-0.31301048398017883,
-0.3517763018608093,
-0.2747950851917267,
0.030909642577171326,
1.0132081508636475,
0.7569947838783264,
-0.16480836272239685,
-0.13173648715019226,
-0.00007536615885328501,
0.2378968596458435,
-0.6470831036567688,
0.20712164044380188,
-0.4843944013118744,
0.04392372816801071,
-0.47794297337532043,
-0.12149346619844437,
-0.5216078758239746,
-0.378741592168808,
-0.09515653550624847,
-0.22783444821834564,
0.1437850445508957,
0.1193958967924118,
0.6691123247146606,
-0.1474127322435379,
-0.35359901189804077,
-0.23565353453159332,
-1.1718569993972778,
0.7063421010971069,
-0.5788072943687439,
0.7519674897193909,
0.5144946575164795,
0.4568682909011841,
0.15116682648658752,
-0.22851717472076416,
-0.4423566460609436,
-0.22266386449337006,
-0.25112685561180115,
-0.11325817555189133,
-0.047858498990535736,
-0.05589951574802399,
0.018415816128253937,
0.33525151014328003,
-0.43750321865081787,
0.1640017330646515,
-0.2800651490688324,
-0.535280704498291,
0.7925641536712646,
-0.2959446310997009,
0.7249878644943237,
0.10410331934690475,
-0.2733423411846161,
-0.16261135041713715,
-0.5957033634185791,
-0.08644198626279831,
0.7767288684844971,
0.5533118844032288,
-0.03254405036568642,
0.3861102759838104,
-0.10477691888809204,
0.4900935888290405,
-0.25704634189605713,
-0.6606760621070862,
0.3357996344566345,
-0.3768221139907837,
0.27955323457717896,
0.36992147564888,
0.7026515007019043,
-0.0032568250317126513,
0.11362946778535843,
-0.4136350452899933,
0.03860880807042122,
0.08567989617586136,
-0.08594727516174316,
-0.5197502970695496,
-0.2369552105665207,
0.2000734806060791,
-0.18720823526382446,
0.18994885683059692,
0.06215645745396614,
-0.5703256130218506,
-0.4493066370487213,
0.1250855177640915,
0.4897281229496002,
-0.5299202799797058,
-0.5308217406272888,
0.18382686376571655,
-0.03424501046538353,
-0.01294722594320774,
0.05787912756204605,
-0.9868791699409485,
0.3497605621814728,
0.5904031991958618,
0.5173646211624146,
-0.10766472667455673,
-0.7024475336074829,
-0.34917351603507996,
0.38798534870147705,
-0.3862903416156769,
0.5611039400100708,
-0.7800576090812683,
-0.4135640263557434,
0.18664856255054474,
0.2923000752925873,
-0.21254287660121918,
-0.3214147388935089,
-0.13316906988620758,
-0.24864619970321655,
0.3963688313961029,
-0.16186374425888062,
-0.48852860927581787,
-0.10941216349601746,
0.22728179395198822,
-0.6525949239730835,
0.4547312259674072,
-0.388683944940567,
-0.8309539556503296,
0.00727074546739459,
-0.2951340675354004,
-0.617408812046051,
-0.03985277935862541,
-0.2339319884777069,
-0.3711056411266327,
-0.009219789877533913,
0.13573689758777618,
0.30438119173049927,
0.04139883443713188,
0.16947878897190094,
-0.1503312885761261,
-0.12110505998134613,
0.4923064410686493,
-0.5215851068496704,
0.9012688994407654,
0.15754161775112152,
-0.1878538578748703,
-0.38064509630203247,
-0.8769204020500183,
-0.3228723108768463,
-0.01008843258023262,
-0.3146394193172455,
-0.2700372636318207,
0.0825154259800911,
-0.047158610075712204,
-0.16207031905651093,
0.3369280695915222,
-1.0832749605178833,
-0.056961603462696075,
-0.5928652882575989,
0.39439064264297485,
0.4284217655658722,
0.1859256625175476,
0.49478957056999207,
-0.24315649271011353,
0.6946141123771667,
-0.19531193375587463,
0.02521049790084362,
-0.547677755355835,
-0.5775230526924133,
-0.5294175744056702,
-0.44438546895980835,
0.60610431432724,
0.789814829826355,
-0.5136485695838928,
-0.08203825354576111,
-0.2814977169036865,
-0.28762301802635193,
-0.7809527516365051,
-0.014823083765804768,
0.5299824476242065,
0.21625740826129913,
0.18899784982204437,
-0.28066954016685486,
-0.4219885766506195,
-1.1011065244674683,
-0.5038135647773743,
-0.21424421668052673,
0.02584458515048027,
0.25182467699050903,
-0.01897514797747135,
-0.004862010944634676,
0.6215932965278625,
-0.1070384532213211,
-0.3404931426048279,
-0.08314616978168488,
-0.38545742630958557,
-0.04537738114595413,
0.6295590400695801,
0.5994321703910828,
-0.7276894450187683,
-0.6985418200492859,
0.4064387381076813,
-0.5278862118721008,
0.17436832189559937,
-0.210740327835083,
0.11878383159637451,
-0.018018309026956558,
0.42509526014328003,
-0.16047325730323792,
0.4526746869087219,
0.8748012185096741,
-0.19041207432746887,
0.22861860692501068,
-0.4500778317451477,
0.24915851652622223,
-1.0869536399841309,
-0.0439847856760025,
-0.411404013633728,
-0.34109339118003845,
-1.104516625404358,
-0.017018863931298256,
0.06036032363772392,
-0.5203892588615417,
-0.5666946172714233,
0.5602983236312866,
-0.5904265642166138,
-0.022326845675706863,
-0.16975605487823486,
-0.07371623814105988,
-0.14057374000549316,
0.216125026345253,
-0.025836210697889328,
0.6813567876815796,
1.0869158506393433,
-0.39051952958106995,
0.1709621548652649,
0.27528953552246094,
-0.21660980582237244,
0.5041609406471252,
-0.27380919456481934,
0.3222869336605072,
-0.32726672291755676,
-0.19175709784030914,
-1.093203067779541,
-0.34108299016952515,
-0.02932925708591938,
-0.6426783204078674,
0.6371946930885315,
-0.19164757430553436,
-0.2874091565608978,
0.4273524284362793,
-0.21032121777534485,
0.36086422204971313,
0.1473243534564972,
-0.7078272104263306,
0.5078707933425903,
0.7585993409156799,
-0.5601548552513123,
-0.585066020488739,
-0.9309849143028259,
0.6529096961021423,
-0.25634169578552246,
-0.5642731785774231,
0.35039493441581726,
-0.115301713347435,
-0.2688920497894287,
-0.03329632058739662,
0.22393977642059326,
-0.3475053608417511,
-0.005800873972475529,
-0.12750963866710663,
-0.24012991786003113,
0.10166970640420914,
0.19572991132736206,
-0.059917330741882324,
-0.2578451931476593,
-0.11742322891950607,
-0.12554848194122314,
0.37929221987724304,
0.25192391872406006,
-0.40695351362228394,
-0.7398285865783691,
0.9875433444976807,
0.3637141287326813,
-0.5072469115257263,
0.8366590142250061,
0.37404876947402954,
-0.48994332551956177,
-0.2487160861492157,
-0.781847357749939,
-0.06756153702735901,
-0.4595932066440582,
0.3049885630607605,
-0.5200731754302979,
-0.8984330296516418,
0.6627001166343689,
-0.018719526007771492,
0.10210484266281128,
-0.015196106396615505,
0.1948997974395752,
0.19937214255332947,
1.0523878335952759,
0.8579525947570801,
-0.26960310339927673,
0.36921223998069763,
0.2277115136384964,
0.4553358554840088,
-0.17359445989131927,
-0.2812572121620178,
-0.8287730813026428,
0.014099853113293648,
-1.1881940364837646,
-0.1719893515110016,
0.3796282112598419,
-0.3976152837276459,
0.20756833255290985,
0.32415640354156494,
-0.34850743412971497,
0.6184676289558411,
0.4896930456161499,
0.0939190462231636,
0.30194926261901855,
0.22895416617393494,
0.12659922242164612,
-0.0872618779540062,
-0.41654664278030396,
-0.3992205262184143,
0.7532062530517578,
0.34818798303604126,
0.642306387424469,
0.3316113352775574,
0.8713081479072571,
0.16493751108646393,
-0.1599659025669098,
-0.4943404197692871,
0.3379252851009369,
-0.2743188738822937,
-0.7374861240386963,
-0.6110215783119202,
-0.3435007929801941,
-1.0786364078521729,
0.4349663555622101,
0.013535791076719761,
-1.0573018789291382,
0.39249637722969055,
0.11442600935697556,
0.10372171550989151,
0.24723251163959503,
-0.7362473607063293,
0.5092059969902039,
-0.032284390181303024,
-0.12765610218048096,
-0.21941284835338593,
-0.5553188920021057,
0.0037355313543230295,
-0.22524558007717133,
0.7984705567359924,
-0.12207530438899994,
0.1550602912902832,
0.7392457723617554,
-0.2498869150876999,
0.7915962338447571,
-0.29768118262290955,
-0.11059793829917908,
-0.1360439658164978,
0.09930182248353958,
0.2653149366378784,
0.20823119580745697,
-0.2846595048904419,
0.3694727122783661,
-0.10909118503332138,
-0.6350056529045105,
-0.4423225224018097,
0.7798363566398621,
-0.49451059103012085,
-0.7040331363677979,
-0.0333767831325531,
-0.3858005106449127,
-0.47398969531059265,
0.26674655079841614,
0.044744547456502914,
0.33294326066970825,
-0.22585776448249817,
0.29801061749458313,
0.38947877287864685,
-0.3804117739200592,
0.6963781118392944,
0.5758123993873596,
0.020249145105481148,
-0.5849488973617554,
1.026254653930664,
0.37563398480415344,
0.04509229212999344,
0.377017080783844,
0.4254557490348816,
-0.3435911238193512,
-0.46371081471443176,
-0.38960132002830505,
0.4453338086605072,
-0.6534567475318909,
0.22855164110660553,
-0.4847365915775299,
-0.012698124162852764,
-0.5398495197296143,
-0.023491958156228065,
-0.666510283946991,
-0.8479101657867432,
0.09524902701377869,
-0.3166525363922119,
-0.04227165877819061,
0.9244915843009949,
-0.27637168765068054,
0.0018394769867882133,
-0.6175318956375122,
0.19836275279521942,
0.4796302616596222,
0.14846917986869812,
-0.25582554936408997,
-0.4116634726524353,
-0.33461815118789673,
0.026261359453201294,
0.12889236211776733,
-1.106342077255249,
0.3888033628463745,
0.7021925449371338,
0.7207434177398682,
0.11016640812158585,
-0.04428952932357788,
0.5820673704147339,
-0.8905762434005737,
0.8359024524688721,
0.14670732617378235,
-0.9413662552833557,
0.6337561011314392,
-0.11378473788499832,
0.2725844979286194,
0.313810259103775,
0.23162630200386047,
-0.4392971694469452,
-0.8068044781684875,
-0.5157102346420288,
-0.723756730556488,
0.7269615530967712,
0.186685711145401,
0.5596070289611816,
0.2927245795726776,
0.06330038607120514,
0.38680654764175415,
0.15236900746822357,
-0.5780518651008606,
-0.5904452800750732,
-0.19900357723236084,
0.238839790225029,
-0.5432950258255005,
-0.20350900292396545,
-0.09516621381044388,
-0.11640351265668869,
0.4977481961250305,
0.23912961781024933,
0.15058305859565735,
0.04580395668745041,
-0.09846167266368866,
0.33858242630958557,
0.6143072843551636,
0.5018932819366455,
0.710451066493988,
0.18257580697536469,
0.4144233167171478,
-0.03188977763056755,
-0.3402296304702759,
0.4573062062263489,
0.2257145494222641,
-0.3657112419605255,
0.4169749617576599,
0.29957282543182373,
0.6440352201461792,
-0.08048290014266968,
-0.180213063955307,
0.4159259796142578,
-0.07943452894687653,
-0.060010816901922226,
-0.14770719408988953,
-0.12789286673069,
0.112327441573143,
-0.028200019150972366,
0.2743535339832306,
-0.11342839896678925,
0.09259428083896637,
-0.6362732648849487,
0.28838011622428894,
0.24659588932991028,
-0.04679970443248749,
-0.6944529414176941,
0.7926008701324463,
0.04144292697310448,
-0.7332900762557983,
0.006816069129854441,
-0.20495054125785828,
-0.3325245678424835,
-0.02204957976937294,
0.7271443009376526,
0.7501009702682495,
-1.1191128492355347,
0.2880572974681854,
0.24131973087787628,
0.39507102966308594,
0.08598995208740234,
0.44104012846946716,
-0.06479004770517349,
-0.7636916041374207,
-0.25736284255981445,
-0.3275909721851349,
-0.6671698689460754,
-0.12582768499851227,
-0.7518513798713684,
-0.17003780603408813,
-0.31264644861221313,
-0.17355231940746307,
0.17082597315311432,
-0.4566109776496887,
-0.5482270121574402,
0.04733888804912567,
0.34623274207115173,
0.2782878279685974,
-1.0826984643936157,
1.0285918712615967,
0.8502781391143799,
0.21952411532402039,
-0.48825985193252563,
-0.10558545589447021,
0.03819093853235245,
-0.6290707588195801,
0.12888365983963013,
0.026502186432480812,
-0.12966835498809814,
-0.1442853808403015,
-0.12218184024095535,
-0.8935840129852295,
0.5485715866088867,
0.9440609216690063,
-0.37515661120414734,
0.385431170463562,
0.7489414811134338,
0.5259072184562683,
-0.19259841740131378,
-0.14243152737617493,
0.4758373200893402,
0.40101152658462524,
-0.39579200744628906,
-1.3378905057907104,
-0.0891946405172348,
-0.16410325467586517,
0.02235407382249832,
-0.007997955195605755,
-0.8046373724937439,
0.8520378470420837,
0.10551335662603378,
-0.45700499415397644,
-0.30555459856987,
0.3753401041030884,
-0.20829764008522034,
-0.014219398610293865,
0.35250324010849,
0.13427066802978516,
0.9895663857460022,
0.09887756407260895,
0.733807384967804,
-0.666267991065979,
0.24199412763118744,
0.9317176342010498,
-0.2157764583826065,
0.7832735776901245,
0.43427860736846924,
-0.10184485465288162,
0.33601903915405273,
0.10170922428369522,
0.26631030440330505,
0.5876343846321106,
-0.04000082612037659,
-0.42390939593315125,
-0.11626236885786057,
-0.40707507729530334,
-0.378103643655777,
0.8135784268379211,
0.3535631000995636,
-0.11763545125722885,
-0.09955300390720367,
0.5863956809043884,
0.395809531211853,
0.25576668977737427,
0.11322341859340668,
0.7219363451004028,
-0.12861661612987518,
-0.3614475429058075,
0.7044586539268494,
0.12113575637340546,
0.35866639018058777,
-0.589195191860199,
0.04084207862615585,
-0.3150343596935272,
0.16671976447105408,
-0.1814645230770111,
-0.11071423441171646,
0.09878289699554443,
-0.06011869013309479,
0.12119879573583603,
-0.6007372140884399,
0.5811200737953186,
-0.6605165004730225,
-0.44291093945503235,
0.34638550877571106,
0.5148835778236389,
0.34856340289115906,
0.30859559774398804,
-0.2869606614112854,
0.2079014778137207,
0.22251318395137787,
-0.3158796727657318,
0.5694855451583862,
0.18402640521526337,
0.2559332847595215,
0.694724440574646,
0.2482631951570511,
0.4281165897846222,
0.2861948311328888,
0.10228710621595383,
0.5332080721855164,
-0.5881048440933228,
-0.8792650699615479,
-0.8309034109115601,
0.393228679895401,
-0.08264433592557907,
-0.07473231852054596,
1.4416320323944092,
0.6569116115570068,
1.2369543313980103,
0.13158577680587769,
0.9389382600784302,
0.2571701407432556,
0.841740608215332,
-0.4518785774707794,
0.7001241445541382,
-0.294611394405365,
0.3739287853240967,
-0.15742649137973785,
-0.8312366008758545,
-0.41940996050834656,
0.4434715807437897,
0.2782781422138214,
-0.35265082120895386,
0.6131300330162048,
0.9770046472549438,
0.08147384971380234,
0.027745788916945457,
0.7238951921463013,
0.17122846841812134,
0.42132607102394104,
0.06040928512811661,
0.5625823140144348,
-0.2811913788318634,
0.44837841391563416,
-0.7338149547576904,
-0.1880357414484024,
0.30615803599357605,
-0.5842525959014893,
-0.8088699579238892,
-0.4608461260795593,
-0.4952918291091919,
0.07006031274795532,
0.33626601099967957,
0.2411223202943802,
0.816004753112793,
-1.0721739530563354,
-0.5280028581619263,
0.5855720043182373,
-0.1754065454006195,
-0.11310431361198425,
-0.09852016717195511,
0.529960036277771,
-0.10079021751880646,
-1.034519076347351,
1.155013918876648,
0.35358595848083496,
0.1208905354142189,
-0.442729651927948,
0.022399520501494408,
-0.04365349933505058,
0.07210519909858704,
0.2901926338672638,
0.4349840581417084,
-0.6712520718574524,
-0.5814400911331177,
-0.04314212501049042,
0.2635347247123718,
0.06085438281297684,
0.6593911647796631,
-0.34643346071243286,
1.059978723526001,
0.40230539441108704,
0.7737357020378113,
0.4149923324584961,
0.14857196807861328,
0.5608060956001282,
-1.33450186252594,
0.422780841588974,
0.17332275211811066,
0.4769608974456787,
0.4525662362575531,
-0.24852126836776733,
0.08813126385211945,
0.09933629631996155,
-0.4082191586494446,
-0.9212045073509216,
0.17003004252910614,
-0.5452727675437927,
-0.2834821343421936,
1.1907744407653809,
-0.5316727757453918,
0.05229143053293228,
-0.34330475330352783,
-0.04279385507106781,
-0.010086179710924625,
-0.29748600721359253,
0.6897095441818237,
0.7808334827423096,
-0.1532006412744522,
-0.12912437319755554,
-0.5485352277755737,
0.3694871664047241,
0.4419018030166626,
-0.5081945657730103,
-0.03871750831604004,
0.20814231038093567,
0.2721942961215973,
0.4912412464618683,
0.7798433303833008,
-0.28051236271858215,
0.09019915759563446,
0.1814960539340973,
-0.03521821275353432,
-0.043940767645835876,
-0.48551779985427856,
-0.5214415788650513,
0.5114293694496155,
0.18226556479930878,
-0.6862779259681702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02936v1 | GraCoRe: Benchmarking Graph Comprehension and Complex Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2024-07-03T09:12:38 | 2024-07-03T09:12:38 | Zike Yuan, Ming Liu, Hui Wang, Bing Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Evaluating the graph comprehension and reasoning abilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) is challenging and often incomplete. Existing benchmarks focus
primarily on pure graph understanding, lacking a comprehensive evaluation
across all graph types and detailed capability definitions. This paper presents
GraCoRe, a benchmark for systematically assessing LLMs' graph comprehension and
reasoning. GraCoRe uses a three-tier hierarchical taxonomy to categorize and
test models on pure graph and heterogeneous graphs, subdividing capabilities
into 10 distinct areas tested through 19 tasks. Our benchmark includes 11
datasets with 5,140 graphs of varying complexity. We evaluated three
closed-source and seven open-source LLMs, conducting thorough analyses from
both ability and task perspectives. Key findings reveal that semantic
enrichment enhances reasoning performance, node ordering impacts task success,
and the ability to process longer texts does not necessarily improve graph
comprehension or reasoning. GraCoRe is open-sourced at
https://github.com/ZIKEYUAN/GraCoRe | [
-0.44237715005874634,
-0.7925092577934265,
0.7265850901603699,
0.30500540137290955,
0.0009527195943519473,
0.2626194357872009,
-0.3874807357788086,
-0.7386764287948608,
-0.3604576885700226,
0.5256099104881287,
-0.3147815763950348,
-0.6883139610290527,
-0.8404956459999084,
0.23719963431358337,
-0.32672828435897827,
0.6446037888526917,
-0.3960176408290863,
0.014108747243881226,
-0.6203539967536926,
-0.39283642172813416,
-0.20688514411449432,
-0.29829198122024536,
-0.6408148407936096,
-0.6493382453918457,
0.7489748597145081,
0.06104772537946701,
0.46058395504951477,
0.5237868428230286,
0.44361424446105957,
0.317656010389328,
-0.33194786310195923,
0.5071222186088562,
-0.657189667224884,
0.06169745698571205,
-0.2842964828014374,
-0.07006049901247025,
-0.4092784523963928,
-0.15171194076538086,
0.6610817909240723,
0.9625545144081116,
0.06305912882089615,
0.12650734186172485,
0.21929800510406494,
0.4748063385486603,
-0.8610144853591919,
0.5260708928108215,
-0.56438148021698,
-0.3769073784351349,
0.08343274891376495,
0.12358041107654572,
-0.4221574366092682,
-0.6681047677993774,
0.11524664610624313,
-0.7988291382789612,
0.11399584263563156,
-0.004430077970027924,
0.9584494233131409,
0.10994943231344223,
-0.5405210852622986,
-0.3805146813392639,
-0.3772616386413574,
0.5446158647537231,
-0.5847024917602539,
0.6056694388389587,
0.3084374964237213,
0.6246113181114197,
-0.1974399983882904,
-1.3004270792007446,
-0.4055192768573761,
-0.3487258851528168,
-0.2541743516921997,
-0.05963650345802307,
-0.3472316861152649,
0.3503054976463318,
0.30327844619750977,
0.45540791749954224,
-0.6094613075256348,
-0.0073531875386834145,
-0.15120422840118408,
-0.3371979892253876,
0.38723835349082947,
0.19522924721240997,
0.36347392201423645,
0.14220520853996277,
-0.08262406289577484,
-0.3485618233680725,
-0.4953593909740448,
0.0487237386405468,
0.4964611530303955,
0.3538350462913513,
0.2841850817203522,
0.524197518825531,
-0.5039696097373962,
1.065975308418274,
-0.5023313760757446,
-0.3454924523830414,
0.4712223410606384,
-0.2036949247121811,
-0.2720228135585785,
-0.20319120585918427,
0.6771973371505737,
0.12944719195365906,
0.3969842791557312,
-0.4630688726902008,
-0.33594173192977905,
0.11314482241868973,
-0.09921535104513168,
-0.8448689579963684,
-0.20340895652770996,
0.1435888260602951,
-0.09815876185894012,
0.15014243125915527,
-0.12546980381011963,
-0.6838435530662537,
-0.4307693541049957,
-0.16398750245571136,
0.3376009166240692,
-0.41488116979599,
0.2356308400630951,
0.5804386138916016,
-0.4696314036846161,
-0.0653509870171547,
0.3147336542606354,
-0.7642408609390259,
0.5964454412460327,
1.0072191953659058,
0.7948123812675476,
-0.02724253199994564,
-0.7365401387214661,
-0.6129999756813049,
0.19226348400115967,
-0.11082389205694199,
1.1141334772109985,
-0.647978663444519,
-0.23293077945709229,
-0.0406787134706974,
0.3457448482513428,
-0.5679346919059753,
-0.5436703562736511,
0.8244466781616211,
-0.5058791041374207,
0.001726921065710485,
-0.3717711269855499,
-0.600706934928894,
-0.4554637372493744,
0.5391499996185303,
-0.6758114695549011,
1.0050057172775269,
0.4945490062236786,
-0.7366458773612976,
0.4699424207210541,
-0.35253557562828064,
-0.6324449181556702,
0.35407498478889465,
-0.3035290539264679,
-0.06868885457515717,
-0.33251699805259705,
0.35932499170303345,
0.10850014537572861,
-0.586026668548584,
0.20965053141117096,
-0.46581247448921204,
-0.47026491165161133,
-0.14990775287151337,
-0.05692640319466591,
0.5465371012687683,
0.05684208124876022,
-0.14111940562725067,
0.028630627319216728,
-0.5733917355537415,
0.427927702665329,
0.13658078014850616,
-0.3700973689556122,
-0.2754705548286438,
0.029235724359750748,
-0.13342714309692383,
-0.009710664860904217,
0.3247371315956116,
-0.5390832424163818,
0.16261352598667145,
-0.19058677554130554,
0.8140602111816406,
0.5098404884338379,
-0.026318848133087158,
0.13630566000938416,
-0.2340155392885208,
0.35920125246047974,
-0.7462427020072937,
0.1489245593547821,
0.06758712977170944,
-0.43796199560165405,
-0.5410565733909607,
-0.7089148163795471,
0.31641125679016113,
0.43663477897644043,
-0.40282946825027466,
0.3450385630130768,
-0.5746756792068481,
-0.7419732809066772,
-0.2841170132160187,
0.19900476932525635,
0.45555204153060913,
0.6132444739341736,
0.43673065304756165,
-0.20839999616146088,
-0.10614284127950668,
-0.9215570092201233,
-0.4675476551055908,
-0.2621571719646454,
-0.06970373541116714,
0.6801609396934509,
0.5350732207298279,
-0.5753893256187439,
0.661622941493988,
-0.49071431159973145,
-0.002820210764184594,
-0.26933300495147705,
0.3522716164588928,
0.16455766558647156,
0.04168430715799332,
0.6258248090744019,
-0.36884909868240356,
-0.2333361953496933,
0.3025975227355957,
-0.6265965700149536,
-0.39242392778396606,
0.3767488896846771,
0.0419786237180233,
-0.0872679352760315,
0.43425121903419495,
-0.5274854302406311,
-0.022476891055703163,
0.8202890753746033,
-0.312260240316391,
0.3901270031929016,
-0.30401116609573364,
0.3190959095954895,
-0.3648572564125061,
0.33061614632606506,
-0.190940260887146,
-0.24810603260993958,
-0.3404719829559326,
0.18397757411003113,
0.07352463155984879,
-0.032141271978616714,
-0.2920593321323395,
0.7062123417854309,
-0.41088244318962097,
-0.5154618620872498,
-0.024953991174697876,
0.3960307240486145,
0.4166836440563202,
0.236542746424675,
-0.21212711930274963,
0.9331745505332947,
0.42938295006752014,
-0.45955824851989746,
0.3216520845890045,
0.2656751573085785,
-0.8995409607887268,
0.1653907150030136,
-1.1173937320709229,
0.1633533388376236,
0.07392452657222748,
0.28678131103515625,
-1.2523938417434692,
-0.3668227791786194,
-0.05991073697805405,
-0.12947797775268555,
-0.09075579792261124,
-0.2785901129245758,
-0.7532976865768433,
-0.5109241604804993,
0.012913117185235023,
0.37372303009033203,
0.25383371114730835,
-0.6003717184066772,
0.8731470704078674,
0.30754753947257996,
-0.2071477174758911,
-0.46720099449157715,
-0.5601655840873718,
-0.05709852650761604,
0.04358220845460892,
-0.885769784450531,
0.216770201921463,
0.0820617750287056,
-0.26192328333854675,
0.1132272481918335,
-0.15955650806427002,
-0.11792119592428207,
0.10254132747650146,
-0.004843817092478275,
-0.13483628630638123,
-0.08210346847772598,
0.009345206432044506,
0.10856865346431732,
-0.1662643700838089,
-0.054774172604084015,
-0.17928241193294525,
0.7790417075157166,
-0.3055241107940674,
-0.47546643018722534,
0.11192003637552261,
-0.0722508579492569,
0.734978973865509,
-0.4311482906341553,
0.36637482047080994,
0.27780401706695557,
-0.1452803760766983,
-0.20871208608150482,
-0.40790215134620667,
0.18437528610229492,
-0.47698378562927246,
0.4418054521083832,
-0.35834071040153503,
-1.159042239189148,
0.6762096285820007,
-0.17665664851665497,
-0.10961010307073593,
0.35294392704963684,
0.4913780987262726,
0.3086608350276947,
1.164937138557434,
0.17304860055446625,
-0.036340534687042236,
0.15538804233074188,
-0.2268335372209549,
0.28041473031044006,
-0.6307716965675354,
-0.4569847881793976,
-0.800491213798523,
0.0488424226641655,
-0.41543665528297424,
-0.40944749116897583,
0.18074831366539001,
0.1682988852262497,
-0.6120412945747375,
0.3172451853752136,
-0.3491068482398987,
0.6006513237953186,
0.23794730007648468,
-0.06283127516508102,
0.5006247162818909,
-0.08857311308383942,
-0.10234628617763519,
0.3705211281776428,
-0.47097137570381165,
-0.7265755534172058,
0.6837782263755798,
0.33800867199897766,
0.7787565588951111,
-0.15507112443447113,
0.19436290860176086,
0.23346790671348572,
0.3086569309234619,
-0.7681721448898315,
0.7307306528091431,
-0.22100786864757538,
-0.3766426742076874,
-0.27023497223854065,
-0.623471200466156,
-1.008836030960083,
0.4703845679759979,
0.021411001682281494,
-1.1197333335876465,
0.17817239463329315,
-0.13313302397727966,
0.1771485060453415,
0.15904930233955383,
-0.636496901512146,
1.1315937042236328,
-0.27065300941467285,
-0.056596506386995316,
-0.10064397007226944,
-0.21067874133586884,
0.31485801935195923,
0.07573218643665314,
0.07299637049436569,
-0.4240822196006775,
-0.15697337687015533,
0.6890406608581543,
-0.37884703278541565,
0.32678717374801636,
0.042513374239206314,
-0.05258709937334061,
0.198772594332695,
0.20418298244476318,
0.5763565897941589,
-0.009232074953615665,
-0.20127956569194794,
0.2268357276916504,
0.049343761056661606,
-0.5568060278892517,
-0.6295140981674194,
0.7872797846794128,
-0.8066555261611938,
-0.4494497776031494,
-0.14630770683288574,
-0.7582830190658569,
-0.687660813331604,
0.5443968176841736,
0.2587108314037323,
0.47182995080947876,
-0.2320539951324463,
0.2375694215297699,
0.5055643320083618,
0.021540692076086998,
0.04616626724600792,
0.32264038920402527,
-0.28279855847358704,
-0.7135086059570312,
0.7410637736320496,
0.09185086190700531,
0.4791310131549835,
0.27395129203796387,
0.03950972482562065,
-0.32532718777656555,
-0.6982890963554382,
-0.3115413784980774,
0.2316543310880661,
-1.0785237550735474,
0.24293099343776703,
-0.9219755530357361,
0.054874055087566376,
-0.3449341356754303,
-0.09733396768569946,
-0.2066648006439209,
-0.28411492705345154,
0.29047077894210815,
-0.08715474605560303,
0.13214652240276337,
0.6780752539634705,
0.27075377106666565,
0.17452190816402435,
-0.6376883387565613,
0.1694016307592392,
0.7255140542984009,
0.36871689558029175,
0.08702101558446884,
-0.29043394327163696,
0.0017301152693107724,
-0.14962102472782135,
0.0055382647551596165,
-0.3870435059070587,
-0.07099784910678864,
-0.012148110195994377,
0.9982618093490601,
0.2548615038394928,
-0.26657727360725403,
0.5878239274024963,
-0.16058434545993805,
0.6775341033935547,
-0.05525278300046921,
-1.0292346477508545,
0.16283564269542694,
-0.5485585927963257,
0.037002768367528915,
0.951656699180603,
0.2334756851196289,
-0.366716593503952,
-0.41095373034477234,
-0.36102405190467834,
-0.9296444654464722,
0.30062392354011536,
0.10430421680212021,
-0.15431450307369232,
0.007803238462656736,
0.16679750382900238,
0.032610729336738586,
0.1993788778781891,
-0.41878849267959595,
0.06859453022480011,
-0.10237378627061844,
0.009040496312081814,
-0.4245436489582062,
-0.07571547478437424,
-0.2842712998390198,
-0.3154737949371338,
0.36629462242126465,
-0.28919950127601624,
-0.0367903895676136,
0.12779514491558075,
-0.15099689364433289,
0.1463976949453354,
0.17929206788539886,
0.3664771616458893,
1.0825989246368408,
-0.2751038074493408,
0.22333677113056183,
0.40745964646339417,
-0.42397642135620117,
-0.028988750651478767,
0.3954484462738037,
0.10062997043132782,
-0.23523306846618652,
1.0044487714767456,
0.7038554549217224,
0.04970970377326012,
-1.0420829057693481,
0.5316823124885559,
-0.15998539328575134,
-0.42003822326660156,
0.39386674761772156,
0.25532811880111694,
0.2734799087047577,
0.1237403005361557,
0.17139627039432526,
-0.5762010216712952,
0.1711210459470749,
-0.4809463620185852,
0.028844358399510384,
0.14578939974308014,
-0.43874242901802063,
0.06978459656238556,
0.4439834654331207,
-0.033930882811546326,
0.041774507611989975,
0.6085255742073059,
-0.2511366605758667,
-0.5306904911994934,
0.7659996151924133,
0.5365463495254517,
0.7001694440841675,
0.2946051061153412,
0.11254965513944626,
0.34349489212036133,
0.45419856905937195,
-0.07093993574380875,
0.30679646134376526,
0.01831940747797489,
-0.6608771681785583,
-0.6732040047645569,
-0.2359851896762848,
-0.7024461030960083,
0.05805446580052376,
-0.5563734769821167,
0.05503245070576668,
-0.3229753375053406,
-0.009812725707888603,
0.01540938951075077,
0.13654886186122894,
-0.4480058550834656,
0.20154407620429993,
-0.17345105111598969,
1.2851654291152954,
-0.9897751808166504,
0.45963481068611145,
0.9074450731277466,
-0.30341649055480957,
-0.6964191198348999,
-0.09663143008947372,
-0.4290143847465515,
-0.9377365112304688,
0.4568953216075897,
0.17448167502880096,
-0.4175608456134796,
-0.16311658918857574,
-0.4328429698944092,
-0.45062118768692017,
1.1965171098709106,
0.6386585235595703,
-0.4620025157928467,
0.19219498336315155,
0.16112177073955536,
0.6448500752449036,
-0.3460201919078827,
0.41218137741088867,
0.9190441966056824,
0.8142043948173523,
0.07910046726465225,
-0.76852947473526,
0.009750986471772194,
-0.17531943321228027,
-0.03891276568174362,
0.31498411297798157,
-0.6265243887901306,
1.0294302701950073,
0.126448854804039,
-0.28817957639694214,
0.0361793227493763,
0.2291642129421234,
0.4589763283729553,
0.39884811639785767,
0.7349709272384644,
0.8597720265388489,
1.091296672821045,
-0.2806444466114044,
1.3137933015823364,
-0.37553805112838745,
0.5176941752433777,
1.0781855583190918,
-0.5888065099716187,
0.39884743094444275,
0.13337107002735138,
-0.03340455889701843,
0.7178403735160828,
0.7747520804405212,
0.1479363739490509,
0.6504212617874146,
0.25385311245918274,
-0.194959357380867,
-0.5311759114265442,
-0.37404975295066833,
-0.46120280027389526,
0.15280140936374664,
0.19523005187511444,
-0.08982342481613159,
-0.622641384601593,
-0.25697457790374756,
0.03658579662442207,
0.1500278264284134,
-0.30679601430892944,
0.6182085275650024,
-0.13289786875247955,
-0.6145843863487244,
0.6662710309028625,
-0.23613430559635162,
-0.0950625091791153,
-0.7751798033714294,
0.10508265346288681,
-0.1673845499753952,
0.26792362332344055,
-0.1323435753583908,
-1.0673598051071167,
-0.09629718959331512,
-0.1889563649892807,
0.09097658097743988,
0.1925448477268219,
0.8286800980567932,
-0.057117871940135956,
-0.2284444123506546,
0.9664095640182495,
0.510334849357605,
-0.091595359146595,
0.003506582695990801,
-0.5786307454109192,
0.22480635344982147,
-0.3168000876903534,
-0.3839220106601715,
0.21305017173290253,
0.6345450282096863,
-0.06223633512854576,
0.9133598208427429,
0.5302889347076416,
-0.02684282325208187,
-0.3317544162273407,
0.4952777922153473,
1.1733500957489014,
-0.3581705391407013,
-0.3966129422187805,
-0.7203675508499146,
0.032546721398830414,
-0.14747653901576996,
-0.5337817072868347,
0.7761915922164917,
0.7474865913391113,
0.8509182333946228,
0.2749919593334198,
0.9315319061279297,
0.007367917336523533,
0.17493890225887299,
-0.3617874085903168,
0.32843494415283203,
-0.5013226270675659,
-0.06271316111087799,
-0.4525292217731476,
-1.0097767114639282,
-0.3031640946865082,
0.29479122161865234,
-0.7247127294540405,
-0.013993742875754833,
0.7163110971450806,
0.8117761611938477,
-0.20139484107494354,
0.04160192236304283,
0.19990436732769012,
-0.02485738694667816,
0.38075241446495056,
0.8068233728408813,
1.1715763807296753,
-0.17011649906635284,
0.6173893809318542,
0.0710352435708046,
-0.28708145022392273,
-0.1515355110168457,
-1.009576439857483,
-1.0841416120529175,
-0.24744904041290283,
0.05741506814956665,
-0.4440545439720154,
0.30901020765304565,
0.505233645439148,
0.6039719581604004,
-0.5807241797447205,
-0.1774822622537613,
-0.29960402846336365,
0.39088621735572815,
-0.3410126268863678,
-0.1652296781539917,
0.37547749280929565,
-0.3940078616142273,
-0.6452129483222961,
0.4550539553165436,
0.37751293182373047,
-0.17395126819610596,
-0.0763896256685257,
-0.33749035000801086,
0.04490434750914574,
0.16325996816158295,
0.5692335367202759,
0.3212849795818329,
-0.345551460981369,
-0.45691174268722534,
-0.051778387278318405,
-0.3344995379447937,
-0.11298132687807083,
0.8418462872505188,
-0.4810642600059509,
0.4695757329463959,
1.0093034505844116,
0.6585239171981812,
0.6278781890869141,
0.08864595741033554,
0.3670939803123474,
-0.048779942095279694,
0.04078817740082741,
0.2656616270542145,
0.7025586366653442,
0.17673960328102112,
0.05221375823020935,
0.8417811989784241,
0.22462964057922363,
-0.6728026270866394,
-0.9351765513420105,
0.09198050945997238,
-0.9688425064086914,
-0.3750526010990143,
1.0385186672210693,
-0.326225221157074,
-0.22799290716648102,
-0.14399555325508118,
-0.07710439711809158,
-0.06128314882516861,
-0.0992736667394638,
0.3011050820350647,
0.7525801062583923,
-0.09584552049636841,
0.22455576062202454,
-0.5360015034675598,
-0.05707263946533203,
0.052256230264902115,
-0.9362004399299622,
0.2974030375480652,
0.4175155758857727,
0.25703367590904236,
0.13181307911872864,
0.7289572358131409,
-0.16756317019462585,
0.29052457213401794,
0.07543939352035522,
0.07131192833185196,
-0.24775417149066925,
-0.48143118619918823,
-0.049851059913635254,
0.2085225135087967,
0.29021868109703064,
0.15115845203399658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02917v1 | Towards Negotiative Dialogue for the Talkamatic Dialogue Manager | 2024-07-03T08:49:18 | 2024-07-03T08:49:18 | Staffan Larsson, Alexander Berman, David Hjelm | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The paper describes a number of dialogue phenomena associated with
negotiative dialogue, as implemented in a development version of the Talkamatic
Dialogue Manager (TDM). This implementation is an initial step towards full
coverage of general features of negotiative dialogue in TDM. | [
-0.7336642146110535,
-0.751451313495636,
0.6247270107269287,
0.41324564814567566,
-0.3193514943122864,
0.5590428709983826,
-0.0894988477230072,
-0.43968889117240906,
0.7350244522094727,
0.9374648332595825,
-0.4119727909564972,
-0.44218170642852783,
-0.5566338896751404,
-0.22391213476657867,
-0.12885090708732605,
1.1154208183288574,
-0.30772721767425537,
0.03914530202746391,
-0.0053107100538909435,
-0.1747867465019226,
-0.6078004837036133,
-0.7258865833282471,
-1.2809209823608398,
-0.9699783325195312,
0.2540658414363861,
0.3204538822174072,
0.9814683198928833,
0.2414196878671646,
0.4884575307369232,
0.24474599957466125,
-0.4710923433303833,
-0.034099217504262924,
0.14257128536701202,
0.3852860927581787,
-0.4129384756088257,
-0.6206568479537964,
-0.5989524126052856,
0.34452375769615173,
0.4146825075149536,
0.37705352902412415,
-0.6150343418121338,
-0.0203339084982872,
-0.1901080310344696,
0.48793166875839233,
-0.16333048045635223,
0.3531888425350189,
-0.3970371186733246,
0.4293876886367798,
0.2631164789199829,
-0.5422558188438416,
-0.3664068877696991,
-0.46986013650894165,
0.6511174440383911,
-0.15667526423931122,
-0.3178819715976715,
-0.3416546583175659,
0.7897291779518127,
0.20199306309223175,
-0.7972903847694397,
-0.43637606501579285,
-1.0031245946884155,
0.6209361553192139,
-0.5420695543289185,
-0.1438060700893402,
0.5449402332305908,
0.5736485123634338,
-0.23502026498317719,
-0.49772295355796814,
-0.5824675559997559,
-0.5384050011634827,
-0.08634030818939209,
0.43976807594299316,
-0.4241258502006531,
0.47472089529037476,
0.16882388293743134,
0.5455861687660217,
-0.26811686158180237,
-0.006183313205838203,
-0.013138880953192711,
0.023572484031319618,
0.3135714530944824,
0.6508958339691162,
0.07820219546556473,
-0.19312132894992828,
-0.3884717524051666,
0.38131576776504517,
-0.5015063881874084,
-0.44499853253364563,
0.32808446884155273,
-0.039321381598711014,
-0.4400213062763214,
0.25789591670036316,
-0.3122129440307617,
0.960127592086792,
-0.0786527693271637,
-0.15057878196239471,
-0.048443689942359924,
-0.6103994846343994,
-0.09871354699134827,
0.1985204815864563,
0.1313609629869461,
0.660331666469574,
0.392837792634964,
-0.05504840984940529,
-0.19983433187007904,
0.2192487269639969,
0.36939990520477295,
-0.562804639339447,
-0.2877570688724518,
0.16700045764446259,
-0.3885599672794342,
-0.6576098203659058,
-0.0933062881231308,
-0.43919211626052856,
-0.11855287104845047,
-0.4966902732849121,
0.18990205228328705,
-0.10735735297203064,
-0.6340476870536804,
0.04425268620252609,
-0.12310152500867844,
0.6581834554672241,
0.6283714771270752,
-0.44051575660705566,
0.5140190720558167,
0.5248280763626099,
1.129063367843628,
0.20865537226200104,
-0.07335751503705978,
-0.1783757358789444,
0.4979305863380432,
-0.4193476438522339,
1.0011792182922363,
-0.7335193157196045,
-1.0086402893066406,
0.08582984656095505,
-0.09555983543395996,
-0.0815664604306221,
-0.9299644827842712,
0.26636427640914917,
0.05382566154003143,
0.3735417127609253,
0.26502424478530884,
-0.12660634517669678,
-0.3228989839553833,
1.008541464805603,
-0.42420706152915955,
0.6177535057067871,
0.1369485855102539,
-0.27427947521209717,
0.3763243556022644,
-1.145098328590393,
-0.31268271803855896,
0.05257795751094818,
0.0214243046939373,
-0.1704382747411728,
0.056153807789087296,
-0.5608545541763306,
-0.067012719810009,
-0.39574533700942993,
0.2963068187236786,
-0.08051895350217819,
-0.26783260703086853,
0.6299245953559875,
-0.1079341471195221,
0.34103333950042725,
0.481463223695755,
-0.3756267726421356,
0.4094538390636444,
-0.47997936606407166,
-0.12566162645816803,
0.041722968220710754,
-0.385745644569397,
0.07695072144269943,
-0.10850748419761658,
-0.05192691832780838,
0.55766761302948,
0.2702084183692932,
-0.07465532422065735,
0.3615240156650543,
-0.2705109715461731,
0.7519487738609314,
0.507014811038971,
0.44654449820518494,
0.5976594090461731,
-0.70644211769104,
0.8164722919464111,
0.4494188129901886,
0.24131935834884644,
-0.43070900440216064,
-0.4349604845046997,
-1.1989279985427856,
0.09838904440402985,
0.24268358945846558,
0.5883470177650452,
-0.8942485451698303,
-0.1256696581840515,
0.16189585626125336,
-0.3654259145259857,
-0.20804457366466522,
-0.27894043922424316,
0.7393477559089661,
0.1823498159646988,
0.12791620194911957,
-0.3865247070789337,
-0.5176023840904236,
-1.1066025495529175,
-0.006527820602059364,
-0.6231447458267212,
0.23646950721740723,
0.026726212352514267,
0.24241086840629578,
-0.13746237754821777,
0.7518453001976013,
-0.40638700127601624,
-0.47257742285728455,
-0.3914647102355957,
0.7300469875335693,
0.21902963519096375,
0.5908213257789612,
0.434364914894104,
-0.6379872560501099,
-0.5947964191436768,
0.11423598229885101,
-0.3982471227645874,
-0.02836287021636963,
-0.08511927723884583,
-0.15200583636760712,
0.5705255270004272,
0.6792429685592651,
-0.8919079899787903,
0.6714863777160645,
0.23739910125732422,
-0.23006783425807953,
0.43453142046928406,
-0.12446007132530212,
0.19124862551689148,
-1.5091890096664429,
-0.3449612557888031,
-0.031636666506528854,
-0.42024919390678406,
-0.6493787169456482,
-0.1374415010213852,
-0.4459244906902313,
-0.25533556938171387,
-0.5158876776695251,
0.33969882130622864,
-0.480969101190567,
0.16264040768146515,
-0.4400896728038788,
0.3788093328475952,
-0.23179438710212708,
0.4651658236980438,
0.5239453911781311,
0.5450189709663391,
0.5855161547660828,
-1.0531630516052246,
0.453869491815567,
0.503777265548706,
0.02158348448574543,
1.2992769479751587,
-0.5048190355300903,
0.2198982983827591,
0.09545168280601501,
0.4109998941421509,
-0.5705403089523315,
-0.05523063242435455,
0.658969521522522,
-0.33514344692230225,
0.22382044792175293,
-0.5537624359130859,
-0.5692318677902222,
-0.19119612872600555,
-0.42267465591430664,
0.05892683565616608,
0.28931093215942383,
-0.3236326575279236,
0.5922339558601379,
0.44643619656562805,
-0.2207423597574234,
-0.14163486659526825,
-0.6193854212760925,
0.5896227955818176,
-0.4865886867046356,
-0.3993716239929199,
0.262027382850647,
-0.038069307804107666,
-0.6327617168426514,
-0.2628379166126251,
-0.09654968231916428,
-0.000736128946300596,
-0.003081273753196001,
0.163890540599823,
-0.07368914783000946,
-0.049660686403512955,
-0.09363110363483429,
0.026679515838623047,
-0.7391024231910706,
0.3240407705307007,
-0.09900692105293274,
0.6855942606925964,
0.147308811545372,
-0.031264856457710266,
-0.18219871819019318,
0.44885173439979553,
0.23276585340499878,
-0.02091732993721962,
0.6178702116012573,
0.276821494102478,
-0.4475758969783783,
0.06837628781795502,
-0.5455436110496521,
-0.10966966301202774,
-0.44396063685417175,
0.04264487698674202,
-0.6131376624107361,
-0.9575865864753723,
0.799523115158081,
-0.6322014331817627,
-0.11905580013990402,
0.2397831529378891,
0.752348005771637,
0.1427188664674759,
1.300081729888916,
0.3958129584789276,
0.35612499713897705,
0.6719410419464111,
0.031906548887491226,
0.04374447837471962,
-0.9561534523963928,
-0.692754864692688,
-0.676481306552887,
-0.3779294192790985,
-0.7262977957725525,
-0.25822317600250244,
0.1674732118844986,
0.31778454780578613,
-0.21062451601028442,
0.49007314443588257,
-0.31320780515670776,
0.35295364260673523,
0.2686753273010254,
-0.15987366437911987,
0.5920712351799011,
-0.559986412525177,
-0.06903503835201263,
-0.09864679723978043,
-0.44813045859336853,
-0.8630638122558594,
0.4443899691104889,
0.31620290875434875,
0.7720492482185364,
0.785746693611145,
0.8574497699737549,
0.08493556082248688,
0.49477964639663696,
-0.8971176147460938,
0.89177006483078,
0.6077496409416199,
-0.6713646650314331,
0.21026697754859924,
-0.37365636229515076,
-0.9606400728225708,
0.029115911573171616,
-0.07761684060096741,
-1.0820183753967285,
0.11182166635990143,
-0.08220332115888596,
0.05576165392994881,
0.08999805152416229,
-0.7510169148445129,
0.9551309943199158,
0.1027987152338028,
0.28303927183151245,
-0.6579606533050537,
-0.5767803192138672,
0.28298717737197876,
0.14081580936908722,
-0.25309669971466064,
-0.17530182003974915,
-0.1907331347465515,
0.7438957691192627,
-0.40309789776802063,
0.5662255883216858,
-0.2796366512775421,
-0.2295997440814972,
0.4026334583759308,
0.5500879883766174,
0.46556657552719116,
0.32361939549446106,
0.353588730096817,
-0.01980764977633953,
-0.2033708095550537,
-0.5619693994522095,
-0.4779917895793915,
0.669499397277832,
-0.31552422046661377,
-1.0740238428115845,
-0.8507175445556641,
-0.5120183825492859,
-0.3097132444381714,
-0.2077459990978241,
0.1511187106370926,
-0.0865863710641861,
-0.6608245372772217,
-0.36887508630752563,
0.6455159187316895,
-0.041044965386390686,
0.70352703332901,
0.810173749923706,
-0.720285177230835,
-0.25915396213531494,
0.6896263957023621,
-0.03869260847568512,
0.5856115221977234,
0.3090169429779053,
-0.2686272859573364,
-0.19405189156532288,
-0.7690833806991577,
-0.1428881138563156,
-0.1929149031639099,
-0.6354640126228333,
-0.4977799654006958,
-0.6711808443069458,
-0.3035966455936432,
0.16851140558719635,
-0.12947015464305878,
-0.096767358481884,
-0.8696057796478271,
-0.11621174216270447,
-0.39333903789520264,
0.7170945405960083,
0.9379303455352783,
-0.21945177018642426,
0.8315685987472534,
-0.6178300380706787,
0.2666301727294922,
0.41430145502090454,
0.24878382682800293,
-0.17945826053619385,
-0.42267799377441406,
-0.6912381649017334,
-0.13832741975784302,
-0.8740021586418152,
-0.8052964210510254,
0.1723613142967224,
-0.27080145478248596,
0.37661421298980713,
0.46658357977867126,
-0.26910173892974854,
0.40034207701683044,
0.047209493815898895,
0.9495607018470764,
0.4351024925708771,
-1.0603218078613281,
0.8894795179367065,
-0.4951407015323639,
0.4553857445716858,
0.34802114963531494,
0.06331348419189453,
-0.693057119846344,
-0.5319666862487793,
-0.650871753692627,
-0.6783706545829773,
0.8042321801185608,
0.20905369520187378,
0.2928597033023834,
-0.2721198797225952,
0.023752715438604355,
-0.16347825527191162,
0.5711313486099243,
-0.4675491750240326,
-0.21883895993232727,
0.08286119252443314,
0.4833436608314514,
-0.04579411819577217,
-0.4968535006046295,
-0.5929744243621826,
-0.031213607639074326,
0.5322110056877136,
0.09198512136936188,
0.38357484340667725,
0.1361394226551056,
-0.2363913655281067,
-0.018716510385274887,
0.6220872402191162,
0.7274143099784851,
1.1060682535171509,
-0.3346969783306122,
0.1877385675907135,
0.0710010901093483,
-0.13286064565181732,
0.33969491720199585,
-0.03641542047262192,
0.29113537073135376,
0.33213910460472107,
0.006377235520631075,
0.7519457340240479,
0.08684036135673523,
-0.1679658740758896,
0.22923626005649567,
0.016432950273156166,
-0.6753827929496765,
-0.526932954788208,
0.1553059220314026,
-0.013194408267736435,
0.582331657409668,
0.0678647831082344,
-0.14609014987945557,
0.20923617482185364,
-0.888384222984314,
0.16961225867271423,
0.29860928654670715,
-0.8140737414360046,
-0.2832987606525421,
0.6246411800384521,
0.466143935918808,
-0.8304924368858337,
0.5035473108291626,
-0.27926895022392273,
-0.7511638402938843,
0.4356828033924103,
0.4949665069580078,
1.22471284866333,
-0.18908846378326416,
0.8453519344329834,
-0.20220902562141418,
0.38310182094573975,
0.08223094046115875,
0.6776750087738037,
-0.32116565108299255,
-0.6981766223907471,
-0.565686047077179,
-0.06683223694562912,
-1.1786761283874512,
-0.284485399723053,
-0.8134303689002991,
0.174960196018219,
-0.5993896722793579,
-0.4112686812877655,
0.06309156864881516,
-0.038073454052209854,
-0.36254429817199707,
-0.08226659893989563,
-0.02806275710463524,
1.052466630935669,
-0.1413465291261673,
1.001512050628662,
0.807866096496582,
-0.6644625067710876,
-0.28639209270477295,
0.1678343266248703,
-0.22425982356071472,
-0.4881693124771118,
0.5424906611442566,
-0.08330473303794861,
-0.13138535618782043,
-0.1722927689552307,
-0.519874095916748,
0.06664885580539703,
0.9363678693771362,
0.6135627627372742,
-0.06290168315172195,
0.15822431445121765,
0.4117306172847748,
0.42335188388824463,
-0.561130702495575,
0.40522775053977966,
0.7150747776031494,
0.8125582933425903,
-0.0540764220058918,
-1.276339054107666,
0.04614505544304848,
-0.3429082930088043,
0.29224562644958496,
0.7077547907829285,
-1.1202244758605957,
0.6226738095283508,
0.1569613218307495,
0.08104614913463593,
0.28309884667396545,
0.24848559498786926,
0.05141538381576538,
0.5213673114776611,
0.2470148205757141,
0.8303926587104797,
0.15501613914966583,
-0.5033888816833496,
0.8575307726860046,
-0.2998221814632416,
0.30628839135169983,
0.9960159659385681,
-0.21441680192947388,
0.061719074845314026,
0.6919206976890564,
-0.31571537256240845,
0.7815978527069092,
0.7427775263786316,
0.4897506535053253,
0.13070863485336304,
0.3661387860774994,
-0.7696459293365479,
-0.01275916863232851,
-0.6738008856773376,
-0.4720117747783661,
0.4919836223125458,
0.36904633045196533,
-0.21548542380332947,
-0.15042011439800262,
-0.2820546329021454,
0.27719369530677795,
-0.022041000425815582,
-0.5804852247238159,
1.2431541681289673,
0.5447050929069519,
-0.2692268490791321,
0.2852894365787506,
0.28497880697250366,
0.5779809951782227,
-0.6814239025115967,
-0.30159300565719604,
-0.3478275537490845,
-0.23965364694595337,
-0.2383386492729187,
-0.7724530696868896,
0.6979844570159912,
-0.3118981122970581,
-0.11785520613193512,
-0.46005725860595703,
0.6093194484710693,
-0.4987996816635132,
0.15828341245651245,
0.41601020097732544,
0.6935880184173584,
0.10873834043741226,
-0.06374780833721161,
-0.6661764979362488,
-0.18507494032382965,
-0.4332689940929413,
-0.39403989911079407,
0.4246816039085388,
0.6376066207885742,
0.048011891543865204,
0.6203035712242126,
0.25923892855644226,
-0.1027006208896637,
-0.2750805914402008,
0.129860520362854,
0.7529187798500061,
-1.3630626201629639,
-0.7246110439300537,
-0.8153645992279053,
0.3494033217430115,
-0.1687169224023819,
-0.32166025042533875,
0.6922284364700317,
0.3387419283390045,
0.7836390137672424,
0.04102972149848938,
0.40836822986602783,
0.1049848422408104,
0.2112697958946228,
-0.699319064617157,
0.38417455554008484,
-0.05384985730051994,
0.02722981385886669,
-0.580573558807373,
-1.2652848958969116,
0.0807148888707161,
0.7137176990509033,
-0.2763564884662628,
0.04452376812696457,
0.8442797660827637,
0.4921044111251831,
0.02895980328321457,
0.3961428701877594,
0.34571462869644165,
0.1543227583169937,
0.0687350481748581,
0.6918895244598389,
1.5833463668823242,
0.045539408922195435,
0.758777916431427,
0.000654735486023128,
0.0560668520629406,
0.11768710613250732,
-0.8534027338027954,
-0.8361876606941223,
-0.412117063999176,
-0.6334581971168518,
-0.8572002053260803,
-0.05059695243835449,
0.7422966361045837,
0.7885153293609619,
-0.4550708532333374,
-0.7570680975914001,
-0.2167755514383316,
0.5220777988433838,
-0.0852346420288086,
-0.3551584482192993,
-0.4024445414543152,
-0.0637073814868927,
-0.9155595302581787,
0.06022236868739128,
0.855109453201294,
0.33184725046157837,
-0.3135155141353607,
-0.48990577459335327,
-0.18876385688781738,
0.4664247930049896,
0.47002559900283813,
0.16089582443237305,
-0.20652282238006592,
-0.2757706046104431,
-0.7120547890663147,
0.22260825335979462,
0.25261902809143066,
1.1496349573135376,
-0.7165082097053528,
0.32796525955200195,
-0.06104986369609833,
0.21408934891223907,
1.1399717330932617,
-0.6981559991836548,
0.909125566482544,
-0.31538423895835876,
0.7491400837898254,
0.4341180622577667,
0.024170689284801483,
0.07028375566005707,
-0.006347013171762228,
0.7508384585380554,
0.07715868204832077,
-0.25025755167007446,
-0.9169855117797852,
0.9426026940345764,
-1.0405733585357666,
0.23262551426887512,
0.6075193881988525,
0.020440028980374336,
0.3142952024936676,
-0.3603362739086151,
-0.4564489722251892,
0.1980925053358078,
-0.49936702847480774,
0.63921058177948,
1.075922966003418,
-0.32183364033699036,
-0.34140071272850037,
-0.4941486716270447,
0.551393985748291,
0.5424349904060364,
-0.9173465371131897,
-0.535144031047821,
0.17128576338291168,
-0.28735145926475525,
0.29633456468582153,
0.8880825638771057,
-0.2116749882698059,
0.19588004052639008,
0.05952297896146774,
-0.21894697844982147,
0.2001405954360962,
-0.3327861428260803,
-0.3057068884372711,
0.008597709238529205,
0.49551302194595337,
-0.19212591648101807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02894v1 | Translatotron-V(ison): An End-to-End Model for In-Image Machine Translation | 2024-07-03T08:15:39 | 2024-07-03T08:15:39 | Zhibin Lan, Liqiang Niu, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Min Zhang, Jinsong Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-image machine translation (IIMT) aims to translate an image containing
texts in source language into an image containing translations in target
language. In this regard, conventional cascaded methods suffer from issues such
as error propagation, massive parameters, and difficulties in deployment and
retaining visual characteristics of the input image. Thus, constructing
end-to-end models has become an option, which, however, faces two main
challenges: 1) the huge modeling burden, as it is required to simultaneously
learn alignment across languages and preserve the visual characteristics of the
input image; 2) the difficulties of directly predicting excessively lengthy
pixel sequences. In this paper, we propose \textit{Translatotron-V(ision)}, an
end-to-end IIMT model consisting of four modules. In addition to an image
encoder, and an image decoder, our model contains a target text decoder and an
image tokenizer. Among them, the target text decoder is used to alleviate the
language alignment burden, and the image tokenizer converts long sequences of
pixels into shorter sequences of visual tokens, preventing the model from
focusing on low-level visual features. Besides, we present a two-stage training
framework for our model to assist the model in learning alignment across
modalities and languages. Finally, we propose a location-aware evaluation
metric called Structure-BLEU to assess the translation quality of the generated
images. Experimental results demonstrate that our model achieves competitive
performance compared to cascaded models with only 70.9\% of parameters, and
significantly outperforms the pixel-level end-to-end IIMT model. | [
-0.2060554474592209,
-0.4425949454307556,
0.24708907306194305,
0.09858908504247665,
-0.991670548915863,
0.019226757809519768,
-0.17785410583019257,
-0.5454781651496887,
-0.2891244888305664,
0.29819148778915405,
-0.34753358364105225,
-0.35570666193962097,
-0.9379131197929382,
0.2395290583372116,
-0.7019148468971252,
0.5132266283035278,
-0.3594081699848175,
0.45062631368637085,
-0.006640355568379164,
-0.14035332202911377,
-0.5108304023742676,
-0.09722092002630234,
-0.43625232577323914,
-0.3729722797870636,
0.012331739999353886,
0.2810608744621277,
0.722001850605011,
1.1681866645812988,
0.9588714838027954,
0.28129348158836365,
-0.2034599632024765,
0.1387905329465866,
-0.12698917090892792,
-0.06239549070596695,
-0.3482365608215332,
-0.3875458240509033,
-0.11499100178480148,
-0.32887426018714905,
0.6819925308227539,
0.35478153824806213,
0.2887086272239685,
0.11308915168046951,
-0.18213732540607452,
0.49762994050979614,
-0.2731597423553467,
-0.18601717054843903,
-0.5242555141448975,
0.11477158218622208,
-0.08007127046585083,
-0.17649807035923004,
-0.44951581954956055,
-0.11331953853368759,
-0.054403986781835556,
-0.32042214274406433,
-0.010714373551309109,
0.0034026673529297113,
1.419226050376892,
0.49430838227272034,
-0.7198931574821472,
-0.07696749269962311,
-0.9631543755531311,
0.4512662887573242,
-0.5291004776954651,
0.6232244968414307,
0.15402895212173462,
0.5276704430580139,
0.04617951437830925,
-0.9440500140190125,
-0.3185144364833832,
-0.16721966862678528,
-0.06098216027021408,
0.5730617046356201,
-0.4831331670284271,
-0.13528819382190704,
0.04126887395977974,
0.030711153522133827,
-0.6971177458763123,
0.2138170599937439,
-0.6891902089118958,
0.21346108615398407,
0.014152034185826778,
0.0811786949634552,
0.34366321563720703,
-0.39157846570014954,
-0.9271121621131897,
0.12075944989919662,
-0.5628785490989685,
-0.05967480689287186,
0.11455527693033218,
0.051695626229047775,
-0.14432765543460846,
0.7854486107826233,
-0.09125949442386627,
0.7517913579940796,
0.13156013190746307,
0.1608833223581314,
-0.08623769134283066,
-0.5185686945915222,
-0.12529176473617554,
0.18230600655078888,
0.9408712387084961,
0.4173991084098816,
0.0039020637050271034,
-0.246270552277565,
-0.21785463392734528,
0.13556267321109772,
0.35679367184638977,
-1.1846673488616943,
0.3547210395336151,
0.17672951519489288,
-0.6195482611656189,
-0.05558307096362114,
-0.030210087075829506,
-0.2891503572463989,
0.33173003792762756,
-0.42903223633766174,
0.5686230659484863,
-1.0418508052825928,
-0.03037167154252529,
-0.04818921536207199,
0.09240564703941345,
0.4321594536304474,
0.3531075716018677,
-0.34058257937431335,
0.2820780277252197,
0.3836103081703186,
1.2794346809387207,
-0.1276678442955017,
-0.30121541023254395,
-0.33509665727615356,
0.22521233558654785,
-0.4066027104854584,
0.9141560792922974,
-0.42203032970428467,
-0.40026259422302246,
-0.16225279867649078,
0.21623632311820984,
0.3216635286808014,
-0.49314576387405396,
0.5583846569061279,
-0.4501314163208008,
0.3574412167072296,
0.10947160422801971,
-0.5456907153129578,
-0.4377732574939728,
0.34750276803970337,
-0.47231847047805786,
0.859609842300415,
0.3317888677120209,
-0.6143426895141602,
0.10770449042320251,
-0.40246641635894775,
-0.428731232881546,
0.36409035325050354,
-0.12330380082130432,
-0.7554111480712891,
0.21066966652870178,
0.08958221226930618,
0.2649528980255127,
-0.8527736663818359,
0.395082950592041,
0.02245745062828064,
-0.5358362793922424,
0.2771202027797699,
-0.17596760392189026,
0.6321403384208679,
0.24000327289104462,
-0.4923724830150604,
0.12141520529985428,
-0.5094372630119324,
-0.17481517791748047,
-0.05209808424115181,
-0.31418517231941223,
-0.2219662368297577,
-0.20423491299152374,
0.16273990273475647,
0.7304003238677979,
0.23463557660579681,
-0.6795408129692078,
0.011758564971387386,
-0.24515943229198456,
0.540306806564331,
0.6183817982673645,
-0.16136154532432556,
0.4751676023006439,
0.02540738880634308,
0.6436359882354736,
0.4454538822174072,
0.29830002784729004,
-0.4097653925418854,
-0.41741159558296204,
-0.4578295946121216,
-0.41744884848594666,
0.3892943859100342,
0.6752164363861084,
-0.892566978931427,
0.399367094039917,
-0.6564915180206299,
-0.571817934513092,
-0.4351787567138672,
-0.08802200108766556,
0.7186237573623657,
0.7444757223129272,
0.2581005394458771,
-0.512263298034668,
-0.29899293184280396,
-1.0899474620819092,
-0.002983691869303584,
0.062209602445364,
0.18474069237709045,
-0.30714285373687744,
0.6026749014854431,
-0.30497103929519653,
0.5036048889160156,
0.08650919049978256,
-0.30931010842323303,
-0.26499006152153015,
-0.1491803228855133,
0.22048364579677582,
0.44522908329963684,
0.34045884013175964,
-0.7543317079544067,
-0.7174900770187378,
0.6811444759368896,
-0.8532618284225464,
0.055636655539274216,
0.05264449119567871,
-0.4542865455150604,
0.09253596514463425,
0.5870804786682129,
-0.6613000631332397,
0.5807651281356812,
0.3292277753353119,
-0.18638789653778076,
0.2080238163471222,
-0.3219756782054901,
0.2212684005498886,
-1.613022804260254,
0.1216086894273758,
0.3715972900390625,
-0.621880829334259,
-0.5993444919586182,
0.08412197232246399,
0.5818992257118225,
-0.20768746733665466,
-0.7366851568222046,
0.47161805629730225,
-0.3322257101535797,
-0.36270377039909363,
-0.5121659636497498,
0.039996903389692307,
-0.12165212631225586,
0.38035643100738525,
0.30875498056411743,
0.5206098556518555,
0.528262197971344,
-0.49875742197036743,
0.36391517519950867,
0.2889728546142578,
-0.2837996184825897,
0.9953359365463257,
-0.8028668165206909,
-0.14068202674388885,
-0.35563963651657104,
0.20422454178333282,
-0.9769070744514465,
-0.13175064325332642,
0.22797073423862457,
-0.6191563010215759,
0.3032152056694031,
-0.32004597783088684,
-0.7111861705780029,
-0.26865851879119873,
0.1307140588760376,
0.7394912838935852,
0.6614590883255005,
-0.5245262980461121,
0.5408466458320618,
-0.18759867548942566,
0.20048066973686218,
-0.48454490303993225,
-0.6509220600128174,
0.2698286175727844,
-0.28775206208229065,
-0.7031180262565613,
0.5720653533935547,
0.09821076691150665,
0.31368768215179443,
0.46149176359176636,
0.2647082507610321,
-0.00267618871293962,
-0.22394725680351257,
0.14916644990444183,
0.3503279983997345,
-0.04883124306797981,
-0.020240336656570435,
0.16518233716487885,
-0.45383119583129883,
-0.28305506706237793,
-0.7852240204811096,
0.49024033546447754,
-0.12957751750946045,
-0.22624331712722778,
-0.765616238117218,
0.39916929602622986,
0.6233217120170593,
-0.5163148641586304,
0.6267024874687195,
0.7344701290130615,
-0.7614620923995972,
0.039630189538002014,
0.1524185836315155,
0.08333615213632584,
-0.37345898151397705,
0.8908467888832092,
-0.3780299723148346,
-0.3420299291610718,
0.5508719086647034,
-0.5513525009155273,
-0.025337571278214455,
0.18089255690574646,
0.8232731223106384,
-0.24681104719638824,
0.9891573786735535,
0.6541064977645874,
0.48728159070014954,
0.6690655946731567,
-0.4346753656864166,
0.28927668929100037,
-0.9523966908454895,
-0.3755917549133301,
-0.15413853526115417,
-0.5681875348091125,
-0.35840585827827454,
-0.5303991436958313,
0.68365877866745,
0.01677628792822361,
-0.3033229112625122,
0.7270412445068359,
-0.6299238801002502,
0.40324828028678894,
0.5567303895950317,
0.15720060467720032,
0.2118242084980011,
0.19837714731693268,
0.21018913388252258,
-0.13827307522296906,
-0.493953675031662,
-0.30795255303382874,
0.8631649017333984,
0.21665865182876587,
0.6827168464660645,
0.25352510809898376,
0.3648177981376648,
0.01056214515119791,
0.1665486842393875,
-0.8312667608261108,
0.4279059171676636,
-0.4761735796928406,
-0.4671585261821747,
-0.024984577670693398,
-0.31482023000717163,
-0.7481476068496704,
0.4519331157207489,
0.18581216037273407,
-0.4328027665615082,
0.06434529274702072,
0.03728732094168663,
0.2569057047367096,
0.4093579649925232,
-0.3434005677700043,
0.8705832362174988,
-0.519472599029541,
-0.39154595136642456,
0.1270437240600586,
-1.1097853183746338,
0.5537309646606445,
-0.13301850855350494,
0.0837785080075264,
0.26346105337142944,
-0.12684516608715057,
0.21958084404468536,
-0.835537850856781,
0.4312765896320343,
0.22052855789661407,
0.3252723217010498,
0.208662211894989,
0.2419460415840149,
0.5144486427307129,
-0.22763164341449738,
-0.0026613534428179264,
0.14539694786071777,
-0.20651565492153168,
-0.38895267248153687,
-0.4729189872741699,
0.3284189701080322,
-0.9695109128952026,
-0.03127415478229523,
-0.1557285189628601,
-0.47984424233436584,
0.3273909091949463,
0.3966948390007019,
0.9577972292900085,
0.7063094973564148,
0.03745925799012184,
0.19019445776939392,
0.5223174095153809,
-0.15689705312252045,
0.4920060634613037,
0.12086360901594162,
-0.2907712161540985,
-0.7723721265792847,
0.8430770635604858,
0.18549272418022156,
0.5884935855865479,
0.6696114540100098,
0.10691088438034058,
-0.437945157289505,
-0.31444883346557617,
-0.9194790124893188,
0.42114096879959106,
-0.9968127012252808,
-0.6009939312934875,
-0.4745709300041199,
-0.3258718252182007,
-0.012616826221346855,
-0.35571497678756714,
-0.7094544172286987,
-0.3244982659816742,
-0.2557646334171295,
-0.08046238124370575,
0.26318061351776123,
0.5249163508415222,
0.0815587118268013,
0.8351783156394958,
-0.6531826257705688,
0.31069472432136536,
-0.3078514635562897,
0.26869139075279236,
-0.27309226989746094,
-1.0311543941497803,
-0.7250747084617615,
-0.30848270654678345,
-0.3104785680770874,
-0.7855868935585022,
0.6007497310638428,
0.07811711728572845,
0.06701938062906265,
0.08751522749662399,
-0.3599984645843506,
0.6913235187530518,
-0.5203748345375061,
0.397550493478775,
0.4411655068397522,
-0.9243900775909424,
0.47115862369537354,
-0.19716863334178925,
0.7392374277114868,
0.2406768798828125,
0.26943185925483704,
-0.5446204543113708,
-0.3132307231426239,
-0.3534925878047943,
-0.9043166637420654,
0.879827082157135,
0.33237048983573914,
-0.13166527450084686,
0.2047252506017685,
0.45983877778053284,
0.0802447497844696,
0.20551137626171112,
-0.9692715406417847,
-0.05671076104044914,
-0.4603697657585144,
-0.45229941606521606,
0.37733060121536255,
0.013369705528020859,
0.2750760018825531,
-0.14773429930210114,
0.8174513578414917,
-0.013007262721657753,
0.33142411708831787,
0.27326586842536926,
-0.3936658501625061,
-0.5458878874778748,
-0.19504107534885406,
0.5969940423965454,
0.3869742751121521,
-0.14625152945518494,
0.20825190842151642,
-0.1418885886669159,
-0.2599480152130127,
0.4002194106578827,
-0.021237168461084366,
-0.4305413067340851,
0.24015529453754425,
0.2084217369556427,
0.8749754428863525,
-0.19633100926876068,
-0.5313108563423157,
0.7290742993354797,
-0.18454435467720032,
-0.19085262715816498,
-0.31501317024230957,
-0.7741194367408752,
0.14569717645645142,
0.18297313153743744,
-0.052963390946388245,
0.21079906821250916,
-0.014202111400663853,
-0.42565324902534485,
0.34077441692352295,
0.28778424859046936,
-0.8853111863136292,
-0.5656881332397461,
0.9650015234947205,
-0.11003852635622025,
-0.42075714468955994,
0.8001204133033752,
-0.15263012051582336,
-0.5983795523643494,
0.7347202301025391,
0.9327981472015381,
0.9839939475059509,
-0.38521793484687805,
0.153184175491333,
0.4806399941444397,
0.7612887620925903,
0.008794013410806656,
0.3782970607280731,
0.31558841466903687,
-0.22272972762584686,
-0.34658607840538025,
-0.48055046796798706,
0.021596163511276245,
-0.2280988246202469,
-0.434722900390625,
0.7903936505317688,
-0.4606788158416748,
-0.170494943857193,
-0.4513323903083801,
-0.6038619875907898,
-0.7535620927810669,
0.37611109018325806,
0.05394861102104187,
0.8181229829788208,
-0.6702890396118164,
0.9060541987419128,
0.8989034295082092,
-0.5430507063865662,
-0.481805682182312,
-0.29991403222084045,
-0.31611859798431396,
-0.5623742938041687,
0.8651182651519775,
0.214982271194458,
-0.06423085182905197,
0.021200228482484818,
-0.5247883200645447,
-0.9392378926277161,
1.2882424592971802,
0.5266126394271851,
-0.41032472252845764,
0.03248613327741623,
0.5208932161331177,
0.5286010503768921,
-0.34222134947776794,
0.36176806688308716,
0.009650743566453457,
0.17793400585651398,
0.3082449436187744,
-0.7160826325416565,
0.09140549600124359,
-0.31910964846611023,
0.5605219602584839,
0.49687063694000244,
-0.9629354476928711,
1.0202769041061401,
0.0672682523727417,
-0.18020980060100555,
0.15320846438407898,
0.9318997859954834,
-0.035177700221538544,
-0.07437615841627121,
0.21652920544147491,
0.713523268699646,
0.022100677713751793,
0.040447723120450974,
0.9888762831687927,
-0.4450310170650482,
0.24433791637420654,
0.8846938610076904,
-0.012946054339408875,
0.5781965255737305,
0.5341469049453735,
0.36796656250953674,
0.21093066036701202,
0.837161123752594,
0.13802886009216309,
0.7741013765335083,
0.043527018278837204,
0.016749029979109764,
-0.25638067722320557,
-0.3574633300304413,
-0.09691455960273743,
0.3740525543689728,
0.3509332239627838,
-0.5077552795410156,
-0.501229465007782,
0.24287304282188416,
-0.11204308271408081,
0.05088841915130615,
-0.15806108713150024,
0.5143768191337585,
0.3287309408187866,
-0.47926339507102966,
0.3880581259727478,
0.36530935764312744,
0.30234405398368835,
-0.5732564330101013,
0.008061099797487259,
-0.2103215605020523,
0.19247210025787354,
0.03422107547521591,
-0.7298455238342285,
0.1833561658859253,
-0.0041773258708417416,
-0.07427804917097092,
-0.05003925412893295,
0.4482307732105255,
-0.5957785844802856,
-0.858414351940155,
0.37304767966270447,
0.42828500270843506,
0.12360520660877228,
0.19946755468845367,
-0.6420961022377014,
0.08303777873516083,
-0.17618675529956818,
-0.08407527953386307,
0.13929729163646698,
0.6831137537956238,
-0.46969595551490784,
0.6199212670326233,
0.24446362257003784,
-0.11489254236221313,
0.2503681480884552,
-0.14656923711299896,
0.5614212155342102,
-0.6661589741706848,
-0.5837039351463318,
-0.9253717064857483,
0.8030039072036743,
0.16226938366889954,
-0.31860581040382385,
0.23160873353481293,
0.7491538524627686,
0.9542238116264343,
0.012495053932070732,
0.801514208316803,
0.08069084584712982,
-0.04012811556458473,
-0.49264705181121826,
0.13219472765922546,
-0.8077919483184814,
-0.02429916337132454,
-0.10080555826425552,
-1.0769352912902832,
-0.3980056643486023,
0.2145557552576065,
0.0782720297574997,
-0.17436523735523224,
0.8037002086639404,
0.526366651058197,
-0.5197991728782654,
-0.3861013650894165,
0.5400297045707703,
0.028726328164339066,
0.6134765148162842,
0.5983381271362305,
0.9011549949645996,
-0.9442846179008484,
0.7520905137062073,
-0.29515761137008667,
-0.048632457852363586,
-0.2786983847618103,
-0.6690894365310669,
-0.7299477458000183,
-0.8585756421089172,
-0.3326904773712158,
-0.3020126223564148,
-0.09174400568008423,
0.8004489541053772,
0.6151091456413269,
-0.09605855494737625,
-0.4184524714946747,
-0.1771656721830368,
-0.10098417848348618,
-0.1602514535188675,
-0.05906694382429123,
0.4290521740913391,
0.03530511632561684,
-0.9991127848625183,
-0.03594432398676872,
0.7074729800224304,
0.2098427712917328,
0.003098735585808754,
-0.08293403685092926,
-0.2399449646472931,
-0.04786795750260353,
0.5052337050437927,
0.012233606539666653,
-0.8163121342658997,
-0.14963844418525696,
0.0923842191696167,
-0.2501186728477478,
0.3924846947193146,
0.3722325265407562,
-0.4992920756340027,
0.7389494776725769,
0.4600820243358612,
0.6930668950080872,
0.5767523050308228,
0.3145730495452881,
0.6011738777160645,
-0.5274126529693604,
0.28352415561676025,
-0.1552322804927826,
0.5415786504745483,
0.45595332980155945,
-0.37840983271598816,
0.5078080892562866,
0.15072132647037506,
-0.3182446360588074,
-0.7326816320419312,
0.4661640524864197,
-1.1058564186096191,
-0.36527398228645325,
0.9178158044815063,
-0.035450562834739685,
-0.7428368926048279,
0.4434879720211029,
-0.22105158865451813,
0.7779532670974731,
-0.14367766678333282,
0.3827449083328247,
0.27241086959838867,
0.025072278454899788,
-0.32455921173095703,
-0.4527289569377899,
-0.10758913308382034,
0.2695416212081909,
-0.76723712682724,
-0.36100026965141296,
0.23422960937023163,
0.1713607758283615,
0.004206404555588961,
0.35147625207901,
-0.3742743134498596,
0.4371851086616516,
-0.24658505618572235,
0.26603806018829346,
-0.0808139368891716,
-0.3441871404647827,
-0.42764827609062195,
-0.19787602126598358,
-0.06896640360355377,
-0.5100328922271729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02891v1 | GPTQT: Quantize Large Language Models Twice to Push the Efficiency | 2024-07-03T08:08:01 | 2024-07-03T08:08:01 | Yipin Guo, Yilin Lang, Qinyuan Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Due to their large size, generative Large Language Models (LLMs) require
significant computing and storage resources. This paper introduces a new
post-training quantization method, GPTQT, to reduce memory usage and enhance
processing speed by expressing the weight of LLM in 3bit/2bit. Practice has
shown that minimizing the quantization error of weights is ineffective, leading
to overfitting. Therefore, GPTQT employs a progressive two-step approach:
initially quantizing weights using Linear quantization to a relatively high
bit, followed by converting obtained int weight to lower bit binary coding. A
re-explore strategy is proposed to optimize initial scaling factor. During
inference, these steps are merged into pure binary coding, enabling efficient
computation. Testing across various models and datasets confirms GPTQT's
effectiveness. Compared to the strong 3-bit quantization baseline, GPTQT
further reduces perplexity by 4.01 on opt-66B and increases speed by 1.24 times
on opt-30b. The results on Llama2 show that GPTQT is currently the best binary
coding quantization method for such kind of LLMs. | [
-0.3252399265766144,
-0.7827544212341309,
0.5256239175796509,
0.2568042278289795,
-0.5718241930007935,
0.11969474703073502,
-0.33106890320777893,
-0.020569156855344772,
-0.3259331285953522,
0.4325087368488312,
-0.11554746329784393,
-0.2511504888534546,
-0.5968443155288696,
-0.3158937394618988,
-0.23951171338558197,
0.8468834161758423,
-0.0610039159655571,
0.23686787486076355,
0.06180954724550247,
0.01927284337580204,
-0.190058171749115,
-0.7313256859779358,
-1.1897679567337036,
-0.14265355467796326,
0.24958300590515137,
0.09490975737571716,
1.089838981628418,
0.5336371064186096,
0.4353235363960266,
0.16950032114982605,
-0.14632026851177216,
-0.2802731394767761,
-0.5874903798103333,
-0.033322129398584366,
0.17121967673301697,
-0.6385524272918701,
-0.5119389295578003,
-0.34765031933784485,
0.9076244235038757,
0.39090099930763245,
-0.3348694145679474,
0.14888803660869598,
-0.20531560480594635,
0.792073667049408,
-0.5317395925521851,
0.24068708717823029,
-0.4257662296295166,
0.055308155715465546,
-0.28413107991218567,
-0.05190958082675934,
-0.22257189452648163,
-0.47371605038642883,
-0.2606438994407654,
-0.3688707649707794,
0.19755634665489197,
-0.0584472194314003,
0.4613885283470154,
0.2029164582490921,
-0.5970923900604248,
0.31848078966140747,
-0.6956374645233154,
0.7826323509216309,
-0.7980718016624451,
0.510708749294281,
0.29464098811149597,
0.16569024324417114,
0.0179616566747427,
-0.7969611883163452,
-0.6252593398094177,
-0.13216985762119293,
0.26441097259521484,
-0.1868479698896408,
-0.22438596189022064,
0.18095465004444122,
0.5961698889732361,
0.5930308103561401,
-0.8419977426528931,
-0.06489172577857971,
-0.17315766215324402,
-0.15693411231040955,
0.6244168877601624,
-0.00996480043977499,
0.20413747429847717,
0.1946439892053604,
-0.17955382168293,
-0.15082083642482758,
-1.0179293155670166,
-0.16731585562229156,
0.20269827544689178,
-0.1677234023809433,
0.26604750752449036,
0.5556164979934692,
-0.28480076789855957,
0.486192911863327,
-0.13598600029945374,
-0.14374108612537384,
0.28551456332206726,
-0.43763312697410583,
-0.22478646039962769,
-0.14394833147525787,
0.8267379403114319,
0.2584770619869232,
0.09123434126377106,
-0.08849863708019257,
-0.4340030252933502,
0.11048685759305954,
0.08182298392057419,
-1.212280035018921,
-0.33232834935188293,
0.10696142166852951,
-0.4580555260181427,
0.009594447910785675,
-0.37911534309387207,
-0.2522975504398346,
0.026449115946888924,
-0.3330165445804596,
0.6488761305809021,
-0.7691643834114075,
-0.4628141522407532,
0.2754959166049957,
0.15598653256893158,
0.3691819906234741,
0.46008366346359253,
-0.9798226356506348,
0.3391144573688507,
0.8960996866226196,
0.9011445641517639,
0.09537652879953384,
0.16921865940093994,
-0.5535190105438232,
0.03346516937017441,
-0.42584142088890076,
0.51334547996521,
-0.18372546136379242,
-0.21516282856464386,
-0.22039306163787842,
-0.3466794788837433,
0.28445327281951904,
-0.37435421347618103,
0.44226953387260437,
-0.907351553440094,
0.06245388090610504,
-0.17148128151893616,
-0.6056138873100281,
-0.25820180773735046,
0.057947710156440735,
-0.635903000831604,
1.1793869733810425,
0.5205175876617432,
-0.6960399746894836,
0.2874663472175598,
-0.45748642086982727,
-0.4469180107116699,
0.4393986463546753,
0.06653179228305817,
-0.38578465580940247,
0.43136170506477356,
0.2958777844905853,
0.2865312993526459,
-0.44735947251319885,
0.2343626320362091,
0.06120140850543976,
-0.8157457709312439,
-0.048554159700870514,
-0.41798898577690125,
0.8090065121650696,
0.25417599081993103,
-0.2702006995677948,
0.0853758454322815,
-0.4799481928348541,
0.4423901438713074,
0.22031494975090027,
-0.6807272434234619,
-0.12540937960147858,
-0.09745441377162933,
-0.015048305504024029,
0.09075913578271866,
0.20387685298919678,
-0.3839428722858429,
0.4603714942932129,
-0.43358710408210754,
0.7388720512390137,
0.5965837240219116,
-0.21463526785373688,
0.35909605026245117,
-0.10567861795425415,
0.6374746561050415,
-0.4257560670375824,
0.2823268473148346,
0.09032842516899109,
-0.4203765094280243,
-0.7232297658920288,
-0.2398953139781952,
0.6152721047401428,
0.6255793571472168,
-1.1284886598587036,
0.32120954990386963,
-0.3601264953613281,
-0.2237035632133484,
-0.5405157804489136,
-0.02315095067024231,
0.3917582631111145,
-0.2112993746995926,
0.2833014726638794,
-0.48821449279785156,
-0.42617014050483704,
-0.746411919593811,
-0.08630054444074631,
-0.18734703958034515,
-0.48270300030708313,
-0.1684175580739975,
0.34055790305137634,
-0.1935998499393463,
0.6232850551605225,
-0.5548419952392578,
0.34037649631500244,
-0.19541412591934204,
0.2591193914413452,
0.17935964465141296,
0.560035228729248,
0.23142561316490173,
-0.7705187797546387,
-0.5712823867797852,
-0.1850372552871704,
-0.3759481608867645,
-0.017967212945222855,
0.01719243824481964,
-0.26558709144592285,
0.3051946461200714,
0.5298408269882202,
-0.773410975933075,
0.24629803001880646,
0.5766788721084595,
-0.15240360796451569,
0.5911521911621094,
-0.1649516075849533,
0.13389034569263458,
-0.7203877568244934,
-0.22973893582820892,
-0.2505839169025421,
-0.49789807200431824,
-0.4946926236152649,
0.2462962567806244,
0.35382935404777527,
-0.04873126372694969,
-0.3077026903629303,
0.24326059222221375,
-0.6114242672920227,
-0.15649893879890442,
-0.3967282474040985,
-0.14410002529621124,
-0.13624729216098785,
0.6298335790634155,
-0.1251264065504074,
1.0973392724990845,
0.5586212277412415,
-0.3609170913696289,
0.631428062915802,
-0.11372429132461548,
-0.3592061996459961,
0.34657391905784607,
-0.6120738983154297,
0.45149537920951843,
-0.18775498867034912,
0.2608347535133362,
-0.982637345790863,
0.3073434829711914,
0.14228275418281555,
-0.36278295516967773,
0.4148181676864624,
-0.21977488696575165,
-0.9557752013206482,
-0.3861139714717865,
-0.4692625403404236,
0.6884029507637024,
0.9037840366363525,
-0.3111051619052887,
0.43251389265060425,
0.23894985020160675,
-0.28015246987342834,
-0.14308981597423553,
-0.5846116542816162,
0.13303132355213165,
-0.16251996159553528,
-0.5914424657821655,
0.32724523544311523,
-0.12927651405334473,
0.11132173240184784,
-0.2004137486219406,
-0.1254924088716507,
-0.01578313112258911,
-0.05983107164502144,
-0.1990862488746643,
0.008354086428880692,
-0.32727867364883423,
0.3624929189682007,
0.027268972247838974,
-0.24102142453193665,
0.1342124491930008,
-0.6548694372177124,
0.7751284837722778,
-0.28008684515953064,
-0.02558162435889244,
-0.35352155566215515,
0.3886415958404541,
0.1139676570892334,
-0.2664785087108612,
0.7432305812835693,
1.0669200420379639,
-0.22730696201324463,
0.10572194308042526,
-0.5451646447181702,
0.04615301638841629,
-0.41855910420417786,
0.7336545586585999,
-0.47301244735717773,
-1.2240468263626099,
0.05162564292550087,
-0.21956995129585266,
-0.037500299513339996,
0.40707337856292725,
0.6379730105400085,
0.21185442805290222,
1.1035125255584717,
0.531192421913147,
-0.05801698938012123,
0.6066321730613708,
-0.28065282106399536,
0.3020453453063965,
-0.99834144115448,
0.18139351904392242,
-0.32767680287361145,
0.043313391506671906,
-0.5253207683563232,
-0.9202457666397095,
0.33970215916633606,
0.5950608253479004,
-0.5798835158348083,
0.28014126420021057,
-0.4180419445037842,
0.5408634543418884,
0.6400578022003174,
0.28387701511383057,
0.25235119462013245,
0.1900365948677063,
0.23842626810073853,
-0.002934408141300082,
-0.7025426030158997,
-0.2147073745727539,
1.38161301612854,
0.3778176009654999,
0.6673261523246765,
0.4639512598514557,
0.4566984176635742,
0.023911941796541214,
0.4463267922401428,
-0.9203232526779175,
0.5759568214416504,
-0.22859802842140198,
-0.26605531573295593,
-0.5962480306625366,
-0.7908025979995728,
-0.596415102481842,
0.49764347076416016,
-0.05637291818857193,
-0.45012620091438293,
-0.3852540850639343,
0.11131180822849274,
-0.40481284260749817,
0.2769567370414734,
-0.7493494749069214,
0.6719961762428284,
-0.18411283195018768,
-0.4170428216457367,
-0.38565197587013245,
-0.4957488477230072,
0.5230106711387634,
-0.2039112001657486,
0.08217847347259521,
0.08468692004680634,
-0.2762601971626282,
0.8281374573707581,
-0.616455614566803,
0.36633604764938354,
-0.0911799967288971,
-0.33913564682006836,
0.26949238777160645,
0.20049911737442017,
0.7576175928115845,
0.1605478972196579,
0.10115490108728409,
0.20413915812969208,
0.02618897520005703,
-0.6335034966468811,
-0.7541834115982056,
0.37267541885375977,
-0.5583469271659851,
-0.7051553130149841,
-0.2237413078546524,
-0.3912862241268158,
-0.28039875626564026,
0.04030780494213104,
0.1494351625442505,
0.2789713144302368,
0.07295691221952438,
0.1902555674314499,
0.8707390427589417,
-0.18049758672714233,
0.308488667011261,
0.38014650344848633,
-0.18452592194080353,
-0.5558614134788513,
0.7291041612625122,
0.05194694176316261,
0.46268683671951294,
0.6085726618766785,
0.2252369076013565,
-0.4056631922721863,
-0.8724373579025269,
-0.3547917604446411,
0.27847468852996826,
-0.4530474841594696,
-0.42149752378463745,
-0.5506789088249207,
-0.2172083705663681,
-0.5801798105239868,
0.24560435116291046,
-0.46103546023368835,
-0.6257871985435486,
0.12139592319726944,
0.07134758681058884,
0.46395260095596313,
0.3000229299068451,
-0.14966034889221191,
0.7934285998344421,
-0.8541091680526733,
0.3479451835155487,
0.5864610075950623,
0.46886715292930603,
0.06644397228956223,
-0.595964789390564,
-0.531213104724884,
-0.044528357684612274,
-0.25469014048576355,
-0.5379494428634644,
0.358394593000412,
0.15760819613933563,
0.14718639850616455,
0.3120057284832001,
-0.3217996060848236,
0.5064889192581177,
-0.4806431233882904,
0.649959921836853,
0.31969910860061646,
-1.175673246383667,
0.2384355068206787,
-0.24666330218315125,
0.5145757794380188,
0.2383684664964676,
0.40407705307006836,
-0.6334691643714905,
0.058187469840049744,
-0.4505687654018402,
-0.9822788834571838,
0.612788736820221,
0.3301004469394684,
0.15923422574996948,
0.16619226336479187,
0.5152478814125061,
-0.2028738111257553,
0.43608734011650085,
-0.6233831644058228,
-0.2067345231771469,
-0.04417257383465767,
0.0065611605532467365,
-0.13971053063869476,
-0.8328078389167786,
0.1446332186460495,
-0.3620857000350952,
0.6913642883300781,
-0.0977858304977417,
0.5092598795890808,
-0.1975986212491989,
-0.09930001199245453,
0.020577531307935715,
0.32472097873687744,
0.2656925618648529,
0.5222388505935669,
-0.21731708943843842,
0.18060307204723358,
0.1546257585287094,
-0.6603085994720459,
0.2979130744934082,
0.11761125922203064,
-0.10225662589073181,
-0.24721404910087585,
0.30851566791534424,
0.9158328771591187,
0.18138471245765686,
-0.41895970702171326,
0.6205109357833862,
-0.23486268520355225,
-0.2558671534061432,
-0.25467562675476074,
0.10415428876876831,
0.1656932383775711,
0.27430304884910583,
0.2587519586086273,
-0.3478729724884033,
0.2637167274951935,
-0.47891372442245483,
0.11432741582393646,
0.45505502820014954,
0.14477664232254028,
-0.14680883288383484,
0.4881170690059662,
-0.03812594711780548,
-0.11115214973688126,
0.8559252619743347,
-0.47089093923568726,
-0.7144919037818909,
0.29333949089050293,
0.4936809837818146,
0.7418003678321838,
-0.4698321223258972,
0.07777517288923264,
0.44918519258499146,
0.2706908881664276,
-0.5065023303031921,
0.34225645661354065,
-0.1646486520767212,
-0.7203112244606018,
-0.9398636817932129,
-0.7139844298362732,
-0.15345808863639832,
0.05115076154470444,
-0.46274954080581665,
-0.04265959560871124,
-0.4679430425167084,
-0.2885996401309967,
-0.31867992877960205,
0.2130746841430664,
-0.479143351316452,
0.1669197380542755,
0.237101748585701,
0.5623124837875366,
-0.38236722350120544,
1.0850673913955688,
0.45150408148765564,
-0.06385412067174911,
-0.9003449082374573,
-0.1330474615097046,
-0.2962532639503479,
-0.819372296333313,
0.5842307209968567,
-0.08831442892551422,
0.12709181010723114,
0.2947152256965637,
-0.6556873321533203,
-1.0653021335601807,
0.985434889793396,
0.35611969232559204,
-0.8697399497032166,
-0.017325229942798615,
-0.05570303276181221,
0.38373786211013794,
0.01120731420814991,
0.3896518051624298,
0.8869147300720215,
0.2819265127182007,
0.4138214886188507,
-0.7894177436828613,
0.30469778180122375,
-0.14570803940296173,
0.5773003101348877,
0.5721985101699829,
-0.694963812828064,
1.1535040140151978,
-0.1726812869310379,
-0.3376986086368561,
0.003860962577164173,
0.6269081830978394,
0.19341392815113068,
-0.25910574197769165,
0.4978904128074646,
0.7196282744407654,
0.6829817295074463,
-0.13793249428272247,
0.9163535833358765,
-0.10494043678045273,
0.5753644704818726,
0.9022002816200256,
-0.1337941586971283,
0.7665402889251709,
0.35522300004959106,
-0.8454007506370544,
0.14682328701019287,
0.6117143630981445,
0.035020966082811356,
0.3792073428630829,
0.742923378944397,
-0.655177116394043,
-0.363128662109375,
0.39879071712493896,
-0.46799203753471375,
0.12886834144592285,
0.15248239040374756,
0.03202018886804581,
-0.05785054713487625,
0.028657091781497,
0.4010532796382904,
-0.457036554813385,
-0.4551393985748291,
0.6012805700302124,
0.056595176458358765,
-0.3886623978614807,
1.0461856126785278,
0.2958190143108368,
0.7899001240730286,
-0.6150174140930176,
-0.07424353808164597,
-0.34137478470802307,
0.003522801212966442,
-0.029001086950302124,
-0.6232650279998779,
0.1444239467382431,
-0.16912367939949036,
-0.05050559714436531,
-0.20731742680072784,
0.3843833804130554,
-0.45744672417640686,
-0.5329244136810303,
-0.04818693920969963,
0.2915097177028656,
0.34612637758255005,
-0.7558695673942566,
-0.5951156616210938,
0.13042320311069489,
0.1825352907180786,
-0.5733892321586609,
0.41060584783554077,
0.7328935861587524,
-0.16993288695812225,
0.5870019197463989,
0.7046233415603638,
0.18493437767028809,
-0.0476035512983799,
0.2646853029727936,
0.9766286611557007,
-0.8807308077812195,
-0.46233195066452026,
-0.8206132054328918,
0.2342846840620041,
0.2947167456150055,
0.13062167167663574,
0.5370911955833435,
0.6383699774742126,
0.8026062250137329,
0.024317990988492966,
0.7097980380058289,
-0.03444113954901695,
0.2289743423461914,
-0.867392361164093,
0.4231584668159485,
-0.41824597120285034,
0.26588305830955505,
-0.028111698105931282,
-0.9720308184623718,
-0.3929693102836609,
0.6719761490821838,
-0.24495796859264374,
0.3031933903694153,
0.8894278407096863,
0.6231388449668884,
0.38525304198265076,
-0.07153057307004929,
0.39202064275741577,
0.2706625163555145,
0.32582953572273254,
1.0997146368026733,
0.6315668821334839,
-0.6650104522705078,
0.4999689757823944,
-0.156834214925766,
-0.43707799911499023,
-0.11164256185293198,
-0.6258448958396912,
-0.6872904896736145,
-0.224400594830513,
-0.5155693292617798,
-0.29171761870384216,
0.006489166058599949,
0.5472680330276489,
0.8301251530647278,
-0.45759549736976624,
-0.09406990557909012,
-0.16967901587486267,
-0.08155924081802368,
-0.2530636191368103,
-0.2657225728034973,
0.5536885261535645,
-0.22100989520549774,
-0.577755331993103,
0.03556292876601219,
0.15181957185268402,
0.1959397941827774,
-0.2574150562286377,
-0.015533482655882835,
0.05999920889735222,
-0.17152230441570282,
0.961362898349762,
-0.05919570103287697,
-0.32359135150909424,
-0.11655551195144653,
-0.4317023754119873,
-0.07599431276321411,
0.11692201346158981,
1.005918025970459,
-0.7848226428031921,
0.08218339830636978,
0.417095422744751,
0.40359821915626526,
0.9385052919387817,
0.1690431535243988,
0.555823802947998,
-0.4996347725391388,
0.25960609316825867,
0.32778775691986084,
0.03231559693813324,
0.31093016266822815,
-0.5319359302520752,
0.6004477739334106,
0.22177661955356598,
-0.6099070310592651,
-0.6134164333343506,
0.1510232388973236,
-0.7859600782394409,
-0.31041449308395386,
1.1424626111984253,
-0.09774627536535263,
-0.3179934024810791,
0.11264094710350037,
-0.306708961725235,
0.30252715945243835,
-0.4431430399417877,
0.4065447449684143,
0.5830394625663757,
-0.11483899503946304,
-0.5933580994606018,
-0.7728412747383118,
0.5934174656867981,
0.42732542753219604,
-0.6176824569702148,
0.06478703767061234,
0.40608760714530945,
0.29355502128601074,
-0.27456268668174744,
1.0264885425567627,
-0.22868885099887848,
0.2148049920797348,
0.15694861114025116,
0.33847713470458984,
0.00927722454071045,
0.15060767531394958,
-0.47003069519996643,
0.126529723405838,
0.2871650755405426,
0.05164360627532005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02885v1 | CogErgLLM: Exploring Large Language Model Systems Design Perspective Using Cognitive Ergonomics | 2024-07-03T07:59:52 | 2024-07-03T07:59:52 | Azmine Toushik Wasi | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Integrating cognitive ergonomics with LLMs is essential for enhancing safety,
reliability, and user satisfaction in human-AI interactions. Current LLM design
often lacks this integration, leading to systems that may not fully align with
human cognitive capabilities and limitations. Insufficient focus on
incorporating cognitive science methods exacerbates biases in LLM outputs,
while inconsistent application of user-centered design principles results in
sub-optimal user experiences. To address these challenges, our position paper
explores the critical integration of cognitive ergonomics principles into LLM
design, aiming to provide a comprehensive framework and practical guidelines
for ethical LLM development. Through our contributions, we seek to advance
understanding and practice in integrating cognitive ergonomics into LLM
systems, fostering safer, more reliable, and ethically sound human-AI
interactions. | [
-0.4262043535709381,
-0.81451416015625,
0.8709325194358826,
-0.001551220309920609,
-0.22544506192207336,
-0.024853933602571487,
-0.3781477212905884,
-1.0600985288619995,
-0.07098976522684097,
0.5234077572822571,
-0.48067423701286316,
-0.45876067876815796,
-0.2840067446231842,
-0.09056847542524338,
-0.16726168990135193,
0.6483132839202881,
-0.024305790662765503,
0.22494035959243774,
-0.4948062598705292,
-0.07715225964784622,
-0.3227292001247406,
-1.129181981086731,
-0.6937084794044495,
-0.579114556312561,
0.20219764113426208,
0.12348854541778564,
0.6369067430496216,
0.08178354054689407,
0.29199275374412537,
0.08896432816982269,
-0.207068532705307,
-0.07853147387504578,
-0.4754941165447235,
0.16708731651306152,
0.029341306537389755,
-0.2882245182991028,
-0.7724169492721558,
-0.06113915517926216,
0.08717381954193115,
0.6739808320999146,
-0.7526959180831909,
0.10267849266529083,
0.38944512605667114,
0.3771832287311554,
-0.4743450880050659,
0.10997656732797623,
0.12877622246742249,
0.41811108589172363,
-0.06438186764717102,
0.040328498929739,
-0.5366742014884949,
-0.3681092858314514,
0.1837432086467743,
-0.7450950741767883,
-0.36735233664512634,
0.5359241962432861,
0.4697461426258087,
0.5400906205177307,
-0.20999254286289215,
-0.5338237285614014,
-0.7643219828605652,
0.9440171718597412,
-1.0978913307189941,
0.6107212901115417,
0.2163950651884079,
-0.06450358778238297,
-0.19882532954216003,
-0.261796772480011,
-0.6305278539657593,
-0.24180564284324646,
-0.29568353295326233,
0.23376238346099854,
0.08546800911426544,
0.41248369216918945,
0.11505307257175446,
-0.012872142717242241,
-0.5875122547149658,
0.3789179027080536,
-0.35136792063713074,
-0.055336516350507736,
0.7850795984268188,
0.39763975143432617,
0.5159375071525574,
0.22831228375434875,
-0.29912659525871277,
0.06223573535680771,
-0.6454742550849915,
0.08953890204429626,
0.4548972547054291,
0.03786211460828781,
-0.20122557878494263,
0.4566271901130676,
-0.061723742634058,
0.9928717017173767,
-0.22108523547649384,
-0.0714757889509201,
0.3023219406604767,
-0.20756374299526215,
-0.4363306760787964,
0.16232793033123016,
0.6314982771873474,
0.4467594027519226,
0.44854336977005005,
-0.20090870559215546,
-0.14082854986190796,
-0.06498681008815765,
0.572744607925415,
-0.29443466663360596,
0.12221604585647583,
0.49580004811286926,
-0.49842292070388794,
-0.45661112666130066,
0.07635854929685593,
-0.6339882016181946,
-0.27357107400894165,
-0.6376809477806091,
-0.05540795251727104,
-0.14187130331993103,
-0.3393772840499878,
0.6411110758781433,
-0.018561864271759987,
0.4868331551551819,
0.5058233141899109,
-0.8932622075080872,
0.4289610683917999,
0.968807578086853,
0.3389865756034851,
-0.37876972556114197,
-0.08584276586771011,
-0.11841611564159393,
0.5404436588287354,
-0.27617284655570984,
0.33200594782829285,
-0.49532660841941833,
-0.751745343208313,
0.1434420496225357,
-0.2864554822444916,
0.06705083698034286,
-0.4794749319553375,
0.8104380369186401,
-0.5619470477104187,
0.3131524920463562,
-0.05466825142502785,
-0.28109011054039,
-0.4455106556415558,
0.4161643087863922,
-0.3079622983932495,
0.8861897587776184,
-0.12030001729726791,
-0.41021591424942017,
0.2544653117656708,
-1.0694493055343628,
-0.6139992475509644,
-0.03958655521273613,
-0.5917502641677856,
-0.0951465517282486,
0.2542441785335541,
-0.07515473663806915,
0.35270562767982483,
-0.5459772944450378,
0.5128509402275085,
-0.5688416361808777,
-0.30974146723747253,
0.3390934467315674,
-0.1537330448627472,
1.222572922706604,
0.4103560149669647,
-0.16160371899604797,
0.07365934550762177,
-0.3472476005554199,
0.34094130992889404,
0.09666705876588821,
-0.574447751045227,
-0.42678841948509216,
0.16637928783893585,
0.4148682951927185,
0.22758549451828003,
0.4538591504096985,
-0.45678842067718506,
-0.1666131168603897,
-0.10499157011508942,
0.4500816762447357,
0.7198878526687622,
-0.1777440756559372,
0.679765522480011,
-0.33645322918891907,
0.5322290062904358,
-0.4535938799381256,
0.6971848011016846,
0.5864455103874207,
-0.1559869796037674,
-0.5578925013542175,
-0.18523256480693817,
-0.3941940665245056,
0.7874848246574402,
-0.34094473719596863,
0.8358545303344727,
0.09427725523710251,
-0.14473207294940948,
-0.08768428862094879,
0.15364238619804382,
0.3170296251773834,
0.5155957341194153,
0.2485455572605133,
-0.26802998781204224,
-0.39747899770736694,
-0.8423917889595032,
-0.28817135095596313,
-0.5286820530891418,
-0.14771974086761475,
0.5263159275054932,
0.18342329561710358,
-0.32497358322143555,
0.9345507025718689,
-0.4851239025592804,
-0.05700359866023064,
-0.10952349752187729,
-0.26423025131225586,
0.2722584307193756,
0.6011969447135925,
0.5496677756309509,
-0.6621170043945312,
0.034556496888399124,
-0.0869220495223999,
-1.4123483896255493,
-0.1671898066997528,
0.23006434738636017,
-0.18724223971366882,
0.4214249849319458,
0.8359308242797852,
-0.6630967259407043,
0.30623793601989746,
0.5875746607780457,
-0.3433343172073364,
0.35289818048477173,
-0.20325911045074463,
0.018891841173171997,
-0.7833027243614197,
0.14047159254550934,
-0.15474651753902435,
0.05383524298667908,
-0.6590152978897095,
0.3093225061893463,
-0.21141202747821808,
-0.17271916568279266,
-0.5775744318962097,
0.398826003074646,
-0.4855104088783264,
0.0006991353584453464,
-0.07871385663747787,
0.06452572345733643,
0.08260727673768997,
0.25933998823165894,
-0.028898699209094048,
0.4111427664756775,
0.2899763882160187,
-0.6752104163169861,
0.3523138761520386,
0.2537693977355957,
-0.3045217990875244,
0.9757058620452881,
-1.0573097467422485,
0.2708641588687897,
0.05463492497801781,
0.4010109007358551,
-0.606285035610199,
-0.22457394003868103,
0.5786571502685547,
-0.29683688282966614,
0.3405378460884094,
0.39816585183143616,
-0.7016047835350037,
-0.3187246024608612,
-0.17643409967422485,
0.6329787969589233,
0.6200386881828308,
-0.26981788873672485,
0.8087220788002014,
0.8092976808547974,
-0.24484483897686005,
-0.4020465016365051,
-1.2168816328048706,
0.10763394832611084,
-0.3751088082790375,
-0.9548078179359436,
0.23992885649204254,
-0.13393369317054749,
-0.7062419056892395,
-0.15377721190452576,
0.036211904138326645,
0.30570724606513977,
0.3522716462612152,
0.11268770694732666,
0.5350229740142822,
-0.052537720650434494,
0.12429220229387283,
-0.12503303587436676,
-0.10433141142129898,
0.18961159884929657,
-0.32085978984832764,
0.5495546460151672,
-0.15220792591571808,
-0.697420060634613,
-0.5808357000350952,
0.4868391156196594,
0.6824260950088501,
-0.07763378322124481,
0.5791707038879395,
0.39028626680374146,
-0.37467333674430847,
0.18899114429950714,
-0.6734991669654846,
-0.2107688933610916,
-0.4505467712879181,
0.3244498372077942,
-0.014899934642016888,
-1.200310230255127,
0.3430822789669037,
0.10866381227970123,
0.26593154668807983,
-0.062000926584005356,
0.5771323442459106,
-0.6156176328659058,
0.76264888048172,
0.9802893996238708,
-0.0391564704477787,
0.5290830135345459,
0.21400515735149384,
0.28643354773521423,
-1.2795294523239136,
-0.3240623474121094,
-0.43641772866249084,
-0.2663150429725647,
-0.3280237913131714,
-0.3529556393623352,
0.4484390616416931,
-0.13276083767414093,
-0.6675572991371155,
-0.12501035630702972,
-0.5209195017814636,
0.07047425210475922,
0.4414600431919098,
0.14257311820983887,
0.34997159242630005,
-0.10018952935934067,
-0.3898504376411438,
0.15436281263828278,
-0.6712068915367126,
-0.7265677452087402,
0.551550030708313,
0.34009143710136414,
1.49001944065094,
0.46230193972587585,
0.8467845320701599,
0.23850752413272858,
0.13541600108146667,
-0.6197047829627991,
0.5753553509712219,
0.06329016387462616,
-0.8507238626480103,
-0.6410394310951233,
0.010204900987446308,
-0.8058796525001526,
0.04509972035884857,
-0.13482120633125305,
-1.023898959159851,
0.29620105028152466,
0.13571855425834656,
-0.5756862759590149,
-0.021508483216166496,
-0.6425106525421143,
0.6358872652053833,
-0.6548376679420471,
-0.4347482919692993,
-0.45405420660972595,
-0.6599181890487671,
0.3056686222553253,
0.07141193747520447,
0.42484211921691895,
-0.07644885033369064,
-0.3730171322822571,
0.7564680576324463,
-0.15085574984550476,
1.199205994606018,
0.08312956243753433,
-0.2530091404914856,
0.2697370648384094,
-0.1753552258014679,
0.395888090133667,
0.030856281518936157,
-0.21619947254657745,
0.3037925064563751,
-0.12393748015165329,
-0.41838040947914124,
-0.2607661485671997,
0.7116522192955017,
-0.9067065119743347,
-0.9492483139038086,
-0.5859978199005127,
-0.6408953666687012,
-0.2723957300186157,
0.09756824374198914,
-0.09047678858041763,
0.0038729701191186905,
-0.48722630739212036,
0.14373335242271423,
0.7931936383247375,
-0.3530796766281128,
0.43023180961608887,
0.3726719319820404,
-0.4612879455089569,
-0.314646452665329,
0.4455167055130005,
-0.0901002585887909,
0.2880302965641022,
0.049255963414907455,
-0.073341503739357,
-0.3100440800189972,
-0.5363003015518188,
-0.3356984555721283,
0.17476502060890198,
-0.6729166507720947,
0.4024546444416046,
-0.47686928510665894,
-0.28297165036201477,
-0.3562452495098114,
-0.5923800468444824,
-0.05412466824054718,
-0.11492109298706055,
-0.5303421020507812,
-0.03242017328739166,
0.2133886069059372,
0.8972176313400269,
0.2065620869398117,
0.25119754672050476,
-0.816371738910675,
0.02104135975241661,
0.1340823620557785,
0.36411577463150024,
0.0709737092256546,
-0.4080033302307129,
-0.21858201920986176,
-0.19998827576637268,
-0.15429991483688354,
-0.3129933178424835,
0.15034465491771698,
-0.34350135922431946,
1.1807832717895508,
0.2151130735874176,
0.1711955964565277,
0.44173067808151245,
-0.32925161719322205,
0.8137491941452026,
0.4824628233909607,
-0.7490559220314026,
0.1385912001132965,
-0.4599964916706085,
0.275616854429245,
0.6136597394943237,
0.1743779331445694,
-0.8454774022102356,
-0.19009418785572052,
-0.5019955635070801,
-0.8741453289985657,
0.536591112613678,
-0.03193507343530655,
-0.00015027540212031454,
0.2201865315437317,
0.2931576371192932,
0.07369257509708405,
0.11934728920459747,
-0.5078926086425781,
0.06548614799976349,
0.38790348172187805,
-0.5045152902603149,
-0.06944933533668518,
-0.24861803650856018,
-0.5482164621353149,
0.00816940888762474,
0.5512787103652954,
0.0005152226076461375,
0.1785290390253067,
0.1320473998785019,
-0.18968476355075836,
0.022862005978822708,
0.22093473374843597,
0.9151356220245361,
0.8165749311447144,
-0.08662505447864532,
0.07780352979898453,
0.3254966735839844,
-0.37056049704551697,
0.06746872514486313,
-0.1464371234178543,
-0.20153556764125824,
-0.6233582496643066,
0.13524438440799713,
0.2144765853881836,
0.1431404948234558,
-0.6986179947853088,
0.03985532000660896,
-0.16442304849624634,
-0.003031861735507846,
-0.8156524896621704,
0.40708041191101074,
0.5063910484313965,
0.48192909359931946,
0.42249199748039246,
0.029769036918878555,
-0.059374306350946426,
-0.5371436476707458,
0.1266360878944397,
0.5995224118232727,
-0.3864816427230835,
-0.15543228387832642,
0.6185240149497986,
0.45260557532310486,
-0.42943644523620605,
0.5820115208625793,
0.3183061182498932,
-0.26145291328430176,
0.5571630001068115,
0.30057963728904724,
0.8156734704971313,
-0.0536133237183094,
-0.362928569316864,
0.044348087161779404,
0.5846632719039917,
-0.23470094799995422,
0.3588728606700897,
0.19247420132160187,
-0.5837152600288391,
-0.44608715176582336,
-0.4636308550834656,
-0.6426689624786377,
-0.4217817187309265,
-0.7249777913093567,
0.3380310535430908,
-0.41763144731521606,
-0.2544212341308594,
-0.4816758930683136,
-0.4196021258831024,
-0.5617767572402954,
0.24051134288311005,
0.46141672134399414,
0.6773322224617004,
-0.5778310894966125,
0.5449414849281311,
0.780372679233551,
-0.3147391676902771,
-0.29878076910972595,
0.059479862451553345,
0.3591013550758362,
-1.1218507289886475,
0.47947242856025696,
-0.25612732768058777,
-0.3371543288230896,
-0.16758796572685242,
-0.6288694143295288,
-0.7432881593704224,
1.431938886642456,
0.3579733967781067,
-0.5586143732070923,
-0.11542683839797974,
0.15605053305625916,
0.45670315623283386,
-0.5713568925857544,
-0.16454170644283295,
0.3269828259944916,
0.639098584651947,
-0.13697269558906555,
-0.7496386766433716,
0.2880396842956543,
0.11576458811759949,
-0.023423023521900177,
0.09053301066160202,
-1.1068108081817627,
0.567238450050354,
-0.12996628880500793,
-0.040221814066171646,
0.09025835245847702,
0.4305744171142578,
0.4535526633262634,
0.4625069499015808,
0.3800996243953705,
0.815613329410553,
0.888476550579071,
0.11220575869083405,
1.1476060152053833,
-0.34018614888191223,
0.40929967164993286,
0.982347846031189,
-0.47045665979385376,
0.6535696983337402,
1.0185644626617432,
-0.15008507668972015,
0.2168966680765152,
0.6113482713699341,
0.45751991868019104,
0.18580631911754608,
0.4036518633365631,
-0.4016874134540558,
-0.27557408809661865,
-0.2404603809118271,
-0.4380071461200714,
0.2900528013706207,
0.6728981733322144,
-0.21227510273456573,
0.07020032405853271,
-0.16011445224285126,
0.14560215175151825,
-0.12771514058113098,
0.011703861877322197,
0.6890890598297119,
0.5975589156150818,
-0.5171314477920532,
0.3260393738746643,
-0.24921676516532898,
0.8920749425888062,
-0.292590856552124,
0.2032470703125,
0.10353913903236389,
0.12889255583286285,
-0.31831178069114685,
-0.9500333070755005,
0.47017914056777954,
-0.12182153016328812,
-0.1013394370675087,
-0.2732357680797577,
0.7180655002593994,
-0.13228507339954376,
-0.3999481499195099,
0.49108076095581055,
0.9283353090286255,
0.08332693576812744,
0.3830713629722595,
-0.6608151197433472,
0.544505774974823,
-0.1378219872713089,
-0.39366820454597473,
0.347866952419281,
0.2068376988172531,
0.02102004550397396,
0.5822859406471252,
0.7223144769668579,
-0.26629742980003357,
-0.308251291513443,
-0.03792589157819748,
0.6319605708122253,
-1.022091031074524,
-0.2831520438194275,
-1.0925800800323486,
0.4138951599597931,
-0.10405396670103073,
-0.18491950631141663,
0.22567281126976013,
0.3449740707874298,
0.7850884199142456,
-0.1190437451004982,
1.1489979028701782,
-0.3324631452560425,
-0.10856770724058151,
-0.6189053654670715,
1.0866559743881226,
-0.47286537289619446,
0.2294168323278427,
-0.016646012663841248,
-0.6740453839302063,
-0.585545003414154,
0.7302510738372803,
-0.4877224266529083,
0.3283643424510956,
0.7176350355148315,
0.6304296851158142,
-0.019597966223955154,
0.11644318699836731,
0.6480026841163635,
0.06458211690187454,
0.5960443019866943,
0.6142823100090027,
1.0217591524124146,
0.13141502439975739,
0.4086143374443054,
0.14073410630226135,
-0.2284696102142334,
-0.700992226600647,
-1.0596390962600708,
-0.7304006218910217,
-0.28079333901405334,
-0.21315701305866241,
-0.14809973537921906,
0.059631310403347015,
1.1152268648147583,
0.7278656959533691,
-0.5985025763511658,
-0.5963119268417358,
-0.0985618606209755,
0.051849838346242905,
0.06379174441099167,
-0.24902896583080292,
-0.1144666001200676,
-0.15921293199062347,
-0.5656955242156982,
-0.03922373056411743,
0.514392614364624,
0.10971495509147644,
-0.39729782938957214,
-0.5379927754402161,
-0.2686598598957062,
0.14538481831550598,
0.6474701166152954,
0.2984501123428345,
-0.9247012734413147,
-0.6562889814376831,
0.23264798521995544,
-0.49035191535949707,
0.025180278345942497,
0.7892633080482483,
-0.36092138290405273,
0.23466040194034576,
0.37896063923835754,
0.7564157247543335,
0.29045844078063965,
-0.19709405303001404,
0.8935896158218384,
-0.1883537322282791,
0.11040444672107697,
0.4741354286670685,
0.44649505615234375,
0.3202480673789978,
-0.5709990859031677,
0.8650470972061157,
-0.024927660822868347,
-0.6805117130279541,
-0.7708656191825867,
0.3783022165298462,
-1.4078311920166016,
-0.04028613492846489,
1.1586359739303589,
-0.10100209712982178,
-0.3948591351509094,
-0.36374524235725403,
-0.35801365971565247,
0.2536967396736145,
-0.3612419068813324,
0.848690390586853,
0.9651607275009155,
-0.7627282738685608,
-0.07210107147693634,
-0.8576624393463135,
0.14385086297988892,
0.46150729060173035,
-0.9562825560569763,
0.017184840515255928,
0.4269047677516937,
0.21356843411922455,
0.11946740746498108,
0.46099284291267395,
-0.31724536418914795,
0.4089725911617279,
-0.28256651759147644,
0.5013920068740845,
-0.11599070578813553,
0.29936617612838745,
-0.2522515058517456,
-0.01763313263654709,
0.45818379521369934,
0.11149619519710541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02883v1 | CoIR: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Code Information Retrieval Models | 2024-07-03T07:58:20 | 2024-07-03T07:58:20 | Xiangyang Li, Kuicai Dong, Yi Quan Lee, Wei Xia, Yichun Yin, Hao Zhang, Yong Liu, Yasheng Wang, Ruiming Tang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Despite the substantial success of Information Retrieval (IR) in various NLP
tasks, most IR systems predominantly handle queries and corpora in natural
language, neglecting the domain of code retrieval. Code retrieval is critically
important yet remains under-explored, with existing methods and benchmarks
inadequately representing the diversity of code in various domains and tasks.
Addressing this gap, we present \textbf{\name} (\textbf{Co}de
\textbf{I}nformation \textbf{R}etrieval Benchmark), a robust and comprehensive
benchmark specifically designed to assess code retrieval capabilities. \name
comprises \textbf{ten} meticulously curated code datasets, spanning
\textbf{eight} distinctive retrieval tasks across \textbf{seven} diverse
domains. We first discuss the construction of \name and its diverse dataset
composition. Further, we evaluate nine widely used retrieval models using
\name, uncovering significant difficulties in performing code retrieval tasks
even with state-of-the-art systems. To facilitate easy adoption and integration
within existing research workflows, \name has been developed as a user-friendly
Python framework, readily installable via pip. It shares same data schema as
other popular benchmarks like MTEB and BEIR, enabling seamless cross-benchmark
evaluations. Through \name, we aim to invigorate research in the code retrieval
domain, providing a versatile benchmarking tool that encourages further
development and exploration of code retrieval systems\footnote{\url{
https://github.com/CoIR-team/coir}}. | [
-0.20669026672840118,
-0.5608007907867432,
-0.02815113589167595,
0.20888136327266693,
-0.002394580515101552,
0.5666724443435669,
-0.1532997041940689,
-0.5820280909538269,
0.08392152190208435,
0.20862026512622833,
-0.08150854706764221,
-0.47614189982414246,
-0.45289576053619385,
0.20361004769802094,
-0.5582358837127686,
0.65804523229599,
-0.023357050493359566,
-0.03929583728313446,
-0.24005383253097534,
-0.31056997179985046,
-0.46107521653175354,
-0.7519341707229614,
-0.3769034147262573,
-0.20337502658367157,
0.6370288133621216,
0.42177295684814453,
0.33937159180641174,
0.491621732711792,
1.2996281385421753,
0.08263317495584488,
0.04843159765005112,
0.20097483694553375,
-0.5294468402862549,
0.14987075328826904,
-0.08623852580785751,
-0.25039151310920715,
-0.3934137225151062,
-0.06157941371202469,
0.3574134409427643,
0.7925990223884583,
-0.2520172894001007,
0.4024992287158966,
-0.10356481373310089,
0.779826283454895,
-1.0890663862228394,
-0.02593015879392624,
-0.48132869601249695,
0.20312078297138214,
-0.15123090147972107,
-0.38862431049346924,
-0.5126699805259705,
-0.5173776149749756,
0.13350066542625427,
-0.32925114035606384,
0.09592719376087189,
0.4655856192111969,
0.8729947805404663,
0.11527427285909653,
-0.20907850563526154,
-0.473638117313385,
-0.867807924747467,
0.9536702036857605,
-0.23480014503002167,
0.5548750758171082,
0.24821756780147552,
0.5317402482032776,
-0.22370395064353943,
-1.1184113025665283,
-0.25922292470932007,
-0.2936859428882599,
-0.08231174200773239,
-0.0024863900616765022,
-0.49686771631240845,
-0.22027364373207092,
0.25919219851493835,
0.6311761736869812,
-0.6981549859046936,
-0.49311259388923645,
-0.4011208713054657,
-0.23290230333805084,
0.4437609612941742,
0.041627634316682816,
0.3566538989543915,
0.13448137044906616,
-0.7245058417320251,
-0.3034074306488037,
-0.6202973127365112,
0.1398446410894394,
0.42587026953697205,
0.28592929244041443,
-0.17710021138191223,
0.4614960551261902,
-0.5244008302688599,
0.7355680465698242,
-0.11010695993900299,
0.16677288711071014,
0.3268957734107971,
-0.23990674316883087,
-0.3319421112537384,
-0.005254858173429966,
0.6435402035713196,
0.10091409087181091,
0.05214058980345726,
-0.6752058267593384,
-0.08376328647136688,
0.1144663393497467,
0.43432459235191345,
-0.8427563905715942,
-0.4971427917480469,
0.13043572008609772,
-0.5126680135726929,
0.007159460801631212,
0.33901408314704895,
-0.8023380041122437,
-0.1495104879140854,
-0.09924545884132385,
0.313212513923645,
-0.372901976108551,
-0.23349788784980774,
0.20488515496253967,
-0.46806663274765015,
0.48087212443351746,
0.040683671832084656,
-0.539970338344574,
0.4622049033641815,
0.9219925403594971,
0.5818925499916077,
-0.4829910397529602,
-0.018988102674484253,
-0.8731797933578491,
-0.1370857208967209,
-0.37011924386024475,
0.7909701466560364,
-1.1246081590652466,
-0.3145197927951813,
-0.17539848387241364,
-0.2878808379173279,
0.07467672228813171,
-0.986808180809021,
0.6469376087188721,
-0.8747074007987976,
-0.09511550515890121,
-0.21851560473442078,
-0.401363343000412,
-0.1670224368572235,
0.3090047240257263,
-0.8363640308380127,
1.1575195789337158,
0.17044267058372498,
-0.9313644766807556,
0.28546738624572754,
-0.3400280177593231,
-0.3622932434082031,
0.20274585485458374,
-0.37566447257995605,
-0.30279356241226196,
0.0004002535715699196,
-0.41352328658103943,
0.1462058424949646,
-0.6563816070556641,
0.3774336278438568,
-0.4840220510959625,
-0.5885393619537354,
0.09364217519760132,
-0.029681850224733353,
0.5168546438217163,
0.6245077252388,
0.006287744268774986,
-0.3024997413158417,
-0.8489416837692261,
0.4574255347251892,
-0.1623028963804245,
-0.3403935134410858,
-0.6530112028121948,
-0.08233793079853058,
0.11015383154153824,
-0.09636648744344711,
0.23714320361614227,
-0.36890652775764465,
0.09951155632734299,
0.19243451952934265,
0.19746989011764526,
0.00509676756337285,
-0.13162027299404144,
0.4176263213157654,
-0.3360140919685364,
0.6087005734443665,
-0.19094933569431305,
0.1340065747499466,
0.014381656423211098,
-0.14694316685199738,
-0.5590052604675293,
-0.4745272696018219,
0.4827634394168854,
0.45123010873794556,
-0.5135141611099243,
0.19357790052890778,
-0.20437617599964142,
-0.8264094591140747,
-0.2516086995601654,
0.010594261810183525,
0.6185821890830994,
0.3362544775009155,
0.5701206922531128,
-0.563222348690033,
-0.9538830518722534,
-0.8124669194221497,
-0.6638460755348206,
-0.25480952858924866,
0.24624314904212952,
0.5300648212432861,
0.6721175909042358,
-0.3489161431789398,
0.9507474303245544,
-0.48403459787368774,
-0.20905037224292755,
-0.10890219360589981,
0.4285029172897339,
0.3503488302230835,
0.5275776386260986,
0.17050452530384064,
-1.118306279182434,
-0.6324747800827026,
-0.12451054900884628,
-0.7022415399551392,
-0.05692195147275925,
0.061101313680410385,
-0.28311464190483093,
-0.2501388490200043,
0.3830816149711609,
-0.1877327561378479,
0.2565816342830658,
0.612250566482544,
-0.2293509691953659,
0.7212666273117065,
-0.13688704371452332,
0.21157541871070862,
-0.7656329870223999,
0.808404803276062,
-0.36564698815345764,
-0.18690992891788483,
-0.4959849715232849,
0.6867254972457886,
0.3236168920993805,
0.11964435130357742,
-0.2860116958618164,
0.5512740612030029,
-0.6338145732879639,
-0.10069387406110764,
0.14898581802845,
-0.2220969796180725,
0.2764444053173065,
0.18624715507030487,
-0.058914512395858765,
1.0181794166564941,
0.4500986933708191,
-0.7751195430755615,
0.35982662439346313,
0.20343494415283203,
-0.5509705543518066,
0.6300305724143982,
-0.8345270752906799,
0.3991941511631012,
0.32448530197143555,
-0.01618121936917305,
-0.5884315371513367,
-0.044449228793382645,
0.05738088861107826,
-0.42485207319259644,
0.03957560285925865,
-0.3546173572540283,
-0.5974844694137573,
-0.1386353075504303,
-0.11641115695238113,
0.5654394626617432,
0.48526620864868164,
-0.5929436683654785,
0.3326735198497772,
0.5418723821640015,
0.0009579671896062791,
-0.944866955280304,
-0.6102532744407654,
0.37929752469062805,
-0.2670888304710388,
-0.20620203018188477,
0.5486837029457092,
-0.45434483885765076,
-0.4321483075618744,
-0.09174281358718872,
-0.3475410044193268,
-0.5909734964370728,
0.19629929959774017,
0.03001043014228344,
0.2490517646074295,
-0.21061360836029053,
0.15199477970600128,
-0.2004782110452652,
-0.07617723941802979,
-0.16606982052326202,
-0.06050407886505127,
0.5882835984230042,
-0.30821043252944946,
-0.24569855630397797,
0.017263153567910194,
0.29919812083244324,
0.26517680287361145,
-0.5867354273796082,
0.2675296366214752,
0.23320649564266205,
-0.21847006678581238,
-0.27831414341926575,
-0.4481391906738281,
0.16902609169483185,
-0.3826259970664978,
0.1068955659866333,
-0.4785349369049072,
-0.7788304686546326,
0.6898740530014038,
-0.30744826793670654,
-0.5534601807594299,
0.23894621431827545,
0.21251438558101654,
-0.006127328611910343,
0.4892914891242981,
0.9283562898635864,
-0.05866607651114464,
0.32741808891296387,
-0.4201197028160095,
0.2931623160839081,
-0.8801752924919128,
-0.38100701570510864,
-0.9491363167762756,
-0.13324251770973206,
-0.4499489367008209,
-0.5884555578231812,
0.02798626385629177,
0.3906446397304535,
-0.17775222659111023,
0.7680966854095459,
-0.6157486438751221,
0.40790536999702454,
0.48157036304473877,
-0.2120753526687622,
0.5591715574264526,
0.14432170987129211,
-0.2683311104774475,
0.1560155153274536,
-0.4391995072364807,
-0.3702392876148224,
0.8479548096656799,
0.01207318902015686,
1.1887530088424683,
0.08027904480695724,
0.9374316334724426,
0.7206433415412903,
-0.12403476238250732,
-0.4577404856681824,
0.3309265971183777,
-0.14589767158031464,
-0.6749207973480225,
0.20190000534057617,
-0.5349933505058289,
-1.1570512056350708,
-0.12155966460704803,
0.05553729832172394,
-0.5693619251251221,
0.6176366209983826,
-0.06649846583604813,
-0.47909271717071533,
0.08965102583169937,
-0.6021786332130432,
0.8623631596565247,
-0.21240383386611938,
-0.5532335638999939,
-0.3156594932079315,
-0.4424310028553009,
-0.1248767301440239,
-0.013837439939379692,
0.014381330460309982,
-0.08890704810619354,
-0.08229242265224457,
0.5232911109924316,
-0.12141820788383484,
0.3225257992744446,
-0.05230623111128807,
0.15749073028564453,
0.3124690055847168,
0.33456549048423767,
0.351059228181839,
0.003410514909774065,
-0.41141122579574585,
0.4215056002140045,
0.3803490698337555,
-0.2731250524520874,
-0.14149846136569977,
0.6901611089706421,
-0.55042964220047,
0.0456489697098732,
-0.427733838558197,
-0.4217679798603058,
0.22905366122722626,
0.4884313941001892,
0.10879247635602951,
0.6878718733787537,
-0.4175048768520355,
0.5761860609054565,
0.708477258682251,
-0.41803643107414246,
0.3452388048171997,
0.622911274433136,
-0.1452094465494156,
-0.28944095969200134,
0.8716904520988464,
-0.05934475362300873,
0.05619946867227554,
0.8602381348609924,
-0.1493203192949295,
-0.10217133164405823,
-0.44402599334716797,
-0.09869077801704407,
-0.08483884483575821,
-0.6294446587562561,
-0.5725551843643188,
-0.8110046982765198,
-0.12367606908082962,
-0.08667830377817154,
0.05149928107857704,
-0.45547038316726685,
-0.2247302383184433,
0.0908900573849678,
0.318661093711853,
0.29538679122924805,
0.641708254814148,
0.06888514012098312,
-0.081724151968956,
-0.74952632188797,
0.4978313148021698,
-0.09365454316139221,
1.0349364280700684,
-0.1224118024110794,
-0.23192434012889862,
-0.4397967457771301,
-0.14796514809131622,
-0.024996699765324593,
-0.33371299505233765,
0.5367646813392639,
0.36119091510772705,
0.648750901222229,
-0.17496517300605774,
0.6354238986968994,
0.7986158728599548,
-0.3700903058052063,
0.5730164051055908,
0.034167565405368805,
-0.6317824721336365,
0.41623520851135254,
0.01679217256605625,
0.08582161366939545,
0.9509779214859009,
0.2586657404899597,
-0.7572718262672424,
-0.2788596749305725,
-0.485749214887619,
-1.1078486442565918,
0.5193895101547241,
0.19412861764431,
0.02092813141644001,
-0.2022244930267334,
0.27167198061943054,
0.5966577529907227,
0.3102186620235443,
-0.3295696973800659,
-0.3903789818286896,
0.22992420196533203,
-0.19131070375442505,
0.3820840120315552,
-0.26127877831459045,
-0.022052820771932602,
0.03033478744328022,
0.3656458258628845,
-0.06565793603658676,
0.8550971150398254,
0.5080375671386719,
-0.5366542339324951,
0.020008040592074394,
0.2951056957244873,
0.18377511203289032,
0.5679323077201843,
-0.5301172137260437,
0.1863144487142563,
-0.19985021650791168,
-0.5754016041755676,
-0.11580207943916321,
0.14725397527217865,
-0.014076344668865204,
-0.06940914690494537,
0.36871522665023804,
0.4158206284046173,
0.010411510244011879,
-0.8453388214111328,
0.3695484697818756,
-0.44517385959625244,
0.05459239333868027,
-0.6580100655555725,
0.3276904821395874,
-0.24417291581630707,
0.4444604218006134,
0.7219200730323792,
0.37728387117385864,
0.5507307052612305,
-0.5462831258773804,
0.5503029227256775,
0.47225889563560486,
-0.44491925835609436,
-0.2142004817724228,
0.687039852142334,
0.07946620881557465,
-0.44752776622772217,
0.5691244602203369,
-0.3578627109527588,
-0.12385096400976181,
0.7583446502685547,
0.36746400594711304,
0.9785311222076416,
0.4043686091899872,
0.0186676774173975,
0.6172521114349365,
-0.040812768042087555,
-0.2649762034416199,
0.634875476360321,
-0.242942214012146,
-0.36344364285469055,
-0.14970973134040833,
-0.5459794998168945,
-0.5800411701202393,
-0.20851828157901764,
-0.973232090473175,
0.28679853677749634,
-0.4325302839279175,
-0.030677905306220055,
-0.25397586822509766,
0.23506055772304535,
-0.8473759889602661,
0.09492715448141098,
0.2998124361038208,
1.396236538887024,
-0.3853950500488281,
0.9521554112434387,
0.7229698896408081,
-0.5988743901252747,
-0.6373217701911926,
0.09962447732686996,
-0.4787393808364868,
-0.5749397873878479,
0.9883309006690979,
0.22958341240882874,
-0.3554559051990509,
-0.03492247313261032,
-0.6177093982696533,
-1.128825068473816,
1.1805435419082642,
0.2720082700252533,
-0.41794243454933167,
0.1008855402469635,
0.17876456677913666,
0.7615833878517151,
-0.5412265658378601,
0.7138606309890747,
0.24165064096450806,
0.4440515637397766,
-0.056244947016239166,
-0.8380023837089539,
-0.04419189691543579,
-0.6572396159172058,
0.02754771150648594,
-0.13350605964660645,
-0.767842173576355,
0.8046654462814331,
-0.25443828105926514,
-0.38675299286842346,
0.4569105803966522,
0.4306887984275818,
0.1678178459405899,
0.513167679309845,
0.22592538595199585,
0.3717154562473297,
0.8790484070777893,
-0.29785165190696716,
1.2207661867141724,
-0.5943116545677185,
0.63108229637146,
1.0999681949615479,
-0.37315890192985535,
1.0934892892837524,
0.49556437134742737,
-0.22951747477054596,
0.768869161605835,
0.3069218099117279,
-0.2681836187839508,
0.8814356923103333,
0.19837051630020142,
0.21064850687980652,
-0.2474740743637085,
-0.2061472088098526,
-0.5266693234443665,
0.4862460196018219,
0.09002427756786346,
-0.14497946202754974,
-0.16140055656433105,
-0.5194715857505798,
-0.3022753894329071,
0.11325555294752121,
0.029743339866399765,
0.5511718392372131,
0.067087821662426,
-0.7887315154075623,
0.6362190842628479,
-0.10117368400096893,
0.696041464805603,
-0.6657595038414001,
-0.31968194246292114,
-0.45974478125572205,
0.5783778429031372,
-0.22055687010288239,
-0.47124525904655457,
0.41288524866104126,
0.005960575304925442,
-0.17345714569091797,
-0.23827356100082397,
0.6077739596366882,
-0.410963773727417,
-0.189200758934021,
0.9111740589141846,
0.33937886357307434,
0.14626513421535492,
0.027644174173474312,
-0.7478931546211243,
0.2166386842727661,
-0.16819798946380615,
0.032787565141916275,
0.22270983457565308,
0.20285344123840332,
0.10100111365318298,
0.7921417355537415,
0.3115590512752533,
-0.102071613073349,
0.0725981593132019,
-0.05423538014292717,
0.7589107751846313,
-0.7942224144935608,
-0.1454731673002243,
-0.6877729296684265,
0.34124523401260376,
-0.0029406999237835407,
-0.10410888493061066,
0.6867628693580627,
1.0548230409622192,
1.0236616134643555,
-0.13407066464424133,
0.812859296798706,
-0.6841739416122437,
0.6835708618164062,
-0.1331963986158371,
0.5687198042869568,
-0.651546061038971,
0.3837583661079407,
-0.3024408221244812,
-0.8107037544250488,
-0.49385738372802734,
0.44515886902809143,
-0.11254946142435074,
0.05169078707695007,
0.7689971327781677,
0.848242998123169,
-0.19814170897006989,
-0.1673729419708252,
0.2985990643501282,
-0.05612039566040039,
0.21732518076896667,
0.3888535797595978,
0.954483687877655,
-0.7439003586769104,
0.7249531149864197,
-0.2521292269229889,
0.07074075937271118,
-0.6390165686607361,
-0.8856697678565979,
-0.6504636406898499,
-0.3874303698539734,
-0.3179642856121063,
-0.13195949792861938,
0.44541603326797485,
1.0780280828475952,
0.7993859052658081,
-1.0962368249893188,
-0.408170610666275,
0.004810107871890068,
0.13550688326358795,
-0.658821702003479,
-0.17418423295021057,
0.176021546125412,
-0.40615519881248474,
-0.6058892011642456,
0.33844584226608276,
0.2992419898509979,
-0.43499624729156494,
0.20253591239452362,
-0.34409835934638977,
-0.30395716428756714,
-0.1528763771057129,
0.33818379044532776,
0.39361509680747986,
-0.3353286683559418,
-0.20457987487316132,
0.5503059029579163,
-0.5578243136405945,
0.2929820418357849,
0.8150891661643982,
-0.9706956148147583,
0.6073402166366577,
0.778304398059845,
0.7132530808448792,
0.1183905303478241,
-0.1460341215133667,
0.6000281572341919,
-0.6814023852348328,
-0.3120807409286499,
0.23096497356891632,
0.2666062116622925,
0.31322237849235535,
-0.3756254017353058,
0.92289799451828,
0.19669178128242493,
-0.4607755243778229,
-0.8858064413070679,
0.01092563197016716,
-1.092176079750061,
-0.027442079037427902,
1.157204031944275,
-0.3419775068759918,
-0.019011305645108223,
-0.24450033903121948,
0.007077361922711134,
0.3129562735557556,
-0.549527645111084,
0.7392578721046448,
0.3666110932826996,
0.052147310227155685,
0.06265241652727127,
-0.527084469795227,
0.2055593878030777,
0.22554895281791687,
-0.5192681550979614,
0.20303615927696228,
0.22588422894477844,
0.23108986020088196,
0.2321576625108719,
0.4615015387535095,
-0.272148072719574,
0.259514719247818,
0.04150811582803726,
0.6639321446418762,
0.01561193261295557,
-0.4461803138256073,
-0.19030055403709412,
0.3202768564224243,
0.24474234879016876,
-0.05507499724626541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02867v1 | Contrast then Memorize: Semantic Neighbor Retrieval-Enhanced Inductive Multimodal Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-07-03T07:31:33 | 2024-07-03T07:31:33 | Yu Zhao, Ying Zhang, Baohang Zhou, Xinying Qian, Kehui Song, Xiangrui Cai | cs.MM | cs.MM, cs.CL | A large number of studies have emerged for Multimodal Knowledge Graph
Completion (MKGC) to predict the missing links in MKGs. However, fewer studies
have been proposed to study the inductive MKGC (IMKGC) involving emerging
entities unseen during training. Existing inductive approaches focus on
learning textual entity representations, which neglect rich semantic
information in visual modality. Moreover, they focus on aggregating structural
neighbors from existing KGs, which of emerging entities are usually limited.
However, the semantic neighbors are decoupled from the topology linkage and
usually imply the true target entity. In this paper, we propose the IMKGC task
and a semantic neighbor retrieval-enhanced IMKGC framework CMR, where the
contrast brings the helpful semantic neighbors close, and then the memorize
supports semantic neighbor retrieval to enhance inference. Specifically, we
first propose a unified cross-modal contrastive learning to simultaneously
capture the textual-visual and textual-textual correlations of query-entity
pairs in a unified representation space. The contrastive learning increases the
similarity of positive query-entity pairs, therefore making the representations
of helpful semantic neighbors close. Then, we explicitly memorize the knowledge
representations to support the semantic neighbor retrieval. At test time, we
retrieve the nearest semantic neighbors and interpolate them to the
query-entity similarity distribution to augment the final prediction. Extensive
experiments validate the effectiveness of CMR on three inductive MKGC datasets.
Codes are available at https://github.com/OreOZhao/CMR. | [
-0.6559392809867859,
-0.6091316938400269,
0.5174813866615295,
-0.2898211181163788,
-0.21920062601566315,
0.2060791701078415,
-0.24507690966129303,
-0.42432937026023865,
0.4560752511024475,
0.370587557554245,
-0.6008666157722473,
-0.6530663371086121,
-0.4527703821659088,
0.07419717311859131,
0.02306821011006832,
0.8184484243392944,
0.0927196815609932,
0.1800098419189453,
-0.6870338916778564,
-0.2792541980743408,
-0.15672609210014343,
-0.07992403209209442,
-0.3860572874546051,
-0.5717077851295471,
0.5657469630241394,
0.5381566882133484,
0.5397125482559204,
0.5785014629364014,
0.32618457078933716,
0.3744991719722748,
-0.06456051021814346,
0.47957274317741394,
-0.4509423077106476,
0.019177889451384544,
-0.1239636242389679,
-0.15292587876319885,
-0.07962639629840851,
-0.08049938082695007,
0.6393118500709534,
0.8293099999427795,
0.28125619888305664,
-0.12304622679948807,
0.20046599209308624,
0.6954824924468994,
-0.7337607145309448,
0.6082881093025208,
-0.872136116027832,
0.21459566056728363,
0.03513748198747635,
-0.21208249032497406,
-0.34972286224365234,
-0.18256475031375885,
0.22523733973503113,
-0.8231431841850281,
0.21418064832687378,
0.10829751938581467,
0.6118090748786926,
0.17898742854595184,
-0.7775770425796509,
-0.25387686491012573,
-0.2873687148094177,
0.4837902784347534,
-0.3614673316478729,
0.66200852394104,
0.4581133723258972,
0.28620439767837524,
-0.14121843874454498,
-0.8738568425178528,
-0.689698338508606,
-0.4002359211444855,
-0.4729267358779907,
0.47043174505233765,
0.09082672744989395,
0.2541005611419678,
0.10725509375333786,
0.4539475739002228,
-0.31135115027427673,
-0.27126553654670715,
-0.42744603753089905,
-0.46108707785606384,
-0.07079654186964035,
0.21864473819732666,
0.0690121203660965,
-0.491821825504303,
-0.6136839985847473,
-0.14533692598342896,
-0.5301609039306641,
-0.03414663299918175,
0.1659584790468216,
0.3294585943222046,
0.14931999146938324,
0.6622375249862671,
-0.57320636510849,
0.38741347193717957,
0.08841949701309204,
-0.40749165415763855,
0.5685692429542542,
-0.6216167211532593,
-0.011797101236879826,
0.10549621284008026,
0.7693971395492554,
0.5328719019889832,
-0.04473019018769264,
-0.39628779888153076,
0.14553077518939972,
-0.12088020890951157,
0.13241080939769745,
-0.7196136116981506,
-0.7189432382583618,
-0.32621243596076965,
-0.677568256855011,
-0.029123978689312935,
0.11299806833267212,
-0.8976832628250122,
-0.1883903294801712,
-0.44446849822998047,
0.5661095380783081,
-0.7825926542282104,
-0.26456156373023987,
-0.4955956041812897,
-0.2181052267551422,
-0.04492533951997757,
0.3566824197769165,
-0.5675647258758545,
0.18601755797863007,
0.38869476318359375,
0.6812012791633606,
0.14454291760921478,
-0.5311567187309265,
-0.45570045709609985,
0.5571269989013672,
0.023691531270742416,
0.5744485259056091,
-0.8124003410339355,
-0.346942663192749,
-0.17010748386383057,
0.22662436962127686,
-0.23429560661315918,
-0.6721214652061462,
0.37774181365966797,
-0.5524073243141174,
0.09756745398044586,
-0.4772956371307373,
-0.5750475525856018,
-0.46680954098701477,
0.6192589998245239,
-0.7469748854637146,
0.8918920159339905,
0.16365055739879608,
-1.1727418899536133,
0.36978545784950256,
-0.19588865339756012,
-0.2875223457813263,
-0.19173723459243774,
-0.19013941287994385,
-0.6534110903739929,
-0.3266267776489258,
0.29590028524398804,
0.5098882913589478,
0.05768826976418495,
-0.34516701102256775,
-0.5499807000160217,
-0.18747778236865997,
-0.08138024061918259,
0.03904057666659355,
0.3180679678916931,
0.2496962547302246,
-0.17176946997642517,
-0.023841718211770058,
-0.7836003303527832,
0.24562352895736694,
-0.10724838823080063,
-0.5017021298408508,
-0.5916078686714172,
-0.23036368191242218,
-0.3260555863380432,
0.246891587972641,
0.09771376103162766,
-0.4920523166656494,
-0.10441116243600845,
0.03485334664583206,
0.120235376060009,
0.5422974228858948,
0.2802443504333496,
0.6936624646186829,
-0.16574208438396454,
0.2790382206439972,
0.40610647201538086,
-0.10000747442245483,
-0.44550225138664246,
-0.2862076163291931,
-0.7370955944061279,
-0.3785596489906311,
0.16242565214633942,
0.25888150930404663,
-1.3723915815353394,
0.008597861975431442,
-0.48111024498939514,
-0.40659767389297485,
-0.4353462755680084,
0.15466055274009705,
0.7814737558364868,
0.833410382270813,
0.6558748483657837,
-0.1922292411327362,
-0.39080679416656494,
-0.7041410803794861,
0.08504757285118103,
-0.11282575130462646,
0.06464820355176926,
0.6337781548500061,
0.4992673099040985,
-0.1498703509569168,
0.6349256634712219,
-0.3365950584411621,
-0.5995494723320007,
-0.011489935219287872,
0.09596232324838638,
-0.3409251570701599,
0.431064248085022,
0.3187728524208069,
-0.953404426574707,
-0.6313494443893433,
0.2850835621356964,
-0.6323535442352295,
0.31437361240386963,
0.189497709274292,
-0.24331530928611755,
-0.1616513431072235,
0.9206914305686951,
-0.5720403790473938,
0.3281031548976898,
0.29555660486221313,
-0.1496969610452652,
0.45756372809410095,
-0.1925404667854309,
0.4777098596096039,
-1.226327896118164,
-0.09932826459407806,
-0.48883649706840515,
-0.15365131199359894,
-0.19697357714176178,
0.032937485724687576,
0.22743463516235352,
0.03379509970545769,
0.08289343863725662,
0.3004154860973358,
-0.6976382732391357,
0.012936143204569817,
-0.035425033420324326,
0.32420772314071655,
0.0011470738099887967,
0.6698088049888611,
-0.15933962166309357,
0.619724690914154,
0.19640661776065826,
-0.8019669651985168,
0.2101464718580246,
0.30495911836624146,
-0.25170189142227173,
0.63103187084198,
-0.16208279132843018,
-0.052558086812496185,
-0.33776339888572693,
0.09191720932722092,
-0.9944190382957458,
-0.2896139323711395,
0.23956245183944702,
-0.7426047325134277,
0.5467457175254822,
-0.3855719268321991,
-0.5864039063453674,
-0.27633631229400635,
-0.2700170576572418,
0.38370266556739807,
0.1918799877166748,
-0.7777462005615234,
0.8965098857879639,
0.19703613221645355,
0.20453450083732605,
-0.6815446615219116,
-0.5073031783103943,
-0.11236225813627243,
-0.01596229337155819,
-0.3778400123119354,
0.4199751913547516,
0.027530469000339508,
-0.010782390832901001,
0.46031323075294495,
-0.023841917514801025,
0.05612322315573692,
-0.16427749395370483,
0.3799203336238861,
-0.06325264275074005,
-0.18492558598518372,
0.4822850525379181,
0.01909610815346241,
-0.20854416489601135,
-0.026268715038895607,
-0.40848982334136963,
0.4100327491760254,
-0.12011956423521042,
-0.4748417139053345,
-0.03688781335949898,
0.23668807744979858,
0.374783456325531,
-0.4329233169555664,
0.635543942451477,
0.9019482731819153,
-0.14195965230464935,
0.18942247331142426,
-0.7050129771232605,
-0.2131129503250122,
-0.4465770125389099,
0.4893130958080292,
-0.6009178161621094,
-0.9344432950019836,
0.5661216974258423,
-0.4530876576900482,
-0.45297399163246155,
0.22582696378231049,
0.22278235852718353,
-0.055424414575099945,
0.5903072953224182,
0.5521944165229797,
0.07800368219614029,
0.5121151208877563,
-0.34664615988731384,
0.03851919621229172,
-1.0446292161941528,
-0.9011118412017822,
-0.2655676305294037,
-0.11157803237438202,
-0.6569181084632874,
-0.5395227074623108,
0.593744695186615,
0.33990323543548584,
-0.021367577835917473,
0.3634358048439026,
-0.2665635645389557,
0.664408802986145,
0.6996971368789673,
0.5287972092628479,
0.5789333581924438,
0.14030155539512634,
-0.9586247205734253,
-0.29484298825263977,
-0.5252255201339722,
0.13637295365333557,
0.9370688796043396,
-0.2013227641582489,
0.6527674794197083,
-0.017599085345864296,
0.9024874567985535,
-0.030464716255664825,
0.109797902405262,
-0.7100399136543274,
0.551561713218689,
0.06277477741241455,
-0.10700694471597672,
-0.12761513888835907,
-0.6879055500030518,
-0.7528195381164551,
0.4141553044319153,
-0.433890700340271,
-0.4734611511230469,
0.032784927636384964,
0.12662163376808167,
0.21434223651885986,
0.5633648633956909,
-0.6483922004699707,
0.7573419809341431,
0.4153657853603363,
-0.2793866693973541,
-0.4024897515773773,
-0.9607025384902954,
0.3803640902042389,
0.20042817294597626,
-0.048646230250597,
-0.004817418288439512,
-0.007595937233418226,
0.3256191611289978,
-0.416282594203949,
0.573567807674408,
-0.0744655653834343,
0.490677148103714,
0.42648637294769287,
0.18110276758670807,
0.6312380433082581,
-0.1267082840204239,
0.028062399476766586,
-0.2767598032951355,
-0.3063066899776459,
-0.4008135199546814,
-0.6499829292297363,
0.7342953085899353,
-0.5108423233032227,
-0.18365685641765594,
0.06353206932544708,
-0.5673741102218628,
-0.15672804415225983,
0.35001859068870544,
0.25960245728492737,
0.38860881328582764,
-0.21337951719760895,
0.2569807469844818,
0.8799666166305542,
0.08141028136014938,
0.43863633275032043,
0.30528873205184937,
-0.13791319727897644,
-0.9924228191375732,
0.949843168258667,
-0.01611652597784996,
0.545224666595459,
0.7018514275550842,
-0.08538999408483505,
-0.2992810904979706,
-0.4083448052406311,
-0.21946264803409576,
0.2783307135105133,
-1.1659209728240967,
-0.3825012147426605,
-1.2265841960906982,
-0.125049889087677,
-0.41996854543685913,
-0.011492312885820866,
-0.23673638701438904,
-0.28664183616638184,
-0.1632179617881775,
-0.14393913745880127,
0.408294141292572,
0.6228244304656982,
-0.21363337337970734,
-0.001645870739594102,
-0.654890239238739,
0.11386381089687347,
0.44245263934135437,
0.2128165364265442,
0.40232324600219727,
-0.11677394062280655,
-0.27310338616371155,
-0.18337306380271912,
-0.21337758004665375,
-0.5389730334281921,
0.04055279120802879,
0.2746428847312927,
0.7596444487571716,
0.5517004728317261,
0.28112074732780457,
0.8956087231636047,
-0.3740977644920349,
0.2920680642127991,
0.3917478621006012,
-0.5608698129653931,
0.3412526249885559,
-0.24067886173725128,
0.3980010449886322,
0.8198270201683044,
0.5912110209465027,
-0.3473670482635498,
-0.4357561469078064,
-0.49150750041007996,
-0.7542814612388611,
0.321618914604187,
0.13266229629516602,
0.05164380371570587,
-0.31936439871788025,
0.2698422968387604,
0.03870434686541557,
0.1732996553182602,
-0.8394333124160767,
-0.3425055146217346,
-0.3121494650840759,
-0.15191738307476044,
0.19719794392585754,
-0.2288602888584137,
0.08801290392875671,
-0.23153884708881378,
0.5699301362037659,
-0.4031356871128082,
0.39116427302360535,
0.29528841376304626,
-0.1822405457496643,
0.14998658001422882,
0.1804499477148056,
0.027944881469011307,
0.4687892198562622,
-0.20339317619800568,
0.5354086756706238,
0.39014866948127747,
-0.4676349461078644,
-0.16278591752052307,
0.17512372136116028,
-0.12947221100330353,
0.06537365913391113,
0.3832707703113556,
0.2647441327571869,
0.5553443431854248,
-0.3876243233680725,
0.6412305235862732,
0.1580052226781845,
-0.09113224595785141,
-0.2684912383556366,
-0.13550013303756714,
0.3388032019138336,
0.5770173072814941,
0.095631904900074,
0.0013388886582106352,
0.26746508479118347,
-0.5418574810028076,
0.5033174157142639,
0.6191917061805725,
-0.7272757291793823,
0.04703155905008316,
0.6398282051086426,
-0.08830581605434418,
0.3137799799442291,
0.8641332983970642,
-0.5768576860427856,
-0.8269088864326477,
0.581080973148346,
0.5282343626022339,
0.5603195428848267,
0.052617594599723816,
0.13549503684043884,
0.8514821529388428,
0.15445385873317719,
0.3892655372619629,
0.008637439459562302,
-0.6205276250839233,
-0.5027850270271301,
-0.17682808637619019,
-0.33634307980537415,
-0.21564851701259613,
-0.3373846411705017,
-0.6536391377449036,
0.21721534430980682,
-0.3228330612182617,
0.03924930468201637,
-0.1537942737340927,
0.1273142397403717,
-0.6053699254989624,
0.14623841643333435,
-0.15769755840301514,
0.6194279789924622,
-0.447307825088501,
0.9476377367973328,
0.5579200983047485,
-0.6958511471748352,
-0.7176095247268677,
0.14681224524974823,
0.09919581562280655,
-0.8208267092704773,
0.6406548023223877,
0.31235650181770325,
-0.26360252499580383,
-0.04702471196651459,
-0.246195986866951,
-0.7506029605865479,
1.6709009408950806,
0.007569131441414356,
-0.026048606261610985,
0.04498982056975365,
0.008393803611397743,
0.27235379815101624,
-0.4731188118457794,
0.4618333578109741,
0.042925190180540085,
0.21462343633174896,
0.6463728547096252,
-0.7012881636619568,
0.2804926633834839,
-0.16882431507110596,
-0.0031952718272805214,
0.5041146278381348,
-0.8259390592575073,
0.8673957586288452,
-0.7428792119026184,
-0.07783450931310654,
0.20834478735923767,
0.7913786172866821,
0.10017632693052292,
0.5916097164154053,
0.4466259181499481,
0.8701140284538269,
0.6950279474258423,
0.027709506452083588,
0.6501455307006836,
-0.11734610050916672,
0.32029494643211365,
1.411935567855835,
0.2179146260023117,
0.6180580854415894,
0.471076637506485,
-0.007304493337869644,
0.5069288611412048,
0.4010278284549713,
-0.023238813504576683,
0.8956742882728577,
-0.2308264523744583,
-0.5277873873710632,
-0.3178654909133911,
-0.49826493859291077,
-0.5377534627914429,
0.29311618208885193,
0.21933485567569733,
-0.6346604228019714,
-0.5234338045120239,
0.010938283987343311,
0.22329752147197723,
0.1420200765132904,
-0.4692373275756836,
1.0096184015274048,
0.03460698574781418,
-0.4331958591938019,
0.10085052996873856,
-0.38730862736701965,
0.3689256012439728,
-0.6960522532463074,
-0.3814030885696411,
-0.12545500695705414,
0.2417251169681549,
-0.16627876460552216,
-0.49626627564430237,
0.0732080340385437,
-0.8321234583854675,
-0.35971811413764954,
0.19159631431102753,
0.7138429284095764,
-0.891399621963501,
-0.1741858273744583,
0.6847421526908875,
0.3304691016674042,
0.06255188584327698,
-0.04492483288049698,
-0.44429755210876465,
-0.49582308530807495,
0.04890357702970505,
0.13352620601654053,
0.49116355180740356,
0.8128504157066345,
0.17595914006233215,
0.7933689951896667,
0.4508958160877228,
-0.44233259558677673,
0.25960224866867065,
-0.09391290694475174,
1.2060420513153076,
-0.6187065243721008,
-0.3214728534221649,
-0.6466880440711975,
0.299523264169693,
-0.1333046853542328,
0.00235976604744792,
0.887919008731842,
0.7468085885047913,
1.2759591341018677,
-0.04123101383447647,
0.3751794397830963,
-0.13582022488117218,
0.4725528061389923,
-0.8598835468292236,
0.6156653761863708,
-0.5946834683418274,
-0.015500514768064022,
-0.49677586555480957,
-0.8648554086685181,
-0.014431972987949848,
0.20365551114082336,
0.046240828931331635,
0.11528926342725754,
0.9060795307159424,
0.9839447140693665,
-0.35307198762893677,
-0.19491350650787354,
0.42111700773239136,
0.049964893609285355,
-0.017870869487524033,
0.6577597856521606,
0.86299067735672,
-0.46900567412376404,
1.1208407878875732,
-0.6891342997550964,
0.14865650236606598,
-0.03842669352889061,
-0.7723085284233093,
-1.1150104999542236,
-0.8078072667121887,
-0.24956946074962616,
-0.6761577725410461,
-0.15586546063423157,
0.9354198575019836,
0.5510873794555664,
-0.5649920105934143,
0.3808498978614807,
0.08195309340953827,
0.3465120792388916,
-0.08032553642988205,
-0.2502301335334778,
0.5299097299575806,
-0.5012200474739075,
-0.6057754755020142,
0.19072075188159943,
0.27412721514701843,
0.3316740393638611,
0.06445745378732681,
-0.22212393581867218,
-0.257291704416275,
-0.4909995198249817,
0.513927161693573,
0.03561997786164284,
-0.6934553980827332,
-0.18870313465595245,
-0.1424373984336853,
-0.06410061568021774,
0.18364934623241425,
0.9992265701293945,
-1.057673692703247,
0.9191464781761169,
0.44762006402015686,
0.7264381647109985,
0.6858426928520203,
-0.16217297315597534,
0.11054319143295288,
-0.7008322477340698,
0.08146274089813232,
0.07444549351930618,
0.42149537801742554,
0.4375990033149719,
-0.2954632043838501,
0.6821149587631226,
0.3959956467151642,
-0.39319178462028503,
-0.1868310421705246,
0.2587805688381195,
-0.8711025714874268,
-0.19324524700641632,
0.795120894908905,
-0.44310301542282104,
-0.04827141389250755,
-0.19184169173240662,
-0.016009310260415077,
0.30740636587142944,
-0.31378573179244995,
0.6484731435775757,
0.5460931658744812,
0.016768861562013626,
-0.37644147872924805,
-0.33526942133903503,
0.3904198110103607,
0.1761198341846466,
-0.5592268705368042,
-0.1933170109987259,
0.5050133466720581,
0.3831583261489868,
0.24713094532489777,
0.6551717519760132,
-0.32125750184059143,
0.24200820922851562,
0.35302045941352844,
-0.07594500482082367,
-0.4424724280834198,
-0.31304365396499634,
0.1513085961341858,
0.0851563960313797,
-0.07746061682701111,
-0.24652503430843353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02855v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02855v1 | Safe Unlearning: A Surprisingly Effective and Generalizable Solution to Defend Against Jailbreak Attacks | 2024-07-03T07:14:05 | 2024-07-03T07:14:05 | Zhexin Zhang, Junxiao Yang, Pei Ke, Shiyao Cui, Chujie Zheng, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | LLMs are known to be vulnerable to jailbreak attacks, even after safety
alignment. An important observation is that, while different types of jailbreak
attacks can generate significantly different queries, they mostly result in
similar responses that are rooted in the same harmful knowledge (e.g., detailed
steps to make a bomb). Therefore, we conjecture that directly unlearn the
harmful knowledge in the LLM can be a more effective way to defend against
jailbreak attacks than the mainstream supervised fine-tuning (SFT) based
approaches. Our extensive experiments confirmed our insight and suggested
surprising generalizability of our unlearning-based approach: using only 20 raw
harmful questions \emph{without} any jailbreak prompt during training, our
solution reduced the Attack Success Rate (ASR) in Vicuna-7B on
\emph{out-of-distribution} (OOD) harmful questions wrapped with various complex
jailbreak prompts from 82.6\% to 7.7\%. This significantly outperforms
Llama2-7B-Chat, which is fine-tuned on about 0.1M safety alignment samples but
still has an ASR of 21.9\% even under the help of an additional safety system
prompt. Further analysis reveals that the generalization ability of our
solution stems from the intrinsic relatedness among harmful responses across
harmful questions (e.g., response patterns, shared steps and actions, and
similarity among their learned representations in the LLM). Our code is
available at \url{https://github.com/thu-coai/SafeUnlearning}. | [
-0.20011045038700104,
-0.9468008875846863,
0.37528130412101746,
0.028214257210493088,
-0.2915819585323334,
0.40782439708709717,
-0.15505389869213104,
-0.4527272582054138,
-0.0418543815612793,
0.5255032181739807,
-0.507936418056488,
-0.6375553011894226,
-0.3366909623146057,
-0.4125782549381256,
-0.24596697092056274,
1.1648467779159546,
0.28366249799728394,
-0.009191980585455894,
0.19896246492862701,
-0.1688152253627777,
-0.7952118515968323,
-0.41320544481277466,
-0.5731372237205505,
0.012910950928926468,
0.3942877948284149,
0.5694180727005005,
0.26999276876449585,
0.5078112483024597,
0.6803733110427856,
0.2196195423603058,
-0.2768062949180603,
0.15838682651519775,
-0.6401228308677673,
0.4064262807369232,
-0.24032281339168549,
-0.5227612257003784,
-0.16319774091243744,
-0.09136178344488144,
-0.02867920510470867,
0.35426920652389526,
-0.39229464530944824,
-0.005994606763124466,
0.17564187943935394,
1.0037891864776611,
-0.786987841129303,
-0.3209363520145416,
-0.983154833316803,
0.055477600544691086,
-0.08987602591514587,
-0.10322441160678864,
-0.5780889987945557,
-0.2851509153842926,
-0.2536699175834656,
-0.37112513184547424,
0.10282713919878006,
0.1352369636297226,
0.3983228802680969,
0.3711995780467987,
-0.41477441787719727,
-0.21334244310855865,
-0.6079321503639221,
0.5583269000053406,
-0.4557582139968872,
0.1623997837305069,
0.27158018946647644,
0.4625977575778961,
-0.5518704056739807,
-0.35341185331344604,
0.06460420042276382,
-0.13171882927417755,
0.2996416687965393,
0.23999939858913422,
-0.4015534818172455,
0.3353211581707001,
0.2739782929420471,
0.01930120587348938,
-0.43971312046051025,
0.3440555930137634,
-0.5746877193450928,
-0.33405405282974243,
0.6886163949966431,
0.1172248125076294,
0.3538573384284973,
-0.04035930335521698,
-0.5819504261016846,
0.12239771336317062,
-1.0813159942626953,
0.33734846115112305,
0.5326720476150513,
0.1539926528930664,
-0.11268804222345352,
0.4025649130344391,
-0.11811746656894684,
0.45066356658935547,
0.13398325443267822,
-0.12055110186338425,
0.05255957692861557,
-0.17416413128376007,
-0.05166902020573616,
0.11870463937520981,
0.9684069752693176,
0.6904534697532654,
0.4401646554470062,
-0.5132929086685181,
0.13064712285995483,
-0.15480875968933105,
0.696056067943573,
-0.6835988759994507,
-0.31419798731803894,
0.2404540479183197,
-0.27230706810951233,
-0.698695182800293,
0.304628849029541,
-0.7931177616119385,
-0.6688457727432251,
0.3768727481365204,
0.18723340332508087,
-0.46794307231903076,
-0.026203997433185577,
-0.043102189898490906,
-0.0032577328383922577,
-0.009444262832403183,
0.04871698096394539,
-0.9021101593971252,
0.14502204954624176,
0.640393078327179,
0.7312968969345093,
-0.18053457140922546,
-0.0052918135188519955,
-0.5708939433097839,
0.2901429831981659,
-0.3600289523601532,
0.6096646785736084,
-0.08108003437519073,
-0.4731172025203705,
-0.3628169298171997,
-0.16397766768932343,
-0.052872952073812485,
-0.718594491481781,
0.4305882751941681,
-0.5078359842300415,
-0.21235543489456177,
-0.04587386175990105,
-0.48477527499198914,
-0.09616080671548843,
0.2786627411842346,
-0.43098244071006775,
0.4933565855026245,
-0.37101972103118896,
-0.8368073105812073,
0.18675579130649567,
-0.552788496017456,
-0.3758407533168793,
-0.3070227801799774,
0.10392764210700989,
-0.5279544591903687,
0.13898418843746185,
0.21734733879566193,
0.3676565885543823,
-0.004238220397382975,
0.4179985821247101,
-0.6173233985900879,
-0.5106387734413147,
0.29027462005615234,
-0.3865360617637634,
0.82871013879776,
0.5457627177238464,
-0.5859535932540894,
0.24232815206050873,
-0.6397395133972168,
0.1027686670422554,
0.10899952799081802,
-0.3994569480419159,
-0.6641920804977417,
0.029623324051499367,
-0.5752504467964172,
-0.030175291001796722,
0.1053561419248581,
-0.7671803832054138,
0.08249037712812424,
-0.3664742112159729,
0.48322027921676636,
0.8432250618934631,
0.3118879795074463,
0.4601295590400696,
-0.2185717523097992,
0.23286199569702148,
0.09524461627006531,
0.519925594329834,
-0.0185561366379261,
-0.5737372636795044,
-0.2772209644317627,
-0.08722742646932602,
-0.09761958569288254,
0.9208878874778748,
-0.23040728271007538,
0.4229077398777008,
0.260606050491333,
-0.5897294282913208,
-0.40931451320648193,
0.5511997938156128,
0.8889409303665161,
0.7561375498771667,
0.5860475301742554,
-0.36895403265953064,
-0.689582884311676,
-0.6527866125106812,
-0.5505873560905457,
-0.3633229732513428,
0.1876615434885025,
-0.03659325838088989,
0.20705854892730713,
-0.35459190607070923,
0.6636158227920532,
-0.548814058303833,
-0.15189020335674286,
-0.24205774068832397,
-0.13265834748744965,
0.05747763067483902,
0.5890287756919861,
0.47489553689956665,
-0.5686116814613342,
-0.286140114068985,
-0.1390874683856964,
-0.9526026844978333,
-0.06737324595451355,
-0.03694131225347519,
-0.18288643658161163,
0.0557716079056263,
0.7305853366851807,
-0.46724897623062134,
0.5321388840675354,
0.05645236372947693,
-0.3501553535461426,
0.4939315617084503,
-0.2095392495393753,
-0.07186297327280045,
-1.2000043392181396,
-0.19830454885959625,
-0.2841813862323761,
-0.0409676693379879,
-0.8176093697547913,
0.3875267505645752,
0.2691875100135803,
0.11418302357196808,
-0.6932418942451477,
0.1420838087797165,
-0.24212825298309326,
0.3134988248348236,
-0.19559542834758759,
-0.0964360386133194,
-0.3449495732784271,
0.30329951643943787,
-0.5029852986335754,
0.8897762298583984,
0.40658828616142273,
-0.4569375514984131,
0.3621489405632019,
0.21215492486953735,
-0.2836057245731354,
0.2370995432138443,
-0.7329630851745605,
0.26586243510246277,
-0.18906690180301666,
-0.10952451825141907,
-0.9021132588386536,
0.008194566704332829,
0.3647332787513733,
-0.33436042070388794,
0.18762017786502838,
-0.40423741936683655,
-0.10505951941013336,
-0.3610040545463562,
-0.7156603336334229,
0.10390596091747284,
0.6905749440193176,
-0.576132595539093,
0.04989626631140709,
0.4326828122138977,
0.03179164603352547,
-1.0644803047180176,
-0.47399863600730896,
-0.06072649732232094,
-0.6928353905677795,
-0.518132209777832,
-0.004460213705897331,
-0.3704794645309448,
-0.4451141655445099,
-0.21602337062358856,
-0.4783772826194763,
0.004706396721303463,
0.677173376083374,
0.7113010883331299,
0.3475306034088135,
0.12529495358467102,
-0.08628777414560318,
0.1874430924654007,
-0.18424630165100098,
0.3398991823196411,
-0.11119604110717773,
0.5128286480903625,
-0.2604195475578308,
-0.5053099393844604,
-0.1675245463848114,
0.22518563270568848,
0.46953901648521423,
0.05216630548238754,
0.8094882965087891,
0.34087151288986206,
-0.12099578976631165,
0.02354525215923786,
-0.6028113961219788,
-0.06707234680652618,
-0.5268911719322205,
0.16885517537593842,
0.05095602199435234,
-1.0164116621017456,
0.5583587884902954,
-0.13612248003482819,
0.1446104794740677,
0.005656138993799686,
0.23514795303344727,
-0.49722665548324585,
0.8679040670394897,
0.6574283242225647,
-0.49980631470680237,
0.4283405542373657,
-0.10127603262662888,
0.26171520352363586,
-0.649757444858551,
-0.669868528842926,
-0.21889303624629974,
-0.31376194953918457,
-0.6499336957931519,
-0.005391877610236406,
0.22388628125190735,
0.6032159328460693,
-0.6390835046768188,
0.44848307967185974,
-0.5032039284706116,
0.7751794457435608,
0.5195104479789734,
0.40630021691322327,
0.4514082670211792,
0.049142081290483475,
-0.3394441306591034,
0.07925813645124435,
-0.26312556862831116,
-0.4452849328517914,
1.4665902853012085,
0.2529711425304413,
1.0125300884246826,
0.2939184606075287,
1.2521541118621826,
0.22049632668495178,
0.2649933695793152,
-0.49647265672683716,
0.5535270571708679,
-0.05835395306348801,
-0.6486719846725464,
-0.13411253690719604,
-0.5650664567947388,
-0.9457800388336182,
0.14795736968517303,
-0.13451458513736725,
-1.1618677377700806,
-0.18999841809272766,
0.15767347812652588,
-0.46092185378074646,
0.645346999168396,
-0.9464111924171448,
0.6116629838943481,
-0.44651615619659424,
-0.32609736919403076,
-0.1638696789741516,
-0.9613877534866333,
0.6477429270744324,
-0.362667053937912,
0.36259815096855164,
-0.20856241881847382,
0.20770174264907837,
0.8912867307662964,
-0.4584265351295471,
0.9997155666351318,
-0.4280208945274353,
0.09010104835033417,
0.42483073472976685,
0.0318501852452755,
0.2852729856967926,
0.3289690613746643,
0.1188882365822792,
-0.18284672498703003,
-0.26183757185935974,
-0.2037142962217331,
-0.521918773651123,
0.6635357141494751,
-0.8442007899284363,
-0.9435274004936218,
-0.05179567262530327,
-0.6403221487998962,
-0.23265324532985687,
0.28362253308296204,
0.4712430536746979,
-0.034431684762239456,
-0.18673603236675262,
0.13760265707969666,
1.0826966762542725,
-0.2207493633031845,
0.5302966833114624,
0.5089277625083923,
-0.13105128705501556,
-0.45860666036605835,
0.7267134785652161,
-0.08910813927650452,
0.20827186107635498,
0.2811982035636902,
0.21878983080387115,
-0.17327162623405457,
-0.8717907667160034,
-0.25350239872932434,
0.04042188823223114,
-0.4609719514846802,
-0.6183615922927856,
-0.5706401467323303,
-0.22303767502307892,
-0.28183242678642273,
-0.18320514261722565,
-0.26549267768859863,
-0.37788572907447815,
-0.05141567066311836,
-0.6575387120246887,
0.5829198956489563,
0.7337902784347534,
-0.42956575751304626,
0.31815505027770996,
-0.9324162006378174,
0.3317817747592926,
0.323419451713562,
0.1978965401649475,
-0.06985747069120407,
-0.3470323383808136,
0.03389022499322891,
0.2096157670021057,
-0.6627918481826782,
-1.063558578491211,
0.14301632344722748,
0.011996731162071228,
0.6836167573928833,
0.8380498886108398,
0.49759984016418457,
0.7032325267791748,
-0.3891739249229431,
0.3382246494293213,
0.493204802274704,
-0.5558027029037476,
0.8511810302734375,
-0.3854081928730011,
-0.2688343822956085,
1.062696099281311,
0.37479883432388306,
-0.16780847311019897,
-0.616472601890564,
-0.6620964407920837,
-1.0118290185928345,
0.21614420413970947,
-0.08653102815151215,
0.1838866025209427,
-0.013030997477471828,
0.3472936153411865,
0.08631882816553116,
0.24349801242351532,
-0.6154453754425049,
-0.3671289086341858,
-0.15890927612781525,
-0.11688287556171417,
0.07927652448415756,
-0.30345290899276733,
-0.2903597950935364,
-0.33593499660491943,
0.43569067120552063,
0.27252572774887085,
0.171970397233963,
-0.2662368416786194,
-0.23046919703483582,
0.034295279532670975,
0.6512050032615662,
0.2998522222042084,
0.09202440083026886,
-0.5001339912414551,
0.30474454164505005,
0.33954134583473206,
-0.8330113887786865,
0.6198104619979858,
-0.07578650861978531,
-0.24707455933094025,
-0.645301878452301,
0.14222928881645203,
0.4250834882259369,
0.20904213190078735,
-0.767275869846344,
0.4135623276233673,
-0.017650283873081207,
-0.11543819308280945,
-0.10732907801866531,
0.62577885389328,
0.09707725048065186,
0.20413461327552795,
0.2923544645309448,
0.24175553023815155,
0.0037571731954813004,
-0.6204198598861694,
0.3514140248298645,
0.5297200083732605,
-0.5630692839622498,
-0.16315153241157532,
0.8596426844596863,
0.1363120973110199,
-0.18556727468967438,
0.7658836245536804,
-0.1925429403781891,
-0.48401495814323425,
0.6051347255706787,
0.8113066554069519,
0.6823214888572693,
-0.2842630445957184,
0.19431640207767487,
0.16822203993797302,
0.5249516367912292,
-0.06587392091751099,
0.2534092366695404,
-0.04180123284459114,
-0.744342029094696,
-0.06718361377716064,
-0.26144668459892273,
-0.41273725032806396,
0.13207560777664185,
-0.8875635862350464,
-0.27062392234802246,
-0.9049267768859863,
0.024754492565989494,
-0.4750761389732361,
-0.12229791283607483,
-0.17750734090805054,
0.03407160937786102,
-0.16692009568214417,
0.9986072778701782,
-0.8110886812210083,
0.6612681150436401,
0.7645943760871887,
-0.32406577467918396,
-0.9310256838798523,
-0.1350061446428299,
0.35839971899986267,
-0.8634728789329529,
0.3045136332511902,
0.4226314127445221,
-0.11861124634742737,
-0.3377016484737396,
-0.6420021057128906,
-0.6107184290885925,
1.0420504808425903,
0.4352245628833771,
-0.8045408129692078,
0.05613790452480316,
0.16382989287376404,
0.3584586977958679,
-0.0106048583984375,
-0.03020443394780159,
0.6578730344772339,
0.16145935654640198,
-0.09308990836143494,
-0.5137887001037598,
0.20978297293186188,
-0.39785036444664,
-0.3696180284023285,
0.4526447653770447,
-0.442627876996994,
0.35658714175224304,
-0.97403484582901,
-0.006749696563929319,
0.1427438110113144,
0.42495667934417725,
0.46020686626434326,
0.6275799870491028,
0.337588906288147,
0.8029051423072815,
0.9667834043502808,
-0.05166942626237869,
0.5664505958557129,
-0.1900613009929657,
0.10101579129695892,
0.9664134383201599,
0.012087914161384106,
0.6987597942352295,
0.5304284691810608,
0.2016245424747467,
0.341585636138916,
0.419985294342041,
0.055348437279462814,
1.0542702674865723,
0.3232581615447998,
-0.3038862347602844,
-0.16022828221321106,
0.23466654121875763,
-0.3798215091228485,
0.2125951498746872,
0.2845609784126282,
-0.06625582277774811,
-0.3664052188396454,
0.24461622536182404,
0.3838244676589966,
0.11891555786132812,
-0.39594146609306335,
0.9677556157112122,
0.19045935571193695,
-0.31653639674186707,
0.4791260063648224,
-0.10715442895889282,
1.0302777290344238,
-0.5568932890892029,
0.355257123708725,
-0.38257279992103577,
0.2793676555156708,
-0.42669105529785156,
-0.8555819392204285,
0.4190380573272705,
0.40347030758857727,
-0.03975467011332512,
0.10835212469100952,
0.9063465595245361,
-0.094390369951725,
0.05048958957195282,
0.5023748874664307,
0.4650532901287079,
0.09481579065322876,
0.0002945468295365572,
-0.5270926356315613,
-0.26078441739082336,
0.27992114424705505,
-0.18735434114933014,
0.7323727607727051,
-0.0019624619744718075,
-0.19062484800815582,
0.9615645408630371,
0.7333776950836182,
-0.06442515552043915,
0.32456764578819275,
-0.13074524700641632,
0.9961587190628052,
-0.6705715656280518,
-0.39597269892692566,
-0.9853551983833313,
0.5453243255615234,
-0.18991148471832275,
-0.09040315449237823,
0.7809637188911438,
0.4420556128025055,
0.8170703053474426,
0.07199840992689133,
0.7960678935050964,
0.0611574724316597,
0.3276476562023163,
-0.551227331161499,
1.0551525354385376,
-0.13381299376487732,
0.642874538898468,
-0.45426833629608154,
-0.7246268391609192,
-0.384689062833786,
0.4935891628265381,
-0.37581631541252136,
-0.21786583960056305,
0.5136253237724304,
0.8011837005615234,
0.11741767823696136,
0.12075620144605637,
0.2492353916168213,
0.005399765446782112,
0.4793001413345337,
0.6989684104919434,
1.0116467475891113,
-0.19877301156520844,
0.9125637412071228,
-0.44861099123954773,
-0.23745612800121307,
0.03982296213507652,
-0.7405783534049988,
-1.0888030529022217,
-0.10167934745550156,
-0.0364207997918129,
-0.28785017132759094,
0.6464072465896606,
0.6621052026748657,
0.2500106692314148,
-0.8524144291877747,
0.01607021875679493,
-0.252370148897171,
0.26156875491142273,
-0.0936620905995369,
-0.13704732060432434,
0.050395667552948,
-0.3111300468444824,
0.11433059722185135,
0.8317228555679321,
0.0665111243724823,
0.14981791377067566,
0.44849562644958496,
-0.09208323061466217,
0.12663237750530243,
-0.17192807793617249,
0.3429707884788513,
0.6310537457466125,
-0.29203879833221436,
-0.4600074887275696,
-0.013791405595839024,
-0.06632586568593979,
-0.038711853325366974,
0.6538247466087341,
-0.6062155961990356,
0.23280635476112366,
0.16540783643722534,
0.7006063461303711,
0.15940293669700623,
0.12047860026359558,
0.27838945388793945,
-0.7789526581764221,
0.21449224650859833,
-0.11173157393932343,
0.4551728367805481,
0.06982587277889252,
-0.463456392288208,
0.6226259469985962,
0.08815857023000717,
-0.4910982847213745,
-0.8970200419425964,
0.47486382722854614,
-0.883303701877594,
-0.43808478116989136,
0.9023966789245605,
-0.2499486804008484,
-0.1286492943763733,
-0.42838725447654724,
-0.27708154916763306,
0.3266628682613373,
-0.5967243313789368,
1.0167065858840942,
-0.020696543157100677,
-0.1553744673728943,
0.04243858531117439,
-0.31765004992485046,
0.25614291429519653,
0.29497426748275757,
-0.8960759043693542,
0.19780795276165009,
0.1834191083908081,
0.7334238290786743,
0.14148737490177155,
0.4357737898826599,
-0.2392231673002243,
0.45365530252456665,
-0.40345901250839233,
-0.20226505398750305,
-0.5714643001556396,
-0.6032308340072632,
-0.24832355976104736,
0.30369603633880615,
0.11019354313611984,
-0.40020325779914856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02854v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02854v1 | Universal Gloss-level Representation for Gloss-free Sign Language Translation and Production | 2024-07-03T07:12:36 | 2024-07-03T07:12:36 | Eui Jun Hwang, Sukmin Cho, Huije Lee, Youngwoo Yoon, Jong C. Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Sign language, essential for the deaf and hard-of-hearing, presents unique
challenges in translation and production due to its multimodal nature and the
inherent ambiguity in mapping sign language motion to spoken language words.
Previous methods often rely on gloss annotations, requiring time-intensive
labor and specialized expertise in sign language. Gloss-free methods have
emerged to address these limitations, but they often depend on external sign
language data or dictionaries, failing to completely eliminate the need for
gloss annotations. There is a clear demand for a comprehensive approach that
can supplant gloss annotations and be utilized for both Sign Language
Translation (SLT) and Sign Language Production (SLP). We introduce Universal
Gloss-level Representation (UniGloR), a unified and self-supervised solution
for both SLT and SLP, trained on multiple datasets including PHOENIX14T,
How2Sign, and NIASL2021. Our results demonstrate UniGloR's effectiveness in the
translation and production tasks. We further report an encouraging result for
the Sign Language Recognition (SLR) on previously unseen data. Our study
suggests that self-supervised learning can be made in a unified manner, paving
the way for innovative and practical applications in future research. | [
-0.047278597950935364,
0.1690005362033844,
0.4200117588043213,
0.3735046684741974,
-0.3364892899990082,
0.056770291179418564,
-0.0541103258728981,
-0.6774886846542358,
0.1831309050321579,
0.617220938205719,
-0.32063406705856323,
-0.7816374897956848,
-0.6475896239280701,
-0.16081996262073517,
-0.4256429076194763,
1.0185604095458984,
-0.04962896183133125,
0.1216372400522232,
0.21283406019210815,
-0.24102307856082916,
-0.09923715889453888,
-0.581992506980896,
-0.5232462286949158,
-0.4252762496471405,
0.17714622616767883,
0.34288808703422546,
0.5954705476760864,
0.2822706401348114,
0.40466710925102234,
0.23609890043735504,
0.06311999261379242,
0.10562016814947128,
-0.03421469405293465,
0.21627554297447205,
0.013823628425598145,
0.28742027282714844,
-0.6876081228256226,
0.11490654200315475,
0.6261042356491089,
1.1020138263702393,
-0.1611999273300171,
0.13622045516967773,
-0.014818967320024967,
0.5758511424064636,
-0.47305336594581604,
0.2810192406177521,
-0.4764564037322998,
0.2943868041038513,
-0.44110846519470215,
0.22960346937179565,
-0.13004979491233826,
0.06387364864349365,
-0.22943778336048126,
-1.0450912714004517,
0.2439603954553604,
0.0005720102926716208,
0.41389745473861694,
0.33925187587738037,
-0.7536529302597046,
-0.40244218707084656,
-0.9478541612625122,
0.4481934607028961,
-0.7486996054649353,
0.5602657794952393,
0.04292372986674309,
0.29173529148101807,
-0.15303801000118256,
-0.6000915765762329,
-0.22099308669567108,
-0.33688297867774963,
-0.18602971732616425,
0.5514440536499023,
0.10517975687980652,
0.4960273504257202,
0.08158942312002182,
0.4886627793312073,
-0.5323989987373352,
0.2235007882118225,
-0.3899315893650055,
-0.483624130487442,
0.7522020936012268,
-0.12439020723104477,
0.32506635785102844,
-0.10435794293880463,
-0.5746192932128906,
-0.07579550892114639,
-0.4172256588935852,
-0.16242748498916626,
-0.002661151345819235,
0.7233316898345947,
-0.009250493720173836,
0.24089787900447845,
-0.26665908098220825,
0.3567567467689514,
-0.23399865627288818,
0.04606866091489792,
0.29861223697662354,
-0.0241690706461668,
-0.1927194595336914,
-0.07078251242637634,
1.0562248229980469,
0.010819307528436184,
0.25801384449005127,
-0.19903846085071564,
-0.5735938549041748,
-0.16596733033657074,
-0.13321758806705475,
-0.18282707035541534,
-0.1020464077591896,
0.05618494749069214,
0.1506936252117157,
0.1726158857345581,
0.42621371150016785,
-0.5438246130943298,
-0.5505331158638,
-0.2540695369243622,
0.3670037090778351,
0.053666215389966965,
-0.48249632120132446,
0.14709976315498352,
0.05685228481888771,
-0.02303319424390793,
0.31316182017326355,
-1.0056201219558716,
0.28273311257362366,
0.32595765590667725,
0.6814696192741394,
-0.29662254452705383,
-0.03867745026946068,
-0.5090985894203186,
0.5077065825462341,
-0.5277813673019409,
0.3026359975337982,
-0.0628964826464653,
-0.3401954770088196,
0.06458888947963715,
-0.24968671798706055,
0.05954138934612274,
-0.562661349773407,
0.5785195827484131,
-0.22841507196426392,
0.17101997137069702,
0.14310888946056366,
-0.4207988381385803,
0.09378476440906525,
-0.5061063766479492,
-0.6333647966384888,
0.9504430294036865,
0.39721381664276123,
-0.0467708595097065,
0.5172333121299744,
-0.9999414086341858,
-0.5641812086105347,
0.4513072371482849,
-0.3110615015029907,
-0.253274530172348,
0.43495887517929077,
0.21223190426826477,
0.32969075441360474,
-0.03883358836174011,
0.18804875016212463,
0.15835577249526978,
-0.04666907712817192,
-0.16860496997833252,
-0.29906579852104187,
0.7451580762863159,
0.2668266296386719,
-0.6062548756599426,
0.1663309633731842,
-0.9302393794059753,
0.05095868930220604,
0.057246603071689606,
-0.2798665463924408,
-0.3218561112880707,
-0.6726556420326233,
0.27413153648376465,
0.3919645845890045,
0.4402827024459839,
-0.8094649314880371,
0.0636640265583992,
-0.1783352941274643,
-0.08734609931707382,
0.6809359788894653,
-0.2218123823404312,
0.35948508977890015,
0.4983191192150116,
0.47081050276756287,
0.14408162236213684,
0.6225751042366028,
0.2154940515756607,
-0.5831138491630554,
-0.8782258033752441,
0.06662055850028992,
0.20066504180431366,
0.38514283299446106,
-0.3543771207332611,
0.19714413583278656,
0.1784655898809433,
-0.07041623443365097,
-0.6252212524414062,
0.5136544704437256,
0.7613850235939026,
0.32586154341697693,
0.5901570916175842,
-0.6623451113700867,
-0.39420098066329956,
-0.7046253085136414,
-0.16680775582790375,
-0.0898023322224617,
-0.3403630554676056,
-0.3588387072086334,
0.16721783578395844,
-0.032668083906173706,
0.5639275312423706,
-0.2312571257352829,
-1.200009822845459,
0.010474425740540028,
0.41785696148872375,
0.32309210300445557,
0.6306434273719788,
0.2599671185016632,
-0.844464898109436,
-0.6676190495491028,
0.2821803689002991,
-0.9152460694313049,
-0.4849311411380768,
-0.40724295377731323,
0.09209967404603958,
0.30154767632484436,
0.7611058354377747,
-0.3198169469833374,
0.49005311727523804,
0.7153452634811401,
-0.47850093245506287,
0.47121796011924744,
-0.4777694046497345,
-0.09349660575389862,
-0.5547462701797485,
0.12195001542568207,
-0.10050016641616821,
-0.3606536388397217,
-1.0455121994018555,
0.13122138381004333,
0.14766407012939453,
-0.22325512766838074,
-0.4870613217353821,
0.3928202688694,
-0.9988625645637512,
-0.5256345868110657,
-0.21483729779720306,
0.4623459279537201,
0.01811450906097889,
0.43258196115493774,
-0.002004372887313366,
0.7817530632019043,
0.6994642615318298,
-0.5075799226760864,
0.36160898208618164,
0.21572785079479218,
-0.19750851392745972,
0.3789594769477844,
-0.6231856942176819,
0.0575118288397789,
-0.056833770126104355,
-0.21498113870620728,
-0.9521784782409668,
-0.2202966958284378,
0.45693910121917725,
-0.2173939347267151,
0.5797334313392639,
0.07617897540330887,
-0.4166533350944519,
-0.4605203866958618,
0.10099219530820847,
0.10529818385839462,
0.5597918629646301,
-0.5820221304893494,
0.5144428014755249,
0.37453529238700867,
0.15836070477962494,
-0.4876192510128021,
-0.8957856297492981,
0.1291843205690384,
0.020248129963874817,
-0.12843158841133118,
0.1296217143535614,
-0.08462172746658325,
-0.04826357960700989,
-0.4291946589946747,
-0.6179544925689697,
-0.01009773276746273,
0.05966600775718689,
0.32348334789276123,
-0.07847864180803299,
-0.028032680973410606,
0.07600369304418564,
0.0011840382358059287,
-0.5884470343589783,
-0.03666875511407852,
-0.3156452178955078,
0.11223185062408447,
-0.1350705325603485,
-0.783616304397583,
-0.4686797857284546,
0.5590918660163879,
0.48362183570861816,
-0.12799811363220215,
0.30746856331825256,
0.6827085614204407,
-0.1725466400384903,
-0.1738324761390686,
-0.24654720723628998,
0.18650662899017334,
-0.5457018613815308,
-0.0481748953461647,
-0.22216999530792236,
-0.7611590027809143,
0.42005884647369385,
-0.14026807248592377,
0.35249072313308716,
0.5585776567459106,
0.19614432752132416,
-0.1838553249835968,
1.059561014175415,
0.4349174201488495,
0.3769633173942566,
0.39363521337509155,
-0.06668947637081146,
-0.018905268982052803,
-0.9432808756828308,
-0.36644381284713745,
-0.06891617923974991,
-0.02349797636270523,
0.0073341797105968,
-0.3228456974029541,
0.48980024456977844,
0.39061132073402405,
-0.1999218761920929,
0.38738128542900085,
-0.9400975704193115,
0.3690457046031952,
0.600973904132843,
-0.4305211305618286,
0.7430291771888733,
-0.022948557510972023,
-0.252246618270874,
0.01756536029279232,
-0.19884151220321655,
-0.49291327595710754,
0.9574108719825745,
0.012778806500136852,
0.6214454770088196,
0.24660299718379974,
0.9262300133705139,
0.48018354177474976,
0.5790095925331116,
-0.4084129333496094,
0.6102352142333984,
-0.5699320435523987,
-0.646755576133728,
-0.46097850799560547,
-0.396679550409317,
-1.0075052976608276,
0.6463534832000732,
-0.0019453628920018673,
-0.6836550235748291,
0.14454379677772522,
0.27695217728614807,
0.004989660810679197,
0.30359864234924316,
-0.6984164118766785,
0.8500987887382507,
-0.6026930212974548,
0.38272586464881897,
0.29029563069343567,
-0.7752452492713928,
0.040156710892915726,
-0.16547159850597382,
0.40796640515327454,
-0.42501047253608704,
-0.07493777573108673,
0.7719020247459412,
-0.311513751745224,
0.9881808757781982,
-0.36535149812698364,
-0.698872447013855,
0.1552523821592331,
0.1421792209148407,
0.07360822707414627,
-0.13922888040542603,
0.12617507576942444,
0.29862502217292786,
-0.246578648686409,
-0.3227650225162506,
-0.48648613691329956,
0.3946947455406189,
-0.6307145357131958,
-0.7318778038024902,
-0.6155700087547302,
-0.6283003687858582,
-0.3407096564769745,
0.4404398500919342,
0.13947121798992157,
0.20360921323299408,
-0.22568093240261078,
-0.3594064712524414,
0.28553205728530884,
0.31147778034210205,
0.4431845247745514,
0.590051531791687,
-0.5474473237991333,
-0.46568116545677185,
0.8158337473869324,
0.13423945009708405,
0.6058574318885803,
0.20040109753608704,
0.20229724049568176,
-0.48371830582618713,
-0.7223182916641235,
-0.5354015827178955,
0.30140450596809387,
-0.8127024173736572,
-0.16776129603385925,
-0.061442628502845764,
0.03066994622349739,
-0.6398887634277344,
0.048069488257169724,
-0.37961363792419434,
-0.8490875959396362,
-0.3201647400856018,
-0.10476614534854889,
0.1656394898891449,
1.187083125114441,
-0.7858132123947144,
0.3712192177772522,
-0.4399246275424957,
0.6576586365699768,
0.5661631226539612,
0.40772268176078796,
-0.23306243121623993,
-0.4006877839565277,
-0.24378274381160736,
0.12823732197284698,
-0.33243197202682495,
-0.7866466641426086,
0.14113043248653412,
0.7577421069145203,
0.5271239876747131,
0.48442402482032776,
0.1967657059431076,
0.4890621304512024,
-0.2661644220352173,
0.7356456518173218,
0.617764413356781,
-1.1502985954284668,
0.5338292121887207,
-0.32994067668914795,
0.3915844261646271,
0.5139309763908386,
0.33351191878318787,
-0.9068594574928284,
-0.699217677116394,
-0.5082778930664062,
-1.0785073041915894,
0.530648946762085,
0.2988872230052948,
-0.06886212527751923,
0.2103942632675171,
0.18416056036949158,
0.16326354444026947,
0.23263578116893768,
-0.8166666626930237,
-0.4137541949748993,
-0.439719557762146,
-0.16235429048538208,
-0.11997756361961365,
0.19692617654800415,
-0.2620445489883423,
-0.2571062445640564,
0.5704682469367981,
-0.22103795409202576,
-0.11324106156826019,
0.26220035552978516,
-0.25642552971839905,
-0.18992868065834045,
0.3172115981578827,
0.3178999423980713,
0.5674517154693604,
-0.07194097340106964,
0.22781997919082642,
-0.09456317871809006,
-0.4792537987232208,
0.279347687959671,
-0.011497817933559418,
-0.43168461322784424,
0.3203054964542389,
0.27002885937690735,
0.6434223055839539,
0.06488360464572906,
-0.4511041045188904,
0.6145363450050354,
0.37803915143013,
-0.27437883615493774,
-0.4874449372291565,
-0.02882823348045349,
0.03958984464406967,
0.09221833199262619,
0.621488630771637,
-0.21509407460689545,
0.18308211863040924,
-0.3563508987426758,
0.23300866782665253,
0.36234307289123535,
-0.6339187622070312,
-0.235963836312294,
1.0582327842712402,
0.164973184466362,
-0.09473904967308044,
0.3842618763446808,
-0.377734899520874,
-0.28766074776649475,
0.3469924032688141,
0.6925312876701355,
0.8151498436927795,
-0.5261668562889099,
0.6526044011116028,
0.08679794520139694,
0.14345382153987885,
0.0839887410402298,
0.26322272419929504,
-0.039408691227436066,
-0.5012240409851074,
-0.25920814275741577,
-0.5627137422561646,
-0.6324861645698547,
0.018297811970114708,
-0.7604672312736511,
-0.40214332938194275,
-0.6239005923271179,
-0.07790380716323853,
-0.2578951418399811,
-0.290829598903656,
-0.43690767884254456,
0.2706390917301178,
0.6988990306854248,
0.45389220118522644,
-1.028192162513733,
0.6079151034355164,
0.7821860909461975,
-0.7808609008789062,
-0.5255714654922485,
-0.22398658096790314,
0.06391899287700653,
-0.8487357497215271,
0.6193315982818604,
0.09198936820030212,
-0.34954893589019775,
-0.029090004041790962,
-0.3604680597782135,
-0.926280677318573,
0.8990904092788696,
0.633545458316803,
-0.42962658405303955,
0.10033080726861954,
0.706872820854187,
0.7474766373634338,
-0.4658161997795105,
-0.14417009055614471,
0.639037549495697,
0.5916337370872498,
0.19725900888442993,
-1.042762041091919,
0.16733478009700775,
-0.04655080288648605,
0.19654622673988342,
0.2683882415294647,
-0.48505207896232605,
0.5634061098098755,
-0.15768256783485413,
-0.7372748255729675,
0.019465934485197067,
1.081676959991455,
0.1690061390399933,
0.2278616577386856,
0.43369260430336,
0.43343618512153625,
0.8880795836448669,
-0.2086733728647232,
0.5026811957359314,
-0.0735083743929863,
0.46923744678497314,
0.9084905385971069,
-0.1277175396680832,
0.40547141432762146,
0.43295595049858093,
-0.18121568858623505,
0.2836732864379883,
0.2094230055809021,
0.08669182658195496,
0.3443259298801422,
0.2241424322128296,
-0.37153080105781555,
-0.41459766030311584,
-0.27661192417144775,
-0.25870805978775024,
0.2475450187921524,
0.4029453694820404,
0.06563951075077057,
-0.48830482363700867,
0.21134379506111145,
0.008109073154628277,
0.2895245850086212,
-0.5089775323867798,
0.681979238986969,
0.44093057513237,
-0.09892584383487701,
0.8184623718261719,
-0.49778440594673157,
0.8441608548164368,
-0.8179953694343567,
0.06096915900707245,
-0.32346832752227783,
0.042828530073165894,
-0.3158318102359772,
-0.9291251301765442,
0.2318100929260254,
-0.345170795917511,
0.3417978584766388,
-0.5889459252357483,
0.4735737442970276,
-0.7951402068138123,
-0.47131627798080444,
0.7304754257202148,
0.5056019425392151,
0.5866584181785583,
-0.048254746943712234,
-0.7065860033035278,
-0.22763150930404663,
-0.0000628811540082097,
-0.15979504585266113,
0.2252882719039917,
0.5164466500282288,
-0.06082690507173538,
0.5180025696754456,
0.618316650390625,
0.25114256143569946,
0.41071590781211853,
0.7284289598464966,
0.5733888149261475,
-0.6384472846984863,
-0.3435840606689453,
-0.04256439954042435,
0.5760518312454224,
-0.12224707752466202,
-0.5293799042701721,
0.7397164106369019,
0.40069904923439026,
0.8058104515075684,
-0.1779562383890152,
0.7962629795074463,
-0.06281644105911255,
0.1906518042087555,
-0.48379403352737427,
0.5918053388595581,
-0.881722629070282,
-0.14736616611480713,
-0.5066612362861633,
-0.9337274432182312,
-0.9662914872169495,
0.44458311796188354,
0.15056011080741882,
0.018338987603783607,
0.6180117130279541,
0.3391185402870178,
-0.08696318417787552,
-0.25065088272094727,
0.7296961545944214,
-0.018800336867570877,
0.36337485909461975,
0.6809906363487244,
0.33091413974761963,
-0.5525526404380798,
0.8108748197555542,
-0.15880434215068817,
-0.28555232286453247,
0.0336025208234787,
-0.7711525559425354,
-0.4980645477771759,
-0.9051779508590698,
-0.4002891182899475,
0.020989084616303444,
-0.17891345918178558,
0.6296612024307251,
0.5864486694335938,
-1.1262099742889404,
-0.5322144627571106,
-0.06079735979437828,
-0.15182575583457947,
-0.48021796345710754,
-0.10179851949214935,
0.5029722452163696,
-0.4496762752532959,
-0.6367043852806091,
0.8570473194122314,
0.2783876061439514,
0.4558575451374054,
-0.38148951530456543,
-0.19402512907981873,
0.061869099736213684,
-0.2609970271587372,
0.4714181125164032,
0.8587754964828491,
-0.6897488236427307,
-0.2699417471885681,
-0.5562953948974609,
-0.09864610433578491,
0.2787451148033142,
0.7660131454467773,
-0.4332987666130066,
0.4695405066013336,
0.11909560114145279,
0.08856270462274551,
0.5285520553588867,
-0.007806101348251104,
0.5132083892822266,
-1.1411733627319336,
0.1922028511762619,
0.13261377811431885,
0.4081976115703583,
0.7078484892845154,
-0.3056575655937195,
0.7369135618209839,
0.16907572746276855,
-0.3294813632965088,
-0.43332624435424805,
0.6627073884010315,
-1.0384215116500854,
-0.16155096888542175,
0.9762964248657227,
-0.0668804943561554,
-0.05161849781870842,
-0.5513925552368164,
0.0048490650951862335,
0.47450730204582214,
-0.5380359888076782,
0.4090578854084015,
0.13596005737781525,
-0.37777596712112427,
-0.12105780839920044,
-0.3897973299026489,
0.558369517326355,
0.39551010727882385,
-0.5782964825630188,
0.4821588397026062,
0.49079498648643494,
-0.04704742133617401,
0.6379120945930481,
0.8851948976516724,
-0.29919546842575073,
0.08151271939277649,
-0.14181123673915863,
0.6828269958496094,
-0.29679617285728455,
-0.46805036067962646,
-0.4747146666049957,
0.2179611325263977,
0.21672466397285461,
-0.1750466674566269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02842v1 | MindBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Mind Map Structure Recognition and Analysis | 2024-07-03T06:39:18 | 2024-07-03T06:39:18 | Lei Chen, Feng Yan, Yujie Zhong, Shaoxiang Chen, Zequn Jie, Lin Ma | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLM) have made significant progress in the
field of document analysis. Despite this, existing benchmarks typically focus
only on extracting text and simple layout information, neglecting the complex
interactions between elements in structured documents such as mind maps and
flowcharts. To address this issue, we introduce the new benchmark named
MindBench, which not only includes meticulously constructed bilingual authentic
or synthetic images, detailed annotations, evaluation metrics and baseline
models, but also specifically designs five types of structured understanding
and parsing tasks. These tasks include full parsing, partial parsing,
position-related parsing, structured Visual Question Answering (VQA), and
position-related VQA, covering key areas such as text recognition, spatial
awareness, relationship discernment, and structured parsing. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate the substantial potential and significant room
for improvement in current models' ability to handle structured document
information. We anticipate that the launch of MindBench will significantly
advance research and application development in structured document analysis
technology. MindBench is available at:
https://miasanlei.github.io/MindBench.github.io/. | [
-0.5475853085517883,
-0.7797529101371765,
0.7450298070907593,
0.28972935676574707,
-0.30349093675613403,
-0.012267987243831158,
-0.2581620514392853,
-0.5421460270881653,
-0.005110211670398712,
0.40964487195014954,
-0.5201255679130554,
-0.8697574138641357,
-0.40450140833854675,
-0.1411607414484024,
-0.5108951330184937,
0.7609095573425293,
-0.3340543210506439,
0.04528237506747246,
-0.4111487865447998,
-0.2836766839027405,
-0.29697179794311523,
-0.5670193433761597,
-0.4805116057395935,
-0.5532722473144531,
0.4866369366645813,
-0.023677125573158264,
0.43467283248901367,
0.47263920307159424,
0.7524922490119934,
0.4089335501194,
0.1111750677227974,
-0.057688288390636444,
-0.1759493052959442,
0.39984720945358276,
-0.27919256687164307,
-0.35525569319725037,
-0.7724956274032593,
0.2838040888309479,
0.7945053577423096,
0.7680162787437439,
-0.23296357691287994,
0.2200758308172226,
-0.02486717887222767,
0.7502955198287964,
-0.6046913862228394,
0.5394759178161621,
-0.40039506554603577,
0.16999545693397522,
-0.4482154846191406,
-0.04609880596399307,
-0.23823504149913788,
-0.2626752555370331,
-0.020143894478678703,
-0.4576773941516876,
0.34455323219299316,
0.3366316556930542,
0.80318683385849,
0.3818668723106384,
-0.20418284833431244,
-0.005168209318071604,
-0.20249655842781067,
0.49224284291267395,
-0.36727607250213623,
0.7455527782440186,
0.35877078771591187,
0.6989758014678955,
-0.3950553834438324,
-0.9198870658874512,
-0.7920617461204529,
0.16933926939964294,
0.1092902198433876,
0.28017449378967285,
0.1298723667860031,
0.0871906653046608,
0.4947987198829651,
0.4911528527736664,
-0.7964352965354919,
-0.3389539122581482,
-0.02006593346595764,
-0.19623450934886932,
0.30677738785743713,
0.1338096261024475,
0.30690622329711914,
-0.18984150886535645,
-0.3321288824081421,
-0.47887861728668213,
-0.12962912023067474,
0.13733793795108795,
0.056185849010944366,
0.0068121785297989845,
-0.17945174872875214,
0.4079614281654358,
-0.25696811079978943,
0.8549073934555054,
-0.13886797428131104,
0.02528037503361702,
0.515500545501709,
-0.06081848219037056,
-0.5674750208854675,
-0.059067197144031525,
0.6666162610054016,
0.5991882085800171,
0.40516239404678345,
-0.30878961086273193,
-0.11020805686712265,
0.11528585851192474,
0.32425785064697266,
-0.883352518081665,
-0.44259345531463623,
0.4406253397464752,
-0.6089329719543457,
-0.03832446411252022,
-0.03384003788232803,
-0.7978287935256958,
-0.6659528613090515,
-0.32790255546569824,
-0.1092061996459961,
-0.49665504693984985,
-0.20538334548473358,
0.14785979688167572,
-0.4891713261604309,
0.6479897499084473,
0.5088156461715698,
-0.6408496499061584,
0.44197341799736023,
0.8942409157752991,
0.9275074601173401,
-0.2406429797410965,
-0.3794991672039032,
-0.4540358781814575,
0.056282784789800644,
-0.41511479020118713,
1.1714019775390625,
-0.4639197587966919,
-0.4303267002105713,
-0.5430541634559631,
-0.027641616761684418,
-0.17794698476791382,
-0.5427736639976501,
0.8026219010353088,
-0.4060990810394287,
0.22108998894691467,
-0.4320228695869446,
-0.5505723357200623,
-0.3381231725215912,
0.8518738150596619,
-0.8602428436279297,
1.12587308883667,
0.327789306640625,
-0.6966428756713867,
0.3927636742591858,
-0.5799558758735657,
-0.17022407054901123,
0.12907956540584564,
-0.5334811210632324,
-0.11727244406938553,
0.0848570466041565,
0.11021757870912552,
0.4189409017562866,
-0.3866036832332611,
0.42485225200653076,
-0.38878968358039856,
-0.28372901678085327,
0.35976529121398926,
-0.08928924798965454,
0.6505618691444397,
0.0986490547657013,
-0.1806286871433258,
0.4236854016780853,
-1.1430951356887817,
0.5515800714492798,
0.15476036071777344,
-0.5004934668540955,
-0.31426239013671875,
0.2851199805736542,
0.498644083738327,
0.5932708382606506,
0.23176813125610352,
-0.7541810870170593,
0.08245579153299332,
-0.3100073039531708,
-0.01024165004491806,
0.5700957775115967,
-0.2043965458869934,
0.04035153612494469,
-0.0743277296423912,
0.4194331467151642,
0.04523035138845444,
-0.18177445232868195,
-0.17458513379096985,
-0.2910183370113373,
-0.7665300965309143,
-0.4625556766986847,
0.29037487506866455,
0.38958272337913513,
-0.38606971502304077,
0.39626339077949524,
-0.5973986983299255,
-0.5151636600494385,
-0.5932248830795288,
0.17581066489219666,
0.5039106011390686,
0.741698682308197,
0.4656178653240204,
-0.588869571685791,
-0.6201554536819458,
-1.1402747631072998,
-0.3795996606349945,
-0.006146336439996958,
-0.16808255016803741,
-0.15790675580501556,
0.45049789547920227,
-0.09053576737642288,
0.8956555724143982,
-0.4970863163471222,
-0.3378020226955414,
-0.2349025160074234,
0.2448139190673828,
0.22961990535259247,
0.4343486428260803,
0.5634267926216125,
-0.9698957204818726,
-0.47456473112106323,
0.0694868415594101,
-0.8477885723114014,
0.08515432476997375,
0.26375114917755127,
-0.34153738617897034,
-0.14239725470542908,
0.5848115682601929,
-0.7085849046707153,
0.26968371868133545,
0.5488396286964417,
-0.3095860183238983,
0.2951808571815491,
0.049239158630371094,
0.06592270731925964,
-0.958246111869812,
0.4007471203804016,
-0.20201802253723145,
-0.4713110625743866,
-0.46610358357429504,
0.49165529012680054,
0.6795234680175781,
-0.3199242949485779,
-0.1999823898077011,
0.5320139527320862,
-0.4520963132381439,
-0.307693749666214,
-0.21839582920074463,
0.17220298945903778,
0.1747743785381317,
0.7942026257514954,
-0.08193953335285187,
0.7434728145599365,
0.20300452411174774,
0.04962113872170448,
0.2663728594779968,
0.1156391128897667,
-0.6708622574806213,
0.9508061408996582,
-0.5266651511192322,
0.41573598980903625,
-0.18611648678779602,
0.42554470896720886,
-1.0636266469955444,
-0.23726269602775574,
0.27137237787246704,
-0.17756035923957825,
0.28295475244522095,
0.2289329171180725,
-0.6869754791259766,
-0.48608848452568054,
-0.40449368953704834,
0.011426986195147038,
0.03675387427210808,
-0.2802078425884247,
1.0375511646270752,
0.4357397258281708,
0.07724045217037201,
-0.3912047743797302,
-0.5951983332633972,
0.13181357085704803,
0.1527230441570282,
-0.5061100721359253,
0.39619460701942444,
-0.3109437823295593,
-0.24412879347801208,
0.056880801916122437,
-0.37666621804237366,
-0.3064785599708557,
0.27083635330200195,
0.6042633652687073,
0.14211677014827728,
-0.2383364588022232,
0.018358828499913216,
-0.22696037590503693,
-0.19906069338321686,
0.047936275601387024,
-0.19952455163002014,
0.5730628371238708,
-0.5399178862571716,
-0.18630261719226837,
0.01008413452655077,
0.4370027482509613,
0.7510514259338379,
-0.7119741439819336,
0.5445483922958374,
0.6260262727737427,
-0.5020684003829956,
-0.20899325609207153,
-0.6375817656517029,
0.5130224823951721,
-0.4857439696788788,
0.3513931930065155,
-0.8300636410713196,
-0.5670952200889587,
0.37277865409851074,
-0.09117382019758224,
0.16692203283309937,
0.3208833932876587,
0.573330283164978,
-0.38273918628692627,
0.6917309761047363,
0.7141558527946472,
-0.29554814100265503,
0.2940106987953186,
0.022786526009440422,
-0.08483865857124329,
-0.9543219208717346,
-0.09040358662605286,
-0.45863738656044006,
-0.6179397106170654,
-0.1251872479915619,
-0.7144520282745361,
0.08965951204299927,
-0.12055779993534088,
0.08724328875541687,
0.2060783952474594,
-0.35530686378479004,
0.62534499168396,
0.3901044726371765,
-0.17866948246955872,
0.23118674755096436,
-0.19004210829734802,
-0.6727800369262695,
-0.005621479824185371,
-0.07873319834470749,
-0.4013802707195282,
1.2219356298446655,
0.062311332672834396,
0.4308033287525177,
-0.11175378412008286,
0.5044471025466919,
0.04609182849526405,
0.6090854406356812,
-0.8753219246864319,
0.8581979870796204,
0.032764095813035965,
-0.6645662188529968,
-0.013445175252854824,
-0.1312904804944992,
-0.8063704967498779,
0.8075514435768127,
0.06059786304831505,
-0.7322574257850647,
0.18631519377231598,
0.08069904148578644,
-0.05083639919757843,
0.18118782341480255,
-0.6814194917678833,
1.1210662126541138,
-0.3745322525501251,
-0.2791779339313507,
-0.3006680905818939,
-0.6027721166610718,
0.06784497946500778,
-0.27341708540916443,
0.22494512796401978,
-0.413325697183609,
-0.010019367560744286,
0.6028458476066589,
0.11127939820289612,
0.37627172470092773,
-0.27934762835502625,
-0.09382209181785583,
-0.06928983330726624,
0.13316090404987335,
0.30234408378601074,
-0.6748303771018982,
-0.36858677864074707,
0.1235157772898674,
0.037255022674798965,
-0.29789289832115173,
-0.8300778865814209,
0.5915411710739136,
-0.4991408884525299,
-0.4727082848548889,
-0.21459250152111053,
-0.895147442817688,
-0.3796278238296509,
0.6090402007102966,
-0.22486448287963867,
0.35394230484962463,
-0.49848195910453796,
0.46223920583724976,
0.3739393651485443,
0.07836578041315079,
0.20794962346553802,
0.7467663884162903,
-0.3913559317588806,
-0.18543483316898346,
0.7738125324249268,
0.11866584420204163,
-0.28311699628829956,
0.60392165184021,
-0.10208377987146378,
-0.15848217904567719,
-0.7126897573471069,
-0.18321438133716583,
0.044518567621707916,
-0.9667196273803711,
0.1277228444814682,
-0.7775965929031372,
-0.14717203378677368,
-0.13297806680202484,
0.09044694155454636,
-0.3043198883533478,
-0.3700093924999237,
0.2547524571418762,
-0.297921359539032,
-0.3422172963619232,
0.2882849872112274,
0.5145474672317505,
0.13411355018615723,
-0.5065702795982361,
0.576259195804596,
0.1624908447265625,
0.610480010509491,
-0.08949308097362518,
0.23685897886753082,
-0.34920671582221985,
-0.45404940843582153,
-0.5471567511558533,
-0.8456595540046692,
0.11788760125637054,
0.09188719093799591,
0.7801194190979004,
0.3405696153640747,
-0.28841525316238403,
0.7386326789855957,
-0.6659104824066162,
0.1840313971042633,
-0.068389892578125,
-0.784294605255127,
0.5743255019187927,
-0.4611347019672394,
0.5466850996017456,
0.7250866889953613,
0.17375710606575012,
-0.7114538550376892,
-0.37915587425231934,
-0.39639297127723694,
-0.6121826767921448,
0.4492681324481964,
0.09515843540430069,
-0.4498445987701416,
0.11186177283525467,
0.16065651178359985,
-0.15109382569789886,
0.4813826382160187,
-0.6121139526367188,
0.1469939649105072,
-0.3483966886997223,
-0.7449785470962524,
-0.2773117125034332,
0.007400275208055973,
-0.2789457142353058,
-0.23845987021923065,
0.0940604880452156,
-0.3993334472179413,
0.06343145668506622,
0.31996044516563416,
-0.4710959792137146,
-0.17086221277713776,
0.4759865403175354,
0.3276181221008301,
0.7014485001564026,
-0.6299000382423401,
0.37746211886405945,
-0.03709720820188522,
-0.5338002443313599,
0.02699306048452854,
0.40025952458381653,
0.06567554175853729,
-0.29209208488464355,
0.42942604422569275,
0.6102511286735535,
0.49303916096687317,
-0.9787832498550415,
0.2833932042121887,
-0.1700175255537033,
-0.14854994416236877,
-0.2034299075603485,
0.33094996213912964,
0.20620568096637726,
0.45077717304229736,
0.18672963976860046,
0.005934770684689283,
0.2922714948654175,
-0.402596116065979,
0.02842598408460617,
0.5147271156311035,
-0.2823897898197174,
-0.257415235042572,
0.6115222573280334,
0.16767829656600952,
-0.13715487718582153,
0.6020985841751099,
0.04874444380402565,
-0.4042821228504181,
0.5804840922355652,
0.30277201533317566,
0.9374881386756897,
-0.07963778078556061,
-0.13693849742412567,
0.14139169454574585,
0.47526752948760986,
0.11642592400312424,
0.5640562772750854,
-0.5044005513191223,
-0.8413281440734863,
0.13124437630176544,
-0.8232598304748535,
-0.7182735800743103,
-0.0030688790138810873,
-0.7043811678886414,
-0.0864221602678299,
-0.6510429382324219,
-0.3691079020500183,
0.174553781747818,
0.17529112100601196,
-1.001602053642273,
0.3143424093723297,
0.34105128049850464,
1.1210908889770508,
-0.3680833876132965,
1.1251109838485718,
0.9376339912414551,
-0.19374202191829681,
-0.4539564847946167,
-0.037346117198467255,
0.4334143400192261,
-0.7039735913276672,
0.520359218120575,
0.5074321031570435,
-0.26215970516204834,
0.09277883917093277,
-0.31644007563591003,
-0.7392932176589966,
1.1555736064910889,
0.1866445243358612,
-0.6125048995018005,
-0.28015002608299255,
-0.21327821910381317,
0.7350481748580933,
-0.2550913989543915,
0.13933683931827545,
0.72508704662323,
0.6466919779777527,
-0.4497974216938019,
-0.5681332945823669,
0.13832049071788788,
-0.714265763759613,
0.010188296437263489,
0.21805594861507416,
-0.616979718208313,
0.9243504405021667,
0.31405654549598694,
-0.5069867372512817,
-0.09921783953905106,
0.5291652679443359,
0.15514659881591797,
0.10324468463659286,
0.6482186317443848,
0.8856244683265686,
0.9001652002334595,
-0.07621719688177109,
1.3505868911743164,
-0.37640202045440674,
0.08648993074893951,
1.5823224782943726,
-0.6426188349723816,
1.2102711200714111,
0.3603443503379822,
-0.3184716999530792,
0.8951807618141174,
0.49325796961784363,
-0.22975127398967743,
0.2164788395166397,
0.05074417218565941,
0.31885838508605957,
-0.17969855666160583,
0.05989667400717735,
-0.295865535736084,
0.420304536819458,
0.5863804221153259,
-0.2763746678829193,
-0.46866780519485474,
-0.1758696436882019,
-0.16488409042358398,
-0.09882929176092148,
0.030335087329149246,
0.4434967041015625,
0.021832970902323723,
-0.7396087050437927,
0.31382134556770325,
0.08329164981842041,
0.28106167912483215,
-1.005935549736023,
0.2542093098163605,
-0.08436136692762375,
0.4407055079936981,
-0.03892577067017555,
-0.8493513464927673,
0.1050228476524353,
-0.05186360329389572,
-0.3932068943977356,
-0.34181898832321167,
0.8860464692115784,
-0.38260942697525024,
-0.41009029746055603,
0.6238816380500793,
0.6267796754837036,
0.17908813059329987,
-0.4536501467227936,
-0.8228966593742371,
0.2456124871969223,
-0.39867570996284485,
-0.507371723651886,
0.3878268897533417,
0.30686062574386597,
-0.1692749410867691,
0.6135465502738953,
0.7108311057090759,
-0.05249395594000816,
-0.033327654004096985,
0.3351946473121643,
0.9995114803314209,
-0.9032761454582214,
-0.6321462988853455,
-0.749904453754425,
0.3560774624347687,
-0.3745741844177246,
-0.19555655121803284,
0.9620945453643799,
0.7703830003738403,
0.7564657330513,
0.006608436815440655,
0.4914492070674896,
0.1494801938533783,
0.44808894395828247,
-0.2819136381149292,
0.9681729078292847,
-0.7299541234970093,
-0.47013264894485474,
-0.5743169188499451,
-1.039975643157959,
-0.21546082198619843,
0.5837922692298889,
-0.32217705249786377,
-0.2576647996902466,
1.0847599506378174,
0.6743209362030029,
-0.19098681211471558,
0.07060210406780243,
0.34622153639793396,
0.1700875461101532,
0.4896668493747711,
0.48521560430526733,
0.6574718356132507,
-0.07643435895442963,
0.4129583537578583,
-0.1243024542927742,
-0.18962767720222473,
0.06524278968572617,
-0.6341447234153748,
-1.0715702772140503,
-0.606840193271637,
-0.0606476329267025,
0.158589169383049,
-0.19784203171730042,
0.7469216585159302,
0.7985032796859741,
-0.7989027500152588,
-0.40401890873908997,
-0.013745401054620743,
0.05319768935441971,
-0.3850945830345154,
-0.22365650534629822,
0.36112046241760254,
-0.24490278959274292,
-0.5510442852973938,
0.602145254611969,
0.7524555325508118,
0.1735040843486786,
-0.24718043208122253,
0.22201989591121674,
-0.27055105566978455,
-0.07737527042627335,
0.5818145871162415,
0.17082546651363373,
-0.7356441617012024,
-0.059990137815475464,
-0.236639142036438,
-0.32768964767456055,
0.25719696283340454,
1.0377225875854492,
-0.7313663959503174,
0.7693473696708679,
0.599724531173706,
0.7741792798042297,
0.633762776851654,
0.13981503248214722,
0.4919864237308502,
-0.6729211211204529,
0.41634881496429443,
-0.08629623055458069,
0.619388222694397,
0.5240405201911926,
-0.08030547946691513,
0.8003888130187988,
0.17446301877498627,
-0.07581394165754318,
-0.6300679445266724,
-0.0378006249666214,
-1.1419298648834229,
-0.38293927907943726,
0.41078439354896545,
-0.321103036403656,
-0.5531886219978333,
-0.21598006784915924,
-0.33480414748191833,
0.20095184445381165,
-0.06421121209859848,
0.5260717272758484,
1.247628092765808,
-0.02077741175889969,
-0.32279375195503235,
-0.6742751598358154,
0.16545265913009644,
0.4432637393474579,
-1.1933804750442505,
0.03635866194963455,
0.6788954734802246,
0.23941457271575928,
0.1711961030960083,
1.0206615924835205,
-0.19042466580867767,
0.26056477427482605,
0.010225425474345684,
0.3258706033229828,
-0.11471854150295258,
-0.4488338828086853,
-0.09554314613342285,
0.5897225737571716,
-0.061322495341300964,
-0.08599257469177246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02837v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02837v1 | Comparing Feature-based and Context-aware Approaches to PII Generalization Level Prediction | 2024-07-03T06:32:03 | 2024-07-03T06:32:03 | Kailin Zhang, Xinying Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Protecting Personal Identifiable Information (PII) in text data is crucial
for privacy, but current PII generalization methods face challenges such as
uneven data distributions and limited context awareness. To address these
issues, we propose two approaches: a feature-based method using machine
learning to improve performance on structured inputs, and a novel context-aware
framework that considers the broader context and semantic relationships between
the original text and generalized candidates. The context-aware approach
employs Multilingual-BERT for text representation, functional transformations,
and mean squared error scoring to evaluate candidates. Experiments on the
WikiReplace dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of both methods, with the
context-aware approach outperforming the feature-based one across different
scales. This work contributes to advancing PII generalization techniques by
highlighting the importance of feature selection, ensemble learning, and
incorporating contextual information for better privacy protection in text
anonymization. | [
-0.37168875336647034,
-0.649635374546051,
0.40062597393989563,
0.22290413081645966,
0.07167262583971024,
0.04101044312119484,
-0.22004130482673645,
-0.6687017679214478,
0.032597143203020096,
0.36970242857933044,
-0.3938964307308197,
-0.5843374729156494,
-0.6139224767684937,
0.03286392614245415,
-0.3144243657588959,
1.0175738334655762,
0.26065340638160706,
0.028832372277975082,
-0.28168371319770813,
0.021509606391191483,
-0.5918972492218018,
-0.9740025997161865,
-0.4841526746749878,
-0.13748446106910706,
0.615155816078186,
0.15132637321949005,
0.24682362377643585,
0.6437015533447266,
0.558092474937439,
0.22060470283031464,
-0.04406217485666275,
-0.16026730835437775,
-0.2388271540403366,
0.3301416039466858,
-0.24659915268421173,
-0.1655869036912918,
-0.32485970854759216,
-0.1386491060256958,
0.5185869336128235,
0.591199517250061,
0.3074442744255066,
-0.041316114366054535,
-0.047471944242715836,
0.5336885452270508,
-1.0795050859451294,
0.0984315276145935,
-0.6589261889457703,
0.2131611704826355,
-0.13245035707950592,
-0.14702145755290985,
-0.3783377707004547,
-0.017514780163764954,
0.5026158094406128,
-0.4215654134750366,
0.40986520051956177,
0.1028347834944725,
0.6120818257331848,
0.05933172255754471,
-0.4649243652820587,
-0.40886232256889343,
-0.6987776756286621,
0.7618860006332397,
-0.22148022055625916,
0.39204666018486023,
0.7907503843307495,
0.19781453907489777,
-0.035912077873945236,
-0.4847185015678406,
-0.23511990904808044,
0.025871912017464638,
-0.4267013967037201,
0.03009858727455139,
-0.03300190344452858,
-0.054118264466524124,
0.11678894609212875,
0.27333521842956543,
-0.6229240298271179,
0.276154488325119,
-0.3490791916847229,
-0.3694549798965454,
0.8663305640220642,
-0.2836062014102936,
-0.009249521419405937,
-0.018590178340673447,
-0.4378860890865326,
-0.3169187903404236,
-0.5502467155456543,
0.4078774154186249,
0.3321864604949951,
0.38722649216651917,
-0.10043126344680786,
0.22055906057357788,
-0.3210259675979614,
0.4309040606021881,
0.2254999876022339,
-0.17152801156044006,
0.38766956329345703,
-0.28130075335502625,
-0.2083275020122528,
0.2335471212863922,
0.7758029103279114,
0.2926298975944519,
0.19321265816688538,
-0.3200964033603668,
0.04606815055012703,
-0.1356634646654129,
0.09855605661869049,
-0.8149136900901794,
-0.18580536544322968,
0.32106584310531616,
-0.47475436329841614,
-0.3340222239494324,
0.7065829634666443,
-0.8720928430557251,
-0.44276612997055054,
-0.1291024386882782,
0.09812227636575699,
-0.5317401885986328,
0.029051892459392548,
-0.4813762605190277,
-0.17399950325489044,
0.007121050730347633,
0.42105668783187866,
-1.2083197832107544,
0.08948632329702377,
0.9564103484153748,
0.7196735739707947,
-0.3006724715232849,
-0.19007907807826996,
-0.400182843208313,
0.5470218658447266,
-0.2157077193260193,
0.4457453191280365,
-0.8840956091880798,
-0.6071101427078247,
-0.02479712665081024,
-0.0011059775715693831,
-0.3755643963813782,
-0.45249244570732117,
0.4680279493331909,
-0.26500239968299866,
0.6567251682281494,
-0.0345291793346405,
-0.6049279570579529,
-0.29835352301597595,
0.1837381273508072,
-0.6005210876464844,
0.834565281867981,
0.017112622037529945,
-1.0969774723052979,
0.6686134338378906,
-0.9917227029800415,
-0.5945950746536255,
-0.006122003775089979,
-0.2727842330932617,
-0.8096216320991516,
0.33589839935302734,
0.277607262134552,
0.8931906819343567,
0.31603485345840454,
0.4322957992553711,
-0.47660139203071594,
-0.4360954761505127,
0.33460915088653564,
-0.3767228424549103,
0.29616889357566833,
0.2614601254463196,
-0.35574644804000854,
0.20187637209892273,
-0.781000018119812,
-0.020713042467832565,
-0.3115679621696472,
-0.0852871984243393,
-0.48451632261276245,
0.12120264768600464,
-0.009206967428326607,
-0.29074960947036743,
0.44757217168807983,
-0.6199914813041687,
-0.16789889335632324,
-0.35886260867118835,
0.4033748209476471,
0.5852642059326172,
0.08105304837226868,
0.6780118942260742,
-0.11394590139389038,
0.07258771359920502,
0.17050762474536896,
0.07410526275634766,
-0.41555672883987427,
-0.7649827599525452,
-0.03722229227423668,
-0.5339751839637756,
0.5827426910400391,
0.9817807078361511,
-0.26041877269744873,
0.7358234524726868,
-0.2715436816215515,
-0.25836634635925293,
0.0671248733997345,
-0.08557809889316559,
0.5506570339202881,
0.4879518449306488,
0.2378131002187729,
-0.34528934955596924,
-0.39666134119033813,
-0.9159764051437378,
-0.5181247591972351,
-0.2725432217121124,
-0.5184102654457092,
0.5600125193595886,
0.2620639204978943,
-0.5269356966018677,
1.0744268894195557,
-0.35892242193222046,
-0.32714569568634033,
-0.02311151847243309,
0.16109579801559448,
-0.06624434143304825,
0.809405505657196,
0.6839343309402466,
-1.3957003355026245,
-0.6109617352485657,
0.44787418842315674,
-0.6051499843597412,
0.14839906990528107,
0.10109668970108032,
0.04728275537490845,
0.1236809566617012,
-0.004287005867809057,
0.13839071989059448,
0.8839108347892761,
0.4257451891899109,
-0.5921639204025269,
-0.14111532270908356,
-0.3364907503128052,
0.48667392134666443,
-1.0061532258987427,
0.28659456968307495,
0.1247490644454956,
-0.2965289354324341,
-1.1823996305465698,
-0.310045450925827,
0.3020990490913391,
-0.2857001721858978,
-0.2930954396724701,
0.6052402853965759,
-0.18260380625724792,
-0.19143760204315186,
-0.13114650547504425,
-0.5147007703781128,
-0.08538869768381119,
0.3626849353313446,
0.05302061885595322,
0.945306122303009,
0.5469680428504944,
-0.7158997654914856,
-0.146232008934021,
0.1263151913881302,
-0.15023986995220184,
0.36083272099494934,
-0.42290252447128296,
0.13560383021831512,
-0.16153208911418915,
0.08587920665740967,
-0.6806328892707825,
-0.7468039393424988,
0.27425768971443176,
-0.783576488494873,
0.5031590461730957,
0.16153612732887268,
-0.172301784157753,
0.0631617084145546,
-0.47877615690231323,
0.47255975008010864,
0.27919337153434753,
-0.3303971290588379,
0.6091145277023315,
0.46115967631340027,
-0.3183780908584595,
-0.6219105124473572,
-0.8049172759056091,
0.05280622839927673,
-0.5731154680252075,
-0.5312030911445618,
0.6402820348739624,
0.03269233554601669,
-0.024772025644779205,
-0.11033724248409271,
0.12292566895484924,
-0.6590732336044312,
0.5074784755706787,
0.5186043381690979,
-0.020628610625863075,
0.21748366951942444,
0.1873290240764618,
0.28885528445243835,
-0.23336544632911682,
-0.2668255567550659,
-0.15996316075325012,
0.28366348147392273,
-0.1762472689151764,
-0.004549650475382805,
-0.7174580097198486,
0.7514607310295105,
0.2891029119491577,
-0.23363535106182098,
0.818248450756073,
0.7151395082473755,
-0.4600936472415924,
0.22869929671287537,
-0.5780823826789856,
-0.036280758678913116,
-0.3738403618335724,
0.34787359833717346,
-0.5108543634414673,
-1.238901972770691,
0.438433974981308,
-0.16474197804927826,
-0.06034580618143082,
0.2805939018726349,
0.4632547199726105,
-0.210155189037323,
0.955650269985199,
1.163245677947998,
-0.34979528188705444,
0.7913191914558411,
-0.07792594283819199,
0.46869775652885437,
-0.6720182299613953,
-0.3391399383544922,
-0.4773736596107483,
-0.29781219363212585,
-0.8575048446655273,
-0.11627116799354553,
0.48053842782974243,
0.28723812103271484,
-0.10905037075281143,
0.3611762523651123,
-0.6693481802940369,
0.27017098665237427,
0.6896538138389587,
0.2204919308423996,
0.18516066670417786,
0.3770294487476349,
0.1828254610300064,
-0.030647512525320053,
-0.3833790123462677,
-0.5475575923919678,
1.3442312479019165,
0.5293235182762146,
0.15884940326213837,
0.08630829304456711,
0.8196287155151367,
0.5157182216644287,
0.305883526802063,
-0.28938281536102295,
0.2142479121685028,
-0.4528054893016815,
-0.5072228312492371,
-0.6552928686141968,
-0.4768518805503845,
-1.0181752443313599,
0.37391048669815063,
-0.5094172954559326,
-1.3015720844268799,
0.49986210465431213,
0.22838960587978363,
-0.14584892988204956,
0.043941695243120193,
-1.0240143537521362,
0.7979177832603455,
-0.12452636659145355,
-0.2984560430049896,
0.0413551963865757,
-0.7179946303367615,
0.14861655235290527,
-0.20702138543128967,
0.3716624677181244,
-0.07555996626615524,
-0.2760230600833893,
0.5100501775741577,
-0.11914891749620438,
0.7818436622619629,
-0.23403021693229675,
0.17169329524040222,
-0.046148885041475296,
-0.42265740036964417,
0.1956310123205185,
0.394365519285202,
-0.2992827296257019,
0.3342616856098175,
0.06224551424384117,
-0.3551015257835388,
-0.7219700813293457,
0.7165480256080627,
-0.631243884563446,
-0.5156360864639282,
-0.20364315807819366,
-0.42486244440078735,
-0.33566418290138245,
0.1608513444662094,
0.7010914087295532,
0.18958276510238647,
-0.3367982506752014,
0.46119561791419983,
0.8349975347518921,
-0.043576281517744064,
0.7325583100318909,
-0.07098346203565598,
0.1661454439163208,
-0.6932961344718933,
0.9103356599807739,
-0.027071980759501457,
-0.2758670747280121,
0.8279402852058411,
0.4402881860733032,
-0.2727966606616974,
-0.4569239914417267,
-0.31071150302886963,
-0.15484315156936646,
-0.3519715964794159,
-0.1119299903512001,
-0.659464955329895,
-0.16502828896045685,
-0.6729806661605835,
-0.20221416652202606,
0.03831218183040619,
-0.3929124176502228,
-0.1862875372171402,
0.16525332629680634,
0.08251345157623291,
0.45380815863609314,
0.11503655463457108,
0.1781785488128662,
-0.5040380954742432,
0.03546435013413429,
0.2257927656173706,
0.387012779712677,
-0.23830962181091309,
-0.03604893013834953,
-0.15328162908554077,
-0.052241019904613495,
-0.17689695954322815,
-0.8295952081680298,
0.3236650824546814,
0.46495532989501953,
0.5250998735427856,
0.5844319462776184,
0.07848428189754486,
0.35836783051490784,
-0.6216560006141663,
0.5668289661407471,
0.3484283983707428,
-0.8929668664932251,
0.9198524355888367,
-0.09842167794704437,
-0.006242468953132629,
0.7421207427978516,
0.39902806282043457,
-0.33821648359298706,
-0.22662878036499023,
-0.6193358302116394,
-0.6451277136802673,
0.30782201886177063,
0.44072720408439636,
0.1218915805220604,
0.14050833880901337,
0.4931059181690216,
0.32537874579429626,
0.6077679395675659,
-0.7499255537986755,
-0.019163215532898903,
-0.29686853289604187,
-0.4075967073440552,
-0.11404912173748016,
-0.2754017114639282,
0.006943709682673216,
-0.15963904559612274,
0.2781449258327484,
-0.2743942141532898,
0.38632553815841675,
0.45876187086105347,
0.11068268120288849,
0.31868496537208557,
0.3662802577018738,
0.7864965796470642,
0.7334048748016357,
-0.08505041152238846,
-0.08001965284347534,
0.1367061734199524,
-0.664298415184021,
0.036322928965091705,
-0.0368676632642746,
-0.45251965522766113,
0.13007186353206635,
0.4759388566017151,
0.9610254764556885,
0.0880289375782013,
-0.477685809135437,
0.8584491014480591,
-0.15232622623443604,
-0.21521718800067902,
-0.3792587220668793,
0.40989795327186584,
-0.41793254017829895,
0.14258421957492828,
0.40900906920433044,
0.04604004696011543,
0.4328209459781647,
-0.578176736831665,
0.1604083627462387,
0.32454749941825867,
-0.37016403675079346,
-0.23620904982089996,
0.42854174971580505,
0.16679279506206512,
-0.4414929747581482,
0.11233794689178467,
0.08177150040864944,
-0.35618823766708374,
0.5547559857368469,
0.1397712081670761,
0.9911626577377319,
-0.5584056377410889,
-0.04711898788809776,
0.33096936345100403,
-0.21569794416427612,
0.12736867368221283,
0.0631452351808548,
-0.4280330538749695,
-0.5657735466957092,
-0.04815179482102394,
-0.28800052404403687,
-0.4873821437358856,
0.007356305606663227,
-0.7585673928260803,
0.010231148451566696,
-0.8206988573074341,
-0.1747676581144333,
-0.09392954409122467,
0.010374397039413452,
-0.6268320083618164,
0.41532784700393677,
0.022101497277617455,
0.5547116994857788,
-0.6614971160888672,
0.8596975803375244,
0.8275706768035889,
0.15238501131534576,
-0.19430595636367798,
0.4061329662799835,
-0.14684411883354187,
-0.2677309811115265,
0.46585115790367126,
0.6653345227241516,
0.19712959229946136,
-0.4441591799259186,
-0.3272813558578491,
-0.8113653659820557,
1.268635630607605,
0.010269954800605774,
-0.6415554881095886,
0.185614213347435,
0.19356226921081543,
0.5164647102355957,
-0.86606365442276,
-0.014266174286603928,
0.4270029067993164,
0.36727026104927063,
0.07027428597211838,
-0.8521881699562073,
-0.20433729887008667,
-0.051592569798231125,
0.5715160369873047,
-0.07830982655286789,
-0.27079451084136963,
0.5662133693695068,
0.10890886932611465,
-0.34383484721183777,
0.0630340501666069,
0.80772465467453,
0.1899425983428955,
0.9900146722793579,
0.43478402495384216,
0.29076457023620605,
1.085608959197998,
-0.06939882040023804,
0.9686006903648376,
-0.4129313826560974,
0.33434370160102844,
0.9612549543380737,
-0.2409762442111969,
1.0534758567810059,
0.2093348205089569,
0.07724562287330627,
0.49947553873062134,
0.6538757085800171,
-0.06254229694604874,
0.7794246673583984,
-0.001418315339833498,
-0.47054746747016907,
0.21909020841121674,
0.11635366827249527,
-0.2995816171169281,
0.5321398973464966,
0.4375552237033844,
-0.4468931555747986,
0.21411773562431335,
0.3002002537250519,
-0.18715757131576538,
0.29003825783729553,
-0.32903972268104553,
1.1926217079162598,
-0.40463775396347046,
-0.4011334478855133,
0.21149922907352448,
0.32314637303352356,
0.9111207127571106,
-0.30143409967422485,
0.20839343965053558,
-0.018376726657152176,
0.09925176948308945,
-0.21807008981704712,
-0.570742130279541,
0.3819865882396698,
0.2104095220565796,
-0.7293895483016968,
-0.19984373450279236,
0.9233120083808899,
-0.37551212310791016,
-0.47872379422187805,
0.15287204086780548,
0.15967372059822083,
0.013262610882520676,
-0.15761271119117737,
-0.5841313600540161,
-0.10691240429878235,
-0.05524871125817299,
-0.047179631888866425,
0.6474310755729675,
0.44922780990600586,
-0.37617483735084534,
0.5280798673629761,
0.46052491664886475,
-0.22605140507221222,
-0.05584919825196266,
-0.1471254974603653,
0.7062193751335144,
-0.6524417400360107,
-0.99732506275177,
-0.7319422364234924,
0.47630825638771057,
-0.5576781034469604,
-0.37104418873786926,
0.3526259958744049,
0.5854148864746094,
1.0695815086364746,
-0.0013176706852391362,
0.8946965932846069,
0.00045360883814282715,
0.8920605182647705,
-0.4315324127674103,
0.6334112286567688,
-0.039996057748794556,
0.2731620967388153,
-0.2571060061454773,
-0.8789510130882263,
-0.4766054153442383,
0.6377468109130859,
-0.5058252811431885,
0.12128898501396179,
0.46900665760040283,
0.5551707744598389,
-0.008875624276697636,
-0.015846431255340576,
0.6033836603164673,
-0.31025606393814087,
0.21686941385269165,
0.4840475916862488,
0.37343263626098633,
-0.43765461444854736,
0.02463040128350258,
-0.5239758491516113,
-0.5791406035423279,
-0.11322975158691406,
-0.9195036888122559,
-1.0353245735168457,
-0.6237449645996094,
-0.36624038219451904,
0.3207881450653076,
0.12584300339221954,
0.30255627632141113,
0.988166868686676,
-1.148561716079712,
-0.09964670240879059,
-0.06533537060022354,
0.1375323385000229,
-0.024638937786221504,
-0.22700202465057373,
0.3769451677799225,
-0.2851656377315521,
-0.7591017484664917,
0.3837496340274811,
0.49954473972320557,
0.2337232381105423,
-0.03488853946328163,
-0.014383388683199883,
0.060582004487514496,
-0.22942101955413818,
0.4864499568939209,
0.36525627970695496,
-0.7930819392204285,
-0.34032246470451355,
-0.2911108434200287,
0.037765294313430786,
-0.0477573424577713,
1.013839840888977,
-0.6668163537979126,
0.35550686717033386,
0.5707131624221802,
0.8356048464775085,
0.2192886471748352,
0.42711153626441956,
0.6094508767127991,
-0.8710857033729553,
0.41415876150131226,
0.17022019624710083,
0.1985962837934494,
0.22545386850833893,
-0.9794699549674988,
0.5451430082321167,
0.18821190297603607,
-0.3695405423641205,
-0.6012013554573059,
0.20274323225021362,
-0.6217896342277527,
-0.5481973886489868,
0.535941481590271,
-0.5672392249107361,
-0.2535841166973114,
-0.06247617304325104,
0.18734298646450043,
-0.17831891775131226,
-0.4563613533973694,
0.6559293270111084,
0.513922929763794,
-0.3758084177970886,
-0.27707308530807495,
-0.2839682102203369,
0.5592894554138184,
0.21079358458518982,
-0.5512497425079346,
-0.12498800456523895,
0.24999792873859406,
0.1315566748380661,
0.30137374997138977,
0.2965919077396393,
-0.04938889667391777,
0.17747017741203308,
-0.4323011636734009,
-0.13862408697605133,
-0.11213602125644684,
-0.7250545620918274,
-0.5004894733428955,
0.4992825984954834,
-0.4319242835044861,
-0.2311578094959259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02834v1 | Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis Techniques: A Comparative Study | 2024-07-03T06:21:07 | 2024-07-03T06:21:07 | Dineth Jayakody, Koshila Isuranda, A V A Malkith, Nisansa de Silva, Sachintha Rajith Ponnamperuma, G G N Sandamali, K L K Sudheera | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since the dawn of the digitalisation era, customer feedback and online
reviews are unequivocally major sources of insights for businesses.
Consequently, conducting comparative analyses of such sources has become the de
facto modus operandi of any business that wishes to give itself a competitive
edge over its peers and improve customer loyalty. Sentiment analysis is one
such method instrumental in gauging public interest, exposing market trends,
and analysing competitors. While traditional sentiment analysis focuses on
overall sentiment, as the needs advance with time, it has become important to
explore public opinions and sentiments on various specific subjects, products
and services mentioned in the reviews on a finer-granular level. To this end,
Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA), supported by advances in Artificial
Intelligence (AI) techniques which have contributed to a paradigm shift from
simple word-level analysis to tone and context-aware analyses, focuses on
identifying specific aspects within the text and determining the sentiment
associated with each aspect. In this study, we compare several deep-NN methods
for ABSA on two benchmark datasets (Restaurant14 and Laptop-14) and found that
FAST LSA obtains the best overall results of 87.6% and 82.6% accuracy but does
not pass LSA+DeBERTa which reports 90.33% and 86.21% accuracy respectively. | [
-0.6959993839263916,
-0.881438672542572,
0.516467273235321,
0.5156508088111877,
-0.3952995240688324,
0.17400942742824554,
0.035660888999700546,
-0.6682605147361755,
0.5018981695175171,
0.2867084741592407,
-0.49981003999710083,
-0.5710155963897705,
-0.05859004333615303,
0.3804045617580414,
-0.22895146906375885,
0.7607082724571228,
0.008346154354512691,
0.31490039825439453,
-0.2610282897949219,
-0.5672035217285156,
-0.3226289749145508,
-0.7193633913993835,
-0.7382002472877502,
-0.3021402955055237,
0.2552679479122162,
0.25384241342544556,
0.5431140661239624,
0.008339516818523407,
0.7551224231719971,
0.35216349363327026,
-0.4427100718021393,
0.29741066694259644,
0.0535045824944973,
0.11312098056077957,
-0.26894140243530273,
-0.3860672116279602,
-0.48732197284698486,
-0.18431247770786285,
0.207607239484787,
0.6429079174995422,
0.13856124877929688,
0.10873352736234665,
0.259878545999527,
1.4585069417953491,
-0.4754525125026703,
0.1602514386177063,
-0.2222813367843628,
0.06838379055261612,
0.011276056058704853,
0.14088012278079987,
0.08012648671865463,
-0.3860476016998291,
0.12083756178617477,
-0.11837661266326904,
0.011649182066321373,
-0.1719115674495697,
0.9046341776847839,
0.12827369570732117,
-0.1123710498213768,
-0.5722894072532654,
-0.885768473148346,
0.8376632928848267,
-1.0015655755996704,
0.42078980803489685,
0.1784875988960266,
0.18755389750003815,
0.24767827987670898,
-0.34360015392303467,
-0.7070213556289673,
-0.027457837015390396,
0.003218409139662981,
0.11839645355939865,
-0.06941449642181396,
-0.030492564663290977,
-0.004596997983753681,
0.8827642798423767,
-0.13657166063785553,
0.27181145548820496,
-0.12916123867034912,
0.08541223406791687,
0.7797496318817139,
0.25995728373527527,
-0.0455034077167511,
-0.770957350730896,
-0.3275974988937378,
-0.17037002742290497,
-0.6371158957481384,
0.4651729166507721,
0.3661936819553375,
0.21747303009033203,
-0.14444325864315033,
0.28471091389656067,
-0.7628734707832336,
0.510708749294281,
0.31254440546035767,
-0.15023501217365265,
0.45987725257873535,
-0.552458643913269,
-0.3942832946777344,
0.07695970684289932,
0.9326451420783997,
0.6768060922622681,
-0.12508441507816315,
0.2295013964176178,
-0.45284926891326904,
0.10603565722703934,
0.1978977918624878,
-0.6814530491828918,
-0.08467819541692734,
0.5810849666595459,
-0.8482906818389893,
-0.4443832039833069,
0.13077469170093536,
-1.1248904466629028,
-0.6854860782623291,
-0.4909939467906952,
0.032046202570199966,
-0.24874353408813477,
-0.1933705359697342,
-0.5175857543945312,
0.11154681444168091,
0.7718151211738586,
0.42272862792015076,
-0.33086130023002625,
0.11813069134950638,
1.0931118726730347,
1.1906960010528564,
-0.10895265638828278,
0.2986299991607666,
0.0892728716135025,
-0.5149540901184082,
-0.5024633407592773,
0.9442809820175171,
-0.49763402342796326,
-0.4305593967437744,
0.0023286601062864065,
-0.26446059346199036,
0.3022204339504242,
-0.6583330035209656,
0.6276221871376038,
-0.44961050152778625,
-0.01680348627269268,
-0.4885806441307068,
-0.45427584648132324,
-0.8167766332626343,
0.6862253546714783,
-0.750942051410675,
1.0241186618804932,
-0.004263482987880707,
-0.6779440641403198,
0.43454742431640625,
-0.6174336075782776,
-0.5835026502609253,
-0.1762077361345291,
-0.30813437700271606,
-0.7111409306526184,
0.5351132154464722,
0.9194997549057007,
0.5138536095619202,
-0.25421857833862305,
-0.08289919793605804,
-0.2739372253417969,
-0.08090274035930634,
0.5931360125541687,
-0.4214960038661957,
0.3496656119823456,
0.3043946921825409,
-0.6183277368545532,
0.2444494217634201,
-0.42851486802101135,
0.0034557944163680077,
-0.15682095289230347,
-0.019854053854942322,
-0.5264068245887756,
-0.06241479143500328,
0.04275388643145561,
0.17868191003799438,
0.23166094720363617,
-0.6587701439857483,
0.08085619658231735,
-0.7956711053848267,
0.4712975323200226,
0.49801716208457947,
0.38883206248283386,
0.31858330965042114,
-0.17310209572315216,
0.5570897459983826,
0.09471862763166428,
0.38998717069625854,
-0.08877761662006378,
-0.4340226948261261,
-0.832317054271698,
-0.11750440299510956,
0.3472878634929657,
0.5004703998565674,
-0.6741489171981812,
0.5955583453178406,
-0.34492242336273193,
-0.7945138812065125,
-0.8421860933303833,
0.15085025131702423,
0.37386226654052734,
0.30394303798675537,
0.2854602634906769,
-0.854367196559906,
-0.29131120443344116,
-0.9377279877662659,
-0.3812171518802643,
-0.0505499430000782,
0.2586367428302765,
0.37757545709609985,
0.06220170482993126,
0.030884087085723877,
0.9447634816169739,
-0.33394497632980347,
-0.6669913530349731,
-0.7756572365760803,
0.08374980092048645,
0.3399801552295685,
0.0850357860326767,
0.7505242228507996,
-0.8763898611068726,
-0.7300641536712646,
0.17804022133350372,
-0.6349952816963196,
0.16140471398830414,
-0.08862634748220444,
0.36835944652557373,
0.6642228960990906,
0.21661679446697235,
-0.23027768731117249,
0.7046669125556946,
0.44204145669937134,
-0.14857187867164612,
0.3214387595653534,
0.13020829856395721,
0.49145999550819397,
-1.109450340270996,
-0.09730633348226547,
0.3425300121307373,
-0.17335280776023865,
-0.5415953397750854,
0.029360363259911537,
-0.08840353786945343,
-0.2694084644317627,
-0.5903730392456055,
0.28087666630744934,
-0.37539777159690857,
-0.2925625145435333,
-0.6021282076835632,
-0.07905988395214081,
0.33219799399375916,
0.5092566609382629,
-0.01575888879597187,
0.8186190128326416,
0.5020321607589722,
-0.5524364709854126,
0.29701584577560425,
-0.024808816611766815,
-0.5360851883888245,
0.8292794227600098,
-0.6667740345001221,
0.3427927494049072,
0.044359415769577026,
0.10924551635980606,
-1.0570746660232544,
0.22920861840248108,
0.42073315382003784,
-0.46290844678878784,
0.1323152482509613,
0.2516651451587677,
-0.2557883560657501,
-0.23254269361495972,
-0.684012770652771,
0.08856973052024841,
0.23543374240398407,
-0.2897443175315857,
0.7942454814910889,
0.17230744659900665,
-0.28299087285995483,
-0.5219960808753967,
-0.571391224861145,
0.1136857271194458,
-0.23710131645202637,
-0.30846965312957764,
0.2147332727909088,
0.31853994727134705,
-0.7385913729667664,
0.03258642926812172,
-0.2666124701499939,
-0.20953108370304108,
-0.031023811548948288,
0.43890830874443054,
-0.16168415546417236,
-0.2778940796852112,
-0.4764132797718048,
0.011232392862439156,
-0.16253261268138885,
0.06195538863539696,
0.3620714545249939,
0.592789888381958,
-0.45595237612724304,
-0.13001586496829987,
-1.1505321264266968,
0.29807618260383606,
0.6625144481658936,
-0.3266487121582031,
0.6228694319725037,
0.41140028834342957,
-0.0985657274723053,
0.08899106830358505,
-0.6158426403999329,
-0.1489587128162384,
-0.49592235684394836,
0.4605477452278137,
-0.16052033007144928,
-0.2420089989900589,
0.5212539434432983,
-0.1108596920967102,
-0.13115641474723816,
0.4842754602432251,
0.3104740381240845,
-0.12923423945903778,
0.6172228455543518,
0.6562747359275818,
-0.781838059425354,
0.566988468170166,
-0.2928756773471832,
0.5488855838775635,
-0.9495481252670288,
-0.3094960153102875,
-0.6515973806381226,
-0.5844923853874207,
-0.5812907814979553,
-0.18920400738716125,
0.1707853078842163,
0.11614427715539932,
0.18395964801311493,
0.1243625283241272,
-0.5321572422981262,
0.32783809304237366,
0.3814345598220825,
0.11338216066360474,
0.21970073878765106,
-0.08461448550224304,
0.0976162701845169,
0.031737320125103,
-0.11593681573867798,
-0.47849228978157043,
0.8672656416893005,
0.4078423082828522,
0.5607866644859314,
0.09497841447591782,
0.5978224277496338,
0.5052304863929749,
0.40924543142318726,
-1.1788980960845947,
0.6211057901382446,
-0.29199495911598206,
-0.3823936879634857,
-0.30031678080558777,
-0.34304267168045044,
-0.5309197306632996,
0.1195257231593132,
-0.10052546113729477,
-0.49543243646621704,
0.48438939452171326,
-0.02392381615936756,
-0.46193498373031616,
0.4338907301425934,
-0.4995606541633606,
0.5649990439414978,
-0.4025154113769531,
-0.3345353305339813,
-0.2768363356590271,
-0.1555066853761673,
0.06084389239549637,
0.020080165937542915,
0.3658187985420227,
-0.19960422813892365,
0.15501274168491364,
0.7709274291992188,
-0.43677181005477905,
0.821719229221344,
-0.45161089301109314,
-0.09865560382604599,
0.41100308299064636,
0.06488312780857086,
0.33168378472328186,
0.22909918427467346,
-0.23304587602615356,
0.6049120426177979,
-0.24135179817676544,
-0.07663672417402267,
-0.8216667771339417,
0.9339205622673035,
-0.828284740447998,
-0.41603562235832214,
-0.4935189187526703,
-0.04580482468008995,
-0.3086547255516052,
-0.011478493921458721,
0.004294545855373144,
0.6207273006439209,
-0.3044285476207733,
0.27942174673080444,
0.39086851477622986,
-0.1496216356754303,
0.9180737137794495,
0.3949398696422577,
-0.23841555416584015,
-0.7850190997123718,
0.9116967916488647,
0.09378477185964584,
-0.16892419755458832,
0.7325233817100525,
0.19098998606204987,
-0.49186936020851135,
-0.5677920579910278,
-0.4424690008163452,
0.00968585442751646,
-0.5590994358062744,
-0.39355775713920593,
-0.40389516949653625,
0.025334371253848076,
-0.38932445645332336,
-0.14802676439285278,
-0.7025436758995056,
-0.3314039409160614,
0.004396836739033461,
-0.1778326779603958,
0.3549036681652069,
0.8645983934402466,
0.1448805183172226,
0.36081787943840027,
-0.6718828082084656,
0.23375482857227325,
0.025287345051765442,
0.22373266518115997,
0.3200753331184387,
-0.01747853122651577,
-0.05450211092829704,
-0.2325037121772766,
-0.6088635325431824,
-1.0099129676818848,
0.5666513442993164,
0.05615825206041336,
0.2835898995399475,
0.8137653470039368,
-0.06619727611541748,
0.5218008756637573,
0.1742762327194214,
1.0991005897521973,
0.09359224885702133,
-1.1427334547042847,
0.4822303056716919,
0.15086166560649872,
0.14187286794185638,
0.9288667440414429,
0.5765811204910278,
-0.5649749040603638,
-0.11545364558696747,
-0.40011510252952576,
-1.3128266334533691,
0.2834392189979553,
0.1147385984659195,
0.014955108985304832,
0.31374722719192505,
0.6134610176086426,
0.3171082139015198,
0.40725570917129517,
-0.5710080862045288,
-0.3099677264690399,
-0.26352617144584656,
-0.23358577489852905,
-0.06769610941410065,
-0.21646535396575928,
0.3701903820037842,
-0.36459603905677795,
0.5940052270889282,
-0.01761740632355213,
0.27741560339927673,
0.4665740430355072,
0.10880430787801743,
0.2142336219549179,
0.5974023938179016,
0.3531074523925781,
1.0154434442520142,
-0.1592387706041336,
-0.2065880447626114,
0.13567933440208435,
-0.42312687635421753,
0.022200902923941612,
-0.2029067873954773,
-0.3461868464946747,
0.0651918351650238,
0.3272097408771515,
0.6573294401168823,
-0.12977536022663116,
-0.21824051439762115,
0.5184302926063538,
-0.02196643315255642,
0.09146282821893692,
-0.5015382170677185,
-0.26142051815986633,
-0.17253351211547852,
0.09488920867443085,
0.3347325921058655,
-0.09805668145418167,
0.42213505506515503,
-0.6936269402503967,
0.0579795315861702,
0.40358465909957886,
-0.9845282435417175,
-0.40003353357315063,
0.043221473693847656,
0.6092710494995117,
-0.3774469494819641,
0.6779674291610718,
-0.14064562320709229,
-0.4815622568130493,
0.6388850808143616,
-0.047419849783182144,
1.2130179405212402,
-0.21617189049720764,
0.20593534409999847,
0.08074122667312622,
0.21924541890621185,
0.25869476795196533,
0.510409414768219,
0.058250874280929565,
-0.49142563343048096,
-0.512285053730011,
-0.8191715478897095,
-0.6792510747909546,
0.30844375491142273,
-0.9129162430763245,
-0.1340080201625824,
-0.7829289436340332,
-0.24093453586101532,
0.04780106619000435,
0.4205564260482788,
-0.6027379631996155,
0.4679035246372223,
-0.024067115038633347,
0.7322692275047302,
-0.7652950286865234,
0.48370715975761414,
0.9514132142066956,
-0.5035940408706665,
-0.6699382066726685,
0.4035395681858063,
-0.006520274560898542,
-0.37539416551589966,
0.3546145260334015,
0.5211471915245056,
-0.16369812190532684,
-0.613492488861084,
-0.25756874680519104,
-0.44490352272987366,
0.7965882420539856,
-0.5126652717590332,
-0.8139088153839111,
0.4271997809410095,
0.23559126257896423,
0.6238516569137573,
-0.28542807698249817,
0.2526469826698303,
0.680825412273407,
0.3692611753940582,
-0.25117895007133484,
-0.8234816789627075,
-0.007137723732739687,
-0.07309842854738235,
-0.057477690279483795,
0.3474287688732147,
-0.9437229037284851,
0.7227419018745422,
0.33677634596824646,
0.19384324550628662,
-0.0770866721868515,
1.0410112142562866,
-0.2186771184206009,
0.8531323075294495,
0.5463333129882812,
0.5252125263214111,
0.48813968896865845,
-0.013818703591823578,
0.894133985042572,
-0.3946272134780884,
0.2567911148071289,
0.8345004916191101,
-0.4115199148654938,
1.1359199285507202,
0.486404687166214,
-0.21625065803527832,
0.8346297144889832,
0.5865212082862854,
0.1986173391342163,
0.7523124814033508,
-0.1686786711215973,
0.07522653788328171,
0.07091056555509567,
-0.13537023961544037,
-0.41527223587036133,
0.584579586982727,
0.43270444869995117,
-0.3034895658493042,
-0.05771506577730179,
-0.009973151609301567,
0.011897368356585503,
0.24579842388629913,
-0.8376303315162659,
1.1752232313156128,
0.32934167981147766,
-0.5353409647941589,
-0.054949041455984116,
0.33662012219429016,
0.8811064958572388,
-0.4258849620819092,
0.16951002180576324,
-0.6536152362823486,
0.45534229278564453,
-0.35033735632896423,
-0.9664198756217957,
0.6689313650131226,
-0.01868445612490177,
-0.10708934813737869,
0.02441626973450184,
0.7256832718849182,
0.39071279764175415,
-0.5643571019172668,
0.040009453892707825,
0.5524699687957764,
-0.12785056233406067,
-0.5558879375457764,
-0.7657030820846558,
0.2136717438697815,
0.011133717373013496,
-0.17775563895702362,
0.16744469106197357,
0.34549546241760254,
-0.013428807258605957,
0.33424100279808044,
0.21326468884944916,
-0.06807811558246613,
-0.5422036647796631,
-0.012302843853831291,
0.7814462184906006,
-1.0779858827590942,
-0.9609536528587341,
-0.9443555474281311,
0.08214228600263596,
-0.4030333161354065,
-0.431990385055542,
0.9819455742835999,
0.6085355281829834,
0.7773224711418152,
0.12844905257225037,
0.6735759973526001,
-0.01184713002294302,
0.530299723148346,
-0.6030913591384888,
0.7476620078086853,
-0.37801891565322876,
0.3160559833049774,
-0.531832754611969,
-1.1098735332489014,
-0.02736002951860428,
0.5710636377334595,
-0.6272368431091309,
0.0755259320139885,
0.7001008987426758,
0.6486858129501343,
0.1935245543718338,
0.48915261030197144,
-0.15296310186386108,
-0.08514773845672607,
0.4135235548019409,
0.04814620316028595,
0.961946427822113,
-0.17212583124637604,
0.15320245921611786,
-0.6280795931816101,
-0.17037463188171387,
-0.39501622319221497,
-0.8169052600860596,
-0.7642384767532349,
-0.26346278190612793,
-0.4260168671607971,
-0.22643373906612396,
-0.083420030772686,
0.8388446569442749,
0.5741462707519531,
-1.0303930044174194,
-0.1811639666557312,
0.07443458586931229,
0.07080017030239105,
-0.8745850920677185,
-0.3656514585018158,
0.6163492202758789,
-0.24173124134540558,
-0.5283079147338867,
0.3436833322048187,
0.4073045253753662,
-0.17604511976242065,
-0.639482319355011,
0.2323574423789978,
0.2694871127605438,
0.37929168343544006,
0.579440712928772,
0.17921705543994904,
-0.6004745960235596,
-0.055617909878492355,
-0.1784147024154663,
0.18468540906906128,
0.38272783160209656,
0.9992445707321167,
-0.6963409185409546,
0.1210818663239479,
0.638292670249939,
0.6220784783363342,
0.216077983379364,
0.31578806042671204,
0.20042204856872559,
-0.6933726668357849,
0.11076119542121887,
0.23977644741535187,
0.1301102340221405,
0.7146961688995361,
-0.5198955535888672,
0.17741219699382782,
0.04213320463895798,
-0.4231344759464264,
-0.4102644622325897,
0.14238575100898743,
-1.0129395723342896,
-0.49116119742393494,
1.0440884828567505,
-0.12974803149700165,
-0.6717779040336609,
-0.1449958235025406,
-0.16591911017894745,
-0.10791386663913727,
-0.77980637550354,
1.0223122835159302,
0.3201703131198883,
-0.6145014762878418,
0.2794787883758545,
-0.18320469558238983,
0.529863178730011,
0.44444525241851807,
-0.9950302243232727,
-0.11894796043634415,
0.3188976049423218,
0.11497378349304199,
0.3352617025375366,
0.628369152545929,
-0.021418185904622078,
-0.008253723382949829,
-0.3506317138671875,
-0.13502714037895203,
-0.07699127495288849,
-0.5510029196739197,
-0.631187379360199,
0.6089819669723511,
0.1549995094537735,
-0.3979305922985077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02833v1 | LANE: Logic Alignment of Non-tuning Large Language Models and Online Recommendation Systems for Explainable Reason Generation | 2024-07-03T06:20:31 | 2024-07-03T06:20:31 | Hongke Zhao, Songming Zheng, Likang Wu, Bowen Yu, Jing Wang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | The explainability of recommendation systems is crucial for enhancing user
trust and satisfaction. Leveraging large language models (LLMs) offers new
opportunities for comprehensive recommendation logic generation. However, in
existing related studies, fine-tuning LLM models for recommendation tasks
incurs high computational costs and alignment issues with existing systems,
limiting the application potential of proven proprietary/closed-source LLM
models, such as GPT-4. In this work, our proposed effective strategy LANE
aligns LLMs with online recommendation systems without additional LLMs tuning,
reducing costs and improving explainability. This innovative approach addresses
key challenges in integrating language models with recommendation systems while
fully utilizing the capabilities of powerful proprietary models. Specifically,
our strategy operates through several key components: semantic embedding, user
multi-preference extraction using zero-shot prompting, semantic alignment, and
explainable recommendation generation using Chain of Thought (CoT) prompting.
By embedding item titles instead of IDs and utilizing multi-head attention
mechanisms, our approach aligns the semantic features of user preferences with
those of candidate items, ensuring coherent and user-aligned recommendations.
Sufficient experimental results including performance comparison, questionnaire
voting, and visualization cases prove that our method can not only ensure
recommendation performance, but also provide easy-to-understand and reasonable
recommendation logic. | [
-0.37746432423591614,
-0.6599426865577698,
1.2243019342422485,
-0.1640072762966156,
-0.3047904968261719,
-0.11415576189756393,
-0.24932575225830078,
-0.21096327900886536,
0.15227758884429932,
0.6379560828208923,
-0.9312215447425842,
-0.5365144610404968,
-0.19986844062805176,
-0.1347050964832306,
-0.12222040444612503,
1.2440309524536133,
-0.17696839570999146,
-0.024562936276197433,
-0.32178354263305664,
-0.2827511727809906,
-0.8769258260726929,
-0.061548274010419846,
-0.4545126259326935,
-0.3445080816745758,
0.5605816841125488,
0.37930622696876526,
0.6105122566223145,
0.6748484969139099,
0.4891180694103241,
0.25877898931503296,
0.2610950469970703,
0.5534233450889587,
-0.3819468915462494,
0.2142852246761322,
-0.5507474541664124,
-0.06027102470397949,
-0.756125271320343,
-0.24664509296417236,
0.21707987785339355,
0.4032703936100006,
-0.33396637439727783,
0.08682881295681,
-0.026574425399303436,
0.6929994225502014,
-0.6477497220039368,
-0.1574208289384842,
-0.714373767375946,
-0.13854637742042542,
-0.13052621483802795,
-0.31231194734573364,
-0.3906964361667633,
-0.6180508136749268,
0.3842485547065735,
-0.9627741575241089,
-0.09488193690776825,
0.46942946314811707,
0.7550541162490845,
0.14927516877651215,
-0.37452760338783264,
-0.3859662413597107,
-0.8272166848182678,
0.8134412169456482,
-0.820736825466156,
0.3436729311943054,
-0.06421736627817154,
0.5061756372451782,
-0.11285114288330078,
-0.3637646734714508,
-0.677804708480835,
0.11863507330417633,
0.18015342950820923,
0.16451936960220337,
-0.17759297788143158,
0.04735647514462471,
0.153625026345253,
0.14440780878067017,
-0.7386780381202698,
-0.06526261568069458,
0.09453007578849792,
-0.08995868265628815,
0.40573012828826904,
0.1110592931509018,
0.2473030537366867,
0.3457404375076294,
-0.5865355134010315,
0.2832302749156952,
-0.8177899718284607,
-0.010918271727859974,
0.5009194016456604,
0.6122870445251465,
0.0023068375885486603,
0.6714433431625366,
-0.24845513701438904,
0.9379095435142517,
0.6379019618034363,
-0.24450761079788208,
0.14872348308563232,
-0.49324363470077515,
-0.22861240804195404,
0.3591717779636383,
0.7110400199890137,
0.7365031242370605,
0.4373866021633148,
-0.29068225622177124,
-0.0882256031036377,
0.06578182429075241,
0.22281336784362793,
-0.6225500702857971,
0.07109907269477844,
0.2689685821533203,
-0.24828845262527466,
-0.370339572429657,
0.0324280746281147,
-0.6362785696983337,
-0.6754158139228821,
-0.43385395407676697,
0.649074375629425,
-0.2986532151699066,
-0.20409739017486572,
0.2154022604227066,
-0.03975626453757286,
0.22846198081970215,
0.36573636531829834,
-0.9535090327262878,
0.2411700189113617,
0.5730976462364197,
0.8025019764900208,
-0.21588407456874847,
-0.054680172353982925,
-0.6855995059013367,
0.5910739302635193,
-0.2841743230819702,
1.008756399154663,
-0.5080941915512085,
0.03197378292679787,
0.09550213068723679,
0.05271098017692566,
0.11392178386449814,
-0.28742581605911255,
0.4188651144504547,
-0.5608714818954468,
0.2877258062362671,
-0.3804006278514862,
-0.8191683292388916,
-0.2414730042219162,
0.33778440952301025,
-0.3310690224170685,
0.45852816104888916,
-0.03571945056319237,
-0.5697497725486755,
0.4542990028858185,
-0.7347358465194702,
-0.25897854566574097,
0.12549933791160583,
-0.09887492656707764,
-0.2528803050518036,
-0.09343995153903961,
0.5325523614883423,
0.31820112466812134,
-0.35018008947372437,
0.48329174518585205,
-0.6953723430633545,
-0.3317486047744751,
0.17448721826076508,
-0.08470914512872696,
0.5160176753997803,
0.1262306571006775,
-0.4624558985233307,
0.6894898414611816,
-0.2797294557094574,
0.20271138846874237,
0.0484929196536541,
0.07391554117202759,
-0.13896088302135468,
0.054963529109954834,
-0.13718144595623016,
0.21860027313232422,
0.5300520062446594,
-0.5143877863883972,
0.1247524619102478,
-0.6961537599563599,
0.48308414220809937,
0.9831320643424988,
-0.1700698733329773,
0.5663068294525146,
-0.451872318983078,
0.42246344685554504,
0.09471402317285538,
0.06845612078905106,
-0.0951300710439682,
-0.3687801659107208,
-0.6378663778305054,
-0.034390803426504135,
0.11117933690547943,
0.5040180087089539,
-0.48756110668182373,
0.5823997855186462,
-0.21378950774669647,
-0.13835716247558594,
-0.5783137679100037,
0.4000016748905182,
0.2438448816537857,
0.6477031707763672,
0.44088637828826904,
0.001973643433302641,
-0.43238911032676697,
-0.9505319595336914,
-0.4491812586784363,
-0.0004713526868727058,
0.058045901358127594,
0.4895939230918884,
-0.02993948385119438,
-0.2085215449333191,
1.1089458465576172,
-0.4797920286655426,
-0.27819666266441345,
-0.5055395364761353,
-0.3057922124862671,
0.3247964084148407,
0.018015993759036064,
0.10130936652421951,
-0.317436546087265,
-0.41048842668533325,
0.08059095591306686,
-0.5557250380516052,
-0.2905554175376892,
-0.030415302142500877,
-0.35886693000793457,
0.1282484382390976,
0.24142596125602722,
-0.5070880651473999,
0.03374108299612999,
0.2886105477809906,
-0.5349395871162415,
0.17081469297409058,
-0.3849829435348511,
-0.16040757298469543,
-1.1131211519241333,
-0.18954205513000488,
0.18799938261508942,
-0.47891509532928467,
-0.40094906091690063,
-0.0365849994122982,
0.0103297745808959,
-0.028304196894168854,
-0.2718576192855835,
0.5042705535888672,
-0.2456548511981964,
0.09251720458269119,
-0.4296795129776001,
0.7769060730934143,
0.19822750985622406,
0.4853018522262573,
-0.15866684913635254,
0.2979862093925476,
0.33485257625579834,
-0.44949495792388916,
0.5133775472640991,
0.15083613991737366,
-0.28426769375801086,
0.8464497327804565,
-0.6188663840293884,
0.12248289585113525,
-0.06914941221475601,
0.35721439123153687,
-0.8822816610336304,
0.1289755254983902,
0.31269773840904236,
0.08322404325008392,
0.04936876520514488,
-0.15104782581329346,
-0.1532718390226364,
0.03917741775512695,
-0.34663286805152893,
0.37486693263053894,
0.43168675899505615,
-0.6584212779998779,
0.6781003475189209,
0.36970385909080505,
0.01719466783106327,
-0.35042357444763184,
-0.1573059856891632,
-0.07519390434026718,
-0.6089044809341431,
-0.7829685807228088,
0.5675520300865173,
-0.28456300497055054,
-0.3608151972293854,
0.1031598448753357,
-0.11092585325241089,
0.30077022314071655,
-0.06854532659053802,
0.26640138030052185,
0.6146924495697021,
-0.42819517850875854,
0.19322316348552704,
-0.10848800092935562,
-0.21828004717826843,
-0.20035262405872345,
-0.9321956634521484,
0.35560283064842224,
-0.3101853132247925,
-0.2665594816207886,
-0.4776376187801361,
0.2826164662837982,
0.5561831593513489,
-0.14385731518268585,
0.5666217803955078,
0.644538164138794,
-0.05320941284298897,
-0.3673036992549896,
-0.6184706091880798,
-0.1532011181116104,
-0.4447755217552185,
-0.005873942747712135,
-0.23234277963638306,
-1.032362699508667,
-0.0030915855895727873,
-0.16425104439258575,
-0.0056336019188165665,
0.3629447817802429,
0.6760905981063843,
-0.16707569360733032,
1.211575984954834,
0.6109281182289124,
0.007491795811802149,
0.1692553460597992,
0.3062770962715149,
0.8921399712562561,
-0.8640943169593811,
-0.10668320953845978,
-0.026394542306661606,
-0.3277934789657593,
-0.6249412298202515,
-0.14101290702819824,
0.19609878957271576,
0.0832185372710228,
-0.42981991171836853,
0.2183474451303482,
-0.5184214115142822,
0.5320257544517517,
0.4125005304813385,
0.05943232402205467,
0.31399035453796387,
-0.035870350897312164,
-0.36103886365890503,
0.14320242404937744,
-0.5191980600357056,
-0.441607266664505,
1.0627703666687012,
0.22622054815292358,
0.7563527822494507,
0.42593786120414734,
0.36502403020858765,
0.22372043132781982,
-0.20318572223186493,
-0.8684244155883789,
0.4093290865421295,
-0.09626355767250061,
-0.3870726227760315,
-0.33739742636680603,
-0.20913924276828766,
-0.700857400894165,
-0.013850094750523567,
-0.4780023396015167,
-0.9211586713790894,
-0.137464702129364,
0.3284129202365875,
-0.7305392026901245,
0.2283160537481308,
-0.5723286271095276,
1.0285650491714478,
-0.49292558431625366,
-0.5752794146537781,
-0.22487159073352814,
-0.425737202167511,
0.3025011420249939,
-0.028642624616622925,
0.32762131094932556,
-0.3089008629322052,
0.10568935424089432,
0.45308607816696167,
-0.5680831074714661,
0.44009169936180115,
-0.15844304859638214,
-0.08818238973617554,
0.025951942428946495,
0.05536087974905968,
0.8014594316482544,
-0.23102542757987976,
0.19205085933208466,
-0.047488242387771606,
-0.06927940249443054,
-0.05393650010228157,
-0.7974084615707397,
1.118033528327942,
-0.5874471068382263,
-0.857526957988739,
-0.1694556176662445,
-0.6775102615356445,
-0.48587748408317566,
0.1964496672153473,
-0.05184195190668106,
0.4281810522079468,
0.18622435629367828,
-0.012998435646295547,
0.6529622673988342,
-0.24905826151371002,
0.15986290574073792,
0.48621445894241333,
-0.4268430769443512,
-0.43619900941848755,
1.2987359762191772,
-0.11915437132120132,
0.1855717897415161,
0.31838124990463257,
0.43548962473869324,
-0.5801756978034973,
-0.4403855800628662,
-0.6178076863288879,
0.3217410445213318,
-0.5566892027854919,
0.06384406983852386,
-0.5032497048377991,
0.0585300475358963,
-0.5391280651092529,
-0.37841928005218506,
-0.07286079972982407,
-0.41793984174728394,
0.13701917231082916,
-0.17873990535736084,
0.4487077593803406,
0.9180689454078674,
0.25007742643356323,
0.2788601815700531,
-0.4606882333755493,
0.21891668438911438,
0.22969597578048706,
0.5259096026420593,
-0.049455683678388596,
-0.40770915150642395,
-0.31384485960006714,
-0.2001924216747284,
-0.5398898124694824,
-0.8294350504875183,
0.21981105208396912,
-0.04917808622121811,
0.5689646601676941,
0.8982707858085632,
0.15263113379478455,
0.8115779757499695,
-0.5203459858894348,
0.6117053627967834,
0.27874213457107544,
-0.9948171973228455,
0.5858927965164185,
-0.6209820508956909,
0.3226991891860962,
0.49889177083969116,
0.2455900013446808,
-0.2685103714466095,
-0.22658716142177582,
-0.45078474283218384,
-1.0437405109405518,
0.5982513427734375,
0.09117391705513,
-0.3221147358417511,
0.22792543470859528,
0.1191510334610939,
0.16054467856884003,
0.2581978440284729,
-0.6584823131561279,
-0.12437941879034042,
-0.14335867762565613,
-0.5811188817024231,
-0.1116405799984932,
-0.12650735676288605,
-0.22438913583755493,
0.0058866641484200954,
0.8641596436500549,
-0.15063594281673431,
-0.11063798516988754,
-0.07039792090654373,
0.013348990119993687,
-0.16472026705741882,
0.4225931763648987,
0.6377986669540405,
0.783417284488678,
-0.35575225949287415,
0.038171470165252686,
0.11036692559719086,
0.1715577244758606,
0.10221454501152039,
-0.18829575181007385,
-0.1590266078710556,
-0.33552059531211853,
0.03978212550282478,
0.9059078097343445,
0.12612378597259521,
-0.5799495577812195,
0.5329900979995728,
-0.057134851813316345,
-0.1865687519311905,
-0.3980454206466675,
0.15084929764270782,
0.3465273082256317,
0.2737227976322174,
-0.21958085894584656,
0.013073939830064774,
0.0984339565038681,
-0.4793468117713928,
-0.13343355059623718,
0.7183696627616882,
-0.6041204333305359,
-0.03454863280057907,
0.458051860332489,
0.3809300661087036,
-0.1430901736021042,
0.48295873403549194,
0.04278125613927841,
-0.18558526039123535,
0.12673471868038177,
0.710048496723175,
0.9437252879142761,
0.24943089485168457,
0.2193780243396759,
0.3046879172325134,
0.0809989720582962,
-0.0555674247443676,
0.027725115418434143,
-0.2100241333246231,
-1.011238932609558,
-0.2288142442703247,
-0.5535851716995239,
-0.39852017164230347,
0.02240486443042755,
-0.4797096252441406,
0.4579622447490692,
-0.543088436126709,
-0.1240658313035965,
-0.008347634226083755,
-0.2747907042503357,
-0.4629470109939575,
0.028610941022634506,
0.17370790243148804,
0.48146843910217285,
-0.7303736805915833,
0.6626749634742737,
0.4585048258304596,
-0.31171268224716187,
-1.0097594261169434,
0.024248186498880386,
0.29121044278144836,
-0.6770876049995422,
0.35117489099502563,
0.25513067841529846,
-0.5486827492713928,
0.05395908281207085,
-0.15134787559509277,
-0.7886337637901306,
1.1945616006851196,
0.32870036363601685,
-0.7057663202285767,
0.02154609002172947,
-0.14634104073047638,
0.21954216063022614,
-0.7685909867286682,
0.47275131940841675,
0.30183929204940796,
0.7071839570999146,
0.2787863612174988,
-0.6226886510848999,
0.39968371391296387,
-0.021538035944104195,
-0.07556101679801941,
0.3738642930984497,
-0.39306846261024475,
0.4834677278995514,
-0.416124552488327,
-0.18740791082382202,
-0.033923279494047165,
0.18282091617584229,
0.5874273777008057,
0.2694587707519531,
0.6352953314781189,
0.8026052117347717,
0.828887939453125,
-0.02026674710214138,
0.9657752513885498,
-0.3956651985645294,
-0.01704452745616436,
1.3038967847824097,
-0.6978200674057007,
0.6686720848083496,
0.5754334926605225,
0.1098058894276619,
0.9528736472129822,
0.5919317007064819,
-0.08305402845144272,
0.6473056674003601,
0.16010281443595886,
-0.173143208026886,
-0.6626226902008057,
-0.32372549176216125,
-0.24969439208507538,
0.181838259100914,
0.10745897144079208,
-0.3036956489086151,
-0.25245770812034607,
-0.27917686104774475,
-0.16537106037139893,
-0.08251184225082397,
-0.1916482150554657,
1.0067704916000366,
-0.05989206209778786,
-0.885331392288208,
0.17869246006011963,
0.07185550034046173,
0.5073038935661316,
-0.6779128909111023,
-0.050466906279325485,
0.15648074448108673,
0.4361075460910797,
-0.3472418785095215,
-0.5732970833778381,
-0.029674233868718147,
0.06416213512420654,
-0.37761595845222473,
-0.3269266188144684,
0.5242704153060913,
-0.41024985909461975,
-0.5511183738708496,
0.32934096455574036,
0.5155322551727295,
0.13956283032894135,
0.07200406491756439,
-0.49609649181365967,
-0.26314878463745117,
0.11552325636148453,
0.12475066632032394,
0.3995356857776642,
0.4124523103237152,
-0.1314990371465683,
0.698462188243866,
0.82774418592453,
0.18985611200332642,
-0.34629446268081665,
0.28960075974464417,
0.5048573613166809,
-0.7654708027839661,
-0.5288758277893066,
-1.217034101486206,
0.5181697607040405,
-0.02296377904713154,
-0.11902125179767609,
0.952204167842865,
0.3156810998916626,
0.5879632234573364,
0.160001739859581,
0.7575106024742126,
0.3181835412979126,
0.40587928891181946,
-0.5701298117637634,
0.47963663935661316,
-0.5941810011863708,
0.5543568730354309,
-0.314435750246048,
-0.9557112455368042,
-0.021930890157818794,
0.47978225350379944,
-0.3682594299316406,
0.15595443546772003,
0.8619269132614136,
0.8362751603126526,
0.06856480985879898,
-0.0492728017270565,
0.33098024129867554,
0.14375117421150208,
0.2875758707523346,
0.7658520340919495,
0.6718302369117737,
0.05265643820166588,
0.5821318626403809,
0.24363209307193756,
-0.2259867936372757,
-0.21491074562072754,
-1.1421793699264526,
-0.8484101295471191,
-0.26181989908218384,
-0.3021567165851593,
-0.36920657753944397,
0.15348686277866364,
1.0129101276397705,
0.602970540523529,
-0.908727765083313,
-0.2879517376422882,
-0.17411795258522034,
0.32335329055786133,
-0.2403630018234253,
-0.24048268795013428,
0.23602671921253204,
-0.2901650369167328,
-0.338944673538208,
0.573657214641571,
0.6392843127250671,
-0.23370255529880524,
-0.3173707127571106,
-0.2561437785625458,
-0.09602193534374237,
0.25231876969337463,
0.36826831102371216,
-0.13804619014263153,
-1.2100322246551514,
-0.20795689523220062,
-0.007290055975317955,
0.08953236043453217,
-0.08021322637796402,
0.7757633328437805,
-0.7489107251167297,
0.6378154158592224,
0.406627357006073,
0.4687266945838928,
0.36995652318000793,
0.19444648921489716,
1.0339761972427368,
-0.14297343790531158,
-0.5187168121337891,
-0.19430169463157654,
0.4451408386230469,
0.3582174479961395,
-0.38553813099861145,
0.15779313445091248,
-0.009311913512647152,
-0.6707086563110352,
-0.4953993260860443,
0.3512149155139923,
-1.1842169761657715,
-0.23098662495613098,
0.9886531829833984,
-0.1413244754076004,
0.03862161934375763,
-0.22215983271598816,
-0.17487648129463196,
0.12099368125200272,
-0.6038619875907898,
0.6336641311645508,
0.8316183686256409,
-0.31055569648742676,
0.00544774578884244,
-0.3983808755874634,
0.38864022493362427,
0.26199042797088623,
-0.5249699354171753,
0.06988150626420975,
0.45416781306266785,
0.3993029296398163,
0.007941083051264286,
0.4141120910644531,
-0.028314806520938873,
0.05024014785885811,
-0.4637581706047058,
-0.06751459091901779,
-0.2550698220729828,
-0.3052595257759094,
-0.379367470741272,
0.21126757562160492,
0.16426736116409302,
0.003161319065839052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02820v1 | Investigating the Contextualised Word Embedding Dimensions Responsible for Contextual and Temporal Semantic Changes | 2024-07-03T05:42:20 | 2024-07-03T05:42:20 | Taichi Aida, Danushka Bollegala | cs.CL | cs.CL | Words change their meaning over time as well as in different contexts. The
sense-aware contextualised word embeddings (SCWEs) such as the ones produced by
XL-LEXEME by fine-tuning masked langauge models (MLMs) on Word-in-Context (WiC)
data attempt to encode such semantic changes of words within the contextualised
word embedding (CWE) spaces. Despite the superior performance of SCWEs in
contextual/temporal semantic change detection (SCD) benchmarks, it remains
unclear as to how the meaning changes are encoded in the embedding space. To
study this, we compare pre-trained CWEs and their fine-tuned versions on
contextual and temporal semantic change benchmarks under Principal Component
Analysis (PCA) and Independent Component Analysis (ICA) transformations. Our
experimental results reveal several novel insights such as (a) although there
exist a smaller number of axes that are responsible for semantic changes of
words in the pre-trained CWE space, this information gets distributed across
all dimensions when fine-tuned, and (b) in contrast to prior work studying the
geometry of CWEs, we find that PCA to better represent semantic changes than
ICA. Source code is available at https://github.com/LivNLP/svp-dims . | [
-0.3917509913444519,
-0.47258901596069336,
0.5232602953910828,
0.2052503228187561,
-0.38550397753715515,
-0.28847387433052063,
-0.26525944471359253,
-0.50858473777771,
0.1928260624408722,
0.10192593932151794,
-0.6797770857810974,
-0.5745847821235657,
-0.6515791416168213,
0.044876500964164734,
-0.08487679064273834,
0.320770800113678,
-0.38380640745162964,
0.20498396456241608,
-0.09321021288633347,
-0.7049538493156433,
-0.6873448491096497,
-0.5892668962478638,
-0.2045377641916275,
-0.027478637173771858,
0.4706661105155945,
-0.05560800060629845,
0.4237729609012604,
0.6854720711708069,
0.25959330797195435,
0.23685918748378754,
-0.28484830260276794,
0.21514685451984406,
-0.18953628838062286,
0.04097018018364906,
-0.5084956288337708,
-0.28205305337905884,
-0.21941132843494415,
0.27399513125419617,
0.512227475643158,
0.7543767690658569,
0.006112792994827032,
0.2085542529821396,
0.3083581328392029,
0.4259244501590729,
-1.0958389043807983,
0.5540077686309814,
-0.9365323185920715,
0.1983059197664261,
-0.1447952687740326,
-0.46189549565315247,
-0.33178478479385376,
0.26400014758110046,
0.051218584179878235,
-0.6079553961753845,
0.13625384867191315,
-0.06551837921142578,
0.8996533751487732,
0.3574834167957306,
-0.4368434548377991,
-0.21228979527950287,
-0.44297417998313904,
0.8876073956489563,
-0.5954235792160034,
0.9244637489318848,
-0.01220215018838644,
0.06915293633937836,
-0.19917172193527222,
-0.5338876843452454,
-0.7584463357925415,
-0.00810220092535019,
-0.11169511079788208,
0.01907564513385296,
-0.22118166089057922,
-0.1366891711950302,
0.06642984598875046,
0.0066809686832129955,
-0.09566082805395126,
0.33785101771354675,
0.030228573828935623,
-0.1314377784729004,
0.49584564566612244,
0.10869598388671875,
0.0961153581738472,
-0.3349001705646515,
-0.5278996229171753,
-0.5983375906944275,
-0.6795914173126221,
0.16048654913902283,
-0.10599290579557419,
0.36724480986595154,
-0.15210875868797302,
0.42253369092941284,
-0.044259168207645416,
0.5238873958587646,
0.04440911486744881,
-0.04714353010058403,
0.3395126163959503,
-0.3865053355693817,
-0.46886569261550903,
0.19717460870742798,
0.2692822515964508,
0.38964253664016724,
-0.03127020224928856,
-0.05402464047074318,
0.013580222614109516,
0.494182288646698,
-0.000895258563105017,
-0.6599098443984985,
0.18996939063072205,
-0.007560971658676863,
-0.5276327133178711,
-0.14769163727760315,
0.13197237253189087,
-0.0525575652718544,
-0.26458579301834106,
-0.844544529914856,
0.4000476598739624,
-0.575339674949646,
0.014247068203985691,
0.4380492568016052,
-0.2429688423871994,
0.6519141793251038,
0.45453113317489624,
-0.5132929086685181,
-0.09048327803611755,
0.5370713472366333,
0.3591171205043793,
-0.2684253454208374,
-0.45739638805389404,
-0.15326297283172607,
0.3217102885246277,
-0.6586261987686157,
0.63079833984375,
-0.5734433531761169,
-0.26401400566101074,
0.09967575967311859,
0.3446701169013977,
-0.33369457721710205,
-0.3770022392272949,
0.13258379697799683,
-0.49000096321105957,
0.13758768141269684,
-0.6963794231414795,
-0.6383247375488281,
0.07661769539117813,
0.1852647364139557,
-0.18509063124656677,
0.9784854054450989,
0.06127269193530083,
-0.8251653909683228,
1.044952154159546,
-0.421781063079834,
-0.09016592800617218,
-0.018785731866955757,
-0.4487549066543579,
-0.1251586675643921,
0.6415388584136963,
0.35908353328704834,
0.6565065979957581,
0.20953911542892456,
-0.02895265631377697,
-0.2683562636375427,
-0.206524059176445,
0.46011456847190857,
-0.3865291476249695,
0.4648866355419159,
0.048243287950754166,
-0.3293174207210541,
0.053170133382081985,
-0.8272187113761902,
0.19992391765117645,
0.0821082666516304,
-0.15225568413734436,
-0.5635280609130859,
0.314075767993927,
0.11031574755907059,
0.44439592957496643,
0.19741691648960114,
-0.768169105052948,
-0.024810640141367912,
-0.018704205751419067,
0.5316047668457031,
0.9120640158653259,
0.044948261231184006,
0.4025537669658661,
0.17571474611759186,
0.11485285311937332,
0.5176725387573242,
0.1484762281179428,
-0.21792633831501007,
-0.2939726710319519,
-0.36526060104370117,
-0.17467156052589417,
0.3100421130657196,
0.37518978118896484,
-0.4910719692707062,
0.3633959889411926,
-0.3830173909664154,
-0.13109035789966583,
-0.3439295291900635,
-0.14964181184768677,
-0.03308757394552231,
0.022049209102988243,
0.5860862135887146,
-0.23972263932228088,
-0.22487898170948029,
-0.8447286486625671,
-0.5207924842834473,
0.03546007722616196,
-0.34214910864830017,
0.377765953540802,
0.3778422176837921,
-0.45693808794021606,
1.0174928903579712,
-0.5652758479118347,
-0.5043390393257141,
0.10358899086713791,
-0.06984184682369232,
-0.42323940992355347,
0.325530081987381,
0.7905735373497009,
-0.5010093450546265,
-0.2853713035583496,
0.09466441720724106,
-0.5731843709945679,
-0.25636547803878784,
-0.38757097721099854,
0.003670228412374854,
0.08039252460002899,
0.9811609387397766,
-0.42617613077163696,
0.8453224301338196,
0.524568498134613,
-0.7051466703414917,
0.41752737760543823,
-0.3673425018787384,
0.1551063358783722,
-0.8731392621994019,
-0.29397615790367126,
-0.3123514950275421,
-0.07239525765180588,
-0.19479896128177643,
0.13126914203166962,
0.4216846525669098,
-0.08783036470413208,
-0.49385637044906616,
0.4906061589717865,
-0.608128547668457,
-0.2181256264448166,
-0.06150203198194504,
0.5278407335281372,
0.06580692529678345,
0.47200486063957214,
-0.1155739352107048,
0.6450254321098328,
0.15136921405792236,
-0.5804768204689026,
-0.24600887298583984,
0.3040849268436432,
-0.3634854853153229,
0.7424706220626831,
-0.4368250072002411,
0.002982957987114787,
-0.16595731675624847,
0.1482003778219223,
-0.6727254986763,
0.22220119833946228,
-0.08081089705228806,
-0.27558353543281555,
0.4064581096172333,
0.3032899498939514,
-0.5803564190864563,
0.005898733623325825,
-0.26161471009254456,
0.39239829778671265,
-0.04075909033417702,
-0.7239269614219666,
0.49968019127845764,
0.2936358153820038,
0.17504480481147766,
-0.213945671916008,
-0.7782198786735535,
0.1986616998910904,
-0.06029535084962845,
-0.5449345111846924,
0.9541624784469604,
0.07093236595392227,
-0.2574305534362793,
0.23258206248283386,
-0.3373199701309204,
0.19766949117183685,
-0.05225595086812973,
0.18140500783920288,
-0.25331637263298035,
-0.11658991873264313,
0.41481637954711914,
0.3111739158630371,
-0.1897437572479248,
0.11541242897510529,
-0.3365764021873474,
0.4757089912891388,
-0.04245837777853012,
-0.3929865062236786,
-0.5000637173652649,
0.5017723441123962,
0.443560928106308,
-0.3764275014400482,
1.079874873161316,
0.7779901027679443,
-0.4411102533340454,
-0.2947201132774353,
-0.3396000862121582,
-0.11482644826173782,
-0.4444582164287567,
0.2547323703765869,
-0.4309711754322052,
-1.091479778289795,
0.6259943246841431,
-0.10030949115753174,
-0.19537438452243805,
0.5562032461166382,
0.24698099493980408,
-0.2336249202489853,
1.0087770223617554,
0.8489129543304443,
0.1745741367340088,
0.6369925737380981,
-0.1158653050661087,
0.26326942443847656,
-0.9890784025192261,
-0.3455113470554352,
-0.402092844247818,
-0.344597727060318,
-0.9348022937774658,
-0.7829053997993469,
0.40859293937683105,
0.2955484688282013,
-0.11954496800899506,
0.2245713770389557,
-0.27757614850997925,
0.12440667301416397,
0.13775470852851868,
-0.0915142074227333,
-0.18171802163124084,
0.0576447919011116,
-0.3224404454231262,
-0.41587400436401367,
-0.6794971823692322,
-0.2070571482181549,
0.6954763531684875,
0.2626873850822449,
0.4705179035663605,
-0.08135513961315155,
0.3265863358974457,
0.28561824560165405,
-0.10455922782421112,
-0.609732985496521,
0.6220535039901733,
-0.2837727665901184,
0.09872270375490189,
-0.13231807947158813,
-0.02697189711034298,
-1.0106422901153564,
0.5229566693305969,
-0.4160250127315521,
-0.7038128972053528,
0.6680303812026978,
-0.26369914412498474,
0.21344245970249176,
0.5191202163696289,
-0.47429120540618896,
0.7380395531654358,
0.1898723840713501,
-0.1973056048154831,
-0.64593905210495,
-0.3196290135383606,
-0.5092793107032776,
0.16167256236076355,
-0.05437696352601051,
-0.092765212059021,
-0.10361838340759277,
0.584173858165741,
-0.610755205154419,
0.710491955280304,
-0.31289419531822205,
-0.31009066104888916,
0.11572165042161942,
0.08943122625350952,
0.4520818889141083,
-0.00369148887693882,
0.32428520917892456,
0.4338272213935852,
0.18666686117649078,
-0.6688308715820312,
-0.5235750079154968,
0.8541675806045532,
-0.7160471081733704,
-0.5748926401138306,
-0.46731990575790405,
-0.4066607356071472,
-0.35915541648864746,
-0.11561739444732666,
0.15423806011676788,
0.5704439282417297,
-0.24264273047447205,
0.4436437785625458,
0.6236295700073242,
-0.6230901479721069,
0.4842633306980133,
0.5462766289710999,
0.045744895935058594,
0.16058996319770813,
0.32655206322669983,
0.3184607923030853,
0.10256058722734451,
0.5726743936538696,
0.21421754360198975,
-0.16549627482891083,
-0.3316168189048767,
-0.27284154295921326,
0.15375037491321564,
-0.7676571011543274,
-0.04002679884433746,
-0.47275248169898987,
-0.10920847952365875,
-0.39566755294799805,
-0.5460166335105896,
-0.3173052668571472,
-0.20359152555465698,
-0.243887796998024,
-0.13094687461853027,
0.3242734968662262,
0.6086387634277344,
-0.25753650069236755,
0.14404769241809845,
-0.4889970123767853,
-0.04718700051307678,
0.3559064567089081,
0.2529858946800232,
-0.2592228949069977,
-0.27140405774116516,
-0.27343642711639404,
0.08888214826583862,
0.009164306335151196,
-1.0250251293182373,
0.18178264796733856,
0.17535023391246796,
0.5511407852172852,
0.5107973217964172,
-0.21439918875694275,
0.7042047381401062,
-0.423025906085968,
1.0902587175369263,
0.04362496733665466,
-1.0446492433547974,
0.5344217419624329,
-0.24035553634166718,
0.8728296160697937,
0.2203923761844635,
-0.14233887195587158,
-0.6231459975242615,
-0.10134284198284149,
-0.35669973492622375,
-0.6194750070571899,
0.3139052987098694,
-0.03938908129930496,
0.23951898515224457,
-0.2840834856033325,
0.3653596341609955,
0.11696293205022812,
0.19016222655773163,
-0.11291520297527313,
-0.13737034797668457,
-0.18837574124336243,
0.22487357258796692,
-0.11593668907880783,
-0.5299301743507385,
0.1767120361328125,
-0.3345915675163269,
0.2773621082305908,
-0.19960325956344604,
0.5016587376594543,
0.2144717127084732,
-0.27321329712867737,
0.2690163552761078,
0.5258881449699402,
0.4519919455051422,
0.7911946177482605,
-0.08005224913358688,
0.09723169356584549,
0.5410732626914978,
-0.4744740128517151,
-0.2693703770637512,
-0.08659832179546356,
0.04747847467660904,
0.16851906478405,
0.6289206147193909,
1.0948162078857422,
0.5466414093971252,
-0.25049889087677,
0.7101491689682007,
-0.06313078105449677,
-0.08126238733530045,
-0.3080712854862213,
-0.18394923210144043,
-0.16396574676036835,
0.029808180406689644,
0.2508499026298523,
0.2463533580303192,
-0.1920849084854126,
-0.4898676872253418,
-0.05004262551665306,
0.2611567974090576,
-0.6456879377365112,
-0.5488525629043579,
0.567334771156311,
-0.24222737550735474,
0.217877596616745,
0.34131404757499695,
-0.18512079119682312,
-0.4492429196834564,
0.18084536492824554,
0.4708966016769409,
0.8248622417449951,
-0.3833046853542328,
0.26903003454208374,
0.07730071246623993,
0.25257638096809387,
0.5837955474853516,
0.37810736894607544,
-0.437692791223526,
-1.077053427696228,
-0.3161318898200989,
-0.6446103453636169,
0.13443523645401,
0.16327473521232605,
-0.987481415271759,
0.09122779220342636,
-0.3670945465564728,
-0.031537558883428574,
-0.07006709277629852,
-0.20296059548854828,
-1.2994879484176636,
0.3414273262023926,
0.03054054081439972,
0.9592257142066956,
-0.806863009929657,
0.7291093468666077,
0.6932641863822937,
0.13381579518318176,
-0.7827440500259399,
0.10911088436841965,
-0.08697047084569931,
-0.5847612619400024,
0.656772255897522,
0.10410364717245102,
-0.4424333870410919,
-0.29048609733581543,
-0.39954155683517456,
-0.7206128239631653,
1.294602632522583,
0.11550156027078629,
-0.45738211274147034,
0.2667886018753052,
0.4491543769836426,
0.728524386882782,
-0.42061930894851685,
-0.36425620317459106,
0.49931448698043823,
0.28508052229881287,
-0.401010125875473,
-0.6918414831161499,
-0.05466635897755623,
0.03573489934206009,
0.5507760047912598,
0.15669770538806915,
-0.32942578196525574,
0.802609920501709,
0.09086223691701889,
-0.6997302174568176,
-0.26453518867492676,
0.6367594003677368,
0.05810670554637909,
0.2065688967704773,
0.5136807560920715,
0.7112593650817871,
0.5024393796920776,
-0.17409829795360565,
0.9941709637641907,
-0.5127140283584595,
0.15905623137950897,
0.9733485579490662,
-0.15382972359657288,
1.1355856657028198,
0.7076969742774963,
-0.2532379627227783,
0.7310216426849365,
0.4547899663448334,
0.43014615774154663,
0.6669648885726929,
0.11498396843671799,
-0.14598916471004486,
-0.3059218227863312,
-0.07184022665023804,
-0.6201062798500061,
0.8077609539031982,
0.707216739654541,
-0.30546215176582336,
-0.23403425514698029,
0.36918044090270996,
0.18865615129470825,
0.21068128943443298,
-0.3688580095767975,
0.6166603565216064,
0.15660594403743744,
-0.06677550077438354,
0.32624948024749756,
0.2865631580352783,
0.5557074546813965,
-0.6776243448257446,
0.23403601348400116,
-0.16452842950820923,
0.4643195867538452,
0.06676246970891953,
-0.6067748069763184,
0.2589688003063202,
-0.5245848298072815,
-0.23237831890583038,
-0.44071125984191895,
0.6874544620513916,
-0.22398902475833893,
-0.28678396344184875,
0.8234726190567017,
0.4965973496437073,
-0.36546236276626587,
-0.10636115074157715,
-0.7429232001304626,
0.4615972340106964,
-0.27510374784469604,
-0.18570294976234436,
0.5353844165802002,
0.6313093900680542,
-0.38648712635040283,
0.22144554555416107,
0.48731112480163574,
0.12481239438056946,
0.13306698203086853,
0.19556854665279388,
0.7092657089233398,
-0.5963028073310852,
-0.8701177835464478,
-0.3002842962741852,
0.12604081630706787,
-0.09349770843982697,
-0.5172513723373413,
0.861315131187439,
0.1739349067211151,
1.2378458976745605,
-0.21870656311511993,
0.36759141087532043,
0.1197061762213707,
0.11171572655439377,
-0.6935495138168335,
0.5447660684585571,
-0.6458938717842102,
0.16282561421394348,
-0.2112571895122528,
-0.8958777189254761,
-0.2028016597032547,
0.5188252329826355,
-0.238469660282135,
-0.18384166061878204,
0.8011764883995056,
0.7651075124740601,
-0.0082496153190732,
0.027913570404052734,
0.3538181483745575,
0.41126716136932373,
0.22560642659664154,
0.1369413286447525,
0.5075057744979858,
-0.5218893885612488,
-0.24749864637851715,
-0.04342294856905937,
-0.004729159642010927,
-0.09501173347234726,
-0.9446336627006531,
-0.5693321228027344,
-1.1283776760101318,
-0.5384909510612488,
-0.16188114881515503,
0.07661318778991699,
0.692902684211731,
0.5616496205329895,
-0.8401424288749695,
0.20854473114013672,
-0.008507140912115574,
-0.4622941017150879,
-0.6274709105491638,
-0.23335909843444824,
0.7650415897369385,
-0.306293249130249,
-0.2989491820335388,
0.7388029098510742,
0.4949164390563965,
-0.08232830464839935,
-0.361341655254364,
0.18214647471904755,
0.049447499215602875,
0.4498692452907562,
1.1136585474014282,
-0.14303839206695557,
-0.7914467453956604,
-0.997539222240448,
-0.10588013380765915,
-0.14059312641620636,
-0.15776479244232178,
0.9758744239807129,
-0.9906436800956726,
0.4117274880409241,
0.6783674359321594,
0.4889465570449829,
0.6029248833656311,
-0.41941389441490173,
0.38583746552467346,
-0.962555468082428,
0.3733634054660797,
-0.39617758989334106,
0.558296799659729,
0.26058661937713623,
-0.20313288271427155,
0.28065526485443115,
0.34077566862106323,
-0.17522844672203064,
-0.5810511112213135,
0.21927183866500854,
-0.9967552423477173,
-0.6594738364219666,
1.0931917428970337,
-0.09507248550653458,
-0.21466469764709473,
0.1251874417066574,
0.009638830088078976,
0.08898313343524933,
0.1700638085603714,
0.6470888257026672,
0.60160893201828,
-0.010212627239525318,
0.11861107498407364,
-0.19240763783454895,
0.5829225778579712,
0.3245452046394348,
-0.5121846795082092,
-0.10959088057279587,
0.46310070157051086,
0.37785449624061584,
0.04228420928120613,
0.33260002732276917,
-0.3998333215713501,
0.07600601017475128,
0.17830780148506165,
-0.10627453029155731,
-0.0707286149263382,
-0.26564013957977295,
-0.2650093138217926,
0.16497746109962463,
-0.3670642375946045,
-0.4048956632614136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02819v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02819v1 | Efficient Training of Language Models with Compact and Consistent Next Token Distributions | 2024-07-03T05:40:41 | 2024-07-03T05:40:41 | Ashutosh Sathe, Sunita Sarawagi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Maximizing the likelihood of the next token is an established, statistically
sound objective for pre-training language models. In this paper we show that we
can train better models faster by pre-aggregating the corpus with a collapsed
$n$-gram distribution. Previous studies have proposed corpus-level $n$-gram
statistics as a regularizer; however, the construction and querying of such
$n$-grams, if done naively, prove to be costly and significantly impede
training speed, thereby limiting their application in modern large language
model pre-training.
We introduce an alternative compact representation of the next token
distribution that, in expectation, aligns with the complete $n$-gram
distribution while markedly reducing variance across mini-batches compared to
the standard next-token loss. Empirically, we demonstrate that both the
$n$-gram regularized model and our approximation yield substantial improvements
in model quality and convergence rate compared to existing methods.
Furthermore, our approximation facilitates scalability of gains to larger
datasets and models compared to the straightforward $n$-gram regularization
method. | [
-0.22542604804039001,
-0.30836132168769836,
0.4896148145198822,
-0.1230330839753151,
-0.4980131685733795,
-0.0354616679251194,
-0.6201845407485962,
-0.07114413380622864,
0.3358900845050812,
0.10338595509529114,
-0.21407455205917358,
-0.6481470465660095,
-0.7519502639770508,
0.013236623257398605,
-0.7330476641654968,
0.665677011013031,
0.30802077054977417,
0.20438171923160553,
0.06638504564762115,
0.060388050973415375,
-0.13575893640518188,
-0.7748856544494629,
-0.7844436764717102,
0.07602204382419586,
0.597294807434082,
0.11917122453451157,
0.7792099714279175,
0.6704822778701782,
0.6423662304878235,
0.3252201974391937,
-0.148224875330925,
-0.12803657352924347,
-0.616066575050354,
-0.22736063599586487,
0.29423388838768005,
-0.8527773022651672,
-0.3432626724243164,
0.1979101151227951,
1.0663337707519531,
1.2230888605117798,
-0.02578919380903244,
0.05829977989196777,
-0.11266712844371796,
0.3869286775588989,
-0.9186690449714661,
0.12424372881650925,
-0.5141541957855225,
-0.04521188884973526,
-0.48340749740600586,
-0.22269393503665924,
-0.7133610844612122,
-0.4594283401966095,
-0.17662537097930908,
-0.6446869969367981,
0.34518951177597046,
0.09480387717485428,
0.9410799145698547,
0.024671398103237152,
-0.10847961902618408,
-0.024008354172110558,
-0.5560458898544312,
0.8712962865829468,
-0.6971540451049805,
0.7967817783355713,
0.5318594574928284,
0.4477616548538208,
-0.01732589304447174,
-0.8683969974517822,
-0.5616755485534668,
-0.4050789475440979,
-0.12518884241580963,
-0.048590704798698425,
-0.0923718586564064,
0.09768974781036377,
-0.22571463882923126,
0.3024182617664337,
-0.3620210886001587,
0.24806293845176697,
-0.08800256997346878,
-0.20217537879943848,
0.27065807580947876,
0.03517773002386093,
0.13025102019309998,
0.2720179259777069,
-0.008209744468331337,
-0.4614247977733612,
-0.6252694725990295,
-0.3548654615879059,
0.6386926770210266,
0.5057840347290039,
0.007944387383759022,
0.3994161784648895,
-0.019914358854293823,
0.8574762344360352,
0.15600888431072235,
-0.3224620521068573,
0.37047460675239563,
-0.5374086499214172,
-0.13068071007728577,
-0.33633953332901,
0.5238766670227051,
0.20166845619678497,
0.2506328225135803,
-0.27244430780410767,
-0.2891713082790375,
0.13388346135616302,
0.013947528786957264,
-0.9073285460472107,
-0.3878045678138733,
-0.06009545177221298,
-0.704150378704071,
-0.23931118845939636,
0.13419483602046967,
-0.4816114008426666,
0.11260955035686493,
-0.27293550968170166,
0.18056964874267578,
-0.44821643829345703,
-0.2725517153739929,
0.2339998334646225,
-0.04077257588505745,
0.0670061856508255,
0.1777578443288803,
-1.148840069770813,
0.6732484698295593,
0.6167408227920532,
0.8843277096748352,
0.009102610871195793,
-0.02846122719347477,
-0.7209151387214661,
-0.07149919122457504,
-0.8210272192955017,
0.8798156380653381,
-0.8372723460197449,
-0.2795040011405945,
0.05563414469361305,
-0.04597577452659607,
-0.14546643197536469,
-0.5868881940841675,
0.549262523651123,
-0.5561802387237549,
0.03171241655945778,
-0.11194077879190445,
-0.711945652961731,
0.10998605936765671,
0.19894373416900635,
-0.43416526913642883,
0.7869347929954529,
0.05283932760357857,
-0.8143038153648376,
0.5755706429481506,
-0.4373483955860138,
-0.23849762976169586,
-0.11351221054792404,
-0.04180899262428284,
-0.17343272268772125,
0.4060688614845276,
0.22080716490745544,
0.5640745759010315,
-0.14720001816749573,
0.04921262711286545,
-0.5409987568855286,
-0.5293729305267334,
-0.08301158994436264,
-0.6145852208137512,
0.7345211505889893,
0.2645334303379059,
0.10562707483768463,
0.15058428049087524,
-0.7305209040641785,
-0.03370170667767525,
0.14998532831668854,
-0.4178828001022339,
-0.5665956735610962,
-0.24724751710891724,
0.232598215341568,
-0.32043489813804626,
0.24544024467468262,
-0.3046847879886627,
0.1997389942407608,
-0.48270466923713684,
0.10704898089170456,
0.7352203726768494,
-0.36409491300582886,
0.7984937429428101,
-0.13232406973838806,
0.5667449235916138,
-0.1596914380788803,
0.33856120705604553,
-0.1342775672674179,
-0.25940632820129395,
-0.5650963187217712,
-0.5031681656837463,
0.9950875639915466,
0.17175425589084625,
-0.3220197260379791,
0.48386019468307495,
-0.5303490161895752,
-0.4840867221355438,
-0.17514894902706146,
-0.07132741808891296,
0.4096316993236542,
0.24226640164852142,
0.13825465738773346,
-0.48256316781044006,
-0.5823587775230408,
-0.587313175201416,
-0.1205848902463913,
-0.33068686723709106,
-0.09561271965503693,
-0.21387258172035217,
0.21233290433883667,
-0.18775177001953125,
0.7629064321517944,
-0.48000645637512207,
-0.09115391224622726,
-0.3326631784439087,
0.07310406118631363,
0.26446297764778137,
0.526459276676178,
0.6566643118858337,
-0.8213804960250854,
-0.5911208391189575,
0.010634894482791424,
-0.18747669458389282,
-0.14460164308547974,
0.2448555827140808,
-0.18432293832302094,
0.15487024188041687,
0.8132969737052917,
-0.3964442312717438,
0.28051525354385376,
0.7353749871253967,
-0.1738085299730301,
0.5693087577819824,
-0.352100133895874,
-0.20641684532165527,
-1.055362343788147,
-0.0072386073879897594,
-0.29993119835853577,
-0.3378351628780365,
-0.745716392993927,
0.04112006723880768,
0.1357458382844925,
0.03521591052412987,
-0.3099418580532074,
0.6652200222015381,
-0.5738071203231812,
-0.3360045850276947,
-0.265554279088974,
0.16262094676494598,
-0.10138415545225143,
0.13640105724334717,
0.06406530737876892,
0.8934029340744019,
0.5725396871566772,
-0.601507306098938,
-0.24368509650230408,
0.38469135761260986,
-0.2283509522676468,
0.1301436722278595,
-0.6043583154678345,
-0.23712898790836334,
-0.2997036278247833,
0.43776434659957886,
-0.924298107624054,
-0.25048717856407166,
-0.12079039216041565,
-0.5446659922599792,
0.586355984210968,
-0.19439196586608887,
-0.7000885009765625,
-0.1296836882829666,
-0.3541310131549835,
0.5495768785476685,
0.9184778332710266,
-0.7099435925483704,
0.5141016840934753,
0.48359915614128113,
0.023671545088291168,
-0.6305485963821411,
-0.7579834461212158,
-0.01806444674730301,
-0.20353536307811737,
-0.4455377459526062,
0.27683672308921814,
-0.05131198465824127,
-0.2323419451713562,
0.11034905910491943,
0.03607424721121788,
-0.12908127903938293,
-0.04003424569964409,
-0.2998218238353729,
0.011927521787583828,
-0.15106810629367828,
0.3322559893131256,
-0.21749795973300934,
-0.3335320055484772,
-0.38958752155303955,
-0.6912481188774109,
1.01886785030365,
0.0027625912334769964,
-0.25497162342071533,
-0.37195873260498047,
0.4249033033847809,
0.23395980894565582,
-0.304364413022995,
0.9584497809410095,
0.691760241985321,
-0.3524164855480194,
0.3229164183139801,
-0.6304512619972229,
-0.18643511831760406,
-0.4484660029411316,
0.422387033700943,
-0.3249567747116089,
-0.7371158599853516,
0.5439483523368835,
0.03216678649187088,
0.15209437906742096,
0.4351685643196106,
0.552824854850769,
0.32640597224235535,
1.1002978086471558,
0.9962319135665894,
-0.1431911438703537,
0.8608667850494385,
-0.29388657212257385,
0.3573547601699829,
-0.6980463266372681,
-0.020727669820189476,
-0.6416255831718445,
0.18238167464733124,
-0.3201029598712921,
-0.6103466749191284,
0.06849321722984314,
0.3545694053173065,
-0.04228638857603073,
0.3082233667373657,
-0.12765410542488098,
0.4297901391983032,
0.6117131114006042,
-0.17970936000347137,
0.05349235609173775,
0.0030813177581876516,
-0.2441904991865158,
0.22417667508125305,
-0.9522632360458374,
-0.5179179310798645,
1.2997004985809326,
0.10525641590356827,
0.6922476291656494,
0.14665277302265167,
1.130724549293518,
-0.15035344660282135,
0.5538718700408936,
-0.6092947125434875,
0.3361740708351135,
-0.4676021337509155,
-0.34329044818878174,
-0.3649078905582428,
-0.5871397852897644,
-1.1709638833999634,
0.24327631294727325,
-0.17401623725891113,
-0.6093024015426636,
0.293023020029068,
0.31457778811454773,
-0.4334498643875122,
0.2989245057106018,
-1.1244776248931885,
0.8529460430145264,
0.2495473325252533,
0.10902069509029388,
0.13005797564983368,
-0.4634990096092224,
0.38228639960289,
-0.3050798177719116,
0.4489120543003082,
-0.07870645821094513,
-0.3728075623512268,
0.7378333806991577,
-0.9194422364234924,
0.7243401408195496,
-0.22231505811214447,
0.014262408949434757,
0.2798862159252167,
-0.24402587115764618,
0.702872097492218,
-0.1452065110206604,
0.006820582319051027,
-0.07103293389081955,
-0.1925354152917862,
-0.7466548085212708,
-0.6915317177772522,
0.28304192423820496,
-0.5051793456077576,
-0.4294477701187134,
0.023140808567404747,
-0.40308627486228943,
-0.14841535687446594,
0.2994407117366791,
0.361873984336853,
0.7354125380516052,
0.09009633958339691,
0.24552659690380096,
0.4085569679737091,
-0.1589115411043167,
0.4812101423740387,
0.06947284191846848,
-0.2550623118877411,
-0.20120340585708618,
0.739184558391571,
0.28366518020629883,
0.5838190913200378,
0.4288268983364105,
0.3898520767688751,
-0.6832427978515625,
-1.027843952178955,
0.026909789070487022,
0.1101832389831543,
-0.8562643527984619,
-0.11120493710041046,
-0.9529942274093628,
0.1532539278268814,
-0.829736590385437,
-0.18914800882339478,
-0.3810397684574127,
-0.46109601855278015,
-0.13859792053699493,
-0.1611921638250351,
0.2525603175163269,
0.31934553384780884,
-0.32319238781929016,
0.757599949836731,
-0.7631769776344299,
0.029113680124282837,
0.10594429820775986,
0.35622453689575195,
0.044076453894376755,
-0.7982396483421326,
-0.35851776599884033,
-0.3923376500606537,
0.19047267735004425,
-0.6302512288093567,
0.36784860491752625,
0.49120619893074036,
0.5282775163650513,
0.7005123496055603,
-0.03018178977072239,
0.9031655788421631,
-0.784126877784729,
0.6653677821159363,
0.4863584041595459,
-0.7610259056091309,
-0.009218091145157814,
-0.2806158661842346,
0.2817012369632721,
0.7491861581802368,
0.24497543275356293,
-0.4001665413379669,
-0.5239324569702148,
-0.7917802929878235,
-0.9457741975784302,
0.3340642750263214,
0.35356009006500244,
0.41866642236709595,
-0.5337893962860107,
0.10566052049398422,
0.06970150023698807,
0.015631992369890213,
-0.45690658688545227,
-0.2782565653324127,
-0.03304551541805267,
-0.44234704971313477,
-0.47672778367996216,
-0.4662023186683655,
0.23437941074371338,
-0.23692262172698975,
0.6683255434036255,
-0.28811079263687134,
0.3362330496311188,
-0.19525742530822754,
-0.013794130645692348,
0.4074484705924988,
-0.031208990141749382,
0.46550947427749634,
0.3738570511341095,
-0.0964955985546112,
0.3035549521446228,
0.2581232786178589,
-0.4859422743320465,
0.24734123051166534,
0.13999998569488525,
-0.10709088295698166,
0.27952927350997925,
0.46402448415756226,
0.5911851525306702,
0.5135456323623657,
-0.7095780372619629,
0.8504122495651245,
-0.3450304865837097,
-0.1807089000940323,
-0.4729253649711609,
-0.19244052469730377,
0.20347602665424347,
0.07526324689388275,
0.2503342628479004,
0.19904141128063202,
0.2942633032798767,
-0.6083481311798096,
0.4656870365142822,
0.47505536675453186,
-0.1096830666065216,
-0.27974507212638855,
0.7872652411460876,
-0.24641625583171844,
-0.20394209027290344,
0.21261179447174072,
-0.42594078183174133,
-0.29310837388038635,
0.3716708719730377,
0.5855635404586792,
0.7577425241470337,
-0.21831484138965607,
0.07854162901639938,
0.48187899589538574,
0.20280194282531738,
-0.6201863288879395,
0.13827328383922577,
-0.016522077843546867,
-0.6496235728263855,
-0.6815493702888489,
-0.8458201885223389,
-0.12647190690040588,
-0.3414497673511505,
-0.5801020860671997,
0.2919701039791107,
-0.5095624327659607,
-0.30438485741615295,
-0.16872110962867737,
-0.16550256311893463,
-0.6034002304077148,
0.24142694473266602,
0.0660189539194107,
1.0208550691604614,
-0.6397511959075928,
0.8607184290885925,
0.240290567278862,
-0.31329771876335144,
-0.9984477162361145,
0.18438196182250977,
-0.3813387155532837,
-0.6913641691207886,
0.45020791888237,
0.27212876081466675,
0.16669128835201263,
0.02981647476553917,
-0.3787148892879486,
-1.243133306503296,
0.677097499370575,
0.6435143351554871,
-0.6957617402076721,
0.010101310908794403,
-0.25864526629447937,
0.5317049026489258,
-0.3863578140735626,
0.4214940369129181,
0.6492422223091125,
0.5433944463729858,
0.14540302753448486,
-0.6159553527832031,
-0.1677026003599167,
-0.3333671987056732,
0.23180773854255676,
0.5868914723396301,
-0.5098416805267334,
1.0316014289855957,
-0.15492293238639832,
-0.4580824077129364,
0.2962207794189453,
0.8304376006126404,
0.1188998818397522,
-0.20304542779922485,
0.7631708979606628,
0.4771827459335327,
1.0038731098175049,
-0.010317249223589897,
1.4179147481918335,
-0.4576977491378784,
0.3238120675086975,
1.1028375625610352,
0.14935077726840973,
0.9001896381378174,
0.41915076971054077,
-0.25804591178894043,
0.27054670453071594,
0.7431140542030334,
0.26039543747901917,
0.6278185844421387,
0.4297696650028229,
-0.26032373309135437,
-0.2430696338415146,
-0.013474389910697937,
-0.3520964980125427,
0.20948010683059692,
0.1114998310804367,
-0.1715535968542099,
-0.3770293593406677,
-0.1386370211839676,
0.025553807616233826,
0.20142465829849243,
-0.3524245321750641,
0.47853976488113403,
-0.09113786369562149,
-0.18505479395389557,
0.8879707455635071,
0.08486689627170563,
0.8026660084724426,
-0.6407724618911743,
0.3457988202571869,
-0.287812203168869,
0.05856238678097725,
0.022965414449572563,
0.0009121301118284464,
0.46337077021598816,
0.04184246063232422,
0.16660331189632416,
0.0622883066534996,
0.33781489729881287,
-0.5348095893859863,
-0.7973541021347046,
0.16540245711803436,
0.11803442239761353,
0.548862099647522,
0.03266708925366402,
-0.2919568121433258,
0.12706352770328522,
-0.39876484870910645,
-0.310456782579422,
0.2933397889137268,
0.3718985915184021,
-0.14404015243053436,
0.480089396238327,
0.8443796038627625,
0.06811773777008057,
0.6939718723297119,
0.3287389576435089,
0.7535711526870728,
-0.37706097960472107,
-0.7774815559387207,
-0.660983681678772,
0.21681377291679382,
-0.16917552053928375,
-0.17414574325084686,
0.7075411081314087,
0.5138687491416931,
1.090721607208252,
-0.007492560427635908,
0.6672893762588501,
0.011246676556766033,
0.34797731041908264,
-0.6096277236938477,
0.35971885919570923,
-0.7700461745262146,
-0.00034300072002224624,
-0.28067538142204285,
-0.985352635383606,
-0.8583083152770996,
0.5893645882606506,
-0.2931985855102539,
0.2896580994129181,
0.7958208322525024,
0.7139376997947693,
-0.09929229319095612,
-0.3659767210483551,
0.7604595422744751,
0.07520502060651779,
0.31668007373809814,
0.2834661900997162,
0.5508731007575989,
-0.3408675789833069,
0.6612439751625061,
-0.13625943660736084,
-0.26795315742492676,
-0.2060469686985016,
-0.6638036966323853,
-0.9046648740768433,
-0.4283874034881592,
0.019520876929163933,
-0.018325835466384888,
-0.0030471503268927336,
0.9230272769927979,
1.0448524951934814,
-0.6722639203071594,
0.08656468242406845,
-0.37376412749290466,
-0.2546234428882599,
-0.14629718661308289,
-0.10898436605930328,
0.5736651420593262,
-0.9350208640098572,
-0.9790181517601013,
0.224457249045372,
0.13519695401191711,
0.2885519564151764,
-0.15460053086280823,
-0.14043714106082916,
-0.007520092185586691,
0.25202515721321106,
0.5119292736053467,
0.024143315851688385,
-0.49188265204429626,
-0.3935129940509796,
-0.06747300177812576,
0.09140485525131226,
0.04718993604183197,
0.8592269420623779,
-0.49352046847343445,
0.17370125651359558,
0.4122392237186432,
0.8819597959518433,
0.43397486209869385,
-0.07772944122552872,
0.5729079246520996,
-0.752993643283844,
0.7111486196517944,
0.09628419578075409,
0.5313065052032471,
0.35145053267478943,
-0.14148235321044922,
0.4458230137825012,
0.1325872242450714,
-0.19074556231498718,
-0.9583125114440918,
0.30499592423439026,
-0.7378199100494385,
-0.13775597512722015,
1.0258208513259888,
-0.4160054922103882,
-0.634644627571106,
-0.10538025200366974,
-0.041982486844062805,
0.2731764316558838,
-0.33358773589134216,
0.43498826026916504,
0.49750807881355286,
0.22669397294521332,
-0.023868218064308167,
-0.37450259923934937,
0.3503798246383667,
0.6604231595993042,
-0.6185600757598877,
0.18729975819587708,
0.26287272572517395,
0.1914343535900116,
0.1839853823184967,
1.0639945268630981,
-0.3288572430610657,
-0.08858475834131241,
0.3917710483074188,
0.02280016988515854,
0.16252091526985168,
-0.49049028754234314,
-0.30172568559646606,
0.3423899710178375,
0.19959627091884613,
-0.2134879231452942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02814v1 | Images Speak Louder than Words: Understanding and Mitigating Bias in Vision-Language Model from a Causal Mediation Perspective | 2024-07-03T05:19:45 | 2024-07-03T05:19:45 | Zhaotian Weng, Zijun Gao, Jerone Andrews, Jieyu Zhao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.7 | Vision-language models (VLMs) pre-trained on extensive datasets can
inadvertently learn biases by correlating gender information with specific
objects or scenarios. Current methods, which focus on modifying inputs and
monitoring changes in the model's output probability scores, often struggle to
comprehensively understand bias from the perspective of model components. We
propose a framework that incorporates causal mediation analysis to measure and
map the pathways of bias generation and propagation within VLMs. This approach
allows us to identify the direct effects of interventions on model bias and the
indirect effects of interventions on bias mediated through different model
components. Our results show that image features are the primary contributors
to bias, with significantly higher impacts than text features, specifically
accounting for 32.57% and 12.63% of the bias in the MSCOCO and PASCAL-SENTENCE
datasets, respectively. Notably, the image encoder's contribution surpasses
that of the text encoder and the deep fusion encoder. Further experimentation
confirms that contributions from both language and vision modalities are
aligned and non-conflicting. Consequently, focusing on blurring gender
representations within the image encoder, which contributes most to the model
bias, reduces bias efficiently by 22.03% and 9.04% in the MSCOCO and
PASCAL-SENTENCE datasets, respectively, with minimal performance loss or
increased computational demands. | [
-0.5493306517601013,
-0.6393440961837769,
0.3765783905982971,
0.39927345514297485,
-0.11513583362102509,
-0.5478904247283936,
-0.13436327874660492,
-0.44924724102020264,
-0.22875261306762695,
0.6944299340248108,
-0.538176953792572,
-0.09818430244922638,
-0.9742487072944641,
0.019327551126480103,
-0.40493878722190857,
0.6904698014259338,
-0.03874443843960762,
0.8557730317115784,
-0.18963049352169037,
-0.22736483812332153,
-1.067474126815796,
-0.21763461828231812,
-0.49327415227890015,
-0.30018365383148193,
0.4847964942455292,
-0.09832469373941422,
0.6714112758636475,
0.6834065914154053,
0.6264061331748962,
0.25899040699005127,
-0.03656914830207825,
0.1029219701886177,
-0.5246784687042236,
-0.053406454622745514,
-0.3613903820514679,
-0.3180408477783203,
-0.06936690956354141,
0.006171438377350569,
0.7777208089828491,
0.7620357275009155,
0.3292495310306549,
0.4017494022846222,
0.3567977845668793,
0.6601048707962036,
-0.9553926587104797,
0.5131089687347412,
-0.5573514699935913,
0.2695483863353729,
-0.022825557738542557,
-0.29092222452163696,
-0.5456417798995972,
0.08722206205129623,
0.3485701382160187,
-0.47255226969718933,
0.2668960690498352,
0.16192501783370972,
0.8919572234153748,
0.4983513057231903,
-0.7741307020187378,
-0.17560292780399323,
-0.8150178790092468,
0.9280667304992676,
-0.40696167945861816,
0.5111139416694641,
0.26606273651123047,
0.1313716322183609,
0.044419918209314346,
-0.2096155732870102,
-0.5574749112129211,
0.10807022452354431,
-0.27491095662117004,
0.0922042652964592,
-0.5709181427955627,
0.04532603919506073,
0.5624250173568726,
-0.1026284396648407,
-0.1948785036802292,
-0.09081491827964783,
-0.45995551347732544,
-0.1639149785041809,
0.4115942418575287,
0.1319768726825714,
0.494373083114624,
-0.0004596655198838562,
-0.15378107130527496,
-0.2718603312969208,
-0.6329578161239624,
-0.14208529889583588,
0.3350643217563629,
0.3474784195423126,
-0.09024080634117126,
0.6546852588653564,
0.1790291666984558,
0.7520781755447388,
0.13163606822490692,
-0.12948554754257202,
0.14454205334186554,
-0.38276273012161255,
-0.4620732069015503,
0.15075454115867615,
0.6332298517227173,
0.6667907238006592,
0.15727737545967102,
0.14008671045303345,
0.004681417252868414,
0.4850635528564453,
0.24425137042999268,
-0.8035394549369812,
0.36633041501045227,
-0.35975417494773865,
-0.7068244814872742,
-0.4866109788417816,
0.028894178569316864,
-0.8535382747650146,
-0.7733164429664612,
-0.5768925547599792,
0.5539257526397705,
0.10221454501152039,
-0.3671856224536896,
0.22689391672611237,
-0.38784146308898926,
0.5743785500526428,
0.08295796066522598,
-0.7042652368545532,
0.3628535270690918,
0.3699724078178406,
0.704118549823761,
0.19444863498210907,
-0.13987001776695251,
-0.405484676361084,
0.19852404296398163,
-0.5114899277687073,
0.44681692123413086,
-0.6048246622085571,
-0.3352879583835602,
0.38520967960357666,
-0.018054073676466942,
-0.12878578901290894,
-0.5488610863685608,
0.6258565783500671,
-0.2742224335670471,
0.3001902401447296,
-0.8219711184501648,
-0.3675840198993683,
-0.15142329037189484,
-0.1647198498249054,
-0.7804352045059204,
0.7702869772911072,
-0.38377174735069275,
-1.0771831274032593,
0.8114750981330872,
-0.5977752804756165,
-0.5159400105476379,
-0.4631515443325043,
-0.7419837713241577,
-0.4530906677246094,
0.388091504573822,
0.5328664779663086,
0.2820250988006592,
-0.6033067107200623,
0.8078482151031494,
-0.1481831818819046,
-0.2701584994792938,
0.2179255187511444,
-0.6836110949516296,
0.7027274370193481,
-0.20074225962162018,
-0.9173159003257751,
0.12432744354009628,
-0.5801094770431519,
-0.7274245619773865,
0.1900874823331833,
0.02752676047384739,
-0.4426129460334778,
0.3771772086620331,
0.09704425185918808,
0.46800172328948975,
-0.31151053309440613,
-0.4595358967781067,
-0.1573822945356369,
-0.05818350613117218,
0.11279221624135971,
0.9220550656318665,
-0.3676513135433197,
0.7135981917381287,
0.05004192516207695,
0.14001277089118958,
0.5400447249412537,
0.4799825847148895,
-0.1532178521156311,
-0.48418956995010376,
-0.9899696111679077,
-0.2918081283569336,
-0.24792808294296265,
0.310484379529953,
-0.98895263671875,
0.0024170922115445137,
-0.4007697105407715,
-0.06835455447435379,
-0.71767258644104,
0.08714759349822998,
0.7009891271591187,
1.0193771123886108,
0.31039145588874817,
-0.531606137752533,
-0.6037184000015259,
-1.4300593137741089,
-0.5614862442016602,
-0.322609007358551,
0.11706569045782089,
0.6665347218513489,
0.48507604002952576,
-0.2065550982952118,
0.9086952209472656,
-0.5148070454597473,
-0.6911211609840393,
-0.052418310195207596,
0.24512648582458496,
-0.006395903415977955,
0.2370636761188507,
0.6455504894256592,
-0.9703059792518616,
0.005727553740143776,
-0.2871383726596832,
-0.8722299337387085,
-0.6637338995933533,
-0.1252821534872055,
-0.1560732126235962,
0.10437048226594925,
0.5541279315948486,
-0.25033655762672424,
0.8822833299636841,
0.46296828985214233,
-0.7333804965019226,
0.39979955554008484,
0.14138449728488922,
0.15453192591667175,
-0.6462415456771851,
-0.008132767863571644,
0.34185731410980225,
-0.038362111896276474,
-0.6139504313468933,
-0.21109873056411743,
-0.10271213948726654,
0.07681271433830261,
-0.5613215565681458,
0.5335347652435303,
-0.6368659734725952,
-0.2062186896800995,
-0.2995535433292389,
0.006764499936252832,
0.13275854289531708,
0.2857452630996704,
0.2664808928966522,
0.6389447450637817,
0.7613937258720398,
-0.3892281949520111,
-0.17172062397003174,
0.1919908970594406,
-0.47704070806503296,
0.5526741743087769,
-0.6544824242591858,
-0.27688583731651306,
-0.6640141606330872,
0.1285889446735382,
-0.8548795580863953,
0.12158318608999252,
0.31308797001838684,
-0.12643644213676453,
0.2556900978088379,
0.021858369931578636,
-0.5001543760299683,
-0.25374913215637207,
-0.15511953830718994,
0.41213521361351013,
0.3016059398651123,
-0.5468694567680359,
0.7296174764633179,
0.4681261479854584,
0.32493695616722107,
-0.7063443064689636,
-0.8816478848457336,
0.12104813754558563,
-0.06992369890213013,
-0.6338117122650146,
0.024087535217404366,
0.17840810120105743,
-0.3817920386791229,
-0.06869876384735107,
0.24873924255371094,
0.08813374489545822,
-0.11041546612977982,
0.7075961828231812,
0.3155948519706726,
-0.13616754114627838,
0.28887513279914856,
0.04927629977464676,
-0.013007314875721931,
0.21900659799575806,
-0.1764417290687561,
0.44022074341773987,
-0.014101208187639713,
-0.3755631744861603,
-0.18656684458255768,
0.5567634105682373,
0.5808544158935547,
-0.15796324610710144,
1.0743318796157837,
0.8577281832695007,
-0.2630169093608856,
0.14946132898330688,
-0.6378318667411804,
-0.4203839898109436,
-0.4165946841239929,
0.5127660036087036,
-0.11699271202087402,
-0.8334041237831116,
0.24761991202831268,
-0.030372368171811104,
-0.08549903333187103,
0.2297828644514084,
0.7215086817741394,
0.1568470001220703,
1.3025614023208618,
0.8308994174003601,
-0.48121994733810425,
0.6808956861495972,
-0.09634068608283997,
0.25529664754867554,
-0.9325547218322754,
-0.27206575870513916,
-0.28980574011802673,
-0.34163039922714233,
-0.4110773801803589,
-0.6250243782997131,
0.28939345479011536,
-0.32210180163383484,
-0.3733719289302826,
-0.019160306081175804,
-0.3225031793117523,
0.2565464973449707,
0.7036043405532837,
0.1493121087551117,
0.04030940681695938,
0.12633594870567322,
-0.050988003611564636,
-0.4223027527332306,
-0.6697080731391907,
-0.3562160134315491,
0.9429864287376404,
0.33701029419898987,
0.769364058971405,
0.026979664340615273,
0.045847151428461075,
0.1941332370042801,
0.2635648548603058,
-0.4435116648674011,
0.6041144728660583,
-0.0006873757229186594,
-0.8631325960159302,
0.035271402448415756,
-0.19830092787742615,
-0.7011978030204773,
0.5700972080230713,
-0.42755600810050964,
-0.5230730772018433,
0.8260508179664612,
0.20543350279331207,
0.3245551884174347,
0.33859172463417053,
-0.6076834797859192,
0.7010765075683594,
-0.05316031724214554,
-0.7709388732910156,
-0.1512608826160431,
-0.53123539686203,
0.5276176333427429,
0.02079855278134346,
0.41448014974594116,
0.1045440211892128,
0.006956206634640694,
0.6274412274360657,
-0.27389413118362427,
1.3196126222610474,
-0.12057863920927048,
-0.1344887912273407,
-0.07683069258928299,
-0.1168181449174881,
0.20910188555717468,
-0.4490554928779602,
0.231435164809227,
0.3566327691078186,
-0.653544008731842,
-0.29183194041252136,
-0.4411405622959137,
0.39852219820022583,
-0.771102249622345,
-0.6116501688957214,
-0.2839830815792084,
-0.5869656205177307,
-0.043654896318912506,
0.1995670050382614,
0.19293901324272156,
0.6594833731651306,
-0.17171131074428558,
-0.02739010564982891,
0.716184139251709,
-0.5352720022201538,
0.40455618500709534,
0.6161952018737793,
-0.3819691240787506,
-0.13071724772453308,
0.6375721096992493,
0.21729998290538788,
0.30840107798576355,
0.19096970558166504,
0.31132352352142334,
-0.07064799219369888,
-0.007429975084960461,
-0.23695726692676544,
0.2762177884578705,
-0.8132046461105347,
-0.04952774941921234,
-0.6352868676185608,
0.015072982758283615,
-0.43262800574302673,
-0.12267099320888519,
-0.26089778542518616,
0.23057372868061066,
-0.2901284098625183,
-0.16026708483695984,
0.05232324078679085,
0.4507702589035034,
-0.01626063883304596,
0.34283819794654846,
-0.3474336266517639,
0.43532630801200867,
0.3964059352874756,
0.16185347735881805,
0.127134308218956,
-0.5135847330093384,
-0.11095446348190308,
-0.08693896234035492,
-0.24523797631263733,
-1.1487197875976562,
0.6690841913223267,
0.17711788415908813,
0.2876681685447693,
0.6635569334030151,
-0.2971562445163727,
0.8888895511627197,
-0.7705207467079163,
0.7661767601966858,
0.4069507420063019,
-1.0628082752227783,
0.7707354426383972,
-0.23565174639225006,
0.3422742187976837,
0.23191958665847778,
0.17755098640918732,
-0.26839590072631836,
-0.4704142212867737,
-0.37107187509536743,
-0.7136933207511902,
0.5804532766342163,
0.3164614737033844,
0.16444995999336243,
-0.020875802263617516,
0.06978338956832886,
-0.27322903275489807,
0.4738985598087311,
-0.8196971416473389,
-0.46484625339508057,
-0.03391911834478378,
-0.07454821467399597,
0.036365680396556854,
-0.5569953322410583,
-0.21515275537967682,
-0.4235340356826782,
0.6145305037498474,
-0.13434725999832153,
0.253808856010437,
0.43057703971862793,
-0.4473373293876648,
-0.17149750888347626,
0.060167521238327026,
0.799045979976654,
0.37699034810066223,
0.0490865595638752,
0.3556572496891022,
-0.11230611056089401,
-0.674506425857544,
-0.03740972653031349,
-0.22331339120864868,
-0.6267861127853394,
0.29436203837394714,
0.685142457485199,
1.3853989839553833,
0.3112986385822296,
-0.6165783405303955,
0.8248222470283508,
-0.20340655744075775,
-0.07993238419294357,
0.09166323393583298,
-0.22503475844860077,
-0.17861482501029968,
0.46855756640434265,
0.24810948967933655,
0.2598511576652527,
0.5207031965255737,
-0.5283061265945435,
-0.08250173926353455,
0.3927379250526428,
-0.9651983976364136,
-0.09504459798336029,
0.7181696891784668,
0.06830926239490509,
0.18439407646656036,
0.4035443663597107,
0.4165772497653961,
-0.5830795764923096,
0.5559382438659668,
0.5605226755142212,
0.8749009966850281,
-0.03813320770859718,
0.2960149645805359,
0.37107840180397034,
0.8440933227539062,
-0.2308775931596756,
0.09208446741104126,
0.20576295256614685,
-0.9826414585113525,
-0.3784283697605133,
-0.3682727515697479,
0.10172212868928909,
-0.08733075857162476,
-0.8603324294090271,
0.21701648831367493,
-0.14665323495864868,
-0.5020315647125244,
0.03617648407816887,
-0.3826465606689453,
-0.9929773211479187,
0.17741020023822784,
0.3319511413574219,
0.6255735754966736,
-1.4349651336669922,
0.43635237216949463,
0.41021645069122314,
-0.5672940015792847,
-0.7531408667564392,
-0.3270080089569092,
0.2852420210838318,
-0.8371416926383972,
1.3213127851486206,
0.06228417530655861,
-0.12902845442295074,
-0.3733997344970703,
-0.7001168727874756,
-0.5715951323509216,
0.9482716917991638,
0.7868627905845642,
-0.637641429901123,
0.33176884055137634,
0.4257117509841919,
0.36700496077537537,
-0.5207927227020264,
0.34949663281440735,
0.56116783618927,
0.6068118214607239,
-0.19057200849056244,
-0.9590243697166443,
0.1021210104227066,
-0.13563752174377441,
0.29175788164138794,
-0.0006779239629395306,
-0.3126644194126129,
0.5209625363349915,
-0.09922366589307785,
-0.13740243017673492,
-0.5639305710792542,
0.5695049166679382,
-0.01839611679315567,
0.18061386048793793,
0.38367146253585815,
0.33318430185317993,
0.42457929253578186,
-0.27274632453918457,
1.3430533409118652,
0.10521294176578522,
0.0011035900097340345,
1.1427741050720215,
-0.24768346548080444,
0.5446301698684692,
1.0677951574325562,
0.06061550974845886,
0.2448902726173401,
0.05526794493198395,
0.08080707490444183,
0.4721965789794922,
0.3165472447872162,
-0.2643253803253174,
-0.22107228636741638,
-0.8179369568824768,
-0.12282189726829529,
0.3586828112602234,
0.15319377183914185,
-1.0441473722457886,
-0.07208021730184555,
0.4368726313114166,
-0.0013815058628097177,
0.08595010638237,
-0.45564648509025574,
0.7719034552574158,
0.2324390411376953,
-0.2654716372489929,
0.041807327419519424,
-0.29689887166023254,
0.5731568932533264,
-0.29485440254211426,
-0.07305175065994263,
-0.1070416122674942,
0.11798128485679626,
0.05259539186954498,
-0.5541289448738098,
0.21153269708156586,
-0.10922221094369888,
-0.6130313873291016,
-0.28515222668647766,
1.0683395862579346,
-0.6171403527259827,
-0.8758494853973389,
0.555418074131012,
0.36499860882759094,
-0.2696426510810852,
0.01033969409763813,
-0.6275194883346558,
0.6799531579017639,
-0.1342492401599884,
0.015787675976753235,
0.1588711440563202,
0.03575500473380089,
-0.29262876510620117,
0.609100341796875,
0.41265079379081726,
0.26299309730529785,
0.38158148527145386,
0.5660919547080994,
0.8457847237586975,
-0.32486894726753235,
-0.025854479521512985,
-1.0783663988113403,
0.47888344526290894,
-0.35652264952659607,
-0.0731881707906723,
0.7057943940162659,
0.29984045028686523,
0.6777130961418152,
-0.3810461461544037,
0.5552219152450562,
0.38123929500579834,
-0.19227810204029083,
-0.36267217993736267,
0.7090079188346863,
-0.4804367125034332,
0.09547620266675949,
-0.7017596364021301,
-0.8280923962593079,
-0.4553530216217041,
0.652787983417511,
-0.5621161460876465,
-0.15205737948417664,
0.3656613230705261,
0.9076951146125793,
0.1881658285856247,
-0.18860740959644318,
0.4235987365245819,
0.3743910491466522,
0.4159868657588959,
0.2676672041416168,
0.7756222486495972,
-0.7966541647911072,
0.24258115887641907,
0.07127905637025833,
-0.26075100898742676,
-0.08758090436458588,
-0.952663004398346,
-1.0216342210769653,
-0.6570510864257812,
-0.5287724733352661,
-0.15018488466739655,
0.10028459131717682,
0.4401486814022064,
0.7218080163002014,
-0.32525625824928284,
-0.22312314808368683,
-0.0550551638007164,
0.18826018273830414,
-0.11701130867004395,
-0.2326291799545288,
0.3378220796585083,
-0.12401217967271805,
-0.5481692552566528,
-0.15737444162368774,
0.5486656427383423,
-0.1391705721616745,
-0.46367180347442627,
-0.08897017687559128,
0.046525727957487106,
0.4062941074371338,
0.9093169569969177,
-0.17943981289863586,
-0.8357567191123962,
-0.2617795169353485,
-0.10900848358869553,
-0.1695466935634613,
-0.12694454193115234,
1.0298633575439453,
-0.7204545140266418,
0.790673017501831,
0.4857639968395233,
0.5044029951095581,
0.24281826615333557,
-0.5198384523391724,
0.9299776554107666,
-0.6074833273887634,
0.36558419466018677,
-0.2500351667404175,
0.6292548775672913,
0.4428185224533081,
-0.1269972175359726,
0.3451741933822632,
0.26896220445632935,
0.001542083453387022,
-0.8527866005897522,
0.24871332943439484,
-0.885355532169342,
-0.28907155990600586,
1.2106760740280151,
0.30405721068382263,
-0.40814220905303955,
0.01246040128171444,
-0.7275640964508057,
0.4452509582042694,
-0.08906014263629913,
0.6393026113510132,
0.7157004475593567,
0.4425898790359497,
-0.3738548457622528,
-0.7259919047355652,
0.40825143456459045,
0.5022537708282471,
-0.5158117413520813,
-0.08328384160995483,
0.7396029233932495,
-0.021700985729694366,
0.12259597331285477,
0.45517873764038086,
-0.4362986385822296,
0.15375329554080963,
0.059862274676561356,
0.19565308094024658,
0.14298635721206665,
-0.18933549523353577,
-0.465565949678421,
-0.14932531118392944,
-0.2570056617259979,
-0.08797599375247955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02783v1 | 52B to 1T: Lessons Learned via Tele-FLM Series | 2024-07-03T03:21:02 | 2024-07-03T03:21:02 | Xiang Li, Yiqun Yao, Xin Jiang, Xuezhi Fang, Chao Wang, Xinzhang Liu, Zihan Wang, Yu Zhao, Xin Wang, Yuyao Huang, Shuangyong Song, Yongxiang Li, Zheng Zhang, Bo Zhao, Aixin Sun, Yequan Wang, Zhongjiang He, Zhongyuan Wang, Xuelong Li, Tiejun Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) represent a significant stride toward Artificial
General Intelligence. As scaling laws underscore the potential of increasing
model sizes, the academic community has intensified its investigations into
LLMs with capacities exceeding 50 billion parameters. This technical report
builds on our prior work with Tele-FLM (also known as FLM-2), a publicly
available 52-billion-parameter model. We delve into two primary areas: we first
discuss our observation of Supervised Fine-tuning (SFT) on Tele-FLM-52B, which
supports the "less is more" approach for SFT data construction; second, we
demonstrate our experiments and analyses on the best practices for
progressively growing a model from 52 billion to 102 billion, and subsequently
to 1 trillion parameters. We will open-source a 1T model checkpoint, namely
Tele-FLM-1T, to advance further training and research. | [
-0.5307216644287109,
-0.7725126147270203,
0.4676378667354584,
0.056587204337120056,
0.003906138939782977,
-0.20392853021621704,
-0.31820738315582275,
-0.6183863878250122,
-0.09676534682512283,
0.7817746996879578,
-0.5580769777297974,
-0.28195181488990784,
-0.6220166087150574,
0.17246730625629425,
-0.670215904712677,
0.9663184881210327,
0.1995670348405838,
0.07325915992259979,
0.1779354363679886,
0.12394682317972183,
-0.3279215097427368,
-0.4916441738605499,
-1.045560598373413,
-0.10048356652259827,
0.6802859306335449,
0.820361852645874,
0.9393200874328613,
0.8492404818534851,
0.729978084564209,
0.2061978131532669,
-0.026768798008561134,
0.13602247834205627,
-0.6876699328422546,
-0.21141082048416138,
0.021027812734246254,
-0.7355911135673523,
-0.6498754024505615,
0.07150372117757797,
0.9026955366134644,
0.825509786605835,
-0.029761984944343567,
0.27062568068504333,
-0.3112889528274536,
0.9995559453964233,
-0.17953082919120789,
0.2079860270023346,
-0.6749011874198914,
-0.02365225926041603,
-0.41783371567726135,
0.12849849462509155,
-0.6350253820419312,
-0.2747291922569275,
0.34817206859588623,
-0.47205424308776855,
0.19258008897304535,
0.178548663854599,
0.626004695892334,
0.5180860161781311,
-0.5520166754722595,
-0.08345835655927658,
-1.0748671293258667,
0.9277216792106628,
-0.8071681261062622,
0.5307216048240662,
0.5786202549934387,
0.3861273229122162,
-0.1442783623933792,
-0.8037413954734802,
-0.1347244530916214,
-0.2862534821033478,
0.313728004693985,
-0.17545554041862488,
-0.24224498867988586,
0.1243862733244896,
0.4162428379058838,
0.2159782350063324,
-0.5866341590881348,
0.27814775705337524,
-0.7999842762947083,
-0.05024893209338188,
0.8019061088562012,
0.25103601813316345,
-0.06257059425115585,
0.17525416612625122,
-0.09386683255434036,
0.17199406027793884,
-0.9769723415374756,
-0.4497967064380646,
0.12673315405845642,
0.28286489844322205,
-0.04614005237817764,
0.4270191490650177,
-0.2793702483177185,
0.5406824946403503,
-0.1332155168056488,
0.17688106000423431,
-0.22715018689632416,
-0.40563103556632996,
-0.27801528573036194,
-0.10939663648605347,
0.6267034411430359,
-0.045879412442445755,
0.8486902713775635,
-0.17009204626083374,
-0.09265334904193878,
-0.36276495456695557,
0.3852365016937256,
-0.9723399877548218,
-0.1379067450761795,
0.062257882207632065,
-0.4675840139389038,
-0.0759936198592186,
0.16112877428531647,
-0.6962575912475586,
-0.3732297420501709,
-0.5050670504570007,
0.21965554356575012,
-0.5731468200683594,
-0.3172866106033325,
0.19861844182014465,
0.08197622746229172,
0.3434218168258667,
0.4546491503715515,
-0.8581211566925049,
0.5978357791900635,
0.89433354139328,
0.9063526391983032,
-0.025783276185393333,
-0.11223497241735458,
-0.4474777281284332,
-0.10890044271945953,
-0.47229793667793274,
0.5491258502006531,
-0.40333864092826843,
-0.408711701631546,
0.11562608182430267,
-0.238030344247818,
0.040771398693323135,
-0.6433488726615906,
0.579151451587677,
-0.6841195225715637,
0.18114134669303894,
-0.41826361417770386,
-0.7174433469772339,
-0.3794550895690918,
-0.03187388926744461,
-0.7744771838188171,
0.7849952578544617,
0.2134082019329071,
-0.6187687516212463,
0.09916713088750839,
-0.8794062733650208,
-0.36828821897506714,
0.06144305318593979,
0.05627007409930229,
-0.28517699241638184,
0.44873175024986267,
-0.053141165524721146,
0.4738085865974426,
-0.6322290897369385,
0.16025394201278687,
-0.3030989170074463,
-0.5530965924263,
-0.021113567054271698,
-0.6920174360275269,
0.7100988030433655,
0.42554986476898193,
-0.021507687866687775,
-0.03895440325140953,
-0.708581268787384,
-0.06915391981601715,
0.17609210312366486,
-0.4170278310775757,
0.07401089370250702,
0.2090137004852295,
-0.04099137336015701,
-0.0069159553386271,
0.20648235082626343,
-0.46414828300476074,
0.08249709755182266,
-0.524848461151123,
0.763285219669342,
0.46755245327949524,
-0.11970744282007217,
0.3751584589481354,
-0.5360624194145203,
0.5433517694473267,
-0.14126281440258026,
0.24645844101905823,
-0.24137668311595917,
-0.31238940358161926,
-0.8800730109214783,
-0.23530228435993195,
0.3564072549343109,
0.5102404952049255,
-0.1829889565706253,
0.23815302550792694,
-0.466117262840271,
-0.543298602104187,
-0.2582929730415344,
0.19942669570446014,
-0.19252607226371765,
0.05598058924078941,
0.31788796186447144,
-0.08323007822036743,
-0.45971307158470154,
-0.936781108379364,
-0.04646014794707298,
-0.13708610832691193,
-0.1641802191734314,
0.25246408581733704,
0.4121565818786621,
-0.30930718779563904,
1.1442466974258423,
-0.395702600479126,
-0.1914021372795105,
-0.14042356610298157,
0.05373944342136383,
-0.0065940679050982,
0.360528826713562,
0.5181185007095337,
-0.6417294144630432,
-0.3931331932544708,
0.06400297582149506,
-0.5611480474472046,
0.12926995754241943,
0.08214113116264343,
0.16637936234474182,
0.287047415971756,
0.6731012463569641,
-0.692243218421936,
0.17402346432209015,
0.26225167512893677,
-0.20713283121585846,
0.5765513777732849,
-0.09723121672868729,
0.02303296886384487,
-1.0475996732711792,
-0.14680349826812744,
0.2489897608757019,
-0.5019952654838562,
-0.6621158123016357,
-0.026065384969115257,
-0.0892624631524086,
-0.14289788901805878,
-0.41951924562454224,
0.3797377645969391,
-0.37682607769966125,
-0.055972080677747726,
-0.2680627405643463,
-0.053535811603069305,
-0.6301445960998535,
0.23414023220539093,
-0.12561629712581635,
0.7730981707572937,
0.5553842186927795,
-0.5214601159095764,
0.5021406412124634,
0.025237135589122772,
-0.3304550051689148,
0.18154481053352356,
-0.768379271030426,
0.33227476477622986,
-0.022815298289060593,
0.17797918617725372,
-0.8971425294876099,
-0.3069956302642822,
-0.20208624005317688,
-0.18288318812847137,
0.38362136483192444,
-0.02074054628610611,
-0.8294483423233032,
-0.4224543869495392,
-0.38111212849617004,
0.41010594367980957,
0.5291677117347717,
-0.34447360038757324,
0.5653784275054932,
0.27349990606307983,
-0.3772185742855072,
-0.023993654176592827,
-0.7378678321838379,
0.16797778010368347,
-0.3868565559387207,
-0.8783445954322815,
-0.018679291009902954,
-0.13834784924983978,
-0.38585129380226135,
-0.19546230137348175,
-0.007104808930307627,
-0.13631968200206757,
0.15728329122066498,
0.2836914360523224,
0.07798751443624496,
-0.6896468997001648,
0.2164546549320221,
-0.041328102350234985,
-0.026943612843751907,
0.39029136300086975,
-0.48649290204048157,
0.5186477899551392,
-0.35309934616088867,
-0.13395749032497406,
-0.43358656764030457,
0.26598280668258667,
0.603996753692627,
-0.22901253402233124,
0.7273899912834167,
0.4625961184501648,
-0.515357255935669,
-0.38210049271583557,
-0.49631279706954956,
-0.3078506886959076,
-0.5369169116020203,
0.6986274719238281,
-0.1881481558084488,
-1.1479579210281372,
0.47934967279434204,
-0.383177250623703,
0.18334022164344788,
0.5311211943626404,
0.44777044653892517,
0.08259715884923935,
0.9217357039451599,
0.945233166217804,
-0.48848801851272583,
0.8126068115234375,
-0.16963064670562744,
0.007734515704214573,
-0.3254183530807495,
0.12721455097198486,
-0.5566873550415039,
-0.27325087785720825,
-0.7212826609611511,
-0.6481584906578064,
0.5393925309181213,
-0.028889672830700874,
-0.6716446280479431,
0.23838908970355988,
-0.09312432259321213,
0.6911906003952026,
0.504778265953064,
0.11923687160015106,
0.38651734590530396,
0.035658929497003555,
0.38839468359947205,
0.234048992395401,
-0.7601262331008911,
-0.6338204741477966,
1.2667181491851807,
0.8746702671051025,
0.6268659830093384,
0.11200231313705444,
0.4595082104206085,
0.3232143223285675,
0.36565926671028137,
-0.8574986457824707,
0.7612531781196594,
-0.49823832511901855,
-0.900371253490448,
-0.6575292944908142,
-0.595244824886322,
-0.6581284999847412,
-0.17598901689052582,
0.11612164974212646,
-0.700131356716156,
-0.3504762053489685,
-0.024450896307826042,
-0.2684001624584198,
0.22640830278396606,
-0.7108307480812073,
0.6013169884681702,
-0.1137673556804657,
0.0514143742620945,
-0.7570414543151855,
-0.8857833743095398,
0.5220393538475037,
-0.3384704291820526,
0.143484964966774,
-0.12028400599956512,
-0.18923263251781464,
0.8544766306877136,
-0.3199063241481781,
0.8037312030792236,
0.023226719349622726,
-0.44206324219703674,
0.3942338824272156,
0.11458229273557663,
0.6047175526618958,
-0.00216328795067966,
-0.4358369708061218,
0.2014608234167099,
0.00993296317756176,
-0.41080811619758606,
-0.24907024204730988,
0.7393109202384949,
-0.8272165060043335,
-0.5576601028442383,
-0.0019367734203115106,
-0.9042980670928955,
-0.4627423882484436,
0.2511959969997406,
0.14248308539390564,
0.5490140318870544,
-0.2792062759399414,
0.40106889605522156,
1.019468903541565,
-0.16881884634494781,
0.42992523312568665,
0.5457751154899597,
-0.334543913602829,
-0.4277576506137848,
0.9052562117576599,
0.4160887897014618,
0.6343680620193481,
0.4524805545806885,
0.1353977918624878,
0.010421395301818848,
-0.715131402015686,
-0.12766754627227783,
0.6267372369766235,
-0.5751142501831055,
-0.12188234180212021,
-0.18872427940368652,
-0.3393327295780182,
-0.3066631853580475,
0.1407623142004013,
-0.5922557711601257,
-0.5342450737953186,
-0.4465315341949463,
-0.03913633152842522,
0.617932915687561,
1.1507893800735474,
0.10172373056411743,
0.5877264142036438,
-0.801660418510437,
0.08585473895072937,
-0.01591809093952179,
0.4906948208808899,
-0.11014644801616669,
-0.8348467946052551,
-0.46688112616539,
0.2811504602432251,
-0.2438625991344452,
-0.5423614978790283,
0.020933572202920914,
0.3903238773345947,
0.06467008590698242,
0.48562827706336975,
-0.04990192502737045,
0.3729894161224365,
-0.6466863751411438,
0.7608642578125,
-0.13430669903755188,
-0.8831245303153992,
0.486147403717041,
-0.8118621110916138,
0.35592323541641235,
0.31909188628196716,
0.6188412308692932,
-0.4183509945869446,
-0.314445823431015,
-0.5074074864387512,
-0.5103663802146912,
0.7476786375045776,
-0.14821653068065643,
0.4002552032470703,
0.2615003287792206,
0.7096340656280518,
0.23714902997016907,
0.027471164241433144,
-0.38629448413848877,
-0.24593494832515717,
0.0937182828783989,
-0.41579410433769226,
-0.026691842824220657,
-0.27595043182373047,
0.15181678533554077,
-0.32948461174964905,
0.7233334183692932,
-0.19989223778247833,
0.15541885793209076,
-0.1588229537010193,
0.06917502731084824,
-0.2689651846885681,
0.15676802396774292,
0.7028618454933167,
0.6866061091423035,
-0.06732254475355148,
0.0016805219929665327,
0.3667469024658203,
-0.45945534110069275,
-0.3436703085899353,
0.180056631565094,
-0.07781433314085007,
-0.307280570268631,
0.49933522939682007,
0.6770616173744202,
0.06346624344587326,
-0.6667033433914185,
0.16776040196418762,
0.1734490692615509,
-0.5692846775054932,
-0.20803363621234894,
0.2490224689245224,
0.12421911954879761,
0.32952430844306946,
0.49745163321495056,
-0.15601834654808044,
-0.12271825969219208,
-0.5132789611816406,
0.48245662450790405,
0.4764164686203003,
-0.41771644353866577,
-0.4331620931625366,
0.7411059737205505,
0.2163662314414978,
-0.1844956874847412,
0.8072875738143921,
-0.013931237161159515,
-0.4601619839668274,
0.638515293598175,
0.4274241626262665,
0.6626229882240295,
-0.11040683835744858,
0.2803814709186554,
0.1629778891801834,
0.5709556341171265,
-0.3999878466129303,
0.15821999311447144,
0.24602577090263367,
-0.525644063949585,
-0.47267067432403564,
-0.49052074551582336,
-0.4876415431499481,
0.1891133338212967,
-0.391289621591568,
0.5404596924781799,
-0.7989820837974548,
-0.08392360061407089,
0.054934773594141006,
0.43195873498916626,
-0.6194866299629211,
0.26640528440475464,
0.2863215506076813,
1.221319556236267,
-0.6260491609573364,
0.960595428943634,
0.5164511203765869,
-0.4381590485572815,
-1.0354716777801514,
0.02260858193039894,
0.15794380009174347,
-0.788043200969696,
0.5430274605751038,
0.06575876474380493,
-0.06477770954370499,
0.3605562746524811,
-0.8771308660507202,
-1.0852316617965698,
1.1773829460144043,
0.6623940467834473,
-0.7737465500831604,
-0.05570198968052864,
0.6036934852600098,
0.6463978886604309,
-0.20704369246959686,
0.2543625235557556,
0.7216570973396301,
0.4557216167449951,
-0.028257424011826515,
-1.2603747844696045,
0.07925758510828018,
0.2474878877401352,
-0.17723995447158813,
0.4439610540866852,
-1.0493385791778564,
0.7438057065010071,
-0.448647677898407,
-0.15748855471611023,
0.23796726763248444,
0.8996118307113647,
-0.2746647596359253,
0.09259892255067825,
0.37493911385536194,
0.31076109409332275,
0.7753663063049316,
0.024736210703849792,
0.9305461049079895,
-0.11204821616411209,
0.355826735496521,
1.0095093250274658,
-0.3683468997478485,
0.8973178267478943,
0.15204234421253204,
-0.4673401713371277,
0.21556293964385986,
0.6515543460845947,
-0.11941708624362946,
0.16595593094825745,
0.38368088006973267,
-0.12192068994045258,
-0.21832771599292755,
-0.2725093960762024,
-0.17382557690143585,
0.37287408113479614,
0.21656008064746857,
-0.25356486439704895,
-0.15873682498931885,
0.0155604537576437,
0.05832017585635185,
-0.11438699811697006,
-0.39326685667037964,
0.723078191280365,
0.3778197467327118,
-0.2548461854457855,
0.4707210063934326,
0.010729856789112091,
0.5431780219078064,
-0.6367993950843811,
0.1779138147830963,
-0.2600208818912506,
0.3225547671318054,
-0.10902203619480133,
-0.647678017616272,
0.4278544485569,
0.12215059250593185,
-0.3839457631111145,
-0.0894903689622879,
0.47897765040397644,
-0.4321535527706146,
-0.6618359684944153,
0.2052495926618576,
0.4318368136882782,
0.27703848481178284,
-0.30275654792785645,
-0.346769779920578,
0.07998199760913849,
-0.08030989021062851,
-0.4182940423488617,
0.3498101830482483,
0.6423876285552979,
-0.17677173018455505,
0.9913719296455383,
0.23830658197402954,
0.21458448469638824,
0.2830108404159546,
0.1437605321407318,
0.6724111437797546,
-0.8747280836105347,
-0.07947896420955658,
-0.7828304171562195,
0.23200887441635132,
0.2662728726863861,
-0.35506221652030945,
0.584141731262207,
0.6270805597305298,
0.8191892504692078,
-0.0009827035246416926,
0.76059889793396,
0.023416534066200256,
0.4823472499847412,
-0.417833149433136,
0.5144452452659607,
-0.4646989405155182,
0.37074533104896545,
0.11730670928955078,
-0.7897881865501404,
-0.2224525511264801,
0.20040592551231384,
-0.319161981344223,
0.16476178169250488,
0.6317499279975891,
0.8070108890533447,
0.06962195783853531,
0.5241996049880981,
0.31889477372169495,
0.41112419962882996,
0.475492000579834,
0.5224384069442749,
0.6062496304512024,
-0.5193489193916321,
0.6436991095542908,
-0.044700875878334045,
-0.11503312736749649,
-0.1042880043387413,
-0.7484397292137146,
-0.8777774572372437,
-0.32929739356040955,
-0.4459352195262909,
0.12700782716274261,
-0.18300549685955048,
1.0869431495666504,
0.8764604330062866,
-0.8934027552604675,
-0.2318650484085083,
-0.2696388065814972,
-0.0061076488345861435,
0.007417609915137291,
-0.19721251726150513,
0.010449702851474285,
-0.24540899693965912,
-0.7048431038856506,
0.4541824162006378,
0.05185256898403168,
-0.02471509575843811,
-0.4802156984806061,
-0.11173982173204422,
-0.07555412501096725,
0.40659621357917786,
0.6667811274528503,
0.11652406305074692,
-0.5819063782691956,
-0.43224185705184937,
0.0689755380153656,
-0.02140962891280651,
-0.030033735558390617,
0.7425607442855835,
-0.3730812072753906,
-0.1754130721092224,
0.3882441520690918,
0.752068042755127,
0.4787636697292328,
0.06205641105771065,
0.9207097887992859,
-0.7125089764595032,
-0.19569629430770874,
0.22752855718135834,
0.1624118536710739,
0.1626848578453064,
-0.2480311244726181,
0.7487341165542603,
0.07286856323480606,
-0.8538028597831726,
-0.7781921625137329,
0.18964402377605438,
-1.038224458694458,
-0.26426199078559875,
1.264012098312378,
0.16123513877391815,
0.33816567063331604,
0.17459078133106232,
-0.22121791541576385,
0.2090633362531662,
-0.3395780622959137,
0.4839857220649719,
0.8631404638290405,
-0.11241275072097778,
-0.22808150947093964,
-1.033692717552185,
0.3704818785190582,
0.5007923245429993,
-1.0669727325439453,
0.36118048429489136,
0.5304228663444519,
0.3942124545574188,
-0.04808066785335541,
0.34511858224868774,
0.0997404232621193,
0.08825298398733139,
0.006082619074732065,
-0.5484787821769714,
-0.1665254831314087,
-0.6154642105102539,
-0.39226698875427246,
0.09814371168613434,
0.2609716057777405,
0.07423380017280579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02776v1 | A Framework for Quantum Finite-State Languages with Density Mapping | 2024-07-03T03:06:37 | 2024-07-03T03:06:37 | SeungYeop Baik, Sicheol Sung, Yo-Sub Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, quant-ph | A quantum finite-state automaton (QFA) is a theoretical model designed to
simulate the evolution of a quantum system with finite memory in response to
sequential input strings. We define the language of a QFA as the set of strings
that lead the QFA to an accepting state when processed from its initial state.
QFAs exemplify how quantum computing can achieve greater efficiency compared to
classical computing. While being one of the simplest quantum models, QFAs are
still notably challenging to construct from scratch due to the preliminary
knowledge of quantum mechanics required for superimposing unitary constraints
on the automata. Furthermore, even when QFAs are correctly assembled, the
limitations of a current quantum computer may cause fluctuations in the
simulation results depending on how an assembled QFA is translated into a
quantum circuit.
We present a framework that provides a simple and intuitive way to build QFAs
and maximize the simulation accuracy. Our framework relies on two methods:
First, it offers a predefined construction for foundational types of QFAs that
recognize special languages MOD and EQU. They play a role of basic building
blocks for more complex QFAs. In other words, one can obtain more complex QFAs
from these foundational automata using standard language operations. Second, we
improve the simulation accuracy by converting these QFAs into quantum circuits
such that the resulting circuits perform well on noisy quantum computers.
Our framework is available at https://github.com/sybaik1/qfa-toolkit. | [
-0.41494524478912354,
-0.943750262260437,
0.8084744811058044,
-0.045215338468551636,
-0.44007444381713867,
0.42424476146698,
0.24756605923175812,
-0.1478491723537445,
0.2634517550468445,
0.2502236068248749,
-0.11285526305437088,
-0.22207900881767273,
-0.14642135798931122,
0.067686066031456,
-0.7971991896629333,
0.3922742009162903,
-0.23312877118587494,
-0.2760798931121826,
0.1288602501153946,
0.08189300447702408,
0.06297722458839417,
-0.4490351676940918,
-0.6366680860519409,
-0.09524422138929367,
-0.06231984868645668,
0.04654800891876221,
1.265427589416504,
0.5921324491500854,
0.11774781346321106,
0.35583582520484924,
0.06570380181074142,
-0.09521936625242233,
-0.40172290802001953,
-0.11475842446088791,
-0.010622500441968441,
-0.3908168375492096,
-0.3018001317977905,
-0.39211881160736084,
0.9857215285301208,
0.48033618927001953,
-0.418470174074173,
0.010139651596546173,
-0.5278177261352539,
0.7166348099708557,
-0.5942001342773438,
-0.010433980263769627,
-0.19610682129859924,
0.308248370885849,
-0.17987196147441864,
-0.23898537456989288,
-0.14270399510860443,
-0.504364013671875,
0.006837406195700169,
-0.9495128989219666,
-0.09591473639011383,
0.20122268795967102,
0.6213393807411194,
0.14128237962722778,
-0.9510694146156311,
-0.03758993744850159,
-0.9600326418876648,
0.5401293635368347,
-0.682577908039093,
0.8064514994621277,
0.1783374696969986,
0.4900749921798706,
-0.7214400768280029,
-0.4263956546783447,
-0.9869139194488525,
-0.15148811042308807,
0.03571050986647606,
0.040062081068754196,
-0.10197065770626068,
0.4256844222545624,
0.18587952852249146,
0.7736126184463501,
-0.6107661128044128,
-0.2225835621356964,
-0.05864416062831879,
-0.14299316704273224,
0.8209668397903442,
0.28875067830085754,
0.48063650727272034,
0.18938854336738586,
-0.13257266581058502,
-0.5046675801277161,
-0.48531389236450195,
0.03329494222998619,
0.22655966877937317,
-0.04018367826938629,
-0.3430107831954956,
0.260140985250473,
-0.5093445777893066,
0.809648871421814,
0.29918670654296875,
-0.2860572040081024,
0.0667186751961708,
-0.32691890001296997,
-0.2972283959388733,
-0.08877398818731308,
0.7372544407844543,
-0.009925736114382744,
0.22345247864723206,
-0.1637222319841385,
-0.3384306728839874,
-0.05989570543169975,
0.19184336066246033,
-0.9068538546562195,
-0.4158346354961395,
0.5082542300224304,
-0.3879275918006897,
-0.17791494727134705,
-0.1708868443965912,
-0.7092772126197815,
-0.19796745479106903,
0.02753004990518093,
0.8171414136886597,
-0.35794007778167725,
-0.6546597480773926,
0.37023821473121643,
-0.10921471565961838,
0.24025142192840576,
0.15300868451595306,
-0.9346083402633667,
0.6181626319885254,
0.26297134160995483,
0.5564926266670227,
0.048461947590112686,
-0.023867659270763397,
-0.28778156638145447,
0.3506908416748047,
-0.8895826935768127,
0.6998897790908813,
-0.4513011872768402,
-0.5687762498855591,
0.007818163372576237,
-0.4181484580039978,
0.07011174410581589,
-0.33878010511398315,
0.0697651132941246,
-0.7647233009338379,
0.02258865348994732,
-0.12105602771043777,
-0.7227067351341248,
-0.3830232620239258,
-0.28091293573379517,
-1.0489921569824219,
0.8615057468414307,
0.5327162742614746,
-0.08934581279754639,
0.09391673654317856,
-0.7537207007408142,
-0.673751950263977,
0.01879621110856533,
-0.41769182682037354,
-0.23992213606834412,
0.2932131588459015,
-0.25944268703460693,
0.1123049333691597,
-0.5531290769577026,
0.3137747347354889,
-0.3015306293964386,
-0.6086030006408691,
0.5387483835220337,
-0.007717821281403303,
0.9064103364944458,
0.5162761807441711,
-0.5173982977867126,
0.1050899550318718,
-0.9922022223472595,
0.07760881632566452,
0.04887145757675171,
-0.35687053203582764,
-0.17495302855968475,
0.21078471839427948,
-0.05013693869113922,
0.28277578949928284,
0.15277037024497986,
-0.386548787355423,
0.0038286461494863033,
-0.5162419080734253,
0.5762837529182434,
0.5616929531097412,
0.1814185529947281,
0.7386332154273987,
-0.27096623182296753,
0.6413205862045288,
0.28517478704452515,
0.19891786575317383,
0.1469094455242157,
-0.43020525574684143,
-0.6567689180374146,
-0.3041688799858093,
0.2730131149291992,
0.45760929584503174,
-0.7217486500740051,
0.43579399585723877,
-0.00856599397957325,
-0.5324773788452148,
-0.43261054158210754,
-0.0003149310650769621,
0.21637603640556335,
0.12604524195194244,
0.18194518983364105,
-0.41395050287246704,
-0.28246140480041504,
-0.9737471342086792,
-0.07593262940645218,
-0.5250480771064758,
0.3918605446815491,
-0.2612207531929016,
0.33698391914367676,
-0.07476149499416351,
0.8762702345848083,
-0.2328970581293106,
0.004793182015419006,
0.26002517342567444,
-0.20397956669330597,
-0.021513905376195908,
0.8590591549873352,
0.4925629794597626,
-0.9646780490875244,
-0.2715413570404053,
0.09480462968349457,
-0.6666222214698792,
0.3028908967971802,
-0.35244759917259216,
-0.6606805920600891,
0.013413517735898495,
0.16230225563049316,
-0.6733318567276001,
0.3612845242023468,
0.406031996011734,
-0.6088199615478516,
0.47511813044548035,
0.17994555830955505,
0.4539436101913452,
-1.1457610130310059,
0.08993708342313766,
-0.24726097285747528,
-0.20582719147205353,
-0.7851516604423523,
0.6742995381355286,
0.05074542760848999,
-0.20207296311855316,
-0.2986328601837158,
0.7247140407562256,
-0.23813332617282867,
-0.28982433676719666,
-0.13891281187534332,
-0.16577257215976715,
-0.02344992384314537,
0.52712482213974,
-0.15251325070858002,
1.0301122665405273,
0.47545215487480164,
-0.7773449420928955,
0.25214019417762756,
0.043161019682884216,
-0.2453688681125641,
0.31966352462768555,
-0.42890846729278564,
-0.05323109030723572,
0.19435465335845947,
0.059643179178237915,
-0.9063131213188171,
0.019890431314706802,
0.1071242094039917,
-0.19632746279239655,
-0.011137276887893677,
0.236601322889328,
-0.8814635872840881,
-0.08345292508602142,
0.11447872221469879,
0.7313859462738037,
0.9115718603134155,
-0.2843528687953949,
1.1485289335250854,
0.5586567521095276,
0.36055296659469604,
0.055385034531354904,
-0.37422996759414673,
-0.32321566343307495,
-0.12071936577558517,
-0.4440832734107971,
0.40360814332962036,
-0.48479163646698,
-0.29712408781051636,
0.1568206548690796,
-0.10481146723031998,
-0.579357385635376,
0.7188817858695984,
0.2003367841243744,
-0.10683723539113998,
-0.31383490562438965,
0.2547524869441986,
0.746758222579956,
0.03376316279172897,
0.11020679026842117,
-0.38639330863952637,
0.3600722551345825,
-0.3196311295032501,
-0.19524931907653809,
-0.6738542318344116,
0.5803053379058838,
0.7007808685302734,
-0.19410254061222076,
0.4651564657688141,
0.25687187910079956,
-0.702420711517334,
-0.21143917739391327,
-0.22787325084209442,
-0.2101891189813614,
-0.548652708530426,
0.10341331362724304,
-0.9855303168296814,
-1.1246000528335571,
0.5322515964508057,
-0.2827693521976471,
0.3767654597759247,
0.513784646987915,
0.5577445030212402,
-0.1178712472319603,
1.3466695547103882,
0.8092975616455078,
0.17684990167617798,
0.4357866942882538,
-0.05831845477223396,
0.3854992389678955,
-0.38284653425216675,
0.30759015679359436,
-0.23895449936389923,
-0.13742779195308685,
-0.4003520905971527,
-0.40867897868156433,
0.25879642367362976,
0.6036303639411926,
-0.4843376576900482,
0.2361845076084137,
-0.23738983273506165,
0.35123199224472046,
0.326337993144989,
-0.3524264693260193,
0.3657597303390503,
0.2266465425491333,
-0.37806612253189087,
0.2888680696487427,
-0.8530263304710388,
-0.20955735445022583,
0.8855136632919312,
0.15578553080558777,
0.3273382782936096,
0.5421954393386841,
1.0925201177597046,
0.3354221284389496,
0.012044575065374374,
-0.541767954826355,
0.7403976321220398,
0.15631859004497528,
-0.6885818839073181,
-0.44844430685043335,
-0.5324491262435913,
-0.6104984283447266,
0.3625580966472626,
-0.3537839353084564,
-0.3170093595981598,
0.4578593075275421,
0.36987289786338806,
-0.7926259636878967,
0.1668774038553238,
-0.6082703471183777,
0.7515799403190613,
-0.08270104229450226,
-0.11706922203302383,
-0.6494311094284058,
-0.07101887464523315,
0.5158010125160217,
-0.4055855870246887,
0.4716574549674988,
-0.04643387347459793,
-0.0060508837923407555,
0.5930653214454651,
-0.49284493923187256,
0.5508281588554382,
-0.009803584776818752,
-0.5360338091850281,
0.4447222054004669,
0.6679429411888123,
0.2721560597419739,
0.14588846266269684,
-0.2033080756664276,
-0.12372288852930069,
0.4841058850288391,
-0.7126742005348206,
-0.694650411605835,
0.4760894775390625,
-0.8228235244750977,
-0.49758172035217285,
-0.29333680868148804,
-0.5424230098724365,
-0.1891339123249054,
0.3947826325893402,
-0.2890893816947937,
0.44753214716911316,
-0.2911504805088043,
-0.5045564770698547,
0.7453306913375854,
-0.024475321173667908,
0.013727203942835331,
0.7896605134010315,
-0.6341843008995056,
-0.31420108675956726,
1.104048252105713,
0.1769394725561142,
0.16105902194976807,
0.39959725737571716,
0.126091867685318,
-0.21239759027957916,
-0.4605241119861603,
-0.8695054054260254,
0.05779041349887848,
-0.6664061546325684,
0.003961092326790094,
-0.333561509847641,
-0.1370549350976944,
-0.4522085189819336,
-0.31835174560546875,
-0.33918699622154236,
-0.7461040019989014,
0.05243675783276558,
0.08439205586910248,
0.5279476046562195,
0.5497868061065674,
-0.2745547890663147,
0.36150264739990234,
-0.6109189987182617,
0.616813063621521,
0.5930063724517822,
0.4054493308067322,
0.10680598765611649,
-0.31788569688796997,
-0.542510449886322,
-0.05015663430094719,
0.06997112929821014,
-1.1192899942398071,
0.005920948926359415,
0.4914097785949707,
0.5459358096122742,
0.41075775027275085,
0.13577432930469513,
0.9521507024765015,
-0.30600598454475403,
0.6102527976036072,
0.01826477237045765,
-1.2488453388214111,
0.459852397441864,
-0.22020263969898224,
0.2511535882949829,
0.5779523253440857,
0.3299727439880371,
-0.1842012107372284,
-0.6026591062545776,
-0.6577708125114441,
-0.5180637836456299,
0.11978540569543839,
0.13951021432876587,
-0.04787786304950714,
-0.25226688385009766,
0.6544049382209778,
-0.17370158433914185,
0.3227338194847107,
-0.2887510657310486,
-0.2751401364803314,
-0.18682219088077545,
-0.4537234306335449,
0.02380671165883541,
-0.21109186112880707,
-0.2820127010345459,
0.0073241982609033585,
0.7081493735313416,
-0.1913243681192398,
0.30592671036720276,
0.24093036353588104,
-0.4797796905040741,
-0.5629595518112183,
0.09246333688497543,
0.6226847171783447,
0.5524418354034424,
0.06150038540363312,
0.20919443666934967,
-0.07821705937385559,
-0.3934965133666992,
0.4771728515625,
0.11801581084728241,
-0.6173093914985657,
-0.08709162473678589,
-0.10464240610599518,
0.6668132543563843,
0.5263351798057556,
-0.9074026942253113,
0.09136220812797546,
-0.05138762295246124,
-0.21751368045806885,
-0.4815910756587982,
0.3218945562839508,
0.08767169713973999,
0.38916289806365967,
0.4499305486679077,
-0.47372111678123474,
0.6526227593421936,
-0.5443715453147888,
0.25539055466651917,
0.24290384352207184,
-0.03188299387693405,
-0.3709462881088257,
0.6674395799636841,
0.14160007238388062,
-0.27167168259620667,
0.3306986391544342,
-0.6358368396759033,
-0.42876914143562317,
0.5489809513092041,
0.6660050749778748,
0.8715786337852478,
-0.3628653287887573,
0.17394979298114777,
0.6563112139701843,
0.34312087297439575,
-0.03882739692926407,
0.6446224451065063,
-0.33801668882369995,
-0.683559238910675,
-0.27426379919052124,
-0.9404319524765015,
-0.2690000832080841,
-0.32093021273612976,
-0.6021119952201843,
-0.18365900218486786,
-1.035548210144043,
-0.3048447072505951,
-0.33091646432876587,
0.1989431530237198,
-0.4618207812309265,
0.2111479938030243,
0.09406202286481857,
0.8314890265464783,
-0.8843064308166504,
0.9150779843330383,
0.7572668790817261,
-0.28631845116615295,
-0.8139411211013794,
-0.23206333816051483,
-0.03253582492470741,
-0.5111188292503357,
0.24149496853351593,
-0.3156929016113281,
-0.27623528242111206,
0.6960247755050659,
-0.1511584222316742,
-1.4008409976959229,
1.0192294120788574,
0.14786240458488464,
-0.6930987238883972,
0.09910829365253448,
-0.038307949900627136,
0.40865570306777954,
-0.23359675705432892,
-0.08480159193277359,
0.656037449836731,
0.2833766043186188,
-0.576335608959198,
-0.7823386192321777,
0.5369719862937927,
-0.4047923982143402,
0.39998146891593933,
0.5965609550476074,
-0.7302646636962891,
0.8889740109443665,
-0.12146133929491043,
-0.6345835328102112,
0.2971545159816742,
1.0655081272125244,
0.48849964141845703,
-0.15733963251113892,
0.7166739702224731,
0.7084415555000305,
0.6746621131896973,
0.1947993040084839,
0.8100045323371887,
-0.7205172181129456,
0.14481452107429504,
0.6699090600013733,
-0.42597293853759766,
0.9129325747489929,
0.5339993834495544,
-0.3886009454727173,
0.9757451415061951,
0.3903869092464447,
0.16285020112991333,
0.3141113817691803,
0.3615342378616333,
-0.30169588327407837,
-0.5606498718261719,
0.2928628623485565,
-0.3777013421058655,
0.018330438062548637,
0.5068597793579102,
0.09228447079658508,
-0.13753359019756317,
0.022335300222039223,
-0.2958853542804718,
0.19156304001808167,
-0.17177489399909973,
0.595548152923584,
0.11049418896436691,
-0.23532071709632874,
0.8189629316329956,
0.1289907693862915,
0.22615492343902588,
-0.4351099133491516,
-0.2860134243965149,
-0.20873166620731354,
-0.4860111176967621,
-0.1036704033613205,
-0.37393832206726074,
0.16204111278057098,
-0.41166800260543823,
-0.2857127785682678,
0.2975548505783081,
0.47051703929901123,
-0.46803727746009827,
-0.3657177984714508,
0.1155930757522583,
0.4033338725566864,
0.2789660692214966,
0.29058921337127686,
-0.7753303050994873,
0.2117118090391159,
-0.23742234706878662,
-0.20157496631145477,
0.4448390007019043,
0.36430981755256653,
-0.2899323105812073,
0.605712890625,
0.8339983820915222,
-0.2399691790342331,
0.36265236139297485,
-0.2933996915817261,
0.5548842549324036,
-0.8071309924125671,
-0.8625165224075317,
-0.37720608711242676,
0.3209291994571686,
0.16934067010879517,
-0.32651907205581665,
0.49433809518814087,
0.5114092230796814,
0.6917484402656555,
0.04382416233420372,
0.6802425384521484,
-0.0005242559709586203,
0.1733248233795166,
-0.6369718313217163,
0.9698590040206909,
-0.7757148146629333,
-0.10742703080177307,
-0.014827948994934559,
-0.7371824383735657,
0.02550455927848816,
0.9964619278907776,
0.1813417673110962,
-0.009420985355973244,
0.6803836822509766,
0.808587372303009,
0.21072708070278168,
-0.022794216871261597,
0.6359778642654419,
0.3263576626777649,
0.18577858805656433,
0.9029665589332581,
0.5866348743438721,
-0.7114766240119934,
0.20266322791576385,
-0.5345574617385864,
-0.27302074432373047,
-0.24240712821483612,
-0.36262157559394836,
-0.5302197337150574,
-0.9058298468589783,
-0.5495941042900085,
-0.28665632009506226,
0.1348744034767151,
0.6673327088356018,
0.6867315769195557,
-0.7644687294960022,
-0.6375811696052551,
-0.31820014119148254,
0.15130026638507843,
-0.3811734914779663,
-0.24637241661548615,
0.1899188756942749,
-0.12500536441802979,
-0.6241868138313293,
0.5763973593711853,
0.3505636751651764,
0.48989713191986084,
-0.5312824249267578,
-0.33055514097213745,
-0.0061940280720591545,
0.45217597484588623,
0.6883423328399658,
0.6853113174438477,
-0.5521780848503113,
-0.06574214994907379,
-0.16043485701084137,
-0.3289543688297272,
-0.2626294493675232,
0.617164134979248,
-0.9958145618438721,
0.5120769143104553,
0.3086863160133362,
0.7706223130226135,
0.2223149687051773,
-0.474445104598999,
0.9257975220680237,
0.09181547164916992,
0.10844153165817261,
0.0835174098610878,
0.10856509208679199,
-0.1527029126882553,
-0.422161340713501,
0.22420072555541992,
0.11056823283433914,
-0.2552947998046875,
-0.9631331562995911,
0.626146137714386,
-1.0312246084213257,
-0.32262471318244934,
0.8032703399658203,
0.21213117241859436,
-0.4939727187156677,
-0.2689144015312195,
0.21518594026565552,
0.29937121272087097,
-0.34436124563217163,
0.7783656120300293,
0.4365149736404419,
0.12985731661319733,
-0.16925670206546783,
-0.44901496171951294,
0.8138963580131531,
0.7888171672821045,
-0.5514199733734131,
-0.35764384269714355,
0.5032132267951965,
0.21680016815662384,
0.19202537834644318,
1.1834747791290283,
-0.1664431244134903,
0.9749694466590881,
0.09105741232633591,
0.28982916474342346,
0.2314375638961792,
-0.18972644209861755,
-0.6340749263763428,
0.20108503103256226,
0.3816542625427246,
0.266065388917923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02775v1 | MLKD-BERT: Multi-level Knowledge Distillation for Pre-trained Language Models | 2024-07-03T03:03:30 | 2024-07-03T03:03:30 | Ying Zhang, Ziheng Yang, Shufan Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Knowledge distillation is an effective technique for pre-trained language
model compression. Although existing knowledge distillation methods perform
well for the most typical model BERT, they could be further improved in two
aspects: the relation-level knowledge could be further explored to improve
model performance; and the setting of student attention head number could be
more flexible to decrease inference time. Therefore, we are motivated to
propose a novel knowledge distillation method MLKD-BERT to distill multi-level
knowledge in teacher-student framework. Extensive experiments on GLUE benchmark
and extractive question answering tasks demonstrate that our method outperforms
state-of-the-art knowledge distillation methods on BERT. In addition, MLKD-BERT
can flexibly set student attention head number, allowing for substantial
inference time decrease with little performance drop. | [
-0.6804898977279663,
-0.8887283802032471,
0.5420455932617188,
0.15626537799835205,
-0.2679685354232788,
0.2180323749780655,
-0.27804726362228394,
-0.23651431500911713,
-0.12226230651140213,
0.28130605816841125,
-0.5917690396308899,
-0.3711441159248352,
-0.8359565734863281,
-0.18438231945037842,
-0.45898622274398804,
1.0978103876113892,
0.21969816088676453,
0.1755674034357071,
-0.37934646010398865,
0.19900530576705933,
-0.3173747658729553,
-0.6377266049385071,
-0.5267154574394226,
-0.24200308322906494,
0.7755375504493713,
0.3295111358165741,
0.2192315012216568,
0.4200046956539154,
0.5528177618980408,
0.3439512848854065,
-0.28658047318458557,
-0.052842769771814346,
-0.6289082169532776,
0.36389726400375366,
0.0020791469141840935,
-0.5102828741073608,
-0.34143713116645813,
0.018159111961722374,
0.4875110387802124,
0.9149562120437622,
-0.31930094957351685,
0.27063190937042236,
0.41709157824516296,
0.922464907169342,
-0.7649208307266235,
-0.02572673372924328,
-0.7823929786682129,
-0.03151606395840645,
-0.010306763462722301,
0.11070653796195984,
-0.44114449620246887,
-0.4459649622440338,
0.5541979074478149,
-0.4294891059398651,
0.34722593426704407,
-0.30558016896247864,
0.7566182017326355,
0.5624184012413025,
-0.43879005312919617,
-0.08798887580633163,
-0.8735178709030151,
0.8476038575172424,
-0.9243574142456055,
0.40728259086608887,
0.4642176032066345,
0.5701155662536621,
0.05703992769122124,
-0.9597694277763367,
-0.7268849611282349,
0.03145277872681618,
0.04822155833244324,
-0.012956270948052406,
0.3280273675918579,
0.30707958340644836,
0.477664053440094,
0.4375782608985901,
-0.30972880125045776,
-0.23079144954681396,
-0.47605717182159424,
0.04176296293735504,
0.2720457911491394,
-0.27262741327285767,
0.03100535459816456,
0.13880164921283722,
-0.4532225728034973,
-0.2863406240940094,
-0.5131375193595886,
0.0989055261015892,
0.26653698086738586,
0.24767987430095673,
0.39850232005119324,
0.2690727412700653,
-0.17890897393226624,
0.8425740003585815,
0.1864837408065796,
-0.5133064985275269,
0.12766508758068085,
-0.11507248133420944,
-0.28613385558128357,
0.15407779812812805,
0.37730154395103455,
0.05647333338856697,
0.4586590826511383,
-0.03999631851911545,
-0.010191593319177628,
-0.18212129175662994,
0.24968867003917694,
-1.1409275531768799,
-0.6260721683502197,
0.26271721720695496,
-0.5765936374664307,
-0.29767510294914246,
-0.030449653044342995,
-0.7521905899047852,
-0.2580547034740448,
-0.4155908524990082,
0.47022250294685364,
-0.43683508038520813,
-0.5227178931236267,
0.019470274448394775,
-0.4650510251522064,
-0.11563281714916229,
0.30276772379875183,
-1.0229015350341797,
0.08515160530805588,
0.5768298506736755,
0.5556453466415405,
-0.029730405658483505,
-0.36153730750083923,
-0.10622004419565201,
0.28160199522972107,
-0.04768095538020134,
0.5335752367973328,
-0.5638193488121033,
-0.12765300273895264,
-0.22732533514499664,
-0.32427889108657837,
0.05943116545677185,
-0.5819444060325623,
0.33952444791793823,
-0.410186767578125,
0.14285510778427124,
-0.5207508206367493,
-0.9079357981681824,
-0.21862953901290894,
0.22963163256645203,
-0.684302568435669,
1.205497145652771,
0.13153453171253204,
-0.8782480955123901,
0.6575921177864075,
-0.43801844120025635,
-0.41608190536499023,
-0.01200819294899702,
0.05510152131319046,
-0.2690024673938751,
0.21471332013607025,
0.5999657511711121,
0.6077267527580261,
0.05287545919418335,
0.33130186796188354,
-0.549227774143219,
-0.12555161118507385,
-0.11322169750928879,
-0.38199692964553833,
0.9837961196899414,
0.35191041231155396,
-0.013735145330429077,
-0.1673862785100937,
-0.8208590745925903,
0.03931991010904312,
0.012159163132309914,
-0.5091053247451782,
-0.7424399852752686,
-0.14401359856128693,
-0.25327634811401367,
0.31003597378730774,
0.5135613679885864,
-0.6039097309112549,
0.4614265561103821,
-0.2816135883331299,
0.2707628905773163,
0.8155595064163208,
0.14834772050380707,
0.3746795952320099,
-0.12803976237773895,
0.2993994355201721,
0.19997741281986237,
0.17058676481246948,
-0.11784917116165161,
-0.5667677521705627,
-0.8582374453544617,
-0.399074524641037,
0.47326067090034485,
0.3160097897052765,
-0.8162803053855896,
0.47865116596221924,
-0.015360092744231224,
-0.5844728946685791,
-0.8598526120185852,
0.2579071819782257,
0.28832998871803284,
0.849602997303009,
0.41214510798454285,
0.07516364753246307,
-0.5519851446151733,
-0.7961136698722839,
-0.13335315883159637,
-0.1338501274585724,
-0.10173826664686203,
0.05448666214942932,
0.15646691620349884,
0.11274173110723495,
1.080603837966919,
-0.755955696105957,
-0.2198283076286316,
-0.2565549910068512,
0.4643171727657318,
0.3038060963153839,
0.5624531507492065,
0.8107109069824219,
-0.8144542574882507,
-0.8741303086280823,
-0.31564080715179443,
-0.48656338453292847,
0.030376361683011055,
0.134894460439682,
-0.2538844048976898,
-0.009959097020328045,
0.4616867005825043,
-0.5271511673927307,
0.2328418791294098,
0.5043708086013794,
-0.09071528911590576,
0.5137540698051453,
-0.3331432342529297,
0.2530032992362976,
-1.3469587564468384,
-0.011944329366087914,
-0.19907858967781067,
-0.18418532609939575,
-0.8339330554008484,
-0.1075851172208786,
0.1594359129667282,
0.01248636282980442,
-0.42346489429473877,
0.080580934882164,
-0.45557424426078796,
0.07791340351104736,
-0.31996750831604004,
0.020601551979780197,
0.07422666251659393,
0.6824552416801453,
0.14854370057582855,
0.4254027009010315,
0.6133193373680115,
-0.6197121739387512,
0.5746346712112427,
0.07827477902173996,
-0.6806317567825317,
0.4115716516971588,
-0.5995275378227234,
0.28902819752693176,
-0.24780206382274628,
0.11878252774477005,
-1.308808445930481,
0.20989257097244263,
-0.2666754722595215,
-0.37819281220436096,
0.467307448387146,
-0.24230967462062836,
-0.43094417452812195,
-0.6195042133331299,
-0.11432712525129318,
0.39197036623954773,
0.5699747204780579,
-0.5815921425819397,
0.5420079827308655,
0.3129638731479645,
-0.36216482520103455,
-0.9281835556030273,
-0.6811383962631226,
-0.22529157996177673,
-0.41797730326652527,
-0.4821065366268158,
0.1757924109697342,
-0.4299507439136505,
-0.10472878068685532,
0.10543455928564072,
-0.4617072641849518,
-0.6320843696594238,
0.1664792001247406,
-0.15269362926483154,
0.1907164752483368,
-0.15081240236759186,
0.10988228768110275,
0.401054710149765,
0.07765207439661026,
0.053095489740371704,
-0.2595982551574707,
0.5100849270820618,
0.2853426933288574,
-0.19312947988510132,
-0.36939749121665955,
0.44086751341819763,
0.5143243074417114,
-0.08539416640996933,
0.9875727891921997,
0.7252612113952637,
-0.4816753566265106,
-0.22486576437950134,
-0.7711905241012573,
-0.5841950178146362,
-0.4895847737789154,
0.418750137090683,
-0.6850996017456055,
-0.9145678877830505,
0.4119378924369812,
-0.2772197723388672,
0.24095267057418823,
0.21957609057426453,
0.5929137468338013,
-0.4194742739200592,
1.0135878324508667,
0.7221579551696777,
-0.25899770855903625,
0.5399390459060669,
-0.17864251136779785,
0.27136746048927307,
-0.4725934863090515,
-0.2027684599161148,
-0.6768750548362732,
-0.5830966234207153,
-0.104598768055439,
-0.05903514474630356,
0.20553027093410492,
0.5775220394134521,
-0.07224172353744507,
0.3071538805961609,
-0.6149889230728149,
0.6482775211334229,
0.784899115562439,
0.17245233058929443,
0.2103080302476883,
-0.11803872883319855,
-0.16251198947429657,
-0.14453189074993134,
-0.6370239853858948,
-0.14072903990745544,
1.1786645650863647,
0.2557881772518158,
0.7836863994598389,
0.013757673092186451,
1.0196892023086548,
0.14112871885299683,
0.15663523972034454,
-0.5715276002883911,
0.41828441619873047,
-0.09779759496450424,
-0.8771456480026245,
-0.6399408578872681,
-0.43850433826446533,
-0.6932616829872131,
0.3369859457015991,
-0.14373473823070526,
-0.7050364017486572,
0.1576765775680542,
0.28888705372810364,
-0.3841836154460907,
0.2716529667377472,
-1.053173303604126,
0.886806845664978,
-0.027127522975206375,
0.2685604691505432,
-0.34222060441970825,
-0.7930724024772644,
0.46961939334869385,
-0.3022646903991699,
0.028211869299411774,
-0.225238636136055,
0.324153870344162,
0.8369337320327759,
-0.6347405314445496,
0.6718742847442627,
-0.7306461930274963,
-0.3926915228366852,
0.20533062517642975,
-0.06947759538888931,
0.5240951776504517,
-0.06944873183965683,
0.23279491066932678,
0.017743561416864395,
0.2975899577140808,
-0.3129267394542694,
-0.8813668489456177,
0.5654399991035461,
-0.6974787712097168,
-0.6658857464790344,
0.013804201036691666,
-0.8722386360168457,
-0.3611668050289154,
0.274847149848938,
0.034454070031642914,
0.19092683494091034,
0.09725046157836914,
0.42846038937568665,
0.9258543848991394,
-0.044772759079933167,
0.5243123173713684,
0.49325719475746155,
-0.24632956087589264,
-0.2205582857131958,
0.9201903939247131,
0.2386995404958725,
0.4009230136871338,
0.5928588509559631,
0.28426316380500793,
-0.3681989014148712,
-0.5328722596168518,
-0.025792792439460754,
-0.11776166409254074,
-0.7423092722892761,
-0.147623673081398,
-0.7725886702537537,
-0.33897489309310913,
-0.8239133358001709,
0.09987284988164902,
-0.5036942958831787,
-0.6795594692230225,
-0.06541819870471954,
-0.11061082035303116,
0.16793419420719147,
0.6661171317100525,
-0.11076740175485611,
0.21532925963401794,
-0.9187883734703064,
0.6025226712226868,
0.7148528695106506,
0.07746433466672897,
0.19869136810302734,
-0.35816672444343567,
-0.35731732845306396,
0.1681891679763794,
-0.1637316644191742,
-0.8459641933441162,
0.24269361793994904,
0.6053161025047302,
0.7202688455581665,
0.7666480541229248,
0.4444565176963806,
0.8913196921348572,
-0.6023654341697693,
0.6527191996574402,
0.25344863533973694,
-0.8645896911621094,
0.6870558857917786,
0.08986368775367737,
0.4439280331134796,
0.6199191212654114,
0.6575948596000671,
-0.2734167277812958,
-0.761762261390686,
-0.4764453172683716,
-0.8680007457733154,
0.62967848777771,
0.010844173841178417,
-0.013655092567205429,
0.2296587973833084,
0.21377965807914734,
0.29698631167411804,
0.40674784779548645,
-0.5080413222312927,
-0.5368157625198364,
-0.17392417788505554,
-0.32504788041114807,
0.002183185890316963,
-0.6591127514839172,
-0.06147720664739609,
-0.6812964677810669,
0.5768721103668213,
0.2016485333442688,
0.12174950540065765,
-0.0003683466056827456,
-0.21091562509536743,
0.1974031627178192,
0.1555478572845459,
0.4183148443698883,
0.774176836013794,
-0.6425911784172058,
0.2624288499355316,
0.19947867095470428,
-0.7411779761314392,
0.2274237722158432,
0.15030233561992645,
0.20515193045139313,
-0.14136244356632233,
0.25853845477104187,
0.5862821340560913,
-0.045376524329185486,
-0.3461243212223053,
0.36056891083717346,
-0.25346383452415466,
-0.43929117918014526,
0.10761366784572601,
0.08501236885786057,
0.2841666340827942,
0.49015820026397705,
0.6580619215965271,
-0.20181666314601898,
0.1711079478263855,
-0.2772873044013977,
0.43517759442329407,
0.11590874195098877,
-0.1080549955368042,
-0.014619122259318829,
0.525292158126831,
0.30816540122032166,
0.1367695927619934,
0.7275177240371704,
0.058087337762117386,
-0.41106116771698,
0.5091614127159119,
0.4549119472503662,
0.6941649317741394,
-0.6567949056625366,
-0.0018332231556996703,
0.4477190673351288,
0.1262231469154358,
0.06827943027019501,
0.35981497168540955,
-0.5710701942443848,
-0.8653993010520935,
-0.7126287817955017,
-0.7334679365158081,
-0.15173636376857758,
0.31898918747901917,
-1.0249171257019043,
-0.04199299216270447,
-0.2895399332046509,
-0.17751632630825043,
0.1893090158700943,
0.06211569532752037,
-0.47282397747039795,
0.13947199285030365,
0.12327558547258377,
0.8748018741607666,
-0.7283043265342712,
1.5101290941238403,
0.5294061303138733,
-0.22982029616832733,
-0.7821479439735413,
0.0034056378062814474,
-0.2702673673629761,
-0.605694591999054,
1.0130547285079956,
0.057983338832855225,
0.18280856311321259,
0.23624283075332642,
-0.42954888939857483,
-0.7814342379570007,
0.9507375955581665,
0.7375547289848328,
-0.926179051399231,
-0.1940498948097229,
0.1735338717699051,
0.3825206756591797,
-0.100919209420681,
0.04945366457104683,
0.7238133549690247,
0.4812813103199005,
0.3337353467941284,
-1.0338187217712402,
-0.2669813334941864,
-0.13331986963748932,
0.05144181847572327,
0.16119107604026794,
-0.13716883957386017,
0.9880762696266174,
-0.19278420507907867,
-0.19144581258296967,
-0.2619338631629944,
0.8575429916381836,
0.06753187626600266,
-0.036573685705661774,
0.7156265377998352,
0.9618939757347107,
0.8789363503456116,
-0.11546279489994049,
0.5421540141105652,
-0.5342517495155334,
0.6252792477607727,
1.2618584632873535,
-0.15472082793712616,
0.7261639833450317,
0.6559756398200989,
-0.306831955909729,
0.42089641094207764,
0.5882868766784668,
0.20400995016098022,
1.0430357456207275,
0.21385368704795837,
-0.3464398682117462,
-0.324736624956131,
0.16814270615577698,
-0.563723623752594,
0.14817063510417938,
0.22779572010040283,
-0.08126258105039597,
-0.32683223485946655,
0.35330185294151306,
-0.07428934425115585,
-0.16935093700885773,
-0.14983373880386353,
1.0448062419891357,
0.024243684485554695,
-0.6914779543876648,
0.8201426267623901,
-0.44291096925735474,
0.5898609757423401,
-0.5592134594917297,
-0.1800757646560669,
-0.03947338089346886,
0.3899837136268616,
0.05485894903540611,
-0.7239698171615601,
0.2128194123506546,
-0.1372969150543213,
-0.46767720580101013,
-0.41808679699897766,
0.8187686204910278,
-1.056042194366455,
-0.299235999584198,
0.19057594239711761,
0.523578941822052,
0.26159945130348206,
-0.32348954677581787,
-0.8048086762428284,
-0.13561700284481049,
0.05244177207350731,
-0.37484225630760193,
0.3821297585964203,
0.7110950946807861,
0.5923762917518616,
0.6098619103431702,
0.5404599905014038,
0.11548300832509995,
0.3221893012523651,
0.30836421251296997,
1.044907569885254,
-0.27357661724090576,
-0.40934672951698303,
-0.9378083348274231,
0.5258206129074097,
-0.1632900983095169,
0.009634886868298054,
0.8878175616264343,
0.4020709991455078,
0.9318305850028992,
-0.2941009998321533,
0.9155182242393494,
-0.25265273451805115,
0.7143466472625732,
-0.37583357095718384,
0.9867501854896545,
-0.49402090907096863,
-0.035638436675071716,
-0.485867977142334,
-1.2092400789260864,
0.06478186696767807,
0.6446600556373596,
0.06560885906219482,
0.0898088663816452,
0.789804995059967,
0.39135104417800903,
0.12174566835165024,
-0.12885251641273499,
0.47185370326042175,
0.22553911805152893,
0.40438371896743774,
0.679970383644104,
0.8012722730636597,
-0.08918120712041855,
0.6416333913803101,
-0.6386252641677856,
-0.2136303186416626,
0.018089555203914642,
-0.925285279750824,
-1.2638458013534546,
-0.954902708530426,
-0.20933127403259277,
-0.012547881342470646,
-0.027612414211034775,
0.6392247676849365,
1.0086561441421509,
-0.8094720840454102,
-0.024706024676561356,
-0.027286671102046967,
0.0317402146756649,
-0.4195375442504883,
-0.2314530462026596,
0.4103984534740448,
-0.6999638676643372,
-1.0134203433990479,
0.33343273401260376,
-0.12750522792339325,
0.12744179368019104,
-0.45363956689834595,
0.04298026114702225,
-0.4635673463344574,
-0.09895070642232895,
0.5747413635253906,
-0.04659314453601837,
-0.5420018434524536,
-0.14503444731235504,
-0.3084241449832916,
-0.01304640807211399,
-0.1200108602643013,
0.9337410926818848,
-0.7635142803192139,
0.5603492259979248,
0.7058959007263184,
0.6260915994644165,
0.7242608666419983,
0.09894999861717224,
0.6624581217765808,
-1.2936493158340454,
0.49023813009262085,
0.16869382560253143,
0.3173474669456482,
-0.028208013623952866,
-0.2507779896259308,
0.20995603501796722,
0.22604221105575562,
-0.5680058002471924,
-0.9173641204833984,
0.05204786732792854,
-0.7939096093177795,
-0.5266979336738586,
0.8999267816543579,
-0.6089049577713013,
-0.07559778541326523,
-0.11794158816337585,
-0.369049072265625,
0.42931175231933594,
-0.4777542054653168,
0.9388469457626343,
1.0255948305130005,
0.11163926869630814,
-0.3753243088722229,
-0.3437005877494812,
0.7375136017799377,
0.18320105969905853,
-0.8019228577613831,
0.17503543198108673,
0.2344156950712204,
0.1997041255235672,
0.14748723804950714,
0.43309831619262695,
0.24726076424121857,
-0.09623213857412338,
0.0238055270165205,
0.2213740199804306,
-0.16447187960147858,
-0.7491635084152222,
0.1352541148662567,
0.2658385932445526,
0.057176265865564346,
-0.2900122404098511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02772v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02772v1 | Automatic gradient descent with generalized Newton's method | 2024-07-03T03:01:43 | 2024-07-03T03:01:43 | Zhiqi Bu, Shiyun Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | We propose the generalized Newton's method (GeN) -- a Hessian-informed
approach that applies to any optimizer such as SGD and Adam, and covers the
Newton-Raphson method as a sub-case. Our method automatically and dynamically
selects the learning rate that accelerates the convergence, without the
intensive tuning of the learning rate scheduler. In practice, out method is
easily implementable, since it only requires additional forward passes with
almost zero computational overhead (in terms of training time and memory cost),
if the overhead is amortized over many iterations. We present extensive
experiments on language and vision tasks (e.g. GPT and ResNet) to showcase that
GeN optimizers match the state-of-the-art performance, which was achieved with
carefully tuned learning rate schedulers. Code to be released at
\url{https://github.com/ShiyunXu/AutoGeN}. | [
-0.47294536232948303,
-0.30837759375572205,
0.28558972477912903,
-0.10647594183683395,
-0.2689751386642456,
0.5540826916694641,
-0.08076111227273941,
-0.414028137922287,
0.19390416145324707,
-0.3191472887992859,
-0.6703093647956848,
-0.21361932158470154,
-0.4165896773338318,
0.01880432292819023,
-0.3925434947013855,
0.9951967597007751,
-0.16670344769954681,
0.2585752010345459,
-0.14048486948013306,
-0.05273720994591713,
0.5825538635253906,
-0.14967238903045654,
-1.3088072538375854,
-0.2975355386734009,
0.3961615562438965,
0.017324935644865036,
0.42055052518844604,
1.0637438297271729,
0.6185404062271118,
0.3381819725036621,
-0.0714825913310051,
0.0009319435339421034,
-0.31793278455734253,
-0.05338313803076744,
-0.003939169924706221,
-0.22490103542804718,
-0.18847300112247467,
-0.037683941423892975,
0.7373635172843933,
0.6261621117591858,
-0.59687739610672,
0.2877940833568573,
0.13276658952236176,
0.9802036285400391,
-0.8182661533355713,
-0.10372107475996017,
-0.4138096272945404,
0.4904314875602722,
0.15285895764827728,
-0.18858830630779266,
0.06188549846410751,
-0.4867238700389862,
0.06372224539518356,
-0.8552401661872864,
0.8710863590240479,
0.07208287715911865,
0.535713255405426,
0.4249531626701355,
-0.07525325566530228,
-0.10092627257108688,
-0.6451514363288879,
0.7417488098144531,
-0.032288115471601486,
0.2545790672302246,
-0.1792728155851364,
0.6694243550300598,
0.18831592798233032,
-0.9654921293258667,
-0.2804924547672272,
-0.5732117891311646,
0.11345776915550232,
0.33807608485221863,
-0.09567312896251678,
0.3573589622974396,
0.5650048851966858,
0.6260779500007629,
-0.7321178913116455,
-0.06001032143831253,
-0.25269681215286255,
0.04798675328493118,
0.7199769616127014,
0.11296136677265167,
0.29658418893814087,
0.2711208164691925,
-0.4600381851196289,
-0.14681831002235413,
-0.5428284406661987,
0.19314728677272797,
0.8297232389450073,
0.019777268171310425,
-0.06908567249774933,
0.26281580328941345,
-0.30314159393310547,
0.6287549138069153,
0.38940656185150146,
0.2510889768600464,
0.46524927020072937,
-0.4177175760269165,
-0.14399608969688416,
-0.30106842517852783,
0.6539174318313599,
0.17744016647338867,
0.4875577688217163,
-0.3398362994194031,
-0.37875622510910034,
-0.00793288554996252,
0.47009801864624023,
-0.8365984559059143,
-0.4029960036277771,
-0.11287648975849152,
-0.4270256757736206,
-0.27625927329063416,
-0.18318483233451843,
-1.16199791431427,
-0.24861878156661987,
-0.41157883405685425,
0.31937935948371887,
-0.07111620903015137,
0.018372781574726105,
-0.20367032289505005,
-0.14594031870365143,
0.294015109539032,
0.1710621565580368,
-1.0542422533035278,
0.48895326256752014,
0.3220343291759491,
0.9119226932525635,
-0.153712660074234,
-0.1324814110994339,
-0.9532603025436401,
-0.21914610266685486,
-0.45582103729248047,
0.43240025639533997,
-0.5241692066192627,
-0.6131218671798706,
0.07156749069690704,
-0.1645062118768692,
-0.27091866731643677,
-0.388415664434433,
0.42105838656425476,
-0.3793916404247284,
0.25012749433517456,
-0.20924347639083862,
-0.39995482563972473,
-0.49809136986732483,
-0.16215309500694275,
-0.3679421842098236,
0.9386215806007385,
0.27945515513420105,
-0.5471500754356384,
0.47767865657806396,
-1.057018518447876,
-0.5341223478317261,
0.19136561453342438,
-0.2974078953266144,
-0.43443435430526733,
0.11529780924320221,
0.32807013392448425,
0.2728910744190216,
-0.29235556721687317,
0.2221968173980713,
-0.1497543603181839,
-0.36962971091270447,
-0.6530454158782959,
-0.18732739984989166,
0.7866783142089844,
0.39784863591194153,
-0.7900999784469604,
0.20492976903915405,
-0.9822028279304504,
-0.027238676324486732,
0.3730672001838684,
-0.09892471879720688,
-0.005726518575102091,
0.4340852200984955,
-0.30565503239631653,
-0.010430372320115566,
0.23474836349487305,
-0.4665350914001465,
0.3904714584350586,
-0.43387553095817566,
0.4076733887195587,
0.5949706435203552,
-0.2666564881801605,
0.6665817499160767,
-0.1952645480632782,
0.9216709733009338,
-0.446928471326828,
0.4370405077934265,
0.04245622456073761,
-0.36013317108154297,
-0.8075260519981384,
-0.11283362656831741,
0.3033961057662964,
0.6395960450172424,
-0.751575231552124,
0.43363460898399353,
-0.03278428688645363,
-0.36353495717048645,
-0.2536187767982483,
0.030600547790527344,
0.590030312538147,
0.7579533457756042,
0.5728393197059631,
-0.3229726254940033,
-0.3888950049877167,
-0.7282410860061646,
-0.2167220413684845,
-0.2165096402168274,
-0.10160884261131287,
0.47292205691337585,
0.3066544830799103,
-0.1350962072610855,
0.6879692077636719,
-0.47890031337738037,
0.15451353788375854,
0.060700275003910065,
0.41723453998565674,
-0.05011867731809616,
0.7156550288200378,
0.9282265305519104,
-0.5540253520011902,
-0.5405754446983337,
0.03753124922513962,
-0.5025343298912048,
-0.24807962775230408,
0.012200734578073025,
-0.14414168894290924,
0.17207598686218262,
0.6578031778335571,
-0.025316128507256508,
0.46152374148368835,
0.4737612307071686,
-0.03768308460712433,
0.46307313442230225,
-0.35769322514533997,
0.1332988291978836,
-0.8747715353965759,
0.23811902105808258,
0.282756507396698,
-0.20443175733089447,
-0.4044201672077179,
0.16249307990074158,
0.023886092007160187,
-0.10993953049182892,
-0.21032604575157166,
0.35229700803756714,
-0.47579383850097656,
-0.3970082402229309,
-0.06924742460250854,
-0.20560894906520844,
-0.24465475976467133,
0.32405567169189453,
-0.12032091617584229,
1.2205764055252075,
0.8340812921524048,
-0.8372040390968323,
0.4947955012321472,
-0.02441001869738102,
-0.13476547598838806,
0.28112784028053284,
-0.794154703617096,
0.19672666490077972,
-0.3570191562175751,
0.0922858715057373,
-0.8224044442176819,
0.05390596017241478,
0.5825676321983337,
-0.4613244831562042,
0.600161075592041,
-0.5509273409843445,
0.03827948123216629,
-0.6503318548202515,
-0.3434872329235077,
0.4783326983451843,
0.7368479371070862,
-0.8462132811546326,
0.7940483689308167,
0.059226348996162415,
-0.029672374948859215,
-0.9712050557136536,
-0.4158755838871002,
-0.07911811769008636,
-0.21183016896247864,
-0.19774454832077026,
0.44131407141685486,
-0.3587055206298828,
-0.08060109615325928,
-0.1475888192653656,
0.08254683017730713,
0.16981451213359833,
0.11120592802762985,
0.001962993061169982,
0.13682056963443756,
-0.010798747651278973,
-0.06941407173871994,
0.039761606603860855,
-0.2777918875217438,
0.10804958641529083,
-0.8450683951377869,
0.40370088815689087,
-0.3135482966899872,
-0.2827145755290985,
-0.33060991764068604,
0.2860928475856781,
0.3607145845890045,
-0.24357300996780396,
0.35678690671920776,
0.9838832020759583,
-0.21333442628383636,
-0.32155656814575195,
-0.35812312364578247,
-0.02255968004465103,
-0.4921935796737671,
0.2648703157901764,
-0.2615790069103241,
-0.7035038471221924,
0.8063926696777344,
-0.056189242750406265,
0.1566465049982071,
0.734777569770813,
0.4052853584289551,
-0.009835705161094666,
1.2545357942581177,
0.6996559500694275,
-0.2672138512134552,
0.6266415119171143,
-0.6502189040184021,
0.03335888683795929,
-0.7393766045570374,
-0.2166333943605423,
-0.5703015923500061,
-0.5588372945785522,
-0.7004438638687134,
0.005696383770555258,
0.31437209248542786,
0.029961058869957924,
-0.4163023829460144,
0.1768408864736557,
-0.7278873920440674,
0.6712802052497864,
0.7544071674346924,
-0.3160836398601532,
-0.0018053909298032522,
0.11924107372760773,
-0.4227164685726166,
0.3873969316482544,
-0.906921923160553,
0.1742756962776184,
1.1342467069625854,
0.06999502331018448,
0.8157947063446045,
-0.35355281829833984,
0.7279524207115173,
0.2847217917442322,
0.3495613932609558,
-0.7193297743797302,
0.5404080152511597,
-0.23097340762615204,
-0.26225560903549194,
-0.13301993906497955,
-0.7670413255691528,
-0.9269818663597107,
0.14750279486179352,
-0.01545131765305996,
-0.5384882688522339,
0.43483656644821167,
0.5866501331329346,
-0.7393872737884521,
0.4981069266796112,
-0.7122376561164856,
0.473784476518631,
-0.23989218473434448,
-0.11267028748989105,
-0.2568356394767761,
-0.8759914636611938,
0.1810157597064972,
-0.15120309591293335,
-0.12523873150348663,
-0.061531998217105865,
-0.2751072347164154,
0.7775208950042725,
-0.41097137331962585,
0.454525351524353,
-0.7408856153488159,
0.1760507971048355,
0.26889941096305847,
-0.13406509160995483,
0.5835797190666199,
0.13993403315544128,
0.28973084688186646,
0.10187994688749313,
-0.4725489616394043,
-0.279308021068573,
-0.5297031998634338,
0.6338453888893127,
-0.5701398253440857,
-0.22335733473300934,
-0.5323281288146973,
-0.2602125406265259,
-0.11917499452829361,
-0.03787896782159805,
0.5143886208534241,
0.5521443486213684,
0.0046907770447432995,
-0.20726607739925385,
0.3746493458747864,
-0.10993246734142303,
0.9551982879638672,
0.42448392510414124,
-0.21242180466651917,
-0.6958657503128052,
0.7466132640838623,
-0.03155584633350372,
0.28839051723480225,
0.02502845786511898,
0.29714491963386536,
-0.515197217464447,
-0.9268774390220642,
-0.8220619559288025,
0.06117743253707886,
-0.4776003956794739,
-0.17100746929645538,
-0.4006791412830353,
-0.22380325198173523,
-0.15330232679843903,
-0.4448044002056122,
-0.2662862539291382,
-0.2804422676563263,
-0.3726411461830139,
0.006268125958740711,
0.20766860246658325,
0.523869514465332,
-0.35602810978889465,
0.2822127044200897,
-0.6060396432876587,
0.44096076488494873,
0.5264548659324646,
0.41434958577156067,
-0.1546163260936737,
-0.5179851055145264,
-0.19283857941627502,
-0.057490065693855286,
0.0011507547460496426,
-0.04527534916996956,
0.21335507929325104,
0.7118415236473083,
0.6700392961502075,
0.6683610081672668,
-0.28034019470214844,
0.5299246311187744,
-0.874147355556488,
0.6687697172164917,
0.4013167917728424,
-0.7493622303009033,
0.48281604051589966,
-0.3078712224960327,
-0.04615738242864609,
0.6744123697280884,
0.6505438685417175,
-0.03893117606639862,
0.05094822496175766,
-0.676261305809021,
-0.6761864423751831,
0.3309159278869629,
0.03734775632619858,
0.0104678338393569,
0.05471289902925491,
0.7116069793701172,
0.02175854705274105,
0.157191663980484,
-0.23513847589492798,
-0.42180654406547546,
-0.04859507828950882,
-0.1642712503671646,
-0.25276413559913635,
-0.11511184275150299,
-0.255748450756073,
-0.6492860317230225,
0.585576593875885,
-0.41846805810928345,
0.44927623867988586,
0.32540619373321533,
-0.0011343795340508223,
-0.5744928121566772,
-0.21941950917243958,
0.7430773973464966,
0.8360950946807861,
-0.16138955950737,
-0.22499170899391174,
0.11396504938602448,
-0.8101349472999573,
0.31885260343551636,
0.5341399908065796,
-0.6415789127349854,
-0.15207096934318542,
-0.29735490679740906,
0.7434310913085938,
-0.3182743787765503,
-0.2992106080055237,
0.4513600468635559,
-0.30493637919425964,
-0.695577085018158,
-0.27102553844451904,
0.32116425037384033,
-0.4111315906047821,
0.33120715618133545,
0.6168719530105591,
0.43811848759651184,
0.3677861988544464,
0.09355780482292175,
0.3412390947341919,
0.611894428730011,
-0.19886694848537445,
-0.24411283433437347,
1.0102958679199219,
0.4215236008167267,
-0.11897248774766922,
0.33145982027053833,
-0.7041202187538147,
-0.5170033574104309,
0.7932749390602112,
0.3370228409767151,
1.4986727237701416,
-0.40640559792518616,
0.2213117778301239,
0.5066263675689697,
0.32945266366004944,
-0.2888488173484802,
0.41269224882125854,
-0.06883081793785095,
-0.5911763310432434,
-0.9606603980064392,
-0.7732312083244324,
-0.44054192304611206,
0.023035336285829544,
-0.6467553377151489,
-0.1330116093158722,
-0.6865675449371338,
-0.16626031696796417,
-0.016815023496747017,
0.09365960955619812,
-0.44569122791290283,
0.45737510919570923,
0.20492467284202576,
0.7225522994995117,
-0.47633975744247437,
0.45963191986083984,
0.7384859919548035,
0.025286108255386353,
-0.27823004126548767,
0.11520253866910934,
-0.11237040162086487,
-0.9190613627433777,
0.586654543876648,
-0.05001421272754669,
-0.6431006193161011,
0.6133339405059814,
-0.47798067331314087,
-0.8001294732093811,
0.8899528980255127,
0.5287894010543823,
-0.8220454454421997,
-0.1522967666387558,
-0.33952972292900085,
0.23521678149700165,
-0.31532615423202515,
0.19334708154201508,
0.4124641418457031,
0.3376212418079376,
0.11135222017765045,
-0.674345850944519,
-0.38545459508895874,
-0.3543957471847534,
0.1898908019065857,
0.49249714612960815,
-0.6634680032730103,
0.6125404834747314,
-0.5555007457733154,
-0.2146604210138321,
0.01463967002928257,
0.7060567140579224,
-0.318337082862854,
0.30436402559280396,
0.7274312376976013,
0.9022750854492188,
0.7549537420272827,
-0.08646882325410843,
1.0793784856796265,
-0.8207288384437561,
0.606482207775116,
0.3990110754966736,
0.09304606914520264,
0.08230791985988617,
0.1531224548816681,
-0.54496830701828,
0.38468730449676514,
0.6725125908851624,
-0.2116418033838272,
0.4823780655860901,
0.5836368203163147,
-0.5553154945373535,
0.0372859463095665,
0.16510382294654846,
-0.4053054451942444,
0.20838406682014465,
0.15425609052181244,
-0.3361772894859314,
-0.2584366202354431,
0.05057935416698456,
-0.22716043889522552,
-0.2142234742641449,
-0.7112260460853577,
0.5293660759925842,
-0.1561519056558609,
-0.42003825306892395,
0.7946719527244568,
-0.2222341150045395,
0.8037499785423279,
-0.589196503162384,
0.2976859509944916,
-0.20268940925598145,
-0.02597721666097641,
-0.022949520498514175,
-0.18592700362205505,
0.23305222392082214,
-0.08976510912179947,
0.026668606325984,
-0.08782020211219788,
0.6440497040748596,
-0.46076685190200806,
-0.4522775411605835,
0.1851251870393753,
0.4130595028400421,
-0.2089761197566986,
0.04707813262939453,
-0.9668964147567749,
-0.4843352138996124,
-0.11623316258192062,
-0.29077836871147156,
0.18143485486507416,
-0.15690912306308746,
0.27685806155204773,
0.8090886473655701,
0.694948136806488,
0.029985198751091957,
0.15149261057376862,
0.23703305423259735,
0.6810736060142517,
-0.5393956899642944,
-0.48908326029777527,
-0.7454857230186462,
0.10014888644218445,
-0.11220932006835938,
-0.45823609828948975,
0.35478800535202026,
0.5851801037788391,
0.9330413341522217,
-0.030975250527262688,
0.8131341934204102,
-0.054098255932331085,
0.4867626428604126,
-0.623724102973938,
0.6833892464637756,
-0.6992620229721069,
-0.26957446336746216,
-0.04926074296236038,
-1.1004736423492432,
-0.4171951413154602,
0.756263017654419,
-0.25283655524253845,
0.5643429160118103,
0.8811429142951965,
0.448822945356369,
-0.004752791952341795,
-0.1570768505334854,
0.024628233164548874,
-0.48512566089630127,
0.2375713437795639,
0.4745514988899231,
0.5915602445602417,
-0.04836840182542801,
0.39619192481040955,
-0.4589424431324005,
-0.2482188642024994,
-0.0710059255361557,
-1.062401533126831,
-0.6252521872520447,
-0.3359132409095764,
-0.6209874749183655,
-0.1494077742099762,
0.3975667953491211,
0.8059828877449036,
0.6748992204666138,
-0.8947098851203918,
0.04432554543018341,
-0.6956800222396851,
-0.49499088525772095,
-0.3378199338912964,
-0.16157843172550201,
0.40720945596694946,
-0.9528273940086365,
-1.0247488021850586,
0.67420893907547,
0.29791581630706787,
0.3086243271827698,
-0.2122257798910141,
-0.1514318585395813,
0.1423911452293396,
-0.21562179923057556,
0.06265319138765335,
0.6935478448867798,
-0.2768409550189972,
-0.20227393507957458,
-0.3148723244667053,
0.08310143649578094,
0.2832276225090027,
1.0204697847366333,
-0.818884551525116,
0.5310956239700317,
0.5295204520225525,
1.0442564487457275,
0.5786246657371521,
0.4269753694534302,
0.6547980904579163,
-0.5674464106559753,
0.07383829355239868,
0.4303337335586548,
0.37707680463790894,
0.210576593875885,
-0.25528210401535034,
0.8155003190040588,
0.751763105392456,
-0.7230719923973083,
-0.46644681692123413,
0.17312629520893097,
-0.6218833327293396,
0.2141173630952835,
0.9245980978012085,
-0.021321889013051987,
-0.17981573939323425,
0.0316307507455349,
0.08564769476652145,
0.25538042187690735,
-0.3388426601886749,
0.7569913864135742,
0.20260873436927795,
-0.20979999005794525,
-0.045553240925073624,
-0.6411511301994324,
1.1869598627090454,
0.5131232738494873,
-0.6869174242019653,
-0.11650228500366211,
0.3479163944721222,
0.07933720201253891,
0.0864393338561058,
0.432901531457901,
0.14970502257347107,
0.24011991918087006,
-0.1131935641169548,
0.3365344703197479,
-0.19689811766147614,
-0.537052571773529,
-0.7330871820449829,
-0.073348768055439,
-0.3250909447669983,
-0.610899031162262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02751v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02751v1 | Emotion and Intent Joint Understanding in Multimodal Conversation: A Benchmarking Dataset | 2024-07-03T01:56:00 | 2024-07-03T01:56:00 | Rui Liu, Haolin Zuo, Zheng Lian, Xiaofen Xing, Björn W. Schuller, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Emotion and Intent Joint Understanding in Multimodal Conversation (MC-EIU)
aims to decode the semantic information manifested in a multimodal
conversational history, while inferring the emotions and intents simultaneously
for the current utterance. MC-EIU is enabling technology for many
human-computer interfaces. However, there is a lack of available datasets in
terms of annotation, modality, language diversity, and accessibility. In this
work, we propose an MC-EIU dataset, which features 7 emotion categories, 9
intent categories, 3 modalities, i.e., textual, acoustic, and visual content,
and two languages, i.e., English and Mandarin. Furthermore, it is completely
open-source for free access. To our knowledge, MC-EIU is the first
comprehensive and rich emotion and intent joint understanding dataset for
multimodal conversation. Together with the release of the dataset, we also
develop an Emotion and Intent Interaction (EI$^2$) network as a reference
system by modeling the deep correlation between emotion and intent in the
multimodal conversation. With comparative experiments and ablation studies, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed EI$^2$ method on the MC-EIU
dataset. The dataset and codes will be made available at:
https://github.com/MC-EIU/MC-EIU. | [
-0.5023275017738342,
-0.6427567601203918,
0.6318387985229492,
0.22831130027770996,
-0.23867088556289673,
-0.2859624922275543,
-0.2949153780937195,
-0.4253217875957489,
0.49677643179893494,
0.2714560627937317,
-0.6341513395309448,
-0.45185548067092896,
-0.4188852608203888,
-0.07753680646419525,
0.2585155665874481,
0.6838927865028381,
-0.20248974859714508,
0.10932464897632599,
-0.3115117847919464,
-0.7204790115356445,
-0.3248511552810669,
-0.3813110589981079,
-0.45434099435806274,
-0.11676523089408875,
0.7935535907745361,
0.8594842553138733,
0.24841223657131195,
0.1230940967798233,
0.5461500883102417,
0.2523593306541443,
0.2746243178844452,
0.19926781952381134,
-0.6965262293815613,
0.053480006754398346,
0.18296095728874207,
-0.1952982097864151,
-0.5623115301132202,
0.024749470874667168,
0.3828452229499817,
0.2651319205760956,
-0.12965449690818787,
0.06673961877822876,
-0.4029192328453064,
0.6330878138542175,
-0.9651107788085938,
0.3390621840953827,
-0.36303651332855225,
0.016084885224699974,
-0.056045182049274445,
-0.23648476600646973,
-0.5716292858123779,
-0.07873840630054474,
0.05395055562257767,
-0.427061527967453,
-0.36218664050102234,
0.149400994181633,
0.5204970836639404,
0.07230930775403976,
-0.9416006803512573,
-0.29293251037597656,
-0.5360278487205505,
0.6706840991973877,
-0.3206333816051483,
0.6811191439628601,
0.2643824517726898,
0.32286474108695984,
0.11926359683275223,
-0.47571226954460144,
-0.7607586979866028,
-0.058757830411195755,
-0.038046568632125854,
0.4538497030735016,
-0.1919724941253662,
0.30941078066825867,
0.2522207200527191,
0.26500749588012695,
-0.6950038075447083,
-0.13595889508724213,
-0.0900748074054718,
0.006705250591039658,
0.5876171588897705,
0.22960501909255981,
0.39439329504966736,
-0.07736565917730331,
-0.46874481439590454,
-0.40386900305747986,
-0.2560194432735443,
0.0974574163556099,
0.32040271162986755,
-0.0490509532392025,
-0.36709970235824585,
0.710555374622345,
-0.4038335680961609,
0.26367002725601196,
-0.3102911412715912,
-0.1622753143310547,
0.5365458726882935,
-0.41919854283332825,
-0.2998904585838318,
0.11202718317508698,
0.9779049754142761,
0.7767523527145386,
0.1485714465379715,
0.03948577120900154,
0.29371780157089233,
0.2310677319765091,
0.12543226778507233,
-0.7736850380897522,
-0.014119594357907772,
0.47769302129745483,
-0.4747355580329895,
0.04732738062739372,
0.017923418432474136,
-0.8534167408943176,
-0.19511663913726807,
-0.2950313687324524,
0.21439799666404724,
-0.323493629693985,
-0.5826826691627502,
-0.10966335237026215,
-0.07740919291973114,
0.021016255021095276,
0.22147472202777863,
-0.7664380073547363,
0.13470400869846344,
0.5306729674339294,
0.5573990941047668,
0.013623280450701714,
-0.32216691970825195,
-0.2133951485157013,
0.16890917718410492,
0.01947847008705139,
0.4915345013141632,
-0.750511109828949,
-0.2939116358757019,
-0.07690653949975967,
0.03556988015770912,
-0.2717224657535553,
-0.08890340477228165,
0.8838354349136353,
-0.12923645973205566,
0.040584009140729904,
-0.07049312442541122,
-0.2267034500837326,
-0.5823665261268616,
0.582465410232544,
-0.7947292923927307,
0.6873631477355957,
-0.2843836843967438,
-0.5366034507751465,
0.12836356461048126,
-0.9381103515625,
-0.27663251757621765,
-0.33769670128822327,
-0.20988880097866058,
-0.3724639117717743,
0.3029775023460388,
0.12643541395664215,
0.42480581998825073,
-0.1954517364501953,
0.28776875138282776,
-0.615850031375885,
-0.042752668261528015,
0.3668713867664337,
-0.5316333770751953,
0.32258841395378113,
0.3501869738101959,
-0.3158724308013916,
0.07374370843172073,
-0.8917033076286316,
-0.05972636118531227,
-0.06618920713663101,
-0.031382493674755096,
-0.3238077163696289,
-0.13783124089241028,
0.08824773877859116,
0.474591463804245,
-0.0036800396628677845,
-0.7557080388069153,
-0.04486366733908653,
0.27879399061203003,
0.07081562280654907,
0.4958023726940155,
-0.14586886763572693,
0.2855379581451416,
0.056809645146131516,
0.2601734399795532,
0.6998363137245178,
0.3231397271156311,
-0.39550167322158813,
-0.48095595836639404,
-0.6749882698059082,
-0.15647216141223907,
-0.21249622106552124,
0.38275617361068726,
-0.8102230429649353,
-0.17198830842971802,
-0.42523035407066345,
-0.31061220169067383,
-0.6517019271850586,
-0.2210026979446411,
0.6148446202278137,
0.3757355809211731,
0.24359077215194702,
-0.3823215365409851,
-0.39443162083625793,
-0.9345611333847046,
-0.08740531653165817,
-0.3202129304409027,
0.2613280415534973,
1.1418547630310059,
0.08184191584587097,
-0.3675934970378876,
0.5979925990104675,
-0.2418842613697052,
-0.05311741679906845,
-0.030968861654400826,
0.7136515974998474,
-0.14763282239437103,
0.37844565510749817,
0.4333365857601166,
-1.1140352487564087,
-0.3397430181503296,
0.08705180883407593,
-0.799627423286438,
0.12176202237606049,
-0.1732306033372879,
-0.5116172432899475,
0.1703789234161377,
0.1394171416759491,
-0.4506423771381378,
0.37031489610671997,
0.7953140139579773,
-0.29970693588256836,
0.11856205016374588,
0.0782056599855423,
0.8957518339157104,
-1.1054543256759644,
0.11725709587335587,
0.2095729559659958,
0.1287911981344223,
-0.9320396184921265,
-0.34374067187309265,
0.30940863490104675,
-0.09141664206981659,
-0.8540141582489014,
0.29281049966812134,
-0.44116735458374023,
-0.05563754960894585,
0.1658668965101242,
0.23992076516151428,
0.0791424959897995,
0.8588199019432068,
0.19504764676094055,
0.37465155124664307,
0.22226986289024353,
-0.4691721498966217,
0.2616859972476959,
0.35892629623413086,
-0.037806250154972076,
0.7881771922111511,
-0.19632656872272491,
0.3904366195201874,
-0.23789967596530914,
0.27637341618537903,
-1.0608203411102295,
-0.3329743444919586,
0.39563509821891785,
-0.4732207655906677,
0.16558216512203217,
-0.1801193654537201,
-0.13279995322227478,
-0.0063871219754219055,
-0.26476749777793884,
0.7349328398704529,
0.10745476186275482,
-0.47951605916023254,
0.9245872497558594,
0.3715614378452301,
-0.11746291816234589,
-0.7248517274856567,
-0.6341679096221924,
0.1658019870519638,
-0.0531005784869194,
-0.7882188558578491,
0.1514379233121872,
-0.3216659724712372,
-0.17220428586006165,
-0.2779902219772339,
0.29854854941368103,
-0.29990270733833313,
-0.06833694130182266,
0.5139368176460266,
0.19995422661304474,
-0.19941329956054688,
0.26075196266174316,
0.20417724549770355,
-0.02441304177045822,
0.10223356634378433,
0.3595280349254608,
0.38705742359161377,
-0.10669256001710892,
-0.49101027846336365,
-0.5754414200782776,
0.45945173501968384,
0.9819324016571045,
-0.12745235860347748,
0.6864122152328491,
1.029584288597107,
-0.26637938618659973,
0.4883289933204651,
-0.699784517288208,
0.09055037796497345,
-0.33460474014282227,
0.3879034221172333,
-0.7062649726867676,
-0.7934285402297974,
0.38816648721694946,
-0.31999850273132324,
0.13677920401096344,
0.2558792233467102,
0.5908088088035583,
0.10003197193145752,
1.2221190929412842,
0.398501992225647,
0.028156574815511703,
0.578621506690979,
-0.06676995754241943,
0.11332695186138153,
-1.1075185537338257,
-0.46843475103378296,
-0.32860514521598816,
-0.642097532749176,
-0.47011953592300415,
-0.17270690202713013,
0.20154441893100739,
-0.16810324788093567,
0.15437108278274536,
0.03154762461781502,
0.03665391728281975,
0.2523236870765686,
0.2965993881225586,
0.32696181535720825,
0.11540376394987106,
-0.14287661015987396,
-0.022098107263445854,
0.03707462549209595,
-0.3230583369731903,
-0.3103805184364319,
1.0193053483963013,
0.3992765247821808,
0.5858790278434753,
0.4829622805118561,
0.5379149317741394,
-0.1533968150615692,
0.361399382352829,
-0.7950477600097656,
0.3927920162677765,
0.10758810490369797,
-0.48945173621177673,
-0.14660532772541046,
-0.694043755531311,
-0.718083381652832,
0.29596033692359924,
-0.20517493784427643,
-0.9614993333816528,
0.4335517883300781,
-0.003542055608704686,
0.0036110938526690006,
0.17896632850170135,
-1.0852947235107422,
1.06796395778656,
-0.2966260313987732,
-0.3976077437400818,
-0.33819887042045593,
-0.7738422751426697,
0.5284013748168945,
0.31783363223075867,
0.2998655140399933,
-0.5423122048377991,
0.14995074272155762,
0.6683446168899536,
-0.015411682426929474,
0.5535864233970642,
-0.21522864699363708,
0.13081520795822144,
0.2182365506887436,
-0.11802228540182114,
0.36644867062568665,
0.19370029866695404,
-0.1650857925415039,
0.23335808515548706,
-0.20222648978233337,
-0.11971186101436615,
-0.6034236550331116,
0.6842546463012695,
-0.6725845336914062,
0.06942329555749893,
-0.12942658364772797,
-0.6040194034576416,
-0.18327347934246063,
-0.08446177840232849,
-0.07688648998737335,
0.6864201426506042,
-0.527732253074646,
0.35817357897758484,
0.6044704914093018,
-0.12477375566959381,
0.4964125156402588,
0.4659031629562378,
0.06046539545059204,
-0.44848647713661194,
1.0460543632507324,
-0.284105509519577,
0.2144649773836136,
0.45124879479408264,
0.057328443974256516,
-0.32996290922164917,
-0.05170990899205208,
-0.5090737342834473,
0.08422359079122543,
-0.6883453130722046,
-0.01683872938156128,
-1.0511763095855713,
0.48798078298568726,
-0.523562490940094,
0.16629807651042938,
-0.25685641169548035,
-0.20566502213478088,
-0.276923805475235,
-0.03138861432671547,
0.3505253493785858,
0.5776161551475525,
0.03751125559210777,
0.07461899518966675,
-0.8641977310180664,
0.4221813380718231,
0.2439303994178772,
0.5804651975631714,
-0.06358469277620316,
0.13322393596172333,
-0.11170267313718796,
0.3353635370731354,
-0.2567480802536011,
-0.8158469796180725,
0.29543840885162354,
0.41181856393814087,
0.421505868434906,
0.679074227809906,
0.2686215937137604,
0.6541764736175537,
-0.27975934743881226,
0.7012977600097656,
0.4586648643016815,
-0.8139352202415466,
0.4558345675468445,
-0.10888534784317017,
0.23779986798763275,
0.7920417785644531,
0.5697843432426453,
-0.8575331568717957,
-0.05711977928876877,
-0.4941084086894989,
-0.7269294261932373,
1.0084314346313477,
0.25659623742103577,
-0.09970642626285553,
-0.21463091671466827,
0.02690516971051693,
0.020334213972091675,
0.14210493862628937,
-0.5656941533088684,
-0.4533815085887909,
-0.13365551829338074,
-0.706127941608429,
-0.2572309672832489,
-0.5189345479011536,
-0.24524837732315063,
0.06093750149011612,
0.49118879437446594,
-0.22501444816589355,
0.6162922978401184,
0.16015996038913727,
-0.46000373363494873,
-0.16124773025512695,
0.47973325848579407,
0.8565716743469238,
0.33507040143013,
-0.3320606052875519,
0.2103520929813385,
0.09144028276205063,
-0.6972494125366211,
0.08365720510482788,
-0.16155023872852325,
0.6091600656509399,
0.01526936236768961,
-0.1769372671842575,
1.1656920909881592,
0.3597396910190582,
-0.680610179901123,
0.5167689323425293,
-0.7011967897415161,
-0.16031034290790558,
-0.058228399604558945,
-0.31970006227493286,
-0.03823795169591904,
0.3485625684261322,
-0.01396059338003397,
-0.0899231880903244,
0.5734103322029114,
-0.7985945343971252,
0.05237811803817749,
0.041792552918195724,
-0.6559787392616272,
-0.29575231671333313,
0.26085489988327026,
0.48404961824417114,
-0.07632733136415482,
0.6479141116142273,
-0.11047998815774918,
-0.4339255392551422,
0.5473909378051758,
0.31392034888267517,
0.9071722030639648,
-0.003937569912523031,
0.21836310625076294,
0.323473185300827,
-0.013088691048324108,
0.21777412295341492,
0.5758213996887207,
-0.25047567486763,
-0.634579598903656,
-0.13591837882995605,
-0.22663943469524384,
-0.7764003276824951,
-0.24238064885139465,
-0.7794908285140991,
0.054196797311306,
-0.06428583711385727,
-0.10839464515447617,
-0.1250866800546646,
-0.2557777464389801,
-0.7936579585075378,
0.27298372983932495,
0.37658005952835083,
0.4349035620689392,
-0.8075234889984131,
0.61213618516922,
0.762339174747467,
-0.23114153742790222,
-0.6482071876525879,
-0.3271481692790985,
0.29221782088279724,
-0.4662622809410095,
0.4472061097621918,
0.4867134988307953,
-0.21720139682292938,
-0.1305357664823532,
-0.23194076120853424,
-0.5638440251350403,
1.2552862167358398,
0.19421504437923431,
-0.5299854874610901,
0.5452373027801514,
0.1384679228067398,
0.2691034972667694,
-0.6223686337471008,
0.9870457649230957,
0.46480461955070496,
0.537253201007843,
0.27840903401374817,
-0.763168454170227,
-0.15644943714141846,
-0.6460343599319458,
-0.3119848370552063,
0.41399863362312317,
-0.8442010879516602,
0.5827383399009705,
-0.02823871187865734,
-0.3265302777290344,
-0.283883273601532,
0.5726739764213562,
0.07514480501413345,
0.8859243988990784,
0.49342697858810425,
0.8155908584594727,
0.5479928851127625,
-0.40201860666275024,
0.8487223386764526,
-0.38207459449768066,
0.2819802165031433,
0.8437955975532532,
-0.3271962106227875,
1.0299201011657715,
0.4808541238307953,
0.13111691176891327,
0.4067574143409729,
0.524157702922821,
0.49459487199783325,
0.18186195194721222,
-0.26217734813690186,
-0.49439454078674316,
-0.03715134039521217,
-0.43231847882270813,
-0.22097007930278778,
0.5688380002975464,
0.48991408944129944,
-0.2798556983470917,
0.2228400856256485,
0.250397264957428,
0.0031062632333487272,
-0.6136166453361511,
-0.21274645626544952,
1.1986701488494873,
-0.16509011387825012,
-0.5435187816619873,
0.12408645451068878,
-0.29219165444374084,
0.6167335510253906,
-0.4092772603034973,
-0.08413276821374893,
-0.1852666437625885,
0.009616518393158913,
-0.24612240493297577,
-0.6751939654350281,
0.04802609607577324,
-0.05527837574481964,
0.022687364369630814,
0.008902185596525669,
0.5550107955932617,
-0.7653658390045166,
-0.1990976631641388,
0.3229180574417114,
0.2293616384267807,
0.43663719296455383,
-0.03937910869717598,
-0.5451500415802002,
0.46966737508773804,
-0.17634734511375427,
-0.36780253052711487,
0.19479863345623016,
0.6311156153678894,
0.27789491415023804,
0.38072389364242554,
0.44741255044937134,
-0.6274110078811646,
-0.0686299279332161,
0.5265812873840332,
0.6594782471656799,
-0.48061293363571167,
-0.3855903744697571,
-0.6955952644348145,
0.7783501744270325,
-0.0917801633477211,
-0.4918653070926666,
0.3185186982154846,
0.40884432196617126,
0.7216946482658386,
0.13243308663368225,
0.5415346026420593,
-0.21010638773441315,
-0.008829114958643913,
-0.47531476616859436,
0.5160492658615112,
-0.7121174931526184,
-0.3798676133155823,
-0.5537418127059937,
-0.7759533524513245,
-0.1144496500492096,
0.24154114723205566,
-0.05008940026164055,
0.09791052341461182,
0.7576146125793457,
0.627450704574585,
-0.16358105838298798,
0.36164024472236633,
0.6149757504463196,
0.041098833084106445,
0.19566099345684052,
0.9089626669883728,
0.6298934817314148,
-0.5202450156211853,
0.6541883945465088,
-0.4144616723060608,
-0.3901843726634979,
-0.492288202047348,
-0.8747221827507019,
-0.6064090132713318,
-0.6805813312530518,
-0.3514840006828308,
-0.09810100495815277,
-0.024905577301979065,
0.92926025390625,
0.6307843923568726,
-0.6225880980491638,
-0.188041090965271,
0.17927759885787964,
0.057881440967321396,
-0.014546073041856289,
-0.16476008296012878,
-0.039410676807165146,
-0.006673566997051239,
-0.8598517179489136,
0.29832151532173157,
0.5301339626312256,
0.09959546476602554,
-0.005322516430169344,
-0.5187623500823975,
-0.5048453211784363,
0.03760844096541405,
0.707779586315155,
0.17189250886440277,
-0.580810546875,
-0.342447429895401,
-0.01316988468170166,
-0.058053579181432724,
0.2820110023021698,
0.9213855266571045,
-0.24817325174808502,
0.9043043851852417,
0.48141729831695557,
0.559806227684021,
0.5203088521957397,
-0.16751734912395477,
0.49320611357688904,
-0.7805896997451782,
0.12059538066387177,
-0.03711233660578728,
0.612694501876831,
0.12137778848409653,
-0.4538671672344208,
0.5280261039733887,
0.00934863556176424,
-0.5369381308555603,
-0.5234983563423157,
0.31393447518348694,
-1.4310967922210693,
0.13078507781028748,
1.000791072845459,
-0.3547457158565521,
-0.2680056393146515,
-0.02067483589053154,
-0.45874395966529846,
0.5273297429084778,
-0.7024023532867432,
0.4678032696247101,
0.660019040107727,
-0.3688541054725647,
-0.7225548624992371,
-0.23318518698215485,
0.06737091392278671,
0.4470662474632263,
-1.0554802417755127,
0.08145294338464737,
0.588426411151886,
-0.4025454819202423,
0.22806784510612488,
0.5388534665107727,
0.013009948655962944,
0.4133371114730835,
0.15676862001419067,
0.40576085448265076,
-0.11486831307411194,
-0.6329662799835205,
-0.3637367784976959,
0.11568734794855118,
-0.33926185965538025,
-0.3587636351585388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02750v1 | Learning to Reduce: Towards Improving Performance of Large Language Models on Structured Data | 2024-07-03T01:51:50 | 2024-07-03T01:51:50 | Younghun Lee, Sungchul Kim, Ryan A. Rossi, Tong Yu, Xiang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been achieving competent performance on a
wide range of downstream tasks, yet existing work shows that inference on
structured data is challenging for LLMs. This is because LLMs need to either
understand long structured data or select the most relevant evidence before
inference, and both approaches are not trivial. This paper proposes a
framework, Learning to Reduce, that fine-tunes a language model with On-Policy
Learning to generate a reduced version of an input structured data. When
compared to state-of-the-art LLMs like GPT-4, Learning to Reduce not only
achieves outstanding performance in reducing the input, but shows
generalizability on different datasets. We further show that the model
fine-tuned with our framework helps LLMs better perform on table QA tasks
especially when the context is longer. | [
-0.1906985491514206,
-0.5439658761024475,
0.6893625259399414,
-0.14287173748016357,
-0.025540003553032875,
-0.2005028873682022,
-0.42005375027656555,
-0.23943699896335602,
-0.22714266180992126,
0.6210870146751404,
-0.6923600435256958,
-0.659843385219574,
-0.34438279271125793,
0.11504019796848297,
-0.4057573080062866,
1.063041090965271,
0.020305410027503967,
-0.04631039500236511,
-0.12297169119119644,
0.013754133135080338,
-0.30668821930885315,
-0.3512914180755615,
-0.879114031791687,
-0.44322332739830017,
0.515407383441925,
0.4050464928150177,
0.43123185634613037,
0.7714158296585083,
0.4416627287864685,
0.2767651677131653,
-0.33703625202178955,
0.18059629201889038,
-1.0067980289459229,
0.050494350492954254,
-0.37990808486938477,
-0.7409145832061768,
-0.21210405230522156,
-0.18885453045368195,
0.7914667129516602,
0.9609680771827698,
-0.274921178817749,
0.15147779881954193,
0.09194520115852356,
0.6279395818710327,
-0.6096378564834595,
0.7532988786697388,
-0.6529965996742249,
0.12675981223583221,
0.057434484362602234,
0.05287080630660057,
-0.5875250101089478,
-0.2563507854938507,
-0.20354966819286346,
-0.6530718803405762,
0.28187504410743713,
-0.2401942014694214,
0.8183542490005493,
0.3833753764629364,
-0.550771176815033,
0.008684138767421246,
-0.8767322301864624,
0.738854706287384,
-0.6551268696784973,
0.5451903939247131,
0.5186632871627808,
0.06531805545091629,
-0.15841077268123627,
-0.7513021230697632,
-0.48271632194519043,
-0.10989011824131012,
-0.09991678595542908,
-0.16025826334953308,
0.04560022056102753,
0.27370038628578186,
0.3512880206108093,
0.2915627062320709,
-0.3236173689365387,
0.21848265826702118,
-0.588407576084137,
-0.09387645125389099,
0.6250977516174316,
0.18461112678050995,
-0.15868806838989258,
0.0820702537894249,
0.049568191170692444,
-0.09489631652832031,
-1.2197831869125366,
0.06631670147180557,
-0.09240128099918365,
0.40615928173065186,
0.031390972435474396,
0.3179745078086853,
-0.4191572368144989,
0.5130767226219177,
-0.08500509709119797,
-0.17108112573623657,
0.030858179554343224,
-0.17912812530994415,
-0.28196266293525696,
-0.2729226052761078,
0.31516674160957336,
0.35051393508911133,
0.21883898973464966,
-0.3020325303077698,
-0.577143132686615,
0.24903887510299683,
0.041481733322143555,
-1.081882119178772,
-0.4753675162792206,
-0.08949737250804901,
-0.35554495453834534,
-0.17990128695964813,
-0.331584095954895,
-0.21348737180233002,
-0.23712293803691864,
-0.4343912899494171,
0.11417149752378464,
-0.16243618726730347,
0.23206275701522827,
0.07205316424369812,
0.2542412579059601,
0.37337931990623474,
0.6681554317474365,
-0.7974196076393127,
0.5587298274040222,
0.8463087677955627,
0.7596210241317749,
-0.11247408390045166,
-0.034095633774995804,
-0.893220067024231,
0.5408443808555603,
-0.7507425546646118,
0.5707418322563171,
-0.5494772791862488,
-0.41336360573768616,
0.0409049317240715,
0.01818978600203991,
-0.015619972720742226,
-0.7855743169784546,
0.40186113119125366,
-0.45360174775123596,
0.23366431891918182,
-0.17333273589611053,
-0.6863366365432739,
-0.2754169702529907,
0.4181930422782898,
-0.8033746480941772,
0.8449813723564148,
0.44180887937545776,
-0.17618224024772644,
0.5998766422271729,
-0.718417763710022,
-0.6601442098617554,
-0.08550810068845749,
-0.07469133287668228,
-0.5986306667327881,
0.3595874607563019,
0.36919668316841125,
0.5231489539146423,
-0.36746203899383545,
0.2884172201156616,
-0.44668665528297424,
-0.28627726435661316,
-0.11960668116807938,
-0.06855458766222,
0.3757624924182892,
0.48329997062683105,
0.1155630573630333,
0.3230237066745758,
-0.9401193857192993,
-0.06537829339504242,
0.13186396658420563,
-0.8357812762260437,
-0.19175738096237183,
0.31114888191223145,
0.18674339354038239,
0.21483740210533142,
-0.18989317119121552,
-0.4641498923301697,
0.3441762626171112,
-0.7326304912567139,
0.863672137260437,
0.6121587157249451,
-0.08576714992523193,
0.5402982234954834,
-0.2885679602622986,
0.4177931845188141,
-0.20788121223449707,
0.2479940503835678,
0.3205157518386841,
-0.13014204800128937,
-0.8273184895515442,
-0.3495156764984131,
0.4242136776447296,
0.5451912879943848,
-0.8969599604606628,
0.11486712098121643,
-0.5214658379554749,
0.021177830174565315,
-0.3800193667411804,
0.3814901113510132,
0.5249882936477661,
0.36478960514068604,
0.4556525647640228,
-0.32194453477859497,
-0.3180452585220337,
-0.6883609890937805,
-0.06665126979351044,
-0.24582861363887787,
-0.49097228050231934,
0.03724055364727974,
0.3439734876155853,
-0.21379472315311432,
0.8224338889122009,
-0.5200432538986206,
-0.3658970296382904,
-0.4277435839176178,
-0.22958782315254211,
0.19738033413887024,
0.4692770838737488,
0.4209851920604706,
-0.6674720048904419,
-0.2742008864879608,
0.06831292062997818,
-0.4020855128765106,
-0.012781288474798203,
0.0005022358382120728,
0.3075595200061798,
0.27022498846054077,
0.7332550287246704,
-0.6063736081123352,
0.5199719667434692,
0.3963635563850403,
-0.22324278950691223,
0.15536080300807953,
-0.12779492139816284,
-0.013748247176408768,
-1.0691936016082764,
-0.17770078778266907,
-0.08105748891830444,
-0.5499204397201538,
-0.7793250679969788,
0.12104950845241547,
0.038979671895504,
-0.3528684377670288,
-0.5156323909759521,
0.46925991773605347,
-0.29425057768821716,
-0.11011720448732376,
0.014459129422903061,
-0.3319607079029083,
0.22928938269615173,
0.6070389747619629,
0.09900517016649246,
0.7467015385627747,
0.20060086250305176,
-0.8376761674880981,
0.02436402626335621,
0.6747019290924072,
-0.49706658720970154,
0.26319652795791626,
-0.5465310215950012,
-0.008631797507405281,
0.057122353464365005,
0.1294090747833252,
-0.8042939305305481,
-0.07822699844837189,
0.14243747293949127,
-0.05785375460982323,
0.5535410046577454,
-0.3038153052330017,
-0.42537638545036316,
-0.12299086898565292,
-0.23038993775844574,
0.17174650728702545,
0.4754081666469574,
-0.5962179899215698,
0.35999050736427307,
0.2482263147830963,
-0.2662447392940521,
-0.14326387643814087,
-0.940558910369873,
-0.012649539858102798,
-0.2118639498949051,
-0.40446925163269043,
0.8163244128227234,
0.10689396411180496,
-0.11514480412006378,
-0.09007752686738968,
-0.20765279233455658,
-0.2910168170928955,
0.30092334747314453,
-0.1166817769408226,
-0.10922322422266006,
-0.1386764496564865,
0.6731610298156738,
0.1288987696170807,
0.00007812526018824428,
0.2133140116930008,
0.10865678638219833,
0.3671102225780487,
0.027434932067990303,
-0.2064196616411209,
-0.6204549670219421,
0.2619923949241638,
0.3125540316104889,
-0.14882422983646393,
0.8916133642196655,
0.1827678233385086,
-0.2649144232273102,
-0.540722668170929,
-0.1664348989725113,
-0.40406399965286255,
-0.495586097240448,
0.5946558117866516,
-0.5657166838645935,
-1.0843043327331543,
0.559541642665863,
-0.35600605607032776,
0.067426398396492,
0.2874985635280609,
0.35651326179504395,
0.16646838188171387,
0.967735230922699,
0.7672280073165894,
-0.32169198989868164,
0.6083821654319763,
-0.3286057412624359,
0.4398648142814636,
-0.4399435520172119,
-0.12203571200370789,
-0.6368800401687622,
0.035435110330581665,
-0.7155417799949646,
-0.560219407081604,
0.15616707503795624,
0.09940217435359955,
-0.39299774169921875,
-0.17596624791622162,
-0.30134114623069763,
0.517127275466919,
0.08281408995389938,
0.41120457649230957,
0.37373632192611694,
-0.08550713956356049,
0.32657086849212646,
0.35145750641822815,
-0.8731989860534668,
-0.2844093143939972,
1.118788480758667,
0.40131184458732605,
0.7695585489273071,
0.2530517876148224,
0.6165967583656311,
0.40976759791374207,
0.36174502968788147,
-0.7907471656799316,
0.4831452965736389,
-0.1803664118051529,
-0.14051824808120728,
-0.5266397595405579,
-0.8347771167755127,
-0.9859638810157776,
0.013645719736814499,
-0.25137585401535034,
-0.1944282501935959,
-0.026291223242878914,
0.31193771958351135,
-0.18086425960063934,
0.15196755528450012,
-0.5758308172225952,
0.6601278185844421,
0.08123475313186646,
-0.29616039991378784,
-0.47249335050582886,
-0.3053779602050781,
0.31565335392951965,
-0.071220263838768,
0.32610073685646057,
-0.11500374227762222,
-0.15854260325431824,
0.5917192697525024,
-0.8474787473678589,
0.904048502445221,
-0.21231068670749664,
-0.26697179675102234,
0.11416549980640411,
0.18184222280979156,
0.9112520813941956,
0.02141079306602478,
-0.07779664546251297,
-0.08021972328424454,
-0.024295365437865257,
-0.5415458679199219,
-0.6835127472877502,
0.5201093554496765,
-0.5436351895332336,
-0.4412998557090759,
0.16785602271556854,
-0.6683269143104553,
-0.39218857884407043,
-0.1326749175786972,
-0.08392981439828873,
0.4147404134273529,
-0.15565526485443115,
0.2598980963230133,
0.7406272292137146,
-0.21039249002933502,
0.21281029284000397,
0.3406791090965271,
-0.37183088064193726,
-0.17238575220108032,
0.7469733357429504,
0.32305118441581726,
0.2920444905757904,
0.5438112616539001,
0.2129848748445511,
-0.5944050550460815,
-1.118489146232605,
-0.013232309371232986,
0.16079303622245789,
-0.9133217334747314,
-0.19830858707427979,
-0.22004705667495728,
0.03279269486665726,
-0.6891705989837646,
-0.008850228041410446,
-0.2015926092863083,
-0.5235926508903503,
-0.31578585505485535,
-0.3198346197605133,
0.5756723880767822,
0.7516991496086121,
0.12861110270023346,
0.6020734906196594,
-0.7338342070579529,
0.3055267035961151,
0.4321446120738983,
0.5294762849807739,
-0.40127888321876526,
-0.6948480010032654,
-0.23555196821689606,
-0.27282315492630005,
-0.0469915047287941,
-0.5721724033355713,
0.6827905774116516,
0.7415608763694763,
0.4865224063396454,
0.2797408699989319,
0.17344756424427032,
0.6128144264221191,
-0.48155343532562256,
0.39152204990386963,
0.06005638837814331,
-1.170672059059143,
0.5311614274978638,
-0.5078865885734558,
0.30255627632141113,
0.5211702585220337,
0.31978368759155273,
-0.31968629360198975,
-0.11194422841072083,
-0.37167468667030334,
-0.8688055276870728,
0.4840186536312103,
0.07839831709861755,
-0.03884678706526756,
0.07732377201318741,
0.6283560991287231,
0.035845156759023666,
0.4002676010131836,
-0.8313024640083313,
0.11072515696287155,
0.2901607155799866,
-0.25428083539009094,
-0.2694956660270691,
-0.2186744511127472,
0.04397878050804138,
-0.5377208590507507,
0.7451483011245728,
-0.40223363041877747,
0.08041538298130035,
-0.1597033590078354,
-0.43594229221343994,
0.11155757308006287,
0.453349769115448,
0.5004165768623352,
0.8788084387779236,
0.03500829264521599,
-0.05139097943902016,
0.46173521876335144,
-0.0849083885550499,
-0.04193496331572533,
-0.2666880190372467,
-0.4504631757736206,
-0.28057748079299927,
0.3158760368824005,
0.8621065020561218,
0.22733232378959656,
-0.6162673830986023,
0.2562442123889923,
0.011261560022830963,
-0.40442273020744324,
-0.08147960156202316,
0.09628701955080032,
-0.021161390468478203,
0.2244059443473816,
-0.04985711723566055,
-0.2658948302268982,
0.35754090547561646,
-0.5768563151359558,
0.2952491343021393,
0.17626996338367462,
-0.35762521624565125,
-0.19944173097610474,
0.3712296485900879,
0.3532046377658844,
-0.18300580978393555,
0.8079460263252258,
-0.23687942326068878,
-0.4948774576187134,
0.470315545797348,
0.45268628001213074,
0.3632557690143585,
-0.36328041553497314,
0.20704402029514313,
0.18463930487632751,
0.3579345643520355,
-0.1602458357810974,
0.2586708068847656,
-0.13797065615653992,
-0.5679076910018921,
-0.968987226486206,
-0.5332446694374084,
-0.5194764137268066,
0.47006577253341675,
-0.8209087252616882,
0.0464928075671196,
-0.7463757395744324,
-0.020829226821660995,
-0.26377424597740173,
0.06329043954610825,
-0.8164629340171814,
0.11792005598545074,
-0.056659191846847534,
0.532132625579834,
-1.0520579814910889,
0.9920355081558228,
0.3469274938106537,
-0.3018329441547394,
-1.0465099811553955,
-0.2941271662712097,
-0.10812729597091675,
-0.5563281178474426,
0.6480329632759094,
0.25295186042785645,
0.1606641560792923,
0.07467544823884964,
-0.6747932434082031,
-0.8022052645683289,
0.5957404375076294,
0.778897762298584,
-0.7439525127410889,
0.05166098102927208,
0.21696417033672333,
0.4957933723926544,
-0.19902382791042328,
-0.11860581487417221,
0.8964719772338867,
0.4601733088493347,
-0.0385788232088089,
-1.0779443979263306,
0.03292861953377724,
-0.06353526562452316,
0.20729351043701172,
0.5505028367042542,
-0.3738138973712921,
1.0231610536575317,
-0.17760565876960754,
-0.3011397123336792,
-0.17167039215564728,
0.6202532649040222,
-0.08675452321767807,
0.32540106773376465,
0.3038191795349121,
0.672921895980835,
0.8382869958877563,
-0.19812773168087006,
1.0864957571029663,
0.08389732986688614,
0.5801445245742798,
1.2065248489379883,
-0.6963106989860535,
0.95307856798172,
0.4483911991119385,
-0.4299844205379486,
0.35840803384780884,
0.7113578915596008,
0.09119735658168793,
0.6702799201011658,
0.41405344009399414,
-0.16073542833328247,
-0.512112557888031,
-0.08553999662399292,
0.016869323328137398,
0.5294323563575745,
0.5467236042022705,
-0.2608122229576111,
-0.3938611149787903,
0.14544305205345154,
0.08735331892967224,
0.38397809863090515,
-0.8094179034233093,
1.0441336631774902,
-0.10917194187641144,
-0.4915620684623718,
0.8425207138061523,
0.04413112252950668,
0.31582358479499817,
-0.40547698736190796,
-0.3405762016773224,
-0.2641844153404236,
0.36567848920822144,
-0.19328835606575012,
-0.5708072781562805,
0.5724343061447144,
-0.23355069756507874,
-0.467928946018219,
-0.3607330322265625,
0.5760268568992615,
-0.5669533610343933,
-0.3785858154296875,
0.37125492095947266,
0.3990262448787689,
0.26410943269729614,
-0.18608355522155762,
-0.7373218536376953,
-0.1025877371430397,
0.05135393515229225,
-0.39589378237724304,
0.5431357026100159,
0.4726545512676239,
-0.31880053877830505,
0.9081162810325623,
0.7498040199279785,
0.25367993116378784,
-0.12813135981559753,
0.18677669763565063,
1.0431462526321411,
-0.5939065217971802,
-0.6665347814559937,
-0.4780413508415222,
0.06620331108570099,
-0.025697387754917145,
-0.04500424116849899,
0.22588391602039337,
0.5898252129554749,
1.2042498588562012,
-0.17693206667900085,
0.7702561020851135,
0.20809635519981384,
0.7914571166038513,
-1.0270330905914307,
0.7303043007850647,
-0.5157200694084167,
0.4318593740463257,
0.2895023226737976,
-0.8514533638954163,
-0.46619006991386414,
0.8602503538131714,
-0.39246389269828796,
0.02884095162153244,
0.5922042727470398,
1.0113164186477661,
0.16441665589809418,
-0.4104156196117401,
0.6613188982009888,
0.14311276376247406,
0.5013155937194824,
0.692905068397522,
0.6181980967521667,
-0.3094286620616913,
0.5387902855873108,
-0.18664148449897766,
0.1985648274421692,
-0.1371532678604126,
-0.7438700199127197,
-0.9721892476081848,
-0.498158723115921,
-0.25468721985816956,
-0.19525012373924255,
0.3066113293170929,
0.877332866191864,
0.6555773615837097,
-1.0233436822891235,
-0.17919152975082397,
-0.19681544601917267,
0.2091480791568756,
-0.1971195489168167,
-0.15151922404766083,
0.4116284251213074,
-0.40486323833465576,
-0.5663875341415405,
0.6729589700698853,
0.060543544590473175,
-0.23358741402626038,
0.036033354699611664,
-0.24700480699539185,
-0.14555014669895172,
0.0978439524769783,
0.8702059388160706,
0.38417235016822815,
-0.4775170683860779,
-0.6004231572151184,
-0.3987621068954468,
0.07271439582109451,
0.19250710308551788,
0.8624287247657776,
-0.9734841585159302,
-0.019051382318139076,
0.6024293899536133,
0.7461133003234863,
0.7621797919273376,
-0.09975171834230423,
0.5817238688468933,
-0.8455146551132202,
0.11023356765508652,
0.4206031560897827,
0.3745572865009308,
0.17361970245838165,
-0.3218572735786438,
0.803093671798706,
0.14409083127975464,
-0.4963904023170471,
-0.8521673083305359,
0.3719943165779114,
-0.8217702507972717,
-0.3649996519088745,
1.2736445665359497,
-0.27043312788009644,
-0.48647627234458923,
-0.45957666635513306,
0.08217816054821014,
0.26054897904396057,
-0.36539149284362793,
0.6856047511100769,
0.271174818277359,
-0.052258823066949844,
-0.38646021485328674,
-0.2958190441131592,
0.7853786945343018,
0.5199881792068481,
-1.2296017408370972,
0.3913634121417999,
0.8580390810966492,
0.47525259852409363,
-0.1744546890258789,
0.47103992104530334,
0.19008523225784302,
0.31967246532440186,
-0.28892213106155396,
0.2604117691516876,
-0.13897626101970673,
-0.5591384172439575,
-0.5953872799873352,
0.2927907109260559,
0.30762678384780884,
-0.01845797523856163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02742v1 | A Comparative Study of DSL Code Generation: Fine-Tuning vs. Optimized Retrieval Augmentation | 2024-07-03T01:28:51 | 2024-07-03T01:28:51 | Nastaran Bassamzadeh, Chhaya Methani | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.2; I.2.7 | Natural Language to Code Generation has made significant progress in recent
years with the advent of Large Language Models(LLMs). While generation for
general-purpose languages like C, C++, and Python has improved significantly,
LLMs struggle with custom function names in Domain Specific Languages or DSLs.
This leads to higher hallucination rates and syntax errors, specially for DSLs
having a high number of custom function names. Additionally, constant updates
to function names add to the challenge as LLMs need to stay up-to-date. In this
paper, we present optimizations for using Retrieval Augmented Generation (or
RAG) with LLMs for DSL generation along with an ablation study comparing these
strategies. We generated a train as well as test dataset with a DSL to
represent automation tasks across roughly 700 APIs in public domain. We used
the training dataset to fine-tune a Codex model for this DSL. Our results
showed that the fine-tuned model scored the best on code similarity metric.
With our RAG optimizations, we achieved parity for similarity metric. The
compilation rate, however, showed that both the models still got the syntax
wrong many times, with RAG-based method being 2 pts better. Conversely,
hallucination rate for RAG model lagged by 1 pt for API names and by 2 pts for
API parameter keys. We conclude that an optimized RAG model can match the
quality of fine-tuned models and offer advantages for new, unseen APIs. | [
-0.7505372762680054,
-0.6990718841552734,
0.4269968271255493,
-0.1531783491373062,
-0.24334236979484558,
0.06336695700883865,
-0.2631242871284485,
-0.6749879121780396,
-0.21453158557415009,
0.8549560904502869,
-0.3487507998943329,
-0.3872147500514984,
-0.25413385033607483,
0.4318581223487854,
-0.3588535189628601,
0.9977118372917175,
0.10223084688186646,
0.029333297163248062,
-0.06533943861722946,
0.034533292055130005,
-0.3236136734485626,
-0.48015081882476807,
-0.6886600852012634,
-0.18079309165477753,
0.32675379514694214,
-0.19145207107067108,
0.5553967952728271,
0.751640260219574,
0.6970812678337097,
0.3469817042350769,
-0.33838585019111633,
0.6774397492408752,
-0.30321523547172546,
0.01624237187206745,
-0.0886000320315361,
-0.260722815990448,
-0.3656752407550812,
-0.4614054262638092,
0.21452267467975616,
0.7285159230232239,
0.1460200399160385,
0.3759087920188904,
-0.0992206260561943,
1.0183314085006714,
-0.7147965431213379,
-0.031551849097013474,
-0.8789926171302795,
-0.21802204847335815,
0.048799362033605576,
-0.5089195370674133,
-0.35233885049819946,
-0.7135764956474304,
-0.01930343359708786,
-0.3467548191547394,
0.45793086290359497,
0.05177665129303932,
0.886192798614502,
0.7790037393569946,
-0.10949921607971191,
-0.6843619346618652,
-0.7313367128372192,
0.9177834987640381,
-0.910689651966095,
0.46615898609161377,
0.3074899911880493,
0.1689664125442505,
-0.15191274881362915,
-0.5628138184547424,
-0.3488723635673523,
-0.4258030652999878,
-0.11530819535255432,
-0.28833630681037903,
0.09651542454957962,
0.11005004495382309,
0.4698919951915741,
0.48548492789268494,
-0.5691617727279663,
0.09980626404285431,
-0.5534061193466187,
0.0509553961455822,
0.8613619208335876,
0.23021970689296722,
0.08843153715133667,
-0.0866822749376297,
-0.18797215819358826,
0.0602482445538044,
-0.7422303557395935,
-0.18079732358455658,
0.6934857964515686,
0.6675176024436951,
0.16759920120239258,
0.556716799736023,
-0.1334441751241684,
1.019944190979004,
0.2213805615901947,
-0.1120261698961258,
0.3673483431339264,
-0.3174072206020355,
-0.3465687930583954,
-0.18842758238315582,
0.1524694412946701,
0.3184424638748169,
0.49278128147125244,
-0.41420111060142517,
-0.6931681632995605,
0.2564321756362915,
0.7597439885139465,
-0.5611768960952759,
-0.0023807743564248085,
0.2864770293235779,
-0.3373335897922516,
-0.33877822756767273,
-0.13108409941196442,
-0.4173188805580139,
-0.37799155712127686,
-0.9641745090484619,
0.38003554940223694,
-0.33112457394599915,
-0.027792733162641525,
0.1385727971792221,
-0.15494254231452942,
0.3037361800670624,
0.27621880173683167,
-0.7280144691467285,
0.14688663184642792,
0.9450680613517761,
0.5566570162773132,
-0.35215067863464355,
0.058365486562252045,
-0.46020111441612244,
-0.24664612114429474,
-0.7041595578193665,
0.7614814043045044,
-0.44610100984573364,
-0.285657674074173,
0.10570421069860458,
-0.1292932778596878,
0.20140831172466278,
-0.9445925354957581,
0.501062273979187,
-0.9322375059127808,
-0.15753941237926483,
-0.13341794908046722,
-0.6443791389465332,
-0.05960821732878685,
0.032107919454574585,
-0.6455813646316528,
0.8926816582679749,
0.288842111825943,
-0.5322808623313904,
0.5161883234977722,
-0.46122726798057556,
-0.44679421186447144,
0.11037483811378479,
-0.2797282934188843,
-0.4245994985103607,
0.40008461475372314,
-0.03958714008331299,
0.2126379907131195,
-0.35474079847335815,
0.14828751981258392,
-0.05512451380491257,
-0.5698173642158508,
0.15179726481437683,
-0.1346924901008606,
0.5168325901031494,
0.6130773425102234,
-0.19415757060050964,
-0.2305963784456253,
-0.880730926990509,
0.28241074085235596,
-0.20491968095302582,
-0.5579630136489868,
-0.3689659833908081,
-0.08912879973649979,
-0.09591123461723328,
-0.063323475420475,
0.20468467473983765,
-0.3480619788169861,
0.11669877171516418,
-0.8166822195053101,
0.02175014838576317,
0.7569780945777893,
0.11122298240661621,
0.4411078989505768,
-0.5281253457069397,
0.4109778106212616,
-0.2807559072971344,
0.034635625779628754,
-0.1863682121038437,
-0.09328167885541916,
-0.6505695581436157,
-0.2638745605945587,
0.253397673368454,
0.18475452065467834,
-0.690621554851532,
0.4593832790851593,
-0.08565182238817215,
-0.40605270862579346,
-0.8140164613723755,
0.1578906923532486,
0.6178924441337585,
0.3924376666545868,
0.5023264288902283,
-0.13037551939487457,
-0.6607173681259155,
-0.885895311832428,
-0.24502742290496826,
0.11742900311946869,
0.024006342515349388,
0.5387550592422485,
0.21866928040981293,
-0.4398047924041748,
0.6953175663948059,
-0.5310693383216858,
-0.06502136588096619,
-0.19690023362636566,
0.040638625621795654,
0.33251985907554626,
0.3482748568058014,
0.7037575244903564,
-0.7415026426315308,
-0.7151700854301453,
0.2224450558423996,
-0.30712783336639404,
-0.3903794586658478,
0.02845352329313755,
0.056647349148988724,
0.9685907363891602,
0.3438480496406555,
-0.2487066239118576,
0.3785153031349182,
0.38821539282798767,
0.036845121532678604,
0.7549576759338379,
-0.305948406457901,
0.3463497459888458,
-0.7904156446456909,
0.27572208642959595,
-0.2031349092721939,
-0.018731990829110146,
-0.709613561630249,
0.45516467094421387,
0.157696932554245,
-0.0892648845911026,
-0.4680333435535431,
0.6334860324859619,
-0.5470504760742188,
-0.45082172751426697,
-0.5962777733802795,
-0.022070005536079407,
-0.012889879755675793,
0.5165343284606934,
-0.1384420543909073,
1.281259298324585,
0.4192667305469513,
-1.0077153444290161,
0.22411012649536133,
0.11881708353757858,
-0.12322501093149185,
0.20791415870189667,
-0.6203055381774902,
0.2162451297044754,
-0.1544952690601349,
-0.29919129610061646,
-0.63877272605896,
-0.11317095160484314,
-0.41526633501052856,
-0.45367658138275146,
0.416549414396286,
-0.13560867309570312,
-0.4960278272628784,
-0.4147484004497528,
-0.27350914478302,
0.26283949613571167,
0.814821720123291,
-0.8050686717033386,
0.15152166783809662,
0.25509902834892273,
0.11773104965686798,
-0.5649568438529968,
-0.6148525476455688,
-0.17386779189109802,
-0.331677109003067,
-0.5711354613304138,
0.39454594254493713,
-0.19446547329425812,
-0.41868916153907776,
-0.19660888612270355,
-0.326511949300766,
-0.05341062322258949,
0.09992993623018265,
-0.1713125854730606,
0.2646056115627289,
-0.26743051409721375,
0.20778729021549225,
-0.11934603005647659,
-0.25701192021369934,
-0.2567256987094879,
-0.1447545289993286,
0.7679691314697266,
-0.0862002819776535,
-0.3408772647380829,
-0.24368959665298462,
0.148976668715477,
0.3597830533981323,
-0.3477277457714081,
0.44875118136405945,
0.38004428148269653,
-0.18561261892318726,
-0.41013938188552856,
-0.8368978500366211,
-0.18885473906993866,
-0.5462494492530823,
0.14853601157665253,
-0.39807477593421936,
-0.509988009929657,
0.47421249747276306,
-0.0587088018655777,
0.27554526925086975,
0.19914871454238892,
0.5640688538551331,
0.21416498720645905,
1.1316362619400024,
0.6809492707252502,
0.06216249242424965,
0.37611302733421326,
-0.3299369215965271,
0.14403682947158813,
-0.9340466856956482,
0.19213947653770447,
-0.6887134313583374,
-0.11778182536363602,
-0.6209248900413513,
-0.43370065093040466,
0.12694886326789856,
0.12153872847557068,
-0.35618942975997925,
0.6417250037193298,
-0.8194854855537415,
0.5674207210540771,
0.4014527499675751,
-0.12215036153793335,
0.41830775141716003,
0.21125684678554535,
-0.023153027519583702,
0.004614927805960178,
-0.32092908024787903,
-0.6934037804603577,
1.235874891281128,
-0.0009091871907003224,
0.9690300226211548,
0.13659599423408508,
0.9895108938217163,
0.30273252725601196,
-0.08078204095363617,
-0.5088555812835693,
0.4183630347251892,
-0.6273890733718872,
-0.3752233386039734,
-0.040967974811792374,
-0.5081056356430054,
-1.0453786849975586,
-0.03122054412961006,
-0.01727784238755703,
-0.48287028074264526,
0.04252476617693901,
0.11440656334161758,
-0.31869077682495117,
0.10317546129226685,
-0.7200142741203308,
0.4084104299545288,
-0.2829969823360443,
-0.4228231608867645,
-0.12483116239309311,
-0.3550077974796295,
0.1465109884738922,
-0.3506311774253845,
0.050255533307790756,
0.13870012760162354,
-0.07920821011066437,
0.07341954857110977,
-0.33148086071014404,
0.3376721441745758,
-0.04003718122839928,
-0.3225829601287842,
0.16259615123271942,
-0.023981815204024315,
0.5490787625312805,
-0.13158319890499115,
-0.5024433135986328,
-0.29765135049819946,
-0.12355365604162216,
-0.1640997976064682,
-0.597359836101532,
0.8160624504089355,
-0.6668731570243835,
-0.5270954370498657,
0.048541415482759476,
-0.5208935737609863,
-0.14904683828353882,
0.2465551346540451,
0.22676058113574982,
0.817470908164978,
0.3318459689617157,
0.02180403284728527,
0.8506654500961304,
-0.5983926653862,
0.29972967505455017,
0.6243000030517578,
-0.27521026134490967,
-0.23065973818302155,
0.8193572163581848,
0.0015918726567178965,
0.5308957695960999,
0.09172401577234268,
-0.22069017589092255,
-0.3163018822669983,
-0.7609850168228149,
-0.4278814196586609,
0.40177851915359497,
-0.6362243294715881,
-0.46580561995506287,
-0.6219916343688965,
-0.4208714962005615,
-0.6039935350418091,
-0.5108711123466492,
-0.38799166679382324,
-0.2737883925437927,
-0.3307247757911682,
0.1894896924495697,
0.4673350155353546,
0.7167194485664368,
0.04257913678884506,
-0.022825412452220917,
-0.71775883436203,
0.6312160491943359,
-0.09517837315797806,
0.5582442879676819,
-0.005693394690752029,
-0.47299009561538696,
-0.2537243366241455,
0.12814854085445404,
-0.24848057329654694,
-0.6013041138648987,
0.5286673903465271,
0.05200878158211708,
0.7222744226455688,
0.009537623263895512,
0.2917203903198242,
0.9766934514045715,
-0.42504674196243286,
0.5378448367118835,
-0.2331026792526245,
-0.5896809697151184,
0.48800984025001526,
-0.07706250995397568,
0.22977612912654877,
0.5709022879600525,
0.10289161652326584,
-0.1817174106836319,
-0.5463517308235168,
-0.5555518865585327,
-0.9645225405693054,
0.6716639995574951,
-0.07309325039386749,
0.1901923567056656,
-0.17157235741615295,
0.5860103368759155,
0.2388346642255783,
0.30224597454071045,
-0.3765780031681061,
-0.23104748129844666,
0.43348774313926697,
-0.130987748503685,
-0.019327636808156967,
0.049779292196035385,
-0.03369661793112755,
-0.01763344183564186,
0.7083355188369751,
-0.1317668855190277,
0.19785413146018982,
0.1502581089735031,
-0.20148581266403198,
-0.2734132409095764,
0.04237227514386177,
0.6105325222015381,
0.5786558985710144,
-0.15750791132450104,
-0.08453990519046783,
0.29602882266044617,
-0.1928020864725113,
-0.10670620948076248,
0.070357546210289,
-0.2300911396741867,
0.13081783056259155,
0.22228361666202545,
0.7675800323486328,
-0.11345425248146057,
-0.8666632175445557,
0.18426810204982758,
0.16456517577171326,
-0.06475412845611572,
-0.3337026834487915,
0.36261841654777527,
-0.17510616779327393,
0.4218275249004364,
0.3122211992740631,
0.11831825226545334,
0.34922754764556885,
-0.2709326148033142,
0.3233219087123871,
0.6258231401443481,
0.02264970913529396,
0.03679534047842026,
0.49705949425697327,
0.030390968546271324,
-0.4603712856769562,
0.31637945771217346,
-0.5094485282897949,
-0.3462376594543457,
0.8091766834259033,
0.6167489290237427,
0.9039092063903809,
0.1959136724472046,
-0.05977742373943329,
0.6077594757080078,
0.1299138069152832,
-0.01434918213635683,
0.2279386818408966,
-0.04898558557033539,
-0.3743951916694641,
-0.48600703477859497,
-1.1171549558639526,
-0.11799321323633194,
0.08506755530834198,
-0.5177305936813354,
0.6060120463371277,
-0.22571860253810883,
-0.21397927403450012,
-0.20919112861156464,
0.4112606346607208,
-0.6781478524208069,
0.0527067705988884,
0.07628215849399567,
0.8512275815010071,
-0.49951091408729553,
0.6219576597213745,
0.7833066582679749,
-0.44599783420562744,
-0.7520818114280701,
-0.012217583134770393,
-0.19844293594360352,
-0.5880773067474365,
0.6908734440803528,
0.13126349449157715,
-0.1020357608795166,
0.1948246955871582,
-0.1835605800151825,
-0.9543153643608093,
1.0940783023834229,
0.18878965079784393,
-0.4501793384552002,
-0.06636316329240799,
0.18291567265987396,
0.9570328593254089,
-0.2878172695636749,
0.06893860548734665,
0.7441113591194153,
0.30745381116867065,
0.033740416169166565,
-0.926256537437439,
-0.129620760679245,
-0.0029201360885053873,
0.3565261662006378,
0.49023544788360596,
-0.23547735810279846,
0.7981265783309937,
-0.2236117124557495,
-0.35608264803886414,
0.41258570551872253,
0.11113124340772629,
0.5328632593154907,
0.27736926078796387,
0.22687631845474243,
0.5428479313850403,
0.566683292388916,
-0.009995931759476662,
1.116870403289795,
-0.5600124597549438,
0.2606090009212494,
0.8723199367523193,
-0.3084885776042938,
0.6742827296257019,
0.46337419748306274,
-0.19213084876537323,
-0.09233351796865463,
0.460469514131546,
-0.16275961697101593,
0.6185104250907898,
0.3577646017074585,
-0.031174177303910255,
0.18571895360946655,
0.039824534207582474,
-0.5279445052146912,
-0.02803102508187294,
0.17907556891441345,
-0.4653208255767822,
-0.3339470624923706,
-0.02371036633849144,
-0.25023218989372253,
0.37781932950019836,
-0.3023447096347809,
1.2303004264831543,
-0.11646954715251923,
-0.8125467300415039,
1.1041897535324097,
-0.04542833939194679,
0.7756502628326416,
-0.2894498109817505,
0.17884841561317444,
-0.5237632989883423,
0.3303791582584381,
-0.31834807991981506,
-0.4543192386627197,
0.7580879926681519,
0.3143923282623291,
-0.05142416059970856,
-0.04565883427858353,
0.6236919164657593,
-0.2962248921394348,
-0.27078819274902344,
0.3472232520580292,
0.2926325500011444,
0.19541019201278687,
0.1083400622010231,
-0.6241530179977417,
0.3352261185646057,
0.15088103711605072,
-0.08950834721326828,
0.2746278643608093,
0.3479134440422058,
0.160653218626976,
0.6492905020713806,
0.7223225235939026,
0.38952764868736267,
0.3383593261241913,
0.19239327311515808,
0.9758850932121277,
-0.4681669771671295,
-0.18699413537979126,
-0.5994002819061279,
0.4076082110404968,
0.07592608779668808,
-0.13204973936080933,
0.5702755451202393,
0.6567358374595642,
0.8620108962059021,
-0.3536306917667389,
0.6327753663063049,
-0.054503269493579865,
0.7259168028831482,
-0.6269875764846802,
0.4055923521518707,
-0.9083318114280701,
0.7011942267417908,
-0.38189926743507385,
-1.239067554473877,
-0.3048674166202545,
0.4522492289543152,
-0.27863872051239014,
0.03926065191626549,
0.362624853849411,
1.296518087387085,
-0.05034477263689041,
-0.2404310405254364,
0.32620078325271606,
-0.17290878295898438,
0.28822654485702515,
0.22306041419506073,
0.7208230495452881,
-0.3453942835330963,
0.4016555845737457,
-0.26586201786994934,
-0.03518516570329666,
-0.3179340064525604,
-0.564336895942688,
-0.6624495387077332,
-0.5468727946281433,
-0.2649342119693756,
-0.15344831347465515,
0.25383833050727844,
1.0021559000015259,
0.45962971448898315,
-0.6592302322387695,
-0.14013731479644775,
-0.42054659128189087,
-0.039303477853536606,
-0.08450257778167725,
-0.27316606044769287,
0.1701711267232895,
-1.2943589687347412,
-0.9768249988555908,
0.09352831542491913,
0.14181628823280334,
0.08508801460266113,
-0.19414113461971283,
-0.23511672019958496,
-0.013038335368037224,
0.3445811867713928,
0.5587328672409058,
0.13398708403110504,
-0.845599889755249,
-0.10483013093471527,
0.24531984329223633,
-0.3865385353565216,
-0.001543276128359139,
0.644885241985321,
-0.759850800037384,
0.4051048755645752,
0.634049117565155,
0.9899650812149048,
0.22411353886127472,
0.32228022813796997,
0.4289400577545166,
-0.7397341132164001,
0.02431318536400795,
0.2791362404823303,
0.07130490988492966,
0.36729639768600464,
-0.3168029189109802,
0.7709023952484131,
-0.29625073075294495,
-0.9281150698661804,
-1.1249098777770996,
0.4242134988307953,
-0.620572566986084,
-0.42167696356773376,
1.3144445419311523,
0.17859028279781342,
-0.07006801664829254,
-0.2550526559352875,
-0.39752864837646484,
0.29594123363494873,
-0.06402137875556946,
0.9564017057418823,
0.20660847425460815,
-0.29193127155303955,
0.2614514231681824,
-0.6030788421630859,
0.8600686192512512,
0.29256975650787354,
-0.6504905819892883,
0.23111745715141296,
0.5208601355552673,
-0.02408755198121071,
0.3511199951171875,
0.3766756057739258,
-0.31401559710502625,
0.300114244222641,
-0.08422921597957611,
0.0879405066370964,
-0.13709034025669098,
-0.22650480270385742,
-0.4166453778743744,
-0.18594621121883392,
0.3087898790836334,
0.07265795767307281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02736v1 | MentalAgora: A Gateway to Advanced Personalized Care in Mental Health through Multi-Agent Debating and Attribute Control | 2024-07-03T01:19:38 | 2024-07-03T01:19:38 | Yeonji Lee, Sangjun Park, Kyunghyun Cho, JinYeong Bak | cs.CL | cs.CL | As mental health issues globally escalate, there is a tremendous need for
advanced digital support systems. We introduce MentalAgora, a novel framework
employing large language models enhanced by interaction between multiple agents
for tailored mental health support. This framework operates through three
stages: strategic debating, tailored counselor creation, and response
generation, enabling the dynamic customization of responses based on individual
user preferences and therapeutic needs. We conduct experiments utilizing a
high-quality evaluation dataset TherapyTalk crafted with mental health
professionals, shwoing that MentalAgora generates expert-aligned and user
preference-enhanced responses. Our evaluations, including experiments and user
studies, demonstrate that MentalAgora aligns with professional standards and
effectively meets user preferences, setting a new benchmark for digital mental
health interventions. | [
-0.815532386302948,
-0.7833439111709595,
0.7246265411376953,
0.23472070693969727,
0.15821939706802368,
0.44992369413375854,
0.09296082705259323,
-0.5881708860397339,
0.5106213092803955,
0.4091747999191284,
-0.7920941114425659,
-0.42392387986183167,
-0.549170732498169,
0.05901319533586502,
-0.08131017535924911,
1.2295308113098145,
0.09911009669303894,
0.21713724732398987,
-0.17008885741233826,
-0.3166796565055847,
-0.6993438601493835,
-0.5237329602241516,
-0.9191692471504211,
-0.799130380153656,
1.011279582977295,
0.4299444556236267,
1.0653841495513916,
0.028122901916503906,
0.5464217662811279,
0.32506710290908813,
0.26462456583976746,
0.25809165835380554,
-0.17528684437274933,
0.20881132781505585,
-0.43110764026641846,
-0.3280901610851288,
-1.1345744132995605,
-0.1278374195098877,
-0.10496587306261063,
0.1591433584690094,
-0.5921314358711243,
0.2369922399520874,
-0.25475603342056274,
0.4627830982208252,
-0.518751323223114,
-0.28542032837867737,
-0.5133306384086609,
0.1464996486902237,
-0.18444427847862244,
0.08474331349134445,
-0.07251988351345062,
-0.6197513341903687,
0.04239775985479355,
-0.7011857628822327,
-0.025353271514177322,
-0.17618146538734436,
0.7012076377868652,
0.33083486557006836,
-0.3549633026123047,
-0.20215871930122375,
-1.1111863851547241,
0.23638051748275757,
-0.5003296732902527,
0.03136896714568138,
0.6791175007820129,
0.8397251963615417,
-0.02808147855103016,
-0.9969478249549866,
-0.6397171020507812,
0.03182445839047432,
0.05149145796895027,
0.22471930086612701,
-0.8974384665489197,
0.32249075174331665,
0.05322838947176933,
0.14595456421375275,
-0.2708994150161743,
0.11788038164377213,
-0.25821566581726074,
-0.1757720559835434,
0.7515479922294617,
0.6102285385131836,
0.3774343729019165,
0.3353442847728729,
0.11981175094842911,
0.1063983216881752,
-0.10742087662220001,
0.03559768199920654,
0.25988978147506714,
-0.03528283163905144,
-0.08493433147668839,
0.7996892333030701,
-0.11257044225931168,
0.32269665598869324,
0.4543505012989044,
-0.1975550651550293,
-0.1262570470571518,
0.07625020295381546,
-0.3707497715950012,
0.15476123988628387,
0.7346522212028503,
0.5557436943054199,
-0.07285922020673752,
-0.1661398708820343,
-0.031492557376623154,
0.5332082509994507,
0.8500135540962219,
-0.7300940752029419,
-0.1605464071035385,
0.6497237086296082,
-0.31828874349594116,
0.026004675775766373,
-0.12831270694732666,
-0.7905094027519226,
-0.6442509293556213,
-0.6006847023963928,
0.29435762763023376,
-0.42148277163505554,
-0.2285517305135727,
0.5004057884216309,
-0.05948672816157341,
-0.09370195120573044,
0.4542158246040344,
-0.5940235257148743,
0.7628408074378967,
0.6192600131034851,
0.9307325482368469,
-0.03654156252741814,
-0.13834360241889954,
-0.41997188329696655,
0.306596040725708,
-0.14724011719226837,
1.2848725318908691,
-0.7186729907989502,
-0.12496412545442581,
-0.2165737748146057,
-0.2481151968240738,
0.16151610016822815,
-0.553997278213501,
0.46311384439468384,
-0.4774858355522156,
0.2315230816602707,
-0.2922138273715973,
-0.21087755262851715,
-0.08706832677125931,
0.326687216758728,
-0.6118256449699402,
0.5284526348114014,
0.40174052119255066,
-0.880455732345581,
0.2175169587135315,
-0.8551242351531982,
-0.1517336219549179,
0.3358520269393921,
-0.14988252520561218,
-0.3634222745895386,
0.18743178248405457,
0.11004026979207993,
0.24856634438037872,
-0.40200257301330566,
0.2946505546569824,
-0.8222765326499939,
-0.3764955699443817,
0.4487023651599884,
-0.034798189997673035,
0.4475001096725464,
0.3005748987197876,
-0.43152356147766113,
0.6814026832580566,
-0.7805425524711609,
0.10625971853733063,
0.1305600106716156,
-0.034644559025764465,
-0.46717649698257446,
-0.051251281052827835,
0.21863031387329102,
0.3506675064563751,
0.03725270554423332,
-0.553669810295105,
0.0880557969212532,
-0.004902884364128113,
0.5717192888259888,
0.8322213888168335,
-0.11851862818002701,
0.036738503724336624,
-0.6225931644439697,
0.8371443748474121,
-0.30894652009010315,
0.40299010276794434,
0.27175286412239075,
-0.4884144067764282,
-0.24928346276283264,
-0.7250459790229797,
-0.1924518644809723,
0.6519915461540222,
-0.3861018717288971,
0.5037190318107605,
0.011686781421303749,
-0.600933313369751,
-0.9996839165687561,
-0.22382597625255585,
0.0820060521364212,
0.28304341435432434,
0.42925533652305603,
-0.2571171820163727,
-0.5151784420013428,
-1.090977430343628,
0.16612856090068817,
0.016509192064404488,
-0.1275063455104828,
0.3311876058578491,
0.1494433432817459,
-0.9901947975158691,
1.1448794603347778,
-0.6080848574638367,
-0.5518364310264587,
-0.3351565897464752,
0.13203807175159454,
-0.20855168998241425,
-0.13386639952659607,
0.5291311144828796,
-0.45552706718444824,
-0.500481367111206,
0.3278641998767853,
-0.7768431901931763,
-0.3875281810760498,
0.05935356020927429,
-0.429174542427063,
-0.46040645241737366,
-0.12157679349184036,
-0.647853672504425,
0.24746622145175934,
0.6107779741287231,
-0.4625031650066376,
0.5673321485519409,
-0.5022493600845337,
0.09547252953052521,
-1.2565091848373413,
0.2972007095813751,
-0.10766588896512985,
-0.25306111574172974,
-0.7409214377403259,
0.0244252011179924,
-0.31703561544418335,
-0.2668221592903137,
-0.12232702225446701,
0.5025695562362671,
0.19842049479484558,
0.13468722999095917,
-0.6139861345291138,
0.12092295289039612,
-0.01680472493171692,
0.32168248295783997,
-0.23968487977981567,
0.6709885597229004,
0.3692564368247986,
-0.14479419589042664,
0.7423105239868164,
0.3526693284511566,
0.1034640520811081,
1.4844633340835571,
-0.8346990346908569,
0.4706479609012604,
-0.21765513718128204,
0.5896614789962769,
-0.8102031350135803,
-0.37955600023269653,
0.45429667830467224,
-0.09482833743095398,
-0.2824915647506714,
0.5923935770988464,
-0.27332696318626404,
-0.4893947243690491,
-0.19469477236270905,
0.3640137016773224,
-0.12638156116008759,
-0.04000459238886833,
0.6282009482383728,
0.768610417842865,
-0.3785449266433716,
-0.3252754509449005,
-0.19281817972660065,
0.5687550902366638,
-0.5992322564125061,
-0.32034263014793396,
0.5278473496437073,
-0.43371084332466125,
-0.5772648453712463,
-0.010713783092796803,
0.27567970752716064,
-0.2147943377494812,
0.06966821849346161,
0.3256504535675049,
-0.06207522749900818,
-0.0012192628346383572,
0.24635876715183258,
0.4337197542190552,
-0.25394371151924133,
0.11268673837184906,
-0.19356535375118256,
0.6619946360588074,
-0.179862841963768,
-0.36420008540153503,
-0.8052512407302856,
0.9912787675857544,
0.8414588570594788,
-0.43078821897506714,
0.5494551658630371,
0.7115727663040161,
-0.670927882194519,
0.1343659907579422,
-0.5913777947425842,
-0.12345868349075317,
-0.46586453914642334,
0.1395287960767746,
-0.5388470888137817,
-0.8727064728736877,
0.7478433847427368,
0.06689517199993134,
0.05321643128991127,
0.06307708472013474,
0.6121154427528381,
-0.07498429715633392,
1.699924111366272,
0.5584865212440491,
-0.05177095904946327,
0.22538037598133087,
-0.007603561505675316,
0.197654128074646,
-0.6685813069343567,
-0.40685299038887024,
-0.4113936722278595,
-0.5152778029441833,
-0.3818836510181427,
-0.1170734316110611,
0.4882182478904724,
-0.08539679646492004,
-0.6105871796607971,
0.19615690410137177,
-0.7691118121147156,
-0.20588341355323792,
0.32213765382766724,
0.6736903786659241,
0.46540892124176025,
-0.1416601985692978,
-0.20615282654762268,
-0.36331263184547424,
-0.3511565625667572,
-0.565997302532196,
0.6885839104652405,
0.3132084012031555,
1.0272853374481201,
0.2231675088405609,
0.18373596668243408,
0.6403954029083252,
0.6832729578018188,
-0.8606729507446289,
0.3587208390235901,
0.2573230564594269,
-0.645477831363678,
-0.08021057397127151,
0.0490805022418499,
-1.1315686702728271,
0.265218585729599,
-0.2770717740058899,
-0.8270427584648132,
0.1258169412612915,
0.15105217695236206,
-0.7613148093223572,
0.1516115963459015,
-0.3553200662136078,
0.40578120946884155,
-0.294706255197525,
-0.38823357224464417,
-0.835779070854187,
-0.4440755546092987,
0.1623404175043106,
-0.270702600479126,
0.031472496688365936,
-0.35786038637161255,
0.025927318260073662,
0.33998915553092957,
-0.2973690330982208,
0.7043594121932983,
0.16524727642536163,
-0.10357987135648727,
-0.03937961161136627,
0.12477759271860123,
0.12913140654563904,
0.3328496515750885,
-0.038019537925720215,
-0.1426440328359604,
0.14236406981945038,
-0.28196120262145996,
-0.8787443041801453,
0.6532808542251587,
-0.9590992331504822,
-0.8197423815727234,
-0.2742420732975006,
-0.5691535472869873,
-0.3719179928302765,
0.23192161321640015,
0.03408624231815338,
0.4399670362472534,
-0.28925055265426636,
-0.09842776507139206,
0.5659517645835876,
-0.2707673907279968,
-0.051227323710918427,
0.5522348284721375,
-0.212554931640625,
-0.9064890742301941,
0.6002784371376038,
0.08619088679552078,
-0.24580304324626923,
0.17749163508415222,
0.4538953900337219,
-0.1860460638999939,
-0.08302287012338638,
-0.2724204659461975,
0.21283790469169617,
-0.5275960564613342,
-0.2783105969429016,
-0.8785728812217712,
-0.1670479029417038,
-0.28614604473114014,
-0.33292052149772644,
-0.48843541741371155,
-0.03228166699409485,
-0.04360141232609749,
-0.32332852482795715,
0.3363182544708252,
1.0449756383895874,
0.08905395120382309,
0.4162755310535431,
-0.6585670709609985,
0.2738911807537079,
0.6752362847328186,
0.5309293866157532,
0.22847948968410492,
0.23960928618907928,
-0.26240670680999756,
-0.11759136617183685,
-0.7207465171813965,
-1.2458128929138184,
0.1493973731994629,
0.06643935292959213,
0.7860228419303894,
0.7550240159034729,
0.1298728734254837,
0.9413987994194031,
-0.6429879665374756,
0.2859231233596802,
0.18402032554149628,
-0.8170038461685181,
0.8320474624633789,
-0.4337875247001648,
0.3636030852794647,
0.45090174674987793,
0.34604671597480774,
-0.7524405717849731,
-0.4205915927886963,
-0.46578311920166016,
-0.5255263447761536,
0.5779995322227478,
0.0031703633721917868,
0.32654860615730286,
0.08371415734291077,
0.3664158582687378,
0.2091475874185562,
0.3040556013584137,
-0.4730978012084961,
-0.13828231394290924,
-0.25407207012176514,
-0.24315184354782104,
0.15063536167144775,
0.058001432567834854,
-0.8897501826286316,
-0.2936074435710907,
0.1506427526473999,
-0.38059261441230774,
0.5492736101150513,
0.2004992663860321,
0.2211659848690033,
-0.2804999351501465,
0.24044106900691986,
0.6591750979423523,
0.8026156425476074,
-0.007630046922713518,
0.1471717357635498,
0.06248041242361069,
-0.4330442547798157,
0.4519079923629761,
0.2682182788848877,
0.15436194837093353,
-0.3010425269603729,
0.10388259589672089,
0.9613649845123291,
0.011170502752065659,
-0.6214057803153992,
-0.12009672820568085,
-0.49745315313339233,
-0.028075052425265312,
-0.1379755139350891,
0.22618484497070312,
0.024686796590685844,
0.5616373419761658,
0.20408976078033447,
-0.026144418865442276,
0.36678677797317505,
-0.2855064570903778,
0.3368764817714691,
0.5772266983985901,
-0.657985508441925,
-0.6716745495796204,
0.85866779088974,
-0.09850956499576569,
-0.8127864003181458,
0.3294123113155365,
0.20433171093463898,
-0.07937346398830414,
0.2814403474330902,
0.7138329148292542,
0.9712579846382141,
-0.44499149918556213,
0.7989535331726074,
0.010720396414399147,
-0.05055023729801178,
0.06823637336492538,
0.22470693290233612,
-0.08360433578491211,
-0.6044934988021851,
0.11662212014198303,
-0.27026018500328064,
-0.7199008464813232,
0.2750549614429474,
-0.9604688286781311,
0.14144296944141388,
-0.6529629230499268,
-1.0367172956466675,
0.031226245686411858,
0.1267452836036682,
-0.6237618923187256,
0.1559184342622757,
0.11175967752933502,
0.6774332523345947,
-0.6372355818748474,
0.7022753953933716,
1.098503828048706,
-0.13732700049877167,
-0.5178712606430054,
0.010912451893091202,
0.0965910404920578,
-0.3906451165676117,
-0.07707701623439789,
0.14486676454544067,
-0.5501422882080078,
0.02859089896082878,
-0.2105940878391266,
-0.5625841617584229,
1.2715106010437012,
0.774198055267334,
-0.1303454339504242,
-0.055758748203516006,
0.1794048249721527,
0.9691103100776672,
-0.5194283127784729,
0.5610262751579285,
0.581975519657135,
0.560279130935669,
0.128311887383461,
-0.7058733105659485,
-0.0436277873814106,
-0.2609999477863312,
0.14556139707565308,
-0.2669885754585266,
-0.8797887563705444,
0.3539704978466034,
-0.25460192561149597,
-0.1455104947090149,
-0.016476111486554146,
0.5051506757736206,
0.5142241716384888,
0.42569074034690857,
0.3461155295372009,
0.5788759589195251,
1.0462971925735474,
0.13432081043720245,
0.8296338319778442,
-0.24374747276306152,
-0.009654562920331955,
1.1169190406799316,
-0.5522432327270508,
0.5582522749900818,
0.1259150207042694,
-0.2217358946800232,
0.7045273780822754,
0.9041407704353333,
0.2611848711967468,
0.3892326056957245,
0.13600040972232819,
-0.6309711337089539,
-0.06790642440319061,
-0.6160492300987244,
-0.3777463138103485,
0.43142375349998474,
0.339138388633728,
0.1482558399438858,
-0.11276812851428986,
0.4838501513004303,
0.39170315861701965,
0.27301231026649475,
-0.17389340698719025,
0.7575238943099976,
0.11634185910224915,
-0.7009248733520508,
0.12483344227075577,
0.12122311443090439,
0.39086878299713135,
-0.7458433508872986,
0.17049524188041687,
-0.4954817593097687,
0.45983874797821045,
-0.19369980692863464,
-0.5742650628089905,
0.4651694595813751,
-0.02856937237083912,
-0.1646915078163147,
-0.04653100296854973,
0.7053413987159729,
-0.13740673661231995,
-0.6089907884597778,
0.752530574798584,
0.5248192548751831,
-0.37733814120292664,
-0.012229605577886105,
-0.9326066374778748,
0.022998826578259468,
-0.606970489025116,
-0.1735394448041916,
0.5590829253196716,
0.3266768455505371,
-0.3686336278915405,
0.9058551788330078,
0.45940926671028137,
0.23461464047431946,
-0.344760924577713,
0.17774754762649536,
1.0079176425933838,
-0.2686951458454132,
-0.554141104221344,
-0.7162456512451172,
0.35693293809890747,
-0.15752817690372467,
-0.4605908691883087,
0.634175181388855,
0.26617661118507385,
0.4688180088996887,
0.25004473328590393,
0.7626986503601074,
-0.009019867517054081,
0.1034143716096878,
0.16642992198467255,
0.7288521528244019,
-0.5413332581520081,
-0.22834552824497223,
-0.3087073862552643,
-0.8333202004432678,
-0.3847709000110626,
0.5517476201057434,
-0.059074584394693375,
-0.18260519206523895,
0.43173298239707947,
0.6880217790603638,
0.0473000593483448,
-0.17286162078380585,
0.19830988347530365,
0.020807970315217972,
0.7345005869865417,
0.4346954822540283,
0.8850561380386353,
0.09521694481372833,
0.1340809166431427,
-0.13286352157592773,
-0.3624403774738312,
0.19262972474098206,
-0.4173266291618347,
-0.8130455613136292,
-0.5144969820976257,
-0.11812296509742737,
-0.24007199704647064,
0.24527467787265778,
1.238893985748291,
0.8296111822128296,
-0.8340761065483093,
-0.40089425444602966,
0.21444883942604065,
0.05243556573987007,
-0.6264737248420715,
-0.22178328037261963,
-0.04334280639886856,
0.03647724166512489,
-0.6440147161483765,
0.14458516240119934,
0.556017279624939,
-0.18046575784683228,
-0.735146164894104,
-0.07927833497524261,
0.053417693823575974,
0.43947121500968933,
0.6413590312004089,
0.09501122683286667,
-0.6897385716438293,
-0.08631040900945663,
0.09815535694360733,
-0.37923333048820496,
0.270597904920578,
0.9457039833068848,
-0.7384544014930725,
0.5283375382423401,
0.3196744918823242,
0.5763587951660156,
0.23609332740306854,
0.03045155480504036,
0.9511315226554871,
0.07843002676963806,
-0.028688441962003708,
0.1626671403646469,
-0.03764716535806656,
0.2061864286661148,
-0.6184473037719727,
0.23843888938426971,
0.014606441371142864,
-0.49265986680984497,
-0.712475061416626,
0.07267073541879654,
-0.6865010261535645,
-0.2648524045944214,
0.5937702059745789,
-0.23149767518043518,
0.3491365313529968,
-0.3866233825683594,
-0.6815283298492432,
0.3109394907951355,
-0.42254772782325745,
1.1907238960266113,
0.5919081568717957,
-0.5796522498130798,
-0.275542289018631,
-0.5451610088348389,
0.3103330731391907,
-0.04347854480147362,
-1.135176658630371,
-0.2510188817977905,
0.4778469502925873,
0.03269374370574951,
0.041026629507541656,
0.9689290523529053,
0.10217779874801636,
0.14678440988063812,
-0.41277921199798584,
0.04738928750157356,
0.021832898259162903,
-0.5213083624839783,
-0.266428679227829,
0.3541509807109833,
-0.0638948529958725,
0.30053314566612244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02723v1 | e-Health CSIRO at "Discharge Me!" 2024: Generating Discharge Summary Sections with Fine-tuned Language Models | 2024-07-03T00:32:28 | 2024-07-03T00:32:28 | Jinghui Liu, Aaron Nicolson, Jason Dowling, Bevan Koopman, Anthony Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Clinical documentation is an important aspect of clinicians' daily work and
often demands a significant amount of time. The BioNLP 2024 Shared Task on
Streamlining Discharge Documentation (Discharge Me!) aims to alleviate this
documentation burden by automatically generating discharge summary sections,
including brief hospital course and discharge instruction, which are often
time-consuming to synthesize and write manually. We approach the generation
task by fine-tuning multiple open-sourced language models (LMs), including both
decoder-only and encoder-decoder LMs, with various configurations on input
context. We also examine different setups for decoding algorithms, model
ensembling or merging, and model specialization. Our results show that
conditioning on the content of discharge summary prior to the target sections
is effective for the generation task. Furthermore, we find that smaller
encoder-decoder LMs can work as well or even slightly better than larger
decoder based LMs fine-tuned through LoRA. The model checkpoints from our team
(aehrc) are openly available. | [
-0.282814085483551,
-0.3280639350414276,
0.8504614233970642,
0.2414376139640808,
-0.45657357573509216,
-0.1574288308620453,
0.07272791862487793,
-0.5788671374320984,
0.35561734437942505,
1.013641119003296,
-0.6040509343147278,
-0.7631670832633972,
-0.4163455069065094,
0.40102601051330566,
-0.43924668431282043,
1.2124133110046387,
-0.026994185522198677,
-0.03173712641000748,
-0.13241827487945557,
0.022435259073972702,
-0.07126377522945404,
-0.39439237117767334,
-0.6030662059783936,
-0.5654625296592712,
0.6832146644592285,
0.30925190448760986,
0.3121405243873596,
0.520906388759613,
0.5031068325042725,
0.14943088591098785,
-0.02299177646636963,
0.32778894901275635,
-0.22886404395103455,
0.15455687046051025,
-0.1201225072145462,
-0.22981324791908264,
-0.8122620582580566,
-0.43266457319259644,
0.2740442156791687,
0.7073689699172974,
-0.3950071930885315,
0.3150845468044281,
0.10448770970106125,
0.6853077411651611,
-0.8986846804618835,
0.031937070190906525,
-0.3305513858795166,
0.023449085652828217,
0.11439363658428192,
-0.24372251331806183,
-0.6030387282371521,
-0.19975505769252777,
-0.20435935258865356,
-0.5125516653060913,
0.470559686422348,
-0.1767573356628418,
0.7747364044189453,
0.1540440320968628,
-0.16945070028305054,
-0.24340178072452545,
-0.7869768738746643,
0.6167231798171997,
-0.9118087291717529,
0.1670653373003006,
0.5856870412826538,
0.1769234538078308,
0.18274816870689392,
-0.9568812847137451,
-0.045680899173021317,
0.021680083125829697,
-0.2802068591117859,
0.37921249866485596,
0.006681292317807674,
0.6167335510253906,
0.25447842478752136,
0.25419124960899353,
-0.5431963205337524,
0.0587913878262043,
-0.7021585702896118,
-0.23879720270633698,
0.5847725868225098,
0.5571115612983704,
0.30156850814819336,
-0.34546539187431335,
0.033014100044965744,
0.14686471223831177,
-0.7598856091499329,
-0.1645904928445816,
-0.0757870078086853,
0.07125537842512131,
-0.49376213550567627,
0.49698305130004883,
-0.4694739580154419,
0.5727939605712891,
0.06600317358970642,
-0.02597684971988201,
0.016732249408960342,
-0.5640469789505005,
-0.30335280299186707,
0.2504033148288727,
0.8095623254776001,
0.3715205788612366,
-0.2295028120279312,
0.0341855026781559,
-0.3073420822620392,
-0.18346551060676575,
0.5484917759895325,
-1.1221894025802612,
-0.3904273509979248,
0.576638400554657,
-0.658476710319519,
-0.24485737085342407,
-0.3699452877044678,
-0.6488120555877686,
-0.08789797872304916,
-0.2992613613605499,
0.044544849544763565,
-0.5802189707756042,
0.1459009200334549,
0.2323179990053177,
0.044001076370477676,
-0.1291000097990036,
0.4067218005657196,
-1.1492139101028442,
0.37389278411865234,
0.6150653958320618,
0.8444250822067261,
0.14939239621162415,
-0.03889351710677147,
-0.8636930584907532,
0.3670083284378052,
0.0555635429918766,
0.7188282608985901,
-0.21370689570903778,
-0.3878653645515442,
0.3004619777202606,
-0.08840729296207428,
0.011974254623055458,
-0.4481068253517151,
0.544853150844574,
-0.1793774962425232,
-0.09979871660470963,
-0.015204162336885929,
-0.357065886259079,
0.35889649391174316,
0.09302393347024918,
-0.7419140338897705,
0.44614651799201965,
0.3898484706878662,
-0.6877427101135254,
0.23381224274635315,
-0.803697943687439,
-0.31183892488479614,
0.28156450390815735,
-0.2645942270755768,
-0.4962853789329529,
0.1414366066455841,
0.36467882990837097,
0.5404453277587891,
-0.24907992780208588,
0.3353354334831238,
-0.07547179609537125,
-0.27062782645225525,
-0.16951970756053925,
0.03896214812994003,
0.6471586227416992,
0.5587040781974792,
0.13533666729927063,
0.2413029670715332,
-0.8255720734596252,
0.006870962213724852,
-0.2350144237279892,
-0.5269113779067993,
-0.12084443122148514,
0.0777086541056633,
0.04078990966081619,
0.09281565994024277,
0.3466426432132721,
-0.5017711520195007,
-0.03956746309995651,
-0.647634744644165,
0.5214728116989136,
0.2604188323020935,
0.31984230875968933,
0.2976715862751007,
-0.543913722038269,
0.7132202982902527,
-0.019176166504621506,
0.5032628178596497,
-0.6446842551231384,
-0.4192692041397095,
-0.4238116145133972,
-0.39606204628944397,
0.04221106320619583,
0.2616948187351227,
-0.5596747994422913,
0.29806435108184814,
-0.09385642409324646,
-0.38828161358833313,
-0.46309858560562134,
-0.06198658049106598,
0.5703198909759521,
0.47985371947288513,
0.538490355014801,
-0.2039249688386917,
-0.6214649081230164,
-0.8623490929603577,
-0.04548412561416626,
-0.12146619707345963,
-0.042581867426633835,
-0.05883187800645828,
0.46685582399368286,
-0.6332222819328308,
0.6373559832572937,
-0.4688957631587982,
-0.16552814841270447,
-0.5657742619514465,
0.5059225559234619,
0.25781017541885376,
0.31345540285110474,
0.4969215989112854,
-0.5163561105728149,
-0.19026710093021393,
-0.006774277426302433,
-0.7675089240074158,
-0.4575407803058624,
-0.07021304965019226,
0.05284935235977173,
-0.06997782737016678,
0.6375108957290649,
-0.2926892340183258,
0.42954155802726746,
0.30484452843666077,
-0.21558886766433716,
0.7479464411735535,
-0.7622061967849731,
0.09034597128629684,
-1.2311040163040161,
0.12038000673055649,
-0.14461158215999603,
-0.42247122526168823,
-0.5667926073074341,
0.3720085322856903,
0.3630494475364685,
-0.41808170080184937,
-0.5451416373252869,
0.3712826371192932,
-0.3961486220359802,
0.28592172265052795,
-0.2169230878353119,
-0.2400069385766983,
0.4401855766773224,
0.18800142407417297,
0.0568433478474617,
0.2929629683494568,
0.2197340428829193,
-0.871597170829773,
0.009116840548813343,
0.4124775230884552,
-0.03836890310049057,
0.25910431146621704,
-0.6465972661972046,
-0.25487059354782104,
-0.08431331813335419,
0.4715103805065155,
-0.424206405878067,
-0.5713926553726196,
-0.03501756489276886,
0.017126843333244324,
0.3284454047679901,
0.04806040972471237,
-0.31328579783439636,
-0.37516626715660095,
-0.41507822275161743,
0.5639436841011047,
0.6405591368675232,
-0.29312971234321594,
0.540095865726471,
0.21118572354316711,
-0.3321880102157593,
-0.4036449193954468,
-0.742598295211792,
0.015502809546887875,
-0.03212932497262955,
-0.31045687198638916,
0.6729021668434143,
0.005246225278824568,
-0.14663361012935638,
-0.15851949155330658,
0.2759413719177246,
-0.11375799030065536,
-0.07446403801441193,
0.45924943685531616,
0.10654657334089279,
-0.12155207991600037,
-0.22161062061786652,
0.5352632999420166,
-0.01176992617547512,
0.25286802649497986,
-0.0384322926402092,
0.6805219650268555,
0.22715044021606445,
-0.7550743222236633,
-0.6449275016784668,
0.7974351048469543,
0.5361347198486328,
-0.25485649704933167,
0.6080998182296753,
0.5657711029052734,
-0.4938066899776459,
-0.16327200829982758,
-0.3631976842880249,
-0.2330571711063385,
-0.4606359004974365,
0.3715225160121918,
-0.00804014503955841,
-0.6688902974128723,
0.6858725547790527,
-0.2730804681777954,
0.4116906523704529,
0.3698325753211975,
0.5260792970657349,
-0.17207595705986023,
1.0880011320114136,
0.8335513472557068,
0.2170555293560028,
0.1862090826034546,
-0.33951395750045776,
0.29097622632980347,
-0.9004456400871277,
-0.4526436924934387,
-0.5746158957481384,
0.14223967492580414,
-0.42113515734672546,
-0.34393754601478577,
0.685843825340271,
0.25337451696395874,
-0.2194681316614151,
0.21092689037322998,
-0.5231460332870483,
0.14881852269172668,
0.22646105289459229,
0.3526785373687744,
0.18195486068725586,
-0.0543384850025177,
-0.1676473170518875,
0.050392407923936844,
-0.7315351963043213,
-0.591564953327179,
1.0030757188796997,
0.2369067221879959,
0.7221136093139648,
-0.2005041241645813,
1.4026930332183838,
0.3478747308254242,
0.08054155856370926,
-0.3494652807712555,
0.5091446042060852,
-0.5781171917915344,
0.05293656513094902,
0.0415206179022789,
-0.033876050263643265,
-0.8708573579788208,
-0.2648640275001526,
-0.04773629084229469,
-0.6908851265907288,
0.134110227227211,
0.467999666929245,
-0.6535579562187195,
-0.011800129897892475,
-0.3591096103191376,
0.5834957361221313,
-0.06360287964344025,
-0.2883972227573395,
-0.42679351568222046,
-0.5863338708877563,
0.5951357483863831,
-0.24181975424289703,
0.4519892930984497,
0.001246633124537766,
0.1138712540268898,
0.44479113817214966,
-0.8851098418235779,
0.7610166072845459,
0.1375153660774231,
-0.1947944611310959,
0.3018799424171448,
-0.11393971741199493,
0.18277637660503387,
0.1449883133172989,
-0.24959880113601685,
-0.1644410789012909,
0.2760268747806549,
-0.30483487248420715,
-0.24467164278030396,
0.5281996130943298,
-0.5240963697433472,
-0.18601466715335846,
-0.024894939735531807,
-0.3152410387992859,
-0.017986232414841652,
0.15638437867164612,
0.7139165997505188,
0.8779855966567993,
-0.48388227820396423,
-0.23005813360214233,
0.6432179808616638,
-0.6870722770690918,
0.3004031479358673,
0.5848819613456726,
-0.33713844418525696,
-0.3334893584251404,
0.84330815076828,
-0.1711166948080063,
0.5324200987815857,
0.5418611168861389,
0.012061567045748234,
-0.2579183280467987,
-0.6242081522941589,
-0.5185410976409912,
0.32911285758018494,
-0.8835365176200867,
-0.30348390340805054,
-0.8332585096359253,
-0.5536291599273682,
-0.5642299056053162,
-0.4520554542541504,
-0.2585345506668091,
-0.35443031787872314,
-0.5346676707267761,
0.053979821503162384,
0.24255473911762238,
1.0690081119537354,
-0.24243003129959106,
0.2923477292060852,
-1.186691403388977,
0.6922420859336853,
-0.11052194982767105,
0.0957583338022232,
-0.31977131962776184,
-0.3777116537094116,
-0.537335991859436,
0.16744010150432587,
-0.506395161151886,
-0.7645084857940674,
0.6687188148498535,
0.27277594804763794,
0.20413529872894287,
0.5408186316490173,
0.12506842613220215,
0.5431963801383972,
-0.5950555801391602,
1.0000724792480469,
0.5287067890167236,
-0.7434132099151611,
0.8821853995323181,
-0.6235304474830627,
0.507296085357666,
0.5389588475227356,
0.19389115273952484,
-0.3232741951942444,
-0.7842751145362854,
-0.5156665444374084,
-1.1412615776062012,
0.7592539191246033,
0.06878533214330673,
-0.06047450378537178,
-0.26622360944747925,
0.40054625272750854,
0.08054214715957642,
-0.04269809648394585,
-0.27503249049186707,
0.06899438798427582,
-0.23261836171150208,
-0.44852888584136963,
0.2285180538892746,
-0.5171278119087219,
-0.19032692909240723,
-0.009232228621840477,
0.4858880639076233,
-0.08312912285327911,
0.2834193706512451,
0.21473011374473572,
0.05371171236038208,
-0.10541034489870071,
0.5001420378684998,
0.7030311226844788,
0.8045380115509033,
-0.3333689272403717,
-0.012612313963472843,
0.03844276815652847,
-0.5443475842475891,
-0.03546508401632309,
-0.0819145068526268,
-0.26542919874191284,
0.2735312283039093,
0.37110018730163574,
0.6585104465484619,
0.3802446126937866,
-0.803446352481842,
0.3592205345630646,
-0.1892947554588318,
-0.4699121415615082,
-0.3093912601470947,
0.2775903344154358,
0.19552992284297943,
-0.11387687921524048,
0.09296230971813202,
-0.09293263405561447,
0.36646410822868347,
-0.4594639241695404,
0.22484949231147766,
0.042102616280317307,
-0.2649778127670288,
-0.42019787430763245,
0.8810787796974182,
0.2768518626689911,
-0.15748342871665955,
0.3960951566696167,
-0.10736996680498123,
-0.26439622044563293,
0.7970576286315918,
0.7688979506492615,
0.8887522220611572,
-0.1323428899049759,
0.3815714716911316,
0.7720039486885071,
0.023716965690255165,
-0.2709771990776062,
0.5532724857330322,
-0.08359810709953308,
-0.2198927253484726,
-0.550358772277832,
-1.1371650695800781,
-0.5633851885795593,
0.279855877161026,
-1.1145395040512085,
0.5123670697212219,
-0.4351329207420349,
0.10019730031490326,
-0.13669712841510773,
-0.5884535312652588,
-0.6941782236099243,
0.4751349985599518,
0.33875831961631775,
0.7442552447319031,
-0.8237851858139038,
0.5537525415420532,
0.512165904045105,
-0.5165755748748779,
-0.9780797958374023,
-0.19723846018314362,
-0.31373631954193115,
-0.5202142000198364,
0.4153941869735718,
0.08355838060379028,
-0.25304868817329407,
-0.17931583523750305,
-0.3453015089035034,
-0.3280893862247467,
1.1274014711380005,
0.2902073860168457,
-0.7614423632621765,
-0.3171716332435608,
0.4186275601387024,
0.7049917578697205,
-0.463029146194458,
0.5772072076797485,
0.5293154120445251,
0.21395470201969147,
-0.37429866194725037,
-1.0516091585159302,
-0.020317498594522476,
-0.32178935408592224,
-0.23088419437408447,
0.12054156512022018,
-0.5463044047355652,
0.8402270674705505,
-0.2577205002307892,
-0.16765949130058289,
0.24035008251667023,
0.4513242542743683,
0.3723001778125763,
0.4746648073196411,
-0.04737987741827965,
0.5234727263450623,
0.6520966291427612,
0.1704312562942505,
1.2585898637771606,
-0.5733199715614319,
0.027554230764508247,
1.1188619136810303,
-0.27700820565223694,
0.6963536143302917,
0.1972312033176422,
-0.01602189987897873,
0.518944501876831,
0.52895587682724,
0.41125166416168213,
0.524988055229187,
-0.0296721700578928,
-0.3996162712574005,
-0.2325834184885025,
-0.41340723633766174,
-0.44461506605148315,
0.3192647695541382,
0.5627550482749939,
-0.745223343372345,
-0.3837573230266571,
0.10510368645191193,
-0.2537168264389038,
0.12086442857980728,
-0.5391813516616821,
0.9402357935905457,
0.3934786319732666,
-0.9077171683311462,
0.7342729568481445,
0.25892409682273865,
0.2515847086906433,
-0.8626757860183716,
-0.08908360451459885,
-0.16468067467212677,
0.0690101757645607,
-0.5445244312286377,
-0.47008001804351807,
0.5450342297554016,
0.1934247612953186,
-0.37280216813087463,
-0.5084906220436096,
0.7359748482704163,
-0.2929033637046814,
-0.45032525062561035,
0.33234092593193054,
0.4546819031238556,
0.217728853225708,
0.062472909688949585,
-0.5007355213165283,
-0.04970073699951172,
0.06332015246152878,
0.18505655229091644,
0.5451165437698364,
0.3286362290382385,
-0.12491020560264587,
0.438952773809433,
0.32726404070854187,
0.4318501055240631,
0.11704271286725998,
0.7032789587974548,
0.7847191095352173,
-0.5696781873703003,
-0.5837721824645996,
-0.8393611311912537,
0.5234630703926086,
0.05105990916490555,
-0.2306077778339386,
0.13233351707458496,
0.7274865508079529,
0.35460442304611206,
-0.23089708387851715,
0.9146273732185364,
0.1390431672334671,
0.5617209076881409,
-0.675226628780365,
0.876581072807312,
-0.5496929883956909,
0.22948843240737915,
-0.08251799643039703,
-0.4997999668121338,
-0.06755208224058151,
0.1017322689294815,
0.13022856414318085,
-0.3607029616832733,
0.8443886637687683,
0.5397595167160034,
-0.22221331298351288,
-0.030278310179710388,
0.31795641779899597,
-0.13028910756111145,
0.4750920832157135,
0.6730214953422546,
0.6549403667449951,
-0.2843312919139862,
0.16646815836429596,
-0.46290960907936096,
-0.06642552465200424,
-0.38682252168655396,
-0.8848639130592346,
-0.7121111750602722,
-0.4883856177330017,
-0.4252815544605255,
-0.21282115578651428,
0.12805089354515076,
0.8371958136558533,
0.6175875663757324,
-0.8056958913803101,
-0.10207775980234146,
-0.23220005631446838,
-0.36495304107666016,
0.0024273365270346403,
-0.09459707140922546,
0.1948777735233307,
-0.335316002368927,
-0.5048157572746277,
0.37843427062034607,
0.6085909605026245,
-0.2521650791168213,
-0.10020064562559128,
-0.13110147416591644,
0.048050571233034134,
-0.04771021008491516,
0.4706980586051941,
0.2812986671924591,
-0.6735650897026062,
0.09894414246082306,
-0.26534175872802734,
-0.31979626417160034,
-0.03015635907649994,
0.9749969840049744,
-0.6337096691131592,
0.4330611526966095,
0.67811119556427,
0.34489092230796814,
0.5938116908073425,
0.2933642566204071,
0.7422990202903748,
-0.6119087934494019,
0.003677142783999443,
0.5267145037651062,
0.5962071418762207,
0.2880544662475586,
-0.4917125403881073,
0.26846379041671753,
-0.3091900646686554,
-0.6394630670547485,
-0.7506009936332703,
0.2868715524673462,
-0.9105042815208435,
-0.14938731491565704,
0.8803567290306091,
-0.16280438005924225,
-0.20898453891277313,
-0.45469003915786743,
-0.09406978636980057,
0.4884141981601715,
-0.23057867586612701,
0.5518653392791748,
0.20832166075706482,
-0.4374094605445862,
0.029407082125544548,
-0.5690515041351318,
0.6712228655815125,
0.3996438682079315,
-1.0315797328948975,
0.06532293558120728,
0.48528850078582764,
0.16336849331855774,
0.15518465638160706,
1.0389559268951416,
-0.1023029014468193,
0.632707953453064,
-0.14484882354736328,
0.1531292349100113,
-0.005816874094307423,
-0.24184036254882812,
-0.2337052971124649,
0.14337676763534546,
-0.033819299191236496,
0.0744757354259491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02719v1 | Boosting Biomedical Concept Extraction by Rule-Based Data Augmentation | 2024-07-03T00:00:21 | 2024-07-03T00:00:21 | Qiwei Shao, Fengran Mo, Jian-Yun Nie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level biomedical concept extraction is the task of identifying
biomedical concepts mentioned in a given document. Recent advancements have
adapted pre-trained language models for this task. However, the scarcity of
domain-specific data and the deviation of concepts from their canonical names
often hinder these models' effectiveness. To tackle this issue, we employ
MetaMapLite, an existing rule-based concept mapping system, to generate
additional pseudo-annotated data from PubMed and PMC. The annotated data are
used to augment the limited training data. Through extensive experiments, this
study demonstrates the utility of a manually crafted concept mapping tool for
training a better concept extraction model. | [
-0.23797890543937683,
-0.6286457777023315,
0.7189735770225525,
-0.3198312819004059,
-0.6178386807441711,
0.15291443467140198,
0.16854815185070038,
-0.4546547830104828,
0.49758684635162354,
0.356975793838501,
-0.6668735146522522,
-0.5989721417427063,
-0.6567047238349915,
0.27061817049980164,
-0.145720437169075,
1.071185827255249,
0.1112249493598938,
0.09684938937425613,
-0.7315062880516052,
0.02887788601219654,
-0.4107678234577179,
-0.45966124534606934,
-0.029739096760749817,
-0.5047235488891602,
0.3386843800544739,
0.33285751938819885,
0.5066383481025696,
0.8802585601806641,
0.8740020394325256,
0.16864575445652008,
-0.09105940163135529,
0.6072598695755005,
-0.325531929731369,
-0.16832804679870605,
-0.3746613562107086,
-0.31595322489738464,
-0.9163212776184082,
0.3471485674381256,
0.29100775718688965,
0.873542070388794,
-0.04265659675002098,
0.09983813017606735,
-0.30469590425491333,
0.4575445353984833,
-0.5497385263442993,
0.35346442461013794,
-0.2862092852592468,
0.08706345409154892,
-0.37187403440475464,
-0.6533161401748657,
-0.08334436267614365,
-0.3653174340724945,
0.4520890712738037,
-0.8306746482849121,
0.3830348253250122,
-0.29621052742004395,
1.0296965837478638,
0.2037946581840515,
-0.0866338238120079,
-0.3540131151676178,
-0.48654642701148987,
0.2433842122554779,
-0.815073549747467,
0.2949158847332001,
0.4062490463256836,
0.014294711872935295,
-0.0011199712753295898,
-0.829865038394928,
-0.4190521836280823,
-0.004834375809878111,
-0.43191513419151306,
0.19004671275615692,
0.15856428444385529,
0.11765136569738388,
0.27814096212387085,
0.28910818696022034,
-0.5392047762870789,
-0.38536104559898376,
-0.5653888583183289,
-0.1241375282406807,
0.6336967349052429,
0.08256684988737106,
0.4536890685558319,
-0.4414813816547394,
-0.0793842300772667,
-0.08577673882246017,
-0.9445708394050598,
-0.317151814699173,
-0.19717919826507568,
0.39540281891822815,
0.2803005874156952,
0.7408010959625244,
-0.33442097902297974,
0.5722829699516296,
0.051550496369600296,
-0.340442031621933,
0.9470943808555603,
-0.6717568635940552,
-0.09927534312009811,
0.13668495416641235,
0.5792247653007507,
0.19893282651901245,
-0.14498038589954376,
-0.36348190903663635,
0.09896856546401978,
-0.21935822069644928,
0.36288920044898987,
-0.9754825234413147,
-0.4600660800933838,
0.26003360748291016,
-0.5172022581100464,
-0.32767757773399353,
0.3201161026954651,
-0.8325206637382507,
-0.3804132640361786,
-0.23654621839523315,
0.5778403282165527,
-0.5400928258895874,
-0.38122817873954773,
0.17632544040679932,
-0.5060065388679504,
0.016663596034049988,
0.27004989981651306,
-0.6056426167488098,
-0.1551230251789093,
0.7434568405151367,
1.0832970142364502,
-0.301351934671402,
0.048467569053173065,
-0.019697707146406174,
0.3582800328731537,
-0.43653830885887146,
0.8745466470718384,
-0.8378815650939941,
-0.8089117407798767,
-0.3629976809024811,
0.19187067449092865,
-0.09545392543077469,
-0.6247766017913818,
0.6560801267623901,
-0.24650558829307556,
0.18268238008022308,
-0.3603992760181427,
-0.8063809275627136,
-0.06125950068235397,
-0.129020094871521,
-0.47662580013275146,
0.7101051807403564,
0.15624769032001495,
-0.9053479433059692,
0.5858168005943298,
-1.0668433904647827,
-0.6405171155929565,
0.4655684530735016,
-0.1742905080318451,
-0.3656224310398102,
0.25368112325668335,
0.08252865076065063,
0.4720761775970459,
-0.1564348340034485,
0.29595834016799927,
-0.3339096009731293,
-0.006240664981305599,
0.2450494021177292,
0.30894848704338074,
0.609499990940094,
0.2884124219417572,
-0.0810510516166687,
-0.07761881500482559,
-0.7910474538803101,
-0.19276964664459229,
0.13042525947093964,
-0.13193602859973907,
-0.7292174100875854,
0.262666791677475,
-0.4181200861930847,
0.3773111402988434,
0.06399332731962204,
-0.7200919985771179,
0.5275342464447021,
-0.4768863916397095,
0.40030622482299805,
0.2856684625148773,
0.3079165816307068,
0.3975564241409302,
-0.3403165638446808,
0.3769751191139221,
-0.19991691410541534,
-0.0730094313621521,
-0.19713038206100464,
-0.5616301894187927,
-0.3576989471912384,
-0.7802085876464844,
0.57247394323349,
0.388452410697937,
-0.7132675051689148,
0.5967655181884766,
-0.5194287300109863,
-0.6327719688415527,
-0.8163967132568359,
-0.0021636909805238247,
0.03405070677399635,
0.7878642678260803,
0.7132587432861328,
-0.35328859090805054,
-0.6804364323616028,
-0.7871177792549133,
0.17770831286907196,
0.0847184881567955,
0.02529696188867092,
0.40743476152420044,
0.43306073546409607,
-0.6547779440879822,
1.1523007154464722,
-0.8487957119941711,
-0.40985816717147827,
-0.08329911530017853,
0.41834720969200134,
0.27241528034210205,
0.5337249040603638,
0.2961083650588989,
-0.8254871368408203,
-0.03294248878955841,
-0.02687997929751873,
-0.8918590545654297,
-0.568873405456543,
-0.15965865552425385,
-0.1608041375875473,
-0.5261160135269165,
0.6934165954589844,
-0.7297332882881165,
0.36017584800720215,
-0.02136576920747757,
-0.10752318799495697,
0.4341418743133545,
-0.2963102161884308,
0.07990234345197678,
-1.0451698303222656,
0.40667858719825745,
-0.032483212649822235,
-0.33591508865356445,
-0.7466832995414734,
0.05184200033545494,
0.3097989857196808,
-0.02927207574248314,
-0.3066118359565735,
0.36559122800827026,
-0.34463879466056824,
0.14095573127269745,
-0.6485857963562012,
-0.02221180871129036,
0.20702293515205383,
-0.1480177342891693,
0.6052682995796204,
0.7228283286094666,
0.35388579964637756,
-0.6121615171432495,
0.1833062618970871,
0.6231101751327515,
0.05972064286470413,
0.37310469150543213,
-0.6757632493972778,
0.07464159280061722,
-0.06700064241886139,
0.36741676926612854,
-0.7618852257728577,
-0.11514735221862793,
0.32740887999534607,
-0.4469110071659088,
0.3813954293727875,
-0.01731470599770546,
-0.5077819228172302,
-0.5532300472259521,
-0.19695231318473816,
0.07307639718055725,
0.3070472776889801,
-0.34009164571762085,
0.44668203592300415,
0.7608423233032227,
-0.38625940680503845,
-0.33296623826026917,
-0.44717803597450256,
0.07992909103631973,
-0.12832143902778625,
-0.15567134320735931,
0.7347521781921387,
-0.14277255535125732,
0.08287546038627625,
0.14082284271717072,
-0.09951721131801605,
-0.08412696421146393,
0.1046665832400322,
0.5283580422401428,
0.46402493119239807,
-0.05279027670621872,
0.4439477026462555,
0.20019754767417908,
-0.10935115814208984,
0.20851846039295197,
-0.17397035658359528,
0.3032896816730499,
0.4006781280040741,
-0.1682041585445404,
-0.28741753101348877,
0.2360820472240448,
0.4000949263572693,
-0.4351624548435211,
0.5077357292175293,
0.46214228868484497,
-0.40428200364112854,
0.019665176048874855,
-0.1503998339176178,
-0.2789560556411743,
-0.3773898184299469,
0.44185784459114075,
-0.3337101340293884,
-0.3394675850868225,
0.028314169496297836,
-0.5755635499954224,
-0.026598742231726646,
0.8124834895133972,
0.6274102926254272,
-0.37611979246139526,
0.6147487759590149,
0.7438939809799194,
0.3421937823295593,
0.2357746958732605,
-0.3499109447002411,
0.04129180312156677,
-0.7912637591362,
-0.4033655822277069,
-0.45550787448883057,
-0.06960795074701309,
-0.36942264437675476,
-0.773130476474762,
0.377577006816864,
-0.10844095051288605,
0.5585875511169434,
0.49931657314300537,
-0.5517423748970032,
0.2840024530887604,
0.2906227111816406,
0.337009072303772,
0.21338269114494324,
-0.3510533273220062,
-0.3702232837677002,
0.02632484957575798,
-0.7165306806564331,
-0.38287922739982605,
1.4777389764785767,
0.25255629420280457,
0.3943832516670227,
-0.18366137146949768,
0.8718492388725281,
0.4430924355983734,
0.5199100375175476,
-0.6683782935142517,
0.2785627841949463,
-0.03936577960848808,
-0.8210718035697937,
-0.012815138325095177,
-0.494895339012146,
-0.7044170498847961,
-0.023786403238773346,
-0.7274192571640015,
-0.23243211209774017,
0.6825661659240723,
-0.05263981223106384,
-0.4289112687110901,
-0.10929850488901138,
-0.5889489650726318,
0.6665515303611755,
-0.05544836446642876,
-0.13162077963352203,
-0.05985581874847412,
-0.6235578060150146,
0.22133980691432953,
-0.7332431077957153,
0.3179713189601898,
-0.027848130092024803,
-0.13424360752105713,
0.8329662084579468,
-0.6879901885986328,
0.5702754259109497,
-0.03849949687719345,
-0.040208786725997925,
0.2109404057264328,
-0.2602637708187103,
0.2294514775276184,
-0.006384272128343582,
0.15088829398155212,
0.17675679922103882,
0.1715061217546463,
-0.35096970200538635,
-0.21532487869262695,
0.1693067103624344,
-0.5609336495399475,
-0.32045599818229675,
-0.45117348432540894,
-0.5072246789932251,
-0.3195593059062958,
0.17787428200244904,
0.36213231086730957,
0.1533139944076538,
-0.27341821789741516,
0.2757561206817627,
0.6642692685127258,
-0.14805130660533905,
0.32920941710472107,
0.7329248189926147,
0.13712483644485474,
-0.32570019364356995,
1.0380208492279053,
0.11242936551570892,
0.03614790365099907,
0.5559089779853821,
0.22067366540431976,
-0.43404895067214966,
-0.7079668641090393,
-0.13579992949962616,
0.19980423152446747,
-0.3487769663333893,
-0.4109499752521515,
-0.9351486563682556,
-0.2421325147151947,
-0.5298233032226562,
0.12758809328079224,
-0.2025485336780548,
-0.5627601742744446,
-0.41649144887924194,
-0.3183669149875641,
0.3298893868923187,
0.42452773451805115,
-0.5923006534576416,
0.3452169895172119,
-0.966161847114563,
0.5647145509719849,
0.20359402894973755,
-0.09920841455459595,
-0.6348427534103394,
-0.41807660460472107,
-0.3178010880947113,
0.036905813962221146,
-0.10032282024621964,
-1.089097499847412,
0.38113459944725037,
0.5573169589042664,
0.7251704931259155,
0.6589264869689941,
-0.0926128700375557,
0.615643322467804,
-0.6176669001579285,
0.30126458406448364,
0.08170154690742493,
-0.6856468319892883,
0.878563642501831,
-0.19922856986522675,
-0.0631643608212471,
0.6001254916191101,
0.575753927230835,
-0.20708931982517242,
-0.10567741841077805,
-0.9217527508735657,
-0.7161524295806885,
0.5192201733589172,
0.10067661851644516,
-0.03431122004985809,
-0.1607060432434082,
0.5958094596862793,
0.4635578989982605,
0.40787625312805176,
-0.27165859937667847,
-0.09849409013986588,
-0.39810091257095337,
-0.30801552534103394,
-0.2751311659812927,
-0.17220215499401093,
-0.2132868468761444,
-0.391262948513031,
0.5923380851745605,
-0.15400715172290802,
0.18907059729099274,
0.4365956783294678,
-0.5703463554382324,
-0.10732588171958923,
-0.05781180039048195,
0.6814079284667969,
0.7104625105857849,
-0.68375164270401,
0.0344117246568203,
-0.08611615002155304,
-0.7663766741752625,
-0.007083219010382891,
0.5616315007209778,
-0.2188858985900879,
0.17444154620170593,
0.5984975695610046,
0.24023081362247467,
-0.10639376193284988,
-0.8554948568344116,
0.5004413723945618,
0.13030728697776794,
-0.4316544830799103,
0.4762795567512512,
0.16550599038600922,
0.0034145982936024666,
0.09072940051555634,
0.4481303095817566,
0.08150338381528854,
0.4711950123310089,
-0.4462338984012604,
0.8023278117179871,
0.4981139302253723,
-0.14210094511508942,
-0.3359527885913849,
0.3949923813343048,
0.3815329372882843,
0.01438977662473917,
-0.0898377075791359,
-0.12685036659240723,
-0.3113778233528137,
0.3522818386554718,
0.5744535326957703,
0.4879189133644104,
-0.17206259071826935,
0.41787171363830566,
0.42894092202186584,
0.19511419534683228,
0.06758632510900497,
0.03551154211163521,
-0.08446397632360458,
-0.48248159885406494,
-0.6490219831466675,
-0.538963258266449,
-0.27421799302101135,
0.059537988156080246,
-0.47439536452293396,
0.24174381792545319,
-0.399359792470932,
-0.33489635586738586,
0.5438835024833679,
0.2812628149986267,
-0.45823970437049866,
0.34341683983802795,
0.20009154081344604,
0.8579554557800293,
-1.1176658868789673,
1.0407065153121948,
0.8073430061340332,
-0.6408327221870422,
-0.36090826988220215,
-0.2961742579936981,
0.015499036759138107,
-0.6563512682914734,
0.6512525081634521,
-0.18389885127544403,
0.25153374671936035,
-0.11455301195383072,
-0.31386175751686096,
-0.6919965147972107,
1.0213587284088135,
-0.05580052733421326,
-0.4753725230693817,
-0.15910358726978302,
0.1146034225821495,
0.6508233547210693,
-0.7250913977622986,
0.2857438325881958,
0.7004439830780029,
0.3773605227470398,
0.2959161102771759,
-0.6946669816970825,
0.03158755600452423,
-0.37088993191719055,
-0.4775157868862152,
-0.006830661557614803,
-0.0033743444364517927,
0.7504566311836243,
-0.1994413584470749,
-0.11468852311372757,
-0.18740743398666382,
0.3638640344142914,
0.07253990322351456,
0.4682169556617737,
0.1993263214826584,
0.6531506776809692,
0.9916233420372009,
-0.09664925187826157,
0.7969306707382202,
-0.14343154430389404,
0.42334580421447754,
1.0975842475891113,
-0.2903442084789276,
0.6195504665374756,
0.24740485846996307,
-0.13586361706256866,
0.4766150414943695,
0.9995580911636353,
-0.11518102139234543,
0.9001368284225464,
-0.13578125834465027,
0.20106874406337738,
-0.21761314570903778,
-0.2865385115146637,
-0.77988201379776,
0.3621060848236084,
0.7440221905708313,
-0.6201910972595215,
-0.13078689575195312,
-0.01112055592238903,
-0.01203268300741911,
-0.4096405506134033,
-0.261823445558548,
1.2410738468170166,
-0.030376901850104332,
-0.03427185118198395,
0.5115339159965515,
-0.11510098725557327,
0.37470343708992004,
-0.5050601959228516,
-0.21618512272834778,
-0.17159198224544525,
-0.08960403501987457,
-0.21503804624080658,
-0.39654552936553955,
0.258922815322876,
-0.15432651340961456,
-0.22315692901611328,
0.023025577887892723,
0.9917178153991699,
-0.4271450638771057,
-0.530107319355011,
-0.051894839853048325,
0.9823746681213379,
0.023221459239721298,
0.024425296112895012,
-0.849807858467102,
-0.3966442048549652,
-0.17471516132354736,
0.3546789884567261,
0.06799931079149246,
0.4788548946380615,
0.27117571234703064,
0.44375529885292053,
0.8579355478286743,
0.5368176102638245,
-0.25291717052459717,
-0.26690128445625305,
0.8838065266609192,
-0.5477319955825806,
-0.45230504870414734,
-0.8060810565948486,
0.1444975584745407,
-0.37459811568260193,
-0.058663856238126755,
0.4997009038925171,
0.5071583986282349,
0.33245351910591125,
-0.11485371738672256,
0.7876280546188354,
0.007173181977123022,
0.8576599955558777,
-0.3246443271636963,
0.7901123762130737,
-0.5885942578315735,
0.09719322621822357,
-0.5939708948135376,
-0.832255482673645,
-0.2651838958263397,
0.6052207350730896,
-0.3058200776576996,
-0.2084118127822876,
0.8859307169914246,
0.5799288153648376,
-0.24499405920505524,
0.027257906273007393,
-0.01216034684330225,
0.09781123697757721,
0.34792816638946533,
0.25813961029052734,
0.5437420010566711,
-0.08033324033021927,
0.130767822265625,
-0.1917428970336914,
-0.4624195694923401,
-0.566506028175354,
-0.8863267302513123,
-0.7391489744186401,
-0.5299357175827026,
-0.5235973596572876,
-0.26631662249565125,
0.14581115543842316,
0.9637271761894226,
1.2757189273834229,
-0.7240508794784546,
0.3201408088207245,
-0.05599747225642204,
-0.010950618423521519,
-0.22212040424346924,
-0.13466010987758636,
0.7306411862373352,
-0.3603651523590088,
-0.3415023684501648,
0.6158741116523743,
0.3545328676700592,
0.3088206946849823,
0.2971508502960205,
0.07261763513088226,
-0.578444242477417,
0.31599658727645874,
0.4334048628807068,
0.340466171503067,
-0.06748905032873154,
0.13145823776721954,
-0.11458446830511093,
-0.15957805514335632,
0.2091066837310791,
0.9368506073951721,
-0.8905758261680603,
0.6512088775634766,
0.4053662121295929,
0.7956743836402893,
0.3084210455417633,
0.3886280953884125,
0.6051740646362305,
-0.7658403515815735,
0.13137061893939972,
0.12667198479175568,
0.20386500656604767,
0.3335351347923279,
-0.2714990973472595,
0.7588329911231995,
0.7835515141487122,
-0.02958703599870205,
-0.7244365811347961,
-0.23604395985603333,
-0.910186767578125,
-0.597987949848175,
1.0051437616348267,
0.09674951434135437,
-0.2212238311767578,
-0.14887741208076477,
-0.30777278542518616,
0.27122947573661804,
-0.24684476852416992,
0.6902568936347961,
0.438699871301651,
-0.0701027512550354,
0.10783714056015015,
-0.5714750289916992,
0.878044605255127,
0.09256244450807571,
-1.2863022089004517,
-0.07394258677959442,
0.3688579797744751,
0.23970527946949005,
0.45148688554763794,
0.6685029864311218,
-0.2739063501358032,
0.38688725233078003,
-0.3338952958583832,
0.12423032522201538,
-0.2670305073261261,
-0.3299287259578705,
-0.031645771116018295,
0.13185453414916992,
-0.22356745600700378,
-0.31732377409935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02694v1 | LLM-Select: Feature Selection with Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T22:23:40 | 2024-07-02T22:23:40 | Daniel P. Jeong, Zachary C. Lipton, Pradeep Ravikumar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | In this paper, we demonstrate a surprising capability of large language
models (LLMs): given only input feature names and a description of a prediction
task, they are capable of selecting the most predictive features, with
performance rivaling the standard tools of data science. Remarkably, these
models exhibit this capacity across various query mechanisms. For example, we
zero-shot prompt an LLM to output a numerical importance score for a feature
(e.g., "blood pressure") in predicting an outcome of interest (e.g., "heart
failure"), with no additional context. In particular, we find that the latest
models, such as GPT-4, can consistently identify the most predictive features
regardless of the query mechanism and across various prompting strategies. We
illustrate these findings through extensive experiments on real-world data,
where we show that LLM-based feature selection consistently achieves strong
performance competitive with data-driven methods such as the LASSO, despite
never having looked at the downstream training data. Our findings suggest that
LLMs may be useful not only for selecting the best features for training but
also for deciding which features to collect in the first place. This could
potentially benefit practitioners in domains like healthcare, where collecting
high-quality data comes at a high cost. | [
-0.49533534049987793,
-0.501701831817627,
0.9077896475791931,
-0.004939024802297354,
-0.27750059962272644,
-0.08320076018571854,
-0.24493621289730072,
-0.6895867586135864,
0.33872970938682556,
0.6710962057113647,
-0.3956761658191681,
-0.478483647108078,
-0.7973538041114807,
0.08125382661819458,
-0.6294800043106079,
1.0512980222702026,
0.10416856408119202,
0.22731871902942657,
-0.23997697234153748,
-0.09315985441207886,
-0.18850749731063843,
-0.6390814185142517,
-0.426042377948761,
-0.4907594621181488,
0.8616840839385986,
0.0560339130461216,
0.6613890528678894,
0.7656980156898499,
0.6599534153938293,
0.11456513404846191,
-0.17424283921718597,
-0.10103312879800797,
-0.44363686442375183,
0.4419761598110199,
0.16143092513084412,
-0.490005761384964,
-0.3742803633213043,
0.052715715020895004,
0.5976857542991638,
0.8192110061645508,
0.33666080236434937,
0.16559985280036926,
0.09049734473228455,
0.7128310203552246,
-0.3829455077648163,
0.1438661366701126,
-0.8013163805007935,
0.03787083551287651,
-0.20512227714061737,
0.001867547631263733,
-0.06344097852706909,
-0.26236796379089355,
0.34152668714523315,
-0.15716929733753204,
0.2722785472869873,
0.09737004339694977,
0.6998805999755859,
0.44006386399269104,
-0.285075306892395,
-0.09415668249130249,
-0.6790921688079834,
0.6750173568725586,
-0.2821252942085266,
0.5278487801551819,
0.5463676452636719,
0.4078732430934906,
0.02440861612558365,
-0.41123536229133606,
-0.14126217365264893,
-0.5273299217224121,
0.24582840502262115,
0.023161523044109344,
0.08958359807729721,
0.1160791665315628,
0.2635195851325989,
0.39011844992637634,
-0.5452407598495483,
0.41838693618774414,
-0.288318395614624,
-0.2692503333091736,
0.5833193063735962,
0.05451995134353638,
0.025742607191205025,
0.017438307404518127,
-0.1362854689359665,
0.15128226578235626,
-1.0710198879241943,
-0.08691327273845673,
-0.05100293830037117,
0.340756356716156,
-0.035366687923669815,
0.6388764381408691,
-0.2520350217819214,
0.6489492058753967,
-0.38315844535827637,
-0.17850811779499054,
0.09248270094394684,
0.05322039872407913,
-0.22495578229427338,
-0.06484676152467728,
0.7065998911857605,
-0.14721643924713135,
0.12932942807674408,
-0.10530165582895279,
-0.2609916627407074,
0.005318029783666134,
-0.03385453298687935,
-0.7111964225769043,
-0.28283655643463135,
0.33899742364883423,
-0.3241882920265198,
-0.46996840834617615,
-0.18441607058048248,
-0.6133978366851807,
-0.39348268508911133,
-0.034608375281095505,
0.035313449800014496,
-0.0555819496512413,
-0.1417212039232254,
-0.17660772800445557,
0.12557998299598694,
-0.007683001924306154,
0.45847439765930176,
-1.024804949760437,
0.10180585086345673,
0.5967917442321777,
0.8751261830329895,
-0.5146640539169312,
-0.2723642885684967,
-0.6404643058776855,
-0.1783815622329712,
-0.46984946727752686,
0.7819256782531738,
-0.8885456323623657,
-0.3022337853908539,
0.01368865929543972,
-0.2296493947505951,
0.20567935705184937,
-0.7081441283226013,
0.31649303436279297,
-0.47477924823760986,
-0.06171346455812454,
-0.4169650077819824,
-0.34704169631004333,
-0.0750560611486435,
0.19574233889579773,
-0.9286004304885864,
0.9528210759162903,
0.26959311962127686,
-0.5129055976867676,
0.7661904096603394,
-0.32655802369117737,
-0.37258180975914,
0.07597914338111877,
-0.44820094108581543,
-0.6780549883842468,
0.31208276748657227,
0.22899042069911957,
0.6825240850448608,
-0.6287649869918823,
0.22394965589046478,
-0.7854291200637817,
-0.3115016222000122,
0.4672691822052002,
-0.46640926599502563,
0.2590464651584625,
0.18582649528980255,
-0.08872640877962112,
0.08787509799003601,
-0.654012143611908,
-0.1818176507949829,
0.2007516622543335,
-0.54653400182724,
0.03632267564535141,
-0.002972718793898821,
-0.08900706470012665,
0.3149949312210083,
0.1562216430902481,
-0.29981809854507446,
0.10320506244897842,
-0.04762660339474678,
0.5459780693054199,
0.3746010363101959,
-0.19382250308990479,
0.3548036515712738,
-0.3254598081111908,
0.824493944644928,
-0.2832471430301666,
0.17077039182186127,
-0.001958116888999939,
-0.4491061866283417,
-0.46433284878730774,
-0.5590657591819763,
0.5096220970153809,
0.3977782130241394,
-0.5047794580459595,
0.28377339243888855,
-0.1452448070049286,
-0.4025440514087677,
-0.5817813873291016,
0.15669932961463928,
0.22498735785484314,
0.3306330442428589,
0.15449626743793488,
0.008716949261724949,
-0.2885608971118927,
-0.768618643283844,
0.17701923847198486,
-0.2981371581554413,
-0.05709591135382652,
0.5481276512145996,
0.15447461605072021,
-0.03213939815759659,
0.6079220175743103,
-0.5998737215995789,
-0.1352681666612625,
-0.5948929786682129,
-0.2637476921081543,
0.19372352957725525,
-0.05775511637330055,
0.5394109487533569,
-0.7894818782806396,
-0.26519885659217834,
0.013916149735450745,
-0.7152118682861328,
-0.2934408187866211,
0.08938712626695633,
-0.05030129477381706,
0.09462406486272812,
0.1811201125383377,
-0.6757764220237732,
0.15513531863689423,
0.6138859987258911,
0.12700431048870087,
0.5216507911682129,
-0.20348922908306122,
-0.10081334412097931,
-0.7956126928329468,
0.13722407817840576,
0.17849504947662354,
-0.251880407333374,
-0.4019187092781067,
-0.2618692219257355,
0.2164241075515747,
-0.2205417901277542,
-0.32826876640319824,
0.8479185700416565,
-0.5195830464363098,
-0.33462920784950256,
-0.2767193913459778,
-0.006919005420058966,
-0.15615667402744293,
0.21497094631195068,
0.12837976217269897,
0.6824605464935303,
0.7865453362464905,
-0.4724029004573822,
0.27174803614616394,
0.17337818443775177,
-0.23562456667423248,
0.010277533903717995,
-0.40022969245910645,
-0.00012216409959364682,
0.12922303378582,
0.00126479787286371,
-0.8758798837661743,
-0.49151700735092163,
-0.29972392320632935,
-0.4580000340938568,
0.41787952184677124,
-0.36252665519714355,
-0.4174251854419708,
-0.623306930065155,
-0.3099544942378998,
-0.057910822331905365,
0.5839787125587463,
-0.28323283791542053,
0.2362210899591446,
0.6688892245292664,
-0.3582615852355957,
-0.5371781587600708,
-0.6946693658828735,
0.08704492449760437,
-0.3697417080402374,
-0.10348972678184509,
0.003841197583824396,
0.03128453716635704,
0.09169122576713562,
-0.16969789564609528,
-0.1858820766210556,
0.06037779524922371,
0.5175192952156067,
0.27946019172668457,
0.6274063587188721,
-0.05589461326599121,
0.27097371220588684,
0.06824002414941788,
-0.19568215310573578,
-0.04472259059548378,
-0.19732992351055145,
0.47216498851776123,
0.2006460428237915,
-0.49033287167549133,
-0.027498241513967514,
0.2321290671825409,
0.6839800477027893,
-0.35419654846191406,
0.3637189269065857,
0.3787423074245453,
-0.28415876626968384,
-0.25516772270202637,
-0.76841139793396,
-0.39067524671554565,
-0.3598369061946869,
0.785723090171814,
-0.20751307904720306,
-1.3627467155456543,
0.5034854412078857,
-0.05199187248945236,
-0.16444969177246094,
0.2611813247203827,
0.557031512260437,
-0.038296375423669815,
1.175930142402649,
0.6099118590354919,
-0.5028752684593201,
0.5820813179016113,
-0.07586421072483063,
0.14467637240886688,
-0.799626886844635,
-0.062427084892988205,
-0.5544004440307617,
-0.2701253294944763,
-0.746017336845398,
-0.17513005435466766,
0.7874703407287598,
0.1509934663772583,
0.048141591250896454,
-0.05054645612835884,
-0.48360908031463623,
0.30159687995910645,
0.34298476576805115,
0.08709698170423508,
0.07945509999990463,
0.08039887994527817,
-0.2764381766319275,
0.01904173381626606,
-0.4897160232067108,
-0.42809897661209106,
1.280898928642273,
0.3862650692462921,
0.7229064702987671,
-0.17626866698265076,
0.7103510499000549,
-0.04566749930381775,
0.3940432071685791,
-0.876375675201416,
0.6311455368995667,
-0.3221456706523895,
-0.3992610573768616,
-0.43871721625328064,
-0.3802565634250641,
-1.0365532636642456,
0.3174353837966919,
-0.7049380540847778,
-0.5489344596862793,
-0.19142122566699982,
0.3086637556552887,
-0.5476084351539612,
0.18147027492523193,
-0.4445309638977051,
0.5850613117218018,
-0.5110390782356262,
-0.32291537523269653,
0.022227413952350616,
-0.39933493733406067,
0.14145204424858093,
-0.46193093061447144,
-0.0377369150519371,
-0.4874575436115265,
-0.2726411521434784,
0.37238919734954834,
-0.029478780925273895,
0.617868185043335,
-0.013534554280340672,
0.3435739278793335,
-0.13901770114898682,
0.1625029295682907,
0.2709228992462158,
0.07507576048374176,
-0.2675354480743408,
0.2264845222234726,
-0.17368188500404358,
-0.14402031898498535,
-0.6569830775260925,
0.7167667150497437,
-0.6228681802749634,
-0.7505263686180115,
-0.2336401641368866,
-0.39898666739463806,
-0.42837297916412354,
0.16439282894134521,
0.20640932023525238,
0.3359329402446747,
-0.18246114253997803,
0.16455680131912231,
0.6015390753746033,
-0.1938243806362152,
0.3751122057437897,
0.32229167222976685,
-0.34573227167129517,
-0.4715922772884369,
0.8379716873168945,
0.432102769613266,
0.3635339140892029,
0.4718652665615082,
0.3488330841064453,
-0.35293686389923096,
-1.2544344663619995,
-0.4359956979751587,
0.442164808511734,
-0.44493818283081055,
-0.19386737048625946,
-0.8126416802406311,
-0.5137968063354492,
-0.07232868671417236,
-0.08017126470804214,
-0.07691624015569687,
-0.4370212256908417,
-0.27937087416648865,
-0.3438580334186554,
0.3559589684009552,
0.7648378610610962,
0.19186636805534363,
-0.031675007194280624,
-0.8616335988044739,
0.07107376307249069,
0.40181267261505127,
0.2517259120941162,
-0.20835022628307343,
-0.35501664876937866,
-0.286874383687973,
-0.47148120403289795,
-0.31484490633010864,
-0.7567484974861145,
0.6510404944419861,
0.049447618424892426,
0.7803629040718079,
0.2496769279241562,
-0.13889478147029877,
0.19337555766105652,
-0.4716951251029968,
0.749711275100708,
0.06219413876533508,
-0.37606528401374817,
0.6925936341285706,
-0.3608081638813019,
0.2735450267791748,
0.4372648298740387,
0.5870794653892517,
-0.2944281995296478,
-0.4247165620326996,
-0.4988110065460205,
-0.781682014465332,
0.513197124004364,
0.04420262202620506,
-0.0051802597008645535,
-0.09351978451013565,
0.37363201379776,
0.24877993762493134,
0.4691283404827118,
-0.5742413997650146,
-0.04970160126686096,
0.19901059567928314,
-0.26980528235435486,
-0.047304026782512665,
-0.4609205722808838,
0.06560426950454712,
-0.02257711812853813,
0.41671523451805115,
-0.36601877212524414,
0.23695039749145508,
0.11758378148078918,
-0.026399819180369377,
-0.09625538438558578,
0.26192328333854675,
0.45687705278396606,
0.7158746719360352,
-0.14354054629802704,
0.05409640073776245,
0.3169459402561188,
-0.5456133484840393,
-0.15655072033405304,
0.3847593367099762,
-0.19345475733280182,
-0.13749994337558746,
0.4557555019855499,
1.0063450336456299,
0.22436851263046265,
-0.6484695076942444,
0.44535666704177856,
0.22949469089508057,
-0.06816446781158447,
-0.16108067333698273,
0.2670730948448181,
0.0659133791923523,
0.42810848355293274,
0.3529615104198456,
-0.14986951649188995,
0.20935989916324615,
-0.3810509145259857,
0.22470054030418396,
0.6602101922035217,
-0.5244744420051575,
-0.3061959743499756,
0.7634446620941162,
0.1658073365688324,
-0.03258732333779335,
0.3750830292701721,
0.042069416493177414,
-0.5146392583847046,
0.6190388798713684,
0.29054051637649536,
0.8532599210739136,
-0.09607690572738647,
0.15018241107463837,
0.13912372291088104,
0.03596349060535431,
-0.35344573855400085,
0.3966597616672516,
0.10487911105155945,
-0.6722234487533569,
-0.5202770233154297,
-0.8051801323890686,
-0.5745043754577637,
0.3858571946620941,
-0.5053773522377014,
0.3920060098171234,
-0.48047390580177307,
-0.2874392867088318,
0.043686944991350174,
0.12895408272743225,
-0.7632853388786316,
0.1609416902065277,
0.582755446434021,
0.7809145450592041,
-0.8496162295341492,
1.1448994874954224,
0.5911139249801636,
-0.305276483297348,
-0.7012655138969421,
-0.0011215473059564829,
0.2946252226829529,
-1.0883111953735352,
0.6873687505722046,
0.11458621174097061,
0.22211401164531708,
-0.22114816308021545,
-0.3653235137462616,
-1.064371109008789,
1.0770025253295898,
0.7134849429130554,
-0.5759516954421997,
-0.17330993711948395,
0.2045375406742096,
0.5115144848823547,
-0.5628783106803894,
0.44332343339920044,
0.6397878527641296,
0.12002474069595337,
0.37377044558525085,
-1.1854993104934692,
0.01112281996756792,
0.10286735743284225,
0.12605324387550354,
0.35320770740509033,
-0.6646254062652588,
0.7448468804359436,
-0.38969165086746216,
0.20130066573619843,
-0.06672380864620209,
0.42255666851997375,
0.5951632857322693,
0.07186102867126465,
0.3411090075969696,
0.3715139627456665,
0.858594536781311,
-0.13769423961639404,
1.2419352531433105,
-0.2992134690284729,
0.2489185929298401,
0.7131916284561157,
-0.5782498717308044,
1.1533658504486084,
0.1645589917898178,
-0.35298967361450195,
-0.08213017135858536,
0.8889014720916748,
-0.035705480724573135,
0.5645129680633545,
0.011671993881464005,
-0.32646775245666504,
-0.4888136684894562,
-0.04811997711658478,
-0.1529199182987213,
0.5095927119255066,
0.4597204029560089,
-0.4925767779350281,
-0.12314625084400177,
0.036196883767843246,
0.01099292654544115,
-0.3537897765636444,
-0.41429421305656433,
0.8157305717468262,
0.30020368099212646,
-0.5207264423370361,
0.656755268573761,
-0.613806962966919,
0.537807822227478,
-0.8265432715415955,
-0.09169799089431763,
-0.19954745471477509,
-0.180325448513031,
-0.11091423779726028,
-0.93355792760849,
0.05014129355549812,
-0.08221815526485443,
-0.19014078378677368,
-0.1970561146736145,
0.7399910688400269,
-0.36720165610313416,
-0.4752447009086609,
0.4276562035083771,
0.6820192933082581,
0.27655351161956787,
-0.3344782590866089,
-0.6824451088905334,
0.19369105994701385,
0.030345769599080086,
-0.31148871779441833,
0.8133851289749146,
0.44993141293525696,
-0.24785083532333374,
0.873512327671051,
0.6828383207321167,
0.8755940794944763,
-0.26670050621032715,
0.1869184821844101,
0.9507101774215698,
-0.8330584764480591,
-0.36137890815734863,
-0.8744180798530579,
0.19300183653831482,
-0.07298173755407333,
-0.09890243411064148,
0.2838576138019562,
0.4309513568878174,
0.6861693263053894,
0.17420463263988495,
1.1468850374221802,
0.42739394307136536,
0.7269692420959473,
-0.6707594990730286,
0.724268913269043,
-0.3988311290740967,
0.3489668369293213,
0.12905487418174744,
-0.9823187589645386,
-0.5385121703147888,
0.2671281695365906,
-0.6288824081420898,
0.19555841386318207,
0.7629029750823975,
0.6692871451377869,
0.08654540777206421,
-0.1639397144317627,
0.8801116347312927,
0.20573866367340088,
0.30788666009902954,
0.47491005063056946,
0.6341413855552673,
0.2086227685213089,
0.4626699984073639,
-0.05382402241230011,
-0.27011868357658386,
-0.4164882302284241,
-0.8276538848876953,
-1.0293335914611816,
-0.4149966239929199,
-0.13406777381896973,
-0.12060050666332245,
-0.1168600469827652,
1.0402958393096924,
0.9078367948532104,
-0.8300553560256958,
0.0005566985928453505,
0.4001367688179016,
0.23631855845451355,
-0.013129138387739658,
-0.08110376447439194,
0.4182955026626587,
-0.34160012006759644,
-0.4981646239757538,
0.3826477527618408,
0.6129382252693176,
0.18133804202079773,
-0.34762611985206604,
0.09403162449598312,
0.2694959044456482,
-0.24521693587303162,
0.5628681778907776,
0.25949826836586,
-0.8406050801277161,
-0.21579571068286896,
0.006740425247699022,
-0.12863393127918243,
0.13915663957595825,
0.8329100012779236,
-0.8643686771392822,
0.20183974504470825,
0.3519403338432312,
0.9040462374687195,
0.6172428131103516,
-0.42993706464767456,
0.4997800886631012,
-0.2960248589515686,
0.024856241419911385,
0.3693748414516449,
0.6506969332695007,
0.4605492353439331,
-0.5564204454421997,
0.44452404975891113,
0.19265994429588318,
-0.7621599435806274,
-0.7539653182029724,
0.2031916379928589,
-0.748917818069458,
-0.10295746475458145,
1.326690673828125,
0.024039428681135178,
-0.26948118209838867,
-0.11399738490581512,
-0.055918361991643906,
-0.08069954067468643,
-0.33981645107269287,
0.7587285041809082,
0.632450520992279,
-0.3874303698539734,
-0.43512362241744995,
-1.178253412246704,
0.6534663438796997,
0.35928982496261597,
-0.7386483550071716,
0.0422271266579628,
0.5622739195823669,
0.4166348874568939,
-0.21762718260288239,
0.5119290947914124,
-0.2182377278804779,
0.12593746185302734,
-0.42997556924819946,
-0.12077860534191132,
-0.10557577759027481,
-0.5046656131744385,
-0.6003208160400391,
0.20200634002685547,
0.5914941430091858,
0.034042175859212875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02678v1 | Reasoning in Large Language Models: A Geometric Perspective | 2024-07-02T21:39:53 | 2024-07-02T21:39:53 | Romain Cosentino, Sarath Shekkizhar | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) for real-world applications
hinges critically on enhancing their reasoning capabilities. In this work, we
explore the reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs) through their
geometrical understanding. We establish a connection between the expressive
power of LLMs and the density of their self-attention graphs. Our analysis
demonstrates that the density of these graphs defines the intrinsic dimension
of the inputs to the MLP blocks. We demonstrate through theoretical analysis
and toy examples that a higher intrinsic dimension implies a greater expressive
capacity of the LLM. We further provide empirical evidence linking this
geometric framework to recent advancements in methods aimed at enhancing the
reasoning capabilities of LLMs. | [
-0.4850512146949768,
-0.86775803565979,
1.195701003074646,
0.22570836544036865,
0.03429659083485603,
-0.048629049211740494,
-0.32770970463752747,
-0.5833399891853333,
0.06499217450618744,
0.6609200835227966,
-0.44117146730422974,
-0.585127592086792,
-0.6189900636672974,
0.06915417313575745,
-0.4299832582473755,
0.35315239429473877,
-0.02596287801861763,
-0.18924084305763245,
-0.31534913182258606,
-0.10023094713687897,
-0.3804813623428345,
-0.7534577250480652,
-0.5239644646644592,
-0.17881432175636292,
0.7507587671279907,
0.1205708310008049,
0.7219994068145752,
0.7922995686531067,
0.6011495590209961,
0.47402703762054443,
-0.08566560596227646,
-0.08195022493600845,
-0.5040535926818848,
0.3263697922229767,
-0.22371438145637512,
-0.424773246049881,
-0.38048234581947327,
-0.08386741578578949,
1.088381290435791,
1.0013777017593384,
0.15433485805988312,
0.03984449431300163,
0.14320147037506104,
0.8020232319831848,
-0.35192808508872986,
0.31833603978157043,
-0.40766090154647827,
0.037746839225292206,
-0.10016516596078873,
0.041223760694265366,
-0.3526458442211151,
-0.3204536736011505,
0.21445739269256592,
-0.5159220099449158,
-0.06238088011741638,
0.08575473725795746,
0.44448116421699524,
0.42899173498153687,
-0.21952952444553375,
-0.2680261731147766,
-0.8552150726318359,
0.6181597113609314,
-0.553356945514679,
0.4778308868408203,
0.27289047837257385,
0.42246612906455994,
-0.2696957290172577,
-0.5869672298431396,
-0.32170289754867554,
-0.28891676664352417,
-0.1566171944141388,
-0.26196208596229553,
-0.13299739360809326,
0.1184380054473877,
0.46604397892951965,
0.6160345673561096,
-0.6507205367088318,
0.25676923990249634,
-0.21501800417900085,
-0.01587928831577301,
0.7483105659484863,
0.09214431047439575,
0.2619878053665161,
-0.1595992147922516,
0.0025798610877245665,
0.24094876646995544,
-0.9370405077934265,
-0.07824301719665527,
0.1274801790714264,
0.1625966727733612,
-0.25784429907798767,
0.8814249634742737,
-0.2826055884361267,
0.9674158096313477,
-0.0566830076277256,
-0.12252531200647354,
-0.18656879663467407,
-0.10174787044525146,
-0.2880595028400421,
-0.012723122723400593,
0.6839576363563538,
-0.02921794354915619,
0.5541539192199707,
-0.02771718055009842,
0.03743031993508339,
-0.32839083671569824,
0.12390974909067154,
-0.7269995212554932,
-0.0722220242023468,
0.38676387071609497,
-0.4986618757247925,
0.003376366337761283,
-0.23663276433944702,
-0.3909299373626709,
-0.45167356729507446,
-0.5139263868331909,
0.187728613615036,
-0.41090965270996094,
-0.3440711200237274,
0.3875187039375305,
0.08359918743371964,
-0.06665502488613129,
0.43908926844596863,
-0.9828075170516968,
0.029997024685144424,
1.0663706064224243,
0.7468482851982117,
0.1311456710100174,
-0.17922456562519073,
-0.16064517199993134,
0.38403505086898804,
-0.4281435012817383,
0.9671851992607117,
-0.7376007437705994,
-0.20383253693580627,
0.014544694684445858,
-0.13403832912445068,
0.12458797544240952,
-0.6123737692832947,
0.4631960690021515,
-0.2353673130273819,
0.10452338308095932,
-0.5319684147834778,
-0.5515276789665222,
-0.35011306405067444,
0.2676941752433777,
-0.5996805429458618,
1.0020387172698975,
0.16638033092021942,
-0.3991542160511017,
0.17862451076507568,
-0.6076279878616333,
-0.34236952662467957,
0.3622835874557495,
-0.48952099680900574,
-0.0367569774389267,
0.43274059891700745,
0.2195414900779724,
0.6774126887321472,
-0.30349013209342957,
0.15124012529850006,
-0.8281405568122864,
-0.011578811332583427,
0.5854005217552185,
-0.17259512841701508,
0.6438583135604858,
0.27771833539009094,
-0.07949696481227875,
0.12780670821666718,
-0.7107687592506409,
0.07896295189857483,
0.26503103971481323,
-0.27925482392311096,
-0.3237055540084839,
0.17168213427066803,
-0.5724213123321533,
0.34792542457580566,
0.3100457787513733,
-0.3328494131565094,
0.3754504323005676,
-0.3266705870628357,
0.598063051700592,
0.8372284770011902,
-0.23361736536026,
0.5302867889404297,
0.025292010977864265,
0.46152597665786743,
-0.3342285454273224,
0.02991344779729843,
0.06149210035800934,
-0.4003373682498932,
-0.843172550201416,
-0.5123283267021179,
0.010445434600114822,
0.21072989702224731,
-0.3722500503063202,
0.6534938216209412,
-0.29231706261634827,
-0.3137041926383972,
-0.23895110189914703,
0.21382242441177368,
0.2041497528553009,
0.2649952173233032,
0.11674957722425461,
0.08714696764945984,
-0.30718541145324707,
-0.9460182785987854,
-0.1980808973312378,
-0.1881757527589798,
-0.14440082013607025,
0.7006266117095947,
0.2762810289859772,
0.2010147124528885,
0.8619332313537598,
-0.44362348318099976,
-0.10165566205978394,
-0.6348271369934082,
-0.24540100991725922,
0.33265286684036255,
0.24662268161773682,
0.6160320043563843,
-0.18732574582099915,
-0.2925781011581421,
0.01656506583094597,
-1.0671406984329224,
-0.3382629156112671,
-0.1286977380514145,
-0.3392186462879181,
-0.161294624209404,
0.4525758922100067,
-0.8008522987365723,
0.24369896948337555,
0.5658251643180847,
-0.4609219431877136,
0.6554092168807983,
-0.09037630259990692,
-0.17717206478118896,
-0.5691841840744019,
-0.30340075492858887,
0.32064756751060486,
-0.2866016626358032,
-0.46823954582214355,
0.23865631222724915,
-0.2593531608581543,
-0.20325401425361633,
-0.1736498326063156,
0.7651594281196594,
-0.7116020917892456,
-0.6874736547470093,
-0.2697247266769409,
0.49007585644721985,
0.10868199169635773,
0.3703101575374603,
0.24778854846954346,
0.5774101614952087,
0.8830181360244751,
-0.7774381637573242,
0.6246703267097473,
-0.07679387181997299,
-0.5440223217010498,
0.7693265080451965,
-0.7970103025436401,
-0.2423776388168335,
-0.06716131418943405,
0.2047218531370163,
-0.9334100484848022,
-0.06841689348220825,
0.07372158765792847,
-0.21556244790554047,
0.3034193217754364,
-0.2664211392402649,
-0.551010251045227,
-0.6452515721321106,
0.048308733850717545,
0.32895123958587646,
0.20088331401348114,
-0.5768427848815918,
0.708984911441803,
0.5027391314506531,
-0.31142958998680115,
-0.14204291999340057,
-0.5065534114837646,
0.07511092722415924,
-0.33103951811790466,
-0.922332763671875,
-0.2237606942653656,
0.003960915841162205,
-0.6607431769371033,
0.00850063655525446,
0.24877215921878815,
0.1851402223110199,
0.1484905481338501,
0.18786707520484924,
0.10139735788106918,
-0.5567004084587097,
0.33455291390419006,
-0.1382198929786682,
-0.23396889865398407,
0.34306153655052185,
-0.6097148060798645,
0.7542102336883545,
-0.3065348267555237,
-0.5867827534675598,
-0.7336748242378235,
0.245645210146904,
0.41195446252822876,
-0.11590194702148438,
0.6555002927780151,
0.26907116174697876,
-0.28666746616363525,
-0.05103292688727379,
-0.6151862740516663,
-0.07504197955131531,
-0.5245130062103271,
0.44897615909576416,
-0.8124640583992004,
-1.1357686519622803,
0.5076031684875488,
-0.037063539028167725,
-0.12198307365179062,
0.7302545309066772,
0.9447212219238281,
-0.2016134262084961,
1.2332922220230103,
0.5103950500488281,
0.09182573109865189,
0.4045190215110779,
-0.3772803843021393,
0.4189242422580719,
-1.2119078636169434,
-0.28882908821105957,
-0.5819423198699951,
-0.4545559883117676,
-0.355103999376297,
-0.5499899387359619,
0.26215484738349915,
0.11351437866687775,
-0.42742663621902466,
0.06095337122678757,
-0.6023038029670715,
0.6321889758110046,
0.26580682396888733,
-0.08778654038906097,
0.15321800112724304,
0.0933404266834259,
-0.05055565387010574,
-0.032077111303806305,
-0.6198917627334595,
-0.5874128937721252,
0.7985507249832153,
0.7653747200965881,
0.8598694205284119,
0.2513803243637085,
0.1387404501438141,
-0.13694940507411957,
0.16277296841144562,
-0.8041467070579529,
0.7560864090919495,
-0.1044292226433754,
-0.5609059929847717,
-0.611177384853363,
-0.6332654356956482,
-0.868777871131897,
0.540628969669342,
-0.020239554345607758,
-0.9716300368309021,
0.17677448689937592,
0.019725635647773743,
-0.3675338625907898,
0.44626396894454956,
-0.6396290063858032,
0.9328667521476746,
-0.5563896298408508,
-0.2700972557067871,
-0.6222360730171204,
-0.088314950466156,
0.520694375038147,
0.31918632984161377,
0.1268511265516281,
-0.4679904878139496,
0.24255584180355072,
0.417530357837677,
-0.33930155634880066,
0.7632281184196472,
0.02447507530450821,
-0.552331268787384,
0.38646283745765686,
0.4947526752948761,
0.3447551727294922,
0.14515799283981323,
-0.08526743203401566,
0.30723416805267334,
-0.26396116614341736,
-0.32582083344459534,
-0.7198430895805359,
0.8705544471740723,
-0.8096771836280823,
-1.0171425342559814,
-0.15061528980731964,
-1.038151741027832,
-0.20342276990413666,
0.027270300313830376,
-0.2327800989151001,
0.6305841207504272,
-0.0013526936527341604,
0.3127603828907013,
0.6409918069839478,
-0.2843821346759796,
0.2411717176437378,
0.13530051708221436,
-0.8020815253257751,
0.1650008261203766,
0.707410454750061,
0.2550245225429535,
0.5013102293014526,
0.35133835673332214,
0.4150914251804352,
-0.6432773470878601,
-0.578315258026123,
-0.539608895778656,
0.7776044607162476,
-0.9385607242584229,
0.2591286599636078,
-0.7893773317337036,
-0.3094545602798462,
-0.4543198347091675,
-0.18230807781219482,
-0.23119357228279114,
-0.8632521629333496,
-0.13675446808338165,
-0.1075773686170578,
0.3778457045555115,
1.1031136512756348,
-0.1632900834083557,
0.27906593680381775,
-0.5117579698562622,
0.2489008754491806,
0.6060940027236938,
0.5225066542625427,
0.25387588143348694,
-0.6457318067550659,
-0.18469741940498352,
-0.03642919287085533,
-0.12712831795215607,
-0.5589684844017029,
0.1817263811826706,
-0.07726088166236877,
0.7200766205787659,
0.7335341572761536,
-0.5043994188308716,
0.6397536993026733,
-0.45137396454811096,
0.5610927939414978,
0.06766325980424881,
-0.8684892058372498,
0.3300504684448242,
-0.4409724473953247,
0.36795198917388916,
-0.08353160321712494,
0.3487464487552643,
-0.4402615427970886,
-0.6697255373001099,
-0.5056620836257935,
-0.17892663180828094,
0.3434201180934906,
-0.008650549687445164,
0.061018072068691254,
0.09022971987724304,
0.5962308049201965,
-0.15693047642707825,
-0.059543974697589874,
-0.8416793942451477,
-0.07705599814653397,
-0.1329522579908371,
-0.22001110017299652,
-0.10530029982328415,
-0.5124819278717041,
-0.16968964040279388,
-0.3861778676509857,
0.3872162699699402,
-0.08974715322256088,
0.2532007694244385,
-0.012846867553889751,
-0.045689430087804794,
0.05116836726665497,
0.08499379456043243,
0.6382996439933777,
1.0586355924606323,
0.03806730732321739,
0.42634597420692444,
0.034729618579149246,
-0.11829866468906403,
-0.07745589315891266,
-0.2134116142988205,
0.18815399706363678,
-0.34467923641204834,
0.39676734805107117,
0.852881669998169,
0.026775214821100235,
-0.42744001746177673,
0.15620987117290497,
0.007230413146317005,
-0.031140033155679703,
-0.2423485368490219,
0.09412425756454468,
0.3412375748157501,
0.3991481363773346,
0.17541667819023132,
-0.51259845495224,
0.06550787389278412,
-0.6700918078422546,
-0.20737333595752716,
0.7912530899047852,
-0.34393537044525146,
-0.3082766830921173,
0.33327168226242065,
0.041764404624700546,
-0.21973633766174316,
0.4995666742324829,
-0.06181199103593826,
-0.5872848629951477,
0.6120200157165527,
0.670742392539978,
0.6780754327774048,
-0.19417494535446167,
0.17434802651405334,
0.45150914788246155,
0.4575051963329315,
0.3581406772136688,
0.05777961388230324,
0.028446456417441368,
-0.7596917152404785,
-0.7589239478111267,
-0.6315724849700928,
-0.19533754885196686,
0.09332060813903809,
-0.16979120671749115,
0.017100432887673378,
-0.7674024701118469,
0.0347415953874588,
0.0740692988038063,
-0.19551727175712585,
-0.3872029483318329,
0.0469619445502758,
0.43038591742515564,
0.4809574782848358,
-0.5365686416625977,
0.650404691696167,
0.3085823953151703,
-0.1793895810842514,
-0.7356064319610596,
-0.510381817817688,
-0.006892181932926178,
-1.2108041048049927,
0.9670174717903137,
0.22027213871479034,
-0.19477692246437073,
-0.0891459584236145,
-0.47462520003318787,
-1.2998615503311157,
0.5617430806159973,
0.4481218159198761,
-0.6654345989227295,
0.1372956782579422,
0.4595302641391754,
0.6148369312286377,
-0.5609898567199707,
0.1326768547296524,
0.5695599317550659,
0.4426133930683136,
0.2826434075832367,
-0.6826183795928955,
0.10568857192993164,
0.10656177997589111,
0.10410155355930328,
0.3577122688293457,
-0.46422454714775085,
0.7675756216049194,
-0.38598114252090454,
-0.302884966135025,
-0.1213754266500473,
0.8709832429885864,
0.5409005284309387,
-0.28981253504753113,
0.36576712131500244,
0.8293120265007019,
0.6707188487052917,
-0.2645019292831421,
1.4811878204345703,
-0.3772859275341034,
0.29739007353782654,
0.8254803419113159,
-0.34753021597862244,
0.5715394020080566,
0.18655066192150116,
-0.4218526780605316,
0.7479968070983887,
0.6186951398849487,
0.18589451909065247,
-0.02467712014913559,
0.48515790700912476,
-0.14718368649482727,
-0.6409398913383484,
-0.15950773656368256,
-0.4459744691848755,
0.26837703585624695,
0.7290796637535095,
-0.22134321928024292,
-0.15568266808986664,
-0.19119203090667725,
-0.07240825146436691,
0.001153116230852902,
-0.5817247033119202,
0.7053231596946716,
0.2523636221885681,
-0.40059950947761536,
0.5025171041488647,
-0.17022117972373962,
0.04928514361381531,
-0.2826177179813385,
0.07336414605379105,
0.12122458964586258,
0.2977704703807831,
-0.16843686997890472,
-1.385382890701294,
0.3582041561603546,
-0.11160901933908463,
-0.09648079425096512,
-0.2401207983493805,
0.6132713556289673,
-0.27051398158073425,
-0.7367522120475769,
0.27041929960250854,
0.4597616493701935,
0.44286105036735535,
-0.20310313999652863,
-0.8967951536178589,
0.20797552168369293,
-0.26095253229141235,
-0.20348809659481049,
0.35988086462020874,
0.9517461061477661,
0.03908185660839081,
1.0789660215377808,
0.7402543425559998,
0.3236434757709503,
0.27920782566070557,
0.37273266911506653,
0.7250450849533081,
-0.5547979474067688,
-0.47787413001060486,
-0.9933257699012756,
0.1918354332447052,
-0.12501627206802368,
0.002084630774334073,
0.7906216979026794,
0.5106832981109619,
0.4536471664905548,
0.1330273449420929,
0.6764407157897949,
0.11971523612737656,
0.5889691114425659,
-0.7198042273521423,
0.4093051254749298,
-0.46250560879707336,
0.30446434020996094,
0.03104482591152191,
-1.1516321897506714,
-0.3993108868598938,
0.9767231941223145,
-0.9502817392349243,
0.17481866478919983,
0.8211005330085754,
0.4900738000869751,
-0.03594953939318657,
-0.16128778457641602,
0.4562380015850067,
0.6643944382667542,
0.4640589952468872,
0.6807249188423157,
1.206333875656128,
0.2431843876838684,
0.2070082426071167,
-0.20907369256019592,
-0.1755470633506775,
-0.0849665179848671,
-0.8799907565116882,
-1.1259442567825317,
-0.4362090528011322,
-0.21134987473487854,
-0.3075837194919586,
-0.4870760142803192,
0.46037840843200684,
0.7294785380363464,
-0.49826571345329285,
-0.46212154626846313,
-0.030999772250652313,
0.5215269327163696,
0.17412607371807098,
-0.24750293791294098,
0.45076560974121094,
-0.33418604731559753,
-0.6536979079246521,
0.19044731557369232,
0.931621789932251,
0.061565201729536057,
-0.9610468745231628,
-0.029327290132641792,
-0.14677594602108002,
0.22088897228240967,
0.9980966448783875,
0.3135739862918854,
-0.8982416987419128,
-0.5579248666763306,
-0.1934889703989029,
-0.15693466365337372,
0.15854476392269135,
1.0214414596557617,
-0.629347562789917,
0.17429611086845398,
0.532346248626709,
0.526155948638916,
0.4260779619216919,
-0.060896292328834534,
0.6006419062614441,
-0.3649406433105469,
0.41490375995635986,
-0.005879525560885668,
0.8124700784683228,
0.356487512588501,
-0.4314993619918823,
0.4379115402698517,
0.2848811447620392,
-0.6880361437797546,
-0.6802039742469788,
0.6307761073112488,
-0.8737040162086487,
-0.3664214015007019,
1.201928973197937,
-0.07013657689094543,
-0.2838459610939026,
-0.11341021955013275,
-0.06173073500394821,
-0.22058120369911194,
0.02583897113800049,
0.7791831493377686,
0.8503698706626892,
-0.2985542118549347,
-0.5220011472702026,
-0.582377552986145,
0.2670785188674927,
0.3493400514125824,
-1.0650452375411987,
0.29606589674949646,
0.6945642828941345,
0.035974834114313126,
0.23999454081058502,
0.6304000020027161,
-0.20354898273944855,
-0.01598478853702545,
-0.34790366888046265,
0.005137937143445015,
0.1955266296863556,
-0.635620653629303,
-0.22699031233787537,
0.1908198744058609,
0.2782087028026581,
0.413360595703125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02662v1 | Supporters and Skeptics: LLM-based Analysis of Engagement with Mental Health (Mis)Information Content on Video-sharing Platforms | 2024-07-02T20:51:06 | 2024-07-02T20:51:06 | Viet Cuong Nguyen, Mini Jain, Abhijat Chauhan, Heather Jaime Soled, Santiago Alvarez Lesmes, Zihang Li, Michael L. Birnbaum, Sunny X. Tang, Srijan Kumar, Munmun De Choudhury | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Over one in five adults in the US lives with a mental illness. In the face of
a shortage of mental health professionals and offline resources, online
short-form video content has grown to serve as a crucial conduit for
disseminating mental health help and resources. However, the ease of content
creation and access also contributes to the spread of misinformation, posing
risks to accurate diagnosis and treatment. Detecting and understanding
engagement with such content is crucial to mitigating their harmful effects on
public health. We perform the first quantitative study of the phenomenon using
YouTube Shorts and Bitchute as the sites of study. We contribute MentalMisinfo,
a novel labeled mental health misinformation (MHMisinfo) dataset of 739 videos
(639 from Youtube and 100 from Bitchute) and 135372 comments in total, using an
expert-driven annotation schema. We first found that few-shot in-context
learning with large language models (LLMs) are effective in detecting MHMisinfo
videos. Next, we discover distinct and potentially alarming linguistic patterns
in how audiences engage with MHMisinfo videos through commentary on both
video-sharing platforms. Across the two platforms, comments could exacerbate
prevailing stigma with some groups showing heightened susceptibility to and
alignment with MHMisinfo. We discuss technical and public health-driven
adaptive solutions to tackling the "epidemic" of mental health misinformation
online. | [
-0.6386041641235352,
-0.7536142468452454,
0.7153714895248413,
0.18261849880218506,
-0.23578421771526337,
-0.0776805579662323,
-0.07679160684347153,
-0.26001906394958496,
0.5333229899406433,
-0.028194786980748177,
-0.900254487991333,
-0.2836169898509979,
-1.0042752027511597,
0.006350846961140633,
-0.3459964394569397,
0.9434853792190552,
-0.08919376879930496,
0.017377151176333427,
-0.13485267758369446,
-0.10597920417785645,
-0.3462395966053009,
-0.5334747433662415,
-0.44932812452316284,
0.03535984084010124,
0.9430390000343323,
0.33080771565437317,
0.464830219745636,
0.1512969732284546,
0.47160494327545166,
0.14266884326934814,
0.09963636100292206,
0.045967500656843185,
-0.9980902075767517,
-0.1525147259235382,
-0.25741997361183167,
-0.24061836302280426,
-0.23538541793823242,
-0.07233698666095734,
0.3328082859516144,
0.31612956523895264,
-0.30258551239967346,
0.5824100375175476,
0.12023389339447021,
0.30122026801109314,
-0.843247652053833,
-0.36408257484436035,
-0.3571073114871979,
0.24434104561805725,
-0.4699545204639435,
-0.42551255226135254,
-0.28204113245010376,
-0.29493850469589233,
-0.11831963807344437,
-0.4609656035900116,
0.1447802037000656,
-0.24504414200782776,
0.4353744089603424,
0.532805860042572,
-0.33254802227020264,
-0.24939991533756256,
-0.7161619067192078,
0.4508710503578186,
-0.5451100468635559,
0.522849440574646,
0.7407369017601013,
0.13126859068870544,
-0.09829594939947128,
-0.2189185917377472,
-0.5184847116470337,
0.2919078767299652,
0.2763507068157196,
0.007983730174601078,
-0.7926063537597656,
-0.0041418978944420815,
0.49731236696243286,
0.1131138950586319,
-0.52397221326828,
-0.044164322316646576,
-0.5671329498291016,
-0.292307049036026,
0.7323855757713318,
0.18158738315105438,
0.528201699256897,
-0.21757446229457855,
-0.15131811797618866,
0.2253204733133316,
-0.40203288197517395,
0.02484252117574215,
0.21837842464447021,
-0.2885489761829376,
-0.18395496904850006,
1.019162654876709,
0.2827375829219818,
0.020741425454616547,
0.43304598331451416,
-0.38139283657073975,
-0.06078343465924263,
-0.135956808924675,
-0.3478296995162964,
0.5072379112243652,
0.7339257597923279,
0.6051797866821289,
0.23575980961322784,
0.12064870446920395,
0.11962144076824188,
0.3265249729156494,
0.4688528776168823,
-0.7793781161308289,
-0.3996630609035492,
0.19457687437534332,
-0.5057460069656372,
0.24680745601654053,
0.013792664743959904,
-0.5780176520347595,
-0.8127102851867676,
-0.14667020738124847,
0.5963544249534607,
-0.4862474501132965,
-0.4150221645832062,
0.1420322209596634,
-0.13901586830615997,
-0.23153910040855408,
0.17062482237815857,
-0.5963948369026184,
0.07218416780233383,
0.6499167084693909,
1.0244269371032715,
-0.09957890212535858,
0.02582087740302086,
-0.41631007194519043,
0.4172457456588745,
-0.3369143307209015,
0.6610009074211121,
-0.2335198074579239,
-0.2323087453842163,
0.21079333126544952,
0.22272923588752747,
-0.04901012405753136,
-0.35119643807411194,
0.45590639114379883,
-0.2523175776004791,
0.05729430913925171,
-0.5639069080352783,
-0.5053260922431946,
-0.01938636600971222,
0.29301807284355164,
-0.5637729167938232,
0.891279935836792,
0.07915244251489639,
-1.0865355730056763,
0.3376244008541107,
-0.6135109066963196,
-0.06512312591075897,
-0.2729780673980713,
-0.15552975237369537,
-0.03946322575211525,
0.2911720275878906,
0.1608455330133438,
0.3577927350997925,
0.13417385518550873,
0.24745772778987885,
-0.6137965321540833,
-0.3217525780200958,
0.5336791276931763,
-0.6797047853469849,
0.3548594117164612,
0.041848551481962204,
-0.21601232886314392,
0.027905283495783806,
-0.18908649682998657,
-0.4336138069629669,
-0.2003006488084793,
0.08447113633155823,
-0.4228889048099518,
-0.025750599801540375,
-0.10385791957378387,
0.49570024013519287,
-0.15201234817504883,
-0.4722076654434204,
-0.2570163905620575,
-0.04205440357327461,
0.2047520875930786,
0.7042087912559509,
0.5912652611732483,
-0.06830033659934998,
-0.5262718200683594,
0.6382113099098206,
0.22151830792427063,
0.6435215473175049,
0.021089613437652588,
-0.5105718970298767,
-0.27917057275772095,
-0.6268934607505798,
-0.18484735488891602,
0.42520448565483093,
-0.38884878158569336,
0.10441206395626068,
-0.17526791989803314,
-0.4802681505680084,
-0.803174614906311,
0.20554186403751373,
-0.02258422039449215,
0.38294267654418945,
0.4131852388381958,
-0.22632987797260284,
-0.6220539808273315,
-0.8657582402229309,
-0.12487207353115082,
-0.1808556616306305,
-0.09195444732904434,
0.2663213908672333,
0.3094135522842407,
-0.5485803484916687,
0.8231544494628906,
-0.3993918001651764,
-0.2435481697320938,
-0.03684146702289581,
0.39623910188674927,
-0.14431443810462952,
-0.08877261728048325,
0.4053059220314026,
-0.5534101724624634,
-0.6740813851356506,
-0.19417300820350647,
-0.9452141523361206,
-0.1659316122531891,
-0.04689783602952957,
-0.14737540483474731,
-0.31524884700775146,
0.18881577253341675,
-0.6114679574966431,
0.5094213485717773,
0.35851210355758667,
0.031558193266391754,
0.49826666712760925,
0.09521491080522537,
0.41179677844047546,
-0.6897055506706238,
-0.24882705509662628,
0.3591344654560089,
0.022258210927248,
-0.54759681224823,
-0.4432336091995239,
-0.3685244023799896,
-0.06654578447341919,
-0.6005984544754028,
-0.034879885613918304,
-0.06065778806805611,
0.1537150740623474,
-0.31450533866882324,
0.22824010252952576,
-0.3946281671524048,
0.11019779741764069,
-0.33468860387802124,
0.704559862613678,
0.43990954756736755,
-0.4024847745895386,
0.14469201862812042,
0.11522680521011353,
-0.14365607500076294,
0.8159199953079224,
-0.24733799695968628,
-0.16481521725654602,
-0.36595070362091064,
0.1761849969625473,
-0.9556282758712769,
-0.7082540392875671,
0.7202320098876953,
-0.5932039022445679,
-0.13967852294445038,
-0.009236268699169159,
-0.45040586590766907,
-0.1383386254310608,
-0.44568726420402527,
0.3973950445652008,
-0.025377243757247925,
-0.13890942931175232,
0.12500201165676117,
0.8879331350326538,
-0.27947598695755005,
-0.47785696387290955,
-0.4680730104446411,
0.1361871361732483,
-0.6544400453567505,
-0.64127516746521,
0.12359543144702911,
-0.08574918657541275,
-0.3924132287502289,
0.032389163970947266,
-0.33798500895500183,
-0.12976689636707306,
0.008608312346041203,
0.42221012711524963,
-0.05645334720611572,
-0.19622938334941864,
0.5370321273803711,
0.06602852046489716,
-0.037413764744997025,
0.36866387724876404,
0.1984507441520691,
0.3257959485054016,
0.13585256040096283,
-0.7151678800582886,
-0.7378450632095337,
0.8837337493896484,
0.4109867513179779,
0.26511362195014954,
0.513822615146637,
0.9144066572189331,
-0.617500901222229,
0.2303772270679474,
-0.6903029680252075,
-0.4228442311286926,
-0.394361674785614,
0.3550138473510742,
0.0037594002205878496,
-0.7745220065116882,
0.16578182578086853,
0.022554218769073486,
-0.10739261656999588,
0.04938044399023056,
0.36665064096450806,
-0.6074113845825195,
1.1142756938934326,
0.7221004366874695,
-0.18582917749881744,
0.35311272740364075,
0.09279977530241013,
0.42000874876976013,
-0.48281437158584595,
-0.21124587953090668,
-0.0017038790974766016,
-0.38002774119377136,
-0.5310679078102112,
-0.6273540258407593,
0.6044542789459229,
0.259086012840271,
-0.32905760407447815,
0.06609156727790833,
-0.20567762851715088,
0.10468047112226486,
0.02646227553486824,
0.41831541061401367,
0.27372223138809204,
-0.005420401692390442,
0.14116708934307098,
-0.8571223020553589,
-0.7678056359291077,
-0.28647780418395996,
0.7613157629966736,
0.5782142877578735,
0.8788811564445496,
0.5530220866203308,
0.50194251537323,
0.949211835861206,
0.641964316368103,
-0.8122187852859497,
0.2740044891834259,
0.17010757327079773,
-0.31507086753845215,
-0.15326260030269623,
-0.14633139967918396,
-0.6994516253471375,
-0.18998363614082336,
-0.3418903946876526,
-0.9315119981765747,
0.15596744418144226,
0.24565306305885315,
-0.2708945870399475,
0.40474605560302734,
-0.41476917266845703,
0.5981216430664062,
-0.286327600479126,
-0.5537608861923218,
-0.5661319494247437,
-0.43176713585853577,
0.6988850831985474,
-0.3577079176902771,
0.6268519759178162,
-0.2575581669807434,
0.18004237115383148,
0.7674885988235474,
-0.021832343190908432,
0.8317595720291138,
-0.05601086840033531,
-0.17816992104053497,
0.2930058240890503,
-0.07890487462282181,
0.030682023614645004,
0.34735891222953796,
0.3699502646923065,
-0.1743827611207962,
0.03768713399767876,
-0.11709198355674744,
-0.5923875570297241,
0.48601990938186646,
-0.6914744973182678,
-0.7333671450614929,
-0.400190532207489,
-0.21600253880023956,
-0.22972480952739716,
-0.10090348869562149,
0.19510526955127716,
0.09513936191797256,
-0.11886397004127502,
0.18334683775901794,
1.2018660306930542,
0.07627468556165695,
0.2358817458152771,
0.22897347807884216,
-0.09875917434692383,
-0.5989668965339661,
0.8090305328369141,
0.12919439375400543,
0.027162732556462288,
0.04216689243912697,
0.1585617959499359,
-0.2598467469215393,
-0.00624639168381691,
-0.19132962822914124,
0.5814517736434937,
-0.6444622874259949,
-0.06586172431707382,
-0.5989452600479126,
-0.23382511734962463,
-0.29364117980003357,
0.03624971583485603,
-0.2931564748287201,
0.24480627477169037,
-0.29573264718055725,
-0.3775774836540222,
0.3721460998058319,
0.7850940227508545,
-0.4407755434513092,
0.5615645051002502,
-0.8733224868774414,
0.16472162306308746,
0.28435763716697693,
0.3427307605743408,
0.11295166611671448,
-0.31905511021614075,
-0.5189875364303589,
0.11698140949010849,
-0.4559265077114105,
-1.799288272857666,
0.031589556485414505,
0.02830001711845398,
0.7714465856552124,
1.123346209526062,
0.22055254876613617,
1.058495044708252,
-0.039642225950956345,
0.7010281682014465,
0.26690346002578735,
-0.6869077682495117,
0.4131549596786499,
-0.42125019431114197,
-0.12612514197826385,
0.5693994164466858,
1.1475460529327393,
-1.026853084564209,
-0.1775122582912445,
-0.6251387000083923,
-0.582094132900238,
0.26798519492149353,
-0.021883781999349594,
0.1496015340089798,
-0.272367924451828,
-0.0252516008913517,
0.07714882493019104,
0.30113711953163147,
-0.7308468818664551,
-0.3183664083480835,
-0.28391340374946594,
-0.15400856733322144,
0.09683604538440704,
-0.4494374990463257,
-0.5081804394721985,
-0.12891025841236115,
0.622455358505249,
-0.032196417450904846,
0.31963250041007996,
0.21786834299564362,
-0.2384924441576004,
-0.32107600569725037,
0.13670393824577332,
0.5190159678459167,
0.63379967212677,
-0.5048472285270691,
0.3580123484134674,
-0.12552930414676666,
-0.6884326934814453,
0.27592191100120544,
-0.3364911675453186,
-0.02181035652756691,
0.3576115071773529,
-0.027941374108195305,
0.5777888298034668,
0.6646682620048523,
-0.8397219777107239,
0.5491654276847839,
0.2275291234254837,
-0.16029255092144012,
-0.24856887757778168,
-0.002289872383698821,
0.21531705558300018,
0.2675519585609436,
0.32081305980682373,
-0.009246384724974632,
0.1354103833436966,
-0.5637170672416687,
0.4776100814342499,
0.37788745760917664,
-0.7562244534492493,
-0.5199532508850098,
0.48070648312568665,
-0.14576900005340576,
-0.29510989785194397,
0.2349383682012558,
0.013710389845073223,
-0.2026916891336441,
0.0863318145275116,
0.36507970094680786,
0.6218494176864624,
0.02081897296011448,
0.5179898142814636,
0.34273386001586914,
0.3083608150482178,
-0.18481847643852234,
0.06396010518074036,
-0.0694718062877655,
-0.4273990988731384,
-0.27804508805274963,
-0.08323681354522705,
-0.33600181341171265,
0.4240127205848694,
-0.9390305280685425,
0.43011292815208435,
-0.33928659558296204,
-0.7422409057617188,
-0.07794847339391708,
-0.22094714641571045,
-0.3751211166381836,
0.00798469502478838,
0.45376768708229065,
0.8940334320068359,
-1.1903868913650513,
0.4959067702293396,
0.5990507006645203,
-0.5113140344619751,
-0.42223504185676575,
0.5040995478630066,
0.39283111691474915,
-0.1952875703573227,
-0.01109021995216608,
0.32560309767723083,
-0.18001362681388855,
-0.301592081785202,
-0.563992440700531,
-0.9572473764419556,
0.84178626537323,
0.45352163910865784,
-0.154349222779274,
0.18546365201473236,
0.3012086749076843,
0.2800682485103607,
-0.3724719285964966,
0.2719326317310333,
0.4474162459373474,
0.44917240738868713,
-0.16655288636684418,
-0.5518707633018494,
-0.21444451808929443,
-0.09464583545923233,
-0.3380880057811737,
0.0766439363360405,
-0.4507867693901062,
0.36652758717536926,
-0.19854295253753662,
-0.49716782569885254,
-0.3745260536670685,
0.615386426448822,
0.722269594669342,
0.7708647847175598,
0.4510953426361084,
0.3197055459022522,
0.8752573728561401,
0.3587754964828491,
0.33404749631881714,
-0.06461324542760849,
0.27255308628082275,
1.0677378177642822,
-0.0878252238035202,
0.994550347328186,
0.8593645691871643,
-0.3214312791824341,
0.428894966840744,
0.8945903182029724,
0.018175996840000153,
0.4190921187400818,
0.19389979541301727,
-0.5291007161140442,
-0.3749799430370331,
-0.3712974786758423,
-0.4352809488773346,
0.17703625559806824,
0.7646286487579346,
-0.23573242127895355,
-0.20583529770374298,
0.28182703256607056,
0.290416955947876,
0.11765772104263306,
-0.21938636898994446,
0.6113613247871399,
0.1397724747657776,
-0.3597373366355896,
0.1043669655919075,
-0.08050015568733215,
0.6757300496101379,
-0.5788828134536743,
0.12846310436725616,
-0.07274075597524643,
-0.30312153697013855,
-0.4041922986507416,
-0.7316046953201294,
0.46577659249305725,
0.3105117678642273,
-0.4426480531692505,
0.11280073970556259,
0.6709199547767639,
-0.20771245658397675,
-0.3101746439933777,
0.3806494474411011,
0.7431861162185669,
0.3796099126338959,
-0.2931654751300812,
-0.4057416617870331,
0.014623959548771381,
-0.08952931314706802,
0.1958862692117691,
0.6630192995071411,
0.5381156206130981,
-0.31374692916870117,
0.5266423225402832,
0.5946018099784851,
0.1894093006849289,
0.26494157314300537,
-0.11116685718297958,
0.6933255791664124,
-0.4227098822593689,
-0.27378737926483154,
-0.8154338002204895,
0.43710675835609436,
-0.24980971217155457,
-0.29666081070899963,
0.8150750398635864,
0.35815176367759705,
0.7757251858711243,
-0.03989599645137787,
0.8552278876304626,
0.07696009427309036,
0.20199905335903168,
-0.1263514757156372,
0.6213937401771545,
-0.5468004941940308,
0.08974112570285797,
-0.0765104591846466,
-0.5811846852302551,
0.06033233553171158,
0.42495647072792053,
-0.32710137963294983,
-0.43241387605667114,
0.4682299494743347,
0.729720950126648,
-0.1433650702238083,
0.0992979109287262,
0.16432784497737885,
0.31128913164138794,
0.19633223116397858,
0.3600979447364807,
0.9458047151565552,
-0.1290750950574875,
0.5461746454238892,
-0.31489259004592896,
-0.19822004437446594,
-0.33419591188430786,
-0.7496935725212097,
-0.7114508152008057,
-0.3204209804534912,
-0.39678069949150085,
-0.2509165406227112,
0.07836724072694778,
1.1116552352905273,
0.5430700182914734,
-0.47524693608283997,
-0.050273969769477844,
0.3271869421005249,
0.2090790569782257,
-0.29744407534599304,
-0.24459318816661835,
0.15360277891159058,
0.1700034886598587,
-0.3330610692501068,
0.15700790286064148,
0.4062335789203644,
-0.23462128639221191,
-0.5202994346618652,
0.0773799940943718,
-0.35673990845680237,
0.32404911518096924,
0.4818832576274872,
0.4156867563724518,
-0.8221448659896851,
-0.1821284145116806,
0.1570795327425003,
-0.20862936973571777,
0.17765982449054718,
0.809550404548645,
-0.34976840019226074,
0.25425711274147034,
0.4401197135448456,
0.49208036065101624,
0.20996510982513428,
0.33992043137550354,
0.336139053106308,
-0.6007155179977417,
-0.23900368809700012,
-0.00948313344269991,
0.21286964416503906,
0.427813321352005,
-0.5735814571380615,
0.06605717539787292,
0.4801149070262909,
-0.23356908559799194,
-0.9553209543228149,
-0.00655052624642849,
-0.8505560755729675,
0.034441571682691574,
0.8917278051376343,
-0.18200907111167908,
-0.042449723929166794,
-0.2444286048412323,
-0.32294976711273193,
0.4389849603176117,
-0.5051971077919006,
1.2293535470962524,
0.7722781896591187,
-0.4261419177055359,
-0.3797987401485443,
-0.9773815274238586,
0.4478415250778198,
0.27579331398010254,
-0.6576594710350037,
-0.10909553617238998,
0.3273841142654419,
0.4165293872356415,
0.06553220748901367,
0.5555342435836792,
0.0911509096622467,
0.5112094283103943,
-0.0947810560464859,
-0.26371416449546814,
0.1478610783815384,
-0.30306315422058105,
-0.2507053017616272,
0.19690057635307312,
-0.3153572082519531,
-0.09909259527921677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02659v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02659v1 | Ensuring Responsible Sourcing of Large Language Model Training Data Through Knowledge Graph Comparison | 2024-07-02T20:49:21 | 2024-07-02T20:49:21 | Devam Mondal, Carlo Lipizzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In light of recent plagiarism allegations Brough by publishers, newspapers,
and other creators of copyrighted corpora against large language model (LLM)
developers, we propose a novel system, a variant of a plagiarism detection
system, that assesses whether a knowledge source has been used in the training
or fine-tuning of a large language model. Unlike current methods, we utilize an
approach that uses Resource Description Framework (RDF) triples to create
knowledge graphs from both a source document and a LLM continuation of that
document. These graphs are then analyzed with respect to content using cosine
similarity and with respect to structure using a normalized version of graph
edit distance that shows the degree of isomorphism. Unlike traditional systems
that focus on content matching and keyword identification between a source and
target corpus, our approach enables a broader evaluation of similarity and thus
a more accurate comparison of the similarity between a source document and LLM
continuation by focusing on relationships between ideas and their organization
with regards to others. Additionally, our approach does not require access to
LLM metrics like perplexity that may be unavailable in closed large language
modeling "black-box" systems, as well as the training corpus. A prototype of
our system will be found on a hyperlinked GitHub repository. | [
-0.10632029920816422,
-0.6578688025474548,
0.5778750777244568,
0.13625329732894897,
-0.17031091451644897,
0.22197569906711578,
-0.31391599774360657,
-0.4292771518230438,
-0.02812715247273445,
0.9348112940788269,
-0.26728352904319763,
-0.6266583800315857,
-0.5006653666496277,
0.37830427289009094,
-0.8050510883331299,
0.929655134677887,
-0.2734551727771759,
0.0040885526686906815,
-0.5380606055259705,
-0.3123511075973511,
-0.13909220695495605,
-0.5224807262420654,
-0.6683149933815002,
-0.3616511821746826,
0.5323445200920105,
0.21326249837875366,
0.5726515650749207,
0.9167884588241577,
0.6312671303749084,
0.27211928367614746,
-0.225185364484787,
0.18392156064510345,
-0.679349422454834,
0.1443730741739273,
-0.34361815452575684,
-0.29852309823036194,
-0.27739498019218445,
-0.053687334060668945,
0.8018039464950562,
0.4976162612438202,
0.09249987453222275,
0.28188225626945496,
0.2117094248533249,
0.6057583689689636,
-0.6918472051620483,
0.3715541362762451,
-0.563890278339386,
-0.024131860584020615,
-0.32728472352027893,
-0.24314433336257935,
-0.49858903884887695,
-0.47304224967956543,
0.03577679395675659,
-0.40486612915992737,
0.3732815086841583,
0.10760568082332611,
0.741844654083252,
-0.029229743406176567,
-0.36691784858703613,
-0.4236702620983124,
-0.4909469485282898,
0.5544264316558838,
-0.6947728395462036,
0.4476475715637207,
0.1978636533021927,
0.1691293716430664,
-0.19285689294338226,
-0.838264524936676,
-0.6730374097824097,
-0.3562335669994354,
-0.1510048508644104,
-0.23430195450782776,
-0.12802551686763763,
-0.12604451179504395,
0.19034656882286072,
0.4546199440956116,
-0.5728512406349182,
0.18463413417339325,
-0.40312373638153076,
-0.48579269647598267,
0.4905800521373749,
-0.13722632825374603,
0.29197317361831665,
-0.2440786063671112,
-0.34636348485946655,
-0.14359307289123535,
-1.0121008157730103,
-0.4353778660297394,
0.5877690315246582,
0.36814936995506287,
-0.017966676503419876,
0.6904439330101013,
-0.1809852123260498,
0.6986002326011658,
-0.2685619592666626,
-0.11757095903158188,
0.3575749397277832,
-0.34966522455215454,
-0.1535627245903015,
0.12224826961755753,
0.8346129655838013,
0.397813081741333,
0.3072531521320343,
-0.4086921513080597,
-0.16849346458911896,
-0.2607673406600952,
0.00019804494513664395,
-0.7875199913978577,
-0.23285557329654694,
-0.14944906532764435,
-0.2279915064573288,
-0.3115895390510559,
0.02324291691184044,
-0.47937846183776855,
-0.5955981612205505,
-0.46829238533973694,
0.05125878006219864,
-0.4967253506183624,
-0.33091187477111816,
-0.16638946533203125,
-0.07420872151851654,
-0.04064379259943962,
0.10190863162279129,
-0.6459280252456665,
0.050541434437036514,
0.9501700401306152,
1.04867684841156,
-0.4220883250236511,
-0.5163952708244324,
-0.4482280910015106,
0.5054424405097961,
-0.19757471978664398,
0.723523736000061,
-0.2252492904663086,
-0.24319905042648315,
0.13728874921798706,
0.10839638859033585,
0.15757544338703156,
-0.7220737934112549,
0.4459456503391266,
-0.9615615606307983,
0.113516665995121,
-0.08498164266347885,
-0.7706735730171204,
-0.02514941804111004,
0.48847532272338867,
-0.9474632143974304,
0.8289283514022827,
0.3562290072441101,
-0.9745203256607056,
0.29211756587028503,
-0.45934709906578064,
-0.32945212721824646,
0.23409628868103027,
-0.12200562655925751,
-0.4952113628387451,
-0.32659557461738586,
-0.005938486661761999,
0.39010554552078247,
-0.20130227506160736,
0.20836162567138672,
-0.5519728064537048,
-0.1331208199262619,
0.21365448832511902,
-0.05322575941681862,
1.037290096282959,
0.310994952917099,
-0.014153282158076763,
0.20098531246185303,
-0.7367140650749207,
-0.08023282885551453,
0.3671526312828064,
-0.6522798538208008,
-0.7096027731895447,
-0.17567293345928192,
-0.0604030005633831,
0.000015802042980794795,
0.48505112528800964,
-0.4433506727218628,
-0.06484972685575485,
-0.2087421864271164,
0.4329143166542053,
0.6590478420257568,
0.029833119362592697,
0.4519515633583069,
-0.188523530960083,
0.3864607512950897,
-0.22095681726932526,
0.06200280785560608,
0.07527978718280792,
-0.15972235798835754,
-0.6018092632293701,
-0.32362455129623413,
0.3952493965625763,
0.3133964538574219,
-0.6006856560707092,
0.6097985506057739,
-0.5157477855682373,
-0.3821133077144623,
-0.27511176466941833,
0.46812865138053894,
0.39823341369628906,
0.6313930749893188,
0.20979996025562286,
-0.2983413636684418,
-0.6344982981681824,
-0.8073282241821289,
-0.22434279322624207,
-0.24357499182224274,
-0.15653230249881744,
0.13605205714702606,
0.5424778461456299,
0.032223451882600784,
1.043354868888855,
-0.3530893325805664,
-0.3480706512928009,
-0.1648152768611908,
0.008245982229709625,
-0.050965260714292526,
0.3084957003593445,
0.6859220862388611,
-0.6445265412330627,
-0.5696700811386108,
0.10648885369300842,
-0.926224410533905,
-0.3951169550418854,
0.3725917339324951,
-0.14205162227153778,
0.17979250848293304,
0.8086155652999878,
-0.4463646411895752,
0.009918754920363426,
0.5559961795806885,
-0.44670814275741577,
0.5266492962837219,
-0.0718819871544838,
-0.008684417232871056,
-1.1221078634262085,
0.3256806433200836,
-0.24342770874500275,
-0.19094359874725342,
-0.20354107022285461,
0.3903295695781708,
0.12926548719406128,
-0.1123022735118866,
-0.3451478183269501,
0.45809632539749146,
-0.2837482690811157,
-0.23099856078624725,
-0.33573803305625916,
0.4473603069782257,
0.1319970339536667,
0.08862898498773575,
-0.057161200791597366,
0.7638241648674011,
0.1528186798095703,
-0.3401331603527069,
0.6725856065750122,
0.3028227388858795,
-0.6614093780517578,
0.6876010894775391,
-0.38826707005500793,
0.3780783712863922,
0.06807275861501694,
0.2485377937555313,
-0.5589289665222168,
-0.03871023282408714,
0.17814314365386963,
-0.23659837245941162,
0.11490443348884583,
-0.3372909724712372,
-0.7848556637763977,
-0.23466725647449493,
-0.11602628976106644,
0.16007423400878906,
0.12137465924024582,
-0.4426202178001404,
0.24643154442310333,
0.3789612054824829,
-0.4227699339389801,
-0.6926894187927246,
-0.5713390111923218,
0.25949588418006897,
-0.06532318145036697,
-0.7217283248901367,
0.14334039390087128,
0.06712130457162857,
-0.34483084082603455,
0.3350417912006378,
0.009035388007760048,
-0.26745468378067017,
0.19111774861812592,
-0.11902940273284912,
0.16556626558303833,
-0.29781198501586914,
0.15805783867835999,
-0.13038377463817596,
0.18475879728794098,
0.1612660437822342,
-0.4374016225337982,
0.5799046158790588,
0.11484435200691223,
-0.3118225336074829,
-0.05763282626867294,
0.17509499192237854,
0.6794973015785217,
-0.3768032491207123,
0.8090097308158875,
0.5299729704856873,
-0.30486440658569336,
-0.3094569742679596,
-0.5578621625900269,
-0.013096318580210209,
-0.40483012795448303,
0.46247270703315735,
-0.03097478672862053,
-1.0442060232162476,
0.46030038595199585,
0.16256478428840637,
-0.07276520133018494,
0.31611332297325134,
0.4873513877391815,
0.21986812353134155,
0.4853084981441498,
0.6894726157188416,
-0.23074142634868622,
0.7271347045898438,
-0.3453805148601532,
0.26690196990966797,
-0.6321077346801758,
-0.2788197696208954,
-0.6543969511985779,
-0.09371455758810043,
-0.3597326874732971,
-0.3084055483341217,
0.04971505329012871,
0.22799603641033173,
-0.4735368490219116,
0.3697171211242676,
-0.24888814985752106,
0.6733787655830383,
0.5464027523994446,
-0.1405203938484192,
0.7530495524406433,
0.2507905662059784,
-0.17883916199207306,
0.21828071773052216,
-0.5516236424446106,
-0.6758902668952942,
1.1780623197555542,
0.2065986841917038,
0.43523770570755005,
0.1335199624300003,
0.702879786491394,
0.3393915593624115,
0.5920394062995911,
-0.6491584777832031,
0.5839459300041199,
-0.20266512036323547,
-0.6226144433021545,
-0.42626628279685974,
-0.7707839608192444,
-0.8851292133331299,
0.07681014388799667,
-0.185359388589859,
-0.48852038383483887,
-0.11417098343372345,
-0.13900749385356903,
0.002296942751854658,
0.4354814291000366,
-0.6548694372177124,
0.863811731338501,
-0.19226619601249695,
-0.4298892319202423,
-0.24986188113689423,
-0.2157072126865387,
0.2792271077632904,
-0.30735233426094055,
0.24338752031326294,
-0.0514669306576252,
0.1719834804534912,
0.9891868829727173,
-0.537314236164093,
0.5690367817878723,
-0.12327823787927628,
-0.24788883328437805,
0.46372368931770325,
0.19964128732681274,
0.4534325897693634,
-0.09456058591604233,
-0.19456247985363007,
0.15781882405281067,
0.05658883973956108,
-0.26747605204582214,
-0.5158483386039734,
0.8248529434204102,
-0.8101848363876343,
-0.4853937327861786,
-0.15712489187717438,
-0.8150633573532104,
-0.09901271015405655,
0.7060739994049072,
-0.004147878848016262,
0.15423531830310822,
-0.2392544001340866,
0.45600396394729614,
0.3933432102203369,
-0.08620507270097733,
0.0960310697555542,
0.8022465109825134,
-0.3105023205280304,
-0.27521780133247375,
0.7243926525115967,
0.03375924751162529,
0.23235666751861572,
0.42963865399360657,
0.24488024413585663,
-0.2553381323814392,
-0.911882221698761,
-0.22050200402736664,
0.3675357401371002,
-0.7551272511482239,
-0.43088820576667786,
-0.4313037395477295,
-0.2096935510635376,
-0.5831725001335144,
0.025942686945199966,
-0.17513617873191833,
-0.0953654870390892,
-0.1239190399646759,
-0.15519338846206665,
0.5441954731941223,
0.892463207244873,
0.16461728513240814,
0.1610879749059677,
-0.8367372751235962,
-0.04040050506591797,
0.31636354327201843,
0.593450665473938,
0.0043457550927996635,
-0.5847191214561462,
-0.42485618591308594,
0.006180293392390013,
-0.2973766326904297,
-0.5580632090568542,
0.3295679986476898,
-0.13526271283626556,
0.4810679852962494,
0.22298398613929749,
-0.00024026376195251942,
0.3156135678291321,
-0.3510025143623352,
0.5678325295448303,
0.168678879737854,
-0.8764751553535461,
0.26469579339027405,
-0.3981679677963257,
-0.07098411023616791,
0.5029546618461609,
0.23768582940101624,
-0.3957868814468384,
-0.6705654859542847,
-0.4316016733646393,
-0.7419499158859253,
0.6241273880004883,
0.13628047704696655,
-0.11925727128982544,
0.05557457357645035,
0.47805193066596985,
-0.06771817803382874,
0.20954081416130066,
-0.7841832637786865,
0.09323185682296753,
0.02768033556640148,
-0.46289870142936707,
-0.01583719626069069,
-0.2903766334056854,
-0.2720857858657837,
0.13024912774562836,
0.5959028005599976,
-0.12597036361694336,
-0.10713288187980652,
-0.07377594709396362,
-0.39154767990112305,
-0.11311916261911392,
0.2358022928237915,
0.12078726291656494,
0.8413493633270264,
-0.21321281790733337,
0.3306437134742737,
0.12226935476064682,
-0.5639249682426453,
0.05980686470866203,
0.14153926074504852,
-0.3500102758407593,
0.017425987869501114,
0.6154491305351257,
0.4682513177394867,
0.12946276366710663,
-0.6866547465324402,
0.6244263648986816,
0.2014051228761673,
-0.25038281083106995,
-0.3302968144416809,
-0.14069201052188873,
0.3283141851425171,
0.45190274715423584,
0.09844943135976791,
-0.239357128739357,
-0.11447488516569138,
-0.40989214181900024,
0.24968692660331726,
0.24897916615009308,
-0.050265997648239136,
-0.10097019374370575,
0.31517294049263,
0.11826779693365097,
-0.4084184169769287,
0.7435923218727112,
-0.19681298732757568,
-0.4469085931777954,
0.5213173031806946,
0.5830326676368713,
0.5309510827064514,
-0.15076273679733276,
0.10783407837152481,
0.11466346681118011,
0.15789714455604553,
-0.2815483510494232,
-0.017831426113843918,
0.127339169383049,
-0.8891814947128296,
-0.5902599692344666,
-0.6041932106018066,
-0.2980562150478363,
0.45289674401283264,
-0.576200008392334,
0.3826838433742523,
-0.50907963514328,
0.024979261681437492,
-0.06230812892317772,
0.10476379096508026,
-0.5763185024261475,
-0.09961768984794617,
0.24032849073410034,
0.8576276302337646,
-0.8668608069419861,
0.987744152545929,
0.6873493790626526,
-0.5795909762382507,
-0.6859955191612244,
-0.10455650091171265,
-0.16221347451210022,
-0.7918177247047424,
0.8485962748527527,
-0.1379518359899521,
-0.15663619339466095,
-0.09112301468849182,
-0.5131637454032898,
-0.8339950442314148,
1.2343261241912842,
0.9527304768562317,
-0.5389203429222107,
-0.10834679007530212,
0.13552433252334595,
0.6250550150871277,
-0.2896328270435333,
-0.24303409457206726,
0.590060830116272,
0.2870711386203766,
-0.10580533742904663,
-0.8774495124816895,
0.12035447359085083,
-0.0028124945238232613,
-0.20379303395748138,
0.07385148853063583,
-0.5339242815971375,
0.7520784735679626,
0.09889097511768341,
-0.2839966416358948,
0.04282220080494881,
0.469713419675827,
0.26016589999198914,
0.2052323818206787,
0.5336557626724243,
0.5754604339599609,
0.8990767598152161,
0.18169595301151276,
0.8433746099472046,
-0.4674133360385895,
0.567051887512207,
1.247035264968872,
-0.4806654155254364,
0.8053786754608154,
0.5371020436286926,
-0.2161227911710739,
0.5451871752738953,
0.21426111459732056,
-0.16306094825267792,
0.4267149269580841,
0.34650635719299316,
-0.12063751369714737,
-0.001059416332282126,
-0.23335953056812286,
-0.19681218266487122,
0.32995858788490295,
0.2578802704811096,
-0.6697472929954529,
-0.44055062532424927,
-0.18721386790275574,
0.07873745262622833,
0.3500542640686035,
-0.2989947199821472,
0.7168833613395691,
0.10545031726360321,
-0.46298375725746155,
0.45493194460868835,
-0.019951561465859413,
0.3386772572994232,
-0.5296667814254761,
0.20837396383285522,
-0.10624881833791733,
0.2796468436717987,
-0.2687316834926605,
-0.8893654942512512,
0.41629672050476074,
0.2540055215358734,
-0.22331225872039795,
-0.2668478190898895,
0.6503178477287292,
-0.509205162525177,
-0.2538190484046936,
0.6565835475921631,
0.5968070030212402,
0.017672564834356308,
0.08557421714067459,
-0.5267723798751831,
0.2220098227262497,
-0.1453302502632141,
-0.01776336319744587,
0.3671485483646393,
0.6152368187904358,
-0.1702684611082077,
0.5307130217552185,
0.5183488726615906,
0.3594844937324524,
-0.10613759607076645,
0.2518414258956909,
0.7035380601882935,
-0.3506690561771393,
-0.6373418569564819,
-0.8784896731376648,
-0.2453782707452774,
-0.41922563314437866,
-0.019747959449887276,
0.8140624761581421,
0.7508366107940674,
1.1922597885131836,
-0.011142765171825886,
1.01834237575531,
0.011762418784201145,
0.6824796199798584,
-0.5507105588912964,
0.8644946217536926,
-0.21735981106758118,
0.3607065975666046,
-0.20209605991840363,
-1.040359377861023,
-0.4647846221923828,
0.4957939088344574,
-0.5105335116386414,
-0.20825596153736115,
0.8970628380775452,
0.9342538118362427,
-0.1508648693561554,
-0.02591121569275856,
0.005298060365021229,
0.27693283557891846,
0.32336854934692383,
0.3311325013637543,
0.8032477498054504,
-0.02086791582405567,
0.9964662790298462,
-0.09540339559316635,
-0.07211064547300339,
-0.3220347762107849,
-0.9616658687591553,
-0.8781594634056091,
-0.46390581130981445,
-0.3412506580352783,
-0.6891486644744873,
0.11671867221593857,
0.7180771231651306,
0.3732393682003021,
-0.9614089727401733,
-0.2795323133468628,
-0.0841580182313919,
0.40952062606811523,
-0.07319420576095581,
-0.24327975511550903,
0.6249843239784241,
-0.13950695097446442,
-0.5487682819366455,
0.1586860865354538,
0.16625981032848358,
-0.021465718746185303,
-0.490624338388443,
0.036706555634737015,
-0.07522137463092804,
-0.2766965925693512,
0.6068080067634583,
0.120887890458107,
-0.39391037821769714,
-0.5889314413070679,
-0.21818538010120392,
-0.33382460474967957,
-0.13772374391555786,
1.0158871412277222,
-0.40336042642593384,
0.34565654397010803,
0.6611108183860779,
0.7713836431503296,
0.42709001898765564,
-0.3259292244911194,
0.6323519349098206,
-0.7966441512107849,
0.17643389105796814,
0.14547571539878845,
0.47424545884132385,
0.7611847519874573,
-0.20454338192939758,
0.41839247941970825,
0.4334210455417633,
-0.48241207003593445,
-0.7578074336051941,
0.2709551751613617,
-0.8588147759437561,
-0.21631211042404175,
1.329135775566101,
-0.5282764434814453,
-0.3241862952709198,
-0.2507369816303253,
-0.08705175668001175,
0.5144179463386536,
-0.3246806561946869,
0.8724510073661804,
0.7458120584487915,
0.4197271764278412,
0.10243608057498932,
-0.3741971552371979,
0.3318767249584198,
-0.13763366639614105,
-0.5677149295806885,
0.32084792852401733,
0.5391186475753784,
0.6812946796417236,
0.25631844997406006,
0.49804285168647766,
-0.26894837617874146,
0.01322339940816164,
-0.23796436190605164,
0.1963636875152588,
-0.4478667080402374,
0.05780257657170296,
-0.20714354515075684,
0.4107820987701416,
0.2765454649925232,
0.0483972430229187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02646v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02646v1 | A Practical Review of Mechanistic Interpretability for Transformer-Based Language Models | 2024-07-02T20:28:16 | 2024-07-02T20:28:16 | Daking Rai, Yilun Zhou, Shi Feng, Abulhair Saparov, Ziyu Yao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Mechanistic interpretability (MI) is an emerging sub-field of
interpretability that seeks to understand a neural network model by
reverse-engineering its internal computations. Recently, MI has garnered
significant attention for interpreting transformer-based language models (LMs),
resulting in many novel insights yet introducing new challenges. However, there
has not been work that comprehensively reviews these insights and challenges,
particularly as a guide for newcomers to this field. To fill this gap, we
present a comprehensive survey outlining fundamental objects of study in MI,
techniques that have been used for its investigation, approaches for evaluating
MI results, and significant findings and applications stemming from the use of
MI to understand LMs. In particular, we present a roadmap for beginners to
navigate the field and leverage MI for their benefit. Finally, we also identify
current gaps in the field and discuss potential future directions. | [
-0.16708461940288544,
-0.5556170344352722,
0.43720853328704834,
0.20941078662872314,
0.03967312350869179,
0.2003551423549652,
0.052555426955223083,
-0.5499643087387085,
0.10090488195419312,
0.47486522793769836,
-0.9677708745002747,
-0.05897656828165054,
-0.7742418050765991,
0.18784455955028534,
-0.6231930255889893,
0.9773246049880981,
-0.13331934809684753,
-0.06225449964404106,
-0.10997121036052704,
0.02580360881984234,
-0.49475112557411194,
-0.3759627640247345,
-0.38910722732543945,
-0.4909293055534363,
0.4679305851459503,
0.3960629105567932,
0.7499704360961914,
0.2411113828420639,
0.6382246017456055,
0.2901707589626312,
-0.42447948455810547,
-0.36791983246803284,
-0.3850138783454895,
0.15516765415668488,
-0.43298810720443726,
-0.799413800239563,
-0.2876943051815033,
0.14603157341480255,
0.49665823578834534,
1.1373034715652466,
-0.10145076364278793,
0.17694512009620667,
0.19814971089363098,
0.5262701511383057,
-0.5007068514823914,
0.17575587332248688,
-0.6519491076469421,
0.10047692805528641,
-0.3126866817474365,
-0.33136579394340515,
-0.6651608347892761,
0.0813448429107666,
0.45772451162338257,
-0.31003034114837646,
0.19089019298553467,
-0.05585717782378197,
0.5066943168640137,
0.1433049440383911,
-0.43735092878341675,
-0.4928264021873474,
-1.2321360111236572,
0.9569696187973022,
-0.7611284255981445,
0.5945801138877869,
0.15061165392398834,
0.8937919735908508,
-0.07244478911161423,
-0.9697587490081787,
-0.5766472220420837,
-0.09606291353702545,
-0.35460716485977173,
0.1526193767786026,
-0.5692573189735413,
0.0503634549677372,
0.0661841332912445,
0.45386409759521484,
-0.5175650715827942,
0.13395723700523376,
-0.5692586302757263,
-0.17263969779014587,
0.34707480669021606,
0.4990699887275696,
0.722846508026123,
-0.1989278346300125,
-0.10580144077539444,
-0.007148552220314741,
-0.6360428929328918,
0.17079564929008484,
0.2504245340824127,
0.25376197695732117,
-0.12044118344783783,
0.43047648668289185,
-0.23445826768875122,
0.5256840586662292,
-0.4344742000102997,
-0.09061145037412643,
-0.02613549679517746,
-0.4906494915485382,
-0.31322619318962097,
-0.39072394371032715,
0.5631536841392517,
0.22420552372932434,
0.3989754915237427,
-0.4736689627170563,
-0.19639602303504944,
-0.4905616044998169,
0.622342050075531,
-0.7124576568603516,
-0.058724239468574524,
0.2207481861114502,
-0.9703022837638855,
-0.4298728406429291,
0.03127117455005646,
-0.6111286282539368,
-0.07260772585868835,
-0.41717344522476196,
0.07017838954925537,
-0.36786267161369324,
-0.704837441444397,
0.01521485485136509,
-0.00013555963232647628,
0.48029524087905884,
0.1798245757818222,
-1.0278416872024536,
0.16112516820430756,
0.7359619140625,
0.968377947807312,
0.16097398102283478,
-0.5610935688018799,
0.20344661176204681,
-0.3478599786758423,
0.014801038429141045,
0.5220091342926025,
-0.3344535827636719,
-0.4266810417175293,
-0.1541593074798584,
0.058983538299798965,
-0.36118242144584656,
-0.33817094564437866,
0.576842725276947,
-0.5876622796058655,
-0.016892462968826294,
0.18743954598903656,
-0.31228113174438477,
-0.38753125071525574,
0.356586217880249,
-0.6861613988876343,
0.30665284395217896,
0.2973006069660187,
-0.6335507035255432,
0.10004470497369766,
-0.7177429795265198,
-0.301289439201355,
-0.1691698431968689,
0.0802367627620697,
0.025457892566919327,
0.283856064081192,
-0.23226207494735718,
0.4579678475856781,
-0.35805943608283997,
0.3473595380783081,
0.02551165409386158,
-0.34809431433677673,
0.5040342807769775,
-0.9193398952484131,
0.7864132523536682,
0.5489969849586487,
-0.301298588514328,
0.09270193427801132,
-0.8474465608596802,
-0.07479559630155563,
-0.09038800001144409,
0.029904432594776154,
-0.04986722394824028,
0.3415851891040802,
0.1422310322523117,
0.14504757523536682,
-0.021845253184437752,
-0.14465796947479248,
0.09990817308425903,
-0.6938139200210571,
0.7009480595588684,
0.5460691452026367,
-0.28962600231170654,
0.6989130973815918,
0.1392940878868103,
0.7873089909553528,
-0.02817857638001442,
0.4304337501525879,
-0.6201955080032349,
-0.4239822030067444,
-0.6141805052757263,
0.14294296503067017,
0.04440629854798317,
0.5989884734153748,
-0.9083253741264343,
0.2965511679649353,
-0.2653658390045166,
-0.8074458241462708,
-0.742608904838562,
-0.0416552908718586,
0.22574810683727264,
0.6438314318656921,
0.653986930847168,
0.33782804012298584,
-0.43282556533813477,
-1.23716139793396,
-0.7075787782669067,
-0.20423483848571777,
-0.1435321420431137,
0.2188860923051834,
0.5001481771469116,
-0.6669390201568604,
0.9459367394447327,
-0.24097828567028046,
-0.07123284041881561,
-0.6028956770896912,
0.36421558260917664,
0.5456678867340088,
0.46757978200912476,
0.31244492530822754,
-0.7064127326011658,
-0.12714572250843048,
-0.02494790591299534,
-0.8897217512130737,
-0.06696287542581558,
-0.23584133386611938,
0.3326699733734131,
-0.19990484416484833,
0.6436653733253479,
-0.32983556389808655,
0.5650126338005066,
0.5608590841293335,
-0.481608510017395,
0.5238956212997437,
-0.12803420424461365,
0.07006514817476273,
-0.9526530504226685,
0.21472813189029694,
-0.053776126354932785,
-0.028337659314274788,
-0.998179018497467,
0.2778608798980713,
-0.12642614543437958,
0.12597490847110748,
-0.6259838342666626,
0.4299449026584625,
-0.4523184299468994,
0.04908444732427597,
-0.4775369167327881,
-0.2769542336463928,
-0.06347896158695221,
0.035194896161556244,
-0.31680071353912354,
0.6335548758506775,
0.37444648146629333,
-0.6141461133956909,
0.015251081436872482,
0.22199983894824982,
-0.46265730261802673,
0.4178759753704071,
-0.8201442956924438,
-0.20712225139141083,
-0.1977572739124298,
0.1467479020357132,
-0.8426125049591064,
-0.04731479659676552,
0.5108029842376709,
-0.511343240737915,
0.4509965479373932,
-0.21040081977844238,
-0.15906427800655365,
-0.19727787375450134,
0.031435370445251465,
0.6235373020172119,
0.4158961772918701,
-0.5857230424880981,
0.8716052770614624,
0.042488086968660355,
-0.08638665080070496,
-0.8154263496398926,
-0.7924520969390869,
0.24030356109142303,
-0.12765520811080933,
-0.6379125118255615,
0.08846618235111237,
-0.045265182852745056,
-0.5778974890708923,
-0.16815148293972015,
-0.11223476380109787,
-0.013863694854080677,
0.6669789552688599,
0.12173783034086227,
0.033448994159698486,
-0.33362722396850586,
-0.11640814691781998,
0.11964723467826843,
-0.6882842779159546,
0.28686395287513733,
0.15888448059558868,
0.36429867148399353,
-0.47645679116249084,
-0.4199579060077667,
-0.43943631649017334,
0.09912149608135223,
0.6528060436248779,
0.04715834558010101,
0.7416865229606628,
0.4282142221927643,
-0.3242742419242859,
-0.034469008445739746,
-0.14800786972045898,
-0.4259752631187439,
-0.4462721347808838,
0.3806407153606415,
-0.6777946352958679,
-0.6578944325447083,
0.4753457009792328,
-0.19834004342556,
0.07696396112442017,
0.7056052684783936,
0.42587801814079285,
-0.4868846833705902,
0.8845705986022949,
0.79200279712677,
0.08870061486959457,
0.20654262602329254,
-0.21741983294487,
0.5888211131095886,
-0.7575854659080505,
-0.5088409781455994,
-0.6240746378898621,
-0.5472294092178345,
-0.6328023672103882,
-0.25003135204315186,
0.1969471573829651,
0.19804783165454865,
0.20197570323944092,
0.35359495878219604,
-0.43860334157943726,
0.4642372131347656,
0.2708359956741333,
-0.27617141604423523,
0.3887486457824707,
-0.3837384283542633,
0.15786539018154144,
-0.34281739592552185,
-0.5175260901451111,
-0.839442789554596,
0.8436784744262695,
0.8225892186164856,
1.0159425735473633,
0.18046298623085022,
0.12058277428150177,
0.014307670295238495,
0.615193247795105,
-1.0279840230941772,
0.23276273906230927,
-0.02783532254397869,
-0.6527115702629089,
-0.3364337980747223,
-0.505121648311615,
-1.0058335065841675,
0.4713314473628998,
-0.25463569164276123,
-0.9498719573020935,
-0.013958952389657497,
0.1978996992111206,
0.19387158751487732,
0.5561873912811279,
-0.640205442905426,
0.8638073205947876,
-0.3363051116466522,
0.2101534605026245,
-0.22850465774536133,
-0.8637406229972839,
0.5093598961830139,
0.16803815960884094,
0.47349482774734497,
0.009269352070987225,
0.22758139669895172,
0.5300341248512268,
-0.3070993721485138,
0.8710218667984009,
-0.12331332266330719,
-0.3307598829269409,
0.1775917261838913,
0.1981360763311386,
0.09886939078569412,
-0.26289162039756775,
-0.04916888475418091,
0.5811493992805481,
0.42217570543289185,
-0.06951145827770233,
-0.9503087401390076,
0.47345876693725586,
-0.5249042510986328,
-0.48891282081604004,
-0.3450496196746826,
-0.6172270178794861,
-0.04944439232349396,
0.25485819578170776,
0.36129656434059143,
0.32781851291656494,
-0.32705920934677124,
0.2347986251115799,
0.4659232795238495,
-0.2940728962421417,
0.3825299143791199,
0.6148450374603271,
-0.3162144720554352,
0.002658569486811757,
1.0050629377365112,
0.19367776811122894,
0.03250281512737274,
0.6688761711120605,
0.30431389808654785,
-0.3404129147529602,
-0.7216957211494446,
-0.49276888370513916,
-0.0481666699051857,
-0.730657696723938,
0.25713133811950684,
-0.5141567587852478,
-0.2778165340423584,
0.0392589345574379,
0.07052547484636307,
-0.4788229465484619,
-0.40606385469436646,
-0.3230011761188507,
0.003357326379045844,
-0.13515082001686096,
0.9013395309448242,
0.3075311779975891,
0.7485077977180481,
-0.9089664220809937,
-0.08427559584379196,
-0.1147826686501503,
0.5473625659942627,
0.2026459276676178,
-0.6098755598068237,
-0.25390708446502686,
0.21448831260204315,
-0.3175363540649414,
-0.8808193802833557,
0.20506130158901215,
-0.12670613825321198,
0.7306483387947083,
0.7335450053215027,
-0.1856762319803238,
0.4182594120502472,
-0.4705953001976013,
0.6649349331855774,
0.17534175515174866,
-1.1452692747116089,
0.6042429804801941,
-0.09674911946058273,
-0.08356351405382156,
0.558802604675293,
0.4862147569656372,
-0.6408733129501343,
-0.2960612177848816,
-0.7270115613937378,
-0.890482485294342,
0.6286854147911072,
0.421983003616333,
0.40015557408332825,
0.33155760169029236,
0.5365796089172363,
0.3151610195636749,
0.058755986392498016,
-0.7429746985435486,
-0.4705469012260437,
-0.10325639694929123,
-0.2801192104816437,
-0.24201631546020508,
-0.2945527732372284,
0.12149837613105774,
-0.12126637250185013,
0.49366626143455505,
-0.2386503964662552,
0.13699690997600555,
-0.10693801194429398,
-0.5306743383407593,
0.09594781696796417,
0.4609360098838806,
0.7134220600128174,
0.9373579025268555,
-0.3702434301376343,
0.39099058508872986,
0.06922660022974014,
-0.2622748017311096,
0.015014717355370522,
-0.13960722088813782,
-0.31145748496055603,
0.008241559378802776,
0.6792964935302734,
0.6799812912940979,
0.4453723430633545,
-0.7439103722572327,
0.37414711713790894,
-0.10947398841381073,
-0.0069586425088346004,
-0.10597696900367737,
-0.0274784155189991,
-0.02331831492483616,
0.33157819509506226,
0.2750062346458435,
0.10709717124700546,
0.5243992805480957,
-0.7307606935501099,
0.03739291802048683,
0.4749222993850708,
-0.5878238677978516,
-0.7931426763534546,
0.642097532749176,
0.18568092584609985,
-0.38058680295944214,
0.6949946880340576,
0.28348278999328613,
-0.4042285084724426,
0.5414333939552307,
0.5152668952941895,
0.8578833341598511,
-0.2343340814113617,
0.08052074164152145,
0.14318512380123138,
0.7903726696968079,
0.18382512032985687,
0.026869554072618484,
0.049545686691999435,
-0.7942262291908264,
-0.3648856580257416,
-0.41230881214141846,
-0.7231163382530212,
0.12523074448108673,
-0.8846403956413269,
0.19863009452819824,
-0.1339116096496582,
0.1573893129825592,
0.16347308456897736,
-0.5703030824661255,
-0.4114609658718109,
0.46543624997138977,
-0.2037373036146164,
1.1128566265106201,
-0.8712563514709473,
0.4957321584224701,
0.6237351894378662,
-0.6024101376533508,
-0.4747643768787384,
0.04888749495148659,
-0.02019389532506466,
-0.9872475862503052,
0.40005096793174744,
0.24916359782218933,
-0.1913403421640396,
-0.20221452414989471,
-0.4566492736339569,
-0.5169365406036377,
1.3740211725234985,
0.2563558518886566,
-0.5118211507797241,
-0.11603964865207672,
0.3036113381385803,
0.7046627998352051,
-0.09933265298604965,
0.9511713981628418,
0.8786128759384155,
0.4435281455516815,
-0.0013493540463969111,
-0.6795734167098999,
-0.11425408720970154,
-0.36052167415618896,
-0.15735049545764923,
0.1601860076189041,
-0.42361214756965637,
0.7313902974128723,
-0.14102599024772644,
-0.2609981894493103,
0.02856624312698841,
0.6497802734375,
-0.09646201878786087,
0.7306034564971924,
0.5197563767433167,
0.06300147622823715,
0.4953906536102295,
-0.08801395446062088,
1.1345860958099365,
-0.47220054268836975,
0.47553905844688416,
1.0152153968811035,
0.3141360282897949,
0.8408963680267334,
0.7993974089622498,
-0.3075007498264313,
0.46553856134414673,
0.48641282320022583,
-0.019047658890485764,
0.22130703926086426,
0.31058865785598755,
0.07739810645580292,
-0.17952506244182587,
0.10478702932596207,
-0.28127917647361755,
0.5711337924003601,
0.4632575213909149,
-0.5914559960365295,
-0.435577392578125,
-0.02297499217092991,
-0.13335442543029785,
-0.16045473515987396,
-0.2048502415418625,
0.5491410493850708,
0.406803697347641,
-0.33264848589897156,
0.08906752616167068,
0.15500330924987793,
0.7263869643211365,
-0.3914651572704315,
-0.1583067923784256,
-0.11744087934494019,
0.15325258672237396,
-0.3653915226459503,
-1.0292941331863403,
1.0423226356506348,
-0.08083990961313248,
-0.4731939435005188,
-0.5822417140007019,
0.9922667741775513,
0.010224797762930393,
-0.36565789580345154,
0.426310271024704,
1.0095081329345703,
0.4317532181739807,
-0.13792400062084198,
-0.5472283363342285,
-0.19995494186878204,
-0.06526146084070206,
-0.29886025190353394,
0.1875784695148468,
0.1383771151304245,
0.1196422353386879,
1.1664953231811523,
0.5477744340896606,
-0.23902970552444458,
-0.21377430856227875,
0.11135265231132507,
0.5628999471664429,
-0.9146263599395752,
-0.1641637086868286,
-1.1655352115631104,
0.7871335744857788,
0.5371325612068176,
-0.24512411653995514,
0.5147618651390076,
0.14922288060188293,
0.5506431460380554,
-0.20667025446891785,
0.7826765179634094,
0.06747452169656754,
0.428920716047287,
-0.6599510312080383,
1.0014621019363403,
-0.4983941614627838,
0.46510621905326843,
-0.09339196979999542,
-0.8331632614135742,
-0.2180502712726593,
0.6494201421737671,
-0.1848558932542801,
-0.024772832170128822,
0.40998631715774536,
0.5720006227493286,
-0.30568233132362366,
0.33317431807518005,
0.47100013494491577,
0.33668094873428345,
0.4325059950351715,
0.23138000071048737,
1.4160528182983398,
-0.49905264377593994,
0.6876065731048584,
-0.13002106547355652,
-0.30910879373550415,
-0.20843052864074707,
-0.9730073809623718,
-0.664337694644928,
-0.4956338703632355,
0.0014115325175225735,
-0.41633379459381104,
-0.499347448348999,
0.7030453085899353,
0.5447424650192261,
-0.9674397706985474,
-0.16787666082382202,
-0.24496415257453918,
0.4698159992694855,
-0.19405688345432281,
-0.2698521912097931,
-0.052894268184900284,
-0.26729342341423035,
-0.8019011616706848,
0.579456627368927,
0.17649242281913757,
0.06791633367538452,
-0.44707420468330383,
-0.154473677277565,
0.19017599523067474,
0.027024250477552414,
0.6655020713806152,
0.33707258105278015,
-0.7678403854370117,
-0.007568798493593931,
0.3512515723705292,
0.250119686126709,
-0.15229865908622742,
1.1199558973312378,
-0.3877711892127991,
0.537255048751831,
0.37956079840660095,
0.7411932945251465,
0.13526254892349243,
-0.4405505955219269,
0.8584527969360352,
-0.4303998351097107,
-0.21225260198116302,
0.16757084429264069,
0.6259202361106873,
0.12958690524101257,
-0.14105920493602753,
0.7576079964637756,
0.22285829484462738,
-0.289429247379303,
-0.8666326403617859,
0.36050331592559814,
-0.9308131337165833,
-0.22298189997673035,
0.8625656962394714,
-0.18439877033233643,
0.13578751683235168,
-0.2410542517900467,
0.004588644485920668,
0.17505007982254028,
0.33956068754196167,
0.5323026776313782,
0.727627694606781,
-0.20097316801548004,
-0.342672199010849,
-0.5874209403991699,
0.10848675668239594,
0.4247521162033081,
-0.8535650968551636,
-0.07850350439548492,
-0.05145491659641266,
0.4047671854496002,
0.44180622696876526,
0.2964971959590912,
0.011517881415784359,
-0.059084195643663406,
-0.0924203023314476,
0.08056802302598953,
0.04786016792058945,
-0.43824729323387146,
-0.6448251605033875,
-0.14416269958019257,
0.2526714503765106,
0.08013365417718887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02637v1 | Change My Frame: Reframing in the Wild in r/ChangeMyView | 2024-07-02T20:09:11 | 2024-07-02T20:09:11 | Arturo Martínez Peguero, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, 68T50, I.2.7 | Recent work in reframing, within the scope of text style transfer, has so far
made use of out-of-context, task-prompted utterances in order to produce
neutralizing or optimistic reframes. Our work aims to generalize reframing
based on the subreddit r/ChangeMyView (CMV). We build a dataset that leverages
CMV's community's interactions and conventions to identify high-value,
community-recognized utterances that produce changes of perspective. With this
data, we widen the scope of the direction of reframing since the changes in
perspective do not only occur in neutral or positive directions. We fine tune
transformer-based models, make use of a modern LLM to refine our dataset, and
explore challenges in the dataset creation and evaluation around this type of
reframing. | [
-0.4683026969432831,
-0.791628360748291,
0.490830659866333,
-0.03556356579065323,
-0.18126949667930603,
-0.1682044416666031,
-0.22053326666355133,
-0.42543911933898926,
0.6673138737678528,
0.7706246972084045,
-0.8689090013504028,
-0.3186630308628082,
-0.714908242225647,
0.346587598323822,
-0.44627973437309265,
1.0364024639129639,
-0.23152676224708557,
0.14416329562664032,
-0.027615629136562347,
-0.31962522864341736,
-0.8904982209205627,
-0.35200735926628113,
-0.3020683825016022,
-0.34527909755706787,
0.6430954933166504,
0.7320914268493652,
0.6468110680580139,
0.4538181722164154,
0.6428967714309692,
0.159864142537117,
-0.015195493586361408,
-0.08256751298904419,
-0.6866803765296936,
0.28130409121513367,
-0.637928307056427,
-0.6812468767166138,
-0.06776612251996994,
0.2505125105381012,
0.2784355580806732,
0.6354742050170898,
-0.2941761016845703,
0.5585809946060181,
-0.23715084791183472,
0.7719854116439819,
-0.5329963564872742,
0.34058329463005066,
-0.9654098749160767,
0.23441553115844727,
-0.19122357666492462,
-0.16677583754062653,
-0.42475488781929016,
-0.2501486837863922,
0.054633233696222305,
-0.7107238173484802,
0.4827118217945099,
0.22956009209156036,
0.6869633197784424,
0.15085284411907196,
-0.5907806754112244,
-0.08283033221960068,
-1.0366593599319458,
0.7972667813301086,
-0.3981521427631378,
0.37803736329078674,
0.21733516454696655,
0.5079671144485474,
0.009376809000968933,
-0.9007691144943237,
-0.6282104849815369,
0.3780162036418915,
-0.04011440649628639,
0.12647207081317902,
-0.5477215647697449,
-0.3703230321407318,
0.3466954529285431,
0.30957379937171936,
-0.25189638137817383,
-0.4429737329483032,
-0.3568209707736969,
0.02255711518228054,
0.46538782119750977,
0.42504578828811646,
0.014239211566746235,
-0.283254474401474,
-0.36626604199409485,
-0.29867544770240784,
-0.39981067180633545,
0.05754312872886658,
0.21653272211551666,
0.16185161471366882,
0.10627084225416183,
0.7737128138542175,
-0.45473983883857727,
0.6700217127799988,
0.32522863149642944,
-0.06888803094625473,
0.3437437117099762,
-0.5460239052772522,
-0.309806227684021,
-0.22027179598808289,
0.003386062104254961,
1.1804968118667603,
0.34625715017318726,
-0.02484886907041073,
-0.09710093587636948,
0.09217418730258942,
0.5909846425056458,
-0.7909189462661743,
-0.285908579826355,
-0.3879724442958832,
-0.7852551937103271,
-0.5784201622009277,
0.026794232428073883,
-0.867068886756897,
-0.7601096034049988,
-0.7193155288696289,
0.19252809882164001,
-0.27957969903945923,
-0.22930432856082916,
0.11043926328420639,
-0.15013563632965088,
0.6436998248100281,
0.5395649671554565,
-0.9484747648239136,
0.13560235500335693,
0.4306529760360718,
0.5185143947601318,
-0.21387310326099396,
0.07525850087404251,
-0.19086284935474396,
-0.17935992777347565,
-0.3273211121559143,
0.8345195055007935,
-0.8734800219535828,
-0.4808313548564911,
0.04612293839454651,
0.33271849155426025,
0.025392772629857063,
-0.7869645953178406,
0.4257587194442749,
-0.5707467198371887,
0.392971396446228,
-0.49188530445098877,
-0.1709752082824707,
-0.17809700965881348,
0.4223317503929138,
-0.5184480547904968,
0.7217048406600952,
0.11294013261795044,
-0.7409563064575195,
0.5745654106140137,
-0.45558446645736694,
-0.37526845932006836,
-0.2005165070295334,
-0.15309812128543854,
-0.17934972047805786,
0.20445239543914795,
0.10949856787919998,
0.14164984226226807,
-0.07774349302053452,
0.3198094666004181,
-0.16987110674381256,
-0.13126109540462494,
0.6852232217788696,
-0.5163703560829163,
0.1353115290403366,
0.3775731921195984,
-0.008054545149207115,
0.1804477870464325,
-0.9291054606437683,
-0.06769631803035736,
-0.07154934108257294,
-0.0739903673529625,
-0.3155181407928467,
0.07083972543478012,
0.3238446116447449,
0.19169101119041443,
0.018150804564356804,
-0.6192232370376587,
0.464246541261673,
-0.24419979751110077,
0.6387816071510315,
0.6975504159927368,
0.4002895951271057,
0.6983253359794617,
-0.44423142075538635,
0.4026584327220917,
0.25381559133529663,
0.24696055054664612,
-0.3381713330745697,
-0.6798834204673767,
-0.5208398103713989,
0.09769586473703384,
-0.05504896864295006,
0.47992080450057983,
-0.8096133470535278,
-0.08102414757013321,
-0.03942607715725899,
-0.12222013622522354,
-0.5333602428436279,
-0.03979885205626488,
0.006827421020716429,
0.8207741975784302,
0.6935562491416931,
-0.6004480123519897,
-0.7212994694709778,
-1.067484736442566,
-0.2926830053329468,
0.1635608673095703,
-0.009928704239428043,
0.15922021865844727,
0.3704053461551666,
-0.5610896944999695,
1.235316514968872,
-0.9154604077339172,
-0.2592596411705017,
-0.18779420852661133,
0.2146577090024948,
0.15140551328659058,
0.4493383467197418,
0.31507575511932373,
-1.1983100175857544,
-0.11153668165206909,
-0.3183397650718689,
-0.5053398609161377,
-0.09675776213407516,
-0.40763112902641296,
-0.29164162278175354,
-0.0008546181488782167,
0.8184018731117249,
-0.38921859860420227,
0.5672480463981628,
0.5413509607315063,
-0.6049937605857849,
0.5222941637039185,
0.1380215287208557,
0.40497642755508423,
-1.2711358070373535,
-0.1836790293455124,
-0.12489195913076401,
-0.22089123725891113,
-0.4188650846481323,
0.01476127840578556,
-0.1468701958656311,
-0.05156060308218002,
-0.5058099627494812,
0.4541114866733551,
-0.25582170486450195,
0.18684037029743195,
-0.26780903339385986,
0.2750202715396881,
0.2932966947555542,
0.43107178807258606,
-0.008232858031988144,
0.5142898559570312,
0.24173805117607117,
-0.09632646292448044,
0.4159342646598816,
0.5706824660301208,
-0.28521597385406494,
0.6260400414466858,
-0.09550442546606064,
0.1005929559469223,
-0.5320711731910706,
0.5591593980789185,
-1.1124539375305176,
-0.36677315831184387,
0.7162788510322571,
-0.2950035333633423,
0.2173599898815155,
-0.2086929976940155,
-0.13119424879550934,
-0.12163256853818893,
-0.29200267791748047,
0.5737832188606262,
0.36982595920562744,
-0.527683675289154,
0.534783124923706,
0.282866895198822,
-0.0008692882838658988,
-0.4647327959537506,
-1.1426221132278442,
0.33881184458732605,
-0.287185937166214,
-0.48340633511543274,
0.6598944664001465,
-0.20924821496009827,
-0.634544312953949,
0.19520610570907593,
-0.16646352410316467,
-0.0746069923043251,
-0.31899958848953247,
0.40510866045951843,
0.12060995399951935,
-0.2952820360660553,
0.031877513974905014,
-0.02182868868112564,
-0.13496743142604828,
0.15602436661720276,
-0.22027407586574554,
0.41634318232536316,
-0.04975581541657448,
-0.2212972342967987,
-0.2788415849208832,
0.3255295157432556,
0.4463474154472351,
-0.28144705295562744,
0.7045016884803772,
0.4064796268939972,
-0.30041396617889404,
-0.21078984439373016,
-0.5745130181312561,
-0.34107649326324463,
-0.440603107213974,
0.34428972005844116,
-0.21864637732505798,
-0.9566542506217957,
0.5027635097503662,
-0.07028017193078995,
0.04385848715901375,
0.03661845251917839,
0.5545109510421753,
0.0006192734581418335,
0.7391831874847412,
0.8889585733413696,
0.2314600646495819,
0.7723588347434998,
-0.05915163829922676,
0.33432576060295105,
-0.8874614238739014,
-0.1873784214258194,
-0.1523299515247345,
-0.6324796676635742,
-0.7586777806282043,
-0.8329755663871765,
0.05129995197057724,
-0.23160474002361298,
0.1777399331331253,
0.4063701331615448,
-0.5219845175743103,
0.5764169692993164,
0.15718595683574677,
0.1951638013124466,
0.5247842073440552,
-0.19072337448596954,
0.28316858410835266,
-0.6394526958465576,
-0.36977702379226685,
-0.5625572204589844,
1.1416960954666138,
0.1303952932357788,
0.8529231548309326,
0.09189052879810333,
0.5387552976608276,
0.3511875569820404,
0.9985058903694153,
-0.9334738254547119,
0.5499803423881531,
-0.050700295716524124,
-0.5505088567733765,
0.04742005839943886,
-0.3048561215400696,
-0.8300716876983643,
0.3136800229549408,
-0.5656145811080933,
-0.3496124744415283,
0.2129540741443634,
0.013364480808377266,
-0.02093404158949852,
0.4958155155181885,
-0.5443884134292603,
0.8512483835220337,
0.33747047185897827,
-0.16696810722351074,
-0.394181489944458,
-0.6525346636772156,
0.45137378573417664,
0.0072511727921664715,
0.340243935585022,
-0.27631068229675293,
0.1757701188325882,
0.335347980260849,
0.14135318994522095,
1.0415804386138916,
-0.01935979537665844,
0.06056671217083931,
0.5284438133239746,
0.3273344337940216,
0.1145198792219162,
0.2753152847290039,
-0.11820313334465027,
0.03903849795460701,
-0.06612415611743927,
-0.1341428905725479,
-0.5122839212417603,
0.5888705849647522,
-0.5482810735702515,
-0.7264930605888367,
-0.2701893448829651,
-0.47615185379981995,
-0.30045533180236816,
0.11472440510988235,
0.2021101862192154,
0.5958868861198425,
-0.6917375326156616,
0.18520353734493256,
0.7731188535690308,
-0.11947418749332428,
0.4146730601787567,
0.5141043663024902,
-0.6698286533355713,
-0.22654199600219727,
0.6105400919914246,
0.1418973058462143,
0.22181709110736847,
0.6252012848854065,
0.11591926962137222,
-0.06963686645030975,
-0.2478189915418625,
-0.45453640818595886,
-0.15927754342556,
-1.063979148864746,
-0.21082212030887604,
0.037424132227897644,
-0.009058783762156963,
-0.4407191276550293,
-0.4299986660480499,
-0.16357533633708954,
-0.5416120886802673,
-0.2245071977376938,
-0.29050111770629883,
0.33048009872436523,
0.7888635993003845,
0.22470161318778992,
-0.005472695920616388,
-0.6104016304016113,
0.3095182776451111,
0.4222155809402466,
0.10113109648227692,
-0.4312922954559326,
-0.615411102771759,
-0.058230526745319366,
-0.0005450090393424034,
-0.3649037182331085,
-0.7826179265975952,
0.5625407099723816,
-0.0255142729729414,
0.20043998956680298,
0.20238837599754333,
0.13575248420238495,
0.6074539422988892,
-0.6563963294029236,
0.8246058225631714,
0.33548492193222046,
-0.7070521116256714,
0.30001458525657654,
-0.21260803937911987,
0.48419350385665894,
0.6007261872291565,
-0.06456224620342255,
-1.0468769073486328,
-0.46757787466049194,
-0.5668466091156006,
-0.8194417953491211,
0.3221921920776367,
0.10484074801206589,
0.6136906147003174,
0.04189562052488327,
0.8090940713882446,
0.26157641410827637,
0.31193116307258606,
-0.7658575773239136,
-0.1845308542251587,
-0.5548539161682129,
-0.23872075974941254,
0.1560196578502655,
0.04534962400794029,
-0.44981223344802856,
-0.33229881525039673,
0.23461070656776428,
-0.45606333017349243,
0.2263977825641632,
0.38814085721969604,
-0.0209165308624506,
-0.3808521032333374,
0.4631972908973694,
0.5782876014709473,
0.7617775201797485,
-0.0489809587597847,
0.36270105838775635,
0.36898812651634216,
-0.4306749999523163,
-0.19832345843315125,
-0.2572580575942993,
-0.24463088810443878,
-0.022145548835396767,
0.17570580542087555,
0.6274367570877075,
0.5708574056625366,
-0.549102783203125,
0.5616730451583862,
-0.32495972514152527,
-0.1359349936246872,
-0.33022308349609375,
0.24107398092746735,
-0.051342759281396866,
0.3510552644729614,
0.1299603283405304,
0.9184319972991943,
0.0857163593173027,
-0.6792631149291992,
0.30157339572906494,
0.17900830507278442,
-0.4572998583316803,
-0.5062727928161621,
0.8409051299095154,
0.33169206976890564,
-0.12572503089904785,
0.5510653257369995,
-0.04294396936893463,
-0.01896531507372856,
0.4668155610561371,
0.564664363861084,
1.0247852802276611,
0.23838423192501068,
0.18627776205539703,
0.36603012681007385,
0.11704303324222565,
0.13770022988319397,
-0.11142626404762268,
-0.10995588451623917,
-1.1974104642868042,
-0.4462427794933319,
-0.8034751415252686,
-0.6148308515548706,
-0.10320882499217987,
-0.9542834758758545,
0.47471874952316284,
-0.49027514457702637,
-0.22276028990745544,
-0.05405775457620621,
-0.4382036030292511,
-0.4942644536495209,
0.363569438457489,
0.572506844997406,
0.9987415671348572,
-0.7743037343025208,
1.0191491842269897,
0.9184669256210327,
-0.18833480775356293,
-0.4401516616344452,
0.42604708671569824,
0.28574493527412415,
-0.9310219287872314,
0.3836100995540619,
0.26934272050857544,
-0.513207197189331,
-0.19591067731380463,
-0.8895267844200134,
-0.8031589984893799,
1.2599232196807861,
-0.028414228931069374,
-0.5816450715065002,
-0.043791189789772034,
0.1070232167840004,
0.6619030833244324,
-0.7425402402877808,
-0.0715976357460022,
0.4331808090209961,
0.5148693919181824,
0.16751012206077576,
-0.3639576733112335,
0.07405610382556915,
-0.05100316181778908,
0.22753338515758514,
0.1644338071346283,
-0.8538781404495239,
0.7275119423866272,
-0.20776642858982086,
-0.1817944049835205,
-0.20062433183193207,
0.946549654006958,
-0.25334081053733826,
0.45045310258865356,
0.40048646926879883,
0.4534129202365875,
0.45023781061172485,
-0.05128795653581619,
0.6615517735481262,
-0.3275752365589142,
0.35142579674720764,
0.9060260057449341,
-0.27084630727767944,
0.9482483267784119,
0.7162106037139893,
0.3096461594104767,
0.7427799105644226,
0.21829387545585632,
-0.009501111693680286,
0.5936552882194519,
0.08940696716308594,
-0.24680538475513458,
-0.202101469039917,
0.12172047793865204,
-0.2480899840593338,
0.40686777234077454,
0.19609805941581726,
-0.24297092854976654,
-0.22798921167850494,
0.3357499837875366,
0.34860485792160034,
0.43953371047973633,
-0.3438407778739929,
0.5012038946151733,
0.16873985528945923,
-0.6834961175918579,
0.15293292701244354,
0.3277224004268646,
0.8202691674232483,
-0.5517981648445129,
-0.13081833720207214,
-0.2870672047138214,
0.46512308716773987,
-0.39897745847702026,
-1.0095646381378174,
0.9180549383163452,
-0.11447659879922867,
-0.6442016959190369,
-1.1399365663528442,
0.7571388483047485,
-0.5197508335113525,
-0.28528597950935364,
0.2911485433578491,
0.3476930558681488,
-0.29465004801750183,
0.04994579777121544,
-0.5802547335624695,
0.1909390538930893,
0.27617841958999634,
-0.4895780384540558,
0.506313145160675,
0.4885607063770294,
-0.1975187510251999,
0.3742923438549042,
0.5197931528091431,
-0.37049439549446106,
-0.057291120290756226,
0.09057941287755966,
0.9114908576011658,
-0.8765428066253662,
-0.17538094520568848,
-0.5420699119567871,
0.33722156286239624,
0.19536638259887695,
-0.8687626719474792,
0.7878178954124451,
0.35090625286102295,
1.0199826955795288,
-0.19513750076293945,
0.558418333530426,
-0.3839494287967682,
0.3164551854133606,
-0.5923172235488892,
0.614836573600769,
-0.4723891019821167,
0.10072914510965347,
-0.09684298932552338,
-0.7761588096618652,
-0.40796762704849243,
0.5612548589706421,
-0.39218923449516296,
-0.506547749042511,
0.5003321766853333,
0.9455412030220032,
0.05161682143807411,
0.5456467866897583,
0.38275474309921265,
0.48893123865127563,
0.3085639178752899,
0.11455312371253967,
0.7975016236305237,
-0.2074921727180481,
0.6131352782249451,
-0.31889450550079346,
-0.3995611071586609,
-0.1311873495578766,
-0.9532419443130493,
-0.41284847259521484,
-0.7638311386108398,
-0.5529788732528687,
-0.43336042761802673,
-0.17171834409236908,
0.9752755761146545,
0.510628879070282,
-0.814612627029419,
-0.18035872280597687,
-0.12828975915908813,
0.020532064139842987,
-0.2326618880033493,
-0.3497103154659271,
-0.40015286207199097,
-0.27117836475372314,
-0.5255963206291199,
0.4939305782318115,
0.1731812208890915,
-0.2793332040309906,
-0.184590145945549,
0.36432549357414246,
0.02021082490682602,
0.3801085352897644,
0.8180315494537354,
0.22962135076522827,
-0.3999859392642975,
-0.8790081143379211,
0.14228905737400055,
-0.16634537279605865,
0.4267810583114624,
1.107153058052063,
-0.7559005618095398,
0.5888919830322266,
0.3804064095020294,
0.25048577785491943,
0.7583225965499878,
0.23321141302585602,
0.5024078488349915,
-0.6629769206047058,
0.12324943393468857,
0.09945162385702133,
0.18963775038719177,
0.36161065101623535,
-0.15825094282627106,
0.32966288924217224,
0.7185976505279541,
-0.6448756456375122,
-0.5360130071640015,
0.5965477228164673,
-0.9657156467437744,
-0.33554691076278687,
1.0019199848175049,
0.27333498001098633,
-0.3134251534938812,
0.049282874912023544,
-0.5917633175849915,
-0.016098594292998314,
-0.22747540473937988,
0.7709407210350037,
0.860997200012207,
-0.7680978775024414,
-0.03795349597930908,
-0.6002357006072998,
0.37296196818351746,
0.2906263470649719,
-0.6926708221435547,
0.1946299821138382,
0.6486655473709106,
0.6914016604423523,
0.1917509287595749,
0.42204713821411133,
-0.24320478737354279,
-0.28276553750038147,
-0.016426341608166695,
0.09469014406204224,
0.24676072597503662,
-0.31179049611091614,
-0.45988768339157104,
0.12355656921863556,
-0.13146033883094788,
-0.06180843338370323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02631v1 | Nollywood: Let's Go to the Movies! | 2024-07-02T19:50:55 | 2024-07-02T19:50:55 | John E. Ortega, Ibrahim Said Ahmad, William Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Nollywood, based on the idea of Bollywood from India, is a series of
outstanding movies that originate from Nigeria. Unfortunately, while the movies
are in English, they are hard to understand for many native speakers due to the
dialect of English that is spoken. In this article, we accomplish two goals:
(1) create a phonetic sub-title model that is able to translate Nigerian
English speech to American English and (2) use the most advanced toxicity
detectors to discover how toxic the speech is. Our aim is to highlight the text
in these videos which is often times ignored for lack of dialectal
understanding due the fact that many people in Nigeria speak a native language
like Hausa at home. | [
-0.17760363221168518,
-0.6611626744270325,
0.32524189352989197,
-0.16463260352611542,
-0.4698939025402069,
0.14754842221736908,
0.08077767491340637,
-0.2535835802555084,
0.3832978904247284,
0.800780177116394,
-0.861589789390564,
-0.18871308863162994,
-0.6595047116279602,
0.3149438798427582,
-0.39113128185272217,
1.1912624835968018,
0.017937572672963142,
0.005111756268888712,
0.12127416580915451,
-0.05495670065283775,
0.02452615089714527,
-0.31539878249168396,
-0.5656118392944336,
-0.0802030861377716,
0.6368846297264099,
0.2555676996707916,
1.0734854936599731,
0.5381330251693726,
0.27615079283714294,
0.19621415436267853,
-0.17587338387966156,
-0.0506773442029953,
-0.715020477771759,
0.060598842799663544,
-0.592879056930542,
-0.497486412525177,
-0.053804051131010056,
-0.1297265589237213,
0.21162855625152588,
0.49875879287719727,
-0.0934615358710289,
0.13922643661499023,
-0.30991625785827637,
0.44324058294296265,
-0.6039177179336548,
-0.025810830295085907,
-0.6402873992919922,
0.3691549003124237,
-0.26824888586997986,
-0.1116052120923996,
-0.10685151815414429,
-0.22437122464179993,
0.0113935312256217,
-0.7452467679977417,
0.13467222452163696,
-0.1738206446170807,
1.1440913677215576,
0.20153562724590302,
-0.6057643890380859,
-0.3223184645175934,
-0.5326618552207947,
0.9312714338302612,
-0.6643829345703125,
0.45205357670783997,
0.5308259725570679,
0.3755289912223816,
-0.2498467117547989,
-0.5955221652984619,
-0.5049511194229126,
-0.29745569825172424,
0.09062104672193527,
0.09952513873577118,
-0.050140079110860825,
-0.09916988760232925,
-0.08121594041585922,
0.6290950775146484,
-0.46955960988998413,
0.19898124039173126,
-0.6645065546035767,
-0.3901996910572052,
0.9315604567527771,
-0.08272001147270203,
0.6562096476554871,
-0.3397989571094513,
-0.34010154008865356,
0.1428341120481491,
-0.5187389850616455,
-0.12083066254854202,
0.30377572774887085,
0.5650345683097839,
-0.18128995597362518,
0.4673895537853241,
-0.06399457156658173,
0.37555408477783203,
-0.14578789472579956,
-0.5633359551429749,
-0.15320587158203125,
-0.3967210650444031,
-0.1857985407114029,
0.36670756340026855,
0.7659503817558289,
0.517564594745636,
0.4190157651901245,
-0.24632547795772552,
0.2447064369916916,
0.2655031085014343,
0.010486416518688202,
-0.9796346426010132,
-0.08345256000757217,
0.26307445764541626,
-0.436977744102478,
-0.37265607714653015,
-0.8879035711288452,
-0.8495989441871643,
-0.5342675447463989,
0.355028361082077,
0.8714839220046997,
-0.4413354992866516,
-0.4922834634780884,
-0.17406189441680908,
-0.15395116806030273,
0.17816388607025146,
0.01792292855679989,
-1.0570076704025269,
0.05898745730519295,
0.1827363818883896,
0.46081408858299255,
0.23824550211429596,
-0.09507708996534348,
-0.5182529091835022,
0.2757416367530823,
-0.3819081783294678,
0.7425224781036377,
-0.3956841230392456,
-0.699600100517273,
0.01188016589730978,
-0.05810276418924332,
-0.12955453991889954,
-0.41770613193511963,
0.6752827167510986,
-0.31403425335884094,
0.3497379720211029,
-0.0089828846976161,
-0.01742864027619362,
-0.3512125015258789,
0.12232174724340439,
-0.4741772711277008,
0.21885329484939575,
0.16917337477207184,
-0.319491982460022,
0.24496546387672424,
-0.3328649699687958,
-0.7953822612762451,
-0.10131919384002686,
-0.02957012690603733,
-0.09054338932037354,
0.019233791157603264,
0.44170552492141724,
0.1309565305709839,
-0.37936702370643616,
0.39360761642456055,
0.00557589391246438,
-0.4159885346889496,
0.24531376361846924,
-0.32037171721458435,
0.8964052200317383,
0.6134060025215149,
-0.27899426221847534,
-0.21238861978054047,
-0.5094917416572571,
-0.2361178994178772,
-0.10562360286712646,
-0.08581625670194626,
-0.07078728079795837,
0.3211400508880615,
0.1090308204293251,
0.33163976669311523,
0.1410405933856964,
-0.5295200347900391,
-0.42939677834510803,
-0.2884695827960968,
0.5317891836166382,
0.5148612856864929,
0.193124920129776,
0.33815309405326843,
-0.2618657648563385,
0.5607513785362244,
-0.07091221213340759,
0.28060558438301086,
-0.14508698880672455,
-0.2753051817417145,
-0.7674477100372314,
-0.009805181063711643,
0.054162267595529556,
0.7920372486114502,
-0.5164201259613037,
-0.23315799236297607,
-0.09320785105228424,
-0.4047171473503113,
-0.33703625202178955,
0.1727503091096878,
0.04538022354245186,
0.5218432545661926,
0.4600927531719208,
-0.29332754015922546,
-0.657256543636322,
-0.8420349955558777,
-0.59791100025177,
-0.42198511958122253,
0.05278098210692406,
0.3995070159435272,
0.30460789799690247,
-0.10432206094264984,
0.35414353013038635,
-0.044436994940042496,
-0.7656197547912598,
-0.3933647572994232,
-0.43312710523605347,
0.5915156006813049,
-0.06188177689909935,
0.1207929477095604,
-0.8276164531707764,
-0.7417938709259033,
0.3142947554588318,
-1.0601234436035156,
0.14865343272686005,
0.053077418357133865,
-0.012956717982888222,
-0.08610490709543228,
0.7347844243049622,
-0.012745237909257412,
0.18443578481674194,
0.41303789615631104,
-0.11065855622291565,
0.18986466526985168,
0.18780702352523804,
0.16082094609737396,
-1.1445417404174805,
-0.4689016342163086,
-0.1565193384885788,
-0.06714704632759094,
-0.37308576703071594,
0.2972559928894043,
-0.4585331082344055,
-0.6997149586677551,
-0.5543859004974365,
0.4282471239566803,
-0.309378981590271,
0.41753873229026794,
0.10485871881246567,
0.4820546805858612,
0.09758530557155609,
0.2697484791278839,
0.3311901092529297,
0.7491265535354614,
0.77690589427948,
-0.7667237520217896,
0.5563666820526123,
0.4116153419017792,
-0.10836613923311234,
1.0065888166427612,
-0.18965347111225128,
-0.3632839024066925,
-0.39927372336387634,
0.0092310206964612,
-1.0712414979934692,
-0.5172052383422852,
-0.12260246276855469,
-0.3799458146095276,
0.34218114614486694,
-0.14165158569812775,
0.16487804055213928,
-0.15666694939136505,
0.0214978139847517,
-0.32226285338401794,
0.5324476361274719,
-0.4209243953227997,
0.4272412955760956,
0.6798712015151978,
-0.38507556915283203,
-0.6867727041244507,
-0.6371707320213318,
0.24846985936164856,
-0.5297352075576782,
-0.5354642271995544,
0.17697270214557648,
0.35018235445022583,
-0.1807417869567871,
-0.06071922555565834,
-0.33020350337028503,
-0.7254688143730164,
-0.12042458355426788,
0.19717934727668762,
0.018731139600276947,
-0.5423632264137268,
-0.07240096479654312,
0.20432884991168976,
0.39520734548568726,
0.07402023673057556,
0.12948091328144073,
0.004901583306491375,
0.36207839846611023,
0.5885395407676697,
-0.39183589816093445,
0.7737913131713867,
0.6111868619918823,
-0.32075902819633484,
0.5495228171348572,
0.5599356889724731,
-0.19029197096824646,
-0.1480685919523239,
-0.08281360566616058,
-0.16855673491954803,
-0.4956132471561432,
0.6730242371559143,
-0.37943655252456665,
-0.6517854928970337,
0.23435178399085999,
-0.029203932732343674,
-0.1577812135219574,
0.3478164076805115,
0.10662885010242462,
-0.4482245445251465,
0.613134503364563,
0.6110242605209351,
0.037588607519865036,
0.10764607787132263,
-0.2177814394235611,
0.5438231825828552,
-0.548143208026886,
-0.16441701352596283,
-0.4455716609954834,
-0.36178797483444214,
-0.7952584624290466,
-0.2517072558403015,
0.3617522418498993,
0.1627969741821289,
-0.2269408255815506,
0.7025700211524963,
-0.04554258659482002,
0.6590040922164917,
-0.10259006917476654,
0.1333848088979721,
0.36085906624794006,
0.32467857003211975,
-0.07108546048402786,
-0.14178602397441864,
-0.49249881505966187,
-0.5930566787719727,
0.8169322609901428,
0.31702056527137756,
0.8092942833900452,
0.530224621295929,
0.8669379353523254,
0.04202466458082199,
0.5232157707214355,
-0.6734535694122314,
0.810139536857605,
-0.7884654998779297,
-1.0870333909988403,
-0.3655313551425934,
0.036313336342573166,
-1.0630207061767578,
0.0039815036579966545,
-0.07625744491815567,
-0.8552970290184021,
0.3203083276748657,
-0.18032366037368774,
-0.528102457523346,
0.4941641092300415,
-0.5340244770050049,
1.1546820402145386,
-0.12212605029344559,
-0.7819497585296631,
-0.19579926133155823,
-0.49245917797088623,
0.4488697350025177,
0.15155179798603058,
0.9467678070068359,
-0.10316141694784164,
-0.019801601767539978,
0.7316879034042358,
-0.36385729908943176,
0.5603392124176025,
0.18609103560447693,
-0.2975810170173645,
0.6284424662590027,
0.3119073808193207,
0.1009310781955719,
0.08826231211423874,
-0.38628146052360535,
0.23622307181358337,
-0.18994390964508057,
-0.20966723561286926,
-0.07518341392278671,
0.9615496397018433,
-0.6648684740066528,
-0.4046816825866699,
-0.49856042861938477,
-0.40709519386291504,
-0.15145547688007355,
0.21369394659996033,
0.5787519812583923,
0.41841134428977966,
-0.3325892388820648,
0.004125361330807209,
0.42998018860816956,
-0.4003790616989136,
0.632936954498291,
0.38228839635849,
-0.43050289154052734,
-0.5036537647247314,
1.1426934003829956,
0.4063331186771393,
0.07848374545574188,
0.39454761147499084,
-0.06216355040669441,
-1.0358067750930786,
-0.4543806314468384,
-0.729097843170166,
0.3223619759082794,
-0.5666810274124146,
0.21526913344860077,
-0.45674940943717957,
-0.1445014774799347,
-0.34962642192840576,
-0.10157398879528046,
-0.18903405964374542,
-0.22001883387565613,
-0.12424777448177338,
-0.3423617482185364,
0.32860511541366577,
0.6386930346488953,
-0.1750154197216034,
0.45981651544570923,
-0.9062052369117737,
0.5751476287841797,
0.7474502325057983,
0.3767267167568207,
-0.42862409353256226,
-0.8839632272720337,
-0.1346212923526764,
-0.09535947442054749,
-0.7065591216087341,
-1.1678478717803955,
0.43429237604141235,
0.6365972757339478,
0.4418618381023407,
0.16500887274742126,
0.0951758623123169,
0.7442390322685242,
-0.3305656611919403,
1.045765995979309,
-0.11371481418609619,
-0.5911023020744324,
0.7541701793670654,
-0.6546705961227417,
-0.23791219294071198,
0.712791919708252,
0.9301270246505737,
-0.5246184468269348,
-0.26961350440979004,
-0.6051790118217468,
-0.7852562069892883,
0.6647869944572449,
0.39263594150543213,
0.6474825143814087,
-0.227489173412323,
-0.24398526549339294,
-0.08289634436368942,
0.36044299602508545,
-0.8100505471229553,
-0.2960484027862549,
-0.22437836229801178,
0.2591323256492615,
-0.39606136083602905,
-0.08981315046548843,
0.29915156960487366,
0.11473021656274796,
0.6919942498207092,
0.5078979134559631,
-0.008773598819971085,
0.27611127495765686,
-0.2190292626619339,
-0.421217679977417,
0.7378804683685303,
0.08347400277853012,
0.31100302934646606,
-0.5991614460945129,
-0.09712587296962738,
-0.07902298867702484,
-0.7017428278923035,
0.36572152376174927,
-0.16516321897506714,
-0.37190917134284973,
0.3875074088573456,
0.10704071819782257,
0.7946315407752991,
0.08483874052762985,
-0.7894442081451416,
0.037518471479415894,
0.3018970489501953,
-0.015137786976993084,
-0.4036817252635956,
0.19672083854675293,
0.06707581132650375,
-0.12036426365375519,
0.3691563904285431,
-0.12881003320217133,
0.30021756887435913,
-1.3310638666152954,
0.31433144211769104,
0.3520122766494751,
-0.6804145574569702,
0.15524056553840637,
1.084312915802002,
0.685032069683075,
-0.5741604566574097,
0.5592519044876099,
-0.17799696326255798,
-0.42818838357925415,
0.5615261197090149,
0.7582201361656189,
0.6715086102485657,
-0.7030377984046936,
0.5491422414779663,
0.8854307532310486,
0.41470569372177124,
0.2892659604549408,
0.3498072326183319,
-0.046811945736408234,
-0.7001141309738159,
-0.7732759118080139,
-0.921308159828186,
-0.36147019267082214,
0.48300328850746155,
-0.6100740432739258,
0.3229885995388031,
-0.6320253610610962,
0.06781356036663055,
0.014636318199336529,
-0.2875153720378876,
0.07760394364595413,
0.5932781100273132,
0.49820274114608765,
0.7813534140586853,
-1.055580973625183,
0.6633260846138,
0.544876217842102,
-0.38144436478614807,
-0.9997530579566956,
-0.032403331249952316,
-0.20243680477142334,
-0.3972024619579315,
0.5738331079483032,
0.443661093711853,
0.19048331677913666,
0.3793306350708008,
-0.14549845457077026,
-0.7427526712417603,
0.47788599133491516,
0.07115083932876587,
-0.26213374733924866,
0.03984843194484711,
-0.035477422177791595,
0.5094189643859863,
-0.18911002576351166,
0.23956052958965302,
0.8094521760940552,
0.30149415135383606,
0.05256215110421181,
-1.2552927732467651,
-0.37069153785705566,
-0.2917552888393402,
-0.24543529748916626,
0.3726341724395752,
-0.5361658334732056,
0.7708302736282349,
-0.5706674456596375,
-0.2824268937110901,
0.151549831032753,
0.6912757754325867,
0.0141331497579813,
0.39518970251083374,
0.1960814744234085,
0.23902484774589539,
0.45468848943710327,
0.04349039867520332,
1.2085368633270264,
0.2960110008716583,
0.17235051095485687,
1.0479161739349365,
-0.351659893989563,
1.049921989440918,
0.5777828097343445,
-0.7156548500061035,
1.1342848539352417,
0.7065269351005554,
0.4595371186733246,
0.5571468472480774,
0.23195865750312805,
-0.5331733822822571,
-0.4224175214767456,
-0.7020489573478699,
-0.3125738799571991,
0.6252598166465759,
0.6667640805244446,
-0.29710087180137634,
-0.6412762999534607,
-0.02472277171909809,
-0.09745313227176666,
0.7327797412872314,
-0.7886853218078613,
0.451876699924469,
0.2516002357006073,
-0.5788112282752991,
1.0940951108932495,
-0.2958550751209259,
0.7392550110816956,
-0.700366735458374,
-0.007747315801680088,
-0.4141431450843811,
-0.2279462218284607,
-0.2806754410266876,
-0.44957613945007324,
0.6089613437652588,
0.009466338902711868,
-0.032991401851177216,
0.03156578540802002,
0.3229137659072876,
-0.6313846707344055,
-0.3480760455131531,
0.23156031966209412,
-0.13221199810504913,
0.8632566928863525,
-0.04261314496397972,
-0.6194815039634705,
-0.21015119552612305,
0.3466346561908722,
0.20301134884357452,
0.22488421201705933,
-0.05491152033209801,
-0.1737070530653,
0.3222518861293793,
0.49376335740089417,
0.08188098669052124,
0.22446782886981964,
-0.30655208230018616,
0.018928220495581627,
-0.5200433731079102,
-0.4342038631439209,
-0.8368762135505676,
0.5307685136795044,
-0.061367593705654144,
-0.14213082194328308,
0.692375659942627,
0.49921292066574097,
0.8007232546806335,
-0.479305624961853,
0.6931635737419128,
-0.338670939207077,
0.45965293049812317,
-0.4136178195476532,
0.8267069458961487,
-0.762222170829773,
0.06448006629943848,
-0.16312600672245026,
-1.1725513935089111,
-0.13611148297786713,
0.9367009997367859,
-0.13978666067123413,
-0.23728172481060028,
0.7688154578208923,
1.0130647420883179,
-0.038273271173238754,
-0.05552723631262779,
0.48914313316345215,
0.6877546906471252,
-0.19569851458072662,
0.7798118591308594,
0.7543072700500488,
-0.9506598114967346,
0.8393315076828003,
-0.45152905583381653,
-0.06918758898973465,
-0.10644516348838806,
-1.0114264488220215,
-0.5931324362754822,
-0.16691796481609344,
-0.5063866972923279,
-0.6161722540855408,
-0.10650821775197983,
0.37135428190231323,
0.4175770878791809,
-0.8485133051872253,
-0.562315821647644,
0.04380994662642479,
0.48868075013160706,
-0.02832075208425522,
-0.1846800148487091,
0.1308242827653885,
0.22000154852867126,
-1.0626646280288696,
0.9862725138664246,
0.4195537865161896,
0.04117178916931152,
-0.20091655850410461,
0.07266030460596085,
-0.29691821336746216,
0.3720795214176178,
0.5885777473449707,
0.6003909707069397,
-0.8011434674263,
0.022366462275385857,
0.0015882222214713693,
-0.07570599019527435,
-0.43763381242752075,
0.07965783774852753,
-0.5600388050079346,
0.4201682507991791,
0.3278212249279022,
-0.04344721883535385,
0.34358784556388855,
-0.35591211915016174,
0.685844361782074,
-0.5263251662254333,
0.3167339861392975,
-0.05466516315937042,
0.05621540918946266,
0.46608227491378784,
-0.6366739869117737,
0.5545384287834167,
0.1857682317495346,
-0.3812847435474396,
-1.0222511291503906,
0.4241929054260254,
-0.9950495362281799,
-0.06539317220449448,
0.8712331652641296,
0.10821940749883652,
-0.615067720413208,
-0.44835999608039856,
-0.286185085773468,
0.11824852973222733,
-0.08117999136447906,
0.4019250273704529,
0.573843240737915,
-0.07304300367832184,
-0.22979332506656647,
-0.670497477054596,
0.49447527527809143,
0.4012891948223114,
-0.26108771562576294,
-0.28270596265792847,
0.21657592058181763,
0.6852885484695435,
0.5367376208305359,
0.7231449484825134,
-0.48948368430137634,
0.387600839138031,
0.08703289926052094,
-0.14376826584339142,
0.3003787398338318,
-0.20555712282657623,
-0.05339367315173149,
-0.023186270147562027,
0.14798778295516968,
-0.301042377948761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02623v1 | Uplifting Lower-Income Data: Strategies for Socioeconomic Perspective Shifts in Vision-Language Models | 2024-07-02T19:27:00 | 2024-07-02T19:27:00 | Joan Nwatu, Oana Ignat, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, K.4; I.2.7; I.2.8 | To address this issue, we formulate translated non-English, geographic, and
socioeconomic integrated prompts and evaluate their impact on VL model
performance for data from different countries and income groups. Our findings
show that geographic and socioeconomic integrated prompts improve VL
performance on lower-income data and favor the retrieval of topic appearances
commonly found in data from low-income households. From our analyses, we
identify and highlight contexts where these strategies yield the most
improvements. Our model analysis code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Anniejoan/Uplifting-Lower-income-data . | [
-0.05614319443702698,
-0.5253459811210632,
0.7090954780578613,
0.27302980422973633,
-0.3127005100250244,
0.3759523630142212,
-0.23419202864170074,
-0.56748366355896,
0.29966989159584045,
0.5613194704055786,
-0.4523666799068451,
-0.5695299506187439,
-0.577707052230835,
-0.004108660854399204,
-0.3301226794719696,
0.962734043598175,
0.2844749093055725,
0.2750674784183502,
-0.43571633100509644,
0.164850652217865,
-0.4368906617164612,
-0.3800545036792755,
-0.4932246208190918,
-0.13291829824447632,
0.3991798758506775,
0.8409368395805359,
0.7570852041244507,
0.5266880393028259,
0.5046544075012207,
0.1372469961643219,
-0.11469493806362152,
-0.05651332065463066,
-0.551288902759552,
-0.35255739092826843,
-0.03159147500991821,
-0.4896010160446167,
-0.24612323939800262,
-0.2744576036930084,
0.35639092326164246,
0.8975674510002136,
-0.1425284445285797,
0.6377021074295044,
0.3730820119380951,
1.0295190811157227,
-0.7687861323356628,
0.3317621946334839,
-0.48812001943588257,
-0.10481714457273483,
-0.4202253818511963,
-0.09743744134902954,
-0.2788753807544708,
-0.549278736114502,
0.21791647374629974,
-0.08901793509721756,
0.2693707346916199,
-0.16572359204292297,
0.7968887090682983,
0.22091908752918243,
-0.46009573340415955,
0.01731015555560589,
-0.8521798253059387,
0.8035293221473694,
-0.5584346652030945,
0.3914810121059418,
0.2328358143568039,
0.1831367462873459,
0.28481894731521606,
-0.5682728290557861,
-0.06442352384328842,
-0.0985880196094513,
-0.0744672417640686,
0.3363683521747589,
-0.24278177320957184,
-0.334258496761322,
0.23593294620513916,
0.35971763730049133,
-0.16528962552547455,
-0.0027433892246335745,
-0.9126423597335815,
0.1442551165819168,
0.6443308591842651,
0.33696475625038147,
0.14129985868930817,
-0.6319512724876404,
-0.27043506503105164,
-0.1766837239265442,
-1.055578351020813,
0.6350420117378235,
0.44338274002075195,
0.7555571794509888,
-0.74882572889328,
0.7362555861473083,
-0.5810673832893372,
0.6223801374435425,
-0.19443146884441376,
-0.12154503911733627,
0.4502872824668884,
-0.6371305584907532,
-0.018924133852124214,
0.15535376965999603,
-0.09613301604986191,
0.930988609790802,
0.23322398960590363,
0.3150225877761841,
-0.29301929473876953,
0.12434309720993042,
0.07134175300598145,
-0.41271430253982544,
-0.21088363230228424,
-0.2231324017047882,
-0.8713834285736084,
-0.5477892160415649,
-0.22881488502025604,
-1.2212415933609009,
-0.7005171775817871,
-0.778482973575592,
-0.03336874023079872,
0.0005379964713938534,
-0.06959912180900574,
0.12734979391098022,
-0.16250821948051453,
0.3383523225784302,
0.7000696063041687,
-0.8545774817466736,
0.1978965550661087,
0.49478980898857117,
0.961544930934906,
0.07629240304231644,
0.2737620770931244,
-0.3472194969654083,
-0.35975730419158936,
-0.2013566792011261,
0.8943873047828674,
-0.7926406860351562,
-0.4254343807697296,
0.27203309535980225,
-0.0476556122303009,
-0.08439822494983673,
-0.5006683468818665,
0.2907009422779083,
-0.2178235948085785,
0.359212726354599,
-0.8661909699440002,
0.16390833258628845,
0.18465642631053925,
0.11248870193958282,
-0.4770154654979706,
1.3173134326934814,
0.3423217236995697,
-0.7730455994606018,
0.4557814598083496,
-0.6816748976707458,
-0.3576487898826599,
0.026782339438796043,
-0.1763966828584671,
-0.01138997171074152,
0.6040856242179871,
0.49656692147254944,
0.08999965339899063,
-0.5030185580253601,
0.22345851361751556,
-0.17061765491962433,
-0.0689028948545456,
-0.14657430350780487,
-0.6621652245521545,
1.0154474973678589,
0.31373298168182373,
-0.2387484312057495,
0.1240275576710701,
-0.8942952156066895,
-0.28357383608818054,
0.17169058322906494,
-0.2872309386730194,
-0.7424044013023376,
0.27445462346076965,
0.18876376748085022,
0.11047595739364624,
0.5136191248893738,
-0.45923787355422974,
0.3338090777397156,
-0.5351792573928833,
0.3204907476902008,
0.7090649008750916,
-0.08249283581972122,
0.312860906124115,
-0.09142616391181946,
0.6550981402397156,
0.2211250513792038,
0.5242353081703186,
0.22184090316295624,
-0.5862472653388977,
-0.6504737734794617,
-0.03933185338973999,
0.32933732867240906,
0.7487193942070007,
-1.0756293535232544,
-0.5094921588897705,
-0.2976509928703308,
-0.28506526350975037,
-0.762466549873352,
0.059154070913791656,
0.21823172271251678,
1.0423308610916138,
0.5960935354232788,
-0.08751087635755539,
-0.7813145518302917,
-1.0249305963516235,
-0.12991352379322052,
-0.17328204214572906,
0.200668066740036,
0.3559979796409607,
0.4332182705402374,
0.032382700592279434,
0.788124144077301,
-0.6309105157852173,
0.039841074496507645,
-0.5087646842002869,
-0.10970715433359146,
0.35234707593917847,
0.20750096440315247,
0.7834833264350891,
-0.9781168699264526,
-0.6712538003921509,
-0.1339719444513321,
-0.37789711356163025,
-0.40822353959083557,
0.20785856246948242,
-0.16446657478809357,
0.1648525893688202,
0.29402557015419006,
-0.2562093734741211,
0.9797961115837097,
0.426400363445282,
-0.45723360776901245,
0.3096250891685486,
-0.1748127043247223,
0.24656842648983002,
-1.2675520181655884,
-0.5055171251296997,
0.31155428290367126,
-0.1653449386358261,
-0.41754740476608276,
-0.2747208774089813,
0.002620283281430602,
-0.1758381426334381,
-0.5797197818756104,
0.3489806652069092,
-0.3565635085105896,
-0.38260549306869507,
0.16909240186214447,
0.1361663043498993,
-0.11202739924192429,
-0.09377752989530563,
0.3039337694644928,
0.826504647731781,
0.6864297986030579,
-0.28287026286125183,
0.22860126197338104,
0.06967595219612122,
-0.4940880537033081,
0.6833924651145935,
-0.7442639470100403,
-0.30999550223350525,
-0.43193313479423523,
-0.34523335099220276,
-1.0240424871444702,
-0.24670462310314178,
0.3473532497882843,
-0.24243628978729248,
-0.0007145762792788446,
-0.15599699318408966,
-0.3143535256385803,
-0.3050347864627838,
-0.35988733172416687,
0.23576273024082184,
0.671784520149231,
-0.6393250823020935,
0.06533282995223999,
0.4581694006919861,
-0.3276868760585785,
-0.49732598662376404,
-0.5274940133094788,
0.17479272186756134,
-0.7489850521087646,
-0.3566683530807495,
0.2746775448322296,
0.04980376735329628,
-0.7082194685935974,
0.260944664478302,
0.3249143362045288,
0.24897150695323944,
0.20877902209758759,
-0.3026043474674225,
0.5347244739532471,
-0.4014122784137726,
0.028151942417025566,
-0.03975735977292061,
-0.030185706913471222,
-0.013587853871285915,
-0.32925930619239807,
0.4579790234565735,
-0.11875218152999878,
-0.04022790491580963,
-0.0317571647465229,
0.41718733310699463,
0.2866939902305603,
-0.30741605162620544,
0.7503826022148132,
0.03912211209535599,
-0.44888731837272644,
0.197065070271492,
-0.13287730515003204,
0.05518559366464615,
-0.4390104115009308,
0.25310948491096497,
-0.15580710768699646,
-0.5832420587539673,
0.4663121700286865,
-0.07554079592227936,
-0.34945330023765564,
0.1540069431066513,
0.68454909324646,
-0.04104870557785034,
1.3460930585861206,
1.0605722665786743,
-0.18412165343761444,
0.6823449730873108,
-0.10204929113388062,
0.27664297819137573,
-0.6952651143074036,
-0.16328175365924835,
-0.6428619027137756,
-0.32901686429977417,
-0.544806957244873,
-0.46996039152145386,
0.5745407342910767,
0.11530783027410507,
0.017275139689445496,
0.14145304262638092,
-0.5032303333282471,
0.5263535976409912,
0.47224652767181396,
0.1644088476896286,
0.3401147723197937,
0.2685277462005615,
0.10335046052932739,
-0.48714590072631836,
-0.5080814361572266,
-0.5188518166542053,
1.108318567276001,
0.18091656267642975,
0.8148225545883179,
0.35795822739601135,
0.8802608847618103,
0.5055232644081116,
0.41216519474983215,
-0.6719654202461243,
0.3868118226528168,
-0.308436781167984,
-0.2226981520652771,
-0.237484872341156,
-0.246606707572937,
-0.8596285581588745,
0.19255372881889343,
-0.23583465814590454,
-1.1834337711334229,
0.8183949589729309,
0.1542552262544632,
-0.3673693835735321,
-0.020678682252764702,
-0.6695688962936401,
0.7228366732597351,
-0.3482491075992584,
-0.3335341513156891,
-0.12667782604694366,
-0.45278695225715637,
0.2518351376056671,
0.1268625557422638,
0.5782053470611572,
-0.1065434142947197,
0.12668871879577637,
0.0912710577249527,
-0.3578636646270752,
1.1261286735534668,
-0.5175512433052063,
-0.19418253004550934,
0.005101695656776428,
-0.511871874332428,
0.26519590616226196,
0.2957063615322113,
-0.1414666771888733,
0.10588011890649796,
-0.09171606600284576,
-0.5113525986671448,
-0.498524010181427,
0.4220544695854187,
-0.7776050567626953,
-0.6500363349914551,
-0.11100000888109207,
-0.4984948933124542,
-0.128863126039505,
0.04649227112531662,
0.40634483098983765,
0.7469542622566223,
0.050909433513879776,
0.6128970384597778,
0.4469165802001953,
-0.20722423493862152,
0.31618571281433105,
0.39887288212776184,
-0.3842395842075348,
-0.3440547287464142,
0.6634425520896912,
0.4413338899612427,
0.2923014760017395,
0.3041010797023773,
0.299623042345047,
-0.4278857111930847,
-0.3618369698524475,
-0.5903301239013672,
0.0014416860649362206,
-0.8514716029167175,
-0.12688380479812622,
-0.27006348967552185,
0.14019057154655457,
-0.8958010673522949,
-0.28614935278892517,
-0.39202195405960083,
-0.36143848299980164,
-0.18916696310043335,
-0.33020976185798645,
0.27655476331710815,
0.5934113264083862,
-0.37273257970809937,
0.17128022015094757,
-0.538716197013855,
0.2605021893978119,
-0.11213883012533188,
-0.16625948250293732,
-0.10112922638654709,
-0.4366668462753296,
-0.6679065823554993,
0.15694062411785126,
0.028254671022295952,
-0.9678025841712952,
0.6798662543296814,
-0.10594511777162552,
0.28618523478507996,
0.05642738938331604,
0.3867439925670624,
1.0912225246429443,
-0.30137646198272705,
0.804165244102478,
0.1061815470457077,
-0.9388120174407959,
0.997374951839447,
-0.25524911284446716,
0.30123865604400635,
0.7468829154968262,
0.37911659479141235,
-0.43201711773872375,
-0.2406677007675171,
-0.34792765974998474,
-1.2351362705230713,
0.600381076335907,
-0.11530119925737381,
0.2706449031829834,
0.1524718999862671,
0.361518532037735,
-0.048796653747558594,
0.5318195223808289,
-0.9279127717018127,
-0.3244010806083679,
-0.2512708902359009,
-0.4200713634490967,
-0.13720153272151947,
-0.260246217250824,
-0.1313842236995697,
-0.6457138061523438,
0.2869519591331482,
-0.2835363745689392,
-0.03210955485701561,
0.40812942385673523,
-0.00496014766395092,
-0.12060534954071045,
0.27489200234413147,
0.42268937826156616,
0.7452632784843445,
-0.0369478203356266,
0.08055353909730911,
0.058945026248693466,
-0.22964158654212952,
-0.08093791455030441,
0.15177646279335022,
-0.6632484197616577,
-0.22076907753944397,
0.40679141879081726,
1.0153454542160034,
0.5491869449615479,
-0.3392553925514221,
0.285602331161499,
-0.3440632224082947,
0.052582111209630966,
-0.5039129853248596,
0.011500993743538857,
-0.09825490415096283,
0.49347496032714844,
0.2665918469429016,
0.12869279086589813,
0.3049963712692261,
-0.829980194568634,
-0.24273602664470673,
0.15807171165943146,
-0.5890823006629944,
-0.3557397723197937,
0.7811338305473328,
0.09996052831411362,
-0.30086663365364075,
0.6552445292472839,
0.11222459375858307,
-0.273637980222702,
0.5906176567077637,
0.5646381974220276,
0.6368523836135864,
0.062382567673921585,
0.694225013256073,
0.0790131539106369,
0.48996472358703613,
0.01804160326719284,
0.6593318581581116,
-0.2645033895969391,
-0.8992578983306885,
-0.1997600644826889,
-0.5618920922279358,
-0.3610909879207611,
-0.09822067618370056,
-1.1211349964141846,
0.5673161745071411,
-0.027601465582847595,
-0.037645526230335236,
-0.03906082734465599,
-0.07840621471405029,
-0.849867045879364,
0.2593097984790802,
0.4764973223209381,
0.8371964693069458,
-1.1806449890136719,
0.9149451851844788,
1.1061732769012451,
-0.5894403457641602,
-0.6473230719566345,
0.2023666501045227,
0.2407810389995575,
-0.8460181951522827,
1.0223321914672852,
0.02202652581036091,
-0.2081519514322281,
0.19126053154468536,
-0.7650619745254517,
-1.159698724746704,
0.933086633682251,
0.46535366773605347,
-0.3418527841567993,
-0.11210507154464722,
0.4690135419368744,
0.7731682062149048,
-0.7329961657524109,
-0.024547580629587173,
0.560515284538269,
0.5533409118652344,
-0.16194657981395721,
-0.6211930513381958,
-0.28873708844184875,
-0.3775072693824768,
0.34505900740623474,
-0.10969142615795135,
-0.7618693709373474,
1.0767621994018555,
-0.40243005752563477,
-0.24989500641822815,
-0.10556978732347488,
0.6055803298950195,
0.13578824698925018,
0.7102998495101929,
0.4775826930999756,
0.39207178354263306,
0.7497082948684692,
-0.13847804069519043,
1.3938206434249878,
-0.49066483974456787,
0.4894569218158722,
0.8179736733436584,
-0.5224557518959045,
0.7407227158546448,
0.4343448579311371,
-0.1658707559108734,
0.6848639249801636,
0.8486638069152832,
0.0051404014229774475,
0.9679338932037354,
-0.10676490515470505,
-0.03562060743570328,
-0.3305540382862091,
-0.35347139835357666,
-0.4693726599216461,
0.670380175113678,
0.28513476252555847,
-0.268708735704422,
-0.35602694749832153,
0.1737343668937683,
-0.23080217838287354,
0.22721818089485168,
-0.5382611155509949,
0.6031572818756104,
0.09054172039031982,
-0.32460203766822815,
0.3528118133544922,
-0.2755202054977417,
0.4292117953300476,
-0.16583868861198425,
-0.22772619128227234,
-0.47649458050727844,
0.27371057868003845,
-0.24639226496219635,
-0.5374327898025513,
0.5667129755020142,
0.1797916144132614,
-0.5783736705780029,
-0.376167356967926,
0.9698412418365479,
-0.29629001021385193,
-0.8658510446548462,
0.5745140314102173,
0.815096378326416,
-0.021369654685258865,
0.32563403248786926,
-0.9139040112495422,
-0.0556517168879509,
0.22537203133106232,
-0.28668212890625,
0.4506125748157501,
0.539372980594635,
-0.3407438397407532,
0.36198607087135315,
0.6216852068901062,
0.34204980731010437,
-0.09107145667076111,
0.4761621952056885,
0.7412241101264954,
-0.7919731140136719,
-0.49624454975128174,
-0.7794211506843567,
0.8892272114753723,
-0.3336833119392395,
-0.3336769640445709,
1.0796897411346436,
0.59027498960495,
1.0927201509475708,
-0.24053631722927094,
0.7407023310661316,
-0.16393426060676575,
0.589333713054657,
-0.6508122682571411,
0.3853355348110199,
-0.9803768992424011,
0.47303056716918945,
-0.35076019167900085,
-0.7563239932060242,
-0.08983822166919708,
0.4858401119709015,
-0.6925128102302551,
-0.15141725540161133,
0.2697775065898895,
0.5959334373474121,
0.22407042980194092,
-0.1452113538980484,
0.36853739619255066,
0.059099242091178894,
0.1464107632637024,
0.160969078540802,
1.0536768436431885,
-0.10816331207752228,
0.16709010303020477,
-0.5962319374084473,
-0.20644187927246094,
-0.19087094068527222,
-0.9378252625465393,
-0.5233741998672485,
-0.29494816064834595,
-0.4873998165130615,
-0.2944168150424957,
0.03215031325817108,
0.7665417790412903,
0.5721137523651123,
-0.7147857546806335,
-0.31284061074256897,
0.08651362359523773,
0.39924874901771545,
-0.1937718242406845,
-0.3897742033004761,
0.2148677259683609,
-0.15675587952136993,
-0.9116358160972595,
0.4644398093223572,
0.5076379179954529,
-0.30224889516830444,
-0.3710813820362091,
0.26058289408683777,
0.05725250393152237,
0.010765145532786846,
0.8619491457939148,
0.08176161348819733,
-0.44460558891296387,
-0.48509833216667175,
0.092849001288414,
0.00669097900390625,
0.24532796442508698,
0.8042904138565063,
-0.7774712443351746,
0.15986670553684235,
0.6292681097984314,
0.3900681436061859,
0.10153142362833023,
0.36497434973716736,
0.5139648914337158,
-0.8260869383811951,
0.23743338882923126,
-0.19786618649959564,
0.5439087152481079,
0.4166173040866852,
-0.8496013283729553,
0.6940549612045288,
0.5667263865470886,
-0.3798753023147583,
-1.0409542322158813,
0.3038604259490967,
-0.49648451805114746,
-0.042550187557935715,
0.8594617247581482,
0.06713996827602386,
-0.41595137119293213,
-0.1368936002254486,
-0.23234812915325165,
-0.000985680497251451,
-0.3755347430706024,
1.0640017986297607,
0.617136538028717,
-0.385413259267807,
-0.6143024563789368,
-0.8802706599235535,
0.2539675235748291,
0.2976358234882355,
-0.8190228343009949,
0.085445336997509,
0.822514533996582,
-0.04620027914643288,
0.059932734817266464,
0.7488256096839905,
-0.37657108902931213,
0.014517990872263908,
-0.1616067886352539,
-0.12322152405977249,
0.4368654191493988,
-0.5252623558044434,
-0.4628916382789612,
-0.01162409596145153,
-0.02592267282307148,
0.16904693841934204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02604v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02604v1 | D-Rax: Domain-specific Radiologic assistant leveraging multi-modal data and eXpert model predictions | 2024-07-02T18:43:10 | 2024-07-02T18:43:10 | Hareem Nisar, Syed Muhammad Anwar, Zhifan Jiang, Abhijeet Parida, Vishwesh Nath, Holger R. Roth, Marius George Linguraru | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.IV | Large vision language models (VLMs) have progressed incredibly from research
to applicability for general-purpose use cases. LLaVA-Med, a pioneering large
language and vision assistant for biomedicine, can perform multi-modal
biomedical image and data analysis to provide a natural language interface for
radiologists. While it is highly generalizable and works with multi-modal data,
it is currently limited by well-known challenges that exist in the large
language model space. Hallucinations and imprecision in responses can lead to
misdiagnosis which currently hinder the clinical adaptability of VLMs. To
create precise, user-friendly models in healthcare, we propose D-Rax -- a
domain-specific, conversational, radiologic assistance tool that can be used to
gain insights about a particular radiologic image. In this study, we enhance
the conversational analysis of chest X-ray (CXR) images to support radiological
reporting, offering comprehensive insights from medical imaging and aiding in
the formulation of accurate diagnosis. D-Rax is achieved by fine-tuning the
LLaVA-Med architecture on our curated enhanced instruction-following data,
comprising of images, instructions, as well as disease diagnosis and
demographic predictions derived from MIMIC-CXR imaging data, CXR-related visual
question answer (VQA) pairs, and predictive outcomes from multiple expert AI
models. We observe statistically significant improvement in responses when
evaluated for both open and close-ended conversations. Leveraging the power of
state-of-the-art diagnostic models combined with VLMs, D-Rax empowers
clinicians to interact with medical images using natural language, which could
potentially streamline their decision-making process, enhance diagnostic
accuracy, and conserve their time. | [
-0.3514297604560852,
-0.8188255429267883,
0.9477739930152893,
-0.14039911329746246,
-0.36939162015914917,
0.1715092957019806,
0.05246825888752937,
-0.6784348487854004,
0.22534291446208954,
0.7122387886047363,
-0.6231133937835693,
-0.421379029750824,
-0.7633841037750244,
0.19043686985969543,
-0.17286093533039093,
0.4729812741279602,
0.2004692703485489,
0.16147096455097198,
-0.49251696467399597,
-0.025472493842244148,
-0.8598619699478149,
-0.2670982778072357,
-0.6021140813827515,
-0.3620118796825409,
0.6522446274757385,
0.31642261147499084,
1.2311698198318481,
0.6548078656196594,
0.7484864592552185,
0.28445032238960266,
0.2142879068851471,
0.41759803891181946,
-0.17011718451976776,
0.3902188837528229,
0.02579069696366787,
-0.12925668060779572,
-0.8457797765731812,
-0.5743771195411682,
0.272951602935791,
0.5777795910835266,
-0.08690733462572098,
-0.17747840285301208,
-0.41160449385643005,
0.6751323938369751,
-0.33265000581741333,
0.4210972785949707,
-0.35100314021110535,
-0.002863969886675477,
0.0420532189309597,
-0.5701152682304382,
-0.3013579547405243,
-0.13953641057014465,
0.20669662952423096,
-0.6703605651855469,
-0.2808873653411865,
0.06186305731534958,
0.6675777435302734,
0.44887104630470276,
-0.2942997217178345,
-0.27940642833709717,
-0.7477789521217346,
0.757140040397644,
-0.4756108820438385,
0.48495882749557495,
0.522720217704773,
0.6917993426322937,
-0.03618313744664192,
-0.8315584063529968,
-0.44236552715301514,
-0.2190338373184204,
-0.26030346751213074,
0.3268865942955017,
-0.7214208245277405,
0.1663542240858078,
0.07268602401018143,
0.2951151132583618,
-0.7015852928161621,
0.059119731187820435,
-0.3127490282058716,
0.09429259598255157,
0.7098680734634399,
0.5876212120056152,
0.39274561405181885,
-0.06782113760709763,
-0.3658994138240814,
-0.12452105432748795,
-0.3894619941711426,
-0.4937591552734375,
-0.5390504002571106,
0.008479601703584194,
-0.1616029441356659,
0.3489442765712738,
-0.4085039496421814,
1.044325590133667,
0.0443265475332737,
-0.43990030884742737,
0.30601975321769714,
-0.037616703659296036,
-0.4153320789337158,
-0.1042647436261177,
0.5577347278594971,
0.31065264344215393,
-0.03827987238764763,
0.07414877414703369,
-0.15751926600933075,
0.18497084081172943,
0.20136402547359467,
-0.5733616948127747,
-0.18255794048309326,
0.2913111448287964,
-0.6382653117179871,
-0.4263063371181488,
-0.38433897495269775,
-0.6886893510818481,
-0.5160788297653198,
-0.613727331161499,
0.3653900623321533,
-0.32570046186447144,
-0.3319554626941681,
0.5719716548919678,
0.21584412455558777,
-0.019531741738319397,
0.6459841132164001,
-0.22354216873645782,
0.3686586320400238,
0.27306267619132996,
0.4747205078601837,
-0.0013708247570320964,
0.14407874643802643,
-0.5888425707817078,
0.10919822007417679,
-0.1305842101573944,
0.8944625854492188,
-1.0225317478179932,
-0.5766507983207703,
-0.14970092475414276,
-0.09929309785366058,
-0.10397031158208847,
-0.474804162979126,
0.26452067494392395,
-0.6341760158538818,
-0.013940129429101944,
-0.02856452204287052,
-0.11610591411590576,
-0.29058054089546204,
0.27776122093200684,
-0.5286666750907898,
0.6853204369544983,
0.054803378880023956,
-0.4485037326812744,
0.0990208238363266,
-0.449677973985672,
-0.18660542368888855,
0.3726983666419983,
-0.6781352758407593,
-0.3730315864086151,
0.09187078475952148,
0.5146770477294922,
0.5953857898712158,
-0.6755076050758362,
0.23597458004951477,
-0.16902019083499908,
0.04419676959514618,
0.575577437877655,
-0.23351459205150604,
0.38671451807022095,
0.31001442670822144,
-0.023030053824186325,
0.08622697740793228,
-0.7549353241920471,
0.11956238001585007,
0.275199294090271,
0.1341518759727478,
-0.4971684515476227,
-0.19279912114143372,
-0.08483705669641495,
0.25963854789733887,
-0.0031549434643238783,
-0.5321667790412903,
0.30827558040618896,
-0.13544178009033203,
-0.06581395864486694,
0.5392206311225891,
0.04875905439257622,
0.01567152328789234,
-0.5533620119094849,
0.9271491169929504,
-0.08767290413379669,
0.5313148498535156,
-0.23955820500850677,
-0.7352676391601562,
-0.4907534122467041,
-0.7140154838562012,
0.04577484726905823,
0.5669934749603271,
-0.7683438658714294,
-0.08487463742494583,
-0.3776351809501648,
-0.29671674966812134,
-0.4986059069633484,
-0.118171826004982,
0.469673216342926,
0.6340591907501221,
0.27581948041915894,
-0.391287624835968,
-0.5683943033218384,
-1.0137572288513184,
0.47300076484680176,
0.07283583283424377,
0.21844297647476196,
0.7917834520339966,
0.11893775314092636,
-0.5661787986755371,
0.6679216027259827,
-0.8935068249702454,
-0.6307146549224854,
-0.34051746129989624,
-0.07634385675191879,
0.1641358882188797,
0.023380976170301437,
0.5269441604614258,
-0.8044260144233704,
-0.5779969692230225,
0.5026600360870361,
-1.0893170833587646,
-0.06015770882368088,
-0.12610943615436554,
0.042463600635528564,
-0.0046756030060350895,
0.42697858810424805,
-0.2335575371980667,
0.70380699634552,
0.5951083302497864,
-0.09726579487323761,
0.24435189366340637,
-0.5124849677085876,
0.41681668162345886,
-0.9191539883613586,
0.00583049189299345,
-0.16140834987163544,
-0.2962941825389862,
-0.638125479221344,
-0.08259725570678711,
-0.069271519780159,
-0.19071032106876373,
-0.17420825362205505,
0.5794780254364014,
-0.5787546634674072,
-0.08161082118749619,
-0.35147032141685486,
-0.026144398376345634,
0.14064665138721466,
0.13369068503379822,
0.5636775493621826,
0.5445356965065002,
0.9137153625488281,
-0.4394078254699707,
0.27501609921455383,
0.6446837782859802,
-0.18351443111896515,
0.5667190551757812,
-0.6976688504219055,
0.5303868651390076,
-0.11102502793073654,
0.13620968163013458,
-0.7975085973739624,
-0.18459481000900269,
0.10804831981658936,
-0.5746527314186096,
0.4973568916320801,
0.0010216376977041364,
-0.15751759707927704,
-0.42926016449928284,
0.03572116419672966,
0.6337984204292297,
0.5296226739883423,
-0.28203022480010986,
0.9142547249794006,
0.40404531359672546,
-0.31856414675712585,
-0.7031691074371338,
-0.709926426410675,
0.5166784524917603,
0.14099368453025818,
-0.7781371474266052,
0.2999960780143738,
-0.28807079792022705,
-0.5381796956062317,
-0.08188869804143906,
0.23340868949890137,
-0.46853798627853394,
-0.2115190476179123,
0.411349892616272,
0.5810686349868774,
-0.28241097927093506,
0.0967119112610817,
-0.1180296242237091,
-0.3055521845817566,
-0.07689115405082703,
0.14155802130699158,
0.27806615829467773,
-0.0814213752746582,
-0.4244288206100464,
-0.5213017463684082,
0.5156106948852539,
0.8215579986572266,
-0.1948661506175995,
0.21525491774082184,
0.14788928627967834,
-0.27452462911605835,
0.01995685324072838,
-0.7020303606987,
-0.2613864541053772,
-0.41224610805511475,
0.4350426197052002,
-0.45774391293525696,
-0.6115920543670654,
0.377728134393692,
0.02102406695485115,
-0.26908329129219055,
-0.0623488649725914,
0.6980292797088623,
0.07575493305921555,
1.1663703918457031,
0.6406676769256592,
0.16085809469223022,
0.03208022192120552,
-0.19842161238193512,
0.19879484176635742,
-0.7427451610565186,
-0.444345623254776,
-0.2577049732208252,
0.07186245173215866,
-0.09192267060279846,
-0.6180776953697205,
0.8123457431793213,
-0.8102629780769348,
0.3342974781990051,
-0.20457111299037933,
-0.6741729974746704,
0.19935478270053864,
0.12410145998001099,
0.39396876096725464,
0.47045207023620605,
0.1375914365053177,
0.31115883588790894,
-0.17078007757663727,
-0.7614874243736267,
-0.19795691967010498,
1.134814739227295,
0.3070233166217804,
1.1260563135147095,
-0.00458845729008317,
0.5574731230735779,
0.529050886631012,
0.016747282817959785,
-0.9739580750465393,
0.49971872568130493,
-0.21329843997955322,
-0.3911234438419342,
0.17634472250938416,
0.0427960529923439,
-1.0514488220214844,
-0.07828572392463684,
-0.34584465622901917,
-0.3535796105861664,
0.41932210326194763,
0.16378797590732574,
-0.6554505825042725,
-0.008703263476490974,
-0.2697852849960327,
0.506627082824707,
-0.3846553564071655,
-0.3655606210231781,
-0.49004170298576355,
-0.6095753908157349,
0.34371739625930786,
-0.14562353491783142,
0.5161724090576172,
0.09464031457901001,
-0.1330106109380722,
0.1634322851896286,
-0.259825199842453,
1.0236413478851318,
0.08174009621143341,
-0.02293567545711994,
-0.04067440330982208,
0.29688993096351624,
0.13565964996814728,
0.10771726071834564,
0.1824377328157425,
0.27311259508132935,
-0.0005426425486803055,
-0.042033202946186066,
-0.6767310500144958,
0.7212286591529846,
-0.868693470954895,
-0.5631182789802551,
-0.5512682795524597,
-0.7429285645484924,
-0.3293682038784027,
-0.0462329238653183,
-0.1647655963897705,
0.9800184369087219,
-0.10561549663543701,
0.05943906307220459,
0.8129989504814148,
-0.5015929937362671,
-0.1367352306842804,
0.7266910076141357,
-0.3388601243495941,
-0.4059293568134308,
0.750104546546936,
-0.14810632169246674,
0.21652111411094666,
0.6389976739883423,
0.2913345396518707,
-0.06835076957941055,
-0.6640272736549377,
-0.41775912046432495,
0.2680617570877075,
-0.8099284172058105,
-0.613365113735199,
-0.768146812915802,
-0.15795396268367767,
-0.13674618303775787,
-0.44317391514778137,
-0.22882190346717834,
-0.2779478430747986,
-0.07045461237430573,
0.2536325454711914,
0.656637966632843,
0.9048575758934021,
-0.17149624228477478,
0.12102555483579636,
-0.8920997381210327,
0.31929752230644226,
0.39827972650527954,
0.07453794032335281,
-0.22149497270584106,
-0.4465152323246002,
-0.15376317501068115,
-0.20152965188026428,
0.10577227920293808,
-0.7859691381454468,
0.5327947735786438,
0.2519614100456238,
0.5210394859313965,
0.17055436968803406,
0.0680343434214592,
0.5893221497535706,
-0.1499125063419342,
0.4547695815563202,
0.31450212001800537,
-0.5514557957649231,
0.771963894367218,
-0.31116625666618347,
0.30034056305885315,
0.1575315296649933,
0.0034387141931802034,
-0.3098704218864441,
-0.3263359069824219,
-0.3828440010547638,
-0.6234298348426819,
0.49258747696876526,
-0.0678124725818634,
0.006601420696824789,
-0.22004781663417816,
0.4154343008995056,
0.293597936630249,
-0.23293457925319672,
-0.32560667395591736,
-0.2604162096977234,
0.017333321273326874,
-0.2331497073173523,
0.22049005329608917,
-0.32963788509368896,
-0.3778895139694214,
-0.25072479248046875,
0.41234931349754333,
-0.3294398784637451,
0.44869258999824524,
0.4759650230407715,
-0.14806531369686127,
-0.03681490570306778,
0.22844040393829346,
0.678610622882843,
0.8925625681877136,
-0.1345951408147812,
-0.01787870191037655,
0.12337373942136765,
-0.7117077112197876,
-0.1368023008108139,
-0.01737704500555992,
0.22030627727508545,
0.049091584980487823,
0.2615716755390167,
0.6987100839614868,
0.1497431993484497,
-0.8827887177467346,
0.5246129631996155,
-0.48107242584228516,
-0.3174096345901489,
-0.45079582929611206,
-0.03455931320786476,
-0.2018386870622635,
0.3788345456123352,
0.3183072805404663,
0.34603363275527954,
0.22707580029964447,
-0.23760253190994263,
0.42990821599960327,
0.3697790503501892,
-0.5030362010002136,
-0.27530771493911743,
0.6192561984062195,
0.1995387077331543,
0.058675676584243774,
0.5175510048866272,
0.4106326997280121,
-0.018665509298443794,
0.6283979415893555,
0.3145917057991028,
0.7467197179794312,
-0.19942277669906616,
0.2988009750843048,
0.36860978603363037,
0.03135313838720322,
0.18787680566310883,
0.3241012394428253,
0.06420817226171494,
-0.6370777487754822,
-0.49611562490463257,
-0.26281213760375977,
-0.4045814275741577,
0.07028552889823914,
-0.8621799349784851,
0.3154821991920471,
-0.5628477931022644,
-0.27447348833084106,
0.25111448764801025,
-0.1516120284795761,
-0.7647888660430908,
0.5869616866111755,
0.4225939214229584,
0.7689802646636963,
-0.5874355435371399,
1.1936286687850952,
0.6678687334060669,
-0.4777013063430786,
-0.5997318625450134,
-0.32872840762138367,
0.12162905931472778,
-1.399783730506897,
0.9726176261901855,
-0.23869003355503082,
-0.3772185146808624,
-0.14352108538150787,
-0.23353098332881927,
-0.8486713171005249,
1.3000245094299316,
0.21413247287273407,
-0.6631278991699219,
0.25437334179878235,
-0.03246495872735977,
0.3898393213748932,
-0.6662473678588867,
0.33796700835227966,
0.42796048521995544,
0.4680888056755066,
0.4657518267631531,
-1.1437904834747314,
0.28757354617118835,
-0.1786317080259323,
-0.03791731968522072,
-0.07921542227268219,
-0.28873854875564575,
0.526306688785553,
-0.49546343088150024,
0.02909507043659687,
0.10943740606307983,
0.3667926490306854,
-0.033461883664131165,
0.3618708848953247,
0.476898193359375,
0.3974124491214752,
0.6118020415306091,
0.10927790403366089,
1.4011831283569336,
-0.37740036845207214,
-0.14198701083660126,
0.6952859163284302,
-0.34403666853904724,
0.6118705868721008,
0.27494025230407715,
-0.080423504114151,
0.5067822933197021,
0.1573554128408432,
0.1943155825138092,
0.5966670513153076,
-0.37503960728645325,
-0.45596471428871155,
-0.566551685333252,
-0.285727858543396,
-0.6029502749443054,
0.6964330077171326,
0.6614142060279846,
-0.2969142198562622,
-0.017658792436122894,
0.33174756169319153,
-0.03948276862502098,
0.10444654524326324,
-0.3153629004955292,
0.9481905698776245,
0.10931175947189331,
-0.2633397877216339,
0.8464720249176025,
-0.44603896141052246,
0.4931768476963043,
-0.8610005378723145,
-0.20695587992668152,
-0.24166728556156158,
0.4650837182998657,
-0.26244693994522095,
-0.7769138216972351,
0.48531225323677063,
-0.3599831461906433,
-0.19030071794986725,
-0.05296153947710991,
0.8590618371963501,
-0.19174380600452423,
-0.49090251326560974,
0.26835164427757263,
0.667919933795929,
0.12652502954006195,
0.15582047402858734,
-0.7488017082214355,
0.6440091729164124,
0.12276368588209152,
0.0731663852930069,
0.47901293635368347,
0.07570511102676392,
-0.06253844499588013,
0.8785858750343323,
0.33506864309310913,
0.04171007499098778,
-0.5280908942222595,
0.07376661151647568,
1.0947420597076416,
-0.3206446170806885,
-0.1165846511721611,
-0.36248788237571716,
0.5003108382225037,
-0.04140938073396683,
-0.14719824492931366,
0.3247319459915161,
0.21635062992572784,
0.29424524307250977,
-0.11643151193857193,
1.0309563875198364,
0.06870415806770325,
0.477282851934433,
-0.5228493213653564,
0.49059441685676575,
-0.9092973470687866,
0.20587702095508575,
-0.1691117137670517,
-0.33319512009620667,
-0.6583682894706726,
0.6940609812736511,
-0.40724804997444153,
-0.056170668452978134,
0.7029773592948914,
1.0137245655059814,
-0.121062271296978,
-0.2004179209470749,
0.8143457174301147,
0.3101298213005066,
0.24167434871196747,
0.5034959316253662,
0.6804530024528503,
-0.2025560885667801,
0.5951412320137024,
-0.1514408141374588,
-0.6202125549316406,
-0.36777183413505554,
-0.6708786487579346,
-0.7402974367141724,
-0.5220780968666077,
-0.7000463604927063,
-0.21168455481529236,
0.2968745827674866,
0.7260055541992188,
0.834364652633667,
-0.2297639399766922,
-0.08627142757177353,
0.42038944363594055,
-0.17793042957782745,
-0.20358240604400635,
-0.1076468750834465,
0.4667235314846039,
-0.0962051972746849,
-0.47506287693977356,
0.6345840692520142,
0.6416141986846924,
-0.08684170991182327,
-0.25767016410827637,
-0.09419561177492142,
0.20156793296337128,
0.17468422651290894,
0.6806911826133728,
0.34782740473747253,
-0.777321994304657,
-0.13880471885204315,
0.3936580419540405,
-0.057477280497550964,
0.19372020661830902,
0.692304253578186,
-1.0408825874328613,
0.9913453459739685,
0.07485982775688171,
0.5330408811569214,
0.3811151385307312,
-0.2956380844116211,
0.7247569561004639,
-0.30839696526527405,
0.22453097999095917,
0.34519585967063904,
0.21720941364765167,
0.4207940101623535,
-0.5821913480758667,
0.18333610892295837,
0.01905818283557892,
-0.5489625930786133,
-0.6392626166343689,
0.30915629863739014,
-1.4151197671890259,
-0.4111107587814331,
1.1729434728622437,
-0.05617889016866684,
-0.19154132902622223,
-0.4426047205924988,
-0.6152300834655762,
-0.33890870213508606,
-0.3660270869731903,
0.665168821811676,
-0.006009223870933056,
-0.47914040088653564,
-0.5160074830055237,
-0.7085990309715271,
0.38064104318618774,
0.22094082832336426,
-0.752354621887207,
-0.05754808336496353,
0.7784446477890015,
0.3188289999961853,
-0.10821925103664398,
0.9706538319587708,
-0.23937435448169708,
0.7138922810554504,
-0.07997290045022964,
0.09866485744714737,
-0.5186596512794495,
-0.14432460069656372,
-0.27088063955307007,
-0.027683282271027565,
0.26389917731285095,
-0.2686098515987396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02596v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02596v1 | Towards More Realistic Extraction Attacks: An Adversarial Perspective | 2024-07-02T18:33:49 | 2024-07-02T18:33:49 | Yash More, Prakhar Ganesh, Golnoosh Farnadi | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models are prone to memorizing large parts of their training data,
making them vulnerable to extraction attacks. Existing research on these
attacks remains limited in scope, often studying isolated trends rather than
the real-world interactions with these models. In this paper, we revisit
extraction attacks from an adversarial perspective, exploiting the brittleness
of language models. We find significant churn in extraction attack trends,
i.e., even minor, unintuitive changes to the prompt, or targeting smaller
models and older checkpoints, can exacerbate the risks of extraction by up to
$2-4 \times$. Moreover, relying solely on the widely accepted verbatim match
underestimates the extent of extracted information, and we provide various
alternatives to more accurately capture the true risks of extraction. We
conclude our discussion with data deduplication, a commonly suggested
mitigation strategy, and find that while it addresses some memorization
concerns, it remains vulnerable to the same escalation of extraction risks
against a real-world adversary. Our findings highlight the necessity of
acknowledging an adversary's true capabilities to avoid underestimating
extraction risks. | [
-0.32611697912216187,
-1.1934711933135986,
0.3729381859302521,
-0.3731565475463867,
-0.1713392734527588,
0.008067122660577297,
-0.1422404646873474,
-0.6136786937713623,
-0.15527066588401794,
0.5526494383811951,
-0.4845127463340759,
0.12569460272789001,
-1.0814613103866577,
-0.13665339350700378,
-0.8526068329811096,
0.8131287693977356,
0.286212682723999,
-0.24922870099544525,
0.046362683176994324,
0.0266102384775877,
-0.5206107497215271,
-0.7362866997718811,
-0.7423058748245239,
-0.0682189092040062,
0.5543936491012573,
0.046835362911224365,
0.9336894154548645,
1.001105546951294,
0.6094366908073425,
0.29667267203330994,
-0.21773454546928406,
-0.30857107043266296,
-0.45178309082984924,
0.450096994638443,
-0.10698442906141281,
-0.7088070511817932,
-0.14370134472846985,
0.2808597683906555,
0.4732179343700409,
0.6048235893249512,
-0.07369883358478546,
-0.12713463604450226,
-0.1097918376326561,
0.8195735812187195,
-0.7161609530448914,
-0.2700514495372772,
-1.2457259893417358,
0.06454955041408539,
-0.4028264880180359,
-0.03226485475897789,
-0.44644126296043396,
-0.13526958227157593,
0.2337399125099182,
-0.20730845630168915,
0.26100587844848633,
-0.35519346594810486,
1.079817533493042,
0.15830795466899872,
-0.07653358578681946,
-0.4191986620426178,
-0.8000755906105042,
0.7180377840995789,
-0.3813396096229553,
0.11826079338788986,
0.338106244802475,
0.7277923822402954,
-0.10040634125471115,
-0.7287511229515076,
-0.25664064288139343,
-0.12774565815925598,
0.22219258546829224,
-0.13395053148269653,
-0.723515510559082,
-0.3020414113998413,
0.526404619216919,
0.40031132102012634,
-0.2753622829914093,
0.18498100340366364,
-0.6314204931259155,
0.009977074339985847,
0.5981281995773315,
0.018083062022924423,
0.5722935795783997,
0.021202852949500084,
-0.6318017244338989,
-0.18320494890213013,
-0.9598240256309509,
-0.13108500838279724,
0.6096135973930359,
0.4389558434486389,
0.26696133613586426,
0.43361610174179077,
0.2919052839279175,
0.43635469675064087,
-0.0906832218170166,
0.30746549367904663,
-0.16452154517173767,
-0.10454810410737991,
-0.2842825949192047,
0.08711197227239609,
0.6379612684249878,
-0.17050336301326752,
0.5195430517196655,
-0.5681345462799072,
-0.2154902219772339,
-0.013439169153571129,
0.8303066492080688,
-0.6165067553520203,
-0.6128820180892944,
0.2739747166633606,
-0.22922416031360626,
-0.7005301117897034,
0.28603652119636536,
-1.24531888961792,
-0.500427782535553,
0.08658378571271896,
0.2583310604095459,
-0.6243500113487244,
-0.21696993708610535,
-0.09816550463438034,
-0.42991703748703003,
0.13682687282562256,
0.3301837742328644,
-0.7089350819587708,
0.30460378527641296,
0.843823254108429,
0.7898679375648499,
-0.13264182209968567,
-0.12325894832611084,
-0.8177903294563293,
-0.005137650761753321,
-0.2147451788187027,
0.5407811403274536,
-0.3674345016479492,
-0.46358299255371094,
-0.11538027971982956,
-0.1420825868844986,
-0.22422020137310028,
-0.6753619909286499,
0.37094950675964355,
-0.6794149875640869,
0.2624659240245819,
-0.26359453797340393,
-0.3378582000732422,
-0.2718046009540558,
0.4537303149700165,
-0.9903165102005005,
0.7089395523071289,
0.0759584903717041,
-0.7126540541648865,
0.13828116655349731,
-0.31947118043899536,
-0.3875730037689209,
-0.020853564143180847,
-0.15914812684059143,
-0.4557799994945526,
0.22828981280326843,
0.2464727759361267,
0.14471611380577087,
-0.3639131784439087,
0.1854926198720932,
-0.410349577665329,
-0.11957886815071106,
0.5411587953567505,
-1.1897978782653809,
1.183261752128601,
0.5666120648384094,
-0.536950409412384,
-0.34959474205970764,
-0.668571412563324,
-0.2370397299528122,
0.48886799812316895,
-0.31658491492271423,
-0.5363023281097412,
0.12211728096008301,
-0.3753964602947235,
0.35173267126083374,
0.033409010618925095,
-0.2924518287181854,
0.2963711619377136,
-0.771872878074646,
0.33504483103752136,
0.930398166179657,
0.12025978416204453,
0.4308820962905884,
-0.35921382904052734,
0.7536491751670837,
-0.09630008786916733,
0.187725231051445,
-0.01425937656313181,
0.07351811975240707,
-0.526523768901825,
-0.5773585438728333,
0.5536450147628784,
0.6875723600387573,
-0.6808010935783386,
0.18183459341526031,
-0.5410177111625671,
-0.6563348174095154,
-0.48751744627952576,
0.3843209147453308,
0.5218687057495117,
0.3971847891807556,
0.30676060914993286,
-0.3094612658023834,
-0.49674084782600403,
-0.6315008997917175,
-0.8127020597457886,
-0.1161099523305893,
-0.13946233689785004,
0.1176101416349411,
0.39204931259155273,
0.03429066017270088,
1.0048757791519165,
-0.6312995553016663,
-0.04542449861764908,
-0.5121641755104065,
0.09696091711521149,
-0.22120332717895508,
0.6470986604690552,
0.7021740674972534,
-1.2090762853622437,
-0.29175007343292236,
-0.1605532169342041,
-0.805762529373169,
0.3399571180343628,
-0.32781147956848145,
0.07814053446054459,
0.10770759731531143,
0.4620668590068817,
-0.9745616316795349,
0.3329709470272064,
0.029915712773799896,
0.14583086967468262,
0.31303125619888306,
0.11202416568994522,
-0.21909530460834503,
-0.9370225667953491,
0.15339046716690063,
-0.1567494124174118,
-0.1194651871919632,
-0.814346194267273,
0.41848745942115784,
-0.005193273536860943,
-0.04477781802415848,
-0.8233144879341125,
0.38063761591911316,
-0.49621862173080444,
0.07958142459392548,
-0.0818701907992363,
0.12189243733882904,
0.11045626550912857,
0.15161314606666565,
-0.22444091737270355,
0.45871302485466003,
0.5527856945991516,
-0.46035486459732056,
0.38664066791534424,
-0.055184874683618546,
-0.22415873408317566,
0.28058817982673645,
-0.5781574845314026,
0.44149890542030334,
-0.1789717972278595,
0.008970826864242554,
-0.6639014482498169,
0.09201537072658539,
0.41051429510116577,
-0.6529679894447327,
0.7948588132858276,
-0.3243693709373474,
-0.3676202595233917,
-0.1026049479842186,
-0.7176231145858765,
-0.04379963129758835,
0.645048201084137,
-0.5214806795120239,
0.46618789434432983,
0.3711659014225006,
-0.3364803194999695,
-0.938454806804657,
-0.7049357891082764,
0.3590793311595917,
-0.8304709196090698,
-0.26585689187049866,
-0.035520028322935104,
0.25262194871902466,
-0.6719852089881897,
-0.1261765956878662,
-0.15618349611759186,
-0.08271603286266327,
0.8947415351867676,
0.1960582584142685,
0.2014361023902893,
0.07870286703109741,
-0.16903573274612427,
-0.47430717945098877,
-0.017339998856186867,
0.3285873532295227,
-0.17527565360069275,
0.5441097617149353,
0.1411658525466919,
-0.33558496832847595,
-0.10518262535333633,
0.4141947329044342,
0.5465388894081116,
-0.17427624762058258,
0.6706936955451965,
0.5398980975151062,
-0.7158365249633789,
0.033526383340358734,
-0.46481651067733765,
-0.1027757003903389,
-0.4567108750343323,
0.5722049474716187,
-0.36975258588790894,
-0.11095269024372101,
0.4322039783000946,
-0.09010519087314606,
0.3112906515598297,
0.5734143853187561,
0.06728791445493698,
-0.1317831575870514,
1.1007381677627563,
0.3647989332675934,
-0.4558963477611542,
0.6439640522003174,
-0.38329192996025085,
-0.0998603031039238,
-0.601882815361023,
-0.1812639683485031,
-0.7767254710197449,
-0.051300760358572006,
-0.3194570541381836,
-0.014166911132633686,
-0.18375733494758606,
0.29902511835098267,
0.15788567066192627,
0.5073021650314331,
-0.05442335456609726,
0.36409515142440796,
0.53739333152771,
0.029388563707470894,
-0.1278105080127716,
0.2008001059293747,
0.32678428292274475,
-0.12209265679121017,
-0.6407521963119507,
-0.4385438561439514,
1.0772225856781006,
0.5033929347991943,
0.7176020741462708,
0.40975695848464966,
0.6731352210044861,
0.4128887355327606,
0.05612742155790329,
-0.7270705699920654,
0.33514168858528137,
-0.29647982120513916,
-0.6147831678390503,
-0.1325194388628006,
-0.5852231383323669,
-1.2595851421356201,
0.3317353129386902,
-0.2268831580877304,
-0.9522358179092407,
0.15079236030578613,
0.10066492110490799,
-0.2632123529911041,
0.48598602414131165,
-0.6353533864021301,
0.8660330176353455,
-0.24536921083927155,
-0.18392816185951233,
0.20520010590553284,
-0.8862932324409485,
0.2845660448074341,
-0.19057999551296234,
0.4434119760990143,
0.18375428020954132,
0.27390122413635254,
0.6079975962638855,
-0.2892867922782898,
0.813479483127594,
-0.2696394622325897,
-0.07027973234653473,
0.3844362795352936,
0.442740797996521,
0.8720777630805969,
-0.2215971201658249,
0.0816076323390007,
-0.036368053406476974,
-0.09686417877674103,
-0.4521435797214508,
-0.6185756325721741,
0.4107818305492401,
-0.5233136415481567,
-0.7869930863380432,
-0.46618929505348206,
-0.37417420744895935,
0.14274688065052032,
0.11401684582233429,
0.28263208270072937,
0.5583749413490295,
-0.46195605397224426,
0.16408590972423553,
0.6600356698036194,
0.024033674970269203,
0.4689260423183441,
0.14291346073150635,
0.4449175000190735,
-0.43157705664634705,
1.4089305400848389,
0.1609669029712677,
0.7119894623756409,
0.2664124667644501,
0.20131659507751465,
-0.327838659286499,
-0.7372323870658875,
-0.3901591897010803,
-0.19978347420692444,
-0.9273707866668701,
-0.15026646852493286,
-0.7120115160942078,
-0.08075547218322754,
-0.6281166672706604,
0.09655462950468063,
-0.4759519696235657,
-0.5721743702888489,
-0.575285017490387,
-0.11773937195539474,
0.07572691887617111,
0.4425320625305176,
0.1436956822872162,
0.1239316463470459,
-1.1370561122894287,
0.22003094851970673,
0.27381080389022827,
-0.4622887074947357,
-0.05035481974482536,
-0.5633288621902466,
-0.12332881987094879,
0.137339785695076,
-0.41835740208625793,
-1.0396018028259277,
0.7161191701889038,
0.2121070772409439,
0.5741251707077026,
0.4180735647678375,
0.004684129264205694,
0.7331043481826782,
-0.514745831489563,
0.9023455381393433,
0.17113806307315826,
-0.6318924427032471,
0.5313059091567993,
0.012675562873482704,
0.16846977174282074,
0.7943518757820129,
0.47958436608314514,
-0.26680755615234375,
-0.4567926228046417,
-1.1848047971725464,
-1.0376510620117188,
0.6126116514205933,
0.04228706657886505,
0.1741660237312317,
-0.08262757211923599,
0.3827154040336609,
0.1781671643257141,
0.17427301406860352,
-0.6671403050422668,
-0.10207120329141617,
-0.028831956908106804,
-0.2705743610858917,
0.06610593944787979,
-0.18588903546333313,
-0.26675140857696533,
0.2143336981534958,
0.39895057678222656,
0.24503134191036224,
-0.0952296182513237,
0.040613602846860886,
-0.6623814702033997,
0.041724421083927155,
0.2887555658817291,
0.2591419219970703,
0.3495241403579712,
-0.14105412364006042,
0.4496997892856598,
0.022447947412729263,
-0.6577430367469788,
-0.008362026885151863,
0.3514080345630646,
-0.18886373937129974,
-0.22045756876468658,
0.5835882425308228,
0.38629674911499023,
-0.13771748542785645,
-0.8939276337623596,
0.7030846476554871,
-0.12231193482875824,
-0.08302219957113266,
-0.4710542857646942,
0.02221808023750782,
-0.30375704169273376,
0.22664406895637512,
0.2917022407054901,
0.36102718114852905,
0.1338455080986023,
-0.5881754159927368,
0.46273142099380493,
0.795116662979126,
-0.8261826038360596,
-0.41659948229789734,
0.5134983062744141,
-0.2335789054632187,
-0.32766783237457275,
0.6739358305931091,
0.027747536078095436,
-0.7913443446159363,
0.7283251881599426,
0.3817204236984253,
0.9384544491767883,
-0.2077195793390274,
-0.22790318727493286,
-0.001918776542879641,
0.6422523260116577,
-0.27464422583580017,
-0.19472984969615936,
0.20669063925743103,
-0.3483463525772095,
0.047075048089027405,
-0.19446909427642822,
-0.11227808147668839,
0.29166120290756226,
-0.8554154634475708,
0.2451726347208023,
-0.45750102400779724,
0.14262478053569794,
0.09767667949199677,
0.02083951234817505,
-0.46160033345222473,
0.1741919219493866,
0.16568899154663086,
0.6421001553535461,
-0.6394705772399902,
0.8103234171867371,
0.285143107175827,
-0.5415048599243164,
-0.4392910301685333,
-0.07823147624731064,
0.3025625944137573,
-0.5657991170883179,
0.5943682789802551,
0.21790708601474762,
0.14889174699783325,
-0.2833400070667267,
-0.29959332942962646,
-0.7325655221939087,
0.8317608833312988,
0.6493907570838928,
-0.2336614429950714,
-0.20749729871749878,
-0.1556212604045868,
0.23701211810112,
0.008719803765416145,
-0.1384247988462448,
0.8974968791007996,
0.048394519835710526,
-0.01690067909657955,
-0.3294791579246521,
0.20820781588554382,
-0.16176272928714752,
-0.22516858577728271,
0.26824796199798584,
-0.18754954636096954,
1.1730605363845825,
-0.11180563271045685,
-0.7064130902290344,
-0.03681911900639534,
0.32404428720474243,
-0.25532516837120056,
-0.06167537719011307,
0.6376085877418518,
0.4719443619251251,
0.5314279198646545,
0.12117008864879608,
1.2755755186080933,
0.19027458131313324,
0.101716548204422,
1.1979557275772095,
-0.10484056919813156,
0.7465811371803284,
0.6190552711486816,
-0.17205552756786346,
-0.0020145776215940714,
0.4784422218799591,
-0.23163309693336487,
0.7136287093162537,
0.23636429011821747,
-0.040748316794633865,
0.10618497431278229,
0.31052958965301514,
-0.29276639223098755,
0.5390021204948425,
0.46227139234542847,
-0.5304049849510193,
-0.2889091670513153,
-0.21515165269374847,
0.43494912981987,
0.16600121557712555,
0.07209555059671402,
0.9820857048034668,
0.031752925366163254,
-0.5404326915740967,
0.6615007519721985,
-0.15092676877975464,
0.40928417444229126,
-0.6151286959648132,
-0.1635632961988449,
0.06934388726949692,
0.210544154047966,
0.0438050739467144,
-0.21025454998016357,
0.38800477981567383,
0.16239894926548004,
0.02018086425960064,
-0.059265173971652985,
0.8698388338088989,
-0.34979766607284546,
-0.2095632255077362,
0.1304369568824768,
0.4198593199253082,
0.13877731561660767,
-0.3915647268295288,
-0.8010420799255371,
-0.03810843080282211,
0.1561550498008728,
-0.45119228959083557,
0.7342442870140076,
0.3193839192390442,
0.18732869625091553,
0.6889408230781555,
0.6370071768760681,
0.6136705279350281,
0.09583419561386108,
-0.1010013297200203,
0.8628597855567932,
-0.5213049054145813,
-0.1533949226140976,
-1.5021731853485107,
0.2338670939207077,
-0.3159005641937256,
-0.02827969565987587,
0.7400743961334229,
0.3516554534435272,
0.6526013016700745,
0.13868841528892517,
0.8687904477119446,
-0.04073217138648033,
0.3220117390155792,
-0.6957234740257263,
0.6947537660598755,
-0.4399174153804779,
0.5873183608055115,
-0.4100764989852905,
-0.6136718988418579,
-0.2999405860900879,
0.222455695271492,
-0.20534498989582062,
-0.18250565230846405,
0.5823230147361755,
0.42508384585380554,
0.02761857584118843,
0.1001766175031662,
0.08041159808635712,
0.07329793274402618,
0.7532951831817627,
0.5704578757286072,
0.8996376395225525,
-0.6146285533905029,
1.0696275234222412,
-0.34389129281044006,
-0.039443645626306534,
-0.01045247633010149,
-0.7976532578468323,
-0.7061196565628052,
-0.28242218494415283,
-0.25946056842803955,
-0.35341277718544006,
0.07204756140708923,
0.5699285864830017,
0.13318602740764618,
-0.5634607672691345,
0.21622617542743683,
-0.12797263264656067,
0.16552291810512543,
-0.47375547885894775,
-0.2678806185722351,
0.5184208750724792,
-0.25334325432777405,
-0.757346510887146,
0.491898775100708,
-0.1335989385843277,
0.3799508810043335,
-0.10795605927705765,
0.36137470602989197,
-0.2932386100292206,
-0.01744980551302433,
0.14161239564418793,
0.5997658967971802,
-0.5411937236785889,
-0.44175398349761963,
-0.1925986409187317,
-0.18339107930660248,
0.09856153279542923,
0.6122370958328247,
-0.5999308824539185,
0.408352792263031,
0.25881069898605347,
1.1358274221420288,
0.16270259022712708,
0.29359325766563416,
0.7326623201370239,
-0.862118124961853,
0.20995646715164185,
0.33139023184776306,
0.3079226315021515,
0.39950746297836304,
-0.4663667380809784,
0.42073962092399597,
0.45811727643013,
0.005226092878729105,
-1.1682524681091309,
0.36229753494262695,
-0.5745881199836731,
-0.6663206815719604,
1.0167618989944458,
-0.6037375330924988,
-0.3583558201789856,
-0.2500452697277069,
-0.03137356415390968,
0.19839173555374146,
0.05217328667640686,
0.8880758881568909,
0.8049678206443787,
0.35012781620025635,
0.2032051682472229,
-0.796255350112915,
0.5136045813560486,
0.38635319471359253,
-0.6682283282279968,
0.48806998133659363,
0.3018655776977539,
0.283496618270874,
0.22577007114887238,
0.3010058104991913,
-0.5779543519020081,
0.2610076665878296,
0.3464968204498291,
-0.35033082962036133,
0.0145914601162076,
-0.559536337852478,
-0.637228786945343,
0.5014131665229797,
0.17351298034191132,
-0.26704731583595276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02490v1 | MInference 1.0: Accelerating Pre-filling for Long-Context LLMs via Dynamic Sparse Attention | 2024-07-02T17:59:56 | 2024-07-02T17:59:56 | Huiqiang Jiang, Yucheng Li, Chengruidong Zhang, Qianhui Wu, Xufang Luo, Surin Ahn, Zhenhua Han, Amir H. Abdi, Dongsheng Li, Chin-Yew Lin, Yuqing Yang, Lili Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The computational challenges of Large Language Model (LLM) inference remain a
significant barrier to their widespread deployment, especially as prompt
lengths continue to increase. Due to the quadratic complexity of the attention
computation, it takes 30 minutes for an 8B LLM to process a prompt of 1M tokens
(i.e., the pre-filling stage) on a single A100 GPU. Existing methods for
speeding up prefilling often fail to maintain acceptable accuracy or efficiency
when applied to long-context LLMs. To address this gap, we introduce MInference
(Milliontokens Inference), a sparse calculation method designed to accelerate
pre-filling of long-sequence processing. Specifically, we identify three unique
patterns in long-context attention matrices-the A-shape, Vertical-Slash, and
Block-Sparsethat can be leveraged for efficient sparse computation on GPUs. We
determine the optimal pattern for each attention head offline and dynamically
build sparse indices based on the assigned pattern during inference. With the
pattern and sparse indices, we perform efficient sparse attention calculations
via our optimized GPU kernels to significantly reduce the latency in the
pre-filling stage of long-context LLMs. Our proposed technique can be directly
applied to existing LLMs without any modifications to the pre-training setup or
additional fine-tuning. By evaluating on a wide range of downstream tasks,
including InfiniteBench, RULER, PG-19, and Needle In A Haystack, and models
including LLaMA-3-1M, GLM4-1M, Yi-200K, Phi-3-128K, and Qwen2-128K, we
demonstrate that MInference effectively reduces inference latency by up to 10x
for pre-filling on an A100, while maintaining accuracy. Our code is available
at https://aka.ms/MInference. | [
-0.7755216360092163,
-0.7936893105506897,
0.7439836263656616,
0.3984305262565613,
-0.5044082999229431,
-0.27476420998573303,
-0.3465970456600189,
-0.6366392970085144,
0.3350330591201782,
0.26939111948013306,
-0.854318380355835,
-0.3754870593547821,
-0.6396000385284424,
0.27568867802619934,
-0.09879753738641739,
0.5969235301017761,
0.10813449323177338,
-0.4141426086425781,
-0.5128195881843567,
-0.028269777074456215,
-0.33677828311920166,
-0.3640374541282654,
-0.6543171405792236,
0.04827779904007912,
0.8562535643577576,
0.5364744067192078,
0.6502261757850647,
0.8107267022132874,
0.29463544487953186,
0.4289616048336029,
-0.32283300161361694,
0.3725038766860962,
-0.6084432601928711,
-0.19390946626663208,
0.17004813253879547,
-0.13506504893302917,
-0.6850851774215698,
0.2318572998046875,
0.6695122122764587,
0.8000611662864685,
0.08358688652515411,
0.4137534499168396,
0.3429141044616699,
0.4523225724697113,
-0.8225506544113159,
0.08945056051015854,
-0.4745884835720062,
0.050499510020017624,
-0.48267439007759094,
-0.25297310948371887,
-0.38797783851623535,
-0.2631338834762573,
0.14015889167785645,
-1.0421414375305176,
0.2538090646266937,
0.17751382291316986,
0.5770605802536011,
0.8182300329208374,
0.03250750154256821,
-0.02473016083240509,
-0.32260268926620483,
0.7940199971199036,
-0.5738251805305481,
0.2738839387893677,
0.5439227223396301,
-0.021679388359189034,
-0.3765074908733368,
-0.7840741276741028,
-0.5987379550933838,
-0.22252097725868225,
-0.22375741600990295,
-0.2202741950750351,
-0.021154124289751053,
0.5288721323013306,
0.7034090757369995,
0.12714892625808716,
-0.331222802400589,
0.1272243708372116,
-0.01614573784172535,
-0.012160489335656166,
0.26361963152885437,
0.09021153301000595,
-0.3881683647632599,
0.04077643156051636,
-0.26485103368759155,
0.2901056110858917,
-0.8433340191841125,
-0.04838533699512482,
-0.0450829342007637,
0.24088039994239807,
-0.22282955050468445,
0.271920770406723,
-0.06758914887905121,
1.0281609296798706,
0.4844492971897125,
-0.35221147537231445,
-0.11101959645748138,
-0.36736860871315,
-0.5278015732765198,
0.17234858870506287,
0.5633974075317383,
0.010105300694704056,
0.2251397967338562,
-0.05140257999300957,
0.17103008925914764,
-0.12692616879940033,
-0.10084756463766098,
-1.1304253339767456,
0.0508110448718071,
0.1380070298910141,
-0.10726895928382874,
-0.09827038645744324,
-0.3698996305465698,
-0.7865981459617615,
-0.4824228286743164,
-0.5430569648742676,
0.2635275423526764,
-0.09202577918767929,
0.2716841697692871,
0.01277805957943201,
0.40979525446891785,
-0.10147272795438766,
0.5541113615036011,
-0.7902345061302185,
0.1960790753364563,
0.7459267973899841,
0.9571676850318909,
-0.23742039501667023,
-0.23170074820518494,
-0.9498159885406494,
0.054617661982774734,
-0.2350102663040161,
0.8983034491539001,
-0.6685457825660706,
-0.1786416918039322,
-0.23172058165073395,
-0.10875971615314484,
-0.05629975348711014,
-0.6306250691413879,
0.641544759273529,
-0.41934287548065186,
0.027735868468880653,
-0.19163136184215546,
-0.6207191944122314,
0.22371986508369446,
0.016686920076608658,
-0.6441748738288879,
1.1592130661010742,
-0.01917685754597187,
-0.7149873971939087,
0.30705752968788147,
-0.7267703413963318,
-0.3609844744205475,
0.1974659562110901,
-0.27626991271972656,
-0.10243869572877884,
0.11673399806022644,
0.24535228312015533,
0.39635583758354187,
-0.4210997521877289,
0.13697758316993713,
-0.4783247113227844,
-0.8032509684562683,
-0.07686657458543777,
-0.13728085160255432,
0.4685613811016083,
0.03878597170114517,
-0.29603585600852966,
0.3721892833709717,
-0.6873794198036194,
-0.06422848254442215,
-0.1251000016927719,
-0.18494948744773865,
-0.23394007980823517,
-0.08506129682064056,
-0.1987987607717514,
0.17090333998203278,
0.2231374830007553,
-0.3318871557712555,
0.22870276868343353,
-0.40783941745758057,
0.5248762369155884,
1.0444085597991943,
-0.2514725625514984,
0.5084396004676819,
0.040761277079582214,
0.5249398946762085,
-0.047310467809438705,
0.15208707749843597,
-0.41262784600257874,
-0.4933384358882904,
-0.7811830043792725,
-0.6222559809684753,
0.44990214705467224,
0.4449672996997833,
-0.538348376750946,
0.42083922028541565,
-0.4699094891548157,
-0.07940436899662018,
-0.5801362991333008,
0.38439902663230896,
0.27669084072113037,
0.5853161811828613,
0.35473230481147766,
0.05002153664827347,
-0.6419241428375244,
-0.7179604768753052,
-0.08730952441692352,
0.10352843999862671,
-0.07065556198358536,
0.42533108592033386,
0.06325940042734146,
-0.2934177815914154,
0.9303938746452332,
-0.5396426320075989,
-0.406317800283432,
0.06115848571062088,
0.04506737366318703,
0.4211985468864441,
0.5206061601638794,
0.2523662745952606,
-0.5666089057922363,
-0.460929811000824,
-0.5215412974357605,
-0.4401687681674957,
-0.28249087929725647,
-0.10236403346061707,
-0.39890509843826294,
0.04206366837024689,
0.7819340229034424,
-0.8379471302032471,
0.4154535233974457,
0.5614879131317139,
-0.29451578855514526,
0.35281485319137573,
-0.021536383777856827,
-0.09530580788850784,
-0.8364807367324829,
0.1280108392238617,
-0.13224588334560394,
-0.3057589530944824,
-0.4810691177845001,
-0.13177736103534698,
0.06866660714149475,
-0.12248551845550537,
-0.4837045669555664,
0.7888817191123962,
-0.4810558557510376,
0.043237052857875824,
-0.33759230375289917,
0.317359983921051,
-0.028871536254882812,
0.6590680480003357,
-0.008791386149823666,
1.1114301681518555,
0.16969682276248932,
-0.7468782067298889,
0.15734465420246124,
0.19610770046710968,
-0.5758551359176636,
0.21065610647201538,
-0.4436097741127014,
0.36360397934913635,
-0.028899597004055977,
0.1844511181116104,
-1.1206912994384766,
-0.06938795745372772,
0.17003099620342255,
-0.297995924949646,
0.36118781566619873,
-0.18296664953231812,
-0.5192828178405762,
-0.40136268734931946,
-0.19897325336933136,
0.743137776851654,
0.2184394896030426,
-0.5807873606681824,
0.5837500691413879,
0.24622280895709991,
-0.5001004934310913,
-0.6022725105285645,
-0.5829576253890991,
0.16532675921916962,
-0.1524709165096283,
-0.7948783040046692,
0.5337044596672058,
-0.3181973993778229,
-0.14973518252372742,
-0.16282518208026886,
-0.1408112496137619,
0.11061029881238937,
0.10088510066270828,
0.4294944703578949,
0.3090347647666931,
-0.3439892530441284,
0.09108588099479675,
-0.00271421205252409,
-0.4383014738559723,
-0.21717792749404907,
-0.2532142400741577,
0.4573361873626709,
0.09936877340078354,
-0.25762251019477844,
-0.4835609793663025,
0.44950318336486816,
0.6474069356918335,
0.04606318473815918,
0.4769574999809265,
0.4015571177005768,
-0.5056496858596802,
0.09248257428407669,
-0.9608543515205383,
-0.27339789271354675,
-0.5566229224205017,
0.37051457166671753,
-0.36878085136413574,
-1.1119130849838257,
0.21602891385555267,
-0.09448250383138657,
-0.037568241357803345,
0.13613827526569366,
0.4814379811286926,
0.10058987885713577,
0.8911532163619995,
0.8332309722900391,
-0.403419554233551,
0.7149810194969177,
0.04371308162808418,
0.16497962176799774,
-0.6826105117797852,
0.10101749002933502,
-0.24301929771900177,
-0.4655252695083618,
-0.3336540162563324,
-0.9577163457870483,
0.30362677574157715,
0.16640444099903107,
-0.1776081770658493,
-0.03430037945508957,
-0.3255541920661926,
0.7685104012489319,
0.4508015513420105,
0.0030737940687686205,
0.2282116860151291,
0.08441418409347534,
-0.2612728476524353,
-0.25508835911750793,
-0.7719986438751221,
-0.22999316453933716,
0.7015835046768188,
0.04083176702260971,
0.6798673272132874,
-0.2402707040309906,
0.43808725476264954,
0.34251868724823,
0.644054114818573,
-0.814502477645874,
0.8143770694732666,
-0.042434923350811005,
-0.2742204964160919,
-0.31734538078308105,
-0.3525370955467224,
-0.7772037386894226,
0.2764872610569,
-0.1312350481748581,
-0.5879237651824951,
0.18295443058013916,
0.45136892795562744,
-0.9676197171211243,
0.10362031310796738,
-0.6747030019760132,
0.9794541597366333,
-0.011825631372630596,
-0.8707140684127808,
-0.25134798884391785,
-0.5607263445854187,
0.39005047082901,
-0.33100080490112305,
0.06984160095453262,
-0.3731059432029724,
-0.300009548664093,
0.5874220132827759,
-0.47236478328704834,
0.7999199628829956,
-0.286190390586853,
-0.03384026885032654,
0.20780056715011597,
-0.12408284097909927,
0.8344041705131531,
0.053726229816675186,
0.007138567045331001,
-0.04145626351237297,
-0.26554250717163086,
-0.49321675300598145,
-0.34872207045555115,
0.7876035571098328,
-0.40929311513900757,
-0.7384472489356995,
-0.400126188993454,
-0.5621646046638489,
-0.3382962942123413,
0.1638537049293518,
0.19518086314201355,
0.12941309809684753,
-0.06072136014699936,
-0.055178429931402206,
0.7670615315437317,
-0.051959093660116196,
0.45366400480270386,
0.4513040781021118,
-0.010198368690907955,
-0.33053460717201233,
0.5663043856620789,
-0.011128776706755161,
0.04120931401848793,
0.2822604179382324,
0.02294960431754589,
-0.3164431154727936,
-0.46612805128097534,
-0.5783935785293579,
0.4129086136817932,
-0.494762122631073,
-0.27821603417396545,
-0.6364312767982483,
0.10533999651670456,
-0.3782690167427063,
-0.21116766333580017,
-0.2606056332588196,
-0.2434752732515335,
-0.37119388580322266,
0.14598694443702698,
0.2896004915237427,
0.24258628487586975,
-0.021889053285121918,
0.4687623381614685,
-0.6313009858131409,
0.4762415587902069,
0.4192144572734833,
0.266612708568573,
-0.023625103756785393,
-0.7362450361251831,
-0.37589994072914124,
-0.07773769646883011,
-0.09729461371898651,
-0.4013022184371948,
0.2008705735206604,
0.4814663529396057,
0.31224751472473145,
0.8940458297729492,
-0.05446229502558708,
1.5816123485565186,
-0.7456084489822388,
0.4609045684337616,
0.0719149112701416,
-1.007992148399353,
0.31277233362197876,
0.02820618823170662,
0.39834722876548767,
0.6681285500526428,
0.31457215547561646,
-0.44401195645332336,
-0.24628587067127228,
-0.3537178635597229,
-0.776391863822937,
0.7943744659423828,
0.09205886721611023,
-0.23287217319011688,
-0.06456738710403442,
0.5977287292480469,
-0.17667947709560394,
0.20160582661628723,
-0.2817448079586029,
-0.21960076689720154,
0.24696175754070282,
-0.07817227393388748,
-0.5321946144104004,
-0.6417784690856934,
-0.08670011907815933,
-0.5694351196289062,
0.4337838590145111,
-0.25940653681755066,
0.4948492646217346,
0.2059679627418518,
-0.24332572519779205,
-0.16762758791446686,
-0.03758445382118225,
1.1135574579238892,
0.6343259811401367,
-0.2356278896331787,
0.1712087094783783,
0.5173109769821167,
-0.6438595652580261,
0.024215372279286385,
0.554399311542511,
-0.07708364725112915,
0.13026875257492065,
0.20137904584407806,
0.7280012369155884,
0.4734787940979004,
-0.654292106628418,
0.45263558626174927,
-0.09356863796710968,
0.03811139613389969,
-0.39092978835105896,
-0.24403563141822815,
0.19321013987064362,
0.21380607783794403,
0.39847323298454285,
-0.12482651323080063,
-0.10904638469219208,
-0.10605227202177048,
0.1427450180053711,
0.31918713450431824,
-0.2581905126571655,
-0.16831795871257782,
0.6535144448280334,
0.24926812946796417,
0.06276986747980118,
0.4850785434246063,
-0.13716013729572296,
-0.2281140834093094,
0.460061639547348,
0.3498585522174835,
0.7885545492172241,
-0.24388402700424194,
-0.5098305940628052,
0.4978514313697815,
0.10616151243448257,
0.10408506542444229,
-0.0284214299172163,
-0.5370345711708069,
-0.4694440960884094,
-1.0623142719268799,
-0.9135770797729492,
-0.37567442655563354,
0.3711167573928833,
-0.3153470754623413,
0.21314071118831635,
-0.6283681392669678,
-0.36198246479034424,
0.18170231580734253,
0.12961436808109283,
-0.5164209604263306,
0.008746926672756672,
0.5781255960464478,
1.1124991178512573,
-0.4191233515739441,
1.0235283374786377,
0.3971250653266907,
0.24261677265167236,
-0.39031776785850525,
-0.3245733678340912,
0.04396494850516319,
-0.7819432020187378,
0.6942063570022583,
0.4074137806892395,
-0.38957759737968445,
0.07262182980775833,
-0.5928882956504822,
-0.8967116475105286,
0.9237020611763,
0.5963953137397766,
-0.8349607586860657,
-0.26976922154426575,
0.1837996542453766,
0.09815933555364609,
-0.2352050095796585,
0.09727972000837326,
0.7302375435829163,
0.5623618960380554,
0.19511108100414276,
-0.6350058913230896,
0.14054077863693237,
-0.29372525215148926,
-0.2362404316663742,
0.35174185037612915,
-0.49529772996902466,
0.7683759927749634,
-0.4674347937107086,
-0.2840820252895355,
0.5009221434593201,
0.9603546261787415,
0.4801369309425354,
0.24565763771533966,
0.641951322555542,
0.7609013915061951,
1.0027517080307007,
-0.05955776199698448,
0.7761639952659607,
-0.6899416446685791,
0.13483771681785583,
1.3601444959640503,
-0.16407805681228638,
0.7872325778007507,
0.7504896521568298,
-0.22603541612625122,
0.15366040170192719,
0.9038206338882446,
0.29397377371788025,
0.33623844385147095,
0.35477957129478455,
-0.6088611483573914,
-0.5534523129463196,
-0.12732632458209991,
-0.49535268545150757,
-0.08083057403564453,
0.571481466293335,
-0.21272608637809753,
-0.07790102809667587,
-0.09621166437864304,
0.09860463440418243,
-0.4000700116157532,
-0.5105128884315491,
0.6952347755432129,
0.26881343126296997,
-0.8437830209732056,
0.9007104635238647,
0.04932829365134239,
0.9147237539291382,
-0.6904856562614441,
0.010654887184500694,
-0.39759448170661926,
0.3916904628276825,
-0.12123645842075348,
-0.2419459968805313,
-0.019207831472158432,
0.15622027218341827,
-0.2647255063056946,
-0.2221563756465912,
0.6559272408485413,
-0.5271177887916565,
-0.33668220043182373,
0.24230608344078064,
0.16077536344528198,
0.14569760859012604,
-0.5882938504219055,
-0.5698701739311218,
0.055340949445962906,
-0.09261573851108551,
-0.1803797483444214,
0.45569908618927,
0.4608999490737915,
0.058660317212343216,
0.6429808139801025,
0.8173351287841797,
0.04748997092247009,
0.42107367515563965,
-0.09593595564365387,
0.9855656623840332,
-0.69512939453125,
-0.521759033203125,
-0.9380798935890198,
0.11931221932172775,
0.08655579388141632,
-0.22923994064331055,
0.6343238949775696,
0.6847714185714722,
0.56626296043396,
-0.031299665570259094,
0.4048292338848114,
0.20873954892158508,
0.3896629810333252,
-0.39678582549095154,
0.4610114097595215,
-0.5251439213752747,
0.04093018174171448,
-0.10968044400215149,
-0.9492411613464355,
-0.27991825342178345,
0.6438689231872559,
-0.2908385694026947,
-0.07049067318439484,
0.5564104318618774,
0.8395701050758362,
-0.2138727903366089,
-0.19684872031211853,
0.46727803349494934,
0.30847474932670593,
-0.03793007507920265,
0.7786895632743835,
0.7402873635292053,
-0.1436648815870285,
0.5614060759544373,
-0.29125797748565674,
-0.2552497684955597,
-0.41488155722618103,
-1.0761638879776,
-0.735286295413971,
-0.18186922371387482,
-0.27500617504119873,
-0.3088615834712982,
0.07410980761051178,
1.181962013244629,
0.8575581908226013,
-0.7474966645240784,
-0.09095758199691772,
-0.020684385672211647,
0.07266078889369965,
0.12679186463356018,
-0.1651236116886139,
0.3809114992618561,
-0.5348377227783203,
-0.9533475041389465,
0.44806164503097534,
0.38401663303375244,
0.07912032306194305,
0.02400299720466137,
-0.21526777744293213,
-0.2371528595685959,
0.042033057659864426,
0.8937379717826843,
0.3875081241130829,
-0.7645593285560608,
-0.06937064230442047,
-0.12998129427433014,
-0.21454554796218872,
0.30919143557548523,
1.024401068687439,
-0.9277786016464233,
0.27552664279937744,
0.3913111090660095,
0.7872440218925476,
0.6771623492240906,
0.2525012195110321,
0.17137689888477325,
-0.6734226942062378,
0.7920264005661011,
0.31974273920059204,
0.3709588050842285,
0.17944025993347168,
-0.25292837619781494,
0.3738512396812439,
0.4943239688873291,
-0.5280367136001587,
-0.8581901788711548,
0.07097073644399643,
-1.1014105081558228,
0.009878083132207394,
0.985211193561554,
-0.1372954249382019,
-0.33567389845848083,
-0.16799966990947723,
-0.1491132378578186,
0.11512455344200134,
-0.3746037185192108,
0.5380463600158691,
0.6330791115760803,
-0.1411510556936264,
-0.24181486666202545,
-0.6238924264907837,
0.8991780877113342,
0.750057578086853,
-0.5971843600273132,
0.2795621454715729,
0.38671353459358215,
0.05527181550860405,
0.19027793407440186,
0.7140384912490845,
0.17645983397960663,
0.21144168078899384,
-0.19834977388381958,
-0.007285802159458399,
-0.24745750427246094,
-0.35957565903663635,
-0.21871845424175262,
0.11302462220191956,
-0.01740092784166336,
-0.10908438265323639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02486v1 | Neurocache: Efficient Vector Retrieval for Long-range Language Modeling | 2024-07-02T17:59:29 | 2024-07-02T17:59:29 | Ali Safaya, Deniz Yuret | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces Neurocache, an approach to extend the effective context
size of large language models (LLMs) using an external vector cache to store
its past states. Like recent vector retrieval approaches, Neurocache uses an
efficient k-nearest-neighbor (kNN) algorithm to retrieve relevant past states
and incorporate them into the attention process. Neurocache improves upon
previous methods by (1) storing compressed states, which reduces cache size;
(2) performing a single retrieval operation per token which increases inference
speed; and (3) extending the retrieval window to neighboring states, which
improves both language modeling and downstream task accuracy. Our experiments
show the effectiveness of Neurocache both for models trained from scratch and
for pre-trained models such as Llama2-7B and Mistral-7B when enhanced with the
cache mechanism. We also compare Neurocache with text retrieval methods and
show improvements in single-document question-answering and few-shot learning
tasks. We made the source code available under:
https://github.com/alisafaya/neurocache | [
-0.23867346346378326,
-0.7795186042785645,
0.6441752314567566,
0.12495678663253784,
-0.23858673870563507,
-0.12101378291845322,
-0.5646024942398071,
-0.5889645218849182,
0.491811066865921,
0.3537653684616089,
-0.29332277178764343,
-0.606608510017395,
-0.3997859060764313,
-0.17499488592147827,
-0.6384570598602295,
0.5969910025596619,
0.03037392348051071,
0.09309057891368866,
-0.35006850957870483,
0.06173637881875038,
-0.15704190731048584,
-0.5523461103439331,
-0.850596010684967,
-0.4622986614704132,
0.8076413869857788,
0.1404518187046051,
0.33381932973861694,
0.45941099524497986,
0.3361983001232147,
0.27751216292381287,
-0.38793236017227173,
-0.07831715792417526,
-0.6483297348022461,
0.3392016291618347,
-0.14239339530467987,
-0.4602108597755432,
-0.3499108850955963,
-0.3286115229129791,
0.47827714681625366,
0.4379340708255768,
-0.18494468927383423,
-0.13323602080345154,
-0.112240731716156,
0.5602965950965881,
-1.0163832902908325,
0.008094784803688526,
-0.5776410102844238,
-0.07128287106752396,
-0.28149107098579407,
0.035811666399240494,
-0.4365452826023102,
-0.5210875272750854,
0.37102052569389343,
-0.35151439905166626,
0.09006886184215546,
-0.3434407114982605,
0.5105613470077515,
0.35806936025619507,
-0.25601017475128174,
-0.08665715903043747,
-0.37263068556785583,
0.7728753089904785,
-0.7186048626899719,
0.3262590169906616,
0.6793947219848633,
0.4080907702445984,
-0.3830505609512329,
-1.13588285446167,
-0.6860606074333191,
-0.412584125995636,
0.4068296253681183,
0.05008456110954285,
-0.18532836437225342,
0.14285750687122345,
0.20417192578315735,
0.24336828291416168,
-0.18082009255886078,
0.3685772716999054,
-0.22007660567760468,
-0.538973331451416,
0.09674762934446335,
0.2013368010520935,
0.19171477854251862,
-0.043629083782434464,
-0.2504241466522217,
-0.14989209175109863,
-0.8498818278312683,
-0.027656875550746918,
0.4572127163410187,
0.23536813259124756,
0.1267804056406021,
0.3294256925582886,
-0.3401019275188446,
0.7842535972595215,
-0.5230936408042908,
0.09370049834251404,
0.08240413665771484,
-0.22848418354988098,
0.010666772723197937,
0.07981185615062714,
0.3431845009326935,
0.14886754751205444,
0.022382955998182297,
-0.318174809217453,
0.0008614382240921259,
0.0827585756778717,
0.3572697341442108,
-1.0302138328552246,
-0.35660281777381897,
0.03849038854241371,
-0.4276840090751648,
-0.13246223330497742,
-0.1640656590461731,
-0.8629546761512756,
-0.23472580313682556,
-0.20456907153129578,
0.32330408692359924,
-0.36797669529914856,
-0.14158618450164795,
0.04397425428032875,
-0.13918845355510712,
0.3494512438774109,
0.33519965410232544,
-0.6697133779525757,
0.46060970425605774,
0.7122797966003418,
1.0529959201812744,
-0.6058335304260254,
-0.14703793823719025,
-0.4931374490261078,
-0.05742054432630539,
-0.20115315914154053,
0.9545189142227173,
-0.7288945317268372,
-0.2619091868400574,
-0.046461667865514755,
-0.044578541070222855,
0.3103235065937042,
-0.4128619432449341,
0.529566764831543,
-0.8529719114303589,
-0.27145251631736755,
-0.549214780330658,
-0.44767996668815613,
-0.4028247594833374,
0.04104545712471008,
-0.9320091009140015,
1.3790298700332642,
-0.10053582489490509,
-0.6571761965751648,
-0.055657897144556046,
-0.49535542726516724,
-0.4765044152736664,
-0.30503594875335693,
0.05751089006662369,
-0.11435893177986145,
0.2377409040927887,
0.2429477721452713,
0.3773411810398102,
-0.3720892369747162,
-0.10276898741722107,
-0.5244380831718445,
-0.46324875950813293,
-0.022654453292489052,
-0.40705135464668274,
0.7656417489051819,
-0.07703155279159546,
-0.16182170808315277,
0.16357484459877014,
-0.6369374990463257,
0.10859685391187668,
0.029871638864278793,
-0.2712521255016327,
-0.5766617655754089,
0.033682722598314285,
-0.06654370576143265,
0.3767135739326477,
0.5472906231880188,
-0.7486711740493774,
0.2280968427658081,
-0.733822226524353,
0.6373171806335449,
0.7996208071708679,
-0.09482209384441376,
0.4441610872745514,
0.010516878217458725,
0.4238950312137604,
-0.0683814138174057,
-0.1637653112411499,
-0.08638644963502884,
-0.2111029177904129,
-0.8475719690322876,
-0.191721111536026,
0.48901328444480896,
0.2556670308113098,
-0.7083005309104919,
0.31966477632522583,
-0.3067722022533417,
-0.5570475459098816,
-0.3492382764816284,
-0.08302473276853561,
0.13567174971103668,
0.6983769536018372,
0.3528097867965698,
-0.41782158613204956,
-0.3509739637374878,
-0.9450823068618774,
0.21882760524749756,
0.22349289059638977,
0.15735803544521332,
0.3025367856025696,
0.5329756140708923,
-0.18345125019550323,
0.7234092950820923,
-0.6133971810340881,
-0.08119864761829376,
-0.053924258798360825,
-0.1699647158384323,
0.12302318215370178,
0.26612749695777893,
0.3245934545993805,
-0.23016004264354706,
-0.21855930984020233,
-0.12301083654165268,
-0.2587369680404663,
0.036135148257017136,
0.38468503952026367,
-0.3847830593585968,
0.4929791986942291,
0.8769510984420776,
-0.6219104528427124,
0.6687890291213989,
0.6071837544441223,
0.1239500343799591,
0.3504997193813324,
-0.3454073369503021,
-0.1664094477891922,
-1.054571270942688,
0.2883051335811615,
-0.40683308243751526,
-0.3070847690105438,
-0.35467958450317383,
0.06308405101299286,
0.29924094676971436,
-0.013788262382149696,
-0.4223826229572296,
0.7501271963119507,
-0.5819574594497681,
-0.22755810618400574,
-0.8304100036621094,
0.3881610631942749,
-0.25544869899749756,
0.5439272522926331,
-0.10139451175928116,
0.765737771987915,
0.8322803974151611,
-0.7473763823509216,
0.31546029448509216,
-0.055792201310396194,
-0.4532783031463623,
0.17074768245220184,
-0.6195183992385864,
0.7077853679656982,
-0.21888193488121033,
0.620451033115387,
-1.0380364656448364,
0.20573732256889343,
-0.19860033690929413,
-0.33416691422462463,
0.24568544328212738,
-0.1104019433259964,
-0.6898936629295349,
-0.26873910427093506,
-0.26406970620155334,
0.5090916156768799,
0.29958251118659973,
-0.8508320450782776,
0.6723427176475525,
0.5778273344039917,
-0.030669821426272392,
-0.7352701425552368,
-0.5472628474235535,
0.08216799795627594,
0.08452090620994568,
-0.3462468385696411,
0.4869069457054138,
-0.05217082425951958,
0.21683725714683533,
0.00244640139862895,
-0.3999905586242676,
-0.1041097417473793,
0.05800051614642143,
0.15997684001922607,
-0.007745165377855301,
-0.009916648268699646,
0.5230311751365662,
0.16632381081581116,
-0.2146006077528,
0.008711292408406734,
-0.20893917977809906,
1.0027002096176147,
-0.0030871962662786245,
0.062460485845804214,
-0.23246023058891296,
0.37382248044013977,
0.23067690432071686,
-0.37762919068336487,
0.6069809794425964,
0.3942035436630249,
-0.672326385974884,
-0.48604580760002136,
-0.4432463049888611,
-0.6197961568832397,
-0.4576212465763092,
0.5232139229774475,
-0.2770310044288635,
-0.8760299682617188,
0.7682479023933411,
-0.22632384300231934,
-0.1460879147052765,
0.4356588125228882,
0.7545149922370911,
0.22315889596939087,
0.6956673264503479,
0.8144176006317139,
-0.4414387345314026,
0.6345687508583069,
-0.2717551290988922,
0.06745000183582306,
-0.959232747554779,
-0.12799787521362305,
-0.6515417098999023,
-0.5290250182151794,
-0.25883081555366516,
-0.6525276899337769,
0.17659197747707367,
-0.07329979538917542,
-0.05973711609840393,
0.40193691849708557,
-0.4008786678314209,
0.6555715203285217,
0.47065749764442444,
0.43132489919662476,
0.09110952168703079,
0.16804403066635132,
-0.49263617396354675,
-0.06169847398996353,
-0.6260671019554138,
-0.125341534614563,
1.1081188917160034,
0.13021741807460785,
0.7861992716789246,
0.12173424661159515,
0.5628268122673035,
-0.27144232392311096,
0.37762513756752014,
-1.059462070465088,
0.6424990892410278,
-0.08695509284734726,
-0.4908652901649475,
-0.2830449342727661,
-0.2276613861322403,
-1.1653391122817993,
0.1941346377134323,
-0.001238516764715314,
-0.8639533519744873,
0.041141338646411896,
-0.0885210782289505,
-0.4431423842906952,
0.23661020398139954,
-0.44649067521095276,
0.5626246929168701,
-0.04035402089357376,
-0.4390143156051636,
-0.6863502264022827,
-0.628257155418396,
0.09655618667602539,
0.008663011714816093,
-0.5617839097976685,
0.014268455095589161,
-0.3469690978527069,
0.71558678150177,
-0.4119561016559601,
0.778550386428833,
-0.013721292838454247,
-0.24753813445568085,
0.22983968257904053,
0.1609993278980255,
0.7155344486236572,
-0.15254375338554382,
-0.25129950046539307,
0.3313899040222168,
-0.19927598536014557,
-0.2447005808353424,
-0.8581807017326355,
1.2395505905151367,
-0.45549216866493225,
-0.3347247242927551,
-0.3835785388946533,
-0.5889814496040344,
-0.09690787643194199,
0.4413508474826813,
0.04893219843506813,
0.5507885813713074,
0.04926299676299095,
0.3245275616645813,
0.7801418900489807,
-0.3117018938064575,
0.757453441619873,
0.40949293971061707,
-0.015752580016851425,
-0.3003442585468292,
0.6036041975021362,
0.1937442570924759,
0.0801641196012497,
0.5240683555603027,
0.11317384988069534,
-0.2793304920196533,
-0.49464452266693115,
0.1750604212284088,
0.21405549347400665,
-0.9631636142730713,
-0.38459324836730957,
-0.7824461460113525,
-0.08614332973957062,
-0.2334386259317398,
0.19813963770866394,
-0.5469154715538025,
-0.47150474786758423,
-0.32615944743156433,
-0.1358093023300171,
0.7074957489967346,
0.4245534837245941,
-0.011061838828027248,
0.35822340846061707,
-0.26186609268188477,
0.3268246352672577,
0.01812904141843319,
0.6096406579017639,
0.46349450945854187,
-0.4003734290599823,
-0.23913411796092987,
-0.16564080119132996,
-0.09018529951572418,
-0.9573444128036499,
0.45959725975990295,
-0.06022798642516136,
0.5945370197296143,
-0.013407199643552303,
-0.14750364422798157,
0.7878519296646118,
-0.6080673933029175,
0.3823671042919159,
-0.13348829746246338,
-0.7569372653961182,
0.37863829731941223,
-0.016031663864850998,
0.7177372574806213,
0.7186035513877869,
0.3805299401283264,
-0.413571834564209,
-0.06998270750045776,
-0.4211171865463257,
-1.2655363082885742,
0.3936060667037964,
-0.10115113854408264,
0.31443193554878235,
-0.31875017285346985,
0.6105262041091919,
0.033851686865091324,
-0.13131873309612274,
-0.3771961033344269,
-0.311279833316803,
0.189479798078537,
-0.158822700381279,
-0.13340282440185547,
-0.14436815679073334,
0.19153031706809998,
-0.4224255084991455,
0.6917592883110046,
-0.2332472950220108,
0.5926080346107483,
0.32864341139793396,
-0.24989071488380432,
0.2041746973991394,
-0.14025373756885529,
0.6198307275772095,
0.5515507459640503,
-0.05064770579338074,
0.2817264199256897,
0.38421258330345154,
-0.6659468412399292,
-0.2028157263994217,
0.14922437071800232,
0.17376309633255005,
-0.09272035211324692,
-0.10916265845298767,
0.3928273916244507,
0.28771206736564636,
-0.5725489258766174,
0.43963027000427246,
-0.1919284611940384,
0.1430213898420334,
-0.4405878186225891,
-0.07058229297399521,
0.35797014832496643,
0.2607738971710205,
0.20932637155056,
-0.324564129114151,
0.2674351632595062,
-0.3028142750263214,
0.3858044147491455,
0.45396000146865845,
-0.41814666986465454,
0.013015196658670902,
0.4237097501754761,
-0.009837170131504536,
-0.0015930811641737819,
0.8557258248329163,
0.11048692464828491,
-0.4032571315765381,
0.5779862999916077,
0.601965069770813,
0.9005817770957947,
-0.13369664549827576,
-0.2080116719007492,
0.4699855446815491,
0.19641850888729095,
-0.23646830022335052,
0.34140342473983765,
-0.22964027523994446,
-0.5352475643157959,
-0.6851241588592529,
-0.46553078293800354,
-0.20326505601406097,
0.24078711867332458,
-0.4330970048904419,
0.17669646441936493,
-0.42960503697395325,
-0.4139364957809448,
-0.08720661699771881,
0.1054263710975647,
-0.46411168575286865,
-0.19088883697986603,
-0.10459993034601212,
1.2517317533493042,
-0.36084264516830444,
1.2131584882736206,
0.3590826690196991,
-0.19295649230480194,
-0.4609350264072418,
0.024785375222563744,
-0.2969217002391815,
-0.6066632270812988,
0.7409623861312866,
0.22682037949562073,
-0.42403075098991394,
0.10860932618379593,
-0.7963722944259644,
-1.2728279829025269,
0.969455361366272,
0.511337161064148,
-0.4422347843647003,
0.03027147427201271,
-0.5104607939720154,
0.6982922554016113,
-0.00796616729348898,
0.2736470699310303,
0.5129116773605347,
0.17434075474739075,
-0.07531685382127762,
-0.6107770204544067,
0.2242334932088852,
-0.27262169122695923,
0.15676511824131012,
0.4594188332557678,
-0.4826444089412689,
0.6790239214897156,
-0.12830884754657745,
-0.13946232199668884,
0.27248942852020264,
1.1113903522491455,
0.19780930876731873,
-0.22617462277412415,
0.26884177327156067,
0.8980043530464172,
0.7514079213142395,
0.013132530264556408,
1.3145722150802612,
-0.3172452449798584,
0.14683957397937775,
1.299018144607544,
-0.15731531381607056,
1.1612613201141357,
0.6187790036201477,
0.23415960371494293,
0.6273550391197205,
0.4361402988433838,
0.28494253754615784,
0.658536434173584,
0.6026474833488464,
-0.2711442708969116,
-0.19056689739227295,
0.07241848111152649,
-0.17977958917617798,
0.4290759861469269,
0.34025824069976807,
-0.23143236339092255,
-0.44234082102775574,
-0.07716155797243118,
0.16849789023399353,
-0.09466516226530075,
-0.22126248478889465,
0.5420124530792236,
0.3275749385356903,
-0.6631548404693604,
0.5718899369239807,
0.15180793404579163,
0.6939755082130432,
-0.5274691581726074,
-0.19575488567352295,
-0.2050936222076416,
0.2703182101249695,
0.073316290974617,
-0.49657556414604187,
0.10223626345396042,
-0.2336941659450531,
-0.1732405424118042,
0.13735395669937134,
0.8283812999725342,
-0.43988847732543945,
-0.20516595244407654,
0.41265833377838135,
0.07906307280063629,
0.24464499950408936,
-0.17995508015155792,
-0.5358942151069641,
0.05863570421934128,
-0.45984718203544617,
-0.23584863543510437,
0.27676305174827576,
0.0381060428917408,
-0.26004719734191895,
0.7314997911453247,
0.6332525610923767,
0.10396602749824524,
0.24127095937728882,
0.1600557118654251,
0.9007692337036133,
-0.7429071068763733,
-0.5443326234817505,
-0.7877820730209351,
0.02929539605975151,
-0.1057664155960083,
-0.32505661249160767,
0.7103055715560913,
0.5910550355911255,
0.7160392999649048,
0.17287379503250122,
0.4186384081840515,
0.15782591700553894,
0.3805932402610779,
-0.5923376083374023,
0.6778491735458374,
-0.35221317410469055,
-0.16285589337348938,
-0.1362965852022171,
-0.9147461652755737,
-0.34375083446502686,
0.8556810617446899,
-0.4399303197860718,
0.2908574640750885,
0.9105521440505981,
1.0745261907577515,
-0.025566166266798973,
-0.04394249990582466,
0.12276487052440643,
0.2543458640575409,
0.2121007740497589,
0.8630160093307495,
0.6968855261802673,
-0.3878686726093292,
0.40426963567733765,
-0.39137277007102966,
0.05024021863937378,
-0.1745639443397522,
-1.0625115633010864,
-0.912594199180603,
-0.5348219871520996,
-0.07109478116035461,
-0.40723076462745667,
-0.13984403014183044,
0.7208713293075562,
0.6886625289916992,
-0.5170527696609497,
-0.09486402571201324,
-0.12064166367053986,
0.058195050805807114,
-0.09445618838071823,
-0.21975795924663544,
0.668316662311554,
-0.27836769819259644,
-0.7545639872550964,
0.5172617435455322,
0.22236855328083038,
-0.09679710119962692,
-0.3960689604282379,
0.16877815127372742,
-0.3029632866382599,
0.01659291610121727,
0.7645999193191528,
0.30248382687568665,
-0.5613811016082764,
-0.21691399812698364,
0.11166109144687653,
-0.3049536347389221,
0.07362400740385056,
0.8555050492286682,
-0.996766209602356,
0.3834958076477051,
0.8082939386367798,
0.9600637555122375,
0.943116307258606,
-0.5000256299972534,
0.5106722116470337,
-0.48473161458969116,
0.2799554765224457,
0.3153058588504791,
0.39553412795066833,
0.1997675597667694,
-0.23500171303749084,
0.2739216089248657,
-0.1562887281179428,
-0.42911484837532043,
-0.6373418569564819,
0.20148605108261108,
-1.1854910850524902,
-0.4245934784412384,
1.1971405744552612,
0.21074119210243225,
-0.5866818428039551,
0.04263778030872345,
-0.22913102805614471,
0.4075379967689514,
-0.4449003040790558,
0.7586392164230347,
0.8068466186523438,
0.15548430383205414,
-0.07346721738576889,
-0.9016837477684021,
0.5027419924736023,
0.5207372903823853,
-0.9516499638557434,
0.03236297890543938,
0.4219561219215393,
0.30764099955558777,
-0.04736366122961044,
0.4735730290412903,
-0.4777475595474243,
0.37106770277023315,
-0.2802232801914215,
0.17314673960208893,
0.043263211846351624,
-0.538363516330719,
-0.6471858620643616,
0.0975925624370575,
-0.3461141884326935,
0.1566901057958603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02485v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02485v1 | RankRAG: Unifying Context Ranking with Retrieval-Augmented Generation in LLMs | 2024-07-02T17:59:17 | 2024-07-02T17:59:17 | Yue Yu, Wei Ping, Zihan Liu, Boxin Wang, Jiaxuan You, Chao Zhang, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) typically utilize the top-k contexts from a
retriever in retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). In this work, we propose a
novel instruction fine-tuning framework RankRAG, which instruction-tunes a
single LLM for the dual purpose of context ranking and answer generation in
RAG. In particular, the instruction-tuned LLMs work surprisingly well by adding
a small fraction of ranking data into the training blend, and outperform
existing expert ranking models, including the same LLM exclusively fine-tuned
on a large amount of ranking data. For generation, we compare our model with
many strong baselines, including GPT-4-0613, GPT-4-turbo-2024-0409, and
ChatQA-1.5, an open-sourced model with the state-of-the-art performance on RAG
benchmarks. Specifically, our Llama3-RankRAG significantly outperforms
Llama3-ChatQA-1.5 and GPT-4 models on nine knowledge-intensive benchmarks. In
addition, it also performs comparably to GPT-4 on five RAG benchmarks in the
biomedical domain without instruction fine-tuning on biomedical data,
demonstrating its superb capability for generalization to new domains. | [
-0.3257026672363281,
-0.6662594079971313,
0.41456031799316406,
0.08058788627386093,
-0.3417941629886627,
0.15839076042175293,
-0.44792312383651733,
-0.22259460389614105,
0.01128395926207304,
0.498620867729187,
-0.3031367063522339,
-0.7497921586036682,
-0.7850132584571838,
-0.018446002155542374,
-0.3032395541667938,
1.361427903175354,
0.25471460819244385,
0.15112300217151642,
-0.24940373003482819,
-0.12321227043867111,
-0.5619617700576782,
-0.39564037322998047,
-0.8318115472793579,
-0.2815174460411072,
0.6666643023490906,
0.6187683939933777,
0.4873911142349243,
0.6507542729377747,
0.5022206902503967,
0.2630837857723236,
-0.2480393797159195,
0.3613683879375458,
-0.9276094436645508,
0.4629169702529907,
-0.056794457137584686,
-0.288004994392395,
-0.7740089893341064,
-0.054968323558568954,
0.6881147623062134,
0.7017521858215332,
-0.21760064363479614,
0.2699168920516968,
0.22551214694976807,
0.6281007528305054,
-0.7316679954528809,
-0.10931351035833359,
-0.8988418579101562,
-0.25806838274002075,
-0.29594969749450684,
-0.6741482019424438,
-0.44230595231056213,
-0.24482207000255585,
-0.26957419514656067,
-0.5798628330230713,
0.2015533149242401,
0.21014466881752014,
0.5554776787757874,
0.8210051655769348,
-0.418899804353714,
-0.11791519820690155,
-0.3441520631313324,
0.7636762857437134,
-0.5428891181945801,
0.29769986867904663,
0.30555933713912964,
0.4689123332500458,
-0.34664273262023926,
-0.8380777835845947,
-0.18741290271282196,
0.03695760667324066,
0.05794588476419449,
0.14990223944187164,
0.18318167328834534,
0.08215517550706863,
0.028374474495649338,
0.38429585099220276,
-0.481308251619339,
0.22992119193077087,
-0.5627887845039368,
0.2777310609817505,
0.5351238250732422,
0.0769314095377922,
0.0658465251326561,
-0.0067777144722640514,
-0.45457354187965393,
0.05785435810685158,
-1.2024081945419312,
-0.07699692994356155,
-0.013635004870593548,
0.4103875160217285,
0.08856169134378433,
0.4172957241535187,
-0.4098275601863861,
0.8631910085678101,
0.27660706639289856,
-0.10845679044723511,
0.030575335025787354,
0.029582850635051727,
-0.15802045166492462,
0.24029284715652466,
0.49662357568740845,
0.4309019148349762,
0.008481190539896488,
-0.39215508103370667,
-0.24077606201171875,
-0.30934804677963257,
0.49950140714645386,
-1.1737186908721924,
-0.16431352496147156,
0.1775851547718048,
-0.09495832026004791,
-0.4825544059276581,
-0.1709219515323639,
-0.6055417060852051,
-0.4190426468849182,
-0.12251552939414978,
0.6119828820228577,
-0.14535307884216309,
0.16076919436454773,
0.1198868602514267,
0.15593507885932922,
0.30107811093330383,
0.33164888620376587,
-1.0555890798568726,
0.18262121081352234,
0.9395662546157837,
0.6185744404792786,
-0.6013619899749756,
-0.20731885731220245,
-0.9256550073623657,
0.36403921246528625,
-0.4746961295604706,
1.0255815982818604,
-0.8818677067756653,
-0.3497221767902374,
-0.2342255562543869,
-0.02923838049173355,
-0.13522978127002716,
-0.7351414561271667,
0.6801354289054871,
-0.6994871497154236,
0.3189757168292999,
-0.11567621678113937,
-0.7389165759086609,
0.09511765837669373,
0.12182135134935379,
-0.2821482717990875,
1.3277122974395752,
0.04321231693029404,
-0.7763776779174805,
0.44547438621520996,
-0.5828056931495667,
-0.3050778806209564,
0.33833056688308716,
-0.27638232707977295,
-0.21993254125118256,
0.055249329656362534,
0.2760404944419861,
0.576373815536499,
-0.42534834146499634,
0.3760257959365845,
-0.1256251335144043,
-0.8754822015762329,
-0.06389066576957703,
-0.34387442469596863,
0.45358574390411377,
-0.015607657842338085,
-0.40241846442222595,
0.2148677408695221,
-0.5425308346748352,
0.246257022023201,
-0.13203011453151703,
-0.7153192162513733,
-0.25354304909706116,
-0.07300300151109695,
-0.17143934965133667,
0.03389284014701843,
0.5231205224990845,
-0.5713784098625183,
0.43589845299720764,
-0.3587535619735718,
0.266445517539978,
0.7328688502311707,
0.09138897806406021,
0.4231903553009033,
-0.34397539496421814,
0.4818035364151001,
-0.14732283353805542,
-0.2307845950126648,
-0.012912251055240631,
-0.5130341053009033,
-0.7676425576210022,
-0.31428560614585876,
0.4754164516925812,
0.5438290238380432,
-0.5413680672645569,
0.2651921212673187,
-0.4288311004638672,
-0.31668728590011597,
-0.813605546951294,
0.14306066930294037,
0.6344163417816162,
0.675512433052063,
0.6389814615249634,
0.0014996649697422981,
-0.30939167737960815,
-0.7895874977111816,
-0.3019016683101654,
0.14431826770305634,
-0.24414657056331635,
0.5476038455963135,
0.12911321222782135,
-0.26083019375801086,
0.6390034556388855,
-0.5170878767967224,
-0.2096097767353058,
-0.15511098504066467,
0.008013683371245861,
0.3834206461906433,
0.5300362706184387,
0.2658172845840454,
-0.7021197080612183,
-0.4180741608142853,
0.039621010422706604,
-0.6280077695846558,
-0.3488188087940216,
0.46485772728919983,
-0.3213937282562256,
0.23483318090438843,
0.5857186913490295,
-0.37053194642066956,
0.21549387276172638,
0.4267585277557373,
-0.23945295810699463,
0.3146430253982544,
-0.44557496905326843,
0.33773449063301086,
-1.3329741954803467,
0.1679820865392685,
-0.35800766944885254,
-0.18761958181858063,
-0.4257654547691345,
0.23139868676662445,
0.07513143867254257,
-0.04800569266080856,
-0.30447158217430115,
0.9031672477722168,
-0.16673672199249268,
-0.11762122064828873,
-0.42153629660606384,
0.04876336455345154,
-0.059218890964984894,
0.5393447875976562,
-0.16629812121391296,
1.2712455987930298,
0.4309283494949341,
-0.6814976334571838,
-0.11572536826133728,
0.2959492802619934,
-0.3290160298347473,
0.5127524137496948,
-0.907372236251831,
0.07715976983308792,
-0.15698473155498505,
0.29997074604034424,
-0.8948285579681396,
-0.5642883777618408,
-0.1063140332698822,
-0.4397055208683014,
0.6039541363716125,
-0.30672499537467957,
-0.23887425661087036,
0.033274900168180466,
-0.2914605140686035,
0.45604726672172546,
0.6275244951248169,
-0.7649028897285461,
-0.04075051471590996,
0.5769239664077759,
-0.41975831985473633,
-0.975470244884491,
-0.3096059560775757,
-0.018037982285022736,
-0.45863503217697144,
-0.30859243869781494,
0.6760785579681396,
-0.22576314210891724,
0.03447207808494568,
-0.3364921808242798,
-0.29534271359443665,
-0.1969752162694931,
0.17946206033229828,
0.12950032949447632,
0.08018843084573746,
-0.17625737190246582,
0.26063066720962524,
0.5453888177871704,
-0.2797020673751831,
-0.267398864030838,
-0.19049210846424103,
0.36885225772857666,
-0.10198657959699631,
-0.24529588222503662,
-0.06917040795087814,
0.2383130043745041,
0.5597886443138123,
-0.22138027846813202,
0.6691779494285583,
0.6056569218635559,
-0.14925256371498108,
-0.39074981212615967,
-0.37336182594299316,
-0.25046736001968384,
-0.5023441314697266,
0.3468918204307556,
-0.24958713352680206,
-1.3957158327102661,
0.14121897518634796,
-0.3341189920902252,
0.2510250210762024,
0.16448882222175598,
0.7281494736671448,
-0.11060868203639984,
1.1399612426757812,
0.46055030822753906,
0.01645193062722683,
0.22566868364810944,
-0.12415708601474762,
0.10831154137849808,
-1.2595984935760498,
-0.09607133269309998,
-0.46991655230522156,
-0.485653281211853,
-0.7221116423606873,
-0.5987601280212402,
0.9650359153747559,
0.5055227875709534,
-0.48410800099372864,
0.04375850409269333,
-0.7612403035163879,
0.6487922668457031,
0.4729365408420563,
0.04486894607543945,
0.2836683392524719,
0.04221837967634201,
-0.2635922133922577,
0.08082003146409988,
-0.873492956161499,
-0.6222097873687744,
1.284997582435608,
-0.026072774082422256,
0.6502009034156799,
0.14282652735710144,
1.0058635473251343,
0.18160003423690796,
0.45809847116470337,
-0.5605260133743286,
0.5192845463752747,
-0.38838186860084534,
-0.4896812438964844,
-0.2891848683357239,
-0.3782801330089569,
-1.2116538286209106,
0.4983937442302704,
-0.08142247796058655,
-0.6771358847618103,
-0.19697846472263336,
0.2026541382074356,
-0.3876766562461853,
0.020126814022660255,
-0.40564221143722534,
0.8454025387763977,
-0.0914183109998703,
-0.6726052165031433,
-0.1692294329404831,
-0.43127205967903137,
0.4188246726989746,
0.0664202943444252,
0.05359838530421257,
-0.22749903798103333,
-0.29685014486312866,
0.5826867818832397,
-0.29822003841400146,
0.5051367282867432,
-0.25122249126434326,
-0.16585847735404968,
-0.10529907792806625,
-0.18078958988189697,
0.19170255959033966,
0.3709010183811188,
-0.268392950296402,
0.03103278949856758,
0.00457037566229701,
-0.360095351934433,
-0.5900684595108032,
1.087099313735962,
-0.5882750749588013,
-0.8009724020957947,
0.03734540566802025,
-0.6040217280387878,
-0.41925710439682007,
0.26106202602386475,
0.5050272941589355,
0.6775487065315247,
-0.0012937175342813134,
0.5642656087875366,
0.8500950932502747,
-0.3407415747642517,
0.1389298141002655,
0.5305016040802002,
-0.10629179328680038,
-0.3733851909637451,
0.9558627605438232,
-0.07114765793085098,
-0.060615092515945435,
0.5674014091491699,
0.12788109481334686,
-0.2408820241689682,
-0.5922386646270752,
-0.8440584540367126,
0.049002375453710556,
-0.4881278872489929,
-0.4991307854652405,
-0.6249815821647644,
-0.21380099654197693,
-0.2804175317287445,
-0.217027485370636,
-0.41323626041412354,
-0.5075621604919434,
-0.028336497023701668,
0.17424148321151733,
0.4687511622905731,
0.8406698703765869,
0.1384177803993225,
0.26759085059165955,
-0.5397375226020813,
0.40159139037132263,
0.37226006388664246,
0.5348133444786072,
-0.13728547096252441,
-0.7565475106239319,
-0.22250278294086456,
-0.010577978566288948,
-0.37284156680107117,
-0.6080923080444336,
0.21983033418655396,
0.3577110767364502,
0.6005412340164185,
0.12231450527906418,
0.10509441047906876,
0.7114847302436829,
-0.9595419764518738,
0.5921763181686401,
-0.49015048146247864,
-0.5029199719429016,
0.41854724287986755,
-0.6684940457344055,
0.36013463139533997,
0.7826359272003174,
0.2612384259700775,
-0.2562219798564911,
-0.604857325553894,
-0.3848000466823578,
-1.0284736156463623,
0.6451844573020935,
-0.015134874731302261,
0.07690447568893433,
-0.13907724618911743,
0.49871352314949036,
0.1690339297056198,
0.30404964089393616,
-0.3727327287197113,
-0.2957060933113098,
0.145297110080719,
-0.2831534743309021,
-0.034108761698007584,
-0.2601992189884186,
-0.18795524537563324,
-0.4352284371852875,
0.7427478432655334,
-0.24924063682556152,
0.3071419894695282,
-0.06593582034111023,
-0.016903970390558243,
-0.0159357450902462,
0.5367035269737244,
0.671881914138794,
0.5950008034706116,
-0.2707138955593109,
-0.028766468167304993,
0.3372964859008789,
-0.3471602201461792,
-0.0036566981580108404,
0.1984747350215912,
-0.21709656715393066,
-0.2626330256462097,
0.17113468050956726,
0.7325332164764404,
0.9887859225273132,
-0.5832787156105042,
0.42051962018013,
-0.06599545478820801,
0.11622874438762665,
-0.07466613501310349,
0.5322036743164062,
0.24214409291744232,
0.165890634059906,
0.5088139176368713,
-0.16788248717784882,
0.2684987783432007,
0.011298928409814835,
0.3540233075618744,
0.5463159084320068,
-0.16139554977416992,
-0.03700637072324753,
0.9889769554138184,
0.2353246808052063,
-0.17472591996192932,
0.2776280343532562,
-0.20216432213783264,
-0.33784034848213196,
0.4480806589126587,
0.592759907245636,
0.5078502893447876,
-0.28076082468032837,
0.012638922780752182,
0.5104875564575195,
-0.0770634263753891,
-0.0663173645734787,
0.20265308022499084,
-0.37480202317237854,
-0.3760349750518799,
-0.4837654232978821,
-1.0753436088562012,
-0.5580757260322571,
0.15453694760799408,
-0.7967715859413147,
0.13897259533405304,
-0.18765147030353546,
0.14120124280452728,
-0.13828401267528534,
0.07760731875896454,
-0.4763399064540863,
0.0823386162519455,
-0.048427268862724304,
0.7585403919219971,
-0.2368716299533844,
0.9538264870643616,
0.9835569858551025,
0.041800227016210556,
-0.6587895750999451,
0.059245720505714417,
-0.18748661875724792,
-0.7093364000320435,
0.595238447189331,
0.3780643045902252,
-0.3514145612716675,
0.5061333775520325,
-0.5592181086540222,
-0.9669626951217651,
1.3737454414367676,
0.5288966298103333,
-0.2804347574710846,
0.006161365192383528,
-0.23322179913520813,
0.5129674077033997,
-0.496358722448349,
0.2759212851524353,
0.5091729164123535,
0.2611068785190582,
0.18260051310062408,
-0.9525654315948486,
-0.1270827353000641,
-0.3650811016559601,
-0.11933203786611557,
0.2648056149482727,
-0.706981360912323,
0.8911613821983337,
-0.22218894958496094,
-0.21862544119358063,
0.21640245616436005,
0.45806342363357544,
0.8704903721809387,
0.20790733397006989,
0.09016641229391098,
0.6866798996925354,
0.8296166062355042,
0.052891798317432404,
1.1390495300292969,
-0.6696339845657349,
0.14786474406719208,
1.1929316520690918,
-0.27312466502189636,
1.1848126649856567,
0.19835416972637177,
0.1341642290353775,
0.5533003807067871,
0.5202206373214722,
0.45885777473449707,
0.46516451239585876,
0.05220301076769829,
-0.2593573331832886,
-0.3748675584793091,
-0.0014180237194523215,
-0.5856444239616394,
0.6965798139572144,
0.4940895140171051,
-0.13836152851581573,
-0.39531126618385315,
-0.29194310307502747,
0.037046391516923904,
-0.0003089483070652932,
-0.40423956513404846,
0.8839775919914246,
-0.061462849378585815,
-0.8810634016990662,
1.180403232574463,
0.18382278084754944,
0.814604640007019,
-0.2605088949203491,
-0.2649766206741333,
-0.4408649504184723,
0.10548649728298187,
-0.09953048080205917,
-0.5043540000915527,
-0.019733402878046036,
0.26785749197006226,
-0.18925830721855164,
-0.24893100559711456,
0.6906429529190063,
-0.6332409381866455,
-0.41490843892097473,
0.06804025173187256,
0.5073623657226562,
0.29571619629859924,
0.15476781129837036,
-0.5921250581741333,
0.11125747859477997,
-0.21891769766807556,
-0.4495633840560913,
0.6056442260742188,
0.3472177982330322,
-0.13203614950180054,
0.6584326028823853,
0.37413376569747925,
0.016444187611341476,
0.04316838085651398,
0.008197094313800335,
0.9295734763145447,
-0.4369937479496002,
-0.41598138213157654,
-0.4138900935649872,
0.32151612639427185,
-0.10837647318840027,
-0.4469662606716156,
0.520587146282196,
0.5702469944953918,
0.8073384761810303,
0.1684114933013916,
0.472687304019928,
0.10843843221664429,
0.8533098101615906,
-0.5342763662338257,
0.9576238393783569,
-0.7557141780853271,
0.42718061804771423,
0.0076837907545268536,
-0.9568663239479065,
-0.14593270421028137,
0.6745057106018066,
-0.34620431065559387,
0.2825138568878174,
0.46907225251197815,
0.9696886539459229,
-0.20960302650928497,
-0.24699977040290833,
0.36157482862472534,
0.14030848443508148,
0.01353892870247364,
0.6984038352966309,
0.5571233034133911,
-0.33380913734436035,
0.35117897391319275,
0.02214837819337845,
-0.2910695970058441,
-0.31250688433647156,
-0.6893381476402283,
-0.8575085401535034,
-0.4493498206138611,
0.01629607379436493,
0.09619119018316269,
0.2657165825366974,
0.774684727191925,
0.8529848456382751,
-0.7406704425811768,
-0.16843701899051666,
0.12556782364845276,
0.10074231028556824,
0.04475855827331543,
-0.214244082570076,
0.3759673833847046,
-0.8369897603988647,
-0.9296550154685974,
0.9968721270561218,
0.35931459069252014,
-0.44831568002700806,
-0.1057872548699379,
-0.21271094679832458,
0.05791290104389191,
-0.08342774957418442,
0.6269299983978271,
0.07561109215021133,
-0.7015566825866699,
-0.25370731949806213,
-0.14057528972625732,
-0.28609326481819153,
0.08214661478996277,
0.7258300185203552,
-1.0331108570098877,
0.1824072003364563,
0.293322890996933,
0.991020679473877,
0.2720082104206085,
0.35227280855178833,
0.46047717332839966,
-1.089242935180664,
0.06446552276611328,
0.18686266243457794,
0.13006719946861267,
0.4503342807292938,
-0.47074079513549805,
0.6393671035766602,
-0.22082461416721344,
-0.9979416728019714,
-0.9355481863021851,
0.1023247167468071,
-0.8030903339385986,
-0.27998262643814087,
1.2155401706695557,
0.0950099304318428,
-0.00900695938616991,
0.09875839948654175,
-0.13926751911640167,
0.24167834222316742,
-0.37271392345428467,
0.9577074646949768,
0.2586982250213623,
-0.269214391708374,
-0.06644266843795776,
-0.8999046683311462,
0.7938387989997864,
0.6352049112319946,
-0.8699049949645996,
0.05454190820455551,
0.5436347126960754,
0.3142874538898468,
-0.2493681162595749,
0.6799255013465881,
-0.11888808012008667,
0.3968871533870697,
-0.3815305531024933,
-0.1262940764427185,
-0.26849642395973206,
-0.5120483636856079,
-0.23485791683197021,
0.3983268737792969,
0.1965886801481247,
-0.03658755496144295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02483v1 | MMedAgent: Learning to Use Medical Tools with Multi-modal Agent | 2024-07-02T17:58:23 | 2024-07-02T17:58:23 | Binxu Li, Tiankai Yan, Yuanting Pan, Zhe Xu, Jie Luo, Ruiyang Ji, Shilong Liu, Haoyu Dong, Zihao Lin, Yixin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multi-Modal Large Language Models (MLLMs), despite being successful, exhibit
limited generality and often fall short when compared to specialized models.
Recently, LLM-based agents have been developed to address these challenges by
selecting appropriate specialized models as tools based on user inputs.
However, such advancements have not been extensively explored within the
medical domain. To bridge this gap, this paper introduces the first agent
explicitly designed for the medical field, named \textbf{M}ulti-modal
\textbf{Med}ical \textbf{Agent} (MMedAgent). We curate an instruction-tuning
dataset comprising six medical tools solving seven tasks, enabling the agent to
choose the most suitable tools for a given task. Comprehensive experiments
demonstrate that MMedAgent achieves superior performance across a variety of
medical tasks compared to state-of-the-art open-source methods and even the
closed-source model, GPT-4o. Furthermore, MMedAgent exhibits efficiency in
updating and integrating new medical tools. | [
-0.12541690468788147,
-0.6818450093269348,
0.914337158203125,
-0.10924208164215088,
-0.22270147502422333,
0.20435532927513123,
-0.016820058226585388,
-0.4413871467113495,
0.30944082140922546,
0.1782640516757965,
-0.8263185620307922,
-0.41390690207481384,
-0.5657680630683899,
0.18932634592056274,
0.11070354282855988,
0.9731587171554565,
0.16833749413490295,
0.4593508243560791,
-0.10487052798271179,
-0.2770855128765106,
-0.3706144392490387,
-0.5724008083343506,
-0.6353578567504883,
-0.6211923956871033,
0.9835065603256226,
0.23785343766212463,
0.9600241780281067,
0.6386483311653137,
0.5530722737312317,
0.40971338748931885,
0.43509945273399353,
0.5519258975982666,
-0.16828733682632446,
0.19359341263771057,
-0.24689224362373352,
-0.45362958312034607,
-0.6954068541526794,
0.2073686420917511,
0.18331684172153473,
0.6123902201652527,
-0.33948978781700134,
-0.02549527771770954,
-0.24485443532466888,
0.3856794536113739,
-0.5204347372055054,
-0.012953256256878376,
-0.30711472034454346,
-0.08950287103652954,
-0.007209319621324539,
-0.42696383595466614,
-0.5235632061958313,
0.07579491287469864,
-0.002936094766482711,
-0.7924360632896423,
-0.012044181115925312,
-0.14560234546661377,
0.47098374366760254,
0.6637062430381775,
-0.6897519826889038,
-0.3938775062561035,
-0.6589581966400146,
0.9200074076652527,
-0.44555720686912537,
0.6447934508323669,
0.4055742621421814,
0.5724051594734192,
-0.2263900637626648,
-0.8291990160942078,
-0.11456072330474854,
-0.5765740275382996,
0.27969661355018616,
0.16993047297000885,
0.0049013979732990265,
0.29553937911987305,
-0.002183926058933139,
0.08156061917543411,
-0.48545342683792114,
0.4884767234325409,
-0.29240304231643677,
-0.23482832312583923,
0.29408445954322815,
0.5491443872451782,
0.14078451693058014,
0.22479978203773499,
-0.44300714135169983,
0.06561432033777237,
-0.5139712691307068,
-0.21601833403110504,
-0.14291219413280487,
0.04720457270741463,
-0.15509767830371857,
0.5945925116539001,
0.05536211282014847,
0.5280463099479675,
0.11793334037065506,
-0.6699430346488953,
0.5529909729957581,
-0.17161549627780914,
-0.48167526721954346,
-0.23216326534748077,
0.6362137794494629,
0.3746807277202606,
-0.13895562291145325,
-0.14887167513370514,
-0.4181804358959198,
-0.024313969537615776,
0.6115438342094421,
-0.8907148241996765,
-0.0926264077425003,
0.3532664179801941,
-0.5504973530769348,
-0.41642650961875916,
-0.31814026832580566,
-0.2679656744003296,
-0.6420639753341675,
-0.5127777457237244,
0.47996464371681213,
-0.34420210123062134,
-0.026910651475191116,
0.18394576013088226,
0.2408573478460312,
-0.002080336445942521,
0.5517603158950806,
-0.7404587864875793,
-0.07518885284662247,
0.560975968837738,
0.8616700768470764,
-0.07967430353164673,
-0.31100016832351685,
-0.5562092065811157,
-0.009487931616604328,
-0.5391095876693726,
0.764875590801239,
-0.5757685899734497,
-0.5251011252403259,
-0.14879199862480164,
0.15273481607437134,
-0.15350553393363953,
-0.5215916037559509,
0.38265863060951233,
-0.3874039351940155,
0.2979808747768402,
-0.08250444382429123,
-0.4246812164783478,
-0.2858085334300995,
0.26411381363868713,
-0.6849135756492615,
0.58501136302948,
0.3367260992527008,
-0.25810888409614563,
0.6672139763832092,
-0.9973894357681274,
-0.37309542298316956,
-0.03386431559920311,
-0.47567641735076904,
-0.4169743061065674,
0.1277632862329483,
0.22997814416885376,
0.6788431406021118,
-0.5826959609985352,
0.18974177539348602,
-0.24400797486305237,
-0.22747798264026642,
0.3617815673351288,
-0.6070573925971985,
0.676785409450531,
0.2526656985282898,
-0.05481494590640068,
0.36263546347618103,
-0.6328099370002747,
-0.21059566736221313,
0.0879116877913475,
-0.6577574610710144,
-0.16956712305545807,
0.03820312023162842,
0.14883163571357727,
0.2629948854446411,
0.16433988511562347,
-0.5928442478179932,
0.3050699532032013,
-0.4587624669075012,
0.1466073840856552,
0.9513773918151855,
-0.2331932634115219,
0.20238056778907776,
-0.8123157620429993,
0.6518476605415344,
-0.05365491658449173,
0.4842683672904968,
-0.1436706930398941,
-0.5673880577087402,
-0.3741355836391449,
-0.7601706981658936,
0.08748693019151688,
0.5554871559143066,
-1.0730094909667969,
0.12572245299816132,
-0.030448108911514282,
-0.633510947227478,
-0.8814651966094971,
0.10557756572961807,
0.30139464139938354,
0.44039008021354675,
0.40232715010643005,
0.017759820446372032,
-0.11585754156112671,
-0.8756496906280518,
0.10674790292978287,
0.04436178877949715,
-0.11781352013349533,
0.7327321171760559,
0.2304377555847168,
-1.0147740840911865,
0.3981114625930786,
-0.3476908802986145,
-0.43584585189819336,
-0.07621102035045624,
-0.02359897457063198,
0.29777562618255615,
0.3475918769836426,
0.7149242758750916,
-0.6877217292785645,
-0.2089051902294159,
0.38074421882629395,
-0.8410029411315918,
-0.27936962246894836,
-0.36196041107177734,
0.09987819194793701,
0.32816362380981445,
0.5439195036888123,
-0.6108977794647217,
0.008621249347925186,
0.8156401515007019,
-0.3948415219783783,
0.7699000239372253,
-0.693094789981842,
0.3017524182796478,
-1.3579696416854858,
0.12334157526493073,
-0.0601668506860733,
-0.45804303884506226,
-0.6743285059928894,
0.14873097836971283,
0.16040734946727753,
0.1831328123807907,
-0.6334207653999329,
0.6590612530708313,
-0.45053502917289734,
0.3346545696258545,
-0.6299651265144348,
-0.3503412902355194,
-0.1262153834104538,
0.33795344829559326,
-0.5121555328369141,
1.012239694595337,
0.4632250666618347,
-0.6437827944755554,
0.4527328610420227,
-0.006799271795898676,
0.2244396060705185,
0.7463602423667908,
-0.6299778819084167,
0.20911665260791779,
-0.045920368283987045,
-0.17111049592494965,
-0.27945950627326965,
-0.35889187455177307,
0.37122195959091187,
-0.29958176612854004,
0.33217653632164,
-0.07590985298156738,
-0.5704551339149475,
-0.22005155682563782,
-0.1410139501094818,
0.37922102212905884,
0.47050660848617554,
-0.5379391312599182,
0.9200946688652039,
0.4123261272907257,
0.03985091671347618,
-0.695310115814209,
-0.4518537223339081,
0.13333682715892792,
-0.009949822910130024,
-0.2741236090660095,
0.11879326403141022,
-0.43997660279273987,
-0.08541658520698547,
-0.22913457453250885,
-0.19429942965507507,
-0.15727952122688293,
0.20173850655555725,
0.4418654441833496,
0.5432175993919373,
-0.33452901244163513,
0.647477388381958,
0.3602076470851898,
-0.4356153607368469,
-0.043303463608026505,
-0.15000279247760773,
0.38686391711235046,
0.032749563455581665,
-0.868086040019989,
-0.18987394869327545,
0.3665298819541931,
0.8830565214157104,
-0.18364712595939636,
0.6077077388763428,
0.5365001559257507,
-0.1792583465576172,
-0.13936574757099152,
-0.6429941654205322,
-0.35926562547683716,
-0.5860744714736938,
0.6248242855072021,
-0.4617181420326233,
-0.8427884578704834,
0.13323958218097687,
-0.3598230183124542,
0.36851122975349426,
0.16116270422935486,
1.1035315990447998,
-0.018148336559534073,
1.3597508668899536,
0.6863925457000732,
-0.04411957412958145,
0.43397581577301025,
-0.03731445595622063,
-0.4077996611595154,
-0.5797614455223083,
-0.23623518645763397,
-0.09585762768983841,
-0.28353869915008545,
-0.39316439628601074,
-0.7427411675453186,
0.7991213202476501,
-0.6834070086479187,
-0.05753595009446144,
-0.13446064293384552,
-0.5204195380210876,
0.39533933997154236,
0.5928555130958557,
0.3457634747028351,
0.07959308475255966,
-0.25898468494415283,
-0.48412731289863586,
0.20001034438610077,
-0.5473995208740234,
-0.38581231236457825,
1.3735907077789307,
0.3699394166469574,
1.1576261520385742,
0.1631752848625183,
0.6428862810134888,
0.29746881127357483,
0.47052001953125,
-1.075776219367981,
0.32289111614227295,
-0.33032703399658203,
-0.5615377426147461,
0.045766741037368774,
-0.2540265917778015,
-1.4383156299591064,
0.675642728805542,
-0.3065241873264313,
-0.270815372467041,
0.06865525990724564,
0.0874110609292984,
-0.40101489424705505,
0.1263207048177719,
-0.671417236328125,
0.5974205136299133,
-0.4097667932510376,
-0.3534771203994751,
-0.4005490243434906,
-0.7215717434883118,
-0.027939632534980774,
-0.3027593493461609,
0.2837051451206207,
-0.25267738103866577,
-0.5491132140159607,
0.2697882354259491,
-0.34745916724205017,
0.791609525680542,
-0.3416852056980133,
0.027991389855742455,
-0.2451520562171936,
0.04793602600693703,
0.07968801259994507,
-0.12888111174106598,
0.05261382460594177,
-0.04837633669376373,
-0.007035134360194206,
-0.35831090807914734,
-0.47400009632110596,
0.6397311687469482,
-0.7763365507125854,
-0.5212239623069763,
-0.3307030498981476,
-0.8679339289665222,
-0.1767597645521164,
0.4762268364429474,
-0.11949390918016434,
0.6869982481002808,
-0.24465836584568024,
0.019489377737045288,
0.6342551708221436,
-0.15921558439731598,
0.30703121423721313,
0.9171019196510315,
-0.23802450299263,
-0.3335905373096466,
0.7528015375137329,
0.0007039831834845245,
0.18883533775806427,
0.224417582154274,
0.3236404061317444,
-0.006499340292066336,
-0.49328938126564026,
-0.6825318932533264,
0.41336193680763245,
-0.6027536392211914,
-0.2686639130115509,
-0.6030867695808411,
-0.04559601470828056,
0.09558970481157303,
-0.35320475697517395,
-0.32544586062431335,
0.02468535304069519,
-0.5400969982147217,
0.0433032363653183,
0.1118309423327446,
0.7448253631591797,
-0.03814062476158142,
0.3693826496601105,
-0.9783047437667847,
0.40259382128715515,
0.2795354127883911,
0.2551179826259613,
-0.41198763251304626,
-0.10240762680768967,
-0.5278627872467041,
0.003970711026340723,
-0.3019339442253113,
-0.9369399547576904,
0.2752443253993988,
0.30868440866470337,
0.9329962134361267,
0.8854840397834778,
-0.3045029640197754,
0.24392375349998474,
-0.7051053643226624,
0.36175477504730225,
0.20607991516590118,
-0.4081207811832428,
0.43273696303367615,
-0.36501097679138184,
0.37295904755592346,
0.31450003385543823,
0.35489606857299805,
-0.36948099732398987,
-0.45630988478660583,
-0.25689926743507385,
-0.5298671126365662,
0.4544509947299957,
-0.26045525074005127,
0.11910582333803177,
0.04489491134881973,
0.186522975564003,
0.5454540252685547,
0.30499887466430664,
-0.40813010931015015,
-0.1500406116247177,
0.13023364543914795,
-0.4883294701576233,
-0.3317801058292389,
0.08465055376291275,
-0.31140580773353577,
-0.10554645955562592,
0.6104313731193542,
-0.5321836471557617,
0.3262665271759033,
0.3027275800704956,
-0.4243371784687042,
-0.1728496104478836,
0.16107724606990814,
0.776308000087738,
0.6606869101524353,
-0.011348678730428219,
0.11231818050146103,
-0.026580529287457466,
-0.7882547974586487,
0.41141366958618164,
0.3916741609573364,
0.19909413158893585,
0.013829605653882027,
0.23674596846103668,
0.4669387936592102,
0.2152138352394104,
-1.1047484874725342,
0.6054350733757019,
0.12604647874832153,
-0.2562134265899658,
-0.014414757490158081,
0.25597354769706726,
-0.012508504092693329,
0.6442899703979492,
0.1142452135682106,
0.284205824136734,
0.46268734335899353,
-0.21615780889987946,
0.3844012916088104,
0.5290372967720032,
-0.5298178195953369,
-0.29603421688079834,
0.8912538886070251,
0.25761234760284424,
-0.23738037049770355,
0.29420948028564453,
-0.1042090430855751,
-0.04372568428516388,
0.4317818880081177,
0.4731732904911041,
0.697261393070221,
-0.6095131039619446,
0.1823110729455948,
-0.24507419764995575,
0.5486403703689575,
0.21792420744895935,
0.4623054265975952,
0.17555218935012817,
-0.5327533483505249,
-0.5223369598388672,
-0.22509847581386566,
-0.39660537242889404,
-0.12677165865898132,
-0.28577256202697754,
0.09107694029808044,
-0.520719587802887,
-0.6024726033210754,
0.36292564868927,
-0.2216099351644516,
-0.8229627013206482,
0.08116640150547028,
-0.062234554439783096,
0.7491030097007751,
-0.541710615158081,
0.948498010635376,
1.13341224193573,
-0.49842938780784607,
-0.5090601444244385,
-0.3185003101825714,
0.4159981906414032,
-1.2554012537002563,
0.1721528023481369,
0.2050175815820694,
-0.3159557282924652,
-0.23157241940498352,
-0.34174367785453796,
-0.3817361891269684,
1.15664803981781,
0.5005837678909302,
-0.32832157611846924,
-0.12394393235445023,
-0.054190944880247116,
0.4711691737174988,
-0.4466007351875305,
0.2511494755744934,
0.31907597184181213,
0.2467753142118454,
-0.09321429580450058,
-1.2022478580474854,
0.034971270710229874,
-0.3488014340400696,
-0.48207536339759827,
0.3068528473377228,
-0.5341037511825562,
1.1326056718826294,
-0.5592868328094482,
0.11423423141241074,
0.024745037779211998,
-0.015353444963693619,
0.2683256268501282,
0.6134499311447144,
0.4269285500049591,
0.283000111579895,
0.8385971784591675,
0.25919124484062195,
1.1147617101669312,
-0.19894516468048096,
-0.005113984923809767,
0.8111603260040283,
-0.24557505548000336,
0.40112605690956116,
0.43409469723701477,
0.02709006704390049,
0.4636509120464325,
0.47277891635894775,
-0.17830590903759003,
0.44920551776885986,
-0.2772291302680969,
-0.5000783205032349,
-0.23698580265045166,
-0.12050587683916092,
-0.23643839359283447,
0.4337124228477478,
0.47221729159355164,
-0.714928925037384,
-0.14430037140846252,
0.4355619549751282,
0.08674665540456772,
-0.2504864037036896,
-0.3854801058769226,
1.0926010608673096,
0.15649579465389252,
-0.20344261825084686,
0.4742562472820282,
0.09949434548616409,
0.5928565859794617,
-0.7520691752433777,
-0.15022628009319305,
0.14289486408233643,
0.2508658766746521,
-0.010791842825710773,
-0.2760893404483795,
-0.20499035716056824,
-0.4320222735404968,
-0.2621387243270874,
0.035316839814186096,
0.7484751343727112,
-0.2123623788356781,
-0.4583151340484619,
0.23623792827129364,
1.070157766342163,
0.1319073587656021,
0.01141805574297905,
-0.8583232164382935,
-0.311033695936203,
-0.22795511782169342,
-0.12090832740068436,
0.2974504828453064,
0.37656500935554504,
0.11457623541355133,
1.049764633178711,
0.8680423498153687,
0.1815938651561737,
-0.003082365496084094,
0.1727723330259323,
0.9505500197410583,
-0.49080896377563477,
-0.4424267113208771,
-0.8824732303619385,
0.473314106464386,
0.17207393050193787,
-0.09703925251960754,
0.45408251881599426,
0.48592662811279297,
0.2653307318687439,
-0.14938928186893463,
0.6543287634849548,
0.27438217401504517,
0.6290939450263977,
-0.4394463002681732,
0.7978132963180542,
-0.8633021712303162,
0.06824839860200882,
0.18110774457454681,
-0.4464787542819977,
-0.24541059136390686,
0.5144482851028442,
0.09885383397340775,
0.32015344500541687,
0.7189657688140869,
0.9282525777816772,
-0.2068524807691574,
-0.4390206038951874,
0.725094199180603,
0.087433822453022,
0.38868677616119385,
0.4924965500831604,
0.6948460936546326,
0.13367611169815063,
0.16306447982788086,
-0.021167125552892685,
-0.6554761528968811,
-0.6156553030014038,
-0.38380205631256104,
-1.1475224494934082,
-0.3897128105163574,
0.18811391294002533,
-0.03386969864368439,
0.09684161096811295,
1.5759161710739136,
1.024904489517212,
-0.407037615776062,
-0.08126016706228256,
0.4949866235256195,
-0.05956322327256203,
-0.3271375894546509,
-0.07318347692489624,
0.1503640115261078,
-0.4859631359577179,
-0.6153172254562378,
0.8660343289375305,
0.38871335983276367,
0.09280158579349518,
-0.35810232162475586,
-0.15299588441848755,
-0.00658362777903676,
0.421256959438324,
0.7219448685646057,
-0.042242154479026794,
-0.763425886631012,
-0.10731390863656998,
0.22361421585083008,
-0.34263166785240173,
0.2300451248884201,
0.8841547966003418,
-0.7016830444335938,
0.738793671131134,
-0.2333974391222,
0.821708083152771,
-0.061134569346904755,
-0.27519816160202026,
0.4741276800632477,
-0.5020711421966553,
0.15068790316581726,
0.4355541169643402,
0.38824915885925293,
-0.00958901084959507,
-0.31758832931518555,
0.38868096470832825,
0.0037355346139520407,
-0.860404372215271,
-0.5691539645195007,
0.1594502180814743,
-0.944421112537384,
-0.5211867094039917,
0.931465208530426,
0.202451691031456,
0.07512317597866058,
-0.3474031090736389,
-0.7290392518043518,
0.17198973894119263,
-0.5488585233688354,
0.6626520156860352,
0.15186439454555511,
-0.37761348485946655,
0.023423701524734497,
-0.8797165751457214,
0.2327803075313568,
0.2739798426628113,
-0.9439440965652466,
-0.40070703625679016,
0.8252436518669128,
0.292068213224411,
-0.03239646181464195,
0.8427572250366211,
0.0065647903829813,
0.6572868824005127,
0.06607592105865479,
0.10497955977916718,
-0.5396236181259155,
-0.4111827313899994,
-0.30442339181900024,
0.02901821956038475,
0.3427498936653137,
-0.4324214458465576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02477v1 | Understanding Alignment in Multimodal LLMs: A Comprehensive Study | 2024-07-02T17:55:03 | 2024-07-02T17:55:03 | Elmira Amirloo, Jean-Philippe Fauconnier, Christoph Roesmann, Christian Kerl, Rinu Boney, Yusu Qian, Zirui Wang, Afshin Dehghan, Yinfei Yang, Zhe Gan, Peter Grasch | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Preference alignment has become a crucial component in enhancing the
performance of Large Language Models (LLMs), yet its impact in Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs) remains comparatively underexplored. Similar to
language models, MLLMs for image understanding tasks encounter challenges like
hallucination. In MLLMs, hallucination can occur not only by stating incorrect
facts but also by producing responses that are inconsistent with the image
content. A primary objective of alignment for MLLMs is to encourage these
models to align responses more closely with image information. Recently,
multiple works have introduced preference datasets for MLLMs and examined
different alignment methods, including Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). However, due to variations in datasets,
base model types, and alignment methods, it remains unclear which specific
elements contribute most significantly to the reported improvements in these
works. In this paper, we independently analyze each aspect of preference
alignment in MLLMs. We start by categorizing the alignment algorithms into two
groups, offline (such as DPO), and online (such as online-DPO), and show that
combining offline and online methods can improve the performance of the model
in certain scenarios. We review a variety of published multimodal preference
datasets and discuss how the details of their construction impact model
performance. Based on these insights, we introduce a novel way of creating
multimodal preference data called Bias-Driven Hallucination Sampling (BDHS)
that needs neither additional annotation nor external models, and show that it
can achieve competitive performance to previously published alignment work for
multimodal models across a range of benchmarks. | [
-0.5481483936309814,
-0.56710284948349,
0.678072988986969,
0.03341366723179817,
-0.15574605762958527,
-0.07777432352304459,
-0.2563929557800293,
-0.5009064674377441,
0.21239393949508667,
0.49291324615478516,
-0.5805448889732361,
-0.34789401292800903,
-0.5168314576148987,
0.05071162059903145,
0.04427381604909897,
0.7982633709907532,
-0.11206116527318954,
0.29121825098991394,
-0.4428917169570923,
-0.3839724063873291,
-0.5621228218078613,
-0.4408414661884308,
-0.16206642985343933,
-0.2850598692893982,
0.6994625329971313,
0.2472088634967804,
1.0477312803268433,
0.7887678742408752,
0.7083509564399719,
0.34083282947540283,
0.057557955384254456,
0.49027183651924133,
-0.49095991253852844,
0.2562013864517212,
0.04944773018360138,
-0.25258639454841614,
-0.5037055611610413,
-0.184502974152565,
0.5281159281730652,
0.5264690518379211,
0.14146707952022552,
-0.0464298389852047,
0.0038608822505921125,
0.9100586771965027,
-0.7365056872367859,
-0.13387243449687958,
-0.7131319046020508,
0.11219459772109985,
-0.10222958773374557,
-0.31143298745155334,
-0.41766616702079773,
-0.3972068130970001,
0.36623939871788025,
-0.4908519685268402,
0.02115495689213276,
0.08396520465612411,
0.8019046783447266,
0.3975158631801605,
-0.6850914359092712,
-0.32186025381088257,
-0.5774077773094177,
0.9629384279251099,
-0.499909371137619,
0.570543646812439,
0.2649778425693512,
0.1992395669221878,
-0.07034486532211304,
-0.1400529146194458,
-0.6586055755615234,
-0.04272904619574547,
-0.15065884590148926,
-0.11785198003053665,
0.045033328235149384,
0.16540031135082245,
0.21786420047283173,
0.3417808711528778,
-0.6808388829231262,
0.2673557698726654,
0.0198176559060812,
-0.27333760261535645,
0.5999360680580139,
0.15325945615768433,
0.09530137479305267,
-0.2328381985425949,
-0.4321383237838745,
-0.15456028282642365,
-0.5673069953918457,
0.06351744383573532,
0.4503225088119507,
0.29030004143714905,
-0.04954826459288597,
0.8708531260490417,
0.0941043272614479,
1.0214924812316895,
0.24073368310928345,
-0.45230522751808167,
0.4247038662433624,
-0.3940601646900177,
-0.15053683519363403,
0.16631385684013367,
0.5886560082435608,
0.8360860347747803,
0.217179074883461,
-0.03779676556587219,
-0.2263759970664978,
0.14268095791339874,
0.33686208724975586,
-0.5223950147628784,
0.12113868445158005,
0.46289539337158203,
-0.7317318916320801,
-0.3028642535209656,
-0.06602908670902252,
-0.7717140913009644,
-0.7409829497337341,
-0.9309508800506592,
0.38770416378974915,
-0.19330169260501862,
-0.2123287320137024,
-0.0227511003613472,
0.0017832033336162567,
0.2903439998626709,
0.404204398393631,
-1.0159045457839966,
-0.10914716869592667,
0.650657594203949,
0.8692357540130615,
-0.46926385164260864,
-0.37113291025161743,
-0.4291456341743469,
0.0635085180401802,
-0.32098400592803955,
0.7263548374176025,
-0.6178367733955383,
-0.1451403796672821,
0.06312215328216553,
0.021999286487698555,
-0.06969568133354187,
-0.5232989192008972,
0.33944064378738403,
-0.5715792179107666,
0.17373810708522797,
-0.4995514452457428,
-0.5686158537864685,
-0.2938888967037201,
0.3058615028858185,
-0.6919495463371277,
0.7931414842605591,
-0.23854364454746246,
-0.7894035577774048,
0.5328606367111206,
-0.472533643245697,
-0.1348535269498825,
-0.41895973682403564,
-0.33193239569664,
-0.43064218759536743,
0.2947535812854767,
0.35162386298179626,
0.5237858891487122,
0.022831780835986137,
0.46964162588119507,
-0.6273861527442932,
-0.3773253858089447,
0.5433539748191833,
-0.291879802942276,
0.6665271520614624,
0.1420685201883316,
-0.43600475788116455,
0.4964008629322052,
-0.5951264500617981,
-0.10415203124284744,
0.02232290431857109,
0.050333283841609955,
-0.329648494720459,
0.1206221729516983,
0.09973018616437912,
0.32988396286964417,
0.26455777883529663,
-0.26660090684890747,
0.36834290623664856,
-0.01100375410169363,
0.16979768872261047,
1.2330527305603027,
-0.33657002449035645,
0.5387005805969238,
-0.39173588156700134,
0.26427149772644043,
0.05886348336935043,
0.3390752077102661,
0.010211491025984287,
-0.21558044850826263,
-0.5577782988548279,
-0.4111135005950928,
0.12302641570568085,
0.24803811311721802,
-0.48664337396621704,
0.38222408294677734,
-0.31149742007255554,
-0.258276104927063,
-0.8854425549507141,
0.14728613197803497,
0.30152004957199097,
0.4523078501224518,
0.3708743453025818,
-0.23167914152145386,
-0.6719881892204285,
-1.2243397235870361,
0.106463223695755,
0.0796465054154396,
0.34016191959381104,
0.5090370774269104,
0.16522158682346344,
-0.3943232297897339,
0.9571258425712585,
-0.5090140700340271,
-0.2527870237827301,
-0.07442125678062439,
-0.17402508854866028,
0.05813734233379364,
0.2027316838502884,
0.5757910013198853,
-0.9771006107330322,
-0.4110274314880371,
0.06393713504076004,
-0.757163941860199,
-0.01904538832604885,
-0.030369238927960396,
-0.26577556133270264,
0.5023659467697144,
0.086704321205616,
-0.516173243522644,
0.2055538147687912,
0.8436271548271179,
-0.12265104055404663,
0.5183776021003723,
-0.07747653126716614,
0.34282031655311584,
-0.8480830192565918,
-0.053880754858255386,
0.05575580522418022,
-0.14166724681854248,
-0.653598964214325,
-0.08726143836975098,
0.09853873401880264,
0.1557929962873459,
-0.49671420454978943,
0.41636624932289124,
-0.5802097320556641,
-0.48271211981773376,
-0.30796825885772705,
0.11002029478549957,
0.003647992853075266,
0.44410520792007446,
0.3906865417957306,
0.7487625479698181,
0.6265357732772827,
-0.4940616488456726,
0.30910396575927734,
0.3051166832447052,
-0.2604082226753235,
0.5182840824127197,
-0.352415531873703,
0.3462812900543213,
-0.385459303855896,
0.03424014523625374,
-1.0984532833099365,
-0.17808474600315094,
0.12918159365653992,
-0.16634516417980194,
0.43798062205314636,
-0.03797778859734535,
-0.2433881163597107,
0.036630723625421524,
-0.5379772782325745,
0.4667525589466095,
0.16535644233226776,
-0.6145055294036865,
0.5837295651435852,
0.6118712425231934,
0.21136175096035004,
-1.0987069606781006,
-0.3073328137397766,
-0.10759588330984116,
-0.3971208930015564,
-0.6442933678627014,
0.37781286239624023,
-0.14106033742427826,
-0.48969700932502747,
-0.23298640549182892,
-0.12694570422172546,
0.2484802007675171,
-0.11869340389966965,
0.3283461630344391,
0.6425749659538269,
-0.21333149075508118,
0.09485551714897156,
-0.20554590225219727,
0.01904868520796299,
-0.29904288053512573,
-0.035879284143447876,
0.7694754004478455,
-0.05950598791241646,
-0.4214697480201721,
-0.5166060328483582,
0.24641577899456024,
0.6744541525840759,
-0.08189088106155396,
0.6118327379226685,
0.554975688457489,
-0.12687163054943085,
0.23625029623508453,
-0.749000608921051,
-0.1552467793226242,
-0.4330812394618988,
0.23763929307460785,
-0.47982028126716614,
-0.7712259888648987,
0.3171629309654236,
0.3115640878677368,
0.1356622725725174,
0.21468152105808258,
0.698336660861969,
-0.27538642287254333,
1.164482593536377,
0.5872041583061218,
-0.11092791706323624,
0.49398452043533325,
0.12170229107141495,
0.21786725521087646,
-0.8231165409088135,
-0.32383716106414795,
-0.28765639662742615,
-0.6722063422203064,
-0.7576910257339478,
-0.329037606716156,
0.23532898724079132,
-0.1303287297487259,
0.02022578939795494,
0.2008567452430725,
-0.48956775665283203,
0.3697207570075989,
0.31659698486328125,
0.2102023810148239,
0.2763610780239105,
0.1830706149339676,
-0.006369967944920063,
-0.3014543652534485,
-0.3837607204914093,
-0.6738881468772888,
1.2360949516296387,
0.3384539484977722,
0.8559768795967102,
0.25742727518081665,
0.47976404428482056,
0.14488840103149414,
0.06938808411359787,
-0.9555546045303345,
0.44002416729927063,
-0.014663995243608952,
-0.49618780612945557,
-0.34943515062332153,
-0.2270740419626236,
-0.8695526123046875,
0.5332906246185303,
-0.3556378185749054,
-0.6407179236412048,
0.40360912680625916,
0.35755014419555664,
-0.21700027585029602,
0.14296358823776245,
-0.6492522358894348,
0.8234124779701233,
-0.654367983341217,
-0.6677277088165283,
-0.1144804134964943,
-0.797373354434967,
0.3042029142379761,
-0.04871457442641258,
0.11210786551237106,
-0.17942263185977936,
-0.015070472843945026,
0.40571704506874084,
0.10459454357624054,
0.6468818187713623,
-0.1303476095199585,
-0.2504936456680298,
-0.19016101956367493,
-0.02557479962706566,
0.3909876048564911,
-0.21576841175556183,
0.005316870752722025,
0.2746995687484741,
0.012937639839947224,
-0.2273017168045044,
-0.5905208587646484,
0.7502053380012512,
-0.8473883271217346,
-0.6241621971130371,
-0.35545995831489563,
-0.8350608944892883,
-0.3693225085735321,
-0.032977502793073654,
0.07118652015924454,
0.4398314952850342,
0.04558930918574333,
0.15686270594596863,
0.8078576326370239,
-0.1821517050266266,
0.41675373911857605,
0.0826490968465805,
-0.5996100902557373,
-0.35130852460861206,
0.8695694804191589,
0.10232166945934296,
0.29802167415618896,
0.5582293272018433,
0.08642791211605072,
-0.6712124347686768,
-0.4529154300689697,
-0.42285850644111633,
0.3548114597797394,
-0.832977294921875,
0.07912643253803253,
-0.8247197866439819,
0.08935730159282684,
-0.610309362411499,
-0.26503464579582214,
-0.2742931544780731,
-0.2679138481616974,
-0.2570684552192688,
0.014777429401874542,
0.0990331768989563,
0.5478271842002869,
0.03960583359003067,
0.016386179253458977,
-0.5949779152870178,
0.36155083775520325,
0.23167887330055237,
0.23852002620697021,
0.024455314502120018,
-0.3832678198814392,
0.02141967974603176,
0.0016409996896982193,
-0.38808658719062805,
-0.8859593868255615,
0.26771771907806396,
-0.1138957217335701,
0.6086441874504089,
0.7775241732597351,
-0.20356571674346924,
1.045430064201355,
-0.3021010458469391,
0.5920804142951965,
0.16318351030349731,
-0.7729039192199707,
0.3494087755680084,
-0.13288043439388275,
0.0195004940032959,
0.4949173033237457,
0.6083685755729675,
-0.4615403115749359,
0.09972140192985535,
-0.1551956832408905,
-0.6127532720565796,
0.5117443799972534,
0.09733564406633377,
0.06017661839723587,
0.25323307514190674,
0.07264380156993866,
0.44251373410224915,
0.3549497723579407,
-0.7879632115364075,
-0.30884069204330444,
-0.1924806386232376,
-0.26403436064720154,
-0.3401607275009155,
-0.4081985056400299,
-0.37010055780410767,
-0.25826627016067505,
0.5654012560844421,
-0.19825389981269836,
0.27031221985816956,
-0.0014064653078094125,
-0.3587871491909027,
-0.017127515748143196,
0.178079754114151,
1.0542198419570923,
0.8607375621795654,
-0.35949090123176575,
0.32620909810066223,
-0.2336650937795639,
-0.16802716255187988,
0.2526257336139679,
-0.2233157753944397,
-0.055537059903144836,
0.006933256983757019,
0.18645153939723969,
1.0500203371047974,
-0.12910501658916473,
-0.5878207087516785,
0.4349077343940735,
0.005063259042799473,
-0.044856827706098557,
-0.05730608478188515,
-0.10462381690740585,
-0.1918257772922516,
0.22309879958629608,
0.1695745289325714,
0.14572648704051971,
0.16328608989715576,
-0.5222468376159668,
0.07125302404165268,
0.829352855682373,
-0.4110182821750641,
-0.16018451750278473,
0.3505954444408417,
-0.008565816096961498,
-0.08136525005102158,
0.5056555867195129,
0.1784254014492035,
-0.4332383871078491,
0.4351707398891449,
0.4924633800983429,
0.7322662472724915,
-0.043450210243463516,
0.2243395745754242,
0.1824917197227478,
0.20705188810825348,
-0.05712110549211502,
0.14342767000198364,
-0.1664784997701645,
-1.0486903190612793,
-0.32562437653541565,
-0.5639359354972839,
-0.356757789850235,
0.12516655027866364,
-0.601447582244873,
0.37322118878364563,
-0.04883259907364845,
-0.324932724237442,
0.0014225519262254238,
-0.33165645599365234,
-0.5562230348587036,
0.06006605178117752,
0.22398371994495392,
0.3389802575111389,
-0.7931380867958069,
0.5703986883163452,
0.6439824104309082,
-0.10063768923282623,
-0.47724470496177673,
0.09465324133634567,
0.3928748667240143,
-1.0054374933242798,
0.6324719190597534,
0.34526383876800537,
-0.17552843689918518,
-0.14932966232299805,
-0.3017955720424652,
-0.9758298993110657,
0.8644685745239258,
0.31126537919044495,
-0.6374499201774597,
0.005834194365888834,
0.10311362147331238,
0.3450421094894409,
-0.5495709776878357,
0.3026699125766754,
0.4341404139995575,
0.5833653211593628,
0.15080206096172333,
-0.9138755202293396,
-0.04011673480272293,
0.05487341806292534,
0.21210114657878876,
0.3304586708545685,
-0.521456778049469,
0.48775675892829895,
-0.3405131995677948,
0.026976831257343292,
-0.19670403003692627,
0.3307899236679077,
0.37137582898139954,
0.33308693766593933,
0.5363479852676392,
0.5040925145149231,
0.7307199239730835,
-0.127556711435318,
0.9238789081573486,
-0.12505480647087097,
0.25681954622268677,
1.0650824308395386,
-0.6124510169029236,
0.7413802742958069,
1.075891137123108,
-0.04568394646048546,
0.18714171648025513,
0.9217286109924316,
-0.05825044959783554,
0.7113798260688782,
-0.036398451775312424,
-0.024262549355626106,
-0.26667627692222595,
-0.33931320905685425,
-0.47707363963127136,
0.6237287521362305,
-0.01214382890611887,
-0.5001981854438782,
0.06494337320327759,
0.05609361454844475,
-0.23675525188446045,
-0.12882088124752045,
-0.2178390622138977,
0.9785954356193542,
-0.30147555470466614,
-0.8985756039619446,
0.4551241099834442,
-0.3348582684993744,
0.7106273174285889,
-0.4182220995426178,
0.09585215896368027,
-0.11076654493808746,
0.183147594332695,
-0.4450537860393524,
-0.8383714556694031,
0.2651137113571167,
-0.29726290702819824,
-0.39268794655799866,
-0.2724637985229492,
0.5011834502220154,
-0.4489881098270416,
-0.20798055827617645,
0.24750053882598877,
0.3391278088092804,
0.1749744564294815,
0.10767260938882828,
-0.6860292553901672,
0.49603942036628723,
0.1719740778207779,
-0.17013908922672272,
0.5456876158714294,
0.06712615489959717,
-0.10555161535739899,
0.5036079287528992,
0.6487319469451904,
-0.010720551945269108,
0.05015599727630615,
0.17565691471099854,
0.6008632183074951,
-0.39416784048080444,
-0.08056079596281052,
-1.120687484741211,
0.569338858127594,
-0.16267921030521393,
-0.18787480890750885,
0.7943799495697021,
0.7279770970344543,
0.8404914736747742,
-0.19091403484344482,
0.5667924284934998,
0.09992045909166336,
0.03275037184357643,
-0.7765301465988159,
0.38100001215934753,
-0.7148526310920715,
0.010897791013121605,
-0.3799946904182434,
-1.2299416065216064,
-0.2981519401073456,
0.6930053234100342,
-0.3993634283542633,
-0.08221442997455597,
0.6729065179824829,
1.1245907545089722,
0.0020766782108694315,
-0.1277817040681839,
0.3764786720275879,
-0.1516239196062088,
0.08960212767124176,
0.2082863748073578,
1.0489141941070557,
-0.062108106911182404,
0.2513135075569153,
-0.4125974178314209,
-0.14693523943424225,
-0.2314883917570114,
-0.9909397959709167,
-0.7535822987556458,
-0.7362644076347351,
-0.301780104637146,
-0.3274960517883301,
-0.11433181911706924,
1.1952261924743652,
0.6819730401039124,
-0.7548312544822693,
-0.4128352999687195,
0.303921103477478,
0.25511080026626587,
-0.23663310706615448,
-0.2147846668958664,
0.4114542603492737,
-0.276819109916687,
-0.80812007188797,
0.09899036586284637,
0.5145556926727295,
0.28893110156059265,
-0.21560242772102356,
-0.24246221780776978,
-0.19779394567012787,
-0.07639025896787643,
0.6546469926834106,
-0.08270064741373062,
-1.1072287559509277,
-0.12451548129320145,
0.2731688618659973,
-0.21403926610946655,
0.46492984890937805,
0.9142186045646667,
-0.2932194769382477,
0.7721720337867737,
0.47911226749420166,
0.7292237281799316,
0.3606829047203064,
0.08430686593055725,
0.4893340766429901,
-0.4854873716831207,
0.06947281956672668,
0.0421728789806366,
0.45032694935798645,
0.458021342754364,
-0.4471777677536011,
0.3245365023612976,
0.08897750079631805,
-0.6282493472099304,
-0.9330397248268127,
0.291648268699646,
-1.1208311319351196,
-0.32221662998199463,
1.2244423627853394,
0.35971203446388245,
-0.053452104330062866,
-0.05934539809823036,
-0.5516020655632019,
0.09819876402616501,
-0.31664180755615234,
1.007832407951355,
0.8765835762023926,
-0.43220728635787964,
-0.2780032455921173,
-0.32079923152923584,
0.4668131470680237,
0.42594167590141296,
-0.5874806642532349,
0.04995723441243172,
0.8915680050849915,
0.038627974689006805,
0.2187746912240982,
0.499187707901001,
-0.10844235867261887,
0.0740535780787468,
-0.5296450853347778,
0.1538345217704773,
0.08983022719621658,
-0.41309675574302673,
-0.5235901474952698,
0.19660870730876923,
0.04083223268389702,
-0.31848156452178955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02472v1 | ValueScope: Unveiling Implicit Norms and Values via Return Potential Model of Social Interactions | 2024-07-02T17:51:27 | 2024-07-02T17:51:27 | Chan Young Park, Shuyue Stella Li, Hayoung Jung, Svitlana Volkova, Tanushree Mitra, David Jurgens, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study introduces ValueScope, a framework leveraging language models to
quantify social norms and values within online communities, grounded in social
science perspectives on normative structures. We employ ValueScope to dissect
and analyze linguistic and stylistic expressions across 13 Reddit communities
categorized under gender, politics, science, and finance. Our analysis provides
a quantitative foundation showing that even closely related communities exhibit
remarkably diverse norms. This diversity supports existing theories and adds a
new dimension--community preference--to understanding community interactions.
ValueScope not only delineates differing social norms among communities but
also effectively traces their evolution and the influence of significant
external events like the U.S. presidential elections and the emergence of new
sub-communities. The framework thus highlights the pivotal role of social norms
in shaping online interactions, presenting a substantial advance in both the
theory and application of social norm studies in digital spaces. | [
-0.5008076429367065,
-0.6970141530036926,
0.5746393203735352,
0.007014775648713112,
-0.038854070007801056,
-0.03870908170938492,
-0.16293106973171234,
-0.49975425004959106,
0.5392257571220398,
0.2822084128856659,
-0.6579504013061523,
-0.3571889102458954,
-0.867206335067749,
0.1083105206489563,
-0.5152157545089722,
1.1438374519348145,
0.43722498416900635,
-0.1255839616060257,
-0.4137934148311615,
-0.13253527879714966,
-0.05147603899240494,
-0.5596925020217896,
-0.21158866584300995,
0.16600742936134338,
0.5508250594139099,
0.4907374083995819,
0.49437281489372253,
0.3012244701385498,
0.6964770555496216,
0.2828596532344818,
-0.16806170344352722,
0.015329655259847641,
-0.9314326643943787,
0.02971809171140194,
-0.14167681336402893,
0.06038505211472511,
-0.361512154340744,
0.45767733454704285,
0.43994593620300293,
0.6769865155220032,
0.15261302888393402,
0.5444173812866211,
0.16096486151218414,
0.6932750344276428,
-0.7499070167541504,
0.4569394290447235,
-0.35669171810150146,
-0.22951583564281464,
-0.10927009582519531,
-0.11917588114738464,
0.08722792565822601,
-0.7972891926765442,
-0.15859173238277435,
-0.6984009742736816,
-0.2314888834953308,
-0.2746604382991791,
1.0294376611709595,
0.02362818829715252,
-0.8240494132041931,
-0.2667693495750427,
-0.5026623606681824,
0.7960010170936584,
-0.30677828192710876,
0.6420935392379761,
0.27882516384124756,
0.4451727271080017,
0.15157127380371094,
-0.9635111093521118,
-0.631437361240387,
0.1765347272157669,
-0.0444934219121933,
-0.017260409891605377,
-0.476878821849823,
-0.039736416190862656,
0.10324928909540176,
0.20829251408576965,
0.26075053215026855,
-0.5891121029853821,
-0.9104454517364502,
0.30742841958999634,
0.6451402306556702,
0.03739799186587334,
0.15295691788196564,
-0.4408441185951233,
0.1787634938955307,
-0.12121368944644928,
-0.2996106743812561,
0.5791053175926208,
0.7507367730140686,
0.2824952304363251,
-0.19823940098285675,
0.6952304244041443,
-0.06163385882973671,
0.2488524168729782,
0.43265098333358765,
-0.06432556360960007,
0.2955726385116577,
-0.9018251895904541,
0.12442801892757416,
-0.35617807507514954,
0.3859921395778656,
0.8412818312644958,
0.6786049604415894,
0.534484326839447,
0.1437252163887024,
0.24905076622962952,
0.47355031967163086,
-0.5742194652557373,
0.054161421954631805,
0.09850243479013443,
-0.7399386167526245,
-1.0314258337020874,
0.11856798082590103,
-0.921022355556488,
-0.4388939142227173,
-0.24405907094478607,
0.01577930338680744,
0.1869330257177353,
-0.7322781682014465,
-0.15691691637039185,
-0.5249553918838501,
0.20023824274539948,
0.39387205243110657,
-0.8352856040000916,
0.6655016541481018,
0.772304117679596,
0.8599380254745483,
0.0015132093103602529,
-0.04290579631924629,
-0.35092514753341675,
-0.3620622456073761,
-0.22297132015228271,
0.49015355110168457,
-0.8009426593780518,
-0.5210083723068237,
0.03274650126695633,
-0.1022721603512764,
0.5010800361633301,
-0.0457327738404274,
0.16282013058662415,
-0.7607512474060059,
-0.22000457346439362,
-0.3595631718635559,
-0.4684916138648987,
0.026625558733940125,
0.45557093620300293,
-0.852185845375061,
1.0587388277053833,
0.031104320660233498,
-0.5648427605628967,
0.7056922316551208,
-1.205765962600708,
-0.14992284774780273,
-0.04768967628479004,
-0.2552430033683777,
-0.2422497421503067,
-0.0025728619657456875,
-0.14525564014911652,
0.2951866388320923,
0.17885836958885193,
0.110000379383564,
-0.6346144676208496,
-0.0123381856828928,
0.5115334987640381,
-0.20524592697620392,
0.8085365295410156,
0.21311333775520325,
-0.29250600934028625,
0.3121137320995331,
-0.7861348390579224,
-0.11958722025156021,
-0.033205363899469376,
-0.05097368732094765,
-0.4908239543437958,
0.19342169165611267,
0.3782378137111664,
0.10787174850702286,
0.1202230378985405,
-0.5967748761177063,
0.14700312912464142,
-0.1422460377216339,
0.9404659867286682,
0.7729387283325195,
0.06476370245218277,
0.5405316352844238,
-0.0012728709261864424,
0.2974441349506378,
-0.019907303154468536,
0.45353013277053833,
0.30750855803489685,
-0.6514601111412048,
-0.45016977190971375,
-0.15626004338264465,
-0.38433802127838135,
-0.06637272238731384,
0.13707493245601654,
-0.021353190764784813,
-0.20111164450645447,
-0.5482052564620972,
-0.5067627429962158,
0.1364574283361435,
-0.0708056092262268,
0.2173623889684677,
0.25069165229797363,
-0.2400672733783722,
-0.5835057497024536,
-0.8157964944839478,
-0.527906060218811,
-0.3173881471157074,
0.10659731924533844,
0.42330002784729004,
0.6622362732887268,
-0.5930190086364746,
1.578729271888733,
-0.4856041371822357,
-0.22134973108768463,
-0.27013343572616577,
0.20826038718223572,
0.12543800473213196,
-0.10598333179950714,
0.38832470774650574,
-1.2896668910980225,
-0.3646697700023651,
-0.22591032087802887,
-0.40398624539375305,
-0.37859997153282166,
0.3486437201499939,
0.22610539197921753,
0.049726489931344986,
0.612721860408783,
0.03694208711385727,
0.5071003437042236,
0.7870844602584839,
-0.6250273585319519,
0.4108734428882599,
0.36342039704322815,
0.6087091565132141,
-1.016119360923767,
-0.018703186884522438,
0.13063214719295502,
-0.37877386808395386,
-0.5221980810165405,
0.05410967394709587,
0.09426598995923996,
0.06281690299510956,
-0.7065045833587646,
0.6600647568702698,
-0.15917333960533142,
-0.2901771366596222,
-0.18466167151927948,
0.18708765506744385,
0.2225019335746765,
-0.07711657136678696,
0.03059370443224907,
0.7268640398979187,
-0.01545950211584568,
-0.43870946764945984,
0.36866864562034607,
0.22957183420658112,
-0.018862223252654076,
0.8172686696052551,
-0.7376396059989929,
-0.07569289952516556,
-0.23632022738456726,
0.010543374344706535,
-1.2297353744506836,
-0.2624524235725403,
0.07937797904014587,
-0.8042085766792297,
-0.5175538063049316,
-0.5405651926994324,
-0.08966079354286194,
-0.03627312555909157,
-0.6159098148345947,
0.7257983088493347,
0.3751648962497711,
-0.19448250532150269,
0.39511626958847046,
1.07888925075531,
0.017589014023542404,
-0.38790732622146606,
-0.5287796854972839,
0.06874209642410278,
-0.2028268575668335,
-0.6640848517417908,
-0.25018230080604553,
-0.06853628903627396,
-1.1099417209625244,
0.17256182432174683,
0.3548082709312439,
-0.3582518398761749,
0.09172108769416809,
0.5756018161773682,
0.10761594027280807,
0.05939203500747681,
0.12140239030122757,
0.10138733685016632,
-0.19370658695697784,
0.06602070480585098,
-0.2917173206806183,
0.310116708278656,
-0.922544538974762,
-0.3201654255390167,
0.00005070530460216105,
0.38654157519340515,
0.7470186352729797,
-0.13723275065422058,
0.64761883020401,
0.2932969629764557,
-0.4238492250442505,
0.4178462624549866,
-0.49881044030189514,
-0.39188089966773987,
-0.5492821335792542,
0.373203307390213,
-0.19873905181884766,
-1.198164939880371,
0.38897058367729187,
0.14176441729068756,
0.27273479104042053,
0.6092336177825928,
0.5651382803916931,
-0.32417821884155273,
0.6295921802520752,
0.9219792485237122,
0.4401681423187256,
0.3103344738483429,
0.07951939851045609,
0.2623608708381653,
-0.5105623602867126,
0.01922701857984066,
-0.290437787771225,
-0.22176839411258698,
-0.7453904151916504,
-0.2787236273288727,
0.8222066760063171,
-0.14205679297447205,
-0.1777717024087906,
0.291263610124588,
-0.47323352098464966,
0.5332320332527161,
0.4142632782459259,
-0.2030380666255951,
0.5866411328315735,
-0.2680068612098694,
0.3186224102973938,
-0.4720739722251892,
-0.29286128282546997,
-0.7429508566856384,
1.216154932975769,
0.3356080651283264,
0.6766883730888367,
0.32856547832489014,
0.4007888436317444,
0.7212859392166138,
0.30699965357780457,
-0.9532920718193054,
0.29165589809417725,
0.01068667322397232,
-0.8026721477508545,
-0.6238041520118713,
-0.20876362919807434,
-0.8809099793434143,
-0.16813425719738007,
-0.4182363748550415,
-0.4161265194416046,
0.33039286732673645,
0.24181701242923737,
-0.2492019087076187,
0.2817079722881317,
-0.3042376637458801,
0.7998855710029602,
-0.0221957266330719,
-0.47944211959838867,
-0.47516393661499023,
-0.5922959446907043,
0.30349770188331604,
0.10537157207727432,
0.686063826084137,
-0.09083063900470734,
0.0064412751235067844,
0.6986356377601624,
-0.10105450451374054,
1.2633346319198608,
0.3276648223400116,
0.1272040754556656,
0.17120318114757538,
0.003186719724908471,
0.17887495458126068,
0.35582953691482544,
0.3003636300563812,
0.5009856224060059,
0.5706111192703247,
-0.2129664272069931,
-0.2100488841533661,
0.806883692741394,
-1.1814548969268799,
-0.18700550496578217,
-0.5564070343971252,
-0.15880587697029114,
0.10247611254453659,
0.3748547434806824,
-0.12824372947216034,
0.25251609086990356,
-0.5509970784187317,
0.2533976435661316,
0.5283627510070801,
0.06910116970539093,
0.059903617948293686,
0.3033495545387268,
-0.2955581843852997,
-0.2602861523628235,
0.48945173621177673,
0.2940852642059326,
0.36856335401535034,
0.014186549000442028,
0.3819078803062439,
-0.3263665735721588,
0.28869935870170593,
-0.1010546013712883,
0.07742035388946533,
-0.9575961232185364,
0.1884968876838684,
-0.7300947308540344,
-0.2509929835796356,
-0.8343198299407959,
-0.7086827158927917,
-0.7414050102233887,
-0.6038252711296082,
-0.25773492455482483,
-0.2173360288143158,
0.8174370527267456,
1.1166887283325195,
-0.3332436680793762,
-0.18154536187648773,
-0.8127521872520447,
0.13234351575374603,
0.6803827285766602,
0.4137166738510132,
-0.44011378288269043,
-0.07945190370082855,
0.0999075248837471,
0.009101040661334991,
-0.11295130103826523,
-1.1663661003112793,
0.4158399999141693,
0.10859542340040207,
0.27625399827957153,
0.5073419213294983,
0.16386017203330994,
0.6413794755935669,
-0.3236539363861084,
0.928968608379364,
0.007835700176656246,
-1.2248599529266357,
0.5930996537208557,
-0.3929090201854706,
-0.03928615152835846,
0.6138035655021667,
0.5690895318984985,
-1.2520802021026611,
-0.30158790946006775,
-0.8024717569351196,
-0.9380553364753723,
0.1401882916688919,
0.39554935693740845,
0.45347076654434204,
-0.1150357648730278,
0.5593267679214478,
0.051548656076192856,
0.523351788520813,
-0.9511992931365967,
-0.3201892077922821,
-0.7152397036552429,
-0.2393626570701599,
0.1581762433052063,
-0.461459755897522,
-0.4730965793132782,
-0.2449640929698944,
0.10235156863927841,
-0.25104671716690063,
0.18911945819854736,
0.09433693438768387,
0.018826676532626152,
-0.45671725273132324,
0.359936386346817,
0.6298747658729553,
1.0009894371032715,
-0.11031497269868851,
0.40080195665359497,
0.11810728162527084,
-0.5170469880104065,
0.011258721351623535,
-0.33813968300819397,
0.039821598678827286,
-0.21480578184127808,
0.10130783170461655,
0.16031137108802795,
0.46226009726524353,
-0.48252829909324646,
0.7920895218849182,
-0.1807570904493332,
-0.16381891071796417,
-0.6442196369171143,
-0.25258028507232666,
0.21186314523220062,
0.3329641819000244,
0.3227737545967102,
0.08187650889158249,
0.37395358085632324,
-0.6855321526527405,
0.45103415846824646,
0.39574599266052246,
-0.6962049603462219,
-0.411188006401062,
0.7299779057502747,
0.5254461765289307,
-0.2245732545852661,
0.2953331172466278,
-0.002767564496025443,
-0.44234412908554077,
0.7086343765258789,
0.04690191149711609,
0.6492289900779724,
0.500637948513031,
0.267367959022522,
0.5178683400154114,
0.4299778342247009,
0.34047579765319824,
-0.022573478519916534,
-0.15782088041305542,
-0.926532506942749,
-0.10301145911216736,
-0.5952520370483398,
-0.5407558083534241,
-0.1248132660984993,
-0.5214674472808838,
0.523820698261261,
-0.4209620952606201,
-0.4304186701774597,
0.1282716989517212,
0.09992858022451401,
-0.4459777772426605,
-0.03434617817401886,
-0.03686465695500374,
0.6578125357627869,
-1.0324290990829468,
0.49118688702583313,
0.548651397228241,
-0.5193617939949036,
-0.3737822473049164,
-0.2558650076389313,
0.6838969588279724,
-0.6830851435661316,
1.0036861896514893,
-0.08123056590557098,
-0.7032450437545776,
-0.07586827874183655,
-0.5677974820137024,
-1.1134240627288818,
0.8566756248474121,
-0.17184481024742126,
-0.44297969341278076,
0.2604011297225952,
0.14159178733825684,
0.4439687132835388,
-0.21711465716362,
0.4804959297180176,
0.22411710023880005,
0.8014099597930908,
-0.05197904631495476,
-0.9183899760246277,
-0.13833945989608765,
-0.6531543135643005,
-0.10949630290269852,
0.24468180537223816,
-0.7506020069122314,
0.6807559132575989,
-0.11184526979923248,
-0.2585446536540985,
-0.4906536936759949,
0.5588607788085938,
0.12036930024623871,
0.32018783688545227,
0.5178367495536804,
0.004212032072246075,
0.38948506116867065,
0.04408326372504234,
0.5725260972976685,
-0.4369119107723236,
0.5393147468566895,
0.4111941456794739,
-0.05597367137670517,
0.7857182025909424,
0.8790987730026245,
-0.17977936565876007,
0.388135701417923,
0.5230903029441833,
0.1743117719888687,
0.16920344531536102,
-0.1250273436307907,
0.10928145051002502,
-0.1950860321521759,
-0.11355061084032059,
-0.2539850175380707,
0.43170127272605896,
0.3994482755661011,
-0.17733356356620789,
-0.03583239018917084,
-0.10325194150209427,
0.13723069429397583,
0.314280241727829,
-0.24906344711780548,
0.7777084112167358,
-0.017651258036494255,
-0.21777036786079407,
-0.08389179408550262,
-0.009208302944898605,
0.7361922264099121,
-0.7277658581733704,
-0.3430357873439789,
-0.07553104311227798,
0.0963480994105339,
-0.3811306357383728,
-1.3058096170425415,
0.7379660606384277,
-0.0045947604812681675,
-0.09932556003332138,
-0.5215014815330505,
0.9003047347068787,
-0.13634422421455383,
-0.4801196753978729,
0.355103462934494,
0.37833306193351746,
-0.026177430525422096,
0.15619757771492004,
-0.2578299641609192,
0.17873221635818481,
-0.47490134835243225,
-0.30522722005844116,
0.1969657987356186,
0.2217107117176056,
-0.21636486053466797,
0.6084434986114502,
0.7923930287361145,
-0.05174752324819565,
0.08624237775802612,
-0.22289150953292847,
0.9467529654502869,
-0.4236002266407013,
-0.6836973428726196,
-0.802924394607544,
0.5713047385215759,
-0.3362054228782654,
-0.6378816366195679,
0.9224330186843872,
0.20938122272491455,
1.005971908569336,
0.16511288285255432,
0.7664399147033691,
-0.20907683670520782,
0.3078950345516205,
0.016597799956798553,
0.9679948687553406,
-0.7969363331794739,
0.09224418550729752,
-0.4044065773487091,
-0.44560950994491577,
-0.2787136435508728,
0.7355056405067444,
-0.4154737889766693,
0.10313387215137482,
0.1729515939950943,
0.6826626658439636,
-0.15301042795181274,
-0.17532280087471008,
0.47587519884109497,
0.10966748744249344,
0.34085211157798767,
-0.134779691696167,
0.7634953856468201,
-0.14830824732780457,
0.6345946192741394,
-0.07051123678684235,
-0.5590865612030029,
-0.5542963147163391,
-0.9133905172348022,
-0.6493401527404785,
-0.961138129234314,
-0.12670691311359406,
-0.5651177167892456,
0.17485594749450684,
1.309774398803711,
0.8029004335403442,
-0.5653985738754272,
-0.5844178795814514,
-0.03123563714325428,
0.0697367787361145,
-0.15880833566188812,
-0.39973169565200806,
-0.23879268765449524,
-0.17376062273979187,
-0.6316207051277161,
-0.10252325981855392,
0.5437204241752625,
-0.2773391306400299,
-0.6073524355888367,
-0.018635446205735207,
-0.09687640517950058,
0.5335311889648438,
0.7838869690895081,
0.3453400731086731,
-0.47665226459503174,
-0.5732007622718811,
0.4037330448627472,
-0.25510847568511963,
0.0708167627453804,
0.7209304571151733,
-0.4349706172943115,
0.5464675426483154,
0.6430127024650574,
0.2588535249233246,
0.4387187957763672,
-0.23954187333583832,
0.5544293522834778,
-0.48246559500694275,
-0.10560872405767441,
0.16107434034347534,
0.0172857865691185,
0.04354123771190643,
-0.45712584257125854,
0.34891754388809204,
0.5230972766876221,
-0.5332095623016357,
-0.447095662355423,
0.7369495034217834,
-0.9147371053695679,
-0.2613218128681183,
1.3432008028030396,
0.3090405762195587,
-0.08559898287057877,
-0.3116447925567627,
-0.09380916506052017,
0.1923828274011612,
-0.5994575619697571,
1.1481589078903198,
0.7019404172897339,
-0.044734444469213486,
-0.6277264952659607,
-0.4686056673526764,
0.6410917639732361,
-0.11852066218852997,
-0.7563926577568054,
-0.13233575224876404,
0.5735377669334412,
0.3820439577102661,
0.2448912113904953,
0.8137009143829346,
-0.3231416344642639,
0.38177022337913513,
-0.18811550736427307,
-0.05279995873570442,
-0.08385394513607025,
-0.0989466980099678,
-0.1601828783750534,
0.324314147233963,
0.11366336047649384,
0.10373936593532562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02552v1 | RLHF Can Speak Many Languages: Unlocking Multilingual Preference Optimization for LLMs | 2024-07-02T17:42:30 | 2024-07-02T17:42:30 | John Dang, Arash Ahmadian, Kelly Marchisio, Julia Kreutzer, Ahmet Üstün, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Preference optimization techniques have become a standard final stage for
training state-of-art large language models (LLMs). However, despite widespread
adoption, the vast majority of work to-date has focused on first-class citizen
languages like English and Chinese. This captures a small fraction of the
languages in the world, but also makes it unclear which aspects of current
state-of-the-art research transfer to a multilingual setting. In this work, we
perform an exhaustive study to achieve a new state-of-the-art in aligning
multilingual LLMs. We introduce a novel, scalable method for generating
high-quality multilingual feedback data to balance data coverage. We establish
the benefits of cross-lingual transfer and increased dataset size in preference
training. Our preference-trained model achieves a 54.4% win-rate against Aya 23
8B, the current state-of-the-art multilingual LLM in its parameter class, and a
69.5% win-rate or higher against widely used models like Gemma-1.1-7B-it,
Llama-3-8B-Instruct, Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.3. As a result of our study, we
expand the frontier of alignment techniques to 23 languages covering half of
the world's population. | [
-0.4664311707019806,
-0.5068288445472717,
0.21291492879390717,
0.432174414396286,
-0.11832620948553085,
0.0913616418838501,
-0.585703432559967,
-0.5925224423408508,
0.329086035490036,
0.4225488603115082,
-0.6061345934867859,
-0.3161253035068512,
-0.412101149559021,
0.07708872109651566,
0.28175532817840576,
0.8981694579124451,
-0.30865466594696045,
0.5359413623809814,
-0.03280610963702202,
-0.5336359739303589,
-0.27169159054756165,
-0.8345080614089966,
-0.43080082535743713,
-0.7455263733863831,
0.7786696553230286,
0.6871587038040161,
0.7171253561973572,
0.692048192024231,
0.5173612833023071,
0.17448696494102478,
0.14625222980976105,
0.45044395327568054,
-0.5828638672828674,
0.15136808156967163,
0.09241296350955963,
-0.3192605674266815,
-0.509663462638855,
-0.14251188933849335,
0.7150744795799255,
0.601222574710846,
-0.39572224020957947,
0.2385088950395584,
-0.0968269482254982,
0.9534676671028137,
-0.6104228496551514,
0.1233804002404213,
-0.5016422867774963,
0.3900231719017029,
-0.22261542081832886,
-0.28894802927970886,
-0.4361528158187866,
-0.4234559237957001,
0.060600172728300095,
-0.7719586491584778,
-0.25788769125938416,
0.20877982676029205,
0.7959305644035339,
0.15419118106365204,
-0.48542648553848267,
-0.03787697106599808,
-0.4444405138492584,
0.9733066558837891,
-0.5676422119140625,
0.761297881603241,
0.24298471212387085,
0.30616095662117004,
-0.05041035637259483,
0.026675431057810783,
-0.3787755072116852,
-0.10730475932359695,
-0.05229297652840614,
0.08331359177827835,
0.2101186364889145,
-0.06783805787563324,
-0.06207110732793808,
0.27967190742492676,
-0.6829977035522461,
0.323198139667511,
0.05363466963171959,
-0.3898274302482605,
0.7900246381759644,
-0.03713172674179077,
0.26766538619995117,
0.09412491321563721,
-0.46371400356292725,
-0.1339486837387085,
-0.8597416281700134,
0.14009395241737366,
0.5770424604415894,
0.630577802658081,
-0.28265324234962463,
0.5768665075302124,
-0.13182328641414642,
0.8866043090820312,
0.1568441241979599,
-0.6889509558677673,
0.20658349990844727,
-0.477115273475647,
-0.008989563211798668,
0.16485509276390076,
0.859260618686676,
0.5704591870307922,
0.47074899077415466,
-0.020161844789981842,
-0.17003442347049713,
-0.22104428708553314,
-0.12030293047428131,
-0.7318603992462158,
0.2578796148300171,
0.10151740163564682,
-0.43580684065818787,
-0.10740068554878235,
-0.22967858612537384,
-0.7109441161155701,
-0.39855849742889404,
-0.38340073823928833,
0.09872279316186905,
-0.0297552477568388,
-0.5975801348686218,
0.33580562472343445,
0.3023826777935028,
0.5019888877868652,
0.10693924874067307,
-1.3004357814788818,
-0.08617588877677917,
0.48099374771118164,
0.5474327206611633,
-0.5439584255218506,
-0.7216078042984009,
-0.4605652689933777,
0.10493308305740356,
-0.46023139357566833,
0.6352291703224182,
-0.3992229402065277,
-0.4379403293132782,
0.27266889810562134,
-0.03486998751759529,
-0.08663184195756912,
-0.4522535800933838,
0.5532006621360779,
-0.6351513862609863,
0.21606387197971344,
-0.4161432683467865,
-0.40284860134124756,
-0.09041386097669601,
0.47879868745803833,
-0.6369829773902893,
1.1416141986846924,
-0.04225373640656471,
-0.7055561542510986,
0.4430887699127197,
-0.30543041229248047,
-0.47717443108558655,
-0.2169867753982544,
-0.1641293466091156,
-0.49821871519088745,
-0.2528231143951416,
0.4094676375389099,
0.3166845440864563,
-0.2721141278743744,
0.42610523104667664,
-0.575454592704773,
-0.1113087609410286,
0.2449217140674591,
-0.43546393513679504,
0.6908801794052124,
0.24319599568843842,
-0.21175804734230042,
0.3435624837875366,
-0.4514171779155731,
0.06181376799941063,
0.011306867003440857,
-0.5940524935722351,
-0.10102775692939758,
-0.26225745677948,
0.2997449040412903,
0.31248214840888977,
0.5015785098075867,
-0.5684670209884644,
0.17872601747512817,
-0.3241744935512543,
0.21837235987186432,
0.6844121217727661,
-0.28351855278015137,
0.5251747965812683,
-0.36579465866088867,
0.807140052318573,
-0.12072068452835083,
0.2286737710237503,
0.02270832657814026,
-0.1572469174861908,
-0.6955671906471252,
-0.09297719597816467,
0.15982402861118317,
0.5439820885658264,
-0.5459792017936707,
0.20790237188339233,
-0.3765532672405243,
-0.3373323082923889,
-0.7810980081558228,
0.34191015362739563,
0.3925284147262573,
0.3811717927455902,
0.2603590786457062,
0.09454816579818726,
-0.44471436738967896,
-1.252443790435791,
-0.19961383938789368,
-0.19965019822120667,
0.6549630165100098,
0.420245498418808,
-0.0822729840874672,
-0.046005114912986755,
0.7622017860412598,
-0.4102713167667389,
-0.21654938161373138,
-0.469640851020813,
-0.5430223941802979,
0.25143131613731384,
0.370352566242218,
0.6461623311042786,
-0.8605760335922241,
-0.8454906344413757,
0.5619352459907532,
-0.7159643173217773,
0.03352949023246765,
0.1127113625407219,
-0.37060117721557617,
0.5716853737831116,
0.2447187602519989,
-0.3703250288963318,
-0.177559033036232,
0.9876735210418701,
0.04008568078279495,
0.4347948729991913,
-0.26071885228157043,
0.26276999711990356,
-1.0169236660003662,
-0.051905471831560135,
0.03665478900074959,
-0.2169017642736435,
-0.4860959053039551,
0.271729975938797,
0.36583712697029114,
-0.0013074621092528105,
-0.6526849269866943,
0.9468852281570435,
-0.6089889407157898,
-0.04011959582567215,
-0.14662495255470276,
0.1623735874891281,
-0.12877871096134186,
0.6873430609703064,
0.3184901177883148,
0.8768973350524902,
0.5892713069915771,
-0.4598895013332367,
0.40920504927635193,
0.10566581785678864,
-0.20830221474170685,
0.5367573499679565,
-0.2542822062969208,
0.0655917227268219,
-0.09773430228233337,
0.1167188510298729,
-0.7897307276725769,
-0.24743840098381042,
0.12108317017555237,
-0.31999585032463074,
0.4836105406284332,
-0.1486782431602478,
-0.18188998103141785,
-0.13571253418922424,
-0.34087935090065,
0.5988878011703491,
0.033840395510196686,
-0.8416825532913208,
0.5970850586891174,
0.6945397853851318,
-0.08677484095096588,
-1.1744143962860107,
-0.6147227883338928,
-0.07792635262012482,
-0.4699997007846832,
-0.639545202255249,
0.15672720968723297,
-0.24688182771205902,
-0.14313024282455444,
-0.35046136379241943,
-0.059760089963674545,
0.050548870116472244,
-0.02532787062227726,
-0.11169803887605667,
0.4210696220397949,
-0.2580088973045349,
-0.05729302763938904,
-0.03556961938738823,
-0.24290773272514343,
-0.21660855412483215,
-0.4136858582496643,
0.4630975127220154,
-0.20241406559944153,
-0.49689269065856934,
-0.16361376643180847,
0.4510921835899353,
0.6533672213554382,
-0.43751657009124756,
0.48494940996170044,
0.7335842251777649,
-0.1524723917245865,
-0.19520963728427887,
-0.6423619985580444,
-0.011676060035824776,
-0.42125341296195984,
0.609607458114624,
-0.3939284086227417,
-1.0494592189788818,
0.44021210074424744,
0.23979060351848602,
0.35663655400276184,
0.18243151903152466,
0.6883753538131714,
0.24114103615283966,
1.0250834226608276,
0.8685082793235779,
-0.5770343542098999,
0.4281877875328064,
0.16810384392738342,
0.2332787811756134,
-0.5083013772964478,
-0.17708012461662292,
-0.40786996483802795,
-0.24014990031719208,
-0.8582046627998352,
-0.2631847560405731,
0.5298541188240051,
-0.022718317806720734,
-0.2179698497056961,
0.14723797142505646,
-0.22975128889083862,
0.4908319413661957,
0.375234991312027,
-0.08315981924533844,
0.3337803781032562,
0.2437480241060257,
-0.14490574598312378,
-0.33180907368659973,
-0.8334152102470398,
-0.25481268763542175,
1.22169828414917,
0.3178379237651825,
0.9390892386436462,
0.380555123090744,
0.7673980593681335,
-0.04807455837726593,
0.40320923924446106,
-1.0104366540908813,
0.23707330226898193,
-0.24813871085643768,
-0.5661298036575317,
-0.5447781682014465,
-0.32688698172569275,
-0.8124793171882629,
0.6017084121704102,
-0.19089771807193756,
-0.3535464107990265,
0.055258817970752716,
0.2739090919494629,
-0.1169610545039177,
0.2944560647010803,
-0.611787736415863,
0.7707671523094177,
-0.6511543989181519,
-0.5117188692092896,
-0.21309080719947815,
-0.6589020490646362,
0.5153098106384277,
-0.17939983308315277,
0.46446263790130615,
-0.25456878542900085,
0.10013020038604736,
0.6561937928199768,
-0.05409141257405281,
0.6021093726158142,
-0.10673795640468597,
-0.557485818862915,
-0.1917480081319809,
-0.19543518126010895,
0.34735167026519775,
0.17823971807956696,
-0.33479219675064087,
0.17104801535606384,
-0.01929289475083351,
-0.44588494300842285,
-0.451401025056839,
0.7857384085655212,
-0.9442881941795349,
-0.6311951875686646,
-0.35140085220336914,
-0.6980376839637756,
-0.49421489238739014,
0.36572518944740295,
0.15264050662517548,
0.13218212127685547,
-0.2856341004371643,
-0.05362030863761902,
0.6185546517372131,
-0.1797199249267578,
0.4445844888687134,
0.7165322303771973,
-0.6058761477470398,
-0.6885662078857422,
1.0643706321716309,
-0.030761009082198143,
0.46157148480415344,
0.6118016839027405,
0.33534443378448486,
-0.5686273574829102,
-0.3057423532009125,
-0.9453771114349365,
0.5130888223648071,
-0.7464067339897156,
-0.10533181577920914,
-0.48231643438339233,
-0.051684215664863586,
-0.3785596489906311,
-0.1236083060503006,
-0.414224237203598,
-0.3347589373588562,
0.10409499704837799,
-0.11623648554086685,
0.10970286279916763,
0.5131258964538574,
-0.032805174589157104,
0.09737032651901245,
-0.764980137348175,
0.21494022011756897,
0.2952039837837219,
0.3473409116268158,
-0.00729622645303607,
-0.43892520666122437,
-0.5298499464988708,
0.08825261890888214,
-0.056643515825271606,
-0.7222825288772583,
0.43129581212997437,
0.20790213346481323,
0.8985111117362976,
0.2578008472919464,
-0.05702194944024086,
0.7913969159126282,
-0.3858504593372345,
0.5537902116775513,
0.14909523725509644,
-0.7136229276657104,
0.10881002247333527,
-0.25781673192977905,
0.12512582540512085,
0.5965381264686584,
0.45182251930236816,
-0.8738909363746643,
-0.051619887351989746,
-0.14768607914447784,
-0.6756776571273804,
0.7428404092788696,
-0.42126575112342834,
0.06485853344202042,
0.32836273312568665,
0.2669999301433563,
0.22532354295253754,
0.26358717679977417,
-0.9986951351165771,
-0.6481333374977112,
-0.12789103388786316,
-0.1087593287229538,
-0.2606064975261688,
-0.22008086740970612,
-0.2855077087879181,
-0.10219380259513855,
0.8966768980026245,
-0.4874271750450134,
-0.24254170060157776,
-0.0692882165312767,
-0.15720108151435852,
-0.3446364402770996,
0.3901599645614624,
0.7336467504501343,
0.655992865562439,
-0.11440141499042511,
0.06898636370897293,
0.11571156978607178,
-0.3564784526824951,
0.3673211932182312,
0.05025842785835266,
-0.1964361071586609,
-0.14987096190452576,
0.33279359340667725,
0.8271641135215759,
0.015663975849747658,
-0.5367872714996338,
0.2958112359046936,
-0.07656576484441757,
-0.17943520843982697,
-0.17108875513076782,
-0.22672507166862488,
0.2090016007423401,
-0.03778395429253578,
0.11254506558179855,
-0.25976040959358215,
-0.24442993104457855,
-0.22865723073482513,
0.030295774340629578,
0.7227647304534912,
-0.39420822262763977,
-0.16988301277160645,
0.3220737874507904,
0.22777463495731354,
-0.07652479410171509,
0.24283255636692047,
0.022454610094428062,
-0.562649130821228,
0.4139561951160431,
0.6753865480422974,
0.6671172380447388,
-0.3015439808368683,
0.19031181931495667,
0.5301458835601807,
0.2653295695781708,
-0.2051106095314026,
0.33936285972595215,
0.03137859329581261,
-1.211209774017334,
-0.4011967182159424,
-0.7680485844612122,
-0.5591428875923157,
-0.051964301615953445,
-0.8000826239585876,
0.2697661817073822,
-0.04503852128982544,
-0.0914878100156784,
-0.10567277669906616,
0.20194494724273682,
-0.3979552090167999,
-0.04924273490905762,
0.13095733523368835,
0.6439173221588135,
-0.8348179459571838,
0.9717148542404175,
0.9053972363471985,
-0.030962225049734116,
-0.9145544171333313,
-0.14866624772548676,
0.20563112199306488,
-1.2973824739456177,
0.5403452515602112,
0.038996439427137375,
-0.3582940995693207,
-0.07784946262836456,
-0.16934126615524292,
-1.0535166263580322,
0.8149663209915161,
0.7078830003738403,
-0.5605242848396301,
0.17996175587177277,
0.1770165115594864,
0.2665932774543762,
-0.5079720616340637,
0.125890851020813,
0.5066473484039307,
0.8030009269714355,
-0.16245552897453308,
-1.0901657342910767,
-0.2713415324687958,
-0.1912829577922821,
-0.08275008201599121,
0.34937921166419983,
-0.9704537987709045,
0.5811101198196411,
-0.4054044485092163,
0.08876068890094757,
-0.21154960989952087,
0.6310862898826599,
0.5775597095489502,
-0.06300359219312668,
0.4617375433444977,
0.3459379971027374,
0.7299801707267761,
0.12959812581539154,
0.8113040328025818,
-0.7384691834449768,
0.4422435164451599,
0.9799584746360779,
-0.5716419816017151,
0.8287792801856995,
0.7846466898918152,
-0.23920121788978577,
0.1324300616979599,
0.9205232858657837,
0.2609594166278839,
0.35527825355529785,
0.023250620812177658,
-0.18041865527629852,
-0.522699773311615,
-0.5125319957733154,
-0.4729728400707245,
0.4300210773944855,
0.15149952471256256,
0.04099982976913452,
-0.09202155470848083,
-0.011295943520963192,
0.23161457479000092,
0.18574094772338867,
-0.08353099972009659,
0.7027412056922913,
-0.0013391313841566443,
-0.9879642128944397,
0.7749279737472534,
0.11086105555295944,
1.0134106874465942,
-0.8479284644126892,
0.20662696659564972,
-0.5104951858520508,
0.21519502997398376,
-0.3485160171985626,
-0.7595289945602417,
-0.01139777060598135,
-0.21361248195171356,
-0.2836103141307831,
-0.48378512263298035,
0.34266194701194763,
-0.9909945726394653,
-0.5097877979278564,
0.6262239217758179,
0.6355389356613159,
-0.07227105647325516,
0.3704003095626831,
-0.6087532639503479,
0.15445636212825775,
0.32888925075531006,
-0.18295249342918396,
0.5911445617675781,
0.18760642409324646,
-0.1496145874261856,
0.7440268397331238,
0.5713338255882263,
0.5279747247695923,
-0.009891274385154247,
0.3371325135231018,
0.49653446674346924,
-0.44992008805274963,
-0.5048660039901733,
-0.7844666242599487,
0.04406186193227768,
0.22228725254535675,
-0.4771140515804291,
0.8291424512863159,
0.6629123091697693,
1.0107123851776123,
0.02404606342315674,
0.8407639861106873,
0.3797626495361328,
0.30412811040878296,
-0.6480087041854858,
0.5614744424819946,
-0.8072758913040161,
0.06523935496807098,
-0.054120294749736786,
-0.8668323159217834,
-0.20641878247261047,
0.41114485263824463,
0.0100434310734272,
0.024721838533878326,
0.5643031597137451,
0.9699588418006897,
0.013551485724747181,
-0.1505381166934967,
0.4015309810638428,
-0.31561464071273804,
0.3494518995285034,
0.587184488773346,
0.6879485249519348,
-0.10692103207111359,
0.4518693685531616,
-0.47674012184143066,
-0.20379002392292023,
0.0006138189346529543,
-0.9623916149139404,
-0.6751955151557922,
-0.3734670579433441,
-0.10818666219711304,
-0.20919181406497955,
-0.06639547646045685,
1.2039397954940796,
0.8373294472694397,
-0.8009170293807983,
-0.9108932614326477,
0.4648738503456116,
0.3338276445865631,
-0.20784883201122284,
-0.14160846173763275,
0.38261139392852783,
-0.4478072226047516,
-0.7946553230285645,
0.38843050599098206,
0.3233175575733185,
0.09063871949911118,
-0.5557390451431274,
-0.4929715394973755,
-0.28471851348876953,
-0.29464390873908997,
0.5455352663993835,
0.28704869747161865,
-0.8979966640472412,
-0.07650256901979446,
0.4166821837425232,
-0.2709423899650574,
0.22428756952285767,
0.8826808929443359,
-0.19620847702026367,
0.483310341835022,
0.3060987591743469,
0.8787432909011841,
0.367215633392334,
-0.029738200828433037,
0.8221701979637146,
-0.6406179666519165,
0.23286782205104828,
-0.05594005808234215,
0.5336061120033264,
0.5718602538108826,
-0.478194922208786,
0.4182332754135132,
0.020979102700948715,
-0.5564302206039429,
-0.7091700434684753,
0.3390030860900879,
-0.9460871815681458,
-0.033593762665987015,
1.3351831436157227,
-0.029649091884493828,
-0.008173373527824879,
0.05296650901436806,
-0.22027286887168884,
0.11079524457454681,
-0.502696692943573,
0.46299561858177185,
0.951303243637085,
-0.2435886412858963,
-0.17995771765708923,
-0.33882710337638855,
0.6482087969779968,
0.7695271372795105,
-0.7025766968727112,
0.4318827986717224,
0.4507203996181488,
0.25024157762527466,
0.06363862752914429,
0.8373242020606995,
-0.1128920242190361,
0.1706407368183136,
-0.5483115911483765,
0.2240624874830246,
0.04252641648054123,
-0.30356714129447937,
-0.5343765020370483,
0.08035580813884735,
0.4844920039176941,
0.011805898509919643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02448v1 | Ensemble of pre-trained language models and data augmentation for hate speech detection from Arabic tweets | 2024-07-02T17:26:26 | 2024-07-02T17:26:26 | Kheir Eddine Daouadi, Yaakoub Boualleg, Kheir Eddine Haouaouchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Today, hate speech classification from Arabic tweets has drawn the attention
of several researchers. Many systems and techniques have been developed to
resolve this classification task. Nevertheless, two of the major challenges
faced in this context are the limited performance and the problem of imbalanced
data. In this study, we propose a novel approach that leverages ensemble
learning and semi-supervised learning based on previously manually labeled. We
conducted experiments on a benchmark dataset by classifying Arabic tweets into
5 distinct classes: non-hate, general hate, racial, religious, or sexism.
Experimental results show that: (1) ensemble learning based on pre-trained
language models outperforms existing related works; (2) Our proposed data
augmentation improves the accuracy results of hate speech detection from Arabic
tweets and outperforms existing related works. Our main contribution is the
achievement of encouraging results in Arabic hate speech detection. | [
-0.3724077641963959,
-0.7634068727493286,
0.07810759544372559,
-0.0003595368470996618,
-0.2902311384677887,
0.7150958776473999,
-0.18874967098236084,
-0.7175276875495911,
0.40463531017303467,
0.42315229773521423,
-0.2887839674949646,
-0.6800362467765808,
-0.8235819935798645,
0.06784746050834656,
-0.7719717025756836,
1.1660748720169067,
0.11920532584190369,
0.16952520608901978,
0.27697086334228516,
-0.35893872380256653,
-0.07180440425872803,
-0.4521653354167938,
-0.4707038998603821,
-0.012172755785286427,
0.4235795736312866,
0.4298189580440521,
0.6984479427337646,
0.16352392733097076,
0.15806321799755096,
0.34902307391166687,
0.32881662249565125,
0.21468579769134521,
-0.30728086829185486,
0.02858920395374298,
-0.005195061210542917,
-0.15860943496227264,
-0.026778921484947205,
-0.019361883401870728,
0.7211024165153503,
0.44063860177993774,
-0.13289965689182281,
0.085349440574646,
0.11184003949165344,
0.1420857459306717,
-0.6797329187393188,
-0.33909255266189575,
-0.7030957937240601,
0.09786403179168701,
-0.48621368408203125,
-0.0351288840174675,
-0.16658122837543488,
-0.4543851315975189,
0.034419167786836624,
-0.17848724126815796,
0.2044837325811386,
0.19277304410934448,
0.33497264981269836,
0.14560742676258087,
-0.3136887848377228,
-0.20070458948612213,
-0.7910412549972534,
0.9683439135551453,
-0.662704586982727,
0.15897823870182037,
0.1684616655111313,
0.2744910717010498,
0.12962645292282104,
-0.4111707806587219,
-0.6653547286987305,
-0.20661941170692444,
-0.023171527311205864,
-0.018631044775247574,
-0.616512656211853,
-0.02017238363623619,
-0.07709299027919769,
0.18810191750526428,
-0.5514330863952637,
0.5225974321365356,
-0.4088006019592285,
-0.5321115851402283,
0.8328741192817688,
-0.23129509389400482,
0.6186691522598267,
0.2775103449821472,
-0.2907337248325348,
0.023207316175103188,
-0.3021562099456787,
-0.3483313322067261,
0.5267963409423828,
0.40883004665374756,
-0.15438532829284668,
0.4758576452732086,
-0.14061196148395538,
0.6367281079292297,
-0.06660337746143341,
-0.053962405771017075,
0.5240416526794434,
0.2477957308292389,
-0.03751697763800621,
0.514171302318573,
0.7369571924209595,
0.1538325548171997,
0.4457613229751587,
-0.4778803288936615,
-0.3098120391368866,
0.49900779128074646,
0.3456595242023468,
-0.6462795734405518,
-0.2523052990436554,
0.19401012361049652,
-0.2783887982368469,
-0.7466446757316589,
-0.337249755859375,
-0.8284037709236145,
-0.5212037563323975,
-0.0708656907081604,
0.48302310705184937,
-0.2918756902217865,
-0.422758549451828,
-0.40206021070480347,
-0.09686292707920074,
-0.2081599086523056,
0.4914565980434418,
-0.6351854205131531,
0.21847869455814362,
0.23819352686405182,
0.7696132659912109,
-0.454274982213974,
-0.09293810278177261,
-0.5606977343559265,
0.006595988757908344,
-0.28312554955482483,
0.7603728175163269,
-1.0629377365112305,
-0.2530613839626312,
0.2927674353122711,
-0.6002125144004822,
0.2946496307849884,
-0.6639378070831299,
0.901992678642273,
-0.6433416604995728,
0.13280808925628662,
0.4053525924682617,
-0.6035613417625427,
-0.10490410774946213,
0.1311919242143631,
-0.433487206697464,
0.8765391707420349,
0.18696849048137665,
-0.7795936465263367,
0.39517271518707275,
-0.44961532950401306,
-0.6986026763916016,
0.23619720339775085,
-0.04905082285404205,
-0.752819299697876,
0.15098801255226135,
0.23942680656909943,
0.25552114844322205,
-0.024686994031071663,
0.1280316263437271,
-0.6683489084243774,
-0.18188387155532837,
0.09253091365098953,
-0.28949806094169617,
0.711444079875946,
0.5342304110527039,
-0.3802972435951233,
0.20920917391777039,
-0.7101547122001648,
0.025978781282901764,
0.05275654047727585,
-0.025875352323055267,
-0.47907716035842896,
-0.059923071414232254,
0.5064276456832886,
0.32411783933639526,
-0.017322715371847153,
-0.7913042902946472,
-0.09603232145309448,
-0.3790208101272583,
0.142696350812912,
0.8663936257362366,
-0.22063229978084564,
0.36198151111602783,
-0.41052621603012085,
0.5269274115562439,
0.33905863761901855,
-0.12332118302583694,
0.4110303223133087,
-0.24473416805267334,
-0.49739158153533936,
-0.23696745932102203,
0.14164261519908905,
0.510453999042511,
-0.82317715883255,
0.42658665776252747,
0.009232960641384125,
-0.6369037628173828,
-0.5199170708656311,
0.04280455783009529,
0.25557297468185425,
0.4809703528881073,
0.6348527073860168,
-0.00981964636594057,
-0.9886490702629089,
-0.8546755909919739,
-0.6649954915046692,
-0.28697341680526733,
0.17778244614601135,
0.051141656935214996,
0.37131404876708984,
-0.12573549151420593,
0.7891020178794861,
-0.08456277847290039,
-0.3037748336791992,
-0.2165166139602661,
0.5963979959487915,
-0.31396788358688354,
0.441654235124588,
0.6966049671173096,
-1.0040576457977295,
-0.6624574065208435,
-0.09986524283885956,
-0.26805850863456726,
-0.5015671849250793,
0.4243704378604889,
0.1605500876903534,
0.34819838404655457,
0.1389337182044983,
0.13110512495040894,
0.5716757774353027,
0.4533555209636688,
-0.0685788244009018,
0.5482497811317444,
0.4502412676811218,
0.2852453291416168,
-1.176964521408081,
-0.516481339931488,
0.156260147690773,
-0.275858074426651,
-0.9857854247093201,
-0.4299704432487488,
-0.21393197774887085,
0.03511622175574303,
-0.5413556694984436,
0.49567103385925293,
-0.10309550911188126,
0.15626884996891022,
-0.5929723381996155,
-0.2828882038593292,
-0.6737147569656372,
0.27435824275016785,
0.2625470459461212,
0.6832871437072754,
0.5412451028823853,
-0.6032533049583435,
0.43105068802833557,
0.036117300391197205,
-0.5288255214691162,
0.432567298412323,
-0.22880248725414276,
0.14200612902641296,
-0.17349325120449066,
0.1363472044467926,
-1.1256227493286133,
-0.20793738961219788,
0.3109374940395355,
-0.6100757718086243,
0.06021791696548462,
-0.2059950977563858,
-0.5570420622825623,
-0.35051414370536804,
-0.18981625139713287,
0.6117275357246399,
0.49816104769706726,
-0.4840954840183258,
0.661260187625885,
0.8958715200424194,
-0.08659476041793823,
-0.5509403944015503,
-0.5709457397460938,
0.04318879172205925,
-0.5510962009429932,
-0.4119027853012085,
0.48238784074783325,
0.2825976312160492,
-0.30036982893943787,
-0.009822885505855083,
-0.07315085083246231,
-0.328274130821228,
0.10040303319692612,
0.17330223321914673,
0.11291683465242386,
0.03800211846828461,
0.35592904686927795,
0.16415277123451233,
0.39684244990348816,
-0.11043602228164673,
-0.6430774927139282,
0.6546033620834351,
0.07594846934080124,
-0.012231502681970596,
-0.39520153403282166,
0.4342593550682068,
0.387992262840271,
-0.3928911089897156,
0.8886778354644775,
1.0117253065109253,
-0.5511863827705383,
-0.3236487805843353,
-0.7238038182258606,
-0.15654850006103516,
-0.4100973308086395,
0.37121471762657166,
0.09181796759366989,
-1.2172428369522095,
0.3268205225467682,
-0.028145689517259598,
0.08688400685787201,
0.4516924023628235,
0.6661452054977417,
-0.2410905659198761,
1.1718038320541382,
0.4026544690132141,
-0.6420560479164124,
0.7043322920799255,
0.13699094951152802,
0.2008371353149414,
-0.0020970716141164303,
0.04542602598667145,
-0.7776620388031006,
-0.427541583776474,
-0.8758862614631653,
-0.18136924505233765,
0.6037641167640686,
-0.34434884786605835,
-0.29265597462654114,
-0.035053033381700516,
-0.3415035307407379,
0.38743525743484497,
0.2517576813697815,
0.0463368259370327,
-0.004210779443383217,
0.6050142645835876,
0.22678983211517334,
-0.009548351168632507,
-0.41225844621658325,
-0.38720911741256714,
1.1343358755111694,
0.09772760421037674,
0.7482489347457886,
0.39444515109062195,
0.8694943785667419,
0.9001941084861755,
0.5429595708847046,
-0.42064163088798523,
0.2647381126880646,
-0.1240815594792366,
-0.7528796195983887,
-0.28035837411880493,
-0.5412390828132629,
-0.6688202023506165,
0.14829209446907043,
-0.3066462576389313,
-0.8933833241462708,
-0.2247658371925354,
0.2527526021003723,
-0.3103780448436737,
0.49465879797935486,
-0.6331619024276733,
0.5586671829223633,
-0.24228982627391815,
-0.4154170751571655,
-0.43739014863967896,
-0.4856971204280853,
0.4230998158454895,
-0.270158052444458,
0.5451563596725464,
0.04485107585787773,
-0.09918222576379776,
1.1713855266571045,
-0.45951369404792786,
0.8460245728492737,
-0.3089112639427185,
-0.10598304867744446,
0.3238708972930908,
-0.19253835082054138,
0.5728083252906799,
-0.44285354018211365,
-0.03645540401339531,
0.1145380437374115,
-0.28487512469291687,
-0.6064342260360718,
-0.4209565818309784,
0.5713912844657898,
-0.8154296875,
-0.351274698972702,
-0.5051212906837463,
-0.5735228657722473,
-0.386658251285553,
0.2512513995170593,
0.1506018042564392,
0.3038371205329895,
-0.32701289653778076,
-0.06413380056619644,
0.3353370726108551,
-0.11875882744789124,
0.3453702926635742,
0.5129348039627075,
-0.33310359716415405,
-0.3371065855026245,
0.9693454504013062,
0.25699397921562195,
0.05310120806097984,
0.2821080982685089,
0.03523460403084755,
-0.48426005244255066,
-0.8778539896011353,
-0.3739694356918335,
-0.2440110594034195,
-0.2050011307001114,
-0.09420333057641983,
-0.9003428220748901,
-0.1342308223247528,
-0.7211282253265381,
0.0811968520283699,
-0.1841718703508377,
-0.31201332807540894,
-0.2006322145462036,
0.05747675150632858,
0.23747164011001587,
0.6926733255386353,
-0.21498993039131165,
0.6369509100914001,
-0.850702166557312,
0.3470897674560547,
0.15761138498783112,
0.016484186053276062,
-0.0412137433886528,
-0.7987997531890869,
-0.3883914053440094,
0.28994226455688477,
-0.36793333292007446,
-1.024341344833374,
0.5207997560501099,
0.022164994850754738,
0.2862197458744049,
0.4871752858161926,
0.4304444491863251,
0.5598155856132507,
-0.4464687407016754,
0.4301340579986572,
0.113876573741436,
-0.6680943965911865,
0.5597389340400696,
-0.31633761525154114,
-0.08226516097784042,
0.36528292298316956,
0.4763142764568329,
-0.27403587102890015,
-0.6386914253234863,
-0.8483536243438721,
-0.4539774954319,
0.9141849875450134,
0.549390971660614,
0.16591520607471466,
0.17320232093334198,
-0.23722213506698608,
0.03435849770903587,
0.33946508169174194,
-0.4528830945491791,
-0.48407676815986633,
-0.1610049605369568,
-0.33650243282318115,
-0.19289414584636688,
-0.2380603402853012,
-0.03147082403302193,
-0.35290685296058655,
0.8168262243270874,
0.2456294447183609,
0.16728641092777252,
-0.340825617313385,
-0.5100914835929871,
-0.13444744050502777,
0.38486427068710327,
0.5509105920791626,
0.38735947012901306,
-0.214796781539917,
0.07688377797603607,
0.3038438558578491,
-0.3699025809764862,
0.3101915121078491,
0.3489345908164978,
-0.14368797838687897,
0.08762294054031372,
0.3705306351184845,
0.7894209623336792,
-0.33131057024002075,
-0.5347898006439209,
0.33492159843444824,
0.19807732105255127,
-0.09322497993707657,
-0.43995240330696106,
0.032759323716163635,
-0.318571001291275,
0.1638292670249939,
0.6292746067047119,
0.2830876410007477,
0.27313530445098877,
-0.4865706264972687,
0.5291444063186646,
0.46971043944358826,
-0.22593015432357788,
-0.20847533643245697,
0.33129429817199707,
0.19270817935466766,
-0.3115919828414917,
0.24652893841266632,
-0.21665716171264648,
-1.014769434928894,
0.45694923400878906,
0.5928872227668762,
0.6738287210464478,
-0.7345399856567383,
0.515752911567688,
0.2343454509973526,
0.21842525899410248,
0.3906319737434387,
0.10319946706295013,
-0.3579358160495758,
-1.1691187620162964,
-0.2496471256017685,
-0.7411319613456726,
-0.3205438554286957,
0.34895631670951843,
-0.4311985969543457,
0.19838598370552063,
-0.6025640964508057,
0.07064058631658554,
0.28646665811538696,
0.08434410393238068,
-0.39539146423339844,
0.4454886019229889,
0.586402416229248,
0.5030141472816467,
-1.2192115783691406,
0.8630498647689819,
0.81779545545578,
-0.12753057479858398,
-0.6430361866950989,
0.17839659750461578,
0.12504693865776062,
-0.9921635985374451,
0.4671832025051117,
0.2868020236492157,
-0.2691323161125183,
0.37208959460258484,
-0.7357199192047119,
-0.5418629050254822,
0.11468217521905899,
0.19287919998168945,
-0.47706931829452515,
0.383389949798584,
0.2902209162712097,
0.5498120784759521,
-0.4699884057044983,
0.3489852249622345,
0.5293733477592468,
0.32871732115745544,
0.13644985854625702,
-0.6819188594818115,
-0.37483587861061096,
-0.24944385886192322,
-0.32305440306663513,
0.44525304436683655,
-0.5607412457466125,
0.4874683618545532,
0.14513102173805237,
-0.2575141489505768,
-0.14544884860515594,
0.9392655491828918,
-0.07698959112167358,
0.458945631980896,
0.8127071261405945,
0.7685977816581726,
0.7437165975570679,
0.026957634836435318,
0.7513028979301453,
0.20134727656841278,
0.1104203388094902,
1.0031927824020386,
-0.17693926393985748,
0.40824809670448303,
0.18103082478046417,
-0.4376518726348877,
0.3426694869995117,
0.6365574598312378,
0.13478662073612213,
0.6316778063774109,
0.3973332345485687,
-0.7792263031005859,
-0.4402630031108856,
-0.6711375117301941,
-0.4199787378311157,
0.4866682291030884,
0.4404458701610565,
-0.2281220555305481,
-0.518432080745697,
0.40971639752388,
0.014353401027619839,
0.23994268476963043,
-0.5218549966812134,
0.7115805149078369,
-0.24281366169452667,
-0.3210426867008209,
0.5429553389549255,
0.1477799266576767,
0.8188928961753845,
-0.20771373808383942,
0.0005515280645340681,
0.244724839925766,
0.09764781594276428,
-0.3668815493583679,
-0.6602228283882141,
0.3570442497730255,
0.36763662099838257,
0.008492385037243366,
-0.16342668235301971,
0.8325042128562927,
-0.645567774772644,
-0.6591533422470093,
0.24767345190048218,
0.22762306034564972,
0.28810635209083557,
-0.23121707141399384,
-0.7138476967811584,
0.03462400287389755,
0.2546502351760864,
0.30855467915534973,
0.3680504560470581,
0.0832514688372612,
-0.2735729217529297,
0.4596443474292755,
0.5891577005386353,
0.03990916535258293,
0.2551460266113281,
0.12867145240306854,
0.9745521545410156,
-0.290290892124176,
-0.47105515003204346,
-1.0090632438659668,
0.22139553725719452,
-0.20938418805599213,
-0.1161588728427887,
0.6961266994476318,
0.7721443772315979,
1.1356658935546875,
0.04592183977365494,
1.2116498947143555,
-0.15637336671352386,
1.1441051959991455,
-0.30666038393974304,
0.5712730884552002,
-0.6598670482635498,
0.06534331291913986,
-0.4556008577346802,
-0.7309833765029907,
-0.5155645608901978,
0.4940938651561737,
-0.624262273311615,
0.3279955983161926,
0.22694282233715057,
0.8833951354026794,
-0.14383307099342346,
0.4146277606487274,
0.35549741983413696,
0.31740331649780273,
0.305682510137558,
0.3709738552570343,
1.0434128046035767,
-0.26637694239616394,
0.396965891122818,
-0.504699170589447,
-0.20452910661697388,
-0.2830957770347595,
-0.41102275252342224,
-0.9422084093093872,
-0.5072064399719238,
-0.327328085899353,
-0.3512406349182129,
0.11602625250816345,
1.0683482885360718,
0.48598629236221313,
-1.1138437986373901,
-0.12053308635950089,
0.08228457719087601,
0.17480936646461487,
0.14832201600074768,
-0.16094404458999634,
0.32487952709198,
-0.2723403871059418,
-0.9375818371772766,
0.28744545578956604,
0.0035514854826033115,
0.21670842170715332,
0.21985766291618347,
-0.03511686250567436,
-0.48525363206863403,
-0.17922630906105042,
0.3624376654624939,
0.31181421875953674,
-0.4566996097564697,
-0.23121534287929535,
-0.602081298828125,
0.07871440052986145,
-0.09051122516393661,
0.5715579986572266,
-0.8701114654541016,
0.16086527705192566,
0.19349385797977448,
0.8393659591674805,
0.36374661326408386,
0.17046812176704407,
0.277011513710022,
-0.7399024963378906,
0.3350369334220886,
0.672714352607727,
0.15375754237174988,
0.1822642982006073,
-0.12277453392744064,
0.19278304278850555,
0.22143609821796417,
-0.2645992934703827,
-0.9947865605354309,
0.24929368495941162,
-0.6184349060058594,
-0.04846492037177086,
0.8515806794166565,
0.26032060384750366,
-0.09910178929567337,
-0.33916938304901123,
-0.21635837852954865,
0.6064572334289551,
-0.689508318901062,
0.8151103258132935,
0.6434887051582336,
0.16495224833488464,
-0.26997414231300354,
-0.05481409654021263,
0.44234660267829895,
0.722640335559845,
-0.7282440066337585,
-0.2934471666812897,
0.6082524657249451,
-0.006474524736404419,
0.1342710256576538,
0.3609358072280884,
0.13862429559230804,
0.3046044409275055,
-0.5666384696960449,
0.0748702809214592,
0.10404250025749207,
-0.3072162866592407,
-0.19977518916130066,
0.35406920313835144,
-0.24903027713298798,
-0.517718493938446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02446v1 | Predicting vs. Acting: A Trade-off Between World Modeling & Agent Modeling | 2024-07-02T17:22:54 | 2024-07-02T17:22:54 | Margaret Li, Weijia Shi, Artidoro Pagnoni, Peter West, Ari Holtzman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | RLHF-aligned LMs have shown unprecedented ability on both benchmarks and
long-form text generation, yet they struggle with one foundational task:
next-token prediction. As RLHF models become agent models aimed at interacting
with humans, they seem to lose their world modeling -- the ability to predict
what comes next in arbitrary documents, which is the foundational training
objective of the Base LMs that RLHF adapts.
Besides empirically demonstrating this trade-off, we propose a potential
explanation: to perform coherent long-form generation, RLHF models restrict
randomness via implicit blueprints. In particular, RLHF models concentrate
probability on sets of anchor spans that co-occur across multiple generations
for the same prompt, serving as textual scaffolding but also limiting a model's
ability to generate documents that do not include these spans. We study this
trade-off on the most effective current agent models, those aligned with RLHF,
while exploring why this may remain a fundamental trade-off between models that
act and those that predict, even as alignment techniques improve. | [
-0.17771753668785095,
-0.7180621027946472,
0.6835652589797974,
-0.2606782615184784,
0.04731432721018791,
0.18628276884555817,
0.21732448041439056,
-1.0709753036499023,
0.019214730709791183,
0.5912819504737854,
-0.9627499580383301,
-0.13317222893238068,
-0.29637500643730164,
-0.24815122783184052,
-0.29555147886276245,
1.0117502212524414,
-0.05575557053089142,
-0.11328712850809097,
-0.6192131638526917,
-0.12081566452980042,
-0.31549394130706787,
-0.37446317076683044,
-0.6443307995796204,
-0.8569413423538208,
0.7222737669944763,
0.1440308839082718,
1.2129465341567993,
0.9718151092529297,
0.49143508076667786,
0.18932798504829407,
0.17886576056480408,
0.12471123039722443,
-0.46104884147644043,
0.562925398349762,
-0.20802552998065948,
-0.24720081686973572,
-0.5609012842178345,
0.1521395444869995,
0.6361380219459534,
0.7103825807571411,
-0.048633769154548645,
0.13671720027923584,
-0.2582528293132782,
0.6600110530853271,
-0.5204162001609802,
0.22466938197612762,
-0.5155879259109497,
0.13191631436347961,
0.15565453469753265,
-0.1210293099284172,
-0.48597127199172974,
-0.018618468195199966,
0.3905927240848541,
-0.5884532332420349,
0.3377450108528137,
0.31400299072265625,
0.8618499040603638,
0.20827597379684448,
-0.37589091062545776,
-0.15719103813171387,
-0.7716211080551147,
0.5967512130737305,
-0.4407421946525574,
0.43844103813171387,
0.3220268785953522,
0.22852319478988647,
-0.36593014001846313,
-1.021944284439087,
-0.3833213448524475,
-0.4412786662578583,
0.0247394610196352,
0.2156049907207489,
0.013663454912602901,
0.3167688548564911,
0.15437674522399902,
-0.02694382146000862,
-0.4806908965110779,
0.3937413990497589,
-0.2786778509616852,
-0.35430195927619934,
0.6573745608329773,
0.32366588711738586,
0.21582750976085663,
0.025591695681214333,
-0.7468946576118469,
-0.2646263837814331,
-0.8021125197410583,
0.20551854372024536,
0.3408929407596588,
0.5291476249694824,
-0.0321895033121109,
0.5484296679496765,
0.14548951387405396,
0.6478577852249146,
0.24410302937030792,
-0.2236579805612564,
-0.444467157125473,
0.12792351841926575,
-0.18704494833946228,
-0.022247876971960068,
0.5167158246040344,
0.4335706830024719,
0.24276570975780487,
-0.04975423961877823,
-0.3773024082183838,
-0.11118858307600021,
0.23676671087741852,
-0.6969553232192993,
0.17918924987316132,
0.32750803232192993,
-0.5227310657501221,
-0.3896926939487457,
0.26924869418144226,
-0.4318484663963318,
-0.5767802000045776,
-0.18252505362033844,
0.3334251940250397,
-0.08303366601467133,
-0.13046415150165558,
-0.2452353537082672,
-0.2654516100883484,
0.13185156881809235,
0.2520657777786255,
-0.7256714105606079,
0.34467098116874695,
0.8340792059898376,
0.5948176383972168,
-0.38298499584198,
-0.9194769263267517,
-0.5052493810653687,
0.2654739022254944,
-0.6199095845222473,
0.8529655933380127,
-0.4780299961566925,
-0.49045872688293457,
0.28503090143203735,
0.067874975502491,
-0.11360105127096176,
-0.2871662676334381,
0.4613804519176483,
-0.6578249931335449,
0.17718878388404846,
-0.1971726268529892,
-0.7052534818649292,
-0.035180751234292984,
0.05880943313241005,
-1.069246768951416,
1.0623207092285156,
0.12867866456508636,
-0.5557187795639038,
0.6893263459205627,
-0.3455287516117096,
-0.2616206407546997,
-0.11401847004890442,
-0.048240307718515396,
-0.6088770031929016,
0.10375355184078217,
-0.28607094287872314,
0.587753176689148,
-0.2589297890663147,
0.3534892499446869,
-0.628592312335968,
-0.46105432510375977,
0.5239169597625732,
-0.4305543899536133,
0.15576401352882385,
0.19406120479106903,
-0.17477555572986603,
0.22703567147254944,
-0.5906146764755249,
-0.005066614132374525,
0.11100533604621887,
-0.4496896266937256,
0.020886195823550224,
0.3041664958000183,
0.12735973298549652,
0.4549519121646881,
0.14696340262889862,
-0.22550663352012634,
0.12491294741630554,
-0.31331804394721985,
0.21584714949131012,
0.9035107493400574,
0.0029101837426424026,
0.7821564674377441,
-0.8909110426902771,
0.9152517914772034,
-0.2795066833496094,
0.12620238959789276,
0.006937331520020962,
-0.5063908696174622,
-0.38574132323265076,
-0.08988424390554428,
0.08127220720052719,
0.23044069111347198,
-0.454939603805542,
-0.05795246362686157,
-0.3690575659275055,
-0.5377554297447205,
-0.3801366090774536,
-0.2028578221797943,
0.4582217335700989,
0.37701621651649475,
0.006107218097895384,
-0.123839370906353,
-0.5558952689170837,
-0.8081464171409607,
-0.5761606693267822,
-0.4942225515842438,
0.648605227470398,
-0.05397867038846016,
0.43833985924720764,
0.07175339013338089,
1.1342309713363647,
-0.1823825091123581,
-0.02340325154364109,
-0.5580929517745972,
-0.05428210273385048,
-0.014099367894232273,
0.3849206268787384,
0.26273617148399353,
-0.9894484877586365,
-0.5897534489631653,
-0.013064533472061157,
-0.4961632192134857,
0.19934937357902527,
-0.42092543840408325,
-0.05797585844993591,
0.5727046132087708,
0.6527637243270874,
-1.1698353290557861,
0.7068681120872498,
0.5256022810935974,
-0.4032571017742157,
0.6120703816413879,
-0.24578224122524261,
-0.18560625612735748,
-0.8021221160888672,
0.004517136141657829,
-0.23544833064079285,
-0.30514633655548096,
-0.7573505640029907,
0.20823408663272858,
0.09221819788217545,
-0.2207767814397812,
-0.48381900787353516,
1.2732270956039429,
-0.6718747615814209,
-0.49599993228912354,
-0.3735714852809906,
0.05801814794540405,
0.1758660525083542,
0.47733381390571594,
0.11589468270540237,
0.7347467541694641,
0.19312910735607147,
-0.438050240278244,
-0.02165917120873928,
0.12586580216884613,
-0.2427382469177246,
0.17285610735416412,
-0.4368956685066223,
0.024022040888667107,
-0.19137227535247803,
0.6393665671348572,
-0.6743226051330566,
-0.450935959815979,
0.19069206714630127,
-0.34246715903282166,
0.5696460604667664,
-0.09052730351686478,
-0.27165499329566956,
-0.4746590554714203,
-0.4093671143054962,
0.25641170144081116,
0.5261708498001099,
-0.4926134943962097,
0.9627288579940796,
0.10123946517705917,
-0.014353725127875805,
-0.8147009611129761,
-0.8899122476577759,
-0.06778372824192047,
-0.23377148807048798,
-0.6169558763504028,
0.5785207152366638,
0.10368762910366058,
-0.42832332849502563,
0.053261637687683105,
-0.21350827813148499,
0.07484494149684906,
0.09680936485528946,
0.6707471013069153,
0.39930176734924316,
-0.05209005996584892,
0.24942804872989655,
-0.08549396693706512,
-0.06853993237018585,
0.015274519100785255,
-0.268422394990921,
0.27644726634025574,
0.15322144329547882,
-0.7135683298110962,
-0.27230411767959595,
0.37285202741622925,
0.848256528377533,
-0.2422981858253479,
0.8765158653259277,
0.39368507266044617,
-0.22012877464294434,
-0.5703185200691223,
-0.3173910677433014,
-0.08584950864315033,
-0.39381155371665955,
0.6265974044799805,
-0.2589877247810364,
-0.4999811351299286,
0.6148633360862732,
0.29754531383514404,
0.3377695679664612,
0.5225070714950562,
0.44429317116737366,
-0.1494227945804596,
1.0184463262557983,
0.6822685599327087,
0.25753554701805115,
0.7028970122337341,
-0.059294067323207855,
0.07191736251115799,
-0.5642533302307129,
-0.11056205630302429,
-0.19894009828567505,
-0.11704210191965103,
-0.6926803588867188,
-0.33059027791023254,
0.09780729562044144,
-0.19705167412757874,
-0.24201175570487976,
0.17687973380088806,
-0.36953458189964294,
0.3624945878982544,
0.5314241051673889,
0.004239676520228386,
0.1928291916847229,
0.031925905495882034,
0.032122835516929626,
0.13096274435520172,
-0.9148389101028442,
-0.49219927191734314,
1.1709940433502197,
0.5873417258262634,
0.8269055485725403,
-0.0991075187921524,
0.6742123365402222,
0.5268659591674805,
0.5284661650657654,
-0.8214806318283081,
0.5860032439231873,
0.18950238823890686,
-0.9381614327430725,
-0.5160174369812012,
-0.006994993891566992,
-1.0341652631759644,
0.3059476912021637,
-0.31377479434013367,
-0.41663843393325806,
0.24643324315547943,
0.2902984619140625,
-0.2956176698207855,
0.36152344942092896,
-0.5141912698745728,
0.6866840720176697,
0.04102669656276703,
-0.6453441977500916,
0.00455551128834486,
-0.749491274356842,
0.29607918858528137,
0.008851617574691772,
0.28975993394851685,
-0.18835332989692688,
-0.0637824535369873,
0.5843518972396851,
-0.34794583916664124,
1.0264861583709717,
-0.0662057027220726,
-0.2493516206741333,
0.6110451817512512,
0.12321343272924423,
0.8589502573013306,
-0.3073166608810425,
-0.29814067482948303,
-0.45123353600502014,
0.02742457017302513,
-0.4196545481681824,
-0.42266136407852173,
0.42929327487945557,
-0.7889431118965149,
-0.6161274313926697,
-0.5713144540786743,
-0.5818482637405396,
-0.2224869281053543,
0.02999015524983406,
0.4868275225162506,
0.5097091197967529,
-0.6419605016708374,
-0.28061506152153015,
0.43613821268081665,
0.17704233527183533,
0.6610031127929688,
0.2524014115333557,
-0.3865329325199127,
-0.32630109786987305,
0.7700555920600891,
0.15783028304576874,
0.7094087600708008,
0.4804657995700836,
0.09218043833971024,
-0.49653518199920654,
-0.29742196202278137,
-0.22815944254398346,
0.2583169937133789,
-1.1404573917388916,
-0.055679745972156525,
-0.49112483859062195,
-0.3211927115917206,
-0.4788020849227905,
-0.27250003814697266,
-0.14237065613269806,
-0.4934100806713104,
-0.3831981122493744,
-0.35425594449043274,
0.09483717381954193,
0.885525643825531,
-0.06750807911157608,
0.11820756644010544,
-0.6822128891944885,
0.06119678542017937,
0.3956078588962555,
0.16696003079414368,
0.29540500044822693,
-0.4992886185646057,
-0.4743916094303131,
-0.03335179388523102,
-0.2556489408016205,
-0.9079824686050415,
0.1609746813774109,
0.4138277471065521,
0.7066970467567444,
0.2478010058403015,
0.02410838007926941,
0.5823903679847717,
-0.39960432052612305,
0.6190996766090393,
0.1288183480501175,
-0.5973755121231079,
-0.0008022291003726423,
-0.47811073064804077,
0.2051134705543518,
0.3104526698589325,
0.08269108086824417,
-0.4924308955669403,
-0.33684754371643066,
-0.8558061122894287,
-0.5053213238716125,
0.7790467739105225,
-0.10251200944185257,
-0.06322338432073593,
0.13426503539085388,
0.29349103569984436,
0.29149511456489563,
0.08726700395345688,
-1.0082342624664307,
-0.008936717174947262,
-0.06953514367341995,
-0.17350269854068756,
-0.04431690275669098,
-0.2826980650424957,
-0.08017276227474213,
0.10645709931850433,
0.6623834371566772,
-0.3586050271987915,
0.3036028742790222,
0.3065362572669983,
-0.08458039164543152,
-0.5785194039344788,
0.030082181096076965,
0.7347660064697266,
0.6850431561470032,
-0.1935173124074936,
0.004750683903694153,
-0.10001091659069061,
-0.4121319651603699,
0.10971533507108688,
0.19110184907913208,
-0.21678848564624786,
-0.10143566876649857,
0.973941445350647,
1.0443251132965088,
0.2532251179218292,
-0.788467288017273,
0.31864601373672485,
0.3118111789226532,
-0.3319299519062042,
-0.3130410313606262,
0.21154800057411194,
0.2462468445301056,
0.31724897027015686,
0.41986918449401855,
0.07821159064769745,
-0.2456454336643219,
-0.8550203442573547,
0.15576604008674622,
0.43605512380599976,
-0.5569608807563782,
-0.2709992229938507,
0.6731787323951721,
0.062422432005405426,
-0.6225114464759827,
0.28046953678131104,
0.08377409726381302,
-0.38688862323760986,
1.0940804481506348,
0.5255950093269348,
0.9869206547737122,
-0.026005003601312637,
0.22166228294372559,
0.061969779431819916,
0.09187745302915573,
-0.3066089451313019,
0.0768653005361557,
0.13309143483638763,
-0.6773431897163391,
-0.2626612186431885,
-0.5372304916381836,
-0.49256429076194763,
-0.16284067928791046,
-0.6834096908569336,
0.21231450140476227,
-0.38382554054260254,
-0.4279676675796509,
-0.21992260217666626,
0.02301660180091858,
-0.6435268521308899,
0.27557191252708435,
0.13429860770702362,
0.8486193418502808,
-0.6685143709182739,
0.685127317905426,
0.7873101830482483,
-0.3996400237083435,
-0.7751107215881348,
0.29516324400901794,
-0.12978385388851166,
-0.8679521679878235,
0.4045451283454895,
0.18894697725772858,
0.019948558881878853,
-0.08255080133676529,
-0.5551069378852844,
-1.0135133266448975,
1.4159910678863525,
0.307594358921051,
-0.2460441291332245,
-0.5784304738044739,
0.08939526975154877,
0.489711731672287,
-0.5439742207527161,
-0.008458083495497704,
0.3625100553035736,
0.6068970561027527,
0.07910565286874771,
-0.7432147264480591,
0.1388915628194809,
0.17382460832595825,
-0.0897466391324997,
0.20209451019763947,
-0.7124481201171875,
1.029217004776001,
-0.45475533604621887,
-0.4040139615535736,
0.39428895711898804,
0.7544571161270142,
0.5228754281997681,
0.501814067363739,
0.43509742617607117,
0.21735580265522003,
0.34687644243240356,
0.20017044246196747,
1.2725958824157715,
-0.268189400434494,
0.31970012187957764,
1.2075291872024536,
-0.579194188117981,
0.8407091498374939,
0.5214343070983887,
-0.18013949692249298,
0.5554327964782715,
0.8346474766731262,
0.040754854679107666,
0.45008447766304016,
-0.09089890867471695,
-0.1425129771232605,
-0.4233536124229431,
-0.05232859402894974,
-0.28313741087913513,
0.4479130208492279,
0.11905613541603088,
-0.23063409328460693,
-0.22937576472759247,
-0.2753206491470337,
-0.042996909469366074,
0.20008844137191772,
-0.16657842695713043,
0.6026350259780884,
0.15924055874347687,
-1.339218258857727,
0.2716975212097168,
-0.055327482521533966,
0.19066452980041504,
-0.6456424593925476,
-0.09985308349132538,
-0.2293350100517273,
0.05438819155097008,
-0.07433930039405823,
-0.6957424879074097,
0.012056075967848301,
-0.5929021835327148,
-0.3850552439689636,
-0.41814088821411133,
1.0769305229187012,
-0.47560611367225647,
-0.3402629494667053,
0.4565993547439575,
0.9123744964599609,
-0.1988898068666458,
0.24464109539985657,
-0.8136651515960693,
-0.147868350148201,
-0.2412319928407669,
-0.5873825550079346,
0.5420518517494202,
0.4049072563648224,
-0.36421895027160645,
0.8683763146400452,
0.8424959778785706,
0.13386225700378418,
0.05127500742673874,
-0.11130789667367935,
0.5486170053482056,
-0.6714513301849365,
-0.652228593826294,
-0.7134628891944885,
0.5065895915031433,
0.13718070089817047,
-0.3666917681694031,
0.3129630982875824,
0.15136374533176422,
0.368435263633728,
-0.11181346327066422,
0.6601300835609436,
0.20806628465652466,
0.36424505710601807,
-0.6238150596618652,
0.8292643427848816,
-0.6330154538154602,
-0.03452204540371895,
-0.11610320955514908,
-0.8646714091300964,
0.058451615273952484,
0.01592235267162323,
0.07168545573949814,
0.267203688621521,
0.8014339804649353,
0.70255047082901,
0.1325811743736267,
-0.2153616100549698,
0.5830783247947693,
-0.03237690031528473,
0.35148870944976807,
0.2592930197715759,
1.0955983400344849,
-0.1559339314699173,
0.48237544298171997,
0.05874346196651459,
0.15233634412288666,
-0.33823516964912415,
-1.0401309728622437,
-0.942563533782959,
-0.6020800471305847,
0.03537389263510704,
-0.30641084909439087,
0.16693371534347534,
0.9595930576324463,
0.7717111706733704,
-0.41813987493515015,
-0.21031825244426727,
-0.2449730783700943,
0.339141309261322,
-0.386944055557251,
-0.18362265825271606,
0.3593604564666748,
-0.20249363780021667,
-0.5515943765640259,
0.3060310184955597,
0.014458339661359787,
0.5174091458320618,
-0.4055638909339905,
-0.28445008397102356,
-0.16545680165290833,
0.3846008777618408,
0.36236655712127686,
0.6007813811302185,
-0.9422200322151184,
-0.2517007291316986,
0.10838393867015839,
-0.3933038115501404,
-0.17934900522232056,
0.7097747921943665,
-0.8878879547119141,
0.11509954184293747,
0.2263442575931549,
0.5288779139518738,
0.26074641942977905,
0.0413302481174469,
0.8406713604927063,
-0.4290238320827484,
0.2577962875366211,
0.19755978882312775,
0.296352744102478,
0.13602207601070404,
-0.47651347517967224,
0.47417309880256653,
0.1882605254650116,
-0.573989748954773,
-0.9669201374053955,
0.45730799436569214,
-0.7539397478103638,
-0.6081914305686951,
1.0538899898529053,
-0.04106968641281128,
-0.37112170457839966,
-0.029422976076602936,
-0.04774051904678345,
0.17123138904571533,
-0.37228628993034363,
0.5782480835914612,
0.8439937829971313,
-0.31554195284843445,
0.024192243814468384,
-0.550988495349884,
0.7240448594093323,
0.5259402394294739,
-0.6262441277503967,
0.2300184816122055,
0.5502880811691284,
-0.0026649374049156904,
-0.028379978612065315,
0.8384377956390381,
0.3256804347038269,
0.6235395073890686,
0.1312546581029892,
0.16330315172672272,
-0.33240312337875366,
-0.5346471667289734,
-0.20959505438804626,
0.2837911546230316,
0.39734557271003723,
0.1544857621192932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02432v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02432v1 | Evaluating the Robustness of Adverse Drug Event Classification Models Using Templates | 2024-07-02T17:09:24 | 2024-07-02T17:09:24 | Dorothea MacPhail, David Harbecke, Lisa Raithel, Sebastian Möller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | An adverse drug effect (ADE) is any harmful event resulting from medical drug
treatment. Despite their importance, ADEs are often under-reported in official
channels. Some research has therefore turned to detecting discussions of ADEs
in social media. Impressive results have been achieved in various attempts to
detect ADEs. In a high-stakes domain such as medicine, however, an in-depth
evaluation of a model's abilities is crucial. We address the issue of thorough
performance evaluation in English-language ADE detection with hand-crafted
templates for four capabilities: Temporal order, negation, sentiment, and
beneficial effect. We find that models with similar performance on held-out
test sets have varying results on these capabilities. | [
-0.0783228874206543,
-0.5976409912109375,
0.7328416109085083,
-0.02867915667593479,
-0.2152104377746582,
-0.16905471682548523,
0.012423589825630188,
-0.5646966695785522,
0.40236759185791016,
0.3488944172859192,
0.04412801191210747,
-0.6539426445960999,
-1.1773306131362915,
0.022122520953416824,
-0.5455742478370667,
1.0372798442840576,
-0.14080138504505157,
0.2705647051334381,
0.09172999858856201,
-0.5423989295959473,
-0.6902264952659607,
-0.3838854730129242,
-0.7925528287887573,
-0.012073823250830173,
0.655952513217926,
0.0022361725568771362,
0.4242785573005676,
0.5284808874130249,
0.8621543645858765,
0.312826931476593,
-0.08599833399057388,
-0.18113072216510773,
-0.24483820796012878,
0.07245546579360962,
-0.48387107253074646,
-0.5046628713607788,
-0.980198085308075,
0.31566905975341797,
0.4455186426639557,
0.4690150320529938,
-0.0401335246860981,
0.10185053199529648,
-0.037002526223659515,
0.3211635947227478,
-0.8063804507255554,
-0.15036191046237946,
-0.49190130829811096,
-0.11795012652873993,
-0.1910151243209839,
-0.015038030222058296,
-0.3402058184146881,
-0.22741737961769104,
0.2767302393913269,
-0.4545741081237793,
0.008634442463517189,
-0.288962721824646,
0.8079363107681274,
-0.04922185465693474,
-0.6827914714813232,
-0.6748983860015869,
-0.7358371019363403,
0.5684664249420166,
-0.8254646062850952,
0.4934314787387848,
0.14950338006019592,
0.46960824728012085,
-0.16248197853565216,
-1.03194260597229,
-0.5404804348945618,
0.08577223867177963,
0.010330354794859886,
-0.05801044777035713,
-0.1478390246629715,
0.1553504765033722,
0.10092532634735107,
0.5438487529754639,
-0.4667488932609558,
0.4887717366218567,
-0.42307886481285095,
-0.22791078686714172,
0.5434525609016418,
0.3141911029815674,
0.41193681955337524,
-0.2960492670536041,
-0.13615044951438904,
0.26427245140075684,
-0.35226017236709595,
0.061752211302518845,
0.16595593094825745,
0.20258668065071106,
-0.27101361751556396,
0.5135509371757507,
0.2248133420944214,
0.5064381957054138,
-0.12128734588623047,
-0.2731231153011322,
0.08140037208795547,
-0.49133092164993286,
-0.23648305237293243,
-0.24871821701526642,
0.8913148045539856,
0.47022828459739685,
-0.15690860152244568,
-0.08913200348615646,
-0.22640256583690643,
0.5649197101593018,
0.3290932774543762,
-0.8700699806213379,
-0.1715838611125946,
0.4514840543270111,
-0.6721605062484741,
-0.6014944314956665,
-0.002388006541877985,
-0.820853590965271,
-0.7625419497489929,
-0.00582809466868639,
0.5888996720314026,
-0.34908926486968994,
-0.06638951599597931,
0.2424730807542801,
-0.3232519030570984,
0.1685851663351059,
0.27404993772506714,
-0.3438410460948944,
0.4200045168399811,
0.49871826171875,
0.7295807003974915,
-0.36360859870910645,
-0.02333860844373703,
-0.5528155565261841,
-0.11744113266468048,
-0.3292357325553894,
1.2412327527999878,
-0.5108982920646667,
-0.3036647140979767,
-0.03181498870253563,
0.06375168263912201,
-0.22988653182983398,
-0.6327185034751892,
0.8625752329826355,
-0.46927347779273987,
0.36011362075805664,
-0.2152782678604126,
-0.8873693346977234,
-0.17198613286018372,
0.04861398786306381,
-0.4714215397834778,
0.1724308282136917,
-0.12040804326534271,
-0.888308048248291,
0.946208119392395,
-0.6439226269721985,
-0.5838815569877625,
-0.06259094923734665,
-0.11910257488489151,
-0.5615496635437012,
0.23594939708709717,
0.06814432889223099,
0.5364242792129517,
-0.1313769668340683,
0.2389558106660843,
-0.3879268765449524,
-0.4662153124809265,
0.3211609423160553,
-0.3643433153629303,
0.6707162261009216,
0.15524281561374664,
-0.33226478099823,
0.2424972802400589,
-0.914511501789093,
-0.2279367446899414,
0.0367712564766407,
-0.44531798362731934,
-0.5873429179191589,
-0.0009286254644393921,
0.14655545353889465,
0.4012128710746765,
-0.1328609138727188,
-0.37247294187545776,
0.007702001370489597,
-0.34374135732650757,
0.1605415940284729,
0.6368956565856934,
0.4882403016090393,
0.23078510165214539,
-0.30480530858039856,
0.541040301322937,
0.06684862822294235,
0.4624970853328705,
-0.09469328075647354,
-0.5840200185775757,
-0.3905254006385803,
-0.3748471140861511,
0.4578793942928314,
0.5336340665817261,
-0.5095691084861755,
0.5573028326034546,
-0.05351588875055313,
-0.2697933316230774,
-0.3060959577560425,
0.1554885059595108,
0.2705783247947693,
0.25409427285194397,
0.2926340699195862,
-0.6018622517585754,
-0.357540100812912,
-0.7068494558334351,
-0.5704534649848938,
-0.15939095616340637,
-0.12151724100112915,
0.21585293114185333,
0.5400996208190918,
-0.3191688358783722,
0.17732229828834534,
-0.5084317326545715,
-0.29813581705093384,
-0.15627869963645935,
0.15028686821460724,
-0.01516655646264553,
0.16142550110816956,
0.8040426969528198,
-0.454667866230011,
-0.3171791434288025,
-0.41081395745277405,
-0.776687502861023,
-0.2539677917957306,
0.021362951025366783,
-0.057272445410490036,
-0.1086030974984169,
0.4242652952671051,
-0.23183980584144592,
0.5355246663093567,
0.29562076926231384,
-0.5371177792549133,
0.24602249264717102,
-0.01432762760668993,
0.41787710785865784,
-1.039601445198059,
0.06809662282466888,
0.3211515545845032,
0.0883261114358902,
-0.8329145312309265,
-0.1907946914434433,
0.19640037417411804,
-0.03815022110939026,
-0.38569027185440063,
0.4975346028804779,
-0.06285815685987473,
0.22921618819236755,
-0.1627740114927292,
0.08651362359523773,
0.31161415576934814,
-0.07625533640384674,
-0.1022358164191246,
0.18255235254764557,
0.6140674352645874,
-0.714422345161438,
0.001842865371145308,
-0.12213703244924545,
-0.37222808599472046,
0.877637505531311,
-0.412428081035614,
-0.1642652153968811,
-0.13037537038326263,
-0.09125567227602005,
-0.9824728965759277,
-0.396056592464447,
0.052580464631319046,
-0.2886757254600525,
0.6040724515914917,
-0.40356558561325073,
-0.1831202507019043,
-0.567029595375061,
-0.47539258003234863,
0.19771136343479156,
0.3894796371459961,
-0.20168595016002655,
0.3118051588535309,
0.6161531209945679,
0.03666147589683533,
-0.39033955335617065,
-0.04909713193774223,
0.017150845378637314,
-0.6293996572494507,
-0.20098133385181427,
0.04422307759523392,
0.2395029366016388,
-0.40537840127944946,
-0.10328163951635361,
-0.08024130016565323,
-0.3916057348251343,
0.1367286741733551,
0.043823424726724625,
0.1562613546848297,
-0.15267404913902283,
0.1489211767911911,
0.038018785417079926,
0.16738620400428772,
0.16756746172904968,
0.05764038488268852,
0.16520465910434723,
0.011242167092859745,
-0.17466087639331818,
-0.5287777185440063,
0.232594296336174,
1.07289719581604,
-0.24467375874519348,
0.6535494923591614,
0.4186074137687683,
-0.8104273080825806,
0.007223410997539759,
-0.4226236343383789,
-0.18647754192352295,
-0.41851940751075745,
0.40386781096458435,
0.11035267263650894,
-0.04648720100522041,
0.7685447931289673,
0.11161573976278305,
0.023931998759508133,
0.5034146308898926,
0.2864153981208801,
-0.10567589849233627,
1.1127172708511353,
0.34486907720565796,
0.2163372039794922,
0.5258152484893799,
-0.5001534223556519,
0.3648771345615387,
-0.7094360589981079,
-0.199785053730011,
-0.2612335681915283,
-0.12333700805902481,
-0.5006583333015442,
-0.35714930295944214,
0.6117406487464905,
-0.04680585488677025,
-0.11539307981729507,
0.13840094208717346,
-0.25725072622299194,
0.10876242816448212,
-0.04277077317237854,
0.12026707828044891,
0.23225188255310059,
-0.18315373361110687,
-0.05076241493225098,
-0.2094353884458542,
-0.720225989818573,
-0.7771050930023193,
1.279808759689331,
0.5811289548873901,
0.5807183384895325,
-0.015454433858394623,
0.41910576820373535,
0.23268142342567444,
0.6242722868919373,
-0.8624464273452759,
0.33454206585884094,
-0.40661364793777466,
-0.6672986745834351,
0.054366081953048706,
-0.10929840803146362,
-0.9240161776542664,
0.08409113436937332,
-0.5765492916107178,
-0.7586211562156677,
0.325913667678833,
0.09814141690731049,
-0.6094151735305786,
0.38419902324676514,
-0.8254703283309937,
1.0228859186172485,
-0.3052142262458801,
-0.4372057020664215,
-0.32908716797828674,
-0.3109224736690521,
0.3246954381465912,
-0.09826608002185822,
0.5341681241989136,
-0.032327570021152496,
0.041274238377809525,
0.9803183674812317,
-0.3235589265823364,
0.6734820008277893,
-0.21197247505187988,
-0.03095722198486328,
0.3202904164791107,
0.1350710541009903,
0.176915243268013,
0.1908840388059616,
0.07658528536558151,
0.13312175869941711,
-0.06057198718190193,
-0.5087412595748901,
-0.6523375511169434,
0.7379146814346313,
-0.3473704159259796,
-0.453871488571167,
-0.2965594530105591,
-0.09565143287181854,
-0.13771513104438782,
0.37913501262664795,
0.440979540348053,
0.7486250996589661,
-0.43421512842178345,
-0.22841589152812958,
0.2176692932844162,
-0.6327351331710815,
0.053260259330272675,
0.8464245796203613,
-0.03265870735049248,
-0.34910401701927185,
0.7509111762046814,
0.5623899102210999,
0.1096210926771164,
-0.08808209002017975,
0.3224009871482849,
-0.29555583000183105,
-0.9206628799438477,
-0.33483219146728516,
0.3315640091896057,
-0.8848428726196289,
-0.061604470014572144,
-0.670992374420166,
0.08873064815998077,
-0.5349444150924683,
-0.22728152573108673,
-0.5711220502853394,
-0.3270782232284546,
-0.14306555688381195,
-0.11198268830776215,
0.20217463374137878,
1.3127520084381104,
-0.017907585948705673,
0.20891165733337402,
-0.6537295579910278,
0.18824034929275513,
0.17576570808887482,
0.8859076499938965,
-0.08539391309022903,
-0.48663005232810974,
-0.21587243676185608,
-0.2780105471611023,
-0.624761700630188,
-0.917326807975769,
0.0016860604519024491,
-0.07005131244659424,
0.7810581922531128,
0.8837717175483704,
0.04520287364721298,
0.3547070324420929,
-0.27351751923561096,
0.6062019467353821,
0.02507474459707737,
-0.5962183475494385,
0.8733866810798645,
-0.4828730523586273,
-0.15112343430519104,
0.4970729947090149,
0.6040040254592896,
-0.31878480315208435,
-0.5435992479324341,
-0.6680415272712708,
-0.9167560338973999,
0.2955857813358307,
0.39622873067855835,
-0.18626472353935242,
-0.4186185300350189,
0.3908619284629822,
0.05277412012219429,
0.10996928066015244,
-0.39500463008880615,
-0.22405529022216797,
-0.018155096098780632,
0.121255062520504,
0.11222545057535172,
-0.3414008319377899,
0.10254640877246857,
-0.11690543591976166,
0.5308092832565308,
0.4435349404811859,
0.05496588349342346,
0.1994432955980301,
0.08156801760196686,
0.041944678872823715,
0.4875062108039856,
0.32963666319847107,
0.5405658483505249,
-0.42634958028793335,
0.25622662901878357,
0.013296663761138916,
-0.6493669748306274,
0.13016951084136963,
0.18176288902759552,
0.1357913315296173,
-0.17500628530979156,
0.8883543014526367,
0.4705882966518402,
-0.0038012161385267973,
-0.41468891501426697,
0.6941895484924316,
-0.33112290501594543,
0.3671089708805084,
0.01508525013923645,
0.01603497564792633,
-0.4258226454257965,
-0.05311586707830429,
-0.06637813150882721,
0.18676912784576416,
0.6844417452812195,
-0.7454562187194824,
0.43002384901046753,
0.2847976088523865,
-0.6762503385543823,
-0.4931289553642273,
0.7453921437263489,
0.3481423258781433,
-0.32077544927597046,
0.22750656306743622,
-0.06924432516098022,
-0.4619693160057068,
0.7431535720825195,
0.2970113754272461,
0.6752612590789795,
-0.5027597546577454,
-0.04370313137769699,
0.4093906879425049,
0.14334025979042053,
0.2892550230026245,
0.3916032016277313,
0.6121922135353088,
-0.5869170427322388,
-0.16761919856071472,
-0.3270932734012604,
0.0014074534410610795,
0.6480334997177124,
-0.7709258198738098,
0.5534120798110962,
-0.5172945261001587,
-0.6734572649002075,
0.4812658727169037,
-0.2152717113494873,
-0.7526084780693054,
0.13630492985248566,
-0.15678982436656952,
0.6535852551460266,
-1.356744647026062,
0.31919053196907043,
1.0478686094284058,
-0.11843830347061157,
-0.48481640219688416,
0.2725051939487457,
0.18234005570411682,
-0.27791085839271545,
0.37606754899024963,
0.2230132520198822,
0.06181143969297409,
-0.5442341566085815,
-0.06825102865695953,
-0.4347712993621826,
0.7686046361923218,
-0.06140521913766861,
-0.0398930087685585,
0.06671992689371109,
-0.13270165026187897,
0.9491714239120483,
-0.3577619791030884,
0.2710396647453308,
0.668592095375061,
0.07998666167259216,
-0.1971496045589447,
-1.0636072158813477,
-0.11029805988073349,
-0.3758113384246826,
-0.16626927256584167,
0.07333493232727051,
-0.20886239409446716,
0.5341757535934448,
-0.4138518273830414,
-0.3430206775665283,
-0.33141738176345825,
-0.0017441101372241974,
0.07386358827352524,
0.4789105951786041,
0.44547390937805176,
0.27384984493255615,
0.635240912437439,
0.0892624482512474,
1.5142415761947632,
-0.1106005534529686,
0.14182552695274353,
0.7536647915840149,
-0.41228657960891724,
0.5965418219566345,
0.2967941164970398,
-0.13476073741912842,
0.4618947505950928,
0.4950619339942932,
0.41509515047073364,
0.609503448009491,
0.10705284774303436,
-0.1632518321275711,
-0.2082752287387848,
-0.14331762492656708,
-0.2533109188079834,
0.5427173376083374,
0.7833998799324036,
-0.6052647233009338,
-0.22323055565357208,
0.1613474041223526,
-0.13143055140972137,
0.20222005248069763,
-0.284911572933197,
0.6468265056610107,
0.06595830619335175,
-0.38527658581733704,
0.4288761615753174,
0.010625012218952179,
0.3892539143562317,
-0.24561889469623566,
-0.3310624957084656,
-0.0992530807852745,
0.5265291333198547,
-0.03839952498674393,
-0.6882508397102356,
0.45554691553115845,
-0.008012393489480019,
0.00354347238317132,
0.589018702507019,
0.7510139346122742,
0.0999877005815506,
-0.5211755037307739,
0.6942771673202515,
0.38574761152267456,
0.024521013721823692,
0.2789808213710785,
-0.5740721225738525,
-0.048292458057403564,
-0.5199629068374634,
-0.21547837555408478,
0.20686158537864685,
0.3892596662044525,
-0.27866753935813904,
0.5117132067680359,
0.2366105318069458,
0.37044215202331543,
-0.18134044110774994,
0.1373714953660965,
0.6768463850021362,
-0.2056863009929657,
-0.5311993360519409,
-0.7531281113624573,
0.5566190481185913,
-0.237163707613945,
-0.22150953114032745,
0.7344094514846802,
0.6806579232215881,
0.4766520857810974,
-0.04565490037202835,
0.7947437763214111,
0.13148407638072968,
0.5035092830657959,
-0.305724561214447,
0.8326979875564575,
-0.5319494605064392,
0.7489374876022339,
-0.4975646436214447,
-0.39204898476600647,
-0.5525667667388916,
0.6840148568153381,
-0.5248004198074341,
0.03088218905031681,
0.7344913482666016,
0.41353750228881836,
-0.26199808716773987,
-0.11193934828042984,
0.23946043848991394,
0.4725983738899231,
0.4688894748687744,
0.4161779284477234,
0.7095181345939636,
-0.9021062850952148,
0.13848882913589478,
-0.27521201968193054,
-0.41189947724342346,
0.022531455382704735,
-0.8172071576118469,
-1.3097904920578003,
-0.41622957587242126,
-0.427784264087677,
-0.7198659181594849,
0.24965496361255646,
0.8191083669662476,
0.5095109343528748,
-1.1636730432510376,
0.1495564877986908,
0.26558688282966614,
0.3727804124355316,
-0.1585279405117035,
-0.25508326292037964,
0.6521527767181396,
-0.042917463928461075,
-0.5488441586494446,
0.2675744593143463,
0.31748899817466736,
0.34096193313598633,
0.09376758337020874,
0.2116636484861374,
-0.17584171891212463,
0.21136751770973206,
0.7602342367172241,
0.01062414888292551,
-0.36281484365463257,
-0.15390107035636902,
-0.03849755600094795,
-0.11805661767721176,
-0.12007267773151398,
1.0998910665512085,
-0.3855592608451843,
0.6404604315757751,
0.4271828234195709,
0.09185906499624252,
0.010033808648586273,
-0.2688247561454773,
0.8685024976730347,
-0.28255313634872437,
0.020186008885502815,
0.25625675916671753,
0.7844216227531433,
0.12463891506195068,
-0.4522671699523926,
0.28923577070236206,
0.31728047132492065,
-0.46907496452331543,
-0.9562239646911621,
0.08022065460681915,
-0.5040688514709473,
-0.5308545827865601,
1.1457931995391846,
-0.22582948207855225,
0.14539222419261932,
-0.649472713470459,
-0.08026646077632904,
0.3416561484336853,
-0.1668729931116104,
1.0358607769012451,
0.5062814354896545,
-0.3060682415962219,
0.4322505593299866,
-0.8294240832328796,
0.5335906147956848,
-0.09472648799419403,
-0.5360469818115234,
-0.0011058449745178223,
0.42006412148475647,
0.5476593375205994,
0.11077488958835602,
0.8290980458259583,
-0.4914259910583496,
0.3300932049751282,
-0.12038633972406387,
-0.10912523418664932,
0.13279983401298523,
-0.48421064019203186,
-0.483254611492157,
0.005345671437680721,
0.29754334688186646,
-0.05548790842294693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02408v1 | CEB: Compositional Evaluation Benchmark for Fairness in Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T16:31:37 | 2024-07-02T16:31:37 | Song Wang, Peng Wang, Tong Zhou, Yushun Dong, Zhen Tan, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed to handle various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, concerns regarding the potential
negative societal impacts of LLM-generated content have also arisen. To
evaluate the biases exhibited by LLMs, researchers have recently proposed a
variety of datasets. However, existing bias evaluation efforts often focus on
only a particular type of bias and employ inconsistent evaluation metrics,
leading to difficulties in comparison across different datasets and LLMs. To
address these limitations, we collect a variety of datasets designed for the
bias evaluation of LLMs, and further propose CEB, a Compositional Evaluation
Benchmark that covers different types of bias across different social groups
and tasks. The curation of CEB is based on our newly proposed compositional
taxonomy, which characterizes each dataset from three dimensions: bias types,
social groups, and tasks. By combining the three dimensions, we develop a
comprehensive evaluation strategy for the bias in LLMs. Our experiments
demonstrate that the levels of bias vary across these dimensions, thereby
providing guidance for the development of specific bias mitigation methods. | [
-0.3552427291870117,
-0.8404422998428345,
0.6562514901161194,
0.71518874168396,
0.12169109284877777,
0.12554530799388885,
-0.5064015984535217,
-0.4666968882083893,
0.11594243347644806,
0.44642335176467896,
-0.3783896863460541,
-0.7816858887672424,
-0.7303174138069153,
-0.003977104090154171,
-0.3391016721725464,
0.9403766989707947,
0.20029130578041077,
0.574542760848999,
-0.6543810367584229,
-0.13903741538524628,
-0.7211876511573792,
-0.3486926853656769,
-0.6604666709899902,
-0.4096754193305969,
0.6051787734031677,
0.23107096552848816,
0.5807642936706543,
0.5289888381958008,
0.5232431888580322,
0.21049082279205322,
-0.3575485348701477,
-0.0196290984749794,
-0.5607085824012756,
0.03447146713733673,
-0.4461739659309387,
-0.36983659863471985,
-0.44316431879997253,
-0.003059349488466978,
0.8603540062904358,
1.1327009201049805,
-0.04841114580631256,
0.38259807229042053,
0.24357154965400696,
0.6972586512565613,
-1.1349587440490723,
0.15808679163455963,
-0.6845141053199768,
0.14002981781959534,
-0.4096985161304474,
0.11186029016971588,
-0.47526437044143677,
-0.5872802734375,
-0.0466771237552166,
-0.24565225839614868,
0.1446235179901123,
-0.12983161211013794,
0.21413441002368927,
0.0960145965218544,
-0.7102383971214294,
-0.29383525252342224,
-0.44654741883277893,
1.0131664276123047,
-0.8700736165046692,
0.37521207332611084,
0.10741722583770752,
0.18745183944702148,
-0.12888836860656738,
-0.4290379285812378,
-0.5405253767967224,
-0.10815689712762833,
0.08145025372505188,
0.02810087241232395,
0.029943762347102165,
0.03817946836352348,
0.22293084859848022,
0.3994300067424774,
-0.4483470916748047,
0.2740488648414612,
-0.027330463752150536,
-0.3870663344860077,
0.632771372795105,
0.43605831265449524,
0.19043032824993134,
-0.260564923286438,
-0.20434290170669556,
0.03067268431186676,
-0.6656931638717651,
-0.17175009846687317,
0.7285403609275818,
0.21288228034973145,
-0.2053598165512085,
0.5239493250846863,
-0.34356239438056946,
0.6214761137962341,
-0.12363900244235992,
-0.10190269351005554,
0.4725259244441986,
-0.20594404637813568,
-0.003398091997951269,
-0.05849186331033707,
0.6834067702293396,
0.7934090495109558,
0.12010613828897476,
-0.19091087579727173,
-0.08030026406049728,
0.36075806617736816,
0.05779891833662987,
-0.7408902645111084,
0.08747323602437973,
0.09027191996574402,
-0.7407190203666687,
-0.23429349064826965,
-0.13345718383789062,
-0.9981846213340759,
-0.7583431005477905,
-0.39901280403137207,
0.1873367428779602,
0.10744749009609222,
-0.19615773856639862,
0.06665004789829254,
0.12341970950365067,
0.2837749719619751,
0.01133711077272892,
-0.8805604577064514,
0.540483832359314,
0.8973397612571716,
0.6065208315849304,
-0.63563072681427,
-0.19658507406711578,
-0.5429280996322632,
0.1604657620191574,
0.013288035057485104,
0.7318664193153381,
-0.8070725202560425,
-0.642025351524353,
0.15893036127090454,
-0.2032420039176941,
0.08066561818122864,
-0.7070337533950806,
1.0023988485336304,
-0.31469863653182983,
-0.03648233041167259,
-0.7912683486938477,
-0.6178131699562073,
0.07218923419713974,
0.28749939799308777,
-0.819486141204834,
0.8403100967407227,
0.0419326089322567,
-0.9487473368644714,
0.5748438239097595,
-0.5779032111167908,
-0.6571542620658875,
-0.05157721787691116,
-0.4403689205646515,
-0.2583862245082855,
0.23124758899211884,
0.15103602409362793,
0.3661932945251465,
-0.47294360399246216,
0.46065664291381836,
-0.8063428997993469,
-0.28836697340011597,
0.30717700719833374,
-0.5952339768409729,
0.733529269695282,
0.20153062045574188,
-0.32831788063049316,
-0.07381566613912582,
-0.6740913987159729,
0.06880715489387512,
-0.026770275086164474,
-0.3985426425933838,
-0.3097851872444153,
0.31717145442962646,
0.28624409437179565,
0.2128666192293167,
0.5051031708717346,
-0.6604775190353394,
-0.298858642578125,
-0.2962521016597748,
0.12984023988246918,
1.0653012990951538,
-0.16652478277683258,
0.621444582939148,
-0.3449172377586365,
0.3905637860298157,
-0.14616182446479797,
0.3220325708389282,
0.3053956627845764,
-0.32500386238098145,
-0.6140080094337463,
-0.19916941225528717,
0.2965926229953766,
0.2766178846359253,
-0.2527218163013458,
0.4594895541667938,
-0.30177730321884155,
-0.48955485224723816,
-0.30447524785995483,
0.2617485821247101,
0.5238609313964844,
0.3768778443336487,
0.16995348036289215,
-0.4971414804458618,
-0.49099481105804443,
-1.1459323167800903,
-0.542539656162262,
0.14387592673301697,
-0.0608588345348835,
0.37213730812072754,
0.3734232187271118,
-0.05216873064637184,
0.9313734173774719,
-0.38895922899246216,
-0.3283209502696991,
-0.15733247995376587,
-0.1460922360420227,
0.18181265890598297,
0.29858505725860596,
0.3000452220439911,
-0.5169379115104675,
-0.41935622692108154,
-0.24349839985370636,
-0.5656678676605225,
-0.7831861972808838,
0.17685124278068542,
-0.20838338136672974,
0.23450936377048492,
0.4139176309108734,
-0.46772605180740356,
0.22476555407047272,
0.8150482177734375,
-0.5505907535552979,
0.49483639001846313,
0.2608036994934082,
0.08230667561292648,
-0.7764667868614197,
0.04320056736469269,
0.016283070668578148,
-0.09617571532726288,
-0.17262548208236694,
-0.04109375178813934,
0.0437001958489418,
0.3169366419315338,
-0.52434241771698,
0.8029606938362122,
-0.32797640562057495,
-0.3207188546657562,
-0.2702321410179138,
0.3475240170955658,
0.09450633078813553,
0.2515696883201599,
-0.10895521193742752,
0.247221902012825,
0.34338659048080444,
-0.4859798848628998,
0.13262084126472473,
0.06680627167224884,
-0.31201282143592834,
1.0548713207244873,
-0.5953747034072876,
0.055927906185388565,
-0.09550037980079651,
0.5668913125991821,
-0.5736376643180847,
0.006244503892958164,
0.04395090416073799,
-0.26723918318748474,
-0.022036992013454437,
0.1549939662218094,
-0.6670977473258972,
-0.2826290428638458,
-0.34234094619750977,
0.66942298412323,
0.11738157272338867,
-0.3835359215736389,
0.8352916836738586,
0.6811941266059875,
-0.11763431131839752,
-0.7232787013053894,
-0.600443959236145,
0.03092767484486103,
-0.28868329524993896,
-0.692405641078949,
0.5435490608215332,
-0.2941248118877411,
-0.4591621458530426,
-0.048649728298187256,
-0.4430204927921295,
0.2992857098579407,
0.12689806520938873,
0.2937505841255188,
0.0981573835015297,
0.13294757902622223,
-0.11972910165786743,
0.07201209664344788,
0.10556267946958542,
0.41126003861427307,
0.028214214369654655,
0.7815492749214172,
-0.0765601247549057,
-0.6219843029975891,
0.04589081183075905,
0.3532754182815552,
0.13535788655281067,
-0.13840803503990173,
0.5700750350952148,
0.7620894908905029,
-0.5055915117263794,
-0.3485580086708069,
-0.9017322063446045,
-0.0335753932595253,
-0.4445863664150238,
0.4343693256378174,
-0.07507328689098358,
-0.9822332859039307,
0.7644985914230347,
0.26548296213150024,
0.16578683257102966,
0.3270112872123718,
0.868614912033081,
0.20086491107940674,
0.9391183257102966,
0.4423586130142212,
-0.22311317920684814,
0.29305851459503174,
0.06553282588720322,
0.13271449506282806,
-0.902430534362793,
-0.4601250886917114,
-0.6740093231201172,
-0.45324990153312683,
-0.7471122741699219,
-0.4341280460357666,
0.27788329124450684,
-0.2844761610031128,
-0.30063745379447937,
-0.12603242695331573,
-0.21487785875797272,
0.795829713344574,
0.46550846099853516,
0.19933468103408813,
0.3410585820674896,
-0.2700556814670563,
-0.050811704248189926,
-0.08847928792238235,
-0.36577126383781433,
-0.7120725512504578,
1.4833147525787354,
0.44877052307128906,
0.7304694056510925,
0.16604627668857574,
0.5828079581260681,
0.5787079930305481,
0.5916117429733276,
-0.649845540523529,
0.6852402091026306,
-0.28388115763664246,
-0.8865743279457092,
-0.08321918547153473,
-0.5478718876838684,
-0.8188295364379883,
0.3948858082294464,
-0.26015594601631165,
-0.8205919861793518,
0.13262830674648285,
0.024215945973992348,
-0.033785056322813034,
0.23742979764938354,
-0.6633557677268982,
0.9449188709259033,
-0.214629128575325,
-0.5697749257087708,
-0.2379058450460434,
-0.5656350255012512,
0.45221593976020813,
-0.16580843925476074,
0.4171893000602722,
-0.4189422130584717,
0.006668571848422289,
0.8318072557449341,
-0.17461349070072174,
0.8608558177947998,
-0.38038748502731323,
-0.3420350253582001,
0.1275893896818161,
0.2125445306301117,
0.29913005232810974,
0.22421547770500183,
-0.31854432821273804,
0.4006066918373108,
-0.00817528460174799,
-0.5299942493438721,
-0.3149682879447937,
0.9568342566490173,
-0.5766777396202087,
-0.39147689938545227,
-0.2917742133140564,
-0.7279486656188965,
-0.5178738236427307,
0.12591302394866943,
-0.10935840010643005,
0.1835540384054184,
-0.4712769389152527,
0.35728052258491516,
0.5428028106689453,
-0.4731299579143524,
0.4943021833896637,
0.5964540839195251,
-0.16915903985500336,
-0.29532986879348755,
0.648630678653717,
-0.15596067905426025,
0.41528141498565674,
0.32118913531303406,
0.10416781157255173,
-0.39879265427589417,
-0.5604658126831055,
0.06481582671403885,
0.060491956770420074,
-0.9440928101539612,
-0.313667356967926,
-0.6465708613395691,
0.006780050229281187,
-0.3992721736431122,
-0.10595040023326874,
-0.3089171051979065,
-0.06765764951705933,
-0.07173839956521988,
0.0282751377671957,
-0.2008088380098343,
0.6330302953720093,
-0.0786958634853363,
0.318691611289978,
-0.5247326493263245,
0.3909675180912018,
0.1855342537164688,
0.6253645420074463,
0.0522809699177742,
-0.509809672832489,
-0.18843413889408112,
-0.05630293861031532,
-0.706491231918335,
-0.6431921720504761,
0.13328342139720917,
-0.05571221560239792,
0.8180074095726013,
0.2099505364894867,
-0.14811614155769348,
0.19842568039894104,
-0.4558432102203369,
0.7673146724700928,
0.15175743401050568,
-1.2890384197235107,
0.14775291085243225,
-0.45077070593833923,
0.21674984693527222,
0.6296053528785706,
-0.05113569647073746,
-0.4853484630584717,
-0.4661422669887543,
-0.45803672075271606,
-0.998223602771759,
0.3830094635486603,
0.145832359790802,
0.3271127939224243,
-0.38320568203926086,
-0.06388203054666519,
0.19588258862495422,
0.28585076332092285,
-1.1189519166946411,
-0.167097270488739,
0.1574682891368866,
-0.38786211609840393,
0.035363711416721344,
-0.2747093141078949,
-0.043366678059101105,
0.08819540590047836,
0.4600730538368225,
-0.05648069456219673,
-0.018225399777293205,
-0.06894198060035706,
-0.2639816105365753,
0.060999926179647446,
0.4504682421684265,
0.24654820561408997,
0.8811028599739075,
-0.1518140435218811,
0.05252651870250702,
0.44409310817718506,
-0.41746070981025696,
-0.09490741044282913,
0.06996693462133408,
-0.13175208866596222,
-0.1508108377456665,
0.29273247718811035,
0.3673988878726959,
0.1423627734184265,
-0.7624380588531494,
0.7509921193122864,
0.11299889534711838,
-0.11706337332725525,
-0.2507353127002716,
-0.038577888160943985,
0.27841895818710327,
0.3747371733188629,
0.14137479662895203,
-0.2613327205181122,
0.46729305386543274,
-0.4729485809803009,
-0.04598267376422882,
0.5908703207969666,
-0.21081072092056274,
0.007732045371085405,
0.6724293231964111,
0.4000680148601532,
-0.11919653415679932,
0.2641284167766571,
-0.10252184420824051,
-0.24323584139347076,
0.695198118686676,
0.4264742434024811,
0.831552267074585,
-0.08974254131317139,
0.196682408452034,
0.1533529907464981,
0.39054012298583984,
0.00629952410236001,
0.2055164873600006,
0.15982282161712646,
-0.842359185218811,
-0.6412757039070129,
-1.0118199586868286,
-0.40164756774902344,
0.19576509296894073,
-0.6995795965194702,
0.35361331701278687,
-0.4351406991481781,
-0.2524982690811157,
-0.00845529418438673,
0.04168307036161423,
-0.9005109667778015,
0.1987622082233429,
0.5126088857650757,
0.8565913438796997,
-1.0170018672943115,
0.34503698348999023,
0.33629560470581055,
-0.09101863950490952,
-0.37447962164878845,
0.05182771384716034,
0.11503295600414276,
-0.706656277179718,
0.5963488817214966,
0.2718487083911896,
-0.021566390991210938,
-0.372653067111969,
-0.4249699115753174,
-0.574352502822876,
0.8770134449005127,
0.5178830623626709,
-0.6474747061729431,
0.06958803534507751,
0.4008001983165741,
0.5230161547660828,
-0.43932148814201355,
0.21795332431793213,
0.9153623580932617,
0.7310917377471924,
-0.34596577286720276,
-0.9592557549476624,
0.1974838227033615,
-0.17487017810344696,
0.19819940626621246,
-0.02670682594180107,
-0.648820161819458,
0.6818305253982544,
0.1803615540266037,
0.0025359191931784153,
-0.01768144592642784,
0.4848804473876953,
0.4908057153224945,
0.49485114216804504,
0.6084260940551758,
0.7232248187065125,
0.6325300931930542,
-0.20777694880962372,
0.8790540099143982,
-0.09353387355804443,
0.25457364320755005,
1.4511218070983887,
-0.6796590089797974,
0.46215587854385376,
0.5597324371337891,
-0.2813102602958679,
0.3133443295955658,
0.5749444961547852,
-0.04344847798347473,
0.3395504057407379,
0.8236402273178101,
-0.4914528727531433,
-0.14324605464935303,
-0.4605378806591034,
-0.28478047251701355,
0.49405238032341003,
0.32092586159706116,
-0.3594353497028351,
-0.18577279150485992,
-0.16488388180732727,
0.143268421292305,
0.543698787689209,
-0.49281376600265503,
0.5831141471862793,
0.040245212614536285,
-0.5189750790596008,
0.024723779410123825,
0.21369795501232147,
0.880098819732666,
-0.36511555314064026,
0.18482494354248047,
-0.34632381796836853,
0.07903213053941727,
-0.3512496054172516,
-0.9360623359680176,
0.27585819363594055,
-0.03853054717183113,
-0.28581658005714417,
-0.03063916228711605,
0.4776657521724701,
-0.26051202416419983,
-0.45178279280662537,
0.5754269361495972,
0.41656550765037537,
-0.08322877436876297,
-0.13688936829566956,
-0.5611820816993713,
0.5443101525306702,
-0.09007693082094193,
-0.1696263998746872,
0.25447097420692444,
0.32578784227371216,
-0.12885114550590515,
0.5280331373214722,
0.5182445645332336,
0.23234699666500092,
0.07653697580099106,
0.5921251177787781,
0.7652193903923035,
-0.6047022938728333,
-0.2662373185157776,
-1.0042020082473755,
0.4867725074291229,
-0.2727085053920746,
-0.06325109302997589,
0.7308366298675537,
0.77366042137146,
1.0432437658309937,
0.1663389354944229,
0.8556100726127625,
-0.16371145844459534,
0.4191761910915375,
-0.5740100741386414,
0.45039883255958557,
-0.31782981753349304,
0.5376247763633728,
-0.649934709072113,
-1.4677269458770752,
-0.3040795922279358,
0.348919540643692,
-0.41304147243499756,
0.4258454442024231,
0.7532750964164734,
0.7640346884727478,
0.04471375793218613,
0.07884565740823746,
0.10849625617265701,
0.10765364021062851,
0.4132809638977051,
0.6099785566329956,
0.8038043975830078,
-0.09787644445896149,
0.4299985468387604,
0.020186355337500572,
-0.12307416647672653,
-0.04145357012748718,
-1.2348593473434448,
-0.9780444502830505,
-0.20312543213367462,
-0.08104852586984634,
-0.5057505965232849,
-0.052909329533576965,
0.8439379930496216,
0.5081732273101807,
-0.6489652395248413,
-0.3199045658111572,
0.1519670933485031,
0.31794893741607666,
0.22327710688114166,
-0.28618499636650085,
0.18865756690502167,
-0.2588801383972168,
-0.8326475024223328,
0.019051402807235718,
0.13270427286624908,
-0.3849624693393707,
-0.4299400746822357,
-0.1479278802871704,
0.09937011450529099,
0.147880420088768,
0.8011805415153503,
-0.1536961942911148,
-0.5839557647705078,
-0.32747912406921387,
-0.1665162444114685,
-0.09031739830970764,
-0.2056560218334198,
0.6929212212562561,
-0.4359261095523834,
0.28575342893600464,
0.4442993104457855,
0.7925612330436707,
0.26924023032188416,
-0.3160507082939148,
0.5057042837142944,
-0.6377454400062561,
-0.1548115760087967,
0.25900551676750183,
0.46828457713127136,
0.5658113956451416,
-0.13962998986244202,
0.4960474371910095,
0.1280767023563385,
-0.692277729511261,
-0.8789489269256592,
0.2114342302083969,
-1.240102767944336,
-0.1567988395690918,
1.4865950345993042,
0.16923145949840546,
-0.07621295005083084,
0.07661247998476028,
-0.15872101485729218,
0.14132577180862427,
-0.40648436546325684,
0.8366607427597046,
0.8991286158561707,
0.2930590510368347,
0.32874274253845215,
-0.6572607159614563,
0.1537391096353531,
0.5024712085723877,
-1.024912714958191,
0.19457058608531952,
0.8350626230239868,
0.46820956468582153,
-0.17493100464344025,
0.6668011546134949,
-0.5472545027732849,
0.1158241406083107,
-0.3590546250343323,
0.3004174530506134,
0.4624903202056885,
-0.06798814237117767,
-0.16147468984127045,
0.1307874321937561,
0.016894858330488205,
0.24731779098510742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02397v1 | Learning to Refine with Fine-Grained Natural Language Feedback | 2024-07-02T16:15:01 | 2024-07-02T16:15:01 | Manya Wadhwa, Xinyu Zhao, Junyi Jessy Li, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has explored the capability of large language models (LLMs) to
identify and correct errors in LLM-generated responses. These refinement
approaches frequently evaluate what sizes of models are able to do refinement
for what problems, but less attention is paid to what effective feedback for
refinement looks like. In this work, we propose looking at refinement with
feedback as a composition of three distinct LLM competencies: (1)
identification of bad generations; (2) fine-grained natural language feedback
generation; (3) refining with fine-grained feedback. The first step can be
implemented with a high-performing discriminative model and steps 2 and 3 can
be implemented either via prompted or fine-tuned LLMs. A key property of this
approach is that the step 2 critique model can give fine-grained feedback about
errors, made possible by offloading the discrimination to a separate model in
step 1. We show that models of different capabilities benefit from refining
with this approach on the task of improving factual consistency of document
grounded summaries. Overall, our proposed method consistently outperforms
existing end-to-end refinement approaches and current trained models not
fine-tuned for factuality critiquing. | [
-0.26040714979171753,
-0.9488218426704407,
0.540238082408905,
-0.10274124890565872,
-0.08213329315185547,
0.3058340549468994,
-0.6793813705444336,
-0.5308875441551208,
-0.10788741707801819,
0.7900705933570862,
-0.5671647191047668,
-0.4556916058063507,
-0.40252017974853516,
0.200831800699234,
-0.320229172706604,
1.4159082174301147,
-0.05744006857275963,
0.169353649020195,
-0.3264766037464142,
-0.1606331765651703,
-0.6407243609428406,
-0.3985573649406433,
-0.611208975315094,
-0.612272322177887,
0.4185766577720642,
0.8553107976913452,
0.4444653391838074,
0.4352269768714905,
0.32433122396469116,
0.29052332043647766,
-0.1913015991449356,
0.6327705383300781,
-0.8464171290397644,
0.05549490451812744,
-0.46135133504867554,
-0.6067389845848083,
-0.27200454473495483,
0.11872458457946777,
0.4234656095504761,
0.8238826990127563,
-0.18406903743743896,
0.29284152388572693,
0.5238870978355408,
0.8930577635765076,
-0.5827335715293884,
0.2553502023220062,
-0.7165027856826782,
-0.14241191744804382,
-0.07413448393344879,
-0.2793581187725067,
-0.6679487228393555,
-0.6963033676147461,
0.1939796656370163,
-0.530800461769104,
0.7829671502113342,
-0.12862592935562134,
1.0115941762924194,
0.29138389229774475,
-0.2262570708990097,
-0.49120286107063293,
-1.0118781328201294,
0.8897802829742432,
-0.9200822710990906,
0.11216514557600021,
0.4621202349662781,
0.27843376994132996,
-0.11145800352096558,
-0.578523576259613,
-0.37673401832580566,
-0.4933948218822479,
-0.2011946141719818,
0.030260933563113213,
0.13955137133598328,
0.0026700934395194054,
0.08512423187494278,
0.6024932861328125,
0.026152724400162697,
0.323886513710022,
-0.4906986355781555,
-0.28537559509277344,
0.7111169695854187,
0.025898221880197525,
-0.21065297722816467,
0.014903668314218521,
-0.21204885840415955,
0.20797184109687805,
-0.5936034321784973,
0.06580723822116852,
0.3532589375972748,
0.7528141736984253,
0.021936513483524323,
0.6067408323287964,
-0.7374110221862793,
0.6512688398361206,
0.4435321092605591,
-0.30088114738464355,
0.019673051312565804,
-0.4054053723812103,
-0.02881929837167263,
-0.08127646148204803,
0.3011992871761322,
0.6359269022941589,
0.3712572753429413,
-0.3745134174823761,
-0.6240837574005127,
-0.02274460904300213,
0.49241313338279724,
-0.7760552763938904,
-0.10883132368326187,
0.09044153243303299,
-0.489042192697525,
-0.418151319026947,
0.1187310442328453,
-0.9103190898895264,
-0.6392301917076111,
-0.9462407231330872,
0.23208792507648468,
-0.44169947504997253,
0.0308087058365345,
0.18348251283168793,
0.07966092973947525,
0.222141295671463,
0.7167752385139465,
-1.0751228332519531,
0.3814679980278015,
0.8191039562225342,
0.5996857285499573,
0.14827363193035126,
-0.06989479809999466,
-0.7753676176071167,
0.006758860778063536,
-0.24240900576114655,
1.0294142961502075,
-0.4555516541004181,
-0.11831433326005936,
0.1905989646911621,
-0.05936579406261444,
0.20181067287921906,
-0.8541214466094971,
0.7201647758483887,
-0.3691002428531647,
0.13671913743019104,
-0.4395892024040222,
-0.5996189117431641,
-0.3529953062534332,
0.6131688952445984,
-0.5779006481170654,
1.041399359703064,
0.2502855360507965,
-0.7220450043678284,
0.5069087147712708,
-0.25874581933021545,
-0.2952520251274109,
-0.011336302384734154,
0.038028936833143234,
-0.3718808591365814,
0.4529908299446106,
0.08400564640760422,
0.40837207436561584,
-0.3287324607372284,
0.40245169401168823,
-0.3509485125541687,
-0.1381818801164627,
0.02977587841451168,
-0.39522501826286316,
0.09246684610843658,
0.1285073310136795,
-0.3004857897758484,
0.2520482838153839,
-1.2939943075180054,
0.10730830579996109,
-0.09530080109834671,
-0.6685215830802917,
-0.0414171926677227,
0.006547512486577034,
-0.19309809803962708,
-0.046191465109586716,
0.20110160112380981,
-0.4954036772251129,
0.09235518425703049,
-0.5580424070358276,
0.3000117838382721,
0.6024217009544373,
0.09103702753782272,
0.3994288742542267,
-0.6214243173599243,
0.25379523634910583,
-0.11800450831651688,
-0.1565508246421814,
-0.13674584031105042,
-0.018384750932455063,
-1.055446982383728,
0.06231207773089409,
0.44329336285591125,
0.268620103597641,
-0.668376088142395,
0.35063302516937256,
-0.18036192655563354,
-0.538537859916687,
-0.4854445457458496,
0.46828141808509827,
0.4834315776824951,
0.6062590479850769,
0.42982104420661926,
-0.4857429265975952,
-0.5952256321907043,
-0.7475301027297974,
-0.21999968588352203,
-0.1885032057762146,
0.030657142400741577,
-0.046024493873119354,
0.2823358178138733,
-0.18111667037010193,
1.1121225357055664,
-0.2659367322921753,
-0.2556816339492798,
-0.36989903450012207,
0.34951603412628174,
-0.10489106178283691,
0.42428773641586304,
0.20280678570270538,
-0.28313595056533813,
-0.22562719881534576,
0.1494833081960678,
-0.3602876663208008,
-0.4255281984806061,
-0.1365242302417755,
0.12457133084535599,
0.18193385004997253,
0.6744816899299622,
-0.42160293459892273,
0.18933628499507904,
0.24325814843177795,
-0.2599289119243622,
0.761993408203125,
-0.23043693602085114,
-0.11731915175914764,
-0.7595917582511902,
0.0941133201122284,
0.06469552963972092,
-0.2818404734134674,
-0.6195858716964722,
0.29505082964897156,
-0.1786143183708191,
0.21140801906585693,
-0.21819163858890533,
0.4367939531803131,
-0.3448552191257477,
0.24670547246932983,
-0.3868340253829956,
0.37116771936416626,
0.25585541129112244,
0.43264633417129517,
-0.21856634318828583,
0.4332587718963623,
0.045194126665592194,
-0.7720353603363037,
0.40209129452705383,
0.03892330080270767,
-0.15032953023910522,
0.7903669476509094,
-0.514349102973938,
0.028658835217356682,
-0.4422968327999115,
0.2767418622970581,
-0.9127442836761475,
-0.4083247482776642,
-0.05548376217484474,
-0.30740493535995483,
0.4720155596733093,
-0.2620496153831482,
-0.3729128837585449,
-0.227476105093956,
-0.38550063967704773,
0.010985016822814941,
0.17152634263038635,
-0.599818229675293,
0.6289896965026855,
-0.02052520029246807,
-0.22777144610881805,
-0.3821037709712982,
-0.6262750029563904,
-0.10878302156925201,
0.0782400518655777,
-0.5133642554283142,
0.23420508205890656,
0.04721076413989067,
-0.42513906955718994,
-0.24683044850826263,
-0.18075136840343475,
-0.025161195546388626,
0.18313276767730713,
0.06651096791028976,
0.11912310868501663,
-0.19136247038841248,
0.1229763776063919,
-0.35694795846939087,
-0.13625101745128632,
-0.07031619548797607,
-0.08949320018291473,
0.49029096961021423,
-0.30449241399765015,
-0.2725500464439392,
-0.2884470820426941,
0.12649855017662048,
0.6638424396514893,
-0.4599270522594452,
0.4185510277748108,
0.5633366107940674,
-0.2468142956495285,
-0.4474777281284332,
-0.8718976974487305,
-0.3661257326602936,
-0.39487066864967346,
0.2662549912929535,
-0.06520749628543854,
-0.9905944466590881,
0.6892619132995605,
-0.07000752538442612,
0.23291552066802979,
0.44403260946273804,
0.6562689542770386,
0.06911870837211609,
0.7493643164634705,
0.775495707988739,
0.1438361406326294,
0.16122055053710938,
-0.323241263628006,
0.1607733815908432,
-0.7211952805519104,
-0.45856258273124695,
-0.7698206305503845,
-0.23772361874580383,
-0.4252942204475403,
-0.22641386091709137,
-0.38396990299224854,
0.44534921646118164,
-0.11769863963127136,
-0.06953128427267075,
-0.30182960629463196,
0.7021739482879639,
0.6659975647926331,
0.18183186650276184,
0.37154656648635864,
-0.08835942298173904,
-0.3139928877353668,
-0.02944186143577099,
-0.44417181611061096,
-0.9656192064285278,
0.8087854981422424,
0.6417312622070312,
0.8819978833198547,
0.050861891359090805,
0.7022200226783752,
-0.006761036813259125,
0.5948929190635681,
-1.0021051168441772,
0.4729525148868561,
-0.17121119797229767,
-0.47250789403915405,
-0.06696625798940659,
-0.3533499538898468,
-0.5633602142333984,
0.04509599879384041,
-0.2564540505409241,
-0.582094132900238,
0.01793416030704975,
0.25239136815071106,
-0.7458869218826294,
0.22064505517482758,
-0.8635514974594116,
0.6564480662345886,
0.12947779893875122,
-0.5615981817245483,
-0.22537465393543243,
-0.6179332137107849,
0.4094306230545044,
-0.05836494639515877,
0.11593765765428543,
-0.15143093466758728,
0.4793126583099365,
0.37566810846328735,
-0.7285981774330139,
1.25469970703125,
-0.22371022403240204,
-0.4218843877315521,
0.4863380193710327,
0.06557725369930267,
0.6234986186027527,
0.06930887699127197,
-0.020349176600575447,
-0.37642428278923035,
-0.12703493237495422,
-0.1949658840894699,
-0.6858353018760681,
0.4940223693847656,
-0.5614554286003113,
-0.67946857213974,
0.033919088542461395,
-0.30116456747055054,
-0.5146389007568359,
0.25741106271743774,
0.22083516418933868,
0.7086208462715149,
-0.2787632942199707,
0.23817726969718933,
0.702433168888092,
0.04583717882633209,
0.2649545669555664,
0.8398865461349487,
-0.3082951307296753,
-0.3831152617931366,
0.8346683382987976,
0.07153117656707764,
0.40301313996315,
0.1450301855802536,
0.12733300030231476,
-0.28603434562683105,
-0.7346379160881042,
-0.2886768579483032,
0.28948867321014404,
-0.8916193842887878,
-0.4558968245983124,
-0.30516403913497925,
-0.24217815697193146,
-0.22729821503162384,
-0.09954588860273361,
-0.5748046636581421,
-0.24794572591781616,
-0.6405391693115234,
-0.27740445733070374,
0.0758725181221962,
0.9301601648330688,
0.12528887391090393,
0.3498760461807251,
-1.0092613697052002,
0.3469603955745697,
0.33426374197006226,
0.6663525104522705,
0.3067353665828705,
-0.7618256211280823,
-0.37368687987327576,
0.19902218878269196,
-0.6830882430076599,
-0.5284215807914734,
0.13852298259735107,
0.2013203650712967,
0.36678895354270935,
0.49633944034576416,
0.04411828890442848,
0.6484864950180054,
-0.5584660768508911,
0.8730164766311646,
-0.03925040736794472,
-0.7215101718902588,
0.4838480055332184,
-0.18508723378181458,
0.3015832304954529,
1.1678392887115479,
-0.0717221349477768,
-0.3745509386062622,
-0.7628262042999268,
-0.5803194642066956,
-0.7023570537567139,
0.6060904860496521,
-0.16344620287418365,
0.179293692111969,
-0.11466246098279953,
0.5607293248176575,
0.2772907316684723,
0.14044691622257233,
-0.6906774640083313,
0.2172134816646576,
-0.12645994126796722,
-0.13398605585098267,
0.11052682250738144,
-0.5941822528839111,
-0.34163013100624084,
-0.0672445222735405,
0.8985274434089661,
-0.3380151391029358,
-0.31128302216529846,
0.24305200576782227,
-0.16025488078594208,
-0.238994762301445,
0.6672948598861694,
0.7141602635383606,
0.7342233061790466,
-0.24518488347530365,
0.2903910279273987,
0.09774964302778244,
-0.36119624972343445,
0.11605949699878693,
0.05253605172038078,
-0.2704741954803467,
0.20948036015033722,
0.5581976771354675,
0.6644388437271118,
0.23255665600299835,
-0.4827014207839966,
0.37881699204444885,
0.03827294707298279,
-0.2536681890487671,
0.0685780793428421,
0.048560939729213715,
-0.1716129034757614,
0.14611944556236267,
0.19877485930919647,
0.30174627900123596,
-0.015350105240941048,
-0.631679356098175,
0.33087319135665894,
0.2863854169845581,
-0.4834742844104767,
-0.30889299511909485,
0.393991082906723,
0.5800413489341736,
0.045293670147657394,
0.508400022983551,
-0.3781300485134125,
-0.5909662842750549,
0.3489994406700134,
0.5650253891944885,
0.8941876292228699,
-0.06974362581968307,
0.2735741436481476,
0.5068578720092773,
0.28174227476119995,
-0.43223318457603455,
0.029713556170463562,
0.09089215099811554,
-0.7744227647781372,
-0.7447429895401001,
-0.7532417178153992,
-0.4356967806816101,
0.23206034302711487,
-0.8608680963516235,
0.48671528697013855,
-0.6637997031211853,
-0.19908270239830017,
-0.05803748220205307,
0.1930764615535736,
-0.4022766351699829,
0.3344358801841736,
0.20583626627922058,
0.8553763628005981,
-0.6620538830757141,
0.4328385293483734,
0.5988984704017639,
-0.5123170018196106,
-0.9863554835319519,
0.1877146065235138,
0.12726132571697235,
-0.5486311316490173,
0.696929395198822,
0.4725934863090515,
-0.15253302454948425,
-0.04936938360333443,
-0.4872337877750397,
-0.7182474732398987,
0.8415243029594421,
0.31108787655830383,
-0.8065809607505798,
-0.00944103579968214,
0.001961245434358716,
0.7983246445655823,
-0.1653740406036377,
0.2462751418352127,
0.8812714219093323,
0.36719608306884766,
0.13532070815563202,
-0.9481229782104492,
-0.07720696181058884,
-0.0869009792804718,
0.1677824705839157,
0.08567732572555542,
-0.6598042249679565,
0.3938833475112915,
-0.42755189538002014,
-0.38122719526290894,
0.1815578192472458,
0.8083163499832153,
0.22776810824871063,
0.31347811222076416,
0.25927767157554626,
0.9662227630615234,
0.9402557015419006,
-0.23062436282634735,
1.040202021598816,
-0.22544656693935394,
0.4342467486858368,
1.5057059526443481,
-0.2548721432685852,
0.7862346172332764,
0.388286828994751,
-0.0506586916744709,
0.5339577794075012,
0.4791477918624878,
-0.0856887474656105,
0.5461767315864563,
0.40670204162597656,
-0.33204740285873413,
-0.06078098714351654,
-0.3452832102775574,
-0.06747929006814957,
0.3811725974082947,
0.1301710158586502,
-0.3078375458717346,
-0.5409943461418152,
-0.17186343669891357,
0.0672377198934555,
0.479055255651474,
-0.5475184917449951,
0.8372110724449158,
-0.05050711706280708,
-0.9524418711662292,
0.6571123003959656,
0.31838613748550415,
0.6589801907539368,
-0.3524443507194519,
-0.14807800948619843,
-0.464558482170105,
0.25341567397117615,
-0.5516768097877502,
-0.606713056564331,
0.4517233371734619,
0.2413807213306427,
-0.658918023109436,
0.009058085270226002,
0.6288814544677734,
-0.6234686970710754,
-0.29011091589927673,
0.0018535959534347057,
0.09724601358175278,
-0.37905892729759216,
0.06822466850280762,
-0.2754267752170563,
0.095892034471035,
0.24380996823310852,
-0.02862028032541275,
-0.08981313556432724,
0.6404722929000854,
0.007297184783965349,
0.6738682389259338,
0.6049587726593018,
0.2075878232717514,
-0.06859908998012543,
0.5445671677589417,
0.7553581595420837,
-0.47864463925361633,
-0.28391921520233154,
-0.8830903172492981,
0.609219491481781,
-0.09755147248506546,
-0.365410178899765,
0.7138281464576721,
0.4946654140949249,
1.091181993484497,
-0.023066218942403793,
0.7229422926902771,
0.15527327358722687,
0.8595055341720581,
-0.8148905038833618,
0.2999494969844818,
-0.11098363995552063,
0.5533112287521362,
-0.00649804575368762,
-1.0035985708236694,
-0.3744294047355652,
0.4001275897026062,
-0.31007274985313416,
0.18251442909240723,
0.6445848941802979,
0.8674882054328918,
0.09098287671804428,
0.17235440015792847,
0.015371212735772133,
0.38831064105033875,
0.4155609905719757,
0.17371700704097748,
1.0210024118423462,
-0.1658671498298645,
0.34985169768333435,
-0.23855361342430115,
-0.16217654943466187,
-0.4190044403076172,
-0.8234984278678894,
-0.789476215839386,
-0.16402746737003326,
-0.5632937550544739,
-0.5947613716125488,
-0.17393112182617188,
0.9647653102874756,
0.47890302538871765,
-0.9553037285804749,
0.05032341554760933,
-0.24855434894561768,
-0.12698066234588623,
0.1004025936126709,
-0.3158971667289734,
-0.09525945037603378,
-0.9356178045272827,
-0.5278072357177734,
0.25735682249069214,
0.2104974389076233,
0.10786116123199463,
-0.2592770755290985,
-0.07015623897314072,
0.128114715218544,
0.16525617241859436,
0.652022659778595,
0.34247738122940063,
-0.9133538007736206,
-0.4932713806629181,
-0.3762567937374115,
-0.21854175627231598,
0.03539888188242912,
0.9056217074394226,
-0.7099683284759521,
0.6174729466438293,
0.259183794260025,
0.8297622799873352,
0.2561340928077698,
0.37619394063949585,
0.6224427819252014,
-1.1640211343765259,
-0.029738370329141617,
0.2563142776489258,
0.30699020624160767,
0.7102752327919006,
-0.17800630629062653,
0.4536948502063751,
0.14895829558372498,
-0.5993179678916931,
-0.69977867603302,
0.18573154509067535,
-0.7908112406730652,
-0.13085226714611053,
1.328643798828125,
-0.012189359404146671,
0.095290906727314,
-0.2148057222366333,
-0.5215818881988525,
0.19053059816360474,
-0.2537930905818939,
0.9409804344177246,
1.04684317111969,
0.18443720042705536,
-0.035095009952783585,
-0.4277234673500061,
0.5799048542976379,
0.510974109172821,
-0.7847310900688171,
0.6105397939682007,
0.7799055576324463,
0.25001218914985657,
0.36555352807044983,
0.37139788269996643,
-0.25819092988967896,
0.12028811126947403,
-0.2895561456680298,
0.057609863579273224,
0.03288701921701431,
-0.3481786847114563,
-0.5126829147338867,
0.1438465714454651,
0.5266160368919373,
0.25516995787620544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02395v1 | Is Your AI-Generated Code Really Secure? Evaluating Large Language Models on Secure Code Generation with CodeSecEval | 2024-07-02T16:13:21 | 2024-07-02T16:13:21 | Jiexin Wang, Xitong Luo, Liuwen Cao, Hongkui He, Hailin Huang, Jiayuan Xie, Adam Jatowt, Yi Cai | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have brought significant advancements to code
generation and code repair, benefiting both novice and experienced developers.
However, their training using unsanitized data from open-source repositories,
like GitHub, raises the risk of inadvertently propagating security
vulnerabilities. Despite numerous studies investigating the safety of code
LLMs, there remains a gap in comprehensively addressing their security
features. In this work, we aim to present a comprehensive study aimed at
precisely evaluating and enhancing the security aspects of code LLMs. To
support our research, we introduce CodeSecEval, a meticulously curated dataset
designed to address 44 critical vulnerability types with 180 distinct samples.
CodeSecEval serves as the foundation for the automatic evaluation of code
models in two crucial tasks: code generation and code repair, with a strong
emphasis on security. Our experimental results reveal that current models
frequently overlook security issues during both code generation and repair
processes, resulting in the creation of vulnerable code. In response, we
propose different strategies that leverage vulnerability-aware information and
insecure code explanations to mitigate these security vulnerabilities.
Furthermore, our findings highlight that certain vulnerability types
particularly challenge model performance, influencing their effectiveness in
real-world applications. Based on these findings, we believe our study will
have a positive impact on the software engineering community, inspiring the
development of improved methods for training and utilizing LLMs, thereby
leading to safer and more trustworthy model deployment. | [
-0.19361352920532227,
-0.5884175300598145,
0.37626078724861145,
-0.12728706002235413,
-0.15388189256191254,
0.3461897671222687,
-0.20888455212116241,
-0.6708162426948547,
-0.15919078886508942,
0.626804530620575,
-0.16871553659439087,
-0.6379661560058594,
-0.5270596146583557,
-0.006061692256480455,
-0.5390818119049072,
1.0651153326034546,
0.07341412454843521,
-0.0073140766471624374,
-0.427011638879776,
0.025452593341469765,
-0.31284376978874207,
-0.7332901358604431,
-0.3713673949241638,
0.001092821592465043,
0.18786293268203735,
0.4176332354545593,
0.8114705681800842,
0.5505072474479675,
0.6984632015228271,
0.29634952545166016,
-0.005053939297795296,
0.06992834806442261,
-0.5404237508773804,
0.41435375809669495,
0.04923215135931969,
-0.5418646931648254,
-0.4613697826862335,
-0.2912067174911499,
0.1758190095424652,
0.3593977093696594,
-0.028873639181256294,
0.4299364984035492,
0.10157622396945953,
0.6445895433425903,
-0.6638662815093994,
0.021058272570371628,
-0.9671117663383484,
-0.035092685371637344,
-0.2754339277744293,
-0.24323797225952148,
-0.48727184534072876,
-0.7593485116958618,
-0.2460210621356964,
-0.09076645225286484,
-0.03812110051512718,
-0.052673760801553726,
0.5882550477981567,
0.2730550169944763,
-0.4238336980342865,
-0.3962583839893341,
-0.7319996953010559,
0.5317848324775696,
-0.8005236983299255,
0.11445615440607071,
0.4680904150009155,
0.138785719871521,
-0.20783740282058716,
-0.587306559085846,
-0.15587669610977173,
-0.5399916768074036,
0.16146035492420197,
-0.24452877044677734,
-0.30432990193367004,
0.03751678019762039,
0.3842327892780304,
0.3069568872451782,
-0.8170098662376404,
0.3392086923122406,
-0.3181993365287781,
-0.3113712668418884,
0.8357394933700562,
0.1929442435503006,
0.6088649034500122,
0.24273550510406494,
-0.2210025042295456,
-0.13375522196292877,
-1.1149166822433472,
0.052433960139751434,
0.8840075135231018,
0.14375633001327515,
-0.2450040578842163,
0.5193399786949158,
0.255858838558197,
0.4496450126171112,
-0.31608977913856506,
0.018063634634017944,
0.12754373252391815,
-0.19715408980846405,
-0.12211932241916656,
-0.09950686991214752,
0.5713809132575989,
0.19836632907390594,
0.5857533812522888,
-0.3095860481262207,
-0.4246644973754883,
0.21320679783821106,
0.5879340767860413,
-0.6788838505744934,
-0.2675288915634155,
0.42627206444740295,
-0.43945518136024475,
-0.9583398103713989,
0.1507655531167984,
-0.5594327449798584,
-0.5671769976615906,
0.035732921212911606,
-0.027688447386026382,
-0.19842930138111115,
-0.34103623032569885,
-0.10240966826677322,
0.07605788856744766,
0.13352331519126892,
0.13110728561878204,
-0.601348876953125,
-0.040579359978437424,
0.7613089084625244,
0.45951905846595764,
0.0981307104229927,
-0.19890837371349335,
-0.5222194790840149,
-0.06740342825651169,
-0.5850280523300171,
0.5590204000473022,
-0.547226071357727,
-0.4265974164009094,
0.376609742641449,
-0.2910021245479584,
0.2511198818683624,
-0.5644304752349854,
0.27745693922042847,
-0.7897084951400757,
-0.4152120351791382,
0.09138257056474686,
-0.5078486204147339,
0.23944538831710815,
0.3357023298740387,
-0.6637447476387024,
0.8389009237289429,
-0.1646212935447693,
-0.7934378385543823,
0.09708075225353241,
-0.39156946539878845,
-0.4328397512435913,
0.1456916779279709,
-0.3932283818721771,
-0.6113469004631042,
0.20207974314689636,
0.14818331599235535,
0.2978958189487457,
-0.16688013076782227,
0.39138859510421753,
-0.5530877709388733,
-0.2846994400024414,
0.7785254716873169,
-0.6137444376945496,
0.6598035097122192,
0.2956032156944275,
-0.482643723487854,
0.19799162447452545,
-0.6174119710922241,
0.2713359296321869,
0.26227810978889465,
-0.17098896205425262,
-0.3241339325904846,
-0.12814447283744812,
-0.01773281954228878,
0.006017331499606371,
0.29289954900741577,
-0.32507777214050293,
0.2447635680437088,
-0.46725669503211975,
0.4418526589870453,
1.035765290260315,
0.1436496376991272,
0.47347861528396606,
-0.1519542634487152,
0.8315362930297852,
-0.12647321820259094,
0.3942674696445465,
-0.3689144551753998,
-0.4005128741264343,
-0.2857896685600281,
-0.07591661810874939,
0.3605145514011383,
0.5052667260169983,
-0.6507877111434937,
0.3440769910812378,
-0.01438690535724163,
-0.6047682762145996,
-0.2051001787185669,
0.2888363301753998,
0.6817954182624817,
0.14056411385536194,
0.013048870489001274,
-0.12138224393129349,
-0.4348423480987549,
-0.7381863594055176,
-0.2898601293563843,
-0.4025537967681885,
-0.06757635623216629,
0.22767634689807892,
0.6697210669517517,
-0.5085220336914062,
0.654162585735321,
-0.56089186668396,
0.284801185131073,
-0.18683135509490967,
-0.07413912564516068,
-0.0969439372420311,
0.6130165457725525,
0.708677351474762,
-0.5567753314971924,
-0.026965050026774406,
-0.16691234707832336,
-0.7984560132026672,
-0.09245457500219345,
-0.1196359172463417,
-0.1475655734539032,
0.3024060130119324,
0.6824557781219482,
-0.37136194109916687,
0.40330296754837036,
0.7760908603668213,
-0.23035511374473572,
0.5230987668037415,
-0.15417557954788208,
0.04018576815724373,
-1.0266966819763184,
0.1764543205499649,
-0.27040594816207886,
-0.24445191025733948,
-0.5462323427200317,
0.5645051002502441,
0.18499986827373505,
-0.592182457447052,
-0.27205467224121094,
0.32357579469680786,
-0.48134657740592957,
-0.1346653550863266,
-0.19388525187969208,
-0.12707428634166718,
-0.048821378499269485,
0.18429838120937347,
-0.3882003724575043,
0.9032251238822937,
0.6555773615837097,
-0.31956586241722107,
0.1090058758854866,
0.06379266828298569,
-0.5048841834068298,
0.11119045317173004,
-0.7261604070663452,
0.6505851149559021,
0.1689152866601944,
0.05581076815724373,
-0.9086187481880188,
-0.35125964879989624,
0.18002331256866455,
-0.6347900629043579,
0.3513380289077759,
-0.36688026785850525,
-0.6058459877967834,
-0.21987895667552948,
-0.4375995993614197,
0.5339409112930298,
0.4134286046028137,
-0.4975103437900543,
0.16456584632396698,
0.6429019570350647,
-0.3172251284122467,
-0.5472873449325562,
-0.682478129863739,
0.3046110272407532,
-0.26665356755256653,
-0.8408722877502441,
-0.03446706756949425,
-0.16536544263362885,
-0.5726180076599121,
-0.15661916136741638,
-0.2022870033979416,
-0.23196162283420563,
0.644977331161499,
0.5472787022590637,
0.4383123219013214,
-0.10024549067020416,
0.11102920025587082,
0.06155022233724594,
-0.1286415010690689,
0.3331200182437897,
-0.2763160467147827,
0.41117602586746216,
-0.26423370838165283,
-0.6537870168685913,
-0.11408429592847824,
0.3539649546146393,
0.7470499873161316,
-0.6121120452880859,
0.6449148058891296,
0.36906248331069946,
-0.5030211210250854,
-0.42385122179985046,
-0.38368043303489685,
-0.25284120440483093,
-0.4793189764022827,
0.3601040542125702,
-0.09037711471319199,
-0.9520770311355591,
0.5026510953903198,
-0.019737035036087036,
0.23842313885688782,
0.042229216545820236,
0.47616299986839294,
-0.11651839315891266,
0.9942057728767395,
0.6376721858978271,
-0.325422465801239,
0.3391043543815613,
-0.1187809407711029,
0.35492613911628723,
-0.31694966554641724,
-0.1502169817686081,
-0.7775943279266357,
-0.031417474150657654,
-0.5555785298347473,
-0.3219924867153168,
0.3946899175643921,
0.03900747746229172,
-0.2977440357208252,
0.3681964874267578,
-0.4345761239528656,
0.4941948652267456,
0.46314090490341187,
0.13001807034015656,
0.24247361719608307,
-0.0924505889415741,
0.2934524416923523,
0.1922820508480072,
-0.4859734773635864,
-0.6515593528747559,
1.3343489170074463,
0.580501139163971,
1.1655737161636353,
0.1948266476392746,
1.046867847442627,
0.6263677477836609,
0.08237402886152267,
-0.40167349576950073,
0.46992772817611694,
0.14046214520931244,
-0.4308646619319916,
-0.1735486090183258,
-0.5334154963493347,
-0.9658829569816589,
-0.19405707716941833,
-0.18650777637958527,
-0.4953781068325043,
-0.046848420053720474,
0.2937721908092499,
-0.37739327549934387,
0.1786424219608307,
-0.7152127027511597,
0.6923016309738159,
-0.5001930594444275,
-0.15002357959747314,
-0.21669508516788483,
-0.5290878415107727,
0.5165160894393921,
-0.2721177041530609,
0.29273462295532227,
0.13491672277450562,
0.130141481757164,
0.44707006216049194,
-0.4831050634384155,
0.9492135047912598,
-0.058465950191020966,
-0.4664749801158905,
0.2981298267841339,
0.40766292810440063,
0.7104815244674683,
0.42896172404289246,
-0.06955846399068832,
0.4159505069255829,
-0.1734476238489151,
-0.35670775175094604,
-0.4332089126110077,
0.8015382289886475,
-0.6720457077026367,
-0.5585018396377563,
-0.38074737787246704,
-0.3900033235549927,
-0.2370186150074005,
0.09736667573451996,
0.28577330708503723,
0.5399115085601807,
-0.1265215277671814,
0.2176600843667984,
0.7993265986442566,
-0.5250367522239685,
0.34092867374420166,
0.17795123159885406,
-0.05075162276625633,
-0.42407935857772827,
0.6616694927215576,
-0.07908801734447479,
0.32784101366996765,
0.018965041264891624,
-0.035522229969501495,
0.07746340334415436,
-0.6808496713638306,
-0.5414396524429321,
-0.028720932081341743,
-0.6574447154998779,
-0.6315066814422607,
-0.309813529253006,
-0.39023056626319885,
-0.495798259973526,
-0.3615661859512329,
-0.4647563695907593,
-0.1649903506040573,
-0.11472510546445847,
-0.35340288281440735,
0.4434863328933716,
0.7162742018699646,
0.3174923062324524,
-0.1381034255027771,
-1.1979082822799683,
0.14853660762310028,
0.0239718034863472,
0.4004926383495331,
-0.1609572321176529,
-0.34990671277046204,
-0.45445674657821655,
0.035869572311639786,
-0.03446229174733162,
-0.8307806849479675,
0.24404284358024597,
-0.1669839471578598,
0.6428176164627075,
0.2991439402103424,
0.27635714411735535,
0.3370235562324524,
-0.4150685966014862,
0.8538636565208435,
-0.05483813211321831,
-0.9216561317443848,
0.6200518608093262,
-0.29871588945388794,
0.09474483877420425,
0.6516997218132019,
0.0014202141901478171,
-0.11567346006631851,
-0.6994381546974182,
-0.6894637942314148,
-0.9223577380180359,
0.2847881019115448,
0.4921805262565613,
0.3312879502773285,
0.02421543374657631,
0.36453744769096375,
0.009400662034749985,
0.2390655279159546,
-0.7324941158294678,
-0.23296025395393372,
0.016061441972851753,
-0.047993797808885574,
0.40764811635017395,
-0.31838223338127136,
-0.33639004826545715,
0.31007087230682373,
0.46840840578079224,
-0.09746938198804855,
0.27839913964271545,
-0.21306486427783966,
-0.2942647337913513,
-0.20150448381900787,
0.2676584720611572,
0.6835758090019226,
0.5552965402603149,
0.11462025344371796,
0.14153210818767548,
-0.018021991476416588,
-0.5610937476158142,
-0.0072130546905100346,
-0.10408265888690948,
-0.07308541983366013,
-0.17662407457828522,
0.7089016437530518,
0.45578745007514954,
0.1077156811952591,
-0.8897442817687988,
0.7062070965766907,
-0.17697125673294067,
-0.06527882814407349,
-0.5665090084075928,
0.3015885651111603,
-0.058026526123285294,
0.3869518041610718,
0.13442662358283997,
0.3452366292476654,
-0.038337405771017075,
-0.5403558611869812,
0.1935587078332901,
0.5048868060112,
-0.08664868772029877,
-0.2641677260398865,
0.6703652739524841,
0.38887670636177063,
-0.2776384949684143,
0.6984391808509827,
0.005945410579442978,
-0.4405902624130249,
1.008394718170166,
0.4324342608451843,
1.1416059732437134,
-0.17789806425571442,
0.12111416459083557,
0.1595434546470642,
0.7227153778076172,
0.06750883162021637,
0.2347184121608734,
0.06420787423849106,
-0.5857552289962769,
-0.025202637538313866,
-0.4238860607147217,
-0.4344463348388672,
0.09439892321825027,
-0.66837477684021,
0.0961303859949112,
-0.4481915235519409,
-0.20565667748451233,
-0.55411297082901,
-0.3437134623527527,
-0.42861059308052063,
-0.00033432821510359645,
0.38006988167762756,
1.0221039056777954,
-0.8563590049743652,
0.8602390885353088,
0.4906737804412842,
-0.357848584651947,
-0.7828624844551086,
0.3057313859462738,
0.023188510909676552,
-0.771720826625824,
0.3475288450717926,
0.08960651606321335,
-0.19020839035511017,
-0.28836169838905334,
-0.7293654084205627,
-0.7832753658294678,
0.9249014854431152,
0.6642074584960938,
-0.6005426049232483,
-0.0028209909796714783,
0.38402432203292847,
0.5057603120803833,
-0.11918219178915024,
0.07003503292798996,
0.22691380977630615,
0.30283626914024353,
-0.4051990807056427,
-0.6163929104804993,
-0.04697658121585846,
-0.5758405327796936,
0.17668519914150238,
0.20980970561504364,
-0.3193804919719696,
0.5167878866195679,
-0.37459370493888855,
-0.03853631019592285,
0.2741696238517761,
0.38177478313446045,
0.394564688205719,
0.31739911437034607,
0.3746923804283142,
0.2996843159198761,
0.8524326682090759,
0.0913342759013176,
1.0136988162994385,
-0.7723943591117859,
0.18399181962013245,
1.0452519655227661,
-0.39504894614219666,
0.6645497679710388,
0.24414002895355225,
0.046933505684137344,
0.23844195902347565,
0.42356738448143005,
-0.12550733983516693,
0.1939568966627121,
0.31471091508865356,
-0.1718752384185791,
-0.19089439511299133,
0.2665586471557617,
-0.634634256362915,
0.4365372359752655,
0.112742580473423,
-0.6044901013374329,
-0.015420309267938137,
0.10023707896471024,
0.2494034320116043,
0.2221190482378006,
-0.20543380081653595,
0.7636617422103882,
0.1564200222492218,
-0.4407024383544922,
0.48082825541496277,
0.0703851506114006,
0.32516783475875854,
-0.634880542755127,
0.04446062818169594,
-0.4410342872142792,
0.22076201438903809,
-0.3234383165836334,
-0.7831814289093018,
0.4119936227798462,
0.5912244319915771,
0.1127755343914032,
-0.21532128751277924,
0.7763980627059937,
-0.190204456448555,
-0.3122037947177887,
0.2642975449562073,
0.22832274436950684,
-0.06413213163614273,
-0.19799388945102692,
-0.5424653887748718,
0.3918307423591614,
-0.010503734461963177,
-0.2318549007177353,
0.6025851964950562,
0.30207955837249756,
-0.15516577661037445,
0.6397791504859924,
0.7533549666404724,
0.02944866754114628,
-0.01008505281060934,
0.1578337699174881,
0.9938036203384399,
-0.5313318371772766,
-0.345603346824646,
-1.0620611906051636,
0.5628788471221924,
-0.03198559954762459,
-0.3275015354156494,
0.751988410949707,
0.6475523114204407,
0.844628095626831,
-0.17387038469314575,
0.8922234177589417,
0.29137274622917175,
-0.013517748564481735,
-0.571686863899231,
0.998595118522644,
-0.2408696413040161,
0.735275149345398,
-0.5187225937843323,
-0.8187459111213684,
-0.44660279154777527,
0.23867705464363098,
-0.19170108437538147,
-0.01547546498477459,
0.3326510190963745,
1.0980467796325684,
0.2697989344596863,
-0.10922984033823013,
0.37131467461586,
0.15236999094486237,
0.6106005311012268,
0.3799493610858917,
0.9232609272003174,
-0.37955889105796814,
0.7467613220214844,
-0.11503928899765015,
-0.22309714555740356,
-0.16634273529052734,
-0.8235705494880676,
-0.8023505806922913,
-0.3692767918109894,
-0.34808605909347534,
-0.5663014650344849,
0.31203407049179077,
0.9544570446014404,
0.40373116731643677,
-0.7037630081176758,
-0.17591162025928497,
-0.142333522439003,
0.06312277913093567,
0.007033812813460827,
-0.16321146488189697,
0.10091507434844971,
-0.37957125902175903,
-0.35361844301223755,
0.47658732533454895,
0.35208138823509216,
-0.08410905301570892,
-0.26838091015815735,
-0.027388062328100204,
0.38989049196243286,
0.15770460665225983,
0.3871982991695404,
0.24697192013263702,
-0.3914619982242584,
-0.3849279284477234,
0.16141705214977264,
-0.4979582130908966,
-0.12154936045408249,
0.8329659700393677,
-0.38229435682296753,
0.2799198627471924,
0.49909159541130066,
0.9540988802909851,
-0.05775227025151253,
-0.0869736596941948,
0.6110012531280518,
-0.6528100371360779,
0.013101392425596714,
0.3289877772331238,
0.42570894956588745,
0.14846527576446533,
-0.7099220752716064,
0.43472424149513245,
-0.09378678351640701,
-0.7931437492370605,
-1.2150360345840454,
0.42759519815444946,
-0.5805928707122803,
-0.281010240316391,
1.2083944082260132,
-0.33178749680519104,
-0.04394946247339249,
0.006206684745848179,
-0.13215002417564392,
0.09366470575332642,
-0.2157663106918335,
0.960787832736969,
0.3421621024608612,
0.19036754965782166,
0.08034268766641617,
-0.35435789823532104,
0.3635435402393341,
0.08982338756322861,
-0.9967827200889587,
0.270674467086792,
0.4341402053833008,
0.21526029706001282,
-0.04364825785160065,
0.35930511355400085,
-0.3540361225605011,
0.4490733742713928,
0.15016213059425354,
0.16061650216579437,
-0.23559387028217316,
-0.48840948939323425,
-0.5656793713569641,
0.22050411999225616,
0.47248318791389465,
-0.07865536212921143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02389v1 | SafaRi:Adaptive Sequence Transformer for Weakly Supervised Referring Expression Segmentation | 2024-07-02T16:02:25 | 2024-07-02T16:02:25 | Sayan Nag, Koustava Goswami, Srikrishna Karanam | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | Referring Expression Segmentation (RES) aims to provide a segmentation mask
of the target object in an image referred to by the text (i.e., referring
expression). Existing methods require large-scale mask annotations. Moreover,
such approaches do not generalize well to unseen/zero-shot scenarios. To
address the aforementioned issues, we propose a weakly-supervised bootstrapping
architecture for RES with several new algorithmic innovations. To the best of
our knowledge, ours is the first approach that considers only a fraction of
both mask and box annotations (shown in Figure 1 and Table 1) for training. To
enable principled training of models in such low-annotation settings, improve
image-text region-level alignment, and further enhance spatial localization of
the target object in the image, we propose Cross-modal Fusion with Attention
Consistency module. For automatic pseudo-labeling of unlabeled samples, we
introduce a novel Mask Validity Filtering routine based on a spatially aware
zero-shot proposal scoring approach. Extensive experiments show that with just
30% annotations, our model SafaRi achieves 59.31 and 48.26 mIoUs as compared to
58.93 and 48.19 mIoUs obtained by the fully-supervised SOTA method SeqTR
respectively on RefCOCO+@testA and RefCOCO+testB datasets. SafaRi also
outperforms SeqTR by 11.7% (on RefCOCO+testA) and 19.6% (on RefCOCO+testB) in a
fully-supervised setting and demonstrates strong generalization capabilities in
unseen/zero-shot tasks. | [
-0.3734821379184723,
-0.4245680868625641,
0.24226193130016327,
0.05034754052758217,
-0.411685973405838,
-0.08142764866352081,
0.1085519790649414,
-0.8893155455589294,
0.3571934401988983,
0.20471720397472382,
-0.6621384024620056,
-0.47809621691703796,
-0.7245282530784607,
0.16228510439395905,
-0.5851282477378845,
1.0413092374801636,
0.20474673807621002,
-0.01219860278069973,
-0.3298499882221222,
-0.6008315682411194,
-0.32027000188827515,
-0.2398531585931778,
-0.3989286422729492,
-0.0015259276842698455,
0.4739392101764679,
0.6392521858215332,
0.6710630059242249,
0.5446086525917053,
0.7799136638641357,
0.28491413593292236,
-0.030650485306978226,
0.0809994712471962,
-0.37176400423049927,
0.15751193463802338,
-0.39698517322540283,
-0.23607392609119415,
-0.17638564109802246,
-0.3505108058452606,
0.5790519714355469,
0.6544983386993408,
0.2453857809305191,
0.26669013500213623,
-0.4181603491306305,
0.6329780220985413,
-0.9162784218788147,
-0.19065991044044495,
-0.8341761231422424,
0.11751218140125275,
-0.08263608068227768,
0.3040803074836731,
-0.19290490448474884,
-0.05086355283856392,
0.32663413882255554,
-0.4348728060722351,
0.6130998134613037,
0.22335901856422424,
1.1349700689315796,
0.40943482518196106,
0.01603461429476738,
0.30241966247558594,
-0.35677576065063477,
0.7349992394447327,
-0.4283701777458191,
0.37813976407051086,
0.35834407806396484,
0.4239368438720703,
0.1509229987859726,
-1.17486572265625,
-0.5118762254714966,
0.1151757463812828,
-0.2476542592048645,
0.06159844622015953,
-0.6124893426895142,
-0.16492925584316254,
0.3799615204334259,
0.31666433811187744,
-0.3145986795425415,
-0.00653283903375268,
-0.498506098985672,
-0.48830488324165344,
0.3907770812511444,
-0.017519833520054817,
0.061293672770261765,
-0.15812183916568756,
-0.5605452656745911,
0.08756164461374283,
-0.6164044737815857,
0.037603095173835754,
-0.24248172342777252,
0.22148704528808594,
-0.06566927582025528,
0.5118006467819214,
-0.4198862314224243,
0.8718991875648499,
0.24813003838062286,
0.12499188631772995,
0.28760045766830444,
-0.1906779706478119,
-0.3523489832878113,
0.1214422658085823,
0.9783626198768616,
0.19945307075977325,
0.16768990457057953,
-0.06034373864531517,
-0.14887510240077972,
0.21732284128665924,
0.261238694190979,
-0.8284963965415955,
-0.3054959177970886,
-0.2925831079483032,
-0.24600005149841309,
-0.23032473027706146,
-0.03855196014046669,
-0.9102975726127625,
-0.3764588236808777,
0.14387691020965576,
0.4163389205932617,
-0.36574622988700867,
0.2551717758178711,
0.050330933183431625,
-0.007433801889419556,
0.3381138741970062,
0.3382563889026642,
-0.8254476189613342,
0.36181434988975525,
0.2602957785129547,
0.9592681527137756,
-0.10859658569097519,
-0.16513970494270325,
-0.8459455966949463,
0.03513801470398903,
-0.06704920530319214,
1.0922614336013794,
-0.9219640493392944,
-0.4906764328479767,
-0.05227098613977432,
0.22499431669712067,
-0.13860377669334412,
-0.46964237093925476,
0.7105068564414978,
-0.36271655559539795,
0.08850271254777908,
0.17683345079421997,
-0.09109358489513397,
-0.26144763827323914,
0.26547887921333313,
-0.46193334460258484,
1.1999591588974,
0.25125402212142944,
-0.5988064408302307,
0.02491593360900879,
-0.6233400106430054,
-0.6316331028938293,
-0.1564221829175949,
0.004301670007407665,
-0.6060730814933777,
0.16996505856513977,
0.6493675708770752,
0.4490633010864258,
-0.38115036487579346,
0.016099145635962486,
-0.31490859389305115,
-0.46008482575416565,
0.18645420670509338,
-0.12239113450050354,
0.21379071474075317,
-0.0548250675201416,
-0.5011417269706726,
0.31173810362815857,
-0.9439778923988342,
-0.024756301194429398,
0.10753726214170456,
0.43518149852752686,
-0.1334000676870346,
-0.047003671526908875,
-0.17947301268577576,
0.36183494329452515,
-0.05293923616409302,
-0.654042661190033,
0.1379147320985794,
-0.2214576154947281,
0.29867568612098694,
0.49429693818092346,
0.3089076578617096,
0.5147883296012878,
-0.39707621932029724,
0.37936344742774963,
0.16835744678974152,
0.18245381116867065,
-0.5202395915985107,
-0.7601232528686523,
-1.1114155054092407,
-0.45973700284957886,
0.44884154200553894,
0.33024752140045166,
-0.6614723801612854,
0.22723828256130219,
-0.44711971282958984,
-0.5254126191139221,
-0.6725780963897705,
0.033888451755046844,
0.4840686619281769,
1.1356662511825562,
0.8666831851005554,
-0.5137288570404053,
-0.6053926348686218,
-1.3202357292175293,
0.12071943283081055,
-0.13964472711086273,
-0.20740889012813568,
0.3308039903640747,
0.2722371220588684,
-0.49117767810821533,
1.0623692274093628,
-0.658711850643158,
-0.6041114926338196,
0.07433335483074188,
0.45500555634498596,
-0.03283759951591492,
0.5477550029754639,
0.48556146025657654,
-0.8511883020401001,
-0.48848819732666016,
-0.08077771216630936,
-0.3154832124710083,
-0.4928923547267914,
0.010318604297935963,
-0.09880538284778595,
-0.0744454562664032,
0.31389227509498596,
-0.4104505479335785,
0.6605498790740967,
0.2511756718158722,
0.035378068685531616,
0.22623658180236816,
0.36631476879119873,
0.02812954969704151,
-0.8567291498184204,
0.23141489923000336,
0.5352464318275452,
-0.6005885601043701,
-0.5827543139457703,
-0.07791520655155182,
0.024875599890947342,
-0.462022989988327,
-0.8633590936660767,
0.2595168948173523,
-0.33930471539497375,
-0.1979466825723648,
-0.3384060561656952,
-0.001895545399747789,
0.05713801085948944,
0.6865294575691223,
0.5645310878753662,
0.734126627445221,
0.8634157180786133,
-0.3743709623813629,
0.134101003408432,
0.32949504256248474,
-0.2545689344406128,
0.4190134108066559,
-0.6336380839347839,
0.32398131489753723,
-0.03518279641866684,
0.4074341952800751,
-1.1319680213928223,
-0.23058666288852692,
0.4618328809738159,
-0.4739725887775421,
0.4135344624519348,
-0.2757452428340912,
-0.02348693460226059,
-0.17473630607128143,
-0.5535032749176025,
0.6289187073707581,
0.6898844242095947,
-0.419705867767334,
0.583661675453186,
0.2550157606601715,
-0.06656862050294876,
-0.5363466143608093,
-0.7622339129447937,
-0.03177925571799278,
0.0340803861618042,
-0.5317364931106567,
0.5661509037017822,
0.30779799818992615,
0.1630416065454483,
0.023524977266788483,
-0.5000176429748535,
-0.24175091087818146,
-0.18185676634311676,
0.38528597354888916,
0.3122590184211731,
-0.4139805734157562,
-0.16081967949867249,
-0.2069445103406906,
-0.326934814453125,
-0.2507080137729645,
-0.07714439928531647,
0.09385916590690613,
-0.1641407459974289,
-0.33701860904693604,
-0.5018098950386047,
0.2673929035663605,
0.5141602158546448,
-0.3245311379432678,
0.36965668201446533,
0.8574715256690979,
-0.48373568058013916,
0.08394379168748856,
-0.5627745985984802,
-0.08652620762586594,
-0.5053982138633728,
0.2688143849372864,
-0.20975986123085022,
-1.0176116228103638,
0.5603475570678711,
-0.28664448857307434,
-0.14295026659965515,
0.6836666464805603,
0.23452945053577423,
-0.1819479614496231,
0.7365083694458008,
0.7178749442100525,
-0.20584622025489807,
0.4985853135585785,
-0.10511579364538193,
0.29701393842697144,
-1.0332636833190918,
-0.2929074168205261,
-0.6113616228103638,
-0.7027008533477783,
-0.3866780996322632,
-0.7430621981620789,
0.3721148669719696,
0.0589277520775795,
-0.08327389508485794,
0.44091787934303284,
-0.7865579724311829,
0.5388913154602051,
0.6026776432991028,
0.04544811695814133,
-0.15058764815330505,
0.06950254738330841,
0.16191835701465607,
-0.09198599308729172,
-0.6369312405586243,
-0.05923200771212578,
0.6538811922073364,
0.36762791872024536,
0.8983064293861389,
-0.004149133339524269,
0.5193946957588196,
0.4659588038921356,
0.4984028935432434,
-1.0476155281066895,
0.7310247421264648,
-0.08842969685792923,
-0.339237242937088,
-0.11706375330686569,
-0.07540209591388702,
-0.6378787755966187,
0.17454051971435547,
-0.30539605021476746,
-1.2657564878463745,
0.65714430809021,
0.03547026216983795,
-0.3994084298610687,
0.09043369442224503,
-0.7894079089164734,
0.855699896812439,
0.14938226342201233,
-0.6452997922897339,
0.2330481857061386,
-1.200209379196167,
0.35350844264030457,
-0.31215742230415344,
-0.10609977692365646,
-0.36350175738334656,
-0.11997342109680176,
0.7809560298919678,
-0.4757268726825714,
0.9759852886199951,
-0.256089985370636,
0.35499870777130127,
0.5948658585548401,
0.06420319527387619,
0.5467738509178162,
-0.17562903463840485,
0.016733340919017792,
0.46677258610725403,
-0.12161407619714737,
-0.2710314989089966,
-0.7170657515525818,
0.6735042929649353,
-0.4144724905490875,
-0.735086977481842,
-0.6308635473251343,
-0.17228245735168457,
-0.6714181900024414,
0.12117960304021835,
0.25705376267433167,
0.2087627500295639,
0.16032356023788452,
0.35729625821113586,
0.5396646857261658,
0.12792016565799713,
0.4849134683609009,
0.6490111351013184,
0.19780687987804413,
-0.5129007697105408,
1.0189909934997559,
-0.3628785014152527,
0.06280192732810974,
0.5502875447273254,
0.22513188421726227,
-0.41893330216407776,
-0.5741500854492188,
-0.3273649215698242,
0.038708459585905075,
-0.7037830352783203,
-0.9586229920387268,
-0.4641267657279968,
-0.1613832265138626,
-0.4327428936958313,
-0.3444116711616516,
-0.2770242691040039,
-0.5825852751731873,
-0.39278173446655273,
0.09672261029481888,
0.3115294575691223,
0.21347421407699585,
-0.06608152389526367,
0.5161438584327698,
-1.0153175592422485,
0.5691176056861877,
0.27262791991233826,
0.08302716910839081,
-0.346189945936203,
-0.7837595343589783,
-0.08161438256502151,
-0.022363292053341866,
-0.34784871339797974,
-0.7434372305870056,
0.07557789981365204,
0.46806252002716064,
0.26343032717704773,
0.397237092256546,
0.19244404137134552,
1.0725306272506714,
-0.5941881537437439,
0.994379460811615,
0.5123211741447449,
-1.0499787330627441,
0.7217321395874023,
-0.015096371993422508,
0.5154670476913452,
0.8097986578941345,
0.466582328081131,
-0.5049960017204285,
-0.161720871925354,
-0.5464537143707275,
-0.9312716126441956,
0.9781365990638733,
0.10043272376060486,
0.11060002446174622,
-0.14470337331295013,
0.1490524709224701,
-0.037465449422597885,
-0.1569274663925171,
-0.8791652321815491,
-0.19833135604858398,
-0.2802177667617798,
-0.330593079328537,
0.35943377017974854,
-0.4048146903514862,
-0.04274991899728775,
-0.3562639653682709,
0.8220783472061157,
-0.4301811158657074,
0.4330698251724243,
0.5387371182441711,
-0.2377680242061615,
-0.33685749769210815,
0.026277439668774605,
0.6459750533103943,
0.3957589864730835,
-0.25850120186805725,
0.22562885284423828,
0.23344488441944122,
-0.4155794084072113,
0.2611570358276367,
0.25397685170173645,
-0.08566433936357498,
0.2065499722957611,
0.5403945446014404,
0.7747630476951599,
0.614820122718811,
-0.6156185865402222,
0.6946525573730469,
0.07854468375444412,
-0.12563571333885193,
0.3565223515033722,
0.1155756264925003,
-0.3909994959831238,
0.003309770720079541,
0.5534347891807556,
0.4521789252758026,
0.31336989998817444,
-0.33016282320022583,
0.45239344239234924,
0.22388094663619995,
-0.8333520889282227,
-0.30779287219047546,
0.4470108151435852,
0.2232353240251541,
-0.23729485273361206,
0.4171501398086548,
0.04462383687496185,
-0.6089457869529724,
0.5069169998168945,
0.7892628312110901,
1.0611519813537598,
-0.29099541902542114,
0.15143916010856628,
0.31852200627326965,
0.20787659287452698,
0.29746484756469727,
-0.2574136555194855,
-0.4401858150959015,
-0.6448224782943726,
-0.31509411334991455,
-0.6892564296722412,
-0.4762173891067505,
0.06462682038545609,
-0.6183496117591858,
0.3096693754196167,
-0.48603248596191406,
-0.050550077110528946,
0.41931572556495667,
-0.4171421229839325,
-0.44713324308395386,
0.5433191657066345,
0.15753811597824097,
0.9943015575408936,
-0.7358064651489258,
0.8519149422645569,
1.0055053234100342,
-0.2930000126361847,
-0.4726676046848297,
0.19238194823265076,
-0.11775464564561844,
-1.048840045928955,
0.5835487842559814,
0.38479721546173096,
-0.3895600438117981,
-0.19172070920467377,
-0.39912739396095276,
-0.8073561191558838,
0.8748869299888611,
0.28890350461006165,
-0.6828598380088806,
0.24897174537181854,
0.03454330191016197,
0.38252249360084534,
-0.2952536344528198,
0.24918340146541595,
0.4021393954753876,
0.16444522142410278,
0.7676267623901367,
-0.724079430103302,
0.0830114409327507,
-0.1568174958229065,
-0.027452377602458,
0.4390871822834015,
-0.673321008682251,
0.07755369693040848,
-0.12652148306369781,
-0.36108872294425964,
0.19797588884830475,
0.8083534836769104,
-0.2789027988910675,
0.49855977296829224,
0.42039230465888977,
0.7137507796287537,
0.4104679226875305,
-0.15340393781661987,
0.7604346871376038,
-0.1705748587846756,
0.27554962038993835,
1.2328263521194458,
-0.38851019740104675,
0.7606975436210632,
0.5756767988204956,
-0.20988701283931732,
0.5612986087799072,
0.7442467212677002,
-0.0645986869931221,
0.8246240019798279,
0.08685648441314697,
-0.49311402440071106,
-0.24444733560085297,
-0.5487579107284546,
-0.22536712884902954,
0.5249649286270142,
0.27249929308891296,
-0.44398126006126404,
-0.4701860547065735,
-0.05597752332687378,
-0.3583672046661377,
-0.14084301888942719,
-0.427906334400177,
0.9528933167457581,
-0.0035430467687547207,
-0.5108264684677124,
0.5455155968666077,
0.17525942623615265,
0.5738861560821533,
-0.8931003212928772,
-0.14758096635341644,
-0.3099929392337799,
-0.11776555329561234,
-0.3873279392719269,
-0.7647120952606201,
0.48586997389793396,
0.24483494460582733,
-0.07707127183675766,
0.09964504092931747,
1.309241771697998,
-0.19175362586975098,
-0.5036869049072266,
-0.17255103588104248,
0.16780275106430054,
0.0441584438085556,
0.13006135821342468,
-0.7856554388999939,
0.19180935621261597,
0.08399510383605957,
-0.02113071270287037,
0.35751834511756897,
0.3484017550945282,
-0.29785335063934326,
0.5209192633628845,
0.5646659731864929,
-0.4141218364238739,
-0.15949569642543793,
0.020275192335247993,
1.1107711791992188,
-0.6431804895401001,
-0.18781957030296326,
-0.8032963275909424,
0.5227153897285461,
-0.18135236203670502,
-0.25005751848220825,
0.5063976049423218,
0.6259280443191528,
0.604456901550293,
-0.11381502449512482,
0.2317221760749817,
-0.08834964781999588,
0.2073899358510971,
-0.2990403175354004,
0.12379009276628494,
-0.4097895920276642,
-0.01154771726578474,
-0.2948533892631531,
-1.0507512092590332,
-0.7420250177383423,
0.7401248812675476,
-0.3482174873352051,
-0.1702868789434433,
0.7380067706108093,
0.822821855545044,
-0.4717278480529785,
-0.02347603254020214,
0.37952902913093567,
-0.1866481900215149,
0.060754623264074326,
0.585651159286499,
0.7589359879493713,
-0.6097702383995056,
0.4918135702610016,
-0.38552406430244446,
-0.1462623029947281,
-0.07575559616088867,
-0.9908301830291748,
-0.6511215567588806,
-0.42452099919319153,
-0.7728655338287354,
-0.12620972096920013,
-0.15058547258377075,
0.6107907891273499,
1.0143455266952515,
-0.9479771256446838,
0.3577626645565033,
-0.05284789577126503,
0.04310856759548187,
-0.012238133698701859,
-0.24642394483089447,
0.44168326258659363,
-0.3402923345565796,
-0.6562716960906982,
0.5690854787826538,
0.6626091599464417,
0.1257150024175644,
0.13680683076381683,
0.18055245280265808,
-0.42119038105010986,
-0.05005994811654091,
0.42940598726272583,
0.6973366737365723,
-0.5553381443023682,
-0.4741859436035156,
-0.24436484277248383,
0.13849550485610962,
0.3072323501110077,
0.7990038394927979,
-1.1363826990127563,
0.6358280777931213,
0.09492550045251846,
1.0312244892120361,
0.7442489862442017,
0.31903398036956787,
0.15123093128204346,
-1.1851190328598022,
0.47916412353515625,
0.5828220248222351,
0.4865574538707733,
0.48820626735687256,
-0.19188037514686584,
0.7229951620101929,
0.5407853722572327,
-0.19843028485774994,
-0.8245125412940979,
0.19337008893489838,
-1.2159656286239624,
-0.0055353171192109585,
0.9672937393188477,
-0.35294589400291443,
-0.5701110363006592,
0.21816764771938324,
-0.31956279277801514,
0.03207576274871826,
-0.35395172238349915,
0.561221718788147,
0.450135737657547,
-0.3076570928096771,
-0.42347100377082825,
0.20515146851539612,
0.46046182513237,
0.6318800449371338,
-0.5772410035133362,
-0.2961658537387848,
0.7909120917320251,
0.11719287186861038,
0.44430971145629883,
0.6235458254814148,
-0.003011352615430951,
0.5721765756607056,
-0.10697434097528458,
-0.1824101358652115,
-0.21557599306106567,
-0.3083069920539856,
-0.4253487288951874,
0.22978998720645905,
-0.09153857827186584,
-0.8002997040748596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02354v1 | Talking to Machines: do you read me? | 2024-07-02T15:19:46 | 2024-07-02T15:19:46 | Lina M. Rojas-Barahona | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | In this dissertation I would like to guide the reader to the research on
dialogue but more precisely the research I have conducted during my career
since my PhD thesis. Starting from modular architectures with machine
learning/deep learning and reinforcement learning to end-to-end deep neural
networks. Besides my work as research associate, I also present the work I have
supervised in the last years.
I review briefly the state of the art and highlight the open research
problems on conversational agents. Afterwards, I present my contribution to
Task-Oriented Dialogues (TOD), both as research associate and as the industrial
supervisor of CIFRE theses. I discuss conversational QA. Particularly, I
present the work of two PhD candidates Thibault Cordier and Sebastien Montella;
as well as the work of the young researcher Quentin Brabant. Finally, I present
the scientific project, where I discuss about Large Language Models (LLMs) for
Task-Oriented Dialogue and Multimodal Task-Oriented Dialogue. | [
-0.44796985387802124,
-0.6469548344612122,
0.6985448002815247,
-0.03935318812727928,
0.007421507500112057,
0.19405235350131989,
0.012796619907021523,
-0.4711329936981201,
0.14762075245380402,
0.7276037335395813,
-0.645984947681427,
-0.29240942001342773,
-0.38846078515052795,
0.21273943781852722,
-0.3970462679862976,
0.6402565240859985,
0.11779788136482239,
0.5227035284042358,
-0.2923046946525574,
-0.054199397563934326,
-0.4612036943435669,
-0.6658288836479187,
-0.746189534664154,
-0.5508623123168945,
0.6200447678565979,
0.5740436911582947,
0.20603832602500916,
0.19794537127017975,
0.1083528995513916,
0.5557069182395935,
-0.11769721657037735,
0.07749251276254654,
-0.3553929328918457,
0.6646131873130798,
-0.20551957190036774,
-0.6724103093147278,
-0.24580568075180054,
-0.0025390195660293102,
0.27413421869277954,
0.8849218487739563,
0.2845785915851593,
0.04331750050187111,
0.1820308268070221,
0.4870895743370056,
-0.17945930361747742,
0.48299577832221985,
-0.09246388077735901,
0.1657964289188385,
0.0322914756834507,
-0.38457170128822327,
-0.583597719669342,
-0.23937009274959564,
0.31559473276138306,
-0.31837549805641174,
0.05456145480275154,
0.07116559892892838,
0.3456849157810211,
-0.02900286577641964,
-0.5215375423431396,
-0.5934884548187256,
-1.2478573322296143,
0.9923939108848572,
-0.7967877984046936,
-0.03719406947493553,
0.3997638523578644,
0.2829402685165405,
-0.2522667348384857,
-1.016082525253296,
-0.7410902976989746,
-0.4866845905780792,
-0.09012186527252197,
0.33280763030052185,
-0.21412573754787445,
0.22086699306964874,
0.16926923394203186,
0.3441472351551056,
-0.3875056803226471,
0.08418042957782745,
-0.794994056224823,
-0.13607919216156006,
0.3765849173069,
0.40887150168418884,
0.23776333034038544,
0.12160031497478485,
-0.09081701189279556,
-0.15464934706687927,
-0.2057957947254181,
0.15854229032993317,
0.6143330335617065,
0.06984754651784897,
-0.10463900119066238,
0.8034160137176514,
-0.3036288917064667,
0.6077606081962585,
-0.05447836220264435,
-0.03690313547849655,
0.03665196895599365,
-0.41231152415275574,
-0.1391461044549942,
-0.2895268499851227,
0.8119989037513733,
0.36005187034606934,
0.44955283403396606,
-0.3780510425567627,
0.1643674373626709,
-0.31535473465919495,
0.49551278352737427,
-0.5696239471435547,
-0.2797507047653198,
0.2752414643764496,
-0.743438720703125,
-0.3112531304359436,
-0.050260789692401886,
-0.5093632340431213,
-0.1905260533094406,
-0.6152516007423401,
0.151246577501297,
-0.22788658738136292,
-0.28531739115715027,
0.25679099559783936,
-0.23975692689418793,
0.2843799293041229,
0.372158020734787,
-0.8287347555160522,
0.3610393702983856,
0.7727338671684265,
0.7125959992408752,
0.04791393131017685,
-0.23534345626831055,
-0.08615050464868546,
0.019939301535487175,
-0.5087070465087891,
0.5046414136886597,
-0.5949056148529053,
-0.8844470977783203,
0.40180251002311707,
0.28718581795692444,
-0.4479602575302124,
-0.7212584614753723,
0.8483697772026062,
-0.4707903563976288,
0.6142402291297913,
0.059500109404325485,
-0.23479630053043365,
-0.20956909656524658,
0.12327397614717484,
-0.23891249299049377,
0.6595695614814758,
0.009224910289049149,
-0.7839356064796448,
-0.3668132722377777,
-0.9209725260734558,
-0.34727761149406433,
-0.22113002836704254,
-0.22748969495296478,
-0.0024468812625855207,
0.0060453289188444614,
-0.26742804050445557,
0.47983962297439575,
-0.10771070420742035,
0.35928356647491455,
-0.4040621519088745,
0.11003018915653229,
0.8394925594329834,
-0.4226115942001343,
0.8376691341400146,
0.5500964522361755,
-0.21704953908920288,
0.22756366431713104,
-0.8078672885894775,
-0.014619965106248856,
-0.2004423290491104,
-0.0904211476445198,
0.0021621654741466045,
-0.01328812912106514,
-0.022485001012682915,
0.279354453086853,
0.19621598720550537,
-0.720007598400116,
0.3291524648666382,
-0.400674432516098,
0.8088703155517578,
0.7143941521644592,
-0.052306611090898514,
0.4809843897819519,
-0.44005483388900757,
0.6666824817657471,
0.2559153735637665,
-0.2358856052160263,
-0.3795047998428345,
-0.3416830599308014,
-1.0985679626464844,
0.143254354596138,
0.24913445115089417,
0.6091601848602295,
-0.8320263624191284,
0.1907823085784912,
0.11700507253408432,
-0.3616268038749695,
-0.6177327036857605,
-0.3261028230190277,
0.36021721363067627,
0.7338317632675171,
0.09347741305828094,
-0.45634472370147705,
-0.5939714908599854,
-1.1938154697418213,
-0.01332172006368637,
-0.5139272212982178,
-0.3040178716182709,
0.5129899382591248,
0.5388504266738892,
-0.27292951941490173,
1.0244145393371582,
-0.7110609412193298,
-0.01960945874452591,
-0.28054752945899963,
0.4472190737724304,
0.2145688682794571,
0.6989461779594421,
0.25777778029441833,
-0.5177658796310425,
-0.4007534682750702,
-0.02482575550675392,
-0.8106175065040588,
-0.1641371101140976,
-0.014439843595027924,
-0.14202581346035004,
-0.1886015683412552,
0.743010938167572,
-0.7211214303970337,
-0.04558718949556351,
0.17886963486671448,
-0.28356921672821045,
0.4943144619464874,
-0.28506970405578613,
0.1768292337656021,
-1.3771952390670776,
0.18665149807929993,
-0.05065532773733139,
-0.34258365631103516,
-1.0649117231369019,
-0.4470989406108856,
-0.7020636200904846,
-0.35981518030166626,
-0.25984957814216614,
0.4729216694831848,
-0.19667400419712067,
-0.005911992862820625,
-0.43628987669944763,
0.06810342520475388,
-0.08428822457790375,
0.5498777031898499,
-0.17952249944210052,
0.7726290822029114,
0.5688840746879578,
-0.7916128039360046,
0.22728407382965088,
0.5350138545036316,
-0.33570170402526855,
0.7115843892097473,
-0.6849993467330933,
0.5155337452888489,
-0.11098533123731613,
0.20144908130168915,
-1.016273856163025,
-0.044744569808244705,
0.8494099974632263,
-0.7012825608253479,
0.3328210711479187,
0.090651735663414,
-0.2842595875263214,
-0.3904302716255188,
-0.029589684680104256,
0.16859079897403717,
0.2121277004480362,
-0.2333807498216629,
0.541226327419281,
0.516112744808197,
-0.7655879259109497,
-0.2594466209411621,
-0.5227097868919373,
0.07419659197330475,
-0.1781259924173355,
-0.7116311192512512,
0.17547161877155304,
-0.30316808819770813,
-0.7613890767097473,
-0.3466009199619293,
0.0785251334309578,
-0.5365779995918274,
-0.06847544759511948,
0.4554344117641449,
-0.21481068432331085,
-0.3229842782020569,
-0.06274191290140152,
-0.1675110012292862,
-0.5337474346160889,
0.3765525221824646,
-0.34543290734291077,
0.5800619721412659,
0.14401111006736755,
-0.3187607228755951,
-0.730180025100708,
0.5389853715896606,
0.42633962631225586,
0.062273673713207245,
0.271496057510376,
0.5148448348045349,
0.199851393699646,
0.054376959800720215,
-0.12760138511657715,
-0.3512480556964874,
-0.5264355540275574,
0.20491516590118408,
-0.3722551167011261,
-1.1820006370544434,
0.4091246724128723,
-0.4513905346393585,
0.07814046740531921,
0.2332557737827301,
0.6186977624893188,
-0.8490806818008423,
0.8311761617660522,
0.9392982125282288,
-0.09705144912004471,
0.49637460708618164,
-0.3697173297405243,
0.46755486726760864,
-0.8026081919670105,
-0.2845889627933502,
-0.9976697564125061,
-0.2381320595741272,
-0.4998488426208496,
-0.6255784630775452,
0.2750457227230072,
-0.04839855805039406,
-0.25479066371917725,
0.06333418935537338,
-0.3773530125617981,
-0.1397564709186554,
0.788734495639801,
-0.02179543673992157,
0.3726254105567932,
-0.43887314200401306,
0.007184370420873165,
0.012502615340054035,
-0.44613900780677795,
-0.8700610995292664,
0.8527095317840576,
0.5150641202926636,
0.8142926096916199,
-0.11630572378635406,
0.3858339190483093,
0.49524927139282227,
-0.21493172645568848,
-0.5985749959945679,
0.8357763290405273,
0.35133978724479675,
-0.6680589914321899,
-0.23336544632911682,
-0.165218323469162,
-1.30417001247406,
0.2868190407752991,
0.2909342646598816,
-0.9910567402839661,
0.23993872106075287,
-0.07084140181541443,
0.06097833067178726,
0.11795907467603683,
-0.42040833830833435,
0.8177466988563538,
-0.07711555063724518,
0.20183613896369934,
-0.590382993221283,
-0.8301981091499329,
0.2636365294456482,
0.47803014516830444,
0.11008720099925995,
-0.1619555950164795,
0.08278670907020569,
0.8228399157524109,
-0.3602994382381439,
1.3280807733535767,
-0.06366119533777237,
-0.14002270996570587,
0.580176055431366,
-0.21656160056591034,
0.10326160490512848,
-0.16594038903713226,
0.025697767734527588,
-0.18190698325634003,
0.26656243205070496,
-0.3484671413898468,
-0.28860703110694885,
0.4359115660190582,
-0.8191916346549988,
-0.7644054889678955,
-0.5643371939659119,
-0.5852274298667908,
-0.16991375386714935,
0.29654887318611145,
-0.20606674253940582,
0.49646106362342834,
-0.4869469404220581,
0.2156834900379181,
0.7481116652488708,
-0.18621408939361572,
0.5294995307922363,
0.6228333115577698,
-0.11746066808700562,
-0.19733454287052155,
0.8488601446151733,
-0.011183319613337517,
0.1690070629119873,
0.601294755935669,
0.08246999233961105,
-0.19665947556495667,
-0.5012173056602478,
-0.5573586821556091,
0.137191504240036,
-0.678284764289856,
0.3823528587818146,
-1.0489271879196167,
-0.1796528697013855,
-0.45848342776298523,
0.09161624312400818,
0.00235944427549839,
-0.36280396580696106,
-0.5271366238594055,
-0.010793273337185383,
0.07443927973508835,
0.991035521030426,
0.004000015091150999,
0.5314913392066956,
-0.510783851146698,
0.32049673795700073,
0.32971256971359253,
-0.013481264002621174,
0.11259430646896362,
-0.24940167367458344,
-0.45524361729621887,
0.1579747498035431,
-0.7136403918266296,
-0.9600272178649902,
0.40139394998550415,
-0.19330322742462158,
0.6301882863044739,
0.3313869535923004,
0.15803438425064087,
0.2092592567205429,
-0.2500573694705963,
0.968958854675293,
0.04240081086754799,
-0.7630595564842224,
0.17078897356987,
-0.5366392731666565,
0.20720119774341583,
0.42506569623947144,
0.3050890266895294,
-0.6725700497627258,
-0.446283757686615,
-0.5871192812919617,
-0.407908171415329,
0.7268208861351013,
0.19049935042858124,
0.3698935806751251,
0.24321191012859344,
0.24839039146900177,
-0.037022870033979416,
0.537797212600708,
-0.5039178133010864,
-0.3612838387489319,
0.19608373939990997,
0.047012221068143845,
0.043921373784542084,
-0.2980092763900757,
-0.43384596705436707,
-0.10753247141838074,
0.754366397857666,
-0.5201529860496521,
0.5353133678436279,
0.35488423705101013,
0.15537890791893005,
0.0867496207356453,
0.42346611618995667,
0.45996132493019104,
0.8057692646980286,
0.21570821106433868,
-0.155020073056221,
-0.06696423143148422,
-0.32443132996559143,
0.06679051369428635,
-0.058192066848278046,
-0.15111713111400604,
0.221253901720047,
0.11484481394290924,
0.6626224517822266,
0.1360483467578888,
-0.5943324565887451,
0.2005896419286728,
-0.2616604268550873,
-0.427217572927475,
-0.3384990990161896,
0.16361552476882935,
0.238290473818779,
0.8338091373443604,
0.16026555001735687,
0.043170683085918427,
0.24514728784561157,
-0.8276758193969727,
0.050778575241565704,
0.3506796360015869,
-0.5478904247283936,
-0.23855336010456085,
0.6324616074562073,
0.44990211725234985,
-0.3889397084712982,
0.41369345784187317,
0.4096708297729492,
-0.5368484258651733,
0.6611310839653015,
0.3654133081436157,
1.1070952415466309,
0.07348420470952988,
0.45286861062049866,
0.07354315370321274,
-0.09558974951505661,
0.22344259917736053,
0.458107054233551,
-0.4585413634777069,
-0.5058639645576477,
-0.2898956537246704,
-0.4274628460407257,
-1.0067952871322632,
0.014713871292769909,
-0.5789689421653748,
-0.08411265909671783,
0.07243460416793823,
-0.15699750185012817,
0.28232914209365845,
0.17779198288917542,
-0.28120431303977966,
0.04840176925063133,
-0.04060656577348709,
0.4718334376811981,
-0.3999428153038025,
0.9941835403442383,
0.37867650389671326,
-0.36356788873672485,
-0.260517954826355,
-0.047389380633831024,
-0.22906625270843506,
-0.5239658355712891,
0.47401514649391174,
-0.1004367247223854,
-0.22557997703552246,
0.07558082789182663,
-0.7111029028892517,
-0.5603095293045044,
1.047486424446106,
0.08447550982236862,
-0.36428168416023254,
0.03130192309617996,
0.37194159626960754,
0.6716626882553101,
-0.4437650442123413,
0.32375672459602356,
0.19025669991970062,
0.4383929669857025,
0.03716012462973595,
-0.7283042669296265,
-0.5510156750679016,
-0.3732248842716217,
-0.09653894603252411,
-0.21073517203330994,
-0.8954461812973022,
0.6741266250610352,
0.017641162499785423,
-0.10230190306901932,
0.7596127986907959,
0.9485906958580017,
-0.24713972210884094,
0.623115599155426,
0.11624351888895035,
0.3077649772167206,
0.6566426753997803,
-0.025901272892951965,
0.7009623050689697,
-0.4366554021835327,
-0.09286251664161682,
1.0476021766662598,
-0.19105695188045502,
0.5354055762290955,
0.30608439445495605,
-0.22176183760166168,
0.3719988465309143,
0.8794586658477783,
0.05464663729071617,
0.3728649616241455,
0.3816523849964142,
-0.5613548159599304,
0.16709114611148834,
-0.19234336912631989,
-0.35874927043914795,
0.00207309378311038,
0.31001120805740356,
-0.40361106395721436,
0.0213686041533947,
0.45663440227508545,
-0.06830421090126038,
0.10650451481342316,
-0.048324186354875565,
1.139703392982483,
0.43729519844055176,
-0.8661596179008484,
0.18861864507198334,
-0.033596470952034,
0.18110206723213196,
-0.4451599717140198,
0.04473334178328514,
0.040724460035562515,
0.2501629889011383,
-0.06450168788433075,
-0.9083056449890137,
0.39632001519203186,
-0.09516235440969467,
-0.515502393245697,
-0.717314600944519,
0.7030324339866638,
-0.3756224513053894,
-0.11241228878498077,
0.12968945503234863,
0.7801291346549988,
0.6700006127357483,
0.34560835361480713,
-0.7939549088478088,
0.012884877622127533,
0.00939666386693716,
0.03489246219396591,
0.4222966730594635,
0.5454692840576172,
0.18154145777225494,
0.8127408027648926,
0.6921806931495667,
-0.2761591374874115,
-0.02883128635585308,
0.1503918617963791,
1.1069698333740234,
-0.9170600771903992,
-0.26832810044288635,
-0.5335983037948608,
0.494737833738327,
0.008289988152682781,
-0.601906955242157,
0.6019311547279358,
0.7680618166923523,
0.7484933733940125,
-0.12751127779483795,
0.9033282399177551,
-0.14012575149536133,
0.8439232707023621,
-0.2510841488838196,
0.3590485453605652,
-0.003826974891126156,
-0.04267190769314766,
-0.05452387034893036,
-0.6614409685134888,
0.2482282966375351,
0.4911368489265442,
-0.4187949001789093,
-0.19288891553878784,
0.5061562061309814,
0.8032500743865967,
0.3076772093772888,
0.25915274024009705,
0.5090705156326294,
0.6519855260848999,
0.5696200132369995,
0.0573187991976738,
1.021074891090393,
-0.14870662987232208,
0.35518619418144226,
-0.12263044714927673,
0.10571911185979843,
-0.2603895962238312,
-0.27481138706207275,
-0.9657688736915588,
-0.8385390639305115,
-0.2227635532617569,
-0.7496622204780579,
0.26821431517601013,
0.4420117437839508,
0.6757363677024841,
-0.6559684872627258,
-0.6311551332473755,
-0.0801251158118248,
0.32535451650619507,
-0.050991106778383255,
-0.15683528780937195,
-0.14491833746433258,
-0.36747032403945923,
-1.2258121967315674,
0.6611899733543396,
0.2715127170085907,
0.013979149982333183,
-0.6745869517326355,
-0.17521634697914124,
-0.155135840177536,
0.13321736454963684,
0.5192291736602783,
0.5870034098625183,
-0.4888651669025421,
0.130817249417305,
-0.0857841819524765,
-0.3512619733810425,
0.3758840560913086,
1.0655956268310547,
-0.6961086392402649,
0.6369815468788147,
0.530342161655426,
0.44413694739341736,
0.9782878160476685,
-0.19128549098968506,
1.1826027631759644,
-0.03871138393878937,
0.13653269410133362,
0.708638072013855,
0.23166850209236145,
0.21060894429683685,
0.03670889139175415,
0.5126613974571228,
0.007161914370954037,
-0.8803747892379761,
-0.6592702865600586,
0.33006003499031067,
-1.1335501670837402,
-0.18449503183364868,
0.7283839583396912,
-0.17600268125534058,
-0.1506241410970688,
-0.599956214427948,
-0.7233825922012329,
0.3687559962272644,
-0.1274055391550064,
0.5693308711051941,
0.7328600287437439,
-0.4244557321071625,
-0.3462584614753723,
-0.9892463088035583,
0.4628859758377075,
0.40463119745254517,
-0.797469437122345,
-0.29145345091819763,
0.25992128252983093,
-0.0415218360722065,
0.1814446747303009,
0.8159838914871216,
0.009264197200536728,
-0.16948427259922028,
0.09750323742628098,
-0.1539841592311859,
0.34712323546409607,
-0.17146113514900208,
-0.13013482093811035,
0.18132291734218597,
0.3040103614330292,
-0.454926997423172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02352v1 | Pelican: Correcting Hallucination in Vision-LLMs via Claim Decomposition and Program of Thought Verification | 2024-07-02T15:17:44 | 2024-07-02T15:17:44 | Pritish Sahu, Karan Sikka, Ajay Divakaran | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Visual Language Models (LVLMs) struggle with hallucinations in visual
instruction following task(s), limiting their trustworthiness and real-world
applicability. We propose Pelican -- a novel framework designed to detect and
mitigate hallucinations through claim verification. Pelican first decomposes
the visual claim into a chain of sub-claims based on first-order predicates.
These sub-claims consist of (predicate, question) pairs and can be
conceptualized as nodes of a computational graph. We then use
Program-of-Thought prompting to generate Python code for answering these
questions through flexible composition of external tools. Pelican improves over
prior work by introducing (1) intermediate variables for precise grounding of
object instances, and (2) shared computation for answering the sub-question to
enable adaptive corrections and inconsistency identification. We finally use
reasoning abilities of LLM to verify the correctness of the the claim by
considering the consistency and confidence of the (question, answer) pairs from
each sub-claim. Our experiments reveal a drop in hallucination rate by
$\sim$8%-32% across various baseline LVLMs and a 27% drop compared to
approaches proposed for hallucination mitigation on MMHal-Bench. Results on two
other benchmarks further corroborate our results. | [
-0.12890388071537018,
-1.0061225891113281,
0.5939727425575256,
0.33322158455848694,
0.059277720749378204,
-0.01621420681476593,
-0.19368284940719604,
-0.45017126202583313,
0.3269091546535492,
0.7361003756523132,
-0.2562527656555176,
-0.46226441860198975,
-0.419158011674881,
0.16880932450294495,
-0.49763914942741394,
0.5367435216903687,
-0.06810273975133896,
-0.042720727622509,
-0.24123230576515198,
0.1872337907552719,
-0.4909783601760864,
-0.49836310744285583,
-0.45920971035957336,
-0.28288763761520386,
0.41862523555755615,
-0.11469627916812897,
0.47941163182258606,
0.44551050662994385,
0.6737363338470459,
0.2923945486545563,
-0.010182072408497334,
0.46209678053855896,
-0.5637340545654297,
-0.06674574315547943,
-0.15785059332847595,
-0.41767585277557373,
-0.8593325614929199,
-0.1872018426656723,
0.5410033464431763,
0.7649708986282349,
-0.32098427414894104,
-0.08953914046287537,
0.19002583622932434,
0.5569282174110413,
-1.0059384107589722,
0.056163325905799866,
-0.8438301682472229,
0.5277730226516724,
-0.18064576387405396,
-0.46900424361228943,
-0.7629395723342896,
-0.025349805131554604,
0.1972430795431137,
-0.4222078025341034,
0.25418221950531006,
0.10090374201536179,
0.7390798330307007,
0.6785709857940674,
-0.09142172336578369,
-0.016175229102373123,
-0.5886022448539734,
0.6017041802406311,
-0.3746487498283386,
0.4324244260787964,
0.5454074144363403,
0.2734830379486084,
-0.261121928691864,
-0.748222291469574,
-0.571018636226654,
-0.3866358697414398,
-0.016763970255851746,
0.003656277898699045,
0.04406292364001274,
0.13483594357967377,
0.5245240926742554,
0.34762465953826904,
-0.7946999669075012,
-0.28245681524276733,
-0.3982549011707306,
-0.6617798805236816,
0.5200187563896179,
0.17726671695709229,
0.2777464687824249,
0.05185336619615555,
-0.278118759393692,
-0.06847870349884033,
-0.8664916157722473,
0.024153634905815125,
0.11606771498918533,
-0.0005151787772774696,
0.26211026310920715,
0.7509453296661377,
-0.0994269996881485,
0.6637794375419617,
0.1721695512533188,
-0.293139785528183,
0.21008138358592987,
-0.18153516948223114,
-0.5947641134262085,
0.5056072473526001,
0.3526938259601593,
0.563703715801239,
0.25004842877388,
-0.217709481716156,
-0.17661245167255402,
0.35796433687210083,
0.42221468687057495,
-0.5114355683326721,
-0.7751098871231079,
0.15402115881443024,
-0.5255125164985657,
-0.3231797516345978,
0.14972150325775146,
-0.6668641567230225,
-0.9033916592597961,
-0.21828512847423553,
0.5070165395736694,
-0.1652815341949463,
-0.36378300189971924,
0.4395391345024109,
0.1770421862602234,
0.3466140925884247,
0.5428409576416016,
-0.6140928864479065,
0.3650451600551605,
0.6428040266036987,
0.7099078893661499,
-0.45243039727211,
-0.5496212840080261,
-0.7468110918998718,
0.08459779620170593,
-0.6263277530670166,
0.9155317544937134,
-0.31565409898757935,
-0.12704221904277802,
-0.17191535234451294,
0.2096012830734253,
-0.3295062482357025,
-0.9801539778709412,
0.19028757512569427,
-0.03830283507704735,
-0.09440575540065765,
-0.18314456939697266,
-0.42558059096336365,
-0.2355448305606842,
0.5030721426010132,
-0.5366571545600891,
0.6942777037620544,
-0.0033807011786848307,
-0.6460826396942139,
0.26599812507629395,
-0.30287230014801025,
-0.28382787108421326,
0.18731379508972168,
-0.482787549495697,
-0.3953637480735779,
0.1916135847568512,
0.265607625246048,
0.28380393981933594,
0.08490823954343796,
0.22056744992733002,
-0.21676748991012573,
-0.591579794883728,
0.32593125104904175,
-0.29384833574295044,
0.5755432844161987,
-0.08320319652557373,
-0.7975108623504639,
0.29493632912635803,
-0.6938990354537964,
-0.033542148768901825,
0.13708290457725525,
-0.06377683579921722,
-0.15718068182468414,
0.0714644342660904,
-0.2977236807346344,
-0.23718911409378052,
0.04642285034060478,
-0.44454386830329895,
0.0847078412771225,
-0.5507558584213257,
0.22135792672634125,
0.8788847327232361,
-0.12012685835361481,
0.33208903670310974,
-0.24001877009868622,
0.3167732059955597,
-0.01509310957044363,
0.4708525538444519,
-0.183733731508255,
-0.30089837312698364,
-1.1411043405532837,
-0.004647667519748211,
-0.22443757951259613,
0.6972559094429016,
-0.8636375665664673,
0.12617768347263336,
0.17943215370178223,
-0.015176420100033283,
-0.07646950334310532,
0.04236285015940666,
0.45018360018730164,
0.7687815427780151,
0.5026264786720276,
0.08852434903383255,
-0.5099258422851562,
-0.9233068227767944,
-0.2190481424331665,
-0.3534718155860901,
0.10028790682554245,
0.24626237154006958,
0.49942663311958313,
-0.19902987778186798,
0.4934477210044861,
-0.375150591135025,
-0.5651753544807434,
0.1293630748987198,
-0.2246968299150467,
0.06780119240283966,
0.4023425281047821,
0.42508119344711304,
-1.0666964054107666,
-0.4200137257575989,
-0.011495948769152164,
-0.9116672277450562,
-0.20046260952949524,
-0.2817075550556183,
0.030728403478860855,
0.40890341997146606,
0.33311623334884644,
-0.3414858877658844,
1.0116533041000366,
0.27156370878219604,
-0.37760892510414124,
0.634916365146637,
-0.20738700032234192,
0.20683962106704712,
-0.5557681918144226,
-0.2684040367603302,
-0.24204032123088837,
-0.22584226727485657,
-0.3125714063644409,
-0.04562262073159218,
0.019921861588954926,
0.010021563619375229,
-0.4975491464138031,
0.014599792659282684,
-0.3805864155292511,
0.016663920134305954,
-0.366265207529068,
-0.005223005544394255,
-0.028834084048867226,
0.23488499224185944,
0.1840449720621109,
0.8191015124320984,
0.8966500759124756,
-0.5791503190994263,
0.6898565292358398,
0.01806936226785183,
-0.11764118820428848,
0.5424280166625977,
-0.7689011693000793,
0.17588593065738678,
-0.11787613481283188,
0.028172558173537254,
-0.6910278797149658,
-0.17334221303462982,
0.8010348081588745,
-0.21129386126995087,
-0.02731066197156906,
0.17229478061199188,
-0.1954948604106903,
-0.4405946731567383,
-0.30974793434143066,
0.22420866787433624,
0.2530163824558258,
-0.677882969379425,
0.9755477905273438,
0.39168423414230347,
0.14843539893627167,
-0.6082138419151306,
-0.7748440504074097,
0.48658156394958496,
-0.08430067449808121,
-0.5930624008178711,
0.5704296827316284,
-0.24900080263614655,
-0.6167329549789429,
0.0037647185381501913,
-0.31972166895866394,
0.0715767964720726,
-0.0034885983914136887,
0.511186957359314,
0.26656174659729004,
-0.18709133565425873,
-0.023773247376084328,
-0.11376605182886124,
-0.16358011960983276,
0.1750164031982422,
-0.3442320227622986,
0.6027833819389343,
-0.6048179268836975,
-0.6764042377471924,
-0.44512128829956055,
0.2797090411186218,
0.5711995959281921,
-0.22387109696865082,
0.5219354629516602,
0.3541658818721771,
-0.7657728791236877,
-0.5101133584976196,
-0.7716531753540039,
-0.320821076631546,
-0.4757962226867676,
0.28475436568260193,
-0.6711480021476746,
-0.49941757321357727,
0.4672384262084961,
-0.09118380397558212,
-0.3116041421890259,
0.09951634705066681,
0.6687819957733154,
0.049380604177713394,
0.9907294511795044,
0.6457430124282837,
0.5425112247467041,
0.05775165930390358,
-0.39095360040664673,
0.444090336561203,
-0.7107042670249939,
-0.7982808351516724,
0.04550698772072792,
-0.16897833347320557,
-0.02168934978544712,
-0.4667148292064667,
0.28202110528945923,
0.060657259076833725,
0.12066522985696793,
0.22609581053256989,
-0.9063946008682251,
0.8341904282569885,
0.272419810295105,
0.5671743750572205,
0.13794517517089844,
0.06404406577348709,
-0.03031434491276741,
-0.16570492088794708,
-0.2973981499671936,
-0.5660407543182373,
1.0392227172851562,
0.05417931452393532,
0.8799823522567749,
-0.17002341151237488,
0.7065571546554565,
0.5209144353866577,
0.062001023441553116,
-0.7748062014579773,
0.8484688997268677,
0.0876135379076004,
-0.14500151574611664,
-0.1930065155029297,
-0.16596616804599762,
-0.47426503896713257,
0.3649996817111969,
-0.3036953806877136,
-0.9521638751029968,
0.2965678870677948,
0.36920079588890076,
-0.5151049494743347,
0.4117480516433716,
-0.41652005910873413,
0.8493834733963013,
-0.5339820981025696,
-0.6664471626281738,
-0.34258154034614563,
-0.43456295132637024,
0.332012802362442,
-0.2464972287416458,
-0.4010518491268158,
0.025551004335284233,
0.11284760385751724,
0.5405734181404114,
-0.5518674850463867,
0.7477595806121826,
-0.13879305124282837,
-0.21436449885368347,
0.3020893633365631,
0.2932674288749695,
0.6763709187507629,
0.0383361391723156,
0.1435731053352356,
0.15471675992012024,
0.09822189062833786,
-0.2273956537246704,
-0.6752305030822754,
0.5774425864219666,
-0.3951508402824402,
-0.6996070742607117,
-0.6390345096588135,
-0.6127995848655701,
0.1349676102399826,
-0.03773941472172737,
0.23730804026126862,
0.27132096886634827,
0.12377329170703888,
0.4131370782852173,
0.8716675639152527,
-0.3204980492591858,
0.21881906688213348,
0.2937711179256439,
-0.6904313564300537,
-0.5061942338943481,
0.8034982681274414,
0.12324953079223633,
-0.17794902622699738,
0.23798488080501556,
0.18104596436023712,
-0.17925521731376648,
-0.8437767028808594,
-0.08809605240821838,
0.20901073515415192,
-0.8985595703125,
0.017278410494327545,
-0.6410343050956726,
-0.1438980996608734,
-0.5077643990516663,
-0.08443231135606766,
-0.5443412065505981,
-0.02609202452003956,
-0.006698215380311012,
0.04575251787900925,
-0.09393596649169922,
0.5783309936523438,
0.14542131125926971,
-0.006045791786164045,
-0.37452685832977295,
0.4685332775115967,
0.41209954023361206,
-0.0035917875356972218,
-0.09970350563526154,
-0.25581294298171997,
0.04649290442466736,
0.1636103093624115,
-0.1894661784172058,
-0.7914948463439941,
0.43761587142944336,
0.07191970199346542,
0.7947741150856018,
0.4171856939792633,
0.28344106674194336,
0.9515658020973206,
-0.35528233647346497,
0.9319627285003662,
0.31008264422416687,
-1.078584909439087,
0.9804214239120483,
0.25854843854904175,
-0.529450535774231,
0.19317372143268585,
-0.05834191292524338,
-0.14339929819107056,
-0.20758137106895447,
-0.2427881509065628,
-0.6291777491569519,
0.2948687970638275,
0.30568692088127136,
-0.24890966713428497,
0.11245007067918777,
0.5783304572105408,
0.06119847670197487,
-0.061901967972517014,
-0.7861271500587463,
0.036677297204732895,
-0.35511934757232666,
0.034843407571315765,
0.13035228848457336,
-0.2001991719007492,
-0.2429579496383667,
-0.5297350883483887,
0.5132032036781311,
-0.2807841897010803,
0.020068861544132233,
0.6856641173362732,
-0.5112951993942261,
0.06816896796226501,
-0.16938553750514984,
0.8416706919670105,
1.1497918367385864,
-0.17878063023090363,
0.642645001411438,
0.3297954201698303,
-0.510793149471283,
0.004544358234852552,
-0.34864816069602966,
-0.34290042519569397,
-0.17545999586582184,
0.3237014412879944,
0.6573264002799988,
-0.11490786075592041,
-0.8257549405097961,
0.6303388476371765,
-0.23212406039237976,
-0.13254348933696747,
-0.6303802728652954,
0.20609579980373383,
-0.3536960184574127,
0.6628808379173279,
0.4264300763607025,
0.26106882095336914,
0.05448859930038452,
-0.26363301277160645,
0.2679431438446045,
0.16469866037368774,
-0.3181363344192505,
-0.34238603711128235,
0.7966378927230835,
-0.07996466010808945,
-0.6422525644302368,
0.464845210313797,
0.0015783044509589672,
-0.6486191153526306,
0.7806198000907898,
0.788181483745575,
0.938636839389801,
0.014857085421681404,
0.24424076080322266,
-0.04643791541457176,
0.44575726985931396,
-0.1755535900592804,
0.31925168633461,
-0.22082409262657166,
-0.7232409119606018,
-0.32780054211616516,
-0.5117459297180176,
-0.4594520330429077,
0.17174014449119568,
-0.4614413380622864,
0.12775899469852448,
-0.5467471480369568,
-0.31627148389816284,
-0.25588858127593994,
-0.23885707557201385,
-0.2645648419857025,
-0.21667958796024323,
0.5371071696281433,
0.5024685859680176,
-0.8220726847648621,
0.8080620765686035,
0.7104949951171875,
-0.4536576569080353,
-0.8382400274276733,
0.19762937724590302,
0.15781964361667633,
-0.6875172853469849,
0.9986791610717773,
0.287252813577652,
-0.5566056370735168,
-0.18298399448394775,
-0.6392471790313721,
-0.36713337898254395,
1.026557445526123,
0.6054396033287048,
-0.4771026074886322,
0.06465546786785126,
0.1463363617658615,
0.28128230571746826,
-0.5434284210205078,
-0.23847146332263947,
0.36391565203666687,
0.4987078607082367,
0.1715809553861618,
-1.0187575817108154,
0.08720241487026215,
-0.39105066657066345,
0.04478621855378151,
-0.12969809770584106,
-0.2787548899650574,
1.0410022735595703,
-0.42101919651031494,
-0.1475149691104889,
0.17473623156547546,
0.4990759789943695,
0.41095462441444397,
0.6644765138626099,
0.5101332068443298,
0.46523547172546387,
1.1090912818908691,
-0.0607813335955143,
0.8881815671920776,
-0.3715260624885559,
0.31990665197372437,
1.042784571647644,
-0.6074674129486084,
0.6627285480499268,
0.942694365978241,
-0.1799459159374237,
0.29953914880752563,
0.5987324118614197,
-0.21126286685466766,
0.4623245596885681,
0.23013345897197723,
-0.26291629672050476,
-0.5356397032737732,
-0.3062334358692169,
-0.47141674160957336,
0.5394551157951355,
0.31424039602279663,
-0.4392336905002594,
0.03989490494132042,
0.3817911446094513,
-0.36700645089149475,
0.2593350410461426,
-0.3823208212852478,
0.4783652424812317,
0.08447348326444626,
-0.6749386787414551,
0.9140069484710693,
-0.49172794818878174,
0.5161277651786804,
-0.18166697025299072,
-0.417912095785141,
-0.1774221956729889,
0.9029256701469421,
-0.3852761685848236,
-0.494985967874527,
0.3155582547187805,
-0.19723838567733765,
-0.18064270913600922,
-0.22458434104919434,
0.9811289310455322,
-0.43429964780807495,
-0.36092138290405273,
0.394064337015152,
0.2775200605392456,
0.4619038999080658,
-0.5106948018074036,
-0.5855326652526855,
0.4273475110530853,
-0.0649573802947998,
-0.004275128245353699,
-0.09115298092365265,
0.12888574600219727,
-0.01743820309638977,
0.9017534255981445,
0.5621260404586792,
0.49208155274391174,
0.40471360087394714,
0.2927863895893097,
0.8119449019432068,
-0.3064056932926178,
-0.2453044205904007,
-1.0227285623550415,
0.1593760848045349,
-0.2884973883628845,
0.10638953000307083,
0.9209439754486084,
0.6060987710952759,
0.8199095129966736,
-0.2343362271785736,
0.25878527760505676,
0.25487369298934937,
0.04111732915043831,
-0.6155166625976562,
0.9470100998878479,
-0.5104646682739258,
0.43284767866134644,
-0.279512882232666,
-1.1706310510635376,
-0.712377667427063,
1.2011579275131226,
-0.32952842116355896,
-0.4385957717895508,
1.0190078020095825,
1.2773771286010742,
0.042661696672439575,
-0.08729176968336105,
0.4015258252620697,
0.17161346971988678,
0.3948749601840973,
0.9209401607513428,
1.1537528038024902,
-0.5041121244430542,
0.5780043601989746,
-0.567033588886261,
-0.23251765966415405,
-0.14991840720176697,
-0.7645665407180786,
-1.0330551862716675,
-0.30513623356819153,
-0.7189981937408447,
-0.7218806743621826,
0.22437547147274017,
0.7150077223777771,
0.8059840798377991,
-0.9362253546714783,
-0.04074119031429291,
-0.25754162669181824,
0.07296762615442276,
-0.3582192659378052,
-0.21853254735469818,
0.5996477603912354,
-0.05247146636247635,
-0.41078487038612366,
0.44066867232322693,
0.7743913531303406,
0.1424616426229477,
-0.3902179002761841,
-0.572791576385498,
0.20691731572151184,
-0.1732305884361267,
0.698188304901123,
0.05236825346946716,
-1.2865092754364014,
-0.41281431913375854,
0.3613269627094269,
-0.03549453988671303,
0.14271558821201324,
0.8758446574211121,
-1.030956745147705,
0.6208158135414124,
0.5084757804870605,
0.6320732235908508,
0.48345285654067993,
-0.2751886248588562,
0.1387830674648285,
-0.11446522921323776,
0.29934823513031006,
0.37712353467941284,
0.5989119410514832,
0.26671314239501953,
-0.5423048138618469,
0.599766731262207,
0.6885308623313904,
-0.26213064789772034,
-1.1776456832885742,
0.1380956768989563,
-1.0254051685333252,
-0.16257590055465698,
0.7341077327728271,
-0.26934748888015747,
-0.6118598580360413,
-0.10938511788845062,
-0.4969862699508667,
0.007298220880329609,
0.24431723356246948,
1.062049388885498,
0.43567124009132385,
-0.31236183643341064,
-0.58322674036026,
-0.0090101333335042,
0.1923651248216629,
0.40458205342292786,
-0.7696030139923096,
0.2134469747543335,
0.5424480438232422,
0.09613841027021408,
0.5019729137420654,
0.5609180927276611,
-0.19524438679218292,
0.39600974321365356,
0.26043838262557983,
-0.001095146406441927,
-0.4319167733192444,
-0.7783105969429016,
-0.052608050405979156,
0.41323384642601013,
-0.4418640732765198,
-0.2948441207408905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02351v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02351v1 | Generative Large Language Models in Automated Fact-Checking: A Survey | 2024-07-02T15:16:46 | 2024-07-02T15:16:46 | Ivan Vykopal, Matúš Pikuliak, Simon Ostermann, Marián Šimko | cs.CL | cs.CL | The dissemination of false information across online platforms poses a
serious societal challenge, necessitating robust measures for information
verification. While manual fact-checking efforts are still instrumental, the
growing volume of false information requires automated methods. Large language
models (LLMs) offer promising opportunities to assist fact-checkers, leveraging
LLM's extensive knowledge and robust reasoning capabilities. In this survey
paper, we investigate the utilization of generative LLMs in the realm of
fact-checking, illustrating various approaches that have been employed and
techniques for prompting or fine-tuning LLMs. By providing an overview of
existing approaches, this survey aims to improve the understanding of utilizing
LLMs in fact-checking and to facilitate further progress in LLMs' involvement
in this process. | [
-0.44301554560661316,
-1.0558044910430908,
1.079426646232605,
0.039314717054367065,
-0.24715274572372437,
0.13056334853172302,
-0.292616605758667,
-0.38594555854797363,
-0.04552629217505455,
0.7525186538696289,
-0.4443728029727936,
-0.6953685879707336,
-0.7115916013717651,
0.29548007249832153,
-0.7619140148162842,
0.9343984127044678,
-0.20873107016086578,
-0.08408515155315399,
-0.44455066323280334,
-0.019739823415875435,
-0.02759111300110817,
-0.7775097489356995,
-0.5622006058692932,
-0.5334897041320801,
0.5131212472915649,
0.29071876406669617,
0.6593849658966064,
0.5133891701698303,
0.4740477502346039,
0.42852166295051575,
-0.16807040572166443,
0.6500609517097473,
-0.35749921202659607,
0.18510718643665314,
-0.12247007340192795,
-0.7152096629142761,
-0.41476765275001526,
0.03323613852262497,
0.7204486131668091,
0.5656048655509949,
-0.15177646279335022,
0.385677695274353,
-0.05434618890285492,
0.4447198510169983,
-0.7483099699020386,
0.4421471357345581,
-0.643964946269989,
0.06685292720794678,
-0.19959953427314758,
-0.2284923642873764,
-0.6024556159973145,
-0.7633053660392761,
-0.20171789824962616,
-0.37485480308532715,
0.3717275559902191,
0.17845390737056732,
0.6150356531143188,
0.34233635663986206,
-0.564697265625,
-0.7311185598373413,
-0.937545895576477,
0.7042288184165955,
-0.7484875321388245,
0.3931626081466675,
0.6038981676101685,
0.01424287911504507,
-0.1728719174861908,
-0.5940932035446167,
-0.8794119954109192,
-0.479961633682251,
-0.23585765063762665,
-0.12251826375722885,
-0.3147338032722473,
0.0933174267411232,
0.6001746654510498,
0.4861690104007721,
-0.42093321681022644,
0.42678502202033997,
0.017250433564186096,
-0.37926656007766724,
0.5000259876251221,
0.1446089893579483,
0.23530668020248413,
-0.15788879990577698,
-0.1762620061635971,
0.018641360104084015,
-1.0898128747940063,
-0.4681699275970459,
0.3042008578777313,
0.09758837521076202,
-0.11821258813142776,
0.8984643220901489,
-0.19048693776130676,
0.8736730217933655,
-0.08303523063659668,
-0.2729133665561676,
-0.11181893199682236,
-0.5498872995376587,
-0.3046816289424896,
-0.07778525352478027,
0.7162579894065857,
0.2898160517215729,
0.035713210701942444,
-0.11358310282230377,
-0.5568339824676514,
0.25279784202575684,
-0.15273217856884003,
-0.7657212615013123,
0.03622137010097504,
0.19145309925079346,
-0.3984285891056061,
-0.29468220472335815,
0.05343996733427048,
-0.7915319204330444,
-0.7476657629013062,
-0.5013260841369629,
0.4401618242263794,
-0.13623933494091034,
-0.12116879969835281,
0.17779020965099335,
-0.02324797213077545,
0.18129627406597137,
0.5852395296096802,
-0.6606907844543457,
-0.16821543872356415,
0.9008055329322815,
0.9036265015602112,
0.10698658227920532,
0.1422983855009079,
-0.8048234581947327,
0.10563575476408005,
-0.6846694350242615,
0.7898971438407898,
-0.3601206839084625,
-0.09496921300888062,
0.4334859848022461,
-0.11498213559389114,
0.30247220396995544,
-0.5865298509597778,
0.7618623971939087,
-0.9119596481323242,
0.1177806481719017,
-0.5337077379226685,
-0.7284529805183411,
-0.13549184799194336,
0.7357398867607117,
-0.7381741404533386,
0.6271845102310181,
-0.2578731179237366,
-0.6628354787826538,
0.2483593374490738,
-0.6535889506340027,
-0.48569101095199585,
-0.0001524809777038172,
-0.09493736177682877,
-0.5187469124794006,
0.006050977855920792,
0.41922593116760254,
0.7353203296661377,
-0.4854413568973541,
0.4250163435935974,
-0.26315414905548096,
0.01801837421953678,
0.5689566731452942,
-0.6559758186340332,
0.7642871737480164,
0.29716387391090393,
-0.27020463347435,
0.1438274383544922,
-0.7098789811134338,
-0.27327683568000793,
0.08515961468219757,
-0.524713397026062,
-0.23135222494602203,
0.09973464161157608,
-0.1124800369143486,
0.05266391113400459,
0.2602083384990692,
-0.442384272813797,
0.2649788558483124,
-0.1773795336484909,
0.38081544637680054,
0.5947433114051819,
-0.01934695988893509,
-0.03781856596469879,
-0.4837851822376251,
0.3409747779369354,
0.039514172822237015,
-0.0018126268405467272,
-0.20315945148468018,
-0.3236669600009918,
-1.1066930294036865,
-0.19981825351715088,
0.5004663467407227,
0.5150928497314453,
-1.034274697303772,
0.6418659090995789,
-0.011417205445468426,
-0.41126057505607605,
-0.14150336384773254,
0.27793312072753906,
0.2501020133495331,
0.19475139677524567,
0.16456979513168335,
0.18303266167640686,
-0.5984027981758118,
-0.6489672660827637,
-0.13944368064403534,
-0.40816447138786316,
-0.016292380169034004,
-0.034471482038497925,
0.517815113067627,
-0.36473891139030457,
0.853191614151001,
-0.384930819272995,
-0.04572427272796631,
-0.32751965522766113,
0.452883243560791,
0.056247636675834656,
0.04756343737244606,
0.4813595414161682,
-0.7943081259727478,
-0.1944354623556137,
-0.0907038077712059,
-0.9743133783340454,
-0.18884339928627014,
-0.2566860020160675,
0.2927023768424988,
0.3550742268562317,
0.6709498167037964,
-0.9920613169670105,
0.10820454359054565,
0.8001040816307068,
-0.27402594685554504,
0.5895140767097473,
-0.22661305963993073,
0.3905952274799347,
-0.9017276763916016,
-0.09055488556623459,
0.1688161939382553,
-0.5833653211593628,
-0.511987566947937,
0.30246269702911377,
0.09954005479812622,
0.25755512714385986,
-0.1916370391845703,
0.19556206464767456,
-0.7305814623832703,
-0.10687501728534698,
-0.32537606358528137,
0.10885375738143921,
-0.2154950350522995,
0.031619101762771606,
-0.09341304004192352,
0.7876911163330078,
0.5439289808273315,
-0.744512140750885,
0.771263599395752,
0.1268104463815689,
-0.772754430770874,
0.38924044370651245,
-0.44484421610832214,
-0.018061436712741852,
-0.33777692914009094,
0.4867747128009796,
-0.8521729707717896,
-0.44842028617858887,
0.13756348192691803,
-0.16208840906620026,
0.1613442599773407,
-0.3777254819869995,
-1.154868483543396,
-0.33324095606803894,
-0.12197159975767136,
0.07030929625034332,
0.5003216862678528,
-0.8409108519554138,
0.6452946662902832,
0.30641689896583557,
-0.2124159187078476,
-0.3422471582889557,
-0.5422151684761047,
0.5456197261810303,
-0.235723078250885,
-0.4529596269130707,
0.008362727239727974,
-0.013272041454911232,
-0.6905544400215149,
-0.2307361513376236,
0.1712927669286728,
0.061518676578998566,
-0.037310004234313965,
0.09514550864696503,
0.35827603936195374,
-0.34782329201698303,
0.16588754951953888,
-0.2848404049873352,
0.09544563293457031,
0.1882007122039795,
-0.17079441249370575,
0.5214715003967285,
-0.12923258543014526,
-0.7484003305435181,
-0.48720645904541016,
0.14962294697761536,
0.9743309617042542,
-0.293149471282959,
0.947784423828125,
0.6122311353683472,
-0.4392140507698059,
-0.1808355152606964,
-1.1452713012695312,
-0.37200069427490234,
-0.46752944588661194,
0.2829705774784088,
0.1336558759212494,
-1.2210216522216797,
0.44353801012039185,
-0.3613836169242859,
0.07335285097360611,
0.40108153223991394,
0.9935230016708374,
-0.006326948292553425,
0.9531734585762024,
0.6262158155441284,
-0.09138323366641998,
0.2906723618507385,
-0.08895062655210495,
0.32966917753219604,
-0.32258084416389465,
-0.13649225234985352,
-0.7091444730758667,
0.2007669359445572,
-0.661999523639679,
-0.6613959074020386,
0.5895581841468811,
-0.18317490816116333,
-0.030543223023414612,
-0.031080618500709534,
0.10945536941289902,
0.4103929400444031,
0.21547304093837738,
-0.03827507421374321,
0.7193476557731628,
0.0011538966791704297,
0.17162242531776428,
0.28263774514198303,
-0.7357046008110046,
-0.6429687142372131,
0.8148667812347412,
0.4924547076225281,
1.057033896446228,
0.3025890588760376,
0.32635262608528137,
0.457911878824234,
0.6544814705848694,
-0.8796015381813049,
0.6992666125297546,
-0.1421901285648346,
-0.5792615413665771,
-0.4172346293926239,
-0.545584499835968,
-0.6740997433662415,
0.11911903321743011,
-0.33837664127349854,
-0.2664738893508911,
0.001929147052578628,
0.5059669017791748,
-0.3085409998893738,
0.530744194984436,
-0.43337148427963257,
0.43183761835098267,
-0.3927166163921356,
-0.13868337869644165,
-0.4524892270565033,
-0.23758664727210999,
0.5934328436851501,
-0.14712606370449066,
0.36446836590766907,
0.05551041662693024,
0.06638731062412262,
0.28124064207077026,
-0.4056853652000427,
1.2181428670883179,
0.14810511469841003,
-0.6053025126457214,
0.3007020950317383,
0.08302459120750427,
1.073047161102295,
0.04392346367239952,
-0.033453453332185745,
0.09529325366020203,
-0.26361459493637085,
0.025451311841607094,
-0.4755871295928955,
0.591480553150177,
-0.6515536904335022,
-0.7729744911193848,
-0.5314882397651672,
-0.4583374261856079,
-0.41821134090423584,
0.1100204661488533,
0.2420416921377182,
0.4768654704093933,
-0.25848260521888733,
0.5387451648712158,
1.085602879524231,
-0.10043017566204071,
0.3095143437385559,
0.7759395837783813,
-0.2979002296924591,
0.0909431055188179,
0.7027308940887451,
0.1028377115726471,
0.25923752784729004,
0.5708593130111694,
0.2569284439086914,
-0.5485230684280396,
-0.6937622427940369,
-0.45761144161224365,
0.2675060033798218,
-0.8162806630134583,
-0.32054778933525085,
-0.7456104755401611,
-0.29720017313957214,
-0.3161674439907074,
0.15762411057949066,
-0.33499202132225037,
-0.2674522399902344,
-0.20121638476848602,
-0.1038031056523323,
0.4196992814540863,
1.0223408937454224,
-0.031301844865083694,
0.05651962384581566,
-0.7361844182014465,
0.6491544842720032,
0.5538328289985657,
0.48611196875572205,
-0.19546250998973846,
-0.34633785486221313,
-0.05602976679801941,
0.13047680258750916,
-0.044094018638134,
-0.8104939460754395,
0.06546831130981445,
-0.06720366328954697,
0.6070985794067383,
0.42279213666915894,
0.08753973245620728,
0.24084125459194183,
-0.259490042924881,
0.8294146656990051,
0.09398961067199707,
-0.7541033029556274,
0.38123297691345215,
-0.3802361488342285,
0.010363235138356686,
-0.03738835081458092,
0.4897187054157257,
-0.5946241617202759,
-0.5220617055892944,
-0.2206183224916458,
-0.4843665063381195,
0.37615838646888733,
0.09416712075471878,
0.21459266543388367,
0.07810403406620026,
0.19410577416419983,
0.0565715990960598,
0.2377569079399109,
-0.656671941280365,
-0.18148739635944366,
-0.12522244453430176,
-0.08679582923650742,
-0.18324829638004303,
-0.6528759002685547,
-0.36313945055007935,
0.07727079838514328,
0.806151807308197,
-0.2390395700931549,
-0.08961290866136551,
0.06327101588249207,
-0.2603209614753723,
-0.184678852558136,
0.7125623822212219,
0.6954271197319031,
0.7915005087852478,
0.12482333183288574,
0.3465108871459961,
0.22647793591022491,
-0.1707674115896225,
0.235287606716156,
-0.05911713466048241,
-0.5418906211853027,
0.032523997128009796,
0.28017643094062805,
0.7164010405540466,
-0.03557645156979561,
-0.6407789587974548,
0.48807984590530396,
0.18301717936992645,
-0.21041060984134674,
-0.3193938136100769,
0.05956558883190155,
0.25399428606033325,
0.03460637480020523,
0.22202478349208832,
-0.12972867488861084,
-0.016084838658571243,
-0.8089275360107422,
-0.0928972065448761,
0.6708552837371826,
0.14954453706741333,
-0.14059323072433472,
0.24397370219230652,
0.15710791945457458,
0.04331497102975845,
0.6801285147666931,
-0.21453671157360077,
-0.6240079402923584,
0.42648330330848694,
0.6105323433876038,
0.657729983329773,
-0.025889402255415916,
0.3292049169540405,
0.31239062547683716,
0.5889625549316406,
-0.5566872954368591,
-0.059173401445150375,
0.06600504368543625,
-0.9488003253936768,
-0.7697736620903015,
-0.6275584697723389,
-0.6405353546142578,
0.528388500213623,
-0.22612303495407104,
0.12275677174329758,
-0.49742838740348816,
-0.17513783276081085,
0.18137912452220917,
-0.3348897099494934,
-0.6795099973678589,
0.14773181080818176,
0.400799959897995,
0.748542308807373,
-0.7991762161254883,
0.4724431335926056,
0.7180476188659668,
-0.2743566930294037,
-0.5036554932594299,
0.30499598383903503,
0.34650930762290955,
-0.7065683603286743,
0.6116625666618347,
-0.20655326545238495,
-0.3656429648399353,
-0.2250763326883316,
-0.8780068159103394,
-0.7752365469932556,
0.7383084297180176,
0.5922681093215942,
-0.7937240600585938,
0.12034914642572403,
0.3296477496623993,
0.6296674609184265,
-0.07176815718412399,
-0.04655660688877106,
0.47597628831863403,
0.7578850388526917,
0.22195923328399658,
-0.7882213592529297,
0.08914321660995483,
0.10679954290390015,
-0.08304426819086075,
0.06210411712527275,
-0.6789858937263489,
0.723347008228302,
-0.222145676612854,
-0.1848350167274475,
0.10052322596311569,
0.7451499104499817,
0.20204408466815948,
0.13895592093467712,
0.7011169791221619,
0.43811312317848206,
0.8149497509002686,
-0.056179873645305634,
0.9560586214065552,
-0.23101121187210083,
0.42519164085388184,
0.7459894418716431,
-0.3566836714744568,
0.659542977809906,
0.3144281804561615,
-0.22657275199890137,
0.5426861047744751,
0.33239781856536865,
-0.2948648929595947,
-0.19584707915782928,
0.14332041144371033,
-0.44837790727615356,
-0.7433886528015137,
-0.24640317261219025,
-0.07990407943725586,
0.5646483898162842,
0.7239208221435547,
-0.31803956627845764,
-0.3513985276222229,
-0.05972743779420853,
0.05213357135653496,
0.1316574215888977,
-0.4333480894565582,
0.785751223564148,
-0.12678369879722595,
-0.8474843502044678,
0.5312199592590332,
0.2516932785511017,
0.7741312384605408,
-0.5499394536018372,
-0.11652198433876038,
-0.08270099014043808,
-0.016374776139855385,
-0.3091224133968353,
-0.9642935991287231,
0.1693248450756073,
0.4362805485725403,
-0.31029462814331055,
-0.2781713306903839,
0.8156341314315796,
-0.45271265506744385,
-0.5172920823097229,
-0.08024264872074127,
0.6478444337844849,
-0.08350715041160583,
-0.25229543447494507,
-0.37843143939971924,
0.3331098258495331,
-0.1550437957048416,
-0.14647823572158813,
0.12477747350931168,
0.38480955362319946,
-0.21821466088294983,
0.9972120523452759,
0.7362196445465088,
0.09014914184808731,
-0.11597077548503876,
0.3050980865955353,
0.7107850313186646,
-0.41435328125953674,
-0.3530598282814026,
-1.007372260093689,
0.116449736058712,
-0.017261195927858353,
0.20771415531635284,
1.0181033611297607,
0.5230731964111328,
0.7548586130142212,
-0.18487648665905,
1.1612675189971924,
-0.1120515763759613,
0.5369014739990234,
-0.8230602145195007,
0.7755357623100281,
-0.30088308453559875,
0.24200130999088287,
-0.0004598103405442089,
-0.7836439609527588,
-0.3810616731643677,
0.3766702115535736,
-0.2584725022315979,
0.08310171216726303,
0.37575119733810425,
1.0879080295562744,
-0.1369495540857315,
0.07078016549348831,
0.4499759376049042,
0.6434174180030823,
0.2935599684715271,
0.038630738854408264,
1.2712202072143555,
-0.005694837309420109,
0.4674544334411621,
0.06473096460103989,
-0.2483735829591751,
-0.524498701095581,
-1.1726139783859253,
-1.1296794414520264,
-0.5222793817520142,
-0.5798320770263672,
-0.4213534891605377,
-0.021883083507418633,
1.0328645706176758,
0.6364145874977112,
-0.974557101726532,
0.04814395308494568,
-0.05837436020374298,
0.4355754256248474,
0.14025430381298065,
-0.1210712268948555,
0.21644842624664307,
-0.2858692407608032,
-0.49195215106010437,
0.29642853140830994,
0.26807543635368347,
0.22117513418197632,
-0.6382341980934143,
0.16507862508296967,
-0.01746019721031189,
0.2348162829875946,
0.9243838787078857,
0.2747427523136139,
-0.9916485548019409,
-0.3407787084579468,
-0.22316208481788635,
-0.26000669598579407,
-0.16535711288452148,
1.2463188171386719,
-0.4665355384349823,
0.26291754841804504,
0.6146706342697144,
0.7107852101325989,
0.32973313331604004,
-0.006376686505973339,
0.39107072353363037,
-0.6488269567489624,
-0.18821683526039124,
0.09828635305166245,
0.5074604153633118,
0.6858723163604736,
-0.41370245814323425,
0.08324666321277618,
0.158927783370018,
-0.5922585129737854,
-0.7856127023696899,
0.36781826615333557,
-0.7373059391975403,
-0.11307617276906967,
1.3432221412658691,
0.04678582400083542,
0.061606310307979584,
-0.33617377281188965,
-0.01667679473757744,
0.18142472207546234,
0.02533898875117302,
0.988723635673523,
0.9054283499717712,
0.16011293232440948,
-0.24361808598041534,
-0.5433976650238037,
0.6373840570449829,
0.21760393679141998,
-1.1311140060424805,
0.4103514552116394,
0.7378377914428711,
0.3787115514278412,
0.20275726914405823,
0.3367616832256317,
-0.16831918060779572,
0.19706259667873383,
-0.21609368920326233,
-0.14419639110565186,
0.046692609786987305,
-0.2430214285850525,
-0.17199985682964325,
0.2206636518239975,
0.33774882555007935,
0.28103578090667725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02345v1 | MORPHEUS: Modeling Role from Personalized Dialogue History by Exploring and Utilizing Latent Space | 2024-07-02T15:12:34 | 2024-07-02T15:12:34 | Yihong Tang, Bo Wang, Dongming Zhao, Xiaojia Jin, Jijun Zhang, Ruifang He, Yuexian Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Personalized Dialogue Generation (PDG) aims to create coherent responses
according to roles or personas. Traditional PDG relies on external role data,
which can be scarce and raise privacy concerns. Approaches address these issues
by extracting role information from dialogue history, which often fail to
generically model roles in continuous space. To overcome these limitations, we
introduce a novel framework \textbf{MO}dels \textbf{R}oles from
\textbf{P}ersonalized Dialogue \textbf{H}istory by \textbf{E}xploring and
\textbf{U}tilizing Latent \textbf{S}pace (MORPHEUS) through a three-stage
training process. Specifically, we create a persona codebook to represent roles
in latent space compactly, and this codebook is used to construct a posterior
distribution of role information. This method enables the model to generalize
across roles, allowing the generation of personalized dialogues even for unseen
roles. Experiments on both Chinese and English datasets demonstrate that
MORPHEUS enhances the extraction of role information, and improves response
generation without external role data. Additionally, MORPHEUS can be considered
an efficient fine-tuning for large language models. | [
-0.11191728711128235,
-0.484347403049469,
0.3213425278663635,
-0.015734178945422173,
-0.03549125790596008,
-0.059013232588768005,
0.11585669219493866,
0.01637323573231697,
0.3656121492385864,
0.7044809460639954,
-0.8183449506759644,
-0.6665704250335693,
-0.20117336511611938,
-0.02950803004205227,
-0.00905658584088087,
1.216943621635437,
0.47473907470703125,
0.12771666049957275,
0.014795130118727684,
0.1301637589931488,
-0.3444063067436218,
-0.4338446855545044,
-0.7569727301597595,
-0.21703636646270752,
0.7529852986335754,
0.16693779826164246,
0.6902111768722534,
0.5869626402854919,
0.10208826512098312,
0.22598882019519806,
-0.031740013509988785,
0.09198545664548874,
-0.4541114568710327,
0.490940660238266,
-0.06660586595535278,
-0.5663845539093018,
-0.7666383981704712,
0.07943779230117798,
0.5647979974746704,
0.7608186602592468,
-0.34137439727783203,
-0.16154398024082184,
0.0841539055109024,
0.2221679389476776,
-0.5892125368118286,
0.3069884777069092,
-0.506467342376709,
0.45883429050445557,
-0.22708623111248016,
-0.5089315176010132,
-0.41990286111831665,
-0.2906632423400879,
0.6313574314117432,
-0.6419926285743713,
0.20123007893562317,
-0.21815423667430878,
0.4446640908718109,
-0.05406520515680313,
-0.4251193404197693,
-0.38406792283058167,
-0.8432167172431946,
0.7235647439956665,
-0.7744879722595215,
-0.10586979985237122,
0.5509780049324036,
0.3685505986213684,
-0.21687257289886475,
-0.7689646482467651,
-0.38302913308143616,
-0.08542779088020325,
-0.036150798201560974,
0.3389786183834076,
-0.05543581396341324,
0.39257895946502686,
0.07172144204378128,
0.4909500777721405,
-0.4380674958229065,
0.040938861668109894,
-0.5483807325363159,
-0.26607874035835266,
0.6837473511695862,
0.32182520627975464,
0.37537097930908203,
-0.27184101939201355,
-0.3233850300312042,
-0.12585954368114471,
-0.783599317073822,
0.2512762248516083,
0.9326386451721191,
0.19762621819972992,
-0.19962717592716217,
0.5978533625602722,
0.0838981345295906,
0.7750179767608643,
0.12785811722278595,
-0.10110104084014893,
-0.151450976729393,
-0.08341236412525177,
-0.22709301114082336,
-0.0022390270605683327,
0.6743576526641846,
0.40094152092933655,
-0.06063065677881241,
-0.08537359535694122,
0.01200480293482542,
-0.11186975240707397,
0.4926603436470032,
-0.6723195910453796,
-0.42791029810905457,
0.24230045080184937,
-0.583755373954773,
-0.4291575253009796,
0.05244991555809975,
-0.8400067687034607,
-0.614782989025116,
-0.16641542315483093,
0.27027276158332825,
-0.25706946849823,
-0.17780227959156036,
-0.1092720627784729,
0.16310088336467743,
0.15370619297027588,
0.3381955921649933,
-0.9892184138298035,
0.2569143772125244,
0.3607081174850464,
0.8398582935333252,
-0.2008810192346573,
0.024830572307109833,
-0.7732977867126465,
0.21271508932113647,
-0.3438488841056824,
0.5186966061592102,
-0.7636198401451111,
-0.451954185962677,
0.158710315823555,
-0.12057458609342575,
-0.2912082374095917,
-0.49648207426071167,
0.30113330483436584,
-0.387002170085907,
0.7978832125663757,
0.10813242197036743,
-0.3024064302444458,
-0.10691864788532257,
0.24995315074920654,
-0.49730542302131653,
0.4365968108177185,
0.1540294885635376,
-0.6116998195648193,
0.1798778474330902,
-0.9741213321685791,
0.055005237460136414,
0.07819870114326477,
-0.383243590593338,
-0.10949656367301941,
-0.03343203663825989,
0.17482256889343262,
0.7650496959686279,
-0.1030723825097084,
0.3685145974159241,
-0.3273313045501709,
-0.35918301343917847,
0.3053598999977112,
-0.13699817657470703,
0.5034469366073608,
0.3809061348438263,
-0.05774490535259247,
0.2053486704826355,
-0.627133846282959,
-0.15008261799812317,
-0.13366581499576569,
-0.3623839318752289,
-0.450356662273407,
0.24798987805843353,
-0.0985637903213501,
0.175556942820549,
0.02846580743789673,
-0.37991762161254883,
0.4043479561805725,
-0.8046939969062805,
0.44190075993537903,
0.7708525061607361,
0.011924819089472294,
0.66949063539505,
-0.32555219531059265,
0.9058480858802795,
0.1202043890953064,
-0.050453320145606995,
-0.5630504488945007,
-0.4243919253349304,
-0.39846885204315186,
-0.3757445812225342,
0.30657458305358887,
0.5530160665512085,
-0.6107368469238281,
0.6422099471092224,
-0.07273460924625397,
-0.31003543734550476,
-0.3076823651790619,
-0.00026257248828187585,
0.4410936236381531,
0.166451558470726,
-0.0660080537199974,
-0.7577143311500549,
-0.6028085350990295,
-1.075628638267517,
-0.04846886917948723,
-0.27202168107032776,
-0.18104372918605804,
0.6099145412445068,
0.08973062038421631,
-0.4484423100948334,
1.162902593612671,
-0.6088770031929016,
-0.41753852367401123,
-0.4605969488620758,
0.06305873394012451,
0.2261136770248413,
0.517123818397522,
0.323580801486969,
-0.93732088804245,
-0.3005693554878235,
-0.08135459572076797,
-0.611926794052124,
-0.34991392493247986,
-0.2231043130159378,
-0.1470518708229065,
-0.10185583680868149,
0.5032640695571899,
-0.3806237280368805,
0.2585606873035431,
1.0128412246704102,
-0.30334532260894775,
0.28065282106399536,
-0.12950211763381958,
0.0753537192940712,
-1.6997711658477783,
0.30026718974113464,
-0.05371594801545143,
-0.10872926563024521,
-0.7155623435974121,
-0.35331711173057556,
-0.4989360272884369,
-0.46274441480636597,
-0.2142385095357895,
0.5414947867393494,
-0.16752798855304718,
-0.17217792570590973,
-0.2286224365234375,
0.30048832297325134,
-0.2566240131855011,
0.7390394806861877,
-0.03790529444813728,
0.5523544549942017,
0.40175604820251465,
-0.689242959022522,
0.20562979578971863,
0.44244515895843506,
-0.3108293414115906,
0.4054986536502838,
-0.6763094663619995,
0.27987509965896606,
-0.11907483637332916,
0.5211897492408752,
-1.2173758745193481,
-0.5085443258285522,
0.5149435997009277,
-0.33078545331954956,
0.19193685054779053,
-0.792445182800293,
-0.4075360894203186,
0.1734687089920044,
-0.10825301706790924,
0.3927466571331024,
0.3410426378250122,
-0.20454229414463043,
0.6380620002746582,
0.7414723634719849,
-0.679872453212738,
-0.6224638223648071,
-0.18907636404037476,
-0.08538082242012024,
-0.5937209725379944,
-0.6599811315536499,
0.574798047542572,
-0.2905513048171997,
-0.17990663647651672,
-0.4657931625843048,
-0.21182024478912354,
-0.40610751509666443,
0.02867347002029419,
0.4817922115325928,
0.17213712632656097,
0.05078553780913353,
0.056152064353227615,
0.4849588871002197,
-0.17863403260707855,
-0.12663593888282776,
-0.32139548659324646,
0.7641797661781311,
0.28897419571876526,
-0.18999719619750977,
-0.3501459062099457,
0.3592884838581085,
0.7370403409004211,
-0.08195827901363373,
0.700009822845459,
0.5011982321739197,
-0.3214421570301056,
-0.12110856175422668,
-0.1655331254005432,
-0.166774183511734,
-0.45647478103637695,
0.20217515528202057,
-0.13687925040721893,
-0.9357113242149353,
0.6572304368019104,
-0.09185105562210083,
0.35556530952453613,
0.02959286794066429,
0.5860347747802734,
0.0692140981554985,
1.1475787162780762,
0.6626282930374146,
0.17296567559242249,
0.7193337082862854,
-0.35133683681488037,
0.18936306238174438,
-1.0819628238677979,
-0.3844130337238312,
-0.10019930452108383,
-0.421337366104126,
-0.37806200981140137,
-0.3567315936088562,
0.5852320194244385,
0.20694884657859802,
0.10234353691339493,
0.4596734642982483,
-0.2768590450286865,
0.20297443866729736,
0.30461710691452026,
0.006191522814333439,
0.1236690804362297,
0.008845142088830471,
-0.21569804847240448,
-0.4800412356853485,
-0.6672757267951965,
-0.8575056791305542,
1.0872490406036377,
0.4179753065109253,
0.9668861627578735,
0.4202895164489746,
0.6286069750785828,
0.45007726550102234,
-0.09675723314285278,
-0.6411194205284119,
0.5608842968940735,
-0.04780660942196846,
-0.48087483644485474,
-0.09279870986938477,
-0.3596329391002655,
-1.232066035270691,
0.46947550773620605,
-0.12296301871538162,
-1.0920490026474,
0.14393682777881622,
0.4039262533187866,
-0.9429757595062256,
-0.04386422410607338,
-0.7852581143379211,
0.8628500699996948,
0.15322691202163696,
-0.43000301718711853,
-0.1390858143568039,
-0.6784337162971497,
0.29799363017082214,
0.0812736302614212,
-0.13115830719470978,
0.07996326684951782,
0.11389294266700745,
0.86327064037323,
-0.06934092938899994,
1.3021348714828491,
-0.38815948367118835,
-0.35310548543930054,
0.11260488629341125,
0.35686516761779785,
0.34565162658691406,
0.5177993774414062,
0.14383725821971893,
-0.3597116470336914,
0.22778908908367157,
-0.1155901551246643,
-0.6144483685493469,
0.7779670357704163,
-0.6747366189956665,
-0.4995013475418091,
-0.29051530361175537,
-0.7522336840629578,
-0.3169344961643219,
-0.0011790544958785176,
0.37225794792175293,
0.5491479635238647,
-0.3167130947113037,
0.5684011578559875,
0.8134127259254456,
-0.7138664722442627,
0.12602369487285614,
0.3944394290447235,
-0.15989252924919128,
-0.29984375834465027,
0.3770514726638794,
-0.1130024716258049,
0.07413036376237869,
0.4795173704624176,
0.21218730509281158,
-0.23122304677963257,
-0.26407545804977417,
-0.06160670146346092,
-0.07036271691322327,
-0.4066520631313324,
-0.0013498988701030612,
-1.006483554840088,
-0.11535700410604477,
-0.5213882327079773,
-0.011292926967144012,
-0.2898761034011841,
-0.2742294371128082,
-0.2506217956542969,
0.17213332653045654,
-0.1735382080078125,
0.5355134010314941,
0.00827921461313963,
0.6334457993507385,
-0.8778222799301147,
0.171223983168602,
0.4978848695755005,
0.1808469444513321,
-0.2745841145515442,
-0.5195701718330383,
-0.2943451702594757,
0.1859976202249527,
-0.6687551140785217,
-0.9339718818664551,
0.7059979438781738,
0.15091314911842346,
0.7095285058021545,
0.5700651407241821,
-0.07621151953935623,
0.6004531383514404,
-0.33675575256347656,
1.0655317306518555,
0.017171306535601616,
-0.8480210304260254,
0.8334805369377136,
-0.8293694257736206,
0.03610297292470932,
0.1410936713218689,
0.22381827235221863,
-0.7205634117126465,
-0.14288806915283203,
-0.6773965954780579,
-1.020390510559082,
1.0721590518951416,
0.4805435240268707,
0.38617247343063354,
0.11788596957921982,
0.3910350501537323,
0.2829224467277527,
0.37176164984703064,
-0.9036045074462891,
0.05271843820810318,
0.03541910648345947,
-0.14038439095020294,
-0.17342638969421387,
-0.23539336025714874,
-0.4508442282676697,
0.05679216608405113,
0.39826133847236633,
-0.28509268164634705,
0.5631355047225952,
0.3363665044307709,
-0.010210941545665264,
0.05271114408969879,
0.4072560667991638,
0.7042636871337891,
0.50412917137146,
-0.19734473526477814,
-0.2568151652812958,
-0.1213945746421814,
-0.23681452870368958,
-0.22088401019573212,
-0.03592105582356453,
0.12728887796401978,
-0.09834383428096771,
0.1467505842447281,
0.7004533410072327,
0.38575848937034607,
-0.6837877631187439,
0.5026172995567322,
0.0025567798875272274,
0.0902014672756195,
-0.6613211631774902,
0.47062963247299194,
-0.12206476181745529,
0.5376797914505005,
0.27112460136413574,
0.09815441071987152,
0.22589707374572754,
-0.6783577799797058,
0.11035841703414917,
0.1771724671125412,
-0.3741092383861542,
-0.5722751021385193,
0.6154388785362244,
0.35343027114868164,
-0.28045395016670227,
0.21609383821487427,
0.16972163319587708,
-0.15463833510875702,
0.3092661499977112,
0.4797133803367615,
0.8259196877479553,
-0.3658919036388397,
0.4109722673892975,
0.229090616106987,
-0.24214541912078857,
-0.10559079051017761,
-0.10200567543506622,
-0.3159070909023285,
-0.7517608404159546,
-0.3402300179004669,
-0.47891896963119507,
-0.43066394329071045,
0.498975932598114,
-0.6949783563613892,
0.008290967904031277,
-0.5549736618995667,
-0.2016250640153885,
-0.23835204541683197,
-0.02321508526802063,
-0.22711347043514252,
0.005744852591305971,
0.11669456958770752,
0.42106351256370544,
-0.6274664998054504,
0.8175510168075562,
0.6981387138366699,
-0.07408055663108826,
-0.45296239852905273,
0.17413008213043213,
0.1917976438999176,
-0.42617499828338623,
0.6558713316917419,
0.21739572286605835,
-0.11891178786754608,
0.08012522757053375,
-0.5628008842468262,
-0.43825802206993103,
1.3763691186904907,
0.5155647993087769,
-0.37214526534080505,
-0.3937111496925354,
-0.31826645135879517,
0.6235559582710266,
-0.9450019598007202,
-0.03392200544476509,
0.13776853680610657,
-0.08638548105955124,
0.11224261671304703,
-0.7422996163368225,
-0.4445517659187317,
-0.5473766326904297,
0.21242377161979675,
-0.18310454487800598,
-0.33468496799468994,
0.8985923528671265,
0.03807639330625534,
-0.2555152475833893,
0.5244678258895874,
0.32474485039711,
0.4297303557395935,
0.2701342701911926,
0.5066251158714294,
0.1857008934020996,
0.612498939037323,
-0.0721355527639389,
1.0456618070602417,
-0.28399863839149475,
0.1760750263929367,
1.1068600416183472,
-0.40759342908859253,
0.40731677412986755,
0.34398913383483887,
0.246450737118721,
0.7449151277542114,
0.4481475353240967,
0.08386331796646118,
0.8590148091316223,
0.24308274686336517,
-0.4442375898361206,
-0.2268003225326538,
0.07550285011529922,
-0.15882806479930878,
0.5939579606056213,
0.46848735213279724,
-0.851353108882904,
-0.056620851159095764,
0.030392790213227272,
-0.04246482253074646,
0.14757755398750305,
-0.008964646607637405,
0.7633858919143677,
0.06347367912530899,
-0.9031295776367188,
-0.03669601306319237,
0.16855299472808838,
0.6248462200164795,
-1.0260210037231445,
-0.21759776771068573,
-0.38663795590400696,
0.470016211271286,
-0.15492631494998932,
-0.5433517694473267,
0.20963649451732635,
0.015407639555633068,
-0.12830640375614166,
-0.4795996844768524,
0.5278220772743225,
-0.5890090465545654,
0.15971195697784424,
0.09832116216421127,
0.47350603342056274,
0.2530435621738434,
0.1019759327173233,
-0.6246132254600525,
-0.13836367428302765,
0.03241106495261192,
-0.08257008343935013,
0.3862049877643585,
0.11868758499622345,
0.03042583540081978,
0.8123111724853516,
0.6315353512763977,
0.0952046662569046,
-0.06385010480880737,
-0.046106379479169846,
0.6038649678230286,
-0.5644218325614929,
-0.9196632504463196,
-0.5404214262962341,
0.6888213157653809,
-0.1392698734998703,
-0.5450147390365601,
0.5634938478469849,
0.49438831210136414,
0.732937216758728,
-0.20088377594947815,
0.9076237678527832,
-0.30349305272102356,
0.44313862919807434,
-0.6893868446350098,
0.7425609827041626,
-0.3636641204357147,
0.5835245251655579,
-0.457487553358078,
-1.053715705871582,
-0.19768817722797394,
1.0338850021362305,
-0.2965186536312103,
0.14133228361606598,
0.3850836455821991,
1.0332750082015991,
-0.23134197294712067,
-0.11077424138784409,
0.535422146320343,
0.14394448697566986,
0.5844531059265137,
0.6850201487541199,
0.9350231885910034,
-0.448050856590271,
0.5559161305427551,
0.056724898517131805,
-0.12697932124137878,
-0.14373506605625153,
-0.5078768730163574,
-1.0565587282180786,
-1.0136854648590088,
-0.2746521830558777,
-0.4469222128391266,
-0.13341064751148224,
1.1875362396240234,
1.0041946172714233,
-0.5420058369636536,
-0.4455485939979553,
-0.08595451712608337,
-0.2658309042453766,
-0.000667765736579895,
-0.27801910042762756,
0.035661421716213226,
-0.007486104965209961,
-1.02341890335083,
0.647611141204834,
0.4130685329437256,
0.06930352747440338,
-0.48653164505958557,
-0.26711228489875793,
0.1417306661605835,
0.07068558037281036,
0.65462726354599,
0.33739951252937317,
-0.6990752220153809,
-0.12805446982383728,
0.009981845505535603,
-0.11791467666625977,
-0.07039846479892731,
1.3181471824645996,
-0.697254478931427,
0.638622522354126,
0.3915546238422394,
0.26317378878593445,
0.3578474521636963,
-0.10795075446367264,
1.3622064590454102,
-1.0218051671981812,
0.10319660604000092,
0.39623957872390747,
0.3166738450527191,
0.2504146695137024,
-0.3828269839286804,
0.5059385895729065,
0.14238058030605316,
-0.39342018961906433,
-0.8201096653938293,
0.5794469714164734,
-1.1831607818603516,
-0.10102701932191849,
1.229292869567871,
-0.5595840215682983,
0.3012242913246155,
-0.25271153450012207,
-0.6658546924591064,
0.24830026924610138,
-0.45754051208496094,
1.009384274482727,
0.4897252917289734,
-0.22356046736240387,
-0.33551153540611267,
-0.45861151814460754,
0.5708460807800293,
0.2960825562477112,
-0.7420284748077393,
0.016208302229642868,
0.5707287192344666,
0.14620782434940338,
0.3891851305961609,
0.8153210282325745,
-0.41778314113616943,
0.1781742125749588,
-0.32570379972457886,
-0.3461036682128906,
0.052818603813648224,
-0.40078115463256836,
-0.3108269274234772,
0.39986711740493774,
-0.30443769693374634,
-0.11877455562353134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02340v1 | RVISA: Reasoning and Verification for Implicit Sentiment Analysis | 2024-07-02T15:07:54 | 2024-07-02T15:07:54 | Wenna Lai, Haoran Xie, Guandong Xu, Qing Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With an increasing social demand for fine-grained sentiment analysis (SA),
implicit sentiment analysis (ISA) poses a significant challenge with the
absence of salient cue words in expressions. It necessitates reliable reasoning
to understand how the sentiment is aroused and thus determine implicit
sentiments. In the era of Large Language Models (LLMs), Encoder-Decoder (ED)
LLMs have gained popularity to serve as backbone models for SA applications,
considering impressive text comprehension and reasoning ability among diverse
tasks. On the other hand, Decoder-only (DO) LLMs exhibit superior natural
language generation and in-context learning capabilities. However, their
responses may contain misleading or inaccurate information. To identify
implicit sentiment with reliable reasoning, this study proposes RVISA, a
two-stage reasoning framework that harnesses the generation ability of DO LLMs
and the reasoning ability of ED LLMs to train an enhanced reasoner.
Specifically, we adopt three-hop reasoning prompting to explicitly furnish
sentiment elements as cues. The generated rationales are utilized to fine-tune
an ED LLM into a skilled reasoner. Additionally, we develop a straightforward
yet effective verification mechanism to ensure the reliability of the reasoning
learning. We evaluated the proposed method on two benchmark datasets and
achieved state-of-the-art results in ISA performance. | [
-0.4126555621623993,
-0.9082951545715332,
0.7826899886131287,
0.6207283735275269,
-0.3343319594860077,
-0.1814933568239212,
-0.05037453770637512,
-0.31758400797843933,
-0.27927365899086,
0.3299528956413269,
-0.6742803454399109,
-0.665554404258728,
-0.6609021425247192,
0.4770723879337311,
-0.23345738649368286,
0.6958597302436829,
-0.3595658242702484,
0.24160709977149963,
-0.5021761059761047,
-0.3013068437576294,
-0.5211427807807922,
-0.18270699679851532,
-0.8317209482192993,
-0.14755754172801971,
0.3000645339488983,
0.5129515528678894,
0.0697239488363266,
0.24647364020347595,
0.3196554481983185,
0.17531903088092804,
-0.07079099118709564,
0.6717477440834045,
-0.2011071890592575,
0.4872299134731293,
-0.15494881570339203,
-0.6222996115684509,
-0.37560153007507324,
-0.36383864283561707,
0.5219033360481262,
0.17024476826190948,
0.18648488819599152,
0.2750202417373657,
0.07715305685997009,
0.6555953621864319,
-0.852554976940155,
0.20694518089294434,
-0.7491998076438904,
-0.30595842003822327,
-0.044618405401706696,
-0.17412936687469482,
-0.7288758754730225,
-0.7003642916679382,
-0.4246576428413391,
-0.16411980986595154,
-0.006570351310074329,
0.020862264558672905,
1.0310660600662231,
0.6096567511558533,
-0.46931594610214233,
-0.24130591750144958,
-0.7084872722625732,
0.7553145885467529,
-0.37692123651504517,
0.3067947328090668,
0.2569388449192047,
0.27541735768318176,
-0.1021435558795929,
-0.4994140863418579,
-0.8965852856636047,
-0.05640177056193352,
-0.009262576699256897,
0.09436774998903275,
-0.03368141129612923,
-0.08339232206344604,
0.26577338576316833,
0.19871549308300018,
-0.44596317410469055,
-0.14928951859474182,
-0.07446742802858353,
0.05845329910516739,
0.45134472846984863,
-0.0032504673581570387,
0.27612048387527466,
-0.44172731041908264,
-0.6118931770324707,
-0.03655797988176346,
-0.9599104523658752,
0.11764366179704666,
0.4024350941181183,
0.1635712832212448,
0.012690250761806965,
0.8200434446334839,
-0.1568458378314972,
0.3426099419593811,
0.01254318654537201,
-0.09663073718547821,
0.11204175651073456,
0.09470412880182266,
-0.2451392412185669,
0.13660800457000732,
0.7949496507644653,
0.28436434268951416,
0.379842072725296,
0.24385111033916473,
-0.31292611360549927,
0.3623298704624176,
0.0809425562620163,
-0.7774296402931213,
0.40739813446998596,
0.6628577709197998,
-0.3213026225566864,
-0.1402987539768219,
-0.14965863525867462,
-0.8525335192680359,
-0.3384397625923157,
-0.2613573372364044,
0.3921189606189728,
-0.39432013034820557,
-0.40798985958099365,
0.17353911697864532,
-0.016297031193971634,
0.7307084202766418,
0.2846250832080841,
-0.6387197375297546,
0.15842948853969574,
0.9964010119438171,
0.6545372605323792,
0.09449601173400879,
-0.10919136554002762,
-0.5588675141334534,
0.059933338314294815,
-0.4546559751033783,
1.0474607944488525,
-0.6618120074272156,
-0.42217183113098145,
0.03486008942127228,
-0.21050815284252167,
-0.07751266658306122,
-0.08173443377017975,
0.8795193433761597,
-0.5915066599845886,
-0.051087092608213425,
-0.5341930985450745,
-0.2914506196975708,
-0.16676925122737885,
0.6066542863845825,
-0.3473307192325592,
1.3224130868911743,
-0.05194174125790596,
-0.8502463698387146,
0.4322296380996704,
-0.6145440340042114,
-0.4745863974094391,
-0.08912301808595657,
-0.345285028219223,
-0.40202316641807556,
0.015828609466552734,
0.6543123722076416,
0.4726337790489197,
-0.4322507679462433,
0.0883946642279625,
-0.43260759115219116,
-0.46447113156318665,
0.2895625829696655,
-0.6260039210319519,
0.4989915192127228,
0.18316161632537842,
-0.3192930519580841,
-0.07824382930994034,
-0.7796784043312073,
-0.018958760425448418,
0.016760291531682014,
-0.05814003199338913,
-0.32368549704551697,
0.04703403636813164,
-0.3917510211467743,
0.058126647025346756,
0.151208758354187,
-0.7967458963394165,
0.2439795881509781,
-0.29782548546791077,
0.0793294608592987,
0.7630592584609985,
0.3894185423851013,
0.21029871702194214,
0.18913927674293518,
0.49523746967315674,
0.027027659118175507,
0.2269849181175232,
-0.15781868994235992,
-0.3720591962337494,
-0.8983446359634399,
-0.5896207690238953,
0.3257353901863098,
0.5862327814102173,
-0.789916455745697,
0.1309603750705719,
-0.4077000021934509,
-0.005983918439596891,
-0.7147294878959656,
-0.10857754945755005,
0.25113165378570557,
0.405884712934494,
0.5592831373214722,
0.42011141777038574,
-0.706528902053833,
-0.8611985445022583,
-0.37037765979766846,
-0.28878703713417053,
0.061814386397600174,
0.2792084217071533,
0.5015722513198853,
-0.5192355513572693,
1.0660443305969238,
-0.48884445428848267,
-0.12221398204565048,
-0.4161783754825592,
0.5020277500152588,
-0.04196067154407501,
0.28020691871643066,
0.30687183141708374,
-0.6913521885871887,
-0.22691136598587036,
-0.12140177935361862,
-0.8749949932098389,
-0.2507270872592926,
-0.1907886266708374,
-0.3002557158470154,
0.3654465973377228,
0.4877520799636841,
-0.8394795656204224,
0.4882667660713196,
0.2097255140542984,
-0.15451057255268097,
0.2514601945877075,
0.03174478933215141,
0.2612062692642212,
-0.8556888699531555,
0.037140749394893646,
0.3138182759284973,
-0.18707752227783203,
-0.03648320958018303,
-0.1419113725423813,
-0.04027102515101433,
0.30370163917541504,
-0.11076563596725464,
0.5347036719322205,
-0.3146018981933594,
-0.011411327868700027,
-0.32867297530174255,
-0.0004114103503525257,
0.2374497503042221,
0.4125724732875824,
0.17799420654773712,
0.6701919436454773,
0.5852855443954468,
-0.5578234195709229,
0.12721721827983856,
0.21406999230384827,
-0.10220331698656082,
0.9168670773506165,
-0.9603749513626099,
0.12700867652893066,
-0.5746397972106934,
0.4366493225097656,
-1.1858115196228027,
-0.3827345371246338,
0.36583346128463745,
-0.5592291951179504,
0.29677456617355347,
-0.5241955518722534,
-0.5079208612442017,
-0.28571146726608276,
-0.15862880647182465,
0.2248731255531311,
0.5271745324134827,
-0.8378336429595947,
1.23643159866333,
0.07360225170850754,
-0.1295800805091858,
-1.015575647354126,
-0.433513343334198,
-0.1535777747631073,
-0.06626475602388382,
-0.5706722736358643,
-0.19300799071788788,
0.15845172107219696,
-0.5092703104019165,
-0.07259859889745712,
-0.31833508610725403,
0.056338079273700714,
-0.06659098714590073,
0.5686048865318298,
0.44373956322669983,
-0.11448673158884048,
-0.04542120173573494,
0.5758681893348694,
-0.24181818962097168,
0.4602605700492859,
0.04508136585354805,
0.3348296582698822,
-0.4843738079071045,
-0.5745845437049866,
-0.12322893738746643,
0.2516471743583679,
0.7803670763969421,
-0.27367258071899414,
0.7357752323150635,
0.8964579105377197,
-0.37179142236709595,
-0.5632451176643372,
-0.6478084325790405,
-0.012327113188803196,
-0.4059104025363922,
-0.058502089232206345,
-0.7170928716659546,
-0.6296330094337463,
0.3037668466567993,
-0.3738042116165161,
-0.0024227367248386145,
0.4351024627685547,
0.38629812002182007,
-0.012772239744663239,
1.4459480047225952,
0.25453171133995056,
0.3709762990474701,
-0.1373651921749115,
-0.2635689675807953,
0.252472460269928,
-1.071485161781311,
-0.7406561970710754,
-0.6569423675537109,
0.0737893283367157,
-0.3261762857437134,
-0.3577425479888916,
0.2916390001773834,
0.11909161508083344,
-0.3416532576084137,
-0.24530553817749023,
-0.30381476879119873,
0.5631190538406372,
0.08248092234134674,
0.04611355438828468,
0.03342081233859062,
-0.13791616261005402,
-0.18738719820976257,
0.20737960934638977,
-0.10418635606765747,
-0.821704089641571,
0.6988023519515991,
0.6353180408477783,
0.6338808536529541,
0.13964296877384186,
0.6499667167663574,
0.3332222104072571,
0.4098718762397766,
-0.825343132019043,
0.787177562713623,
0.1695237010717392,
-0.334454208612442,
-0.00354811642318964,
-0.3801007866859436,
-0.34911805391311646,
0.34285882115364075,
-0.13976764678955078,
-0.5437487959861755,
0.49782299995422363,
-0.019479170441627502,
-0.15980444848537445,
-0.07560553401708603,
-0.3411364257335663,
0.6016643643379211,
-0.11229690909385681,
-0.7244625687599182,
-0.09503350406885147,
-0.4947046637535095,
0.5736919641494751,
0.24606716632843018,
0.19909051060676575,
-0.34616029262542725,
0.08577751368284225,
0.2168605774641037,
-0.4416031837463379,
0.7312239408493042,
-0.3902927041053772,
-0.19883111119270325,
0.2934846878051758,
0.24701158702373505,
0.6861068606376648,
0.5583453178405762,
-0.17097915709018707,
0.155502051115036,
-0.2571953535079956,
-0.09057873487472534,
-0.5886459946632385,
0.8807641863822937,
-0.6428213715553284,
-0.46208104491233826,
-0.5575603246688843,
-0.06717357784509659,
-0.4962085485458374,
0.016521262004971504,
0.14145570993423462,
0.3959391713142395,
-0.042555272579193115,
0.14959657192230225,
1.053098201751709,
0.1511113941669464,
0.10275712609291077,
0.34381353855133057,
-0.09164606779813766,
-0.3742790222167969,
0.7767844200134277,
-0.4641820788383484,
-0.1492900252342224,
0.42150020599365234,
0.025812380015850067,
-0.5615378022193909,
-0.5329580307006836,
-0.7890241742134094,
0.1287112832069397,
-0.930412769317627,
-0.33286476135253906,
-0.7996985912322998,
0.04120123013854027,
-0.01751559227705002,
-0.13648006319999695,
-0.513741135597229,
-0.12389981746673584,
-0.16609413921833038,
-0.21651755273342133,
0.6324689984321594,
0.7693435549736023,
-0.10349743813276291,
0.021948115900158882,
-0.5659675002098083,
0.6526927351951599,
0.4089801609516144,
0.4135582447052002,
-0.1665203720331192,
-0.2048056274652481,
0.24389952421188354,
0.20886750519275665,
0.1832830011844635,
-0.8612083196640015,
0.30349355936050415,
-0.16271235048770905,
0.46101313829421997,
0.4143376350402832,
0.025392359122633934,
0.49255919456481934,
-0.2526591420173645,
0.8899809122085571,
-0.11989312618970871,
-1.0862598419189453,
0.7489678263664246,
-0.2831721305847168,
-0.1530415117740631,
0.690104067325592,
0.5337742567062378,
0.06114640831947327,
-0.28719133138656616,
-0.3054216206073761,
-0.9990119338035583,
0.5192191004753113,
0.16256874799728394,
-0.09516941010951996,
-0.401821106672287,
0.5790244340896606,
0.10733045637607574,
-0.05547782778739929,
-0.6114587187767029,
-0.19676506519317627,
-0.3747228980064392,
-0.5447537302970886,
0.5416114330291748,
-0.5800676345825195,
0.013320949859917164,
-0.0954008549451828,
0.9090729355812073,
-0.32665663957595825,
-0.009158743545413017,
0.16411757469177246,
-0.18924260139465332,
-0.07841414958238602,
0.49222996830940247,
0.2827455997467041,
0.49012312293052673,
-0.39979633688926697,
0.08423033356666565,
0.323388010263443,
-0.35570329427719116,
0.2485874742269516,
-0.08833235502243042,
-0.3247310221195221,
0.04399574548006058,
0.044868748635053635,
0.9020148515701294,
0.1601998656988144,
-0.44733691215515137,
0.8579849600791931,
-0.5403867959976196,
-0.03474351763725281,
-0.4109821021556854,
0.005380426999181509,
-0.12700091302394867,
0.13547417521476746,
0.3710674047470093,
0.33016642928123474,
0.14174064993858337,
-0.253334105014801,
-0.1508975476026535,
0.4860149025917053,
-0.4206361472606659,
-0.0781392976641655,
0.6059171557426453,
0.2581809163093567,
0.1900397688150406,
0.5518049001693726,
-0.28557291626930237,
-0.48352670669555664,
0.3578615188598633,
0.41050097346305847,
0.9934388399124146,
0.0688619464635849,
0.3090420961380005,
0.5079678297042847,
0.4083280861377716,
-0.44898873567581177,
0.7021725177764893,
-0.13111166656017303,
-0.6463820338249207,
-0.6605771780014038,
-0.8450207114219666,
-0.5380868315696716,
-0.023371897637844086,
-1.0038868188858032,
0.3603235185146332,
-0.29999399185180664,
-0.09600940346717834,
-0.3390428125858307,
-0.30992910265922546,
-0.5794777274131775,
0.43469271063804626,
0.30645036697387695,
0.9029659032821655,
-1.0669974088668823,
0.35080745816230774,
0.6642151474952698,
-0.5718974471092224,
-0.7667837738990784,
0.35481151938438416,
-0.1550709307193756,
-0.6990957856178284,
0.7366684079170227,
0.37214547395706177,
-0.7615025639533997,
-0.07282864302396774,
-0.8058024644851685,
-0.5024056434631348,
0.8982986211776733,
0.2337399125099182,
-0.4206392168998718,
0.4012126922607422,
0.020933393388986588,
0.4956897497177124,
-0.38667261600494385,
0.553021252155304,
0.6373207569122314,
0.5709347724914551,
0.5544060468673706,
-0.13099920749664307,
0.19905559718608856,
-0.24189315736293793,
0.09822706878185272,
0.04312459006905556,
-0.45158088207244873,
0.6444854140281677,
-0.29358187317848206,
-0.2687393128871918,
-0.15266236662864685,
1.0276148319244385,
0.6865996718406677,
0.27947157621383667,
0.39993929862976074,
0.46735432744026184,
0.737859845161438,
-0.37734994292259216,
1.1836148500442505,
-0.15556268393993378,
-0.05926612764596939,
0.857970118522644,
-0.5870905518531799,
1.1197534799575806,
0.3595644533634186,
0.020076356828212738,
1.1108931303024292,
0.3752588629722595,
0.18111427128314972,
0.3412081003189087,
-0.0981246829032898,
-0.514689564704895,
-0.5908902287483215,
-0.1441607028245926,
-0.19521823525428772,
0.6456268429756165,
0.6631622314453125,
-0.08759723603725433,
0.06985986232757568,
0.05688643082976341,
0.09232142567634583,
0.0840727686882019,
-0.4766293466091156,
0.784834086894989,
0.12744183838367462,
-0.7415242195129395,
0.3970695734024048,
0.1540220081806183,
0.5123952627182007,
-0.6681298613548279,
-0.30418381094932556,
-0.2800525724887848,
0.36904585361480713,
-0.31671738624572754,
-0.8988086581230164,
0.1867847442626953,
0.32633107900619507,
-0.1216338649392128,
-0.14993689954280853,
0.8603067994117737,
-0.23387430608272552,
-0.5559492111206055,
0.07081010192632675,
0.39320409297943115,
0.005307821556925774,
0.04911256209015846,
-0.37481898069381714,
0.4946225583553314,
-0.13378775119781494,
-0.30431562662124634,
-0.10591741651296616,
0.6100443601608276,
-0.00037854930269531906,
0.7084357142448425,
0.6998798847198486,
0.14859583973884583,
-0.399737149477005,
0.4924844801425934,
0.7157895565032959,
-0.3315809369087219,
-0.29734450578689575,
-1.0194917917251587,
0.5674530267715454,
-0.2522037923336029,
-0.07073432207107544,
0.975582480430603,
0.3132297992706299,
0.3656947612762451,
0.029869426041841507,
1.0362058877944946,
0.10208367556333542,
0.44674137234687805,
-0.6625582575798035,
0.2533285319805145,
-0.3411119878292084,
0.5576021075248718,
-0.02915860526263714,
-0.7234970331192017,
-0.19609792530536652,
0.8160258531570435,
-0.43237292766571045,
0.08058253675699234,
0.6973673105239868,
0.7674481272697449,
0.09252927452325821,
0.3332187235355377,
-0.36536774039268494,
0.2701092064380646,
0.15047721564769745,
0.2762904465198517,
1.1092841625213623,
-0.40759891271591187,
0.5217310190200806,
0.19877026975154877,
-0.22417216002941132,
-0.20661209523677826,
-1.1376092433929443,
-0.9551808834075928,
-0.2299051731824875,
-0.4375707805156708,
-0.720828652381897,
0.16798898577690125,
1.0051277875900269,
0.24488160014152527,
-0.7214372754096985,
0.40618911385536194,
-0.3415359556674957,
0.43486863374710083,
-0.22910338640213013,
-0.2642665207386017,
0.31509241461753845,
-0.29441043734550476,
-0.5489039421081543,
0.4122956395149231,
0.37823888659477234,
-0.11320506036281586,
-0.4504144787788391,
-0.07107499986886978,
0.05662817135453224,
0.7143653035163879,
0.6652358770370483,
0.3112157881259918,
-0.6557381749153137,
-0.26326802372932434,
-0.10611928999423981,
-0.2117302566766739,
-0.12181749939918518,
0.5685014724731445,
-0.7873175740242004,
0.17662233114242554,
0.6177094578742981,
0.29894155263900757,
0.42697176337242126,
0.20313763618469238,
0.5816396474838257,
-0.971384584903717,
-0.17234627902507782,
0.1661255955696106,
0.6211454272270203,
0.5072510838508606,
-0.44214585423469543,
0.33963635563850403,
-0.08853977918624878,
-0.39741218090057373,
-1.1037200689315796,
0.17692729830741882,
-1.029008150100708,
-0.12790289521217346,
1.7713916301727295,
-0.08394569903612137,
-0.48876020312309265,
-0.23403987288475037,
-0.37934285402297974,
0.17614731192588806,
-0.33412593603134155,
0.5574147701263428,
0.3160615861415863,
-0.10188136994838715,
-0.19441844522953033,
-0.22257772088050842,
0.5665626525878906,
0.06335987150669098,
-0.9539510607719421,
0.07278714329004288,
0.5573220252990723,
0.3183821141719818,
-0.10264118015766144,
0.5806710124015808,
-0.2313985824584961,
0.3417126536369324,
0.2766808867454529,
0.0849069133400917,
-0.3662557899951935,
-0.5973458290100098,
-0.19441598653793335,
0.3729437291622162,
0.10051316022872925,
-0.19789253175258636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02337v1 | Open foundation models for Azerbaijani language | 2024-07-02T15:05:47 | 2024-07-02T15:05:47 | Jafar Isbarov, Kavsar Huseynova, Elvin Mammadov, Mammad Hajili | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of multilingual large language models has enabled the
development of language understanding and generation systems in Azerbaijani.
However, most of the production-grade systems rely on cloud solutions, such as
GPT-4. While there have been several attempts to develop open foundation models
for Azerbaijani, these works have not found their way into common use due to a
lack of systemic benchmarking. This paper encompasses several lines of work
that promote open-source foundation models for Azerbaijani. We introduce (1) a
large text corpus for Azerbaijani, (2) a family of encoder-only language models
trained on this dataset, (3) labeled datasets for evaluating these models, and
(4) extensive evaluation that covers all major open-source models with
Azerbaijani support. | [
-0.34786519408226013,
-0.6102601289749146,
0.388816773891449,
0.26486942172050476,
-0.14789843559265137,
-0.18675385415554047,
-0.48426929116249084,
-0.5092437267303467,
-0.23859041929244995,
0.9376904368400574,
-0.34307602047920227,
-0.7105101943016052,
-0.689226508140564,
0.17217563092708588,
-0.6084731221199036,
1.0214515924453735,
-0.3594038784503937,
0.23072440922260284,
0.010044066235423088,
-0.18914882838726044,
-0.13508258759975433,
-0.5821104645729065,
-0.3329072594642639,
-0.121535524725914,
-0.09854552894830704,
0.5809040665626526,
0.5660513639450073,
0.7304816246032715,
0.7549622654914856,
0.22728079557418823,
0.15027521550655365,
-0.5056055784225464,
-0.199405699968338,
0.3609663248062134,
-0.05654677003622055,
-0.22769390046596527,
-0.08964642882347107,
-0.24172115325927734,
1.0458829402923584,
0.6284564137458801,
-0.41005441546440125,
0.11932064592838287,
-0.1402188390493393,
0.6575095653533936,
-0.8017928600311279,
0.34702250361442566,
-0.4757971465587616,
0.02954627200961113,
-0.46924763917922974,
0.4752715528011322,
-0.3217982351779938,
-0.3870273232460022,
0.04548454284667969,
-0.16640429198741913,
0.2756076753139496,
-0.19776928424835205,
0.49540236592292786,
0.03956093266606331,
-0.40454599261283875,
-0.6186555624008179,
-0.9929795861244202,
0.8987401723861694,
-0.7034297585487366,
0.7108203172683716,
0.5641064047813416,
0.5543332695960999,
-0.1727670282125473,
-0.6272590160369873,
-0.46459662914276123,
-0.3388710618019104,
0.24357683956623077,
0.07133421301841736,
-0.08225177228450775,
0.045875318348407745,
-0.09660691767930984,
0.6545606255531311,
-0.490815132856369,
-0.12042616307735443,
-0.29373565316200256,
0.09328491240739822,
0.31922101974487305,
0.10983956605195999,
0.0749022513628006,
0.17798660695552826,
-0.2628052532672882,
0.07875130325555801,
-0.9613355398178101,
0.04882868751883507,
0.4597814977169037,
0.37038612365722656,
-0.09463770687580109,
0.9776523113250732,
-0.5005982518196106,
0.9790345430374146,
-0.2716674208641052,
0.11380898207426071,
0.04142077639698982,
-0.5967641472816467,
-0.45606836676597595,
0.048377037048339844,
0.6975404024124146,
-0.2919746935367584,
0.2572832703590393,
-0.3161468803882599,
-0.21180011332035065,
0.37022435665130615,
0.058774419128894806,
-1.0372791290283203,
-0.09578300267457962,
0.38531893491744995,
-0.36028894782066345,
-0.3830616772174835,
0.11802880465984344,
-0.7729547619819641,
-0.40792474150657654,
0.04219567030668259,
0.15212854743003845,
-0.26025891304016113,
-0.39738333225250244,
0.41387858986854553,
0.13192422688007355,
0.210520401597023,
-0.009635759517550468,
-1.0961225032806396,
0.5684701204299927,
0.4807693064212799,
0.766194760799408,
0.20925314724445343,
-0.20650531351566315,
-0.4818882346153259,
0.016620924696326256,
-0.5790103673934937,
0.7145757675170898,
-0.9799816012382507,
-0.24458548426628113,
0.25572240352630615,
0.1492462456226349,
0.04526294395327568,
-0.2906244695186615,
0.8105276226997375,
-0.4238842725753784,
0.34311893582344055,
-0.052755095064640045,
-0.24599385261535645,
-0.1555464118719101,
0.08981497585773468,
-0.6804596781730652,
0.7174715399742126,
0.29948705434799194,
-0.671600341796875,
0.2790474593639374,
-0.82538902759552,
-0.1621188372373581,
0.12912708520889282,
-0.12479083985090256,
-0.5033208131790161,
-0.019061220809817314,
0.1835630238056183,
0.47757595777511597,
-0.601616621017456,
0.3456508219242096,
-0.10375869274139404,
-0.09376838803291321,
-0.027711138129234314,
-0.13520772755146027,
0.6747404932975769,
0.26971903443336487,
-0.4098702073097229,
0.1525455266237259,
-0.8092958331108093,
-0.06390984356403351,
-0.08413007855415344,
-0.6147326231002808,
-0.08895537257194519,
0.20291639864444733,
0.24823765456676483,
0.24121670424938202,
0.10680248588323593,
-0.8198363780975342,
0.23124118149280548,
-0.4147825837135315,
0.5998766422271729,
0.4593023359775543,
-0.13409414887428284,
0.3508073091506958,
-0.015811309218406677,
0.7251498699188232,
0.027875162661075592,
-0.16095653176307678,
-0.32024723291397095,
-0.5191596150398254,
-0.885191023349762,
-0.38345927000045776,
0.4037145674228668,
0.21397048234939575,
-0.5417428612709045,
0.1695493757724762,
-0.10128085315227509,
-0.43551409244537354,
-0.7017924785614014,
0.019279124215245247,
0.45801836252212524,
0.20709531009197235,
0.3084818720817566,
-0.16283243894577026,
-0.45213308930397034,
-1.0245927572250366,
0.008545038290321827,
0.3638674020767212,
0.21966391801834106,
0.12287908792495728,
0.7290792465209961,
-0.07900234311819077,
0.9712544679641724,
-0.1416722536087036,
-0.26886120438575745,
-0.17654532194137573,
0.03917977213859558,
0.2677129805088043,
0.4412878155708313,
0.5676906108856201,
-0.8653226494789124,
-0.46326059103012085,
0.30320611596107483,
-0.5451756119728088,
0.0707235038280487,
0.6226028203964233,
0.0658530443906784,
0.4160970449447632,
0.113577701151371,
-0.6806668043136597,
0.21504004299640656,
1.0305578708648682,
-0.3293294608592987,
0.5725786089897156,
0.010250733233988285,
0.32683101296424866,
-1.303389310836792,
0.2861665189266205,
-0.06536024808883667,
-0.03077860362827778,
-0.7455143928527832,
0.4161887764930725,
0.10500231385231018,
-0.41603875160217285,
-0.46401622891426086,
0.5014271140098572,
-0.6448206901550293,
-0.3069302439689636,
-0.07153573632240295,
0.01071892213076353,
-0.1882779598236084,
0.10385416448116302,
0.3654434382915497,
0.8954169154167175,
0.7034331560134888,
-0.3742842674255371,
0.6111258268356323,
0.3841947019100189,
-0.8250893354415894,
0.40569761395454407,
-0.6544844508171082,
0.15123635530471802,
-0.10836681723594666,
0.3031694293022156,
-0.8100169897079468,
-0.5214899778366089,
0.38308754563331604,
-0.2570132315158844,
0.14000216126441956,
-0.5499176383018494,
-0.26828378438949585,
-0.44938018918037415,
-0.09557836502790451,
0.2159278243780136,
0.3904484510421753,
-0.45401155948638916,
0.39668789505958557,
0.3044198751449585,
-0.3122222125530243,
-1.02016019821167,
-0.6942070126533508,
-0.020640779286623,
-0.08778316527605057,
-0.8959068655967712,
0.13011689484119415,
-0.04003053903579712,
-0.36265847086906433,
0.32794713973999023,
0.027300242334604263,
-0.5408440828323364,
0.015819605439901352,
0.24352438747882843,
-0.22808663547039032,
-0.7966895699501038,
0.19894802570343018,
-0.2405843436717987,
-0.008072705008089542,
-0.1806679517030716,
-0.6189780235290527,
0.5427365303039551,
-0.5535757541656494,
-0.38408464193344116,
0.021915823221206665,
0.4946618974208832,
0.7594427466392517,
-0.9219048023223877,
1.2232321500778198,
0.18285751342773438,
-0.7150664925575256,
-0.2663211524486542,
-0.3004184663295746,
0.14345811307430267,
-0.4193285405635834,
0.38522809743881226,
-0.5184551477432251,
-0.9678438901901245,
0.5650360584259033,
0.07652510702610016,
-0.027140965685248375,
0.49153873324394226,
0.8666942119598389,
0.3153441250324249,
0.8678439259529114,
0.7025673389434814,
-0.052781324833631516,
0.2483726590871811,
-0.240675151348114,
0.18397675454616547,
-0.6928434371948242,
-0.08484971523284912,
-1.2374391555786133,
0.40752196311950684,
-0.2750609219074249,
-0.2545946538448334,
-0.07428586483001709,
0.5300485491752625,
-0.30744755268096924,
0.46699681878089905,
-0.3051088750362396,
0.6059255003929138,
0.1926453411579132,
-0.34266406297683716,
0.3956035375595093,
0.005410559941083193,
-0.08089910447597504,
0.3063015937805176,
-0.5432235598564148,
-0.6606889367103577,
1.1959106922149658,
0.1894703358411789,
0.5696473121643066,
0.4826592803001404,
0.5409632921218872,
0.08229807019233704,
0.48468977212905884,
-0.5108568668365479,
0.067766934633255,
-0.2557883560657501,
-0.8422659039497375,
-0.45320865511894226,
-0.29586416482925415,
-1.0156917572021484,
0.3524009883403778,
-0.37996289134025574,
-0.6921765804290771,
0.0287236999720335,
0.008525483310222626,
-0.07830823212862015,
0.11332298070192337,
-0.42886701226234436,
1.080130934715271,
0.17203053832054138,
-0.21176187694072723,
-0.21006804704666138,
-0.2214564085006714,
0.6395225524902344,
-0.3749762177467346,
0.3954424560070038,
-0.09798835963010788,
0.2281094789505005,
0.5221177935600281,
-0.47557565569877625,
0.3484850525856018,
-0.1949436068534851,
-0.14338447153568268,
0.4728253483772278,
-0.06806626170873642,
0.5604654550552368,
-0.34966740012168884,
-0.4284517765045166,
0.1219429075717926,
-0.11813447624444962,
-0.4146527051925659,
-0.30030450224876404,
0.9783856272697449,
-0.8824867606163025,
-0.3305610418319702,
-0.2484791874885559,
-0.014774556271731853,
-0.2512921690940857,
0.3648117184638977,
0.1355540156364441,
0.702969491481781,
-0.5188953876495361,
0.9351398348808289,
0.39941680431365967,
-0.09764113277196884,
0.3925801217556,
0.5115518569946289,
-0.19608595967292786,
-0.33881068229675293,
0.5071794986724854,
0.09330838918685913,
0.22582513093948364,
0.17595291137695312,
0.2048950493335724,
-0.3051174581050873,
-0.7559627294540405,
-0.9832654595375061,
-0.0021907829213887453,
-0.8788976669311523,
-0.1526896357536316,
-0.7887463569641113,
-0.12912358343601227,
-0.5033944249153137,
-0.16369406878948212,
-0.4271197021007538,
-0.4538186192512512,
0.1668277084827423,
-0.10199132561683655,
0.3586074411869049,
1.2148388624191284,
0.28755220770835876,
0.4014304578304291,
-0.8200912475585938,
0.24705567955970764,
-0.03927839919924736,
0.8286570310592651,
-0.029562868177890778,
-0.05649234727025032,
-0.5471013784408569,
0.34733524918556213,
-0.15366537868976593,
-0.8420664072036743,
0.11956261098384857,
0.20983874797821045,
0.721863329410553,
0.21371081471443176,
-0.05860801413655281,
0.04662984609603882,
-0.497312068939209,
0.8677661418914795,
-0.07534659653902054,
-1.1166719198226929,
0.2833074629306793,
-0.7794806957244873,
0.045973002910614014,
0.3493136167526245,
0.41899052262306213,
-0.565598726272583,
-0.1848968118429184,
-0.22721430659294128,
-0.6298685073852539,
0.8907268643379211,
0.44649308919906616,
0.06681232154369354,
-0.017014414072036743,
-0.07789183408021927,
0.15020209550857544,
0.3512383997440338,
-0.7307671904563904,
0.16623766720294952,
-0.43116626143455505,
-0.5150368213653564,
-0.2579289972782135,
-0.023306388407945633,
0.04910403862595558,
0.3166067898273468,
0.7494437098503113,
0.02747531607747078,
0.14354205131530762,
-0.052634093910455704,
-0.20678752660751343,
-0.30337128043174744,
0.5285800099372864,
0.7163776159286499,
0.41968628764152527,
-0.14776864647865295,
-0.2574371099472046,
-0.1752023994922638,
-0.4972665011882782,
0.4041123688220978,
0.06795230507850647,
0.003200216218829155,
-0.3228205144405365,
0.2597479820251465,
0.7678172588348389,
0.15777845680713654,
-0.5370713472366333,
0.6759253144264221,
0.07490258663892746,
-0.20087674260139465,
-0.38619232177734375,
-0.05512155964970589,
0.4012403190135956,
0.058031558990478516,
0.1404024064540863,
-0.062116459012031555,
-0.11412189155817032,
-0.6198108792304993,
0.13418567180633545,
0.4520426094532013,
-0.344902366399765,
-0.20944155752658844,
0.5558729767799377,
0.41680261492729187,
-0.28999826312065125,
0.6873465776443481,
0.30890172719955444,
-0.5222904682159424,
0.7784859538078308,
0.7503976821899414,
0.8945682048797607,
-0.47583821415901184,
0.1351195126771927,
0.23936913907527924,
0.35905906558036804,
-0.3243042826652527,
0.2818388044834137,
-0.12297613173723221,
-0.9336796998977661,
-0.37419164180755615,
-0.9880742430686951,
-0.5372796654701233,
0.17451895773410797,
-0.388409823179245,
0.4890419542789459,
-0.42164966464042664,
0.08403962850570679,
0.012956826016306877,
-0.02094743587076664,
-0.7644733190536499,
0.3437070846557617,
-0.025155765935778618,
0.9301593899726868,
-0.8151551485061646,
1.056776523590088,
0.5836309790611267,
-0.5376219153404236,
-0.4023224413394928,
-0.1850956827402115,
-0.3954981863498688,
-0.5111051797866821,
0.5210399031639099,
0.2358221858739853,
-0.5127968788146973,
0.3781927227973938,
-0.3703749477863312,
-1.0049772262573242,
0.8368499279022217,
0.2750622034072876,
-0.3548300564289093,
0.2829127311706543,
0.13587859272956848,
0.5127573609352112,
-0.7889211773872375,
0.16294875741004944,
0.210272878408432,
0.7035822868347168,
-0.16529619693756104,
-0.7094751000404358,
-0.19952964782714844,
-0.29360097646713257,
-0.2099021077156067,
0.6702206134796143,
-0.5532994866371155,
1.0877398252487183,
-0.00865978840738535,
-0.34700924158096313,
0.42102161049842834,
0.29647764563560486,
-0.1393037587404251,
-0.13917827606201172,
-0.04155947268009186,
0.5638846755027771,
0.43709346652030945,
-0.1716286689043045,
1.1997647285461426,
-0.5226903557777405,
0.47516077756881714,
0.7929510474205017,
-0.47016507387161255,
1.0720702409744263,
-0.009988346137106419,
-0.12090162187814713,
0.5389751195907593,
0.3774491846561432,
-0.06159456819295883,
0.5071823000907898,
0.3811812996864319,
-0.4396962523460388,
-0.029311994090676308,
-0.05928055942058563,
-0.6900339722633362,
0.6019627451896667,
0.33054494857788086,
-0.48312172293663025,
-0.2882772386074066,
-0.021527700126171112,
-0.11593382805585861,
0.08450145274400711,
-0.2788333296775818,
0.5086918473243713,
-0.1707504391670227,
-0.5827898383140564,
0.4866802990436554,
0.627133309841156,
0.41470271348953247,
-0.7847817540168762,
-0.029098251834511757,
-0.0176702793687582,
0.3339918255805969,
-0.1911131888628006,
-0.6265826225280762,
0.4590032994747162,
0.22639743983745575,
-0.22900551557540894,
-0.026061147451400757,
0.6806696653366089,
-0.684067964553833,
-0.575235903263092,
0.36877304315567017,
0.4153556823730469,
0.1661669909954071,
-0.18733544647693634,
-0.21554656326770782,
0.00917347427457571,
-0.24386239051818848,
-0.5204416513442993,
0.14082609117031097,
0.19505874812602997,
-0.3628128170967102,
0.5613778233528137,
0.8070597052574158,
-0.04449573531746864,
0.03797216713428497,
-0.23041380941867828,
0.6524257659912109,
-0.6407846212387085,
-0.3830798268318176,
-0.7627475261688232,
0.4255550801753998,
0.26422375440597534,
-0.3204876184463501,
0.6338121891021729,
0.5115606188774109,
0.7646811604499817,
-0.24827496707439423,
1.1917705535888672,
-0.01854964718222618,
0.316602498292923,
-0.6096974611282349,
0.9489129185676575,
-0.2747306227684021,
-0.3784862160682678,
-0.26930487155914307,
-1.3609981536865234,
-0.36533576250076294,
0.6657427549362183,
-0.1818864345550537,
0.00045938172843307257,
0.6400869488716125,
0.6070725917816162,
-0.1119828075170517,
0.3906590938568115,
0.38161134719848633,
0.36113736033439636,
0.18361182510852814,
0.6055954098701477,
0.8697305917739868,
-0.2385128289461136,
0.38393574953079224,
-0.10466931760311127,
-0.3565690219402313,
-0.18307216465473175,
-1.0607290267944336,
-0.8445881009101868,
-0.7796876430511475,
0.15341778099536896,
-0.2829301059246063,
0.33513763546943665,
0.8607058525085449,
0.7586343884468079,
-1.1292892694473267,
-0.30752524733543396,
-0.29168471693992615,
-0.2070257067680359,
0.040570635348558426,
-0.08656386286020279,
0.26880258321762085,
0.09567578881978989,
-0.4986826181411743,
0.5766658186912537,
0.08437732607126236,
0.10422109067440033,
-0.4606421887874603,
-0.1750011295080185,
0.010638379491865635,
0.17279331386089325,
0.3313275873661041,
0.22089821100234985,
-0.635827898979187,
-0.28890153765678406,
-0.03763440623879433,
-0.13934895396232605,
0.1000046581029892,
0.8595232367515564,
-0.6403273344039917,
0.3271401524543762,
0.4083006680011749,
0.6745309829711914,
0.6428842544555664,
-0.0355440229177475,
0.7517497539520264,
-0.3628399074077606,
0.16280092298984528,
0.1422181874513626,
0.5278458595275879,
0.560703456401825,
-0.19743984937667847,
0.500011682510376,
0.07845784723758698,
-0.4648970067501068,
-0.6303883790969849,
0.47352585196495056,
-0.325954794883728,
-0.06910542398691177,
0.9429908394813538,
-0.397422194480896,
0.001077881664969027,
-0.29189571738243103,
-0.1030140146613121,
-0.008718760684132576,
-0.2967369556427002,
0.3513418734073639,
1.338792324066162,
0.2404222935438156,
-0.08320653438568115,
-0.5464711785316467,
0.38477760553359985,
-0.08343146741390228,
-0.7697705626487732,
0.3716926574707031,
0.5455285310745239,
0.30149590969085693,
0.03967800736427307,
0.803678572177887,
-0.18896782398223877,
0.10887884348630905,
0.2750486135482788,
0.3335250914096832,
-0.20158246159553528,
-0.6638144850730896,
-0.6013898849487305,
0.3909077048301697,
0.22180312871932983,
0.0196213498711586
] |