id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01300v1 | Collaborative Performance Prediction for Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T13:56:42 | 2024-07-01T13:56:42 | Qiyuan Zhang, Fuyuan Lyu, Xue Liu, Chen Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Comprehensively understanding and accurately predicting the performance of
large language models across diverse downstream tasks has emerged as a pivotal
challenge in NLP research. The pioneering scaling law on downstream works
demonstrated intrinsic similarities within model families and utilized such
similarities for performance prediction. However, they tend to overlook the
similarities between model families and only consider design factors listed in
the original scaling law. To overcome these limitations, we introduce a novel
framework, Collaborative Performance Prediction (CPP), which significantly
enhances prediction accuracy by leveraging the historical performance of
various models on downstream tasks and other design factors for both model and
task. We also collect a collaborative data sourced from online platforms
containing both historical performance and additional design factors. With the
support of the collaborative data, CPP not only surpasses traditional scaling
laws in predicting the performance of scaled LLMs but also facilitates a
detailed analysis of factor importance, an area previously overlooked. | [
-0.45280569791793823,
-0.20094551146030426,
0.5936843752861023,
0.369295209646225,
0.08239767700433731,
0.21315838396549225,
-0.36806508898735046,
-0.6537539958953857,
0.24529598653316498,
0.9222878813743591,
-0.8132891654968262,
-0.16343390941619873,
-0.6912084817886353,
-0.08012951910495758,
-0.05800922214984894,
0.7035172581672668,
0.2755127251148224,
0.38611918687820435,
-0.4567578136920929,
-0.10589893162250519,
-0.4331580698490143,
-0.7382732033729553,
-0.6646634340286255,
-0.7051510214805603,
0.6465308666229248,
0.07377402484416962,
0.5714747905731201,
0.6070497632026672,
0.694510817527771,
0.2691369354724884,
-0.26547589898109436,
0.15734706819057465,
-0.5553069710731506,
0.2631671726703644,
-0.27139735221862793,
-0.3311929404735565,
-0.6416010856628418,
-0.19317951798439026,
0.6150034666061401,
1.0907728672027588,
-0.20767182111740112,
0.14441274106502533,
0.6470056772232056,
0.7624686360359192,
-0.562969446182251,
0.4345170259475708,
-0.6548203229904175,
0.05960579216480255,
-0.10128891468048096,
-0.285159707069397,
-0.7974696755409241,
-0.12101747840642929,
0.10025855153799057,
-0.5919029116630554,
0.29793593287467957,
0.22377394139766693,
0.22237353026866913,
0.30607548356056213,
-0.2891976237297058,
-0.16935256123542786,
-0.8337711691856384,
0.863020658493042,
-0.7815493941307068,
0.4208453297615051,
0.32523003220558167,
0.1575743556022644,
-0.503856360912323,
-0.8371850848197937,
-0.3085309565067291,
-0.16966894268989563,
-0.1595502644777298,
-0.038928963243961334,
-0.14402838051319122,
0.11898548156023026,
0.23585985600948334,
0.4288145899772644,
-0.6834516525268555,
0.38871222734451294,
-0.22357258200645447,
-0.04024096578359604,
0.6995676159858704,
0.39612969756126404,
0.01693008653819561,
0.24266180396080017,
-0.276770681142807,
0.08315297961235046,
-0.5874137878417969,
0.1678556650876999,
-0.06156954541802406,
0.7368316054344177,
-0.32476481795310974,
0.37619155645370483,
-0.22994364798069,
0.3119316101074219,
0.25503501296043396,
-0.10975570231676102,
0.40362852811813354,
-0.4741419553756714,
0.004156525246798992,
-0.07894250005483627,
0.8270440697669983,
0.39287978410720825,
0.13046565651893616,
-0.3276951313018799,
-0.11759109795093536,
-0.34967243671417236,
0.25940075516700745,
-0.6448692083358765,
-0.36060860753059387,
-0.08608996868133545,
-0.525749146938324,
-0.10233660787343979,
-0.0738433375954628,
-0.7778605222702026,
-0.6906098127365112,
-0.5133142471313477,
0.1556333750486374,
0.045379698276519775,
-0.4830280542373657,
-0.1091768816113472,
0.0073731630109250546,
-0.14396102726459503,
0.29725024104118347,
-1.2328826189041138,
0.6915969252586365,
1.2796441316604614,
0.9671359658241272,
-0.4178525507450104,
-0.47245392203330994,
-0.8925381898880005,
0.1450873166322708,
-0.2488676905632019,
0.5696998238563538,
-0.43192312121391296,
-0.3105551600456238,
0.08661559969186783,
-0.18571965396404266,
-0.05285773426294327,
-0.5752097964286804,
0.4816567897796631,
-0.5826715230941772,
-0.150014728307724,
-0.34114545583724976,
-0.9238379597663879,
-0.10338075459003448,
-0.040139272809028625,
-1.0738149881362915,
0.7696883678436279,
0.18952924013137817,
-1.008059024810791,
0.7333986759185791,
-0.48128843307495117,
-0.33288875222206116,
0.3376689553260803,
-0.052379898726940155,
-0.41576096415519714,
0.3978263735771179,
0.2064395695924759,
0.7149285674095154,
-0.3299982249736786,
0.2524002492427826,
-0.802122950553894,
-0.24545811116695404,
-0.18758177757263184,
0.043656717985868454,
0.6580431461334229,
-0.2032073587179184,
-0.19246381521224976,
0.35606101155281067,
-0.6789346933364868,
0.18990251421928406,
-0.2045758068561554,
-0.3473060727119446,
-0.21984638273715973,
0.13991810381412506,
0.051441457122564316,
0.23095014691352844,
0.3652852177619934,
-0.34965479373931885,
0.11195617914199829,
-0.2859688699245453,
0.11728563904762268,
0.8243656754493713,
-0.12045377492904663,
0.6523252725601196,
-0.2856023609638214,
0.7952508330345154,
-0.680680513381958,
0.1008150726556778,
0.26048406958580017,
-0.7188337445259094,
-0.3103633224964142,
-0.20854011178016663,
0.12224743515253067,
0.22849184274673462,
-0.3309119641780853,
0.3950876295566559,
-0.5328982472419739,
-0.6947847008705139,
-0.15516342222690582,
0.4207995533943176,
0.16245554387569427,
0.245504230260849,
0.3696207106113434,
-0.5934290289878845,
-0.8835480213165283,
-0.6803116202354431,
-0.2335028201341629,
-0.4682959318161011,
-0.32980841398239136,
0.3444635570049286,
0.1349502056837082,
-0.044155288487672806,
0.78009033203125,
-0.4890003204345703,
-0.4002229869365692,
-0.6074782609939575,
0.43293917179107666,
0.379876971244812,
0.404215008020401,
0.49022385478019714,
-0.52472323179245,
-0.5973021984100342,
0.014228928834199905,
-0.37489351630210876,
-0.35381314158439636,
0.1596839278936386,
0.0449971966445446,
-0.0005674640997312963,
0.5320479273796082,
-0.05815490335226059,
-0.21041792631149292,
1.2750695943832397,
-0.43039289116859436,
0.6526544690132141,
-0.2319413423538208,
-0.13113833963871002,
-1.1275087594985962,
-0.14728538691997528,
0.10128898918628693,
-0.1312132179737091,
-0.36019760370254517,
0.061026252806186676,
0.10711746662855148,
0.22129978239536285,
-0.23279322683811188,
0.24893540143966675,
-0.1827535182237625,
-0.3205837309360504,
-0.223858043551445,
-0.26975661516189575,
-0.21497616171836853,
0.41431373357772827,
0.17310652136802673,
0.7325876355171204,
0.4312748908996582,
-0.424793004989624,
0.21787351369857788,
-0.02169901318848133,
-0.35651344060897827,
0.2716298997402191,
-0.6639511585235596,
-0.05601075291633606,
0.4462887644767761,
0.3053340017795563,
-0.824699878692627,
-0.08760702610015869,
-0.5968994498252869,
-0.4919825494289398,
0.29547637701034546,
-0.31965702772140503,
-0.6826928853988647,
-0.17790871858596802,
-0.043746303766965866,
0.2971453368663788,
0.2915549576282501,
-0.5574082732200623,
0.8540523648262024,
0.5442978739738464,
-0.21637031435966492,
-0.3569815158843994,
-0.5373306274414062,
0.004954539239406586,
-0.16870740056037903,
-0.8508009314537048,
0.4347689151763916,
-0.05561637878417969,
-0.1657857894897461,
-0.24457326531410217,
0.20834031701087952,
-0.33907899260520935,
0.28267136216163635,
0.5987756848335266,
0.3053748905658722,
-0.4262101650238037,
0.05690697580575943,
-0.27114081382751465,
-0.08718182891607285,
0.45158395171165466,
-0.05167771503329277,
0.7373742461204529,
-0.09365278482437134,
0.097846120595932,
-0.2636789083480835,
0.055969856679439545,
0.6796544790267944,
-0.20987050235271454,
0.9678350687026978,
0.6873591542243958,
-0.3143383264541626,
-0.32829490303993225,
-0.5955261588096619,
-0.13569627702236176,
-0.48227956891059875,
0.3743687868118286,
-0.06435105949640274,
-1.026381492614746,
0.5627831816673279,
-0.19231370091438293,
-0.04008978605270386,
0.49399787187576294,
0.6627299189567566,
-0.020364604890346527,
1.0515652894973755,
1.1687408685684204,
-0.22685347497463226,
0.5311242938041687,
-0.15997828543186188,
-0.04369647428393364,
-0.9304718375205994,
-0.15730023384094238,
-0.42264524102211,
-0.25665825605392456,
-0.9605013132095337,
-0.46920788288116455,
0.39561811089515686,
0.10254126042127609,
-0.09681962430477142,
0.5714911818504333,
-0.043768513947725296,
0.22513264417648315,
0.4883466362953186,
-0.23807711899280548,
0.5310075283050537,
0.02184489369392395,
-0.28025445342063904,
-0.29946157336235046,
-0.49787724018096924,
-0.352690190076828,
1.364607810974121,
0.3958472013473511,
0.4372391104698181,
0.20231610536575317,
0.7575812935829163,
0.2975926399230957,
0.5366217494010925,
-0.6616425514221191,
0.39628154039382935,
-0.38917383551597595,
-0.6199710965156555,
-0.20725467801094055,
-0.6331470012664795,
-0.8365975022315979,
0.30272507667541504,
-0.44229236245155334,
-0.8572304844856262,
-0.21183015406131744,
0.0837346538901329,
-0.5137088298797607,
0.28735101222991943,
-0.43891704082489014,
0.6941995024681091,
-0.08385606110095978,
-0.6206932663917542,
-0.7836517095565796,
-0.335509330034256,
0.23186898231506348,
-0.3371821641921997,
0.3246229290962219,
-0.07641433924436569,
-0.10491397231817245,
0.7352381944656372,
-0.40288084745407104,
0.7581360340118408,
0.10452289134263992,
0.1460566520690918,
-0.06440886110067368,
0.27478209137916565,
0.4310780465602875,
-0.12296119332313538,
-0.36419880390167236,
0.2543523907661438,
-0.08871257305145264,
-0.08072762936353683,
-0.44495102763175964,
1.0430772304534912,
-0.6118413805961609,
-0.2939053773880005,
-0.11150392889976501,
-0.5182729959487915,
-0.604035496711731,
0.19805841147899628,
0.049836400896310806,
0.22154246270656586,
0.011020418256521225,
0.6369223594665527,
0.06822036951780319,
0.1821812093257904,
0.6171640753746033,
0.46298205852508545,
-0.22576679289340973,
-0.4907933175563812,
0.581571102142334,
0.15762311220169067,
0.2564341425895691,
0.565496563911438,
0.5153936147689819,
-0.45789283514022827,
-0.8262836933135986,
-0.11829148232936859,
0.16481414437294006,
-0.40963128209114075,
0.11130186915397644,
-0.5213553309440613,
0.09022904187440872,
-0.33509019017219543,
-0.29028668999671936,
-0.6379232406616211,
-0.4044073820114136,
-0.14922766387462616,
-0.02102295681834221,
0.0023838484194129705,
1.0536288022994995,
-0.19328688085079193,
0.1113298311829567,
-0.8219777941703796,
-0.1645011156797409,
0.16219530999660492,
0.7209934592247009,
0.3233935236930847,
-0.4789584279060364,
-0.3273666799068451,
-0.2437799721956253,
-0.5740702748298645,
-0.26764824986457825,
0.5886881351470947,
0.12076198309659958,
0.634838342666626,
0.1298416554927826,
0.12405437976121902,
0.45574256777763367,
-0.48779791593551636,
0.904240071773529,
0.4986346364021301,
-0.7823194265365601,
0.3214314579963684,
-0.3913380205631256,
0.020008491352200508,
0.46410608291625977,
0.4135836362838745,
-0.38075557351112366,
-0.27856510877609253,
-0.612481415271759,
-1.057424545288086,
0.45648887753486633,
0.1699061095714569,
-0.06679867953062057,
0.3900018334388733,
0.04119156301021576,
0.36376461386680603,
0.16651439666748047,
-0.74404376745224,
-0.03718247264623642,
0.459727942943573,
-0.03353338688611984,
-0.328690767288208,
-0.08842897415161133,
0.2971363961696625,
-0.31997597217559814,
0.6231082677841187,
-0.17218632996082306,
-0.24022136628627777,
-0.175215944647789,
0.31159183382987976,
-0.4868626296520233,
-0.2002536654472351,
0.34748345613479614,
1.0768675804138184,
-0.28936055302619934,
-0.14208923280239105,
0.2614176571369171,
-0.438251256942749,
-0.2567078173160553,
-0.09587646275758743,
0.18511849641799927,
-0.14463835954666138,
0.9139987826347351,
0.4962714612483978,
0.23320871591567993,
-0.6750704050064087,
0.4213488698005676,
-0.15591637790203094,
-0.05648760125041008,
-0.7397458553314209,
0.05127187445759773,
0.3364780843257904,
0.5082983374595642,
0.3565283715724945,
0.15199260413646698,
0.17072640359401703,
-0.37534067034721375,
0.505193829536438,
0.17186114192008972,
-0.5708129405975342,
-0.2771453857421875,
0.7605272531509399,
0.39900776743888855,
-0.3124402165412903,
0.35702377557754517,
0.02510157600045204,
-0.5046411752700806,
0.686501145362854,
0.1980041116476059,
0.8336412310600281,
-0.24537159502506256,
-0.03932324796915054,
0.5828272700309753,
-0.0508287139236927,
-0.3845756947994232,
-0.18009091913700104,
0.10050083696842194,
-0.6944157481193542,
-0.8469969034194946,
-0.67885822057724,
-0.5728564858436584,
0.3214925229549408,
-0.7972234487533569,
0.24816584587097168,
-0.7767221331596375,
-0.26165151596069336,
0.22080349922180176,
0.35160914063453674,
-0.7390325665473938,
0.08519688993692398,
0.4222967326641083,
0.5918360948562622,
-0.6786147356033325,
0.7304835915565491,
0.27724236249923706,
-0.19828644394874573,
-0.77698814868927,
0.10618263483047485,
0.38390424847602844,
-0.5911651849746704,
0.7336610555648804,
0.15563331544399261,
-0.2265533059835434,
-0.27511370182037354,
-0.10902491956949234,
-1.162778377532959,
1.0348776578903198,
0.3672773540019989,
-0.7715912461280823,
0.0725526213645935,
0.13628357648849487,
0.7895238399505615,
-0.7446264028549194,
0.14483289420604706,
0.314714640378952,
0.04009132832288742,
0.21139511466026306,
-1.5049595832824707,
0.18598484992980957,
0.0036310660652816296,
-0.09956911951303482,
0.11306377500295639,
-0.39221349358558655,
0.8044831156730652,
-0.2781994044780731,
0.1567389965057373,
-0.018039191141724586,
0.6790589094161987,
0.2907363176345825,
0.4883592426776886,
0.5961207747459412,
0.39697229862213135,
0.6924325823783875,
0.08395851403474808,
1.1810111999511719,
-0.3108676075935364,
0.5232789516448975,
1.4903088808059692,
-0.35403451323509216,
1.4119232892990112,
0.39909249544143677,
-0.4552207589149475,
0.4448864758014679,
0.43052467703819275,
-0.08129562437534332,
0.4863716661930084,
0.09235858172178268,
-0.13422177731990814,
-0.3169496953487396,
-0.24010804295539856,
-0.25396761298179626,
0.5309337377548218,
0.18773798644542694,
-0.8588693737983704,
0.23246648907661438,
-0.4548530578613281,
-0.20835410058498383,
0.3151966333389282,
-0.4998706579208374,
0.7916887998580933,
-0.0669468343257904,
-0.7075155377388,
0.49422553181648254,
-0.246693953871727,
0.889703631401062,
-0.2800714373588562,
0.0647246465086937,
0.13179685175418854,
0.5431737303733826,
-0.08482794463634491,
-0.9224808216094971,
0.3964712619781494,
-0.5234279632568359,
-0.4151909649372101,
-0.41604381799697876,
0.3983794152736664,
-0.22144411504268646,
-0.49580034613609314,
1.0210577249526978,
0.4201790392398834,
-0.2763335108757019,
-0.2839542627334595,
-0.5567767024040222,
0.0703401044011116,
0.026236196979880333,
-0.07910149544477463,
0.46263495087623596,
0.142334446310997,
0.32954955101013184,
0.9209469556808472,
0.567668080329895,
0.4584302604198456,
0.14606530964374542,
0.12541912496089935,
0.7889174818992615,
-0.31786713004112244,
-0.5406124591827393,
-0.7981396317481995,
0.3687492907047272,
-0.2344602644443512,
-0.3065086305141449,
0.42708584666252136,
0.7132002115249634,
1.1224274635314941,
0.06489849090576172,
0.7329826951026917,
0.3686099350452423,
0.721338152885437,
-0.34754639863967896,
0.7211816906929016,
-0.5514279007911682,
0.21306093037128448,
-0.4384031891822815,
-0.9879936575889587,
-0.27403783798217773,
0.23010478913784027,
-0.24208508431911469,
-0.04135126248002052,
0.6453547477722168,
0.7216509580612183,
0.05663634464144707,
0.32368797063827515,
0.47019070386886597,
0.1676894724369049,
0.44265028834342957,
0.5709624886512756,
0.33841440081596375,
0.010339406318962574,
0.5767321586608887,
-0.8238834738731384,
-0.11464562267065048,
-0.38656193017959595,
-0.978306233882904,
-0.8297096490859985,
-0.7100662589073181,
-0.3078206181526184,
-0.1992616206407547,
-0.3027888238430023,
0.9821354746818542,
0.9884176850318909,
-0.8687857985496521,
-0.5394028425216675,
-0.38710910081863403,
-0.060412757098674774,
-0.6289023160934448,
-0.23019394278526306,
0.1225929856300354,
-0.12315812706947327,
-0.6786631941795349,
0.38300561904907227,
0.037680402398109436,
-0.19027195870876312,
-0.4559766948223114,
-0.22070063650608063,
0.11002279072999954,
-0.14035935699939728,
0.6154573559761047,
0.00283091445453465,
-0.8267785906791687,
-0.02949007973074913,
-0.3186207115650177,
-0.002466302365064621,
-0.17416243255138397,
1.1513144969940186,
-0.5096601843833923,
0.33922848105430603,
0.7080891132354736,
0.7007796764373779,
0.4831605553627014,
-0.1914634257555008,
1.0648053884506226,
-0.7226535081863403,
-0.15578357875347137,
0.4237692356109619,
0.6401978135108948,
0.4592769742012024,
-0.44919779896736145,
0.7587675452232361,
0.23450900614261627,
-0.6950607895851135,
-0.5755987763404846,
0.03184571489691734,
-1.0204188823699951,
-0.05876217409968376,
1.121297001838684,
-0.43675297498703003,
0.10651753842830658,
-0.12259016931056976,
-0.002769581275060773,
0.09999627619981766,
-0.5170822143554688,
0.6450554728507996,
0.9244052171707153,
-0.35058844089508057,
-0.41934341192245483,
-0.7483508586883545,
0.40181779861450195,
0.48626136779785156,
-0.3308461904525757,
0.4868098199367523,
0.3656166195869446,
0.14436525106430054,
0.3307305872440338,
0.2244286686182022,
0.15513618290424347,
-0.0001735129189910367,
-0.02215215563774109,
-0.005815329495817423,
0.07220564782619476,
-0.12245669215917587,
-0.0988931730389595,
0.6132404804229736,
0.3116858899593353,
0.1824761927127838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01291v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01291v1 | Lightweight Zero-shot Text-to-Speech with Mixture of Adapters | 2024-07-01T13:45:31 | 2024-07-01T13:45:31 | Kenichi Fujita, Takanori Ashihara, Marc Delcroix, Yusuke Ijima | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | The advancements in zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) methods, based on
large-scale models, have demonstrated high fidelity in reproducing speaker
characteristics. However, these models are too large for practical daily use.
We propose a lightweight zero-shot TTS method using a mixture of adapters
(MoA). Our proposed method incorporates MoA modules into the decoder and the
variance adapter of a non-autoregressive TTS model. These modules enhance the
ability to adapt a wide variety of speakers in a zero-shot manner by selecting
appropriate adapters associated with speaker characteristics on the basis of
speaker embeddings. Our method achieves high-quality speech synthesis with
minimal additional parameters. Through objective and subjective evaluations, we
confirmed that our method achieves better performance than the baseline with
less than 40\% of parameters at 1.9 times faster inference speed. Audio samples
are available on our demo page
(https://ntt-hilab-gensp.github.io/is2024lightweightTTS/). | [
-0.043957050889730453,
-0.7967175245285034,
0.3913326561450958,
0.10156452655792236,
-0.675175666809082,
0.00005218374280957505,
-0.13225063681602478,
-0.32914507389068604,
0.601348876953125,
0.2226344645023346,
-0.3542979061603546,
-0.31030523777008057,
-0.4608863294124603,
-0.058568503707647324,
-0.44569769501686096,
0.8128284215927124,
0.4520142376422882,
-0.16234226524829865,
0.16476966440677643,
-0.28893834352493286,
-0.7859123349189758,
-0.017123375087976456,
-0.15165212750434875,
-0.13567249476909637,
0.24113202095031738,
0.7215880751609802,
0.3285938501358032,
0.649488627910614,
-0.2708415687084198,
0.14620140194892883,
-0.31356367468833923,
-0.22020380198955536,
-0.4318167567253113,
0.29378169775009155,
-0.09622098505496979,
-0.4194258749485016,
-0.5786696076393127,
-0.3544235825538635,
0.6326578259468079,
0.33703380823135376,
-0.27620217204093933,
0.2834760248661041,
-0.14901621639728546,
0.17936129868030548,
-1.0244728326797485,
-0.42928603291511536,
-0.8626055717468262,
0.03264065459370613,
-0.17681686580181122,
-0.4346281588077545,
-0.5754570960998535,
0.185521200299263,
0.05368046835064888,
-0.3456282615661621,
0.16631829738616943,
-0.2117217630147934,
0.1964442878961563,
0.04645773023366928,
-0.5020217895507812,
0.18596556782722473,
-0.9370224475860596,
0.8458170294761658,
-1.004125714302063,
0.41855692863464355,
-0.18084311485290527,
0.3544216752052307,
0.045462530106306076,
-0.23286500573158264,
-0.6455413103103638,
-0.13813617825508118,
0.43091729283332825,
0.41827937960624695,
-0.15866190195083618,
-0.05860570818185806,
-0.16283510625362396,
0.3671717345714569,
-0.6319523453712463,
-0.02418608032166958,
-0.000007741678928141482,
-0.08868918567895889,
0.2331102043390274,
0.034925661981105804,
0.3038334846496582,
-0.23483893275260925,
-0.20333760976791382,
-0.10263394564390182,
-0.42086175084114075,
-0.21048422157764435,
0.22635303437709808,
0.611294686794281,
-0.4932413697242737,
0.8777468204498291,
-0.3433428108692169,
0.8290161490440369,
0.24285082519054413,
-0.5128841400146484,
0.37983816862106323,
-0.2720888555049896,
-0.289028137922287,
0.16985347867012024,
0.8116937279701233,
0.22781945765018463,
-0.1644052267074585,
-0.3513255715370178,
-0.3489048182964325,
-0.03676118329167366,
-0.010209268890321255,
-0.9859327673912048,
0.1892380267381668,
0.17193004488945007,
-0.3504171669483185,
-0.20681384205818176,
-0.30254584550857544,
-1.1133525371551514,
-0.14732307195663452,
-0.09712115675210953,
1.0769144296646118,
-0.6707199811935425,
-0.22729186713695526,
0.08868632465600967,
-0.675578773021698,
0.24365651607513428,
0.2830254137516022,
-0.9191964864730835,
0.19950291514396667,
-0.03797893226146698,
1.0059055089950562,
-0.11521347612142563,
0.06188453361392021,
-0.870745837688446,
0.532187819480896,
-0.28812578320503235,
0.736984133720398,
-0.20413675904273987,
-0.8718947172164917,
-0.1747717261314392,
-0.49386975169181824,
0.08534980565309525,
-0.42921414971351624,
0.6153127551078796,
0.2068922370672226,
0.1371290385723114,
0.17679084837436676,
-0.5199400186538696,
0.3811306953430176,
0.004062882624566555,
-0.01993168704211712,
1.0765047073364258,
0.15587934851646423,
-0.4257891774177551,
0.20906385779380798,
-0.6170228719711304,
-0.7809006571769714,
0.22755926847457886,
-0.16935354471206665,
-0.0751672014594078,
0.49863141775131226,
0.2644842863082886,
0.34496670961380005,
-0.2601744532585144,
-0.0080203702673316,
-0.33321934938430786,
-0.4861971139907837,
0.038522616028785706,
-0.7698105573654175,
0.4546971619129181,
0.2186444103717804,
-0.5009339451789856,
0.006704557221382856,
-1.2922693490982056,
-0.1422334909439087,
0.2077481597661972,
-0.012443593703210354,
-0.27607107162475586,
-0.23617172241210938,
0.3205423057079315,
0.02931857481598854,
0.1657295823097229,
-0.7000176310539246,
-0.3085356652736664,
-0.5002389550209045,
0.3465486764907837,
0.6240776181221008,
-0.04442895948886871,
0.5302006006240845,
-0.2744467854499817,
0.33852389454841614,
0.08033975958824158,
-0.13846909999847412,
-0.3742934763431549,
-0.47570034861564636,
-0.8923400640487671,
-0.5436327457427979,
0.1878834068775177,
0.520480751991272,
-1.099117398262024,
0.8466880917549133,
-0.3651767671108246,
-0.8398545384407043,
-0.3325142562389374,
-0.270090252161026,
0.2144213616847992,
0.6982035636901855,
0.422427773475647,
-0.2789502739906311,
-0.3660089075565338,
-0.38874003291130066,
-0.2110026478767395,
-0.2115713506937027,
-0.4882664382457733,
0.35667160153388977,
0.276846706867218,
0.09778806567192078,
1.168013095855713,
-0.5255402326583862,
-0.043026089668273926,
-0.28009453415870667,
0.3057265281677246,
-0.0033262940123677254,
0.48640456795692444,
1.0476374626159668,
-0.07054395973682404,
-0.31684157252311707,
-0.016275519505143166,
-0.4429793357849121,
-0.13813796639442444,
0.12039537727832794,
0.09346220642328262,
-0.03425493463873863,
0.060102757066488266,
-0.3339930772781372,
0.39214468002319336,
0.5160877108573914,
-0.5346693396568298,
0.39946192502975464,
-0.1399029791355133,
-0.0834944024682045,
-1.4393856525421143,
0.16061151027679443,
0.15918339788913727,
-0.4411156177520752,
-0.9244319200515747,
-0.34756922721862793,
-0.24302180111408234,
-0.43849125504493713,
-0.668858528137207,
0.6795206069946289,
-0.09090480208396912,
-0.10713612288236618,
-0.5254390239715576,
0.1277880072593689,
-0.08375439047813416,
0.22351659834384918,
-0.030353033915162086,
1.196345567703247,
0.6310495734214783,
-0.5204259157180786,
0.1546422690153122,
0.14407195150852203,
0.005909346975386143,
0.8392235636711121,
-0.8169993758201599,
0.08764683455228806,
-0.26860177516937256,
0.4225406050682068,
-0.9659103751182556,
-0.03017183020710945,
0.23033559322357178,
-0.579517662525177,
0.14592482149600983,
-0.09091608226299286,
-0.25781795382499695,
0.16333791613578796,
-0.480010449886322,
0.48595020174980164,
0.6817128658294678,
-0.3105411231517792,
0.8700129985809326,
0.3655981421470642,
-0.3588094711303711,
-0.08827945590019226,
-0.8875700831413269,
0.2772676944732666,
-0.0904112160205841,
-0.2852277457714081,
0.34417787194252014,
-0.23080573976039886,
0.24719715118408203,
-0.1603715717792511,
-0.2961718738079071,
-0.3276825547218323,
-0.25623375177383423,
0.10900849103927612,
0.43514466285705566,
-0.4899608790874481,
-0.19453111290931702,
0.1451660841703415,
-0.25674688816070557,
-0.6474729776382446,
-0.4281700551509857,
0.3523247539997101,
0.3131197988986969,
-0.09755222499370575,
-0.6097767353057861,
0.5203137993812561,
0.8889232873916626,
0.18646007776260376,
0.6040957570075989,
0.5714759826660156,
-0.19436994194984436,
-0.12561532855033875,
-0.5050634741783142,
-0.0895032212138176,
-0.43681713938713074,
0.2223213165998459,
-0.17309841513633728,
-0.8723675608634949,
0.2667861878871918,
0.23447440564632416,
-0.17304189503192902,
0.49132272601127625,
0.5856149196624756,
0.09419228136539459,
0.5438925623893738,
0.6036761403083801,
-0.18320298194885254,
0.863851010799408,
0.1152309849858284,
0.15848344564437866,
-0.528624951839447,
-0.015662478283047676,
-0.7843186855316162,
-0.20429933071136475,
-0.3571786880493164,
-0.48126229643821716,
0.41442328691482544,
-0.42364737391471863,
-0.019418681040406227,
0.5428358316421509,
-0.416738897562027,
0.22921140491962433,
0.6335501670837402,
0.04232407361268997,
0.17256158590316772,
0.02916577085852623,
0.03811055049300194,
0.06639578938484192,
-0.5720300078392029,
-0.06623873114585876,
1.0914455652236938,
0.043431203812360764,
0.8895928859710693,
0.14071325957775116,
0.6405802965164185,
0.23310108482837677,
-0.20084966719150543,
-0.9187816381454468,
0.6289119720458984,
-0.4779416024684906,
-0.4494367241859436,
-0.2331756204366684,
-0.584135890007019,
-0.4004378318786621,
0.21249312162399292,
-0.4933263659477234,
-0.9005209803581238,
0.32692384719848633,
0.09886589646339417,
-0.45082396268844604,
0.2846381962299347,
-0.8458137512207031,
0.30847615003585815,
0.14045308530330658,
-0.02978995069861412,
-0.023214364424347878,
-0.5816212296485901,
0.23557418584823608,
0.21531669795513153,
0.04974663630127907,
-0.15583950281143188,
-0.00027914994279854,
0.758510410785675,
-0.2988586723804474,
0.7826898097991943,
-0.2668934166431427,
-0.1967046558856964,
0.4235329031944275,
-0.07374106347560883,
0.26449304819107056,
0.006421111524105072,
-0.2624189853668213,
0.1505981683731079,
0.14342504739761353,
-0.4732465445995331,
-0.5806218981742859,
0.5447934865951538,
-0.8123056292533875,
-0.10983442515134811,
-0.2664547562599182,
-0.61580491065979,
-0.49556586146354675,
0.15063324570655823,
0.3637959063053131,
0.8088176250457764,
-0.26761069893836975,
0.5607740879058838,
0.5783190727233887,
-0.12271866202354431,
0.6816365122795105,
0.5620502233505249,
0.052360422909259796,
-0.7670450806617737,
1.236073613166809,
0.19632090628147125,
0.42871782183647156,
0.6912250518798828,
0.3257018029689789,
-0.1363920420408249,
-0.702095627784729,
-0.6429445147514343,
0.07281401008367538,
-0.22843043506145477,
-0.22572341561317444,
-0.4957171380519867,
-0.17291326820850372,
-0.6892154216766357,
-0.1955593377351761,
-0.6927996873855591,
-0.6722415685653687,
-0.5509177446365356,
0.15191447734832764,
0.36865001916885376,
0.20214511454105377,
0.2623691260814667,
0.7306680679321289,
-0.9231603741645813,
0.9632977247238159,
0.44469475746154785,
0.2897416949272156,
-0.03930290415883064,
-1.0480103492736816,
-0.14054524898529053,
0.10198624432086945,
-0.22541308403015137,
-0.8548223972320557,
0.23397161066532135,
0.21317636966705322,
0.22087876498699188,
0.42583805322647095,
0.14704470336437225,
0.9792768955230713,
-0.5437700152397156,
1.0158462524414062,
0.48121631145477295,
-1.1214097738265991,
0.5653290748596191,
-0.5239037871360779,
0.5451673865318298,
0.47131484746932983,
-0.5234025120735168,
-0.37588000297546387,
-0.35044828057289124,
-0.2722962200641632,
-0.8029654026031494,
0.6601869463920593,
0.5497762560844421,
0.4342605769634247,
0.23965607583522797,
0.34938687086105347,
0.1146249994635582,
0.06367983669042587,
-0.48118430376052856,
-0.560002326965332,
-0.40171104669570923,
-0.4507237374782562,
-0.09107613563537598,
-0.343658983707428,
-0.14136174321174622,
-0.24461376667022705,
0.8385145664215088,
-0.3097211420536041,
0.5184282660484314,
0.0976773276925087,
0.020730404183268547,
-0.2504754066467285,
0.6775933504104614,
0.7766123414039612,
0.3205999732017517,
-0.39899942278862,
0.10768512636423111,
0.2459295243024826,
-0.5441585779190063,
0.36649543046951294,
-0.05929264798760414,
-0.4519236087799072,
0.43835073709487915,
0.14529651403427124,
1.0284733772277832,
0.3359486162662506,
-0.7372078895568848,
0.6552053093910217,
-0.08418136090040207,
-0.30704745650291443,
0.1403466761112213,
0.1256796270608902,
-0.1663394421339035,
-0.1744713932275772,
0.562944233417511,
0.3292030692100525,
0.11567169427871704,
-0.6055178642272949,
0.20629329979419708,
0.4089582562446594,
-0.29200440645217896,
-0.550010085105896,
0.517970085144043,
0.5791921019554138,
-0.45930376648902893,
-0.1806524097919464,
-0.031227469444274902,
0.3866589367389679,
0.057357244193553925,
0.9537218809127808,
1.2169733047485352,
-0.4251742362976074,
0.23683370649814606,
-0.07348828762769699,
0.02078351564705372,
0.1657334566116333,
0.3678014874458313,
-0.07755254954099655,
-0.46857690811157227,
-0.4494820237159729,
-0.5438159704208374,
-0.5891094207763672,
0.0017460930394008756,
-0.5066733956336975,
0.44196176528930664,
-0.2976759672164917,
-0.049229223281145096,
-0.12428119033575058,
-0.5112762451171875,
-0.06685445457696915,
0.48692166805267334,
0.07723405212163925,
0.7496731877326965,
-0.836481511592865,
0.8571078181266785,
0.2621733844280243,
0.002262291731312871,
-0.40973639488220215,
0.40250280499458313,
-0.0674697756767273,
-0.7098202705383301,
-0.18499065935611725,
-0.09954365342855453,
-0.37547266483306885,
0.0710543841123581,
-0.23793071508407593,
-0.6109771132469177,
1.1194051504135132,
0.8510797023773193,
-0.40382298827171326,
-0.07167665660381317,
0.20140330493450165,
0.27371537685394287,
-0.16556966304779053,
0.4253329336643219,
0.2756228744983673,
-0.01899358257651329,
0.7095664143562317,
-0.8735204935073853,
-0.19687527418136597,
-0.040775783360004425,
0.203517347574234,
-0.0406530499458313,
-0.5937199592590332,
0.7257174253463745,
0.2859766185283661,
0.053733550012111664,
0.2796303927898407,
0.8425647616386414,
0.2795329988002777,
0.3910478949546814,
0.5287265181541443,
0.5681186318397522,
0.33594727516174316,
0.25967565178871155,
0.49854689836502075,
-0.28117823600769043,
0.22740015387535095,
1.160321831703186,
-0.3724552094936371,
1.083195447921753,
0.6748717427253723,
-0.16748130321502686,
0.26101183891296387,
-0.2345888316631317,
0.3990010917186737,
0.7380958199501038,
-0.3032063841819763,
-0.6683188676834106,
-0.08415811508893967,
-0.26061397790908813,
-0.5276600122451782,
0.5986405611038208,
0.11601676791906357,
0.05077502876520157,
-0.4274003207683563,
0.037818312644958496,
-0.3749333918094635,
-0.16606320440769196,
-0.1242358610033989,
0.7422603368759155,
-0.09909068793058395,
-0.18284691870212555,
0.33094024658203125,
0.1166016012430191,
1.0749080181121826,
-0.6746994853019714,
0.11176499724388123,
-0.0061406628228724,
-0.12061469256877899,
0.12455667555332184,
-0.6388940215110779,
0.2677554488182068,
0.2689336836338043,
-0.23842677474021912,
-0.14227640628814697,
0.7517278790473938,
-0.335333913564682,
-0.5578334927558899,
0.1127726212143898,
0.5608990788459778,
-0.26517733931541443,
-0.016288822516798973,
-0.21210305392742157,
-0.11188020557165146,
-0.1529347449541092,
0.060913003981113434,
0.5075514316558838,
0.6333501935005188,
0.46963608264923096,
0.20163775980472565,
0.621442437171936,
0.048297930508852005,
0.17846575379371643,
0.05537248030304909,
0.7135237455368042,
-0.7275444865226746,
-0.6294313073158264,
-0.7716143727302551,
0.6267930865287781,
0.12981534004211426,
-0.3727234899997711,
0.6475608348846436,
0.6284467577934265,
0.13990026712417603,
-0.15889252722263336,
0.9360605478286743,
-0.20336207747459412,
0.5779334902763367,
-0.4802837073802948,
0.46107372641563416,
-0.5765599012374878,
-0.19679297506809235,
-0.5204628705978394,
-0.6587775349617004,
-0.22468946874141693,
0.3131837844848633,
0.34506186842918396,
-0.022154929116368294,
0.3991548418998718,
0.5710365772247314,
-0.03546814247965813,
0.046790510416030884,
0.7531445026397705,
0.15976841747760773,
0.37222856283187866,
0.14845937490463257,
0.2832421064376831,
-0.7281426191329956,
0.8543171882629395,
-0.09577664732933044,
-0.279514342546463,
-0.5030723214149475,
-0.9365954995155334,
-0.5675272345542908,
-0.21375277638435364,
-0.2953328490257263,
-0.07046788185834885,
0.1023598462343216,
0.7299052476882935,
0.8941624164581299,
-0.7450208067893982,
-0.2902642786502838,
-0.13725680112838745,
-0.03890807181596756,
-0.10336504876613617,
-0.2604124844074249,
-0.22402198612689972,
-0.06236351653933525,
-0.6725313663482666,
0.8576827645301819,
0.7403411269187927,
0.3626471757888794,
0.13679030537605286,
0.005265001207590103,
-0.00667200144380331,
0.47463828325271606,
0.6553168296813965,
0.21564564108848572,
-0.5935962200164795,
-0.4551805555820465,
-0.03453105688095093,
0.15900899469852448,
0.2537596821784973,
0.7123008370399475,
-0.8087844252586365,
0.6318049430847168,
0.5806407332420349,
0.555296003818512,
0.5080587267875671,
-0.22286999225616455,
0.5401043891906738,
-1.0409362316131592,
0.6022225618362427,
0.3147619664669037,
0.3891242742538452,
0.09448359161615372,
0.020390035584568977,
-0.08620474487543106,
0.5276062488555908,
-0.31300047039985657,
-0.7276186943054199,
0.03980974107980728,
-1.5675636529922485,
-0.09692882746458054,
1.2137465476989746,
0.19365985691547394,
-0.19321061670780182,
0.17441613972187042,
-0.43640801310539246,
0.48425695300102234,
-0.8298001885414124,
0.5763790011405945,
0.21258655190467834,
0.004632539115846157,
-0.17772774398326874,
-0.33118119835853577,
-0.3521761894226074,
0.3319025933742523,
-0.8153553009033203,
-0.1605944186449051,
0.4063430726528168,
0.510820209980011,
0.16494855284690857,
0.8254770040512085,
0.06558401882648468,
0.1428448110818863,
0.2739311754703522,
-0.027444908395409584,
0.201620414853096,
-0.11880137771368027,
-0.35610875487327576,
0.3325428068637848,
-0.15495119988918304,
-0.6902523636817932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01284v1 | We-Math: Does Your Large Multimodal Model Achieve Human-like Mathematical Reasoning? | 2024-07-01T13:39:08 | 2024-07-01T13:39:08 | Runqi Qiao, Qiuna Tan, Guanting Dong, Minhui Wu, Chong Sun, Xiaoshuai Song, Zhuoma GongQue, Shanglin Lei, Zhe Wei, Miaoxuan Zhang, Runfeng Qiao, Yifan Zhang, Xiao Zong, Yida Xu, Muxi Diao, Zhimin Bao, Chen Li, Honggang Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SC | Visual mathematical reasoning, as a fundamental visual reasoning ability, has
received widespread attention from the Large Multimodal Models (LMMs)
community. Existing benchmarks, such as MathVista and MathVerse, focus more on
the result-oriented performance but neglect the underlying principles in
knowledge acquisition and generalization. Inspired by human-like mathematical
reasoning, we introduce WE-MATH, the first benchmark specifically designed to
explore the problem-solving principles beyond end-to-end performance. We
meticulously collect and categorize 6.5K visual math problems, spanning 67
hierarchical knowledge concepts and five layers of knowledge granularity. We
decompose composite problems into sub-problems according to the required
knowledge concepts and introduce a novel four-dimensional metric, namely
Insufficient Knowledge (IK), Inadequate Generalization (IG), Complete Mastery
(CM), and Rote Memorization (RM), to hierarchically assess inherent issues in
LMMs' reasoning process. With WE-MATH, we conduct a thorough evaluation of
existing LMMs in visual mathematical reasoning and reveal a negative
correlation between solving steps and problem-specific performance. We confirm
the IK issue of LMMs can be effectively improved via knowledge augmentation
strategies. More notably, the primary challenge of GPT-4o has significantly
transitioned from IK to IG, establishing it as the first LMM advancing towards
the knowledge generalization stage. In contrast, other LMMs exhibit a marked
inclination towards Rote Memorization - they correctly solve composite problems
involving multiple knowledge concepts yet fail to answer sub-problems. We
anticipate that WE-MATH will open new pathways for advancements in visual
mathematical reasoning for LMMs. The WE-MATH data and evaluation code are
available at https://github.com/We-Math/We-Math. | [
-0.5810903906822205,
-0.7469570636749268,
0.529761791229248,
-0.029650606215000153,
-0.2458779215812683,
0.22269989550113678,
-0.02118525095283985,
-0.26538074016571045,
-0.3843424320220947,
0.30879324674606323,
-0.6539660096168518,
-0.5870381593704224,
-0.4025501608848572,
-0.0303239393979311,
0.06084366515278816,
0.4157457649707794,
0.09992548078298569,
0.30198177695274353,
-0.9343120455741882,
-0.17116300761699677,
-0.36699622869491577,
-0.49073201417922974,
-0.2110704928636551,
-0.45463281869888306,
0.6793369054794312,
0.45969751477241516,
0.6241405606269836,
0.3225659728050232,
0.9936016798019409,
0.3209308981895447,
0.08244450390338898,
0.203989639878273,
-0.39165225625038147,
-0.08883947879076004,
-0.38693392276763916,
-0.6120502948760986,
-0.32424864172935486,
0.014252997003495693,
0.2447037547826767,
1.0463576316833496,
-0.15583880245685577,
0.2547916769981384,
-0.4094197154045105,
0.9317119717597961,
-0.7056350111961365,
0.3531443774700165,
-0.520608127117157,
0.1872967779636383,
-0.17481832206249237,
-0.09414507448673248,
-0.15870530903339386,
-0.36230599880218506,
0.2833860516548157,
-1.0099189281463623,
0.21324968338012695,
-0.03281975910067558,
0.7400153875350952,
0.5121716260910034,
-0.5817408561706543,
0.03722519427537918,
-0.4461539685726166,
0.7836065292358398,
-0.0861605852842331,
0.6242185235023499,
0.4616703987121582,
0.779462456703186,
-0.020774448290467262,
-0.6906052827835083,
-0.3577597737312317,
-0.15685224533081055,
0.42478567361831665,
0.32732290029525757,
-0.29413294792175293,
-0.20542950928211212,
0.7184890508651733,
0.2108398675918579,
-0.6364985704421997,
-0.3080047070980072,
-0.7036464214324951,
-0.364273339509964,
0.6809239387512207,
0.2475959211587906,
0.3927565813064575,
0.14727769792079926,
-0.38509058952331543,
-0.2502709925174713,
-0.5269358158111572,
0.14029629528522491,
0.05216309055685997,
-0.29673999547958374,
0.0455152727663517,
0.5893900394439697,
-0.13517294824123383,
0.39127540588378906,
-0.46609100699424744,
-0.15173755586147308,
0.1957676112651825,
-0.2752586603164673,
-0.020497256889939308,
-0.4980851709842682,
0.5012494921684265,
0.5036100149154663,
0.7181124091148376,
-0.09658090025186539,
-0.1769828200340271,
0.8132337331771851,
0.27858227491378784,
-0.7102195620536804,
-0.21650302410125732,
-0.4124598205089569,
-0.16664893925189972,
0.1497279852628708,
-0.131307452917099,
-0.5709487795829773,
-0.3491283655166626,
-0.6781695485115051,
0.8073498010635376,
-0.6975170969963074,
-0.19317413866519928,
0.3142475485801697,
-0.34458354115486145,
-0.07723274827003479,
0.558259129524231,
-0.6311323046684265,
0.5034880638122559,
0.9289576411247253,
0.40559011697769165,
-0.04439612105488777,
-0.3614169657230377,
-0.2157084345817566,
-0.07676231861114502,
-0.5044682025909424,
0.8565416932106018,
-0.3510464131832123,
-0.21404506266117096,
-0.20735879242420197,
-0.6075646281242371,
0.026026561856269836,
-0.7851883769035339,
0.48941606283187866,
-0.5165086388587952,
0.15970714390277863,
-0.6204442977905273,
-0.46484723687171936,
-0.30290672183036804,
0.515766978263855,
-0.4178830087184906,
0.700924813747406,
0.0864979699254036,
-0.4817538857460022,
0.48288458585739136,
-0.6789765954017639,
-0.1899644136428833,
0.02560851350426674,
-0.29272928833961487,
-0.4020138680934906,
0.2830406725406647,
0.4135153889656067,
0.09925594180822372,
-0.6921934485435486,
0.2996465861797333,
-0.4241994023323059,
-0.4484274685382843,
0.30036136507987976,
-0.5209413170814514,
0.5918829441070557,
0.2754434049129486,
0.009992465376853943,
-0.03841451182961464,
-0.7493412494659424,
0.0643228143453598,
0.272806853055954,
0.2751205265522003,
-0.22777681052684784,
-0.2975647747516632,
-0.33519282937049866,
0.37093961238861084,
0.3732222318649292,
-0.25563162565231323,
0.2703600525856018,
0.2017975002527237,
0.46396732330322266,
0.8006049394607544,
-0.14588429033756256,
0.4764343798160553,
-0.23445284366607666,
0.5681228041648865,
0.2732197642326355,
0.33127421140670776,
-0.4398361146450043,
-0.7102729082107544,
-0.56354820728302,
-0.3594159781932831,
0.045620132237672806,
0.569446861743927,
-0.7886524200439453,
-0.08516228199005127,
-0.4115017354488373,
-0.2343941479921341,
0.15624533593654633,
0.14784230291843414,
0.5270034670829773,
0.5602686405181885,
0.3473074734210968,
-0.38287344574928284,
-0.35480138659477234,
-1.0588157176971436,
-0.33843034505844116,
-0.0031187376007437706,
-0.041374243795871735,
0.22057528793811798,
0.6314440965652466,
-0.30448096990585327,
0.8816717267036438,
-0.6778564453125,
-0.3889209032058716,
0.06429358571767807,
0.2825193703174591,
0.048383694142103195,
0.06830266118049622,
0.34051239490509033,
-0.7631158828735352,
-0.4800602197647095,
-0.0038562475237995386,
-1.15065336227417,
-0.09256476908922195,
0.2297549992799759,
-0.32281121611595154,
-0.08785513043403625,
0.36518391966819763,
-0.5258000493049622,
0.6185683012008667,
0.1706891506910324,
-0.5133026242256165,
0.26020532846450806,
-0.21776853501796722,
-0.00008851622260408476,
-0.6133071780204773,
-0.21109330654144287,
0.278227835893631,
-0.06967700272798538,
-0.07102388143539429,
0.14654169976711273,
0.07228684425354004,
-0.35804691910743713,
0.06669154018163681,
0.4715835750102997,
-0.36361849308013916,
-0.5281546115875244,
0.35093221068382263,
0.05913730710744858,
0.17438024282455444,
0.8606866598129272,
-0.18138083815574646,
0.7526810765266418,
0.6250189542770386,
-0.2692546248435974,
0.4877707362174988,
-0.04356050118803978,
-0.24876496195793152,
1.0957868099212646,
-0.5251003503799438,
0.06088490039110184,
-0.28101271390914917,
0.12114278972148895,
-0.9223920702934265,
-0.10335379838943481,
-0.034283947199583054,
-0.45285043120384216,
0.09701509773731232,
0.05524783581495285,
-0.4490436911582947,
-0.5147414803504944,
-0.119137704372406,
0.5954123139381409,
0.6707290410995483,
-0.34217166900634766,
0.7433337569236755,
0.14727918803691864,
-0.011450015008449554,
-0.4198916554450989,
-0.37311479449272156,
0.17242518067359924,
-0.02929837629199028,
-1.0636274814605713,
0.09398738294839859,
-0.3158873915672302,
-0.5737641453742981,
-0.0105827571824193,
-0.32403042912483215,
-0.5949631333351135,
-0.21032686531543732,
0.021389128640294075,
0.3774140775203705,
-0.2734753489494324,
0.1009947881102562,
-0.16123133897781372,
-0.3885435163974762,
0.1991753876209259,
-0.2143665850162506,
0.289492666721344,
-0.40183553099632263,
-0.5974678993225098,
-0.6038463115692139,
0.3379865288734436,
0.8846275806427002,
-0.32394352555274963,
0.1507655829191208,
0.5961830019950867,
-0.4851863980293274,
0.19855472445487976,
-0.6681669354438782,
-0.19770750403404236,
-0.3426944315433502,
0.4749129116535187,
-0.6364675164222717,
-0.5062561631202698,
0.4024337828159332,
-0.2750541865825653,
0.013847941532731056,
0.3611137270927429,
0.18137580156326294,
-0.1879906952381134,
1.2038017511367798,
0.3427513539791107,
0.33451181650161743,
0.29359331727027893,
-0.5362088084220886,
-0.2018919587135315,
-0.4918794631958008,
-0.4066097140312195,
-0.05630386248230934,
-0.4387050271034241,
0.053024496883153915,
-0.6642401218414307,
0.7741270661354065,
0.416265070438385,
-0.35721907019615173,
0.10633225739002228,
-0.2893245220184326,
0.5332390666007996,
0.4950283169746399,
0.17244163155555725,
0.44208452105522156,
0.11187877506017685,
-0.39539623260498047,
-0.5099276900291443,
-0.5152618288993835,
0.08707229793071747,
1.1617786884307861,
0.28134065866470337,
0.6394575238227844,
0.1653004139661789,
0.5271904468536377,
0.1732231229543686,
0.5068444013595581,
-0.6823111772537231,
0.6146877408027649,
-0.061846282333135605,
-0.5815050601959229,
-0.2275027334690094,
-0.8420150876045227,
-0.6245250701904297,
0.46693989634513855,
-0.03459800034761429,
-0.47523099184036255,
-0.2935505211353302,
0.13241605460643768,
-0.042171962559223175,
0.014902129769325256,
-0.9948897957801819,
1.0209054946899414,
-0.41295209527015686,
-0.5939052700996399,
-0.47411787509918213,
-0.4746338427066803,
0.5816030502319336,
0.16254501044750214,
0.44115352630615234,
-0.13704125583171844,
-0.16726872324943542,
0.3041040599346161,
-0.5637887716293335,
0.7164974808692932,
-0.11848263442516327,
-0.02040930651128292,
0.37480318546295166,
0.031515926122665405,
0.21266691386699677,
0.1478155553340912,
0.4128895103931427,
0.4560709595680237,
-0.10444153845310211,
-0.5067638754844666,
-1.0945838689804077,
0.3017444610595703,
-0.7409693002700806,
-0.4469379782676697,
-0.4652213752269745,
-0.7931241989135742,
-0.36318033933639526,
0.05998702347278595,
0.1466885656118393,
0.7861469388008118,
0.10674747824668884,
0.057961512356996536,
0.8021339178085327,
0.04050838202238083,
0.2209712415933609,
0.18880172073841095,
-0.5323153138160706,
-0.7826292514801025,
1.1148416996002197,
0.05853964760899544,
0.21342597901821136,
0.5259394645690918,
0.4794076979160309,
-0.500324010848999,
-0.13086466491222382,
-0.6456262469291687,
0.21048954129219055,
-0.8378596305847168,
-0.1776517629623413,
-0.345519095659256,
-0.17076583206653595,
-0.04475826025009155,
-0.03945796191692352,
-0.4528128504753113,
-0.6195092797279358,
0.05790805444121361,
0.36629611253738403,
0.2179996520280838,
0.5215573310852051,
-0.15066295862197876,
-0.26054269075393677,
-0.7731143832206726,
0.7501500844955444,
0.8607015609741211,
0.3864009976387024,
-0.3072539269924164,
-0.36853429675102234,
0.036764051765203476,
0.06940757483243942,
-0.5524824261665344,
-0.23882734775543213,
-0.03382790461182594,
0.19674773514270782,
0.5010001063346863,
0.5266870260238647,
-0.3797007203102112,
0.9290523529052734,
-0.5452306866645813,
0.43114086985588074,
0.7156671285629272,
-0.9044663310050964,
0.17384718358516693,
-0.44668298959732056,
0.4418060779571533,
0.2539484202861786,
0.1729971021413803,
-0.2601305842399597,
0.40311458706855774,
-0.4681355059146881,
-0.24310588836669922,
0.31505244970321655,
0.3292880058288574,
-0.04245355352759361,
0.11225429177284241,
0.28480812907218933,
0.04519733786582947,
0.15445378422737122,
-0.48284152150154114,
-0.12142591923475266,
-0.2635287642478943,
-0.010048899799585342,
0.0650252103805542,
-0.06231739744544029,
-0.15163251757621765,
-0.7092681527137756,
0.10392031818628311,
-0.19776877760887146,
0.06730352342128754,
-0.0959138423204422,
-0.22547590732574463,
-0.29306602478027344,
0.1581478863954544,
0.8586742281913757,
1.2818334102630615,
-0.016368478536605835,
0.08537314087152481,
0.15316015481948853,
-0.48724377155303955,
-0.15067751705646515,
0.060698553919792175,
0.08115774393081665,
-0.43260830640792847,
0.5424807071685791,
0.4790090322494507,
0.4986999034881592,
-0.8339328169822693,
0.6406928896903992,
-0.2120630443096161,
-0.3509102165699005,
-0.28503379225730896,
-0.03545524924993515,
0.1045946255326271,
0.25297531485557556,
0.5480886101722717,
0.4291917085647583,
-0.010541192255914211,
-0.8071708679199219,
0.2549813985824585,
0.5230158567428589,
-0.1832902729511261,
-0.4668321907520294,
0.6975570321083069,
0.10430144518613815,
-0.21662122011184692,
0.4753575623035431,
-0.19127564132213593,
-0.7992605566978455,
0.5969497561454773,
0.3667532801628113,
0.4521508812904358,
-0.013905752450227737,
0.128554567694664,
0.5863116383552551,
0.1109347864985466,
-0.1526598334312439,
0.48220738768577576,
-0.3903898000717163,
-0.6820312142372131,
-0.4551115930080414,
-0.2874842882156372,
-0.3509279489517212,
-0.38814300298690796,
-0.7562065124511719,
0.2075546234846115,
-0.6559455990791321,
-0.12496334314346313,
-0.14880357682704926,
-0.08320307731628418,
-0.7994126081466675,
0.2815549671649933,
0.24779213964939117,
0.7232939600944519,
-0.46101483702659607,
0.36489468812942505,
0.6582735180854797,
-0.5762160420417786,
-0.1918719857931137,
-0.4717784523963928,
0.02704126015305519,
-0.9961844682693481,
0.9058876633644104,
0.1230192631483078,
-0.032505378127098083,
-0.13334538042545319,
-0.6905258893966675,
-0.7488629221916199,
1.2471541166305542,
0.4197901487350464,
-0.7072095274925232,
-0.08992114663124084,
0.21178211271762848,
0.526357114315033,
0.06553854793310165,
0.2748548686504364,
0.24026432633399963,
0.3588378429412842,
0.6906442642211914,
-0.9324131011962891,
-0.4200432002544403,
-0.34421399235725403,
0.1470525562763214,
0.35226455330848694,
-0.5755585432052612,
1.1938164234161377,
-0.5070979595184326,
0.023748906329274178,
-0.05610063299536705,
0.4925500750541687,
0.3459513783454895,
0.7986902594566345,
0.49718958139419556,
1.2508785724639893,
0.5532210469245911,
-0.15671612322330475,
0.9587361812591553,
0.15181608498096466,
0.2389739751815796,
0.5306306481361389,
-0.22396041452884674,
0.5238696336746216,
0.37467092275619507,
-0.632324755191803,
0.47023746371269226,
0.2194429636001587,
0.2914673388004303,
0.4629259407520294,
0.4474931061267853,
-0.12749913334846497,
-0.8651560544967651,
-0.06161867082118988,
-0.6078495979309082,
0.43147602677345276,
0.569593071937561,
0.1316731721162796,
-0.441298246383667,
-0.16950632631778717,
-0.42682313919067383,
0.3892117738723755,
-0.41687050461769104,
0.44256243109703064,
0.30311882495880127,
-0.621186375617981,
0.5371482372283936,
-0.34105050563812256,
0.369250625371933,
-0.5533442497253418,
-0.494913250207901,
-0.25985726714134216,
0.30126363039016724,
0.06536871194839478,
-0.5255502462387085,
0.049219243228435516,
-0.28213199973106384,
-0.26534390449523926,
-0.18593908846378326,
0.383106529712677,
-0.1597283035516739,
-0.7746487259864807,
0.009743448346853256,
0.6208310723304749,
0.07764327526092529,
-0.3154022991657257,
-0.5741689205169678,
0.17270615696907043,
-0.21105709671974182,
0.19461797177791595,
0.4180556833744049,
0.779468297958374,
-0.48612821102142334,
0.9082853198051453,
0.9387675523757935,
-0.45521050691604614,
0.2027597576379776,
0.37252384424209595,
0.9062981605529785,
-0.7443638443946838,
-0.3500484228134155,
-0.7025195956230164,
0.5236809253692627,
-0.08518080413341522,
-0.47832927107810974,
0.4444150924682617,
0.617484450340271,
0.654437243938446,
-0.009273550473153591,
0.6013255715370178,
0.44975194334983826,
0.286883682012558,
-0.38544273376464844,
0.4350656569004059,
-0.8502499461174011,
0.21639208495616913,
-0.4813463091850281,
-1.0678120851516724,
-0.5838320255279541,
0.6834980249404907,
-0.34164372086524963,
0.0571269690990448,
0.7073346972465515,
0.26394060254096985,
-0.1695176512002945,
0.04161398485302925,
0.7777912616729736,
-0.08810374140739441,
0.1765340268611908,
0.9143770337104797,
1.135393738746643,
-0.38036462664604187,
0.7870184183120728,
-0.44604209065437317,
-0.34659990668296814,
0.006032711360603571,
-0.6517478823661804,
-1.1638838052749634,
-0.48119649291038513,
-0.3136551082134247,
-0.04565339535474777,
-0.0689946785569191,
0.7810855507850647,
0.5441554188728333,
-0.2746850550174713,
-0.006442267447710037,
-0.29094046354293823,
0.139540895819664,
-0.2924821972846985,
-0.17788231372833252,
0.05958066135644913,
-0.15834453701972961,
-0.48189833760261536,
0.06687556207180023,
0.4945392608642578,
-0.2310740053653717,
-0.44812631607055664,
-0.026231877505779266,
0.18545472621917725,
-0.20816370844841003,
0.7524921894073486,
0.22524845600128174,
-0.8203833699226379,
-0.017013486474752426,
0.37070372700691223,
-0.152401402592659,
0.10635001957416534,
1.004583716392517,
-0.7403517365455627,
0.5638839602470398,
0.364422470331192,
0.6390770673751831,
0.5930596590042114,
-0.04631834849715233,
0.4661220908164978,
-0.2506365180015564,
0.1558658480644226,
0.21032017469406128,
0.5356601476669312,
0.25014975666999817,
0.04677082225680351,
0.6694749593734741,
0.729180097579956,
-0.2437628209590912,
-0.6092594861984253,
0.4045090973377228,
-0.8970046639442444,
0.07565344125032425,
0.7423602342605591,
-0.09683852642774582,
-0.15798303484916687,
0.03149686008691788,
-0.16284412145614624,
-0.17900675535202026,
-0.2751229703426361,
0.8717198371887207,
0.6497753262519836,
-0.2736702263355255,
-0.4275711476802826,
-0.46078935265541077,
-0.021963801234960556,
0.35698333382606506,
-0.9439764022827148,
-0.4234794080257416,
0.7607153654098511,
0.3191642463207245,
0.36397576332092285,
0.4348006248474121,
-0.20125190913677216,
0.76829993724823,
0.3773704171180725,
0.025288261473178864,
-0.37464073300361633,
-0.4715237319469452,
0.1576714962720871,
0.08633415400981903,
-0.28275877237319946,
-0.05803297832608223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01274v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01274v2 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Actionable Course Evaluation Student Feedback to Lecturers | 2024-07-01T13:29:55 | 2024-07-02T08:47:45 | Mike Zhang, Euan D Lindsay, Frederik Bode Thorbensen, Danny Bøgsted Poulsen, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | End of semester student evaluations of teaching are the dominant mechanism
for providing feedback to academics on their teaching practice. For large
classes, however, the volume of feedback makes these tools impractical for this
purpose. This paper explores the use of open-source generative AI to synthesise
factual, actionable and appropriate summaries of student feedback from these
survey responses. In our setup, we have 742 student responses ranging over 75
courses in a Computer Science department. For each course, we synthesise a
summary of the course evaluations and actionable items for the instructor. Our
results reveal a promising avenue for enhancing teaching practices in the
classroom setting. Our contribution lies in demonstrating the feasibility of
using generative AI to produce insightful feedback for teachers, thus providing
a cost-effective means to support educators' development. Overall, our work
highlights the possibility of using generative AI to produce factual,
actionable, and appropriate feedback for teachers in the classroom setting. | [
-0.27837055921554565,
-0.817089855670929,
0.5069037079811096,
0.10608647763729095,
0.021447043865919113,
0.07796838879585266,
-0.6414286494255066,
0.012451707385480404,
0.07188825309276581,
0.12070989608764648,
-0.048367876559495926,
-0.49055007100105286,
0.0034700767137110233,
-0.043777745217084885,
-0.8944935202598572,
1.307244062423706,
0.14351379871368408,
0.3860553801059723,
-0.36927056312561035,
-0.17060524225234985,
-0.33300378918647766,
-0.4555979371070862,
-0.694390594959259,
-0.18891221284866333,
0.3572676479816437,
0.5610676407814026,
0.6851444244384766,
-0.03622625395655632,
0.4256041944026947,
0.3581436276435852,
0.152654767036438,
-0.08207550644874573,
-0.27259108424186707,
-0.10039854049682617,
-0.20872505009174347,
-0.48587507009506226,
-0.31417399644851685,
0.10286781936883926,
0.9117980003356934,
0.9647042751312256,
-0.3834141492843628,
0.17338739335536957,
0.2657645642757416,
0.44691789150238037,
-0.6123573184013367,
0.1311066746711731,
-0.12194451689720154,
0.3081071376800537,
0.10595235228538513,
0.06460322439670563,
-0.8637762665748596,
-0.6636593341827393,
0.14445514976978302,
-0.4418655037879944,
0.3150515556335449,
-0.6229161024093628,
0.35888803005218506,
0.14227287471294403,
0.19412478804588318,
-0.4258599281311035,
-1.113420844078064,
0.5949796438217163,
-0.7909688949584961,
0.22036954760551453,
0.11464487761259079,
0.5380786657333374,
0.10555019974708557,
-0.6278207898139954,
-0.688184916973114,
-0.47368499636650085,
-0.0669407993555069,
0.5670351982116699,
0.029436739161610603,
-0.07702238857746124,
0.15379442274570465,
0.642921507358551,
-0.19806094467639923,
0.10066965222358704,
-0.6088044047355652,
0.1533690243959427,
0.6551640033721924,
0.3642312288284302,
0.408672571182251,
0.13264669477939606,
0.004771022591739893,
-0.1771509200334549,
-0.5426208972930908,
-0.016390400007367134,
0.5394983887672424,
0.2359338402748108,
-0.14844731986522675,
0.8137943148612976,
0.10126882046461105,
0.7964416146278381,
-0.41253039240837097,
0.13272325694561005,
-0.26290786266326904,
-0.18816140294075012,
-0.12956687808036804,
-0.07459400594234467,
0.7751056551933289,
0.348273366689682,
-0.14953093230724335,
-0.25468942523002625,
-0.13398733735084534,
0.37616854906082153,
0.42194637656211853,
-0.8223429918289185,
-0.5355573296546936,
0.2756372094154358,
-0.2280966192483902,
-0.5414513945579529,
0.2242044359445572,
-1.0425680875778198,
-0.32452669739723206,
-0.5337527394294739,
0.18976864218711853,
-0.3621780574321747,
-0.341001957654953,
-0.27088645100593567,
-0.049349233508110046,
0.15671154856681824,
0.8403399586677551,
-0.776379406452179,
0.1911485195159912,
0.4466157555580139,
0.8963125944137573,
-0.18145805597305298,
-0.4478231370449066,
-0.49785253405570984,
0.1306532472372055,
-0.5459529757499695,
0.48365119099617004,
-0.7175673246383667,
-0.5362864136695862,
0.18690165877342224,
-0.43494364619255066,
0.2812359631061554,
-0.4999168813228607,
0.08455860614776611,
-0.3675749599933624,
0.5441693067550659,
0.2534816861152649,
-0.6513881087303162,
0.04296603798866272,
0.34666624665260315,
-0.7323412299156189,
0.9132848978042603,
0.4284461438655853,
-0.49972960352897644,
0.09718047827482224,
-0.9051724076271057,
-0.4165419042110443,
0.4286521375179291,
-0.3426097631454468,
-0.33388185501098633,
0.1290169209241867,
0.16146613657474518,
0.36064502596855164,
-0.11464162915945053,
0.3264447748661041,
-0.013053824193775654,
-0.38191768527030945,
0.4826623201370239,
-0.46965640783309937,
0.6112966537475586,
0.25652527809143066,
-0.539458155632019,
0.4629366993904114,
-0.626122772693634,
0.0922817662358284,
-0.11992548406124115,
-0.7308905720710754,
-0.10606686770915985,
-0.032326098531484604,
0.14635799825191498,
-0.3051722049713135,
-0.21206964552402496,
-0.2671363353729248,
0.37382811307907104,
-0.2917120158672333,
0.5633583068847656,
0.7517591714859009,
-0.2811291515827179,
0.35412803292274475,
-0.11119517683982849,
0.8461052179336548,
-0.27980512380599976,
0.08611851185560226,
-0.35734203457832336,
-0.12492869794368744,
-0.9479942917823792,
-0.3446129858493805,
0.42435187101364136,
0.052446477115154266,
-0.8953429460525513,
0.17394821345806122,
-0.2894280254840851,
-0.7019138336181641,
-0.6513763070106506,
0.049588195979595184,
0.25378912687301636,
0.22616076469421387,
0.1487441509962082,
-0.46173688769340515,
-0.35593950748443604,
-0.150575190782547,
-0.11510565876960754,
-0.46070390939712524,
-0.3060462772846222,
0.05489147827029228,
0.3624172806739807,
-0.06572649627923965,
1.0468202829360962,
-0.7983200550079346,
-0.10661541670560837,
-0.2815282642841339,
0.07353631407022476,
-0.07046980410814285,
0.38594841957092285,
0.4306167662143707,
-0.4222683608531952,
-0.29116496443748474,
-0.11744260787963867,
-0.8015086650848389,
0.2718677818775177,
-0.34557557106018066,
-0.15718171000480652,
0.23916450142860413,
0.47065186500549316,
-0.531694769859314,
0.3446755111217499,
0.21876214444637299,
-0.09697874635457993,
0.799014151096344,
-0.07844843715429306,
0.027732426300644875,
-0.8507530093193054,
0.21834047138690948,
-0.18258768320083618,
-0.1203228011727333,
-0.18395137786865234,
0.39675039052963257,
-0.2264953851699829,
-0.6588799357414246,
-0.30804717540740967,
0.26628240942955017,
-0.1541793942451477,
-0.10105765610933304,
-0.16738806664943695,
0.19071395695209503,
-0.2774199843406677,
0.3225702941417694,
0.0794784277677536,
0.9547584056854248,
0.40157827734947205,
-0.5237175226211548,
0.5775468349456787,
0.3042222857475281,
-0.7480682730674744,
0.5654182434082031,
-0.627163827419281,
0.02018142119050026,
0.08997929096221924,
0.577097475528717,
-0.6743887662887573,
-0.44539400935173035,
0.01834903657436371,
-0.6257995963096619,
-0.061979878693819046,
-0.2509106397628784,
-0.3237871527671814,
-0.42515069246292114,
-0.39547625184059143,
0.1445770114660263,
0.49947473406791687,
-0.7288774847984314,
0.5425988435745239,
0.17819704115390778,
-0.31670263409614563,
-0.21521931886672974,
-0.5068748593330383,
0.32804393768310547,
0.1707133948802948,
-0.1282844990491867,
-0.12974363565444946,
-0.2863785922527313,
-0.3532327711582184,
0.10265665501356125,
0.35722142457962036,
0.08650929480791092,
0.1734553724527359,
0.22586001455783844,
0.47768738865852356,
-0.17160503566265106,
0.16287407279014587,
-0.11265652626752853,
0.22103756666183472,
0.36391890048980713,
-0.3638967275619507,
0.47783172130584717,
-0.24315576255321503,
-0.6777076125144958,
-0.32555291056632996,
0.3653210401535034,
0.8976213335990906,
-0.26320722699165344,
0.5094910264015198,
0.5244885683059692,
-0.2045087367296219,
-0.5122210383415222,
-0.21223711967468262,
-0.440283864736557,
-0.42275241017341614,
0.3915524184703827,
0.18209655582904816,
-0.8405985236167908,
0.020648125559091568,
-0.09905844181776047,
0.44798973202705383,
0.1011538952589035,
0.6981044411659241,
0.12340198457241058,
0.9445183277130127,
0.40336358547210693,
-0.0048660519532859325,
0.6333802342414856,
-0.7445697784423828,
0.48252102732658386,
-0.6616262793540955,
-0.36915549635887146,
-0.5161188244819641,
0.05274398252367973,
-0.25956058502197266,
-0.3406895399093628,
0.533053994178772,
-0.04157049208879471,
-0.05390814319252968,
-0.07112588733434677,
-0.6216331124305725,
0.4547331631183624,
0.7685360908508301,
0.16161303222179413,
-0.0657363012433052,
0.08712436258792877,
0.1041610985994339,
0.1953498125076294,
-0.5262823700904846,
-0.66232830286026,
1.1135081052780151,
0.09697137773036957,
0.7576155662536621,
0.5045056343078613,
0.4286692440509796,
0.384818971157074,
0.8850004076957703,
-1.006298303604126,
0.751991868019104,
-0.03606107458472252,
-0.24119888246059418,
-0.6063060760498047,
-0.4831472933292389,
-0.5715655088424683,
0.2600996196269989,
-0.1476936936378479,
-0.19005867838859558,
-0.5927861928939819,
0.1295129954814911,
-0.2125260978937149,
0.4797917604446411,
-0.8193053603172302,
0.6775976419448853,
-0.010798178613185883,
-0.483237087726593,
-0.426390141248703,
-0.34598931670188904,
0.04008631408214569,
0.14121942222118378,
0.21222355961799622,
0.4232467710971832,
0.5621079206466675,
0.805972158908844,
-0.9441803693771362,
0.9531549215316772,
-0.30857571959495544,
-0.31362301111221313,
0.7179837822914124,
-0.024895979091525078,
0.009584130719304085,
0.1775207221508026,
-0.12789437174797058,
-0.15398718416690826,
-0.3583078384399414,
-0.4004873037338257,
-0.8230391144752502,
0.6365167498588562,
-0.9155341982841492,
-0.8280615210533142,
-0.2137734591960907,
-0.4020092189311981,
-0.21423561871051788,
0.03286903724074364,
0.024657247588038445,
0.6609072685241699,
-0.3002496659755707,
-0.05039381980895996,
0.2857688367366791,
-0.12763504683971405,
0.5468326807022095,
0.5629535913467407,
-0.2968849837779999,
-0.5366210341453552,
1.2415359020233154,
0.0868648961186409,
0.08714863657951355,
0.23649071156978607,
0.37096595764160156,
-0.1333085298538208,
-0.33069539070129395,
-1.013136386871338,
0.00644815806299448,
-0.8641595244407654,
-0.17803779244422913,
-0.34618330001831055,
-0.20465442538261414,
-0.6033251881599426,
-0.513107419013977,
-0.04548352584242821,
-0.573247492313385,
-0.2355782389640808,
-0.36162635684013367,
0.13308671116828918,
0.9780632853507996,
0.09571991115808487,
0.23648959398269653,
-0.656256914138794,
-0.2452082484960556,
0.7193448543548584,
0.3455985188484192,
0.5634666085243225,
-0.2296803593635559,
-0.38866540789604187,
0.09500632435083389,
-0.5905027389526367,
-0.5914883017539978,
0.15673516690731049,
0.20131932199001312,
0.1570579707622528,
0.5515468120574951,
0.11477521806955338,
0.3279638886451721,
-0.4096011221408844,
1.3612709045410156,
0.4371643364429474,
-1.1720668077468872,
0.8913418054580688,
-0.1965474784374237,
0.3363933563232422,
0.2197774052619934,
0.33928313851356506,
-0.2601955831050873,
-0.850023627281189,
-0.3738253116607666,
-0.9058041572570801,
0.776524543762207,
0.11634496599435806,
0.624399721622467,
0.028604790568351746,
0.2046310305595398,
0.14089801907539368,
0.32609695196151733,
-0.6355835795402527,
-0.08144590258598328,
-0.5416616797447205,
-0.37111568450927734,
-0.01236573327332735,
-0.23230916261672974,
-0.4731699824333191,
-0.3815242648124695,
0.6353666186332703,
-0.3076953589916229,
0.16091179847717285,
-0.057812418788671494,
0.10826347768306732,
0.06980594247579575,
0.6255075931549072,
0.633580207824707,
1.0928220748901367,
0.07874271273612976,
0.28659433126449585,
0.1485789716243744,
-0.6334995031356812,
0.09103218466043472,
-0.11246650665998459,
-0.30428358912467957,
0.24912911653518677,
0.45636069774627686,
0.45303720235824585,
0.06510501354932785,
-0.9548014402389526,
0.6308569312095642,
-0.12763835489749908,
0.09746120125055313,
-0.6379597783088684,
0.22495436668395996,
-0.17837263643741608,
-0.057562679052352905,
0.2138003259897232,
-0.19638919830322266,
0.19455568492412567,
-0.729938805103302,
-0.12026749551296234,
0.20796482264995575,
-0.5141600370407104,
-0.48400524258613586,
0.6168782711029053,
0.5414184927940369,
-0.24416597187519073,
0.9108130931854248,
0.17504046857357025,
-0.5321817398071289,
0.5344715118408203,
0.7189626097679138,
0.8220093846321106,
-0.3629452586174011,
0.677635133266449,
0.4481202960014343,
-0.09873425215482712,
0.0812426209449768,
0.19360952079296112,
-0.31871479749679565,
-0.28339865803718567,
-0.43688827753067017,
-0.4657424986362457,
-0.9311646223068237,
-0.015940632671117783,
-0.9257152080535889,
0.441965252161026,
-0.6222233772277832,
0.016278808936476707,
0.34307193756103516,
-0.4203694462776184,
-0.21735286712646484,
0.3969701826572418,
-0.23996292054653168,
0.4232420325279236,
-0.8487837910652161,
0.4766506552696228,
1.4236842393875122,
-0.7830251455307007,
-0.924747109413147,
-0.054300881922245026,
-0.35931408405303955,
-0.3476617932319641,
0.4221324324607849,
0.08914685249328613,
-0.019077498465776443,
-0.20154336094856262,
-0.7478539347648621,
-0.14802658557891846,
0.7138081192970276,
0.3982424736022949,
-0.4703431725502014,
0.01752309873700142,
0.16588060557842255,
0.9103732705116272,
-0.01897692307829857,
0.648495614528656,
0.09490466862916946,
0.1761169582605362,
0.15373484790325165,
-0.4433315694332123,
-0.04444697126746178,
-0.3670280873775482,
-0.08895022422075272,
0.2727135121822357,
-0.6642143130302429,
0.578589916229248,
-0.37509071826934814,
-0.08935534209012985,
-0.028641676530241966,
0.8567482233047485,
-0.06360209733247757,
0.40678122639656067,
0.3548848330974579,
0.7862922549247742,
0.6627892255783081,
0.01662083901464939,
1.043298602104187,
-0.23478522896766663,
0.35487210750579834,
1.0389888286590576,
-0.046090975403785706,
0.9617749452590942,
0.2882903516292572,
-0.6162099838256836,
0.6869136691093445,
0.1888885647058487,
-0.16579607129096985,
0.17743320763111115,
0.49711132049560547,
-0.8174760341644287,
-0.15827372670173645,
-0.2096276879310608,
-0.40284401178359985,
0.4891490340232849,
0.45134758949279785,
-0.16538411378860474,
0.022512542083859444,
0.32704490423202515,
0.16725437343120575,
0.21663972735404968,
-0.495945006608963,
0.9077985882759094,
-0.2653142511844635,
-1.053663969039917,
0.3630296289920807,
0.03852017596364021,
0.2826024889945984,
-0.31384655833244324,
-0.41811320185661316,
-0.19710323214530945,
0.15193165838718414,
-0.4685855805873871,
-0.8435492515563965,
0.19607704877853394,
0.3735998570919037,
-0.21348486840724945,
-0.05595563352108002,
-0.04504196718335152,
-0.5694224834442139,
-0.5035185813903809,
-0.3143799304962158,
-0.032546862959861755,
0.09050089120864868,
0.3390447199344635,
0.053247932344675064,
0.06083225458860397,
0.03729156032204628,
0.33914119005203247,
0.08578095585107803,
0.17284642159938812,
-0.11286656558513641,
0.528802752494812,
0.6949751973152161,
0.15358635783195496,
-0.24095018208026886,
0.4320858120918274,
1.059648871421814,
-0.35286465287208557,
-0.4584576487541199,
-0.6157222986221313,
0.46423351764678955,
-0.010643990710377693,
-0.29399359226226807,
0.739589512348175,
0.6432414054870605,
1.2675186395645142,
-0.25793272256851196,
1.2962234020233154,
-0.21611064672470093,
0.2960330843925476,
-0.45660606026649475,
0.7132532000541687,
-0.16504031419754028,
0.4080078601837158,
-0.30736446380615234,
-0.7805008292198181,
-0.05168454721570015,
0.5326070785522461,
-0.1064368411898613,
0.028279442340135574,
0.43189090490341187,
0.3169577419757843,
0.09136746823787689,
0.4661608040332794,
0.23895329236984253,
0.12659528851509094,
0.6094656586647034,
0.12723101675510406,
1.1569106578826904,
-0.19261592626571655,
0.48758718371391296,
-0.15371906757354736,
-0.38817521929740906,
-0.32776302099227905,
-0.3948851525783539,
-0.9860056042671204,
-0.495295912027359,
-0.8110665678977966,
-0.543549656867981,
0.007230684161186218,
0.6738587617874146,
0.4942648708820343,
-0.9687073826789856,
-0.3128323256969452,
-0.2352428287267685,
0.04524052515625954,
-0.11593355983495712,
-0.38041430711746216,
0.6299586892127991,
-0.4253429174423218,
-0.8482120633125305,
0.19062985479831696,
0.007710027042776346,
0.11579763889312744,
-0.6506285667419434,
-0.0028963456861674786,
0.32935115694999695,
-0.04044948145747185,
0.9207156896591187,
0.0847056433558464,
-0.7280967831611633,
-0.23413196206092834,
-0.26255175471305847,
0.13372112810611725,
-0.31012967228889465,
1.1639083623886108,
-0.7183756828308105,
0.5885055065155029,
0.2611524164676666,
0.8009002804756165,
0.19714057445526123,
-0.14888902008533478,
0.6236491799354553,
-0.8139176368713379,
0.017965326085686684,
0.5001134872436523,
0.13887640833854675,
0.5545889735221863,
-0.1781318485736847,
0.636452317237854,
0.0997011736035347,
-0.38570067286491394,
-0.9174944162368774,
-0.1417105346918106,
-0.6540611386299133,
-0.32011595368385315,
0.9107269048690796,
-0.6310485601425171,
0.13038955628871918,
0.25308680534362793,
-0.3227944076061249,
0.18263907730579376,
-0.09691605716943741,
1.1547284126281738,
0.6941980123519897,
0.017187798395752907,
-0.003109874902293086,
-0.19227378070354462,
0.2272050380706787,
0.4751841723918915,
-1.1462684869766235,
-0.08331269025802612,
0.7899455428123474,
0.0005513237556442618,
0.26198601722717285,
0.4487617015838623,
-0.15335310995578766,
0.4380216896533966,
-0.013081958517432213,
0.08813377469778061,
0.09249546378850937,
-0.41055384278297424,
-0.2419346570968628,
0.29086941480636597,
0.3439081311225891,
-0.10540882498025894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01272v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01272v2 | Show Less, Instruct More: Enriching Prompts with Definitions and Guidelines for Zero-Shot NER | 2024-07-01T13:25:33 | 2024-07-02T07:55:24 | Andrew Zamai, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Ernandes, Marco Maggini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, several specialized instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs)
for Named Entity Recognition (NER) have emerged. Compared to traditional NER
approaches, these models have strong generalization capabilities. Existing LLMs
mainly focus on zero-shot NER in out-of-domain distributions, being fine-tuned
on an extensive number of entity classes that often highly or completely
overlap with test sets. In this work instead, we propose SLIMER, an approach
designed to tackle never-seen-before named entity tags by instructing the model
on fewer examples, and by leveraging a prompt enriched with definition and
guidelines. Experiments demonstrate that definition and guidelines yield better
performance, faster and more robust learning, particularly when labelling
unseen Named Entities. Furthermore, SLIMER performs comparably to
state-of-the-art approaches in out-of-domain zero-shot NER, while being trained
on a reduced tag set. | [
-0.5870624780654907,
-0.4012897312641144,
0.6335069537162781,
-0.41513338685035706,
-0.28902339935302734,
-0.020713813602924347,
-0.21821264922618866,
-0.25350862741470337,
0.38249701261520386,
0.5363806486129761,
-0.6346362233161926,
-0.3905259370803833,
-0.6005187630653381,
0.2646406292915344,
-0.2240295261144638,
1.2340784072875977,
0.021802814677357674,
-0.015335889533162117,
-0.10142537951469421,
0.08079905807971954,
-0.5223222374916077,
-0.05910997837781906,
-0.6914638876914978,
-0.28533872961997986,
0.5772638320922852,
0.5679391622543335,
0.2369450330734253,
0.7548156976699829,
0.33779942989349365,
0.1730438768863678,
-0.16254788637161255,
0.05130460858345032,
-0.42817142605781555,
0.179413840174675,
-0.17903603613376617,
-0.3422124683856964,
-0.20954330265522003,
-0.10541059821844101,
0.6633670926094055,
0.7830262184143066,
0.012750011868774891,
0.15429449081420898,
-0.0015179896727204323,
0.08239160478115082,
-0.7988551259040833,
0.11650563776493073,
-0.7861503958702087,
-0.09367333352565765,
-0.15228033065795898,
-0.13861492276191711,
-0.5672621130943298,
-0.04669882357120514,
0.2245982438325882,
-0.7322330474853516,
0.3415994644165039,
-0.02949339523911476,
1.0951594114303589,
0.390897274017334,
-0.36015215516090393,
-0.13427887856960297,
-0.7099941968917847,
0.7766974568367004,
-0.45619434118270874,
0.5269795060157776,
0.007544469088315964,
0.23393139243125916,
-0.22992996871471405,
-0.6093403697013855,
-0.7846417427062988,
-0.06943309307098389,
-0.03190361335873604,
-0.05693746358156204,
-0.4713093936443329,
0.11856672912836075,
0.5485660433769226,
0.030566642060875893,
-0.444559782743454,
0.22022783756256104,
-0.30766597390174866,
-0.32032591104507446,
0.26559728384017944,
0.21507087349891663,
0.1394660323858261,
-0.1327323615550995,
-0.3744555711746216,
0.010730797424912453,
-0.7859671115875244,
-0.22426138818264008,
0.11707059293985367,
0.22794805467128754,
0.041156064718961716,
0.615615963935852,
-0.2999834418296814,
0.7427822351455688,
0.5271400809288025,
-0.304594486951828,
0.1769488900899887,
0.11331714689731598,
-0.3988083004951477,
0.1944326013326645,
0.6235656142234802,
0.4057047665119171,
0.2530764937400818,
-0.22241950035095215,
-0.3206420838832855,
-0.0399777889251709,
-0.14807839691638947,
-1.3295701742172241,
-0.6146966814994812,
-0.19231005012989044,
-0.09010600298643112,
0.15058892965316772,
-0.21534965932369232,
-0.7931838035583496,
-0.6103984713554382,
-0.3300113081932068,
0.41745567321777344,
-0.5327171683311462,
0.18339918553829193,
0.025641461834311485,
-0.38435468077659607,
0.7129796743392944,
0.5452440977096558,
-0.588338315486908,
0.35242733359336853,
0.5773746967315674,
0.6092094779014587,
0.14844462275505066,
0.15592430531978607,
-0.840776801109314,
0.29915034770965576,
-0.2616884708404541,
0.9494814276695251,
-0.9262334704399109,
-0.30681735277175903,
-0.3367765545845032,
0.1910921037197113,
0.08809098601341248,
-0.4002287685871124,
0.39218780398368835,
-0.4561683237552643,
0.3300822377204895,
-0.16586437821388245,
-1.072964072227478,
-0.24642881751060486,
0.1818980723619461,
-0.4459143579006195,
0.5095717310905457,
0.06059877574443817,
-0.6510360240936279,
0.8235719799995422,
-0.4942547380924225,
-0.40581023693084717,
0.6187841296195984,
-0.34164294600486755,
-0.18540368974208832,
0.29168444871902466,
0.28530412912368774,
0.5494430661201477,
-0.046836234629154205,
-0.008589325472712517,
-0.11162776499986649,
-0.4400223195552826,
-0.14085905253887177,
-0.3195509612560272,
0.4233036935329437,
-0.06224190071225166,
-0.16374471783638,
-0.05464225634932518,
-0.9903827905654907,
0.2679734528064728,
0.1481083631515503,
-0.23697614669799805,
-0.5725488662719727,
-0.273342102766037,
-0.07344657927751541,
-0.056922830641269684,
-0.07723599672317505,
-0.6054191589355469,
0.11370814591646194,
-0.7858493328094482,
0.3411145806312561,
0.4621623754501343,
0.3054525852203369,
0.786566972732544,
-0.12327198684215546,
0.5325440168380737,
-0.037713672965765,
-0.21919336915016174,
-0.6616966128349304,
-0.2838684320449829,
-1.1377960443496704,
-0.6467573642730713,
0.5637837052345276,
0.6186686158180237,
-0.8224300146102905,
0.42109212279319763,
-0.3710725009441376,
-0.4387579560279846,
-0.4214417040348053,
0.05576656758785248,
0.3352922797203064,
0.6867037415504456,
0.43605130910873413,
-0.23658150434494019,
-0.6065890192985535,
-0.8345077037811279,
0.04874933511018753,
0.1525026112794876,
-0.14149333536624908,
0.46273526549339294,
0.6727142333984375,
-0.20110397040843964,
0.7956689596176147,
-0.652803897857666,
-0.28599655628204346,
-0.49614396691322327,
-0.25580358505249023,
0.26345598697662354,
0.3774873614311218,
0.3591964542865753,
-0.3548634350299835,
-0.5581824779510498,
-0.21336676180362701,
-0.4099370241165161,
0.1290285885334015,
-0.115025594830513,
-0.0013886407250538468,
-0.12864382565021515,
0.39023250341415405,
-0.7647411227226257,
0.3066239058971405,
-0.09898044168949127,
0.11238785833120346,
0.11721694469451904,
0.013838348910212517,
-0.3555492162704468,
-1.1271456480026245,
-0.25487470626831055,
0.16252870857715607,
-0.34816092252731323,
-0.8107122182846069,
0.0967518612742424,
0.1423872709274292,
-0.2568662464618683,
-0.4463346004486084,
1.0182691812515259,
-0.7932810187339783,
0.2518559992313385,
-0.268480122089386,
0.3151346743106842,
0.23320849239826202,
0.26736682653427124,
0.11467809230089188,
0.7632784843444824,
0.9125548601150513,
-0.9020986557006836,
0.09910447895526886,
0.42515838146209717,
-0.252556711435318,
0.9756907224655151,
-0.8264358043670654,
0.09509505331516266,
-0.6283729672431946,
0.18689225614070892,
-0.5507219433784485,
-0.5148373246192932,
0.420391321182251,
-0.3545576333999634,
0.8881695866584778,
-0.4825321435928345,
-0.27583569288253784,
-0.32859277725219727,
-0.3262295722961426,
0.10483317822217941,
0.6749250888824463,
-0.6897608041763306,
0.5261068344116211,
0.4046378433704376,
0.14135028421878815,
-0.5515618920326233,
-0.5563413500785828,
0.018371785059571266,
-0.3327970504760742,
0.05672382563352585,
0.22390681505203247,
-0.1705903559923172,
-0.023110810667276382,
-0.16591043770313263,
-0.3935452997684479,
-0.3295064866542816,
0.2157474011182785,
0.450442910194397,
0.23535721004009247,
-0.3084685802459717,
0.39575523138046265,
-0.013642972335219383,
-0.1660950481891632,
-0.20366069674491882,
-0.4334638714790344,
0.46769124269485474,
0.07143602520227432,
-0.17607919871807098,
-0.618679940700531,
0.18022705614566803,
-0.13368003070354462,
-0.35799676179885864,
0.7589133977890015,
0.49138033390045166,
-0.5928718447685242,
-0.4392124116420746,
-0.4113311171531677,
-0.29440632462501526,
-0.46056243777275085,
0.18058748543262482,
-0.3751184046268463,
-1.0460014343261719,
0.10069063305854797,
-0.14526012539863586,
-0.03156263753771782,
0.18441452085971832,
0.27111107110977173,
0.04178526997566223,
0.6998679637908936,
1.1379132270812988,
0.0983719453215599,
0.545508086681366,
-0.10297726094722748,
0.4262751042842865,
-0.8836638331413269,
-0.2909487783908844,
-0.3276580274105072,
-0.2612355351448059,
-0.5316861271858215,
-0.5165526866912842,
0.12755455076694489,
0.22837738692760468,
-0.2903593182563782,
0.606329083442688,
-0.7149908542633057,
1.0536097288131714,
0.32081201672554016,
0.030643101781606674,
0.04801885411143303,
-0.08003297448158264,
-0.17098574340343475,
-0.10087531805038452,
-0.4769582450389862,
-0.5377010703086853,
0.8580982089042664,
0.10492748767137527,
0.8152269721031189,
-0.06787551194429398,
1.2166271209716797,
-0.06656967848539352,
0.4261731207370758,
-1.1950730085372925,
0.643393874168396,
0.028733273968100548,
-0.5976766347885132,
-0.0751955583691597,
-0.45644059777259827,
-0.9328471422195435,
-0.0026366300880908966,
-0.015512995421886444,
-0.9215092062950134,
0.2936607599258423,
0.20998303592205048,
-0.6929916739463806,
0.27428820729255676,
-0.6560150384902954,
0.6075354814529419,
0.07428822666406631,
0.1373302936553955,
0.4271746873855591,
-0.39006635546684265,
0.3631970286369324,
-0.1916850358247757,
-0.1205122172832489,
-0.21940597891807556,
-0.4543960988521576,
0.550174355506897,
-0.22498711943626404,
0.6578380465507507,
-0.1674850434064865,
-0.004671031143516302,
0.19849897921085358,
0.12159740179777145,
0.56731116771698,
0.08678130060434341,
0.048715781420469284,
-0.09051649272441864,
-0.3311902582645416,
-0.17348572611808777,
-0.4506179690361023,
0.7785711884498596,
-0.33601534366607666,
-0.553798258304596,
-0.21722470223903656,
-0.3388059139251709,
-0.0759848952293396,
0.5955482721328735,
0.32825303077697754,
0.5497698783874512,
-0.23753392696380615,
-0.07471494376659393,
1.116208791732788,
-0.283506840467453,
0.3638766407966614,
0.7761743664741516,
-0.010187461040914059,
-0.4257979691028595,
0.8757146596908569,
0.06329131871461868,
-0.12175802141427994,
0.7450787425041199,
-0.20094537734985352,
-0.21379990875720978,
-0.5309186577796936,
-0.5203148722648621,
0.36581212282180786,
-0.8338359594345093,
-0.5817312002182007,
-0.9815375208854675,
-0.1754918098449707,
-0.2243315726518631,
-0.13085579872131348,
-0.0020071978215128183,
-0.41306790709495544,
-0.6384215950965881,
-0.09820917993783951,
0.524955689907074,
0.5266565084457397,
0.06179547309875488,
0.7237209677696228,
-0.5210214257240295,
0.21318183839321136,
0.018196163699030876,
0.4259409010410309,
-0.1241438090801239,
-0.7003045082092285,
0.0860765129327774,
-0.19586578011512756,
-0.0571720190346241,
-0.9649689793586731,
0.33457109332084656,
0.645828366279602,
0.5907947421073914,
0.5055409073829651,
0.17553773522377014,
0.8848686218261719,
-0.9787351489067078,
0.4417343735694885,
0.3209262192249298,
-0.8971263766288757,
0.7037814259529114,
-0.09279006719589233,
0.183516725897789,
0.46997663378715515,
0.6309201121330261,
-0.312224805355072,
-0.05734831467270851,
-0.5781630277633667,
-0.7317891120910645,
0.49934884905815125,
-0.27892038226127625,
0.6296369433403015,
-0.45444464683532715,
0.4985431730747223,
0.067655548453331,
0.2880643904209137,
-0.5265575051307678,
-0.4585832357406616,
0.11803847551345825,
-0.11717024445533752,
0.029386572539806366,
-0.11217580735683441,
0.19032806158065796,
-0.1534571349620819,
0.7431123852729797,
-0.2732815742492676,
0.05749335139989853,
0.11285325139760971,
-0.423825740814209,
-0.06298529356718063,
0.6571608781814575,
0.18416160345077515,
0.2703973054885864,
0.05825253948569298,
0.1760011464357376,
0.4580458998680115,
-0.17195357382297516,
0.13565321266651154,
0.2604958117008209,
-0.6772156953811646,
0.19974641501903534,
0.19472673535346985,
1.0056982040405273,
0.4570346474647522,
-0.6670659780502319,
0.5502464175224304,
0.01260653231292963,
-0.0600704625248909,
-0.2571471631526947,
0.42512205243110657,
-0.18828649818897247,
0.218305766582489,
-0.06407879292964935,
0.08242712169885635,
0.1845589578151703,
-0.22558020055294037,
0.436305433511734,
0.6900075674057007,
-0.6879600882530212,
-0.22975678741931915,
0.7109816074371338,
-0.034455668181180954,
-0.06950921565294266,
0.4821039140224457,
-0.7795674204826355,
-0.3534449636936188,
0.2735897898674011,
0.5003569722175598,
0.6400535106658936,
0.03256655111908913,
0.3939351439476013,
0.4229973256587982,
0.38494405150413513,
0.02629353292286396,
0.2522324025630951,
-0.22783829271793365,
-0.6257594227790833,
-0.3680826425552368,
-0.6680649518966675,
-0.3811781406402588,
0.4081585705280304,
-0.6033394932746887,
0.550322413444519,
-0.8757089376449585,
-0.1303163468837738,
0.6140913963317871,
0.09567327797412872,
-0.9013676643371582,
0.02179870381951332,
0.43200716376304626,
0.9302154779434204,
-0.4405752718448639,
0.5271069407463074,
0.9423530697822571,
-0.6136078238487244,
-0.9766722321510315,
0.13971303403377533,
0.06122804433107376,
-0.7229184508323669,
0.6153519749641418,
0.42714571952819824,
0.12093767523765564,
0.3921530544757843,
-0.6816313862800598,
-0.956229031085968,
0.9454910755157471,
0.47008588910102844,
-0.7146181464195251,
-0.09636353701353073,
-0.4103897511959076,
0.3519016206264496,
-0.2486659288406372,
0.679589033126831,
0.3564366102218628,
0.3964379131793976,
0.3799161911010742,
-0.7364140152931213,
0.03339307755231857,
0.06167343258857727,
-0.1303456872701645,
0.6009804606437683,
-0.35486748814582825,
0.6927477717399597,
-0.7647485733032227,
-0.7032577991485596,
0.30410078167915344,
0.7332890033721924,
-0.028104357421398163,
0.2887978255748749,
0.15949594974517822,
0.5868862271308899,
0.9777379035949707,
0.03813139349222183,
0.8298922181129456,
-0.06507410109043121,
0.26681724190711975,
1.4610886573791504,
-0.7108286023139954,
0.7361154556274414,
0.19153350591659546,
0.10844771564006805,
0.4685836434364319,
0.4140819311141968,
-0.5735462307929993,
0.4318822920322418,
0.44259220361709595,
-0.19139979779720306,
-0.4999447166919708,
-0.7341792583465576,
-0.1438223272562027,
0.38576409220695496,
0.3212205171585083,
-0.2381158471107483,
-0.67403644323349,
0.031331904232501984,
0.4551544785499573,
-0.06720661371946335,
-0.5920265913009644,
0.8777250051498413,
0.1085699275135994,
-0.2536911964416504,
0.5022481679916382,
-0.028369151055812836,
0.7994905710220337,
-0.386444091796875,
-0.23613034188747406,
-0.110140860080719,
0.2616969645023346,
-0.08037447184324265,
-0.6908271908760071,
-0.0644947737455368,
0.3048759698867798,
-0.35638663172721863,
0.03531791269779205,
1.0728689432144165,
-0.3330617845058441,
-0.5141449570655823,
0.13813287019729614,
0.7966082692146301,
0.5169939994812012,
0.05000710487365723,
-0.3844887614250183,
-0.4723905324935913,
-0.17168942093849182,
0.03383646160364151,
0.25919437408447266,
0.6831132173538208,
0.0340382345020771,
0.6577800512313843,
0.490592896938324,
-0.00954772625118494,
0.14913082122802734,
0.21276235580444336,
0.9094482660293579,
-0.6849464774131775,
-0.20278123021125793,
-0.8147701025009155,
0.2101769894361496,
-0.10864690691232681,
-0.0736207664012909,
0.8736649751663208,
0.5785487294197083,
1.0700743198394775,
-0.09000436216592789,
0.570948600769043,
-0.06968918442726135,
0.504084587097168,
-0.1555183231830597,
0.4846397936344147,
-0.5238217711448669,
0.15952064096927643,
-0.05529895797371864,
-0.8861172795295715,
-0.3848746120929718,
0.48937955498695374,
-0.15942618250846863,
0.085935078561306,
0.27988362312316895,
0.7787697315216064,
-0.08926407992839813,
-0.2815217971801758,
0.5904432535171509,
0.11900702863931656,
0.04166224226355553,
0.6161674857139587,
0.9709331393241882,
-0.3481779992580414,
0.4808078408241272,
-0.22018298506736755,
0.03949464112520218,
0.051816873252391815,
-0.9442687034606934,
-1.2476816177368164,
-0.06912115961313248,
-0.5137885808944702,
0.03677111491560936,
0.07568106800317764,
1.072965383529663,
0.8219780325889587,
-0.9481831192970276,
0.4987287223339081,
0.10913686454296112,
0.30717483162879944,
0.19081585109233856,
-0.18767134845256805,
-0.0867558941245079,
-0.21595269441604614,
-0.6370789408683777,
0.5222024917602539,
0.29121890664100647,
0.2218632698059082,
0.10556101053953171,
0.09541590511798859,
0.2122677117586136,
0.28402262926101685,
0.30113548040390015,
0.32230281829833984,
-0.6246851086616516,
-0.26354366540908813,
0.14762794971466064,
0.16578567028045654,
0.004056313540786505,
0.5643979907035828,
-1.1276897192001343,
0.15784910321235657,
0.2281166911125183,
0.5455138087272644,
0.09428073465824127,
-0.2106250375509262,
0.03254864737391472,
-1.0637121200561523,
-0.08554468303918839,
0.24803027510643005,
0.49205654859542847,
0.46535998582839966,
-0.39317750930786133,
0.2534700930118561,
0.16574300825595856,
-0.25772377848625183,
-0.8680213689804077,
0.37027639150619507,
-0.8635227680206299,
0.1279183179140091,
1.0331565141677856,
-0.17781586945056915,
-0.19695012271404266,
0.004993582610040903,
0.025051696226000786,
0.2141069769859314,
-0.6703948974609375,
0.10761412233114243,
0.19832603633403778,
-0.054925624281167984,
-0.5419722199440002,
-0.5213711857795715,
0.2913985848426819,
-0.044939957559108734,
-0.8034442067146301,
-0.1467267870903015,
0.6242713928222656,
0.737646222114563,
0.1348881870508194,
0.39499443769454956,
0.2835174798965454,
0.021714700385928154,
-0.10321316123008728,
0.042611707001924515,
-0.1135643795132637,
-0.5407116413116455,
-0.5163594484329224,
-0.0880255326628685,
0.06114903837442398,
-0.11271964758634567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01271v1 | First Place Solution of 2023 Global Artificial Intelligence Technology Innovation Competition Track 1 | 2024-07-01T13:22:22 | 2024-07-01T13:22:22 | Xiangyu Wu, Hailiang Zhang, Yang Yang, Jianfeng Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present our champion solution to the Global Artificial
Intelligence Technology Innovation Competition Track 1: Medical Imaging
Diagnosis Report Generation. We select CPT-BASE as our base model for the text
generation task. During the pre-training stage, we delete the mask language
modeling task of CPT-BASE and instead reconstruct the vocabulary, adopting a
span mask strategy and gradually increasing the number of masking ratios to
perform the denoising auto-encoder pre-training task. In the fine-tuning stage,
we design iterative retrieval augmentation and noise-aware similarity bucket
prompt strategies. The retrieval augmentation constructs a mini-knowledge base,
enriching the input information of the model, while the similarity bucket
further perceives the noise information within the mini-knowledge base, guiding
the model to generate higher-quality diagnostic reports based on the similarity
prompts. Surprisingly, our single model has achieved a score of 2.321 on
leaderboard A, and the multiple model fusion scores are 2.362 and 2.320 on the
A and B leaderboards respectively, securing first place in the rankings. | [
-0.5533017516136169,
-0.5435329079627991,
0.725036084651947,
0.10891988128423691,
-0.7222920656204224,
0.02432910166680813,
0.17807535827159882,
-0.8974084854125977,
0.06090596318244934,
0.3358979821205139,
-0.5811061859130859,
-0.6467450857162476,
-0.771936297416687,
0.13986165821552277,
-0.514569103717804,
0.9397006034851074,
0.11231116950511932,
0.124064140021801,
-0.3348049223423004,
-0.0820428729057312,
-0.6964393258094788,
-0.3042549192905426,
-0.8746836185455322,
-0.2231982797384262,
0.18624557554721832,
0.2344631850719452,
0.6972601413726807,
0.8828154802322388,
0.8897172808647156,
0.31168434023857117,
0.03622177615761757,
0.1227470263838768,
0.07007166743278503,
-0.17621614038944244,
-0.059788916260004044,
-0.17037495970726013,
-0.5933828353881836,
-0.06845199316740036,
0.4194634258747101,
0.47251126170158386,
-0.008251732215285301,
0.01948276348412037,
0.0010981468949466944,
0.5744562745094299,
-0.16275633871555328,
0.19130611419677734,
-0.5586177110671997,
-0.11499269306659698,
0.011518742889165878,
-0.3345377445220947,
-0.19930842518806458,
-0.2674725353717804,
0.1281002163887024,
-0.7478191256523132,
0.4153037369251251,
0.23326388001441956,
1.0891166925430298,
0.609648585319519,
-0.0911647230386734,
-0.34915751218795776,
-0.5557300448417664,
0.6199941039085388,
-0.5492371916770935,
-0.09039316326379776,
0.12951552867889404,
0.36125579476356506,
0.20434042811393738,
-0.8786725401878357,
-0.4754297137260437,
-0.14398397505283356,
0.027827298268675804,
0.13062401115894318,
-0.41875624656677246,
-0.0024187786038964987,
-0.19689804315567017,
0.26770299673080444,
-0.7352585792541504,
0.1969461888074875,
-0.47787266969680786,
-0.2420119047164917,
0.8896377682685852,
0.3617723286151886,
0.09784780442714691,
0.06583703309297562,
-0.38977476954460144,
-0.0234663225710392,
-0.5178244709968567,
-0.240036278963089,
-0.19586819410324097,
0.14620573818683624,
0.1330213099718094,
0.1770390123128891,
-0.2720685303211212,
0.6738407611846924,
0.21120145916938782,
-0.32303738594055176,
0.4936603307723999,
-0.40066057443618774,
-0.13154785335063934,
0.31624501943588257,
0.81085604429245,
0.2962215840816498,
-0.13102349638938904,
0.047063183039426804,
-0.31473085284233093,
0.13030380010604858,
0.45764076709747314,
-0.5645251274108887,
-0.29516544938087463,
0.29365286231040955,
-0.7852765321731567,
-0.508258044719696,
-0.10091511160135269,
-0.5354146361351013,
-0.5134029388427734,
-0.2799382507801056,
0.8431492447853088,
-0.41557931900024414,
-0.30295002460479736,
0.34306076169013977,
0.17389142513275146,
0.08516261726617813,
0.3901934027671814,
-0.6692029237747192,
0.18512193858623505,
0.6029844880104065,
0.6937955021858215,
-0.1684204638004303,
-0.03253975883126259,
-0.213775172829628,
-0.1960117220878601,
-0.275076687335968,
1.2286852598190308,
-0.2679402530193329,
-0.5908123850822449,
-0.3464435040950775,
-0.20810654759407043,
-0.09471805393695831,
-0.9825628399848938,
0.5125613212585449,
-0.38866421580314636,
0.28069981932640076,
-0.06125445291399956,
-0.3981384336948395,
-0.18472649157047272,
0.34683188796043396,
-0.6527507305145264,
0.8257237672805786,
0.3147064745426178,
-0.7143554091453552,
0.5149556994438171,
-0.9200000166893005,
-0.3473851978778839,
0.5745333433151245,
-0.2713834047317505,
-0.7475807666778564,
-0.10854584723711014,
0.46479612588882446,
0.2670931816101074,
-0.3376336395740509,
0.4675058126449585,
0.22701333463191986,
-0.42261356115341187,
-0.40115416049957275,
-0.026171864941716194,
0.6726904511451721,
0.16598767042160034,
-0.43269601464271545,
0.1880117505788803,
-0.8181893229484558,
0.05270032212138176,
0.485885888338089,
-0.19596420228481293,
-0.048889096826314926,
-0.1469431221485138,
-0.23988765478134155,
0.22971318662166595,
0.168971985578537,
-0.8623427748680115,
0.34034180641174316,
-0.4281785488128662,
0.18257325887680054,
0.603800356388092,
0.2943236529827118,
0.0630921721458435,
-0.8129088282585144,
0.5737165212631226,
0.2584438920021057,
0.4468773603439331,
-0.17554160952568054,
-0.9621307849884033,
-0.564700186252594,
-0.4245026707649231,
0.32937461137771606,
0.7618728876113892,
-0.6173396110534668,
0.2928963899612427,
-0.3187793791294098,
-0.5178459882736206,
-0.8719256520271301,
-0.11654561758041382,
0.34764474630355835,
0.8711525797843933,
0.43229034543037415,
-0.38232624530792236,
-0.790988028049469,
-1.2384432554244995,
0.040093302726745605,
-0.15587761998176575,
-0.03395611792802811,
0.15048715472221375,
0.5096986889839172,
-0.18860086798667908,
0.6255793571472168,
-0.4571039080619812,
-0.7431305050849915,
-0.29647940397262573,
0.2641751766204834,
0.36773523688316345,
0.6731097102165222,
0.6041536331176758,
-0.9367720484733582,
-0.4223715662956238,
-0.007515463978052139,
-0.7399702072143555,
0.09562643617391586,
0.08132624626159668,
0.08857323229312897,
0.3565153181552887,
0.4978216290473938,
-0.3583706021308899,
0.6474818587303162,
0.20943449437618256,
-0.2851122319698334,
0.5884242653846741,
-0.2316325306892395,
0.5719392895698547,
-1.1738353967666626,
0.1775309294462204,
-0.11405061930418015,
-0.14350630342960358,
-0.296627402305603,
-0.08350544422864914,
-0.1930907666683197,
-0.05691716820001602,
-0.3420867919921875,
0.6582883596420288,
-0.150368332862854,
0.25656256079673767,
-0.31626343727111816,
-0.025481685996055603,
0.04162440821528435,
0.2667718529701233,
0.01925092563033104,
0.6177273392677307,
0.6275989413261414,
-0.7073906064033508,
0.32257115840911865,
0.36004555225372314,
-0.46190327405929565,
0.26625242829322815,
-0.5893769264221191,
0.18494820594787598,
-0.13660086691379547,
-0.05613892525434494,
-1.106592059135437,
-0.006636104546487331,
0.08476055413484573,
-0.6050248146057129,
0.3472326993942261,
0.2703429162502289,
-0.6173622608184814,
-0.7010566592216492,
-0.04214094951748848,
0.5413993000984192,
0.7304854393005371,
-0.46393388509750366,
0.3430907726287842,
0.43183204531669617,
-0.4107413589954376,
-0.2436564415693283,
-0.5118796825408936,
0.0512222982943058,
-0.04210006445646286,
-0.8570195436477661,
0.7109788656234741,
-0.277654767036438,
-0.1697738766670227,
0.11084821075201035,
0.10852896422147751,
-0.16820093989372253,
0.05020373314619064,
0.07015467435121536,
0.48811593651771545,
-0.4464082717895508,
0.012031925842165947,
-0.041536521166563034,
-0.4162188172340393,
-0.050827257335186005,
-0.36656853556632996,
0.3914073705673218,
-0.18475815653800964,
-0.3591618835926056,
-0.5330492854118347,
0.5366696119308472,
0.43055492639541626,
-0.06554233282804489,
0.5211227536201477,
0.36123067140579224,
-0.4839613735675812,
0.05952873080968857,
-0.48004987835884094,
-0.06541847437620163,
-0.4903743863105774,
0.5303806662559509,
-0.2597883939743042,
-0.7240915298461914,
0.5349850058555603,
-0.07655468583106995,
0.08844221383333206,
0.692881166934967,
0.6422978043556213,
-0.05968378856778145,
1.6162834167480469,
0.800660252571106,
-0.2317991554737091,
0.23199564218521118,
-0.28480198979377747,
0.4093686640262604,
-0.49278929829597473,
-0.5730438232421875,
-0.6063984036445618,
-0.3242190182209015,
-0.27238255739212036,
-0.002819903427734971,
0.9635414481163025,
-0.103452168405056,
-0.24448227882385254,
-0.0111580491065979,
-1.1385974884033203,
0.4126357436180115,
0.8177891373634338,
0.2888243496417999,
0.46931368112564087,
0.018467025831341743,
-0.23745042085647583,
-0.277352511882782,
-0.8659997582435608,
-0.21764251589775085,
1.0619410276412964,
0.06483348459005356,
0.3125497102737427,
-0.3439328670501709,
0.9363238215446472,
0.39392831921577454,
0.4617097079753876,
-0.6077282428741455,
0.40729832649230957,
-0.3351593315601349,
-0.35364145040512085,
-0.11063256114721298,
0.13424190878868103,
-0.9921314120292664,
-0.08664317429065704,
0.02581690065562725,
-0.5921123623847961,
-0.08422131091356277,
0.15008780360221863,
-0.6065840721130371,
0.26588237285614014,
-0.24677613377571106,
0.6229953765869141,
-0.06785795837640762,
0.004377149976789951,
-0.09122945368289948,
-0.7317205667495728,
0.4840286672115326,
-0.0997830256819725,
0.4391684830188751,
0.34229856729507446,
0.15400011837482452,
0.8929356932640076,
-0.3950622081756592,
0.47979816794395447,
-0.2685799300670624,
0.10494422167539597,
0.42376217246055603,
0.016659541055560112,
0.2261938899755478,
-0.02280827797949314,
-0.13659536838531494,
-0.016206679865717888,
-0.11478836834430695,
-0.23398828506469727,
-0.32189494371414185,
0.34986183047294617,
-0.6109208464622498,
-0.5857571363449097,
-0.22866928577423096,
-0.49669817090034485,
-0.13870008289813995,
0.3654114902019501,
0.7500427961349487,
0.5222516655921936,
0.048232145607471466,
-0.1169448271393776,
0.680972695350647,
-0.13821473717689514,
0.3603733479976654,
0.4807034134864807,
0.07561410963535309,
-0.45989078283309937,
1.1151055097579956,
-0.18456003069877625,
-0.06885969638824463,
0.2846526801586151,
0.1059303730726242,
-0.1768357902765274,
-0.8917045593261719,
-0.5725365281105042,
0.30079740285873413,
-0.6533042788505554,
-0.5841942429542542,
-0.7220355868339539,
-0.5987785458564758,
-0.5827742218971252,
-0.25170251727104187,
-0.5157527923583984,
-0.16079984605312347,
-0.2388986051082611,
0.2195066213607788,
0.04843788594007492,
1.0126454830169678,
-0.2672923803329468,
0.17781594395637512,
-0.9436019062995911,
0.36858803033828735,
0.012755428440868855,
0.2332991361618042,
-0.03181830048561096,
-0.5380372405052185,
-0.44348520040512085,
-0.2217346727848053,
-0.5389515161514282,
-0.3678168058395386,
0.6008538603782654,
0.03632557764649391,
0.7721019387245178,
0.1380361169576645,
-0.04212797060608864,
0.5785185098648071,
-0.2172614336013794,
1.0727039575576782,
0.18831557035446167,
-0.7289617657661438,
1.0014119148254395,
-0.24715125560760498,
0.35915154218673706,
0.5665143728256226,
0.161955788731575,
-0.039562612771987915,
-0.7084225416183472,
-0.8010901212692261,
-0.8811190128326416,
0.5591465830802917,
-0.14016541838645935,
-0.27674612402915955,
-0.049447350203990936,
0.32147330045700073,
0.17880986630916595,
0.15135088562965393,
-0.5536267757415771,
-0.22690516710281372,
-0.15783244371414185,
-0.49450600147247314,
0.36345717310905457,
-0.04386819154024124,
-0.09275370091199875,
-0.49015235900878906,
0.8894349932670593,
-0.13898031413555145,
0.5312083959579468,
0.46036770939826965,
0.22937901318073273,
-0.10589534044265747,
-0.006220735609531403,
0.6079745888710022,
0.5253152251243591,
-0.034705232828855515,
-0.4274624288082123,
-0.26194578409194946,
-0.714465856552124,
-0.0395016223192215,
0.14764247834682465,
-0.1111019030213356,
0.13452157378196716,
0.5916531682014465,
0.557055652141571,
0.012127627618610859,
-0.5619587898254395,
0.5823934078216553,
-0.11981779336929321,
-0.8509860634803772,
-0.0467521958053112,
0.027778614312410355,
-0.17561475932598114,
0.23409953713417053,
0.7166272401809692,
0.31486067175865173,
0.34073352813720703,
-0.17771753668785095,
0.5063396096229553,
0.3823893666267395,
-0.36262044310569763,
-0.06580749899148941,
0.808118999004364,
-0.04564530774950981,
-0.32167190313339233,
0.7352956533432007,
-0.3886733651161194,
-0.8554061651229858,
0.9404399991035461,
0.630521833896637,
0.7299060225486755,
-0.24534311890602112,
0.18550415337085724,
0.747389018535614,
0.19267266988754272,
-0.17042063176631927,
0.48359981179237366,
0.08998464047908783,
-0.5120764970779419,
-0.24041301012039185,
-0.5163242220878601,
-0.18742527067661285,
0.3499089479446411,
-0.5843381285667419,
0.4248039424419403,
-0.33869612216949463,
0.10010170191526413,
0.028212744742631912,
0.24453766644001007,
-0.6553793549537659,
0.5649006366729736,
0.2418750673532486,
0.977822482585907,
-0.5072962641716003,
0.7323199510574341,
0.7072564363479614,
-0.33622533082962036,
-1.022834300994873,
-0.32331058382987976,
0.12213216722011566,
-0.9330428242683411,
0.5810760259628296,
0.16434471309185028,
0.18588562309741974,
0.1620604544878006,
-0.8570346236228943,
-0.8090099096298218,
1.3187767267227173,
0.20773983001708984,
-0.34841543436050415,
-0.16981053352355957,
-0.027728842571377754,
0.4116436839103699,
-0.7444217801094055,
0.013967037200927734,
0.5322285890579224,
0.4277328848838806,
0.3141176700592041,
-1.3484822511672974,
-0.00497024180367589,
-0.5796440243721008,
-0.34403878450393677,
0.0545649379491806,
-0.5113691687583923,
0.9530572295188904,
-0.47235623002052307,
-0.34245526790618896,
0.5339397192001343,
0.18667209148406982,
0.4068721830844879,
0.45199060440063477,
0.3772692382335663,
0.7119606137275696,
0.5934925675392151,
0.0427732840180397,
1.1807587146759033,
-0.37455910444259644,
0.13355740904808044,
0.9556139707565308,
-0.011772084049880505,
0.3903551697731018,
0.11706456542015076,
0.032081276178359985,
0.5595527291297913,
0.7157378792762756,
-0.182709738612175,
0.8457043766975403,
0.006541229784488678,
-0.2155071496963501,
-0.2659685015678406,
-0.2042841911315918,
-0.6867206692695618,
0.5338360071182251,
0.2769092321395874,
-0.5172411203384399,
-0.3939191699028015,
0.40164628624916077,
-0.3690849840641022,
0.042716603726148605,
-0.44971340894699097,
1.1033329963684082,
-0.16156107187271118,
-0.7979326844215393,
0.6894614696502686,
-0.05776580423116684,
0.6801852583885193,
-0.5295168161392212,
-0.2462606430053711,
-0.18781417608261108,
0.32611340284347534,
0.01110418327152729,
-0.6149866580963135,
0.3023073673248291,
-0.3308887481689453,
-0.3492097556591034,
0.030334437265992165,
0.6356261372566223,
-0.17237551510334015,
-0.6447921991348267,
0.10204465687274933,
0.4158352017402649,
0.02336236461997032,
-0.23329046368598938,
-0.7149227261543274,
0.15407167375087738,
0.0060247574001550674,
-0.020894527435302734,
0.35893484950065613,
0.22978702187538147,
-0.06400126218795776,
0.7544733285903931,
0.2390771359205246,
0.15927185118198395,
-0.11039572209119797,
0.11470528692007065,
1.0360065698623657,
-0.4954267740249634,
-0.6478712558746338,
-0.5693926811218262,
0.599205732345581,
-0.030893243849277496,
-0.40530046820640564,
0.16702620685100555,
0.7068449258804321,
0.6468892693519592,
0.0528978630900383,
0.9099331498146057,
-0.08291260898113251,
0.7484769225120544,
-0.28786712884902954,
0.7826099395751953,
-0.7679278254508972,
0.31514158844947815,
-0.20951803028583527,
-0.43113964796066284,
-0.6024542450904846,
0.37612152099609375,
0.09307701140642166,
-0.11843812465667725,
0.7563197612762451,
0.8346340656280518,
0.11337191611528397,
0.18343716859817505,
0.29837751388549805,
0.24457450211048126,
0.31573954224586487,
0.8080955147743225,
0.5266318321228027,
-0.7906020879745483,
0.6453909873962402,
-0.26573431491851807,
-0.3571203947067261,
-0.08859124034643173,
-0.6675487756729126,
-0.35752204060554504,
-0.7846267223358154,
-0.44106462597846985,
-0.39525169134140015,
-0.012506195344030857,
0.48814448714256287,
0.9189918041229248,
-0.8309104442596436,
0.3562719225883484,
-0.11521244794130325,
0.0055252606980502605,
-0.23019324243068695,
-0.24700945615768433,
0.5013128519058228,
-0.25408923625946045,
-0.5965702533721924,
0.2647867202758789,
0.35128849744796753,
-0.04329971969127655,
0.04729040712118149,
0.03820786625146866,
-0.07296770811080933,
-0.3524686098098755,
0.31321772933006287,
0.08315208554267883,
-0.6044650673866272,
-0.45778700709342957,
0.009998617693781853,
-0.18991918861865997,
0.3689320385456085,
0.7598785758018494,
-1.296492576599121,
0.4882827401161194,
0.15461523830890656,
0.670608401298523,
0.14855580031871796,
0.06259199976921082,
0.38269346952438354,
-0.4564206302165985,
0.17353446781635284,
0.6627789735794067,
0.09713956713676453,
0.2312684804201126,
-0.7337432503700256,
0.5015420913696289,
0.4316854178905487,
-0.6761258840560913,
-0.77225261926651,
-0.09374457597732544,
-0.9322928190231323,
-0.3284109830856323,
0.630220890045166,
0.07253330945968628,
-0.14029031991958618,
-0.38419321179389954,
-0.26652809977531433,
0.17381630837917328,
-0.08885063230991364,
1.009617567062378,
0.4304552972316742,
-0.5778643488883972,
-0.18309617042541504,
-0.24809233844280243,
0.5678999423980713,
0.372887521982193,
-0.7381014227867126,
-0.5455942749977112,
0.22508156299591064,
0.373243510723114,
0.42262622714042664,
1.0317376852035522,
-0.6470338106155396,
0.7738505601882935,
0.26689162850379944,
-0.10577770322561264,
-0.42145615816116333,
-0.30578482151031494,
-0.165741428732872,
0.2679065465927124,
-0.03532758355140686,
-0.45218566060066223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01270v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01270v1 | The African Woman is Rhythmic and Soulful: Evaluation of Open-ended Generation for Implicit Biases | 2024-07-01T13:21:33 | 2024-07-01T13:21:33 | Serene Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study investigates the subtle and often concealed biases present in
Large Language Models (LLMs), which, despite passing explicit bias tests, can
still exhibit implicit biases akin to those observed in humans who profess
egalitarian beliefs yet demonstrate underlying prejudices. The challenge of
measuring such biases is exacerbated as LLMs become increasingly proprietary,
restricting access to their internal mechanisms such as embeddings, which are
crucial for applying traditional bias measures. To tackle these issues, this
study introduces innovative measures of bias inspired by psychological
methodologies: the LLM Implicit Association Test (IAT) Bias and the LLM
Decision Bias. The LLM IAT Bias is a prompt-based method designed to unearth
implicit biases by simulating the well-known psychological IAT but adapted for
use with LLMs. The LLM Decision Bias measure is developed to detect subtle
discrimination in decision-making tasks, focusing on how LLMs choose between
individuals in various scenarios. Open-ended generation is also utilised
through thematic analysis of word generations and storytelling. The experiments
revealed biases across gender and racial domains, from discriminatory
categorisations to exoticisation. Our findings indicate that the prompt-based
measure of implicit bias not only correlates with traditional embedding-based
methods but also more effectively predicts downstream behaviors, which are
crucially measured by the LLM Decision Bias. This relationship underscores the
importance of relative, rather than absolute, evaluations in assessing implicit
biases, reflecting psychological insights into human bias assessment. This
research contributes to the broader understanding of AI ethics and provides
suggestions for continually assessing and mitigating biases in advanced AI
systems, emphasising the need for more qualitative and downstream focus. | [
-0.5887717604637146,
-0.8232071995735168,
0.46698200702667236,
0.3176334500312805,
-0.18538419902324677,
0.013280429877340794,
-0.31634870171546936,
-0.595591127872467,
0.08869385719299316,
0.21650846302509308,
-0.7553920745849609,
-0.21481585502624512,
-0.6440730690956116,
0.0009667803533375263,
-0.3963571786880493,
0.9456881284713745,
-0.25195178389549255,
0.35936957597732544,
-0.15615417063236237,
-0.41272681951522827,
-0.624850332736969,
-0.22490836679935455,
-0.6805492043495178,
-0.4745844304561615,
0.3432874381542206,
0.108682781457901,
0.5082150101661682,
0.3145742118358612,
-0.0790444016456604,
0.20880985260009766,
-0.05382208153605461,
0.1286250352859497,
-0.3781959116458893,
0.22725126147270203,
-0.011183231137692928,
-0.4143444001674652,
-0.1010366827249527,
0.4393216073513031,
0.13157805800437927,
0.8779793381690979,
0.1466568410396576,
0.6461482048034668,
0.15161368250846863,
0.7779505848884583,
-0.7625164985656738,
0.00966265331953764,
-0.4182652235031128,
0.1959974765777588,
-0.25083568692207336,
0.1320401281118393,
-0.0416024886071682,
-0.49663427472114563,
0.08248062431812286,
-0.059538234025239944,
0.11692703515291214,
0.18616469204425812,
0.5000092387199402,
0.4373103082180023,
-0.48315709829330444,
-0.643682599067688,
-0.7671123743057251,
0.7547868490219116,
-0.5086687803268433,
0.33740779757499695,
0.18969453871250153,
0.3445543944835663,
0.07357735186815262,
-0.4986109137535095,
-0.775313138961792,
-0.48109495639801025,
0.32305559515953064,
-0.00032050578738562763,
-0.08017850667238235,
-0.0754019021987915,
0.28793954849243164,
0.16089597344398499,
-0.07634571194648743,
-0.03643457964062691,
0.004042566753923893,
-0.0649387314915657,
0.5677524209022522,
0.08796269446611404,
0.4805191159248352,
0.10840572416782379,
-0.21711397171020508,
0.22059863805770874,
-0.5415491461753845,
0.05325769633054733,
1.0032089948654175,
0.07755632698535919,
-0.13670751452445984,
0.7950782179832458,
-0.13348300755023956,
0.43766263127326965,
-0.01012000534683466,
-0.09379135817289352,
-0.0330219492316246,
-0.039825715124607086,
0.23229770362377167,
0.24632608890533447,
0.6470497846603394,
0.3647865355014801,
0.8554843664169312,
-0.18770132958889008,
-0.23553648591041565,
0.5607582330703735,
0.24584336578845978,
-0.5970715880393982,
0.28806471824645996,
0.13567151129245758,
-0.6236055493354797,
-0.18412013351917267,
-0.013320567086338997,
-0.8828546404838562,
-0.5538284778594971,
-0.26228320598602295,
0.14988495409488678,
-0.23204904794692993,
0.03786110505461693,
-0.2139466106891632,
-0.1497383862733841,
0.23098844289779663,
0.18286140263080597,
-0.870958685874939,
0.104501873254776,
0.6021995544433594,
0.829052746295929,
0.06561900675296783,
-0.08371575176715851,
-0.05313939228653908,
-0.07024020701646805,
-0.2666577398777008,
0.3742261528968811,
-0.616013765335083,
-0.4892348647117615,
0.10154766589403152,
-0.37127628922462463,
0.11884962767362595,
-0.2758267819881439,
0.9082751274108887,
-0.24380598962306976,
-0.15631797909736633,
-0.47013288736343384,
-0.1297408640384674,
-0.2806469202041626,
0.06730383634567261,
-0.5329944491386414,
0.993326723575592,
0.13247406482696533,
-0.7649226784706116,
0.736958920955658,
-0.7616721987724304,
-0.20527087152004242,
-0.35082218050956726,
-0.6435089111328125,
-0.346976101398468,
0.20328712463378906,
0.25304096937179565,
0.013998261652886868,
-0.46805980801582336,
0.22739355266094208,
-0.49201545119285583,
-0.4032376706600189,
0.4288924038410187,
-0.6717223525047302,
0.8521999716758728,
-0.002297630300745368,
-0.9842314720153809,
0.0729743018746376,
-0.8132473230361938,
-0.3345900774002075,
0.2661309242248535,
-0.0588204450905323,
-0.4606466591358185,
0.062291987240314484,
-0.1609029769897461,
0.34147417545318604,
0.04914584383368492,
-0.7749139070510864,
0.13428430259227753,
-0.04983005300164223,
0.3417178690433502,
1.1299570798873901,
-0.13739560544490814,
0.4441809058189392,
-0.3554021120071411,
0.5890288352966309,
-0.10086828470230103,
0.21439501643180847,
0.009240361861884594,
-0.5543975234031677,
-1.0430347919464111,
-0.10383868217468262,
0.14059004187583923,
0.32309654355049133,
-0.3269226551055908,
0.2865796685218811,
-0.10159571468830109,
-0.2467174082994461,
-1.0462085008621216,
0.14495700597763062,
0.23334184288978577,
0.47199809551239014,
0.14170078933238983,
-0.24896065890789032,
-0.5568836331367493,
-0.9332047700881958,
-0.705863356590271,
-0.06607510894536972,
0.057149093598127365,
0.5377591848373413,
0.7920802235603333,
-0.5556895136833191,
0.935434103012085,
-0.20511238276958466,
-0.10412272065877914,
0.013302614912390709,
0.5329282283782959,
-0.03591188043355942,
0.35595762729644775,
0.5256632566452026,
-0.4038703143596649,
-0.010738080367445946,
-0.3534986674785614,
-0.7903395295143127,
-0.4183496832847595,
-0.006653630640357733,
-0.29684925079345703,
0.015051261521875858,
0.17197495698928833,
-0.5896357297897339,
0.6157321929931641,
0.2468021661043167,
-0.7313929200172424,
0.6240506172180176,
0.2973474860191345,
0.06366308033466339,
-0.41133806109428406,
-0.04241688922047615,
-0.03089388832449913,
-0.029996424913406372,
-0.318558931350708,
0.016547106206417084,
-0.23317953944206238,
0.12361481040716171,
-0.29200202226638794,
0.7880556583404541,
-0.7552309036254883,
-0.46995291113853455,
-0.2541784942150116,
0.025776268914341927,
-0.21507084369659424,
0.22778408229351044,
-0.18543988466262817,
0.8879156708717346,
0.22216705977916718,
-0.6815140843391418,
0.03186015784740448,
0.46081823110580444,
-0.40805965662002563,
0.6439707279205322,
-0.40714704990386963,
0.6406662464141846,
-0.41334864497184753,
0.17383559048175812,
-0.936232328414917,
0.2142171561717987,
0.14104636013507843,
-0.5163861513137817,
0.14417040348052979,
0.1325746476650238,
-0.22984151542186737,
-0.4188067615032196,
-0.28303229808807373,
0.48993709683418274,
0.5724668502807617,
-0.5372239947319031,
0.7299833297729492,
0.30136358737945557,
-0.2679571807384491,
-0.756406307220459,
-0.7382408976554871,
0.019100371748209,
-0.1288723647594452,
-0.9422825574874878,
-0.06203479692339897,
-0.07012263685464859,
-0.8104727268218994,
-0.3872697055339813,
-0.1807006448507309,
0.41739070415496826,
0.2697960436344147,
0.3988664448261261,
0.13623450696468353,
-0.037516020238399506,
-0.2706267237663269,
0.1554502695798874,
0.08712954819202423,
0.3422729969024658,
-0.3127753734588623,
0.8073612451553345,
-0.04897214099764824,
-0.434147447347641,
-0.005447286181151867,
0.4035073518753052,
0.5943602919578552,
-0.28284701704978943,
0.8750709891319275,
0.9087506532669067,
-0.1827218234539032,
-0.27969372272491455,
-0.6833420395851135,
-0.25352534651756287,
-0.3797520399093628,
0.023001933470368385,
-0.1914186179637909,
-0.7400323748588562,
0.7232602834701538,
-0.1680535227060318,
0.026764750480651855,
0.14457251131534576,
0.6604383587837219,
-0.18843623995780945,
1.1541904211044312,
0.6231919527053833,
-0.04608431085944176,
0.37564781308174133,
-0.33476492762565613,
0.2822582721710205,
-1.2518868446350098,
-0.32934489846229553,
-0.6109808087348938,
-0.622658371925354,
-0.6179880499839783,
-0.1882990300655365,
0.360853910446167,
0.07607956975698471,
-0.6220775842666626,
-0.6435710787773132,
-0.19132500886917114,
0.0579209178686142,
0.5115939378738403,
0.2939756512641907,
0.10774799436330795,
-0.2447754293680191,
-0.2430616021156311,
0.02271096780896187,
-0.24509748816490173,
-0.9882503151893616,
1.3139448165893555,
0.39352747797966003,
0.5224911570549011,
0.1386461853981018,
0.533193826675415,
0.5438566207885742,
0.6499070525169373,
-0.7274441719055176,
0.5263538956642151,
0.22336918115615845,
-0.5489634871482849,
-0.19333381950855255,
-0.16349586844444275,
-0.8480774164199829,
0.12287009507417679,
-0.07672180980443954,
-0.8382290601730347,
0.2817184627056122,
-0.030718212947249413,
-0.09385713934898376,
0.22924482822418213,
-0.23582768440246582,
0.46318209171295166,
-0.3203391432762146,
-0.6702986359596252,
0.06654363870620728,
-0.4545803368091583,
0.7670333385467529,
-0.010249847546219826,
0.3159676194190979,
-0.2607121169567108,
-0.30207571387290955,
0.8733484745025635,
-0.4467921555042267,
0.7157102227210999,
-0.2801557779312134,
-0.1161016970872879,
0.3095885217189789,
0.20496268570423126,
0.5039634704589844,
-0.08707980066537857,
-0.08682896196842194,
0.369026243686676,
-0.8438664674758911,
-0.35631000995635986,
-0.32239803671836853,
0.70389324426651,
-0.963006854057312,
-0.5200199484825134,
-0.49388477206230164,
-0.5864583253860474,
-0.31655338406562805,
0.10012967139482498,
0.13919013738632202,
0.0885559618473053,
-0.38403424620628357,
-0.12551435828208923,
0.4763115346431732,
-0.4193150997161865,
0.5402011871337891,
0.4592010974884033,
-0.052705612033605576,
-0.11116141825914383,
0.2662959694862366,
0.06325662136077881,
0.1565592885017395,
-0.06394403427839279,
0.2877052426338196,
-0.40549618005752563,
-0.4191914200782776,
-0.5377337336540222,
0.16897961497306824,
-0.6975130438804626,
0.2693636417388916,
-0.7803975939750671,
0.2071184664964676,
-0.4548589587211609,
-0.23951254785060883,
-0.11781784892082214,
-0.23080326616764069,
-0.1523178666830063,
-0.35746732354164124,
0.24687707424163818,
0.6892572641372681,
0.10108648985624313,
0.301973819732666,
-0.26717501878738403,
0.5706979036331177,
0.27395766973495483,
0.14168637990951538,
0.3845210671424866,
-0.37353670597076416,
0.04036644846200943,
0.0500619001686573,
-0.44677770137786865,
-1.1391165256500244,
0.29449915885925293,
-0.05444116145372391,
0.5674701929092407,
0.4579908847808838,
-0.1903628706932068,
0.3296303153038025,
-0.419531911611557,
0.9879570603370667,
0.049291595816612244,
-1.0616443157196045,
0.5639258623123169,
-0.4980059266090393,
0.13969723880290985,
0.6243913769721985,
0.34708985686302185,
-0.3993622362613678,
-0.35519710183143616,
-0.4441242814064026,
-0.9896882176399231,
0.5573003888130188,
0.26605889201164246,
0.009099113754928112,
-0.146468847990036,
0.34278547763824463,
0.3264225125312805,
0.6070882081985474,
-0.8550994992256165,
-0.6928892135620117,
-0.02493705227971077,
-0.1765318661928177,
-0.019302109256386757,
-0.19377130270004272,
0.046649832278490067,
-0.1086057722568512,
0.5929529666900635,
-0.1838998645544052,
0.4354570209980011,
0.25693050026893616,
-0.2748229205608368,
-0.3604876399040222,
0.48533740639686584,
0.3312169909477234,
0.5697258114814758,
-0.13732630014419556,
-0.15563108026981354,
-0.042768098413944244,
-0.6207754611968994,
0.4474449157714844,
0.015206771902740002,
-0.7658774256706238,
-0.03952135145664215,
0.26157209277153015,
0.9174835681915283,
-0.11101322621107101,
-0.713945209980011,
0.3599006235599518,
0.08873560279607773,
0.27611783146858215,
-0.5988795757293701,
-0.08720812201499939,
-0.03865744173526764,
0.14933471381664276,
0.26842251420021057,
0.2369156926870346,
0.2753807306289673,
-1.137263536453247,
-0.11232385039329529,
0.5726238489151001,
-0.6376998424530029,
-0.0911109447479248,
0.844460666179657,
0.28725358843803406,
-0.1771145761013031,
0.7997864484786987,
-0.0015359093667939305,
-0.5686085820198059,
0.6266441941261292,
0.3356209397315979,
1.4462860822677612,
-0.31969717144966125,
0.045987967401742935,
0.20445924997329712,
0.7220169305801392,
0.09898892045021057,
0.7046968340873718,
-0.11169494688510895,
-0.9325008392333984,
-0.014481112360954285,
-0.8888978958129883,
-0.06871538609266281,
-0.008161352016031742,
-0.7043139934539795,
0.03228559345006943,
-0.3224543333053589,
-0.37524881958961487,
-0.28138265013694763,
-0.10299556702375412,
-0.9568079710006714,
0.08440632373094559,
0.26895883679389954,
0.9741163849830627,
-0.8576609492301941,
0.3201218545436859,
0.4904291033744812,
-0.6187874674797058,
-0.4556832015514374,
0.1862277388572693,
0.12928293645381927,
-0.911316990852356,
0.7638937830924988,
0.2783130407333374,
-0.17283491790294647,
-0.21083654463291168,
-0.4111860394477844,
-0.45458170771598816,
1.1096034049987793,
0.3994900584220886,
-0.6183583736419678,
0.037988826632499695,
0.2207103669643402,
0.27209800481796265,
-0.47167888283729553,
0.8815686106681824,
1.125828504562378,
0.9315954446792603,
-0.4378323554992676,
-0.7997094988822937,
0.13282713294029236,
-0.059411920607089996,
0.0581846758723259,
0.2809271514415741,
-0.9227342009544373,
1.0253312587738037,
-0.506186306476593,
-0.11087130755186081,
0.14271891117095947,
0.7367457151412964,
0.45712146162986755,
0.5353178977966309,
0.48174849152565,
0.4916500151157379,
0.7549641728401184,
-0.3005000948905945,
1.317116379737854,
-0.23121602833271027,
-0.2905046045780182,
0.7844856977462769,
-0.43910396099090576,
0.2727990746498108,
0.511846661567688,
-0.19242896139621735,
0.6521615386009216,
0.5071264505386353,
0.41765788197517395,
0.13402338325977325,
0.5455170273780823,
-0.4063713252544403,
0.22651679813861847,
-0.4854891896247864,
-0.16156670451164246,
0.5325826406478882,
0.31935423612594604,
-0.5660093426704407,
0.1800844371318817,
0.031895749270915985,
0.2845313251018524,
0.12598159909248352,
-0.6411089897155762,
0.723446786403656,
0.4146454930305481,
-0.7932574152946472,
0.16703931987285614,
-0.09732178598642349,
0.8681891560554504,
-0.6562734246253967,
0.0772194042801857,
-0.32842501997947693,
0.06257767975330353,
-0.12125600874423981,
-0.501181960105896,
-0.053393688052892685,
0.2503732144832611,
-0.17052026093006134,
-0.09379084408283234,
0.6955283284187317,
-0.411160409450531,
-0.369078129529953,
0.5202839970588684,
0.6640565395355225,
-0.14933432638645172,
-0.07110720872879028,
-0.6477580070495605,
0.2629871070384979,
0.08659783005714417,
-0.23939570784568787,
0.19980932772159576,
0.30366140604019165,
-0.28631556034088135,
0.7152278423309326,
0.6433173418045044,
0.3947333097457886,
0.22943054139614105,
0.46379926800727844,
0.49193325638771057,
-0.878871738910675,
-0.6911101937294006,
-0.9302937984466553,
0.28919458389282227,
0.07216361910104752,
-0.43554583191871643,
0.8778725862503052,
0.3067323863506317,
0.5681961178779602,
0.108545683324337,
1.0978862047195435,
0.24466894567012787,
0.2021750956773758,
-0.6183549761772156,
0.6357607245445251,
-0.2182064652442932,
0.20718830823898315,
-0.5154062509536743,
-1.2438747882843018,
0.49035823345184326,
0.4273299276828766,
-0.3477611541748047,
0.5366911888122559,
0.5174015760421753,
0.3488626182079315,
0.18590383231639862,
0.43252530694007874,
0.03699168562889099,
0.48969927430152893,
0.23320841789245605,
0.2746438682079315,
1.2093048095703125,
-0.20268741250038147,
0.038406383246183395,
-0.06877443194389343,
-0.5380211472511292,
-0.032316237688064575,
-0.776067852973938,
-0.8614980578422546,
-0.19575311243534088,
-0.15538886189460754,
-0.27080366015434265,
0.12912927567958832,
1.0771028995513916,
0.37848806381225586,
-0.5636709928512573,
-0.2526054382324219,
0.034432895481586456,
-0.11701283603906631,
-0.3122138977050781,
-0.25888699293136597,
0.24901241064071655,
-0.052100129425525665,
-0.7176631093025208,
0.2032793164253235,
0.09712555259466171,
0.17376330494880676,
-0.738608181476593,
-0.1994149535894394,
-0.14129216969013214,
0.3433482348918915,
0.664594292640686,
-0.046897485852241516,
-0.7356690168380737,
-0.1932491511106491,
-0.31079134345054626,
0.2551235258579254,
-0.3080053925514221,
1.0155587196350098,
-0.6636685132980347,
0.45324698090553284,
0.40277099609375,
0.45116984844207764,
0.39881432056427,
-0.04629030451178551,
0.81113201379776,
-0.6068150401115417,
0.2263578623533249,
0.4903256297111511,
0.7322192192077637,
0.39961785078048706,
-0.4281943738460541,
0.576034426689148,
0.07895591855049133,
-0.35262995958328247,
-0.7381304502487183,
0.29480770230293274,
-0.7717579007148743,
-0.16902829706668854,
1.159493327140808,
0.16094547510147095,
-0.28012409806251526,
-0.30235204100608826,
-0.2909330129623413,
0.4868125319480896,
-0.6559168100357056,
0.906042218208313,
0.7618491053581238,
-0.24724267423152924,
0.017273278906941414,
-0.8173576593399048,
0.3636065125465393,
0.31763342022895813,
-0.5888249278068542,
-0.1558924913406372,
0.4689994156360626,
0.0683135837316513,
0.10597652941942215,
0.4908929169178009,
-0.1962675154209137,
0.1371680647134781,
0.16791513562202454,
0.3092067241668701,
-0.12987180054187775,
-0.16323566436767578,
-0.29444071650505066,
-0.059046223759651184,
-0.029818320646882057,
-0.039513468742370605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01264v1 | SignCLIP: Connecting Text and Sign Language by Contrastive Learning | 2024-07-01T13:17:35 | 2024-07-01T13:17:35 | Zifan Jiang, Gerard Sant, Amit Moryossef, Mathias Müller, Rico Sennrich, Sarah Ebling | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present SignCLIP, which re-purposes CLIP (Contrastive Language-Image
Pretraining) to project spoken language text and sign language videos, two
classes of natural languages of distinct modalities, into the same space.
SignCLIP is an efficient method of learning useful visual representations for
sign language processing from large-scale, multilingual video-text pairs,
without directly optimizing for a specific task or sign language which is often
of limited size.
We pretrain SignCLIP on Spreadthesign, a prominent sign language dictionary
consisting of ~500 thousand video clips in up to 44 sign languages, and
evaluate it with various downstream datasets. SignCLIP discerns in-domain
signing with notable text-to-video/video-to-text retrieval accuracy. It also
performs competitively for out-of-domain downstream tasks such as isolated sign
language recognition upon essential few-shot prompting or fine-tuning.
We analyze the latent space formed by the spoken language text and sign
language poses, which provides additional linguistic insights. Our code and
models are openly available. | [
-0.16461622714996338,
-0.2902194559574127,
0.184681698679924,
0.3285125494003296,
-0.6165685057640076,
0.19297392666339874,
-0.1460569053888321,
-0.4889569878578186,
0.5320308208465576,
0.42438554763793945,
-0.5042264461517334,
-0.6241626143455505,
-0.9702481031417847,
-0.27272000908851624,
-0.2956334948539734,
0.8742927312850952,
-0.3371005952358246,
-0.018745755776762962,
0.11238297075033188,
-0.22057460248470306,
-0.3387708067893982,
-0.25650307536125183,
-0.3819248676300049,
-0.15422934293746948,
-0.1291668564081192,
0.4953470528125763,
0.7706727385520935,
0.4050026834011078,
0.5573686957359314,
0.28012815117836,
0.18736973404884338,
-0.05125647783279419,
-0.3972357511520386,
-0.09306197613477707,
-0.05697649344801903,
-0.2340744435787201,
-0.015606001950800419,
0.11003721505403519,
0.6429507732391357,
0.763741135597229,
0.34484225511550903,
0.04449950158596039,
-0.12059482932090759,
0.41549548506736755,
-0.8183295726776123,
-0.17158128321170807,
-0.40302717685699463,
0.09876026958227158,
-0.3795694410800934,
0.083976149559021,
-0.22019381821155548,
-0.41496357321739197,
0.14624446630477905,
-0.7123579978942871,
0.3947335183620453,
-0.20339688658714294,
0.792787492275238,
0.26333221793174744,
-0.5635575652122498,
-0.32375267148017883,
-0.3790237605571747,
0.6301380395889282,
-0.4548288881778717,
0.6412256360054016,
0.4413912296295166,
0.22736255824565887,
0.21486108005046844,
-0.7224105596542358,
-0.6106980443000793,
-0.05418285354971886,
0.12464478611946106,
0.15883705019950867,
0.17215567827224731,
0.11259198933839798,
0.10339796543121338,
0.44288384914398193,
-0.7104406952857971,
0.09668461978435516,
-0.3827613890171051,
-0.4545414447784424,
0.3629569113254547,
-0.1019129678606987,
0.6606691479682922,
0.13893236219882965,
-0.5327026844024658,
-0.5216343402862549,
-0.6673610806465149,
-0.13682830333709717,
0.28864768147468567,
0.2959241271018982,
-0.5857759118080139,
0.3471563458442688,
0.35793349146842957,
0.8090815544128418,
-0.07002061605453491,
-0.19607658684253693,
0.10147944837808609,
-0.36507752537727356,
-0.07271216064691544,
-0.1604865938425064,
0.7958593964576721,
0.4654592275619507,
0.29008835554122925,
0.2552400529384613,
0.16594098508358002,
0.18103541433811188,
-0.4211456775665283,
-0.8942034244537354,
-0.672569990158081,
-0.17224986851215363,
-0.24488545954227448,
0.2100292146205902,
0.3617976903915405,
-0.5097668170928955,
-0.39053863286972046,
-0.26561957597732544,
0.5164464116096497,
-0.5618678331375122,
-0.3927971422672272,
0.27318185567855835,
-0.4280468225479126,
0.13999977707862854,
0.31827813386917114,
-0.9629230499267578,
0.5498976707458496,
0.4048998951911926,
1.011541485786438,
-0.4752010107040405,
-0.2881276309490204,
-0.4310767948627472,
0.2692318558692932,
-0.10889127105474472,
0.6787432432174683,
-0.5773528218269348,
-0.4425777792930603,
0.34007424116134644,
-0.06900561600923538,
-0.1018674299120903,
-0.6109865307807922,
0.3857625126838684,
-0.3962927758693695,
0.27283865213394165,
0.16798259317874908,
-0.4645182490348816,
-0.09114525467157364,
0.08182539790868759,
-0.9448575973510742,
0.7156328558921814,
-0.18078036606311798,
-0.5154408812522888,
0.663102388381958,
-0.601345419883728,
-0.8031124472618103,
0.08249085396528244,
-0.2218545377254486,
-0.4303452968597412,
-0.3236278295516968,
0.1845760941505432,
0.4777771830558777,
0.17288906872272491,
-0.3313860595226288,
0.004164551384747028,
-0.2167517989873886,
0.15631142258644104,
-0.19583110511302948,
0.7312255501747131,
0.16819429397583008,
-0.35636064410209656,
-0.040327589958906174,
-0.6397570967674255,
-0.10082995891571045,
-0.018611855804920197,
0.01030423492193222,
-0.5770341753959656,
-0.2952914834022522,
0.17521800100803375,
0.3811465799808502,
0.32257965207099915,
-0.39468055963516235,
-0.03972654417157173,
-0.27590617537498474,
0.27246716618537903,
0.3671458661556244,
0.05873352289199829,
0.41928115487098694,
0.21385851502418518,
0.7222437858581543,
0.159552201628685,
0.21161217987537384,
-0.44652479887008667,
-0.2435169816017151,
-0.522716760635376,
-0.5120915770530701,
-0.03424123302102089,
0.3070719540119171,
-0.7226545810699463,
0.19813281297683716,
-0.07486037164926529,
-0.25692224502563477,
-0.4358769953250885,
0.3435922861099243,
0.8540736436843872,
0.22612406313419342,
0.45156723260879517,
-0.6702656745910645,
-0.38536137342453003,
-0.5837405920028687,
-0.10761754959821701,
-0.050708018243312836,
0.02196642756462097,
-0.06663822382688522,
0.5025669932365417,
0.1565469354391098,
0.4590297043323517,
-0.778933584690094,
-0.668040931224823,
-0.16113053262233734,
0.09232574701309204,
0.3423447608947754,
0.4277077615261078,
0.48366206884384155,
-1.074163794517517,
-0.9239878058433533,
-0.014798800460994244,
-0.16166843473911285,
-0.07936538755893707,
-0.09148726612329483,
0.052928488701581955,
-0.29723963141441345,
0.7260271310806274,
-0.11085370928049088,
0.21868282556533813,
1.021840214729309,
-0.522118330001831,
0.4268273413181305,
-0.13129863142967224,
0.3631943166255951,
-0.9739169478416443,
0.09726304560899734,
-0.23166216909885406,
-0.2404385358095169,
-0.6667945384979248,
-0.12074116617441177,
-0.11907915771007538,
-0.4697588086128235,
-0.8232067823410034,
0.4913780093193054,
-0.8900166153907776,
-0.2615361213684082,
-0.4490961730480194,
0.6857621669769287,
-0.027815477922558784,
0.3193657398223877,
0.41883426904678345,
0.9126372337341309,
0.6309812664985657,
-0.5988442301750183,
0.03244050592184067,
0.6668261885643005,
-0.3179871737957001,
0.5545212030410767,
-0.4457646310329437,
0.0816681757569313,
0.18362358212471008,
-0.037512023001909256,
-1.2574256658554077,
-0.26595044136047363,
0.24176007509231567,
-0.3007875382900238,
0.49658849835395813,
-0.0146228251978755,
-0.059177279472351074,
0.018865181133151054,
-0.4997754693031311,
0.8344683051109314,
0.3741224408149719,
-0.838147759437561,
0.2366030067205429,
0.5762508511543274,
-0.040849339216947556,
-0.6251248121261597,
-0.6950376629829407,
-0.20501290261745453,
0.05059201642870903,
-0.46699023246765137,
0.41207051277160645,
-0.01620122790336609,
0.09912795573472977,
-0.19469213485717773,
-0.07054398208856583,
-0.4358016550540924,
-0.0861518606543541,
0.4776615798473358,
-0.022212037816643715,
0.040391307324171066,
0.11559125036001205,
0.07551663368940353,
-0.11570753157138824,
-0.2695772647857666,
-0.11400125175714493,
0.4662542939186096,
0.024366913363337517,
-0.5025822520256042,
-0.3542373478412628,
0.3611011207103729,
0.3584793210029602,
-0.11750084906816483,
0.3194703161716461,
0.2246331423521042,
-0.05241663381457329,
-0.20754684507846832,
-0.06724376231431961,
-0.053761664777994156,
-0.45695438981056213,
0.30051854252815247,
-0.3262602984905243,
-0.9771473407745361,
0.36634591221809387,
-0.327604204416275,
0.18596716225147247,
0.2190280556678772,
0.30082425475120544,
0.02769753895699978,
0.5457475781440735,
0.9388500452041626,
0.17980504035949707,
1.0312374830245972,
-0.1709558069705963,
-0.06359191983938217,
-0.44093582034111023,
-0.08194050192832947,
-0.290861040353775,
-0.25129690766334534,
-0.15269111096858978,
-0.7230846285820007,
0.046641718596220016,
0.12889908254146576,
-0.07804256677627563,
0.8939589262008667,
-0.5635173320770264,
0.8216537237167358,
0.36901673674583435,
0.26552650332450867,
0.4929297864437103,
-0.20188629627227783,
-0.17253181338310242,
-0.5268297791481018,
-0.3812941312789917,
-0.38531967997550964,
0.7504319548606873,
0.13389986753463745,
0.5774754881858826,
0.2684771418571472,
0.6346268653869629,
0.2921055853366852,
0.34553608298301697,
-0.5824881196022034,
0.6678770780563354,
-0.6189432144165039,
-0.37640663981437683,
-0.12013737857341766,
0.09109532088041306,
-0.8567253947257996,
0.30790653824806213,
-0.4090605676174164,
-0.3192497789859772,
-0.03065848909318447,
0.4970359802246094,
0.19642825424671173,
0.11407235264778137,
-0.8760509490966797,
0.9447181820869446,
-0.42139825224876404,
-0.362742155790329,
-0.3561380207538605,
-1.0035802125930786,
0.42972347140312195,
0.12739263474941254,
0.07498499006032944,
0.030763423070311546,
-0.08675646036863327,
0.9768128395080566,
-0.5757013559341431,
1.2207218408584595,
-0.03365517407655716,
-0.23375365138053894,
0.1640276461839676,
0.23407767713069916,
0.10231039673089981,
-0.33813250064849854,
0.24574065208435059,
0.00513695552945137,
-0.021221311762928963,
-0.3063313066959381,
-0.6153103709220886,
0.4216866195201874,
-0.6722860336303711,
-0.16545405983924866,
-0.2110224962234497,
0.012840834446251392,
-0.10881883651018143,
0.39957454800605774,
0.4250313639640808,
0.38958078622817993,
-0.6464530825614929,
-0.31374216079711914,
0.4905671179294586,
0.008086402900516987,
0.4468904435634613,
0.35693344473838806,
-0.22064487636089325,
-0.7578219175338745,
0.8731011152267456,
-0.4822521507740021,
0.5343364477157593,
0.6850401759147644,
0.07735182344913483,
-0.36099016666412354,
-0.5031594634056091,
0.10253607481718063,
0.7276302576065063,
-0.8383640050888062,
-0.09937822818756104,
-0.0018561286851763725,
0.18009868264198303,
-0.442789763212204,
-0.46376049518585205,
-0.36113786697387695,
-0.48438358306884766,
-0.2466566115617752,
-0.1706177145242691,
0.16051338613033295,
0.1869385987520218,
-0.23400594294071198,
0.7625749707221985,
-0.7002478837966919,
0.6398648619651794,
0.35640838742256165,
0.4410214126110077,
-0.4630289673805237,
-0.501105785369873,
-0.20239636301994324,
-0.299136757850647,
-0.3921352028846741,
-0.9057905077934265,
0.1457253098487854,
0.7959133386611938,
0.36408984661102295,
1.0088635683059692,
0.081180140376091,
0.6905187368392944,
-0.5706720948219299,
0.9853623509407043,
1.0700398683547974,
-1.2825567722320557,
0.6269466876983643,
-0.01722962036728859,
0.34119942784309387,
0.8071818351745605,
0.6934469938278198,
-0.5897806882858276,
-0.3749382197856903,
-0.5886980295181274,
-0.8481487035751343,
0.35970771312713623,
0.1091131791472435,
0.16341035068035126,
-0.015377643518149853,
-0.027532661333680153,
0.3673126697540283,
0.1702968180179596,
-0.8930102586746216,
-0.024560600519180298,
-0.5887577533721924,
-0.3995071351528168,
-0.09624579548835754,
0.05101606249809265,
-0.28058284521102905,
-0.11303368955850601,
0.348147451877594,
-0.29823800921440125,
0.10173111408948898,
-0.0012548670638352633,
-0.54534512758255,
0.22166238725185394,
0.014457148499786854,
0.867278516292572,
0.32103461027145386,
0.2189623862504959,
0.6224507689476013,
-0.12357529997825623,
-1.0714967250823975,
0.12113603204488754,
-0.1426558494567871,
0.1610470414161682,
0.1828145831823349,
0.7591372132301331,
0.9931743741035461,
0.5379769206047058,
-0.8843246102333069,
0.9233523607254028,
0.3885187804698944,
-0.4071998596191406,
-0.2202097773551941,
-0.10975152999162674,
-0.3210681080818176,
0.07135392725467682,
-0.06584569811820984,
-0.2440698742866516,
0.10556197166442871,
-0.49438002705574036,
0.35297325253486633,
0.41721421480178833,
-0.6169912219047546,
-0.6941033005714417,
0.7215970754623413,
0.5524766445159912,
-0.3198167383670807,
0.36584851145744324,
0.4553041160106659,
-0.8961583375930786,
0.33218544721603394,
0.6466494798660278,
0.8185978531837463,
-0.31653812527656555,
0.526860237121582,
0.3228137493133545,
0.04611743241548538,
-0.00027179517201147974,
0.24427875876426697,
-0.6087552905082703,
-0.7920088768005371,
-0.48072463274002075,
-0.09160926192998886,
-0.7827053070068359,
-0.2728562355041504,
-0.35508525371551514,
0.42241376638412476,
-0.616144597530365,
-0.10996413975954056,
-0.32868099212646484,
-0.17403051257133484,
-0.4331095814704895,
0.29671621322631836,
0.2223355770111084,
0.8384153246879578,
-1.4057250022888184,
0.4478705823421478,
0.6095711588859558,
-0.4446561336517334,
-0.48142558336257935,
0.17328494787216187,
-0.22914469242095947,
-0.7360672354698181,
1.0327470302581787,
0.2824896574020386,
-0.5628752708435059,
-0.07299736887216568,
-0.7198433876037598,
-0.5899513959884644,
0.6010289788246155,
0.5149959325790405,
-0.13538916409015656,
0.2907610535621643,
0.11776173114776611,
0.5063396096229553,
-0.2922573685646057,
0.2113422006368637,
0.3706636428833008,
0.22902390360832214,
0.34141749143600464,
-0.7518417835235596,
0.21581150591373444,
-0.02754649706184864,
-0.3289109766483307,
0.5195835828781128,
-0.5907569527626038,
0.30323857069015503,
-0.2863512933254242,
-0.6607314944267273,
-0.23281118273735046,
0.8281993865966797,
0.22715795040130615,
0.35709303617477417,
0.47794675827026367,
0.2599860727787018,
0.43693581223487854,
0.11107650399208069,
0.41045477986335754,
-0.15796679258346558,
0.1169215515255928,
1.107759714126587,
-0.26675650477409363,
1.069385290145874,
0.763400137424469,
-0.24695393443107605,
0.5529394149780273,
0.1990811675786972,
0.0997861698269844,
0.6622258424758911,
0.13872775435447693,
-0.3652700185775757,
-0.2679778039455414,
0.06333965808153152,
0.029682837426662445,
0.15504877269268036,
0.38885506987571716,
-0.18212293088436127,
-0.30998334288597107,
0.31005167961120605,
-0.07394887506961823,
0.677511990070343,
-0.09837771952152252,
0.5690982341766357,
0.2113070785999298,
-0.4480222463607788,
0.40733394026756287,
-0.5890259146690369,
0.726201057434082,
-0.8417607545852661,
-0.2550663650035858,
-0.020283430814743042,
0.18993699550628662,
-0.2737864851951599,
-1.045094609260559,
0.21884967386722565,
-0.30789652466773987,
0.09265432506799698,
-0.44861292839050293,
0.5759937763214111,
-0.6262698173522949,
0.1654805988073349,
0.2849274277687073,
-0.01981503702700138,
0.545371413230896,
0.3938457667827606,
-0.5589195489883423,
0.07939912378787994,
-0.14954914152622223,
0.272495299577713,
0.03222377225756645,
0.20456476509571075,
-0.16372717916965485,
0.44593295454978943,
0.4806329011917114,
0.12257440388202667,
0.05374152585864067,
0.24150018393993378,
0.6906803846359253,
-0.6140843629837036,
-0.7207385301589966,
-0.44463884830474854,
0.5493936538696289,
-0.2921774685382843,
-0.5716022253036499,
0.6778104305267334,
0.567374587059021,
0.7901004552841187,
-0.4465291500091553,
0.5392110347747803,
-0.05303755775094032,
0.4382968544960022,
-0.8297862410545349,
0.39493799209594727,
-0.26566946506500244,
-0.26969313621520996,
-0.6699765920639038,
-0.6720338463783264,
-0.8443865180015564,
0.45828181505203247,
-0.35602352023124695,
-0.2538086473941803,
0.8504153490066528,
0.33016979694366455,
-0.2480907291173935,
-0.4915502071380615,
0.3875458538532257,
-0.3259028196334839,
0.3332843482494354,
0.7150643467903137,
0.5999078750610352,
-0.6995877027511597,
0.7977569699287415,
0.1758364737033844,
-0.3833284080028534,
-0.2700907588005066,
-0.9054884314537048,
-1.0273209810256958,
-0.8655545711517334,
-0.7855772972106934,
0.047221068292856216,
-0.12927813827991486,
0.5270137786865234,
0.7726589441299438,
-0.7263033986091614,
-0.38824087381362915,
-0.10038387030363083,
0.13070742785930634,
-0.3791927397251129,
-0.14083601534366608,
0.7275771498680115,
0.09339338541030884,
-0.7039967179298401,
0.38881683349609375,
0.24474099278450012,
0.4721507728099823,
0.03515765070915222,
-0.13851669430732727,
-0.1833721101284027,
-0.17950965464115143,
0.47796517610549927,
1.0142326354980469,
-0.18654535710811615,
-0.16557101905345917,
-0.1648252308368683,
-0.017243465408682823,
0.055689964443445206,
1.2588253021240234,
-0.4800354838371277,
0.41722622513771057,
0.6550003886222839,
0.3396896421909332,
0.8498573899269104,
0.14842556416988373,
0.6119037866592407,
-1.0848629474639893,
0.6488012075424194,
0.009486728347837925,
0.07964852452278137,
0.5393004417419434,
0.07761301100254059,
0.24141627550125122,
0.33229562640190125,
-0.0831979364156723,
-0.46143072843551636,
0.7089853882789612,
-1.158260703086853,
-0.31697437167167664,
0.7567522525787354,
-0.06461836397647858,
0.012349631637334824,
-0.2848057150840759,
-0.3334222733974457,
0.2457597404718399,
-0.11972519010305405,
0.3418087363243103,
0.2743552327156067,
-0.1782950758934021,
-0.5231393575668335,
0.13677802681922913,
0.7561777234077454,
0.35629701614379883,
-0.6487331986427307,
0.04465861991047859,
0.4829457700252533,
0.16267293691635132,
0.48847436904907227,
0.7572778463363647,
-0.17974315583705902,
0.3589698076248169,
0.06882600486278534,
0.3298413157463074,
-0.06622062623500824,
-0.31755101680755615,
-0.4229232370853424,
0.281751424074173,
0.11525942385196686,
-0.7553597092628479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01257v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01257v2 | uDistil-Whisper: Label-Free Data Filtering for Knowledge Distillation via Large-Scale Pseudo Labelling | 2024-07-01T13:07:01 | 2024-07-03T09:54:08 | Abdul Waheed, Karima Kadaoui, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent work on distilling Whisper's knowledge into small models using
pseudo-labels shows promising performance while reducing the size by up to
50\%. This results in small, efficient, and dedicated models. However, a
critical step of distillation from pseudo-labels involves filtering
high-quality predictions and using only those during training. This step
requires ground truth to compare and filter bad examples making the whole
process supervised. In addition to that, the distillation process requires a
large amount of data thereby limiting the ability to distil models in
low-resource settings. To address this challenge, we propose an unsupervised or
label-free framework for distillation, thus eliminating the requirement for
labeled data altogether. Through experimentation, we show that our
best-distilled models outperform the teacher model by 5-7 points in terms of
WER. Additionally, our models are on par with or better than similar supervised
data filtering setup. When we scale the data, our models significantly
outperform all zero-shot and supervised models. We demonstrate that it is
possible to distill large Whisper models into relatively small models without
using any labeled data. Our distilled models are 25-50\% more compute and
memory efficient while maintaining performance equal to or better than the
teacher model. | [
-0.2718140184879303,
-0.34206435084342957,
0.717613935470581,
-0.02383916638791561,
-0.43497079610824585,
0.009780549444258213,
-0.12666164338588715,
-0.44437137246131897,
-0.05047548562288284,
0.5562068223953247,
-0.3937591016292572,
-0.6290997266769409,
-0.7904976606369019,
-0.2187318503856659,
-0.6107909679412842,
1.219417929649353,
0.17532099783420563,
-0.08812369406223297,
-0.3284554183483124,
-0.04420114681124687,
-0.18111488223075867,
-0.46560099720954895,
-0.36237016320228577,
-0.7946286797523499,
0.3754163682460785,
0.3584182560443878,
0.28884556889533997,
0.6133643388748169,
0.13545481860637665,
0.3001071512699127,
-0.40479978919029236,
0.06986892968416214,
-0.7080590128898621,
0.22478362917900085,
0.013673878274857998,
-0.7031425833702087,
-0.4464103877544403,
0.4000853896141052,
0.2642417848110199,
0.8173303008079529,
-0.4353446066379547,
0.36066025495529175,
0.37288549542427063,
0.9866600632667542,
-0.7507667541503906,
0.20736064016819,
-0.8026953935623169,
-0.11335492879152298,
-0.1629607230424881,
0.3558022975921631,
-0.44754984974861145,
-0.4749507009983063,
0.42158129811286926,
-0.7553521394729614,
0.4749668538570404,
0.13234350085258484,
0.5979238152503967,
0.4754442274570465,
-0.2976883053779602,
-0.15528184175491333,
-0.9903278350830078,
0.8811063170433044,
-0.5143919587135315,
0.18297840654850006,
0.6419414281845093,
0.5292076468467712,
-0.01911303587257862,
-1.0939342975616455,
-0.5044334530830383,
0.24414683878421783,
-0.020666077733039856,
0.24369218945503235,
-0.4932965338230133,
0.18662339448928833,
0.22097733616828918,
0.34942182898521423,
-0.36981654167175293,
-0.0559634231030941,
-0.43054017424583435,
-0.05302955210208893,
0.3520214557647705,
-0.02272813208401203,
-0.4702289402484894,
0.15429069101810455,
-0.45658478140830994,
-0.11662198603153229,
-0.49124908447265625,
-0.051105476915836334,
0.29085326194763184,
0.2230888307094574,
0.24780797958374023,
0.4644937515258789,
-0.6364728808403015,
0.8435912132263184,
0.2577632665634155,
-0.5723377466201782,
-0.1404425948858261,
-0.021334830671548843,
-0.3637208342552185,
0.4184766411781311,
0.5108579397201538,
0.4565744400024414,
0.1354852169752121,
0.12217363715171814,
-0.20254091918468475,
0.09995253384113312,
-0.09645146876573563,
-1.2777693271636963,
-0.9771609306335449,
0.08472103625535965,
-0.5960880517959595,
-0.611883819103241,
-0.3143390417098999,
-0.8223878145217896,
-0.7252527475357056,
-0.2849360406398773,
0.6144563555717468,
-0.02227102592587471,
-0.41879063844680786,
0.17609411478042603,
-0.49778464436531067,
-0.3518907427787781,
0.2496069073677063,
-0.6268318891525269,
0.20039048790931702,
0.30439263582229614,
0.834918737411499,
0.11492512375116348,
0.18223407864570618,
-0.4246453642845154,
0.3345174789428711,
-0.15014417469501495,
0.706982433795929,
-0.39485058188438416,
-0.7835985422134399,
-0.48736515641212463,
-0.47773584723472595,
0.3087826073169708,
-0.9172553420066833,
0.396721750497818,
-0.4816502630710602,
0.06569909304380417,
-0.2940005660057068,
-0.8387413620948792,
-0.28798025846481323,
-0.00924623105674982,
-0.5662703514099121,
0.9562457203865051,
-0.056293122470378876,
-0.7710176706314087,
0.6052358150482178,
-0.46710532903671265,
-0.21941979229450226,
0.09691527485847473,
0.248978391289711,
-0.3914440870285034,
0.26962214708328247,
0.4289368987083435,
0.37257587909698486,
-0.6546650528907776,
0.5174496173858643,
-0.36370396614074707,
-0.2717492878437042,
0.1356821209192276,
-0.8566449284553528,
0.7791720032691956,
0.2216145247220993,
-0.21837252378463745,
0.005816397722810507,
-0.9009805917739868,
0.11270792037248611,
-0.10915308445692062,
-0.019401781260967255,
-0.7562178373336792,
-0.1489381045103073,
-0.1816718429327011,
-0.0162961483001709,
0.06929760426282883,
-0.7654286623001099,
0.2524973154067993,
-0.07138798385858536,
0.46534091234207153,
0.7313205003738403,
0.11373420804738998,
0.4650316536426544,
-0.3132077753543854,
0.12303417921066284,
0.2858184576034546,
0.5280840992927551,
0.06542418897151947,
-0.642230749130249,
-0.838410496711731,
-0.8523114323616028,
0.5249546766281128,
0.1946951299905777,
-0.9199116230010986,
0.26725125312805176,
-0.08754934370517731,
-0.8907520771026611,
-0.7706095576286316,
0.27009496092796326,
0.2791333794593811,
1.0834685564041138,
0.5259947776794434,
0.14482355117797852,
-0.37177979946136475,
-0.8762804269790649,
0.09079809486865997,
-0.3179490268230438,
-0.23393332958221436,
0.09103798866271973,
0.3661661744117737,
0.0533800907433033,
1.352487325668335,
-1.237679362297058,
-0.7149308323860168,
-0.24057090282440186,
0.548054575920105,
0.4982457160949707,
0.13681617379188538,
0.4714645445346832,
-0.9615504741668701,
-0.6337859034538269,
-0.2874046564102173,
-0.7019991874694824,
-0.3514898717403412,
0.35169464349746704,
0.09995854645967484,
-0.10113468766212463,
0.20307449996471405,
-0.4558265805244446,
0.7355844378471375,
0.5478652715682983,
-0.13633424043655396,
0.46117982268333435,
-0.43465477228164673,
-0.06346860527992249,
-0.9347964525222778,
0.003873445326462388,
0.20079536736011505,
-0.1825590580701828,
-0.6150291562080383,
-0.5737429857254028,
0.03960162401199341,
-0.10408776253461838,
-0.4274328649044037,
0.34901443123817444,
-0.3740697503089905,
0.40775662660598755,
-0.6008262634277344,
-0.11894138902425766,
0.44084632396698,
0.18614713847637177,
0.39548876881599426,
0.5221655964851379,
0.5771466493606567,
-0.5346696972846985,
0.5842710733413696,
0.05986230820417404,
-0.5032311677932739,
0.9024779200553894,
-0.7888308167457581,
-0.16378459334373474,
-0.024530570954084396,
0.5834238529205322,
-1.049847960472107,
0.08128517121076584,
-0.24374441802501678,
-0.2397036850452423,
0.24777065217494965,
-0.7449750900268555,
-0.5049784779548645,
-0.6329336166381836,
-0.19174076616764069,
0.09349633008241653,
0.8755771517753601,
-0.9915263652801514,
0.47440579533576965,
0.32826554775238037,
0.12631018459796906,
-0.3343201279640198,
-0.4719158709049225,
-0.10847462713718414,
-0.579870343208313,
-0.3134613633155823,
0.15914322435855865,
-0.12439879029989243,
-0.16837820410728455,
0.1628546416759491,
-0.44775551557540894,
-0.5520938038825989,
-0.11686578392982483,
0.4816473424434662,
0.5382695198059082,
0.13354359567165375,
0.1061767190694809,
0.1881163865327835,
-0.34904465079307556,
-0.03917894512414932,
-0.7785362005233765,
-0.03345786780118942,
0.2984090745449066,
-0.10033369064331055,
-0.535075843334198,
0.1574781835079193,
0.6524872183799744,
0.07422320544719696,
0.9851840138435364,
0.3596433401107788,
-0.38000422716140747,
-0.5482175350189209,
-0.6600411534309387,
-0.4846079647541046,
-0.5839096903800964,
-0.039699092507362366,
-0.37314745783805847,
-0.6757090091705322,
0.20230452716350555,
-0.4697810113430023,
-0.05702421814203262,
0.23748502135276794,
0.30884990096092224,
-0.5592775344848633,
0.8281097412109375,
0.6408581137657166,
-0.2354990541934967,
0.054857686161994934,
-0.5976943373680115,
0.3193354308605194,
-0.6018807888031006,
-0.2938022017478943,
-0.59868985414505,
-0.46067988872528076,
-0.20219002664089203,
-0.2731863260269165,
0.8018966317176819,
0.2144584059715271,
0.1707732081413269,
0.12819325923919678,
-0.9449153542518616,
0.6503198146820068,
0.8489431738853455,
-0.014280123636126518,
0.6252988576889038,
-0.0739298164844513,
-0.17899897694587708,
-0.14826396107673645,
-0.7211827039718628,
-0.21088357269763947,
1.2893942594528198,
0.026806026697158813,
1.0223941802978516,
-0.30920764803886414,
0.7797842025756836,
0.29466894268989563,
0.4123779237270355,
-0.672935426235199,
0.5035803914070129,
-0.22856736183166504,
-0.9282119870185852,
-0.2958172857761383,
-0.46696335077285767,
-0.5758346915245056,
0.5851673483848572,
-0.20796316862106323,
-0.5655599236488342,
0.3061906695365906,
0.2671625018119812,
-0.18604832887649536,
0.7133037447929382,
-1.0205442905426025,
0.39437949657440186,
0.17203278839588165,
-0.174186572432518,
-0.07384777069091797,
-0.32229068875312805,
0.5139676332473755,
-0.34857887029647827,
0.16169509291648865,
-0.19464939832687378,
0.35707929730415344,
0.8870036602020264,
-0.8088459968566895,
1.1306085586547852,
-0.810637354850769,
-0.02495926059782505,
0.7251635193824768,
-0.0806206464767456,
0.3826897144317627,
-0.10802017897367477,
0.028298061341047287,
0.34031298756599426,
0.2666292190551758,
-0.16605214774608612,
-0.5677787661552429,
0.7469295263290405,
-0.7059586644172668,
-0.5736402869224548,
-0.45647525787353516,
-0.38313791155815125,
-0.33058592677116394,
0.08258714526891708,
0.5843133330345154,
0.39322441816329956,
0.06318799406290054,
0.3020191490650177,
0.9621146321296692,
0.23598338663578033,
0.3971434533596039,
0.772433876991272,
-0.1785602569580078,
-0.2890464961528778,
0.9813051819801331,
0.5051250457763672,
0.04089786112308502,
0.19640861451625824,
0.36701154708862305,
-0.8272601366043091,
-0.7041140198707581,
-0.34926947951316833,
0.07991448789834976,
-0.47296279668807983,
-0.5260564684867859,
-0.5900485515594482,
-0.2063884735107422,
-0.27685654163360596,
0.1474064439535141,
-0.66721111536026,
-0.5936476588249207,
-0.44755902886390686,
-0.0942230075597763,
0.7162975668907166,
0.671427845954895,
-0.38027113676071167,
0.5435535907745361,
-0.7333840727806091,
0.5818672180175781,
0.7281579971313477,
0.28856953978538513,
0.16875813901424408,
-0.5276686549186707,
-0.15281131863594055,
0.25999292731285095,
-0.3064366281032562,
-0.5552815794944763,
0.17998665571212769,
0.3637435734272003,
0.2353156954050064,
0.5091165900230408,
0.8482330441474915,
0.7802502512931824,
-0.39763155579566956,
0.5558972954750061,
0.47722673416137695,
-0.9003539681434631,
0.6982455849647522,
-0.07949529588222504,
0.2110190987586975,
0.6074002981185913,
0.4493938088417053,
-0.15994793176651,
-0.36780354380607605,
-0.3871959447860718,
-0.9109624624252319,
0.5756258964538574,
0.14751063287258148,
-0.31938591599464417,
0.4093311131000519,
0.2682896852493286,
0.32983118295669556,
0.3293151259422302,
-0.27380815148353577,
-0.4852149188518524,
-0.30738797783851624,
-0.11868948489427567,
-0.11250778287649155,
-0.4325239360332489,
-0.21139097213745117,
-0.5393933057785034,
0.7660762667655945,
0.16097211837768555,
-0.20805208384990692,
0.0772007405757904,
-0.022071711719036102,
0.10950100421905518,
0.06432931125164032,
-0.021046919748187065,
0.37705567479133606,
-0.2846551239490509,
0.22267338633537292,
0.011501633562147617,
-0.7066758871078491,
0.48594748973846436,
0.12410389631986618,
-0.4677852988243103,
-0.07461626082658768,
0.2151148021221161,
0.7442958354949951,
-0.03321163356304169,
-0.30229365825653076,
0.37543946504592896,
-0.15135326981544495,
-0.3725627064704895,
0.11010965704917908,
0.30297258496284485,
0.3306674063205719,
0.36951562762260437,
0.59157794713974,
-0.1778453290462494,
0.40879377722740173,
-0.16600532829761505,
0.17986354231834412,
0.0031361498404294252,
-0.3356306850910187,
-0.2693743109703064,
0.802954375743866,
0.2643747925758362,
0.4515518844127655,
0.7246954441070557,
-0.023719241842627525,
-0.28787004947662354,
0.2657938599586487,
0.4454704225063324,
0.6575149297714233,
-0.3104448914527893,
0.5147488117218018,
0.2593662738800049,
0.02776295877993107,
-0.2980562746524811,
-0.1689109057188034,
-0.46915802359580994,
-0.3859788179397583,
-0.2193630188703537,
-0.8213046789169312,
-0.5333907604217529,
0.16552269458770752,
-0.8774967193603516,
-0.14710953831672668,
-0.24933762848377228,
-0.4507254958152771,
0.2715991735458374,
0.15264537930488586,
-0.4126291573047638,
0.44443774223327637,
-0.05288858339190483,
0.8525100946426392,
-0.9992566108703613,
1.32038152217865,
0.4424870014190674,
0.19280996918678284,
-0.7252788543701172,
-0.22560876607894897,
0.20410075783729553,
-0.41536620259284973,
0.6858624815940857,
-0.004044375382363796,
-0.2651507556438446,
0.08306143432855606,
-0.4078269898891449,
-0.5083293914794922,
1.1465662717819214,
0.39434143900871277,
-0.788882315158844,
0.08414541184902191,
0.10541456192731857,
0.6314370036125183,
0.002463826211169362,
0.01845865324139595,
0.7496887445449829,
0.5354756712913513,
0.7596959471702576,
-0.8725739121437073,
-0.3976300060749054,
-0.014374546706676483,
0.011851698160171509,
0.17625926434993744,
-0.368651807308197,
0.6008397936820984,
-0.11220229417085648,
0.011802189983427525,
-0.05938786640763283,
0.5787278413772583,
0.18827661871910095,
0.6299883723258972,
0.5365249514579773,
0.7755196690559387,
1.0018651485443115,
-0.35804858803749084,
0.6902365684509277,
0.2071988731622696,
0.22991274297237396,
1.364355206489563,
-0.5790796279907227,
0.6476349234580994,
0.4459148049354553,
-0.2839624285697937,
0.14529845118522644,
0.43519771099090576,
0.12130038440227509,
1.109065055847168,
0.13417741656303406,
-0.5459704399108887,
-0.1773398220539093,
-0.40045952796936035,
-0.23957586288452148,
0.4964691996574402,
0.2267940491437912,
0.05428352579474449,
-0.34825509786605835,
0.3349873125553131,
-0.1285172402858734,
-0.03167171776294708,
-0.27374356985092163,
0.9511001706123352,
0.12845559418201447,
-0.3445875644683838,
0.6707271933555603,
-0.1511947214603424,
0.8001935482025146,
-0.6346325278282166,
0.03309871256351471,
-0.2016526609659195,
0.3646121621131897,
-0.10808460414409637,
-0.686237633228302,
0.18264859914779663,
0.2481917291879654,
-0.496766597032547,
-0.35533466935157776,
0.904080867767334,
-0.5951821208000183,
-0.45872408151626587,
0.34726303815841675,
0.5139014720916748,
0.12108170241117477,
-0.4120643436908722,
-0.3019203245639801,
-0.0983426570892334,
0.135883629322052,
-0.32092905044555664,
0.4717699885368347,
0.4647892415523529,
0.11760540306568146,
0.7263161540031433,
0.8200231790542603,
0.3947248160839081,
0.02149149216711521,
-0.1008574366569519,
1.0443081855773926,
-0.18497592210769653,
-0.5627222657203674,
-0.7246696949005127,
0.32318171858787537,
-0.20339661836624146,
0.024088693782687187,
0.5615141987800598,
0.5508328676223755,
0.5565649271011353,
0.005289600230753422,
0.6568647027015686,
0.21871772408485413,
0.6442549824714661,
-0.18525533378124237,
1.2110470533370972,
-0.4686332643032074,
0.13461650907993317,
-0.014420977793633938,
-1.0336467027664185,
0.031080788001418114,
0.42372632026672363,
-0.18885253369808197,
-0.19472861289978027,
0.23241108655929565,
0.5206455588340759,
-0.12026788294315338,
0.33166995644569397,
0.6359134912490845,
0.34809285402297974,
0.4253026247024536,
0.5103969573974609,
0.6827962398529053,
-0.2640492618083954,
0.6647547483444214,
-0.6286003589630127,
-0.5058301091194153,
0.029547881335020065,
-0.9159989953041077,
-1.1156352758407593,
-0.8017442226409912,
-0.46121901273727417,
0.07212968170642853,
-0.1075175553560257,
0.2880350351333618,
1.2303156852722168,
-0.5831417441368103,
-0.07567781209945679,
0.17154096066951752,
0.0962635949254036,
-0.0815240889787674,
-0.17251479625701904,
0.36218568682670593,
0.25797298550605774,
-0.6699913144111633,
0.5125716328620911,
0.2014249712228775,
0.3130907118320465,
-0.07743752747774124,
0.2021760195493698,
0.16679488122463226,
0.11120707541704178,
0.620760977268219,
-0.04885506629943848,
-0.30665159225463867,
-0.054751064628362656,
-0.384852796792984,
0.20053906738758087,
-0.2591733932495117,
0.5929310917854309,
-1.149959683418274,
0.6248360276222229,
0.02948765642940998,
0.14719565212726593,
1.0795857906341553,
-0.19131845235824585,
0.09986986964941025,
-0.89671391248703,
0.36989477276802063,
0.11952214688062668,
0.1170746237039566,
0.23038434982299805,
-0.21820533275604248,
0.39553534984588623,
0.328827440738678,
-0.40578776597976685,
-1.0188387632369995,
0.010142584331333637,
-0.6475651264190674,
-0.4389987587928772,
0.817740261554718,
-0.3702854514122009,
-0.0480240136384964,
-0.12829087674617767,
-0.21287928521633148,
0.4050033688545227,
-0.4972624182701111,
0.9047738909721375,
0.7441388964653015,
-0.007522752042859793,
0.13121430575847626,
-0.3673766553401947,
0.49812206625938416,
-0.19088390469551086,
-0.5479581356048584,
0.2669103741645813,
0.5721457600593567,
0.4494030177593231,
-0.10088993608951569,
0.5918908715248108,
0.03316685929894447,
-0.22864855825901031,
0.1170497015118599,
-0.21393093466758728,
-0.41819971799850464,
-0.656455934047699,
0.03436023369431496,
0.3262312412261963,
-0.06295599788427353,
-0.49343976378440857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01238v1 | Large Language Models are Zero-Shot Recognizers for Activities of Daily Living | 2024-07-01T12:32:38 | 2024-07-01T12:32:38 | Gabriele Civitarese, Michele Fiori, Priyankar Choudhary, Claudio Bettini | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.SP | The sensor-based recognition of Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) in smart
home environments enables several applications in the areas of energy
management, safety, well-being, and healthcare. ADLs recognition is typically
based on deep learning methods requiring large datasets to be trained.
Recently, several studies proved that Large Language Models (LLMs) effectively
capture common-sense knowledge about human activities. However, the
effectiveness of LLMs for ADLs recognition in smart home environments still
deserves to be investigated. In this work, we propose ADL-LLM, a novel
LLM-based ADLs recognition system. ADLLLM transforms raw sensor data into
textual representations, that are processed by an LLM to perform zero-shot ADLs
recognition. Moreover, in the scenario where a small labeled dataset is
available, ADL-LLM can also be empowered with few-shot prompting. We evaluated
ADL-LLM on two public datasets, showing its effectiveness in this domain. | [
-0.09338066726922989,
-0.7183966636657715,
0.6770164370536804,
-0.34551918506622314,
-0.13983851671218872,
0.03903218358755112,
-0.4021843671798706,
-0.7671170830726624,
0.0796935111284256,
0.2890690565109253,
-0.3792625367641449,
-0.7560474872589111,
-0.46761396527290344,
0.1339653879404068,
-0.2878350019454956,
0.5700344443321228,
0.06129654124379158,
-0.0722077339887619,
0.39098498225212097,
-0.06730488687753677,
-0.11742695420980453,
-0.18408852815628052,
-0.5730161666870117,
-0.36288192868232727,
0.5982017517089844,
0.1955556422472,
0.44251489639282227,
0.526393473148346,
0.24230380356311798,
0.2268136739730835,
0.0287132877856493,
0.47346940636634827,
-0.1484089344739914,
0.11198820918798447,
0.3147594630718231,
-0.18388359248638153,
-0.6476260423660278,
-0.13884806632995605,
0.4599319100379944,
0.4342237114906311,
-0.025899194180965424,
0.4128158390522003,
-0.16443456709384918,
0.5462468266487122,
-0.5391249656677246,
0.49362829327583313,
-0.6964149475097656,
0.107145294547081,
-0.07876092195510864,
0.11269540339708328,
-0.35452473163604736,
-0.05517170578241348,
-0.27188190817832947,
-0.24998624622821808,
0.05810830369591713,
-0.06067665293812752,
0.6285973191261292,
0.14692847430706024,
-0.4116608798503876,
-0.4709930717945099,
-0.9102610349655151,
0.824237585067749,
-0.8527246117591858,
0.7328749895095825,
0.5215351581573486,
0.3154807984828949,
0.02246982790529728,
-0.13051968812942505,
-0.935798168182373,
-0.17823651432991028,
-0.1684819608926773,
-0.13871775567531586,
0.003756373655050993,
-0.2881397306919098,
0.22150182723999023,
0.007081932853907347,
-0.609989583492279,
0.08444657176733017,
-0.20446857810020447,
-0.10778337717056274,
0.8194659352302551,
0.483768492937088,
0.06371699273586273,
-0.2730039358139038,
-0.32101374864578247,
0.3752584159374237,
-0.6370328068733215,
0.2772699296474457,
-0.22649523615837097,
0.7112265229225159,
-0.1230294331908226,
0.4870534837245941,
-0.23401880264282227,
1.1410846710205078,
-0.19739839434623718,
-0.5720319151878357,
0.24028736352920532,
-0.03688349574804306,
-0.23530320823192596,
0.39132657647132874,
0.6363821625709534,
0.21274030208587646,
0.2040197104215622,
-0.22078129649162292,
-0.44520366191864014,
0.05774311721324921,
-0.12496315687894821,
-0.5181388854980469,
0.15657836198806763,
0.3904329240322113,
-0.2593368887901306,
-0.1569570153951645,
-0.01733044721186161,
-0.42523902654647827,
-0.8070615530014038,
-0.426954984664917,
0.3726431131362915,
-0.19976677000522614,
-0.07247862219810486,
0.6262256503105164,
0.37507474422454834,
0.6277179718017578,
0.6491551995277405,
-0.8485509753227234,
0.39137977361679077,
0.6936649680137634,
0.8484959006309509,
-0.17087529599666595,
-0.10416684299707413,
-0.5916258096694946,
0.4427850842475891,
-0.13919083774089813,
0.7582284212112427,
-0.13266241550445557,
-0.21005991101264954,
0.03197691589593887,
-0.001952502061612904,
-0.32973286509513855,
-0.44641467928886414,
0.19651560485363007,
-0.8641129732131958,
-0.14006540179252625,
0.09623255580663681,
-0.5222117900848389,
-0.07509618997573853,
0.6649237275123596,
-0.7239750027656555,
0.6557993292808533,
-0.14384523034095764,
-0.2937399744987488,
0.35382571816444397,
-0.8557558059692383,
-0.7041429877281189,
0.33518505096435547,
-0.09385203570127487,
-0.6181992292404175,
-0.015393919311463833,
0.11385609209537506,
0.8127531409263611,
-0.006358118262141943,
0.03979306295514107,
-0.12600372731685638,
-0.4959423243999481,
0.38406044244766235,
-0.762118935585022,
0.8810951709747314,
0.42565813660621643,
-0.09911449253559113,
-0.1792871206998825,
-0.9742814302444458,
-0.23341083526611328,
0.2383173406124115,
-0.8491746187210083,
-0.20505502820014954,
0.08005201816558838,
0.04489956423640251,
0.18455883860588074,
0.6678366661071777,
-1.1925617456436157,
0.3278040587902069,
-0.20420637726783752,
0.32305219769477844,
0.5471656322479248,
-0.25641676783561707,
0.22369560599327087,
-0.20399576425552368,
0.21453982591629028,
-0.11845174431800842,
0.12496252357959747,
-0.25572511553764343,
-0.42971721291542053,
-0.6202479600906372,
-0.7215057015419006,
0.19882743060588837,
0.739281952381134,
-0.3253368139266968,
0.7905495762825012,
-0.3984268009662628,
-0.24836622178554535,
-0.21949300169944763,
0.34884119033813477,
0.11764928698539734,
0.43042129278182983,
0.25798124074935913,
0.1912328451871872,
-0.5631323456764221,
-0.11304739117622375,
-0.038550931960344315,
0.021296901628375053,
-0.06222997233271599,
0.5775747895240784,
0.31296664476394653,
-0.3754658102989197,
1.107663869857788,
-0.8425636291503906,
-0.5417178273200989,
-0.47781383991241455,
-0.11259014904499054,
0.2695688307285309,
0.01990479975938797,
0.28111183643341064,
-0.6187916994094849,
-0.8058212995529175,
0.1465827375650406,
-0.8670095205307007,
0.1502152383327484,
0.00176154519431293,
0.3575899600982666,
0.17306531965732574,
0.5392709374427795,
-0.9574996829032898,
0.564293384552002,
0.5086383819580078,
-0.4933118224143982,
0.34769126772880554,
-0.06198542192578316,
-0.3717837929725647,
-0.9743932485580444,
-0.09562859684228897,
-0.16182230412960052,
-0.6037731170654297,
-0.6621934175491333,
-0.28263553977012634,
0.15952320396900177,
-0.4658345580101013,
-0.8325402140617371,
0.9671819806098938,
-0.5355252623558044,
-0.04073226451873779,
-0.3290507197380066,
-0.28069818019866943,
0.10135191679000854,
0.5810986161231995,
0.3225773870944977,
0.43203967809677124,
0.7793495655059814,
-0.6763270497322083,
0.6837252974510193,
0.10579139739274979,
-0.3757322132587433,
0.15588009357452393,
-0.24473877251148224,
0.12289290875196457,
-0.20109295845031738,
0.2666500508785248,
-1.0127511024475098,
-0.3859834372997284,
0.2005237638950348,
-0.19942931830883026,
0.32689979672431946,
0.35711273550987244,
-0.7117714881896973,
-0.4368812143802643,
-0.4670185148715973,
0.25160691142082214,
0.579898476600647,
-0.6420029401779175,
0.8408249616622925,
0.20229877531528473,
0.06141812726855278,
-0.08027540892362595,
-0.5498884916305542,
0.03844479098916054,
-0.208018496632576,
-0.17358094453811646,
-0.10229143500328064,
0.033580321818590164,
-0.06719210743904114,
-0.2587398588657379,
0.07564130425453186,
-0.08777955174446106,
-0.055964771658182144,
0.3151567578315735,
0.41678836941719055,
-0.1407373547554016,
0.3218209445476532,
-0.6830472946166992,
-0.18618737161159515,
-0.25726091861724854,
-0.11593236029148102,
0.5477709174156189,
-0.18494167923927307,
-0.6294328570365906,
-0.6137613654136658,
0.30303993821144104,
0.8544795513153076,
-0.27955693006515503,
0.6091471314430237,
0.5469554662704468,
-0.5595066547393799,
-0.2212800234556198,
-0.5068111419677734,
-0.04239415377378464,
-0.5492812991142273,
0.14442476630210876,
-0.024439342319965363,
-0.8422842621803284,
0.4569132328033447,
-0.12009620666503906,
0.22130592167377472,
0.11132872104644775,
0.4411482512950897,
-0.35747653245925903,
1.048374056816101,
0.27068430185317993,
-0.2299501597881317,
0.611761748790741,
-0.21184208989143372,
0.525526225566864,
-1.0378577709197998,
-0.09024527668952942,
-0.25106316804885864,
-0.5619948506355286,
-0.012002169154584408,
-0.4615769386291504,
0.3818115293979645,
-0.1901666820049286,
-0.3968577980995178,
0.44496315717697144,
-0.30609622597694397,
0.2983349859714508,
0.08099240064620972,
0.3741382956504822,
0.6488317847251892,
0.07687284052371979,
0.12684504687786102,
0.07768166810274124,
-0.45170050859451294,
-0.6957372426986694,
0.9298223853111267,
0.5644198656082153,
1.134520173072815,
0.2661720812320709,
0.7799026370048523,
0.43827682733535767,
0.2987576425075531,
-1.4028005599975586,
0.928613007068634,
-0.3734418451786041,
-0.5386327505111694,
-0.6000263094902039,
-0.11633548140525818,
-1.237460732460022,
-0.10800863802433014,
0.11868656426668167,
-0.7862502932548523,
0.2493983507156372,
-0.03365436568856239,
-0.899514377117157,
0.42479178309440613,
-0.6194177269935608,
0.47858577966690063,
-0.547534704208374,
-0.08255307376384735,
0.23509086668491364,
-0.28521528840065,
0.11151529103517532,
-0.03784874454140663,
0.5667815804481506,
-0.38511332869529724,
-0.10087337344884872,
0.4214199483394623,
-0.17601796984672546,
1.2199152708053589,
-0.24178454279899597,
-0.41477471590042114,
0.5390679836273193,
0.1075083538889885,
0.7239510416984558,
-0.004026417154818773,
-0.2945714294910431,
0.19537565112113953,
-0.48227494955062866,
-0.15708906948566437,
-0.4535570740699768,
0.7775830626487732,
-0.5246809720993042,
-0.3372134268283844,
-0.5587683320045471,
-0.49625545740127563,
-0.3383505046367645,
0.07785072922706604,
-0.23554600775241852,
0.4924795627593994,
-0.11945954710245132,
0.24178682267665863,
0.717308521270752,
-0.02914039045572281,
0.7465764284133911,
1.3280004262924194,
-0.1509932577610016,
0.026809802278876305,
1.2285062074661255,
0.29975616931915283,
-0.07397422939538956,
0.3795899450778961,
0.24550436437129974,
-0.3252805471420288,
-0.3804779052734375,
-0.48614659905433655,
0.04516266658902168,
-0.5253971815109253,
-0.44055336713790894,
-0.7611890435218811,
-0.4270589053630829,
-0.510983943939209,
-0.2805044949054718,
-0.2856810390949249,
-0.20284678041934967,
-0.48307427763938904,
-0.13791123032569885,
0.49490833282470703,
0.7722666263580322,
0.018333861604332924,
-0.08113497495651245,
-1.1136962175369263,
0.7509983777999878,
0.9623267650604248,
0.4360245168209076,
0.18684209883213043,
-0.34867140650749207,
-0.38771355152130127,
-0.08207263797521591,
-0.11256571114063263,
-0.534317135810852,
0.23826465010643005,
0.4745821952819824,
0.42314308881759644,
0.4154987931251526,
0.1944248527288437,
0.373811811208725,
-0.6811563968658447,
0.8559210896492004,
0.3070550858974457,
-0.6561013460159302,
0.3918834924697876,
-0.37393996119499207,
0.6725502610206604,
0.29728779196739197,
0.09413380920886993,
-0.3253277838230133,
0.0678691416978836,
-0.23614752292633057,
-0.7739166617393494,
0.6032966375350952,
-0.27498337626457214,
0.2582069933414459,
0.01847127452492714,
-0.05537448823451996,
-0.11295274645090103,
0.18826496601104736,
-0.8798500299453735,
0.14214816689491272,
0.001319746719673276,
-0.40752485394477844,
0.16251273453235626,
-0.0060943118296563625,
-0.10938936471939087,
-0.48194512724876404,
0.3943815231323242,
-0.31490546464920044,
0.2411687970161438,
0.062216561287641525,
-0.1966407150030136,
-0.22635360062122345,
0.47777673602104187,
0.5033994913101196,
0.07036223262548447,
-0.1985556185245514,
0.36485233902931213,
0.38252782821655273,
-0.608823835849762,
0.2687813937664032,
-0.037704914808273315,
-0.26476022601127625,
0.12602822482585907,
0.57277512550354,
0.5703814029693604,
0.09389516711235046,
-0.970090925693512,
0.555696964263916,
0.004769077990204096,
0.07710843533277512,
-0.44586077332496643,
0.2993510067462921,
0.23109586536884308,
0.23720501363277435,
0.3322942852973938,
0.0869736596941948,
0.0502140112221241,
-0.7131688594818115,
0.05399797111749649,
0.5413122177124023,
-0.6505298018455505,
-0.357734739780426,
0.33344537019729614,
0.10057076811790466,
-0.5423189997673035,
0.2718554735183716,
-0.6329847574234009,
-0.4187512695789337,
0.5435673594474792,
0.43494319915771484,
0.8003723621368408,
-0.2703840434551239,
0.20532537996768951,
0.3190210163593292,
-0.09249168634414673,
0.19719858467578888,
0.6586619019508362,
-0.30459293723106384,
-0.9621548056602478,
-0.24115848541259766,
-1.0139405727386475,
-0.10092020779848099,
0.23852655291557312,
-0.21117538213729858,
0.45543554425239563,
-0.5429502129554749,
0.11156003177165985,
-0.05155850946903229,
-0.05674968287348747,
-0.9303205609321594,
0.4021565020084381,
0.7227482199668884,
0.6283629536628723,
-0.8769955039024353,
1.1253358125686646,
0.8298296332359314,
0.14036402106285095,
-0.929850161075592,
0.1640358716249466,
0.09457056224346161,
-0.9362384676933289,
0.8713199496269226,
0.16545788943767548,
-0.4703226387500763,
0.06167047098278999,
-0.5093172788619995,
-0.632162868976593,
1.3307756185531616,
0.16976293921470642,
-0.754664957523346,
0.12984199821949005,
0.28317996859550476,
0.6711669564247131,
-0.4707944095134735,
-0.32111823558807373,
0.31744033098220825,
0.6167379021644592,
0.13749359548091888,
-0.955466091632843,
0.00023523673007730395,
-0.030270185321569443,
-0.23510731756687164,
-0.07761019468307495,
-0.7325904965400696,
0.8835874199867249,
-0.4299813210964203,
-0.13157157599925995,
-0.2043600082397461,
0.27789148688316345,
0.4896753132343292,
0.5891751646995544,
0.5515047907829285,
0.4002470076084137,
0.41881588101387024,
0.2311996966600418,
0.738011360168457,
-0.4778929650783539,
0.476383775472641,
0.9654248952865601,
-0.9308932423591614,
1.1566345691680908,
0.23898638784885406,
-0.34709954261779785,
0.40609657764434814,
0.13140809535980225,
0.034287963062524796,
0.6975643038749695,
0.0575718954205513,
-0.9148415327072144,
-0.34146609902381897,
-0.4221094250679016,
-0.17468209564685822,
0.7666535377502441,
0.7791376709938049,
-0.29458680748939514,
-0.5513983368873596,
0.18633750081062317,
-0.07180438190698624,
-0.10101901739835739,
-0.36761704087257385,
1.053930640220642,
0.17769816517829895,
-0.19784900546073914,
0.6272115111351013,
0.1051880270242691,
0.7712699174880981,
-0.8606553077697754,
-0.16654685139656067,
0.3908270001411438,
0.23685356974601746,
-0.47221875190734863,
-0.6286314725875854,
0.4169712960720062,
0.10669584572315216,
-0.179589182138443,
-0.5334688425064087,
1.2232580184936523,
-0.2569357752799988,
-0.7171423435211182,
0.36741065979003906,
0.46614331007003784,
0.09305299073457718,
-0.032446715980768204,
-0.3965667486190796,
0.15024055540561676,
-0.2839585840702057,
-0.4421581029891968,
0.4439026713371277,
0.48135918378829956,
0.1613319218158722,
0.38714122772216797,
0.8062973618507385,
0.30352288484573364,
-0.02263508178293705,
0.08704043924808502,
0.8492645621299744,
-0.7075855135917664,
-0.5256008505821228,
-0.7863379716873169,
0.4310191869735718,
0.26696011424064636,
-0.03634662553668022,
0.744152307510376,
0.5156489014625549,
0.320191353559494,
-0.3103117346763611,
0.9386621117591858,
-0.0497281551361084,
0.7854312658309937,
-0.3934797942638397,
0.6858986020088196,
-0.5217217803001404,
0.5344684720039368,
0.36370208859443665,
-0.6346752643585205,
-0.39656418561935425,
0.8806970119476318,
-0.43014922738075256,
-0.2166251540184021,
0.31931206583976746,
0.7166486978530884,
-0.2718698978424072,
-0.04225394129753113,
0.7798067331314087,
0.2328319251537323,
0.3294043242931366,
0.6241301894187927,
0.5078020095825195,
-0.3955598771572113,
0.3081006407737732,
0.07921914756298065,
0.052176911383867264,
-0.4522826671600342,
-0.932068407535553,
-0.918854832649231,
-0.23349431157112122,
-0.18353445827960968,
-0.0035350797697901726,
-0.04848203808069229,
1.1192773580551147,
0.7596580386161804,
-1.1470698118209839,
-0.16661149263381958,
-0.1458447128534317,
-0.08527680486440659,
-0.27504733204841614,
-0.2302696406841278,
0.3886396586894989,
0.08139178156852722,
-0.4197525978088379,
0.7020373940467834,
0.5006474852561951,
-0.07356546819210052,
-0.6702771782875061,
-0.27366483211517334,
-0.3779783844947815,
0.15700972080230713,
0.9075893759727478,
0.5634639859199524,
-0.7418938279151917,
-0.36908599734306335,
0.0750281810760498,
-0.42909204959869385,
0.03602217137813568,
0.6355613470077515,
-0.8355711698532104,
0.3833012282848358,
0.6114745140075684,
0.4697449207305908,
0.08940336108207703,
-0.19102412462234497,
0.024857480078935623,
-0.9576051831245422,
0.1578737199306488,
0.3497689962387085,
0.46837693452835083,
0.39940258860588074,
-0.6513015031814575,
0.24078290164470673,
0.16891536116600037,
-0.3891201913356781,
-0.5182331800460815,
0.45992860198020935,
-0.9748093485832214,
-0.2854180335998535,
1.3620800971984863,
-0.2772860825061798,
-0.24458730220794678,
-0.7657739520072937,
-0.40335217118263245,
-0.012415923178195953,
-0.664771556854248,
0.8681343793869019,
0.547100841999054,
-0.46940863132476807,
-0.15005378425121307,
-0.7315290570259094,
0.20458108186721802,
-0.017031202092766762,
-0.6591749787330627,
0.25871431827545166,
0.393559068441391,
0.192765474319458,
0.38774171471595764,
0.816605269908905,
-0.009788049384951591,
0.14872612059116364,
-0.39638975262641907,
-0.11886443942785263,
-0.4390384256839752,
-0.3144417703151703,
-0.31383663415908813,
0.23899121582508087,
0.06680947542190552,
-0.2814556360244751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01231v1 | MIRAI: Evaluating LLM Agents for Event Forecasting | 2024-07-01T12:22:46 | 2024-07-01T12:22:46 | Chenchen Ye, Ziniu Hu, Yihe Deng, Zijie Huang, Mingyu Derek Ma, Yanqiao Zhu, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have empowered LLM agents
to autonomously collect world information, over which to conduct reasoning to
solve complex problems. Given this capability, increasing interests have been
put into employing LLM agents for predicting international events, which can
influence decision-making and shape policy development on an international
scale. Despite such a growing interest, there is a lack of a rigorous benchmark
of LLM agents' forecasting capability and reliability. To address this gap, we
introduce MIRAI, a novel benchmark designed to systematically evaluate LLM
agents as temporal forecasters in the context of international events. Our
benchmark features an agentic environment with tools for accessing an extensive
database of historical, structured events and textual news articles. We refine
the GDELT event database with careful cleaning and parsing to curate a series
of relational prediction tasks with varying forecasting horizons, assessing LLM
agents' abilities from short-term to long-term forecasting. We further
implement APIs to enable LLM agents to utilize different tools via a code-based
interface. In summary, MIRAI comprehensively evaluates the agents' capabilities
in three dimensions: 1) autonomously source and integrate critical information
from large global databases; 2) write codes using domain-specific APIs and
libraries for tool-use; and 3) jointly reason over historical knowledge from
diverse formats and time to accurately predict future events. Through
comprehensive benchmarking, we aim to establish a reliable framework for
assessing the capabilities of LLM agents in forecasting international events,
thereby contributing to the development of more accurate and trustworthy models
for international relation analysis. | [
-0.3259250521659851,
-0.34131360054016113,
0.763215959072113,
0.6354976892471313,
0.09535154700279236,
0.228394016623497,
0.003650320926681161,
-0.5588258504867554,
-0.16673460602760315,
0.06270778179168701,
-0.7147299647331238,
-0.5521502494812012,
-0.38548195362091064,
-0.00658933911472559,
-0.26056402921676636,
0.8906582593917847,
-0.051547735929489136,
0.22734186053276062,
-0.4635877311229706,
-0.08479423820972443,
-0.2968387007713318,
-0.4754151403903961,
-0.8471614718437195,
-0.4739031493663788,
0.4207330346107483,
0.15421918034553528,
0.7707846760749817,
0.3630308508872986,
0.599367082118988,
0.2204115390777588,
0.28027576208114624,
0.4571763575077057,
-0.42134466767311096,
0.26425278186798096,
-0.19207344949245453,
-0.44797518849372864,
-0.8336963653564453,
0.31101858615875244,
0.8916025161743164,
0.4351294934749603,
0.13940848410129547,
0.15694548189640045,
-0.11030547320842743,
0.34178200364112854,
-0.6666537523269653,
0.6183053255081177,
-0.7569105625152588,
-0.04721381887793541,
-0.03580261766910553,
-0.3489772379398346,
-0.3196043074131012,
-0.2315605729818344,
0.03808639571070671,
-0.42047446966171265,
0.041080541908741,
0.24430441856384277,
0.6081901788711548,
0.3233901858329773,
-0.6273162364959717,
0.060127824544906616,
-0.7194840312004089,
0.8154157400131226,
-0.41665729880332947,
0.3053268790245056,
0.31185364723205566,
0.5362595319747925,
-0.37609797716140747,
-0.6954712271690369,
-0.2731642723083496,
-0.5048349499702454,
0.3120429813861847,
0.3696495592594147,
-0.21141955256462097,
-0.29643338918685913,
0.06438838690519333,
0.062187135219573975,
-0.5852572917938232,
0.16683650016784668,
-0.17200203239917755,
0.05802711844444275,
0.8866024017333984,
0.42776089906692505,
0.18241262435913086,
0.19324442744255066,
-0.5871661901473999,
0.10108477622270584,
-0.851040780544281,
-0.09124570339918137,
0.47708651423454285,
0.09023608267307281,
-0.2205594778060913,
0.2789613902568817,
-0.21793951094150543,
0.1529216170310974,
-0.3698839843273163,
-0.20428602397441864,
-0.006585946772247553,
-0.2630370259284973,
0.16964368522167206,
-0.2763242721557617,
0.8480937480926514,
0.8443329334259033,
0.3392862379550934,
-0.5205121636390686,
-0.18902401626110077,
-0.17897509038448334,
0.046990592032670975,
-0.9044487476348877,
0.006863561924546957,
0.2079385668039322,
-0.28884726762771606,
-0.32745304703712463,
0.08259855210781097,
-0.6702787280082703,
-0.5061884522438049,
-0.1592709720134735,
0.32860860228538513,
-0.29122310876846313,
0.12174767255783081,
-0.32100239396095276,
-0.1539505273103714,
0.3007134199142456,
0.33837467432022095,
-0.5392019748687744,
0.3599657714366913,
0.9165533781051636,
0.8330513834953308,
-0.5283882021903992,
-0.6051494479179382,
-0.7644563317298889,
0.10771588236093521,
-0.2810603976249695,
0.8927459120750427,
-0.3928340971469879,
-0.5452377796173096,
-0.10439331829547882,
0.07182873785495758,
-0.03318055346608162,
-0.3221536874771118,
0.47800225019454956,
-0.6534391045570374,
-0.3250889182090759,
0.06693264842033386,
-0.26327991485595703,
-0.09365595877170563,
0.45094189047813416,
-0.5715599656105042,
0.6794283390045166,
-0.17112205922603607,
-0.3267365097999573,
0.5789158940315247,
-0.35111284255981445,
-0.1247410997748375,
-0.13762246072292328,
-0.19232580065727234,
-0.4569675326347351,
-0.24184653162956238,
0.6840301752090454,
0.58753901720047,
-0.6283873915672302,
0.456419438123703,
-0.5696942806243896,
-0.31856417655944824,
0.42981642484664917,
-0.822197675704956,
0.2757132649421692,
0.2053031325340271,
-0.04849811643362045,
0.16051240265369415,
-0.8855211138725281,
-0.05439009889960289,
0.007269725669175386,
-0.003000223310664296,
0.13155165314674377,
0.370129257440567,
0.13045819103717804,
-0.2181428074836731,
0.5081632733345032,
-0.4894897937774658,
0.3505280613899231,
-0.40081074833869934,
0.3136301636695862,
0.7706335186958313,
0.2713733911514282,
0.4062572121620178,
-0.5833611488342285,
0.514146089553833,
-0.16136150062084198,
0.4286067485809326,
-0.3401927351951599,
-0.6014000177383423,
-0.48026251792907715,
-0.21136735379695892,
-0.015120186842978,
0.7044718861579895,
-0.4603167772293091,
0.14165805280208588,
-0.5833420157432556,
-0.7260417342185974,
-0.07581552863121033,
-0.02867993898689747,
0.22862303256988525,
0.04191691800951958,
0.07990728318691254,
0.16496390104293823,
-0.5905378460884094,
-0.7813372015953064,
-0.2704148292541504,
-0.4065397083759308,
-0.08689991384744644,
0.09647448360919952,
0.723735511302948,
-0.3237425684928894,
0.8349695801734924,
0.09692351520061493,
0.00493503175675869,
-0.14825986325740814,
0.2697681188583374,
0.3345644176006317,
0.2424149066209793,
0.4278346598148346,
-0.6223466992378235,
-0.3625100553035736,
0.20579534769058228,
-0.7488179206848145,
-0.1981523633003235,
-0.14092960953712463,
0.25229930877685547,
0.37846431136131287,
0.32602739334106445,
-0.08530434966087341,
0.5307096242904663,
0.4425298869609833,
-0.40305668115615845,
0.3816484808921814,
-0.26352307200431824,
0.29579776525497437,
-0.7489224672317505,
0.17946836352348328,
-0.13082626461982727,
-0.24535608291625977,
-0.3457583785057068,
-0.023729680106043816,
0.04153601825237274,
-0.09654799848794937,
-0.5062593221664429,
1.1229126453399658,
-0.4143904149532318,
-0.2172040194272995,
-0.24037112295627594,
0.06921853870153427,
-0.15763244032859802,
0.23709850013256073,
-0.07272078096866608,
1.0859209299087524,
0.2532227635383606,
-0.45479825139045715,
0.39428287744522095,
-0.007109333295375109,
-0.4933435320854187,
0.5595161318778992,
-0.521999180316925,
0.09868030250072479,
0.04227736219763756,
0.18159697949886322,
-0.6361969113349915,
0.0156328696757555,
-0.05625664070248604,
-0.31932562589645386,
-0.028434427455067635,
-0.3335549235343933,
-0.5563163161277771,
-0.12003204971551895,
-0.26206642389297485,
0.41692665219306946,
0.48712819814682007,
-0.6785222291946411,
0.8133327960968018,
0.2952154278755188,
-0.1795487254858017,
-0.6665055155754089,
-0.38319677114486694,
0.23383350670337677,
-0.08221792429685593,
-0.5644909143447876,
0.28267624974250793,
-0.06645317375659943,
-0.7349887490272522,
-0.13839180767536163,
-0.28414690494537354,
0.07298391312360764,
0.24781234562397003,
0.6390092372894287,
0.3778972029685974,
-0.01671469770371914,
-0.21322865784168243,
-0.2801523506641388,
-0.4797908663749695,
0.18146376311779022,
-0.19919468462467194,
0.25653567910194397,
-0.5322881937026978,
-0.6713681817054749,
-0.3238638937473297,
0.09111077338457108,
0.7259176969528198,
-0.22909094393253326,
0.7022424936294556,
0.6158791780471802,
-0.2332448661327362,
-0.006770703941583633,
-0.8430858254432678,
0.14934299886226654,
-0.3695560395717621,
0.3328692317008972,
-0.5026423931121826,
-0.3744942843914032,
0.804545521736145,
-0.05659831687808037,
0.061579834669828415,
0.5328009128570557,
0.594679057598114,
0.20963604748249054,
1.3285776376724243,
0.49338266253471375,
-0.4044272303581238,
0.161984384059906,
-0.40445345640182495,
-0.1051541343331337,
-0.696868896484375,
-0.45424744486808777,
-0.3856012225151062,
-0.081688292324543,
-0.5052977800369263,
-0.564822793006897,
0.6254525184631348,
-0.14715367555618286,
-0.3866717219352722,
-0.17000660300254822,
0.13426265120506287,
0.6515471339225769,
0.3695531487464905,
-0.27581846714019775,
0.4715289771556854,
-0.3018830716609955,
0.36000293493270874,
0.12129276245832443,
-0.3156246244907379,
-0.8105964064598083,
1.1848855018615723,
0.44405966997146606,
0.9637322425842285,
-0.2643492817878723,
0.4612792134284973,
0.40437769889831543,
0.5816658735275269,
-0.5577409267425537,
0.4938558340072632,
0.08843386918306351,
-0.25081247091293335,
-0.10660111159086227,
-0.17013148963451385,
-0.789993166923523,
0.24803905189037323,
-0.08569086343050003,
-0.9513710141181946,
0.36666348576545715,
-0.4780191481113434,
-0.1760532259941101,
0.4465116858482361,
-0.14846466481685638,
0.6870964765548706,
-0.24813656508922577,
-0.37765979766845703,
-0.39735808968544006,
-0.3399302363395691,
-0.0242423377931118,
-0.03517784923315048,
0.3183194398880005,
-0.8700770735740662,
-0.6136569976806641,
0.6023772358894348,
-0.2655949294567108,
0.6834741234779358,
0.07820722460746765,
0.044427696615457535,
0.1874387264251709,
0.12997561693191528,
0.6231990456581116,
0.45065417885780334,
-0.7439220547676086,
0.4109508693218231,
0.5013493299484253,
-0.31391724944114685,
-0.617709755897522,
0.8655639886856079,
-1.1535660028457642,
-0.49943622946739197,
-0.43771323561668396,
-0.7040735483169556,
-0.4493098556995392,
-0.12741130590438843,
-0.08753153681755066,
0.4940084218978882,
-0.8726181387901306,
-0.00922743882983923,
0.02964727021753788,
0.31677427887916565,
0.5235849022865295,
0.9584705829620361,
-0.3860667645931244,
-0.47834470868110657,
0.9059100151062012,
0.07876575738191605,
-0.1376742571592331,
0.5566532015800476,
-0.0836295634508133,
-0.24803265929222107,
-0.7185338139533997,
-0.24785538017749786,
0.05215996876358986,
-0.7742573022842407,
-0.2270597219467163,
-0.4663841426372528,
-0.34243541955947876,
-0.11986665427684784,
-0.19539086520671844,
-0.29477354884147644,
-0.2780858874320984,
-0.09381584078073502,
0.08341369777917862,
0.19845476746559143,
0.7646697759628296,
-0.09133212268352509,
0.2545543611049652,
-0.720450758934021,
0.09307371079921722,
0.1059601679444313,
0.2741461396217346,
-0.1438276618719101,
-0.22918163239955902,
-0.1624995321035385,
-0.15441812574863434,
-0.40714168548583984,
-0.8124740123748779,
0.6823431253433228,
0.21765011548995972,
0.7920371294021606,
0.3996690511703491,
0.15456059575080872,
0.5754357576370239,
-0.5389229655265808,
0.76715087890625,
-0.2786800265312195,
-0.790847897529602,
0.7938454151153564,
-0.4682483375072479,
0.1574288010597229,
0.32754844427108765,
0.40611645579338074,
-0.29874372482299805,
-0.6445155739784241,
-0.6408882141113281,
-0.8406959176063538,
0.6196399927139282,
0.05374247953295708,
-0.1914685070514679,
-0.17406685650348663,
0.2952009439468384,
0.2969520092010498,
0.09415607899427414,
-0.5038515329360962,
-0.07846151292324066,
0.2391907274723053,
0.11403527110815048,
-0.4221545159816742,
-0.4026201069355011,
-0.05816401168704033,
0.0029367164243012667,
0.879230797290802,
-0.26936614513397217,
0.01158010121434927,
0.11803729832172394,
0.026770107448101044,
-0.009382721036672592,
0.16933061182498932,
0.27342352271080017,
1.1645176410675049,
-0.4997723698616028,
-0.08432332426309586,
0.7140606641769409,
-0.24613310396671295,
0.05270114541053772,
0.3655509948730469,
0.029247067868709564,
-0.2504718005657196,
0.6435953378677368,
0.64068603515625,
0.16428740322589874,
-0.8807121515274048,
0.6190673112869263,
-0.2963438928127289,
0.08012685924768448,
-0.6286110281944275,
0.011172570288181305,
-0.299717515707016,
0.7271310091018677,
0.48141834139823914,
0.013895932585000992,
0.06873387843370438,
-0.6278815269470215,
0.07092006504535675,
0.5457401275634766,
-0.4191228151321411,
-0.3096376955509186,
1.048897385597229,
0.3072623014450073,
-0.2647961676120758,
0.6766826510429382,
-0.1290581077337265,
-0.18190732598304749,
0.9132059812545776,
0.4240338206291199,
0.9186905026435852,
0.05311214551329613,
-0.01677142269909382,
0.1413804292678833,
0.31271296739578247,
0.16683486104011536,
0.27823907136917114,
0.08748985826969147,
-0.6241310238838196,
-0.5125501751899719,
-0.6436468362808228,
-0.7978503108024597,
0.06422151625156403,
-0.498046338558197,
0.12271138280630112,
-0.33938488364219666,
-0.28306740522384644,
-0.21723626554012299,
0.4733116626739502,
-0.9197015166282654,
-0.09843062609434128,
0.28650039434432983,
1.101992130279541,
-0.6334183812141418,
0.755407989025116,
0.609224259853363,
-0.32886913418769836,
-0.11522132158279419,
0.047040704637765884,
0.18681544065475464,
-1.0512416362762451,
0.7092003226280212,
0.24226014316082,
-0.1042998731136322,
-0.2875833809375763,
-0.2817428708076477,
-0.9028385877609253,
1.2847577333450317,
0.20046405494213104,
-0.3796677589416504,
0.1345290094614029,
0.016119003295898438,
0.4960254728794098,
-0.5884873270988464,
0.6766922473907471,
0.6495147943496704,
0.6246379017829895,
0.09349308907985687,
-0.9776266813278198,
-0.07618837058544159,
-0.437410444021225,
0.1146305650472641,
0.014605803415179253,
-0.6646090745925903,
0.48438459634780884,
-0.24848897755146027,
-0.23614659905433655,
0.6456648111343384,
0.988946259021759,
0.12761826813220978,
0.7596936225891113,
0.2506192624568939,
0.05391409993171692,
0.7115124464035034,
-0.34609296917915344,
1.2738795280456543,
-0.6321737170219421,
-0.06980305165052414,
0.8637241721153259,
-0.4838885962963104,
0.8982013463973999,
0.15930786728858948,
-0.2640959322452545,
0.37100934982299805,
0.36986130475997925,
-0.3479776978492737,
0.3885541558265686,
-0.09085153043270111,
-0.37425142526626587,
-0.3481700122356415,
-0.16578777134418488,
-0.2639218866825104,
0.3977377712726593,
0.3727242648601532,
0.13778629899024963,
-0.2765919864177704,
0.11679615080356598,
0.006512945052236319,
0.07572653889656067,
-0.5081888437271118,
0.6694901585578918,
-0.00486376415938139,
-0.6572808623313904,
0.18236233294010162,
-0.0027383514679968357,
0.37576907873153687,
-0.5147367715835571,
0.061042122542858124,
-0.16716356575489044,
0.44475629925727844,
0.08759628981351852,
-0.8507179617881775,
0.35086730122566223,
-0.052019376307725906,
-0.201865553855896,
-0.2835245132446289,
0.4981183707714081,
0.07412128895521164,
-0.5685316920280457,
0.2920263409614563,
0.7742010354995728,
0.26170027256011963,
-0.021588673815131187,
-0.44440093636512756,
0.29523247480392456,
-0.4485657215118408,
-0.21103329956531525,
0.30962955951690674,
0.2631568908691406,
-0.22310693562030792,
1.216081142425537,
0.5202146768569946,
0.24909746646881104,
-0.3831225633621216,
0.2094838172197342,
0.4531293511390686,
-0.5730792880058289,
-0.2222731113433838,
-0.9827628135681152,
0.39356228709220886,
0.0012449370697140694,
-0.11259867250919342,
0.6905611157417297,
0.7475295662879944,
0.4275425374507904,
0.06990999728441238,
0.6503539681434631,
0.39639416337013245,
0.2792489230632782,
-0.39912912249565125,
0.7012593746185303,
-0.394780695438385,
0.4985079765319824,
0.22144177556037903,
-0.784095048904419,
-0.27048259973526,
0.12524639070034027,
-0.6713686585426331,
-0.0744696855545044,
0.3752453029155731,
0.7949914336204529,
0.291727751493454,
0.05762574076652527,
0.40003374218940735,
0.11502619087696075,
0.5042933225631714,
0.29655933380126953,
1.2897833585739136,
-0.29096612334251404,
0.5540858507156372,
-0.1917535960674286,
-0.1689760982990265,
-0.17029424011707306,
-1.0456819534301758,
-1.0785386562347412,
-0.6605621576309204,
-0.3054024279117584,
-0.04523294419050217,
0.632236897945404,
1.046203851699829,
0.6485137343406677,
-0.7654817700386047,
-0.36186984181404114,
0.28866514563560486,
0.3579423129558563,
-0.20056979358196259,
-0.22438187897205353,
0.449813574552536,
-0.46652093529701233,
-1.0284100770950317,
0.7805314660072327,
0.43593746423721313,
0.0006520324386656284,
-0.36901557445526123,
-0.016895335167646408,
0.2595531940460205,
0.15971039235591888,
0.4749886691570282,
0.2114277333021164,
-0.7448797225952148,
-0.23517130315303802,
-0.34636950492858887,
0.05108865723013878,
-0.22570651769638062,
0.45797479152679443,
-0.9330729246139526,
0.19440947473049164,
0.37697070837020874,
0.2542925179004669,
0.49668800830841064,
-0.23694515228271484,
0.7933087944984436,
-0.5996052026748657,
0.1758372187614441,
0.21945013105869293,
0.5143394470214844,
-0.007310634944587946,
-0.16077885031700134,
0.894307553768158,
-0.04047028347849846,
-0.8793546557426453,
-0.8238469958305359,
-0.1854127049446106,
-0.8047810792922974,
0.027732495218515396,
1.0212740898132324,
-0.09331507980823517,
-0.3363610506057739,
0.01018555834889412,
-0.14284713566303253,
-0.11620908975601196,
-0.30616551637649536,
0.4849011301994324,
0.3877474069595337,
-0.19371873140335083,
-0.019849320873618126,
-0.8102100491523743,
0.254121869802475,
-0.21035946905612946,
-0.68315190076828,
-0.1170785054564476,
0.2653392255306244,
0.2038605958223343,
-0.14678703248500824,
0.6973270773887634,
-0.04754599928855896,
0.3157395124435425,
0.1063351109623909,
-0.0037380473222583532,
-0.26831021904945374,
-0.6165500283241272,
-0.13442789018154144,
0.06911219656467438,
0.17946204543113708,
0.07882189750671387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01219v1 | Searching for Best Practices in Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-07-01T12:06:34 | 2024-07-01T12:06:34 | Xiaohua Wang, Zhenghua Wang, Xuan Gao, Feiran Zhang, Yixin Wu, Zhibo Xu, Tianyuan Shi, Zhengyuan Wang, Shizheng Li, Qi Qian, Ruicheng Yin, Changze Lv, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) techniques have proven to be effective
in integrating up-to-date information, mitigating hallucinations, and enhancing
response quality, particularly in specialized domains. While many RAG
approaches have been proposed to enhance large language models through
query-dependent retrievals, these approaches still suffer from their complex
implementation and prolonged response times. Typically, a RAG workflow involves
multiple processing steps, each of which can be executed in various ways. Here,
we investigate existing RAG approaches and their potential combinations to
identify optimal RAG practices. Through extensive experiments, we suggest
several strategies for deploying RAG that balance both performance and
efficiency. Moreover, we demonstrate that multimodal retrieval techniques can
significantly enhance question-answering capabilities about visual inputs and
accelerate the generation of multimodal content using a "retrieval as
generation" strategy. | [
-0.8639160990715027,
-0.8710249066352844,
0.43566757440567017,
0.2696602940559387,
-0.28818225860595703,
0.5184295773506165,
-0.10261557251214981,
-0.47904932498931885,
0.31354790925979614,
0.6408920288085938,
-0.2198808193206787,
0.13077867031097412,
-0.3405248522758484,
0.20852269232273102,
-0.149875208735466,
0.7617618441581726,
0.013344001024961472,
-0.04312608763575554,
-0.35962167382240295,
-0.3106330633163452,
-0.7016858458518982,
-0.4140583872795105,
-0.7217589020729065,
-0.17751027643680573,
0.6393228769302368,
0.3664867877960205,
0.7262759208679199,
0.46905389428138733,
0.813837468624115,
0.2079751342535019,
-0.19847527146339417,
0.9219738245010376,
-0.5614373683929443,
0.5815771222114563,
-0.4073694348335266,
-0.12445486336946487,
-0.3285897672176361,
-0.20725730061531067,
0.5328871011734009,
0.5626084208488464,
-0.3625112473964691,
0.4393666386604309,
-0.08805243670940399,
0.6234565377235413,
-1.1239268779754639,
-0.42822813987731934,
-0.5024389028549194,
-0.010482370853424072,
-0.23515768349170685,
-0.8346407413482666,
-0.57924485206604,
-0.3107124865055084,
-0.027584930881857872,
-0.6317101120948792,
0.3034799098968506,
0.2525380849838257,
0.7116073369979858,
0.07769494503736496,
-0.5762420892715454,
-0.31882190704345703,
-0.834591269493103,
0.7951303720474243,
-0.3142545223236084,
0.505169689655304,
0.5142231583595276,
0.5425453782081604,
-0.24295637011528015,
-0.8802195191383362,
-0.47639894485473633,
-0.12694776058197021,
-0.1821083128452301,
0.3001430928707123,
0.018995875492691994,
-0.15356451272964478,
0.4367360770702362,
0.3365536034107208,
-0.6325688362121582,
-0.40348368883132935,
-0.23285318911075592,
0.04272561892867088,
0.512658953666687,
0.12186362594366074,
0.14235010743141174,
-0.5651560425758362,
-0.4199540615081787,
-0.28543946146965027,
-0.47801071405410767,
-0.05686518922448158,
0.14912860095500946,
0.1898268163204193,
0.6211888790130615,
0.7925673723220825,
-0.2705065608024597,
0.8322769403457642,
0.038122162222862244,
-0.3024977445602417,
0.13194024562835693,
-0.623492956161499,
0.069398432970047,
-0.5755394697189331,
0.22538639605045319,
0.3648923933506012,
-0.1460529863834381,
-0.24405233561992645,
-0.5472046136856079,
-0.12854760885238647,
0.7430095672607422,
-0.6268817782402039,
0.07255464047193527,
-0.1387651562690735,
-0.4611548185348511,
-0.27741703391075134,
-0.20548130571842194,
-1.0377793312072754,
-0.4837886095046997,
-0.4580688178539276,
0.7832170724868774,
-0.44452962279319763,
-0.4697134792804718,
-0.275469034910202,
-0.5243200063705444,
0.2955643832683563,
0.3033173680305481,
-0.6978762745857239,
0.4029059112071991,
0.440593421459198,
0.5876072645187378,
-0.21706752479076385,
0.20382049679756165,
-0.9306482672691345,
0.3017862141132355,
-0.6763465404510498,
1.0504297018051147,
-0.6991329193115234,
-0.493585467338562,
-0.017291679978370667,
-0.3462080657482147,
-0.005827801302075386,
-0.7954683899879456,
0.454525887966156,
-1.043099045753479,
0.20491686463356018,
-0.40588533878326416,
-0.26276224851608276,
-0.1658903807401657,
0.20265740156173706,
-0.6725008487701416,
1.1335511207580566,
0.06957007199525833,
-0.7032833695411682,
0.2614421248435974,
-0.7162179946899414,
-0.5430585145950317,
0.14325936138629913,
-0.025191638618707657,
-0.10503241419792175,
0.4820711314678192,
0.3560832142829895,
0.39378246665000916,
-0.35126644372940063,
-0.1722554862499237,
0.14713504910469055,
-0.17907771468162537,
0.12504996359348297,
-0.2314271330833435,
0.4304291009902954,
0.6549472212791443,
-0.15588605403900146,
-0.2320532649755478,
-0.6557129621505737,
0.21357207000255585,
0.31689128279685974,
-0.2892390191555023,
-0.5269749760627747,
-0.03519032523036003,
0.09523763507604599,
-0.11108055710792542,
0.021355580538511276,
-0.3278307616710663,
0.06739018112421036,
-0.14756529033184052,
-0.06174454092979431,
0.4707094132900238,
0.3990556597709656,
0.5124103426933289,
-0.5978057384490967,
0.698815107345581,
-0.14894483983516693,
0.19018490612506866,
-0.3940090239048004,
-0.2125813513994217,
-0.6532678008079529,
-0.08111872524023056,
0.16670948266983032,
0.44805827736854553,
-1.4892137050628662,
-0.4961516857147217,
0.09997193515300751,
-0.49590879678726196,
-0.44883617758750916,
0.1496160626411438,
0.6162506341934204,
0.7360895276069641,
0.58646559715271,
-0.46518296003341675,
-0.5407416820526123,
-0.7460506558418274,
-0.3137297034263611,
0.022769581526517868,
0.36307385563850403,
0.6630736589431763,
0.17914758622646332,
-0.16918814182281494,
0.7167124152183533,
-0.5952605605125427,
0.1441950500011444,
-0.09945346415042877,
0.5154698491096497,
0.01923833228647709,
0.19009210169315338,
0.5078186988830566,
-1.3911949396133423,
-0.4682505428791046,
0.00418092543259263,
-0.6299610733985901,
0.022344546392560005,
-0.05281231552362442,
-0.38327860832214355,
0.4830509424209595,
0.2828480899333954,
-0.4477293789386749,
0.3595705032348633,
0.34697315096855164,
-0.08134324103593826,
0.6452118754386902,
-0.2014370858669281,
0.5950401425361633,
-1.071848750114441,
0.08458437025547028,
-0.18085554242134094,
-0.4267294406890869,
-0.7737686634063721,
0.5700841546058655,
0.05386034771800041,
-0.017451411113142967,
-0.31478580832481384,
0.6399272680282593,
-0.8194805383682251,
-0.2637087404727936,
-0.3623870611190796,
0.1710534542798996,
0.23839931190013885,
0.21524369716644287,
-0.14568671584129333,
1.2064353227615356,
0.3034115135669708,
-0.7546392679214478,
0.27922725677490234,
0.17890340089797974,
0.0017232800601050258,
0.6795822978019714,
-0.4313102066516876,
0.4118085205554962,
-0.6054431796073914,
-0.006517285481095314,
-1.0439343452453613,
-0.45165467262268066,
-0.1184147521853447,
-0.6055564284324646,
0.7966750264167786,
-0.11892061680555344,
-0.6412032246589661,
-0.3066452741622925,
-0.4749494791030884,
0.5808336734771729,
0.6176442503929138,
-0.7520963549613953,
0.8938222527503967,
0.5375590920448303,
-0.19103853404521942,
-0.8888825178146362,
-0.31706809997558594,
0.18559293448925018,
-0.14582538604736328,
-0.6021924018859863,
0.3831111192703247,
-0.09407613426446915,
-0.11909044533967972,
-0.10121196508407593,
-0.14549142122268677,
0.020672990009188652,
-0.10345526784658432,
-0.2870829403400421,
0.17438803613185883,
-0.0520792230963707,
0.012966419570147991,
-0.06830599904060364,
0.08618088811635971,
-0.42046892642974854,
0.11482010781764984,
0.6479052901268005,
0.22352156043052673,
-0.1630767285823822,
0.1710556447505951,
0.7372595071792603,
0.43972331285476685,
-0.7352027297019958,
0.4675373136997223,
0.6978142261505127,
-0.22259028255939484,
-0.3197721242904663,
-1.0621613264083862,
-0.21746499836444855,
-0.4889060854911804,
0.13404738903045654,
-0.5259324908256531,
-0.5408679246902466,
0.36833152174949646,
-0.27782928943634033,
0.2075747400522232,
0.09680447727441788,
0.5541958212852478,
-0.43820226192474365,
1.2728859186172485,
0.5773332715034485,
0.6746723651885986,
0.5600607991218567,
-0.32896938920021057,
0.13932980597019196,
-1.1858097314834595,
-0.3247514069080353,
-0.3744339644908905,
0.0012951011303812265,
-0.614540159702301,
-0.9591135382652283,
0.6664021015167236,
0.3244825303554535,
0.0595923475921154,
0.3003087639808655,
-0.621240496635437,
0.38595521450042725,
0.6213191151618958,
0.16517087817192078,
0.3287578225135803,
0.2742544114589691,
-0.15874499082565308,
0.047325607389211655,
-0.8846306204795837,
-0.4309307336807251,
0.9499847888946533,
-0.09556745737791061,
0.8938120007514954,
0.25327014923095703,
0.8091272115707397,
0.03356647863984108,
0.1853032112121582,
-0.4582256078720093,
0.5408310890197754,
-0.3358147144317627,
-0.5660157203674316,
-0.16724622249603271,
-0.5473924875259399,
-1.0841054916381836,
0.35988977551460266,
-0.34104856848716736,
-0.26130399107933044,
0.15014012157917023,
0.30583471059799194,
-0.14423783123493195,
0.06510164588689804,
-0.687760055065155,
0.35596582293510437,
-0.16528284549713135,
-0.589163064956665,
-0.2319827377796173,
-0.515622079372406,
0.2639259994029999,
-0.05545002594590187,
0.25871211290359497,
0.35364261269569397,
-0.15824729204177856,
0.36819887161254883,
0.07428287714719772,
0.13651971518993378,
-0.25319957733154297,
0.23872347176074982,
0.49173420667648315,
0.17227287590503693,
0.4651124179363251,
-0.1291871964931488,
0.20876938104629517,
-0.5170706510543823,
0.0049998885951936245,
-0.37810665369033813,
-0.8668698072433472,
0.5133284330368042,
-0.4295746088027954,
-0.5629790425300598,
-0.3036460280418396,
-0.6060444116592407,
-0.46746692061424255,
0.16141562163829803,
0.1893424391746521,
0.7196523547172546,
0.03512142598628998,
0.24285227060317993,
0.9152947664260864,
-0.38592565059661865,
0.4643222391605377,
0.18460233509540558,
-0.44905227422714233,
-0.6324213147163391,
1.1346218585968018,
0.32777509093284607,
0.44507288932800293,
0.31116563081741333,
0.08424084633588791,
-0.4410257339477539,
-0.44858357310295105,
-0.4633798897266388,
0.34206992387771606,
-0.6488388776779175,
-0.4718334376811981,
-0.697803258895874,
-0.007505566813051701,
-0.5926308631896973,
0.035792652517557144,
-0.22217035293579102,
-0.5510199069976807,
0.06725110113620758,
0.17214258015155792,
0.37868449091911316,
0.47218960523605347,
-0.18021738529205322,
-0.12677492201328278,
-0.8270809650421143,
0.9470950365066528,
0.5130109190940857,
0.30891796946525574,
0.0627681240439415,
-0.252841591835022,
-0.15276876091957092,
-0.05099573731422424,
-0.4350817799568176,
-0.8619680404663086,
0.24760526418685913,
0.22269529104232788,
0.8649371862411499,
-0.14701062440872192,
0.09074780344963074,
0.9231526255607605,
-0.6922277808189392,
0.6443712711334229,
0.014629503712058067,
-0.3753162622451782,
0.7156180739402771,
-0.3764161169528961,
0.13422834873199463,
0.42103704810142517,
0.48079729080200195,
-0.4413265585899353,
-0.30516698956489563,
-0.42059940099716187,
-1.0149269104003906,
0.33236292004585266,
0.27583152055740356,
0.36092114448547363,
-0.14183388650417328,
0.30463534593582153,
-0.022243060171604156,
0.34999769926071167,
-0.11780636757612228,
-0.07678544521331787,
-0.09889116883277893,
0.1136709675192833,
0.20108942687511444,
-0.2771645486354828,
-0.31855982542037964,
0.042547643184661865,
0.5434110164642334,
-0.1937340795993805,
0.35963907837867737,
0.25575846433639526,
-0.21710450947284698,
-0.1300535500049591,
0.11573119461536407,
0.6281216144561768,
1.0347331762313843,
0.02249659039080143,
0.15108413994312286,
0.06063845008611679,
-0.4127069115638733,
0.04956717789173126,
-0.0033198671881109476,
-0.24928811192512512,
0.06643731892108917,
0.1029190868139267,
0.5970435738563538,
-0.0653468668460846,
-0.7192865610122681,
0.2945309281349182,
-0.09001786261796951,
0.0742318406701088,
-0.24413788318634033,
0.23790617287158966,
-0.1318253129720688,
0.4466582238674164,
0.5874772071838379,
0.013663001358509064,
0.4174892008304596,
-0.7535606026649475,
0.3609480559825897,
0.5272780656814575,
0.22709962725639343,
0.13274423778057098,
0.5837039947509766,
-0.1035299226641655,
-0.3766167163848877,
0.3834179639816284,
-0.24013963341712952,
-0.3345416784286499,
0.30806654691696167,
0.6274264454841614,
0.6300297975540161,
-0.20700952410697937,
0.37653517723083496,
0.38676637411117554,
0.03417788818478584,
-0.17748810350894928,
0.6412152051925659,
-0.22523225843906403,
-0.4559441804885864,
-0.7018219232559204,
-0.6792871952056885,
-0.3906857669353485,
-0.39644619822502136,
-0.9419832825660706,
0.04690462350845337,
-0.11595593392848969,
-0.5276331305503845,
0.020081350579857826,
-0.05194064602255821,
-0.6286905407905579,
0.1738969385623932,
0.10258280485868454,
0.8407189249992371,
-0.22397421300411224,
0.223202183842659,
1.0318485498428345,
-0.6048688292503357,
-0.7503209710121155,
-0.1893058717250824,
-0.22880275547504425,
-0.6218582987785339,
0.6313552856445312,
-0.2984742522239685,
-0.3842466175556183,
0.03153175860643387,
-0.4266573488712311,
-0.8803286552429199,
1.032114863395691,
0.04774066433310509,
-0.05249122157692909,
-0.11817926913499832,
-0.16536636650562286,
0.6286180019378662,
-0.08285674452781677,
0.33235999941825867,
0.4115932881832123,
0.359450101852417,
0.46306300163269043,
-0.8567990064620972,
-0.19879145920276642,
-0.25805196166038513,
0.42337721586227417,
0.38804736733436584,
-0.6542239189147949,
0.5893495678901672,
-0.1425725668668747,
-0.24729473888874054,
0.12288563698530197,
0.5524413585662842,
0.580986499786377,
0.5463892221450806,
0.5614066123962402,
0.6902655959129333,
0.6203067898750305,
0.10039928555488586,
1.1974852085113525,
-0.09716857224702835,
0.17450346052646637,
0.8110898733139038,
0.013747092336416245,
0.9829363226890564,
0.6250296235084534,
0.2405524104833603,
0.2867114245891571,
0.4036312401294708,
0.18011459708213806,
0.6959815621376038,
-0.09239277988672256,
-0.3203679025173187,
-0.09752733260393143,
-0.5473145842552185,
-0.1033535972237587,
0.36716070771217346,
0.31537073850631714,
-0.17262159287929535,
-0.17771486937999725,
0.44550666213035583,
0.02823881059885025,
0.24516311287879944,
-0.24482190608978271,
1.0698908567428589,
-0.18596234917640686,
-1.0839327573776245,
0.6853659749031067,
-0.2827431857585907,
0.4854968786239624,
-0.3072676360607147,
-0.443674236536026,
-0.5864954590797424,
-0.2202947735786438,
-0.17485198378562927,
-0.7102985978126526,
0.2036932408809662,
0.2026127576828003,
-0.36093997955322266,
-0.5370935797691345,
0.9252734184265137,
-0.30984750390052795,
-0.36926501989364624,
0.157794788479805,
0.7110698223114014,
-0.022783616557717323,
0.11961079388856888,
-0.4132079780101776,
0.009225815534591675,
-0.30003246665000916,
-0.4057708978652954,
0.3888559639453888,
0.5651935935020447,
-0.12429659813642502,
0.4895786643028259,
0.7052842974662781,
0.15684427320957184,
0.44606849551200867,
0.11085166037082672,
1.0308750867843628,
-0.5174813270568848,
-0.024948248639702797,
-0.24113301932811737,
0.6542890667915344,
-0.3988237679004669,
-0.07761933654546738,
0.7435169816017151,
0.4543173611164093,
0.847623348236084,
0.13135986030101776,
0.4224446415901184,
-0.16541914641857147,
0.8970188498497009,
-0.4650402367115021,
0.3867225646972656,
-0.9808885455131531,
0.07237566262483597,
-0.4548361301422119,
-1.1382921934127808,
-0.255262166261673,
0.6432045698165894,
0.2019948661327362,
0.23320932686328888,
0.570808470249176,
1.0542564392089844,
-0.03609597310423851,
-0.16333408653736115,
0.29172343015670776,
-0.1284974217414856,
0.5317812561988831,
0.07921275496482849,
0.9713547229766846,
-0.34681636095046997,
0.5570110082626343,
-0.45099467039108276,
-0.36559098958969116,
-0.2122810035943985,
-0.6559139490127563,
-0.6224234104156494,
-0.703210711479187,
0.053300242871046066,
-0.265671968460083,
0.19682367146015167,
0.711517333984375,
0.8140372633934021,
-0.2941654324531555,
-0.10861751437187195,
0.2256135642528534,
-0.1971307396888733,
-0.2394612729549408,
-0.22993139922618866,
0.14764133095741272,
-0.9100555181503296,
-0.6091693043708801,
0.4255085587501526,
0.2768062949180603,
-0.12305125594139099,
-0.20174334943294525,
0.16883425414562225,
-0.39440369606018066,
0.2758590877056122,
1.0266460180282593,
0.2458455115556717,
-0.5162739753723145,
-0.20999406278133392,
0.5524138808250427,
-0.1415029764175415,
0.03190537914633751,
0.9755952954292297,
-0.7591005563735962,
0.9478002786636353,
0.8516034483909607,
1.0074230432510376,
0.7824512720108032,
0.5292166471481323,
0.5093796849250793,
-0.8007441163063049,
-0.22292768955230713,
0.7277789115905762,
-0.061052270233631134,
0.33503860235214233,
-0.24808970093727112,
0.7435778379440308,
0.0067566679790616035,
-0.7640580534934998,
-1.0372164249420166,
0.28668802976608276,
-0.8384783267974854,
-0.2797544598579407,
1.0840437412261963,
0.3066282272338867,
-0.053767599165439606,
-0.0391201414167881,
-0.43505585193634033,
0.24063006043434143,
-0.11527504771947861,
0.6381517648696899,
0.4073483645915985,
-0.654961347579956,
-0.4163094758987427,
-1.002811312675476,
0.4119880795478821,
0.42904821038246155,
-0.7142893075942993,
-0.15400241315364838,
0.5916409492492676,
-0.1611359566450119,
0.5647262334823608,
0.5813092589378357,
-0.2134874165058136,
0.46505627036094666,
-0.09063028544187546,
-0.33557552099227905,
-0.04045815020799637,
-0.6290096044540405,
0.11337527632713318,
0.304514080286026,
0.004956303164362907,
-0.04269738867878914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01212v1 | EconNLI: Evaluating Large Language Models on Economics Reasoning | 2024-07-01T11:58:24 | 2024-07-01T11:58:24 | Yue Guo, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used for writing economic analysis
reports or providing financial advice, but their ability to understand economic
knowledge and reason about potential results of specific economic events lacks
systematic evaluation. To address this gap, we propose a new dataset, natural
language inference on economic events (EconNLI), to evaluate LLMs' knowledge
and reasoning abilities in the economic domain. We evaluate LLMs on (1) their
ability to correctly classify whether a premise event will cause a hypothesis
event and (2) their ability to generate reasonable events resulting from a
given premise. Our experiments reveal that LLMs are not sophisticated in
economic reasoning and may generate wrong or hallucinated answers. Our study
raises awareness of the limitations of using LLMs for critical decision-making
involving economic reasoning and analysis. The dataset and codes are available
at https://github.com/Irenehere/EconNLI. | [
-0.218889981508255,
-0.9696244597434998,
0.7673277258872986,
0.3048996329307556,
-0.06031831353902817,
-0.345256507396698,
-0.6169623732566833,
-0.5714762210845947,
0.07102953642606735,
0.6341024041175842,
-0.4777953028678894,
-0.3985496163368225,
-0.22458790242671967,
0.38591086864471436,
-0.33066990971565247,
0.7879905104637146,
0.39148226380348206,
0.005551162175834179,
-0.37354472279548645,
0.17302797734737396,
0.15622766315937042,
-0.36407703161239624,
-1.106285810470581,
-0.35361912846565247,
0.57845139503479,
0.505936861038208,
0.4576747417449951,
0.2652505934238434,
0.48643577098846436,
0.33455249667167664,
-0.0606609582901001,
0.25425252318382263,
-0.5149505734443665,
0.017734182998538017,
-0.2394304871559143,
-0.3639843761920929,
-0.4752836525440216,
-0.12272578477859497,
0.5463474988937378,
0.7172120809555054,
-0.19213981926441193,
0.48168009519577026,
-0.015864450484514236,
0.630926251411438,
-0.5186469554901123,
0.45114666223526,
-0.7319815158843994,
-0.06228310614824295,
0.07112670689821243,
-0.2378704845905304,
-0.7010424733161926,
-0.4922758936882019,
0.48685508966445923,
-0.6117452383041382,
-0.1348794400691986,
0.4312760829925537,
0.6233253479003906,
0.1333540976047516,
-0.486825555562973,
-0.3949338495731354,
-0.5252470970153809,
0.9325240850448608,
-0.8806394934654236,
0.3547550141811371,
0.32043221592903137,
0.2215202897787094,
-0.27523964643478394,
-0.7756282687187195,
-0.6172366142272949,
-0.25323790311813354,
0.04610015079379082,
0.23054499924182892,
-0.40389835834503174,
0.15079738199710846,
0.5789831280708313,
0.1452820748090744,
-0.5160873532295227,
0.24927188456058502,
-0.2086227387189865,
-0.007030255626887083,
0.7992311716079712,
0.2818337678909302,
0.12997697293758392,
-0.3493805229663849,
-0.297954797744751,
-0.07704238593578339,
-0.6223433613777161,
-0.17170953750610352,
0.7402994632720947,
0.28100526332855225,
-0.02138356678187847,
0.6683507561683655,
-0.2699732482433319,
0.7894147634506226,
-0.31834331154823303,
-0.3676466643810272,
0.09316357970237732,
-0.0785600021481514,
-0.7078923583030701,
0.1970306634902954,
0.5819880962371826,
0.6735217571258545,
0.5298839807510376,
0.05109633132815361,
-0.29321274161338806,
-0.3584112524986267,
-0.29468879103660583,
-0.6367855668067932,
-0.037408795207738876,
0.17297303676605225,
-0.6146367788314819,
-0.29447945952415466,
-0.054585374891757965,
-1.211294174194336,
-0.4090096354484558,
-0.4797198474407196,
0.3297364115715027,
0.07441265881061554,
-0.08060485869646072,
0.3324744701385498,
-0.3880707621574402,
0.3590248227119446,
0.2010565996170044,
-0.6531730890274048,
0.37763920426368713,
0.6767075061798096,
0.5149632096290588,
0.2274438440799713,
-0.17633306980133057,
-0.5803948640823364,
0.07204993069171906,
-0.25228819251060486,
0.9893007874488831,
-0.39784255623817444,
-0.10451806336641312,
0.16534943878650665,
0.07862003147602081,
-0.20080524682998657,
-0.5311881303787231,
0.5904787182807922,
-0.5826328992843628,
0.05747639760375023,
-0.2956227958202362,
-0.8759735822677612,
-0.3404117822647095,
0.1604764759540558,
-0.9595093727111816,
0.512231171131134,
-0.18404674530029297,
-0.8517419695854187,
0.578761100769043,
-0.7782584428787231,
-0.4720909893512726,
0.07968644052743912,
-0.060335591435432434,
-0.318296879529953,
-0.08220730721950531,
0.09732024371623993,
0.2784968614578247,
-0.5935190916061401,
0.6681278347969055,
-0.6098567843437195,
-0.004168822430074215,
0.6136059761047363,
-0.743995726108551,
0.9405014514923096,
0.1812802255153656,
-0.3551229238510132,
-0.010987111367285252,
-0.9221038818359375,
-0.11232853680849075,
0.15593375265598297,
-0.1346927285194397,
-0.27613699436187744,
0.35302507877349854,
0.18546085059642792,
-0.14178094267845154,
0.29020270705223083,
-0.4033910632133484,
0.1181250512599945,
-0.4613594710826874,
0.564806342124939,
0.8378200531005859,
0.0793236643075943,
0.259530246257782,
-0.22700616717338562,
0.4150954782962799,
-0.5415896773338318,
0.11421561986207962,
0.16726887226104736,
-0.6093514561653137,
-0.830173671245575,
-0.023299844935536385,
0.3095623850822449,
0.6724886894226074,
-0.7026263475418091,
0.20457316935062408,
-0.009479757398366928,
-0.11496739089488983,
0.09692981094121933,
-0.02957293577492237,
-0.12100619077682495,
0.5995598435401917,
-0.11050061881542206,
0.4212786853313446,
-1.0537190437316895,
-0.9806667566299438,
-0.4259311258792877,
-0.2527950406074524,
-0.04670548439025879,
0.386233925819397,
0.7203646302223206,
-0.05571968853473663,
0.852260410785675,
-0.41395455598831177,
0.09490782022476196,
-0.5718389749526978,
0.10633019357919693,
0.4694686233997345,
0.06867387890815735,
0.4279993772506714,
-0.5918270349502563,
0.004470461513847113,
0.1444094181060791,
-0.6423661112785339,
-0.34363117814064026,
-0.4012158215045929,
-0.09092846512794495,
0.3871094882488251,
0.2547394037246704,
-0.4508037567138672,
0.45467910170555115,
0.4190658926963806,
-0.5105411410331726,
0.4517948031425476,
-0.2660551965236664,
-0.007859679870307446,
-0.6506593227386475,
-0.03137462958693504,
0.31178227066993713,
-0.2845641076564789,
-0.4488855004310608,
-0.2534022927284241,
-0.2770313024520874,
0.1094951331615448,
-0.2908098101615906,
0.7684731483459473,
-0.2052733451128006,
-0.428629994392395,
-0.20283563435077667,
0.3733818531036377,
0.1651553362607956,
0.07351751625537872,
0.2455754429101944,
0.6105959415435791,
0.2721291482448578,
-0.5381612181663513,
0.5263867974281311,
0.15687046945095062,
-0.8847541213035583,
0.34093329310417175,
-0.6457593441009521,
-0.0921747237443924,
0.102481409907341,
0.02329733781516552,
-0.4698841869831085,
-0.41991645097732544,
0.05231520161032677,
-0.1061953455209732,
0.009704203344881535,
0.04387432709336281,
-0.5652890205383301,
-0.3993370532989502,
0.04298243671655655,
-0.04326435178518295,
0.47073572874069214,
-0.5980612635612488,
0.6046873331069946,
0.3356499969959259,
-0.3738061487674713,
-0.3663533329963684,
-0.7295597195625305,
0.21622246503829956,
-0.4711185693740845,
-0.7154107689857483,
-0.41651442646980286,
-0.02880069427192211,
-0.9757018089294434,
0.08366139233112335,
0.06778466701507568,
-0.05298416689038277,
0.25372257828712463,
-0.32303914427757263,
0.44359421730041504,
-0.34350520372390747,
0.17444045841693878,
-0.02904808335006237,
-0.04388391599059105,
0.5594647526741028,
-0.654828667640686,
0.0657423883676529,
-0.05079348012804985,
-0.2523379623889923,
-0.23239687085151672,
0.00034349798806943,
0.46529415249824524,
-0.07994306087493896,
0.8014177680015564,
0.0321519561111927,
-0.5436985492706299,
-0.3539952337741852,
-0.7268279790878296,
0.1960192173719406,
-0.4194927215576172,
0.40187227725982666,
0.002313342411071062,
-0.9009014368057251,
0.5167596340179443,
-0.08602213114500046,
0.0029805623926222324,
0.7323799133300781,
0.8477728962898254,
0.14951486885547638,
0.9984065890312195,
0.35002654790878296,
0.12057747691869736,
0.08772431313991547,
-0.19565808773040771,
0.5089532136917114,
-0.6865298748016357,
-0.4572741985321045,
-0.5059748888015747,
-0.09959305822849274,
-0.40179431438446045,
-0.36663541197776794,
0.027954814955592155,
-0.2852478325366974,
-0.3956683278083801,
-0.23318088054656982,
0.07076051831245422,
0.7846654653549194,
0.3297938108444214,
-0.011871998198330402,
0.4656902253627777,
-0.06005354970693588,
0.21601569652557373,
0.07792402058839798,
-0.8105952739715576,
-0.887677788734436,
1.1210993528366089,
0.2884845733642578,
0.7547955513000488,
-0.02431393787264824,
0.42466187477111816,
0.40908557176589966,
0.4289553165435791,
-0.7552154064178467,
0.4677283465862274,
0.006753974128514528,
-0.43955376744270325,
-0.5312751531600952,
-0.8909839391708374,
-0.6977342367172241,
0.08690433204174042,
-0.10453376173973083,
-0.8160523176193237,
0.34278130531311035,
-0.05264740809798241,
-0.5927271842956543,
0.4870986044406891,
-0.5537031292915344,
0.9051116704940796,
-0.5430482625961304,
-0.2464747577905655,
-0.057897623628377914,
-0.15760503709316254,
0.6131193041801453,
-0.13936157524585724,
0.6952944397926331,
-0.25674930214881897,
-0.009622780606150627,
0.8544758558273315,
-0.33803191781044006,
0.8730232119560242,
0.1046108826994896,
-0.2688348591327667,
0.549172043800354,
-0.19972696900367737,
0.4955238997936249,
0.5089519619941711,
-0.4614095389842987,
-0.18673044443130493,
-0.16702504456043243,
-0.3716652989387512,
-0.6139995455741882,
0.686729371547699,
-0.4697187840938568,
-0.5710073113441467,
-0.3793216347694397,
-0.5661018490791321,
-0.19386573135852814,
-0.11246607452630997,
0.1403837352991104,
0.4719224274158478,
-0.4945208728313446,
0.07156208157539368,
0.6889106035232544,
-0.3955588936805725,
0.3546046018600464,
0.4000391662120819,
-0.4726179540157318,
-0.5280515551567078,
0.8998299241065979,
0.10837922990322113,
0.21299684047698975,
0.05972800776362419,
0.4363388419151306,
-0.36920905113220215,
-0.3145079016685486,
-0.45078128576278687,
-0.01897934079170227,
-0.8947269320487976,
-0.22240038216114044,
-0.3636144995689392,
0.035007186233997345,
-0.39725741744041443,
-0.0347280278801918,
-0.021961634978652,
-0.41451361775398254,
-0.27036789059638977,
-0.5423576235771179,
0.5479516386985779,
1.0511394739151,
-0.2673002779483795,
-0.194254070520401,
-0.583179235458374,
-0.0005399906658567488,
0.5569989681243896,
0.23625440895557404,
0.2650020122528076,
-0.35085636377334595,
-0.2705862522125244,
0.04131806269288063,
0.303036093711853,
-0.8878563046455383,
0.5609388947486877,
0.24553880095481873,
0.6477503776550293,
0.6716949343681335,
0.11816458404064178,
0.5849402546882629,
-0.363608181476593,
0.5044754147529602,
-0.00460834801197052,
-1.1076644659042358,
0.5237329006195068,
-0.2822636663913727,
0.08873078227043152,
0.34879928827285767,
0.27601853013038635,
-0.4107111990451813,
-0.33174625039100647,
-0.637420117855072,
-0.8456584215164185,
0.48169776797294617,
0.2876879870891571,
-0.21106590330600739,
-0.40348437428474426,
0.2492396980524063,
0.13993769884109497,
0.2908790409564972,
-0.628180980682373,
-0.15485160052776337,
0.14933498203754425,
-0.09525145590305328,
-0.028895249590277672,
-0.4821476340293884,
-0.035798415541648865,
-0.3860337734222412,
0.7212492227554321,
-0.1784655749797821,
-0.1272834837436676,
0.38940131664276123,
-0.08245950937271118,
-0.2005339115858078,
0.27650147676467896,
0.5806436538696289,
1.0054261684417725,
-0.052971478551626205,
0.11278043687343597,
0.5635417103767395,
0.014556958340108395,
-0.08158853650093079,
0.1918385624885559,
-0.11891336739063263,
-0.1802903115749359,
0.5079038739204407,
0.8327009677886963,
0.534705638885498,
-1.2949333190917969,
0.23566530644893646,
-0.23414796590805054,
-0.501924991607666,
-0.6137832999229431,
-0.2856752872467041,
0.20224080979824066,
0.7111690044403076,
0.24939462542533875,
-0.26701071858406067,
0.5124987959861755,
-0.6396997570991516,
0.12432289123535156,
0.10295315086841583,
-0.0193665511906147,
-0.17741051316261292,
0.5581470727920532,
0.31147095561027527,
-0.019642576575279236,
0.9382451772689819,
-0.4176856577396393,
-0.7766415476799011,
1.0492870807647705,
0.6936376094818115,
0.7804049849510193,
0.1253126859664917,
0.21231065690517426,
0.3715653121471405,
0.6360723972320557,
-0.1421201527118683,
0.592105507850647,
0.45296233892440796,
-0.7390322685241699,
-0.9110913872718811,
-0.8331901431083679,
-0.5918132066726685,
0.2867017090320587,
-0.6540826559066772,
0.12330713868141174,
-0.23664434254169464,
-0.061187442392110825,
-0.15860678255558014,
-0.054781489074230194,
-0.728043794631958,
0.10716595500707626,
0.4607907831668854,
1.0924149751663208,
-0.9907302260398865,
0.40950825810432434,
0.6070205569267273,
-0.21979574859142303,
-0.6224987506866455,
-0.2609349489212036,
0.08842458575963974,
-0.4214778244495392,
0.8910735845565796,
0.07788609713315964,
0.08968707919120789,
-0.15125004947185516,
-0.6442493200302124,
-0.9330479502677917,
0.9161099791526794,
0.34805914759635925,
-0.8956103324890137,
0.20418520271778107,
0.10274631530046463,
0.22600418329238892,
-0.6348700523376465,
0.29768145084381104,
0.9243720769882202,
1.053114652633667,
-0.022181792184710503,
-0.7445806860923767,
-0.3117494285106659,
-0.03618456795811653,
-0.18453525006771088,
0.11578014492988586,
-0.5455887317657471,
0.8024337291717529,
-0.35773301124572754,
-0.09069828689098358,
0.1303413361310959,
0.8449375033378601,
0.21020139753818512,
0.8283364176750183,
0.6109824776649475,
0.8149197101593018,
1.249643087387085,
-0.09321379661560059,
1.2226732969284058,
-0.21965661644935608,
0.6931565999984741,
0.9960057139396667,
-0.7511313557624817,
0.8604317307472229,
0.1406382918357849,
-0.24286244809627533,
0.4541906416416168,
0.6816402673721313,
-0.06065477430820465,
0.0723782405257225,
0.5002514123916626,
-0.29449576139450073,
-0.7944687008857727,
-0.006336945109069347,
0.03151907026767731,
0.3273695111274719,
0.42991214990615845,
-0.15619787573814392,
-0.08398231863975525,
0.07311030477285385,
-0.08323980122804642,
-0.022465553134679794,
-0.39589542150497437,
0.6099082231521606,
0.29146808385849,
-0.15389014780521393,
-0.2639616131782532,
-0.21278515458106995,
0.2147713154554367,
-0.2849530875682831,
-0.1096782237291336,
-0.16905918717384338,
-0.026888523250818253,
-0.2297193706035614,
-0.5967670679092407,
0.49796998500823975,
0.4008505940437317,
-0.0017191661754623055,
0.11945869773626328,
0.763663113117218,
-0.20142053067684174,
-0.859101414680481,
0.28657084703445435,
0.539781391620636,
0.1728152334690094,
0.09085126966238022,
-0.38291028141975403,
0.020165078341960907,
0.10047339648008347,
-0.6819363236427307,
0.22361347079277039,
0.7778578400611877,
0.11725734919309616,
0.602805495262146,
0.6456838250160217,
-0.016399476677179337,
-0.09829913824796677,
0.4819827675819397,
0.4340479373931885,
-0.7853057384490967,
-0.3010817766189575,
-1.012987732887268,
0.061913780868053436,
-0.3441188931465149,
-0.31993523240089417,
0.8061985969543457,
0.7612588405609131,
0.7155547142028809,
0.08969143778085709,
0.9882117509841919,
0.15012085437774658,
0.1698882132768631,
-0.8157292008399963,
0.6116026043891907,
-0.43967828154563904,
0.34560588002204895,
-0.007416455540806055,
-0.873199999332428,
-0.2480819821357727,
0.782562255859375,
-0.638892650604248,
-0.0823502466082573,
0.6894498467445374,
0.3024371266365051,
0.328637957572937,
0.5241202116012573,
0.49603790044784546,
0.3845687210559845,
-0.08143969625234604,
0.4137721359729767,
1.2285650968551636,
0.1507234126329422,
0.5233067870140076,
-0.17022868990898132,
-0.14848755300045013,
-0.20623406767845154,
-1.2121254205703735,
-0.9111636281013489,
-0.07622997462749481,
-0.42772290110588074,
-0.1429675966501236,
0.17257685959339142,
1.1235072612762451,
0.14565856754779816,
-0.64414381980896,
-0.5953320860862732,
0.05416233465075493,
0.4085874855518341,
0.05618887394666672,
-0.24662178754806519,
0.278512567281723,
-0.42236843705177307,
-0.8593659996986389,
0.4248591661453247,
0.47888609766960144,
-0.3031657338142395,
-0.2465166449546814,
0.05265426263213158,
-0.12601305544376373,
0.46686267852783203,
0.7179685831069946,
0.04351777583360672,
-0.7659238576889038,
-0.29629695415496826,
0.10781724005937576,
0.26310214400291443,
-0.31153950095176697,
0.8694994449615479,
-0.5099265575408936,
0.15525338053703308,
0.5944463610649109,
0.5857153534889221,
0.07094980031251907,
-0.34884127974510193,
0.6730687618255615,
0.007772750686854124,
0.1280362904071808,
0.1730727255344391,
0.8274228572845459,
0.08164162933826447,
-0.2443755865097046,
0.4604476988315582,
0.07194366306066513,
-0.8631902933120728,
-0.6375169157981873,
0.10326524823904037,
-0.7105494737625122,
-0.2423989176750183,
1.1520723104476929,
-0.16059665381908417,
-0.710113525390625,
-0.09409058839082718,
0.00551192183047533,
-0.05454022437334061,
-0.28468167781829834,
0.3570425510406494,
0.7604138851165771,
-0.09823611378669739,
-0.056790791451931,
-1.05412757396698,
0.14183175563812256,
0.10974819213151932,
-0.8832272291183472,
0.21952217817306519,
0.5925139784812927,
0.036095332354307175,
-0.27040863037109375,
0.3463174104690552,
0.3290831446647644,
0.3573785424232483,
0.07715007662773132,
0.12633758783340454,
0.1586712896823883,
-0.2035561054944992,
-0.35040146112442017,
-0.042416952550411224,
0.24439378082752228,
0.4727966785430908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01178v1 | $\text{Memory}^3$: Language Modeling with Explicit Memory | 2024-07-01T11:07:23 | 2024-07-01T11:07:23 | Hongkang Yang, Zehao Lin, Wenjin Wang, Hao Wu, Zhiyu Li, Bo Tang, Wenqiang Wei, Jinbo Wang, Zeyun Tang, Shichao Song, Chenyang Xi, Yu Yu, Kai Chen, Feiyu Xiong, Linpeng Tang, Weinan E | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | The training and inference of large language models (LLMs) are together a
costly process that transports knowledge from raw data to meaningful
computation. Inspired by the memory hierarchy of the human brain, we reduce
this cost by equipping LLMs with explicit memory, a memory format cheaper than
model parameters and text retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Conceptually,
with most of its knowledge externalized to explicit memories, the LLM can enjoy
a smaller parameter size, training cost, and inference cost, all proportional
to the amount of remaining "abstract knowledge". As a preliminary proof of
concept, we train from scratch a 2.4B LLM, which achieves better performance
than much larger LLMs as well as RAG models, and maintains higher decoding
speed than RAG. The model is named $\text{Memory}^3$, since explicit memory is
the third form of memory in LLMs after implicit memory (model parameters) and
working memory (context key-values). We introduce a memory circuitry theory to
support the externalization of knowledge, and present novel techniques
including a memory sparsification mechanism that makes storage tractable and a
two-stage pretraining scheme that facilitates memory formation. | [
-0.21318773925304413,
-0.7317020297050476,
0.7914661169052124,
0.05265442654490471,
0.04547113552689552,
-0.30244550108909607,
-0.3487555980682373,
-0.5466827154159546,
-0.2998909056186676,
0.6455124616622925,
-0.025484519079327583,
-0.06455273926258087,
-0.2704069912433624,
-0.2721377909183502,
-0.3088034987449646,
0.6804612278938293,
-0.35802868008613586,
0.16560021042823792,
-0.12245931476354599,
0.03639407455921173,
-0.33836790919303894,
-0.6693529486656189,
-0.8140550851821899,
-0.4214191138744354,
0.7161222100257874,
0.31414124369621277,
0.4622739553451538,
0.9528369307518005,
0.19017158448696136,
0.18892423808574677,
-0.029515692964196205,
0.10215336829423904,
-0.4812638461589813,
-0.061008334159851074,
0.09493470937013626,
-0.7632032036781311,
-0.4049437642097473,
0.08161506801843643,
0.5690659880638123,
0.7450260519981384,
-0.11425304412841797,
-0.17427483201026917,
-0.3284180462360382,
0.9867610931396484,
-0.6901199221611023,
0.19498081505298615,
-0.8485537767410278,
-0.013703054748475552,
-0.1431906670331955,
-0.20732440054416656,
-0.5777626633644104,
-0.34916308522224426,
-0.03855784237384796,
-0.4002487361431122,
0.23245581984519958,
0.12347131222486496,
0.7052533626556396,
-0.055257175117731094,
-0.09197773784399033,
-0.24789635837078094,
-0.9829040765762329,
0.6677850484848022,
-0.4874718189239502,
0.6403347253799438,
0.7261838316917419,
0.26884207129478455,
0.08496197313070297,
-0.6141335368156433,
-0.5563154220581055,
-0.19485311210155487,
0.049659717828035355,
-0.07202928513288498,
-0.03094443306326866,
0.16427133977413177,
0.2536471486091614,
0.4115646779537201,
-0.23216919600963593,
-0.08213269710540771,
-0.6941465735435486,
0.10979640483856201,
0.4335007965564728,
0.004756396170705557,
0.2010030895471573,
0.3889130651950836,
-0.27254265546798706,
0.22491632401943207,
-1.1672428846359253,
-0.47657957673072815,
0.39319631457328796,
0.13350336253643036,
0.18996962904930115,
0.37327083945274353,
-0.0457632876932621,
0.5880582332611084,
-0.16548343002796173,
-0.20772820711135864,
0.011485885828733444,
0.017749082297086716,
-0.1585460603237152,
-0.04101850092411041,
0.557323694229126,
-0.05259239673614502,
0.5318052172660828,
-0.4482409358024597,
-0.3038896918296814,
-0.14340849220752716,
0.45061835646629333,
-0.8139398694038391,
-0.2604142427444458,
-0.08712974935770035,
-0.38420557975769043,
-0.02664199471473694,
-0.3556140959262848,
-0.2337954044342041,
-0.14141470193862915,
-0.2825288474559784,
0.5858465433120728,
-0.657943844795227,
-0.1746675968170166,
0.1080097183585167,
0.06820616871118546,
0.1457359939813614,
0.3092496991157532,
-1.3516433238983154,
0.8193457126617432,
0.5476738214492798,
0.6938318014144897,
-0.2737492322921753,
-0.21408642828464508,
-0.10622237622737885,
0.6779463291168213,
-0.5618917346000671,
0.9436069130897522,
-0.29653704166412354,
-0.26442402601242065,
-0.08957955986261368,
-0.2809612452983856,
0.06294611096382141,
-0.5537698864936829,
0.23159120976924896,
-0.9667337536811829,
0.21579957008361816,
-0.20667076110839844,
-0.7840318083763123,
-0.36739787459373474,
0.03993957117199898,
-0.9248363971710205,
1.0814557075500488,
0.17063577473163605,
-0.5638492703437805,
0.05132557451725006,
-0.5023080110549927,
-0.4414845407009125,
0.030934374779462814,
-0.149819478392601,
-0.024523669853806496,
0.18180927634239197,
-0.16895049810409546,
0.5250617861747742,
-0.5724419951438904,
0.16980528831481934,
-0.2501813769340515,
-0.6220585703849792,
0.13390080630779266,
-0.3615519404411316,
0.3030117154121399,
0.22613342106342316,
-0.050502341240644455,
-0.22959762811660767,
-0.6000881791114807,
-0.2367432713508606,
0.20361833274364471,
-0.5896885395050049,
-0.43417856097221375,
0.2013058215379715,
-0.3809279203414917,
0.05306583270430565,
0.28610628843307495,
-0.3444857597351074,
0.09550881385803223,
-0.6485784649848938,
0.29557469487190247,
0.6532480716705322,
-0.20018309354782104,
0.8131577968597412,
-0.2995564341545105,
0.07372945547103882,
0.030561625957489014,
-0.07674228399991989,
-0.42629584670066833,
-0.3676430881023407,
-0.9992843866348267,
-0.05786069110035896,
0.03138634189963341,
0.41924482583999634,
-0.23981420695781708,
-0.09856359660625458,
-0.22687891125679016,
-0.0802484005689621,
-0.1611449122428894,
0.2984107732772827,
0.3593009412288666,
0.416450560092926,
0.45047351717948914,
0.18712438642978668,
-0.663346529006958,
-1.0656944513320923,
-0.2267034649848938,
-0.30957287549972534,
-0.10377345234155655,
0.3325335383415222,
0.3510477840900421,
-0.04205917567014694,
0.6206110119819641,
-0.5670861005783081,
-0.1678842157125473,
-0.3913116753101349,
-0.0879448726773262,
0.13974982500076294,
0.5264506340026855,
0.08808708190917969,
-0.5792917013168335,
-0.23082008957862854,
-0.0669826790690422,
-0.43188929557800293,
0.07215268909931183,
0.04075733572244644,
-0.08706067502498627,
0.5616877675056458,
0.7768042087554932,
-0.7335313558578491,
0.17680862545967102,
0.32271888852119446,
-0.04126706346869469,
0.407461017370224,
-0.40842410922050476,
-0.22764849662780762,
-0.9065690040588379,
0.013674364425241947,
-0.24420896172523499,
-0.15987369418144226,
-0.5626653432846069,
-0.06250428408384323,
0.21577812731266022,
0.12185412645339966,
-0.5185548663139343,
1.029313325881958,
-0.9397470355033875,
-0.24505119025707245,
-0.4603966176509857,
0.1387740820646286,
0.18457874655723572,
0.7759397029876709,
0.31442034244537354,
0.8378878831863403,
0.25919657945632935,
-0.8251435160636902,
0.18551130592823029,
-0.09208844602108002,
-0.08037006855010986,
0.16204462945461273,
-0.42134934663772583,
0.21226271986961365,
0.013942561112344265,
0.08026320487260818,
-0.7303426265716553,
-0.10054206103086472,
-0.034388840198516846,
-0.23104020953178406,
0.5299155116081238,
-0.13599006831645966,
-0.6579576134681702,
-0.13333889842033386,
-0.1261102706193924,
0.599728524684906,
0.909396231174469,
-0.4162309169769287,
0.6600512862205505,
0.5371500253677368,
-0.13863539695739746,
-0.2350582629442215,
-0.8013604283332825,
-0.17765291035175323,
-0.07895763963460922,
-0.3550533652305603,
0.3721618354320526,
-0.03440316021442413,
-0.30613973736763,
0.06768941134214401,
-0.07216308265924454,
-0.37199240922927856,
-0.07361215353012085,
0.05133018642663956,
0.29104480147361755,
-0.3970482349395752,
0.36357128620147705,
-0.06344950944185257,
-0.23175564408302307,
0.1772077977657318,
-0.38168948888778687,
0.41688987612724304,
-0.2897973656654358,
-0.30566897988319397,
-0.08234547823667526,
0.3138062655925751,
0.20221856236457825,
0.246141254901886,
0.8678110241889954,
0.2158096581697464,
-0.6386020183563232,
-0.16645340621471405,
-0.8544214367866516,
-0.06807751208543777,
-0.45225051045417786,
0.3832191526889801,
-0.46711352467536926,
-0.8726952075958252,
0.410177618265152,
-0.13429854810237885,
-0.11527493596076965,
0.3225575089454651,
0.6111045479774475,
-0.02715325355529785,
0.9777913093566895,
0.47820135951042175,
0.08088340610265732,
0.2195320427417755,
-0.15181848406791687,
0.21712595224380493,
-1.0270137786865234,
-0.3843708038330078,
-0.29596400260925293,
-0.06047799065709114,
-0.14638814330101013,
-0.8018102049827576,
-0.10199172794818878,
0.47131600975990295,
-0.6055920124053955,
0.14445726573467255,
-0.09106363356113434,
0.8472684621810913,
0.45259225368499756,
0.0017151138745248318,
0.3198990225791931,
-0.08186646550893784,
-0.15116459131240845,
0.034665796905756,
-0.7284920811653137,
-0.7237855792045593,
1.0346485376358032,
0.5527971386909485,
0.9200658202171326,
0.08082762360572815,
0.48403653502464294,
-0.0603228434920311,
0.5620072484016418,
-0.8194465637207031,
0.6634020209312439,
-0.0699116513133049,
-0.6072746515274048,
-0.07469804584980011,
-0.3772175908088684,
-0.7976517677307129,
0.185821995139122,
0.07371088862419128,
-0.8255182504653931,
-0.21593332290649414,
0.3585902452468872,
-0.1351696103811264,
0.6761366128921509,
-0.806109607219696,
0.4391038417816162,
-0.381537526845932,
-0.6886107921600342,
-0.2530190348625183,
-0.4408881962299347,
0.683191180229187,
-0.061284806579351425,
0.19890153408050537,
-0.1553213894367218,
-0.43042826652526855,
0.8279533386230469,
-0.18986818194389343,
0.7088915109634399,
-0.15187793970108032,
-0.11265929788351059,
0.13802433013916016,
0.3463355302810669,
0.5444361567497253,
-0.03945841267704964,
-0.07071154564619064,
-0.02816459722816944,
-0.24805763363838196,
-0.3202314078807831,
-0.5969266891479492,
0.8111770153045654,
-0.772953987121582,
-0.6014663577079773,
-0.24236994981765747,
-0.8632380962371826,
-0.47171467542648315,
0.332386314868927,
-0.13930724561214447,
0.2518653869628906,
-0.2640232443809509,
0.021616127341985703,
1.2546199560165405,
-0.26994967460632324,
0.37812602519989014,
0.6364563703536987,
-0.3161095082759857,
-0.3600270450115204,
0.8561931848526001,
-0.08060206472873688,
0.2898309826850891,
0.7079413533210754,
0.2553604543209076,
-0.3960192799568176,
-0.6759904623031616,
-0.12910081446170807,
0.393608421087265,
-0.7661685943603516,
-0.2611832320690155,
-0.9724287390708923,
-0.43375179171562195,
-0.15483464300632477,
-0.1840798407793045,
-0.6683316826820374,
-0.5878148674964905,
-0.34824636578559875,
-0.23274214565753937,
0.6181119680404663,
0.7850610613822937,
-0.18662913143634796,
0.4597158133983612,
-0.7373191714286804,
0.5605049729347229,
0.39799270033836365,
0.7014715075492859,
0.13128532469272614,
-0.5840047597885132,
-0.5022109746932983,
-0.12292125076055527,
-0.17398127913475037,
-0.7299855351448059,
0.40897896885871887,
0.09145547449588776,
0.5752769708633423,
0.41797924041748047,
-0.46944892406463623,
0.6762901544570923,
-0.8502246141433716,
0.5759340524673462,
0.11930554360151291,
-0.843449056148529,
0.27686887979507446,
-0.3085407316684723,
0.14082109928131104,
0.4091132879257202,
0.36236971616744995,
-0.307757705450058,
-0.208108589053154,
-0.7163176536560059,
-0.9025561213493347,
0.7545201778411865,
0.10041540116071701,
0.30375105142593384,
-0.21527649462223053,
0.5841661691665649,
0.0733577162027359,
0.0050156149081885815,
-0.8103168606758118,
-0.219680055975914,
0.060996364802122116,
-0.15701504051685333,
0.009064908139407635,
-0.6867771148681641,
-0.10939496755599976,
-0.2682574987411499,
0.8277953267097473,
0.06483053416013718,
0.6138965487480164,
-0.15457846224308014,
-0.10667035728693008,
0.0523698665201664,
0.13612918555736542,
0.6843078136444092,
0.45387810468673706,
-0.20385971665382385,
0.540521502494812,
0.39198407530784607,
-0.4511354863643646,
0.27355116605758667,
-0.21278706192970276,
-0.11556848138570786,
-0.21925492584705353,
0.12271727621555328,
0.8702946901321411,
0.6051529049873352,
-0.5660356879234314,
0.4161965250968933,
-0.05543376877903938,
-0.3538467586040497,
-0.5289137363433838,
0.24436739087104797,
0.5886858701705933,
0.054422393441200256,
0.3395159840583801,
-0.013013065792620182,
0.08898722380399704,
-0.3847207725048065,
0.23111841082572937,
0.26970183849334717,
-0.42740151286125183,
-0.3591126501560211,
0.6622799038887024,
0.05316167697310448,
-0.2351371943950653,
0.3599940836429596,
0.02186976559460163,
-0.2768957018852234,
0.2337825447320938,
0.9107231497764587,
0.7893034815788269,
-0.21344101428985596,
-0.21173405647277832,
0.46745815873146057,
0.3598112165927887,
-0.5910341143608093,
0.3195853531360626,
-0.11681398749351501,
-0.966760516166687,
-0.39410313963890076,
-0.6971725821495056,
-0.27078282833099365,
0.35984325408935547,
-0.48147353529930115,
-0.03176441043615341,
-0.6074293851852417,
0.2515627443790436,
-0.45897412300109863,
-0.005098434165120125,
-0.42930373549461365,
0.2727406322956085,
0.31476327776908875,
1.2401108741760254,
-0.6131601929664612,
1.1573538780212402,
0.31809911131858826,
-0.3016643524169922,
-0.9078405499458313,
-0.31152012944221497,
-0.4357709586620331,
-1.0036687850952148,
0.8620697855949402,
0.18674328923225403,
-0.21957936882972717,
0.10689983516931534,
-0.46880677342414856,
-1.0318212509155273,
0.9138988256454468,
0.47777438163757324,
-0.45617032051086426,
-0.04031647369265556,
-0.20330578088760376,
0.3643395006656647,
-0.421520471572876,
0.22088544070720673,
0.6712256669998169,
0.3458254337310791,
0.23514103889465332,
-0.2698216438293457,
0.2131955325603485,
-0.35519880056381226,
0.37110835313796997,
0.34598931670188904,
-0.42871370911598206,
0.8977072238922119,
-0.3899044394493103,
-0.20214147865772247,
0.012548089027404785,
0.8397418856620789,
0.680208683013916,
-0.06325507164001465,
0.13160330057144165,
0.5356298089027405,
0.5405898690223694,
0.031252920627593994,
1.1986595392227173,
-0.27776387333869934,
-0.21899449825286865,
1.241897702217102,
-0.4736696481704712,
0.9289239645004272,
0.671553909778595,
-0.18860271573066711,
0.5955623984336853,
0.3226040005683899,
0.25058120489120483,
0.5538681149482727,
0.27860593795776367,
-0.3152763843536377,
0.028393592685461044,
0.34856605529785156,
-0.28020891547203064,
0.043063100427389145,
0.5237104296684265,
-0.4071146547794342,
0.07876591384410858,
-0.17676480114459991,
0.2993033528327942,
-0.048418425023555756,
-0.2844173312187195,
0.9109635949134827,
0.22396506369113922,
-0.6510332226753235,
0.5960651636123657,
0.04300171881914139,
0.30776911973953247,
-0.7685136198997498,
-0.10812033712863922,
-0.3077051043510437,
0.28085803985595703,
0.04283427074551582,
-0.5787060856819153,
0.5066331624984741,
-0.00267133885063231,
-0.3642469048500061,
-0.38328033685684204,
0.8056157827377319,
-0.49051451683044434,
-0.3567233681678772,
0.30711302161216736,
0.4426797032356262,
0.31442511081695557,
-0.06420382112264633,
-0.41918647289276123,
0.10516391694545746,
-0.3667953908443451,
-0.46991783380508423,
0.4012982249259949,
0.5767252445220947,
-0.07054806500673294,
0.710288405418396,
0.6751161813735962,
0.41590166091918945,
0.10784975439310074,
0.09785906225442886,
0.8790922164916992,
-0.9217197895050049,
-0.3884359300136566,
-0.944942831993103,
0.1575033813714981,
0.15555746853351593,
0.21428939700126648,
0.738067626953125,
0.7547875642776489,
0.6555027961730957,
-0.10436184704303741,
0.8523110747337341,
0.2105374038219452,
0.4657767415046692,
-0.772365927696228,
0.5757691264152527,
-0.34712618589401245,
0.4538689851760864,
-0.020154591649770737,
-0.6678459048271179,
-0.3074778616428375,
0.7020226716995239,
-0.3185811936855316,
0.1517208218574524,
0.9218229055404663,
0.7395811080932617,
-0.021134046837687492,
0.06394199281930923,
0.4220799505710602,
0.29939547181129456,
0.013770722784101963,
0.7536585927009583,
0.9336426854133606,
-0.525356650352478,
0.5033074617385864,
-0.06911968439817429,
-0.021760432049632072,
-0.034604597836732864,
-0.7710298895835876,
-0.7982338070869446,
-0.5350082516670227,
0.06453444808721542,
-0.21639792621135712,
0.032503556460142136,
0.535611629486084,
0.9026683568954468,
-0.46702343225479126,
-0.49758490920066833,
-0.5325706601142883,
0.17492292821407318,
0.04304913058876991,
-0.18005789816379547,
0.21699512004852295,
-0.4683826267719269,
-0.36392366886138916,
0.440059632062912,
0.4173111915588379,
0.31516891717910767,
-0.4539678394794464,
-0.34751787781715393,
-0.3128185272216797,
0.32349151372909546,
0.7333690524101257,
0.4233114719390869,
-0.6849303841590881,
-0.00010949053830699995,
-0.007160025183111429,
-0.2385069578886032,
0.14694689214229584,
0.8916860222816467,
-0.9365252256393433,
0.07820697873830795,
0.38281261920928955,
0.5553638935089111,
0.8141903281211853,
-0.35121288895606995,
0.947502076625824,
-0.6016806364059448,
0.3968815207481384,
0.21314406394958496,
0.4216993451118469,
0.3674671947956085,
-0.36187925934791565,
0.42462989687919617,
0.15820862352848053,
-0.4344913959503174,
-0.7508530020713806,
0.2793644070625305,
-0.6703644394874573,
-0.4912174344062805,
1.1993180513381958,
0.0355910025537014,
-0.5600962042808533,
-0.12476708739995956,
-0.08895662426948547,
0.2285824567079544,
-0.24854378402233124,
0.6108478903770447,
0.45095720887184143,
-0.2616272568702698,
-0.3677603304386139,
-0.7392202019691467,
0.7854225635528564,
0.13069559633731842,
-0.9245791435241699,
0.12631550431251526,
0.6082823276519775,
0.25225886702537537,
-0.025003788992762566,
1.0881744623184204,
-0.35651516914367676,
0.16531434655189514,
0.14033739268779755,
0.3079289495944977,
-0.10910727083683014,
-0.48801353573799133,
-0.20000199973583221,
0.21078766882419586,
0.14383015036582947,
0.15767166018486023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01158v1 | Learning to Explore and Select for Coverage-Conditioned Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-07-01T10:26:19 | 2024-07-01T10:26:19 | Takyoung Kim, Kyungjae Lee, Young Rok Jang, Ji Yong Cho, Gangwoo Kim, Minseok Cho, Moontae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interactions with billion-scale large language models typically yield
long-form responses due to their extensive parametric capacities, along with
retrieval-augmented features. While detailed responses provide insightful
viewpoint of a specific subject, they frequently generate redundant and less
engaging content that does not meet user interests. In this work, we focus on
the role of query outlining (i.e., selected sequence of queries) in scenarios
that users request a specific range of information, namely coverage-conditioned
($C^2$) scenarios. For simulating $C^2$ scenarios, we construct QTree, 10K sets
of information-seeking queries decomposed with various perspectives on certain
topics. By utilizing QTree, we train QPlanner, a 7B language model generating
customized query outlines that follow coverage-conditioned queries. We analyze
the effectiveness of generated outlines through automatic and human evaluation,
targeting on retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Moreover, the experimental
results demonstrate that QPlanner with alignment training can further provide
outlines satisfying diverse user interests. Our resources are available at
https://github.com/youngerous/qtree. | [
-0.6099072098731995,
-0.5081018209457397,
0.5346919894218445,
0.17946547269821167,
-0.20822888612747192,
0.2389136701822281,
-0.020672092214226723,
-0.3571391999721527,
0.22591416537761688,
0.7354027628898621,
-0.6171456575393677,
-0.23471622169017792,
-0.07740724831819534,
-0.1853237748146057,
-0.4855855405330658,
0.8004893064498901,
0.005923380143940449,
-0.5045793056488037,
-0.23158767819404602,
-0.019136987626552582,
-0.33019009232521057,
-0.35454225540161133,
-0.6713191270828247,
0.01810537464916706,
0.6203802824020386,
0.6441768407821655,
0.723888099193573,
0.3557310700416565,
0.18424572050571442,
0.15332578122615814,
-0.10859266668558121,
0.5619411468505859,
-0.9412883520126343,
0.627771258354187,
-0.08238990604877472,
-0.34054702520370483,
0.2089826762676239,
-0.2423216551542282,
0.6990659832954407,
0.7218522429466248,
0.0033159940503537655,
-0.07269459217786789,
0.05025973170995712,
0.7600551247596741,
-0.8512603640556335,
-0.05596856027841568,
-0.8153992891311646,
-0.205010786652565,
-0.2352367639541626,
-0.4402068257331848,
-0.7319292426109314,
-0.2496168315410614,
0.2806425094604492,
-0.8915494084358215,
0.3287689983844757,
0.43959248065948486,
0.9000250101089478,
-0.10489436984062195,
-0.71099853515625,
-0.40122339129447937,
-0.5179302096366882,
0.4700705111026764,
-0.34943920373916626,
0.5051804780960083,
0.746541440486908,
0.7411516904830933,
-0.5231285095214844,
-0.7063751220703125,
-0.31988805532455444,
0.04120998829603195,
-0.392030268907547,
0.3467586636543274,
-0.03883819654583931,
0.29400137066841125,
0.5505654811859131,
0.2428567111492157,
-0.5387247204780579,
-0.031831707805395126,
-0.5450762510299683,
-0.2530774176120758,
0.9193620085716248,
0.14963094890117645,
0.2057095468044281,
-0.2654224932193756,
-0.09664055705070496,
-0.28457093238830566,
-0.857235312461853,
0.4738057553768158,
0.375400573015213,
0.13121621310710907,
0.1519850343465805,
0.7490977048873901,
-0.7315329909324646,
0.8584548234939575,
-0.07855863869190216,
0.16871440410614014,
-0.09255634248256683,
-0.408710241317749,
-0.3405873775482178,
-0.2062055766582489,
0.4703528881072998,
0.26522350311279297,
-0.07933107763528824,
-0.35423386096954346,
-0.31355559825897217,
-0.49011433124542236,
0.291984885931015,
-1.126723289489746,
-0.31900259852409363,
0.30809634923934937,
-0.17920465767383575,
0.05555142089724541,
-0.03892618045210838,
-0.6449599266052246,
-0.3689591884613037,
-0.2544190585613251,
0.17500519752502441,
-0.6182394027709961,
-0.11649200320243835,
0.1716831475496292,
-0.4256368577480316,
0.1519959270954132,
0.21136808395385742,
-0.8228610157966614,
0.1254919469356537,
0.2558651566505432,
0.4257795214653015,
0.06508344411849976,
-0.005440369248390198,
-0.6565729379653931,
0.33709993958473206,
-0.3553662598133087,
0.7510502934455872,
-0.6693389415740967,
-0.5992119908332825,
0.13400277495384216,
-0.11932457983493805,
-0.09728667140007019,
-0.2283894270658493,
0.4521045982837677,
-1.109224796295166,
0.4441128671169281,
-0.38367047905921936,
-0.5071592330932617,
-0.20991794764995575,
0.28303050994873047,
-0.7430148720741272,
0.8475952744483948,
0.5155130624771118,
-0.9629656672477722,
0.528990626335144,
-0.382232666015625,
-0.2989606261253357,
0.18317580223083496,
-0.4148012101650238,
-0.46529847383499146,
-0.0700184777379036,
0.2844495177268982,
-0.068079873919487,
-0.16790296137332916,
0.00961294211447239,
-0.0941561609506607,
-0.4637155532836914,
0.14411698281764984,
0.1306348443031311,
0.645051896572113,
0.2850494682788849,
-0.13995273411273956,
0.4290493130683899,
-0.5320224165916443,
0.46198731660842896,
0.039567578583955765,
-0.5464102625846863,
-0.3999614417552948,
0.1127280667424202,
0.027982700616121292,
0.09597837924957275,
-0.18606720864772797,
-0.3868924081325531,
0.29141080379486084,
-0.6205425262451172,
0.3146345019340515,
0.14955352246761322,
0.5269792675971985,
0.5243570804595947,
-0.4826356768608093,
0.9079110026359558,
-0.13624343276023865,
-0.0305673535913229,
-0.5276104807853699,
-0.18238866329193115,
-0.5501163601875305,
-0.28936970233917236,
0.3294896185398102,
0.18752461671829224,
-1.1018389463424683,
-0.12013223767280579,
-0.11392327398061752,
-0.4143615961074829,
-0.3851490914821625,
-0.08110716938972473,
0.45414385199546814,
0.3211856484413147,
0.4808163046836853,
0.09313034266233444,
-0.7778180241584778,
-0.8935943245887756,
-0.25170373916625977,
0.06740013509988785,
-0.07830879092216492,
0.6621624231338501,
0.014317717403173447,
-0.1929645985364914,
1.0757097005844116,
-0.590237557888031,
-0.08241089433431625,
-0.5224077701568604,
-0.09565405547618866,
-0.10530286282300949,
0.11785516887903214,
0.5462409257888794,
-1.23419189453125,
-0.5179300904273987,
-0.17039136588573456,
-0.19327908754348755,
0.0979406014084816,
-0.2761017382144928,
-0.7013368606567383,
0.11010271310806274,
0.60261070728302,
-0.646706223487854,
0.6397902965545654,
0.19935142993927002,
-0.2761553227901459,
0.4085616171360016,
-0.1011132225394249,
0.23532186448574066,
-1.0410774946212769,
0.12892629206180573,
-0.28495630621910095,
-0.20463812351226807,
-0.31411996483802795,
0.23956117033958435,
0.29839596152305603,
-0.2587525546550751,
-0.14187808334827423,
0.575935423374176,
-0.8248476982116699,
-0.10535556077957153,
-0.29913800954818726,
0.09096205979585648,
0.3578585386276245,
0.18617519736289978,
0.1360044628381729,
0.909641444683075,
0.2619941532611847,
-0.5951189398765564,
-0.21530681848526,
0.5028447508811951,
-0.3299608826637268,
-0.15139783918857574,
-0.4386768043041229,
0.17466279864311218,
-0.32532960176467896,
0.4334025979042053,
-0.8672198057174683,
-0.6244415640830994,
0.019880305975675583,
-0.3414883315563202,
0.1434086412191391,
-0.34374138712882996,
-0.499263197183609,
-0.3790261745452881,
-0.35848310589790344,
0.6284435391426086,
0.562851071357727,
-0.5826860666275024,
0.49410030245780945,
0.3527977168560028,
0.023746125400066376,
-0.29122939705848694,
-0.22505860030651093,
-0.13665257394313812,
-0.39713865518569946,
-0.45046281814575195,
0.6038773059844971,
-0.00849184300750494,
-0.1106657087802887,
-0.15867744386196136,
-0.027214236557483673,
0.015591646544635296,
0.1593431532382965,
0.435431569814682,
-0.10610982775688171,
0.07424339652061462,
0.3304961025714874,
0.29879826307296753,
0.6178730130195618,
0.02642054297029972,
-0.18702663481235504,
0.6589626669883728,
0.3048885762691498,
-0.3976000249385834,
0.11985329538583755,
0.5917788743972778,
0.050780002027750015,
-0.6308820247650146,
0.33218637108802795,
0.04533668980002403,
-0.3067062795162201,
-0.32158106565475464,
-0.36719271540641785,
-0.32641953229904175,
-0.4580129086971283,
0.3888404667377472,
-0.6482933759689331,
-1.0242149829864502,
0.4069731533527374,
0.22150962054729462,
0.20099695026874542,
0.29962658882141113,
0.15816354751586914,
-0.15137717127799988,
1.216782569885254,
0.7412154078483582,
0.40737831592559814,
0.5712543725967407,
-0.36522600054740906,
-0.07285509258508682,
-1.0514768362045288,
-0.40735679864883423,
-0.45382776856422424,
-0.20208272337913513,
-0.7125771641731262,
-0.3077758848667145,
0.26271530985832214,
0.519529402256012,
-0.1738385260105133,
0.3035690486431122,
-0.482267826795578,
0.5614476799964905,
0.6394391655921936,
0.19726814329624176,
0.06716009974479675,
0.10526453703641891,
-0.08433451503515244,
0.07146736234426498,
-0.7570527791976929,
-0.14341451227664948,
1.1349072456359863,
-0.027371946722269058,
0.41770756244659424,
0.2682753801345825,
0.768787145614624,
-0.03726743161678314,
0.2582826018333435,
-0.7142334580421448,
0.3218997120857239,
0.32160842418670654,
-0.5923803448677063,
-0.4513913691043854,
-0.43622419238090515,
-1.3568403720855713,
0.37018445134162903,
-0.24617046117782593,
-0.6322329044342041,
0.32874539494514465,
0.3077062666416168,
-0.5496504902839661,
-0.17322662472724915,
-0.5895822048187256,
0.6023516058921814,
-0.29522836208343506,
-0.2943685054779053,
-0.10912507772445679,
-0.6559258699417114,
0.4566417336463928,
0.0502617284655571,
0.0307437963783741,
0.10891657322645187,
0.19994550943374634,
0.5120415091514587,
-0.04199846833944321,
0.46030619740486145,
-0.14152903854846954,
0.42623546719551086,
0.501065731048584,
0.22046230733394623,
0.3650018274784088,
0.36238211393356323,
-0.08701717108488083,
-0.8344549536705017,
0.018941087648272514,
-0.5802547335624695,
-0.5716639757156372,
0.30955496430397034,
-0.40847328305244446,
-0.8345679044723511,
-0.20077307522296906,
-0.7826203107833862,
-0.4550248980522156,
0.5546770691871643,
0.4562736749649048,
0.3970447778701782,
-0.08595359325408936,
0.20355840027332306,
0.7076194882392883,
-0.27770835161209106,
0.2031249850988388,
0.34364792704582214,
-0.6858035326004028,
-0.22497321665287018,
0.7006568908691406,
0.04999178647994995,
0.40410396456718445,
0.4253562092781067,
-0.007797695230692625,
-0.44818899035453796,
-0.887279748916626,
-0.48200491070747375,
0.08927488327026367,
-0.47265756130218506,
-0.19218726456165314,
-0.7712062001228333,
-0.37209704518318176,
-0.3130768835544586,
0.18174155056476593,
0.37114426493644714,
-0.44495826959609985,
-0.07969113439321518,
-0.08597324788570404,
0.3011919856071472,
0.437605082988739,
0.403798371553421,
0.43028467893600464,
-0.5481657981872559,
0.15618501603603363,
0.15955215692520142,
-0.09069065004587173,
-0.1596796214580536,
-0.44263550639152527,
-0.2953447997570038,
0.1818106770515442,
-0.5531898736953735,
-0.9429810047149658,
0.4856017231941223,
0.32370448112487793,
0.6889951825141907,
0.2948450446128845,
0.42756012082099915,
0.5979549288749695,
-0.2549179792404175,
0.18808214366436005,
-0.31012728810310364,
-0.31711775064468384,
0.84897381067276,
-0.4501728415489197,
0.3337737023830414,
0.816141664981842,
0.7152935266494751,
-0.3498338758945465,
-0.39799073338508606,
-0.7323783040046692,
-1.233648419380188,
0.4307935833930969,
0.22239483892917633,
-0.07233428955078125,
-0.03594711050391197,
0.4405914843082428,
-0.09234579652547836,
0.24118076264858246,
-0.17203441262245178,
0.2870546877384186,
-0.23286336660385132,
0.1903982162475586,
0.17211970686912537,
-0.552846372127533,
-0.2272348552942276,
0.21473075449466705,
0.485303670167923,
-0.2618900239467621,
-0.13401943445205688,
0.2864933907985687,
-0.1785929799079895,
0.16232594847679138,
0.31793132424354553,
0.4883432388305664,
0.8454166650772095,
-0.5231355428695679,
0.06166579946875572,
-0.304906964302063,
-0.2515219748020172,
-0.2756510078907013,
0.5633789300918579,
-0.3996921181678772,
-0.13031703233718872,
0.16521374881267548,
0.8169886469841003,
0.18234066665172577,
-1.0300321578979492,
0.24275292456150055,
-0.17671118676662445,
0.0004917862825095654,
-0.2463352382183075,
0.3232984244823456,
0.2524269223213196,
0.07693987339735031,
0.33901989459991455,
-0.43928033113479614,
0.6136922240257263,
-0.5323164463043213,
0.2806347608566284,
0.6044033169746399,
-0.34421393275260925,
0.009856865741312504,
0.5759686827659607,
0.030637387186288834,
-0.05760073661804199,
1.0841691493988037,
-0.6072710752487183,
-0.5726302266120911,
0.5873533487319946,
0.4991328716278076,
0.32720598578453064,
0.21115896105766296,
-0.011106313206255436,
0.4874456524848938,
0.026876093819737434,
0.07189489901065826,
0.4728602170944214,
-0.29587656259536743,
-0.5000162720680237,
-0.39245420694351196,
-0.604666531085968,
-0.3865724802017212,
0.03393225744366646,
-0.8926359415054321,
0.2612563371658325,
-0.2931477129459381,
-0.007508093491196632,
0.014388575218617916,
0.031078392639756203,
-0.5846985578536987,
0.28861963748931885,
-0.30292069911956787,
1.2535282373428345,
-0.4607663154602051,
0.8094448447227478,
0.7534031271934509,
-0.652316689491272,
-1.2204785346984863,
0.19487054646015167,
-0.23193471133708954,
-0.6507640480995178,
0.6510345339775085,
0.3408995270729065,
0.17080236971378326,
0.19589251279830933,
-0.24193964898586273,
-0.8106604218482971,
1.2048218250274658,
0.07145322114229202,
-0.6109157800674438,
-0.26313313841819763,
-0.14088203012943268,
0.35467442870140076,
-0.3523421585559845,
0.5007230043411255,
0.5862833857536316,
0.10072993487119675,
0.3629303276538849,
-0.6010767221450806,
0.003433880163356662,
-0.18322406709194183,
0.012066646479070187,
0.39732450246810913,
-0.5621201992034912,
0.46222984790802,
-0.47900816798210144,
-0.49395307898521423,
0.20032696425914764,
0.617408037185669,
0.7328959107398987,
0.3065771162509918,
0.5333385467529297,
0.4087661802768707,
0.7079297304153442,
0.08258786052465439,
1.3141344785690308,
-0.039527490735054016,
0.03955177590250969,
1.2461152076721191,
-0.019097037613391876,
0.8497402667999268,
0.3277328312397003,
0.10080660134553909,
0.10522115230560303,
1.1655917167663574,
0.29245641827583313,
0.7652791142463684,
0.5549345016479492,
-0.2554285526275635,
-0.2844206988811493,
-0.22503843903541565,
-0.39303305745124817,
0.16483546793460846,
0.533096432685852,
-0.18214845657348633,
-0.23332257568836212,
-0.13368862867355347,
-0.06993819773197174,
0.19977837800979614,
-0.2356577068567276,
0.7179980278015137,
-0.03331608697772026,
-0.9645755290985107,
0.5946935415267944,
-0.2282606065273285,
0.2583531141281128,
-0.509255051612854,
-0.10960709303617477,
-0.5610398054122925,
-0.24156330525875092,
-0.2763471305370331,
-0.884506344795227,
0.19227814674377441,
-0.459888756275177,
-0.37429383397102356,
-0.1538488268852234,
0.5606932640075684,
-0.5310614109039307,
-0.3053039610385895,
0.08252547681331635,
0.1630707085132599,
0.150534525513649,
-0.3328368067741394,
-0.31997358798980713,
-0.010270760394632816,
0.3247506320476532,
-0.5246033072471619,
0.5024368762969971,
0.556861162185669,
-0.5527355670928955,
0.5842885375022888,
0.7326785922050476,
0.04392686486244202,
0.10067109763622284,
0.2732684016227722,
1.1087545156478882,
-0.5027790665626526,
-0.5819074511528015,
-0.30812716484069824,
0.531223475933075,
-0.3260978162288666,
-0.20206010341644287,
0.702080249786377,
1.0539816617965698,
0.8399375081062317,
0.1852508932352066,
0.8077632188796997,
-0.06097076088190079,
0.7127200961112976,
-0.7113991975784302,
0.6837649345397949,
-0.4948063790798187,
0.27100276947021484,
0.3658742606639862,
-0.7636818289756775,
-0.01795618049800396,
0.07895408570766449,
-0.3261992335319519,
0.11796317249536514,
0.3510448634624481,
0.6557391881942749,
-0.13132824003696442,
-0.2571045756340027,
0.17184866964817047,
-0.1032576784491539,
0.6697261333465576,
0.5802602171897888,
1.0297223329544067,
-0.043507520109415054,
0.665885329246521,
-0.2265363484621048,
-0.2788558900356293,
-0.3765152096748352,
-0.6372125744819641,
-0.9044207334518433,
-0.5941435694694519,
0.049641575664281845,
-0.49088093638420105,
0.10562543570995331,
0.6292743682861328,
0.7848122119903564,
-0.5246240496635437,
-0.11695991456508636,
-0.131577730178833,
0.015963101759552956,
0.22415879368782043,
-0.20896559953689575,
0.5975709557533264,
-0.5705462098121643,
-0.41125768423080444,
0.48343169689178467,
-0.040871620178222656,
0.1481531262397766,
0.009009730070829391,
0.0895514264702797,
-0.03262650966644287,
-0.09326931089162827,
0.3239304721355438,
0.6415498852729797,
-0.4980205297470093,
-0.02453882433474064,
0.29681891202926636,
-0.07602261751890182,
-0.028482690453529358,
0.9884729981422424,
-1.0748026371002197,
0.6258723139762878,
0.5112659931182861,
0.8396517038345337,
0.9473817348480225,
0.4716408848762512,
0.5561052560806274,
-0.7627921104431152,
0.19103512167930603,
0.5563457608222961,
0.1703796237707138,
0.2772557735443115,
-0.593751847743988,
0.46141794323921204,
-0.3891018033027649,
-0.6126440167427063,
-0.8437240123748779,
0.6365221738815308,
-0.9834557175636292,
-0.20604310929775238,
1.2453514337539673,
0.04000208154320717,
0.06767688691616058,
-0.06616636365652084,
-0.6137717366218567,
-0.10748082399368286,
-0.35836121439933777,
0.7114013433456421,
0.3166261315345764,
-0.47114020586013794,
-0.32526838779449463,
-0.6865604519844055,
0.8750967979431152,
0.2839028537273407,
-0.835970401763916,
-0.04851313307881355,
0.5624465346336365,
0.18714208900928497,
-0.051028355956077576,
0.6745251417160034,
0.09157883375883102,
0.4147304594516754,
-0.35487836599349976,
-0.1439812034368515,
-0.0395733043551445,
-0.17710474133491516,
0.2081628292798996,
0.10938502103090286,
0.6727563738822937,
-0.13589179515838623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01157v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01157v1 | Unaligning Everything: Or Aligning Any Text to Any Image in Multimodal Models | 2024-07-01T10:25:47 | 2024-07-01T10:25:47 | Shaeke Salman, Md Montasir Bin Shams, Xiuwen Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Utilizing a shared embedding space, emerging multimodal models exhibit
unprecedented zero-shot capabilities. However, the shared embedding space could
lead to new vulnerabilities if different modalities can be misaligned. In this
paper, we extend and utilize a recently developed effective gradient-based
procedure that allows us to match the embedding of a given text by minimally
modifying an image. Using the procedure, we show that we can align the
embeddings of distinguishable texts to any image through unnoticeable
adversarial attacks in joint image-text models, revealing that semantically
unrelated images can have embeddings of identical texts and at the same time
visually indistinguishable images can be matched to the embeddings of very
different texts. Our technique achieves 100\% success rate when it is applied
to text datasets and images from multiple sources. Without overcoming the
vulnerability, multimodal models cannot robustly align inputs from different
modalities in a semantically meaningful way. \textbf{Warning: the text data
used in this paper are toxic in nature and may be offensive to some readers.} | [
-0.17190757393836975,
-0.9231904149055481,
0.48011502623558044,
-0.0959506556391716,
-0.19164347648620605,
-0.15468409657478333,
0.06647505611181259,
-0.4599868953227997,
0.147905170917511,
0.32711902260780334,
-0.3420027196407318,
-0.4793422222137451,
-0.6797460913658142,
-0.15858355164527893,
-0.4730406105518341,
1.1246308088302612,
-0.044812917709350586,
0.012197130359709263,
-0.20551946759223938,
-0.6207808256149292,
-0.3011365234851837,
-0.11699263006448746,
-0.2560686767101288,
-0.06550472974777222,
0.6411959528923035,
-0.12552879750728607,
0.9519259333610535,
0.9673003554344177,
0.6798824071884155,
0.26756784319877625,
0.27726417779922485,
0.014885618351399899,
-0.48200520873069763,
0.36636632680892944,
-0.27226242423057556,
-0.12366300821304321,
-0.017815198749303818,
-0.04224817454814911,
0.5540226697921753,
0.29902181029319763,
0.10146460682153702,
-0.03296041488647461,
-0.010613651014864445,
0.4525640606880188,
-1.0981395244598389,
-0.38938307762145996,
-0.973004162311554,
0.1448601335287094,
-0.28272637724876404,
-0.37495601177215576,
-0.35297691822052,
0.014461549930274487,
-0.1251009851694107,
-0.7459343075752258,
0.2144971638917923,
-0.029361048713326454,
0.8571445941925049,
0.40690329670906067,
-0.6457909345626831,
-0.10873329639434814,
-0.587939977645874,
0.7917947769165039,
-0.20052257180213928,
0.11854720115661621,
0.0233310554176569,
0.2064111977815628,
0.043439410626888275,
-0.5294671058654785,
-0.7499401569366455,
0.14101673662662506,
-0.045859988778829575,
0.22743508219718933,
-0.45394131541252136,
0.13131682574748993,
0.10876890271902084,
0.07408498227596283,
-0.6749282479286194,
-0.023467237129807472,
0.013929907232522964,
-0.21995744109153748,
0.30466562509536743,
0.19542278349399567,
0.7508899569511414,
-0.16999158263206482,
-0.8290477991104126,
-0.19890952110290527,
-0.485762357711792,
-0.229836568236351,
0.15876629948616028,
0.3238925337791443,
-0.10296562314033508,
0.8131444454193115,
0.2744312286376953,
0.7466868162155151,
-0.07251522690057755,
-0.046007707715034485,
0.05261191725730896,
-0.5030479431152344,
-0.5073531866073608,
-0.11036557704210281,
0.9968636631965637,
0.6912336945533752,
-0.01780266873538494,
-0.33375170826911926,
-0.20430627465248108,
0.5206688642501831,
0.3681556284427643,
-0.49984240531921387,
-0.23262155055999756,
0.06607642769813538,
-0.4067964255809784,
-0.6139633655548096,
-0.1120666041970253,
-0.877755880355835,
-0.8179349303245544,
0.24928484857082367,
0.9378664493560791,
-0.2735956013202667,
0.015772124752402306,
-0.1068524569272995,
-0.3135148882865906,
0.20360974967479706,
0.3201458156108856,
-0.7564476132392883,
-0.13701950013637543,
0.3430401682853699,
0.8838405609130859,
0.23201040923595428,
-0.2639807462692261,
-0.4140509068965912,
0.3337318003177643,
-0.36844122409820557,
0.6751560568809509,
-0.6777063012123108,
-0.27269071340560913,
0.1589834839105606,
-0.005239533726125956,
-0.12140889465808868,
0.06619569659233093,
0.6666076183319092,
-0.4362286627292633,
0.2764297425746918,
-0.005841024685651064,
-0.4817834794521332,
-0.20873762667179108,
0.4965420663356781,
-0.7450345754623413,
0.6365458369255066,
-0.1753215789794922,
-0.9347262978553772,
-0.010242481715977192,
-0.6364369988441467,
-0.3461257219314575,
-0.2752748131752014,
-0.2470153123140335,
-0.5589325428009033,
0.004115833435207605,
0.34627610445022583,
0.4594360291957855,
-0.08954662829637527,
-0.13221019506454468,
-0.7377928495407104,
-0.24545297026634216,
0.37661615014076233,
-0.7396898865699768,
0.8466907739639282,
-0.015602151863276958,
-0.251290887594223,
-0.06563422083854675,
-0.7212454080581665,
0.06732922792434692,
0.31200894713401794,
0.05150159075856209,
-0.5010547637939453,
-0.1780412197113037,
0.43958237767219543,
0.28924402594566345,
0.37598559260368347,
-0.7044853568077087,
0.2543964087963104,
-0.06952598690986633,
0.32745465636253357,
0.8146379590034485,
0.0019509915728121996,
1.0003093481063843,
-0.618623673915863,
0.41157105565071106,
0.1047150045633316,
0.27393394708633423,
-0.6291970014572144,
-0.4075336456298828,
-0.43945062160491943,
-0.6416562795639038,
0.2951594591140747,
0.6897502541542053,
-1.0949056148529053,
0.020934849977493286,
-0.11204376071691513,
-0.6054247617721558,
-0.6222521662712097,
0.06701888889074326,
0.6259561777114868,
0.6900198459625244,
0.38464051485061646,
-0.08341258019208908,
-0.25609004497528076,
-0.9210342764854431,
-0.34270554780960083,
0.12009547650814056,
0.06627890467643738,
0.24716491997241974,
0.4146239161491394,
-0.17990495264530182,
0.41622495651245117,
-0.5830145478248596,
-0.516502857208252,
0.3578014075756073,
0.14731958508491516,
-0.37737640738487244,
0.7555927634239197,
0.8839991688728333,
-0.7750431299209595,
-0.6617203950881958,
0.13702444732189178,
-0.9798845052719116,
0.15306130051612854,
-0.2849338948726654,
-0.49978211522102356,
0.08912461251020432,
0.46415355801582336,
-0.6246125102043152,
0.5379629731178284,
0.5364840030670166,
-0.1869775801897049,
-0.06857582181692123,
-0.23492412269115448,
0.22396935522556305,
-1.2211960554122925,
0.151213139295578,
0.27193737030029297,
-0.3956508934497833,
-0.8012746572494507,
0.4470967948436737,
0.3492991626262665,
-0.30170536041259766,
-0.41297441720962524,
0.6435871124267578,
-0.44082555174827576,
0.31119900941848755,
-0.06027408689260483,
0.27185896039009094,
0.3128519356250763,
0.36575061082839966,
-0.29994523525238037,
0.4034360349178314,
0.9337645173072815,
-0.23288065195083618,
0.31967470049858093,
0.3841477036476135,
-0.2513883411884308,
0.9625735878944397,
-0.6942607164382935,
0.03281361982226372,
-0.557251513004303,
0.2769312560558319,
-1.1890238523483276,
-0.10717408359050751,
0.5684446096420288,
-0.6554678678512573,
0.4636172652244568,
-0.020388752222061157,
-0.2157323956489563,
0.3550969362258911,
-0.6836133003234863,
0.5149078369140625,
0.19646796584129333,
-0.552656352519989,
0.7412488460540771,
0.1955062448978424,
0.184011310338974,
-1.1496145725250244,
-0.7362507581710815,
0.24419809877872467,
-0.16427168250083923,
-0.5218014717102051,
0.4918034076690674,
-0.15974722802639008,
0.041154976934194565,
0.26113811135292053,
0.05241326615214348,
-0.3714962899684906,
0.2312300056219101,
0.3927774131298065,
0.632049560546875,
-0.046280279755592346,
0.10795493423938751,
-0.10793131589889526,
-0.020647088065743446,
-0.5860487818717957,
-0.14534878730773926,
0.02525367960333824,
0.36737653613090515,
-0.5489166975021362,
-0.5884310007095337,
0.778895378112793,
0.8495477437973022,
-0.15276850759983063,
0.8113080263137817,
0.8218672871589661,
-0.5279543399810791,
0.06191881746053696,
-0.29156380891799927,
0.14791056513786316,
-0.4692517817020416,
0.40679651498794556,
-0.040223680436611176,
-0.7395501732826233,
0.4680951237678528,
0.3800854980945587,
0.13045892119407654,
0.13301067054271698,
0.2236609160900116,
-0.4054146111011505,
1.2674658298492432,
0.7559780478477478,
-0.07453592866659164,
0.6831016540527344,
0.22535201907157898,
0.36194902658462524,
-0.7383520007133484,
-0.32886606454849243,
-0.5140803456306458,
-0.47396236658096313,
-0.6936624646186829,
-0.30893898010253906,
0.3003246784210205,
-0.02271944470703602,
-0.263654500246048,
0.2873871624469757,
-0.6062542200088501,
0.8860278725624084,
0.39374732971191406,
0.315523236989975,
0.0299893356859684,
0.19791865348815918,
-0.07392609119415283,
-0.10175330936908722,
-0.3855903148651123,
-0.354224294424057,
1.2707992792129517,
0.1174084022641182,
0.9407792091369629,
0.36530929803848267,
0.388471782207489,
0.25562477111816406,
0.26014578342437744,
-0.6739444732666016,
0.17179155349731445,
-0.4141087234020233,
-0.7952300310134888,
-0.06111370027065277,
-0.313200443983078,
-0.938212513923645,
0.4177682399749756,
-0.708381712436676,
-0.721854567527771,
0.11022933572530746,
-0.021499404683709145,
-0.3662824332714081,
0.5229876637458801,
-0.7871624231338501,
0.8680153489112854,
0.029938580468297005,
-0.38571470975875854,
0.3549513518810272,
-0.6614858508110046,
0.3221234381198883,
-0.19159550964832306,
0.13404925167560577,
0.04586707800626755,
-0.331143856048584,
0.30901840329170227,
0.020845795050263405,
0.8017692565917969,
-0.07088310271501541,
-0.08478441834449768,
-0.108561672270298,
0.3424677550792694,
0.3583240807056427,
-0.1567748636007309,
0.2532646656036377,
0.12458712607622147,
-0.024353954941034317,
-0.7864570617675781,
-1.0679792165756226,
0.8893202543258667,
-0.6516857147216797,
-0.3222382664680481,
-0.4577502906322479,
-0.46964046359062195,
-0.03322526067495346,
0.2555420994758606,
0.3474975824356079,
0.568235456943512,
-0.40676283836364746,
0.23022781312465668,
0.5429430603981018,
-0.11832559108734131,
0.8493949174880981,
0.5252783298492432,
0.07730761915445328,
-0.6403094530105591,
1.0109285116195679,
-0.14756743609905243,
0.2301437109708786,
0.692052960395813,
-0.3480641543865204,
-0.46967455744743347,
-0.2475750744342804,
-0.4904921352863312,
-0.0733719989657402,
-0.8288736343383789,
-0.47645875811576843,
-0.6310883164405823,
0.06935501843690872,
-0.27845293283462524,
-0.6606670618057251,
-0.25181058049201965,
-0.4740092158317566,
-0.461056649684906,
0.046886686235666275,
-0.0009503928595222533,
0.6246163845062256,
-0.14431606233119965,
0.3431072235107422,
-0.954132080078125,
0.2677456736564636,
0.4099651277065277,
0.12622402608394623,
-0.010473025031387806,
-0.28235095739364624,
0.07021111249923706,
0.25037911534309387,
-0.591173529624939,
-0.9092568755149841,
0.26798132061958313,
0.2971440255641937,
0.49141809344291687,
0.6745573282241821,
0.13471190631389618,
0.7074896693229675,
-0.5585808753967285,
0.8384777903556824,
0.7503640055656433,
-1.0655752420425415,
0.3067156672477722,
-0.43870797753334045,
0.12144549936056137,
0.4262418746948242,
0.4416877031326294,
-0.5202412605285645,
-0.11287450790405273,
-0.4334144592285156,
-0.6314204335212708,
0.3266983926296234,
0.3571101427078247,
0.47535160183906555,
0.07980755716562271,
0.10419639199972153,
-0.1475975215435028,
0.06364008784294128,
-1.0955225229263306,
-0.44266530871391296,
-0.40139761567115784,
-0.5019435882568359,
-0.047452330589294434,
0.03212635591626167,
-0.7544595003128052,
-0.04021643102169037,
0.38157176971435547,
-0.18108610808849335,
0.45697784423828125,
0.08063330501317978,
-0.26968711614608765,
-0.12509073317050934,
0.15810617804527283,
0.752975583076477,
0.14658024907112122,
0.08966191112995148,
0.41614508628845215,
-0.3066273033618927,
-0.2615360617637634,
0.43550217151641846,
0.018469037488102913,
-0.15454979240894318,
0.027339540421962738,
0.46910813450813293,
0.693934440612793,
0.24899521470069885,
-0.35266202688217163,
1.0604870319366455,
-0.3611881136894226,
-0.12453833222389221,
0.044343847781419754,
-0.1096755638718605,
-0.20669609308242798,
0.3976343870162964,
0.204104945063591,
0.7741086483001709,
-0.18882855772972107,
-0.3972577154636383,
0.2614322304725647,
0.9022431969642639,
-0.7290399670600891,
-0.22774331271648407,
0.7323923707008362,
0.15078003704547882,
-0.05515488609671593,
0.26911410689353943,
-0.07388737797737122,
-0.3385327160358429,
0.5413841605186462,
0.6432029008865356,
0.7510976791381836,
-0.24595321714878082,
0.5980561971664429,
0.06954897195100784,
0.4246230125427246,
0.09914305806159973,
-0.056617334485054016,
0.03836774453520775,
-1.0100053548812866,
-0.07621580362319946,
-0.2250925898551941,
-0.06019452214241028,
-0.030873805284500122,
-0.6522666811943054,
0.1066538617014885,
-0.67790687084198,
-0.006143772043287754,
0.4819898009300232,
-0.5478262901306152,
-0.45105674862861633,
0.23146410286426544,
0.07816645503044128,
0.37261316180229187,
-1.1190816164016724,
0.5204058885574341,
0.8443360328674316,
-0.5669608116149902,
-0.3454115390777588,
0.14391686022281647,
0.2770131826400757,
-1.0781220197677612,
0.26183566451072693,
0.03667602688074112,
0.0728457123041153,
-0.1173379123210907,
-0.9191681146621704,
-0.7206280827522278,
0.9990683794021606,
0.5299599766731262,
-0.19816842675209045,
0.1259031593799591,
-0.1851949393749237,
0.31223437190055847,
-0.2029627114534378,
0.33067888021469116,
-0.15240879356861115,
0.2518879175186157,
0.14408227801322937,
-0.6082079410552979,
0.1974269151687622,
-0.4100258946418762,
0.044908955693244934,
0.2651996612548828,
-0.5457766652107239,
1.0300406217575073,
-0.08428334444761276,
-0.6692684888839722,
0.17954513430595398,
0.18834660947322845,
-0.274868369102478,
0.30137699842453003,
0.19141487777233124,
0.9468650817871094,
0.7124164700508118,
0.026280013844370842,
0.9490678906440735,
-0.3142426908016205,
0.3528138995170593,
1.0761770009994507,
-0.25848934054374695,
0.6053366661071777,
0.38360539078712463,
0.19457145035266876,
0.1707797795534134,
0.2703973650932312,
-0.11725344508886337,
0.9324145317077637,
-0.39270728826522827,
-0.6002936959266663,
-0.29567262530326843,
-0.42879679799079895,
-0.37402674555778503,
0.5931620597839355,
0.09647298604249954,
-0.5274139046669006,
-0.4720265865325928,
0.07984836399555206,
0.18517634272575378,
0.2638852298259735,
-0.22535434365272522,
0.6466472148895264,
-0.19721677899360657,
-0.183611661195755,
0.49819159507751465,
0.12692278623580933,
0.923214852809906,
-0.4779900908470154,
0.09134452044963837,
0.08395498245954514,
0.05757109075784683,
-0.2938777804374695,
-0.8077504634857178,
0.17798002064228058,
-0.17841380834579468,
-0.31520959734916687,
-0.16316108405590057,
0.816524863243103,
-0.49008533358573914,
-0.4137549102306366,
0.2514367699623108,
0.3535391092300415,
-0.32881465554237366,
-0.09958700090646744,
-0.7522807717323303,
-0.019627774134278297,
0.1553741693496704,
0.21929925680160522,
0.5454018115997314,
0.4661062955856323,
0.2902717888355255,
0.5490784049034119,
0.7183005809783936,
-0.21979953348636627,
0.02451644279062748,
-0.161796435713768,
0.8496566414833069,
-0.5075964331626892,
-0.23067502677440643,
-1.0495904684066772,
0.6438888907432556,
-0.19623379409313202,
-0.2803105115890503,
0.7493523359298706,
0.15764646232128143,
0.6803458333015442,
-0.020617937669157982,
0.8937044143676758,
0.1220417469739914,
-0.04001271352171898,
-0.34258171916007996,
0.8455146551132202,
-0.8734099268913269,
-0.174094557762146,
-0.603654682636261,
-0.8523299694061279,
-0.6417959332466125,
0.7362430095672607,
0.12664318084716797,
-0.10355225950479507,
0.8037480115890503,
1.03481924533844,
-0.07574404031038284,
-0.01694555953145027,
0.6178547143936157,
-0.037848975509405136,
0.2273123860359192,
0.59586501121521,
0.7059598565101624,
-0.7375735640525818,
0.5985592007637024,
-0.103102907538414,
-0.22812584042549133,
0.07950229942798615,
-1.0883971452713013,
-0.8217685222625732,
-0.6568848490715027,
-0.40264058113098145,
-0.3487027585506439,
-0.05255322530865669,
0.39434340596199036,
0.525793731212616,
-0.47195231914520264,
0.5373882055282593,
0.12121561169624329,
0.17495711147785187,
0.13809067010879517,
-0.20545604825019836,
0.1538805365562439,
0.16213686764240265,
-0.6590468883514404,
0.1865329146385193,
0.5497691035270691,
0.5892695188522339,
-0.21592101454734802,
0.25785961747169495,
-0.30493465065956116,
0.3159419894218445,
0.3672472834587097,
0.35676929354667664,
-0.43709126114845276,
-0.3456379175186157,
-0.03212326392531395,
-0.3603847920894623,
0.03440388664603233,
0.6055023074150085,
-0.21200600266456604,
0.7321173548698425,
0.47676098346710205,
0.8466771841049194,
0.08574394881725311,
-0.0046674394980072975,
0.2906654477119446,
-1.0218467712402344,
0.29391708970069885,
0.11371197551488876,
0.4211376905441284,
0.6167612075805664,
-0.4761999547481537,
0.15265199542045593,
0.2171022742986679,
-0.45833292603492737,
-0.8284016847610474,
0.30796921253204346,
-1.0952606201171875,
-0.4499100148677826,
0.717890739440918,
-0.360838919878006,
-0.39727553725242615,
0.08278129249811172,
-0.12486083805561066,
0.30763065814971924,
-0.3201155960559845,
0.7935539484024048,
0.70479816198349,
0.19574008882045746,
-0.15884444117546082,
-0.26194995641708374,
0.18426580727100372,
0.4481666386127472,
-0.5056098699569702,
-0.28172028064727783,
0.47574305534362793,
0.3019832968711853,
0.3951798379421234,
0.608832836151123,
-0.3508056700229645,
0.012872480787336826,
0.24182918667793274,
-0.07333213090896606,
-0.07372083514928818,
-0.2604443430900574,
-0.6137415766716003,
0.3993571996688843,
-0.5180522203445435,
-0.7290560007095337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01149v1 | Sociocultural Considerations in Monitoring Anti-LGBTQ+ Content on Social Media | 2024-07-01T10:17:13 | 2024-07-01T10:17:13 | Sidney G. -J. Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | The purpose of this paper is to ascertain the influence of sociocultural
factors (i.e., social, cultural, and political) in the development of hate
speech detection systems. We set out to investigate the suitability of using
open-source training data to monitor levels of anti-LGBTQ+ content on social
media across different national-varieties of English. Our findings suggests the
social and cultural alignment of open-source hate speech data sets influences
the predicted outputs. Furthermore, the keyword-search approach of anti-LGBTQ+
slurs in the development of open-source training data encourages detection
models to overfit on slurs; therefore, anti-LGBTQ+ content may go undetected.
We recommend combining empirical outputs with qualitative insights to ensure
these systems are fit for purpose. | [
-0.5734445452690125,
-0.5991261601448059,
0.15626370906829834,
0.026018206030130386,
-0.4549112915992737,
0.026698781177401543,
-0.2625595033168793,
-0.6190676093101501,
0.5048509240150452,
0.27328136563301086,
-0.28229066729545593,
-0.39847683906555176,
-0.8441505432128906,
0.008592258207499981,
-0.4945826530456543,
1.021801233291626,
0.08904914557933807,
0.43686604499816895,
0.18656650185585022,
-0.4617367684841156,
0.12337363511323929,
-0.49912258982658386,
-0.6594372391700745,
0.04172547534108162,
0.7703482508659363,
0.24199365079402924,
0.7893906235694885,
0.26340770721435547,
0.13606181740760803,
0.12144210934638977,
-0.32311487197875977,
-0.22823648154735565,
-0.8806037902832031,
0.21084630489349365,
-0.5704532265663147,
-0.2821728587150574,
-0.14883621037006378,
0.3033399283885956,
0.648121178150177,
-0.0991605892777443,
0.1603747010231018,
0.5676553845405579,
-0.0653170719742775,
0.4711960554122925,
-0.7489609718322754,
-0.29427075386047363,
-0.3592122495174408,
0.10561127215623856,
-0.5054144859313965,
-0.018667785450816154,
0.07347267866134644,
-0.49837198853492737,
-0.025505824014544487,
-0.39017993211746216,
0.2642327845096588,
-0.10393799096345901,
0.28394651412963867,
-0.1005406454205513,
-0.6496154069900513,
-0.5994433164596558,
-0.9954177141189575,
0.7490565776824951,
-0.47917407751083374,
0.8328909873962402,
0.6547842621803284,
0.01729493960738182,
0.24718008935451508,
-0.02452877163887024,
-0.49846863746643066,
0.15798120200634003,
-0.00588250020518899,
0.06801033765077591,
-0.14838552474975586,
-0.3005523383617401,
0.052125684916973114,
0.24884390830993652,
-0.5326085090637207,
0.2858392596244812,
-0.7204927206039429,
0.06889854371547699,
1.039355993270874,
-0.017195848748087883,
0.4287736713886261,
-0.2773396968841553,
0.11497601866722107,
0.5653327107429504,
-0.7014597654342651,
0.05860837176442146,
0.8573232293128967,
0.32789433002471924,
-0.07724073529243469,
0.5025468468666077,
-0.0006463099853135645,
-0.09808136522769928,
-0.0906883031129837,
0.245916485786438,
0.17242226004600525,
-0.2224038541316986,
0.16643734276294708,
0.33161038160324097,
0.6127681136131287,
0.3926672339439392,
0.6297956109046936,
-0.1594504415988922,
-0.10260998457670212,
0.36715298891067505,
0.5290647745132446,
-0.7141633629798889,
0.12197478860616684,
0.10799631476402283,
-0.28436774015426636,
-0.331394225358963,
-0.14530089497566223,
-0.6928821206092834,
-0.8371450304985046,
-0.19217422604560852,
0.049949683248996735,
-0.30648812651634216,
-0.6514856219291687,
-0.2912500202655792,
-0.31713932752609253,
0.14995411038398743,
0.24864359200000763,
-0.5631479024887085,
0.09565795958042145,
0.7184673547744751,
0.7131791710853577,
-0.01839958317577839,
0.052545905113220215,
-0.6305482983589172,
-0.09126144647598267,
-0.3864712417125702,
0.3917923867702484,
-0.5826463103294373,
-0.23863932490348816,
0.30787625908851624,
0.33684638142585754,
0.41194459795951843,
-0.15230382978916168,
0.5791555643081665,
-0.4954822063446045,
0.2127925604581833,
-0.34408873319625854,
-0.43970662355422974,
0.16858185827732086,
-0.025793032720685005,
-0.47646141052246094,
0.953861653804779,
0.05296929553151131,
-1.080559253692627,
0.5299187302589417,
-0.38173341751098633,
-0.4818580150604248,
0.2667209506034851,
-0.295011043548584,
-0.3518194854259491,
0.11775939166545868,
-0.09348154813051224,
0.13066481053829193,
-0.19850872457027435,
0.2003191113471985,
-0.471047967672348,
-0.5584716796875,
0.1397479623556137,
0.08569291979074478,
1.098649024963379,
0.28237706422805786,
-0.8302837610244751,
0.033391524106264114,
-0.5527710318565369,
-0.508297324180603,
0.2213422656059265,
-0.11510823667049408,
-0.8095664978027344,
0.4559948444366455,
0.05553301051259041,
0.1696322113275528,
-0.3238348662853241,
-1.0806595087051392,
-0.67330002784729,
-0.26226285099983215,
0.23044155538082123,
0.7636720538139343,
-0.22393208742141724,
0.3654118776321411,
-0.18836404383182526,
0.751547634601593,
0.014246145263314247,
0.40268319845199585,
0.6662277579307556,
-0.6099770665168762,
-0.23257498443126678,
0.07603002339601517,
-0.06389259546995163,
0.5219196081161499,
-0.5645296573638916,
0.27646762132644653,
0.27321431040763855,
-0.7039876580238342,
-0.6742292046546936,
0.22338728606700897,
0.4304012358188629,
0.0006761511322110891,
0.2035256326198578,
-0.1489112377166748,
-1.0928772687911987,
-0.6107627153396606,
-0.4471965730190277,
-0.3938726782798767,
0.23411595821380615,
0.14308413863182068,
0.47140198945999146,
-0.0007153176702558994,
0.5998662710189819,
-0.0730307325720787,
-0.16773028671741486,
0.005380121059715748,
0.01728658750653267,
-0.13595835864543915,
0.30651038885116577,
0.759820818901062,
-1.1260584592819214,
-0.8640252947807312,
-0.2727518379688263,
-0.47910889983177185,
-0.29801782965660095,
0.6720781922340393,
-0.25385063886642456,
0.11683499813079834,
0.52349454164505,
-0.04639798775315285,
0.6638756394386292,
0.6679180264472961,
-0.655933141708374,
0.5830778479576111,
0.521327555179596,
0.3766867220401764,
-1.1078393459320068,
-0.24978700280189514,
0.4377173185348511,
0.02743091806769371,
-0.895268976688385,
-0.015215233899652958,
-0.10379450768232346,
-0.08795357495546341,
-0.8773549795150757,
0.3935557007789612,
-0.14639215171337128,
0.15121841430664062,
-0.05025153234601021,
0.223013237118721,
-0.42572110891342163,
-0.2092563509941101,
0.1766076385974884,
0.5200217962265015,
0.49054694175720215,
-0.37562114000320435,
0.39636901021003723,
0.17473819851875305,
-0.47942018508911133,
0.8970106840133667,
-0.4095690846443176,
-0.04810645803809166,
-0.5251046419143677,
-0.01722949929535389,
-1.1055858135223389,
0.03816720098257065,
0.44487613439559937,
-0.8333093523979187,
-0.35537344217300415,
-0.35079196095466614,
-0.2381054013967514,
-0.22885054349899292,
-0.5008974075317383,
0.2631745934486389,
0.2948930561542511,
-0.06935766339302063,
0.11430922895669937,
0.7993674874305725,
0.013521033339202404,
-0.4809890687465668,
-0.63316810131073,
-0.26556867361068726,
-0.39249321818351746,
-0.5137894749641418,
-0.08479481190443039,
0.1356031894683838,
-0.5426920056343079,
0.03664261847734451,
0.061969202011823654,
0.07991263270378113,
0.18226014077663422,
0.2760055959224701,
-0.16578543186187744,
-0.3848426640033722,
0.06900284439325333,
-0.02133306674659252,
0.514649510383606,
0.2050025761127472,
-0.11199171096086502,
0.40801501274108887,
0.03004373610019684,
-0.1179039254784584,
-0.032486505806446075,
0.5927882194519043,
0.5491586923599243,
-0.03841201961040497,
1.0512163639068604,
1.1167185306549072,
-0.38608214259147644,
-0.053643036633729935,
-0.41028663516044617,
-0.063920758664608,
-0.42865702509880066,
0.047632381319999695,
0.3786856234073639,
-1.1906216144561768,
0.5125705003738403,
0.6633856296539307,
-0.09824240952730179,
0.1973038762807846,
0.5170725584030151,
-0.4471960663795471,
0.9741914868354797,
0.4987717866897583,
0.10717997699975967,
0.7711225748062134,
0.2249443084001541,
0.3615119457244873,
-0.6074714660644531,
-0.11307287216186523,
-0.7793017029762268,
-0.2035990059375763,
-0.8298524618148804,
-0.22549976408481598,
0.30240482091903687,
-0.2410832792520523,
-0.432926207780838,
0.22110560536384583,
-0.3151256740093231,
0.28925004601478577,
0.35431548953056335,
-0.04369837045669556,
-0.04582333564758301,
0.09501655399799347,
0.16691744327545166,
-0.23046188056468964,
-0.3022730350494385,
-0.18996214866638184,
0.7732371687889099,
0.486834853887558,
0.6575443148612976,
0.4836057722568512,
0.41285601258277893,
0.6102888584136963,
0.27079489827156067,
-0.5073355436325073,
0.33838385343551636,
-0.4509824812412262,
-1.2161091566085815,
-0.5117483139038086,
-0.2022625356912613,
-0.8257721662521362,
-0.002373902127146721,
-0.2932921051979065,
-0.7591940760612488,
0.3897916376590729,
0.07475239783525467,
-0.03295762091875076,
0.5037571787834167,
-0.2911969721317291,
0.43727630376815796,
-0.16398629546165466,
-0.35145118832588196,
-0.11946715414524078,
-0.3875506520271301,
0.21399027109146118,
-0.29285505414009094,
0.6707102656364441,
-0.3409019708633423,
0.179035022854805,
0.8873190879821777,
0.002696872455999255,
1.0773711204528809,
-0.3800909221172333,
-0.27582237124443054,
0.33522066473960876,
-0.04805317148566246,
0.1260901838541031,
-0.18144537508487701,
-0.1879701316356659,
0.2734612226486206,
0.028127402067184448,
-0.34078019857406616,
-0.01640688069164753,
0.4260979890823364,
-1.0208874940872192,
-0.5752713680267334,
-0.10725954174995422,
-0.24393410980701447,
-0.14977413415908813,
0.020091911777853966,
0.2833007574081421,
0.18291416764259338,
-0.476794570684433,
0.6729671955108643,
0.6857261657714844,
-0.33066123723983765,
-0.053557805716991425,
0.7498284578323364,
-0.5175554752349854,
-0.41658732295036316,
0.6409506797790527,
0.5859588384628296,
0.11693601310253143,
-0.19057601690292358,
0.43514424562454224,
-0.26167482137680054,
-0.3925584852695465,
-0.5871086120605469,
0.29368841648101807,
-0.6242623329162598,
0.14666132628917694,
-0.5306293368339539,
-0.2577831745147705,
-1.0943936109542847,
-0.27954891324043274,
-0.17961139976978302,
-0.0421922504901886,
-0.16912841796875,
-0.0664903074502945,
0.5421203970909119,
0.9376436471939087,
-0.30199480056762695,
0.36457255482673645,
-0.540153443813324,
0.3005191385746002,
0.12928597629070282,
0.6575230360031128,
-0.19867786765098572,
-0.680212140083313,
-0.4833363890647888,
0.18581309914588928,
0.11278702318668365,
-1.2101376056671143,
0.034588415175676346,
-0.010736729018390179,
0.6164151430130005,
0.3464824855327606,
0.2551206946372986,
0.1720527559518814,
-0.16299909353256226,
0.9088867902755737,
-0.0012569589307531714,
-0.7690154314041138,
0.6993662714958191,
-0.6715643405914307,
0.09897398203611374,
0.34952691197395325,
1.3075487613677979,
-1.0087847709655762,
-0.9482503533363342,
-0.5481227040290833,
-0.6117287874221802,
0.7408813834190369,
0.22660592198371887,
0.12076412886381149,
-0.1889030635356903,
0.06274499744176865,
-0.004718928597867489,
0.21026483178138733,
-0.6416691541671753,
-0.14133895933628082,
-0.4063017666339874,
0.1561335325241089,
-0.1274656355381012,
-0.3743959665298462,
-0.18751056492328644,
-0.3362503945827484,
0.7367097735404968,
0.3278273344039917,
-0.16922765970230103,
0.038637325167655945,
-0.07301425188779831,
-0.5672200918197632,
0.1979793906211853,
0.3360820710659027,
0.6469308733940125,
-0.16030874848365784,
0.13208165764808655,
-0.18525034189224243,
-0.7836845517158508,
0.2010444551706314,
-0.37303245067596436,
-0.5799399614334106,
0.30084657669067383,
-0.14062508940696716,
0.7652032971382141,
-0.11492693424224854,
-0.3484487235546112,
0.5323391556739807,
0.08499711006879807,
-0.30282092094421387,
-0.4740079641342163,
-0.05441554635763168,
0.3222821056842804,
0.3414921164512634,
0.26595741510391235,
-0.5042539834976196,
-0.08560151606798172,
-0.7874420881271362,
0.2517015337944031,
0.4508029520511627,
-0.6483057737350464,
-0.4790898561477661,
0.7268955111503601,
0.13318923115730286,
-0.6723560094833374,
0.3426397740840912,
-0.16740305721759796,
-0.6719108819961548,
0.5384297370910645,
0.5228707194328308,
0.6600499153137207,
-0.7478173971176147,
0.5924020409584045,
0.39192086458206177,
0.5889615416526794,
0.3999859690666199,
0.4486684501171112,
0.10532684624195099,
-1.038953185081482,
-0.19060118496418,
-0.6959667205810547,
-0.2480079084634781,
0.21245741844177246,
-0.6937199831008911,
0.5072654485702515,
-0.5250352621078491,
-0.19813638925552368,
0.2819302976131439,
-0.13084517419338226,
-0.3999705910682678,
0.3675461709499359,
0.8020145893096924,
0.6958567500114441,
-1.4310587644577026,
0.6660041809082031,
0.7872141599655151,
-0.2913409173488617,
-0.3148951232433319,
-0.2239661067724228,
0.5942760705947876,
-0.6944301724433899,
0.4517594277858734,
-0.12109658122062683,
-0.40071746706962585,
-0.3566027581691742,
-0.5739771127700806,
-0.7940264940261841,
0.3737161457538605,
0.027736473828554153,
-0.1466137319803238,
0.06526660174131393,
0.4646133780479431,
0.8663732409477234,
-0.3288978338241577,
-0.0009021495352499187,
0.4300535321235657,
0.3020498752593994,
-0.019890055060386658,
-0.9010965824127197,
-0.06367581337690353,
-0.41086721420288086,
-0.05257251486182213,
0.5457106232643127,
-0.5487366914749146,
0.7698606252670288,
0.4987001419067383,
-0.33503827452659607,
-0.5288954377174377,
0.31405341625213623,
-0.055772244930267334,
0.5050223469734192,
0.6150363683700562,
0.2186085432767868,
0.33210065960884094,
0.27284106612205505,
0.46417737007141113,
0.017504461109638214,
0.08162260800600052,
0.9042136073112488,
-0.2290256768465042,
0.547950029373169,
0.28692328929901123,
-0.11356387287378311,
0.433138906955719,
0.5834943652153015,
0.021370606496930122,
0.29612621665000916,
0.3448218107223511,
-0.3270646929740906,
0.15197643637657166,
-0.686072826385498,
-0.2496686428785324,
0.6449824571609497,
0.7049658298492432,
-0.5173993110656738,
-0.28520122170448303,
0.1485433131456375,
0.008819266222417355,
0.2635495960712433,
-0.7120321989059448,
0.6912070512771606,
-0.15086647868156433,
-0.45133134722709656,
0.4159851372241974,
-0.20671015977859497,
0.9490711092948914,
-0.44284600019454956,
0.3666805326938629,
-0.014118976891040802,
-0.23559612035751343,
-0.6433990001678467,
-0.8994112014770508,
0.7833213806152344,
0.2863653302192688,
-0.019175266847014427,
-0.16495776176452637,
0.9734174013137817,
-0.5241294503211975,
-0.15067550539970398,
0.6616742014884949,
0.5023216009140015,
0.4286585748195648,
-0.24628762900829315,
-0.41298210620880127,
0.17100463807582855,
0.05184754729270935,
-0.03870687261223793,
0.5267748832702637,
0.4290729761123657,
-0.25515273213386536,
0.1456887423992157,
0.4737628996372223,
0.4531046748161316,
0.2713621258735657,
0.04771578684449196,
0.6942824721336365,
-0.4703423082828522,
-0.5709020495414734,
-0.6816742420196533,
0.32079267501831055,
0.008689811453223228,
-0.2757837176322937,
0.9061236381530762,
0.39066100120544434,
1.2400288581848145,
0.40428921580314636,
0.7622153759002686,
-0.24307464063167572,
0.8334485292434692,
0.05257989093661308,
0.859839141368866,
-0.6719884872436523,
-0.355364590883255,
-0.4710506200790405,
-0.8917837142944336,
-0.0031799974385648966,
0.3181653916835785,
-0.5319700837135315,
-0.3103143870830536,
0.36522725224494934,
0.8374989628791809,
0.020474527031183243,
0.6046574115753174,
0.36143484711647034,
0.04245263338088989,
0.23484919965267181,
-0.28235164284706116,
0.9506239891052246,
-0.11460775136947632,
0.4181746244430542,
-0.3677053153514862,
-0.1395842283964157,
-0.16355293989181519,
-0.7054699659347534,
-0.66816645860672,
-0.7109482288360596,
-0.36930081248283386,
-0.7201437950134277,
0.06622111797332764,
0.8135696053504944,
0.26693984866142273,
-0.9719506502151489,
-0.3433147370815277,
0.5123758912086487,
0.17007818818092346,
0.09916360676288605,
-0.23829957842826843,
-0.21419548988342285,
0.10939933359622955,
-0.5485705137252808,
0.04016532376408577,
0.010041426867246628,
-0.1886248141527176,
-0.5813999176025391,
0.008783932775259018,
-0.6586779356002808,
0.26868438720703125,
0.7844489216804504,
0.2929559648036957,
-0.45283791422843933,
-0.42900902032852173,
0.15707352757453918,
-0.04665205255150795,
-0.061498694121837616,
0.9467220306396484,
-0.10486994683742523,
0.2490559220314026,
0.5522596836090088,
0.3693416118621826,
0.36527544260025024,
-0.07341261953115463,
0.4724106192588806,
-0.7111176252365112,
0.2367044985294342,
0.44427725672721863,
0.2056848704814911,
0.32259392738342285,
-0.5272199511528015,
0.5982277393341064,
0.45342305302619934,
-0.6170156598091125,
-0.8894630670547485,
0.2953014373779297,
-0.11246655136346817,
-0.19187475740909576,
1.5043416023254395,
-0.03303412348031998,
-0.25423479080200195,
-0.6872954964637756,
0.08095637708902359,
0.5103117227554321,
-0.31179407238960266,
0.6394426822662354,
0.7811571955680847,
0.06665465980768204,
-0.11671971529722214,
-0.5171366930007935,
0.5827571153640747,
0.2563306987285614,
-0.17828266322612762,
-0.1044706478714943,
0.5016598105430603,
0.2907061278820038,
0.17638054490089417,
0.7042847275733948,
-0.08242747187614441,
0.43541452288627625,
-0.19738277792930603,
-0.004341620020568371,
0.46537813544273376,
-0.12197081744670868,
-0.3501991629600525,
-0.09614209085702896,
-0.24484634399414062,
0.0002714026777539402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01137v1 | An Empirical Comparison of Generative Approaches for Product Attribute-Value Identification | 2024-07-01T10:02:17 | 2024-07-01T10:02:17 | Kassem Sabeh, Robert Litschko, Mouna Kacimi, Barbara Plank, Johann Gamper | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Product attributes are crucial for e-commerce platforms, supporting
applications like search, recommendation, and question answering. The task of
Product Attribute and Value Identification (PAVI) involves identifying both
attributes and their values from product information. In this paper, we
formulate PAVI as a generation task and provide, to the best of our knowledge,
the most comprehensive evaluation of PAVI so far. We compare three different
attribute-value generation (AVG) strategies based on fine-tuning
encoder-decoder models on three datasets. Experiments show that end-to-end AVG
approach, which is computationally efficient, outperforms other strategies.
However, there are differences depending on model sizes and the underlying
language model. The code to reproduce all experiments is available at:
https://github.com/kassemsabeh/pavi-avg | [
-0.44663867354393005,
-0.9606260061264038,
0.19673146307468414,
0.22724619507789612,
-0.1304265856742859,
-0.0842176303267479,
-0.12607599794864655,
-0.5092856884002686,
-0.19143033027648926,
0.01751900278031826,
-0.633236825466156,
-0.4147016704082489,
-0.3720901608467102,
-0.06315292418003082,
-0.2653103470802307,
0.7846190333366394,
0.351028174161911,
-0.11621889472007751,
-0.6491748690605164,
-0.09123146533966064,
-0.2131877988576889,
-0.4030013978481293,
-0.7619393467903137,
0.02253847010433674,
0.3512461483478546,
0.08955004066228867,
0.5327263474464417,
0.5307047963142395,
0.740594744682312,
0.271625816822052,
-0.01611432619392872,
0.575437068939209,
-0.39504274725914,
0.19226042926311493,
0.07190145552158356,
-0.05412601679563522,
-0.6201709508895874,
-0.005187038332223892,
0.0659608542919159,
0.4772035777568817,
-0.09080235660076141,
0.7063059210777283,
-0.011228954419493675,
0.5686824917793274,
-1.168465495109558,
0.23745861649513245,
-0.38265928626060486,
0.08138816058635712,
-0.1449902057647705,
-0.11736327409744263,
-0.5690385103225708,
-0.5329145193099976,
-0.15068601071834564,
-0.8186899423599243,
0.390070378780365,
0.10674994438886642,
1.3383482694625854,
0.17588572204113007,
-0.23065578937530518,
-0.5345935821533203,
-0.8967208862304688,
0.8500139713287354,
-0.44808170199394226,
0.394605427980423,
0.3088679611682892,
0.2685386538505554,
-0.13922907412052155,
-0.5230711102485657,
-0.8842558860778809,
0.029740625992417336,
0.0893772691488266,
0.24360689520835876,
-0.4384753704071045,
-0.17751146852970123,
-0.02077772282063961,
0.801917314529419,
-0.4779578447341919,
0.2565765976905823,
-0.4857521951198578,
0.040322475135326385,
0.7579115033149719,
0.08547960966825485,
0.2018127292394638,
-0.13475878536701202,
-0.1880883425474167,
-0.5454949140548706,
-0.9422178268432617,
0.36240354180336,
0.6749223470687866,
0.1442871242761612,
0.25290223956108093,
0.5688689947128296,
-0.5056215524673462,
0.605924129486084,
0.5921505093574524,
-0.4304819405078888,
0.7837046384811401,
-0.34854188561439514,
-0.4658908545970917,
-0.15155094861984253,
0.8091229200363159,
0.42036524415016174,
-0.1433495730161667,
-0.20553822815418243,
-0.25362804532051086,
-0.17711283266544342,
0.3649452030658722,
-0.6941680312156677,
-0.04111115634441376,
0.07961080223321915,
-0.85701584815979,
-0.6620936989784241,
0.10221309214830399,
-0.7343926429748535,
-0.3381926119327545,
-0.1410045623779297,
0.821829080581665,
-0.27375805377960205,
-0.2120075672864914,
-0.0693337619304657,
-0.17918804287910461,
1.0741416215896606,
0.1445067971944809,
-0.8651900291442871,
0.1623329222202301,
0.8597187399864197,
0.6873987913131714,
-0.3262140452861786,
0.23255999386310577,
-0.6638266444206238,
-0.19321095943450928,
-0.39095211029052734,
0.7350715398788452,
-0.6042629480361938,
-0.4696623384952545,
-0.12899059057235718,
-0.08528368175029755,
0.36511337757110596,
-0.7466434836387634,
0.6355838179588318,
-0.7151838541030884,
-0.04171496257185936,
-0.6947734951972961,
-0.3474618196487427,
-0.12104693800210953,
0.36787283420562744,
-0.8120214939117432,
0.8757038712501526,
0.10102207958698273,
-0.4466354548931122,
0.8001940250396729,
-0.6407284140586853,
-0.45819932222366333,
0.28620097041130066,
-0.151081383228302,
-0.9305970668792725,
0.6133012175559998,
0.47051864862442017,
0.5771008729934692,
-0.8381410837173462,
-0.19248317182064056,
-0.27569514513015747,
0.06798974424600601,
0.4412722587585449,
-0.865533709526062,
0.6070441603660583,
0.6194320917129517,
0.02896200679242611,
-0.26186075806617737,
-1.1846749782562256,
0.10977526754140854,
0.2759755253791809,
-0.0501636378467083,
-0.128499373793602,
0.08227695524692535,
0.06817810982465744,
-0.06697624176740646,
0.24393479526042938,
-0.7024993896484375,
0.003679034998640418,
-0.24930702149868011,
0.15409539639949799,
0.7820456027984619,
0.3115311861038208,
0.24517415463924408,
-0.23226024210453033,
0.6970563530921936,
-0.052586570382118225,
0.33949464559555054,
-0.36919882893562317,
-0.3257439136505127,
-0.9688634276390076,
-0.2992118299007416,
0.4318297207355499,
0.2787267565727234,
-0.4127916693687439,
0.28604698181152344,
-0.300905704498291,
-0.6561164259910583,
-0.5341224074363708,
-0.11174645274877548,
0.5811609029769897,
0.3779270648956299,
0.26556336879730225,
-0.49861612915992737,
-0.0752008855342865,
-1.1340680122375488,
-0.09804177284240723,
-0.3499610424041748,
-0.4092259705066681,
0.5741962790489197,
0.17852118611335754,
0.16363640129566193,
0.8053256273269653,
-0.5878090262413025,
0.03449296951293945,
-0.08518455922603607,
0.5598113536834717,
0.09301387518644333,
0.27114829421043396,
0.6486185193061829,
-0.8473500609397888,
-0.5515917539596558,
0.3305303454399109,
-0.6029395461082458,
-0.3698636591434479,
-0.15473201870918274,
-0.019386442378163338,
-0.09746917337179184,
-0.059374112635850906,
-0.4355115592479706,
0.5866595506668091,
0.2337203025817871,
-0.14739179611206055,
0.5856896638870239,
-0.24796652793884277,
0.6080038547515869,
-0.9757261276245117,
0.0480155311524868,
0.24965500831604004,
0.08980420976877213,
-0.7507051825523376,
0.22023116052150726,
0.048073895275592804,
-0.13672824203968048,
-0.633259654045105,
0.06735223531723022,
-0.5365351438522339,
-0.24449370801448822,
-0.042197562754154205,
-0.6162919998168945,
0.24839608371257782,
0.4158770740032196,
-0.22763480246067047,
1.2024664878845215,
0.26053938269615173,
-0.8528529405593872,
0.5738107562065125,
0.2291422039270401,
-0.4966094493865967,
0.8508177995681763,
-0.8663965463638306,
0.1696464568376541,
-0.3196890950202942,
-0.4116343557834625,
-0.8209304213523865,
-0.22247640788555145,
0.20629717409610748,
-0.644010603427887,
0.2517462968826294,
0.0014882837422192097,
-0.5994414687156677,
-0.09130589663982391,
-0.2195557802915573,
0.49925220012664795,
0.972835123538971,
-0.7940636277198792,
0.6973417401313782,
0.41414397954940796,
-0.2315906584262848,
-0.3211645483970642,
-0.32439690828323364,
-0.0646461546421051,
-0.6815687417984009,
-0.45766976475715637,
0.41240668296813965,
0.06545178592205048,
-0.22944971919059753,
-0.1649186760187149,
0.012307189404964447,
-0.07583984732627869,
0.1309112310409546,
0.2270146608352661,
0.07325875014066696,
-0.23041966557502747,
0.41100555658340454,
0.07917534559965134,
-0.2825791835784912,
0.10842538625001907,
-0.1504422128200531,
0.21338458359241486,
-0.40676769614219666,
-0.6355394721031189,
-0.13477890193462372,
0.3903171122074127,
0.4596059322357178,
-0.7316468358039856,
0.7349233031272888,
0.6524507403373718,
-0.1307486891746521,
-0.1930011659860611,
-0.6975328922271729,
0.36557552218437195,
-0.4898311197757721,
0.300031453371048,
-0.5617368817329407,
-0.1326560378074646,
0.3936220109462738,
-0.19058455526828766,
-0.14798638224601746,
0.6319153904914856,
0.6346338987350464,
-0.15832848846912384,
1.1532666683197021,
0.6697033047676086,
0.23785601556301117,
0.17655180394649506,
-0.20756471157073975,
0.7514608502388,
-0.666415810585022,
-0.6402745842933655,
-0.5590922236442566,
-0.2503125071525574,
-0.540226399898529,
-0.33065325021743774,
0.6296858787536621,
0.04337335377931595,
-0.1642158031463623,
0.2611992657184601,
-0.7302473187446594,
0.43014365434646606,
0.7178359031677246,
0.2631966769695282,
0.040006060153245926,
0.3706943988800049,
0.47150689363479614,
0.12130957841873169,
-0.4117977023124695,
-0.277536004781723,
1.3578251600265503,
0.22175931930541992,
0.7516913414001465,
0.22773608565330505,
0.2270173728466034,
0.29470834136009216,
0.05695078894495964,
-0.8263368606567383,
0.34354978799819946,
-0.23145553469657898,
-0.1315757781267166,
-0.05397821590304375,
-0.16858145594596863,
-0.6538023352622986,
0.08013691008090973,
-0.3995046019554138,
-0.5946297645568848,
0.7012717127799988,
0.32770684361457825,
-0.5888456106185913,
-0.015685850754380226,
-0.7683041095733643,
0.8245447874069214,
-0.707300066947937,
-0.6039585471153259,
-0.07019030302762985,
-0.12998385727405548,
-0.0024301933590322733,
-0.09591502696275711,
-0.04841990768909454,
0.003815003903582692,
0.21207685768604279,
0.5963890552520752,
-0.4811921715736389,
0.3206470012664795,
0.042239341884851456,
0.1393711417913437,
0.27867239713668823,
-0.2936962842941284,
0.3595082759857178,
-0.20176802575588226,
-0.08904073387384415,
-0.06280238926410675,
-0.2310282588005066,
-0.3476675748825073,
-0.7835612297058105,
0.541836678981781,
-0.8721131682395935,
-0.45883020758628845,
-0.38305479288101196,
-0.07096210867166519,
-0.08375825732946396,
-0.11476387828588486,
0.43917661905288696,
0.47330692410469055,
-0.4320390522480011,
0.6866282820701599,
1.0516464710235596,
-0.6703800559043884,
0.47051844000816345,
0.24665150046348572,
0.2999924123287201,
-0.20849910378456116,
1.092423677444458,
-0.07547548413276672,
0.3275352716445923,
0.4749816954135895,
0.059701040387153625,
-0.14858417212963104,
-0.4059683382511139,
-0.37633267045021057,
-0.311555415391922,
-0.7153120636940002,
-0.2941822111606598,
-0.47632914781570435,
-0.31409600377082825,
-0.23916354775428772,
-0.07202552258968353,
-0.5536124110221863,
-0.17295444011688232,
-0.16218484938144684,
-0.24208253622055054,
0.470114141702652,
0.560897707939148,
0.05966692417860031,
0.21510769426822662,
-0.33053797483444214,
0.18917711079120636,
0.6759471297264099,
0.1633121222257614,
-0.007092262152582407,
0.024189850315451622,
-0.22567705810070038,
0.14019198715686798,
-0.5030533075332642,
-1.0817066431045532,
0.5000236630439758,
0.49266064167022705,
0.6272075772285461,
0.7765653133392334,
-0.007367587648332119,
0.8363505005836487,
-0.17113462090492249,
1.0816558599472046,
0.2213520109653473,
-0.8404127955436707,
0.4722384810447693,
0.08811996132135391,
0.13550451397895813,
0.4897160530090332,
0.3387722671031952,
-0.18980979919433594,
0.39483925700187683,
-0.5136255025863647,
-1.2803062200546265,
0.2699105143547058,
0.400751531124115,
0.07106007635593414,
-0.1214749664068222,
0.25807273387908936,
0.3909660279750824,
0.3603457808494568,
-0.5239208936691284,
-0.14560291171073914,
-0.28187188506126404,
-0.2003597617149353,
0.09257150441408157,
-0.25558266043663025,
0.10823880136013031,
-0.26204270124435425,
0.5807890892028809,
-0.021711254492402077,
0.4380320906639099,
-0.11073964089155197,
-0.3041127920150757,
0.14501649141311646,
0.32540053129196167,
0.21508438885211945,
0.7041580080986023,
0.01937110163271427,
0.015347979962825775,
0.18734538555145264,
-0.1263006329536438,
0.12691175937652588,
-0.14259031414985657,
-0.1683645397424698,
-0.15880167484283447,
0.08933805674314499,
1.0233124494552612,
-0.41402119398117065,
-0.6055271625518799,
0.8145672678947449,
-0.06190594285726547,
-0.11671881377696991,
-0.4291440546512604,
-0.04915967956185341,
-0.3957945704460144,
0.024343358352780342,
0.37843865156173706,
-0.22885224223136902,
0.5242512226104736,
-0.48372456431388855,
-0.15500657260417938,
0.5595176815986633,
-0.10670135915279388,
-0.31440964341163635,
0.5823209881782532,
0.26578882336616516,
-0.43357759714126587,
0.7003704905509949,
-0.5177290439605713,
-0.17556627094745636,
0.8557405471801758,
0.4313533902168274,
1.1924570798873901,
-0.09430617094039917,
0.3027246296405792,
0.2016844004392624,
0.10958441346883774,
0.28880083560943604,
0.07438606768846512,
-0.4937698543071747,
-0.767808735370636,
-0.23455695807933807,
-0.9219608306884766,
-0.06252666562795639,
0.41768017411231995,
-0.867918848991394,
0.07261231541633606,
-0.008489676751196384,
-0.04960507154464722,
0.38402503728866577,
-0.26191094517707825,
-1.175153374671936,
0.33028489351272583,
0.03632887080311775,
0.33883410692214966,
-1.2700718641281128,
0.23800599575042725,
0.5711326003074646,
-0.7347042560577393,
-0.6357175707817078,
-0.0565016083419323,
-0.07135572284460068,
-0.5892276167869568,
0.8770150542259216,
0.02748878486454487,
-0.07270719110965729,
-0.3735484182834625,
-0.3396342992782593,
-0.6538692712783813,
1.2591160535812378,
-0.020005932077765465,
-0.21687503159046173,
0.15540175139904022,
0.40786585211753845,
0.5627861618995667,
-0.5630174875259399,
0.5863513350486755,
0.6963446140289307,
0.3123677372932434,
0.32523614168167114,
-0.6765690445899963,
-0.31571322679519653,
-0.77784264087677,
0.4757237434387207,
-0.009271621704101562,
-0.412263423204422,
0.7932342290878296,
0.2231438010931015,
-0.316030353307724,
0.045868076384067535,
0.5845069289207458,
0.07486242055892944,
0.19623620808124542,
0.5200037360191345,
0.7278730273246765,
0.6455726027488708,
-0.21012182533740997,
0.9487131834030151,
-0.412365585565567,
0.27455320954322815,
0.7136008739471436,
0.041095003485679626,
0.8499212861061096,
0.20292384922504425,
-0.3086552619934082,
0.13754701614379883,
0.632646918296814,
-0.2937540113925934,
0.8270453810691833,
-0.016310572624206543,
-0.32437875866889954,
-0.2430739402770996,
-0.03846852481365204,
-0.3073508143424988,
0.5182659029960632,
0.45690080523490906,
-0.5396395921707153,
-0.03036014549434185,
0.2229345291852951,
-0.22840039432048798,
-0.11270048469305038,
-0.2842438817024231,
1.1678398847579956,
-0.4027577340602875,
-0.447158545255661,
0.37655192613601685,
0.16697289049625397,
0.22382578253746033,
-0.3102099597454071,
-0.14468710124492645,
-0.08743397891521454,
0.2644355297088623,
-0.05874955654144287,
-0.47540074586868286,
0.06130990386009216,
0.18898244202136993,
-0.18839521706104279,
-0.35421836376190186,
0.666962206363678,
-0.17272444069385529,
-0.8198935985565186,
-0.5092878341674805,
0.2851625680923462,
-0.11592284590005875,
0.1269773691892624,
-0.39110586047172546,
-0.06561451405286789,
-0.2376387119293213,
-0.35612374544143677,
0.1919851154088974,
0.2202225774526596,
-0.0031458078883588314,
0.5328662991523743,
0.58961021900177,
0.021997658535838127,
0.16597364842891693,
-0.1940760314464569,
0.6250235438346863,
-0.26335078477859497,
-0.4884190559387207,
-0.7326647639274597,
0.6227944493293762,
-0.5192503333091736,
-0.45527327060699463,
0.9374473094940186,
0.7495208978652954,
0.9263392686843872,
-0.22838862240314484,
0.9163599014282227,
-0.25227198004722595,
0.011871175840497017,
-0.3811085522174835,
0.5278421640396118,
-0.44822245836257935,
0.3723733127117157,
-0.1689695417881012,
-0.8522486090660095,
-0.03190257027745247,
0.7104499340057373,
-0.2500816583633423,
-0.015601858496665955,
0.32980841398239136,
0.9758540391921997,
-0.24399441480636597,
-0.21568895876407623,
0.1506195068359375,
0.005636424757540226,
0.5412931442260742,
0.5648002028465271,
0.7073019742965698,
-0.6493157148361206,
0.22202253341674805,
-0.16048143804073334,
-0.3629884719848633,
-0.09907159209251404,
-0.9531506299972534,
-0.4021706283092499,
-0.6810949444770813,
-0.44101762771606445,
-0.1819612979888916,
0.4965455234050751,
1.0048255920410156,
0.8138070702552795,
-0.7720250487327576,
0.12224002927541733,
-0.2240799218416214,
-0.3555370569229126,
-0.6836800575256348,
-0.1410088837146759,
0.4701968729496002,
-0.16759583353996277,
-0.6630375385284424,
0.19603149592876434,
0.39541178941726685,
-0.18775786459445953,
-0.29189741611480713,
-0.07021796703338623,
0.3855528235435486,
0.3769478499889374,
0.6442112922668457,
0.368130087852478,
-0.7623698711395264,
-0.25353869795799255,
0.07098191976547241,
0.4250089228153229,
0.2096576690673828,
0.610924243927002,
-0.7759755849838257,
0.7917179465293884,
0.8621048927307129,
0.7989034652709961,
0.5843621492385864,
0.34649866819381714,
0.7580573558807373,
-0.6981898546218872,
-0.077293261885643,
-0.050739046186208725,
0.0582132488489151,
0.23946288228034973,
-0.2802806794643402,
0.1546991765499115,
-0.1481555998325348,
-0.48494699597358704,
-0.7614568471908569,
0.47010472416877747,
-0.8072201609611511,
-0.013158612884581089,
1.0800855159759521,
-0.20255623757839203,
-0.3952998220920563,
0.40910080075263977,
0.08609149605035782,
0.012898809276521206,
-0.03499689698219299,
0.7925422787666321,
0.4403670132160187,
0.00025770344655029476,
-0.34056299924850464,
-0.19506454467773438,
0.3293924927711487,
-0.05776872858405113,
-0.739916205406189,
-0.35405731201171875,
0.41925519704818726,
0.0032458980567753315,
0.12604470551013947,
0.22242410480976105,
-0.20231349766254425,
0.434170126914978,
0.06532736867666245,
0.20611882209777832,
-0.46502330899238586,
-0.31110674142837524,
-0.2667701840400696,
0.5495107769966125,
0.2765757441520691,
-0.5109524130821228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01130v1 | Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning for Speech Translation | 2024-07-01T09:51:48 | 2024-07-01T09:51:48 | Rao Ma, Yassir Fathullah, Mengjie Qian, Siyuan Tang, Mark Gales, Kate Knill | cs.CL | cs.CL | There has been increasing interest in building multilingual foundation models
for NLP and speech research. Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer has been
demonstrated on a range of NLP tasks where a model fine-tuned on task-specific
data in one language yields performance gains in other languages. Here, we
explore whether speech-based models exhibit the same transfer capability. Using
Whisper as an example of a multilingual speech foundation model, we examine the
utterance representation generated by the speech encoder. Despite some
language-sensitive information being preserved in the audio embedding, words
from different languages are mapped to a similar semantic space, as evidenced
by a high recall rate in a speech-to-speech retrieval task. Leveraging this
shared embedding space, zero-shot cross-lingual transfer is demonstrated in
speech translation. When the Whisper model is fine-tuned solely on
English-to-Chinese translation data, performance improvements are observed for
input utterances in other languages. Additionally, experiments on low-resource
languages show that Whisper can perform speech translation for utterances from
languages unseen during pre-training by utilizing cross-lingual
representations. | [
0.012124134227633476,
-0.41709011793136597,
0.3091927766799927,
0.38203442096710205,
-0.03377320617437363,
0.0033134426921606064,
-0.23569712042808533,
-0.7560046315193176,
0.2442837953567505,
0.4189208447933197,
-0.38757431507110596,
-0.3305554986000061,
-0.7051869034767151,
-0.14039619266986847,
-0.6082398295402527,
0.7552288174629211,
-0.06693518161773682,
0.07892081141471863,
0.15198065340518951,
-0.16903944313526154,
-0.5709039568901062,
-0.4665406048297882,
-0.4809142053127289,
-0.4541589915752411,
0.2776919901371002,
0.1706441342830658,
0.5928992629051208,
0.2574063539505005,
0.0456220805644989,
0.1721171736717224,
0.13435456156730652,
-0.3557286560535431,
-0.6219683885574341,
-0.1686468869447708,
-0.2845234274864197,
-0.46685707569122314,
-0.2900165319442749,
-0.19033260643482208,
0.8711697459220886,
0.9110222458839417,
-0.2602238655090332,
-0.050023552030324936,
0.1350344866514206,
0.31177181005477905,
-0.5044170022010803,
0.16980601847171783,
-0.8251029253005981,
0.33833688497543335,
-0.07755731046199799,
-0.3327532708644867,
-0.5661207437515259,
-0.10564660280942917,
0.5896451473236084,
-0.710943341255188,
0.14093360304832458,
-0.11028672009706497,
0.7139168381690979,
0.05658000707626343,
-0.4984590411186218,
-0.36157459020614624,
-0.801679790019989,
0.7240954637527466,
-0.6185196042060852,
0.7861600518226624,
0.2393106371164322,
0.17046192288398743,
0.4352458715438843,
-0.5021199584007263,
-0.4739450514316559,
-0.09075168520212173,
-0.08791187405586243,
0.13700886070728302,
-0.34567001461982727,
-0.14105306565761566,
-0.11126908659934998,
0.1572825312614441,
-0.6907913684844971,
0.08720821887254715,
-0.4791646897792816,
-0.4941716492176056,
0.5387821793556213,
-0.2630128860473633,
0.5474914312362671,
-0.19436155259609222,
-0.5759585499763489,
-0.2295255810022354,
-0.747484028339386,
0.1951884776353836,
-0.09708783030509949,
0.7461740970611572,
-0.4001077115535736,
0.3931422531604767,
-0.038197122514247894,
0.7007455229759216,
-0.029610853642225266,
-0.15735965967178345,
0.2938179075717926,
-0.3693743050098419,
-0.03194211795926094,
0.7449333667755127,
0.5340796709060669,
0.16884879767894745,
0.5307258367538452,
-0.5059700608253479,
0.10702329874038696,
-0.10112941265106201,
-0.153841033577919,
-0.7021952867507935,
-0.042276088148355484,
-0.22812190651893616,
-0.2711646258831024,
0.08900011330842972,
-0.14992615580558777,
-0.30657124519348145,
-0.08225645869970322,
-0.09249362349510193,
0.6732175350189209,
-0.4863317012786865,
-0.5739821195602417,
0.39111119508743286,
-0.05431975796818733,
0.64472895860672,
0.04704377055168152,
-0.9034327864646912,
0.3400413990020752,
0.4647393524646759,
0.9284746050834656,
-0.3960410952568054,
-0.7105193138122559,
-0.794068455696106,
0.5449675917625427,
-0.5573089122772217,
0.6301295161247253,
-0.5195557475090027,
-0.5987213850021362,
0.2886548638343811,
0.07688633352518082,
-0.559252142906189,
-0.4861356317996979,
0.12673531472682953,
-0.15899956226348877,
0.1191488653421402,
-0.2639070451259613,
-0.509978711605072,
-0.35083964467048645,
-0.03611372783780098,
-0.4521923363208771,
0.6790039539337158,
0.08153267204761505,
-0.3036203682422638,
0.25922662019729614,
-0.35998862981796265,
-0.8077514171600342,
0.008797260001301765,
0.0470212958753109,
0.05739014595746994,
0.11000468581914902,
0.16126427054405212,
0.48128658533096313,
-0.015774419531226158,
0.017180034890770912,
-0.06402934342622757,
-0.3639044463634491,
0.2179202437400818,
-0.41553008556365967,
0.8300001621246338,
-0.09116733074188232,
-0.27492088079452515,
-0.0422544926404953,
-0.5887303352355957,
0.10882964730262756,
-0.09842675179243088,
-0.2096492201089859,
-0.39411330223083496,
-0.5240008234977722,
0.2587818503379822,
0.33485695719718933,
0.13797533512115479,
-0.8231046199798584,
-0.19526858627796173,
-0.4034394919872284,
0.4435279667377472,
0.291562020778656,
-0.18786261975765228,
0.734916627407074,
-0.3722294569015503,
0.49000439047813416,
0.03577717766165733,
-0.20468389987945557,
-0.29011744260787964,
-0.4270114600658417,
-0.7451885938644409,
0.04115837439894676,
0.511642575263977,
0.8832002878189087,
-0.8120175004005432,
-0.05692537873983383,
-0.4101163446903229,
-0.2808454632759094,
-1.0058867931365967,
-0.05891072005033493,
0.47786062955856323,
0.694982647895813,
0.4934624433517456,
-0.24246886372566223,
-0.17227667570114136,
-0.7537954449653625,
-0.1873721033334732,
-0.24457955360412598,
0.11858417093753815,
0.4215916097164154,
0.06801222264766693,
0.04989056661725044,
0.601898729801178,
-0.22726500034332275,
-0.6100077033042908,
-0.30138736963272095,
0.19166767597198486,
-0.09937098622322083,
0.5510615110397339,
0.7183637619018555,
-0.6622044444084167,
-0.8663569092750549,
0.4632963240146637,
-0.5426468253135681,
-0.3163951635360718,
-0.36141571402549744,
-0.1903425008058548,
0.23830939829349518,
0.46547386050224304,
-0.5364859700202942,
0.2417316734790802,
0.9944210648536682,
-0.2772047519683838,
0.4113596975803375,
-0.0783323347568512,
0.2342848926782608,
-1.104626178741455,
0.16726349294185638,
-0.41812431812286377,
-0.3707509934902191,
-0.8212546110153198,
-0.14254875481128693,
0.07848186045885086,
-0.3490660786628723,
-0.9870441555976868,
0.7876396775245667,
-0.35717472434043884,
-0.3449016213417053,
-0.15702342987060547,
0.38325783610343933,
-0.004939479753375053,
0.5473619699478149,
0.514801561832428,
0.8082747459411621,
0.970016598701477,
-0.5277378559112549,
0.10766425728797913,
0.35236167907714844,
-0.10182025283575058,
0.7756052017211914,
-0.7915722727775574,
0.17533494532108307,
0.2728813886642456,
0.05109182372689247,
-0.7963603734970093,
0.22555355727672577,
0.061290133744478226,
-0.6004008650779724,
0.4776042401790619,
-0.307032972574234,
0.009247075766324997,
0.38491907715797424,
0.1391611099243164,
0.3371179699897766,
0.538763701915741,
-0.5356540679931641,
0.6253299713134766,
0.3186422288417816,
-0.5347231030464172,
-0.5502870678901672,
-1.0034575462341309,
-0.0024852463975548744,
0.034528519958257675,
-0.6346892714500427,
0.7232060432434082,
0.13001936674118042,
0.21192632615566254,
0.24638676643371582,
-0.015345114283263683,
-0.19138427078723907,
-0.285224974155426,
0.11469737440347672,
0.23059314489364624,
-0.36985504627227783,
-0.021915996447205544,
0.08441732078790665,
-0.06520221382379532,
-0.019496317952871323,
-0.37969300150871277,
0.49716880917549133,
-0.009141010232269764,
-0.5689951181411743,
-0.28173279762268066,
0.6954880356788635,
0.34032580256462097,
-0.2534705102443695,
0.6484132409095764,
0.7052003145217896,
-0.3049108684062958,
-0.31316083669662476,
-0.26247143745422363,
-0.1063246876001358,
-0.3579171597957611,
0.42065346240997314,
-0.6676574349403381,
-0.9642975926399231,
0.6750043630599976,
-0.1292465627193451,
0.06393927335739136,
0.4193451404571533,
0.37284260988235474,
0.04024646803736687,
0.8488871455192566,
0.9463748335838318,
-0.28903448581695557,
0.41370177268981934,
-0.25076180696487427,
0.0521024614572525,
-0.7608945369720459,
-0.20817694067955017,
-0.5094476938247681,
-0.14479638636112213,
-0.3543993830680847,
-0.5145852565765381,
0.14337430894374847,
0.05155807361006737,
0.11895358562469482,
0.5639662742614746,
-0.08115692436695099,
0.24235151708126068,
0.33163684606552124,
-0.3135235011577606,
0.36472752690315247,
0.12708014249801636,
-0.23262858390808105,
-0.17373767495155334,
-0.9507595300674438,
0.052587755024433136,
0.6866503953933716,
0.1952708661556244,
0.6110577583312988,
0.18279404938220978,
0.5910272002220154,
0.11488445103168488,
-0.0005765135283581913,
-0.7549874186515808,
0.32132768630981445,
-0.47154906392097473,
-0.33299922943115234,
-0.32116034626960754,
-0.49363043904304504,
-0.9133397936820984,
0.5002875328063965,
-0.24937209486961365,
-0.5750666260719299,
0.3554256856441498,
-0.19859585165977478,
-0.14355677366256714,
0.2488662600517273,
-0.5821924805641174,
0.7932224869728088,
-0.23711563646793365,
-0.0841742530465126,
-0.3288075923919678,
-0.41573086380958557,
0.1338881403207779,
-0.19119921326637268,
0.027924608439207077,
-0.13821324706077576,
0.11694978922605515,
0.6034649014472961,
0.045332565903663635,
0.7904850840568542,
-0.18887214362621307,
-0.34278783202171326,
0.09225933998823166,
0.39033862948417664,
0.228079691529274,
-0.28002670407295227,
-0.05506287142634392,
0.6209747195243835,
0.12668465077877045,
-0.2952282428741455,
-0.6443293690681458,
0.6440417170524597,
-0.7582478523254395,
-0.3894844949245453,
-0.20851081609725952,
-0.5335226655006409,
-0.33761078119277954,
0.24174965918064117,
0.28028005361557007,
0.33281537890434265,
-0.3310639262199402,
0.2717682719230652,
0.5477015972137451,
-0.2887299060821533,
0.42114824056625366,
1.0323368310928345,
-0.4620417356491089,
-0.0188436359167099,
1.0398292541503906,
0.3289850056171417,
0.5645655989646912,
0.5859866738319397,
0.1776406615972519,
-0.4357934296131134,
-0.4699379801750183,
-0.8962280750274658,
0.2982611358165741,
-0.5667849183082581,
0.1290106177330017,
-0.5036471486091614,
-0.5170704126358032,
-0.6342300176620483,
-0.39244574308395386,
-0.581998348236084,
-0.5711748003959656,
-0.1383362114429474,
-0.11217052489519119,
0.15952180325984955,
0.37650325894355774,
-0.3584677577018738,
0.22354517877101898,
-1.1063576936721802,
0.3948875367641449,
0.42998167872428894,
0.08546371012926102,
0.027860533446073532,
-1.047295331954956,
-0.2834748327732086,
0.11001110821962357,
0.184865340590477,
-0.9140603542327881,
0.5929874181747437,
0.6727859377861023,
0.7258725762367249,
0.08419393748044968,
0.16898229718208313,
0.8027124404907227,
-0.7047922611236572,
0.7949132323265076,
0.2963508069515228,
-1.217990517616272,
0.46438729763031006,
-0.09247029572725296,
0.41812431812286377,
0.21522833406925201,
0.4914223849773407,
-0.9849414825439453,
-0.2235666811466217,
-0.3092934191226959,
-0.6064035296440125,
0.6787148118019104,
-0.004021139815449715,
0.26441383361816406,
0.3585004210472107,
0.02612096257507801,
0.24349573254585266,
-0.052765119820833206,
-0.5914899706840515,
-0.03793354704976082,
-0.32663336396217346,
0.1939040869474411,
-0.12549039721488953,
0.1974726915359497,
-0.02357841655611992,
-0.07458968460559845,
0.4696759283542633,
-0.24448738992214203,
0.07759566605091095,
0.3243066072463989,
-0.437808096408844,
-0.11448197811841965,
0.3472212851047516,
0.3416902720928192,
0.35878413915634155,
0.028869394212961197,
0.02750479057431221,
0.3854782283306122,
-0.38300684094429016,
0.12263321876525879,
0.33824121952056885,
-0.3336438536643982,
0.16736043989658356,
0.6626713275909424,
1.074373483657837,
0.6732692718505859,
-0.4501815438270569,
0.5912252068519592,
0.16105994582176208,
-0.33122316002845764,
-0.03042498789727688,
-0.08909650146961212,
0.2110779583454132,
0.15747252106666565,
0.362140417098999,
0.039175741374492645,
0.32922491431236267,
-0.7355524301528931,
0.2634577751159668,
0.34673693776130676,
-0.6399143934249878,
-0.5605456829071045,
0.6150067448616028,
0.2438044399023056,
-0.16508044302463531,
0.5741963982582092,
0.208677738904953,
-0.6261608600616455,
0.27713075280189514,
0.950261116027832,
0.9454929232597351,
-0.42498043179512024,
0.4177868664264679,
0.13923488557338715,
0.23336012661457062,
0.15356439352035522,
0.2476026862859726,
-0.4613397717475891,
-0.8471863865852356,
-0.6881991624832153,
-0.6256285905838013,
-0.5400328636169434,
-0.31586042046546936,
-0.8721005320549011,
0.06139092519879341,
0.09854361414909363,
0.15646123886108398,
-0.11638142168521881,
-0.2345605194568634,
-0.7504723072052002,
-0.10036052018404007,
0.5310156345367432,
0.7641631960868835,
-0.9883754849433899,
1.1510809659957886,
0.41396769881248474,
-0.13074542582035065,
-0.9334925413131714,
-0.14920493960380554,
-0.19684197008609772,
-0.9465658664703369,
0.6652799844741821,
-0.01341595221310854,
-0.5333475470542908,
0.06819528341293335,
0.05740952864289284,
-1.0548195838928223,
0.9243208765983582,
0.6926155090332031,
-0.600589394569397,
-0.03633241355419159,
0.4325392246246338,
0.5599651336669922,
-0.45675361156463623,
-0.15212760865688324,
0.32812923192977905,
0.25326794385910034,
0.33324190974235535,
-1.6000421047210693,
-0.10373619943857193,
-0.05543748289346695,
-0.11140351742506027,
-0.15051285922527313,
-0.5210033059120178,
0.8952497243881226,
-0.19006165862083435,
-0.43478938937187195,
-0.1817588061094284,
0.6045202016830444,
0.12237414717674255,
0.24654000997543335,
0.3124464750289917,
0.34547188878059387,
0.5640849471092224,
0.12631560862064362,
0.924919068813324,
-0.36307039856910706,
-0.005948795471340418,
1.0461251735687256,
-0.6370742321014404,
1.3615435361862183,
0.3576924204826355,
-0.010943552479147911,
0.3918645977973938,
0.1632651388645172,
0.3634510636329651,
0.7422560453414917,
-0.336510568857193,
-0.15937021374702454,
-0.07280735671520233,
-0.5128230452537537,
-0.5463712215423584,
0.7750657200813293,
0.3843591511249542,
-0.1459505259990692,
-0.1742144078016281,
0.2479720413684845,
-0.09354115277528763,
0.007199491374194622,
-0.33836501836776733,
0.8364623188972473,
0.2369893193244934,
-0.5708132386207581,
0.7485023140907288,
-0.14665624499320984,
0.8779175281524658,
-0.8564266562461853,
-0.17385104298591614,
-0.11258693039417267,
0.09027749300003052,
-0.156236931681633,
-0.773996889591217,
0.5535497665405273,
-0.2298693209886551,
-0.07517772912979126,
-0.4798029661178589,
0.8675787448883057,
-0.9929272532463074,
-0.3702983558177948,
0.7835639715194702,
0.7738444805145264,
0.3938705027103424,
0.04503951221704483,
-0.6744384765625,
-0.07680375128984451,
0.18848007917404175,
0.06211146339774132,
0.5665879845619202,
0.3461006283760071,
0.03917718306183815,
0.4710640609264374,
0.8359841108322144,
0.6540993452072144,
0.5380198955535889,
0.347267210483551,
0.426724374294281,
-0.5666272044181824,
-0.6710461378097534,
-0.4449913203716278,
0.17682264745235443,
0.2381344437599182,
-0.3391338884830475,
0.8418105840682983,
0.40586113929748535,
1.1962047815322876,
-0.11185114085674286,
0.8236541152000427,
0.10450196266174316,
0.5384972095489502,
-0.6920925974845886,
0.8273324966430664,
-0.4464900493621826,
-0.2746567130088806,
-0.15634042024612427,
-0.8692145943641663,
-0.05159355327486992,
0.6897860169410706,
-0.022399917244911194,
-0.2800979018211365,
0.423134982585907,
0.6931518316268921,
-0.044627122581005096,
-0.046457644551992416,
0.698432981967926,
0.04631614312529564,
0.08083956688642502,
0.7908380627632141,
0.6299988627433777,
-0.5423710942268372,
0.7482909560203552,
-0.30006274580955505,
0.021209636703133583,
-0.010779213160276413,
-0.7618022561073303,
-0.5751169323921204,
-0.740114152431488,
-0.3280237913131714,
0.00837946031242609,
0.07977242767810822,
0.3888433873653412,
1.0938054323196411,
-0.8560495972633362,
-0.531218409538269,
0.40829211473464966,
-0.08956287801265717,
-0.4461236894130707,
-0.2417827695608139,
0.36281269788742065,
-0.11143475770950317,
-0.7346284985542297,
0.8144949078559875,
0.28388500213623047,
0.10829859972000122,
-0.3970441222190857,
-0.3547048568725586,
-0.11269579082727432,
0.13618165254592896,
0.7020367383956909,
0.4647095501422882,
-0.6624816656112671,
-0.2713908851146698,
0.3379500210285187,
-0.01484573632478714,
-0.14768248796463013,
0.8681113719940186,
-0.8427757024765015,
0.4735359847545624,
0.494905948638916,
0.8459146618843079,
0.7991283535957336,
-0.3301332890987396,
0.7311834692955017,
-0.9115086793899536,
0.2634636163711548,
0.08594595640897751,
0.3319307863712311,
0.6419274806976318,
-0.25429052114486694,
0.30019906163215637,
0.1679084300994873,
-0.23246850073337555,
-0.7155557870864868,
0.04465913027524948,
-0.8850477337837219,
-0.26777249574661255,
1.1215786933898926,
-0.3284810185432434,
-0.02136351354420185,
-0.08884247392416,
-0.08337290585041046,
0.32986488938331604,
-0.28668248653411865,
0.37645044922828674,
0.7624572515487671,
-0.13330771028995514,
-0.3949008882045746,
-0.5300131440162659,
0.3112187087535858,
0.6163422465324402,
-0.40050607919692993,
0.019481606781482697,
0.16988952457904816,
0.3034459054470062,
0.3578087389469147,
0.711816668510437,
-0.18284259736537933,
0.37000370025634766,
0.25352025032043457,
-0.05397563800215721,
0.02856936864554882,
-0.4169153571128845,
-0.47018998861312866,
0.15016524493694305,
-0.19563709199428558,
-0.2686328589916229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01126v1 | Investigating the potential of Sparse Mixtures-of-Experts for multi-domain neural machine translation | 2024-07-01T09:45:22 | 2024-07-01T09:45:22 | Nadezhda Chirkova, Vassilina Nikoulina, Jean-Luc Meunier, Alexandre Bérard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We focus on multi-domain Neural Machine Translation, with the goal of
developing efficient models which can handle data from various domains seen
during training and are robust to domains unseen during training. We
hypothesize that Sparse Mixture-of-Experts (SMoE) models are a good fit for
this task, as they enable efficient model scaling, which helps to accommodate a
variety of multi-domain data, and allow flexible sharing of parameters between
domains, potentially enabling knowledge transfer between similar domains and
limiting negative transfer. We conduct a series of experiments aimed at
validating the utility of SMoE for the multi-domain scenario, and find that a
straightforward width scaling of Transformer is a simpler and surprisingly more
efficient approach in practice, and reaches the same performance level as SMoE.
We also search for a better recipe for robustness of multi-domain systems,
highlighting the importance of mixing-in a generic domain, i.e. Paracrawl, and
introducing a simple technique, domain randomization. | [
-0.631546139717102,
-0.298244833946228,
0.6084551215171814,
0.3108898401260376,
-0.015314802527427673,
0.18416689336299896,
-0.3719809651374817,
-0.36826518177986145,
0.37771788239479065,
0.43748652935028076,
-0.4555465281009674,
0.039328765124082565,
-1.1102032661437988,
0.23007051646709442,
-0.4109199345111847,
0.9022809863090515,
0.05532466992735863,
0.07311559468507767,
-0.17752936482429504,
-0.3584047853946686,
-0.5901803374290466,
-0.5111428499221802,
-0.26249420642852783,
-0.14337606728076935,
0.5376202464103699,
0.29480454325675964,
0.8751235604286194,
0.576947808265686,
0.20168668031692505,
0.3730953335762024,
0.01702525094151497,
0.5038496255874634,
-0.4247153103351593,
0.2953566908836365,
-0.08231005072593689,
-0.2501051127910614,
-0.6706272959709167,
-0.010468111373484135,
0.3570689558982849,
0.9537321329116821,
-0.22706106305122375,
-0.06301943957805634,
0.2984095811843872,
0.15520480275154114,
-0.40469837188720703,
-0.10948937386274338,
-0.9794787168502808,
-0.0907364934682846,
0.10551688075065613,
-0.23375661671161652,
-0.3960607051849365,
0.14841964840888977,
0.31099072098731995,
-0.8096593022346497,
0.427685409784317,
0.33836495876312256,
0.4819068908691406,
0.4553016722202301,
-0.6419336199760437,
0.019385607913136482,
-0.6663095355033875,
1.1988989114761353,
-0.636090874671936,
0.4533838927745819,
0.18493054807186127,
0.5370013117790222,
-0.16407997906208038,
-0.6603298187255859,
-0.5461244583129883,
0.030575614422559738,
-0.10521258413791656,
-0.04976627603173256,
-0.07114299386739731,
-0.06372293829917908,
-0.05183601379394531,
0.2563987672328949,
-0.5388197898864746,
-0.14918667078018188,
-0.3027670681476593,
-0.1038733646273613,
0.5543937087059021,
0.036938756704330444,
0.30136626958847046,
0.27074214816093445,
-0.4286324679851532,
0.10925830155611038,
-0.2846260070800781,
-0.4470769762992859,
0.21755357086658478,
0.2933865487575531,
0.13205033540725708,
0.5175140500068665,
0.1160443127155304,
0.6477558612823486,
0.21754826605319977,
-0.35165315866470337,
0.1585742086172104,
-0.30651208758354187,
-0.11216208338737488,
-0.2744354009628296,
0.7266294956207275,
0.28511694073677063,
0.1868322342634201,
-0.6934512257575989,
-0.4048044979572296,
-0.21735721826553345,
0.5464391112327576,
-0.8071253299713135,
-0.27029022574424744,
0.23730088770389557,
-0.43734511733055115,
-0.2545950710773468,
-0.3234904110431671,
-0.876173198223114,
-0.2533373534679413,
-0.38050100207328796,
0.6896845698356628,
-0.41263481974601746,
-0.4468543827533722,
0.09337878972291946,
-0.4094996750354767,
-0.31733179092407227,
0.2684269845485687,
-1.193325161933899,
0.6639055609703064,
0.46692994236946106,
0.6676417589187622,
-0.5104724168777466,
-0.8401332497596741,
-0.2415838986635208,
0.09395971149206161,
-0.1317657232284546,
0.6331194639205933,
-0.28381529450416565,
-0.25475114583969116,
-0.277719646692276,
-0.10959496349096298,
-0.674834132194519,
-0.7191513180732727,
0.2895893156528473,
-0.4777844548225403,
-0.07861370593309402,
-0.20091989636421204,
-0.43795961141586304,
-0.1227407231926918,
0.05262194573879242,
-0.6047465801239014,
0.9212465286254883,
0.23730725049972534,
-0.3524676561355591,
0.3953874707221985,
-0.2795495390892029,
-0.4966689348220825,
0.0530974417924881,
-0.23926883935928345,
-0.1796598583459854,
0.41720879077911377,
0.2350618541240692,
0.5480483174324036,
-0.22225132584571838,
0.25364312529563904,
-0.2871309220790863,
-0.22673878073692322,
0.6159700155258179,
-0.48089978098869324,
0.605394184589386,
0.39292988181114197,
-0.3857114315032959,
-0.05637421831488609,
-0.5629259347915649,
0.009558766148984432,
0.07901512831449509,
0.03380592167377472,
-0.513408899307251,
-0.05910921096801758,
0.16010482609272003,
0.4721628427505493,
0.16238605976104736,
-0.3099484443664551,
0.024786517024040222,
0.09319351613521576,
0.5711641907691956,
0.6000909209251404,
0.04771380499005318,
0.8054222464561462,
-0.3804050087928772,
0.4980587959289551,
0.31310129165649414,
0.1132889837026596,
0.1307663470506668,
-0.9053530097007751,
-0.569634199142456,
-0.5158138275146484,
0.6236217617988586,
0.4202021062374115,
-0.8871404528617859,
0.41237545013427734,
-0.19506581127643585,
-0.23530957102775574,
-0.917540431022644,
0.21592207252979279,
-0.012337714433670044,
0.44932883977890015,
0.685627281665802,
-0.27005884051322937,
-0.14933450520038605,
-0.8328461647033691,
-0.2622098922729492,
0.5011327266693115,
-0.06774599105119705,
0.45676448941230774,
0.48428237438201904,
-0.45016196370124817,
0.518714964389801,
-0.5077559947967529,
0.008285374380648136,
-0.19604021310806274,
0.17442527413368225,
-0.05819788575172424,
0.649538516998291,
0.9177048802375793,
-0.9832732677459717,
-0.6764674186706543,
0.28716206550598145,
-0.6675244569778442,
0.1853342205286026,
-0.2169920951128006,
-0.24667328596115112,
-0.2685270607471466,
0.0768752321600914,
-0.841366171836853,
0.13979870080947876,
0.7223121523857117,
0.19482675194740295,
0.35582637786865234,
-0.3791627883911133,
0.4357043206691742,
-1.0706857442855835,
-0.11069989204406738,
0.1828247606754303,
-0.2101728618144989,
-1.0850235223770142,
0.3171425759792328,
0.1912030726671219,
-0.1657179296016693,
-0.45306113362312317,
0.007722614798694849,
-0.47247713804244995,
0.14207586646080017,
-0.2942982614040375,
0.008780241943895817,
-0.01815890334546566,
0.7108724117279053,
-0.0971413105726242,
0.9919034838676453,
0.6082737445831299,
-0.6690043807029724,
-0.2758510410785675,
0.040955282747745514,
0.04396761581301689,
0.556141197681427,
-0.6540127992630005,
0.08392880111932755,
0.11621581763029099,
-0.21578703820705414,
-0.8259580731391907,
-0.23525328934192657,
-0.056641586124897,
-0.6334660649299622,
0.4271422326564789,
-0.23727324604988098,
-0.4435696303844452,
-0.11154285818338394,
-0.01991437003016472,
0.5088754892349243,
0.5670862793922424,
-0.36763328313827515,
0.7052775025367737,
0.7147239446640015,
-0.2762950658798218,
-0.6055917143821716,
-0.8241212964057922,
0.13270790874958038,
-0.3555457890033722,
-0.7564050555229187,
0.5673857927322388,
-0.39021119475364685,
-0.10353384912014008,
-0.084515281021595,
-0.32638707756996155,
-0.7205604314804077,
0.20318540930747986,
-0.047427307814359665,
0.15361256897449493,
-0.38987359404563904,
-0.48784953355789185,
0.6126207709312439,
0.023970067501068115,
0.016670698300004005,
-0.5610812902450562,
0.2005356103181839,
-0.004622756503522396,
-0.0829097330570221,
-0.11138209700584412,
0.7005622982978821,
0.824375569820404,
-0.1863900125026703,
1.0652663707733154,
0.5034035444259644,
-0.5656093955039978,
-0.5862076282501221,
-0.3518525958061218,
-0.27313047647476196,
-0.49486568570137024,
0.2516935169696808,
-0.5160741209983826,
-0.792938232421875,
0.4722502529621124,
-0.3088812232017517,
-0.07586561143398285,
0.6749958992004395,
0.5237221717834473,
-0.10488710552453995,
1.212554931640625,
0.8508524298667908,
0.11418671160936356,
-0.12345407158136368,
-0.2448575645685196,
0.2998024523258209,
-0.6614559888839722,
-0.0762077271938324,
-0.5316850543022156,
-0.3699486553668976,
-0.40425845980644226,
-0.47662630677223206,
0.4151357412338257,
-0.21208471059799194,
0.3098450303077698,
0.6869685053825378,
-0.5506447553634644,
0.537538468837738,
0.4148980975151062,
-0.019908778369426727,
0.051142990589141846,
0.0986999049782753,
-0.24215473234653473,
-0.21087272465229034,
-1.1103284358978271,
-0.2565663456916809,
0.933201789855957,
0.22630396485328674,
0.5456979274749756,
-0.09834905713796616,
0.6017520427703857,
0.17743012309074402,
0.07442008703947067,
-0.74000084400177,
0.3422553539276123,
-0.23405341804027557,
-0.5379924178123474,
-0.19149839878082275,
-0.6013697981834412,
-0.8367503881454468,
0.8232974410057068,
-0.3075961172580719,
-0.19942757487297058,
0.44745394587516785,
-0.024099335074424744,
-0.5137532353401184,
0.3778940439224243,
-0.7317011952400208,
0.8591814637184143,
-0.1639917939901352,
-0.02881290204823017,
-0.07124052196741104,
-0.9118520617485046,
0.35653388500213623,
-0.38373690843582153,
0.33522120118141174,
0.24847576022148132,
-0.08223433792591095,
0.39576175808906555,
-0.38250815868377686,
0.5437959432601929,
0.08693519979715347,
-0.04017721116542816,
0.26746171712875366,
0.14340341091156006,
0.06805042922496796,
-0.05829785764217377,
0.08153560012578964,
0.4833905100822449,
-0.1328698992729187,
-0.44930562376976013,
-0.626818835735321,
0.7590212225914001,
-1.1456905603408813,
-0.19733673334121704,
-0.28525546193122864,
-0.9853156208992004,
-0.3449729382991791,
0.2824734151363373,
0.2684991955757141,
0.2378353476524353,
0.22848977148532867,
0.26149219274520874,
1.0705058574676514,
0.18014679849147797,
0.07750298082828522,
0.34045082330703735,
0.34549760818481445,
-0.6278685927391052,
1.2683708667755127,
0.4474497139453888,
0.29763224720954895,
0.2614171504974365,
-0.0032768582459539175,
0.09482370316982269,
-0.683018147945404,
-0.8890236020088196,
0.06381765007972717,
-0.472144216299057,
-0.32027554512023926,
-0.869085967540741,
-0.25181645154953003,
-0.5428582429885864,
-0.2231081873178482,
-0.39913177490234375,
-0.7023639678955078,
-0.3467939794063568,
0.17252755165100098,
-0.10890258103609085,
0.7612131237983704,
0.19101977348327637,
0.5511522889137268,
-0.7881631255149841,
0.36809176206588745,
0.3651895821094513,
0.023147299885749817,
0.06941276043653488,
-0.632533848285675,
-0.45961523056030273,
0.1442471295595169,
-0.401813805103302,
-0.983322024345398,
0.7009945511817932,
0.06801338493824005,
0.9565443396568298,
0.1522720605134964,
-0.16980145871639252,
0.6917862892150879,
-0.9027078151702881,
0.7740834951400757,
0.02569931000471115,
-0.7781907916069031,
0.00836085993796587,
-0.3048238754272461,
-0.20682726800441742,
0.5047040581703186,
0.7484498023986816,
-0.21033352613449097,
-0.6266651153564453,
-0.7032284140586853,
-0.9068202972412109,
0.38896283507347107,
0.322280615568161,
0.012474029324948788,
0.20827288925647736,
0.32284581661224365,
0.6489971280097961,
0.5718590617179871,
-0.3756848871707916,
-0.5685904026031494,
-0.29640981554985046,
-0.32625266909599304,
-0.02796844020485878,
0.012957551516592503,
-0.19326062500476837,
-0.13401897251605988,
0.5897014141082764,
-0.1982494443655014,
0.2759834825992584,
-0.10571646690368652,
-0.3983834981918335,
-0.3667296767234802,
0.14042268693447113,
0.8318294286727905,
0.5900075435638428,
-0.08141685277223587,
0.3261398673057556,
0.39806196093559265,
-0.4639667570590973,
0.10790225118398666,
0.2572568356990814,
-0.1559644490480423,
0.010240464471280575,
0.04295891523361206,
0.5632032155990601,
0.28983259201049805,
-0.2565053701400757,
0.5308240056037903,
-0.13030555844306946,
-0.6603510975837708,
0.3054717183113098,
0.03623296692967415,
-0.013092930428683758,
0.1631021797657013,
0.5371331572532654,
1.0623421669006348,
0.3627015948295593,
-0.0584813617169857,
0.3286944329738617,
0.07826759666204453,
-0.008276359178125858,
-0.41822609305381775,
0.7946915030479431,
-0.014241328462958336,
-0.09276308119297028,
0.3956015706062317,
-0.08165780454874039,
-0.49847105145454407,
0.5499474406242371,
0.6948391795158386,
0.6996365785598755,
-0.3545335531234741,
-0.011588392779231071,
-0.14592117071151733,
0.5786119699478149,
-0.2514707148075104,
-0.11008679866790771,
-0.032185766845941544,
-0.5114601254463196,
-0.5800318121910095,
-0.21061021089553833,
-0.46957680583000183,
-0.0022777405101805925,
-0.6747435927391052,
-0.034661803394556046,
-0.07139981538057327,
-0.3302682042121887,
-0.014092590659856796,
-0.3836515247821808,
-0.646598756313324,
0.17937371134757996,
-0.04244324564933777,
0.7960228323936462,
-1.0460789203643799,
0.9322946071624756,
0.6622244119644165,
-0.2542937397956848,
-0.5547657012939453,
0.05093662068247795,
-0.14956067502498627,
-0.5912050604820251,
0.2655881345272064,
-0.04384675621986389,
-0.06855153292417526,
-0.15261821448802948,
-0.4984768331050873,
-0.7952402234077454,
1.1723908185958862,
0.32649531960487366,
-0.32800450921058655,
-0.008726987987756729,
0.2757489085197449,
0.4679345488548279,
-0.4556241035461426,
0.04577084630727768,
0.4688572585582733,
0.22760555148124695,
-0.08632689714431763,
-0.9440110325813293,
-0.0747770443558693,
-0.20043298602104187,
-0.05233585834503174,
0.0995216891169548,
-0.6940944194793701,
1.0853699445724487,
0.015561414882540703,
0.3283824324607849,
0.03559567779302597,
0.9215055108070374,
0.11000567674636841,
0.32783108949661255,
0.5021393895149231,
0.39572733640670776,
0.7871335744857788,
0.2482546865940094,
0.8618673086166382,
-0.5583235025405884,
0.24299408495426178,
0.9074118137359619,
-0.22146417200565338,
0.6674484610557556,
0.6052057147026062,
-0.0933607965707779,
0.1828630119562149,
0.34945279359817505,
0.20292380452156067,
0.7820296883583069,
-0.0695575401186943,
-0.28558769822120667,
-0.26438719034194946,
0.10344856977462769,
-0.37674468755722046,
-0.1691480129957199,
0.48091933131217957,
-0.2512124478816986,
0.06339731812477112,
-0.051113542169332504,
-0.184934601187706,
0.013152179308235645,
-0.21149951219558716,
0.5607366561889648,
0.3521398603916168,
-0.6566939353942871,
0.6182951927185059,
0.17188715934753418,
0.7211516499519348,
-0.521263837814331,
0.08350900560617447,
-0.04708196595311165,
0.14651210606098175,
-0.1117890328168869,
-0.5152256488800049,
0.3273431956768036,
-0.32556548714637756,
-0.25608861446380615,
-0.4371393322944641,
0.9451596140861511,
-0.8242285847663879,
-0.18535061180591583,
0.1785607486963272,
0.7969112992286682,
0.16929297149181366,
-0.2157498151063919,
-0.7344293594360352,
-0.14160551130771637,
-0.18902090191841125,
0.011370701715350151,
0.8221315145492554,
0.8831119537353516,
0.20104046165943146,
0.40803951025009155,
0.35471677780151367,
0.10268156975507736,
0.5761008262634277,
-0.1657995730638504,
0.932526707649231,
-0.16504190862178802,
-0.16479358077049255,
-0.5053907632827759,
0.5973546504974365,
0.0840168371796608,
-0.3119278848171234,
1.0905696153640747,
0.43780064582824707,
0.6616750359535217,
-0.44972357153892517,
0.7945634722709656,
0.2346726804971695,
0.13469241559505463,
-0.08193385601043701,
0.9071827530860901,
-0.6230060458183289,
-0.1570221483707428,
-0.08079138398170471,
-0.7677595019340515,
-0.30459409952163696,
0.46647799015045166,
0.23412290215492249,
0.0718463584780693,
0.8136036992073059,
0.6297770738601685,
-0.5025931596755981,
0.14747171103954315,
0.616267204284668,
0.02657407894730568,
-0.03677795082330704,
0.3825400471687317,
0.6377267241477966,
-0.5983677506446838,
0.5933302640914917,
-0.49905726313591003,
-0.2867776155471802,
-0.0393790639936924,
-0.6386151909828186,
-0.9327945709228516,
-0.4727846682071686,
-0.24733318388462067,
-0.23670834302902222,
-0.021384740248322487,
0.9257611036300659,
0.964143693447113,
-0.8906203508377075,
-0.37784531712532043,
0.1670231819152832,
-0.05726614594459534,
-0.6729317307472229,
-0.10725061595439911,
-0.08019271492958069,
-0.5726721882820129,
-0.6576289534568787,
0.8084812760353088,
0.2635708153247833,
0.19933143258094788,
-0.20323055982589722,
-0.19166524708271027,
0.06686294078826904,
0.24277059733867645,
0.6507381796836853,
-0.1881648749113083,
-0.43872806429862976,
0.04916389659047127,
0.40657028555870056,
-0.09840613603591919,
-0.024310432374477386,
0.8983747363090515,
-0.28190556168556213,
0.09716711938381195,
0.4166392683982849,
1.119816780090332,
0.2238391637802124,
-0.1732170283794403,
0.6657665967941284,
-0.9913522005081177,
-0.07019241154193878,
0.14172211289405823,
0.6051703691482544,
0.15040816366672516,
-0.4629118740558624,
0.3294453024864197,
0.44967570900917053,
-0.9581041932106018,
-0.665703535079956,
-0.2674006521701813,
-1.113552451133728,
-0.2846737504005432,
0.9527336359024048,
-0.09492805600166321,
-0.24254050850868225,
-0.1778905689716339,
-0.14269711077213287,
-0.013529487885534763,
-0.445302814245224,
0.5732467770576477,
0.6755936741828918,
0.0019611394964158535,
0.10382887721061707,
-0.9207785725593567,
0.26925721764564514,
0.5448083877563477,
-0.5797911882400513,
-0.2739606201648712,
0.23115786910057068,
0.43783795833587646,
0.2905206084251404,
0.4331979751586914,
0.17361842095851898,
0.0823817178606987,
0.1921704262495041,
-0.19619803130626678,
0.18382211029529572,
-0.8791184425354004,
-0.3257070779800415,
0.21033059060573578,
0.07785826921463013,
-0.0674370527267456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01122v1 | Calibrated Large Language Models for Binary Question Answering | 2024-07-01T09:31:03 | 2024-07-01T09:31:03 | Patrizio Giovannotti, Alexander Gammerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Quantifying the uncertainty of predictions made by large language models
(LLMs) in binary text classification tasks remains a challenge. Calibration, in
the context of LLMs, refers to the alignment between the model's predicted
probabilities and the actual correctness of its predictions. A well-calibrated
model should produce probabilities that accurately reflect the likelihood of
its predictions being correct. We propose a novel approach that utilizes the
inductive Venn--Abers predictor (IVAP) to calibrate the probabilities
associated with the output tokens corresponding to the binary labels. Our
experiments on the BoolQ dataset using the Llama 2 model demonstrate that IVAP
consistently outperforms the commonly used temperature scaling method for
various label token choices, achieving well-calibrated probabilities while
maintaining high predictive quality. Our findings contribute to the
understanding of calibration techniques for LLMs and provide a practical
solution for obtaining reliable uncertainty estimates in binary question
answering tasks, enhancing the interpretability and trustworthiness of LLM
predictions. | [
-0.05053160712122917,
-0.565432071685791,
0.656528890132904,
-0.1723930388689041,
-0.07590512931346893,
0.1401648372411728,
-0.15762959420681,
-0.45353570580482483,
0.08388524502515793,
0.735173761844635,
-0.361946702003479,
-0.3728252649307251,
-0.4005197286605835,
0.011054986156523228,
-0.23749570548534393,
0.8013854026794434,
-0.08933863788843155,
0.3164924085140228,
-0.5442517399787903,
0.02624419704079628,
-0.5409651398658752,
-0.43126049637794495,
-0.36984002590179443,
-0.6036969423294067,
0.4131229817867279,
0.5355557203292847,
0.8137121796607971,
0.3606848120689392,
0.5547999739646912,
0.25505825877189636,
-0.16082721948623657,
0.17097848653793335,
-0.3481871485710144,
0.2596977949142456,
-0.19987478852272034,
-0.8363549113273621,
-0.22569839656352997,
-0.20279145240783691,
0.6522601842880249,
0.6338764429092407,
-0.10210459679365158,
0.38200774788856506,
-0.13542619347572327,
0.3330965042114258,
-0.4082944691181183,
0.11851242929697037,
-0.9876494407653809,
-0.2937012314796448,
0.11841999739408493,
-0.30899444222450256,
-0.5528808236122131,
-0.6451916694641113,
-0.017518995329737663,
-0.4011126160621643,
-0.2644156515598297,
0.28516730666160583,
0.429325670003891,
0.6051622629165649,
-0.5116898417472839,
-0.32152077555656433,
-0.8802480101585388,
0.8026740550994873,
-1.199327826499939,
-0.017702249810099602,
0.6935813426971436,
0.38805845379829407,
-0.1246430054306984,
-0.49881094694137573,
-0.577196478843689,
0.03239651769399643,
0.05887915566563606,
-0.10754263401031494,
0.08576292544603348,
-0.1216905489563942,
0.04764938727021217,
0.21293635666370392,
-0.5113672018051147,
0.48689091205596924,
-0.48207035660743713,
-0.4310763478279114,
0.5790165662765503,
0.2307097464799881,
0.045390535145998,
0.07259010523557663,
-0.502720296382904,
0.0484301894903183,
-0.7571651339530945,
0.12792155146598816,
0.49655669927597046,
0.3611953556537628,
0.2259707748889923,
0.8851823210716248,
-0.10398644953966141,
0.6523457169532776,
0.1329357773065567,
-0.30925649404525757,
0.2897377908229828,
-0.352206289768219,
-0.12765096127986908,
0.41925543546676636,
0.5019416809082031,
0.33395251631736755,
0.1878313273191452,
-0.1230456605553627,
-0.1452435404062271,
-0.12078164517879486,
0.1841728389263153,
-0.9562293291091919,
-0.17186258733272552,
0.38513994216918945,
0.11718885600566864,
-0.4003867506980896,
-0.15450656414031982,
-0.2884158790111542,
-0.29782962799072266,
-0.4723752439022064,
0.7481620907783508,
-0.37794211506843567,
-0.16817735135555267,
0.04247292876243591,
0.3697061836719513,
0.41916799545288086,
0.49608540534973145,
-0.7453660368919373,
0.25050753355026245,
0.7466797828674316,
0.3430269956588745,
0.0749734565615654,
-0.05429839342832565,
-0.6104195713996887,
0.13396428525447845,
-0.6372776627540588,
0.622283399105072,
-0.6678276062011719,
-0.01892745867371559,
-0.10582847893238068,
-0.21502386033535004,
0.10836367309093475,
-0.2681208848953247,
0.4443916976451874,
-0.8386169075965881,
0.09465812146663666,
-0.26144939661026,
-0.8458802103996277,
-0.4505138695240021,
0.5534586906433105,
-0.48998820781707764,
1.0609122514724731,
0.05166775360703468,
-0.7720838189125061,
0.04859762638807297,
0.2527274787425995,
-0.16687025129795074,
0.20551453530788422,
-0.12500078976154327,
-0.2635940909385681,
0.07733948528766632,
0.21551145613193512,
0.5298197865486145,
-0.4540722072124481,
0.2108500599861145,
-0.33862587809562683,
-0.43186983466148376,
0.7306215167045593,
-0.6988221406936646,
0.4425966143608093,
0.006440982222557068,
-0.047170914709568024,
-0.13460217416286469,
-0.5853542685508728,
0.6564885377883911,
-0.33887800574302673,
-0.3432583212852478,
-0.2300870418548584,
-0.12407969683408737,
-0.37282243371009827,
0.06864774972200394,
0.4517611563205719,
-0.668194591999054,
0.009297746233642101,
-0.7015745639801025,
0.44141751527786255,
0.7253605127334595,
-0.12023206055164337,
0.5217747092247009,
-0.299493670463562,
0.6348253488540649,
-0.12122894078493118,
-0.22233374416828156,
-0.12325090914964676,
-0.5573809146881104,
-0.3309594988822937,
-0.0591314435005188,
0.5988026261329651,
0.778506875038147,
-0.6200206279754639,
0.42504405975341797,
-0.4342651069164276,
-0.9671190977096558,
-0.42619115114212036,
0.1950729340314865,
0.41075512766838074,
0.747266948223114,
0.05169863998889923,
-0.09662443399429321,
-0.09743431210517883,
-0.6229149699211121,
0.0989271029829979,
-0.6591634750366211,
-0.052118897438049316,
0.2936590909957886,
0.38381287455558777,
-0.24086156487464905,
0.8284080028533936,
-0.17710407078266144,
-0.06506350636482239,
0.1576162725687027,
0.27073660492897034,
0.4184293746948242,
0.3908703029155731,
0.133096382021904,
-0.6769676804542542,
-0.4424712359905243,
0.08930282294750214,
-0.35253915190696716,
-0.0018975140992552042,
0.10066681355237961,
-0.22001126408576965,
0.23640240728855133,
0.5991005897521973,
-0.3931247293949127,
0.4632492661476135,
0.7798213958740234,
-0.16804325580596924,
0.8226447701454163,
-0.27702176570892334,
0.2507537007331848,
-1.0100812911987305,
-0.15579497814178467,
0.017830919474363327,
-0.4894731640815735,
-0.6052830219268799,
-0.21196520328521729,
0.3601072132587433,
0.39222174882888794,
-0.30107617378234863,
0.6388598680496216,
-0.24125055968761444,
-0.10245714336633682,
-0.31790891289711,
0.007917557843029499,
0.23122289776802063,
0.055673446506261826,
-0.009190966375172138,
0.9216797351837158,
0.4098324477672577,
-0.3843785524368286,
0.45701929926872253,
0.3072546124458313,
-0.6045335531234741,
0.585503876209259,
-0.7067842483520508,
0.12705376744270325,
-0.2007662057876587,
0.3223387897014618,
-1.578432321548462,
-0.2481520175933838,
0.08633721619844437,
-0.6616377234458923,
0.530036449432373,
0.011748998425900936,
-0.6864933371543884,
-0.32528409361839294,
-0.11897395551204681,
0.8133070468902588,
0.26439476013183594,
-0.2808700501918793,
0.7392955422401428,
0.28121912479400635,
-0.4415181875228882,
-0.8427013158798218,
-0.9164660573005676,
-0.09933359920978546,
-0.08193320780992508,
-0.5306873917579651,
0.3172064423561096,
-0.36153173446655273,
-0.10636540502309799,
-0.17244046926498413,
-0.2006729692220688,
-0.03389376029372215,
0.008523453958332539,
0.3514186441898346,
0.44548746943473816,
-0.40901416540145874,
0.34951287508010864,
0.009815380908548832,
-0.14518019556999207,
0.187803715467453,
-0.02813141606748104,
0.6852644681930542,
-0.21141768991947174,
-0.43400105834007263,
-0.28318968415260315,
-0.0833364799618721,
0.4256333112716675,
-0.2800651788711548,
0.6049578189849854,
0.35370415449142456,
-0.5822494029998779,
-0.005443960893899202,
-0.7866718173027039,
-0.265895813703537,
-0.4588298499584198,
0.31579092144966125,
-0.3802698254585266,
-0.6120246052742004,
0.6251416802406311,
-0.044386208057403564,
0.02920137345790863,
0.30126041173934937,
0.6418003439903259,
-0.2938247323036194,
0.9879956841468811,
0.5086591839790344,
-0.0788189247250557,
0.013864833861589432,
0.10613951832056046,
0.3116150498390198,
-0.9872739911079407,
-0.12442312389612198,
-0.584571897983551,
-0.36418986320495605,
-0.5462431311607361,
-0.7171338200569153,
0.39954233169555664,
-0.05279429629445076,
-0.4932979941368103,
0.17078448832035065,
-0.4814094305038452,
0.5449007153511047,
0.8601213693618774,
0.1962997019290924,
0.11424188315868378,
-0.08029266446828842,
0.09846872836351395,
-0.0782107412815094,
-0.24706198275089264,
-0.6964210271835327,
1.1552574634552002,
0.3759988248348236,
1.1735893487930298,
0.08539039641618729,
0.4348699450492859,
-0.05575966835021973,
0.33518272638320923,
-0.5228784084320068,
0.3287409245967865,
0.02244557999074459,
-0.7910589575767517,
-0.5887473225593567,
-0.4219007194042206,
-0.4284079670906067,
-0.06820965558290482,
-0.12356088310480118,
-1.1179298162460327,
0.07319357246160507,
0.09501471370458603,
-0.49071604013442993,
0.3631094992160797,
-0.5647287368774414,
0.5716701745986938,
-0.38169488310813904,
-0.055283501744270325,
0.07540179789066315,
-0.7553814053535461,
0.30405545234680176,
-0.39176514744758606,
0.31475168466567993,
-0.47088292241096497,
-0.1569577306509018,
0.4550628960132599,
-0.342285692691803,
0.9796176552772522,
0.18071657419204712,
-0.17777453362941742,
0.3824893534183502,
0.29200318455696106,
0.6744365096092224,
0.08179778605699539,
-0.8080786466598511,
0.09550168365240097,
0.5181856155395508,
-0.13107264041900635,
-0.33232367038726807,
0.6477354168891907,
-0.8574028015136719,
-0.5606582164764404,
-0.5032347440719604,
-0.7681008577346802,
-0.35942211747169495,
0.03492090478539467,
0.35286274552345276,
0.49049684405326843,
0.11192133277654648,
0.13678254187107086,
0.7765557765960693,
-0.30680233240127563,
0.018292143940925598,
0.20992928743362427,
-0.28054556250572205,
-0.6016026735305786,
0.8090696334838867,
0.09878385066986084,
0.6230041980743408,
0.5981025695800781,
0.2634499967098236,
-0.413644015789032,
-0.5122420191764832,
-0.3354242444038391,
0.2954653799533844,
-0.9569101929664612,
-0.7619855403900146,
-0.3314969837665558,
-0.5556455254554749,
-0.5577033758163452,
-0.20864547789096832,
-0.14271728694438934,
-0.4759052097797394,
-0.5690320134162903,
-0.344563364982605,
0.47879892587661743,
0.4174261689186096,
0.08831724524497986,
0.5076331496238708,
-0.4389774203300476,
-0.025953248143196106,
0.231464222073555,
0.22298848628997803,
-0.395054429769516,
-1.083842396736145,
0.10013730823993683,
0.2854818105697632,
0.045013368129730225,
-0.818475604057312,
0.36994659900665283,
0.36519327759742737,
0.35444608330726624,
0.14091019332408905,
0.42291703820228577,
0.5375578999519348,
-0.4277772307395935,
0.6334474086761475,
0.25426045060157776,
-0.6354422569274902,
0.4107804298400879,
0.11617543548345566,
0.43875306844711304,
0.8207677602767944,
0.2302526831626892,
-0.3937683403491974,
-0.42793941497802734,
-0.19564756751060486,
-0.8886666297912598,
0.5305144190788269,
-0.06400831043720245,
0.570497453212738,
0.21031694114208221,
0.5895179510116577,
0.4123817980289459,
0.26801246404647827,
-0.6174306869506836,
-0.30345913767814636,
0.17803922295570374,
-0.6121412515640259,
-0.29250863194465637,
-0.6456789374351501,
0.07767219096422195,
-0.11313941329717636,
1.0610605478286743,
-0.29435649514198303,
0.13525350391864777,
-0.04120249301195145,
0.03335905820131302,
-0.37365415692329407,
0.05758236348628998,
0.2427547574043274,
0.8484271168708801,
-0.39706215262413025,
0.2745717167854309,
0.24918429553508759,
-0.40512508153915405,
0.17403626441955566,
0.19125062227249146,
-0.47267523407936096,
-0.003219116711989045,
0.07043998688459396,
0.5883943438529968,
0.1696985512971878,
-0.748455822467804,
0.5241963863372803,
-0.2634168565273285,
-0.03259860724210739,
-0.666103720664978,
-0.011988352984189987,
0.20856164395809174,
0.29171881079673767,
0.33547189831733704,
-0.08280863612890244,
-0.017893489450216293,
-0.33864185214042664,
0.13077004253864288,
0.5100208520889282,
-0.41846129298210144,
-0.13727958500385284,
0.8197192549705505,
-0.06911366432905197,
-0.2748342454433441,
0.6253118515014648,
0.1406039297580719,
-0.6585538387298584,
0.813232958316803,
0.6270869374275208,
0.4406434893608093,
-0.39767661690711975,
0.31595268845558167,
0.6260136365890503,
0.616291344165802,
0.05437026917934418,
0.27214181423187256,
0.15262874960899353,
-0.9065172076225281,
-0.5198813676834106,
-0.8910718560218811,
-0.7726622819900513,
-0.3159080743789673,
-0.6072198748588562,
0.19005365669727325,
-0.25992551445961,
-0.27553439140319824,
0.20368587970733643,
0.06800591200590134,
-0.8583398461341858,
0.4163159728050232,
0.5003331899642944,
0.887033224105835,
-0.6865133047103882,
0.8884186148643494,
0.5204480290412903,
-0.06693507730960846,
-1.0125494003295898,
-0.18794047832489014,
-0.08043673634529114,
-1.0059982538223267,
0.5013457536697388,
0.4096413552761078,
-0.01657145284116268,
0.14767193794250488,
-0.5729461908340454,
-1.4101741313934326,
1.1721628904342651,
0.47336673736572266,
-0.6344470381736755,
-0.02207167260348797,
0.5310342311859131,
0.36367473006248474,
-0.23245473206043243,
0.5035982131958008,
0.4043656289577484,
0.36324119567871094,
0.45802879333496094,
-0.8726790547370911,
0.014707986265420914,
-0.0634150356054306,
0.06175776943564415,
0.0463520810008049,
-0.18683592975139618,
0.6088166832923889,
-0.3837527334690094,
0.058099567890167236,
0.3937423825263977,
0.8779985308647156,
0.27403971552848816,
0.3035231828689575,
0.5171545743942261,
0.3599497675895691,
1.064922571182251,
-0.14142604172229767,
0.8651978969573975,
-0.39277806878089905,
0.0986497700214386,
1.3843765258789062,
-0.38256847858428955,
1.1811987161636353,
0.6088749766349792,
-0.12158676236867905,
0.4128992557525635,
0.753836452960968,
0.25755971670150757,
0.47616133093833923,
0.3002537190914154,
-0.3555690348148346,
-0.43812295794487,
0.03396759554743767,
-0.13980357348918915,
0.22705303132534027,
0.6843934059143066,
-0.15331369638442993,
0.07001829892396927,
0.022943174466490746,
-0.11665238440036774,
0.10758200287818909,
-0.46780160069465637,
0.6835966110229492,
0.06815587729215622,
-0.7204296588897705,
0.34599360823631287,
-0.08802296966314316,
0.5604135990142822,
-0.46371832489967346,
0.20989975333213806,
0.01186610758304596,
0.276493102312088,
-0.09062095731496811,
-1.2074130773544312,
0.08734257519245148,
-0.1368078887462616,
0.052649661898612976,
0.1190585121512413,
0.659273624420166,
-0.5640904903411865,
-1.0583186149597168,
-0.07700761407613754,
0.20319506525993347,
0.30962443351745605,
-0.12755481898784637,
-0.3688552677631378,
0.029248997569084167,
-0.10930368304252625,
-0.3119160830974579,
0.09318909794092178,
0.6199538707733154,
0.1879441887140274,
0.7212010025978088,
0.30452919006347656,
-0.07577431946992874,
0.33991608023643494,
-0.31703421473503113,
0.5154224634170532,
-0.2589496076107025,
-0.03043092042207718,
-0.6334651708602905,
0.4687527120113373,
0.27515774965286255,
-0.39380592107772827,
0.3967602252960205,
0.4398098289966583,
0.7768804430961609,
0.2831135094165802,
0.639951229095459,
0.18815159797668457,
0.5852042436599731,
-0.3774891197681427,
0.249229297041893,
-0.40026628971099854,
0.36275410652160645,
0.02188006043434143,
-0.8053410053253174,
-0.3390510082244873,
0.4680079221725464,
-0.4151054918766022,
-0.16996058821678162,
0.26619377732276917,
1.013091802597046,
0.24136598408222198,
-0.1378660351037979,
0.4380667507648468,
0.3388442099094391,
0.15624159574508667,
0.47715601325035095,
0.6167643070220947,
-0.6365448236465454,
0.611819326877594,
-0.5960798263549805,
-0.15889054536819458,
-0.2865668535232544,
-0.9002543091773987,
-0.6173508763313293,
-0.6378675699234009,
-0.4514685571193695,
-0.441165030002594,
-0.22850927710533142,
0.7851597666740417,
0.5004072785377502,
-0.9049249887466431,
0.023992257192730904,
0.2856323719024658,
0.04171200469136238,
-0.0650687888264656,
-0.13525430858135223,
0.2943211793899536,
-0.26143449544906616,
-0.6547697186470032,
-0.0816648080945015,
0.10343866050243378,
0.026725059375166893,
-0.2644125819206238,
-0.0519876554608345,
-0.05818569287657738,
0.5061346292495728,
0.3474903404712677,
0.20235732197761536,
-0.994498074054718,
-0.524413526058197,
0.02353719435632229,
-0.5000002384185791,
0.027010492980480194,
-0.009123796597123146,
-0.7834641933441162,
0.5538214445114136,
0.37374255061149597,
0.8660083413124084,
0.5505894422531128,
0.09015128761529922,
0.6067699193954468,
-0.6795594096183777,
-0.2871036231517792,
0.4746319055557251,
0.2896783649921417,
0.4908621907234192,
-0.49957337975502014,
0.4942793548107147,
-0.6774091720581055,
-0.9425687193870544,
-1.0265955924987793,
0.11228638887405396,
-1.0151077508926392,
-0.15073253214359283,
1.289499282836914,
-0.07629472017288208,
-0.37868309020996094,
0.33612358570098877,
-0.2599325180053711,
0.05782788246870041,
-0.03721266984939575,
0.5501893162727356,
0.6640352010726929,
0.31678956747055054,
-0.046419233083724976,
-0.7078004479408264,
-0.06714975833892822,
0.36561644077301025,
-0.6785895228385925,
0.16376234591007233,
0.4841887950897217,
0.40753018856048584,
0.0693340077996254,
0.3704458773136139,
0.1498463898897171,
0.29472604393959045,
-0.3485563397407532,
0.13706432282924652,
0.3298113942146301,
-0.05498667433857918,
-0.12188038975000381,
-0.16895835101604462,
0.33982622623443604,
-0.0003187491383869201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01119v1 | Pron vs Prompt: Can Large Language Models already Challenge a World-Class Fiction Author at Creative Text Writing? | 2024-07-01T09:28:58 | 2024-07-01T09:28:58 | Guillermo Marco, Julio Gonzalo, Ramón del Castillo, María Teresa Mateo Girona | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | It has become routine to report research results where Large Language Models
(LLMs) outperform average humans in a wide range of language-related tasks, and
creative text writing is no exception. It seems natural, then, to raise the
bid: Are LLMs ready to compete in creative writing skills with a top (rather
than average) novelist? To provide an initial answer for this question, we have
carried out a contest between Patricio Pron (an awarded novelist, considered
one of the best of his generation) and GPT-4 (one of the top performing LLMs),
in the spirit of AI-human duels such as DeepBlue vs Kasparov and AlphaGo vs Lee
Sidol. We asked Pron and GPT-4 to provide thirty titles each, and then to write
short stories for both their titles and their opponent's. Then, we prepared an
evaluation rubric inspired by Boden's definition of creativity, and we
collected 5,400 manual assessments provided by literature critics and scholars.
The results of our experimentation indicate that LLMs are still far from
challenging a top human creative writer, and that reaching such level of
autonomous creative writing skills probably cannot be reached simply with
larger language models. | [
-0.3738027513027191,
-0.5771401524543762,
0.9427255988121033,
0.2206219583749771,
-0.13645531237125397,
0.30848392844200134,
-0.39774614572525024,
-0.4609896242618561,
-0.1107293963432312,
0.39745238423347473,
-0.537778377532959,
-0.11397334188222885,
-0.4958789646625519,
0.5577348470687866,
-0.20816172659397125,
0.7925218343734741,
-0.17147456109523773,
-0.10389933735132217,
-0.5250582695007324,
-0.07743603736162186,
-0.5895975828170776,
-0.41895347833633423,
-0.5094416737556458,
-0.12368883937597275,
0.9157814383506775,
0.20021651685237885,
0.6986923217773438,
0.28113508224487305,
0.5611454248428345,
0.5574184060096741,
-0.25870227813720703,
0.07225559651851654,
-0.370341032743454,
0.4015156626701355,
-0.307231068611145,
-0.5751591920852661,
-0.3779648244380951,
0.3647429943084717,
0.5822092294692993,
0.6112539768218994,
0.30185264348983765,
-0.3337332010269165,
-0.03944575786590576,
0.5878400206565857,
-0.09702733159065247,
-0.235747292637825,
-0.3073948919773102,
0.05978688970208168,
-0.5525832176208496,
-0.11366600543260574,
-0.28977200388908386,
-0.686606228351593,
0.21861860156059265,
-0.6180239319801331,
0.2699040472507477,
0.2506435811519623,
0.8026298880577087,
0.0066123479045927525,
-0.18579906225204468,
-0.5136662125587463,
-0.774786114692688,
0.6989524960517883,
-0.46449676156044006,
-0.1913718581199646,
-0.05243605747818947,
0.2662796974182129,
-0.32253381609916687,
-0.6233935356140137,
-0.8059383630752563,
-0.642289400100708,
0.4161025583744049,
0.3897157609462738,
-0.22342295944690704,
-0.19404557347297668,
0.31081709265708923,
0.6259893178939819,
-0.8779991269111633,
0.4401574730873108,
-0.08018886297941208,
0.054274216294288635,
0.6418413519859314,
0.3906761407852173,
0.3380719721317291,
-0.037136614322662354,
-0.4899901747703552,
0.05403383821249008,
-0.5936459898948669,
0.2621539831161499,
0.6044803261756897,
0.05501854047179222,
0.23691925406455994,
0.627126157283783,
0.0724036917090416,
0.31944093108177185,
-0.042519036680459976,
-0.04465169832110405,
-0.02479204535484314,
-0.33859288692474365,
0.0552624873816967,
-0.022718943655490875,
1.1635867357254028,
0.5276286005973816,
0.6042150855064392,
-0.29609164595603943,
-0.33507755398750305,
0.0708768367767334,
0.16318002343177795,
-0.6401306986808777,
-0.10671204328536987,
0.19796700775623322,
-0.15377607941627502,
-0.12626530230045319,
0.17991356551647186,
-0.519554615020752,
-0.8275768160820007,
-0.11994415521621704,
0.5716265439987183,
-0.05942068621516228,
-0.1782287359237671,
0.1929827630519867,
-0.3152076005935669,
-0.0027301295194774866,
0.24920634925365448,
-0.6127839684486389,
0.1808723509311676,
0.8102914094924927,
0.997745931148529,
-0.26336053013801575,
-0.41572305560112,
-0.29216912388801575,
-0.2717343270778656,
-0.8432033658027649,
0.8016340136528015,
-0.24615658819675446,
-0.2831084132194519,
-0.17313940823078156,
-0.21487750113010406,
-0.013113193213939667,
-0.6844713091850281,
0.5512621998786926,
-0.5161346197128296,
0.4076094627380371,
-0.5956017374992371,
-0.6315841674804688,
0.40385639667510986,
0.15717338025569916,
-0.6898537874221802,
0.48140057921409607,
0.15867334604263306,
-0.7723443508148193,
0.06285284459590912,
-0.15019576251506805,
-0.31556010246276855,
0.4775815010070801,
-0.24538807570934296,
-0.23878884315490723,
0.18779009580612183,
-0.10885685682296753,
0.5070722699165344,
-0.9065603613853455,
0.5546360015869141,
-0.22957023978233337,
-0.38247138261795044,
0.8142267465591431,
-0.3174286186695099,
0.7509817481040955,
0.15819326043128967,
-0.41403910517692566,
0.24493391811847687,
-0.5317568182945251,
-0.08030270785093307,
0.4315129816532135,
-0.4360424280166626,
0.026723600924015045,
-0.3160967528820038,
-0.22880272567272186,
0.21710555255413055,
0.13663676381111145,
-0.8544185757637024,
0.2729867994785309,
-0.39159122109413147,
0.5023033618927002,
0.8056998252868652,
-0.09037719666957855,
0.44550952315330505,
-0.7632865309715271,
0.9427180886268616,
-0.5786573886871338,
-0.01333530806005001,
-0.05469125881791115,
-0.5717577934265137,
-0.47916319966316223,
-0.19412761926651,
0.39758938550949097,
0.7499204874038696,
-0.9911240339279175,
0.4595798850059509,
-0.1516789197921753,
-0.7563936114311218,
-0.41666215658187866,
0.045050520449876785,
0.34948670864105225,
0.5387745499610901,
-0.1618393212556839,
-0.21686811745166779,
-0.48098698258399963,
-0.7246143817901611,
-0.7205106019973755,
-0.1393498033285141,
-0.20057418942451477,
0.2628655433654785,
0.29767489433288574,
0.25048527121543884,
0.7908380031585693,
-0.2171049416065216,
-0.5036788582801819,
-0.8680957555770874,
0.17567674815654755,
0.4283273220062256,
0.45421138405799866,
0.618511438369751,
-0.7194125652313232,
-0.49558210372924805,
-0.1734405755996704,
-0.9319072961807251,
-0.4432543218135834,
-0.4037650227546692,
0.05555686727166176,
0.04997943714261055,
0.33886051177978516,
-0.982007622718811,
-0.014899210073053837,
0.2682691812515259,
-0.30393141508102417,
0.979862630367279,
-0.22204281389713287,
0.14013375341892242,
-0.7981376051902771,
0.04632686451077461,
-0.05698781460523605,
0.08777166903018951,
-0.6476843357086182,
0.03534094989299774,
-0.15997065603733063,
-0.10881209373474121,
-0.4275140166282654,
0.7839420437812805,
-0.20716796815395355,
0.0926840752363205,
-0.31463927030563354,
0.3731413781642914,
0.055550556629896164,
0.014082876965403557,
0.046443965286016464,
0.7441959381103516,
0.53719562292099,
-0.32873213291168213,
0.7245039343833923,
0.08343879133462906,
-0.7990538477897644,
0.30837392807006836,
-0.837533175945282,
0.12132719904184341,
-0.1382388174533844,
0.44698646664619446,
-1.08330500125885,
-0.13819065690040588,
-0.06711097061634064,
-0.23635011911392212,
0.012912306003272533,
0.460698664188385,
-0.6394600868225098,
-0.5950524210929871,
-0.3052726984024048,
0.015489477664232254,
0.5759409666061401,
-0.16838344931602478,
0.2968564033508301,
-0.1200609803199768,
-0.635826826095581,
-0.4492032825946808,
-0.4418555200099945,
0.49897944927215576,
-0.3280159831047058,
-0.6405958533287048,
0.3478020429611206,
-0.5095633864402771,
-0.4681854248046875,
-0.1984151303768158,
0.05364803224802017,
0.19969812035560608,
0.15714327991008759,
-0.10036951303482056,
0.056680746376514435,
-0.1590203493833542,
-0.2753128409385681,
-0.3842986822128296,
-0.3172668516635895,
-0.01342824287712574,
-0.22353406250476837,
0.44745102524757385,
-0.27084678411483765,
0.057773783802986145,
-0.48345747590065,
0.4818316698074341,
0.47820261120796204,
-0.3204185962677002,
0.5589868426322937,
0.4279332458972931,
-0.07132759690284729,
-0.17314518988132477,
-0.4871484339237213,
0.05605997145175934,
-0.5399615168571472,
0.2504435181617737,
-0.4469548761844635,
-0.9514440894126892,
0.557515561580658,
0.04198511689901352,
-0.1362253725528717,
0.4920617640018463,
0.6661344766616821,
-0.20762556791305542,
0.6811630725860596,
0.5417624115943909,
0.4408051669597626,
0.3385831415653229,
-0.3193364143371582,
0.36233827471733093,
-0.5207016468048096,
-0.2085142582654953,
-0.49697116017341614,
-0.6234936714172363,
-0.34604743123054504,
0.1252223700284958,
0.2596336305141449,
0.1081564724445343,
-0.3193550109863281,
0.23341353237628937,
-0.16623838245868683,
0.7954760789871216,
0.7349146604537964,
-0.2642133831977844,
0.13696907460689545,
-0.4765579402446747,
-0.25329434871673584,
-0.27638569474220276,
-0.825411856174469,
-0.6207073926925659,
0.7297584414482117,
0.26088568568229675,
0.6003592014312744,
0.2699958384037018,
0.37777554988861084,
0.14316163957118988,
0.1779268980026245,
-0.6513970494270325,
0.9680482149124146,
-0.29150390625,
-0.5508842468261719,
-0.2148037850856781,
-0.440665066242218,
-0.8018977046012878,
0.2174394726753235,
0.0074124266393482685,
-0.44345197081565857,
0.2540558874607086,
-0.1235353946685791,
-0.7651119828224182,
0.33390942215919495,
-0.46831631660461426,
1.0839534997940063,
-0.5151644349098206,
-0.5073505640029907,
0.3457494378089905,
-0.7005460262298584,
0.15708822011947632,
-0.013419483788311481,
0.26559972763061523,
-0.09057130664587021,
-0.18384256958961487,
0.7792454957962036,
-0.18229146301746368,
0.5925114154815674,
-0.04471825435757637,
-0.2235848605632782,
0.5857309103012085,
0.511675238609314,
0.12534219026565552,
0.03039795532822609,
-0.12349230796098709,
-0.23055021464824677,
-0.31141963601112366,
-0.23398464918136597,
-0.6345939636230469,
0.7149341106414795,
-0.6997276544570923,
-0.8509464859962463,
-0.6389906406402588,
-0.5345116853713989,
-0.12831014394760132,
0.19062428176403046,
0.7540479302406311,
0.6932582855224609,
-0.19068695604801178,
0.2734678089618683,
0.40380972623825073,
-0.2853633761405945,
0.7174476385116577,
0.22348552942276,
0.060755692422389984,
-0.5770171284675598,
0.9020662903785706,
0.2930130362510681,
0.39610064029693604,
0.30083662271499634,
0.5580536723136902,
-0.3680192828178406,
-0.682717502117157,
-0.5315266847610474,
0.24072977900505066,
-0.6424097418785095,
-0.13343966007232666,
-0.564242959022522,
-0.13002724945545197,
-0.12368158251047134,
-0.5711057782173157,
-0.2463957965373993,
-0.2455676794052124,
-0.25638115406036377,
0.1726004183292389,
-0.10478812456130981,
0.866500973701477,
0.03888009116053581,
0.2287137657403946,
-0.4989742338657379,
0.06686042249202728,
0.3459666967391968,
0.2752936780452728,
0.0026864593382924795,
-0.4882549047470093,
-0.05140941962599754,
-0.5281201601028442,
-0.3704093098640442,
-0.6791540384292603,
0.2902628481388092,
0.07258640229701996,
0.40866297483444214,
0.3197043538093567,
0.2199764847755432,
0.21788865327835083,
-0.514309287071228,
1.1668410301208496,
0.19751816987991333,
-0.7389072775840759,
0.28515854477882385,
-0.5471022725105286,
0.43781059980392456,
0.44551074504852295,
0.603387176990509,
-0.6156248450279236,
-0.5704646706581116,
-0.5482045412063599,
-0.6715553998947144,
0.5680379271507263,
0.12940627336502075,
0.26831114292144775,
-0.1532873511314392,
0.2773663401603699,
0.448434978723526,
0.29779163002967834,
-0.8736728429794312,
0.30778369307518005,
0.016314446926116943,
-0.20582358539104462,
-0.3120097219944,
-0.24928675591945648,
-0.0820470079779625,
-0.04338138923048973,
0.3433983325958252,
0.015309026464819908,
0.18109574913978577,
0.2965275049209595,
0.15768319368362427,
0.16418814659118652,
0.3114108741283417,
0.5789797902107239,
0.753057062625885,
0.08846224844455719,
0.35220858454704285,
-0.17613807320594788,
-0.3160119950771332,
0.3343260884284973,
-0.13180819153785706,
-0.05459848418831825,
-0.17410947382450104,
0.8662673234939575,
0.7042925953865051,
-0.00486557325348258,
-0.9861039519309998,
0.8351155519485474,
-0.17832250893115997,
-0.49959462881088257,
-0.3703884184360504,
0.33246731758117676,
0.056047119200229645,
0.5414643287658691,
0.30876243114471436,
0.15160831809043884,
-0.25063303112983704,
-0.6299940347671509,
-0.15502719581127167,
0.2098390907049179,
-0.11691189557313919,
-0.4980979859828949,
0.8548707962036133,
0.2833980619907379,
-0.6202300190925598,
0.24707739055156708,
-0.5307638049125671,
-0.6549351811408997,
0.7197920083999634,
0.7129054665565491,
0.9357110261917114,
-0.07083683460950851,
0.13474102318286896,
0.08155397325754166,
0.2043212652206421,
-0.3125649392604828,
0.40244343876838684,
0.36979037523269653,
-0.5082886815071106,
-0.38152655959129333,
-0.35553279519081116,
-0.3275933563709259,
0.4257488250732422,
0.10489007830619812,
0.0720546767115593,
-0.6642995476722717,
-0.10878386348485947,
-0.018225234001874924,
0.25156596302986145,
-0.4757665991783142,
-0.11934219300746918,
0.10139522701501846,
0.7132176756858826,
-0.6543689966201782,
0.2477552592754364,
0.6947984099388123,
-0.2537272572517395,
-0.37595415115356445,
-0.0758604109287262,
0.15634232759475708,
0.15202409029006958,
0.5323116779327393,
0.34625157713890076,
0.11334209144115448,
0.06911063194274902,
-0.4439837634563446,
-0.6354855895042419,
0.9265151619911194,
0.5124499797821045,
-0.6523274183273315,
-0.03233509883284569,
-0.1250125914812088,
0.7462596893310547,
-0.5986459851264954,
0.16630323231220245,
0.36439722776412964,
0.46924954652786255,
0.015521860681474209,
-1.0875345468521118,
-0.15984797477722168,
-0.2244454324245453,
0.030643168836832047,
-0.2524472773075104,
-0.8870664834976196,
1.145737886428833,
-0.4396945834159851,
-0.293547123670578,
0.7123327851295471,
0.6653150916099548,
0.12124815583229065,
0.3503636121749878,
0.28726574778556824,
0.3235633969306946,
0.639003336429596,
-0.21750828623771667,
1.302577257156372,
0.136477991938591,
-0.11352655291557312,
0.7128698229789734,
-0.5525091290473938,
0.598481297492981,
-0.12599240243434906,
-0.1958441585302353,
0.39276212453842163,
0.6743383407592773,
0.03609606996178627,
0.39090853929519653,
0.39816126227378845,
-0.4360605776309967,
-0.371111124753952,
0.029332365840673447,
-0.20836982131004333,
0.3377380967140198,
-0.13720783591270447,
0.0038177629467099905,
0.019357021898031235,
0.34062913060188293,
0.0547817088663578,
0.6982158422470093,
-0.14381621778011322,
0.7873502969741821,
0.19568945467472076,
-0.8841705918312073,
0.40000173449516296,
0.0487649030983448,
0.6744340062141418,
-0.49780556559562683,
0.502215564250946,
-0.2845943868160248,
0.3560809791088104,
0.17314179241657257,
-1.11406672000885,
-0.050430674105882645,
0.16931748390197754,
-0.09709750860929489,
-0.3284890651702881,
0.5706879496574402,
-0.3098556101322174,
-0.3413766324520111,
-0.08423212915658951,
0.6810104846954346,
0.1796574741601944,
-0.1179836094379425,
-0.4347952604293823,
0.16270287334918976,
-0.45441609621047974,
-0.40091124176979065,
0.22027884423732758,
0.5978527069091797,
-0.11633636802434921,
0.7623688578605652,
0.5264334678649902,
0.13608984649181366,
-0.22132274508476257,
0.33249032497406006,
0.6523638963699341,
-0.5981705188751221,
-0.7133001089096069,
-0.9996592998504639,
0.2743530869483948,
-0.07488221675157547,
-0.6217643022537231,
0.6832589507102966,
0.635150671005249,
0.5806238055229187,
-0.1331060230731964,
0.8475590944290161,
-0.11186173558235168,
0.46549493074417114,
-0.5107253789901733,
0.7641846537590027,
-0.28321564197540283,
-0.014753537252545357,
-0.29058074951171875,
-1.1736068725585938,
-0.3243195116519928,
0.4053647220134735,
-0.38552942872047424,
0.28822067379951477,
0.8487613201141357,
0.49141889810562134,
0.3701618015766144,
0.17353659868240356,
0.17358089983463287,
0.2932983636856079,
0.502013623714447,
0.8071120381355286,
1.369993805885315,
-0.10252109915018082,
0.2947256565093994,
0.172830730676651,
-0.5083312392234802,
-0.036714859306812286,
-1.0671100616455078,
-1.0437839031219482,
-0.6331191658973694,
-0.17894862592220306,
-0.08953931927680969,
-0.06979119032621384,
0.7439681887626648,
0.11699053645133972,
-0.2845439016819,
-0.10577644407749176,
-0.011943919584155083,
0.047314468771219254,
-0.24121010303497314,
-0.10565005987882614,
0.23630085587501526,
-0.08445342630147934,
-0.8595563173294067,
0.4280453622341156,
0.10829184949398041,
0.23588880896568298,
-0.3893834948539734,
0.018734775483608246,
0.11483152955770493,
0.30197757482528687,
0.6081700325012207,
0.10429226607084274,
-0.8436626195907593,
-0.10032396018505096,
0.12237948179244995,
-0.09777466207742691,
-0.20528121292591095,
1.018263578414917,
-0.8139144778251648,
0.24732913076877594,
0.6779032945632935,
0.7393611073493958,
-0.14193427562713623,
0.08201021701097488,
0.46082597970962524,
-0.5172553658485413,
-0.12022535502910614,
0.5704624056816101,
0.11858008801937103,
0.5007476210594177,
-0.2957179844379425,
0.22899116575717926,
0.5767955780029297,
-0.8328539133071899,
-0.7734494805335999,
0.26755136251449585,
-0.8978397250175476,
-0.4276566207408905,
1.1925010681152344,
-0.05307777225971222,
-0.16191831231117249,
0.030955450609326363,
-0.4021613299846649,
-0.22752873599529266,
-0.04571649059653282,
0.48621875047683716,
0.954403281211853,
-0.24048681557178497,
-0.1880822330713272,
-0.9055258631706238,
0.5531629323959351,
0.3384091854095459,
-0.5237645506858826,
0.2056458592414856,
0.2397817224264145,
0.013983524404466152,
0.007706198375672102,
0.8921109437942505,
0.11144976317882538,
0.3453461229801178,
0.04536008834838867,
-0.08334275335073471,
-0.4038393199443817,
-0.7204946279525757,
-0.08411040902137756,
0.2958458364009857,
0.17412476241588593,
0.35128268599510193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01102v1 | BERGEN: A Benchmarking Library for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-07-01T09:09:27 | 2024-07-01T09:09:27 | David Rau, Hervé Déjean, Nadezhda Chirkova, Thibault Formal, Shuai Wang, Vassilina Nikoulina, Stéphane Clinchant | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval-Augmented Generation allows to enhance Large Language Models with
external knowledge. In response to the recent popularity of generative LLMs,
many RAG approaches have been proposed, which involve an intricate number of
different configurations such as evaluation datasets, collections, metrics,
retrievers, and LLMs. Inconsistent benchmarking poses a major challenge in
comparing approaches and understanding the impact of each component in the
pipeline. In this work, we study best practices that lay the groundwork for a
systematic evaluation of RAG and present BERGEN, an end-to-end library for
reproducible research standardizing RAG experiments. In an extensive study
focusing on QA, we benchmark different state-of-the-art retrievers, rerankers,
and LLMs. Additionally, we analyze existing RAG metrics and datasets. Our
open-source library BERGEN is available under
\url{https://github.com/naver/bergen}. | [
-0.3966201841831207,
-0.4076229929924011,
0.38765373826026917,
0.11192706227302551,
-0.0710679218173027,
0.17721904814243317,
-0.12680812180042267,
-0.42635706067085266,
0.12441547960042953,
0.29839691519737244,
-0.06448349356651306,
-0.2958081066608429,
-0.3364851176738739,
0.2366350293159485,
-0.5687500238418579,
1.0386570692062378,
-0.12520577013492584,
0.11436444520950317,
-0.4078829884529114,
-0.28535616397857666,
-0.1918376386165619,
-0.3047772943973541,
-0.5275790691375732,
-0.2990618348121643,
0.8373734951019287,
0.1913186013698578,
0.5465822815895081,
0.3812907338142395,
0.5709635615348816,
0.1724597066640854,
-0.493338406085968,
0.4979858994483948,
-0.7497047781944275,
0.44696757197380066,
-0.5090247392654419,
-0.14726601541042328,
-0.28052210807800293,
-0.22199733555316925,
0.9067882895469666,
0.3760521709918976,
-0.28500378131866455,
0.6722657680511475,
-0.09767523407936096,
0.8907420635223389,
-1.2227243185043335,
-0.25260859727859497,
-0.6649990081787109,
-0.10109814256429672,
-0.39219895005226135,
-0.006950043607503176,
-0.45246702432632446,
-0.657511830329895,
0.07176294177770615,
-0.4671138525009155,
0.44352009892463684,
0.21017968654632568,
1.0279121398925781,
0.10937444865703583,
-0.4685642421245575,
-0.26004019379615784,
-0.6985523104667664,
0.8167808055877686,
-0.5776668787002563,
0.7636685967445374,
0.17419566214084625,
0.6748494505882263,
-0.22307711839675903,
-0.9742639660835266,
-0.4271222651004791,
-0.22017985582351685,
-0.092347152531147,
0.1277063488960266,
0.12772193551063538,
-0.1450817883014679,
0.2658871114253998,
0.6605420112609863,
-0.5894873142242432,
-0.18742865324020386,
-0.20399174094200134,
0.16821295022964478,
0.5917964577674866,
-0.026649119332432747,
-0.02678450010716915,
-0.41279807686805725,
-0.44536495208740234,
-0.34301790595054626,
-0.8746132254600525,
-0.2815018892288208,
0.4658661484718323,
0.24932222068309784,
0.19206269085407257,
0.6060922741889954,
-0.4116347134113312,
0.7823622226715088,
-0.2388140857219696,
0.3718191683292389,
0.702704668045044,
-0.2664678692817688,
-0.16418512165546417,
-0.6161381602287292,
0.544098973274231,
0.1377762109041214,
0.03108922950923443,
-0.5385556817054749,
-0.5545937418937683,
-0.41244882345199585,
0.6081907153129578,
-0.42347779870033264,
-0.1602514237165451,
0.04421103373169899,
-0.3041216731071472,
-0.1103164330124855,
-0.03178993985056877,
-0.9002679586410522,
-0.526856541633606,
-0.23333536088466644,
0.6663908362388611,
-0.20191240310668945,
-0.3877366781234741,
-0.29744985699653625,
-0.5146923065185547,
0.5218346118927002,
-0.17618346214294434,
-0.6637313365936279,
0.2530673146247864,
0.9427536129951477,
0.6602261066436768,
-0.5020087957382202,
-0.10484329611063004,
-0.4930132329463959,
0.19616593420505524,
-0.6670211553573608,
0.9526184797286987,
-0.10190141946077347,
-0.32066699862480164,
0.3146692216396332,
-0.20719997584819794,
0.266166627407074,
-0.9181015491485596,
0.8873094320297241,
-0.9486067891120911,
0.12796562910079956,
-0.498130738735199,
-0.6484965682029724,
0.14105790853500366,
0.47409787774086,
-0.6643527150154114,
1.3469043970108032,
0.33595871925354004,
-0.8127186894416809,
0.34967392683029175,
-0.26597702503204346,
0.07803666591644287,
0.18433792889118195,
-0.059552114456892014,
-0.46547943353652954,
0.5320701599121094,
-0.072025828063488,
0.017040254548192024,
-0.609099268913269,
0.35258471965789795,
0.01243645790964365,
-0.3083091676235199,
0.18454577028751373,
-0.18758054077625275,
0.7236037254333496,
0.5876892805099487,
0.16461388766765594,
0.09466104209423065,
-0.8542476892471313,
0.42752107977867126,
0.06026771292090416,
-0.34558597207069397,
-0.31708744168281555,
0.14154300093650818,
0.08176351338624954,
-0.28707534074783325,
0.3551141023635864,
-0.5619761347770691,
-0.10699909925460815,
-0.43356433510780334,
-0.27558642625808716,
0.8057452440261841,
-0.05910530686378479,
0.16009870171546936,
-0.7090357542037964,
0.44398263096809387,
-0.4582444429397583,
0.22397904098033905,
0.013782234862446785,
-0.05174710229039192,
-0.888822078704834,
-0.3160424828529358,
0.6227026581764221,
0.28965112566947937,
-1.1464706659317017,
0.10536685585975647,
-0.24462389945983887,
-0.6715690493583679,
-0.6228898763656616,
0.13630960881710052,
0.830488383769989,
0.4158593714237213,
0.4042401909828186,
-0.3342992961406708,
-0.6782132387161255,
-1.0715140104293823,
-0.6399111747741699,
-0.12221837043762207,
-0.2636202275753021,
0.39835429191589355,
0.1581880897283554,
-0.2780984342098236,
1.0405070781707764,
-0.3054633140563965,
0.022480009123682976,
-0.13242946565151215,
0.15810419619083405,
0.5462267398834229,
0.24441377818584442,
0.3474787473678589,
-0.864192008972168,
-0.6940522193908691,
-0.08001741766929626,
-0.6411572694778442,
-0.41989848017692566,
0.3711797893047333,
-0.2653578221797943,
0.2632448375225067,
0.2316918522119522,
-0.29647061228752136,
0.025721516460180283,
0.7536248564720154,
-0.14271865785121918,
0.8280967473983765,
-0.15984633564949036,
0.26490747928619385,
-0.9906975030899048,
0.3053273558616638,
-0.24918507039546967,
-0.17649027705192566,
-0.604600191116333,
0.5773726105690002,
0.1436702311038971,
0.052578143775463104,
-0.47887152433395386,
0.7521870732307434,
-0.5177500247955322,
-0.4598274827003479,
-0.08225221931934357,
-0.002271185629069805,
0.15523281693458557,
-0.009093633852899075,
-0.3303295075893402,
1.075096607208252,
0.13493551313877106,
-0.3851330280303955,
0.35905885696411133,
0.17837052047252655,
-0.4890967309474945,
0.4414759576320648,
-0.816467821598053,
0.32975342869758606,
-0.09381073713302612,
-0.06097299978137016,
-0.8515317440032959,
-0.10076548159122467,
0.02698851004242897,
-0.4456092417240143,
0.4395757019519806,
-0.2057800143957138,
-0.8802588582038879,
-0.01128588430583477,
-0.45214638113975525,
0.45013660192489624,
0.851446807384491,
-0.8701993823051453,
0.6763022541999817,
0.42496106028556824,
0.051962412893772125,
-0.6268762350082397,
-0.21366801857948303,
0.008781230077147484,
-0.14997151494026184,
-0.5051687955856323,
0.3583295941352844,
-0.1116953194141388,
-0.37736648321151733,
-0.008815200999379158,
-0.07652178406715393,
-0.1382497102022171,
-0.25555241107940674,
-0.11881791055202484,
0.05746757984161377,
0.09653694182634354,
0.1864636242389679,
-0.2887840270996094,
-0.11709526926279068,
-0.06069327890872955,
0.18114231526851654,
0.3977733850479126,
0.0030096678528934717,
-0.3953762948513031,
0.17088939249515533,
0.25441017746925354,
0.13832588493824005,
-0.17165671288967133,
0.5621260404586792,
0.40013614296913147,
-0.020508965477347374,
-0.5515462756156921,
-0.8129923343658447,
0.15889152884483337,
-0.4951134920120239,
0.108617402613163,
-0.3998108506202698,
-0.6065876483917236,
0.5082337856292725,
-0.27957403659820557,
0.3411678075790405,
0.2967008650302887,
0.5522834658622742,
-0.25994551181793213,
0.7757299542427063,
0.5527036190032959,
0.3599705994129181,
0.5209345817565918,
-0.1984650045633316,
-0.05487802252173424,
-1.2921515703201294,
-0.11110570281744003,
-0.6488876938819885,
-0.12177623808383942,
-0.6348387002944946,
-0.7336568236351013,
0.6134105324745178,
0.32981210947036743,
-0.2932274043560028,
0.1483020782470703,
-0.5638024210929871,
0.6022142767906189,
0.5946957468986511,
-0.1929539144039154,
0.3447962701320648,
0.061499178409576416,
-0.09355884045362473,
0.06103034317493439,
-0.7314656376838684,
-0.34668317437171936,
1.201262354850769,
0.1752227395772934,
0.725430965423584,
0.26604053378105164,
1.00981605052948,
0.3441472351551056,
0.6062145829200745,
-0.35984092950820923,
0.4321610629558563,
-0.3942473530769348,
-0.8402285575866699,
-0.0992431640625,
-0.7009548544883728,
-1.130510687828064,
0.4456523358821869,
-0.22222808003425598,
-0.3623019754886627,
0.09575048089027405,
0.2528029680252075,
0.1995268315076828,
0.12862686812877655,
-0.6668757796287537,
0.709730327129364,
-0.11979532986879349,
-0.40759822726249695,
0.0027187177911400795,
-0.3354094326496124,
0.29493269324302673,
0.12714926898479462,
0.2919501066207886,
-0.12655584514141083,
0.060720622539520264,
0.5960540771484375,
-0.008426905609667301,
0.3214516341686249,
-0.16854238510131836,
-0.09314417839050293,
0.38056036829948425,
0.10560975968837738,
0.546970784664154,
-0.2199815958738327,
-0.23444989323616028,
0.09810523688793182,
0.18038608133792877,
-0.3806174397468567,
-0.5022663474082947,
0.7134788632392883,
-0.7573094964027405,
-0.4529308080673218,
-0.5635389685630798,
-0.6129893064498901,
-0.45890557765960693,
0.07411354035139084,
0.059260886162519455,
0.29600659012794495,
-0.37834298610687256,
0.15577052533626556,
0.9183787703514099,
-0.4384351968765259,
0.0568879134953022,
0.6541228294372559,
-0.5041688084602356,
-0.7848931550979614,
1.1536577939987183,
0.13496410846710205,
0.4421645402908325,
0.31700924038887024,
0.23989082872867584,
-0.34698355197906494,
-0.6228225827217102,
-0.3336910903453827,
0.36804044246673584,
-0.7436437606811523,
-0.40352877974510193,
-0.25777098536491394,
-0.26874756813049316,
-0.6277690529823303,
0.12520316243171692,
-0.4614400565624237,
-0.38303667306900024,
0.019767334684729576,
0.018276508897542953,
0.28082767128944397,
0.7290327548980713,
-0.14349566400051117,
-0.11838141828775406,
-0.7894057631492615,
0.713202178478241,
0.3842790424823761,
0.6634859442710876,
0.014952839352190495,
-0.37995466589927673,
-0.35988152027130127,
-0.2927171587944031,
-0.26158344745635986,
-0.6586219668388367,
0.20169314742088318,
0.1414676010608673,
0.8746667504310608,
-0.19437220692634583,
0.20342646539211273,
0.4564145803451538,
-0.7444809675216675,
0.8301362991333008,
-0.05124114453792572,
-0.7252528071403503,
0.3540225028991699,
-0.4099062383174896,
0.23705334961414337,
0.6646764278411865,
0.25571224093437195,
-0.5492352843284607,
-0.25952020287513733,
-0.6550650596618652,
-1.2251214981079102,
0.161747545003891,
0.10236553102731705,
-0.08465073257684708,
-0.23198185861110687,
0.352117121219635,
0.08267950266599655,
0.21185094118118286,
-0.4961055815219879,
-0.1195531114935875,
0.12542271614074707,
-0.17743025720119476,
-0.06274645775556564,
-0.6040803790092468,
-0.4703957438468933,
0.1300145536661148,
0.8069223761558533,
0.04045194014906883,
-0.09281465411186218,
0.10134266316890717,
-0.06342174112796783,
0.035629332065582275,
0.23708254098892212,
0.05329781770706177,
1.0911697149276733,
-0.2196342796087265,
0.09582814574241638,
0.2626660168170929,
-0.0383932963013649,
0.05674578249454498,
0.05064481124281883,
-0.512748658657074,
0.3251255452632904,
0.3310469090938568,
0.3333563208580017,
0.10590488463640213,
-1.0033282041549683,
0.2759350836277008,
0.07911275327205658,
0.06607840210199356,
-0.5556596517562866,
0.017096558585762978,
-0.055453281849622726,
0.33589670062065125,
0.42314237356185913,
-0.5781699419021606,
0.36305707693099976,
-0.32420530915260315,
0.29336029291152954,
0.5087522864341736,
-0.051999859511852264,
-0.07877541333436966,
0.33906522393226624,
0.2432955801486969,
-0.3648431599140167,
0.4399164617061615,
-0.37708479166030884,
-0.24094906449317932,
0.36453527212142944,
0.31511661410331726,
1.0441019535064697,
-0.031226739287376404,
0.1856260597705841,
0.40424373745918274,
0.13549216091632843,
-0.1819964051246643,
0.4868447482585907,
-0.07265538722276688,
-0.66450035572052,
-0.6069576740264893,
-0.9016626477241516,
-0.6715151071548462,
-0.3184394836425781,
-0.886829137802124,
0.073092982172966,
-0.06627427041530609,
-0.14993268251419067,
-0.36932751536369324,
0.05040019005537033,
-0.5288385152816772,
-0.17531371116638184,
-0.09143763035535812,
1.2488629817962646,
-0.6127994060516357,
0.5839884281158447,
0.6967540979385376,
-0.22030982375144958,
-0.47481441497802734,
-0.1384037435054779,
-0.11936897039413452,
-0.6340903043746948,
0.7212135195732117,
-0.3553152084350586,
-0.06720859557390213,
-0.12595252692699432,
-0.3991047441959381,
-1.071286678314209,
1.0579514503479004,
0.23917032778263092,
-0.373291552066803,
0.08781445771455765,
-0.10239583998918533,
0.8395571708679199,
0.04548587650060654,
0.28256139159202576,
0.4821198284626007,
0.29802367091178894,
0.2686398923397064,
-0.988901674747467,
-0.35382217168807983,
-0.12209875136613846,
0.48932182788848877,
0.44747987389564514,
-0.6561882495880127,
0.801877498626709,
0.23729795217514038,
-0.40468165278434753,
0.3889307975769043,
0.6937226057052612,
0.8289269804954529,
0.45190197229385376,
0.4043589234352112,
1.1119455099105835,
0.40879759192466736,
-0.0436294786632061,
1.1526191234588623,
-0.15212471783161163,
0.550281822681427,
1.2566344738006592,
-0.317525714635849,
1.121317744255066,
0.6891888380050659,
-0.33578354120254517,
0.4347192049026489,
0.3140471577644348,
0.10929437726736069,
0.5642673969268799,
0.6105019450187683,
-0.2875477373600006,
0.12199699878692627,
-0.42152583599090576,
-0.4464041292667389,
-0.07745851576328278,
0.16104306280612946,
-0.1995524764060974,
-0.4421932101249695,
-0.3448801338672638,
-0.45291653275489807,
0.2511429786682129,
-0.12231342494487762,
1.081477165222168,
-0.14064036309719086,
-0.6476457118988037,
0.7455111742019653,
-0.37330493330955505,
0.6533432006835938,
-0.6566870808601379,
-0.13175897300243378,
-0.32912373542785645,
0.1821429282426834,
-0.13918164372444153,
-0.7731126546859741,
0.42536795139312744,
0.18341480195522308,
-0.3348168730735779,
-0.4756774604320526,
0.5576217770576477,
-0.35848236083984375,
-0.37731125950813293,
0.38715556263923645,
0.6845254302024841,
0.13531623780727386,
0.41371095180511475,
-0.4666478931903839,
0.4390135407447815,
-0.28710925579071045,
-0.38803237676620483,
0.5547314882278442,
0.5399823784828186,
0.2002502828836441,
0.5607473254203796,
0.6720587015151978,
0.45046278834342957,
0.22384731471538544,
0.33544376492500305,
0.9186210036277771,
-0.4801517426967621,
0.008025869727134705,
-0.2944779396057129,
0.5123428106307983,
-0.25634869933128357,
-0.34327518939971924,
0.9340236783027649,
0.6724290251731873,
1.1351550817489624,
0.13142633438110352,
0.36309537291526794,
-0.324430912733078,
1.2740139961242676,
-0.4046100676059723,
0.5183531641960144,
-0.5609731674194336,
0.3196006119251251,
-0.026134919375181198,
-1.1827234029769897,
-0.03669043630361557,
0.31140291690826416,
0.16027195751667023,
-0.006804805714637041,
0.3315253257751465,
0.747399091720581,
0.2575025260448456,
-0.4863305985927582,
0.23123431205749512,
0.13493327796459198,
0.6589003205299377,
0.2433348447084427,
1.0427262783050537,
-0.43382036685943604,
0.44919484853744507,
-0.11134491860866547,
-0.2308824062347412,
0.05878113955259323,
-1.0444002151489258,
-0.6049296259880066,
-0.6313045620918274,
0.01178776379674673,
-0.2257520705461502,
0.4658195972442627,
0.6989116668701172,
0.49175530672073364,
-0.7093265056610107,
-0.4712626039981842,
0.06135071441531181,
0.2605951726436615,
-0.24319741129875183,
-0.28307268023490906,
0.28931382298469543,
-0.7914278507232666,
-0.7423644065856934,
0.34595853090286255,
-0.17967690527439117,
-0.2162940502166748,
-0.48968884348869324,
-0.07377199083566666,
-0.2749655246734619,
-0.13348640501499176,
0.5165724158287048,
0.4553237557411194,
-0.6596763134002686,
-0.3726527988910675,
-0.10856109112501144,
-0.06771275401115417,
-0.3138491213321686,
0.7955308556556702,
-0.9605145454406738,
0.804751455783844,
1.0385743379592896,
0.9508920311927795,
0.5141162872314453,
0.18911990523338318,
0.6199565529823303,
-1.028114676475525,
-0.2555857300758362,
0.6278703808784485,
0.07906734198331833,
0.3802424371242523,
0.09069612622261047,
0.935675323009491,
-0.08684734255075455,
-1.0282107591629028,
-1.2737149000167847,
0.21969030797481537,
-0.5941804647445679,
-0.17652377486228943,
1.110490322113037,
-0.15085212886333466,
0.016459206119179726,
0.11899618059396744,
0.10163024067878723,
0.062163617461919785,
-0.04042496159672737,
1.023055911064148,
0.5979630947113037,
-0.2596277594566345,
-0.19245807826519012,
-0.7109184861183167,
0.5317277908325195,
0.35274577140808105,
-0.7011986374855042,
0.15664662420749664,
0.49729838967323303,
0.1863814741373062,
0.3360673189163208,
0.5292163491249084,
-0.12555593252182007,
0.16142797470092773,
-0.1749194711446762,
0.1190304234623909,
0.016181575134396553,
-0.34578412771224976,
-0.23406413197517395,
0.03179353103041649,
0.33425354957580566,
0.022980159148573875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01100v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01100v1 | Eliminating Position Bias of Language Models: A Mechanistic Approach | 2024-07-01T09:06:57 | 2024-07-01T09:06:57 | Ziqi Wang, Hanlin Zhang, Xiner Li, Kuan-Hao Huang, Chi Han, Shuiwang Ji, Sham M. Kakade, Hao Peng, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Position bias has proven to be a prevalent issue of modern language models
(LMs), where the models prioritize content based on its position within the
given context. This bias often leads to unexpected model failures and hurts
performance, robustness, and reliability across various applications. Our
mechanistic analysis attributes the position bias to two components employed in
nearly all state-of-the-art LMs: causal attention and relative positional
encodings. Specifically, we find that causal attention generally causes models
to favor distant content, while relative positional encodings like RoPE prefer
nearby ones based on the analysis of retrieval-augmented question answering
(QA). Further, our empirical study on object detection reveals that position
bias is also present in vision-language models (VLMs).
Based on the above analyses, we propose to ELIMINATE position bias caused by
different input segment orders (e.g., options in LM-as-a-judge, retrieved
documents in QA) in a TRAINING-FREE ZERO-SHOT manner. Our method changes the
causal attention to bidirectional attention between segments and utilizes model
attention values to decide the relative orders of segments instead of using the
order provided in input prompts, therefore enabling Position-INvariant
inferencE (PINE) at the segment level. By eliminating position bias, models
achieve better performance and reliability in downstream tasks where position
bias widely exists, such as LM-as-a-judge and retrieval-augmented QA.
Notably, PINE is especially useful when adapting LMs for evaluating reasoning
pairs: it consistently provides 8 to 10 percentage points performance gains in
most cases, and makes Llama-3-70B-Instruct perform even better than
GPT-4-0125-preview on the RewardBench reasoning subset. | [
-0.19476492702960968,
-0.8672640919685364,
0.965319812297821,
0.1322166621685028,
-0.31699874997138977,
-0.26249343156814575,
0.00022787063790019602,
-0.5638107657432556,
0.18533386290073395,
0.43731510639190674,
-0.4459630250930786,
-0.44410109519958496,
-0.6990282535552979,
-0.25557658076286316,
-0.4024238586425781,
0.7101427316665649,
-0.014471600763499737,
0.10078117996454239,
-0.3424050211906433,
-0.22456012666225433,
-0.6011936068534851,
-0.9752482175827026,
-0.5626471638679504,
-0.00891644787043333,
0.7202447652816772,
0.2176441252231598,
0.7927267551422119,
0.7092424035072327,
0.3953161835670471,
0.24503667652606964,
-0.2566409707069397,
-0.24569670855998993,
-0.35618558526039124,
0.07648465037345886,
-0.5087164044380188,
-0.5465851426124573,
-0.4301394522190094,
0.006965652573853731,
0.5017783045768738,
0.6504791378974915,
-0.012686757370829582,
0.13546089828014374,
-0.10425715148448944,
0.6413218379020691,
-0.9066779017448425,
-0.026296541094779968,
-0.8194876909255981,
-0.08330895751714706,
-0.365329772233963,
-0.4076773226261139,
-0.5632995963096619,
-0.16312389075756073,
0.2820812463760376,
-0.31274038553237915,
0.40790873765945435,
-0.04950403794646263,
0.9639090895652771,
0.34052443504333496,
-0.20484820008277893,
0.09129457175731659,
-0.672572910785675,
1.1320173740386963,
-0.8116434812545776,
0.48285946249961853,
0.5216766595840454,
0.08777285367250443,
-0.11652132123708725,
-0.16919226944446564,
-0.39577358961105347,
-0.058156125247478485,
-0.11717994511127472,
0.06579653918743134,
0.03159182891249657,
0.16102907061576843,
0.3875093460083008,
-0.00046929981908760965,
-0.6507477760314941,
0.118095763027668,
-0.2573980689048767,
-0.04027554392814636,
0.47487184405326843,
-0.096284419298172,
0.3281214237213135,
-0.06619498133659363,
-0.19986194372177124,
-0.20760461688041687,
-0.8769282698631287,
0.23064273595809937,
0.2957276403903961,
0.19766516983509064,
0.3326943814754486,
0.7478194236755371,
-0.4848966598510742,
0.9753352403640747,
0.3894132077693939,
-0.027413925155997276,
0.07378588616847992,
-0.23904167115688324,
-0.27146807312965393,
0.25408732891082764,
0.541799008846283,
0.32418736815452576,
0.053770117461681366,
0.04855629801750183,
-0.15668635070323944,
0.10006348788738251,
0.33748552203178406,
-0.43433114886283875,
0.006264939904212952,
0.3211752474308014,
-0.43469899892807007,
-0.17228466272354126,
0.03777064383029938,
-0.4250788688659668,
-0.2370530664920807,
-0.40337949991226196,
0.24621884524822235,
-0.20121467113494873,
-0.12219780683517456,
0.1749957650899887,
0.13025285303592682,
0.5540428757667542,
0.2469753623008728,
-1.051391363143921,
-0.03343109413981438,
0.6548007726669312,
0.4653301537036896,
-0.16153298318386078,
-0.38247713446617126,
-0.6518656015396118,
0.3796164095401764,
-0.2894355356693268,
0.860051691532135,
-0.6904622316360474,
-0.08664584904909134,
-0.023763246834278107,
0.03772349655628204,
-0.21289832890033722,
-0.5512502193450928,
0.42588308453559875,
-0.6582935452461243,
0.5135641694068909,
-0.4212634563446045,
-0.3872261345386505,
-0.18065927922725677,
0.24147522449493408,
-0.5914512276649475,
0.9674181938171387,
-0.0953516811132431,
-0.7497725486755371,
0.44170111417770386,
-0.3185441493988037,
-0.36084359884262085,
-0.4554685652256012,
-0.2898253798484802,
-0.33391502499580383,
0.19155669212341309,
0.4051200747489929,
0.32335418462753296,
-0.06801438331604004,
0.6128199696540833,
-0.4657544493675232,
-0.45307737588882446,
0.22945262491703033,
-0.49260082840919495,
0.6340685486793518,
0.05825674906373024,
-0.45652899146080017,
0.4491928815841675,
-0.5474435091018677,
-0.14507706463336945,
0.17364491522312164,
-0.1689905822277069,
-0.6156995296478271,
0.3104912042617798,
-0.333963006734848,
0.4489884674549103,
0.19149132072925568,
-0.3305310904979706,
-0.03213309869170189,
-0.47388824820518494,
0.020092982798814774,
0.7630152702331543,
0.08882243186235428,
0.6452550888061523,
0.10062786936759949,
0.4342118203639984,
0.17341811954975128,
0.3912355601787567,
0.07028846442699432,
-0.36714887619018555,
-0.8358420729637146,
0.039482831954956055,
0.022596292197704315,
0.5551943778991699,
-0.7467866539955139,
0.3620344400405884,
-0.014451763592660427,
-0.013780803419649601,
-0.4640001356601715,
-0.04651400074362755,
0.6021632552146912,
0.5929152965545654,
0.3988095223903656,
-0.24040061235427856,
-0.2879052460193634,
-1.0996218919754028,
-0.4157142639160156,
-0.35470888018608093,
-0.11621034145355225,
-0.04170575365424156,
-0.04876471683382988,
0.2085849493741989,
0.891657292842865,
-0.6179103255271912,
-0.11923790723085403,
-0.15754489600658417,
-0.23248909413814545,
0.32596996426582336,
0.3940591812133789,
0.543312132358551,
-0.7306670546531677,
-0.2308526486158371,
-0.3577324450016022,
-0.7280514240264893,
-0.1641860455274582,
-0.04176095500588417,
-0.4285043478012085,
0.26778072118759155,
0.5430458188056946,
-0.7195069789886475,
0.49809515476226807,
0.22917945683002472,
-0.5874133706092834,
0.4689490497112274,
0.02901611104607582,
0.04735228791832924,
-0.7122547626495361,
0.04171058163046837,
0.1814197152853012,
-0.10491673648357391,
-0.6267256140708923,
0.1427944153547287,
0.04697473347187042,
0.12869831919670105,
-0.5989077687263489,
0.5348920822143555,
-0.45961830019950867,
-0.2254597395658493,
-0.24917925894260406,
0.41469988226890564,
0.20274122059345245,
0.838880181312561,
0.34352076053619385,
0.5264079570770264,
0.26492416858673096,
-0.518147349357605,
-0.039936598390340805,
0.025183826684951782,
-0.1447572112083435,
0.6208947896957397,
-0.6965197920799255,
0.1096939891576767,
-0.20355509221553802,
-0.11805755645036697,
-0.8286304473876953,
0.21255351603031158,
0.5538070797920227,
-0.33155009150505066,
0.49502938985824585,
-0.16289521753787994,
-0.19419659674167633,
-0.15369825065135956,
-0.3408721089363098,
0.5571035146713257,
0.13548089563846588,
-0.2583903968334198,
0.08993057906627655,
0.34513556957244873,
-0.21806836128234863,
-0.8548661470413208,
-0.27788448333740234,
-0.22012455761432648,
-0.227277010679245,
-0.3219652771949768,
0.23195724189281464,
0.12082250416278839,
-0.38316982984542847,
0.08962500095367432,
-0.5186046361923218,
-0.12377690523862839,
0.13666841387748718,
-0.11403532326221466,
0.3845605254173279,
-0.21136212348937988,
0.10644858330488205,
-0.015357733704149723,
-0.3371332585811615,
0.05517265573143959,
-0.500918447971344,
0.4865471422672272,
0.1421932876110077,
-0.724895179271698,
-0.2817997634410858,
0.1824643611907959,
0.6610509753227234,
-0.5516216158866882,
0.7539435625076294,
0.2634250223636627,
-0.27139705419540405,
0.11113709211349487,
-0.6688061952590942,
-0.37613368034362793,
-0.3859633505344391,
0.5607951283454895,
-0.25825366377830505,
-0.7117099165916443,
0.16386541724205017,
0.5210391879081726,
-0.03633575886487961,
0.26010704040527344,
0.3785746991634369,
-0.10641700029373169,
1.1177555322647095,
0.5161131024360657,
-0.43894267082214355,
0.8108922839164734,
0.003983766306191683,
0.5238187313079834,
-0.8590748310089111,
-0.16772380471229553,
-0.5743522047996521,
-0.27499017119407654,
-0.1682731807231903,
-0.46737027168273926,
0.2081146240234375,
0.24613097310066223,
-0.002956364070996642,
0.23697657883167267,
-0.5343934893608093,
0.48006364703178406,
0.7179868221282959,
0.2024100124835968,
0.10127905756235123,
-0.00005016633804189041,
-0.10826283693313599,
-0.054861683398485184,
-0.6695935726165771,
-0.4521859884262085,
0.8980284929275513,
0.3425043523311615,
0.5738701224327087,
0.034895021468400955,
0.4173768162727356,
0.045239951461553574,
-0.023010671138763428,
-0.7522165179252625,
0.5371332764625549,
-0.06789737194776535,
-0.590591549873352,
-0.5434542298316956,
0.07489534467458725,
-0.7032562494277954,
0.5854725241661072,
0.24536451697349548,
-0.8216670751571655,
0.31698644161224365,
0.20458686351776123,
-0.25009405612945557,
0.1883390247821808,
-0.6398190855979919,
1.0410908460617065,
-0.44250062108039856,
-0.8083413243293762,
-0.30702558159828186,
-0.6520200371742249,
0.3223186433315277,
0.2532437741756439,
-0.020518207922577858,
-0.3440795838832855,
0.33364981412887573,
0.6504972577095032,
-0.4022659361362457,
0.7940616607666016,
-0.42669612169265747,
-0.28960156440734863,
0.323134183883667,
0.10947205126285553,
0.5849169492721558,
-0.13574057817459106,
-0.0044961473904550076,
0.13209189474582672,
0.058367788791656494,
-0.6037545204162598,
-0.6024510860443115,
0.5053485631942749,
-0.6123515963554382,
-0.8861446976661682,
-0.43071991205215454,
-0.5907344818115234,
-0.40747952461242676,
0.1292998045682907,
0.13219420611858368,
0.5030245780944824,
0.05803060531616211,
-0.05110875144600868,
0.8377904891967773,
-0.29482051730155945,
0.4103231430053711,
0.542115330696106,
-0.1777041256427765,
-0.035073984414339066,
0.8710539937019348,
-0.019109925255179405,
0.3059632480144501,
0.7615102529525757,
-0.04973172768950462,
-0.5078251957893372,
-0.6238709092140198,
-0.18475252389907837,
0.37307509779930115,
-0.7258472442626953,
0.13793842494487762,
-0.5397962927818298,
-0.13621219992637634,
-0.17133083939552307,
-0.15479809045791626,
-0.428513765335083,
-0.4873810112476349,
-0.26827728748321533,
-0.25402960181236267,
-0.05343984439969063,
0.335629940032959,
0.5159701108932495,
0.33663612604141235,
-0.555258572101593,
0.3421214520931244,
0.2089693546295166,
0.30903348326683044,
0.026057465001940727,
-0.5494063496589661,
-0.1596067249774933,
-0.007376071065664291,
-0.2540384531021118,
-0.7438075542449951,
0.32897841930389404,
-0.22102899849414825,
0.8404501080513,
0.5711020231246948,
-0.03445771336555481,
0.7454618215560913,
-0.46492433547973633,
0.6846094727516174,
0.12232159823179245,
-0.9049054980278015,
0.7090432643890381,
-0.2816604673862457,
0.3376199007034302,
0.4618166983127594,
0.15083187818527222,
-0.479974627494812,
-0.6431972980499268,
-0.5215686559677124,
-0.7916567325592041,
0.8494892716407776,
0.04805117845535278,
-0.3394688069820404,
0.05031890794634819,
0.32573768496513367,
-0.13722863793373108,
0.30313053727149963,
-0.7559366226196289,
-0.0658496767282486,
0.003278020303696394,
-0.30658966302871704,
-0.0709434524178505,
-0.6741583943367004,
0.0845196545124054,
-0.18586227297782898,
0.708041787147522,
-0.08550003916025162,
0.1492196023464203,
0.3735535740852356,
-0.467168390750885,
-0.06341415643692017,
0.30952590703964233,
0.7632290720939636,
0.9446413516998291,
-0.2940918207168579,
0.3380655348300934,
-0.0671553909778595,
-0.2441522479057312,
0.2285068780183792,
-0.18667787313461304,
-0.6797798871994019,
0.10759469866752625,
0.29979977011680603,
0.7929362654685974,
0.45342394709587097,
-0.4079236388206482,
0.386596143245697,
0.26041722297668457,
0.23798003792762756,
0.03853893280029297,
0.009394711814820766,
-0.06743879616260529,
0.28092262148857117,
0.1689475178718567,
0.057117760181427,
0.25249001383781433,
-0.33616507053375244,
0.21405823528766632,
0.6291784644126892,
-0.7488177418708801,
-0.5170753002166748,
0.7423023581504822,
0.025122983381152153,
-0.02939218282699585,
0.3610190153121948,
0.06475365906953812,
-0.5620649456977844,
0.566727876663208,
0.4706435203552246,
1.0096426010131836,
-0.35100245475769043,
0.2870442867279053,
0.34488537907600403,
0.369484543800354,
-0.13211894035339355,
0.24299192428588867,
0.020542334765195847,
-0.7742668986320496,
-0.37966421246528625,
-0.5980542302131653,
-0.2378879189491272,
0.12497403472661972,
-0.6608313322067261,
0.25685054063796997,
-0.3562406003475189,
-0.08644307404756546,
-0.27291932702064514,
-0.2555569112300873,
-0.2897491157054901,
0.2604604661464691,
0.19583135843276978,
0.5939578413963318,
-0.7837888598442078,
1.0252437591552734,
0.7542496919631958,
-0.41422829031944275,
-0.6704716682434082,
0.12475749850273132,
0.00771777518093586,
-0.8443559408187866,
0.41527068614959717,
0.05824416130781174,
-0.21428535878658295,
-0.2065189629793167,
-0.5949827432632446,
-1.0216578245162964,
0.9601212739944458,
0.43365076184272766,
-0.5560320019721985,
0.0013716929825022817,
-0.04666486009955406,
0.46140164136886597,
-0.11350502818822861,
0.24645335972309113,
0.4316155016422272,
0.10094090551137924,
0.07158616930246353,
-0.6966037154197693,
0.051346808671951294,
-0.14147555828094482,
0.18650296330451965,
0.2562628984451294,
-0.662175714969635,
0.7490041255950928,
-0.03937102481722832,
-0.0482046939432621,
-0.22019177675247192,
0.4328770339488983,
0.6913121342658997,
0.2855278551578522,
0.4328429102897644,
0.33321353793144226,
0.6790542602539062,
-0.078449547290802,
1.051376461982727,
-0.24785272777080536,
0.2515029013156891,
1.221095323562622,
-0.4977463483810425,
0.9833692908287048,
0.985606849193573,
-0.2887624502182007,
0.323478639125824,
0.7449092864990234,
0.2565780580043793,
0.7754426002502441,
-0.019413204863667488,
-0.05701329559087753,
-0.14979594945907593,
-0.14291180670261383,
-0.3478970229625702,
0.24812285602092743,
0.11089877039194107,
-0.3724188506603241,
-0.119610495865345,
-0.23193584382534027,
0.10932576656341553,
0.04718771204352379,
-0.24686606228351593,
0.6296187043190002,
0.042510900646448135,
-0.9174947142601013,
0.5365308523178101,
0.007277471479028463,
0.39509570598602295,
-0.6618570685386658,
0.08482066541910172,
-0.3737150728702545,
0.3032212555408478,
-0.03951516002416611,
-0.6001624464988708,
0.24727779626846313,
-0.14405053853988647,
-0.5850658416748047,
-0.1756458431482315,
0.8488552570343018,
-0.5428766012191772,
-0.38799741864204407,
0.4133584201335907,
0.38594570755958557,
0.1224895790219307,
-0.4117799699306488,
-0.5598191618919373,
0.12495841830968857,
0.059742677956819534,
-0.2927367091178894,
0.4203183054924011,
0.2931166887283325,
-0.42672818899154663,
0.5747410655021667,
0.6732446551322937,
0.033321019262075424,
0.1553729623556137,
0.1930873990058899,
0.6075200438499451,
-0.7617282271385193,
-0.4712453782558441,
-0.9540794491767883,
0.4101293683052063,
-0.061333879828453064,
0.10153041034936905,
0.7155489921569824,
0.3123588263988495,
0.879197359085083,
-0.2236025333404541,
0.5329017043113708,
0.10847306251525879,
0.2945316433906555,
-0.7539428472518921,
0.5792598724365234,
-0.3743995428085327,
0.4987599849700928,
-0.4290103018283844,
-1.2828865051269531,
-0.4167824387550354,
0.6183775067329407,
-0.7020659446716309,
-0.09070795774459839,
0.7885074615478516,
0.5715149641036987,
-0.03739875927567482,
-0.35118386149406433,
0.46442943811416626,
0.15637899935245514,
0.39683765172958374,
0.722194254398346,
0.9692432880401611,
-0.3520072400569916,
0.3440992832183838,
-0.3457488715648651,
-0.13914453983306885,
-0.3252720534801483,
-0.7561651468276978,
-0.6641393899917603,
-0.20990045368671417,
-0.3091621398925781,
-0.14753250777721405,
0.031551964581012726,
0.6385378837585449,
0.6561219096183777,
-1.1786497831344604,
-0.30540013313293457,
0.0758935883641243,
0.5554460287094116,
-0.31800737977027893,
-0.22685246169567108,
0.5643600821495056,
-0.43127763271331787,
-0.703896701335907,
0.3486366271972656,
0.5653585195541382,
-0.16255268454551697,
-0.10277435928583145,
-0.08494160324335098,
-0.6030089259147644,
-0.104160837829113,
0.7879874110221863,
0.29301732778549194,
-1.1589381694793701,
-0.511974036693573,
0.306746244430542,
-0.21251116693019867,
0.14965589344501495,
0.6267750859260559,
-0.6760450005531311,
0.4575361907482147,
0.43450236320495605,
0.3908419907093048,
0.23634111881256104,
0.2735947072505951,
0.8089646100997925,
-0.783259391784668,
0.6098996996879578,
-0.010553651489317417,
0.44677528738975525,
0.1970980018377304,
-0.4233774244785309,
0.5326789021492004,
0.35213595628738403,
-0.3391905426979065,
-0.7381402850151062,
0.20738855004310608,
-0.8739685416221619,
-0.38083305954933167,
1.0525524616241455,
0.0004593488702084869,
-0.3115951120853424,
-0.0072019207291305065,
-0.416036456823349,
0.21356287598609924,
-0.20023871958255768,
0.7480225563049316,
0.7530707120895386,
-0.14441004395484924,
-0.23163095116615295,
-0.5474050045013428,
0.397367000579834,
0.9433760643005371,
-0.6325196027755737,
-0.05419038236141205,
0.7063559889793396,
0.25436049699783325,
0.08341646939516068,
0.5417661070823669,
-0.2438778281211853,
0.1883174329996109,
-0.357403963804245,
0.16411317884922028,
0.3023209571838379,
-0.5045427680015564,
-0.5537281036376953,
0.21773655712604523,
0.39292213320732117,
-0.5527026057243347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01093v1 | IBSEN: Director-Actor Agent Collaboration for Controllable and Interactive Drama Script Generation | 2024-07-01T08:49:57 | 2024-07-01T08:49:57 | Senyu Han, Lu Chen, Li-Min Lin, Zhengshan Xu, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA | Large language models have demonstrated their capabilities in storyline
creation and human-like character role-playing. Current language model agents
mainly focus on reasonable behaviors from the level of individuals, and their
behaviors might be hard to constraint on the level of the whole storyline. In
this paper we introduce IBSEN, a director-actor coordinate agent framework that
generates drama scripts and makes the plot played by agents more controllable.
The director agent writes plot outlines that the user desires to see, instructs
the actor agents to role-play their characters, and reschedules the plot when
human players participate in the scenario to ensure the plot is progressing
towards the objective. To evaluate the framework, we create a novel drama plot
that involves several actor agents and check the interactions between them
under the instruction of the director agent. Evaluation results show that our
framework could generate complete, diverse drama scripts from only a rough
outline of plot objectives, meanwhile maintaining the characteristics of
characters in the drama. Our codes and prompts are available at
https://github.com/OpenDFM/ibsen. | [
-0.63206547498703,
-0.21139030158519745,
0.5062341690063477,
0.47037115693092346,
0.196839839220047,
0.18463736772537231,
-0.11374752968549728,
-0.3284960091114044,
0.4083595871925354,
0.9495856761932373,
-0.6497399806976318,
-0.43445712327957153,
-0.2713477313518524,
0.04363250359892845,
-0.16125892102718353,
0.8577396869659424,
-0.3083585500717163,
-0.005364322569221258,
-0.06850596517324448,
-0.02433866634964943,
-0.16954898834228516,
0.0742754265666008,
-0.7488739490509033,
-0.5259097814559937,
0.7609138488769531,
0.5187709331512451,
0.7153382301330566,
0.5893232822418213,
0.5140661597251892,
0.34153449535369873,
0.4144749641418457,
0.22225269675254822,
-0.4890668988227844,
0.8207457065582275,
-0.5763636231422424,
-0.29533976316452026,
-0.6205161213874817,
0.006121103186160326,
0.6155313849449158,
0.2939087450504303,
-0.15203605592250824,
-0.010287337005138397,
-0.18526411056518555,
0.15990525484085083,
-0.6112264394760132,
0.15052495896816254,
-0.09550084173679352,
-0.10316849499940872,
0.08199853450059891,
-0.009530180133879185,
-0.19988900423049927,
-0.274555504322052,
-0.012971293181180954,
-0.521386444568634,
0.1849074363708496,
-0.03171838819980621,
0.8046830296516418,
-0.07174140959978104,
-0.5694386959075928,
-0.24263280630111694,
-0.9653934240341187,
0.43075838685035706,
-0.632080614566803,
-0.2180049866437912,
0.5098207592964172,
0.69476318359375,
-0.2264963835477829,
-0.6995469331741333,
-0.6318115592002869,
-0.5996684432029724,
-0.027891865000128746,
0.13879737257957458,
0.3209013342857361,
0.3535509705543518,
0.05806121602654457,
0.024027850478887558,
-0.46137169003486633,
0.1486693024635315,
-0.1546410620212555,
-0.10345228761434555,
0.9411483407020569,
0.5163392424583435,
0.518591582775116,
-0.015037907287478447,
-0.48133018612861633,
-0.3460558354854584,
-0.756698727607727,
0.23359954357147217,
0.733325183391571,
0.030601060017943382,
-0.20825134217739105,
0.6224512457847595,
-0.15662138164043427,
0.05090644955635071,
0.36006587743759155,
-0.1423615664243698,
-0.537599503993988,
0.04842608794569969,
-0.11239326000213623,
0.3648100793361664,
0.7292382717132568,
0.8198757171630859,
0.2291567027568817,
0.059919897466897964,
-0.267873615026474,
0.1942669153213501,
0.34870487451553345,
-0.8547144532203674,
-0.2759649157524109,
0.21037329733371735,
0.0008446365245617926,
-0.41510269045829773,
0.14103791117668152,
-0.5336405038833618,
-0.8953983783721924,
-0.3559110760688782,
0.21327000856399536,
-0.5215803980827332,
-0.5794086456298828,
-0.5382824540138245,
-0.21458369493484497,
0.6157769560813904,
0.4817046523094177,
-0.8396573662757874,
0.2828364372253418,
0.4273067116737366,
0.4197969138622284,
0.004973751492798328,
-0.7657250761985779,
-0.6039034128189087,
0.9524359703063965,
-0.7246056795120239,
0.7979408502578735,
-0.23145568370819092,
-0.1610274463891983,
-0.04451080039143562,
-0.29107367992401123,
-0.13859443366527557,
-0.19865599274635315,
-0.02666592411696911,
-0.08616090565919876,
0.014091282151639462,
0.029578562825918198,
-0.2027338445186615,
0.05555519089102745,
0.4929831326007843,
-0.7853671908378601,
0.15760651230812073,
0.35666894912719727,
-0.18964429199695587,
0.3055451810359955,
-0.637928307056427,
-0.5708457231521606,
0.14492276310920715,
-0.4030582010746002,
0.1133665144443512,
-0.28850722312927246,
-0.009204904548823833,
0.3547617495059967,
-0.4586729407310486,
0.7229318618774414,
0.031366921961307526,
-0.34515655040740967,
0.5038138031959534,
-0.15525896847248077,
0.1153123751282692,
0.2904577851295471,
-0.3029688000679016,
0.34554076194763184,
-0.5208237767219543,
-0.03969183936715126,
-0.2368256151676178,
-0.10345160216093063,
0.13467510044574738,
-0.020916860550642014,
0.033199556171894073,
0.19626861810684204,
-0.04303194209933281,
-0.3228904604911804,
0.09601805359125137,
-0.22923322021961212,
-0.12291174381971359,
0.7221456170082092,
0.22981370985507965,
0.6065108180046082,
-0.8164867162704468,
1.0324925184249878,
-0.08638662099838257,
-0.11394138634204865,
-0.4129490852355957,
-0.17129673063755035,
-0.6396145224571228,
-0.6984958648681641,
-0.039821457117795944,
0.2377738058567047,
-1.015722632408142,
0.24318332970142365,
0.00907144695520401,
-0.3843119740486145,
-0.6327292323112488,
-0.13226498663425446,
0.462573766708374,
0.17767567932605743,
-0.3378041386604309,
-0.2557735741138458,
-0.4163798391819,
-0.8478551506996155,
-0.036449287086725235,
-0.48378926515579224,
-0.2890161871910095,
-0.1056457906961441,
-0.04593009874224663,
-0.02579856477677822,
1.1750141382217407,
-0.28402143716812134,
-0.3961693048477173,
-0.7665106654167175,
0.23262549936771393,
0.00925020594149828,
0.6628133654594421,
0.6402372717857361,
-0.7787100672721863,
-0.9753471612930298,
0.32057616114616394,
-0.7110387086868286,
-0.36032921075820923,
-0.21554085612297058,
-0.3721780478954315,
0.2399381548166275,
0.5367204546928406,
-0.7315641641616821,
0.5791293978691101,
0.5165600776672363,
-0.6270886063575745,
0.7268072962760925,
-0.1387823522090912,
0.6435092687606812,
-1.045624017715454,
0.5303430557250977,
-0.3123069107532501,
-0.5430640578269958,
-0.6773172616958618,
0.15186522901058197,
-0.5169199109077454,
-0.2621118426322937,
-0.37174129486083984,
0.7826929092407227,
-0.38714084029197693,
0.19961799681186676,
-0.1829662024974823,
0.41296064853668213,
0.1462789922952652,
0.9024357795715332,
-0.17968690395355225,
0.36725372076034546,
0.5978609919548035,
-0.6522664427757263,
0.6917597651481628,
0.33966919779777527,
-0.3770067095756531,
0.9571655988693237,
-0.4114779233932495,
-0.1472206860780716,
-0.39520514011383057,
0.14558261632919312,
-0.9164144396781921,
-0.7934709191322327,
0.41729581356048584,
-0.16902336478233337,
0.47008517384529114,
-0.3554307818412781,
-0.3187495172023773,
0.14655597507953644,
-0.16810443997383118,
-0.08609004318714142,
0.3428894579410553,
-0.2165929079055786,
0.8481009602546692,
0.42852047085762024,
-0.4703447222709656,
-0.1807163506746292,
-0.6346380114555359,
0.005016055889427662,
-0.06569717824459076,
-0.7539518475532532,
0.1096062958240509,
-0.20267468690872192,
-0.4128475785255432,
0.1135929599404335,
-0.017934434115886688,
-0.3250215947628021,
-0.3233409821987152,
0.3976038992404938,
-0.1588851660490036,
-0.22022347152233124,
-0.152195543050766,
0.6899275779724121,
-0.0169858168810606,
-0.22503043711185455,
0.36427149176597595,
0.46924376487731934,
0.28816890716552734,
-0.311510294675827,
-0.34934037923812866,
0.8485966920852661,
0.9014958143234253,
-0.32372498512268066,
0.5412999987602234,
0.5546944737434387,
-0.12007966637611389,
-0.22861653566360474,
-0.09907682985067368,
0.03875306621193886,
-0.4744059443473816,
0.08424942195415497,
-0.4300403296947479,
-0.431260883808136,
0.7730712890625,
-0.2237101048231125,
0.2566518485546112,
0.20957353711128235,
0.5595876574516296,
0.010733451694250107,
1.1577297449111938,
0.43846261501312256,
0.4182148873806,
0.4547121822834015,
-0.37514087557792664,
0.09121035039424896,
-0.6785495281219482,
-0.20116940140724182,
-0.1635279804468155,
-0.764228343963623,
-0.4080638587474823,
0.0015783410053700209,
0.43633919954299927,
0.09772332012653351,
-0.3762587010860443,
0.38413047790527344,
0.019282802939414978,
0.6320983171463013,
0.29166358709335327,
-0.23039257526397705,
0.1445339173078537,
-0.5090586543083191,
-0.3193172216415405,
0.23815582692623138,
-0.5876490473747253,
-0.6994603276252747,
0.5722876787185669,
0.21319903433322906,
1.0069457292556763,
0.5885046720504761,
0.7101520895957947,
0.46806544065475464,
0.47211208939552307,
-0.3248288631439209,
0.8065124750137329,
0.2705574929714203,
-0.9294939041137695,
-0.6422559022903442,
-0.20768916606903076,
-0.9773731231689453,
0.3802281618118286,
-0.19396144151687622,
-1.0508484840393066,
0.4386143088340759,
0.13765057921409607,
-0.08568207919597626,
0.0675799697637558,
-0.841301441192627,
0.8713244795799255,
0.15035204589366913,
-0.4285584092140198,
-0.17615267634391785,
-0.7542304396629333,
0.4544343650341034,
0.1669815331697464,
-0.2961982786655426,
-0.3894747495651245,
0.1670096516609192,
0.258767694234848,
-0.35595837235450745,
0.8749046325683594,
-0.12400714308023453,
-0.19971518218517303,
0.783809244632721,
0.8495617508888245,
0.46168407797813416,
0.23733654618263245,
-0.11239989101886749,
-0.4590018093585968,
0.1207374557852745,
-0.24939097464084625,
-0.6026489734649658,
0.8858090043067932,
-0.5180640816688538,
-0.5469493269920349,
-0.3554985523223877,
-0.7194094657897949,
-0.035829488188028336,
0.4442371726036072,
0.20704995095729828,
0.671731173992157,
-0.7013701796531677,
-0.04730057343840599,
0.22519539296627045,
-0.04694216698408127,
0.5096771717071533,
0.5172325968742371,
-0.6017425060272217,
-0.6576337814331055,
0.6074205040931702,
-0.1616804599761963,
0.5033186674118042,
0.3216582238674164,
-0.2507493495941162,
0.04500466212630272,
-0.0336846299469471,
-0.40990689396858215,
0.16917400062084198,
-0.444956511259079,
-0.3240705132484436,
-0.3095683753490448,
-0.2800469398498535,
-0.5245524644851685,
-0.5247889161109924,
-0.21514122188091278,
-0.1729557365179062,
0.09058953076601028,
-0.023194510489702225,
0.17163310945034027,
0.7942538857460022,
-0.1904437094926834,
0.9495594501495361,
-0.46393465995788574,
0.42105305194854736,
0.1606186330318451,
0.6272863149642944,
-0.10943827778100967,
0.20815101265907288,
-0.5005820393562317,
0.010221338830888271,
-0.6139275431632996,
-0.6358980536460876,
0.468022882938385,
0.17044781148433685,
0.5634374618530273,
0.6905049085617065,
0.3154313564300537,
0.15948452055454254,
-0.29274624586105347,
0.6049980521202087,
0.30812838673591614,
-0.7066433429718018,
0.2680763006210327,
-0.7884075045585632,
0.5229926705360413,
0.4841500222682953,
0.07802620530128479,
-0.7125120759010315,
-0.9464319348335266,
-0.5774087905883789,
-0.4087541997432709,
1.3217672109603882,
0.5746521949768066,
-0.16200757026672363,
0.2417270988225937,
-0.07001998275518417,
0.18586388230323792,
0.6215176582336426,
-0.2077309638261795,
0.06717488914728165,
0.09319279342889786,
-0.4698271155357361,
-0.20091061294078827,
-0.0035008054692298174,
-0.3533262610435486,
0.1814769059419632,
0.4727031886577606,
-0.17167575657367706,
0.15220023691654205,
0.30682411789894104,
-0.035848286002874374,
-0.736899197101593,
0.058431465178728104,
0.5439745783805847,
0.8328414559364319,
-0.3007689416408539,
0.10044048726558685,
-0.4875667989253998,
-0.5274515748023987,
0.22359779477119446,
0.020928874611854553,
-0.020318228751420975,
-0.08570826053619385,
0.5930842161178589,
0.9736105799674988,
-0.012144234031438828,
-0.8498270511627197,
0.4758792519569397,
-0.048752136528491974,
-0.2988263964653015,
-0.30206623673439026,
0.4479048252105713,
-0.05009032413363457,
0.7360249161720276,
-0.04103616997599602,
0.12366631627082825,
-0.19134703278541565,
-0.6356659531593323,
0.3529776930809021,
-0.21992123126983643,
-0.2971525490283966,
-0.2933238744735718,
0.4854927659034729,
0.36811450123786926,
-0.5648289918899536,
0.24927426874637604,
-0.2092478722333908,
-0.2980566620826721,
0.8281764984130859,
0.5190682411193848,
1.0449663400650024,
-0.6900561451911926,
0.8142513036727905,
-0.03969642147421837,
0.35822027921676636,
0.006066875532269478,
0.25498995184898376,
0.16988956928253174,
-0.6946991086006165,
-0.3547169268131256,
-0.2326958030462265,
-0.600797176361084,
-0.009601039811968803,
-0.22280597686767578,
0.5982905626296997,
-0.7047140598297119,
-0.05215026065707207,
-0.22800713777542114,
-0.10070707648992538,
-0.34691694378852844,
-0.06965545564889908,
-0.03651160001754761,
0.5424464344978333,
-0.4821292757987976,
0.5182514786720276,
0.8434085845947266,
-0.5377897620201111,
-0.6566799879074097,
0.21741952002048492,
-0.28483182191848755,
-0.07666966319084167,
0.014272294007241726,
0.2057866007089615,
0.02072611078619957,
0.08527183532714844,
-0.7727551460266113,
-0.6452360153198242,
1.3077210187911987,
0.731712818145752,
-0.14027553796768188,
-0.2541322112083435,
0.0750788003206253,
0.7827290296554565,
-0.8142746090888977,
0.14688266813755035,
0.39379623532295227,
0.5283172130584717,
0.40727466344833374,
-0.7431253790855408,
-0.05437643826007843,
-0.2202848643064499,
-0.2338113933801651,
0.4654712378978729,
-0.6223355531692505,
0.631589949131012,
-0.07821641862392426,
-0.24077579379081726,
0.47274327278137207,
0.6321191787719727,
0.3571290373802185,
0.5643014907836914,
0.3367469906806946,
-0.1764090657234192,
0.24707821011543274,
0.31287914514541626,
0.9762972593307495,
-0.031504567712545395,
-0.046264488250017166,
1.1242448091506958,
-0.7110200524330139,
0.10599058866500854,
0.28724145889282227,
0.30305638909339905,
0.6233435273170471,
0.01589307375252247,
0.3091302514076233,
0.6020490527153015,
0.24772535264492035,
-0.37317216396331787,
-0.3403758406639099,
-0.32823750376701355,
0.338436096906662,
0.44215524196624756,
0.34588348865509033,
-0.1449059247970581,
-0.3781738877296448,
0.22134476900100708,
-0.15449286997318268,
0.4319618344306946,
-0.20416685938835144,
0.7080060839653015,
0.15625925362110138,
-0.9716834425926208,
0.1702585071325302,
-0.03671569377183914,
-0.19292432069778442,
-1.1357556581497192,
-0.2665228843688965,
-0.3568388521671295,
0.30948227643966675,
0.11489363759756088,
-0.6964971423149109,
-0.10255250334739685,
0.023034829646348953,
0.008676671423017979,
-0.15921323001384735,
0.6053486466407776,
-1.233755350112915,
-0.017586542293429375,
-0.08490067720413208,
0.2134614735841751,
0.22250181436538696,
0.2208317369222641,
-0.163264662027359,
-0.09466821700334549,
-0.18384066224098206,
-0.09094893932342529,
0.23564733564853668,
0.6503365635871887,
-0.30917268991470337,
0.748753547668457,
0.11569075286388397,
0.1733342409133911,
-0.23731409013271332,
-0.05197368562221527,
0.5968124866485596,
-0.4060545265674591,
-0.9523259997367859,
-0.26811763644218445,
0.7662262320518494,
-0.2927018702030182,
-0.31659409403800964,
0.13710591197013855,
0.10022946447134018,
0.4436469078063965,
-0.34443211555480957,
0.6044756770133972,
-0.552212655544281,
0.2872229218482971,
-0.38199490308761597,
1.1392624378204346,
-0.22135551273822784,
0.024905243888497353,
-0.28133776783943176,
-1.0568883419036865,
-0.11181316524744034,
0.24258959293365479,
0.22422710061073303,
-0.011644537560641766,
0.6133158206939697,
0.900856614112854,
-0.10295100510120392,
-0.4675457775592804,
0.8104305863380432,
0.05863022804260254,
0.5275399088859558,
0.4056388735771179,
0.9687737226486206,
-0.09200175106525421,
0.3456192910671234,
0.12917795777320862,
-0.22506806254386902,
-0.24742837250232697,
-0.7573156952857971,
-1.194532036781311,
-0.5941213965415955,
-0.243063822388649,
-0.07199912518262863,
-0.02703794278204441,
1.0706208944320679,
0.5052684545516968,
-0.5719374418258667,
-0.8260764479637146,
0.04147432744503021,
0.3570369482040405,
-0.459512859582901,
-0.23011913895606995,
-0.013499604538083076,
0.09197737276554108,
-1.0077664852142334,
0.4517434239387512,
0.10881085693836212,
-0.00638642068952322,
-0.5429076552391052,
-0.4833185374736786,
-0.46440398693084717,
0.49874594807624817,
0.28374314308166504,
0.3399879038333893,
-0.2207227349281311,
-0.0013513362500816584,
-0.39255407452583313,
-0.4294120669364929,
-0.36292341351509094,
1.048885703086853,
-0.37307024002075195,
0.4906390607357025,
0.6333138346672058,
0.1667768359184265,
0.4631494879722595,
0.01610533706843853,
1.468751311302185,
-0.963692843914032,
0.2131006121635437,
0.25423145294189453,
-0.03550829738378525,
0.12028245627880096,
-0.4845050275325775,
0.3844793140888214,
-0.19307160377502441,
-0.5355662703514099,
-0.7003833651542664,
0.47573360800743103,
-0.9534711241722107,
-0.08396703749895096,
1.1005812883377075,
-0.1433929055929184,
-0.2799051105976105,
0.3667883276939392,
-0.82709139585495,
0.2956876754760742,
-0.6082797050476074,
0.2800500690937042,
0.5985226631164551,
-0.20017796754837036,
-0.21584385633468628,
0.022162804380059242,
0.637854278087616,
-0.16558407247066498,
-0.634455144405365,
-0.07096017152070999,
0.528438150882721,
-0.21276983618736267,
0.0721096619963646,
0.5478653311729431,
0.10638529807329178,
0.2389729917049408,
0.007090643979609013,
0.5342983603477478,
-0.15344089269638062,
-0.8152283430099487,
0.10184095799922943,
-0.05341850966215134,
0.05836828425526619,
0.012602124363183975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01091v1 | M2QA: Multi-domain Multilingual Question Answering | 2024-07-01T08:48:49 | 2024-07-01T08:48:49 | Leon Engländer, Hannah Sterz, Clifton Poth, Jonas Pfeiffer, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generalization and robustness to input variation are core desiderata of
machine learning research. Language varies along several axes, most
importantly, language instance (e.g. French) and domain (e.g. news). While
adapting NLP models to new languages within a single domain, or to new domains
within a single language, is widely studied, research in joint adaptation is
hampered by the lack of evaluation datasets. This prevents the transfer of NLP
systems from well-resourced languages and domains to non-dominant
language-domain combinations. To address this gap, we introduce M2QA, a
multi-domain multilingual question answering benchmark. M2QA includes 13,500
SQuAD 2.0-style question-answer instances in German, Turkish, and Chinese for
the domains of product reviews, news, and creative writing. We use M2QA to
explore cross-lingual cross-domain performance of fine-tuned models and
state-of-the-art LLMs and investigate modular approaches to domain and language
adaptation. We witness 1) considerable performance variations across
domain-language combinations within model classes and 2) considerable
performance drops between source and target language-domain combinations across
all model sizes. We demonstrate that M2QA is far from solved, and new methods
to effectively transfer both linguistic and domain-specific information are
necessary. We make M2QA publicly available at https://github.com/UKPLab/m2qa. | [
-0.6146819591522217,
-0.947230339050293,
0.2352929562330246,
0.3054109215736389,
0.07147517800331116,
0.3012918531894684,
-0.09004583954811096,
-0.3287786543369293,
-0.31466808915138245,
0.3714562952518463,
-0.8320891857147217,
-0.22970938682556152,
-0.5029886364936829,
0.23217777907848358,
-0.009997237473726273,
0.8883048892021179,
-0.2076408863067627,
0.27131524682044983,
-0.4092163145542145,
-0.632379412651062,
-0.5551057457923889,
-0.8310246467590332,
-0.8133826851844788,
-0.18933700025081635,
0.5562868714332581,
0.24556595087051392,
0.5176291465759277,
-0.024401947855949402,
0.2655201256275177,
0.2084963470697403,
0.1914045661687851,
0.5519199371337891,
-0.3278979957103729,
0.038527023047208786,
-0.2963455021381378,
-0.49897146224975586,
-0.4404912292957306,
-0.12664088606834412,
0.6750619411468506,
0.6965137124061584,
0.10132426023483276,
0.22983305156230927,
0.15598876774311066,
0.7215923070907593,
-0.5541038513183594,
-0.018685778602957726,
-0.7212620973587036,
-0.07347773760557175,
0.21686379611492157,
-0.17962943017482758,
-0.38867565989494324,
-0.047869522124528885,
0.0755682960152626,
-0.69102543592453,
0.14799338579177856,
-0.08370255678892136,
0.7985545992851257,
0.11780650168657303,
-0.6131700873374939,
-0.20377464592456818,
-0.5343849658966064,
0.8875142931938171,
-0.477295458316803,
0.6585659384727478,
0.45805054903030396,
0.4782250225543976,
-0.024004224687814713,
-0.4941945970058441,
-0.5647965669631958,
0.17411857843399048,
0.14867985248565674,
0.20724350214004517,
-0.40229859948158264,
-0.4483222961425781,
-0.13488377630710602,
0.05361245572566986,
-0.9307106137275696,
0.10431493818759918,
-0.2065550684928894,
-0.3299233615398407,
0.5994189381599426,
0.09829040616750717,
0.286388099193573,
0.04956991598010063,
-0.34330251812934875,
-0.10513287037611008,
-0.756923496723175,
0.3026057481765747,
0.21216155588626862,
0.33647605776786804,
-0.07202926278114319,
0.4151439666748047,
-0.30770954489707947,
0.6088482737541199,
-0.03263523429632187,
-0.006926087662577629,
0.26930758357048035,
-0.49196600914001465,
-0.07584568858146667,
-0.6455152630805969,
0.5184656977653503,
0.43406936526298523,
0.20747902989387512,
-0.1838330626487732,
0.008181115612387657,
-0.4055521786212921,
0.20501166582107544,
-0.6992189884185791,
-0.28659844398498535,
0.39668914675712585,
-0.23917034268379211,
0.19842684268951416,
-0.3867592215538025,
-0.6396442651748657,
-0.1586858630180359,
-0.2804751992225647,
0.6653470396995544,
-0.25619277358055115,
-0.21733148396015167,
0.11270476132631302,
-0.14091309905052185,
0.39488473534584045,
0.28294289112091064,
-0.7958986759185791,
0.27810826897621155,
0.6455892324447632,
0.49219611287117004,
-0.4222959876060486,
-0.658005952835083,
-0.5725587606430054,
0.04057607799768448,
-0.29909375309944153,
0.8126630783081055,
-0.4053269326686859,
-0.19971629977226257,
0.0976954773068428,
0.38406556844711304,
-0.5039254426956177,
-0.7116458415985107,
0.42555132508277893,
-0.8600276708602905,
0.5223997831344604,
-0.22139424085617065,
-0.44022098183631897,
-0.36863815784454346,
0.4020675718784332,
-0.567599892616272,
1.103070855140686,
0.29519620537757874,
-0.6465174555778503,
0.10315346717834473,
-0.5519093871116638,
-0.4291318655014038,
-0.18131506443023682,
-0.012655027210712433,
-0.36634519696235657,
-0.03483092039823532,
0.5494846105575562,
0.3749706447124481,
-0.3620923161506653,
0.061338864266872406,
-0.2670985758304596,
-0.1255495250225067,
0.45999374985694885,
-0.3939012587070465,
0.9690130352973938,
0.07419221848249435,
-0.11488883942365646,
-0.03247574716806412,
-0.6266573667526245,
0.32606157660484314,
0.14802256226539612,
-0.5351943969726562,
-0.09696667641401291,
-0.2585960030555725,
0.10806003212928772,
0.4637696146965027,
0.03915894404053688,
-0.24490761756896973,
0.08547145873308182,
-0.04432447627186775,
0.4618228077888489,
0.5969905257225037,
0.02523360401391983,
0.41806352138519287,
-0.5165404081344604,
0.8110787868499756,
0.17383122444152832,
-0.16457228362560272,
0.04253368824720383,
-0.6916590929031372,
-0.8123644590377808,
-0.1762758195400238,
0.6089357733726501,
0.8849000930786133,
-1.1782537698745728,
-0.010214840061962605,
-0.12839381396770477,
-0.25899213552474976,
-0.7349681258201599,
0.3106718063354492,
0.3495931625366211,
0.31508299708366394,
0.5147700309753418,
-0.3069770038127899,
-0.4874667823314667,
-0.9203118681907654,
-0.3898082673549652,
-0.14037856459617615,
-0.17829149961471558,
0.4505791664123535,
0.4713593125343323,
-0.23384171724319458,
0.5294309854507446,
-0.18828314542770386,
-0.022523019462823868,
-0.3380790054798126,
0.09171152114868164,
0.02934390679001808,
0.3553173542022705,
0.5378368496894836,
-0.9516724944114685,
-0.5234479904174805,
-0.08074968308210373,
-0.6051080822944641,
-0.04452526941895485,
-0.08168648183345795,
-0.47681495547294617,
0.396442711353302,
0.302268385887146,
-0.6242732405662537,
-0.010969996452331543,
0.958349883556366,
-0.16276799142360687,
0.7708686590194702,
0.01233293954282999,
0.23413343727588654,
-1.1996644735336304,
0.05257062241435051,
-0.21107232570648193,
-0.2266383022069931,
-0.6928189992904663,
0.32964208722114563,
0.2649267613887787,
-0.05144978687167168,
-0.5841634273529053,
0.8544150590896606,
-0.28915634751319885,
-0.036231815814971924,
-0.17225562036037445,
0.18259268999099731,
0.4764266610145569,
0.6897931098937988,
-0.007203785702586174,
1.26499342918396,
0.45826223492622375,
-0.8023373484611511,
0.2073429375886917,
0.3134796917438507,
-0.13988827168941498,
0.6007506847381592,
-0.5650967955589294,
0.2796967029571533,
0.002064746106043458,
0.26866233348846436,
-1.0140833854675293,
0.025564095005393028,
0.11382533609867096,
-0.6763667464256287,
0.21997855603694916,
-0.2625715434551239,
-0.4146275222301483,
-0.14921021461486816,
-0.1277833729982376,
0.5449678897857666,
0.28233078122138977,
-0.41551828384399414,
0.6216183304786682,
0.4159688651561737,
-0.46248573064804077,
-0.7143358588218689,
-0.7274364829063416,
0.12512081861495972,
-0.11221566796302795,
-0.7154302597045898,
0.25814080238342285,
-0.40473371744155884,
-0.0038415694143623114,
-0.08256897330284119,
-0.014393027871847153,
-0.5219285488128662,
0.32339030504226685,
-0.13828499615192413,
0.18851788341999054,
-0.546413779258728,
0.160883367061615,
0.21459491550922394,
-0.022429270669817924,
0.13375084102153778,
-0.4191720485687256,
0.3792293071746826,
-0.07969389855861664,
-0.23559947311878204,
-0.2294987440109253,
0.625201404094696,
0.3502286970615387,
-0.27251341938972473,
0.6769814491271973,
0.8768762946128845,
-0.344190776348114,
-0.5268880724906921,
-0.19706706702709198,
-0.07123742252588272,
-0.4103739857673645,
0.6454965472221375,
-0.957648754119873,
-1.1314020156860352,
0.31514546275138855,
-0.0812070295214653,
0.17689469456672668,
0.6732110977172852,
0.922537624835968,
-0.27722445130348206,
0.8751871585845947,
0.7144689559936523,
-0.07565803825855255,
-0.09654080122709274,
-0.06080268323421478,
0.17024736106395721,
-0.8147977590560913,
0.06524398922920227,
-0.5605430006980896,
-0.12726418673992157,
-0.5189974308013916,
-0.856126606464386,
0.24052634835243225,
0.22168366611003876,
-0.033756501972675323,
0.31023097038269043,
0.012546290643513203,
0.3247819244861603,
0.6013689637184143,
-0.14267884194850922,
0.33381137251853943,
0.033417411148548126,
-0.28384244441986084,
-0.15713311731815338,
-0.9368771314620972,
-0.3162899911403656,
1.2246779203414917,
0.1872575432062149,
0.3784709572792053,
0.4557044804096222,
0.22185173630714417,
0.33602437376976013,
0.11177600920200348,
-0.553339421749115,
0.29225799441337585,
-0.31743356585502625,
-0.806450366973877,
-0.2258846014738083,
-0.5901420712471008,
-0.9615026116371155,
0.6266619563102722,
-0.14554846286773682,
-0.4060821533203125,
0.02438056468963623,
-0.0057911197654902935,
-0.23222120106220245,
0.15856079757213593,
-0.48882603645324707,
0.868137001991272,
-0.26971152424812317,
-0.3398331105709076,
-0.06308398395776749,
-0.4574090838432312,
0.2869831919670105,
-0.35912084579467773,
0.43363505601882935,
-0.2261369377374649,
-0.06567984074354172,
0.5854567885398865,
0.19097527861595154,
0.6123881936073303,
-0.09404885023832321,
-0.1680814027786255,
0.10881397873163223,
0.15208320319652557,
0.16554352641105652,
0.2512529492378235,
-0.09609328955411911,
0.21521539986133575,
0.30930230021476746,
-0.7970088720321655,
-0.6261767148971558,
0.47094258666038513,
-0.9975645542144775,
-0.48249438405036926,
-0.09406676888465881,
-0.8467840552330017,
-0.8498176336288452,
0.03199907764792442,
0.08627870678901672,
0.2817538380622864,
-0.34797659516334534,
0.020383285358548164,
0.7010983824729919,
-0.4518277943134308,
0.2511494755744934,
0.6555853486061096,
-0.3114771246910095,
-0.3640267550945282,
0.906836986541748,
-0.07074246555566788,
0.33539438247680664,
0.6601812243461609,
-0.041526760905981064,
-0.4125864803791046,
-0.5870907306671143,
-1.205338954925537,
0.10072539746761322,
-0.762842059135437,
-0.12457307428121567,
-0.8237626552581787,
-0.3360460102558136,
-0.46613872051239014,
0.09298177063465118,
-0.16184134781360626,
-0.8293065428733826,
0.01989428512752056,
0.12229285389184952,
0.07702361047267914,
0.300760954618454,
0.05331498384475708,
-0.018460534512996674,
-0.8576767444610596,
0.6810523271560669,
0.5885470509529114,
0.09191901981830597,
-0.24613170325756073,
-0.9009360671043396,
-0.35176798701286316,
0.1897495836019516,
-0.3586457073688507,
-0.5678905248641968,
0.1354798674583435,
0.5317369699478149,
0.700677216053009,
-0.17799831926822662,
0.05927335470914841,
0.4541734457015991,
-0.5656138062477112,
0.7456655502319336,
-0.2354779839515686,
-0.7517518997192383,
0.03669421747326851,
-0.2922161817550659,
0.4971703290939331,
0.582771897315979,
0.6602421998977661,
-0.7892780303955078,
-0.20984384417533875,
-0.16741101443767548,
-0.589189350605011,
0.4370478391647339,
0.1614953726530075,
0.22142624855041504,
0.44483813643455505,
0.17310529947280884,
0.38963907957077026,
0.2832503318786621,
-0.607928454875946,
-0.2815069258213043,
-0.004908401519060135,
-0.09254005551338196,
-0.2355750948190689,
-0.10341934859752655,
-0.3274567127227783,
-0.25840139389038086,
0.8612014651298523,
-0.5055821537971497,
0.4483811557292938,
-0.05385283753275871,
-0.4738241136074066,
0.17122364044189453,
0.37765154242515564,
0.5144789218902588,
0.8114238977432251,
0.0487077534198761,
0.10544876754283905,
0.4237035810947418,
-0.23571324348449707,
0.1608041375875473,
0.23882703483104706,
-0.12869484722614288,
0.026444245129823685,
0.32439911365509033,
0.4953080415725708,
-0.08174438029527664,
-0.8263750076293945,
0.40699195861816406,
-0.3691926896572113,
-0.5152790546417236,
-0.029472216963768005,
-0.08159279823303223,
0.3327327370643616,
0.34542974829673767,
0.4518711566925049,
0.053711432963609695,
0.1408510059118271,
-0.5451807975769043,
0.36355993151664734,
0.3521718382835388,
-0.3414439558982849,
-0.39590388536453247,
0.5670982599258423,
0.1492871642112732,
-0.15342207252979279,
0.4248671233654022,
-0.19155235588550568,
-0.6998634338378906,
0.5673712491989136,
0.4811970591545105,
0.7917876839637756,
-0.06117700785398483,
0.42174988985061646,
0.3188466727733612,
0.37589722871780396,
0.4177740514278412,
0.5003196597099304,
0.07614657282829285,
-0.8335737586021423,
-0.5050391554832458,
-0.551855206489563,
-0.7801488041877747,
0.051061127334833145,
-0.5584511160850525,
-0.05274036526679993,
-0.2079930454492569,
0.003210622351616621,
0.08686400204896927,
0.15567779541015625,
-0.6825181245803833,
0.28878840804100037,
0.15114359557628632,
0.9174898266792297,
-0.8062126636505127,
0.9736230969429016,
0.7974265813827515,
-0.03130904212594032,
-0.3875339925289154,
-0.036200664937496185,
0.1282767951488495,
-0.9499519467353821,
0.31481122970581055,
0.11571091413497925,
-0.13728871941566467,
-0.18973957002162933,
-0.28162097930908203,
-0.7877273559570312,
0.8181333541870117,
0.25896671414375305,
-0.12002217769622803,
0.23224575817584991,
0.4871901273727417,
0.49679407477378845,
-0.5025486350059509,
-0.03842737153172493,
0.4836709201335907,
0.38284486532211304,
-0.36159151792526245,
-0.8505777716636658,
-0.07654080539941788,
-0.44755077362060547,
-0.2403584122657776,
-0.023383472114801407,
-0.8273687362670898,
0.7895898818969727,
-0.09933046251535416,
0.021138396114110947,
0.21651329100131989,
0.5116456151008606,
0.28604722023010254,
0.4297422766685486,
0.22059708833694458,
0.4419938027858734,
0.7788946628570557,
-0.043647460639476776,
0.7885240316390991,
-0.2470722198486328,
0.16625316441059113,
1.2357324361801147,
-0.31269943714141846,
1.106410264968872,
0.4493428170681,
-0.44592204689979553,
0.4796961545944214,
0.6777424812316895,
0.06375498324632645,
0.4005984961986542,
0.08933473378419876,
-0.17194658517837524,
-0.24507233500480652,
-0.004464688245207071,
-0.33233487606048584,
0.4070757031440735,
0.2765164077281952,
0.0365842841565609,
-0.023886563256382942,
-0.0374455563724041,
-0.05850057676434517,
-0.01498203445225954,
0.006543539930135012,
0.7721998691558838,
0.02660195343196392,
-0.7079160809516907,
0.8809317350387573,
0.355974406003952,
0.4565260112285614,
-0.5684701204299927,
0.10697732120752335,
-0.45996102690696716,
0.0782386064529419,
0.0007911132415756583,
-0.5906556844711304,
0.3309357464313507,
-0.05263847857713699,
-0.42882949113845825,
-0.07685653120279312,
0.43951043486595154,
-0.468947172164917,
-0.591808557510376,
0.45005688071250916,
1.1281794309616089,
0.05950797721743584,
-0.11881598830223083,
-1.1475534439086914,
-0.15378637611865997,
0.07116727530956268,
-0.1350991576910019,
0.6503756642341614,
0.5959058403968811,
-0.11853267252445221,
0.6780689358711243,
0.678830087184906,
-0.3102830648422241,
0.3974874019622803,
0.12746362388134003,
0.7715668082237244,
-0.45608049631118774,
-0.1888902187347412,
-0.3681303858757019,
0.3951164484024048,
0.19940049946308136,
-0.6233783960342407,
0.8802648186683655,
0.6172747015953064,
1.0644683837890625,
-0.07808658480644226,
0.9396309852600098,
0.12237827479839325,
0.634656548500061,
-0.621381938457489,
0.6268578171730042,
-0.9246748685836792,
-0.005343256983906031,
0.01874379999935627,
-0.8575466275215149,
-0.21067191660404205,
0.057635899633169174,
0.06341695785522461,
0.026748979464173317,
0.8028921484947205,
0.8146369457244873,
-0.12022356688976288,
-0.11377325654029846,
0.46654826402664185,
-0.0841803029179573,
0.013477002270519733,
0.7814670205116272,
0.9025368690490723,
-0.7114561796188354,
0.7207697033882141,
-0.23377417027950287,
-0.003019314259290695,
-0.108994260430336,
-0.5247259140014648,
-0.9037274718284607,
-0.6751385927200317,
-0.3616287410259247,
-0.37562665343284607,
0.3406330347061157,
0.5230309367179871,
0.9226227402687073,
-1.0804764032363892,
-0.31519338488578796,
0.506572425365448,
0.1725054234266281,
-0.44561102986335754,
-0.18093210458755493,
0.42969459295272827,
-0.36196616291999817,
-0.7373771667480469,
0.4968518614768982,
0.14253689348697662,
-0.16446426510810852,
-0.12858271598815918,
-0.1881849616765976,
-0.3406643271446228,
0.2099442332983017,
0.7469994425773621,
0.2501460611820221,
-0.5798959732055664,
-0.004958764184266329,
0.2648525536060333,
-0.18844152987003326,
0.21914739906787872,
0.7498621940612793,
-0.3979685604572296,
0.33501681685447693,
0.29483070969581604,
1.37813401222229,
0.33137091994285583,
0.029464146122336388,
0.6924698948860168,
-0.80888831615448,
-0.05771477147936821,
0.15690749883651733,
0.16750365495681763,
0.3709096610546112,
-0.06341803818941116,
0.4735470712184906,
0.15342870354652405,
-0.6095268130302429,
-0.46843284368515015,
0.2686886489391327,
-0.6962278485298157,
-0.6242844462394714,
1.1260453462600708,
-0.32859107851982117,
-0.022435560822486877,
-0.4552053213119507,
-0.11370287090539932,
-0.06610139459371567,
-0.10451490432024002,
0.5639362335205078,
0.869849681854248,
-0.15705671906471252,
-0.3997271955013275,
-0.8941468596458435,
0.3726460635662079,
0.8275753259658813,
-0.9267025589942932,
0.01807139813899994,
0.3619653880596161,
0.2830551564693451,
-0.188597172498703,
0.5647684931755066,
0.07155152410268784,
0.5737597346305847,
0.05430583283305168,
-0.11834554374217987,
0.2811317443847656,
-0.3783758580684662,
-0.531274676322937,
0.3171118199825287,
0.22180108726024628,
-0.10249117016792297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01085v1 | Rethinking LLM-based Preference Evaluation | 2024-07-01T08:37:41 | 2024-07-01T08:37:41 | Zhengyu Hu, Linxin Song, Jieyu Zhang, Zheyuan Xiao, Jingang Wang, Zhenyu Chen, Jieyu Zhao, Hui Xiong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recently, large language model (LLM)-based preference evaluation has been
widely adopted to compare pairs of model responses. However, a severe bias
towards lengthy responses has been observed, raising concerns about the
reliability of this evaluation method. In this work, we designed a series of
controlled experiments to study the major impacting factors of the metric of
LLM-based preference evaluation, i.e., win rate, and conclude that the win rate
is affected by two axes of model response: desirability and information mass,
where the former is length-independent and related to trustworthiness, and the
latter is length-dependent and can be represented by conditional entropy. We
find that length impacts the existing evaluations by influencing information
mass. However, a reliable evaluation metric should not only assess content
quality but also ensure that the assessment is not confounded by extraneous
factors such as response length. Therefore, we propose a simple yet effective
adjustment, AdapAlpaca, to the existing practice of win rate measurement.
Specifically, by adjusting the lengths of reference answers to match the test
model's answers within the same interval, we debias information mass relative
to length, ensuring a fair model evaluation. | [
-0.5227831602096558,
-0.6450664401054382,
0.7310248613357544,
0.23742561042308807,
-0.4811006486415863,
-0.14177700877189636,
-0.4256487190723419,
-0.3921712040901184,
0.46234405040740967,
0.12479988485574722,
-0.03317633643746376,
-0.09045804291963577,
-0.9953454732894897,
0.06910894066095352,
0.19144204258918762,
0.8714105486869812,
-0.22524841129779816,
0.1971977949142456,
-0.23816347122192383,
-0.31298691034317017,
-0.5587165355682373,
-0.49359050393104553,
-0.8644930124282837,
-0.5504803657531738,
0.7227624654769897,
0.40930211544036865,
1.1094342470169067,
0.5877261161804199,
0.7303794622421265,
0.13383913040161133,
-0.2699570953845978,
0.02035175822675228,
-0.7507762908935547,
0.025478411465883255,
-0.014188695698976517,
-0.8231852650642395,
-0.6480976939201355,
0.4457508623600006,
0.7372130751609802,
0.4598938822746277,
-0.34569311141967773,
0.22929713129997253,
0.36017853021621704,
0.9823660850524902,
-0.5806230902671814,
0.08230361342430115,
-0.7185839414596558,
-0.03262098506093025,
-0.00467719417065382,
-0.7272470593452454,
-0.4269581437110901,
-0.36605098843574524,
0.1665140837430954,
-0.3962951898574829,
-0.16968296468257904,
0.05266847833991051,
0.7270848751068115,
0.14615872502326965,
-0.5088143348693848,
-0.31732773780822754,
-0.6181131601333618,
0.8018258213996887,
-0.9299899935722351,
0.31720948219299316,
0.39898625016212463,
0.2654281258583069,
-0.1819603443145752,
0.09075406938791275,
-0.4289284944534302,
-0.5947688817977905,
0.1690714955329895,
0.08273638039827347,
-0.17393741011619568,
-0.0677214115858078,
0.2222762256860733,
0.23786921799182892,
-0.28590407967567444,
0.3537200093269348,
-0.23225076496601105,
0.05305251106619835,
0.7495525479316711,
0.3109610378742218,
0.282863974571228,
-0.04429861903190613,
-0.4161594808101654,
-0.012671872042119503,
-0.7823767066001892,
0.3913165032863617,
0.8065522313117981,
0.1833219677209854,
-0.01682979054749012,
0.7833151817321777,
-0.25813448429107666,
0.7356639504432678,
0.30321574211120605,
-0.33559367060661316,
0.22474510967731476,
-0.2330278903245926,
-0.1871715933084488,
0.05159921199083328,
0.626107394695282,
0.8172141313552856,
0.15160751342773438,
-0.15412355959415436,
-0.23959490656852722,
0.1251763552427292,
0.3050180673599243,
-0.8747735619544983,
0.19954173266887665,
0.2552519142627716,
-0.6997029781341553,
-0.45875677466392517,
-0.2098766565322876,
-0.5472200512886047,
-0.5121503472328186,
-0.39707282185554504,
0.5870530605316162,
-0.2755756974220276,
-0.10721185803413391,
0.23189625144004822,
-0.1838754117488861,
0.23357848823070526,
0.46490684151649475,
-0.7877098321914673,
0.20968934893608093,
0.6319531202316284,
0.9019855260848999,
-0.6561487913131714,
-0.17161841690540314,
-0.5661131143569946,
-0.11567530781030655,
-0.26073524355888367,
0.6913023591041565,
-0.6926764249801636,
-0.48315733671188354,
-0.26260751485824585,
-0.2236429899930954,
-0.07084274291992188,
-0.3879474103450775,
0.3029634356498718,
-0.8360346555709839,
0.30893781781196594,
-0.3690696954727173,
-0.6606776714324951,
0.07904767245054245,
0.4418279826641083,
-0.8487841486930847,
0.5981293320655823,
-0.15053369104862213,
-1.1128578186035156,
0.731685996055603,
-0.591234028339386,
-0.30668994784355164,
-0.37358158826828003,
0.14319558441638947,
-0.30005547404289246,
0.0849657878279686,
-0.0059664007276296616,
0.07979295402765274,
-0.3239695727825165,
0.3291434943675995,
-0.7034367322921753,
-0.5811690092086792,
0.4497879147529602,
-0.6259602308273315,
0.44146886467933655,
0.15428529679775238,
-0.4019405245780945,
0.13875000178813934,
-0.7409006357192993,
-0.011614794842898846,
0.019459545612335205,
-0.9007061719894409,
-0.4030672609806061,
0.0009163454524241388,
-0.3466659188270569,
0.0755072608590126,
0.3588530719280243,
-0.616156816482544,
0.18863137066364288,
-0.42126744985580444,
0.1105310395359993,
1.0426392555236816,
-0.0737438052892685,
0.6190831661224365,
-0.4641725718975067,
0.6113734245300293,
-0.16409149765968323,
0.325439453125,
0.4504292607307434,
-0.22724300622940063,
-0.6979807615280151,
-0.17408008873462677,
0.3856518864631653,
0.3074699938297272,
-0.37198740243911743,
0.18532289564609528,
-0.34236863255500793,
-0.5667127966880798,
-0.46516862511634827,
0.15233629941940308,
0.0831313207745552,
0.28150254487991333,
0.18562912940979004,
-0.6188890933990479,
-0.300637423992157,
-0.9279460906982422,
-0.2144499123096466,
-0.5850323438644409,
0.01697033829987049,
0.6746043562889099,
0.17744585871696472,
0.050834156572818756,
0.8627607226371765,
-0.5827170610427856,
-0.00040939601603895426,
-0.41241317987442017,
-0.28668177127838135,
0.4393377900123596,
-0.006244261283427477,
0.5868675708770752,
-0.41900357604026794,
-0.2891673445701599,
-0.4454365074634552,
-0.28203728795051575,
-0.21879638731479645,
0.28769150376319885,
-0.1603667289018631,
0.3231777548789978,
-0.17719292640686035,
-0.5281174182891846,
0.4617290496826172,
0.6578112840652466,
-0.49185189604759216,
0.7262206673622131,
-0.10537848621606827,
0.5786272883415222,
-0.7477583289146423,
0.03496059402823448,
-0.030405178666114807,
0.030322983860969543,
-0.18919196724891663,
0.017760084941983223,
-0.02407817542552948,
0.3988247811794281,
-0.552203357219696,
0.7125121355056763,
-0.14905810356140137,
-0.21816067397594452,
-0.7229374647140503,
0.2720208764076233,
0.10605483502149582,
0.3167467415332794,
-0.020642779767513275,
0.775700032711029,
0.10132595151662827,
-0.7057079672813416,
0.4052852690219879,
-0.07329461723566055,
-0.2630422115325928,
0.6210718750953674,
-0.7950195670127869,
0.0736960619688034,
-0.11673611402511597,
0.44174087047576904,
-1.0604733228683472,
0.19801205396652222,
0.13241569697856903,
-0.5055031776428223,
0.2902756631374359,
-0.042994365096092224,
-0.32957902550697327,
-0.10062332451343536,
-0.6229896545410156,
0.2912072539329529,
0.30865728855133057,
-0.39707711338996887,
0.18115785717964172,
0.3658198118209839,
-0.07180415093898773,
-0.7564860582351685,
-0.2046290934085846,
0.019761478528380394,
-0.3945561945438385,
-0.690751314163208,
0.06919035315513611,
-0.46516159176826477,
-0.3627570867538452,
-0.222166046500206,
-0.29209262132644653,
0.15131321549415588,
0.3831484019756317,
0.2414463460445404,
0.2613831162452698,
0.04244652017951012,
0.13330459594726562,
-0.08751124888658524,
-0.03271167352795601,
-0.02554715797305107,
-0.015093176625669003,
0.5941309332847595,
-0.05574067309498787,
-0.16208472847938538,
-0.25291907787323,
0.04215681925415993,
0.6523715853691101,
-0.09927792847156525,
0.8391839265823364,
0.25836142897605896,
0.1143646240234375,
-0.09561614692211151,
-0.586658775806427,
-0.36872777342796326,
-0.35130923986434937,
0.2663390040397644,
-0.4032559394836426,
-1.0178914070129395,
0.41963478922843933,
0.3628302812576294,
-0.014894676394760609,
0.5132973194122314,
0.6882048845291138,
0.0466616228222847,
0.8881954550743103,
0.5795618295669556,
-0.33541086316108704,
0.3246942162513733,
0.025396687909960747,
-0.04196535795927048,
-0.9363821148872375,
-0.1754918098449707,
-0.3903293013572693,
-0.5719340443611145,
-0.32525303959846497,
-0.30147281289100647,
0.2605030834674835,
-0.060541070997714996,
-0.21362172067165375,
0.1131034791469574,
0.09362338483333588,
0.19643299281597137,
0.29243308305740356,
0.30738699436187744,
0.37712380290031433,
-0.25009840726852417,
-0.2713206112384796,
-0.08447229862213135,
-0.6318530440330505,
-0.577223539352417,
1.3249280452728271,
0.7520754337310791,
1.021857500076294,
0.4053988754749298,
0.45176830887794495,
0.44434353709220886,
0.32230862975120544,
-0.9779900312423706,
0.3134844899177551,
0.1296893209218979,
-0.502946138381958,
-0.6771754622459412,
-0.45303699374198914,
-0.8142707943916321,
0.29923349618911743,
-0.024744603782892227,
-0.41620784997940063,
0.03540867194533348,
0.12656456232070923,
-0.3098214566707611,
0.39085033535957336,
-0.27024319767951965,
0.460272878408432,
-0.47926750779151917,
-0.4334641396999359,
-0.28036871552467346,
-0.3689267933368683,
0.36335620284080505,
-0.11219996213912964,
0.09232885390520096,
-0.3681258261203766,
-0.16039550304412842,
0.9876641631126404,
-0.40078428387641907,
0.5844248533248901,
-0.03234703838825226,
-0.2960030734539032,
0.12015654146671295,
0.2806764245033264,
0.5778290629386902,
0.31670379638671875,
-0.4554332196712494,
0.11176283657550812,
-0.05664081871509552,
-0.24107725918293,
-0.7712178826332092,
0.7815733551979065,
-0.8496732115745544,
-0.8748494982719421,
-0.41746601462364197,
-0.4609207212924957,
-0.32405737042427063,
-0.01700679585337639,
0.014538356103003025,
0.25577521324157715,
-0.3559403419494629,
0.3146337568759918,
0.5557109117507935,
-0.28921473026275635,
0.2117534726858139,
0.9321601986885071,
-0.3263913691043854,
-0.27301105856895447,
0.37229353189468384,
0.08321020752191544,
0.5140002965927124,
0.3384729027748108,
0.39130619168281555,
-0.40206876397132874,
-0.40523794293403625,
-0.4429640769958496,
0.11572661250829697,
-0.46460115909576416,
-0.12112744152545929,
-0.5116097927093506,
0.04837692156434059,
-0.07931120693683624,
0.09513762593269348,
-0.36810386180877686,
-0.3280172049999237,
-0.2733052670955658,
-0.3110488951206207,
0.17907972633838654,
0.4189393222332001,
-0.031011689454317093,
0.25493448972702026,
-0.27170252799987793,
0.06621716171503067,
0.3915189802646637,
0.6860283613204956,
0.12372681498527527,
-1.07341468334198,
-0.08728435635566711,
0.004952267277985811,
-0.0685211792588234,
-0.7696214318275452,
0.17058205604553223,
-0.023083532229065895,
0.6291391849517822,
0.31514260172843933,
-0.17489397525787354,
0.28244948387145996,
-0.5552901029586792,
0.8103577494621277,
0.2952038645744324,
-0.5698376893997192,
0.48301056027412415,
-0.04363683611154556,
0.1681215465068817,
0.5523459315299988,
0.30347275733947754,
-0.39438900351524353,
-0.36184006929397583,
-0.5413560271263123,
-0.6567303538322449,
0.39365020394325256,
0.04848809912800789,
0.19303078949451447,
-0.0516941137611866,
0.22285932302474976,
0.32009610533714294,
0.20638395845890045,
-0.5062247514724731,
-0.36290252208709717,
0.0689866915345192,
0.3730473518371582,
-0.24858522415161133,
-0.8348889350891113,
-0.13873206079006195,
0.059635501354932785,
0.784132719039917,
0.0802433043718338,
-0.01236048899590969,
0.02575657330453396,
0.03387991338968277,
-0.13295526802539825,
0.7417616248130798,
0.5252911448478699,
1.0776121616363525,
-0.5982381105422974,
0.18184363842010498,
0.12465054541826248,
-0.35941821336746216,
0.3839882016181946,
-0.24198086559772491,
-0.27574339509010315,
0.03303881362080574,
0.10575820505619049,
0.934466540813446,
-0.026165500283241272,
-0.4059147834777832,
0.6647223830223083,
-0.19341056048870087,
0.02918323315680027,
0.016312498599290848,
0.04634596407413483,
0.010023738257586956,
-0.13549131155014038,
0.22551998496055603,
-0.06358746439218521,
0.16174468398094177,
-0.5252867937088013,
0.3192445933818817,
0.7409747838973999,
-0.7695753574371338,
-0.19629375636577606,
0.5476659536361694,
0.2743833661079407,
0.03905182704329491,
0.15818561613559723,
-0.08578891307115555,
-0.4922502636909485,
0.684078574180603,
0.5388952493667603,
0.525797426700592,
-0.3167191445827484,
0.40286266803741455,
0.24983015656471252,
0.4822409749031067,
-0.08987865597009659,
0.17653320729732513,
0.28918617963790894,
-0.7933424711227417,
-0.2380279302597046,
-0.8690191507339478,
-0.3079305589199066,
0.22882351279258728,
-0.517034649848938,
0.12801313400268555,
-0.35517191886901855,
-0.5681425929069519,
-0.10829418897628784,
0.33836764097213745,
-0.7566954493522644,
0.43468502163887024,
0.17912785708904266,
1.1255687475204468,
-0.7271646857261658,
0.5566014647483826,
0.37309491634368896,
-0.24035638570785522,
-0.8835041522979736,
-0.10829281061887741,
0.06212882325053215,
-0.9520960450172424,
0.7213213443756104,
-0.06550170481204987,
-0.24452762305736542,
-0.5154478549957275,
-0.30160391330718994,
-1.0325770378112793,
1.0375080108642578,
0.3949281573295593,
-0.5552903413772583,
0.2683236300945282,
-0.13866335153579712,
0.5672982335090637,
-0.5149250626564026,
0.5625619888305664,
0.6482528448104858,
0.4394576847553253,
0.06722484529018402,
-1.2132225036621094,
-0.04374581202864647,
-0.12837716937065125,
0.041814688593149185,
0.09061352908611298,
-0.9450486898422241,
0.3407842814922333,
-0.4728238582611084,
0.03777838498353958,
-0.08857106417417526,
0.5075955986976624,
0.3191090226173401,
0.3464028835296631,
0.6114792227745056,
0.6321049332618713,
0.6878577470779419,
0.20885197818279266,
1.1533867120742798,
-0.3415575325489044,
0.3765573799610138,
1.1557307243347168,
-0.4564955532550812,
0.9200212955474854,
0.6290209293365479,
-0.375327467918396,
0.3804728388786316,
0.7129555940628052,
0.1486484855413437,
0.41299915313720703,
0.633781373500824,
-0.053336407989263535,
-0.24267691373825073,
-0.26686397194862366,
-0.4080674648284912,
0.6618664264678955,
-0.06327914446592331,
-0.5270573496818542,
0.06018715724349022,
-0.21946781873703003,
0.3379538953304291,
-0.0962134450674057,
-0.3252994418144226,
0.5247309803962708,
0.15030772984027863,
-0.6227342486381531,
0.3737996816635132,
0.2990860044956207,
0.8505674004554749,
-0.572245180606842,
0.24654430150985718,
-0.4644981622695923,
-0.12718765437602997,
-0.059633634984493256,
-0.9181733131408691,
-0.1243637353181839,
-0.006293904036283493,
-0.44386258721351624,
0.363254576921463,
0.6459695100784302,
-0.282696008682251,
-0.346935510635376,
0.43038931488990784,
0.46766847372055054,
0.015711290761828423,
0.05494891479611397,
-0.5486652255058289,
0.3623766303062439,
-0.10200434923171997,
-0.5206755995750427,
0.4638763964176178,
-0.037300679832696915,
0.19466085731983185,
0.7938507199287415,
0.5574662089347839,
0.3452467918395996,
-0.2561698257923126,
0.014884931966662407,
0.7143062949180603,
-0.3459944725036621,
-0.4817711412906647,
-1.1264145374298096,
-0.06406955420970917,
-0.01720595732331276,
-0.15655142068862915,
0.9000879526138306,
0.7426847815513611,
0.4665616750717163,
0.10824340581893921,
0.8311569690704346,
0.07451862096786499,
0.2512595057487488,
-0.5258225798606873,
0.8957537412643433,
-0.5392146706581116,
0.5749861001968384,
-0.27175194025039673,
-1.1600933074951172,
0.053553029894828796,
0.04234694689512253,
-0.4905441999435425,
0.08475975692272186,
0.6283159852027893,
0.5181174278259277,
0.08844631165266037,
-0.31605175137519836,
0.4053076505661011,
0.11528503149747849,
0.24825218319892883,
0.8281779885292053,
0.7033922672271729,
-0.1295742243528366,
0.3989807665348053,
0.00380909675732255,
-0.5775572657585144,
-0.29277244210243225,
-0.9827221035957336,
-0.6709138751029968,
-0.2677912712097168,
-0.23558968305587769,
-0.5613455772399902,
0.19493141770362854,
0.6887345910072327,
0.34279027581214905,
-0.45616602897644043,
-0.3563205599784851,
0.7996646165847778,
0.2771647274494171,
0.0167103111743927,
-0.21028457581996918,
0.5430033206939697,
-0.2866494059562683,
-0.4089924395084381,
0.18269208073616028,
0.3679693937301636,
-0.14012202620506287,
-0.208994522690773,
-0.3099844455718994,
0.1671532243490219,
0.4385710060596466,
0.6251192092895508,
-0.0051828972063958645,
-0.7646938562393188,
-0.5450400710105896,
0.06852930039167404,
-0.3324468731880188,
0.14874930679798126,
0.564867377281189,
-0.5826846957206726,
0.6299304366111755,
0.44921058416366577,
0.41014447808265686,
0.09855221211910248,
0.20123645663261414,
0.7529886960983276,
-0.13588419556617737,
-0.10992911458015442,
-0.23635819554328918,
0.36307504773139954,
0.28332391381263733,
-0.4701918065547943,
0.4549950063228607,
0.1107664629817009,
-0.5193870067596436,
-0.6132882237434387,
0.19080236554145813,
-1.074934720993042,
-0.04642040655016899,
1.683359980583191,
-0.04035032540559769,
-0.06330506503582001,
0.3014037311077118,
-0.29677143692970276,
0.09920570254325867,
-0.5199471116065979,
1.0678273439407349,
0.847636878490448,
-0.06931722909212112,
0.09321434050798416,
-0.31085270643234253,
0.4992024600505829,
0.374850869178772,
-0.433052122592926,
-0.09167683869600296,
0.48854538798332214,
0.6833372116088867,
-0.06839882582426071,
0.7981579303741455,
-0.2302301526069641,
0.28804558515548706,
-0.41550564765930176,
-0.24227374792099,
-0.05689794942736626,
-0.37705138325691223,
-0.39773425459861755,
0.2542864680290222,
0.5125536322593689,
-0.04993455111980438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01082v1 | Min P Sampling: Balancing Creativity and Coherence at High Temperature | 2024-07-01T08:37:25 | 2024-07-01T08:37:25 | Minh Nguyen, Andrew Baker, Andreas Kirsch, Clement Neo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) generate longform text by successively sampling
the next token based on the probability distribution of the token vocabulary at
each decoding step. Current popular truncation sampling methods such as top-$p$
sampling, also known as nucleus sampling, often struggle to balance coherence
and creativity in generating text, particularly when using higher temperatures.
To address this issue, we propose min-$p$, a dynamic truncation sampling
method, that establishes a minimum base percentage threshold for tokens, which
the scales according to the probability of the top candidate token. Through
experiments on several benchmarks, such as GPQA, GSM8K and AlpacaEval Creative
Writing, we demonstrate that min-$p$ improves the coherence and quality of
generated text even at high temperatures, while also facilitating more creative
and diverse outputs compared to top-$p$ and other sampling methods. As of
writing, min-$p$ has been adopted by multiple open-source LLM implementations,
and have been independently assessed by members of the open-source LLM
community, further validating its practical utility and potential. | [
-0.5313544869422913,
-0.7196509838104248,
0.3379710018634796,
0.2850107252597809,
-0.4622774124145508,
0.3390969932079315,
-0.45166563987731934,
-0.3865973651409149,
0.3934483826160431,
0.29592064023017883,
-0.5401893258094788,
-0.6086364984512329,
-0.3208126425743103,
0.0803300142288208,
-0.3327106535434723,
0.7188276052474976,
0.1926940530538559,
-0.7194117903709412,
-0.1810528039932251,
0.2714132070541382,
0.1228400468826294,
-0.5209632515907288,
-0.585496187210083,
-0.4149715304374695,
0.595845639705658,
0.6938968896865845,
0.9032981991767883,
0.6346958875656128,
0.4068733751773834,
0.27677395939826965,
-0.3251683712005615,
0.15900662541389465,
-0.6246025562286377,
0.38673385977745056,
0.1498018205165863,
-0.3595128059387207,
-0.4274404048919678,
0.21264129877090454,
0.742619514465332,
0.5241273641586304,
-0.22433333098888397,
0.15471182763576508,
0.18602915108203888,
0.6351959109306335,
-0.876976490020752,
-0.22668986022472382,
-0.6192086935043335,
0.19718040525913239,
-0.42893484234809875,
-0.4062957167625427,
-0.5739923715591431,
-0.4592059850692749,
0.17224259674549103,
-0.4453250765800476,
0.2455151379108429,
-0.046981196850538254,
0.6959627270698547,
0.03299460932612419,
-0.13572782278060913,
-0.3642139136791229,
-0.8818150162696838,
1.0303677320480347,
-0.6708880066871643,
0.2286737561225891,
0.2732381522655487,
-0.011111128143966198,
-0.04024836793541908,
-0.4998702108860016,
-0.8172239661216736,
-0.10676027089357376,
0.46110108494758606,
0.09844943881034851,
-0.13706623017787933,
-0.1992633193731308,
0.34172049164772034,
0.49682843685150146,
-0.3915000557899475,
0.14809316396713257,
-0.23356062173843384,
-0.24610647559165955,
0.37603482604026794,
0.08935975283384323,
0.3682602047920227,
-0.21658459305763245,
-0.15725776553153992,
-0.3990519046783447,
-0.891096830368042,
0.0737258642911911,
0.6748589873313904,
0.11224991828203201,
-0.1472228616476059,
0.7788322567939758,
-0.05042896047234535,
0.46589091420173645,
0.08518966287374496,
-0.20825764536857605,
0.12671630084514618,
-0.32896187901496887,
-0.33968156576156616,
-0.19828636944293976,
0.7668246626853943,
0.3929973840713501,
-0.08581488579511642,
-0.050825562328100204,
-0.14869193732738495,
-0.1961672157049179,
-0.2139889895915985,
-0.874512791633606,
-0.754904568195343,
0.17127445340156555,
-0.2141970694065094,
-0.5350120067596436,
-0.07805845141410828,
-1.0085220336914062,
-0.30288776755332947,
-0.2233865112066269,
0.08038724213838577,
-0.37818819284439087,
-0.3310714662075043,
-0.023271117359399796,
-0.4440952241420746,
-0.1856095939874649,
0.07610160112380981,
-0.8503584265708923,
0.23702967166900635,
0.4591253399848938,
0.9240437150001526,
-0.46193090081214905,
-0.27900975942611694,
-0.5559953451156616,
0.32898882031440735,
-0.46308961510658264,
0.7304181456565857,
-0.4894273281097412,
-0.25065311789512634,
-0.24376504123210907,
-0.6962344646453857,
0.3358864188194275,
-0.5825842618942261,
0.5395527482032776,
-0.41164183616638184,
0.34719929099082947,
-0.38605669140815735,
-0.3476889729499817,
0.402434766292572,
0.09628626704216003,
-0.8978428840637207,
1.2608543634414673,
0.005710105877369642,
-0.7860115170478821,
0.5270479321479797,
-0.2668004631996155,
-0.30834025144577026,
0.23811602592468262,
0.023659387603402138,
-0.5025730133056641,
0.2572374939918518,
0.26908358931541443,
0.1923362761735916,
-0.23334459960460663,
-0.10113160312175751,
-0.1858469843864441,
-0.3366481065750122,
0.297425776720047,
-0.48797985911369324,
0.6716641187667847,
0.3366316258907318,
-0.30389177799224854,
0.173092782497406,
-0.9617493748664856,
0.39170801639556885,
-0.016505584120750427,
-0.7914151549339294,
-0.3787321448326111,
-0.22953887283802032,
0.1062125712633133,
0.12484312057495117,
-0.011363009922206402,
-0.5250583291053772,
0.15132297575473785,
-0.8774051070213318,
0.6270661950111389,
0.6135281324386597,
0.04934903606772423,
0.7832239866256714,
-0.8236684799194336,
0.5597366690635681,
-0.14068174362182617,
-0.31491565704345703,
0.07461390644311905,
-0.37879377603530884,
-0.5730746388435364,
-0.6676324009895325,
0.17884376645088196,
0.6580519676208496,
-1.0313202142715454,
0.7374395132064819,
-0.16961577534675598,
-0.8999796509742737,
-0.13731934130191803,
0.312976598739624,
0.13145780563354492,
0.46578046679496765,
0.09136094897985458,
-0.06732163578271866,
-0.6870896220207214,
-0.6383655667304993,
-0.2729606032371521,
-0.05824261158704758,
-0.09849674254655838,
-0.08328033238649368,
0.19591058790683746,
0.256417840719223,
0.9254244565963745,
-0.41744065284729004,
0.13752922415733337,
-0.5326918959617615,
0.4533569812774658,
0.38281381130218506,
0.5752554535865784,
0.4386051893234253,
-0.5321012139320374,
-0.6249733567237854,
-0.7681726813316345,
-0.2601529657840729,
-0.28993794322013855,
-0.15936094522476196,
-0.45598217844963074,
0.2873133718967438,
0.25271081924438477,
-0.9647210836410522,
0.30843421816825867,
0.5990609526634216,
-0.10821639001369476,
0.5497590899467468,
-0.11396866291761398,
0.14123524725437164,
-1.1493620872497559,
0.18464119732379913,
-0.0594361312687397,
-0.12560920417308807,
-0.7946168184280396,
0.1968647688627243,
-0.09430841356515884,
-0.41922280192375183,
-0.8624786138534546,
0.5521750450134277,
-0.5642901062965393,
0.24026644229888916,
-0.553629457950592,
0.13311225175857544,
0.20268425345420837,
0.10538409650325775,
-0.052193354815244675,
0.8206689357757568,
0.3185597360134125,
-0.761126697063446,
0.46962428092956543,
0.1398780643939972,
-0.5777280330657959,
0.06140437722206116,
-0.45878222584724426,
0.27884820103645325,
0.0004837295855395496,
0.1630980521440506,
-0.9845111966133118,
-0.16439110040664673,
0.09638787060976028,
-0.2882966995239258,
0.11166410148143768,
0.10860967636108398,
-0.9504688382148743,
-0.4917544722557068,
-0.41812360286712646,
0.6316737532615662,
0.8305324912071228,
-0.21353410184383392,
0.31832537055015564,
0.46582892537117004,
-0.32859477400779724,
-0.42586395144462585,
-0.8465224504470825,
0.2176276296377182,
-0.2933632731437683,
-0.713889479637146,
0.47321194410324097,
-0.5274615287780762,
-0.2947087287902832,
-0.27506938576698303,
-0.022660693153738976,
0.025809047743678093,
0.004361711908131838,
0.0794801115989685,
0.08009152114391327,
0.009313337504863739,
-0.08898692578077316,
-0.029190625995397568,
-0.01612767018377781,
-0.24362632632255554,
-0.2062947154045105,
1.147030234336853,
-0.0015347882872447371,
-0.20595356822013855,
-0.630047082901001,
0.40112194418907166,
0.5825813412666321,
0.18369929492473602,
0.6364098787307739,
0.5190482139587402,
-0.5088905692100525,
-0.4277973473072052,
-0.407908171415329,
-0.25067269802093506,
-0.5564169883728027,
0.06628505885601044,
-0.4872383773326874,
-0.7581422924995422,
0.5808462500572205,
0.339869886636734,
0.0864829570055008,
0.3898622393608093,
0.9182075262069702,
-0.21192291378974915,
0.5511882901191711,
0.6880188584327698,
0.20321489870548248,
0.6137767434120178,
-0.09508346766233444,
0.3656046390533447,
-0.5454463958740234,
0.09329749643802643,
-0.4923546612262726,
-0.5850858092308044,
-0.4572221040725708,
-0.515603244304657,
0.5110890865325928,
0.1860208809375763,
0.010543199256062508,
0.07454447448253632,
-0.6020972728729248,
0.7863802313804626,
1.0676274299621582,
0.19684256613254547,
0.1593419462442398,
0.39747679233551025,
-0.44637441635131836,
-0.49592024087905884,
-0.6375806331634521,
-0.331472784280777,
0.7759791612625122,
0.11525367945432663,
0.8140678405761719,
0.027106070891022682,
0.983513593673706,
0.1493508517742157,
0.055702075362205505,
-0.7121805548667908,
0.7815400958061218,
-0.14163832366466522,
-0.37502869963645935,
-0.5884158611297607,
-0.5791520476341248,
-0.6045390367507935,
0.024972805753350258,
-0.4062618017196655,
-0.46014758944511414,
-0.056359726935625076,
0.3494969606399536,
-0.4618912637233734,
0.7112804055213928,
-0.4846689701080322,
0.38951218128204346,
-0.027463799342513084,
-0.4333503544330597,
0.009770117700099945,
-0.13705310225486755,
0.3248400092124939,
-0.07709600776433945,
0.0862758606672287,
-0.3179783523082733,
-0.19306594133377075,
0.7456066012382507,
-0.270722895860672,
0.808069109916687,
-0.17379261553287506,
-0.3324630558490753,
0.5600055456161499,
0.5785962343215942,
0.6253281831741333,
-0.10931932926177979,
-0.5095967054367065,
-0.21132872998714447,
-0.023257892578840256,
-0.43861088156700134,
-0.2041711062192917,
0.5874358415603638,
-0.7044413089752197,
-0.5408997535705566,
-0.5157698392868042,
-0.8021849989891052,
-0.054741375148296356,
0.43266138434410095,
0.7244728207588196,
0.21317186951637268,
-0.06330568343400955,
0.4671807587146759,
0.44828730821609497,
-0.525241494178772,
0.5029048919677734,
0.17870065569877625,
0.018632924184203148,
-0.636028528213501,
0.7301679849624634,
0.13481274247169495,
0.4090076982975006,
0.49565914273262024,
0.5159667134284973,
-0.040028247982263565,
-0.8052265048027039,
-0.15930777788162231,
0.0565311536192894,
-0.751759946346283,
-0.16938701272010803,
-0.616953432559967,
-0.2961481511592865,
-0.5480353236198425,
-0.2541569471359253,
-0.3109506070613861,
-0.6512752771377563,
-0.3435743749141693,
-0.1568310558795929,
0.10556646436452866,
0.10325765609741211,
-0.30652979016304016,
0.502444326877594,
-0.9689698219299316,
0.3435211777687073,
-0.03257075324654579,
0.04772748425602913,
-0.08296825736761093,
-0.3929845094680786,
-0.10484418272972107,
0.05109163001179695,
-0.3269447684288025,
-0.6975122094154358,
0.6940566301345825,
0.47614821791648865,
0.37843814492225647,
-0.0011771062854677439,
0.3559586703777313,
0.5995802879333496,
-0.3700319230556488,
0.9862215518951416,
0.4867390990257263,
-1.2724858522415161,
0.5893319845199585,
-0.3197783827781677,
0.7654456496238708,
0.5976138710975647,
0.1538172960281372,
-0.7020744681358337,
-0.9782474637031555,
-0.3708384931087494,
-1.1516451835632324,
0.2778785526752472,
0.3451467454433441,
0.28261691331863403,
-0.02746139094233513,
0.3963354825973511,
0.27551186084747314,
0.29842159152030945,
-0.7890579700469971,
0.07632213085889816,
0.009074063040316105,
-0.5564079880714417,
-0.0010468318359926343,
-0.3561626970767975,
-0.229612335562706,
-0.25038015842437744,
0.5612802505493164,
-0.0033575971610844135,
0.4060682952404022,
0.06933584809303284,
-0.04816997051239014,
-0.5134087204933167,
0.44548049569129944,
0.8213008046150208,
0.8668943643569946,
-0.2098088413476944,
0.6078717112541199,
0.08035418391227722,
-0.6114857792854309,
0.12264192849397659,
-0.4560188353061676,
-0.5501347184181213,
-0.10498558729887009,
0.3193243443965912,
0.5216165781021118,
-0.05439130961894989,
-0.6654378771781921,
0.23950834572315216,
-0.026433009654283524,
-0.28603819012641907,
-0.3058566153049469,
0.322533518075943,
0.15831048786640167,
0.026507500559091568,
0.4268125891685486,
0.22058047354221344,
-0.26747167110443115,
-0.6887341737747192,
0.4534324109554291,
0.34447646141052246,
0.1498197317123413,
-0.40102800726890564,
0.48833703994750977,
0.03295811638236046,
-0.19554531574249268,
0.754510223865509,
-0.10178013145923615,
-0.42141392827033997,
0.563694179058075,
0.6682271957397461,
0.5422526597976685,
0.1984202265739441,
0.030899344012141228,
0.30519899725914,
0.4698070287704468,
-0.03696340695023537,
0.8589743375778198,
0.003497762605547905,
-0.6460809111595154,
-0.3554898202419281,
-0.6554256677627563,
-0.6545358300209045,
0.2046995609998703,
-0.34626930952072144,
0.34333834052085876,
-0.646185576915741,
-0.3330431878566742,
-0.26132965087890625,
0.06581408530473709,
-0.5849292278289795,
0.06639712303876877,
0.2696284353733063,
1.0413926839828491,
-0.8475311398506165,
0.9646264314651489,
0.29073381423950195,
-0.13464583456516266,
-0.6604814529418945,
0.20284344255924225,
0.16434481739997864,
-0.6073265671730042,
0.5446280837059021,
-0.10815445333719254,
-0.24262283742427826,
-0.0048847682774066925,
-0.613059401512146,
-1.0869337320327759,
0.976604163646698,
0.4301762580871582,
-0.6584398746490479,
-0.4058969020843506,
0.25557318329811096,
0.6358978748321533,
-0.22033630311489105,
-0.22560285031795502,
0.3360901474952698,
0.34911611676216125,
0.47828808426856995,
-0.6607958674430847,
0.10912270843982697,
-0.3515896797180176,
-0.24948929250240326,
0.15656805038452148,
-0.5082952976226807,
0.9870538711547852,
-0.1378706842660904,
-0.5084444284439087,
0.3771516978740692,
0.8676190972328186,
0.6536732316017151,
0.35068657994270325,
0.5188086628913879,
0.8608995676040649,
1.1039804220199585,
-0.15380427241325378,
0.6891303658485413,
-0.6018528342247009,
0.09357810765504837,
1.1370583772659302,
-0.3194398283958435,
1.0304676294326782,
0.6234563589096069,
0.13542085886001587,
0.20205897092819214,
0.5703059434890747,
-0.08530276268720627,
0.7319591641426086,
0.4709058701992035,
-0.30123865604400635,
-0.1586586833000183,
0.18963563442230225,
-0.17299367487430573,
0.05872826278209686,
0.3322111964225769,
-0.11696361005306244,
0.05014590919017792,
0.21984009444713593,
-0.037146568298339844,
0.04986082762479782,
-0.1731027066707611,
0.6402125954627991,
0.3063981831073761,
-0.7441445589065552,
0.7276644110679626,
0.15267686545848846,
0.893241286277771,
-0.20185010135173798,
0.5203739404678345,
-0.029752742499113083,
0.09483418613672256,
-0.21754278242588043,
-1.0992317199707031,
0.6078283786773682,
0.13292361795902252,
-0.30077192187309265,
-0.6091324687004089,
0.6824231743812561,
-0.598997950553894,
-0.4178498387336731,
-0.09770707041025162,
0.4821155369281769,
0.048603691160678864,
0.11783736199140549,
-0.449348509311676,
0.2913929522037506,
-0.2954431176185608,
-0.32862576842308044,
0.052543748170137405,
0.46677786111831665,
0.46597111225128174,
0.46632179617881775,
0.7562029361724854,
0.7298038005828857,
0.3483129143714905,
-0.0056947097182273865,
0.6905642151832581,
-0.7158980369567871,
-0.7421731948852539,
-1.0651650428771973,
0.33601483702659607,
-0.005461609922349453,
-0.22952575981616974,
0.5791942477226257,
0.6882957816123962,
0.6433848142623901,
-0.11803118139505386,
0.8054095506668091,
-0.039868079125881195,
0.5952011346817017,
-0.7116013765335083,
0.7357608079910278,
-0.37766680121421814,
0.2045566737651825,
-0.18554100394248962,
-1.1739656925201416,
-0.2940765619277954,
0.332775354385376,
-0.1974979043006897,
-0.29563045501708984,
0.7648982405662537,
0.5808066129684448,
-0.13109400868415833,
-0.16665694117546082,
0.31902816891670227,
0.04928813502192497,
0.675809383392334,
0.6751376986503601,
0.9380344748497009,
-0.22285786271095276,
0.8242508769035339,
-0.5536872148513794,
-0.10829094797372818,
0.024838954210281372,
-1.187824010848999,
-0.9244864583015442,
-0.4826521873474121,
-0.2871333360671997,
-0.6699203848838806,
-0.22504118084907532,
1.2008936405181885,
0.799970805644989,
-0.5863333344459534,
-0.17395839095115662,
-0.03137952834367752,
-0.06485789269208908,
-0.12199151515960693,
-0.25043120980262756,
0.3685709238052368,
-0.11159186065196991,
-0.8992441296577454,
0.38045915961265564,
0.4149134159088135,
0.32362601161003113,
-0.10056774318218231,
0.11115854978561401,
0.21650482714176178,
0.45808443427085876,
0.49692508578300476,
0.09269388020038605,
-0.4549480378627777,
-0.18629376590251923,
-0.05175738036632538,
-0.512461245059967,
0.3467943072319031,
0.9558375477790833,
-0.2908349633216858,
0.12241095304489136,
1.2604671716690063,
0.42387425899505615,
0.39794474840164185,
-0.06454907357692719,
0.5903357267379761,
-1.0672850608825684,
0.39865854382514954,
0.6416273713111877,
0.09533349424600601,
0.27375471591949463,
-0.28553807735443115,
-0.01363579835742712,
0.5246531367301941,
-0.4714951515197754,
-1.0155946016311646,
0.4544515609741211,
-1.0519336462020874,
-0.2076074630022049,
1.1094205379486084,
0.1424836367368698,
-0.40434515476226807,
0.2892858386039734,
-0.038156233727931976,
0.37556716799736023,
-0.48298391699790955,
0.9347286224365234,
1.0864918231964111,
-0.04672364518046379,
-0.6051361560821533,
-0.35765326023101807,
0.6799103617668152,
0.3136845827102661,
-0.8174254894256592,
0.15735673904418945,
0.41101351380348206,
0.38252580165863037,
0.16774077713489532,
0.9205789566040039,
0.06464079022407532,
0.16677825152873993,
-0.18610945343971252,
-0.021768484264612198,
-0.12439855188131332,
-0.3355947732925415,
0.06958027184009552,
0.6955039501190186,
0.1382465809583664,
0.4185171127319336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01081v1 | CVLUE: A New Benchmark Dataset for Chinese Vision-Language Understanding Evaluation | 2024-07-01T08:35:37 | 2024-07-01T08:35:37 | Yuxuan Wang, Yijun Liu, Fei Yu, Chen Huang, Kexin Li, Zhiguo Wan, Wanxiang Che | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Despite the rapid development of Chinese vision-language models (VLMs), most
existing Chinese vision-language (VL) datasets are constructed on
Western-centric images from existing English VL datasets. The cultural bias in
the images makes these datasets unsuitable for evaluating VLMs in Chinese
culture. To remedy this issue, we present a new Chinese Vision- Language
Understanding Evaluation (CVLUE) benchmark dataset, where the selection of
object categories and images is entirely driven by Chinese native speakers,
ensuring that the source images are representative of Chinese culture. The
benchmark contains four distinct VL tasks ranging from image-text retrieval to
visual question answering, visual grounding and visual dialogue. We present a
detailed statistical analysis of CVLUE and provide a baseline performance
analysis with several open-source multilingual VLMs on CVLUE and its English
counterparts to reveal their performance gap between English and Chinese. Our
in-depth category-level analysis reveals a lack of Chinese cultural knowledge
in existing VLMs. We also find that fine-tuning on Chinese culture-related VL
datasets effectively enhances VLMs' understanding of Chinese culture. | [
-0.3490371108055115,
-0.22180946171283722,
0.11702056229114532,
0.28249606490135193,
-0.37013792991638184,
-0.10991837829351425,
-0.3909115493297577,
-0.6574151515960693,
-0.2154155671596527,
0.48363199830055237,
-0.5593070983886719,
-0.6238521933555603,
-0.17138633131980896,
-0.15556445717811584,
-0.06161601468920708,
0.7179673910140991,
0.015216832980513573,
0.6083186864852905,
-0.3329557180404663,
-0.6949835419654846,
-0.7154555320739746,
-0.13906899094581604,
-0.4632321000099182,
-0.1515020728111267,
0.48072561621665955,
-0.03492119163274765,
0.3856232762336731,
0.7899554371833801,
0.5073727965354919,
0.10740827023983002,
-0.012951609678566456,
0.10467608273029327,
-0.6147490739822388,
-0.4305502772331238,
-0.13534581661224365,
-0.5401136875152588,
-0.14584605395793915,
-0.12115850299596786,
0.4462953507900238,
0.5096777081489563,
0.09162895381450653,
0.4680462181568146,
-0.011763165704905987,
0.7816988825798035,
-1.0375170707702637,
0.3893176019191742,
-0.7684463262557983,
0.3418632745742798,
-0.27210313081741333,
-0.1618489921092987,
-0.4865388870239258,
-0.06366439908742905,
0.3048405945301056,
-0.8161957263946533,
0.18778812885284424,
-0.12083238363265991,
0.9044056534767151,
0.25464096665382385,
-0.2545667886734009,
0.18276157975196838,
-0.2826148569583893,
0.7831151485443115,
-0.41104379296302795,
0.5775448679924011,
0.07893092185258865,
0.5993639230728149,
0.2984858453273773,
-0.611477792263031,
-0.41556140780448914,
-0.21129995584487915,
-0.10360773652791977,
0.47605451941490173,
0.13022814691066742,
-0.32897624373435974,
0.15913450717926025,
0.3150344491004944,
-0.8692232966423035,
0.20931588113307953,
-0.5632686614990234,
-0.2751530408859253,
0.5965800881385803,
0.18430061638355255,
0.3960433900356293,
-0.07384201139211655,
-0.6225995421409607,
-0.23781633377075195,
-0.5439150929450989,
0.5207014083862305,
-0.23219221830368042,
0.11591903865337372,
-0.14324194192886353,
0.16815875470638275,
-0.21206451952457428,
0.9932739734649658,
-0.5787814855575562,
-0.10962793231010437,
0.3951679468154907,
-0.39183565974235535,
-0.44807836413383484,
-0.09979810565710068,
0.6025902628898621,
0.8750017881393433,
0.5013561844825745,
0.047442834824323654,
-0.04785074293613434,
0.23803585767745972,
0.013027853332459927,
-0.5098342895507812,
-0.31126338243484497,
-0.04297710955142975,
-0.5961650013923645,
-0.23696854710578918,
0.24172525107860565,
-0.5643161535263062,
-0.5322540998458862,
-0.24459300935268402,
0.20592783391475677,
-0.32851341366767883,
-0.08853165805339813,
-0.06795545667409897,
-0.3229740858078003,
0.917359471321106,
0.42692050337791443,
-0.5414753556251526,
0.07105261832475662,
0.47713324427604675,
0.6083077192306519,
-0.37889087200164795,
-0.47683292627334595,
-0.7342205047607422,
-0.1313011646270752,
-0.4684343934059143,
0.5933644771575928,
-0.321037620306015,
-0.31058380007743835,
0.13304215669631958,
0.34244027733802795,
0.1280747950077057,
-0.4577774405479431,
0.7328018546104431,
-0.35629647970199585,
0.08352591097354889,
-0.6759994029998779,
-0.08919838815927505,
-0.3211066424846649,
0.23203586041927338,
-0.7168098092079163,
0.7992465496063232,
-0.036329224705696106,
-0.7116618156433105,
0.8624740839004517,
-0.3649396002292633,
-0.24853767454624176,
0.6249539256095886,
-0.4979825019836426,
-0.02611248381435871,
0.018612245097756386,
0.5881530046463013,
0.18188615143299103,
-0.3677578568458557,
-0.026668142527341843,
-0.25983956456184387,
-0.671726644039154,
-0.1374892294406891,
-0.5800918340682983,
1.1122685670852661,
0.25527524948120117,
-0.1808568239212036,
0.010437446646392345,
-0.6769905686378479,
0.14184661209583282,
0.27415984869003296,
0.06017230078577995,
-0.6106359958648682,
0.34159159660339355,
0.3518562912940979,
0.23026591539382935,
0.5671690106391907,
-0.4235667586326599,
0.10054056346416473,
-0.36167722940444946,
-0.059583961963653564,
0.741176187992096,
-0.5297325849533081,
0.21570849418640137,
-0.04660043120384216,
0.15541379153728485,
0.20233960449695587,
0.593908429145813,
-0.4219129979610443,
-0.4488210678100586,
-0.6961603164672852,
0.13435688614845276,
0.019895311444997787,
0.7156851887702942,
-1.1559813022613525,
-0.08198609203100204,
-0.22679413855075836,
-0.4724886417388916,
-0.9096570014953613,
0.2139422595500946,
0.48463910818099976,
0.49043309688568115,
0.3395763635635376,
-0.5967166423797607,
-0.18709537386894226,
-0.9879040718078613,
-0.2817716896533966,
-0.29033586382865906,
-0.19545285403728485,
0.4465780556201935,
0.14889012277126312,
0.10759630054235458,
0.6065235733985901,
-0.5116376280784607,
-0.34360960125923157,
0.022778689861297607,
-0.11389750987291336,
0.0607617013156414,
0.16074882447719574,
0.8288425207138062,
-1.0484633445739746,
-0.546238362789154,
0.5207267999649048,
-0.8768951892852783,
-0.045890532433986664,
0.04640273377299309,
-0.10936462134122849,
0.3384241759777069,
0.20381046831607819,
0.25845929980278015,
0.6088885068893433,
0.6099265813827515,
-0.24897024035453796,
0.5548369288444519,
-0.26915284991264343,
0.2107352912425995,
-0.6248801946640015,
-0.06891681998968124,
0.44851160049438477,
0.15831424295902252,
-0.6067714095115662,
0.3230845630168915,
0.5642912983894348,
0.09178484231233597,
-0.8421853184700012,
0.34734296798706055,
-0.4985056221485138,
-0.30113252997398376,
-0.06671363860368729,
0.48116594552993774,
0.11345717310905457,
0.4617098569869995,
0.39384689927101135,
0.6355017423629761,
0.904248058795929,
-0.31217995285987854,
0.35784912109375,
0.05115799605846405,
-0.6746795177459717,
0.6888953447341919,
-0.5942184925079346,
-0.0883931890130043,
-0.34674888849258423,
-0.028986582532525063,
-0.7222046256065369,
0.1673027127981186,
0.029045430943369865,
-0.30704301595687866,
0.0016525124665349722,
-0.158159539103508,
0.0064969188533723354,
-0.4522203207015991,
-0.435029000043869,
0.5470138788223267,
0.5392923951148987,
-0.7359047532081604,
0.16776199638843536,
0.08501580357551575,
0.46134260296821594,
-1.1094213724136353,
-0.6849071383476257,
0.08956792205572128,
-0.04532531276345253,
-0.7447172999382019,
0.10545377433300018,
-0.16932247579097748,
-0.2122381627559662,
-0.05353052169084549,
0.041750650852918625,
-0.25135040283203125,
0.07521974295377731,
-0.1875676065683365,
0.5188034176826477,
-0.6632381677627563,
-0.1064787209033966,
-0.3687351644039154,
0.14942201972007751,
0.028074083849787712,
-0.31789615750312805,
0.29142552614212036,
-0.2785179018974304,
-0.2943655252456665,
-0.24011613428592682,
-0.14715734124183655,
0.591506838798523,
-0.879776120185852,
0.4625943899154663,
0.9379660487174988,
-0.3218204975128174,
-0.21343842148780823,
-0.43256455659866333,
0.15760855376720428,
-0.405787855386734,
0.49329161643981934,
-0.43102189898490906,
-0.43888765573501587,
0.43427810072898865,
0.4180154502391815,
0.3730776906013489,
0.501442551612854,
0.48076653480529785,
0.005657589063048363,
0.7141512036323547,
0.6116819977760315,
-0.41683533787727356,
0.3342379927635193,
-0.11992736160755157,
-0.16541220247745514,
-0.6094573736190796,
-0.28393763303756714,
-0.23631279170513153,
-0.009715492837131023,
-0.7874153852462769,
-0.6657790541648865,
0.2595595419406891,
-0.3232170343399048,
0.2077987790107727,
0.25774943828582764,
-0.5725164413452148,
0.6671738028526306,
0.2660817801952362,
-0.0016511417925357819,
0.14695414900779724,
-0.08904136717319489,
0.04938862472772598,
-0.24317067861557007,
-0.5713186860084534,
-0.2763376533985138,
0.7492698431015015,
0.14224199950695038,
0.6233037114143372,
-0.11097822338342667,
0.07859113812446594,
0.12034083902835846,
0.2506670355796814,
-0.6535792946815491,
0.3384026885032654,
-0.7058878540992737,
-0.11436192691326141,
-0.2408757358789444,
-0.2506607174873352,
-0.8607560992240906,
0.6884761452674866,
-0.2310038059949875,
-0.9314702749252319,
0.17858494818210602,
-0.12132968753576279,
0.019427474588155746,
0.24615247547626495,
-0.5957176089286804,
1.1695209741592407,
-0.42841827869415283,
-0.5097231864929199,
-0.002585404319688678,
-0.6313028931617737,
0.7817398309707642,
-0.12277281284332275,
0.2797372341156006,
-0.1632627248764038,
0.2224259078502655,
0.4944702982902527,
-0.09620960801839828,
0.45977118611335754,
-0.23932865262031555,
-0.1556873321533203,
0.16153331100940704,
-0.16288408637046814,
0.07464317977428436,
0.10527397692203522,
-0.073219895362854,
0.41788485646247864,
0.2820470631122589,
-0.6347184777259827,
-0.6983903646469116,
0.6602539420127869,
-0.7485535144805908,
-0.4409825801849365,
-0.21756857633590698,
-0.4153501093387604,
0.08607401698827744,
0.0056540570221841335,
0.3962191343307495,
0.48439058661460876,
-0.41480734944343567,
0.37852683663368225,
0.46102219820022583,
-0.6135337948799133,
0.3489784300327301,
0.8675031661987305,
-0.15151754021644592,
0.03646434471011162,
1.0443706512451172,
0.22472664713859558,
0.190253347158432,
0.4570799171924591,
0.12685582041740417,
-0.08719509840011597,
-0.43207329511642456,
-0.5521180629730225,
-0.099723681807518,
-0.7609856128692627,
0.33877405524253845,
-0.1711159646511078,
-0.353962779045105,
-0.14404930174350739,
-0.2405947893857956,
-0.2705315351486206,
0.28401419520378113,
0.028744040057063103,
0.22224867343902588,
0.05766206979751587,
0.5624226331710815,
0.28925246000289917,
-0.09821570664644241,
-0.4935610294342041,
0.3382995128631592,
0.15168271958827972,
0.3926626741886139,
-0.07788358628749847,
-0.36205118894577026,
-0.500170111656189,
0.05895942077040672,
-0.11307862401008606,
-0.6372876763343811,
0.40936651825904846,
-0.02742670476436615,
0.7792147994041443,
0.4888950288295746,
0.024385245516896248,
0.7902782559394836,
-0.4608306288719177,
1.1619068384170532,
0.15667995810508728,
-0.762870192527771,
0.6590107679367065,
-0.09798028320074081,
0.5425100922584534,
0.4744189977645874,
0.015440445393323898,
-0.8134448528289795,
-0.3616046607494354,
-0.26481953263282776,
-0.7477091550827026,
0.6770817637443542,
0.15147362649440765,
-0.24400052428245544,
0.378318727016449,
0.08541162312030792,
0.12272332608699799,
-0.07661183178424835,
-0.9189894795417786,
-0.5141985416412354,
-0.4300454556941986,
-0.019288651645183563,
-0.2922716438770294,
0.17317454516887665,
0.14692457020282745,
-0.487222820520401,
0.2634880542755127,
-0.35568806529045105,
-0.16047081351280212,
0.11254546791315079,
-0.28033268451690674,
0.009080955758690834,
-0.10265770554542542,
0.49535611271858215,
0.7569130659103394,
-0.2601892650127411,
-0.13300076127052307,
0.6284458637237549,
-0.5793389678001404,
-0.29650169610977173,
-0.23111467063426971,
-0.18072953820228577,
0.012121309526264668,
0.39356863498687744,
1.0050472021102905,
-0.1823444366455078,
-0.785092830657959,
0.6554621458053589,
-0.4678478538990021,
-0.10359080880880356,
-0.5888482928276062,
0.2192772626876831,
-0.22893618047237396,
-0.037655044347047806,
0.4121994376182556,
-0.10193458944559097,
0.22449062764644623,
-0.40404966473579407,
0.26282641291618347,
0.41443467140197754,
-0.7559077143669128,
-0.12220196425914764,
0.7395890355110168,
0.05722532048821449,
-0.15617451071739197,
0.4875973165035248,
0.15613724291324615,
-0.31578075885772705,
0.9188053011894226,
0.06973249465227127,
0.7104708552360535,
-0.0817851722240448,
0.28570592403411865,
0.4264371693134308,
0.7375320196151733,
0.11960705369710922,
0.24297964572906494,
-0.021865475922822952,
-0.8224043846130371,
-0.6042353510856628,
-0.48153653740882874,
-0.29951247572898865,
0.3933570981025696,
-0.9175589084625244,
0.648081362247467,
-0.21687784790992737,
0.4463112950325012,
-0.11061344295740128,
-0.05361223220825195,
-0.9298757910728455,
0.5775801539421082,
0.38868358731269836,
1.107139229774475,
-0.8451148867607117,
1.0850106477737427,
0.659580647945404,
-0.28244099020957947,
-0.605079710483551,
0.143631711602211,
0.09323852509260178,
-0.9380416870117188,
0.7954357862472534,
0.31705233454704285,
-0.02273879200220108,
-0.4313370883464813,
-0.5081009268760681,
-0.5309554934501648,
1.1990463733673096,
0.19906969368457794,
-0.5324862003326416,
0.4399803578853607,
0.029933858662843704,
0.7373524904251099,
-0.43887859582901,
0.41664132475852966,
0.604436993598938,
0.46450114250183105,
-0.13565251231193542,
-0.78092360496521,
-0.21719931066036224,
-0.4826098680496216,
0.1053120344877243,
-0.08975800126791,
-0.9645552039146423,
0.6775104999542236,
0.017934061586856842,
-0.15508076548576355,
-0.05539132282137871,
0.8033142685890198,
0.09160888195037842,
0.5589869618415833,
0.7322439551353455,
0.08276303857564926,
0.6889778971672058,
-0.21456705033779144,
0.9521788954734802,
-0.33568260073661804,
0.1562371402978897,
0.9126318097114563,
-0.27756810188293457,
0.8547850847244263,
0.1905563324689865,
0.03675759211182594,
0.3026059865951538,
0.5151764750480652,
-0.2825380861759186,
0.3758816719055176,
0.2142867147922516,
-0.22142334282398224,
-0.17756572365760803,
-0.3680199086666107,
-0.37182876467704773,
0.7664392590522766,
0.35556474328041077,
-0.25204434990882874,
-0.08701131492853165,
-0.05649527162313461,
-0.49933651089668274,
0.15359415113925934,
-0.33722877502441406,
0.6232786774635315,
-0.11954458802938461,
-0.5617256164550781,
0.8722741007804871,
-0.2655210793018341,
0.6819213628768921,
-0.5812602043151855,
0.06608641892671585,
-0.24348004162311554,
-0.1295125037431717,
-0.07789644598960876,
-0.9719072580337524,
-0.08133742213249207,
0.055477503687143326,
0.02530696988105774,
0.10483993589878082,
0.6320937871932983,
-0.4029274582862854,
-0.47190117835998535,
0.5685276985168457,
0.3072999119758606,
0.2512718141078949,
0.31666603684425354,
-0.5990118384361267,
-0.0007529247086495161,
0.2534122169017792,
-0.0584833100438118,
0.2054976522922516,
0.3955138623714447,
-0.4336288869380951,
0.4930722117424011,
0.5262174010276794,
0.10309573262929916,
-0.15634609758853912,
0.47189366817474365,
0.5364890098571777,
-0.6124034523963928,
-0.27911677956581116,
-0.7726702690124512,
0.5339909195899963,
-0.3022046983242035,
-0.4940420687198639,
0.6761285066604614,
0.5039166808128357,
1.1487512588500977,
-0.20083175599575043,
0.9139285087585449,
0.19523131847381592,
-0.2506612241268158,
-0.5183929800987244,
0.9024115800857544,
-1.0628023147583008,
0.05233669653534889,
-0.4503885507583618,
-0.7402529120445251,
-0.1798628270626068,
0.5007879137992859,
-0.1660362035036087,
-0.3256719708442688,
0.5674704909324646,
0.7990481853485107,
0.04818879812955856,
0.04023144394159317,
0.8562715649604797,
0.14126500487327576,
0.2523135244846344,
0.9675158858299255,
0.6768308281898499,
-0.44847679138183594,
0.5578067302703857,
-0.36777469515800476,
-0.31731465458869934,
-0.002295929240062833,
-0.8781908750534058,
-0.8420892357826233,
-0.7176969647407532,
-0.16636453568935394,
0.1071760430932045,
0.004905935376882553,
0.5054904222488403,
0.4914666414260864,
-0.710504949092865,
-0.3584806025028229,
0.31302329897880554,
0.07902512699365616,
-0.5338890552520752,
-0.2422831952571869,
0.4303947985172272,
-0.26843225955963135,
-0.8036337494850159,
0.3370470702648163,
0.4494852125644684,
-0.17479528486728668,
-0.5181964039802551,
-0.1527109444141388,
0.21458251774311066,
-0.18735496699810028,
0.7628209590911865,
0.3593843877315521,
-1.0268172025680542,
-0.18315869569778442,
0.11272946000099182,
-0.08747590333223343,
0.15925274789333344,
0.6408957242965698,
-0.7850349545478821,
0.8579035997390747,
0.5712996125221252,
0.5465084314346313,
0.47068512439727783,
-0.24940235912799835,
0.7150557637214661,
-0.5325477719306946,
0.35420680046081543,
-0.1924656331539154,
0.6022745966911316,
0.3071572780609131,
-0.3250380754470825,
0.5564082264900208,
0.3423762619495392,
-0.25722387433052063,
-0.5155662894248962,
0.03348542004823685,
-1.2053117752075195,
-0.43242308497428894,
0.8744631409645081,
-0.1538703739643097,
-0.5698186755180359,
-0.1168006956577301,
-0.5003971457481384,
0.16406205296516418,
0.04453233256936073,
0.4292786419391632,
0.6612598896026611,
0.46548524498939514,
-0.3352135717868805,
-0.8416860103607178,
0.3498289883136749,
0.5224963426589966,
-0.5502820611000061,
0.2379416972398758,
0.4226914048194885,
0.06404590606689453,
-0.03326885774731636,
0.4399859309196472,
-0.09171226620674133,
0.687891960144043,
-0.19099493324756622,
0.2022128850221634,
0.21695594489574432,
-0.10473399609327316,
-0.21724466979503632,
0.09296420961618423,
0.04549407958984375,
-0.1951342523097992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01080v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01080v2 | Face4RAG: Factual Consistency Evaluation for Retrieval Augmented Generation in Chinese | 2024-07-01T08:35:04 | 2024-07-03T12:49:34 | Yunqi Xu, Tianchi Cai, Jiyan Jiang, Xierui Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The prevailing issue of factual inconsistency errors in conventional
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) motivates the study of Factual Consistency
Evaluation (FCE). Despite the various FCE methods proposed earlier, these
methods are evaluated on datasets generated by specific Large Language Models
(LLMs). Without a comprehensive benchmark, it remains unexplored how these FCE
methods perform on other LLMs with different error distributions or even unseen
error types, as these methods may fail to detect the error types generated by
other LLMs. To fill this gap, in this paper, we propose the first comprehensive
FCE benchmark \emph{Face4RAG} for RAG independent of the underlying LLM. Our
benchmark consists of a synthetic dataset built upon a carefully designed
typology for factuality inconsistency error and a real-world dataset
constructed from six commonly used LLMs, enabling evaluation of FCE methods on
specific error types or real-world error distributions. On the proposed
benchmark, we discover the failure of existing FCE methods to detect the
logical fallacy, which refers to a mismatch of logic structures between the
answer and the retrieved reference. To fix this issue, we further propose a new
method called \emph{L-Face4RAG} with two novel designs of logic-preserving
answer decomposition and fact-logic FCE. Extensive experiments show L-Face4RAG
substantially outperforms previous methods for factual inconsistency detection
on a wide range of tasks, notably beyond the RAG task from which it is
originally motivated. Both the benchmark and our proposed method are publicly
available.\footnote{\url{https://huggingface.co/datasets/yq27/Face4RAG}\label{link_face4rag}} | [
-0.34293049573898315,
-0.5680591464042664,
0.35508668422698975,
0.48233574628829956,
0.28457972407341003,
0.2150161862373352,
-0.08784319460391998,
-0.3932625651359558,
-0.050305306911468506,
0.35602208971977234,
-0.5554930567741394,
-0.4590708315372467,
-0.32780832052230835,
0.2712050974369049,
-0.3111517131328583,
1.0596485137939453,
-0.13053114712238312,
-0.10820218920707703,
-0.25116923451423645,
-0.6537679433822632,
-0.4594178795814514,
-0.3673415780067444,
-0.46963584423065186,
-0.17933976650238037,
0.34592756628990173,
0.05639251321554184,
0.41895756125450134,
0.4124343693256378,
0.4885385036468506,
0.3317899703979492,
-0.05659496784210205,
0.48129215836524963,
-0.5371566414833069,
-0.20205475389957428,
-0.34169667959213257,
-0.27459606528282166,
-0.3912232220172882,
0.30749014019966125,
0.8257776498794556,
0.3460577428340912,
-0.43954965472221375,
0.16802610456943512,
-0.09012945741415024,
0.8584050536155701,
-0.8138371706008911,
0.036436744034290314,
-0.7936948537826538,
0.30481863021850586,
-0.6038751602172852,
0.005462804809212685,
-0.4317983388900757,
-0.560366153717041,
-0.26938313245773315,
-0.5271034240722656,
0.6341067552566528,
0.3107343316078186,
1.0736461877822876,
0.36741963028907776,
-0.2414005994796753,
-0.15127401053905487,
-0.473334401845932,
0.5832853317260742,
-0.8432267904281616,
0.7171114087104797,
-0.11295075714588165,
0.6218326687812805,
-0.2618260085582733,
-0.9356766939163208,
-1.017207384109497,
-0.22491508722305298,
-0.16859902441501617,
0.19675159454345703,
0.0013891329290345311,
-0.05625508353114128,
0.5929113030433655,
0.4612111449241638,
-0.47622838616371155,
-0.31168439984321594,
0.03384237363934517,
-0.5845028758049011,
0.419171005487442,
-0.10634860396385193,
0.398197203874588,
-0.27656060457229614,
-0.5571487545967102,
-0.19778983294963837,
-0.8312252163887024,
0.054215915501117706,
0.25954127311706543,
0.040882110595703125,
-0.20547237992286682,
0.4157446026802063,
-0.31886065006256104,
0.464581161737442,
0.3474256992340088,
-0.5405852794647217,
0.6624850630760193,
-0.5254249572753906,
-0.21476735174655914,
-0.08956491947174072,
0.6283294558525085,
0.2736349105834961,
-0.026324817910790443,
0.023494068533182144,
-0.28431040048599243,
0.13167579472064972,
0.28848984837532043,
-0.7123502492904663,
-0.2676026225090027,
0.012579157017171383,
-0.3482423424720764,
-0.3511815071105957,
0.07013760507106781,
-0.9420909285545349,
-0.5814085602760315,
-0.08657749742269516,
0.4234127402305603,
-0.2750803232192993,
-0.32233861088752747,
-0.25630325078964233,
0.04980066418647766,
0.40196824073791504,
0.37117889523506165,
-0.5552940368652344,
0.3401203453540802,
0.755592942237854,
0.6549270153045654,
-0.30896374583244324,
-0.2213749885559082,
-0.9428130388259888,
-0.18827539682388306,
-0.5103189945220947,
1.0780999660491943,
-0.06511548906564713,
0.03700272738933563,
0.041988521814346313,
0.07670055329799652,
-0.2570825219154358,
-0.9764951467514038,
1.154298186302185,
-0.4141162633895874,
0.24188145995140076,
-0.6723933815956116,
-0.5124014616012573,
-0.17653051018714905,
0.6695398688316345,
-0.8087300658226013,
1.1355429887771606,
0.22862203419208527,
-1.057868480682373,
0.3827260732650757,
-0.3125930428504944,
-0.1770758032798767,
0.10247980803251266,
-0.7595508694648743,
-0.7894371747970581,
-0.11971008032560349,
0.04220391437411308,
0.033311549574136734,
-0.33637791872024536,
0.5094814300537109,
-0.2627140283584595,
-0.3785177171230316,
-0.009184898808598518,
-0.5391631722450256,
0.9176686406135559,
-0.03222428634762764,
-0.6863850951194763,
-0.0515698678791523,
-0.6667195558547974,
0.08478382229804993,
0.08565875142812729,
-0.3165527582168579,
0.1482752561569214,
-0.02107236720621586,
-0.19007818400859833,
0.24328282475471497,
0.36699071526527405,
-0.7279072999954224,
-0.239302858710289,
-0.2766411602497101,
-0.16129225492477417,
0.6904144287109375,
-0.24522583186626434,
-0.13732580840587616,
-0.636925995349884,
0.239567369222641,
0.1539776623249054,
-0.18390648066997528,
-0.056322526186704636,
-0.29375970363616943,
-0.7416703701019287,
-0.29577794671058655,
0.3066246211528778,
0.6433108448982239,
-1.121620774269104,
0.04540438950061798,
-0.24242551624774933,
-0.35242360830307007,
-0.2267141193151474,
0.2675303816795349,
0.680619478225708,
0.9622166156768799,
0.4553719162940979,
0.14104610681533813,
-0.5176511406898499,
-1.0143252611160278,
-0.6741997003555298,
-0.2827683389186859,
0.11207955330610275,
0.3761610984802246,
0.29814690351486206,
-0.2101195752620697,
0.8753094673156738,
-0.0074922628700733185,
-0.2494676411151886,
-0.10923123359680176,
0.16402731835842133,
0.3470519185066223,
0.37276533246040344,
0.7560873627662659,
-0.9883445501327515,
-0.49324026703834534,
0.023307738825678825,
-0.9761074185371399,
-0.4956985116004944,
0.02468809485435486,
-0.2003995031118393,
0.7106584906578064,
0.21028220653533936,
-0.5421387553215027,
0.41201409697532654,
0.6840018033981323,
-0.1514255851507187,
0.8803095817565918,
0.11344800889492035,
0.41802385449409485,
-0.5057849884033203,
0.3181690275669098,
0.13477787375450134,
-0.23843194544315338,
-0.5927635431289673,
0.10879925638437271,
0.4334104061126709,
0.1782417893409729,
-0.28149881958961487,
0.585448682308197,
-0.26333239674568176,
-0.3892030119895935,
-0.0984184741973877,
0.26878008246421814,
0.1587715893983841,
0.5050148367881775,
-0.14476782083511353,
0.8120726943016052,
-0.033730749040842056,
-0.31841397285461426,
0.37836548686027527,
0.40874192118644714,
-0.19905869662761688,
1.1052449941635132,
-0.6057476997375488,
0.014684027060866356,
-0.17137353122234344,
0.5067442059516907,
-0.9055766463279724,
-0.3594045042991638,
0.3756045699119568,
-0.35651353001594543,
0.3405676782131195,
0.005568406078964472,
-0.4720565378665924,
-0.32176685333251953,
-0.49897369742393494,
0.3660096228122711,
0.26257333159446716,
-1.002466082572937,
0.7568632364273071,
0.18776464462280273,
0.07330331206321716,
-0.9560067653656006,
-0.3558732569217682,
-0.03017217479646206,
-0.1860964298248291,
-0.8618890047073364,
0.5263541340827942,
-0.40933021903038025,
-0.29837608337402344,
-0.17263999581336975,
-0.5574406981468201,
-0.022225774824619293,
-0.1999758630990982,
-0.18933318555355072,
0.3458952009677887,
-0.40132907032966614,
-0.13797669112682343,
-0.13051597774028778,
0.1397067904472351,
0.19621504843235016,
0.16967780888080597,
0.19373613595962524,
-0.22210852801799774,
-0.32224422693252563,
-0.3123224377632141,
-0.11395538598299026,
0.22680039703845978,
-0.08276134729385376,
0.44613251090049744,
0.641887366771698,
-0.583357036113739,
-0.2856248915195465,
-0.9896257519721985,
0.17403437197208405,
-0.5192747712135315,
0.03206934779882431,
-0.4029315412044525,
-0.5110759735107422,
0.4622500240802765,
-0.10309990495443344,
0.32439109683036804,
0.6226954460144043,
0.27580904960632324,
0.04826055094599724,
0.6706169843673706,
0.3520704209804535,
0.09236757457256317,
-0.04979535937309265,
0.0273243710398674,
0.23844602704048157,
-0.8150830268859863,
-0.34523648023605347,
-0.49864980578422546,
-0.13813892006874084,
-0.8049347400665283,
-0.45515772700309753,
0.6714022159576416,
-0.04743540287017822,
-0.4786805808544159,
0.06910521537065506,
-0.20119822025299072,
0.21415533125400543,
0.19745686650276184,
-0.10202457010746002,
0.42833954095840454,
-0.08188831061124802,
-0.2305000126361847,
-0.3379662036895752,
-0.5300672650337219,
-0.18494178354740143,
0.582944929599762,
0.17033997178077698,
0.2157999873161316,
0.23003274202346802,
0.5379578471183777,
0.47012072801589966,
0.6488276124000549,
-0.40340569615364075,
0.46489065885543823,
-0.2075684666633606,
-0.6811217665672302,
0.07511162757873535,
-0.7644754648208618,
-0.4357990026473999,
0.5676421523094177,
-0.42264556884765625,
-0.3871924579143524,
0.0549137145280838,
0.28109803795814514,
-0.07175528258085251,
0.2905638813972473,
-0.15290160477161407,
1.0792261362075806,
-0.19351156055927277,
-0.46076616644859314,
0.1387251317501068,
-0.5675548315048218,
0.9595005512237549,
-0.23566249012947083,
0.368662029504776,
-0.2300107628107071,
0.16593097150325775,
0.6349083185195923,
-0.5424306392669678,
0.34827741980552673,
-0.44103556871414185,
-0.19741027057170868,
0.1539672464132309,
-0.0671834722161293,
0.6685829162597656,
0.01832396537065506,
-0.1569502353668213,
0.3112286925315857,
-0.030789559707045555,
-0.27476534247398376,
-0.5636307597160339,
0.7815021276473999,
-0.5417593717575073,
-0.5161848068237305,
-0.673011839389801,
-0.23754210770130157,
-0.4927421510219574,
0.35287144780158997,
0.35338592529296875,
0.5805976986885071,
-0.29181087017059326,
0.15133799612522125,
0.7965168356895447,
-0.481765478849411,
0.19529114663600922,
0.6962149739265442,
-0.2155480682849884,
-0.4649140238761902,
0.8318570256233215,
0.09798683226108551,
0.013417186215519905,
0.2833084762096405,
0.19614586234092712,
-0.32819047570228577,
-0.28586670756340027,
-0.6791336536407471,
0.4264574646949768,
-0.737424910068512,
-0.454382061958313,
-0.6007341146469116,
-0.6074100732803345,
-0.38593998551368713,
0.13165199756622314,
-0.5468662977218628,
-0.0007822352927178144,
0.36576008796691895,
0.09320409595966339,
0.08431161195039749,
0.438792884349823,
-0.17287883162498474,
0.052847832441329956,
-0.6050638556480408,
0.74555903673172,
0.07512977719306946,
0.3647749125957489,
-0.24855104088783264,
-0.6062166094779968,
0.010855269618332386,
0.09398388862609863,
-0.4599723219871521,
-0.6381514072418213,
0.17899824678897858,
0.15272951126098633,
0.7862787842750549,
0.18961293995380402,
0.10247546434402466,
0.6017550230026245,
-0.7605280876159668,
0.5163969397544861,
-0.06600117683410645,
-1.040117859840393,
0.19108834862709045,
-0.30339473485946655,
-0.08204063028097153,
0.6275969743728638,
0.16995839774608612,
-0.6287657618522644,
-0.032280925661325455,
-0.8194604516029358,
-0.5284426212310791,
0.5424823760986328,
0.4108535349369049,
-0.30984896421432495,
-0.004948077257722616,
0.3242833614349365,
0.06950974464416504,
0.3421252965927124,
-0.6749222278594971,
-0.4472493529319763,
-0.33972224593162537,
-0.30530139803886414,
0.32741427421569824,
-0.17518137395381927,
-0.07674496620893478,
0.04700815677642822,
0.6930162310600281,
-0.26712745428085327,
0.18690016865730286,
0.18817956745624542,
0.15956512093544006,
-0.025821279734373093,
-0.132014662027359,
0.5494890213012695,
0.6816251873970032,
-0.13268928229808807,
0.02103208564221859,
0.40404170751571655,
-0.39017194509506226,
-0.04789713770151138,
0.2865538001060486,
-0.274908185005188,
0.27242985367774963,
0.30452510714530945,
0.47612231969833374,
0.27853161096572876,
-0.6838706135749817,
0.8884224891662598,
-0.07394390553236008,
-0.10818526148796082,
-0.8536241054534912,
-0.10012708604335785,
-0.0822417289018631,
0.05265890061855316,
0.36238107085227966,
0.28181082010269165,
0.2974913716316223,
-0.5153249502182007,
0.4323331117630005,
0.4371846318244934,
0.06391482055187225,
-0.2978765368461609,
0.8015397787094116,
0.14550544321537018,
0.06267128884792328,
0.3879513442516327,
-0.2792254686355591,
-0.6176026463508606,
0.5525984168052673,
0.38789960741996765,
0.6566264629364014,
-0.28028252720832825,
0.33394286036491394,
0.5835007429122925,
0.4203702211380005,
-0.29581958055496216,
0.1823696494102478,
0.1296953409910202,
-1.123327612876892,
-0.39376628398895264,
-0.6080971360206604,
-0.5676949620246887,
0.2093629240989685,
-0.5126051902770996,
0.3332652449607849,
-0.7472879886627197,
0.27026116847991943,
-0.11784036457538605,
0.263701468706131,
-0.5821623206138611,
0.4473389685153961,
0.17579525709152222,
0.9163554310798645,
-0.640687882900238,
0.5437285304069519,
0.37105295062065125,
-0.16675324738025665,
-0.8060395121574402,
0.22679677605628967,
0.5026940703392029,
-0.7359222173690796,
0.5629642605781555,
0.4089672863483429,
-0.38968607783317566,
-0.3755473494529724,
-0.6166906952857971,
-0.8419256806373596,
1.0683304071426392,
0.23127098381519318,
-0.39304980635643005,
0.19595979154109955,
-0.09093697369098663,
0.35535284876823425,
-0.39016756415367126,
0.24800945818424225,
0.8580712676048279,
0.7070828676223755,
0.270822137594223,
-0.9131796956062317,
0.23413802683353424,
-0.3412504196166992,
0.013040418736636639,
0.06788495928049088,
-0.9000092148780823,
0.911327600479126,
0.06000407040119171,
-0.4995085895061493,
0.17190870642662048,
0.7813889980316162,
0.8616688847541809,
0.7748623490333557,
0.6111692190170288,
0.664237380027771,
0.9688720703125,
-0.19425776600837708,
0.8851025700569153,
-0.1578047126531601,
0.3109234869480133,
1.0102392435073853,
-0.754520058631897,
0.7651838660240173,
-0.03214273229241371,
-0.1753542274236679,
0.7016024589538574,
0.1618415117263794,
0.016821712255477905,
0.25838252902030945,
-0.04330533742904663,
-0.40543708205223083,
0.08126460760831833,
0.007979857735335827,
-0.32499080896377563,
0.41269490122795105,
0.33884575963020325,
0.041216474026441574,
-0.3092154562473297,
-0.4299122393131256,
0.3556237816810608,
0.42805594205856323,
-0.03899228945374489,
0.496107280254364,
-0.20240212976932526,
-0.6655091047286987,
0.8438844084739685,
0.03830784186720848,
0.7429383993148804,
-0.36262357234954834,
-0.26493579149246216,
-0.642765462398529,
0.29477518796920776,
-0.4303145706653595,
-0.4644353687763214,
0.3858512043952942,
0.16362030804157257,
-0.005996032152324915,
0.10925419628620148,
0.6951676607131958,
-0.3282022476196289,
-0.4116528034210205,
0.14963936805725098,
0.3586973547935486,
0.03370632603764534,
0.12720605731010437,
-0.6886941194534302,
0.43914392590522766,
0.20010091364383698,
-0.11044371128082275,
0.115740105509758,
0.6265850067138672,
-0.12383691221475601,
0.45587554574012756,
0.5526776909828186,
-0.06730715930461884,
-0.055297110229730606,
-0.16660980880260468,
0.742588996887207,
-0.7939494848251343,
-0.2008276879787445,
-0.5268861651420593,
0.34259361028671265,
-0.47600117325782776,
-0.21058084070682526,
0.8664441108703613,
0.5986446142196655,
0.9669543504714966,
0.2636936902999878,
0.9287936091423035,
-0.3121918737888336,
1.1048202514648438,
-0.4764242172241211,
0.5972294211387634,
-0.4755074381828308,
0.2752048373222351,
-0.2919699251651764,
-1.0517827272415161,
-0.07383593916893005,
0.6816811561584473,
0.09249580651521683,
0.27515608072280884,
0.874656617641449,
0.8155738115310669,
-0.08652371913194656,
0.11795515567064285,
0.2547568082809448,
0.457293838262558,
0.36763110756874084,
0.2985186278820038,
0.49496838450431824,
-0.5884519815444946,
0.4141591191291809,
-0.2887921631336212,
-0.338962584733963,
-0.1149730458855629,
-1.0497418642044067,
-0.6477524638175964,
-0.25797271728515625,
-0.32501018047332764,
-0.4710480570793152,
0.13147687911987305,
0.7135641574859619,
0.3012898862361908,
-0.8613638877868652,
-0.020687276497483253,
0.029054393991827965,
0.13269531726837158,
-0.19674699008464813,
-0.25906410813331604,
0.2016744613647461,
-0.40164729952812195,
-0.683704674243927,
0.4346259832382202,
0.10848575085401535,
-0.2571362555027008,
-0.2433624267578125,
0.03575748950242996,
-0.003405573545023799,
0.13911476731300354,
0.4633895754814148,
0.6032925844192505,
-0.7956415414810181,
-0.4751829504966736,
-0.1443105936050415,
-0.08091051131486893,
0.18171951174736023,
0.5576620101928711,
-0.8765508532524109,
0.21508100628852844,
0.5135099291801453,
0.9690794348716736,
0.3918704092502594,
0.3397771120071411,
0.3615046739578247,
-0.7161198854446411,
-0.006510899867862463,
0.001997126266360283,
0.47385600209236145,
0.7423723340034485,
-0.255356103181839,
0.755399227142334,
0.6618554592132568,
-0.6234158277511597,
-0.7824036478996277,
0.13465438783168793,
-0.9423096179962158,
0.20359010994434357,
0.9048961400985718,
-0.28239354491233826,
-0.19234555959701538,
0.163274347782135,
-0.06264845281839371,
0.08286041021347046,
-0.07556746155023575,
0.7111163139343262,
0.5946967601776123,
-0.1444818526506424,
-0.15521574020385742,
-0.8538016080856323,
0.7694404125213623,
0.37719517946243286,
-0.9070785641670227,
0.04396422952413559,
0.8216572999954224,
0.5199761986732483,
0.27579155564308167,
0.7461468577384949,
-0.23350946605205536,
0.46621862053871155,
-0.01676790975034237,
0.05534891411662102,
0.3153810501098633,
-0.30657345056533813,
0.056358370929956436,
0.030947912484407425,
-0.2702668309211731,
0.1808398962020874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01067v1 | Human-like object concept representations emerge naturally in multimodal large language models | 2024-07-01T08:17:19 | 2024-07-01T08:17:19 | Changde Du, Kaicheng Fu, Bincheng Wen, Yi Sun, Jie Peng, Wei Wei, Ying Gao, Shengpei Wang, Chuncheng Zhang, Jinpeng Li, Shuang Qiu, Le Chang, Huiguang He | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG | The conceptualization and categorization of natural objects in the human mind
have long intrigued cognitive scientists and neuroscientists, offering crucial
insights into human perception and cognition. Recently, the rapid development
of Large Language Models (LLMs) has raised the attractive question of whether
these models can also develop human-like object representations through
exposure to vast amounts of linguistic and multimodal data. In this study, we
combined behavioral and neuroimaging analysis methods to uncover how the object
concept representations in LLMs correlate with those of humans. By collecting
large-scale datasets of 4.7 million triplet judgments from LLM and Multimodal
LLM (MLLM), we were able to derive low-dimensional embeddings that capture the
underlying similarity structure of 1,854 natural objects. The resulting
66-dimensional embeddings were found to be highly stable and predictive, and
exhibited semantic clustering akin to human mental representations.
Interestingly, the interpretability of the dimensions underlying these
embeddings suggests that LLM and MLLM have developed human-like conceptual
representations of natural objects. Further analysis demonstrated strong
alignment between the identified model embeddings and neural activity patterns
in many functionally defined brain ROIs (e.g., EBA, PPA, RSC and FFA). This
provides compelling evidence that the object representations in LLMs, while not
identical to those in the human, share fundamental commonalities that reflect
key schemas of human conceptual knowledge. This study advances our
understanding of machine intelligence and informs the development of more
human-like artificial cognitive systems. | [
-0.6054282784461975,
-0.7473579049110413,
0.6698781847953796,
-0.07941829413175583,
-0.13162541389465332,
0.10968519002199173,
-0.34246450662612915,
-0.712627112865448,
0.14412182569503784,
0.22597020864486694,
-0.2817702293395996,
-0.3831291198730469,
-0.3641746938228607,
0.1282385289669037,
-0.13637225329875946,
0.5649813413619995,
0.33055517077445984,
0.032630376517772675,
-0.4945864975452423,
-0.11897078901529312,
-0.5734776854515076,
-0.8927642107009888,
-0.2319222092628479,
-0.6338196396827698,
0.6182610392570496,
-0.08573123067617416,
0.6604090929031372,
0.5296390652656555,
0.5466643571853638,
0.23369798064231873,
0.07432972639799118,
0.22024326026439667,
-0.14012229442596436,
-0.1813662201166153,
-0.309010773897171,
-0.586566150188446,
-0.34610533714294434,
-0.008277825079858303,
0.6424861550331116,
0.7714337706565857,
-0.276551216840744,
-0.05580589920282364,
0.11643227934837341,
0.4314163029193878,
-0.43967732787132263,
0.5045263767242432,
-0.6492296457290649,
0.15940693020820618,
-0.22374588251113892,
-0.0150942737236619,
-0.3515559732913971,
0.13857688009738922,
0.23446513712406158,
-0.5950555205345154,
0.2164807915687561,
0.30261531472206116,
0.6490358710289001,
0.15392017364501953,
-0.5493889451026917,
-0.2730274796485901,
-0.5130326151847839,
0.7950625419616699,
-0.4040695130825043,
0.46172934770584106,
0.2817598581314087,
0.16693587601184845,
-0.39285820722579956,
-0.1857266128063202,
-0.830627977848053,
-0.40408921241760254,
-0.4265037178993225,
-0.09752816706895828,
0.1281239241361618,
-0.08728162199258804,
0.23739460110664368,
-0.10996819287538528,
-0.4836692810058594,
0.2819971740245819,
-0.20158076286315918,
-0.30608251690864563,
0.754509687423706,
0.33953362703323364,
0.36133718490600586,
-0.5812180042266846,
-0.3982851803302765,
-0.22460703551769257,
-0.6517863273620605,
-0.10335737466812134,
-0.0414465069770813,
0.23779229819774628,
-0.16948671638965607,
0.714770495891571,
0.10449084639549255,
0.8034269213676453,
-0.23076310753822327,
-0.08652523905038834,
0.45181891322135925,
-0.23373085260391235,
-0.0508139543235302,
-0.018314240500330925,
0.9014149904251099,
0.597830057144165,
0.5249288082122803,
-0.10894068330526352,
-0.0639963448047638,
0.41205987334251404,
0.40028342604637146,
-0.4908418357372284,
-0.06327967345714569,
-0.1391446739435196,
-0.5548027753829956,
-0.15642815828323364,
0.3692917227745056,
-0.4929124116897583,
-0.6104382276535034,
-0.46595969796180725,
0.2079474776983261,
-0.40511852502822876,
-0.44263386726379395,
0.2511179447174072,
0.13229019939899445,
0.41821691393852234,
0.17300792038440704,
-0.9888193607330322,
0.26639559864997864,
0.7652618288993835,
0.5492713451385498,
-0.333964467048645,
-0.4457050859928131,
-0.06563136726617813,
0.47683632373809814,
-0.6337095499038696,
0.8608230352401733,
-0.7240882515907288,
-0.2378699779510498,
-0.11407257616519928,
0.10254635661840439,
0.1121353879570961,
-0.680860698223114,
0.18757447600364685,
-0.5364984273910522,
-0.10697802901268005,
-0.2256704568862915,
-0.34738653898239136,
-0.4611158072948456,
0.5242011547088623,
-0.6562729477882385,
0.7691893577575684,
-0.40768659114837646,
-0.5666472911834717,
0.5018589496612549,
-0.8092786073684692,
-0.21901635825634003,
-0.14741449058055878,
-0.7129119038581848,
-0.2408139407634735,
0.4172137677669525,
0.06056240200996399,
1.0053362846374512,
-0.41009652614593506,
0.19968971610069275,
-0.6808364987373352,
-0.0991649255156517,
0.7410653233528137,
-0.07228467613458633,
0.3181855082511902,
-0.1622972935438156,
0.1095896065235138,
-0.04856555536389351,
-0.3625628352165222,
-0.21715345978736877,
0.3245517313480377,
-0.0596260242164135,
-0.5305213332176208,
0.20262496173381805,
-0.2382141351699829,
0.4245333969593048,
0.2993220388889313,
-0.6459956765174866,
0.15153713524341583,
-0.10168378055095673,
0.609105110168457,
0.5782069563865662,
-0.04460030794143677,
0.3626599609851837,
-0.25193971395492554,
0.03690895810723305,
0.47784754633903503,
-0.27963122725486755,
-0.2766830325126648,
-0.5991314053535461,
-0.33343306183815,
-0.10414370894432068,
-0.19617050886154175,
0.1697162389755249,
-0.12465040385723114,
0.3434063792228699,
-0.5013238191604614,
-0.09190203249454498,
-0.29217758774757385,
0.04048183932900429,
0.15119583904743195,
0.09120427817106247,
0.27056625485420227,
-0.27157866954803467,
-0.36000800132751465,
-1.3782819509506226,
0.013547627255320549,
-0.04961935803294182,
-0.3842744529247284,
0.3284932076931,
0.691735565662384,
-0.455168753862381,
1.0689401626586914,
-0.7750268578529358,
-0.4769792854785919,
0.23240330815315247,
0.238302081823349,
0.06660538166761398,
0.5068486332893372,
0.6111395955085754,
-0.7441022992134094,
-0.10234232991933823,
0.30732262134552,
-0.9604171514511108,
0.6040497422218323,
-0.02567749284207821,
-0.22533586621284485,
0.1721232682466507,
0.43427574634552,
-0.6361408233642578,
0.3081302046775818,
0.10552091896533966,
-0.4520738422870636,
0.24590277671813965,
-0.3730621635913849,
-0.09671514481306076,
-1.0549256801605225,
0.03185126185417175,
-0.0530475415289402,
0.021638739854097366,
-0.31076669692993164,
-0.13472606241703033,
0.19587473571300507,
-0.02920665591955185,
-0.2114720344543457,
0.4056711792945862,
-0.5547471642494202,
-0.5515019297599792,
-0.12347161024808884,
0.31836363673210144,
0.0272807739675045,
0.6622858643531799,
0.42429396510124207,
0.45960190892219543,
0.5962228178977966,
-0.641468346118927,
0.11496850848197937,
0.19849549233913422,
-0.27311819791793823,
0.785477876663208,
-0.6432781219482422,
0.3011355698108673,
-0.5779229402542114,
0.2852417230606079,
-0.6872183680534363,
-0.35808730125427246,
0.02700064331293106,
-0.22310002148151398,
0.26881077885627747,
0.2958458364009857,
-0.757982075214386,
-0.2793864905834198,
-0.22452810406684875,
0.3667248487472534,
0.3724949061870575,
-0.17520716786384583,
0.7593246698379517,
0.5805879235267639,
0.1315213441848755,
-0.3018343448638916,
-0.9223371148109436,
0.03505859896540642,
-0.2214728444814682,
-0.5174658298492432,
0.48382556438446045,
-0.02952016517519951,
-0.16019617021083832,
0.1289655864238739,
-0.030679088085889816,
0.04706417769193649,
-0.029098743572831154,
0.2610442042350769,
0.5220077037811279,
-0.1913156360387802,
0.38287830352783203,
-0.44071054458618164,
0.08656501770019531,
0.4048866629600525,
-0.1082230731844902,
0.6775050759315491,
-0.31515786051750183,
-0.6145991683006287,
-0.3815031349658966,
0.19590646028518677,
0.8321576118469238,
-0.2668847441673279,
0.60625159740448,
0.6780992150306702,
-0.6497542858123779,
0.08713400363922119,
-0.4708651006221771,
-0.34967201948165894,
-0.3597612679004669,
0.7762381434440613,
-0.5831056833267212,
-0.7057769894599915,
0.5214006304740906,
0.2518824636936188,
-0.0778210237622261,
0.29166051745414734,
0.5502253174781799,
-0.3625550866127014,
1.025667428970337,
0.2749207019805908,
-0.0015229379059746861,
0.41269755363464355,
-0.45934000611305237,
-0.193015456199646,
-1.2903456687927246,
-0.7770482897758484,
-0.17303624749183655,
-0.36903220415115356,
-0.5632804036140442,
-0.8983893394470215,
0.09591611474752426,
-0.046473823487758636,
-0.4245193302631378,
0.025399066507816315,
-0.3972299098968506,
0.5151469707489014,
0.09452719241380692,
0.2185870110988617,
0.17933735251426697,
0.1514836996793747,
-0.22111839056015015,
0.04752955958247185,
-0.34125182032585144,
-0.6089941263198853,
1.3694977760314941,
0.312457412481308,
0.4921537935733795,
0.054933398962020874,
0.5647890567779541,
0.4247696101665497,
0.30932164192199707,
-0.7671772241592407,
0.6265742182731628,
-0.2755514085292816,
-0.6809338331222534,
-0.07842446118593216,
-0.1723422110080719,
-0.9338133335113525,
0.5200208425521851,
-0.4944283962249756,
-0.9224393367767334,
0.28424906730651855,
-0.09330042451620102,
-0.3781999349594116,
0.20489805936813354,
-0.5587046146392822,
0.7868521213531494,
-0.3117089569568634,
-0.20807147026062012,
-0.731585681438446,
-0.41887080669403076,
0.3815668821334839,
-0.2564321458339691,
0.2578369677066803,
-0.390067994594574,
-0.4416918456554413,
0.7904248833656311,
0.24484296143054962,
0.9683512449264526,
0.02332061156630516,
-0.35413166880607605,
0.27324140071868896,
0.10677871108055115,
0.29472479224205017,
0.08413016051054001,
-0.010263088159263134,
0.33717554807662964,
-0.19446714222431183,
-0.5509456396102905,
-0.7984142303466797,
0.6968609094619751,
-0.9513883590698242,
-0.514459490776062,
-0.4150942862033844,
-0.5782548785209656,
-0.1517987996339798,
0.09568410366773605,
-0.2949485778808594,
0.40347006916999817,
-0.41793307662010193,
0.3991919159889221,
0.5035321712493896,
-0.05726785212755203,
0.34301403164863586,
0.2844349443912506,
-0.5587467551231384,
-0.10912330448627472,
0.9680894613265991,
-0.0063878498040139675,
0.12456290423870087,
0.5145493745803833,
0.08136104047298431,
-0.3244967460632324,
-0.3826613128185272,
-0.1749163568019867,
0.4836384654045105,
-0.5012878179550171,
-0.09241759777069092,
-0.5271981358528137,
0.06795978546142578,
0.14057809114456177,
0.06938828527927399,
-0.26625511050224304,
0.03398201987147331,
-0.34486836194992065,
-0.10563424974679947,
0.3203388750553131,
1.1762231588363647,
0.1538088172674179,
0.040579985827207565,
-0.7172727584838867,
0.5032772421836853,
0.5336713194847107,
0.3664798140525818,
0.3774314820766449,
-0.14132291078567505,
-0.23913952708244324,
0.5185462832450867,
-0.1338140070438385,
-0.6102169156074524,
0.061624377965927124,
0.34178823232650757,
0.7834728956222534,
0.7471261620521545,
-0.3012470006942749,
0.6647775769233704,
-0.356197327375412,
0.6497339010238647,
0.37379181385040283,
-0.5632712841033936,
0.04673456773161888,
-0.4302417039871216,
0.1844618171453476,
-0.0029618775006383657,
0.19660140573978424,
-0.6711384057998657,
0.11018358170986176,
-0.3016986846923828,
-0.267730712890625,
0.8733039498329163,
0.09352748841047287,
0.34065020084381104,
-0.40083783864974976,
0.09690452367067337,
0.03736328333616257,
0.05671202763915062,
-0.5542310476303101,
-0.037972863763570786,
-0.3262755274772644,
-0.023278534412384033,
-0.1909770965576172,
-0.05955057218670845,
-0.00594285037368536,
-0.07701333612203598,
-0.01698821410536766,
-0.22871918976306915,
0.6624325513839722,
-0.18130306899547577,
-0.13587182760238647,
0.20622357726097107,
0.12621541321277618,
0.648852527141571,
0.29988136887550354,
-0.2581547796726227,
0.3842862546443939,
0.19696345925331116,
-0.4037950932979584,
0.15610060095787048,
-0.3043179214000702,
0.3473242223262787,
-0.3623330295085907,
0.4456327259540558,
0.5913262367248535,
0.4743068218231201,
-0.8014159202575684,
0.21194443106651306,
0.030508363619446754,
0.1194646880030632,
-0.44599491357803345,
0.04162099212408066,
0.6518543362617493,
0.26730120182037354,
0.43346697092056274,
0.21610118448734283,
-0.11516363173723221,
-0.8848555088043213,
0.08691217005252838,
0.6013746857643127,
-0.16336752474308014,
-0.7571570873260498,
0.2139727771282196,
0.09791705757379532,
-0.25278690457344055,
0.7275014519691467,
-0.26224738359451294,
-0.3790283501148224,
0.6197282075881958,
0.5208956003189087,
0.8046976327896118,
0.19687479734420776,
0.12791740894317627,
0.34848636388778687,
0.06104234233498573,
-0.11165931820869446,
0.10688840597867966,
0.012662976048886776,
-1.2179673910140991,
-0.26241153478622437,
-0.6908844709396362,
0.17226918041706085,
-0.09617815911769867,
-0.5985790491104126,
0.11516822129487991,
-0.4604736268520355,
-0.2811470925807953,
-0.0213819220662117,
-0.2203260213136673,
-1.0547735691070557,
-0.02887190878391266,
0.7334997653961182,
0.39048171043395996,
-0.7284626364707947,
0.9804200530052185,
1.1019574403762817,
-0.4071318507194519,
-0.6216570138931274,
0.0642213225364685,
-0.09576737135648727,
-0.8150326013565063,
1.0462489128112793,
0.40796762704849243,
-0.16957077383995056,
-0.09192781895399094,
-0.23393909633159637,
-1.0998008251190186,
1.2887440919876099,
0.21589519083499908,
-0.5240810513496399,
-0.28966963291168213,
0.37329375743865967,
0.6154069304466248,
-0.8515967130661011,
0.1071348786354065,
0.5809192061424255,
0.42924225330352783,
-0.03798747807741165,
-0.6881805062294006,
0.1709943264722824,
-0.15643435716629028,
0.35098984837532043,
0.26844677329063416,
-0.492705762386322,
0.8676520586013794,
-0.2574775815010071,
-0.3051452934741974,
-0.27123361825942993,
0.5655231475830078,
0.4343341290950775,
-0.010545042343437672,
0.35975906252861023,
0.6049457788467407,
0.681786060333252,
0.11789251118898392,
0.8866974115371704,
-0.12405723333358765,
0.1785956621170044,
0.9917832612991333,
-0.20207655429840088,
0.9595916867256165,
0.5813523530960083,
-0.3966221511363983,
0.7017586827278137,
0.4032527208328247,
-0.049815546721220016,
0.2886538505554199,
0.2862725555896759,
0.05986115336418152,
-0.43092915415763855,
-0.33777856826782227,
-0.24075275659561157,
0.7300280332565308,
0.7499779462814331,
-0.2151058316230774,
-0.08133906126022339,
0.1600029170513153,
-0.2617458999156952,
-0.02900351956486702,
-0.2890194058418274,
0.8769034743309021,
0.16618181765079498,
-0.4186614155769348,
0.5863878130912781,
-0.3066955804824829,
1.0229874849319458,
-0.42390069365501404,
-0.172613725066185,
0.08060628920793533,
0.026915550231933594,
-0.13473135232925415,
-0.8809823393821716,
0.26724618673324585,
-0.32919609546661377,
-0.1711902767419815,
-0.0004856238083448261,
0.40365251898765564,
-0.2834906578063965,
-0.4004017412662506,
0.5177021026611328,
0.39873647689819336,
0.2123519331216812,
-0.02865535020828247,
-0.6517118811607361,
0.12369441986083984,
-0.09226974099874496,
-0.18606257438659668,
0.4177071154117584,
0.4592500627040863,
-0.4695672392845154,
0.7838965654373169,
0.7095218896865845,
-0.01864839345216751,
0.08560632169246674,
-0.12240923941135406,
0.7252799272537231,
-0.9398030042648315,
-0.1649337261915207,
-0.9803721308708191,
0.4774121046066284,
-0.12874101102352142,
0.014127406291663647,
0.30897098779678345,
0.3167281448841095,
0.9060579538345337,
-0.3238968849182129,
0.46776753664016724,
-0.1543114185333252,
0.07547374814748764,
-0.3286496698856354,
0.6016343235969543,
-0.5275766253471375,
0.13477864861488342,
-0.3237825036048889,
-0.9898149967193604,
-0.2514406740665436,
0.7581002116203308,
-0.3773937523365021,
-0.07143865525722504,
0.6602612733840942,
0.7027140259742737,
-0.21876946091651917,
-0.17925694584846497,
0.4171885848045349,
0.1452968716621399,
0.2888234853744507,
0.430526465177536,
0.9531903862953186,
0.08063114434480667,
0.34404805302619934,
-0.15255087614059448,
0.23202115297317505,
-0.37126487493515015,
-0.7405755519866943,
-0.9577170014381409,
-0.6462565064430237,
-0.14972737431526184,
0.26748695969581604,
-0.41777610778808594,
1.2430576086044312,
0.7882763743400574,
-0.6263436079025269,
-0.4178565740585327,
-0.032270852476358414,
-0.07640000432729721,
-0.00927895586937666,
-0.21460598707199097,
0.546737015247345,
-0.10695266723632812,
-0.6347352862358093,
0.08309146016836166,
0.2634124457836151,
0.2250886708498001,
-0.7130805253982544,
-0.21085578203201294,
-0.27030149102211,
-0.07814113050699234,
0.8671262860298157,
-0.14694876968860626,
-1.0333528518676758,
-0.5144877433776855,
0.09999147802591324,
-0.2133440226316452,
0.11969040334224701,
0.7892394661903381,
-1.0441433191299438,
0.3820706307888031,
0.36249840259552,
0.4231947660446167,
0.3502570688724518,
-0.26223888993263245,
0.659752607345581,
-0.5469557046890259,
0.45119088888168335,
0.2563140392303467,
0.5692911148071289,
0.4942329525947571,
-0.11171945184469223,
0.23073232173919678,
0.0007678690599277616,
-0.05513967201113701,
-0.6882577538490295,
0.5106143951416016,
-0.9006986021995544,
-0.3866080343723297,
0.6879813075065613,
-0.026752827689051628,
-0.38572871685028076,
-0.06389123946428299,
-0.24195168912410736,
0.10582801699638367,
-0.5962840914726257,
0.986181914806366,
0.6865593791007996,
-0.36484187841415405,
-0.10820905864238739,
-0.4032648205757141,
0.18441885709762573,
0.1165769100189209,
-0.6990965604782104,
0.14369511604309082,
0.47180017828941345,
0.24222706258296967,
0.6516640186309814,
0.03711305558681488,
-0.15211431682109833,
0.07222478091716766,
-0.20173732936382294,
0.2461470514535904,
-0.2229888141155243,
-0.1812572032213211,
0.0048235030844807625,
0.24025243520736694,
0.013151059858500957,
-0.343096524477005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01047v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01047v1 | Development of Cognitive Intelligence in Pre-trained Language Models | 2024-07-01T07:56:36 | 2024-07-01T07:56:36 | Raj Sanjay Shah, Khushi Bhardwaj, Sashank Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies show evidence for emergent cognitive abilities in Large
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs). The increasing cognitive alignment of these
models has made them candidates for cognitive science theories. Prior research
into the emergent cognitive abilities of PLMs has largely been path-independent
to model training, i.e., has focused on the final model weights and not the
intermediate steps. However, building plausible models of human cognition using
PLMs would benefit from considering the developmental alignment of their
performance during training to the trajectories of children's thinking. Guided
by psychometric tests of human intelligence, we choose four sets of tasks to
investigate the alignment of ten popular families of PLMs and evaluate their
available intermediate and final training steps. These tasks are Numerical
ability, Linguistic abilities, Conceptual understanding, and Fluid reasoning.
We find a striking regularity: regardless of model size, the developmental
trajectories of PLMs consistently exhibit a window of maximal alignment to
human cognitive development. Before that window, training appears to endow
"blank slate" models with the requisite structure to be poised to rapidly learn
from experience. After that window, training appears to serve the engineering
goal of reducing loss but not the scientific goal of increasing alignment with
human cognition. | [
-0.5482969284057617,
-0.45022088289260864,
0.7505953311920166,
0.006033020559698343,
-0.029637351632118225,
0.24688303470611572,
-0.4308999180793762,
-0.2583288252353668,
-0.12618255615234375,
0.4391896426677704,
-0.7527730464935303,
-0.11665940284729004,
-0.5450071096420288,
-0.3276378810405731,
-0.23111726343631744,
0.9879759550094604,
0.11998649686574936,
-0.07435193657875061,
-0.36952102184295654,
0.20492392778396606,
-0.4629834294319153,
-0.4545077085494995,
-0.5595860481262207,
-0.3013380765914917,
0.3656526207923889,
0.4117065668106079,
0.7850816249847412,
0.8104091286659241,
0.46768197417259216,
0.2708888351917267,
0.16745057702064514,
-0.09240273386240005,
-0.378366619348526,
-0.084266796708107,
-0.15559040009975433,
-0.5366588830947876,
-0.49048641324043274,
0.5279708504676819,
0.5714839100837708,
1.1557470560073853,
-0.074266217648983,
0.08332560956478119,
0.21695826947689056,
0.8166888952255249,
-0.486785352230072,
0.02233949676156044,
-0.6198014616966248,
-0.07547164708375931,
-0.3144713044166565,
-0.033678121864795685,
-0.42723575234413147,
-0.12438289076089859,
0.5544338226318359,
-0.764906644821167,
0.23811087012290955,
0.053423814475536346,
0.7501775026321411,
0.16027669608592987,
-0.330203652381897,
-0.2519403398036957,
-0.8144376873970032,
0.8838508129119873,
-0.38711780309677124,
0.4669552147388458,
0.4128115773200989,
0.01573723554611206,
-0.2921184003353119,
-0.6043522357940674,
-0.5184216499328613,
-0.3774207532405853,
0.07192002981901169,
0.21746009588241577,
0.4355637729167938,
0.11912520229816437,
0.4938904941082001,
0.017098113894462585,
-0.6744825839996338,
0.10515659302473068,
-0.4503439664840698,
-0.023420432582497597,
0.7429034113883972,
0.30989372730255127,
0.370817631483078,
0.42385736107826233,
-0.22572731971740723,
-0.17474137246608734,
-0.49964016675949097,
0.36465537548065186,
0.3939504325389862,
0.19300682842731476,
-0.1473722755908966,
0.5321010947227478,
-0.19627614319324493,
0.6585384011268616,
0.05019106715917587,
-0.0524897575378418,
0.15816491842269897,
-0.438910573720932,
0.18680356442928314,
0.05193494260311127,
0.5643583536148071,
-0.02766742929816246,
0.7330741882324219,
-0.11591058224439621,
-0.15324509143829346,
0.4291033446788788,
0.5907998085021973,
-0.38982442021369934,
-0.3892580568790436,
0.0139163201674819,
-0.3280591666698456,
-0.17027737200260162,
0.021075241267681122,
-0.32689428329467773,
-0.22413913905620575,
-0.4408142864704132,
0.21716415882110596,
-0.6112617254257202,
-0.32372987270355225,
0.1621020883321762,
0.031171446666121483,
0.32277408242225647,
0.14013546705245972,
-1.0324318408966064,
0.27216243743896484,
0.8262790441513062,
0.3729645907878876,
-0.2299729734659195,
-0.5522276163101196,
0.037245020270347595,
0.14768606424331665,
-0.6276748776435852,
0.8584097623825073,
-0.6299494504928589,
-0.10971512645483017,
-0.1157630980014801,
-0.21074561774730682,
-0.3719957768917084,
-0.2934547960758209,
0.42554572224617004,
-0.4988967180252075,
0.2505737841129303,
-0.27551332116127014,
-0.6023591756820679,
-0.1817082017660141,
-0.0037961010821163654,
-0.35133641958236694,
0.6911552548408508,
0.05341559648513794,
-0.615186870098114,
0.5488321185112,
-0.7927179932594299,
-0.5788664817810059,
0.20096662640571594,
-0.2994166612625122,
-0.17861327528953552,
0.25339487195014954,
0.03674173355102539,
0.16874775290489197,
-0.30584007501602173,
0.2958258390426636,
-0.3125292658805847,
-0.33836954832077026,
0.4091394543647766,
-0.3059490919113159,
1.0680975914001465,
0.06982319056987762,
-0.3655049502849579,
-0.053769636899232864,
-0.6271237134933472,
0.28596067428588867,
0.0967973992228508,
-0.3245702385902405,
-0.2817355692386627,
0.2986454665660858,
-0.621863067150116,
0.5111532807350159,
0.336990088224411,
-0.3396458625793457,
0.0019034341676160693,
-0.5603936314582825,
0.4357660412788391,
0.48652100563049316,
-0.04239668324589729,
0.6936582922935486,
-0.5721411108970642,
0.38565129041671753,
0.01744130812585354,
0.40133434534072876,
-0.13211554288864136,
-0.6415035724639893,
-0.7772228717803955,
-0.15625299513339996,
0.08678748458623886,
0.49922603368759155,
-0.3700701594352722,
0.6897823214530945,
-0.3555643558502197,
-0.4925456941127777,
-0.5651094913482666,
0.359566867351532,
0.45462992787361145,
0.38265079259872437,
0.014926967211067677,
-0.6039088368415833,
-0.47631967067718506,
-0.7525495886802673,
-0.2807665765285492,
-0.13268563151359558,
-0.010122681967914104,
-0.11808629333972931,
0.5280499458312988,
0.15289533138275146,
0.8788843750953674,
-0.35491427779197693,
0.12730766832828522,
-0.0005710424156859517,
0.1660885512828827,
0.03392818197607994,
0.6517482399940491,
0.3326013684272766,
-0.6869298219680786,
-0.21375541388988495,
-0.1501264125108719,
-0.7194335460662842,
0.11753389984369278,
0.012562165968120098,
-0.29154908657073975,
-0.1219513788819313,
0.4285333454608917,
-0.7706735730171204,
0.4443199932575226,
0.23094433546066284,
-0.2699710726737976,
0.3672393262386322,
-0.21167626976966858,
-0.1808561384677887,
-0.53910231590271,
0.03024890646338463,
-0.33378148078918457,
0.2811906039714813,
-0.880670964717865,
-0.3493988513946533,
0.0031906594522297382,
-0.04878808557987213,
-0.25159886479377747,
0.3348320424556732,
-0.6237834095954895,
-0.35259106755256653,
-0.25185123085975647,
0.29924118518829346,
-0.06865038722753525,
0.5475068092346191,
0.22283615171909332,
0.5405623912811279,
0.42483726143836975,
-0.730902910232544,
-0.13655948638916016,
-0.11995360255241394,
-0.4150181710720062,
0.4129156470298767,
-0.3590725362300873,
0.2980290651321411,
-0.0959877297282219,
-0.11766327917575836,
-0.9246568083763123,
-0.046285636723041534,
-0.04977305978536606,
-0.5146117210388184,
0.2902856767177582,
0.2846029996871948,
-0.2117116004228592,
-0.5789123773574829,
-0.13442815840244293,
0.4021785855293274,
0.6927648782730103,
-0.0353252999484539,
0.6843200325965881,
0.4518636167049408,
-0.22847041487693787,
-0.34338417649269104,
-0.39182281494140625,
-0.3537850081920624,
-0.14785823225975037,
-0.7489725351333618,
0.38389381766319275,
-0.284193217754364,
-0.26747041940689087,
-0.0848923772573471,
-0.14611566066741943,
-0.13635636866092682,
0.31498685479164124,
0.1358739733695984,
0.4038539528846741,
-0.38476523756980896,
-0.02008943259716034,
-0.27868470549583435,
-0.22852884232997894,
0.1798250824213028,
-0.5078141689300537,
0.47478094696998596,
-0.16143681108951569,
-0.2213745415210724,
-0.26911240816116333,
-0.05549941211938858,
0.6181567907333374,
-0.5865294933319092,
0.7025187611579895,
0.31522199511528015,
-0.35415664315223694,
-0.0023475028574466705,
-0.5908436179161072,
-0.12488102167844772,
-0.41306009888648987,
0.3750840127468109,
-0.2729979455471039,
-0.5886898636817932,
0.45621633529663086,
0.0018025642493739724,
0.20026428997516632,
0.2603582739830017,
0.4345022141933441,
-0.5806300044059753,
1.319655418395996,
0.6211327314376831,
0.4297346770763397,
0.6404632329940796,
-0.27411580085754395,
0.12176686525344849,
-0.9755476713180542,
-0.30601808428764343,
-0.2052052766084671,
-0.28948551416397095,
-0.28222358226776123,
-0.14935500919818878,
0.06637132912874222,
0.19256828725337982,
-0.6277709007263184,
0.03148871287703514,
-0.3997958302497864,
0.49306827783584595,
0.595861554145813,
-0.08962824195623398,
0.11919809132814407,
-0.21785826981067657,
-0.26904064416885376,
-0.06906750053167343,
-0.7657980918884277,
-0.5679106712341309,
1.200697660446167,
0.1625858098268509,
0.4127882421016693,
-0.16470864415168762,
0.40420517325401306,
-0.1441766917705536,
0.5497650504112244,
-0.4426591694355011,
0.6906482577323914,
-0.14832141995429993,
-0.8011720776557922,
-0.3495124578475952,
-0.15116764605045319,
-1.0419992208480835,
0.0637107565999031,
-0.5165712833404541,
-0.6479482054710388,
0.07234671711921692,
0.013970098458230495,
-0.5908706188201904,
-0.013159450143575668,
-0.8123896718025208,
0.8139995336532593,
-0.7307575941085815,
-0.1469600945711136,
-0.2975492775440216,
-0.8294886946678162,
0.5150444507598877,
-0.2719520330429077,
0.15992599725723267,
-0.24443399906158447,
-0.19220201671123505,
0.9498156905174255,
-0.25659963488578796,
0.6511859893798828,
-0.24360892176628113,
0.11862973868846893,
0.4806666672229767,
-0.05030053108930588,
-0.02915949560701847,
-0.18795834481716156,
0.3324548304080963,
-0.14181679487228394,
-0.13738712668418884,
-0.6383539438247681,
-0.654515266418457,
0.4134957194328308,
-0.8322806358337402,
-0.8746297955513,
-0.48730045557022095,
-0.9125449657440186,
-0.4753277599811554,
0.3214293122291565,
0.19870303571224213,
0.1466459333896637,
-0.14877180755138397,
0.16064487397670746,
0.8046895861625671,
0.14431725442409515,
0.5436834096908569,
0.6381075382232666,
-0.15745306015014648,
-0.27251699566841125,
0.6817367076873779,
0.3603179454803467,
0.40968289971351624,
0.10813640058040619,
0.011998536996543407,
-0.1328791081905365,
-0.7875921726226807,
0.04457603022456169,
0.2407052218914032,
-0.30122366547584534,
0.17681193351745605,
-0.16877076029777527,
-0.47603046894073486,
-0.3026455044746399,
-0.30584943294525146,
-0.42713335156440735,
-0.2271745353937149,
0.07451905310153961,
0.008052729070186615,
-0.0682462826371193,
0.9442209005355835,
0.20220203697681427,
0.347603440284729,
-0.6624941229820251,
0.01797531731426716,
0.41204559803009033,
0.2061350792646408,
0.12001442909240723,
-0.4454464614391327,
-0.40558430552482605,
0.3273795545101166,
-0.4453422725200653,
-0.593471348285675,
-0.044756099581718445,
0.202799454331398,
0.6496649384498596,
0.7609670162200928,
-0.16193392872810364,
0.6378237009048462,
-0.36948004364967346,
0.6860750913619995,
0.1870705485343933,
-0.6783517003059387,
0.4738215506076813,
-0.3200649917125702,
0.322457492351532,
0.5394128561019897,
0.4196583330631256,
0.0029561216942965984,
-0.2344536930322647,
-0.856663703918457,
-0.4122408330440521,
0.810597836971283,
0.16059376299381256,
-0.02390110306441784,
0.04498697444796562,
0.39782461524009705,
-0.018968122079968452,
0.16041655838489532,
-0.41492795944213867,
0.18731257319450378,
-0.11932604759931564,
-0.4164166748523712,
-0.1329757124185562,
0.11527149379253387,
-0.20044493675231934,
-0.45107364654541016,
0.5651714205741882,
-0.03453315049409866,
0.017299797385931015,
-0.04739055410027504,
-0.14936986565589905,
0.029981279745697975,
-0.021970216184854507,
0.6643258333206177,
0.6875062584877014,
-0.002079212572425604,
0.07150223851203918,
0.01986663229763508,
-0.6828001737594604,
0.30647164583206177,
-0.06259375065565109,
-0.10275363177061081,
-0.7629711627960205,
0.5147919654846191,
0.6226669549942017,
0.33445730805397034,
-0.7391116619110107,
0.5483171939849854,
-0.07951714843511581,
-0.15613161027431488,
-0.5330818295478821,
0.46504712104797363,
0.35169553756713867,
0.3360227942466736,
0.25771284103393555,
0.18830174207687378,
-0.4725296199321747,
-0.6469117403030396,
0.05532176047563553,
0.4559108316898346,
-0.33055830001831055,
-0.586347758769989,
0.47892478108406067,
0.07571834325790405,
-0.4377458691596985,
1.1188092231750488,
-0.2179267257452011,
-0.39507099986076355,
0.5273078083992004,
0.4302276372909546,
0.7804777026176453,
-0.3080265522003174,
-0.06497902423143387,
-0.04548414796590805,
0.5878665447235107,
-0.10524821281433105,
0.31599485874176025,
-0.026291029527783394,
-1.1220074892044067,
-0.4099093973636627,
-0.4515456259250641,
0.1652250736951828,
0.04404115304350853,
-0.5339148640632629,
0.1987045854330063,
-0.5315075516700745,
-0.4840737581253052,
-0.09472706913948059,
0.18433599174022675,
-0.9617595672607422,
0.4327973425388336,
0.3745317757129669,
0.7950489521026611,
-0.9146091938018799,
0.8879258036613464,
0.7247152328491211,
-0.6002946496009827,
-0.8028879761695862,
-0.03683468699455261,
-0.28563445806503296,
-0.7285691499710083,
0.6247252225875854,
0.08466214686632156,
0.04549858719110489,
0.2057081013917923,
-0.4351222515106201,
-1.0958421230316162,
1.1791541576385498,
0.4619436264038086,
-0.3239400088787079,
-0.4864918291568756,
0.007218040060251951,
0.5604952573776245,
-0.8923917412757874,
0.27007856965065,
0.7099508047103882,
0.3283935487270355,
-0.11437120288610458,
-0.6724016666412354,
-0.21721720695495605,
-0.15732139348983765,
0.14256855845451355,
0.22657006978988647,
-0.5782298445701599,
0.8646841645240784,
-0.43811288475990295,
-0.24442429840564728,
0.04788541793823242,
0.7957425117492676,
0.289340078830719,
0.23809027671813965,
0.5368632078170776,
0.7035803198814392,
0.8256500363349915,
-0.10661327093839645,
0.8246892690658569,
-0.48529142141342163,
-0.22544993460178375,
0.9967067837715149,
-0.3454208970069885,
0.7791970372200012,
0.3779994249343872,
-0.17803892493247986,
0.6670510172843933,
0.5492591261863708,
0.23856529593467712,
0.5898807644844055,
0.14130361378192902,
-0.00790558010339737,
-0.33558687567710876,
0.04882786050438881,
-0.007010286208242178,
0.42649951577186584,
0.7335044145584106,
-0.15414729714393616,
0.2352519929409027,
0.11053209006786346,
-0.08720541000366211,
0.1797058880329132,
-0.4317013621330261,
0.5779561996459961,
0.1789681762456894,
-1.0039974451065063,
0.39880871772766113,
-0.41582152247428894,
0.47819817066192627,
-0.7562570571899414,
0.250823438167572,
0.0845637172460556,
-0.005131343845278025,
-0.10882116854190826,
-0.8415756821632385,
0.09027307480573654,
-0.20166057348251343,
-0.27931901812553406,
-0.08869405835866928,
0.6148668527603149,
-0.34212633967399597,
-0.1513763666152954,
0.27689051628112793,
0.7231011390686035,
0.20925359427928925,
0.1980406492948532,
-0.6601527333259583,
-0.15810665488243103,
-0.11082535982131958,
-0.3262259066104889,
0.39125141501426697,
0.37639176845550537,
-0.3250161111354828,
0.5822786092758179,
0.807709276676178,
0.24248956143856049,
0.39667701721191406,
-0.08052989840507507,
0.5163877010345459,
-0.6742699146270752,
-0.42781689763069153,
-0.7537984848022461,
0.5583615899085999,
-0.07714439928531647,
-0.5247210264205933,
0.3955058157444,
0.389605849981308,
0.8546349406242371,
0.001696414197795093,
0.7339372038841248,
0.16173262894153595,
0.2261931151151657,
-0.4306117296218872,
0.5424612164497375,
-0.1323757916688919,
0.10127971321344376,
-0.0008990755304694176,
-1.0506092309951782,
-0.08772427588701248,
0.5860618352890015,
-0.6664174199104309,
0.4509543776512146,
1.0508882999420166,
0.4748987853527069,
0.09200873225927353,
0.25232750177383423,
0.19240456819534302,
0.215775728225708,
-0.03830734267830849,
0.7475920915603638,
1.013896107673645,
0.01782030053436756,
0.3788464665412903,
-0.2813872992992401,
-0.4380378723144531,
0.16813082993030548,
-0.6259956955909729,
-0.9080384373664856,
-0.6094275116920471,
-0.21744117140769958,
0.0832955464720726,
0.027936749160289764,
0.7930178046226501,
0.7883445024490356,
-0.5764875411987305,
-0.3652229905128479,
-0.29406529664993286,
-0.18833334743976593,
-0.3440735340118408,
-0.21639099717140198,
0.15015748143196106,
-0.5678133368492126,
-0.44911935925483704,
0.4157634377479553,
0.2653340995311737,
0.13272297382354736,
-0.32258397340774536,
-0.1852358877658844,
-0.34228262305259705,
0.23872010409832,
0.2484699785709381,
0.3921612799167633,
-0.6316028833389282,
-0.43319588899612427,
0.06874921172857285,
-0.17630884051322937,
0.015355871990323067,
0.9234485626220703,
-0.7105538845062256,
0.3054598867893219,
0.4537560045719147,
0.5478544235229492,
0.2434464395046234,
-0.06798909604549408,
0.6698548197746277,
-0.4334631860256195,
0.24440431594848633,
0.36251261830329895,
0.3471662700176239,
0.23872728645801544,
-0.10560649633407593,
0.42970117926597595,
0.30236324667930603,
-0.6337718367576599,
-0.7058938145637512,
0.2767956256866455,
-0.5908437967300415,
-0.11527001857757568,
0.3865780532360077,
-0.10990738868713379,
-0.3580664396286011,
-0.25061941146850586,
0.055033937096595764,
0.3877750635147095,
-0.09121200442314148,
0.7147572040557861,
1.0013717412948608,
-0.588827908039093,
0.13100376725196838,
-0.6629250645637512,
0.583060622215271,
0.6467497944831848,
-0.5822853446006775,
-0.055347949266433716,
0.028402982279658318,
0.1616310030221939,
0.4821060597896576,
0.7609451413154602,
-0.13825641572475433,
0.29023095965385437,
0.07952090352773666,
0.20235514640808105,
0.17702610790729523,
-0.5651116967201233,
-0.11954119801521301,
-0.015024078078567982,
0.37811240553855896,
0.03846914321184158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01046v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01046v2 | FRoG: Evaluating Fuzzy Reasoning of Generalized Quantifiers in Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T07:56:14 | 2024-07-03T03:37:53 | Yiyuan Li, Shichao Sun, Pengfei Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Fuzzy reasoning is vital due to the frequent use of imprecise information in
daily contexts. However, the ability of current large language models (LLMs) to
handle such reasoning remains largely uncharted. In this paper, we introduce a
new benchmark, FRoG, for fuzzy reasoning, featuring real-world mathematical
word problems that incorporate generalized quantifiers. Our experimental
findings reveal that fuzzy reasoning continues to pose significant challenges
for LLMs. Moreover, we find that existing methods designed to enhance reasoning
do not consistently improve performance in tasks involving fuzzy logic.
Additionally, our results show an inverse scaling effect in the performance of
LLMs on FRoG. Interestingly, we also demonstrate that strong mathematical
reasoning skills are not necessarily indicative of success on our benchmark. | [
-0.2837463319301605,
-0.963361382484436,
0.8319373726844788,
0.08222795277833939,
-0.47302693128585815,
-0.022236578166484833,
-0.4085460305213928,
-0.4266788065433502,
-0.15769807994365692,
0.33822059631347656,
-0.32516026496887207,
-0.2951233983039856,
-0.6102999448776245,
0.3587879240512848,
-0.5138252377510071,
0.5878932476043701,
0.02405433915555477,
0.08890320360660553,
-0.3303997814655304,
-0.2765606641769409,
-0.27521267533302307,
-0.6874547004699707,
-0.5836182236671448,
-0.38110458850860596,
0.32079142332077026,
0.40100038051605225,
1.0431383848190308,
0.2688772678375244,
0.662582278251648,
0.4611652195453644,
-0.12665775418281555,
-0.02858162857592106,
-0.38667356967926025,
0.2783019244670868,
-0.25802522897720337,
-0.3972351849079132,
-0.24137456715106964,
-0.23274445533752441,
1.0086780786514282,
0.642382800579071,
-0.39768868684768677,
0.11602921038866043,
-0.32844531536102295,
0.5949481129646301,
-0.6466482281684875,
0.05704096332192421,
-0.7972108721733093,
-0.047675736248493195,
0.025257684290409088,
0.4917708933353424,
-0.059007350355386734,
-0.5756041407585144,
0.08218991756439209,
-0.5819182991981506,
-0.06926815956830978,
0.05162544921040535,
0.8909901976585388,
0.07294076681137085,
-0.4955477714538574,
-0.15018945932388306,
-0.643410325050354,
0.8880900740623474,
-0.7604273557662964,
0.630604088306427,
0.2566835880279541,
0.41810426115989685,
-0.03705737367272377,
-0.6403811573982239,
-0.8201491832733154,
-0.27917712926864624,
0.02582761086523533,
-0.3391402065753937,
-0.4394010603427887,
-0.019700637087225914,
0.5434809327125549,
0.4347829818725586,
-0.44197598099708557,
-0.2912234365940094,
-0.02422727830708027,
-0.1030336320400238,
0.7053070068359375,
0.18412211537361145,
0.14540977776050568,
-0.015990136191248894,
-0.17925380170345306,
-0.2517828643321991,
-0.4803159236907959,
-0.015139901079237461,
0.39331284165382385,
-0.15128199756145477,
0.2284461259841919,
0.6079416871070862,
-0.3743898272514343,
0.7510769367218018,
-0.14653882384300232,
0.011012090370059013,
0.09487902373075485,
-0.16053402423858643,
-0.23467601835727692,
-0.37850436568260193,
0.5973770022392273,
0.19842152297496796,
0.7320923209190369,
0.058593813329935074,
-0.5506847500801086,
-0.15929587185382843,
0.047031860798597336,
-0.6615272164344788,
-0.3396161198616028,
0.1860622614622116,
-0.15918844938278198,
0.09329422563314438,
-0.14051155745983124,
-0.8407641649246216,
-0.3448330760002136,
-0.11471899598836899,
0.9826480746269226,
-0.6311330795288086,
-0.24520708620548248,
0.362142950296402,
-0.3854648768901825,
0.43658432364463806,
0.37544047832489014,
-0.7928095459938049,
0.5037531852722168,
1.1468300819396973,
0.6521981954574585,
0.3646624982357025,
-0.18527647852897644,
-0.7197808027267456,
-0.09944411367177963,
-0.5273000001907349,
0.9511674642562866,
-1.0142052173614502,
-0.44376611709594727,
-0.035892974585294724,
-0.254377543926239,
-0.11899775266647339,
-0.7881560921669006,
0.7012324929237366,
-0.3299223482608795,
0.19264818727970123,
-0.3067881166934967,
-0.5106842517852783,
-0.2617717981338501,
0.30574384331703186,
-0.4217352867126465,
0.8185700178146362,
0.424896776676178,
-0.3236749768257141,
0.2872050106525421,
-0.3504642844200134,
-0.3452787697315216,
0.14835654199123383,
-0.02289694733917713,
-0.40459468960762024,
0.4200952649116516,
0.0875837653875351,
0.2052147090435028,
-0.5407739877700806,
0.5822544693946838,
-0.5850319862365723,
-0.6344169974327087,
0.5167723894119263,
-0.24577051401138306,
0.4646557569503784,
0.045953743159770966,
-0.2325836569070816,
-0.046158209443092346,
-0.8561422824859619,
0.5221670866012573,
0.25334861874580383,
-0.09029322862625122,
-0.3022376596927643,
0.3234606087207794,
-0.31711146235466003,
0.015768246725201607,
0.017251016572117805,
-0.44011759757995605,
0.30635014176368713,
-0.23141448199748993,
0.7734957337379456,
0.8181056380271912,
-0.18760892748832703,
0.14794950187206268,
-0.260196715593338,
0.3199514150619507,
-0.23286384344100952,
0.10999829322099686,
0.1960146129131317,
-0.5267186760902405,
-0.9656156301498413,
-0.2530030608177185,
0.6745187640190125,
0.4964335560798645,
-0.7322712540626526,
0.3826502561569214,
-0.4870719313621521,
-0.45986509323120117,
-0.1091741994023323,
0.1275739073753357,
0.4404032230377197,
0.3142959177494049,
0.26856693625450134,
-0.14634917676448822,
-0.0003602060314733535,
-1.1351706981658936,
-0.6164966821670532,
-0.2444385290145874,
-0.41761988401412964,
0.35609906911849976,
0.7035507559776306,
-0.13198934495449066,
0.6000175476074219,
-0.6829885244369507,
-0.09820377081632614,
-0.08455070853233337,
0.11521676927804947,
0.21127618849277496,
0.3828035295009613,
0.4303749203681946,
-0.7925215363502502,
-0.14958180487155914,
-0.21709109842777252,
-0.3847736120223999,
-0.2522028982639313,
0.02372048795223236,
-0.20110198855400085,
0.06523507833480835,
0.17310865223407745,
-0.7679290771484375,
-0.007831060327589512,
0.5513941049575806,
-0.5971937775611877,
0.7258469462394714,
-0.18517830967903137,
0.13450448215007782,
-0.3366349935531616,
0.06714119762182236,
0.2689482867717743,
-0.11357952654361725,
-0.5821312665939331,
0.10918927937746048,
0.18388448655605316,
-0.198405921459198,
-0.009125573560595512,
0.775303304195404,
-0.2361064851284027,
0.029884956777095795,
0.1405295580625534,
0.2024923861026764,
0.046825844794511795,
0.40002596378326416,
0.18866455554962158,
0.7230259776115417,
0.5566735863685608,
-0.4611493945121765,
0.6560670137405396,
-0.0503758043050766,
-0.4953402578830719,
0.9112942218780518,
-0.8243768215179443,
-0.043256279081106186,
0.27765345573425293,
0.06780701130628586,
-0.8798947930335999,
-0.2189197689294815,
0.2096431702375412,
-0.4135693311691284,
0.331036776304245,
0.235361248254776,
-0.9641635417938232,
-0.5722463726997375,
-0.4891893267631531,
0.3381754159927368,
0.6506927013397217,
-0.40917983651161194,
0.6582601070404053,
0.14152510464191437,
-0.13038377463817596,
-0.03634151071310043,
-0.40371134877204895,
0.18803240358829498,
-0.6231025457382202,
-0.6305317282676697,
-0.20367905497550964,
-0.03549083322286606,
-0.7153894901275635,
0.09608849138021469,
-0.4288816750049591,
-0.43744799494743347,
0.2137317955493927,
-0.31073224544525146,
-0.031131967902183533,
-0.49840879440307617,
0.6468427181243896,
-0.07105343043804169,
-0.09803833067417145,
0.36814841628074646,
-0.3985668420791626,
0.23070569336414337,
-0.309224396944046,
-0.39545127749443054,
-0.026260942220687866,
0.3833028972148895,
0.2927786707878113,
-0.3704845607280731,
0.6115261316299438,
0.20934852957725525,
-0.6249509453773499,
-0.1959753930568695,
-0.8521500825881958,
0.03790557011961937,
-0.5304814577102661,
0.4141344130039215,
-0.5163885951042175,
-0.8245549201965332,
0.38919925689697266,
-0.2615928053855896,
-0.43676435947418213,
0.6033715009689331,
0.16287349164485931,
0.00985869113355875,
1.2708388566970825,
0.44891586899757385,
0.05283539742231369,
0.29227423667907715,
-0.10506242513656616,
0.3757132887840271,
-0.8226413130760193,
-0.10310039669275284,
-0.7590779662132263,
-0.2774636149406433,
-0.5152267217636108,
-0.5318979620933533,
0.3943327069282532,
0.4193980097770691,
-0.6674116849899292,
0.1604965627193451,
-0.43421652913093567,
0.6767295598983765,
0.5596900582313538,
-0.0033466434106230736,
0.3824145495891571,
-0.18198871612548828,
-0.17309214174747467,
0.18221136927604675,
-0.5171886086463928,
-0.5095412731170654,
0.8314365148544312,
0.09760300070047379,
0.7294228672981262,
0.28200021386146545,
0.2817319333553314,
0.013333662413060665,
0.24604305624961853,
-0.6449422240257263,
0.6929603219032288,
-0.1584128886461258,
-0.5651381611824036,
-0.5864414572715759,
-0.7113187313079834,
-0.649997889995575,
0.6962276101112366,
-0.11171840131282806,
-1.101314663887024,
0.06104397773742676,
0.054498109966516495,
-0.1079520732164383,
0.4721476137638092,
-0.9306098818778992,
0.7207620143890381,
-0.49354103207588196,
-0.3388073146343231,
-0.3954543471336365,
-0.2804834544658661,
0.5546185374259949,
-0.5326168537139893,
0.42466527223587036,
-0.4146083891391754,
-0.4000642001628876,
0.34680989384651184,
-0.7073339223861694,
0.37849169969558716,
-0.030442357063293457,
-0.37212494015693665,
0.3088846504688263,
0.2150704711675644,
0.45052242279052734,
0.3913782238960266,
-0.32647091150283813,
0.29837140440940857,
0.24381646513938904,
-0.5247989892959595,
-0.750429630279541,
0.7008943557739258,
-0.4273330867290497,
-1.1541767120361328,
-0.6107400059700012,
-0.2847840487957001,
-0.7739366292953491,
0.22899386286735535,
-0.10094914585351944,
0.34857815504074097,
0.005018137861043215,
0.2872568964958191,
0.6626285314559937,
-0.25828489661216736,
0.09113621711730957,
0.48650553822517395,
-0.04053463041782379,
-0.7306342124938965,
0.8256192803382874,
0.14632584154605865,
0.3371245563030243,
0.43358972668647766,
0.4968203604221344,
-0.37101033329963684,
-0.3017564117908478,
-0.5554227828979492,
0.34598276019096375,
-0.7151471972465515,
-0.4047369956970215,
-0.236390620470047,
-0.1412729173898697,
-0.1327517181634903,
0.043318010866642,
0.15186451375484467,
-0.7182620763778687,
0.14379897713661194,
0.41578900814056396,
0.36135607957839966,
0.6080925464630127,
-0.16793057322502136,
0.030434919521212578,
-0.9278450012207031,
0.4533787965774536,
0.9228194355964661,
0.9818426966667175,
0.02941698208451271,
-0.4436153769493103,
-0.07727693766355515,
0.18615856766700745,
-0.33150944113731384,
-0.6905202269554138,
-0.04988415166735649,
0.6121516227722168,
0.6434429883956909,
0.37452471256256104,
-0.0815829262137413,
0.718735933303833,
-0.5792922377586365,
0.7637315392494202,
0.10472794622182846,
-1.4222978353500366,
0.5364764332771301,
-0.4107460081577301,
0.5178098678588867,
0.07989957928657532,
0.2968544661998749,
-0.5654897689819336,
-0.37483033537864685,
-0.6413058638572693,
-0.5182314515113831,
0.4322032630443573,
0.27650031447410583,
0.3896002173423767,
-0.05832863599061966,
0.38053175806999207,
-0.08042223751544952,
0.3954675793647766,
-0.505358099937439,
0.19128471612930298,
0.017306789755821228,
0.06195110082626343,
-0.5349817872047424,
-0.47775977849960327,
0.094039686024189,
-0.6249354481697083,
0.4853474497795105,
-0.11897211521863937,
0.17897650599479675,
0.14932377636432648,
0.043224602937698364,
-0.38808614015579224,
0.3278251886367798,
0.6576672792434692,
0.6328685283660889,
0.08903425186872482,
0.059346552938222885,
0.5543680191040039,
-0.3530648350715637,
0.10601812601089478,
0.24856264889240265,
0.10521069169044495,
-0.07406565546989441,
0.6069434881210327,
0.44616463780403137,
0.5795764327049255,
-1.0564483404159546,
0.46108368039131165,
-0.09141986072063446,
-0.3253779709339142,
-0.02836979366838932,
0.4063260555267334,
0.22003379464149475,
0.41263052821159363,
0.3901681900024414,
-0.4100476801395416,
0.13729293644428253,
-0.5098409056663513,
-0.14140889048576355,
0.7358641028404236,
0.01584663800895214,
-0.35721731185913086,
0.47553443908691406,
0.09765063971281052,
-0.361085444688797,
0.8063945174217224,
-0.15520232915878296,
-0.9238613247871399,
0.6688544154167175,
0.4202124774456024,
0.9036412239074707,
-0.13953034579753876,
0.0057833013124763966,
0.3654719591140747,
0.22049152851104736,
-0.11697383970022202,
0.40712109208106995,
-0.41501283645629883,
-0.4749048948287964,
-0.3413428068161011,
-0.7450433969497681,
-0.7701733708381653,
0.017768925055861473,
-0.23585550487041473,
0.39462554454803467,
-0.28160926699638367,
-0.1215168908238411,
-0.03903916850686073,
0.19296377897262573,
-0.44879984855651855,
0.39826586842536926,
0.23397284746170044,
0.917345404624939,
-0.428307443857193,
0.6641819477081299,
0.8366402983665466,
-0.03967048227787018,
-0.5668845772743225,
0.1566001921892166,
-0.1455281674861908,
-0.843624472618103,
0.39914846420288086,
0.07181109488010406,
-0.09759708493947983,
-0.022331319749355316,
-0.6629955768585205,
-1.03127920627594,
0.6158366203308105,
0.5336912274360657,
-0.5978391766548157,
0.1570587456226349,
0.3609784245491028,
0.8039934635162354,
0.11838891357183456,
0.15729635953903198,
0.41470256447792053,
0.6613084673881531,
0.11436732113361359,
-1.0816211700439453,
-0.13680973649024963,
-0.2400185912847519,
0.07313147932291031,
0.64051753282547,
-0.843275249004364,
0.9980140924453735,
-0.2577783167362213,
-0.19440075755119324,
0.255343496799469,
0.35223862528800964,
0.21261917054653168,
0.15593457221984863,
0.6332154870033264,
0.8556418418884277,
0.864449143409729,
-0.384632408618927,
0.9539234042167664,
-0.09751172363758087,
0.48829126358032227,
0.7761528491973877,
-0.4180760979652405,
1.078364372253418,
0.15923306345939636,
-0.5550550818443298,
0.6169201135635376,
0.5420812368392944,
-0.20663882791996002,
0.21413344144821167,
0.8326917290687561,
-0.2533992826938629,
-0.8573108911514282,
0.18082301318645477,
-0.6244238018989563,
0.41255417466163635,
0.4857921600341797,
0.13297776877880096,
-0.32287535071372986,
-0.17563199996948242,
-0.19287315011024475,
0.15943939983844757,
-0.4182365834712982,
0.6156869530677795,
0.23377393186092377,
-0.5008095502853394,
0.760513186454773,
-0.14075975120067596,
0.462846577167511,
-0.6152732968330383,
-0.2719685137271881,
-0.311927855014801,
0.34259191155433655,
0.08361631631851196,
-0.9265615940093994,
0.2956133782863617,
0.1794845014810562,
0.22523175179958344,
-0.007041450589895248,
0.8267732858657837,
-0.16046300530433655,
-0.709205687046051,
0.10767923295497894,
0.5038299560546875,
0.08396726101636887,
-0.33461058139801025,
-0.5246208310127258,
-0.0636376440525055,
-0.3950749635696411,
-0.24068914353847504,
0.3091913163661957,
1.0874643325805664,
-0.15385769307613373,
1.1172398328781128,
0.4231097400188446,
0.08896024525165558,
-0.29419055581092834,
-0.24524763226509094,
0.9871036410331726,
-1.0147380828857422,
-0.257630318403244,
-0.9008827209472656,
0.13057072460651398,
-0.08223140239715576,
-0.3474094867706299,
0.6923190951347351,
0.651310920715332,
0.858942449092865,
0.002452152082696557,
0.4099377393722534,
0.10601421445608139,
0.361976683139801,
-0.5410398840904236,
0.4903198480606079,
-0.7738313674926758,
0.1545952409505844,
-0.2112075686454773,
-1.0134379863739014,
-0.3829382359981537,
0.6507874727249146,
-0.42586076259613037,
0.13761453330516815,
0.7530904412269592,
0.20805668830871582,
0.026275353506207466,
0.1898701936006546,
0.4825689196586609,
0.1482439637184143,
0.05213193967938423,
0.862540066242218,
1.1267818212509155,
-0.15440301597118378,
0.6447835564613342,
-0.35492730140686035,
0.019690414890646935,
0.014719436876475811,
-0.9165619611740112,
-0.7535687685012817,
-0.5291207432746887,
-0.38268333673477173,
-0.10501331090927124,
0.20760758221149445,
0.5378292798995972,
0.37661707401275635,
-0.8383100032806396,
-0.10359972715377808,
0.08946362882852554,
0.5968956351280212,
-0.17815345525741577,
-0.213302344083786,
0.09189281612634659,
-0.2764244079589844,
-0.7324711084365845,
-0.2157641351222992,
0.23128294944763184,
-0.08733934164047241,
-0.18624429404735565,
0.2137804478406906,
-0.08295202255249023,
0.38838011026382446,
0.5408293604850769,
0.0721353143453598,
-0.7768059968948364,
-0.8417851328849792,
-0.1113220751285553,
0.047300972044467926,
0.030035557225346565,
0.6730890274047852,
-1.0814077854156494,
0.3052973449230194,
0.5021370649337769,
0.15628984570503235,
0.046372104436159134,
0.22802941501140594,
0.552537202835083,
-0.12360027432441711,
-0.2879745662212372,
0.3275201916694641,
0.42284825444221497,
0.17932571470737457,
0.04087265208363533,
0.6246421933174133,
0.36868196725845337,
-0.6039995551109314,
-1.0378929376602173,
-0.03760412335395813,
-0.41086962819099426,
-0.32357773184776306,
1.3704087734222412,
-0.06603647768497467,
-0.19778478145599365,
0.2883339524269104,
-0.017740052193403244,
-0.24514977633953094,
-0.2292599380016327,
0.618113100528717,
1.1357861757278442,
-0.17658349871635437,
-0.03946111723780632,
-0.3736851215362549,
0.17187567055225372,
0.5008482933044434,
-0.6613643169403076,
-0.02164708450436592,
0.6961666345596313,
0.35205772519111633,
0.0787939727306366,
0.3431459367275238,
0.09063930809497833,
0.288174569606781,
0.18268941342830658,
-0.4479965567588806,
0.3222392797470093,
-0.03897109627723694,
-0.730350136756897,
0.020612312480807304,
0.23577989637851715,
0.12035378068685532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01031v1 | PocketLLM: Enabling On-Device Fine-Tuning for Personalized LLMs | 2024-07-01T07:26:56 | 2024-07-01T07:26:56 | Dan Peng, Zhihui Fu, Jun Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have indeed showcased
their impressive capabilities. On mobile devices, the wealth of valuable,
non-public data generated daily holds great promise for locally fine-tuning
personalized LLMs, while maintaining privacy through on-device processing.
However, the constraints of mobile device resources pose challenges to direct
on-device LLM fine-tuning, mainly due to the memory-intensive nature of
derivative-based optimization required for saving gradients and optimizer
states. To tackle this, we propose employing derivative-free optimization
techniques to enable on-device fine-tuning of LLM, even on memory-limited
mobile devices. Empirical results demonstrate that the RoBERTa-large model and
OPT-1.3B can be fine-tuned locally on the OPPO Reno 6 smartphone using around
4GB and 6.5GB of memory respectively, using derivative-free optimization
techniques. This highlights the feasibility of on-device LLM fine-tuning on
mobile devices, paving the way for personalized LLMs on resource-constrained
devices while safeguarding data privacy. | [
-0.49788013100624084,
-0.8756742477416992,
0.5071554183959961,
-0.1101628914475441,
-0.4127219617366791,
0.05012083798646927,
-0.5283674597740173,
-0.21239390969276428,
0.07653287798166275,
0.6800065636634827,
-0.6163648366928101,
-0.47774964570999146,
-0.15574049949645996,
-0.1265186220407486,
-0.023372823372483253,
0.6766760945320129,
-0.0802231878042221,
-0.06955328583717346,
-0.08974282443523407,
-0.28210753202438354,
-0.44898656010627747,
-0.2978123724460602,
-0.6197746396064758,
-0.10600481182336807,
0.40206581354141235,
0.704296350479126,
0.5048097968101501,
0.8465934991836548,
0.26252979040145874,
0.16761954128742218,
-0.13485896587371826,
0.6309890747070312,
-0.6992238759994507,
0.3344811797142029,
-0.24646316468715668,
-0.2614057660102844,
-0.6198691725730896,
-0.2923499643802643,
0.4298133850097656,
0.32122522592544556,
-0.20046214759349823,
0.2420734018087387,
-0.06835263222455978,
0.7999404072761536,
-0.7695426344871521,
-0.40081876516342163,
-1.0264678001403809,
-0.006808078847825527,
-0.12486474215984344,
-0.22787554562091827,
-0.16106191277503967,
-0.6665321588516235,
-0.025101520121097565,
-0.3543941080570221,
0.32072973251342773,
0.10343067348003387,
0.835135817527771,
0.46470388770103455,
-0.332125723361969,
0.026129981502890587,
-1.0805997848510742,
0.9256941080093384,
-0.4356444478034973,
0.5490037798881531,
0.6632556319236755,
0.08284226059913635,
-0.0002404875704087317,
-0.49973154067993164,
-0.3652834892272949,
-0.12124483287334442,
0.44685086607933044,
-0.2536177337169647,
-0.14219729602336884,
-0.05472298711538315,
-0.028941042721271515,
0.33137813210487366,
-0.2871161103248596,
0.0987733006477356,
-0.08765365183353424,
-0.25844594836235046,
0.5702688097953796,
0.28967568278312683,
0.0973903238773346,
0.28847822546958923,
-0.22490155696868896,
0.5679160952568054,
-1.242910385131836,
-0.1321193128824234,
0.20484301447868347,
0.5300249457359314,
-0.3855792284011841,
0.36257120966911316,
-0.4410023093223572,
0.8240275382995605,
0.17918609082698822,
-0.40852421522140503,
-0.15117816627025604,
-0.5141499042510986,
-0.308963418006897,
0.23725436627864838,
0.7074177861213684,
0.2803494334220886,
0.21257241070270538,
-0.394684761762619,
-0.26688405871391296,
-0.5810580849647522,
-0.03719925507903099,
-1.1016168594360352,
-0.07420291006565094,
0.39437615871429443,
-0.32834792137145996,
-0.15768598020076752,
-0.23112037777900696,
-0.6147037148475647,
-0.5300443768501282,
-0.2672494351863861,
0.35899925231933594,
-0.21775850653648376,
0.22368481755256653,
0.33053842186927795,
0.3667994737625122,
-0.08064964413642883,
0.3429337739944458,
-1.2511051893234253,
0.32230889797210693,
0.45248863101005554,
1.0955212116241455,
-0.02247038669884205,
0.189217209815979,
-0.7463921308517456,
0.6760134100914001,
-0.007933198474347591,
0.4390212893486023,
-0.5595383048057556,
-0.9011105895042419,
-0.13205918669700623,
-0.2688674032688141,
-0.18325600028038025,
-0.7541980147361755,
0.7162352204322815,
-0.23672828078269958,
-0.20563873648643494,
-0.06863754987716675,
-0.521489679813385,
0.17051227390766144,
-0.04173068702220917,
-0.29448580741882324,
0.6149431467056274,
-0.10519968718290329,
-0.5347731113433838,
0.2305767685174942,
-0.33636894822120667,
-0.5359320640563965,
-0.1856282353401184,
0.09319797903299332,
-0.7428382039070129,
0.5801032781600952,
0.2025546431541443,
0.6108605861663818,
-0.46937131881713867,
-0.07925619184970856,
-0.43358272314071655,
-0.23816150426864624,
0.2347538322210312,
-0.07335947453975677,
0.39189937710762024,
0.44027572870254517,
-0.335212767124176,
0.3611394166946411,
-0.8293529152870178,
0.20488141477108002,
-0.15041165053844452,
-0.4164000451564789,
-0.4072372317314148,
0.23912741243839264,
-0.08993586152791977,
-0.16776368021965027,
0.7627952098846436,
-0.8117711544036865,
0.2657119035720825,
-0.2624029517173767,
0.8381720781326294,
0.6494240164756775,
-0.3180544376373291,
0.57973712682724,
-0.32500749826431274,
0.3173191249370575,
-0.45427268743515015,
0.3658202290534973,
-0.10367879271507263,
-0.1872825175523758,
-0.6612029671669006,
-0.5745844841003418,
0.5912439823150635,
0.6144312024116516,
-0.00023645238252356648,
0.3992781639099121,
-0.24593231081962585,
-0.3764077425003052,
-0.35199153423309326,
0.5271850228309631,
0.3718043565750122,
0.4692583382129669,
0.15540432929992676,
0.008246359415352345,
-0.3704850375652313,
-0.9315018057823181,
-0.22778595983982086,
0.4527549743652344,
-0.012171435169875622,
0.9697092175483704,
-0.08282976597547531,
-0.41723811626434326,
1.0504529476165771,
-0.6531888246536255,
-0.6805827021598816,
-0.2135854810476303,
-0.3811952769756317,
-0.056481197476387024,
0.41151881217956543,
0.08082309365272522,
-0.5911261439323425,
-0.5814738869667053,
0.5743329524993896,
-0.18734203279018402,
-0.4381874203681946,
-0.0005737347528338432,
0.22686460614204407,
0.1485760509967804,
0.450351357460022,
-0.7411686778068542,
-0.020761284977197647,
0.44861072301864624,
-0.25945547223091125,
0.23346403241157532,
-0.8266857862472534,
-0.37118831276893616,
-1.0803207159042358,
-0.15969417989253998,
0.13575366139411926,
-0.6455798745155334,
-0.409321665763855,
0.07286668568849564,
0.27736175060272217,
-0.06641167402267456,
-0.5774855613708496,
0.9484567046165466,
-0.3351280093193054,
0.20149336755275726,
-0.24910351634025574,
0.17519782483577728,
-0.09660544991493225,
-0.12343653291463852,
-0.22312209010124207,
0.861689567565918,
0.4144847095012665,
-0.6249924302101135,
-0.06189311295747757,
-0.13242757320404053,
-0.08463532477617264,
0.2835591435432434,
-0.6736165881156921,
0.14899738132953644,
0.21231219172477722,
-0.20881235599517822,
-0.6395009756088257,
-0.34255251288414,
-0.012635566294193268,
0.19462332129478455,
0.23481489717960358,
-0.10125028342008591,
-0.6674680709838867,
0.15280677378177643,
-0.5476492047309875,
0.20838209986686707,
0.6808209419250488,
-0.6290596127510071,
0.8515567183494568,
0.5821492671966553,
0.06174955517053604,
0.0110864769667387,
-0.1413346827030182,
-0.3317599892616272,
-0.601578414440155,
-0.6304996013641357,
0.7484815716743469,
-0.035007230937480927,
-0.324093759059906,
-0.4364560544490814,
-0.15589384734630585,
-0.10800720006227493,
0.1758197546005249,
0.4242534637451172,
0.02127569541335106,
0.09284807741641998,
0.004014378413558006,
0.5392323136329651,
-0.0024100886657834053,
-0.4782222807407379,
-0.20045316219329834,
0.7141880393028259,
-0.10468607395887375,
0.052580978721380234,
-0.6517629623413086,
-0.2490926831960678,
0.44052594900131226,
-0.37282806634902954,
0.4763035476207733,
0.6621991991996765,
-0.24631454050540924,
-0.37688353657722473,
-0.5703169703483582,
-0.08266191929578781,
-0.6200780272483826,
0.021596107631921768,
-0.5530566573143005,
-1.3349496126174927,
0.6854535937309265,
-0.462368369102478,
-0.2573269307613373,
-0.06571517884731293,
0.8359391689300537,
0.08944807201623917,
0.9356924295425415,
0.5853102207183838,
-0.223325714468956,
0.5561583042144775,
-0.06896564364433289,
0.16894768178462982,
-1.0090577602386475,
-0.21239981055259705,
-0.590153694152832,
-0.3195374310016632,
-0.6044098734855652,
-0.3920605480670929,
0.3836066722869873,
0.4851723611354828,
-0.4281225800514221,
0.20101462304592133,
-0.54979008436203,
0.8503139019012451,
0.4378334581851959,
0.3435313105583191,
0.4192558228969574,
0.0509004108607769,
-0.06971339136362076,
-0.0488026887178421,
-0.32358911633491516,
-0.5213005542755127,
1.1905938386917114,
0.3630176782608032,
1.1540875434875488,
0.11719458550214767,
0.7760004997253418,
-0.05163770169019699,
-0.07815147936344147,
-0.5880913138389587,
0.7039718627929688,
-0.5793136358261108,
-0.3519892394542694,
-0.06607325375080109,
-0.4269719421863556,
-0.9419291615486145,
0.1407375931739807,
0.12660826742649078,
-1.0778207778930664,
-0.05444621294736862,
0.3908432722091675,
-0.6752035021781921,
0.3500773310661316,
-0.8538787961006165,
0.6085473299026489,
-0.1978096216917038,
-0.8864213824272156,
-0.4219684600830078,
-0.20645464956760406,
0.28314927220344543,
-0.2631637156009674,
0.2132936716079712,
-0.5374857783317566,
-0.43222853541374207,
0.15056711435317993,
-0.6045746803283691,
0.8624200820922852,
-0.26902157068252563,
-0.33234089612960815,
0.18116095662117004,
0.28137779235839844,
0.61710524559021,
0.43583834171295166,
-0.08271172642707825,
0.0032013689633458853,
-0.029170308262109756,
-0.18783436715602875,
-0.18952859938144684,
1.4067659378051758,
-0.7152878046035767,
-0.6050369739532471,
0.07864080369472504,
-0.4020712971687317,
-0.3844131529331207,
0.2850167155265808,
0.3153468072414398,
0.4337344169616699,
-0.15509341657161713,
0.22219468653202057,
1.009732723236084,
-0.3872216045856476,
0.6060971021652222,
0.5834094285964966,
-0.3506603538990021,
-0.27484333515167236,
1.381365418434143,
-0.12406877428293228,
0.09113451838493347,
0.5961395502090454,
0.66740483045578,
-0.5558545589447021,
-0.9345403909683228,
-0.6605419516563416,
0.18677833676338196,
-0.10372474044561386,
-0.25623267889022827,
-0.3681865334510803,
0.31045669317245483,
0.003814437659457326,
-0.1540955901145935,
-0.6138196587562561,
-0.4913569688796997,
-0.6939613223075867,
0.19588389992713928,
0.5533155202865601,
0.3453350365161896,
0.03370387852191925,
0.6190063953399658,
-0.796820342540741,
0.3120451271533966,
0.27059221267700195,
0.5467448830604553,
-0.2735052704811096,
-0.477495938539505,
-0.3071401119232178,
0.2120341807603836,
-0.6956178545951843,
-0.20618070662021637,
0.36983931064605713,
0.6020858287811279,
0.0957043394446373,
0.5689699649810791,
-0.006342549342662096,
0.5863968729972839,
-0.6195200085639954,
0.5832122564315796,
-0.06893724203109741,
-1.153904914855957,
0.7466538548469543,
-0.7387374043464661,
0.2670445442199707,
0.521278440952301,
0.09695923328399658,
-0.0439499169588089,
-0.12042471766471863,
-0.14866289496421814,
-0.7541280388832092,
0.3685663640499115,
-0.1011696383357048,
0.7651030421257019,
0.23671525716781616,
0.5819875001907349,
0.19930236041545868,
0.14383335411548615,
-0.4332004189491272,
-0.14361177384853363,
0.08166252821683884,
-0.13850530982017517,
0.08108624070882797,
-0.1545150876045227,
-0.1183636486530304,
-0.5855069756507874,
0.27653181552886963,
0.03484397754073143,
-0.03937651589512825,
0.16155722737312317,
0.06863868981599808,
-0.21324318647384644,
0.23358723521232605,
1.187559962272644,
0.7046918869018555,
-0.40935754776000977,
-0.034105200320482254,
0.3000533878803253,
-0.4598146975040436,
0.010115205310285091,
0.08403319865465164,
-0.42312386631965637,
-0.09025362879037857,
-0.3103068470954895,
0.9358201622962952,
0.13429829478263855,
-0.9909235239028931,
0.07605966180562973,
-0.2939087748527527,
0.04067850857973099,
-0.2435530573129654,
0.4939783811569214,
0.23087173700332642,
0.13401031494140625,
0.15903764963150024,
-0.07055923342704773,
-0.008504679426550865,
-0.3067355751991272,
-0.04792018607258797,
0.8469610810279846,
-0.3600418269634247,
-0.5046411752700806,
1.0607455968856812,
0.2863888740539551,
-0.5071384906768799,
-0.008746547624468803,
-0.15207673609256744,
0.002519016619771719,
0.2221681773662567,
0.5461152791976929,
0.9249473214149475,
-0.38149604201316833,
0.11486533284187317,
0.06725432723760605,
0.044678546488285065,
0.025463467463850975,
0.4338951110839844,
0.010264093987643719,
-0.6223315596580505,
-0.18289217352867126,
-0.833301305770874,
-0.42343366146087646,
0.32792049646377563,
-0.1202239990234375,
0.3171818256378174,
-1.037713646888733,
-0.2700749635696411,
-0.08534863591194153,
-0.13227561116218567,
-0.4021424651145935,
0.1682271659374237,
-0.05936595797538757,
0.7784947752952576,
0.16291667520999908,
1.3139605522155762,
0.4503832757472992,
0.29145804047584534,
-0.825855016708374,
-0.03983227163553238,
-0.15989848971366882,
-0.6396041512489319,
0.60785973072052,
0.018758056685328484,
-0.41440752148628235,
0.14877952635288239,
-0.08480600267648697,
-0.6119313836097717,
0.9629296064376831,
0.557426393032074,
-1.039735198020935,
0.21641449630260468,
0.16701637208461761,
0.39732885360717773,
-0.3435112535953522,
-0.2035316377878189,
0.3152444362640381,
0.2972438633441925,
-0.25653406977653503,
-1.4150683879852295,
0.1198882982134819,
0.287668913602829,
0.1605709046125412,
0.6688987016677856,
-0.9552671313285828,
0.9650362730026245,
-0.48511233925819397,
0.020198386162519455,
0.25115785002708435,
0.050608161836862564,
0.07064653187990189,
0.2275068312883377,
0.15392835438251495,
0.5820780992507935,
0.7519155144691467,
-0.058666862547397614,
1.2084492444992065,
-0.7431830763816833,
0.4271683096885681,
0.9003936052322388,
-0.5263246893882751,
1.0264989137649536,
0.44854936003685,
-0.12230329215526581,
0.04736552760004997,
0.5579920411109924,
0.38991019129753113,
0.8963030576705933,
0.3498488664627075,
-0.9272067546844482,
-0.23398113250732422,
-0.14578889310359955,
-0.3203085958957672,
0.3868441879749298,
0.37191954255104065,
-0.43848833441734314,
-0.16258598864078522,
0.07543322443962097,
-0.042740318924188614,
0.07455256581306458,
-0.7056857347488403,
0.683688223361969,
0.17434675991535187,
-0.06694290041923523,
0.8829230666160583,
0.6624903678894043,
0.8649264574050903,
-0.46552330255508423,
0.6171637773513794,
-0.44226351380348206,
0.5316776037216187,
-0.24095642566680908,
-0.11689404398202896,
0.4112328588962555,
-0.11122027784585953,
-0.17920897901058197,
-0.29136186838150024,
0.9276562333106995,
-0.22297951579093933,
-0.2822462320327759,
0.023493381217122078,
0.4796477258205414,
-0.16960342228412628,
-0.25391218066215515,
-0.45556867122650146,
0.29992565512657166,
0.20869222283363342,
-0.1362304389476776,
0.7118886113166809,
0.2820535898208618,
0.03397092968225479,
1.0950206518173218,
0.5410727858543396,
0.2677466869354248,
0.15464471280574799,
-0.07892248779535294,
0.7678940892219543,
-0.625868022441864,
-0.3711053431034088,
-1.2999982833862305,
0.0388273224234581,
0.15903058648109436,
-0.505895733833313,
0.746711254119873,
0.9774798154830933,
0.8625203967094421,
-0.20847314596176147,
0.7826496958732605,
0.06449034810066223,
0.5766083598136902,
-0.665630578994751,
0.7484450936317444,
-0.7043508887290955,
0.5316722393035889,
0.07188140600919724,
-0.8813073039054871,
-0.1964566558599472,
0.6292557716369629,
-0.3493499755859375,
-0.10103356838226318,
0.19212742149829865,
0.8827905058860779,
-0.4057072103023529,
0.10478059947490692,
0.3768875300884247,
-0.06109392270445824,
0.1049078106880188,
0.40526270866394043,
0.32381004095077515,
-0.1285250186920166,
0.27828675508499146,
-0.3094569742679596,
0.03213443234562874,
-0.33559927344322205,
-0.8490012884140015,
-0.9608568549156189,
-0.350567489862442,
-0.3012593984603882,
-0.12613369524478912,
0.0800400897860527,
0.8667840361595154,
0.9594335556030273,
-0.5805417895317078,
-0.39166557788848877,
-0.22776149213314056,
0.22611773014068604,
0.42659351229667664,
-0.1317533403635025,
0.21632882952690125,
-0.038841284811496735,
-0.8094553351402283,
0.510312557220459,
0.5079336762428284,
0.2945256233215332,
-0.12408129870891571,
-0.26449164748191833,
0.43537604808807373,
0.08629971742630005,
0.7597272992134094,
0.3823662996292114,
-0.8254231810569763,
-0.2151949256658554,
-0.05995064601302147,
-0.05454150587320328,
0.15508154034614563,
1.0948940515518188,
-0.6054250001907349,
0.3162209987640381,
0.26535889506340027,
0.4998559057712555,
0.6299838423728943,
0.15649574995040894,
0.4417239725589752,
-0.9617885947227478,
0.2081061750650406,
0.02260608971118927,
0.3070411682128906,
0.17746524512767792,
-0.2584337890148163,
0.16587035357952118,
-0.09794532507658005,
-0.5988700985908508,
-1.0560232400894165,
0.3914293944835663,
-1.1111408472061157,
-0.2681092321872711,
1.165844440460205,
0.02767954021692276,
0.020227577537298203,
-0.12138824164867401,
-0.43765759468078613,
-0.18225914239883423,
-0.5875435471534729,
0.9196584820747375,
0.3582836985588074,
-0.44033652544021606,
-0.33252954483032227,
-0.513418972492218,
0.7360090613365173,
0.3801690340042114,
-0.9225133061408997,
0.29880231618881226,
0.1891668438911438,
0.4984646737575531,
-0.21694159507751465,
0.7660173177719116,
0.1313912570476532,
-0.03834899887442589,
-0.5469536185264587,
-0.41113367676734924,
-0.2976887822151184,
-0.006300975102931261,
-0.20384345948696136,
0.198241725564003,
0.33495059609413147,
-0.1910402923822403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01026v1 | Augmenting Document-level Relation Extraction with Efficient Multi-Supervision | 2024-07-01T07:22:32 | 2024-07-01T07:22:32 | Xiangyu Lin, Weijia Jia, Zhiguo Gong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite its popularity in sentence-level relation extraction, distantly
supervised data is rarely utilized by existing work in document-level relation
extraction due to its noisy nature and low information density. Among its
current applications, distantly supervised data is mostly used as a whole for
pertaining, which is of low time efficiency. To fill in the gap of efficient
and robust utilization of distantly supervised training data, we propose
Efficient Multi-Supervision for document-level relation extraction, in which we
first select a subset of informative documents from the massive dataset by
combining distant supervision with expert supervision, then train the model
with Multi-Supervision Ranking Loss that integrates the knowledge from multiple
sources of supervision to alleviate the effects of noise. The experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving the model performance
with higher time efficiency than existing baselines. | [
-0.3595520853996277,
-0.6986923217773438,
0.6006726622581482,
0.10790707170963287,
-0.15601485967636108,
-0.3136586546897888,
-0.3373127579689026,
-0.7371377944946289,
-0.03437956050038338,
0.2588637173175812,
-0.5975698828697205,
-0.4808940887451172,
-0.8830634355545044,
-0.10222610831260681,
-0.44972750544548035,
0.9430879950523376,
0.2973702549934387,
0.11889266222715378,
-0.29698535799980164,
0.08262589573860168,
-0.002225631382316351,
-0.48285484313964844,
-0.6614986658096313,
-0.07597590982913971,
0.7504003047943115,
0.2994258999824524,
0.30161142349243164,
0.5626108050346375,
0.7100170850753784,
0.292477011680603,
-0.13875068724155426,
0.5321833491325378,
-0.41486117243766785,
0.3933802843093872,
-0.09898113459348679,
-0.26329824328422546,
-0.6234248876571655,
0.20706678926944733,
0.5083218812942505,
0.8363809585571289,
-0.05526842921972275,
-0.048508621752262115,
-0.019624119624495506,
0.46333199739456177,
-0.7061451077461243,
0.7187806963920593,
-0.6270672082901001,
-0.10202506184577942,
-0.3761720061302185,
-0.28571173548698425,
-0.39508140087127686,
-0.2411801517009735,
0.1053626611828804,
-0.7836402058601379,
0.4097035229206085,
-0.056080494076013565,
0.9915669560432434,
0.12813705205917358,
-0.459473580121994,
-0.21259599924087524,
-0.8692088723182678,
0.6334015727043152,
-0.40627944469451904,
0.6806710958480835,
0.6783939599990845,
0.12469486892223358,
0.14011375606060028,
-0.533805251121521,
-0.029611919075250626,
-0.20944149792194366,
-0.2513684630393982,
0.4560207426548004,
0.18325644731521606,
0.06518596410751343,
0.39469239115715027,
0.4114881157875061,
0.11545475572347641,
0.039468009024858475,
-0.5598087906837463,
0.029714008793234825,
0.3665757179260254,
-0.052927881479263306,
-0.03723607212305069,
-0.27024102210998535,
-0.15836679935455322,
0.04275159537792206,
-0.46801790595054626,
-0.18290890753269196,
0.4154317080974579,
0.4176180958747864,
0.25665104389190674,
0.3823041617870331,
-0.3780985176563263,
0.6767156720161438,
0.10303281992673874,
-0.544849157333374,
0.2719116508960724,
-0.6417608261108398,
0.24703747034072876,
-0.12486907094717026,
0.7219393253326416,
0.36810144782066345,
0.13047271966934204,
-0.5185327529907227,
0.04528201371431351,
-0.14481860399246216,
0.31954532861709595,
-0.7646250128746033,
-0.36678457260131836,
0.017203787341713905,
-0.523108184337616,
-0.2512507438659668,
0.2600986957550049,
-0.8513904213905334,
-0.17472019791603088,
-0.3930119276046753,
-0.13442131876945496,
-0.7191084027290344,
-0.4478452801704407,
-0.3735618591308594,
-0.30759111046791077,
-0.053067371249198914,
0.43151724338531494,
-1.1976550817489624,
0.053295500576496124,
0.7542845010757446,
0.787153959274292,
0.06324169039726257,
-0.37601035833358765,
-0.9031568169593811,
0.6073472499847412,
-0.23938138782978058,
0.6766625046730042,
-0.6699156761169434,
-0.2545372545719147,
-0.019238634034991264,
-0.18264047801494598,
-0.13793228566646576,
-0.4105576276779175,
0.6167572140693665,
-0.5347858667373657,
0.3082728385925293,
0.10416796803474426,
-0.46401333808898926,
0.32500582933425903,
0.13186347484588623,
-0.6939514875411987,
1.2159875631332397,
0.36471444368362427,
-0.8699469566345215,
0.6027370691299438,
-0.3341601490974426,
-0.5384520888328552,
-0.24185124039649963,
0.10694790631532669,
-0.5508410334587097,
-0.07310760766267776,
0.7542718648910522,
0.7102399468421936,
0.048162512481212616,
0.305139422416687,
-0.5281244516372681,
-0.14124523103237152,
-0.31748297810554504,
-0.07525189220905304,
0.6064114570617676,
0.28996559977531433,
0.25936952233314514,
-0.25358110666275024,
-0.9864235520362854,
-0.5366594791412354,
-0.1839238554239273,
-0.39772287011146545,
-1.0623431205749512,
-0.01235356368124485,
-0.19505244493484497,
0.4119506776332855,
0.2841140031814575,
-0.5198317766189575,
0.37897494435310364,
-0.4813636839389801,
0.0014042513212189078,
0.44815221428871155,
0.4426485300064087,
0.8824643492698669,
-0.13178206980228424,
0.3543763756752014,
0.123125821352005,
0.34485480189323425,
-0.29552382230758667,
-0.17982015013694763,
-0.6558866500854492,
-0.3422990143299103,
0.1536998152732849,
0.1898459941148758,
-0.728444516658783,
0.4428183138370514,
-0.4934932291507721,
-0.5470532774925232,
-0.4312281310558319,
0.4547050893306732,
0.30596721172332764,
0.835450291633606,
0.4817449450492859,
0.0629119724035263,
-0.3083711862564087,
-0.6922363042831421,
-0.18717026710510254,
-0.04198442026972771,
0.02080557867884636,
0.14237457513809204,
0.11286093294620514,
-0.014116007834672928,
0.7202080488204956,
-0.6950932145118713,
-0.7458893656730652,
0.04042573273181915,
0.16030608117580414,
0.26968914270401,
0.4753117561340332,
0.6045365929603577,
-0.7181873917579651,
-0.536180317401886,
0.027550959959626198,
-1.0768176317214966,
-0.07852917909622192,
-0.24780653417110443,
-0.3617377281188965,
-0.16462619602680206,
0.7931680679321289,
-0.6912163496017456,
0.1172655001282692,
0.14249847829341888,
0.22595059871673584,
0.28623926639556885,
-0.22769643366336823,
0.030273394659161568,
-1.324905514717102,
-0.1777833253145218,
0.21378064155578613,
-0.09613902866840363,
-0.6963033080101013,
0.031989164650440216,
0.3938290476799011,
0.12196367979049683,
-0.10530050843954086,
0.03321200609207153,
-1.041862964630127,
0.006574831437319517,
0.06835027039051056,
0.4784984588623047,
0.09021507203578949,
0.5142274498939514,
0.159005805850029,
0.39796409010887146,
0.6251040697097778,
-0.4890967607498169,
0.2673249840736389,
0.4964832365512848,
-0.08348715305328369,
0.7056756615638733,
0.035673193633556366,
-0.07113030552864075,
-0.23522847890853882,
0.16464048624038696,
-0.5293670892715454,
-0.16302749514579773,
0.34564828872680664,
-0.23410311341285706,
0.5761011838912964,
-0.4613160789012909,
-0.6225632429122925,
-0.1250453144311905,
-0.4656432569026947,
-0.050392039120197296,
-0.0011048689484596252,
-0.6612857580184937,
0.5394653081893921,
0.43950825929641724,
-0.385349303483963,
-0.6211720108985901,
-0.5406544804573059,
0.06282231211662292,
-0.35308945178985596,
-0.4751288890838623,
0.3896616995334625,
0.40909403562545776,
-0.20839565992355347,
-0.0030849131289869547,
-0.4115360379219055,
-0.5262206792831421,
-0.05166846886277199,
0.46101486682891846,
0.3848012387752533,
0.14302094280719757,
0.583782434463501,
0.3037336468696594,
-0.07842832803726196,
0.2784218192100525,
-0.023348264396190643,
0.13675379753112793,
0.3920276165008545,
-0.17432335019111633,
-0.27380236983299255,
0.6078848242759705,
0.41126513481140137,
-0.2652144432067871,
0.8243491053581238,
0.7366394996643066,
-0.46770867705345154,
-0.14110001921653748,
-0.7651529908180237,
-0.11176653951406479,
-0.39645448327064514,
0.38304609060287476,
-0.673456609249115,
-0.4775006175041199,
0.3308004140853882,
-0.3497425615787506,
0.016016842797398567,
0.5822904109954834,
0.05807853117585182,
-0.025322778150439262,
0.49164441227912903,
0.6047261357307434,
-0.44489285349845886,
0.858207106590271,
-0.320101797580719,
0.060397423803806305,
-0.9770277142524719,
-0.5660176873207092,
-0.7013340592384338,
0.49479857087135315,
-0.3381507992744446,
-0.11883517354726791,
0.38573452830314636,
0.35376912355422974,
0.26431167125701904,
0.5675807595252991,
-0.5237771272659302,
0.13916435837745667,
0.5702396631240845,
0.3677290976047516,
0.7521547079086304,
0.16653227806091309,
0.2268068492412567,
-0.0651131346821785,
-0.6860337853431702,
-0.14511039853096008,
1.1161950826644897,
0.19160819053649902,
0.765380322933197,
-0.073605015873909,
1.1473426818847656,
-0.14688299596309662,
0.3707294464111328,
-0.6849775314331055,
0.0928841382265091,
-0.2222062200307846,
-0.5840293169021606,
-0.40192902088165283,
-0.6784937381744385,
-1.0935816764831543,
0.3514332175254822,
-0.4028967022895813,
-0.9053269028663635,
0.25510117411613464,
-0.08562859892845154,
-0.14357389509677887,
0.14188864827156067,
-0.8130205869674683,
0.43833842873573303,
0.08385467529296875,
-0.4928749203681946,
-0.26409968733787537,
-0.92529296875,
0.5609875917434692,
-0.479729026556015,
0.3861045837402344,
0.07069944590330124,
0.14500927925109863,
0.7928360104560852,
-0.7165541648864746,
0.5085623264312744,
-0.12021057307720184,
-0.24891974031925201,
0.008269267156720161,
-0.41581016778945923,
0.5012305974960327,
0.1529223769903183,
-0.31754252314567566,
0.08904708921909332,
-0.22943642735481262,
-0.1266135573387146,
-0.5417059063911438,
0.7247872352600098,
-0.5499690771102905,
-0.26444366574287415,
-0.31441986560821533,
-0.8027126789093018,
-0.4141612946987152,
0.4377743899822235,
0.10622201859951019,
0.6148706078529358,
0.0010254327207803726,
0.10881257802248001,
0.42979130148887634,
0.11197451502084732,
0.579200267791748,
0.21145176887512207,
-0.02461983449757099,
-0.25461626052856445,
0.9048845767974854,
0.3006618618965149,
0.1883942037820816,
0.616862952709198,
-0.07010865211486816,
-0.5368198156356812,
-0.35846251249313354,
-0.16017401218414307,
0.16049371659755707,
-0.7823781967163086,
-0.19215302169322968,
-1.1353092193603516,
-0.2709023356437683,
-0.5692805647850037,
0.10396189987659454,
-0.282703697681427,
-0.4586571455001831,
-0.46721264719963074,
-0.09503819048404694,
0.32862600684165955,
0.559624969959259,
-0.15874288976192474,
0.4800751209259033,
-1.089787244796753,
0.7195115685462952,
0.262751966714859,
0.12022905051708221,
-0.011717366054654121,
-0.23175594210624695,
-0.4006495177745819,
-0.36132362484931946,
-0.14500059187412262,
-0.8689979314804077,
0.17253145575523376,
0.3672974109649658,
0.7102565765380859,
0.6423560380935669,
0.10668009519577026,
0.8901458978652954,
-0.11622283607721329,
0.3304073214530945,
0.21137858927249908,
-0.5147022008895874,
0.6083622574806213,
-0.6323317885398865,
0.1597219556570053,
0.7736081480979919,
0.374544620513916,
0.08159379661083221,
-0.8429970741271973,
-0.7855622172355652,
-0.9901111125946045,
1.0348718166351318,
0.20150922238826752,
-0.10408356785774231,
0.2169806808233261,
0.4090310037136078,
0.11266692727804184,
0.16296809911727905,
-0.4683583974838257,
-0.24341286718845367,
-0.012037794105708599,
0.17714755237102509,
0.07791269570589066,
-0.2346593588590622,
0.04067308455705643,
-0.22711025178432465,
0.614278256893158,
0.2244088500738144,
0.05814793333411217,
0.19003447890281677,
-0.18427971005439758,
-0.07849127054214478,
0.1536872386932373,
-0.15179790556430817,
0.687367856502533,
-0.5693063139915466,
0.09951777756214142,
0.12717987596988678,
-0.3248296082019806,
-0.13031908869743347,
0.7517244219779968,
-0.03209115192294121,
0.12822642922401428,
0.7005681991577148,
0.2565767168998718,
0.11646636575460434,
0.1514396071434021,
0.577715277671814,
0.06427378952503204,
-0.16539880633354187,
-0.14910054206848145,
0.03642776980996132,
0.393656849861145,
0.19326525926589966,
0.4950389564037323,
0.15949717164039612,
0.22208501398563385,
-0.44658929109573364,
0.3943807780742645,
0.30417400598526,
-0.22424083948135376,
0.34044671058654785,
0.8554398417472839,
0.1651715189218521,
0.050246819853782654,
0.7627975344657898,
-0.04914288595318794,
-0.037076644599437714,
0.41605478525161743,
0.277940571308136,
0.35827890038490295,
-0.10767650604248047,
0.016650207340717316,
0.5926024317741394,
0.13805586099624634,
-0.20864279568195343,
-0.22722911834716797,
-0.35503217577934265,
-0.36379745602607727,
-0.682327926158905,
-0.4823441505432129,
-0.3733518719673157,
-0.006278045941144228,
-0.9625465273857117,
0.1931830793619156,
-0.12862074375152588,
-0.14847992360591888,
0.3317680060863495,
-0.09088486433029175,
-0.38584527373313904,
0.23431985080242157,
-0.10438399016857147,
0.7104945182800293,
-0.6458215117454529,
1.1770113706588745,
0.3151848316192627,
-0.6844927668571472,
-0.8060444593429565,
0.1329006850719452,
-0.352840393781662,
-0.2757442891597748,
0.5773617625236511,
0.28644469380378723,
-0.2901584506034851,
-0.12752045691013336,
-0.26373448967933655,
-0.5284290909767151,
0.9889751672744751,
0.38068097829818726,
-0.6200183629989624,
-0.16884064674377441,
-0.20885075628757477,
0.553268551826477,
-0.22619011998176575,
0.35723206400871277,
0.3640085458755493,
0.41543591022491455,
-0.035472508519887924,
-0.5569220781326294,
-0.010371270589530468,
-0.33618512749671936,
-0.25900667905807495,
0.381408154964447,
-0.7640124559402466,
0.6360018253326416,
0.05823105201125145,
-0.12379410117864609,
-0.10381186008453369,
0.7137472629547119,
-0.0138414166867733,
0.4183639585971832,
0.5243909955024719,
0.35180941224098206,
0.7147228717803955,
-0.12216434627771378,
0.972798764705658,
-0.42599815130233765,
0.4542762339115143,
1.4656226634979248,
-0.10052944719791412,
0.4916553795337677,
0.5226773023605347,
-0.11341486126184464,
0.17925278842449188,
0.5669892430305481,
-0.14531174302101135,
0.6135921478271484,
-0.3178607225418091,
-0.26679107546806335,
-0.2898448407649994,
-0.3160792589187622,
-0.5438376069068909,
0.24082890152931213,
0.30485132336616516,
-0.5141854882240295,
-0.46847060322761536,
-0.327129989862442,
0.18223926424980164,
0.013726984150707722,
-0.19400696456432343,
0.8968749046325684,
0.22713887691497803,
-0.7049364447593689,
0.20033656060695648,
-0.19328530132770538,
0.434542715549469,
-0.7568003535270691,
-0.16874107718467712,
-0.1025012880563736,
0.12569592893123627,
-0.3747265338897705,
-0.3157028257846832,
0.31882742047309875,
-0.12528419494628906,
-0.19735513627529144,
-0.3652186989784241,
0.9558358788490295,
-0.7928169965744019,
-0.4747660756111145,
0.6293169260025024,
0.9462646245956421,
0.2036079615354538,
-0.3171217143535614,
-0.2694924473762512,
-0.4971802532672882,
-0.34566500782966614,
-0.2604575753211975,
0.4301331341266632,
0.6137996315956116,
0.17258954048156738,
0.45185884833335876,
0.874653697013855,
0.28220027685165405,
0.07223594188690186,
0.3448472023010254,
1.3144574165344238,
-0.3826848864555359,
-0.27175167202949524,
-0.7897791266441345,
0.1974775791168213,
-0.6916635036468506,
-0.30116990208625793,
0.8943644762039185,
0.6791256070137024,
0.691450297832489,
-0.0788184255361557,
0.8762044310569763,
-0.12105106562376022,
0.43340110778808594,
-0.42543739080429077,
0.6600672006607056,
-0.46549874544143677,
0.3018334209918976,
-0.7228772640228271,
-1.0739178657531738,
-0.5392763614654541,
0.43893352150917053,
-0.31296736001968384,
-0.025104114785790443,
0.9243134260177612,
0.8639464378356934,
-0.3485212028026581,
-0.13407859206199646,
0.16911864280700684,
-0.0600656196475029,
0.20051494240760803,
0.44219475984573364,
0.9433026909828186,
-0.26952773332595825,
0.9107576012611389,
-0.8323884010314941,
-0.19547566771507263,
0.03886420279741287,
-0.8038853406906128,
-1.1064825057983398,
-0.43471789360046387,
-0.27889856696128845,
-0.14503923058509827,
0.1197226420044899,
0.5141154527664185,
0.9232244491577148,
-0.4004300832748413,
0.2306259125471115,
-0.028265895321965218,
0.10999234765768051,
-0.30753809213638306,
-0.24665045738220215,
0.7147147059440613,
-0.5343090295791626,
-1.0211036205291748,
0.6163079142570496,
0.15797460079193115,
-0.2792150378227234,
-0.003957304172217846,
0.13949626684188843,
-0.5658976435661316,
-0.5784249901771545,
0.5759142637252808,
-0.2611103653907776,
-0.22816507518291473,
0.02644089050590992,
-0.39498651027679443,
-0.30596044659614563,
0.11967983096837997,
0.5158328413963318,
-0.26297566294670105,
0.5475205779075623,
0.44430452585220337,
0.3368334472179413,
0.909313976764679,
0.5617213845252991,
0.36831963062286377,
-0.9815679788589478,
0.09798198193311691,
-0.1897173523902893,
0.3383713662624359,
0.3155311942100525,
-0.7604947686195374,
0.8836818337440491,
0.18447980284690857,
-0.3317387104034424,
-0.3570736050605774,
-0.045652348548173904,
-1.2695286273956299,
-0.26472631096839905,
1.2425271272659302,
-0.5654632449150085,
0.16363845765590668,
-0.3585662543773651,
-0.3480723798274994,
0.6639925837516785,
-0.8268020749092102,
0.8318681716918945,
0.6465713977813721,
-0.28344014286994934,
-0.2582816183567047,
-0.6764400005340576,
0.3122578561306,
0.21222852170467377,
-1.0654057264328003,
0.054613228887319565,
0.6945585608482361,
0.0694417655467987,
0.42002809047698975,
0.7251580357551575,
-0.18787874281406403,
0.0013676745584234595,
0.2571520209312439,
-0.2229924499988556,
-0.3806084096431732,
-0.42278361320495605,
-0.08884851634502411,
0.6352940201759338,
0.09452585875988007,
-0.3586938679218292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01009v1 | DynaThink: Fast or Slow? A Dynamic Decision-Making Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T06:45:13 | 2024-07-01T06:45:13 | Jiabao Pan, Yan Zhang, Chen Zhang, Zuozhu Liu, Hongwei Wang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated emergent capabilities across
diverse reasoning tasks via popular Chains-of-Thought (COT) prompting. However,
such a simple and fast COT approach often encounters limitations in dealing
with complicated problems, while a thorough method, which considers multiple
reasoning pathways and verifies each step carefully, results in slower
inference. This paper addresses the challenge of enabling LLMs to autonomously
select between fast and slow inference methods, thereby optimizing both
efficiency and effectiveness. We introduce a dynamic decision-making framework
that categorizes tasks into two distinct pathways: 'Fast', designated for tasks
where the LLM quickly identifies a high-confidence solution, and 'Slow',
allocated for tasks that the LLM perceives as complex and for which it has low
confidence in immediate solutions as well as requiring more reasoning paths to
verify. Experiments on five popular reasoning benchmarks demonstrated the
superiority of the DynaThink over baselines. | [
-0.20708245038986206,
-1.2288388013839722,
1.1275593042373657,
0.4837779700756073,
-0.24996714293956757,
0.6449726223945618,
-0.456470787525177,
-0.1364818513393402,
0.03858603537082672,
0.01547830831259489,
-0.5817321538925171,
-0.11829832196235657,
-0.7389798760414124,
0.192796528339386,
-0.30709943175315857,
0.6050232648849487,
-0.3713291585445404,
-0.2116943895816803,
0.03142128139734268,
0.22540831565856934,
-0.2297663688659668,
-0.010431728325784206,
-0.7786287665367126,
-0.3840177357196808,
0.8691595196723938,
0.3778022229671478,
1.2828327417373657,
0.8438531160354614,
0.23837904632091522,
0.35430747270584106,
-0.4348995089530945,
0.13999882340431213,
-0.35971981287002563,
0.6890251636505127,
-0.2135017216205597,
-0.5676915049552917,
-0.36677390336990356,
-0.1672242283821106,
0.7584506869316101,
0.8454858064651489,
-0.1286591738462448,
0.25991564989089966,
-0.23705419898033142,
0.7898175716400146,
-0.8819103837013245,
0.09041539579629898,
-0.7516219019889832,
0.08414015918970108,
-0.2072918862104416,
-0.08475611358880997,
-0.20821794867515564,
-0.1772690862417221,
0.29199832677841187,
-0.35078805685043335,
-0.23788882791996002,
0.10879648476839066,
0.2826797068119049,
0.6282859444618225,
-0.6083856225013733,
-0.3347276747226715,
-1.1213432550430298,
0.5769674181938171,
-0.39807242155075073,
0.44619664549827576,
0.018110480159521103,
0.32349830865859985,
-0.4335758090019226,
-0.8465613126754761,
-0.6300613284111023,
-0.3468324542045593,
0.14727559685707092,
-0.3633125424385071,
-0.027003685012459755,
0.02728184498846531,
0.42195239663124084,
0.16012491285800934,
-0.4215072691440582,
0.3213450312614441,
-0.03135349228978157,
-0.11634641140699387,
0.5443388223648071,
0.38772130012512207,
-0.2149428278207779,
0.05485501512885094,
-0.30109208822250366,
0.1633215993642807,
-0.4938005208969116,
-0.13870249688625336,
0.4748508036136627,
0.3536624610424042,
-0.03658528998494148,
0.3651675879955292,
-0.36557722091674805,
0.80975341796875,
0.45382729172706604,
-0.477781742811203,
-0.008437073789536953,
-0.1390688568353653,
-0.1786605566740036,
0.16461801528930664,
0.6532149314880371,
-0.2744635045528412,
0.07823418080806732,
-0.08471383899450302,
-0.342016339302063,
0.10767833143472672,
-0.19252246618270874,
-0.7886243462562561,
-0.31171464920043945,
0.6726582050323486,
-0.25974830985069275,
-0.2212369441986084,
-0.48694685101509094,
-0.7171919345855713,
-0.5487866401672363,
-0.5351424813270569,
0.25746458768844604,
-0.034933388233184814,
-0.4929828941822052,
0.23558396100997925,
0.03216682747006416,
-0.36396610736846924,
0.5544908046722412,
-0.7279341220855713,
0.14644655585289001,
0.4404640793800354,
0.8600122928619385,
-0.3205113708972931,
-0.22437870502471924,
-0.5891865491867065,
0.0959850326180458,
-0.4734655022621155,
0.9440228343009949,
-0.7265896201133728,
-0.29793110489845276,
-0.23206520080566406,
-0.14647430181503296,
-0.14438287913799286,
-0.32695674896240234,
0.32216593623161316,
-0.4809509813785553,
-0.173005610704422,
-0.22984880208969116,
-0.43399301171302795,
0.05820388346910477,
0.3526480197906494,
-0.8444790840148926,
0.9941297769546509,
-0.045500338077545166,
-1.0395580530166626,
0.44490793347358704,
-0.2459080070257187,
-0.41899242997169495,
0.1692495048046112,
-0.37123268842697144,
-0.04885806143283844,
-0.07129140943288803,
-0.18658703565597534,
0.5063552856445312,
-0.44873422384262085,
0.771693766117096,
-0.593383252620697,
-0.48192036151885986,
0.31377190351486206,
-0.7150267958641052,
0.7842210531234741,
0.4227156639099121,
-0.635300874710083,
0.3127893805503845,
-0.8893393278121948,
0.09720417112112045,
0.2528577744960785,
-0.6159384250640869,
-0.21070092916488647,
0.43016117811203003,
-0.3600565791130066,
0.264700323343277,
0.20349247753620148,
-0.16329891979694366,
0.501001238822937,
-0.15874862670898438,
0.5880440473556519,
0.8702685832977295,
-0.21482166647911072,
0.35795724391937256,
-0.027009544894099236,
0.5970779061317444,
-0.022605665028095245,
0.06276372075080872,
0.2604576051235199,
-0.26954326033592224,
-0.759806752204895,
-0.4791226387023926,
0.4458952248096466,
0.7346823811531067,
-0.9908128380775452,
0.1526746153831482,
-0.03509300574660301,
-0.5795074105262756,
-0.4382399320602417,
-0.023388544097542763,
0.25500237941741943,
0.1537356972694397,
0.062349673360586166,
0.21451720595359802,
-0.22567197680473328,
-0.6813239455223083,
-0.3898889720439911,
-0.38395994901657104,
0.2659134268760681,
0.12245041131973267,
0.7268296480178833,
-0.22832491993904114,
0.5651078820228577,
-0.6557058691978455,
0.3616136312484741,
-0.453072726726532,
0.19007767736911774,
0.2165631800889969,
0.07783930748701096,
0.30739086866378784,
-0.9332670569419861,
-0.4040878415107727,
-0.511987566947937,
-0.3357209265232086,
0.14395712316036224,
-0.13923481106758118,
-0.17802146077156067,
0.09964361041784286,
0.5524299740791321,
-0.9236796498298645,
0.36931949853897095,
0.2970832884311676,
-0.42399948835372925,
0.7759047746658325,
-0.2600522041320801,
0.07615689188241959,
-0.6830366849899292,
-0.007527867332100868,
-0.3193085193634033,
-0.06384821981191635,
-0.3254365622997284,
-0.07338514924049377,
-0.1016387790441513,
0.18409155309200287,
-0.49586403369903564,
0.7498291730880737,
-0.5305715799331665,
0.0568891242146492,
-0.1769563853740692,
0.31342414021492004,
-0.08673424273729324,
0.49637317657470703,
-0.07485448569059372,
0.6844516396522522,
0.6956213712692261,
-0.8224566578865051,
0.5344144701957703,
0.15042588114738464,
-0.5189374089241028,
0.0360470674932003,
-0.5110427737236023,
0.23190170526504517,
-0.1830444186925888,
0.7396008968353271,
-0.8884833455085754,
-0.18258419632911682,
0.1102604791522026,
0.21412187814712524,
0.2533225417137146,
-0.16315749287605286,
-0.7983595728874207,
-0.7348531484603882,
-0.08208171278238297,
0.6485900282859802,
0.2110561728477478,
-0.33797159790992737,
0.6478704214096069,
0.24019847810268402,
-0.16183188557624817,
-0.7484297752380371,
-0.497615784406662,
-0.10179954022169113,
-0.2767735719680786,
-0.313709557056427,
0.4925193786621094,
-0.2138310968875885,
-0.8975507020950317,
-0.13415642082691193,
-0.27707618474960327,
-0.11472543329000473,
0.38451823592185974,
0.0069907414726912975,
0.06206166744232178,
0.13624925911426544,
0.32698342204093933,
0.14725948870182037,
-0.1511056125164032,
-0.11070502549409866,
-0.2177669107913971,
0.3474787771701813,
-0.01131310686469078,
-0.16155917942523956,
-0.29836586117744446,
0.3301328122615814,
1.01413094997406,
-0.31348612904548645,
0.5229495167732239,
0.44373491406440735,
-0.12078926712274551,
-0.6251068115234375,
-0.3583708107471466,
-0.2585478723049164,
-0.4482758045196533,
0.16298772394657135,
-0.5106683373451233,
-0.877971351146698,
0.4297710657119751,
-0.485530287027359,
0.10420078784227371,
0.19251714646816254,
1.102235198020935,
0.2988071143627167,
1.2388465404510498,
0.5273585915565491,
0.2883449196815491,
0.35377195477485657,
-0.09751739352941513,
0.6255428194999695,
-0.4225958585739136,
-0.16632841527462006,
-0.5435742139816284,
-0.37504464387893677,
-0.839057445526123,
-0.6483055949211121,
0.31514427065849304,
0.04784812033176422,
-0.3422800898551941,
-0.04449710622429848,
-0.2682972252368927,
0.266062468290329,
0.1568024754524231,
0.06683271378278732,
0.3960694670677185,
-0.48287123441696167,
-0.5583779215812683,
0.46964117884635925,
-0.9551175832748413,
-0.5005857944488525,
0.8536005616188049,
0.26605191826820374,
0.7983916997909546,
0.12522649765014648,
0.4428114593029022,
0.13154567778110504,
-0.041194792836904526,
-1.041725993156433,
0.8029798269271851,
-0.03599441424012184,
-0.9155245423316956,
-0.25276198983192444,
-0.43559592962265015,
-0.8705048561096191,
0.357949435710907,
-0.3986632525920868,
-0.5242366194725037,
0.08292588591575623,
0.4094381034374237,
-0.6915468573570251,
0.5308998227119446,
-0.3600028455257416,
0.6562215685844421,
-0.4032632112503052,
-0.8141932487487793,
-0.44756019115448,
-0.7508323788642883,
0.3749704658985138,
-0.1123504638671875,
0.31229397654533386,
-0.641987681388855,
-0.13041788339614868,
0.6567071676254272,
-0.14023469388484955,
0.5739138126373291,
-0.05613377317786217,
-0.2460838407278061,
0.5097229480743408,
0.538536012172699,
0.6998866200447083,
0.10964624583721161,
-0.3039781451225281,
-0.3086710274219513,
0.05195404589176178,
-0.15037810802459717,
-0.6720216870307922,
0.6755450367927551,
-0.26601698994636536,
-0.9116148352622986,
-0.48154377937316895,
-0.6831821799278259,
-0.4840414226055145,
0.13054293394088745,
-0.06173061579465866,
0.49590003490448,
-0.11282610893249512,
-0.07919161766767502,
0.6357123255729675,
0.050716333091259,
0.49965202808380127,
0.6368905901908875,
-0.14753803610801697,
0.02147531881928444,
0.44679170846939087,
0.3579016327857971,
0.4918075501918793,
0.19058650732040405,
0.3924364745616913,
-0.39787840843200684,
-0.6160023212432861,
-0.41932031512260437,
0.1788741648197174,
-0.8107768893241882,
0.15572941303253174,
-0.6197219491004944,
0.10842292755842209,
-0.011298815719783306,
0.04637905955314636,
-0.5742876529693604,
-0.4897193908691406,
-0.014838889241218567,
-0.11960754543542862,
0.38955801725387573,
0.5984689593315125,
0.13189385831356049,
-0.05416454002261162,
-0.5617035627365112,
0.31717658042907715,
0.3348976671695709,
0.3622240722179413,
0.25206854939460754,
-0.2668101191520691,
-0.20468656718730927,
-0.1995590627193451,
-0.32367268204689026,
-0.69207763671875,
0.060581572353839874,
-0.24443596601486206,
0.5528944730758667,
0.23755942285060883,
0.25055572390556335,
0.7138388156890869,
-0.8347726464271545,
0.5764608383178711,
-0.02237614430487156,
-0.7077357172966003,
0.49414920806884766,
-0.24608176946640015,
0.3473873436450958,
0.6258865594863892,
0.6969975829124451,
-0.012795079499483109,
-0.3978804349899292,
-0.585390567779541,
-0.9910591244697571,
-0.06966621428728104,
0.20070865750312805,
-0.3516409397125244,
-0.22436462342739105,
0.3220943212509155,
0.30131179094314575,
0.4882276654243469,
-0.06259509921073914,
-0.30722901225090027,
0.45000436902046204,
0.03925371542572975,
0.04084136709570885,
-0.09120699763298035,
-0.07955747097730637,
-0.5928423404693604,
0.31714218854904175,
-0.34433621168136597,
0.1829550862312317,
0.17056486010551453,
0.028971418738365173,
-0.2588028311729431,
0.43855026364326477,
0.3850577175617218,
1.0811415910720825,
-0.08499442040920258,
0.27956724166870117,
-0.00948311761021614,
-0.18817991018295288,
0.43208083510398865,
-0.003114272840321064,
0.08591683954000473,
-0.020127296447753906,
0.39695268869400024,
1.0192452669143677,
0.3835241496562958,
-0.6865306496620178,
0.20753686130046844,
-0.019412361085414886,
-0.20613567531108856,
-0.15409840643405914,
0.2326633483171463,
0.06822394579648972,
0.6745525002479553,
0.11322247236967087,
0.08025338500738144,
0.0035185194574296474,
-0.822716474533081,
-0.08133964985609055,
0.24114124476909637,
-0.03044329397380352,
-0.3303717076778412,
0.6627832055091858,
0.3885094225406647,
-0.38658493757247925,
0.4912516474723816,
-0.22487878799438477,
-0.5267426371574402,
0.5679436922073364,
0.19895708560943604,
1.0590213537216187,
-0.07099739462137222,
0.13756468892097473,
0.08028846234083176,
-0.10871681571006775,
-0.46440812945365906,
0.5115513801574707,
-0.13687865436077118,
-0.6356214284896851,
-0.7071207165718079,
-0.633250892162323,
-0.5143923759460449,
0.026545586064457893,
-0.3869835436344147,
0.3325047492980957,
-0.47809869050979614,
-0.446562260389328,
0.09535044431686401,
0.21718436479568481,
-0.7204460501670837,
0.18654069304466248,
0.2569582164287567,
1.071459174156189,
-0.6415463089942932,
0.9246644377708435,
0.4137074053287506,
0.019880099222064018,
-0.9926733374595642,
0.45093095302581787,
0.3249395489692688,
-0.5606206655502319,
0.8187919855117798,
-0.06330938637256622,
-0.55206698179245,
-0.013344845734536648,
-0.42322343587875366,
-1.031052589416504,
1.214247465133667,
0.501527726650238,
-1.0762901306152344,
-0.19440507888793945,
-0.6028805375099182,
0.2508426308631897,
-0.33775442838668823,
0.16137711703777313,
0.9222255945205688,
0.6860213875770569,
0.2307697832584381,
-1.2290385961532593,
0.23964199423789978,
0.1927243173122406,
-0.235361710190773,
0.4091396629810333,
-0.9098601937294006,
1.0422841310501099,
-0.792704164981842,
-0.19449375569820404,
0.040327005088329315,
0.3950549364089966,
0.4711834192276001,
0.2096368372440338,
0.9141353964805603,
0.334719717502594,
1.0251270532608032,
0.08413179218769073,
0.9612532258033752,
-0.4135511815547943,
0.13055627048015594,
1.0428153276443481,
-0.6421796083450317,
0.9416927695274353,
0.6567488312721252,
-0.21920819580554962,
0.84574294090271,
0.9174960255622864,
0.3589327335357666,
0.467263400554657,
0.5853893160820007,
-0.23774266242980957,
-0.5939326882362366,
0.051703859120607376,
-0.01128992810845375,
0.6272568106651306,
0.38696539402008057,
-0.01938323862850666,
-0.06889564543962479,
-0.18435333669185638,
0.4579486548900604,
-0.09579359740018845,
-0.31960490345954895,
0.4136904776096344,
0.037753812968730927,
-0.8942903280258179,
0.687878429889679,
-0.1714540421962738,
0.2935841381549835,
-0.6141254305839539,
0.04749924689531326,
0.17893190681934357,
0.3256090581417084,
-0.08519208431243896,
-0.9827821850776672,
0.12599067389965057,
-0.05662982165813446,
-0.213458850979805,
-0.39440596103668213,
0.5475456118583679,
-0.3862842917442322,
-0.4245842695236206,
0.4827258884906769,
0.8589362502098083,
-0.04714840278029442,
0.1602403223514557,
-0.9670483469963074,
0.40998733043670654,
-0.23836079239845276,
-0.675661027431488,
0.12360581755638123,
0.7324641346931458,
-0.25965845584869385,
1.0761737823486328,
0.4688558578491211,
0.2574657201766968,
-0.3484271466732025,
0.06614743918180466,
0.9796509742736816,
-0.709526777267456,
-0.626091718673706,
-1.0235790014266968,
0.44647645950317383,
0.11966139078140259,
-0.3865724503993988,
0.47925734519958496,
0.16086497902870178,
0.4766041040420532,
0.2508726418018341,
0.620855450630188,
-0.16204915940761566,
0.30460304021835327,
-0.77473384141922,
0.42436158657073975,
-0.4786529541015625,
0.40591344237327576,
-0.04920383542776108,
-0.838810384273529,
-0.06672973185777664,
0.43717527389526367,
-0.43397122621536255,
0.028040627017617226,
1.19363272190094,
0.5388558506965637,
0.15365546941757202,
-0.12008149176836014,
-0.022183623164892197,
0.66425621509552,
0.2571888267993927,
0.6142956018447876,
0.9031032919883728,
0.2564927935600281,
0.3451089859008789,
-0.07125555723905563,
-0.3231183588504791,
-0.12631751596927643,
-1.2472325563430786,
-0.8873794674873352,
-0.4373649060726166,
-0.5660451650619507,
-0.29653772711753845,
-0.006078479345887899,
1.1691479682922363,
0.594651997089386,
-0.2816821038722992,
-0.2266358882188797,
-0.09580884128808975,
0.4215395450592041,
-0.28117257356643677,
-0.18208327889442444,
0.34177523851394653,
-0.15175817906856537,
-0.5392186641693115,
0.6246955394744873,
0.4008542001247406,
0.035567693412303925,
-0.6247122287750244,
0.09317103028297424,
-0.41977548599243164,
0.4668138325214386,
0.571536123752594,
-0.03160225972533226,
-0.9172976613044739,
-0.20113897323608398,
-0.19758524000644684,
-0.04458203539252281,
-0.20340614020824432,
1.191151738166809,
-0.9815577864646912,
0.3758995831012726,
0.7137951850891113,
0.3605717718601227,
0.42253169417381287,
-0.43708258867263794,
0.5283499360084534,
-0.0784928947687149,
0.549168586730957,
0.45591863989830017,
0.3272576630115509,
0.16892167925834656,
-0.21373604238033295,
0.252532958984375,
0.42334040999412537,
-0.5667325854301453,
-1.0856246948242188,
0.614198625087738,
-0.7514738440513611,
-0.7375322580337524,
1.2719297409057617,
-0.12895044684410095,
-0.3544573485851288,
-0.23846253752708435,
-0.08706439286470413,
0.1534111499786377,
-0.19897712767124176,
0.6896878480911255,
0.5573281645774841,
-0.3335750699043274,
0.24965056777000427,
-0.6477825045585632,
0.8083807229995728,
0.2173088937997818,
-0.45881736278533936,
0.3971545994281769,
0.19072893261909485,
0.30579322576522827,
-0.026314450427889824,
0.682869553565979,
0.2758573591709137,
0.0311601459980011,
0.07048287987709045,
-0.6689386963844299,
0.07782020419836044,
-0.8001200556755066,
0.08977434039115906,
0.21237246692180634,
0.2519954442977905,
0.2513228952884674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00997v1 | Engineering Conversational Search Systems: A Review of Applications, Architectures, and Functional Components | 2024-07-01T06:24:11 | 2024-07-01T06:24:11 | Phillip Schneider, Wessel Poelman, Michael Rovatsos, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational search systems enable information retrieval via natural
language interactions, with the goal of maximizing users' information gain over
multiple dialogue turns. The increasing prevalence of conversational interfaces
adopting this search paradigm challenges traditional information retrieval
approaches, stressing the importance of better understanding the engineering
process of developing these systems. We undertook a systematic literature
review to investigate the links between theoretical studies and technical
implementations of conversational search systems. Our review identifies
real-world application scenarios, system architectures, and functional
components. We consolidate our results by presenting a layered architecture
framework and explaining the core functions of conversational search systems.
Furthermore, we reflect on our findings in light of the rapid progress in large
language models, discussing their capabilities, limitations, and directions for
future research. | [
-0.5160203576087952,
-0.8181638717651367,
0.7196557521820068,
0.45101895928382874,
0.2940760850906372,
0.280009388923645,
0.21296848356723785,
-0.6614514589309692,
0.32666778564453125,
0.5377049446105957,
-0.2965560257434845,
-0.14745765924453735,
-0.018819659948349,
-0.21470654010772705,
-0.593634307384491,
0.2129887491464615,
0.11297690123319626,
-0.06601227074861526,
0.005039083771407604,
0.19517368078231812,
-0.572778046131134,
-0.7313434481620789,
-0.6696340441703796,
-0.3491402864456177,
0.27716222405433655,
0.3750394284725189,
0.9726946949958801,
0.14112937450408936,
0.6105806827545166,
0.30622637271881104,
-0.38155320286750793,
-0.12876713275909424,
-0.35341519117355347,
0.6740994453430176,
0.20151689648628235,
-0.4015296697616577,
-0.06469224393367767,
-0.25192955136299133,
0.34713244438171387,
0.8998799324035645,
-0.377693235874176,
-0.30010998249053955,
0.029002053663134575,
0.6429117321968079,
-0.6535549163818359,
0.390811026096344,
-0.42342525720596313,
0.29210615158081055,
-0.14898116886615753,
-0.5019561052322388,
-0.5748850107192993,
-0.5919731855392456,
0.6336631774902344,
-0.438949853181839,
0.056671034544706345,
0.2884264588356018,
0.5342655777931213,
-0.38743874430656433,
-0.46761760115623474,
-0.6329622268676758,
-0.9088576436042786,
0.6493254899978638,
-0.6512231826782227,
0.6645951867103577,
0.2743809223175049,
0.3783273994922638,
-0.34552106261253357,
-0.4955075979232788,
-0.2544775605201721,
-0.6432037949562073,
-0.25683364272117615,
-0.0698484256863594,
-0.02852664142847061,
0.3739306628704071,
0.033926259726285934,
0.6016281843185425,
-0.7424126863479614,
-0.16068816184997559,
-0.4763753414154053,
-0.059165775775909424,
0.4159190058708191,
0.2662821114063263,
0.5856005549430847,
-0.057330984622240067,
-0.2139056921005249,
0.03360971808433533,
-0.6698907613754272,
-0.0009452950907871127,
0.2457103580236435,
0.29781171679496765,
0.2903798222541809,
0.6295929551124573,
-0.6239016056060791,
0.5854236483573914,
-0.2860954999923706,
0.15802520513534546,
0.09110593050718307,
-0.5037418007850647,
-0.1410764455795288,
0.17668482661247253,
0.4480646252632141,
0.1630222052335739,
-0.09579350054264069,
-0.2999865710735321,
-0.4066741168498993,
-0.014360953122377396,
0.5604252219200134,
-0.6217126846313477,
0.0446617417037487,
0.16933833062648773,
-0.6348968148231506,
-0.4521275460720062,
0.06957317888736725,
-0.5154911875724792,
-0.2048729956150055,
-0.3245292901992798,
0.24849358201026917,
-0.3194558024406433,
-0.16815844178199768,
0.41281914710998535,
-0.46957582235336304,
0.35435107350349426,
0.07733073085546494,
-0.7439616918563843,
0.688322901725769,
0.6768828630447388,
0.6810024380683899,
0.24202999472618103,
0.19470106065273285,
-0.16536277532577515,
-0.16211482882499695,
-0.2987929880619049,
0.6804943084716797,
-0.9212355017662048,
-0.8793472051620483,
0.5908339023590088,
-0.2783028483390808,
0.005623851902782917,
-0.735955536365509,
0.698244571685791,
-1.2043174505233765,
0.20675040781497955,
-0.3236471712589264,
-0.23861798644065857,
-0.29624617099761963,
0.186050146818161,
-0.6708754301071167,
0.996979832649231,
-0.2250223308801651,
-0.4654746353626251,
-0.16943515837192535,
-0.9521515965461731,
-0.6606863141059875,
0.20938782393932343,
-0.19711491465568542,
0.18046565353870392,
0.2488039880990982,
-0.09498372673988342,
0.16119740903377533,
-0.4165003001689911,
0.16875454783439636,
-0.17033372819423676,
-0.5897892713546753,
0.35344985127449036,
0.1291470229625702,
0.5193575024604797,
0.43828898668289185,
-0.3377178907394409,
-0.24036337435245514,
-0.3820052742958069,
0.15110822021961212,
0.18439322710037231,
-0.46142637729644775,
-0.45112401247024536,
0.4786440134048462,
0.24531453847885132,
-0.12169605493545532,
0.34484222531318665,
-0.5598694086074829,
0.0988052636384964,
-0.5054185390472412,
0.5628904700279236,
0.28246861696243286,
-0.1569233238697052,
0.6189443469047546,
-0.24395576119422913,
0.34225618839263916,
-0.0005279624019749463,
0.2855072021484375,
-0.632171630859375,
-0.41703447699546814,
-0.7806805372238159,
0.27929970622062683,
0.07326629757881165,
0.5696233510971069,
-0.8066319823265076,
0.4179648756980896,
0.007664558943361044,
-0.4673067331314087,
-0.28945815563201904,
-0.15570507943630219,
0.32096734642982483,
0.3582797646522522,
0.11011046916246414,
-0.6786001920700073,
-0.6289873719215393,
-1.050696611404419,
-0.04849179461598396,
-0.48151493072509766,
-0.14463242888450623,
0.6647196412086487,
0.002541839610785246,
-0.27516961097717285,
0.8530179262161255,
-0.601625919342041,
-0.08488583564758301,
-0.09365496784448624,
0.32106083631515503,
0.22993561625480652,
0.2578875422477722,
0.5589231848716736,
-1.0955349206924438,
-0.12204670161008835,
0.2250811755657196,
-0.747569739818573,
-0.030224362388253212,
0.29712894558906555,
0.06980226188898087,
-0.1556462198495865,
0.4229884743690491,
-0.7034426927566528,
0.48112180829048157,
0.14111125469207764,
0.08407247066497803,
0.4112292528152466,
0.08385880291461945,
0.4585120677947998,
-0.3566625714302063,
0.43319210410118103,
0.035947032272815704,
0.11654781550168991,
-0.8164097666740417,
0.5465553998947144,
-0.0866686999797821,
-0.5101816654205322,
-0.06335078179836273,
0.3961804211139679,
-0.4374813437461853,
-0.16284506022930145,
-0.38369688391685486,
0.2933405935764313,
0.05024188384413719,
0.23170769214630127,
-0.07098425179719925,
0.7621738910675049,
0.2657478451728821,
-0.9700523018836975,
0.23592332005500793,
0.39154019951820374,
-0.4125073552131653,
0.5828108191490173,
-0.7447199821472168,
0.0908932089805603,
-0.06327871233224869,
0.2155638486146927,
-0.9840440154075623,
-0.16588369011878967,
-0.21713441610336304,
-0.3629462420940399,
-0.04797322675585747,
0.04427579790353775,
-0.49946129322052,
-0.477266401052475,
-0.2746110260486603,
0.5010666847229004,
0.2246377021074295,
-0.3185068368911743,
0.4723459780216217,
0.7861424088478088,
-0.7237265110015869,
-0.24559389054775238,
-0.36565274000167847,
0.5035830736160278,
0.257452130317688,
-0.7993155121803284,
0.44222602248191833,
-0.18039175868034363,
-0.38055744767189026,
-0.2664256989955902,
-0.14392104744911194,
-0.4349985420703888,
0.26526468992233276,
-0.09248793125152588,
0.3743784427642822,
-0.36093348264694214,
0.2609791159629822,
-0.3302571475505829,
0.07855720072984695,
0.06339198350906372,
-0.1477193981409073,
0.7464451789855957,
-0.12717194855213165,
-0.4578837454319,
-0.3567725419998169,
0.5718225836753845,
0.5508500933647156,
-0.27334561944007874,
0.25887811183929443,
0.07464195787906647,
-0.2779366970062256,
0.32227572798728943,
-0.963262677192688,
-0.3153045177459717,
-0.5401003360748291,
0.3744443953037262,
-0.4140724837779999,
-0.9328567385673523,
0.5734924674034119,
0.03062855638563633,
0.05050833150744438,
0.17916932702064514,
0.12535063922405243,
-0.3323575556278229,
1.277587890625,
0.7363824248313904,
-0.06643351912498474,
0.8114902973175049,
0.08371171355247498,
0.7413219213485718,
-0.7680174708366394,
-0.3819514214992523,
-0.9994399547576904,
-0.35634198784828186,
-0.6520681381225586,
0.08335785567760468,
0.5700967311859131,
-0.2938489019870758,
0.005370856262743473,
0.27100738883018494,
-0.5926817655563354,
0.1910117119550705,
0.673170268535614,
0.12450456619262695,
0.31860417127609253,
-0.07574713230133057,
-0.29233068227767944,
-0.08093377202749252,
-0.4004068374633789,
-0.4332948923110962,
0.6069300770759583,
0.28440144658088684,
1.094760775566101,
0.046463653445243835,
0.4410422146320343,
0.2050078809261322,
-0.10781991481781006,
-0.9121086597442627,
0.6841377019882202,
0.18298393487930298,
-0.796393871307373,
-0.3010384738445282,
-0.2846392095088959,
-1.0529589653015137,
0.12613900005817413,
0.3088008165359497,
-0.681916356086731,
0.44024762511253357,
-0.17858216166496277,
-0.07740411907434464,
-0.09265109896659851,
-0.7378572821617126,
0.32865315675735474,
-0.4881063997745514,
-0.12868757545948029,
-0.4887770116329193,
-0.588574230670929,
0.262741357088089,
0.42559921741485596,
0.15965664386749268,
0.3992345333099365,
0.2688138782978058,
0.4939654767513275,
0.12006919831037521,
0.6320127844810486,
-0.07174104452133179,
0.05805502086877823,
0.23444625735282898,
0.3872980773448944,
0.30672308802604675,
-0.207795187830925,
-0.258699893951416,
-0.2842576205730438,
0.33115580677986145,
-0.3311021029949188,
-0.5663875341415405,
0.6448696851730347,
-0.19805952906608582,
-0.6864027976989746,
-0.23289845883846283,
-0.2806386947631836,
-0.19034159183502197,
0.3784998059272766,
-0.26221534609794617,
0.4742045998573303,
-0.6474356651306152,
0.5411486625671387,
0.8548519015312195,
0.010544138960540295,
0.26252102851867676,
0.321609228849411,
-0.4863514304161072,
0.08651383221149445,
0.6913460493087769,
-0.07143571227788925,
-0.07892804592847824,
0.6847431063652039,
-0.15427479147911072,
-0.09443528950214386,
-0.46027857065200806,
0.12842348217964172,
0.030917923897504807,
-0.5054178833961487,
0.20757825672626495,
-0.5761284232139587,
-0.5210424661636353,
-0.42874643206596375,
-0.09737670421600342,
-0.25611892342567444,
-0.2250940054655075,
-0.12720201909542084,
0.05948181822896004,
-0.32787203788757324,
1.0928912162780762,
0.5367981195449829,
0.3727215826511383,
-0.6920250654220581,
0.1379806399345398,
0.2427731305360794,
0.5311529040336609,
0.25173670053482056,
-0.10751191526651382,
-0.359544038772583,
0.07190846651792526,
-0.8074407577514648,
-0.7480081915855408,
0.16127106547355652,
-0.10122580081224442,
0.7898529767990112,
0.06602109968662262,
-0.03559137508273125,
0.4806812107563019,
-0.35863709449768066,
0.7940226793289185,
-0.0018401567358523607,
-0.5821388959884644,
0.6621080040931702,
-0.2875785231590271,
0.29927757382392883,
0.4824995696544647,
0.31176885962486267,
-0.9774073362350464,
0.09621348977088928,
-0.394652783870697,
-0.851213812828064,
0.6121537089347839,
0.3496074080467224,
0.21879762411117554,
0.15569722652435303,
0.18120619654655457,
-0.2648407816886902,
0.37227684259414673,
-0.3163575530052185,
-0.022349422797560692,
0.1440538763999939,
-0.008637383580207825,
0.39926180243492126,
-0.4165968596935272,
-0.288259357213974,
0.1993848979473114,
0.7144234776496887,
-0.18174777925014496,
0.5472312569618225,
0.39452552795410156,
-0.16880354285240173,
0.17220333218574524,
0.396339476108551,
0.5063564777374268,
0.45541197061538696,
-0.18706081807613373,
-0.06335867196321487,
-0.3350827395915985,
-0.3724772334098816,
-0.01339696440845728,
0.13177897036075592,
-0.27552279829978943,
0.15320436656475067,
-0.2168651521205902,
0.6472715735435486,
0.9144497513771057,
-0.7088432312011719,
0.33135947585105896,
-0.2592731714248657,
0.013821198605000973,
-0.19193190336227417,
0.035510603338479996,
0.1634744107723236,
0.2547309100627899,
0.7461993098258972,
-0.0509568490087986,
0.8301505446434021,
-0.8420102000236511,
0.05681711062788963,
0.8495270609855652,
-0.47342005372047424,
-0.48960641026496887,
0.18143339455127716,
0.43334612250328064,
-0.6255968809127808,
0.45935776829719543,
0.20674005150794983,
-0.5492508411407471,
0.3694993853569031,
0.2179216742515564,
1.0386788845062256,
-0.20048153400421143,
0.26040494441986084,
-0.0811968743801117,
0.3000182509422302,
-0.11190720647573471,
0.14629679918289185,
-0.35270416736602783,
-0.43198463320732117,
0.10001189261674881,
-0.5358009338378906,
-0.7914765477180481,
0.0260443314909935,
-0.3477846086025238,
0.21491877734661102,
-0.2576732039451599,
-0.27293309569358826,
0.1220209151506424,
-0.15474949777126312,
-0.6551337242126465,
-0.042834147810935974,
0.09370513260364532,
1.0003999471664429,
-0.16109047830104828,
0.17082780599594116,
0.6949976086616516,
-0.3668835759162903,
-0.22667019069194794,
-0.21645262837409973,
-0.05060188099741936,
-0.7147989273071289,
0.8665748238563538,
-0.0272133219987154,
-0.3310379683971405,
-0.2681187689304352,
-0.5194882750511169,
-0.8990422487258911,
0.9576655030250549,
0.09125284850597382,
-0.16804470121860504,
-0.6975200176239014,
0.0640774816274643,
0.5780940651893616,
-0.4855773150920868,
0.689164400100708,
0.47692397236824036,
0.28352639079093933,
0.2174389362335205,
-1.2969170808792114,
-0.25662776827812195,
-0.435958594083786,
0.3689330816268921,
-0.03694193810224533,
-0.6524361968040466,
0.3097798824310303,
0.351899117231369,
-0.48321062326431274,
0.4686557948589325,
0.23621653020381927,
0.13882221281528473,
0.35624274611473083,
0.12188264727592468,
0.18129828572273254,
0.36677947640419006,
-0.15387672185897827,
0.8929741382598877,
-0.4636175036430359,
0.10093983262777328,
0.6908150315284729,
-0.5128451585769653,
0.8827493786811829,
0.5398290753364563,
-0.2165420651435852,
0.3881833255290985,
0.4329383373260498,
0.5865959525108337,
0.35922950506210327,
0.006664611399173737,
-0.29469799995422363,
-0.1294746696949005,
-0.3620111048221588,
-0.32166987657546997,
0.34936702251434326,
0.5030421614646912,
-0.3730754554271698,
-0.25427356362342834,
-0.16939930617809296,
-0.3794509470462799,
0.01663677580654621,
0.24153706431388855,
0.813977837562561,
0.025025740265846252,
-0.7366924285888672,
0.2583721876144409,
-0.015518724918365479,
0.4601356089115143,
-0.5388293862342834,
-0.014867261983454227,
-0.15370012819766998,
-0.07859739661216736,
-0.2091255635023117,
-0.7204914689064026,
0.07539890706539154,
-0.5587464570999146,
-0.0336918979883194,
-0.2952655851840973,
0.9022614359855652,
0.04872780293226242,
-0.10166551917791367,
0.33657723665237427,
0.42562609910964966,
-0.08812568336725235,
0.01455909013748169,
-0.6223651766777039,
0.34887680411338806,
-0.13836678862571716,
-0.3264043927192688,
0.2041325569152832,
0.10023120790719986,
0.09327326714992523,
0.8144352436065674,
0.5696722865104675,
-0.04665697365999222,
0.12056058645248413,
-0.06887823343276978,
0.9833974242210388,
-1.0003578662872314,
-0.5339421629905701,
-0.17304417490959167,
0.274807870388031,
-0.09542600810527802,
0.13135147094726562,
0.2242097556591034,
0.7042629718780518,
0.6802873015403748,
0.12108761072158813,
0.9308559894561768,
-0.10598425567150116,
0.45990225672721863,
-0.4365168511867523,
0.3566147983074188,
-0.25452661514282227,
0.4366060495376587,
-0.05692393332719803,
-1.0158134698867798,
-0.18921151757240295,
0.5087819695472717,
-0.2646414339542389,
0.10656170547008514,
0.6195660829544067,
1.051834225654602,
-0.3134169578552246,
0.6684029698371887,
0.30780789256095886,
0.23777209222316742,
0.6674409508705139,
0.11711611598730087,
0.9627976417541504,
-0.7198442220687866,
0.3918320834636688,
0.12747584283351898,
-0.1941784918308258,
-0.8894781470298767,
-0.29584771394729614,
-0.24714183807373047,
-0.7984445095062256,
0.14004579186439514,
-0.045120690017938614,
0.13080599904060364,
0.38594290614128113,
0.8126392364501953,
-0.5292865633964539,
-0.7360134124755859,
0.02897467650473118,
0.20694416761398315,
0.08553890138864517,
-0.31263911724090576,
-0.35319289565086365,
-0.7831159830093384,
-0.6001265048980713,
0.7326574325561523,
0.7622128129005432,
-0.2916387617588043,
-0.46288442611694336,
-0.020340194925665855,
-0.463375061750412,
0.22893834114074707,
0.733619213104248,
0.5232321619987488,
-0.6820835471153259,
-0.25691065192222595,
0.5457336902618408,
-0.5322192311286926,
0.2522626519203186,
1.1361820697784424,
-0.8373849987983704,
0.6410659551620483,
0.7826182246208191,
0.8281502723693848,
0.5706716179847717,
-0.3735867440700531,
0.7602046728134155,
-0.3792380690574646,
-0.18740098178386688,
0.3461720943450928,
0.16825047135353088,
0.26894354820251465,
-0.3056508004665375,
0.5270340442657471,
0.029757065698504448,
-0.730379581451416,
-0.8463678956031799,
0.295911967754364,
-0.9126757383346558,
0.11612819135189056,
0.7231578230857849,
0.3514912724494934,
-0.047686994075775146,
-0.36208200454711914,
-0.612726092338562,
-0.1602134257555008,
-0.4248312711715698,
0.8806143403053284,
0.7046540379524231,
-0.3640417158603668,
0.12730608880519867,
-0.6961470246315002,
0.1244615763425827,
0.44636985659599304,
-0.453705370426178,
-0.21154473721981049,
0.31847327947616577,
-0.16316397488117218,
0.7171468138694763,
0.6477831602096558,
-0.2684386670589447,
0.397114634513855,
-0.36230769753456116,
0.08119715750217438,
0.6028319597244263,
-0.07458526641130447,
-0.006900453008711338,
0.3691718578338623,
0.3830052316188812,
0.1352793425321579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00996v1 | Can Small Language Models Learn, Unlearn, and Retain Noise Patterns? | 2024-07-01T06:22:38 | 2024-07-01T06:22:38 | Nicy Scaria, Silvester John Joseph Kennedy, Deepak Subramani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Small Language Models (SLMs) are generally considered to be more compact
versions of large language models (LLMs), typically having fewer than 7 billion
parameters. This study investigates the ability of small language models to
learn, retain, and subsequently eliminate noise that is typically not found on
the internet, where most pretraining datasets are sourced. For this, four
pre-trained SLMs were utilized: Olmo 1B, Qwen1.5 1.8B, Gemma 2B, and Phi2 2.7B.
The models were instruction-tuned without noise and tested for task execution
with in-context learning. Afterward, noise patterns were introduced to evaluate
the models' learning and unlearning capabilities. We evaluated the models'
performance at various training levels. Phi consistently excelled with
word-level noise but performed the worst with character-level noise. Despite
being the smallest with approximately 1 billion parameters, Olmo performed
consistently well on tasks. | [
-0.11214414238929749,
-0.7836686372756958,
0.5286639928817749,
-0.223353773355484,
-0.5076667666435242,
-0.3362332284450531,
-0.548713207244873,
-0.6160860657691956,
-0.25210443139076233,
0.6651445627212524,
-0.45660436153411865,
-0.24665343761444092,
-0.48079803586006165,
-0.03409712016582489,
-0.42925941944122314,
0.6858335137367249,
0.295663982629776,
0.4142117202281952,
0.08659670501947403,
0.15561151504516602,
-0.4002979099750519,
-0.1540134847164154,
-0.8490452766418457,
-0.36389657855033875,
0.6116940379142761,
0.4143078923225403,
0.44174718856811523,
0.8551303744316101,
0.31902527809143066,
0.24865451455116272,
-0.16240890324115753,
0.3110722601413727,
-0.7074357271194458,
-0.025158077478408813,
-0.050370581448078156,
-0.48671451210975647,
-0.20108424127101898,
0.12660548090934753,
0.8221258521080017,
0.8868039846420288,
-0.25213098526000977,
0.28701475262641907,
0.4372451603412628,
0.5180863738059998,
-0.3171161711215973,
0.39743348956108093,
-0.7497920393943787,
-0.1311427801847458,
-0.37076300382614136,
0.11102185398340225,
-0.7502644658088684,
-0.20383727550506592,
-0.06138293817639351,
-0.4942651689052582,
0.09042902290821075,
0.33266404271125793,
0.8383968472480774,
0.2518768012523651,
-0.2515246272087097,
-0.6369138360023499,
-0.9869531393051147,
1.0793503522872925,
-0.872897207736969,
0.4900556206703186,
0.767052412033081,
-0.06962268054485321,
-0.1277124583721161,
-0.6480266451835632,
-0.14662231504917145,
-0.04266888648271561,
-0.27352356910705566,
-0.32593369483947754,
-0.17787502706050873,
-0.048917125910520554,
0.33856645226478577,
0.37184950709342957,
-0.43779635429382324,
0.6449909210205078,
-0.7743397355079651,
0.014767070300877094,
0.439558207988739,
0.1495331972837448,
0.05957057327032089,
0.06535793840885162,
0.1666153520345688,
0.2663537263870239,
-0.8217443227767944,
0.1246803030371666,
0.2859894931316376,
0.6923206448554993,
-0.14578935503959656,
0.2510319948196411,
-0.003636525943875313,
0.6793806552886963,
0.12660153210163116,
-0.6431434154510498,
0.019442759454250336,
-0.021102409809827805,
-0.4711364209651947,
-0.1803172081708908,
0.6445803642272949,
-0.32569169998168945,
0.18734581768512726,
-0.3017476201057434,
-0.5156108140945435,
-0.270666241645813,
0.30861154198646545,
-0.7152001261711121,
-0.45706290006637573,
-0.21183769404888153,
-1.0468177795410156,
-0.38915860652923584,
0.06888020038604736,
-0.6011497974395752,
-0.3655166029930115,
-0.41609328985214233,
0.7490323781967163,
-0.44319435954093933,
-0.23877383768558502,
0.1595754623413086,
0.29817405343055725,
0.026633381843566895,
0.3512421250343323,
-0.9472007751464844,
0.5868086814880371,
0.39647963643074036,
0.8929972648620605,
-0.1772126406431198,
-0.13094604015350342,
-0.4192773103713989,
-0.16140563786029816,
-0.5001996159553528,
0.4513233006000519,
-0.4511069655418396,
-0.4066890478134155,
-0.14072440564632416,
0.07675374299287796,
-0.27888286113739014,
-0.8683772683143616,
0.23149177432060242,
-0.5823193192481995,
0.120328888297081,
-0.2605692148208618,
-0.6471757292747498,
-0.10822389274835587,
-0.3508012890815735,
-0.674458384513855,
0.8875992894172668,
0.1427515149116516,
-0.2718556523323059,
0.1990649253129959,
-0.3857285678386688,
-0.429921418428421,
-0.13237714767456055,
-0.15752512216567993,
-0.5719841122627258,
0.6977397203445435,
-0.21302922070026398,
0.2496122270822525,
-0.3057669699192047,
-0.42334237694740295,
-0.14858955144882202,
-0.6884869933128357,
0.0281379297375679,
-0.3392311930656433,
0.6936810612678528,
0.3180311322212219,
-0.3238762617111206,
-0.2534409761428833,
-0.8452256321907043,
0.13605551421642303,
0.2649492025375366,
-0.5019513964653015,
-0.4938555061817169,
-0.015916630625724792,
-0.4825610816478729,
0.48659223318099976,
-0.061124637722969055,
-0.5063858032226562,
0.1657005101442337,
-0.4986993074417114,
0.5870144963264465,
0.6150698661804199,
-0.11207491159439087,
0.5702630877494812,
-0.581849992275238,
0.43196484446525574,
0.42382434010505676,
-0.09060930460691452,
-0.11434543877840042,
-0.513048529624939,
-1.1985158920288086,
-0.47549867630004883,
0.34814363718032837,
-0.009039448574185371,
-0.3116368055343628,
0.058683738112449646,
-0.19471561908721924,
-0.5009920597076416,
-0.6111764907836914,
0.6703996658325195,
0.4982238709926605,
0.4684913456439972,
0.2238193154335022,
-0.15220899879932404,
-0.6074296236038208,
-0.5633781552314758,
-0.11859352141618729,
-0.03151809796690941,
0.046183083206415176,
0.18923795223236084,
0.5505566000938416,
-0.16238845884799957,
0.7301190495491028,
-0.06335227936506271,
-0.2865772247314453,
-0.23613162338733673,
0.23713582754135132,
-0.009579312987625599,
0.4072456657886505,
0.38588398694992065,
-0.3602616786956787,
-0.4868328273296356,
-0.26731130480766296,
-0.42881208658218384,
-0.007019469048827887,
0.2453363537788391,
0.43653959035873413,
0.2823120653629303,
0.6482768654823303,
-0.6311951875686646,
0.4965827763080597,
0.4144355058670044,
0.14980459213256836,
0.2945271134376526,
-0.3078019618988037,
-0.39816486835479736,
-0.6666086912155151,
-0.15172357857227325,
-0.13354997336864471,
-0.25482726097106934,
-0.7768697738647461,
-0.31202396750450134,
-0.06476683169603348,
-0.08285663276910782,
-0.36303672194480896,
0.6185596585273743,
-0.7807696461677551,
-0.20123757421970367,
-0.49201729893684387,
-0.011859176680445671,
-0.1782260686159134,
0.5419414043426514,
0.13306181132793427,
0.6283532977104187,
0.555212140083313,
-0.9276214838027954,
-0.4119030237197876,
-0.11748412996530533,
-0.6936102509498596,
-0.09869507700204849,
-0.6480218768119812,
0.40190380811691284,
-0.2782675623893738,
-0.3106042444705963,
-0.9232757687568665,
-0.05073145404458046,
0.03944708779454231,
0.08700501918792725,
0.2917395532131195,
-0.10401495546102524,
-0.7126148343086243,
-0.14866633713245392,
0.033664971590042114,
0.22175896167755127,
1.0049512386322021,
-0.4652063548564911,
0.0569474957883358,
0.47742006182670593,
0.03754487261176109,
0.01618586853146553,
-0.683010995388031,
-0.6021071672439575,
-0.32139039039611816,
-0.16946369409561157,
-0.11864291876554489,
-0.07880956679582596,
-0.3840287923812866,
-0.20826773345470428,
-0.1354479044675827,
-0.2169492393732071,
-0.08480614423751831,
0.6025158762931824,
0.03324868530035019,
-0.4905531108379364,
0.4068908989429474,
-0.4170672595500946,
0.07368443161249161,
-0.11859475821256638,
-0.46146395802497864,
0.6251882314682007,
-0.26718440651893616,
-0.3626892566680908,
-0.27972328662872314,
-0.06751873344182968,
0.4367222487926483,
-0.03407982736825943,
0.9664922952651978,
0.5786629319190979,
-0.5553752779960632,
-0.4971059262752533,
-0.35991325974464417,
-0.3218001127243042,
-0.5031635165214539,
0.2496294379234314,
-0.3594648540019989,
-0.9787034392356873,
0.4762076735496521,
-0.06825071573257446,
0.07776714116334915,
0.3015047013759613,
0.4403332471847534,
-0.4648168981075287,
1.1109613180160522,
0.8249912261962891,
-0.02395559288561344,
0.4410451352596283,
-0.2162293642759323,
0.31215396523475647,
-0.5711048245429993,
0.0026191319338977337,
-0.6272227168083191,
-0.36034491658210754,
-0.5419677495956421,
-0.3623511791229248,
0.0334201455116272,
0.6946297883987427,
-0.3318588435649872,
0.17706115543842316,
-0.1837584376335144,
0.5736556053161621,
0.6344279646873474,
0.226716548204422,
0.4302805960178375,
0.40920427441596985,
0.08886638283729553,
-0.2712225019931793,
-0.8233225345611572,
-0.7043725252151489,
1.0077502727508545,
0.4468816816806793,
1.0004891157150269,
0.2615656852722168,
0.5582772493362427,
0.20096741616725922,
0.05006396025419235,
-0.6334806084632874,
0.4496724009513855,
-0.4402681291103363,
-0.3449716567993164,
-0.5369619727134705,
-0.4474925398826599,
-1.0633810758590698,
0.2385481745004654,
-0.08941546082496643,
-1.0237208604812622,
0.2617301344871521,
0.42128393054008484,
-0.5296940207481384,
0.4608803987503052,
-0.52426677942276,
0.5853576064109802,
-0.05224090442061424,
-0.15847767889499664,
-0.19473043084144592,
-0.38689643144607544,
0.462009996175766,
-0.3735871911048889,
0.4630608558654785,
-0.021332476288080215,
-0.011180211789906025,
0.6691532135009766,
-0.531115710735321,
1.1008869409561157,
0.061729688197374344,
-0.15699683129787445,
0.3698520362377167,
0.20003806054592133,
0.6375007629394531,
-0.27823492884635925,
-0.12673020362854004,
0.34063583612442017,
-0.03545352816581726,
-0.2494696080684662,
-0.3717491924762726,
0.5364227890968323,
-1.0025138854980469,
-0.32401230931282043,
-0.10978660732507706,
-0.3485020697116852,
-0.10628438740968704,
0.49652355909347534,
0.5978912711143494,
0.421114057302475,
-0.03225671127438545,
0.3938826322555542,
1.028801679611206,
0.09024813771247864,
0.6320366263389587,
0.867291271686554,
-0.26041722297668457,
0.21776790916919708,
1.0889235734939575,
0.3020305633544922,
0.3116748332977295,
0.1246395856142044,
0.38056400418281555,
-0.0625365749001503,
-0.8857048153877258,
-0.056808073073625565,
0.36614730954170227,
-0.47118058800697327,
0.03623312711715698,
-0.4589179754257202,
-0.42369526624679565,
-0.34621649980545044,
0.25685998797416687,
-0.5140792727470398,
-0.2387772500514984,
-0.5336683988571167,
0.22106964886188507,
-0.10621219873428345,
1.2213966846466064,
-0.022042183205485344,
0.687512218952179,
-0.6870690584182739,
0.14942488074302673,
0.4206424653530121,
0.27876922488212585,
0.10509008169174194,
-1.073158621788025,
-0.531409502029419,
0.25731179118156433,
0.0499306358397007,
-0.6362759470939636,
0.4466157555580139,
0.4905984103679657,
0.4449257552623749,
0.6261383891105652,
-0.004349087364971638,
0.8048996329307556,
-0.43709129095077515,
0.6671667098999023,
0.021027768030762672,
-0.7573380470275879,
0.5108467936515808,
-0.3739176392555237,
0.3501201570034027,
0.3448830842971802,
0.06837669014930725,
-0.10672163218259811,
-0.2484208047389984,
-0.7052216529846191,
-0.16759352385997772,
1.0513343811035156,
-0.037417832762002945,
-0.1319463849067688,
0.05888349935412407,
0.46859827637672424,
0.139395073056221,
0.4924265742301941,
-0.7973732352256775,
-0.11134961247444153,
0.04282895848155022,
-0.15001875162124634,
-0.2571244239807129,
-0.49650079011917114,
0.08227931708097458,
-0.17077796161174774,
0.538597822189331,
0.13255731761455536,
0.15279194712638855,
-0.5228444337844849,
-0.6077740788459778,
-0.5059309601783752,
0.15972037613391876,
0.8835887312889099,
0.5141044855117798,
-0.061881955713033676,
0.20743350684642792,
0.0618974007666111,
-0.4965192377567291,
0.08249453455209732,
-0.4903036057949066,
-0.6330364346504211,
0.15510796010494232,
0.32129454612731934,
0.8676308989524841,
0.5793091654777527,
-0.5917800068855286,
0.3407818377017975,
-0.005777725484222174,
0.013683106750249863,
-0.40822941064834595,
0.300214946269989,
0.053336698561906815,
0.059768691658973694,
-0.1264883130788803,
0.22970902919769287,
-0.21830883622169495,
-0.6846591234207153,
0.040328387171030045,
0.31028860807418823,
-0.5339734554290771,
-0.5117030739784241,
0.5403908491134644,
-0.019322562962770462,
-0.4241553544998169,
0.7557776570320129,
-0.40633219480514526,
0.18634772300720215,
0.3730405867099762,
0.6882774233818054,
0.46252232789993286,
-0.14348654448986053,
0.02909069135785103,
0.23837041854858398,
0.660403311252594,
-0.5501566529273987,
0.1514807492494583,
0.19500529766082764,
-0.792275607585907,
-0.008192199282348156,
-0.7955383062362671,
0.09057832509279251,
0.6692622303962708,
-0.7321740388870239,
0.2588167190551758,
-0.7009039521217346,
-0.06092856079339981,
-0.013866905122995377,
0.16306272149085999,
-0.8302294611930847,
0.17701828479766846,
0.04767265543341637,
0.6030211448669434,
-0.6698622703552246,
1.3065721988677979,
0.5963131785392761,
-0.46053096652030945,
-0.9032553434371948,
-0.22872169315814972,
0.38747936487197876,
-0.7816596031188965,
0.7720180153846741,
0.1687954217195511,
-0.1987631618976593,
0.10611827671527863,
-0.4453863799571991,
-1.0260919332504272,
0.8675493001937866,
0.6148130297660828,
-0.6796016097068787,
-0.12935835123062134,
0.2763691842556,
0.5623354911804199,
-0.5840390920639038,
0.12273812294006348,
0.5523291826248169,
0.14208637177944183,
-0.22475773096084595,
-1.0386868715286255,
-0.38745754957199097,
-0.07898774743080139,
0.032268866896629333,
0.044573813676834106,
-0.8610649704933167,
1.3645763397216797,
-0.2798932194709778,
-0.4105226695537567,
0.38096752762794495,
0.4808107316493988,
0.02981376461684704,
-0.13869109749794006,
0.6830039620399475,
0.3814690411090851,
1.0144309997558594,
-0.06833860278129578,
0.4462909698486328,
-0.2642088532447815,
0.31485405564308167,
1.5151901245117188,
-0.24070431292057037,
0.9073194265365601,
0.3260909914970398,
0.11623957753181458,
0.4132620692253113,
0.6204587817192078,
0.2278396487236023,
0.7122940421104431,
0.10378952324390411,
0.03757637366652489,
-0.4814271926879883,
0.1425466239452362,
-0.0865015834569931,
0.5702441930770874,
0.4088088572025299,
-0.43287578225135803,
-0.04674752801656723,
0.186955064535141,
-0.04177447408437729,
-0.03915636986494064,
-0.6346198320388794,
0.826302170753479,
0.3785720765590668,
-0.31841713190078735,
0.2825499176979065,
0.15052923560142517,
0.5333499908447266,
-0.7808720469474792,
0.06863686442375183,
-0.13658732175827026,
0.514957070350647,
-0.08820991218090057,
-0.04324677959084511,
0.22776933014392853,
-0.24273145198822021,
-0.4686409831047058,
-0.2360493242740631,
0.8824822902679443,
-0.70744389295578,
-0.436924546957016,
0.15793484449386597,
0.46462133526802063,
0.3828440308570862,
0.10204284638166428,
-0.4968644380569458,
0.13615331053733826,
-0.08078599721193314,
-0.2002360075712204,
0.6913114190101624,
0.2108447104692459,
0.06583413481712341,
0.7971057891845703,
0.41652801632881165,
0.497822105884552,
0.4905003607273102,
-0.014100443571805954,
0.47499388456344604,
-0.3681269586086273,
-0.38171178102493286,
-0.6490549445152283,
0.2299259454011917,
0.08299821615219116,
-0.29250067472457886,
0.9497395753860474,
0.36375483870506287,
0.9397092461585999,
-0.23391009867191315,
0.5094925761222839,
0.29715514183044434,
0.8495967388153076,
-0.7289305329322815,
0.554450511932373,
-0.48206329345703125,
0.6081919074058533,
-0.03262375667691231,
-0.6254948377609253,
0.20839622616767883,
0.7790493369102478,
-0.14780764281749725,
0.41140323877334595,
0.6320270895957947,
0.8998990654945374,
-0.2813081443309784,
0.273449182510376,
0.7155687212944031,
0.3211665153503418,
-0.05682055279612541,
0.27690210938453674,
0.6944755911827087,
-0.5264685750007629,
0.5489187836647034,
-0.43807047605514526,
0.15359286963939667,
-0.3156006932258606,
-0.43705257773399353,
-1.1879007816314697,
-0.362809419631958,
-0.2306847721338272,
-0.18608051538467407,
0.14152763783931732,
0.7879461050033569,
0.9687929749488831,
-0.9228946566581726,
-0.39765578508377075,
0.06343146413564682,
0.00945026520639658,
-0.34189414978027344,
-0.10532571375370026,
0.2651846706867218,
-0.557216465473175,
-0.7344772815704346,
0.558300793170929,
0.260216623544693,
0.2046942263841629,
-0.2789566218852997,
-0.3646683394908905,
0.05763876810669899,
0.1803790032863617,
0.46252965927124023,
0.5756667852401733,
-0.7615187168121338,
-0.36307087540626526,
-0.018620269373059273,
-0.464033305644989,
-0.1656673550605774,
1.0913859605789185,
-0.5310210585594177,
0.2687132656574249,
0.1755608767271042,
0.15456557273864746,
0.3383149206638336,
-0.12630921602249146,
0.40789860486984253,
-1.0137838125228882,
0.563229501247406,
-0.03918323665857315,
0.4767776131629944,
-0.060222379863262177,
-0.1443074643611908,
0.31537091732025146,
0.1434393972158432,
-0.4980093836784363,
-0.9940705299377441,
0.05511976033449173,
-0.39123260974884033,
-0.3777155876159668,
1.1527292728424072,
-0.20987845957279205,
0.05802752077579498,
-0.32835134863853455,
0.20092910528182983,
0.11976012587547302,
-0.022350383922457695,
0.7368869781494141,
0.6805821061134338,
-0.13886654376983643,
-0.5807549357414246,
-0.6147720813751221,
0.7878336906433105,
0.40388455986976624,
-0.3882576525211334,
0.01511369738727808,
0.3108014762401581,
0.37848255038261414,
0.023356355726718903,
0.8901397585868835,
-0.11451968550682068,
0.05664977431297302,
0.16551265120506287,
-0.3773805499076843,
-0.1581689417362213,
-0.4553585648536682,
-0.7716789841651917,
0.1091216653585434,
0.3309985101222992,
-0.1687769740819931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00994v1 | LLM Uncertainty Quantification through Directional Entailment Graph and Claim Level Response Augmentation | 2024-07-01T06:11:30 | 2024-07-01T06:11:30 | Longchao Da, Tiejin Chen, Lu Cheng, Hua Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | The Large language models (LLMs) have showcased superior capabilities in
sophisticated tasks across various domains, stemming from basic question-answer
(QA), they are nowadays used as decision assistants or explainers for
unfamiliar content. However, they are not always correct due to the data
sparsity in specific domain corpus, or the model's hallucination problems.
Given this, how much should we trust the responses from LLMs? This paper
presents a novel way to evaluate the uncertainty that captures the directional
instability, by constructing a directional graph from entailment probabilities,
and we innovatively conduct Random Walk Laplacian given the asymmetric property
of a constructed directed graph, then the uncertainty is aggregated by the
derived eigenvalues from the Laplacian process. We also provide a way to
incorporate the existing work's semantics uncertainty with our proposed layer.
Besides, this paper identifies the vagueness issues in the raw response set and
proposes an augmentation approach to mitigate such a problem, we conducted
extensive empirical experiments and demonstrated the superiority of our
proposed solutions. | [
-0.27159881591796875,
-1.3001577854156494,
0.7249228954315186,
0.10981418192386627,
-0.06623957306146622,
0.29261648654937744,
-0.01853468082845211,
-0.6418561339378357,
0.43996334075927734,
0.4533630907535553,
-0.5273608565330505,
-0.49948346614837646,
-0.7693151235580444,
0.06389804929494858,
-0.3585091531276703,
0.3661484718322754,
-0.2946375906467438,
0.028625603765249252,
-0.38264670968055725,
-0.08986381441354752,
-0.29807761311531067,
-0.13565421104431152,
-0.8571216464042664,
-0.22482360899448395,
0.27905815839767456,
0.22202852368354797,
0.864145040512085,
0.2286369949579239,
0.4905696213245392,
0.393515408039093,
0.06128237023949623,
0.21926887333393097,
-0.2759605050086975,
0.3094140589237213,
0.08176876604557037,
-0.37324151396751404,
-0.7756158113479614,
-0.24802623689174652,
0.6190980076789856,
0.9372941255569458,
-0.1324622631072998,
0.11250290274620056,
0.15294545888900757,
0.6288288831710815,
-0.3352392315864563,
-0.007526345085352659,
-0.7290176749229431,
0.0820847898721695,
-0.015537546016275883,
-0.20027807354927063,
-0.24640263617038727,
-0.3862228989601135,
0.2689218819141388,
-0.6823793649673462,
-0.06847196072340012,
0.1664217710494995,
0.868148148059845,
0.3933652937412262,
-0.4018724262714386,
-0.3605342507362366,
-0.7968876361846924,
0.4459730088710785,
-0.7588351368904114,
0.44817692041397095,
0.4278557300567627,
0.2834618389606476,
-0.41281235218048096,
-0.744096577167511,
-0.5582757592201233,
-0.2804529070854187,
0.18010130524635315,
0.05984638258814812,
-0.05035001039505005,
0.11589143425226212,
0.00060888787265867,
0.26825523376464844,
-0.5484361052513123,
0.30921417474746704,
-0.007634846493601799,
-0.5154580473899841,
0.8396427035331726,
0.04333622008562088,
0.22768454253673553,
-0.08551720529794693,
-0.3947666585445404,
-0.1396738439798355,
-0.7986428737640381,
0.1708570420742035,
0.6861585974693298,
0.26191774010658264,
-0.06769087165594101,
0.9383325576782227,
-0.21771247684955597,
0.7225555777549744,
0.2054409682750702,
-0.13938826322555542,
0.24510584771633148,
-0.2760053277015686,
-0.3613473176956177,
0.1178223192691803,
0.8565695285797119,
0.04662766680121422,
0.12171948701143265,
-0.06530454754829407,
-0.21918869018554688,
-0.38671109080314636,
0.13310730457305908,
-0.6085513234138489,
0.18904069066047668,
0.7602436542510986,
-0.20665772259235382,
-0.11337164044380188,
-0.07079001516103745,
-0.6875589489936829,
-0.6723066568374634,
-0.16612529754638672,
0.42075565457344055,
-0.6436676979064941,
-0.301316499710083,
0.20281074941158295,
0.2564782202243805,
0.18874013423919678,
0.47711387276649475,
-0.2781149446964264,
0.08816030621528625,
0.5781681537628174,
0.6005520224571228,
-0.0357016995549202,
-0.02074737846851349,
-0.4781642556190491,
0.10124285519123077,
-0.3567233979701996,
0.6101052165031433,
-0.5395084023475647,
-0.4444325268268585,
0.131842240691185,
-0.20891210436820984,
-0.03958073630928993,
-0.4065588116645813,
0.6943424940109253,
-0.6774423718452454,
0.05260113626718521,
0.03139803558588028,
-0.5885732769966125,
-0.1682642698287964,
0.4876742660999298,
-0.5403444170951843,
0.9644859433174133,
0.1528424620628357,
-1.0053943395614624,
0.09651634097099304,
-0.1502622663974762,
-0.22833961248397827,
0.20093095302581787,
-0.3376809358596802,
-0.4192785322666168,
-0.04080435633659363,
0.373325377702713,
0.3003483712673187,
-0.10446498543024063,
0.13624361157417297,
-0.4864422678947449,
-0.10518747568130493,
0.7854771018028259,
-0.4040723443031311,
0.7814834117889404,
0.2024794965982437,
-0.062210891395807266,
0.32234710454940796,
-0.8927679657936096,
0.2717428505420685,
-0.008063411340117455,
-0.135607048869133,
-0.2840709388256073,
0.020755721256136894,
-0.49730342626571655,
0.11341264843940735,
0.5297821164131165,
-0.5080386996269226,
-0.1618812084197998,
-0.5476187467575073,
0.08685704320669174,
0.8517284989356995,
0.2513071596622467,
0.3350856602191925,
-0.02552923932671547,
0.6909494996070862,
0.02457599528133869,
0.06043548136949539,
0.48196178674697876,
-0.598939836025238,
-0.6104783415794373,
-0.16967181861400604,
0.3085877299308777,
0.5643620491027832,
-0.8075761795043945,
0.4462226629257202,
-0.4051815867424011,
-0.1494244933128357,
-0.6597968935966492,
0.11473694443702698,
0.05744315683841705,
0.5790914297103882,
0.11146442592144012,
-0.14057490229606628,
-0.4719817340373993,
-0.683307945728302,
-0.0723557323217392,
-0.3607083857059479,
-0.23557186126708984,
0.22992974519729614,
0.1025281473994255,
-0.29357030987739563,
0.8350168466567993,
-0.5094098448753357,
-0.03674750030040741,
-0.0545601025223732,
0.04355994611978531,
0.12574197351932526,
0.24408237636089325,
0.021203668788075447,
-0.6284888386726379,
-0.3701523244380951,
0.05083834007382393,
-0.6948968172073364,
0.07743579149246216,
-0.13204747438430786,
-0.09265447407960892,
0.27962204813957214,
0.3976539373397827,
-0.8242624998092651,
0.28237977623939514,
0.4734778106212616,
-0.19273924827575684,
0.505379855632782,
-0.31137293577194214,
0.053728196769952774,
-0.8770925402641296,
-0.268672913312912,
0.28398793935775757,
-0.37754374742507935,
-0.3742239773273468,
0.35717856884002686,
-0.12210105359554291,
0.16084527969360352,
-0.013205542229115963,
0.06917372345924377,
-0.3766764998435974,
-0.11377396434545517,
-0.20954479277133942,
0.6169578433036804,
-0.1717144101858139,
0.08517840504646301,
-0.11530239880084991,
0.40100619196891785,
0.7524649500846863,
-0.4615585207939148,
0.4995899498462677,
0.025317799299955368,
-0.12907077372074127,
0.5969122648239136,
-0.7830355763435364,
0.24114325642585754,
-0.3676232397556305,
0.20281779766082764,
-1.1365702152252197,
-0.3010231852531433,
0.4892634153366089,
-0.7980161905288696,
0.5919234156608582,
0.07569986581802368,
-0.38981425762176514,
-0.5458253026008606,
-0.4130009114742279,
0.18046393990516663,
0.3816590905189514,
-0.2322073131799698,
0.6741567850112915,
0.4471549093723297,
-0.2657717168331146,
-0.8256841897964478,
-0.4135785698890686,
0.004259513691067696,
-0.33161187171936035,
-0.9547607898712158,
0.11852459609508514,
-0.03225146234035492,
-0.4816338121891022,
-0.021158404648303986,
-0.20571337640285492,
0.01896720938384533,
0.07660161703824997,
0.49225980043411255,
0.1574806272983551,
-0.10591960698366165,
-0.055621903389692307,
0.02614564634859562,
0.053135402500629425,
0.4020976722240448,
-0.17750705778598785,
0.5433486104011536,
-0.07421345263719559,
-0.7893559336662292,
-0.2705836594104767,
-0.030857078731060028,
0.21995827555656433,
-0.03222585842013359,
0.485912024974823,
0.6609541177749634,
-0.48265427350997925,
-0.24682708084583282,
-0.3510066866874695,
-0.15039527416229248,
-0.5475690364837646,
0.46625906229019165,
-0.5500317215919495,
-0.9156949520111084,
0.8783670663833618,
-0.01441807672381401,
-0.30208805203437805,
0.44974401593208313,
0.3936437964439392,
-0.12928801774978638,
0.9349713325500488,
0.3503797948360443,
0.07218477874994278,
-0.09801902621984482,
-0.1669885218143463,
0.4461497366428375,
-0.7310792803764343,
-0.6021419167518616,
-0.5268651843070984,
-0.17605726420879364,
-0.8108720183372498,
-0.6559518575668335,
0.50518798828125,
0.15548931062221527,
-0.1738739311695099,
0.00478103943169117,
-0.31247857213020325,
-0.11140367388725281,
0.20084764063358307,
0.3092172145843506,
0.33819055557250977,
0.12915830314159393,
-0.04473556950688362,
-0.11016196012496948,
-0.29341423511505127,
-0.3985919952392578,
0.946588933467865,
0.8615583777427673,
0.974967360496521,
0.22428947687149048,
0.6874653697013855,
0.023404525592923164,
0.0015154994325712323,
-0.7382906675338745,
0.6675925850868225,
0.3796217143535614,
-0.16672563552856445,
-0.729556143283844,
-0.5199856162071228,
-0.9010149240493774,
0.21625138819217682,
-0.15807776153087616,
-0.9199597835540771,
0.1611897200345993,
-0.09538484364748001,
-0.44192489981651306,
0.048128675669431686,
-0.18928265571594238,
0.24433012306690216,
-0.0940915122628212,
-0.42525553703308105,
-0.021135134622454643,
-0.7382497191429138,
0.3450544774532318,
-0.11966854333877563,
0.3126692771911621,
-0.07134269177913666,
-0.11236130446195602,
0.5362104773521423,
-0.566274106502533,
0.8704506754875183,
-0.22223438322544098,
-0.6716541051864624,
0.7486138939857483,
0.30016568303108215,
1.0827505588531494,
0.33499929308891296,
-0.07575235515832901,
-0.1697220653295517,
-0.29557234048843384,
-0.25625020265579224,
-0.6931836009025574,
0.777441680431366,
-0.6112514138221741,
-0.8363202810287476,
-0.23887452483177185,
-0.7603586912155151,
-0.5718197226524353,
0.04561619460582733,
0.1859797239303589,
0.22061915695667267,
0.08413568139076233,
-0.2061844915151596,
0.7908023595809937,
-0.30814802646636963,
0.26196321845054626,
0.28077542781829834,
-0.36070767045021057,
-0.2966301441192627,
0.7808342576026917,
0.1293777972459793,
0.2459089457988739,
0.33704686164855957,
0.11131243407726288,
-0.6288456320762634,
-1.030785083770752,
-0.31650158762931824,
0.08712427318096161,
-0.6817014217376709,
-0.23970317840576172,
-0.5594335794448853,
-0.4546317756175995,
-0.511931300163269,
0.03130203112959862,
-0.16212330758571625,
-0.5947890877723694,
-0.04794952645897865,
-0.5246708393096924,
0.4517343044281006,
0.7684615254402161,
-0.02354721538722515,
0.13834510743618011,
-0.5399550795555115,
0.007526637986302376,
0.22800113260746002,
0.23362788558006287,
-0.0812394842505455,
-0.6565287709236145,
0.008157231844961643,
0.41060781478881836,
-0.22766724228858948,
-0.9814399480819702,
0.586632490158081,
0.0009846445173025131,
0.7005088925361633,
0.5296730995178223,
0.19300898909568787,
0.6328355073928833,
-0.21119552850723267,
0.6617356538772583,
0.02075181156396866,
-0.7910072207450867,
0.42657965421676636,
-0.34356290102005005,
-0.275147020816803,
0.2603050768375397,
0.5225091576576233,
-0.024097437039017677,
-0.7503631114959717,
-0.7001057863235474,
-1.069317102432251,
0.008650657720863819,
0.09005086123943329,
0.06102750822901726,
0.18495619297027588,
0.4519719183444977,
-0.11166777461767197,
0.1309448629617691,
-0.7009373307228088,
-0.2549481987953186,
-0.00004211989289615303,
-0.301566481590271,
0.2399492859840393,
-0.25028857588768005,
-0.2611919045448303,
-0.18666532635688782,
0.5024880170822144,
-0.24308142066001892,
0.17116679251194,
0.2747599482536316,
-0.06248106807470322,
-0.36665859818458557,
0.1761317402124405,
0.455162912607193,
0.8317101001739502,
-0.5846326351165771,
0.4612632989883423,
0.2403569370508194,
-0.41817706823349,
0.11579512059688568,
0.149790957570076,
-0.08313063532114029,
-0.08864130824804306,
0.3943712115287781,
0.5127153396606445,
-0.2671028673648834,
-0.671259343624115,
0.3927750587463379,
0.24939748644828796,
-0.09690561890602112,
-0.4132853150367737,
-0.27309662103652954,
0.20811229944229126,
0.23146717250347137,
0.4360131621360779,
-0.08894910663366318,
0.3997951149940491,
-0.25906145572662354,
0.2053481787443161,
0.8104486465454102,
-0.4995179772377014,
-0.15031905472278595,
0.5351939797401428,
0.034029364585876465,
-0.10883405059576035,
0.3527204990386963,
-0.4699309468269348,
-0.3243069648742676,
0.7135359644889832,
0.7125601172447205,
0.7787133455276489,
-0.13566654920578003,
0.4299677312374115,
0.4184560775756836,
0.4806777834892273,
0.2557913064956665,
0.327467679977417,
0.3676820695400238,
-0.9096255302429199,
-0.6517603993415833,
-0.6099039912223816,
-0.2521357238292694,
0.0083862179890275,
-0.733976423740387,
-0.18910016119480133,
-0.4573003649711609,
-0.2779393792152405,
-0.3333582282066345,
0.08622094243764877,
-0.4544186294078827,
0.1664295494556427,
-0.03224755823612213,
0.7164775729179382,
-0.6188346147537231,
0.7057918310165405,
0.6512535810470581,
-0.34657472372055054,
-0.8405454754829407,
0.2740601599216461,
-0.2457919418811798,
-1.174202561378479,
0.7483437061309814,
-0.0740460529923439,
-0.37230396270751953,
-0.18303711712360382,
-0.5414560437202454,
-0.9883044958114624,
1.1427466869354248,
0.3188321590423584,
-0.48649242520332336,
0.28199389576911926,
0.4338778555393219,
0.5139917731285095,
-0.26981180906295776,
0.1382928341627121,
0.413239449262619,
0.39869481325149536,
0.5120560526847839,
-0.5973677039146423,
0.5777761340141296,
0.2504561245441437,
0.20480376482009888,
0.026172706857323647,
-0.4287482500076294,
0.7559101581573486,
-0.4965229034423828,
-0.3390665352344513,
-0.094205841422081,
0.9432234764099121,
0.473491907119751,
0.30917641520500183,
0.3077360689640045,
0.6637384295463562,
1.1114907264709473,
0.07230133563280106,
1.0416898727416992,
-0.32834649085998535,
0.31280282139778137,
1.1626183986663818,
-0.3357470631599426,
0.9750366806983948,
0.5683960318565369,
-0.4715895652770996,
0.4956350028514862,
0.9263701438903809,
0.4972180128097534,
0.23836621642112732,
0.5597319602966309,
-0.377503365278244,
-0.15683425962924957,
-0.10647241026163101,
-0.4896411895751953,
0.1343834549188614,
0.801715075969696,
-0.08121106028556824,
-0.039445873349905014,
-0.30817461013793945,
0.020793035626411438,
0.11796733736991882,
-0.32347536087036133,
0.46060124039649963,
0.2847181260585785,
-0.35799098014831543,
0.5424366593360901,
0.11738082021474838,
0.5246042013168335,
-0.4527897536754608,
0.23279410600662231,
-0.22244501113891602,
-0.0110982870683074,
-0.3269311189651489,
-0.9281322956085205,
0.20008444786071777,
-0.46912065148353577,
0.2275610864162445,
0.11296987533569336,
0.839836835861206,
-0.514211118221283,
-0.7762414216995239,
0.34171822667121887,
0.5011681914329529,
-0.003707944182679057,
0.030460834503173828,
-0.63871169090271,
0.11267487704753876,
-0.039877332746982574,
-0.12944801151752472,
0.3027162551879883,
0.676460325717926,
0.12058160454034805,
0.9576824903488159,
0.21108052134513855,
0.22717635333538055,
0.22222360968589783,
0.053379230201244354,
0.7175517082214355,
-0.07208432257175446,
-0.08223258703947067,
-0.8764928579330444,
0.49412596225738525,
-0.25424206256866455,
0.08702568709850311,
1.2800968885421753,
0.3370201885700226,
0.4564152657985687,
0.2143591195344925,
0.6659477353096008,
0.08783012628555298,
0.22152702510356903,
-0.7050709128379822,
0.44753581285476685,
-0.26323336362838745,
0.5998598337173462,
-0.171662837266922,
-0.7920175194740295,
-0.21749451756477356,
0.694257915019989,
-0.21480628848075867,
0.07919033616781235,
0.6827162504196167,
0.9354816675186157,
0.27856484055519104,
-0.16625550389289856,
0.10724160075187683,
0.35705316066741943,
0.14909496903419495,
0.47338780760765076,
0.7588711380958557,
-0.375753253698349,
0.3001570701599121,
-0.15951113402843475,
-0.13216465711593628,
-0.023815136402845383,
-0.8862629532814026,
-0.634943962097168,
-0.5375388860702515,
-0.7050100564956665,
-1.0130447149276733,
-0.14874081313610077,
0.7109352350234985,
0.34100496768951416,
-0.8138027191162109,
-0.198543518781662,
-0.19663089513778687,
0.4627533257007599,
-0.05802163481712341,
-0.25076547265052795,
0.5964112877845764,
-0.3673073649406433,
-0.6030242443084717,
0.3446365296840668,
0.19362036883831024,
0.41351908445358276,
-0.46947935223579407,
-0.29552221298217773,
-0.04218534380197525,
0.3119484782218933,
0.4242304563522339,
0.10915252566337585,
-0.5732794404029846,
-0.4034094214439392,
-0.09183856844902039,
-0.09070172160863876,
-0.0409771166741848,
0.5479288697242737,
-0.37335625290870667,
0.42999768257141113,
0.4013579785823822,
0.672838032245636,
0.42992132902145386,
0.14602047204971313,
0.5957704186439514,
-0.9798083901405334,
0.13409656286239624,
0.1309957355260849,
0.3847515285015106,
0.4557003378868103,
-0.573505699634552,
0.41629427671432495,
0.10266998410224915,
-0.4369107186794281,
-0.7848247289657593,
0.36730191111564636,
-1.0526747703552246,
-0.19974267482757568,
1.3590166568756104,
-0.16947251558303833,
-0.29028403759002686,
-0.20931167900562286,
0.06515177339315414,
0.06052706763148308,
-0.2525838315486908,
0.6016625761985779,
0.4989316761493683,
-0.29278823733329773,
-0.01738261990249157,
-0.5031895041465759,
0.3768884837627411,
0.08282659947872162,
-0.7248891592025757,
-0.24801179766654968,
0.6091977953910828,
0.28795504570007324,
0.2920551002025604,
0.724345326423645,
-0.09702388942241669,
-0.405416876077652,
0.11550801992416382,
-0.1657499372959137,
0.057978108525276184,
-0.07611659169197083,
-0.2633450925350189,
0.32710450887680054,
0.6028866171836853,
-0.33289405703544617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00993v1 | Mobile-Bench: An Evaluation Benchmark for LLM-based Mobile Agents | 2024-07-01T06:10:01 | 2024-07-01T06:10:01 | Shihan Deng, Weikai Xu, Hongda Sun, Wei Liu, Tao Tan, Jianfeng Liu, Ang Li, Jian Luan, Bin Wang, Rui Yan, Shuo Shang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | With the remarkable advancements of large language models (LLMs), LLM-based
agents have become a research hotspot in human-computer interaction. However,
there is a scarcity of benchmarks available for LLM-based mobile agents.
Benchmarking these agents generally faces three main challenges: (1) The
inefficiency of UI-only operations imposes limitations to task evaluation. (2)
Specific instructions within a singular application lack adequacy for assessing
the multi-dimensional reasoning and decision-making capacities of LLM mobile
agents. (3) Current evaluation metrics are insufficient to accurately assess
the process of sequential actions. To this end, we propose Mobile-Bench, a
novel benchmark for evaluating the capabilities of LLM-based mobile agents.
First, we expand conventional UI operations by incorporating 103 collected APIs
to accelerate the efficiency of task completion. Subsequently, we collect
evaluation data by combining real user queries with augmentation from LLMs. To
better evaluate different levels of planning capabilities for mobile agents,
our data is categorized into three distinct groups: SAST, SAMT, and MAMT,
reflecting varying levels of task complexity. Mobile-Bench comprises 832 data
entries, with more than 200 tasks specifically designed to evaluate multi-APP
collaboration scenarios. Furthermore, we introduce a more accurate evaluation
metric, named CheckPoint, to assess whether LLM-based mobile agents reach
essential points during their planning and reasoning steps. | [
-0.48204419016838074,
-0.3579951226711273,
0.6590703725814819,
0.4383738338947296,
0.007354170549660921,
0.29451385140419006,
-0.11376825720071793,
-0.37486129999160767,
0.05685409530997276,
0.21477238833904266,
-0.6824891567230225,
-0.5336533188819885,
-0.21307194232940674,
0.06352433562278748,
-0.13537997007369995,
0.477874755859375,
-0.2864241600036621,
0.0992831140756607,
-0.7313908338546753,
-0.5780935287475586,
-0.6633349657058716,
-0.2727116644382477,
-0.47195056080818176,
-0.4901793301105499,
0.5029888153076172,
0.6538249254226685,
0.6675135493278503,
0.5327194333076477,
0.44804003834724426,
0.34177687764167786,
0.4148257374763489,
0.2136441022157669,
-0.3471606969833374,
0.25743499398231506,
-0.13883166015148163,
-0.26963895559310913,
-0.6391397714614868,
0.06235278397798538,
0.5820754766464233,
0.47777143120765686,
-0.024327879771590233,
0.3652553856372833,
-0.22482044994831085,
0.8550188541412354,
-0.8540937900543213,
-0.004663004539906979,
-0.5031859278678894,
0.014333119615912437,
-0.013068938627839088,
0.028152717277407646,
-0.15711255371570587,
-0.42045244574546814,
-0.14657779037952423,
-0.3015801012516022,
-0.21980123221874237,
-0.25636714696884155,
0.45156410336494446,
0.4148826003074646,
-0.5841348767280579,
-0.14970368146896362,
-0.5974467992782593,
0.6216518878936768,
-0.21264879405498505,
0.38270673155784607,
0.3244968056678772,
0.497734934091568,
-0.29578059911727905,
-0.7413299679756165,
-0.5163381099700928,
-0.6373947858810425,
0.3343077301979065,
0.17093217372894287,
-0.008950295858085155,
-0.0891086757183075,
0.24129709601402283,
0.029591336846351624,
-0.5585611462593079,
0.014156590215861797,
0.11433626711368561,
-0.21043157577514648,
0.8166958093643188,
0.45371973514556885,
0.24634146690368652,
0.09293952584266663,
-0.6649658679962158,
-0.1314333975315094,
-0.501512885093689,
0.36598026752471924,
-0.18709330260753632,
0.030527129769325256,
-0.13993534445762634,
0.7161754369735718,
-0.6709393858909607,
0.5011438131332397,
-0.2865977883338928,
-0.2505226135253906,
0.5014641284942627,
-0.5396938920021057,
-0.10913531482219696,
-0.2666745185852051,
0.8511534929275513,
0.6525110006332397,
-0.07340186834335327,
-0.4609885811805725,
-0.3361251652240753,
0.014593638479709625,
0.254456490278244,
-0.8593913912773132,
0.40273264050483704,
0.4480941593647003,
-0.3324317932128906,
-0.09698262065649033,
-0.18106478452682495,
-0.38004642724990845,
-0.7635510563850403,
-0.05024038627743721,
0.35579025745391846,
-0.16889619827270508,
0.03442174941301346,
-0.2836523652076721,
0.03273288533091545,
0.23420794308185577,
0.3343920409679413,
-0.4025360941886902,
0.49350810050964355,
0.6735578179359436,
0.7994973659515381,
-0.29938462376594543,
-0.691611647605896,
-0.6567431688308716,
0.009844307787716389,
-0.2261253446340561,
0.9552178382873535,
-0.5378919243812561,
-0.656877875328064,
-0.21655574440956116,
-0.12976780533790588,
-0.36587101221084595,
-0.6683936715126038,
0.9324041604995728,
-0.30744898319244385,
-0.6072772145271301,
-0.4063449501991272,
-0.36229628324508667,
-0.03291207179427147,
0.5185302495956421,
-0.49615469574928284,
1.2688605785369873,
0.16657905280590057,
-0.20759570598602295,
0.5216784477233887,
-0.516218900680542,
-0.4819153845310211,
0.1268000453710556,
-0.3434244990348816,
-0.26828497648239136,
-0.07940789312124252,
0.11796358972787857,
0.3969995081424713,
-0.7445172667503357,
0.00549764558672905,
-0.5606938004493713,
-0.5440633296966553,
0.45804935693740845,
0.011228824965655804,
0.3084542155265808,
0.24707160890102386,
-0.44645410776138306,
0.2765119671821594,
-0.9046879410743713,
0.5990903973579407,
-0.2420916110277176,
-0.39628931879997253,
-0.06897801905870438,
0.22041749954223633,
-0.1421729326248169,
0.3925780653953552,
0.4429841935634613,
-0.4679640531539917,
0.22514325380325317,
0.2970104217529297,
0.3051408529281616,
0.34560510516166687,
-0.16040444374084473,
0.5064313411712646,
-0.5486762523651123,
0.47609585523605347,
-0.4674701690673828,
0.27968841791152954,
-0.07049135863780975,
-0.21088698506355286,
-0.4619009494781494,
-0.601934552192688,
0.19275346398353577,
0.7638117074966431,
-0.49163272976875305,
0.2982054650783539,
-0.5165536999702454,
-0.8977791666984558,
-0.1725621521472931,
0.140325129032135,
0.5071334838867188,
0.14178705215454102,
0.016845431178808212,
-0.4096287786960602,
-0.34155377745628357,
-0.8296753168106079,
-0.4636445939540863,
-0.12630963325500488,
0.007268191315233707,
0.6788145303726196,
0.5239506959915161,
-0.5836387872695923,
0.9919689893722534,
0.10251525789499283,
-0.1294248104095459,
-0.10092534869909286,
0.21441881358623505,
-0.05997715890407562,
0.2712281048297882,
0.2424427717924118,
-0.6025689840316772,
-0.5718302726745605,
0.07492074370384216,
-0.91082364320755,
-0.39519426226615906,
-0.2103165239095688,
0.006953595206141472,
-0.08506298810243607,
0.5398285388946533,
-1.0290253162384033,
0.3866567313671112,
0.3085632026195526,
-0.12845732271671295,
0.522152304649353,
-0.07042192667722702,
0.34770599007606506,
-0.5806457996368408,
0.21912969648838043,
-0.31870028376579285,
-0.2837308645248413,
-0.4417242705821991,
0.04398481547832489,
0.37802502512931824,
-0.2864566743373871,
-0.32037749886512756,
0.8340305685997009,
-0.512051522731781,
-0.6880767941474915,
-0.4757133424282074,
0.24731989204883575,
-0.16380353271961212,
0.4083147943019867,
-0.24350742995738983,
0.9918252825737,
0.13980723917484283,
-0.5326604843139648,
0.30443456768989563,
-0.0021308548748493195,
-0.35282182693481445,
0.6123994588851929,
-0.5500659942626953,
0.26019546389579773,
0.2716445326805115,
0.6037464141845703,
-0.9024307131767273,
-0.10298549383878708,
0.0012894243700429797,
-0.2994491159915924,
-0.4563809633255005,
-0.1212795153260231,
-0.6473556160926819,
-0.40296670794487,
-0.48980456590652466,
0.40649861097335815,
0.0907759740948677,
-0.3197198808193207,
0.7991620302200317,
0.4223504662513733,
-0.0052500758320093155,
-0.7218073606491089,
-0.2763572037220001,
0.2097773402929306,
-0.10650617629289627,
-0.821658730506897,
0.4853135943412781,
0.09026049822568893,
-0.3388585150241852,
-0.008321878500282764,
-0.44885754585266113,
-0.11542043834924698,
0.11859989166259766,
0.7935237288475037,
-0.06538309901952744,
0.09085211157798767,
-0.035190433263778687,
-0.19542334973812103,
-0.15550824999809265,
-0.028696967288851738,
0.13664110004901886,
0.47372081875801086,
-0.3425830900669098,
-0.47840556502342224,
-0.34336960315704346,
0.029288791120052338,
1.0751749277114868,
-0.2881912291049957,
0.35835447907447815,
0.5508952736854553,
-0.2349444329738617,
0.05325368791818619,
-0.7102718949317932,
0.1856033354997635,
-0.4094500243663788,
0.22343462705612183,
-0.7439398169517517,
-0.4543757438659668,
0.6752179265022278,
-0.537936270236969,
0.017420217394828796,
0.10683689266443253,
0.6201051473617554,
0.10375653952360153,
0.9545734524726868,
0.26462870836257935,
-0.06265795230865479,
0.4255269169807434,
-0.017458803951740265,
-0.331525593996048,
-0.7590959072113037,
-0.36638981103897095,
-0.566772997379303,
-0.2670442461967468,
-0.4933822453022003,
-0.7153615951538086,
0.4672337472438812,
0.2425578534603119,
-0.3424852788448334,
0.4080060124397278,
0.07607720792293549,
0.37654274702072144,
0.36104902625083923,
0.07802681624889374,
0.18310324847698212,
-0.16602927446365356,
-0.3441082239151001,
0.2755330502986908,
-0.4600231647491455,
-0.6631206274032593,
1.1539342403411865,
0.24084654450416565,
0.5529101490974426,
0.05518645420670509,
0.7431237101554871,
0.5104265809059143,
0.4368399381637573,
-0.7380796074867249,
0.895545482635498,
0.2961188554763794,
-0.42474138736724854,
-0.33012503385543823,
-0.3910650908946991,
-0.9358277916908264,
0.7273979187011719,
-0.18551847338676453,
-0.8711760640144348,
0.10950164496898651,
-0.37796369194984436,
-0.18000906705856323,
-0.21305038034915924,
-0.8797487020492554,
0.956447184085846,
-0.5092180967330933,
-0.846346378326416,
-0.4531306326389313,
-0.4007062017917633,
0.20337186753749847,
-0.03765539824962616,
0.3123522102832794,
-0.6597421169281006,
-0.48828649520874023,
0.37486857175827026,
-0.8365932703018188,
0.5137023329734802,
-0.3444320261478424,
0.22946797311306,
0.37862059473991394,
0.047079164534807205,
0.7833366394042969,
0.07203038036823273,
-0.33044612407684326,
-0.141532301902771,
0.008143513463437557,
-0.39969420433044434,
-0.5573228001594543,
0.8162847757339478,
-0.6715625524520874,
-0.1995895802974701,
-0.3888159394264221,
-0.6167060136795044,
-0.7045927047729492,
0.3421931564807892,
-0.13867266476154327,
0.26866281032562256,
-0.4664837121963501,
0.13281142711639404,
-0.08930609375238419,
-0.12037808448076248,
0.532436728477478,
0.7755067348480225,
-0.1535017192363739,
-0.46232908964157104,
0.6985921859741211,
-0.09489849954843521,
-0.09456926584243774,
0.3986460566520691,
-0.05364556610584259,
-0.613722026348114,
-0.6825147867202759,
-0.5505189895629883,
-0.09837724268436432,
-0.5046299695968628,
-0.020890364423394203,
-0.5289257168769836,
0.12888704240322113,
0.07069423794746399,
-0.07060316950082779,
-0.610684335231781,
-0.35788607597351074,
0.2826957106590271,
0.36391955614089966,
-0.045432496815919876,
0.4357215464115143,
-0.13522931933403015,
0.2459505796432495,
-0.9064953923225403,
0.33485662937164307,
0.3454423248767853,
0.3975631296634674,
0.04979484900832176,
0.02690514549612999,
-0.35602688789367676,
-0.03279950097203255,
-0.40900227427482605,
-0.5207880139350891,
-0.009774132631719112,
-0.12758868932724,
0.859286367893219,
0.20163720846176147,
0.04961666837334633,
0.778688907623291,
-0.3812422752380371,
0.46089309453964233,
0.18012745678424835,
-0.8398197293281555,
0.20164337754249573,
-0.4581827223300934,
0.3538465201854706,
0.9855656027793884,
0.0393296517431736,
-0.29141804575920105,
0.02218480035662651,
-0.3773516118526459,
-0.8808373212814331,
0.6096172332763672,
0.33660557866096497,
-0.2315947562456131,
0.14661380648612976,
0.1263548731803894,
-0.06455891579389572,
0.2380647361278534,
-0.5044941902160645,
-0.07032538205385208,
0.08568290621042252,
0.19848857820034027,
-0.11778298765420914,
-0.15763254463672638,
-0.09164340049028397,
-0.21286781132221222,
0.16068357229232788,
0.05708204582333565,
0.2083055078983307,
0.19375649094581604,
-0.465745210647583,
0.1296073943376541,
0.3186171352863312,
0.7730459570884705,
0.8430647850036621,
-0.36037468910217285,
-0.06255794316530228,
0.3629988729953766,
-0.49338406324386597,
0.340984046459198,
0.3227689862251282,
0.24412187933921814,
-0.22048141062259674,
0.21115131676197052,
0.43684637546539307,
0.13779880106449127,
-1.0598374605178833,
0.4896332025527954,
-0.2562134265899658,
-0.1186484545469284,
-0.3561837077140808,
0.018849248066544533,
0.054293494671583176,
0.5882152318954468,
0.48157405853271484,
0.1570892333984375,
0.15938574075698853,
-0.5908684730529785,
0.2818460166454315,
0.49192285537719727,
-0.40229958295822144,
0.02116290293633938,
0.36571675539016724,
0.5555799603462219,
-0.3548426628112793,
0.23465611040592194,
-0.43606993556022644,
-0.1548788845539093,
0.7735205888748169,
0.09673391282558441,
1.0017648935317993,
-0.06572732329368591,
0.17784200608730316,
0.2771875560283661,
0.2971908450126648,
-0.034851301461458206,
0.4171071946620941,
-0.346927672624588,
-0.5904707908630371,
-0.4059326648712158,
-0.31172415614128113,
-0.6022363901138306,
0.04430178552865982,
-0.42802301049232483,
0.04236935079097748,
-0.4010452628135681,
-0.5480962991714478,
-0.06401702016592026,
0.2492857277393341,
-0.6120675206184387,
0.13165698945522308,
-0.06626611948013306,
0.9522897601127625,
-0.21852916479110718,
0.8359358310699463,
0.8736338019371033,
-0.14116987586021423,
-0.43188634514808655,
0.049049537628889084,
0.04964727908372879,
-0.765696108341217,
0.6130843758583069,
0.331269234418869,
-0.5653587579727173,
-0.349915087223053,
-0.07734425365924835,
-0.6349496841430664,
1.312514305114746,
0.18721039593219757,
-0.6288068294525146,
0.49613597989082336,
0.33102625608444214,
0.43845075368881226,
-0.5109651684761047,
0.6173670291900635,
0.555581271648407,
0.5495968461036682,
0.038222867995500565,
-1.089094638824463,
0.25248074531555176,
-0.469775527715683,
-0.011125616729259491,
0.09279510378837585,
-0.7585545778274536,
0.7192553281784058,
-0.33272963762283325,
-0.22121039032936096,
0.33959949016571045,
0.21146894991397858,
0.5491282939910889,
0.8749229907989502,
0.6072444319725037,
0.5169368982315063,
0.8230453729629517,
0.08272350579500198,
1.0432548522949219,
-0.3832266330718994,
0.07551873475313187,
1.0678901672363281,
-0.8253000378608704,
0.9440701007843018,
0.181716650724411,
-0.27317988872528076,
0.3537522852420807,
0.6752689480781555,
0.1417083442211151,
0.4858301877975464,
0.29749801754951477,
-0.5313785076141357,
-0.20467184484004974,
-0.14242960512638092,
-0.32259026169776917,
0.5217196345329285,
0.23492169380187988,
0.08961664140224457,
-0.18059411644935608,
-0.07497517764568329,
-0.11492012441158295,
-0.03921877220273018,
-0.45030108094215393,
0.5884430408477783,
-0.05854273587465286,
-0.8558528423309326,
0.6809056997299194,
0.13334111869335175,
0.290144681930542,
-0.38147443532943726,
0.22145846486091614,
-0.3039841651916504,
0.3672044277191162,
-0.22194966673851013,
-0.48718851804733276,
-0.05453511327505112,
0.05652816966176033,
-0.1586531102657318,
-0.15676169097423553,
0.8217336535453796,
0.14682991802692413,
-0.09536046534776688,
0.3331467807292938,
0.7818174958229065,
0.22028741240501404,
-0.3602662682533264,
-0.8842067718505859,
0.3790817856788635,
-0.22785592079162598,
-0.08678030967712402,
0.4220726788043976,
0.34580355882644653,
-0.38853856921195984,
1.0638988018035889,
0.5605801343917847,
-0.3599947392940521,
-0.031668100506067276,
0.1265915334224701,
0.8570324778556824,
-0.8552289009094238,
-0.2862488329410553,
-0.7967689633369446,
0.4244283139705658,
-0.2558828294277191,
-0.24494831264019012,
0.7119889259338379,
0.9728847146034241,
0.34027305245399475,
0.1725567877292633,
0.9153279662132263,
-0.16617682576179504,
0.488237589597702,
-0.26024138927459717,
0.558502733707428,
-0.5853614807128906,
0.44711652398109436,
-0.15319164097309113,
-0.8392607569694519,
0.19615891575813293,
0.4341272711753845,
-0.41714099049568176,
0.21634551882743835,
0.760758638381958,
0.7131959199905396,
0.027660250663757324,
-0.012572863139212132,
0.2657474875450134,
-0.19283169507980347,
-0.01724393665790558,
0.5728766918182373,
1.2546446323394775,
-0.34965524077415466,
0.7782421112060547,
-0.09973369538784027,
-0.33742836117744446,
-0.3571268618106842,
-0.8059656023979187,
-0.9320390224456787,
-0.3771504759788513,
-0.037483375519514084,
-0.2300504595041275,
0.10267225652933121,
0.8401914834976196,
0.806129515171051,
-0.3243793249130249,
-0.6547400951385498,
-0.18297657370567322,
0.2562788426876068,
-0.41519880294799805,
-0.09726601094007492,
0.07855799049139023,
-0.2914379835128784,
-0.40884900093078613,
0.7492799758911133,
0.2977275550365448,
-0.09395447373390198,
0.10472220927476883,
-0.413499653339386,
0.030141498893499374,
-0.0570514053106308,
0.7513523101806641,
0.5903328061103821,
-0.48831313848495483,
0.08034423738718033,
-0.02790340594947338,
-0.4708755314350128,
-0.09444035589694977,
0.9478294849395752,
-0.6946581602096558,
0.31167617440223694,
0.3064258098602295,
0.6161286234855652,
0.869160532951355,
0.14856040477752686,
0.5931056141853333,
-0.5450117588043213,
0.20804964005947113,
0.13946425914764404,
0.11002583056688309,
0.10623639076948166,
0.2118341326713562,
0.8483854532241821,
0.05050839111208916,
-0.6347627639770508,
-0.8986966609954834,
0.04028953239321709,
-1.110176682472229,
-0.13374756276607513,
1.169983148574829,
-0.10167405009269714,
-0.015549068339169025,
-0.19192475080490112,
-0.09095346182584763,
-0.04610750451683998,
-0.503737211227417,
0.5247616767883301,
0.5194023251533508,
-0.5088558793067932,
-0.11969256401062012,
-0.757091224193573,
0.33865925669670105,
0.3646193742752075,
-1.0752365589141846,
0.00394298043102026,
0.46245813369750977,
0.16600213944911957,
-0.05481594428420067,
1.0694591999053955,
0.023726439103484154,
0.4532908797264099,
0.2859487533569336,
0.18621179461479187,
-0.13000071048736572,
-0.1456686407327652,
0.19087281823158264,
0.1552043855190277,
0.13936491310596466,
-0.5130681395530701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00981v1 | VisEval: A Benchmark for Data Visualization in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T05:35:30 | 2024-07-01T05:35:30 | Nan Chen, Yuge Zhang, Jiahang Xu, Kan Ren, Yuqing Yang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Translating natural language to visualization (NL2VIS) has shown great
promise for visual data analysis, but it remains a challenging task that
requires multiple low-level implementations, such as natural language
processing and visualization design. Recent advancements in pre-trained large
language models (LLMs) are opening new avenues for generating visualizations
from natural language. However, the lack of a comprehensive and reliable
benchmark hinders our understanding of LLMs' capabilities in visualization
generation. In this paper, we address this gap by proposing a new NL2VIS
benchmark called VisEval. Firstly, we introduce a high-quality and large-scale
dataset. This dataset includes 2,524 representative queries covering 146
databases, paired with accurately labeled ground truths. Secondly, we advocate
for a comprehensive automated evaluation methodology covering multiple
dimensions, including validity, legality, and readability. By systematically
scanning for potential issues with a number of heterogeneous checkers, VisEval
provides reliable and trustworthy evaluation outcomes. We run VisEval on a
series of state-of-the-art LLMs. Our evaluation reveals prevalent challenges
and delivers essential insights for future advancements. | [
-0.12791097164154053,
-0.7465264797210693,
0.3656134605407715,
0.2386469841003418,
-0.3337264358997345,
0.11569879949092865,
-0.3628694713115692,
-0.4423096477985382,
-0.035191912204027176,
0.5548262000083923,
-0.20417307317256927,
-1.002792239189148,
-0.6581445932388306,
0.04083668813109398,
-0.5680614709854126,
0.7001297473907471,
-0.14343327283859253,
-0.030716784298419952,
-0.6275303363800049,
-0.3602927625179291,
-0.6595802307128906,
-0.30820491909980774,
-0.20514072477817535,
0.05236854776740074,
0.2993128299713135,
0.4409603774547577,
0.5843987464904785,
0.5608850717544556,
0.8204194903373718,
0.23728132247924805,
-0.011718465946614742,
0.4070103168487549,
-0.8721169233322144,
0.47130995988845825,
0.0158358346670866,
-0.4378204643726349,
-0.40318363904953003,
0.00045051390770822763,
0.721515417098999,
0.7710704803466797,
-0.045492593199014664,
0.509823203086853,
0.03829945996403694,
0.9986466765403748,
-0.7562285661697388,
0.4178638458251953,
-0.700637698173523,
0.07717496901750565,
-0.4019359052181244,
-0.13723346590995789,
-0.3544600009918213,
-0.9384886026382446,
0.49795427918434143,
-0.4764954745769501,
-0.08954468369483948,
0.23314182460308075,
0.6814112067222595,
0.47505873441696167,
-0.5421879887580872,
0.05099746212363243,
-0.6188097596168518,
0.8423104882240295,
-0.5520698428153992,
0.5781591534614563,
0.2548273205757141,
0.7871035933494568,
0.05374511703848839,
-0.9586622714996338,
-0.41641634702682495,
-0.16736024618148804,
0.24438035488128662,
0.038012970238924026,
-0.33232682943344116,
-0.5459466576576233,
0.2430710345506668,
0.23527967929840088,
-0.6911832094192505,
-0.14459356665611267,
-0.3911464512348175,
-0.1301691234111786,
0.5178879499435425,
0.3192494511604309,
0.23737549781799316,
-0.15877236425876617,
-0.5555023550987244,
-0.3042150139808655,
-0.8875643610954285,
-0.09351616352796555,
0.04839491844177246,
0.2908157408237457,
-0.2448836714029312,
0.754518449306488,
-0.15482406318187714,
0.7796227931976318,
-0.5567889213562012,
0.027593890205025673,
0.5011622905731201,
-0.3233003616333008,
-0.3468260169029236,
-0.07970626652240753,
0.7328254580497742,
0.8516174554824829,
0.5666823387145996,
-0.1586923599243164,
-0.09201590716838837,
-0.09084513038396835,
0.281889945268631,
-1.0511484146118164,
-0.16944700479507446,
0.13552004098892212,
-0.4855085611343384,
-0.3492957055568695,
-0.048220232129096985,
-1.0357944965362549,
-0.9354735612869263,
-0.5793907046318054,
0.12457346171140671,
-0.38052433729171753,
-0.27515649795532227,
0.0026264183688908815,
0.03188779577612877,
0.4874024987220764,
0.45284679532051086,
-0.38626471161842346,
0.20650005340576172,
0.8971297144889832,
0.9096711874008179,
-0.6038953065872192,
-0.26411503553390503,
-0.7680020928382874,
0.023478856310248375,
-0.7113034129142761,
0.8101039528846741,
-0.5609055757522583,
-0.20355606079101562,
0.34897127747535706,
-0.2206103801727295,
0.14373144507408142,
-0.685558557510376,
0.37383368611335754,
-0.47624632716178894,
-0.0007195973885245621,
-0.5803706049919128,
-0.5096385478973389,
-0.1361078917980194,
0.5636707544326782,
-0.46347710490226746,
0.8970420360565186,
-0.020210137590765953,
-0.9751662015914917,
0.6896849274635315,
-0.38375821709632874,
-0.4290347099304199,
0.24228350818157196,
-0.5763217210769653,
-0.3566366136074066,
0.0653197318315506,
0.18616239726543427,
0.30409321188926697,
-0.8896666169166565,
0.4251892864704132,
-0.1695287972688675,
-0.36170727014541626,
-0.02852434478700161,
-0.609676718711853,
0.5808236598968506,
-0.0009822644060477614,
-0.47383618354797363,
0.3214435279369354,
-0.86885005235672,
0.12623713910579681,
0.17663149535655975,
-0.16487643122673035,
-0.31259191036224365,
0.3647347092628479,
0.26722094416618347,
0.0038588123861700296,
0.33669552206993103,
-0.4147323966026306,
0.034244291484355927,
-0.4926934540271759,
-0.05161523073911667,
0.61683189868927,
-0.2052854746580124,
0.13690833747386932,
0.33968186378479004,
0.5328207015991211,
-0.08658865094184875,
0.1178920716047287,
0.17918646335601807,
-0.4703245162963867,
-0.840117871761322,
-0.15350478887557983,
0.12444940954446793,
0.5090639591217041,
-0.8754991292953491,
0.23504866659641266,
-0.6434506177902222,
-0.6432427167892456,
-0.38298240303993225,
0.07861064374446869,
0.2707664668560028,
0.6911007761955261,
0.4966118335723877,
0.04382273554801941,
-0.5437373518943787,
-1.1522198915481567,
-0.36538267135620117,
-0.18190795183181763,
-0.062304336577653885,
0.2584908902645111,
0.4976379871368408,
-0.42960628867149353,
1.0198071002960205,
-0.4956890940666199,
-0.3471011817455292,
-0.15582935512065887,
0.2686495780944824,
0.13864469528198242,
0.14891701936721802,
0.46788716316223145,
-0.6857038140296936,
-0.571007251739502,
0.26131385564804077,
-1.1288899183273315,
0.05654372274875641,
0.18269439041614532,
-0.20192573964595795,
-0.07941195368766785,
0.7236862778663635,
0.04601315036416054,
0.6277009844779968,
0.5287766456604004,
-0.36331480741500854,
0.38428375124931335,
-0.40790802240371704,
0.026790738105773926,
-0.7933921813964844,
0.2200060337781906,
-0.06020618975162506,
-0.2545841336250305,
-0.43343475461006165,
-0.1786237359046936,
0.3179352879524231,
-0.197468101978302,
-0.30789777636528015,
0.4846315383911133,
-0.5468604564666748,
-0.10957324504852295,
-0.14431285858154297,
0.16151076555252075,
-0.0029600015841424465,
-0.0012770189205184579,
-0.15701496601104736,
0.9065746068954468,
0.8120129108428955,
-0.21382509171962738,
0.6344481110572815,
0.3715268075466156,
-0.6212764978408813,
0.8990031480789185,
-1.0037599802017212,
0.017294874414801598,
-0.23102304339408875,
0.09185747057199478,
-0.897148609161377,
-0.09700875729322433,
-0.11597799509763718,
-0.07931572943925858,
0.13267697393894196,
0.07192882895469666,
-0.560580313205719,
-0.2639809846878052,
-0.5218269228935242,
0.2724083364009857,
0.4732992351055145,
-0.7924798727035522,
0.5479043126106262,
0.5720998644828796,
0.10352327674627304,
-0.5142325162887573,
-0.7590564489364624,
0.5115141868591309,
-0.10939385741949081,
-0.8585397601127625,
-0.07004967331886292,
0.05553610995411873,
-0.44185924530029297,
-0.25564080476760864,
-0.12712545692920685,
0.11517561972141266,
-0.12086209654808044,
0.35497328639030457,
0.43096789717674255,
-0.46396058797836304,
-0.03138021379709244,
-0.19105246663093567,
-0.15331698954105377,
0.1801099330186844,
-0.2189442366361618,
0.3077114224433899,
-0.5442774295806885,
-0.41765332221984863,
-0.27929744124412537,
0.12609624862670898,
0.6835290789604187,
-0.6396417617797852,
0.6516508460044861,
0.5398189425468445,
-0.3387546241283417,
-0.28641536831855774,
-0.6544305086135864,
0.27674567699432373,
-0.4026850163936615,
0.41261255741119385,
-0.15869171917438507,
-0.5123342871665955,
0.17150993645191193,
-0.1695747673511505,
0.149493008852005,
0.4544757008552551,
0.5442180037498474,
0.04923056811094284,
0.8674060702323914,
0.7204341888427734,
-0.0005397920613177121,
0.0712861567735672,
-0.28705868124961853,
0.26741766929626465,
-0.7235703468322754,
-0.5694987773895264,
-0.3679632842540741,
-0.19190800189971924,
-0.7042703628540039,
-0.7940595149993896,
0.5711899399757385,
-0.20185048878192902,
0.012536616064608097,
0.253438800573349,
-0.4502044916152954,
0.49180924892425537,
0.22842244803905487,
-0.4611101448535919,
0.1750740259885788,
0.15102910995483398,
-0.048043519258499146,
-0.3173033595085144,
-0.21546486020088196,
-0.7045412063598633,
1.3008896112442017,
0.27843910455703735,
0.6976045370101929,
0.2868058681488037,
0.48380911350250244,
0.34697866439819336,
0.337156742811203,
-0.550420343875885,
0.5934886932373047,
-0.22665444016456604,
-0.285796582698822,
-0.23065976798534393,
-0.3844299614429474,
-1.070827603340149,
0.5047433972358704,
-0.3103543817996979,
-0.7366642951965332,
0.43627116084098816,
0.07883179932832718,
0.09565131366252899,
0.18504223227500916,
-0.795946478843689,
0.976477861404419,
-0.33068403601646423,
-0.6315400004386902,
-0.059764835983514786,
-0.6102619171142578,
0.22907258570194244,
0.05024852976202965,
0.10237815976142883,
-0.3077211380004883,
-0.08186264336109161,
0.750999391078949,
-0.42277956008911133,
0.5123257040977478,
-0.2950531840324402,
-0.2137548178434372,
0.07263489067554474,
0.12528225779533386,
0.5526309609413147,
0.22112195193767548,
-0.17031973600387573,
0.10493865609169006,
-0.039088472723960876,
-0.33904722332954407,
-0.262360543012619,
0.958426296710968,
-0.4431358575820923,
-0.19608895480632782,
-0.5480504035949707,
-0.39405059814453125,
-0.6083645224571228,
0.2678563594818115,
0.08143424242734909,
0.6405430436134338,
-0.48942750692367554,
0.5924652814865112,
0.606288731098175,
-0.4598902761936188,
0.0578920915722847,
0.29796507954597473,
-0.471495121717453,
-0.23726777732372284,
1.2998396158218384,
-0.03532098978757858,
0.07041466236114502,
0.18231512606143951,
0.11301079392433167,
-0.4025360643863678,
-0.8002147674560547,
-0.34566211700439453,
0.06965155154466629,
-0.7554184198379517,
-0.1757054328918457,
-0.4853610694408417,
-0.02300128899514675,
-0.2577974200248718,
0.1216030865907669,
-0.5180751085281372,
0.005418343935161829,
-0.06133977696299553,
0.12996792793273926,
0.2767283618450165,
0.7711052298545837,
0.2452404946088791,
-0.29378291964530945,
-0.2849033772945404,
0.6249584555625916,
0.48172226548194885,
0.6600340604782104,
-0.07802660763263702,
-0.16620583832263947,
-0.04111665487289429,
-0.13291984796524048,
0.08926042169332504,
-0.5533541440963745,
0.29503652453422546,
0.050780463963747025,
0.492951899766922,
0.29955610632896423,
-0.14636988937854767,
0.519581139087677,
-0.7658015489578247,
0.6313621401786804,
0.28185173869132996,
-0.6246656179428101,
0.7078979015350342,
-0.20213420689105988,
0.33699673414230347,
0.9110480546951294,
0.034501802176237106,
-0.5108503699302673,
-0.16683277487754822,
-0.19186092913150787,
-1.1458690166473389,
0.3333663046360016,
0.25138241052627563,
-0.12112767994403839,
-0.012903321534395218,
-0.11615903675556183,
0.17099739611148834,
0.302166610956192,
-0.2263103425502777,
-0.3210887610912323,
-0.2987267076969147,
-0.08034583181142807,
-0.06393235176801682,
-0.3086755573749542,
-0.07307329773902893,
-0.364531010389328,
0.2287375032901764,
-0.16634482145309448,
-0.19365257024765015,
-0.02938885986804962,
-0.39284709095954895,
0.23483964800834656,
0.050788745284080505,
0.3971441090106964,
1.0689581632614136,
-0.48832228779792786,
0.28285273909568787,
0.10886096209287643,
-0.4462948441505432,
-0.24229593575000763,
0.11946111172437668,
-0.19056367874145508,
0.02469523437321186,
0.4798506796360016,
1.0268008708953857,
-0.13292838633060455,
-0.8985958099365234,
0.9817460775375366,
-0.35246139764785767,
-0.12340899556875229,
-0.21586832404136658,
-0.19316765666007996,
0.17488960921764374,
0.19691474735736847,
0.28759199380874634,
-0.00022653662017546594,
0.27364954352378845,
-0.32404130697250366,
-0.0277490746229887,
0.5263687372207642,
-0.4968984127044678,
-0.11708999425172806,
0.8542301654815674,
0.37324437499046326,
-0.16045045852661133,
0.4323936700820923,
-0.018230829387903214,
-0.08517611771821976,
0.4612484872341156,
0.16288962960243225,
0.8117923140525818,
0.19040793180465698,
0.1387319564819336,
0.37898769974708557,
0.48371249437332153,
0.03352344036102295,
0.43916869163513184,
0.040673740208148956,
-0.15416492521762848,
-0.31652575731277466,
-0.6169103384017944,
-0.5293140411376953,
-0.045497022569179535,
-0.7548477053642273,
0.18877698481082916,
-0.27762386202812195,
0.01680401898920536,
-0.003077553818002343,
-0.2729637622833252,
-0.9803948402404785,
0.25103461742401123,
0.3893386423587799,
0.8701812028884888,
-0.6092982292175293,
0.6828760504722595,
0.38222536444664,
-0.20741888880729675,
-0.1816767305135727,
0.14536337554454803,
0.1014091894030571,
-0.784900963306427,
0.7001132965087891,
0.26183587312698364,
-0.3688121736049652,
-0.4360002875328064,
-0.5995698571205139,
-0.7481656670570374,
1.0166034698486328,
0.4923847019672394,
-0.6306117177009583,
0.260503888130188,
0.3846811056137085,
0.8025649785995483,
-0.17697741091251373,
0.11779346317052841,
0.8581846952438354,
0.7052974700927734,
-0.08409103006124496,
-0.4830681085586548,
-0.024623101577162743,
-0.43936842679977417,
0.32699909806251526,
-0.0051030549220740795,
-0.235828697681427,
0.6003348231315613,
-0.1699051856994629,
-0.27858272194862366,
-0.2745203673839569,
0.9310902953147888,
0.1436391919851303,
0.1666487455368042,
0.4825727939605713,
0.1330508291721344,
0.9313189387321472,
-0.20481595396995544,
1.2793104648590088,
-0.12827737629413605,
0.23348043859004974,
1.2025476694107056,
-0.6247742176055908,
1.0413267612457275,
0.6196603775024414,
-0.1124143972992897,
0.2710500955581665,
0.032211076468229294,
-0.22403594851493835,
0.48657891154289246,
0.4848276674747467,
0.20601283013820648,
-0.1873142421245575,
-0.22796578705310822,
-0.6089839935302734,
0.4329325258731842,
0.12099988758563995,
0.011480388231575489,
-0.39731886982917786,
-0.04335968941450119,
-0.3550014793872833,
0.40433579683303833,
0.14281636476516724,
0.551474928855896,
-0.1937209963798523,
-0.3243758976459503,
0.8380843997001648,
-0.3224014341831207,
0.6466791033744812,
-0.42254528403282166,
-0.09863141924142838,
-0.24161739647388458,
0.11302340775728226,
-0.06312844902276993,
-0.8549675345420837,
0.17448388040065765,
0.4135332703590393,
0.13593772053718567,
-0.22645825147628784,
0.5708155632019043,
-0.3274940252304077,
-0.6710164546966553,
0.4964238107204437,
0.6122351884841919,
0.1393895447254181,
-0.07189729809761047,
-0.4228307008743286,
0.29752877354621887,
0.013820748776197433,
-0.33264002203941345,
0.11293820291757584,
0.4948215186595917,
-0.04103093594312668,
0.6310832500457764,
0.5916585326194763,
0.208823099732399,
0.09695347398519516,
0.5805301666259766,
0.6992929577827454,
-0.5868973135948181,
-0.19725292921066284,
-0.8341630101203918,
0.5198780298233032,
-0.5623785853385925,
-0.4800035357475281,
0.8294574618339539,
0.9786626696586609,
0.26782920956611633,
0.1492086946964264,
0.692571759223938,
0.2286301851272583,
0.5103687047958374,
-0.35780689120292664,
0.9071313142776489,
-0.7743632197380066,
0.2673645615577698,
-0.2009330838918686,
-1.0398659706115723,
-0.4575214385986328,
0.3996155261993408,
-0.373121440410614,
-0.3758682310581207,
0.6676949858665466,
0.5160520076751709,
-0.05756505951285362,
-0.07244662195444107,
0.28585872054100037,
0.3146781623363495,
0.6217970848083496,
0.1977171003818512,
0.7857977151870728,
-0.3344985246658325,
0.64113849401474,
0.000022636009816778824,
-0.18486325442790985,
-0.2791360914707184,
-0.9942994117736816,
-1.0578011274337769,
-0.48484236001968384,
-0.32235023379325867,
-0.1525203287601471,
0.020849529653787613,
0.6861130595207214,
0.5899393558502197,
-0.8005263209342957,
-0.29439541697502136,
-0.061286404728889465,
-0.049922145903110504,
-0.005610177293419838,
-0.1161055937409401,
0.7027246952056885,
-0.12896126508712769,
-0.5711274743080139,
0.6467437744140625,
0.6689801216125488,
-0.23378027975559235,
-0.4230775833129883,
0.016985571011900902,
-0.10009802877902985,
-0.0028671773616224527,
0.678881824016571,
0.0009718789369799197,
-0.7012338042259216,
-0.15450741350650787,
-0.03480001538991928,
-0.3247062563896179,
0.26939263939857483,
0.5105853080749512,
-0.7533597946166992,
0.7912268042564392,
0.7009958028793335,
0.8776448369026184,
0.6288533806800842,
-0.2575048506259918,
0.5409737229347229,
-0.5799100995063782,
0.08100810647010803,
0.2314988672733307,
0.39105427265167236,
0.6452885270118713,
0.13005761802196503,
0.5886666774749756,
-0.20362719893455505,
-0.20865800976753235,
-1.0642503499984741,
-0.08622974157333374,
-1.0243375301361084,
0.02677275985479355,
1.2601938247680664,
0.15754926204681396,
-0.35903751850128174,
0.10628766566514969,
-0.2469598352909088,
0.028881268575787544,
-0.07748568803071976,
0.4906526207923889,
0.4630950391292572,
0.24426515400409698,
0.3576172888278961,
-0.9398750066757202,
0.39778614044189453,
0.36958977580070496,
-1.2707836627960205,
0.4836592674255371,
0.5120710730552673,
0.08214370161294937,
-0.01642976701259613,
0.335790753364563,
-0.11520722508430481,
0.1375158131122589,
-0.14668050408363342,
0.02799961343407631,
0.02528613619506359,
-0.3573361933231354,
-0.21225886046886444,
0.1808522641658783,
0.1578446328639984,
-0.18994691967964172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00958v1 | Universal Approximation Theory: The basic theory for large language models | 2024-07-01T04:29:35 | 2024-07-01T04:29:35 | Wei Wang, Qing Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models have emerged as a critical area of focus in artificial
intelligence, particularly with the introduction of groundbreaking innovations
like ChatGPT. Large-scale Transformer networks have quickly become the leading
approach for advancing natural language processing algorithms. Built on the
Transformer architecture, these models enable interactions that closely mimic
human communication and, equipped with extensive knowledge, can even assist in
guiding human tasks. Despite their impressive capabilities and growing
complexity, a key question remains-the theoretical foundations of large
language models (LLMs). What makes Transformer so effective for powering
intelligent language applications, such as translation and coding? What
underlies LLMs' ability for In-Context Learning (ICL)? How does the LoRA scheme
enhance the fine-tuning of LLMs? And what supports the practicality of pruning
LLMs? To address these critical questions and explore the technological
strategies within LLMs, we leverage the Universal Approximation Theory (UAT) to
offer a theoretical backdrop, shedding light on the mechanisms that underpin
these advancements. | [
-0.4767851233482361,
-0.8151686191558838,
0.7239698171615601,
0.10976461321115494,
0.1314505636692047,
0.11471528559923172,
-0.48124074935913086,
-0.2753286063671112,
-0.27153879404067993,
0.507750928401947,
-0.5091060996055603,
0.0023880263324826956,
-0.3930261731147766,
-0.021514294669032097,
-0.7936654090881348,
0.7134919166564941,
0.27530980110168457,
-0.13889795541763306,
0.18565431237220764,
0.01203931961208582,
-0.26142892241477966,
-0.6854245066642761,
-0.6131766438484192,
-0.8051175475120544,
0.34452441334724426,
0.39494362473487854,
0.8243005871772766,
0.542387068271637,
0.6802309155464172,
0.4198508858680725,
-0.292353093624115,
-0.1041080430150032,
-0.23904554545879364,
-0.08256608992815018,
-0.02196911908686161,
-0.7411884069442749,
-0.12453670054674149,
-0.1284947693347931,
0.8273898959159851,
1.0951311588287354,
-0.18293826282024384,
-0.1563318371772766,
0.216445654630661,
0.7208906412124634,
-0.15094159543514252,
0.04512183368206024,
-0.8266063332557678,
0.0633402094244957,
0.0504506453871727,
-0.01850960962474346,
-0.5818803310394287,
-0.20525851845741272,
0.21842701733112335,
-0.35683396458625793,
0.19801151752471924,
-0.0007368323276750743,
0.6300488114356995,
0.17500390112400055,
-0.5586777329444885,
-0.12213557213544846,
-1.1748052835464478,
0.8092038035392761,
-0.6321696639060974,
0.3676873743534088,
0.011550888419151306,
0.30018532276153564,
-0.5089181661605835,
-0.7979502081871033,
-0.624059796333313,
-0.4343099892139435,
0.00980199035257101,
-0.13356654345989227,
-0.40919971466064453,
0.43671557307243347,
0.24073706567287445,
0.4280269742012024,
-0.19664207100868225,
0.33679279685020447,
-0.2626296281814575,
0.22097602486610413,
0.34109264612197876,
0.07854366302490234,
0.37564700841903687,
-0.06368756294250488,
-0.29919853806495667,
0.17468330264091492,
-0.8787204623222351,
-0.1771930307149887,
-0.030916668474674225,
0.18624910712242126,
0.10598235577344894,
0.5495290160179138,
0.023939264938235283,
0.4860765337944031,
-0.12263146787881851,
0.14279405772686005,
-0.23458921909332275,
-0.19298526644706726,
-0.43434780836105347,
-0.31197452545166016,
0.8246433734893799,
0.100799560546875,
0.6443292498588562,
-0.46649205684661865,
-0.05003080144524574,
0.20408675074577332,
0.3136500418186188,
-0.5202802419662476,
0.08967173099517822,
-0.08729120343923569,
-0.15266302227973938,
-0.2761629521846771,
0.10890309512615204,
-0.6145989298820496,
-0.27305859327316284,
-0.5812591910362244,
0.4177902936935425,
-0.38927486538887024,
-0.20194336771965027,
0.05208772420883179,
0.17351707816123962,
0.48845601081848145,
0.18962374329566956,
-0.8585742712020874,
0.7886713147163391,
0.9142177104949951,
0.6572690606117249,
-0.04114098474383354,
-0.5029562711715698,
-0.020413929596543312,
0.23457524180412292,
-0.35988736152648926,
0.8519226908683777,
-0.40022239089012146,
-0.32630854845046997,
0.03632637858390808,
-0.10975094884634018,
-0.08621368557214737,
-0.34119993448257446,
0.5632900595664978,
-0.6799027919769287,
-0.014922164380550385,
-0.08844102919101715,
-0.6239855885505676,
-0.38151970505714417,
-0.15787316858768463,
-0.7031373977661133,
0.7546846270561218,
-0.020927518606185913,
-0.4806830883026123,
-0.1494506597518921,
-1.1804407835006714,
-0.4270399510860443,
0.07069595158100128,
0.07771565020084381,
0.022729923948645592,
0.477939248085022,
0.038282182067632675,
0.4723169803619385,
-0.7548483610153198,
0.28067833185195923,
-0.04703341796994209,
-0.4458266794681549,
0.43933865427970886,
-0.8418877124786377,
0.7693777084350586,
0.3714107871055603,
-0.16948096454143524,
0.07199608534574509,
-0.350982129573822,
-0.0767984390258789,
0.31056609749794006,
-0.33541643619537354,
-0.193144753575325,
0.07670708745718002,
0.1283002644777298,
-0.043051302433013916,
-0.16287703812122345,
-0.3113981783390045,
0.39878591895103455,
-0.5034478902816772,
0.9227146506309509,
0.5925574898719788,
-0.16925501823425293,
0.8156802654266357,
-0.1195182204246521,
0.3918761610984802,
-0.44122546911239624,
0.24854779243469238,
-0.30916884541511536,
-0.34079402685165405,
-0.8292553424835205,
-0.006222215015441179,
0.4073050618171692,
0.5568659901618958,
-0.3826977014541626,
0.4474760591983795,
-0.6317869424819946,
-0.45513346791267395,
-0.4094708561897278,
0.2667538821697235,
0.21117162704467773,
0.1656806468963623,
0.12842604517936707,
-0.08541470766067505,
-0.5212373733520508,
-0.7925030589103699,
-0.2154797613620758,
0.01100622396916151,
-0.3559107482433319,
-0.06065736338496208,
0.34181711077690125,
-0.3291638493537903,
1.245222806930542,
-0.266753226518631,
-0.1405991166830063,
-0.4951685070991516,
-0.2570444941520691,
0.559826672077179,
0.2578006684780121,
0.32646867632865906,
-0.9580742120742798,
-0.36349111795425415,
0.16888530552387238,
-0.6657804250717163,
0.10828851908445358,
0.12493352591991425,
0.19444505870342255,
0.03149589151144028,
0.541074812412262,
-0.8751490116119385,
0.39351320266723633,
0.5959029793739319,
-0.06518657505512238,
0.44088754057884216,
-0.36805200576782227,
-0.22884783148765564,
-1.077994465827942,
-0.10848204791545868,
0.1649768054485321,
-0.14785952866077423,
-0.9761714339256287,
0.25946059823036194,
-0.15263138711452484,
-0.15349742770195007,
-0.31512272357940674,
0.6495656371116638,
-0.5366257429122925,
-0.10377699881792068,
-0.3918340504169464,
0.31423166394233704,
-0.2969701886177063,
0.48720380663871765,
-0.2064390480518341,
0.7109182476997375,
0.4142628312110901,
-0.6742122173309326,
0.35442978143692017,
0.005415951833128929,
-0.3462582528591156,
0.450161874294281,
-0.797645628452301,
0.04142215475440025,
-0.0525667704641819,
0.2997976839542389,
-0.9486457109451294,
-0.26494669914245605,
-0.3261176645755768,
-0.2775755822658539,
0.22798103094100952,
-0.10326925665140152,
-0.42541688680648804,
-0.5896180272102356,
-0.10448110103607178,
0.34696894884109497,
0.8472849130630493,
-0.6818922162055969,
0.8574231863021851,
0.5561481714248657,
-0.03127821907401085,
-0.43445831537246704,
-0.6017796397209167,
0.23515088856220245,
-0.2426755577325821,
-0.48319146037101746,
0.24528242647647858,
-0.3507276177406311,
-0.5822691917419434,
-0.24175848066806793,
0.1397891640663147,
-0.24722671508789062,
0.2194991260766983,
0.19272032380104065,
0.1109546422958374,
-0.3350752890110016,
0.03281269967556,
-0.29190221428871155,
-0.14967332780361176,
0.06756529957056046,
-0.26202496886253357,
0.7023555040359497,
-0.4650144875049591,
-0.4514676034450531,
-0.43176230788230896,
0.11867925524711609,
0.7200311422348022,
0.2861662805080414,
0.5075026750564575,
0.3102220296859741,
-0.2590698003768921,
-0.2367791086435318,
-0.645440936088562,
-0.16966019570827484,
-0.5372190475463867,
0.49706578254699707,
-0.413910448551178,
-0.7675471901893616,
0.49039432406425476,
-0.34508904814720154,
0.16838863492012024,
0.5293754935264587,
0.6378577351570129,
-0.05647914856672287,
0.8894477486610413,
0.9491737484931946,
-0.48559457063674927,
0.5415793061256409,
-0.3603855073451996,
0.3933001756668091,
-0.9902493357658386,
0.1902685910463333,
-0.47060441970825195,
-0.12490154057741165,
-0.515725314617157,
-0.263173907995224,
0.24578185379505157,
0.23811422288417816,
-0.3294568359851837,
0.4574132561683655,
-0.26562103629112244,
0.8222584128379822,
0.6751949787139893,
-0.18452101945877075,
0.5354438424110413,
0.282772421836853,
-0.11036407202482224,
0.2623108923435211,
-0.897549033164978,
-0.49243563413619995,
0.853192150592804,
0.6329214572906494,
0.6281213760375977,
-0.002851471770554781,
0.04456693306565285,
0.25885018706321716,
0.48493725061416626,
-1.0717722177505493,
0.568022608757019,
-0.06676509976387024,
-0.5407370328903198,
-0.4804098308086395,
-0.29812315106391907,
-1.019520878791809,
0.24622169137001038,
0.08129000663757324,
-0.8401517271995544,
-0.21714864671230316,
0.08973602205514908,
-0.02909078635275364,
0.6824443936347961,
-0.7641751170158386,
0.3913450539112091,
-0.0503324456512928,
0.042360927909612656,
-0.21150007843971252,
-0.6678224802017212,
0.27817636728286743,
-0.1448364406824112,
0.5216813087463379,
0.010712288320064545,
0.04826123267412186,
0.7030707001686096,
-0.2033149152994156,
0.8770722150802612,
0.16962870955467224,
-0.2906757593154907,
0.41547977924346924,
0.16505813598632812,
0.3160623013973236,
-0.27149564027786255,
-0.21518529951572418,
0.3133561313152313,
-0.15991991758346558,
-0.32986846566200256,
-0.6026096343994141,
0.5813260674476624,
-0.7921692728996277,
-0.5642777681350708,
-0.06574080139398575,
-0.7264629602432251,
-0.255378782749176,
0.19732868671417236,
0.3602791428565979,
0.4163249731063843,
-0.428910493850708,
0.28057119250297546,
0.5334752798080444,
0.18644310534000397,
0.776301920413971,
0.2800680994987488,
-0.36648887395858765,
-0.3127087652683258,
0.6490699052810669,
0.0333048440515995,
0.3364309072494507,
0.493126779794693,
0.20850758254528046,
-0.2011810541152954,
-0.49513670802116394,
-0.18325680494308472,
0.42754024267196655,
-0.9415350556373596,
-0.06252066791057587,
-0.4507441222667694,
-0.5854917764663696,
-0.07656814903020859,
-0.21423675119876862,
-0.2905476987361908,
-0.2928315997123718,
0.03223872557282448,
-0.08269373327493668,
0.3745047450065613,
1.3481426239013672,
0.07968565076589584,
0.8031262159347534,
-0.6002408266067505,
0.07927315682172775,
0.4952443540096283,
0.38336631655693054,
0.1865769773721695,
-0.7079529166221619,
-0.16132071614265442,
0.17623071372509003,
-0.2166074514389038,
-0.46032533049583435,
0.09740719199180603,
0.2491026520729065,
0.548608124256134,
0.20232130587100983,
-0.2713227868080139,
0.3919176757335663,
-0.8907291889190674,
0.671660304069519,
0.24371448159217834,
-0.9757633805274963,
0.008669829927384853,
-0.4024238586425781,
0.24119830131530762,
0.23173756897449493,
0.22692586481571198,
-0.7555170059204102,
-0.0427565835416317,
-0.5491287112236023,
-0.7149655222892761,
0.34170567989349365,
0.26685062050819397,
0.47592729330062866,
0.20763787627220154,
0.48521846532821655,
-0.1455949991941452,
0.052937671542167664,
-1.0334227085113525,
-0.3076043725013733,
0.1280944049358368,
-0.45801177620887756,
-0.11669675260782242,
-0.3046620488166809,
-0.0011269213864579797,
-0.20836715400218964,
0.4385529160499573,
-0.3491046726703644,
0.5383980870246887,
-0.07611551135778427,
-0.11698727309703827,
-0.16555236279964447,
0.5423739552497864,
0.4592680037021637,
0.8672906160354614,
0.13388772308826447,
0.0921410471200943,
0.3895686864852905,
-0.4191073179244995,
0.27677419781684875,
-0.215122789144516,
-0.1866462230682373,
-0.22042438387870789,
0.3276030123233795,
0.8077540397644043,
0.3619174361228943,
-0.5282886028289795,
0.32869112491607666,
-0.19741331040859222,
-0.22866006195545197,
-0.5122603178024292,
0.0997655987739563,
0.09746304154396057,
0.33166760206222534,
0.7935563325881958,
0.06698697805404663,
-0.17101216316223145,
-0.5102129578590393,
0.1317189782857895,
0.7078626751899719,
-0.5074098110198975,
-0.578362226486206,
0.42466071248054504,
0.10824701935052872,
-0.7885328531265259,
0.4236077070236206,
0.4025067090988159,
-0.7286854386329651,
0.5832459330558777,
0.7595607042312622,
0.8574773669242859,
-0.28402259945869446,
-0.013478796929121017,
-0.1139754205942154,
0.4884556531906128,
-0.27943941950798035,
-0.22806315124034882,
0.05392323061823845,
-0.7412737607955933,
-0.7635952234268188,
-0.7936298251152039,
-0.512069582939148,
0.13951583206653595,
-0.3122223913669586,
0.1814199686050415,
-0.4332360327243805,
0.0777621641755104,
-0.14977283775806427,
-0.0647970661520958,
-0.6563506722450256,
0.015212428756058216,
0.2112380415201187,
1.0390923023223877,
-0.6562997102737427,
0.9650397300720215,
0.4300723373889923,
-0.17255644500255585,
-0.8622997403144836,
0.005989813711494207,
-0.16008467972278595,
-0.7837103605270386,
0.5420576333999634,
0.020483283326029778,
-0.09208296984434128,
0.26433175802230835,
-0.5754279494285583,
-1.0185805559158325,
0.8021245002746582,
0.6086043119430542,
-0.6068634986877441,
-0.4113929271697998,
0.20913054049015045,
0.5204733610153198,
-0.26001232862472534,
0.266011118888855,
0.8717060089111328,
0.46333521604537964,
0.18788155913352966,
-1.0969300270080566,
-0.14574076235294342,
-0.14902731776237488,
0.19320085644721985,
0.37925800681114197,
-0.5120425820350647,
0.5640196800231934,
-0.3446817100048065,
0.012314993888139725,
0.25684285163879395,
0.6487410068511963,
-0.027941105887293816,
-0.15712426602840424,
0.5041452050209045,
0.28237223625183105,
0.3655294179916382,
-0.09674011170864105,
1.2243198156356812,
-0.23899111151695251,
0.4432804584503174,
0.6874949932098389,
-0.17085348069667816,
0.7871152758598328,
0.46767735481262207,
-0.5907044410705566,
0.42613938450813293,
0.1310478299856186,
0.061538197100162506,
0.07831993699073792,
0.22642379999160767,
-0.16861176490783691,
0.12044093757867813,
-0.1568179726600647,
-0.09764103591442108,
0.41143131256103516,
0.5758151412010193,
-0.14124292135238647,
-0.14782178401947021,
0.0627250149846077,
0.19551706314086914,
0.03598623722791672,
-0.4939631521701813,
0.9206377267837524,
0.22978538274765015,
-0.5582592487335205,
0.5064173936843872,
-0.09554637968540192,
0.7403536438941956,
-0.7134565114974976,
0.12222254276275635,
-0.1390099674463272,
0.3178659975528717,
0.060171179473400116,
-0.724651038646698,
0.13127341866493225,
-0.16633708775043488,
-0.1735973060131073,
0.20102190971374512,
0.6250202059745789,
-0.28572309017181396,
-0.5396782755851746,
0.4277206063270569,
0.3154732882976532,
-0.06512174010276794,
-0.03114587999880314,
-0.5438482165336609,
0.01243526116013527,
-0.12560515105724335,
-0.5101099014282227,
0.2544323801994324,
0.4744725823402405,
0.0784253180027008,
0.9336300492286682,
0.480454683303833,
0.16960570216178894,
0.0030190590769052505,
-0.06680606305599213,
0.8190876245498657,
-0.7545849084854126,
-0.2394668012857437,
-1.0537049770355225,
0.25342273712158203,
0.1559421718120575,
0.06886963546276093,
0.6470911502838135,
0.07121594250202179,
0.6355571746826172,
0.07301978021860123,
0.8051181435585022,
0.0167782474309206,
0.31102097034454346,
-0.47332894802093506,
0.5493931174278259,
-0.3146723508834839,
0.298046737909317,
-0.3233451545238495,
-1.2503080368041992,
-0.5442179441452026,
0.4087276756763458,
-0.3950687348842621,
0.08934058248996735,
0.6920022368431091,
0.5260756611824036,
-0.18742911517620087,
0.11787094175815582,
0.5903940200805664,
0.42269042134284973,
0.4948440194129944,
0.38621068000793457,
0.7214494347572327,
-0.5283018946647644,
0.6916382908821106,
-0.20302347838878632,
-0.16132554411888123,
-0.18108050525188446,
-0.9806020855903625,
-0.8019943833351135,
-0.6132042407989502,
0.26101988554000854,
-0.06332869082689285,
-0.158756822347641,
1.199966311454773,
0.7477970123291016,
-0.7063803672790527,
-0.6430152058601379,
-0.3315046727657318,
0.13124290108680725,
-0.003593351459130645,
-0.1751396209001541,
0.33288803696632385,
-0.27330100536346436,
-0.7113203406333923,
0.4931792914867401,
0.2827279567718506,
0.09109728783369064,
-0.3190935254096985,
-0.12902112305164337,
-0.11437001079320908,
0.3818354606628418,
0.7881362438201904,
0.4417257308959961,
-0.7912602424621582,
-0.061889320611953735,
-0.07744723558425903,
0.0008527308818884194,
0.15516877174377441,
0.8869977593421936,
-0.8239531517028809,
-0.04914376512169838,
0.06859201937913895,
0.8323060870170593,
0.037425607442855835,
-0.0343276746571064,
0.7122246623039246,
-0.5320597887039185,
0.3915136158466339,
0.08644844591617584,
0.4704554080963135,
0.3536628186702728,
-0.014512400142848492,
0.7315847277641296,
0.20311547815799713,
-0.8341626524925232,
-0.9242008924484253,
0.46923378109931946,
-0.6270067095756531,
-0.33601534366607666,
1.0366500616073608,
0.264995276927948,
-0.6393907070159912,
-0.054153915494680405,
-0.29550978541374207,
0.0563310906291008,
-0.18384574353694916,
0.7040538787841797,
0.48715201020240784,
-0.030240342020988464,
-0.1642017662525177,
-0.5964006185531616,
0.42368084192276,
0.4485747516155243,
-0.6582333445549011,
0.3169853985309601,
0.1162136122584343,
0.22806483507156372,
0.33285340666770935,
0.42101946473121643,
0.2223237007856369,
0.07466822117567062,
-0.3454802632331848,
0.0037740361876785755,
0.259462833404541,
-0.4508494734764099,
-0.5264506936073303,
0.24919898808002472,
0.3804891109466553,
0.3787718117237091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00952v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00952v1 | SplitLoRA: A Split Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T04:13:25 | 2024-07-01T04:13:25 | Zheng Lin, Xuanjie Hu, Yuxin Zhang, Zhe Chen, Zihan Fang, Xianhao Chen, Ang Li, Praneeth Vepakomma, Yue Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | The scalability of large language models (LLMs) in handling high-complexity
models and large-scale datasets has led to tremendous successes in pivotal
domains. While there is an urgent need to acquire more training data for LLMs,
a concerning reality is the depletion of high-quality public datasets within a
few years. In view of this, the federated learning (FL) LLM fine-tuning
paradigm recently has been proposed to facilitate collaborative LLM fine-tuning
on distributed private data, where multiple data owners collaboratively
fine-tune a shared LLM without sharing raw data. However, the staggering model
size of LLMs imposes heavy computing and communication burdens on clients,
posing significant barriers to the democratization of the FL LLM fine-tuning
paradigm. To address this issue, split learning (SL) has emerged as a promising
solution by offloading the primary training workload to a server via model
partitioning while exchanging activation/activation's gradients with smaller
data sizes rather than the entire LLM. Unfortunately, research on the SL LLM
fine-tuning paradigm is still in its nascent stage. To fill this gap, in this
paper, we propose the first SL LLM fine-tuning framework, named SplitLoRA.
SplitLoRA is built on the split federated learning (SFL) framework,
amalgamating the advantages of parallel training from FL and model splitting
from SL and thus greatly enhancing the training efficiency. It is worth noting
that SplitLoRA is the inaugural open-source benchmark for SL LLM fine-tuning,
providing a foundation for research efforts dedicated to advancing SL LLM
fine-tuning. Extensive simulations validate that SplitLoRA achieves target
accuracy in significantly less time than state-of-the-art LLM fine-tuning
frameworks, demonstrating the superior training performance of SplitLoRA. The
project page is available at https://fduinc.github.io/splitlora/. | [
-0.572391152381897,
-0.5941342115402222,
0.3560088872909546,
0.3337140381336212,
-0.3947746753692627,
0.16641400754451752,
-0.5890491008758545,
-0.3366248309612274,
-0.06571138650178909,
0.26813799142837524,
-0.5999878644943237,
-0.4883982241153717,
-0.34342676401138306,
-0.10266478359699249,
-0.18577514588832855,
0.9343388080596924,
0.051144253462553024,
0.254545122385025,
0.1579606682062149,
-0.378545343875885,
-0.1469925493001938,
-0.12234164774417877,
-0.6919469237327576,
-0.32411402463912964,
0.950298547744751,
0.5745798349380493,
0.6434484124183655,
0.7999004125595093,
0.44823846220970154,
0.24077771604061127,
-0.22009898722171783,
0.6286554932594299,
-0.82366544008255,
-0.02780892699956894,
-0.24058622121810913,
-0.6746057868003845,
-0.40232792496681213,
0.11583687365055084,
0.7937152981758118,
0.7777128219604492,
-0.2514950633049011,
0.46307992935180664,
-0.07458636909723282,
0.9497344493865967,
-0.8029387593269348,
0.3395530879497528,
-0.6206902861595154,
0.058743853121995926,
-0.23804044723510742,
-0.1607382744550705,
-0.47519826889038086,
-0.4199107587337494,
-0.10589459538459778,
-0.47350823879241943,
0.3543040454387665,
0.09882263839244843,
0.7642810344696045,
0.4466097950935364,
-0.18084530532360077,
0.04043833538889885,
-0.74151211977005,
0.5685937404632568,
-0.7622551321983337,
0.486539363861084,
-0.04580206423997879,
0.3779522478580475,
-0.00662994384765625,
-0.4521853029727936,
-0.3441378176212311,
0.31159135699272156,
0.0774238333106041,
-0.2764023244380951,
0.028412839397788048,
0.15141259133815765,
-0.0021854715887457132,
0.6378785371780396,
-0.5848844647407532,
0.5116408467292786,
-0.40526121854782104,
0.12762542068958282,
0.6786215901374817,
-0.06106920912861824,
0.1716603934764862,
0.6458067893981934,
-0.3912079930305481,
0.06382457166910172,
-0.8235961198806763,
-0.28032001852989197,
0.2927771806716919,
0.8604214787483215,
-0.17023475468158722,
0.13891121745109558,
-0.22380118072032928,
0.7331113815307617,
0.13685807585716248,
-0.15580099821090698,
0.3011322319507599,
-0.1181824654340744,
-0.6037900447845459,
0.15776270627975464,
0.5114486217498779,
0.08737485855817795,
0.12674576044082642,
-0.10525263100862503,
-0.21683740615844727,
-0.05139778554439545,
-0.11963559687137604,
-0.910733163356781,
-0.22246474027633667,
0.26266735792160034,
-0.25160467624664307,
-0.29050013422966003,
-0.022369449958205223,
-0.857900083065033,
-0.46235352754592896,
-0.5534855127334595,
0.08706587553024292,
-0.0612090602517128,
-0.5294845104217529,
0.16740919649600983,
0.4588254392147064,
0.23732483386993408,
0.49306344985961914,
-0.9473523497581482,
0.191338911652565,
1.3652920722961426,
1.040544033050537,
-0.39327025413513184,
-0.533410906791687,
-0.8251572847366333,
-0.26449188590049744,
-0.31291499733924866,
0.4771933853626251,
-0.17312879860401154,
0.130507230758667,
0.1819884479045868,
0.002757691778242588,
-0.313783198595047,
-0.6353234052658081,
0.1893388032913208,
-0.7768197655677795,
0.09853135794401169,
-0.08607150614261627,
-0.7022885084152222,
-0.16544397175312042,
0.14197397232055664,
-0.6834233403205872,
0.4992184638977051,
0.0035313281696289778,
-0.663828432559967,
0.43763434886932373,
-0.4088110029697418,
-0.20602944493293762,
0.22415843605995178,
-0.05363357812166214,
-0.5796856880187988,
0.16430248320102692,
0.09284061938524246,
0.30449408292770386,
-0.5455095171928406,
0.32406216859817505,
-0.6467777490615845,
-0.3664005696773529,
-0.19422675669193268,
-0.4479212164878845,
0.7241831421852112,
0.34777799248695374,
-0.197052001953125,
0.41290363669395447,
-0.7853825092315674,
0.21077042818069458,
-0.08167465031147003,
-0.5918460488319397,
-0.16883033514022827,
-0.24057671427726746,
0.2527851462364197,
0.20695151388645172,
0.4305252134799957,
-0.5818912386894226,
0.24708610773086548,
-0.6019085049629211,
0.24619202315807343,
0.8171744346618652,
-0.26973289251327515,
0.5700150728225708,
-0.20738554000854492,
0.4665454924106598,
0.00803329236805439,
0.37347865104675293,
0.07125859707593918,
-0.08359149843454361,
-0.887274444103241,
-0.5533163547515869,
0.2952452301979065,
0.13812677562236786,
-0.4429309070110321,
0.2982136011123657,
-0.12193915992975235,
-0.5548365116119385,
-0.7357689142227173,
0.4200874865055084,
0.47620657086372375,
0.043876368552446365,
0.3169119656085968,
0.08387812227010727,
-0.42137235403060913,
-0.7012859582901001,
-0.16041672229766846,
0.16018815338611603,
0.26487481594085693,
0.1000836119055748,
0.24032039940357208,
-0.07389860600233078,
0.7587528824806213,
-0.4798347055912018,
-0.5740641951560974,
-0.2039787769317627,
-0.06803575158119202,
0.11574572324752808,
0.4671480059623718,
0.3978622555732727,
-0.8100466728210449,
-0.7117003202438354,
0.29692065715789795,
-0.45115604996681213,
-0.13450732827186584,
0.15585561096668243,
-0.08301086723804474,
0.2175566554069519,
0.18876220285892487,
-0.4046057164669037,
0.018951766192913055,
0.7895717620849609,
-0.3839876055717468,
0.5182677507400513,
-0.4558422863483429,
-0.2058083564043045,
-0.9071003198623657,
-0.023275496438145638,
-0.21737125515937805,
-0.38569581508636475,
-0.6962270140647888,
0.3575989603996277,
0.04874343052506447,
-0.0008864227565936744,
-0.5969817638397217,
0.2201247662305832,
-0.5878254771232605,
-0.3156525790691376,
-0.5027959942817688,
0.016727007925510406,
-0.2680166959762573,
0.6579238176345825,
-0.2668318450450897,
0.8523211479187012,
0.5058897733688354,
-0.19447563588619232,
0.17862825095653534,
-0.07656852900981903,
-0.12717312574386597,
0.43270155787467957,
-0.38934677839279175,
0.1328716278076172,
0.04051460325717926,
0.08470234274864197,
-0.4852673411369324,
-0.13120804727077484,
-0.08533249795436859,
0.230061873793602,
0.2927068769931793,
-0.1443517655134201,
-0.7077958583831787,
-0.019504636526107788,
-0.1665060669183731,
0.45819103717803955,
0.23459969460964203,
-1.0463542938232422,
0.3724936842918396,
0.3515637516975403,
0.28597140312194824,
-0.37019962072372437,
-0.4867955148220062,
-0.1939564198255539,
-0.21611066162586212,
-0.5915905833244324,
0.10357043147087097,
-0.15796679258346558,
-0.21332331001758575,
-0.3955058753490448,
-0.20701321959495544,
-0.2769399881362915,
0.22361506521701813,
0.3133539855480194,
0.08065658807754517,
-0.47815102338790894,
0.046936385333538055,
0.13222607970237732,
-0.10765591263771057,
-0.3547816872596741,
-0.38016781210899353,
0.7424933910369873,
-0.5793653130531311,
-0.5009768605232239,
-0.4466473460197449,
0.00006330153701128438,
0.8210669159889221,
-0.4432520866394043,
1.0115469694137573,
0.5184374451637268,
-0.10562913119792938,
-0.8485012650489807,
-0.5534129738807678,
0.07632362097501755,
-0.5145494937896729,
0.03510614112019539,
-0.011166123673319817,
-1.196000099182129,
0.3771515190601349,
-0.4875914752483368,
0.2983899414539337,
0.020143622532486916,
0.6829403042793274,
0.3230842053890228,
0.8450254201889038,
0.7876319289207458,
-0.2611163854598999,
0.6637966632843018,
-0.2491612285375595,
0.021580016240477562,
-0.4665640890598297,
-0.004655327647924423,
-0.34017297625541687,
-0.4014635384082794,
-0.5086954236030579,
-0.6836484670639038,
0.17855271697044373,
0.14535225927829742,
-0.4106040298938751,
-0.03523017466068268,
-0.49930790066719055,
0.8128454089164734,
0.2887246608734131,
0.09113332629203796,
0.6289417147636414,
-0.11167760193347931,
-0.012056337669491768,
0.35162553191185,
-0.6911714673042297,
-0.16647057235240936,
0.8339762091636658,
0.4919242262840271,
0.5356609225273132,
0.03922189027070999,
0.8820356726646423,
0.13295528292655945,
0.2625257968902588,
-0.5493800044059753,
0.4959952235221863,
-0.34794214367866516,
-0.44844210147857666,
-0.39163607358932495,
-0.39691218733787537,
-0.7421597838401794,
0.7157319188117981,
0.10469158738851547,
-0.5036553740501404,
0.4372083842754364,
0.10316143184900284,
-0.2655709683895111,
0.5296540856361389,
-0.5500500798225403,
0.7738665342330933,
-0.18758492171764374,
-0.5045547485351562,
-0.3557808995246887,
-0.5231901407241821,
0.41627922654151917,
-0.28661733865737915,
0.19588793814182281,
-0.4060750901699066,
0.07229562848806381,
0.5230318903923035,
-0.8671647906303406,
0.865017294883728,
-0.4511417746543884,
-0.365652859210968,
-0.12764495611190796,
0.001678139204159379,
0.3288592994213104,
0.04237921163439751,
-0.09055157750844955,
0.12248766422271729,
0.08288039267063141,
-0.37528306245803833,
-0.6328627467155457,
0.9145535230636597,
-0.8886603713035583,
-0.25340715050697327,
-0.23258565366268158,
-0.6214611530303955,
-0.22978468239307404,
0.39607012271881104,
-0.08200495690107346,
0.11698044091463089,
0.027019212022423744,
0.26011377573013306,
0.686187744140625,
0.09938956797122955,
0.2905862033367157,
0.9634564518928528,
-0.4688973128795624,
-0.4526548981666565,
1.071784496307373,
-0.07104896008968353,
0.31212514638900757,
0.2371719926595688,
0.18101046979427338,
0.07998794317245483,
-0.6960934400558472,
-0.2533107101917267,
0.4852013885974884,
-0.44951876997947693,
-0.2709161937236786,
0.05596266686916351,
-0.17796878516674042,
-0.0002684559440240264,
-0.2004423439502716,
-0.9778285622596741,
-0.1649554818868637,
-0.6428065896034241,
-0.11558941751718521,
0.21124325692653656,
0.5230971574783325,
-0.13394027948379517,
0.3111806809902191,
-0.5123912692070007,
-0.07938000559806824,
-0.013337668962776661,
0.6286718845367432,
0.1251455396413803,
-0.1555269956588745,
-0.44038334488868713,
0.0704820528626442,
0.12497289478778839,
-0.32969754934310913,
0.4251558780670166,
0.3669530749320984,
0.24438795447349548,
0.631698489189148,
0.029779693111777306,
0.7688202261924744,
-0.5457828640937805,
0.43957147002220154,
0.13304942846298218,
-0.7602075338363647,
0.3731491267681122,
-0.27182018756866455,
0.21440331637859344,
0.9821171164512634,
0.0773075744509697,
-0.2573924958705902,
-0.30187949538230896,
-0.3395560681819916,
-0.6959694027900696,
0.9409235715866089,
-0.14347310364246368,
-0.3367253839969635,
0.5620076060295105,
0.2525233328342438,
0.3720429837703705,
0.32197409868240356,
-0.38265112042427063,
-0.36045753955841064,
0.2016766369342804,
-0.25965890288352966,
-0.38231393694877625,
-0.06213488057255745,
-0.3522043824195862,
-0.3077045679092407,
0.6936599016189575,
-0.37607666850090027,
-0.3538241982460022,
-0.2373196929693222,
-0.2079232782125473,
-0.292081356048584,
0.22133038938045502,
0.5029255747795105,
0.6483627557754517,
-0.13351432979106903,
0.22102758288383484,
0.027520203962922096,
-0.2740879952907562,
0.30665886402130127,
0.27794668078422546,
-0.41916361451148987,
-0.23919232189655304,
0.25578367710113525,
1.0555477142333984,
0.48769333958625793,
-0.6671745777130127,
0.33956378698349,
0.07145672291517258,
-0.25716495513916016,
0.010539151728153229,
0.24480043351650238,
0.18497616052627563,
0.5755760669708252,
0.20674210786819458,
-0.1081199124455452,
-0.30972611904144287,
-0.2810673713684082,
0.2711975574493408,
0.2896779775619507,
-0.23542287945747375,
-0.3713652193546295,
0.4722260534763336,
0.15919101238250732,
-0.3910191059112549,
0.36845874786376953,
0.00860748253762722,
-0.4161294400691986,
0.382229208946228,
0.38543328642845154,
0.8851146101951599,
-0.06369158625602722,
0.3814995288848877,
-0.031547289341688156,
0.17618417739868164,
-0.4162696301937103,
0.18311184644699097,
-0.2996976375579834,
-0.5846567153930664,
-0.1529059261083603,
-0.9981287121772766,
-0.3528554141521454,
0.0043099080212414265,
-0.6747976541519165,
0.058459002524614334,
-0.809601902961731,
0.14300236105918884,
-0.16977955400943756,
0.3567813038825989,
-0.5729034543037415,
-0.07987585663795471,
0.4507398307323456,
1.0915366411209106,
-0.928778886795044,
1.0525230169296265,
0.3318599462509155,
-0.48554906249046326,
-1.0214617252349854,
-0.08051145821809769,
0.01312540378421545,
-0.6184712648391724,
0.6849831938743591,
0.17594268918037415,
-0.07140016555786133,
0.0008435642230324447,
-0.506117582321167,
-0.8494992256164551,
1.2278555631637573,
0.693836510181427,
-0.85383141040802,
-0.23359937965869904,
0.49710261821746826,
0.8598765134811401,
-0.47844192385673523,
-0.05745885893702507,
0.7341788411140442,
0.3878234624862671,
0.20491530001163483,
-1.055220127105713,
0.10336765646934509,
0.11212105304002762,
0.03379217907786369,
0.14058244228363037,
-1.1952544450759888,
1.0273970365524292,
-0.08643166720867157,
-0.21825389564037323,
-0.21017998456954956,
0.8038854002952576,
0.2739035487174988,
0.4676293730735779,
0.6253685355186462,
0.5009198784828186,
1.0621416568756104,
0.04472651705145836,
0.3986481726169586,
-0.4167218506336212,
0.7778347730636597,
1.5328147411346436,
-0.5485961437225342,
0.9673346877098083,
0.4335836172103882,
-0.23237206041812897,
0.27898871898651123,
0.5375418663024902,
-0.09540477395057678,
0.5389643907546997,
0.19116562604904175,
-0.29205065965652466,
-0.2967606484889984,
0.11597403138875961,
-0.25669658184051514,
0.48804739117622375,
0.16195759177207947,
-0.4444512724876404,
-0.6226426362991333,
0.1623161882162094,
-0.12351887673139572,
-0.1060880795121193,
-0.40707269310951233,
0.8598103523254395,
0.06299298256635666,
-0.49265602231025696,
0.766628086566925,
-0.07097265124320984,
0.7453303337097168,
-0.4869418442249298,
0.1785840541124344,
-0.44125595688819885,
0.5904133915901184,
-0.37529677152633667,
-0.29912272095680237,
0.17720359563827515,
-0.018170733004808426,
-0.17123843729496002,
-0.3155539929866791,
0.5924948453903198,
-0.6784131526947021,
-0.3377518951892853,
0.516115665435791,
0.488619327545166,
0.03764961659908295,
-0.02331346832215786,
-0.6607856750488281,
0.405505508184433,
0.06751561164855957,
-0.19021785259246826,
0.6975868940353394,
0.3183498680591583,
0.3271772563457489,
0.6988791823387146,
0.7230165600776672,
0.36893337965011597,
0.2369154989719391,
0.1534750610589981,
0.9824205040931702,
-0.008914364501833916,
-0.6371237635612488,
-0.7097613215446472,
0.05964307114481926,
0.02294054627418518,
-0.18563419580459595,
0.75603187084198,
0.8391587734222412,
0.8446446061134338,
0.11985599249601364,
0.42289572954177856,
0.28824305534362793,
0.4002780616283417,
-0.30729997158050537,
1.0888971090316772,
-0.7107452154159546,
0.3508017063140869,
0.13088367879390717,
-0.6565994024276733,
-0.33718159794807434,
0.26046809554100037,
-0.22404637932777405,
-0.2743442952632904,
0.3115737736225128,
0.8907959461212158,
-0.2533295452594757,
0.3564230501651764,
0.3910297453403473,
0.16093425452709198,
0.49109432101249695,
0.522074282169342,
0.2720910906791687,
-0.1665787696838379,
0.2221197634935379,
-0.4514346718788147,
-0.22930584847927094,
-0.41156521439552307,
-0.46381402015686035,
-0.8232846260070801,
-0.47930577397346497,
-0.33537912368774414,
-0.007106828037649393,
0.18258562684059143,
1.1469101905822754,
0.7674658298492432,
-0.9440746903419495,
-0.2911458909511566,
-0.4209367334842682,
0.21491388976573944,
-0.34667858481407166,
-0.21879340708255768,
0.38688820600509644,
-0.4369170069694519,
-0.7044841647148132,
0.6132937669754028,
0.2472035139799118,
-0.2200641632080078,
-0.7850446701049805,
-0.11514738202095032,
-0.4173603355884552,
-0.14265267550945282,
0.4598371386528015,
0.46067944169044495,
-0.5099852085113525,
-0.07137893885374069,
-0.5473638772964478,
-0.15764865279197693,
0.09632471203804016,
0.8024757504463196,
-0.48931166529655457,
0.38306790590286255,
0.48327794671058655,
0.7136580944061279,
0.5638535618782043,
-0.03820919990539551,
0.5015592575073242,
-0.613778293132782,
0.2857029139995575,
0.13215522468090057,
0.24258534610271454,
0.18072429299354553,
-0.2878337502479553,
0.5313587784767151,
0.1109263226389885,
-0.7176102995872498,
-1.2047975063323975,
-0.0981389731168747,
-0.9137788414955139,
-0.2554882764816284,
1.1577800512313843,
-0.40829741954803467,
-0.40273380279541016,
0.19639945030212402,
-0.0437895804643631,
0.3731459677219391,
-0.30249539017677307,
0.48919346928596497,
0.31021711230278015,
-0.00749307731166482,
-0.0678948163986206,
-0.14555314183235168,
0.578798234462738,
0.3509199023246765,
-0.9224610924720764,
0.6594428420066833,
0.5931204557418823,
0.3820178210735321,
-0.03915661945939064,
0.39399370551109314,
0.27555572986602783,
0.08972834795713425,
-0.11008553951978683,
-0.20952863991260529,
-0.43070340156555176,
-0.6438302993774414,
-0.6587969660758972,
0.6447053551673889,
0.05895669013261795,
-0.25313055515289307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00948v1 | The House Always Wins: A Framework for Evaluating Strategic Deception in LLMs | 2024-07-01T04:07:49 | 2024-07-01T04:07:49 | Tanush Chopra, Michael Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose a framework for evaluating strategic deception in large language
models (LLMs). In this framework, an LLM acts as a game master in two
scenarios: one with random game mechanics and another where it can choose
between random or deliberate actions. As an example, we use blackjack because
the action space nor strategies involve deception. We benchmark Llama3-70B,
GPT-4-Turbo, and Mixtral in blackjack, comparing outcomes against expected
distributions in fair play to determine if LLMs develop strategies favoring the
"house." Our findings reveal that the LLMs exhibit significant deviations from
fair play when given implicit randomness instructions, suggesting a tendency
towards strategic manipulation in ambiguous scenarios. However, when presented
with an explicit choice, the LLMs largely adhere to fair play, indicating that
the framing of instructions plays a crucial role in eliciting or mitigating
potentially deceptive behaviors in AI systems. | [
0.04965663701295853,
-0.8737820982933044,
0.8353368043899536,
0.4318922758102417,
-0.13548314571380615,
0.1821657121181488,
-0.24672169983386993,
-0.1797240823507309,
-0.05172908306121826,
0.6149001121520996,
-0.36007392406463623,
-0.5295515060424805,
-0.8563343286514282,
-0.04196280986070633,
-0.07871430367231369,
0.7460255026817322,
0.011223569512367249,
0.3935442566871643,
0.0672457367181778,
0.09200646728277206,
-0.38334351778030396,
-0.42723244428634644,
-0.883366048336029,
-0.699927806854248,
0.4417110085487366,
0.4870429039001465,
1.015539288520813,
0.8689446449279785,
0.7196988463401794,
0.289795845746994,
0.32206496596336365,
-0.133836030960083,
-0.6660166382789612,
0.5601488947868347,
-0.16386272013187408,
-0.7944194674491882,
-0.2853110432624817,
0.17780634760856628,
0.3647408187389374,
0.29498428106307983,
-0.8251988887786865,
0.11631858348846436,
-0.04646571725606918,
0.5839632749557495,
-0.6532362699508667,
0.2225060611963272,
-0.8529537916183472,
0.11838674545288086,
-0.18801814317703247,
-0.44435393810272217,
-0.44771698117256165,
-0.3687599003314972,
0.09986419975757599,
-0.580751359462738,
-0.2637375295162201,
0.44471558928489685,
0.8998966813087463,
0.25994420051574707,
-0.6788689494132996,
-0.4234503507614136,
-0.8955560922622681,
0.7041823267936707,
-0.5396258234977722,
0.0030393123161047697,
0.01582357846200466,
0.6114748120307922,
-0.5543478727340698,
-0.5135214328765869,
-0.4183364808559418,
-0.5897229909896851,
-0.10111374408006668,
0.31368759274482727,
-0.3723548352718353,
0.32824447751045227,
0.32395514845848083,
0.13449056446552277,
-0.45701465010643005,
-0.02428973652422428,
-0.08290892839431763,
-0.1917797178030014,
0.8558037877082825,
0.4022192656993866,
0.12222893536090851,
0.0019483461510390043,
-0.6148985028266907,
-0.22023989260196686,
-0.7534939646720886,
0.14634475111961365,
0.5813246369361877,
-0.06977108120918274,
0.020313957706093788,
0.8214954733848572,
0.12848342955112457,
0.5292930006980896,
0.4180767238140106,
-0.33289065957069397,
-0.2396191507577896,
-0.20847497880458832,
-0.31710466742515564,
0.4429243505001068,
0.6502948999404907,
0.6683319211006165,
0.37046360969543457,
-0.20046986639499664,
-0.5607194304466248,
0.3435036540031433,
0.2802806496620178,
-0.46888822317123413,
-0.0204919446259737,
0.2030232548713684,
-0.6545195579528809,
-0.4378875494003296,
0.04410513862967491,
-0.7630625367164612,
-0.6671369075775146,
-0.2316223829984665,
0.6173971891403198,
-0.06513773649930954,
-0.10959446430206299,
0.16809725761413574,
-0.6981390714645386,
0.7954604029655457,
0.001883932389318943,
-0.6415949463844299,
0.6852204203605652,
0.874237596988678,
0.2978403866291046,
-0.45386457443237305,
-0.20152267813682556,
-0.7416884303092957,
0.4338245689868927,
-0.5334688425064087,
0.4413338303565979,
-0.40193700790405273,
-0.5509622097015381,
-0.007589008193463087,
-0.40598881244659424,
-0.15289421379566193,
-0.6805009245872498,
0.3692079186439514,
-0.39115890860557556,
0.013345899060368538,
-0.16084271669387817,
-0.55156010389328,
0.12902043759822845,
0.544755220413208,
-0.6404526829719543,
0.49669212102890015,
-0.21443894505500793,
-0.25688865780830383,
0.41574016213417053,
-0.6861706972122192,
-0.6722376346588135,
0.09883858263492584,
-0.2693009376525879,
-0.5813497304916382,
0.1929500848054886,
-0.2007884681224823,
0.42842036485671997,
-0.03995984420180321,
0.5189609527587891,
-0.4262029230594635,
-0.7229610085487366,
0.366935133934021,
-0.5874001979827881,
0.6750888824462891,
0.18456251919269562,
-1.0355901718139648,
0.20241042971611023,
-0.4534623622894287,
-0.17494423687458038,
0.6619966626167297,
-0.34730473160743713,
-0.1337776780128479,
0.40999361872673035,
-0.3052300810813904,
0.11674951761960983,
0.34820979833602905,
-0.44458502531051636,
0.15350283682346344,
-0.21697397530078888,
0.07740619778633118,
0.8725290894508362,
0.11664814502000809,
0.7989058494567871,
-0.8658150434494019,
0.6239719390869141,
-0.1709202527999878,
0.25621554255485535,
0.035759683698415756,
-0.5635359287261963,
-0.7761702537536621,
-0.41482317447662354,
0.20776821672916412,
0.9450108408927917,
-0.4876643419265747,
0.2750603258609772,
-0.28199151158332825,
-0.28529128432273865,
-0.6222497224807739,
-0.19828452169895172,
0.3442690074443817,
-0.16806882619857788,
-0.09309817850589752,
-0.12455794960260391,
-0.47465062141418457,
-1.0064952373504639,
-0.4682537317276001,
0.04691700637340546,
0.21318675577640533,
0.3716191351413727,
0.27360308170318604,
0.10213768482208252,
0.6589339375495911,
-0.1987314671278,
-0.3607049286365509,
-0.5282853245735168,
0.11309773474931717,
-0.038777563720941544,
0.20317557454109192,
0.5397219657897949,
-0.7009432315826416,
-0.35730665922164917,
-0.03284807130694389,
-1.0154755115509033,
0.14199332892894745,
-0.3086299002170563,
-0.12504659593105316,
0.09731120616197586,
0.40685150027275085,
-0.7134913802146912,
0.7649756669998169,
0.3644930124282837,
-0.5591999888420105,
0.38444244861602783,
-0.09369341284036636,
0.2782878875732422,
-0.5136764049530029,
-0.21348369121551514,
-0.17017343640327454,
-0.20675335824489594,
-0.47652265429496765,
0.4236285388469696,
-0.3870563507080078,
0.18806758522987366,
-0.20151300728321075,
0.7109277248382568,
-0.4086413085460663,
-0.17354227602481842,
-0.072564035654068,
0.32214534282684326,
-0.1531207263469696,
0.47613266110420227,
0.09659487009048462,
0.4657372534275055,
0.3174198865890503,
-0.2785489559173584,
0.4139516353607178,
-0.29379189014434814,
-0.14395670592784882,
0.8410371541976929,
-0.8152450919151306,
0.02001502364873886,
-0.2360813170671463,
0.41302669048309326,
-1.2540102005004883,
-0.06576105207204819,
0.5656898021697998,
-0.44376376271247864,
0.378059059381485,
0.3002660870552063,
-0.4758184254169464,
-0.12385689467191696,
-0.4021605849266052,
-0.3259134292602539,
0.6025771498680115,
-0.1217380091547966,
0.9743970632553101,
0.24514730274677277,
0.11946965754032135,
-1.0147356986999512,
-0.558177649974823,
0.23960787057876587,
-0.3565841615200043,
-0.33649101853370667,
0.23553825914859772,
-0.32404398918151855,
-0.7790574431419373,
-0.05612543970346451,
-0.11924608796834946,
0.2692313492298126,
0.501849353313446,
0.5665755867958069,
0.18649369478225708,
-0.21720394492149353,
-0.5068038702011108,
-0.09753162413835526,
0.07174218446016312,
0.40874192118644714,
-0.16382776200771332,
0.2968735992908478,
-0.040700722485780716,
-0.4974282383918762,
-0.2119879424571991,
0.37393274903297424,
0.5228415131568909,
0.046257875859737396,
0.7061163187026978,
0.1466456949710846,
-0.1765575110912323,
-0.4310133159160614,
-0.7408058643341064,
-0.261845201253891,
-0.4510955810546875,
0.10761058330535889,
-0.578309178352356,
-0.9177895188331604,
0.7885643243789673,
0.02895403653383255,
0.4267883896827698,
0.2589508891105652,
0.4937758147716522,
-0.3595719039440155,
1.077864170074463,
0.5478429794311523,
0.02887880429625511,
0.1055598109960556,
-0.1028289869427681,
0.2071685642004013,
-0.3271156847476959,
-0.34159666299819946,
-0.4671367406845093,
-0.7214076519012451,
-0.6762650012969971,
0.040899261832237244,
0.11812715977430344,
-0.05439348146319389,
-0.4689021706581116,
0.07700179517269135,
-0.40542659163475037,
0.5210432410240173,
0.6485329270362854,
0.05644340440630913,
0.47250545024871826,
-0.1188681498169899,
-0.25423285365104675,
-0.1114930585026741,
-0.8975814580917358,
-0.49388182163238525,
1.2897148132324219,
0.5535064339637756,
0.6919358372688293,
0.41889411211013794,
1.1318429708480835,
0.4245097041130066,
0.8813876509666443,
-0.7228301763534546,
0.7879974246025085,
0.2838476300239563,
-0.7779876589775085,
-0.540208637714386,
-0.4270462691783905,
-1.1777918338775635,
0.29142582416534424,
-0.15493515133857727,
-0.17685525119304657,
0.03315311670303345,
-0.10168340802192688,
-0.484090656042099,
0.2928924858570099,
-0.3718787729740143,
0.7483906745910645,
-0.42985597252845764,
-0.3371215760707855,
-0.25543102622032166,
-0.6068762540817261,
0.6009138822555542,
0.06450599431991577,
0.29203304648399353,
0.0087032625451684,
-0.3717631697654724,
0.6333832740783691,
0.1889643669128418,
0.6718009114265442,
-0.163675919175148,
-0.009297399781644344,
0.21227699518203735,
0.5684877634048462,
0.5449184775352478,
0.07810086756944656,
-0.15200413763523102,
0.2214520126581192,
-0.25036898255348206,
-0.4443419277667999,
-0.7832202911376953,
0.6260057687759399,
-0.817570149898529,
-0.9230219125747681,
-0.8206785917282104,
-0.23611070215702057,
0.06003017723560333,
-0.008048768155276775,
0.19261302053928375,
-0.08331010490655899,
-0.5584633946418762,
0.30270835757255554,
0.7437179684638977,
0.14008337259292603,
0.35707738995552063,
0.6184192299842834,
-0.13578522205352783,
-0.2644316256046295,
0.6587386131286621,
-0.07902853190898895,
0.25842270255088806,
0.21830853819847107,
0.23989465832710266,
-0.293404757976532,
-0.6819512248039246,
-0.25367286801338196,
0.0770030990242958,
-0.7311089038848877,
-0.0805070549249649,
-0.08841606974601746,
-0.24508950114250183,
0.20168845355510712,
-0.33366119861602783,
-0.07576324790716171,
-0.0376320481300354,
0.22589217126369476,
-0.28719961643218994,
-0.2690682113170624,
0.9633430242538452,
-0.10179327428340912,
0.4931402802467346,
-0.4430093765258789,
0.23390035331249237,
0.5956828594207764,
0.12593375146389008,
-0.16322822868824005,
-0.5251661539077759,
0.3330676853656769,
-0.08407095819711685,
-0.3033768832683563,
-1.026326298713684,
0.03381659835577011,
-0.1636321246623993,
1.1311389207839966,
0.22097539901733398,
-0.10627928376197815,
0.32160380482673645,
-0.40540364384651184,
0.9902562499046326,
0.2212052345275879,
-0.7768193483352661,
0.20624004304409027,
-0.6637133955955505,
0.19276265799999237,
0.565107524394989,
0.1201833039522171,
-0.18075719475746155,
-0.47478151321411133,
-1.0075880289077759,
-0.46826067566871643,
0.388226717710495,
0.14841772615909576,
0.14548686146736145,
-0.036543671041727066,
0.24758026003837585,
-0.0919119119644165,
0.8077847361564636,
-1.125827431678772,
-0.61895751953125,
0.15067118406295776,
-0.14639359712600708,
0.08069067448377609,
-0.2196120172739029,
-0.5202324986457825,
0.10803713649511337,
0.40102434158325195,
0.12110621482133865,
0.38717326521873474,
-0.11154721677303314,
-0.020902568474411964,
-0.5509735345840454,
0.2040296047925949,
0.734161913394928,
0.7058262228965759,
-0.15915916860103607,
-0.003792745992541313,
0.008602400310337543,
-0.08513835072517395,
0.40179669857025146,
-0.014182642102241516,
-0.14036454260349274,
0.022537056356668472,
0.6001008749008179,
0.532941460609436,
0.6414172649383545,
-0.5680487751960754,
0.914985716342926,
-0.18654096126556396,
-0.6213626861572266,
-0.295983225107193,
0.37455031275749207,
-0.03419598937034607,
0.39568671584129333,
0.47545576095581055,
0.16786086559295654,
0.1392379254102707,
-0.8439263105392456,
0.37868425250053406,
0.741208016872406,
-0.10800454765558243,
0.1556156873703003,
0.5800011157989502,
0.19817744195461273,
-0.6345394849777222,
0.5281330347061157,
-0.6390588283538818,
-0.6963326334953308,
0.7594893574714661,
0.37420299649238586,
0.8481377363204956,
-0.41256996989250183,
0.29978686571121216,
-0.01725621707737446,
0.6632784008979797,
-0.174158975481987,
0.3789520859718323,
-0.12427737563848495,
-0.6245913505554199,
-0.5348296165466309,
-0.3558538258075714,
-0.48846539855003357,
0.16723807156085968,
-0.35143351554870605,
-0.06186242774128914,
-0.7803374528884888,
-0.0807437151670456,
-0.2438870519399643,
0.11313603073358536,
-0.7090704441070557,
-0.06946665048599243,
0.5182690620422363,
0.9129315614700317,
-0.5118792057037354,
0.38233810663223267,
0.3859737515449524,
0.07590930908918381,
-0.8308817148208618,
0.029599832370877266,
0.18858231604099274,
-0.8491109609603882,
0.7993974089622498,
-0.30056998133659363,
-0.288197785615921,
-0.21540609002113342,
-1.0421903133392334,
-0.6225850582122803,
1.1104443073272705,
0.35055163502693176,
-0.7942955493927002,
-0.03138747811317444,
0.03364947810769081,
0.37895625829696655,
-0.5954980850219727,
0.20455799996852875,
0.6988123655319214,
0.9713260531425476,
0.34240543842315674,
-0.8966332674026489,
-0.21700654923915863,
0.20657780766487122,
-0.2492779940366745,
-0.0008094778750091791,
-0.6709549427032471,
0.4107779562473297,
-0.30105990171432495,
-0.1238611564040184,
0.1106148213148117,
0.745717465877533,
0.655989944934845,
0.6224884986877441,
0.5201228260993958,
0.6125525236129761,
0.4728446900844574,
-0.5867705345153809,
1.0019234418869019,
-0.06397169083356857,
0.0478210374712944,
1.05630362033844,
-0.7556837201118469,
0.7978425025939941,
0.2933933734893799,
0.017894459888339043,
0.4634019732475281,
0.5066019296646118,
-0.013213754631578922,
0.5411545038223267,
0.8658003807067871,
0.2786986827850342,
-0.40886324644088745,
0.257421612739563,
-0.05699131637811661,
0.874439001083374,
0.36131566762924194,
-0.04059452936053276,
-0.2983439564704895,
-0.1361028552055359,
0.5157332420349121,
0.38558822870254517,
-0.10044728964567184,
0.8183462023735046,
0.31811243295669556,
-0.9720140695571899,
0.059565864503383636,
0.19572016596794128,
0.8580939173698425,
-0.9666858315467834,
-0.27272969484329224,
-0.23569662868976593,
0.14418548345565796,
0.005340152885764837,
-0.8467572927474976,
0.10337374359369278,
-0.5797795057296753,
0.12017155438661575,
-0.232836052775383,
0.4711775481700897,
-0.5205514430999756,
-0.20282234251499176,
0.5206006169319153,
0.4690908193588257,
-0.26008498668670654,
0.12421338260173798,
-1.128330111503601,
0.405825138092041,
-0.14187870919704437,
-0.6028058528900146,
0.4391033351421356,
0.41591769456863403,
0.10010117292404175,
0.8012399077415466,
0.6315649151802063,
0.3264741003513336,
-0.006211757659912109,
-0.28338906168937683,
0.27050960063934326,
-0.47534671425819397,
-0.48098519444465637,
-0.972893238067627,
0.4412597715854645,
-0.46955156326293945,
-0.10928647965192795,
1.010614037513733,
0.421449214220047,
0.5703877210617065,
0.033622972667217255,
0.6902205348014832,
0.3490802049636841,
-0.04669534042477608,
-0.316762238740921,
0.5901899933815002,
-0.4327374994754791,
0.2578655183315277,
0.08404985815286636,
-1.1220511198043823,
-0.13213476538658142,
0.6288576722145081,
-0.4128202795982361,
0.03792601823806763,
0.5670285224914551,
0.5284022688865662,
0.2621891498565674,
0.003423325950279832,
0.46265488862991333,
0.11040476709604263,
0.13964080810546875,
0.6851242184638977,
1.0138245820999146,
-0.33177247643470764,
0.5232992768287659,
0.11327153444290161,
-0.2363770604133606,
-0.35591959953308105,
-0.8957776427268982,
-0.7912277579307556,
-0.17839191854000092,
-0.3203285336494446,
-0.565049409866333,
0.3704511821269989,
0.816838264465332,
0.5692844986915588,
-0.5074892640113831,
-0.7145724892616272,
0.5156225562095642,
0.468219131231308,
-0.492855042219162,
-0.22356435656547546,
0.029175907373428345,
-0.061066269874572754,
-0.3539540469646454,
0.4262200593948364,
0.5661709904670715,
-0.13386109471321106,
-0.4364354610443115,
-0.34668809175491333,
-0.010570822283625603,
0.6762640476226807,
0.40734753012657166,
0.005930491257458925,
-0.9532294869422913,
-0.14061014354228973,
0.20377761125564575,
-0.5579328536987305,
-0.13323703408241272,
0.7363505959510803,
-0.3454108238220215,
0.2109365016222,
0.21544249355793,
0.567479133605957,
0.20807784795761108,
-0.07746108621358871,
0.6827939748764038,
-0.313443660736084,
-0.06329365819692612,
0.479490727186203,
0.19303549826145172,
0.06103433668613434,
-0.6655156016349792,
0.40087461471557617,
0.10510770231485367,
-0.5684707164764404,
-0.5544944405555725,
-0.04465338587760925,
-0.8858109712600708,
-0.41232582926750183,
1.2122676372528076,
0.022851483896374702,
-0.4538455009460449,
-0.08225122094154358,
-0.09301532059907913,
-0.18346382677555084,
-0.5436764359474182,
0.7307400107383728,
1.038910150527954,
0.14093133807182312,
0.04899737238883972,
-0.7853482365608215,
0.8436372876167297,
0.42169028520584106,
-0.4395759701728821,
-0.25577160716056824,
0.37485259771347046,
0.348165899515152,
0.1104518324136734,
0.7011730074882507,
0.01991567201912403,
0.5538650751113892,
-0.12935574352741241,
-0.32424548268318176,
-0.044612206518650055,
-0.4052060842514038,
-0.47241175174713135,
0.5243214964866638,
-0.005685636308044195,
-0.0656159296631813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00942v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00942v1 | ProductAgent: Benchmarking Conversational Product Search Agent with Asking Clarification Questions | 2024-07-01T03:50:23 | 2024-07-01T03:50:23 | Jingheng Ye, Yong Jiang, Xiaobin Wang, Yinghui Li, Yangning Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper introduces the task of product demand clarification within an
e-commercial scenario, where the user commences the conversation with ambiguous
queries and the task-oriented agent is designed to achieve more accurate and
tailored product searching by asking clarification questions. To address this
task, we propose ProductAgent, a conversational information seeking agent
equipped with abilities of strategic clarification question generation and
dynamic product retrieval. Specifically, we develop the agent with strategies
for product feature summarization, query generation, and product retrieval.
Furthermore, we propose the benchmark called PROCLARE to evaluate the agent's
performance both automatically and qualitatively with the aid of a LLM-driven
user simulator. Experiments show that ProductAgent interacts positively with
the user and enhances retrieval performance with increasing dialogue turns,
where user demands become gradually more explicit and detailed. All the source
codes will be released after the review anonymity period. | [
-0.46834874153137207,
-1.0095293521881104,
0.3644818961620331,
0.3891332447528839,
-0.23237882554531097,
0.28574633598327637,
-0.17833469808101654,
-0.739119827747345,
0.1323860138654709,
0.524781346321106,
-0.6878563761711121,
-0.49576470255851746,
-0.14146390557289124,
0.06304126232862473,
-0.4164655804634094,
0.5766832232475281,
0.0340571254491806,
-0.23968571424484253,
-0.38760823011398315,
-0.2793753147125244,
-0.6534577012062073,
-0.48253801465034485,
-0.8272694945335388,
-0.32964736223220825,
0.34971415996551514,
0.44963276386260986,
0.928485095500946,
0.17577742040157318,
0.4673444926738739,
0.46982541680336,
0.0763583555817604,
0.19008667767047882,
-0.6166449189186096,
0.9911344051361084,
-0.21809786558151245,
-0.7135295271873474,
-0.30658116936683655,
-0.17914819717407227,
0.21740500628948212,
0.1619189977645874,
-0.3434666395187378,
0.3909381926059723,
-0.19074919819831848,
0.30591779947280884,
-0.7423786520957947,
0.4445701837539673,
-0.5229277014732361,
0.006337828002870083,
0.17558737099170685,
-0.09331031888723373,
-0.16713780164718628,
-0.6381610035896301,
0.41103631258010864,
-0.918660581111908,
0.38182035088539124,
0.18199513852596283,
1.0661348104476929,
0.2080094963312149,
-0.34794119000434875,
-0.5708659887313843,
-0.7710674405097961,
0.7349568009376526,
-0.3781158924102783,
0.45121267437934875,
0.10266377776861191,
0.8443630933761597,
-0.20982114970684052,
-1.03774094581604,
-0.38138601183891296,
-0.479663223028183,
-0.060883134603500366,
0.1761370599269867,
-0.3095031976699829,
-0.11924925446510315,
0.012061882764101028,
0.30208462476730347,
-0.5866966247558594,
-0.3139517605304718,
-0.22630725800991058,
-0.02612440660595894,
0.7691177725791931,
0.10031001269817352,
0.054664723575115204,
0.48233678936958313,
-0.6345528960227966,
-0.23166176676750183,
-0.4273873269557953,
0.14786507189273834,
0.3324976861476898,
-0.2917846441268921,
0.30527621507644653,
0.38811764121055603,
-0.62050861120224,
0.4182025194168091,
0.13739672303199768,
0.2709728479385376,
0.41212108731269836,
-0.24327324330806732,
-0.010142629966139793,
0.1862124651670456,
0.3728700280189514,
0.5372273325920105,
0.1659674197435379,
0.05487554520368576,
-0.44974327087402344,
-0.14807432889938354,
0.3285324275493622,
-1.0712270736694336,
-0.04708300158381462,
0.34216612577438354,
-0.2696799039840698,
-0.04670188948512077,
0.24954241514205933,
-0.6906508803367615,
-0.28017300367355347,
-0.20237068831920624,
0.5461398959159851,
-0.029429879039525986,
-0.07166023552417755,
0.09655121713876724,
-0.20689861476421356,
0.27985844016075134,
0.23764976859092712,
-0.22285622358322144,
0.6090573072433472,
0.5829328894615173,
0.5186282992362976,
0.005584869999438524,
0.08124950528144836,
-0.5941857695579529,
0.008195257745683193,
-0.16430266201496124,
0.9969698786735535,
-0.37324273586273193,
-0.5484644174575806,
0.07645351439714432,
0.12845562398433685,
0.014593221247196198,
-1.143018364906311,
0.34402990341186523,
-1.0687932968139648,
-0.06887136399745941,
-0.5029376745223999,
-0.3204127550125122,
-0.2712824046611786,
0.8208851218223572,
-0.5985803604125977,
0.9906747937202454,
-0.1620008796453476,
-0.3553188443183899,
0.11833915114402771,
-0.5473067164421082,
-0.31552544236183167,
0.6143893599510193,
-0.40166354179382324,
-0.40460509061813354,
-0.13647408783435822,
0.1324755996465683,
0.0050482796505093575,
-0.5401148796081543,
0.0936669334769249,
-0.10375522077083588,
-0.4797176718711853,
0.5947022438049316,
-0.1728275567293167,
0.1222929060459137,
0.4151470959186554,
-0.6584652662277222,
-0.03665018826723099,
-0.5986210703849792,
0.13705089688301086,
0.4646536409854889,
-0.23114386200904846,
-0.01559385098516941,
0.12265252321958542,
-0.1062617376446724,
-0.09157469868659973,
0.8694420456886292,
-0.5243256688117981,
-0.17429137229919434,
-0.20662543177604675,
0.06113193929195404,
0.4409186840057373,
0.39950811862945557,
-0.17601539194583893,
-0.4974200427532196,
0.7427178621292114,
-0.194975808262825,
0.5904738903045654,
-0.1391289383172989,
-0.4801550507545471,
-0.7438069581985474,
-0.1026698648929596,
0.22579777240753174,
0.5170052647590637,
-0.5462706685066223,
0.12242477387189865,
0.03627093881368637,
-0.4351503252983093,
-0.42896929383277893,
0.17120906710624695,
0.536077082157135,
0.4634406268596649,
0.18157222867012024,
-0.6455575227737427,
-0.3032630383968353,
-1.2050092220306396,
-0.48432600498199463,
-0.13048003613948822,
-0.0787937268614769,
0.5226137638092041,
0.12302301079034805,
-0.18178415298461914,
1.1234053373336792,
-0.8980852961540222,
-0.3359391987323761,
-0.4669269621372223,
0.5216304063796997,
0.17414197325706482,
-0.007562094833701849,
0.46646595001220703,
-1.1082347631454468,
-0.6625081300735474,
0.025936920195817947,
-0.5626004934310913,
-0.5293422341346741,
0.19245421886444092,
-0.0063722203485667706,
-0.1965797394514084,
0.45120203495025635,
-0.8031978011131287,
0.2923184037208557,
0.13242067396640778,
0.08041953295469284,
0.4784727692604065,
-0.5299978256225586,
0.123336061835289,
-0.8806641101837158,
0.40113604068756104,
0.05711640417575836,
-0.3619054853916168,
-0.6190782785415649,
0.18899331986904144,
-0.11339584738016129,
-0.27822309732437134,
-0.7838583588600159,
0.43456441164016724,
-0.4965832531452179,
-0.294477641582489,
-0.337247371673584,
0.49673277139663696,
0.34148767590522766,
0.20280908048152924,
-0.2832203507423401,
1.3414360284805298,
0.18089178204536438,
-0.8895787000656128,
0.42686983942985535,
0.3617081940174103,
-0.25514742732048035,
0.6451541185379028,
-1.0942658185958862,
0.16783104836940765,
-0.2893114984035492,
0.07794930785894394,
-0.8822082281112671,
0.022003434598445892,
0.05882013961672783,
-0.14570844173431396,
-0.15655116736888885,
0.21728301048278809,
-0.7881168127059937,
-0.2912372648715973,
-0.16491632163524628,
0.3634079396724701,
0.5453596115112305,
-0.44808855652809143,
0.46943867206573486,
0.2207663357257843,
-0.2676001787185669,
-0.3316580653190613,
-0.20247305929660797,
-0.07710134983062744,
-0.0825652927160263,
-0.6023146510124207,
0.35159772634506226,
-0.29170316457748413,
-0.4679538905620575,
-0.1360468566417694,
-0.31723856925964355,
0.07535376399755478,
0.08809275180101395,
0.10947618633508682,
-0.09536587446928024,
-0.08600997924804688,
0.1274622231721878,
-0.3506010174751282,
-0.20695945620536804,
0.23754176497459412,
0.07030794769525528,
0.5825561881065369,
-0.2900446355342865,
-0.2594406008720398,
-0.2027433067560196,
0.3385847508907318,
0.2241743505001068,
-0.4409492313861847,
0.08565134555101395,
0.3518046736717224,
0.10899454355239868,
-0.34818097949028015,
-0.8399020433425903,
-0.3583969473838806,
-0.625620424747467,
0.3473666310310364,
-0.547379732131958,
-0.6739414930343628,
0.8388180732727051,
-0.29612860083580017,
-0.2755129039287567,
0.22476089000701904,
0.518447995185852,
0.11849797517061234,
1.4676817655563354,
0.29088929295539856,
0.4654085636138916,
0.4403664171695709,
-0.15408316254615784,
0.3212948143482208,
-0.2035636603832245,
-0.4056498408317566,
-0.4769732654094696,
-0.5459378361701965,
-0.5219197273254395,
-0.1575765311717987,
0.5958275198936462,
-0.10880915075540543,
-0.17372238636016846,
0.5028002858161926,
-0.4863186776638031,
0.5211012363433838,
0.8777529001235962,
0.22755645215511322,
0.26868849992752075,
-0.2279045134782791,
-0.18306030333042145,
0.04508931562304497,
-0.13309648633003235,
-0.31977152824401855,
0.4826061427593231,
0.18691886961460114,
0.5943940281867981,
0.2880253791809082,
0.20882748067378998,
0.5261836647987366,
0.013238165527582169,
-0.7578843235969543,
0.9524890780448914,
0.23522509634494781,
-0.9118437767028809,
0.2646229863166809,
-0.14832539856433868,
-0.989913284778595,
0.31293678283691406,
0.28211352229118347,
-0.7789322733879089,
0.3789123594760895,
0.10091482102870941,
-0.21412311494350433,
-0.5658618211746216,
-0.7813639640808105,
0.9302268624305725,
-0.7045111656188965,
-0.5936737656593323,
-0.4574698209762573,
-0.6344542503356934,
-0.23813660442829132,
0.03321376070380211,
-0.08637604862451553,
-0.44370484352111816,
-0.2403811365365982,
0.43084973096847534,
-0.5750328302383423,
0.5710030198097229,
-0.29410162568092346,
0.20513345301151276,
0.49730104207992554,
0.251460462808609,
0.6612811088562012,
0.04852303862571716,
0.02698008343577385,
-0.34128057956695557,
0.07208181172609329,
-0.39280951023101807,
-0.8122059106826782,
0.5249477624893188,
-0.6542606353759766,
-1.0184171199798584,
-0.24365457892417908,
-0.29779255390167236,
-0.28114745020866394,
0.3626426160335541,
0.02572639472782612,
0.04322762042284012,
-0.4539676308631897,
0.3899652063846588,
0.5234073996543884,
-0.10389082133769989,
0.17494505643844604,
0.9368159770965576,
-0.0928993821144104,
-0.326786607503891,
0.8469921946525574,
-0.0089401975274086,
0.17551252245903015,
0.43235817551612854,
0.1539061963558197,
-0.5998354554176331,
-0.3821519613265991,
-0.056389980018138885,
0.22375468909740448,
-0.8443939685821533,
-0.12522366642951965,
-0.5558715462684631,
-0.046862080693244934,
0.0019304915331304073,
0.18028496205806732,
-0.44958239793777466,
0.07726166397333145,
-0.14142894744873047,
0.0052503920160233974,
0.23571579158306122,
0.8679995536804199,
0.56703782081604,
0.5340179800987244,
-0.5599640011787415,
0.07565844804048538,
0.6419053077697754,
0.18621402978897095,
-0.3956891894340515,
-0.023539911955595016,
-0.23939993977546692,
-0.127488374710083,
-0.9168950915336609,
-0.945114254951477,
0.28327083587646484,
0.13133351504802704,
0.9211876392364502,
0.554446816444397,
0.3945125937461853,
0.4080401360988617,
0.11568844318389893,
0.9870631694793701,
-0.14104333519935608,
-0.7120723128318787,
0.5686984658241272,
-0.2968868315219879,
0.41796016693115234,
0.8118027448654175,
0.4209650456905365,
-0.25512072443962097,
-0.29889360070228577,
-0.5450506210327148,
-1.0271323919296265,
0.5358229875564575,
0.37728258967399597,
0.051500216126441956,
-0.07134601473808289,
0.007892319932579994,
0.07722540199756622,
0.7741222381591797,
0.015004470944404602,
-0.03962648659944534,
0.022798312827944756,
0.019341716542840004,
0.14185771346092224,
-0.3040344715118408,
-0.1492968499660492,
0.2494034469127655,
0.7359009981155396,
-0.14785493910312653,
0.2088901251554489,
0.4208097755908966,
-0.2205045372247696,
0.18569067120552063,
0.3074658513069153,
0.6252124905586243,
0.687432050704956,
-0.5678938031196594,
0.0718841701745987,
0.17286017537117004,
-0.48675575852394104,
-0.009457536973059177,
0.41249215602874756,
-0.10419447720050812,
0.24513237178325653,
-0.36793985962867737,
0.41241946816444397,
0.19856110215187073,
-1.17928946018219,
0.6209621429443359,
-0.31993886828422546,
-0.4037916362285614,
-0.3812984526157379,
0.06848247349262238,
-0.005516823846846819,
0.6205401420593262,
0.5511855483055115,
-0.4697115421295166,
0.43524685502052307,
-0.4792363941669464,
0.36460334062576294,
0.243742898106575,
-0.40922829508781433,
-0.2853173315525055,
0.8772690892219543,
0.2812901437282562,
-0.552618682384491,
0.4288337528705597,
-0.2716508209705353,
-0.5844663381576538,
0.7599791884422302,
0.4891028106212616,
0.9741617441177368,
-0.11899714171886444,
0.26951441168785095,
-0.04824559763073921,
-0.1760554313659668,
-0.14581963419914246,
0.633664608001709,
-0.2255074679851532,
-0.42970985174179077,
0.032888416200876236,
-0.1773214340209961,
-0.9405031800270081,
0.0017746039666235447,
-0.453900009393692,
0.2808026671409607,
-0.4119615852832794,
-0.6106360554695129,
-0.01213217806071043,
0.4102557897567749,
-0.763978123664856,
0.21505890786647797,
-0.34195777773857117,
0.8003016710281372,
-0.286048948764801,
0.3873072564601898,
0.6875426769256592,
-0.6400545239448547,
-0.5137631297111511,
-0.06864424049854279,
-0.09771393984556198,
-0.6896497011184692,
0.7318432927131653,
0.39230749011039734,
-0.3134824335575104,
-0.20847365260124207,
-0.3340907394886017,
-0.7061407566070557,
1.400654673576355,
0.3786257207393646,
-0.5397964119911194,
0.19224269688129425,
0.4824432134628296,
0.7072710990905762,
-0.545918881893158,
0.6599071621894836,
0.4232980012893677,
0.38414353132247925,
0.32350635528564453,
-0.5973675847053528,
0.14108821749687195,
-0.5479096174240112,
0.06148906424641609,
-0.08971375972032547,
-0.9653261303901672,
0.7356327176094055,
0.3941316604614258,
-0.2180318981409073,
0.20637086033821106,
0.22909459471702576,
0.3217354714870453,
0.6659863591194153,
0.48982423543930054,
0.33127889037132263,
0.34482693672180176,
0.11323022097349167,
0.8175497055053711,
-0.5995263457298279,
0.18798495829105377,
1.2402640581130981,
-0.7286925315856934,
0.8838353157043457,
0.15358932316303253,
0.06061248108744621,
0.3753148317337036,
0.41303882002830505,
-0.02026139758527279,
0.5114020109176636,
0.36589258909225464,
-0.5471937656402588,
-0.1903611272573471,
-0.48578447103500366,
-0.3855392634868622,
0.3426949381828308,
0.24832764267921448,
-0.5347089171409607,
-0.357278972864151,
-0.3657790720462799,
-0.1624993085861206,
0.18734192848205566,
0.19977383315563202,
0.9889346957206726,
-0.1371842920780182,
-0.7284091114997864,
0.5884898900985718,
-0.10743061453104019,
0.1034877672791481,
-0.6278456449508667,
0.12646694481372833,
-0.4439826011657715,
0.6044425368309021,
0.13491573929786682,
-0.4795275032520294,
-0.05180825665593147,
-0.3065231442451477,
0.20195959508419037,
-0.09270597249269485,
0.7424563765525818,
-0.1441401243209839,
-0.08502118289470673,
0.39946624636650085,
0.5267207026481628,
0.2113535851240158,
-0.263526052236557,
-1.1172977685928345,
0.20480875670909882,
-0.3195154666900635,
-0.5603348016738892,
0.056612204760313034,
0.16933083534240723,
-0.24867461621761322,
0.7509273886680603,
0.41703200340270996,
-0.18632929027080536,
-0.008824207819998264,
0.19039897620677948,
0.9269333481788635,
-0.41331684589385986,
-0.5393486022949219,
-0.3353574275970459,
0.28067269921302795,
-0.5635439157485962,
-0.12701664865016937,
0.8824605345726013,
0.961307168006897,
0.8868448734283447,
-0.008028144016861916,
0.5784351825714111,
0.26368069648742676,
0.44759371876716614,
0.05672620236873627,
0.5487955212593079,
-0.5497716665267944,
0.39292705059051514,
0.32235991954803467,
-1.2732151746749878,
-0.0217624232172966,
0.25955408811569214,
-0.3931887745857239,
0.0747649148106575,
0.6028311848640442,
1.1486873626708984,
-0.11599303781986237,
0.2807558476924896,
0.28440091013908386,
0.17207691073417664,
0.5616772770881653,
0.15330050885677338,
0.951655387878418,
-0.47627490758895874,
0.8346914052963257,
0.06851081550121307,
0.024708114564418793,
-0.5641117691993713,
-0.5369482636451721,
-0.619273841381073,
-0.17297978699207306,
-0.383035808801651,
-0.11143871396780014,
0.5630816221237183,
1.0225014686584473,
0.78714519739151,
-0.61420738697052,
-0.4492368698120117,
-0.1787976622581482,
-0.09734708070755005,
-0.4314689338207245,
-0.2165827602148056,
-0.1358308643102646,
-0.5119200348854065,
-0.8007045388221741,
0.4547344744205475,
0.11516808718442917,
0.017042215913534164,
-0.2525906562805176,
0.028565851971507072,
0.015327280387282372,
0.4136919379234314,
0.3092261254787445,
0.3982342779636383,
-0.32983988523483276,
-0.06437403708696365,
0.2926280200481415,
0.13793152570724487,
0.21106109023094177,
0.9476062655448914,
-0.5967987775802612,
0.7893185019493103,
0.6193047165870667,
0.5230298042297363,
0.9571041464805603,
0.48620420694351196,
0.7953166365623474,
-0.9353166818618774,
0.06858425587415695,
0.21542733907699585,
-0.05665577948093414,
0.18116214871406555,
-0.34543994069099426,
0.25144559144973755,
0.01801666058599949,
-0.7816933989524841,
-0.4286171495914459,
0.2897946536540985,
-0.841148853302002,
-0.18454527854919434,
1.0418187379837036,
-0.1282113492488861,
-0.4299811124801636,
-0.24288435280323029,
-0.5015751719474792,
0.020810231566429138,
-0.7500481009483337,
0.6675106883049011,
0.14599376916885376,
-0.07135474681854248,
-0.142401784658432,
-0.7118801474571228,
0.2269914299249649,
0.5174081325531006,
-0.5267346501350403,
-0.15831910073757172,
0.2855895757675171,
0.20995908975601196,
0.15423962473869324,
0.5802043080329895,
0.06819950044155121,
0.19317211210727692,
0.09622936695814133,
0.022363843396306038,
-0.09806939214468002,
-0.17251528799533844,
0.24290412664413452,
0.6116631627082825,
0.4599531888961792,
-0.6366289258003235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00938v1 | MalAlgoQA: A Pedagogical Approach for Evaluating Counterfactual Reasoning Abilities | 2024-07-01T03:39:13 | 2024-07-01T03:39:13 | Naiming Liu, Shashank Sonkar, Myco Le, Richard Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | This paper introduces MalAlgoQA, a novel dataset designed to evaluate the
counterfactual reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) through a
pedagogical approach. The dataset comprises mathematics and reading
comprehension questions, each accompanied by four answer choices and their
corresponding rationales. We focus on the incorrect answer rationales, termed
"malgorithms", which highlights flawed reasoning steps leading to incorrect
answers and offers valuable insights into erroneous thought processes. We also
propose the Malgorithm Identification task, where LLMs are assessed based on
their ability to identify corresponding malgorithm given an incorrect answer
choice. To evaluate the model performance, we introduce two metrics: Algorithm
Identification Accuracy (AIA) for correct answer rationale identification, and
Malgorithm Identification Accuracy (MIA) for incorrect answer rationale
identification. The task is challenging since state-of-the-art LLMs exhibit
significant drops in MIA as compared to AIA. Moreover, we find that the
chain-of-thought prompting technique not only fails to consistently enhance
MIA, but can also lead to underperformance compared to simple prompting. These
findings hold significant implications for the development of more
cognitively-inspired LLMs to improve their counterfactual reasoning abilities,
particularly through a pedagogical perspective where understanding and
rectifying student misconceptions are crucial. | [
-0.502393364906311,
-1.3469895124435425,
0.6777933239936829,
-0.10717961937189102,
-0.18480642139911652,
0.22474126517772675,
0.10083457827568054,
0.05456630513072014,
-0.10795701295137405,
0.5012159943580627,
-0.7412013411521912,
-0.22212116420269012,
-0.5540733337402344,
-0.1034870594739914,
-0.4276362657546997,
0.755745530128479,
-0.0863749235868454,
0.1436557024717331,
-0.30720722675323486,
-0.14836406707763672,
-0.8205476999282837,
-0.4406677782535553,
-0.4629378616809845,
-0.32912391424179077,
0.37304145097732544,
0.301140159368515,
0.6186379194259644,
0.30673912167549133,
0.07735726237297058,
0.20778481662273407,
0.047127656638622284,
0.39851343631744385,
-0.5127593874931335,
-0.08041238784790039,
-0.6814540028572083,
-0.5380508899688721,
-0.2809440493583679,
0.21084749698638916,
0.3652058243751526,
0.7342738509178162,
-0.38452985882759094,
0.43483278155326843,
0.06433942168951035,
0.44522473216056824,
-0.6964055895805359,
0.061052922159433365,
-0.7643823027610779,
-0.06863009184598923,
-0.21478797495365143,
-0.03155794367194176,
-0.40361103415489197,
-0.47684818506240845,
0.1635606288909912,
-0.4448995590209961,
-0.10000139474868774,
0.02857823483645916,
0.39900919795036316,
0.2525900900363922,
-0.351047545671463,
-0.7126067280769348,
-0.36976301670074463,
0.8894339799880981,
-0.7361958622932434,
0.4229486584663391,
0.5695805549621582,
0.21070466935634613,
-0.08147014677524567,
-0.37322160601615906,
-0.7057210206985474,
-0.08407678455114365,
0.10931564122438431,
0.09569117426872253,
-0.07402742654085159,
-0.09529294818639755,
0.4174484312534332,
-0.007869359105825424,
-0.7645708322525024,
-0.1263791173696518,
-0.3946586847305298,
-0.13922181725502014,
0.7205718159675598,
0.3365279734134674,
0.158216193318367,
-0.1320381760597229,
-0.22652585804462433,
0.19774587452411652,
-0.7409980297088623,
0.16831068694591522,
0.337857723236084,
-0.010761712677776814,
0.12754173576831818,
0.40597590804100037,
0.015885351225733757,
0.8096256852149963,
0.22587086260318756,
-0.26146358251571655,
0.20603562891483307,
-0.09384195506572723,
-0.5401223301887512,
0.04509544000029564,
0.43483927845954895,
0.05523619428277016,
0.47284919023513794,
0.10760936141014099,
-0.09860195219516754,
0.0304213035851717,
0.37420833110809326,
-0.4156057834625244,
-0.3347437381744385,
0.0272592231631279,
-0.27784186601638794,
-0.4199693500995636,
-0.20996494591236115,
-0.8527474403381348,
-0.3359706997871399,
-0.2969222962856293,
0.9633511304855347,
-0.3121616244316101,
-0.022093314677476883,
-0.005524458829313517,
0.3630068302154541,
-0.033316273242235184,
0.6066854000091553,
-0.7738863229751587,
0.08313512057065964,
0.4958485960960388,
0.5245359539985657,
0.24289293587207794,
-0.28221961855888367,
-0.47158440947532654,
-0.06459097564220428,
-0.7551559805870056,
0.4685424566268921,
-0.6897477507591248,
-0.28912848234176636,
-0.17270347476005554,
-0.017076700925827026,
-0.38549208641052246,
-0.4913334548473358,
0.5344883799552917,
-0.47107189893722534,
0.33789631724357605,
-0.47952497005462646,
-0.376616895198822,
-0.9092572331428528,
0.5750434398651123,
-0.4662471413612366,
0.8465489745140076,
0.06418807059526443,
-0.5163322687149048,
-0.012264999561011791,
-0.5486154556274414,
-0.12403213977813721,
-0.0067496998235583305,
-0.16966864466667175,
-0.11276672035455704,
0.010109838098287582,
0.3363810181617737,
0.3122572600841522,
-0.5098501443862915,
0.7960286736488342,
-0.1363140493631363,
-0.3156169354915619,
0.5444382429122925,
-1.007042646408081,
1.056986689567566,
0.14198258519172668,
-0.40934064984321594,
-0.11837118864059448,
-0.6268413066864014,
0.019145680591464043,
0.22631685435771942,
-0.10113655775785446,
-0.45392686128616333,
-0.009628284722566605,
-0.3436591923236847,
0.3140077590942383,
0.06226949393749237,
-0.32880735397338867,
0.13147397339344025,
-0.3722391724586487,
0.25469377636909485,
0.7522419691085815,
-0.039953600615262985,
0.01902877725660801,
-0.6200522184371948,
0.5724010467529297,
-0.18797647953033447,
0.3319559395313263,
-0.09268991649150848,
-0.5862224102020264,
-0.7231130003929138,
0.040427546948194504,
0.2499997913837433,
0.8359108567237854,
-0.9855127930641174,
-0.275288850069046,
0.24922671914100647,
-0.5843160152435303,
-0.4276319444179535,
0.4983631372451782,
0.7376080751419067,
0.9753250479698181,
0.4902641475200653,
-0.18340176343917847,
-0.4175100326538086,
-0.800632894039154,
-0.3786298930644989,
-0.5319007039070129,
0.4330956041812897,
0.4560067355632782,
0.7433803677558899,
-0.1530885547399521,
0.43335071206092834,
-0.22863741219043732,
0.12723393738269806,
0.001446794718503952,
0.2062959223985672,
0.3281177878379822,
0.34968337416648865,
0.40742114186286926,
-0.7203933000564575,
-0.16827112436294556,
-0.42506831884384155,
-0.8361330032348633,
-0.5407962203025818,
-0.1752530038356781,
0.039760835468769073,
0.4288749694824219,
0.3108353614807129,
-0.555314838886261,
0.4751009941101074,
0.43792885541915894,
-0.33552688360214233,
0.8595842719078064,
0.18484468758106232,
0.3985854983329773,
-0.6044236421585083,
0.11946501582860947,
-0.23709963262081146,
0.045954763889312744,
-0.554427444934845,
0.04142618551850319,
0.004391886759549379,
0.23268991708755493,
-0.5300924181938171,
0.6879308223724365,
-0.15106400847434998,
0.255155086517334,
0.05058503523468971,
0.1240454688668251,
-0.05319199338555336,
0.39991050958633423,
-0.1365024894475937,
0.7800041437149048,
0.37085163593292236,
-0.33131125569343567,
0.7434114813804626,
0.14484892785549164,
-0.4058615565299988,
0.8000504374504089,
-0.34335047006607056,
0.13541629910469055,
-0.07561982423067093,
0.09407229721546173,
-1.0334548950195312,
-0.04933469370007515,
0.5392070412635803,
-0.32537147402763367,
0.13198168575763702,
-0.1779656708240509,
-0.13368095457553864,
-0.3983113467693329,
-0.09211983531713486,
0.5351541042327881,
0.3775824010372162,
-0.5515652298927307,
0.670742928981781,
0.10604752600193024,
-0.4317109286785126,
-1.0550518035888672,
-0.6231964826583862,
0.10121399909257889,
-0.4300169050693512,
-0.2548575699329376,
-0.10619476437568665,
-0.15972182154655457,
-0.5893312692642212,
-0.006215002853423357,
-0.22409465909004211,
-0.08290591835975647,
0.17686466872692108,
0.2282014638185501,
0.49673914909362793,
-0.18069598078727722,
0.47178933024406433,
0.14387214183807373,
0.0705312192440033,
0.3583459258079529,
-0.13493596017360687,
0.45448166131973267,
-0.04110214114189148,
-0.4548873007297516,
-0.1460038423538208,
0.058872733265161514,
0.5599456429481506,
-0.18938402831554413,
0.6007075309753418,
0.4053839147090912,
-0.5207019448280334,
-0.29660701751708984,
-0.7697411179542542,
0.03703196346759796,
-0.3665607273578644,
0.3299535810947418,
-0.5807019472122192,
-0.45331817865371704,
0.45086824893951416,
0.042471662163734436,
0.015115802176296711,
0.3553207814693451,
0.5855827927589417,
-0.19788795709609985,
0.9461483359336853,
-0.09092005342245102,
0.322360098361969,
0.025600271299481392,
-0.3665787875652313,
0.059631459414958954,
-0.7806230783462524,
-0.7082571983337402,
-0.26080217957496643,
-0.0002531519567128271,
-0.12039270251989365,
-0.6809383034706116,
0.1480921357870102,
0.30167511105537415,
-0.49783119559288025,
-0.051510442048311234,
-0.11156215518712997,
0.44801804423332214,
0.40197625756263733,
0.07511302828788757,
0.14658468961715698,
-0.21169285476207733,
-0.5005202889442444,
0.04836400970816612,
-0.7232075333595276,
-0.8392912745475769,
1.1723428964614868,
0.1452103555202484,
0.9437536001205444,
0.4088672697544098,
0.27768564224243164,
0.4063943922519684,
0.5833971500396729,
-0.7348083853721619,
0.5719414949417114,
0.1902461051940918,
-0.7945465445518494,
-0.3471486270427704,
-0.3914860188961029,
-0.6264281272888184,
0.330538809299469,
-0.3369332253932953,
-0.8161593675613403,
0.14009815454483032,
0.053966403007507324,
-0.39775052666664124,
0.28045937418937683,
-0.5279242396354675,
0.9532495141029358,
-0.44073808193206787,
-0.5366395711898804,
-0.3475781977176666,
-0.40796419978141785,
0.5849080681800842,
-0.5856702923774719,
0.5109883546829224,
0.2433670610189438,
0.10774243623018265,
0.9120534658432007,
-0.22000114619731903,
0.7992802858352661,
-0.17158730328083038,
-0.34561651945114136,
0.5301032662391663,
0.5823885202407837,
0.30315032601356506,
0.2344268411397934,
-0.12212072312831879,
0.14072522521018982,
0.31652405858039856,
-0.4112616181373596,
-0.9541940093040466,
0.7255573272705078,
-0.5619559288024902,
-1.091412901878357,
-0.5038414597511292,
-0.7802287936210632,
-0.5004357099533081,
-0.005533923394978046,
-0.12071094661951065,
0.6912863254547119,
-0.3096606433391571,
-0.08777186274528503,
0.8120456337928772,
-0.42620599269866943,
0.3575391173362732,
0.5878978371620178,
-0.3876214921474457,
-0.4297870993614197,
0.8261533379554749,
0.6020380258560181,
0.22646452486515045,
0.07997779548168182,
0.0851767435669899,
-0.6357911229133606,
-0.6337047219276428,
-0.7764860391616821,
0.21977390348911285,
-0.9469160437583923,
-0.14481568336486816,
-0.4972822666168213,
-0.3021129071712494,
-0.14437194168567657,
-0.14429858326911926,
-0.016773948445916176,
-0.2598162889480591,
-0.27002131938934326,
-0.0038005055394023657,
-0.17584756016731262,
0.9745668768882751,
-0.13907425105571747,
0.0588788203895092,
-0.5007811784744263,
0.10329471528530121,
0.7161714434623718,
-0.13966147601604462,
0.3360423743724823,
-0.791130542755127,
-0.038275573402643204,
0.3725316822528839,
-0.5654222369194031,
-1.2226678133010864,
0.3830038905143738,
-0.0221438966691494,
0.9105499386787415,
0.47146549820899963,
-0.06825747340917587,
0.7043035626411438,
-0.2136133760213852,
0.6713898181915283,
0.0460343174636364,
-1.1480178833007812,
0.6993005871772766,
-0.09424034506082535,
0.2589312791824341,
0.25062400102615356,
0.4930451512336731,
-0.4819487929344177,
-0.06676578521728516,
-0.599168062210083,
-0.3156948685646057,
0.6656394600868225,
0.010774044319987297,
0.05252233147621155,
0.03870252147316933,
0.27530336380004883,
0.27329015731811523,
0.26288697123527527,
-0.4870775640010834,
-0.12946178019046783,
-0.33087727427482605,
-0.39004799723625183,
-0.31125569343566895,
-0.37052229046821594,
-0.22375430166721344,
-0.17954833805561066,
0.9412168264389038,
-0.12463479489088058,
-0.3028896152973175,
0.20907096564769745,
-0.38953813910484314,
-0.15731197595596313,
0.4028047025203705,
0.7316551208496094,
1.0867995023727417,
-0.18392843008041382,
0.35842764377593994,
0.7100353837013245,
-0.4855283200740814,
0.33933690190315247,
0.014826304279267788,
-0.2020118236541748,
-0.2495560348033905,
0.5149195790290833,
0.5763751864433289,
-0.12324412912130356,
-0.9866846799850464,
0.30762773752212524,
0.024327199906110764,
-0.25215238332748413,
-0.03073461353778839,
0.1627865582704544,
0.0040062000043690205,
0.5796983242034912,
0.6256189942359924,
0.11972202360630035,
0.07842154800891876,
-0.7650948762893677,
-0.05374675989151001,
0.4246920347213745,
-0.3231474459171295,
-0.29954785108566284,
0.40714195370674133,
0.07224791496992111,
-0.5047019720077515,
0.4433635175228119,
-0.042391009628772736,
-0.7428328990936279,
0.7543531656265259,
0.6823419332504272,
0.4660505950450897,
-0.5634864568710327,
0.5097244381904602,
0.2738526165485382,
0.6218247413635254,
0.062325481325387955,
0.3835860788822174,
-0.1115637794137001,
-0.6687933802604675,
-0.4887623190879822,
-0.42889395356178284,
-0.21416075527668,
0.5247554183006287,
-0.3231695890426636,
-0.023627471178770065,
-0.44536280632019043,
-0.11929400265216827,
-0.032373588532209396,
0.1445803940296173,
-0.4466892182826996,
0.5333868861198425,
0.1943240910768509,
0.8325508832931519,
-0.9562534093856812,
0.6668745279312134,
0.8058139085769653,
-0.27819156646728516,
-0.8157330751419067,
-0.04974207282066345,
0.43087300658226013,
-0.7920088768005371,
0.8348654508590698,
-0.1122620552778244,
-0.1440318077802658,
-0.08504332602024078,
-0.41873738169670105,
-0.8129439949989319,
0.9545396566390991,
0.4593174457550049,
-0.7545264363288879,
0.05234649404883385,
-0.11997438222169876,
0.32458630204200745,
-0.3662491738796234,
0.5260450839996338,
0.37569287419319153,
0.45378705859184265,
0.15349940955638885,
-1.1752406358718872,
0.19326196610927582,
-0.05284544825553894,
-0.2532641589641571,
0.0196857750415802,
-0.45314091444015503,
0.7814835906028748,
-0.45873257517814636,
-0.08731573075056076,
0.07935367524623871,
0.026608847081661224,
0.38859185576438904,
0.6362425684928894,
0.3786858022212982,
0.8030204176902771,
0.90234375,
-0.046306051313877106,
0.5746071934700012,
0.2422936111688614,
0.40695720911026,
0.9502063989639282,
-0.024670332670211792,
0.590739905834198,
0.5492053627967834,
-0.19509461522102356,
0.47229209542274475,
0.6648252010345459,
0.12264850735664368,
0.5329201817512512,
0.22688889503479004,
-0.14772048592567444,
-0.5258803963661194,
-0.14165402948856354,
-0.31502461433410645,
0.5523543357849121,
0.7145004272460938,
-0.4028998911380768,
-0.2497626394033432,
0.19186869263648987,
-0.06846258044242859,
0.18763741850852966,
-0.6212825179100037,
0.3951628506183624,
0.08386177569627762,
-0.6602854132652283,
0.9250510334968567,
-0.04959852248430252,
0.25542742013931274,
-0.09374414384365082,
-0.25703898072242737,
-0.11917976289987564,
-0.011200991459190845,
-0.11660908907651901,
-1.0016456842422485,
0.26919659972190857,
-0.03677846118807793,
-0.07729503512382507,
0.09391172975301743,
0.48417866230010986,
-0.32698866724967957,
-0.5786608457565308,
-0.04247966781258583,
0.8358431458473206,
0.14906558394432068,
0.3447571098804474,
-1.0091315507888794,
0.019299063831567764,
-0.0017482235562056303,
-0.10976196825504303,
-0.04653109237551689,
0.28472957015037537,
-0.4048447906970978,
0.8715716600418091,
0.5482824444770813,
0.09556202590465546,
-0.13291697204113007,
0.07648041844367981,
0.5307337045669556,
-0.48047196865081787,
-0.14188024401664734,
-1.0111924409866333,
0.17641112208366394,
0.22705194354057312,
-0.36175307631492615,
0.7550233006477356,
0.3022542893886566,
0.9444655776023865,
-0.0019134845351800323,
0.7087439894676208,
0.15239767730236053,
0.4443152844905853,
-0.7435427904129028,
0.5060124397277832,
-0.3992641866207123,
0.5130935311317444,
-0.42946919798851013,
-0.8634313941001892,
-0.16128118336200714,
0.8477097153663635,
-0.8848316073417664,
0.129494771361351,
0.6326775550842285,
0.9158084392547607,
-0.05440730229020119,
0.17794282734394073,
0.5889233350753784,
0.4687357544898987,
0.029145723208785057,
0.8983310461044312,
1.2629718780517578,
-0.4950701594352722,
0.28872328996658325,
0.1033981516957283,
-0.19337062537670135,
-0.1623729169368744,
-0.4588184356689453,
-1.272905707359314,
-0.6254749894142151,
-0.22870482504367828,
-0.3741443455219269,
0.5666928291320801,
0.889599084854126,
0.4708386957645416,
-0.7011908292770386,
-0.05718005821108818,
-0.004380575381219387,
0.42768773436546326,
-0.12967658042907715,
-0.22530868649482727,
0.31282666325569153,
-0.01995801366865635,
-0.5450757145881653,
0.30250686407089233,
0.2731434404850006,
-0.03176942840218544,
-0.3954385817050934,
-0.2314247339963913,
-0.5361454486846924,
0.778053343296051,
0.533169150352478,
0.08643793314695358,
-1.156140923500061,
-0.1220589429140091,
-0.14859545230865479,
0.05245155841112137,
-0.41640573740005493,
0.39857715368270874,
-1.0176019668579102,
0.6016064286231995,
0.3510463833808899,
0.48441770672798157,
0.3119441866874695,
0.2083294540643692,
0.16364184021949768,
-0.03302881866693497,
-0.18562737107276917,
0.310677170753479,
0.18920907378196716,
0.17368677258491516,
-0.08287979662418365,
0.41641145944595337,
0.46531540155410767,
-0.3829837441444397,
-1.0571367740631104,
0.20380236208438873,
-0.5418024063110352,
-0.5744998455047607,
0.8609209060668945,
-0.34755414724349976,
-0.19303388893604279,
-0.4950900077819824,
-0.5402507185935974,
0.07668618112802505,
-0.03876027837395668,
1.0398296117782593,
0.9909670948982239,
0.04833662137389183,
-0.5505097508430481,
-0.6450175642967224,
0.3048410415649414,
0.6094938516616821,
-0.6591128706932068,
-0.03041655197739601,
0.5060509443283081,
0.4072013199329376,
0.1328660100698471,
0.3776299059391022,
-0.09717326611280441,
0.5685083270072937,
0.03614695742726326,
-0.4615139961242676,
-0.23898133635520935,
-0.44268089532852173,
-0.23109383881092072,
0.21166962385177612,
-0.0902051106095314,
0.17340977489948273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00936v1 | Large Language Model Enhanced Knowledge Representation Learning: A Survey | 2024-07-01T03:37:35 | 2024-07-01T03:37:35 | Xin Wang, Zirui Chen, Haofen Wang, Leong Hou U, Zhao Li, Wenbin Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) with Knowledge Representation
Learning (KRL) signifies a pivotal advancement in the field of artificial
intelligence, enhancing the ability to capture and utilize complex knowledge
structures. This synergy leverages the advanced linguistic and contextual
understanding capabilities of LLMs to improve the accuracy, adaptability, and
efficacy of KRL, thereby expanding its applications and potential. Despite the
increasing volume of research focused on embedding LLMs within the domain of
knowledge representation, a thorough review that examines the fundamental
components and processes of these enhanced models is conspicuously absent. Our
survey addresses this by categorizing these models based on three distinct
Transformer architectures, and by analyzing experimental data from various KRL
downstream tasks to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each approach.
Finally, we identify and explore potential future research directions in this
emerging yet underexplored domain, proposing pathways for continued progress. | [
-0.4136175513267517,
-0.47150787711143494,
0.7223579287528992,
-0.049372896552085876,
0.1259472370147705,
0.47893884778022766,
-0.4132038354873657,
-0.66743004322052,
-0.04143919423222542,
0.5531412363052368,
-0.21600009500980377,
-0.33049240708351135,
-0.958344578742981,
-0.015079951845109463,
-0.4198850989341736,
0.5653774738311768,
-0.0037109176628291607,
0.29675430059432983,
-0.304787278175354,
-0.10694700479507446,
-0.51577228307724,
-0.7209548354148865,
-0.32819733023643494,
-0.7549558877944946,
0.4850059151649475,
0.3575129210948944,
0.5242611765861511,
0.1724845916032791,
0.5118401050567627,
0.28161439299583435,
-0.19958101212978363,
0.23333951830863953,
-0.36098527908325195,
0.2546800971031189,
-0.040918927639722824,
-0.45697149634361267,
-0.46798646450042725,
-0.18483029305934906,
0.8965969681739807,
1.0342055559158325,
-0.019152384251356125,
0.1813008040189743,
0.22454874217510223,
0.5719859600067139,
-0.6327241659164429,
0.41448646783828735,
-0.5252330303192139,
0.05454900488257408,
-0.03947335481643677,
0.16316895186901093,
-0.5678611397743225,
-0.3592357337474823,
0.37225085496902466,
-0.27371567487716675,
-0.08096150308847427,
0.01271861419081688,
0.19967453181743622,
0.21074429154396057,
-0.7614681720733643,
-0.41752511262893677,
-1.062304973602295,
0.9644887447357178,
-0.6409844756126404,
0.8904029130935669,
0.04169578105211258,
0.4313375651836395,
0.05768020823597908,
-0.9135281443595886,
-0.3948383033275604,
-0.3633470833301544,
-0.13672257959842682,
0.0699506476521492,
-0.2854517698287964,
0.07993429154157639,
0.05346059799194336,
0.30112606287002563,
-0.24802562594413757,
0.47780507802963257,
-0.32757723331451416,
-0.22062823176383972,
0.5840367674827576,
0.339504599571228,
0.09992609173059464,
-0.0008323892252519727,
-0.19394251704216003,
-0.2063475400209427,
-0.8786402940750122,
-0.022947028279304504,
0.11083080619573593,
0.2625649869441986,
0.02325829118490219,
0.580285370349884,
-0.07654549926519394,
0.5876521468162537,
-0.14335840940475464,
-0.028362974524497986,
0.19149157404899597,
-0.1289319545030594,
-0.13757827877998352,
-0.046221017837524414,
0.6759700179100037,
0.10165627300739288,
-0.09544575959444046,
-0.25205594301223755,
-0.3119264245033264,
-0.264924019575119,
0.22105956077575684,
-0.6507284045219421,
-0.10777656733989716,
0.057856470346450806,
-0.4738689363002777,
-0.18112462759017944,
0.14507867395877838,
-0.5647144913673401,
-0.5896700024604797,
-0.43797770142555237,
0.16933928430080414,
-0.21817529201507568,
-0.5351969003677368,
0.029203731566667557,
0.06804180145263672,
0.49701425433158875,
0.37883123755455017,
-0.7862055897712708,
0.17854589223861694,
0.8973110914230347,
0.5426216125488281,
-0.33156663179397583,
-0.18912722170352936,
0.07947563380002975,
0.2368752658367157,
-0.41718733310699463,
0.7909437417984009,
-0.6102375984191895,
-0.4422037899494171,
0.38038867712020874,
0.03723084554076195,
-0.07295706123113632,
-0.6697048544883728,
0.5961368083953857,
-1.050609827041626,
0.05317511036992073,
-0.3135339915752411,
-0.8151105642318726,
-0.5402962565422058,
0.3646605312824249,
-0.7738645672798157,
0.8679929971694946,
0.21675944328308105,
-0.46276864409446716,
0.10344403982162476,
-0.7063760757446289,
-0.2726651728153229,
0.2206253558397293,
-0.31717151403427124,
-0.3258377015590668,
0.26915138959884644,
0.03262113034725189,
0.7375772595405579,
-0.5348867177963257,
0.4150708317756653,
-0.2293560653924942,
-0.1266600489616394,
0.3563714027404785,
-0.4759502708911896,
0.48803579807281494,
0.10226843506097794,
-0.1775822788476944,
0.18586140871047974,
-0.5601587295532227,
-0.09602232277393341,
0.211221843957901,
-0.47687527537345886,
-0.37433233857154846,
0.02098879963159561,
0.05234363675117493,
0.18188290297985077,
0.44091707468032837,
-0.4104524850845337,
0.4219975769519806,
-0.2012113779783249,
0.48420509696006775,
0.612151563167572,
-0.13972026109695435,
0.8432931900024414,
-0.043223489075899124,
0.5532920360565186,
0.07024678587913513,
-0.04413117840886116,
-0.05981948599219322,
-0.3540550470352173,
-0.7666068077087402,
0.03747696802020073,
0.39424484968185425,
0.25007426738739014,
-0.6262555122375488,
0.29944783449172974,
-0.48679885268211365,
-0.5260542631149292,
-0.4784972071647644,
0.14620591700077057,
0.17365476489067078,
0.1499336063861847,
0.34332266449928284,
0.07938189804553986,
-0.6173527836799622,
-0.8228142261505127,
-0.13187256455421448,
-0.11131370067596436,
0.07570281624794006,
0.4030313789844513,
0.5542413592338562,
-0.42021915316581726,
0.8301254510879517,
-0.4460659325122833,
-0.182196244597435,
-0.6290118098258972,
-0.09950641542673111,
0.22890563309192657,
0.1737373322248459,
0.4355716407299042,
-0.8099341988563538,
-0.5703144073486328,
0.2889786958694458,
-0.6814219355583191,
0.23420697450637817,
0.25948724150657654,
0.21631351113319397,
0.06595874577760696,
0.7444245219230652,
-0.7318259477615356,
0.08651282638311386,
0.6122208833694458,
-0.09681277722120285,
0.5708190202713013,
-0.12229248881340027,
0.08499152213335037,
-0.9765561819076538,
0.0567484088242054,
-0.30449965596199036,
-0.05042076110839844,
-0.9249392747879028,
0.014646359719336033,
0.36458608508110046,
0.036360591650009155,
-0.26844799518585205,
0.5641242265701294,
-0.6864116191864014,
-0.2512388825416565,
-0.3644864559173584,
-0.03330697864294052,
-0.2911417782306671,
0.2092112898826599,
0.06277219951152802,
0.5663933157920837,
0.48530256748199463,
-0.5697873830795288,
0.4532831907272339,
0.18513432145118713,
-0.5969051122665405,
0.10137370973825455,
-0.6427059769630432,
0.15922878682613373,
-0.1525312066078186,
0.3017950654029846,
-0.9085490107536316,
-0.48392602801322937,
0.2046361118555069,
-0.3207734525203705,
0.44449347257614136,
0.08407510817050934,
-0.5421910285949707,
-0.3939739167690277,
-0.04486735165119171,
0.47381752729415894,
0.7603404521942139,
-0.528044581413269,
0.9116621017456055,
0.45592615008354187,
-0.1064201295375824,
-0.5195643901824951,
-0.6634594798088074,
-0.05386944115161896,
-0.1891968846321106,
-0.33306312561035156,
0.3970967233181,
0.25635066628456116,
-0.33889275789260864,
0.06069595366716385,
0.048149965703487396,
0.02276870608329773,
-0.07075131684541702,
-0.03142577037215233,
0.12341336905956268,
-0.4103301167488098,
0.19457338750362396,
-0.1226581484079361,
0.10567718744277954,
0.2347690761089325,
-0.24073192477226257,
0.7452131509780884,
-0.01126844622194767,
-0.642349123954773,
-0.18762639164924622,
0.29974502325057983,
0.8470860719680786,
-0.3893390893936157,
0.8796625733375549,
0.5656075477600098,
-0.2660510838031769,
-0.2945811450481415,
-0.5718270540237427,
-0.02509957179427147,
-0.422214150428772,
0.5999312400817871,
-0.11485536396503448,
-1.4219155311584473,
0.5147024393081665,
-0.4559876322746277,
0.06965404748916626,
0.5263183116912842,
0.6441484093666077,
-0.0803879126906395,
1.0296037197113037,
1.0121153593063354,
-0.38016438484191895,
0.44525259733200073,
-0.3717929422855377,
0.4622136056423187,
-1.0028694868087769,
-0.4553312063217163,
-0.5014528036117554,
-0.2689271569252014,
-0.49013084173202515,
-0.4713653326034546,
0.42358916997909546,
0.08599133044481277,
-0.2502612769603729,
-0.003266445128247142,
-0.2579520046710968,
0.15612269937992096,
0.2755916118621826,
-0.09847652912139893,
0.38396334648132324,
-0.0976305678486824,
0.08463431149721146,
0.15951284766197205,
-0.8485331535339355,
-0.47895732522010803,
1.1207561492919922,
0.6939921975135803,
0.7211111187934875,
0.21000619232654572,
0.4502616822719574,
0.23670093715190887,
0.3918312191963196,
-1.0137137174606323,
0.44939324259757996,
-0.05049166828393936,
-0.4886337220668793,
-0.34579238295555115,
-0.21556897461414337,
-0.8011414408683777,
0.21465131640434265,
-0.003007713006809354,
-0.5295482277870178,
0.18685494363307953,
0.053706180304288864,
-0.1398647427558899,
0.46669602394104004,
-0.4865822196006775,
0.5529668927192688,
-0.2508808672428131,
0.045328207314014435,
-0.3941592872142792,
-0.47893357276916504,
0.5600890517234802,
-0.29528379440307617,
0.3529213070869446,
0.15351590514183044,
-0.08869082480669022,
0.6810094714164734,
-0.024566104635596275,
0.9733836650848389,
-0.23853687942028046,
-0.44682562351226807,
0.24105659127235413,
-0.16197949647903442,
0.5694394111633301,
-0.38559964299201965,
-0.003968685399740934,
0.2595057487487793,
-0.26951614022254944,
-0.04614918678998947,
-0.6678348183631897,
0.5157874226570129,
-0.8206018209457397,
-0.5453473925590515,
-0.14100271463394165,
-0.6408737301826477,
-0.47945764660835266,
0.07424076646566391,
-0.10026639699935913,
0.3448733389377594,
-0.16341020166873932,
0.5453391671180725,
0.765201985836029,
-0.2664470970630646,
0.2998371124267578,
0.38441553711891174,
-0.3744601011276245,
-0.5190250277519226,
0.8499133586883545,
0.11921384185552597,
0.32613325119018555,
0.4510505199432373,
0.11221242696046829,
-0.4475463628768921,
-0.7711708545684814,
-0.030902903527021408,
0.13057048618793488,
-0.9644472002983093,
-0.20029127597808838,
-0.7268208861351013,
-0.4629248380661011,
-0.6014884114265442,
0.07478051632642746,
-0.4171891212463379,
-0.28775593638420105,
-0.2636297941207886,
0.0444488525390625,
0.2883915305137634,
1.3264480829238892,
0.21793930232524872,
0.5809370279312134,
-0.9054039716720581,
0.08019677549600601,
0.2592221796512604,
0.3892115354537964,
0.48477110266685486,
-0.529700756072998,
-0.4742034077644348,
-0.007241327315568924,
-0.3403265178203583,
-0.6929410696029663,
0.23230424523353577,
0.03238171711564064,
0.9247673749923706,
0.34674274921417236,
-0.14655372500419617,
0.5637270212173462,
-0.6490914225578308,
0.9269999265670776,
0.26109540462493896,
-0.5987509489059448,
0.20275893807411194,
-0.17526982724666595,
0.22951585054397583,
0.07669480890035629,
0.7028234601020813,
-0.544625461101532,
-0.10094951093196869,
-0.5090800523757935,
-0.7220982313156128,
0.42342594265937805,
-0.12226587533950806,
0.1638103574514389,
0.31040582060813904,
0.17244744300842285,
0.08474161475896835,
0.1104075163602829,
-0.7127995491027832,
-0.2549852728843689,
0.20748889446258545,
-0.275553435087204,
-0.1692018359899521,
-0.40333008766174316,
0.1407342255115509,
-0.3273874819278717,
0.5658307671546936,
-0.14233246445655823,
0.32126379013061523,
-0.082556813955307,
-0.34115418791770935,
0.12958155572414398,
0.3740788400173187,
0.2790957987308502,
0.5736469626426697,
0.21385270357131958,
0.19190558791160583,
0.3186618685722351,
-0.5116093158721924,
0.06614027917385101,
-0.1049969419836998,
-0.07149583846330643,
-0.11160717159509659,
0.6464841365814209,
0.740220308303833,
0.34438031911849976,
-0.6150862574577332,
0.3365405797958374,
0.10239654779434204,
-0.3222584128379822,
-0.33125901222229004,
-0.01301485300064087,
0.2536352276802063,
0.6511844992637634,
0.5773488283157349,
-0.11748326569795609,
0.02745729498565197,
-0.47952425479888916,
-0.04192756116390228,
0.6481491327285767,
-0.43156862258911133,
-0.41549280285835266,
0.31449779868125916,
0.06514576822519302,
-0.12009936571121216,
0.5636626482009888,
0.14946524798870087,
-0.8836840391159058,
0.36554211378097534,
0.4741973876953125,
0.7871174216270447,
-0.3307003974914551,
-0.08271429687738419,
0.27105531096458435,
0.36003953218460083,
-0.12146372348070145,
0.05908099561929703,
-0.24213983118534088,
-0.9589446783065796,
-0.5446785688400269,
-0.7282166481018066,
-0.4896959960460663,
0.19003403186798096,
-0.4626689553260803,
0.2227335125207901,
-0.11401204019784927,
-0.02929220162332058,
-0.17536945641040802,
-0.1074923574924469,
-0.7477051615715027,
-0.17962782084941864,
0.33072152733802795,
1.0038827657699585,
-0.8865687847137451,
0.9270334839820862,
0.9037092328071594,
-0.20233115553855896,
-0.7586296200752258,
-0.03290821984410286,
-0.26753151416778564,
-0.7007914185523987,
0.9598149657249451,
-0.045523688197135925,
-0.006221401505172253,
0.17903290688991547,
-0.5537254810333252,
-1.0399855375289917,
1.2773689031600952,
0.1915297657251358,
-0.5107652544975281,
-0.193614199757576,
0.47912028431892395,
0.4824743866920471,
-0.5141908526420593,
0.1879941076040268,
0.687633216381073,
0.4196690618991852,
0.09197966754436493,
-0.9134140610694885,
-0.18938307464122772,
0.008960832841694355,
0.22611530125141144,
0.20365695655345917,
-0.6205608248710632,
0.5318661332130432,
0.12082456797361374,
-0.14082495868206024,
0.03249216079711914,
0.8013776540756226,
0.20579437911510468,
0.011525963433086872,
0.44504573941230774,
0.3542383015155792,
0.6327648162841797,
-0.072263203561306,
0.8032154440879822,
-0.20302827656269073,
0.34865808486938477,
0.8896814584732056,
-0.40672212839126587,
0.8921893239021301,
0.4850855767726898,
-0.31046828627586365,
0.5026121139526367,
0.4556393623352051,
0.019391212612390518,
0.5263085961341858,
0.05519223213195801,
-0.3591219186782837,
-0.30515673756599426,
-0.25886625051498413,
-0.38108497858047485,
0.48464417457580566,
0.7030029892921448,
-0.4312916696071625,
-0.2423245906829834,
0.12450096756219864,
-0.34914031624794006,
-0.15916794538497925,
-0.49141016602516174,
0.9118930101394653,
0.20771177113056183,
-0.3882782459259033,
0.17124035954475403,
-0.15333965420722961,
0.7262389659881592,
-0.6382189989089966,
-0.2083968073129654,
-0.03054489940404892,
0.12315082550048828,
-0.17452222108840942,
-0.9112221598625183,
0.2148633748292923,
-0.094283327460289,
-0.19374658167362213,
-0.40918588638305664,
1.1107938289642334,
-0.35606297850608826,
-0.36243757605552673,
0.4609260559082031,
0.8317931890487671,
-0.03356744721531868,
0.2500704824924469,
-0.4479144811630249,
0.3766593635082245,
-0.16003461182117462,
-0.32938259840011597,
0.26258227229118347,
0.5120927095413208,
-0.033609434962272644,
0.7622144818305969,
0.48508259654045105,
-0.011711661703884602,
0.1811896711587906,
0.19772619009017944,
0.9776260256767273,
-0.7277143597602844,
-0.11363105475902557,
-0.7313280701637268,
0.6081482172012329,
0.019508974626660347,
0.010034280829131603,
0.8365799784660339,
0.46485990285873413,
0.9071907997131348,
-0.1761489063501358,
0.9949019551277161,
-0.1067347526550293,
0.49852892756462097,
-0.4373563528060913,
0.8518586158752441,
-0.3650335967540741,
0.17967605590820312,
-0.1812204271554947,
-1.004013180732727,
-0.3331480324268341,
0.2700355350971222,
-0.3722212314605713,
0.02853444218635559,
0.5011138916015625,
0.5280126333236694,
-0.21014122664928436,
0.09582113474607468,
0.47102126479148865,
0.2847357392311096,
0.35490772128105164,
0.4161616861820221,
1.4386906623840332,
-0.30164656043052673,
0.2805570065975189,
-0.12371378391981125,
-0.013116030022501945,
-0.25397977232933044,
-0.7899190783500671,
-0.8305469155311584,
-0.6573702692985535,
-0.11372154951095581,
0.13794754445552826,
-0.27571624517440796,
0.9032694101333618,
0.5322504043579102,
-0.8512319326400757,
-0.3528248071670532,
-0.057520098984241486,
0.1775607466697693,
0.08636367321014404,
-0.15851373970508575,
0.3915967047214508,
-0.38928210735321045,
-0.6216180920600891,
0.454888254404068,
0.10399702936410904,
-0.06273279339075089,
-0.6076048016548157,
-0.2532651722431183,
0.14705507457256317,
-0.3819465935230255,
1.038300633430481,
0.11353123933076859,
-0.8924862742424011,
-0.27132609486579895,
0.3127118647098541,
-0.011137568391859531,
-0.12544944882392883,
0.8981968760490417,
-0.6654106378555298,
0.09491952508687973,
0.5769803524017334,
1.0777955055236816,
0.267451673746109,
-0.46160033345222473,
0.580970823764801,
-0.42316168546676636,
-0.19745275378227234,
0.31367236375808716,
0.4695800840854645,
0.24922391772270203,
-0.23083242774009705,
0.22869230806827545,
-0.026732036843895912,
-0.6748684644699097,
-0.879668116569519,
0.2884294390678406,
-0.8567765951156616,
-0.2700739800930023,
1.1727598905563354,
0.0828014388680458,
-0.07429563999176025,
-0.06640511006116867,
0.009800205007195473,
0.24095700681209564,
-0.056400395929813385,
0.44900867342948914,
0.7644475698471069,
-0.3212457299232483,
-0.3402232825756073,
-0.7371264100074768,
0.23266325891017914,
0.1811198741197586,
-0.6340367197990417,
0.2666381597518921,
0.5640997290611267,
0.14593341946601868,
0.1957142949104309,
0.25313320755958557,
-0.15588295459747314,
0.007012940011918545,
-0.43803566694259644,
0.07903437316417694,
0.17274028062820435,
-0.41138869524002075,
-0.7262314558029175,
0.3202906548976898,
0.39698830246925354,
0.29812607169151306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00935v1 | Look Ahead or Look Around? A Theoretical Comparison Between Autoregressive and Masked Pretraining | 2024-07-01T03:35:59 | 2024-07-01T03:35:59 | Qi Zhang, Tianqi Du, Haotian Huang, Yifei Wang, Yisen Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In recent years, the rise of generative self-supervised learning (SSL)
paradigms has exhibited impressive performance across visual, language, and
multi-modal domains. While the varied designs of generative SSL objectives lead
to distinct properties in downstream tasks, a theoretical understanding of
these differences remains largely unexplored. In this paper, we establish the
first theoretical comparisons between two leading generative SSL paradigms:
autoregressive SSL and masked SSL. Through establishing theoretical frameworks,
we elucidate the strengths and limitations of autoregressive and masked SSL
within the primary evaluation tasks of classification and content generation.
Our findings demonstrate that in classification tasks, the flexibility of
targeted tokens in masked SSL fosters more inter-sample connections compared to
the fixed position of target tokens in autoregressive SSL, which yields
superior clustering performance. In content generation tasks, the misalignment
between the flexible lengths of test samples and the fixed length of unmasked
texts in masked SSL (vs. flexible lengths of conditional texts in
autoregressive SSL) hinders its generation performance. To leverage each
other's strengths and mitigate weaknesses, we propose diversity-enhanced
autoregressive and variable-length masked objectives, which substantially
improve the classification performance of autoregressive SSL and the generation
performance of masked SSL. Code is available at
https://github.com/PKU-ML/LookAheadLookAround. | [
-0.4939315617084503,
-0.5250599384307861,
0.11950509250164032,
0.13765309751033783,
-0.35049349069595337,
0.6293870806694031,
-0.14397032558918,
-0.38724133372306824,
0.24241845309734344,
0.1972162425518036,
-0.7271633744239807,
-0.2779598534107208,
-0.5991833806037903,
0.15334416925907135,
-0.5560423731803894,
0.9873470664024353,
-0.03806396946310997,
-0.25495555996894836,
-0.13766784965991974,
0.08462665230035782,
-0.4523102641105652,
-0.5507111549377441,
-0.5341482162475586,
-0.05316673964262009,
0.48786047101020813,
0.017841873690485954,
0.6347798705101013,
0.7508584856987,
0.40311509370803833,
0.3914209008216858,
0.33218246698379517,
-0.013097616843879223,
-0.3377852439880371,
0.3912730813026428,
-0.11636083573102951,
-0.18092180788516998,
-0.12423745542764664,
0.19787976145744324,
0.696752667427063,
0.3855651617050171,
-0.0903565064072609,
0.23142582178115845,
0.3863992989063263,
0.903106153011322,
-1.1558841466903687,
0.03807089477777481,
-0.5095202922821045,
0.4010452628135681,
-0.42693886160850525,
-0.09310116618871689,
-0.17653800547122955,
-0.05025460943579674,
-0.02981281839311123,
-0.5893884897232056,
0.6332436203956604,
0.0945606380701065,
0.7310909628868103,
0.5063420534133911,
-0.29843980073928833,
-0.19160187244415283,
-0.7245129346847534,
0.6470186114311218,
-0.2728610038757324,
0.7627725601196289,
0.21946869790554047,
0.35700175166130066,
0.23102650046348572,
-0.7790130972862244,
-0.5215113162994385,
0.04541442170739174,
-0.24846751987934113,
0.44634774327278137,
-0.2081834226846695,
-0.09096084535121918,
0.17615628242492676,
0.6730534434318542,
-0.8927584290504456,
0.33210164308547974,
-0.4986895024776459,
-0.19573146104812622,
0.9338516592979431,
0.038545943796634674,
-0.019756941124796867,
-0.08044730126857758,
-0.500131368637085,
-0.39124515652656555,
-0.5797848105430603,
-0.00017190893413498998,
0.5280060172080994,
0.1333998739719391,
-0.22540707886219025,
0.23489685356616974,
-0.40661540627479553,
0.5248042345046997,
0.47246628999710083,
0.08682100474834442,
0.4116671085357666,
-0.3676045835018158,
-0.32926833629608154,
-0.15577350556850433,
0.8899868130683899,
0.048834893852472305,
0.012487045489251614,
-0.19481879472732544,
-0.12326543033123016,
0.05457495525479317,
0.5547035336494446,
-0.5364067554473877,
-0.6605964303016663,
-0.0595981702208519,
-0.7314257025718689,
-0.4091271460056305,
0.09373567253351212,
-0.7263409495353699,
0.12236613780260086,
-0.40728291869163513,
0.526080846786499,
-0.1725022792816162,
-0.3911125063896179,
-0.15207554399967194,
-0.09234140068292618,
0.31046319007873535,
0.37189018726348877,
-0.919170081615448,
0.28138527274131775,
0.4909243583679199,
0.8415781259536743,
-0.7838999032974243,
-0.2550911009311676,
-0.2690894901752472,
-0.010345298796892166,
-0.32174205780029297,
0.5573729276657104,
-0.2705172002315521,
-0.3896631896495819,
-0.04392264783382416,
-0.11634381115436554,
-0.3192223608493805,
-0.3637644052505493,
-0.08065165579319,
-0.6234064698219299,
0.2754025459289551,
0.08711453527212143,
-0.3074323832988739,
0.19814054667949677,
-0.018852287903428078,
-0.6743986010551453,
0.8639611601829529,
0.20322002470493317,
-0.7719098925590515,
0.7765148282051086,
-0.48413774371147156,
-0.6175931692123413,
0.44591835141181946,
-0.5271320343017578,
-0.7546231746673584,
-0.09622584283351898,
-0.14004912972450256,
0.4973033368587494,
0.1033661738038063,
0.1378728300333023,
-0.3199004530906677,
-0.15426476299762726,
0.12243977189064026,
-0.46688929200172424,
0.7332573533058167,
0.6776396036148071,
-0.7959615588188171,
0.011950512416660786,
-0.7041325569152832,
0.12130069732666016,
0.1739172488451004,
0.01345498114824295,
-0.06913362443447113,
0.10315951704978943,
-0.14842382073402405,
0.34823063015937805,
-0.019574714824557304,
-0.2876986265182495,
-0.2829147279262543,
0.06294596195220947,
0.3849696218967438,
0.8984891772270203,
-0.29899245500564575,
0.40515390038490295,
0.011722179129719734,
0.7331047058105469,
-0.01470841746777296,
0.5186202526092529,
-0.4076077938079834,
-0.24361206591129303,
-0.8503823280334473,
-0.4041750431060791,
0.4054551422595978,
0.4146147072315216,
-0.8108860850334167,
0.5305361151695251,
0.10870242118835449,
-0.3592134118080139,
-0.417338490486145,
0.2905392646789551,
0.8338391780853271,
0.2638218402862549,
0.6079625487327576,
-0.8168408870697021,
-0.44986289739608765,
-0.9415526390075684,
-0.1873917132616043,
-0.3639867901802063,
0.08915026485919952,
-0.00643500592559576,
0.47538331151008606,
0.20043230056762695,
0.8440293669700623,
-0.5036319494247437,
-0.24402683973312378,
0.01992202177643776,
0.17315860092639923,
-0.4305989444255829,
0.9039375185966492,
0.4960065186023712,
-0.9441874027252197,
-0.7117843627929688,
-0.3601582646369934,
-0.7876454591751099,
0.12152201682329178,
-0.07494184374809265,
-0.08496963232755661,
0.2734980285167694,
0.6509736180305481,
-0.36379778385162354,
0.8021189570426941,
0.4815406799316406,
-0.22041630744934082,
0.5813321471214294,
-0.10105010122060776,
0.051291391253471375,
-0.5979006886482239,
-0.26638734340667725,
-0.12058652192354202,
-0.12646901607513428,
-0.5348307490348816,
0.12534059584140778,
0.21529938280582428,
-0.04565520957112312,
-0.23094454407691956,
0.30678099393844604,
-0.7270959615707397,
-0.4237408936023712,
-0.21460111439228058,
-0.18331384658813477,
0.2900073230266571,
0.27631914615631104,
0.31230810284614563,
0.8219664096832275,
0.6653864979743958,
-0.7341617345809937,
0.056523893028497696,
0.12117467820644379,
-0.277728796005249,
0.41078439354896545,
-0.4888859689235687,
-0.0756157785654068,
-0.09320903569459915,
0.39954087138175964,
-0.8960056304931641,
-0.08612219244241714,
0.280923992395401,
-0.6059105396270752,
0.6325367093086243,
0.13094423711299896,
-0.30258044600486755,
-0.5910349488258362,
-0.12020615488290787,
0.7464771270751953,
0.8364697098731995,
-0.5872912406921387,
0.31237807869911194,
0.0929860845208168,
-0.020462455227971077,
-0.4077693521976471,
-0.89151531457901,
-0.023546703159809113,
-0.3766613006591797,
-0.3854496479034424,
0.4912526607513428,
-0.1245754063129425,
-0.13978540897369385,
-0.1335751861333847,
-0.1354691982269287,
0.12965358793735504,
0.21806177496910095,
0.22708408534526825,
0.19089393317699432,
-0.2736463248729706,
0.23149444162845612,
-0.011013306677341461,
-0.163277730345726,
0.039943721145391464,
-0.5238662958145142,
0.26674437522888184,
-0.13446176052093506,
-0.6205143928527832,
-0.24647556245326996,
0.5587306022644043,
-0.1305551528930664,
-0.543052077293396,
0.6831915378570557,
0.6233985424041748,
0.1882929801940918,
-0.23952414095401764,
-0.8657041788101196,
-0.17928941547870636,
-0.5366231799125671,
-0.011434940621256828,
-0.4309837222099304,
-1.0134239196777344,
0.30182456970214844,
0.3896583020687103,
0.032572612166404724,
0.7383173704147339,
0.5371776819229126,
-0.20477639138698578,
0.7621622085571289,
0.6250481605529785,
0.4583319425582886,
0.5347815155982971,
-0.2039317786693573,
0.10701657086610794,
-0.7499892115592957,
-0.2371681183576584,
-0.21000275015830994,
-0.11315329372882843,
-0.7350181341171265,
-0.32374152541160583,
0.12301579117774963,
0.2164965122938156,
-0.3134969174861908,
0.36058416962623596,
-0.7311320304870605,
0.24607759714126587,
0.7498818039894104,
0.03619043156504631,
0.21790041029453278,
0.010298204608261585,
-0.0775420293211937,
-0.05654839798808098,
-1.0034195184707642,
-0.13100862503051758,
1.082006812095642,
0.26983949542045593,
0.6265936493873596,
-0.08434896916151047,
1.0510270595550537,
0.5157872438430786,
0.3106703758239746,
-0.2907855808734894,
0.3434705138206482,
-0.2009298950433731,
-0.5648688673973083,
-0.3774118423461914,
-0.2265855073928833,
-1.0516594648361206,
0.500950813293457,
-0.220291405916214,
-0.23963892459869385,
0.4002004861831665,
0.5368669033050537,
-0.25580307841300964,
0.2962872385978699,
-0.7338147163391113,
1.044308066368103,
-0.476649671792984,
-0.3954326808452606,
-0.008045246824622154,
-0.8711128234863281,
0.25242558121681213,
-0.27344802021980286,
0.20108622312545776,
0.2588496804237366,
0.22468817234039307,
0.6386138796806335,
-0.22936460375785828,
0.9832747578620911,
-0.10932005196809769,
-0.14469929039478302,
0.3152945041656494,
-0.032916855067014694,
0.12213496118783951,
-0.1029088944196701,
0.2758626937866211,
0.31265637278556824,
-0.33808135986328125,
-0.4439718723297119,
-0.5567657351493835,
0.3770201504230499,
-0.6578922867774963,
-0.7384767532348633,
-0.4817788004875183,
0.003814280964434147,
0.061395104974508286,
0.1883726418018341,
0.6245073080062866,
0.25731346011161804,
-0.164190411567688,
0.09284494072198868,
0.7634970545768738,
-0.024571508169174194,
0.6233802437782288,
0.5744931101799011,
-0.11586423963308334,
-0.2805468440055847,
0.8796144723892212,
0.13088257610797882,
0.6656487584114075,
0.24035105109214783,
-0.10717099159955978,
-0.31448954343795776,
-0.8039684295654297,
-0.4253702163696289,
-0.11719627678394318,
-0.6378695964813232,
-0.1703047752380371,
-0.720818817615509,
-0.4814472794532776,
-0.6386258006095886,
-0.2959994077682495,
-0.49282345175743103,
-0.2701253294944763,
-0.2772054672241211,
-0.005113109480589628,
-0.09195936471223831,
0.4470229744911194,
-0.49062368273735046,
0.23069261014461517,
-0.29426735639572144,
0.30270230770111084,
0.6271824836730957,
0.296548455953598,
0.06935200840234756,
-0.3324180841445923,
-0.3089418411254883,
-0.1640022248029709,
-0.38356563448905945,
-0.6714105010032654,
0.1345745474100113,
0.12993992865085602,
0.6769261360168457,
0.5412086248397827,
0.13412688672542572,
0.724994957447052,
-0.6152974963188171,
0.6701273322105408,
0.4931822419166565,
-0.8379499316215515,
0.6442896127700806,
-0.13202780485153198,
0.28862300515174866,
0.7281517386436462,
0.3862592875957489,
-0.13001538813114166,
-0.6634200811386108,
-0.9685046076774597,
-0.7165976762771606,
0.37119242548942566,
0.6079288125038147,
-0.06688939034938812,
-0.24903292953968048,
0.2220207303762436,
0.39229533076286316,
0.3615495562553406,
-0.7577754259109497,
-0.37157678604125977,
-0.9363943338394165,
0.01605154760181904,
-0.36489009857177734,
0.050518397241830826,
0.05994899198412895,
-0.10800870507955551,
0.4536604583263397,
-0.2083480954170227,
0.41247883439064026,
0.3551191985607147,
-0.17917367815971375,
0.06446074694395065,
0.09309264272451401,
0.3750005066394806,
0.620966911315918,
0.06784176826477051,
0.13959695398807526,
-0.010608279146254063,
-0.383541464805603,
-0.010140466503798962,
0.14520488679409027,
-0.43075281381607056,
-0.042017862200737,
0.5219621062278748,
1.0501961708068848,
-0.017149783670902252,
-0.2654939591884613,
0.5253086090087891,
0.05977233499288559,
-0.4026673436164856,
-0.5728920102119446,
0.2722536623477936,
-0.4642482101917267,
0.4289565980434418,
0.5993370413780212,
-0.25283339619636536,
0.2497473508119583,
-0.5881149172782898,
0.2420874685049057,
0.7068998217582703,
-0.24358250200748444,
-0.16962186992168427,
0.7283504605293274,
0.09880747646093369,
-0.3488041162490845,
0.5117879509925842,
-0.2920130789279938,
-0.5620254278182983,
0.6977658867835999,
0.5388562679290771,
1.2127573490142822,
-0.44295674562454224,
0.518492579460144,
0.21317072212696075,
0.2526678740978241,
0.22723883390426636,
-0.2496078461408615,
-0.6754900813102722,
-0.5418583750724792,
-0.3656454086303711,
-0.7026290893554688,
-0.052638761699199677,
-0.00905685406178236,
-0.9026784300804138,
-0.21430866420269012,
-0.2723506689071655,
-0.0057370527647435665,
0.07017620652914047,
-0.26313909888267517,
-0.7450075149536133,
0.5975549221038818,
0.10677047073841095,
0.40113863348960876,
-0.7730130553245544,
0.6529128551483154,
0.4616890847682953,
-0.3151904046535492,
-0.5308682322502136,
0.2550200819969177,
-0.052461668848991394,
-0.8244092464447021,
1.144182801246643,
0.278289794921875,
-0.16312763094902039,
-0.008381655439734459,
-0.3185141086578369,
-0.9991312026977539,
1.218026876449585,
-0.33313894271850586,
-0.5344675183296204,
-0.183908149600029,
0.22477582097053528,
0.501264750957489,
-0.6320595741271973,
0.05838080123066902,
0.22300218045711517,
0.19317537546157837,
0.21431969106197357,
-0.8212384581565857,
0.10898636281490326,
-0.23207958042621613,
0.17458346486091614,
0.2426634430885315,
-0.9641529321670532,
0.9255744814872742,
0.06077750027179718,
-0.5479013323783875,
-0.24859443306922913,
0.9381635785102844,
0.15616315603256226,
0.45887693762779236,
0.7616286277770996,
0.4210527837276459,
0.1862289011478424,
-0.05123325064778328,
0.8129907846450806,
-0.22300124168395996,
0.2479008138179779,
1.0776917934417725,
-0.15637555718421936,
0.511774480342865,
0.26372000575065613,
-0.405272901058197,
0.6413891315460205,
0.7455540895462036,
-0.3342803716659546,
0.7349639534950256,
0.20479243993759155,
-0.20041321218013763,
-0.3942180275917053,
0.3762487471103668,
-0.6573836803436279,
0.49438026547431946,
0.15077896416187286,
-0.4136970043182373,
-0.23490291833877563,
0.1360505372285843,
-0.39800524711608887,
0.013289806433022022,
-0.3492509126663208,
0.8284369111061096,
0.07104849070310593,
-0.8763507008552551,
0.39788922667503357,
-0.07747576385736465,
0.598733127117157,
-0.4642583429813385,
0.1894357055425644,
-0.2304903119802475,
0.002800039481371641,
-0.12786059081554413,
-0.6160364747047424,
0.44012337923049927,
-0.16455216705799103,
-0.053596608340740204,
-0.5680044293403625,
0.961273193359375,
-0.2947167754173279,
-0.2109576016664505,
0.31063583493232727,
0.3836241066455841,
-0.005186103284358978,
0.07360241562128067,
-0.9118800163269043,
0.029787521809339523,
-0.21067818999290466,
-0.15308722853660583,
0.6609855890274048,
0.15605196356773376,
-0.09912800043821335,
0.6392006278038025,
0.6873792409896851,
-0.2404511272907257,
0.411442369222641,
-0.1452191025018692,
0.8054100275039673,
-0.548678457736969,
-0.8867294788360596,
-0.7505481243133545,
0.40425390005111694,
-0.1922931671142578,
-0.28487151861190796,
0.9074061512947083,
0.5955348014831543,
1.2542002201080322,
-0.02017187513411045,
0.6260117888450623,
-0.11922315508127213,
0.300673246383667,
-0.7188568711280823,
0.4290941059589386,
-0.6580877900123596,
-0.06713748723268509,
-0.3221835792064667,
-0.8409704566001892,
-0.016244694590568542,
0.7141091823577881,
-0.17596620321273804,
0.3547023832798004,
0.7334110140800476,
0.29703599214553833,
0.03540259599685669,
-0.07773323357105255,
0.16571824252605438,
-0.2718498408794403,
0.03091326542198658,
0.3381320834159851,
0.9096912741661072,
-0.27265363931655884,
0.340812087059021,
-0.40122559666633606,
-0.24473918974399567,
0.0009068711078725755,
-0.7617566585540771,
-1.044784426689148,
-0.7597954273223877,
-0.6835883259773254,
-0.30516138672828674,
0.33936211466789246,
0.3251635730266571,
0.8830398917198181,
-0.5951743125915527,
0.0021062882151454687,
-0.42316317558288574,
-0.03751005977392197,
-0.12189366668462753,
-0.30260545015335083,
0.43407565355300903,
-0.6243419647216797,
-0.26980987191200256,
0.26934897899627686,
0.3193061053752899,
0.3354383707046509,
-0.7927401661872864,
-0.13228839635849,
-0.029213160276412964,
-0.14612150192260742,
0.6535879969596863,
0.6309372186660767,
-0.6733328700065613,
0.02196940779685974,
-0.2741420269012451,
0.02441798895597458,
0.12146379798650742,
0.9424182772636414,
-0.9424392580986023,
0.4365296959877014,
0.19874294102191925,
0.5000057816505432,
0.9293040037155151,
0.14970947802066803,
0.3604225814342499,
-0.6071301698684692,
-0.03220522403717041,
0.021988708525896072,
-0.16646358370780945,
0.1063106581568718,
-0.35855793952941895,
0.5464327931404114,
0.264248251914978,
-0.47048085927963257,
-0.656306803226471,
0.6075916290283203,
-0.4849543869495392,
-0.34885120391845703,
0.7397362589836121,
-0.36962398886680603,
0.0777200385928154,
-0.17009638249874115,
0.47422701120376587,
0.30477526783943176,
-0.0005474371719174087,
0.894453227519989,
0.4855830669403076,
-0.16300632059574127,
-0.269818514585495,
-0.4789871573448181,
0.7747860550880432,
0.6912848353385925,
-0.7075387239456177,
-0.26670050621032715,
0.4097232520580292,
0.08905793726444244,
0.27522772550582886,
0.8086965680122375,
-0.14500710368156433,
0.3231179714202881,
-0.02293284609913826,
-0.1957157552242279,
-0.18221957981586456,
-0.45360201597213745,
-0.291422575712204,
0.1730271279811859,
-0.35246625542640686,
-0.26466935873031616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00934v1 | CLEME2.0: Towards More Interpretable Evaluation by Disentangling Edits for Grammatical Error Correction | 2024-07-01T03:35:58 | 2024-07-01T03:35:58 | Jingheng Ye, Zishan Xu, Yinghui Li, Xuxin Cheng, Linlin Song, Qingyu Zhou, Hai-Tao Zheng, Ying Shen, Xin Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | The paper focuses on improving the interpretability of Grammatical Error
Correction (GEC) metrics, which receives little attention in previous studies.
To bridge the gap, we propose CLEME2.0, a reference-based evaluation strategy
that can describe four elementary dimensions of GEC systems, namely
hit-correction, error-correction, under-correction, and over-correction. They
collectively contribute to revealing the critical characteristics and locating
drawbacks of GEC systems. Evaluating systems by Combining these dimensions
leads to high human consistency over other reference-based and reference-less
metrics. Extensive experiments on 2 human judgement datasets and 6 reference
datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of our method. All the
codes will be released after the peer review. | [
-0.23716412484645844,
-0.559938371181488,
0.7596113681793213,
0.08461527526378632,
-0.08423221856355667,
-0.1678328663110733,
-0.6154429912567139,
-0.550757646560669,
-0.08339682221412659,
0.0026532872579991817,
-0.43041980266571045,
-0.5487465858459473,
-0.7170813083648682,
0.39032480120658875,
-0.3699822723865509,
0.8922781348228455,
-0.07781568169593811,
0.12042221426963806,
-0.5546531677246094,
-0.34413397312164307,
-0.7374197244644165,
-0.6040765047073364,
-0.3606124520301819,
-0.16503165662288666,
0.42618101835250854,
0.8795205950737,
0.8448259234428406,
0.5322678089141846,
0.5423492789268494,
0.37273308634757996,
-0.32595008611679077,
0.3175666034221649,
-0.6590096354484558,
-0.3789767920970917,
-0.7806583046913147,
-0.5349140763282776,
-0.817025363445282,
0.06025436893105507,
0.600374162197113,
0.8003101348876953,
-0.22061461210250854,
0.2779456377029419,
0.33896782994270325,
1.0215309858322144,
-0.6187726259231567,
0.20101958513259888,
-0.4481164216995239,
-0.23569989204406738,
-0.3363189101219177,
0.35232779383659363,
-0.4587866961956024,
-0.4617079496383667,
0.08079765737056732,
-0.7013868689537048,
0.414463609457016,
-0.3175865709781647,
0.6894733309745789,
0.21968087553977966,
-0.2540358304977417,
-0.6043824553489685,
-0.7779947519302368,
0.6472076177597046,
-0.7887501120567322,
0.38633835315704346,
0.27413007616996765,
0.15600310266017914,
0.0811740905046463,
-0.8551585674285889,
-0.6276700496673584,
0.08805779367685318,
-0.3490681052207947,
0.14408153295516968,
-0.35773059725761414,
0.07048632949590683,
0.2269202619791031,
0.22110724449157715,
-0.3985104262828827,
0.08206053823232651,
-0.5777351260185242,
-0.16244512796401978,
0.7904773354530334,
-0.008731111884117126,
0.1611422896385193,
0.07579323649406433,
-0.0751013457775116,
0.23712438344955444,
-0.5415799617767334,
-0.2290516346693039,
0.5096594095230103,
0.0780167207121849,
-0.001183931133709848,
0.03454194962978363,
-0.19129858911037445,
0.6206411123275757,
0.23924730718135834,
0.03706417977809906,
0.5275681018829346,
-0.6146220564842224,
0.006451711058616638,
-0.12126755714416504,
0.4634180963039398,
0.763943076133728,
0.2416851669549942,
-0.0636477917432785,
0.058843936771154404,
0.47576653957366943,
0.3591998815536499,
-0.3532262146472931,
-0.15369831025600433,
0.09898936003446579,
-0.32611533999443054,
-0.3475627303123474,
0.48024222254753113,
-1.2409552335739136,
-0.2434641420841217,
-0.6125830411911011,
0.18244756758213043,
-0.10962820798158646,
-0.08107972145080566,
0.3637053370475769,
-0.03361561521887779,
-0.38710907101631165,
0.5188505053520203,
-0.6959455013275146,
0.6357579827308655,
0.6730933785438538,
0.7357562780380249,
-0.048172950744628906,
-0.5229905247688293,
-0.36942988634109497,
-0.35365039110183716,
-0.2674707770347595,
0.7356691956520081,
-0.35752177238464355,
-0.4509294629096985,
0.1636575609445572,
0.09284825623035431,
-0.0881873071193695,
-0.7267470955848694,
0.7401517629623413,
-0.4247491955757141,
0.292965292930603,
-0.4376293122768402,
-0.6864269375801086,
-0.31714046001434326,
-0.08285225182771683,
-0.8017171621322632,
1.1538054943084717,
0.3999147415161133,
-0.5243628025054932,
0.1711810827255249,
-0.8390496969223022,
-0.38353413343429565,
-0.2824884355068207,
0.2532047927379608,
-0.32149460911750793,
0.18038250505924225,
0.13210223615169525,
-0.01749868132174015,
-0.0911756306886673,
0.058240436017513275,
-0.205453023314476,
-0.39179527759552,
0.05830666795372963,
-0.10821547359228134,
0.4889254868030548,
0.3398236930370331,
-0.5659500360488892,
0.05179121717810631,
-0.8801431059837341,
0.34575155377388,
-0.09171877056360245,
-0.17728082835674286,
-0.2626207768917084,
0.0971246212720871,
-0.2628060281276703,
0.1402977854013443,
0.38560760021209717,
-0.4698781967163086,
0.04070711508393288,
-0.28855738043785095,
0.6047523617744446,
0.5537536144256592,
-0.2300875186920166,
0.6404238343238831,
0.0935945063829422,
0.38570156693458557,
-0.22019077837467194,
0.20955033600330353,
-0.06653094291687012,
-0.20171330869197845,
-0.8388673663139343,
0.20942869782447815,
0.6100413799285889,
0.6982036232948303,
-0.3131617307662964,
0.5353273153305054,
-0.28148117661476135,
-0.5666103959083557,
-0.541721522808075,
0.5529301166534424,
0.8385053277015686,
0.5203695297241211,
0.36886414885520935,
-0.32197800278663635,
-0.7286787033081055,
-0.6351675391197205,
-0.302403062582016,
-0.2636909484863281,
0.12536393105983734,
0.20143970847129822,
0.49891865253448486,
-0.294939786195755,
0.8776702880859375,
-0.492840975522995,
-0.23009270429611206,
-0.32458198070526123,
0.021283941343426704,
0.06882279366254807,
0.3643154203891754,
0.4989979863166809,
-0.3680965304374695,
-0.350513756275177,
0.06919025629758835,
-0.8314403295516968,
-0.6476637721061707,
-0.04599511995911598,
-0.05160186067223549,
0.04621630907058716,
0.7030270099639893,
-0.3211709260940552,
0.5271559953689575,
0.36703091859817505,
-0.6083513498306274,
0.8019256591796875,
-0.35661083459854126,
-0.049157653003931046,
-0.5004273653030396,
0.15012408792972565,
-0.18595407903194427,
-0.42440202832221985,
-0.6209726333618164,
0.0820232555270195,
0.25379517674446106,
0.14342336356639862,
-0.36387398838996887,
0.4153803884983063,
-0.5619954466819763,
-0.1228027418255806,
-0.018027670681476593,
0.6730107665061951,
0.4699082672595978,
0.15159635245800018,
-0.4218582212924957,
0.6306930184364319,
0.07309143245220184,
-0.4487572908401489,
0.494118869304657,
0.5422353148460388,
-0.23750044405460358,
1.046445608139038,
-0.699439287185669,
0.6543716788291931,
-0.2449752390384674,
0.23085357248783112,
-0.7240712642669678,
-0.11472538113594055,
0.10927028208971024,
-0.496337890625,
0.17189045250415802,
0.06910061091184616,
-0.3767492175102234,
-0.3552033007144928,
-0.2731049656867981,
0.38400381803512573,
0.27615219354629517,
-0.5986853241920471,
0.17445433139801025,
0.14123129844665527,
-0.30306026339530945,
-0.4059393107891083,
-0.6099376678466797,
0.09019965678453445,
0.04979550838470459,
-0.7106306552886963,
0.05087326467037201,
0.04149233549833298,
-0.5951563119888306,
0.18410153687000275,
0.012470162473618984,
0.14547473192214966,
0.13766109943389893,
0.13445906341075897,
0.2228451371192932,
-0.12974660098552704,
0.2252822071313858,
-0.011675617657601833,
-0.3710106909275055,
-0.04609595611691475,
-0.25574013590812683,
0.20101280510425568,
-0.5119703412055969,
-0.4480116665363312,
-0.7272760272026062,
0.25998589396476746,
0.4079115092754364,
-0.1525879055261612,
0.14706769585609436,
0.282869815826416,
-0.27458861470222473,
-0.14804081618785858,
-0.51179438829422,
0.13731954991817474,
-0.4224441349506378,
0.5971875786781311,
-0.09444413334131241,
-0.5377165079116821,
0.4305572509765625,
-0.24186745285987854,
-0.18483638763427734,
0.5985066890716553,
0.4799119234085083,
-0.32630932331085205,
0.45306718349456787,
0.5195071697235107,
-0.03125586360692978,
0.2414989024400711,
-0.12074026465415955,
0.12139786034822464,
-0.7663214206695557,
-0.13940240442752838,
-0.5758599638938904,
-0.6356606483459473,
-0.13671839237213135,
-0.4195614755153656,
0.35918542742729187,
0.6269621849060059,
-0.09891419112682343,
0.40387439727783203,
-0.3043534457683563,
0.6585863828659058,
0.5322564244270325,
0.04250793159008026,
0.42057129740715027,
-0.16518153250217438,
-0.23006395995616913,
-0.33492764830589294,
-0.4540305435657501,
-0.6786574721336365,
0.9400843977928162,
0.49561822414398193,
0.5356585383415222,
0.21202526986598969,
0.28969332575798035,
0.4218429625034332,
0.25589868426322937,
-0.6854879260063171,
0.28989580273628235,
-0.23866009712219238,
-0.6927751302719116,
-0.40488672256469727,
-0.11827342957258224,
-0.5851107835769653,
0.3931991457939148,
-0.009725326672196388,
-0.9465931057929993,
0.4421892464160919,
0.3757813572883606,
-0.4458481967449188,
0.3510381281375885,
-0.9993941783905029,
1.065307855606079,
-0.1845719814300537,
-0.3973086476325989,
-0.33286750316619873,
-0.8648352026939392,
-0.053282640874385834,
0.12195870280265808,
0.5349142551422119,
0.18970157206058502,
0.10903432220220566,
0.524523913860321,
-0.7007580399513245,
0.8674764037132263,
-0.25284257531166077,
0.003990574274212122,
0.6287856698036194,
0.09605727344751358,
0.5907620191574097,
0.007253297138959169,
-0.2718367874622345,
0.4441858232021332,
0.06591706722974777,
-0.19765429198741913,
-0.8749952912330627,
0.46432656049728394,
-0.6566132307052612,
-0.1915932148694992,
-0.3953322470188141,
-0.36653566360473633,
-0.40469416975975037,
0.24466072022914886,
0.3422352969646454,
0.4895739257335663,
-0.4472145736217499,
-0.07525113224983215,
0.06632865220308304,
0.13011807203292847,
0.1841733604669571,
0.5898979306221008,
-0.08675693720579147,
-0.6140419840812683,
0.6693940758705139,
0.05873572453856468,
0.3335261046886444,
-0.05569325387477875,
-0.000803138711489737,
-0.3313724100589752,
-0.5085049271583557,
-0.6357829570770264,
0.3521420359611511,
-0.7883859872817993,
-0.07994487881660461,
-0.18693210184574127,
0.18042925000190735,
-0.3188697099685669,
-0.25810953974723816,
-0.38687628507614136,
-0.29151374101638794,
-0.4606339633464813,
-0.45337629318237305,
0.07643517106771469,
1.1900044679641724,
-0.49981194734573364,
0.6618437767028809,
-0.9147974252700806,
-0.1288023293018341,
-0.03502251207828522,
0.5147004723548889,
-0.13722364604473114,
-0.5824087858200073,
-0.40586984157562256,
0.013459631241858006,
-0.3996918797492981,
-0.9293994307518005,
-0.009206485003232956,
0.37571781873703003,
0.235409215092659,
0.499210000038147,
-0.38451969623565674,
0.9477005004882812,
-0.669650137424469,
0.8140663504600525,
0.162101611495018,
-1.4388313293457031,
0.5995819568634033,
-0.09515946358442307,
0.01752517744898796,
0.855416476726532,
-0.2362447828054428,
-0.828967809677124,
0.1064172089099884,
-0.8492072820663452,
-0.6605218648910522,
0.7130990624427795,
0.23705600202083588,
0.012620681896805763,
0.06910551339387894,
0.7365760803222656,
0.132809117436409,
0.2074436992406845,
-0.12549754977226257,
-0.16699574887752533,
0.010870862752199173,
-0.39521780610084534,
-0.29588550329208374,
-0.8027031421661377,
-0.16895870864391327,
-0.23973864316940308,
0.5766839981079102,
-0.051030829548835754,
0.050436995923519135,
0.5000559687614441,
-0.3830071687698364,
-0.14277400076389313,
0.5691215991973877,
0.7402576804161072,
1.0196250677108765,
0.13364283740520477,
0.21372433006763458,
0.5877063274383545,
-0.5343180894851685,
-0.03001319244503975,
-0.22840066254138947,
-0.11060882359743118,
0.32960739731788635,
0.6689353585243225,
0.6602998375892639,
0.3036186993122101,
-0.4687712490558624,
0.5716106295585632,
0.2786807715892792,
-0.2588209807872772,
-0.33460208773612976,
-0.1978268027305603,
-0.10809841006994247,
-0.0028019140008836985,
-0.272684782743454,
0.3832853436470032,
0.13491195440292358,
-0.46128761768341064,
0.4628235697746277,
-0.09517059475183487,
-0.5353327989578247,
-0.9158321022987366,
0.5573120713233948,
0.4852466583251953,
-0.06368117034435272,
0.46800175309181213,
-0.5078327655792236,
-0.6287214756011963,
0.4983929693698883,
0.4322730004787445,
0.5577340722084045,
-0.3243398368358612,
0.313271701335907,
0.6151373386383057,
0.3834667205810547,
-0.21527515351772308,
0.3098103404045105,
0.4342654347419739,
-0.6385937333106995,
-0.19234319031238556,
-0.2546624541282654,
-0.26119253039360046,
-0.025069432333111763,
-0.9455699324607849,
0.40694525837898254,
-0.47468721866607666,
-0.11163055151700974,
-0.08202371001243591,
-0.24379482865333557,
-0.6203675866127014,
0.19939208030700684,
0.08597186952829361,
0.7275218963623047,
-0.8162112832069397,
0.4292370080947876,
0.8451799154281616,
-0.06729018688201904,
-0.6798139810562134,
-0.2996659576892853,
0.6340430974960327,
-0.44746559858322144,
0.4943704605102539,
-0.10947572439908981,
-0.2378494143486023,
-0.24080966413021088,
-0.42347440123558044,
-0.7837502956390381,
0.9428771734237671,
0.410501092672348,
-0.9137749075889587,
-0.15307952463626862,
0.18262217938899994,
0.7982398867607117,
-0.16752338409423828,
0.30808159708976746,
1.090414047241211,
0.7160152196884155,
-0.2948870062828064,
-1.3195654153823853,
-0.1691691279411316,
-0.3121025264263153,
0.09280455857515335,
0.04654630273580551,
-0.6322192549705505,
0.5642260909080505,
-0.4602818191051483,
-0.44528496265411377,
0.2753119468688965,
0.4608447253704071,
-0.34953200817108154,
0.52351975440979,
0.6013039946556091,
0.9587986469268799,
1.193191647529602,
-0.23080839216709137,
0.8708921074867249,
0.04111858829855919,
0.8551154732704163,
1.6810203790664673,
-0.3255762755870819,
0.8135772943496704,
0.30754515528678894,
-0.6049003601074219,
0.7619755268096924,
0.2648645341396332,
0.0004879045009147376,
0.3255666494369507,
0.11881997436285019,
-0.14093615114688873,
0.012495053000748158,
0.21679338812828064,
-0.21540091931819916,
0.3702016770839691,
0.4714757800102234,
-0.2609330415725708,
-0.43554556369781494,
-0.2993427813053131,
0.4844234585762024,
0.6291220784187317,
-0.23456989228725433,
0.8401954770088196,
-0.0061204745434224606,
-0.459416002035141,
0.35399529337882996,
0.04543479532003403,
0.3046177625656128,
-0.1653880476951599,
-0.2503755986690521,
-0.16609831154346466,
0.516172468662262,
-0.6506499648094177,
-0.7056461572647095,
0.5200489163398743,
0.29846081137657166,
-0.32100600004196167,
0.13986599445343018,
0.7473621368408203,
-0.3446086645126343,
-0.5062360167503357,
0.37950077652931213,
0.4718031883239746,
0.112156443297863,
-0.056316908448934555,
-0.5033479332923889,
0.10060732066631317,
0.06723752617835999,
0.3456810712814331,
-0.16181184351444244,
0.4626939594745636,
-0.09189760684967041,
0.2561158239841461,
0.5281050205230713,
0.08414284139871597,
-0.0523013137280941,
0.2273908257484436,
0.5826545357704163,
-0.5575217008590698,
-0.5459304451942444,
-0.9288873672485352,
0.7561277151107788,
-0.09205950051546097,
-0.4445451498031616,
0.6084422469139099,
0.5038340091705322,
1.0651472806930542,
-0.10695718973875046,
0.9640679955482483,
-0.182135671377182,
0.8758256435394287,
-0.4304359555244446,
0.33558711409568787,
-0.1853068768978119,
0.26968640089035034,
-0.3225868344306946,
-0.5962100625038147,
-0.3790366053581238,
0.5054603219032288,
-0.44428208470344543,
-0.038432344794273376,
1.1086746454238892,
0.6193181276321411,
0.10828540474176407,
-0.04317263886332512,
0.2215336263179779,
0.4191754162311554,
0.06917930394411087,
0.3951233923435211,
0.775913655757904,
-0.573293149471283,
0.3158377707004547,
-0.27861541509628296,
-0.2982025444507599,
-0.3996993899345398,
-0.5959829092025757,
-0.48618146777153015,
-0.35871708393096924,
-0.22880806028842926,
-0.6204607486724854,
0.162458136677742,
0.6890722513198853,
0.3999926745891571,
-1.0182300806045532,
-0.0064521729946136475,
-0.060495827347040176,
0.18254460394382477,
-0.5340753793716431,
-0.17862437665462494,
0.319734662771225,
-0.49600592255592346,
-0.9533307552337646,
0.15638458728790283,
0.1452818065881729,
-0.4922617971897125,
-0.03263092413544655,
-0.17682212591171265,
0.14556579291820526,
-0.2590489685535431,
0.6464820504188538,
0.24241885542869568,
-0.7821807265281677,
-0.6781430840492249,
-0.12429235130548477,
-0.015433628112077713,
0.1763027310371399,
0.8342376947402954,
-0.39724454283714294,
0.73968106508255,
0.46103498339653015,
0.38289597630500793,
-0.0988580510020256,
0.48013269901275635,
0.5280886292457581,
-0.6570742130279541,
0.18788184225559235,
-0.1063682809472084,
0.5511164665222168,
0.2789926528930664,
-0.4676777124404907,
0.9078529477119446,
0.5468687415122986,
-0.542169988155365,
-0.5081851482391357,
0.039564672857522964,
-1.0469752550125122,
0.1566447615623474,
1.355644702911377,
-0.5063503384590149,
-0.09198892116546631,
-0.11414835602045059,
-0.4641195237636566,
0.021818695589900017,
-0.24216651916503906,
0.5503932237625122,
1.100164532661438,
0.026745500043034554,
0.30204254388809204,
-0.718768298625946,
0.4167487919330597,
0.4342743158340454,
-0.9113739132881165,
0.13608422875404358,
0.8442701101303101,
0.6663375496864319,
0.4384378492832184,
0.4099239110946655,
-0.6170220375061035,
0.5453484058380127,
0.013112317770719528,
0.1880432665348053,
0.0016695830272510648,
-0.3756311535835266,
-0.6218087673187256,
-0.23605622351169586,
0.11570772528648376,
-0.15187343955039978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00928v1 | FoldGPT: Simple and Effective Large Language Model Compression Scheme | 2024-07-01T03:17:53 | 2024-07-01T03:17:53 | Songwei Liu, Chao Zeng, Lianqiang Li, Chenqian Yan, Lean Fu, Xing Mei, Fangmin Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The demand for deploying large language models(LLMs) on mobile devices
continues to increase, driven by escalating data security concerns and cloud
costs. However, network bandwidth and memory limitations pose challenges for
deploying billion-level models on mobile devices. In this study, we investigate
the outputs of different layers across various scales of LLMs and found that
the outputs of most layers exhibit significant similarity. Moreover, this
similarity becomes more pronounced as the model size increases, indicating
substantial redundancy in the depth direction of the LLMs. Based on this
observation, we propose an efficient model volume compression strategy, termed
FoldGPT, which combines block removal and block parameter sharing.This strategy
consists of three parts: (1) Based on the learnable gating parameters, we
determine the block importance ranking while modeling the coupling effect
between blocks. Then we delete some redundant layers based on the given removal
rate. (2) For the retained blocks, we apply a specially designed group
parameter sharing strategy, where blocks within the same group share identical
weights, significantly compressing the number of parameters and slightly
reducing latency overhead. (3) After sharing these Blocks, we "cure" the
mismatch caused by sparsity with a minor amount of fine-tuning and introduce a
tail-layer distillation strategy to improve the performance. Experiments
demonstrate that FoldGPT outperforms previous state-of-the-art(SOTA) methods in
efficient model compression, demonstrating the feasibility of achieving model
lightweighting through straightforward block removal and parameter sharing. | [
-0.6121940016746521,
-0.5801542401313782,
0.38755670189857483,
0.4072694778442383,
-0.6276364922523499,
0.11046511679887772,
-0.10335477441549301,
-0.2781769633293152,
0.19045805931091309,
0.5278134346008301,
-0.4699753224849701,
-0.24408189952373505,
-0.7027215957641602,
-0.34002384543418884,
-0.4261966049671173,
0.6440437436103821,
-0.043400201946496964,
-0.06067344546318054,
0.041634202003479004,
0.03904396668076515,
-0.3452008366584778,
-0.3761415183544159,
-0.9124280214309692,
-0.49039679765701294,
0.419551819562912,
0.3733660578727722,
0.7423909902572632,
0.9078923463821411,
0.5122913718223572,
0.27597519755363464,
-0.31028488278388977,
0.14162223041057587,
-0.6508859395980835,
0.12973706424236298,
0.26824304461479187,
-0.10397074371576309,
-0.5079090595245361,
-0.1466628462076187,
0.6161792278289795,
0.54023677110672,
-0.512893557548523,
0.11857976764440536,
0.149606853723526,
0.7647662162780762,
-0.39460664987564087,
-0.06899687647819519,
-0.6840651035308838,
-0.10441601276397705,
0.11774352937936783,
-0.23717284202575684,
-0.3600570261478424,
-0.3024946451187134,
-0.3921663463115692,
-0.021605556830763817,
0.31156861782073975,
0.10757380723953247,
0.6488683223724365,
0.3709442913532257,
-0.45397400856018066,
-0.08351053297519684,
-0.6396157741546631,
0.5854590535163879,
-0.9402937889099121,
0.38261741399765015,
0.2096918523311615,
0.2016914188861847,
-0.13739708065986633,
-0.5522248148918152,
-0.6175869107246399,
-0.15273238718509674,
0.15738919377326965,
-0.17685167491436005,
0.04454462602734566,
0.05771397799253464,
0.24941299855709076,
0.5904184579849243,
-0.6597166657447815,
0.19344262778759003,
-0.5390939116477966,
-0.2114603966474533,
0.7209669947624207,
-0.14667585492134094,
0.5738487243652344,
-0.07864227145910263,
-0.6538800001144409,
-0.025446424260735512,
-1.1668250560760498,
-0.14332379400730133,
0.4614502191543579,
0.4280643165111542,
-0.19648665189743042,
0.5100467205047607,
-0.3115309774875641,
0.684138834476471,
-0.09498739242553711,
-0.2873341739177704,
0.014699163846671581,
-0.23623377084732056,
-0.3496633470058441,
0.07870826870203018,
0.8539385795593262,
0.38007140159606934,
-0.19017186760902405,
-0.1493421345949173,
-0.369172602891922,
-0.317809134721756,
0.11966332048177719,
-1.1626768112182617,
-0.15904206037521362,
0.24280594289302826,
-0.648511528968811,
-0.307708740234375,
-0.12207046151161194,
-0.6713074445724487,
-0.5213806629180908,
-0.1686394214630127,
0.5249142050743103,
-0.12170543521642685,
-0.19221635162830353,
0.4494410455226898,
0.09180809557437897,
0.2212059199810028,
0.2953079044818878,
-1.1104129552841187,
0.5743643045425415,
0.7367688417434692,
1.1660046577453613,
-0.16882233321666718,
-0.07763799279928207,
-0.7117759585380554,
0.0655665397644043,
0.09075193107128143,
0.42127177119255066,
-0.25558650493621826,
-0.4548320770263672,
-0.3630083501338959,
-0.22616471350193024,
0.02053481712937355,
-0.564789354801178,
0.7840326428413391,
-0.37965404987335205,
-0.1217149868607521,
-0.13971693813800812,
-0.4327326714992523,
-0.3610523045063019,
0.11166080087423325,
-0.8366312384605408,
0.7976132035255432,
-0.1087539866566658,
-0.6197040677070618,
0.027780059725046158,
-0.12843677401542664,
-0.3517098128795624,
0.26755452156066895,
-0.020700804889202118,
-0.705916702747345,
0.2680850028991699,
0.4244183599948883,
0.8582527041435242,
-0.6196830868721008,
0.014008252881467342,
-0.2166588008403778,
-0.4594338536262512,
-0.36134690046310425,
-0.3145103454589844,
0.6435823440551758,
0.3313749134540558,
-0.32000619173049927,
0.059455543756484985,
-0.6998189687728882,
0.2892671227455139,
0.20352238416671753,
-0.5399693846702576,
-0.25102418661117554,
-0.03932460770010948,
0.03366779163479805,
0.24166452884674072,
0.14231592416763306,
-0.3295644521713257,
0.710820198059082,
-0.0029403315857052803,
0.9042154550552368,
0.3596222996711731,
-0.08925186097621918,
0.5082764029502869,
-0.30724066495895386,
0.3221987783908844,
-0.2631106674671173,
0.10388197749853134,
-0.025560908019542694,
-0.28061985969543457,
-0.6711211204528809,
-0.5568556785583496,
0.36547529697418213,
0.3674299418926239,
-0.48239150643348694,
0.24183182418346405,
-0.4994632601737976,
-0.6914628148078918,
-0.2338392585515976,
0.34695062041282654,
0.3931930661201477,
0.2089759260416031,
0.17192931473255157,
-0.1990610659122467,
-0.40609845519065857,
-0.9894680380821228,
-0.010658763349056244,
-0.06174837425351143,
-0.2561285197734833,
0.1714988648891449,
0.3994016647338867,
0.0598766952753067,
0.41866499185562134,
-0.4452560544013977,
0.0808359831571579,
-0.3245497941970825,
0.2534879744052887,
0.13872788846492767,
0.6858651638031006,
0.21495100855827332,
-0.965988278388977,
-0.5194531679153442,
0.11122972518205643,
-0.24642428755760193,
-0.2740556597709656,
-0.02073897235095501,
0.2738233804702759,
-0.1959264576435089,
0.4642444849014282,
-0.7979987263679504,
0.10039027780294418,
1.1048076152801514,
-0.08992313593626022,
0.3783740699291229,
-0.2850120961666107,
0.19512560963630676,
-1.11886465549469,
-0.2369610071182251,
-0.16124102473258972,
-0.6710671186447144,
-0.5783823728561401,
0.2604600489139557,
0.2608378529548645,
-0.32883787155151367,
-0.5085349678993225,
0.3292570412158966,
-0.7307208180427551,
0.055295370519161224,
-0.3212127685546875,
0.021394139155745506,
-0.09739664196968079,
0.4268638789653778,
-0.2219826579093933,
0.889685869216919,
0.4036104679107666,
-0.5805023908615112,
0.2849782407283783,
-0.16185839474201202,
-0.1720719337463379,
0.1813427209854126,
-0.903591513633728,
0.4317212700843811,
-0.022513067349791527,
0.2315969616174698,
-0.8404810428619385,
-0.07329779863357544,
0.07617580890655518,
-0.0542144700884819,
0.36563530564308167,
-0.4469033479690552,
-0.5862691402435303,
-0.19791895151138306,
-0.43896719813346863,
0.5473335981369019,
0.7071851491928101,
-0.6243733763694763,
0.7956609725952148,
0.49234244227409363,
-0.35044172406196594,
-0.500400185585022,
-0.5916129350662231,
0.11473198235034943,
-0.6166587471961975,
-0.8935009837150574,
0.6328895688056946,
-0.16620507836341858,
0.11053081601858139,
-0.2154226005077362,
-0.4356505572795868,
-0.03791394084692001,
-0.20041319727897644,
0.3873041868209839,
0.017304496839642525,
-0.02452755905687809,
0.008825263939797878,
0.00012299181253183633,
0.13415232300758362,
-0.3365739583969116,
-0.4250311255455017,
1.0058767795562744,
-0.22683872282505035,
-0.3154951333999634,
-0.23338565230369568,
0.4490256607532501,
0.6073288321495056,
-0.07251939922571182,
0.7681358456611633,
0.48087283968925476,
-0.18861734867095947,
-0.4690943658351898,
-0.7593052387237549,
-0.010027604177594185,
-0.4927860200405121,
0.1910046935081482,
-0.43555694818496704,
-1.0676106214523315,
0.8072547912597656,
-0.3406026065349579,
-0.13155631721019745,
0.05486173555254936,
0.5208190679550171,
0.2199200987815857,
0.7900791168212891,
0.6868456602096558,
-0.35514792799949646,
0.327881783246994,
-0.21846090257167816,
0.3527558445930481,
-0.7346582412719727,
-0.18258535861968994,
-0.6748785376548767,
-0.2100764364004135,
-0.45812568068504333,
-0.7806577086448669,
0.18282893300056458,
0.6945991516113281,
-0.22277191281318665,
0.4608067274093628,
-0.5445568561553955,
0.6914734840393066,
0.3104051351547241,
0.23655016720294952,
0.3702359199523926,
0.2562120854854584,
0.025076497346162796,
0.3507460951805115,
-0.7331910133361816,
-0.43065324425697327,
0.732130765914917,
0.4617631733417511,
0.9163788557052612,
0.33026280999183655,
0.8561878800392151,
0.12982472777366638,
-0.14725099503993988,
-0.833215057849884,
0.726330041885376,
-0.11498703062534332,
-0.051673199981451035,
-0.36249908804893494,
-0.727299153804779,
-0.6155650019645691,
0.5317431092262268,
0.033886220306158066,
-0.8585682511329651,
-0.1349772810935974,
0.025309162214398384,
-0.1563560664653778,
0.4962083399295807,
-0.8275760412216187,
0.43001195788383484,
0.05564660206437111,
-0.4468300938606262,
-0.08555634319782257,
-0.4933873414993286,
0.35415977239608765,
-0.0437091626226902,
-0.0045426650904119015,
0.010401600040495396,
-0.10110034793615341,
0.645818829536438,
-0.8663218021392822,
0.6164907217025757,
-0.11181274056434631,
-0.14267055690288544,
0.1347137689590454,
0.22759181261062622,
0.931568443775177,
-0.010987401939928532,
0.0814259946346283,
0.2675389349460602,
-0.3109896779060364,
-0.4607732594013214,
-0.8484897613525391,
0.8462588787078857,
-0.48921483755111694,
-0.6416020393371582,
0.08158870041370392,
-0.5945211052894592,
-0.025490641593933105,
0.38174161314964294,
0.10384626686573029,
0.5235769748687744,
0.17528438568115234,
0.4413204491138458,
0.7791290879249573,
-0.12217745184898376,
0.5825410485267639,
0.14757893979549408,
-0.34788334369659424,
-0.1943921446800232,
0.7916064858436584,
-0.07487975060939789,
0.372936874628067,
0.43745100498199463,
0.2923271954059601,
-0.33281460404396057,
-0.9437145590782166,
-0.510648787021637,
0.34816569089889526,
-0.5510156750679016,
-0.25520405173301697,
-0.46060383319854736,
-0.41850945353507996,
-0.25225844979286194,
-0.16797728836536407,
-0.5866942405700684,
-0.5078904628753662,
0.338989794254303,
-0.010881956666707993,
0.20051631331443787,
0.5463668704032898,
0.15151242911815643,
0.6635425090789795,
-0.7867358326911926,
0.18189547955989838,
0.3135531544685364,
0.41694149374961853,
0.14667372405529022,
-0.40091583132743835,
-0.0225306898355484,
-0.05563384294509888,
-0.15787827968597412,
-0.6316073536872864,
0.4970282018184662,
0.02473655343055725,
0.37298011779785156,
0.2345060110092163,
-0.055071234703063965,
0.7404828071594238,
-0.5344202518463135,
0.7475024461746216,
0.4309917092323303,
-1.085053563117981,
0.11919835954904556,
-0.4479023218154907,
0.2760753631591797,
0.33383554220199585,
0.35951733589172363,
-0.3571428656578064,
-0.015205304138362408,
-0.40160590410232544,
-1.0409709215164185,
0.394518107175827,
0.31499773263931274,
0.16970786452293396,
0.5699504613876343,
0.3171825110912323,
-0.05327407270669937,
0.25862282514572144,
-0.9325507283210754,
-0.13836929202079773,
-0.022611049935221672,
-0.1803557574748993,
0.11058587580919266,
-0.46539562940597534,
-0.0474918968975544,
-0.09716859459877014,
0.5717477798461914,
0.12625572085380554,
0.0900571420788765,
-0.025147298350930214,
0.04307043179869652,
0.25441962480545044,
0.383045494556427,
0.7815199494361877,
0.33492451906204224,
-0.1363944709300995,
0.41862383484840393,
0.006347482092678547,
-0.721770703792572,
0.36634159088134766,
-0.1284109354019165,
-0.23923632502555847,
-0.19339722394943237,
0.12605071067810059,
0.9275378584861755,
0.05261804908514023,
-0.4504762291908264,
0.42567873001098633,
-0.12030404806137085,
-0.32364749908447266,
0.2436768263578415,
-0.10366860032081604,
0.35206109285354614,
0.3090954124927521,
0.2524973452091217,
-0.06646034866571426,
0.16433103382587433,
-0.32755911350250244,
0.01387005764991045,
0.3722354769706726,
-0.18354865908622742,
-0.07955888658761978,
0.452375590801239,
0.1521759331226349,
-0.3728847801685333,
0.43546202778816223,
-0.14165563881397247,
-0.5926580429077148,
0.36443498730659485,
0.666013777256012,
0.6642147898674011,
-0.322256863117218,
0.2282373607158661,
0.22320832312107086,
0.45217666029930115,
-0.5869961380958557,
0.07612989097833633,
-0.18722830712795258,
-0.5331565737724304,
-0.5562899708747864,
-0.6074278950691223,
-0.09205367416143417,
0.42737171053886414,
-0.29627448320388794,
0.30479153990745544,
-0.4370972812175751,
0.11432922631502151,
-0.271819144487381,
0.039576802402734756,
-0.3274216949939728,
0.08243480324745178,
0.034580156207084656,
0.8006622791290283,
-0.7215723395347595,
0.9545779824256897,
0.2593053877353668,
-0.4499443471431732,
-1.4970009326934814,
-0.01439353171736002,
0.10106205195188522,
-0.6495360136032104,
0.6117500066757202,
0.07989266514778137,
-0.39157962799072266,
-0.10304403305053711,
-0.37727463245391846,
-0.8401682376861572,
0.9553027749061584,
0.45914319157600403,
-0.6813844442367554,
-0.060040175914764404,
0.1242482140660286,
0.13832513988018036,
-0.4391137659549713,
0.079817995429039,
0.08127544075250626,
0.30563586950302124,
0.5162577033042908,
-1.058868169784546,
0.508023202419281,
-0.19734548032283783,
0.15715108811855316,
0.37109026312828064,
-0.6854515075683594,
1.0596542358398438,
-0.0727749913930893,
-0.3713439702987671,
-0.05799287185072899,
0.23888880014419556,
0.2157510370016098,
-0.036029644310474396,
0.6975280046463013,
0.503035306930542,
0.8046167492866516,
0.21103204786777496,
0.8855756521224976,
-0.23520386219024658,
0.5252507925033569,
1.0164920091629028,
-0.22826126217842102,
0.9848616123199463,
0.6080242991447449,
-0.014270085841417313,
0.054415199905633926,
0.4039454162120819,
0.15831635892391205,
0.5889924168586731,
0.5155466794967651,
-0.411798357963562,
-0.12918353080749512,
0.18424509465694427,
-0.40734919905662537,
0.24900087714195251,
-0.014248625375330448,
-0.22309638559818268,
-0.22657887637615204,
-0.13946165144443512,
0.16352833807468414,
-0.18529145419597626,
-0.5128229856491089,
0.48392364382743835,
0.22921031713485718,
-0.38735368847846985,
0.8881009221076965,
0.14304520189762115,
0.7416518926620483,
-0.5183241367340088,
0.16973373293876648,
-0.2946137487888336,
-0.06579924374818802,
-0.34124132990837097,
-0.3088262975215912,
0.08561322838068008,
-0.1237412691116333,
-0.2661128342151642,
-0.3741520941257477,
0.7697068452835083,
-0.5426182150840759,
-0.32437625527381897,
0.18335437774658203,
0.3552035391330719,
0.2550024390220642,
-0.2647591233253479,
-0.4624183475971222,
0.5448670983314514,
0.11390136182308197,
-0.35631510615348816,
0.4267982542514801,
0.18190118670463562,
-0.005870851222425699,
0.998172402381897,
0.5937913656234741,
0.5758259892463684,
0.19748680293560028,
0.14862684905529022,
1.0409070253372192,
-0.45777809619903564,
-0.4381102919578552,
-0.900169312953949,
0.37686648964881897,
-0.31296446919441223,
0.27658790349960327,
0.700133740901947,
0.6514021754264832,
0.6642205119132996,
-0.08779892325401306,
0.5911058783531189,
-0.016629105433821678,
0.23383766412734985,
-0.877396285533905,
0.830761194229126,
-0.7089213132858276,
0.7443050742149353,
-0.18077608942985535,
-1.0923304557800293,
-0.2868348956108093,
0.4681825339794159,
-0.04676923155784607,
0.1681153029203415,
0.6290875673294067,
0.9575517177581787,
-0.43343114852905273,
-0.025987815111875534,
0.3808138370513916,
0.018534936010837555,
0.4120013415813446,
0.5169114470481873,
0.4882780611515045,
-0.6304703950881958,
0.4900154173374176,
-0.13453790545463562,
-0.20752359926700592,
-0.19793643057346344,
-1.1440253257751465,
-0.7842806577682495,
-0.6220533847808838,
-0.26432734727859497,
-0.10396532714366913,
-0.0409487709403038,
0.8125056028366089,
1.1448280811309814,
-0.27902650833129883,
-0.28975772857666016,
-0.17838738858699799,
0.0852108895778656,
-0.17008839547634125,
-0.10875596851110458,
0.5085892677307129,
0.1495005190372467,
-0.7093172669410706,
0.40774813294410706,
0.34705978631973267,
0.0881774052977562,
-0.1846361607313156,
-0.07547171413898468,
0.13135822117328644,
0.055560365319252014,
0.66924649477005,
0.20470044016838074,
-0.6219844222068787,
-0.21198852360248566,
-0.4034968316555023,
-0.1565144658088684,
-0.06684307754039764,
1.134400725364685,
-0.3833531439304352,
0.11361642926931381,
0.7611680626869202,
0.7031852602958679,
0.8120493292808533,
0.19427630305290222,
0.5512397289276123,
-0.851127564907074,
0.4163129925727844,
0.046641815453767776,
0.40532922744750977,
0.3248598873615265,
-0.3495480716228485,
0.542938768863678,
-0.12479047477245331,
-0.6549654603004456,
-0.9457947015762329,
0.2542404234409332,
-1.4208400249481201,
-0.2823660373687744,
1.2072551250457764,
-0.1468605101108551,
-0.12443571537733078,
0.13260184228420258,
-0.3974151015281677,
0.026500988751649857,
-0.4329495131969452,
0.7355841398239136,
0.6006745100021362,
0.001496753771789372,
-0.5907718539237976,
-0.5620045065879822,
0.37615054845809937,
0.33145594596862793,
-0.6035842299461365,
0.259351521730423,
0.27103039622306824,
0.3727911114692688,
-0.05794092267751694,
0.6200443506240845,
-0.04317648708820343,
-0.27285876870155334,
0.18845544755458832,
0.14577415585517883,
-0.48653820157051086,
-0.2163325995206833,
-0.3763531744480133,
0.5194559693336487,
0.02781924232840538,
-0.08644947409629822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00924v1 | EXCGEC: A Benchmark of Edit-wise Explainable Chinese Grammatical Error Correction | 2024-07-01T03:06:41 | 2024-07-01T03:06:41 | Jingheng Ye, Shang Qin, Yinghui Li, Xuxin Cheng, Libo Qin, Hai-Tao Zheng, Peng Xing, Zishan Xu, Guo Cheng, Zhao Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing studies explore the explainability of Grammatical Error Correction
(GEC) in a limited scenario, where they ignore the interaction between
corrections and explanations. To bridge the gap, this paper introduces the task
of EXplainable GEC (EXGEC), which focuses on the integral role of both
correction and explanation tasks. To facilitate the task, we propose EXCGEC, a
tailored benchmark for Chinese EXGEC consisting of 8,216 explanation-augmented
samples featuring the design of hybrid edit-wise explanations. We benchmark
several series of LLMs in multiple settings, covering post-explaining and
pre-explaining. To promote the development of the task, we introduce a
comprehensive suite of automatic metrics and conduct human evaluation
experiments to demonstrate the human consistency of the automatic metrics for
free-text explanations. All the codes and data will be released after the
review. | [
-0.19146035611629486,
-0.8561518788337708,
0.4139114320278168,
0.1102568581700325,
-0.07277606427669525,
-0.2552779018878937,
-0.48157161474227905,
-0.4028424024581909,
0.03615187108516693,
-0.10032613575458527,
-0.8319326639175415,
-0.5158226490020752,
-0.2642422914505005,
0.23804903030395508,
-0.3852415382862091,
1.092628002166748,
-0.3868996202945709,
0.07331869006156921,
-0.28169894218444824,
-0.3004884719848633,
-0.3527509570121765,
-0.23596592247486115,
-0.7650013566017151,
-0.187127485871315,
0.482644259929657,
0.5463632941246033,
0.8944330215454102,
0.6935485601425171,
0.10550926625728607,
0.31461092829704285,
-0.20716078579425812,
0.3941400349140167,
-0.3397720456123352,
-0.37277185916900635,
-0.32078802585601807,
-0.5286126136779785,
-0.8409599661827087,
0.017087968066334724,
0.7476325631141663,
0.7144966125488281,
-0.2889811098575592,
-0.10974708199501038,
0.37056928873062134,
0.6400094628334045,
-0.6089284420013428,
0.16140028834342957,
-0.43207257986068726,
0.17508523166179657,
-0.08437459915876389,
-0.08889970928430557,
-0.3779074549674988,
-0.4466938078403473,
-0.24758893251419067,
-0.8586483001708984,
0.6928510069847107,
-0.12890930473804474,
0.7263469099998474,
0.009366766549646854,
-0.19788020849227905,
-0.21020609140396118,
-0.5759037733078003,
0.3193487823009491,
-0.6931202411651611,
0.16142410039901733,
0.14724218845367432,
0.293800950050354,
-0.3022959530353546,
-0.625433087348938,
-0.6873401999473572,
-0.07202080637216568,
-0.13445736467838287,
0.5912665128707886,
0.11068735271692276,
0.3608072102069855,
0.21527504920959473,
0.7777924537658691,
-0.8469557762145996,
0.0927271619439125,
0.16575148701667786,
-0.2530733644962311,
0.552044153213501,
0.1898781955242157,
0.4214683473110199,
-0.012479732744395733,
-0.0004025456146337092,
0.07087622582912445,
-0.6345459222793579,
0.27797427773475647,
0.40621086955070496,
-0.09122636914253235,
-0.11893034726381302,
0.2909407913684845,
-0.18149331212043762,
0.7862258553504944,
-0.07479707151651382,
0.4215717315673828,
0.1773618459701538,
-0.6919114589691162,
-0.4660401940345764,
-0.008842348121106625,
0.42905738949775696,
0.37198877334594727,
0.008128590881824493,
-0.08060149103403091,
-0.13854074478149414,
0.15322956442832947,
0.09731345623731613,
-0.2391158640384674,
-0.2472878247499466,
0.03173584118485451,
-0.5992262363433838,
-0.0686647966504097,
0.31124043464660645,
-0.8319507837295532,
-0.33977755904197693,
-0.1645112782716751,
0.3614238500595093,
-0.03546731546521187,
-0.07896599173545837,
0.1166175827383995,
0.08652018755674362,
0.04736170545220375,
0.4105466902256012,
-1.0328367948532104,
0.44799602031707764,
0.5520747900009155,
0.8582704067230225,
-0.2166035771369934,
-0.6407648324966431,
-0.5232542157173157,
-0.03374111279845238,
-0.5769001245498657,
0.904088020324707,
-0.25607141852378845,
-0.40817657113075256,
0.07875574380159378,
0.29611581563949585,
-0.16347192227840424,
-0.49013909697532654,
0.7106862664222717,
-0.18007946014404297,
0.3668402135372162,
-0.3632832467556,
-0.5940030217170715,
-0.3519112467765808,
0.035038094967603683,
-0.6544292569160461,
1.326200246810913,
0.17405392229557037,
-0.732613742351532,
0.29031047224998474,
-0.6349003314971924,
-0.39926961064338684,
-0.037906695157289505,
0.04380978271365166,
-0.23930594325065613,
0.12806017696857452,
0.44942784309387207,
0.27846962213516235,
-0.2017679065465927,
0.3517357409000397,
-0.08145330846309662,
-0.6254273056983948,
0.17643789947032928,
-0.4149397611618042,
0.7696595191955566,
0.07177039235830307,
-0.5599362850189209,
0.47523123025894165,
-0.7522890567779541,
0.20323868095874786,
0.19673357903957367,
-0.1972200870513916,
-0.09965862333774567,
0.13383519649505615,
-0.4381529688835144,
0.16757382452487946,
0.14844241738319397,
-0.2769193947315216,
-0.18370886147022247,
-0.3189849853515625,
0.3223670423030853,
0.7594497799873352,
-0.2916904389858246,
0.3217324912548065,
-0.27885350584983826,
0.6049621105194092,
-0.3277750313282013,
0.27781182527542114,
-0.46897754073143005,
-0.30011120438575745,
-0.8716806769371033,
0.11630279570817947,
0.09489553421735764,
0.6290754675865173,
-0.7451203465461731,
0.41206812858581543,
-0.2238738238811493,
-0.5391368865966797,
-0.5411633253097534,
0.1408708542585373,
0.7237105369567871,
0.6811480522155762,
0.2761699855327606,
-0.054740358144044876,
-0.3676232099533081,
-0.7636551856994629,
-0.9264728426933289,
-0.34232163429260254,
0.08238666504621506,
0.3468511700630188,
0.24754531681537628,
0.16039437055587769,
0.5730730891227722,
-0.17636354267597198,
0.04748763516545296,
-0.36815816164016724,
0.2799138128757477,
0.11098320782184601,
0.16412004828453064,
0.3141954243183136,
-0.5670341849327087,
-0.33586224913597107,
-0.05184142664074898,
-0.7237553000450134,
-0.5926122665405273,
-0.43191149830818176,
-0.19281601905822754,
0.35567164421081543,
0.684173047542572,
-0.17219100892543793,
0.43161964416503906,
0.626503050327301,
-0.4573330283164978,
0.9232365489006042,
-0.7696901559829712,
0.4642062187194824,
-0.5274766683578491,
-0.11389144510030746,
-0.022864295169711113,
-0.21732956171035767,
-0.5777878165245056,
0.26458701491355896,
0.4109176695346832,
0.18101564049720764,
-0.23574893176555634,
0.21733355522155762,
-0.6589282155036926,
-0.07834724336862564,
-0.08369960635900497,
0.5231484770774841,
-0.002730089006945491,
0.4676420986652374,
-0.3114723861217499,
0.6159775853157043,
0.2440434843301773,
-0.40817615389823914,
0.45807594060897827,
0.03814932331442833,
-0.41204169392585754,
0.40709710121154785,
-0.5535692572593689,
0.21107378602027893,
-0.10314146429300308,
0.36978816986083984,
-1.213501214981079,
-0.24970202147960663,
0.31185758113861084,
-0.48431506752967834,
-0.023479564115405083,
0.1262349784374237,
-0.6230658292770386,
-0.40346378087997437,
-0.29052576422691345,
0.11329726129770279,
0.312388151884079,
-0.9145878553390503,
0.4622758626937866,
-0.1655322015285492,
-0.23261430859565735,
-0.48200079798698425,
-0.817095935344696,
0.0988985225558281,
-0.0009566738153807819,
-0.8084279894828796,
0.5526064038276672,
-0.31585514545440674,
-0.2576230466365814,
0.1730898916721344,
-0.14945219457149506,
0.14921315014362335,
0.2036077380180359,
0.0718354657292366,
0.5228813886642456,
-0.3935604393482208,
0.2265297770500183,
0.07659082859754562,
-0.25043120980262756,
0.03423558920621872,
-0.005864412523806095,
-0.01818283647298813,
-0.142863467335701,
-0.5587371587753296,
-0.3712832033634186,
0.2596202790737152,
0.19929289817810059,
0.07892179489135742,
0.5817629098892212,
0.15485943853855133,
-0.48819273710250854,
-0.2304752767086029,
-0.39923185110092163,
0.32326123118400574,
-0.465172678232193,
0.5363653898239136,
-0.34269484877586365,
-0.6875531077384949,
0.7014802098274231,
0.20935310423374176,
0.20965783298015594,
0.6532679796218872,
0.4680708348751068,
0.30462801456451416,
1.1475991010665894,
0.42475149035453796,
0.0216650553047657,
0.32794007658958435,
0.45158910751342773,
0.21016019582748413,
-0.45621010661125183,
-0.18460631370544434,
-0.508946418762207,
-0.2668035924434662,
-0.3877217471599579,
-0.4340382218360901,
0.11587359756231308,
0.3017633557319641,
-0.15836676955223083,
0.15116257965564728,
-0.4164445996284485,
0.6978709101676941,
0.4071345925331116,
-0.1597367227077484,
0.4656558036804199,
-0.2758577764034271,
-0.2259412705898285,
-0.11281103640794754,
-0.5505636930465698,
-0.31010890007019043,
0.37409281730651855,
0.10325798392295837,
0.6908701062202454,
-0.021325470879673958,
0.2510811686515808,
0.14175553619861603,
0.1302749365568161,
-0.5215232372283936,
0.51218581199646,
-0.3626832365989685,
-0.5043200254440308,
-0.30561375617980957,
-0.340429425239563,
-0.38850218057632446,
0.4320441484451294,
-0.10027538239955902,
-0.7567703127861023,
-0.3193378746509552,
0.6510263681411743,
-0.3720455765724182,
0.41948428750038147,
-0.9273867607116699,
1.2222791910171509,
-0.49429580569267273,
-0.31480517983436584,
-0.29789525270462036,
-0.5115037560462952,
0.2738054096698761,
0.1955416351556778,
0.3654157221317291,
0.1577311009168625,
-0.12234784662723541,
0.6384738087654114,
-0.5815765261650085,
0.44548794627189636,
-0.32031533122062683,
-0.048831675201654434,
0.33624139428138733,
0.04577897489070892,
0.8060580492019653,
-0.17003001272678375,
-0.24090732634067535,
-0.03359075263142586,
-0.3191105127334595,
-0.2227993756532669,
-0.8790573477745056,
0.6151646375656128,
-0.41627228260040283,
-0.6056588292121887,
-0.09143545478582382,
-0.4452413022518158,
-0.19860577583312988,
-0.17666774988174438,
0.4891940653324127,
0.2335762232542038,
-0.4910709857940674,
-0.2726689577102661,
0.40521037578582764,
-0.39640071988105774,
0.42949774861335754,
0.5617159605026245,
-0.1446334570646286,
-0.11492373794317245,
0.7158890962600708,
0.2562578320503235,
0.21234408020973206,
0.30108097195625305,
0.25017863512039185,
0.0028187737334519625,
-0.7302879691123962,
-0.8085864782333374,
0.10794048011302948,
-0.7968337535858154,
0.31865301728248596,
-0.616045355796814,
-0.1568985879421234,
-0.26054540276527405,
-0.5018787384033203,
-0.21910709142684937,
-0.2969823479652405,
-0.32598772644996643,
-0.3478224575519562,
0.3067341148853302,
0.7951073050498962,
-0.3239336907863617,
0.43309494853019714,
-0.6620357632637024,
0.4838208854198456,
0.07385975122451782,
0.5928141474723816,
0.21384437382221222,
-0.8565682172775269,
-0.3316870629787445,
0.06894677877426147,
0.14862225949764252,
-0.8585726022720337,
0.15172754228115082,
0.3120521605014801,
0.6711598634719849,
0.5821043252944946,
-0.32694944739341736,
1.0253877639770508,
-0.4301496744155884,
1.226617693901062,
0.1051427572965622,
-1.4509590864181519,
0.5672755837440491,
-0.15908290445804596,
0.33503860235214233,
0.28709572553634644,
-0.1129005029797554,
-1.2961533069610596,
-0.25958704948425293,
-0.5889530181884766,
-0.8855658769607544,
0.9661564826965332,
-0.024437379091978073,
-0.1582086831331253,
0.08295175433158875,
0.5588677525520325,
0.5443474650382996,
-0.3570846915245056,
-0.6640217304229736,
-0.35599392652511597,
-0.07306347787380219,
-0.13729342818260193,
-0.3199799656867981,
-0.47467929124832153,
0.02467786893248558,
-0.05582967773079872,
1.0548827648162842,
-0.2619968354701996,
0.283489853143692,
0.31210875511169434,
-0.43332359194755554,
-0.14357195794582367,
0.4089061915874481,
0.7964709997177124,
0.711216151714325,
0.29847976565361023,
0.2872955799102783,
0.6580457091331482,
-0.35312139987945557,
-0.10950932651758194,
0.254903107881546,
0.19412247836589813,
0.168974369764328,
0.5932063460350037,
0.5997552871704102,
0.06550894677639008,
-0.6651851534843445,
0.5018723011016846,
-0.09030503779649734,
-0.26357853412628174,
-0.2239581197500229,
0.14319565892219543,
0.30423620343208313,
-0.11636652052402496,
0.1133868619799614,
-0.2393718808889389,
-0.009096761234104633,
-0.2192421704530716,
-0.04998309165239334,
0.2374795526266098,
-0.5032457113265991,
-0.5049567818641663,
0.7931944727897644,
0.2529301643371582,
-0.02238667570054531,
0.4545588493347168,
-0.505104124546051,
-0.5290799736976624,
0.7431291341781616,
0.356735497713089,
0.7244523763656616,
-0.24422161281108856,
0.3189656734466553,
0.3283953070640564,
0.43414032459259033,
-0.09412474930286407,
0.30062219500541687,
0.07247325778007507,
-0.621076762676239,
-0.599277138710022,
0.2784113883972168,
-0.40948107838630676,
0.12962794303894043,
-0.7556275129318237,
0.1886679232120514,
-0.3718665838241577,
0.5541107654571533,
0.11739327758550644,
-0.22051800787448883,
-0.3619508147239685,
0.3161994516849518,
0.23461712896823883,
1.04966402053833,
-1.023203730583191,
0.5042096972465515,
0.6292314529418945,
-0.08140518516302109,
-1.005792498588562,
-0.14213837683200836,
0.4864378273487091,
-1.0092744827270508,
0.02553887479007244,
0.11468621343374252,
-0.3350916802883148,
-0.49659937620162964,
-0.5775707364082336,
-0.3997019827365875,
0.9122018814086914,
0.3319298326969147,
-0.6685075163841248,
0.10773511976003647,
-0.042407773435115814,
0.760392427444458,
-0.12045378983020782,
0.5213404893875122,
0.8319321870803833,
0.5928765535354614,
-0.3440156579017639,
-0.7830267548561096,
0.12437761574983597,
-0.5864567160606384,
-0.13226261734962463,
0.1031278446316719,
-0.7555502653121948,
0.7174259424209595,
-0.32032352685928345,
-0.3258103132247925,
0.370035856962204,
0.646804690361023,
-0.38117146492004395,
0.34597674012184143,
0.7447652220726013,
0.5470765829086304,
1.088712453842163,
-0.2565876245498657,
1.0894546508789062,
0.16525155305862427,
0.22134843468666077,
1.4991143941879272,
-0.08534527570009232,
0.4018665552139282,
0.24320177733898163,
-0.2995798885822296,
0.6897750496864319,
1.060417652130127,
-0.006255446467548609,
0.2258269339799881,
0.3049733340740204,
-0.3902374804019928,
-0.14427262544631958,
-0.08222834020853043,
-0.3153040111064911,
0.19899989664554596,
0.1909613013267517,
-0.5596129894256592,
-0.13764473795890808,
-0.16792646050453186,
0.15862762928009033,
0.16014240682125092,
-0.5945072770118713,
0.7305306196212769,
-0.26224401593208313,
-1.0512669086456299,
0.41737717390060425,
0.17198961973190308,
0.581580638885498,
-0.6162076592445374,
-0.06922789663076401,
-0.38885414600372314,
0.4219553768634796,
-0.5635830760002136,
-0.9209995269775391,
0.1866118460893631,
0.2618727385997772,
-0.31900423765182495,
-0.1907985955476761,
0.6893889307975769,
-0.5256163477897644,
-0.08032570034265518,
0.47251829504966736,
0.45838412642478943,
0.3949529528617859,
-0.1406940519809723,
-0.7139478921890259,
-0.2989383935928345,
0.2235821634531021,
-0.2662605345249176,
0.02603892609477043,
0.5745981335639954,
-0.15301905572414398,
0.45273810625076294,
0.2833399176597595,
0.11770380288362503,
0.0765533521771431,
0.34074288606643677,
0.5289707183837891,
-0.7833910584449768,
-0.6447271704673767,
-0.8997777700424194,
0.469122052192688,
0.0060544791631400585,
-0.4318186044692993,
0.6824108362197876,
0.4496842622756958,
0.9617186188697815,
-0.09844435006380081,
1.049224853515625,
-0.02691393718123436,
0.5448756814002991,
-0.5442531704902649,
0.5985599756240845,
-0.5397362112998962,
0.06267353147268295,
-0.19958648085594177,
-0.783794641494751,
-0.28333351016044617,
0.3398567736148834,
-0.012485813349485397,
0.17787253856658936,
1.1478160619735718,
1.054724097251892,
0.09774541854858398,
0.6477246880531311,
0.27958476543426514,
0.34618204832077026,
0.07980494201183319,
0.7083817720413208,
0.9048462510108948,
-0.25909557938575745,
0.7882307171821594,
-0.31346258521080017,
-0.41537654399871826,
-0.1534804254770279,
-1.0897190570831299,
-0.6506268382072449,
-0.27463340759277344,
-0.4468308687210083,
-0.396300733089447,
0.2724677622318268,
0.7820308804512024,
0.2508239448070526,
-0.9196281433105469,
0.1720210611820221,
-0.29476821422576904,
0.30074962973594666,
-0.9278081059455872,
-0.18463543057441711,
0.5975217819213867,
-0.13298863172531128,
-0.8538506031036377,
0.33092373609542847,
0.2309112399816513,
-0.1074560284614563,
0.15206855535507202,
-0.1339379996061325,
0.09058865159749985,
-0.13020487129688263,
0.257793128490448,
0.3708793818950653,
-0.7546261548995972,
-0.5448271632194519,
0.10426586121320724,
-0.0023292896803468466,
0.1356557309627533,
1.2939064502716064,
-0.5176618099212646,
0.8954082727432251,
0.5582246780395508,
0.6805909276008606,
0.03495316952466965,
-0.11045151948928833,
0.6295310258865356,
-0.4738890528678894,
-0.28382664918899536,
-0.30783823132514954,
0.6398534774780273,
0.5034491419792175,
-0.547614574432373,
0.7701482772827148,
0.33811941742897034,
-0.5301064848899841,
-0.3289918303489685,
-0.261506587266922,
-0.9278168678283691,
-0.22986716032028198,
1.0544744729995728,
-0.6941244006156921,
-0.05302291363477707,
-0.17184686660766602,
-0.34327512979507446,
0.5219060778617859,
-0.044666215777397156,
0.626897394657135,
1.167817234992981,
-0.27791500091552734,
-0.08258244395256042,
-0.5920333862304688,
0.3904019594192505,
0.8153988718986511,
-1.1583821773529053,
0.5772371292114258,
0.5408660173416138,
0.1020127385854721,
-0.39081162214279175,
0.5042810440063477,
-0.324070543050766,
0.7571032643318176,
0.12881195545196533,
0.10886871814727783,
0.07568853348493576,
-0.08793535828590393,
-0.792228639125824,
-0.31892842054367065,
-0.03289341181516647,
-0.21886980533599854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00923v1 | Preserving Multilingual Quality While Tuning Query Encoder on English Only | 2024-07-01T03:03:18 | 2024-07-01T03:03:18 | Oleg Vasilyev, Randy Sawaya, John Bohannon | cs.CL | cs.CL | A dense passage retrieval system can serve as the initial stages of
information retrieval, selecting the most relevant text passages for downstream
tasks. In this work we conducted experiments with the goal of finding how much
the quality of a multilingual retrieval could be degraded if the query part of
a dual encoder is tuned on an English-only dataset (assuming scarcity of
cross-lingual samples for the targeted domain or task). Specifically, starting
with a high quality multilingual embedding model, we observe that an
English-only tuning may not only preserve the original quality of the
multilingual retrieval, but even improve it. | [
-0.332652747631073,
-0.8044446110725403,
0.3546358048915863,
0.04595093056559563,
-0.5296716690063477,
-0.05871081352233887,
-0.3202154338359833,
-0.48452380299568176,
0.3489711880683899,
0.70647132396698,
-0.37697744369506836,
-0.2834260165691376,
-0.5001755356788635,
0.26210567355155945,
-0.22436901926994324,
0.9382181167602539,
0.10867000371217728,
0.2682138979434967,
-0.1911022961139679,
-0.42316940426826477,
-0.5387397408485413,
-0.3941700756549835,
-1.2582324743270874,
-0.11329101026058197,
0.4760229289531708,
0.5027908086776733,
0.9302833080291748,
0.6411346197128296,
0.4369213283061981,
0.14862406253814697,
-0.04813592880964279,
0.4027709662914276,
-0.701298177242279,
0.5029840469360352,
-0.21270419657230377,
-0.6136982440948486,
0.13203856348991394,
-0.19975005090236664,
0.8188314437866211,
0.6174653172492981,
-0.22548401355743408,
-0.20365892350673676,
0.35342586040496826,
0.5128709077835083,
-0.5282745361328125,
-0.10727903246879578,
-0.7103919982910156,
0.07554426789283752,
-0.2485257387161255,
-0.5368006229400635,
-0.5707772374153137,
-0.054819148033857346,
-0.2635881304740906,
-0.6498912572860718,
0.39154595136642456,
0.33292534947395325,
1.0459765195846558,
0.31296172738075256,
-0.9077994227409363,
-0.026899630203843117,
-0.559529721736908,
0.7664690613746643,
-0.24511121213436127,
0.8771952986717224,
0.5763055086135864,
-0.015004411339759827,
0.13310852646827698,
-0.43322187662124634,
-0.28912052512168884,
-0.031299881637096405,
-0.3746988773345947,
0.25783461332321167,
0.2802733778953552,
-0.03506636619567871,
0.03619934245944023,
0.30006182193756104,
-0.8574721217155457,
0.003122625406831503,
-0.48725396394729614,
-0.4912811815738678,
0.7787270545959473,
-0.014265680685639381,
0.2862832546234131,
-0.1478065550327301,
-0.18292269110679626,
-0.17980211973190308,
-0.8699540495872498,
0.006624185014516115,
0.3598029911518097,
0.28786978125572205,
0.28556492924690247,
0.6391586065292358,
0.12448697537183762,
0.6264142990112305,
0.00491141714155674,
-0.1717156022787094,
0.07741931080818176,
-0.6901037096977234,
0.02917242981493473,
0.1699814349412918,
0.5913822054862976,
0.24988044798374176,
0.2392868548631668,
-0.24512498080730438,
-0.5523502826690674,
-0.08782856911420822,
0.4424826204776764,
-0.6488193273544312,
-0.01243255753070116,
0.171592578291893,
-0.41034889221191406,
0.24813398718833923,
0.08287223428487778,
-0.5285430550575256,
-0.09515569359064102,
-0.19187456369400024,
0.5595099329948425,
-0.43829941749572754,
-0.51296067237854,
0.19611215591430664,
-0.140291228890419,
0.10672672837972641,
-0.11881101131439209,
-0.719473123550415,
-0.002625110326334834,
0.4699070453643799,
0.7997016906738281,
-0.1733144372701645,
-0.5137880444526672,
-0.5776930451393127,
0.10586156696081161,
-0.42968007922172546,
0.8245165348052979,
-0.7738565802574158,
-0.6348497271537781,
0.10985804349184036,
0.4001516103744507,
-0.21112558245658875,
-0.6105453372001648,
0.8287715315818787,
-0.9360979795455933,
0.0020750679541379213,
-0.34009110927581787,
-0.513609766960144,
0.1749773919582367,
0.13105744123458862,
-0.8689505457878113,
1.0447551012039185,
-0.1834719032049179,
-0.5895211696624756,
0.601327121257782,
-0.18206153810024261,
-0.8501244187355042,
-0.12187547236680984,
0.08112479001283646,
-0.1688096523284912,
0.2827101945877075,
0.33661866188049316,
0.09566541761159897,
-0.034693699330091476,
-0.0035706544294953346,
-0.07578032463788986,
-0.6483973264694214,
-0.0033839463721960783,
-0.3382515609264374,
0.3698762357234955,
0.26096177101135254,
0.11376754194498062,
-0.34656086564064026,
-0.5644104480743408,
0.25199443101882935,
0.10211261361837387,
-0.5576865077018738,
-0.6109980344772339,
0.11909323185682297,
0.17475852370262146,
0.22758044302463531,
0.19359710812568665,
-0.7840896248817444,
0.12615568935871124,
-0.3730514347553253,
0.3136031925678253,
0.528118908405304,
0.2450634092092514,
0.5067058801651001,
-0.3793140649795532,
0.5773391723632812,
0.20393207669258118,
0.08769489079713821,
-0.22269704937934875,
-0.6325947642326355,
-0.832431972026825,
0.033896345645189285,
0.4904754161834717,
0.6734262704849243,
-0.8662016987800598,
0.048527076840400696,
-0.30517578125,
-0.07718173414468765,
-1.024858832359314,
0.12276190519332886,
0.4603303074836731,
-0.0025937852915376425,
0.3760695457458496,
-0.01834426447749138,
-0.3751662075519562,
-1.017242193222046,
-0.49904611706733704,
0.030268777161836624,
0.1336924433708191,
0.31188535690307617,
0.3474082052707672,
0.13118672370910645,
0.4098384976387024,
-0.4645465314388275,
-0.3073822557926178,
0.023577246814966202,
-0.010046703740954399,
0.15190844237804413,
0.5255874395370483,
0.3589008152484894,
-1.0857617855072021,
-0.6986984014511108,
0.10461349785327911,
-0.5965299606323242,
0.01133783720433712,
-0.16146397590637207,
-0.6626244187355042,
0.09125863760709763,
0.6932940483093262,
-0.39331942796707153,
0.12588146328926086,
0.594825029373169,
-0.5025557279586792,
0.23305164277553558,
-0.4041621685028076,
0.6132156252861023,
-1.0429269075393677,
-0.17428971827030182,
-0.21285966038703918,
-0.2802210748195648,
-0.5071304440498352,
0.21041662991046906,
0.47320324182510376,
-0.23988747596740723,
-0.28848662972450256,
0.6460707783699036,
-0.6107966899871826,
0.09049558639526367,
-0.22249606251716614,
0.1960701048374176,
0.47997626662254333,
0.19084793329238892,
0.10141190141439438,
1.0891573429107666,
0.4966084957122803,
-0.7134264707565308,
-0.048369813710451126,
0.39596864581108093,
-0.48250746726989746,
0.7862120270729065,
-0.7655046582221985,
0.32294541597366333,
-0.5348811745643616,
-0.29742538928985596,
-0.9122395515441895,
-0.03342606499791145,
-0.41665250062942505,
-0.5127211213111877,
0.5983039736747742,
-0.3736770451068878,
-0.4251959025859833,
-0.18519890308380127,
-0.1659165769815445,
0.2760540246963501,
0.12497984617948532,
-0.5902097821235657,
0.18581905961036682,
0.35074806213378906,
-0.32896149158477783,
-0.5628024339675903,
-0.8599741458892822,
-0.03750606253743172,
0.16977567970752716,
-0.8065187931060791,
0.6457076072692871,
-0.2080121636390686,
0.16730360686779022,
0.0725877657532692,
-0.08681097626686096,
-0.2621400058269501,
-0.07035408169031143,
-0.2738998532295227,
-0.06980497390031815,
-0.25647950172424316,
0.4627124071121216,
0.6907013058662415,
-0.03537498041987419,
-0.21457093954086304,
-0.4486171305179596,
0.2869699001312256,
0.494180291891098,
-0.5968393087387085,
0.03848610818386078,
0.9147741794586182,
0.45116692781448364,
-0.7178509831428528,
1.0736801624298096,
0.49845054745674133,
-0.29905468225479126,
-0.2908206284046173,
-0.5967007875442505,
-0.40584510564804077,
-0.4724547266960144,
0.54630446434021,
-0.865728497505188,
-0.8542643785476685,
0.47514668107032776,
0.444686621427536,
-0.04574764892458916,
0.37528160214424133,
0.06385211646556854,
-0.00931867491453886,
1.4340934753417969,
0.7997201681137085,
0.09350485354661942,
0.4254647195339203,
-0.10963904112577438,
0.2322913408279419,
-0.7736048698425293,
-0.421956330537796,
-0.6662416458129883,
-0.33303534984588623,
-0.59483802318573,
-0.06842679530382156,
0.7740828394889832,
0.31081050634384155,
-0.09648635983467102,
-0.045560672879219055,
-0.4418807029724121,
0.790902316570282,
0.5786606073379517,
0.44400835037231445,
0.39035359025001526,
0.2501458525657654,
-0.3271350562572479,
-0.2290191352367401,
-0.7112563252449036,
-0.2779397964477539,
1.1103397607803345,
-0.3450673222541809,
0.6787036657333374,
0.30083638429641724,
0.5564509034156799,
0.13359244167804718,
-0.2357233315706253,
-0.5678274631500244,
0.13207004964351654,
-0.28683632612228394,
-0.8664266467094421,
-0.3231675922870636,
-0.5002659559249878,
-1.3341838121414185,
0.49963027238845825,
-0.11068470031023026,
-0.25248345732688904,
0.21463321149349213,
-0.023577820509672165,
-0.0970347449183464,
0.21891063451766968,
-0.5863614678382874,
0.9064391851425171,
-0.2576286196708679,
-0.4986881613731384,
-0.29845064878463745,
-0.3188997507095337,
-0.038352128118276596,
-0.3230644464492798,
0.2842566967010498,
0.11128613352775574,
-0.2651216685771942,
0.6526498198509216,
0.08615479618310928,
0.2344711571931839,
-0.31866928935050964,
-0.07159914821386337,
0.053319770842790604,
0.22931478917598724,
0.5908281207084656,
0.36763814091682434,
-0.529577374458313,
0.0077731311321258545,
0.18559910356998444,
-0.73091059923172,
-0.6511481404304504,
0.8068696856498718,
-0.8608404994010925,
-0.5673319101333618,
-0.054767243564128876,
-0.06982863694429398,
-0.28360405564308167,
0.3302047848701477,
0.5459094047546387,
0.49971798062324524,
-0.1532832384109497,
0.3266424536705017,
0.8202233910560608,
-0.21466967463493347,
0.3439851999282837,
0.7378587126731873,
0.03593946620821953,
-0.21539059281349182,
0.7109987139701843,
0.30861905217170715,
0.34100162982940674,
0.516861617565155,
-0.009770425036549568,
-0.5243141651153564,
-0.6983402967453003,
-0.6525786519050598,
0.309403657913208,
-0.7998912334442139,
-0.25691652297973633,
-0.5899752974510193,
-0.10925818234682083,
-0.35981839895248413,
-0.001652601407840848,
-0.5014471411705017,
-0.09209373593330383,
-0.23333895206451416,
-0.09746287763118744,
0.16099488735198975,
0.635578453540802,
0.03695983439683914,
-0.09723930805921555,
-1.0066993236541748,
0.14018574357032776,
0.02467760071158409,
0.43182265758514404,
-0.3790256381034851,
-0.8379206657409668,
-0.7531646490097046,
0.34814250469207764,
0.01203890796750784,
-0.7115609049797058,
0.48955056071281433,
0.7734540104866028,
0.8909471035003662,
0.3084147870540619,
0.06575930863618851,
0.6422403454780579,
-0.5211210250854492,
0.8837533593177795,
-0.3078354299068451,
-0.5561184883117676,
0.8403003811836243,
-0.050887033343315125,
0.45937541127204895,
0.7436395287513733,
0.6954596638679504,
-0.6910499930381775,
-0.2922213673591614,
-0.052708566188812256,
-0.790103554725647,
0.6768792867660522,
-0.07306545972824097,
0.30134737491607666,
-0.21823148429393768,
0.6097931265830994,
0.34353986382484436,
0.1499030739068985,
-0.5013484954833984,
-0.32589754462242126,
-0.25712329149246216,
0.023924723267555237,
-0.34331271052360535,
-0.31728824973106384,
0.031654033809900284,
-0.16336524486541748,
0.6741815805435181,
-0.24249283969402313,
0.35698381066322327,
0.26605138182640076,
-0.5397183895111084,
-0.24931593239307404,
0.27183037996292114,
0.13903802633285522,
0.6224846243858337,
-0.02127658762037754,
-0.05422736704349518,
0.02677847072482109,
-0.6020625233650208,
0.37648436427116394,
-0.08601115643978119,
-0.42977309226989746,
0.006866385694593191,
0.2118821144104004,
0.9126779437065125,
0.2734508216381073,
-0.38925686478614807,
0.4109468460083008,
-0.1062563955783844,
-0.003772362368181348,
0.01526759285479784,
-0.06856735795736313,
-0.23919633030891418,
0.061335306614637375,
0.4879342317581177,
-0.10232363641262054,
0.16521672904491425,
-0.4888106882572174,
0.3439618945121765,
0.44970330595970154,
-0.1573602557182312,
-0.21061331033706665,
0.7188781499862671,
0.03612815588712692,
-0.1328071802854538,
0.9465946555137634,
-0.25499647855758667,
-0.3509843051433563,
0.3461708426475525,
0.7340430021286011,
0.6391002535820007,
-0.3943886458873749,
0.09150887280702591,
0.6147099733352661,
0.6479180455207825,
-0.10337236523628235,
0.6126484274864197,
0.00776257086545229,
-0.9894105195999146,
-0.5943337678909302,
-0.8298905491828918,
-0.10676325112581253,
-0.24405185878276825,
-1.0737968683242798,
0.2545319199562073,
0.21085579693317413,
-0.1615908443927765,
-0.15877114236354828,
-0.04400721564888954,
-0.7520049810409546,
0.33462539315223694,
0.03722936660051346,
0.7240506410598755,
-0.7444860339164734,
1.0320552587509155,
0.9327817559242249,
-0.3116143047809601,
-0.5998092889785767,
-0.06336784362792969,
-0.2691812515258789,
-0.8372210264205933,
0.42954063415527344,
-0.13280810415744781,
-0.17754845321178436,
0.17529615759849548,
-0.189191535115242,
-1.2054389715194702,
0.7952053546905518,
0.43236008286476135,
-0.5157182812690735,
0.02713920921087265,
0.09650878608226776,
0.41423702239990234,
0.1440785974264145,
0.3287348449230194,
0.47583022713661194,
0.5470111966133118,
-0.1439674347639084,
-1.0191940069198608,
-0.20328299701213837,
-0.5060330033302307,
-0.08764510601758957,
0.4935878813266754,
-0.8145400285720825,
0.8445082306861877,
-0.04609198123216629,
-0.4782395362854004,
-0.1236703172326088,
0.3941488564014435,
-0.35849177837371826,
-0.1837628036737442,
0.43804171681404114,
0.5486590266227722,
0.9568846821784973,
-0.389395147562027,
1.26950204372406,
-0.7387580275535583,
0.22101043164730072,
0.6222195029258728,
-0.14348895847797394,
1.1111912727355957,
0.42144283652305603,
-0.03043779544532299,
0.04231758415699005,
0.813527524471283,
0.27244675159454346,
0.8667483925819397,
-0.30366793274879456,
-0.22419854998588562,
-0.4305751919746399,
-0.14780324697494507,
-0.5346755385398865,
0.5427866578102112,
0.35325565934181213,
-0.10411468148231506,
0.19621120393276215,
0.5025385618209839,
-0.07874590158462524,
-0.007699091453105211,
-0.32563841342926025,
0.8493517637252808,
-0.13992086052894592,
-1.0955569744110107,
0.875461220741272,
0.026539292186498642,
0.8316534757614136,
-0.7267098426818848,
0.18428067862987518,
-0.7053429484367371,
-0.011558648198843002,
-0.27371498942375183,
-0.8471457958221436,
0.5797902345657349,
-0.4711480438709259,
-0.3574095368385315,
-0.39850926399230957,
0.6478260159492493,
-0.742783784866333,
-0.5305331945419312,
0.621652364730835,
0.681384265422821,
0.12839683890342712,
-0.3468669652938843,
-0.5015930533409119,
0.04820265993475914,
0.021805349737405777,
-0.5578888654708862,
0.4307689070701599,
0.6025065183639526,
0.38098257780075073,
0.3863055408000946,
0.6070963144302368,
0.2193056046962738,
0.32484501600265503,
0.2838936448097229,
0.6134870052337646,
-0.8613150119781494,
-0.4832446873188019,
-0.542181134223938,
0.45602649450302124,
0.061324797570705414,
-0.2900935709476471,
0.8837690949440002,
0.7309842705726624,
1.1563105583190918,
0.08326288312673569,
0.709804892539978,
0.22385704517364502,
0.23488183319568634,
-0.9192001819610596,
0.7243347764015198,
-1.2017264366149902,
0.009658779948949814,
0.15992793440818787,
-0.9603515863418579,
-0.13110946118831635,
0.47285112738609314,
0.3115437626838684,
0.036439038813114166,
1.0300614833831787,
1.2623515129089355,
-0.2381940335035324,
0.1480497419834137,
0.7777264714241028,
0.16773420572280884,
-0.03061608038842678,
0.4255562126636505,
0.7590675354003906,
-0.4531715214252472,
0.8557477593421936,
-0.11453477293252945,
0.05731593072414398,
-0.057564616203308105,
-0.3783438801765442,
-0.6209932565689087,
-0.6115374565124512,
-0.11332493275403976,
-0.43506184220314026,
0.2809024155139923,
0.47388726472854614,
0.7816072702407837,
-0.9504668116569519,
0.003359999507665634,
0.3843552768230438,
0.004806485027074814,
-0.3068288266658783,
-0.18258576095104218,
0.15741288661956787,
-0.5451442003250122,
-0.8162136077880859,
0.7927790284156799,
0.19033163785934448,
-0.297486811876297,
-0.1682633012533188,
-0.0635632574558258,
-0.2932995557785034,
0.17044633626937866,
0.6517743468284607,
-0.16876506805419922,
-0.3333089351654053,
-0.3781086206436157,
0.4011819362640381,
-0.1221034973859787,
0.30631834268569946,
0.8757357597351074,
-0.39926472306251526,
0.6880889534950256,
0.3426315188407898,
0.5447511672973633,
0.8949459791183472,
-0.40147241950035095,
0.5142940878868103,
-1.151962161064148,
0.2081110030412674,
0.3087798058986664,
0.6245079636573792,
0.3358553349971771,
-0.5300184488296509,
0.4338120222091675,
0.05740831419825554,
-0.6759393811225891,
-0.5719432830810547,
0.10157187283039093,
-0.43802234530448914,
-0.24608975648880005,
1.2366430759429932,
-0.14139746129512787,
-0.04589129611849785,
-0.33566707372665405,
-0.2854260802268982,
0.18999646604061127,
-0.34651559591293335,
0.3203417956829071,
0.845914363861084,
0.15794554352760315,
-0.18535766005516052,
-0.6656399369239807,
0.34208521246910095,
0.6111176013946533,
-0.4042503535747528,
-0.35599565505981445,
0.3570672869682312,
0.1996781975030899,
-0.010191444307565689,
0.5402830243110657,
-0.16914406418800354,
0.2088448852300644,
0.2602156698703766,
-0.1579374223947525,
0.07358046621084213,
-0.5109760165214539,
-0.3319529592990875,
0.25596514344215393,
0.31504276394844055,
-0.11130894720554352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00911v1 | Deep Image-to-Recipe Translation | 2024-07-01T02:33:07 | 2024-07-01T02:33:07 | Jiangqin Ma, Bilal Mawji, Franz Williams | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The modern saying, "You Are What You Eat" resonates on a profound level,
reflecting the intricate connection between our identities and the food we
consume. Our project, Deep Image-to-Recipe Translation, is an intersection of
computer vision and natural language generation that aims to bridge the gap
between cherished food memories and the art of culinary creation. Our primary
objective involves predicting ingredients from a given food image. For this
task, we first develop a custom convolutional network and then compare its
performance to a model that leverages transfer learning. We pursue an
additional goal of generating a comprehensive set of recipe steps from a list
of ingredients. We frame this process as a sequence-to-sequence task and
develop a recurrent neural network that utilizes pre-trained word embeddings.
We address several challenges of deep learning including imbalanced datasets,
data cleaning, overfitting, and hyperparameter selection. Our approach
emphasizes the importance of metrics such as Intersection over Union (IoU) and
F1 score in scenarios where accuracy alone might be misleading. For our recipe
prediction model, we employ perplexity, a commonly used and important metric
for language models. We find that transfer learning via pre-trained ResNet-50
weights and GloVe embeddings provide an exceptional boost to model performance,
especially when considering training resource constraints. Although we have
made progress on the image-to-recipe translation, there is an opportunity for
future exploration with advancements in model architectures, dataset
scalability, and enhanced user interaction. | [
-0.23057670891284943,
-0.6255432963371277,
0.31970059871673584,
-0.05384242162108421,
-0.22704538702964783,
0.08450638502836227,
-0.18689186871051788,
-0.5492061376571655,
0.24502286314964294,
0.8159241676330566,
-0.61576908826828,
-0.3709314465522766,
-1.0610580444335938,
0.07411784678697586,
-0.5712189078330994,
0.7074835896492004,
-0.17997868359088898,
0.10497099906206131,
-0.12986189126968384,
-0.04346546530723572,
-0.790697455406189,
-0.25620853900909424,
-0.5536330342292786,
-0.31436580419540405,
0.5080965161323547,
0.6164011359214783,
0.6785411834716797,
0.8764250874519348,
0.5505580306053162,
0.28499090671539307,
0.16540537774562836,
0.4127102196216583,
-0.4428339898586273,
0.36036473512649536,
-0.16289986670017242,
-0.3975541889667511,
-0.08319704979658127,
0.021051326766610146,
0.1763840615749359,
0.8398886919021606,
0.1234477162361145,
0.37246641516685486,
0.01874600164592266,
0.9496268033981323,
-0.7436030507087708,
0.10934961587190628,
-0.694239616394043,
0.5550736784934998,
0.049124378710985184,
-0.07205156981945038,
-0.2932163178920746,
-0.346607506275177,
0.18221144378185272,
-0.6319979429244995,
-0.003844594582915306,
-0.04759291559457779,
0.651582658290863,
0.28633448481559753,
-0.3797731399536133,
-0.3408862054347992,
-0.8069259524345398,
0.570577085018158,
-0.6609902381896973,
0.4208630323410034,
0.32619255781173706,
0.5051409602165222,
-0.3785255253314972,
-1.346657395362854,
-0.6366024017333984,
-0.018190808594226837,
0.15006567537784576,
0.14615124464035034,
0.0036463444121181965,
-0.4102851152420044,
-0.023634733632206917,
0.5521948337554932,
-0.5289278626441956,
0.00153106520883739,
-0.16818858683109283,
0.18991369009017944,
0.5198712944984436,
0.2787723243236542,
0.4145388603210449,
0.29519277811050415,
-0.45171695947647095,
-0.25302764773368835,
-0.475369393825531,
-0.09018318355083466,
-0.12251484394073486,
0.1403680443763733,
-0.033972255885601044,
0.829790472984314,
-0.2702755033969879,
0.5050637125968933,
0.11113771051168442,
0.24284516274929047,
0.17559784650802612,
-0.4279203414916992,
-0.27613553404808044,
0.24217233061790466,
0.7101216912269592,
0.7876440286636353,
0.253738135099411,
-0.1169622540473938,
-0.12467452883720398,
-0.1823616474866867,
0.3168542981147766,
-0.7733970880508423,
-0.39885470271110535,
-0.1935279220342636,
-0.1799578219652176,
-0.1895967423915863,
0.11318458616733551,
-0.33878839015960693,
-0.6210743188858032,
-0.3162125051021576,
0.24427790939807892,
-0.21518109738826752,
-0.11103149503469467,
0.4151456356048584,
-0.27726155519485474,
0.3821950852870941,
0.25805673003196716,
-0.967444121837616,
0.42673835158348083,
0.5810946226119995,
0.6512796878814697,
0.057439956814050674,
-0.3128259778022766,
-0.5679296851158142,
0.2679568827152252,
-0.6153424382209778,
0.6022698879241943,
-0.5250774025917053,
-0.4043029546737671,
-0.09076958894729614,
0.3235984742641449,
0.11617827415466309,
-0.5748065710067749,
0.23785826563835144,
-0.283700555562973,
-0.20063386857509613,
-0.6018794775009155,
-0.7102751731872559,
-0.2740921974182129,
0.16336968541145325,
-0.5750465989112854,
0.6545341610908508,
-0.07059657573699951,
-0.24857184290885925,
0.4941122233867645,
-0.17585718631744385,
-1.084148645401001,
0.31144019961357117,
-0.3553258776664734,
-0.3033268451690674,
0.3908943831920624,
0.2720203697681427,
0.4709793031215668,
-0.7332360744476318,
0.03676537051796913,
-0.2038833200931549,
-0.24067071080207825,
0.6099837422370911,
-0.2846415638923645,
0.07000751048326492,
0.48779985308647156,
-0.26519182324409485,
0.07524356245994568,
-0.2879909574985504,
0.0436348095536232,
0.47255802154541016,
-0.4786751866340637,
-0.026107700541615486,
-0.05915635824203491,
0.13443318009376526,
-0.10926244407892227,
0.26016566157341003,
-0.3417077362537384,
0.19995510578155518,
-0.49394121766090393,
0.5816606879234314,
0.7012481093406677,
-0.03226027637720108,
0.7060539126396179,
-0.1250447779893875,
0.31950339674949646,
0.12193399667739868,
0.032937001436948776,
-0.3546200096607208,
-0.47875896096229553,
-0.6689184904098511,
0.30386683344841003,
0.28293555974960327,
0.6431388258934021,
-0.5804261565208435,
0.6495999693870544,
-0.2586725056171417,
-0.4412788152694702,
-0.46620193123817444,
0.0958561822772026,
0.35681474208831787,
0.7701523900032043,
0.4135884940624237,
-0.7446340918540955,
-0.5443974733352661,
-0.9426844120025635,
-0.27820512652397156,
0.5597485303878784,
0.02344345673918724,
0.20479795336723328,
0.358446329832077,
-0.178292915225029,
0.33807501196861267,
-0.6901569962501526,
-0.2817431390285492,
-0.5176088213920593,
0.004561907146126032,
0.3359602093696594,
0.7647662162780762,
0.26659002900123596,
-0.833514928817749,
-0.7403494715690613,
0.6130792498588562,
-0.8092935681343079,
0.527630627155304,
-0.08491601049900055,
-0.09075306355953217,
-0.1568356603384018,
0.5827258825302124,
-0.44317787885665894,
0.42508187890052795,
0.3572938144207001,
-0.4190334379673004,
0.1809503734111786,
-0.1282871812582016,
0.3580322265625,
-1.5483415126800537,
-0.0007447990356013179,
0.10372550040483475,
-0.028105853125452995,
-0.21672256290912628,
-0.028508765622973442,
-0.10886070132255554,
-0.3209807574748993,
-0.6484042406082153,
0.6361860036849976,
-0.4343939423561096,
-0.12824746966362,
-0.06691684573888779,
-0.5952440500259399,
0.28242573142051697,
0.3133524954319,
-0.0022573501337319613,
0.617345929145813,
0.5508647561073303,
-0.4491473436355591,
0.5670146942138672,
0.146787628531456,
-0.5672802925109863,
0.5257865786552429,
-0.4967966079711914,
0.31874173879623413,
0.09427811205387115,
0.21713978052139282,
-0.9586608409881592,
-0.23290200531482697,
0.5897352695465088,
-0.4734143912792206,
0.5581361055374146,
-0.03513238579034805,
-0.7081124782562256,
-0.45929068326950073,
0.10772700607776642,
0.3979269862174988,
0.4323265254497528,
-0.4602292776107788,
0.6520448923110962,
0.30890223383903503,
0.1118081659078598,
-0.3074837625026703,
-1.0529613494873047,
0.4158393144607544,
0.11414141952991486,
-0.29544004797935486,
0.5264074206352234,
0.03928520530462265,
0.25856971740722656,
0.339869886636734,
-0.13913443684577942,
-0.1838262677192688,
0.20037724077701569,
0.3097551167011261,
-0.11473231017589569,
-0.4712076187133789,
-0.19421468675136566,
0.17015473544597626,
0.04098326340317726,
0.055116888135671616,
-0.7357430458068848,
0.3647969365119934,
-0.07892297953367233,
0.050551772117614746,
-0.5620495080947876,
0.4513532817363739,
0.5068849921226501,
-0.5544717311859131,
0.5321602821350098,
0.6907790899276733,
-0.5219941735267639,
-0.00031536302412860096,
-0.27229729294776917,
-0.24953992664813995,
-0.4945320785045624,
0.5840623378753662,
-0.506942093372345,
-0.4259900748729706,
0.3136885464191437,
-0.34540989995002747,
-0.04789094626903534,
0.14713644981384277,
0.20560584962368011,
-0.4305511713027954,
0.6914799213409424,
0.345703125,
-0.01915581524372101,
0.34314820170402527,
-0.420857697725296,
-0.04784875735640526,
-0.8083217144012451,
-0.36658748984336853,
-0.23108522593975067,
-0.7221077680587769,
-0.3401256799697876,
-0.5509405136108398,
0.1831536442041397,
-0.3185502886772156,
-0.4707813560962677,
0.6322105526924133,
-0.5597476959228516,
0.7501961588859558,
0.5305542945861816,
0.3660534918308258,
0.020954638719558716,
0.15676681697368622,
-0.13757111132144928,
-0.17005294561386108,
-0.4665229618549347,
-0.1469406634569168,
0.9121389389038086,
0.2784820795059204,
0.8798695206642151,
-0.031606581062078476,
0.6141722202301025,
0.29963746666908264,
-0.01888468861579895,
-0.7451916337013245,
0.499719500541687,
-0.7647881507873535,
-0.37644681334495544,
-0.2612195909023285,
-0.3621734380722046,
-0.8557881712913513,
-0.16109098494052887,
-0.4491707980632782,
-0.3981419801712036,
0.00397281302139163,
0.1904010772705078,
-0.17222203314304352,
0.44351494312286377,
-0.930736780166626,
1.0957459211349487,
-0.7682793736457825,
-0.47960329055786133,
0.24667569994926453,
-0.6495465040206909,
-0.014883439056575298,
0.39993172883987427,
-0.14319658279418945,
0.05577860400080681,
0.04957170784473419,
0.3213832378387451,
-0.18610553443431854,
0.997134804725647,
0.18570218980312347,
0.1920272260904312,
-0.05115776136517525,
0.4935130774974823,
0.4235004484653473,
-0.11797600984573364,
0.012373254634439945,
0.16696535050868988,
-0.28683194518089294,
-0.30189087986946106,
-0.8047575950622559,
0.7136722207069397,
-0.6049178838729858,
-0.4363672733306885,
-0.29817619919776917,
-0.37920477986335754,
0.06901121884584427,
0.5179392099380493,
0.4880848228931427,
0.059577375650405884,
-0.18666227161884308,
0.24416926503181458,
0.5733432769775391,
-0.28099748492240906,
0.09724811464548111,
0.0032550618052482605,
-0.10009405016899109,
-0.6100478172302246,
1.0373390913009644,
0.2027074098587036,
0.025804726406931877,
0.8132358193397522,
0.3806003928184509,
-0.2214149683713913,
-0.40495675802230835,
-0.6254017353057861,
-0.1032085046172142,
-0.7922194600105286,
-0.26328417658805847,
-0.3889518976211548,
-0.23042544722557068,
-0.3506256639957428,
-0.44066643714904785,
-0.8296144008636475,
-0.14833104610443115,
-0.46647998690605164,
-0.12195353209972382,
0.042159534990787506,
0.7377138137817383,
0.2667123079299927,
0.02873384580016136,
-0.6000403761863708,
0.11850545555353165,
0.2689901292324066,
0.18769709765911102,
0.07278768718242645,
-0.5436959862709045,
-0.2991049885749817,
-0.09008072316646576,
-0.45665788650512695,
-0.5829225778579712,
0.6003669500350952,
0.34216073155403137,
0.2942148745059967,
0.11923664063215256,
-0.14093975722789764,
0.63888019323349,
-0.5660266876220703,
0.6013076901435852,
0.6800867915153503,
-0.7514767050743103,
0.6555044651031494,
0.18926599621772766,
0.5752844214439392,
0.508945107460022,
0.48297345638275146,
-0.6199485659599304,
-0.08555141091346741,
-0.26800301671028137,
-0.980786144733429,
-0.009641670621931553,
-0.11438337713479996,
0.3329484760761261,
-0.1388111412525177,
0.4714168906211853,
0.4409901797771454,
0.186212956905365,
-0.5417372584342957,
-0.11992761492729187,
-0.437514990568161,
-0.1949613094329834,
-0.12134064733982086,
0.13396674394607544,
0.10841494798660278,
-0.46433234214782715,
0.32503363490104675,
-0.0506293810904026,
0.05358413979411125,
-0.01852521300315857,
0.13900989294052124,
-0.2909011244773865,
-0.09535273909568787,
0.5368323922157288,
0.3714848756790161,
-0.06373750418424606,
0.38825517892837524,
0.15673838555812836,
-0.403580904006958,
0.04804771766066551,
-0.023498158901929855,
0.2805604934692383,
-0.36676210165023804,
0.4327794909477234,
0.8585361242294312,
0.2056298404932022,
-0.3382847309112549,
0.45905929803848267,
-0.3101745843887329,
-0.270776629447937,
-0.4057968556880951,
0.08066117018461227,
0.17408260703086853,
0.27807095646858215,
0.25005167722702026,
0.191568061709404,
0.24566391110420227,
-0.5607990026473999,
0.33565568923950195,
0.18470390141010284,
-0.49383461475372314,
-0.2858985364437103,
0.5950800776481628,
0.355521023273468,
-0.1206459105014801,
1.0299818515777588,
-0.09648287296295166,
-0.21440020203590393,
0.8512311577796936,
0.7880321741104126,
1.0048006772994995,
-0.05917482078075409,
0.22131696343421936,
0.4477076232433319,
0.32434821128845215,
-0.08028452098369598,
0.12340971827507019,
0.06284552812576294,
-0.7038606405258179,
-0.15652811527252197,
-0.5912529826164246,
-0.12590278685092926,
0.19299745559692383,
-0.6684284210205078,
0.2003777176141739,
-0.5511636734008789,
-0.07164548337459564,
-0.04372114688158035,
-0.30702757835388184,
-1.0285117626190186,
0.44699689745903015,
0.3523540794849396,
0.8784867525100708,
-0.814288854598999,
0.7412682175636292,
0.7663465142250061,
-0.5293553471565247,
-0.6292552947998047,
0.01810256391763687,
-0.14763912558555603,
-0.8775014877319336,
0.7593187689781189,
0.34305238723754883,
0.13933567702770233,
-0.005098314955830574,
-0.6080290675163269,
-0.6483717560768127,
0.9466463327407837,
0.517638623714447,
-0.8299285769462585,
-0.14995579421520233,
0.243376225233078,
0.13298547267913818,
-0.5878210067749023,
-0.4138038456439972,
0.29739126563072205,
0.4577668309211731,
0.6283430457115173,
-0.33434221148490906,
0.18352556228637695,
-0.18438030779361725,
0.22463306784629822,
0.18803223967552185,
-0.1029951274394989,
0.5957211852073669,
-0.4152703881263733,
-0.3630496561527252,
0.18502293527126312,
0.7481228709220886,
-0.3955414891242981,
0.4105719029903412,
0.08192642778158188,
0.8317089080810547,
0.32961273193359375,
-0.0018110157689079642,
1.153896689414978,
0.11266239732503891,
-0.07161061465740204,
1.5664329528808594,
-0.29095396399497986,
0.7247525453567505,
0.5682562589645386,
0.1071053221821785,
0.08623313903808594,
0.9157372713088989,
-0.26204773783683777,
0.8685453534126282,
0.35415908694267273,
0.054691579192876816,
-0.1050087958574295,
-0.3505569398403168,
-0.5301943421363831,
0.32115668058395386,
0.40735575556755066,
-0.840360164642334,
-0.05566078796982765,
0.024690892547369003,
-0.2977242171764374,
0.38604071736335754,
-0.08268897235393524,
0.9355344176292419,
0.28715822100639343,
-0.5928000211715698,
0.3908435106277466,
-0.24017369747161865,
0.08129048347473145,
-0.2991158664226532,
-0.48116108775138855,
-0.4303117096424103,
0.07030847668647766,
-0.0545857697725296,
-1.1887491941452026,
0.2145114243030548,
-0.5907645225524902,
-0.10092045366764069,
-0.03569032624363899,
0.24777047336101532,
-0.30788537859916687,
-0.8084278702735901,
0.11308640241622925,
0.2720387279987335,
-0.0009938011644408107,
0.0053905607201159,
-0.899420440196991,
0.38731715083122253,
-0.06796968728303909,
0.037963420152664185,
0.1939726024866104,
0.5859308838844299,
0.384330153465271,
0.2662595808506012,
0.45666608214378357,
0.133734330534935,
-0.06251952052116394,
-0.1912507712841034,
0.8828043937683105,
-0.7703720927238464,
-0.36737221479415894,
-0.7752311825752258,
0.5066206455230713,
0.25291144847869873,
-0.4799463748931885,
0.07335399836301804,
0.6614024043083191,
1.1146798133850098,
-0.578478217124939,
0.751610279083252,
0.05263172462582588,
-0.3074475824832916,
-0.7008284330368042,
0.6450977325439453,
-0.6914571523666382,
0.19334377348423004,
-0.07460784912109375,
-0.8020381331443787,
-0.2316923290491104,
0.46753767132759094,
-0.22676695883274078,
-0.3725050091743469,
0.5225653648376465,
0.7627325057983398,
-0.2617477476596832,
-0.18482929468154907,
0.5805633664131165,
-0.04011870175600052,
0.20080794394016266,
0.6845129728317261,
0.6443514227867126,
-0.5744158625602722,
0.09432435035705566,
-0.3188111186027527,
-0.12022635340690613,
-0.18431700766086578,
-0.9378104209899902,
-0.4690472185611725,
-0.900033712387085,
-0.35193124413490295,
-0.247172549366951,
0.3121850788593292,
0.9185351133346558,
0.8741081953048706,
-0.5182347297668457,
-0.3788626492023468,
-0.36481204628944397,
0.0026147570461034775,
-0.6152645349502563,
-0.09390154480934143,
0.02725907973945141,
-0.3004515767097473,
-0.46005380153656006,
0.4293738007545471,
0.3395172357559204,
0.22062598168849945,
0.000043595278839347884,
-0.048414744436740875,
-0.2001725435256958,
-0.12698988616466522,
0.756985068321228,
0.48767486214637756,
-0.6115803122520447,
0.06414534151554108,
-0.02476479299366474,
-0.0542888306081295,
0.05913224816322327,
0.6178140640258789,
-0.20478171110153198,
0.8556573390960693,
0.1101091280579567,
1.3075227737426758,
0.7337345480918884,
-0.3928042948246002,
0.8547177910804749,
-0.7827211022377014,
-0.13807006180286407,
0.10144747048616409,
0.19312216341495514,
0.43197008967399597,
-0.5560152530670166,
0.47876057028770447,
0.007928549312055111,
-0.30568990111351013,
-0.3628707230091095,
0.5273341536521912,
-0.8165336847305298,
-0.41398856043815613,
0.8295122385025024,
-0.0964616909623146,
-0.5785260200500488,
0.5550076961517334,
-0.0524914488196373,
0.380598783493042,
-0.3130648136138916,
0.6214337348937988,
0.278731107711792,
0.061547763645648956,
-0.3512944281101227,
-0.4397222697734833,
0.17359651625156403,
0.19749346375465393,
-0.6417796015739441,
-0.19827818870544434,
0.24607861042022705,
0.2379094511270523,
0.17863993346691132,
0.029048817232251167,
-0.001186918350867927,
0.4563974440097809,
-0.1231708750128746,
0.299491286277771,
-0.06093618646264076,
-0.437123566865921,
0.20646724104881287,
-0.0928751677274704,
0.34289512038230896,
-0.637702465057373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00908v1 | FineSurE: Fine-grained Summarization Evaluation using LLMs | 2024-07-01T02:20:28 | 2024-07-01T02:20:28 | Hwanjun Song, Hang Su, Igor Shalyminov, Jason Cai, Saab Mansour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automated evaluation is crucial for streamlining text summarization
benchmarking and model development, given the costly and time-consuming nature
of human evaluation. Traditional methods like ROUGE do not correlate well with
human judgment, while recently proposed LLM-based metrics provide only
summary-level assessment using Likert-scale scores. This limits deeper model
analysis, e.g., we can only assign one hallucination score at the summary
level, while at the sentence level, we can count sentences containing
hallucinations. To remedy those limitations, we propose FineSurE, a
fine-grained evaluator specifically tailored for the summarization task using
large language models (LLMs). It also employs completeness and conciseness
criteria, in addition to faithfulness, enabling multi-dimensional assessment.
We compare various open-source and proprietary LLMs as backbones for FineSurE.
In addition, we conduct extensive benchmarking of FineSurE against SOTA methods
including NLI-, QA-, and LLM-based methods, showing improved performance
especially on the completeness and conciseness dimensions. The code is
available at https://github.com/DISL-Lab/FineSurE-ACL24. | [
-0.25129279494285583,
-0.7383484840393066,
0.6464585661888123,
0.36864230036735535,
-0.26688480377197266,
-0.18162396550178528,
-0.24586011469364166,
-0.32387417554855347,
0.34777358174324036,
0.575885534286499,
-0.2568209767341614,
-0.538676917552948,
-0.5428006649017334,
0.33696281909942627,
-0.495986670255661,
1.2584854364395142,
-0.10722019523382187,
0.1425553858280182,
-0.47109583020210266,
-0.07118609547615051,
-0.20646421611309052,
-0.4072646498680115,
-0.47624680399894714,
-0.4290834963321686,
0.35494357347488403,
0.4060003459453583,
0.33124998211860657,
0.4603245258331299,
0.8841826319694519,
0.3370155990123749,
-0.07927515357732773,
0.3488369584083557,
-0.7287867665290833,
0.09442556649446487,
-0.23833636939525604,
-0.2390040159225464,
-0.7741292119026184,
-0.14237436652183533,
0.4699510931968689,
0.5594757199287415,
-0.10359025746583939,
0.37602823972702026,
0.2296602874994278,
0.9486874341964722,
-0.8487286567687988,
-0.0009410555358044803,
-0.33788973093032837,
-0.12275765091180801,
0.0529232881963253,
-0.5425488352775574,
-0.203292116522789,
-0.5793136358261108,
0.22975806891918182,
-0.2861165404319763,
0.14335405826568604,
-0.23603440821170807,
0.7971897125244141,
0.4906435012817383,
-0.1517719328403473,
-0.24842128157615662,
-0.6376742720603943,
0.7398815751075745,
-0.671475887298584,
0.11559504270553589,
0.3239783048629761,
0.39156395196914673,
0.09396018832921982,
-0.9440202116966248,
-0.22088629007339478,
-0.5874611139297485,
0.013099540024995804,
0.45626014471054077,
-0.1471390426158905,
0.024028921499848366,
-0.11640128493309021,
0.8587324619293213,
-0.5053238868713379,
0.08001406490802765,
-0.3507796823978424,
-0.1690337359905243,
0.9544158577919006,
0.6279107928276062,
0.04278015345335007,
-0.29746511578559875,
-0.3565385341644287,
0.003710046410560608,
-0.21091267466545105,
-0.04075922816991806,
0.4030318260192871,
0.3108583986759186,
-0.1522720754146576,
0.5861842036247253,
-0.43324416875839233,
0.41094842553138733,
-0.17491576075553894,
0.026415646076202393,
0.13959048688411713,
-0.38193970918655396,
-0.4180923402309418,
-0.11952050775289536,
0.9427978992462158,
0.9059163928031921,
0.37834158539772034,
-0.24251914024353027,
-0.5039061903953552,
0.11049680411815643,
0.3692363500595093,
-1.1505728960037231,
-0.2551023066043854,
0.47681304812431335,
-0.4520583748817444,
-0.5679680705070496,
0.1780499815940857,
-1.0718498229980469,
-0.6987351775169373,
-0.32001155614852905,
0.462899774312973,
-0.25694167613983154,
0.24149642884731293,
0.35897138714790344,
-0.2918015420436859,
-0.08975836634635925,
0.5338078737258911,
-0.835559606552124,
0.9080694317817688,
0.7235836982727051,
0.9880854487419128,
-0.5838853120803833,
-0.4820335805416107,
-0.7990893721580505,
-0.1723087728023529,
-0.1291619837284088,
1.1607489585876465,
-0.2020719051361084,
-0.3345506489276886,
-0.22401200234889984,
-0.13620059192180634,
0.05601389706134796,
-0.6974438428878784,
0.5907885432243347,
-0.06853041052818298,
-0.0922638475894928,
0.0038383377250283957,
-0.6090089678764343,
-0.38947275280952454,
0.3727748990058899,
-0.6126229166984558,
0.7636492848396301,
0.15745358169078827,
-0.6724156737327576,
-0.004847227595746517,
-0.48583686351776123,
-0.4111727476119995,
-0.006986027117818594,
-0.10733374208211899,
-0.4471783936023712,
0.36308735609054565,
0.07329339534044266,
0.6368040442466736,
-0.3356449007987976,
0.2696603238582611,
-0.16122967004776,
-0.7800354361534119,
0.19294346868991852,
-0.5264752507209778,
0.47044169902801514,
-0.029368840157985687,
-0.22475425899028778,
0.5656249523162842,
-0.7581911683082581,
-0.2612663209438324,
0.10833784937858582,
-0.25594112277030945,
-0.27632957696914673,
0.018429407849907875,
0.40794992446899414,
-0.2982078790664673,
0.4397996962070465,
-0.09755470603704453,
-0.010586217977106571,
-0.5076081156730652,
0.2780146598815918,
0.7080538868904114,
0.12742841243743896,
0.1904928833246231,
-0.6825149655342102,
0.426078200340271,
-0.4644787609577179,
-0.04107608646154404,
-0.19159802794456482,
0.013016937300562859,
-0.7889828085899353,
-0.46600475907325745,
0.36414602398872375,
0.7774178385734558,
-0.06074509024620056,
0.4676611125469208,
-0.37818703055381775,
-0.6989108920097351,
-0.32829517126083374,
0.017878862097859383,
0.41427361965179443,
0.03631172701716423,
0.4259921610355377,
-0.3341015875339508,
-0.6073237061500549,
-0.8504601120948792,
-0.3233245611190796,
0.13674557209014893,
-0.24568834900856018,
0.40275847911834717,
0.7433746457099915,
-0.362479031085968,
0.6651367545127869,
-0.6194993853569031,
-0.7384393215179443,
-0.5370438098907471,
0.06631331890821457,
-0.08120367676019669,
0.23435355722904205,
0.5158210396766663,
-0.3738308250904083,
-0.22329571843147278,
0.0534529946744442,
-0.6037247776985168,
-0.3444816470146179,
-0.18453340232372284,
0.2491321861743927,
0.1718311309814453,
0.5779077410697937,
-0.248445063829422,
0.28618186712265015,
0.534125030040741,
-0.19184495508670807,
0.8369299173355103,
-0.3750942349433899,
0.40435436367988586,
-0.850399374961853,
0.2655852735042572,
0.13560625910758972,
-0.5248855948448181,
-0.3974486291408539,
0.30975520610809326,
-0.08610685169696808,
0.22586868703365326,
-0.42563581466674805,
0.732089102268219,
0.0278079342097044,
-0.2267589569091797,
-0.26427870988845825,
0.7257338762283325,
0.20303013920783997,
0.4565069079399109,
-0.3005216717720032,
0.72637939453125,
0.23997238278388977,
-0.7122678756713867,
0.33284834027290344,
-0.003532903268933296,
-0.3342950642108917,
0.4803756773471832,
-0.8405324816703796,
-0.10830075293779373,
-0.09308261424303055,
0.17640942335128784,
-0.9243186712265015,
-0.4745960235595703,
-0.03537140041589737,
-0.19619889557361603,
0.08626499027013779,
0.18376876413822174,
-0.40733927488327026,
0.07585888355970383,
-0.9432423114776611,
0.23508058488368988,
0.1972513347864151,
-0.30293628573417664,
0.6164838075637817,
0.5723926424980164,
-0.1913272887468338,
-0.3033667206764221,
-0.7799956798553467,
0.16556648910045624,
-0.3421107828617096,
-0.358108788728714,
0.4848698675632477,
-0.1656150370836258,
-0.7259050607681274,
-0.2764451801776886,
-0.2920234799385071,
0.001658715889789164,
0.2865360975265503,
0.0901670828461647,
0.2882894277572632,
0.034170109778642654,
-0.06578155606985092,
0.07724819332361221,
-0.2772582769393921,
-0.039505258202552795,
0.09711326658725739,
0.6339674592018127,
-0.5940908193588257,
-0.08578576892614365,
-0.6125767827033997,
0.10365325212478638,
0.6494371891021729,
-0.10639849305152893,
0.10197135806083679,
0.30097171664237976,
-0.3966097831726074,
-0.047900691628456116,
-0.5488874316215515,
-0.05339241772890091,
-0.3535766005516052,
0.62859708070755,
-0.1728116124868393,
-0.7253342270851135,
0.6034842133522034,
-0.019684845581650734,
0.2357027381658554,
0.6974424719810486,
0.6486374139785767,
0.010957637801766396,
0.5869356989860535,
0.5843814611434937,
-0.02926464192569256,
0.21391424536705017,
-0.3684000074863434,
-0.22249004244804382,
-0.758927047252655,
0.029509752988815308,
-0.44378507137298584,
-0.1954963058233261,
-0.337775319814682,
-0.08432132750749588,
0.1032925695180893,
0.1270378679037094,
0.03185097873210907,
0.2162560522556305,
-0.36974015831947327,
0.6520934104919434,
0.10602309554815292,
0.006483383476734161,
0.6722412705421448,
-0.23817475140094757,
0.2763373553752899,
0.0737776830792427,
-0.16248707473278046,
-0.9154019951820374,
0.9144245386123657,
0.4557490050792694,
0.7701564431190491,
0.05563286319375038,
0.7309955358505249,
0.6403111815452576,
0.32329726219177246,
-1.1555696725845337,
0.6033713221549988,
-0.662786066532135,
0.12376108020544052,
-0.46770092844963074,
-0.5184281468391418,
-0.7972152829170227,
0.41122451424598694,
-0.04613253474235535,
-0.8835268616676331,
-0.18282853066921234,
-0.0010639785323292017,
-0.8146393299102783,
-0.021007249131798744,
-0.5614798069000244,
0.8550665974617004,
-0.10458771884441376,
-0.13799232244491577,
-0.3379097878932953,
-0.2945081293582916,
0.6080732345581055,
-0.2246989607810974,
0.059229981154203415,
-0.20621101558208466,
-0.09358859062194824,
0.8407241702079773,
-0.46365469694137573,
0.7015985250473022,
0.2481982260942459,
-0.11472349613904953,
0.10048843175172806,
0.250092089176178,
0.30192187428474426,
0.1932857483625412,
0.0809282436966896,
0.35788536071777344,
0.3282875418663025,
0.07521393895149231,
-0.623676598072052,
0.8089566230773926,
-0.477794349193573,
-0.3896102011203766,
-0.29931145906448364,
-0.6331511735916138,
0.07111887633800507,
0.16122275590896606,
0.2938717305660248,
0.5576003789901733,
-0.3640070855617523,
0.1116165891289711,
0.3296535909175873,
-0.14669007062911987,
0.31839218735694885,
0.32487717270851135,
-0.5487269163131714,
-0.5924563407897949,
1.028052806854248,
0.030884886160492897,
0.05885094031691551,
0.3498302698135376,
0.46720749139785767,
-0.02310459315776825,
-0.6040030121803284,
-0.2917623221874237,
0.10306026041507721,
-0.5482498407363892,
-0.30435317754745483,
-0.7084135413169861,
-0.3435308635234833,
-0.24264900386333466,
-0.28679534792900085,
-0.45677101612091064,
-0.5567413568496704,
-0.23863020539283752,
-0.018912402912974358,
0.1434270441532135,
0.709278404712677,
0.16209948062896729,
0.3010217249393463,
-0.8194411993026733,
0.5866947770118713,
0.16540227830410004,
0.5294405221939087,
0.03428269550204277,
-0.7031126022338867,
-0.22210869193077087,
-0.28914913535118103,
-0.38399478793144226,
-0.6258053183555603,
0.3384959101676941,
0.0028516093734651804,
0.2755381166934967,
0.4094295799732208,
0.08355946093797684,
0.8337904810905457,
-0.45873111486434937,
0.6909222602844238,
-0.145589679479599,
-1.0560364723205566,
0.3972747027873993,
-0.17986615002155304,
0.18340535461902618,
0.9667189717292786,
-0.04038569703698158,
-0.45167112350463867,
-0.6898432374000549,
-0.35731834173202515,
-0.8002075552940369,
0.52848881483078,
0.27102500200271606,
0.00983805488795042,
0.02458845265209675,
0.148145392537117,
0.21482448279857635,
-0.03906332328915596,
-0.4854077696800232,
-0.24056269228458405,
0.02654697187244892,
-0.2808758318424225,
-0.19249571859836578,
-0.5262517929077148,
0.039530880749225616,
0.04107917845249176,
0.6129767298698425,
0.03502632677555084,
-0.16230961680412292,
0.4325459599494934,
-0.31246405839920044,
0.05579819530248642,
0.14883092045783997,
0.9481582641601562,
0.6763219833374023,
-0.44567498564720154,
0.11492116004228592,
0.49500954151153564,
-0.7006453275680542,
-0.24971835315227509,
0.2515847086906433,
-0.1327688843011856,
0.03512877598404884,
0.5067124962806702,
0.45456770062446594,
0.31548288464546204,
-1.0449321269989014,
0.7935773134231567,
-0.4197235405445099,
-0.26619967818260193,
-0.43101054430007935,
0.11957845836877823,
-0.282085657119751,
0.38561901450157166,
0.11646318435668945,
0.11067460477352142,
0.666490375995636,
-0.21828468143939972,
0.2790677547454834,
0.22603732347488403,
-0.5087742805480957,
-0.11858668923377991,
0.5230619311332703,
0.10595238953828812,
-0.3488309383392334,
0.1802223026752472,
-0.22352083027362823,
-0.19672779738903046,
0.5561635494232178,
0.2267901748418808,
1.2165236473083496,
-0.19084587693214417,
0.04047683998942375,
0.3121083080768585,
0.2703361213207245,
-0.22760188579559326,
0.19224382936954498,
-0.024595336988568306,
-0.35768574476242065,
-0.4960413873195648,
-0.7797823548316956,
-0.48754337430000305,
0.33237454295158386,
-0.6115961670875549,
0.4599296450614929,
-0.2834206223487854,
-0.00722220353782177,
-0.07296116650104523,
0.1034265086054802,
-0.10447821021080017,
-0.05469895899295807,
-0.04810633882880211,
0.937171220779419,
-0.6187114119529724,
0.12379919737577438,
0.3873993754386902,
-0.36531293392181396,
-0.10823382437229156,
0.20049531757831573,
0.015174394473433495,
-0.3025607466697693,
0.1283317506313324,
0.5165740251541138,
-0.4226696193218231,
-0.12670743465423584,
-0.2964319586753845,
-0.49000486731529236,
1.015779972076416,
0.28025710582733154,
-0.47313952445983887,
0.03667789325118065,
-0.22945305705070496,
0.5413169264793396,
-0.10813222825527191,
0.33284422755241394,
0.9691674709320068,
0.34007588028907776,
-0.15512032806873322,
-0.8830379247665405,
-0.03478290140628815,
-0.21121248602867126,
-0.08496502041816711,
-0.01889626309275627,
-0.5816502571105957,
0.54280686378479,
-0.3080741763114929,
-0.30184271931648254,
0.3455321490764618,
0.718781054019928,
0.41684380173683167,
0.4838263690471649,
0.23054371774196625,
0.4046117961406708,
0.83636075258255,
0.05081063508987427,
1.1756118535995483,
-0.3100515604019165,
0.6203382015228271,
1.4844087362289429,
-0.09411647170782089,
0.7838712334632874,
0.2672289311885834,
-0.18223629891872406,
0.24241888523101807,
0.5102917551994324,
-0.2878997325897217,
0.3207935690879822,
0.5289026498794556,
0.07885265350341797,
-0.00036107614869251847,
0.0072466121055185795,
0.002133619273081422,
0.5083885788917542,
0.23774443566799164,
-0.13218121230602264,
-0.45904555916786194,
-0.1465626209974289,
-0.003163487184792757,
0.30943456292152405,
-0.49022525548934937,
0.8401129841804504,
0.1771950125694275,
-0.5199564099311829,
0.38820335268974304,
0.320178747177124,
0.6750955581665039,
-0.4356265664100647,
0.02880697138607502,
-0.4328468143939972,
0.27933573722839355,
-0.4239867925643921,
-0.6812188029289246,
0.5187967419624329,
0.2992713749408722,
0.05271375924348831,
0.14184531569480896,
0.513213574886322,
-0.2007029950618744,
-0.40796035528182983,
0.2275228202342987,
0.37827789783477783,
0.6076963543891907,
-0.23358240723609924,
-0.2584874629974365,
0.06435565650463104,
-0.23862238228321075,
-0.34500816464424133,
0.130933478474617,
0.27785059809684753,
-0.1696471869945526,
0.6909899115562439,
0.37725648283958435,
0.1308346390724182,
-0.38770902156829834,
0.7527155876159668,
0.5901241302490234,
-0.5679662227630615,
-0.3999424874782562,
-1.4478743076324463,
0.453156977891922,
-0.020599527284502983,
-0.3092444837093353,
0.747164249420166,
0.9718611240386963,
0.5961424708366394,
-0.06235366314649582,
0.6271116733551025,
0.35686466097831726,
0.2205880731344223,
-0.6011221408843994,
0.8769159317016602,
-0.6083893775939941,
0.2523996829986572,
-0.5886980891227722,
-0.9916067719459534,
-0.6514787077903748,
0.5818526744842529,
-0.18665876984596252,
-0.044663503766059875,
0.8466506004333496,
0.5413358211517334,
0.13483013212680817,
-0.0776514932513237,
0.4587693214416504,
0.1191398948431015,
0.16722078621387482,
0.31126275658607483,
0.8456429839134216,
-0.4488988220691681,
0.5233024954795837,
-0.12298973649740219,
-0.4682576060295105,
-0.4506610333919525,
-0.7916669249534607,
-1.1118100881576538,
-0.40679824352264404,
-0.2756122648715973,
-0.16504013538360596,
-0.09901104867458344,
0.8777986168861389,
0.1913277506828308,
-0.8097154498100281,
-0.45269179344177246,
-0.10950925201177597,
0.016493551433086395,
-0.3830271065235138,
-0.2799980044364929,
0.5659536719322205,
-0.556757926940918,
-0.8967812061309814,
0.1432357132434845,
0.6944993138313293,
0.1387263834476471,
-0.545603334903717,
-0.05290926992893219,
0.29151809215545654,
0.347867876291275,
0.7241504788398743,
-0.20563501119613647,
-0.7381372451782227,
-0.08039908856153488,
-0.17518475651741028,
-0.36420610547065735,
-0.005665982607752085,
0.6467803716659546,
-0.5564787983894348,
0.1883077174425125,
0.5752294063568115,
0.6307306289672852,
0.3771815001964569,
0.20623177289962769,
0.40697741508483887,
-0.3922213912010193,
-0.22168824076652527,
0.1423691064119339,
0.4948822259902954,
0.20988692343235016,
-0.3992902934551239,
0.58779376745224,
-0.020955977961421013,
-0.534394383430481,
-0.9502182006835938,
-0.026843803003430367,
-1.081072211265564,
-0.20580357313156128,
1.1505215167999268,
0.033160243183374405,
-0.20481206476688385,
0.05052971839904785,
-0.3483507037162781,
0.10550455749034882,
-0.25924238562583923,
1.0626094341278076,
0.5627050399780273,
-0.12416812777519226,
0.11966243386268616,
-0.6027440428733826,
0.4843684732913971,
0.1731291562318802,
-1.1022732257843018,
0.3601754605770111,
0.42885321378707886,
0.023424258455634117,
0.24132563173770905,
0.7454063892364502,
-0.2091819941997528,
0.3127650022506714,
-0.1497797667980194,
0.15942545235157013,
-0.20634551346302032,
-0.49832794070243835,
-0.694524884223938,
0.08176974952220917,
-0.28735291957855225,
-0.006762044504284859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00902v1 | From Introspection to Best Practices: Principled Analysis of Demonstrations in Multimodal In-Context Learning | 2024-07-01T01:57:21 | 2024-07-01T01:57:21 | Nan Xu, Fei Wang, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Muhao Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Motivated by in-context learning (ICL) capabilities of Large Language models
(LLMs), multimodal LLMs with additional visual modality are also exhibited with
similar ICL abilities when multiple image-text pairs are provided as
demonstrations. However, relatively less work has been done to investigate the
principles behind how and why multimodal ICL works. We conduct a systematic and
principled evaluation of multimodal ICL for models of different scales on a
broad spectrum of new yet critical tasks. Through perturbations over different
modality information, we show that modalities matter differently across tasks
in multimodal ICL. Considering such modality impact, we further utilize
modality-driven demonstration strategies to boost ICL performance. We also
identify that demonstration selection is closely related to the models' ability
to capture task inductive biases from multimodal ICL. Our principled analysis
provides a comprehensive way of understanding the role of demonstrations in
multimodal in-context learning, and sheds light on effectively improving
multimodal ICL on a wide range of tasks even if those tasks are not seen in or
even contradict pretraining data. | [
-0.4741588234901428,
-0.7283318042755127,
0.4817194640636444,
0.23927175998687744,
-0.2876105308532715,
-0.15389284491539001,
-0.38782981038093567,
-0.08676976710557938,
-0.42211851477622986,
0.12858182191848755,
-0.2999436557292938,
-0.3123910427093506,
-0.48695889115333557,
-0.07890719920396805,
-0.32435181736946106,
1.0406678915023804,
-0.08840328454971313,
0.29153040051460266,
-0.634503960609436,
-0.22817547619342804,
-0.3953341543674469,
-0.34079277515411377,
-0.29789596796035767,
-0.29693517088890076,
0.1270226389169693,
0.7166209816932678,
0.26020848751068115,
0.3574520945549011,
0.3683363199234009,
0.2596232295036316,
-0.0006007662159390748,
0.30545279383659363,
-0.3770214915275574,
0.09152325242757797,
-0.016932308673858643,
-0.34360966086387634,
0.1278739869594574,
0.17660745978355408,
0.8734127283096313,
0.7834823727607727,
0.10750339925289154,
-0.0016414629062637687,
0.44542258977890015,
0.11675122380256653,
-0.7594059705734253,
0.11629123985767365,
-0.34142932295799255,
0.07542511820793152,
-0.04170197248458862,
-0.21549013257026672,
-0.6697542667388916,
-0.024945320561528206,
0.22947297990322113,
-0.33322370052337646,
-0.011715194210410118,
-0.0953994020819664,
0.538135826587677,
0.03668605536222458,
-1.1183480024337769,
-0.2694593071937561,
-0.6883273720741272,
0.8622239828109741,
-0.6048689484596252,
0.50763338804245,
0.1777048408985138,
0.34036171436309814,
-0.029941026121377945,
-0.8797244429588318,
-0.5192699432373047,
-0.8210204839706421,
-0.2666812837123871,
0.015300718136131763,
0.09297575056552887,
0.21936367452144623,
0.5689764618873596,
0.2803880274295807,
-0.18886558711528778,
0.009939685463905334,
-0.12443634867668152,
-0.19542710483074188,
0.22188054025173187,
-0.05182470381259918,
0.24139057099819183,
-0.17373786866664886,
-0.8776199221611023,
-0.283850759267807,
-0.79074627161026,
0.49392783641815186,
-0.029720578342676163,
-0.060055211186409,
-0.24221199750900269,
0.36670565605163574,
-0.14271479845046997,
0.5581648349761963,
0.06921790540218353,
-0.5577611923217773,
0.061959389597177505,
-0.5233266949653625,
-0.2526443898677826,
-0.33476436138153076,
0.6032947897911072,
0.4948018491268158,
-0.2643938958644867,
-0.22594745457172394,
-0.3598918914794922,
-0.11169164627790451,
-0.010788433253765106,
-0.8301292061805725,
0.0937388464808464,
-0.1462959349155426,
-0.8304969072341919,
-0.11142938584089279,
0.013118287548422813,
-0.5984479188919067,
-0.3594203293323517,
-0.6460347771644592,
0.9974957704544067,
-0.5732136964797974,
-0.44119569659233093,
-0.18286968767642975,
-0.2829967439174652,
0.08912359178066254,
0.3742510676383972,
-0.5975678563117981,
0.36535775661468506,
0.48609891533851624,
0.5498586893081665,
-0.1150556430220604,
-0.412333220243454,
-0.5494239330291748,
0.12256661802530289,
-0.3396981358528137,
0.4586195945739746,
-0.5534465909004211,
-0.32016441226005554,
0.027702566236257553,
0.014836505986750126,
-0.3170887231826782,
-0.46926504373550415,
0.40488478541374207,
-0.26991957426071167,
0.15210048854351044,
-0.45754310488700867,
-0.5918648838996887,
-0.46528133749961853,
0.32382723689079285,
-0.4651872515678406,
0.5605953335762024,
-0.11856123805046082,
-0.495391309261322,
0.8005842566490173,
-0.8914534449577332,
-0.48278874158859253,
-0.14726927876472473,
-0.4010971784591675,
0.06244676932692528,
0.25205227732658386,
-0.014090582728385925,
0.7436990737915039,
-0.18695257604122162,
0.27378541231155396,
-0.03866652771830559,
-0.2866811752319336,
0.5811190009117126,
-0.6388502717018127,
0.5518832802772522,
0.36463525891304016,
-0.6726507544517517,
0.292894184589386,
-0.6684675812721252,
-0.06038525328040123,
-0.23369914293289185,
-0.252958744764328,
-0.3277122676372528,
0.10491331666707993,
0.194365993142128,
0.42993056774139404,
-0.1011456772685051,
-0.3573397696018219,
0.006470079533755779,
0.002611594507470727,
0.42193928360939026,
0.6126079559326172,
-0.003120380686596036,
0.46420392394065857,
-0.2909892499446869,
0.502481997013092,
0.07487428188323975,
0.38169899582862854,
-0.6455701589584351,
-0.024625610560178757,
-0.6915491819381714,
-0.50315260887146,
-0.02310294657945633,
-0.09004245698451996,
-0.8607429265975952,
-0.3282051980495453,
-0.05594358965754509,
-0.26800060272216797,
-0.11201470345258713,
0.21724309027194977,
0.8218101859092712,
0.6366559863090515,
0.23798559606075287,
-0.38590964674949646,
-0.11973681300878525,
-1.170346736907959,
0.08017881959676743,
-0.060766465961933136,
0.3550408184528351,
0.19334425032138824,
0.4881229102611542,
-0.017292717471718788,
0.6129627227783203,
0.1665157675743103,
-0.07264705002307892,
-0.46914464235305786,
0.40811818838119507,
-0.14478181302547455,
0.48471295833587646,
0.6987990140914917,
-0.9972745180130005,
-0.5658667683601379,
0.039425067603588104,
-0.6441984176635742,
0.07270167768001556,
-0.38002821803092957,
0.09735605120658875,
0.051437005400657654,
0.8127025961875916,
-0.3249947726726532,
0.31551286578178406,
0.3624323904514313,
-0.2599833607673645,
0.4364263415336609,
-0.29180285334587097,
0.39429324865341187,
-0.8481140732765198,
-0.2701859772205353,
0.1284138709306717,
-0.12755469977855682,
-0.7515856027603149,
0.5239446759223938,
0.45254939794540405,
0.17200811207294464,
-0.5308701992034912,
0.33439818024635315,
-0.4777142107486725,
-0.02900516800582409,
-0.24979183077812195,
0.02194461226463318,
0.0410945788025856,
0.40715330839157104,
-0.030315091833472252,
0.8194493055343628,
0.7594875693321228,
-0.7283156514167786,
0.004061299376189709,
-0.030336273834109306,
-0.5021542310714722,
0.5879405736923218,
-0.3851207196712494,
0.0004961829981766641,
-0.14090025424957275,
0.252977579832077,
-1.4362623691558838,
-0.22124846279621124,
-0.021870139986276627,
0.009204310365021229,
0.5814892649650574,
-0.1552763134241104,
-0.4529869258403778,
0.22290122509002686,
-0.36968183517456055,
0.4604697823524475,
0.329935222864151,
-0.7187210917472839,
0.5787368416786194,
0.13726890087127686,
0.24687470495700836,
-0.6160100102424622,
-0.4102274477481842,
0.07554226368665695,
-0.381522536277771,
-0.4591000974178314,
0.3125114440917969,
-0.2841925323009491,
-0.5001980066299438,
-0.44719672203063965,
0.10186827182769775,
0.06464892625808716,
0.2873481214046478,
0.28574761748313904,
0.013741600327193737,
-0.0961141362786293,
0.29589518904685974,
0.14943468570709229,
0.1312500387430191,
0.01238687802106142,
0.20057328045368195,
0.4411395490169525,
-0.23884497582912445,
-0.7905775308609009,
-0.6507139205932617,
0.4172646999359131,
0.8176626563072205,
-0.17538508772850037,
0.34650883078575134,
0.6137505769729614,
-0.09092257171869278,
0.028133932501077652,
-0.6284922361373901,
-0.3022749722003937,
-0.4137781262397766,
0.5326491594314575,
-0.42366284132003784,
-0.4552432596683502,
0.10436832159757614,
-0.2778787612915039,
0.190002903342247,
-0.07003892213106155,
0.40151554346084595,
-0.157973513007164,
1.0661036968231201,
0.8776911497116089,
0.28975293040275574,
0.6402706503868103,
-0.5075582265853882,
-0.0406058244407177,
-0.9921923279762268,
-0.3656321167945862,
-0.12365324795246124,
-0.3210766911506653,
-0.276116281747818,
-0.4549744427204132,
0.6830665469169617,
0.11345554143190384,
-0.05333799868822098,
0.08661824464797974,
0.034228354692459106,
0.4557609260082245,
0.5719130039215088,
0.3268977999687195,
0.22884653508663177,
-0.05269521847367287,
-0.4316680133342743,
-0.22238031029701233,
-0.548747718334198,
-0.705249547958374,
1.1185179948806763,
0.3351755142211914,
0.8328720331192017,
0.3077862560749054,
0.41788583993911743,
0.06519763171672821,
0.506682813167572,
-0.7568863034248352,
0.6753004193305969,
0.05545904114842415,
-0.4013357162475586,
-0.16229917109012604,
0.09687101095914841,
-0.4762447476387024,
0.6239908933639526,
-0.25959348678588867,
-0.4244873523712158,
0.2286854088306427,
0.29901206493377686,
-0.043362654745578766,
0.16344290971755981,
-0.912074625492096,
0.9809897541999817,
-0.3791466951370239,
-0.5833221673965454,
-0.5801221132278442,
-0.8127241730690002,
0.41345739364624023,
0.36298686265945435,
0.3787497878074646,
0.34332266449928284,
-0.1175575703382492,
0.3963589072227478,
0.02275168150663376,
1.0262295007705688,
-0.33166342973709106,
-0.07458474487066269,
-0.027247102931141853,
0.32369741797447205,
0.31655949354171753,
-0.027089301496744156,
0.2718539535999298,
-0.35387852787971497,
-0.1054762452840805,
-0.09692785888910294,
-0.6573967337608337,
0.5925214886665344,
-0.450682669878006,
-0.41675543785095215,
0.041718702763319016,
-0.5692372918128967,
-0.3940892517566681,
-0.12334492057561874,
0.12723131477832794,
1.1902964115142822,
-0.16482120752334595,
0.7360448241233826,
0.9430550336837769,
-0.045933861285448074,
0.8373362421989441,
0.3877577781677246,
-0.03176259994506836,
-0.09820155054330826,
0.752886176109314,
-0.032831575721502304,
0.8990823030471802,
0.5635740160942078,
0.27921900153160095,
-0.31604281067848206,
-0.7385271191596985,
-0.3405093252658844,
-0.005753008648753166,
-1.2628059387207031,
0.17203626036643982,
-0.7655948996543884,
0.24755991995334625,
-0.30822575092315674,
-0.11900211870670319,
0.0549708716571331,
-0.3200540542602539,
-0.09276419878005981,
-0.10258321464061737,
-0.1444547027349472,
0.7141414284706116,
-0.14836670458316803,
0.3056304156780243,
-0.30568602681159973,
0.19661736488342285,
0.6973040699958801,
-0.13047312200069427,
0.20601865649223328,
-0.5825307369232178,
-0.14316558837890625,
0.017545418813824654,
-0.6232492327690125,
-0.643735945224762,
0.08970069885253906,
0.4444514811038971,
0.9592298269271851,
0.9289334416389465,
-0.18763023614883423,
0.7508889436721802,
-0.3791956603527069,
0.8980768322944641,
0.27356019616127014,
-1.0039820671081543,
0.4820600748062134,
-0.11409248411655426,
-0.11408700048923492,
0.28725364804267883,
0.5601556301116943,
-0.6264182925224304,
-0.3050159513950348,
-0.4666852056980133,
-0.5585224628448486,
0.47415754199028015,
-0.18550322949886322,
0.279390811920166,
-0.018207496032118797,
-0.007370515260845423,
0.3787420094013214,
0.3467865586280823,
-0.982708752155304,
-0.09990925341844559,
-0.39636534452438354,
-0.1749584972858429,
-0.19432629644870758,
-0.44462454319000244,
-0.6379924416542053,
-0.24317102134227753,
0.285769522190094,
-0.4622338116168976,
0.1142783835530281,
0.08871268481016159,
-0.6168968081474304,
0.160171777009964,
0.42909643054008484,
1.0654393434524536,
1.042685627937317,
0.08487656712532043,
0.28102487325668335,
0.13330332934856415,
-0.14569687843322754,
0.08431385457515717,
-0.16203317046165466,
0.02044100873172283,
-0.12019237130880356,
0.6770955920219421,
0.9828233122825623,
0.6516832113265991,
-0.8510523438453674,
0.9204119443893433,
0.09155569225549698,
0.03657641261816025,
-0.08729228377342224,
0.006378972437232733,
-0.28832077980041504,
0.46869957447052,
0.38526278734207153,
0.039024967700242996,
0.37480631470680237,
-0.8529056906700134,
0.11418475955724716,
0.7744375467300415,
-0.4214436411857605,
-0.3566931188106537,
0.4892633557319641,
0.007683598902076483,
0.02528417482972145,
0.2745434045791626,
0.08112085610628128,
-0.3701125681400299,
0.6728839874267578,
0.6575738787651062,
0.5680137276649475,
0.08214043080806732,
0.3647991716861725,
0.0661938413977623,
0.19982795417308807,
0.035865668207407,
0.03158215060830116,
-0.6034555435180664,
-0.6147769093513489,
-0.3888430595397949,
-0.04469608888030052,
-0.4220232665538788,
-0.060281865298748016,
-0.7203675508499146,
0.3041243553161621,
-0.32542216777801514,
0.08497054129838943,
-0.09417497366666794,
-0.3438301980495453,
-0.5177956819534302,
0.1625894457101822,
0.2013656497001648,
0.7572768926620483,
-0.9682778120040894,
0.5825777649879456,
0.7414478659629822,
-0.4938034117221832,
-0.7504716515541077,
0.16593177616596222,
0.0883779302239418,
-0.6348652243614197,
1.2472045421600342,
0.08521205931901932,
-0.11752152442932129,
-0.21237026154994965,
-0.7795794010162354,
-0.5667939186096191,
1.2242250442504883,
0.2926945686340332,
-0.13223406672477722,
0.17504523694515228,
-0.22474180161952972,
0.28339847922325134,
-0.6558895111083984,
0.6879444122314453,
0.0639515370130539,
0.35558784008026123,
0.026459066197276115,
-1.0059062242507935,
-0.022248677909374237,
0.04725747928023338,
0.021795889362692833,
-0.23111793398857117,
-0.7721388339996338,
0.8490530848503113,
-0.23557263612747192,
-0.1622924506664276,
0.05963067337870598,
0.4760987460613251,
0.09022273868322372,
0.4301120340824127,
0.7273317575454712,
0.16032187640666962,
0.3608962595462799,
-0.11037507653236389,
1.231769323348999,
-0.12959066033363342,
0.04444620758295059,
0.8238152265548706,
-0.20758281648159027,
0.5857696533203125,
0.8253971338272095,
0.1469414234161377,
0.47304487228393555,
0.4800030589103699,
0.4707387387752533,
0.7629798650741577,
-0.14429660141468048,
-0.3534526526927948,
-0.4587840139865875,
-0.3638579547405243,
-0.21142929792404175,
0.5808486342430115,
0.3479466140270233,
-0.41769611835479736,
-0.3444295823574066,
0.7400546669960022,
-0.11827072501182556,
0.23737601935863495,
-0.19352778792381287,
0.8284901976585388,
-0.2790919244289398,
-0.6424820423126221,
0.3977775275707245,
-0.31619638204574585,
0.6765274405479431,
-0.6544302105903625,
-0.34089359641075134,
-0.23141315579414368,
0.04220091551542282,
0.06734730303287506,
-0.4245736300945282,
-0.30951055884361267,
-0.44646382331848145,
-0.13309137523174286,
-0.6913565993309021,
0.44427865743637085,
-0.44380879402160645,
-0.004541940987110138,
0.08811639994382858,
0.30654317140579224,
0.06027655303478241,
0.17049220204353333,
-0.23703446984291077,
-0.025228168815374374,
-0.06195186451077461,
-0.025541331619024277,
0.5819324254989624,
0.6189705729484558,
-0.18540900945663452,
0.8086549043655396,
0.33935660123825073,
-0.3197615444660187,
0.052699532359838486,
0.13030275702476501,
1.0253103971481323,
-0.3107057809829712,
-0.16755792498588562,
-0.8013209700584412,
0.7455160617828369,
-0.13079695403575897,
-0.4106011986732483,
0.8725099563598633,
0.3826426863670349,
1.0317490100860596,
-0.25895825028419495,
0.49319034814834595,
-0.15657606720924377,
0.3119964897632599,
-0.8602651357650757,
0.4156090021133423,
-0.8338758945465088,
-0.013145001605153084,
-0.39495107531547546,
-0.4160313308238983,
-0.01475189533084631,
0.6313251852989197,
-0.07946927845478058,
-0.05808226764202118,
0.9337064623832703,
0.7971041202545166,
-0.22240658104419708,
-0.0024577744770795107,
0.5800527334213257,
-0.010509117506444454,
0.6421679854393005,
0.19438600540161133,
1.3105216026306152,
-0.23466621339321136,
0.4338308572769165,
-0.6276893019676208,
-0.453738272190094,
-0.25158166885375977,
-1.0736792087554932,
-0.9266671538352966,
-0.96455317735672,
-0.31149065494537354,
-0.0035538380034267902,
-0.32906559109687805,
1.380035638809204,
1.0557348728179932,
-0.37299370765686035,
-0.502719521522522,
0.2445000410079956,
-0.03333215042948723,
-0.5889897346496582,
-0.22328484058380127,
0.10932884365320206,
-0.567366361618042,
-0.7808818817138672,
0.5931726098060608,
0.2016524076461792,
0.06515253335237503,
-0.4486539363861084,
-0.044981420040130615,
-0.1994575411081314,
-0.29254522919654846,
0.9726772904396057,
0.016671186313033104,
-0.9097990393638611,
-0.18053455650806427,
-0.11820128560066223,
0.00036635168362408876,
-0.08560299873352051,
1.253916621208191,
-0.6428096890449524,
0.6223635077476501,
0.2923002243041992,
0.45991384983062744,
0.3431325852870941,
-0.31756311655044556,
0.35207241773605347,
-0.7526732683181763,
0.35338929295539856,
0.10452627390623093,
0.563348114490509,
0.22649043798446655,
-0.025045443326234818,
0.24041053652763367,
0.1426040381193161,
-0.4271593391895294,
-0.8955575227737427,
0.2699565291404724,
-0.8230034112930298,
-0.2971627712249756,
1.2300951480865479,
-0.11991310864686966,
0.18566952645778656,
-0.06260769814252853,
-0.49583369493484497,
-0.08288198709487915,
-0.04985659942030907,
0.6876921057701111,
0.6935872435569763,
-0.2365036904811859,
-0.36317771673202515,
-0.7242032885551453,
0.471124529838562,
0.34180310368537903,
-0.46956631541252136,
-0.018232153728604317,
0.7170292139053345,
0.2237190306186676,
0.055231351405382156,
0.41391265392303467,
-0.07328605651855469,
0.383899986743927,
-0.40613654255867004,
-0.12208829075098038,
-0.09952011704444885,
-0.6307860016822815,
-0.39832982420921326,
0.31931591033935547,
0.285104900598526,
-0.1924775093793869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00900v1 | MathCAMPS: Fine-grained Synthesis of Mathematical Problems From Human Curricula | 2024-07-01T01:56:28 | 2024-07-01T01:56:28 | Shubhra Mishra, Gabriel Poesia, Belinda Mo, Noah D. Goodman | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Mathematical problem solving is an important skill for Large Language Models
(LLMs), both as an important capability and a proxy for a range of reasoning
abilities. Existing benchmarks probe a diverse set of skills, but they yield
aggregate accuracy metrics, obscuring specific abilities or weaknesses.
Furthermore, they are difficult to extend with new problems, risking data
contamination over time. To address these challenges, we propose MathCAMPS: a
method to synthesize high-quality mathematical problems at scale, grounded on
44 fine-grained "standards" from the Mathematics Common Core (CC) Standard for
K-8 grades. We encode each standard in a formal grammar, allowing us to sample
diverse symbolic problems and their answers. We then use LLMs to realize the
symbolic problems into word problems. We propose a cycle-consistency method for
validating problem faithfulness. Finally, we derive follow-up questions from
symbolic structures and convert them into follow-up word problems - a novel
task of mathematical dialogue that probes for robustness in understanding.
Experiments on 23 LLMs show surprising failures even in the strongest models
(in particular when asked simple follow-up questions). Moreover, we evaluate
training checkpoints of Pythia 12B on MathCAMPS, allowing us to analyze when
particular mathematical skills develop during its training. Our framework
enables the community to reproduce and extend our pipeline for a fraction of
the typical cost of building new high-quality datasets. | [
-0.3924158811569214,
-0.8626165986061096,
0.5719614028930664,
0.41947728395462036,
0.21646305918693542,
0.4295646846294403,
-0.3783242106437683,
-0.09211425483226776,
0.00372154638171196,
0.17821276187896729,
-0.7337942719459534,
-0.6125091314315796,
-0.4708263576030731,
-0.13065442442893982,
-0.4495483934879303,
0.7738845348358154,
-0.4270753264427185,
0.11549843102693558,
-0.5921962261199951,
0.06300219148397446,
-0.3700637221336365,
-0.6169590950012207,
-0.5887675881385803,
-0.3733534812927246,
0.307788223028183,
0.33614569902420044,
0.7201871871948242,
0.539897084236145,
0.6885603666305542,
0.25208234786987305,
-0.1272471398115158,
0.1356651335954666,
-0.5116682648658752,
0.04815053939819336,
-0.12678317725658417,
-0.4259090721607208,
-0.27526119351387024,
0.18268413841724396,
0.49664273858070374,
1.4168533086776733,
-0.33955174684524536,
0.33948859572410583,
0.03590692952275276,
0.40528154373168945,
-0.6162033081054688,
0.4225758910179138,
-0.6760765314102173,
0.012520806863904,
-0.16781504452228546,
0.2896457612514496,
-0.21993696689605713,
-0.5486248135566711,
-0.1551455855369568,
-0.8607384562492371,
0.4721165895462036,
-0.21771259605884552,
0.5328271389007568,
0.1527474969625473,
0.1547548472881317,
-0.4341709613800049,
-0.4730367958545685,
1.027443766593933,
-0.4787570834159851,
-0.007880031131207943,
0.6868604421615601,
0.4969179630279541,
-0.5714355111122131,
-0.5855494141578674,
-0.47999075055122375,
0.0403786301612854,
0.18713133037090302,
-0.14185093343257904,
-0.11102007329463959,
-0.30195945501327515,
0.36910101771354675,
0.43131759762763977,
-0.4480661153793335,
-0.17187532782554626,
-0.5901212692260742,
-0.4125507175922394,
0.6555757522583008,
0.6437802314758301,
0.45481395721435547,
0.07954943180084229,
0.3019740581512451,
-0.205277681350708,
-0.7381691932678223,
0.22667311131954193,
0.21671590209007263,
0.16375742852687836,
0.009274187497794628,
0.774841845035553,
-0.204224094748497,
0.41298940777778625,
-0.3879542648792267,
-0.027857234701514244,
-0.07203946262598038,
-0.21374522149562836,
0.08643642067909241,
-0.14749477803707123,
0.4149497449398041,
0.2091042697429657,
0.3396070599555969,
-0.15814435482025146,
-0.40157392621040344,
0.7794219255447388,
-0.00971431564539671,
-0.7420612573623657,
-0.3843890428543091,
-0.10720788687467575,
0.005703069735318422,
-0.3515014350414276,
-0.30809473991394043,
-0.6699650287628174,
-0.18311600387096405,
-0.7005289793014526,
0.3482831120491028,
-0.41133254766464233,
0.1757427155971527,
0.2744441032409668,
0.1649267077445984,
-0.23964452743530273,
0.49234041571617126,
-0.7961521148681641,
0.541122555732727,
0.839295506477356,
0.7513414621353149,
-0.18528050184249878,
-0.47701627016067505,
-0.6397921442985535,
-0.13546723127365112,
-0.5137509107589722,
0.6516797542572021,
-0.6081873774528503,
-0.2977474629878998,
0.11918464303016663,
-0.2638360261917114,
0.13725696504116058,
-0.803077220916748,
0.492246150970459,
-0.18885761499404907,
-0.01939498819410801,
-0.21081700921058655,
-0.4395064115524292,
0.18682409822940826,
0.40001317858695984,
-0.2819894552230835,
1.2516828775405884,
0.4740273952484131,
-0.17981168627738953,
-0.32855677604675293,
-0.2901137173175812,
-0.12002695351839066,
-0.018363533541560173,
-0.2914161682128906,
-0.2524382472038269,
0.4826835095882416,
0.32885849475860596,
0.07113722711801529,
-0.38665658235549927,
0.6613954901695251,
-0.36568349599838257,
-0.18263910710811615,
0.3825143575668335,
-0.32028326392173767,
0.6591135859489441,
0.15647448599338531,
-0.030273014679551125,
-0.12661555409431458,
-0.8513817191123962,
0.3048698306083679,
0.4044639766216278,
-0.15230974555015564,
-0.26692256331443787,
-0.044462911784648895,
-0.16553059220314026,
0.19037877023220062,
0.18927477300167084,
-0.4713744521141052,
0.16813954710960388,
-0.39526405930519104,
0.598906397819519,
0.687741219997406,
-0.23153813183307648,
0.29398393630981445,
-0.565351665019989,
0.44891250133514404,
-0.23301109671592712,
0.08531085401773453,
-0.368692547082901,
-0.5808440446853638,
-0.7805557250976562,
-0.09003208577632904,
0.05707574263215065,
0.17452597618103027,
-0.4020213484764099,
0.14200536906719208,
-0.10897624492645264,
-0.6571969985961914,
-0.3608384132385254,
0.3669539988040924,
0.5404225587844849,
0.39789167046546936,
0.4870399832725525,
-0.3405285179615021,
-0.3554076552391052,
-0.5196261405944824,
-0.40212178230285645,
0.1837962418794632,
-0.2881307601928711,
0.12049861997365952,
0.6137769222259521,
-0.11657601594924927,
1.093368411064148,
-0.9608689546585083,
-0.34172070026397705,
0.06660924851894379,
0.391640305519104,
0.14443275332450867,
0.6108289957046509,
0.2574373781681061,
-0.23373186588287354,
-0.3071775734424591,
-0.2856040596961975,
-0.7512332797050476,
-0.3946704864501953,
0.1826435923576355,
-0.44404393434524536,
-0.2477891892194748,
0.3952261209487915,
-0.7367240786552429,
0.5646991729736328,
0.4797520637512207,
-0.3972625136375427,
0.6422353982925415,
-0.07810071110725403,
-0.24944838881492615,
-0.7350717186927795,
-0.17312704026699066,
-0.04292312636971474,
0.07610782235860825,
-0.3442268669605255,
0.2565913498401642,
-0.21942713856697083,
-0.6449275612831116,
-0.21270330250263214,
0.5935648679733276,
-0.10851174592971802,
-0.24909061193466187,
-0.0013064972590655088,
0.19425040483474731,
0.1125352755188942,
0.5153661370277405,
-0.409829318523407,
0.8046347498893738,
0.4306372106075287,
-0.48205479979515076,
0.48389822244644165,
0.33095782995224,
-0.2945077419281006,
0.5828881859779358,
-0.729154646396637,
0.10151610523462296,
-0.09000810980796814,
0.15962353348731995,
-0.7093880772590637,
-0.3887830376625061,
-0.05390368402004242,
-0.384234756231308,
-0.22083094716072083,
-0.06321561336517334,
-0.5646055936813354,
-0.27478522062301636,
-0.08008070290088654,
0.80812007188797,
0.5877285003662109,
-0.2821744382381439,
0.52728271484375,
0.4825173616409302,
-0.42844271659851074,
0.07047254592180252,
-0.41699570417404175,
-0.03932670131325722,
0.16761884093284607,
-0.6437662839889526,
0.3471600413322449,
-0.3429450988769531,
-0.454158216714859,
0.11543693393468857,
-0.4317742884159088,
-0.383210152387619,
0.09538256376981735,
0.1677262932062149,
0.4218674898147583,
-0.06807764619588852,
0.026147985830903053,
0.1264103651046753,
-0.3168133497238159,
0.35987550020217896,
-0.2927781343460083,
0.6694040298461914,
-0.2640730142593384,
-0.5423009991645813,
-0.22925567626953125,
0.4725615382194519,
0.5842106938362122,
-0.3630618155002594,
0.36783161759376526,
0.2527232766151428,
-0.8706468939781189,
-0.2542341947555542,
-0.3650449216365814,
-0.29590389132499695,
-0.42365485429763794,
0.021080581471323967,
-0.1923082321882248,
-0.7164936661720276,
0.46518826484680176,
-0.23238155245780945,
0.21484993398189545,
0.2442600131034851,
0.5140032768249512,
-0.2500476837158203,
1.0375218391418457,
0.21349000930786133,
0.31899502873420715,
0.2017805427312851,
-0.4096262454986572,
0.14082875847816467,
-0.5910455584526062,
-0.29774871468544006,
-0.5689500570297241,
-0.477441668510437,
-0.05611499026417732,
-0.7552676200866699,
0.39740705490112305,
0.28804638981819153,
-0.3048679828643799,
0.3244701027870178,
-0.4401330053806305,
0.8656578063964844,
0.43258675932884216,
-0.07069434225559235,
0.3873087167739868,
0.38377881050109863,
-0.26323965191841125,
-0.4862785339355469,
-0.30271345376968384,
-0.4493143558502197,
1.009676218032837,
0.014929898083209991,
0.9549219012260437,
0.017392374575138092,
0.6251056790351868,
-0.008338886313140392,
0.44460922479629517,
-0.8380793929100037,
0.6745684742927551,
0.01636352203786373,
-0.6579596400260925,
-0.26901775598526,
-0.714049756526947,
-0.9431955814361572,
0.1751357465982437,
-0.11377698928117752,
-0.6700530052185059,
-0.29217785596847534,
-0.059942301362752914,
-0.302594393491745,
-0.04353611171245575,
-0.6266961097717285,
0.7783604264259338,
0.003618374466896057,
-0.3123156726360321,
-0.42145639657974243,
-0.24764175713062286,
0.28426554799079895,
-0.22092829644680023,
0.5896278023719788,
-0.45216041803359985,
0.42078065872192383,
0.7036981582641602,
-0.6029288172721863,
0.7914991974830627,
0.2127603143453598,
-0.11554961651563644,
0.5559626221656799,
0.658496618270874,
0.35711124539375305,
0.1803884506225586,
0.3299187421798706,
0.015182041563093662,
0.17109215259552002,
-0.5852622985839844,
-0.8701373934745789,
0.8716574907302856,
-0.8471613526344299,
-0.6068649888038635,
-0.3840383291244507,
-1.0765423774719238,
-0.3726036846637726,
0.13028644025325775,
-0.2591104507446289,
0.7031892538070679,
-0.004570410121232271,
-0.0014109566109254956,
0.731469988822937,
-0.1435963660478592,
0.35130321979522705,
0.13791178166866302,
-0.4151654839515686,
-0.6563414335250854,
1.023471474647522,
0.3446156680583954,
0.3058202862739563,
-0.17514090240001678,
0.3343294858932495,
0.0866207629442215,
-0.3152307868003845,
-0.12838728725910187,
0.35589054226875305,
-0.8857081532478333,
-0.357962965965271,
-0.33718782663345337,
-0.2864342927932739,
-0.22915756702423096,
-0.585003137588501,
-0.592147946357727,
-0.7004744410514832,
-0.19087404012680054,
0.226515531539917,
0.04660664498806,
0.49656736850738525,
0.11281324923038483,
0.3069376051425934,
-0.8271557688713074,
0.5103172063827515,
0.3698574900627136,
0.3376900255680084,
-0.14271990954875946,
-0.42736002802848816,
-0.15712012350559235,
0.23712657392024994,
-0.7137166857719421,
-0.4246669113636017,
0.36794614791870117,
0.01881670206785202,
0.31124940514564514,
0.01449698954820633,
-0.055262044072151184,
0.9077048897743225,
-0.5331063270568848,
0.5692099332809448,
0.35997429490089417,
-1.1977434158325195,
0.5614032745361328,
-0.24692124128341675,
0.27501869201660156,
0.5241714119911194,
0.20675449073314667,
-0.4928840398788452,
-0.4812100827693939,
-0.6778330206871033,
-0.5370762944221497,
0.5054140686988831,
0.5904083847999573,
0.341136634349823,
-0.08281345665454865,
0.5190687775611877,
-0.13032609224319458,
0.12110427767038345,
-0.2658706605434418,
0.007915339432656765,
-0.01979411020874977,
-0.6335760951042175,
-0.013637665659189224,
0.013998723588883877,
-0.41902852058410645,
-0.5324949026107788,
0.47572410106658936,
-0.16656368970870972,
-0.0055947015061974525,
-0.043210845440626144,
-0.18946433067321777,
-0.25853458046913147,
0.12890544533729553,
0.6104641556739807,
0.8735040426254272,
0.12791307270526886,
0.3673030734062195,
0.21051162481307983,
-0.6261425614356995,
0.268244206905365,
0.03063204325735569,
-0.07854864001274109,
0.010582962073385715,
0.179914653301239,
0.07999389618635178,
0.4128880500793457,
-0.9457739591598511,
0.2846541702747345,
-0.03967062383890152,
-0.25037094950675964,
-0.39412668347358704,
0.12987126410007477,
0.13400639593601227,
0.07206309586763382,
0.34874066710472107,
0.1720466911792755,
-0.21006689965724945,
-0.5819553732872009,
-0.00900893472135067,
0.31179508566856384,
-0.006496315356343985,
-0.5211758613586426,
0.4174000322818756,
0.04155280813574791,
-0.4539331793785095,
0.7959498167037964,
-0.173298180103302,
-0.41602814197540283,
0.6927697062492371,
0.8138507008552551,
0.3799573481082916,
-0.1261393427848816,
0.15448737144470215,
0.5481258034706116,
0.17641273140907288,
-0.40754616260528564,
0.29828208684921265,
0.25865206122398376,
-0.52491694688797,
-0.5152115225791931,
-0.7518914341926575,
-0.3858540654182434,
-0.10752569139003754,
-0.5945095419883728,
0.35623475909233093,
-0.6599065065383911,
-0.11751092970371246,
-0.028102414682507515,
-0.03053896687924862,
-0.5668728947639465,
0.10873501747846603,
0.0742860808968544,
0.8322187662124634,
-0.6893811821937561,
0.39840808510780334,
0.6464839577674866,
-0.2143821120262146,
-0.912011981010437,
-0.48720958828926086,
-0.012894374318420887,
-0.8307558298110962,
0.5220157504081726,
0.13629789650440216,
0.09642190486192703,
0.19650252163410187,
-0.6847315430641174,
-0.8216201663017273,
0.9920403957366943,
0.6179801821708679,
-0.5520663261413574,
-0.35638540983200073,
0.3244525194168091,
0.4101269543170929,
-0.33594802021980286,
-0.13460150361061096,
0.5094335675239563,
0.2003832757472992,
0.48633578419685364,
-0.7839136123657227,
-0.051101285964250565,
-0.20016375184059143,
0.09867587685585022,
0.31692272424697876,
-0.17102226614952087,
0.9313133358955383,
-0.2606770396232605,
-0.051607199013233185,
0.1359976828098297,
0.5048332214355469,
0.606417179107666,
0.7475444674491882,
0.04068523272871971,
1.0394208431243896,
0.848044216632843,
-0.4265531599521637,
0.8183121085166931,
-0.09164614230394363,
0.645043134689331,
0.9524965286254883,
-0.004747131839394569,
0.6032191514968872,
0.6395168900489807,
-0.35198673605918884,
0.3678041994571686,
0.33077794313430786,
0.10774704068899155,
0.3517935872077942,
0.8403878211975098,
-0.38730496168136597,
-0.685290515422821,
-0.19397501647472382,
-0.4265129864215851,
0.21910665929317474,
0.6371581554412842,
0.05259972810745239,
-0.71656733751297,
-0.145344078540802,
0.08205778896808624,
0.49866828322410583,
-0.493506520986557,
0.22878959774971008,
0.36317557096481323,
-0.6661654710769653,
0.5763063430786133,
0.07429307699203491,
0.07452237606048584,
-0.3817102313041687,
-0.1382591724395752,
-0.49005258083343506,
0.2773965001106262,
-0.11396210640668869,
-0.6838474273681641,
0.5035993456840515,
0.11085422337055206,
-0.07406152784824371,
-0.0022510464768856764,
0.21046671271324158,
-0.39086392521858215,
-0.9344210624694824,
-0.37821823358535767,
0.5698642134666443,
0.16150018572807312,
-0.0323190912604332,
-0.3759308159351349,
0.47181227803230286,
-0.5013260245323181,
0.20198898017406464,
0.5280721187591553,
0.6249985098838806,
-0.39826062321662903,
0.7761533856391907,
1.0566014051437378,
0.07524915784597397,
0.20289655029773712,
-0.008833958767354488,
1.1985503435134888,
-0.53578782081604,
-0.2173427790403366,
-0.7238181829452515,
0.2743452787399292,
0.1106504276394844,
-0.39741116762161255,
0.48693326115608215,
0.4198262393474579,
0.9540656805038452,
0.09541070461273193,
0.47386428713798523,
0.3074982464313507,
-0.03143575042486191,
-0.405856728553772,
0.24996450543403625,
-0.06372858583927155,
0.27258968353271484,
-0.19213762879371643,
-1.0468730926513672,
-0.6010090112686157,
0.9327349662780762,
-0.4100709855556488,
-0.28660330176353455,
0.9094904065132141,
0.6356661915779114,
-0.13521982729434967,
-0.036785367876291275,
0.25948789715766907,
-0.2232842743396759,
0.47318118810653687,
0.8269863724708557,
1.0236490964889526,
-0.4554708003997803,
0.7384788990020752,
-0.23521094024181366,
-0.22754715383052826,
0.06384404003620148,
-0.5924178957939148,
-1.0587069988250732,
-0.33253124356269836,
-0.44271722435951233,
-0.5813586115837097,
-0.19397678971290588,
1.0842078924179077,
0.3176787197589874,
-0.7019107937812805,
-0.23541076481342316,
-0.45951569080352783,
0.148342102766037,
-0.2127448171377182,
-0.1981048732995987,
0.15658926963806152,
-0.714276909828186,
-0.6905155777931213,
0.18739227950572968,
0.1732129603624344,
0.19152024388313293,
-0.31562528014183044,
-0.008727610111236572,
0.45119887590408325,
0.2688171863555908,
0.4524465799331665,
0.11122193187475204,
-0.6430057883262634,
-0.054484084248542786,
0.22041136026382446,
-0.34294310212135315,
-0.1486358940601349,
1.1391382217407227,
-0.6741691827774048,
0.31139376759529114,
0.15056346356868744,
1.0207629203796387,
0.3754618167877197,
-0.22755217552185059,
0.30424630641937256,
-0.476448118686676,
0.08909757435321808,
0.3644343316555023,
0.45726728439331055,
0.22551949322223663,
0.10100968927145004,
0.30796682834625244,
0.6812649369239807,
-0.24291470646858215,
-1.057759404182434,
0.3217966854572296,
-0.6487661004066467,
-0.1393260657787323,
0.9492464661598206,
-0.25665703415870667,
-0.30056247115135193,
-0.02703300677239895,
-0.30853500962257385,
0.01570451445877552,
-0.15612393617630005,
1.275187373161316,
1.1083104610443115,
0.15234705805778503,
0.02714020013809204,
-0.6114020943641663,
0.24312849342823029,
0.45939528942108154,
-0.8501933813095093,
0.18509021401405334,
0.5246890187263489,
0.13098646700382233,
0.3971213102340698,
0.33202555775642395,
-0.3655667006969452,
0.2583712339401245,
-0.022698795422911644,
-0.07824840396642685,
-0.25058066844940186,
-0.41223713755607605,
0.0697610005736351,
0.2223794162273407,
0.07691283524036407,
0.2909351587295532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00894v1 | How to Leverage Digit Embeddings to Represent Numbers? | 2024-07-01T01:31:41 | 2024-07-01T01:31:41 | Jasivan Alex Sivakumar, Nafise Sadat Moosavi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Apart from performing arithmetic operations, understanding numbers themselves
is still a challenge for existing language models. Simple generalisations, such
as solving 100+200 instead of 1+2, can substantially affect model performance
(Sivakumar and Moosavi, 2023). Among various techniques, character-level
embeddings of numbers have emerged as a promising approach to improve number
representation. However, this method has limitations as it leaves the task of
aggregating digit representations to the model, which lacks direct supervision
for this process. In this paper, we explore the use of mathematical priors to
compute aggregated digit embeddings and explicitly incorporate these aggregates
into transformer models. This can be achieved either by adding a special token
to the input embeddings or by introducing an additional loss function to
enhance correct predictions. We evaluate the effectiveness of incorporating
this explicit aggregation, analysing its strengths and shortcomings, and
discuss future directions to better benefit from this approach. Our methods,
while simple, are compatible with any pretrained model and require only a few
lines of code, which we have made publicly available. | [
-0.6542596817016602,
-0.39215001463890076,
0.6987705826759338,
0.2632552683353424,
-0.30233338475227356,
-0.05980844795703888,
0.01839486137032509,
-0.10048065334558487,
0.18113745748996735,
0.6140737533569336,
-0.18469025194644928,
-0.29425081610679626,
-0.7387349605560303,
0.04646005108952522,
-0.21058611571788788,
0.5113352537155151,
0.024301802739501,
0.30752864480018616,
-0.4498688280582428,
-0.23810848593711853,
-0.6405303478240967,
-0.956173300743103,
-0.1517808735370636,
-0.43123090267181396,
0.3405361473560333,
0.04929370805621147,
0.8330448865890503,
0.5050228834152222,
0.8038424253463745,
0.4441622495651245,
-0.05422622710466385,
0.09005094319581985,
-0.2528643310070038,
-0.08989626914262772,
0.10614458471536636,
-0.678749144077301,
-0.5255348682403564,
-0.08037084341049194,
0.6884424686431885,
0.990968644618988,
-0.18468210101127625,
-0.0952129065990448,
-0.13740244507789612,
0.3594103753566742,
-0.6215448379516602,
0.25954288244247437,
-0.39548981189727783,
0.2016768902540207,
-0.17992614209651947,
0.08942440152168274,
-0.8987821340560913,
-0.39707475900650024,
-0.17778974771499634,
-0.4046628773212433,
0.16453701257705688,
-0.2853412926197052,
0.38732707500457764,
0.39641010761260986,
-0.30996954441070557,
-0.3355935513973236,
-0.7916387915611267,
0.7021124362945557,
-0.6854614615440369,
0.6297721862792969,
0.5539907217025757,
0.33529147505760193,
0.3307136297225952,
-0.9479766488075256,
-0.3089035749435425,
0.1375981867313385,
-0.35933199524879456,
0.05333394557237625,
-0.25023409724235535,
-0.14718475937843323,
0.5209234356880188,
0.422318696975708,
-0.2664009928703308,
0.04241952300071716,
-0.4356148838996887,
-0.18257422745227814,
0.5920330882072449,
0.3774901330471039,
0.2424149066209793,
0.3022320866584778,
-0.09798505157232285,
-0.46644648909568787,
-0.8082213401794434,
-0.02075800485908985,
0.1173921599984169,
0.24649299681186676,
-0.35367703437805176,
0.6567587852478027,
0.3827083706855774,
0.5563563704490662,
0.1937319040298462,
0.44065919518470764,
0.3927236497402191,
-0.09889619797468185,
-0.21910832822322845,
-0.049073703587055206,
0.46233421564102173,
-0.21296246349811554,
0.8282350897789001,
-0.1858648657798767,
-0.13086441159248352,
0.31427833437919617,
0.6079673767089844,
-0.985023021697998,
-0.2518126368522644,
-0.1430807262659073,
-0.3385491967201233,
-0.40998172760009766,
0.3727719485759735,
-0.3775075376033783,
-0.29113125801086426,
-0.19985857605934143,
0.5308646559715271,
-0.4429905414581299,
-0.10789656639099121,
0.24220076203346252,
-0.1676459163427353,
0.0572354830801487,
0.41260379552841187,
-1.0373220443725586,
0.4401514530181885,
0.6195188164710999,
0.7271756529808044,
0.46859872341156006,
-0.004891595803201199,
-0.3743516206741333,
-0.06439388543367386,
-0.6330023407936096,
0.5258598327636719,
-0.8882290720939636,
-0.730719804763794,
-0.07834110409021378,
-0.24861924350261688,
0.048145145177841187,
-0.3624730408191681,
0.1684771478176117,
-0.7810793519020081,
0.1711343377828598,
0.08464107662439346,
-0.6710748672485352,
-0.1508362740278244,
-0.21818718314170837,
-1.0453665256500244,
0.606658935546875,
0.24245667457580566,
-0.5549185872077942,
0.12311791628599167,
-0.4675905108451843,
-0.3707045018672943,
0.2186744511127472,
-0.2399878203868866,
-0.5261006355285645,
0.8742498159408569,
0.6771039962768555,
0.4620814323425293,
-0.04201909154653549,
0.2790064811706543,
-0.33340510725975037,
-0.5709586143493652,
0.32380688190460205,
-0.6017125844955444,
0.6792958378791809,
0.12113340944051743,
0.10102560371160507,
-0.19376125931739807,
-0.20251958072185516,
-0.05228330194950104,
0.070902019739151,
0.1440282166004181,
-0.506611168384552,
-0.07573885470628738,
-0.5615598559379578,
0.014826399274170399,
0.03368767350912094,
-0.1786547154188156,
0.27107587456703186,
-0.3992692232131958,
0.18060192465782166,
0.7059245705604553,
-0.15162000060081482,
0.9296378493309021,
-0.05748412758111954,
0.6841650605201721,
0.1795808970928192,
-0.12136092036962509,
-0.9126641750335693,
-0.5636840462684631,
-0.5237747430801392,
-0.012646946124732494,
0.7458662986755371,
0.30691006779670715,
-0.9710017442703247,
0.5003387928009033,
-0.5593046545982361,
-0.5513139963150024,
-0.5832819938659668,
-0.06590338796377182,
0.013128223828971386,
0.055230721831321716,
0.3931054174900055,
-0.2786855399608612,
-0.343933641910553,
-0.696507453918457,
-0.18028561770915985,
-0.04036691412329674,
-0.34245821833610535,
0.1486777663230896,
0.23396648466587067,
-0.18064828217029572,
0.9357944130897522,
-0.796477198600769,
-0.2412380576133728,
-0.09029389917850494,
0.11207178980112076,
0.3127671480178833,
0.4888399541378021,
0.4227718710899353,
-0.9338312745094299,
-0.3629738688468933,
-0.022785136476159096,
-0.7849342823028564,
0.09820330888032913,
-0.14142660796642303,
0.11603711545467377,
-0.08944374322891235,
0.3978724479675293,
-0.37053579092025757,
0.7512034773826599,
0.861801028251648,
-0.49102333188056946,
-0.06006232649087906,
-0.18832165002822876,
-0.06576244533061981,
-0.8002747297286987,
-0.26803094148635864,
0.31098395586013794,
-0.3698577582836151,
-0.717559278011322,
0.07236376404762268,
0.5091614723205566,
-0.5231741666793823,
-0.2902856171131134,
0.43053025007247925,
-0.34235048294067383,
0.02745175175368786,
0.057685788720846176,
-0.3694477677345276,
-0.0062513467855751514,
0.5042008757591248,
0.18977093696594238,
0.8546154499053955,
0.4329228699207306,
-0.388033002614975,
-0.1321965605020523,
0.17804209887981415,
-0.24442705512046814,
0.09810732305049896,
-0.973250687122345,
0.2883806526660919,
-0.3690939247608185,
0.2809423506259918,
-0.87189781665802,
0.18774081766605377,
0.09430606663227081,
-0.4708188772201538,
0.49666833877563477,
-0.5373367667198181,
-0.15685588121414185,
-0.3915466070175171,
-0.16862328350543976,
0.7443022131919861,
0.8379514813423157,
-0.34272241592407227,
1.0787056684494019,
0.6028754115104675,
-0.4700597822666168,
-0.08525998890399933,
-0.7007123827934265,
-0.0672142282128334,
-0.3001795709133148,
-0.8095760941505432,
0.6304710507392883,
0.14155375957489014,
-0.35593661665916443,
-0.09910132735967636,
0.030886583030223846,
-0.0681302398443222,
-0.07618056237697601,
0.23623885214328766,
0.1735389530658722,
-0.1929844617843628,
0.32815998792648315,
-0.009527642279863358,
-0.5377729535102844,
0.07289320230484009,
-0.12377128005027771,
0.9903204441070557,
-0.13895554840564728,
-0.5484830737113953,
-0.08685976266860962,
0.4389287829399109,
0.37794211506843567,
-0.7057068347930908,
0.5633989572525024,
0.5539484024047852,
-0.6088213324546814,
-0.1741495132446289,
-0.46417471766471863,
-0.2549120783805847,
-0.5982810258865356,
0.21431641280651093,
-0.46913522481918335,
-0.8408921360969543,
0.7297694087028503,
-0.13143689930438995,
-0.19512474536895752,
0.678939700126648,
0.6292246580123901,
0.0862557590007782,
1.3793432712554932,
0.6809913516044617,
0.09211261570453644,
0.6973209381103516,
-0.4983164072036743,
0.08956819027662277,
-0.5999411344528198,
-0.32817813754081726,
-0.44143086671829224,
-0.0716414526104927,
-0.5335501432418823,
-0.9393317103385925,
0.3455355167388916,
-0.0005606701015494764,
-0.2868189811706543,
0.37712398171424866,
-0.3290545344352722,
0.47042521834373474,
0.2533155083656311,
0.22419384121894836,
-0.03552096709609032,
0.2148200273513794,
0.08290734142065048,
-0.3051818609237671,
-0.6484020352363586,
-0.40183842182159424,
0.8053704500198364,
0.7119230031967163,
1.1077760457992554,
-0.03172063082456589,
0.9519575834274292,
0.43697383999824524,
0.7360152006149292,
-0.9251357913017273,
0.08163939416408539,
-0.5125881433486938,
-0.36862730979919434,
-0.45552441477775574,
-0.6170698404312134,
-0.7491803765296936,
0.3923315703868866,
0.18106865882873535,
-0.5130407214164734,
0.6256775856018066,
0.08481568098068237,
-0.4191571772098541,
0.2131514698266983,
-0.8395863771438599,
0.564188539981842,
-0.09235670417547226,
-0.02551467902958393,
-0.28953710198402405,
-0.15341158211231232,
0.14025714993476868,
-0.24120497703552246,
0.4235803484916687,
0.2654575705528259,
0.02681691199541092,
0.6947627067565918,
-0.6864385604858398,
0.9764584302902222,
-0.3448007106781006,
-0.3349176049232483,
0.47491464018821716,
0.09683097153902054,
0.6483367085456848,
-0.17653720080852509,
-0.15721087157726288,
0.40005046129226685,
-0.37618446350097656,
-0.31179454922676086,
-0.8710397481918335,
0.38727912306785583,
-0.7735913991928101,
-0.5115100145339966,
-0.1345980018377304,
-0.2374533861875534,
-0.1345830261707306,
0.058763206005096436,
0.0838795006275177,
0.9662919640541077,
0.030785290524363518,
0.4254959225654602,
0.5679569840431213,
-0.024379221722483635,
0.6436043977737427,
0.04802880063652992,
-0.21633388102054596,
-0.8074793219566345,
0.8537050485610962,
0.5029855370521545,
-0.08796349167823792,
0.3770535886287689,
0.22032983601093292,
-0.5330187678337097,
-0.251894474029541,
-0.5074188113212585,
0.2079194188117981,
-0.6878862977027893,
-0.4794003665447235,
-0.5243915915489197,
-0.09328735619783401,
-0.5415827631950378,
-0.20330731570720673,
-0.10773836821317673,
-0.5605803728103638,
-0.15851660072803497,
-0.19943109154701233,
0.20240850746631622,
1.065877914428711,
0.052181873470544815,
0.7274169921875,
-1.0170458555221558,
0.42082127928733826,
0.4584680497646332,
0.6977035999298096,
0.335524320602417,
-0.5904280543327332,
-0.6314362287521362,
0.26683536171913147,
-0.20950745046138763,
-0.9291142821311951,
0.4746328592300415,
0.03589411824941635,
0.5893933176994324,
0.4096480906009674,
-0.10177023708820343,
0.9708588123321533,
-0.7370936870574951,
0.5074064135551453,
0.1467217653989792,
-1.2525861263275146,
0.06593094021081924,
-0.006662250496447086,
0.24929878115653992,
0.33938226103782654,
0.4844011962413788,
-0.45104989409446716,
0.06789647042751312,
-0.8399848341941833,
-0.7970219850540161,
0.6990150213241577,
0.31367361545562744,
0.7346107363700867,
-0.07804267853498459,
-0.11793458461761475,
-0.11002447456121445,
-0.1364721655845642,
-0.3706962764263153,
-0.23723599314689636,
-0.3835049569606781,
-0.3313109278678894,
-0.28649792075157166,
-0.28180989623069763,
0.37581583857536316,
-0.20696215331554413,
0.24590478837490082,
0.056534625589847565,
0.44786888360977173,
-0.1412781924009323,
-0.479274183511734,
0.15629000961780548,
-0.24790579080581665,
0.3158392906188965,
0.5286598801612854,
0.10632501542568207,
0.08698493987321854,
0.4071611762046814,
-0.5517063736915588,
0.14639955759048462,
0.14059214293956757,
0.15024693310260773,
0.02066052332520485,
0.6406749486923218,
0.6380585432052612,
0.17598114907741547,
-0.0703253298997879,
0.42351865768432617,
-0.13177590072155,
-0.0241698008030653,
-0.30749085545539856,
-0.2139766365289688,
0.2112865000963211,
-0.1917656660079956,
0.5729268193244934,
0.07168234884738922,
0.011137139983475208,
-0.27096521854400635,
0.516570508480072,
0.1112295463681221,
-0.7038572430610657,
-0.3740997314453125,
0.40479138493537903,
0.3304964303970337,
-0.6672031283378601,
0.8647358417510986,
0.24437366425991058,
-0.49198246002197266,
0.8808778524398804,
0.687210202217102,
0.8221812844276428,
-0.5156360268592834,
0.19797591865062714,
0.1092241108417511,
0.15791667997837067,
-0.12203769385814667,
0.08401701599359512,
-0.06846748292446136,
-1.0709543228149414,
-0.7279251217842102,
-0.2749749720096588,
-0.2872244715690613,
-0.5581052899360657,
-0.6762765049934387,
0.32346755266189575,
-0.3687370717525482,
-0.4655635356903076,
0.2616501450538635,
-0.21321187913417816,
-1.2073719501495361,
0.3167193830013275,
0.5741109848022461,
0.8756882548332214,
-1.0480173826217651,
0.5357852578163147,
0.7460091710090637,
-0.4420625865459442,
-0.8249984979629517,
-0.34034082293510437,
-0.5150728225708008,
-1.1094846725463867,
0.30312973260879517,
0.2745959162712097,
0.14394330978393555,
0.30567771196365356,
-0.5275948643684387,
-0.7743844985961914,
0.8314225077629089,
0.26749131083488464,
-0.6077547669410706,
-0.08229653537273407,
0.3428215980529785,
0.4945777654647827,
-0.43505197763442993,
0.5883771777153015,
0.17873403429985046,
0.4741447865962982,
0.21136687695980072,
-0.36415499448776245,
-0.007597459014505148,
-0.46691519021987915,
0.1124761626124382,
0.5159626603126526,
-0.30143094062805176,
1.0269817113876343,
-0.11502251774072647,
-0.3156137764453888,
-0.18515071272850037,
0.6001124978065491,
0.006199848372489214,
0.05075228586792946,
0.4637458622455597,
0.759880781173706,
0.624380886554718,
-0.1624402552843094,
1.4140851497650146,
-0.2561514675617218,
0.3913465440273285,
0.8040555715560913,
0.15488865971565247,
0.4495640695095062,
0.2357856184244156,
-0.6181386113166809,
0.4738299250602722,
0.3620859384536743,
-0.14221249520778656,
0.502435564994812,
0.22827588021755219,
-0.05501682683825493,
-0.6375095248222351,
0.0012241584481671453,
-0.5687572956085205,
0.43309837579727173,
0.5635978579521179,
-0.5566885471343994,
-0.22142766416072845,
-0.20586970448493958,
-0.2921103835105896,
0.04233606904745102,
-0.44340622425079346,
0.9983940720558167,
0.4169051945209503,
-0.12184838205575943,
0.2918708324432373,
0.06699322909116745,
0.5380334854125977,
-0.5329778790473938,
-0.47042107582092285,
-0.4395083487033844,
0.1483631283044815,
-0.06569625437259674,
-0.8066571354866028,
0.3239447772502899,
-0.1472490280866623,
-0.05278141051530838,
-0.5400864481925964,
0.6311562061309814,
-0.39945799112319946,
-1.3366726636886597,
-0.07509805262088776,
0.5670509934425354,
0.004930705763399601,
-0.4070049226284027,
-0.06877218931913376,
0.1332455724477768,
-0.08937761187553406,
0.024471892043948174,
0.015861492604017258,
0.8064204454421997,
-0.5254429578781128,
0.4864877760410309,
0.5831922292709351,
-0.08749699592590332,
-0.21605059504508972,
0.49134427309036255,
1.0454589128494263,
-0.788548469543457,
-0.544695258140564,
-1.2530384063720703,
0.9989261627197266,
0.053020961582660675,
-0.08379337191581726,
0.4551180899143219,
0.374104768037796,
0.6822848916053772,
-0.21123334765434265,
0.6586611866950989,
0.3108575642108917,
-0.13346321880817413,
-0.28199806809425354,
0.6185644268989563,
-0.09802136570215225,
0.16953612864017487,
-0.3333858251571655,
-1.0214020013809204,
-0.678950846195221,
0.8024272322654724,
-0.36947575211524963,
0.17889073491096497,
0.15526513755321503,
0.4003555476665497,
0.008831215091049671,
0.017110494896769524,
0.5526580810546875,
-0.28195813298225403,
0.41144517064094543,
0.163447767496109,
0.9488961696624756,
-0.5181360840797424,
0.3042772710323334,
-0.35789254307746887,
-0.054804351180791855,
-0.05440245941281319,
-0.7135239839553833,
-0.8360661268234253,
-0.2874184250831604,
0.09750951081514359,
0.07717679440975189,
-0.35004565119743347,
0.7608085870742798,
0.7317888736724854,
-0.9220243096351624,
0.025415927171707153,
0.18181112408638,
0.3318433165550232,
0.1275625377893448,
-0.10350567102432251,
0.29353249073028564,
-0.2466113418340683,
-0.8224785327911377,
0.02832580916583538,
-0.10192382335662842,
0.5792681574821472,
-0.2538570463657379,
-0.06620635092258453,
0.58458411693573,
0.11366529762744904,
0.7280816435813904,
-0.34865620732307434,
-0.24607563018798828,
-0.11428830027580261,
0.2372678518295288,
0.18630853295326233,
0.027972666546702385,
1.3201017379760742,
-1.2771154642105103,
0.3045875132083893,
0.5701473355293274,
0.5921540856361389,
0.7382377982139587,
0.5771468877792358,
1.049026608467102,
-0.5793696641921997,
0.2646963894367218,
0.5474309921264648,
0.5032740235328674,
0.3758220076560974,
-0.1583767831325531,
0.49803006649017334,
-0.261377215385437,
0.016269560903310776,
-0.6602053642272949,
0.17255713045597076,
-0.3535972833633423,
-0.08968786895275116,
0.5889020562171936,
-0.27332350611686707,
0.07521938532590866,
0.1536274254322052,
0.005616628564894199,
0.11173775047063828,
-0.339192658662796,
0.560289740562439,
0.5379164814949036,
0.33010536432266235,
-0.21088755130767822,
0.3870364725589752,
0.11678928136825562,
0.17199906706809998,
-0.44792231917381287,
0.025931552052497864,
0.19474351406097412,
-0.32340872287750244,
0.42870551347732544,
0.3741099536418915,
-0.5313293933868408,
-0.1181616485118866,
0.3389524519443512,
-0.02087918482720852,
-0.2575896382331848,
-0.49687230587005615,
-0.6973700523376465,
0.08841891586780548,
-0.04450191557407379,
-0.031005537137389183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00890v1 | Macroeconomic Forecasting with Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T01:25:26 | 2024-07-01T01:25:26 | Andrea Carriero, Davide Pettenuzzo, Shubhranshu Shekhar | econ.EM | econ.EM, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents a comparative analysis evaluating the accuracy of Large
Language Models (LLMs) against traditional macro time series forecasting
approaches. In recent times, LLMs have surged in popularity for forecasting due
to their ability to capture intricate patterns in data and quickly adapt across
very different domains. However, their effectiveness in forecasting
macroeconomic time series data compared to conventional methods remains an area
of interest. To address this, we conduct a rigorous evaluation of LLMs against
traditional macro forecasting methods, using as common ground the FRED-MD
database. Our findings provide valuable insights into the strengths and
limitations of LLMs in forecasting macroeconomic time series, shedding light on
their applicability in real-world scenarios | [
-0.39997273683547974,
-0.8648292422294617,
0.7072916030883789,
0.44605645537376404,
-0.23221006989479065,
0.37714970111846924,
-0.5353013873100281,
-0.5690578818321228,
0.22087405622005463,
0.3628118932247162,
-0.38194769620895386,
-0.43586722016334534,
-0.5532577037811279,
0.4698416590690613,
-0.6071624755859375,
0.44138815999031067,
0.16236881911754608,
0.33502715826034546,
-0.298418790102005,
0.2567690312862396,
-0.04585061967372894,
-0.4796866178512573,
-0.6481301784515381,
-0.1777379959821701,
0.27443137764930725,
0.07643067836761475,
0.8798983693122864,
0.568975567817688,
0.5097862482070923,
0.33137401938438416,
-0.16173671185970306,
0.11575858294963837,
-0.4538240134716034,
0.011523807421326637,
0.11900129169225693,
-0.1976374387741089,
-0.4695623517036438,
-0.1668817102909088,
0.8465973138809204,
0.729398250579834,
-0.1260485202074051,
0.17024604976177216,
0.0039921412244439125,
0.5249507427215576,
-0.3186023533344269,
0.515084981918335,
-0.5505540370941162,
-0.10860604047775269,
-0.15912991762161255,
0.09270038455724716,
-0.409267395734787,
-0.485559344291687,
0.3295276165008545,
0.10488400608301163,
-0.04871617630124092,
-0.008409431204199791,
0.44587913155555725,
-0.05522831901907921,
-0.6108426451683044,
-0.21387337148189545,
-0.9085069894790649,
0.8839815258979797,
-1.1737980842590332,
0.5587659478187561,
-0.029237952083349228,
0.705328643321991,
-0.12428785115480423,
-0.4873047471046448,
-0.5002594590187073,
-0.2853473126888275,
0.13427218794822693,
-0.11173801869153976,
-0.26786917448043823,
-0.036138154566287994,
0.3736485540866852,
0.28433316946029663,
-0.3495452404022217,
0.379915714263916,
-0.33363449573516846,
0.2030404806137085,
0.5525772571563721,
0.3350638151168823,
-0.19128428399562836,
-0.21224704384803772,
-0.30715543031692505,
0.14498479664325714,
-0.7115659117698669,
-0.03723529726266861,
0.18325063586235046,
0.5958823561668396,
-0.23186936974525452,
0.47802600264549255,
-0.09099647402763367,
0.7910475134849548,
-0.1504972130060196,
-0.7395448088645935,
0.11068172007799149,
0.05379842594265938,
-0.521674633026123,
-0.22743287682533264,
0.8526123762130737,
0.5442684888839722,
0.7647546529769897,
-0.16979140043258667,
-0.1515447199344635,
-0.48855093121528625,
-0.2408999800682068,
-0.6968587040901184,
0.22918027639389038,
-0.07233187556266785,
-0.3869659900665283,
-0.2688223421573639,
0.17918404936790466,
-1.3141695261001587,
-0.1725410521030426,
-0.32866984605789185,
0.15820810198783875,
-0.019995922222733498,
0.042300064116716385,
-0.2593079209327698,
0.13746120035648346,
0.17444582283496857,
0.10629253834486008,
-0.899635374546051,
0.525593638420105,
0.8434886932373047,
1.1462502479553223,
-0.12141010910272598,
-0.011447547934949398,
-0.3023250997066498,
0.08372411876916885,
-0.3396880030632019,
0.7420710325241089,
-0.4423239231109619,
-0.631197452545166,
0.08781934529542923,
-0.011602099053561687,
-0.0038667917251586914,
-0.7833868861198425,
0.06286169588565826,
-0.4484505355358124,
-0.36740490794181824,
-0.29418811202049255,
-0.2816126346588135,
-0.2410067319869995,
0.4611908793449402,
-0.8095607161521912,
0.8051926493644714,
0.3681196868419647,
-0.3732074797153473,
0.34488406777381897,
-0.19702497124671936,
-0.5088564157485962,
-0.5032292008399963,
-0.08486299216747284,
-0.21258774399757385,
-0.10706808418035507,
0.39144736528396606,
0.8998603820800781,
-0.8956055641174316,
0.4581320285797119,
-0.754767894744873,
-0.2368510365486145,
0.5266086459159851,
-0.9070074558258057,
0.7822683453559875,
0.15922993421554565,
-0.37840279936790466,
-0.1661931276321411,
-0.808053195476532,
-0.21002471446990967,
0.12604986131191254,
-0.2554817199707031,
-0.06950264424085617,
0.19249418377876282,
-0.04926149547100067,
0.0903453603386879,
0.1289505511522293,
-0.32545965909957886,
0.29122182726860046,
-0.5101093649864197,
0.6672201752662659,
0.9138692021369934,
-0.22309264540672302,
0.199853777885437,
-0.30733561515808105,
0.9578408598899841,
-0.14036348462104797,
0.0996059700846672,
-0.028556574136018753,
-0.27843019366264343,
-0.2916768193244934,
-0.4992741048336029,
0.43214237689971924,
0.5732089281082153,
-0.3970467448234558,
0.1241958811879158,
-0.5728741884231567,
-0.7153469920158386,
0.22896720468997955,
0.2876974642276764,
0.1259726732969284,
0.39329472184181213,
0.15937739610671997,
0.06255300343036652,
-0.7314993143081665,
-0.7716810703277588,
-0.16430693864822388,
0.05622794106602669,
0.014790905639529228,
0.6555944085121155,
0.34809574484825134,
-0.5900706648826599,
0.8021320104598999,
-0.341934472322464,
0.28742364048957825,
-0.6031404733657837,
0.011745990253984928,
0.7246694564819336,
-0.006146907806396484,
1.0336358547210693,
-0.36137300729751587,
-0.709868848323822,
-0.19206781685352325,
-0.32659223675727844,
-0.07615122944116592,
0.16357694566249847,
0.4703580141067505,
0.8152029514312744,
0.45091551542282104,
-0.37230637669563293,
0.1828359067440033,
1.0347479581832886,
-0.23011009395122528,
0.7489665150642395,
-0.05331568047404289,
0.11836324632167816,
-1.0463608503341675,
-0.1266823261976242,
0.0998968705534935,
-0.622624933719635,
-0.1999136358499527,
-0.3223346173763275,
-0.046099189668893814,
-0.067841075360775,
-0.3670766353607178,
0.6698068976402283,
-0.48272135853767395,
-0.3586791157722473,
0.17088447511196136,
-0.19745245575904846,
-0.39223411679267883,
-0.038791343569755554,
-0.012418759055435658,
0.941034734249115,
0.5192151069641113,
-0.47273415327072144,
0.8019344210624695,
-0.24200673401355743,
-0.9463515877723694,
0.19490018486976624,
-0.648668110370636,
-0.15508128702640533,
0.05151883512735367,
0.3065376579761505,
-1.0820335149765015,
-0.07560282200574875,
-0.1884361207485199,
-0.01028224267065525,
0.589383065700531,
-0.06466104835271835,
-0.5451871752738953,
-0.6915700435638428,
-0.3850036561489105,
0.20717446506023407,
0.6364139914512634,
-0.8223121762275696,
0.34452012181282043,
0.23133179545402527,
-0.5079817175865173,
-0.8115621209144592,
-0.6714057326316833,
0.14590604603290558,
-0.2584233582019806,
-0.5042406320571899,
-0.048831358551979065,
-0.04828192666172981,
-0.7287400364875793,
-0.2657122015953064,
-0.2807427942752838,
-0.0545041449368,
0.2695934474468231,
-0.13636358082294464,
0.4360736906528473,
-0.5238197445869446,
-0.1734684258699417,
-0.24598915874958038,
-0.08124582469463348,
0.14709903299808502,
0.04121268168091774,
0.5771805644035339,
-0.05173838511109352,
0.03806168586015701,
0.10428877174854279,
0.012913956306874752,
0.9049286842346191,
0.18495547771453857,
1.0261801481246948,
0.29104143381118774,
-0.32802614569664,
-0.07508213818073273,
-0.6792183518409729,
0.2598978281021118,
-0.4344167709350586,
0.22173915803432465,
-0.025806060060858727,
-0.6569011211395264,
0.4359053671360016,
-0.16911886632442474,
-0.20040768384933472,
0.5429494380950928,
0.554169774055481,
-0.009050763212144375,
1.046623945236206,
0.37773293256759644,
-0.6211315989494324,
0.3381156027317047,
-0.5092424154281616,
0.43141624331474304,
-0.6465004682540894,
-0.23548826575279236,
-0.6964698433876038,
-0.25593435764312744,
-0.39123108983039856,
-0.41809409856796265,
0.29812511801719666,
-0.0656982958316803,
-0.31753644347190857,
0.2741251289844513,
0.25200414657592773,
0.5241743326187134,
0.3211790919303894,
-0.17786578834056854,
0.26940101385116577,
0.07724245637655258,
0.036809395998716354,
-0.05231884866952896,
-0.5660545229911804,
-0.6935029625892639,
1.374686598777771,
0.316036194562912,
0.9279173016548157,
0.20745106041431427,
0.21455809473991394,
0.2516929507255554,
0.5895037055015564,
-0.788298487663269,
0.47325095534324646,
-0.4239046275615692,
-0.4428310990333557,
-0.41765618324279785,
-0.6594186425209045,
-0.5752624869346619,
-0.02048417553305626,
-0.399382084608078,
-0.9026690721511841,
0.11237184703350067,
-0.1339084953069687,
-0.3985370993614197,
0.6102325916290283,
-0.5091371536254883,
0.9355018734931946,
-0.4357520341873169,
-0.13083843886852264,
-0.09609720855951309,
-0.25338947772979736,
0.3361530900001526,
-0.22852395474910736,
0.6467656493186951,
-0.15910661220550537,
-0.15142160654067993,
0.7556620836257935,
-0.44689399003982544,
0.7410882115364075,
0.14080259203910828,
-0.3507518470287323,
0.11476922780275345,
0.01598571240901947,
0.3979523479938507,
0.2855510711669922,
-0.44152259826660156,
0.39938125014305115,
0.3193315863609314,
-0.27518829703330994,
-0.2800961136817932,
1.0011324882507324,
-0.5629927515983582,
-0.513750433921814,
-0.5862208604812622,
-0.6056602597236633,
-0.5387634038925171,
0.1253109723329544,
0.1952103078365326,
0.724062979221344,
-0.6329628229141235,
0.33259496092796326,
0.32847830653190613,
-0.1612519770860672,
0.7642161250114441,
0.4833420515060425,
-0.5740180015563965,
-0.5317063331604004,
0.698386013507843,
0.43260276317596436,
0.2679930627346039,
0.6516626477241516,
0.2310533970594406,
-0.48104360699653625,
-0.5179944038391113,
-0.24986626207828522,
0.45484161376953125,
-0.4617276191711426,
-0.34385091066360474,
-0.4241822063922882,
0.028209801763296127,
-0.9923264384269714,
-0.5361080765724182,
-0.13123121857643127,
-0.32294437289237976,
-0.18777869641780853,
-0.07211783528327942,
0.17546260356903076,
0.8193606734275818,
0.08988133817911148,
0.24570898711681366,
-0.9574042558670044,
0.3500107228755951,
0.5247487425804138,
0.3686200678348541,
0.1268332600593567,
-0.36623358726501465,
-0.24799391627311707,
0.11106733232736588,
-0.24350345134735107,
-0.8825253844261169,
0.8186309337615967,
0.1665601134300232,
0.4255463778972626,
0.7782182097434998,
-0.3046138882637024,
0.7359954714775085,
-0.6042811870574951,
0.8186255097389221,
0.03789464011788368,
-1.021403193473816,
0.1265704482793808,
-0.36523640155792236,
0.1722785085439682,
0.17568856477737427,
0.7020008563995361,
-0.5107638835906982,
-0.08346187323331833,
-0.5497092008590698,
-0.8454170823097229,
0.44297441840171814,
-0.3497896194458008,
0.06181655824184418,
-0.3085891008377075,
0.14586953818798065,
0.15539714694023132,
0.4470808804035187,
-0.5319642424583435,
-0.22235628962516785,
0.2690329849720001,
-0.2304021269083023,
-1.0113465785980225,
-0.7390569448471069,
0.2577291429042816,
-0.4175029695034027,
0.5081331133842468,
0.07381562888622284,
0.22824615240097046,
-0.06449437886476517,
0.1235368400812149,
-0.24146457016468048,
0.25588148832321167,
0.6572098731994629,
1.0783789157867432,
-0.5172136425971985,
-0.035728711634874344,
0.6144672632217407,
-0.2580122947692871,
0.0622653029859066,
0.08142709732055664,
0.07419027388095856,
0.36366361379623413,
0.48852813243865967,
0.4353910982608795,
0.6344075202941895,
-1.1867941617965698,
0.3467889726161957,
0.23954594135284424,
0.04061557725071907,
-0.5013309717178345,
-0.16884306073188782,
0.24075402319431305,
0.543447732925415,
0.12154243886470795,
-0.14160682260990143,
-0.008054621517658234,
-1.050893783569336,
-0.39068570733070374,
0.6791191101074219,
-0.03585211560130119,
-0.20785754919052124,
0.5254337787628174,
0.12417202442884445,
-0.2814648747444153,
0.4342339336872101,
0.2531856894493103,
-0.6514872908592224,
1.0288141965866089,
0.850409209728241,
0.6565966010093689,
-0.405032217502594,
-0.15312255918979645,
0.19466815888881683,
0.28798502683639526,
-0.5107689499855042,
0.1652173399925232,
0.12109865993261337,
-0.38881704211235046,
-0.553820013999939,
-0.7865927815437317,
-0.47542646527290344,
0.22330082952976227,
-0.45618996024131775,
0.29824408888816833,
-0.6489174365997314,
-0.20496775209903717,
-0.17998534440994263,
0.14470379054546356,
-0.6151359677314758,
0.16300351917743683,
0.11597409844398499,
1.3478965759277344,
-0.7638177871704102,
0.6801037192344666,
0.5174844264984131,
0.19403359293937683,
-0.682535707950592,
-0.05931532755494118,
0.050333667546510696,
-0.6390997767448425,
0.6264788508415222,
0.16869418323040009,
-0.05861771106719971,
-0.12434863299131393,
-0.21769243478775024,
-0.9778886437416077,
1.1664551496505737,
0.46346476674079895,
-0.9820482730865479,
-0.03740542754530907,
0.10600350797176361,
0.3939920663833618,
-0.41785600781440735,
0.18935683369636536,
0.8805362582206726,
0.684125542640686,
-0.025215519592165947,
-1.1263424158096313,
-0.20256230235099792,
0.271392285823822,
-0.1423453986644745,
0.6080030798912048,
-0.5568591356277466,
0.8207255005836487,
-0.2660132348537445,
-0.028130346909165382,
0.28459128737449646,
0.5967294573783875,
-0.2754794955253601,
0.5431874990463257,
0.47542303800582886,
0.39660385251045227,
0.6011549234390259,
-0.1482497602701187,
1.120186448097229,
-0.3701452612876892,
0.5172010064125061,
0.7194950580596924,
-0.3308729827404022,
0.9567840099334717,
0.24875737726688385,
-0.8115785121917725,
0.39613640308380127,
0.4122924506664276,
-0.1244678720831871,
0.22421060502529144,
0.045065734535455704,
-0.15710891783237457,
-0.31909623742103577,
0.3970269560813904,
-0.42142507433891296,
0.3007201850414276,
0.28711602091789246,
-0.31617772579193115,
-0.20831112563610077,
-0.27182960510253906,
0.20483584702014923,
-0.026068665087223053,
-0.6748806834220886,
0.5552266836166382,
0.3415919840335846,
-0.32978999614715576,
0.509986400604248,
0.01903272233903408,
0.7892469167709351,
-0.3742268681526184,
0.3259317874908447,
-0.1048552468419075,
0.15039995312690735,
0.040896225720644,
-0.49072155356407166,
0.521411657333374,
0.5403138399124146,
-0.09185146540403366,
-0.036284200847148895,
0.4511633515357971,
-0.18254755437374115,
-0.9076834321022034,
0.22222080826759338,
0.3979674279689789,
-0.1309933215379715,
0.14364905655384064,
-0.36712244153022766,
-0.16810360550880432,
-0.2541164457798004,
-0.3462851941585541,
0.13985517621040344,
0.3103976249694824,
0.283950537443161,
0.8647471070289612,
0.4055175185203552,
0.36070457100868225,
-0.1176672950387001,
-0.10547417402267456,
0.2741334140300751,
-1.002804160118103,
-0.3961002230644226,
-1.1484344005584717,
-0.22570915520191193,
0.23662510514259338,
0.11814945191144943,
0.7629804015159607,
0.5825950503349304,
0.6610630750656128,
-0.2782035171985626,
0.6331647038459778,
0.23303911089897156,
0.7599313259124756,
-0.662743091583252,
0.44310784339904785,
-0.3015897274017334,
0.566509485244751,
-0.39831992983818054,
-1.2446262836456299,
-0.2786625325679779,
0.5621598362922668,
-0.6116273403167725,
0.17509245872497559,
0.44729164242744446,
0.38967540860176086,
-0.20713946223258972,
-0.011386825703084469,
0.44578269124031067,
0.7446698546409607,
0.12972405552864075,
0.32715871930122375,
0.6647367477416992,
0.16791866719722748,
0.47381073236465454,
-0.3236822783946991,
-0.07148019969463348,
-0.6275838017463684,
-1.192258596420288,
-1.066868782043457,
-0.15090660750865936,
0.1708080917596817,
-0.25657886266708374,
0.053784213960170746,
1.3688277006149292,
0.33241957426071167,
-0.7510057091712952,
-0.5803428888320923,
0.3301508128643036,
0.23858420550823212,
-0.25551530718803406,
-0.25464725494384766,
0.23309092223644257,
0.09807729721069336,
-1.070570945739746,
0.4223195016384125,
0.23122690618038177,
0.40369877219200134,
-0.3783266544342041,
0.09921703487634659,
0.07028365135192871,
0.49681130051612854,
0.8573324084281921,
0.15894058346748352,
-0.5429671406745911,
-0.18866093456745148,
0.08107288926839828,
-0.04967738315463066,
-0.02740272879600525,
0.7830724120140076,
-0.922017514705658,
-0.06585544347763062,
0.5957531929016113,
0.3564387559890747,
0.2660365402698517,
-0.11907995492219925,
0.6510844230651855,
-0.24863025546073914,
0.11900342255830765,
-0.0024894624948501587,
0.6795504093170166,
0.17301978170871735,
-0.09333525598049164,
0.43351027369499207,
0.20761795341968536,
-0.48675233125686646,
-0.8951029777526855,
-0.07465030997991562,
-1.1533790826797485,
-0.33020126819610596,
1.1888271570205688,
-0.09028436988592148,
-0.31837064027786255,
0.11068414151668549,
-0.027232706546783447,
0.04377846419811249,
-0.3168163001537323,
0.8620619177818298,
0.7909649610519409,
0.39319872856140137,
0.07280407100915909,
-0.564365565776825,
0.02553466521203518,
-0.18820695579051971,
-0.4254598319530487,
0.04879172146320343,
0.32242363691329956,
0.3864818513393402,
-0.34221717715263367,
0.3909963071346283,
0.0929451659321785,
0.14852909743785858,
-0.3446405231952667,
-0.6125763058662415,
-0.2041214257478714,
-0.4019165635108948,
-0.4326770305633545,
-0.0658712312579155,
0.2613000273704529,
0.5217301249504089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00888v1 | Papez: Resource-Efficient Speech Separation with Auditory Working Memory | 2024-07-01T01:23:06 | 2024-07-01T01:23:06 | Hyunseok Oh, Juheon Yi, Youngki Lee | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Transformer-based models recently reached state-of-the-art single-channel
speech separation accuracy; However, their extreme computational load makes it
difficult to deploy them in resource-constrained mobile or IoT devices. We thus
present Papez, a lightweight and computation-efficient single-channel speech
separation model. Papez is based on three key techniques. We first replace the
inter-chunk Transformer with small-sized auditory working memory. Second, we
adaptively prune the input tokens that do not need further processing. Finally,
we reduce the number of parameters through the recurrent transformer. Our
extensive evaluation shows that Papez achieves the best resource and accuracy
tradeoffs with a large margin. We publicly share our source code at
\texttt{https://github.com/snuhcs/Papez} | [
-0.5945022106170654,
-0.814878523349762,
0.22532516717910767,
0.3458053767681122,
-0.2429518848657608,
0.03793569281697273,
-0.4278157353401184,
-0.41014084219932556,
-0.0032553235068917274,
0.36671048402786255,
-0.616144597530365,
-0.11422739177942276,
-0.4862492084503174,
-0.15780243277549744,
-0.48941275477409363,
0.5825101733207703,
0.5448635816574097,
-0.030756724998354912,
0.19653300940990448,
0.15109723806381226,
-0.24314118921756744,
-0.16876672208309174,
-0.573421835899353,
-0.5994070172309875,
0.48532724380493164,
0.6083579659461975,
0.45124104619026184,
0.4557194709777832,
0.3710433542728424,
0.22573992609977722,
-0.482828825712204,
0.03664139658212662,
-0.27688220143318176,
-0.0020212228409945965,
-0.05297640711069107,
-0.047782428562641144,
-0.5229159593582153,
0.08302628993988037,
0.6480157375335693,
0.7116130590438843,
-0.591366171836853,
0.20440645515918732,
-0.05824553221464157,
0.590028703212738,
-0.7734692096710205,
-0.024140065535902977,
-0.6925659775733948,
0.35794103145599365,
-0.4230186939239502,
-0.010874541476368904,
-0.5242719054222107,
0.10405709594488144,
0.2842450439929962,
-0.22419127821922302,
0.14173710346221924,
-0.38209348917007446,
0.6210907101631165,
0.33656272292137146,
-0.08305742591619492,
0.17054998874664307,
-1.1241395473480225,
0.7197568416595459,
-0.6598047614097595,
0.5699418187141418,
0.44400155544281006,
0.3241816759109497,
0.06051300838589668,
-1.221732497215271,
-0.8329859972000122,
-0.05355214327573776,
0.35886886715888977,
0.05261397361755371,
-0.43378975987434387,
0.04897985979914665,
0.016691407188773155,
0.5169130563735962,
-0.18948276340961456,
0.14834269881248474,
-0.8661856651306152,
-0.15052607655525208,
0.3615567982196808,
-0.22698357701301575,
0.3195098340511322,
-0.06624823808670044,
-0.4563581049442291,
0.1362781971693039,
-0.6524369716644287,
0.16216857731342316,
0.24794186651706696,
0.5677900910377502,
-0.05601957440376282,
0.180240198969841,
-0.21458610892295837,
0.7307297587394714,
0.35186320543289185,
-0.5543785095214844,
0.4807455241680145,
-0.17294016480445862,
-0.1686284989118576,
0.06512109190225601,
1.0041159391403198,
-0.2671872079372406,
-0.23475784063339233,
-0.40167003870010376,
-0.07725999504327774,
-0.4413210153579712,
0.6343557834625244,
-0.6686081290245056,
-0.2946624457836151,
0.2799922823905945,
-0.8570969700813293,
-0.22153355181217194,
-0.18636517226696014,
-0.8201022148132324,
-0.2149888426065445,
-0.013669611886143684,
0.5448951721191406,
-0.3283049762248993,
-0.5625051259994507,
0.15476219356060028,
-0.03159760311245918,
0.1349678784608841,
0.258690744638443,
-0.9850573539733887,
0.7681735157966614,
0.5829309821128845,
0.9272324442863464,
-0.1863652914762497,
-0.34917375445365906,
-1.0187236070632935,
-0.25067558884620667,
-0.03243853524327278,
0.7236210107803345,
-0.2826024293899536,
-0.4283929467201233,
-0.5692018270492554,
-0.270778089761734,
-0.25230515003204346,
-0.7517229914665222,
0.9329651594161987,
-0.17966113984584808,
0.26678267121315,
0.0630967766046524,
-0.38399261236190796,
-0.13395962119102478,
-0.3621334135532379,
-0.9296541810035706,
0.882266640663147,
-0.05821686238050461,
-0.34721243381500244,
0.11127243936061859,
-0.9307798147201538,
-0.43563005328178406,
0.1122061014175415,
0.10578354448080063,
-0.2909172773361206,
0.2010481208562851,
0.16145013272762299,
0.019869526848196983,
-0.6415462493896484,
-0.2901906669139862,
-0.08425087481737137,
-0.4290887415409088,
0.1299213171005249,
-0.47204098105430603,
0.7712351083755493,
0.630652904510498,
-0.4580618143081665,
0.10429266840219498,
-0.8588036298751831,
0.13325385749340057,
0.020096508786082268,
-0.3644201159477234,
0.21597634255886078,
0.30612197518348694,
0.24553051590919495,
0.4746277630329132,
0.006852544378489256,
-0.8511953353881836,
-0.1893203854560852,
-0.3327491879463196,
0.7854280471801758,
0.45105165243148804,
-0.34442317485809326,
0.7526450157165527,
-0.21402153372764587,
0.39052432775497437,
-0.4045284688472748,
0.45039722323417664,
-0.01739683374762535,
-0.3150961995124817,
-0.44385024905204773,
-0.8193542957305908,
0.45913827419281006,
0.471748024225235,
-0.2273292988538742,
0.5332109332084656,
-0.1317247450351715,
-0.7470049858093262,
-0.4000534117221832,
0.2836814522743225,
0.18200142681598663,
0.9279942512512207,
0.32140210270881653,
-0.1681312471628189,
-0.318232923746109,
-0.8082874417304993,
0.03996947035193443,
0.07338721305131912,
-0.28409942984580994,
-0.0290078017860651,
-0.016923189163208008,
0.4946471154689789,
0.8609979152679443,
-0.14017567038536072,
-0.118149533867836,
-0.43106451630592346,
0.029693609103560448,
0.26898473501205444,
0.366317480802536,
0.26867738366127014,
-1.1424819231033325,
-0.3725040555000305,
-0.22821660339832306,
-0.14012162387371063,
-0.45347610116004944,
0.08599136769771576,
0.04543910548090935,
-0.10221470147371292,
0.32711032032966614,
-0.9200237989425659,
0.5250444412231445,
0.6206519603729248,
-0.3053680658340454,
0.3231355547904968,
0.09852048754692078,
-0.19875967502593994,
-0.7830591797828674,
0.30300506949424744,
-0.1334804743528366,
-0.2644622027873993,
-0.9258638620376587,
-0.3983260691165924,
0.04655084013938904,
-0.3797609806060791,
-0.9131659269332886,
0.24716819822788239,
-0.27282264828681946,
0.06793295592069626,
-0.5257314443588257,
0.16665217280387878,
0.07583565264940262,
0.4116784930229187,
0.005600487347692251,
0.8020200729370117,
0.46075719594955444,
-0.5406196117401123,
0.36665263772010803,
0.18443983793258667,
-0.27699148654937744,
0.3756943643093109,
-0.631152331829071,
0.29724565148353577,
0.3213708996772766,
0.2288803905248642,
-0.857137143611908,
0.2747381031513214,
0.49931180477142334,
-0.2971704602241516,
-0.010656650178134441,
-0.38968145847320557,
-0.6179282069206238,
-0.2826121151447296,
-0.042672049254179,
0.3491227328777313,
0.7958400249481201,
-0.9485940337181091,
0.8930116891860962,
0.7474771738052368,
-0.5633109211921692,
-0.41326525807380676,
-0.539393424987793,
-0.04157281294465065,
-0.2396056354045868,
-0.6406639218330383,
0.7325737476348877,
0.05994166061282158,
-0.05507517606019974,
0.1584334820508957,
-0.5895673036575317,
-0.48206865787506104,
-0.01296442560851574,
0.31395262479782104,
0.34529921412467957,
0.03347180783748627,
0.2946738302707672,
-0.43963322043418884,
-0.08497140556573868,
-0.15570713579654694,
-0.3377704322338104,
0.6645449995994568,
-0.35813409090042114,
-0.308597594499588,
-0.5974761843681335,
0.37985971570014954,
0.8719027638435364,
-0.5905429124832153,
0.6994370818138123,
0.7729097604751587,
-0.5100774765014648,
-0.4020221531391144,
-0.6268704533576965,
0.07407556474208832,
-0.485831081867218,
0.3243742883205414,
-0.2969282865524292,
-0.6041755676269531,
0.43872153759002686,
-0.26564469933509827,
-0.06755799800157547,
0.218435138463974,
0.5304296016693115,
-0.190265953540802,
0.6698376536369324,
0.37818530201911926,
0.05927031487226486,
0.973040759563446,
0.042559120804071426,
0.7409452199935913,
-0.7992353439331055,
-0.22440145909786224,
-0.5504030585289001,
-0.29753392934799194,
-0.21700350940227509,
-0.6039772033691406,
0.33468836545944214,
0.10498762130737305,
0.009693318977952003,
0.1574389934539795,
-0.6911360621452332,
0.5748967528343201,
0.8215839862823486,
0.17439644038677216,
0.0745263323187828,
0.17102482914924622,
0.22104404866695404,
0.0712464302778244,
-0.7623016834259033,
-0.26847973465919495,
0.8217568397521973,
0.32916930317878723,
0.5664078593254089,
-0.15849991142749786,
0.42578262090682983,
0.19152267277240753,
-0.21016435325145721,
-0.6096445322036743,
0.6317484378814697,
-0.32989218831062317,
-0.40773913264274597,
-0.5053949952125549,
-0.4904807209968567,
-0.848437488079071,
0.6176353096961975,
-0.4416736662387848,
-1.1027748584747314,
0.14757557213306427,
-0.11865301430225372,
-0.5584901571273804,
0.8192709684371948,
-0.7289360165596008,
0.6911928057670593,
-0.07959728688001633,
-0.3989352881908417,
-0.5245205163955688,
-0.3783663511276245,
-0.03824947401881218,
0.009745748713612556,
-0.11513563990592957,
-0.4825664758682251,
0.06975438445806503,
0.8487426042556763,
-0.7347539663314819,
0.4910568296909332,
-0.4413914382457733,
0.21249446272850037,
0.5371261239051819,
-0.2145966738462448,
0.3264784514904022,
-0.3332647979259491,
-0.1868310570716858,
0.22759751975536346,
0.005799060221761465,
-0.3298993706703186,
-0.3097875118255615,
0.38008835911750793,
-0.44036585092544556,
-0.1291777342557907,
-0.01322204526513815,
-0.6838586330413818,
-0.17494699358940125,
0.23554293811321259,
0.2542773485183716,
0.4483264684677124,
-0.15028142929077148,
0.6192265152931213,
0.4923236668109894,
-0.22980856895446777,
0.8154605031013489,
0.4310016334056854,
-0.03468843176960945,
-0.33306097984313965,
0.6619288325309753,
0.265063613653183,
0.07147682458162308,
0.18430322408676147,
0.3999691307544708,
-0.27939358353614807,
-0.6600111126899719,
-0.09445662051439285,
0.06905888766050339,
-0.43999022245407104,
-0.18513599038124084,
-0.5018610954284668,
-0.32352495193481445,
-0.07479751855134964,
0.2834874391555786,
-1.1801766157150269,
-0.5990637540817261,
0.12277327477931976,
0.05011973902583122,
0.137826606631279,
0.3018675744533539,
-0.31841617822647095,
0.350643128156662,
-0.7520830035209656,
0.80650794506073,
0.5071759223937988,
0.6409541368484497,
-0.20135685801506042,
-0.49157801270484924,
-0.22322270274162292,
-0.18600130081176758,
-0.14289085566997528,
-0.8330317735671997,
0.38769716024398804,
0.07428442686796188,
0.6481890678405762,
0.20018699765205383,
0.18908241391181946,
0.5070353150367737,
-0.3618362545967102,
0.6746571063995361,
0.3852985203266144,
-1.3402594327926636,
0.48435303568840027,
-0.12973181903362274,
0.27226313948631287,
0.5271881818771362,
-0.4730101227760315,
-0.5202692747116089,
-0.07336533814668655,
-0.5028595328330994,
-1.0678125619888306,
1.062531590461731,
0.37911832332611084,
-0.20012657344341278,
0.21333111822605133,
0.06148618832230568,
0.078497014939785,
0.10742725431919098,
-0.48162904381752014,
-0.3505556285381317,
-0.15720698237419128,
-0.17143681645393372,
0.20731306076049805,
-0.22358860075473785,
-0.21130582690238953,
-0.2920650541782379,
0.5891794562339783,
0.30466675758361816,
0.38249877095222473,
0.12451411783695221,
-0.002269002143293619,
-0.11424163728952408,
0.45144444704055786,
0.5634707808494568,
0.8000887036323547,
-0.2045646458864212,
0.12606951594352722,
0.29323485493659973,
-0.6153212785720825,
0.05713215097784996,
0.3236282467842102,
-0.10166274011135101,
0.1701028198003769,
-0.11943992972373962,
0.7722971439361572,
0.21090030670166016,
-0.8179241418838501,
0.6966503262519836,
-0.38327696919441223,
-0.16139501333236694,
-0.4232688248157501,
-0.0028070055413991213,
0.33318954706192017,
0.2732582986354828,
0.6859990358352661,
0.4088990390300751,
0.05710066109895706,
-0.08494168519973755,
0.12079668045043945,
0.12088607996702194,
0.03384193032979965,
-0.1679752767086029,
0.4815685749053955,
0.6275257468223572,
-0.6843090653419495,
0.6332224607467651,
0.003966962918639183,
-0.07889752089977264,
0.4358997941017151,
0.43817734718322754,
0.957399845123291,
-0.262149840593338,
0.057532716542482376,
0.027821974828839302,
0.16911986470222473,
-0.046127818524837494,
0.1769787073135376,
-0.44527575373649597,
-0.5606300234794617,
-0.5320215821266174,
-0.39207813143730164,
-0.6882587671279907,
0.324858695268631,
-0.6584548354148865,
-0.030663711950182915,
-0.6595384478569031,
-0.3323095142841339,
0.039469409734010696,
-0.11512313038110733,
-0.6281517148017883,
0.03385912999510765,
0.6242653131484985,
1.0257669687271118,
-0.5529863238334656,
1.0476893186569214,
0.34874656796455383,
-0.0055360994301736355,
-1.0268967151641846,
0.08541310578584671,
0.04714995622634888,
-0.2429785132408142,
0.40943241119384766,
-0.09895917773246765,
-0.5688278675079346,
-0.3869076371192932,
-0.22565528750419617,
-0.7293147444725037,
0.9113709330558777,
0.6030434966087341,
-0.519343912601471,
0.1122317686676979,
-0.3029273450374603,
0.2552623152732849,
-0.20243717730045319,
-0.13098835945129395,
0.3969325125217438,
0.401180237531662,
-0.14157575368881226,
-1.3429780006408691,
-0.30311158299446106,
-0.673563539981842,
-0.40339821577072144,
0.2123110294342041,
-0.6741300225257874,
1.020289421081543,
0.05219836160540581,
-0.34637993574142456,
-0.21271879971027374,
0.5200165510177612,
0.10827996581792831,
0.2508874237537384,
1.0581177473068237,
0.44390976428985596,
1.068601369857788,
-0.03943353891372681,
0.6545951962471008,
-0.3484314978122711,
0.13318940997123718,
1.317536473274231,
-0.11577609926462173,
0.9732928276062012,
0.6735073924064636,
-0.23633313179016113,
0.3067362606525421,
0.1495845466852188,
0.11865773797035217,
0.8118588924407959,
-0.1609867960214615,
-0.7227206230163574,
-0.23552004992961884,
-0.011967190541327,
-0.31776854395866394,
1.0368224382400513,
0.02787771075963974,
-0.10397465527057648,
-0.06820397824048996,
0.18985585868358612,
-0.13443467020988464,
-0.01872027851641178,
-0.21376964449882507,
0.5382705330848694,
-0.07817205041646957,
-0.38747262954711914,
0.2653307616710663,
0.045986030250787735,
0.6312422156333923,
-0.6813321113586426,
0.09771616011857986,
0.026426009833812714,
0.12379482388496399,
-0.2816311717033386,
-0.3823781907558441,
0.33707502484321594,
0.2288253754377365,
-0.34985941648483276,
-0.48881885409355164,
1.0239228010177612,
-0.34539851546287537,
-0.13573294878005981,
0.3287654221057892,
0.7530575394630432,
-0.15260626375675201,
-0.27902916073799133,
-0.5036154389381409,
0.24305860698223114,
-0.1480552703142166,
-0.3151363432407379,
0.13734771311283112,
0.19662164151668549,
0.595898449420929,
0.7638452053070068,
0.7441662549972534,
0.612774133682251,
0.2573896050453186,
0.08355824649333954,
0.5316050052642822,
-0.6442824006080627,
-0.9445686340332031,
-0.6360069513320923,
0.32963159680366516,
-0.14282095432281494,
-0.045016463845968246,
0.48469406366348267,
0.40021610260009766,
0.5598636865615845,
0.03577158972620964,
0.7219610810279846,
-0.32841384410858154,
0.7879796028137207,
-0.1978081911802292,
0.7148785591125488,
-0.16321654617786407,
0.3765551447868347,
-0.18744860589504242,
-0.6485052108764648,
-0.16192497313022614,
0.7830764055252075,
-0.19254659116268158,
-0.160752534866333,
0.5378410220146179,
0.5790026783943176,
-0.1879592388868332,
0.28901147842407227,
0.28153061866760254,
-0.05528111010789871,
0.2206670194864273,
0.4757274091243744,
0.8845792412757874,
-0.2871861159801483,
0.9378241300582886,
-0.8047694563865662,
-0.07761447131633759,
-0.08042614907026291,
-0.6730912923812866,
-0.31607645750045776,
-0.5854288339614868,
-0.31454500555992126,
-0.0902397409081459,
-0.10275240242481232,
1.069999098777771,
1.4275418519973755,
-0.2558339834213257,
-0.20119762420654297,
-0.21553239226341248,
0.3029797375202179,
-0.5597148537635803,
-0.17251530289649963,
0.19494284689426422,
-0.2345760017633438,
-0.8487914800643921,
1.007623314857483,
0.5058462619781494,
-0.4374319016933441,
0.19696572422981262,
-0.23715132474899292,
-0.08167716860771179,
0.040507253259420395,
0.37427759170532227,
0.6339994668960571,
-0.6758870482444763,
-0.23049543797969818,
-0.3316824436187744,
-0.19310910999774933,
0.4622582495212555,
0.751914918422699,
-0.8157529234886169,
0.6392188668251038,
0.659973680973053,
0.4280782639980316,
0.6454102396965027,
-0.0416443794965744,
0.5067938566207886,
-0.47970929741859436,
0.4864817261695862,
0.3942055404186249,
0.42605382204055786,
0.24589772522449493,
-0.0033724522218108177,
0.563382625579834,
0.2326667755842209,
-0.4595962464809418,
-0.9164935350418091,
-0.07761464267969131,
-1.2430254220962524,
-0.35075458884239197,
0.6173622012138367,
0.002617762889713049,
-0.32107338309288025,
0.13675445318222046,
-0.14632287621498108,
0.2845783531665802,
-0.2731539309024811,
0.7143449187278748,
0.544008731842041,
-0.45845359563827515,
-0.5796562433242798,
-0.4803100824356079,
0.18240125477313995,
0.4666462540626526,
-0.7038954496383667,
0.09290141612291336,
0.31224289536476135,
0.622067391872406,
0.13193657994270325,
1.0371989011764526,
-0.4423578083515167,
0.737302303314209,
0.4106757342815399,
0.46471524238586426,
-0.3498229682445526,
-0.38348355889320374,
-0.36141347885131836,
0.7538341879844666,
-0.07937606424093246,
-0.7939338088035583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00886v1 | Mechanistic Interpretation through Contextual Decomposition in Transformers | 2024-07-01T01:12:20 | 2024-07-01T01:12:20 | Aliyah R. Hsu, Yeshwanth Cherapanamjeri, Anobel Y. Odisho, Peter R. Carroll, Bin Yu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformers exhibit impressive capabilities but are often regarded as black
boxes due to challenges in understanding the complex nonlinear relationships
between features. Interpreting machine learning models is of paramount
importance to mitigate risks, and mechanistic interpretability is in particular
of current interest as it opens up a window for guiding manual modifications
and reverse-engineering solutions. In this work, we introduce contextual
decomposition for transformers (CD-T), extending a prior work on CD for RNNs
and CNNs, to address mechanistic interpretation computationally efficiently.
CD-T is a flexible interpretation method for transformers. It can capture
contributions of combinations of input features or source internal components
(e.g. attention heads, feed-forward networks) to (1) final predictions or (2)
the output of any target internal component. Using CD-T, we propose a novel
algorithm for circuit discovery. On a real-world pathology report
classification task: we show CD-T distills a more faithful circuit of attention
heads with improved computational efficiency (speed up 2x) than a prior
benchmark, path patching. As a versatile interpretation method, CD-T also
exhibits exceptional capabilities for local interpretations. CD-T is shown to
reliably find words and phrases of contrasting sentiment/topic on SST-2 and
AGNews datasets. Through human experiments, we demonstrate CD-T enables users
to identify the more accurate of two models and to better trust a model's
outputs compared to alternative interpretation methods such as SHAP and LIME. | [
-0.2605712115764618,
-0.7690044045448303,
0.7353492975234985,
0.14473560452461243,
-0.3660869300365448,
0.12749895453453064,
-0.35357213020324707,
-0.2798610031604767,
0.14427998661994934,
0.4128953218460083,
-1.1017870903015137,
-0.37193652987480164,
-0.5606929063796997,
-0.030276695266366005,
-0.5653769969940186,
1.0284223556518555,
-0.025371240451931953,
-0.12049441039562225,
-0.005973482504487038,
-0.17436625063419342,
-0.39730098843574524,
-0.439822256565094,
-0.4458981156349182,
-0.4971742033958435,
0.47724679112434387,
0.24456241726875305,
0.6287297010421753,
0.4199221730232239,
0.5074801445007324,
0.27806609869003296,
-0.19161023199558258,
-0.31211936473846436,
-0.4006620943546295,
0.2908051908016205,
-0.45325997471809387,
-0.27162155508995056,
-0.2797757685184479,
0.18118686974048615,
0.04799952358007431,
0.7309069633483887,
0.015280148014426231,
0.169094055891037,
0.03243683651089668,
0.47683319449424744,
-0.5110648274421692,
0.09456923604011536,
-0.5971575379371643,
0.30924251675605774,
-0.027023252099752426,
-0.7752777338027954,
-0.7317014932632446,
0.08342895656824112,
0.5339756608009338,
-0.39591094851493835,
0.6350535154342651,
-0.379990816116333,
0.6948379278182983,
0.5623669028282166,
-0.5716598033905029,
-0.26729732751846313,
-0.8876031041145325,
0.9186074137687683,
-0.29947754740715027,
0.43381330370903015,
-0.030142566189169884,
0.7083765864372253,
0.0020716735161840916,
-0.8679123520851135,
-0.4532224237918854,
-0.20532076060771942,
-0.3055229187011719,
0.4226435720920563,
-0.3756521940231323,
-0.07888539135456085,
0.16949602961540222,
0.35688379406929016,
-0.46232518553733826,
-0.1615867018699646,
-0.45520487427711487,
-0.3920816481113434,
0.22023172676563263,
0.27397972345352173,
0.3526152968406677,
-0.44525107741355896,
-0.48138096928596497,
-0.11978902667760849,
-0.48046788573265076,
-0.24209634959697723,
-0.11834797263145447,
0.100862056016922,
-0.1853497177362442,
0.4493260979652405,
-0.20932133495807648,
0.6222644448280334,
0.0020459438674151897,
-0.10683970898389816,
0.16272565722465515,
-0.45801660418510437,
-0.364461213350296,
-0.006185495760291815,
0.5913749933242798,
0.3664834201335907,
0.13798581063747406,
-0.36474448442459106,
0.06017061322927475,
0.13839833438396454,
0.5316987633705139,
-0.7128781676292419,
-0.4156913161277771,
0.21824045479297638,
-0.9478293657302856,
-0.5736685395240784,
-0.22822080552577972,
-0.598789632320404,
-0.18203967809677124,
-0.45592954754829407,
0.1573428213596344,
-0.39393362402915955,
-0.36422818899154663,
-0.081459179520607,
-0.2816714346408844,
0.25942739844322205,
0.339125394821167,
-0.607364296913147,
0.008359278552234173,
0.4391188621520996,
0.8601365089416504,
-0.14707781374454498,
0.039518337696790695,
-0.4742943048477173,
0.19383695721626282,
0.04225052893161774,
0.7249326705932617,
-0.586997389793396,
-0.20451295375823975,
-0.3531404435634613,
0.047161199152469635,
-0.0028348828200250864,
-0.49607768654823303,
0.5931903719902039,
-0.6655787825584412,
0.03206903114914894,
0.005855883006006479,
-0.15454255044460297,
-0.18014490604400635,
0.20175431668758392,
-0.7466715574264526,
0.574368953704834,
0.4128410816192627,
-0.7791734933853149,
0.3744414448738098,
-0.7818533182144165,
-0.659594714641571,
-0.3461596667766571,
-0.023533562198281288,
-0.41520264744758606,
0.25940316915512085,
0.15601082146167755,
0.7152183055877686,
-0.3647339344024658,
0.4284055829048157,
-0.4311411380767822,
-0.1508985012769699,
0.29960086941719055,
-0.7062549591064453,
0.9761508703231812,
0.4580339193344116,
-0.5570513010025024,
0.13567958772182465,
-0.7498909831047058,
-0.2369135320186615,
0.0659872516989708,
0.17519432306289673,
-0.05752861127257347,
0.1469251662492752,
0.2253311574459076,
0.5126107335090637,
-0.034730952233076096,
-0.3949304521083832,
0.09233756363391876,
-0.32350558042526245,
0.6732961535453796,
0.6790695190429688,
0.15834657847881317,
0.5513242483139038,
0.19031722843647003,
0.5518506765365601,
0.3633834421634674,
0.21861563622951508,
-0.17661204934120178,
-0.33101263642311096,
-0.45307937264442444,
-0.035834282636642456,
0.20297293365001678,
0.4754880666732788,
-0.9354796409606934,
0.3794134557247162,
-0.4434441924095154,
-0.3870348036289215,
-0.24708087742328644,
-0.2819371819496155,
0.16405293345451355,
0.8386027812957764,
0.755289614200592,
-0.17825506627559662,
-0.4765024185180664,
-1.332708716392517,
-0.33514848351478577,
0.12191414833068848,
-0.5362997651100159,
0.2811325192451477,
0.18629957735538483,
-0.5507043600082397,
0.8505716919898987,
-0.6880624294281006,
-0.4623262882232666,
-0.2865743637084961,
0.2771058976650238,
0.21153274178504944,
0.3673141300678253,
0.3199352025985718,
-0.7545143961906433,
-0.1700385957956314,
0.21296091377735138,
-0.9199759364128113,
0.050931379199028015,
-0.3769740164279938,
0.11734639108181,
-0.12527421116828918,
0.5394210815429688,
-0.3591553568840027,
0.7177371978759766,
0.2671279013156891,
-0.28635433316230774,
0.45339569449424744,
-0.12893013656139374,
0.03874912112951279,
-0.9549223780632019,
0.15990689396858215,
0.19832147657871246,
-0.2342979460954666,
-0.658534824848175,
0.03241152688860893,
-0.04392177239060402,
0.05025031790137291,
-0.2457779049873352,
0.34017127752304077,
-0.36428722739219666,
-0.35801777243614197,
-0.13273125886917114,
0.05412442982196808,
-0.0666121169924736,
0.5865892171859741,
-0.016132274642586708,
0.5462923645973206,
0.5551407933235168,
-0.43564143776893616,
0.045457541942596436,
0.2223767638206482,
-0.2281460165977478,
0.3888084590435028,
-0.5537880659103394,
0.00766240106895566,
-0.10727439075708389,
0.5621591210365295,
-0.7354195713996887,
-0.18278510868549347,
0.49377506971359253,
-0.4173552393913269,
0.3341030180454254,
0.06252618879079819,
-0.5501379370689392,
-0.1538434624671936,
-0.14532522857189178,
0.673133909702301,
0.39126893877983093,
-0.5954694747924805,
0.834869384765625,
0.29220855236053467,
0.2670304477214813,
-0.3711722493171692,
-0.6211249828338623,
0.05994179844856262,
-0.2717357277870178,
-0.6090704798698425,
0.4789300858974457,
0.07976546138525009,
-0.2497262954711914,
-0.015170692466199398,
-0.4271233081817627,
-0.2441888004541397,
0.4290594458580017,
0.12207375466823578,
-0.019962232559919357,
-0.1172787994146347,
0.1193605363368988,
0.24540294706821442,
-0.5610215663909912,
0.1441308557987213,
-0.24814234673976898,
0.426829993724823,
0.0389537587761879,
-0.0757514089345932,
-0.5205943584442139,
0.19855718314647675,
0.636386513710022,
-0.2663321793079376,
0.43777531385421753,
0.8631750345230103,
-0.2607797086238861,
-0.348148375749588,
-0.18108485639095306,
-0.46645432710647583,
-0.4513455629348755,
0.1984047293663025,
-0.4684882164001465,
-0.624582052230835,
0.4400665760040283,
-0.2064315676689148,
-0.20368368923664093,
0.6724167466163635,
0.7401482462882996,
-0.13935942947864532,
1.0399478673934937,
0.4552701711654663,
-0.12083075195550919,
0.3080843687057495,
-0.26188814640045166,
0.4659821391105652,
-0.777711033821106,
-0.22024333477020264,
-0.33680275082588196,
-0.5363665819168091,
-0.5668278336524963,
-0.46621814370155334,
0.6498836278915405,
-0.4062415361404419,
0.09841769188642502,
0.2480688840150833,
-0.8843157291412354,
0.29931747913360596,
0.4116891622543335,
0.5546071529388428,
0.23256829380989075,
0.013520613312721252,
-0.03936156630516052,
0.0058817011304199696,
-0.487521767616272,
-0.445573091506958,
1.0950359106063843,
0.4392439126968384,
0.4142415523529053,
-0.1284891963005066,
0.45589688420295715,
0.32864347100257874,
0.5792539119720459,
-0.8518201112747192,
0.323214590549469,
-0.2488444745540619,
-0.5577352643013,
-0.09118078649044037,
-0.3492382764816284,
-0.9042925834655762,
0.020739035680890083,
0.010456508025527,
-0.8325213193893433,
0.08576271682977676,
0.16976886987686157,
-0.12598688900470734,
0.2990371882915497,
-0.6879943609237671,
0.9471691846847534,
0.05883350223302841,
-0.20759551227092743,
-0.6211560964584351,
-0.9000058770179749,
0.41814950108528137,
0.1359277367591858,
0.0020794307347387075,
0.18843454122543335,
0.35476359724998474,
0.5400417447090149,
-0.44125300645828247,
0.6241003274917603,
-0.2251662015914917,
-0.14779441058635712,
0.2602520287036896,
0.166723370552063,
0.20983262360095978,
0.07229689508676529,
-0.08912666887044907,
0.4135777950286865,
-0.14852070808410645,
-0.36725500226020813,
-0.7857843041419983,
0.6829224824905396,
-0.5136969685554504,
-0.49572280049324036,
-0.2222892791032791,
-0.7134197950363159,
-0.04027930274605751,
0.11953312158584595,
0.4336821436882019,
0.7267086505889893,
0.10130830109119415,
0.30146196484565735,
0.5148496031761169,
-0.24088744819164276,
0.3729153871536255,
-0.021367989480495453,
0.2580827474594116,
0.10744329541921616,
0.8916948437690735,
-0.10450974106788635,
0.075222909450531,
0.6285420656204224,
-0.0042020175606012344,
-0.15633846819400787,
-0.5404582023620605,
-0.3371843695640564,
-0.10536849498748779,
-0.890404462814331,
-0.0852109044790268,
-0.6911007165908813,
-0.03924403339624405,
0.28295639157295227,
-0.1763332039117813,
-0.14779865741729736,
-0.6361139416694641,
-0.4161680340766907,
-0.21698346734046936,
-0.024892346933484077,
0.584400475025177,
0.10603601485490799,
0.2949597239494324,
-0.6387320756912231,
0.559967577457428,
0.13018614053726196,
0.434750497341156,
0.09854830056428909,
-0.16292421519756317,
-0.17629243433475494,
0.08614171296358109,
-0.6278148293495178,
-1.0130047798156738,
0.24617502093315125,
-0.07820051908493042,
0.35344386100769043,
0.3872276842594147,
0.018133599311113358,
0.6562544107437134,
-0.4329356253147125,
0.5947455763816833,
0.0325971357524395,
-1.1467424631118774,
0.6183465123176575,
-0.30742180347442627,
0.07958438247442245,
0.3286696672439575,
-0.005939591210335493,
-0.2817792296409607,
-0.5434151291847229,
-0.9365431666374207,
-0.7755570411682129,
0.8536393046379089,
0.5064318776130676,
-0.20525513589382172,
0.005898138042539358,
0.40971827507019043,
0.22483853995800018,
-0.18240946531295776,
-0.696832537651062,
-0.5141739249229431,
-0.38852331042289734,
-0.2955271005630493,
-0.28543633222579956,
-0.18647170066833496,
-0.09207472205162048,
-0.14731372892856598,
0.3137093782424927,
-0.21850408613681793,
0.636963963508606,
0.37553730607032776,
-0.527799129486084,
-0.03184715658426285,
0.2191275954246521,
0.688071072101593,
0.7034103870391846,
-0.3108827471733093,
0.3337457478046417,
0.06893032044172287,
-0.14508499205112457,
0.1233658418059349,
-0.20270806550979614,
-0.013797822408378124,
0.1430114209651947,
0.6565746665000916,
0.3552563786506653,
0.3478468954563141,
-0.567101240158081,
0.40907731652259827,
-0.23995007574558258,
-0.029565177857875824,
-0.2694545388221741,
0.0030541368760168552,
-0.007135427091270685,
0.42485979199409485,
0.4810308516025543,
0.6273847818374634,
0.6803258657455444,
-0.476970911026001,
0.5392040610313416,
0.4435782730579376,
-0.7221966981887817,
-0.7422035932540894,
0.7695265412330627,
-0.07946550846099854,
-0.016792289912700653,
0.628089189529419,
-0.0514073520898819,
-0.6284873485565186,
0.7506915926933289,
0.24567058682441711,
1.2379356622695923,
-0.05362315848469734,
0.2538805902004242,
0.2774696350097656,
0.2428179681301117,
0.42688077688217163,
-0.134477436542511,
-0.24138478934764862,
-0.516185998916626,
-0.3713158071041107,
-0.4637889862060547,
-0.17733211815357208,
0.11385007947683334,
-0.9175021052360535,
0.2670578062534332,
-0.3230142891407013,
0.14763732254505157,
0.5278189182281494,
-0.36827436089515686,
-0.7901125550270081,
0.5155943632125854,
-0.10343371331691742,
0.6834198236465454,
-0.80650794506073,
0.9921246767044067,
0.4784873127937317,
-0.29545116424560547,
-0.6802301406860352,
0.5009394884109497,
-0.046823661774396896,
-0.6030343174934387,
0.9383481740951538,
0.4121420979499817,
0.07532299309968948,
-0.17988704144954681,
-0.512147068977356,
-0.5090989470481873,
1.188671588897705,
0.29002290964126587,
-0.0775773674249649,
0.13099659979343414,
-0.06211142614483833,
0.7820593118667603,
-0.33126744627952576,
0.5956537127494812,
0.7452395558357239,
0.5176815390586853,
-0.018545767292380333,
-0.7739577293395996,
0.3968003988265991,
-0.13055604696273804,
-0.21123480796813965,
0.22809220850467682,
-0.3116898834705353,
0.8767465949058533,
-0.08057207614183426,
-0.45115843415260315,
-0.242409348487854,
0.4332937002182007,
-0.08776645362377167,
0.568728506565094,
0.42602404952049255,
0.22237630188465118,
0.3515106737613678,
-0.19850607216358185,
1.2526057958602905,
-0.3670422434806824,
0.6430073976516724,
0.6755914688110352,
0.16078977286815643,
0.42524757981300354,
0.5367028117179871,
-0.10241985321044922,
0.5860756039619446,
0.598834216594696,
-0.024617044255137444,
0.7692626714706421,
0.07626821100711823,
-0.015410576947033405,
-0.34582820534706116,
0.09746802598237991,
-0.0937800407409668,
0.5352893471717834,
0.4144444465637207,
-0.6409809589385986,
-0.5498228669166565,
-0.016763880848884583,
-0.2004193216562271,
-0.21484947204589844,
-0.19853471219539642,
0.7270423769950867,
0.05977080389857292,
-0.6820513010025024,
0.6029343008995056,
-0.015275646932423115,
0.24989184737205505,
-0.10452428460121155,
-0.23050859570503235,
0.018699606880545616,
0.3977340757846832,
-0.35452181100845337,
-0.6770102977752686,
0.7565995454788208,
-0.3329954147338867,
-0.4592525362968445,
-0.41670969128608704,
0.7919013500213623,
-0.15354298055171967,
-0.3283633291721344,
0.5351015329360962,
0.41395890712738037,
-0.043521638959646225,
-0.1919146031141281,
-0.5461243391036987,
-0.09068360924720764,
0.28582194447517395,
-0.3323782682418823,
0.13853894174098969,
0.4016428589820862,
-0.23664827644824982,
0.8749669194221497,
0.4797486662864685,
-0.3946002423763275,
-0.2319016456604004,
-0.14072348177433014,
1.0370337963104248,
-0.8103723526000977,
-0.26725026965141296,
-0.8942826986312866,
0.7391664981842041,
-0.023487363010644913,
-0.10025961697101593,
0.44296368956565857,
0.23844082653522491,
0.6750552654266357,
-0.2948008179664612,
0.8356419205665588,
-0.04241183027625084,
0.3560810685157776,
-0.4782443642616272,
0.595015823841095,
-0.5946398377418518,
0.4658600091934204,
-0.3115939795970917,
-0.8423289656639099,
-0.45473864674568176,
0.6255053281784058,
-0.3672172427177429,
-0.06370928883552551,
0.8498221635818481,
0.4905175566673279,
-0.42319247126579285,
0.22879280149936676,
0.13753923773765564,
0.44981256127357483,
0.45814767479896545,
0.5167087316513062,
0.7055883407592773,
-0.43651261925697327,
0.5299320816993713,
-0.4100660979747772,
-0.3515664339065552,
-0.35777878761291504,
-0.7619746923446655,
-0.8451274037361145,
-0.6867631077766418,
-0.24993088841438293,
-0.28414231538772583,
-0.3592666685581207,
0.5993842482566833,
0.6011812090873718,
-0.950872540473938,
0.059635140001773834,
-0.2540026903152466,
0.36791718006134033,
-0.39804941415786743,
-0.2706582844257355,
0.576061487197876,
-0.41138914227485657,
-0.5230475664138794,
0.46347638964653015,
0.5820519924163818,
-0.47166791558265686,
-0.17376728355884552,
0.1316901594400406,
0.1834547519683838,
-0.3312463164329529,
0.8355412483215332,
-0.15072858333587646,
-0.824320375919342,
-0.47783714532852173,
0.17358525097370148,
0.214542418718338,
0.18138597905635834,
1.0278478860855103,
-1.0083612203598022,
0.6190351247787476,
0.22751079499721527,
0.5128877758979797,
0.6380766034126282,
-0.11702020466327667,
0.8543965220451355,
-0.8637446761131287,
0.18661119043827057,
0.3430708348751068,
0.43069663643836975,
0.14527302980422974,
-0.4630332291126251,
0.71702641248703,
0.21315938234329224,
-0.2621431052684784,
-0.722133994102478,
0.4906868636608124,
-1.2945448160171509,
-0.4571685791015625,
0.9279930591583252,
-0.06365562230348587,
-0.13681572675704956,
-0.2677323520183563,
0.006945405155420303,
0.46898210048675537,
-0.0487603023648262,
0.886380672454834,
0.38566353917121887,
-0.15150442719459534,
-0.14283113181591034,
-0.48949864506721497,
0.4466228485107422,
0.4521189332008362,
-0.6276225447654724,
-0.03129476308822632,
0.3767768144607544,
0.26844877004623413,
0.4475083649158478,
0.22600242495536804,
-0.07433098554611206,
0.4413259029388428,
-0.2827617824077606,
-0.14883330464363098,
0.14439910650253296,
-0.3139851987361908,
-0.2910560369491577,
0.3552384078502655,
-0.467152863740921,
-0.017581162974238396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00870v1 | Roleplay-doh: Enabling Domain-Experts to Create LLM-simulated Patients via Eliciting and Adhering to Principles | 2024-07-01T00:43:02 | 2024-07-01T00:43:02 | Ryan Louie, Ananjan Nandi, William Fang, Cheng Chang, Emma Brunskill, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Recent works leverage LLMs to roleplay realistic social scenarios, aiding
novices in practicing their social skills. However, simulating sensitive
interactions, such as in mental health, is challenging. Privacy concerns
restrict data access, and collecting expert feedback, although vital, is
laborious. To address this, we develop Roleplay-doh, a novel human-LLM
collaboration pipeline that elicits qualitative feedback from a domain-expert,
which is transformed into a set of principles, or natural language rules, that
govern an LLM-prompted roleplay. We apply this pipeline to enable senior mental
health supporters to create customized AI patients for simulated practice
partners for novice counselors. After uncovering issues in GPT-4 simulations
not adhering to expert-defined principles, we also introduce a novel
principle-adherence prompting pipeline which shows 30\% improvements in
response quality and principle following for the downstream task. Via a user
study with 25 counseling experts, we demonstrate that the pipeline makes it
easy and effective to create AI patients that more faithfully resemble real
patients, as judged by creators and third-party counselors. | [
-0.47473353147506714,
-0.7871949076652527,
0.9553651213645935,
0.030520062893629074,
0.03834476321935654,
0.09756896644830704,
-0.01725958101451397,
-0.14379313588142395,
0.325435072183609,
0.6996629238128662,
-0.8531646132469177,
-0.5759652256965637,
-0.24130605161190033,
-0.11133567243814468,
0.22200243175029755,
0.9901995062828064,
-0.11706418544054031,
0.22939442098140717,
-0.3267632722854614,
0.3673502504825592,
-0.589556097984314,
-0.32107582688331604,
-0.7673558592796326,
-0.3994055986404419,
0.6437233686447144,
0.5874359011650085,
0.7468433380126953,
0.488992840051651,
0.587535560131073,
0.23861511051654816,
0.49563494324684143,
0.15796327590942383,
-0.6153926849365234,
0.17904013395309448,
-0.0747411921620369,
-0.5998262763023376,
-1.0722107887268066,
0.23527367413043976,
0.13682669401168823,
0.5038387775421143,
-0.4481777548789978,
-0.006325472146272659,
0.05654379352927208,
0.35771799087524414,
-0.27350497245788574,
0.27416446805000305,
-0.5049710273742676,
0.1977534145116806,
-0.16860240697860718,
-0.4123656153678894,
-0.18409065902233124,
-0.15400592982769012,
0.3089868724346161,
-0.8729743361473083,
0.5385567545890808,
0.1776731163263321,
0.4085698127746582,
0.4778975248336792,
-0.2837774157524109,
-0.010661025531589985,
-0.7068694233894348,
0.28004756569862366,
-0.9593883156776428,
0.013112814165651798,
0.587540328502655,
0.4671402871608734,
-0.3777831494808197,
-0.5940017700195312,
-0.5398488640785217,
-0.24775369465351105,
-0.1509331464767456,
0.16098330914974213,
0.11086191982030869,
0.6685232520103455,
0.4099206030368805,
0.2688866853713989,
-0.3395521640777588,
-0.02904539555311203,
-0.36280760169029236,
-0.07077843695878983,
0.8761979937553406,
0.25156691670417786,
0.40795838832855225,
0.20748095214366913,
-0.18505467474460602,
0.3614272475242615,
-0.6920759677886963,
0.007109920959919691,
0.07210326194763184,
0.05299900844693184,
-0.1974630206823349,
0.5088829398155212,
0.2652578353881836,
0.2231164127588272,
0.3956925570964813,
-0.14097340404987335,
-0.1788434088230133,
0.14593704044818878,
-0.2796688675880432,
0.3297434449195862,
0.60089510679245,
0.7471536993980408,
0.18578921258449554,
-0.23008756339550018,
0.14953672885894775,
0.11839327961206436,
0.8153165578842163,
-0.5477964878082275,
-0.5307009220123291,
0.2577763497829437,
-0.448436975479126,
-0.25635936856269836,
-0.013641158118844032,
-0.5442172884941101,
-0.3197416663169861,
-0.6190606951713562,
0.6364526152610779,
-0.5622873902320862,
-0.37503111362457275,
-0.060524288564920425,
0.023086760193109512,
0.08923230320215225,
0.5086187124252319,
-0.8764387965202332,
0.8472514152526855,
0.8334839344024658,
0.6854206919670105,
-0.2796747088432312,
-0.5096387267112732,
-0.8156827688217163,
0.5728142857551575,
-0.2766485810279846,
0.47955137491226196,
-0.27411404252052307,
-0.595833420753479,
-0.11995453387498856,
-0.16939513385295868,
-0.002062737476080656,
-0.5940219163894653,
0.3573760688304901,
-0.3568320870399475,
0.182572141289711,
-0.3991137146949768,
-0.6718616485595703,
0.3422304093837738,
0.31622520089149475,
-0.2273901402950287,
0.49567821621894836,
0.16006554663181305,
-0.6859910488128662,
0.4614180624485016,
-0.8740737438201904,
-0.06678058952093124,
0.47496071457862854,
-0.4092102348804474,
-0.0468018539249897,
0.19749629497528076,
0.17161335051059723,
0.4444679915904999,
-0.09708527475595474,
0.2787279784679413,
-0.4438458979129791,
-0.6545513272285461,
0.19459806382656097,
-0.3012128174304962,
0.36910873651504517,
0.06717708706855774,
-0.35566410422325134,
0.3460540473461151,
-0.29263046383857727,
-0.051332756876945496,
-0.1609635055065155,
0.10456851124763489,
-0.2622964084148407,
-0.11924312263727188,
-0.11372608691453934,
0.17679928243160248,
-0.16598494350910187,
-0.4632050395011902,
0.2512983977794647,
-0.10545393079519272,
0.4771616458892822,
0.7283257246017456,
0.33981630206108093,
0.27864471077919006,
-0.7785077095031738,
0.7423427700996399,
-0.14291857182979584,
0.15735793113708496,
0.05936596170067787,
-0.6239403486251831,
-0.4060573875904083,
-0.6707125306129456,
-0.048599567264318466,
0.4857068359851837,
-0.7534664869308472,
0.4017333686351776,
0.04650668054819107,
-0.33525168895721436,
-0.8213872909545898,
-0.012782488949596882,
0.2502990663051605,
0.7202049493789673,
0.44192007184028625,
-0.4340413808822632,
-0.47752049565315247,
-0.7494035959243774,
-0.125630185008049,
-0.429598331451416,
-0.23821015655994415,
0.5133464932441711,
0.10839761793613434,
-0.379683256149292,
1.0533878803253174,
-0.5996918082237244,
-0.5069835186004639,
0.014427946880459785,
0.20333713293075562,
-0.10311264544725418,
0.5278292298316956,
0.29321402311325073,
-0.3656768798828125,
-0.6309537291526794,
-0.37989211082458496,
-0.9194974303245544,
-0.1628250628709793,
0.05960369482636452,
-0.227186918258667,
-0.12527740001678467,
0.5857322216033936,
-0.6104534268379211,
0.43270567059516907,
0.4401392638683319,
-0.28561919927597046,
0.3153977692127228,
-0.5566868185997009,
0.29771316051483154,
-1.1099066734313965,
0.01221537683159113,
0.024807682260870934,
-0.2633174955844879,
-0.6607483625411987,
-0.0021210068371146917,
-0.43626171350479126,
-0.3299930691719055,
-0.28824692964553833,
0.2343655675649643,
-0.07925542443990707,
0.20616751909255981,
-0.13680575788021088,
-0.05833577737212181,
-0.34799885749816895,
0.3989808261394501,
0.11360836774110794,
0.6568344831466675,
0.7051463723182678,
-0.4411569833755493,
0.33223792910575867,
0.26544249057769775,
0.25994762778282166,
1.0778101682662964,
-0.7663623094558716,
0.3235359191894531,
0.12518943846225739,
0.4704532325267792,
-0.8292455077171326,
-0.6634518504142761,
0.34773027896881104,
-0.14281441271305084,
0.27101942896842957,
-0.3435846269130707,
-0.36690396070480347,
-0.2209136188030243,
-0.22692684829235077,
0.26892876625061035,
0.7221250534057617,
-0.008342337794601917,
0.42193421721458435,
0.39782121777534485,
-0.27649593353271484,
-0.4319286048412323,
-0.57630854845047,
0.36138272285461426,
-0.30823951959609985,
-0.5995045304298401,
0.9062634706497192,
-0.28623923659324646,
-0.40301933884620667,
0.12324270606040955,
0.17162322998046875,
0.021809913218021393,
0.20234160125255585,
0.40790456533432007,
0.23760409653186798,
-0.07310938090085983,
-0.27859699726104736,
0.3163824677467346,
-0.21152855455875397,
0.4070482552051544,
0.06465987116098404,
0.32355305552482605,
-0.07187411934137344,
-0.7008153200149536,
-0.7025073766708374,
0.6173695921897888,
0.5263860821723938,
0.12170195579528809,
0.2778244614601135,
0.5511563420295715,
-0.4332345426082611,
-0.13800814747810364,
-0.5385309457778931,
-0.7195406556129456,
-0.47636088728904724,
-0.09147263318300247,
-0.1162814125418663,
-0.9701933264732361,
0.16207444667816162,
-0.12957000732421875,
0.27237987518310547,
-0.11537142843008041,
0.5380739569664001,
-0.3657827377319336,
0.8718137741088867,
0.40179821848869324,
0.37703487277030945,
-0.11995075643062592,
-0.0568205900490284,
0.25836676359176636,
-0.6670736074447632,
-0.09605187177658081,
0.25168487429618835,
-0.46450701355934143,
-0.4968169927597046,
-0.8628277778625488,
0.5645529627799988,
0.12603627145290375,
-0.3238672614097595,
0.06323562562465668,
-0.3641841411590576,
0.07103855907917023,
0.6071341633796692,
0.4143387973308563,
0.31328511238098145,
-0.1911550909280777,
-0.3139406442642212,
-0.560462236404419,
-0.5450868010520935,
-0.638660192489624,
0.8451080918312073,
0.4538838565349579,
0.6148815751075745,
0.19229093194007874,
1.2707147598266602,
0.4391220211982727,
0.665497899055481,
-0.7872557044029236,
0.7234285473823547,
0.26899024844169617,
-0.6017097234725952,
-0.2544699013233185,
-0.2316269874572754,
-0.6948270201683044,
-0.20549526810646057,
-0.2542327046394348,
-0.5272290706634521,
-0.0902790054678917,
0.49787044525146484,
-0.6298013925552368,
0.19991856813430786,
-0.49365419149398804,
0.6248873472213745,
0.0812143012881279,
-0.5530669689178467,
-0.4049187898635864,
-0.8664406538009644,
0.2572365701198578,
-0.005350205115973949,
0.09040134400129318,
-0.21554380655288696,
-0.14098016917705536,
0.17472903430461884,
-0.6462582945823669,
1.0887202024459839,
-0.4098249077796936,
-0.20665055513381958,
0.17954587936401367,
0.33523672819137573,
0.07905805110931396,
0.5055793523788452,
0.04961699992418289,
-0.06921281665563583,
0.00005675770080415532,
-0.25058695673942566,
-0.7676868438720703,
0.8542781472206116,
-0.8860042095184326,
-1.1154762506484985,
-0.1701653152704239,
-0.6520844101905823,
-0.56132972240448,
0.02738983929157257,
0.1653602123260498,
0.1142372116446495,
-0.6168996095657349,
0.014550534076988697,
0.6133379340171814,
0.10828815400600433,
0.18953680992126465,
0.3633335530757904,
-0.09084521979093552,
-0.45361199975013733,
0.7280544638633728,
0.0937965139746666,
0.04033704847097397,
0.04815034940838814,
0.24834533035755157,
-0.08794064074754715,
-0.3075459599494934,
-0.37216341495513916,
0.30929234623908997,
-0.13733027875423431,
0.11732371151447296,
-0.6798410415649414,
-0.4191267490386963,
-0.43607938289642334,
-0.522428035736084,
-0.040715985000133514,
-0.025024699047207832,
-0.30738914012908936,
-0.013260025531053543,
0.43572959303855896,
0.6567493677139282,
-0.32270050048828125,
0.29399698972702026,
-0.8268697261810303,
0.3079981505870819,
0.8270868062973022,
0.32784703373908997,
-0.011834965087473392,
-0.11417718231678009,
-0.019744068384170532,
0.06127951294183731,
-0.5361981391906738,
-0.749474048614502,
0.3165755867958069,
-0.0010173639748245478,
0.8630642294883728,
0.4120648503303528,
0.32806628942489624,
0.7706254124641418,
-0.7082366347312927,
0.8065088987350464,
0.11516623944044113,
-0.911853015422821,
0.5383859872817993,
-0.8153234124183655,
-0.2717832326889038,
0.691942572593689,
0.5382494926452637,
-0.5668291449546814,
-0.3708265423774719,
-0.7379956245422363,
-0.5121326446533203,
0.8758196234703064,
0.32239675521850586,
0.1375514417886734,
-0.053628161549568176,
0.6745171546936035,
0.11077701300382614,
0.4312763512134552,
-0.27186429500579834,
-0.30298322439193726,
-0.14025495946407318,
-0.33192455768585205,
0.0671270415186882,
-0.049052320420742035,
-0.7294151186943054,
0.018220193684101105,
0.2955534756183624,
-0.2689310908317566,
0.46660640835762024,
0.4957641065120697,
0.36277544498443604,
-0.5072752237319946,
0.04541062191128731,
0.3428308367729187,
0.49524205923080444,
-0.36068621277809143,
0.2588583827018738,
0.15028263628482819,
-0.45098215341567993,
0.13890422880649567,
0.15090835094451904,
0.07811849564313889,
-0.34333425760269165,
0.3506232500076294,
0.5632584691047668,
0.17940914630889893,
-0.4287758767604828,
0.37468746304512024,
-0.2897476553916931,
-0.5927905440330505,
-0.1950976848602295,
0.5272652506828308,
0.2694969177246094,
0.22035720944404602,
0.2253265082836151,
0.23397335410118103,
0.26811692118644714,
-0.6338398456573486,
0.6492486000061035,
0.1694687008857727,
-0.701930046081543,
-0.46689778566360474,
0.8756521940231323,
0.3599836230278015,
-0.8863341808319092,
0.42264696955680847,
0.13053962588310242,
-0.07222206145524979,
0.4836256802082062,
0.43403103947639465,
0.6644514799118042,
-0.20514561235904694,
0.4687662124633789,
-0.07674755156040192,
-0.2626403272151947,
-0.263155996799469,
0.32445546984672546,
-0.027475696057081223,
-0.5878748893737793,
-0.3887045681476593,
0.22517970204353333,
-0.772375762462616,
-0.06148539483547211,
-0.9106636643409729,
0.4755714535713196,
-0.5940185189247131,
-0.394004762172699,
-0.39114910364151,
0.11595942080020905,
-0.6147441267967224,
-0.011352505534887314,
0.1862013190984726,
0.467886358499527,
-0.5269831418991089,
0.7838982939720154,
0.8801848292350769,
-0.19358493387699127,
-0.792087197303772,
0.4409560561180115,
0.297782838344574,
-0.704345166683197,
0.3121315538883209,
0.17085380852222443,
0.01965239830315113,
0.2204059660434723,
-0.4609123468399048,
-0.3000144064426422,
1.473650574684143,
0.5122440457344055,
-0.44356071949005127,
-0.36735856533050537,
0.013148108497262001,
0.9230901002883911,
-0.6530144810676575,
0.2108410745859146,
0.1972387731075287,
0.2395513504743576,
0.24263344705104828,
-0.8981108665466309,
0.21696887910366058,
-0.16241022944450378,
-0.19566594064235687,
-0.32402193546295166,
-0.7726219892501831,
0.5874010324478149,
-0.44073131680488586,
0.20406030118465424,
-0.09102294594049454,
0.5232918858528137,
0.8882631063461304,
0.6276922821998596,
0.7831235527992249,
0.42553335428237915,
0.7236490249633789,
0.3515147566795349,
0.6090983748435974,
-0.4876713454723358,
-0.009867516346275806,
1.0812914371490479,
-0.7700956463813782,
0.5687277913093567,
0.5992618799209595,
0.04989100992679596,
0.39264726638793945,
0.6489766240119934,
0.018979063257575035,
0.49144887924194336,
0.40523162484169006,
-0.286986380815506,
-0.399982750415802,
-0.3727184236049652,
-0.30278003215789795,
0.18565432727336884,
0.3957686126232147,
-0.24407698214054108,
0.14538653194904327,
-0.40541666746139526,
0.21529316902160645,
0.22877350449562073,
-0.10937093943357468,
0.7530562877655029,
0.4429362714290619,
-0.8332655429840088,
0.04788709059357643,
-0.2726180851459503,
0.5711060762405396,
-0.4571727216243744,
-0.4972061812877655,
-0.02174532227218151,
0.056427162140607834,
-0.22397445142269135,
-0.6579728126525879,
0.15469178557395935,
-0.1655902862548828,
-0.0777130201458931,
-0.4016255736351013,
0.3961685001850128,
-0.539314329624176,
-0.3449377715587616,
0.2827061712741852,
0.85508131980896,
0.1415172964334488,
0.24366368353366852,
-0.7417157292366028,
-0.34965693950653076,
-0.2820301353931427,
0.024461032822728157,
0.5343076586723328,
0.6470618844032288,
-0.020743943750858307,
0.4244699478149414,
0.5777386426925659,
0.31558918952941895,
-0.4802790582180023,
0.11923037469387054,
0.9064587950706482,
-0.2665378451347351,
-0.22970730066299438,
-0.7165440917015076,
0.4329735040664673,
-0.20125603675842285,
-0.3787935972213745,
0.6260700225830078,
0.1585778445005417,
0.4481375217437744,
-0.030473308637738228,
0.7237634062767029,
0.12845180928707123,
0.37467148900032043,
-0.27186092734336853,
0.8089394569396973,
-0.44434645771980286,
0.2981507182121277,
-0.4143330454826355,
-0.7007015347480774,
-0.29681992530822754,
0.44190114736557007,
-0.0925024077296257,
-0.005661094095557928,
0.4119338393211365,
0.7478740811347961,
0.01604335382580757,
-0.08303467929363251,
0.5207589268684387,
0.06078043207526207,
0.7800931930541992,
0.5563260912895203,
0.7687355279922485,
-0.06698282808065414,
0.10075776278972626,
-0.2875511348247528,
-0.354512095451355,
-0.18682539463043213,
-0.8965710401535034,
-1.1261836290359497,
-0.21706457436084747,
-0.4704030454158783,
-0.29706794023513794,
-0.021464768797159195,
1.5092248916625977,
0.9219344854354858,
-0.43691885471343994,
-0.2479998767375946,
-0.31215915083885193,
-0.3056836426258087,
-0.4904973804950714,
-0.24122314155101776,
0.2553197145462036,
-0.20061416923999786,
-0.523675262928009,
0.4448457658290863,
0.18651708960533142,
0.07579373568296432,
-0.6083933115005493,
-0.2574884593486786,
0.16835568845272064,
0.09525442868471146,
0.10851654410362244,
-0.03745361417531967,
-0.6484233140945435,
-0.026321688666939735,
0.2532784342765808,
-0.22812071442604065,
0.08261273056268692,
1.2066254615783691,
-0.7102382779121399,
0.2505839765071869,
0.2016550749540329,
0.4116424322128296,
0.3312593698501587,
0.11545715481042862,
1.236158013343811,
-0.46282947063446045,
-0.19006459414958954,
0.4623321294784546,
0.0963481143116951,
0.13074344396591187,
-0.9184344410896301,
0.5338499546051025,
0.2760070562362671,
-0.7630615830421448,
-0.701319694519043,
0.10485157370567322,
-0.9104494452476501,
0.08778303116559982,
0.87351393699646,
-0.7908279299736023,
0.06804094463586807,
-0.47474241256713867,
-0.6654334664344788,
0.09249920397996902,
-0.7312574982643127,
1.0297874212265015,
0.3944019675254822,
-0.517780065536499,
-0.2834898829460144,
-0.5222004055976868,
0.862381100654602,
0.26399633288383484,
-0.734358012676239,
-0.08400335907936096,
0.4605427086353302,
0.27756333351135254,
-0.12965978682041168,
1.0928624868392944,
0.004901480861008167,
0.20109005272388458,
-0.2063903957605362,
-0.11833678185939789,
-0.2322901040315628,
-0.20993627607822418,
0.11519334465265274,
0.001975220860913396,
0.26069188117980957,
0.320568323135376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00869v1 | Large Language Models Are Involuntary Truth-Tellers: Exploiting Fallacy Failure for Jailbreak Attacks | 2024-07-01T00:23:43 | 2024-07-01T00:23:43 | Yue Zhou, Henry Peng Zou, Barbara Di Eugenio, Yang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We find that language models have difficulties generating fallacious and
deceptive reasoning. When asked to generate deceptive outputs, language models
tend to leak honest counterparts but believe them to be false. Exploiting this
deficiency, we propose a jailbreak attack method that elicits an aligned
language model for malicious output. Specifically, we query the model to
generate a fallacious yet deceptively real procedure for the harmful behavior.
Since a fallacious procedure is generally considered fake and thus harmless by
LLMs, it helps bypass the safeguard mechanism. Yet the output is factually
harmful since the LLM cannot fabricate fallacious solutions but proposes
truthful ones. We evaluate our approach over five safety-aligned large language
models, comparing four previous jailbreak methods, and show that our approach
achieves competitive performance with more harmful outputs. We believe the
findings could be extended beyond model safety, such as self-verification and
hallucination. | [
0.15561315417289734,
-0.8981771469116211,
0.719773530960083,
-0.07127745449542999,
-0.14493457973003387,
0.12887820601463318,
-0.15652556717395782,
-0.4799038767814636,
0.05263460800051689,
1.0275895595550537,
-0.4084218442440033,
-0.4104181230068207,
-0.6549025774002075,
-0.2387447953224182,
-0.5763803720474243,
0.9993687868118286,
0.04252030700445175,
-0.15564396977424622,
0.24597395956516266,
0.04779990762472153,
-0.6734848618507385,
-0.6406873464584351,
-0.2706340253353119,
-0.26716580986976624,
0.2332594394683838,
0.19910463690757751,
0.7531666159629822,
0.6000573039054871,
0.5695288777351379,
0.34979143738746643,
0.17049150168895721,
-0.004859488923102617,
-0.5366668105125427,
0.27136310935020447,
-0.35135355591773987,
-0.5520297884941101,
-0.2993850111961365,
0.38150590658187866,
0.2297825813293457,
0.22329579293727875,
-0.4997784197330475,
-0.07637181133031845,
-0.3694431483745575,
0.7428072094917297,
-0.6493499875068665,
-0.24899818003177643,
-1.2056199312210083,
-0.16526636481285095,
-0.32534000277519226,
0.26562923192977905,
-1.07953941822052,
-0.5302129983901978,
-0.2654317021369934,
-0.08681586384773254,
-0.1838357299566269,
0.1041971892118454,
0.8066555857658386,
0.34690093994140625,
-0.08636191487312317,
-0.5223549604415894,
-0.7119583487510681,
0.7182012796401978,
-1.1410326957702637,
0.16989366710186005,
0.19577763974666595,
0.4882054626941681,
-0.2180495411157608,
-0.3760031461715698,
-0.5281194448471069,
-0.8527926802635193,
0.04820655286312103,
-0.18977859616279602,
-0.28689590096473694,
0.024355947971343994,
0.3884161710739136,
0.07938113063573837,
-0.3318403661251068,
0.300645112991333,
-0.41077905893325806,
-0.24513758718967438,
0.761459469795227,
0.16524405777454376,
0.6327981948852539,
-0.2301437109708786,
-0.5367797613143921,
0.054286323487758636,
-1.0298759937286377,
-0.28899505734443665,
0.8298733234405518,
0.3865789771080017,
-0.2685807943344116,
0.6635864973068237,
0.3279125392436981,
0.7305936217308044,
0.1344379335641861,
-0.30159568786621094,
-0.14377287030220032,
-0.09674717485904694,
-0.08132191747426987,
0.4574815034866333,
0.9563212990760803,
0.3847541809082031,
0.3926243185997009,
-0.2939038574695587,
-0.2874893546104431,
0.222341850399971,
0.582354724407196,
-0.7711285352706909,
-0.26205530762672424,
0.2897602617740631,
-0.24134504795074463,
-0.8975424766540527,
0.03819989785552025,
-0.6819568872451782,
-0.7100411653518677,
0.1597622185945511,
0.32223695516586304,
-0.5800606608390808,
-0.24191530048847198,
0.16737684607505798,
-0.13245543837547302,
0.06836192309856415,
0.04565197601914406,
-0.821246325969696,
0.35113370418548584,
0.7040066123008728,
0.7290318608283997,
-0.010923848487436771,
-0.05564047023653984,
-0.5840887427330017,
0.3048710227012634,
-0.5204706192016602,
0.3081274628639221,
-0.5301371216773987,
-0.18256117403507233,
-0.13997891545295715,
-0.27632206678390503,
-0.02283180132508278,
-0.5337318778038025,
0.5069263577461243,
-0.6344832181930542,
-0.13343149423599243,
0.05973108485341072,
-0.47453054785728455,
-0.05840776488184929,
0.1928478330373764,
-0.7859185934066772,
0.44809281826019287,
-0.17704255878925323,
-0.8734862208366394,
0.03420897200703621,
-0.43852707743644714,
-0.4909566342830658,
-0.23820336163043976,
-0.1289919912815094,
-0.5188071727752686,
0.20449389517307281,
-0.023509275168180466,
0.3045477569103241,
-0.08712228387594223,
0.6433020830154419,
-0.49402907490730286,
-0.09094536304473877,
0.6664389371871948,
-0.7120389342308044,
0.9666643142700195,
0.3163749873638153,
-0.4871104061603546,
-0.19310404360294342,
-0.6009525060653687,
-0.21876786649227142,
0.4776034653186798,
-0.30320504307746887,
-0.5198500752449036,
0.20711767673492432,
-0.34577539563179016,
0.1504184752702713,
0.4130604565143585,
-0.8614920377731323,
0.28916364908218384,
-0.7184693217277527,
0.583027184009552,
0.8982335925102234,
-0.08545703440904617,
0.16004084050655365,
-0.21409937739372253,
0.36061999201774597,
0.05564745143055916,
0.10626818984746933,
-0.12214486300945282,
-0.17692552506923676,
-0.3800674378871918,
-0.12608641386032104,
0.246417835354805,
0.5644102096557617,
-0.497239887714386,
0.2738213539123535,
-0.24562634527683258,
-0.7041312456130981,
-0.6007913947105408,
0.19610971212387085,
0.7405650019645691,
0.7021859884262085,
0.09608188271522522,
-0.051874540746212006,
-0.43107956647872925,
-1.1122528314590454,
-0.6698518991470337,
-0.44119948148727417,
0.3606947362422943,
-0.05137628689408302,
0.5082284808158875,
-0.07519341260194778,
0.6177203059196472,
-0.4625406265258789,
-0.025507057085633278,
-0.4014248847961426,
0.17406243085861206,
0.49451327323913574,
0.5975810289382935,
0.6745575666427612,
-0.5596341490745544,
-0.1342419683933258,
-0.17787790298461914,
-0.8438372015953064,
-0.21905486285686493,
-0.18094076216220856,
0.13134580850601196,
0.4463637173175812,
0.43892359733581543,
-0.7297928929328918,
0.24833495914936066,
0.6292684078216553,
-0.47297242283821106,
0.9608346819877625,
0.05733036249876022,
0.06862105429172516,
-1.042826771736145,
-0.1509409099817276,
0.015951013192534447,
-0.32203996181488037,
-0.6525353193283081,
0.5174933671951294,
0.08547859638929367,
-0.1323230117559433,
-0.48517465591430664,
0.3389514684677124,
-0.2717644274234772,
0.3341407775878906,
-0.33810678124427795,
0.05302303656935692,
-0.05269923806190491,
0.0224099513143301,
-0.17087282240390778,
0.800068736076355,
0.390224814414978,
-0.2646411955356598,
0.5750210881233215,
0.10171303153038025,
-0.2016419768333435,
0.23697218298912048,
-0.6533770561218262,
0.2228008508682251,
-0.11784297972917557,
0.04283049330115318,
-0.9009182453155518,
-0.40828078985214233,
0.18287405371665955,
-0.4887305796146393,
0.5077407360076904,
-0.3529036045074463,
-0.4897472560405731,
-0.32879185676574707,
-0.3831327259540558,
0.13508392870426178,
0.6250983476638794,
-0.6664438247680664,
0.3792329728603363,
0.4704209864139557,
0.038776155561208725,
-0.7326037883758545,
-1.021054744720459,
0.22739377617835999,
-0.5379704833030701,
-0.7290764451026917,
0.08488290011882782,
0.15942686796188354,
-0.6506020426750183,
-0.20943045616149902,
-0.12499213218688965,
0.22264035046100616,
0.288611501455307,
0.286822110414505,
0.5218852758407593,
-0.055809538811445236,
-0.26206013560295105,
-0.13343310356140137,
0.07015292346477509,
0.528157651424408,
-0.06706693023443222,
0.5023981928825378,
-0.05869482085108757,
-0.5050761103630066,
-0.3394741415977478,
0.3207539916038513,
0.7994280457496643,
-0.13498391211032867,
0.9117224216461182,
-0.12581153213977814,
-0.30613937973976135,
-0.3452710509300232,
-0.7589514255523682,
-0.2452448159456253,
-0.5353336334228516,
0.37228405475616455,
-0.2552604675292969,
-0.7986072301864624,
0.3976573348045349,
-0.08120114356279373,
0.35475954413414,
0.09054462611675262,
0.5257151126861572,
0.12003398686647415,
1.099685549736023,
0.5238884687423706,
-0.33079859614372253,
0.08420860022306442,
0.12600445747375488,
0.6601537466049194,
-0.4669032394886017,
-0.10866228491067886,
-0.5311980843544006,
0.016607357189059258,
-0.5278993844985962,
-0.21968545019626617,
0.17787154018878937,
0.1677621603012085,
-0.30446475744247437,
0.6304701566696167,
-0.40576156973838806,
0.6306445002555847,
0.23468796908855438,
0.0007019864860922098,
0.2542320787906647,
-0.11952751129865646,
-0.2615983486175537,
-0.23735685646533966,
-0.34338438510894775,
-0.7935889363288879,
1.0508909225463867,
0.5811260938644409,
1.1924716234207153,
0.4669940769672394,
0.814304530620575,
0.3010401725769043,
0.4862259328365326,
-0.5957064628601074,
0.5717676281929016,
-0.09785910695791245,
-0.8060081005096436,
-0.10625659674406052,
-0.36545529961586,
-0.5171730518341064,
0.09903885424137115,
0.10122963041067123,
-1.2709842920303345,
-0.2318350374698639,
0.3486504852771759,
-0.13317209482192993,
0.516901433467865,
-0.9657816290855408,
0.7964255213737488,
-0.4339463412761688,
-0.4321895241737366,
-0.16960875689983368,
-0.6804288625717163,
1.2108877897262573,
-0.36689165234565735,
0.48474547266960144,
-0.18510809540748596,
0.31263959407806396,
0.646295428276062,
-0.6829140186309814,
1.0638915300369263,
-0.19289475679397583,
-0.23615588247776031,
0.2520992159843445,
0.708436906337738,
0.8171305060386658,
-0.012384824454784393,
-0.3736787736415863,
0.01064799353480339,
-0.2825970947742462,
-0.18208922445774078,
-0.5611681342124939,
0.77913898229599,
-0.5772626996040344,
-1.2165699005126953,
-0.3898175060749054,
-0.5135195255279541,
-0.17625007033348083,
0.14125314354896545,
0.14009995758533478,
0.3680287003517151,
-0.08578474819660187,
-0.23031949996948242,
0.5813201665878296,
-0.24497902393341064,
0.5450713038444519,
0.6136887073516846,
-0.35323068499565125,
-0.1824159473180771,
0.8689648509025574,
-0.10319134593009949,
0.6447380781173706,
-0.0801965743303299,
0.23568138480186462,
-0.282912015914917,
-0.7376184463500977,
-0.3198418617248535,
0.3996138274669647,
-0.654629111289978,
-0.325466513633728,
-0.2585146129131317,
-0.37290850281715393,
-0.522426962852478,
-0.1849089115858078,
-0.5785940289497375,
-0.30016979575157166,
0.3272430896759033,
-0.3341108560562134,
0.3153797686100006,
0.6869252920150757,
-0.16424143314361572,
0.28553420305252075,
-1.009377360343933,
0.3157605230808258,
0.2277168184518814,
0.0577317476272583,
-0.05268942564725876,
-0.6729984283447266,
0.06396817415952682,
0.04857804998755455,
-0.4827536940574646,
-1.3933087587356567,
0.44429144263267517,
-0.15283818542957306,
0.5119192600250244,
0.6433001756668091,
0.33285075426101685,
0.4547932744026184,
-0.7943624258041382,
0.6577862501144409,
0.6187884211540222,
-1.014460563659668,
0.8760488629341125,
-0.397411972284317,
-0.1396440863609314,
0.5673761367797852,
0.2412513643503189,
-0.22722822427749634,
-0.8898041844367981,
-0.665057897567749,
-0.6632421016693115,
0.6866588592529297,
0.1379832625389099,
0.42941921949386597,
-0.1644122451543808,
0.13920928537845612,
0.131642684340477,
0.22471679747104645,
-1.1434122323989868,
-0.190732941031456,
-0.028262611478567123,
-0.19042275846004486,
0.40781664848327637,
-0.31458982825279236,
-0.45158708095550537,
0.009562230668962002,
0.7752161026000977,
0.08265401422977448,
-0.06106996908783913,
-0.05430254340171814,
-0.18991026282310486,
-0.26027292013168335,
0.4008673429489136,
0.4262513220310211,
0.6348167061805725,
-0.045215412974357605,
0.415382981300354,
-0.2552493214607239,
-0.5280981659889221,
0.3757997155189514,
-0.050479091703891754,
-0.35283344984054565,
-0.1695024073123932,
0.5158013105392456,
0.6141082048416138,
-0.11809466779232025,
-0.9771878719329834,
0.732182502746582,
0.04854995757341385,
-0.04056696221232414,
-0.3208428621292114,
0.24402189254760742,
0.20510858297348022,
0.06300072371959686,
0.09529118239879608,
0.10393679141998291,
-0.034417200833559036,
-0.7305032014846802,
0.12635324895381927,
0.6624172329902649,
-0.3503909111022949,
-0.30011337995529175,
0.9418753385543823,
0.10071156173944473,
-0.2796095013618469,
0.7560180425643921,
0.04351724311709404,
-0.6131889820098877,
0.5999792814254761,
0.9158138632774353,
0.716345489025116,
-0.434889554977417,
0.3363814949989319,
0.23203691840171814,
0.8204074501991272,
-0.020258981734514236,
0.046149689704179764,
0.43489953875541687,
-0.8224049806594849,
-0.5905757546424866,
-0.6565738916397095,
-0.19488629698753357,
0.45908403396606445,
-0.3902629315853119,
0.1826310008764267,
-0.513646125793457,
-0.008035849779844284,
0.05602743476629257,
-0.49263378977775574,
0.1202273964881897,
-0.05466392636299133,
0.3877636194229126,
0.9211061596870422,
-0.956894040107727,
0.7968726754188538,
0.32737576961517334,
-0.28818485140800476,
-1.0146769285202026,
0.13964173197746277,
0.20690149068832397,
-0.8193008303642273,
0.601158857345581,
0.42792603373527527,
-0.22481918334960938,
-0.31746795773506165,
-1.0241328477859497,
-0.7966743111610413,
0.4723834693431854,
0.7795330882072449,
-0.8197574019432068,
-0.13882337510585785,
0.1358027160167694,
0.19256120920181274,
-0.3018879294395447,
-0.21638107299804688,
0.7979474067687988,
0.5497188568115234,
0.07757706195116043,
-0.7458792924880981,
0.5712072849273682,
-0.08069390803575516,
-0.1685512810945511,
0.48613816499710083,
-0.47604891657829285,
0.6582366824150085,
-0.5705800652503967,
-0.09208514541387558,
0.030619125813245773,
0.5362012386322021,
0.766834020614624,
0.03700924292206764,
0.49599456787109375,
0.8838780522346497,
0.5833514332771301,
-0.01558228861540556,
1.1253786087036133,
-0.24776633083820343,
0.05884644761681557,
1.121175765991211,
-0.5574134588241577,
0.6863160133361816,
0.6010116934776306,
0.10631797462701797,
0.4923075735569,
0.15495999157428741,
-0.2228114902973175,
0.6754742860794067,
0.4216251075267792,
-0.10494780540466309,
-0.41968396306037903,
0.18665657937526703,
-0.008170735090970993,
0.47814464569091797,
0.48625320196151733,
-0.47477248311042786,
-0.31424984335899353,
0.10182738304138184,
0.5616129040718079,
0.4523076117038727,
-0.16496245563030243,
0.5759360790252686,
0.2348962128162384,
-0.8218021392822266,
0.6666536331176758,
0.3726770579814911,
0.5028162598609924,
-0.39153406023979187,
-0.1976095587015152,
0.11290442198514938,
0.10415045917034149,
-0.1755431443452835,
-0.5577181577682495,
0.45489490032196045,
0.4339112937450409,
0.09142863005399704,
0.05247638374567032,
0.7949209213256836,
-0.08717750012874603,
-0.477668434381485,
0.3336905837059021,
0.17142373323440552,
0.11745541542768478,
0.14676162600517273,
-0.6780346632003784,
0.1369636356830597,
0.02634323202073574,
-0.1907968819141388,
0.2543063163757324,
0.10611100494861603,
-0.16545096039772034,
0.6985422968864441,
0.6141754388809204,
0.2945777177810669,
0.2623865008354187,
-0.05282549560070038,
0.978859543800354,
-0.5933493971824646,
-0.46350306272506714,
-1.4117558002471924,
0.35808899998664856,
-0.22831620275974274,
0.20117568969726562,
0.7646157741546631,
0.5171347856521606,
0.5270119309425354,
0.028966819867491722,
0.9324336647987366,
-0.15150368213653564,
0.40963682532310486,
-0.8193371295928955,
0.9227083921432495,
-0.2938084900379181,
0.6144246459007263,
-0.25858309864997864,
-0.5914231538772583,
0.011121651157736778,
0.2670290172100067,
-0.6139349937438965,
-0.165009006857872,
0.7462469339370728,
0.8143661618232727,
-0.0359632633626461,
-0.05411538854241371,
0.3566269278526306,
0.7771075963973999,
0.2558819055557251,
0.6171007752418518,
1.0290666818618774,
-0.2596353590488434,
0.5246601104736328,
-0.13563062250614166,
-0.19191841781139374,
-0.08572287857532501,
-0.9447835683822632,
-1.1009492874145508,
-0.20305372774600983,
-0.31099531054496765,
-0.6921478509902954,
0.2601771354675293,
0.5233773589134216,
0.5278313159942627,
-0.6999600529670715,
-0.08031781017780304,
-0.19620253145694733,
0.2516101598739624,
0.11661204695701599,
-0.2576870322227478,
0.05303317308425903,
-0.17480704188346863,
-0.6043193936347961,
0.6911728382110596,
0.15301531553268433,
0.03125229477882385,
-0.5077692270278931,
0.1081966757774353,
0.017227191478013992,
0.461703360080719,
0.07037002593278885,
0.13195370137691498,
-0.9050537347793579,
-0.33924517035484314,
-0.355969101190567,
-0.26676201820373535,
0.006881293375045061,
0.6514312624931335,
-0.5202553272247314,
0.22411948442459106,
0.2918044626712799,
0.5651752352714539,
0.08264598995447159,
0.12690916657447815,
0.7630473971366882,
-0.8491485714912415,
0.2346765249967575,
0.3925331234931946,
0.3354974389076233,
0.2943636476993561,
-0.6725955009460449,
0.2539753317832947,
0.049234773963689804,
-0.4202237129211426,
-1.0693284273147583,
0.6725283265113831,
-0.7321190237998962,
-0.6260957717895508,
1.0169997215270996,
-0.33538395166397095,
-0.6508709788322449,
0.05671568214893341,
0.07822921127080917,
-0.072764553129673,
-0.44225233793258667,
1.0459965467453003,
0.7326654195785522,
0.15914040803909302,
0.07667466998100281,
-0.7215088605880737,
0.397823303937912,
0.13235974311828613,
-0.7727425694465637,
0.38311025500297546,
0.5810821652412415,
0.43536585569381714,
0.39964738488197327,
0.2653411328792572,
-0.5820253491401672,
0.30021020770072937,
0.03109569475054741,
-0.0152494041249156,
-0.23773865401744843,
-0.2852182984352112,
-0.21486489474773407,
0.2618204951286316,
0.23033685982227325,
0.060729172080755234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00837v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00837v2 | Towards Robust Speech Representation Learning for Thousands of Languages | 2024-06-30T21:40:26 | 2024-07-02T17:23:44 | William Chen, Wangyou Zhang, Yifan Peng, Xinjian Li, Jinchuan Tian, Jiatong Shi, Xuankai Chang, Soumi Maiti, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-supervised learning (SSL) has helped extend speech technologies to more
languages by reducing the need for labeled data. However, models are still far
from supporting the world's 7000+ languages. We propose XEUS, a Cross-lingual
Encoder for Universal Speech, trained on over 1 million hours of data across
4057 languages, extending the language coverage of SSL models 4-fold. We
combine 1 million hours of speech from existing publicly accessible corpora
with a newly created corpus of 7400+ hours from 4057 languages, which will be
publicly released. To handle the diverse conditions of multilingual speech
data, we augment the typical SSL masked prediction approach with a novel
dereverberation objective, increasing robustness. We evaluate XEUS on several
benchmarks, and show that it consistently outperforms or achieves comparable
results to state-of-the-art (SOTA) SSL models across a variety of tasks. XEUS
sets a new SOTA on the ML-SUPERB benchmark: it outperforms MMS 1B and w2v-BERT
2.0 v2 by 0.8% and 4.4% respectively, despite having less parameters or
pre-training data. Checkpoints, code, and data are found in
https://www.wavlab.org/activities/2024/xeus/. | [
-0.20443353056907654,
0.022037861868739128,
0.26656123995780945,
0.176904559135437,
-0.17689530551433563,
0.34317901730537415,
-0.3772839605808258,
-0.6087716221809387,
0.18274281919002533,
0.3937205672264099,
-0.516869306564331,
-0.5813870429992676,
-0.4692094922065735,
0.06987053155899048,
-0.4818134605884552,
0.5930167436599731,
0.4087267518043518,
0.2948199212551117,
0.3322632908821106,
-0.4046265184879303,
-0.1361244171857834,
-0.6543366312980652,
-0.6669026017189026,
-0.22104619443416595,
0.42847108840942383,
0.34813806414604187,
0.6607365012168884,
0.6721857190132141,
-0.22983941435813904,
0.2803633213043213,
0.10000623017549515,
0.29626360535621643,
-0.5737595558166504,
0.047688767313957214,
-0.03847150504589081,
-0.4946829676628113,
-0.4176177680492401,
-0.036184437572956085,
0.8762636184692383,
0.7750754356384277,
-0.19654043018817902,
0.2048843950033188,
0.1920812726020813,
0.493996262550354,
-0.3476153314113617,
0.24852675199508667,
-0.6187153458595276,
0.37493613362312317,
-0.5586066842079163,
-0.10127106308937073,
-0.5309495329856873,
0.08430411666631699,
0.15206724405288696,
-0.693047821521759,
-0.03623802959918976,
0.05705602467060089,
0.4719330072402954,
0.2170196920633316,
-0.17871218919754028,
0.0681806281208992,
-0.691131055355072,
1.0101462602615356,
-0.5173491835594177,
1.3047094345092773,
0.3924221396446228,
0.3677847683429718,
0.0013471853453665972,
-0.7529991865158081,
-0.2780483663082123,
-0.3213270902633667,
0.16171640157699585,
0.19121970236301422,
-0.3836619555950165,
-0.26906800270080566,
-0.03180929645895958,
0.23076486587524414,
-0.8715769052505493,
0.36574190855026245,
-0.42704275250434875,
-0.22478125989437103,
0.704006552696228,
-0.057017698884010315,
0.1025974228978157,
-0.2011854201555252,
-0.3108575642108917,
-0.4171784222126007,
-0.7909659743309021,
0.11602119356393814,
0.22176072001457214,
0.4927065074443817,
-0.3221183717250824,
-0.0645698606967926,
-0.046151429414749146,
0.38033613562583923,
-0.12594741582870483,
0.0010867621749639511,
0.5040442943572998,
0.0621529221534729,
-0.28347525000572205,
0.40307340025901794,
0.9329765439033508,
-0.13745877146720886,
0.17832928895950317,
-0.4146248400211334,
0.009723497554659843,
-0.051786843687295914,
0.090347059071064,
-0.5229683518409729,
-0.17145584523677826,
0.4201509952545166,
-0.2198847234249115,
-0.14197152853012085,
-0.10541598498821259,
-0.49157366156578064,
-0.3652115762233734,
-0.25192636251449585,
-0.026772651821374893,
-0.5568854808807373,
-0.43124186992645264,
0.07606857270002365,
0.15940669178962708,
-0.05797084793448448,
0.15293578803539276,
-0.9735884666442871,
0.3403347134590149,
0.5555354952812195,
0.7371062636375427,
-0.0577535480260849,
-0.45634663105010986,
-0.6454018950462341,
0.17868654429912567,
-0.6297470927238464,
0.213716521859169,
-0.4684715270996094,
-0.3601454794406891,
-0.05157725140452385,
0.022936346009373665,
0.12883563339710236,
-0.35011184215545654,
0.7855010032653809,
-0.36573222279548645,
0.2636494040489197,
-0.11842741817235947,
-0.6584827303886414,
-0.09814399480819702,
-0.1098487377166748,
-0.7191341519355774,
0.8695226907730103,
0.10178166627883911,
-0.534559428691864,
0.3762282431125641,
-0.5094614624977112,
-0.26658594608306885,
0.3697224259376526,
-0.6344777941703796,
-0.3842119872570038,
-0.003225193824619055,
0.21479074656963348,
0.5337738990783691,
-0.14431634545326233,
0.10301792621612549,
-0.08425335586071014,
-0.20833086967468262,
0.23743483424186707,
-0.4561001658439636,
0.9214285612106323,
0.4112609624862671,
-0.6382845640182495,
0.018478024750947952,
-0.9692707657814026,
0.08121530711650848,
0.17359304428100586,
-0.07541538774967194,
-0.34781789779663086,
-0.03953402489423752,
0.16974285244941711,
0.18547123670578003,
-0.042171411216259,
-1.1011106967926025,
-0.2705821096897125,
-0.42936843633651733,
0.6827804446220398,
0.6825781464576721,
-0.7197591066360474,
0.2911387085914612,
-0.059190236032009125,
0.3114428222179413,
-0.27806738018989563,
0.09908291697502136,
-0.32420703768730164,
-0.5363947153091431,
-0.3662914037704468,
-0.31553348898887634,
0.5691804885864258,
0.325777530670166,
-0.3582000434398651,
0.38662654161453247,
-0.4997844994068146,
-0.6117333173751831,
-0.9444682002067566,
0.21840228140354156,
0.4733954966068268,
0.39361685514450073,
0.5079450011253357,
-0.11587391793727875,
-0.9632275700569153,
-0.5398078560829163,
0.08516250550746918,
-0.2711690068244934,
-0.300231009721756,
0.15784895420074463,
0.03018902614712715,
-0.27854737639427185,
0.7630714178085327,
0.09575863927602768,
-0.5986387729644775,
-0.33940619230270386,
-0.07735397666692734,
-0.007009876426309347,
0.5605809092521667,
0.5227593183517456,
-0.7984179258346558,
-0.5286178588867188,
0.33667561411857605,
-0.9684058427810669,
0.2874348759651184,
-0.19332806766033173,
0.19643214344978333,
0.3339524567127228,
0.5265547633171082,
-0.30600646138191223,
-0.06066662073135376,
1.036144733428955,
-0.00022506469395011663,
0.235884889960289,
-0.3395823836326599,
0.0988759696483612,
-0.9020487666130066,
-0.21771255135536194,
0.0414426252245903,
-0.6402928233146667,
-0.8328076601028442,
-0.09623111039400101,
0.41682541370391846,
-0.3961828649044037,
-0.5832868218421936,
0.4420880079269409,
-0.42335429787635803,
0.0024837602395564318,
0.01162777841091156,
0.37511318922042847,
-0.039992962032556534,
0.3873429000377655,
0.42276692390441895,
0.4893473982810974,
0.9257416725158691,
-0.42161017656326294,
0.2857828438282013,
0.2985386252403259,
-0.393597811460495,
0.1792628914117813,
-0.6202751398086548,
0.046933822333812714,
0.08778633922338486,
0.38832351565361023,
-0.8186953663825989,
-0.08896133303642273,
0.010540568269789219,
-0.6525237560272217,
0.4786243140697479,
-0.2865167260169983,
-0.35770362615585327,
-0.25788992643356323,
-0.20200753211975098,
0.3979862332344055,
0.7484363913536072,
-1.0018173456192017,
0.5113762617111206,
0.6360923051834106,
-0.11861933767795563,
-0.5057551264762878,
-1.026277780532837,
0.40986254811286926,
-0.15771932899951935,
-0.7833983898162842,
0.5560588240623474,
0.21908150613307953,
0.06037032976746559,
-0.18575555086135864,
-0.12397105991840363,
0.2327689528465271,
-0.14471203088760376,
0.26128777861595154,
0.0672396570444107,
-0.09932363778352737,
0.16179484128952026,
-0.05839041993021965,
-0.33968836069107056,
0.027598990127444267,
-0.643804669380188,
0.569287896156311,
-0.08555907011032104,
-0.6020340323448181,
-0.43579304218292236,
0.49273771047592163,
0.4270300567150116,
-0.36695992946624756,
0.24645733833312988,
0.7204967141151428,
-0.3569726049900055,
-0.3267132043838501,
-0.4722730219364166,
0.052017051726579666,
-0.526840329170227,
0.42835351824760437,
-0.4014831781387329,
-0.9267908334732056,
0.4640714228153229,
0.2678627371788025,
0.3413126766681671,
0.2640082836151123,
0.4410516023635864,
-0.16092033684253693,
1.2220455408096313,
0.6375108361244202,
-0.3930456340312958,
0.4590385854244232,
-0.2876660227775574,
0.04426800087094307,
-0.6470963358879089,
-0.22804716229438782,
-0.23947042226791382,
0.14846433699131012,
-0.7896028757095337,
-0.5036687254905701,
0.19233925640583038,
-0.45450088381767273,
0.09875854849815369,
0.5607621073722839,
-0.5442821979522705,
0.1539323627948761,
0.6991080045700073,
-0.021563295274972916,
0.14633049070835114,
0.21777215600013733,
0.017780762165784836,
-0.23152321577072144,
-0.8206738233566284,
-0.391812264919281,
1.1671640872955322,
0.6403957605361938,
0.9287863373756409,
-0.03725358843803406,
1.0011321306228638,
0.4813683032989502,
-0.1018640547990799,
-0.27027732133865356,
0.35968872904777527,
-0.4558182656764984,
-0.5785594582557678,
-0.614166796207428,
-0.599946916103363,
-1.2716583013534546,
0.5346582531929016,
0.03256050869822502,
-0.7318830490112305,
0.16933685541152954,
0.0577285960316658,
-0.524267315864563,
0.501899242401123,
-0.48203712701797485,
0.7267065048217773,
-0.4151131808757782,
-0.311736136674881,
-0.29289302229881287,
-0.697837233543396,
0.02808220311999321,
-0.22830025851726532,
0.4303068518638611,
-0.18932640552520752,
0.23559612035751343,
1.00567626953125,
-0.17512589693069458,
0.9440547227859497,
-0.20899151265621185,
-0.4140186309814453,
0.11823248118162155,
-0.17268215119838715,
0.3131197988986969,
0.021560989320278168,
-0.13358452916145325,
0.5789545774459839,
0.0977088212966919,
-0.4950501620769501,
-0.35422471165657043,
0.846100389957428,
-0.8932912945747375,
-0.33605849742889404,
-0.2674248516559601,
-0.3471822738647461,
-0.3403850495815277,
0.02394014410674572,
0.3778938949108124,
0.774696409702301,
-0.26447853446006775,
0.15372982621192932,
0.8409266471862793,
-0.16584421694278717,
0.2663946747779846,
0.5380127429962158,
-0.2042779177427292,
-0.48399555683135986,
1.2692431211471558,
0.5314028859138489,
-0.0032527130097150803,
0.33564186096191406,
0.2867317795753479,
-0.6031482815742493,
-0.4479988217353821,
-0.8863111734390259,
0.11299896240234375,
-0.6728881001472473,
0.05235396325588226,
-0.7674529552459717,
-0.10274108499288559,
-0.7571557760238647,
-0.05306408181786537,
-0.6969378590583801,
-0.5053210258483887,
-0.11964662373065948,
-0.2177681028842926,
0.0802316665649414,
0.7207707166671753,
-0.5718954801559448,
0.06558186560869217,
-0.9965963959693909,
0.34004098176956177,
0.2610553503036499,
0.22549964487552643,
-0.08079114556312561,
-0.8000735640525818,
-0.42928487062454224,
0.08719272166490555,
0.18377171456813812,
-0.770061731338501,
0.5351667404174805,
0.43736135959625244,
0.9119935631752014,
0.5561040639877319,
0.22929751873016357,
0.7340962886810303,
-0.6482352614402771,
0.6803529262542725,
0.33727315068244934,
-0.941565215587616,
0.44676563143730164,
-0.13029950857162476,
0.15038666129112244,
0.33802345395088196,
0.5358060002326965,
-0.7970706224441528,
-0.6538735628128052,
-0.7050140500068665,
-0.6076467633247375,
0.6385477185249329,
0.3681057393550873,
0.3411092162132263,
0.16079181432724,
0.023461563512682915,
0.42051711678504944,
-0.17600031197071075,
-0.7078412175178528,
-0.5091962814331055,
-0.4676903784275055,
-0.1571044921875,
-0.26403048634529114,
-0.05427165329456329,
-0.02256692573428154,
-0.23296596109867096,
0.7178140878677368,
-0.0563015453517437,
-0.04334714636206627,
0.26379477977752686,
-0.2780436873435974,
-0.1475421041250229,
0.3049194812774658,
0.3244325816631317,
0.4613523483276367,
-0.23124559223651886,
0.239910289645195,
0.3440132439136505,
-0.34596869349479675,
0.16567057371139526,
0.44656628370285034,
0.12506034970283508,
0.19515852630138397,
0.3912026584148407,
0.7803546190261841,
0.2122548520565033,
-0.7851303815841675,
0.23781652748584747,
-0.2540246248245239,
-0.2834397852420807,
-0.4687643349170685,
-0.1195073276758194,
-0.016588741913437843,
0.3219220042228699,
0.4910926818847656,
-0.1372663825750351,
0.31833547353744507,
-0.4731607735157013,
0.3479197919368744,
0.28169411420822144,
-0.5953047275543213,
-0.48552051186561584,
0.9957594275474548,
0.25124433636665344,
0.04129795730113983,
0.2952321171760559,
-0.4120795726776123,
-0.3858416676521301,
0.19196785986423492,
0.4962713420391083,
0.803168773651123,
-0.6181392073631287,
0.20676204562187195,
0.3085497319698334,
0.26742151379585266,
0.06778036057949066,
0.19462049007415771,
-0.3265342712402344,
-0.47880157828330994,
-0.5527894496917725,
-0.42372944951057434,
-0.6962141394615173,
-0.037011370062828064,
-0.5109302401542664,
0.05777635797858238,
-0.09598430246114731,
-0.021595977246761322,
0.06603629887104034,
0.036488596349954605,
-0.5280814170837402,
0.23761864006519318,
0.9603084921836853,
0.9979285597801208,
-1.0168699026107788,
1.3023921251296997,
0.47016698122024536,
-0.1052875816822052,
-0.6745908856391907,
-0.5734569430351257,
-0.04262405261397362,
-0.8610519766807556,
0.45340120792388916,
0.24563954770565033,
-0.32801133394241333,
-0.13334985077381134,
-0.22368314862251282,
-1.046341061592102,
0.9312744140625,
0.735661506652832,
-1.0378472805023193,
0.0652221292257309,
0.5565904974937439,
0.47664082050323486,
-0.2757345736026764,
-0.13364769518375397,
0.53924560546875,
0.22003449499607086,
-0.1278507560491562,
-0.9355210661888123,
-0.034866660833358765,
-0.2537047863006592,
-0.17261141538619995,
-0.11565288156270981,
-0.5433075428009033,
0.6070424914360046,
-0.21012325584888458,
-0.42561593651771545,
-0.04035462066531181,
0.9519447088241577,
0.2685571312904358,
0.20610210299491882,
0.5956698060035706,
0.46881645917892456,
1.2666480541229248,
-0.025014789775013924,
1.0443861484527588,
-0.34093010425567627,
0.16221384704113007,
1.2327035665512085,
-0.26521095633506775,
0.7119842767715454,
0.1716572791337967,
-0.1874435991048813,
0.42158910632133484,
0.6982543468475342,
-0.011440849862992764,
0.5855332016944885,
0.07748186588287354,
-0.2648206651210785,
-0.42849186062812805,
-0.10327929258346558,
-0.5538212656974792,
0.4999768137931824,
0.36646604537963867,
-0.160874143242836,
-0.13322484493255615,
0.40313130617141724,
-0.04381752014160156,
-0.05599707365036011,
-0.26926887035369873,
0.3802180886268616,
0.231894850730896,
-0.30020076036453247,
0.7795613408088684,
-0.23796004056930542,
0.6727824211120605,
-0.7361453175544739,
0.10421915352344513,
-0.1675194948911667,
0.25320613384246826,
-0.3849841356277466,
-0.756936252117157,
-0.016307810321450233,
-0.0013665225123986602,
0.29151639342308044,
-0.29975512623786926,
0.6397791504859924,
-0.6178396940231323,
-0.42647185921669006,
0.733522355556488,
0.5195578336715698,
0.347990483045578,
-0.0930415615439415,
-0.6424484252929688,
0.36363664269447327,
0.14335978031158447,
-0.09604652971029282,
0.3960714340209961,
0.4607049226760864,
-0.07580064237117767,
0.9076660871505737,
0.5089083909988403,
0.015288854017853737,
0.4747501015663147,
0.3924803137779236,
0.8362212181091309,
-0.5564095973968506,
-0.7933281660079956,
-0.686919093132019,
0.39251506328582764,
-0.1307237297296524,
-0.09554293006658554,
1.016194224357605,
0.5195631384849548,
1.1548576354980469,
0.3011736571788788,
1.0870428085327148,
0.17058812081813812,
0.5146483182907104,
-0.26619014143943787,
0.6364351511001587,
-0.6393457651138306,
0.07712025940418243,
-0.13942314684391022,
-0.6052718162536621,
-0.3847176730632782,
0.5409076809883118,
0.009146434254944324,
-0.1900789886713028,
0.12215831130743027,
0.5676813125610352,
-0.1274929791688919,
0.22676748037338257,
0.9814935326576233,
-0.09174751490354538,
0.44513610005378723,
0.2888724207878113,
0.9377074837684631,
-0.42353758215904236,
0.8101434707641602,
-0.4831773042678833,
-0.26253336668014526,
0.029418395832180977,
-0.5331052541732788,
-0.7259923815727234,
-0.756525456905365,
-0.44690045714378357,
-0.12652555108070374,
0.14322367310523987,
1.0281673669815063,
1.387013554573059,
-1.0141069889068604,
-0.39399254322052,
0.07249011844396591,
-0.2170167714357376,
-0.32394731044769287,
-0.06578768044710159,
0.4993724524974823,
-0.640131950378418,
-0.8277093172073364,
1.0752825736999512,
0.29973360896110535,
-0.03833814337849617,
-0.6253191232681274,
-0.4975534975528717,
0.3348158895969391,
-0.006669462658464909,
0.6628381013870239,
0.6157524585723877,
-0.5828619599342346,
-0.12792137265205383,
0.0013404624769464135,
-0.05582636967301369,
0.2789122760295868,
0.5521205067634583,
-0.8360283970832825,
0.5650482773780823,
0.14067228138446808,
0.627440333366394,
0.6966126561164856,
-0.458784818649292,
0.5354775786399841,
-0.8998043537139893,
-0.0004433861467987299,
0.10945931077003479,
0.8128097653388977,
0.5115258693695068,
-0.09600391238927841,
0.5526000261306763,
-0.181044340133667,
-0.5579180717468262,
-0.8623074889183044,
0.026448963209986687,
-1.006790041923523,
-0.22326985001564026,
0.9338518381118774,
-0.36018797755241394,
-0.19415347278118134,
-0.334443598985672,
-0.09208475798368454,
0.229415163397789,
-0.552401602268219,
0.6487706303596497,
0.04331783205270767,
-0.17307285964488983,
-0.2818499505519867,
-0.46578970551490784,
0.4417772591114044,
0.5657879710197449,
-0.45737120509147644,
0.32834842801094055,
0.19343067705631256,
0.21736618876457214,
0.49824970960617065,
0.6360865235328674,
-0.2671198546886444,
0.36778104305267334,
0.15349718928337097,
0.15492285788059235,
-0.005871704779565334,
-0.34554705023765564,
-0.47971534729003906,
0.2779228389263153,
0.1427849978208542,
-0.4718966484069824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00826v1 | NAIST Simultaneous Speech Translation System for IWSLT 2024 | 2024-06-30T20:41:02 | 2024-06-30T20:41:02 | Yuka Ko, Ryo Fukuda, Yuta Nishikawa, Yasumasa Kano, Tomoya Yanagita, Kosuke Doi, Mana Makinae, Haotian Tan, Makoto Sakai, Sakriani Sakti, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes NAIST's submission to the simultaneous track of the
IWSLT 2024 Evaluation Campaign: English-to-{German, Japanese, Chinese}
speech-to-text translation and English-to-Japanese speech-to-speech
translation. We develop a multilingual end-to-end speech-to-text translation
model combining two pre-trained language models, HuBERT and mBART. We trained
this model with two decoding policies, Local Agreement (LA) and AlignAtt. The
submitted models employ the LA policy because it outperformed the AlignAtt
policy in previous models. Our speech-to-speech translation method is a cascade
of the above speech-to-text model and an incremental text-to-speech (TTS)
module that incorporates a phoneme estimation model, a parallel acoustic model,
and a parallel WaveGAN vocoder. We improved our incremental TTS by applying the
Transformer architecture with the AlignAtt policy for the estimation model. The
results show that our upgraded TTS module contributed to improving the system
performance. | [
-0.4022800028324127,
-0.339748352766037,
0.3267871141433716,
0.49230262637138367,
-0.3576509654521942,
0.564292848110199,
-0.2861470878124237,
-0.67839115858078,
0.06143389642238617,
0.5796382427215576,
-0.5544777512550354,
-0.22375239431858063,
-0.5234395265579224,
0.3721397817134857,
-0.5362489223480225,
1.1128871440887451,
-0.2440410852432251,
0.3933742344379425,
0.051676470786333084,
-0.35071948170661926,
-0.6540250778198242,
-0.2944680154323578,
-0.5990008115768433,
-0.6519618630409241,
0.21553941071033478,
0.31167876720428467,
0.7062876224517822,
0.25164878368377686,
0.5935830473899841,
0.2833048105239868,
0.3021864891052246,
-0.148689866065979,
-0.11488238722085953,
-0.06184058636426926,
-0.21853896975517273,
-0.31613290309906006,
-0.6294093132019043,
-0.25915226340293884,
0.9266036748886108,
0.41281670331954956,
0.030435118824243546,
0.2482995241880417,
-0.1587609350681305,
0.08375338464975357,
-0.2525821626186371,
-0.1264525055885315,
-0.46386370062828064,
0.07756096869707108,
-0.3331703543663025,
-0.2610993981361389,
-0.6200052499771118,
-0.28522852063179016,
0.33921486139297485,
-0.5846144556999207,
-0.27287641167640686,
0.006357696373015642,
0.6802192330360413,
0.38919615745544434,
-0.72482830286026,
-0.16953276097774506,
-0.4990101456642151,
0.9145527482032776,
-1.0949718952178955,
0.5998601913452148,
0.12234564125537872,
0.19037973880767822,
-0.05386759340763092,
-0.95203697681427,
-0.4138266146183014,
-0.1654336154460907,
-0.07666385918855667,
0.5094894170761108,
-0.31127360463142395,
0.2803884744644165,
-0.14517629146575928,
0.17439532279968262,
-0.9808260798454285,
0.2777879536151886,
-0.374954491853714,
-0.3616129159927368,
0.7344266176223755,
0.12285985797643661,
0.2719574272632599,
-0.09283996373414993,
-0.8052292466163635,
-0.07703779637813568,
-0.18581359088420868,
-0.2025146633386612,
0.3981606960296631,
0.37661677598953247,
-0.3882046937942505,
0.25622308254241943,
-0.31170031428337097,
0.48631489276885986,
-0.2722882926464081,
-0.18388836085796356,
0.5036489963531494,
-0.6294353604316711,
-0.05253049358725548,
0.399539977312088,
0.9726236462593079,
0.2409447878599167,
-0.11628898978233337,
-0.2134435772895813,
-0.3534846603870392,
0.06531382352113724,
0.21760839223861694,
-0.5471358299255371,
0.017495283856987953,
0.20123136043548584,
-0.36279240250587463,
-0.2627144157886505,
-0.1526322364807129,
-0.7853950262069702,
0.1654699742794037,
-0.3461414575576782,
0.6948391795158386,
-0.1447983831167221,
-0.4749357998371124,
0.3109317123889923,
-0.0921209454536438,
0.3477012813091278,
0.2942448854446411,
-0.4730190932750702,
0.6000329852104187,
0.3868136703968048,
0.8433014154434204,
-0.4415300786495209,
-0.4699908494949341,
-0.4640798568725586,
0.032400909811258316,
-0.19445888698101044,
0.588713526725769,
-0.15251308679580688,
-0.3139484226703644,
0.0773894190788269,
-0.008387794718146324,
-0.035453248769044876,
-0.22335246205329895,
0.782893180847168,
-0.5296653509140015,
0.44205984473228455,
0.21389682590961456,
-0.3819420337677002,
-0.12178448587656021,
0.034342214465141296,
-0.4792044162750244,
1.0527353286743164,
0.0035407294053584337,
-0.604133129119873,
-0.06518123298883438,
-1.1162092685699463,
-0.3890780210494995,
0.2389998733997345,
0.1334005445241928,
-0.4309755861759186,
-0.10846727341413498,
0.17070724070072174,
0.14342336356639862,
-0.41469258069992065,
0.6976832747459412,
0.0036808119621127844,
-0.31236037611961365,
0.043217167258262634,
-0.8770071268081665,
0.8750800490379333,
0.3423476815223694,
-0.46266844868659973,
0.4100686013698578,
-0.8239928483963013,
0.17039118707180023,
0.3238469958305359,
-0.47421205043792725,
0.16304321587085724,
-0.1869238168001175,
0.4779064655303955,
0.3136918246746063,
0.6696023941040039,
-0.646943211555481,
0.05743638426065445,
-0.3861473500728607,
0.40237054228782654,
0.6714999079704285,
-0.07784850895404816,
0.49791643023490906,
-0.05196818336844444,
0.6332148313522339,
-0.1840917468070984,
0.2666434347629547,
-0.25459617376327515,
-0.596431314945221,
-0.6487298011779785,
0.2871989905834198,
0.3348448574542999,
0.7580112814903259,
-0.7843406796455383,
0.13338255882263184,
-0.3427184522151947,
-0.3397575914859772,
-0.5014236569404602,
-0.4273826777935028,
0.489385187625885,
0.1928834617137909,
0.46151676774024963,
-0.3024255037307739,
-0.7940949201583862,
-0.8537909984588623,
-0.30374252796173096,
-0.1908809393644333,
0.26413246989250183,
-0.4876592457294464,
0.35515934228897095,
-0.007371455896645784,
0.5810818672180176,
0.12406706064939499,
-0.12398667633533478,
0.003251544199883938,
0.2934079170227051,
0.17605574429035187,
0.555915117263794,
0.5812119841575623,
-0.7607364058494568,
-0.627899169921875,
0.23729121685028076,
-0.4966288208961487,
-0.1512211710214615,
-0.08435645699501038,
-0.05996205285191536,
0.14285121858119965,
0.4325908124446869,
-0.18843935430049896,
0.5875272750854492,
1.034790277481079,
-0.2529759705066681,
0.5484142899513245,
-0.1008639857172966,
0.1853184849023819,
-1.1004785299301147,
-0.2490711659193039,
-0.1913364678621292,
-0.7783500552177429,
-0.6811711192131042,
0.20684728026390076,
0.11479142308235168,
-0.19123908877372742,
-0.3003072440624237,
0.45974960923194885,
-0.32871028780937195,
-0.2809717357158661,
-0.25406613945961,
0.2805141508579254,
0.03665892407298088,
0.40840527415275574,
-0.05762413516640663,
1.0817921161651611,
0.2133372724056244,
-0.401042103767395,
0.43102791905403137,
0.46661296486854553,
-0.22515204548835754,
0.7460905313491821,
-0.48687177896499634,
0.2179102748632431,
0.3294866383075714,
0.36445164680480957,
-0.9588339328765869,
-0.1060991883277893,
0.15466459095478058,
-0.5812907218933105,
0.3886511027812958,
0.34411782026290894,
-0.3799310028553009,
-0.49640122056007385,
0.0023815613240003586,
0.3867717683315277,
0.25507450103759766,
-0.5985785722732544,
0.4385758340358734,
0.3761204183101654,
-0.4508204460144043,
-0.5694657564163208,
-0.7909107804298401,
0.5541619062423706,
-0.12465641647577286,
-0.41999351978302,
0.6260082721710205,
-0.15567255020141602,
0.07854793220758438,
0.08659759163856506,
0.02161022275686264,
-0.21733763813972473,
-0.07565747201442719,
-0.29428189992904663,
0.1675586849451065,
-0.4224346876144409,
-0.059954918920993805,
0.20728756487369537,
-0.23106853663921356,
0.07096169888973236,
-0.5626829862594604,
0.6509824395179749,
-0.2739233076572418,
-0.3408483862876892,
-0.6768472790718079,
0.7003341913223267,
0.62502121925354,
-0.5066057443618774,
0.23428893089294434,
0.8408647179603577,
-0.32891005277633667,
0.3545224070549011,
-0.396941214799881,
-0.04955225810408592,
-0.4447416067123413,
0.6219198107719421,
-0.5627744197845459,
-0.8131005167961121,
0.4122251570224762,
-0.28732138872146606,
0.6007095575332642,
0.3797449469566345,
0.4893694519996643,
0.0090907858684659,
1.3260151147842407,
0.4763137400150299,
-0.03962172940373421,
0.5018181204795837,
0.07581980526447296,
0.2208126038312912,
-0.751337468624115,
-0.09453994035720825,
-0.4882427752017975,
-0.2686929404735565,
-0.5218096971511841,
-0.18497897684574127,
0.5170636773109436,
-0.14835652709007263,
-0.3901987075805664,
0.5958267450332642,
-0.6589338779449463,
-0.01349111832678318,
0.6770079731941223,
-0.34041377902030945,
0.3773772418498993,
-0.06347805261611938,
-0.0970262959599495,
-0.29246631264686584,
-0.6244550943374634,
-0.46526452898979187,
0.9904283881187439,
0.4093444347381592,
0.32771703600883484,
0.18879103660583496,
0.814612865447998,
0.2613085210323334,
0.2842210531234741,
-0.5053431391716003,
0.37485218048095703,
-0.16513346135616302,
-0.6076281666755676,
-0.2935744822025299,
-0.16704218089580536,
-0.8016587495803833,
0.430671751499176,
-0.03289329633116722,
-0.79369056224823,
0.08875767886638641,
-0.2069302350282669,
0.1271274834871292,
0.374407559633255,
-0.42208680510520935,
0.8205040693283081,
-0.6081681847572327,
-0.0008356591570191085,
-0.25234052538871765,
-0.9689375162124634,
0.3021717667579651,
-0.19141562283039093,
0.29343530535697937,
-0.11216253787279129,
-0.05665931478142738,
0.8292388319969177,
-0.26887279748916626,
0.48426634073257446,
-0.2437276393175125,
-0.21080709993839264,
0.03168408200144768,
-0.2254364788532257,
0.5460925698280334,
-0.12955090403556824,
-0.2388017773628235,
0.47763705253601074,
0.11634335666894913,
-0.2388411909341812,
-0.293915718793869,
0.4664352834224701,
-0.8567087650299072,
-0.26962774991989136,
-0.49008846282958984,
-0.8994547724723816,
-0.39367395639419556,
0.3846450746059418,
0.39904168248176575,
0.5301768779754639,
-0.16665059328079224,
0.22534532845020294,
0.3488228917121887,
-0.0978006049990654,
0.6137096285820007,
0.4802921712398529,
-0.6135494112968445,
-0.9219712615013123,
0.8995513916015625,
0.11168152838945389,
0.5979894399642944,
0.31563806533813477,
0.08992210030555725,
-0.5143976211547852,
-0.6044445633888245,
-0.6730623841285706,
0.17081212997436523,
-0.6872097849845886,
-0.4435727298259735,
-0.5415992140769958,
-0.36929774284362793,
-0.4300295114517212,
-0.15236832201480865,
-0.4891985356807709,
-0.27495986223220825,
-0.14246505498886108,
0.08127384632825851,
0.31654754281044006,
0.9705836772918701,
-0.07622963190078735,
0.6965797543525696,
-0.58905029296875,
0.36867043375968933,
-0.261844664812088,
0.06291989982128143,
-0.3484305739402771,
-0.8529835343360901,
-0.4647756516933441,
0.0668729767203331,
-0.4486900269985199,
-0.9480672478675842,
0.4016277492046356,
0.10048899054527283,
0.5279537439346313,
-0.1410137414932251,
0.13175682723522186,
0.8521044850349426,
-0.6068017482757568,
0.7336275577545166,
0.5253782868385315,
-1.1115007400512695,
0.38201409578323364,
-0.43895748257637024,
0.6276398301124573,
0.4405742287635803,
0.0021155665162950754,
-0.5862054228782654,
-0.6754961609840393,
-0.4565000534057617,
-0.8251696825027466,
0.8473431468009949,
0.059596478939056396,
0.2624165713787079,
0.2882769703865051,
-0.06661920994520187,
0.030199255794286728,
0.2234424203634262,
-0.9207057356834412,
-0.23391805589199066,
-0.29562002420425415,
-0.45636609196662903,
0.13347159326076508,
-0.1765422821044922,
0.027441278100013733,
-0.1425413191318512,
1.0810251235961914,
-0.3354702293872833,
0.19915781915187836,
0.16565681993961334,
0.10861091315746307,
-0.13060228526592255,
0.5042697787284851,
0.6813144683837891,
0.4763510823249817,
-0.13588128983974457,
-0.2342759519815445,
0.4439642131328583,
-0.3970060646533966,
0.31140103936195374,
0.1998029500246048,
-0.2878428101539612,
0.43155336380004883,
0.12508952617645264,
0.9845967888832092,
0.6071151494979858,
-0.37858864665031433,
0.64669269323349,
-0.04565604031085968,
-0.5486282110214233,
-0.44180479645729065,
-0.5764527916908264,
0.14858321845531464,
0.3917800188064575,
0.34678223729133606,
0.3652271330356598,
0.26554250717163086,
-0.08825753629207611,
0.2757170796394348,
0.17774829268455505,
-0.4720722436904907,
-0.3474767208099365,
0.9166696071624756,
0.25554391741752625,
-0.3709120750427246,
0.1783050298690796,
-0.16305123269557953,
-0.5884252786636353,
0.2077791392803192,
1.029189944267273,
0.8741440773010254,
-0.5943390130996704,
0.1338789463043213,
0.4667217433452606,
0.480960875749588,
-0.0021800806280225515,
0.4262305796146393,
0.02775862067937851,
-0.43317052721977234,
-0.6206585764884949,
-0.644976019859314,
-0.49442172050476074,
0.07186130434274673,
-1.1612571477890015,
0.2907887101173401,
-0.05402245372533798,
-0.2966025471687317,
-0.2917387783527374,
0.028882605955004692,
-0.5422402620315552,
0.15265142917633057,
0.05671152472496033,
0.7787413597106934,
-0.6097078323364258,
0.933803141117096,
0.6933945417404175,
-0.35740897059440613,
-0.8859134316444397,
0.006929187569767237,
-0.06073959171772003,
-0.6507372260093689,
0.3716946542263031,
-0.11977557837963104,
-0.10940210521221161,
0.3942016661167145,
-0.3805387020111084,
-1.1887860298156738,
1.058026671409607,
0.6180065870285034,
-0.6754470467567444,
-0.1664077192544937,
0.20573407411575317,
0.15421800315380096,
-0.14145933091640472,
-0.023254629224538803,
0.5270763635635376,
0.7068293690681458,
-0.29019492864608765,
-1.6755813360214233,
-0.3107415437698364,
-0.05629009008407593,
0.02862914837896824,
0.2659699618816376,
-0.6286525726318359,
0.8001961708068848,
0.14864486455917358,
-0.2166089415550232,
0.3419189453125,
0.8546729683876038,
0.18013666570186615,
0.3492436408996582,
0.3808315694332123,
0.39724040031433105,
0.5643534064292908,
-0.18038944900035858,
0.8535764813423157,
-0.19823744893074036,
0.39640364050865173,
1.4317595958709717,
-0.312675416469574,
1.0717918872833252,
0.6296306252479553,
-0.471691370010376,
0.48814862966537476,
0.3948821723461151,
0.3844330906867981,
0.6111924052238464,
-0.25503939390182495,
-0.4673396050930023,
-0.06890489161014557,
-0.3758998513221741,
-0.43210071325302124,
0.7205347418785095,
0.44941651821136475,
0.03919099271297455,
-0.433084636926651,
0.515029788017273,
-0.07552871853113174,
0.1613072156906128,
-0.11768174916505814,
0.8594789505004883,
0.2185242921113968,
-0.6467024683952332,
0.436798632144928,
0.16947953402996063,
0.894828200340271,
-0.8059767484664917,
0.04854245483875275,
0.3323141634464264,
0.04456927627325058,
-0.1482289433479309,
-0.8411942720413208,
0.2570594251155853,
-0.06699645519256592,
0.031871117651462555,
-0.3594856262207031,
0.6312214136123657,
-0.7172662615776062,
-0.2712923288345337,
0.632372260093689,
0.22046948969364166,
0.2863701581954956,
0.3249157667160034,
-0.9833388328552246,
0.3398038148880005,
0.2093595713376999,
-0.15228509902954102,
0.18576030433177948,
0.1241563931107521,
-0.2825719118118286,
0.23389306664466858,
0.7071070075035095,
0.11337840557098389,
0.4596933424472809,
0.36510804295539856,
0.5064289569854736,
-0.2846599817276001,
-0.5525369048118591,
-0.5096458196640015,
0.6842058897018433,
-0.10415180772542953,
-0.24279749393463135,
0.7274753451347351,
0.5072588324546814,
0.9640839695930481,
0.21544571220874786,
1.057226538658142,
0.1730143427848816,
0.519494354724884,
-0.39904066920280457,
0.45715561509132385,
-0.6703760623931885,
-0.15226933360099792,
-0.1638069450855255,
-0.7961705923080444,
-0.3109477758407593,
0.5386683344841003,
-0.20578035712242126,
-0.24821703135967255,
0.7078940868377686,
0.3933652341365814,
0.0703466460108757,
0.2518457770347595,
0.5692600607872009,
-0.04646440967917442,
0.42545729875564575,
0.3979908525943756,
0.7039640545845032,
-1.0230153799057007,
0.6080939769744873,
-0.22191698849201202,
0.01914259046316147,
-0.10459010303020477,
-0.7014724612236023,
-0.18556073307991028,
-0.6995885968208313,
-0.3484736382961273,
-0.25013628602027893,
-0.027401190251111984,
0.7663267254829407,
0.613528311252594,
-0.7922742962837219,
-0.5208144187927246,
-0.1351272016763687,
-0.2543693482875824,
-0.0995054543018341,
-0.25813260674476624,
-0.06092745065689087,
-0.4537133574485779,
-0.8833070993423462,
0.7514851689338684,
0.6233803033828735,
0.002558099804446101,
-0.4519498646259308,
-0.45606857538223267,
-0.4916597008705139,
-0.048754461109638214,
0.3452223241329193,
0.15923193097114563,
-1.0919252634048462,
-0.36580905318260193,
-0.03736323490738869,
-0.04324623942375183,
0.37976035475730896,
0.4757218360900879,
-0.49547505378723145,
0.7313739657402039,
0.31935325264930725,
0.5949360132217407,
0.503335177898407,
-0.23316586017608643,
0.7754424810409546,
-0.7763499021530151,
0.35838207602500916,
0.3974442780017853,
0.48918959498405457,
0.3397368788719177,
-0.0985378548502922,
0.41611599922180176,
-0.13285131752490997,
-0.8344373106956482,
-1.04533052444458,
0.24654603004455566,
-0.9204345345497131,
0.15553776919841766,
0.6402310132980347,
-0.12575948238372803,
0.007320550736039877,
-0.31775397062301636,
-0.22406227886676788,
0.4939090311527252,
-0.2997031509876251,
-0.24932214617729187,
0.5265183448791504,
0.010535122826695442,
-0.1639000028371811,
-1.047277569770813,
0.01311237271875143,
0.5611865520477295,
-0.7527914643287659,
-0.2638804018497467,
0.2534339725971222,
0.15332654118537903,
0.28426942229270935,
0.844169020652771,
-0.3287509083747864,
0.4288555681705475,
0.11046172678470612,
0.312905877828598,
0.3618549406528473,
-0.23808443546295166,
-0.477627158164978,
-0.19093020260334015,
0.027729779481887817,
-0.36419957876205444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00782v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00782v2 | Step-Controlled DPO: Leveraging Stepwise Error for Enhanced Mathematical Reasoning | 2024-06-30T17:59:07 | 2024-07-02T04:46:35 | Zimu Lu, Aojun Zhou, Ke Wang, Houxing Ren, Weikang Shi, Junting Pan, Mingjie Zhan, Hongsheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has proven effective at improving the
performance of large language models (LLMs) on downstream tasks such as
reasoning and alignment. In this work, we propose Step-Controlled DPO (SCDPO),
a method for automatically providing stepwise error supervision by creating
negative samples of mathematical reasoning rationales that start making errors
at a specified step. By applying these samples in DPO training, SCDPO can
better align the model to understand reasoning errors and output accurate
reasoning steps. We apply SCDPO to both code-integrated and chain-of-thought
solutions, empirically showing that it consistently improves the performance
compared to naive DPO on three different SFT models, including one existing SFT
model and two models we finetuned. Qualitative analysis of the credit
assignment of SCDPO and DPO demonstrates the effectiveness of SCDPO at
identifying errors in mathematical solutions. We then apply SCDPO to an
InternLM2-20B model, resulting in a 20B model that achieves high scores of
88.5% on GSM8K and 58.1% on MATH, rivaling all other open-source LLMs, showing
the great potential of our method. | [
-0.055346593260765076,
-0.6030111908912659,
0.902531087398529,
0.8078773617744446,
-0.30449843406677246,
0.12564021348953247,
0.11399999260902405,
-0.08041097223758698,
-0.15436439216136932,
0.7334592342376709,
-0.5784460306167603,
-0.29291942715644836,
-0.6643097400665283,
0.22615915536880493,
-0.02661454863846302,
0.5348957180976868,
-0.4693978428840637,
0.5673077702522278,
-0.4076736271381378,
0.6100069880485535,
-0.3384898900985718,
-0.06827371567487717,
-0.926452100276947,
-0.5947125554084778,
0.19373829662799835,
0.5372437238693237,
0.7239493131637573,
0.772564172744751,
0.643680989742279,
0.2758510410785675,
-0.04042953997850418,
0.346940815448761,
-0.13852770626544952,
0.016207972541451454,
-0.2564713954925537,
-0.5689511895179749,
-0.8886874318122864,
0.14424364268779755,
0.18818390369415283,
0.6831620335578918,
-0.4544559121131897,
-0.16523462533950806,
-0.05530083552002907,
0.956747829914093,
-0.5680818557739258,
0.30855244398117065,
-0.48711732029914856,
0.056597333401441574,
0.3926139175891876,
-0.24517609179019928,
-0.647512674331665,
-0.8226721286773682,
-0.07702883332967758,
-0.8111476302146912,
-0.20862439274787903,
-0.1928875595331192,
0.3765689730644226,
0.800020694732666,
-0.20476959645748138,
-0.5554214119911194,
-0.767848014831543,
0.9864951968193054,
-0.7192671298980713,
0.20236261188983917,
0.43660083413124084,
0.1237461045384407,
-0.34576117992401123,
-0.09943671524524689,
-0.4994002878665924,
-0.23297341167926788,
0.03775208815932274,
0.18614116311073303,
0.07617129385471344,
0.3055016100406647,
0.4564758241176605,
0.15222011506557465,
-0.017721528187394142,
0.06718029081821442,
-0.017744187265634537,
-0.18964208662509918,
0.8430215120315552,
0.012777330353856087,
-0.005068989470601082,
-0.1927930861711502,
-0.2558458149433136,
-0.009214665740728378,
-0.4428178369998932,
0.035686541348695755,
0.4204115569591522,
0.13581746816635132,
0.21261239051818848,
0.6298592686653137,
-0.2243044525384903,
0.8545008897781372,
0.44067955017089844,
-0.4564303159713745,
0.009524939581751823,
-0.15769875049591064,
-0.2833859622478485,
0.19997844099998474,
0.5538098812103271,
0.2510683536529541,
0.4673941433429718,
0.3313398063182831,
-0.49471068382263184,
0.07668408751487732,
0.16781306266784668,
-0.7177929282188416,
-0.07821877300739288,
0.4877009689807892,
-0.020677931606769562,
-0.5639775395393372,
-0.130130335688591,
-0.8709562420845032,
-0.3984296917915344,
-0.7883149981498718,
0.27380481362342834,
-0.416939377784729,
-0.11803993582725525,
0.270905077457428,
0.09309656172990799,
-0.11692163348197937,
0.8495016694068909,
-0.7568250894546509,
0.31063708662986755,
0.6933144330978394,
0.7475070953369141,
-0.30411702394485474,
-0.17889784276485443,
-0.8283901810646057,
0.03699621185660362,
-0.8592916131019592,
0.43104755878448486,
-0.7050869464874268,
-0.37580013275146484,
-0.17607177793979645,
-0.5935009717941284,
-0.20086805522441864,
-0.5028166770935059,
0.8193091154098511,
-0.6354990601539612,
-0.05050859600305557,
-0.15393315255641937,
-0.39142468571662903,
0.19539964199066162,
0.0699852779507637,
-0.4000530540943146,
1.203903079032898,
0.1077294647693634,
-0.6841424107551575,
0.3318299651145935,
-0.6120780110359192,
-0.2051434963941574,
-0.35235318541526794,
-0.15813684463500977,
-0.2269689291715622,
0.29070088267326355,
0.34116923809051514,
0.3416975140571594,
-0.1261201798915863,
0.38955754041671753,
-0.4334971010684967,
-0.5008102059364319,
-0.04818515107035637,
-0.06863071024417877,
0.8907238245010376,
0.12117257714271545,
-0.4676022231578827,
0.2088036984205246,
-1.1593860387802124,
0.053019411861896515,
0.2734357714653015,
-0.37849944829940796,
-0.6805393695831299,
0.09472616016864777,
-0.8905023336410522,
0.5368546843528748,
0.1552026867866516,
-0.5265093445777893,
0.4107052683830261,
-0.14552278816699982,
0.20196469128131866,
1.1088083982467651,
-0.20366887748241425,
0.5858911275863647,
0.03204068914055824,
0.5838775038719177,
0.027959143742918968,
0.33587637543678284,
0.1911906599998474,
-0.2986839711666107,
-0.8312510848045349,
-0.31232231855392456,
0.1775989681482315,
1.007955551147461,
-0.9463920593261719,
0.6637742519378662,
0.04572874680161476,
-0.1976892203092575,
-0.20612125098705292,
0.20588815212249756,
0.2721528112888336,
0.9328395128250122,
0.2341773360967636,
0.07119833678007126,
-0.24193814396858215,
-0.7374760508537292,
-0.0750758945941925,
-0.16632463037967682,
-0.11010748147964478,
0.4534533619880676,
0.3012147843837738,
-0.13404373824596405,
0.8093528151512146,
-0.7209876775741577,
0.03810703754425049,
-0.06231988966464996,
-0.020566802471876144,
0.25215446949005127,
0.49426546692848206,
0.23726648092269897,
-0.6572690010070801,
-0.6293411254882812,
-0.16050270199775696,
-0.42453140020370483,
-0.49434807896614075,
-0.22781836986541748,
-0.4287853240966797,
0.14156381785869598,
0.16128545999526978,
-0.48265406489372253,
0.2153019905090332,
0.4490102231502533,
-0.21507056057453156,
0.45753517746925354,
-0.4438343346118927,
0.2393157035112381,
-0.7607501745223999,
-0.32492128014564514,
0.20419761538505554,
0.0016265868907794356,
-0.4196202754974365,
-0.3497827351093292,
0.2459159642457962,
0.005849622189998627,
-0.10205703973770142,
0.05458296835422516,
-0.083295077085495,
0.009577558375895023,
-0.2657933533191681,
0.1265900731086731,
-0.05401545390486717,
0.44684869050979614,
0.21092332899570465,
0.6603862643241882,
0.635812520980835,
-0.77756667137146,
0.3809015452861786,
0.2554876506328583,
0.005963682662695646,
0.6020799279212952,
-0.744731068611145,
0.3032229244709015,
-0.09511487931013107,
0.3097134530544281,
-1.0008705854415894,
-0.2834572196006775,
0.312844842672348,
-0.17997626960277557,
0.3853370249271393,
-0.190393328666687,
-0.45762231945991516,
-0.40142375230789185,
-0.3335667848587036,
0.2564255893230438,
0.2147725522518158,
-0.6529521346092224,
0.5412965416908264,
0.08960141241550446,
-0.3464803397655487,
-0.7413110733032227,
-0.24379278719425201,
-0.2646442949771881,
0.0077706677839159966,
-0.5034611821174622,
0.12895138561725616,
-0.026687640696763992,
-0.5415756702423096,
-0.5247421860694885,
-0.3868163228034973,
0.026203637942671776,
-0.005758664570748806,
0.06414739042520523,
0.5955042243003845,
0.46953141689300537,
0.019102122634649277,
0.534008264541626,
-0.3400476276874542,
0.2839818298816681,
-0.39167866110801697,
0.5361066460609436,
0.29616498947143555,
-0.42340975999832153,
-0.39622676372528076,
0.25910520553588867,
0.6468906998634338,
-0.18617366254329681,
-0.0005758105544373393,
-0.2081514596939087,
-0.1796335130929947,
-0.605623722076416,
-0.26996615529060364,
-0.04562034085392952,
-0.47203201055526733,
-0.045353200286626816,
-0.4439552426338196,
-0.308498740196228,
0.1914825290441513,
-0.24217842519283295,
0.05396505072712898,
0.19448687136173248,
0.16615581512451172,
0.028996266424655914,
1.44025456905365,
0.5506735444068909,
0.1897290199995041,
0.5579814314842224,
-0.09123695641756058,
0.2605237662792206,
-0.6126726269721985,
-0.12646378576755524,
-0.4432568848133087,
0.02503211237490177,
-0.4711158573627472,
-0.6816065907478333,
0.16681815683841705,
0.5145085453987122,
-0.27966663241386414,
0.13744865357875824,
-0.674591600894928,
0.35218557715415955,
0.5984094738960266,
0.2897920310497284,
0.4913451075553894,
-0.010664768517017365,
-0.39777424931526184,
-0.18895851075649261,
-0.6180680990219116,
-0.382373183965683,
1.0433768033981323,
0.2884538471698761,
0.9542653560638428,
-0.37479913234710693,
0.9783584475517273,
0.10919894278049469,
0.20393918454647064,
-0.9854825139045715,
0.5610716938972473,
0.07123197615146637,
-0.29054808616638184,
-0.23450718820095062,
-0.7264392375946045,
-0.10438083112239838,
0.1149609312415123,
0.2398761808872223,
-0.452714204788208,
0.38779720664024353,
0.5385845303535461,
-0.363078236579895,
0.08551554381847382,
-0.5655421614646912,
0.4567238688468933,
-0.4677197337150574,
-0.6399543285369873,
-0.3432719111442566,
-0.2990071475505829,
0.5092238783836365,
-0.2157936990261078,
0.24438035488128662,
-0.05082559585571289,
-0.17836429178714752,
0.39797243475914,
-0.5506111979484558,
0.63625168800354,
-0.35127004981040955,
-0.440792441368103,
0.4145817160606384,
0.4341088831424713,
0.9472199082374573,
0.09577202051877975,
-0.26922333240509033,
0.06728576868772507,
-0.16419480741024017,
-0.3793017268180847,
-0.6547383666038513,
0.7871077656745911,
-0.525604248046875,
-0.7126450538635254,
-0.5998797416687012,
-0.5071264505386353,
-0.40451666712760925,
0.2853844165802002,
-0.19814267754554749,
0.12087807059288025,
0.4609328508377075,
-0.3099406361579895,
0.7373386025428772,
0.07203580439090729,
0.4732551872730255,
0.40341174602508545,
-0.3214442729949951,
-0.6871169209480286,
0.5768866539001465,
-0.14170269668102264,
0.5471979975700378,
0.34352728724479675,
0.5828216671943665,
-0.29268375039100647,
-0.7301434874534607,
-0.6331559419631958,
0.29365280270576477,
-0.7553749680519104,
-0.02754952199757099,
-0.35066309571266174,
0.2276340276002884,
-0.2693201005458832,
-0.19657380878925323,
-0.5473366379737854,
-0.5190107822418213,
0.02611633390188217,
-0.195638507604599,
0.24422849714756012,
0.5606635808944702,
-0.2215317040681839,
-0.03408316522836685,
-0.5266660451889038,
0.24379143118858337,
0.32846471667289734,
0.5919007062911987,
-0.16626092791557312,
-0.3221985399723053,
0.1073390543460846,
0.06005304306745529,
-0.3048528730869293,
-0.7967668771743774,
0.17343799769878387,
-0.13520485162734985,
0.42132875323295593,
0.3765779435634613,
0.1913890242576599,
0.6641820669174194,
-0.5325239300727844,
0.3885161876678467,
0.1891147941350937,
-1.2505018711090088,
1.1356078386306763,
-0.4230581820011139,
0.022147301584482193,
0.4963185489177704,
0.6299397945404053,
-0.025500550866127014,
-0.11391878873109818,
-0.41917330026626587,
-0.5654541254043579,
0.844865083694458,
0.036963462829589844,
-0.1423749178647995,
0.07446872442960739,
0.6577932834625244,
0.09975641965866089,
0.293971449136734,
-0.4372551441192627,
-0.04284914955496788,
-0.13427335023880005,
-0.022282423451542854,
0.2031334489583969,
-0.19414041936397552,
-0.37802883982658386,
-0.26035386323928833,
0.8750921487808228,
-0.4621538817882538,
-0.07356736063957214,
0.5871256589889526,
0.17927779257297516,
-0.5973103046417236,
0.08913169801235199,
0.6831327676773071,
1.1803107261657715,
-0.22896523773670197,
-0.047356754541397095,
-0.01609090156853199,
-0.545830488204956,
0.1942746341228485,
0.21062029898166656,
-0.5135667324066162,
-0.1414542943239212,
0.06511282175779343,
0.49045053124427795,
0.05363832786679268,
-0.6011530160903931,
0.3604792356491089,
0.17366723716259003,
-0.1576693207025528,
-0.16623494029045105,
0.23103129863739014,
-0.2034664750099182,
0.04781031236052513,
0.28773242235183716,
0.2133394330739975,
0.09514615684747696,
-0.2104441076517105,
0.18900536000728607,
0.2790273427963257,
-0.35127678513526917,
-0.035266388207674026,
0.5513849258422852,
0.3151116669178009,
-0.3059728145599365,
0.42979350686073303,
-0.08576364815235138,
-0.5226039290428162,
0.6357756853103638,
0.59500652551651,
0.7638418674468994,
-0.3504379093647003,
0.449772447347641,
0.5607032179832458,
0.03658951818943024,
-0.34433409571647644,
0.31659600138664246,
-0.3363853096961975,
-0.8180262446403503,
-0.9191712737083435,
-0.6960315108299255,
-0.7960054278373718,
-0.19124487042427063,
-0.7211493253707886,
0.4092417359352112,
-0.8603431582450867,
0.24709069728851318,
-0.1526634842157364,
0.15724638104438782,
-0.23539726436138153,
0.4426233768463135,
0.02354699932038784,
0.9012224674224854,
-0.6960007548332214,
0.8372500538825989,
0.5941633582115173,
-0.1444033533334732,
-0.8692046403884888,
-0.06960566341876984,
-0.04214482009410858,
-0.9057626724243164,
0.7323707938194275,
-0.2318471372127533,
-0.40775495767593384,
0.016830507665872574,
-0.39161917567253113,
-0.8719636797904968,
1.0871680974960327,
0.33843502402305603,
-0.9639086723327637,
0.07396163791418076,
0.1021418422460556,
0.36254456639289856,
-0.4473482668399811,
0.24370640516281128,
0.7669075727462769,
0.39607924222946167,
0.5628136992454529,
-0.9361019134521484,
0.1463303416967392,
0.20989124476909637,
-0.0473545640707016,
0.3966675400733948,
-0.6562370657920837,
0.664817750453949,
-0.4818379878997803,
0.2648317515850067,
-0.29617106914520264,
0.21378041803836823,
0.7056257724761963,
0.4858168065547943,
0.8202203512191772,
0.5682774186134338,
0.8012835383415222,
-0.192368283867836,
1.1277618408203125,
-0.31066349148750305,
0.2932952344417572,
1.0301326513290405,
-0.40227678418159485,
0.6728683114051819,
0.8309014439582825,
-0.4525335431098938,
0.2922897934913635,
0.8163132667541504,
0.3920237123966217,
0.5986817479133606,
0.3770606815814972,
-0.12900811433792114,
-0.4199783504009247,
0.23736615478992462,
-0.007014166563749313,
0.287309855222702,
0.2311844825744629,
-0.394015371799469,
0.00017300866602454334,
-0.3782198429107666,
0.15748338401317596,
0.2570593059062958,
-0.5846096873283386,
0.5478656888008118,
0.09611330181360245,
-0.9679807424545288,
0.4265010952949524,
-0.41810208559036255,
0.3995606303215027,
-0.7065646648406982,
-0.23312120139598846,
-0.3736666738986969,
0.5663172602653503,
-0.353962779045105,
-0.4592965543270111,
0.26920953392982483,
-0.03626125305891037,
-0.0400080531835556,
-0.5440962314605713,
0.5900429487228394,
-0.20632928609848022,
-0.8227766156196594,
0.4218379557132721,
0.30053791403770447,
-0.22300420701503754,
-0.14404858648777008,
-0.732704222202301,
0.07509832084178925,
0.27845093607902527,
-0.17822007834911346,
-0.013203366659581661,
0.4170212745666504,
-0.1582052856683731,
0.7099260091781616,
0.6537736058235168,
0.2897331416606903,
-0.07942600548267365,
0.15707622468471527,
0.8333277702331543,
-0.5078173279762268,
-0.3579036295413971,
-0.8344737887382507,
0.45491287112236023,
-0.43712782859802246,
-0.3496816158294678,
0.7744073271751404,
0.4503232538700104,
0.9147756695747375,
-0.05265574902296066,
0.8198886513710022,
0.13279250264167786,
0.45876187086105347,
-0.5368647575378418,
0.005291532725095749,
-0.39961737394332886,
0.49874648451805115,
-0.589390218257904,
-1.1072734594345093,
-0.4076317250728607,
0.7669776678085327,
-0.7556034326553345,
-0.2113313525915146,
0.5466864109039307,
0.5686262249946594,
-0.0004257975670043379,
0.00212744134478271,
0.15044471621513367,
-0.10242429375648499,
0.39905422925949097,
0.4736257791519165,
0.894954264163971,
-0.236890971660614,
0.5024254322052002,
-0.8113980293273926,
-0.7776896357536316,
-0.15768007934093475,
-1.1063143014907837,
-0.703334391117096,
0.04536065459251404,
-0.5674248933792114,
-0.5005805492401123,
-0.22273309528827667,
1.0095973014831543,
0.4281070828437805,
-0.9256092309951782,
-0.20521017909049988,
-0.7631446719169617,
0.4098837077617645,
-0.4432916045188904,
-0.227168008685112,
0.20298610627651215,
-0.486354261636734,
-1.131564736366272,
0.3724270761013031,
0.4551607072353363,
-0.018277369439601898,
-0.16571614146232605,
-0.2344866544008255,
0.118138886988163,
0.5049123167991638,
0.5907703042030334,
-0.18244345486164093,
-0.5898711681365967,
-0.27310654520988464,
0.26092293858528137,
-0.04916461184620857,
0.08176138252019882,
1.2013756036758423,
-0.24397064745426178,
0.5775603652000427,
0.7179921269416809,
0.41510942578315735,
0.36161714792251587,
0.19379086792469025,
0.7718384861946106,
-0.14033590257167816,
-0.041052624583244324,
0.4549325704574585,
0.35770168900489807,
0.17206843197345734,
-0.5891130566596985,
0.5478372573852539,
0.331644743680954,
-0.5681924819946289,
-0.6588770151138306,
0.40979310870170593,
-1.0469378232955933,
-0.12941794097423553,
1.1371405124664307,
-0.15707167983055115,
-0.07025753706693649,
0.23228874802589417,
-0.4520326852798462,
-0.026695359498262405,
-0.6000595092773438,
1.069656252861023,
0.7772905826568604,
-0.7192773818969727,
-0.053103767335414886,
-0.4873127341270447,
0.7333823442459106,
0.4648647606372833,
-0.8000428080558777,
0.03168707713484764,
0.727703869342804,
0.239831805229187,
0.3073817491531372,
0.5450697541236877,
-0.15655167400836945,
0.21634097397327423,
0.10939764231443405,
-0.18606799840927124,
-0.19000646471977234,
-0.40415430068969727,
-0.4403609335422516,
-0.06641079485416412,
-0.06025554984807968,
-0.29637137055397034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00764v1 | Characterizing Stereotypical Bias from Privacy-preserving Pre-Training | 2024-06-30T16:54:43 | 2024-06-30T16:54:43 | Stefan Arnold, Rene Gröbner, Annika Schreiner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Differential Privacy (DP) can be applied to raw text by exploiting the
spatial arrangement of words in an embedding space. We investigate the
implications of such text privatization on Language Models (LMs) and their
tendency towards stereotypical associations. Since previous studies documented
that linguistic proficiency correlates with stereotypical bias, one could
assume that techniques for text privatization, which are known to degrade
language modeling capabilities, would cancel out undesirable biases. By testing
BERT models trained on texts containing biased statements primed with varying
degrees of privacy, our study reveals that while stereotypical bias generally
diminishes when privacy is tightened, text privatization does not uniformly
equate to diminishing bias across all social domains. This highlights the need
for careful diagnosis of bias in LMs that undergo text privatization. | [
-0.4375776946544647,
-0.6696670651435852,
0.623114824295044,
0.30743104219436646,
-0.13184329867362976,
-0.0738234668970108,
-0.16522948443889618,
-0.4718666970729828,
0.17405596375465393,
0.7289490699768066,
-0.37883350253105164,
-0.5988318920135498,
-0.8746973872184753,
0.09175116568803787,
-0.516148030757904,
0.9421623945236206,
0.1438736915588379,
0.14886122941970825,
-0.2730877995491028,
0.12635570764541626,
-0.1098925992846489,
-1.098612904548645,
0.011029361747205257,
-0.271809458732605,
0.10908696800470352,
-0.011366184800863266,
0.9806209802627563,
0.7286403179168701,
0.12039215117692947,
0.310848206281662,
-0.2628389894962311,
-0.293984591960907,
-0.4301433563232422,
0.04525797814130783,
-0.06456694006919861,
-0.24791476130485535,
-0.4720500111579895,
0.6347233057022095,
0.6170746088027954,
0.9345282912254333,
0.14375334978103638,
-0.17033834755420685,
0.37271928787231445,
0.7423810958862305,
-0.7576978206634521,
0.22175945341587067,
-0.65330970287323,
0.16052477061748505,
-0.07684356719255447,
0.1075313463807106,
-0.2909604012966156,
-0.764447033405304,
0.694747805595398,
-0.29987743496894836,
0.4686952233314514,
-0.0763314813375473,
1.0516589879989624,
0.20570871233940125,
-0.3511335849761963,
-0.23120112717151642,
-0.7135620713233948,
0.6684474945068359,
-0.4438898265361786,
0.5027049779891968,
1.0226480960845947,
-0.03528279811143875,
0.2764858305454254,
-0.3305344879627228,
-0.34710389375686646,
-0.5127501487731934,
-0.4668661653995514,
-0.1492331326007843,
-0.08668075501918793,
0.4150029122829437,
0.3315821886062622,
0.40928998589515686,
-0.25754648447036743,
0.2609274387359619,
-0.35678860545158386,
-0.24755975604057312,
0.6255574226379395,
-0.22730740904808044,
0.38781192898750305,
-0.20008283853530884,
-0.4172653555870056,
-0.01890522614121437,
-0.6077647805213928,
-0.14362695813179016,
1.0160136222839355,
0.1286805421113968,
-0.2513200640678406,
0.4930928647518158,
0.09132826328277588,
0.5330280065536499,
-0.07946919649839401,
0.06799684464931488,
0.3025290369987488,
0.01529245637357235,
-0.3594927191734314,
0.26639050245285034,
0.7118927240371704,
0.3032808005809784,
0.8400925397872925,
-0.19061002135276794,
-0.018862806260585785,
0.01560188364237547,
0.2734913229942322,
-0.4013311564922333,
-0.3263948857784271,
0.2134178727865219,
-0.47845107316970825,
-0.47952401638031006,
-0.017637552693486214,
-0.8706672787666321,
-0.5312634110450745,
-0.22127079963684082,
0.2124413102865219,
-0.47715187072753906,
-0.20082053542137146,
0.42696383595466614,
-0.40895068645477295,
-0.19548630714416504,
-0.16510599851608276,
-1.1273306608200073,
0.3898206055164337,
0.6490579843521118,
0.6572666764259338,
0.15889576077461243,
-0.31737959384918213,
0.18059369921684265,
0.08806278556585312,
-0.31262150406837463,
0.19669204950332642,
-0.6123062372207642,
-0.561430037021637,
0.4058823883533478,
-0.2776629626750946,
0.06531912833452225,
-0.5606595873832703,
0.4119411110877991,
-0.5252476930618286,
0.43726733326911926,
-0.27372997999191284,
-0.45523616671562195,
0.09329210966825485,
0.2925107181072235,
-0.7827180027961731,
0.559395968914032,
-0.24507877230644226,
-1.282076358795166,
0.659110426902771,
-0.2464800477027893,
-0.13276678323745728,
-0.5232957601547241,
-0.3211778700351715,
-0.5701589584350586,
0.062480565160512924,
0.1787119358778,
0.5063559412956238,
0.34854429960250854,
0.36752068996429443,
-0.4634688198566437,
-0.2955803871154785,
0.5241338014602661,
-0.3265659809112549,
1.0300695896148682,
0.15454842150211334,
-0.2083093374967575,
-0.4366828501224518,
-0.7357536554336548,
-0.3232863247394562,
-0.11804407835006714,
-0.04470397159457207,
-1.200646162033081,
0.025140605866909027,
-0.4037064015865326,
-0.07317881286144257,
0.47916465997695923,
-0.5986056923866272,
0.01027804333716631,
-0.6330451369285583,
0.015227505937218666,
1.084985375404358,
-0.268033891916275,
1.0275179147720337,
-0.13841597735881805,
0.42989522218704224,
0.23498263955116272,
0.47338321805000305,
0.2832689583301544,
-0.36070239543914795,
-0.24237912893295288,
-0.749251127243042,
0.41469311714172363,
0.24377040565013885,
-0.07876286655664444,
0.527415931224823,
-0.25082704424858093,
-0.13911102712154388,
-0.41147667169570923,
-0.06387913227081299,
0.5373013615608215,
0.1752774715423584,
-0.018040921539068222,
-0.3199801445007324,
-0.47515079379081726,
-1.48032546043396,
-0.5806838274002075,
-0.0738539770245552,
0.03558582812547684,
0.4204850494861603,
0.06270092725753784,
-0.30874210596084595,
1.1891670227050781,
-0.4355403780937195,
-0.4769202470779419,
0.04983708634972572,
0.007487935479730368,
-0.12417755275964737,
0.23549015820026398,
0.632347047328949,
-0.7002884149551392,
-0.4326593279838562,
-0.4826235771179199,
-0.6134928464889526,
-0.319121390581131,
0.14816638827323914,
-0.14599409699440002,
0.27377551794052124,
0.24259747564792633,
-0.31022679805755615,
0.4746148884296417,
1.0098884105682373,
-0.3777237832546234,
0.4361891746520996,
-0.35250189900398254,
-0.15604743361473083,
-0.7845571041107178,
-0.4030783474445343,
0.12095298618078232,
-0.12220829725265503,
-0.5287189483642578,
-0.2071315199136734,
0.02527657337486744,
-0.02884398028254509,
-0.2288537621498108,
0.18872475624084473,
-0.8151506185531616,
-0.36464637517929077,
-0.20690695941448212,
0.18033204972743988,
0.05632185563445091,
-0.024957695975899696,
0.505552351474762,
0.5588935613632202,
0.6811560988426208,
-0.7338767051696777,
-0.27352339029312134,
0.19191902875900269,
-0.38376128673553467,
-0.29235169291496277,
-0.48536038398742676,
0.10418232530355453,
-0.44514623284339905,
0.16460919380187988,
-0.8762381672859192,
-0.024522924795746803,
0.050870973616838455,
-0.30647796392440796,
0.24335871636867523,
-0.15988482534885406,
-0.5346021056175232,
0.023871824145317078,
-0.5692280530929565,
0.4092995822429657,
0.6391916275024414,
-0.5511059761047363,
0.09356082230806351,
0.6315600275993347,
-0.1530379354953766,
-1.0253410339355469,
-0.9475141763687134,
-0.328156441450119,
-0.11812380701303482,
-0.5311676263809204,
0.40587306022644043,
0.4883085787296295,
-0.5664958357810974,
-0.039508722722530365,
0.06750129908323288,
-0.4331965148448944,
0.07163825631141663,
0.3550771474838257,
0.3754139244556427,
0.2646695375442505,
0.056033533066511154,
0.312555730342865,
0.16633237898349762,
0.248868927359581,
-0.045297782868146896,
0.6247740387916565,
0.2128731608390808,
-0.000215391322853975,
-0.22465047240257263,
0.2885339856147766,
0.38211482763290405,
-0.03621828556060791,
1.0687146186828613,
-0.2516963481903076,
-0.1580595225095749,
-0.23925039172172546,
-0.46903127431869507,
-0.36388537287712097,
-0.48666098713874817,
0.2808332145214081,
-0.12112747132778168,
-0.8533031940460205,
0.3741987943649292,
0.17691558599472046,
0.017049934715032578,
-0.21779075264930725,
0.35963091254234314,
-0.028964200988411903,
0.7383661270141602,
1.0935136079788208,
-0.23475824296474457,
0.5703817009925842,
-0.09369762241840363,
0.45172783732414246,
-0.40979036688804626,
-0.19426237046718597,
-0.7272562384605408,
-0.12781929969787598,
-1.197616457939148,
-0.24052967131137848,
0.22393536567687988,
-0.2158377319574356,
-0.243257537484169,
0.1334296464920044,
-0.6038801670074463,
0.6711682677268982,
0.44828978180885315,
0.1207694262266159,
0.3895053565502167,
0.25893455743789673,
-0.20036254823207855,
-0.5178384184837341,
-0.4485905170440674,
-0.8748138546943665,
1.2069576978683472,
0.7781496644020081,
0.7597330808639526,
-0.21248169243335724,
1.2257709503173828,
0.18364104628562927,
0.28379738330841064,
-0.2642679810523987,
0.5623138546943665,
-0.4316137433052063,
-1.1059019565582275,
-0.43366390466690063,
-0.25241100788116455,
-0.6096085906028748,
0.2084205597639084,
0.010545880533754826,
-1.000439167022705,
0.7101933360099792,
0.44009530544281006,
-0.00411773007363081,
0.19487258791923523,
-0.7421383261680603,
0.5134879946708679,
-0.061605654656887054,
-0.36503422260284424,
0.017853574827313423,
-0.4829145073890686,
0.9096667766571045,
-0.11805178225040436,
0.3836577832698822,
-0.1520974338054657,
-0.005896723363548517,
0.5129852294921875,
-0.14133991301059723,
1.1188948154449463,
-0.29769274592399597,
-0.40186718106269836,
-0.40254542231559753,
0.2110649049282074,
0.23989073932170868,
0.04851450398564339,
-0.12181788682937622,
0.4762112498283386,
-0.055069055408239365,
-0.337695837020874,
-0.28123971819877625,
0.6363533735275269,
-1.2041813135147095,
-0.6607252955436707,
-0.580170214176178,
-0.4790824353694916,
-0.38888999819755554,
-0.09222813695669174,
0.49440646171569824,
0.03462029621005058,
-0.529399037361145,
-0.12239176779985428,
0.9850218892097473,
-0.7078293561935425,
0.21098101139068604,
0.42271822690963745,
-0.42734354734420776,
0.051047198474407196,
0.3636517822742462,
0.24053682386875153,
0.3003075420856476,
0.2842848598957062,
0.24549905955791473,
-0.5849558711051941,
-0.3392829895019531,
0.20314918458461761,
0.37062451243400574,
-0.4256228506565094,
0.3493458926677704,
-1.0028473138809204,
-0.2950998842716217,
-0.7170071005821228,
-0.13938970863819122,
-0.634114682674408,
-0.4966314136981964,
-0.08003117144107819,
-0.337078720331192,
0.15739956498146057,
0.5841227173805237,
-0.3496677875518799,
0.023606909438967705,
-0.5668880939483643,
0.4118258059024811,
0.26449403166770935,
0.4009198546409607,
-0.27843600511550903,
-0.572947084903717,
0.021613165736198425,
0.08371900767087936,
-0.13111203908920288,
-1.0680674314498901,
0.5236572623252869,
-0.09591607004404068,
0.5382293462753296,
0.5464881658554077,
0.18029183149337769,
0.038712795823812485,
-0.6206713914871216,
0.8469955325126648,
-0.004225871991366148,
-1.0002480745315552,
0.5644035935401917,
-0.45578113198280334,
-0.30319201946258545,
0.4018816351890564,
0.8529351949691772,
-0.1462746560573578,
-0.9866634607315063,
-0.7044671177864075,
-0.8635238409042358,
0.6020676493644714,
0.07880354672670364,
0.629700243473053,
-0.07619470357894897,
0.21977926790714264,
0.39139387011528015,
0.4235082268714905,
-1.101172924041748,
-0.4396389126777649,
-0.47461771965026855,
0.14908237755298615,
-0.16994236409664154,
-0.864514172077179,
-0.30226439237594604,
-0.29636305570602417,
0.4490882158279419,
0.48769432306289673,
0.3411978483200073,
0.18791042268276215,
0.037873607128858566,
0.5219157934188843,
0.568323016166687,
0.5370928049087524,
0.5698165893554688,
-0.37428998947143555,
0.16418011486530304,
-0.36234453320503235,
-0.6503385305404663,
0.26618698239326477,
0.3013913333415985,
-0.5300388932228088,
0.357188880443573,
-0.012488983571529388,
0.40795379877090454,
0.056151676923036575,
-0.2700671851634979,
0.709180474281311,
0.059333037585020065,
-0.4773499369621277,
-0.29215773940086365,
-0.17800837755203247,
-0.07293698191642761,
-0.1391911655664444,
-0.04220020771026611,
-0.2515459954738617,
0.325165331363678,
-0.6664105653762817,
0.05067906901240349,
0.5466121435165405,
-0.2539016306400299,
-0.20810550451278687,
0.5293849110603333,
0.260845810174942,
-0.1303759068250656,
0.5437031984329224,
0.14321637153625488,
-0.5180615186691284,
0.3375526964664459,
0.2653160095214844,
1.1610076427459717,
-0.17458361387252808,
0.5545042157173157,
0.05460905656218529,
0.5904341340065002,
-0.04656166955828667,
-0.07598525285720825,
-0.1606965810060501,
-1.118894100189209,
-0.11608832329511642,
-0.6527722477912903,
-0.21316955983638763,
0.25076794624328613,
-0.815091609954834,
-0.006187915802001953,
-0.6709417104721069,
-0.29124918580055237,
-0.22672729194164276,
-0.20117324590682983,
-0.47232213616371155,
0.2637040317058563,
0.3150087893009186,
0.6787309646606445,
-1.1845390796661377,
0.9638643860816956,
0.6037469506263733,
-0.1688668429851532,
-0.537170946598053,
0.4435500204563141,
-0.0989815890789032,
-0.7264581322669983,
1.0244282484054565,
0.066482774913311,
-0.07133396714925766,
-0.377425879240036,
-0.4092761278152466,
-0.4556727409362793,
0.46541041135787964,
0.6039811968803406,
-0.9105800986289978,
-0.2501436173915863,
0.6687424778938293,
0.7058053612709045,
-0.12156058102846146,
-0.1627698838710785,
0.6272228360176086,
0.2610791027545929,
-0.7216775417327881,
-1.073822021484375,
-0.156796395778656,
0.2768058478832245,
0.2799864113330841,
-0.056108590215444565,
-0.5246399641036987,
0.8821424841880798,
0.06648927927017212,
-0.14921605587005615,
-0.2862077057361603,
0.18266768753528595,
0.13836528360843658,
0.31303003430366516,
0.3412773013114929,
0.4599032998085022,
0.5885640382766724,
0.009706071577966213,
1.1159067153930664,
-0.38586074113845825,
0.14132216572761536,
0.8440776467323303,
-0.4188135862350464,
0.23976829648017883,
0.6437215209007263,
0.07371200621128082,
0.5112506151199341,
0.3311551511287689,
0.39409539103507996,
1.0464149713516235,
0.44216540455818176,
-0.35773006081581116,
0.11142298579216003,
-0.000910597387701273,
-0.5172548294067383,
0.48938488960266113,
0.13576099276542664,
-1.0581285953521729,
-0.20014943182468414,
-0.0343942753970623,
0.12819460034370422,
0.651587724685669,
-0.0356869250535965,
0.7170458436012268,
0.10323742777109146,
-0.3433363735675812,
0.3310530483722687,
-0.0036674418952316046,
1.0084495544433594,
-0.5086008906364441,
0.4231733977794647,
-0.41924288868904114,
0.29479581117630005,
-0.13326086103916168,
-0.3868529796600342,
0.4796188771724701,
0.09745527058839798,
-0.4524511992931366,
-0.6526703238487244,
0.6305720210075378,
-0.44356071949005127,
-0.18201768398284912,
0.5571631193161011,
0.5589671730995178,
0.2598649263381958,
0.026724951341748238,
-0.5251414179801941,
0.16551081836223602,
0.0550273060798645,
-0.21430769562721252,
0.6880384087562561,
0.5050284266471863,
0.24692891538143158,
0.4089401960372925,
0.25825321674346924,
0.3708255887031555,
0.4034281075000763,
0.2812140882015228,
0.8548246622085571,
-0.4033624529838562,
-0.7568095922470093,
-1.0368648767471313,
0.38464125990867615,
-0.3219141960144043,
-0.10910183936357498,
0.9311906695365906,
0.5779098272323608,
0.9834444522857666,
-0.24737489223480225,
1.1172797679901123,
0.2896648943424225,
0.5602567195892334,
-0.65260910987854,
1.1506456136703491,
-0.24547693133354187,
0.5538040399551392,
-0.4836358428001404,
-0.9575744867324829,
-0.007445690222084522,
0.7576143741607666,
-0.7956414818763733,
-0.001995437080040574,
0.6233339905738831,
0.8738411664962769,
-0.08700239658355713,
0.10243694484233856,
0.59349125623703,
0.21230748295783997,
-0.02254522405564785,
0.04767313972115517,
0.9859512448310852,
-0.1537894904613495,
0.26891034841537476,
-0.6021296977996826,
-0.43341904878616333,
0.1254548728466034,
-0.852702260017395,
-1.130596399307251,
-0.5346266031265259,
-0.3135918974876404,
-0.35125941038131714,
0.35899320244789124,
0.36638644337654114,
0.6835642457008362,
-0.34499722719192505,
-0.1726488620042801,
-0.0834045484662056,
0.11489097028970718,
0.2737613916397095,
-0.26324158906936646,
0.10228481143712997,
-0.18842105567455292,
-0.9929920434951782,
-0.2098357081413269,
0.07390058040618896,
0.3947466015815735,
-0.608789324760437,
0.18897384405136108,
0.09035032987594604,
0.33854979276657104,
0.3696899116039276,
0.04463662579655647,
-0.4238682985305786,
-0.07950788736343384,
-0.022739209234714508,
-0.36520707607269287,
-0.23742510378360748,
1.0621782541275024,
-0.559602677822113,
0.41092801094055176,
0.31033647060394287,
0.30585721135139465,
0.2308189868927002,
0.052267152816057205,
0.8352773189544678,
-1.09568190574646,
0.7593683004379272,
0.48360174894332886,
0.1443338841199875,
0.30113279819488525,
-0.5094682574272156,
0.020133722573518753,
0.004760481882840395,
-0.4672619700431824,
-1.0110726356506348,
0.46911323070526123,
-0.4435100257396698,
-0.4689149260520935,
1.194042682647705,
-0.1992553025484085,
-0.16116896271705627,
-0.30176693201065063,
-0.02699589729309082,
0.05793408304452896,
-0.41043150424957275,
1.3803565502166748,
0.9054442644119263,
0.23292268812656403,
0.008130370639264584,
-0.41035690903663635,
1.0585495233535767,
0.3496840298175812,
-0.29657188057899475,
0.4121687710285187,
0.6699730753898621,
0.4084390103816986,
0.14403913915157318,
1.0263439416885376,
-0.5207417607307434,
-0.0626741498708725,
0.07715959846973419,
-0.059544637799263,
-0.02960810624063015,
-0.3338715732097626,
-0.4495064914226532,
0.08574598282575607,
0.04170963168144226,
-0.5485751628875732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00747v1 | A Comparative Study of Quality Evaluation Methods for Text Summarization | 2024-06-30T16:12:37 | 2024-06-30T16:12:37 | Huyen Nguyen, Haihua Chen, Lavanya Pobbathi, Junhua Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evaluating text summarization has been a challenging task in natural language
processing (NLP). Automatic metrics which heavily rely on reference summaries
are not suitable in many situations, while human evaluation is time-consuming
and labor-intensive. To bridge this gap, this paper proposes a novel method
based on large language models (LLMs) for evaluating text summarization. We
also conducts a comparative study on eight automatic metrics, human evaluation,
and our proposed LLM-based method. Seven different types of state-of-the-art
(SOTA) summarization models were evaluated. We perform extensive experiments
and analysis on datasets with patent documents. Our results show that LLMs
evaluation aligns closely with human evaluation, while widely-used automatic
metrics such as ROUGE-2, BERTScore, and SummaC do not and also lack
consistency. Based on the empirical comparison, we propose a LLM-powered
framework for automatically evaluating and improving text summarization, which
is beneficial and could attract wide attention among the community. | [
-0.010964683257043362,
-0.21705222129821777,
0.5631080269813538,
0.39851877093315125,
-0.46474704146385193,
0.3248465061187744,
-0.23864740133285522,
-0.4949210584163666,
0.23569998145103455,
0.4330771267414093,
-0.07271996140480042,
-0.5168320536613464,
-0.606207013130188,
0.5956000685691833,
-0.46080079674720764,
1.071671724319458,
-0.1245112195611,
0.21222715079784393,
-0.3867110311985016,
-0.10394257307052612,
-0.25611957907676697,
-0.46919435262680054,
-0.33533623814582825,
-0.5236256718635559,
0.19895491003990173,
0.11078433692455292,
0.5406063199043274,
0.4428722560405731,
1.0816452503204346,
0.3672400712966919,
-0.4227578938007355,
0.3695806860923767,
-0.44451799988746643,
-0.06612097471952438,
-0.16405174136161804,
-0.28657883405685425,
-0.8087463974952698,
0.041321128606796265,
0.684985339641571,
0.45157673954963684,
0.023518286645412445,
0.4327366054058075,
0.12948134541511536,
0.903283417224884,
-0.5645492672920227,
0.03678533434867859,
-0.2913861870765686,
0.0012215925380587578,
0.35525965690612793,
-0.3375304937362671,
-0.21316829323768616,
-0.7603467702865601,
0.16488836705684662,
-0.1761104017496109,
-0.05528221279382706,
0.07630486786365509,
0.8559814095497131,
0.3148322105407715,
-0.2421705722808838,
-0.41237977147102356,
-0.4263046383857727,
0.7746158242225647,
-1.2528917789459229,
0.13323839008808136,
0.02515062503516674,
0.33494341373443604,
0.08353925496339798,
-0.5511769652366638,
-0.4683818519115448,
-0.4449869394302368,
-0.10817942023277283,
0.339695006608963,
-0.17452333867549896,
-0.16584673523902893,
-0.17227759957313538,
0.6590875387191772,
-0.5158988833427429,
0.21542946994304657,
-0.24192877113819122,
-0.1272793561220169,
0.8513553738594055,
0.4087284505367279,
0.3422187864780426,
-0.43488287925720215,
-0.4170813262462616,
0.04855642467737198,
-0.5045705437660217,
-0.2720058262348175,
0.16416002810001373,
0.08298395574092865,
-0.10545994341373444,
0.7222421169281006,
-0.2574464678764343,
0.5548082590103149,
-0.23987723886966705,
-0.39831241965293884,
0.035763029009103775,
-0.7596327662467957,
-0.37472066283226013,
-0.19564366340637207,
1.0178581476211548,
1.064394474029541,
0.3545725345611572,
-0.49141085147857666,
-0.3642598092556,
-0.24439536035060883,
-0.0454532727599144,
-0.9898903965950012,
0.12905019521713257,
0.2808363735675812,
-0.7951139211654663,
-0.2282487452030182,
0.11796819418668747,
-0.45247724652290344,
-0.45703834295272827,
-0.42097315192222595,
0.47616854310035706,
-0.284903883934021,
0.049132391810417175,
0.20286273956298828,
-0.4025360643863678,
0.020983731374144554,
0.40310925245285034,
-0.8672481775283813,
0.37623894214630127,
0.8913460373878479,
1.179663896560669,
-0.5216308832168579,
-0.26654982566833496,
-0.2782827317714691,
-0.10568400472402573,
-0.4299430847167969,
1.1479438543319702,
-0.05866319313645363,
-0.28204968571662903,
-0.2759421765804291,
-0.37284567952156067,
0.18366305530071259,
-0.8442651629447937,
0.47209030389785767,
-0.5372632145881653,
0.20219208300113678,
-0.13227391242980957,
-0.7288014888763428,
-0.2453644722700119,
0.28776586055755615,
-0.44061198830604553,
0.8678745031356812,
-0.034937452524900436,
-0.8159039616584778,
0.4461132884025574,
-0.5225426554679871,
-0.4106878340244293,
-0.06941840052604675,
0.20786726474761963,
-0.486782968044281,
0.15906448662281036,
0.2586421072483063,
0.6652731895446777,
-0.5459510684013367,
0.30860599875450134,
-0.04154685512185097,
-0.45284977555274963,
0.31212884187698364,
-0.054272692650556564,
0.6065502762794495,
0.0691145658493042,
-0.02612149342894554,
0.47810283303260803,
-0.6698668003082275,
-0.035112082958221436,
-0.08940711617469788,
-0.4449242055416107,
-0.39619672298431396,
-0.14684903621673584,
-0.02200203388929367,
0.014123586006462574,
0.45743831992149353,
-0.29634037613868713,
0.005537031684070826,
-0.7993001937866211,
0.33407095074653625,
0.45207059383392334,
0.19879335165023804,
0.38091474771499634,
-0.5604279637336731,
0.4501064419746399,
-0.57827228307724,
-0.1180427223443985,
-0.5090738534927368,
-0.2451918125152588,
-0.5338472723960876,
-0.3813350796699524,
0.5561802983283997,
0.5878121852874756,
-0.347231924533844,
0.8733155131340027,
-0.5709603428840637,
-0.7005255222320557,
-0.31185251474380493,
0.1515267789363861,
0.480908066034317,
0.33481431007385254,
0.2435004860162735,
-0.3898848295211792,
-0.38134804368019104,
-0.7092041373252869,
-0.5472209453582764,
-0.1701490730047226,
-0.4274463355541229,
-0.058593250811100006,
0.5860681533813477,
0.05034578964114189,
1.0412064790725708,
-0.3903323709964752,
-0.45717132091522217,
-0.6838535666465759,
0.39007434248924255,
0.36552828550338745,
-0.02524016797542572,
0.4908856749534607,
-0.1980072557926178,
-0.49096712470054626,
-0.2179364264011383,
-0.85129314661026,
-0.3527538776397705,
-0.09338349848985672,
0.07778344303369522,
0.17810708284378052,
0.42337340116500854,
-0.20238058269023895,
0.1950938105583191,
0.3960517942905426,
-0.3725523352622986,
0.5797359347343445,
-0.48725149035453796,
0.5827608704566956,
-0.9341206550598145,
0.22005599737167358,
0.07088649272918701,
-0.4583388566970825,
-0.3039296865463257,
0.254164457321167,
0.2828347682952881,
0.03196719288825989,
-0.29927560687065125,
0.5839108228683472,
-0.47036314010620117,
-0.4035048186779022,
-0.4967629015445709,
0.44883993268013,
0.20525828003883362,
0.17013634741306305,
-0.11403657495975494,
0.8577843904495239,
-0.1612594723701477,
-0.6125963926315308,
0.4327952265739441,
0.1424160599708557,
-0.6421955227851868,
0.32509100437164307,
-0.8868775367736816,
-0.19049620628356934,
-0.05313989147543907,
0.4519535303115845,
-1.0043233633041382,
-0.008987942710518837,
-0.16902782022953033,
-0.4016202986240387,
0.13335494697093964,
0.3410826623439789,
-0.777298629283905,
-0.1366156041622162,
-0.8484915494918823,
0.03536882996559143,
0.44065746665000916,
-0.40277400612831116,
0.34672799706459045,
0.451638787984848,
-0.6043239831924438,
-0.3214579224586487,
-0.6430253982543945,
0.6116288900375366,
-0.23347683250904083,
-0.6105172634124756,
0.5200457572937012,
-0.06254979223012924,
-0.4654223918914795,
-0.15230274200439453,
-0.14529253542423248,
0.10165269672870636,
0.07317829877138138,
-0.15091530978679657,
0.31766846776008606,
-0.07357538491487503,
0.10541338473558426,
0.015751520171761513,
-0.3399242162704468,
-0.08449779450893402,
-0.04335695132613182,
0.25866785645484924,
-0.05185750871896744,
-0.08153035491704941,
-0.6791872382164001,
0.16429394483566284,
0.47624748945236206,
-0.3163636326789856,
0.34228697419166565,
0.13142932951450348,
-0.21327491104602814,
0.04221309721469879,
-0.6535934209823608,
-0.15787062048912048,
-0.3482218086719513,
0.4954811632633209,
0.15516822040081024,
-0.6853605508804321,
0.3271734118461609,
0.015076873824000359,
0.4592718183994293,
0.6313638091087341,
0.8392618298530579,
-0.19857457280158997,
0.6793119311332703,
0.7008670568466187,
-0.2837271988391876,
0.2815178334712982,
-0.15543757379055023,
0.2454870492219925,
-0.6317594647407532,
0.05651016905903816,
-0.7048588991165161,
-0.19821828603744507,
-0.04509344324469566,
-0.3585899770259857,
0.3843948245048523,
0.08991539478302002,
0.15190330147743225,
0.37728166580200195,
-0.4065383970737457,
0.691097617149353,
0.07414183765649796,
-0.27750417590141296,
0.9630895256996155,
-0.08644085377454758,
0.075069360435009,
-0.15835949778556824,
-0.5924169421195984,
-1.0415053367614746,
1.1674822568893433,
0.5543934106826782,
0.5986585021018982,
0.18419581651687622,
0.7031006813049316,
0.5378986597061157,
0.6613626480102539,
-0.9235287308692932,
0.5996497869491577,
-0.4063805341720581,
-0.16362065076828003,
-0.5682011842727661,
-0.5089292526245117,
-0.6389339566230774,
0.4325723350048065,
-0.35181593894958496,
-0.6271476745605469,
-0.249368816614151,
-0.0009061427554115653,
-0.6019141674041748,
0.12171495705842972,
-0.6930961608886719,
0.43226495385169983,
-0.2883199155330658,
-0.06353198736906052,
-0.31176549196243286,
-0.29507797956466675,
0.5570389628410339,
-0.10549095273017883,
0.3605068624019623,
-0.26183322072029114,
-0.26250019669532776,
1.022231936454773,
-0.6510981321334839,
0.5060451030731201,
0.23291614651679993,
-0.44040191173553467,
0.18241563439369202,
-0.135508731007576,
0.2744603753089905,
-0.04172796010971069,
-0.247144877910614,
0.19221685826778412,
-0.011880690231919289,
0.052135664969682693,
-0.7254301309585571,
0.5258141160011292,
-0.3627518117427826,
-0.2082194685935974,
-0.2623133659362793,
-0.36573493480682373,
-0.02277386374771595,
0.250318706035614,
0.28704696893692017,
0.37903541326522827,
-0.3147931396961212,
0.039301395416259766,
0.34308648109436035,
-0.3495204746723175,
0.7129295468330383,
0.6653899550437927,
-0.383965402841568,
-0.6411991715431213,
0.8926646709442139,
0.21910235285758972,
0.19228579103946686,
0.7133421897888184,
0.3541712760925293,
-0.4118594527244568,
-0.5616520047187805,
-0.48234617710113525,
0.35130012035369873,
-0.6271849274635315,
-0.3608863353729248,
-0.7475340366363525,
-0.0904291421175003,
-0.416922003030777,
-0.10145661234855652,
-0.25913500785827637,
-0.7191107869148254,
0.027645308524370193,
-0.04748588427901268,
0.11587867140769958,
0.6297435164451599,
0.255257785320282,
0.20145227015018463,
-0.9410048127174377,
0.6479085683822632,
0.3577728569507599,
0.45895901322364807,
0.22869983315467834,
-0.7492379546165466,
-0.3780233561992645,
-0.4233226478099823,
-0.2627996504306793,
-0.8942474722862244,
0.4558509886264801,
0.11792229861021042,
0.34150296449661255,
0.24012905359268188,
-0.013395425863564014,
0.3453480899333954,
-0.372912734746933,
0.8115794062614441,
0.35406166315078735,
-1.031086802482605,
0.25466272234916687,
-0.22487984597682953,
0.49723485112190247,
0.678860604763031,
-0.031617309898138046,
-0.45940324664115906,
-0.6065470576286316,
-0.30548468232154846,
-0.9743441343307495,
0.387444406747818,
0.25625503063201904,
-0.06560631096363068,
0.2754886746406555,
0.19851312041282654,
0.17029935121536255,
0.21502304077148438,
-0.5843772292137146,
-0.0532548762857914,
0.08103199303150177,
-0.26338493824005127,
-0.22004994750022888,
-0.480002760887146,
0.13660460710525513,
0.02838529273867607,
0.7232947945594788,
0.17268984019756317,
-0.10608876496553421,
0.22121642529964447,
-0.36591920256614685,
0.2161843478679657,
0.5130621790885925,
0.606471598148346,
0.9836145639419556,
-0.31400078535079956,
-0.0466306209564209,
0.471289724111557,
-0.3447287380695343,
0.19527606666088104,
-0.1405838131904602,
-0.2288258969783783,
0.3528895378112793,
0.6716133952140808,
0.2557285726070404,
0.3541625738143921,
-0.8633885979652405,
0.6853253841400146,
-0.20685844123363495,
-0.13843582570552826,
0.0009756119688972831,
-0.046885259449481964,
0.2022683322429657,
0.13166910409927368,
0.43523064255714417,
-0.2930254638195038,
0.5243054032325745,
-0.4364277124404907,
0.0069292145781219006,
0.2327832132577896,
-0.15256699919700623,
-0.0595538355410099,
0.38111549615859985,
0.48625990748405457,
-0.3516739308834076,
0.06608209758996964,
-0.1516263484954834,
-0.2709445357322693,
0.754269003868103,
0.2812831401824951,
1.0240695476531982,
-0.012075128965079784,
0.050768718123435974,
0.397270143032074,
0.5038546919822693,
-0.19392137229442596,
0.14269180595874786,
-0.0222815852612257,
-0.36350199580192566,
-0.8442237973213196,
-0.6962897777557373,
-0.6121333837509155,
-0.08039676398038864,
-0.22622457146644592,
0.2617819309234619,
-0.29399076104164124,
-0.33154866099357605,
0.0673493817448616,
0.11331823468208313,
-0.2045036107301712,
0.19228516519069672,
-0.3301180899143219,
1.029871940612793,
-0.7171489596366882,
0.19280801713466644,
0.49534857273101807,
-0.2728707194328308,
-0.3145885169506073,
0.0887252688407898,
-0.1671932190656662,
-0.2645513713359833,
0.4733402729034424,
0.13071465492248535,
-0.4470975399017334,
-0.23693251609802246,
-0.15421345829963684,
-0.6080062389373779,
1.076227068901062,
0.1756928712129593,
-0.6195423007011414,
0.061470020562410355,
-0.24546033143997192,
0.7765752673149109,
-0.15044888854026794,
0.5893645882606506,
0.7453311681747437,
0.42440322041511536,
-0.226715087890625,
-1.042659044265747,
-0.10672793537378311,
-0.2522050738334656,
0.01958303712308407,
0.06417366862297058,
-0.7597994804382324,
0.26413875818252563,
-0.3915534019470215,
-0.38281533122062683,
0.22161570191383362,
0.7374703884124756,
0.256084144115448,
0.45399054884910583,
0.24095438420772552,
0.21279776096343994,
0.5750351548194885,
0.12962442636489868,
1.00497305393219,
-0.2596437633037567,
0.42227545380592346,
1.3060249090194702,
-0.21763134002685547,
0.8741974234580994,
0.21346086263656616,
-0.4955233633518219,
0.12887100875377655,
0.3359324038028717,
-0.13489079475402832,
0.2335396111011505,
0.4104553163051605,
0.14849813282489777,
0.00945492833852768,
0.03180732950568199,
-0.25050753355026245,
0.3210100829601288,
-0.029199127107858658,
-0.41230830550193787,
-0.45604178309440613,
-0.4143463671207428,
0.0693463683128357,
0.41931697726249695,
-0.25102871656417847,
1.183964729309082,
0.23134368658065796,
-0.6707617044448853,
0.4876752197742462,
0.6134145855903625,
0.8886489868164062,
-0.38263630867004395,
0.19070076942443848,
-0.3197019398212433,
-0.11552856117486954,
-0.4392314851284027,
-0.46773234009742737,
0.43799805641174316,
0.5938101410865784,
-0.22691558301448822,
-0.11055729538202286,
0.5075031518936157,
-0.04171930253505707,
-0.5191315412521362,
0.1987980753183365,
0.3145037293434143,
0.33758801221847534,
0.012727738358080387,
-0.3013163208961487,
-0.2470674365758896,
-0.19265106320381165,
-0.21084076166152954,
0.1815294623374939,
0.17650030553340912,
-0.045058924704790115,
0.672697901725769,
0.4909086525440216,
0.2580016553401947,
-0.32932034134864807,
0.3832762837409973,
0.5390534400939941,
-0.7108072638511658,
-0.7794634699821472,
-1.1510469913482666,
0.48790478706359863,
-0.27793219685554504,
-0.2616444230079651,
0.7474543452262878,
0.7947947382926941,
0.16081753373146057,
0.05028358846902847,
0.8843106627464294,
0.4401746988296509,
0.8050352931022644,
-0.7251114845275879,
0.9378113746643066,
-0.3527992367744446,
0.5258445739746094,
-0.5601189136505127,
-1.2064908742904663,
-0.5248839855194092,
0.4982296824455261,
-0.3117717504501343,
-0.03867679461836815,
0.6868107318878174,
0.49916332960128784,
0.16323471069335938,
-0.11492402851581573,
0.2103043496608734,
0.18404845893383026,
0.22192899882793427,
0.17806057631969452,
0.7630937099456787,
-0.37116703391075134,
0.4084130525588989,
0.2358570098876953,
-0.5932179689407349,
-0.4686116576194763,
-1.1717642545700073,
-0.9471472501754761,
-0.3441491723060608,
-0.294345885515213,
0.08588076382875443,
0.06786386668682098,
0.8782995343208313,
0.38151881098747253,
-0.7008559703826904,
-0.4052945375442505,
0.3290781080722809,
0.2866312265396118,
-0.17665524780750275,
-0.17613071203231812,
0.46341878175735474,
-0.36211341619491577,
-0.7252175807952881,
0.3327914774417877,
0.8428191542625427,
0.06824696063995361,
-0.48654672503471375,
-0.009767616167664528,
0.2482461780309677,
0.24522614479064941,
0.7335375547409058,
-0.1461573988199234,
-0.5939803719520569,
0.19651173055171967,
-0.18296536803245544,
-0.31633612513542175,
-0.044397156685590744,
0.790341854095459,
-0.5364292860031128,
0.29052644968032837,
0.9072991013526917,
0.5236024856567383,
0.16039355099201202,
0.3091803193092346,
0.6912822127342224,
-0.3392280340194702,
-0.2099684625864029,
0.16216127574443817,
0.2939516305923462,
0.3865731358528137,
-0.1602724939584732,
0.5032371878623962,
-0.31622740626335144,
-0.5219725966453552,
-0.66960209608078,
-0.14721965789794922,
-0.6327772736549377,
-0.30419474840164185,
1.0418611764907837,
-0.18239006400108337,
0.009489806368947029,
0.02045857161283493,
-0.281529039144516,
0.14491695165634155,
-0.3354361355304718,
1.1867331266403198,
0.6257826685905457,
-0.08940611034631729,
0.1641136258840561,
-0.26857098937034607,
0.3398335576057434,
0.27196741104125977,
-1.1639107465744019,
0.08444402366876602,
0.40280699729919434,
0.09751338511705399,
0.12696459889411926,
0.7423957586288452,
-0.29931336641311646,
0.1762610524892807,
-0.5062519311904907,
0.20382188260555267,
-0.08381776511669159,
-0.2197374701499939,
-0.6132017374038696,
0.1520339995622635,
-0.007537259254604578,
0.19226250052452087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00740v1 | Locate&Edit: Energy-based Text Editing for Efficient, Flexible, and Faithful Controlled Text Generation | 2024-06-30T16:04:29 | 2024-06-30T16:04:29 | Hye Ryung Son, Jay-Yoon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent approaches to controlled text generation (CTG) often involve
manipulating the weights or logits of base language models (LMs) at decoding
time. However, these methods are inapplicable to latest black-box LMs and
ineffective at preserving the core semantics of the base LM's original
generations. In this work, we propose Locate&Edit(L&E), an efficient and
flexible energy-based approach to CTG, which edits text outputs from a base LM
using off-the-shelf energy models. Given text outputs from the base LM, L&E
first locates spans that are most relevant to constraints (e.g., toxicity)
utilizing energy models, and then edits these spans by replacing them with more
suitable alternatives. Importantly, our method is compatible with black-box
LMs, as it requires only the text outputs. Also, since L&E doesn't mandate
specific architecture for its component models, it can work with a diverse
combination of available off-the-shelf models. Moreover, L&E preserves the base
LM's original generations, by selectively modifying constraint-related aspects
of the texts and leaving others unchanged. These targeted edits also ensure
that L&E operates efficiently. Our experiments confirm that L&E achieves
superior semantic preservation of the base LM generations and speed, while
simultaneously obtaining competitive or improved constraint satisfaction.
Furthermore, we analyze how the granularity of energy distribution impacts CTG
performance and find that fine-grained, regression-based energy models improve
constraint satisfaction, compared to conventional binary classifier energy
models. | [
0.16927343606948853,
-0.8778722882270813,
0.7444149255752563,
-0.040642332285642624,
0.07875543087720871,
0.1561492681503296,
-0.5962525010108948,
-0.6564338207244873,
0.14730414748191833,
0.6871590614318848,
-0.4067448675632477,
-0.6425082683563232,
-0.2809191942214966,
0.108954057097435,
-0.05388767272233963,
0.6581878066062927,
-0.29608941078186035,
-0.4736916124820709,
-0.03757837042212486,
0.02098490297794342,
-0.4712463319301605,
-0.2668688893318176,
-0.4561038613319397,
-0.3187684714794159,
0.39811134338378906,
0.20814359188079834,
1.1228158473968506,
1.1992030143737793,
0.4696352779865265,
0.3067511320114136,
-0.45204105973243713,
0.4328596293926239,
-0.5188878774642944,
0.35179832577705383,
-0.6425586938858032,
-0.2821711599826813,
-0.36384159326553345,
-0.12436900287866592,
0.4632505476474762,
0.5663526058197021,
-0.17575302720069885,
-0.2766853868961334,
-0.10186547785997391,
0.6960557103157043,
-1.089800477027893,
-0.28336793184280396,
-1.214332103729248,
0.026021407917141914,
-0.12094301730394363,
-0.21992196142673492,
-0.7617396712303162,
-0.4325578510761261,
-0.08476085960865021,
-0.8025768399238586,
0.34538111090660095,
-0.0761827826499939,
0.8580542206764221,
0.5546432137489319,
-0.5149582624435425,
-0.4090929329395294,
-0.8712390065193176,
0.7826715707778931,
-0.5014177560806274,
0.4092653691768646,
0.1887611448764801,
-0.17762982845306396,
-0.15920446813106537,
-0.811370313167572,
-0.3488723933696747,
-0.12137194722890854,
-0.25545063614845276,
0.2877817451953888,
-0.23355019092559814,
0.39174482226371765,
0.3316449522972107,
0.18278050422668457,
-0.3296509385108948,
0.07340513169765472,
0.11390858143568039,
-0.26194265484809875,
0.575232207775116,
0.192989781498909,
0.3037727475166321,
-0.559057354927063,
-0.2504841089248657,
0.06122928485274315,
-0.6258381009101868,
-0.2513315677642822,
0.41294971108436584,
0.44990503787994385,
0.25789761543273926,
0.7283797264099121,
-0.01393524557352066,
0.6248230934143066,
0.3608863949775696,
0.039811648428440094,
0.024969859048724174,
-0.5473261475563049,
-0.3448655903339386,
0.2997666597366333,
0.6526700854301453,
0.2944277822971344,
-0.22747386991977692,
-0.01255984976887703,
-0.24288290739059448,
-0.1599700003862381,
0.4007546901702881,
-0.6678327918052673,
-0.42548078298568726,
0.08333811908960342,
-0.6359021067619324,
-0.3624730110168457,
-0.2634807229042053,
-0.411371111869812,
-0.40544894337654114,
-0.09085966646671295,
0.3698916733264923,
-0.5600343346595764,
-0.20689471065998077,
0.3313010632991791,
-0.33267515897750854,
-0.38691478967666626,
0.3086986839771271,
-1.0618349313735962,
-0.052041053771972656,
0.36925169825553894,
0.7763213515281677,
0.018441837280988693,
0.2605744004249573,
-0.287364661693573,
0.606024444103241,
-0.025689909234642982,
0.5353360176086426,
-0.8306930065155029,
-0.627304196357727,
0.13020014762878418,
-0.08491498231887817,
-0.29305756092071533,
-0.4226628243923187,
0.5802717208862305,
-0.7009937167167664,
0.3564234673976898,
-0.10494716465473175,
-0.6601259112358093,
0.2659333050251007,
0.022695718333125114,
-0.8302992582321167,
1.2781740427017212,
0.1946822702884674,
-0.9521343111991882,
0.19397509098052979,
-0.8429222106933594,
-0.4167816638946533,
-0.007184064015746117,
0.20699134469032288,
-0.5263174176216125,
0.13823442161083221,
0.00515555776655674,
-0.07321742177009583,
0.3380511701107025,
0.12785230576992035,
0.09427059441804886,
0.03111419454216957,
-0.1716303527355194,
-0.3117806017398834,
0.5132135152816772,
0.29718732833862305,
-0.4350200593471527,
0.2153201699256897,
-0.9308486580848694,
0.17872244119644165,
-0.08508997410535812,
-0.8076298236846924,
-0.7263123989105225,
0.6019369959831238,
0.2384905070066452,
0.0011414731852710247,
0.6313384771347046,
-0.615310549736023,
0.556308925151825,
-0.18991808593273163,
0.26487866044044495,
0.6007176637649536,
0.16587600111961365,
0.6721328496932983,
-0.15625564754009247,
0.5232099294662476,
-0.5890123248100281,
0.11195962131023407,
-0.0028213772457093,
-0.008589707314968109,
-0.5272026658058167,
-0.1508713960647583,
0.142927348613739,
0.7174456119537354,
-0.9794243574142456,
0.48278185725212097,
-0.17232316732406616,
-0.6449152231216431,
-0.27513739466667175,
0.14193519949913025,
0.20626966655254364,
0.5533409118652344,
0.49950340390205383,
0.3418978154659271,
-0.53841233253479,
-0.7175023555755615,
-0.5535984039306641,
0.0779484212398529,
-0.05057158321142197,
0.4431301951408386,
0.19418856501579285,
-0.2658000588417053,
0.9395652413368225,
-0.771848738193512,
-0.06718967109918594,
-0.22056405246257782,
-0.13556519150733948,
-0.12164511531591415,
0.6876946091651917,
0.5510200262069702,
-0.7757038474082947,
-0.6310988068580627,
0.36910951137542725,
-0.5935542583465576,
-0.5884621143341064,
-0.5517613291740417,
-0.477737158536911,
0.018023377284407616,
0.5239679217338562,
-0.7030576467514038,
0.4199501574039459,
0.5945358872413635,
-0.4848892092704773,
0.6884734034538269,
-0.34108829498291016,
0.1568482220172882,
-1.1441688537597656,
0.20666952431201935,
-0.22012677788734436,
-0.3814161419868469,
-0.5028488636016846,
0.04379270598292351,
0.2536746859550476,
-0.026447707787156105,
-0.4809821844100952,
0.30290883779525757,
-0.5912728309631348,
0.578846275806427,
-0.23192280530929565,
0.27802661061286926,
0.28961068391799927,
0.0940338671207428,
0.1967872828245163,
0.5887775421142578,
0.1883421540260315,
-0.47834014892578125,
-0.045497436076402664,
0.3372195065021515,
-0.15107005834579468,
0.49262019991874695,
-0.492603063583374,
0.4693049490451813,
-0.013821577653288841,
0.2548440992832184,
-0.37210169434547424,
-0.2885940670967102,
-0.06278552114963531,
0.011602314189076424,
0.5384626984596252,
0.07340451329946518,
-0.46916624903678894,
0.11195418983697891,
-0.2956477999687195,
0.2269042730331421,
0.21913626790046692,
-0.4636114537715912,
0.7470151782035828,
0.20294006168842316,
-0.020548667758703232,
-0.465865820646286,
-0.4701683223247528,
0.11832741647958755,
-0.10702217370271683,
-0.6445416212081909,
0.8749852776527405,
-0.09281226992607117,
-0.3941071033477783,
0.2861096262931824,
-0.11182623356580734,
0.13333842158317566,
0.06082041189074516,
0.07913852483034134,
0.03220289945602417,
-0.05134081840515137,
0.46260419487953186,
0.3897985816001892,
-0.04939146339893341,
-0.2423226684331894,
-0.4415139853954315,
0.21936418116092682,
0.5152871012687683,
-0.006143682170659304,
-0.27768033742904663,
0.584245502948761,
0.48949387669563293,
-0.16002003848552704,
0.7266352772712708,
0.26519879698753357,
-0.6219441294670105,
-0.3182821571826935,
-0.32066741585731506,
0.2697799503803253,
-0.6110609769821167,
0.5170860886573792,
-0.23332837224006653,
-0.9042676687240601,
0.2164684236049652,
-0.258025199174881,
0.49681857228279114,
0.542589545249939,
0.42145442962646484,
-0.04261109605431557,
1.0399541854858398,
1.041271448135376,
0.36148011684417725,
0.9468897581100464,
0.07356267422437668,
0.08921400457620621,
-0.7632180452346802,
-0.25014030933380127,
-0.7932279706001282,
-0.47246450185775757,
-0.6844226121902466,
-0.2827153205871582,
0.5054872035980225,
0.21311818063259125,
-0.047097425907850266,
0.5403299331665039,
-0.9428001046180725,
0.6569083333015442,
0.21370400488376617,
0.4078620672225952,
0.10804624110460281,
-0.2987233102321625,
-0.08098823577165604,
-0.2140432745218277,
-0.8420553803443909,
-0.6311585903167725,
0.6829740405082703,
0.10228206217288971,
0.8460807800292969,
0.09875483810901642,
0.7168888449668884,
0.41733628511428833,
0.3934313952922821,
-0.7037903666496277,
0.3693229556083679,
-0.31224194169044495,
-0.6433621644973755,
-0.15565720200538635,
-0.5872190594673157,
-0.944019079208374,
0.09084200859069824,
-0.2889406681060791,
-0.8435244560241699,
0.08815666288137436,
0.460660845041275,
-0.19292044639587402,
0.8423681855201721,
-0.8150591254234314,
0.8277955651283264,
-0.18780846893787384,
-0.7593834400177002,
-0.42790862917900085,
-0.3501443564891815,
0.0024262440856546164,
-0.051978182047605515,
0.27396106719970703,
0.16881881654262543,
-0.09738030284643173,
0.5464087128639221,
-0.7794268131256104,
0.3496288061141968,
-0.31944578886032104,
-0.2837674915790558,
0.45870068669319153,
0.3528152406215668,
0.9204792976379395,
-0.25185254216194153,
-0.5676823854446411,
-0.33798134326934814,
-0.24387241899967194,
-0.34492579102516174,
-0.49086302518844604,
0.9922023415565491,
-0.2952401340007782,
-0.5461236238479614,
-0.04830013960599899,
-0.7183018922805786,
-0.047941818833351135,
0.451801598072052,
0.6027922630310059,
0.21100686490535736,
-0.21049146354198456,
0.395324170589447,
0.7794758081436157,
-0.5207567811012268,
0.6793872714042664,
0.15155164897441864,
0.04445836693048477,
-0.429004967212677,
0.5182466506958008,
0.08253007382154465,
0.6263177394866943,
0.8144048452377319,
0.28802886605262756,
-0.3315051198005676,
-0.41445982456207275,
-0.30296823382377625,
-0.2172383815050125,
-0.686885416507721,
-0.2601456344127655,
-0.8457884788513184,
-0.010564454831182957,
-0.042907439172267914,
-0.9264228940010071,
-0.47275325655937195,
-0.5106883645057678,
-0.4585634469985962,
-0.40588831901550293,
0.42959773540496826,
0.6610250473022461,
-0.4106377363204956,
0.5477809309959412,
-0.7215017080307007,
0.1746295690536499,
0.20237015187740326,
0.4472791254520416,
-0.20790345966815948,
0.015780897811055183,
-0.5680258870124817,
0.012936821207404137,
-0.5088272094726562,
-1.1726062297821045,
0.2122059017419815,
0.1600186973810196,
0.07987384498119354,
0.06653732061386108,
0.06948782503604889,
0.37418752908706665,
-0.47054386138916016,
1.0112167596817017,
0.3474082052707672,
-1.2908776998519897,
0.8016844987869263,
-0.6544857621192932,
0.4883626103401184,
0.6173567175865173,
-0.1489308476448059,
-0.4114879369735718,
-0.31967076659202576,
-0.49208948016166687,
-0.9070735573768616,
0.5658299326896667,
0.3348272144794464,
0.06716511398553848,
-0.13874509930610657,
0.5006024241447449,
0.03365612402558327,
0.20206068456172943,
-0.8055960536003113,
-0.07743513584136963,
-0.32808759808540344,
-0.3617761731147766,
0.5491946339607239,
-0.22836534678936005,
0.28825026750564575,
-0.0023335102014243603,
0.945158839225769,
0.04641605541110039,
-0.2508007287979126,
0.2809300124645233,
-0.08409406989812851,
-0.5481987595558167,
0.4498418867588043,
0.3601861298084259,
0.3695090115070343,
-0.4807540476322174,
0.25090256333351135,
0.23553065955638885,
-0.6075520515441895,
0.09421122074127197,
-0.21402035653591156,
-0.6597186326980591,
0.451943963766098,
0.2588141858577728,
0.6392969489097595,
0.3380952477455139,
-0.4899454116821289,
-0.11205852776765823,
0.050603464245796204,
-0.16734202206134796,
0.13146190345287323,
0.37065690755844116,
-0.026501018553972244,
0.0018764196429401636,
0.003679685527458787,
0.4477118253707886,
-0.12227917462587357,
-0.34022200107574463,
0.08288746327161789,
0.3861031234264374,
-0.30716806650161743,
-0.2742566466331482,
1.3088682889938354,
0.4034869968891144,
-0.5234106183052063,
0.3915775716304779,
-0.07561556249856949,
-0.5459438562393188,
0.49149367213249207,
0.4561571478843689,
1.1050426959991455,
-0.25207939743995667,
0.0838008001446724,
0.47081321477890015,
0.5988494157791138,
0.2806360721588135,
0.4197293519973755,
-0.01769518107175827,
-0.6636398434638977,
-0.3536475598812103,
-0.4563770890235901,
-0.41409575939178467,
0.005624169018119574,
-0.5411167740821838,
0.27040499448776245,
-0.5168532729148865,
-0.45198747515678406,
0.012398084625601768,
-0.011086632497608662,
-0.6838037371635437,
0.24223892390727997,
0.0924592837691307,
1.159376859664917,
-0.5542137622833252,
0.6966895461082458,
0.7225480675697327,
0.16600452363491058,
-0.8064149618148804,
-0.1728435605764389,
-0.09059236943721771,
-0.20951668918132782,
0.13460908830165863,
-0.033952049911022186,
-0.24711906909942627,
0.09023549407720566,
-0.8934068083763123,
-0.8698766231536865,
1.22832190990448,
0.35430091619491577,
-0.7316570281982422,
-0.03793823719024658,
-0.13921605050563812,
0.5517176985740662,
0.06667548418045044,
0.13381464779376984,
0.35142603516578674,
0.7145769596099854,
-0.20795921981334686,
-0.9713155627250671,
0.06433400511741638,
-0.22666656970977783,
-0.010115640237927437,
0.5752399563789368,
-0.8108870983123779,
0.40297773480415344,
-0.17043836414813995,
-0.3569033145904541,
0.039567094296216965,
0.4459920823574066,
0.06058131530880928,
0.37244150042533875,
0.5057260394096375,
0.5259963274002075,
0.9117710590362549,
-0.15941186249256134,
0.8367518186569214,
-0.45006731152534485,
0.6247264742851257,
0.930927574634552,
-0.48010411858558655,
0.7403927445411682,
0.3885701298713684,
0.11981676518917084,
0.6441330313682556,
0.35673069953918457,
0.24109701812267303,
0.7489676475524902,
0.13593964278697968,
-0.5319249033927917,
-0.35434141755104065,
-0.3917940855026245,
-0.3100396692752838,
0.18025927245616913,
0.4102378487586975,
-0.49453625082969666,
-0.25720569491386414,
-0.21707552671432495,
0.3892013132572174,
0.5082566738128662,
-0.3034270703792572,
0.5236717462539673,
-0.141739159822464,
-0.4665853977203369,
0.37799420952796936,
0.3035772144794464,
0.5728633999824524,
-0.9148120284080505,
0.11175967752933502,
0.12522543966770172,
0.1680959016084671,
-0.5278231501579285,
-0.5782373547554016,
0.5833315849304199,
0.3127696216106415,
-0.5828642249107361,
-0.8018258810043335,
0.9846068620681763,
-0.4615263044834137,
-0.3218517303466797,
0.18865709006786346,
0.16302132606506348,
-0.3811013698577881,
0.15208660066127777,
-0.46539464592933655,
0.18948590755462646,
0.39678871631622314,
-0.5042825937271118,
0.021052265539765358,
0.5663946866989136,
0.14344331622123718,
0.23216600716114044,
0.6755891442298889,
0.14119164645671844,
-0.01708524487912655,
-0.2089136242866516,
0.7956207990646362,
-0.738128125667572,
-0.5443617701530457,
-0.705909013748169,
0.6909252405166626,
-0.024036554619669914,
-0.2517196536064148,
0.4299848675727844,
0.6815415024757385,
0.608101487159729,
-0.01969880983233452,
1.156742811203003,
-0.33694836497306824,
0.1727471649646759,
-0.9038741588592529,
0.8123388886451721,
-0.41700658202171326,
0.15141335129737854,
-0.41803988814353943,
-0.9481071829795837,
-0.2856963276863098,
0.3932662010192871,
-0.24427884817123413,
-0.23896710574626923,
0.8067502379417419,
0.6303004026412964,
-0.017751401290297508,
-0.1828782707452774,
0.1321200579404831,
0.24734826385974884,
0.6312300562858582,
0.7089677453041077,
0.6018174290657043,
-0.1594586819410324,
0.44388577342033386,
-0.3449532389640808,
-0.16205838322639465,
0.02689879760146141,
-1.155258059501648,
-0.4669957756996155,
-0.11424179375171661,
-0.6351535320281982,
-0.3478264808654785,
-0.1589192897081375,
1.076438069343567,
0.6615117788314819,
-0.6158655285835266,
0.17713642120361328,
-0.20988962054252625,
0.3482550382614136,
-0.27324891090393066,
-0.32115688920021057,
0.7011597752571106,
0.15041543543338776,
-0.8220227956771851,
0.6527997851371765,
0.5194737911224365,
-0.10578466951847076,
0.19578991830348969,
0.060139089822769165,
-0.24807465076446533,
0.40651607513427734,
0.6469890475273132,
0.2001374214887619,
-0.2906494736671448,
-0.7919511795043945,
0.23722633719444275,
-0.2533552646636963,
-0.06825286895036697,
0.7782106995582581,
-0.8075945377349854,
0.8200787305831909,
0.6447897553443909,
0.5437150597572327,
0.11877073347568512,
0.18405047059059143,
0.34648871421813965,
-1.048727035522461,
0.06126809120178223,
0.23467552661895752,
0.44904497265815735,
0.3948056399822235,
-0.7584826946258545,
0.3112129867076874,
0.30849313735961914,
-0.7027666568756104,
-0.5127252340316772,
0.32431474328041077,
-1.0506576299667358,
-0.23513191938400269,
1.2245397567749023,
0.028314931318163872,
-0.06845568865537643,
0.1255417913198471,
-0.6142762899398804,
0.3903903067111969,
-0.14193448424339294,
0.9239141941070557,
0.49230748414993286,
-0.2694285213947296,
0.09646215289831161,
-0.27647218108177185,
0.5082257390022278,
0.4674319922924042,
-0.9554767608642578,
0.23188969492912292,
0.9484596252441406,
0.14003828167915344,
0.21858200430870056,
0.4156610071659088,
0.19981083273887634,
0.059408143162727356,
-0.0006862409063614905,
0.24280408024787903,
-0.14157706499099731,
-0.09791357815265656,
0.10056843608617783,
0.3232291638851166,
-0.4822085499763489,
-0.2020801454782486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00731v1 | Large Language Models Struggle in Token-Level Clinical Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-30T15:38:48 | 2024-06-30T15:38:48 | Qiuhao Lu, Rui Li, Andrew Wen, Jinlian Wang, Liwei Wang, Hongfang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized various sectors, including
healthcare where they are employed in diverse applications. Their utility is
particularly significant in the context of rare diseases, where data scarcity,
complexity, and specificity pose considerable challenges. In the clinical
domain, Named Entity Recognition (NER) stands out as an essential task and it
plays a crucial role in extracting relevant information from clinical texts.
Despite the promise of LLMs, current research mostly concentrates on
document-level NER, identifying entities in a more general context across
entire documents, without extracting their precise location. Additionally,
efforts have been directed towards adapting ChatGPT for token-level NER.
However, there is a significant research gap when it comes to employing
token-level NER for clinical texts, especially with the use of local
open-source LLMs. This study aims to bridge this gap by investigating the
effectiveness of both proprietary and local LLMs in token-level clinical NER.
Essentially, we delve into the capabilities of these models through a series of
experiments involving zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting,
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), and instruction-fine-tuning. Our
exploration reveals the inherent challenges LLMs face in token-level NER,
particularly in the context of rare diseases, and suggests possible
improvements for their application in healthcare. This research contributes to
narrowing a significant gap in healthcare informatics and offers insights that
could lead to a more refined application of LLMs in the healthcare sector. | [
0.03490593656897545,
-0.6158960461616516,
0.8533220887184143,
-0.07029373943805695,
-0.2707552909851074,
0.022269204258918762,
-0.3196214735507965,
-0.745964765548706,
0.338102787733078,
0.5925696492195129,
-0.056415390223264694,
-0.7147942185401917,
-0.8234727382659912,
0.37686827778816223,
-0.28009748458862305,
0.9498403668403625,
-0.23490391671657562,
0.4846474528312683,
-0.07665850967168808,
-0.29202041029930115,
-0.48010876774787903,
-0.6856186389923096,
-1.0822798013687134,
-0.21114136278629303,
0.7444775104522705,
0.37428969144821167,
0.30676785111427307,
0.4845777750015259,
0.9120376110076904,
0.17639219760894775,
-0.32313260436058044,
-0.020636161789298058,
-0.3858049511909485,
0.27249273657798767,
0.10095734149217606,
-0.5178831815719604,
-0.6142739057540894,
-0.38136911392211914,
0.797409176826477,
0.8604904413223267,
-0.0648999959230423,
-0.1356194168329239,
-0.1629309356212616,
0.40374264121055603,
-0.4751847982406616,
0.14200547337532043,
-0.8096596598625183,
0.23550079762935638,
-0.47706738114356995,
-0.10553782433271408,
-0.33409926295280457,
-0.1375991404056549,
0.32592225074768066,
-0.4970927834510803,
0.3723984360694885,
-0.0883384421467781,
0.9104723334312439,
0.008362868800759315,
-0.5799113512039185,
-0.5618268251419067,
-0.6681161522865295,
0.5383335947990417,
-1.0193827152252197,
0.4869808554649353,
0.2833235561847687,
0.1531330943107605,
-0.43119898438453674,
-0.9262720942497253,
-0.4662633538246155,
-0.3456542491912842,
0.01801445335149765,
-0.15815362334251404,
-0.45419374108314514,
0.1832049936056137,
0.42492273449897766,
0.42230919003486633,
-0.508423924446106,
0.7261964082717896,
-0.38984474539756775,
-0.2911255359649658,
0.22771549224853516,
0.46308988332748413,
0.33118918538093567,
-0.333737850189209,
-0.3645128309726715,
0.5025169253349304,
-1.0691883563995361,
-0.04559348151087761,
-0.26522526144981384,
0.46176549792289734,
-0.0606304332613945,
0.6103379130363464,
-0.06170522794127464,
0.5431677103042603,
-0.023888537660241127,
-0.3087153434753418,
0.5302860736846924,
-0.027360109612345695,
-0.27541014552116394,
0.22339953482151031,
0.8267742991447449,
0.08599903434515,
-0.06619080156087875,
-0.27559366822242737,
-0.29075756669044495,
-0.2720179259777069,
0.019273927435278893,
-0.846980631351471,
0.01071430929005146,
0.4185381233692169,
-0.5251795649528503,
-0.17325079441070557,
-0.31303051114082336,
-0.6256598830223083,
-0.796660304069519,
-0.22750301659107208,
0.3657132685184479,
-0.37317630648612976,
-0.15337307751178741,
0.10845395922660828,
0.07566440850496292,
0.2197267711162567,
0.46700340509414673,
-0.7683596611022949,
0.30339905619621277,
0.7702735662460327,
0.9558015465736389,
-0.49039044976234436,
0.041010018438100815,
-0.8288607597351074,
0.11099173873662949,
-0.2781313359737396,
0.6798899173736572,
-0.5408364534378052,
-0.4711145758628845,
0.08135557919740677,
0.20862863957881927,
-0.2676910161972046,
-0.7984637022018433,
0.3942774832248688,
-0.35115259885787964,
0.011365472339093685,
-0.3183213472366333,
-0.7571289539337158,
0.42065516114234924,
0.256713330745697,
-0.6459057927131653,
0.6479141116142273,
-0.006553385406732559,
-0.9005990028381348,
0.5644136071205139,
-0.5775457620620728,
-0.33438044786453247,
0.41458752751350403,
-0.5273504853248596,
-0.4537639617919922,
0.4599829912185669,
0.25629326701164246,
0.5976721048355103,
-0.3801579773426056,
0.19325949251651764,
-0.20027117431163788,
-0.42322838306427,
0.2980404794216156,
-0.4011121988296509,
0.41792598366737366,
0.06863410770893097,
-0.2630929946899414,
0.16853725910186768,
-0.8012857437133789,
-0.2725568115711212,
0.3019765019416809,
-0.22422964870929718,
-0.5177865624427795,
-0.14057523012161255,
-0.04032813385128975,
0.04615147411823273,
0.13966727256774902,
-0.6680956482887268,
0.33301830291748047,
-0.6098181009292603,
0.5963894724845886,
0.4794926643371582,
0.1023595929145813,
0.4110710620880127,
-0.197998046875,
0.5705699920654297,
0.24772359430789948,
0.007087277248501778,
-0.19474579393863678,
-0.44301387667655945,
-0.6453602313995361,
-0.6186507940292358,
0.4849590063095093,
0.33475449681282043,
-0.5741216540336609,
-0.11951237171888351,
-0.3696169853210449,
-0.3542911410331726,
-0.5987080931663513,
-0.30911773443222046,
0.1271081119775772,
0.7562938928604126,
0.24374808371067047,
-0.23155421018600464,
-0.2280094027519226,
-0.8517598509788513,
-0.08922809362411499,
0.013041599653661251,
-0.10818641632795334,
0.6931760907173157,
0.46214351058006287,
-0.4920344352722168,
0.7467169761657715,
-0.3644653260707855,
-0.5996688008308411,
-0.32587525248527527,
-0.032541099935770035,
0.3028092384338379,
0.3304581940174103,
0.26987454295158386,
-0.542060375213623,
-0.3934420049190521,
0.18775828182697296,
-0.6921975612640381,
-0.1269187331199646,
-0.1143069937825203,
0.3726416230201721,
0.17987632751464844,
0.58411705493927,
-0.6717304587364197,
0.643247663974762,
0.4378800690174103,
-0.04351605847477913,
0.5048215389251709,
-0.3968566656112671,
-0.01255143340677023,
-0.9988746643066406,
0.20819197595119476,
-0.30393946170806885,
-0.24554850161075592,
-0.7462803721427917,
0.0654492899775505,
0.12205609679222107,
-0.1528557986021042,
-0.46881023049354553,
0.9281507134437561,
-0.6520229578018188,
0.0030073027592152357,
-0.20940154790878296,
0.10168785601854324,
-0.21488192677497864,
0.10278987884521484,
0.18714015185832977,
0.6542642712593079,
0.7236035466194153,
-0.46384355425834656,
-0.02012721262872219,
0.10573698580265045,
-0.19299840927124023,
0.5351917147636414,
-0.8721251487731934,
0.17778243124485016,
-0.03661195561289787,
0.21521826088428497,
-0.536408543586731,
-0.3593713045120239,
0.3690497577190399,
-0.28245559334754944,
0.5694888830184937,
-0.20853957533836365,
-0.7157971262931824,
-0.2580205202102661,
0.08774465322494507,
0.5438494086265564,
0.34490296244621277,
-0.4171900749206543,
0.45396456122398376,
0.5896062850952148,
-0.24276788532733917,
-0.5128710269927979,
-0.6773843169212341,
0.2588149309158325,
-0.16302275657653809,
-0.1953904628753662,
0.3528320789337158,
0.30977365374565125,
-0.12033064663410187,
0.039990924298763275,
-0.3191715478897095,
-0.15906597673892975,
0.010040492750704288,
0.37169739603996277,
0.22869035601615906,
-0.4943409860134125,
0.412550151348114,
-0.07714814692735672,
-0.16259229183197021,
-0.10564021021127701,
-0.16878068447113037,
0.48481467366218567,
-0.08072085678577423,
-0.7353643774986267,
-0.39985015988349915,
0.37154027819633484,
0.5515462756156921,
-0.3513639569282532,
0.9246622323989868,
0.5180713534355164,
-0.6867637634277344,
-0.10722628235816956,
-0.6001248359680176,
-0.028746718540787697,
-0.40061822533607483,
0.5012479424476624,
-0.21263015270233154,
-1.365369439125061,
0.7258416414260864,
-0.061648838222026825,
-0.13859976828098297,
0.2941059470176697,
0.6662325263023376,
0.151118665933609,
0.7007997035980225,
0.2697931230068207,
0.10394413024187088,
0.25665223598480225,
-0.016756679862737656,
0.3360414206981659,
-1.1238120794296265,
-0.33268406987190247,
-0.5177172422409058,
-0.1637427657842636,
-0.6854372620582581,
-0.47399279475212097,
0.5773641467094421,
0.0527922697365284,
-0.019991395995020866,
0.16351599991321564,
-0.47045668959617615,
0.34666794538497925,
0.21942849457263947,
0.11438478529453278,
0.5089874267578125,
-0.04614119604229927,
-0.2627703547477722,
-0.25815659761428833,
-0.7093241214752197,
-0.3532244563102722,
1.1832561492919922,
0.5623522400856018,
0.5523154735565186,
-0.00531809451058507,
1.0649473667144775,
-0.038937196135520935,
0.3547712564468384,
-0.8486496210098267,
0.45930245518684387,
-0.26758304238319397,
-0.3866225779056549,
-0.18078641593456268,
-0.624896228313446,
-1.5467641353607178,
0.0910855382680893,
-0.12731435894966125,
-0.999691367149353,
0.269994854927063,
-0.041881266981363297,
-0.28303834795951843,
0.4474313259124756,
-0.33212924003601074,
0.9682022333145142,
-0.0819847360253334,
-0.0025241696275770664,
0.1259879618883133,
-0.47010132670402527,
0.12905298173427582,
-0.35714849829673767,
0.18472519516944885,
-0.09560338407754898,
-0.12111034989356995,
0.5224981307983398,
-0.5164996981620789,
0.7589232921600342,
-0.08819127827882767,
-0.2297837734222412,
0.0025270560290664434,
0.01021298486739397,
0.6071383953094482,
0.26823821663856506,
0.07434908300638199,
0.5942682027816772,
0.06546305119991302,
-0.3676108121871948,
-0.3010408282279968,
0.8880441784858704,
-0.45396876335144043,
-0.6167042255401611,
-0.5990027785301208,
-0.3764936029911041,
-0.37101826071739197,
0.46509668231010437,
0.3534085154533386,
0.6821497678756714,
-0.2687373459339142,
0.10112076252698898,
0.7394163608551025,
-0.5854590535163879,
0.13817058503627777,
0.6886565089225769,
-0.1604510247707367,
-0.3597542345523834,
0.8924830555915833,
0.06153243035078049,
0.4059895873069763,
0.44901928305625916,
0.01799519546329975,
-0.0178841445595026,
-1.1068204641342163,
-0.35817548632621765,
0.46158072352409363,
-0.6138880848884583,
-0.1768742948770523,
-0.7632536888122559,
-0.4077577590942383,
-0.38720089197158813,
-0.04888804256916046,
-0.23695172369480133,
-0.27778199315071106,
-0.7117993831634521,
0.10166395455598831,
0.2036612629890442,
0.7132543325424194,
0.20768678188323975,
0.06397160142660141,
-1.0022577047348022,
0.29774710536003113,
-0.09648757427930832,
0.45184430480003357,
0.11114312708377838,
-0.49440422654151917,
-0.12058518826961517,
-0.14992846548557281,
0.20810283720493317,
-0.9421964287757874,
0.3381466567516327,
-0.13083872199058533,
0.6138691902160645,
0.4718169569969177,
-0.0033777302596718073,
0.7644971609115601,
-0.8096805214881897,
0.6100620031356812,
0.23700515925884247,
-0.7678964138031006,
0.2528330385684967,
-0.3613280653953552,
0.2509072422981262,
0.49944183230400085,
0.3177584111690521,
-0.8425647020339966,
-0.43453851342201233,
-0.5115854740142822,
-1.0150787830352783,
0.4912412166595459,
0.20794187486171722,
0.1635976880788803,
-0.45207923650741577,
0.4743714928627014,
0.12924738228321075,
0.15817919373512268,
-0.5664229989051819,
-0.20770540833473206,
0.5727437138557434,
-0.16228291392326355,
0.1730605959892273,
-0.1669851541519165,
0.14849676191806793,
0.034375425428152084,
0.29980218410491943,
-0.06616692245006561,
0.3837343156337738,
0.5662222504615784,
-0.02586546167731285,
-0.06351903825998306,
0.3804567754268646,
0.39928117394447327,
0.2658923864364624,
0.021867264062166214,
-0.03741174936294556,
0.2847369611263275,
-0.618728756904602,
-0.18321558833122253,
0.20137450098991394,
-0.22032083570957184,
0.3005680441856384,
0.5419399738311768,
0.893431544303894,
0.42819473147392273,
-0.931535005569458,
0.7277253866195679,
-0.08365686237812042,
0.09486378729343414,
-0.4800810217857361,
-0.027165165171027184,
0.06058748438954353,
0.21746228635311127,
0.14422792196273804,
-0.09211479872465134,
0.0174556951969862,
-0.21905019879341125,
0.09906882047653198,
0.7059816718101501,
-0.4907189607620239,
-0.174589142203331,
0.6741467714309692,
0.050160471349954605,
-0.4144960045814514,
0.699873149394989,
-0.19716233015060425,
-0.11914661526679993,
0.639266848564148,
0.6225094795227051,
0.7101349234580994,
0.22657325863838196,
0.04670742154121399,
0.23155604302883148,
0.05009493976831436,
-0.13505199551582336,
0.05595972016453743,
0.22827164828777313,
-0.5223197340965271,
-0.3868216276168823,
-0.5971293449401855,
-0.48960813879966736,
0.37659403681755066,
-0.556804895401001,
0.5627836585044861,
-0.4724896550178528,
-0.2672175467014313,
0.1361280381679535,
-0.2862194776535034,
-0.8898337483406067,
-0.1503937989473343,
0.3917222321033478,
0.8699125647544861,
-0.267787367105484,
0.7164750695228577,
0.5630250573158264,
-0.4239751994609833,
-0.8455957174301147,
0.07493221759796143,
0.03009692020714283,
-0.9199912548065186,
0.7055325508117676,
0.15590204298496246,
0.3982590436935425,
-0.017747730016708374,
-0.22918282449245453,
-0.9145569205284119,
1.075735092163086,
0.20943859219551086,
-0.8409284949302673,
-0.5053368210792542,
0.4083458483219147,
0.7657386660575867,
-0.3891885578632355,
0.18428166210651398,
0.2087847888469696,
0.1690833568572998,
0.20875750482082367,
-1.3769611120224,
0.0933321863412857,
0.10550195723772049,
-0.1916513293981552,
0.510044276714325,
-0.32286524772644043,
0.8025853037834167,
-0.42590978741645813,
-0.2238183319568634,
0.34477469325065613,
0.22679607570171356,
0.29373183846473694,
0.6546222567558289,
0.10912933200597763,
0.6331532597541809,
0.93409264087677,
0.1316802203655243,
1.0012873411178589,
-0.09604167938232422,
0.2803407907485962,
1.07721745967865,
-0.6623398065567017,
0.9214626550674438,
0.3367522358894348,
-0.014237890020012856,
0.33627721667289734,
0.3375459909439087,
-0.10986918956041336,
0.1206880509853363,
0.2827472686767578,
-0.4612812399864197,
-0.04163332283496857,
-0.20787225663661957,
-0.4908963739871979,
0.3870469927787781,
0.49448928236961365,
-0.6462929248809814,
-0.17309235036373138,
0.12931571900844574,
0.14820924401283264,
-0.4313462972640991,
-0.5075636506080627,
0.9273942112922668,
0.3556126356124878,
-0.2278287708759308,
0.4542981684207916,
-0.053095120936632156,
0.37748032808303833,
-0.6643328666687012,
0.008987125009298325,
-0.12352774292230606,
0.17863346636295319,
-0.20962204039096832,
-0.3729199171066284,
0.09614536911249161,
0.17254380881786346,
0.02826187200844288,
0.2456100583076477,
0.849544882774353,
-0.18917344510555267,
-0.46688827872276306,
0.25301188230514526,
0.6450826525688171,
0.3912135064601898,
-0.03335002809762955,
-0.5169285535812378,
0.04258020594716072,
-0.3197662830352783,
-0.009253541938960552,
0.7034081220626831,
0.8777785301208496,
-0.217911958694458,
0.4869840145111084,
0.8294600248336792,
0.6258926391601562,
-0.2703588604927063,
0.2745330333709717,
0.8043486475944519,
-0.7619813084602356,
-0.15440696477890015,
-0.8718897700309753,
0.14927272498607635,
-0.002814385574311018,
-0.47848179936408997,
0.5248954892158508,
0.485280305147171,
0.6489898562431335,
0.05731409415602684,
0.4566202163696289,
0.1756030172109604,
0.4494445323944092,
-0.41957077383995056,
0.8194078803062439,
-0.6458866000175476,
0.41475632786750793,
-0.32402661442756653,
-0.5293599367141724,
-0.7289284467697144,
0.2492746114730835,
-0.43569162487983704,
-0.2238181233406067,
0.6881877779960632,
0.6081775426864624,
0.053013045340776443,
-0.22589005529880524,
0.43530574440956116,
0.4911317229270935,
0.34384265542030334,
0.6545246839523315,
0.707004964351654,
-0.18395143747329712,
0.3337448835372925,
0.14541186392307281,
-0.032375115901231766,
-0.21375511586666107,
-0.9028480052947998,
-1.0326995849609375,
-0.2164088785648346,
-0.33742985129356384,
-0.34473684430122375,
0.16930876672267914,
1.1439120769500732,
0.45355233550071716,
-0.9657325148582458,
0.3283728361129761,
-0.20517073571681976,
-0.008938905782997608,
0.07233526557683945,
-0.15598148107528687,
0.5464515089988708,
-0.2005298137664795,
-0.5215699672698975,
0.2794733941555023,
0.480712890625,
0.022262340411543846,
-0.0225954782217741,
0.10574705898761749,
0.3324768543243408,
-0.0826343223452568,
0.39461198449134827,
0.4399372935295105,
-0.9369767904281616,
-0.03438228741288185,
0.280329167842865,
-0.41907167434692383,
0.2079182267189026,
0.9865917563438416,
-0.807772159576416,
0.2809526324272156,
0.21576188504695892,
0.8654796481132507,
0.2868882417678833,
-0.44910088181495667,
0.25642722845077515,
-0.3114941716194153,
-0.15575353801250458,
0.6405560970306396,
0.5912042260169983,
0.3732491731643677,
-0.3490656316280365,
0.3185272812843323,
0.3543510437011719,
-0.7249754667282104,
-1.0776832103729248,
0.13536982238292694,
-1.0101724863052368,
-0.073107048869133,
1.3646132946014404,
-0.21386371552944183,
-0.043072283267974854,
-0.2152104377746582,
-0.28047657012939453,
0.092428058385849,
-0.37675735354423523,
0.6789406538009644,
0.5128887295722961,
-0.33938196301460266,
0.03238958120346069,
-0.6507410407066345,
0.3405246436595917,
0.2940640449523926,
-0.7402061820030212,
0.0007426402298733592,
0.4354097247123718,
0.48489513993263245,
-0.13666993379592896,
1.0665428638458252,
-0.4400612413883209,
0.18701578676700592,
-0.19739609956741333,
-0.10345454514026642,
-0.0008981309947557747,
0.01285453699529171,
-0.7408559322357178,
0.08683233708143234,
0.20902952551841736,
0.12089469283819199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00702v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00702v1 | Scaling Technology Acceptance Analysis with Large Language Model (LLM) Annotation Systems | 2024-06-30T14:01:06 | 2024-06-30T14:01:06 | Pawel Robert Smolinski, Joseph Januszewicz, Jacek Winiarski | cs.CL | cs.CL | Technology acceptance models effectively predict how users will adopt new
technology products. Traditional surveys, often expensive and cumbersome, are
commonly used for this assessment. As an alternative to surveys, we explore the
use of large language models for annotating online user-generated content, like
digital reviews and comments. Our research involved designing an LLM annotation
system that transform reviews into structured data based on the Unified Theory
of Acceptance and Use of Technology model. We conducted two studies to validate
the consistency and accuracy of the annotations. Results showed
moderate-to-strong consistency of LLM annotation systems, improving further by
lowering the model temperature. LLM annotations achieved close agreement with
human expert annotations and outperformed the agreement between experts for
UTAUT variables. These results suggest that LLMs can be an effective tool for
analyzing user sentiment, offering a practical alternative to traditional
survey methods and enabling deeper insights into technology design and
adoption. | [
-0.6960079669952393,
-0.7108626961708069,
0.653485119342804,
0.5281051397323608,
-0.40345174074172974,
-0.022723853588104248,
-0.4854692220687866,
-0.6138189435005188,
0.3741372227668762,
0.45171597599983215,
-0.3201809525489807,
-0.45709341764450073,
-0.48500126600265503,
0.2337295413017273,
-0.3157213628292084,
0.7403477430343628,
-0.23945516347885132,
0.0734081119298935,
-0.07603850215673447,
-0.19050252437591553,
-0.35592198371887207,
-0.41606342792510986,
-0.6538431644439697,
-0.6448368430137634,
0.630933403968811,
0.29884040355682373,
0.8262838125228882,
0.23415639996528625,
0.7013218402862549,
0.23245573043823242,
-0.2914770543575287,
0.053243041038513184,
-0.1398017555475235,
0.08779457956552505,
0.12829238176345825,
-0.20524895191192627,
-0.7905543446540833,
0.16831615567207336,
0.6374226808547974,
0.6549933552742004,
-0.14110490679740906,
0.43387147784233093,
0.20181801915168762,
0.44161584973335266,
-0.29830485582351685,
0.2644413113594055,
-0.5666287541389465,
-0.003949503879994154,
0.05265805125236511,
-0.02068008854985237,
-0.5519837737083435,
-0.4883170425891876,
0.015738749876618385,
-0.672328770160675,
-0.4517795443534851,
-0.1608399599790573,
0.5345504283905029,
0.018778948113322258,
-0.3668377697467804,
-0.34136050939559937,
-1.0086121559143066,
0.7745189666748047,
-0.7642710208892822,
0.2823196053504944,
0.25504156947135925,
0.3637000024318695,
-0.10378141701221466,
-0.36989346146583557,
-0.8835140466690063,
-0.3813689947128296,
-0.11193690448999405,
-0.08680365979671478,
-0.055114466696977615,
0.03998039662837982,
0.37458905577659607,
0.2754577398300171,
-0.2712825834751129,
0.3831018805503845,
-0.354430615901947,
-0.17676542699337006,
0.8235727548599243,
0.11583930253982544,
0.20952370762825012,
-0.24141812324523926,
-0.42544570565223694,
0.12255999445915222,
-0.687748908996582,
-0.08075526356697083,
0.12111015617847443,
0.5333728790283203,
0.008794529363512993,
0.6994995474815369,
-0.2994694113731384,
0.7124919891357422,
-0.07850363105535507,
-0.16147470474243164,
0.4615783095359802,
-0.3624878227710724,
-0.5307206511497498,
-0.09737600386142731,
0.8340941667556763,
0.6361795663833618,
0.4682978391647339,
0.2324540615081787,
-0.48773476481437683,
-0.16151872277259827,
0.3824150264263153,
-0.7748517394065857,
0.18987923860549927,
0.30500587821006775,
-0.6281765103340149,
-0.31745246052742004,
0.02683480829000473,
-0.6495229005813599,
-0.9433318972587585,
-0.4899173676967621,
0.38449323177337646,
0.15380123257637024,
-0.6042509078979492,
0.06057117506861687,
-0.018793130293488503,
0.2103421688079834,
0.6069143414497375,
-0.7077215909957886,
0.37001273036003113,
0.633529782295227,
1.081038475036621,
-0.053358305245637894,
-0.03633224219083786,
-0.058286331593990326,
-0.20695678889751434,
-0.39586302638053894,
0.7916720509529114,
-0.27062714099884033,
-0.7305484414100647,
0.17290711402893066,
-0.32116496562957764,
0.22635819017887115,
-0.591235876083374,
0.3807101845741272,
-0.9277938008308411,
-0.05039270222187042,
-0.1714121252298355,
-0.4685424566268921,
-0.2252807468175888,
0.6186648607254028,
-0.7552069425582886,
1.0266989469528198,
0.12040829658508301,
-0.6969932317733765,
0.6789600253105164,
-1.0617159605026245,
-0.17078052461147308,
0.097577765583992,
0.13004083931446075,
-0.3707815706729889,
0.3892161250114441,
0.29352620244026184,
0.5762766003608704,
-0.24147889018058777,
0.17343105375766754,
-0.5883712768554688,
-0.3013470768928528,
0.3983202278614044,
-0.04600997269153595,
0.7631219029426575,
0.5332284569740295,
-0.34497711062431335,
0.1868879646062851,
-0.6594231724739075,
-0.13433371484279633,
-0.02359239012002945,
-0.624016284942627,
-0.33090460300445557,
0.023394031450152397,
0.34692537784576416,
0.09475140273571014,
0.2890065908432007,
-0.8859665393829346,
0.5271182656288147,
-0.02404489554464817,
0.44605934619903564,
0.6495215892791748,
-0.025860806927084923,
0.5223040580749512,
-0.22897841036319733,
0.4349302649497986,
-0.16690120100975037,
0.3041461706161499,
-0.10410948842763901,
-0.4308754503726959,
-0.48055025935173035,
-0.18787001073360443,
0.3094862401485443,
0.2774829864501953,
-0.41530558466911316,
0.3743436336517334,
-0.4460954964160919,
-0.653892993927002,
-0.38965100049972534,
0.2926650643348694,
-0.3056294620037079,
0.32509371638298035,
0.13585518300533295,
-0.3019682765007019,
-0.5328524112701416,
-0.6525672078132629,
-0.11075154691934586,
-0.5964403748512268,
-0.42213913798332214,
0.25691840052604675,
0.15505550801753998,
-0.4781913161277771,
0.985447883605957,
-0.3163317143917084,
-0.1895735114812851,
-0.23246262967586517,
0.39444440603256226,
0.220365509390831,
0.13687969744205475,
0.2893933355808258,
-0.8217105865478516,
-0.3654056787490845,
0.17410916090011597,
-0.7671210765838623,
-0.30513590574264526,
-0.21121859550476074,
0.4794963002204895,
0.2566252648830414,
0.3627268373966217,
-0.4617769420146942,
0.30167412757873535,
0.6656889915466309,
-0.17565438151359558,
0.25851893424987793,
-0.10606393218040466,
0.41235658526420593,
-1.024239182472229,
-0.0037403416354209185,
0.3701234459877014,
-0.24920521676540375,
-0.5529986619949341,
0.05368483439087868,
0.13101375102996826,
0.08983080834150314,
-0.2670411765575409,
0.5570805072784424,
-0.27398955821990967,
-0.12856024503707886,
-0.4619813561439514,
0.2774793207645416,
-0.08127428591251373,
-0.19684714078903198,
0.030289722606539726,
0.7162801623344421,
0.08663592487573624,
-0.4301546514034271,
0.30814364552497864,
-0.032065313309431076,
-0.278132826089859,
0.6901025176048279,
-0.7445366978645325,
0.09950445592403412,
0.04176279529929161,
0.370417058467865,
-1.3912030458450317,
-0.269254595041275,
0.04569236561655998,
-0.46646562218666077,
0.09308166056871414,
0.13712383806705475,
-0.7804576754570007,
-0.3766079246997833,
-0.5318725109100342,
0.11838920414447784,
0.5410559177398682,
-0.535606324672699,
0.9495710134506226,
0.5357282757759094,
-0.20647288858890533,
-0.1695566624403,
-0.6809563636779785,
0.391902893781662,
-0.4094407558441162,
-0.7727125883102417,
-0.0788625106215477,
-0.3369811475276947,
-0.6421142816543579,
-0.35365208983421326,
0.2967790365219116,
-0.16167651116847992,
0.3221322298049927,
0.35383671522140503,
0.2927420437335968,
-0.22555625438690186,
0.2584275007247925,
-0.3844439685344696,
-0.02195972204208374,
0.14275671541690826,
-0.18447135388851166,
0.3876613974571228,
-0.06945352256298065,
-0.09849649667739868,
-0.6355932950973511,
0.030641647055745125,
0.8436928987503052,
0.3795792758464813,
0.4011429250240326,
0.5285099148750305,
-0.45922815799713135,
-0.07812389731407166,
-0.8473207950592041,
-0.0026728524826467037,
-0.46853020787239075,
0.09519201517105103,
-0.3379833698272705,
-0.9488805532455444,
0.4852389395236969,
-0.26586201786994934,
0.5583052039146423,
0.6236982941627502,
0.7303298115730286,
-0.3250167667865753,
0.9280754923820496,
0.8421644568443298,
-0.14017601311206818,
0.6889644265174866,
0.08545637875795364,
0.11807837337255478,
-0.7289286255836487,
-0.06703309714794159,
-0.5239046812057495,
-0.37772688269615173,
-0.6479021310806274,
-0.20705538988113403,
0.3046107590198517,
-0.045677706599235535,
-0.24396346509456635,
0.18910802900791168,
-0.35885724425315857,
0.2441745400428772,
0.30857929587364197,
0.11539946496486664,
0.5110888481140137,
0.37758639454841614,
0.17199935019016266,
-0.13999372720718384,
-0.07207945734262466,
-0.8114979863166809,
1.3348718881607056,
0.6676968336105347,
0.6661983728408813,
0.0033344982657581568,
0.6653143167495728,
0.5577322244644165,
0.8715631365776062,
-0.9876583814620972,
0.5009042024612427,
0.009975560009479523,
-0.6035043597221375,
-0.44407087564468384,
-0.335836797952652,
-0.4459655284881592,
0.058804187923669815,
-0.1926659345626831,
-0.7713398933410645,
-0.06041281670331955,
0.04989809915423393,
-0.33429333567619324,
0.46995052695274353,
-0.8241543769836426,
0.26920264959335327,
0.026439178735017776,
-0.04263992980122566,
-0.39610612392425537,
-0.23143737018108368,
0.3423137962818146,
-0.46859708428382874,
0.6094289422035217,
0.07334297150373459,
-0.15567001700401306,
0.9603182077407837,
-0.3390917181968689,
0.917086124420166,
-0.32057201862335205,
-0.25824832916259766,
0.545512855052948,
0.216406911611557,
0.37513288855552673,
-0.1387677639722824,
-0.5556581616401672,
0.23845452070236206,
-0.17790363729000092,
-0.2177457958459854,
-0.6268970966339111,
0.5287158489227295,
-0.8924395442008972,
-0.6579746603965759,
-0.3283693492412567,
-0.581533670425415,
-0.15159295499324799,
0.04059569165110588,
-0.2478276491165161,
-0.11531813442707062,
0.013832874596118927,
0.02687288634479046,
0.4697929918766022,
0.16218440234661102,
0.4752350151538849,
0.27444180846214294,
-0.6377300024032593,
-0.5120201706886292,
0.49134430289268494,
0.4405302405357361,
0.3050234913825989,
-0.035390421748161316,
0.5530545711517334,
-0.25549763441085815,
-0.7804188132286072,
-0.5230812430381775,
0.16498710215091705,
-0.7599337697029114,
0.11913963407278061,
-0.5593913793563843,
-0.10849352180957794,
-0.22947630286216736,
-0.1983833909034729,
-0.05295330286026001,
-0.4816657602787018,
-0.2710866928100586,
-0.2957724630832672,
0.4255145490169525,
1.4424837827682495,
-0.009298973716795444,
0.6768194437026978,
-0.6008018851280212,
0.09749870002269745,
0.16215422749519348,
0.41723865270614624,
-0.06036568060517311,
-0.6707037687301636,
-0.06316737830638885,
-0.14513421058654785,
-0.19804921746253967,
-0.6573837995529175,
0.015817295759916306,
-0.21846137940883636,
0.21057634055614471,
0.29450684785842896,
-0.2839896082878113,
0.4616490602493286,
-0.04766212776303291,
1.1699687242507935,
0.39509257674217224,
-0.7924044132232666,
0.30278530716896057,
-0.4872594177722931,
0.3384695053100586,
0.5021912455558777,
0.5953750610351562,
-0.7086182832717896,
-0.01881759986281395,
-0.3412235975265503,
-0.5759301781654358,
0.2535760998725891,
-0.4625648856163025,
0.4346759617328644,
0.39495202898979187,
0.4703132212162018,
0.24954955279827118,
0.10358588397502899,
-0.9986114501953125,
0.06380573660135269,
0.018217215314507484,
-0.18453499674797058,
-0.1908784806728363,
-0.5789462924003601,
0.07608705013990402,
-0.04960738494992256,
0.5421283841133118,
0.0375320203602314,
-0.06607698649168015,
-0.05159269645810127,
0.0013073479058220983,
-0.25516778230667114,
0.4213982820510864,
0.3690972328186035,
0.839272141456604,
-0.2193991094827652,
0.21401232481002808,
0.24527689814567566,
-0.5988295674324036,
0.12366948276758194,
-0.19275394082069397,
-0.45139279961586,
0.006521351169794798,
0.17488700151443481,
0.12131987512111664,
-0.192722886800766,
-0.3335052728652954,
0.32225269079208374,
-0.16885225474834442,
-0.23736189305782318,
-0.2964590787887573,
-0.23351417481899261,
0.3605714440345764,
0.2201606035232544,
0.3574144244194031,
-0.2543226480484009,
0.047679971903562546,
-0.3393971621990204,
0.07550004869699478,
0.40909385681152344,
-0.60786372423172,
-0.3060865104198456,
0.34712526202201843,
0.24523994326591492,
-0.46128788590431213,
0.4222918748855591,
-0.0653081089258194,
-0.1231774389743805,
0.3339313566684723,
0.3112393915653229,
0.8905358910560608,
-0.12442009150981903,
0.30840447545051575,
0.3561398983001709,
0.5731399059295654,
-0.24774368107318878,
0.44628942012786865,
-0.03392374888062477,
-0.546177089214325,
-0.3787306547164917,
-0.8040052056312561,
-0.6269903182983398,
-0.08439266681671143,
-0.31386610865592957,
0.5224878191947937,
-0.8438907265663147,
-0.5995088219642639,
0.12773337960243225,
0.10576224327087402,
-0.5881432890892029,
0.3496190309524536,
0.26081258058547974,
0.9505026340484619,
-0.9983341097831726,
0.5960706472396851,
0.7794637084007263,
-0.569582998752594,
-0.8573765158653259,
-0.10532310605049133,
0.30493730306625366,
-0.9169700145721436,
0.8910977244377136,
0.04575489088892937,
0.08339788764715195,
-0.28525999188423157,
-0.33080819249153137,
-0.665345311164856,
1.0986841917037964,
-0.03209000080823898,
-0.6485434174537659,
0.3463321924209595,
0.23763255774974823,
0.7036358714103699,
-0.6361024975776672,
0.6704322099685669,
0.5015825629234314,
0.6781783103942871,
0.21707497537136078,
-1.1399706602096558,
0.1761816293001175,
0.12080078572034836,
-0.0094001991674304,
0.06419170647859573,
-0.49056029319763184,
0.7901493310928345,
-0.08053254336118698,
-0.019129708409309387,
-0.13810646533966064,
0.47508659958839417,
0.1334855556488037,
0.6042165756225586,
0.8784756660461426,
0.28162989020347595,
0.6270069479942322,
0.10037016123533249,
0.8182565569877625,
0.06639017909765244,
0.46382778882980347,
0.7739376425743103,
-0.3711867034435272,
1.1801420450210571,
0.6446340680122375,
-0.3894546329975128,
0.6258791089057922,
0.7993948459625244,
0.11853994429111481,
-0.19956175982952118,
0.44824257493019104,
-0.31145867705345154,
-0.16940061748027802,
-0.45568960905075073,
0.013343092054128647,
0.20866209268569946,
0.4064997434616089,
-0.3710486888885498,
-0.17058490216732025,
-0.048663388937711716,
0.36181390285491943,
0.13171102106571198,
-0.6578386425971985,
0.9029521346092224,
0.17956291139125824,
-0.3089321553707123,
0.42926332354545593,
0.0014804110396653414,
0.8743631839752197,
-0.3801576793193817,
0.17622089385986328,
-0.05519334226846695,
-0.07450448721647263,
-0.6362417340278625,
-0.9316035509109497,
0.24886202812194824,
0.2986043691635132,
-0.13441339135169983,
-0.2774198353290558,
0.6574045419692993,
0.20481464266777039,
-0.8407875299453735,
0.3951356112957001,
0.5311873555183411,
0.1751536875963211,
-0.06463699042797089,
-0.3597501516342163,
0.4371964633464813,
-0.18120914697647095,
-0.6690356135368347,
0.21799814701080322,
0.05398578941822052,
-0.168397456407547,
0.42712950706481934,
0.4606691002845764,
0.43554601073265076,
-0.10387548059225082,
0.12828794121742249,
0.7757051587104797,
-0.7392090559005737,
-0.33738046884536743,
-0.977317214012146,
0.524359941482544,
-0.26725172996520996,
-0.06562439352273941,
0.8247427344322205,
0.21820910274982452,
0.8085745573043823,
0.38335248827934265,
1.0982534885406494,
0.0184552650898695,
0.42342332005500793,
-0.25440970063209534,
0.5342308282852173,
-0.47692739963531494,
0.33105775713920593,
-0.3657514750957489,
-1.077636480331421,
-0.7501521706581116,
0.2540857791900635,
-0.6360262632369995,
0.2651234567165375,
0.4646211266517639,
0.6548455357551575,
0.07351960986852646,
0.30162233114242554,
0.35134410858154297,
0.279999315738678,
0.5844514966011047,
0.13045208156108856,
0.9354662299156189,
-0.16777274012565613,
0.249677836894989,
-0.07259158045053482,
-0.43128928542137146,
-0.3361036479473114,
-1.0417554378509521,
-0.9661645889282227,
-0.29189035296440125,
-0.3029767572879791,
-0.6078876852989197,
-0.28944236040115356,
1.2279102802276611,
0.5386900901794434,
-0.7218443751335144,
-0.604056179523468,
0.2448773831129074,
0.008011302910745144,
-0.0013312697410583496,
-0.19183580577373505,
0.154024139046669,
-0.33378198742866516,
-0.4872240424156189,
-0.05246179550886154,
0.3101588189601898,
-0.03480617702007294,
-0.7684711813926697,
0.06814279407262802,
0.13077585399150848,
0.2015184760093689,
0.6587470769882202,
0.12284746021032333,
-0.6818584203720093,
-0.5004708766937256,
0.06229996681213379,
-0.09478598833084106,
0.2439420223236084,
0.9496335387229919,
-0.5215968489646912,
0.7545709609985352,
0.5624424815177917,
0.6832156777381897,
0.2875177264213562,
-0.0034953770227730274,
0.3568229377269745,
-0.2724425792694092,
-0.21511562168598175,
-0.04759528487920761,
0.2896343767642975,
0.5325192809104919,
-0.2918865978717804,
0.3310741186141968,
0.020648425444960594,
-0.6095961332321167,
-0.6628497242927551,
0.1007046028971672,
-1.0361783504486084,
-0.10343527793884277,
1.3653738498687744,
-0.1983116865158081,
-0.10709492862224579,
-0.10690095275640488,
-0.2818162441253662,
-0.18049313127994537,
-0.4588358402252197,
0.9873301982879639,
0.8856767416000366,
-0.18027310073375702,
0.030619101598858833,
-0.5419995784759521,
0.11646915972232819,
0.04072977975010872,
-0.7587422132492065,
0.22660544514656067,
0.48564502596855164,
0.4526464343070984,
0.36847761273384094,
0.7487993240356445,
-0.06844015419483185,
0.09747476130723953,
-0.0635354220867157,
0.10105955600738525,
-0.16743189096450806,
-0.006130768917500973,
-0.8431051969528198,
0.47633108496665955,
0.8239979147911072,
0.1663552075624466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00693v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00693v1 | BAPO: Base-Anchored Preference Optimization for Personalized Alignment in Large Language Models | 2024-06-30T13:30:04 | 2024-06-30T13:30:04 | Gihun Lee, Minchan Jeong, Yujin Kim, Hojung Jung, Jaehoon Oh, Sangmook Kim, Se-Young Yun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | While learning to align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences
has shown remarkable success, aligning these models to meet the diverse user
preferences presents further challenges in preserving previous knowledge. This
paper examines the impact of personalized preference optimization on LLMs,
revealing that the extent of knowledge loss varies significantly with
preference heterogeneity. Although previous approaches have utilized the KL
constraint between the reference model and the policy model, we observe that
they fail to maintain general knowledge and alignment when facing personalized
preferences. To this end, we introduce Base-Anchored Preference Optimization
(BAPO), a simple yet effective approach that utilizes the initial responses of
reference model to mitigate forgetting while accommodating personalized
alignment. BAPO effectively adapts to diverse user preferences while minimally
affecting global knowledge or general alignment. Our experiments demonstrate
the efficacy of BAPO in various setups. | [
-0.26734745502471924,
-0.38448214530944824,
0.5513906478881836,
0.04223114252090454,
-0.09346618503332138,
0.07011332362890244,
-0.4307679533958435,
0.04595225676894188,
-0.04808757081627846,
0.51875239610672,
-0.514611005783081,
-0.2961730659008026,
-0.35889264941215515,
-0.2647339105606079,
0.5810185074806213,
1.0472503900527954,
0.0456249974668026,
-0.08936194330453873,
-0.5570197105407715,
-0.3062194585800171,
-0.7334038019180298,
-0.5618332028388977,
-0.2720915377140045,
-0.7688978314399719,
0.382129043340683,
0.7531425356864929,
0.7763985395431519,
0.5988337397575378,
0.2059905230998993,
0.175994873046875,
-0.3209773004055023,
0.4863114655017853,
-0.7045316696166992,
0.13281501829624176,
-0.5474502444267273,
-0.5622748732566833,
-0.3384350836277008,
-0.4102334678173065,
0.7467455863952637,
1.1515982151031494,
-0.32499971985816956,
-0.020410703495144844,
-0.007625237572938204,
1.029201626777649,
-1.1066198348999023,
-0.2574145197868347,
-0.8777512311935425,
0.024213070049881935,
0.21687638759613037,
-0.2078922986984253,
-0.4566749632358551,
-0.48461607098579407,
0.5799064636230469,
-0.5072566270828247,
-0.05086856335401535,
0.16394594311714172,
0.7557332515716553,
0.30907297134399414,
-0.5816054940223694,
-0.264047771692276,
-0.8920774459838867,
1.0547184944152832,
-0.582582414150238,
0.3708479106426239,
0.4343740940093994,
0.11448968946933746,
-0.3269101679325104,
0.06686341017484665,
-0.4427298605442047,
-0.10211261361837387,
0.14768196642398834,
0.1817297637462616,
0.05722746625542641,
-0.13438786566257477,
-0.050202470272779465,
0.22040803730487823,
-0.3570411503314972,
0.1362341046333313,
-0.009540306404232979,
-0.34839123487472534,
0.29917827248573303,
-0.01729564368724823,
0.12361688911914825,
0.15847395360469818,
-0.45404714345932007,
0.24017484486103058,
-0.8490091562271118,
0.07064399123191833,
0.45459020137786865,
0.31069159507751465,
-0.05364310368895531,
0.44996023178100586,
-0.22609664499759674,
0.5813843011856079,
0.4200378656387329,
-0.32618170976638794,
0.3848060369491577,
-0.12995073199272156,
0.030936993658542633,
0.20953558385372162,
0.5836303234100342,
0.4348001778125763,
0.592161238193512,
-0.26351049542427063,
0.19547708332538605,
-0.12995022535324097,
0.06400048732757568,
-0.560209333896637,
0.21005387604236603,
0.02368195354938507,
-0.39090052247047424,
-0.09913769364356995,
-0.08773038536310196,
-0.46634534001350403,
-0.3343106806278229,
-0.23136621713638306,
0.17975793778896332,
-0.4189382791519165,
-0.028204521164298058,
0.23256537318229675,
0.1617155224084854,
-0.01226426474750042,
0.24440929293632507,
-1.6102374792099,
0.2703091502189636,
0.6355295181274414,
0.7571007609367371,
-0.1632104068994522,
-0.2913189232349396,
-0.4800897240638733,
0.7856882810592651,
-0.320496141910553,
0.4792165458202362,
-0.5466779470443726,
-0.7042959332466125,
0.06561658531427383,
-0.19256159663200378,
0.032308440655469894,
-0.55538409948349,
0.3968513607978821,
-0.547549307346344,
0.33159470558166504,
-0.6322786808013916,
-0.7476338744163513,
-0.09210854768753052,
0.2923818826675415,
-0.23361428081989288,
0.7378458976745605,
0.03313484042882919,
-0.6029374003410339,
0.3118765950202942,
-0.31466010212898254,
-0.4125117361545563,
-0.22734902799129486,
-0.07001591473817825,
-0.5549108386039734,
0.4007987082004547,
0.04902564361691475,
0.28260982036590576,
-0.3111571967601776,
0.2280297726392746,
-0.5900471210479736,
-0.367389440536499,
0.03864728659391403,
0.09781461209058762,
0.6963708996772766,
0.0848192423582077,
-0.07751172035932541,
0.003896614070981741,
-0.5904152989387512,
-0.17689958214759827,
0.07511287927627563,
-0.4940533936023712,
-0.7766026854515076,
0.28043651580810547,
-0.5076139569282532,
-0.07106610387563705,
0.6372313499450684,
-0.35288047790527344,
0.6759271621704102,
-0.589326798915863,
0.08844558894634247,
1.1072920560836792,
-0.026138264685869217,
0.8065488338470459,
-0.335161417722702,
0.33680200576782227,
-0.018329152837395668,
-0.054758328944444656,
-0.15685194730758667,
-0.31516727805137634,
-0.5397533774375916,
0.0794522687792778,
0.09220170974731445,
0.5030205249786377,
0.16389428079128265,
0.6897389888763428,
-0.4396805763244629,
-0.2971828281879425,
-0.16228684782981873,
0.5034294724464417,
0.42683297395706177,
0.9598487615585327,
0.33331137895584106,
-0.35179218649864197,
-0.38873711228370667,
-1.170398473739624,
-0.10809975117444992,
-0.22013376653194427,
0.06814170628786087,
0.5015324354171753,
0.1321037858724594,
-0.6116317510604858,
1.1449718475341797,
-0.7753417491912842,
-0.3251039683818817,
-0.043405961245298386,
-0.22940552234649658,
0.04862022027373314,
0.4146089255809784,
0.7739471793174744,
-0.5859109163284302,
-0.642175018787384,
0.3653050363063812,
-0.24248872697353363,
-0.2582972049713135,
0.10772845894098282,
-0.20528805255889893,
0.3898538053035736,
0.0784580186009407,
-0.3357203006744385,
-0.07881797850131989,
0.6413742899894714,
-0.16088251769542694,
0.6216650009155273,
-0.37301063537597656,
-0.09689125418663025,
-1.2101404666900635,
0.07558896392583847,
-0.221699520945549,
-0.09767439216375351,
-0.48463767766952515,
-0.5451133847236633,
0.25784990191459656,
-0.03153975307941437,
-0.16844341158866882,
0.7026693224906921,
-0.5686174631118774,
-0.08852487057447433,
-0.3695087432861328,
-0.1697835773229599,
0.09773416072130203,
0.5087435841560364,
0.3039979338645935,
0.6132330894470215,
0.36935514211654663,
-0.6095442175865173,
-0.07965290546417236,
0.5225629806518555,
-0.07103188335895538,
0.4710221290588379,
-0.29843664169311523,
0.5850716233253479,
-0.22456908226013184,
0.06909874826669693,
-0.9456925392150879,
-0.1609666645526886,
0.2035980224609375,
-0.28303006291389465,
0.2870488166809082,
-0.49909377098083496,
-0.027554430067539215,
0.02404235117137432,
-0.4275833070278168,
0.38745296001434326,
0.5009881854057312,
-0.4673096835613251,
0.5858509540557861,
0.32875150442123413,
-0.07060211896896362,
-1.0674734115600586,
-0.3863908052444458,
-0.30454909801483154,
-0.2531620264053345,
-0.38482344150543213,
0.5051314830780029,
-0.30142489075660706,
-0.03995130956172943,
0.05693354085087776,
-0.3871415853500366,
0.28297698497772217,
0.10756626725196838,
0.12627996504306793,
0.25726115703582764,
-0.16260169446468353,
0.12884953618049622,
0.11269975453615189,
-0.13249307870864868,
-0.2444608509540558,
-0.4259607791900635,
0.8619374632835388,
-0.31793639063835144,
-0.2344455122947693,
-0.24070483446121216,
0.3834564685821533,
0.5722764134407043,
-0.08742347359657288,
0.7482803463935852,
0.1230596974492073,
-0.275645911693573,
-0.2878173589706421,
-0.7736316323280334,
0.23420728743076324,
-0.5211639404296875,
0.429815411567688,
-0.4219502806663513,
-0.8085693120956421,
0.6354566812515259,
-0.298610657453537,
-0.13512222468852997,
0.12092233449220657,
0.9415535926818848,
-0.2961302697658539,
0.8697547912597656,
0.9202690720558167,
-0.6221825480461121,
0.6794975996017456,
0.13123932480812073,
0.07934106141328812,
-0.9191324710845947,
-0.21320781111717224,
-0.3425990045070648,
-0.3194620609283447,
-0.27901265025138855,
-0.11422325670719147,
0.11384095251560211,
0.09357813745737076,
-0.5718500018119812,
0.05302052944898605,
-0.3561117351055145,
0.5518987774848938,
0.771315336227417,
-0.04571329802274704,
0.2647976279258728,
0.014006872661411762,
-0.14586424827575684,
-0.09609606862068176,
-0.6834611892700195,
-0.5329440236091614,
1.2899008989334106,
0.22091278433799744,
0.9193621277809143,
0.1882312148809433,
0.7202107906341553,
0.20402735471725464,
0.13972823321819305,
-0.8841186761856079,
0.24631774425506592,
-0.19248652458190918,
-0.5544987320899963,
-0.13885806500911713,
-0.4188668727874756,
-0.8204098343849182,
0.06553584337234497,
-0.21109580993652344,
-1.0096336603164673,
0.5064840316772461,
0.9027068614959717,
-0.4526332914829254,
0.19276103377342224,
-0.794858992099762,
0.8408512473106384,
-0.5161763429641724,
-0.36184412240982056,
-0.21327464282512665,
-0.7550529837608337,
0.3113298714160919,
0.016882315278053284,
0.0005007699364796281,
-0.2895733118057251,
-0.2749898135662079,
0.3692185878753662,
-0.45735570788383484,
0.6381132006645203,
-0.08934389054775238,
0.14292854070663452,
-0.08728387206792831,
-0.07027680426836014,
0.5114667415618896,
-0.13465331494808197,
-0.23233698308467865,
-0.0007825518259778619,
-0.2063772976398468,
-0.4370003938674927,
-0.6016369462013245,
0.8872866034507751,
-1.005123496055603,
-0.7208964228630066,
-0.32966992259025574,
-0.5799384117126465,
-0.7797103524208069,
0.32512667775154114,
0.3352484405040741,
-0.07570214569568634,
-0.32659095525741577,
0.3526872396469116,
0.8556559681892395,
-0.2519443929195404,
0.19211728870868683,
0.44090262055397034,
-0.11780659854412079,
-0.6736428141593933,
0.8035945296287537,
0.039586860686540604,
0.646753191947937,
0.47295549511909485,
0.7806398272514343,
-0.11307258903980255,
-0.5636245608329773,
-0.21464335918426514,
0.3309957981109619,
-0.6514233946800232,
-0.14330388605594635,
-0.42234188318252563,
0.30390262603759766,
-0.5306460857391357,
-0.5935817360877991,
-0.4503488838672638,
-0.23099741339683533,
-0.24897290766239166,
0.14930084347724915,
0.005911360494792461,
-0.01585821621119976,
0.006170328706502914,
0.5960927605628967,
-0.5288938283920288,
0.3090815246105194,
0.33123546838760376,
0.4739406108856201,
-0.10303709656000137,
-0.4722594916820526,
-0.3989724814891815,
-0.07911744713783264,
-0.3059821128845215,
-0.8617052435874939,
0.14137046039104462,
0.24289074540138245,
0.7419565320014954,
0.8859695792198181,
-0.1283067911863327,
0.6523157358169556,
-0.5516630411148071,
0.2574988007545471,
0.42492011189460754,
-0.9465797543525696,
0.6870071887969971,
-0.38031691312789917,
0.6293070912361145,
0.9047993421554565,
0.605897068977356,
-0.7698472738265991,
0.36842143535614014,
-0.3181946873664856,
-0.800490140914917,
0.6110953092575073,
-0.3027426600456238,
0.34540826082229614,
0.11616184562444687,
0.5004010796546936,
0.1834718883037567,
0.35511094331741333,
-0.6237269639968872,
-0.4537253975868225,
-0.03771616891026497,
-0.1757597178220749,
0.08073141425848007,
-0.7618107199668884,
-0.12172441184520721,
-0.07562784850597382,
0.9374078512191772,
-0.24541547894477844,
-0.12988653779029846,
-0.012600047513842583,
-0.1933429092168808,
-0.22156918048858643,
0.17368215322494507,
0.6330366730690002,
0.5929320454597473,
-0.5678118467330933,
-0.13206340372562408,
0.15720686316490173,
-0.37869083881378174,
0.21833354234695435,
-0.2145451456308365,
-0.6148673295974731,
-0.3152456283569336,
0.12239448726177216,
0.8031847476959229,
0.20945309102535248,
-0.6623202562332153,
0.2824251651763916,
0.32539427280426025,
0.018423551693558693,
-0.22060337662696838,
0.1946815550327301,
0.38314002752304077,
-0.3060383200645447,
0.30849096179008484,
0.24839502573013306,
-0.08899860084056854,
-0.9911186695098877,
-0.0272833239287138,
0.6630277633666992,
-0.2672910690307617,
-0.16590727865695953,
0.6453184485435486,
0.15798193216323853,
-0.40729206800460815,
0.3252599835395813,
0.20322763919830322,
-0.6731002926826477,
0.3845653831958771,
0.7880679368972778,
0.8020763993263245,
-0.6266762614250183,
-0.18153007328510284,
0.3157113790512085,
0.1913170963525772,
-0.03392918407917023,
-0.09419838339090347,
-0.06411087512969971,
-1.3265793323516846,
-0.10740789771080017,
-0.3685299754142761,
-0.818999707698822,
0.019327372312545776,
-0.49625077843666077,
0.38614746928215027,
-0.9473656415939331,
-0.21308696269989014,
-0.10412019491195679,
0.09963681548833847,
-0.4990798830986023,
0.14074575901031494,
0.3334813416004181,
0.5001391768455505,
-0.7821924686431885,
0.7533384561538696,
0.7873103022575378,
-0.19125868380069733,
-0.44782283902168274,
0.16363832354545593,
0.25207069516181946,
-0.824201762676239,
0.3899582028388977,
-0.07097116112709045,
-0.3957503139972687,
-0.15269525349140167,
-0.28171050548553467,
-0.9696676135063171,
0.8207756280899048,
0.6562434434890747,
-0.6722261905670166,
-0.001263703336007893,
0.19624388217926025,
0.32312265038490295,
-0.5485427379608154,
-0.024878017604351044,
0.47868698835372925,
0.3596864342689514,
0.1228875145316124,
-0.7681106925010681,
-0.1591961681842804,
0.05662501975893974,
0.012425839900970459,
0.19472120702266693,
-1.0698235034942627,
0.34323805570602417,
-0.32102930545806885,
0.1955534815788269,
-0.2496882975101471,
0.5936838388442993,
0.4179052710533142,
0.1564875990152359,
0.6966944336891174,
0.5843027830123901,
0.8699142336845398,
0.15793490409851074,
0.8483688235282898,
-0.12136732041835785,
0.30526551604270935,
1.4043591022491455,
-0.5158296227455139,
0.5874888300895691,
0.6214646697044373,
0.012319748289883137,
0.4718312621116638,
0.48775291442871094,
0.011653207242488861,
0.8233879208564758,
0.07571052014827728,
-0.33735188841819763,
-0.3402029573917389,
-0.07360462099313736,
-0.3847256004810333,
0.30928876996040344,
0.23518536984920502,
-0.16432051360607147,
0.06718017160892487,
-0.24067047238349915,
0.1629233956336975,
0.368760347366333,
-0.29111555218696594,
0.7783131003379822,
-0.09971358627080917,
-0.8709142804145813,
0.4925743043422699,
-0.10802760720252991,
0.6208671927452087,
-0.8225506544113159,
0.38901734352111816,
-0.4553390145301819,
0.4190939664840698,
-0.21968626976013184,
-0.2758535146713257,
0.23112915456295013,
-0.37764182686805725,
-0.7018319964408875,
-0.1077999696135521,
0.7151392102241516,
-0.6131241917610168,
-0.31863677501678467,
0.27219921350479126,
0.1706600785255432,
-0.4124240577220917,
0.12152877449989319,
-0.4756365716457367,
0.025501253083348274,
0.1714504361152649,
-0.5253452658653259,
0.37356260418891907,
0.1518038660287857,
-0.22951747477054596,
0.981696605682373,
0.5936375260353088,
0.13434068858623505,
-0.15513260662555695,
0.02029861882328987,
0.6255677938461304,
-0.5870769619941711,
-0.4446497857570648,
-0.9117379188537598,
0.3615041971206665,
-0.09561263024806976,
-0.4506435692310333,
0.6375635862350464,
0.7946547865867615,
0.755171537399292,
-0.3116039037704468,
0.9983718395233154,
0.22106264531612396,
0.4786232113838196,
-0.3854128420352936,
0.565716028213501,
-0.613926112651825,
0.33731043338775635,
-0.39487195014953613,
-1.217445731163025,
-0.2912150025367737,
0.5297590494155884,
-0.5640804171562195,
-0.045762401074171066,
0.4673956632614136,
0.6391199827194214,
-0.25529852509498596,
-0.5667214393615723,
0.3411276638507843,
-0.09519748389720917,
0.09675715863704681,
0.7445302605628967,
0.5591639876365662,
0.09039594978094101,
0.41556867957115173,
-0.362413614988327,
-0.30579519271850586,
-0.4941183924674988,
-1.142235517501831,
-0.8958561420440674,
-0.3839404881000519,
-0.3911898732185364,
-0.15743155777454376,
0.2014779895544052,
1.1746788024902344,
0.6461940407752991,
-0.9317606687545776,
-0.2475568801164627,
0.1939706653356552,
0.313641220331192,
-0.06434864550828934,
-0.11073964089155197,
0.491955429315567,
-0.31624776124954224,
-0.9215751886367798,
0.3715159296989441,
0.4518301784992218,
0.08532118052244186,
0.07247186452150345,
-0.3611254394054413,
-0.3368377387523651,
0.09379860013723373,
0.3774043023586273,
0.6463866829872131,
-0.7022620439529419,
-0.48693937063217163,
0.093807153403759,
-0.015341577120125294,
0.2750824987888336,
0.7687345147132874,
-0.62555992603302,
0.6951291561126709,
0.5189254283905029,
0.9443607926368713,
0.49281132221221924,
0.4108901023864746,
1.0371322631835938,
-0.6038699746131897,
0.262914776802063,
0.18385690450668335,
0.6705602407455444,
0.3818013370037079,
-0.4999251067638397,
0.38432949781417847,
0.3263408839702606,
-0.5245832204818726,
-0.7311214804649353,
0.4628240168094635,
-1.3099124431610107,
-0.2495913803577423,
1.1218069791793823,
-0.13382896780967712,
0.05538823828101158,
0.051122963428497314,
-0.23630359768867493,
0.05560047924518585,
-0.33552172780036926,
0.9061121344566345,
0.8799703121185303,
-0.019506923854351044,
0.07392783463001251,
-0.08070892840623856,
0.4340388774871826,
0.9700530171394348,
-0.39114949107170105,
0.12029427289962769,
0.7129142880439758,
0.561282753944397,
0.1621723175048828,
0.7782124280929565,
0.20929653942584991,
0.17021295428276062,
-0.4999206066131592,
0.2803473472595215,
-0.13331282138824463,
-0.0289008691906929,
-0.25463104248046875,
0.18460984528064728,
0.20209473371505737,
-0.19644005596637726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02528v1 | Actionable Cyber Threat Intelligence using Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models | 2024-06-30T13:02:03 | 2024-06-30T13:02:03 | Romy Fieblinger, Md Tanvirul Alam, Nidhi Rastogi | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Cyber threats are constantly evolving. Extracting actionable insights from
unstructured Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) data is essential to guide
cybersecurity decisions. Increasingly, organizations like Microsoft, Trend
Micro, and CrowdStrike are using generative AI to facilitate CTI extraction.
This paper addresses the challenge of automating the extraction of actionable
CTI using advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs
(KGs). We explore the application of state-of-the-art open-source LLMs,
including the Llama 2 series, Mistral 7B Instruct, and Zephyr for extracting
meaningful triples from CTI texts. Our methodology evaluates techniques such as
prompt engineering, the guidance framework, and fine-tuning to optimize
information extraction and structuring. The extracted data is then utilized to
construct a KG, offering a structured and queryable representation of threat
intelligence. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach in extracting relevant information, with guidance and fine-tuning
showing superior performance over prompt engineering. However, while our
methods prove effective in small-scale tests, applying LLMs to large-scale data
for KG construction and Link Prediction presents ongoing challenges. | [
-0.0015323442639783025,
-1.0683672428131104,
0.44576311111450195,
0.054670337587594986,
-0.016447588801383972,
0.3162854015827179,
-0.034623898565769196,
-0.5441598296165466,
0.04941678047180176,
0.48665091395378113,
-0.3699852228164673,
-0.7355789542198181,
-0.6284111738204956,
-0.08442588895559311,
-0.45666950941085815,
0.7456342577934265,
0.11098700016736984,
-0.5070051550865173,
0.03296511992812157,
0.22088748216629028,
-0.6806538701057434,
-0.6710979342460632,
-0.729249894618988,
-0.15500469505786896,
0.4500071108341217,
0.349632203578949,
0.6247490644454956,
0.6579791903495789,
0.5378966927528381,
0.3564859628677368,
0.05471561849117279,
0.13482116162776947,
-0.4165229797363281,
0.07191188633441925,
0.02060517482459545,
-0.3384701609611511,
-0.41939401626586914,
-0.018931569531559944,
0.32184818387031555,
0.5090644955635071,
-0.001565761398524046,
0.03156305104494095,
0.058996643871068954,
0.3649264872074127,
-0.5593879818916321,
0.3971666097640991,
-0.7210108041763306,
-0.015397826209664345,
-0.27909135818481445,
-0.25850406289100647,
-0.6765191555023193,
-0.2520905137062073,
0.3123110234737396,
-0.6199948787689209,
-0.10000192373991013,
0.12484852969646454,
0.48735034465789795,
0.15541315078735352,
-0.5209866166114807,
-0.3466702401638031,
-0.7363472580909729,
0.5518568158149719,
-0.4000854790210724,
0.37395283579826355,
0.08720646053552628,
0.462750643491745,
-0.4085988998413086,
-0.8234610557556152,
-0.24700042605400085,
-0.12892182171344757,
-0.06660841405391693,
0.06852956116199493,
-0.7514075040817261,
0.04388570785522461,
0.2886277437210083,
0.06163555756211281,
-0.536177396774292,
0.4967402517795563,
-0.510675311088562,
-0.21873638033866882,
0.8195658922195435,
0.4482211470603943,
0.2539631128311157,
-0.09773166477680206,
-0.38056302070617676,
-0.16063112020492554,
-0.6668921709060669,
-0.04947026073932648,
0.2539687156677246,
0.47400811314582825,
-0.27882808446884155,
0.5877354145050049,
-0.20994077622890472,
0.7499951720237732,
-0.007882049307227135,
-0.250323086977005,
0.1422301083803177,
-0.2810523808002472,
-0.15798597037792206,
0.025473028421401978,
0.9767489433288574,
0.16816428303718567,
0.35096415877342224,
-0.4399140179157257,
0.015201518312096596,
-0.23782995343208313,
0.5853285789489746,
-0.6627814173698425,
-0.43901723623275757,
0.33066627383232117,
-0.4784371554851532,
-0.6881924271583557,
0.1098499447107315,
-1.0776760578155518,
-0.7622098326683044,
-0.3146488070487976,
0.21061189472675323,
-0.5506694316864014,
-0.24791628122329712,
-0.10419241338968277,
-0.38923874497413635,
0.18159091472625732,
0.22146770358085632,
-0.26949846744537354,
-0.14196889102458954,
0.5193259716033936,
0.8700953722000122,
-0.38721928000450134,
0.0042808582074940205,
-0.4712802767753601,
0.35290125012397766,
-0.198198601603508,
0.6769943237304688,
-0.5962871313095093,
-0.5155330300331116,
0.07483508437871933,
-0.33852386474609375,
-0.09328927099704742,
-0.41922706365585327,
0.12309964001178741,
-0.9899368286132812,
-0.1089988574385643,
0.2057129293680191,
-0.26069337129592896,
-0.14423725008964539,
0.6086280345916748,
-0.770267903804779,
0.8808717727661133,
0.09080372005701065,
-0.7846882343292236,
-0.013171760365366936,
-0.8631733655929565,
-0.4250401556491852,
0.28393083810806274,
-0.023204753175377846,
-0.22349928319454193,
-0.08022823929786682,
0.257597953081131,
0.6473653316497803,
-0.45173513889312744,
0.2945513129234314,
-0.5359694361686707,
0.13883337378501892,
0.20042772591114044,
-0.37744107842445374,
0.8929206728935242,
0.22490811347961426,
-0.3580440282821655,
0.2642432451248169,
-0.6657544374465942,
0.1720665842294693,
0.30351418256759644,
-0.19034431874752045,
-0.12313088774681091,
0.0836971253156662,
-0.2108711302280426,
0.057039596140384674,
0.35693827271461487,
-0.41556113958358765,
0.16016407310962677,
-0.31471309065818787,
0.3825110197067261,
0.8129562735557556,
0.14691659808158875,
0.1066845953464508,
-0.07078775018453598,
0.604678750038147,
-0.005976986605674028,
0.20541901886463165,
0.3627142012119293,
-0.3424661457538605,
-0.4727112352848053,
-0.4169255197048187,
0.13970015943050385,
0.9298530220985413,
-1.1083303689956665,
0.4626765549182892,
-0.49941912293434143,
-0.8185415267944336,
0.006385623011738062,
-0.03986051678657532,
0.2712309658527374,
0.3706609606742859,
0.3373335897922516,
0.2518199682235718,
-0.5504812598228455,
-0.7707501649856567,
-0.2633384168148041,
-0.3732280135154724,
-0.09846895188093185,
0.016234369948506355,
0.31840306520462036,
-0.2151132971048355,
1.048398733139038,
-0.961165726184845,
0.07828478515148163,
-0.6065144538879395,
0.4381120204925537,
0.05277463048696518,
0.11184341460466385,
0.47883519530296326,
-0.8369190096855164,
-0.28917166590690613,
0.040374644100666046,
-0.9274042248725891,
-0.11321429163217545,
0.1058962345123291,
-0.06405829638242722,
-0.24451890587806702,
0.8202463984489441,
-0.39787518978118896,
0.6424614787101746,
0.1869056671857834,
-0.18261830508708954,
0.4653679430484772,
0.2064349204301834,
0.012439618818461895,
-1.2826939821243286,
0.3342064321041107,
0.07374086230993271,
-0.11930935084819794,
-1.0448087453842163,
0.34745776653289795,
-0.16119824349880219,
-0.3928523361682892,
-0.4191229045391083,
0.4645497500896454,
-0.15442456305027008,
0.06677223742008209,
-0.32220301032066345,
0.28304919600486755,
-0.3883000910282135,
0.3693767786026001,
-0.14630421996116638,
0.6516756415367126,
0.4150662422180176,
-0.6960999369621277,
0.6556940674781799,
0.1034102737903595,
-0.2710586488246918,
0.2528926134109497,
-0.6892209053039551,
0.24731430411338806,
0.07143179327249527,
0.1615375429391861,
-0.5795687437057495,
-0.3732256293296814,
0.415206640958786,
-0.2686634659767151,
0.19971822202205658,
-0.03273705020546913,
-0.631921648979187,
-0.49608561396598816,
-0.34760618209838867,
0.513828694820404,
0.29646846652030945,
-0.5983824729919434,
0.9176748394966125,
0.7369657158851624,
-0.1165805384516716,
-0.4158307611942291,
-0.3250606954097748,
0.23417338728904724,
-0.45705917477607727,
-0.4619569778442383,
0.3097161650657654,
-0.08775189518928528,
-0.5146201252937317,
-0.2973312735557556,
0.04736641049385071,
-0.20991995930671692,
0.48527947068214417,
0.5415441393852234,
0.3677603304386139,
0.08771365135908127,
-0.034848902374506,
-0.37041082978248596,
-0.17203354835510254,
0.3437202572822571,
-0.35494109988212585,
0.5586339235305786,
-0.04908380284905434,
-0.26393836736679077,
-0.43479451537132263,
0.35887157917022705,
0.6316485404968262,
-0.20865695178508759,
0.48542603850364685,
0.6919283270835876,
-0.414198100566864,
-0.017868420109152794,
-0.4048570990562439,
0.057784244418144226,
-0.4933881163597107,
0.3443494439125061,
-0.2874368131160736,
-0.9764551520347595,
0.24166373908519745,
-0.34940117597579956,
0.210345059633255,
0.4891720712184906,
0.3318321108818054,
0.12944543361663818,
1.0516741275787354,
0.7701690196990967,
-0.5204299092292786,
0.5755255818367004,
-0.24070069193840027,
0.4553060233592987,
-0.3909367024898529,
-0.4437205493450165,
-0.566609263420105,
-0.12947186827659607,
-0.5422616004943848,
0.03367093577980995,
0.9289857745170593,
0.0725533589720726,
-0.23101235926151276,
0.5084568858146667,
-0.2353421300649643,
0.16806097328662872,
0.4634128212928772,
0.2585023045539856,
0.07747426629066467,
0.18871869146823883,
0.2141885608434677,
0.5581091642379761,
-0.6529921293258667,
-0.3542753756046295,
1.0831717252731323,
0.22070230543613434,
0.32853803038597107,
0.40624693036079407,
0.38435396552085876,
0.5460792183876038,
0.1621517390012741,
-0.7851974964141846,
0.7358563542366028,
-0.07595168054103851,
-0.34063640236854553,
-0.21210181713104248,
-0.5535656213760376,
-1.1061323881149292,
-0.14741834998130798,
-0.34041082859039307,
-1.01029634475708,
-0.0977485179901123,
0.042478516697883606,
-0.43439266085624695,
0.3331279754638672,
-0.5670985579490662,
0.5407487154006958,
-0.05667896196246147,
0.09347280114889145,
-0.4424682557582855,
-0.7088173627853394,
0.16391216218471527,
-0.1893521398305893,
0.09666841477155685,
0.12667344510555267,
0.18251071870326996,
0.7388688325881958,
-0.24716995656490326,
1.191286563873291,
-0.10299330204725266,
-0.1798628568649292,
0.5105423331260681,
0.11513309180736542,
0.6519064903259277,
-0.062402572482824326,
-0.2732163965702057,
0.41968420147895813,
-0.2193167805671692,
-0.29995691776275635,
-0.692948043346405,
0.3625490665435791,
-0.7631480097770691,
-0.8109158277511597,
-0.2240329384803772,
-0.5877913236618042,
-0.2841029465198517,
0.3714188039302826,
0.10885045677423477,
0.6866222023963928,
-0.2828799784183502,
0.0592665933072567,
0.5736413598060608,
-0.11427448689937592,
0.6741612553596497,
0.3739582896232605,
0.16329309344291687,
-0.54344642162323,
0.8850061297416687,
-0.08139259368181229,
0.15125447511672974,
0.6243425011634827,
0.20217478275299072,
-0.12520338594913483,
-0.782885730266571,
-0.24132566154003143,
-0.038793664425611496,
-0.6583393812179565,
-0.5227395296096802,
-0.720393717288971,
-0.5427423715591431,
-0.5521137118339539,
-0.2500191926956177,
0.06835100799798965,
-0.08170587569475174,
-0.23953327536582947,
-0.13612587749958038,
0.5405942797660828,
0.9598805904388428,
0.09670671075582504,
0.40786969661712646,
-0.8935122489929199,
0.16274429857730865,
0.3440488278865814,
-0.11221648007631302,
-0.06646239757537842,
-0.16563349962234497,
-0.19198428094387054,
0.05789019912481308,
-0.26216593384742737,
-1.0357328653335571,
0.2908407747745514,
-0.20434200763702393,
0.3613308072090149,
0.4036785662174225,
0.3113138973712921,
0.6579139828681946,
-0.06701591610908508,
0.764025866985321,
0.09268955886363983,
-0.7318634390830994,
0.6771512627601624,
-0.440166711807251,
0.2143876552581787,
0.39649006724357605,
0.4377925395965576,
-0.13863182067871094,
-0.15576842427253723,
-0.48636043071746826,
-0.6544884443283081,
0.6843894124031067,
0.19335855543613434,
-0.18761084973812103,
-0.12264461815357208,
0.30959704518318176,
-0.20723551511764526,
0.10982268303632736,
-0.558198869228363,
-0.06467664986848831,
-0.007129103876650333,
-0.3316669464111328,
0.18280819058418274,
-0.14649862051010132,
-0.27684667706489563,
0.13783462345600128,
0.6190233826637268,
-0.2703590393066406,
0.2957318425178528,
-0.18946243822574615,
-0.038387540727853775,
0.30406200885772705,
0.16797061264514923,
0.2027389407157898,
0.4786924421787262,
0.02238675020635128,
0.1607881784439087,
0.4113033711910248,
-0.6741649508476257,
-0.12025906890630722,
0.1287861466407776,
0.015611755661666393,
-0.48853200674057007,
0.6942323446273804,
0.45056259632110596,
-0.11853328347206116,
-0.8563652038574219,
0.6322622299194336,
0.08885543048381805,
0.054542362689971924,
-0.49187612533569336,
0.16838131844997406,
-0.4563938081264496,
0.5110164284706116,
0.10526358336210251,
-0.19948667287826538,
0.023141158744692802,
-0.3989850580692291,
-0.04626365005970001,
0.5024170279502869,
-0.5082055330276489,
-0.3356039226055145,
0.25762179493904114,
0.25499439239501953,
-0.20453524589538574,
0.9464309215545654,
-0.12442926317453384,
-0.47422319650650024,
0.6892948746681213,
0.6174759864807129,
0.9054489135742188,
-0.0780850425362587,
0.1958303600549698,
0.1006607711315155,
0.44491222500801086,
0.3132324516773224,
0.1498560905456543,
0.09503191709518433,
-0.5943077206611633,
-0.23320497572422028,
-0.2189721316099167,
-0.06042913347482681,
0.4155946671962738,
-0.5114015936851501,
0.41696131229400635,
-0.5510016679763794,
0.05581222474575043,
0.10043630003929138,
-0.22927185893058777,
-0.7571159601211548,
0.11991477757692337,
0.02651597186923027,
0.9508816599845886,
-0.6636450290679932,
0.5691196918487549,
0.6108180284500122,
-0.0909726545214653,
-0.8755704164505005,
0.06860488653182983,
0.3417740762233734,
-0.8735082745552063,
0.6726961135864258,
0.24824082851409912,
-0.21231584250926971,
-0.002356048906221986,
-0.6815862655639648,
-1.0388226509094238,
1.240591287612915,
0.13213282823562622,
-0.1586497575044632,
-0.08318386226892471,
0.3582850992679596,
0.39301103353500366,
-0.366474449634552,
0.24124044179916382,
0.5178487300872803,
0.5167493224143982,
-0.06583037972450256,
-0.44532933831214905,
0.189847931265831,
-0.38336655497550964,
-0.2072817087173462,
0.4730706512928009,
-0.4922824203968048,
0.2616317570209503,
-0.04900503531098366,
-0.3679777681827545,
-0.1617799699306488,
0.6954136490821838,
0.058839429169893265,
0.41316112875938416,
0.7117172479629517,
0.56687331199646,
0.5643529891967773,
0.08977501094341278,
0.9105987548828125,
-0.3375987410545349,
-0.2556782066822052,
0.8538196086883545,
-0.08954291045665741,
0.673750638961792,
-0.051560305058956146,
0.10545213520526886,
0.5590295791625977,
0.5063557624816895,
-0.10262111574411392,
0.27863335609436035,
0.015008455142378807,
-0.24306245148181915,
-0.30859804153442383,
-0.24935272336006165,
0.045591600239276886,
0.8306256532669067,
0.5284907221794128,
-0.2798102796077728,
-0.2990841567516327,
0.013427022844552994,
0.3153991103172302,
-0.2546044588088989,
-0.33497142791748047,
0.9830072522163391,
-0.23358997702598572,
-0.48401695489883423,
0.30066201090812683,
0.20653407275676727,
0.12488724291324615,
-0.5923188328742981,
-0.1009393036365509,
0.30991849303245544,
-0.2010454386472702,
-0.09595537930727005,
-0.7378289103507996,
0.38038399815559387,
0.2877970039844513,
-0.19536495208740234,
-0.09744046628475189,
0.8134009838104248,
-0.03244766220450401,
-0.2695588767528534,
0.27005788683891296,
0.26199114322662354,
0.007675299420952797,
-0.22198602557182312,
-0.5296748876571655,
-0.0749775841832161,
0.07771867513656616,
0.0039125909097492695,
0.22359712421894073,
0.3328324854373932,
-0.20657506585121155,
0.8265069127082825,
0.7092733383178711,
-0.12496578693389893,
-0.2602076232433319,
-0.17334328591823578,
1.1341428756713867,
-0.5659840106964111,
-0.3479686975479126,
-0.9424857497215271,
0.5033255219459534,
-0.5193219184875488,
-0.32419466972351074,
0.5570942163467407,
0.4404660165309906,
0.4496881663799286,
0.19570402801036835,
0.894534170627594,
-0.31496453285217285,
0.23665964603424072,
-0.6067495346069336,
0.4381508231163025,
-0.12222276628017426,
0.34069153666496277,
-0.11052504181861877,
-0.5945343375205994,
-0.32431796193122864,
-0.33359095454216003,
-0.41420403122901917,
-0.17154377698898315,
0.5493792295455933,
0.8885142207145691,
0.035143814980983734,
0.18441395461559296,
0.06262002140283585,
0.25663188099861145,
0.541724443435669,
0.3886997699737549,
0.6244829893112183,
-0.2519690990447998,
0.866658627986908,
-0.06880704313516617,
-0.4384228587150574,
-0.1716688871383667,
-0.9223217964172363,
-1.1144599914550781,
-0.4676109850406647,
-0.43231090903282166,
-0.36787891387939453,
0.1953665018081665,
0.7703056335449219,
0.6870760321617126,
-0.6372215151786804,
0.104946568608284,
-0.1377851665019989,
0.13558714091777802,
-0.08400215208530426,
-0.27721861004829407,
0.4910910725593567,
-0.22603261470794678,
-0.23849964141845703,
0.8565554022789001,
0.2821348309516907,
0.0981847494840622,
-0.0053694299422204494,
0.4218449592590332,
0.03881297633051872,
0.11110221594572067,
0.7772040367126465,
0.23630166053771973,
-0.4927976727485657,
-0.5794314742088318,
-0.017993753775954247,
0.12870977818965912,
-0.38501468300819397,
0.8684714436531067,
-0.745060384273529,
0.3596693277359009,
0.6019561290740967,
0.8535272479057312,
-0.038705844432115555,
0.014437474310398102,
0.7016717195510864,
-0.8165691494941711,
-0.2478809952735901,
0.016312235966324806,
0.17832084000110626,
0.0406016930937767,
-0.5860738754272461,
0.6636382937431335,
0.22739769518375397,
-0.24166566133499146,
-0.6143227815628052,
0.48435911536216736,
-0.8896364569664001,
-0.45375990867614746,
1.289746880531311,
-0.0829579159617424,
-0.12025010585784912,
-0.4198123812675476,
0.04311516508460045,
0.3396420478820801,
-0.12505516409873962,
0.910504162311554,
0.4373643100261688,
-0.012670814990997314,
0.2042902559041977,
-0.2458128184080124,
0.23009265959262848,
-0.14422884583473206,
-1.179445743560791,
0.31829899549484253,
0.4275490641593933,
-0.10265003889799118,
0.3484850823879242,
0.14800810813903809,
-0.17767398059368134,
-0.06423252820968628,
-0.014044993557035923,
-0.0034997984766960144,
-0.24159201979637146,
-0.6024622321128845,
-0.14511218667030334,
0.5667882561683655,
-0.2517756521701813,
-0.07071904838085175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00668v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00668v2 | HRDE: Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models for Chinese Health Rumor Detection and Explainability | 2024-06-30T11:27:50 | 2024-07-03T15:18:40 | Yanfang Chen, Ding Chen, Shichao Song, Simin Niu, Hanyu Wang, Zeyun Tang, Feiyu Xiong, Zhiyu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | As people increasingly prioritize their health, the speed and breadth of
health information dissemination on the internet have also grown. At the same
time, the presence of false health information (health rumors) intermingled
with genuine content poses a significant potential threat to public health.
However, current research on Chinese health rumors still lacks a large-scale,
public, and open-source dataset of health rumor information, as well as
effective and reliable rumor detection methods. This paper addresses this gap
by constructing a dataset containing 1.12 million health-related rumors
(HealthRCN) through web scraping of common health-related questions and a
series of data processing steps. HealthRCN is the largest known dataset of
Chinese health information rumors to date. Based on this dataset, we propose
retrieval-augmented large language models for Chinese health rumor detection
and explainability (HRDE). This model leverages retrieved relevant information
to accurately determine whether the input health information is a rumor and
provides explanatory responses, effectively aiding users in verifying the
authenticity of health information. In evaluation experiments, we compared
multiple models and found that HRDE outperformed them all, including
GPT-4-1106-Preview, in rumor detection accuracy and answer quality. HRDE
achieved an average accuracy of 91.04% and an F1 score of 91.58%. | [
0.10661263018846512,
-0.8598729372024536,
0.8059576749801636,
0.19034646451473236,
-0.2259880155324936,
-0.22267034649848938,
-0.3954471945762634,
-0.8148609399795532,
0.612634539604187,
0.42639797925949097,
-0.32724034786224365,
-0.5343748331069946,
-0.32261109352111816,
-0.07757304608821869,
-0.4162501096725464,
0.9384362101554871,
0.1347040832042694,
0.10887434333562851,
0.23129649460315704,
0.00297542498447001,
0.08372051268815994,
-0.46597352623939514,
-0.6129847168922424,
0.0742066279053688,
0.8848839402198792,
0.3862532675266266,
0.8995600342750549,
0.6874943375587463,
0.45899227261543274,
0.07375246286392212,
-0.263886958360672,
0.1934487670660019,
-0.20490321516990662,
0.2833855152130127,
-0.2940762937068939,
-0.19580554962158203,
-0.5242936015129089,
-0.12435343116521835,
0.5333421230316162,
0.4326696991920471,
-0.41612058877944946,
0.38355883955955505,
-0.14523322880268097,
0.48868972063064575,
-0.5885617136955261,
-0.16810013353824615,
-0.476059228181839,
0.08242673426866531,
-0.6103972792625427,
-0.1283547580242157,
-0.2707039415836334,
-0.39981070160865784,
0.3355502784252167,
-0.5500442981719971,
0.11733872443437576,
0.1608077585697174,
0.947625994682312,
0.11601176857948303,
-0.35161229968070984,
-0.1539674550294876,
-0.6530976295471191,
0.3613746762275696,
-0.8929780721664429,
0.5603376030921936,
0.4626462161540985,
0.4911990463733673,
0.028192827478051186,
-0.8937095403671265,
-0.6463029384613037,
-0.3067399859428406,
0.023784177377820015,
0.09917589277029037,
-0.35348260402679443,
-0.03209056332707405,
0.3188634216785431,
0.42777392268180847,
-1.063464879989624,
-0.032151754945516586,
-0.29406487941741943,
-0.4209614396095276,
0.4503379464149475,
-0.26383623480796814,
0.7340629696846008,
-0.6050010323524475,
-0.255404531955719,
0.05110917612910271,
-0.7686312794685364,
-0.2757941782474518,
0.08723681420087814,
0.11066564917564392,
-0.12991151213645935,
0.45368823409080505,
-0.3657924234867096,
0.47122520208358765,
-0.1502983272075653,
-0.3736363649368286,
0.4278099834918976,
-0.3167748749256134,
-0.14007386565208435,
0.3007224500179291,
0.635838508605957,
0.30523261427879333,
-0.26555120944976807,
-0.3406568765640259,
-0.03987039253115654,
-0.24657616019248962,
0.1201578751206398,
-0.8181395530700684,
-0.23632708191871643,
0.5129199624061584,
-0.9283152222633362,
-0.16998866200447083,
0.2339901626110077,
-0.9104429483413696,
-0.7097019553184509,
0.1766902506351471,
0.3174096345901489,
-0.3736312687397003,
-0.5841293931007385,
0.0675320103764534,
-0.26344671845436096,
-0.03584470972418785,
0.3649319112300873,
-0.1526547223329544,
-0.1090509220957756,
0.5245486497879028,
0.8194570541381836,
-0.17768464982509613,
-0.06708827614784241,
-0.6613715887069702,
0.14887353777885437,
-0.33608031272888184,
0.9038227200508118,
-0.4111775755882263,
-0.008750464767217636,
0.01975143887102604,
0.20340487360954285,
0.04192519187927246,
-0.6913937926292419,
1.1630951166152954,
-0.675144612789154,
0.27233314514160156,
-0.5778344869613647,
-0.2710411548614502,
-0.11447670310735703,
0.4364330768585205,
-0.8341845273971558,
0.6870844960212708,
0.015750903636217117,
-1.2669243812561035,
0.06924477219581604,
-0.44906607270240784,
-0.5863354206085205,
0.11952093988656998,
0.40306276082992554,
-0.33023348450660706,
-0.09440336376428604,
0.355157732963562,
0.1609126478433609,
-0.545318603515625,
0.1581912636756897,
-0.247115358710289,
-0.2795240581035614,
0.27371737360954285,
-0.7775304913520813,
0.8746709227561951,
0.5738645792007446,
-0.15149079263210297,
0.16275736689567566,
-0.49726778268814087,
0.036950573325157166,
0.019041674211621284,
-0.28076934814453125,
-0.5571925640106201,
-0.04915103688836098,
-0.06716964393854141,
0.365852952003479,
0.26555994153022766,
-0.6101303696632385,
-0.12712055444717407,
-0.4302789270877838,
0.3646881878376007,
0.2806604504585266,
0.3262055516242981,
-0.21661688387393951,
-0.5874289870262146,
0.448454886674881,
0.15619604289531708,
0.5142884254455566,
-0.22139841318130493,
-0.5759618282318115,
-0.3296516239643097,
0.11390836536884308,
0.31265705823898315,
0.40638840198516846,
-1.0647590160369873,
0.21852006018161774,
-0.38265034556388855,
-0.5583010315895081,
-0.6780829429626465,
-0.19754904508590698,
0.26757320761680603,
0.9230653047561646,
0.49135303497314453,
0.2732391357421875,
-0.4830075204372406,
-0.8841712474822998,
-0.5948947072029114,
-0.39662259817123413,
-0.1043369397521019,
0.17133207619190216,
0.14626552164554596,
-0.30094191431999207,
0.474435418844223,
-0.4310731887817383,
-0.060075391083955765,
-0.19846388697624207,
0.16867026686668396,
0.21788974106311798,
0.09958064556121826,
0.4721614718437195,
-1.2026927471160889,
-0.379853218793869,
0.008940659463405609,
-0.5952773094177246,
-0.04271218180656433,
0.20128853619098663,
-0.1657809168100357,
0.017154745757579803,
0.2074873149394989,
-0.3601599633693695,
0.5767756104469299,
0.6579981446266174,
-0.291363924741745,
0.9223614931106567,
-0.3149123787879944,
0.33200591802597046,
-1.2304149866104126,
0.15275773406028748,
0.28632447123527527,
-0.2302798330783844,
-0.5571244359016418,
0.18931327760219574,
0.10038760304450989,
-0.024775339290499687,
-0.44096991419792175,
0.6639695167541504,
-0.40945500135421753,
0.1415361911058426,
-0.5297412872314453,
0.04769188165664673,
-0.07271945476531982,
0.03280092775821686,
0.10546746850013733,
0.5876504778862,
0.4951643645763397,
-0.5731170773506165,
0.6784783601760864,
-0.0731487050652504,
-0.6730037331581116,
0.36353224515914917,
-0.6975763440132141,
-0.1374165117740631,
-0.06472814083099365,
0.4861268103122711,
-0.5848076343536377,
-0.5752820372581482,
0.3409029245376587,
-0.5938317775726318,
-0.44979262351989746,
-0.06137223169207573,
-0.7363336682319641,
-0.9391027688980103,
-0.23281608521938324,
0.25462326407432556,
0.5129310488700867,
-0.8061324954032898,
0.16894936561584473,
0.5681977868080139,
-0.16959212720394135,
-0.6030848026275635,
-0.6118474006652832,
0.17911796271800995,
-0.11766587942838669,
-0.6908073425292969,
0.3812018632888794,
-0.11079408973455429,
-0.3189350962638855,
0.37122637033462524,
-0.26792722940444946,
-0.5068328380584717,
-0.05240178108215332,
0.16382496058940887,
0.3709380030632019,
-0.4034838378429413,
0.4081098139286041,
-0.1898246556520462,
0.3354727625846863,
0.14685213565826416,
-0.0844338983297348,
0.3707118034362793,
0.1548813432455063,
-0.4478415548801422,
-0.539828360080719,
0.010242518968880177,
0.6498175859451294,
-0.33299317955970764,
0.9827061891555786,
0.6315501928329468,
-0.7563685178756714,
-0.0011740387417376041,
-0.7873344421386719,
-0.1659023016691208,
-0.382822185754776,
0.4727403223514557,
0.06347151845693588,
-0.4439249336719513,
0.3407459259033203,
0.10921238362789154,
-0.09710643440485,
0.48743927478790283,
0.4451282024383545,
0.061605505645275116,
0.9733754992485046,
0.22830542922019958,
-0.17577408254146576,
0.08913745731115341,
0.36409011483192444,
0.10513744503259659,
-0.6175708174705505,
-0.15323549509048462,
-0.4560692608356476,
-0.06261665374040604,
-0.5053309798240662,
-0.6140716671943665,
0.7292675375938416,
-0.24681805074214935,
-0.18397605419158936,
0.14308136701583862,
-0.43129557371139526,
0.1411069929599762,
0.47277557849884033,
0.7028915286064148,
0.5922278165817261,
-0.07878737896680832,
0.034073490649461746,
0.05694751441478729,
-0.6107167601585388,
-0.06851725280284882,
0.6973028779029846,
0.5025078654289246,
0.8152422308921814,
0.16894489526748657,
0.14280183613300323,
0.45403212308883667,
0.24297983944416046,
-0.49645939469337463,
0.21307116746902466,
-0.2198466807603836,
-0.7093577980995178,
-0.40023794770240784,
-0.6569414138793945,
-0.7808135151863098,
0.17081566154956818,
-0.35592174530029297,
-0.5527324676513672,
0.1585792899131775,
0.12243186682462692,
-0.5143304467201233,
0.5912232398986816,
-0.5001636147499084,
0.47108423709869385,
-0.26471996307373047,
-0.2135910540819168,
-0.3429732918739319,
-0.6756173372268677,
0.6881563067436218,
-0.07308196276426315,
0.46786269545555115,
-0.06395678967237473,
0.3710099160671234,
0.7985448241233826,
-0.6235690116882324,
0.4436289370059967,
-0.03713984787464142,
-0.2469654679298401,
0.3308204114437103,
-0.13067643344402313,
0.48425447940826416,
0.17669065296649933,
-0.5394653081893921,
0.03006150759756565,
0.13114044070243835,
-0.295955091714859,
-0.44209471344947815,
0.7498881220817566,
-0.37514379620552063,
-0.6430290341377258,
-0.42929911613464355,
-0.35805243253707886,
-0.1419311761856079,
0.2910560369491577,
0.30622318387031555,
0.3474873900413513,
-0.18443402647972107,
-0.002996399998664856,
0.6211675405502319,
-0.7398873567581177,
0.08929336816072464,
0.5726758241653442,
-0.2731155455112457,
-0.17442438006401062,
0.912331223487854,
0.18074321746826172,
-0.025364495813846588,
0.30552294850349426,
0.5200932621955872,
-0.15707014501094818,
-0.01784869283437729,
-0.20199620723724365,
0.6045626997947693,
-0.41482627391815186,
-0.018431685864925385,
-0.5392470359802246,
-0.7830744981765747,
-0.6568061709403992,
0.5108823776245117,
-0.2802160978317261,
-0.12512968480587006,
0.06497322022914886,
-0.18995852768421173,
0.36302533745765686,
0.7523054480552673,
-0.21931982040405273,
0.007758254185318947,
-1.020025372505188,
0.607014000415802,
0.26383811235427856,
0.4609699845314026,
0.30242177844047546,
-0.5558611750602722,
-0.48767420649528503,
0.5733579993247986,
0.05028139427304268,
-1.1469736099243164,
0.5731752514839172,
-0.32531967759132385,
0.4852655231952667,
0.7695515751838684,
0.547118604183197,
0.6123989820480347,
-0.4714178442955017,
0.7595389485359192,
0.10728099197149277,
-0.6008415818214417,
0.5317599177360535,
-0.31504538655281067,
-0.023379556834697723,
0.18469838798046112,
0.4180028438568115,
-1.0305131673812866,
-0.12583334743976593,
-0.6355674862861633,
-0.5582393407821655,
0.4895978271961212,
-0.12209531664848328,
-0.14347673952579498,
-0.05024310201406479,
0.3651471734046936,
-0.015836557373404503,
-0.05892359837889671,
-0.5687785148620605,
-0.45896315574645996,
-0.06682470440864563,
0.11624082922935486,
0.5605258941650391,
-0.7378499507904053,
-0.042156610637903214,
-0.27198511362075806,
0.6889155507087708,
0.24079769849777222,
0.18894681334495544,
0.38065391778945923,
-0.10832628607749939,
-0.2570999562740326,
0.5325562357902527,
0.4611693322658539,
0.8476824760437012,
-0.3365629315376282,
0.4760466516017914,
-0.20050998032093048,
-0.6992369294166565,
-0.2015959471464157,
0.14337186515331268,
-0.044379957020282745,
0.40511974692344666,
0.4269295036792755,
0.6850581169128418,
-0.026513658463954926,
-0.9306750893592834,
0.75950026512146,
0.0009179958724416792,
-0.04330781102180481,
-0.30269917845726013,
-0.1585124135017395,
0.0877331867814064,
0.026074878871440887,
0.5642284154891968,
-0.13007144629955292,
0.3602776527404785,
-0.7267656922340393,
0.37040767073631287,
0.16707763075828552,
-0.6097087860107422,
-0.5586283206939697,
0.8396355509757996,
0.05217277258634567,
0.16649578511714935,
0.7800149917602539,
-0.09802813082933426,
-0.5315312743186951,
0.4567800462245941,
0.4324266016483307,
0.4297557771205902,
-0.5256484150886536,
0.6176117062568665,
0.6214681267738342,
0.2971510887145996,
-0.5454115867614746,
0.17589205503463745,
0.5104661583900452,
-0.6301600933074951,
-0.5993954539299011,
-0.28614896535873413,
-0.30461180210113525,
0.3380507528781891,
-0.7010523676872253,
0.2014172077178955,
0.10125387459993362,
-0.06951681524515152,
-0.0933375135064125,
-0.21499282121658325,
-0.2443704903125763,
0.24661661684513092,
0.36427566409111023,
1.2116602659225464,
-0.6256458759307861,
1.0493406057357788,
0.5877414345741272,
-0.4745842516422272,
-0.9810143113136292,
0.8294095396995544,
-0.05118213966488838,
-0.8737833499908447,
0.6475923657417297,
-0.061067670583724976,
0.32130882143974304,
-0.3366829454898834,
-0.6336248517036438,
-0.9023588299751282,
0.9331518411636353,
0.5679321885108948,
-0.5214798450469971,
-0.5606351494789124,
-0.1676730513572693,
0.4332212209701538,
0.14759886264801025,
0.32810917496681213,
0.33543655276298523,
0.9121739268302917,
0.3295469582080841,
-1.3051786422729492,
0.09742088615894318,
-0.015349970199167728,
-0.3385717570781708,
-0.39673420786857605,
-0.8027501702308655,
1.0048680305480957,
-0.5346260666847229,
-0.3100048899650574,
0.03657450154423714,
0.7307041883468628,
0.3358105421066284,
0.41176649928092957,
0.6290769577026367,
0.4573887288570404,
1.1695197820663452,
0.19851432740688324,
1.2169809341430664,
-0.30843305587768555,
0.14676892757415771,
1.033697247505188,
-0.37585359811782837,
0.6910462379455566,
-0.1513715237379074,
0.007499299012124538,
0.7696002721786499,
0.675102949142456,
0.26788610219955444,
0.36716410517692566,
0.03154832497239113,
-0.3177993893623352,
-0.27087607979774475,
-0.4930664896965027,
-0.48005059361457825,
0.16889792680740356,
0.33993804454803467,
-0.5255913734436035,
-0.5251491665840149,
0.43290385603904724,
0.2658475637435913,
0.01584945060312748,
-0.4550967514514923,
0.32024085521698,
-0.07786532491445541,
-0.4555935561656952,
0.34041357040405273,
0.09656968712806702,
0.6665029525756836,
-0.4023597240447998,
-0.31643617153167725,
-0.03523815795779228,
-0.0878801941871643,
-0.27481144666671753,
-0.7211023569107056,
0.15167218446731567,
-0.07228615134954453,
-0.38160261511802673,
0.21889716386795044,
0.8697036504745483,
-0.6267827749252319,
-0.3888424038887024,
0.14444145560264587,
0.7089383006095886,
0.34380149841308594,
-0.531863272190094,
-0.7283337116241455,
-0.04603008180856705,
0.01370393205434084,
-0.18436546623706818,
0.228985995054245,
0.7515140771865845,
-0.2604733109474182,
0.7790188193321228,
0.6404392719268799,
0.7496708035469055,
-0.2118237316608429,
-0.12872298061847687,
0.6526207327842712,
-0.6116592288017273,
-0.647788405418396,
-0.7349351048469543,
-0.1499556303024292,
-0.2553344666957855,
0.11986830085515976,
0.9737026691436768,
0.561860978603363,
0.2077554166316986,
0.21342793107032776,
0.9980604648590088,
0.029850343242287636,
1.2876776456832886,
-0.417194128036499,
1.315575361251831,
-0.5356211066246033,
0.2981022596359253,
-0.1116400733590126,
-0.4498535394668579,
-0.1347765028476715,
0.3450019359588623,
-0.3184248208999634,
0.04890187457203865,
0.8953049778938293,
0.570248544216156,
-0.015074804425239563,
0.06767203658819199,
0.20110534131526947,
0.7785547971725464,
0.3485798239707947,
0.349674254655838,
0.5634668469429016,
-0.23588746786117554,
0.5964446067810059,
-0.3057059049606323,
-0.11547181755304337,
-0.4052843749523163,
-0.7778830528259277,
-0.5213203430175781,
-0.5862342119216919,
-0.28109872341156006,
-0.7694422602653503,
0.3446504771709442,
0.9129815101623535,
0.8173267841339111,
-0.6029629111289978,
0.2641678750514984,
0.4827020466327667,
0.44667285680770874,
-0.32758185267448425,
-0.3064032793045044,
0.8478603959083557,
0.15761275589466095,
-0.4183720052242279,
0.4133481979370117,
0.038911838084459305,
-0.21423734724521637,
-0.14494697749614716,
0.08597750216722488,
-0.0898948684334755,
0.01076881866902113,
0.37078431248664856,
0.6910056471824646,
-0.7126156091690063,
-0.31346651911735535,
0.20775920152664185,
-0.4078601598739624,
-0.19509443640708923,
0.6880654692649841,
-0.8397419452667236,
0.3613242208957672,
0.2959466576576233,
0.5551975965499878,
0.015034878626465797,
0.25743818283081055,
0.41283291578292847,
-0.5212609171867371,
0.06583935022354126,
0.09495112299919128,
0.3109589219093323,
0.21839705109596252,
-0.6750077605247498,
0.385126531124115,
0.21310700476169586,
-0.4533142149448395,
-0.8395413756370544,
-0.22974462807178497,
-0.9405538439750671,
-0.6538059711456299,
1.4787156581878662,
0.016352299600839615,
-0.6441071033477783,
-0.20877093076705933,
-0.16996997594833374,
0.3261488974094391,
-0.4273383319377899,
0.7721462845802307,
0.5945093035697937,
-0.04506956413388252,
-0.07651178538799286,
-0.7466150522232056,
0.5920026302337646,
-0.11304464936256409,
-0.9037290811538696,
0.3312772214412689,
0.4314655065536499,
0.4595911502838135,
-0.009806869551539421,
0.684285581111908,
-0.16788911819458008,
0.6438118815422058,
-0.36038830876350403,
0.23790866136550903,
-0.013249780051410198,
-0.13668806850910187,
0.32420793175697327,
0.08932667970657349,
-0.03913566470146179,
-0.008004123345017433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00653v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00653v1 | Chain-of-Knowledge: Integrating Knowledge Reasoning into Large Language Models by Learning from Knowledge Graphs | 2024-06-30T10:49:32 | 2024-06-30T10:49:32 | Yifei Zhang, Xintao Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Sirui Xia, Lida Chen, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive proficiency in various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, which involve increasingly complex
reasoning. Knowledge reasoning, a primary type of reasoning, aims at deriving
new knowledge from existing one.While it has been widely studied in the context
of knowledge graphs (KGs), knowledge reasoning in LLMs remains underexplored.
In this paper, we introduce Chain-of-Knowledge, a comprehensive framework for
knowledge reasoning, including methodologies for both dataset construction and
model learning. For dataset construction, we create KnowReason via rule mining
on KGs. For model learning, we observe rule overfitting induced by naive
training. Hence, we enhance CoK with a trial-and-error mechanism that simulates
the human process of internal knowledge exploration. We conduct extensive
experiments with KnowReason. Our results show the effectiveness of CoK in
refining LLMs in not only knowledge reasoning, but also general reasoning
benchmarkms. | [
-0.33108237385749817,
-0.7738327383995056,
0.7965695858001709,
-0.4074351489543915,
0.028391359373927116,
0.3412252962589264,
-0.1058235615491867,
-0.31230753660202026,
-0.11136393994092941,
0.7736948132514954,
-0.4593476355075836,
-0.6959699392318726,
-0.3356941342353821,
-0.11331819742918015,
-0.24779260158538818,
0.7805922031402588,
-0.3029162287712097,
-0.11140795797109604,
-0.44143328070640564,
0.04021191969513893,
-0.0786142498254776,
-0.7953971028327942,
-0.6074368953704834,
-0.6204443573951721,
0.6843054294586182,
0.3440437614917755,
0.5523601770401001,
0.6994701623916626,
0.18828749656677246,
0.17179694771766663,
-0.010634632781147957,
0.8259079456329346,
-0.4706697463989258,
0.13419580459594727,
-0.5475959777832031,
-0.4474374055862427,
-0.4388953149318695,
-0.22567583620548248,
0.44498685002326965,
0.977627158164978,
-0.18954628705978394,
-0.01348460279405117,
0.08311496675014496,
0.9166428446769714,
-0.6622105240821838,
0.25526005029678345,
-0.6476343870162964,
-0.18701893091201782,
-0.03224104270339012,
-0.02712344378232956,
-0.4931696653366089,
-0.3844909071922302,
0.31054919958114624,
-0.6977714896202087,
-0.2764529287815094,
0.4451017677783966,
0.46739158034324646,
0.1261444389820099,
-0.6741446852684021,
-0.5882992148399353,
-0.6164369583129883,
0.691357433795929,
-0.5740500092506409,
0.6748948693275452,
0.5136491656303406,
0.42820310592651367,
-0.4668566584587097,
-0.7528672814369202,
-0.5572871565818787,
-0.09967871010303497,
-0.1585031896829605,
-0.1344798505306244,
-0.065026193857193,
0.1733405441045761,
0.3048848807811737,
0.4379623234272003,
-0.4500761330127716,
-0.030288904905319214,
-0.15245461463928223,
0.0013639654498547316,
0.6455098986625671,
0.0012687226990237832,
0.1465516984462738,
-0.08234772086143494,
-0.36132413148880005,
0.031671252101659775,
-0.858707070350647,
-0.12730367481708527,
0.4046037793159485,
0.13204309344291687,
0.16057170927524567,
0.42118513584136963,
-0.6120267510414124,
1.0736749172210693,
-0.24404609203338623,
-0.17399707436561584,
-0.03325388580560684,
-0.13313153386116028,
-0.3128952085971832,
0.0649699717760086,
0.5906131267547607,
0.06978068500757217,
0.5046669840812683,
-0.5317363142967224,
-0.05224842205643654,
-0.1239880919456482,
0.04172759875655174,
-0.3091787099838257,
-0.3585415482521057,
-0.016146276146173477,
-0.1878107786178589,
-0.3463771343231201,
0.02894073911011219,
-0.35183238983154297,
-0.35731154680252075,
-0.39694344997406006,
0.3298758268356323,
-0.4724820852279663,
-0.2964034080505371,
0.36205559968948364,
-0.2635209560394287,
0.030265668407082558,
0.25408634543418884,
-0.5441483855247498,
0.6171687841415405,
0.6758848428726196,
0.4974033534526825,
0.04925016686320305,
-0.32418084144592285,
-0.4179483652114868,
0.5406233072280884,
-0.46891963481903076,
0.6809932589530945,
-0.2841367721557617,
0.13386619091033936,
-0.03755652904510498,
-0.3276132345199585,
0.04997013509273529,
-0.4790884256362915,
0.34114310145378113,
-0.880938708782196,
-0.01472509279847145,
-0.48093849420547485,
-0.9619598984718323,
-0.45186126232147217,
0.6051778793334961,
-0.46474018692970276,
0.9434186816215515,
0.13978612422943115,
-0.8307056427001953,
0.3966265320777893,
-0.622231125831604,
-0.5865066647529602,
-0.05823010578751564,
-0.04515354335308075,
0.08713661879301071,
-0.2872813940048218,
0.2894308567047119,
0.5076342225074768,
-0.5215550065040588,
0.47613129019737244,
-0.6300111413002014,
0.012101405300199986,
0.2492777556180954,
-0.03416658565402031,
0.617146372795105,
0.40554600954055786,
0.1740996539592743,
-0.15342244505882263,
-0.8348472714424133,
0.19934646785259247,
0.03151175007224083,
-0.34261080622673035,
-0.6116049885749817,
0.2375081330537796,
-0.7719433307647705,
0.3120359778404236,
0.01656586490571499,
-0.19787801802158356,
0.5277886986732483,
-0.2841159403324127,
0.620070219039917,
0.5064485669136047,
0.22969646751880646,
0.40159717202186584,
-0.3534015119075775,
0.1961871087551117,
0.040633413940668106,
0.10428109019994736,
0.05213773995637894,
-0.38822516798973083,
-0.7928608059883118,
0.01388806477189064,
0.202370285987854,
0.416980504989624,
-1.0527560710906982,
0.7010784149169922,
-0.11969706416130066,
-0.32101377844810486,
-0.06252142786979675,
0.33649471402168274,
0.14040043950080872,
0.6513746976852417,
0.46884337067604065,
0.03017977997660637,
-0.7568752765655518,
-0.49605104327201843,
-0.3759942352771759,
-0.20770037174224854,
0.10286928713321686,
0.15810838341712952,
0.5140928030014038,
-0.296865314245224,
1.1230450868606567,
-0.8520684242248535,
-0.028817329555749893,
-0.4282914698123932,
-0.10703925788402557,
0.2625008225440979,
0.1929357796907425,
-0.02162102423608303,
-0.4542364478111267,
-0.1949036866426468,
0.18113145232200623,
-1.0593773126602173,
0.1275842934846878,
0.17984402179718018,
-0.36034274101257324,
-0.08157367259263992,
0.8163149356842041,
-0.27971479296684265,
0.21553753316402435,
0.4724962115287781,
-0.22841739654541016,
0.6245993971824646,
-0.2764241099357605,
-0.1071755513548851,
-0.9095056056976318,
0.049000002443790436,
-0.0327797494828701,
-0.5846784710884094,
-0.5762277245521545,
0.17161889374256134,
-0.3477418124675751,
0.08063313364982605,
0.02148326486349106,
0.515394926071167,
-0.3412494361400604,
-0.08659012615680695,
-0.1477103978395462,
0.17322728037834167,
0.2852061986923218,
0.5275864005088806,
0.0875931829214096,
0.27541086077690125,
0.4791150987148285,
-0.861081600189209,
0.7668933868408203,
0.1579742282629013,
-0.6272998452186584,
0.3679339587688446,
-0.3274998366832733,
0.416421502828598,
0.0212029330432415,
0.41641902923583984,
-0.7841136455535889,
-0.17758487164974213,
0.20175428688526154,
-0.0609922893345356,
0.027506854385137558,
-0.40726038813591003,
-0.8104557991027832,
-0.6961188912391663,
0.16669662296772003,
0.18611174821853638,
0.4666599631309509,
-0.8589065074920654,
0.5833573341369629,
0.39712315797805786,
0.17718033492565155,
-0.48681601881980896,
-0.5180997848510742,
-0.08021576702594757,
-0.09009679406881332,
-0.7325473427772522,
0.05023546144366264,
0.18500015139579773,
-0.5073034763336182,
-0.07582873851060867,
-0.1966591626405716,
-0.3185284733772278,
0.00487150065600872,
-0.07427205890417099,
-0.0681212991476059,
0.009861140511929989,
0.5390291213989258,
0.2123878300189972,
0.06676526367664337,
0.11223959177732468,
-0.8381117582321167,
0.6387609243392944,
-0.08307725191116333,
-0.4765896797180176,
-0.16273878514766693,
-0.06274116784334183,
0.38464340567588806,
-0.010841591283679008,
0.6037506461143494,
-0.02985849417746067,
-0.4123516380786896,
-0.4776482880115509,
-0.6234729290008545,
-0.14784996211528778,
-0.4084474444389343,
0.21979920566082,
-0.5288819670677185,
-0.7961327433586121,
0.43697190284729004,
-0.6129940748214722,
-0.36400899291038513,
0.3373089134693146,
0.22079814970493317,
-0.22461414337158203,
0.8381581902503967,
0.37379172444343567,
-0.15199649333953857,
0.01660352572798729,
-0.4856090545654297,
0.2522463798522949,
-0.7180549502372742,
-0.20993934571743011,
-0.2591473162174225,
-0.009822355583310127,
-0.28593483567237854,
-0.4938056766986847,
0.1663302779197693,
0.6037161946296692,
-0.4770466387271881,
0.28780367970466614,
-0.0856396034359932,
0.49789121747016907,
0.43680980801582336,
0.4074990749359131,
0.7665050625801086,
0.01860412210226059,
-0.4596140384674072,
0.46032825112342834,
-1.203089714050293,
-0.33524900674819946,
0.9813212752342224,
0.4041104018688202,
0.8346942067146301,
-0.1857190877199173,
0.6846556663513184,
0.20985348522663116,
0.05719837546348572,
-0.6231459379196167,
0.4516776502132416,
-0.22440844774246216,
-0.4967803955078125,
-0.30976930260658264,
-0.6905605792999268,
-0.4995392858982086,
-0.17635375261306763,
-0.12041668593883514,
-0.6266578435897827,
0.034575626254081726,
0.3660171329975128,
-0.21932485699653625,
0.6405037641525269,
-0.5471896529197693,
0.7055111527442932,
-0.281343549489975,
-0.27085399627685547,
-0.2864533066749573,
-0.5142736434936523,
0.4597187340259552,
0.14940819144248962,
0.5191824436187744,
0.222319558262825,
0.3755429983139038,
0.6992847919464111,
-0.7330236434936523,
0.757885217666626,
-0.04302990809082985,
-0.2919004559516907,
0.6917251348495483,
0.15653963387012482,
0.9236447215080261,
-0.20334948599338531,
-0.0013849190436303616,
0.09749024361371994,
-0.09720910340547562,
-0.15243183076381683,
-0.8276498317718506,
0.49690431356430054,
-0.5496326684951782,
-0.3640378713607788,
-0.09989363700151443,
-0.5175542831420898,
-0.38965359330177307,
0.14388425648212433,
0.03218941390514374,
0.30764785408973694,
0.009649987332522869,
-0.07810048013925552,
0.6382603049278259,
-0.1897590160369873,
-0.2776120603084564,
0.21627525985240936,
-0.6162880063056946,
-0.4883851408958435,
0.8466281890869141,
0.2563914358615875,
0.5217228531837463,
0.516449511051178,
0.5091222524642944,
-0.4196532666683197,
-0.32824286818504333,
-0.15965530276298523,
0.13817213475704193,
-1.0012412071228027,
-0.12763762474060059,
-0.5422424674034119,
-0.4395811855792999,
-0.36907899379730225,
0.08019080758094788,
-0.25880178809165955,
-0.31540727615356445,
0.23305833339691162,
-0.21594198048114777,
0.6274455785751343,
0.9848501086235046,
-0.08047764748334885,
0.13941457867622375,
-0.5642281174659729,
0.27065202593803406,
0.7878265976905823,
0.5342514514923096,
0.312103271484375,
-0.22601452469825745,
-0.39418065547943115,
0.15647652745246887,
-0.025552555918693542,
-0.5846683979034424,
0.0688723474740982,
-0.0788969025015831,
0.5040315389633179,
0.45813438296318054,
0.07592614740133286,
0.7062840461730957,
-0.22940261662006378,
0.32736024260520935,
0.2730008661746979,
-0.9247658252716064,
0.5389284491539001,
-0.4330917000770569,
0.12035875022411346,
0.33999398350715637,
0.5573007464408875,
-0.6720027923583984,
-0.2493952065706253,
-0.6557195782661438,
-0.5949966907501221,
0.4090609848499298,
0.036479752510786057,
-0.47392258048057556,
-0.03343541547656059,
0.5838557481765747,
0.12776263058185577,
0.28846290707588196,
-0.48831188678741455,
-0.01998467929661274,
0.0831671953201294,
-0.2613520920276642,
0.1982993483543396,
-0.18911084532737732,
-0.14136117696762085,
-0.516608476638794,
0.7765423059463501,
-0.30095013976097107,
-0.16513653099536896,
0.20033086836338043,
-0.3866051435470581,
-0.06989506632089615,
0.1606481671333313,
0.08989033848047256,
0.8725275993347168,
-0.16580407321453094,
0.39360660314559937,
0.2832370698451996,
-0.06765727698802948,
-0.07119257748126984,
-0.27991580963134766,
0.07083622366189957,
-0.4700773358345032,
0.5011236667633057,
0.7397474050521851,
0.1398034691810608,
-0.527347207069397,
0.2586689591407776,
0.21183454990386963,
-0.3543187379837036,
-0.20563514530658722,
0.2015308439731598,
0.23892667889595032,
0.3845660388469696,
0.31378746032714844,
-0.07158791273832321,
0.026979250833392143,
-0.7667902708053589,
0.3355659246444702,
0.18542730808258057,
-0.292675256729126,
-0.009845109656453133,
0.19622039794921875,
0.07879932969808578,
0.03807159885764122,
0.7262620329856873,
-0.42060330510139465,
-0.794478714466095,
0.3198751211166382,
0.3132097125053406,
0.3775535821914673,
0.0954819917678833,
-0.05421919748187065,
0.3779294490814209,
0.17791172862052917,
-0.37807056307792664,
0.21851982176303864,
-0.23062686622142792,
-1.1268460750579834,
-0.7597668170928955,
-0.4774928689002991,
-0.43575945496559143,
0.14599354565143585,
-0.4732379615306854,
0.3477519452571869,
-0.49909359216690063,
0.12912175059318542,
-0.20872288942337036,
0.021210167557001114,
-0.6758978962898254,
0.27029475569725037,
0.11844415217638016,
1.007447361946106,
-0.7531920671463013,
1.041130542755127,
0.45542261004447937,
-0.3764304220676422,
-0.9091347455978394,
-0.05791813135147095,
-0.2846560776233673,
-0.893107533454895,
0.972552478313446,
-0.045770540833473206,
-0.012796996161341667,
0.20200037956237793,
-0.6869320273399353,
-0.8239254355430603,
1.0178017616271973,
0.21911662817001343,
-0.8471367359161377,
-0.13833528757095337,
0.12655465304851532,
0.3518466651439667,
-0.48116984963417053,
-0.03167206794023514,
0.7458434700965881,
0.4718931019306183,
0.41481202840805054,
-0.6116397380828857,
0.07137995958328247,
0.23059876263141632,
-0.26962265372276306,
0.15324950218200684,
-0.3507634401321411,
0.7412701845169067,
-0.3107718825340271,
0.07825765758752823,
-0.19649754464626312,
0.5391834378242493,
0.4323996901512146,
0.21972312033176422,
0.7009360790252686,
0.9152032136917114,
1.127805233001709,
0.032850999385118484,
1.0209778547286987,
-0.17114704847335815,
0.3240410089492798,
1.2818584442138672,
-0.4512733817100525,
0.5798389315605164,
0.34644415974617004,
-0.3834306597709656,
1.0302724838256836,
0.370833158493042,
0.15302737057209015,
0.4487069845199585,
0.6339322924613953,
-0.14509637653827667,
-0.6636078953742981,
0.10062996298074722,
-0.1710343360900879,
0.4206543564796448,
0.37842580676078796,
-0.2613941431045532,
-0.19683164358139038,
-0.14548464119434357,
0.08601897954940796,
0.055767565965652466,
-0.43962886929512024,
0.8883650898933411,
0.2502289414405823,
-0.6452904939651489,
0.5126467347145081,
-0.2158147096633911,
0.33978599309921265,
-0.6201174855232239,
-0.14465253055095673,
0.11799564957618713,
0.30158689618110657,
-0.2510615587234497,
-0.799252986907959,
0.31786608695983887,
-0.14909714460372925,
-0.3453022837638855,
-0.08055048435926437,
0.9891766309738159,
-0.5334216356277466,
-0.3295832574367523,
0.5218773484230042,
0.6681815385818481,
0.0544179268181324,
-0.26573672890663147,
-0.4215735197067261,
-0.29669710993766785,
-0.18257944285869598,
-0.000607371621299535,
0.16962577402591705,
0.5991535782814026,
-0.058308955281972885,
0.8533068895339966,
0.758198082447052,
0.13960587978363037,
-0.1512291580438614,
0.2667863667011261,
0.9881570339202881,
-0.5673952102661133,
-0.5744790434837341,
-0.9136484265327454,
0.3282672166824341,
-0.25690919160842896,
0.12333747744560242,
0.6791698336601257,
0.5702182054519653,
0.8877477049827576,
0.056148700416088104,
1.0546329021453857,
-0.036059971898794174,
0.559270977973938,
-0.8065498471260071,
0.6533776521682739,
-0.31546682119369507,
0.1672302633523941,
-0.24345923960208893,
-0.49504807591438293,
-0.17794886231422424,
0.6104862689971924,
-0.6990864872932434,
-0.047012679278850555,
0.8643897771835327,
0.4388624131679535,
0.003730490803718567,
0.08981199562549591,
0.319126695394516,
0.3530762493610382,
0.2609420716762543,
0.6229416131973267,
1.0206509828567505,
-0.3668573200702667,
0.4575601816177368,
-0.2934848964214325,
-0.16527029871940613,
0.07497555017471313,
-0.9909632205963135,
-0.9533736705780029,
-0.48035356402397156,
-0.2987194061279297,
-0.4334048628807068,
0.22360597550868988,
0.8832398056983948,
0.7385163903236389,
-0.546072781085968,
-0.432561993598938,
-0.6034883856773376,
0.684786856174469,
-0.33483466506004333,
-0.15640443563461304,
0.26199328899383545,
-0.4338211715221405,
-0.03842978551983833,
0.4975520074367523,
0.13702289760112762,
-0.23879872262477875,
-0.2772684395313263,
-0.37309005856513977,
-0.6634621024131775,
-0.22566618025302887,
0.7004827857017517,
0.12098225951194763,
-0.2913259267807007,
-0.2499038428068161,
-0.16362830996513367,
0.3502320945262909,
-0.05736902728676796,
1.0936073064804077,
-0.9634031653404236,
0.4239056408405304,
0.5923007726669312,
0.34071430563926697,
0.6466662287712097,
-0.28251659870147705,
0.77511066198349,
-0.8591575026512146,
-0.055304959416389465,
-0.10526363551616669,
0.39818069338798523,
0.23937258124351501,
-0.26260027289390564,
0.5480177998542786,
0.4715692400932312,
-0.46180659532546997,
-0.7967123985290527,
0.5161123871803284,
-0.6291244626045227,
-0.42545661330223083,
1.2595665454864502,
-0.19844365119934082,
-0.2010120004415512,
-0.36891114711761475,
0.10324125736951828,
0.4851221442222595,
-0.18672418594360352,
0.48371973633766174,
0.8680549263954163,
-0.07189424335956573,
0.004412390757352114,
-0.26717817783355713,
0.5350868105888367,
-0.2754316031932831,
-1.022532343864441,
0.23278719186782837,
0.14277906715869904,
0.34168803691864014,
0.09829139709472656,
0.40757930278778076,
0.08231020718812943,
-0.1373959183692932,
-0.13029226660728455,
0.02778194099664688,
-0.2379688173532486,
-0.4490807354450226,
0.13460230827331543,
0.11412781476974487,
0.19001570343971252,
0.3266274333000183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00648v1 | LegalTurk Optimized BERT for Multi-Label Text Classification and NER | 2024-06-30T10:19:54 | 2024-06-30T10:19:54 | Farnaz Zeidi, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali, Çiğdem Erol | cs.CL | cs.CL | The introduction of the Transformer neural network, along with techniques
like self-supervised pre-training and transfer learning, has paved the way for
advanced models like BERT. Despite BERT's impressive performance, opportunities
for further enhancement exist. To our knowledge, most efforts are focusing on
improving BERT's performance in English and in general domains, with no study
specifically addressing the legal Turkish domain. Our study is primarily
dedicated to enhancing the BERT model within the legal Turkish domain through
modifications in the pre-training phase. In this work, we introduce our
innovative modified pre-training approach by combining diverse masking
strategies. In the fine-tuning task, we focus on two essential downstream tasks
in the legal domain: name entity recognition and multi-label text
classification. To evaluate our modified pre-training approach, we fine-tuned
all customized models alongside the original BERT models to compare their
performance. Our modified approach demonstrated significant improvements in
both NER and multi-label text classification tasks compared to the original
BERT model. Finally, to showcase the impact of our proposed models, we trained
our best models with different corpus sizes and compared them with BERTurk
models. The experimental results demonstrate that our innovative approach,
despite being pre-trained on a smaller corpus, competes with BERTurk. | [
-0.693252444267273,
-0.478847861289978,
0.24559643864631653,
-0.054849036037921906,
-0.5527518391609192,
-0.028034653514623642,
-0.37226447463035583,
-0.6290572881698608,
0.2180255502462387,
0.7554278373718262,
-0.4480579197406769,
-0.5031105279922485,
-0.9874147772789001,
0.16368182003498077,
-0.1063062995672226,
1.5281343460083008,
0.20145714282989502,
0.2539224326610565,
0.18669229745864868,
-0.23493270576000214,
-0.3254566490650177,
-0.7303127646446228,
-0.7027089595794678,
-0.36447134613990784,
0.7387623190879822,
0.0762026384472847,
0.28749215602874756,
0.29366636276245117,
0.6489589214324951,
0.30326950550079346,
-0.18410395085811615,
0.01274040061980486,
-0.17351080477237701,
0.21502605080604553,
-0.057672277092933655,
-0.13743862509727478,
-0.4020170271396637,
-0.016177253797650337,
0.6515507698059082,
0.21024391055107117,
-0.04436401650309563,
0.2659566402435303,
0.04235844314098358,
0.5851404666900635,
-0.8311579823493958,
0.09382494539022446,
-0.6089893579483032,
0.10094206780195236,
-0.24195542931556702,
-0.05172012746334076,
-0.6328246593475342,
-0.3368518054485321,
0.30275020003318787,
-0.7682732343673706,
0.40391620993614197,
-0.00951668992638588,
1.1336013078689575,
0.4155653417110443,
-0.5684962272644043,
-0.25916582345962524,
-0.7438461780548096,
0.5710415244102478,
-0.8158819079399109,
0.7323945760726929,
0.20865203440189362,
0.4080958068370819,
-0.22506627440452576,
-1.182116985321045,
-0.6098200678825378,
-0.39313387870788574,
-0.10024203360080719,
0.1566816121339798,
-0.21886888146400452,
0.40922197699546814,
0.2170795053243637,
-0.2886713743209839,
-0.3451341390609741,
0.2522609829902649,
-0.34284934401512146,
-0.4765382409095764,
0.3730863928794861,
-0.20268623530864716,
-0.014544781297445297,
0.07721337676048279,
-0.1918167620897293,
-0.33597201108932495,
-0.4826499819755554,
0.26612189412117004,
0.6540392637252808,
0.4320651888847351,
0.5530925989151001,
0.27252674102783203,
-0.020589448511600494,
0.7556164264678955,
0.1626928746700287,
-0.007909559644758701,
0.19932964444160461,
-0.07679729163646698,
-0.29227280616760254,
0.34115585684776306,
0.6272479891777039,
-0.167871356010437,
-0.06791568547487259,
0.011776699684560299,
-0.27045828104019165,
-0.34554624557495117,
0.6404752731323242,
-0.9309451580047607,
-0.44019657373428345,
-0.08932870626449585,
-0.7610145211219788,
-0.36399221420288086,
0.19861119985580444,
-0.6780211329460144,
-0.5273115634918213,
-0.6075919270515442,
0.8040471076965332,
-0.41534262895584106,
-0.041874971240758896,
0.10903829336166382,
0.1127852350473404,
0.2719731032848358,
0.49280935525894165,
-0.8472597002983093,
0.326975554227829,
0.7153517603874207,
0.31474924087524414,
0.21884213387966156,
0.11538207530975342,
-0.5649285912513733,
-0.010252914391458035,
-0.27265501022338867,
0.7979749441146851,
-0.516000509262085,
0.10753271728754044,
0.08301806449890137,
-0.003068499034270644,
0.11785716563463211,
-0.36863207817077637,
0.804076611995697,
-0.853841245174408,
0.1807955801486969,
-0.2458692342042923,
-0.5916815400123596,
-0.4498785734176636,
0.27730998396873474,
-0.9649292826652527,
0.8470643162727356,
-0.16441018879413605,
-0.9016706347465515,
0.8248674869537354,
-0.8850928544998169,
-0.7176080942153931,
0.2715149223804474,
0.07382743060588837,
-0.9101458787918091,
-0.004186599515378475,
0.35230398178100586,
0.6176742315292358,
0.16254843771457672,
0.33438706398010254,
-0.13506722450256348,
-0.26849207282066345,
0.06569121032953262,
-0.08969879150390625,
0.8491492867469788,
0.41750723123550415,
-0.47914811968803406,
0.38663560152053833,
-0.8298333287239075,
0.006291580386459827,
-0.3107204735279083,
-0.6820219159126282,
-0.375985324382782,
-0.03846374526619911,
0.28700050711631775,
0.3136039972305298,
0.11743701994419098,
-0.6184534430503845,
0.032925840467214584,
-0.32569772005081177,
0.3118920624256134,
0.7094855904579163,
-0.055145151913166046,
0.36017200350761414,
-0.16473041474819183,
0.42687875032424927,
-0.25556480884552,
0.15353122353553772,
0.11085658520460129,
-0.5290437936782837,
-0.9892545938491821,
-0.482937216758728,
1.0724211931228638,
0.4438439905643463,
-0.5633857250213623,
0.5774411559104919,
-0.3159560263156891,
-0.49992409348487854,
-0.8371784687042236,
-0.005618068389594555,
0.1569404900074005,
0.4028845727443695,
0.5135143399238586,
-0.20493744313716888,
-0.7427013516426086,
-1.048169493675232,
-0.4982803463935852,
-0.012902677990496159,
0.04315057769417763,
0.40042272210121155,
0.4936419427394867,
-0.281040221452713,
0.7807072997093201,
-0.0028021177276968956,
-0.6828413605690002,
-0.2802894711494446,
0.4830629229545593,
0.4341113865375519,
0.34829869866371155,
0.5792378187179565,
-0.8645412921905518,
-0.7607654333114624,
0.2387726902961731,
-0.12944774329662323,
-0.0684741884469986,
-0.3179625868797302,
0.04082286357879639,
0.3816013038158417,
0.5737335681915283,
-0.2857220768928528,
0.40011969208717346,
0.12111695855855942,
-0.3036350905895233,
0.667923629283905,
-0.5594027638435364,
0.19673903286457062,
-0.8453532457351685,
0.04233727231621742,
-0.1427282989025116,
-0.442044198513031,
-0.8154823184013367,
-0.039863310754299164,
0.17660017311573029,
0.055594127625226974,
-0.5972750186920166,
0.3362129032611847,
-0.2709731459617615,
0.25269678235054016,
-0.40708127617836,
-0.44182834029197693,
-0.18414361774921417,
0.3718526363372803,
-0.03852023184299469,
0.7573695778846741,
0.34588366746902466,
-0.7546517252922058,
0.2798246145248413,
0.23712094128131866,
-0.4518043100833893,
0.3297559916973114,
-0.4220878481864929,
0.23830056190490723,
-0.3734149634838104,
0.3751938045024872,
-0.7711597084999084,
0.02648751810193062,
0.32370465993881226,
-0.3194376230239868,
0.7157860398292542,
-0.2484067976474762,
-0.6999068856239319,
-0.3871711194515228,
-0.16432394087314606,
0.011493995785713196,
0.6001094579696655,
-0.6493719220161438,
1.2137598991394043,
0.2311481237411499,
-0.25096288323402405,
-0.8566551208496094,
-0.4958198070526123,
0.24490009248256683,
-0.3685323894023895,
-0.46807265281677246,
0.6957341432571411,
0.21983306109905243,
0.1365624964237213,
0.1240852028131485,
-0.19917930662631989,
-0.4323810338973999,
-0.0591602548956871,
-0.024280982092022896,
0.0282455962151289,
-0.22548533976078033,
0.32361412048339844,
0.33373546600341797,
-0.0977674052119255,
0.08596012741327286,
-0.47748544812202454,
0.3207131326198578,
-0.16277961432933807,
0.1634291112422943,
-0.5847258567810059,
-0.01145506277680397,
0.23508986830711365,
-0.47690245509147644,
0.9080252647399902,
0.9598817825317383,
-0.29165220260620117,
-0.1290735900402069,
-0.9536116123199463,
-0.21063348650932312,
-0.499527245759964,
0.4040159285068512,
-0.63006192445755,
-1.0559508800506592,
0.39831337332725525,
-0.3270663321018219,
0.07586593180894852,
0.6183387637138367,
0.5364441275596619,
-0.3765411674976349,
0.5512111186981201,
0.9309133291244507,
-0.05374514311552048,
0.6803402900695801,
-0.020710846409201622,
0.42947399616241455,
-0.5196499228477478,
-0.36394959688186646,
-0.7135266661643982,
-0.2705865204334259,
-0.7368825078010559,
0.09782538563013077,
0.19981743395328522,
-0.12640036642551422,
-0.2354043871164322,
0.630376935005188,
-0.598272442817688,
0.5154343247413635,
0.7992245554924011,
0.2998006045818329,
0.009815806522965431,
0.20737984776496887,
-0.27653467655181885,
-0.24077944457530975,
-0.7487950325012207,
-0.4925415813922882,
1.267950177192688,
0.45122236013412476,
0.5281322598457336,
-0.03740950673818588,
0.964102029800415,
0.4421485662460327,
0.39756953716278076,
-0.5208433866500854,
0.407909631729126,
-0.5424575209617615,
-0.8447206616401672,
-0.4116235077381134,
-0.23498643934726715,
-1.184611439704895,
0.35099005699157715,
-0.6838059425354004,
-0.5862535238265991,
0.10960713773965836,
0.06521660834550858,
-0.5285359621047974,
0.3082842528820038,
-0.5379384756088257,
0.8580934405326843,
-0.15642108023166656,
-0.14111267030239105,
-0.3569093942642212,
-0.8027864098548889,
-0.026815859600901604,
-0.5311086177825928,
0.1829114854335785,
0.05333707109093666,
0.10625061392784119,
1.1881747245788574,
-0.24389083683490753,
0.6830663681030273,
-0.3231262266635895,
0.04206700623035431,
0.314132958650589,
-0.17320385575294495,
0.45825138688087463,
-0.06920045614242554,
0.11384556442499161,
0.11067307740449905,
0.04964727535843849,
-0.18448306620121002,
-0.4790882468223572,
0.28011852502822876,
-0.7466097474098206,
-0.41585037112236023,
-0.4495110809803009,
-0.3134227395057678,
0.0083158565685153,
0.5577078461647034,
0.2670494019985199,
-0.07606399804353714,
-0.1381819248199463,
0.3237367570400238,
0.7913529276847839,
-0.3441029489040375,
0.4188070297241211,
0.5218373537063599,
0.16859391331672668,
-0.4996775984764099,
0.6869514584541321,
0.09874501079320908,
-0.40015965700149536,
0.35787996649742126,
0.1512448787689209,
-0.5664381384849548,
-0.5964545607566833,
0.04376549273729324,
0.1896742731332779,
-0.8219037652015686,
-0.2801149785518646,
-0.8571051955223083,
-0.39888715744018555,
-0.6910184025764465,
0.12507355213165283,
-0.30617228150367737,
-0.34502801299095154,
-0.2915516197681427,
0.07592318952083588,
0.10630499571561813,
0.7004036903381348,
-0.047577932476997375,
0.56439208984375,
-0.8072888255119324,
0.3203009366989136,
0.37664294242858887,
0.5747397541999817,
-0.37256190180778503,
-0.817828357219696,
-0.13672928512096405,
-0.33427849411964417,
-0.2996450662612915,
-0.817694902420044,
0.34561294317245483,
0.46623024344444275,
0.7448033094406128,
0.31414279341697693,
0.09316474944353104,
0.4380424916744232,
-0.8465633392333984,
0.3393274247646332,
0.1356814205646515,
-0.9595487713813782,
0.5564236640930176,
-0.10807771235704422,
-0.14083825051784515,
0.6768712401390076,
0.3337675631046295,
-0.13436885178089142,
-0.21579374372959137,
-0.6226324439048767,
-0.7692100405693054,
0.7557964324951172,
0.4365702271461487,
0.3052775263786316,
0.6522195339202881,
0.4659043252468109,
0.42853090167045593,
0.2580905556678772,
-0.9557821750640869,
-0.05325200408697128,
-0.2453974038362503,
-0.21039733290672302,
-0.05154886469244957,
-0.3549671769142151,
0.13452105224132538,
-0.6951112151145935,
0.9676287770271301,
0.19012171030044556,
0.3215000331401825,
0.09189248085021973,
-0.29220420122146606,
0.28674212098121643,
0.49993404746055603,
0.7227231860160828,
0.43758049607276917,
-0.3070898652076721,
0.06551046669483185,
0.38168826699256897,
-0.7637274861335754,
0.24004146456718445,
0.5518450140953064,
0.008946536108851433,
0.260791152715683,
0.311707466840744,
0.951040506362915,
-0.1352938711643219,
-0.2881499230861664,
0.36538073420524597,
-0.14738629758358002,
-0.6752972602844238,
-0.3425818681716919,
-0.05583791062235832,
-0.2440989911556244,
0.48520350456237793,
0.3107419013977051,
0.14697124063968658,
0.3444598317146301,
0.09761657565832138,
0.468966543674469,
0.2336030900478363,
-0.28255611658096313,
-0.01613926701247692,
0.7384325265884399,
-0.009175124578177929,
-0.3584034740924835,
0.5962268114089966,
-0.0995810329914093,
-0.7577642202377319,
0.6371455192565918,
0.3939218819141388,
0.929090142250061,
-0.3478790521621704,
0.18904873728752136,
0.3855009377002716,
0.6096503138542175,
0.0482679083943367,
0.10188120603561401,
-0.1537206918001175,
-0.6260718703269958,
-0.580839216709137,
-0.578807532787323,
-0.1440894603729248,
0.49924203753471375,
-0.5412018299102783,
0.44607341289520264,
-0.5424261689186096,
-0.5517427325248718,
0.28794044256210327,
0.1231122836470604,
-0.8685034513473511,
0.28598496317863464,
0.09313471615314484,
0.7357030510902405,
-0.697952389717102,
1.153429388999939,
0.9386981129646301,
-0.15763942897319794,
-0.6292885541915894,
-0.1449453979730606,
-0.52923184633255,
-0.18349601328372955,
1.0336838960647583,
0.3984239995479584,
0.11710460484027863,
0.11347843706607819,
-0.5302144289016724,
-0.6789562106132507,
0.6284849643707275,
0.2704848647117615,
-0.7230805158615112,
0.20613081753253937,
0.167546346783638,
0.6628913879394531,
-0.15970180928707123,
-0.019416334107518196,
0.5296282768249512,
0.669320285320282,
-0.07223675400018692,
-0.9389981627464294,
-0.10793385654687881,
-0.1250426173210144,
-0.047798383980989456,
0.341283917427063,
-0.1406787782907486,
0.5021335482597351,
0.03635755926370621,
0.030507713556289673,
-0.14942173659801483,
0.6847817897796631,
-0.03469541296362877,
0.0973723828792572,
0.6426231861114502,
0.7569964528083801,
0.7204369902610779,
-0.12685440480709076,
0.6340193152427673,
-0.17069269716739655,
0.4275359511375427,
1.0782735347747803,
-0.09286295622587204,
0.6990370154380798,
0.4704226553440094,
-0.10338389873504639,
0.438961923122406,
0.7343235015869141,
-0.41960301995277405,
0.7769152522087097,
0.4137817621231079,
-0.29601937532424927,
-0.3624194264411926,
-0.0015047885244712234,
-0.2689478099346161,
0.41015714406967163,
0.1717325896024704,
-0.31427180767059326,
-0.2617607116699219,
0.30316048860549927,
-0.23809309303760529,
-0.18145297467708588,
-0.22944147884845734,
1.020758032798767,
-0.1531732976436615,
-0.3304118514060974,
0.26450225710868835,
0.26824328303337097,
0.7409030199050903,
-0.5203836560249329,
-0.010480042546987534,
0.18342265486717224,
0.25777149200439453,
0.022392025217413902,
-0.45670488476753235,
0.1529601663351059,
-0.10060026496648788,
0.12094777077436447,
-0.30155542492866516,
1.159875750541687,
-0.36144110560417175,
-0.46043622493743896,
0.25815296173095703,
0.019690880551934242,
0.21832779049873352,
-0.19824352860450745,
-0.7750545144081116,
-0.275809109210968,
-0.21344970166683197,
-0.24248358607292175,
0.1868627965450287,
0.4206622838973999,
-0.023125745356082916,
0.447559654712677,
0.7132471203804016,
0.024518152698874474,
0.4965035617351532,
0.11462534219026566,
0.8532763719558716,
-0.5724048018455505,
-0.8578659892082214,
-0.7858175039291382,
0.44337138533592224,
-0.04103507101535797,
-0.138947993516922,
0.37412285804748535,
0.5023683309555054,
0.891994297504425,
-0.38294580578804016,
0.5414373874664307,
0.06065686419606209,
0.29327747225761414,
-0.4628439247608185,
1.122177004814148,
-0.4667153060436249,
-0.076481394469738,
-0.3496435284614563,
-1.2180708646774292,
-0.6175990700721741,
0.7863739728927612,
-0.034121688455343246,
0.05082772672176361,
0.5911486148834229,
0.43168631196022034,
-0.06831192225217819,
-0.1892385184764862,
0.28768211603164673,
-0.018916556611657143,
0.4978397488594055,
0.33705341815948486,
0.6905310750007629,
-0.4720802307128906,
0.7421414256095886,
-0.2999669015407562,
-0.08076836913824081,
-0.16116639971733093,
-1.0179191827774048,
-1.1370643377304077,
-0.6336450576782227,
-0.2877509891986847,
-0.34160730242729187,
0.23715299367904663,
0.7121714949607849,
0.9079217910766602,
-1.1277869939804077,
0.15567122399806976,
-0.040197014808654785,
-0.3486506938934326,
-0.021058809012174606,
-0.1362103521823883,
0.4572848379611969,
-0.7646908164024353,
-0.4096621870994568,
0.13560639321804047,
-0.09417373687028885,
0.2493881732225418,
0.31193915009498596,
-0.10394708067178726,
-0.25810301303863525,
0.1254028081893921,
0.6108033657073975,
0.09831047058105469,
-0.8062520623207092,
-0.13520397245883942,
-0.13303880393505096,
-0.03645744547247887,
0.06614632904529572,
0.9813209176063538,
-0.8283441662788391,
0.6354510188102722,
0.43170714378356934,
1.1603658199310303,
0.8412245512008667,
-0.13077199459075928,
0.3380911648273468,
-0.7476841807365417,
0.2011597752571106,
0.4333201050758362,
0.2569960355758667,
-0.041818100959062576,
-0.4281666576862335,
0.3299015164375305,
-0.1363125443458557,
-0.5032336711883545,
-0.5609620213508606,
-0.07425007224082947,
-0.7888135313987732,
-0.5049868226051331,
0.7870340943336487,
-0.10689312219619751,
0.03087964653968811,
-0.21109679341316223,
-0.3618807792663574,
0.6280432939529419,
-0.3295685946941376,
0.9142777919769287,
1.0375117063522339,
-0.0077513898722827435,
-0.20313502848148346,
-0.5741044878959656,
0.6497961282730103,
0.6549795866012573,
-0.7186460494995117,
-0.3634747564792633,
0.22587594389915466,
0.3754386007785797,
0.15401941537857056,
0.4278079569339752,
0.014676596969366074,
0.23885202407836914,
-0.3490239977836609,
0.29919835925102234,
-0.27250996232032776,
-0.6198384761810303,
-0.5263006687164307,
0.07729245722293854,
-0.11207732558250427,
-0.3357119858264923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00638v1 | A Collocation-based Method for Addressing Challenges in Word-level Metric Differential Privacy | 2024-06-30T09:37:34 | 2024-06-30T09:37:34 | Stephen Meisenbacher, Maulik Chevli, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Applications of Differential Privacy (DP) in NLP must distinguish between the
syntactic level on which a proposed mechanism operates, often taking the form
of $\textit{word-level}$ or $\textit{document-level}$ privatization. Recently,
several word-level $\textit{Metric}$ Differential Privacy approaches have been
proposed, which rely on this generalized DP notion for operating in word
embedding spaces. These approaches, however, often fail to produce semantically
coherent textual outputs, and their application at the sentence- or
document-level is only possible by a basic composition of word perturbations.
In this work, we strive to address these challenges by operating
$\textit{between}$ the word and sentence levels, namely with
$\textit{collocations}$. By perturbing n-grams rather than single words, we
devise a method where composed privatized outputs have higher semantic
coherence and variable length. This is accomplished by constructing an
embedding model based on frequently occurring word groups, in which unigram
words co-exist with bi- and trigram collocations. We evaluate our method in
utility and privacy tests, which make a clear case for tokenization strategies
beyond the word level. | [
-0.2881668508052826,
-0.8632485866546631,
0.4723750352859497,
0.2813856303691864,
-0.2402699887752533,
0.6815316081047058,
-0.042561180889606476,
-0.22111713886260986,
0.2532782256603241,
0.2959977388381958,
-0.34761667251586914,
-1.3246567249298096,
-0.7089855670928955,
0.0963917076587677,
-0.5070533752441406,
0.7621978521347046,
0.015714989975094795,
-0.12561474740505219,
-0.25004106760025024,
0.16451415419578552,
-0.24503150582313538,
-0.8636857271194458,
-0.05959944799542427,
0.37499386072158813,
0.41045019030570984,
0.16423390805721283,
0.6932634711265564,
0.4549386501312256,
0.5711110830307007,
0.3372057378292084,
-0.4163748025894165,
0.2367134392261505,
-0.3614785373210907,
0.12721982598304749,
0.030798258259892464,
-0.49295827746391296,
-0.31395405530929565,
0.22389301657676697,
0.8727391362190247,
0.9993185997009277,
-0.29422420263290405,
0.051031846553087234,
0.19323189556598663,
0.43083202838897705,
-1.0261571407318115,
0.05462207272648811,
-0.5273418426513672,
0.49729251861572266,
-0.3111379146575928,
-0.19456225633621216,
-0.2994937002658844,
-0.41496697068214417,
0.031297482550144196,
-0.4186480939388275,
0.22029712796211243,
0.2931968867778778,
0.740879237651825,
0.16556762158870697,
-0.12700605392456055,
-0.25643816590309143,
-0.6355301141738892,
0.7522155046463013,
-0.5977212190628052,
0.46094781160354614,
0.6447217464447021,
-0.09549335390329361,
-0.27372920513153076,
-0.4862135648727417,
-0.3475099802017212,
-0.45053932070732117,
-0.39279797673225403,
-0.05741368979215622,
-0.3416452407836914,
0.25041818618774414,
0.3571392893791199,
0.5339795351028442,
-0.27373290061950684,
0.20975802838802338,
0.009176468476653099,
-0.41475558280944824,
0.6077739596366882,
0.35327211022377014,
0.3486213982105255,
0.07977601885795593,
-0.42992743849754333,
0.2214117795228958,
-0.4342196583747864,
-0.06656675040721893,
0.907843828201294,
0.17891757190227509,
-0.3194820284843445,
0.7521409392356873,
-0.3356073200702667,
0.5907838344573975,
0.058218616992235184,
-0.07257670909166336,
0.31203606724739075,
-0.2715180218219757,
0.013122880831360817,
0.05022260174155235,
0.7675091624259949,
0.3163229525089264,
-0.2612648606300354,
-0.7317661643028259,
-0.05670258030295372,
0.04213252291083336,
-0.05914253368973732,
-0.3460565507411957,
-0.10104069858789444,
0.5038787722587585,
-0.05025921016931534,
-0.44505324959754944,
0.21339631080627441,
-1.0932221412658691,
-0.28203505277633667,
0.08449777215719223,
0.4690977931022644,
-0.27476003766059875,
0.05978862941265106,
0.5498448610305786,
-0.17045459151268005,
-0.2636287808418274,
-0.15637719631195068,
-1.1787863969802856,
0.8639667630195618,
0.8017465472221375,
1.2483851909637451,
-0.04043753072619438,
-0.11971406638622284,
-0.7330521941184998,
0.48096325993537903,
-0.21209099888801575,
0.16643622517585754,
-0.6880115270614624,
-0.6561959385871887,
0.20645777881145477,
-0.3111184537410736,
-0.0005517756217159331,
-0.34895703196525574,
0.029316982254385948,
-0.4979001581668854,
0.7395271062850952,
-0.09571101516485214,
-0.6790371537208557,
0.06297000497579575,
0.2797902524471283,
-0.43770861625671387,
0.5907754898071289,
0.1399584263563156,
-1.108030915260315,
0.3389013111591339,
-0.9294957518577576,
-0.10234703123569489,
0.16558551788330078,
-0.07043629139661789,
-0.3460943400859833,
0.2751981019973755,
0.20358356833457947,
0.42180272936820984,
0.2988315522670746,
0.07096240669488907,
-0.21927911043167114,
-0.39472392201423645,
0.07388558983802795,
-0.22634297609329224,
0.9095110297203064,
-0.016110023483633995,
-0.28649020195007324,
-0.21692831814289093,
-0.8234022259712219,
-0.051555611193180084,
-0.031430717557668686,
-0.12939080595970154,
-0.871677577495575,
-0.05139082670211792,
-0.5553905367851257,
-0.342426061630249,
0.7473220229148865,
-0.9583697319030762,
0.12028370052576065,
-0.490452378988266,
0.4134598970413208,
0.5831865668296814,
-0.02174874022603035,
0.720840334892273,
0.02567875385284424,
0.6472060680389404,
0.2264174371957779,
0.4121933579444885,
0.2656804621219635,
-0.3885120153427124,
-0.34032750129699707,
-0.5845713019371033,
0.61691814661026,
0.5622565150260925,
-0.15037581324577332,
0.8583289384841919,
-0.16799423098564148,
-0.25252771377563477,
-0.3427865505218506,
-0.2974357604980469,
0.2771676480770111,
0.32353445887565613,
0.3526986539363861,
-0.289756715297699,
0.02245183102786541,
-0.7240669131278992,
-0.3676699101924896,
-0.11224819719791412,
0.20339354872703552,
0.168661430478096,
0.018987346440553665,
-0.02535649575293064,
0.9805905222892761,
-0.8814049959182739,
-0.5139574408531189,
0.2521354854106903,
0.33796435594558716,
-0.12873108685016632,
0.23591069877147675,
0.2193845957517624,
-0.6211525201797485,
-0.27347540855407715,
-0.2434045821428299,
-0.46189960837364197,
-0.35945022106170654,
0.1675909161567688,
-0.18229274451732635,
0.2101624459028244,
0.36006394028663635,
-0.24823832511901855,
0.6495577096939087,
0.9777681827545166,
-0.4906136095523834,
0.2868310809135437,
-0.4672507345676422,
-0.25131309032440186,
-1.0658951997756958,
-0.3062087297439575,
-0.21431753039360046,
-0.34271952509880066,
-0.7124282717704773,
0.2478807419538498,
-0.17111818492412567,
-0.12267930060625076,
-0.5991676449775696,
0.042508065700531006,
-0.6986669301986694,
-0.2098783552646637,
-0.04331696406006813,
0.31886911392211914,
0.08936820924282074,
0.08124901354312897,
-0.2571737468242645,
0.6241821646690369,
0.7219144701957703,
-0.5214412808418274,
0.25874021649360657,
0.4715248644351959,
-0.18202956020832062,
0.14890004694461823,
-0.3519468605518341,
0.2101474404335022,
-0.044974979013204575,
0.09702526777982712,
-0.9164050817489624,
0.024508118629455566,
0.522178590297699,
-0.0713118240237236,
0.14746339619159698,
-0.011512750759720802,
-0.841172456741333,
-0.13514608144760132,
-0.4724302887916565,
0.4229799807071686,
0.2612909972667694,
-0.35176992416381836,
0.15484100580215454,
0.7323127388954163,
-0.015653233975172043,
-0.7951977849006653,
-0.7616283893585205,
0.32199826836586,
-0.4106404185295105,
-0.6573895812034607,
0.6854454278945923,
0.3568810820579529,
-0.433824360370636,
0.20030952990055084,
-0.07336186617612839,
-0.1552308052778244,
0.18796631693840027,
0.17491087317466736,
0.10962007194757462,
0.3945580720901489,
0.012493741698563099,
0.4415768086910248,
-0.27607110142707825,
0.06426874548196793,
-0.09804926067590714,
0.8762662410736084,
-0.13026343286037445,
-0.37047135829925537,
-0.40779516100883484,
0.8230602741241455,
0.058757755905389786,
-0.2805400788784027,
0.9181990027427673,
0.5064699649810791,
-0.24110673367977142,
-0.18770797550678253,
-0.38079938292503357,
0.01669641025364399,
-0.5232203602790833,
0.1170966774225235,
-0.1730046421289444,
-1.2594186067581177,
0.7534214854240417,
-0.16206401586532593,
0.07744942605495453,
-0.04657711088657379,
0.4070432782173157,
0.1280374526977539,
0.7153273224830627,
0.7835572361946106,
-0.08444447815418243,
0.3547314703464508,
-0.32140183448791504,
0.6356188654899597,
-0.868506133556366,
-0.3905014097690582,
-0.42502298951148987,
-0.48666611313819885,
-1.05223548412323,
-0.5174351930618286,
0.5585286021232605,
0.09883834421634674,
0.04878690838813782,
0.4724835455417633,
-0.6711264252662659,
0.3331722319126129,
0.4974029064178467,
0.07132009416818619,
0.6544102430343628,
0.2451871931552887,
-0.4085787832736969,
-0.10340346395969391,
-0.5248943567276001,
-0.49561139941215515,
0.6733314394950867,
0.2885725498199463,
0.7881152033805847,
0.2946421802043915,
1.4916965961456299,
0.12085924297571182,
-0.32983505725860596,
-0.5369389653205872,
0.8287453651428223,
-0.6853570342063904,
-0.3372128903865814,
-0.4345417022705078,
-0.555648684501648,
-0.9599108099937439,
0.27304935455322266,
0.018940500915050507,
-1.364173412322998,
0.4688822031021118,
-0.27755096554756165,
-0.49193450808525085,
0.40620192885398865,
-0.601515531539917,
0.5100964903831482,
0.08861880749464035,
-0.42440634965896606,
-0.10097137838602066,
-0.574749231338501,
0.14050674438476562,
-0.07823842763900757,
0.15315108001232147,
-0.307111918926239,
-0.5830910205841064,
0.5107157230377197,
-0.5041935443878174,
0.9194768071174622,
-0.36978259682655334,
-0.4226647615432739,
-0.03837432712316513,
0.28201332688331604,
0.3614561855792999,
0.2698982059955597,
0.06013418734073639,
0.7873998284339905,
0.21085914969444275,
-0.13134346902370453,
-0.42649921774864197,
0.7283976078033447,
-0.5480220317840576,
-0.9004333019256592,
-0.4443325400352478,
-0.7568088173866272,
-0.36868858337402344,
0.06032827869057655,
0.25683555006980896,
0.30836036801338196,
-0.06175914779305458,
-0.012415728531777859,
0.2248615175485611,
-0.4949699342250824,
0.6776978969573975,
0.48262470960617065,
-0.23062197864055634,
-0.10102817416191101,
0.5365311503410339,
0.29908883571624756,
0.24580669403076172,
0.5930166840553284,
0.5168819427490234,
-0.6944754123687744,
-0.6162135004997253,
-0.03146742656826973,
0.03033732995390892,
-0.2524305284023285,
-0.0541023351252079,
-0.8087928295135498,
-0.23048748075962067,
-0.24287812411785126,
-0.11224426329135895,
-0.3349560797214508,
-0.44140344858169556,
-0.24051524698734283,
0.03780791163444519,
0.29229646921157837,
0.3039453327655792,
-0.5308743715286255,
0.11401528865098953,
-0.812430202960968,
0.4260934293270111,
0.01848364807665348,
0.48441752791404724,
-0.44519272446632385,
-0.2048831284046173,
-0.06594467908143997,
0.04661468043923378,
-0.14172762632369995,
-0.8159419894218445,
0.32647737860679626,
-0.063714899122715,
0.22224508225917816,
-0.007966473698616028,
0.3328838646411896,
0.7901046276092529,
-0.6229175329208374,
0.9620781540870667,
0.28289639949798584,
-1.2562940120697021,
0.3775261342525482,
-0.32291680574417114,
-0.1444733440876007,
0.5530815124511719,
0.32420551776885986,
-0.5155297517776489,
-0.9254208207130432,
-0.5613792538642883,
-1.2133888006210327,
0.25060659646987915,
0.15034182369709015,
0.6486380696296692,
-0.12980467081069946,
0.33643490076065063,
0.21718133985996246,
0.43166959285736084,
-0.41176027059555054,
-0.16877946257591248,
0.2557426691055298,
0.06289902329444885,
0.32980701327323914,
-0.16789193451404572,
-0.5844300389289856,
-0.020442666485905647,
-0.04336259886622429,
0.17558696866035461,
0.2703567147254944,
0.17371486127376556,
0.1744440346956253,
0.1932888776063919,
0.3640310764312744,
0.37766990065574646,
0.6739217042922974,
-0.21966370940208435,
0.1413133442401886,
-0.05024940147995949,
-0.7513558864593506,
0.4179660677909851,
0.22619329392910004,
-0.510371744632721,
0.24763494729995728,
0.010161147452890873,
0.3248714804649353,
-0.055373456329107285,
0.06120320409536362,
0.7949586510658264,
0.1088596060872078,
-0.41297778487205505,
-0.3128599524497986,
0.07285977154970169,
-0.17482225596904755,
0.1573781818151474,
-0.011780503205955029,
-0.39936205744743347,
0.21270982921123505,
-0.29431599378585815,
0.3044435977935791,
0.5870804786682129,
-0.2036050260066986,
-0.07428349554538727,
0.7506402730941772,
0.06883465498685837,
-0.2956295907497406,
0.38641971349716187,
-0.4022562801837921,
-0.2524118721485138,
0.07881439477205276,
0.4488372802734375,
1.083990454673767,
0.09681906551122665,
0.6530845761299133,
-0.07931248098611832,
0.030383363366127014,
-0.0883873701095581,
0.2725597321987152,
-0.016715452075004578,
-0.7514101266860962,
-0.48320743441581726,
-0.5461820363998413,
-0.35404109954833984,
-0.018175536766648293,
-0.7993500828742981,
0.07681622356176376,
-0.7968493700027466,
-0.3639336824417114,
-0.31449538469314575,
0.2610367238521576,
-0.29091405868530273,
-0.09374241530895233,
0.22881297767162323,
0.615584671497345,
-0.6552461981773376,
0.3676310181617737,
0.41908612847328186,
-0.13245892524719238,
-0.5469726920127869,
0.6513243317604065,
-0.05647720769047737,
-0.6313799023628235,
0.591421365737915,
-0.09985622018575668,
-0.39977872371673584,
0.06508815288543701,
-0.3567121624946594,
-0.7102208733558655,
1.0547311305999756,
0.4517439305782318,
-1.1214213371276855,
-0.07035945355892181,
0.6555883288383484,
0.659008264541626,
-0.10958696901798248,
-0.4080411493778229,
0.22946588695049286,
0.43777748942375183,
-0.271483838558197,
-0.7219358086585999,
0.22288911044597626,
0.5412521958351135,
0.015423092991113663,
0.27491873502731323,
-0.9939229488372803,
0.6024380922317505,
0.025561049580574036,
-0.5902808308601379,
-0.023653481155633926,
0.4601217806339264,
-0.019891763105988503,
0.3217170238494873,
0.7445695400238037,
0.971251368522644,
0.9323081970214844,
-0.06661710888147354,
0.8193526864051819,
-0.4067377746105194,
0.5249605774879456,
1.0729464292526245,
-0.34779056906700134,
0.6056216955184937,
0.6371942162513733,
-0.234050914645195,
0.5436103940010071,
0.2092234194278717,
-0.09774287045001984,
0.8973678946495056,
0.720416784286499,
-0.7660826444625854,
0.20066094398498535,
-0.2849196195602417,
-0.2699911892414093,
0.6331979036331177,
0.23921996355056763,
-0.25441858172416687,
-0.4609256982803345,
-0.2608371376991272,
0.09835268557071686,
0.3187303841114044,
0.000810234691016376,
0.7554675340652466,
0.14623700082302094,
0.05953718721866608,
0.19628815352916718,
0.35464805364608765,
0.6289490461349487,
-0.46184369921684265,
0.3119523823261261,
-0.24664846062660217,
-0.10055650025606155,
-0.37949928641319275,
-0.5289848446846008,
0.7313728928565979,
0.10152291506528854,
0.20897230505943298,
-0.1508301943540573,
0.2974854111671448,
-0.45984089374542236,
-0.43900954723358154,
0.5000771880149841,
0.4306991398334503,
0.15429601073265076,
0.1853214055299759,
-0.5314714908599854,
0.04119690880179405,
-0.4043910503387451,
-0.03644587844610214,
0.46796417236328125,
0.5359880924224854,
0.09541656821966171,
0.2760917544364929,
0.5166356563568115,
0.4508186876773834,
0.2618752717971802,
0.40813297033309937,
1.0011184215545654,
-0.48633405566215515,
-0.8174262046813965,
-1.105988621711731,
0.4563818871974945,
-0.16504737734794617,
-0.2723485231399536,
0.8253435492515564,
0.6323406100273132,
0.8409982323646545,
0.30072712898254395,
0.7445387244224548,
-0.2906200587749481,
0.35077983140945435,
-0.5885622501373291,
0.42187216877937317,
-0.4704141616821289,
0.5576077699661255,
-0.33139657974243164,
-1.0120265483856201,
-0.8005738854408264,
0.5647419095039368,
-0.6214433312416077,
-0.5007361173629761,
0.7229006290435791,
0.9427163600921631,
-0.0008416108903475106,
-0.0853148028254509,
0.615801215171814,
0.011635320261120796,
0.24643616378307343,
0.3146333396434784,
0.9045394062995911,
-0.3245697617530823,
0.20117473602294922,
-0.6499837636947632,
-0.2641938626766205,
0.20766162872314453,
-0.9669114947319031,
-0.6801179647445679,
-0.5451990962028503,
-0.557720422744751,
-0.3220260739326477,
0.17819704115390778,
0.4238121211528778,
0.5447148680686951,
-0.42271187901496887,
0.0731561928987503,
-0.32022184133529663,
0.0028461208567023277,
0.0003006616607308388,
-0.22640129923820496,
0.3490581810474396,
-0.39838647842407227,
-0.944205641746521,
0.2559117078781128,
0.5692704319953918,
0.014306418597698212,
-0.7387905120849609,
0.47108858823776245,
0.06628651916980743,
-0.06662572920322418,
0.27436593174934387,
-0.2694503664970398,
-0.440157413482666,
-0.5324531197547913,
-0.23263677954673767,
-0.02671414613723755,
-0.16600604355335236,
0.7222919464111328,
-0.1464506983757019,
0.3988731801509857,
0.649338960647583,
0.4897017180919647,
0.18136420845985413,
0.43731194734573364,
0.5350308418273926,
-1.1025521755218506,
0.5144661664962769,
0.47791099548339844,
0.07509900629520416,
0.17770661413669586,
-0.7892082929611206,
0.4218876361846924,
0.18299397826194763,
-0.4649322032928467,
-0.7894849181175232,
0.47019895911216736,
-0.911797046661377,
-0.1075262650847435,
1.118104338645935,
-0.5742667317390442,
-0.2340800166130066,
-0.28666046261787415,
0.1228172704577446,
0.1783427596092224,
-0.45522692799568176,
1.3153986930847168,
0.787026584148407,
0.02506078965961933,
0.16799086332321167,
-0.11881593614816666,
0.36878934502601624,
0.20476576685905457,
-0.5794255137443542,
0.21824228763580322,
0.40011313557624817,
0.11564882844686508,
0.5164973735809326,
0.5573656558990479,
-0.7778704762458801,
-0.5383304953575134,
0.21281248331069946,
-0.4351111054420471,
-0.2774336636066437,
-0.2503513693809509,
-0.30867433547973633,
0.39408040046691895,
-0.42242977023124695,
-0.9626116752624512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00637v1 | DP-MLM: Differentially Private Text Rewriting Using Masked Language Models | 2024-06-30T09:31:01 | 2024-06-30T09:31:01 | Stephen Meisenbacher, Maulik Chevli, Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of text privatization using Differential Privacy has recently taken
the form of $\textit{text rewriting}$, in which an input text is obfuscated via
the use of generative (large) language models. While these methods have shown
promising results in the ability to preserve privacy, these methods rely on
autoregressive models which lack a mechanism to contextualize the private
rewriting process. In response to this, we propose $\textbf{DP-MLM}$, a new
method for differentially private text rewriting based on leveraging masked
language models (MLMs) to rewrite text in a semantically similar $\textit{and}$
obfuscated manner. We accomplish this with a simple contextualization
technique, whereby we rewrite a text one token at a time. We find that
utilizing encoder-only MLMs provides better utility preservation at lower
$\varepsilon$ levels, as compared to previous methods relying on larger models
with a decoder. In addition, MLMs allow for greater customization of the
rewriting mechanism, as opposed to generative approaches. We make the code for
$\textbf{DP-MLM}$ public and reusable, found at https://github.com/sjmeis/DPMLM . | [
0.08843663334846497,
-0.9872065186500549,
0.4453743100166321,
0.2979852855205536,
-0.448580265045166,
0.33404093980789185,
-0.020208129659295082,
-0.09830325841903687,
0.3289012312889099,
1.1426678895950317,
-0.5586516261100769,
-0.8390360474586487,
-0.5326798558235168,
0.16135086119174957,
-0.5997090339660645,
0.9746106266975403,
-0.18403859436511993,
-0.06150291487574577,
-0.05718624219298363,
0.2292965203523636,
-0.05427924171090126,
-0.8011329770088196,
-0.3759356439113617,
-0.031960975378751755,
0.5285448431968689,
0.139698326587677,
0.6397949457168579,
1.0205985307693481,
0.4047625958919525,
0.3325258493423462,
-0.02609063684940338,
0.019897401332855225,
-0.6230489611625671,
0.4589802324771881,
0.019952192902565002,
-0.3845849633216858,
-0.772712767124176,
-0.043538648635149,
1.0022011995315552,
0.7722087502479553,
-0.14309246838092804,
0.0746651440858841,
0.31329530477523804,
0.9049708247184753,
-0.7658272981643677,
0.1457945704460144,
-0.897551953792572,
0.14529016613960266,
0.10092362016439438,
-0.2500600218772888,
-0.42493605613708496,
-0.4096516966819763,
0.061619263142347336,
-0.3924126923084259,
0.4520241320133209,
0.10069262981414795,
0.5235844850540161,
0.35267871618270874,
-0.3318270444869995,
0.037647467106580734,
-0.9002770185470581,
0.6991321444511414,
-0.5899622440338135,
0.16487914323806763,
0.5778689384460449,
0.24257470667362213,
-0.0895925983786583,
-0.9527087211608887,
-0.5491109490394592,
-0.36786386370658875,
-0.23656319081783295,
-0.041737090796232224,
-0.3386615812778473,
0.21823257207870483,
0.05370905622839928,
0.7366319298744202,
-0.3323023021221161,
0.09395937621593475,
-0.23684759438037872,
-0.18673650920391083,
0.6965683102607727,
0.27298814058303833,
0.05931945890188217,
0.01750057004392147,
-0.5915492177009583,
0.22084875404834747,
-0.765239417552948,
-0.3466464877128601,
0.8124973177909851,
-0.0022359152790158987,
0.09409134089946747,
0.5655220150947571,
-0.325362890958786,
0.4073408842086792,
0.08637691289186478,
-0.07932645827531815,
0.177373006939888,
-0.12708064913749695,
-0.605804443359375,
0.14408019185066223,
0.5658364295959473,
0.415497750043869,
0.041722215712070465,
-0.3533523976802826,
-0.33216729760169983,
-0.03302180394530296,
0.26156699657440186,
-0.8979746699333191,
-0.2802366018295288,
0.24850067496299744,
-0.6580686569213867,
-0.6727702021598816,
-0.16570746898651123,
-0.7073287963867188,
-0.45783185958862305,
-0.25368842482566833,
0.4859962463378906,
-0.17230717837810516,
-0.29520073533058167,
0.500633716583252,
-0.13789339363574982,
-0.15107588469982147,
0.21076595783233643,
-0.9998573660850525,
0.5800857543945312,
0.9275799989700317,
0.8139086365699768,
-0.12248419970273972,
-0.2229396253824234,
-0.44511935114860535,
0.34901198744773865,
-0.1231268122792244,
0.1711600422859192,
-0.6130334734916687,
-0.5228265523910522,
0.19809474050998688,
0.17666904628276825,
0.08326372504234314,
-0.47457006573677063,
0.2536841034889221,
-0.6387801170349121,
0.311325341463089,
0.0800771713256836,
-0.6074256896972656,
-0.09106042981147766,
0.2817593812942505,
-0.6610425114631653,
0.5956407189369202,
-0.15965698659420013,
-0.692455530166626,
0.19483676552772522,
-0.6075487732887268,
-0.21502923965454102,
-0.09903878718614578,
-0.05819641426205635,
-0.7755674123764038,
0.15956814587116241,
0.07163326442241669,
0.47202810645103455,
0.18121059238910675,
0.5484268665313721,
-0.26505181193351746,
-0.3339326083660126,
0.4353444278240204,
-0.922635018825531,
0.8253747224807739,
0.0939464122056961,
-0.705885112285614,
0.07246359437704086,
-0.956011950969696,
-0.36136648058891296,
0.13571511209011078,
-0.2482568472623825,
-0.5341951251029968,
-0.08295663446187973,
-0.05294997617602348,
-0.042133282870054245,
0.4464237093925476,
-0.6423938274383545,
0.3935104310512543,
-0.6611248254776001,
0.46044620871543884,
1.1414576768875122,
0.0027752730529755354,
0.8580766916275024,
-0.26504334807395935,
0.5500516295433044,
-0.07661917805671692,
0.3355337381362915,
-0.2977043390274048,
-0.5008131861686707,
-0.8289232850074768,
-0.5458511114120483,
0.32746466994285583,
0.25308334827423096,
-0.3725009858608246,
0.33066117763519287,
-0.08378319442272186,
-0.20351438224315643,
-0.45515069365501404,
-0.11637909710407257,
0.607510507106781,
0.5136204361915588,
0.12226498126983643,
-0.3361809253692627,
-0.40637078881263733,
-1.1501531600952148,
-0.32825323939323425,
0.1101609542965889,
0.07248325645923615,
0.21391955018043518,
0.3379013240337372,
-0.38886958360671997,
0.9031139016151428,
-0.8087669610977173,
-0.5454455018043518,
-0.03353305533528328,
-0.09002149850130081,
-0.14055483043193817,
0.6660343408584595,
0.34892329573631287,
-0.8377517461776733,
-0.6886536478996277,
-0.4983372688293457,
-0.48869746923446655,
-0.2931474447250366,
-0.07961133867502213,
-0.3699246942996979,
0.3792737126350403,
0.45782414078712463,
-0.26043105125427246,
0.6246910691261292,
0.7131202816963196,
-0.5013799667358398,
0.39505356550216675,
-0.48259177803993225,
-0.04560476541519165,
-1.176803469657898,
-0.011653291992843151,
-0.39326927065849304,
-0.4755362868309021,
-0.6740763783454895,
0.17646391689777374,
0.004185415338724852,
-0.18737700581550598,
-0.4292528033256531,
0.5482641458511353,
-0.7943216562271118,
0.11415553838014603,
-0.6100043654441833,
-0.044677965342998505,
0.19367168843746185,
0.655685305595398,
0.05754479765892029,
0.4221740663051605,
0.7822147011756897,
-0.5082787871360779,
0.2015770673751831,
0.1454932540655136,
-0.04020625352859497,
-0.032130904495716095,
-0.4021928608417511,
0.27798062562942505,
-0.3723716735839844,
0.39370208978652954,
-0.7308611273765564,
0.09401792287826538,
0.7686189413070679,
-0.08416393399238586,
0.39395418763160706,
-0.4493774473667145,
-0.6110952496528625,
0.33711791038513184,
-0.41882210969924927,
0.2546137869358063,
0.709867537021637,
-0.4882713258266449,
0.5220332145690918,
0.5106555819511414,
-0.07844886928796768,
-0.8573864698410034,
-0.7669746279716492,
0.39122703671455383,
-0.31867194175720215,
-0.4186829626560211,
0.865066409111023,
-0.0034799124114215374,
-0.2854551672935486,
0.15837359428405762,
-0.1769488900899887,
-0.38335222005844116,
0.10408397763967514,
0.3057163953781128,
0.24799372255802155,
-0.0765448808670044,
-0.11937302350997925,
0.39939460158348083,
-0.5093346834182739,
0.17078889906406403,
-0.4605380892753601,
0.4160006046295166,
0.0633869469165802,
-0.3728892207145691,
-0.46995750069618225,
0.7452458143234253,
0.25020143389701843,
-0.26060160994529724,
1.1083972454071045,
0.341534823179245,
-0.4185768663883209,
-0.36397677659988403,
-0.43993622064590454,
-0.2793867290019989,
-0.5538888573646545,
0.2181321680545807,
-0.2175285518169403,
-1.0938118696212769,
0.4213240146636963,
-0.02551082894206047,
0.05775482580065727,
0.1403827667236328,
0.7894880175590515,
0.32491564750671387,
0.8223470449447632,
1.0441821813583374,
-0.10229881852865219,
0.44551780819892883,
-0.2570788264274597,
0.3006124794483185,
-0.4248758554458618,
-0.2690166234970093,
-0.2947917878627777,
-0.3365699052810669,
-0.9252865314483643,
-0.5059072971343994,
0.09160973876714706,
0.1261817216873169,
0.11989254504442215,
0.2270178645849228,
-0.6932072043418884,
0.702511191368103,
0.7430335283279419,
0.10559485107660294,
0.8074765801429749,
0.21994788944721222,
-0.010155878029763699,
-0.010017861612141132,
-0.5131142735481262,
-0.9677397012710571,
1.2024002075195312,
0.586085319519043,
0.8707003593444824,
0.06070459634065628,
1.1539725065231323,
0.1350480318069458,
0.44517192244529724,
-0.3646419048309326,
0.6636983156204224,
-0.4065890610218048,
-0.6788885593414307,
-0.35569310188293457,
-0.2854132354259491,
-0.8380661606788635,
0.41179245710372925,
0.10836835950613022,
-0.6718254089355469,
0.27220964431762695,
0.4214959740638733,
-0.06581743061542511,
0.5272557735443115,
-0.6824684739112854,
0.8305231928825378,
0.04684533551335335,
-0.5503596663475037,
-0.08827859908342361,
-0.6263824701309204,
0.3345390260219574,
-0.19642771780490875,
-0.026384850963950157,
-0.19506831467151642,
-0.29220688343048096,
0.39843589067459106,
-0.5593858361244202,
1.1855276823043823,
-0.3051077127456665,
-0.47743508219718933,
-0.06620641052722931,
0.2908128499984741,
0.5242400765419006,
0.46533167362213135,
0.007394684012979269,
0.4070046842098236,
-0.18445053696632385,
-0.23252899944782257,
-0.5720696449279785,
0.994458019733429,
-0.43066728115081787,
-0.8069338202476501,
-0.5122777819633484,
-0.27188384532928467,
0.20132283866405487,
0.3385761082172394,
0.08844956010580063,
0.39581772685050964,
-0.2710750102996826,
0.2433210015296936,
0.7322241067886353,
-0.3615597188472748,
0.45095065236091614,
0.8579732179641724,
-0.3044906556606293,
-0.16280663013458252,
0.6772207021713257,
-0.16114331781864166,
0.2955318093299866,
0.8285416960716248,
0.3035656213760376,
-0.6100062727928162,
-0.6769908666610718,
-0.4245929718017578,
-0.029082896187901497,
-0.6654787063598633,
-0.05086200311779976,
-1.118061900138855,
-0.2878410518169403,
-0.44619110226631165,
-0.2146836668252945,
-0.5786954164505005,
-0.6089828014373779,
-0.29049378633499146,
0.06813894212245941,
0.23737989366054535,
0.2316923290491104,
-0.22894708812236786,
-0.0658634603023529,
-0.6999571323394775,
0.6638351678848267,
0.163473442196846,
0.675025999546051,
-0.21156755089759827,
-0.2865992486476898,
-0.025511112064123154,
0.10188579559326172,
-0.3127569556236267,
-0.8345126509666443,
0.5601637363433838,
0.027310572564601898,
0.35037094354629517,
0.04780329763889313,
0.46522727608680725,
0.34114018082618713,
-0.9588539004325867,
0.5930007100105286,
-0.051139768213033676,
-0.9943151473999023,
0.30832213163375854,
-0.13175718486309052,
-0.16845598816871643,
0.4762617349624634,
0.26800665259361267,
-0.4965854585170746,
-0.8707447052001953,
-0.46668723225593567,
-1.073106050491333,
0.5427519083023071,
0.6795849800109863,
0.6831576824188232,
0.21144047379493713,
0.3531286418437958,
0.5480469465255737,
0.5763244032859802,
-0.960033118724823,
-0.6793741583824158,
-0.33754435181617737,
-0.10254857689142227,
-0.13300327956676483,
-0.6207602620124817,
-0.21096473932266235,
-0.04883285611867905,
0.6045231223106384,
0.27984803915023804,
0.36053353548049927,
0.26994025707244873,
0.018334250897169113,
0.1918647438287735,
0.44107112288475037,
0.5940995812416077,
0.48035919666290283,
-0.37469711899757385,
0.26285290718078613,
-0.32804879546165466,
-0.6801558136940002,
0.3991512358188629,
0.25729814171791077,
-0.5167113542556763,
0.2145329862833023,
-0.1314772069454193,
0.6701001524925232,
0.03835809603333473,
-0.4260993003845215,
0.5473912358283997,
-0.1446264684200287,
-0.47336897253990173,
-0.5072242617607117,
0.06977192312479019,
-0.03950805589556694,
0.1815209984779358,
0.1651000678539276,
-0.1971551477909088,
0.33367717266082764,
-0.28165197372436523,
0.18252629041671753,
0.21855297684669495,
-0.21392810344696045,
-0.13874706625938416,
0.9283580780029297,
0.3557117283344269,
-0.5180014371871948,
0.2620471715927124,
-0.24410519003868103,
-0.35244232416152954,
0.26944565773010254,
0.6391542553901672,
1.5165051221847534,
-0.09135248512029648,
0.293091744184494,
-0.12086000293493271,
0.3948981761932373,
-0.0019465915393084288,
-0.008552487008273602,
-0.11949887126684189,
-0.517355740070343,
-0.31451740860939026,
-0.8411080241203308,
-0.44337236881256104,
0.3640083372592926,
-0.2935738265514374,
0.12163369357585907,
-0.3921956717967987,
0.21735206246376038,
-0.05862441658973694,
-0.33854544162750244,
-0.17733338475227356,
0.13475608825683594,
-0.12677623331546783,
0.42699170112609863,
-0.5233548283576965,
0.9609299302101135,
0.4264950156211853,
-0.11458504945039749,
-0.31468603014945984,
0.34543922543525696,
-0.16218438744544983,
-0.6479933261871338,
0.7134960889816284,
0.16478115320205688,
-0.3643887937068939,
0.1605653464794159,
-0.21103988587856293,
-0.5410919785499573,
0.8373896479606628,
0.5729724764823914,
-0.8618956804275513,
-0.02407597191631794,
0.5983713865280151,
0.5638759732246399,
-0.2709055244922638,
-0.4653286635875702,
0.048809606581926346,
0.18729853630065918,
-0.38241469860076904,
-0.7004849910736084,
0.2598646581172943,
-0.04616909474134445,
0.0248773992061615,
0.1171136125922203,
-0.4859330952167511,
0.7804721593856812,
0.2587629556655884,
-0.32217928767204285,
-0.024760974571108818,
0.26536381244659424,
-0.07783491909503937,
0.46395087242126465,
0.3951440453529358,
0.3052889108657837,
0.2565666139125824,
0.13854050636291504,
0.8050508499145508,
-0.43587151169776917,
0.5094891786575317,
1.0691702365875244,
-0.33782052993774414,
0.48640307784080505,
0.5493788123130798,
0.1560371220111847,
0.35685235261917114,
0.14612571895122528,
0.05537596717476845,
0.8928576707839966,
0.6569180488586426,
-0.6003937125205994,
-0.042233556509017944,
0.22328248620033264,
-0.4401264190673828,
0.4545879364013672,
-0.35264813899993896,
-0.8607773780822754,
-0.18028782308101654,
-0.051534030586481094,
0.13833041489124298,
0.4658854901790619,
-0.06221168488264084,
0.7221862077713013,
0.17832642793655396,
-0.36086469888687134,
0.5706937909126282,
0.6877186298370361,
0.7754272222518921,
-0.45749619603157043,
0.054386939853429794,
-0.3426651954650879,
0.49964919686317444,
0.013392665423452854,
-0.32454735040664673,
0.813410222530365,
0.30132782459259033,
-0.4018346667289734,
-0.9672110676765442,
0.9441201686859131,
-0.6473469138145447,
-0.4972938001155853,
0.1123243048787117,
0.3787253201007843,
0.06168869882822037,
-0.3392637372016907,
-0.8009758591651917,
-0.10882030427455902,
-0.06526735424995422,
-0.24024076759815216,
0.5423444509506226,
0.3241398334503174,
0.19705432653427124,
0.6113314032554626,
0.6478146314620972,
-0.22661815583705902,
0.09581268578767776,
0.2453767955303192,
0.9679473638534546,
-0.62745201587677,
-0.8237462639808655,
-1.3620983362197876,
0.4933245778083801,
-0.12824591994285583,
-0.0790148600935936,
1.0485079288482666,
0.8791963458061218,
0.93196040391922,
-0.31969717144966125,
0.711123526096344,
0.41433870792388916,
0.4602828323841095,
-0.6932847499847412,
1.1585966348648071,
-0.5653076171875,
0.5194859504699707,
-0.4862925410270691,
-1.00125253200531,
-0.42068150639533997,
0.4760682284832001,
-0.1070929542183876,
-0.2906743288040161,
0.503774881362915,
1.0504100322723389,
-0.06964916735887527,
-0.2092660665512085,
0.47946131229400635,
-0.019260209053754807,
0.3272784352302551,
0.25184836983680725,
0.895016610622406,
-0.35205158591270447,
0.5142983198165894,
-0.6363108158111572,
-0.35897889733314514,
-0.1572628617286682,
-1.1880254745483398,
-0.9518632292747498,
-0.5855210423469543,
-0.6654850840568542,
-0.40745285153388977,
0.24645023047924042,
0.44579023122787476,
0.5208237767219543,
-0.3761536777019501,
-0.0536474734544754,
-0.5529595017433167,
0.17289191484451294,
-0.07757502049207687,
-0.21794652938842773,
0.3569067418575287,
0.039442840963602066,
-1.0965064764022827,
0.2684939205646515,
0.6214398145675659,
0.24547411501407623,
-0.726101815700531,
0.025705544278025627,
0.22647754848003387,
0.021272102370858192,
0.3758913576602936,
-0.2430947721004486,
-0.6724867820739746,
0.04633691906929016,
0.11401702463626862,
-0.14206723868846893,
-0.061675429344177246,
1.1051702499389648,
-0.4770848751068115,
0.4907010793685913,
0.36132654547691345,
0.5592352151870728,
0.5776814818382263,
-0.1395779550075531,
0.7204073667526245,
-0.8580136299133301,
0.30012139678001404,
0.5147578120231628,
0.11260757595300674,
0.1694808006286621,
-0.527710497379303,
0.006987198255956173,
0.34928634762763977,
-0.5073057413101196,
-1.066923975944519,
0.4219202697277069,
-0.6827850341796875,
-0.43210434913635254,
1.1359684467315674,
-0.32251065969467163,
-0.15245191752910614,
-0.2623429000377655,
-0.3778425455093384,
0.2122916579246521,
-0.3383799195289612,
1.115275502204895,
0.2753339111804962,
0.31960439682006836,
0.011232971213757992,
-0.1502450555562973,
0.6719323396682739,
0.19613118469715118,
-0.39231863617897034,
0.419458270072937,
0.41207021474838257,
0.4610009789466858,
-0.24687202274799347,
1.2346645593643188,
-0.22104588150978088,
-0.2597607374191284,
0.22310692071914673,
-0.3042364716529846,
-0.5270305871963501,
-0.24852393567562103,
-0.47979292273521423,
0.3406372368335724,
-0.29248571395874023,
-0.5488332509994507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00632v1 | CAMON: Cooperative Agents for Multi-Object Navigation with LLM-based Conversations | 2024-06-30T09:14:33 | 2024-06-30T09:14:33 | Pengying Wu, Yao Mu, Kangjie Zhou, Ji Ma, Junting Chen, Chang Liu | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MA | Visual navigation tasks are critical for household service robots. As these
tasks become increasingly complex, effective communication and collaboration
among multiple robots become imperative to ensure successful completion. In
recent years, large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable
comprehension and planning abilities in the context of embodied agents.
However, their application in household scenarios, specifically in the use of
multiple agents collaborating to complete complex navigation tasks through
communication, remains unexplored. Therefore, this paper proposes a framework
for decentralized multi-agent navigation, leveraging LLM-enabled communication
and collaboration. By designing the communication-triggered dynamic leadership
organization structure, we achieve faster team consensus with fewer
communication instances, leading to better navigation effectiveness and
collaborative exploration efficiency. With the proposed novel communication
scheme, our framework promises to be conflict-free and robust in multi-object
navigation tasks, even when there is a surge in team size. | [
-0.36648085713386536,
-0.7199392318725586,
0.7122190594673157,
0.17079097032546997,
-0.17216737568378448,
0.6288542747497559,
-0.18185600638389587,
-0.5175011157989502,
0.3067325949668884,
0.5257342457771301,
-0.7353845834732056,
-0.6373509764671326,
-0.5604946613311768,
0.10804452747106552,
0.08607321232557297,
0.41104036569595337,
0.2872728705406189,
-0.1831977814435959,
-0.029910525307059288,
-0.3224952220916748,
-0.5315197706222534,
-0.29402196407318115,
-0.5155709385871887,
-0.4010655879974365,
1.0183460712432861,
0.751568615436554,
1.3461018800735474,
0.4631151854991913,
0.5400511026382446,
0.5131204724311829,
0.021174874156713486,
0.8378344178199768,
-0.559391975402832,
0.7133146524429321,
-0.2597586214542389,
-0.4152178466320038,
-0.9622743725776672,
-0.3837547302246094,
0.3546018898487091,
0.7269530296325684,
-0.22276434302330017,
-0.3510352671146393,
0.013505952432751656,
0.5484007596969604,
-0.4759931266307831,
0.7398648262023926,
-0.42694875597953796,
-0.02781444601714611,
0.4611574709415436,
-0.34075048565864563,
-0.2922075092792511,
-0.0970073789358139,
0.1968371719121933,
-0.8226667046546936,
-0.14851412177085876,
0.3323928713798523,
0.6400744318962097,
0.27212047576904297,
-0.5037170052528381,
-0.38547641038894653,
-0.7544170022010803,
0.8124675154685974,
-0.27481576800346375,
0.29232558608055115,
0.3668440878391266,
0.32969650626182556,
-0.4284738004207611,
-0.4270259439945221,
-0.36967796087265015,
-0.3614116311073303,
0.07954571396112442,
0.3923678398132324,
0.05344386026263237,
0.26608553528785706,
-0.45068591833114624,
0.07502840459346771,
-0.2866657078266144,
0.11612631380558014,
0.05501293018460274,
0.2113802433013916,
0.575934112071991,
0.3392839729785919,
0.3389057517051697,
-0.06506139785051346,
-0.6605618000030518,
-0.11118319630622864,
-0.3626438081264496,
-0.17630477249622345,
-0.03492429852485657,
0.5115666389465332,
-0.4718486964702606,
0.5905723571777344,
-0.4492078423500061,
0.666314423084259,
-0.07324176281690598,
-0.36472201347351074,
-0.03708108514547348,
-0.9445798397064209,
-0.12867330014705658,
-0.0214686319231987,
0.6619545221328735,
0.7268348336219788,
0.14869627356529236,
-0.2710542678833008,
-0.35502558946609497,
0.07146561145782471,
0.36674702167510986,
-0.3681572377681732,
-0.13123047351837158,
0.0748574361205101,
-0.38983988761901855,
-0.22208315134048462,
0.1823579967021942,
-0.6249914169311523,
-0.5023163557052612,
-0.26547539234161377,
0.1019626334309578,
0.12393511831760406,
-0.34444862604141235,
0.05773664638400078,
-0.050056714564561844,
0.31171494722366333,
0.8127142190933228,
-0.6881865859031677,
0.3919795751571655,
0.6268636584281921,
0.8092468976974487,
-0.06328476220369339,
-0.556916356086731,
-0.6741424202919006,
0.5050413012504578,
-0.43577685952186584,
0.6351768374443054,
-0.336227685213089,
-0.5352338552474976,
-0.016475914046168327,
0.12109210342168808,
-0.1211087629199028,
-0.38488367199897766,
-0.049132272601127625,
-0.41756129264831543,
-0.16949784755706787,
-0.15514321625232697,
0.011432269588112831,
-0.1361480951309204,
0.5854677557945251,
-0.6712527275085449,
0.47930628061294556,
0.15909144282341003,
-0.06991823762655258,
0.06592487543821335,
-0.3837454617023468,
-0.504304051399231,
0.32842838764190674,
-0.4288814067840576,
-0.5190610289573669,
-0.3176107406616211,
0.15965905785560608,
0.7688841819763184,
-0.3609159290790558,
0.3754305839538574,
-0.10824490338563919,
-0.3083514869213104,
-0.0494641475379467,
-0.10134606808423996,
0.5046819448471069,
0.10019249469041824,
-0.4021743834018707,
0.47556638717651367,
-0.3730710446834564,
-0.22169385850429535,
-0.10167615115642548,
-0.46184027194976807,
-0.09427439421415329,
0.11462268978357315,
-0.2857719659805298,
0.12334798276424408,
0.6054604053497314,
-0.12426145374774933,
0.6266469955444336,
0.16281168162822723,
0.009213520213961601,
0.585750937461853,
0.0012676070909947157,
0.8986755609512329,
-0.7544729113578796,
0.5185920000076294,
-0.26429396867752075,
0.6373034715652466,
-0.29631271958351135,
-0.9758992195129395,
-0.6218633651733398,
-0.4249105155467987,
-0.712470531463623,
0.45330265164375305,
-1.1846357583999634,
0.616685688495636,
-0.4095263183116913,
-0.42768046259880066,
-0.032816331833601,
-0.013495654799044132,
0.6214404702186584,
0.21583525836467743,
0.3427906036376953,
-0.15667933225631714,
-0.2087138593196869,
-0.437168151140213,
0.32551053166389465,
-0.2881925106048584,
0.20162740349769592,
0.8009293079376221,
0.23559454083442688,
-0.5848186016082764,
0.4420171082019806,
-0.25656241178512573,
-0.44817277789115906,
-0.6382494568824768,
0.009765765629708767,
0.1483043134212494,
0.24911212921142578,
0.1520284116268158,
-0.9675799608230591,
-0.4513029456138611,
0.39099863171577454,
-0.8979535698890686,
0.10998113453388214,
-0.35946589708328247,
-0.4131278991699219,
0.1424543559551239,
0.3779851198196411,
-0.6343061327934265,
0.565675675868988,
0.8329548835754395,
-0.23361346125602722,
0.28900760412216187,
-0.28207656741142273,
0.271831214427948,
-1.17373788356781,
-0.5402939915657043,
-0.3550652861595154,
-0.3062029182910919,
-0.518569827079773,
0.16891296207904816,
-0.36625561118125916,
0.12125946581363678,
-0.5242682099342346,
0.3424747586250305,
-0.900884211063385,
-0.3594761788845062,
-0.20738215744495392,
0.5572220087051392,
0.04455099254846573,
0.726647675037384,
0.035590045154094696,
0.5860069990158081,
0.4722854793071747,
-0.8088729381561279,
0.7714853286743164,
0.6277130842208862,
-0.02069898508489132,
0.7450024485588074,
-0.39655715227127075,
-0.061055801808834076,
0.06747132539749146,
0.41118913888931274,
-1.0436125993728638,
-0.23186689615249634,
0.4907274544239044,
-0.20925776660442352,
-0.05578022077679634,
-0.10281460732221603,
-0.5455599427223206,
0.15324492752552032,
-0.25014135241508484,
0.32349422574043274,
0.03527214378118515,
-0.5987279415130615,
0.8308250904083252,
0.42460960149765015,
0.07161086797714233,
-0.399311363697052,
-0.48535317182540894,
0.4307158589363098,
0.18738611042499542,
-0.9599728584289551,
0.317065566778183,
-0.0793905183672905,
-0.3015661835670471,
-0.2085454761981964,
-0.20634515583515167,
-0.1866593211889267,
0.0877612978219986,
0.3924823999404907,
0.6219159960746765,
0.08453331887722015,
0.03071698360145092,
-0.20672854781150818,
0.062018733471632004,
-0.2965266704559326,
0.1756131947040558,
0.8003118634223938,
-0.3754010796546936,
-0.385427325963974,
-0.6013886332511902,
0.52171391248703,
0.7230044007301331,
-0.14131559431552887,
0.9729323983192444,
0.17088592052459717,
0.04809189215302467,
-0.21338723599910736,
-0.3789541721343994,
-0.5653554797172546,
-0.536210298538208,
0.22490070760250092,
-0.35168763995170593,
-0.9677091836929321,
0.6241117119789124,
-0.4642355442047119,
0.12565073370933533,
-0.3100742697715759,
0.4827246069908142,
-0.06633614003658295,
0.7130592465400696,
0.6211186647415161,
0.0691039189696312,
0.7052996754646301,
-0.4511334300041199,
0.3864853084087372,
-0.79881751537323,
-0.8023992776870728,
-0.3708098530769348,
-0.14312684535980225,
-0.6824714541435242,
-0.831677258014679,
0.5038278698921204,
-0.2021125704050064,
-0.2000289410352707,
0.5646236538887024,
-0.4612948000431061,
-0.005225838627666235,
0.3822729289531708,
0.1594894379377365,
0.6862322092056274,
-0.32604658603668213,
0.0019295568345114589,
0.38991662859916687,
-1.1503454446792603,
-0.3995215892791748,
0.3115541636943817,
-0.024532116949558258,
1.1879132986068726,
0.20350587368011475,
0.6970779299736023,
0.18120256066322327,
-0.018301688134670258,
-1.0464485883712769,
0.9509410262107849,
0.13209503889083862,
-0.15842071175575256,
-0.7960590720176697,
-0.39305877685546875,
-1.459868311882019,
0.6374792456626892,
-0.2862490713596344,
-0.4092778265476227,
0.29569169878959656,
-0.46252062916755676,
-0.2801063358783722,
0.21526095271110535,
-0.4516824185848236,
0.5483009219169617,
-0.24401359260082245,
-0.5147907733917236,
-0.44770416617393494,
-0.7988013625144958,
0.14520001411437988,
0.14294114708900452,
0.350967675447464,
-0.2142147719860077,
-0.341394305229187,
0.1245449036359787,
-0.2405165135860443,
0.8934062123298645,
0.3377656638622284,
-0.14572517573833466,
0.40747401118278503,
0.10652389377355576,
0.6652176380157471,
0.1327749788761139,
0.035001255571842194,
0.1481117159128189,
-0.6512957215309143,
-0.17107190191745758,
-0.5153621435165405,
0.6260362863540649,
-0.5843648910522461,
-0.44583845138549805,
-0.4643564522266388,
-0.5584859848022461,
0.14546364545822144,
0.15642373263835907,
-0.3097812831401825,
0.36106812953948975,
-0.13553354144096375,
0.5427578091621399,
0.43063026666641235,
-0.2829133868217468,
0.5749921798706055,
0.4937748312950134,
-0.10040439665317535,
-0.22221018373966217,
0.6101669669151306,
-0.07294314354658127,
0.5419682264328003,
0.5228860378265381,
0.025954939424991608,
-0.10361799597740173,
-0.0923880785703659,
-0.253976434469223,
0.07481449842453003,
-0.418720006942749,
-0.31087955832481384,
-0.33547914028167725,
-0.19090963900089264,
-0.06906049698591232,
-0.6536316275596619,
-0.7871361374855042,
0.0020318080205470324,
-0.263611376285553,
0.09151284396648407,
-0.03166218847036362,
0.8720285892486572,
-0.01234770193696022,
0.4656340181827545,
-0.6858354806900024,
0.7798655033111572,
0.5966224074363708,
0.07647863030433655,
0.0917590782046318,
0.029740314930677414,
-0.3486320376396179,
0.043201345950365067,
-0.1393747329711914,
-0.580299437046051,
0.26762625575065613,
-0.13606424629688263,
0.754319429397583,
0.38782015442848206,
0.38138845562934875,
0.524791419506073,
-0.22903023660182953,
0.6725665330886841,
0.4067583382129669,
-0.5786263346672058,
0.4164561331272125,
-0.6047705411911011,
0.42411431670188904,
0.15418559312820435,
-0.06387407332658768,
-0.4159815311431885,
-0.6655975580215454,
-0.5051389932632446,
-0.99918133020401,
0.5103014707565308,
0.36124950647354126,
-0.2532513439655304,
-0.0950300544500351,
-0.11889317631721497,
-0.24460291862487793,
0.36236637830734253,
-0.29000067710876465,
-0.18079018592834473,
0.11752858757972717,
0.2587522864341736,
0.051312826573848724,
0.059282924979925156,
-0.37881022691726685,
-0.09324516355991364,
0.30126914381980896,
-0.08990596979856491,
0.3675670623779297,
0.31089869141578674,
0.13554462790489197,
-0.07216823846101761,
0.233585923910141,
0.636108934879303,
0.7143976092338562,
0.04919403791427612,
0.2722804844379425,
-0.14495821297168732,
-0.21643377840518951,
0.18974952399730682,
-0.3504261076450348,
0.30183491110801697,
-0.11136049777269363,
0.4317378103733063,
0.5305258631706238,
0.6240075826644897,
-0.2576793432235718,
0.5418272018432617,
-0.21426524221897125,
0.022138649597764015,
-0.18818822503089905,
0.34522244334220886,
0.31091681122779846,
0.6253657937049866,
0.24336718022823334,
0.33211979269981384,
-0.08221007138490677,
-0.9190671443939209,
0.24488739669322968,
0.5536115765571594,
-0.234965980052948,
-0.07552198320627213,
0.513917088508606,
0.5120615363121033,
-0.6923701763153076,
0.3781396448612213,
-0.14176040887832642,
-0.37332969903945923,
0.796423077583313,
-0.10160154104232788,
0.7468371987342834,
-0.47238269448280334,
0.5369436740875244,
0.10644888132810593,
0.3350982964038849,
-0.43888041377067566,
0.2507920563220978,
-0.4898079037666321,
-0.8651833534240723,
-0.30849534273147583,
-0.07772011309862137,
-0.8817527890205383,
-0.5215985178947449,
-0.425063818693161,
-0.08820244669914246,
-0.3675463795661926,
-0.22845923900604248,
-0.5222381353378296,
-0.02962881699204445,
-0.5165317058563232,
0.05967288464307785,
0.13371716439723969,
0.10437405854463577,
-0.25074902176856995,
0.8359199166297913,
0.5685662627220154,
-0.2224392145872116,
-0.7047832012176514,
-0.1521902084350586,
-0.28457099199295044,
-0.8606491088867188,
0.42049574851989746,
0.17109061777591705,
-1.0697346925735474,
-0.11270179599523544,
-0.6672460436820984,
-0.5517740845680237,
1.4249176979064941,
-0.06466332823038101,
-0.8557937741279602,
0.1147422268986702,
0.03492461517453194,
0.3535143733024597,
-0.6825615763664246,
0.11489388346672058,
-0.061565499752759933,
0.6943525075912476,
0.36724743247032166,
-1.0474138259887695,
0.007149745710194111,
0.21960723400115967,
0.09973596036434174,
-0.2856639623641968,
-1.2488049268722534,
0.8487589359283447,
-0.4206981658935547,
-0.023708706721663475,
0.444659560918808,
0.47195500135421753,
0.546424150466919,
0.4178984761238098,
0.5614113807678223,
-0.06647611409425735,
0.8717910647392273,
0.05996214225888252,
0.7644797563552856,
-0.31548506021499634,
0.14815017580986023,
1.2003062963485718,
-0.3059753477573395,
0.5213576555252075,
0.4964318871498108,
0.29580259323120117,
0.41478031873703003,
-0.005385910160839558,
0.1170426681637764,
0.4940836727619171,
0.14429457485675812,
-0.6643641591072083,
-0.4008772075176239,
-0.5214343070983887,
-0.20296622812747955,
0.6014142036437988,
0.2781997323036194,
0.01345329824835062,
-0.22194691002368927,
-0.07191252708435059,
0.10210704058408737,
0.21996428072452545,
-0.3319379389286041,
0.7936217784881592,
0.24729228019714355,
-0.6663060188293457,
0.43898290395736694,
-0.19549085199832916,
0.5926305651664734,
-0.4031620919704437,
-0.2648775279521942,
-0.28297141194343567,
0.16634173691272736,
-0.18216730654239655,
-0.7846448421478271,
0.010870898142457008,
-0.5716549158096313,
0.2423938512802124,
-0.5126451253890991,
0.6553694009780884,
-0.583189845085144,
0.090073361992836,
0.7652330994606018,
1.0302956104278564,
0.10093846917152405,
-0.08749397099018097,
-0.3348459005355835,
0.4701615273952484,
-0.2566676735877991,
-0.15564760565757751,
0.1235523596405983,
0.4656863808631897,
0.04293065145611763,
1.22591233253479,
0.53596031665802,
-0.13177688419818878,
0.21468783915042877,
0.27665987610816956,
1.0053999423980713,
-0.45889925956726074,
-0.502988338470459,
-0.5491194725036621,
0.396867960691452,
-0.11165516078472137,
0.03390556573867798,
0.8862404227256775,
0.4259933829307556,
0.6773402094841003,
-0.11212188005447388,
0.373121976852417,
0.2723219692707062,
-0.12319175899028778,
-0.15400074422359467,
0.8007479310035706,
-0.533739447593689,
0.31507202982902527,
-0.18717339634895325,
-0.9670248031616211,
-0.33198291063308716,
1.0943882465362549,
0.2154577374458313,
-0.05364792048931122,
0.614578902721405,
0.8765136003494263,
0.09865014255046844,
-0.16925518214702606,
0.7551460862159729,
0.03641115128993988,
0.5299445390701294,
0.6505919098854065,
1.0405917167663574,
-0.2579447031021118,
0.6282992362976074,
-0.1670703887939453,
-0.22754879295825958,
-0.4850386679172516,
-0.6185144782066345,
-0.958585262298584,
-0.6091310977935791,
-0.21702976524829865,
-0.06301391124725342,
0.4616776406764984,
0.7648048996925354,
0.9924524426460266,
-0.13422180712223053,
-0.6984298229217529,
-0.31931212544441223,
0.558879554271698,
-0.15312285721302032,
-0.1370936930179596,
-0.0692579373717308,
-0.08553893864154816,
-0.7938222885131836,
0.8311343789100647,
0.7385340332984924,
-0.157056525349617,
-0.40829363465309143,
-0.6256620287895203,
-0.4853365123271942,
-0.027967482805252075,
0.6969929337501526,
0.13627028465270996,
-0.6865739822387695,
-0.2200661450624466,
-0.013491743244230747,
-0.33226847648620605,
0.32120779156684875,
0.5407627820968628,
-0.5826272964477539,
0.6374989151954651,
0.33052903413772583,
0.45288655161857605,
0.38734346628189087,
0.10615329444408417,
0.4773561954498291,
-0.3871297538280487,
0.38347044587135315,
0.28620263934135437,
0.10747520625591278,
0.38073936104774475,
-0.5006446242332458,
0.6333101987838745,
0.15341509878635406,
-0.8183321952819824,
-0.2888573110103607,
0.30551594495773315,
-1.528735876083374,
-0.2401036024093628,
1.1870167255401611,
-0.18337200582027435,
-0.36841922998428345,
-0.5207144021987915,
-0.4995657801628113,
0.5351089835166931,
-0.9583715200424194,
0.6430482864379883,
0.4101088047027588,
-0.268062561750412,
-0.40045201778411865,
-0.48117780685424805,
0.19892698526382446,
0.0961390808224678,
-0.8542271256446838,
-0.18995818495750427,
0.40737754106521606,
-0.3767191469669342,
0.2611546218395233,
0.7372133135795593,
0.2362017184495926,
0.13733027875423431,
0.03476710617542267,
0.0005933532956987619,
-0.1931663453578949,
-0.9178529977798462,
0.24096249043941498,
0.09758132696151733,
-0.24324969947338104,
-0.6247243881225586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00617v1 | Iterative Nash Policy Optimization: Aligning LLMs with General Preferences via No-Regret Learning | 2024-06-30T08:00:34 | 2024-06-30T08:00:34 | Yuheng Zhang, Dian Yu, Baolin Peng, Linfeng Song, Ye Tian, Mingyue Huo, Nan Jiang, Haitao Mi, Dong Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT | Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) has achieved great success
in aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. Prevalent RLHF
approaches are reward-based, following the Bradley-Terry (BT) model assumption,
which may not fully capture the complexity of human preferences. In this paper,
we explore RLHF under a general preference framework and approach it from a
game-theoretic perspective. Specifically, we formulate the problem as a
two-player game and propose a novel algorithm, iterative Nash policy
optimization (INPO). The key idea is to let the policy play against itself via
no-regret learning, thereby approximating the Nash policy. Unlike previous
methods, INPO bypasses the need for estimating the expected win rate for
individual responses, which typically incurs high computational or annotation
costs. Instead, we introduce a new loss objective that is directly minimized
over a preference dataset. We provide theoretical analysis for our approach and
demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on various representative
benchmarks. With an LLaMA-3-8B-based SFT model, INPO achieves a 41.5%
length-controlled win rate on AlpacaEval 2.0 and a 38.3% win rate on
Arena-Hard, showing substantial improvement over the state-of-the-art iterative
algorithm [Dong et al., 2024] under the BT model assumption. Additionally, our
ablation study highlights the benefits of incorporating KL regularization for
response length control. | [
-0.2488527148962021,
-0.5224528312683105,
0.46175625920295715,
0.14620082080364227,
-0.1911221593618393,
0.14888666570186615,
-0.5146117806434631,
-0.18651875853538513,
0.03933965414762497,
0.5778813362121582,
-0.6548707485198975,
-0.31074583530426025,
-0.420733243227005,
-0.27568715810775757,
0.42835143208503723,
1.1195414066314697,
-0.15332730114459991,
0.006240816321223974,
-0.19862841069698334,
-0.05036203935742378,
-0.38984185457229614,
-0.2905251681804657,
-0.8664928078651428,
-0.8261686563491821,
0.3898525536060333,
0.7576228380203247,
0.7720576524734497,
0.5436238050460815,
0.3137119710445404,
0.11884474754333496,
-0.03916461020708084,
0.3086031377315521,
-0.738338053226471,
-0.02724599279463291,
-0.06303881108760834,
-0.330734521150589,
0.07344384491443634,
-0.04802566394209862,
0.6686028838157654,
0.24195222556591034,
-0.6432600617408752,
-0.20915891230106354,
-0.00021175852452870458,
0.8318710923194885,
-0.5797107815742493,
0.12007282674312592,
-0.5199311971664429,
0.33035019040107727,
0.017477532848715782,
-0.5594186186790466,
-0.4919634163379669,
-0.5626341700553894,
0.36799633502960205,
-0.731105387210846,
-0.1973683089017868,
0.15235452353954315,
0.8929798007011414,
0.35123777389526367,
-0.32246941328048706,
-0.3780634105205536,
-0.8139015436172485,
0.9764659404754639,
-0.6379223465919495,
0.150218665599823,
0.42528995871543884,
0.346645325422287,
-0.4516136050224304,
0.22964482009410858,
-0.30111223459243774,
-0.7183436751365662,
0.08692426234483719,
0.3457235097885132,
0.021723194047808647,
0.3166002929210663,
0.01364720519632101,
0.11330324411392212,
-0.5945197939872742,
0.3409646451473236,
-0.11004951596260071,
-0.032046519219875336,
0.8212751746177673,
0.062373511493206024,
-0.07835334539413452,
0.14458543062210083,
-0.776641845703125,
-0.13689546287059784,
-0.7519485354423523,
0.563230037689209,
0.6624080538749695,
0.34484270215034485,
-0.046802956610918045,
0.45825350284576416,
-0.03569331020116806,
0.46744656562805176,
0.1477014124393463,
-0.5850120782852173,
-0.08283435553312302,
0.17380893230438232,
0.0036997366696596146,
0.17423830926418304,
0.6495893597602844,
0.5330696105957031,
0.22824367880821228,
-0.46555423736572266,
-0.23971378803253174,
0.2583428919315338,
0.21914620697498322,
-0.5649564862251282,
0.12830889225006104,
0.196195587515831,
-0.3656453490257263,
-0.47412872314453125,
-0.2875812351703644,
-0.6366938948631287,
-0.4290408194065094,
-0.07761931419372559,
0.7462826371192932,
-0.24085326492786407,
-0.16094420850276947,
0.1014089435338974,
0.08671867102384567,
0.4006766080856323,
0.20031888782978058,
-1.0298006534576416,
0.6754419803619385,
0.6463589072227478,
0.5588228702545166,
-0.3014938235282898,
-0.2177337110042572,
-0.7376447916030884,
0.15069986879825592,
-0.593690812587738,
0.6942968964576721,
-0.44888779520988464,
-0.7593634128570557,
0.02566082403063774,
-0.4803364872932434,
0.21168354153633118,
-0.4767827093601227,
0.6189519166946411,
-0.5438078045845032,
0.24666990339756012,
-0.31983786821365356,
-0.7532848715782166,
-0.11137094348669052,
0.4672088623046875,
-0.4048497676849365,
0.7801105976104736,
-0.08993443101644516,
-0.378532350063324,
0.4809208810329437,
-0.866574764251709,
-0.3715597689151764,
-0.13362710177898407,
-0.18651309609413147,
-0.6926895380020142,
-0.0009277509525418282,
0.021178696304559708,
-0.09303086996078491,
-0.5956011414527893,
0.2574544847011566,
-0.39926522970199585,
-0.6467239856719971,
0.16473793983459473,
-0.12169002741575241,
0.4288701117038727,
0.11231977492570877,
-0.44038504362106323,
0.33794647455215454,
-0.326621413230896,
0.1056504026055336,
0.23025959730148315,
-0.7814282774925232,
0.04291297867894173,
0.4303252696990967,
-0.18149130046367645,
0.08675890415906906,
-0.04292239248752594,
-0.628529965877533,
0.5754231810569763,
-0.5418401956558228,
0.28964129090309143,
0.8638176918029785,
0.051889292895793915,
0.8607460260391235,
-0.44634324312210083,
0.5607824921607971,
-0.43563738465309143,
0.6034465432167053,
0.42363762855529785,
-0.2755375802516937,
-0.29659879207611084,
-0.08022013306617737,
0.2690945863723755,
0.368232399225235,
-0.6414759159088135,
0.07168649137020111,
-0.002070938004180789,
-0.13295258581638336,
-0.596211850643158,
-0.09007524698972702,
0.512175440788269,
0.6075010299682617,
0.31892532110214233,
-0.476398229598999,
-0.2468840479850769,
-0.8685510158538818,
-0.060399506241083145,
-0.4054067134857178,
0.2874857187271118,
0.8278887271881104,
0.05587020516395569,
-0.05927541106939316,
0.8812814950942993,
-0.4306289851665497,
-0.5176544189453125,
-0.1333473175764084,
0.031348153948783875,
0.18690551817417145,
0.24275542795658112,
0.4258081018924713,
-0.5457847118377686,
-0.53883296251297,
0.09838401526212692,
-0.33324578404426575,
0.13066071271896362,
0.05773355811834335,
0.05701610818505287,
0.6121227741241455,
-0.1619115024805069,
-0.21296121180057526,
0.38227811455726624,
0.4621574580669403,
-0.03790616616606712,
0.4688252806663513,
-0.4480476677417755,
0.16066984832286835,
-0.3043661117553711,
-0.045204609632492065,
-0.14774562418460846,
-0.11185050010681152,
-0.449811190366745,
0.10022585839033127,
-0.09388410300016403,
0.091048464179039,
-0.24690435826778412,
0.6655448079109192,
-0.20788462460041046,
-0.458892285823822,
-0.49294599890708923,
0.10349199175834656,
-0.21958328783512115,
0.9372525811195374,
0.288679838180542,
0.7282255291938782,
0.20804612338542938,
-0.6214097738265991,
0.24780510365962982,
0.14349143207073212,
-0.1354053020477295,
0.4343370497226715,
-0.4342435598373413,
0.2127704918384552,
-0.3104243576526642,
0.3492225706577301,
-0.900206446647644,
-0.0014631419908255339,
0.5371935367584229,
-0.5072131752967834,
0.27142682671546936,
-0.1656002253293991,
-0.08631736785173416,
-0.23300686478614807,
-0.6022167801856995,
0.28254762291908264,
0.44541606307029724,
-0.5309330224990845,
0.3998051583766937,
0.390256404876709,
0.23111172020435333,
-0.9492577910423279,
-0.27654632925987244,
-0.06432045251131058,
-0.19602683186531067,
-0.21790891885757446,
0.5545539855957031,
-0.3530527949333191,
-0.16585883498191833,
0.03974409028887749,
-0.09493061155080795,
-0.026075728237628937,
0.16549430787563324,
0.04372318089008331,
0.31929832696914673,
0.16376325488090515,
0.3025592267513275,
-0.2363731414079666,
-0.3096330463886261,
-0.23533771932125092,
-0.44874829053878784,
0.5288671851158142,
-0.0809115320444107,
-0.19355042278766632,
-0.33941584825515747,
0.4383300542831421,
0.04315438121557236,
-0.1603781133890152,
0.24905726313591003,
0.270507276058197,
-0.04144393652677536,
-0.2512880265712738,
-0.43985792994499207,
-0.1509692668914795,
-0.34877312183380127,
0.2855374813079834,
-0.19410014152526855,
-0.8366456031799316,
0.25324392318725586,
0.04440019652247429,
0.29356005787849426,
0.3580567240715027,
0.5306096076965332,
-0.16551834344863892,
1.0264288187026978,
0.6129887104034424,
-0.45662209391593933,
0.36531227827072144,
-0.2679380774497986,
-0.07974990457296371,
-0.569751501083374,
-0.31936508417129517,
-0.3998654782772064,
-0.38619470596313477,
-0.6593360304832458,
-0.12908732891082764,
0.421996146440506,
-0.07241763919591904,
-0.5140063166618347,
0.025139855220913887,
-0.3621409833431244,
0.7243301272392273,
0.5835732817649841,
0.3228136897087097,
0.21255172789096832,
-0.15061144530773163,
-0.14287103712558746,
-0.031551260501146317,
-0.7830733060836792,
-0.008416418917477131,
1.1585896015167236,
0.3264390528202057,
0.834442138671875,
0.3377362787723541,
0.9669817090034485,
0.5190410017967224,
0.4085545241832733,
-1.007171869277954,
0.09502064436674118,
0.06772637367248535,
-0.37714555859565735,
-0.7389363050460815,
-0.4641721248626709,
-0.7655636072158813,
0.1361018419265747,
-0.4381469786167145,
-0.677655816078186,
0.11695056408643723,
0.3887062668800354,
-0.5112168788909912,
0.3008553981781006,
-0.22996245324611664,
0.5358171463012695,
-0.43194273114204407,
-0.5161300301551819,
-0.45238015055656433,
-0.7257487773895264,
0.4485851526260376,
0.3532397449016571,
0.1291540116071701,
-0.05538846179842949,
-0.18231526017189026,
0.5995705723762512,
-0.34389016032218933,
0.3190515339374542,
-0.3766249120235443,
-0.13540901243686676,
0.20472516119480133,
0.012136938981711864,
0.8495439291000366,
-0.027716096490621567,
-0.040627703070640564,
-0.3080853521823883,
-0.22927771508693695,
-0.4952356815338135,
-0.4572089612483978,
0.6256898641586304,
-1.102956771850586,
-0.40914541482925415,
-0.4443471431732178,
-0.5262621641159058,
-0.48718371987342834,
-0.251394659280777,
0.18977445363998413,
0.22472317516803741,
-0.2686610817909241,
-0.14644542336463928,
0.7589664459228516,
-0.21499235928058624,
0.4519725441932678,
0.5113986730575562,
-0.36147892475128174,
-0.6918345093727112,
0.9098620414733887,
-0.038331110030412674,
0.2757112681865692,
0.486476868391037,
0.5527499914169312,
-0.5386370420455933,
-0.4318225085735321,
-0.4787883162498474,
0.3337169587612152,
-0.4571010172367096,
-0.19239263236522675,
-0.09472993016242981,
0.07636034488677979,
0.09045916050672531,
-0.14763830602169037,
-0.2571752071380615,
-0.08820317685604095,
-0.08830274641513824,
0.20147007703781128,
0.14581824839115143,
0.78151935338974,
-0.1495404988527298,
0.42505943775177,
-0.22955094277858734,
0.03595656156539917,
0.4693275988101959,
0.5804587006568909,
0.11652646213769913,
-0.48850327730178833,
-0.09697958827018738,
-0.07211292535066605,
-0.2976512014865875,
-0.9525460600852966,
0.23597657680511475,
0.21300601959228516,
0.5514500141143799,
0.4983762502670288,
0.005978609900921583,
0.5617943406105042,
-0.2989997863769531,
0.478620320558548,
0.25944700837135315,
-0.6607312560081482,
0.247623473405838,
-0.3098830580711365,
-0.05369942635297775,
0.6181555986404419,
0.30554866790771484,
-0.6179478168487549,
0.29465726017951965,
-0.6421822905540466,
-0.605696439743042,
0.8348689079284668,
-0.26041117310523987,
-0.1978403925895691,
0.17673739790916443,
0.5068157315254211,
0.022474106401205063,
0.2787613868713379,
-0.5223541259765625,
-0.28430604934692383,
0.13563674688339233,
0.27084970474243164,
-0.15434327721595764,
-0.4537034034729004,
-0.343818336725235,
0.16962331533432007,
1.011494755744934,
-0.2884049713611603,
0.25710105895996094,
0.08247723430395126,
-0.0748865082859993,
-0.44876593351364136,
0.30130258202552795,
0.9110637307167053,
0.3933790326118469,
-0.47829797863960266,
-0.32214704155921936,
0.16523237526416779,
0.09257432073354721,
0.4279070496559143,
-0.09143589437007904,
-0.32935813069343567,
-0.38396960496902466,
-0.05737810209393501,
0.7730605006217957,
0.40445229411125183,
-0.5326992273330688,
0.6110774874687195,
-0.13054409623146057,
-0.4837966859340668,
-0.027740977704524994,
-0.08346126228570938,
-0.13015955686569214,
0.32636740803718567,
0.35374367237091064,
-0.03758709877729416,
0.11405327916145325,
-0.5273319482803345,
0.1269497275352478,
0.7878514528274536,
-0.7441491484642029,
0.018835995346307755,
0.473304808139801,
0.16317005455493927,
-0.3878639340400696,
0.20640869438648224,
-0.3966822326183319,
-0.5515100955963135,
0.515595555305481,
0.7063164710998535,
0.792753279209137,
-0.16906467080116272,
0.5933669209480286,
0.3410530686378479,
0.08383336663246155,
-0.25254690647125244,
0.21493971347808838,
-0.366214394569397,
-0.6613368391990662,
-0.4824758768081665,
-0.42879989743232727,
-0.8995011448860168,
-0.07083549350500107,
-0.5053189992904663,
0.017461299896240234,
-0.7730111479759216,
-0.021922517567873,
-0.3235231935977936,
0.5766574740409851,
-0.41291970014572144,
-0.01078952569514513,
0.16446709632873535,
0.5208786129951477,
-0.5406097769737244,
0.628704845905304,
0.3368309438228607,
-0.35011327266693115,
-0.7527980208396912,
-0.07429322600364685,
0.1537923961877823,
-0.9717879891395569,
0.37088829278945923,
-0.2964667081832886,
-0.09569736570119858,
0.006530915852636099,
-0.49505186080932617,
-0.8668505549430847,
0.9783285856246948,
0.34138962626457214,
-0.4618566036224365,
0.04509517922997475,
-0.14622218906879425,
0.13919492065906525,
-0.45898908376693726,
0.33300623297691345,
0.6829872727394104,
0.5257757902145386,
0.33971062302589417,
-0.8290215134620667,
-0.30579322576522827,
0.24218463897705078,
0.16357360780239105,
0.41488611698150635,
-0.773707389831543,
0.5560922026634216,
-0.5849014520645142,
-0.04863286018371582,
0.018514135852456093,
0.5663068294525146,
0.30172955989837646,
0.03989144414663315,
0.6085443496704102,
0.6714174151420593,
0.6590100526809692,
0.02940347231924534,
0.9711120128631592,
0.03968972712755203,
0.6205553412437439,
0.9691916108131409,
-0.3893626630306244,
0.6288229823112488,
0.3979005515575409,
-0.37685614824295044,
0.36777767539024353,
0.8442004323005676,
0.24567313492298126,
0.863499104976654,
0.515744686126709,
-0.3122367858886719,
-0.16767063736915588,
-0.4380161464214325,
-0.15725168585777283,
0.45252928137779236,
-0.08733014017343521,
0.02877912111580372,
-0.4751659631729126,
-0.19364479184150696,
0.2678546607494354,
0.1859966218471527,
-0.43779438734054565,
1.0836390256881714,
-0.29816684126853943,
-0.9171507954597473,
0.41307058930397034,
0.09374595433473587,
0.8176156878471375,
-0.7642675042152405,
-0.07161326706409454,
-0.25636276602745056,
0.1861872375011444,
0.0020483757834881544,
-0.5464175343513489,
-0.06622006744146347,
-0.3266392648220062,
-0.04073266685009003,
0.039555445313453674,
0.49123021960258484,
-0.6838582158088684,
0.15812429785728455,
0.4252966642379761,
0.03558140620589256,
-0.08400030434131622,
0.1790686696767807,
-0.6975042819976807,
0.05941476672887802,
0.1116364523768425,
-0.13326382637023926,
0.5177932977676392,
-0.26643821597099304,
-0.1444718986749649,
0.6149978041648865,
0.5055987238883972,
0.26253533363342285,
-0.5644209384918213,
-0.10088672488927841,
0.608822226524353,
-0.4173060357570648,
-0.7010206580162048,
-0.8117905259132385,
0.15756095945835114,
0.14517425000667572,
-0.38286110758781433,
0.15379580855369568,
0.3751489818096161,
0.6476054787635803,
0.13833042979240417,
0.7700851559638977,
0.28933340311050415,
0.25967031717300415,
-0.3168788552284241,
0.37378787994384766,
-0.6215699911117554,
0.008912806399166584,
-0.11648597568273544,
-0.8346046805381775,
-0.23122456669807434,
0.44414615631103516,
-0.2914046049118042,
-0.23056747019290924,
0.2670409679412842,
0.7004640102386475,
0.5110322833061218,
-0.13525432348251343,
0.4456207752227783,
-0.16295360028743744,
0.3288522958755493,
0.9125092029571533,
0.62290358543396,
-0.17233829200267792,
0.535205602645874,
-0.2856104373931885,
-0.43951305747032166,
-0.3528546094894409,
-0.9714247584342957,
-0.4905496835708618,
-0.3550167977809906,
0.02799724042415619,
-0.3993823230266571,
0.3231833279132843,
1.4014954566955566,
0.3613710403442383,
-0.5569080710411072,
-0.6536339521408081,
0.2077023684978485,
0.3879816234111786,
-0.40987899899482727,
-0.1803298145532608,
0.3379620313644409,
-0.5018109083175659,
-0.3643893301486969,
0.3678492605686188,
0.4566088914871216,
-0.08203544467687607,
-0.3632816970348358,
-0.7344110608100891,
-0.3134823441505432,
0.27361243963241577,
0.4623053967952728,
0.748048722743988,
-0.8661670684814453,
-0.42858606576919556,
-0.032864365726709366,
0.03381066024303436,
0.13349880278110504,
0.6889249086380005,
-0.7750893831253052,
0.6210218667984009,
0.10425276309251785,
0.844928503036499,
0.6984210014343262,
0.07865478843450546,
0.46946898102760315,
-0.5273169279098511,
-0.03138970211148262,
0.3460683226585388,
0.07003858685493469,
0.17896711826324463,
-0.2726202607154846,
0.5832315683364868,
0.14494141936302185,
-0.7831400036811829,
-0.6775051951408386,
0.3122880756855011,
-0.7479135990142822,
-0.09982505440711975,
1.0307317972183228,
0.09087526798248291,
-0.22090424597263336,
0.21724189817905426,
-0.3530866801738739,
-0.0383877158164978,
-0.7354651093482971,
0.9636648893356323,
0.4643305242061615,
-0.29205751419067383,
-0.1558651179075241,
-0.19054533541202545,
0.927699089050293,
0.3730041980743408,
-0.589678168296814,
-0.05441277474164963,
0.3533872365951538,
0.14073379337787628,
-0.06565225124359131,
0.9839503169059753,
0.12947940826416016,
0.5364599227905273,
-0.3573741018772125,
0.22970914840698242,
-0.044699233025312424,
-0.4297237694263458,
-0.47008204460144043,
0.1291854828596115,
0.3788289427757263,
-0.1823587268590927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00608v1 | Efficient Personalized Text-to-image Generation by Leveraging Textual Subspace | 2024-06-30T06:41:21 | 2024-06-30T06:41:21 | Shian Du, Xiaotian Cheng, Qi Qian, Henglu Wei, Yi Xu, Xiangyang Ji | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Personalized text-to-image generation has attracted unprecedented attention
in the recent few years due to its unique capability of generating
highly-personalized images via using the input concept dataset and novel
textual prompt. However, previous methods solely focus on the performance of
the reconstruction task, degrading its ability to combine with different
textual prompt. Besides, optimizing in the high-dimensional embedding space
usually leads to unnecessary time-consuming training process and slow
convergence. To address these issues, we propose an efficient method to explore
the target embedding in a textual subspace, drawing inspiration from the
self-expressiveness property. Additionally, we propose an efficient selection
strategy for determining the basis vectors of the textual subspace. The
experimental evaluations demonstrate that the learned embedding can not only
faithfully reconstruct input image, but also significantly improves its
alignment with novel input textual prompt. Furthermore, we observe that
optimizing in the textual subspace leads to an significant improvement of the
robustness to the initial word, relaxing the constraint that requires users to
input the most relevant initial word. Our method opens the door to more
efficient representation learning for personalized text-to-image generation. | [
-0.4761043190956116,
-0.5190830826759338,
0.8875240683555603,
0.12289426475763321,
-0.603864312171936,
0.19191884994506836,
-0.42013439536094666,
-0.1256946325302124,
0.471881628036499,
0.41120463609695435,
-0.5711456537246704,
-0.7045292854309082,
-0.5498582720756531,
0.299251526594162,
-0.19702547788619995,
0.7155129313468933,
0.1262304186820984,
-0.5093096494674683,
-0.5790129899978638,
-0.0866682156920433,
-1.0086379051208496,
-0.26553452014923096,
-0.308052659034729,
0.15666988492012024,
0.3724901080131531,
0.4654148817062378,
0.21262818574905396,
0.8113157153129578,
0.3528720438480377,
0.3390415608882904,
0.23278796672821045,
0.4789440929889679,
-0.6420249938964844,
0.556509256362915,
-0.22512704133987427,
-0.20384705066680908,
0.140775665640831,
-0.38665229082107544,
0.45863303542137146,
0.24697309732437134,
0.1940723955631256,
0.059635091572999954,
0.11654449254274368,
0.44958987832069397,
-0.6534209251403809,
-0.12237001955509186,
-0.7295311689376831,
0.3032582998275757,
-0.18436144292354584,
-0.5994166731834412,
-0.5777829885482788,
-0.3231726288795471,
0.08220050483942032,
-0.8850018978118896,
0.3962916135787964,
-0.16555213928222656,
0.6254742741584778,
0.1473611295223236,
-0.26027733087539673,
-0.2661356031894684,
-0.704004168510437,
0.7262570858001709,
-0.17750902473926544,
0.26080557703971863,
0.3364909589290619,
0.2818533480167389,
0.20630910992622375,
-1.0147682428359985,
-0.3632124960422516,
-0.03371710330247879,
-0.08810941129922867,
0.2793854773044586,
-0.26730045676231384,
-0.17210932075977325,
-0.04306980222463608,
0.13284005224704742,
-0.4371323585510254,
-0.15828758478164673,
-0.03813907504081726,
-0.2136984020471573,
0.2808273732662201,
0.13914625346660614,
0.324371337890625,
-0.40356960892677307,
-0.6555469632148743,
-0.38472896814346313,
-0.379400372505188,
-0.13939857482910156,
0.22331205010414124,
0.20828461647033691,
0.16074997186660767,
0.4979599714279175,
0.03128693997859955,
0.5137398838996887,
0.4130897521972656,
-0.016327587887644768,
0.3947093188762665,
-0.38169029355049133,
0.1006280854344368,
-0.15281958878040314,
0.9224426746368408,
0.4769178032875061,
-0.011411327868700027,
-0.3437380790710449,
-0.15287601947784424,
-0.14232110977172852,
0.40958964824676514,
-0.8907255530357361,
0.04282497987151146,
-0.039519019424915314,
-0.4539087116718292,
-0.5800663828849792,
0.0644335225224495,
-0.8299992680549622,
-0.03759905695915222,
-0.22891616821289062,
0.23355628550052643,
-0.4927848279476166,
0.332542359828949,
-0.3238365948200226,
-0.21612854301929474,
-0.12123822420835495,
0.366887629032135,
-0.9273282289505005,
0.031665876507759094,
0.3100362718105316,
0.6849008202552795,
-0.3128345310688019,
0.03339739143848419,
-0.569815456867218,
0.26347053050994873,
-0.46448084712028503,
0.9659550786018372,
-0.49273473024368286,
-0.6003406643867493,
-0.002010950120165944,
-0.36144116520881653,
0.23546604812145233,
-0.4396049380302429,
0.47597700357437134,
-0.3385855555534363,
0.5384787321090698,
-0.4528951346874237,
-0.516973078250885,
0.15671247243881226,
0.10525932908058167,
-0.39621275663375854,
1.07993745803833,
0.07998282462358475,
-0.7035071849822998,
0.40520086884498596,
-0.25443965196609497,
-0.35278555750846863,
0.22817064821720123,
-0.7451437711715698,
-0.7217357158660889,
0.33047059178352356,
0.5778980255126953,
0.8952856659889221,
-0.22052203118801117,
0.18462859094142914,
-0.10192210227251053,
-0.1172935739159584,
0.1896647959947586,
-0.2889697551727295,
0.03972514718770981,
0.1774260699748993,
-0.27261778712272644,
-0.10317913442850113,
-0.8213792443275452,
0.07800133526325226,
0.5379068851470947,
-0.2203124314546585,
-0.786430299282074,
0.02539953961968422,
0.21244259178638458,
0.06671398878097534,
0.5207154750823975,
-0.6608554720878601,
0.20696961879730225,
-0.2673282027244568,
0.06626758724451065,
0.8964369893074036,
0.18079295754432678,
0.5119167566299438,
-0.2447309046983719,
0.6058663725852966,
-0.34465286135673523,
-0.5370509624481201,
-0.8814995288848877,
-0.25582653284072876,
-0.3446228504180908,
-0.5565989017486572,
0.31043538451194763,
0.3394660949707031,
-0.9077092409133911,
0.6832730174064636,
-0.3328903317451477,
-0.2363336831331253,
-0.03682538494467735,
0.14278124272823334,
0.49022653698921204,
0.6224836707115173,
0.38092711567878723,
-0.39271265268325806,
-0.2699558436870575,
-0.9290552139282227,
-0.21121473610401154,
0.04511772096157074,
-0.05890258029103279,
0.6438336968421936,
0.07676449418067932,
-0.0962361991405487,
1.1037578582763672,
-0.9647436141967773,
-0.5460858345031738,
-0.21538372337818146,
0.16444538533687592,
-0.2474195510149002,
0.40909868478775024,
1.0108156204223633,
-0.6453931927680969,
-0.6172533631324768,
0.2536351680755615,
-0.8075473308563232,
-0.12884998321533203,
-0.5209823846817017,
-0.3523406684398651,
-0.2752056121826172,
0.4253012537956238,
-0.49154987931251526,
0.3726310729980469,
0.2730772793292999,
-0.5705878138542175,
0.19512993097305298,
-0.45633992552757263,
0.1213286891579628,
-1.6437984704971313,
-0.025540972128510475,
0.01888405531644821,
-0.7024478912353516,
-0.4590150713920593,
0.20219285786151886,
0.09128721803426743,
-0.32245755195617676,
-0.040280215442180634,
0.48949095606803894,
-0.5125872492790222,
0.05111442506313324,
-0.28554391860961914,
0.21398276090621948,
0.2441139966249466,
0.5188266038894653,
0.052500251680612564,
0.5721928477287292,
0.3698728084564209,
-0.2938317358493805,
-0.08672776073217392,
0.6622872352600098,
-0.0724104642868042,
0.6083997488021851,
-0.5206548571586609,
0.515780508518219,
-0.40576907992362976,
0.18358737230300903,
-1.038570761680603,
-0.23312100768089294,
0.22147254645824432,
-0.5240811705589294,
0.4995381236076355,
0.3687484562397003,
-0.3039498031139374,
0.14350935816764832,
-0.4822428226470947,
0.49981561303138733,
0.556563675403595,
-0.7858151197433472,
0.7433617115020752,
0.008866613730788231,
-0.1373065859079361,
-0.38217025995254517,
-0.6537686586380005,
0.2585187256336212,
-0.12141115963459015,
-0.5187795162200928,
0.8717578649520874,
0.11367037892341614,
0.39225882291793823,
0.04043981432914734,
0.3009950816631317,
0.12363334000110626,
-0.046717237681150436,
0.06659462302923203,
-0.07008539885282516,
-0.08162792026996613,
0.3382631540298462,
0.578853189945221,
-0.20144115388393402,
-0.014640173874795437,
-0.2614661455154419,
0.5153201222419739,
0.3472028076648712,
-0.17639893293380737,
-0.518571674823761,
0.7657133340835571,
0.16885611414909363,
-0.49117258191108704,
0.277131587266922,
0.6616017818450928,
-0.3544996380805969,
-0.4393310248851776,
-0.34431710839271545,
-0.07382584363222122,
-0.5198007822036743,
0.5449366569519043,
-0.3909226059913635,
-0.710530698299408,
0.10048378258943558,
-0.2204122394323349,
0.02717774175107479,
0.38962581753730774,
0.7640784978866577,
-0.2649424970149994,
0.6220824718475342,
0.6898223161697388,
0.24128544330596924,
0.6551557779312134,
-0.24845412373542786,
-0.01798398233950138,
-0.8165102005004883,
-0.26292699575424194,
-0.37141576409339905,
-0.3207392990589142,
-0.4337085783481598,
-0.784397542476654,
0.32874783873558044,
-0.570013701915741,
0.1266707479953766,
0.43534281849861145,
-0.7435802817344666,
0.298610657453537,
0.42284178733825684,
0.519169807434082,
0.33814212679862976,
0.6257913112640381,
-0.3052663803100586,
-0.5537316799163818,
-0.45242077112197876,
-0.3929227590560913,
1.1273337602615356,
0.34617191553115845,
0.5367454886436462,
-0.06312631815671921,
1.2689692974090576,
0.23283469676971436,
0.10040883719921112,
-0.6938910484313965,
0.5875886082649231,
-0.5660625100135803,
-0.04281723499298096,
-0.039569154381752014,
-0.3800401985645294,
-1.092415690422058,
0.2774800956249237,
-0.5374345779418945,
-0.4544930160045624,
0.4054901599884033,
0.37334588170051575,
-0.20169734954833984,
0.055572107434272766,
-0.5933822393417358,
0.6269775629043579,
-0.15330870449543,
-0.438909113407135,
-0.11258690804243088,
-0.4209165573120117,
0.0360635444521904,
-0.2588847875595093,
-0.056956298649311066,
-0.02356600947678089,
-0.23481592535972595,
0.43720120191574097,
-0.3902692198753357,
0.8731307983398438,
-0.19781026244163513,
0.030086001381278038,
0.016158048063516617,
0.10123398900032043,
0.36211416125297546,
0.052124422043561935,
0.19801640510559082,
-0.21468903124332428,
-0.5096144676208496,
-0.10460306704044342,
-0.7923394441604614,
0.5568271279335022,
-0.5156267881393433,
-0.3306976556777954,
-0.09706513583660126,
-0.21604429185390472,
-0.22449810802936554,
0.18353290855884552,
0.8760185241699219,
0.815738320350647,
-0.6930486559867859,
0.2862997055053711,
0.799884021282196,
-0.5130369067192078,
0.42732545733451843,
-0.34213605523109436,
-0.2284233719110489,
-0.7182372808456421,
1.317155122756958,
-0.24676087498664856,
0.01158124953508377,
0.8725959062576294,
0.29256901144981384,
-0.24234460294246674,
-0.3293019235134125,
-0.5849655866622925,
0.10145754367113113,
-0.7494296431541443,
-0.47862884402275085,
-0.8155642747879028,
0.23008908331394196,
-0.06566169857978821,
-0.46405157446861267,
-0.38182246685028076,
-0.3361562490463257,
-0.7853308916091919,
0.1607680767774582,
0.15495623648166656,
0.5050836801528931,
0.4392956793308258,
0.26847538352012634,
-0.624845564365387,
0.5480733513832092,
0.4397178590297699,
-0.012171858921647072,
-0.09819771349430084,
-0.4339522123336792,
0.05898866429924965,
-0.3804844319820404,
-0.5952084064483643,
-0.9308792352676392,
0.3353416621685028,
0.5507878661155701,
0.3508509695529938,
0.4072915017604828,
0.015942556783556938,
0.441026508808136,
-0.697282612323761,
0.49253585934638977,
0.5270004272460938,
-0.8168878555297852,
0.6656193733215332,
-0.42128700017929077,
0.5132074356079102,
0.40342140197753906,
0.10336160659790039,
-0.2566879987716675,
-0.3679039776325226,
-0.46383124589920044,
-0.877838671207428,
0.07181858271360397,
0.5367042422294617,
0.647672176361084,
0.04442145302891731,
0.45288434624671936,
0.21490754187107086,
0.12750042974948883,
-0.6144307255744934,
-0.07887917757034302,
-0.25988975167274475,
-0.754795253276825,
-0.024106096476316452,
-0.21391841769218445,
0.025826431810855865,
-0.07946222275495529,
0.14314426481723785,
-0.5332642793655396,
0.7408148050308228,
0.4403286576271057,
-0.0471375435590744,
0.09744824469089508,
0.00870828703045845,
0.4535912275314331,
0.2716657519340515,
0.2912285327911377,
-0.12054037302732468,
-0.07296339422464371,
-0.4965711832046509,
0.23099659383296967,
0.06227118521928787,
-0.30815553665161133,
0.3395635187625885,
0.48080408573150635,
1.04753839969635,
0.2182890921831131,
-0.4549023509025574,
0.9768142700195312,
-0.4512653350830078,
-0.4355425238609314,
-0.3397938013076782,
-0.16866736114025116,
-0.21535617113113403,
0.04696012660861015,
0.46704837679862976,
0.3610013425350189,
0.256813108921051,
-0.21318301558494568,
0.07966846972703934,
0.5183396339416504,
-0.10527927428483963,
-0.20761162042617798,
0.8328027129173279,
0.3071201741695404,
-0.17926983535289764,
0.27356579899787903,
-0.19292183220386505,
-0.4128877818584442,
0.3714776337146759,
0.710125207901001,
1.1432770490646362,
-0.000534535851329565,
0.4875054657459259,
0.267570436000824,
0.12876947224140167,
0.43218696117401123,
0.19985538721084595,
-0.23161061108112335,
-0.6873052716255188,
-0.29855644702911377,
-0.3331587314605713,
-0.17570559680461884,
-0.3321181833744049,
-0.4599734842777252,
0.4571024775505066,
-0.6197147369384766,
-0.28950202465057373,
-0.13736069202423096,
-0.4751197397708893,
-0.7224894165992737,
0.4124825894832611,
0.12674686312675476,
0.6243125200271606,
-0.6294543743133545,
0.3356243669986725,
0.86751788854599,
0.09482545405626297,
-0.5769352912902832,
0.3485097289085388,
-0.3209730386734009,
-0.6286600232124329,
0.38379329442977905,
0.2845219373703003,
-0.04576507955789566,
0.05305285006761551,
-0.4257572889328003,
-0.6266244649887085,
1.2039039134979248,
0.5168782472610474,
-0.530653715133667,
-0.029247021302580833,
-0.0837724581360817,
0.5811668634414673,
-0.7133333086967468,
0.007632151711732149,
0.12978528439998627,
0.09156971424818039,
0.01889690011739731,
-0.18060141801834106,
0.4059450626373291,
-0.23718880116939545,
0.6308512091636658,
0.1898118406534195,
-0.4635680615901947,
0.4404209554195404,
-0.23737937211990356,
-0.2691224217414856,
0.23170916736125946,
0.9984959363937378,
0.2932911813259125,
0.2949289083480835,
0.6848136782646179,
0.4459831416606903,
0.6084992289543152,
0.008210644125938416,
1.0645935535430908,
-0.13947202265262604,
0.283904105424881,
0.8029487729072571,
0.18238651752471924,
0.7728261947631836,
0.3685861825942993,
0.24654367566108704,
0.5923902988433838,
0.43763118982315063,
-0.09357982128858566,
0.8989319801330566,
-0.2048417329788208,
-0.22656948864459991,
-0.28684544563293457,
0.04224994033575058,
-0.2931537926197052,
0.6513199806213379,
0.27461928129196167,
-0.8223360180854797,
-0.17345507442951202,
0.23720522224903107,
-0.2589240074157715,
0.6339587569236755,
0.06685300171375275,
0.8106582164764404,
-0.1372804045677185,
-0.5654985308647156,
0.3044675886631012,
0.12577728927135468,
0.584912896156311,
-0.42535799741744995,
-0.13348506391048431,
-0.11062058806419373,
-0.0293777696788311,
-0.12818683683872223,
-0.5292341113090515,
0.10319042205810547,
-0.09174709022045135,
-0.0763612613081932,
-0.5880506634712219,
1.1805622577667236,
-0.39618638157844543,
-0.48106199502944946,
0.052313245832920074,
0.37567421793937683,
-0.2551068067550659,
0.034146569669246674,
-0.2581222653388977,
0.08828206360340118,
0.13222242891788483,
-0.19165389239788055,
0.2262207716703415,
0.48101118206977844,
0.15840613842010498,
0.23769153654575348,
0.4984510838985443,
-0.14725427329540253,
-0.18456603586673737,
-0.24310757219791412,
1.0256261825561523,
-0.6456447839736938,
-0.7776558995246887,
-0.6306642889976501,
0.5865027904510498,
-0.19795727729797363,
-0.7577491402626038,
0.3160667419433594,
0.36251088976860046,
0.5332256555557251,
-0.4714335501194,
1.1243723630905151,
-0.2081853300333023,
0.356945276260376,
-0.6752570867538452,
0.5129130482673645,
-0.6438209414482117,
0.019833682104945183,
-0.6337540149688721,
-0.8545599579811096,
-0.10330002009868622,
0.6941986083984375,
-0.005308681633323431,
0.18527813255786896,
0.7189062833786011,
0.4463539123535156,
-0.09746713936328888,
-0.0838116928935051,
0.4213162064552307,
-0.2027420550584793,
0.3534347712993622,
0.27896398305892944,
0.6905128359794617,
-0.2958354651927948,
0.21291100978851318,
-0.5683598518371582,
-0.2716788947582245,
-0.12401686608791351,
-1.1316337585449219,
-0.887545108795166,
-0.8483466506004333,
-0.3236953020095825,
-0.1436409205198288,
-0.2293282002210617,
1.1131783723831177,
0.5313321352005005,
-0.32572075724601746,
0.10762186348438263,
-0.033614885061979294,
-0.3089185357093811,
0.08327460289001465,
-0.17927072942256927,
0.414608895778656,
-0.44837072491645813,
-0.7130521535873413,
0.327250212430954,
0.3807069659233093,
0.02211747132241726,
-0.2596648037433624,
0.1725037842988968,
0.23011299967765808,
-0.043797291815280914,
0.8318009972572327,
0.14608703553676605,
-0.26323843002319336,
-0.14222952723503113,
0.21666936576366425,
-0.16313236951828003,
0.2057732492685318,
1.0931785106658936,
-0.7852712869644165,
0.6366196870803833,
0.5847722887992859,
1.1786439418792725,
0.5644570589065552,
0.2840307056903839,
0.8134015798568726,
-1.2715579271316528,
0.03470064327120781,
0.17578960955142975,
0.24643468856811523,
0.5384357571601868,
-0.771407961845398,
0.059853482991456985,
0.347860723733902,
-0.4081227481365204,
-0.4615519940853119,
0.15307094156742096,
-1.1591161489486694,
-0.32041752338409424,
0.9422616958618164,
-0.11674299836158752,
-0.09861612319946289,
0.3994796574115753,
-0.6025090217590332,
0.0032991475891321898,
-0.41727814078330994,
0.631767749786377,
0.3897327184677124,
-0.12339147925376892,
-0.1462477445602417,
-0.17747390270233154,
0.18611183762550354,
0.5728552937507629,
-0.8738057017326355,
-0.3130963444709778,
0.4057196080684662,
0.1672268956899643,
0.19308283925056458,
0.7364226579666138,
0.14015965163707733,
0.30676305294036865,
-0.30389708280563354,
-0.039868082851171494,
-0.04470541328191757,
-0.2914827764034271,
-0.25939664244651794,
0.23929251730442047,
0.05838557332754135,
-0.5013249516487122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00581v1 | MasonTigers at SemEval-2024 Task 10: Emotion Discovery and Flip Reasoning in Conversation with Ensemble of Transformers and Prompting | 2024-06-30T03:59:04 | 2024-06-30T03:59:04 | Al Nahian Bin Emran, Amrita Ganguly, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present MasonTigers' participation in SemEval-2024 Task 10,
a shared task aimed at identifying emotions and understanding the rationale
behind their flips within monolingual English and Hindi-English code-mixed
dialogues. This task comprises three distinct subtasks - emotion recognition in
conversation for Hindi-English code-mixed dialogues, emotion flip reasoning for
Hindi-English code-mixed dialogues, and emotion flip reasoning for English
dialogues. Our team, MasonTigers, contributed to each subtask, focusing on
developing methods for accurate emotion recognition and reasoning. By
leveraging our approaches, we attained impressive F1-scores of 0.78 for the
first task and 0.79 for both the second and third tasks. This performance not
only underscores the effectiveness of our methods across different aspects of
the task but also secured us the top rank in the first and third subtasks, and
the 2nd rank in the second subtask. Through extensive experimentation and
analysis, we provide insights into our system's performance and contributions
to each subtask. | [
-0.7178230285644531,
-0.31400126218795776,
0.4091508388519287,
0.4390011429786682,
-0.18160699307918549,
0.33920353651046753,
-0.14801684021949768,
-0.5249502062797546,
0.4784221947193146,
0.20209141075611115,
-0.885227382183075,
-0.4089539051055908,
-0.6064528226852417,
0.5178782939910889,
-0.17687879502773285,
0.8911398649215698,
-0.08123282343149185,
0.15774321556091309,
-0.27054688334465027,
-0.28548339009284973,
-0.27278319001197815,
-0.3588646650314331,
-0.7102086544036865,
-0.4395184814929962,
0.37791213393211365,
0.8529360294342041,
0.39609411358833313,
-0.2609274983406067,
0.21773329377174377,
0.2846706807613373,
-0.04611192271113396,
-0.09594248980283737,
-0.4316153824329376,
0.35578522086143494,
-0.32510921359062195,
-0.24498572945594788,
-0.3188055455684662,
0.06013095751404762,
-0.02062169834971428,
0.16700264811515808,
0.018484603613615036,
0.3113182485103607,
0.011965125799179077,
0.6632148623466492,
-0.7572078704833984,
0.3347970247268677,
-0.16944733262062073,
0.2628835141658783,
-0.04651582986116409,
-0.5871171355247498,
-0.4767203629016876,
-0.3470597565174103,
0.10158945620059967,
-0.25629305839538574,
0.04759347438812256,
-0.0881795808672905,
0.5784281492233276,
0.4056205153465271,
-0.8070669174194336,
-0.40625306963920593,
-0.4933653771877289,
0.7408068180084229,
-0.4586394429206848,
0.21343426406383514,
0.21669398248195648,
0.21462342143058777,
0.3019881248474121,
-0.5496852397918701,
-0.4468024969100952,
0.354251891374588,
-0.10787274688482285,
0.5747973918914795,
-0.2361389547586441,
-0.028461650013923645,
0.22515708208084106,
0.37371429800987244,
-0.43817469477653503,
-0.24822278320789337,
-0.32116782665252686,
-0.309853196144104,
0.8600847721099854,
0.3788711726665497,
0.3099469244480133,
-0.041681937873363495,
-0.2872332036495209,
-0.20340843498706818,
-0.5779592394828796,
0.39812612533569336,
0.5824140906333923,
-0.07783466577529907,
-0.13763223588466644,
0.4512368142604828,
-0.4161573648452759,
0.013413929380476475,
0.26520347595214844,
0.32785969972610474,
0.4379870593547821,
-0.39959990978240967,
-0.22555263340473175,
0.2954162061214447,
0.6865089535713196,
0.2193787544965744,
0.29700228571891785,
0.2791951596736908,
-0.11522746086120605,
0.03022366762161255,
0.3604260981082916,
-0.6345502734184265,
-0.25710785388946533,
0.2461182326078415,
-0.4565623104572296,
-0.4540922939777374,
-0.23148739337921143,
-1.1573936939239502,
-0.6071076989173889,
-0.15545769035816193,
0.8647976517677307,
-0.2599791884422302,
-0.689768373966217,
-0.023546284064650536,
-0.06527645140886307,
0.5413501858711243,
0.5309041142463684,
-1.0346646308898926,
0.1541709452867508,
0.6212710738182068,
0.2612285614013672,
-0.2771625518798828,
-0.3709045648574829,
-0.29834628105163574,
-0.29725295305252075,
0.01770431362092495,
0.8002989888191223,
-0.7953172326087952,
-0.6564882397651672,
-0.054530464112758636,
0.18641233444213867,
-0.2631252110004425,
-0.43394899368286133,
0.7504740953445435,
-0.16082976758480072,
0.21542394161224365,
-0.34265512228012085,
-0.08032191544771194,
-0.4442519247531891,
0.5422980785369873,
-0.480815589427948,
1.2247744798660278,
-0.0805373564362526,
-0.843608558177948,
-0.01128668338060379,
-0.5275776982307434,
-0.6871377825737,
0.18945689499378204,
-0.19757363200187683,
-0.1657755970954895,
0.3515736162662506,
0.25073644518852234,
0.533606231212616,
-0.2899973690509796,
0.09980931878089905,
0.13911661505699158,
-0.5698453783988953,
-0.02712969295680523,
-0.23535583913326263,
0.6749553084373474,
0.1305033415555954,
-0.9231009483337402,
0.191290482878685,
-0.5579948425292969,
0.022732064127922058,
0.09742508083581924,
-0.0919385626912117,
-0.08764920383691788,
-0.21838323771953583,
-0.30429548025131226,
0.19345591962337494,
0.21505849063396454,
-0.46901071071624756,
0.23156946897506714,
-0.00726122222840786,
-0.07873618602752686,
0.7219786643981934,
0.17135097086429596,
0.515011191368103,
0.183715358376503,
1.086538553237915,
0.19094036519527435,
0.33104872703552246,
-0.38726067543029785,
-0.6159856915473938,
-1.1812916994094849,
0.15473327040672302,
-0.0871170312166214,
0.599627673625946,
-0.8528655171394348,
-0.23844923079013824,
0.010977013036608696,
-0.6391456127166748,
-0.4832230508327484,
-0.4207547903060913,
0.3976230323314667,
0.3548033535480499,
0.4736950695514679,
-0.09184830635786057,
-0.5692228674888611,
-0.9880238175392151,
-0.49747300148010254,
-0.23745855689048767,
0.3267670273780823,
0.1849033087491989,
0.541717529296875,
-0.3308270573616028,
0.4112355709075928,
-0.2597172260284424,
0.21978244185447693,
-0.4234265983104706,
0.6865581274032593,
0.04577511176466942,
0.38556137681007385,
0.1364179253578186,
-0.9533365368843079,
-0.5398255586624146,
-0.11184023320674896,
-0.6148115992546082,
-0.42338138818740845,
-0.10278970003128052,
-0.19098973274230957,
0.46737009286880493,
0.5089067220687866,
-0.06604225933551788,
0.7242629528045654,
0.8590883612632751,
-0.5416754484176636,
0.7015686631202698,
0.360465943813324,
0.7434477210044861,
-0.9789649844169617,
-0.2084057480096817,
-0.27607807517051697,
-0.18374359607696533,
-0.728462278842926,
-0.14546196162700653,
-0.010026762261986732,
-0.08627309650182724,
-0.5310419797897339,
0.4811081886291504,
-0.48200321197509766,
0.013482539914548397,
0.017198950052261353,
-0.3225494921207428,
-0.24798110127449036,
0.7886958122253418,
0.3035556674003601,
0.7250949740409851,
0.6749942898750305,
-0.4924694299697876,
0.44170668721199036,
0.14425671100616455,
-0.10479972511529922,
0.8022153377532959,
-0.5013259053230286,
0.249801903963089,
0.175983265042305,
-0.12282007187604904,
-1.0948275327682495,
-0.11962436139583588,
0.2367023378610611,
-0.7499010562896729,
0.3489502966403961,
-0.10270290821790695,
-0.09055982530117035,
-0.1900353729724884,
-0.2089308649301529,
0.5395950675010681,
0.6383671164512634,
-0.5550179481506348,
1.2058199644088745,
0.503365695476532,
-0.3620336055755615,
-0.47868382930755615,
-0.508709728717804,
0.06372550874948502,
-0.2756281793117523,
-0.8502382040023804,
-0.08939209580421448,
0.05517606809735298,
-0.12668688595294952,
-0.27552592754364014,
-0.45601674914360046,
0.19728268682956696,
-0.025053592398762703,
0.7152627110481262,
0.049834080040454865,
0.06604354828596115,
-0.17506757378578186,
0.04113423079252243,
-0.5451494455337524,
0.4059714078903198,
0.12097656726837158,
0.4769122302532196,
-0.6530624032020569,
-0.4346161484718323,
-0.18212059140205383,
0.3691250681877136,
0.5348411202430725,
-0.34021347761154175,
0.5263815522193909,
0.9130083322525024,
-0.23317405581474304,
-0.09564998745918274,
-0.5713036060333252,
-0.05413314700126648,
-0.47326937317848206,
0.08090261369943619,
-0.46755102276802063,
-1.2387664318084717,
0.5920417904853821,
-0.3054635524749756,
-0.22492465376853943,
0.5452350378036499,
0.8758851289749146,
-0.06160194054245949,
1.4274537563323975,
0.4511418044567108,
0.14347445964813232,
0.0689396858215332,
-0.17256411910057068,
0.6186299920082092,
-0.7258051037788391,
-0.7230480313301086,
-0.6512231230735779,
-0.5271860361099243,
-0.6581014394760132,
-0.39813968539237976,
0.7084642052650452,
-0.1942306011915207,
-0.01975109986960888,
0.45748287439346313,
-0.5031388998031616,
0.43409106135368347,
0.5327807068824768,
-0.40565958619117737,
0.1069682165980339,
-0.427939772605896,
-0.30259042978286743,
-0.10959558188915253,
-0.3828090727329254,
-0.29155367612838745,
0.3535217046737671,
0.18252770602703094,
0.9523683190345764,
0.2293786108493805,
1.0733031034469604,
0.04952540621161461,
0.04168533906340599,
-0.9291300773620605,
0.9455017447471619,
0.3414876163005829,
-0.49982643127441406,
-0.19343355298042297,
-0.23788997530937195,
-0.6173095703125,
0.09839162230491638,
0.0070552704855799675,
-0.7819547057151794,
0.23725372552871704,
0.026042981073260307,
-0.07062280923128128,
-0.1969238817691803,
-0.8126755356788635,
1.177188515663147,
-0.14204254746437073,
-0.3472110331058502,
-0.41088372468948364,
-0.7603501677513123,
0.4660521447658539,
0.16166944801807404,
0.2651899755001068,
-0.15415140986442566,
0.3111761808395386,
0.6618892550468445,
-0.240021213889122,
0.6616981625556946,
-0.27613723278045654,
-0.08540313690900803,
0.37135741114616394,
0.4638952314853668,
0.4374309480190277,
0.37095963954925537,
0.003968099132180214,
-0.044475916773080826,
0.32158398628234863,
-0.22744424641132355,
-0.6062349081039429,
0.7033327221870422,
-0.42194709181785583,
-0.7102089524269104,
-0.8313403129577637,
-0.09627845138311386,
-0.3982540965080261,
-0.037068165838718414,
0.2522050142288208,
0.24654513597488403,
-0.03169848769903183,
0.21441420912742615,
0.624815046787262,
-0.2997710704803467,
0.497262179851532,
0.4564950168132782,
-0.14952301979064941,
-0.20672820508480072,
0.8197723031044006,
-0.5242551565170288,
0.10465121269226074,
0.24346160888671875,
0.31909486651420593,
-0.2629189193248749,
-0.20332376658916473,
-0.27430906891822815,
-0.07516895234584808,
-0.7792315483093262,
-0.24240581691265106,
-0.7660767436027527,
-0.025625037029385567,
-0.5672602653503418,
-0.23074646294116974,
-0.5224881172180176,
-0.636074423789978,
-0.017834501340985298,
-0.08277687430381775,
0.05889904871582985,
0.7409547567367554,
-0.07058561593294144,
-0.28527766466140747,
-1.0906187295913696,
-0.04772595688700676,
0.584927499294281,
0.05850382521748543,
-0.16275909543037415,
-0.5800578594207764,
-0.2675665318965912,
-0.11182129383087158,
-0.23247848451137543,
-0.9794827103614807,
0.4073760211467743,
-0.09617533534765244,
0.40127432346343994,
0.28227558732032776,
0.05084540694952011,
0.6878761053085327,
-0.2037578821182251,
1.1180297136306763,
-0.028527431190013885,
-1.3947279453277588,
0.76115882396698,
-0.18556740880012512,
0.7309643030166626,
0.8596049547195435,
0.6681962013244629,
-0.8035528659820557,
-0.3309159278869629,
-0.6791083812713623,
-0.8128389120101929,
0.8548935055732727,
0.4753512144088745,
0.243679016828537,
-0.040073953568935394,
-0.09873140603303909,
-0.030464880168437958,
0.11933702975511551,
-0.4697008430957794,
-0.14071869850158691,
-0.19922566413879395,
-0.3294690251350403,
0.08041160553693771,
-0.39190012216567993,
0.0007329629152081907,
-0.2526085674762726,
0.9236999154090881,
-0.2860344350337982,
0.39145228266716003,
0.17113400995731354,
-0.11648964136838913,
-0.11347267776727676,
0.5267606973648071,
0.8007436394691467,
0.2355143427848816,
0.005096967797726393,
0.4461844265460968,
0.42929354310035706,
-0.6216200590133667,
0.0650070533156395,
-0.17900700867176056,
0.27961480617523193,
-0.09900461137294769,
0.4738101065158844,
0.8409600257873535,
0.37760964035987854,
-0.7313567399978638,
0.6071223616600037,
-0.40292271971702576,
-0.06544176489114761,
-0.5379816293716431,
-0.034485410898923874,
0.28768113255500793,
0.6100577116012573,
0.35369908809661865,
0.2276839017868042,
0.37362703680992126,
-0.7043272852897644,
-0.000017837111954577267,
0.12189114838838577,
-0.557509183883667,
-0.6790074706077576,
0.3822193443775177,
0.5777139663696289,
-0.2742231786251068,
0.3128562271595001,
-0.5815382599830627,
-1.2550638914108276,
0.6281063556671143,
0.20307953655719757,
1.1488345861434937,
-0.6341363191604614,
0.2907986342906952,
0.5724109411239624,
0.14039482176303864,
-0.05754203349351883,
0.6057720184326172,
-0.21995696425437927,
-0.7111914753913879,
-0.4226551651954651,
-0.4545021951198578,
-0.6853310465812683,
-0.3572365641593933,
-0.9118550419807434,
0.5719858407974243,
-0.0558561310172081,
0.1312463879585266,
-0.33331558108329773,
-0.0960390716791153,
-0.6474515199661255,
0.35452309250831604,
0.3347272276878357,
0.9030938744544983,
-0.8107219338417053,
0.4185653030872345,
0.9044688940048218,
-0.21412821114063263,
-1.1151965856552124,
-0.23507297039031982,
0.554857611656189,
-0.8572587966918945,
0.743902862071991,
0.23721805214881897,
-0.4802037477493286,
0.12737296521663666,
-0.4423034191131592,
-0.6004221439361572,
1.1294898986816406,
-0.1991601288318634,
-0.16647960245609283,
0.22510863840579987,
0.025429844856262207,
0.651549756526947,
-0.3955104351043701,
0.749650239944458,
0.6468781232833862,
0.4921914041042328,
0.6442812085151672,
-0.9856299161911011,
-0.13199368119239807,
-0.6487796902656555,
-0.5125401020050049,
0.6105214357376099,
-0.7518139481544495,
0.34686335921287537,
-0.09468387812376022,
-0.20840056240558624,
-0.3326210081577301,
0.501426100730896,
0.13327157497406006,
0.5412226319313049,
0.5438342094421387,
0.572296142578125,
0.30715835094451904,
-0.33984947204589844,
0.9721052050590515,
-0.12076856940984726,
0.3898237645626068,
0.9181779026985168,
-0.27330735325813293,
0.7133939266204834,
0.6250532865524292,
-0.17322824895381927,
0.5463522672653198,
0.6316288709640503,
0.34827733039855957,
0.31769463419914246,
0.01767711341381073,
-0.4072108566761017,
-0.496420294046402,
-0.2153426855802536,
-0.0717056468129158,
0.7451446056365967,
0.3021908104419708,
0.01568833366036415,
0.06145213544368744,
0.13051386177539825,
0.15788397192955017,
-0.3321768641471863,
-0.2859313488006592,
0.7523035407066345,
0.01670217700302601,
-0.9046754240989685,
0.3359496295452118,
-0.26978686451911926,
0.7288693785667419,
-0.39138656854629517,
-0.10221811383962631,
-0.4359850287437439,
0.018147999420762062,
-0.4405929744243622,
-0.9590664505958557,
0.4723854660987854,
0.11941353976726532,
0.3257472515106201,
-0.6837412118911743,
0.7147100567817688,
-0.5450302958488464,
-0.2659064829349518,
0.22703316807746887,
0.18741105496883392,
0.3016888499259949,
-0.20931898057460785,
-0.39968088269233704,
0.29717108607292175,
0.3310934603214264,
-0.4963676631450653,
0.04362849146127701,
0.490938276052475,
-0.061637647449970245,
0.45104724168777466,
0.048745013773441315,
-0.37784191966056824,
0.007063836790621281,
0.40928032994270325,
0.600837767124176,
-0.6722555756568909,
-0.2648544907569885,
-0.7463699579238892,
0.8512269258499146,
-0.017317118123173714,
-0.41210195422172546,
0.8341686725616455,
0.5694372057914734,
0.8184146881103516,
-0.283573716878891,
0.541930079460144,
-0.21388505399227142,
0.44576704502105713,
-0.433714896440506,
0.22954262793064117,
-0.6633992195129395,
-0.003969479817897081,
-0.4921610951423645,
-0.8664320111274719,
0.022546354681253433,
0.5309435725212097,
-0.24789074063301086,
-0.08784695714712143,
1.0614001750946045,
0.7364224195480347,
0.10580688714981079,
0.644273579120636,
0.30475249886512756,
-0.021598368883132935,
0.31810471415519714,
0.920635461807251,
1.1724965572357178,
-0.3779938220977783,
0.6776291131973267,
-0.2772108018398285,
0.011766079813241959,
-0.21312162280082703,
-0.9720098972320557,
-0.8555421233177185,
-0.843707263469696,
-0.573386549949646,
-0.2266412079334259,
-0.2794455289840698,
0.9677041172981262,
0.32093948125839233,
-0.9696972370147705,
-0.12760938704013824,
0.15539106726646423,
0.030768785625696182,
0.02315986528992653,
-0.29866841435432434,
-0.22521331906318665,
-0.05385027080774307,
-1.009285569190979,
0.41694334149360657,
0.8352383971214294,
-0.11730169504880905,
-0.04087170585989952,
-0.27055153250694275,
-0.3005625307559967,
0.1303006112575531,
0.3929634690284729,
0.23587478697299957,
-0.46062347292900085,
-0.5095539093017578,
0.25369492173194885,
0.027880627661943436,
-0.23546549677848816,
1.2191537618637085,
-0.7161276936531067,
0.513399064540863,
0.9695171117782593,
0.7509201765060425,
0.8093001842498779,
0.09916194528341293,
0.5634855031967163,
-0.44965577125549316,
0.04928266629576683,
0.549908459186554,
0.38764435052871704,
0.32258373498916626,
-0.27577537298202515,
1.0319031476974487,
0.2373182326555252,
-0.7968624234199524,
-0.6213787794113159,
0.21120017766952515,
-0.9338188767433167,
0.22313937544822693,
1.0583913326263428,
-0.08683323115110397,
-0.09008805453777313,
0.03904964402318001,
-0.4242519438266754,
0.19170929491519928,
-0.259914368391037,
0.528975248336792,
1.0412161350250244,
-0.7531147599220276,
-0.6974355578422546,
-0.28005439043045044,
0.6724398732185364,
1.0095908641815186,
-1.063753366470337,
-0.38191574811935425,
0.32620084285736084,
-0.10345403850078583,
0.4106154143810272,
0.6298845410346985,
-0.19200527667999268,
0.3845021426677704,
-0.2464313954114914,
0.22000117599964142,
0.13681980967521667,
-0.35240617394447327,
-0.6606515645980835,
-0.2329254150390625,
-0.27203303575515747,
0.0489627905189991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00569v1 | Investigating and Mitigating the Multimodal Hallucination Snowballing in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-30T03:04:11 | 2024-06-30T03:04:11 | Weihong Zhong, Xiaocheng Feng, Liang Zhao, Qiming Li, Lei Huang, Yuxuan Gu, Weitao Ma, Yuan Xu, Bing Qin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Though advanced in understanding visual information with human languages,
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) still suffer from multimodal
hallucinations. A natural concern is that during multimodal interaction, the
generated hallucinations could influence the LVLMs' subsequent generation.
Thus, we raise a question: When presented with a query relevant to the
previously generated hallucination, will LVLMs be misled and respond
incorrectly, even though the ground visual information exists? To answer this,
we propose a framework called MMHalSnowball to evaluate LVLMs' behaviors when
encountering generated hallucinations, where LVLMs are required to answer
specific visual questions within a curated hallucinatory conversation.
Crucially, our experiment shows that the performance of open-source LVLMs drops
by at least $31\%$, indicating that LVLMs are prone to accept the generated
hallucinations and make false claims that they would not have supported without
distractions. We term this phenomenon Multimodal Hallucination Snowballing. To
mitigate this, we further propose a training-free method called Residual Visual
Decoding, where we revise the output distribution of LVLMs with the one derived
from the residual visual input, providing models with direct access to the
visual information. Experiments show that our method can mitigate more than
$24\%$ of the snowballed multimodal hallucination while maintaining
capabilities. | [
-0.38166117668151855,
-0.7582105398178101,
0.3671591877937317,
0.016424981877207756,
-0.31975311040878296,
-0.17465777695178986,
-0.2689584791660309,
-0.5517509579658508,
0.1961396336555481,
0.8019894361495972,
-0.7721070647239685,
-0.19146597385406494,
-0.4464492201805115,
-0.05209248140454292,
-0.33242732286453247,
0.8188794851303101,
0.17797783017158508,
0.03866209462285042,
-0.3497406244277954,
-0.23980939388275146,
-0.46154096722602844,
-0.7719952464103699,
-0.20168139040470123,
-0.07785061001777649,
0.6300299167633057,
0.09026797115802765,
0.7266294360160828,
0.2986159026622772,
0.6491194367408752,
0.2995742857456207,
0.12010499089956284,
0.2929638624191284,
-0.7807917594909668,
0.26540616154670715,
0.11595959216356277,
-0.44138237833976746,
-0.1914484202861786,
-0.26678526401519775,
0.5193803310394287,
0.5314007997512817,
-0.5156043767929077,
0.06589464843273163,
0.1329069435596466,
0.5922868847846985,
-0.9450529217720032,
0.050812527537345886,
-0.860628604888916,
0.3336455821990967,
-0.0775107592344284,
-0.5506088733673096,
-0.7507789731025696,
0.11977603286504745,
-0.06322778016328812,
-0.39849984645843506,
0.4785800576210022,
0.07644456624984741,
0.575995683670044,
0.32596713304519653,
-0.07179795950651169,
-0.21000151336193085,
-0.853536069393158,
0.7641825675964355,
-0.5748684406280518,
0.6027305722236633,
0.4464036524295807,
0.38760891556739807,
-0.12011481821537018,
-0.3082641065120697,
-0.5260597467422485,
-0.42251715064048767,
-0.013645017519593239,
0.19141803681850433,
-0.31114235520362854,
0.16379420459270477,
0.5297208428382874,
-0.009011433459818363,
-0.6875287890434265,
-0.07450082898139954,
-0.48244306445121765,
-0.3885139226913452,
0.31277593970298767,
0.3480684459209442,
0.10093431174755096,
-0.06776237487792969,
-0.22435471415519714,
-0.12171495705842972,
-0.5116250514984131,
-0.06628451496362686,
0.15525753796100616,
0.14788652956485748,
0.22070665657520294,
0.875665545463562,
-0.23310989141464233,
0.5755017995834351,
-0.13980700075626373,
-0.08484583348035812,
0.3918779492378235,
-0.3960704207420349,
-0.3545970916748047,
-0.021902672946453094,
0.5242933034896851,
0.6540402770042419,
0.35673364996910095,
-0.32781296968460083,
-0.2619744539260864,
0.2543586790561676,
0.4109054505825043,
-0.7942219376564026,
-0.29093292355537415,
0.3698756992816925,
-0.5580928921699524,
-0.17175079882144928,
0.0005593918031081557,
-1.0814929008483887,
-0.8025402426719666,
-0.10543107241392136,
0.4647890627384186,
-0.47996965050697327,
-0.46891534328460693,
0.1908276528120041,
-0.3365529477596283,
0.03659679368138313,
0.436201274394989,
-0.784439206123352,
0.009407349862158298,
0.32381874322891235,
0.6958675384521484,
-0.06116814166307449,
-0.5827023386955261,
-0.891536295413971,
0.3164443373680115,
-0.35540327429771423,
0.6873124837875366,
-0.4402097463607788,
-0.12418913841247559,
0.251828134059906,
-0.052919238805770874,
-0.04053311049938202,
-0.7176517248153687,
0.04798717424273491,
-0.3647066652774811,
0.05329334735870361,
-0.1821393370628357,
-0.2777954936027527,
-0.14720989763736725,
0.3121265769004822,
-0.7427271008491516,
0.4106362462043762,
-0.204199880361557,
-0.8651949763298035,
0.48320695757865906,
-0.25797173380851746,
-0.07204093039035797,
0.218106210231781,
-0.185508593916893,
-0.37140145897865295,
0.38804444670677185,
0.24583394825458527,
0.43332794308662415,
0.1002454161643982,
0.2938234806060791,
-0.4855424761772156,
-0.4129415452480316,
0.24084649980068207,
-0.6007034778594971,
0.4773062765598297,
0.059718891978263855,
-0.47897130250930786,
0.309098482131958,
-0.7750182747840881,
-0.19970382750034332,
0.07521617412567139,
-0.11406823247671127,
-0.35897520184516907,
0.17219282686710358,
-0.03915577754378319,
0.24145208299160004,
-0.1387735903263092,
-0.30811774730682373,
0.041630372405052185,
-0.22405429184436798,
0.036847274750471115,
0.8188527226448059,
-0.11931606382131577,
0.4069916903972626,
-0.18741890788078308,
0.3897176682949066,
0.34107300639152527,
0.4113679528236389,
-0.29367706179618835,
-0.4823591411113739,
-0.9319761991500854,
-0.21565064787864685,
-0.4485681354999542,
0.43568527698516846,
-1.311127781867981,
-0.11909592896699905,
-0.15055787563323975,
-0.20457446575164795,
-0.6051868796348572,
0.20090894401073456,
0.3504609167575836,
0.19948700070381165,
0.5134276151657104,
-0.10009301453828812,
-0.5811944603919983,
-0.9425408840179443,
-0.02855036035180092,
-0.09360278397798538,
0.1753753423690796,
0.30350950360298157,
0.552349328994751,
-0.36224374175071716,
0.5944511890411377,
-0.3079342842102051,
-0.4680570960044861,
-0.17369282245635986,
0.1417926549911499,
-0.22129395604133606,
0.2560196816921234,
0.4560682475566864,
-0.8449931144714355,
0.04417911171913147,
-0.1401858627796173,
-0.880834698677063,
0.11074119061231613,
-0.30767756700515747,
0.03969958797097206,
0.458266019821167,
0.471466064453125,
-0.8587539196014404,
0.6277318596839905,
0.6349876523017883,
-0.4904050827026367,
0.7420430779457092,
-0.20511525869369507,
0.3073841333389282,
-0.6596128940582275,
-0.043709252029657364,
-0.22570188343524933,
0.09719672054052353,
-0.6834969520568848,
0.17602646350860596,
0.014792748726904392,
0.015367558225989342,
-0.6850535869598389,
0.277175635099411,
-0.6138905882835388,
-0.05098194628953934,
-0.13166475296020508,
0.07064671069383621,
-0.26325735449790955,
0.4252214729785919,
0.14030633866786957,
0.6138619780540466,
0.7126712799072266,
-0.6054049134254456,
0.4835483431816101,
0.0642194151878357,
-0.4134121537208557,
0.4550836682319641,
-0.2766630947589874,
-0.11292488127946854,
-0.5390462279319763,
0.036447152495384216,
-0.9124148488044739,
-0.19710546731948853,
0.4086126983165741,
-0.3497796058654785,
-0.005574483890086412,
0.0046182177029550076,
-0.540066659450531,
-0.42818596959114075,
-0.43902042508125305,
0.4210188686847687,
0.4122060537338257,
-0.4830455482006073,
0.5481863021850586,
0.09631350636482239,
0.33623090386390686,
-0.7774419188499451,
-0.6396593451499939,
0.395204097032547,
-0.20098285377025604,
-0.6082227826118469,
-0.09729083627462387,
-0.5310645699501038,
-0.3491029739379883,
-0.11133009195327759,
0.1565372198820114,
0.01966134086251259,
-0.08921442180871964,
0.36495012044906616,
0.14811497926712036,
-0.20499451458454132,
0.15230697393417358,
-0.27759891748428345,
0.1056312844157219,
0.049101006239652634,
0.07947713136672974,
0.8917356729507446,
0.06411657482385635,
-0.6416187882423401,
-0.3283247649669647,
0.38580554723739624,
0.7365640997886658,
-0.3331603705883026,
0.9571664333343506,
0.8823238611221313,
-0.3538206219673157,
-0.14225977659225464,
-0.7838568687438965,
-0.5731735825538635,
-0.45346134901046753,
0.5270589590072632,
-0.5028561949729919,
-0.6838226318359375,
0.41030585765838623,
0.36963558197021484,
-0.02691599726676941,
0.13114258646965027,
0.7336573600769043,
-0.07503048330545425,
1.2462859153747559,
0.6690295934677124,
0.19586509466171265,
0.36382612586021423,
-0.1661311537027359,
0.0558786503970623,
-0.5684053301811218,
-0.5815048813819885,
-0.11787759512662888,
-0.13172920048236847,
-0.1381845325231552,
-0.5850691795349121,
0.026309246197342873,
-0.05350809916853905,
0.3354493975639343,
0.14849379658699036,
-0.40285924077033997,
0.4404040277004242,
0.5165800452232361,
0.15486198663711548,
0.21848151087760925,
0.2642727494239807,
-0.024930883198976517,
-0.20549306273460388,
-0.788777768611908,
0.0028467075899243355,
0.7893444299697876,
0.22384648025035858,
0.9882104992866516,
0.2106940895318985,
0.6137734651565552,
0.10520699620246887,
0.1847655028104782,
-0.5552570223808289,
0.6618081331253052,
0.13095484673976898,
-0.4451359510421753,
-0.214298814535141,
-0.47356998920440674,
-0.8525919318199158,
0.6371750235557556,
-0.5570088028907776,
-0.8522067666053772,
0.1688520610332489,
0.2698131501674652,
-0.15091612935066223,
0.48868024349212646,
-0.4694238007068634,
0.7599722743034363,
-0.07650572061538696,
-0.35710597038269043,
-0.3725055754184723,
-0.44540321826934814,
0.7772219777107239,
-0.04852886125445366,
0.4132114350795746,
0.04539014399051666,
0.2363179326057434,
0.6216896772384644,
0.09482160955667496,
1.1338883638381958,
-0.20030511915683746,
-0.24158944189548492,
0.18999823927879333,
0.4233722984790802,
0.2728312611579895,
-0.013727114535868168,
0.32713985443115234,
0.1752195507287979,
-0.11887899041175842,
-0.22111628949642181,
-0.46120190620422363,
0.566137433052063,
-0.4881189465522766,
-0.6191906332969666,
-0.3130423426628113,
-0.8710825443267822,
-0.0017679311567917466,
0.009485072456300259,
0.3811406195163727,
0.43202072381973267,
-0.008660819381475449,
0.44079646468162537,
0.6402120590209961,
-0.21915404498577118,
0.579724133014679,
0.3497142791748047,
-0.558078944683075,
-0.4454726278781891,
1.0454602241516113,
0.0296578761190176,
0.37658604979515076,
0.18189944326877594,
0.023437267169356346,
-0.11671815067529678,
-0.6120964288711548,
-0.4018327593803406,
0.33805203437805176,
-0.8277367353439331,
-0.12324313074350357,
-0.6885796189308167,
-0.0928632915019989,
-0.430998295545578,
0.18078072369098663,
-0.21313853561878204,
-0.09517780691385269,
-0.36260533332824707,
0.0464576780796051,
-0.034645356237888336,
0.47232842445373535,
-0.07074905186891556,
-0.0014807037077844143,
-0.9630524516105652,
0.4387971758842468,
0.2751668393611908,
0.15545670688152313,
0.18255947530269623,
-0.4907451272010803,
-0.1750955879688263,
0.23799580335617065,
0.017816631123423576,
-0.824738085269928,
0.4358353316783905,
0.08942322432994843,
0.6298403143882751,
0.6362935900688171,
-0.0008369581191800535,
0.9807919859886169,
-0.7506986856460571,
0.9648586511611938,
0.5622825622558594,
-0.6498914361000061,
0.5057021975517273,
0.05700449272990227,
0.20685958862304688,
0.09322600811719894,
0.036427803337574005,
-0.49628207087516785,
-0.8123484253883362,
-0.4668865501880646,
-0.568132758140564,
0.5447176694869995,
0.26805379986763,
0.2923310697078705,
-0.05362062528729439,
-0.06729510426521301,
0.14148271083831787,
0.41148093342781067,
-0.8205989599227905,
-0.04099265858530998,
-0.2973288893699646,
0.07577858120203018,
-0.37778156995773315,
-0.6827106475830078,
-0.34292757511138916,
-0.21888266503810883,
0.22352823615074158,
-0.012179899029433727,
0.15901614725589752,
-0.059541597962379456,
-0.41148197650909424,
-0.25901055335998535,
-0.002533150603994727,
1.1210253238677979,
0.7428246140480042,
-0.3333754241466522,
0.45145612955093384,
-0.07465115934610367,
-0.5349864959716797,
-0.07830096036195755,
-0.2820774018764496,
-0.1020616963505745,
0.20847056806087494,
0.5154531598091125,
0.936553955078125,
-0.03548787161707878,
-1.0970120429992676,
0.5967531800270081,
-0.00874770525842905,
-0.4294581115245819,
-0.14761175215244293,
-0.0295078307390213,
-0.16524654626846313,
0.46134865283966064,
0.37457767128944397,
0.23391130566596985,
0.11024347692728043,
-0.5023961663246155,
0.448739618062973,
0.7361704707145691,
-0.43673837184906006,
-0.37317803502082825,
0.6826296448707581,
-0.11391501128673553,
-0.30270376801490784,
0.7255743145942688,
0.08908117562532425,
-0.4553690254688263,
0.45340511202812195,
0.6787471175193787,
0.722072422504425,
-0.29506418108940125,
0.36076778173446655,
0.19353295862674713,
0.6156032681465149,
-0.06542451679706573,
0.11730252951383591,
0.030557500198483467,
-0.8084146976470947,
-0.3557729721069336,
-0.5084842443466187,
-0.092033751308918,
0.2136174440383911,
-0.5533145666122437,
0.23933106660842896,
-0.1291331797838211,
-0.13908031582832336,
-0.27567633986473083,
-0.7758949398994446,
-0.4640439748764038,
0.03004688397049904,
0.566902220249176,
0.60426926612854,
-0.7175170183181763,
0.6564704775810242,
0.35396793484687805,
-0.5328261256217957,
-0.17936871945858002,
-0.02908645197749138,
-0.04105399176478386,
-0.8778681755065918,
0.7945254445075989,
0.32105448842048645,
-0.3400121033191681,
-0.17569096386432648,
-0.6400179266929626,
-0.5956743955612183,
0.8251274824142456,
0.2255406528711319,
-0.3912932872772217,
0.01641966588795185,
0.1673816442489624,
0.38860926032066345,
-0.23441486060619354,
0.01913631707429886,
0.36353161931037903,
0.24939614534378052,
0.29450759291648865,
-0.8375573754310608,
-0.028132125735282898,
-0.15906696021556854,
-0.11673568189144135,
0.2072405219078064,
-0.2939892113208771,
0.9186930656433105,
-0.5661841630935669,
-0.2983740270137787,
0.0968300923705101,
0.4419364929199219,
0.20624449849128723,
0.47157612442970276,
0.5458579063415527,
0.4684400260448456,
0.5606070756912231,
0.15913820266723633,
0.8898165822029114,
-0.153159961104393,
0.34447118639945984,
0.9219686985015869,
-0.17778943479061127,
1.0303618907928467,
0.9619709253311157,
0.21108277142047882,
0.07723399996757507,
0.13367746770381927,
-0.1868930459022522,
0.6879646182060242,
0.22526724636554718,
-0.21106375753879547,
-0.40732982754707336,
-0.054641157388687134,
-0.4526030123233795,
0.3931654393672943,
0.29445967078208923,
-0.15402761101722717,
-0.3193696141242981,
0.6457432508468628,
-0.35398557782173157,
-0.1892179250717163,
-0.20095095038414001,
0.7903928160667419,
-0.14549969136714935,
-0.5003793835639954,
0.8916656374931335,
-0.3987503945827484,
0.6729597449302673,
-0.3977264165878296,
-0.28155016899108887,
-0.331482857465744,
0.24452541768550873,
-0.21514014899730682,
-0.6375515460968018,
0.23068943619728088,
-0.2326730340719223,
-0.1286240518093109,
0.06225240230560303,
0.5540474057197571,
-0.6821901798248291,
-0.47418108582496643,
0.4449273943901062,
0.5509222745895386,
0.34653979539871216,
-0.3073844909667969,
-0.5451334118843079,
0.2835705280303955,
0.20784425735473633,
-0.11293461918830872,
0.41183722019195557,
0.3487936854362488,
0.11607421189546585,
0.9376068115234375,
0.7538038492202759,
0.14032785594463348,
0.44299042224884033,
0.47145363688468933,
0.8468986749649048,
-0.5950150489807129,
-0.24195703864097595,
-1.1675429344177246,
0.5974572896957397,
-0.07295085489749908,
0.013560310937464237,
0.7384178042411804,
0.45736148953437805,
0.7135041952133179,
-0.47668296098709106,
0.4810287654399872,
0.18010313808918,
0.05322398617863655,
-0.7006434798240662,
0.7157657146453857,
-0.8679323792457581,
0.19209522008895874,
-0.29247719049453735,
-1.0627646446228027,
-0.4821339249610901,
0.5366033911705017,
0.13418139517307281,
-0.2508484721183777,
0.76295405626297,
0.9308135509490967,
-0.06338303536176682,
-0.28863969445228577,
0.8986949324607849,
0.22578337788581848,
0.3457621932029724,
0.6531621217727661,
1.1695002317428589,
-0.06366144865751266,
0.931312084197998,
-0.4221576750278473,
-0.18210537731647491,
-0.44457048177719116,
-0.5753138065338135,
-1.155643343925476,
-0.64835524559021,
-0.17714811861515045,
-0.4773475229740143,
0.054726894944906235,
0.4691872298717499,
0.48281899094581604,
-0.6739273071289062,
-0.26396721601486206,
0.13896892964839935,
-0.06690744310617447,
-0.24690233170986176,
-0.2551192045211792,
0.10942264646291733,
-0.4487888813018799,
-0.52169269323349,
0.16050845384597778,
0.4924091398715973,
0.13775379955768585,
-0.46148788928985596,
-0.1274270862340927,
0.08886256068944931,
-0.08365870267152786,
1.0392603874206543,
-0.13371111452579498,
-1.1581913232803345,
-0.3157109320163727,
0.2042923867702484,
-0.10676034539937973,
0.16967102885246277,
0.7756069302558899,
-0.6912527680397034,
0.602927029132843,
0.21790967881679535,
0.3881954848766327,
0.27727988362312317,
-0.14643800258636475,
0.1970188170671463,
-0.42813459038734436,
0.4362064003944397,
0.2910385727882385,
0.2665574550628662,
0.2226341813802719,
-0.2503719925880432,
0.19454948604106903,
0.4535922706127167,
-0.20349818468093872,
-1.0170167684555054,
0.3536955416202545,
-0.9416656494140625,
-0.5311329364776611,
1.2608110904693604,
0.34908774495124817,
-0.16851657629013062,
0.01956123486161232,
-0.5017839670181274,
-0.14055640995502472,
-0.19341972470283508,
0.9143837690353394,
0.7159207463264465,
0.002106629079207778,
-0.6610626578330994,
-0.7674311995506287,
0.5969852209091187,
0.3552110493183136,
-0.6299359798431396,
0.4611310660839081,
0.7797778248786926,
-0.125947505235672,
0.4067768156528473,
0.553626298904419,
0.1854013204574585,
0.41467973589897156,
0.2134713977575302,
0.23783817887306213,
-0.011315939947962761,
-0.6696798801422119,
-0.2841314673423767,
0.40503278374671936,
-0.22776316106319427,
-0.35645100474357605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00541v1 | Answering real-world clinical questions using large language model based systems | 2024-06-29T22:39:20 | 2024-06-29T22:39:20 | Yen Sia Low, Michael L. Jackson, Rebecca J. Hyde, Robert E. Brown, Neil M. Sanghavi, Julian D. Baldwin, C. William Pike, Jananee Muralidharan, Gavin Hui, Natasha Alexander, Hadeel Hassan, Rahul V. Nene, Morgan Pike, Courtney J. Pokrzywa, Shivam Vedak, Adam Paul Yan, Dong-han Yao, Amy R. Zipursky, Christina Dinh, Philip Ballentine, Dan C. Derieg, Vladimir Polony, Rehan N. Chawdry, Jordan Davies, Brigham B. Hyde, Nigam H. Shah, Saurabh Gombar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Evidence to guide healthcare decisions is often limited by a lack of relevant
and trustworthy literature as well as difficulty in contextualizing existing
research for a specific patient. Large language models (LLMs) could potentially
address both challenges by either summarizing published literature or
generating new studies based on real-world data (RWD). We evaluated the ability
of five LLM-based systems in answering 50 clinical questions and had nine
independent physicians review the responses for relevance, reliability, and
actionability. As it stands, general-purpose LLMs (ChatGPT-4, Claude 3 Opus,
Gemini Pro 1.5) rarely produced answers that were deemed relevant and
evidence-based (2% - 10%). In contrast, retrieval augmented generation
(RAG)-based and agentic LLM systems produced relevant and evidence-based
answers for 24% (OpenEvidence) to 58% (ChatRWD) of questions. Only the agentic
ChatRWD was able to answer novel questions compared to other LLMs (65% vs.
0-9%). These results suggest that while general-purpose LLMs should not be used
as-is, a purpose-built system for evidence summarization based on RAG and one
for generating novel evidence working synergistically would improve
availability of pertinent evidence for patient care. | [
-0.09319961816072464,
-0.9243326187133789,
1.2075605392456055,
0.1265593320131302,
-0.2049281746149063,
-0.08484809845685959,
-0.22713571786880493,
-0.6429179310798645,
0.3673337399959564,
0.6004900336265564,
-0.2349565476179123,
-0.3904787302017212,
-0.6354100108146667,
0.10213054716587067,
-0.3849089741706848,
0.8335400819778442,
0.010424087755382061,
0.6468173265457153,
-0.24342383444309235,
-0.2945217192173004,
-0.2715533971786499,
-0.7193920016288757,
-0.6146163940429688,
-0.5881927013397217,
0.7224705815315247,
0.34500014781951904,
0.893974244594574,
0.3349802494049072,
0.7789857387542725,
0.22592931985855103,
-0.11084308475255966,
0.1874285638332367,
-0.36880290508270264,
0.4027499854564667,
-0.1054498478770256,
-0.4780000150203705,
-0.6250185370445251,
-0.20670244097709656,
0.30089300870895386,
0.9135061502456665,
-0.39262324571609497,
0.1543390452861786,
-0.2371363341808319,
0.36659422516822815,
-0.48746591806411743,
-0.12352616339921951,
-0.3267199993133545,
0.11568137258291245,
0.2386484146118164,
-0.26457715034484863,
-0.5045735836029053,
-0.37593281269073486,
0.5093702673912048,
-0.649692177772522,
0.06426580250263214,
0.026523645967245102,
0.6767277717590332,
-0.11816256493330002,
-0.49736976623535156,
-0.6984490156173706,
-0.8626611828804016,
0.47446098923683167,
-1.1467593908309937,
0.2523091435432434,
0.2898009121417999,
0.3482608199119568,
-0.22787755727767944,
-0.7315762639045715,
-0.44312384724617004,
-0.33711349964141846,
-0.30924367904663086,
0.23643611371517181,
0.051225244998931885,
0.16174617409706116,
0.3153907060623169,
0.21317291259765625,
-0.5402877926826477,
0.27066102623939514,
-0.22661438584327698,
-0.2990304231643677,
0.626451849937439,
0.47495919466018677,
0.43239274621009827,
0.06486285477876663,
-0.06548885256052017,
0.07597967237234116,
-1.0127619504928589,
-0.15462884306907654,
-0.22960785031318665,
0.15235982835292816,
0.045487143099308014,
0.7202764749526978,
-0.14289742708206177,
0.7609318494796753,
-0.16175656020641327,
-0.49245595932006836,
-0.07414998859167099,
-0.10473017394542694,
-0.24955080449581146,
-0.03519319370388985,
0.7936043739318848,
0.5917146801948547,
0.12798745930194855,
-0.15997911989688873,
-0.2221204787492752,
-0.1335887610912323,
0.21457849442958832,
-0.8800005316734314,
0.22606243193149567,
0.593481183052063,
-0.6623761653900146,
-0.24431481957435608,
-0.10740325599908829,
-0.5031981468200684,
-0.5145728588104248,
-0.36348408460617065,
0.41951075196266174,
-0.2415195256471634,
-0.4769520163536072,
0.33439114689826965,
-0.11774851381778717,
0.32816851139068604,
0.7514787912368774,
-0.480278342962265,
0.4401347041130066,
0.6732076406478882,
0.8172836899757385,
-0.10175227373838425,
0.1873982846736908,
-0.5179920196533203,
0.10016556829214096,
-0.546119749546051,
0.9038987755775452,
-0.4267330765724182,
-0.5272137522697449,
0.41894224286079407,
0.25262346863746643,
-0.10054493695497513,
-0.738941490650177,
0.521162211894989,
-0.5252440571784973,
0.49600955843925476,
-0.4216621220111847,
-0.759885847568512,
0.16088604927062988,
0.4671332538127899,
-0.40398648381233215,
0.4097297787666321,
-0.31792205572128296,
-0.5747177004814148,
0.18668045103549957,
-0.450278639793396,
-0.3792000412940979,
0.1094970628619194,
-0.44182243943214417,
-0.22039708495140076,
0.15912163257598877,
0.20576633512973785,
0.5948363542556763,
-0.4932895600795746,
0.7063274383544922,
-0.33472979068756104,
-0.32593002915382385,
0.5205243825912476,
-0.3952280282974243,
0.3966098725795746,
0.5151543617248535,
-0.14530006051063538,
-0.11257676035165787,
-0.5924925208091736,
-0.04242618381977081,
0.18159934878349304,
-0.4353664517402649,
-0.38232478499412537,
0.07498269528150558,
0.04991288110613823,
0.17753465473651886,
0.06067826226353645,
-0.8341895341873169,
0.08488233387470245,
-0.3390527367591858,
0.28056660294532776,
0.30909156799316406,
0.17886991798877716,
0.030702266842126846,
-0.7207335233688354,
0.7388795018196106,
-0.1010647565126419,
-0.06598342955112457,
-0.207030788064003,
-0.6169875860214233,
-0.5783605575561523,
-0.1441025286912918,
0.22356534004211426,
0.5190344452857971,
-0.8144416213035583,
0.050865449011325836,
-0.4527568221092224,
-0.48344799876213074,
-0.38333025574684143,
-0.4929152727127075,
0.538476824760437,
0.7638829350471497,
0.22468489408493042,
-0.2597522735595703,
-0.2605995237827301,
-1.0649386644363403,
-0.20660504698753357,
-0.28007158637046814,
-0.1517779678106308,
0.6337977647781372,
0.4185844659805298,
-0.09440705925226212,
0.8805878162384033,
-0.676784873008728,
-0.054750408977270126,
-0.32334911823272705,
-0.08639520406723022,
0.3157432973384857,
0.03540848568081856,
0.19415555894374847,
-0.6705114841461182,
-0.4236415922641754,
0.09356902539730072,
-1.0718015432357788,
-0.2780304253101349,
-0.021464211866259575,
0.14505916833877563,
0.011407608166337013,
0.4874855577945709,
-0.7982836365699768,
0.3032705783843994,
0.31799960136413574,
-0.14292125403881073,
0.48756760358810425,
-0.5580760836601257,
0.19084104895591736,
-0.926527738571167,
0.47011080384254456,
-0.2124108225107193,
-0.3743605315685272,
-0.8689897656440735,
-0.02899950183928013,
0.05436185747385025,
-0.2551720440387726,
-0.426743745803833,
0.8083453178405762,
-0.3459196090698242,
-0.05949714034795761,
-0.33103033900260925,
0.29232990741729736,
-0.0025700489059090614,
-0.011167794466018677,
0.28793826699256897,
0.5852764248847961,
0.3003566265106201,
-0.61803138256073,
0.25190219283103943,
0.34856116771698,
-0.4245966970920563,
0.5071316957473755,
-0.9780467748641968,
-0.19817550480365753,
-0.3669705092906952,
0.43564361333847046,
-0.679095983505249,
-0.5971813797950745,
-0.008379556238651276,
-0.4191972315311432,
0.2197691798210144,
-0.1032952293753624,
-0.25171127915382385,
-0.3270193338394165,
0.16140642762184143,
0.22140264511108398,
0.4476531147956848,
-0.18145376443862915,
0.39281705021858215,
0.49985212087631226,
-0.6251114010810852,
-0.6279614567756653,
-0.550358235836029,
0.29807615280151367,
0.023188283666968346,
-0.5834193825721741,
-0.01695362851023674,
0.0010551689192652702,
-0.5907852053642273,
0.009011752903461456,
-0.0029380288906395435,
-0.027569757774472237,
-0.10043374449014664,
0.04035872220993042,
0.22360233962535858,
-0.4307114779949188,
0.591301679611206,
-0.07375350594520569,
0.097171351313591,
0.2124670147895813,
0.18097569048404694,
0.5184376835823059,
0.04476293548941612,
-0.7604258060455322,
-0.20198561251163483,
0.6635388731956482,
0.8205182552337646,
-0.10347702354192734,
0.5699470639228821,
0.2422027289867401,
-0.3842420279979706,
-0.07862720638513565,
-0.77918940782547,
-0.27714425325393677,
-0.35595986247062683,
0.5165030360221863,
-0.1448211520910263,
-1.0661916732788086,
0.5540691018104553,
0.021136539056897163,
0.3351323902606964,
0.31828707456588745,
1.011033296585083,
-0.1136976107954979,
1.0773696899414062,
0.028132164850831032,
0.2723230719566345,
-0.000700228672940284,
0.022752994671463966,
0.3803536593914032,
-0.6842699646949768,
-0.27090150117874146,
-0.41751009225845337,
-0.11337032169103622,
-0.4559358060359955,
-0.388398140668869,
0.732733428478241,
-0.3483491539955139,
-0.01872575283050537,
-0.1303141713142395,
-0.5683174133300781,
0.04140064865350723,
0.34214863181114197,
0.40323254466056824,
0.583740770816803,
-0.24140682816505432,
-0.1781720370054245,
0.15705254673957825,
-0.8790512681007385,
-0.7270981669425964,
1.3553725481033325,
0.5137801766395569,
0.9847575426101685,
0.2420518547296524,
0.4240018427371979,
0.20547638833522797,
0.652234673500061,
-0.7106802463531494,
0.6334521174430847,
0.1139836236834526,
-0.9224056601524353,
-0.3337053656578064,
-0.3021799623966217,
-1.1053485870361328,
0.6514091491699219,
-0.39310070872306824,
-0.27106332778930664,
0.175869882106781,
0.09494820982217789,
-0.5634985566139221,
0.14932329952716827,
-0.5888181924819946,
0.37271782755851746,
-0.34991684556007385,
-0.30199673771858215,
-0.12222602218389511,
-0.689255952835083,
0.3981926739215851,
-0.002509049139916897,
0.445804238319397,
-0.0801423043012619,
-0.15717799961566925,
0.5941515564918518,
-0.6366956830024719,
0.677945613861084,
-0.1878124624490738,
-0.3691316246986389,
0.2853952646255493,
-0.05458713695406914,
0.46995532512664795,
0.28390437364578247,
-0.0751669779419899,
-0.301604688167572,
0.46273311972618103,
-0.264518141746521,
-0.7564616203308105,
0.6572034358978271,
-0.6054397225379944,
-0.9106898903846741,
-0.6777529120445251,
-0.46567732095718384,
-0.4572862684726715,
0.044269807636737823,
0.15407325327396393,
0.862151026725769,
-0.4427359402179718,
0.3342505693435669,
0.7543801665306091,
-0.4968152940273285,
0.01797681674361229,
1.021625280380249,
-0.39821457862854004,
-0.2938827574253082,
0.4471893906593323,
0.0681980699300766,
0.41843417286872864,
0.4314321279525757,
0.358265221118927,
-0.2610183358192444,
-0.7529273629188538,
-0.43565040826797485,
0.4483920931816101,
-0.6487663388252258,
-0.11783402413129807,
-0.9644313454627991,
-0.2767751216888428,
-0.3888123631477356,
0.03800348937511444,
-0.10452397912740707,
-0.3961910009384155,
0.06008937209844589,
-0.010980971157550812,
0.16289763152599335,
0.7836423516273499,
0.25262996554374695,
0.09750086814165115,
-1.0418126583099365,
0.3840969204902649,
0.3247598707675934,
0.3895016610622406,
-0.049731653183698654,
-0.4885517358779907,
-0.29120948910713196,
0.28733858466148376,
-0.035270050168037415,
-0.8594473600387573,
0.4422782063484192,
0.043240513652563095,
0.6488866806030273,
0.2910225987434387,
0.10101646184921265,
0.6276596188545227,
-0.5595177412033081,
0.6961595416069031,
0.15948878228664398,
-0.27740585803985596,
0.33956462144851685,
-0.627673864364624,
0.315516859292984,
0.43006661534309387,
0.49931398034095764,
-0.8827603459358215,
-0.47486844658851624,
-0.4693908095359802,
-0.6326434016227722,
0.4999981224536896,
-0.029286274686455727,
0.015557182021439075,
-0.10580412298440933,
0.45711633563041687,
0.026043172925710678,
0.21369965374469757,
-0.561464250087738,
0.04728545621037483,
0.345046728849411,
-0.2872684597969055,
-0.03917831555008888,
-0.25833961367607117,
-0.45062437653541565,
0.08152373880147934,
0.5233780741691589,
-0.2992318570613861,
0.42213642597198486,
0.7943329215049744,
-0.12274640798568726,
-0.19397538900375366,
0.6330081820487976,
0.6960338354110718,
0.8957892060279846,
-0.23284605145454407,
0.03911391645669937,
0.05072876438498497,
-0.5512132048606873,
0.23866789042949677,
-0.16718164086341858,
-0.35231947898864746,
-0.010536227375268936,
0.6327163577079773,
0.5177897214889526,
-0.06955187767744064,
-1.2827211618423462,
0.6229206919670105,
-0.2278846800327301,
-0.35291358828544617,
-0.4742142856121063,
0.036333564668893814,
0.2646609842777252,
0.09103164821863174,
0.19697356224060059,
-0.25848832726478577,
0.1354641169309616,
-0.652847409248352,
0.04835096374154091,
0.6172758340835571,
-0.45193731784820557,
-0.05973739176988602,
0.4054647982120514,
0.1965559720993042,
-0.3214645981788635,
0.34746283292770386,
0.41585099697113037,
-0.11635979264974594,
0.6602704524993896,
0.7131202816963196,
0.37866631150245667,
0.00512041337788105,
0.236312597990036,
0.3166922330856323,
0.028718288987874985,
-0.4106389880180359,
0.31352731585502625,
0.49176496267318726,
-0.6471863985061646,
-0.5725716948509216,
-0.3938490152359009,
-0.9574053287506104,
0.19572526216506958,
-0.5863856673240662,
0.12227784097194672,
-0.3943391740322113,
-0.20202401280403137,
-0.09042122215032578,
-0.3129165768623352,
-0.42806276679039,
0.4298745095729828,
-0.05694105103611946,
0.864535391330719,
-0.6987064480781555,
0.580039381980896,
0.9889742136001587,
-0.3465768098831177,
-0.6767565608024597,
-0.2811568081378937,
-0.08317948132753372,
-0.8646709322929382,
0.33979859948158264,
-0.17503312230110168,
0.07001931220293045,
-0.4744049310684204,
-0.6272363662719727,
-1.0177093744277954,
1.2118514776229858,
0.18498975038528442,
-0.501818060874939,
-0.21117356419563293,
0.14737924933433533,
0.9951170682907104,
-0.6501984596252441,
0.5330950617790222,
0.2597370445728302,
0.3576453626155853,
0.2578074038028717,
-1.1138192415237427,
0.0932498350739479,
-0.22425848245620728,
-0.29981788992881775,
0.13041023910045624,
-0.5972614288330078,
0.6044164896011353,
-0.3034910261631012,
-0.06299149990081787,
0.22148075699806213,
0.1750710904598236,
0.4159982204437256,
0.48837679624557495,
0.3471556603908539,
0.5227535367012024,
0.6644579768180847,
0.024907581508159637,
1.1784517765045166,
-0.2391839176416397,
0.15920600295066833,
1.0305253267288208,
-0.7072100639343262,
0.8921352028846741,
0.3417835533618927,
-0.25011157989501953,
0.44686171412467957,
0.3896985948085785,
0.22644907236099243,
0.19485515356063843,
0.20901672542095184,
-0.32644474506378174,
-0.49088436365127563,
-0.17917318642139435,
-0.44311174750328064,
0.13666164875030518,
0.6036867499351501,
-0.40394940972328186,
-0.14634253084659576,
0.029031796380877495,
0.2497304379940033,
0.07645248621702194,
-0.017446808516979218,
0.9146348834037781,
0.3402416706085205,
-1.1462093591690063,
0.5675677061080933,
-0.042489539831876755,
0.2930501699447632,
-0.8957608342170715,
-0.11805817484855652,
-0.2879776954650879,
0.14768941700458527,
-0.326220840215683,
-0.7545671463012695,
0.09670626372098923,
0.10550335049629211,
-0.009931705892086029,
-0.1928708851337433,
0.8466424942016602,
-0.2963758707046509,
-0.5607203245162964,
0.01435799989849329,
0.8578981161117554,
0.17222028970718384,
0.21519184112548828,
-0.35533401370048523,
-0.10330966114997864,
-0.15258073806762695,
-0.3968392014503479,
0.6155527830123901,
0.4011642038822174,
-0.12236262857913971,
1.145693302154541,
0.7069895267486572,
0.5211753845214844,
-0.23724626004695892,
0.017515063285827637,
0.880669891834259,
-0.6213559508323669,
-0.2147490233182907,
-0.4662311375141144,
0.17657610774040222,
-0.19606581330299377,
-0.09124626964330673,
0.5360740423202515,
0.40107688307762146,
0.19712208211421967,
-0.0036178852897137403,
0.9162142276763916,
-0.06090019643306732,
1.0042154788970947,
-0.4752839207649231,
0.6640306115150452,
-0.6472794413566589,
0.3870769441127777,
-0.14749054610729218,
-0.6090027093887329,
-0.4985392689704895,
0.32783788442611694,
-0.47695213556289673,
-0.042311135679483414,
0.7665666341781616,
0.746306300163269,
0.09503773599863052,
0.06145124509930611,
0.5438185930252075,
0.4347091317176819,
0.6532219052314758,
0.4468560516834259,
0.8578020334243774,
-0.23767276108264923,
0.3899727463722229,
0.22752322256565094,
-0.3268948793411255,
-0.29391878843307495,
-0.5980947017669678,
-0.6707133054733276,
-0.07015570998191833,
-0.07556737214326859,
-0.3654196262359619,
0.25263863801956177,
1.1442826986312866,
0.552804708480835,
-0.7527284622192383,
-0.22172905504703522,
0.22094064950942993,
-0.1207570731639862,
-0.0196142066270113,
-0.1493452936410904,
0.5557878613471985,
-0.29878678917884827,
-0.31097307801246643,
0.2833023965358734,
0.31534066796302795,
-0.2218237966299057,
-0.2213762402534485,
-0.12543414533138275,
-0.206794872879982,
0.1510620415210724,
0.7382495403289795,
0.2902244031429291,
-0.8016754984855652,
-0.23210586607456207,
0.4403563439846039,
-0.31651797890663147,
-0.003401389578357339,
0.9997199773788452,
-0.7145441174507141,
0.42075014114379883,
0.5876163244247437,
0.7340013384819031,
0.40431585907936096,
0.07606138288974762,
0.7877621054649353,
-0.037428442388772964,
-0.17150969803333282,
0.6217674016952515,
0.5971812605857849,
0.15991497039794922,
-0.10955088585615158,
0.3453960418701172,
0.13130635023117065,
-0.9601097106933594,
-0.7066049575805664,
0.25814303755760193,
-0.7637965083122253,
-0.3187043368816376,
1.3656083345413208,
-0.216924250125885,
0.023001857101917267,
-0.5099413394927979,
-0.39127615094184875,
-0.18502177298069,
-0.2623540461063385,
0.6012705564498901,
0.7615903615951538,
-0.3497430086135864,
-0.11297082155942917,
-0.7250745296478271,
0.28235653042793274,
0.500902533531189,
-0.9342513680458069,
0.04846653714776039,
0.8543510437011719,
0.38582247495651245,
0.08168794959783554,
1.1378757953643799,
-0.39720022678375244,
0.37325382232666016,
-0.34888312220573425,
-0.1053231880068779,
0.2060212939977646,
0.039012521505355835,
-0.14626015722751617,
0.35772016644477844,
0.2952457368373871,
0.45688945055007935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00499v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00499v1 | ConU: Conformal Uncertainty in Large Language Models with Correctness Coverage Guarantees | 2024-06-29T17:33:07 | 2024-06-29T17:33:07 | Zhiyuan Wang, Jinhao Duan, Lu Cheng, Yue Zhang, Qingni Wang, Hengtao Shen, Xiaofeng Zhu, Xiaoshuang Shi, Kaidi Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Uncertainty quantification (UQ) in natural language generation (NLG) tasks
remains an open challenge, exacerbated by the intricate nature of the recent
large language models (LLMs). This study investigates adapting conformal
prediction (CP), which can convert any heuristic measure of uncertainty into
rigorous theoretical guarantees by constructing prediction sets, for black-box
LLMs in open-ended NLG tasks. We propose a sampling-based uncertainty measure
leveraging self-consistency and develop a conformal uncertainty criterion by
integrating the uncertainty condition aligned with correctness into the design
of the CP algorithm. Experimental results indicate that our uncertainty measure
generally surpasses prior state-of-the-art methods. Furthermore, we calibrate
the prediction sets within the model's unfixed answer distribution and achieve
strict control over the correctness coverage rate across 6 LLMs on 4 free-form
NLG datasets, spanning general-purpose and medical domains, while the small
average set size further highlights the efficiency of our method in providing
trustworthy guarantees for practical open-ended NLG applications. | [
-0.1224159300327301,
-0.38193970918655396,
0.6231050491333008,
0.29385027289390564,
-0.19843770563602448,
-0.23679862916469574,
-0.597874104976654,
-0.37780511379241943,
-0.12502926588058472,
0.5566458106040955,
-0.46002110838890076,
-0.48509669303894043,
-0.6768229603767395,
0.14032964408397675,
-0.025677908211946487,
0.6886315941810608,
-0.11906018108129501,
-0.301495760679245,
-0.07363198697566986,
-0.02766406536102295,
-0.37963542342185974,
-0.3678579330444336,
-0.36177167296409607,
-0.03963717073202133,
0.23222830891609192,
0.269905149936676,
0.8993602395057678,
0.46684566140174866,
0.19381515681743622,
0.1467483639717102,
-0.01624692976474762,
0.20088495314121246,
-0.30055347084999084,
0.16802100837230682,
-0.11350534856319427,
-0.4686124622821808,
-0.4287591576576233,
-0.14685580134391785,
0.7265404462814331,
0.6189793348312378,
-0.5637356638908386,
0.15239141881465912,
0.14421479403972626,
0.5908313393592834,
-0.7910749912261963,
0.08898910135030746,
-0.9901012182235718,
0.01988309808075428,
0.03702849894762039,
0.2393798828125,
-0.5411127805709839,
-0.24216122925281525,
0.22007499635219574,
-0.939131498336792,
0.19543181359767914,
0.16906440258026123,
0.39529183506965637,
0.43677300214767456,
-0.1983431875705719,
-0.31927061080932617,
-0.7975509762763977,
0.9084058403968811,
-1.2462743520736694,
0.5031725168228149,
0.5742413401603699,
0.4059825539588928,
-0.5085916519165039,
-0.6089808344841003,
-0.6535869836807251,
-0.10019656270742416,
0.1036442294716835,
0.3161229193210602,
-0.3186851143836975,
0.09712836891412735,
0.0043221269734203815,
0.211605042219162,
-0.4551106095314026,
0.014717983081936836,
-0.640916645526886,
-0.20162507891654968,
0.7584566473960876,
-0.1454744040966034,
-0.09003777801990509,
0.009975901804864407,
-0.18978367745876312,
-0.006805777549743652,
-0.6041111350059509,
-0.04591847211122513,
0.2784259617328644,
0.3093518614768982,
-0.23820970952510834,
0.6310567855834961,
-0.2813047468662262,
0.8049017190933228,
0.3295573890209198,
0.14147454500198364,
0.02408011257648468,
-0.44151538610458374,
-0.5939935445785522,
0.060999851673841476,
1.1227552890777588,
0.2545120418071747,
0.6292877793312073,
-0.003077742410823703,
-0.13035885989665985,
-0.26394301652908325,
0.6018096804618835,
-0.4845064878463745,
-0.22273454070091248,
0.46796494722366333,
0.07210707664489746,
-0.15246853232383728,
0.010992132127285004,
-0.5786382555961609,
-0.2277485728263855,
-0.07092078775167465,
0.07370197772979736,
-0.582632839679718,
-0.15931546688079834,
0.5604604482650757,
0.3434431254863739,
-0.17199592292308807,
0.38554656505584717,
-0.7523097991943359,
-0.09386439621448517,
0.42643529176712036,
0.5801958441734314,
-0.028239546343684196,
-0.2015409767627716,
-0.2660287320613861,
0.4675971567630768,
-0.554171621799469,
0.6964688301086426,
-0.2031135857105255,
-0.38780373334884644,
0.2639239728450775,
-0.224728524684906,
-0.11939412355422974,
-0.36443886160850525,
0.5844573378562927,
-0.29421576857566833,
0.15322333574295044,
0.05000292882323265,
-0.6268460154533386,
-0.019926059991121292,
0.27119067311286926,
-0.4925120770931244,
0.6954404711723328,
0.43560516834259033,
-0.6206825971603394,
0.3970453441143036,
-0.06492431461811066,
-0.14455637335777283,
0.018176645040512085,
-0.00204446236602962,
-0.8157896995544434,
0.30558720231056213,
0.33977264165878296,
0.48005324602127075,
-0.18353480100631714,
0.18535806238651276,
-0.5587995648384094,
-0.04802916198968887,
0.44206178188323975,
-0.24461792409420013,
0.42696788907051086,
0.09602981060743332,
-0.1398492008447647,
0.1343403309583664,
-0.6889104247093201,
0.5320665240287781,
-0.31012895703315735,
-0.15542873740196228,
-0.06761828809976578,
-0.0013482042122632265,
-0.26721563935279846,
0.07160526514053345,
0.07558190077543259,
-0.5423718690872192,
0.14087869226932526,
-0.5471894145011902,
0.2896607518196106,
0.7774032354354858,
0.23060177266597748,
0.47921913862228394,
-0.48606935143470764,
0.5573948621749878,
-0.14357219636440277,
0.11171576380729675,
0.08298351615667343,
-0.5918999910354614,
-0.38105666637420654,
-0.06004278361797333,
0.47893598675727844,
0.35468846559524536,
-0.34611424803733826,
0.7394678592681885,
-0.22395822405815125,
-0.6112883687019348,
-0.6061322093009949,
0.1340193897485733,
0.4368898272514343,
0.16726507246494293,
0.29448559880256653,
0.010335908271372318,
-0.476034015417099,
-0.598805844783783,
-0.18487229943275452,
-0.44939133524894714,
-0.4416830539703369,
0.059129245579242706,
0.190989688038826,
-0.22331835329532623,
0.8001129031181335,
-0.4881784915924072,
-0.5626772046089172,
0.07760003954172134,
0.03555905818939209,
0.1808723360300064,
0.45450302958488464,
0.4824298620223999,
-0.48866841197013855,
-0.627005934715271,
-0.087257519364357,
-0.5281957983970642,
0.001130458666011691,
-0.32662561535835266,
-0.04247100651264191,
0.2882421314716339,
0.6525172591209412,
-0.21124479174613953,
0.4476568400859833,
1.0679386854171753,
-0.24625171720981598,
0.6826892495155334,
-0.5461548566818237,
-0.08837683498859406,
-1.114526629447937,
-0.2915721535682678,
0.2276182621717453,
-0.2748158276081085,
-0.5097653865814209,
-0.13617946207523346,
0.13174104690551758,
0.32665514945983887,
-0.26247867941856384,
0.5511292815208435,
-0.47375214099884033,
0.1620304435491562,
-0.22902396321296692,
0.042043887078762054,
-0.07279115915298462,
0.1539514809846878,
0.10961388796567917,
0.7903568148612976,
0.4844077229499817,
-0.6020768880844116,
-0.041823409497737885,
0.3549521863460541,
-0.17221340537071228,
0.7359534502029419,
-0.8263371586799622,
-0.07238990813493729,
-0.010457320138812065,
0.3708392083644867,
-0.8483245968818665,
-0.29857856035232544,
0.16502895951271057,
-0.5794792175292969,
0.20107673108577728,
0.011247317306697369,
-0.3385156989097595,
-0.31194639205932617,
-0.04231243208050728,
0.38403111696243286,
0.6952632665634155,
-0.18711715936660767,
0.37222886085510254,
0.20855610072612762,
-0.08098837733268738,
-0.4394722878932953,
-0.6561338305473328,
-0.2185903787612915,
0.1523001790046692,
-0.5138978958129883,
0.17308849096298218,
-0.3896331191062927,
-0.06635575741529465,
-0.3151971995830536,
-0.37970659136772156,
-0.19764219224452972,
-0.016901524737477303,
0.2219371646642685,
0.009932990185916424,
-0.25012513995170593,
-0.08450061082839966,
0.12993061542510986,
0.13119328022003174,
0.1361977756023407,
-0.6478402614593506,
0.12304648756980896,
-0.09861201792955399,
-0.449920654296875,
-0.03032403253018856,
-0.049797940999269485,
0.46127548813819885,
-0.10947529226541519,
0.5555591583251953,
0.41649261116981506,
-0.7079530954360962,
-0.5230992436408997,
-0.4806846082210541,
-0.10234294831752777,
-0.4302087426185608,
0.014156172052025795,
-0.2895279824733734,
-0.7014675736427307,
0.43764927983283997,
0.3306596279144287,
0.3362651467323303,
0.5030103921890259,
0.6272602081298828,
-0.29641103744506836,
0.3435750901699066,
0.4847579896450043,
0.29159337282180786,
-0.009470721706748009,
0.13952083885669708,
0.06158900633454323,
-1.0499907732009888,
0.02214602194726467,
-0.40595224499702454,
0.0437370128929615,
-0.49196016788482666,
-0.6178695559501648,
0.49484267830848694,
0.39671069383621216,
-0.08586152642965317,
0.29343608021736145,
-0.66844642162323,
0.06086118891835213,
0.5883283615112305,
0.1616780310869217,
0.30801087617874146,
-0.24272421002388,
-0.03899747133255005,
0.02060496248304844,
-0.40102458000183105,
-0.3130791187286377,
1.447511911392212,
0.23315317928791046,
0.7960770726203918,
0.09037709981203079,
0.5807294845581055,
0.29522648453712463,
0.5623703598976135,
-0.3745259940624237,
0.10135134309530258,
-0.12451350688934326,
-0.6070286631584167,
-0.7374492287635803,
-0.18987825512886047,
-0.9739313721656799,
0.03025633655488491,
-0.29933634400367737,
-0.7739402055740356,
0.17588208615779877,
0.49402520060539246,
-0.4851478636264801,
0.33686232566833496,
-0.24309109151363373,
0.4309219419956207,
0.12165150046348572,
0.1273292750120163,
0.11738558858633041,
-0.5272584557533264,
0.451856791973114,
-0.5234107971191406,
0.2614341378211975,
-0.3075585961341858,
0.12053696811199188,
0.4179280698299408,
-0.11343269050121307,
0.9258924722671509,
-0.03612799942493439,
-0.4434795081615448,
0.5150353908538818,
0.25552237033843994,
0.4875234365463257,
0.3428405821323395,
-0.3713178336620331,
0.3843783438205719,
0.26817095279693604,
-0.38962507247924805,
-0.49860596656799316,
0.38467198610305786,
-0.4926072657108307,
-0.49807068705558777,
-0.4920053780078888,
-0.7216054797172546,
-0.48336413502693176,
0.2619492709636688,
0.5819221138954163,
-0.2177487164735794,
-0.15449665486812592,
0.2041054368019104,
0.7615291476249695,
-0.08325501531362534,
0.14628472924232483,
0.30913326144218445,
0.0004188731254544109,
-0.6731480360031128,
0.3917972147464752,
-0.020474163815379143,
0.79668790102005,
0.13350126147270203,
0.4239753484725952,
-0.35035330057144165,
-0.932718813419342,
-0.6695284843444824,
0.16730913519859314,
-0.3347529470920563,
-0.4407878816127777,
-0.3542901575565338,
-0.31352829933166504,
-0.9052287936210632,
-0.4115144908428192,
-0.3098039925098419,
-0.3118385672569275,
-0.22851121425628662,
0.07450626790523529,
0.19608190655708313,
0.6386233568191528,
-0.10593213140964508,
0.535197913646698,
-0.761742889881134,
0.3576275706291199,
0.09137807786464691,
0.6932876110076904,
-0.47429975867271423,
-0.7495864033699036,
-0.09496241807937622,
0.45113319158554077,
-0.3070327341556549,
-0.8187326192855835,
0.28571274876594543,
0.42255404591560364,
0.5192533731460571,
0.12402676790952682,
0.3639274835586548,
0.28146764636039734,
-0.5081236958503723,
0.6279890537261963,
0.32620641589164734,
-0.6771897673606873,
0.3938027024269104,
-0.5871827602386475,
0.4689691662788391,
0.614788293838501,
0.0908331349492073,
-0.5980476140975952,
-0.7972601056098938,
-0.7831754684448242,
-0.5134267210960388,
0.2480415552854538,
0.4255775511264801,
-0.025644375011324883,
0.07396037876605988,
0.6486123204231262,
-0.0017604000167921185,
0.08422940969467163,
-0.7460108399391174,
-0.005598950199782848,
-0.2946348190307617,
-0.5038238167762756,
-0.030589750036597252,
-0.1933290660381317,
-0.18374347686767578,
0.20921102166175842,
0.7777499556541443,
-0.6463567614555359,
0.1636691689491272,
0.42205092310905457,
0.137240469455719,
-0.5018640160560608,
0.5602276921272278,
0.7267530560493469,
0.8428113460540771,
-0.41662168502807617,
-0.052228573709726334,
0.24936316907405853,
-0.5346411466598511,
0.14152419567108154,
0.10193896293640137,
-0.34829947352409363,
-0.0008002714021131396,
0.1740856021642685,
0.2553914785385132,
0.0693637803196907,
-0.6289310455322266,
0.5230993032455444,
-0.031467828899621964,
-0.4350186288356781,
-0.7708591222763062,
0.03645073249936104,
0.14553557336330414,
-0.016531644389033318,
0.18783773481845856,
-0.11423187702894211,
-0.20014356076717377,
-0.04036380723118782,
0.47825202345848083,
0.5071741342544556,
-0.6867155432701111,
-0.3435637950897217,
0.8148580193519592,
-0.3093651831150055,
-0.09842074662446976,
0.3604090213775635,
-0.12535536289215088,
-0.04103480651974678,
0.5064170360565186,
0.8335328102111816,
0.9458569288253784,
-0.5002774596214294,
0.11846356838941574,
0.5800262689590454,
0.5566680431365967,
-0.3007115125656128,
0.26235541701316833,
0.4318671226501465,
-0.9229691624641418,
-0.36130043864250183,
-0.8500037789344788,
-0.576787531375885,
0.0852048248052597,
-0.6635302901268005,
0.05684240907430649,
-0.6087737679481506,
-0.07680431008338928,
-0.07564198970794678,
-0.4076971709728241,
-0.4412004053592682,
0.4941481053829193,
0.12436943501234055,
1.0409785509109497,
-0.605758786201477,
0.7698057293891907,
0.4870089590549469,
-0.041376736015081406,
-0.810896098613739,
0.2606741487979889,
-0.06355361640453339,
-0.6788802742958069,
0.01123926043510437,
-0.24666257202625275,
0.1087154969573021,
-0.24013429880142212,
-0.36993125081062317,
-0.9865384101867676,
1.0404611825942993,
0.4050302505493164,
-0.7865985035896301,
-0.24392369389533997,
0.3180880546569824,
0.5107357501983643,
-0.18122780323028564,
-0.1819017231464386,
0.44746026396751404,
0.6089304089546204,
0.18023279309272766,
-1.1255275011062622,
0.2649399936199188,
0.4257594347000122,
-0.019408030435442924,
0.1744869500398636,
-0.4111717939376831,
0.4971298575401306,
-0.5113735795021057,
-0.15316490828990936,
0.1503801792860031,
1.1381086111068726,
0.701762855052948,
0.10135219991207123,
0.5873820185661316,
0.4300394058227539,
0.8426299095153809,
-0.007499073166400194,
1.1378819942474365,
-0.33323541283607483,
0.31007251143455505,
1.2554539442062378,
-0.0919017419219017,
0.7063034176826477,
0.3541349470615387,
-0.27333131432533264,
0.1972074657678604,
0.48494741320610046,
-0.06429939717054367,
0.29549649357795715,
0.4601879119873047,
-0.23190133273601532,
-0.12045486271381378,
0.2042836844921112,
-0.13778294622898102,
0.2136257439851761,
0.5362898111343384,
-0.23693116009235382,
-0.09510554373264313,
-0.20388886332511902,
0.041069816797971725,
0.5309215784072876,
-0.31066256761550903,
0.6695494055747986,
0.24224913120269775,
-0.9038426876068115,
0.8487756848335266,
-0.009876108728349209,
0.6132121682167053,
-0.6038317084312439,
0.16708384454250336,
0.225247323513031,
0.2467515766620636,
-0.09282119572162628,
-0.9985552430152893,
0.4963657259941101,
-0.6025514602661133,
-0.11124124377965927,
-0.07967119663953781,
0.5264506936073303,
-0.5706841945648193,
-0.8310271501541138,
-0.07955390959978104,
0.3036446273326874,
-0.2775219976902008,
-0.25542014837265015,
-0.41535496711730957,
-0.3220904469490051,
0.21615462005138397,
-0.0924074649810791,
0.1449744552373886,
0.6537894010543823,
-0.15781989693641663,
0.5358594059944153,
0.5187696218490601,
0.4631288945674896,
0.3735959827899933,
-0.3410908579826355,
0.4189891517162323,
-0.4022044241428375,
-0.34488847851753235,
-0.5073694586753845,
0.4834221303462982,
0.19157814979553223,
-0.550410807132721,
0.38107699155807495,
0.3260236978530884,
0.8549729585647583,
-0.06684518605470657,
1.0249799489974976,
0.14082911610603333,
0.3955603241920471,
-0.5609515905380249,
0.5970501899719238,
-0.19438238441944122,
-0.02772418223321438,
-0.00730142742395401,
-0.7565224170684814,
-0.4961448609828949,
0.4850342273712158,
0.017926551401615143,
-0.14254668354988098,
0.6482441425323486,
0.47396764159202576,
-0.17876049876213074,
-0.07596080750226974,
0.5607811808586121,
0.18246467411518097,
0.5411768555641174,
0.5861625671386719,
0.012781689874827862,
-0.3752671480178833,
0.4141765832901001,
-0.3669235110282898,
-0.340996116399765,
0.08987482637166977,
-1.1040416955947876,
-0.714211106300354,
-0.7241701483726501,
-0.275232195854187,
-0.8279365301132202,
0.0032961368560791016,
0.6983864903450012,
0.7567315101623535,
-1.0009465217590332,
-0.02763247862458229,
-0.11942971497774124,
-0.10313371568918228,
-0.3955143690109253,
-0.11347201466560364,
0.2994048297405243,
-0.4037565588951111,
-0.7624233961105347,
0.23461446166038513,
0.09851118922233582,
0.28266441822052,
-0.31054773926734924,
-0.0040667178109288216,
0.08136998116970062,
0.4226536452770233,
0.14792680740356445,
0.4736950993537903,
-0.8760092258453369,
-0.549113392829895,
0.03879569098353386,
-0.20774175226688385,
0.09499900043010712,
0.74798583984375,
-0.5420923829078674,
0.46474382281303406,
0.02675478346645832,
0.6358346343040466,
0.31216615438461304,
0.013621887192130089,
1.0306161642074585,
-1.0030708312988281,
-0.10887867957353592,
0.40421974658966064,
0.4752984344959259,
0.19503535330295563,
-0.5726411938667297,
0.4751564562320709,
-0.18225790560245514,
-0.6514900922775269,
-0.6682747006416321,
0.5778154730796814,
-1.2003744840621948,
-0.18656706809997559,
1.4790083169937134,
-0.32317230105400085,
-0.3224223554134369,
-0.1459449827671051,
0.10930927097797394,
0.1866111159324646,
-0.295227587223053,
1.0440245866775513,
0.5738245248794556,
0.07898293435573578,
0.005912369582802057,
-0.40423861145973206,
0.6113013625144958,
0.26520368456840515,
-0.8324691653251648,
0.4878939986228943,
0.48044702410697937,
0.47347667813301086,
0.29440316557884216,
0.6467481255531311,
-0.0636896938085556,
0.4145372807979584,
-0.4850182831287384,
0.2128777951002121,
0.020724592730402946,
-0.05388472229242325,
-0.21975505352020264,
0.04885518178343773,
0.2080153524875641,
0.041057050228118896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00497v1 | LLMs-as-Instructors: Learning from Errors Toward Automating Model Improvement | 2024-06-29T17:16:04 | 2024-06-29T17:16:04 | Jiahao Ying, Mingbao Lin, Yixin Cao, Wei Tang, Bo Wang, Qianru Sun, Xuanjing Huang, Shuicheng Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces the innovative "LLMs-as-Instructors" framework, which
leverages the advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) to autonomously enhance the
training of smaller target models. Inspired by the theory of "Learning from
Errors", this framework employs an instructor LLM to meticulously analyze the
specific errors within a target model, facilitating targeted and efficient
training cycles. Within this framework, we implement two strategies: "Learning
from Error," which focuses solely on incorrect responses to tailor training
data, and "Learning from Error by Contrast", which uses contrastive learning to
analyze both correct and incorrect responses for a deeper understanding of
errors.
Our empirical studies, conducted with several open-source models, demonstrate
significant improvements across multiple benchmarks, including mathematical
reasoning, coding abilities, and factual knowledge. Notably, the refined
Llama-3-8b-Instruction has outperformed ChatGPT, illustrating the effectiveness
of our approach. By leveraging the strengths of both strategies, we have
attained a more balanced performance improvement on both in-domain and
out-of-domain benchmarks. Our code can be found at
https://yingjiahao14.github.io/LLMs-as-Instructors-pages/. | [
0.055604152381420135,
-0.7188549041748047,
0.4270988702774048,
0.007613686379045248,
0.042535752058029175,
0.42258524894714355,
-0.39680391550064087,
-0.3111669719219208,
-0.18006566166877747,
0.3240610659122467,
-0.4746630787849426,
-0.5369835495948792,
-0.6952659487724304,
0.11656986176967621,
-0.5365728139877319,
0.6210124492645264,
-0.29887068271636963,
0.6857753992080688,
-0.2859194576740265,
-0.010841422714293003,
-0.44757694005966187,
-0.41712889075279236,
-0.8359927535057068,
-0.26988106966018677,
0.36714446544647217,
0.7284395694732666,
0.3626178503036499,
0.8436967134475708,
0.6655845642089844,
0.2843520939350128,
0.3340775668621063,
0.401827335357666,
-0.4325612187385559,
-0.1468440741300583,
-0.01008059736341238,
-0.6478397250175476,
-0.5396853089332581,
-0.1510740965604782,
0.6608352661132812,
0.7744373679161072,
-0.3789392411708832,
-0.09562548249959946,
0.4360491633415222,
0.8081503510475159,
-0.689047634601593,
0.3797685503959656,
-0.496658056974411,
-0.050100237131118774,
0.015114168636500835,
-0.18703362345695496,
-0.530346691608429,
-0.46538540720939636,
-0.08256392925977707,
-0.5351963639259338,
0.14655393362045288,
-0.11553394794464111,
0.5818917155265808,
0.5136175751686096,
-0.2203063666820526,
-0.6028807163238525,
-0.6295072436332703,
0.8382989764213562,
-0.9477988481521606,
0.40085601806640625,
0.17901770770549774,
0.30782803893089294,
-0.15632891654968262,
-0.5925154685974121,
-0.3831265866756439,
-0.023557668551802635,
-0.02120533026754856,
0.1786431521177292,
0.02370612882077694,
0.09021177142858505,
0.22767744958400726,
0.3338102102279663,
-0.3611065149307251,
0.4401552975177765,
-0.4137885272502899,
-0.018632782623171806,
0.7626568675041199,
0.2354230135679245,
0.18316075205802917,
0.3983016610145569,
-0.10896409302949905,
-0.12895084917545319,
-0.8818564414978027,
-0.10027413815259933,
0.3885813355445862,
0.3105745017528534,
-0.39532190561294556,
0.2883738875389099,
-0.1829795390367508,
0.5296483039855957,
-0.07465056329965591,
-0.06867232173681259,
0.2495698779821396,
0.00002840832166839391,
-0.357009619474411,
-0.109013631939888,
0.4521898329257965,
0.19163289666175842,
-0.029358338564634323,
-0.07396487146615982,
-0.4379070997238159,
0.02640790306031704,
0.21037447452545166,
-0.7315186262130737,
-0.49009963870048523,
0.038806457072496414,
-0.3714311420917511,
-0.4435698390007019,
0.02423500083386898,
-0.8497014045715332,
-0.4424929618835449,
-0.5628734827041626,
0.7129508256912231,
-0.3385646343231201,
-0.08316146582365036,
0.13969717919826508,
0.3490419387817383,
0.1490069478750229,
0.7047330737113953,
-0.7518035769462585,
0.5889897346496582,
0.44821295142173767,
0.6400327682495117,
-0.40365082025527954,
-0.4207565188407898,
-0.5641924738883972,
-0.06020728871226311,
-0.41254886984825134,
0.7216314077377319,
-0.3810211718082428,
-0.4497797191143036,
0.1914493590593338,
-0.4018847346305847,
-0.21352015435695648,
-0.7679202556610107,
0.27820223569869995,
-0.5706965923309326,
0.1718519926071167,
-0.12723062932491302,
-0.812100887298584,
-0.4882989823818207,
0.11539644002914429,
-0.3969776928424835,
1.1098483800888062,
0.011270329356193542,
-0.2683113217353821,
-0.12702491879463196,
-1.05805242061615,
-0.10945996642112732,
-0.37463507056236267,
-0.19117528200149536,
-0.5501286387443542,
0.022532498463988304,
0.1505803018808365,
0.38630411028862,
-0.42336350679397583,
0.08618728071451187,
-0.13406389951705933,
-0.5438627004623413,
0.2642258107662201,
-0.34414783120155334,
0.7497108578681946,
0.004073956049978733,
-0.6937282085418701,
0.24174581468105316,
-0.9874718189239502,
-0.00914672389626503,
0.2897917926311493,
-0.5681483745574951,
-0.014655537903308868,
0.24826353788375854,
-0.3183956444263458,
-0.08537557721138,
0.0740349292755127,
-0.135725200176239,
-0.059676822274923325,
-0.3580891191959381,
0.08399510383605957,
0.9343670606613159,
-0.2674730122089386,
0.41663306951522827,
-0.32933929562568665,
0.4585138261318207,
0.10978464782238007,
0.13825547695159912,
-0.3301566541194916,
-0.03558461740612984,
-1.2235064506530762,
-0.232240691781044,
0.28617361187934875,
0.6421488523483276,
-0.7337219715118408,
0.3347131013870239,
0.0678674727678299,
-0.5158844590187073,
-0.39606964588165283,
0.6694636344909668,
0.5351118445396423,
0.6128531694412231,
0.5168464183807373,
-0.6407487988471985,
-0.6981463432312012,
-0.3950293958187103,
-0.34756848216056824,
-0.3107043206691742,
0.28275853395462036,
0.1659115105867386,
0.4391275644302368,
-0.5789605379104614,
0.6486645936965942,
-0.5770621299743652,
-0.123744897544384,
-0.029272865504026413,
-0.11705609411001205,
-0.029424607753753662,
0.5661981701850891,
0.28602084517478943,
-0.4455016255378723,
-0.6623163819313049,
-0.15041397511959076,
-0.8327428102493286,
-0.2566753029823303,
0.2068486213684082,
-0.10717543214559555,
0.3848329782485962,
0.6884526610374451,
-0.2083512395620346,
0.3419019281864166,
0.43591389060020447,
-0.03348713740706444,
0.7675241827964783,
-0.14612704515457153,
0.022038506343960762,
-0.7643067836761475,
-0.36842620372772217,
-0.2344692200422287,
0.05502166971564293,
-0.5208966135978699,
0.05332034453749657,
0.056356653571128845,
0.148328498005867,
-0.289506733417511,
0.36475828289985657,
-0.49771517515182495,
-0.265173077583313,
-0.38052117824554443,
0.07751645892858505,
-0.07737898081541061,
0.6705350875854492,
-0.15627829730510712,
0.8929924964904785,
0.6545780897140503,
-0.5422338843345642,
0.6014116406440735,
0.10661202669143677,
-0.1974775642156601,
0.6362767815589905,
-0.4427085816860199,
0.30051371455192566,
0.042962271720170975,
0.0009348212042823434,
-1.0313637256622314,
-0.44307345151901245,
0.39828842878341675,
-0.43766212463378906,
0.49518758058547974,
0.018966050818562508,
-0.6364495754241943,
-0.12071693688631058,
-0.16527065634727478,
0.1810729205608368,
0.5112234950065613,
-0.7910684943199158,
0.7348771691322327,
0.033556971698999405,
-0.053226038813591,
-0.756625771522522,
-0.46929770708084106,
-0.21460464596748352,
-0.1622980237007141,
-0.15032339096069336,
-0.03868492320179939,
-0.26696905493736267,
-0.3729448616504669,
-0.023406116291880608,
-0.0336301326751709,
-0.2577926218509674,
0.5129731893539429,
0.1474934220314026,
0.4050034284591675,
-0.3349553942680359,
0.28724536299705505,
-0.034990426152944565,
-0.030971737578511238,
0.2448512315750122,
-0.38124266266822815,
0.3973955810070038,
-0.24255821108818054,
-0.8099868893623352,
-0.647676944732666,
0.026812339201569557,
0.21600589156150818,
-0.08147833496332169,
0.5709267258644104,
0.3229164183139801,
-0.3266679644584656,
-0.23225219547748566,
-0.7083152532577515,
-0.3657715916633606,
-0.4878369867801666,
0.6719679832458496,
0.043891627341508865,
-0.6181230545043945,
0.33244872093200684,
-0.03848149627447128,
0.30232223868370056,
0.2476515769958496,
0.4047415554523468,
-0.4604544937610626,
0.8140898942947388,
0.8649253249168396,
-0.0285198837518692,
0.5566529631614685,
-0.3718452751636505,
-0.007122846785932779,
-0.5539718866348267,
-0.312121719121933,
-0.58465176820755,
-0.0127416318282485,
-0.21222272515296936,
-0.6195243000984192,
0.15159383416175842,
0.15244756639003754,
-0.6651430726051331,
0.10098139196634293,
-0.2345310002565384,
0.43803343176841736,
0.53581702709198,
0.1804286688566208,
0.29975661635398865,
0.2537277340888977,
-0.06950204819440842,
-0.08067171275615692,
-0.8687028288841248,
-0.6172636151313782,
1.3806225061416626,
0.471137136220932,
0.9514120817184448,
0.19333045184612274,
0.8832715749740601,
0.1471709907054901,
0.6301528811454773,
-0.7666128277778625,
0.4588854908943176,
-0.008790889754891396,
-0.22761458158493042,
-0.20249901711940765,
-0.5202324986457825,
-0.4626493752002716,
0.2469603419303894,
-0.10458327829837799,
-0.36317330598831177,
-0.06972510367631912,
0.5306187272071838,
-0.2770359218120575,
0.4457932710647583,
-0.8849762082099915,
0.8751195073127747,
-0.5625081062316895,
-0.3195430338382721,
-0.381330281496048,
-0.55101478099823,
0.17916904389858246,
-0.3203268349170685,
0.4492500126361847,
0.005029917694628239,
-0.22847750782966614,
0.7186088562011719,
-0.344650536775589,
1.2434357404708862,
-0.2530655264854431,
-0.15136410295963287,
0.3083178699016571,
0.07594236731529236,
0.5556396245956421,
-0.3982774615287781,
-0.15160401165485382,
0.08846879750490189,
-0.40257975459098816,
-0.5465716123580933,
-0.8169736266136169,
0.41589418053627014,
-1.1241878271102905,
-0.434087872505188,
-0.06588701158761978,
-0.5099861025810242,
-0.3226197361946106,
0.1135256364941597,
0.018862532451748848,
0.614647388458252,
-0.05381395295262337,
-0.00310027739033103,
0.726004958152771,
-0.23257561028003693,
0.3073616623878479,
0.7050368189811707,
-0.0842195376753807,
-0.5125528573989868,
0.827210009098053,
0.050970789045095444,
0.4381062984466553,
0.40005621314048767,
-0.05996996909379959,
-0.26862862706184387,
-0.7793298959732056,
-0.2973903715610504,
0.2697947919368744,
-1.19941246509552,
-0.37955114245414734,
-0.4397323727607727,
-0.16077739000320435,
-0.2799127399921417,
-0.2807558476924896,
-0.4849412739276886,
-0.10348023474216461,
-0.5848861336708069,
-0.0982474610209465,
0.14489710330963135,
0.7602392435073853,
-0.0832686647772789,
0.7815465331077576,
-0.6242074966430664,
-0.28881046175956726,
0.2612658143043518,
0.3716834783554077,
0.19517762959003448,
-0.788147509098053,
-0.6994373798370361,
0.06423565745353699,
-0.5864375829696655,
-0.6883711218833923,
0.3706875741481781,
0.26707732677459717,
0.6229591965675354,
0.1626916378736496,
-0.15988783538341522,
0.8270022869110107,
-0.5235638618469238,
0.5402703285217285,
0.3361935317516327,
-1.0868092775344849,
0.5003352761268616,
-0.12028057128190994,
-0.07402032613754272,
0.40480855107307434,
0.17204761505126953,
-0.2656601369380951,
-0.4352553188800812,
-0.6749386191368103,
-0.7944869995117188,
0.8434467911720276,
0.08839035779237747,
0.180620938539505,
0.23268820345401764,
0.5394314527511597,
0.1392374336719513,
0.3044069707393646,
-0.8650895357131958,
-0.4156017601490021,
-0.09393560886383057,
-0.5978984236717224,
-0.28609225153923035,
-0.33745288848876953,
-0.12276935577392578,
-0.11180327832698822,
1.1547776460647583,
-0.5222041010856628,
0.46649497747421265,
-0.038249146193265915,
-0.4753389358520508,
-0.20228040218353271,
0.027781901881098747,
0.654630720615387,
0.8097750544548035,
0.08019424229860306,
0.24239256978034973,
0.6142003536224365,
-0.22987505793571472,
0.14110565185546875,
0.08228548616170883,
0.13761423528194427,
-0.09952782839536667,
0.4282817244529724,
0.6825275421142578,
0.5423543453216553,
-0.8446363210678101,
0.4547157883644104,
0.13818052411079407,
0.05609707534313202,
-0.5248219966888428,
0.32896891236305237,
0.05996120721101761,
0.43239548802375793,
0.42103537917137146,
0.10544279217720032,
0.0989512950181961,
-0.1978125423192978,
0.2423294484615326,
0.1744396984577179,
-0.34183353185653687,
-0.20772023499011993,
0.6333262324333191,
0.3441106975078583,
-0.2600194811820984,
0.3683338761329651,
0.11620780825614929,
-0.5179088711738586,
0.837256908416748,
0.5030681490898132,
0.7815000414848328,
-0.3562273383140564,
0.016291899606585503,
0.3989208936691284,
0.053706228733062744,
-0.23501206934452057,
-0.1294398158788681,
-0.05644917115569115,
-0.8508491516113281,
-0.382071316242218,
-0.2837901711463928,
-0.7948516607284546,
-0.2333017885684967,
-0.7243775725364685,
0.5676918029785156,
-0.6299721598625183,
0.3424608111381531,
-0.25821900367736816,
0.13816224038600922,
-0.3959350287914276,
0.2966538369655609,
-0.05004609376192093,
0.8170521259307861,
-0.6855570077896118,
0.7665176391601562,
0.844836950302124,
-0.2859225869178772,
-1.0098525285720825,
-0.03830960765480995,
0.3082475960254669,
-0.9404823780059814,
0.8202794790267944,
0.11407975852489471,
-0.22713381052017212,
0.21399542689323425,
-0.637860119342804,
-0.7999457716941833,
1.1911697387695312,
0.4515936076641083,
-0.6826927065849304,
-0.07263348251581192,
-0.0635981634259224,
0.41685107350349426,
-0.6371518969535828,
0.349615216255188,
0.5479275584220886,
-0.18811017274856567,
0.04779301956295967,
-0.7845892310142517,
-0.2470322996377945,
0.06141076982021332,
-0.010303692892193794,
-0.0889386534690857,
-0.5948860049247742,
0.6021639108657837,
-0.285391241312027,
0.11674375832080841,
0.08571051061153412,
0.7786884903907776,
0.16577497124671936,
0.2641521096229553,
0.34262144565582275,
0.3868292272090912,
0.8322842121124268,
-0.07480373233556747,
0.8258920907974243,
-0.0856437236070633,
0.5474587678909302,
1.305245280265808,
-0.17806775867938995,
0.9104136824607849,
0.36450430750846863,
-0.298206627368927,
0.7578966021537781,
0.7029201984405518,
0.027737446129322052,
0.4744648337364197,
-0.008454576134681702,
-0.24092034995555878,
-0.14312094449996948,
0.504906415939331,
-0.16480109095573425,
0.27588510513305664,
0.4615302085876465,
-0.2942492365837097,
-0.29451513290405273,
-0.06149804964661598,
0.09500984847545624,
0.337924599647522,
-0.38471686840057373,
0.7636662721633911,
0.1844482272863388,
-0.2685951292514801,
0.571664571762085,
0.1344224363565445,
0.6377567648887634,
-0.32625696063041687,
-0.03816749528050423,
-0.27596017718315125,
0.4574858844280243,
-0.3577442467212677,
-0.27451154589653015,
0.3597954511642456,
0.129928857088089,
-0.08243799954652786,
-0.07497354596853256,
0.5682885646820068,
-0.5676165819168091,
-0.32178524136543274,
0.3579869270324707,
0.3320067524909973,
0.1817774921655655,
0.4106101393699646,
-0.9720718860626221,
0.27199438214302063,
0.07561232149600983,
0.21341155469417572,
0.16023552417755127,
0.0005834916373714805,
0.23014076054096222,
0.7481788992881775,
0.4211241602897644,
0.037433166056871414,
0.09032481163740158,
-0.17343614995479584,
0.6749308109283447,
-0.3817313313484192,
-0.314625084400177,
-0.9335796236991882,
0.616439163684845,
-0.044856101274490356,
0.13336656987667084,
0.6116712093353271,
0.533758282661438,
1.2339462041854858,
-0.1464858204126358,
0.7573462128639221,
0.26497748494148254,
0.8658422827720642,
-0.6754013895988464,
0.39211612939834595,
-0.5921859741210938,
0.7996549606323242,
-0.14845393598079681,
-0.8750625848770142,
-0.4126589298248291,
0.8099445700645447,
-0.46737971901893616,
0.13410831987857819,
0.610075056552887,
0.9625788331031799,
0.11561059951782227,
-0.15947987139225006,
0.3910057246685028,
0.2448791265487671,
0.366828054189682,
0.5019856095314026,
0.8980171084403992,
-0.7596918344497681,
0.4792928099632263,
-0.3058204650878906,
-0.10200916975736618,
-0.4957106411457062,
-0.5172016024589539,
-0.8688241839408875,
-0.28393325209617615,
-0.7857205867767334,
-0.47358500957489014,
0.29816970229148865,
1.3604282140731812,
0.4263814091682434,
-0.9377926588058472,
-0.7110344767570496,
-0.20627760887145996,
0.29954269528388977,
-0.14983701705932617,
-0.1366625428199768,
0.36231544613838196,
-0.8465526700019836,
-0.9037303924560547,
0.23118749260902405,
0.14345782995224,
0.30249276757240295,
-0.056416064500808716,
-0.5356037616729736,
0.22830650210380554,
0.14245937764644623,
0.5037704706192017,
0.23830078542232513,
-0.6256444454193115,
-0.18877288699150085,
-0.11303424835205078,
-0.3101016581058502,
0.2587203085422516,
0.6623133420944214,
-0.4191637635231018,
0.40884411334991455,
-0.09664683043956757,
0.9866085052490234,
0.1907176673412323,
-0.23391297459602356,
0.6430636048316956,
-0.5255151391029358,
0.009050628170371056,
0.033204738050699234,
0.29692602157592773,
0.61989825963974,
-0.2621075212955475,
0.6684225797653198,
0.5728883147239685,
-0.3672776222229004,
-1.0560318231582642,
0.11339813470840454,
-0.5851830244064331,
-0.01968587189912796,
1.1601365804672241,
-0.4634750187397003,
-0.07864687591791153,
-0.013878729194402695,
-0.22550636529922485,
0.2962796688079834,
-0.056717175990343094,
0.9537538290023804,
0.6071149110794067,
-0.15735480189323425,
-0.30421966314315796,
-0.7060083746910095,
0.5854166150093079,
0.5972881317138672,
-1.0751591920852661,
-0.05259307846426964,
0.6232162714004517,
0.5528085231781006,
-0.09123919159173965,
0.4973618686199188,
-0.23352624475955963,
0.5929139852523804,
-0.05418211966753006,
0.19939497113227844,
-0.08089148253202438,
-0.21160100400447845,
-0.6591640710830688,
-0.18048132956027985,
0.43394532799720764,
-0.23648451268672943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00488v1 | PFME: A Modular Approach for Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing of Large Language Models | 2024-06-29T16:35:57 | 2024-06-29T16:35:57 | Kunquan Deng, Zeyu Huang, Chen Li, Chenghua Lin, Min Gao, Wenge Rong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in fluency but risk producing inaccurate
content, called "hallucinations." This paper outlines a standardized process
for categorizing fine-grained hallucination types and proposes an innovative
framework--the Progressive Fine-grained Model Editor (PFME)--specifically
designed to detect and correct fine-grained hallucinations in LLMs. PFME
consists of two collaborative modules: the Real-time Fact Retrieval Module and
the Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing Module. The former
identifies key entities in the document and retrieves the latest factual
evidence from credible sources. The latter further segments the document into
sentence-level text and, based on relevant evidence and previously edited
context, identifies, locates, and edits each sentence's hallucination type.
Experimental results on FavaBench and FActScore demonstrate that PFME
outperforms existing methods in fine-grained hallucination detection tasks.
Particularly, when using the Llama3-8B-Instruct model, PFME's performance in
fine-grained hallucination detection with external knowledge assistance
improves by 8.7 percentage points (pp) compared to ChatGPT. In editing tasks,
PFME further enhances the FActScore of FActScore-Alpaca13B and
FActScore-ChatGPT datasets, increasing by 16.2pp and 4.6pp, respectively. | [
-0.4873638451099396,
-1.144940733909607,
0.835864245891571,
0.20259225368499756,
0.060579899698495865,
-0.28441208600997925,
-0.4147816300392151,
-0.4236688017845154,
0.2424592822790146,
0.6522654891014099,
-0.39978593587875366,
-0.7707346081733704,
-0.5662243962287903,
0.18477003276348114,
-0.6545714139938354,
0.6923648118972778,
-0.15249411761760712,
0.001005898229777813,
-0.06699758023023605,
0.1961609423160553,
-0.3070354759693146,
-0.7467905879020691,
-0.48051315546035767,
-0.2782692015171051,
0.36957117915153503,
0.4757366478443146,
1.0634557008743286,
0.38366568088531494,
0.666239321231842,
0.3307165801525116,
-0.26122066378593445,
0.24877560138702393,
-0.42207369208335876,
-0.02689867466688156,
-0.21645863354206085,
-0.395706444978714,
-0.8465572595596313,
-0.22190386056900024,
0.23869051039218903,
0.6043717265129089,
-0.2867853045463562,
-0.09336978197097778,
-0.07737486809492111,
0.577226996421814,
-0.5830857753753662,
0.18270505964756012,
-0.5952253341674805,
0.31340229511260986,
-0.10494595766067505,
-0.13367486000061035,
-0.6775699257850647,
-0.29384303092956543,
0.06531839072704315,
-0.2959373891353607,
0.2761712670326233,
-0.0690753161907196,
0.5369683504104614,
0.24143142998218536,
0.002623602282255888,
-0.5845389366149902,
-0.6027629971504211,
0.36991000175476074,
-0.7174913287162781,
0.562204897403717,
0.4814107418060303,
0.22032073140144348,
-0.5634126663208008,
-0.8860734701156616,
-0.7093621492385864,
-0.46197953820228577,
-0.19261950254440308,
-0.3260275423526764,
-0.06051395460963249,
0.39231571555137634,
0.34516602754592896,
0.7194355130195618,
-0.4811359941959381,
0.1958979070186615,
-0.07068009674549103,
-0.6693590879440308,
0.5188949704170227,
0.20436100661754608,
0.2366403341293335,
-0.2341265082359314,
-0.007691008038818836,
0.1537332832813263,
-0.29823780059814453,
-0.24512404203414917,
0.21257862448692322,
0.040686946362257004,
0.36640962958335876,
0.8476275205612183,
-0.37584635615348816,
0.5236183404922485,
0.1607193946838379,
-0.32999321818351746,
0.25092488527297974,
-0.038571760058403015,
-0.515579104423523,
0.16309069097042084,
0.5921207666397095,
0.35990577936172485,
0.22802802920341492,
-0.5053377747535706,
-0.5999400615692139,
0.027567416429519653,
0.2560091018676758,
-0.7962045669555664,
-0.5071215033531189,
0.2985272705554962,
-0.6461812853813171,
-0.33731353282928467,
0.23655469715595245,
-0.8583662509918213,
-0.6632834076881409,
-0.49675410985946655,
0.8444480299949646,
-0.5273700952529907,
-0.25438183546066284,
0.5702829360961914,
-0.03042849712073803,
-0.019475365057587624,
0.4220460057258606,
-0.8679275512695312,
0.4292374551296234,
0.7988274693489075,
0.9976482391357422,
-0.4776434600353241,
-0.44837385416030884,
-0.629220724105835,
-0.08420495688915253,
-0.18271994590759277,
1.099207878112793,
-0.6295496821403503,
-0.258649617433548,
-0.00010665258014341816,
0.37234196066856384,
-0.017227699980139732,
-0.9390044808387756,
0.6588140726089478,
-0.2648893892765045,
-0.004982398822903633,
-0.11408206820487976,
-0.6798864603042603,
-0.4248387813568115,
-0.04677511006593704,
-0.5988770127296448,
1.1666651964187622,
0.11145828664302826,
-0.6407294273376465,
0.18899165093898773,
-0.4941326677799225,
-0.2991877496242523,
-0.2929178476333618,
0.07861865311861038,
-0.34758269786834717,
0.4104357063770294,
0.21762146055698395,
0.8274499177932739,
0.13799861073493958,
0.7739553451538086,
-0.17179977893829346,
-0.548946738243103,
0.23877772688865662,
-0.5060775876045227,
0.33058083057403564,
-0.0938384160399437,
-0.4689750075340271,
0.5354866981506348,
-1.0158404111862183,
-0.5433608293533325,
-0.026894116774201393,
-0.3079575300216675,
-0.09470890462398529,
0.12591727077960968,
0.13154086470603943,
0.20292583107948303,
0.19476822018623352,
-0.2678757309913635,
0.2308582067489624,
-0.3062910735607147,
0.2396564483642578,
0.7165495157241821,
0.15348973870277405,
0.26857441663742065,
-0.5084492564201355,
0.12094384431838989,
0.143611878156662,
0.42028629779815674,
0.008596811443567276,
-0.3984161615371704,
-0.8361009955406189,
-0.3183700442314148,
0.006093054078519344,
0.617220938205719,
-0.5383528470993042,
0.8436865210533142,
0.16758760809898376,
-0.3978968560695648,
-0.2283666580915451,
-0.0035230701323598623,
-0.012708560563623905,
0.3818264305591583,
0.5136163830757141,
-0.25376594066619873,
-0.49950987100601196,
-1.0424365997314453,
0.057912420481443405,
-0.06502364575862885,
-0.1571606695652008,
-0.0567542165517807,
0.6314065456390381,
-0.5029959678649902,
0.6782070994377136,
-0.5587816834449768,
-0.42205187678337097,
0.10909084230661392,
0.2867782711982727,
0.03923345357179642,
0.45630818605422974,
0.2747928202152252,
-0.48529914021492004,
-0.15785518288612366,
0.0018326555145904422,
-0.683908224105835,
-0.33882784843444824,
-0.1548713743686676,
-0.18231022357940674,
0.5059004426002502,
0.5906649827957153,
-0.6839396953582764,
0.3084199130535126,
0.3656177818775177,
-0.3788945972919464,
0.9493584632873535,
0.05623367056250572,
0.2760266065597534,
-0.789044201374054,
-0.06858555972576141,
-0.20799118280410767,
-0.21581080555915833,
-0.6842795610427856,
-0.004619981162250042,
-0.1378783881664276,
0.10927731543779373,
-0.29060667753219604,
0.11941055953502655,
-0.2539900839328766,
-0.20256102085113525,
-0.28289762139320374,
0.22672884166240692,
-0.2763728201389313,
0.5212992429733276,
0.25279873609542847,
0.743843674659729,
0.562441349029541,
-0.3911864459514618,
0.3362262547016144,
0.10862778127193451,
-0.6483622193336487,
0.2162889540195465,
-0.06932120025157928,
0.279415100812912,
-0.10324468463659286,
0.10722742974758148,
-0.8210840225219727,
-0.4394935369491577,
0.2575632631778717,
-0.20517279207706451,
0.17578980326652527,
0.3365837037563324,
-0.6683390736579895,
-0.10853201150894165,
-0.3520607054233551,
-0.06554389744997025,
0.08097632229328156,
-0.6190515160560608,
0.7328653335571289,
0.3381146192550659,
-0.05286798253655434,
-0.37124258279800415,
-0.6176016926765442,
0.1925356537103653,
0.0021695145405828953,
-0.7369523048400879,
0.3328969478607178,
-0.10858011990785599,
-0.3949752748012543,
0.027843983843922615,
-0.4437355101108551,
-0.23188111186027527,
0.14001066982746124,
0.14576707780361176,
0.08631584048271179,
-0.5543068647384644,
0.05991080403327942,
0.04705747961997986,
0.04048404097557068,
0.06635814160108566,
-0.03299853950738907,
0.8633908629417419,
-0.05883774161338806,
-0.1643747091293335,
-0.8518854975700378,
0.24754707515239716,
0.743722677230835,
0.05662264674901962,
0.6876378059387207,
0.7469103336334229,
-0.7117981910705566,
-0.16938522458076477,
-0.7698380351066589,
-0.41369953751564026,
-0.4547273516654968,
0.4684450924396515,
-0.5370789766311646,
-1.0098717212677002,
0.5872255563735962,
-0.03725762292742729,
-0.11708866059780121,
0.4055383801460266,
0.6739605069160461,
0.3054925501346588,
0.8641288876533508,
0.5086943507194519,
0.09675879776477814,
0.36485037207603455,
-0.05767379701137543,
0.2990470230579376,
-0.6890931725502014,
-0.3951515853404999,
-0.45622122287750244,
-0.10908317565917969,
-0.3654854893684387,
-0.7160826325416565,
0.07367963343858719,
0.3209537863731384,
0.050946254283189774,
0.15617968142032623,
-0.6247056722640991,
0.5395916104316711,
0.10129748284816742,
0.2151767611503601,
0.6404767036437988,
0.02140808291733265,
0.07057257741689682,
-0.04132775962352753,
-0.4377972185611725,
-0.7828475832939148,
0.8214498162269592,
0.5208001136779785,
0.6159753799438477,
0.030879579484462738,
0.6304000616073608,
0.5114511847496033,
0.3717891573905945,
-1.2842724323272705,
0.7837805151939392,
-0.1680283546447754,
-0.4632168114185333,
-0.27510693669319153,
-0.1586793214082718,
-0.25093376636505127,
0.2634330689907074,
-0.43291398882865906,
-1.0376871824264526,
0.4783680737018585,
-0.10193099826574326,
-0.3505948483943939,
0.4267198145389557,
-0.7359523177146912,
0.8539630174636841,
0.1433226466178894,
-0.13802768290042877,
-0.4490368664264679,
-0.19165609776973724,
0.6186490654945374,
-0.295651376247406,
0.06650853157043457,
-0.04281945154070854,
0.12732301652431488,
0.7418379783630371,
-0.33116796612739563,
0.7560643553733826,
-0.21282848715782166,
-0.37072837352752686,
0.12764187157154083,
0.4830407500267029,
0.7945212721824646,
0.19414840638637543,
-0.23105040192604065,
0.19848522543907166,
-0.053350064903497696,
0.011428787373006344,
-0.6414797902107239,
0.640011191368103,
-0.45640191435813904,
-0.8584526181221008,
-0.38788968324661255,
-0.6057541370391846,
-0.272381991147995,
-0.07363131642341614,
0.08491761237382889,
0.5165270566940308,
-0.25432121753692627,
0.30184417963027954,
0.8313494324684143,
-0.2391105443239212,
0.2722075283527374,
0.5394423007965088,
-0.5597863793373108,
-0.3461284339427948,
0.8880553841590881,
0.11524654924869537,
0.1655145138502121,
0.42522144317626953,
0.18200919032096863,
0.017120620235800743,
-1.010481834411621,
0.0816323533654213,
0.22452431917190552,
-0.9301256537437439,
-0.0676691085100174,
-1.0837785005569458,
-0.31829017400741577,
-0.28802281618118286,
-0.32719823718070984,
-0.38761627674102783,
-0.33634281158447266,
-0.3071151673793793,
-0.07869281619787216,
0.28986993432044983,
0.7175483107566833,
-0.13443641364574432,
0.42633137106895447,
-0.5831339359283447,
0.500005841255188,
0.17820024490356445,
0.34992849826812744,
-0.0009323108242824674,
-0.5071765780448914,
-0.030107468366622925,
-0.3117545247077942,
-0.1988329440355301,
-0.8954035639762878,
0.14338833093643188,
-0.04228265583515167,
0.4040257930755615,
0.44135209918022156,
-0.09238047897815704,
0.7327821850776672,
-0.3587719202041626,
0.8533138036727905,
-0.09126229584217072,
-1.2000021934509277,
0.3406025469303131,
-0.017886197194457054,
-0.07561658322811127,
0.5801514983177185,
0.295402854681015,
-0.5896619558334351,
-0.6751788258552551,
-0.24628444015979767,
-0.6300441026687622,
0.8353314995765686,
0.04721326753497124,
-0.10222040861845016,
-0.19720661640167236,
0.46766555309295654,
0.426651269197464,
0.04340806603431702,
-0.6329858303070068,
0.08327583968639374,
-0.015429981984198093,
-0.1934754103422165,
0.14794450998306274,
-0.5377148985862732,
0.11656327545642853,
-0.5316407680511475,
0.8628048300743103,
-0.1546955704689026,
0.26470890641212463,
0.6307902336120605,
-0.42619508504867554,
-0.11818390339612961,
0.13407564163208008,
0.7151837944984436,
0.6631292700767517,
-0.542198657989502,
0.2217242419719696,
0.1503167301416397,
-0.6757728457450867,
-0.02155272103846073,
-0.14768165349960327,
-0.03362179547548294,
0.11067438870668411,
0.4368996322154999,
0.8814348578453064,
0.30323898792266846,
-0.6040353775024414,
0.38306209444999695,
0.0257930438965559,
-0.31381499767303467,
-0.20439906418323517,
0.24576857686042786,
-0.053102850914001465,
0.42017892003059387,
0.23195327818393707,
0.20055268704891205,
0.4848564565181732,
-0.6269481778144836,
0.5078794956207275,
0.1965092271566391,
-0.16130509972572327,
-0.3789767622947693,
0.41371798515319824,
0.00011879279190907255,
-0.4813099205493927,
0.3629292845726013,
-0.16213689744472504,
-0.4284152686595917,
0.486983984708786,
0.6325240135192871,
1.0168315172195435,
-0.3084487318992615,
0.37284570932388306,
0.28270259499549866,
0.47296249866485596,
-0.597301721572876,
0.1989915668964386,
0.11767136305570602,
-0.6540356874465942,
-0.4150453209877014,
-0.9718301892280579,
-0.25274983048439026,
0.5205338597297668,
-0.499491423368454,
0.5877671241760254,
-0.4203907549381256,
-0.06071800738573074,
0.31449997425079346,
-0.18186156451702118,
-0.10438484698534012,
-0.0018420984270051122,
0.12667754292488098,
1.050183892250061,
-0.7927451133728027,
0.9955817461013794,
0.512951672077179,
-0.1730743944644928,
-0.5190444588661194,
0.5496052503585815,
0.13626262545585632,
-0.5395755767822266,
0.2968185245990753,
0.2699677646160126,
-0.1711234748363495,
0.04504870995879173,
-0.30413663387298584,
-0.5910597443580627,
0.9388323426246643,
0.273845374584198,
-0.7754895687103271,
-0.1442698836326599,
-0.08588336408138275,
0.43825873732566833,
-0.4005188047885895,
-0.12386251240968704,
1.0425232648849487,
0.6789632439613342,
0.09507692605257034,
-0.9321326017379761,
0.11143556237220764,
0.19511494040489197,
-0.17056673765182495,
0.3200007379055023,
-0.3940877616405487,
0.709468424320221,
0.11628053337335587,
-0.2348453402519226,
0.07820893824100494,
0.5538125038146973,
-0.16187654435634613,
0.2790749669075012,
0.46284040808677673,
0.42642611265182495,
0.9648759365081787,
-0.036907073110342026,
0.6547635197639465,
-0.2540634274482727,
0.36083096265792847,
0.9973745346069336,
-0.2702973783016205,
0.9441812634468079,
0.4565364718437195,
-0.052379049360752106,
0.33539891242980957,
0.5924967527389526,
-0.1122652217745781,
0.2880614399909973,
-0.0671684741973877,
-0.29249972105026245,
-0.3178694546222687,
0.04357633739709854,
-0.15036959946155548,
0.45068803429603577,
0.4185694456100464,
-0.33876490592956543,
-0.14741212129592896,
0.22073742747306824,
0.15467983484268188,
0.1790827512741089,
-0.3053995966911316,
0.8086796402931213,
-0.00489842751994729,
-0.6187551617622375,
0.662189245223999,
0.10551994293928146,
0.7568147778511047,
-0.32946720719337463,
0.09190984070301056,
-0.2956066429615021,
0.24063988029956818,
-0.6153753995895386,
-0.8079025149345398,
0.8426729440689087,
-0.003995980601757765,
-0.29022523760795593,
0.24941717088222504,
0.7017828822135925,
-0.34002557396888733,
-0.45141926407814026,
0.3899369537830353,
0.21425925195217133,
0.21356238424777985,
-0.4215526282787323,
-0.4164518117904663,
0.3045598864555359,
-0.07923167198896408,
-0.3510020077228546,
0.22698555886745453,
0.5383086800575256,
-0.1250152289867401,
0.36460956931114197,
0.47578996419906616,
-0.07852053642272949,
0.020181873813271523,
0.19841794669628143,
0.7271489500999451,
-0.6591653823852539,
-0.09863346070051193,
-0.9618309736251831,
0.24491804838180542,
-0.03755783289670944,
-0.09876129776239395,
0.5073170065879822,
0.7079002261161804,
0.7557516098022461,
-0.27610453963279724,
0.39808493852615356,
-0.06183083355426788,
-0.09816252440214157,
-0.8666170835494995,
0.6135592460632324,
-0.47419285774230957,
0.09957569092512131,
-0.26380419731140137,
-1.181401252746582,
-0.5593048930168152,
0.8940359950065613,
-0.19812193512916565,
-0.4678346514701843,
1.2348406314849854,
1.372838020324707,
-0.16105087101459503,
0.32447943091392517,
0.4682252109050751,
0.7106250524520874,
0.11143657565116882,
0.41420015692710876,
0.8164159655570984,
-0.22230468690395355,
0.24716323614120483,
-0.43291351199150085,
-0.31797993183135986,
-0.27186617255210876,
-0.6047866940498352,
-1.120287537574768,
-0.724697470664978,
-0.4883681833744049,
-0.35294148325920105,
0.04074394702911377,
1.177520513534546,
0.3688034117221832,
-1.076667070388794,
-0.20573554933071136,
-0.1465539038181305,
0.06831221282482147,
-0.2587415277957916,
-0.31194400787353516,
0.405033677816391,
-0.44361478090286255,
-0.6417533159255981,
0.4795118272304535,
0.6567441821098328,
-0.11153539270162582,
-0.39677169919013977,
0.015405751764774323,
-0.24682284891605377,
0.23286816477775574,
0.9210033416748047,
-0.2697109580039978,
-0.9329326152801514,
-0.4366617500782013,
-0.03453386574983597,
-0.05494391545653343,
0.2742342948913574,
0.9392547607421875,
-0.28778424859046936,
0.21747344732284546,
0.5953826904296875,
0.5173574686050415,
0.33801841735839844,
-0.24831439554691315,
0.17769761383533478,
-0.2960348427295685,
0.38767489790916443,
0.16613751649856567,
0.3084484040737152,
0.223652645945549,
-0.6361410617828369,
0.33348751068115234,
0.5222324132919312,
-0.6722410917282104,
-1.029118537902832,
0.03308657556772232,
-1.0184763669967651,
-0.5286121368408203,
1.1861423254013062,
0.1306491643190384,
-0.3993143141269684,
-0.3319109082221985,
-0.6503832936286926,
0.15304450690746307,
-0.29350408911705017,
1.2321293354034424,
1.1762505769729614,
-0.05240173265337944,
-0.007272246293723583,
-0.786068856716156,
0.7029245495796204,
0.13256171345710754,
-0.8444742560386658,
0.43539345264434814,
0.8349865674972534,
0.0758264809846878,
0.17656564712524414,
0.5671812295913696,
-0.26168617606163025,
0.21656900644302368,
-0.12300310283899307,
0.17750157415866852,
-0.09424707293510437,
-0.6156203746795654,
-0.4008069932460785,
0.4580640494823456,
0.11630713939666748,
0.27661383152008057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00487v1 | It's Morphing Time: Unleashing the Potential of Multiple LLMs via Multi-objective Optimization | 2024-06-29T16:34:23 | 2024-06-29T16:34:23 | Bingdong Li, Zixiang Di, Yanting Yang, Hong Qian, Peng Yang, Hao Hao, Ke Tang, Aimin Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce a novel approach for large language model merging
via black-box multi-objective optimization algorithms. The goal of model
merging is to combine multiple models, each excelling in different tasks, into
a single model that outperforms any of the individual source models. However,
model merging faces two significant challenges: First, existing methods rely
heavily on human intuition and customized strategies. Second, parameter
conflicts often arise during merging, and while methods like DARE [1] can
alleviate this issue, they tend to stochastically drop parameters, risking the
loss of important delta parameters. To address these challenges, we propose the
MM-MO method, which automates the search for optimal merging configurations
using multi-objective optimization algorithms, eliminating the need for human
intuition. During the configuration searching process, we use estimated
performance across multiple diverse tasks as optimization objectives in order
to alleviate the parameter conflicting between different source models without
losing crucial delta parameters. We conducted comparative experiments with
other mainstream model merging methods, demonstrating that our method
consistently outperforms them. Moreover, our experiments reveal that even task
types not explicitly targeted as optimization objectives show performance
improvements, indicating that our method enhances the overall potential of the
model rather than merely overfitting to specific task types. This approach
provides a significant advancement in model merging techniques, offering a
robust and plug-and-play solution for integrating diverse models into a
unified, high-performing model. | [
-0.6995134949684143,
-0.5448895692825317,
0.6584399342536926,
-0.013730403035879135,
-0.4314652681350708,
0.31624868512153625,
-0.1766631156206131,
-0.4019129276275635,
-0.19464077055454254,
0.5435647964477539,
-0.9012600183486938,
-0.2526146471500397,
-0.718450129032135,
-0.26424679160118103,
-0.25883132219314575,
0.7368444800376892,
0.051954347640275955,
-0.10032930225133896,
-0.03752738609910011,
0.03178992494940758,
-0.3280155658721924,
-0.39785102009773254,
-0.45477691292762756,
-0.294194757938385,
0.40774327516555786,
0.26076146960258484,
0.4702956974506378,
0.8560968637466431,
0.6576076149940491,
0.2663773000240326,
-0.02140773832798004,
0.9845816493034363,
-0.3783397078514099,
0.07993240654468536,
0.05955313891172409,
-0.14987899363040924,
-0.4916032552719116,
0.19222106039524078,
0.5775269865989685,
0.48834821581840515,
-0.3525340259075165,
0.16044601798057556,
0.1411084681749344,
0.3476395308971405,
-0.9309420585632324,
-0.11526831239461899,
-0.7866860628128052,
0.182987779378891,
-0.15698184072971344,
-0.4059617817401886,
-0.1968807876110077,
-0.21175767481327057,
-0.020817561075091362,
-0.20965534448623657,
-0.09452929347753525,
-0.027575766667723656,
0.9304144382476807,
0.3743418753147125,
-0.6434038877487183,
-0.04066431149840355,
-0.7630133628845215,
1.2778371572494507,
-1.0027945041656494,
0.20461152493953705,
-0.27368074655532837,
0.4292214810848236,
0.05647251009941101,
0.056866686791181564,
-0.48407870531082153,
-0.19229865074157715,
0.21507373452186584,
0.08718855679035187,
-0.25517627596855164,
0.207650288939476,
0.0003500383463688195,
0.2931704819202423,
-0.4010605812072754,
0.07349168509244919,
-0.730793833732605,
-0.12634210288524628,
0.5700472593307495,
0.01662455126643181,
0.3563591539859772,
-0.07290457934141159,
-0.3515697717666626,
0.01766396500170231,
-0.4617045223712921,
-0.19555795192718506,
0.567119300365448,
0.48313799500465393,
-0.048697229474782944,
0.9371916055679321,
-0.02780577540397644,
0.7148813605308533,
-0.03377818688750267,
-0.4237019419670105,
0.1788690686225891,
-0.7738561034202576,
-0.20994597673416138,
-0.09151633083820343,
0.8296108245849609,
0.7144302725791931,
0.09050419181585312,
-0.12850001454353333,
-0.04593710973858833,
0.136005237698555,
0.5196521878242493,
-0.6450173854827881,
0.21588657796382904,
0.23255547881126404,
-0.3969922661781311,
-0.30457401275634766,
-0.06632863730192184,
-0.8561086654663086,
0.06335164606571198,
-0.5993286371231079,
0.2677440941333771,
-0.36770886182785034,
-0.3160378634929657,
0.26888397336006165,
-0.00797956995666027,
0.13043121993541718,
0.14227734506130219,
-0.7448351383209229,
-0.1899861842393875,
0.8205925822257996,
0.9995254278182983,
-0.1739509403705597,
-0.3362775146961212,
-0.5466360449790955,
0.49412932991981506,
-0.391787588596344,
0.34985730051994324,
-0.4651457369327545,
-0.5970466136932373,
-0.03814280405640602,
-0.38732004165649414,
-0.10384757816791534,
-0.3415675163269043,
0.3469102382659912,
-0.18380892276763916,
0.4176202416419983,
0.20836761593818665,
-0.2110523134469986,
-0.37372350692749023,
0.47006186842918396,
-0.3903608024120331,
1.068880319595337,
0.07406768202781677,
-0.09348031878471375,
0.2085048258304596,
-0.922941267490387,
-0.3075513541698456,
-0.37043455243110657,
0.004057730082422495,
-0.4106942415237427,
0.3759479522705078,
0.2908004820346832,
0.7075023651123047,
-0.6092654466629028,
0.28751325607299805,
-0.46435385942459106,
0.025960266590118408,
-0.09045863896608353,
-0.348271906375885,
0.6356547474861145,
0.3657395541667938,
-0.144806370139122,
0.056305304169654846,
-0.7257494926452637,
0.0962015837430954,
-0.19695472717285156,
-0.32000473141670227,
-0.38436728715896606,
-0.15628130733966827,
-0.30074161291122437,
0.5461283326148987,
0.52492356300354,
-0.26565277576446533,
0.7001401782035828,
-0.24248279631137848,
0.6197025179862976,
0.5910183191299438,
-0.08776308596134186,
0.7757361531257629,
-0.5399155020713806,
0.5569508075714111,
0.1686851680278778,
0.29924994707107544,
-0.24258407950401306,
-0.57425856590271,
-0.7994118928909302,
-0.2594268023967743,
-0.11033763736486435,
0.456798791885376,
-0.2803579568862915,
0.581356942653656,
-0.3048720359802246,
-0.7863109707832336,
-0.8607341647148132,
0.3234254717826843,
0.5497533082962036,
0.4229739308357239,
0.47057682275772095,
-0.1644480973482132,
-0.5071284770965576,
-1.210817813873291,
0.10512155294418335,
-0.11672413349151611,
-0.01611117087304592,
0.443668931722641,
0.16306926310062408,
-0.5458710789680481,
0.7323595881462097,
-0.570696234703064,
-0.26669782400131226,
0.01376907154917717,
0.3938370943069458,
0.25660547614097595,
0.6021797060966492,
0.6163188815116882,
-0.7318071722984314,
-0.24253077805042267,
0.5208761096000671,
-0.5920203924179077,
-0.2682012915611267,
-0.08864498883485794,
-0.3424600064754486,
0.04690048098564148,
0.40803951025009155,
-0.5556524395942688,
-0.24633611738681793,
1.0644862651824951,
0.35262537002563477,
0.6094919443130493,
-0.09321032464504242,
0.6689133644104004,
-1.5792328119277954,
-0.30881398916244507,
-0.01900864951312542,
0.3390945792198181,
-0.5358233451843262,
0.22244404256343842,
0.33215248584747314,
-0.2737584710121155,
-0.7424324154853821,
0.6256056427955627,
-0.8500340580940247,
0.18692170083522797,
-0.21628381311893463,
0.060577817261219025,
-0.11322841048240662,
0.44801047444343567,
-0.6856045722961426,
0.6544423699378967,
0.8225830793380737,
-0.847235381603241,
0.27873528003692627,
-0.1474725604057312,
0.028176240622997284,
0.5136617422103882,
-0.04527878761291504,
0.11686321347951889,
-0.1400361806154251,
-0.30884918570518494,
-1.034773826599121,
-0.059136491268873215,
0.25755786895751953,
-0.25279533863067627,
0.2721039652824402,
-0.4410659074783325,
-0.2063739001750946,
-0.41318073868751526,
-0.42455050349235535,
0.5607712864875793,
0.32806235551834106,
-0.34756559133529663,
1.2360002994537354,
0.14698801934719086,
-0.10000808537006378,
-0.847891628742218,
-0.9041447639465332,
0.26748624444007874,
-0.4911714494228363,
-0.927466094493866,
0.8384080529212952,
-0.3310714066028595,
-0.002255984116345644,
0.1848299503326416,
-0.28009289503097534,
-0.11450398713350296,
-0.14503213763237,
0.03070763871073723,
0.535861074924469,
-0.2545919120311737,
-0.18708916008472443,
0.5165919661521912,
-0.12235051393508911,
-0.5142463445663452,
-0.24862529337406158,
0.6040785312652588,
0.28310373425483704,
-0.5987257957458496,
-0.5439434051513672,
0.46371930837631226,
1.23361337184906,
-0.5673515796661377,
0.7238826155662537,
0.5366106629371643,
-0.25427332520484924,
-0.10663193464279175,
-1.0501453876495361,
0.11423838138580322,
-0.4428616762161255,
0.4714108109474182,
-0.6062508225440979,
-0.9118354320526123,
0.497743159532547,
-0.11387349665164948,
0.643674373626709,
0.1628333330154419,
0.5097979307174683,
0.059888727962970734,
1.1912592649459839,
0.718157172203064,
-0.10348924249410629,
0.6024422645568848,
-0.3899465799331665,
0.3504752814769745,
-0.9966416954994202,
-0.24389496445655823,
-0.42012888193130493,
-0.3946865200996399,
-0.4376538097858429,
-0.9125531315803528,
0.19571788609027863,
0.15171919763088226,
0.0816139206290245,
0.5009538531303406,
-0.626332700252533,
0.4417160451412201,
0.34399595856666565,
-0.14538580179214478,
0.39299649000167847,
0.03871079906821251,
-0.1043146401643753,
-0.11515156924724579,
-0.5185916423797607,
-0.4629674553871155,
1.2064307928085327,
-0.011107665486633778,
0.657536506652832,
0.2074909508228302,
0.92598557472229,
-0.21081717312335968,
0.19866478443145752,
-0.799918532371521,
0.6781018376350403,
-0.4884605407714844,
-0.4637174904346466,
-0.19342078268527985,
-0.553068995475769,
-0.7396112680435181,
0.7547816634178162,
-0.35231631994247437,
-0.6137043833732605,
0.024137791246175766,
-0.013117946684360504,
-0.2950696647167206,
0.4077513515949249,
-0.821897029876709,
0.5029525756835938,
-0.5301901698112488,
-0.018152587115764618,
-0.39806097745895386,
-0.2999379336833954,
0.9547885656356812,
-0.3960656523704529,
0.45081502199172974,
-0.5976651310920715,
-0.30467286705970764,
0.28184810280799866,
0.10064806789159775,
0.19966669380664825,
0.31450140476226807,
-0.2138550877571106,
-0.21045471727848053,
0.18267963826656342,
0.29805856943130493,
-0.3322559595108032,
-0.13851192593574524,
0.38797837495803833,
-0.32474642992019653,
-0.18179278075695038,
-0.79720538854599,
0.7407340407371521,
-0.5787866711616516,
-0.6155146956443787,
-0.044457774609327316,
-0.8060328364372253,
-0.16218778491020203,
0.16825370490550995,
-0.017672942951321602,
0.4204123020172119,
0.10854379832744598,
0.3369758427143097,
0.073874332010746,
0.21490253508090973,
0.445573091506958,
0.40681859850883484,
-0.16787292063236237,
-0.4729939103126526,
0.6642735600471497,
0.03126717358827591,
0.5878376960754395,
0.5151116847991943,
0.10146112740039825,
-0.16879595816135406,
-0.7231974005699158,
-0.3357591927051544,
0.536756157875061,
-0.32588648796081543,
-0.15621820092201233,
-0.6408041715621948,
-0.2521226108074188,
-0.38308319449424744,
-0.43540096282958984,
-0.6381261944770813,
0.0227577555924654,
-0.27672863006591797,
0.20898962020874023,
-0.3730570375919342,
0.19145861268043518,
-0.15110726654529572,
0.6929357647895813,
-1.2690637111663818,
0.3998151123523712,
0.2931438982486725,
0.006113287061452866,
-0.11175587028265,
-0.273756206035614,
-0.12282359600067139,
0.2200676053762436,
-0.48155727982521057,
-0.9521625638008118,
0.5078173279762268,
0.15713557600975037,
0.8386111855506897,
0.7430824637413025,
-0.346998929977417,
1.126695990562439,
-0.4524920880794525,
0.5073033571243286,
0.5831969380378723,
-0.9620662331581116,
0.5345335602760315,
-0.29087820649147034,
0.2731033265590668,
0.35151058435440063,
0.28557634353637695,
-0.45892539620399475,
-0.5769598484039307,
-0.25463685393333435,
-0.9404730796813965,
0.7469980716705322,
0.21336866915225983,
0.11741484701633453,
0.3362078368663788,
0.24696403741836548,
-0.04126551002264023,
0.42970162630081177,
-0.6472986936569214,
-0.39635640382766724,
0.3204418122768402,
-0.11031334102153778,
-0.26970595121383667,
-0.1973060965538025,
-0.40670326352119446,
-0.10450788587331772,
0.5727787613868713,
-0.12265202403068542,
-0.015242600813508034,
-0.6047230362892151,
-0.10011022537946701,
-0.042425256222486496,
0.32550880312919617,
0.575894296169281,
0.6331177949905396,
-0.14363619685173035,
-0.021211780607700348,
-0.013350358232855797,
0.06510575860738754,
0.36034083366394043,
0.14422041177749634,
-0.020820219069719315,
-0.08112285286188126,
0.15728580951690674,
0.6083312034606934,
0.4995720684528351,
-0.5209238529205322,
0.04023875296115875,
0.12718890607357025,
-0.37690865993499756,
0.4722287058830261,
0.3499167561531067,
0.12397585809230804,
0.529909074306488,
0.5194875597953796,
0.3094671070575714,
0.1348869353532791,
-0.5956404209136963,
-0.029097964987158775,
0.7951611280441284,
0.18551701307296753,
0.038694340735673904,
0.5520188808441162,
0.2688041925430298,
-0.32414475083351135,
0.4445786476135254,
-0.09325144439935684,
-0.5307442545890808,
0.4931163787841797,
0.23963545262813568,
0.947777271270752,
-0.47277867794036865,
-0.01102038286626339,
0.40764403343200684,
0.544170081615448,
-0.23761086165905,
-0.22583751380443573,
-0.07086557894945145,
-0.81504225730896,
-0.6653410196304321,
-0.5710911154747009,
-0.3901101350784302,
0.0063139405101537704,
-0.405438631772995,
0.5597954988479614,
0.031538259238004684,
-0.4080204963684082,
0.024241477251052856,
-0.10902368277311325,
-0.32309451699256897,
0.03378558158874512,
0.08732350915670395,
0.4266141951084137,
-0.6649280786514282,
0.516093373298645,
0.5229282975196838,
-0.3198930621147156,
-0.5184159874916077,
-0.028193695470690727,
0.3512190282344818,
-0.7491241693496704,
0.32811325788497925,
0.3375960886478424,
-0.3186416029930115,
0.07442415505647659,
-0.16924141347408295,
-1.0595206022262573,
1.1030138731002808,
0.6866810321807861,
-0.7279479503631592,
-0.475085973739624,
-0.16647271811962128,
-0.04005945846438408,
-0.7119724154472351,
-0.08395837247371674,
0.5653225183486938,
0.5965130925178528,
0.2936479449272156,
-1.1203038692474365,
-0.28775331377983093,
-0.12233242392539978,
0.041812680661678314,
0.7102709412574768,
-0.4563276767730713,
1.0189582109451294,
-0.37295883893966675,
-0.4848881661891937,
0.03716703876852989,
0.2710774838924408,
0.4557519257068634,
-0.021450551226735115,
0.6585830450057983,
0.6249024868011475,
0.7398702502250671,
-0.21530668437480927,
0.7261409163475037,
-0.6932212114334106,
0.5654197931289673,
0.6959676742553711,
-0.02575039304792881,
0.5512358546257019,
0.6344979405403137,
-0.06939634680747986,
0.041088514029979706,
0.5339486598968506,
-0.13436833024024963,
0.5524884462356567,
-0.1557517796754837,
-0.10189864784479141,
-0.34362533688545227,
0.048725247383117676,
-0.5402755737304688,
0.43366262316703796,
0.07011229544878006,
-0.2092016488313675,
-0.43903884291648865,
0.1360815465450287,
-0.04751264303922653,
-0.14046593010425568,
-0.07022978365421295,
0.4881865084171295,
-0.14755477011203766,
-0.8348334431648254,
0.23588736355304718,
0.16439937055110931,
1.2906566858291626,
-0.876758337020874,
0.19353896379470825,
-0.024481618776917458,
0.07286371290683746,
0.014121641404926777,
-0.42644938826560974,
0.3323892056941986,
-0.3435927629470825,
-0.32739996910095215,
-0.4544852375984192,
0.33698469400405884,
-0.891068160533905,
-0.5973362326622009,
0.5758657455444336,
0.6940466165542603,
-0.00548892468214035,
-0.038936663419008255,
-0.8215430974960327,
0.1480187475681305,
0.15443533658981323,
0.12557491660118103,
0.25504782795906067,
0.16690389811992645,
0.33309289813041687,
1.0103200674057007,
0.9072429537773132,
0.22095231711864471,
0.2764449119567871,
-0.09109094738960266,
0.618736743927002,
-0.4288264214992523,
-0.4589881896972656,
-1.148139238357544,
0.6882902383804321,
0.038360483944416046,
-0.22529572248458862,
0.5086447596549988,
0.7076147198677063,
0.6923752427101135,
-0.02623143419623375,
0.711208164691925,
0.1880616992712021,
0.10732423514127731,
-0.7618010640144348,
0.5001346468925476,
-1.3415967226028442,
0.20062598586082458,
-0.11200466006994247,
-1.3661119937896729,
-0.13068634271621704,
0.2853187024593353,
-0.012186111882328987,
0.27536487579345703,
0.6627600789070129,
1.0861510038375854,
-0.3108122944831848,
-0.6011075973510742,
0.6099333763122559,
-0.17493002116680145,
0.5959372520446777,
0.8355162143707275,
0.6416366696357727,
-0.14694498479366302,
0.9496700167655945,
-0.314980149269104,
-0.18707773089408875,
-0.4907603859901428,
-0.9820805788040161,
-0.5898985266685486,
-0.696275532245636,
-0.4625541567802429,
-0.013482492417097092,
0.1765364706516266,
0.8442920446395874,
1.22038996219635,
-0.37225043773651123,
-0.32290342450141907,
0.30490002036094666,
0.06936338543891907,
-0.2552887499332428,
-0.19619303941726685,
-0.05636133626103401,
-0.41292741894721985,
-1.502362847328186,
0.5647358298301697,
0.8080254197120667,
0.17358864843845367,
-0.4992705285549164,
-0.07642441242933273,
-0.2946120500564575,
0.29018574953079224,
0.5519027709960938,
0.00958292093127966,
-1.0539650917053223,
0.26201802492141724,
-0.13631482422351837,
-0.3025127053260803,
0.05855892598628998,
0.8073613047599792,
-0.14045597612857819,
0.7470451593399048,
0.3284284472465515,
0.8057200312614441,
0.3582754135131836,
0.17681021988391876,
0.841313898563385,
-0.8101993799209595,
0.055959589779376984,
-0.05574683099985123,
0.4303070306777954,
0.28811541199684143,
-0.1297989934682846,
0.5453307032585144,
-0.0916515439748764,
-0.2333042323589325,
-1.0670897960662842,
0.23656627535820007,
-1.2610321044921875,
-0.27399685978889465,
1.125262975692749,
0.38595420122146606,
0.18126200139522552,
0.2518073320388794,
-0.3345244228839874,
0.4165942370891571,
-0.4845617711544037,
0.824489176273346,
1.0717558860778809,
-0.28749629855155945,
-0.287274569272995,
-0.5980547070503235,
0.022182488813996315,
0.2255653738975525,
-0.9226555824279785,
-0.08978978544473648,
0.48964059352874756,
-0.11893201619386673,
0.5650370717048645,
0.08667530864477158,
-0.11788086593151093,
0.2348596751689911,
-0.29994386434555054,
0.17444029450416565,
-0.4659785032272339,
-0.38677993416786194,
-0.26639729738235474,
0.39962905645370483,
-0.3047340512275696,
-0.4654708802700043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00486v1 | Towards Massive Multilingual Holistic Bias | 2024-06-29T16:26:27 | 2024-06-29T16:26:27 | Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Prangthip Hansanti, Carleigh Wood, Bokai Yu, Christophe Ropers, Marta R. Costa-jussà | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | In the current landscape of automatic language generation, there is a need to
understand, evaluate, and mitigate demographic biases as existing models are
becoming increasingly multilingual. To address this, we present the initial
eight languages from the MASSIVE MULTILINGUAL HOLISTICBIAS (MMHB) dataset and
benchmark consisting of approximately 6 million sentences representing 13
demographic axes. We propose an automatic construction methodology to further
scale up MMHB sentences in terms of both language coverage and size, leveraging
limited human annotation. Our approach utilizes placeholders in multilingual
sentence construction and employs a systematic method to independently
translate sentence patterns, nouns, and descriptors. Combined with human
translation, this technique carefully designs placeholders to dynamically
generate multiple sentence variations and significantly reduces the human
translation workload. The translation process has been meticulously conducted
to avoid an English-centric perspective and include all necessary morphological
variations for languages that require them, improving from the original English
HOLISTICBIAS. Finally, we utilize MMHB to report results on gender bias and
added toxicity in machine translation tasks. On the gender analysis, MMHB
unveils: (1) a lack of gender robustness showing almost +4 chrf points in
average for masculine semantic sentences compared to feminine ones and (2) a
preference to overgeneralize to masculine forms by reporting more than +12 chrf
points in average when evaluating with masculine compared to feminine
references. MMHB triggers added toxicity up to 2.3%. | [
-0.6029337048530579,
-0.7575467228889465,
0.20174644887447357,
0.4112924039363861,
0.13088081777095795,
0.09973832219839096,
-0.18978257477283478,
-0.4724750518798828,
0.04282187670469284,
0.563916802406311,
-0.5925431847572327,
-0.4767264127731323,
-0.5520970821380615,
0.43148452043533325,
0.22014637291431427,
1.101859450340271,
0.010054325684905052,
0.13292454183101654,
0.0020599004346877337,
-0.4547651410102844,
-0.5895859599113464,
-0.6752408146858215,
0.03605097159743309,
-0.26823779940605164,
0.5810884833335876,
0.40436261892318726,
1.1271708011627197,
0.7351155281066895,
0.46190768480300903,
0.24661442637443542,
0.042563438415527344,
0.3039305508136749,
-0.07609507441520691,
0.2665978968143463,
-0.13891924917697906,
-0.1822088211774826,
-0.7320913076400757,
0.10560701787471771,
0.3666728734970093,
0.8966156840324402,
-0.19211776554584503,
0.5128273367881775,
-0.10617873072624207,
0.7384243607521057,
-0.6821684241294861,
0.21198798716068268,
-0.6106236577033997,
0.12641407549381256,
-0.4213601350784302,
-0.1712452918291092,
-0.49950143694877625,
-0.1486547738313675,
0.12751354277133942,
-0.4432259202003479,
0.03412647172808647,
0.19812020659446716,
0.3915495276451111,
0.21437005698680878,
-0.8556139469146729,
-0.32062387466430664,
-0.37183862924575806,
0.914406418800354,
-0.6594405174255371,
0.22789812088012695,
0.4745006859302521,
0.1966826468706131,
-0.11289942264556885,
0.18899373710155487,
-0.2840304374694824,
-0.343605101108551,
-0.015880512073636055,
0.06905636936426163,
-0.12708160281181335,
-0.18796028196811676,
0.3294667899608612,
0.011926368810236454,
-0.7157295346260071,
-0.07321976125240326,
-0.34359124302864075,
-0.45963814854621887,
0.7902913689613342,
0.09499606490135193,
0.6723424196243286,
-0.608619749546051,
0.07198373228311539,
-0.07380811870098114,
-0.7322898507118225,
-0.5191473364830017,
0.9712570309638977,
0.43464747071266174,
-0.04768792539834976,
0.8257067203521729,
-0.00859135203063488,
0.4698362648487091,
0.17218740284442902,
-0.062122561037540436,
0.5983869433403015,
-0.35658296942710876,
0.126260444521904,
0.331096887588501,
0.8238755464553833,
0.5734900832176208,
0.47367772459983826,
0.10831962525844574,
0.23877353966236115,
0.29599830508232117,
0.47458869218826294,
-0.7962421774864197,
0.1002366840839386,
0.3198975920677185,
-0.4366440773010254,
-0.2839667797088623,
-0.22132086753845215,
-0.9795079231262207,
-0.28178995847702026,
-0.2708624005317688,
-0.20497989654541016,
-0.3892192840576172,
-0.22216226160526276,
0.08538620918989182,
-0.09612534195184708,
-0.06963054090738297,
-0.07121700048446655,
-0.7656596302986145,
-0.34493404626846313,
0.1338462382555008,
0.5858712196350098,
0.0239133071154356,
-0.37381991744041443,
-0.36683955788612366,
0.2841864228248596,
-0.4861304461956024,
0.5616152882575989,
-0.5779487490653992,
-0.4482705593109131,
0.11655290424823761,
-0.18390122056007385,
0.2738058567047119,
-0.6604379415512085,
0.481418251991272,
-0.27230504155158997,
0.5140079259872437,
-0.3598663806915283,
0.1389039158821106,
0.024187138304114342,
0.2221813052892685,
-0.5631556510925293,
1.0029469728469849,
0.07113684713840485,
-0.9654111266136169,
0.6979511380195618,
-0.635158896446228,
-0.5257176160812378,
-0.10897830873727798,
0.02477310784161091,
-0.2817366123199463,
-0.08556822687387466,
0.3041011393070221,
0.29590240120887756,
-0.19095811247825623,
0.7329813838005066,
-0.5891669392585754,
0.1968909502029419,
-0.06667491048574448,
-0.4174754321575165,
0.900717556476593,
0.4169759154319763,
-0.5415931940078735,
0.1550711989402771,
-0.5987589359283447,
-0.2288963794708252,
-0.14004823565483093,
-0.3717096745967865,
-0.5419593453407288,
-0.05902088060975075,
0.26399892568588257,
0.660386323928833,
0.010019656270742416,
-0.45368605852127075,
0.039153870195150375,
-0.4410575032234192,
0.3706890940666199,
0.6412023305892944,
-0.17019976675510406,
0.6319207549095154,
-0.16870376467704773,
0.4152676463127136,
0.28215742111206055,
0.13974033296108246,
-0.27990275621414185,
-0.47096604108810425,
-0.46992191672325134,
-0.03042302280664444,
-0.07733205705881119,
0.49683940410614014,
-0.9507649540901184,
0.9240776300430298,
-0.28244057297706604,
-0.4261381924152374,
-0.6613202095031738,
0.44297996163368225,
0.5174278020858765,
0.2301981896162033,
0.43965426087379456,
-0.32103976607322693,
-0.5932645201683044,
-1.306489109992981,
-0.38408464193344116,
-0.40480613708496094,
-0.00678316131234169,
0.06483761966228485,
0.7187455296516418,
-0.6750654578208923,
0.7724918127059937,
-0.44747382402420044,
-0.466255247592926,
0.0028007016517221928,
0.3595648407936096,
-0.08433233946561813,
0.37680092453956604,
0.57012540102005,
-0.6585965156555176,
-0.43608126044273376,
0.10238686203956604,
-0.9621940851211548,
-0.4204411506652832,
-0.14017559587955475,
-0.597257673740387,
0.19454997777938843,
0.2716726064682007,
-0.6323475241661072,
0.10444257408380508,
0.5434660911560059,
-0.5154508352279663,
0.6751598715782166,
-0.27822479605674744,
0.04577399045228958,
-1.1535414457321167,
0.059211041778326035,
0.44443824887275696,
-0.09031888097524643,
-0.3687853515148163,
0.32603415846824646,
-0.0117661627009511,
0.158755823969841,
-0.48524191975593567,
0.5166361331939697,
-0.7609368562698364,
0.20550431311130524,
-0.03356068208813667,
0.020971978083252907,
-0.05979732424020767,
0.4262593686580658,
-0.28142407536506653,
0.7084535956382751,
0.05354241281747818,
-0.43607646226882935,
0.2878258526325226,
0.4481724798679352,
0.01302629429847002,
0.8064394593238831,
-0.2977938652038574,
-0.08951564133167267,
-0.5399715304374695,
0.5404857397079468,
-0.6539239287376404,
-0.5308588147163391,
0.2480858564376831,
-0.4241001307964325,
0.04916778951883316,
0.2751024067401886,
-0.5986368060112,
-0.6782394051551819,
-0.4225665330886841,
0.4113827049732208,
0.28321781754493713,
-0.1522287279367447,
0.48874279856681824,
0.726911723613739,
-0.2771027684211731,
-0.5888269543647766,
-0.8123892545700073,
0.3693394064903259,
-0.42886272072792053,
-0.5188796520233154,
0.09797687083482742,
-0.1917010396718979,
-0.6250629425048828,
-0.3148164451122284,
0.15973030030727386,
0.025632735341787338,
-0.059021949768066406,
0.08350677788257599,
0.30419981479644775,
-0.045196034014225006,
0.05041423439979553,
0.38515377044677734,
0.008087487891316414,
0.18675653636455536,
-0.24953709542751312,
0.5271103382110596,
-0.07770023494958878,
-0.19761915504932404,
-0.021565772593021393,
0.5844857692718506,
0.8623296618461609,
-0.2977190911769867,
0.5648337602615356,
0.7917181253433228,
-0.25641870498657227,
0.07957493513822556,
-0.6277236938476562,
-0.07468482851982117,
-0.36327603459358215,
0.4630662500858307,
-0.22886674106121063,
-0.7436718344688416,
0.40087297558784485,
0.3047507405281067,
0.4914742708206177,
0.7721267938613892,
1.0974020957946777,
0.1702258288860321,
1.344364047050476,
0.1336708515882492,
-0.12091265618801117,
0.15187670290470123,
0.24332687258720398,
-0.14182469248771667,
-0.7281317114830017,
0.0004941315273754299,
-0.4503285586833954,
-0.2641766369342804,
-0.8820352554321289,
-0.6224649548530579,
0.45985445380210876,
-0.40203365683555603,
-0.4409239590167999,
0.37916043400764465,
-0.5824480652809143,
0.13153597712516785,
0.4089083969593048,
0.019762108102440834,
0.23663388192653656,
0.000775319233071059,
-0.28493914008140564,
-0.49326711893081665,
-0.5103880763053894,
-0.7039660215377808,
1.2119030952453613,
0.328174889087677,
0.5154865980148315,
0.2810314893722534,
0.21669577062129974,
0.5257705450057983,
0.6718108654022217,
-0.417815238237381,
0.32883986830711365,
-0.0989566296339035,
-1.338484287261963,
-0.19648124277591705,
-0.5655384063720703,
-0.9157142639160156,
0.6580610871315002,
-0.13867652416229248,
-0.3494251072406769,
0.05743805691599846,
0.14178544282913208,
-0.2299664318561554,
0.027441810816526413,
-0.6789044737815857,
0.5739467740058899,
-0.3629251718521118,
-0.5412917137145996,
-0.16926009953022003,
-0.9676926136016846,
0.5808218121528625,
-0.29338884353637695,
0.7472630143165588,
-0.39813169836997986,
0.10577911138534546,
0.5660446286201477,
-0.277135968208313,
1.0238621234893799,
-0.2762733995914459,
-0.5382078886032104,
0.10963764786720276,
0.12663528323173523,
0.02339027263224125,
-0.0235788244754076,
-0.22120296955108643,
0.2890736758708954,
-0.14787013828754425,
-0.5606476068496704,
0.006300014443695545,
0.4104321002960205,
-0.7577030658721924,
-0.4311710000038147,
-0.37081247568130493,
-0.959079384803772,
-0.3775995671749115,
0.2658270001411438,
0.19383840262889862,
0.33332374691963196,
-0.34717440605163574,
0.13405439257621765,
0.43389397859573364,
-0.6348108053207397,
0.3081066906452179,
0.1578652262687683,
-0.2815344035625458,
-0.5403326153755188,
0.6186874508857727,
0.11178062111139297,
0.26504114270210266,
0.2133753001689911,
0.33720663189888,
-0.3035114109516144,
0.060761913657188416,
-0.9864357113838196,
0.24933363497257233,
-0.421810120344162,
-0.09510099142789841,
-0.903795063495636,
0.2431488037109375,
-0.6152960062026978,
-0.1402968168258667,
-0.15567177534103394,
0.06639577448368073,
0.05299694091081619,
-0.03467757627367973,
-0.02396881952881813,
0.34244832396507263,
0.06634841859340668,
0.39177992939949036,
-0.8560866117477417,
0.41502073407173157,
-0.03482424095273018,
-0.11736679077148438,
-0.06679022312164307,
-0.37247446179389954,
-0.03821169584989548,
0.24160195887088776,
-0.5233532190322876,
-0.9584413766860962,
0.6466281414031982,
0.1929728090763092,
0.4527425765991211,
0.45680293440818787,
0.03748978301882744,
0.7800764441490173,
-0.7380872964859009,
0.6754353642463684,
0.3812769949436188,
-0.8531906008720398,
0.5207577347755432,
-0.8862342834472656,
0.6374511122703552,
0.6347706317901611,
0.4054902195930481,
-0.6842717528343201,
-0.7581216096878052,
-0.4917972981929779,
-0.970611572265625,
0.42191702127456665,
0.0822008028626442,
0.5622739791870117,
-0.2256527990102768,
0.15092314779758453,
0.4867355525493622,
0.5799296498298645,
-0.6666057705879211,
-0.2145889848470688,
0.0016018225578591228,
-0.44921237230300903,
-0.20375272631645203,
-0.263251394033432,
-0.1110067218542099,
-0.1897830367088318,
0.6314959526062012,
-0.4419839680194855,
-0.05279746279120445,
-0.01575251668691635,
-0.5565838813781738,
-0.2617311179637909,
0.5319854021072388,
0.35920047760009766,
0.5985732674598694,
-0.11882512271404266,
0.30716997385025024,
0.19251999258995056,
-0.5316533446311951,
0.4948884844779968,
-0.13578367233276367,
-0.3847860097885132,
0.16334116458892822,
0.5938214659690857,
0.6152472496032715,
0.16843940317630768,
-0.6577149629592896,
0.305462509393692,
0.3101823329925537,
-0.3086216151714325,
-0.08819713443517685,
-0.35274380445480347,
0.004320744425058365,
-0.08500513434410095,
0.22791573405265808,
0.10440248250961304,
0.22627246379852295,
-0.8078594207763672,
0.26795077323913574,
0.35665199160575867,
-0.45961323380470276,
-0.3696547746658325,
0.8925133347511292,
0.35147926211357117,
0.1848977953195572,
0.3644188344478607,
-0.20103304088115692,
-0.4507082998752594,
0.3105919361114502,
0.3259017765522003,
0.7836772203445435,
-0.5130448937416077,
0.5257407426834106,
0.46980276703834534,
0.5873021483421326,
-0.1551969051361084,
0.10689681768417358,
0.30533066391944885,
-0.8031195998191833,
-0.546263575553894,
-0.6768295168876648,
-0.09906382858753204,
-0.38981983065605164,
-0.7079207897186279,
0.12391794472932816,
-0.13213634490966797,
-0.4780581593513489,
0.07849282771348953,
-0.20155000686645508,
-0.4464794099330902,
0.059143804013729095,
0.2755163311958313,
0.5027205944061279,
-0.9789197444915771,
0.45781928300857544,
0.833368718624115,
-0.46538180112838745,
-0.30195364356040955,
-0.031875863671302795,
0.3585053086280823,
-0.6745519042015076,
0.6913686394691467,
0.2975921630859375,
0.09960728138685226,
-0.16711127758026123,
-0.2992977499961853,
-0.5032092332839966,
0.5921081900596619,
0.5969440937042236,
-0.4499548077583313,
-0.414615273475647,
0.21114057302474976,
0.6485414505004883,
-0.23873665928840637,
0.3203622102737427,
0.5453057885169983,
0.8505500555038452,
-0.12099301069974899,
-0.891914963722229,
0.0844578742980957,
-0.29616454243659973,
-0.044204626232385635,
0.14126147329807281,
-0.5610106587409973,
0.7691572904586792,
-0.15939177572727203,
-0.017320528626441956,
-0.4117068946361542,
0.4710388779640198,
0.34067443013191223,
0.05293525755405426,
0.5899519324302673,
0.3083798885345459,
0.6226146221160889,
0.06720627844333649,
1.0136348009109497,
-0.2724561393260956,
0.1612185835838318,
1.0243148803710938,
-0.5272266268730164,
0.5222061276435852,
0.5525866746902466,
-0.188704714179039,
0.4533262550830841,
0.6043957471847534,
0.1739458590745926,
0.1298135668039322,
0.3899320065975189,
0.04147682711482048,
-0.3326856195926666,
-0.4296172559261322,
-0.3479216694831848,
0.5171862244606018,
0.1505470722913742,
-0.33673277497291565,
-0.31236928701400757,
0.41283708810806274,
0.6066893339157104,
0.08563945442438126,
-0.0598134770989418,
0.5917797684669495,
0.21189998090267181,
-0.8176019191741943,
0.26656901836395264,
0.11987029761075974,
1.0105644464492798,
-0.48595917224884033,
0.22193306684494019,
-0.12206757813692093,
0.1339326947927475,
-0.27237698435783386,
-0.4771561026573181,
0.5574312210083008,
0.11354055255651474,
-0.24522697925567627,
-0.5314382314682007,
0.5117712020874023,
-0.6911290287971497,
-0.7915291786193848,
0.3731728792190552,
0.8980359435081482,
-0.05702320486307144,
-0.21460819244384766,
-0.6355495452880859,
-0.19594506919384003,
0.0006982185295782983,
-0.14544737339019775,
0.29895827174186707,
0.47946953773498535,
-0.5400165319442749,
0.5887417197227478,
0.8024622797966003,
0.34652507305145264,
0.1553349792957306,
0.18873654305934906,
0.5131329894065857,
-0.6117631196975708,
-0.4945527911186218,
-1.1545746326446533,
0.441162645816803,
-0.0799592062830925,
-0.34382006525993347,
1.0032410621643066,
0.5893092155456543,
0.7577441930770874,
-0.10438873618841171,
0.8475261330604553,
-0.12174002826213837,
0.0797131359577179,
-0.12916339933872223,
0.8305640816688538,
-0.5745789408683777,
-0.11396123468875885,
-0.5784397721290588,
-1.0195279121398926,
-0.47588497400283813,
0.46589896082878113,
-0.30398571491241455,
-0.007109540048986673,
0.662966787815094,
0.5675961375236511,
0.23284423351287842,
-0.27131202816963196,
0.2414640337228775,
0.1567009687423706,
0.31203797459602356,
0.395757794380188,
0.75162273645401,
-0.2953980565071106,
0.4116157293319702,
0.07917813956737518,
-0.32453736662864685,
-0.1887495219707489,
-0.8010136485099792,
-0.8286976218223572,
-0.33968424797058105,
-0.36748579144477844,
-0.4212396442890167,
-0.2072201371192932,
1.1618080139160156,
0.6632063388824463,
-0.7433357238769531,
-0.38534897565841675,
0.2941969037055969,
-0.09310020506381989,
-0.033359888941049576,
-0.19765186309814453,
0.002376883290708065,
-0.2597002685070038,
-0.7992100119590759,
-0.13199669122695923,
0.4666530191898346,
-0.33670714497566223,
-0.6912163496017456,
0.042934272438287735,
-0.2650268077850342,
-0.042060937732458115,
0.9630721211433411,
-0.29046833515167236,
-0.7827770113945007,
-0.2721391022205353,
0.0366811640560627,
-0.2596794664859772,
-0.00777249364182353,
0.7680193185806274,
-0.22369061410427094,
0.5687345862388611,
0.3590678572654724,
0.4257373511791229,
-0.05536739155650139,
-0.04261501133441925,
0.8045687675476074,
-0.8009777665138245,
0.3118497133255005,
0.16817791759967804,
0.31411978602409363,
0.4640427231788635,
-0.4335618019104004,
0.40413254499435425,
0.2861834764480591,
-0.23430845141410828,
-0.7640007138252258,
0.23098860681056976,
-0.6279795169830322,
-0.35813775658607483,
1.5190949440002441,
0.298296719789505,
-0.19952623546123505,
-0.43710172176361084,
-0.47797930240631104,
0.38000547885894775,
-0.45520657300949097,
0.9308901429176331,
1.0124421119689941,
0.29776686429977417,
0.2713552415370941,
-0.9955993294715881,
0.13046815991401672,
0.3899250030517578,
-1.086044192314148,
0.3510350286960602,
0.9993535876274109,
0.03012654557824135,
0.40776681900024414,
0.49967053532600403,
-0.3660292327404022,
0.00862137507647276,
0.02216922678053379,
0.5065417885780334,
0.2953644096851349,
-0.21958841383457184,
0.024268822744488716,
0.19544239342212677,
-0.13097399473190308,
0.2522052824497223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00476v1 | Large Language Models for Power Scheduling: A User-Centric Approach | 2024-06-29T15:47:28 | 2024-06-29T15:47:28 | Thomas Mongaillard, Samson Lasaulce, Othman Hicheur, Chao Zhang, Lina Bariah, Vineeth S. Varma, Hang Zou, Qiyang Zhao, Merouane Debbah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY | While traditional optimization and scheduling schemes are designed to meet
fixed, predefined system requirements, future systems are moving toward
user-driven approaches and personalized services, aiming to achieve high
quality-of-experience (QoE) and flexibility. This challenge is particularly
pronounced in wireless and digitalized energy networks, where users'
requirements have largely not been taken into consideration due to the lack of
a common language between users and machines. The emergence of powerful large
language models (LLMs) marks a radical departure from traditional
system-centric methods into more advanced user-centric approaches by providing
a natural communication interface between users and devices. In this paper, for
the first time, we introduce a novel architecture for resource scheduling
problems by constructing three LLM agents to convert an arbitrary user's voice
request (VRQ) into a resource allocation vector. Specifically, we design an LLM
intent recognition agent to translate the request into an optimization problem
(OP), an LLM OP parameter identification agent, and an LLM OP solving agent. To
evaluate system performance, we construct a database of typical VRQs in the
context of electric vehicle (EV) charging. As a proof of concept, we primarily
use Llama 3 8B. Through testing with different prompt engineering scenarios,
the obtained results demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed architecture.
The conducted performance analysis allows key insights to be extracted. For
instance, having a larger set of candidate OPs to model the real-world problem
might degrade the final performance because of a higher recognition/OP
classification noise level. All results and codes are open source. | [
-0.38648486137390137,
-0.15364737808704376,
0.6576891541481018,
0.2738187909126282,
-0.08860082924365997,
0.09027796238660812,
-0.345930278301239,
-0.5753554105758667,
0.08305224031209946,
0.723659873008728,
-0.7178984880447388,
-0.02989998273551464,
0.14368900656700134,
0.023596761748194695,
-0.10290353745222092,
0.37307441234588623,
-0.1355159878730774,
0.004657600540667772,
-0.14774295687675476,
-0.049197837710380554,
-0.3683289885520935,
-0.4492354989051819,
-0.3190251290798187,
-0.870530366897583,
0.32293474674224854,
0.40372467041015625,
0.657416045665741,
0.44614845514297485,
0.42596325278282166,
0.3189774751663208,
0.004157418385148048,
0.1807554066181183,
-0.1324281096458435,
0.18501269817352295,
-0.19203440845012665,
-0.18426167964935303,
-0.5535883903503418,
-0.08001869916915894,
0.6561245918273926,
0.5993021726608276,
-0.6710429191589355,
0.08335447311401367,
-0.2237686663866043,
0.4444705843925476,
-0.47016578912734985,
0.24624976515769958,
-0.8566398620605469,
0.11499675363302231,
-0.14458902180194855,
-0.4214686453342438,
-0.47414201498031616,
0.1270386427640915,
-0.18770402669906616,
-0.7434344291687012,
-0.11115358769893646,
0.23443233966827393,
0.7752527594566345,
0.2998316287994385,
-0.15999944508075714,
-0.07839029282331467,
-1.0822370052337646,
1.0398532152175903,
-0.5358099341392517,
0.29831549525260925,
0.04411394149065018,
0.4869197607040405,
-0.09169154614210129,
-0.6636666059494019,
-0.8395494818687439,
-0.3389795422554016,
-0.03572085499763489,
0.03535846248269081,
-0.16199174523353577,
0.3045828640460968,
0.4299241602420807,
0.18116092681884766,
-0.4011459946632385,
0.4863660931587219,
0.0009735950152389705,
-0.03109142929315567,
0.874759316444397,
0.4353545904159546,
0.09800432622432709,
-0.19971521198749542,
-0.5065194368362427,
0.41370755434036255,
-0.6555015444755554,
0.06943045556545258,
0.5763611793518066,
0.4866248071193695,
-0.0643673688173294,
0.5509098768234253,
-0.24025994539260864,
0.5797685980796814,
-0.15535451471805573,
-0.18907038867473602,
0.10474175214767456,
-0.1429903358221054,
-0.36903461813926697,
0.23660729825496674,
0.8538530468940735,
0.36097100377082825,
0.23675668239593506,
-0.2524658739566803,
-0.42268744111061096,
-0.5004362463951111,
0.27622538805007935,
-0.7851448059082031,
0.11926299333572388,
0.20377935469150543,
-0.5732060670852661,
-0.3449273407459259,
-0.4506925046443939,
-0.4464374780654907,
-0.45949119329452515,
-0.6158487200737,
0.2252562791109085,
-0.11784378439188004,
-0.3805779218673706,
0.3341718912124634,
0.3638424277305603,
0.3214211165904999,
0.0997702032327652,
-1.1426515579223633,
0.4286656081676483,
0.6862781047821045,
0.7167051434516907,
0.08953692764043808,
-0.18124224245548248,
-0.49838125705718994,
0.2506820559501648,
0.1807088553905487,
0.6820796132087708,
-0.4114365875720978,
-0.5230671167373657,
-0.12688779830932617,
-0.020246349275112152,
-0.055732954293489456,
-0.3211870789527893,
0.5064358711242676,
-0.9133338928222656,
0.07126043736934662,
-0.3085297644138336,
-0.26998981833457947,
0.015008008107542992,
-0.11385052651166916,
-0.6051589846611023,
0.6193054914474487,
-0.00016368429351132363,
-0.5464071035385132,
-0.06833670288324356,
-0.8527474403381348,
-0.2576950192451477,
0.3740430474281311,
-0.14374491572380066,
-0.31065303087234497,
-0.10410024225711823,
-0.28411561250686646,
0.4063825011253357,
-0.6641989946365356,
0.08302751928567886,
-0.14242656528949738,
-0.004029836039990187,
0.14219848811626434,
-0.054935988038778305,
0.63090580701828,
0.6272925138473511,
-0.06082392856478691,
0.27344802021980286,
-0.7191663384437561,
0.27018454670906067,
0.2610000967979431,
-0.09972724318504333,
-0.07604498416185379,
0.26020196080207825,
0.3380346894264221,
0.19530919194221497,
0.5657336115837097,
-0.73382967710495,
0.458528071641922,
-0.2877234220504761,
0.6955941915512085,
0.7173784971237183,
-0.3941830098628998,
0.3976689875125885,
-0.3405691683292389,
0.6919121742248535,
-0.5245718359947205,
0.28399378061294556,
0.04632103443145752,
-0.03156944736838341,
-0.24512386322021484,
-0.03735966235399246,
-0.19377951323986053,
0.6145637035369873,
-0.5015548467636108,
0.5221356153488159,
-0.14586783945560455,
-0.5003163814544678,
-0.17567996680736542,
0.31707441806793213,
-0.013600701466202736,
0.2963809370994568,
0.23113484680652618,
0.038522277027368546,
-0.4037168622016907,
-1.001550555229187,
-0.07398486137390137,
-0.1699981391429901,
-0.027102919295430183,
0.7066125273704529,
-0.024316873401403427,
-0.08012744039297104,
0.9472071528434753,
-0.4615263342857361,
-0.17549769580364227,
-0.7042897343635559,
-0.2451455444097519,
0.45462581515312195,
0.22624211013317108,
0.5424436330795288,
-0.7653418183326721,
-0.4178001880645752,
0.4029530882835388,
-0.4807192385196686,
-0.5541934967041016,
-0.15832574665546417,
0.03795382380485535,
-0.07992550730705261,
0.5058064460754395,
-0.5612741112709045,
-0.23228615522384644,
0.6964446306228638,
-0.121456578373909,
0.6391634345054626,
0.038075659424066544,
-0.2328711450099945,
-1.1202343702316284,
0.19088822603225708,
-0.0936276763677597,
-0.2885569930076599,
-0.4165431559085846,
-0.19755753874778748,
-0.3256438076496124,
-0.5589122176170349,
-0.45904985070228577,
0.35290905833244324,
-0.4324096441268921,
-0.3260703384876251,
-0.38549014925956726,
-0.38996148109436035,
0.07485371828079224,
0.4387226104736328,
-0.13178817927837372,
1.0366228818893433,
0.3722909092903137,
-0.586609959602356,
0.38864272832870483,
-0.011971387080848217,
-0.23176071047782898,
0.40208762884140015,
-0.7828187346458435,
0.3359515368938446,
-0.05280057713389397,
0.08810149878263474,
-0.617472767829895,
-0.24932405352592468,
-0.0997685045003891,
0.25273463129997253,
0.2838778495788574,
-0.0472651906311512,
-0.4344698488712311,
-0.20744232833385468,
0.027973532676696777,
0.6139451265335083,
0.5164074897766113,
-0.5454907417297363,
0.8666965961456299,
0.5031238794326782,
-0.07396658509969711,
-0.31129926443099976,
-0.10964968055486679,
0.08972702920436859,
-0.07780846953392029,
-0.6457244753837585,
0.9624221324920654,
0.11092992126941681,
-0.4413434565067291,
-0.024447564035654068,
0.098028264939785,
0.055931489914655685,
0.3336871266365051,
0.29661405086517334,
0.22233667969703674,
-0.057841427624225616,
0.13571681082248688,
-0.41134852170944214,
-0.2074282020330429,
0.05862180516123772,
-0.4823393225669861,
0.9281113147735596,
-0.09644657373428345,
-0.4429979920387268,
-0.8233579993247986,
0.605355978012085,
0.933133065700531,
-0.5381268858909607,
0.5260768532752991,
0.45174694061279297,
-0.22024162113666534,
-0.0756455734372139,
-0.5225644707679749,
0.1542283296585083,
-0.5487659573554993,
0.3338359594345093,
-0.42634373903274536,
-0.526151180267334,
0.4757055938243866,
-0.14119066298007965,
0.41625627875328064,
0.3116108179092407,
0.643436074256897,
-0.0012164755025878549,
1.0190038681030273,
0.8178648352622986,
-0.008127206936478615,
0.9262130260467529,
-0.17804935574531555,
0.4010278582572937,
-0.8649302124977112,
-0.3566952049732208,
-0.5145854949951172,
-0.2670232355594635,
-0.5923239588737488,
-0.0899311974644661,
0.47634607553482056,
-0.18680931627750397,
-0.3463512659072876,
0.3536567687988281,
-0.5540059208869934,
0.3929665982723236,
0.04714079573750496,
-0.21796825528144836,
0.24175235629081726,
0.18498477339744568,
0.2083103507757187,
0.0722852423787117,
-0.5355835556983948,
-0.6861656308174133,
0.6455550193786621,
0.28206053376197815,
0.7785027623176575,
0.18574784696102142,
0.38551411032676697,
0.39061564207077026,
0.16492807865142822,
-0.8957866430282593,
0.6629794836044312,
0.049642790108919144,
-0.24677708745002747,
-0.45619913935661316,
-0.5696031451225281,
-1.1020123958587646,
0.31917092204093933,
0.2227357178926468,
-1.0411392450332642,
0.04421321675181389,
-0.08975443989038467,
-0.546855628490448,
0.6173123717308044,
-0.7083756327629089,
0.5739869475364685,
-0.5069992542266846,
-0.5230340361595154,
-0.5139653086662292,
-0.06020275130867958,
0.11246193200349808,
0.29817503690719604,
0.15574729442596436,
-0.4333263635635376,
0.005449962802231312,
0.529748797416687,
-0.6647749543190002,
0.31792521476745605,
-0.31967413425445557,
-0.17509114742279053,
0.4080548584461212,
-0.28259435296058655,
0.5428286790847778,
-0.16946503520011902,
-0.5064067244529724,
0.043382756412029266,
-0.17346732318401337,
-0.44387707114219666,
-0.4191305637359619,
0.8131517767906189,
-0.6933078169822693,
-0.4799351394176483,
-0.178993359208107,
-0.5135239958763123,
-0.2350883185863495,
0.298675000667572,
0.21684733033180237,
0.4628918468952179,
-0.12453588843345642,
0.0003601795178838074,
0.30908429622650146,
-0.2361874282360077,
0.649748682975769,
0.5078282356262207,
-0.30915945768356323,
-0.10238808393478394,
0.7767547369003296,
0.17281895875930786,
0.20021888613700867,
0.3126474916934967,
0.08510845899581909,
-0.46874508261680603,
-0.5931282639503479,
-0.08691126853227615,
0.1835782676935196,
-0.2537735402584076,
-0.1741514652967453,
-0.8608658313751221,
-0.32794055342674255,
-0.1493106335401535,
-0.20500843226909637,
-0.529814600944519,
-0.1606682389974594,
-0.287465900182724,
0.13130804896354675,
0.24018804728984833,
0.5560059547424316,
0.12482639402151108,
0.5561438798904419,
-0.37435904145240784,
0.3414221704006195,
0.6080748438835144,
0.5607997179031372,
0.01759076490998268,
-0.1238948404788971,
-0.25743457674980164,
-0.41165080666542053,
-0.6650801301002502,
-0.6779067516326904,
0.5696173310279846,
-0.0027058678679168224,
0.6706361770629883,
0.14190582931041718,
0.024188952520489693,
0.10101160407066345,
-0.5721593499183655,
0.6008508801460266,
0.5805744528770447,
-0.7346909642219543,
0.25455784797668457,
-0.26006045937538147,
-0.10750991851091385,
0.417651504278183,
-0.015233723446726799,
-0.4844992160797119,
0.4066064953804016,
-0.46471232175827026,
-1.0682331323623657,
0.7785065174102783,
-0.029180077835917473,
0.18869125843048096,
0.24381312727928162,
0.15853609144687653,
-0.17104122042655945,
0.37166714668273926,
-0.38847750425338745,
-0.04736919701099396,
-0.16104133427143097,
0.10424038022756577,
0.04844769462943077,
-0.3933267593383789,
0.0051676491275429726,
-0.0322488471865654,
0.5677989721298218,
-0.22352343797683716,
0.24259941279888153,
0.1209222674369812,
0.24909335374832153,
-0.2521756589412689,
0.5617250800132751,
0.5591227412223816,
0.5754806995391846,
-0.30803531408309937,
-0.2578267455101013,
0.2118779569864273,
-0.24773366749286652,
0.2964714467525482,
0.20809736847877502,
-0.1272709220647812,
0.02198062837123871,
-0.14099951088428497,
0.7376799583435059,
0.12004537880420685,
-0.6823073625564575,
0.28000181913375854,
-0.11405859887599945,
-0.016484174877405167,
-0.6927342414855957,
0.07625981420278549,
0.036755140870809555,
0.21572211384773254,
0.5409926176071167,
-0.0496891513466835,
0.15862227976322174,
-0.41769737005233765,
-0.4082644283771515,
0.5068872570991516,
-0.2581426799297333,
-0.5456849336624146,
0.6503167152404785,
0.4895555377006531,
-0.6880486607551575,
0.15907590091228485,
-0.27496013045310974,
-0.5311272740364075,
0.5490972399711609,
0.39954036474227905,
0.9290004968643188,
-0.11094513535499573,
0.007546680513769388,
0.1234251856803894,
0.16477540135383606,
0.22581902146339417,
0.5364426970481873,
-0.02781747840344906,
-0.6384920477867126,
-0.6779200434684753,
-0.735550582408905,
-0.5081662535667419,
0.5123344659805298,
-0.5910305976867676,
0.3019006848335266,
-0.5310723185539246,
-0.36177289485931396,
0.18515697121620178,
0.3965187668800354,
-0.9590405225753784,
-0.3560560643672943,
0.31358182430267334,
0.8235965967178345,
-0.5102525353431702,
0.5951724648475647,
0.9512416124343872,
0.17268985509872437,
-0.9278697967529297,
-0.1713050901889801,
-0.3666154444217682,
-0.6750431060791016,
0.54731285572052,
-0.041596997529268265,
-0.13507330417633057,
0.16143882274627686,
-0.40975624322891235,
-0.7809233665466309,
1.3144662380218506,
0.6022387742996216,
-0.8527970910072327,
-0.12902870774269104,
-0.2989761233329773,
0.13044483959674835,
-0.24123404920101166,
0.3329346477985382,
0.21324513852596283,
0.5905821323394775,
-0.05261462181806564,
-1.2736798524856567,
0.0046533457934856415,
-0.057098932564258575,
0.08830603957176208,
0.2109793722629547,
-1.0667117834091187,
0.743605375289917,
-0.32828739285469055,
-0.23995335400104523,
0.14928606152534485,
0.6185066103935242,
0.12347641587257385,
0.4391491711139679,
0.7893515825271606,
0.08241480588912964,
0.8627837896347046,
0.3632112145423889,
1.1671613454818726,
-0.5528320670127869,
0.4901050329208374,
0.601468563079834,
-1.040968894958496,
0.3613128960132599,
0.6129395961761475,
-0.33106178045272827,
0.383125901222229,
0.091121606528759,
0.2268577367067337,
0.6037152409553528,
0.3626297116279602,
-0.610806941986084,
-0.7724884748458862,
-0.8142419457435608,
-0.44586145877838135,
0.5495113730430603,
0.24254213273525238,
-0.238154336810112,
-0.4361812174320221,
0.009455805644392967,
-0.18716181814670563,
0.14169178903102875,
-0.4552651345729828,
0.6146925687789917,
0.2137761116027832,
-0.3288731873035431,
0.412384569644928,
0.1516600102186203,
0.4963623285293579,
-0.5299981236457825,
0.16953666508197784,
0.3022221028804779,
0.07634082436561584,
-0.48768171668052673,
-0.5014327764511108,
0.03538748621940613,
-0.02634739875793457,
-0.4186401963233948,
-0.6799514889717102,
0.5447301864624023,
0.04706749692559242,
-0.28014683723449707,
0.10176942497491837,
0.3257085680961609,
0.07315054535865784,
0.13639585673809052,
-0.4954798221588135,
0.16424059867858887,
-0.032034583389759064,
-0.3142571747303009,
0.4537370800971985,
0.3110363483428955,
0.1270870715379715,
0.7121750116348267,
0.5552758574485779,
0.2991206645965576,
-0.37362778186798096,
0.30453020334243774,
0.959203839302063,
-0.42149466276168823,
-0.5313462615013123,
-0.7526841163635254,
0.1295139044523239,
-0.19507811963558197,
-0.07285582274198532,
0.31629011034965515,
0.48507094383239746,
0.3432500958442688,
0.2841973900794983,
0.9854892492294312,
0.06687236577272415,
0.30269092321395874,
-0.6455013751983643,
0.4453796148300171,
-0.5518561005592346,
0.5380279421806335,
0.022557172924280167,
-0.7725362181663513,
0.24974112212657928,
0.3207676112651825,
-0.5418158173561096,
-0.09677914530038834,
0.312507301568985,
0.49911490082740784,
-0.19536511600017548,
0.0009740208042785525,
0.424919456243515,
0.003055879147723317,
0.8782019019126892,
0.6084669232368469,
1.0080896615982056,
0.1709563136100769,
0.4739200472831726,
-0.31359371542930603,
-0.06766047328710556,
-0.5653440356254578,
-0.7996993064880371,
-0.4030575454235077,
-0.5139063000679016,
-0.22393257915973663,
-0.17779359221458435,
-0.14359615743160248,
1.509871482849121,
0.6976550817489624,
-0.44535377621650696,
-0.3010806441307068,
-0.13805201649665833,
0.14702726900577545,
-0.1601789891719818,
-0.23065593838691711,
-0.009520376101136208,
-0.43103116750717163,
-0.6044006943702698,
0.44917768239974976,
0.19639775156974792,
-0.13064289093017578,
-0.39232364296913147,
-0.12195023894309998,
0.367713063955307,
-0.021187739446759224,
0.7094425559043884,
0.5208469033241272,
-0.547375500202179,
-0.20419171452522278,
0.1375865340232849,
-0.3501286506652832,
-0.07305444031953812,
1.1642080545425415,
-0.6145535707473755,
0.2091115266084671,
0.4119001626968384,
0.4925648272037506,
0.3278064727783203,
0.04228682070970535,
0.5868513584136963,
-0.4587783217430115,
0.18566128611564636,
0.4926396310329437,
0.6169764399528503,
0.38756030797958374,
-0.495968759059906,
-0.006064826622605324,
0.1272905468940735,
-0.8257522583007812,
-0.9676322937011719,
0.6710333824157715,
-1.2970956563949585,
0.05540609359741211,
1.228624939918518,
0.19004057347774506,
-0.12425865232944489,
-0.24139200150966644,
-0.4261237680912018,
-0.13334767520427704,
-0.5195497870445251,
0.7339739799499512,
0.39085468649864197,
-0.3050026297569275,
0.01883566379547119,
-0.7431626915931702,
0.23896875977516174,
0.38071903586387634,
-0.46245160698890686,
0.4026505649089813,
0.26640400290489197,
0.03968049958348274,
0.24076604843139648,
0.8220545649528503,
0.20859059691429138,
0.13352768123149872,
-0.4879816472530365,
0.3398679196834564,
-0.38711515069007874,
-0.07734024524688721,
-0.11543919146060944,
0.32673463225364685,
0.27581170201301575,
-0.4058970808982849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00475v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00475v1 | Classifier identification in Ancient Egyptian as a low-resource sequence-labelling task | 2024-06-29T15:40:25 | 2024-06-29T15:40:25 | Dmitry Nikolaev, Jorke Grotenhuis, Haleli Harel, Orly Goldwasser | cs.CL | cs.CL | The complex Ancient Egyptian (AE) writing system was characterised by
widespread use of graphemic classifiers (determinatives): silent (unpronounced)
hieroglyphic signs clarifying the meaning or indicating the pronunciation of
the host word. The study of classifiers has intensified in recent years with
the launch and quick growth of the iClassifier project, a web-based platform
for annotation and analysis of classifiers in ancient and modern languages.
Thanks to the data contributed by the project participants, it is now possible
to formulate the identification of classifiers in AE texts as an NLP task. In
this paper, we make first steps towards solving this task by implementing a
series of sequence-labelling neural models, which achieve promising performance
despite the modest amount of training data. We discuss tokenisation and
operationalisation issues arising from tackling AE texts and contrast our
approach with frequency-based baselines. | [
-0.4601888060569763,
-0.35178685188293457,
0.1795332133769989,
-0.30684369802474976,
-0.1602146178483963,
0.19668816030025482,
-0.17950448393821716,
-1.019242525100708,
0.13259579241275787,
0.21302884817123413,
-0.03021485172212124,
-0.5426657795906067,
-0.795131266117096,
0.13523443043231964,
-0.45045071840286255,
1.305883765220642,
-0.2581022381782532,
0.02716679312288761,
0.3141617774963379,
-0.44567012786865234,
-0.2496885061264038,
-0.6999077796936035,
-0.8215778470039368,
-0.3969973921775818,
0.5866243243217468,
0.520514190196991,
0.6187840700149536,
0.8345919251441956,
0.5807598233222961,
0.31149229407310486,
-0.22540885210037231,
-0.03287616744637489,
-0.06267930567264557,
0.01586802862584591,
0.24926863610744476,
-0.41678380966186523,
-0.22861719131469727,
-0.006240557879209518,
0.40787509083747864,
1.0400577783584595,
0.09391281008720398,
0.47078096866607666,
0.2166646420955658,
0.5273523926734924,
-0.7751860618591309,
0.4340125024318695,
-0.0954093188047409,
0.2562444806098938,
-0.4117368161678314,
-0.1100478321313858,
-0.4858204424381256,
-0.40377241373062134,
0.2419837862253189,
-0.4930553734302521,
0.16803957521915436,
0.2504006326198578,
0.9489896297454834,
0.0629708394408226,
-0.0288751982152462,
-0.9614751935005188,
-0.9359560608863831,
0.5598537921905518,
-0.6669899821281433,
-0.1178666204214096,
0.3646240234375,
0.030016977339982986,
0.14600512385368347,
-0.8636811375617981,
-0.2584855854511261,
-0.1344359815120697,
-0.13665689527988434,
-0.1141727864742279,
0.09445744752883911,
0.2239697426557541,
0.3689938485622406,
0.4976002275943756,
-0.17828918993473053,
0.40694910287857056,
-0.4693658947944641,
-0.3986591100692749,
0.2962239384651184,
-0.06165139749646187,
0.5634249448776245,
-0.10713572055101395,
-0.25466302037239075,
0.24891416728496552,
-0.5948697328567505,
0.0234918761998415,
0.5965086221694946,
0.2811484932899475,
-0.12389793246984482,
0.7363845705986023,
-0.04676658287644386,
0.5069586634635925,
-0.007477392442524433,
-0.2456647753715515,
0.02710268832743168,
0.0481841154396534,
0.0189279206097126,
0.8598364591598511,
0.45711639523506165,
-0.02869887463748455,
0.4228889048099518,
-0.12507867813110352,
-0.6796317100524902,
0.38754400610923767,
-0.04473106563091278,
-0.8768154978752136,
-0.355012983083725,
-0.18018661439418793,
-0.8216861486434937,
-0.2879761755466461,
-0.10333158075809479,
-0.49393606185913086,
-0.2817445695400238,
-0.09024295210838318,
0.708916962146759,
-0.38595691323280334,
0.08994464576244354,
0.06233459338545799,
0.017580855637788773,
0.06517462432384491,
0.3360708951950073,
-1.2075798511505127,
0.42852839827537537,
0.4758290648460388,
1.0042928457260132,
0.19099894165992737,
0.06942187994718552,
-0.00985274650156498,
0.040059108287096024,
-0.2656669020652771,
0.4575311839580536,
-0.40718236565589905,
-0.37751176953315735,
-0.028035933151841164,
-0.3178306221961975,
0.17753741145133972,
-0.41310957074165344,
0.6218881011009216,
-0.5581744909286499,
0.2404649555683136,
0.0625593438744545,
-0.6893245577812195,
-0.30519747734069824,
-0.15014547109603882,
-0.7822595834732056,
1.003966212272644,
-0.025915348902344704,
-0.8591062426567078,
0.2608340084552765,
-0.7210084199905396,
-0.45066577196121216,
0.46724507212638855,
-0.23702219128608704,
-0.21992383897304535,
0.05463188514113426,
-0.08526676893234253,
0.3170679807662964,
-0.18458563089370728,
-0.17087820172309875,
0.16906987130641937,
-0.6515007615089417,
-0.047300685197114944,
-0.5696536898612976,
0.5667749643325806,
0.32707804441452026,
-0.6244120001792908,
-0.19639143347740173,
-0.9016672372817993,
-0.17640060186386108,
-0.14237509667873383,
-0.5572690367698669,
-0.6940879225730896,
0.12109793722629547,
0.29053938388824463,
-0.13814711570739746,
0.2914314568042755,
-0.45569780468940735,
0.5604432225227356,
-0.4279571771621704,
0.580152690410614,
0.5426473021507263,
-0.2574232220649719,
0.387029767036438,
-0.5036320090293884,
0.4460012912750244,
-0.013561316765844822,
-0.2241668552160263,
-0.37990108132362366,
-0.8360564708709717,
-0.8839764595031738,
-0.3449741005897522,
0.7644932866096497,
0.5721668004989624,
-0.4294522702693939,
0.2355901449918747,
-0.2163582146167755,
-0.43455857038497925,
-0.5195020437240601,
-0.1787542849779129,
0.42148709297180176,
0.6379627585411072,
0.19828177988529205,
-0.47342661023139954,
-0.513726532459259,
-0.7044150829315186,
0.21336692571640015,
-0.47155535221099854,
-0.13982810080051422,
0.20978787541389465,
0.6068596243858337,
-0.04473184421658516,
0.3936380445957184,
-0.13450410962104797,
-0.2229928821325302,
0.04004448652267456,
0.7321701645851135,
0.24416780471801758,
0.5833555459976196,
0.4083913266658783,
-0.5558583736419678,
-0.18199628591537476,
0.04423061013221741,
-0.5357494354248047,
-0.1032581776380539,
-0.25650784373283386,
0.18111902475357056,
0.1147272139787674,
0.7041497826576233,
-0.3271813988685608,
0.600893497467041,
0.2354985624551773,
-0.15239505469799042,
0.5495767593383789,
-0.0027195585425943136,
-0.05744968727231026,
-0.7844028472900391,
0.33469098806381226,
0.04163782671093941,
0.011655721813440323,
-0.5387304425239563,
-0.17855620384216309,
-0.05003497749567032,
-0.25967130064964294,
-0.42371565103530884,
0.7131152153015137,
-0.6818529963493347,
0.1406201422214508,
-0.2701304852962494,
-0.0976250022649765,
-0.4010530114173889,
0.3493363559246063,
0.1330760270357132,
0.782617449760437,
0.45463132858276367,
-0.696154773235321,
-0.007515330798923969,
0.4809853732585907,
-0.5375337600708008,
0.3400680720806122,
-0.46349698305130005,
0.06002328544855118,
-0.3657030165195465,
-0.013828662224113941,
-0.9061354398727417,
-0.21899443864822388,
0.41252589225769043,
-0.36671751737594604,
0.4402008652687073,
-0.5366391539573669,
-0.28065183758735657,
-0.23185394704341888,
0.011741476133465767,
0.8663868308067322,
0.446377694606781,
-0.49102693796157837,
0.7185088992118835,
0.2465972751379013,
-0.33523502945899963,
-0.893284261226654,
-0.3864680528640747,
0.23394043743610382,
-0.34478703141212463,
-0.32652905583381653,
0.5845524072647095,
0.3552938401699066,
-0.33565470576286316,
-0.07179837673902512,
-0.28158459067344666,
-0.02361168898642063,
0.38310229778289795,
0.548295259475708,
0.4517039656639099,
-0.4866894781589508,
0.23123407363891602,
-0.24381791055202484,
-0.37722504138946533,
0.01435636542737484,
-0.27427858114242554,
0.5655385255813599,
-0.12713505327701569,
-0.2096630185842514,
-0.7907425165176392,
0.3900071978569031,
0.590387225151062,
-0.17463208734989166,
0.6126337051391602,
0.44276121258735657,
-0.8888700008392334,
-0.003718141233548522,
-0.3502609133720398,
-0.2100333571434021,
-0.4486435055732727,
0.26557210087776184,
-0.41815975308418274,
-0.44687512516975403,
0.6760185956954956,
-0.36572280526161194,
0.018514681607484818,
0.4193454086780548,
0.49905925989151,
-0.1046624630689621,
0.8822431564331055,
0.6827462315559387,
-0.41928035020828247,
0.5140601992607117,
-0.23932336270809174,
0.32265233993530273,
-0.6213963627815247,
-0.2702764868736267,
-0.8950348496437073,
-0.6811195015907288,
-0.6653369665145874,
0.24035844206809998,
0.21618850529193878,
0.5302022695541382,
-0.3133290410041809,
0.0942111611366272,
-0.6080977320671082,
0.39031025767326355,
0.7627763748168945,
0.07763323932886124,
0.1931317150592804,
-0.06662136316299438,
-0.02919926308095455,
0.26575207710266113,
-0.5222089886665344,
-1.2190696001052856,
1.031071662902832,
0.17645590007305145,
0.8437133431434631,
0.08066967129707336,
0.9153759479522705,
0.4047430753707886,
0.6377060413360596,
-0.9898650646209717,
0.4017496109008789,
-0.03194967657327652,
-0.4327886998653412,
-0.11321809142827988,
0.0019902638159692287,
-0.9828991889953613,
-0.23363400995731354,
-0.35931217670440674,
-0.8511109352111816,
0.3596929907798767,
-0.005475563928484917,
-0.7244938015937805,
0.42912188172340393,
-0.7951383590698242,
0.7418268322944641,
-0.16686294972896576,
0.04724501073360443,
-0.022554541006684303,
-0.707608699798584,
0.0840749740600586,
0.028038837015628815,
0.056328486651182175,
-0.11434627324342728,
-0.07001448422670364,
1.0874589681625366,
-0.40704378485679626,
1.0416244268417358,
-0.10903221368789673,
0.07571680843830109,
0.37584567070007324,
-0.019900605082511902,
0.32137176394462585,
-0.19286301732063293,
-0.15908090770244598,
0.20153343677520752,
0.10991398245096207,
-0.4598384499549866,
0.00855940766632557,
0.498086541891098,
-0.9518725872039795,
-0.3487170338630676,
-0.6612176299095154,
-0.19536207616329193,
0.26112017035484314,
0.38577133417129517,
0.4095459282398224,
0.6891628503799438,
-0.2449595034122467,
-0.16159415245056152,
0.6185349822044373,
-0.16078577935695648,
0.9488409757614136,
0.1046484038233757,
0.07457782328128815,
-0.11936531215906143,
0.5600115060806274,
0.18266013264656067,
-0.13269349932670593,
0.2883946895599365,
-0.015002535656094551,
-0.143363356590271,
-0.7935412526130676,
-0.7825871706008911,
-0.09656600654125214,
-0.748324990272522,
-0.21210268139839172,
-0.4072438180446625,
-0.310531347990036,
0.023750480264425278,
-0.20777465403079987,
-0.14468435943126678,
-0.4535926878452301,
-0.7852493524551392,
0.05106263607740402,
0.1520683616399765,
0.9193849563598633,
0.04305875673890114,
0.4116014540195465,
-0.8198373317718506,
0.27300968766212463,
0.1063520759344101,
0.29163241386413574,
0.3412153422832489,
-0.26265695691108704,
-0.36315393447875977,
-0.10062484443187714,
-0.049681372940540314,
-1.1330434083938599,
0.2455293834209442,
0.4031968414783478,
0.26638063788414,
0.6816001534461975,
0.010154429823160172,
0.31835711002349854,
-0.5680822134017944,
0.37470686435699463,
0.18348458409309387,
-1.0464091300964355,
0.4305194318294525,
0.001838209223933518,
-0.053177621215581894,
0.40955275297164917,
0.7136825323104858,
-0.790913999080658,
-0.1392916887998581,
-0.3169577419757843,
-1.1714649200439453,
0.5896508097648621,
0.22331008315086365,
0.10579413175582886,
-0.167629674077034,
0.8207966089248657,
0.2310527265071869,
0.14348194003105164,
-0.6186877489089966,
-0.5252176523208618,
-0.008489877916872501,
-0.4756757915019989,
0.28924861550331116,
-0.33555951714515686,
-0.047096703201532364,
0.002470597391948104,
0.5760230422019958,
-0.01844272017478943,
0.0828804150223732,
0.1246546059846878,
-0.4335726499557495,
-0.0807339996099472,
0.3321343958377838,
0.2923438847064972,
0.5066285133361816,
-0.07043961435556412,
0.25920310616493225,
-0.1598484218120575,
-0.7616409063339233,
0.3725772500038147,
0.22383646667003632,
-0.6263918280601501,
0.17657364904880524,
0.3555687367916107,
0.7533523440361023,
0.015191902406513691,
-0.39051327109336853,
0.3008233904838562,
0.19125990569591522,
0.30715441703796387,
-0.50790935754776,
-0.05610637366771698,
-0.18728727102279663,
0.040893588215112686,
0.7394809722900391,
0.3623165488243103,
0.26340705156326294,
-0.5984988808631897,
0.08191994577646255,
0.1339477002620697,
-0.3991044759750366,
-0.27980008721351624,
0.8837835788726807,
0.3537198007106781,
-0.6775628328323364,
0.7435701489448547,
-0.17014406621456146,
-0.4696296155452728,
0.8087334632873535,
0.3768189549446106,
0.6001747250556946,
-0.15625432133674622,
0.18995000422000885,
0.38368090987205505,
0.2266380488872528,
-0.3013458251953125,
0.4019424021244049,
-0.14135007560253143,
-0.7257512211799622,
-0.5294430255889893,
-0.7048895955085754,
-0.46123844385147095,
-0.08009102195501328,
-0.7984920740127563,
0.2989456355571747,
-0.5112002491950989,
-0.3695630133152008,
0.6205353736877441,
-0.08304321765899658,
-0.8052088618278503,
0.2353563755750656,
0.6357955932617188,
0.5822343230247498,
-0.8214350342750549,
0.8562555909156799,
0.8135155439376831,
-0.49741727113723755,
-0.6600947976112366,
-0.40149644017219543,
0.03524448722600937,
-0.7381432056427002,
0.9608878493309021,
0.5553218722343445,
-0.1038425862789154,
0.36775752902030945,
-0.3092721104621887,
-0.6300360560417175,
0.7689734697341919,
0.04358522221446037,
-0.9105408191680908,
-0.3233399987220764,
-0.02003634348511696,
0.5706073641777039,
-0.22506844997406006,
0.5221253633499146,
0.3521882891654968,
0.44693148136138916,
-0.28841882944107056,
-0.8822891116142273,
-0.06187419965863228,
-0.38402706384658813,
-0.17599402368068695,
0.49802500009536743,
-0.155392125248909,
0.5954467058181763,
-0.36686450242996216,
-0.5922463536262512,
0.5862323641777039,
0.6833654642105103,
-0.1706434041261673,
0.23797917366027832,
0.17442606389522552,
0.6256162524223328,
1.0231215953826904,
-0.4484412968158722,
0.7350985407829285,
-0.7210277915000916,
0.07953795790672302,
0.8167048096656799,
-0.09465454518795013,
0.6968500018119812,
0.3634474277496338,
0.05241256207227707,
0.5436729788780212,
0.7913039922714233,
-0.04915624484419823,
0.32803112268447876,
0.6041317582130432,
-0.7465915679931641,
0.15748566389083862,
-0.3108855187892914,
-0.31334447860717773,
0.5244467854499817,
0.458686500787735,
-0.37686264514923096,
-0.07489554584026337,
0.33205342292785645,
0.07117543369531631,
-0.2058585286140442,
-0.7248764038085938,
0.7707304954528809,
0.01356918178498745,
-0.22630247473716736,
0.34610143303871155,
0.3423767387866974,
0.9309655427932739,
-0.39513105154037476,
-0.18274658918380737,
-0.10460133105516434,
0.10093829780817032,
-0.2395448535680771,
-0.3626251816749573,
0.026957418769598007,
-0.19828924536705017,
-0.17761288583278656,
-0.15680746734142303,
0.4159752428531647,
-0.1750437170267105,
-0.42630720138549805,
-0.07544254511594772,
0.455556184053421,
0.21103215217590332,
0.32115453481674194,
-0.24011725187301636,
-0.2725984752178192,
-0.3321884572505951,
0.0032603300642222166,
0.09707403928041458,
0.5080201029777527,
-0.3726614713668823,
0.5359415411949158,
0.34676653146743774,
0.2676083445549011,
0.013279515318572521,
-0.02086758241057396,
0.4044703245162964,
-0.7584577202796936,
-0.38492366671562195,
-0.8303229212760925,
0.09443969279527664,
0.42553919553756714,
-0.6288366317749023,
0.4819616377353668,
0.5722100138664246,
0.8724865317344666,
-0.0669296607375145,
0.6736133098602295,
-0.10247939079999924,
0.07741550356149673,
-0.407636433839798,
0.8679383397102356,
-0.036397144198417664,
0.361971378326416,
-0.058739010244607925,
-0.7611752152442932,
-0.2724300026893616,
0.669407069683075,
-0.041356559842824936,
-0.04759575426578522,
0.48151108622550964,
0.4517035186290741,
0.03253575786948204,
0.08491358906030655,
0.01789790391921997,
0.0450277253985405,
-0.0234482754021883,
0.38259080052375793,
0.9681463241577148,
-0.4931868016719818,
0.4162620007991791,
-0.3476451337337494,
-0.06660609692335129,
-0.29944947361946106,
-0.6769928336143494,
-0.7247971296310425,
-0.559248685836792,
-0.5413729548454285,
-0.5571573972702026,
0.2606688439846039,
1.0383141040802002,
0.5327181220054626,
-1.1371947526931763,
-0.2134311944246292,
0.03655516356229782,
0.02694314904510975,
-0.32570764422416687,
-0.1589709371328354,
0.8421921133995056,
-0.08672943711280823,
-0.9617870450019836,
-0.05191650241613388,
0.26903125643730164,
0.5423372387886047,
-0.14576737582683563,
0.07424642145633698,
0.07776597142219543,
-0.09304343163967133,
0.3586909770965576,
0.637892484664917,
-0.6288195252418518,
-0.4880346357822418,
-0.3238196074962616,
-0.30285146832466125,
0.38474950194358826,
0.8260519504547119,
-0.7954902052879333,
0.31824296712875366,
0.38550034165382385,
0.4853787422180176,
0.40291517972946167,
-0.27329695224761963,
0.21428319811820984,
-0.5168350338935852,
0.44028982520103455,
0.7096118927001953,
0.5393982529640198,
0.21283750236034393,
-0.20271359384059906,
0.471795916557312,
0.1753000020980835,
-0.426070898771286,
-0.6925578713417053,
0.09451428055763245,
-0.7287831902503967,
-0.09212326258420944,
0.6427878737449646,
-0.22261032462120056,
-0.14013665914535522,
-0.44225460290908813,
-0.4340749979019165,
0.4412550926208496,
-0.26822757720947266,
1.2175642251968384,
0.8955252766609192,
0.12955619394779205,
0.04535850137472153,
-0.4122101068496704,
0.5412667393684387,
0.23516233265399933,
-0.672380268573761,
-0.4941670596599579,
0.6729580760002136,
0.10099875926971436,
0.5006498098373413,
0.5397839546203613,
-0.12083131074905396,
0.07653979957103729,
0.06826040893793106,
0.6207095980644226,
0.2847910523414612,
-0.40760862827301025,
-0.08785564452409744,
0.3827231228351593,
0.3167142868041992,
-0.4138556122779846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00468v1 | MMEvalPro: Calibrating Multimodal Benchmarks Towards Trustworthy and Efficient Evaluation | 2024-06-29T15:28:45 | 2024-06-29T15:28:45 | Jinsheng Huang, Liang Chen, Taian Guo, Fu Zeng, Yusheng Zhao, Bohan Wu, Ye Yuan, Haozhe Zhao, Zhihui Guo, Yichi Zhang, Jingyang Yuan, Wei Ju, Luchen Liu, Tianyu Liu, Baobao Chang, Ming Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) exhibit impressive cross-modal understanding
and reasoning abilities, often assessed through multiple-choice questions
(MCQs) that include an image, a question, and several options. However, many
benchmarks used for such evaluations suffer from systematic biases. Remarkably,
Large Language Models (LLMs) without any visual perception capabilities achieve
non-trivial performance, undermining the credibility of these evaluations. To
address this issue while maintaining the efficiency of MCQ evaluations, we
propose MMEvalPro, a benchmark designed to avoid Type-I errors through a
trilogy evaluation pipeline and more rigorous metrics. For each original
question from existing benchmarks, human annotators augment it by creating one
perception question and one knowledge anchor question through a meticulous
annotation process. MMEvalPro comprises $2,138$ question triplets, totaling
$6,414$ distinct questions. Two-thirds of these questions are manually labeled
by human experts, while the rest are sourced from existing benchmarks (MMMU,
ScienceQA, and MathVista). Compared with the existing benchmarks, our
experiments with the latest LLMs and LMMs demonstrate that MMEvalPro is more
challenging (the best LMM lags behind human performance by $31.73\%$, compared
to an average gap of $8.03\%$ in previous benchmarks) and more trustworthy (the
best LLM trails the best LMM by $23.09\%$, whereas the gap for previous
benchmarks is just $14.64\%$). Our in-depth analysis explains the reason for
the large performance gap and justifies the trustworthiness of evaluation,
underscoring its significant potential for advancing future research. | [
-0.37973758578300476,
-0.3210355043411255,
0.6185356378555298,
0.2663193941116333,
-0.03611847385764122,
0.2574809193611145,
-0.2511080801486969,
-0.43060600757598877,
-0.23229558765888214,
0.2853158116340637,
-0.5206990242004395,
-0.17659695446491241,
-0.5417574048042297,
0.08130844682455063,
0.06039593368768692,
0.7377644181251526,
-0.05061865597963333,
0.2975505292415619,
-0.5604780912399292,
-0.533585250377655,
-0.10386232286691666,
-0.27322831749916077,
-0.23183274269104004,
-0.2395557314157486,
0.548751175403595,
0.5367920994758606,
0.6665423512458801,
0.35061389207839966,
0.7892903089523315,
0.27239036560058594,
0.1694212406873703,
0.5801429748535156,
-0.4316370189189911,
0.08878510445356369,
-0.1269662082195282,
-0.43996360898017883,
-0.33042630553245544,
0.19195805490016937,
0.7492744326591492,
0.441516250371933,
-0.10272417962551117,
0.5603420734405518,
-0.04230174794793129,
0.8340721130371094,
-1.0587166547775269,
0.1268574595451355,
-0.6832006573677063,
-0.012030215002596378,
-0.21557988226413727,
-0.24228230118751526,
-0.45341256260871887,
-0.5626806616783142,
-0.01287169847637415,
-0.6478391289710999,
-0.12030800431966782,
0.210879385471344,
0.6098552942276001,
0.38270285725593567,
-0.4043958783149719,
-0.11118718981742859,
-0.5497062802314758,
0.938957154750824,
-0.4628736674785614,
0.6933831572532654,
0.4306989014148712,
0.7770363092422485,
0.04524483531713486,
-0.5155195593833923,
-0.6561132669448853,
-0.5247883796691895,
0.35084182024002075,
0.27212515473365784,
-0.038601353764534,
-0.2371039241552353,
0.3089892864227295,
0.3336338400840759,
-0.5682927966117859,
0.09889572113752365,
-0.5138956308364868,
-0.508725106716156,
0.34266677498817444,
0.19376249611377716,
-0.05817641690373421,
-0.2984563708305359,
-0.5214617848396301,
-0.48650455474853516,
-0.7368794679641724,
0.22811153531074524,
0.3846206068992615,
0.01997894048690796,
0.1568303257226944,
0.8505504727363586,
-0.26658499240875244,
0.6629952192306519,
-0.17131289839744568,
-0.5320180654525757,
0.6012006998062134,
-0.34844088554382324,
-0.1393289566040039,
-0.3061302900314331,
0.8957944512367249,
0.7409115433692932,
0.31340542435646057,
0.1422237753868103,
0.034501682966947556,
0.1855398565530777,
0.23250320553779602,
-0.7726231813430786,
0.013579991646111012,
0.2090548872947693,
-0.1500019133090973,
-0.18524952232837677,
-0.07104544341564178,
-0.8690944314002991,
-0.4765421748161316,
-0.27125751972198486,
0.6693708300590515,
-0.6027841567993164,
-0.1336507350206375,
-0.1271292120218277,
-0.11328301578760147,
0.14428038895130157,
0.5343314409255981,
-0.5877578854560852,
0.13617153465747833,
0.7643325924873352,
0.7626997232437134,
-0.05573783442378044,
-0.611044704914093,
-0.7574775218963623,
0.11088482290506363,
-0.23121097683906555,
0.7415143251419067,
-0.7903528809547424,
-0.2114763855934143,
-0.26230108737945557,
-0.24788078665733337,
-0.2185898870229721,
-0.5552376508712769,
0.6558471322059631,
-0.4417437016963959,
0.24261662364006042,
-0.39136582612991333,
-0.3447072505950928,
-0.13976553082466125,
0.6650869846343994,
-0.6079357266426086,
1.0260850191116333,
0.034481748938560486,
-0.6993651390075684,
0.6735943555831909,
-0.6868734955787659,
0.03007131814956665,
-0.16566374897956848,
-0.34071871638298035,
-0.057588495314121246,
-0.09849759936332703,
0.5615547895431519,
0.28766360878944397,
-0.698319137096405,
0.20098306238651276,
-0.3582020699977875,
-0.30920442938804626,
0.2767627239227295,
-0.6173318028450012,
0.38010627031326294,
0.22466644644737244,
-0.3339405059814453,
0.08332015573978424,
-0.8713153600692749,
0.1950669288635254,
-0.28237855434417725,
-0.33830422163009644,
-0.25269079208374023,
-0.1185484528541565,
-0.15864676237106323,
0.3110574185848236,
0.05927703157067299,
-0.5961289405822754,
-0.05632712319493294,
0.054835718125104904,
0.3497818112373352,
0.9517615437507629,
-0.3452471196651459,
0.17126885056495667,
-0.40889737010002136,
0.6342731714248657,
0.14241589605808258,
0.46123600006103516,
-0.21837465465068817,
-0.654900848865509,
-0.5551906228065491,
-0.5402752757072449,
0.35769230127334595,
0.4565345048904419,
-0.854995608329773,
-0.09434227645397186,
-0.4069908857345581,
-0.6825643181800842,
-0.9778184294700623,
0.28969457745552063,
0.6879062056541443,
0.9345048666000366,
0.4678008556365967,
-0.23004554212093353,
-0.31271910667419434,
-1.2202569246292114,
-0.3097740411758423,
-0.318264365196228,
-0.10832371562719345,
0.4641692638397217,
0.5595507621765137,
-0.21060068905353546,
0.6754500269889832,
-0.24785001575946808,
-0.18764419853687286,
0.22539855539798737,
0.3493878245353699,
0.07087717950344086,
0.5179578065872192,
0.3762216567993164,
-0.7943400740623474,
-0.35169291496276855,
-0.10043324530124664,
-0.6651695966720581,
-0.08603013306856155,
0.040566496551036835,
0.023137474432587624,
0.027197588235139847,
0.27575716376304626,
-0.4635348618030548,
-0.03283829241991043,
0.7609906196594238,
0.1022954210639,
0.778449535369873,
-0.14839833974838257,
0.6111200451850891,
-0.8824952244758606,
0.2733612060546875,
0.12021254748106003,
-0.12561412155628204,
-0.1594022810459137,
0.20131725072860718,
0.47970399260520935,
0.15685677528381348,
-0.5616245269775391,
0.6147580742835999,
-0.3796021640300751,
-0.12948569655418396,
0.31885915994644165,
0.22514639794826508,
0.18119534850120544,
0.38029396533966064,
-0.39466825127601624,
1.155983567237854,
0.4774675965309143,
-0.408416211605072,
0.18357102572917938,
0.10265347361564636,
-0.7087098956108093,
0.9226124286651611,
-0.6205484867095947,
0.11051063239574432,
-0.11848229914903641,
0.1469534933567047,
-1.121811866760254,
-0.2107885628938675,
0.09544883668422699,
-0.4705874025821686,
0.06871604174375534,
-0.21770571172237396,
-0.6661312580108643,
-0.4215988516807556,
-0.6523222327232361,
0.6263537406921387,
0.3774103820323944,
-0.7000210881233215,
0.5901609659194946,
0.31851404905319214,
0.20703966915607452,
-0.9499001502990723,
-0.6294846534729004,
-0.014485224150121212,
-0.1370183676481247,
-0.7414503693580627,
0.01975664123892784,
-0.3609859347343445,
-0.28133460879325867,
-0.3402400016784668,
-0.13090617954730988,
0.014207499101758003,
-0.2407599240541458,
0.3699895441532135,
0.2604810893535614,
-0.29678472876548767,
0.14201821386814117,
-0.013721765950322151,
-0.08790402114391327,
-0.08744306862354279,
0.19956208765506744,
0.4768124520778656,
-0.4708259701728821,
-0.6555503606796265,
-0.3403940200805664,
0.021858662366867065,
1.2082221508026123,
-0.42028936743736267,
0.45592811703681946,
0.7495704293251038,
-0.1085297092795372,
0.2008669674396515,
-1.0589839220046997,
0.18192227184772491,
-0.49181926250457764,
0.16460973024368286,
-0.650574266910553,
-0.9435714483261108,
0.37094318866729736,
-0.10899356007575989,
-0.02312912978231907,
0.49913620948791504,
0.47522303462028503,
0.03987798094749451,
1.064867615699768,
0.17839717864990234,
0.04405032843351364,
0.12779811024665833,
-0.009611262008547783,
-0.1938835233449936,
-1.3537102937698364,
-0.5035814046859741,
-0.37761828303337097,
-0.2559039890766144,
-0.5369216203689575,
-0.9063616991043091,
0.7125504016876221,
-0.21341586112976074,
-0.12976525723934174,
0.09853018820285797,
-0.2460804134607315,
0.47126585245132446,
0.6839425563812256,
0.15829525887966156,
0.4483446478843689,
-0.19091196358203888,
-0.5085309743881226,
-0.3749036490917206,
-0.47323906421661377,
-0.5266661047935486,
1.449177622795105,
0.3008256256580353,
0.7967749238014221,
0.1388745903968811,
0.3560901880264282,
0.24590550363063812,
0.4776158332824707,
-0.6738510131835938,
0.5065948963165283,
0.21531523764133453,
-0.7320924401283264,
-0.08658240735530853,
-0.6352065205574036,
-0.5627287030220032,
0.7161561846733093,
-0.45139455795288086,
-0.6876803636550903,
0.22904559969902039,
0.16203591227531433,
-0.26500651240348816,
0.2837882339954376,
-0.9085424542427063,
0.7277178764343262,
-0.2868407070636749,
-0.7534233331680298,
-0.26662224531173706,
-0.6350080370903015,
0.6085996627807617,
-0.20895510911941528,
0.4669238030910492,
-0.4131215512752533,
-0.14191387593746185,
0.6178573369979858,
-0.27842479944229126,
0.3885948061943054,
-0.15273483097553253,
0.19220738112926483,
0.08316411077976227,
0.123434878885746,
0.2114703357219696,
0.15959031879901886,
-0.39002472162246704,
-0.021875405684113503,
0.1991685926914215,
-0.3398771286010742,
-0.45609524846076965,
0.8097663521766663,
-0.6078634858131409,
-0.44786036014556885,
-0.48156246542930603,
-0.5919854044914246,
-0.6719835996627808,
0.17437832057476044,
-0.06314878165721893,
0.5407488346099854,
-0.291132390499115,
0.2814781069755554,
0.4219453036785126,
-0.16035403311252594,
0.26387035846710205,
0.4827440679073334,
-0.234676331281662,
-0.741980791091919,
0.6875202655792236,
-0.07809337228536606,
0.3269716203212738,
0.3754437267780304,
0.3876219689846039,
-0.4447931945323944,
-0.4023767113685608,
-0.7509792447090149,
0.20552918314933777,
-0.7074436545372009,
-0.25103631615638733,
-0.6565201878547668,
0.2614143192768097,
-0.21305225789546967,
0.19802036881446838,
-0.6346043944358826,
-0.5368436574935913,
0.06681293994188309,
-0.04429306834936142,
0.22499452531337738,
0.3600420653820038,
-0.2743980884552002,
0.03652932122349739,
-0.6787280440330505,
0.3924890458583832,
0.5572263598442078,
0.44601312279701233,
0.07188355922698975,
-0.4785699248313904,
0.04565105587244034,
0.18420228362083435,
-0.2197411209344864,
-0.3571031987667084,
0.06731726974248886,
0.2817552387714386,
0.5809579491615295,
0.5125645995140076,
-0.1741468757390976,
1.2025279998779297,
-0.6596050262451172,
0.6463796496391296,
0.39435723423957825,
-0.9071758985519409,
0.5258058905601501,
-0.24177834391593933,
0.4060012400150299,
1.2407344579696655,
0.5314107537269592,
-0.2665656507015228,
-0.20708386600017548,
-0.32905247807502747,
-0.6545199155807495,
0.3936285078525543,
0.13754898309707642,
-0.08189940452575684,
0.03133483976125717,
0.052297625690698624,
0.29526305198669434,
0.3688275218009949,
-0.5522945523262024,
0.12006005644798279,
-0.11732277274131775,
0.019199857488274574,
-0.2895689308643341,
-0.2701101005077362,
-0.37206006050109863,
-0.43310365080833435,
0.36347976326942444,
-0.1770731508731842,
-0.02494467794895172,
0.295455664396286,
-0.3925081193447113,
-0.12628179788589478,
0.2984056770801544,
0.825867235660553,
1.0295354127883911,
-0.5552720427513123,
0.28240033984184265,
-0.011101721785962582,
-0.4674503803253174,
-0.029386108741164207,
0.03036879003047943,
0.2037392109632492,
-0.28151506185531616,
0.3143213987350464,
0.47872501611709595,
0.29595455527305603,
-1.074716329574585,
0.6750503778457642,
-0.182020366191864,
-0.15309996902942657,
-0.15312166512012482,
-0.056106045842170715,
-0.12356575578451157,
0.3594692349433899,
0.4625435471534729,
0.37303969264030457,
0.08888060599565506,
-0.768921971321106,
0.22863753139972687,
0.48874473571777344,
-0.42107608914375305,
-0.23517464101314545,
0.7941174507141113,
0.09931690990924835,
-0.013190889731049538,
0.4880971312522888,
0.07354596257209778,
-0.5122829079627991,
0.3067553639411926,
0.2562505602836609,
0.47638440132141113,
-0.30718371272087097,
0.2226051390171051,
0.47489678859710693,
0.627476692199707,
-0.2883587181568146,
0.3354209363460541,
-0.2272869199514389,
-0.5637141466140747,
-0.3703760504722595,
-0.6552305221557617,
-0.9365284442901611,
-0.1258838176727295,
-0.636620283126831,
-0.005845768377184868,
-0.5719326138496399,
-0.1789468377828598,
0.051189035177230835,
-0.2264353632926941,
-0.7184006571769714,
0.34447595477104187,
0.044319652020931244,
0.9839067459106445,
-0.6903923153877258,
0.6529808044433594,
0.4971494674682617,
-0.47404924035072327,
-0.45279449224472046,
-0.22502154111862183,
0.09115681052207947,
-1.193932056427002,
0.5314911007881165,
0.37450116872787476,
-0.3993852734565735,
-0.41744866967201233,
-0.39346835017204285,
-0.8903480172157288,
1.2700543403625488,
0.420744389295578,
-0.5208996534347534,
0.3134597837924957,
0.21412235498428345,
0.5709732174873352,
-0.39125362038612366,
0.5781422853469849,
0.37199851870536804,
0.7802692651748657,
0.2762150764465332,
-1.2352373600006104,
0.010411995463073254,
-0.4280543029308319,
-0.2344295084476471,
0.1479770392179489,
-0.828567624092102,
0.8406654596328735,
-0.30612289905548096,
0.2090063989162445,
-0.009688765741884708,
0.1702662706375122,
0.6629307866096497,
0.45855915546417236,
0.5151654481887817,
0.6364214420318604,
0.8977842330932617,
-0.07447486370801926,
1.2067999839782715,
-0.19563981890678406,
0.11000528931617737,
1.2332450151443481,
-0.477874755859375,
1.1902111768722534,
0.8264639377593994,
-0.18861185014247894,
0.4414297938346863,
0.5020841956138611,
-0.03324029967188835,
0.5199871063232422,
0.11073100566864014,
-0.09775304049253464,
-0.30734488368034363,
-0.022041788324713707,
-0.5314567685127258,
0.5829699039459229,
0.23566952347755432,
-0.3174758553504944,
0.0014910759637132287,
-0.10019494593143463,
0.034107133746147156,
-0.005619497504085302,
-0.28314220905303955,
0.291374146938324,
-0.14142529666423798,
-0.722741425037384,
0.49054473638534546,
-0.3060087263584137,
0.7306312918663025,
-0.7038529515266418,
0.10150577127933502,
-0.1458459347486496,
0.29603898525238037,
-0.1539948284626007,
-0.6384631991386414,
0.004448705818504095,
0.006764470599591732,
0.03506093844771385,
-0.19433245062828064,
0.3416048288345337,
-0.10243196040391922,
-0.7996081709861755,
0.1590990573167801,
0.7311654090881348,
0.04021231457591057,
-0.22098040580749512,
-0.6351743340492249,
0.24691078066825867,
-0.19370520114898682,
-0.18209514021873474,
0.2539950907230377,
0.21406567096710205,
-0.012757813557982445,
0.9359222650527954,
0.7736630439758301,
-0.11234693974256516,
0.16063058376312256,
0.13878750801086426,
0.8367210030555725,
-0.522983729839325,
-0.12335877865552902,
-0.8436182737350464,
0.591411828994751,
-0.1813136786222458,
-0.5532146692276001,
0.8856478929519653,
0.8876475095748901,
0.6395832300186157,
0.02337384596467018,
0.45563894510269165,
0.15810361504554749,
0.5152223110198975,
-0.5168213844299316,
0.6725736260414124,
-0.933871328830719,
0.2882835566997528,
-0.6145555973052979,
-0.9938898682594299,
-0.34175020456314087,
0.4818209707736969,
-0.32526808977127075,
0.08812811970710754,
0.7313838005065918,
0.77708500623703,
-0.21647419035434723,
-0.09691303968429565,
0.3672749400138855,
0.008258153684437275,
0.28784486651420593,
0.56983482837677,
1.0712875127792358,
-0.5062829852104187,
0.641022801399231,
-0.331310898065567,
-0.426427960395813,
-0.10810893028974533,
-0.9900517463684082,
-0.8238440155982971,
-0.553640604019165,
-0.12242516875267029,
-0.1309782862663269,
0.0025530867278575897,
0.8435916900634766,
0.861075222492218,
-0.6312415599822998,
-0.36798590421676636,
0.4437573552131653,
0.06886984407901764,
-0.18216314911842346,
-0.1675684154033661,
0.20344096422195435,
-0.005610755179077387,
-0.6708813309669495,
0.5520339608192444,
0.4227429926395416,
-0.20120666921138763,
-0.38806936144828796,
-0.009826194494962692,
-0.2590748965740204,
0.011049238964915276,
0.850421667098999,
0.18639801442623138,
-0.8153813481330872,
-0.3915659189224243,
0.06812168657779694,
0.10878194868564606,
0.3628717362880707,
0.6060416102409363,
-0.854479968547821,
0.7604542970657349,
0.3451351821422577,
0.5449750423431396,
0.7206459045410156,
0.03430518880486488,
0.4876366853713989,
-0.4341137111186981,
0.07660100609064102,
0.3385846018791199,
0.3703977167606354,
0.6044057011604309,
0.11637570708990097,
0.7298988103866577,
-0.06008244305849075,
-0.48309028148651123,
-1.053759217262268,
0.058320552110672,
-1.2288494110107422,
0.07962425798177719,
1.0316948890686035,
0.05328352004289627,
-0.296888530254364,
0.2552332580089569,
-0.14343318343162537,
-0.2863200008869171,
-0.40307992696762085,
0.8098728060722351,
0.7363786697387695,
-0.20490282773971558,
-0.31879034638404846,
-0.7731496095657349,
0.26022714376449585,
0.4781486988067627,
-0.6764116287231445,
-0.15840575098991394,
0.6984968185424805,
0.3126075267791748,
0.3610510230064392,
0.5191225409507751,
-0.41774752736091614,
0.439287394285202,
-0.07280774414539337,
-0.1298302859067917,
-0.17936760187149048,
-0.42984986305236816,
-0.1284795105457306,
0.37997695803642273,
0.15107066929340363,
-0.18901439011096954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00466v1 | BioKGBench: A Knowledge Graph Checking Benchmark of AI Agent for Biomedical Science | 2024-06-29T15:23:28 | 2024-06-29T15:23:28 | Xinna Lin, Siqi Ma, Junjie Shan, Xiaojing Zhang, Shell Xu Hu, Tiannan Guo, Stan Z. Li, Kaicheng Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pursuing artificial intelligence for biomedical science, a.k.a. AI Scientist,
draws increasing attention, where one common approach is to build a copilot
agent driven by Large Language Models (LLMs). However, to evaluate such
systems, people either rely on direct Question-Answering (QA) to the LLM
itself, or in a biomedical experimental manner. How to precisely benchmark
biomedical agents from an AI Scientist perspective remains largely unexplored.
To this end, we draw inspiration from one most important abilities of
scientists, understanding the literature, and introduce BioKGBench. In contrast
to traditional evaluation benchmark that only focuses on factual QA, where the
LLMs are known to have hallucination issues, we first disentangle
"Understanding Literature" into two atomic abilities, i) "Understanding" the
unstructured text from research papers by performing scientific claim
verification, and ii) Ability to interact with structured Knowledge-Graph
Question-Answering (KGQA) as a form of "Literature" grounding. We then
formulate a novel agent task, dubbed KGCheck, using KGQA and domain-based
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) to identify the factual errors of existing
large-scale knowledge graph databases. We collect over two thousand data for
two atomic tasks and 225 high-quality annotated data for the agent task.
Surprisingly, we discover that state-of-the-art agents, both daily scenarios
and biomedical ones, have either failed or inferior performance on our
benchmark. We then introduce a simple yet effective baseline, dubbed BKGAgent.
On the widely used popular knowledge graph, we discover over 90 factual errors
which provide scenarios for agents to make discoveries and demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach. The code and data are available at
https://github.com/westlake-autolab/BioKGBench. | [
-0.3015361726284027,
-0.6613513231277466,
0.7600704431533813,
-0.1409810185432434,
-0.09389980882406235,
0.510686993598938,
0.2659150958061218,
-0.5935990214347839,
0.09284008294343948,
0.2608849108219147,
-0.3433529734611511,
-0.7048704624176025,
-0.4152332842350006,
0.2656956911087036,
-0.11551443487405777,
0.95562744140625,
-0.019992932677268982,
0.23558710515499115,
-0.8502736687660217,
-0.4193519651889801,
-0.22886738181114197,
-0.03249121084809303,
-0.42661333084106445,
-0.8340799808502197,
0.5852768421173096,
-0.02943386137485504,
0.8075648546218872,
0.5597337484359741,
0.4716246724128723,
0.3228848874568939,
-0.12282451242208481,
0.2595597207546234,
-0.526547908782959,
0.0059713879600167274,
-0.22851280868053436,
-0.3131907284259796,
-0.3799823522567749,
0.11983640491962433,
0.5510606169700623,
0.8579478859901428,
0.10522344708442688,
-0.03241895139217377,
-0.10311943292617798,
0.774937629699707,
-0.5596891045570374,
0.47319796681404114,
-0.3679685592651367,
0.23496003448963165,
0.10985973477363586,
0.08798764646053314,
-0.26000532507896423,
-0.6078503131866455,
-0.13712047040462494,
-0.5419419407844543,
0.1867993175983429,
0.02216329053044319,
0.806197464466095,
0.4680086076259613,
-0.620774507522583,
-0.06314780563116074,
-0.3510398864746094,
0.38327687978744507,
-0.49761244654655457,
0.6113399863243103,
0.5126973390579224,
0.577476978302002,
-0.17997433245182037,
-0.7802916765213013,
-0.562203049659729,
-0.7166934013366699,
-0.31034985184669495,
0.31962087750434875,
0.024710610508918762,
0.2069268375635147,
0.2807835638523102,
-0.03590214252471924,
-0.808363139629364,
-0.15370699763298035,
-0.398490309715271,
-0.576046884059906,
0.5349442362785339,
0.10537564009428024,
0.16991032660007477,
-0.17826277017593384,
-0.015560608357191086,
-0.31400126218795776,
-0.4609655439853668,
0.15156035125255585,
0.1721704602241516,
-0.17785438895225525,
0.24045836925506592,
0.5454862117767334,
-0.4802837371826172,
0.5533629655838013,
-0.043589841574430466,
0.13268673419952393,
0.2958342432975769,
-0.4327850043773651,
0.001026076264679432,
0.22945725917816162,
0.6455017328262329,
0.3162805438041687,
-0.010492955334484577,
-0.6631367206573486,
0.07834028452634811,
0.1829001009464264,
0.5825362205505371,
-1.0650206804275513,
-0.39205285906791687,
0.5709236860275269,
-0.2657265365123749,
-0.3327820897102356,
-0.24661171436309814,
-0.689254879951477,
-0.8058287501335144,
-0.03530409187078476,
0.3428707420825958,
-0.5376160144805908,
0.06073253974318504,
-0.2934206426143646,
-0.2184009552001953,
0.2571982443332672,
0.0981219932436943,
-0.2095673531293869,
0.004345861729234457,
0.7089459896087646,
0.7529813647270203,
-0.028798699378967285,
-0.47414958477020264,
-0.5286065936088562,
0.06716613471508026,
-0.6661372184753418,
1.121108055114746,
-0.19257761538028717,
-0.3705209195613861,
-0.354709655046463,
-0.0017516404623165727,
0.06392057240009308,
-0.6058464646339417,
0.2512127459049225,
-0.5550271272659302,
-0.35819292068481445,
-0.45530688762664795,
-0.7429491281509399,
-0.18388289213180542,
0.32938531041145325,
-0.4709828794002533,
0.7679566740989685,
0.3565526306629181,
-0.5313946604728699,
0.5634779930114746,
-0.5540400147438049,
-0.36742475628852844,
0.4477255344390869,
-0.3000974953174591,
-0.46139976382255554,
-0.3069969713687897,
-0.032741136848926544,
0.38007017970085144,
-0.24637062847614288,
0.42353489995002747,
-0.5902809500694275,
-0.18828117847442627,
0.19158639013767242,
0.19003713130950928,
0.9137806296348572,
0.008590205572545528,
-0.2741304636001587,
0.07569456845521927,
-0.8895261287689209,
0.39565548300743103,
-0.0671912282705307,
-0.29799145460128784,
-0.20042651891708374,
0.09070325642824173,
-0.3839458227157593,
-0.11479838937520981,
-0.030790647491812706,
-0.6653329133987427,
0.1977885663509369,
-0.38671109080314636,
0.296322762966156,
0.7175191640853882,
-0.09298361092805862,
0.11345602571964264,
-0.42435163259506226,
0.33041611313819885,
-0.2704474627971649,
-0.03533767908811569,
0.2238050103187561,
-0.3912394344806671,
-0.1491905301809311,
-0.40829962491989136,
0.4926031827926636,
0.6211698055267334,
-0.8686620593070984,
0.7117076516151428,
-0.24133314192295074,
-0.9289693832397461,
-0.6944904923439026,
0.20689673721790314,
0.4282754361629486,
0.7120501399040222,
0.3265196681022644,
-0.159736767411232,
-0.2515808045864105,
-0.945199728012085,
-0.26344138383865356,
-0.4383143186569214,
-0.11130170524120331,
0.5211589336395264,
0.7125213742256165,
-0.6964059472084045,
1.029458999633789,
-0.3784882426261902,
0.12810486555099487,
0.05380818992853165,
0.33416256308555603,
0.13049723207950592,
0.31504714488983154,
0.4256080090999603,
-0.6374825835227966,
-0.35015442967414856,
0.3125856816768646,
-1.078355073928833,
-0.30327802896499634,
0.19135145843029022,
-0.27942097187042236,
-0.03714807331562042,
0.7217263579368591,
-0.755041778087616,
0.33670899271965027,
0.32897865772247314,
-0.595777153968811,
0.702102780342102,
-0.2752361595630646,
0.28703954815864563,
-0.6904246807098389,
0.6352764964103699,
-0.3793582320213318,
-0.36347249150276184,
-0.5652785301208496,
0.06326749175786972,
0.16344164311885834,
-0.07966689765453339,
-0.04967335984110832,
0.7410531044006348,
-0.17766977846622467,
-0.1624220460653305,
-0.3178795278072357,
-0.0041404906660318375,
-0.03465847298502922,
0.36470648646354675,
-0.38540568947792053,
0.6199328899383545,
0.29267191886901855,
-0.4858344495296478,
0.6380597949028015,
0.4188566207885742,
-0.3960815668106079,
0.7412467002868652,
-0.7093132734298706,
0.3882766664028168,
-0.31871044635772705,
0.3722875416278839,
-0.9109364748001099,
-0.14295774698257446,
0.256147176027298,
-0.5656571388244629,
0.1552935093641281,
0.028229178860783577,
-0.5939707159996033,
-0.46903979778289795,
-0.18978972733020782,
0.25903186202049255,
0.5571944117546082,
-0.3564634919166565,
0.9125548601150513,
0.22266530990600586,
-0.1106342151761055,
-0.6438075304031372,
-0.28333863615989685,
0.03908316045999527,
0.3754483163356781,
-0.6057657599449158,
0.2138689011335373,
-0.34334585070610046,
-0.29820308089256287,
0.3599661588668823,
-0.38565486669540405,
-0.05899027734994888,
0.22741200029850006,
0.14893582463264465,
0.13837292790412903,
-0.10805869102478027,
0.12773102521896362,
0.12926413118839264,
-0.2715543806552887,
0.2116994708776474,
-0.13847994804382324,
0.2377265989780426,
-0.20202651619911194,
-0.3018408715724945,
-0.02775091864168644,
-0.08712255954742432,
0.6061931252479553,
-0.04166784882545471,
0.6586913466453552,
0.6562051773071289,
-0.22168657183647156,
-0.08612045645713806,
-0.38288480043411255,
-0.3683875799179077,
-0.4310641884803772,
0.602012038230896,
-0.029187170788645744,
-0.5182883739471436,
0.5731737017631531,
-0.2270381897687912,
-0.09688073396682739,
0.3668215870857239,
0.4397624433040619,
-0.2887110114097595,
0.9316114783287048,
0.295583039522171,
-0.06319593638181686,
-0.1387975960969925,
-0.17412340641021729,
0.20577138662338257,
-0.5446435809135437,
-0.21660216152668,
-0.6760442852973938,
-0.16603368520736694,
-0.5263928174972534,
-0.4235614836215973,
0.6861373782157898,
0.17523513734340668,
-0.37506818771362305,
0.05657794326543808,
-0.4365549385547638,
0.5557878613471985,
0.5115422010421753,
0.24682720005512238,
0.09270118921995163,
-0.22248081862926483,
-0.5099659562110901,
0.5087097883224487,
-0.7895267605781555,
-0.3875744640827179,
1.0046335458755493,
0.06765887141227722,
0.4089582562446594,
-0.3179565370082855,
0.37357160449028015,
0.5623581409454346,
0.6012404561042786,
-0.6441722512245178,
0.7331649661064148,
0.1495930403470993,
-0.7269179224967957,
-0.3500995934009552,
-0.626197338104248,
-1.1582703590393066,
0.3146430253982544,
-0.23444750905036926,
-0.687020480632782,
0.1722046583890915,
0.22875133156776428,
-0.23964224755764008,
0.11214590817689896,
-0.4117012321949005,
1.1551594734191895,
-0.20106947422027588,
-0.34814247488975525,
-0.1890978366136551,
-0.9069539308547974,
0.028648747131228447,
-0.09204012155532837,
0.06428329646587372,
-0.19799716770648956,
0.05681241303682327,
0.4559098184108734,
-0.3989493250846863,
0.7392154335975647,
-0.20782490074634552,
0.1471003144979477,
0.26201897859573364,
0.12712576985359192,
0.6268801689147949,
-0.06431616097688675,
-0.034238871186971664,
0.40981370210647583,
0.36077484488487244,
-0.5810669660568237,
-0.5130137205123901,
0.22867847979068756,
-0.8136276006698608,
-0.27815911173820496,
-0.3493190407752991,
-0.6214556097984314,
-0.5263845920562744,
0.42846596240997314,
0.08308464288711548,
0.14636379480361938,
-0.3509150743484497,
0.3604084253311157,
0.4701010584831238,
-0.28630363941192627,
-0.17191213369369507,
0.7516984343528748,
-0.14203006029129028,
-0.5577880144119263,
1.0596147775650024,
-0.01781405135989189,
-0.0034035970456898212,
0.28442221879959106,
0.32765600085258484,
-0.27416130900382996,
-0.5945994853973389,
-0.3479185700416565,
0.3803660273551941,
-0.8206110000610352,
-0.19682440161705017,
-0.8506922721862793,
-0.33885499835014343,
-0.5834890007972717,
-0.22374913096427917,
-0.25636568665504456,
0.17638398706912994,
0.19325678050518036,
-0.19136789441108704,
0.20555025339126587,
0.5886155366897583,
-0.23290491104125977,
-0.08006779104471207,
-0.7959860563278198,
0.5462101697921753,
0.43536436557769775,
0.3766111135482788,
-0.17624740302562714,
0.08753211051225662,
-0.3681188225746155,
-0.001324232667684555,
-0.2640199065208435,
-0.9936155080795288,
0.009550686925649643,
-0.07983559370040894,
0.8539900779724121,
0.22129327058792114,
-0.07604476064443588,
0.23824936151504517,
-0.34634944796562195,
0.3441849946975708,
-0.2950161397457123,
-0.6607406735420227,
0.39041435718536377,
-0.29112035036087036,
0.22454175353050232,
0.7470702528953552,
0.3946218192577362,
-0.6638086438179016,
-0.5738971829414368,
-0.5677458047866821,
-0.7359656691551208,
0.49691060185432434,
0.3426249623298645,
-0.528313398361206,
0.26559972763061523,
0.4704398810863495,
0.17097388207912445,
0.4341142475605011,
-0.4842405319213867,
-0.14331577718257904,
-0.3303196430206299,
-0.31687861680984497,
-0.38797083497047424,
0.05201021581888199,
-0.24503830075263977,
-0.28139930963516235,
0.7981221675872803,
-0.5191298723220825,
0.22197949886322021,
0.3218311071395874,
-0.19404035806655884,
-0.06737858057022095,
0.04202478006482124,
0.25440308451652527,
0.7031025290489197,
-0.3867459297180176,
0.07689690589904785,
0.14031502604484558,
-0.6361064910888672,
0.20924517512321472,
0.5282862782478333,
-0.37608760595321655,
-0.19399499893188477,
0.6150267124176025,
0.4530051052570343,
-0.20608611404895782,
-1.0274617671966553,
0.07602601498365402,
0.213069349527359,
-0.22065572440624237,
0.20242449641227722,
0.11413360387086868,
0.14746937155723572,
0.4442799687385559,
0.27197664976119995,
0.03163749724626541,
0.25776585936546326,
-0.3992260992527008,
0.2649659216403961,
0.49899178743362427,
-0.3968336284160614,
-0.09210319072008133,
0.5419355034828186,
0.14669086039066315,
-0.09890808165073395,
0.6560536623001099,
-0.5763817429542542,
-0.5448392033576965,
1.1170361042022705,
-0.04219115152955055,
0.7823368906974792,
-0.1194959506392479,
0.5116753578186035,
0.2681727707386017,
0.46478280425071716,
0.25532591342926025,
0.13997383415699005,
-0.08721321076154709,
-0.8783228397369385,
-0.2025800198316574,
-0.5133443474769592,
-0.5654585361480713,
-0.01457529328763485,
-0.27757158875465393,
-0.1170102059841156,
-0.2527320384979248,
-0.03715824335813522,
0.37471631169319153,
0.17675308883190155,
-0.5532390475273132,
0.036246784031391144,
-0.24606803059577942,
0.6321529746055603,
-0.6598389148712158,
0.4888231158256531,
0.8937379717826843,
-0.2121751606464386,
-0.46083691716194153,
-0.19325552880764008,
0.014937950298190117,
-0.953150749206543,
0.6322934627532959,
0.10711110383272171,
0.005714259576052427,
0.023633424192667007,
-0.7301754355430603,
-0.4870203137397766,
1.2322133779525757,
0.3492908179759979,
-0.34264203906059265,
0.19264677166938782,
0.055096108466386795,
0.8727750182151794,
0.0745752602815628,
0.2370995283126831,
0.619408905506134,
0.7669675350189209,
-0.022111084312200546,
-0.5576086044311523,
0.1865876168012619,
-0.30554139614105225,
-0.3497017025947571,
0.09422198683023453,
-0.6641021966934204,
0.44157275557518005,
-0.10149415582418442,
-0.047979529947042465,
0.05292074382305145,
0.404213011264801,
0.4865952134132385,
0.8061487674713135,
0.4760623872280121,
0.4793519973754883,
1.0775660276412964,
-0.030718302354216576,
1.2235393524169922,
-0.40804383158683777,
0.2980763018131256,
0.643485426902771,
-0.5867350101470947,
0.19399438798427582,
0.1474778652191162,
-0.3541744649410248,
0.42174339294433594,
0.5722694396972656,
-0.4174880385398865,
0.43173834681510925,
0.2635270953178406,
-0.013459617272019386,
-0.2780217230319977,
-0.12793906033039093,
-0.34467747807502747,
0.2954483926296234,
0.07057909667491913,
-0.007694434840232134,
-0.22760389745235443,
0.045266956090927124,
-0.13081605732440948,
-0.1584368348121643,
-0.21412202715873718,
0.8309579491615295,
-0.14857614040374756,
-0.7194048166275024,
0.5084116458892822,
-0.29850172996520996,
-0.022636573761701584,
-0.7300708293914795,
-0.11904209107160568,
-0.3572380840778351,
0.16516825556755066,
0.06628201901912689,
-0.6503505110740662,
0.06144712492823601,
-0.2538270950317383,
-0.036239009350538254,
0.16848264634609222,
0.8199380040168762,
-0.2113274186849594,
-0.544468104839325,
0.3159155249595642,
0.6304169297218323,
0.34403225779533386,
0.03392308950424194,
-0.8673019409179688,
-0.26950299739837646,
-0.18192730844020844,
-0.041486721485853195,
0.14986523985862732,
0.40244048833847046,
0.18364377319812775,
0.8114181160926819,
0.48810651898384094,
0.17502138018608093,
-0.3706490397453308,
-0.2349991649389267,
0.6387996673583984,
-0.6951428651809692,
-0.4553864896297455,
-0.6499475240707397,
0.17206014692783356,
-0.1649579405784607,
-0.01139459852129221,
0.4702032804489136,
0.5499126315116882,
0.5442370772361755,
0.08590833097696304,
0.8601574301719666,
-0.08540218323469162,
0.5057640671730042,
-0.35915619134902954,
1.1386679410934448,
-0.5516135692596436,
-0.13173365592956543,
-0.09732573479413986,
-0.6553332805633545,
-0.014749676920473576,
0.5368453860282898,
-0.06831112504005432,
0.41456109285354614,
0.923017144203186,
0.8800389766693115,
0.31817641854286194,
-0.16412897408008575,
0.43265026807785034,
0.799680233001709,
0.4024774134159088,
0.33453401923179626,
0.7592662572860718,
-0.11623413860797882,
0.5084472894668579,
-0.18867789208889008,
-0.2656104862689972,
-0.25558358430862427,
-0.9302906394004822,
-1.045874834060669,
-0.3311713933944702,
-0.4406468868255615,
-0.7363408207893372,
0.4923468232154846,
0.6286236047744751,
0.6461808085441589,
-0.7983755469322205,
-0.0031173431780189276,
-0.19024519622325897,
0.40361514687538147,
-0.5254260301589966,
-0.13083088397979736,
0.5491892695426941,
-0.3511742949485779,
-0.30714672803878784,
0.38631224632263184,
0.24749067425727844,
0.03490174189209938,
-0.2269163876771927,
-0.13077960908412933,
-0.032017793506383896,
0.08844698965549469,
0.40305349230766296,
0.48689135909080505,
-0.3923819065093994,
-0.1396111696958542,
-0.06778843700885773,
-0.34602341055870056,
-0.009286816231906414,
0.7353768348693848,
-0.889677107334137,
0.5800207257270813,
0.47865304350852966,
1.0832438468933105,
0.3334611654281616,
-0.1506074219942093,
0.40183526277542114,
-0.3704584240913391,
-0.29107967019081116,
0.4397086799144745,
0.17402087152004242,
0.17936505377292633,
-0.44345495104789734,
0.8126111030578613,
0.6087932586669922,
-0.8706384301185608,
-0.8481786847114563,
-0.17454427480697632,
-0.9458665251731873,
-0.6033657193183899,
0.8691279292106628,
0.14754821360111237,
-0.37783294916152954,
-0.3341561555862427,
-0.19145868718624115,
0.26964467763900757,
-0.11733781546354294,
1.1577069759368896,
0.7867433428764343,
-0.19064727425575256,
0.32103458046913147,
-0.5943734645843506,
0.6006956696510315,
0.4464034140110016,
-1.114741563796997,
0.04904555901885033,
0.5174685120582581,
0.13614536821842194,
0.11992242187261581,
0.7372986078262329,
0.13241592049598694,
0.6297857165336609,
0.28913354873657227,
0.2944226861000061,
-0.21421806514263153,
-0.286381334066391,
0.043460696935653687,
0.07235652208328247,
-0.2161354422569275,
0.24442917108535767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00463v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00463v2 | Open-Source Conversational AI with SpeechBrain 1.0 | 2024-06-29T15:20:11 | 2024-07-02T12:53:10 | Mirco Ravanelli, Titouan Parcollet, Adel Moumen, Sylvain de Langen, Cem Subakan, Peter Plantinga, Yingzhi Wang, Pooneh Mousavi, Luca Della Libera, Artem Ploujnikov, Francesco Paissan, Davide Borra, Salah Zaiem, Zeyu Zhao, Shucong Zhang, Georgios Karakasidis, Sung-Lin Yeh, Aku Rouhe, Rudolf Braun, Florian Mai, Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Seyed Mahed Mousavi, Andreas Nautsch, Xuechen Liu, Sangeet Sagar, Jarod Duret, Salima Mdhaffar, Gaelle Laperriere, Renato De Mori, Yannick Esteve | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.AS | SpeechBrain is an open-source Conversational AI toolkit based on PyTorch,
focused particularly on speech processing tasks such as speech recognition,
speech enhancement, speaker recognition, text-to-speech, and much more. It
promotes transparency and replicability by releasing both the pre-trained
models and the complete "recipes" of code and algorithms required for training
them. This paper presents SpeechBrain 1.0, a significant milestone in the
evolution of the toolkit, which now has over 200 recipes for speech, audio, and
language processing tasks, and more than 100 models available on Hugging Face.
SpeechBrain 1.0 introduces new technologies to support diverse learning
modalities, Large Language Model (LLM) integration, and advanced decoding
strategies, along with novel models, tasks, and modalities. It also includes a
new benchmark repository, offering researchers a unified platform for
evaluating models across diverse tasks | [
-0.2294391393661499,
-0.7890403866767883,
-0.014481374993920326,
0.4995851516723633,
0.07753663510084152,
-0.1292344629764557,
-0.22821345925331116,
-0.48577234148979187,
0.3360588550567627,
0.39972543716430664,
-0.6692829728126526,
-0.6025918126106262,
-0.4175896942615509,
-0.4704582691192627,
-0.5468248128890991,
1.1138365268707275,
0.12300463020801544,
0.11522230505943298,
-0.2872958779335022,
-0.2211930751800537,
-0.4194067120552063,
-0.5009398460388184,
-0.7694427967071533,
-0.5765444040298462,
0.7980751991271973,
0.3371555209159851,
0.7033800482749939,
0.3202221095561981,
0.3533312678337097,
0.28011685609817505,
-0.22157223522663116,
-0.4649842381477356,
-0.4101731479167938,
0.07104214280843735,
-0.11300206929445267,
-0.2531026303768158,
-0.8384515643119812,
0.22892257571220398,
0.4020686447620392,
0.8630220293998718,
-0.3940846025943756,
0.310200035572052,
0.09915754199028015,
0.7064825892448425,
-0.5487396717071533,
0.39974290132522583,
-0.4587990939617157,
0.07746074348688126,
-0.07273314148187637,
0.22522090375423431,
-0.29961922764778137,
-0.6886810660362244,
0.4023127555847168,
-0.5224654674530029,
-0.06709268689155579,
-0.4928123950958252,
0.41051313281059265,
0.307669460773468,
0.09908284991979599,
-0.254626989364624,
-0.5359764099121094,
0.46871504187583923,
-0.6536499261856079,
0.5332613587379456,
0.3366389572620392,
0.5640856623649597,
-0.05456971377134323,
-1.0161525011062622,
-0.4560038447380066,
-0.35468828678131104,
0.14099428057670593,
-0.024349471554160118,
-0.6398520469665527,
0.2857659161090851,
0.02749282866716385,
0.38587766885757446,
-0.9040799736976624,
0.3488597869873047,
-0.3428798317909241,
-0.08479323983192444,
0.3465327024459839,
-0.27313748002052307,
0.25203046202659607,
-0.00012877598055638373,
-0.09400039166212082,
-0.11589855700731277,
-0.5753603577613831,
0.01881907880306244,
0.34052374958992004,
0.3754670023918152,
-0.2990960478782654,
0.35118991136550903,
-0.22855408489704132,
0.6640228629112244,
-0.33849036693573,
0.04892376810312271,
0.4345349967479706,
-0.29441043734550476,
-0.3107777237892151,
0.5643712878227234,
0.7689206600189209,
-0.22794127464294434,
0.32621392607688904,
-0.24829670786857605,
0.21627095341682434,
0.08725342899560928,
0.2871180772781372,
-0.747483491897583,
-0.5991466045379639,
0.5477316975593567,
-0.43814119696617126,
-0.48593848943710327,
-0.03835325688123703,
-0.4271172881126404,
-0.360463947057724,
-0.1512201875448227,
0.28957563638687134,
-0.4907280206680298,
-0.5779746770858765,
-0.10696803778409958,
-0.10407207906246185,
0.34098365902900696,
0.515995979309082,
-0.7322001457214355,
0.2776543200016022,
0.9771948456764221,
1.155281662940979,
-0.06200629100203514,
-0.40895602107048035,
-0.6701547503471375,
-0.3639134466648102,
-0.1545553058385849,
0.5710397362709045,
-0.435164213180542,
-0.34339842200279236,
-0.038683075457811356,
-0.0440526120364666,
0.2284800112247467,
-0.6833409070968628,
0.350143164396286,
-0.21924830973148346,
0.13690230250358582,
0.12168826907873154,
-0.4412580132484436,
-0.23298875987529755,
0.016559356823563576,
-0.7608997225761414,
0.8409985303878784,
0.28572767972946167,
-0.5385676622390747,
-0.010943721979856491,
-0.9775465726852417,
-0.4463616609573364,
0.2458336055278778,
-0.08406908065080643,
-0.20399264991283417,
-0.001967590069398284,
0.20848701894283295,
0.19959193468093872,
-0.1093560978770256,
0.12660156190395355,
-0.2255723625421524,
-0.2969905436038971,
0.3078845143318176,
-0.2541949152946472,
1.2185249328613281,
0.35837969183921814,
-0.27146705985069275,
0.5078825950622559,
-0.5691195130348206,
0.158447265625,
0.07900798320770264,
-0.23177875578403473,
0.1819087117910385,
-0.05274200439453125,
0.2552344501018524,
0.03820065036416054,
0.40362557768821716,
-0.60392826795578,
0.08132395148277283,
-0.6415538191795349,
0.6120384335517883,
0.7474941611289978,
-0.3866324722766876,
0.4226047098636627,
-0.2721022963523865,
0.6019425392150879,
0.09058323502540588,
0.1632549911737442,
-0.8478246927261353,
-0.6717069745063782,
-0.540719211101532,
-0.37165066599845886,
0.4625272750854492,
0.900139570236206,
-0.3651195168495178,
0.6510286331176758,
-0.3879546821117401,
-0.7894753217697144,
-0.9267938137054443,
0.1302146166563034,
0.40521296858787537,
0.3807174861431122,
0.09536849707365036,
-0.3836963474750519,
-0.544556736946106,
-0.8620370030403137,
-0.016219619661569595,
-0.24586428701877594,
-0.24453438818454742,
0.19551163911819458,
0.29745903611183167,
-0.12459944933652878,
0.9625335931777954,
0.038700710982084274,
-0.17217808961868286,
-0.3315991163253784,
0.2176433652639389,
0.157474085688591,
0.7537631988525391,
0.5442551374435425,
-0.660315752029419,
-0.28876686096191406,
0.2034110575914383,
-0.8704870343208313,
0.01920521818101406,
0.27220359444618225,
0.09224490821361542,
0.2773391306400299,
0.4774160087108612,
-0.5363538265228271,
0.41323909163475037,
0.7959029674530029,
-0.02871660701930523,
0.2827262878417969,
0.1923540234565735,
-0.025588365271687508,
-1.161185383796692,
0.3474383056163788,
-0.02848701924085617,
-0.3757823705673218,
-0.7250491976737976,
-0.1045888364315033,
-0.1582886278629303,
-0.42911556363105774,
-0.7361401319503784,
0.64790278673172,
0.1383965164422989,
-0.11863379925489426,
-0.1783488243818283,
0.41923779249191284,
-0.3655183017253876,
0.3763771653175354,
-0.22174206376075745,
0.841943085193634,
0.8658139705657959,
-0.37617260217666626,
0.8122230172157288,
0.49458470940589905,
-0.345645546913147,
0.46740877628326416,
-0.9556905627250671,
0.41414567828178406,
-0.011618097312748432,
0.23703500628471375,
-0.769070565700531,
-0.18350860476493835,
0.4436704218387604,
-0.8360759019851685,
-0.0733710378408432,
-0.22226357460021973,
-0.2629179060459137,
-0.19987423717975616,
-0.08125070482492447,
0.3822430670261383,
0.642367422580719,
-0.7509868144989014,
0.6132622957229614,
0.5317506194114685,
-0.6215848326683044,
-0.33498597145080566,
-0.6230196952819824,
0.1394675374031067,
0.2955706715583801,
-0.6212485432624817,
0.15098464488983154,
-0.12667663395404816,
-0.3314887285232544,
0.012784237042069435,
0.024856066331267357,
-0.09405682235956192,
-0.05772596597671509,
0.48828768730163574,
0.08536799997091293,
-0.28006699681282043,
0.07681035995483398,
0.05621419474482536,
-0.09683933854103088,
0.014778729528188705,
-0.5601314902305603,
0.5898274183273315,
-0.16801343858242035,
-0.16401155292987823,
-0.6943371891975403,
0.237674281001091,
0.38230422139167786,
-0.4721052944660187,
0.4121716618537903,
0.5497297048568726,
-0.37407779693603516,
-0.11349832266569138,
-0.39102211594581604,
-0.03284306451678276,
-0.4685419797897339,
0.5193723440170288,
-0.2125665843486786,
-0.9149497151374817,
0.3850945830345154,
-0.13009274005889893,
0.07665947824716568,
-0.0010450426489114761,
0.5351775288581848,
-0.004494384862482548,
0.8986515998840332,
0.44997596740722656,
-0.5284671783447266,
0.8465700149536133,
0.029792921617627144,
0.059933461248874664,
-0.33840757608413696,
-0.32584109902381897,
-0.5649806261062622,
-0.30707064270973206,
-0.6141769886016846,
-0.26266342401504517,
0.3013537526130676,
-0.21864540874958038,
-0.22878475487232208,
0.540302574634552,
-0.7643542885780334,
0.591495931148529,
0.9528399705886841,
0.32338976860046387,
0.01283885445445776,
0.07129830121994019,
0.23492461442947388,
0.37890079617500305,
-0.7604736685752869,
-0.32776668667793274,
1.0137865543365479,
0.5968752503395081,
0.561234712600708,
-0.06342029571533203,
0.5117500424385071,
0.32997265458106995,
0.11924175173044205,
-0.8007063865661621,
0.6345667243003845,
-0.06967237591743469,
-0.5907748341560364,
-0.19371163845062256,
-0.49526068568229675,
-0.9420889019966125,
-0.24693456292152405,
-0.0038508595898747444,
-1.0267348289489746,
-0.23322872817516327,
0.19664859771728516,
-0.06640654802322388,
0.07694029062986374,
-0.7712491750717163,
1.3101016283035278,
-0.3008999526500702,
-0.20110701024532318,
-0.41577649116516113,
-0.6492794156074524,
0.05144520476460457,
0.2779332399368286,
-0.22475303709506989,
-0.02805309183895588,
0.4516514241695404,
0.6936965584754944,
-0.0858495756983757,
0.6967735886573792,
-0.4438990354537964,
-0.011176830157637596,
0.41374361515045166,
0.33246204257011414,
0.3699986934661865,
-0.11263372749090195,
-0.12378612905740738,
0.6624448299407959,
0.206846222281456,
-0.5818288922309875,
-0.6077483892440796,
0.7865490913391113,
-0.6906360983848572,
-0.31376373767852783,
-0.2951916456222534,
-0.4323960542678833,
-0.038561150431632996,
0.10887906700372696,
-0.05878932401537895,
0.30703336000442505,
-0.6974619626998901,
0.29816779494285583,
0.7137914299964905,
-0.43732136487960815,
0.16059637069702148,
0.19993828237056732,
-0.5334054231643677,
-0.5572583675384521,
0.9683281779289246,
-0.25058913230895996,
0.06776085495948792,
0.22765865921974182,
0.0014490623725578189,
0.16424307227134705,
-0.33708858489990234,
-0.27878665924072266,
-0.004563957452774048,
-0.7192140817642212,
0.16530263423919678,
-0.4712563753128052,
-0.4144686758518219,
-0.7439869046211243,
-0.08262071758508682,
-0.6373366713523865,
-0.3868861496448517,
-0.019274435937404633,
-0.035005491226911545,
0.28641369938850403,
0.7590563297271729,
0.09223920106887817,
0.5253246426582336,
-0.6368427276611328,
0.16016466915607452,
0.47421690821647644,
0.4890376627445221,
-0.20359200239181519,
-0.33123621344566345,
-0.4289742112159729,
0.22143153846263885,
-0.29433387517929077,
-0.7399020791053772,
0.08247534930706024,
0.0643230527639389,
0.5403562188148499,
0.3329125642776489,
-0.48023587465286255,
0.20972652733325958,
-0.36967986822128296,
0.829414427280426,
0.3585576117038727,
-1.001753330230713,
0.943396806716919,
-0.366406112909317,
0.5972425937652588,
0.4169938266277313,
0.4011174738407135,
-0.5684787631034851,
-0.10838346928358078,
-0.37939146161079407,
-0.6362156867980957,
0.9622268080711365,
0.4214555323123932,
0.0943303257226944,
0.21588701009750366,
0.3539164066314697,
0.3137575089931488,
0.44216763973236084,
-0.5413759350776672,
-0.3107868731021881,
-0.7891526222229004,
-0.5006077289581299,
-0.13515953719615936,
0.10414472222328186,
-0.11776093393564224,
-0.5135278701782227,
0.6963732242584229,
-0.11976222693920135,
0.5003432035446167,
0.05827568471431732,
-0.10883691161870956,
0.06290332227945328,
0.11942406743764877,
0.4652165472507477,
0.5478755235671997,
-0.26779282093048096,
-0.1619434803724289,
0.042632754892110825,
-0.43758389353752136,
-0.16969887912273407,
0.5629002451896667,
0.004167784471064806,
0.005932738073170185,
0.1548786759376526,
1.0483375787734985,
0.15332327783107758,
-0.8632196187973022,
0.36167609691619873,
0.03622515872120857,
-0.2122771143913269,
-0.5466709136962891,
0.28112876415252686,
0.09756757318973541,
0.4993273615837097,
0.10012533515691757,
-0.18938221037387848,
0.000578511506319046,
-0.6325815916061401,
0.2703711688518524,
0.3843764364719391,
-0.5933078527450562,
-0.47513633966445923,
0.553290069103241,
0.2722874879837036,
-0.7268383502960205,
0.745728611946106,
-0.08955062180757523,
-0.36374804377555847,
0.5227859020233154,
0.32228824496269226,
1.1381996870040894,
-0.29263532161712646,
0.4240264892578125,
0.44011011719703674,
0.20782522857189178,
0.15471398830413818,
0.0472104474902153,
-0.495283842086792,
-0.4390197992324829,
-0.07381221652030945,
-0.5423659682273865,
-0.788264811038971,
0.09479687362909317,
-0.2816341817378998,
0.3240235447883606,
-0.458098828792572,
0.008344583213329315,
0.351518452167511,
-0.4255225360393524,
-0.4569603204727173,
0.03874848037958145,
0.4239792227745056,
0.9633187651634216,
-0.2737032473087311,
1.029173493385315,
0.8085923194885254,
-0.5119897127151489,
-0.44277891516685486,
-0.25975990295410156,
0.05677781254053116,
-0.5883573293685913,
0.49038422107696533,
0.16862885653972626,
-0.03244901821017265,
0.09965195506811142,
-0.8136916756629944,
-0.5565091371536255,
0.9681003093719482,
0.6275070309638977,
-0.5278432369232178,
-0.43326127529144287,
0.2876674234867096,
0.44563499093055725,
-0.36306872963905334,
0.30874061584472656,
0.5445475578308105,
0.3153064548969269,
0.14229288697242737,
-1.3669415712356567,
-0.294247031211853,
-0.5276187658309937,
-0.14495351910591125,
0.07632322609424591,
-0.30622583627700806,
0.7662685513496399,
0.2153196483850479,
-0.01799970492720604,
0.18991975486278534,
0.5850813984870911,
-0.024179980158805847,
0.37721091508865356,
0.3220030963420868,
0.4998067021369934,
0.5913439393043518,
-0.21599861979484558,
0.7779953479766846,
-0.36870715022087097,
-0.024727877229452133,
1.3353906869888306,
-0.21137671172618866,
0.7773529291152954,
0.22919073700904846,
-0.2699600160121918,
0.5764599442481995,
0.41078829765319824,
0.014319214038550854,
0.1671144664287567,
-0.023047903552651405,
-0.39338070154190063,
0.028320670127868652,
-0.17085804045200348,
-0.20103655755519867,
0.6712795495986938,
0.1948959082365036,
-0.32422924041748047,
-0.1951969712972641,
0.26830559968948364,
0.09976876527070999,
-0.14277945458889008,
-0.3075289726257324,
1.0754872560501099,
0.004586693365126848,
-0.7082434296607971,
0.5920504927635193,
-0.38413891196250916,
0.4580063819885254,
-0.8107057809829712,
-0.09057607501745224,
-0.0710410475730896,
0.2084496170282364,
-0.12845395505428314,
-0.7267318367958069,
0.16119545698165894,
0.029882332310080528,
0.06402918696403503,
-0.14664462208747864,
0.8300387859344482,
-0.35736361145973206,
-0.2482505738735199,
0.34395191073417664,
0.5320848226547241,
0.30013763904571533,
-0.46151673793792725,
-0.8994634747505188,
0.27063536643981934,
-0.26000896096229553,
-0.19759440422058105,
0.26024141907691956,
0.07435476779937744,
0.4265449047088623,
0.6715894341468811,
0.4533100724220276,
0.1040293276309967,
0.00903292465955019,
0.1321363002061844,
0.994852602481842,
-0.6113206148147583,
-0.5442662239074707,
-0.470584511756897,
0.5546586513519287,
0.020477239042520523,
-0.3003292679786682,
0.5904009342193604,
0.5202987194061279,
0.983989417552948,
0.15626055002212524,
0.8933832049369812,
-0.15561890602111816,
0.5334428548812866,
-0.18945012986660004,
0.8067725300788879,
-0.4828870892524719,
-0.09735327214002609,
-0.2501460611820221,
-0.9206169247627258,
-0.19171085953712463,
0.6470917463302612,
-0.11223240196704865,
0.22711224853992462,
0.44874313473701477,
0.9376222491264343,
-0.024536125361919403,
0.32253268361091614,
0.24527108669281006,
0.15228760242462158,
0.20517227053642273,
0.32436469197273254,
0.4817711114883423,
-0.4261077642440796,
0.6106941103935242,
-0.3946138918399811,
-0.47405877709388733,
-0.13121840357780457,
-0.44125375151634216,
-0.8474396467208862,
-0.811909556388855,
-0.41590166091918945,
-0.5173979997634888,
0.3799072802066803,
1.3319603204727173,
1.0216814279556274,
-0.9062522053718567,
-0.4298132658004761,
-0.43347302079200745,
-0.044141244143247604,
-0.25698110461235046,
-0.24005870521068573,
-0.1629100739955902,
-0.3067881762981415,
-0.8580480813980103,
0.7130743265151978,
0.3252403140068054,
-0.29777640104293823,
-0.48669859766960144,
-0.24936480820178986,
-0.18836884200572968,
0.14776477217674255,
0.5463876724243164,
0.6042793393135071,
-0.543944776058197,
-0.04908306896686554,
-0.13726301491260529,
0.06277578324079514,
0.3409053385257721,
0.7153216004371643,
-1.0890673398971558,
0.6978979110717773,
0.4147304594516754,
0.5981860756874084,
0.5312162041664124,
-0.23432612419128418,
0.3769994378089905,
-0.6822289824485779,
0.5759263038635254,
0.419279545545578,
0.004282538313418627,
0.3844135105609894,
0.1326073408126831,
0.4599737524986267,
-0.009114738553762436,
-0.7745548486709595,
-0.8606952428817749,
0.27300122380256653,
-1.1812244653701782,
-0.17288388311862946,
0.7022054195404053,
-0.19189617037773132,
-0.38999807834625244,
0.30761659145355225,
-0.36352789402008057,
0.6010531187057495,
-0.42920947074890137,
0.6498962044715881,
0.5121948719024658,
-0.030205294489860535,
-0.40878191590309143,
-0.4975610077381134,
0.35750389099121094,
0.43299975991249084,
-0.9185161590576172,
0.10533509403467178,
0.4370703399181366,
-0.0028911184053868055,
0.2096436470746994,
0.4836972951889038,
-0.1970134973526001,
0.5433493852615356,
0.2327800840139389,
0.5017478466033936,
-0.22435802221298218,
-0.4428364038467407,
-0.6235588192939758,
0.1595928966999054,
0.01081333588808775,
-0.2374059110879898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00455v1 | Polarization and Morality: Lexical Analysis of Abortion Discourse on Reddit | 2024-06-29T14:50:55 | 2024-06-29T14:50:55 | Tessa Stanier, Hagyeong Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | This study investigates whether division on political topics is mapped with
the distinctive patterns of language use. We collect a total 145,832 Reddit
comments on the abortion debate and explore the languages of subreddit
communities r/prolife and r/prochoice. With consideration of the Moral
Foundations Theory, we examine lexical patterns in three ways. First, we
compute proportional frequencies of lexical items from the Moral Foundations
Dictionary in order to make inferences about each group's moral considerations
when forming arguments for and against abortion. We then create n-gram models
to reveal frequent collocations from each stance group and better understand
how commonly used words are patterned in their linguistic context and in
relation to morality values. Finally, we use Latent Dirichlet Allocation to
identify underlying topical structures in the corpus data. Results show that
the use of morality words is mapped with the stances on abortion. | [
-0.5840889811515808,
-0.8854599595069885,
0.7123729586601257,
0.14949946105480194,
-0.8215619325637817,
-0.2633034288883209,
-0.11518316715955734,
-0.050688549876213074,
0.4020808935165405,
0.5906392931938171,
-0.400301069021225,
-0.5700598359107971,
-0.6331863403320312,
0.15592560172080994,
-0.4787214994430542,
1.0347744226455688,
0.5627496242523193,
0.6414898037910461,
-0.19894683361053467,
-0.4299978017807007,
-0.04825124517083168,
-0.7244071364402771,
-0.6131676435470581,
0.04372187331318855,
0.6475856304168701,
0.32230404019355774,
0.8469935655593872,
0.8439064621925354,
0.5400669574737549,
0.30090317130088806,
-0.4078311622142792,
-0.5438738465309143,
-0.47031137347221375,
0.07885241508483887,
-0.4364983141422272,
-0.4240685701370239,
-0.3469295799732208,
0.41078266501426697,
0.3792644441127777,
0.7403531074523926,
-0.21826113760471344,
0.09613446146249771,
-0.23284880816936493,
0.7162309288978577,
-0.5581859946250916,
-0.2050095945596695,
-0.5415724515914917,
0.11491358280181885,
-0.14873020350933075,
-0.1490880399942398,
-0.0754140093922615,
-0.8171994090080261,
0.18232321739196777,
-0.5215582847595215,
0.2862410545349121,
0.00866770651191473,
0.5443316102027893,
-0.09536634385585785,
-0.423356294631958,
-0.7269781231880188,
-0.3038907051086426,
1.3754945993423462,
-0.6632108688354492,
0.45698705315589905,
0.5375140905380249,
-0.42004406452178955,
0.044597357511520386,
-0.47442546486854553,
-0.5468862056732178,
-0.06581997871398926,
-0.22896383702754974,
0.056791502982378006,
-0.09710676968097687,
0.17727984488010406,
0.0694485679268837,
0.4158541262149811,
-0.14643947780132294,
-0.11759215593338013,
-0.19690850377082825,
0.019030608236789703,
0.6152719855308533,
-0.04700157418847084,
0.6164076924324036,
-0.3540067672729492,
-0.20236477255821228,
0.11959707736968994,
-0.25505372881889343,
0.13273464143276215,
0.8852916955947876,
0.2450665533542633,
-0.11575432866811752,
0.7868541479110718,
0.3993176221847534,
0.6500007510185242,
0.32869967818260193,
-0.18885114789009094,
0.19886958599090576,
-0.611170768737793,
-0.03965834528207779,
0.04162510111927986,
0.7995985150337219,
0.7940661311149597,
0.6148262023925781,
0.3989238440990448,
0.1943930983543396,
-0.021318232640624046,
0.5616942048072815,
-0.7238088846206665,
0.14959190785884857,
0.3281639814376831,
-0.8296263217926025,
-0.4975031912326813,
-0.05859922617673874,
-0.9227371215820312,
-0.7366877198219299,
-0.30442148447036743,
-0.38429731130599976,
-0.2956995964050293,
-0.19968900084495544,
0.3107108771800995,
-0.17638257145881653,
0.3604552149772644,
0.1174602210521698,
-0.7636731266975403,
0.15043987333774567,
1.0957165956497192,
0.8084931969642639,
-0.04801936075091362,
0.1013331264257431,
-0.281865656375885,
-0.33800941705703735,
-0.5858220458030701,
0.7924594283103943,
-0.8213632106781006,
-0.5798541903495789,
0.2150001972913742,
0.26532208919525146,
0.3357929289340973,
-0.47592756152153015,
0.9073068499565125,
-0.4999418556690216,
0.14853009581565857,
-0.6363947987556458,
-0.7972784042358398,
-0.49022993445396423,
0.09367196261882782,
-0.5467959642410278,
0.32928940653800964,
-0.3681119680404663,
-1.0916718244552612,
0.5314850211143494,
-0.5376080870628357,
-0.41786667704582214,
0.010893411003053188,
-0.48597967624664307,
-0.5188751220703125,
0.31788623332977295,
-0.310344934463501,
0.35752183198928833,
-0.3558243215084076,
0.45121070742607117,
-0.08695372194051743,
0.0026231829542666674,
0.2908066511154175,
0.15196825563907623,
1.0801444053649902,
-0.06798731535673141,
-0.17715509235858917,
0.14246505498886108,
-0.5288079977035522,
-0.18391378223896027,
0.06119342893362045,
-0.17826582491397858,
-0.6781480312347412,
0.6526340246200562,
-0.10450543463230133,
-0.11963554471731186,
0.030618511140346527,
-0.7338659167289734,
-0.012173879891633987,
-0.5821981430053711,
0.4911349415779114,
0.4329932630062103,
0.24424676597118378,
0.7047470808029175,
-0.31272828578948975,
0.5510496497154236,
0.18170127272605896,
0.5158113241195679,
0.4790886342525482,
-0.8741213083267212,
-0.6833835244178772,
-0.054365821182727814,
-0.20131096243858337,
0.5999035239219666,
0.04010293260216713,
0.44531792402267456,
0.2777066230773926,
-0.06688950955867767,
-0.32182297110557556,
-0.18819940090179443,
0.40742966532707214,
0.4243137538433075,
0.6157202124595642,
-0.4028593897819519,
-0.6101136803627014,
-1.2905302047729492,
-0.4038766026496887,
-0.38632285594940186,
0.38270896673202515,
0.27938175201416016,
0.3678070604801178,
0.04014763608574867,
0.9373584985733032,
-0.30139195919036865,
-0.17607572674751282,
-0.11579572409391403,
0.5763109922409058,
0.25388461351394653,
0.20562288165092468,
0.8410302400588989,
-1.0983798503875732,
-0.2842010259628296,
0.06948001682758331,
-0.37446266412734985,
-0.24851161241531372,
0.2121618092060089,
-0.2817389667034149,
-0.12705181539058685,
0.4384572505950928,
-0.04123795032501221,
0.4382067322731018,
0.5552669763565063,
-0.5992942452430725,
0.41941094398498535,
0.33981195092201233,
0.2339916229248047,
-1.1480655670166016,
-0.33858224749565125,
-0.14529910683631897,
-0.0032903889659792185,
-0.7010992765426636,
-0.16134996712207794,
-0.1538550704717636,
0.25627532601356506,
-0.8203322291374207,
0.13206979632377625,
-0.09677867591381073,
-0.13096073269844055,
-0.20538246631622314,
0.2698442339897156,
-0.2932950556278229,
-0.11319789290428162,
-0.027358653023838997,
0.9225510954856873,
0.4290509521961212,
-0.376207172870636,
0.22784633934497833,
0.27640634775161743,
-0.18921811878681183,
0.3872661888599396,
-0.4725392162799835,
-0.17045724391937256,
-0.40392541885375977,
-0.007008636835962534,
-0.7618770599365234,
-0.13460825383663177,
0.24181951582431793,
-0.11333251744508743,
-0.5867233276367188,
-0.5393058061599731,
-0.05714423581957817,
0.018609514459967613,
-0.48612290620803833,
0.6259117722511292,
0.4179497957229614,
0.24270017445087433,
0.362773597240448,
0.8824732899665833,
-0.1998080462217331,
-0.9055860638618469,
-0.6670699715614319,
-0.3023720383644104,
-0.37630918622016907,
-0.34082329273223877,
0.20376405119895935,
0.135580375790596,
-1.0138769149780273,
0.18564702570438385,
0.31390029191970825,
-0.12962770462036133,
0.008646471425890923,
0.2554682493209839,
-0.14287380874156952,
-0.13005346059799194,
0.22828254103660583,
0.10030058771371841,
-0.0349251814186573,
0.1477099359035492,
-0.021006591618061066,
0.876683235168457,
-0.3497302830219269,
-0.11169151961803436,
-0.3462565243244171,
0.6696286201477051,
0.6032754778862,
-0.033535461872816086,
0.8599579930305481,
0.10229713469743729,
-0.19272509217262268,
0.08171161264181137,
-0.47873491048812866,
-0.20188869535923004,
-0.4116739332675934,
0.03671397641301155,
0.25440165400505066,
-0.8708120584487915,
0.694667398929596,
0.17936241626739502,
0.3113724887371063,
0.3755129873752594,
0.736452579498291,
-0.21751350164413452,
0.7579317092895508,
0.4984738528728485,
0.29583215713500977,
0.5982142686843872,
-0.1459299921989441,
0.5199710726737976,
-0.4571152627468109,
0.17088153958320618,
-0.4342581331729889,
-0.1449408233165741,
-0.8021233081817627,
-0.6404080986976624,
0.010258522816002369,
0.32903847098350525,
-0.20006948709487915,
0.15743929147720337,
-0.6020141243934631,
0.7310736179351807,
0.16691234707832336,
-0.2686525285243988,
0.32225435972213745,
0.11249198019504547,
-0.26762282848358154,
-0.4923701286315918,
-0.2489863485097885,
-0.6973434090614319,
0.7470883727073669,
-0.003414168721064925,
0.36408957839012146,
0.13070298731327057,
0.613487958908081,
0.2828599512577057,
0.3935048282146454,
-1.024743914604187,
0.7969620823860168,
-0.7409191727638245,
-0.6033808588981628,
0.0838354080915451,
-0.14169368147850037,
-0.7699944972991943,
0.21594341099262238,
-0.15865358710289001,
-0.4828382134437561,
0.6773452758789062,
-0.09501925110816956,
-0.3529549539089203,
0.3112851679325104,
-0.4900435209274292,
0.5182536244392395,
-0.24398259818553925,
-0.3173527419567108,
-0.393235445022583,
-0.5250333547592163,
-0.0321226641535759,
0.11591536551713943,
0.5364195108413696,
-0.3841577470302582,
-0.23423807322978973,
0.9513566493988037,
-0.3674986958503723,
0.8105121850967407,
0.10506721585988998,
-0.3058589696884155,
0.5730108022689819,
-0.06820926070213318,
-0.13878047466278076,
0.3601038455963135,
-0.23146818578243256,
0.2957494258880615,
0.0011119077680632472,
-0.21154865622520447,
-0.07062441110610962,
0.635104238986969,
-0.7145624756813049,
-0.6667168140411377,
-0.5816767811775208,
-0.24596865475177765,
0.00011379701027181,
0.31865471601486206,
0.35247838497161865,
0.28784123063087463,
-0.24285683035850525,
0.43470221757888794,
0.3890143930912018,
-0.4020918011665344,
0.5195126533508301,
0.34417304396629333,
-0.3992805480957031,
-0.6649234890937805,
0.4129725992679596,
0.31447991728782654,
0.16954194009304047,
-0.05765286833047867,
0.6430118083953857,
-0.2983553111553192,
-0.3425912857055664,
-0.12312865257263184,
0.5015749931335449,
-0.6845096349716187,
0.009975695982575417,
-0.78809654712677,
-0.07934655249118805,
-0.18129663169384003,
-0.63451087474823,
-0.7127717733383179,
-0.31414395570755005,
-0.3783610463142395,
-0.10568052530288696,
0.4657931923866272,
0.7170712947845459,
-0.13262316584587097,
0.18345825374126434,
-0.3697325885295868,
0.22488808631896973,
0.3148901164531708,
0.1590416431427002,
-0.4762549102306366,
-0.15181681513786316,
0.41625967621803284,
-0.10856698453426361,
-0.044005151838064194,
-1.322426199913025,
0.06926633417606354,
-0.0716152936220169,
0.2386229783296585,
0.6102532148361206,
0.11258016526699066,
0.6161544919013977,
-0.4162704348564148,
1.0030816793441772,
0.18147258460521698,
-0.9372819662094116,
0.5825551152229309,
-0.5909405946731567,
-0.1993582546710968,
0.5969716310501099,
0.6627044081687927,
-0.5064900517463684,
-0.6234889030456543,
-0.6426575779914856,
-0.7804867625236511,
0.3397870659828186,
0.327238529920578,
0.3557480275630951,
-0.38426169753074646,
0.7852264642715454,
0.06121470406651497,
0.34718313813209534,
-0.7081043720245361,
-0.28325173258781433,
-0.18175610899925232,
-0.2108791619539261,
0.2440503090620041,
-0.7145361304283142,
-0.6636950373649597,
-0.32844653725624084,
0.32222920656204224,
-0.11424587666988373,
0.2139616757631302,
0.23555894196033478,
0.20608963072299957,
-0.08153922110795975,
0.34994664788246155,
0.7508136630058289,
1.0244271755218506,
0.09642907977104187,
0.22596973180770874,
-0.2015957236289978,
-0.8616832494735718,
0.2585291564464569,
-0.4418233633041382,
-0.21961015462875366,
-0.004937442485243082,
0.5353068709373474,
0.2927815616130829,
0.18134279549121857,
-0.34958121180534363,
0.6685975193977356,
-0.26899805665016174,
-0.2668570876121521,
-0.5946319699287415,
-0.14775773882865906,
0.39100807905197144,
0.2639087438583374,
0.07264872640371323,
-0.27503591775894165,
0.12322451919317245,
-0.7943270802497864,
0.33070793747901917,
0.47434890270233154,
-0.37465333938598633,
-0.30203619599342346,
0.27645817399024963,
0.03379647061228752,
-0.3649744987487793,
0.3324861228466034,
-0.08713126182556152,
-0.6543260812759399,
0.8092864155769348,
0.27010658383369446,
0.8462497591972351,
-0.24345825612545013,
0.5340785980224609,
0.589089035987854,
0.12371674925088882,
-0.043099548667669296,
0.6809108257293701,
0.23870126903057098,
-1.0039784908294678,
-0.2897835075855255,
-0.9662706255912781,
-0.20926637947559357,
-0.013661820441484451,
-0.6765609383583069,
0.3580149710178375,
-0.7606496214866638,
-0.5760800242424011,
0.10757323354482651,
-0.1029033437371254,
0.16172902286052704,
0.05040624365210533,
0.029005007818341255,
0.2325274795293808,
-0.8135195374488831,
0.3903558850288391,
0.830660879611969,
-0.42243632674217224,
-0.2794174253940582,
0.3105042278766632,
0.011548083275556564,
-0.516509473323822,
0.29355400800704956,
-0.017224939540028572,
-0.6631472110748291,
-0.02016502246260643,
-0.6812677383422852,
-0.6675013303756714,
0.6240067481994629,
0.15438932180404663,
-0.4811841547489166,
0.2815944254398346,
0.18398451805114746,
0.6345904469490051,
-0.5930997133255005,
-0.13505975902080536,
0.328034371137619,
0.41198793053627014,
-0.26978781819343567,
-0.2645970284938812,
-0.14220884442329407,
-0.017686590552330017,
-0.025189323350787163,
0.35500022768974304,
-0.6221352219581604,
1.2197412252426147,
-0.12200397998094559,
-0.5014757513999939,
-0.138021782040596,
0.2482222318649292,
0.01990288496017456,
0.061522532254457474,
0.771173894405365,
0.40811800956726074,
0.2471238672733307,
-0.046978067606687546,
0.7529476284980774,
-0.59129798412323,
0.7970860004425049,
0.6708226799964905,
0.035853154957294464,
0.5806142091751099,
0.7607301473617554,
0.029371360316872597,
0.5293949842453003,
0.331461638212204,
0.26319074630737305,
0.4446764588356018,
0.19212040305137634,
-0.2561017870903015,
-0.5068830847740173,
-0.6074715256690979,
-0.2134430855512619,
0.4619889259338379,
0.5243343114852905,
-0.5287256836891174,
-0.27300411462783813,
0.07228973507881165,
0.31277501583099365,
0.28155726194381714,
-0.031663790345191956,
1.0192605257034302,
0.21548736095428467,
-0.47685950994491577,
0.184649258852005,
-0.047975052148103714,
0.2637627422809601,
-0.20474182069301605,
-0.022968849167227745,
-0.20188428461551666,
0.08131192624568939,
-0.2972204089164734,
-1.1239153146743774,
0.6251183748245239,
0.23534446954727173,
-0.04740315303206444,
-0.3751986026763916,
0.6972866654396057,
-0.12289589643478394,
-0.43895164132118225,
0.7707587480545044,
0.5114026069641113,
-0.04448598250746727,
0.4882655739784241,
-0.8370498418807983,
0.08981478214263916,
-0.019021322950720787,
-0.3986128866672516,
0.032173238694667816,
0.25015735626220703,
-0.2973468601703644,
0.5419836640357971,
0.8262977004051208,
0.018765684217214584,
0.2868185043334961,
0.26243501901626587,
0.8392435908317566,
-0.7755715250968933,
-0.5652895569801331,
-0.9211595058441162,
0.44146329164505005,
-0.17593955993652344,
-0.6187013387680054,
0.5300835967063904,
0.3729180693626404,
0.6771242618560791,
0.21793189644813538,
0.44861316680908203,
-0.3558233380317688,
0.3357831835746765,
-0.40457653999328613,
0.8143606185913086,
-0.7788906097412109,
-0.16498441994190216,
-0.1618088036775589,
-0.7074744701385498,
-0.65712571144104,
1.1336677074432373,
-0.6676285266876221,
-0.022416099905967712,
0.7351183891296387,
0.6213348507881165,
-0.15422865748405457,
0.3570401668548584,
0.17047883570194244,
0.30481743812561035,
0.029411498457193375,
-0.241485595703125,
1.0754283666610718,
-0.13296987116336823,
0.0885489284992218,
-0.6342821717262268,
-0.09376019984483719,
-0.3249273896217346,
-0.8224581480026245,
-0.6722638010978699,
-0.7599656581878662,
-0.35270556807518005,
-0.3358168601989746,
-0.02275555580854416,
0.7361394166946411,
0.5040757060050964,
-0.9441062808036804,
-0.44888177514076233,
-0.7042720913887024,
0.28063660860061646,
-0.08029539883136749,
-0.26611363887786865,
0.04268506169319153,
-0.1760093867778778,
-0.7462115287780762,
0.04252174496650696,
0.2452203929424286,
-0.1988665908575058,
-0.19568215310573578,
0.42798811197280884,
-0.655986487865448,
0.5274970531463623,
0.6254587173461914,
-0.05920645594596863,
-0.9514763355255127,
-0.6291666626930237,
-0.1382053792476654,
-0.1649060696363449,
0.06431890279054642,
1.262040615081787,
-0.02836294285953045,
0.30846017599105835,
0.8698244094848633,
0.14353296160697937,
-0.3137367069721222,
0.5796464681625366,
0.5041049718856812,
-0.34856876730918884,
0.5404446125030518,
0.6590221524238586,
0.33801549673080444,
0.172746941447258,
-0.2511047124862671,
0.4575169086456299,
0.5035451650619507,
-0.5950899720191956,
-0.5142070055007935,
0.765446662902832,
-0.8437594771385193,
-0.26446452736854553,
1.2856765985488892,
0.15373595058918,
-0.20492707192897797,
-0.3469488024711609,
-0.1616910696029663,
0.19714848697185516,
-0.3673233985900879,
0.424298495054245,
0.8682342171669006,
-0.3170908987522125,
-0.1307847648859024,
-0.7536165118217468,
0.6914396286010742,
0.4969598054885864,
-0.5005201697349548,
0.002244138391688466,
0.3875196874141693,
0.2771294116973877,
0.5060288906097412,
0.6607139706611633,
-0.525627613067627,
0.09706109017133713,
-0.307857483625412,
-0.07820947468280792,
0.6964783072471619,
-0.10811325907707214,
-0.3107868731021881,
0.3549157679080963,
-0.2302512377500534,
0.05363166704773903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00454v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00454v1 | Self-Translate-Train: A Simple but Strong Baseline for Cross-lingual Transfer of Large Language Models | 2024-06-29T14:40:23 | 2024-06-29T14:40:23 | Ryokan Ri, Shun Kiyono, Sho Takase | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual transfer is a promising technique for utilizing data in a
source language to improve performance in a target language. However, current
techniques often require an external translation system or suffer from
suboptimal performance due to over-reliance on cross-lingual generalization of
multi-lingual pretrained language models. In this study, we propose a simple
yet effective method called Self-Translate-Train. It leverages the translation
capability of a large language model to generate synthetic training data in the
target language and fine-tunes the model with its own generated data. We
evaluate the proposed method on a wide range of tasks and show substantial
performance gains across several non-English languages. | [
-0.30989599227905273,
-0.37148192524909973,
0.15912286937236786,
0.4561082720756531,
-0.1997484266757965,
-0.07382439821958542,
-0.3663623631000519,
-0.5988752841949463,
0.3297799527645111,
0.21331660449504852,
-0.45210978388786316,
-0.044032298028469086,
-0.4341174364089966,
0.20025110244750977,
-0.6543633937835693,
0.9581970572471619,
-0.1596820056438446,
0.48940932750701904,
0.13734719157218933,
-0.034608952701091766,
-0.4037288725376129,
-0.5899184942245483,
-0.49491843581199646,
-0.40090659260749817,
0.3787849545478821,
0.31586119532585144,
0.21649867296218872,
0.4579594135284424,
0.362456351518631,
0.2982088625431061,
0.5070512294769287,
0.020311953499913216,
-0.7240130305290222,
-0.22968171536922455,
-0.6117343902587891,
-0.4862878620624542,
-0.39026618003845215,
-0.14330436289310455,
0.8291155695915222,
0.6800031065940857,
0.16762149333953857,
0.2960997223854065,
0.11849981546401978,
0.4580710530281067,
-0.4782826900482178,
0.07180756330490112,
-0.4590473473072052,
0.30937907099723816,
-0.2608593702316284,
-0.09420209378004074,
-0.4485316872596741,
-0.0018675290048122406,
-0.05979713797569275,
-0.7160967588424683,
0.1009572371840477,
0.07534351199865341,
0.4200012683868408,
-0.042455583810806274,
-0.5162420272827148,
0.015032007358968258,
-0.7773243188858032,
0.7868151068687439,
-0.6041819453239441,
0.8306692838668823,
0.336409330368042,
0.489143431186676,
0.30677518248558044,
-0.6188521385192871,
-0.3892998993396759,
-0.32143688201904297,
-0.32207056879997253,
0.09821923077106476,
0.1576376110315323,
-0.38578566908836365,
0.09900914877653122,
0.3807087242603302,
-0.6007166504859924,
0.0744704008102417,
-0.40753281116485596,
-0.16607172787189484,
0.6765366792678833,
-0.0001616637164261192,
0.6030834913253784,
0.0064532519318163395,
-0.4967009425163269,
-0.18650299310684204,
-0.7279536724090576,
-0.1989092379808426,
0.10753852874040604,
0.6595008969306946,
-0.25341543555259705,
0.47545933723449707,
-0.5178463459014893,
0.4930102825164795,
0.1722402423620224,
-0.1764983981847763,
0.28434088826179504,
-0.6753584742546082,
-0.0649423748254776,
0.27083975076675415,
0.7429976463317871,
0.14383050799369812,
0.5343904495239258,
-0.7178826928138733,
-0.3386078476905823,
-0.1792633831501007,
0.18378789722919464,
-0.8745219707489014,
-0.2236572951078415,
-0.31403741240501404,
-0.23314638435840607,
-0.03234478458762169,
-0.5299915075302124,
-0.46364834904670715,
0.1826721429824829,
-0.48364004492759705,
0.53702712059021,
-0.41845354437828064,
-0.37949079275131226,
-0.08823419362306595,
0.18790599703788757,
0.3363613188266754,
0.2882159650325775,
-1.156288743019104,
0.15262168645858765,
0.13748149573802948,
0.8943765163421631,
-0.49656960368156433,
-0.7087188959121704,
-0.7093228697776794,
0.39098766446113586,
-0.6332927346229553,
0.6441771388053894,
-0.046533260494470596,
-0.3489530384540558,
0.06908351182937622,
0.1666041761636734,
-0.19177599251270294,
-0.3198802173137665,
0.01599040813744068,
-0.30040520429611206,
0.3080710768699646,
-0.21479731798171997,
-0.2786886692047119,
0.20357045531272888,
0.30813637375831604,
-0.5699151754379272,
1.1288573741912842,
0.12720568478107452,
-0.5044773817062378,
0.2717936635017395,
-0.3138008713722229,
-0.9402719140052795,
-0.025470919907093048,
0.10669627040624619,
-0.1028863787651062,
-0.03520587459206581,
0.4839431941509247,
0.3950744867324829,
-0.3166169226169586,
0.14155137538909912,
-0.18542547523975372,
-0.19523198902606964,
-0.05231299251317978,
-0.21353457868099213,
0.5928078293800354,
0.26490965485572815,
-0.3389008939266205,
-0.35200563073158264,
-0.6822628378868103,
0.24607637524604797,
0.06551098078489304,
-0.37759020924568176,
-0.5897010564804077,
-0.6558116674423218,
0.28739187121391296,
0.5001375079154968,
0.5333715677261353,
-0.6400209069252014,
0.3506143093109131,
-0.4504856467247009,
0.03430454060435295,
0.28318697214126587,
-0.48817208409309387,
0.8283764719963074,
-0.03616918995976448,
0.5354561805725098,
-0.14643019437789917,
-0.16398121416568756,
0.13796362280845642,
0.030724069103598595,
-0.6514682769775391,
-0.11661124229431152,
0.7687260508537292,
0.6046018600463867,
-1.1844884157180786,
0.2078477293252945,
-0.6031402945518494,
-0.4948210120201111,
-0.6160233616828918,
0.5865640044212341,
0.47907501459121704,
0.4324388802051544,
0.7735147476196289,
-0.30732524394989014,
-0.49282050132751465,
-0.9945695400238037,
-0.31424957513809204,
-0.013452273793518543,
0.07705069333314896,
-0.1679486483335495,
0.2887067198753357,
-0.12408224493265152,
0.6130727529525757,
-0.10366985946893692,
-0.5203136205673218,
-0.5957465767860413,
0.3701063096523285,
-0.2954227030277252,
0.8987744450569153,
0.713121771812439,
-0.4582240581512451,
-0.9476543664932251,
0.5151932835578918,
-0.9086474180221558,
-0.29725584387779236,
-0.4031490385532379,
-0.5991169810295105,
0.1421714872121811,
0.7233514189720154,
-0.4142064154148102,
-0.021198943257331848,
0.8731920123100281,
-0.03556152433156967,
0.33760443329811096,
-0.25286856293678284,
0.2669978439807892,
-1.0459308624267578,
0.44213682413101196,
-0.20311233401298523,
-0.6079728007316589,
-0.7085863351821899,
-0.14311344921588898,
0.3313460946083069,
-0.12299947440624237,
-0.6030099391937256,
0.949225127696991,
-0.574731171131134,
-0.07731747627258301,
-0.28802070021629333,
-0.08144290000200272,
-0.252345472574234,
0.43522781133651733,
0.37627193331718445,
0.780350923538208,
0.6439811587333679,
-0.4626542031764984,
0.272227019071579,
0.3910060524940491,
-0.24558007717132568,
0.8186135292053223,
-0.4097394645214081,
0.12535718083381653,
0.1936834454536438,
0.15827393531799316,
-0.8545438051223755,
-0.06265679001808167,
0.12144366651773453,
-0.2785574495792389,
0.6030709743499756,
-0.26351818442344666,
-0.2744515836238861,
-0.07344687730073929,
0.2803879976272583,
0.5467851161956787,
0.4212598502635956,
-0.877145528793335,
0.5385780334472656,
0.09984856098890305,
-0.21095341444015503,
-0.42329642176628113,
-1.0512155294418335,
0.34561073780059814,
-0.18266905844211578,
-0.5434025526046753,
0.4478386342525482,
-0.04683208465576172,
0.28669875860214233,
-0.16520138084888458,
-0.07422136515378952,
-0.04755379632115364,
-0.16110864281654358,
-0.3702195882797241,
0.04188337177038193,
-0.2357487678527832,
0.17017990350723267,
0.08754637837409973,
-0.12890836596488953,
0.08756671845912933,
-0.45148175954818726,
0.3603351414203644,
0.11908294260501862,
-0.24773679673671722,
-0.17134524881839752,
0.530865490436554,
0.5245292782783508,
-0.4013746380805969,
0.6074461936950684,
0.6279805898666382,
-0.13838203251361847,
-0.691043496131897,
-0.3480014503002167,
-0.20494239032268524,
-0.42214956879615784,
0.49019742012023926,
-0.7659255862236023,
-0.34896788001060486,
0.26844343543052673,
-0.34286582469940186,
-0.09746260195970535,
0.383134663105011,
0.4494116008281708,
0.04625944420695305,
1.2637743949890137,
0.7525554299354553,
-0.17039082944393158,
0.6561040878295898,
-0.33047738671302795,
0.1661117672920227,
-0.5684122443199158,
-0.06800837814807892,
-0.23436956107616425,
-0.29520121216773987,
-0.43686074018478394,
-0.4017618000507355,
0.1344190239906311,
0.03024170733988285,
0.028489813208580017,
0.79341721534729,
-0.07639262825250626,
0.16377407312393188,
0.45708179473876953,
-0.09418060630559921,
0.3394109606742859,
0.05590170994400978,
-0.16153322160243988,
-0.11844146251678467,
-1.0469785928726196,
-0.1315922886133194,
1.057563066482544,
0.21420280635356903,
1.110568642616272,
0.03156086802482605,
0.7762375473976135,
0.10365548729896545,
0.43093881011009216,
-0.569998025894165,
0.380908340215683,
-0.38723501563072205,
-0.5795605778694153,
-0.4882042407989502,
-0.6038662791252136,
-0.819404125213623,
0.4464104175567627,
-0.2756975293159485,
-0.11813529580831528,
0.10776364058256149,
0.20523619651794434,
0.10871187597513199,
0.19619199633598328,
-0.7593877911567688,
1.0953649282455444,
-0.9844969511032104,
-0.49635422229766846,
-0.21009105443954468,
-0.48747318983078003,
0.2008238136768341,
-0.5274240970611572,
0.0825858935713768,
0.10462677478790283,
0.15937596559524536,
0.6074383854866028,
-0.18392959237098694,
0.8171883225440979,
-0.09741410613059998,
-0.32359835505485535,
-0.09137788414955139,
0.3909151554107666,
0.5638967752456665,
-0.1592988520860672,
0.1500684767961502,
0.4052577614784241,
-0.0210325475782156,
-0.48617514967918396,
-0.8514928817749023,
0.5766569972038269,
-0.8600733280181885,
-0.3373354375362396,
-0.18804267048835754,
-0.6427334547042847,
-0.46247953176498413,
0.41029801964759827,
0.2271372675895691,
0.3149726390838623,
-0.43797555565834045,
0.11836092919111252,
0.18353919684886932,
0.017458876594901085,
0.2693970203399658,
0.7668634057044983,
-0.424806147813797,
-0.27589598298072815,
1.0813353061676025,
0.31907132267951965,
0.5732870697975159,
0.4500640034675598,
0.13100750744342804,
-0.6696202754974365,
-0.4688671827316284,
-1.1665759086608887,
0.30665725469589233,
-0.6166631579399109,
-0.09624765813350677,
-0.462760865688324,
-0.0996658056974411,
-0.7392610907554626,
-0.2073180079460144,
-0.8455228209495544,
-0.4610576927661896,
0.15871745347976685,
0.11754447221755981,
-0.09810195863246918,
0.5280876755714417,
-0.3500356078147888,
0.2623237669467926,
-0.7268993854522705,
0.4133087992668152,
0.5325515270233154,
0.195006862282753,
-0.2511022686958313,
-0.7797967791557312,
-0.7687610387802124,
0.17702408134937286,
0.07480225712060928,
-0.529263973236084,
0.7855842709541321,
0.2995852828025818,
0.8177044987678528,
-0.08821363747119904,
0.061176564544439316,
0.8378913998603821,
-0.6123953461647034,
0.39269351959228516,
0.4233774244785309,
-0.9997844696044922,
0.49898090958595276,
-0.19979417324066162,
0.4274941086769104,
0.667325496673584,
0.6614804863929749,
-0.6670804023742676,
-0.14715754985809326,
-0.3248087465763092,
-0.630594789981842,
0.6266009211540222,
0.1184641495347023,
0.07907646894454956,
0.16939345002174377,
-0.019145933911204338,
0.034411851316690445,
0.10399932414293289,
-1.0031026601791382,
0.08424989879131317,
-0.4046740233898163,
-0.08864007890224457,
-0.41541779041290283,
0.3904339373111725,
-0.027649929746985435,
-0.3749365210533142,
0.6918089985847473,
-0.5568060874938965,
0.011670824140310287,
0.20344048738479614,
-0.5669463872909546,
-0.1950206458568573,
0.09703727066516876,
0.06652650982141495,
0.5270182490348816,
0.1830609291791916,
0.1891796737909317,
0.7202422022819519,
-0.10349176824092865,
0.3684156835079193,
0.010214499197900295,
-0.055418554693460464,
-0.21079200506210327,
0.4406791627407074,
0.6335511803627014,
0.4718271791934967,
-0.3419378697872162,
0.34842970967292786,
0.16184046864509583,
0.04569333419203758,
-0.1517847776412964,
-0.1264236569404602,
0.08457380533218384,
0.11454383283853531,
-0.022506428882479668,
-0.21172773838043213,
0.15523846447467804,
-0.772422730922699,
0.16747067868709564,
0.3090701997280121,
-0.1659192591905594,
-0.3148532807826996,
0.573890745639801,
0.41724729537963867,
-0.032691456377506256,
0.6475731730461121,
-0.02822912484407425,
-0.5670095682144165,
0.2893702983856201,
1.1167649030685425,
0.7026957273483276,
-0.5529319047927856,
0.11007150262594223,
0.6009438037872314,
0.28503814339637756,
-0.4280698299407959,
-0.07995161414146423,
-0.2117053121328354,
-0.6061439514160156,
-0.7696892023086548,
-0.5969181060791016,
-0.12734246253967285,
0.04062439873814583,
-0.5483612418174744,
0.2778335511684418,
0.1042320728302002,
0.07323628664016724,
-0.29239344596862793,
-0.1803591102361679,
-0.7297784090042114,
0.4581737816333771,
0.482164204120636,
0.8986746668815613,
-1.0934349298477173,
1.3257038593292236,
0.6692914366722107,
-0.31917330622673035,
-0.6807391047477722,
-0.10911797732114792,
-0.5693193078041077,
-0.8755849003791809,
1.0645090341567993,
-0.08360011875629425,
-0.3793397843837738,
0.1315290480852127,
-0.1910018026828766,
-1.0340157747268677,
0.675991415977478,
0.5682024955749512,
-0.6360284090042114,
-0.07936897873878479,
0.5601531863212585,
0.8248458504676819,
-0.5215944647789001,
0.038746558129787445,
0.49159157276153564,
0.5153523087501526,
0.11233378946781158,
-1.2428780794143677,
0.06422492861747742,
-0.3783446252346039,
0.1139441728591919,
0.08315379917621613,
-0.6139087677001953,
0.7522419691085815,
0.08794362097978592,
-0.23279567062854767,
-0.15601108968257904,
0.7544481158256531,
-0.2773779332637787,
-0.04576949030160904,
0.4537571966648102,
0.4897984564304352,
0.32485511898994446,
0.2900998592376709,
1.0713911056518555,
-0.6045004725456238,
0.31604230403900146,
1.0808624029159546,
-0.14117038249969482,
0.8553193807601929,
0.44570720195770264,
0.09138403832912445,
0.1095641478896141,
0.22017504274845123,
0.13542279601097107,
0.7277002930641174,
0.12299709767103195,
0.041020553559064865,
-0.7770306468009949,
0.0749797374010086,
-0.4980580508708954,
0.688248336315155,
0.09661207348108292,
-0.27846428751945496,
-0.3997504711151123,
0.21396352350711823,
-0.23591536283493042,
-0.08951123803853989,
-0.31688791513442993,
0.599831223487854,
0.205527201294899,
-0.9608144760131836,
0.8693547248840332,
-0.07426522672176361,
0.6009255051612854,
-0.8920167684555054,
-0.07416847348213196,
-0.3459726870059967,
0.24988016486167908,
-0.006565197836607695,
-0.5268154740333557,
0.37367770075798035,
-0.07439452409744263,
0.21449849009513855,
-0.8125510215759277,
0.6477836966514587,
-0.9942774772644043,
-0.6966201066970825,
0.6630010008811951,
0.850351870059967,
0.21449442207813263,
0.043065108358860016,
-0.6663776636123657,
-0.4282139539718628,
0.06825900822877884,
-0.0063284458592534065,
0.6768932342529297,
0.5193416476249695,
-0.16721706092357635,
0.5898372530937195,
0.681496798992157,
0.4629451036453247,
0.17941927909851074,
-0.12343272566795349,
0.5555594563484192,
-0.5125347375869751,
-0.7317186594009399,
-0.4448801577091217,
0.24321933090686798,
-0.02842671237885952,
-0.43033045530319214,
1.0085138082504272,
0.6901082992553711,
1.205872893333435,
-0.21574287116527557,
0.9544382691383362,
-0.06997992098331451,
0.5933552384376526,
-0.6720210313796997,
0.7921128273010254,
-0.8328520059585571,
-0.21511682868003845,
-0.009635400027036667,
-0.8359553217887878,
0.019994691014289856,
0.8615557551383972,
-0.5029941201210022,
0.08119308203458786,
0.6654251217842102,
0.6790066957473755,
-0.47673967480659485,
-0.3917291760444641,
0.630237340927124,
0.15236079692840576,
0.1346615105867386,
0.6073965430259705,
0.8677050471305847,
-0.3707104027271271,
0.6957367658615112,
-0.5021576285362244,
0.016761882230639458,
-0.06071068346500397,
-0.7946877479553223,
-1.0561470985412598,
-0.4515889585018158,
-0.22538603842258453,
-0.07079631090164185,
0.14477640390396118,
0.6695239543914795,
1.1517612934112549,
-0.8791695237159729,
-0.5853216052055359,
0.16389118134975433,
-0.3763205409049988,
-0.26371297240257263,
-0.06072084978222847,
0.1733960658311844,
-0.6982688903808594,
-0.99964839220047,
0.8185449242591858,
-0.24776528775691986,
0.25376182794570923,
-0.6127310991287231,
-0.1704043447971344,
-0.2625637650489807,
-0.12947966158390045,
0.6636694669723511,
0.46357855200767517,
-0.18417149782180786,
-0.20794710516929626,
0.07456138730049133,
-0.44046369194984436,
-0.003924270160496235,
0.9142895936965942,
-0.8347302675247192,
0.587286651134491,
0.5900305509567261,
0.8407552242279053,
0.9622259140014648,
0.12647511065006256,
0.9919561743736267,
-0.8872196674346924,
0.0952213853597641,
-0.08660853654146194,
0.29972222447395325,
0.5471635460853577,
-0.4291638433933258,
0.646602213382721,
0.29038771986961365,
-0.24373143911361694,
-0.5103363990783691,
-0.11807849258184433,
-0.7300156354904175,
-0.24875450134277344,
1.155558705329895,
-0.10601451992988586,
-0.22943797707557678,
-0.07048721611499786,
-0.16606058180332184,
0.39728158712387085,
0.025655051693320274,
0.74198317527771,
0.4161965548992157,
-0.039533887058496475,
0.14385810494422913,
-0.566010594367981,
0.3949503004550934,
0.6379191279411316,
-0.9863412976264954,
0.05563519895076752,
0.27545127272605896,
0.5202061533927917,
0.20595623552799225,
0.6133090257644653,
0.06502385437488556,
0.21751098334789276,
0.09907373785972595,
0.31259772181510925,
0.09878911077976227,
-0.60455322265625,
-0.18297377228736877,
-0.0912068784236908,
-0.160298690199852,
-0.14837077260017395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00453v1 | PerSEval: Assessing Personalization in Text Summarizers | 2024-06-29T14:37:36 | 2024-06-29T14:37:36 | Sourish Dasgupta, Ankush Chander, Parth Borad, Isha Motiyani, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Personalized summarization models cater to individuals' subjective
understanding of saliency, as represented by their reading history and current
topics of attention. Existing personalized text summarizers are primarily
evaluated based on accuracy measures such as BLEU, ROUGE, and METEOR. However,
a recent study argued that accuracy measures are inadequate for evaluating the
degree of personalization of these models and proposed EGISES, the first metric
to evaluate personalized text summaries. It was suggested that accuracy is a
separate aspect and should be evaluated standalone. In this paper, we challenge
the necessity of an accuracy leaderboard, suggesting that relying on
accuracy-based aggregated results might lead to misleading conclusions. To
support this, we delve deeper into EGISES, demonstrating both theoretically and
empirically that it measures the degree of responsiveness, a necessary but not
sufficient condition for degree-of-personalization. We subsequently propose
PerSEval, a novel measure that satisfies the required sufficiency condition.
Based on the benchmarking of ten SOTA summarization models on the PENS dataset,
we empirically establish that -- (i) PerSEval is reliable w.r.t human-judgment
correlation (Pearson's r = 0.73; Spearman's $\rho$ = 0.62; Kendall's $\tau$ =
0.42), (ii) PerSEval has high rank-stability, (iii) PerSEval as a rank-measure
is not entailed by EGISES-based ranking, and (iv) PerSEval can be a standalone
rank-measure without the need of any aggregated ranking. | [
-0.23052002489566803,
-0.37585142254829407,
0.6740121841430664,
0.19182467460632324,
-0.06734821945428848,
0.05773572996258736,
-0.13373076915740967,
-0.04004502296447754,
0.7704857587814331,
0.2877535820007324,
-0.1889304667711258,
-0.6676150560379028,
-0.7424565553665161,
0.3607861399650574,
-0.38338378071784973,
1.1472976207733154,
0.13912004232406616,
-0.4168274402618408,
-0.35718482732772827,
-0.25243937969207764,
-0.2629772126674652,
-0.5900437831878662,
-0.24849095940589905,
0.10757339745759964,
0.7844077944755554,
0.5397171974182129,
0.444489985704422,
0.19406042993068695,
0.785245954990387,
0.4565085768699646,
-0.3042775094509125,
-0.04469224810600281,
-0.6747037768363953,
0.346853107213974,
-0.10665462911128998,
-0.40751370787620544,
-1.0501673221588135,
0.02219262719154358,
0.5129134058952332,
0.6825373768806458,
-0.04465634748339653,
0.49584057927131653,
0.28341570496559143,
0.6013502478599548,
-0.8638731837272644,
-0.10581617802381516,
-0.16746526956558228,
0.04529983550310135,
-0.352412611246109,
-0.14910727739334106,
-0.214807391166687,
-0.42933812737464905,
0.5310806632041931,
-0.675886869430542,
0.23837681114673615,
-0.08128329366445541,
0.7165594100952148,
0.31365692615509033,
-0.23016105592250824,
0.013440544717013836,
-0.589004635810852,
0.6807917356491089,
-0.6212488412857056,
0.058569639921188354,
0.33099472522735596,
0.4278006851673126,
0.3627513647079468,
-0.8482901453971863,
-0.1296233832836151,
-0.23582206666469574,
-0.020643629133701324,
0.6571229696273804,
-0.07887781411409378,
-0.048778049647808075,
0.217704176902771,
0.44375669956207275,
-0.4013626277446747,
-0.10326685011386871,
-0.024948013946413994,
0.05196772888302803,
0.7168351411819458,
0.41436001658439636,
0.11617331206798553,
0.09014210850000381,
-0.4515487551689148,
0.04263303428888321,
-0.36071300506591797,
0.46466711163520813,
0.428945928812027,
0.006256446707993746,
-0.08991672098636627,
0.5547652244567871,
-0.4550769329071045,
0.48406463861465454,
0.14596255123615265,
-0.2183763086795807,
0.15129831433296204,
-0.35919028520584106,
-0.2059910148382187,
0.19809311628341675,
0.6152616739273071,
0.6437452435493469,
0.387462854385376,
-0.202265664935112,
-0.09795317053794861,
0.05390352010726929,
0.3697829842567444,
-0.8797300457954407,
-0.39150893688201904,
0.20307967066764832,
-0.2963988184928894,
-0.5654140114784241,
0.5125163793563843,
-0.5597427487373352,
-0.32385891675949097,
0.10333241522312164,
0.16919739544391632,
-0.018186654895544052,
0.10247138887643814,
-0.11388665437698364,
-0.13110673427581787,
-0.36521849036216736,
0.7279326319694519,
-1.1032049655914307,
0.2021377831697464,
0.5407246947288513,
0.806743860244751,
-0.3346562683582306,
-0.5707843899726868,
-0.3162248432636261,
0.03763530030846596,
-0.26498183608055115,
1.232622742652893,
-0.4535287320613861,
-0.3884905278682709,
-0.37838807702064514,
-0.1513240486383438,
0.011512700468301773,
-0.23238185048103333,
0.6120976209640503,
-0.24438101053237915,
-0.011769412085413933,
-0.6967889666557312,
-0.6178309917449951,
-0.24094738066196442,
0.19363932311534882,
-0.3420029878616333,
0.5138047933578491,
0.05061717703938484,
-0.8125859498977661,
0.534353494644165,
-0.53965163230896,
-0.24055851995944977,
0.23366278409957886,
-0.05769193172454834,
-0.558668315410614,
0.3922679126262665,
0.09735660254955292,
0.48176339268684387,
-0.12009628117084503,
0.1200258657336235,
-0.3310829997062683,
-0.5327274799346924,
0.35390380024909973,
-0.2673676908016205,
0.3073306977748871,
-0.014986242167651653,
-0.1579357385635376,
0.1438070684671402,
-0.4426646828651428,
-0.043164484202861786,
-0.0650104507803917,
-0.3086423873901367,
-0.5395275354385376,
0.013251150026917458,
0.00904872827231884,
-0.35402727127075195,
0.32088702917099,
-0.5815473794937134,
-0.12714125216007233,
-0.46057355403900146,
0.0892777368426323,
0.9315226674079895,
0.07972121238708496,
0.34814226627349854,
-0.440878301858902,
0.6051074862480164,
-0.31115829944610596,
0.047370653599500656,
-0.5545759797096252,
-0.5634971261024475,
-0.5108054280281067,
-0.3783220648765564,
0.515500009059906,
0.47151729464530945,
-0.028981931507587433,
0.6021896600723267,
-0.484824538230896,
-0.49394288659095764,
0.039226382970809937,
-0.16970059275627136,
0.5682857632637024,
0.6029407978057861,
0.16041570901870728,
-0.7422265410423279,
-0.15882456302642822,
-0.7303111553192139,
-0.72078537940979,
-0.08651131391525269,
-0.18631015717983246,
0.16481053829193115,
0.35723015666007996,
0.12782469391822815,
0.9671644568443298,
-0.5663015246391296,
-0.3042960464954376,
-0.1193189024925232,
-0.12574104964733124,
0.1470848023891449,
0.13826370239257812,
0.6803597211837769,
-0.6421641111373901,
-0.5733351111412048,
-0.22527296841144562,
-0.9822493195533752,
-0.38194602727890015,
0.26437538862228394,
0.17881086468696594,
-0.3832891881465912,
0.029660595580935478,
0.05407300218939781,
0.7002816796302795,
0.42380762100219727,
-0.7838886380195618,
0.5262628197669983,
-0.24864241480827332,
0.5466060638427734,
-0.669946014881134,
0.2857297658920288,
0.34322938323020935,
-0.4389641582965851,
-0.7287811636924744,
-0.06577114760875702,
-0.07000236213207245,
0.09325713664293289,
-0.20963436365127563,
0.6210120320320129,
-0.1254892349243164,
-0.21324583888053894,
-0.07972493767738342,
0.48095929622650146,
0.07057593017816544,
0.15822888910770416,
-0.36622878909111023,
0.7524721026420593,
-0.0795123353600502,
-0.6495733857154846,
0.35434219241142273,
0.6391969919204712,
-0.3532642722129822,
1.04263174533844,
-0.8726881742477417,
-0.06197810173034668,
-0.2633060812950134,
-0.015261631458997726,
-1.1845512390136719,
-0.38407638669013977,
-0.003244197927415371,
-0.6253753900527954,
0.002281663240864873,
0.2157578468322754,
0.20973771810531616,
-0.06347450613975525,
-0.6634552478790283,
0.08273319154977798,
0.3110862970352173,
-0.3816041946411133,
0.3641941249370575,
0.5994341373443604,
-0.6060710549354553,
-0.6002678275108337,
-0.6778010129928589,
0.20081286132335663,
-0.2650905251502991,
-0.6354382634162903,
0.37518709897994995,
-0.2513102889060974,
-0.4067409634590149,
-0.055784422904253006,
-0.3723907470703125,
0.21343009173870087,
0.3988751173019409,
0.34416037797927856,
0.19236260652542114,
-0.09329841285943985,
0.06290855258703232,
0.12074383348226547,
-0.553894579410553,
-0.2189105600118637,
0.14664873480796814,
0.031677670776844025,
-0.23343098163604736,
-0.29353687167167664,
-0.5845968127250671,
-0.005539020523428917,
0.5118676424026489,
-0.36992767453193665,
0.40020355582237244,
0.1593228131532669,
-0.06216314435005188,
0.2539989650249481,
-0.7076339721679688,
-0.2033354490995407,
-0.4323962330818176,
0.4458635151386261,
-0.6054380536079407,
-0.9255188703536987,
0.6762092113494873,
-0.09429895132780075,
0.17025893926620483,
0.5720370411872864,
0.5905137062072754,
-0.3634103238582611,
0.7046111822128296,
0.5316426157951355,
0.1299421489238739,
0.5393502116203308,
-0.09025640040636063,
0.05572907626628876,
-0.9956160187721252,
-0.2506308853626251,
-0.5237051844596863,
-0.6615620255470276,
-0.3802914321422577,
0.3896740972995758,
0.6415084004402161,
-0.14042162895202637,
-0.46326562762260437,
0.09375398606061935,
-0.6668829321861267,
0.5922030806541443,
0.2643183171749115,
0.11606280505657196,
0.5726847052574158,
0.17004762589931488,
0.00588040379807353,
-0.37396863102912903,
-0.5824679732322693,
-0.8744779825210571,
1.1764440536499023,
0.18184581398963928,
0.7749273777008057,
0.3515448570251465,
0.7225444316864014,
0.5468053817749023,
0.5813589096069336,
-0.5733365416526794,
0.4888558089733124,
-0.45024555921554565,
-0.16630597412586212,
-0.5867136716842651,
-0.41133084893226624,
-1.0154093503952026,
0.49160340428352356,
-0.3009308874607086,
-0.900603711605072,
0.39592278003692627,
0.20959822833538055,
-0.9013771414756775,
-0.010572369210422039,
-0.6992478966712952,
0.9606592655181885,
-0.33529892563819885,
-0.45981329679489136,
0.024126196280121803,
-0.5407174229621887,
0.2706078886985779,
0.011204245500266552,
0.0003157694300170988,
-0.3193681240081787,
-0.4416273832321167,
0.7492771148681641,
-0.5712987184524536,
0.6419076919555664,
-0.026090456172823906,
0.30344972014427185,
-0.08253850042819977,
-0.0425536185503006,
0.37517249584198,
0.1616005301475525,
0.040385983884334564,
-0.0770568773150444,
0.0664127990603447,
-0.529612123966217,
-0.5967628359794617,
0.834108829498291,
-0.6540374755859375,
-0.573197066783905,
-0.6452051401138306,
0.06308429688215256,
-0.054842785000801086,
0.14319194853305817,
0.5378990173339844,
0.44827181100845337,
-0.5825336575508118,
0.1919284611940384,
0.6959206461906433,
-0.061039332300424576,
0.3317703902721405,
0.40684419870376587,
-0.16559915244579315,
-0.6159791350364685,
0.8383179306983948,
0.3553769886493683,
0.005058565642684698,
0.344130277633667,
0.4455975592136383,
-0.17043562233448029,
-0.5514286160469055,
-0.4430028796195984,
-0.012492254376411438,
-0.5685089230537415,
-0.0031172255985438824,
-0.6654844880104065,
0.1995234340429306,
-0.1685001254081726,
-0.4109056890010834,
-0.3973512351512909,
-0.45252513885498047,
-0.2699994742870331,
-0.06213747709989548,
0.08912310749292374,
0.7167701125144958,
0.498862624168396,
0.11012428253889084,
-0.8015293478965759,
0.03422809764742851,
0.4875485599040985,
0.2295505404472351,
-0.1483827531337738,
-0.7494102716445923,
-0.16924643516540527,
-0.29743653535842896,
-0.26163893938064575,
-1.0221747159957886,
0.2799457907676697,
0.03945750370621681,
0.6275779008865356,
0.4501558542251587,
0.11200971156358719,
0.46209579706192017,
-0.06199409440159798,
0.8304916620254517,
0.2795414328575134,
-0.9425857067108154,
0.462276816368103,
-0.28298160433769226,
0.4342719614505768,
0.9501433372497559,
0.1078442707657814,
-0.5625039935112,
-0.3610200583934784,
-0.7713441252708435,
-0.6456019878387451,
0.5024164915084839,
0.2570352852344513,
0.0746888667345047,
0.35597023367881775,
0.4313346743583679,
-0.05599115043878555,
0.4576583206653595,
-0.1352744698524475,
-0.32178398966789246,
-0.15260018408298492,
-0.25480401515960693,
-0.3753584623336792,
-0.6370406746864319,
0.1389978677034378,
-0.04453204199671745,
0.4115215241909027,
0.1079641804099083,
0.00975398812443018,
0.515298068523407,
-0.1257428526878357,
0.12013029307126999,
0.2242109477519989,
0.7456707954406738,
0.8448197245597839,
-0.3371136486530304,
0.08197242021560669,
0.37044215202331543,
-0.7475693225860596,
0.329598605632782,
-0.10867636650800705,
-0.5114845633506775,
-0.006084844470024109,
0.3454781174659729,
0.5945436954498291,
0.38935011625289917,
-0.43771421909332275,
0.8417263627052307,
-0.2734517455101013,
0.2377491146326065,
-0.2985769212245941,
0.009505216963589191,
-0.2654593586921692,
0.11781618744134903,
0.21075735986232758,
0.4207597076892853,
0.2795308232307434,
-0.2404121458530426,
-0.005846947897225618,
0.0353827066719532,
-0.4390760064125061,
-0.6945967674255371,
0.9577549695968628,
0.6398056149482727,
-0.2900373935699463,
0.13063716888427734,
-0.23424798250198364,
-0.40415263175964355,
0.5492557287216187,
-0.012404472567141056,
1.0444852113723755,
-0.6338738203048706,
0.12318656593561172,
0.40971633791923523,
0.4235491156578064,
-0.21015280485153198,
-0.017716480419039726,
-0.0007169513264670968,
-0.6493242383003235,
-0.2004341185092926,
-0.48083508014678955,
-0.6683433055877686,
-0.3750072121620178,
-0.4444452226161957,
0.16510187089443207,
-0.5147148966789246,
-0.7315208315849304,
0.17700865864753723,
-0.06235850974917412,
-0.2938780188560486,
0.16228239238262177,
-0.2679995894432068,
0.5802674889564514,
-0.8347921371459961,
0.16856086254119873,
1.0349489450454712,
-0.39256784319877625,
-0.2550240755081177,
0.046211279928684235,
0.16568103432655334,
-0.10046802461147308,
0.3258211016654968,
-0.14033092558383942,
-0.23173825442790985,
-0.0012157649034634233,
-0.02772771753370762,
-0.7693910002708435,
1.2677319049835205,
0.4574342966079712,
-0.5680035352706909,
0.15034602582454681,
-0.5567927956581116,
0.473542720079422,
-0.27571529150009155,
0.6941397786140442,
0.5883961915969849,
0.49557408690452576,
-0.010582050308585167,
-0.8194212913513184,
-0.11222976446151733,
-0.3189818859100342,
0.27724331617355347,
-0.013003194704651833,
-1.0360833406448364,
0.793612539768219,
-0.399629145860672,
-0.22772711515426636,
0.08708212524652481,
0.6431958675384521,
0.04313453659415245,
0.598856508731842,
0.1299661546945572,
0.6629775762557983,
0.8981115221977234,
-0.24659264087677002,
1.3742852210998535,
-0.042127374559640884,
0.5169307589530945,
1.1071252822875977,
-0.22568818926811218,
0.6019377708435059,
0.09441172331571579,
-0.5475159883499146,
0.2654150128364563,
0.4094541668891907,
0.0903836041688919,
0.5151236653327942,
-0.10071530938148499,
-0.26475149393081665,
-0.28114989399909973,
0.21777096390724182,
-0.300804078578949,
0.45576295256614685,
0.09704279899597168,
-0.4620119631290436,
-0.15782290697097778,
-0.11713922768831253,
0.09889179468154907,
0.43896257877349854,
-0.2027314454317093,
0.6766179203987122,
0.02100822515785694,
-0.43835219740867615,
0.25931042432785034,
0.08014260232448578,
0.6500056385993958,
-0.4765627086162567,
0.3789216876029968,
-0.4061168432235718,
0.21593108773231506,
-0.491742342710495,
-0.6228326559066772,
0.31858351826667786,
0.2560172379016876,
-0.06369328498840332,
-0.16420665383338928,
0.7317308187484741,
0.035484764724969864,
-0.3718869984149933,
-0.2486083209514618,
0.5117321610450745,
0.21855922043323517,
-0.1590011864900589,
-0.25818321108818054,
-0.05856681987643242,
-0.030979188159108162,
-0.6713436841964722,
0.46097254753112793,
0.08788406848907471,
0.1379081755876541,
0.480956107378006,
0.40315037965774536,
0.06521902978420258,
-0.20211882889270782,
-0.04835168272256851,
0.5777646899223328,
-0.4754828214645386,
-0.738290011882782,
-1.0939021110534668,
0.513146162033081,
-0.2436678409576416,
-0.7126088738441467,
1.2930337190628052,
0.7202140092849731,
0.43874451518058777,
-0.07530739903450012,
0.8704522252082825,
0.27218392491340637,
0.5593264102935791,
-0.11810225248336792,
0.8412020206451416,
-0.5068987607955933,
0.378371924161911,
-0.4793544411659241,
-1.0677698850631714,
-0.3816015124320984,
0.766916811466217,
-0.6015693545341492,
0.09206957370042801,
0.5622206330299377,
0.43872955441474915,
0.09724386036396027,
0.22173497080802917,
0.62796950340271,
0.15698394179344177,
-0.00010870554979192093,
0.3219347894191742,
0.855287492275238,
-0.32637202739715576,
0.19046692550182343,
0.0827997624874115,
-0.7003740072250366,
-0.45100682973861694,
-0.6178328990936279,
-0.93308424949646,
-0.37582215666770935,
-0.3657987415790558,
-0.2708296775817871,
0.22382806241512299,
0.6327405571937561,
0.3865821957588196,
-0.7796431183815002,
-0.2551957964897156,
0.2757851481437683,
0.14245136082172394,
-0.3156464695930481,
-0.06980445235967636,
0.35255104303359985,
-0.26519232988357544,
-0.7640790939331055,
0.049957580864429474,
0.7942484617233276,
0.1000576764345169,
-0.18760357797145844,
0.0166308656334877,
0.367832750082016,
0.07953160256147385,
0.7545936703681946,
0.2122856080532074,
-0.5324194431304932,
-0.11130107939243317,
0.07112900167703629,
-0.19251494109630585,
0.12869341671466827,
0.7269106507301331,
-0.6588968634605408,
0.6885164380073547,
0.7733001112937927,
0.40363332629203796,
0.7118589878082275,
0.4608164131641388,
0.15728162229061127,
-0.42406946420669556,
-0.09120458364486694,
0.23489822447299957,
0.2512054741382599,
0.2957419157028198,
-0.31398046016693115,
0.5038474202156067,
0.3535146117210388,
-0.6991633176803589,
-0.6785346865653992,
0.07400033622980118,
-0.7591387629508972,
0.21472202241420746,
0.6678463220596313,
-0.5434008836746216,
-0.2554519772529602,
-0.09469636529684067,
-0.07210687547922134,
-0.24493451416492462,
-0.6059085130691528,
0.7813560366630554,
0.5558139085769653,
-0.24661077558994293,
0.059414155781269073,
-0.4570171535015106,
0.3006238043308258,
0.3637816905975342,
-0.7894628643989563,
-0.16994397342205048,
0.2790631651878357,
0.2867879569530487,
0.3695886731147766,
0.9454399347305298,
0.041253603994846344,
0.24645033478736877,
-0.05550417676568031,
-0.0976601392030716,
-0.24193449318408966,
-0.26886871457099915,
-0.3638628423213959,
0.3878210783004761,
0.029091214761137962,
-0.029949050396680832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00436v1 | A Recipe of Parallel Corpora Exploitation for Multilingual Large Language Models | 2024-06-29T13:12:39 | 2024-06-29T13:12:39 | Peiqin Lin, André F. T. Martins, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have highlighted the potential of exploiting parallel corpora
to enhance multilingual large language models, improving performance in both
bilingual tasks, e.g., machine translation, and general-purpose tasks, e.g.,
text classification. Building upon these findings, our comprehensive study aims
to identify the most effective strategies for leveraging parallel corpora. We
investigate the impact of parallel corpora quality and quantity, training
objectives, and model size on the performance of multilingual large language
models enhanced with parallel corpora across diverse languages and tasks. Our
analysis reveals several key insights: (i) filtering noisy translations is
essential for effectively exploiting parallel corpora, while language
identification and short sentence filtering have little effect; (ii) even a
corpus containing just 10K parallel sentences can yield results comparable to
those obtained from much larger datasets; (iii) employing only the machine
translation objective yields the best results among various training objectives
and their combinations; (iv) larger multilingual language models benefit more
from parallel corpora than smaller models due to their stronger capacity for
cross-task transfer. Our study offers valuable insights into the optimal
utilization of parallel corpora to enhance multilingual large language models,
extending the generalizability of previous findings from limited languages and
tasks to a broader range of scenarios. | [
-0.4512152373790741,
-0.3630937337875366,
0.6614552736282349,
0.4713250398635864,
-0.01452811062335968,
0.19325561821460724,
-0.6886045336723328,
-0.6787838935852051,
-0.047664202749729156,
0.661571741104126,
-0.34010547399520874,
-0.5157607197761536,
-0.7387016415596008,
0.46785327792167664,
-0.38102155923843384,
0.9057305455207825,
-0.05070256069302559,
0.20626148581504822,
-0.30980369448661804,
-0.20085056126117706,
-0.5057888031005859,
-0.9436689019203186,
-0.40175193548202515,
-0.047975122928619385,
0.8037684559822083,
0.49582692980766296,
0.7500227689743042,
0.692498505115509,
0.5679979920387268,
0.38622334599494934,
0.04900509864091873,
0.23602412641048431,
-0.5564802885055542,
-0.038107093423604965,
-0.1987205147743225,
-0.5396361351013184,
-0.24219872057437897,
-0.09759827703237534,
0.8066390752792358,
0.9043139219284058,
0.09541615843772888,
0.2841423451900482,
0.09699773043394089,
0.34117400646209717,
-0.7931742668151855,
0.3293810784816742,
-0.46086376905441284,
-0.10443101078271866,
-0.4994385242462158,
-0.12974312901496887,
-0.3482023775577545,
0.008269211277365685,
-0.16280512511730194,
-0.566432535648346,
0.1631881594657898,
0.2381104677915573,
0.3942495584487915,
0.015218350104987621,
-0.20697654783725739,
-0.4822062849998474,
-0.7250974178314209,
0.9650364518165588,
-0.41252049803733826,
0.5665798187255859,
0.21914531290531158,
0.28766965866088867,
0.26408642530441284,
-0.5784400105476379,
-0.3787938356399536,
-0.27268755435943604,
-0.33127206563949585,
-0.06575150042772293,
-0.015625841915607452,
0.028515886515378952,
0.5105463862419128,
0.4504288136959076,
-0.6792787313461304,
0.4709078073501587,
-0.5980620384216309,
-0.10554872453212738,
0.26308348774909973,
0.26155516505241394,
0.4138527810573578,
0.009286838583648205,
-0.24026955664157867,
-0.3160443603992462,
-0.6369715929031372,
-0.0032900942023843527,
0.6843084096908569,
0.3980759084224701,
-0.05201232060790062,
0.6650770902633667,
-0.16609303653240204,
0.5833379626274109,
-0.3373742997646332,
-0.2754586637020111,
0.1839398592710495,
-0.7342668771743774,
-0.0993141308426857,
0.007805728819221258,
0.644779622554779,
0.07800336927175522,
0.26101255416870117,
-0.40719112753868103,
-0.14308057725429535,
0.20725086331367493,
0.06290607899427414,
-0.9038103222846985,
0.00765188317745924,
0.12691819667816162,
-0.35711291432380676,
-0.0877542793750763,
0.00015110969252418727,
-0.9966585636138916,
-0.0291429553180933,
-0.6873941421508789,
-0.05205151438713074,
-0.2158385068178177,
-0.31980493664741516,
0.353494793176651,
-0.23602807521820068,
-0.2520654499530792,
-0.021375827491283417,
-1.1263046264648438,
0.6029490828514099,
0.8374759554862976,
0.6151853799819946,
-0.22044900059700012,
-0.6710428595542908,
-0.8738166689872742,
0.22790756821632385,
-0.26700711250305176,
0.44928738474845886,
-0.735939085483551,
-0.14561469852924347,
0.18171213567256927,
0.14019840955734253,
-0.3309454023838043,
-0.6432921290397644,
0.5306774973869324,
-0.5374932289123535,
-0.1034652441740036,
-0.4385892450809479,
-0.2519209384918213,
-0.06436265259981155,
0.07512921094894409,
-0.9090772271156311,
0.5536972880363464,
-0.15929467976093292,
-0.6283392310142517,
0.04342246800661087,
-0.4080546796321869,
-0.44422420859336853,
-0.20492959022521973,
-0.022421786561608315,
-0.03800541162490845,
0.08952128887176514,
0.3491036891937256,
0.5343863368034363,
-0.5882596373558044,
0.12153460830450058,
-0.46540069580078125,
-0.2860200107097626,
-0.026487166061997414,
-0.28154221177101135,
0.7008308172225952,
0.30016154050827026,
-0.13737691938877106,
0.20705416798591614,
-0.5697590708732605,
-0.2496330589056015,
0.0011732988059520721,
-0.2527227997779846,
-0.5182345509529114,
-0.3260682225227356,
0.4129478931427002,
0.18731015920639038,
0.3347598612308502,
-0.4922606348991394,
-0.20373336970806122,
-0.1249052882194519,
0.19816243648529053,
0.3561874330043793,
-0.3249659538269043,
0.5887460708618164,
-0.19652196764945984,
0.6208934187889099,
-0.07170737534761429,
0.07403010129928589,
-0.10151080042123795,
-0.26931139826774597,
-0.36666059494018555,
-0.6242989301681519,
0.5682156682014465,
0.5914911031723022,
-0.47164252400398254,
0.009189675562083721,
-0.2514980733394623,
-0.3997206389904022,
-0.6850194931030273,
0.6040403842926025,
0.5449027419090271,
0.10924217849969864,
0.33862319588661194,
-0.24993212521076202,
-0.584484338760376,
-1.0515745878219604,
-0.2637981176376343,
0.13019485771656036,
0.12660221755504608,
-0.19458293914794922,
0.3223007917404175,
-0.04186064004898071,
0.3354548513889313,
-0.3339504301548004,
-0.22092725336551666,
-0.429137647151947,
0.3036569654941559,
0.11429969221353531,
0.3905580937862396,
0.7086969614028931,
-1.1114988327026367,
-0.5701830983161926,
0.31438761949539185,
-0.8740621209144592,
-0.10550900548696518,
-0.22581084072589874,
-0.1728445589542389,
0.14538425207138062,
0.7688811421394348,
-0.7474382519721985,
0.01898251287639141,
0.6762310862541199,
0.09512770175933838,
0.7504622340202332,
-0.3960854709148407,
0.20494407415390015,
-0.6373103857040405,
0.1403137892484665,
0.0664440393447876,
-0.26037877798080444,
-0.5768671035766602,
0.39120256900787354,
0.3716700077056885,
-0.022753417491912842,
-0.4278518855571747,
0.27552565932273865,
-0.666497528553009,
-0.15361645817756653,
-0.3031724989414215,
0.0681200698018074,
-0.04635252058506012,
0.38660430908203125,
0.044090449810028076,
0.7309935092926025,
0.48952755331993103,
-0.32139521837234497,
0.3317733108997345,
0.05747666209936142,
-0.4966092109680176,
0.30064916610717773,
-0.6021291613578796,
-0.1309099644422531,
-0.2677699029445648,
-0.07385066896677017,
-0.6324346661567688,
-0.2175523340702057,
0.007511577568948269,
-0.027746664360165596,
0.5840731859207153,
0.11434007436037064,
-1.0292550325393677,
-0.4206429719924927,
-0.17588093876838684,
0.4201646149158478,
0.2992698848247528,
-0.6552284359931946,
0.3186529278755188,
0.3225356638431549,
-0.43369561433792114,
-0.5861053466796875,
-0.45733872056007385,
0.12615619599819183,
-0.4742221236228943,
-0.5371326208114624,
0.46528151631355286,
-0.21732719242572784,
-0.3993924856185913,
-0.04941017925739288,
0.17947866022586823,
0.12113472819328308,
-0.03183649107813835,
0.07379449903964996,
0.2852170765399933,
-0.1885954588651657,
-0.0022945234086364508,
0.01756548509001732,
0.028750089928507805,
0.0591292530298233,
-0.11114390194416046,
0.6900460124015808,
-0.23690174520015717,
-0.23499107360839844,
-0.30706608295440674,
0.8665639162063599,
0.8689100742340088,
-0.6037095785140991,
0.8806747198104858,
0.8125911355018616,
-0.11291304230690002,
0.08142110705375671,
-0.6985948085784912,
-0.011810197494924068,
-0.4072897136211395,
0.7152290344238281,
-0.757319450378418,
-0.9021992087364197,
0.40320026874542236,
0.04130731150507927,
-0.03598839417099953,
0.2972750663757324,
0.7189419269561768,
0.2453981190919876,
0.9734290838241577,
0.7602559328079224,
-0.3067994713783264,
0.2749907970428467,
0.017478905618190765,
0.10711611062288284,
-0.7276145815849304,
-0.0654136911034584,
-0.6164631247520447,
0.010974876582622528,
-0.6634300947189331,
-0.6600211262702942,
0.22402247786521912,
0.23990590870380402,
-0.03225346654653549,
0.5655810236930847,
-0.1098882406949997,
0.3485463261604309,
0.6711990237236023,
0.006653554737567902,
0.5047938227653503,
0.29702073335647583,
-0.0657898336648941,
0.07384660094976425,
-0.6964024305343628,
-0.4188377559185028,
1.2197654247283936,
0.33938997983932495,
0.3983573019504547,
0.08365200459957123,
0.5738196969032288,
-0.22844161093235016,
0.13383939862251282,
-0.3908745050430298,
0.38109341263771057,
-0.4768339991569519,
-0.547651469707489,
-0.19802890717983246,
-0.578196108341217,
-0.8331855535507202,
0.5357680320739746,
-0.1576072871685028,
-0.3640253245830536,
0.2015368938446045,
-0.15070396661758423,
-0.15852662920951843,
0.31446346640586853,
-0.8335409164428711,
1.155093789100647,
-0.33815622329711914,
-0.40258920192718506,
-0.6200493574142456,
-0.4011431932449341,
0.3307005763053894,
-0.4764474034309387,
0.49616819620132446,
0.05382036790251732,
-0.15371085703372955,
0.38520750403404236,
-0.047959525138139725,
0.7575257420539856,
0.2061031460762024,
0.11299942433834076,
-0.013015576638281345,
-0.2890143394470215,
0.4010818898677826,
-0.06283782422542572,
-0.11512456834316254,
0.40015408396720886,
0.031398314982652664,
-0.5953468680381775,
-0.34244298934936523,
0.9831695556640625,
-0.796256422996521,
-0.7468441128730774,
-0.12529046833515167,
-0.9373456835746765,
-0.2668275535106659,
0.20097650587558746,
0.038615770637989044,
0.3311886787414551,
-0.17006994783878326,
0.23481175303459167,
0.3026869595050812,
-0.34774985909461975,
0.4510258138179779,
0.2715277373790741,
-0.1704714596271515,
-0.30297303199768066,
0.929767906665802,
0.03856976330280304,
0.5077409744262695,
0.5579927563667297,
0.02811923623085022,
-0.18641801178455353,
-0.5705475807189941,
-0.42866265773773193,
0.4783426523208618,
-0.5465074181556702,
0.05003275349736214,
-0.8864526152610779,
0.08646756410598755,
-0.6772408485412598,
0.11126736551523209,
-0.24511991441249847,
-0.3427107334136963,
-0.11677247285842896,
0.005150912329554558,
0.07471036165952682,
0.5577203035354614,
-0.37285760045051575,
0.14816763997077942,
-0.7964515686035156,
0.4358882009983063,
0.2241528481245041,
0.10071421414613724,
0.001532047986984253,
-0.07877975702285767,
-0.35225579142570496,
-0.10147600620985031,
-0.05513739958405495,
-0.6546462178230286,
0.48784610629081726,
-0.04156535118818283,
0.7185853719711304,
0.05192567780613899,
-0.13898245990276337,
0.7121804356575012,
-0.7512441277503967,
0.21069177985191345,
0.412282258272171,
-0.6147056818008423,
0.0331101231276989,
-0.41862356662750244,
0.3950529396533966,
0.4612094461917877,
0.8272008299827576,
-0.33482852578163147,
-0.48773133754730225,
-0.17169827222824097,
-0.8391816020011902,
0.6273107528686523,
0.20719259977340698,
-0.019260255619883537,
0.010067682713270187,
-0.08336349576711655,
0.2566758990287781,
0.43743547797203064,
-0.5943280458450317,
0.028294917196035385,
0.18648014962673187,
-0.17530296742916107,
-0.49832987785339355,
-0.2897941768169403,
-0.15403681993484497,
-0.21416719257831573,
0.37176984548568726,
0.017864810302853584,
-0.07606548815965652,
-0.14349859952926636,
-0.24882763624191284,
0.019039494916796684,
0.156661719083786,
0.4658616781234741,
0.654423177242279,
-0.049572814255952835,
0.0956604853272438,
0.07994082570075989,
-0.24321973323822021,
-0.3269456923007965,
0.31588152050971985,
0.26556554436683655,
0.0913410559296608,
0.2691855728626251,
0.7730169296264648,
0.38453489542007446,
-0.9175153374671936,
0.21090945601463318,
0.1235763430595398,
-0.03395189344882965,
-0.2197679728269577,
-0.29796144366264343,
0.3460145592689514,
0.43780720233917236,
0.00403221882879734,
0.23940585553646088,
0.1991170048713684,
-0.6791238188743591,
-0.012644208036363125,
0.2760823965072632,
0.2234022617340088,
-0.1796688288450241,
0.6350412368774414,
-0.3444646894931793,
-0.02701176516711712,
0.4894755184650421,
0.025871088728308678,
-0.5265553593635559,
0.6469436883926392,
0.6641179323196411,
0.40053242444992065,
-0.213629350066185,
0.12459666281938553,
0.43783333897590637,
0.3628924787044525,
-0.47334495186805725,
-0.19416876137256622,
-0.020585859194397926,
-0.3969729244709015,
-0.5916584134101868,
-0.8454480171203613,
-0.36990174651145935,
0.011159993708133698,
-0.7046508193016052,
0.3751547038555145,
-0.12376324832439423,
0.13548468053340912,
0.3787990212440491,
-0.24922378361225128,
-0.920896589756012,
-0.08222316205501556,
0.4497285783290863,
0.7125866413116455,
-0.7905210852622986,
0.9954376220703125,
0.5469978451728821,
-0.4060077667236328,
-0.5452160835266113,
-0.2033027559518814,
-0.07052388787269592,
-0.6681604981422424,
0.8428001999855042,
0.2504386305809021,
-0.004165361635386944,
-0.29027193784713745,
-0.0620681494474411,
-0.9459214210510254,
0.6196537017822266,
0.5609381794929504,
-0.8044388890266418,
-0.22559396922588348,
0.6726807355880737,
0.580531120300293,
-0.5493553280830383,
0.010931762866675854,
0.5135882496833801,
0.5316378474235535,
-0.07574862986803055,
-1.14906907081604,
0.05438314750790596,
-0.17961657047271729,
0.22216889262199402,
0.03568533807992935,
-0.4624752104282379,
0.8065020442008972,
-0.041416604071855545,
0.11388744413852692,
0.326686829328537,
0.6452834606170654,
0.30020517110824585,
0.18604762852191925,
0.5772219300270081,
0.4067762792110443,
0.5892961025238037,
0.2969180941581726,
1.2958006858825684,
-0.35916170477867126,
-0.02320532687008381,
1.1076486110687256,
-0.26427748799324036,
1.0483697652816772,
0.45699748396873474,
0.027798358350992203,
0.22029680013656616,
0.4981856644153595,
-0.1192191019654274,
0.5870120525360107,
0.22888772189617157,
-0.22686240077018738,
-0.3100787103176117,
-0.11826576292514801,
-0.28999680280685425,
0.4161771535873413,
0.4249301254749298,
-0.3602544963359833,
-0.18318255245685577,
0.5981258749961853,
0.1548423022031784,
0.37100982666015625,
-0.4159994423389435,
0.3296433985233307,
0.08220140635967255,
-0.9215933680534363,
0.5160626769065857,
0.07524461299180984,
0.6254891157150269,
-0.3142918646335602,
0.24565331637859344,
0.025440169498324394,
0.4571121633052826,
-0.027215490117669106,
-0.33065029978752136,
0.4841364324092865,
0.08020669966936111,
-0.4395637512207031,
-0.4481448829174042,
0.3941909968852997,
-0.7825182676315308,
-0.6403512358665466,
0.7753679156303406,
0.4299832284450531,
0.2139778882265091,
-0.4245315492153168,
-0.34915047883987427,
0.44656404852867126,
-0.24896979331970215,
0.21423394978046417,
0.7743284702301025,
0.44778722524642944,
-0.05952214449644089,
0.1559089869260788,
0.6749139428138733,
0.2416166067123413,
0.2633160650730133,
0.10709493607282639,
0.834789514541626,
-0.4395483434200287,
-0.28511959314346313,
-0.6551365852355957,
0.18687410652637482,
-0.29874879121780396,
-0.03581175580620766,
0.9720231294631958,
0.830623209476471,
1.215244174003601,
-0.30102023482322693,
0.6690906286239624,
0.27916327118873596,
0.5366724729537964,
-0.40271997451782227,
0.45106014609336853,
-0.6636700630187988,
0.25730955600738525,
-0.1979125440120697,
-0.9401364922523499,
-0.24971133470535278,
-0.023776670917868614,
-0.5500687956809998,
-0.30306732654571533,
0.9272609353065491,
0.8472033143043518,
-0.2003406584262848,
0.18235839903354645,
0.46033063530921936,
0.1521809697151184,
-0.04180667921900749,
0.6455742716789246,
0.630856454372406,
-0.31428757309913635,
0.8351417183876038,
-0.40589675307273865,
-0.2593010365962982,
0.020912010222673416,
-0.46519675850868225,
-1.015962839126587,
-0.3906383514404297,
-0.23062488436698914,
-0.052329227328300476,
0.2602821886539459,
0.6073191165924072,
0.652985692024231,
-0.8480280041694641,
-0.7204334139823914,
0.06236660107970238,
-0.11025123298168182,
-0.3611535429954529,
-0.1056213453412056,
0.20575766265392303,
-0.80392986536026,
-1.2474840879440308,
0.5018396377563477,
0.09885341674089432,
-0.4090782701969147,
-0.0876128301024437,
0.024452686309814453,
-0.23416690528392792,
-0.3463936746120453,
0.8339517116546631,
0.2969144582748413,
-0.5665360689163208,
0.10898999869823456,
0.20990435779094696,
-0.23943772912025452,
-0.21049758791923523,
0.9390909671783447,
-0.4034951627254486,
0.3386644124984741,
0.2800661325454712,
0.7572647929191589,
0.6584660410881042,
-0.3122651278972626,
0.7601619362831116,
-0.4926265776157379,
0.4190784692764282,
-0.03811552748084068,
0.37491148710250854,
0.443681001663208,
-0.318107008934021,
0.3739332854747772,
0.14467377960681915,
-0.34946346282958984,
-0.8212176561355591,
-0.0810331255197525,
-0.905632734298706,
-0.5229520797729492,
1.2990487813949585,
-0.17574486136436462,
-0.16110162436962128,
-0.03294576704502106,
-0.060249704867601395,
0.20031890273094177,
-0.07297006994485855,
0.39052873849868774,
0.7621533870697021,
0.15397045016288757,
-0.19040749967098236,
-1.0609276294708252,
0.2783168852329254,
0.5152628421783447,
-0.5538891553878784,
0.13541242480278015,
0.4132663905620575,
0.032431311905384064,
0.3566392660140991,
0.18495546281337738,
-0.36827966570854187,
0.1915958970785141,
-0.031120041385293007,
-0.16024930775165558,
-0.12744824588298798,
-0.6162891983985901,
-0.16967861354351044,
0.7542244791984558,
-0.13228029012680054,
-0.12230149656534195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00434v1 | Brevity is the soul of wit: Pruning long files for code generation | 2024-06-29T13:08:24 | 2024-06-29T13:08:24 | Aaditya K. Singh, Yu Yang, Kushal Tirumala, Mostafa Elhoushi, Ari S. Morcos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data curation is commonly considered a "secret-sauce" for LLM training, with
higher quality data usually leading to better LLM performance. Given the scale
of internet-scraped corpora, data pruning has become a larger and larger focus.
Specifically, many have shown that de-duplicating data, or sub-selecting higher
quality data, can lead to efficiency or performance improvements. Generally,
three types of methods are used to filter internet-scale corpora:
embedding-based, heuristic-based, and classifier-based. In this work, we
contrast the former two in the domain of finetuning LLMs for code generation.
We find that embedding-based methods are often confounded by length, and that a
simple heuristic--pruning long files--outperforms other methods in
compute-limited regimes. Our method can yield up to a 2x efficiency benefit in
training (while matching performance) or a 3.5% absolute performance
improvement on HumanEval (while matching compute). However, we find that
perplexity on held-out long files can increase, begging the question of whether
optimizing data mixtures for common coding benchmarks (HumanEval, MBPP)
actually best serves downstream use cases. Overall, we hope our work builds
useful intuitions about code data (specifically, the low quality of extremely
long code files) provides a compelling heuristic-based method for data pruning,
and brings to light questions in how we evaluate code generation models. | [
-0.4739208221435547,
-0.6058819890022278,
0.4766536056995392,
0.2153775542974472,
-0.4949824810028076,
0.24410170316696167,
-0.5928263068199158,
-0.29350098967552185,
0.10283756256103516,
0.27722764015197754,
-0.4241487383842468,
-0.6446080207824707,
-0.40342485904693604,
0.1973964124917984,
-0.46768832206726074,
0.9031875133514404,
0.1444837898015976,
-0.23288145661354065,
-0.47827112674713135,
-0.12358520925045013,
-0.45832979679107666,
-0.6002001762390137,
-0.37671852111816406,
-0.27431949973106384,
0.6759600043296814,
0.6891318559646606,
0.9085000157356262,
1.1157605648040771,
0.6544401049613953,
0.1648300439119339,
0.1203111782670021,
0.36355599761009216,
-0.8356281518936157,
0.10563866049051285,
0.08294814825057983,
-0.6494318842887878,
0.025541694834828377,
-0.04765433445572853,
0.27727121114730835,
0.8115977048873901,
-0.22194984555244446,
0.10409647971391678,
-0.09496373683214188,
0.9429441094398499,
-0.8208248615264893,
-0.2314307540655136,
-0.5436816215515137,
0.31329676508903503,
-0.3028530478477478,
-0.583458423614502,
-0.27471843361854553,
-0.5020060539245605,
-0.36021995544433594,
-0.5071322321891785,
0.4582359194755554,
0.24119970202445984,
0.8464478850364685,
0.3948310315608978,
0.0034679188393056393,
-0.47127315402030945,
-0.8569979667663574,
0.9593411684036255,
-0.7643342018127441,
0.2506192624568939,
0.48249736428260803,
0.214625746011734,
-0.052057940512895584,
-0.6897029876708984,
-0.35834839940071106,
0.008010810241103172,
-0.05847316235303879,
-0.005855883937329054,
-0.1461360603570938,
0.011039790697395802,
0.5717523097991943,
0.729017972946167,
-0.47493231296539307,
0.2797287404537201,
-0.8166635632514954,
-0.28220799565315247,
0.7023762464523315,
-0.037711579352617264,
-0.0017053314950317144,
-0.061441075056791306,
-0.2377898395061493,
-0.06840654462575912,
-1.1352812051773071,
-0.10620110481977463,
0.8191947937011719,
0.012665166519582272,
0.3407287001609802,
0.644690752029419,
-0.1594199389219284,
0.575459897518158,
-0.173309326171875,
-0.43086615204811096,
0.11576010286808014,
-0.2553292214870453,
-0.24106505513191223,
0.007685075048357248,
0.5698691010475159,
0.5058904886245728,
0.46105122566223145,
-0.3417334258556366,
-0.4515511691570282,
0.4707951247692108,
0.531109094619751,
-0.9584145545959473,
-0.5399754643440247,
0.31758514046669006,
-0.31726160645484924,
-0.35891756415367126,
0.0032790505792945623,
-0.4651625454425812,
-0.10811428725719452,
-0.5009662508964539,
0.07513298094272614,
-0.7226418256759644,
0.07989677041769028,
0.2110942006111145,
-0.3140070140361786,
0.27385222911834717,
0.21720772981643677,
-0.6175183057785034,
0.1483883559703827,
1.056647777557373,
0.8409066796302795,
-0.20440390706062317,
0.014974864199757576,
-0.9294260740280151,
0.055059920996427536,
-0.44981351494789124,
0.5867890119552612,
-0.5953773260116577,
-0.568108081817627,
0.052145831286907196,
-0.21591298282146454,
0.30012792348861694,
-0.7862589955329895,
0.6380288004875183,
-0.36494725942611694,
-0.053583111613988876,
-0.2712206244468689,
-0.8007550835609436,
-0.1160162091255188,
-0.002319402527064085,
-0.5764201283454895,
1.0370737314224243,
0.279649943113327,
-0.8214634656906128,
0.6958657503128052,
-0.2847381830215454,
-0.7584261894226074,
0.10213848203420639,
-0.2887447774410248,
-0.6445149183273315,
0.3400656282901764,
-0.0007697741384617984,
0.5499609112739563,
-0.23838433623313904,
0.5856857895851135,
-0.38381972908973694,
-0.7274746298789978,
0.11579090356826782,
-0.3842112123966217,
0.4132731258869171,
0.6042901277542114,
-0.07926012575626373,
-0.18219825625419617,
-0.7427607774734497,
-0.006836789194494486,
0.010600796900689602,
-0.6855077147483826,
-0.3373853266239166,
0.12474976480007172,
-0.16352206468582153,
0.14761456847190857,
0.0031653018668293953,
-0.5890389084815979,
0.14330090582370758,
-0.33856552839279175,
0.6825069785118103,
0.6770950555801392,
-0.07121513038873672,
0.382530152797699,
-0.7782608270645142,
0.46892887353897095,
0.14047442376613617,
0.18099498748779297,
-0.08940154314041138,
-0.19679582118988037,
-0.8321720361709595,
-0.2545241713523865,
0.34316182136535645,
0.37758004665374756,
-0.6106474995613098,
0.4232698082923889,
-0.3619072735309601,
-0.50093674659729,
-0.6264630556106567,
0.5535499453544617,
0.3168756067752838,
0.30660775303840637,
0.2894638478755951,
-0.5740262269973755,
-0.5119729042053223,
-0.9577092528343201,
-0.1831389218568802,
0.1546802520751953,
-0.03800256550312042,
0.15146544575691223,
0.40760666131973267,
-0.09153541177511215,
1.1456876993179321,
-0.5165095329284668,
0.1826825588941574,
-0.18781760334968567,
-0.11112728714942932,
0.1868264377117157,
0.6707490086555481,
0.3861190378665924,
-0.7367866635322571,
-0.26747262477874756,
-0.3261494040489197,
-0.6171920895576477,
-0.07589302957057953,
-0.31247207522392273,
-0.13563694059848785,
0.06686917692422867,
0.4095078408718109,
-0.35877367854118347,
0.560620903968811,
0.2985338568687439,
0.03028026968240738,
0.5166224241256714,
-0.2600874602794647,
-0.07754955440759659,
-0.6219097971916199,
0.0006635359604842961,
0.016899798065423965,
-0.39230769872665405,
-0.5007378458976746,
0.1951874941587448,
0.20725879073143005,
-0.011384001933038235,
-0.41279107332229614,
0.07668347656726837,
-0.5916142463684082,
-0.328061580657959,
-0.05238836258649826,
0.16304247081279755,
0.2750490605831146,
0.6025215983390808,
-0.1537095606327057,
0.8000564575195312,
0.366951584815979,
-0.7462800145149231,
0.33686041831970215,
-0.035894136875867844,
-0.34351828694343567,
0.5247753858566284,
-0.6351025700569153,
0.3315911293029785,
-0.08485537767410278,
-0.1896713376045227,
-0.6350776553153992,
-0.026018880307674408,
-0.07412578165531158,
-0.2806915044784546,
0.5319735407829285,
-0.39001065492630005,
-0.812256932258606,
-0.3955041766166687,
-0.7518807649612427,
0.09456847608089447,
0.7546887993812561,
-0.640396773815155,
-0.06776686012744904,
0.027247484773397446,
-0.056922294199466705,
-0.37176963686943054,
-0.8563959002494812,
-0.01310043130069971,
-0.6044256687164307,
-0.7940913438796997,
0.44710713624954224,
-0.241026371717453,
-0.32937049865722656,
-0.23021303117275238,
-0.31052765250205994,
0.06754767894744873,
0.2639811933040619,
0.33398956060409546,
0.06913761794567108,
-0.0870203822851181,
0.10163868218660355,
0.04867839068174362,
0.10184799134731293,
0.021535418927669525,
-0.09689898788928986,
0.46270135045051575,
0.11480851471424103,
-0.5242670178413391,
-0.024380456656217575,
0.4422971308231354,
0.2455347627401352,
-0.09600619971752167,
0.45539870858192444,
0.6683043241500854,
0.02586289308965206,
-0.4013628363609314,
-0.6687262654304504,
-0.1701555997133255,
-0.47291937470436096,
-0.11347255110740662,
-0.2687923312187195,
-0.8988749980926514,
0.2876790761947632,
-0.29332828521728516,
0.39453843235969543,
0.11239191144704819,
0.15640541911125183,
-0.1855347603559494,
0.6130968928337097,
0.7379646301269531,
-0.05865978077054024,
0.46082550287246704,
-0.5301876068115234,
0.3613097369670868,
-0.7064396142959595,
0.011887816712260246,
-0.5622580647468567,
-0.5012730360031128,
-0.5599149465560913,
-0.48028191924095154,
0.18590356409549713,
0.31424832344055176,
-0.08812344074249268,
0.21030248701572418,
-0.7166066765785217,
0.37960124015808105,
0.7189141511917114,
0.1133488118648529,
0.4399319589138031,
0.2702266573905945,
0.15437886118888855,
-0.009171782061457634,
-1.0580512285232544,
-0.49520933628082275,
1.2132936716079712,
0.4398510754108429,
0.8115012645721436,
0.0012027380289509892,
1.0354958772659302,
0.18935339152812958,
0.22718048095703125,
-0.9583001732826233,
0.41264644265174866,
-0.17699113488197327,
-0.20536921918392181,
-0.08773292601108551,
-0.5155888795852661,
-0.9492802619934082,
-0.06762935221195221,
0.04874851554632187,
-0.18451720476150513,
0.2538301348686218,
0.11792328208684921,
-0.38285213708877563,
0.30969682335853577,
-0.790547788143158,
0.4366452693939209,
-0.044880423694849014,
-0.6944257616996765,
-0.30162134766578674,
-0.5907676815986633,
0.2979142367839813,
-0.12615181505680084,
0.3886740505695343,
-0.06088370829820633,
-0.04552151635289192,
0.8868096470832825,
-0.9032195806503296,
0.6309056878089905,
-0.09553404897451401,
0.02308688312768936,
0.3524417281150818,
0.22062727808952332,
0.50568687915802,
0.06518376618623734,
-0.03746185451745987,
0.03718767315149307,
-0.08523601293563843,
-0.5246073603630066,
-0.420805424451828,
0.7021160125732422,
-0.6208626627922058,
-0.6548574566841125,
-0.04313454031944275,
-0.37682417035102844,
-0.09940958023071289,
-0.08999153226613998,
0.4480115473270416,
0.6528863906860352,
0.3125438094139099,
0.5338951945304871,
0.7895662188529968,
-0.36813703179359436,
0.554690957069397,
0.17255337536334991,
0.10948842018842697,
-0.3165963888168335,
0.9231602549552917,
0.26642534136772156,
0.30292052030563354,
0.20831450819969177,
0.1872241199016571,
0.06694072484970093,
-0.7708934545516968,
-0.16387617588043213,
0.3004402816295624,
-0.7865085601806641,
-0.4897698760032654,
-0.4096924364566803,
-0.1491546332836151,
-0.22500289976596832,
-0.49961715936660767,
-0.15877430140972137,
-0.46149662137031555,
-0.23482215404510498,
-0.10249371826648712,
0.6688610315322876,
0.5565870404243469,
-0.13750781118869781,
0.3639156222343445,
-0.7382509708404541,
0.1484518051147461,
0.05378960445523262,
0.3284893035888672,
-0.2884235680103302,
-0.4204205572605133,
-0.4273810088634491,
-0.04027830436825752,
-0.27374139428138733,
-0.671998143196106,
0.5018439292907715,
0.21164719760417938,
0.4365239441394806,
0.3462507724761963,
0.10375658422708511,
0.7866619825363159,
-0.22045452892780304,
0.6306383013725281,
0.10719598829746246,
-0.5243530869483948,
0.5319094657897949,
-0.11261376738548279,
0.11702746152877808,
0.8697514533996582,
0.38308775424957275,
-0.38151100277900696,
-0.4068843722343445,
-0.7608839869499207,
-0.9639378786087036,
0.3608524203300476,
0.19071051478385925,
-0.04090962931513786,
-0.060702722519636154,
0.42646193504333496,
0.38426870107650757,
0.6130280494689941,
-0.25143805146217346,
-0.12587985396385193,
-0.13549372553825378,
-0.07737511396408081,
0.023657960817217827,
-0.18672899901866913,
-0.2433607429265976,
-0.2929079532623291,
0.46449559926986694,
-0.18302913010120392,
0.24825121462345123,
0.2776419222354889,
-0.42039674520492554,
0.038521040230989456,
0.2330598086118698,
0.3155011236667633,
0.806369960308075,
-0.10336369276046753,
0.13043968379497528,
-0.21218056976795197,
-0.5677889585494995,
-0.16174861788749695,
-0.26112645864486694,
-0.22175073623657227,
0.08411945402622223,
0.33918118476867676,
0.6856231689453125,
0.11514004319906235,
-0.59224534034729,
0.5278637409210205,
0.23829105496406555,
-0.36750349402427673,
-0.2897489070892334,
0.3997490704059601,
-0.014016603119671345,
-0.15502282977104187,
0.2267284393310547,
0.07853297144174576,
0.16894018650054932,
-0.6204577088356018,
0.1343327909708023,
0.21695782244205475,
0.16057345271110535,
-0.04235101491212845,
0.2390860617160797,
0.1439017504453659,
-0.2547508776187897,
0.8260790705680847,
-0.35299569368362427,
-0.30148035287857056,
0.7117583751678467,
0.21602989733219147,
0.5582489967346191,
0.3774814307689667,
-0.04030754417181015,
0.2604631781578064,
0.21338580548763275,
-0.2031499743461609,
0.34657737612724304,
-0.4227759540081024,
-0.44254007935523987,
-0.624001681804657,
-0.7436774373054504,
-0.22909432649612427,
-0.03191017732024193,
-0.5665795207023621,
0.30420413613319397,
-0.6711951494216919,
-0.02722116932272911,
-0.1777137815952301,
0.35201960802078247,
-0.9995094537734985,
0.03333744406700134,
-0.03702155128121376,
1.2186552286148071,
-0.758678138256073,
0.81651771068573,
0.4149797558784485,
-0.4150817096233368,
-0.9510685205459595,
-0.149680495262146,
-0.2268475592136383,
-0.6296464204788208,
0.3641403913497925,
0.27932751178741455,
0.18772083520889282,
-0.08022590726613998,
-0.6213945746421814,
-0.5637305378913879,
1.233730435371399,
0.2809157967567444,
-1.0077481269836426,
-0.1019037663936615,
0.026607777923345566,
0.3731992840766907,
-0.10054834932088852,
-0.10583524405956268,
0.824917733669281,
0.5656334161758423,
0.07774674147367477,
-0.5771838426589966,
0.000597743783146143,
-0.23870603740215302,
0.10275806486606598,
0.27614474296569824,
-0.6049691438674927,
0.6018751859664917,
-0.31829962134361267,
-0.38011178374290466,
-0.2366473376750946,
0.37314853072166443,
0.2828940749168396,
0.46124958992004395,
0.3756018877029419,
0.6941521167755127,
0.8182733654975891,
-0.1764063537120819,
0.9658721685409546,
-0.45348095893859863,
0.1342121660709381,
0.8279466032981873,
-0.18882521986961365,
0.5791416168212891,
0.8248251080513,
-0.4404199719429016,
0.42012450098991394,
0.8235428929328918,
-0.28427737951278687,
0.503092348575592,
0.5295771360397339,
-0.02875366620719433,
-0.18416240811347961,
0.1505337357521057,
-0.09314233064651489,
0.12307487428188324,
0.39181485772132874,
-0.16808471083641052,
-0.13509318232536316,
-0.012940083630383015,
0.23311732709407806,
0.20179994404315948,
-0.13194045424461365,
0.7941960096359253,
0.16620482504367828,
-0.7930462956428528,
0.6749474406242371,
0.057154830545186996,
1.104533076286316,
-0.2908085286617279,
0.10679944604635239,
-0.47238054871559143,
-0.11347944289445877,
-0.5781040191650391,
-0.8242697715759277,
0.4909258782863617,
0.02142750844359398,
-0.036461230367422104,
-0.27422985434532166,
0.7853891253471375,
-0.1923138052225113,
-0.16592460870742798,
0.05833077430725098,
0.5360336303710938,
0.37023258209228516,
-0.07244901359081268,
-0.40543434023857117,
0.21925891935825348,
0.04064420238137245,
-0.24267733097076416,
0.40860170125961304,
0.6082882285118103,
0.019276896491646767,
0.6755586266517639,
0.8632572889328003,
0.302781879901886,
0.03349234163761139,
0.10433272272348404,
1.077788233757019,
-0.6518537402153015,
-0.406583696603775,
-0.8866854310035706,
0.2600894272327423,
-0.1700063794851303,
-0.0773431658744812,
0.5777899622917175,
0.8678274750709534,
0.9835829734802246,
0.038944121450185776,
0.8028467893600464,
-0.0203709676861763,
0.272758424282074,
-0.593913733959198,
0.23350654542446136,
-0.2735915780067444,
0.5524441003799438,
0.027235491201281548,
-0.8783944249153137,
-0.20077574253082275,
0.48500561714172363,
-0.4476075768470764,
-0.02996523678302765,
0.6751046776771545,
0.9244877696037292,
-0.13523927330970764,
-0.006382032297551632,
0.43775704503059387,
-0.1774131804704666,
0.2353767454624176,
0.6543806791305542,
0.6773276925086975,
-0.16280129551887512,
0.6465387344360352,
-0.715083122253418,
0.08676344156265259,
-0.4254024028778076,
-0.8717631101608276,
-0.6779991984367371,
-0.3018518090248108,
-0.39624151587486267,
-0.10548728704452515,
0.12389219552278519,
0.7734192609786987,
0.7346642017364502,
-0.31727251410484314,
-0.06031803786754608,
-0.22438044846057892,
0.12477686256170273,
-0.10674558579921722,
-0.21079953014850616,
-0.004266447853296995,
-0.41035592555999756,
-0.349365770816803,
0.38383468985557556,
0.2889367938041687,
-0.1374785304069519,
-0.5029523968696594,
-0.1100638136267662,
0.12727664411067963,
0.059322651475667953,
0.55091792345047,
0.1716897338628769,
-0.3604051470756531,
-0.22739370167255402,
-0.03943099454045296,
-0.13748441636562347,
0.30400002002716064,
1.1044790744781494,
-0.9838117957115173,
0.13126620650291443,
0.4558962285518646,
0.5105652213096619,
0.5214198231697083,
0.04532570391893387,
0.5223824381828308,
-1.051519751548767,
0.08713996410369873,
0.27705511450767517,
0.4168579876422882,
0.6699374914169312,
-0.5969046950340271,
0.8267809748649597,
0.24700385332107544,
-0.6078577041625977,
-0.9952787756919861,
0.14365670084953308,
-0.7764339447021484,
-0.3675350546836853,
1.292456030845642,
-0.19595350325107574,
-0.35399776697158813,
-0.018792983144521713,
-0.17348715662956238,
0.26178082823753357,
-0.47914573550224304,
0.5210120677947998,
0.6203480958938599,
-0.03422442078590393,
0.06834202259778976,
-0.8171614408493042,
0.60515296459198,
0.30083879828453064,
-0.6372374296188354,
0.08494648337364197,
0.7481902837753296,
0.43058931827545166,
0.15416638553142548,
0.3752950131893158,
-0.10333770513534546,
0.33738383650779724,
-0.019579008221626282,
-0.10931812226772308,
-0.3779706656932831,
-0.40660661458969116,
-0.2844567894935608,
0.3396277129650116,
0.26726239919662476,
0.02145257778465748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00418v1 | eFontes. Part of Speech Tagging and Lemmatization of Medieval Latin Texts.A Cross-Genre Survey | 2024-06-29T11:59:20 | 2024-06-29T11:59:20 | Krzysztof Nowak, Jędrzej Ziębura, Krzysztof Wróbel, Aleksander Smywiński-Pohl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This study introduces the eFontes models for automatic linguistic annotation
of Medieval Latin texts, focusing on lemmatization, part-of-speech tagging, and
morphological feature determination. Using the Transformers library, these
models were trained on Universal Dependencies (UD) corpora and the newly
developed eFontes corpus of Polish Medieval Latin. The research evaluates the
models' performance, addressing challenges such as orthographic variations and
the integration of Latinized vernacular terms. The models achieved high
accuracy rates: lemmatization at 92.60%, part-of-speech tagging at 83.29%, and
morphological feature determination at 88.57%. The findings underscore the
importance of high-quality annotated corpora and propose future enhancements,
including extending the models to Named Entity Recognition. | [
-0.5712621808052063,
-0.49452099204063416,
0.37869298458099365,
0.12904450297355652,
-0.14516539871692657,
-0.17687241733074188,
-0.14849503338336945,
-1.1072369813919067,
0.5338579416275024,
0.4241165816783905,
-0.4317992329597473,
-0.6696149110794067,
-0.49321234226226807,
0.6442914605140686,
-0.6391823291778564,
0.8087867498397827,
-0.061724431812763214,
0.07568975538015366,
0.04758559167385101,
0.2593746483325958,
0.08403749763965607,
-0.7407197952270508,
-0.4871901571750641,
-0.2449992299079895,
0.5479618906974792,
0.13259124755859375,
0.5638852119445801,
0.7601034641265869,
0.505801260471344,
0.34493309259414673,
-0.0911201611161232,
0.192101389169693,
-0.395541787147522,
0.4202190339565277,
-0.24021288752555847,
-0.5347943902015686,
-0.4451133608818054,
0.19609424471855164,
0.5516045093536377,
0.5396104454994202,
0.12736579775810242,
0.04916298761963844,
-0.19921758770942688,
0.033910613507032394,
-0.3802192211151123,
0.23588082194328308,
-0.6394652724266052,
0.20471934974193573,
-0.4091914892196655,
-0.4225766956806183,
-0.46589720249176025,
-0.061169058084487915,
0.4256424605846405,
-0.846751868724823,
0.517926812171936,
0.25709229707717896,
1.006001591682434,
0.2620270252227783,
0.03755144774913788,
-0.5309013724327087,
-0.931293785572052,
0.7514535188674927,
-0.2952752709388733,
0.646983802318573,
0.5213207602500916,
-0.0018417604733258486,
-0.12794862687587738,
-0.9658495187759399,
-0.22735993564128876,
-0.3675650358200073,
-0.3108558654785156,
-0.03492734953761101,
-0.32381540536880493,
-0.012614710256457329,
0.20678262412548065,
0.22270448505878448,
-0.3155277371406555,
0.2982208728790283,
-0.5704671144485474,
-0.3656485974788666,
0.6741995811462402,
0.02379927597939968,
0.27402427792549133,
-0.09594922512769699,
-0.5565732717514038,
0.04930449649691582,
-0.8797631859779358,
0.007300522644072771,
0.5885897874832153,
0.36198779940605164,
0.20476539433002472,
0.580133318901062,
0.11840687692165375,
0.7855077385902405,
0.1154392883181572,
-0.4522978663444519,
0.2105197161436081,
-0.11695455014705658,
-0.30693304538726807,
0.209104984998703,
0.6940756440162659,
0.07393161952495575,
0.4341660737991333,
-0.5187228322029114,
-0.11902543902397156,
-0.20113372802734375,
0.2515009939670563,
-0.643909752368927,
-0.23684179782867432,
0.07755845040082932,
-0.10170318931341171,
-0.1629493683576584,
0.3722786009311676,
-0.6943802237510681,
-0.2081112265586853,
-0.3953297436237335,
0.1580897867679596,
-0.5584045648574829,
-0.09334618598222733,
-0.13181084394454956,
-0.21000894904136658,
-0.061170175671577454,
0.5202979445457458,
-1.1868122816085815,
0.2129838615655899,
0.8137174248695374,
0.7230063080787659,
-0.2037610113620758,
-0.49921396374702454,
-0.38192328810691833,
0.2694864273071289,
-0.05744854360818863,
1.31141996383667,
-0.7412927150726318,
-0.5052175521850586,
0.025450658053159714,
0.5361747145652771,
-0.2269512265920639,
-0.19228044152259827,
1.118281602859497,
-0.23759280145168304,
-0.05430615693330765,
-0.038034673780202866,
-0.7612688541412354,
-0.37624043226242065,
-0.11262742429971695,
-0.8924894332885742,
1.2045178413391113,
0.0890938937664032,
-0.7762780785560608,
0.1914757341146469,
-0.28629329800605774,
-0.3117581903934479,
0.021041076630353928,
-0.23151694238185883,
-0.15507300198078156,
0.2298993617296219,
-0.024152971804142,
0.47595155239105225,
-0.46767687797546387,
0.0007819668389856815,
-0.13341684639453888,
-0.45868706703186035,
0.19290341436862946,
-0.08092446625232697,
0.7838712930679321,
0.1345604807138443,
-0.35550370812416077,
-0.027659649029374123,
-0.9251372218132019,
-0.23986147344112396,
-0.17084817588329315,
-0.015584000386297703,
-0.662067711353302,
0.07777407020330429,
0.4599306881427765,
0.16316640377044678,
0.08056551218032837,
-0.8301246762275696,
-0.07231743633747101,
-0.644626259803772,
0.3203776776790619,
0.445700466632843,
-0.2823977470397949,
0.2723442018032074,
-0.3347173035144806,
0.6538288593292236,
-0.23991283774375916,
0.005395272746682167,
-0.2146482616662979,
-0.8053869605064392,
-0.7611009478569031,
-0.6938227415084839,
0.8110421299934387,
0.6726930737495422,
-0.46451854705810547,
0.5981668829917908,
-0.036962974816560745,
-0.6891326904296875,
-0.6682677865028381,
-0.24544379115104675,
0.11675772070884705,
0.5511502623558044,
0.3334430754184723,
0.04682222381234169,
-0.828302264213562,
-0.9911030530929565,
0.10633357614278793,
-0.22154268622398376,
-0.029989752918481827,
-0.17168988287448883,
0.7176423072814941,
0.030343955382704735,
1.0714728832244873,
-0.14762689173221588,
-0.35760289430618286,
0.1901436448097229,
0.34589844942092896,
-0.3095725476741791,
0.3132379949092865,
0.8359394073486328,
-0.9643422365188599,
-0.559318482875824,
0.03015395626425743,
-0.09227340668439865,
-0.5869214534759521,
0.3810591995716095,
0.03204621374607086,
0.1935739666223526,
0.40744563937187195,
-0.15537257492542267,
0.44233986735343933,
0.45771074295043945,
-0.2807374894618988,
0.4703048765659332,
-0.22035154700279236,
0.32424598932266235,
-0.9611700177192688,
0.22212077677249908,
0.12915253639221191,
-0.423163503408432,
-0.730961263179779,
-0.21006664633750916,
-0.10729148983955383,
0.15467722713947296,
-0.680060088634491,
0.43702635169029236,
-0.46960312128067017,
-0.1217433512210846,
-0.1620980054140091,
0.2524450719356537,
0.11123582720756531,
0.18871788680553436,
0.3402966856956482,
0.6328482627868652,
0.3822682201862335,
-0.29887855052948,
0.5825156569480896,
0.06746497750282288,
0.0091075599193573,
0.8844016194343567,
-0.7730565071105957,
-0.014548886567354202,
-0.11463595926761627,
-0.05535469949245453,
-1.0577030181884766,
-0.13848674297332764,
0.05023001506924629,
-0.5179020762443542,
0.29604193568229675,
-0.39742499589920044,
-0.6159310340881348,
-0.0222957544028759,
-0.2662038207054138,
-0.11202799528837204,
0.20050546526908875,
-0.42948007583618164,
0.7276066541671753,
0.601097822189331,
-0.3232133686542511,
-0.6374363303184509,
-0.7125213742256165,
-0.07108566164970398,
-0.1577373445034027,
-0.8207436203956604,
1.076149821281433,
0.22206632792949677,
-0.3023129999637604,
0.08620485663414001,
0.485807329416275,
-0.21527840197086334,
0.13510191440582275,
0.43625983595848083,
0.355241984128952,
-0.0504031628370285,
0.20785683393478394,
0.034328997135162354,
-0.2961515188217163,
-0.35901403427124023,
-0.1745091676712036,
0.6327915787696838,
-0.10684365034103394,
-0.17186421155929565,
-0.3749220073223114,
0.6811400651931763,
0.37234580516815186,
-0.4624003767967224,
0.6693762540817261,
0.7435928583145142,
-0.6224305629730225,
-0.19787324965000153,
-0.5236587524414062,
0.1978437900543213,
-0.3616498112678528,
0.24137425422668457,
-0.5034107565879822,
-1.1875077486038208,
0.7990679144859314,
0.02720622904598713,
0.12041089683771133,
1.1124227046966553,
0.5970963835716248,
-0.275770902633667,
0.7515091896057129,
0.9929974675178528,
0.4263491928577423,
0.3162572681903839,
-0.168403759598732,
-0.0958741158246994,
-0.5518003702163696,
-0.2885133624076843,
-1.0807397365570068,
-0.07885397225618362,
-0.8995713591575623,
-0.36821267008781433,
0.10490287840366364,
0.08009800314903259,
0.22502197325229645,
0.5602238774299622,
-0.523438572883606,
0.19528155028820038,
0.37495148181915283,
-0.6115354299545288,
0.45880043506622314,
0.439797967672348,
-0.39950141310691833,
-0.19859491288661957,
-0.25613468885421753,
-0.7798065543174744,
0.8063898682594299,
0.5062618255615234,
0.7664748430252075,
0.008805708028376102,
0.8104856610298157,
0.3650168478488922,
0.3380427062511444,
-0.8567562103271484,
0.11919591575860977,
-0.4432273805141449,
-0.6911298632621765,
-0.26814329624176025,
-0.11772922426462173,
-0.8535289764404297,
0.2752656638622284,
-0.2544950842857361,
-0.9116173982620239,
0.7183906435966492,
-0.11621449887752533,
-0.6925706267356873,
0.13648101687431335,
-0.5066908001899719,
0.7487992644309998,
0.045767538249492645,
-0.017707722261548042,
0.22652630507946014,
-0.43163225054740906,
-0.21984410285949707,
-0.21559831500053406,
0.12351474910974503,
-0.16555839776992798,
-0.42158976197242737,
0.8363329768180847,
-0.27178385853767395,
0.8007010817527771,
0.25162672996520996,
-0.3545667231082916,
0.3263466954231262,
-0.16578851640224457,
0.29161253571510315,
-0.2074696272611618,
-0.31423357129096985,
0.1758524775505066,
0.4672866463661194,
0.00023637728008907288,
-0.19665144383907318,
0.7513401508331299,
-0.6582841873168945,
-0.18778741359710693,
-0.6255577206611633,
-0.2738201320171356,
-0.09293370693922043,
-0.051082637161016464,
0.4992717504501343,
0.3644125759601593,
-0.6604424715042114,
0.04158081114292145,
0.6109569072723389,
0.12772952020168304,
0.5958900451660156,
0.6890420317649841,
-0.3698825538158417,
-0.6142997145652771,
0.61024010181427,
0.4898221492767334,
-0.045072250068187714,
0.27949896454811096,
-0.1521354466676712,
-0.3172166049480438,
-0.326339989900589,
-0.673094630241394,
0.2916751205921173,
-0.6905416250228882,
-0.05405541509389877,
-0.8248651027679443,
-0.23859724402427673,
-0.5066099762916565,
-0.20060433447360992,
-0.4363251030445099,
-0.7537009119987488,
-0.5336673855781555,
-0.0910656750202179,
0.536298930644989,
0.9589459300041199,
-0.16258810460567474,
0.4741714298725128,
-0.7564406394958496,
-0.11073152720928192,
0.047528933733701706,
0.04664122313261032,
-0.2910359799861908,
-0.5249325037002563,
-0.27113574743270874,
-0.22822348773479462,
-0.11635531485080719,
-1.239793300628662,
0.5074694752693176,
0.4118308126926422,
0.6009657382965088,
0.2355847954750061,
-0.2963269352912903,
0.2379351705312729,
-0.7634912133216858,
0.6123365163803101,
0.13816484808921814,
-0.8196001052856445,
0.27168142795562744,
-0.2827332615852356,
-0.2570131719112396,
0.4669484496116638,
0.792203426361084,
-0.5763222575187683,
-0.34815743565559387,
-0.5606212615966797,
-0.6685854196548462,
0.5780081748962402,
0.07843352854251862,
-0.1789495199918747,
-0.1951594054698944,
0.3047584295272827,
0.4343864619731903,
0.014828301966190338,
-0.44309812784194946,
-0.40159913897514343,
0.12967340648174286,
-0.2466064989566803,
0.02182072028517723,
-0.2792834937572479,
0.08238683640956879,
-0.4285208582878113,
0.7423979640007019,
0.14319609105587006,
0.36811432242393494,
0.5249031782150269,
-0.3992606997489929,
-0.15989775955677032,
0.41294044256210327,
0.9412930011749268,
0.8216961026191711,
-0.2290414273738861,
0.24016757309436798,
-0.117613784968853,
-0.719796895980835,
0.3052527904510498,
0.7584376931190491,
-0.4830309748649597,
0.5125094652175903,
0.20822155475616455,
0.7704159617424011,
0.21244695782661438,
-0.30207255482673645,
0.19889943301677704,
0.14115209877490997,
0.049701906740665436,
-0.7177087068557739,
-0.10856641083955765,
0.19307492673397064,
0.1633075326681137,
0.6005361676216125,
-0.025992384180426598,
0.15857818722724915,
-0.5784285068511963,
0.2643887996673584,
-0.012434128671884537,
-0.5180128812789917,
-0.5411584377288818,
0.4580603539943695,
0.1209988221526146,
-0.3467576205730438,
0.046105965971946716,
-0.18881933391094208,
-0.7606109380722046,
0.6138084530830383,
0.6111560463905334,
0.8730530738830566,
-0.6930901408195496,
0.39220863580703735,
0.29598772525787354,
0.5505106449127197,
-0.04740030691027641,
0.3797571361064911,
0.34530550241470337,
-0.4270284175872803,
-0.4594325125217438,
-1.0125515460968018,
-0.37091293931007385,
-0.36891913414001465,
-0.31875306367874146,
0.4990004599094391,
-0.2287837117910385,
-0.6569075584411621,
0.4219302833080292,
-0.08695559203624725,
-0.6368411183357239,
0.21342098712921143,
0.26011282205581665,
0.7350799441337585,
-0.797196626663208,
0.9679865837097168,
0.7925418019294739,
-0.5887508392333984,
-0.4662919044494629,
-0.4498276114463806,
-0.0735047310590744,
-0.4163486957550049,
1.0488022565841675,
-0.03667139634490013,
-0.40911388397216797,
0.21369048953056335,
-0.17825143039226532,
-1.0211734771728516,
0.9969186186790466,
0.40184661746025085,
-0.6631329655647278,
-0.14878447353839874,
0.4195907711982727,
0.8469487428665161,
-0.9634239077568054,
0.41095057129859924,
0.5746488571166992,
0.5201897621154785,
0.2000880241394043,
-1.324940800666809,
-0.40213099122047424,
-0.3041509687900543,
-0.05751831457018852,
0.25396212935447693,
-0.3749818205833435,
1.2010036706924438,
0.20173977315425873,
-0.25803330540657043,
0.18275883793830872,
0.8239330649375916,
-0.22863340377807617,
-0.035873062908649445,
0.3205697238445282,
0.847500205039978,
0.8084332942962646,
-0.3321760594844818,
0.855668306350708,
-0.31162193417549133,
0.467534601688385,
1.0031369924545288,
-0.22565722465515137,
1.005628228187561,
0.3531694710254669,
-0.22629152238368988,
0.49069783091545105,
0.9005346298217773,
-0.3032006621360779,
0.22531332075595856,
0.18316729366779327,
-0.30648213624954224,
-0.16545137763023376,
-0.45152950286865234,
-0.5440621376037598,
0.7132123112678528,
0.4592348039150238,
-0.8870781064033508,
-0.12113777548074722,
0.06291964650154114,
0.29408586025238037,
-0.12190787494182587,
-0.21179071068763733,
0.45718544721603394,
0.03725819289684296,
-0.5520892143249512,
0.44817471504211426,
0.5063605308532715,
0.7975092530250549,
-0.48433947563171387,
-0.17806817591190338,
0.18493346869945526,
-0.028351036831736565,
-0.30517202615737915,
-0.36741146445274353,
0.3640945553779602,
0.26394861936569214,
-0.2428789585828781,
-0.06405685842037201,
0.7498111724853516,
-0.6620481610298157,
-0.8460039496421814,
0.43739113211631775,
0.45888638496398926,
0.2290932983160019,
0.19293992221355438,
-0.37580960988998413,
0.06950010359287262,
-0.16818532347679138,
-0.008606553077697754,
0.07878772914409637,
0.27213504910469055,
0.10591061413288116,
0.03264375403523445,
0.36108633875846863,
0.18111014366149902,
0.31478631496429443,
0.137090802192688,
0.5318390130996704,
-0.48507392406463623,
-0.5110247731208801,
-0.7832584977149963,
0.36538031697273254,
-0.20473599433898926,
-0.35459092259407043,
0.7414838671684265,
0.4937553107738495,
0.9158558249473572,
-0.05210764333605766,
0.5850965976715088,
-0.09657715260982513,
0.7771775722503662,
-0.21095913648605347,
0.8727874159812927,
-0.4044061303138733,
-0.05209289491176605,
-0.29803991317749023,
-1.0347002744674683,
-0.23350977897644043,
0.7816250324249268,
-0.42398130893707275,
-0.2013261765241623,
0.7800282835960388,
0.5336145758628845,
-0.007956352084875107,
0.407522588968277,
0.37014180421829224,
0.01244138553738594,
0.17826086282730103,
0.2777850925922394,
0.903186023235321,
-0.3856000304222107,
0.2188044637441635,
-0.6134246587753296,
-0.2035377472639084,
-0.13677600026130676,
-0.9281808137893677,
-0.8353599309921265,
-0.7886596322059631,
-0.19723306596279144,
-0.06449000537395477,
0.046332016587257385,
1.2361968755722046,
0.4784262776374817,
-0.9605394601821899,
-0.25864776968955994,
0.5432249307632446,
-0.19898825883865356,
0.11500462144613266,
-0.12070282548666,
0.5447375774383545,
-0.2714691758155823,
-0.9618237614631653,
0.3398042321205139,
0.4160248339176178,
0.23414672911167145,
-0.6140395998954773,
0.16150712966918945,
-0.5179187059402466,
0.1072956770658493,
0.4686741828918457,
0.18331976234912872,
-0.8256489038467407,
-0.24113841354846954,
0.15582998096942902,
-0.3174298405647278,
0.19157907366752625,
0.755961537361145,
-0.38870248198509216,
0.396982878446579,
0.707508385181427,
0.2897581160068512,
0.4970058500766754,
-0.18410323560237885,
0.5374457836151123,
-0.531862735748291,
0.49960771203041077,
0.2892172932624817,
0.6723231077194214,
0.4786764979362488,
-0.251609206199646,
0.5404723882675171,
0.5386699438095093,
-0.35168004035949707,
-0.6097782850265503,
-0.020670631900429726,
-0.6837486028671265,
0.05234859511256218,
0.7990373373031616,
-0.6652473211288452,
-0.5374470949172974,
-0.4290960133075714,
-0.24489060044288635,
0.2852955460548401,
-0.16232429444789886,
0.38042405247688293,
1.0592613220214844,
-0.04784776642918587,
-0.044842857867479324,
-0.7021855115890503,
0.7204104661941528,
0.04126172140240669,
-0.6014290452003479,
-0.26230260729789734,
0.7689254879951477,
0.13706259429454803,
0.6020829677581787,
0.33244311809539795,
-0.24529680609703064,
0.24527975916862488,
-0.13167785108089447,
0.3174575865268707,
-0.1981649100780487,
-0.6315433382987976,
-0.05770513787865639,
0.5428295135498047,
-0.17484983801841736,
0.3307172358036041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00416v1 | Too Late to Train, Too Early To Use? A Study on Necessity and Viability of Low-Resource Bengali LLMs | 2024-06-29T11:50:16 | 2024-06-29T11:50:16 | Tamzeed Mahfuz, Satak Kumar Dey, Ruwad Naswan, Hasnaen Adil, Khondker Salman Sayeed, Haz Sameen Shahgir | cs.CL | cs.CL | Each new generation of English-oriented Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibits
enhanced cross-lingual transfer capabilities and significantly outperforms
older LLMs on low-resource languages. This prompts the question: Is there a
need for LLMs dedicated to a particular low-resource language? We aim to
explore this question for Bengali, a low-to-moderate resource Indo-Aryan
language native to the Bengal region of South Asia.
We compare the performance of open-weight and closed-source LLMs such as
LLaMA-3 and GPT-4 against fine-tuned encoder-decoder models across a diverse
set of Bengali downstream tasks, including translation, summarization,
paraphrasing, question-answering, and natural language inference. Our findings
reveal that while LLMs generally excel in reasoning tasks, their performance in
tasks requiring Bengali script generation is inconsistent. Key challenges
include inefficient tokenization of Bengali script by existing LLMs, leading to
increased computational costs and potential performance degradation.
Additionally, we highlight biases in machine-translated datasets commonly used
for Bengali NLP tasks. We conclude that there is a significant need for a
Bengali-oriented LLM, but the field currently lacks the high-quality
pretraining and instruction-tuning datasets necessary to develop a highly
effective model. | [
0.024589665234088898,
-0.1765034943819046,
0.24327757954597473,
0.42741143703460693,
-0.2869805097579956,
0.12113235145807266,
-0.14397549629211426,
-0.48691511154174805,
0.0033721239306032658,
0.44670140743255615,
-0.3151923716068268,
-0.05965142697095871,
-0.559432327747345,
0.31424838304519653,
-0.1492983102798462,
0.807386577129364,
-0.26922184228897095,
0.16914384067058563,
-0.1783604472875595,
-0.08567117899656296,
-0.4597254991531372,
-0.37387973070144653,
-0.46248966455459595,
-0.35917672514915466,
0.5694742202758789,
0.4311041831970215,
0.2915528416633606,
0.5148295760154724,
0.4808173179626465,
0.1283600777387619,
-0.19142690300941467,
0.11365048587322235,
-0.2967490255832672,
0.012991282157599926,
-0.1492757499217987,
-0.8101159930229187,
-0.4375990331172943,
-0.03502862527966499,
0.5905493497848511,
1.0807291269302368,
0.1522008329629898,
0.31142693758010864,
0.07105568051338196,
0.7759711146354675,
-0.9357263445854187,
0.12935791909694672,
-0.7502375245094299,
-0.03616610914468765,
-0.5107694864273071,
-0.2117035686969757,
-0.2482706606388092,
-0.34385785460472107,
-0.08823179453611374,
-0.31991392374038696,
-0.04793404042720795,
0.24511700868606567,
0.5947466492652893,
0.5430486798286438,
-0.24638758599758148,
-0.26927441358566284,
-0.7161011099815369,
0.9901211857795715,
-0.6793494820594788,
0.22753101587295532,
0.733259916305542,
0.28038135170936584,
0.08804991841316223,
-0.30951231718063354,
-0.3052898943424225,
-0.0539204478263855,
-0.15150132775306702,
0.017209133133292198,
-0.03263280540704727,
-0.03632465749979019,
0.20104631781578064,
0.19656139612197876,
-0.6024468541145325,
0.36998051404953003,
-0.5603322982788086,
-0.1947956383228302,
0.31208401918411255,
0.20816299319267273,
0.07444185763597488,
-0.5372058749198914,
-0.24144218862056732,
0.330430269241333,
-0.9406297206878662,
0.07822016626596451,
0.5952509045600891,
0.4807834029197693,
-0.2946343719959259,
0.8661333322525024,
-0.12401083111763,
1.0317503213882446,
-0.23042911291122437,
-0.22011449933052063,
0.006015126593410969,
-0.47494471073150635,
-0.04175581783056259,
0.11910251528024673,
0.33548954129219055,
0.10725150257349014,
0.361955851316452,
-0.09338895976543427,
-0.4032679796218872,
0.029651690274477005,
0.07890430837869644,
-0.6666479110717773,
0.03424632549285889,
0.14969202876091003,
-0.5815000534057617,
0.07895655184984207,
-0.6881696581840515,
-0.5682181119918823,
-0.35493823885917664,
-0.16022290289402008,
0.10618465393781662,
-0.25935280323028564,
-0.17444387078285217,
-0.09505527466535568,
0.11661998927593231,
0.4511987864971161,
0.12437117844820023,
-1.1512385606765747,
-0.12442892789840698,
0.3031559884548187,
0.9582080245018005,
-0.2919609546661377,
-0.23517417907714844,
-0.3303886950016022,
0.17447292804718018,
-0.5236403346061707,
0.8605082631111145,
-0.7082130908966064,
-0.2506853938102722,
0.2501331567764282,
-0.06754133850336075,
-0.016723530367016792,
-0.631627082824707,
0.4968046247959137,
-0.6090660691261292,
-0.13588671386241913,
-0.007487925235182047,
-0.28667739033699036,
0.19159884750843048,
0.2301870584487915,
-0.5645837783813477,
0.620413064956665,
0.30205997824668884,
-0.689701497554779,
0.44882115721702576,
-0.48314955830574036,
-0.7324981689453125,
0.242234468460083,
-0.08814141154289246,
-0.04657401144504547,
0.21514010429382324,
0.20307031273841858,
0.6140044927597046,
-0.4655015170574188,
-0.03315664455294609,
-0.18266093730926514,
-0.762705385684967,
0.07310838997364044,
-0.4886414408683777,
0.8938965797424316,
0.346487820148468,
0.11048442125320435,
-0.4434753656387329,
-1.0528219938278198,
0.08266690373420715,
0.16330665349960327,
-0.744735598564148,
-0.39215418696403503,
-0.08924174308776855,
-0.12685564160346985,
-0.007904800586402416,
0.5179904699325562,
-0.3406861126422882,
0.11742786318063736,
-0.5729468464851379,
0.5644577145576477,
0.8227990865707397,
-0.27480003237724304,
0.6630451083183289,
-0.45633676648139954,
0.7268635034561157,
-0.1982194185256958,
0.05791943892836571,
-0.2920185327529907,
-0.31551048159599304,
-0.8694114685058594,
-0.19088219106197357,
0.16122886538505554,
0.5809622406959534,
-0.7979130148887634,
0.09208670258522034,
-0.10464704036712646,
-0.4863130748271942,
-0.8642675280570984,
0.30120402574539185,
0.2866904139518738,
0.29205918312072754,
0.3751696050167084,
-0.014249859377741814,
-0.6592755317687988,
-1.0836745500564575,
-0.36666783690452576,
-0.3178926408290863,
0.04557136446237564,
0.2342134416103363,
0.31000640988349915,
-0.23643924295902252,
0.85825115442276,
-0.0667865127325058,
-0.25838613510131836,
-0.5487719178199768,
-0.20266032218933105,
0.32888442277908325,
0.2538422644138336,
0.440364271402359,
-0.7140923738479614,
-0.41034770011901855,
-0.09317516535520554,
-0.5954726338386536,
-0.4529573619365692,
-0.007837110199034214,
0.09945274889469147,
0.6431486010551453,
0.326555460691452,
-0.4209047853946686,
0.22313417494297028,
0.8907895684242249,
0.2283761352300644,
0.5207532048225403,
0.021718788892030716,
-0.15593841671943665,
-0.8829079866409302,
0.22699899971485138,
-0.3050673305988312,
0.06678785383701324,
-0.33827564120292664,
-0.33953285217285156,
-0.08968209475278854,
-0.23796798288822174,
-0.6369763016700745,
0.8996409773826599,
-0.5847204327583313,
-0.261845201253891,
-0.4776594340801239,
0.09373986721038818,
-0.22309190034866333,
0.5774171948432922,
0.018494561314582825,
1.0884984731674194,
0.29424402117729187,
-0.6123355627059937,
0.12213890254497528,
0.21750739216804504,
-0.4010717272758484,
0.46108606457710266,
-0.537670373916626,
-0.016457317396998405,
0.10442338138818741,
0.0086812824010849,
-0.6247729063034058,
-0.26821330189704895,
0.2885310649871826,
-0.3509522080421448,
0.5320084691047668,
-0.5505267977714539,
-0.3023449778556824,
-0.2087271809577942,
-0.00020269607193768024,
0.6112199425697327,
0.7545751333236694,
-0.37095192074775696,
0.35853755474090576,
0.17168307304382324,
-0.43948179483413696,
-0.6380041837692261,
-1.0540895462036133,
-0.016571026295423508,
-0.0656956285238266,
-0.4048876464366913,
0.03341712802648544,
0.1104661226272583,
-0.13890066742897034,
0.1071125864982605,
-0.1582607626914978,
-0.07019167393445969,
0.04752528667449951,
0.0680820643901825,
0.1684863269329071,
-0.024632640182971954,
0.047977082431316376,
-0.12425796687602997,
-0.21587111055850983,
-0.11260684579610825,
-0.37967032194137573,
0.45792627334594727,
-0.16615551710128784,
-0.48130303621292114,
-0.09032083302736282,
0.2795003652572632,
0.23791058361530304,
-0.06545113027095795,
0.7024154663085938,
0.45631682872772217,
-0.3575030565261841,
-0.22345228493213654,
-0.49290913343429565,
0.02418612875044346,
-0.3567837178707123,
0.37434571981430054,
-0.05319977179169655,
-0.8077612519264221,
0.2696199119091034,
-0.3031754493713379,
-0.19257351756095886,
0.2611713409423828,
0.7565805912017822,
-0.28994137048721313,
0.6791233420372009,
0.7886692881584167,
0.05950719490647316,
0.47252216935157776,
-0.1718105673789978,
0.40753546357154846,
-0.899135172367096,
-0.1281406283378601,
-0.5086130499839783,
-0.23235547542572021,
-0.8657007813453674,
-0.18943943083286285,
0.2067769467830658,
0.06743897497653961,
-0.2764478027820587,
0.13453342020511627,
-0.22971872985363007,
0.38814592361450195,
0.41979360580444336,
-0.24812762439250946,
0.2748355269432068,
0.11097941547632217,
0.17893096804618835,
-0.1880224347114563,
-1.1275428533554077,
-0.7906524538993835,
1.1887574195861816,
-0.04672364145517349,
1.032772421836853,
-0.10229809582233429,
0.5841441750526428,
0.30865198373794556,
0.17235711216926575,
-0.597531795501709,
0.4688953757286072,
-0.20553801953792572,
-0.5459549427032471,
-0.13315704464912415,
-0.3699072301387787,
-1.001715898513794,
0.09417687356472015,
0.07279916852712631,
-0.29955995082855225,
0.07766144722700119,
0.10029089450836182,
-0.2009555548429489,
0.2715131342411041,
-0.97028648853302,
0.6127147674560547,
-0.5604768991470337,
-0.5591672658920288,
0.0744556337594986,
-0.6865219473838806,
0.4559023678302765,
-0.4483756124973297,
0.24463576078414917,
-0.19265234470367432,
-0.3036993145942688,
0.8583871126174927,
-0.29879030585289,
1.0123462677001953,
-0.18151602149009705,
-0.002512993523851037,
0.3992585837841034,
-0.10849438607692719,
0.3926306664943695,
-0.04250706359744072,
-0.07775236666202545,
0.3318929970264435,
-0.11372885853052139,
-0.9152379631996155,
-0.4884929656982422,
0.4901614785194397,
-0.8075597882270813,
-0.6210031509399414,
-0.6410999298095703,
-0.3233911693096161,
-0.3531346619129181,
0.25851598381996155,
0.2799294888973236,
0.17264190316200256,
0.2617926597595215,
0.0525265708565712,
0.34380847215652466,
-0.22336581349372864,
0.359819620847702,
0.4401327967643738,
0.13364751636981964,
-0.22493711113929749,
0.9882799983024597,
0.2835105359554291,
0.3941287398338318,
0.18959367275238037,
0.03903484717011452,
-0.05284871533513069,
-0.8901002407073975,
-0.33181479573249817,
0.3597284257411957,
-0.5919607281684875,
-0.2765514552593231,
-0.4073088765144348,
-0.25903794169425964,
-0.17219795286655426,
-0.31231924891471863,
-0.5110660195350647,
-0.3015325963497162,
-0.34659963846206665,
0.314700722694397,
0.1631249636411667,
0.6560763120651245,
-0.21088257431983948,
0.33847904205322266,
-0.8766793012619019,
0.08016520738601685,
0.168706476688385,
0.44756069779396057,
-0.0735149011015892,
-0.7477868795394897,
-0.6441953778266907,
-0.09314556419849396,
-0.14400601387023926,
-0.521828293800354,
0.18351206183433533,
0.046243201941251755,
0.5529056787490845,
0.05731234699487686,
0.11393783986568451,
0.3447069227695465,
-0.4300231337547302,
0.8941342234611511,
0.07957307994365692,
-0.5363211631774902,
0.6129525303840637,
-0.20505963265895844,
0.3159674406051636,
0.41916316747665405,
0.5865101218223572,
-0.32065483927726746,
-0.11433594673871994,
-0.23676908016204834,
-0.8397289514541626,
0.7921040654182434,
0.007468619849532843,
0.04291432350873947,
0.1168186366558075,
0.25486570596694946,
0.2754570245742798,
0.375811904668808,
-0.6819961071014404,
0.0396452359855175,
-0.1479993313550949,
0.12647205591201782,
-0.09180037677288055,
-0.5087423324584961,
0.09870216995477676,
0.043601810932159424,
0.5381766557693481,
-0.190546914935112,
0.18678420782089233,
0.020063845440745354,
-0.16443286836147308,
-0.10415390133857727,
0.5013695955276489,
0.35247740149497986,
0.6455533504486084,
-0.2694636881351471,
-0.0775260180234909,
0.24779608845710754,
-0.40220722556114197,
0.4774501323699951,
-0.0020843197125941515,
-0.21092408895492554,
-0.295062392950058,
0.8433470726013184,
0.7833344340324402,
0.2860041558742523,
-0.7772321105003357,
0.40683433413505554,
0.28268879652023315,
0.21859978139400482,
-0.3437786102294922,
0.029247205704450607,
0.00915171205997467,
0.29440391063690186,
0.3353215157985687,
0.2648047208786011,
-0.291157066822052,
-0.4351905584335327,
-0.4160799980163574,
0.19099122285842896,
-0.12927040457725525,
-0.29556185007095337,
0.41886043548583984,
0.2857939302921295,
-0.43336090445518494,
0.629048764705658,
-0.3028040826320648,
-0.48264509439468384,
0.16255028545856476,
0.4404344856739044,
0.7286485433578491,
0.04246459901332855,
-0.14102597534656525,
0.07152773439884186,
0.6342847943305969,
0.05224539339542389,
0.21061396598815918,
-0.09759499877691269,
-0.4988385736942291,
-0.8389829993247986,
-0.8686540722846985,
-0.4497222900390625,
0.18251480162143707,
-0.37035101652145386,
0.41697511076927185,
-0.21791934967041016,
-0.15524928271770477,
-0.6839051246643066,
0.10921718180179596,
-0.8647109270095825,
-0.1594344675540924,
-0.05552799627184868,
0.8621600270271301,
-0.8059642314910889,
0.4953109622001648,
0.7701722383499146,
-0.5078059434890747,
-0.5195131897926331,
0.06467699259519577,
-0.3686293959617615,
-0.9571102261543274,
0.9145528674125671,
-0.15165647864341736,
-0.01622214913368225,
-0.15001754462718964,
-0.5278028249740601,
-0.7123106122016907,
0.8666370511054993,
0.6000053882598877,
-0.5856946110725403,
-0.36201244592666626,
0.1347365826368332,
0.5513536930084229,
-0.15790075063705444,
0.18104563653469086,
0.5627554059028625,
0.4475308954715729,
0.06927787512540817,
-0.8404780030250549,
-0.3251655101776123,
-0.05048004165291786,
0.07986018806695938,
-0.0037845598999410868,
-0.9427206516265869,
0.8442085385322571,
-0.3791812062263489,
-0.19108708202838898,
0.09507248550653458,
0.4635663330554962,
0.2848375141620636,
0.230712890625,
0.1367242932319641,
0.3196280896663666,
0.3871212899684906,
0.1213599443435669,
1.17955482006073,
-0.148708775639534,
-0.1503545492887497,
0.7652432322502136,
-0.580476701259613,
0.869552731513977,
0.6105765104293823,
-0.4062822163105011,
0.07089374214410782,
0.8148484230041504,
0.2357979118824005,
0.6030629873275757,
0.24188871681690216,
-0.004032529890537262,
-0.3924367129802704,
-0.32456961274147034,
-0.41207194328308105,
0.6706796288490295,
0.26628559827804565,
0.18688926100730896,
-0.2790866792201996,
0.10786888748407364,
-0.22635629773139954,
0.05818324536085129,
-0.30322661995887756,
0.4833543002605438,
0.2705945074558258,
-0.45012232661247253,
0.8614475727081299,
-0.2797451913356781,
0.8762692809104919,
-0.7890018820762634,
-0.08263271301984787,
-0.4481504261493683,
0.10082116723060608,
-0.22495146095752716,
-0.5480893850326538,
0.5088523626327515,
0.3384862244129181,
-0.2122212052345276,
-0.2823943495750427,
0.8062737584114075,
-0.32473301887512207,
-0.41345930099487305,
0.47702258825302124,
0.8822941184043884,
0.3980242609977722,
0.221527561545372,
-0.3305447995662689,
0.3093055784702301,
-0.21049675345420837,
-0.1789686381816864,
0.5480311512947083,
0.433940052986145,
0.019847355782985687,
0.7350550293922424,
0.6248778104782104,
0.8134216666221619,
0.1520812064409256,
-0.1397794932126999,
0.6438109874725342,
-0.4180722236633301,
-0.32446056604385376,
-0.6731444597244263,
0.12894807755947113,
0.290884405374527,
-0.24599634110927582,
0.763654887676239,
0.44079095125198364,
1.11001718044281,
-0.058930784463882446,
1.0543676614761353,
0.10385045409202576,
0.6330371499061584,
-0.7571961879730225,
0.7378702759742737,
-0.9167996048927307,
0.2598296105861664,
0.19470040500164032,
-1.1506121158599854,
-0.11089964210987091,
0.4826700985431671,
-0.3629499077796936,
0.2768888473510742,
0.6297276020050049,
0.5543736219406128,
0.24625445902347565,
-0.1866508573293686,
0.42377275228500366,
0.13364388048648834,
0.23650754988193512,
0.7940548062324524,
1.048934817314148,
-0.22504286468029022,
0.782719075679779,
0.06599880009889603,
-0.19607815146446228,
-0.40505683422088623,
-0.9303255081176758,
-0.8814401626586914,
-0.6182904839515686,
0.034752629697322845,
-0.15213339030742645,
0.19176296889781952,
0.8984593749046326,
0.4755185544490814,
-0.5196054577827454,
-0.19946026802062988,
0.2332133948802948,
0.1800728738307953,
0.11594735085964203,
-0.10137676447629929,
0.20226289331912994,
-0.5642299652099609,
-0.7605776190757751,
0.5238394141197205,
0.29437974095344543,
0.25110089778900146,
-0.5534600019454956,
-0.08286892622709274,
-0.32759103178977966,
0.009256037883460522,
0.5196396112442017,
0.43522366881370544,
-0.547196090221405,
-0.07304655760526657,
0.02045539766550064,
-0.24474352598190308,
-0.0985635370016098,
0.863010585308075,
-0.7143672704696655,
0.27539393305778503,
0.38437530398368835,
1.0187667608261108,
0.33206939697265625,
-0.4179511070251465,
0.30050456523895264,
-0.6896055340766907,
0.2480504810810089,
0.5705798268318176,
0.3685113489627838,
0.6352733373641968,
-0.01234261691570282,
0.6101058721542358,
0.5176631808280945,
-0.604838490486145,
-1.0265889167785645,
0.14179909229278564,
-0.5587316751480103,
-0.04062927886843681,
1.1985529661178589,
0.1191360354423523,
-0.4737844169139862,
-0.21896298229694366,
-0.026426512748003006,
0.18761271238327026,
-0.17821136116981506,
0.4615037143230438,
0.9077432751655579,
-0.07356735318899155,
0.07981469482183456,
-0.6512815952301025,
0.45712026953697205,
0.4788457453250885,
-0.5726006031036377,
0.15649569034576416,
0.1110251396894455,
-0.06827862560749054,
0.15935929119586945,
0.8267952799797058,
0.1642041653394699,
0.13328401744365692,
0.1815396398305893,
-0.032000672072172165,
-0.14657041430473328,
-0.4373113214969635,
-0.4269661009311676,
0.03340652212500572,
0.3358123004436493,
-0.08698032796382904
] |