Datasets:

research-dump

/

wiki-stance-en

like 0

Follow

Hsuvas's Research Backups 1

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Armenian historiography

User:Brandmeister

09:31, 5 May 2009 (UTC)

keep

"I don't wonder, given who is prodding the article. Another case of and it is not ""certain scholars"", but even Armenian ones or of Armenian heritage, such as Suny, not to mention the third-parties. Indeed, this is just the tip of the iceberg and I have much more to write. The criticism clearly detected several forgeries in particular, so it falls under the falsification of history template pretty well. And I don't think that Turkkaya Ataov or even just knowledgeable man can't debunk the misattribution and fake caption for quite notable painting"

Deletion of Criticism of Armenian historiography

WP:IDONTLIKEIT

Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salustiano Sanchez

User:Newshunter12

01:42, 24 November 2018 (UTC)

delete

"This article blatantly fails , , and . There is no policy that the ""oldest x"" is notable and this article is packed with longevity fancruft like he played an instrument while growing up, was partially self-educated, and the standard longevity secret. His name, life dates, and nationality are best handled on the three lists they already reside on. This is not needed"

Deletion of Salustiano Sanchez

WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E||WP:NOPAGE||WP:PERMASTUB

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PrimaveraReader (software)

User:Ubiquity

10:26, 28 July 2016 (UTC)

delete

WP:PROMO|Promotional article that lets the reader know all about the product's features without ever establishing (or even asserting) |notability. References are self-published or commercial

Deletion of PrimaveraReader (software)

WP:N

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annual Assault 2008

User:Esradekan

00:58, 29 October 2008 (UTC)

delete

article fails to establish notability as per #Albums.2C_singles_and_songs|#Albums

Deletion of Annual Assault 2008

WP:MUSIC

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swapan Purkait

User:Paste

10:56, 16 November 2016 (UTC)

delete

Autobio that fails no independent coverage and looks like a vanity article

Deletion of Swapan Purkait

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jiyas Jamal

User:CommanderWaterford

19:22, 25 February 2021 (UTC)

delete

per nom, I PRODed him. An usual lawyer, no given

Deletion of Jiyas Jamal

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jasper (singer)

User:Greg

13:08, 12 April 2009 (UTC)

delete

"Fails and . And I'd like to point out that this discussion has two nominations for ""keep"", one by the original editor. If you remove all comments by the original editor (who seems to be a ), the discussion is fairly bland. For those interested, you can"

Deletion of Jasper (singer)

WP:N||WP:V||WP:SPA

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond's Run

User:Robert

06:04, 23 November 2020 (UTC)

delete

or '''Speedy Delete''' as |G12 - Seems to have been copied from a blurb

Deletion of Raymond's Run

WP:G12

Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Paul's Parish, Azam Basti

User:Atlantic306

17:22, 15 July 2018 (UTC)

keep

as passes for the news coverage it has attracted

Deletion of St Paul's Parish, Azam Basti

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Revolutionary Ideology

User:Stifle

19:43, 4 November 2007 (UTC)

delete

per etc

Deletion of American Revolutionary Ideology

WP:NOR

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wanda harrell

User:Valrith

22:16, 20 November 2006 (UTC)

delete

Possibly written by the subject of the article, but fails at any rate

Deletion of Wanda harrell

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ice hockey at the 1998 Winter Olympics match stats (women)

User:Lugnuts

15:10, 8 July 2019 (UTC)

delete

Obvious . All the pertinent information is contained in the main tournament summary. And this is all unsourced too

Deletion of Ice hockey at the 1998 Winter Olympics match stats (women)

WP:NOTSTATS

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Rendall (actor)

User:EuroCarGT

03:55, 28 October 2014 (UTC)

delete

after performing a web search on the subject, he is a minor actor, I could't find much coverage on David Rendall indicating he is |not notable

Deletion of David Rendall (actor)

WP:NACTOR

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armaan Story of a Storyteller

User:Coderzombie

19:24, 8 February 2017 (UTC)

delete

per and failing

Deletion of Armaan Story of a Storyteller

WP:PROMOTION||WP:NMOVIE

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GetLunchin

User:Northamerica1000

11:54, 10 May 2015 (UTC)

delete

Only finding http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2015-04-17/news/61253805_1_chefs-bridges-gap-foodies one source that provides significant coverage. Does not meet

Deletion of GetLunchin

WP:N

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Paramore songs (2nd nomination)

User:Frankie

14:09, 15 June 2011 (UTC)

keep

This list is a different item from the discography and it serves a different purpose. It could be included on the discography, but that may be bloating an article with information that is beyond its scope. The information ''is'' redundant when presented like this, but it is inevitable that any list will replicate information found elsewhere, since its purpose is to centralize such information for better access by the user. Lastly, I don't think that is much of an issue here, as the songs is the lowest point we can get to in terms of coverage (I think we would mostly agree that List of Paramore Verses is over the top). The notes section of the table looks like |original research, so it should either be sourced properly, or be dropped

Deletion of List of Paramore songs (2nd nomination)

WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:OR

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unleashed (Skillet album)

User:Lawrencekhoo

05:43, 6 June 2016 (UTC)

delete

Fails . Also, there is hardly any material except for the track listing. The article as currently exists is specifically forbidden by the guideline. On a side note, video views is not a basis for notability

Deletion of Unleashed (Skillet album)

WP:NALBUM||WP:NALBUM

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophy Gardner

User:RightCowLeftCoast

19:48, 18 October 2014 (UTC)

merge

to Next United Kingdom general election; Subject appears to not have received significant coverage outside of being a candidate in an upcoming election; therefore per the article should be made into a redirect into the article about that particular race. Outside of the political race subject does not appear to receive |significant coverage from |tertiary reliable sources to indicate subject is notable per , , or

Deletion of Sophy Gardner

WP:POLOUTCOMES||WP:SIGCOV||WP:PSTS||WP:GNG||WP:SOLDIER||WP:NPOL

Wikipedia:Deletion policy

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stratified multi criteria decision making

User:XOR

17:56, 28 July 2018 (UTC)

delete

"The very first sentence of the article is an admission that this is |too soon. The !vote above, with its insistence that the method was ""proposed and published '''for the first time in July 2018'''"", makes a very good case for deletion (albeit inadvertently"

Deletion of Stratified multi criteria decision making

WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Too soon

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shinjini Kundu

User:The

23:24, 17 August 2017 (UTC)

keep

added another source, meets

Deletion of Shinjini Kundu

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of papabili in the 2013 papal conclave

User:Stifle

20:11, 18 March 2013 (UTC)

delete

inclusion criteria are too arbitrary. See items 9 and 10

Deletion of List of papabili in the 2013 papal conclave

WP:LC

Wikipedia:Listcruft

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voltage (Skrillex album)

User:Gongshow

07:17, 6 April 2012 (UTC)

delete

per . No significant coverage in reliable sources, no confirmed release date or track listing. If/when this album is released, the coverage will presumably follow for this notable artist. An article can be created at that time. For now, this possible upcoming release does not meet or at this time

Deletion of Voltage (Skrillex album)

WP:CRYSTAL||WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruthellen Josselson

User:Ad

06:21, 23 January 2014 (UTC)

keep

This is a reluctant keep since there is clear evidence of COI. But the Fulbright Fellowship is a pretty major award. It satisfies and . I am less sure about the other two awards. But the Fulbright is sufficient on its own

Deletion of Ruthellen Josselson

WP:GNG||WP:NACADEMICS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bushism

User:Crockspot

19:51, 8 September 2006 (UTC)

delete

per nom. Filled with POV, , poorly sourced, unencyclopedic, and probably violates . I'm not opposed to the topic, per se. But this execution is wrong in so many ways

Deletion of Bushism

WP:OR||WP:BLP

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video game websites

User:Bruguiea

04:12, 24 October 2005 (UTC)

delete

by a web directory. Unmaintainble and liable to be POV

Deletion of List of video game websites

WP:NOT

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dre Davis

User:Winner

23:02, 11 May 2015 (UTC)

delete

Non notable actress, fails

Deletion of Dre Davis

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tharizdun

User:Folken

21:19, 7 September 2013 (UTC)

merge

to List of Greyhawk deities, as there is no ''significant'' coverage from multiple reliable independent secondary sources, topic doesn't establish notability per . The newly added sources don't even allow the article to comply to

Deletion of Tharizdun

WP:GNG||WP:NOTPLOT

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. Dhanayake

User:BlackJack

10:33, 24 October 2017 (UTC)

keep

Although these obsessive anti-CRIN individuals will not admit it, there are in existence significant Sri Lankan sources as we were able to establish in the case of Suresh Perera (Old Cambrians cricketer). A contact in Sri Lanka was willing to check a highly reputable Sinhalese newspaper, ''Dinamina'', for a specific match report and found additional information about that player. While we obviously cannot expect anyone in Sri Lanka to perform short-term checks of ''Dinamina'' for every single first-class player, the match report she did check proves not only that Sinhalese sources exist but also that their cricket coverage effectively matches that of newspapers in the English-speaking countries. The fact of this level of coverage by ''Dinamina'' and other Sinhalese publications meets the terms of . These nominations are disruptive

Deletion of S. Dhanayake

WP:NEXIST

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Online Communist Party

User:Stormtracker94

12:47, 21 October 2007 (UTC)

delete

per and

Deletion of World Online Communist Party

WP:WEB||WP:V

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nyeema Morgan

User:Gobonobo

22:04, 12 February 2021 (UTC)

keep

Morgan has works in the permanent collections of the Bowdoin College Museum of Art and the Menil Collection and meets #4(b) with nine solo/duo exhibitions as well as residencies at Smack Mellon and the Skowhegan School of Painting and Sculpture. She also meets GNG with significant coverage in https://www.dailycamera.com/2020/09/17/fall-exhibits-at-bmoca-capture-the-cosmos-and-fracture-the-female-formula/ Daily Camera, https://bombmagazine.org/articles/soft-power-hard-margins-nyeema-morgan-interviewed/ BOMB magazine, and https://www.arcadeprojectzine.com/features/the-stem-the-flower-the-root-the-seed Arcade Project. This article doesn't yet include all of her exhibitions (which also have references... see https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887323809304578429202021577858 Wall Street Journal, https://www.artforum.com/picks/itasca-62459 ArtForum, https://news.artnet.com/art-world/advice-to-young-female-artists-542609#.V6y--CifpP8.twitter ArtNet

Deletion of Nyeema Morgan

WP:ARTIST

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xodo

User:Dialectric

18:41, 15 July 2015 (UTC)

delete

Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. As above, a search turned up incidental mentions but no significant coverage. Article was created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as possibly promotional

Deletion of Xodo

WP:RS||WP:RS

Wikipedia:Reliable sources

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Involuntary celibacy (4th nomination)

[[User talk:SSTflyer|sst✈]]

13:43, 29 December 2015 (UTC)

keep

as a pass of . If this is not a medical topic it does not need to meet medical SNGs. Saying that this should be deleted for failing is like saying that Moses should be deleted for failing

Deletion of Involuntary celibacy (4th nomination)

WP:SIGCOV||WP:MEDRS||WP:PORNBIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Animal City (film)

User:Liquidfinale

13:37, 31 October 2007 (UTC)

delete

as either a hoax, or zero claim to notability under |notability guidelines for films. Best regards

Deletion of Animal City (film)

WP:NF

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oleg Frish

User:Edison

15:46, 21 January 2011 (UTC)

delete

It has not been demonstrated that he satisfies . Not everyone who records a record at Capitol Studios automatically gets an encyclopedia article. Did Capitol release the record, or was it recorded at Capitol for private distribution? How high did it climb in the popular music charts? Perhaps someone could demonstrate that he also has multiple reliable and independent sources with substantial coverage

Deletion of Oleg Frish

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Holtzman

User:Alphachimp

11:29, 11 July 2006 (UTC)

delete

WP:NOT|Wikipedia is not free hosting for his resume. Also

Deletion of Jason Holtzman

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Clemmensen

User:Wine

02:08, 26 January 2010 (UTC)

delete

to Short Stack per . This one's easy

Deletion of Andrew Clemmensen

WP:BAND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ascertia

User:Ihcoyc

14:47, 11 April 2011 (UTC)

delete

and '''salt'''. |Yet another

Deletion of Ascertia

WP:MILL

Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lexi Love

User:Richard3120

21:26, 31 October 2018 (UTC)

delete

"I completely agree with Hullabaloo Wolfowitz that Wikipedia should not suppress potentially embarrassing information just because the subject demands it. The trouble is, I cannot find a single reliable source about this person that mentions the name ""Lexi Love"" in connection with her, or her past career. The arguments for keeping the article thus completely fail , and on its own, the article fails . If someone shows me a reliable source that explicitly states that this person was Lexi Love, I'd be happy to change my vote"

Deletion of Lexi Love

WP:V||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riccardo Corradini

User:Edinburgh

23:53, 3 April 2012 (UTC)

delete

Fails and relevant football guidelines

Deletion of Riccardo Corradini

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marina Matiss

User:onel5969

14:55, 2 January 2021 (UTC)

delete

Bingo by {{u|Mccapra}} - who was apparently reviewing this at the same time I was. Might be a case of , but definitely a case of overzealous representation by her PR team

Deletion of Marina Matiss

WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Too soon

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Dragunsky

User:Kges1901

20:41, 30 July 2020 (UTC)

keep

Dragunsky is notable per and with significant coverage in Russian sources, being a colonel general, and relatively rare double Hero of the Soviet Union, his country's highest honorary title. AfD is not cleanup

Deletion of David Dragunsky

WP:GNG||WP:MILPEOPLE

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zarbe Yadullahi

User:Coolabahapple

15:01, 8 March 2016 (UTC)

delete

does not meet or as a gsearch brings up no reviews, nothing useable

Deletion of Zarbe Yadullahi

WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

"Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The ""Blog"" of ""Unnecessary"" Quotation Marks"

User:Jasynnash2

12:08, 10 October 2008 (UTC)

delete

OT| Wikipedia is not news nor for processing news stories, the website itself fails as well as the majority of | notability points, it is unencyclopedic and an unlikely search term

"Deletion of The ""Blog"" of ""Unnecessary"" Quotation Marks"

WP:WEB||WP:N

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saltwater Croc vs. Great White Shark

User:Scientizzle

20:08, 13 July 2006 (UTC)

delete

The show isn't notable enough to warrant individual pages for each episode. And the commentary on the result was completely |OR. I'm going to de-red link Animal Face-Off right now to discourage more of these articles

Deletion of Saltwater Croc vs. Great White Shark

WP:OR

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siri Gamage

User:RayAYang

14:44, 29 September 2010 (UTC)

delete

Fails WP:PROF as Xxan says, and press mentions seem to be insignificant for in general

Deletion of Siri Gamage

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vanguard (2011 film)

User:RL0919

21:08, 16 December 2009 (UTC)

delete

Decently done up to look like a regular film article, but at its heart this is , with a bit of as well

Deletion of Vanguard (2011 film)

WP:SPAM||WP:CRYSTAL

Wikipedia:Spam

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suspension Training

User:Keeper76

15:02, 20 August 2008 (UTC)

comment

towards keep. I declined the speedy on this one, and added the NYT reference. I was going to continue to see if this was viable, but decided to go offline instead. Not to a gym, just to a different television|sitting position like most Wikipedians I presume. Gazimoff's references are very good, seem independent. Yes, this was added from a new editor, presumable a editor, but I think it just might be notable. I very much like Trulyblue's draft more than this one, they can easily be merged. In fact, Trulyblue, be |bold and do it! You are allowed to update the article while the debate runs. In fact, I just gutted the good faith out of it, as it wasn't helping this debate at all

Deletion of Suspension Training

WP:COI||WP:BOLD||WP:OR

Wikipedia:Conflict of interest

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SMK Semera

[[User_talk:Benjiboi| -- Banjeboi]]

15:02, 28 December 2008 (UTC)

comment

I'm quite concerned about the itey-ness here and would feel more comfortable if some experienced in that region could offer some insight. A school of that capacity and length of existence is quite likely to have stumbled into some notability and may not know what lever to pull at wikipedia to sort that out. I don't see this as a hoax as much as newbies needing help

Deletion of SMK Semera

WP:B

Wikipedia:Bots

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Ayo

User:Wikicology

10:20, 2 August 2014 (UTC)

delete

fails . Possible policy violation confirmed here https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/588676919 where the article creator clearly dislosed to be an Alumni of Covenant University where the subject is a vice chancellor. Perhaps he created it for his vice chancellor

Deletion of Charles Ayo

WP:GNG||WP:COI

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rio (Amatrice)

User:SportingFlyer

05:13, 30 June 2019 (UTC)

keep

Looks like there are plenty of sources available in Italian and maybe French. First one I found was http://www.meteoweb.eu/foto/la-frazione-di-rio-di-amatrice-distrutta-dal-terremoto-gallery/id/740964/, which isn't necessarily sigcov but gets it over and potentially . I've linked the article to its other languages

Deletion of Rio (Amatrice)

WP:V||WP:GEOLAND

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Friedrich Nichtmargen

User:DarkAudit

15:10, 16 July 2006 (UTC)

delete

as non-notable and . This reads like an ad. Wikipedia is not free ad space

Deletion of Friedrich Nichtmargen

WP:SPAM

Wikipedia:Spam

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young Leek (2nd nomination)

User:Starblind

18:36, 2 February 2008 (UTC)

delete

per or '''Speedy delete''' per previous AfD

Deletion of Young Leek (2nd nomination)

WP:MUSIC

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sci.psychology.psychotherapy

User:Wiki_alf

09:57, 28 December 2005 (UTC)

delete

unless I'm missing something obvious here, this does not meet

Deletion of Sci.psychology.psychotherapy

WP:WEB

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fluorine pill

User:Allisonmontgomery69

23:05, 30 July 2006 (UTC)

delete

per

Deletion of Fluorine pill

WP:V

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fir Hill Manor

User:Oakshade

21:54, 7 April 2013 (UTC)

keep

per nom (outside of the nonsensical contention. Nom states that there was a BBC documentary about this topic as well as several news outlets giving coverage

Deletion of Fir Hill Manor

WP:BLP1E

Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Himatdan Gadhavi

User:J04n

18:38, 16 April 2011 (UTC)

delete

unable to find significant coverage in |reliable sources independent of the subject of this unsourced |BLP

Deletion of Himatdan Gadhavi

WP:RS||WP:BLP

Wikipedia:Reliable sources

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manjeet Kumar

User:PRehse

19:12, 8 August 2015 (UTC)

delete

As per nominator. Clearly does not meet and the references are general and not specifically about him

Deletion of Manjeet Kumar

WP:NBOX

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernie Bro

User:E

23:22, 15 May 2016 (UTC)

comment

I surmise that some of the ''delete'' iVotes were prompted by the sourcing in the article which, when I came to it, was sourced heavily to blogs and non-mainstream news outlets. My rewrite depends on major, mainstream sources like the Washington Post, Wall Street Journal and The Atlantic and USA Today. Really, I think with coverage that is ongoing, and in-depth since October, this topic sails past . The larger challenge was not too few sources in searches, but, rather, sifting through the myriad hits on this topic in reliable sources

Deletion of Bernie Bro

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exploding sheep (3rd nomination)

User:Otto4711

18:30, 12 July 2010 (UTC)

delete

not notable as a concept in that there do not appear to be independent reliable sources that significantly cover the subject. The article conflates sheep that explode in video games with sheep who trigger bombs with sheep that explode via growth. These are unrelated to each other and the conflation constitutes |original research by sythesis

Deletion of Exploding sheep (3rd nomination)

WP:OR

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iaoco

User:ThaddeusB

20:57, 31 August 2009 (UTC)

delete

I'm not seeing any substantial |reliable source coverage in my good faith searches

Deletion of Iaoco

WP:RS

Wikipedia:Reliable sources

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Walmart brands

User:Carrite

00:05, 12 May 2013 (UTC)

comment

I'm sort of in land on this one. I can certainly see utility here and really don't see it as advertising, as the nominator intimates. Does that make it an encyclopedic topic? I'm less sure of that

Deletion of List of Walmart brands

WP:ITSUSEFUL

Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mikhail Katz

User:Xxanthippe

00:07, 23 May 2011 (UTC)

comment

All three persons above would be likely to pass the above average professor test. rof finds that notability may be established by citations in the scholarly literature to the subject's work and goes into some detail about this in Note 1. If editors wish to change Wikipedia policy they should do so on the policy pages, not here

Deletion of Mikhail Katz

WP:P

Wikipedia:Portal

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ArchLabs

User:Eggishorn

01:34, 16 October 2017 (UTC)

keep

Articles in https://www.linuxinsider.com/story/84823.html''Linux Insider'', https://itsfoss.com/archlabs-review/ ''It's FOSS'', and https://stationx.rocks/blogs/station-x-featured-distros/archlabs-5-0-one-of-the-best-gets-even-better ''StationX'' are significant coverage in indepedent, reliable sources and so passes

Deletion of ArchLabs

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Trump (2nd nomination)

User:Hmlarson

00:20, 29 June 2016 (UTC)

keep

breadth of articles indicate criteria is met. Article could use expansion, not deletion per

Deletion of Tiffany Trump (2nd nomination)

WP:GNG||WP:ATD

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betsy Sweet

User:GPL93

22:38, 3 January 2020 (UTC)

delete

Fails and there is not enough significant coverage outside of her campaigns to pass at the moment. The article can be recreated if she wins the election. Best

Deletion of Betsy Sweet

WP:NPOL||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flyswatter (album) (3rd nomination)

User:Sergecross73

15:15, 12 July 2012 (UTC)

delete

Per nom, it seems the article creators don't seem to understand that |Notability is not inherited

Deletion of Flyswatter (album) (3rd nomination)

WP:NALBUMS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wuxx

User:Rhododendrites

04:43, 31 May 2016 (UTC)

comment

ping|JDDJS}} Why not these? I don't see any substantial edits other than the sockpuppet (the only one which looks big was actually just filling in bare references, which isn't a substantial improvement. &mdash

Deletion of Wuxx

WP:G5

Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moshe Sacks

User:J04n

18:24, 31 October 2010 (UTC)

delete

unable to find any reliable sources independent of the subject. Does not meet or

Deletion of Moshe Sacks

WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saman Halgamuge

User:Dan

23:14, 25 December 2016 (UTC)

delete

non-notable University professor- fails

Deletion of Saman Halgamuge

WP:NACADEMIC

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CthulhuTech

User:Protonk

07:50, 27 October 2008 (UTC)

delete

Fails and . There are academic journals devoted to Games (namely Games and Culture) and there are plenty of journals, magazines, books and articles devoted to the roleplaying game industry. A lack of sources found doesn't immediately mean that our search methods are too parochial. The sources cited in the article and noted above are mainly non-RS. I'm on the fence about RPGnet because they appear to have some clout but don't specify where the edited content ends and user-generated content begins. Most of the rest don't count. I don't find anything on Books, News or Scholar ('Scept the io9 post, and io9 isn't an RS

Deletion of CthulhuTech

WP:CORP||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonia Bernath

User:Ahecht

22:41, 26 April 2018 (UTC)

keep

Assuming the Sunday Times article really is a profile, and not an interview, that, combined with the other sources, seems to fulfill

Deletion of Antonia Bernath

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of largest cities in England by population

User:Andrewa

14:39, 29 July 2007 (UTC)

keep

No reason has been given for deletion in terms of Wikipedia:deletion policy|deletion policy, and I can't see one to raise. I think we can Wikipedia:assume good faith|assume good faith about the nomination, and even commend the general conduct of the discussion. But it wouldn't hurt to review anyway, in view of the procedural mistakes of which this nomination is the most recent. The claim that there is consensus to delete appears to be false; If there is consensus, it's to merge and redirect, which shouldn't involve an AfD nomination anyway

Deletion of List of largest cities in England by population

WP:POINT

Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jasmine Tridevil

[[User talk:TheRedPenOfDoom|TRPoD aka The Red Pen of Doom]]

17:22, 24 September 2014 (UTC)

delete

"WP:BLP1E a flash in the pan hoax that made some ""news of the weird"" filler before being ""exposed"". no indication of this being a hoax of any lasing significance that anyone will mention after the next tabloid sexpose hits the screens. Wikipedia should not be playing into her desire to become ""famous"

Deletion of Jasmine Tridevil

WP:NOTADVERT

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big T

User:Canyouhearmenow

11:44, 2 July 2014 (UTC)

delete

Subject fails , and standards and requirements. All search material chases back to subjects own created articles in the majority of cases. Awards are not mainstream recognized, although that means very little as there are tons of awards out there. Finally the discography listed is not found in Soundscan or bar coded so I would assume they would fail as well

Deletion of Big T

WP:MUSIC||WP:NOTABILITY||WP:BLP||WP:ALBUM

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Before You Exit

User:Ubelowme

19:55, 13 June 2012 (UTC)

delete

I combed through pages of Ghits and found nothing that qualified under criterion #1 of , although there were a couple of very brief interview bits including one in Seventeen magazine (doesn't qualify under #1 as it's the band talking about itself). I could see no other criterion that potentially applied except #5 and, to the best of my knowledge, under #5, they release their own music through iTunes. This group may become more |notable in the future but there's not enough in the way of |reliable sources yet

Deletion of Before You Exit

WP:BAND||WP:N||WP:RS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Identical (film)

User:MichaelQSchmidt

01:59, 20 November 2013 (UTC)

delete

modified stance from original keep) per |research, research, research... and yes, post-1982 UPI sources should be investigated thoroughly. I have not been able to find any connection between the interview on http://www.independentfilmquarterly.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1025&Itemid=125 ''Independent Film Quarterly'' and the filmmakers or production company. And Ed Asner's words quoted in ''AV Club'' do not seem spurious. Nor does the little blurb about this film in http://www.nytimes.com/movies/movie/461977/Bleecker-Street/overview ''The New York Times'' under its original title of ''Bleecker Street'' seem fraught with cast, crew or production conflicts. That said and lacking notability for a separate article, we have enough |verifiability that this title may be redirected-after-deletion to the Ed Asner filmography and have allowed mentions in a related articles

Deletion of Identical (film)

WP:BEFORE||WP:V

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Spark: A Mother's Story of Nurturing Genius

User:David

08:48, 19 February 2018 (UTC)

delete

"I'd been holding off on providing an opinion in this AfD in the hope that it would be possible to make a neutral article that covers the book in an appropriate level of depth while avoiding the hype and BLP problems that surround it. But signs point to no: the article text avoids those problems only by being too lacking in content, the sources we have in the article are all still hype and churnalism, and the remaining non-hype source identified here (the skeptic one) is only tangentially about the book and more about Barnett and the stories that have been built around him. And having at best only one non-publicity-driven source, it doesn't meet the ""two or more"" requirement of "

Deletion of The Spark: A Mother's Story of Nurturing Genius

WP:BKCRIT

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tallahassee SC

User:onel5969

04:09, 27 August 2019 (UTC)

comment

Just like to point out to the closing editor, that not a single one of the keep !votes has provided the type of in-depth sourcing to show that any of these teams passes, , and they clearly do not pass . The only sources provided are a nice in-depth article from a non-RS source (urban pitch) and several token mentions of the Bugeaters team. The Tallahasee and AFC Mobile teams have nothing but routine local coverage. The Bugeaters turned up a whopping 8 hits, mostly local coverage, with a couple of brief mentions, the Central Texas team turned up zilch, while the Biloxi team turned up 2 local coverage articles

Deletion of Tallahassee SC

WP:GNG||WP:FOOTYN

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rockets

User:Worthawholebean

15:36, 9 December 2005 (UTC)

delete

does not seem to meet . NN

Deletion of The Rockets

WP:MUSIC

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semiotics of the structure

User:Chiswick

17:07, 20 November 2011 (UTC)

delete

google returns exactly 15 results, nearly all irrelevant; 1 by Tevet, 1 a wiki. Article seems entirely and very close to pure bafflegab, . Since it has few or no reliable independent citations (Anderson, M., Merrell, F., 1991. On Semiotic Modeling. is real but doesn't support the article's theory), delete seems unavoidable

Deletion of Semiotics of the structure

WP:OR||WP:NONSENSE

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comey memos

User:LM2000

21:11, 31 August 2017 (UTC)

merge

Not independently notable. There are a lot of sources but not much longterm notability

Deletion of Comey memos

WP:NOTNEWS

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sexuality in Star Trek

User:RFerreira

08:33, 2 December 2007 (UTC)

delete

major and original research issues, amongst other problems

Deletion of Sexuality in Star Trek

WP:SYNTH

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halvsie

User:Gavin

20:35, 27 September 2007 (UTC)

delete

per nom. The article looks like |original research

Deletion of Halvsie

WP:OR

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cassavettes

NONE

14:11, 9 April 2007 (UTC)

delete

They do assert notability in their claim to have been chosen the best local band in Boston. However that may not rise to the standards of . The article does not meet which is critical especially in regards to their claim of best local band. JBEvans

Deletion of Cassavettes

WP:MUSIC||WP:ATTRIBUTION

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journal of Global Information Management

User:Mark

00:51, 19 November 2016 (UTC)

keep

In Scopus and has a JCR impact factor, so it meets notability via

Deletion of Journal of Global Information Management

WP:NJOURNALS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdulrahman Elsamni

User:Bonadea

17:13, 17 December 2017 (UTC)

delete

"does not meet or . Having written one chapter of a EU document is not at all remarkable or grounds for notability. His Masters thesis (described in the article as ""his research"" - sorry, but no) has been quoted in a few places. Good for him, but it does not make him meet "

Deletion of Abdulrahman Elsamni

WP:NPROF||WP:GNG||WP:NPROF

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thon (river)

User:Dolovis

03:43, 21 June 2013 (UTC)

keep

per

Deletion of Thon (river)

WP:GEOLAND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macau at the 2016 Asian Beach Games

User:Comatmebro

16:10, 2 October 2016 (UTC)

delete

Could not locate third-party coverage of this specific country in the Asia Beach games. Per nom, fails and should be deleted

Deletion of Macau at the 2016 Asian Beach Games

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chronology of the Harry Potter series

User:Dalejenkins

09:49, 15 April 2009 (UTC)

delete

per and the opening argument

Deletion of Chronology of the Harry Potter series

WP:PLOT

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Eustachian tube (band)

User:JohnCD

15:19, 6 August 2011 (UTC)

delete

nowhere near the standard of

Deletion of The Eustachian tube (band)

WP:BAND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of state parties of the Democratic Party (United States)

NONE

NONE

keep

WP:NOTDIRECTORY does not fit as a criticism of this particular article, as a quick glance will show. Additionally, oppose per , and . At Wikipedia lists have a purpose. This list fits perfectly into two of the three purposes.PURP From that guidance

Deletion of List of state parties of the Democratic Party (United States)

WP:LIST||WP:MOS||WP:LISTPURP

Wikipedia:Lists

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marius Kazlauskas

User:Argyle

17:03, 19 June 2011 (UTC)

delete

Fails and

Deletion of Marius Kazlauskas

WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Burritt

User:Siva1979

12:56, 20 October 2007 (UTC)

delete

Fails . Moreover, this article does not contain any |reliable sources as well. --|S

Deletion of Bruce Burritt

WP:BIO||WP:RS||WP:ESP

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Godly Ball Religion

User:Flyguy649

05:18, 14 June 2007 (UTC)

delete

Wikipedia is |not for religions made up while bored

Deletion of The Godly Ball Religion

WP:NFT

Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SM City Caloocan

User:DAJF

05:52, 13 June 2012 (UTC)

delete

No indication or assertion of notability (#A7

Deletion of SM City Caloocan

WP:CSD

Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Rare Region 4 DVDs

User:Shawn

14:57, 25 November 2016 (UTC)

delete

Yep, an arbitrary selection of both titles ''and'' territories that violates a number of guidelines, I daresay, including

Deletion of List of Rare Region 4 DVDs

WP:NOTCATALOGUE

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Howie Wright (baseball)

User:GPL93

16:04, 26 February 2019 (UTC)

delete

Being in a school's individual hall of fame doesn't meet . Most of the sources, one of which is literally his being confirmed as dead by the federal government, are primary or don't support . best

Deletion of Howie Wright (baseball)

WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hightower (Transformers)

User:Mathewignash

12:32, 16 July 2011 (UTC)

keep

to List_of_Transformers:_Robots_in_Disguise_characters#Build_Team per #5, as this is the character page for the anime series Hightower was a character in

Deletion of Hightower (Transformers)

WP:BEFORE

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noshoring

User:Tangerines

20:03, 1 April 2008 (UTC)

delete

As per

Deletion of Noshoring

WP:NEO

Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poku short film

User:MichaelQSchmidt

13:42, 31 December 2013 (UTC)

delete

for now. Searches show this seems |TOO SOON. Allow undeletion or recreation when Malayalam-reading Wikipedians can come up with sources

Deletion of Poku short film

WP:NYF

Wikipedia:Too soon