Datasets:

research-dump

/

wiki-stance-en

like 0

Follow

Hsuvas's Research Backups 1

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Descendants of Adam and Eve

User:Cullen328

07:06, 14 November 2010 (UTC)

keep

"It seems that StAnselm's argument is . That's not enough. The article collects information from various books of the bible into a single list, and saying that someone can just look it up in the bible is like saying that anyone can just do their own research instead of reading a Wikipedia article. Why does Wikipedia exist then? We cover notable topics in Wikipedia, whether or not a given editor finds the topic personally useful. Many bible topics including this one are notable and this may include many ""minor"" or lesser known characters, but there are major ones on the list as well"

Deletion of Descendants of Adam and Eve

WP:USELESS

Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On the curb

User:Uzma

13:06, 29 August 2012 (UTC)

keep

"On the curb"" raises issues, but curb trading is more descriptive of the topic. Redirect New York Curb Exchange, curbstone broker, curb exchange, and/or the Curb to curb trading. The topic seems valid as since it appears to originate from the 1800s and has an interesting history (see my post above). The US based term may have spread to mondern day India, Poland, and Belarus: http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/27768361/foreign-investment-economic-reform-tajikistan Columbia Journal of World Business mentions ""The short duration of trading hours and its corollary of trading on the curb represent other aspects of the markets weaknesses"" for stock trading in India. In Poland, http://business.highbeam.com/435552/article-1G1-54681755/overview an article notes, ""Large blocks of securities can be traded in off-session (on the curb)."" Another article contrasts the open market with on the kerb (spelled ""kerb"") market for Belarus"

Deletion of On the curb

WP:NOTNEO

Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tito Munoz

User:Edison

20:14, 1 November 2008 (UTC)

delete

Lacks sufficient independent coverage to satisfy notability, and falls under #NEWS. The burst of coverage is far shorter than that of , say, Joe the Plumber. We do not need an article on every person who has a first name and a profession or hobby who gets mentioned by a political candidate once or twice

Deletion of Tito Munoz

WP:NOT

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GB Innomech

User:SamHolt6

22:27, 15 July 2017 (UTC)

delete

Mentioned in the sources cited, but not enough (IMO) to confer notability. Fails

Deletion of GB Innomech

WP:CORPDEPTH

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stars in astrology

User:Bearian

21:38, 13 July 2011 (UTC)

keep

it's now a |fringe topic, but up through Isaac Newton's occult studies|Isaac Newton's day it was quite the notable topic. This is a well-cited article

Deletion of Stars in astrology

WP:FRINGE

Wikipedia:Fringe theories

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve McVey

User:WilliamJE

11:20, 7 November 2019 (UTC)

delete

Fails

Deletion of Steve McVey

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philanthroteer

User:BaronVonYiffington

18:04, 23 February 2010 (UTC)

delete

"per . There are no independent sources, and the only result google brings up for ""Philanthroteer"" is the Wikipedia page for the word"

Deletion of Philanthroteer

WP:NEO

Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Art student scam

User:Tarc

16:57, 12 August 2010 (UTC)

keep

Article clearly establishes notability via several reliable sources. A bad-faith nomination in the same vein that has plagued the likes of the Israeli apartheid article over the years. A band of like-minded editors who seek to delete what they cannot water down

Deletion of Art student scam

WP:IDONTLIKEIT

Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Union of Greek Australian Students

User:Alzarian16

14:28, 24 April 2010 (UTC)

delete

Fails all relevant guidelines such as and

Deletion of National Union of Greek Australian Students

WP:ORG||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schoolgirl Apocalypse

NONE

NONE

keep

the topic meets Puchon International Fantastic Film Festival (has a Wikipedia entry) is a legitimate fantastic film festival in Seoul Korea and is noteworthy. Schoolgirl Apocalypse was developed in the IT Project and has screened at two consecutive festivals. In weeks the full lineup to the Fantasia Festival in Montreal (has a Wikipedia entry and is a notable fanastic film festival) will be announced and Schoolgirl Apocalypse will screen on July 30th of this festival as well

Deletion of Schoolgirl Apocalypse

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myatt's Fields South Estate

User:Ammarpad

14:03, 10 November 2017 (UTC)

keep

I thinks we should keep this article first for generally meeting some points of . (And it's not hard rule to meet all). Second, Wikipedia documents history for posterity, this article at least has substantial historical claims which are well sourced. This article may not have the wide that will convince everybody here to easily change their !vote due to the inherent nature of the subject. And this is clearly reflected in guideline, it is very relaxed compared to other criteria, because everything is assessed on their on merit and nature, that's why we have tens of specific guidelines and general ones, so that by weighing against varying criteria we come to reasonable conclusion of whether to include or exclude. '' —''&nbsp

Deletion of Myatt's Fields South Estate

WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GEOLAND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stay (SafetySuit song)

User:Talkingbirds

14:00, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

keep

Both songs do meet as they charted, and a Google News search brings up some interesting articles on the songs. I'm going to go ahead and add some more content to these articles once they're off AfD

Deletion of Stay (SafetySuit song)

WP:NSONGS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Ohio Patriots

User:CosmicPenguin

16:26, 18 February 2007 (UTC)

delete

There being no criteria on American football teams, one must revert to and , which this fails due to a lack of . Given the long list of articles of minor league or defunct teams, there seems to be enough critical mass to develop some sort of criteria. The matter should be brought to the Wikipedia:WikiProject_American_football| American Football Wikiproject to start developing a consensus

Deletion of Southern Ohio Patriots

WP:V||WP:N||WP:RS

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yvette Rosser (2nd nomination)

User:GPL93

22:48, 22 May 2019 (UTC)

delete

doesn't pass , WP:NACADEMIC or . Best

Deletion of Yvette Rosser (2nd nomination)

WP:GNG||WP:NAUTHOR

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asian supremacy

User:Kevin1243

10:18, 13 June 2006 (UTC)

delete

Song lyrics and an article that doesn't mention the subject are not reliable sources, so this fails by a long shot

Deletion of Asian supremacy

WP:V

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayor of Pittston, Pennsylvania

User:Bearcat

16:18, 8 January 2017 (UTC)

merge

a significantly trimmed version of this into Pittston, Pennsylvania. While it's true that the city isn't large enough to hand its mayors an automatic pass, a basic mostly unlinked list of the mayors' ''names'' isn't unreasonable information for us to maintain, so long as it's properly sourced and not a . It doesn't need to be a ''standalone'' list if there's nowhere for it to link besides the city itself and ''one'' mayor who cleared NPOL for other reasons — but it's not unreasonable for them to be listed as a subsection ''in'' the city's main article rather than as a standalone spinoff

Deletion of Mayor of Pittston, Pennsylvania

WP:NPOL||WP:HOAX

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stand-Down to Address Extremism in the Ranks

User:Sandstein

11:04, 27 June 2021 (UTC)

merge

to Aftermath of the 2021 United States Capitol attack#Department of Defense, if there are sources linking this to the attack. Otherwise fails

Deletion of Stand-Down to Address Extremism in the Ranks

WP:NOTNEWS

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of churches in Florence

User:Malinaccier

20:58, 1 December 2007 (UTC)

keep

In #Wikipedia is not a directory| it states: Wikipedia is not the yellow pages. A listing of places (like churches in my opinion) in a city would qualify as this. Despite this, the argumentst presented by all above have persuaded me to |ignore this, and change to keep

Deletion of List of churches in Florence

WP:NOT||WP:IAR

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bit (character)

User:Paulmcdonald

11:18, 29 July 2008 (UTC)

keep

"but the only reason I can think of is ""I liked bit!"" and I know that isn't really an argument... DANG"

Deletion of Bit (character)

WP:ILIKEIT

Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/White male

User:RJC

21:21, 12 November 2010 (UTC)

merge

to White people as suggested. The current article cannot help but become a . If someone wants to write about perceptions of the white male in American culture, there are a number of academic journals that exist for that purpose; some of them are even open access

Deletion of White male

WP:POVFORK

Wikipedia:Content forking

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Day Before (Film)

User:ZappaOMati

22:59, 1 June 2012 (UTC)

delete

Does not meet

Deletion of Day Before (Film)

WP:NFILMS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dirt Rocket

User:Shooterwalker

21:38, 2 September 2010 (UTC)

delete

due to lack of sources to of this topic as a character or as a consumer toy

Deletion of Dirt Rocket

WP:verify notability

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seyed Mohammad Hosseini (presenter) (2nd nomination)

User:Pharaoh

16:30, 11 December 2017 (UTC)

delete

per nom Fails and

Deletion of Seyed Mohammad Hosseini (presenter) (2nd nomination)

WP:SIGCOV||WP:CREATIVE

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DoggyRide

User:Ukexpat

15:41, 24 January 2010 (UTC)

merge

selectively with bicycle trailer. No significant coverage to indicate that it meets

Deletion of DoggyRide

WP:PRODUCT

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mmm Papi (2nd nomination)

User:Bi

12:28, 11 January 2021 (UTC)

merge

The subject seems to fail and lack |significant coverage in multiple |reliable, |independent sources

Deletion of Mmm Papi (2nd nomination)

WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IFFHS World's Best Goalkeeper

User:Northamerica1000

11:00, 13 May 2012 (UTC)

keep

per -REASON and

Deletion of IFFHS World's Best Goalkeeper

WP:DEL||WP:NRVE

Wikipedia:Deletion policy

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 77

User:Kwsn

15:40, 26 June 2007 (UTC)

delete

it's notable, not a hoax, but . Chances are though, it'll happen

Deletion of UFC 77

WP:CRYSTAL

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Smeeton

User:ScrapIronIV

20:34, 29 January 2016 (UTC)

delete

as fails , , and

Deletion of Phil Smeeton

WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC||WP:NACTOR

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Legend of Zelda: The Hero of Time (2nd nomination)

User:Piotrus

06:49, 13 June 2017 (UTC)

merge

This is cool, but... where are the references? Like EMG above, I cannot find any. As such, this fails and sadly, does not deserve an independent early. Strange, though, that a geeky topic like this didn't generate any coverage, you'd think Kotaku etc. would be all over it. I found some coverage of an audiotrack with a similar name (https://www.gizmodo.com.au/2016/12/the-legend-of-zelda-ocarina-of-time-soundtrack-is-coming-to-vinyl/), but I think that's what we are discussing here

Deletion of The Legend of Zelda: The Hero of Time (2nd nomination)

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Child of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge

User:Lugnuts

09:23, 4 July 2013 (UTC)

keep

Read . And read it again

Deletion of Child of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pravat Rout

User:Robert

19:34, 22 February 2020 (UTC)

comment

The submitter has also submitted Draft:Pravat Rout. I have declined the draft as duplicating this article, on account of the previous AFD, and as failing to address |notability for creative professions. If the article is kept, the draft should be redirected to the article. If the article is deleted, the draft may be kept for future notability

Deletion of Pravat Rout

WP:NCREATIVE

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nerrupukozhi

User:David

17:46, 20 October 2007 (UTC)

delete

a #Future films, incomplete films, and undistributed films|future film, no sources asserting the production itself is notable

Deletion of Nerrupukozhi

WP:NF

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Brandner

User:Nuttah68

12:09, 11 February 2007 (UTC)

delete

gets nowhere near meeting

Deletion of James Brandner

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malik Noureed Awan

User:davidwr

21:16, 3 October 2013 (UTC)

delete

"may ''barely'' pass otability but as written - and presumably as would need to be written for a fair article - the subject is portrayed in a bad light. This person is in that grey area between ""most people would say not quite notable, a few would say barely notable"" and ""most would say barely notable, a few would say not quite notable."" For such articles, issues can and IMHO should turn the tide towards ''delete.'' I'm open to changing my mind if there is new information, particularly from people in that industry or from that part of the world, that would indicate that he is well into ""clearly notable"" territory"

Deletion of Malik Noureed Awan

WP:N||WP:BLP

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Courtney Corey

User:Ravenswing

16:02, 7 October 2008 (UTC)

delete

Fails . The scanty Google list, devoid of |reliable sources, is a well-accustomed litany of non-notability: her personal website, followed by this Wiki article, followed by Youtube self-promotional clips, followed by Facebook, followed by Zoominfo ... toss in various Wiki mirrors, LJ and the like. Obviously she's very diligent at self-promotion, and when she achieves notability no doubt someone will write an article on her

Deletion of Courtney Corey

WP:BIO||WP:RS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Framis

User:Leuko

03:18, 31 March 2007 (UTC)

comment

Thanks for the offer, but I would prefer an independent editor to verify it. The external links provided are not , and are essentially self-published sources. Thank you for the compliment, and yes, I do have high standards for articles in WP, so I hope you do not take offense to my nomination of an article which is |unverified. Your contributions are positive from what I saw, but the only thing nagging me is that the only mention that I could find on the internet is from the Urban Dictionary (not a either), but it lists a completely different definition

Deletion of Framis

WP:RS||WP:V||WP:RS

Wikipedia:Reliable sources

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahmood Al-Hasani

User:Sir

16:20, 28 July 2014 (UTC)

delete

He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and

Deletion of Mahmood Al-Hasani

WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glenda Green

User:Orangemike

18:56, 1 November 2007 (UTC)

comment

A lot of what you've put in is from advertisements, and does not meet the need for '''|reliable sources'''. Most of this still has no real sourcing

Deletion of Glenda Green

:WP:RS

Wikipedia:Reliable sources

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Goodwin

User:Matt91486

20:54, 3 August 2009 (UTC)

keep

passes ATHLETE despite what the nominee asserts; nomination seems to be made on grounds of

Deletion of Lee Goodwin

WP:POINT

Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malissa Jones

User:Cullen328

01:38, 24 May 2011 (UTC)

delete

"as a |biography of a living person known for only one event. The brief article says that she ""made headlines"" but does not assert any ongoing notability"

Deletion of Malissa Jones

WP:BLP1E

Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruenor Battlehammer

User:Zahakiel

17:27, 3 December 2007 (UTC)

comment

"That assessment is incorrect on at least three points; a) It is not a stub, for, from a stub is ""an article containing only a few sentences of text... ... Sizable articles are usually not considered stubs, even if they lack wikification or copy editing."" b) A main character of a large number of hugely notable books cannot by any stretch of the imagination be considered merely a stock character; it's obvious a heaping helping of is coloring your vision here from the somewhat contemptuous tone you have employed. c) The notability guideline ''requires'' common sense in order to properly determine whether or not a character is presumed notable; it does not ''require'' the depth of sources you are culling from , particularly since a guideline can never trump a |policy. If it seems I am repeating myself here, at least I'm not copying-and-pasting (yet"

Deletion of Bruenor Battlehammer

WP:STUB||WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:FICT||WP:CONSENSUS

Wikipedia:Stub

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pollards Corner, Virginia

User:Smartyllama

14:29, 15 April 2020 (UTC)

keep

Passes as a legally recognized, populated place

Deletion of Pollards Corner, Virginia

WP:GEOLAND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lou Yanong

User:Whiteguru

10:45, 7 February 2021 (UTC)

delete

There are two references that ''might'' lend notability. Nonetheless, this is another case of for this starlet. Insufficient references to meet GNG

Deletion of Lou Yanong

WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Too soon

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of omnipotent fictional characters

User:Mike

11:51, 4 April 2007 (UTC)

delete

"Per the arguments above, the list would have to be renamed to something like ""List of fictional characters for whom claims of omnipotence have been made"", if it were to be maintainable. This highlights a notability concern, as there seems no reason that list is notable. Any character in a storyline can assert someone is omnipotent. If there have been reliable sources which discuss the question of which characters are regarded as omnipotent, so that belonging to this list is clearly a matter of encyclopaedic interest to comics readers, then the list might be justified. However, then inclusion would have to depend on those sources to avoid problems with "

Deletion of List of omnipotent fictional characters

WP:OR

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janna Cachola

User:Snotbot

07:08, 10 April 2012 (UTC)

comment

This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 April 10

Deletion of Janna Cachola

WP:AFDHOWTO

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorong 1 Geylang Bus Terminal

User:onel5969

22:52, 7 July 2017 (UTC)

delete

as per nom, MB and Charlesdrakew. Fails

Deletion of Lorong 1 Geylang Bus Terminal

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ordinariate for the Faithful of the Eastern Rite in Romania

[[User talk:202.124.75.250|talk]])

01:36, 26 January 2012 (UTC)

keep

"The small size now is outweighed by the historical importance, as the religious grouping of Armenian Catholics in Transylvania. A Google search finds several reliable sources, some under the name of ""Gherla Ordinariate."" Nominator should note . -- Special:Contributions/202.124.75.250|202.124.75.250"

Deletion of Ordinariate for the Faithful of the Eastern Rite in Romania

WP:BEFORE

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mp3nity

User:OSborn

03:43, 16 November 2010 (UTC)

delete

per popularity doesn't confer notability. All of the current references are to sites or pages controlled by the software's publisher. Google searches seem to bring up exclusively cracks and downloads. Page has |RS issues

Deletion of Mp3nity

WP:RS

Wikipedia:Reliable sources

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Karmazin

User:Deor

01:46, 29 January 2009 (UTC)

delete

Only 34 Google hits for the name, and not one supports any of the article's content. Thoroughly fails

Deletion of Alex Karmazin

WP:V

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SLSP LTD

User:HighKing

16:48, 25 August 2017 (UTC)

delete

Fails GNG, references fail and/or

Deletion of SLSP LTD

WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BodyBuilding on a Luna Calender

User:Glenfarclas

00:04, 15 February 2010 (UTC)

delete

as copyvio of http://www.naturalmuscle.com/html/squat_sponge.html , which I've tagged it for; if for some reason refused, then obviously '''delete''' per

Deletion of BodyBuilding on a Luna Calender

WP:NOT

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of selfie-related injuries and deaths

User:Northamerica1000

01:59, 26 August 2015 (UTC)

keep

"Per the sources presented above, the topic passes , having ""been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources"

Deletion of List of selfie-related injuries and deaths

WP:LISTN

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loco (Gobots)

User:Malkinann

00:00, 10 October 2010 (UTC)

merge

to Challenge_of_the_GoBots#Characters per

Deletion of Loco (Gobots)

WP:BEFORE

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor Power Rangers characters

User:23skidoo

04:41, 20 November 2008 (UTC)

keep

"the list and possibly merge the other two unless it can be argued they're major characters. Plenty of precedent for minor character lists for TV shows, and this is preferable to doing separate articles on each one. This is an example of a topic that faces discrimination by Wikipedia because it's a recent media topic and therefore is unlikely to have much third-party coverage. However the existence of the characters can be verified by checking the shows cited, therefore ""verifiability, not truth"" is satisfied. Obviously if there happens to be any or going on then that should be trimmed, but that's a content issue. The Wikiproject under which this article fall should be contacted and encouraged to add sources that might exist"

Deletion of List of minor Power Rangers characters

WP:SYNTH||WP:OR

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tasha Chiu

User:Thparkth

22:24, 18 November 2015 (UTC)

keep

for two reasons. Firstly, because of the referenced Langley Advance article http://www.canada.com/langleyadvance/news/story.html?id=e8ecdd1f-8c17-4988-9a64-8ccbefc45102, an independent reliable source, which when combined with the less-substantial Georgia Straight article http://www.straight.com/article-92090/call-of-the-wild and a little benefit-of-the-doubt, just about meets . Secondly, because in my opinion a television presenter (note, not producer) who is known and recognizable to potentially millions of people (the Greater Vancouver area, with a population of around three million) is notable

Deletion of Tasha Chiu

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Parker (transsexual)

User:Bec

04:56, 27 December 2006 (UTC)

delete

in my view does not meet

Deletion of Lucy Parker (transsexual)

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of characters in The Nightmare Before Christmas

User:Otherlleft

17:35, 11 November 2008 (UTC)

keep

per

Deletion of List of characters in The Nightmare Before Christmas

WP:CLN

Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Chamber of Commerce in Belgium

User:Blaxthos

14:19, 13 October 2007 (UTC)

delete

Fails , no reliable secondary sources

Deletion of American Chamber of Commerce in Belgium

WP:CORP

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian Valentin

User:Nfitz

17:18, 29 June 2008 (UTC)

keep

"Meets criteria of ""''Competitors who have competed in a fully professional league''"" as he plays in the MLS Reserve Division which is fully professional"

Deletion of Julian Valentin

WP:ATHLETE

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ernandes Dias Luz

User:Alzarian16

09:42, 29 September 2010 (UTC)

keep

Meets by a fair distance with the new sources and the information is verifiable

Deletion of Ernandes Dias Luz

WP:NSPORTS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keychain Logistics

User:HighKing

20:35, 17 January 2017 (UTC)

delete

Fails GNG and . Probably

Deletion of Keychain Logistics

WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boys Generally Asian

User:Rockysmile11

09:18, 27 March 2017 (UTC)

comment

iTunes is NOT a national music chart and cannot be used to meet , and as

Deletion of Boys Generally Asian

WP:BAND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardiology (album)

User:FreeRangeFrog

18:56, 5 February 2009 (UTC)

delete

Band is notable, but without a valid source (and that single link isn't) this is just at best. Delete so it can be created when and if the album is announced

Deletion of Cardiology (album)

WP:CRYSTAL

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed AlNeaimy

[[User talk:2601:188:180:11F0:65F5:930C:B0B2:CD63|talk]])

22:27, 19 April 2018 (UTC)

delete

per nom. Very passing mention as a co-creator of limited interest technology, with no biographical information contained in any of the sources. Lacks substantial coverage. is a kind assessment. Special:Contributions/2601:188:180:11F0:65F5:930C:B0B2:CD63|2601:188:180:11F0:65F5:930C:B0B2:CD63

Deletion of Ahmed AlNeaimy

WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Too soon

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Scottish Premiership clubs

User:JMHamo

11:41, 27 August 2013 (UTC)

delete

per

Deletion of List of Scottish Premiership clubs

WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Too soon

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Costello (baseball)

User:4meter4

04:11, 27 November 2019 (UTC)

keep

While it fails it passes with the significant coverage in the ''Hartford Courant'' and ''Keene Sentinel''. An SNG does not trump GNG

Deletion of Ryan Costello (baseball)

WP:NBASE||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Torquay United F.C. season 1996–97

User:BigDom

21:42, 8 September 2010 (UTC)

keep

articles need referencing and improving; there is no doubt that the sources to do this exist (perhaps a thorough check was in order here). The NSPORT guideline is outrageously US-centric when it comes to individual seasons - the GNG is the only thing that matters here

Deletion of Torquay United F.C. season 1996–97

WP:BEFORE

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamil gangs

User:Walton_monarchist89

16:05, 5 March 2007 (UTC)

delete

unsourced and |unattributed, reads like |original research, possibly also a |POV fork. Potentially inflammatory content means that this page should not be given the benefit of the doubt

Deletion of Tamil gangs

WP:ATT||WP:OR||WP:POVFORK

Wikipedia:Attribution

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Object Prevalence

User:Ihcoyc

14:21, 6 October 2008 (UTC)

comment

"The article strikes me as so seriously lacking in context that I could easily understand why other editors might find it unintelligible. It's uncertain from the article whether this is some kind of management philosophy or a product of some sort.On the merits of the subject itself, I would question whether we really need detailed articles about every label given to a management plan or ""model"" for supervising computer programmers or making collective programming more efficient. These things tend to be rather esoteric, and of limited interest outside of corporate computer programming, which may make them |not notable. They also need to be carefully watched for |commercial |conflict of interest, as well as |bad corporate prose style. Not sure whether Slashdot counts as a |reliable source, either; no opinion about the IBM site.That said, '''no opinion''' about the merits of the current article. It surely can be improved, and be clearer as to what it's about, so I'm willing to wait. Note also that it should move to Object prevalence if kept. That is what the Prevayler article links to, whatever that is"

Deletion of Object Prevalence

WP:N||WP:SPAM||WP:COI||WP:BOLLOCKS||WP:RS

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalubowila

[[User talk:Lourdes|'''Lourdes''']]

04:14, 9 September 2016 (UTC)

keep

and close... The nominator needs to undertake a standard recommended search |BEFORE nominating articles like this on Afd. Even a https://www.google.com/?gfe_rd=cr&ei=pDbSV8jiBcGL8Qep5b3gCw#q=%22Kalubowila%22&tbm=nws Google news search would have been enough. Pinging {{u|Northamerica1000}} on this (as he relisted this

Deletion of Kalubowila

WP:BEFORE

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Identification in Burkean rhetoric

User:StraussInTheHouse

15:20, 30 March 2019 (UTC)

delete

completely |original research framed as an essay, something |Wikipedia is not for

Deletion of Identification in Burkean rhetoric

WP:OR||WP:NOTESSAY

Wikipedia:No original research

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeev Schwartz

User:Clean

20:49, 13 May 2018 (UTC)

delete

Fails and , maybe a case of

Deletion of Zeev Schwartz

WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Blumenthal

User:Pegnawl

16:56, 26 May 2018 (UTC)

keep

Notable per RS and . Activity of nominator a bit erratic; how can someone attain autoconfirm status such that they're nominating for deletion and publishing new entries within an hour of account creation

Deletion of Adam Blumenthal

WP:BASIC

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rand Kannenberg

User:OlEnglish

01:44, 14 July 2009 (UTC)

delete

per DoriSmith officially, and personally because of the incessant promotion by suspected sockpuppets/meatpuppets

Deletion of Rand Kannenberg

WP:SPA

Wikipedia:Single-purpose account

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of eponymous albums

User:Pax

08:42, 23 April 2007 (UTC)

delete

"This is a good example of stuff that is true but holds no encyclopedic value (""That something is 100% true does not automatically mean it is suitable for inclusion in Wikipedia"" #INDISCRIMINATE"

Deletion of List of eponymous albums

WP:NOT

Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus Christ: The Musical

User:Springnuts

11:44, 26 July 2009 (UTC)

keep

WP:ITSFUNNY|Some people think it's funny, and |I don't like it - so what? It is |sourced

Deletion of Jesus Christ: The Musical

WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:RS

Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space Captain Smith

User:Doctorfluffy

20:42, 8 July 2008 (UTC)

delete

Fails . I couldn't find significant coverage in reliable secondary sources independent of the subject. Obvious at work as well

Deletion of Space Captain Smith

WP:BK||WP:COI

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S/V Rembrandt van Rijn

User:ÄDA

15:57, 23 December 2013 (UTC)

keep

Neither ship is small, actually they are quite large for sailing vessels. ''Noorderlicht'' is a former naval ship of Germany and thus notable as per . ''Rembrandt van Rijn'' is notable as one of the last veteran sailing ships still working. I can't find that the fact that these ships are operated by a cruise line featured disproportionally in the articles

Deletion of S/V Rembrandt van Rijn

WP:MILUNIT

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diego Gonzalez (fighter)

User:Luchuslu

18:07, 14 January 2013 (UTC)

delete

No top-tier fights, so he fails . Very few sources, very little context given besides the fight table

Deletion of Diego Gonzalez (fighter)

WP:NMMA

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omgsplosion

User:Royboycrashfan

06:31, 30 March 2006 (UTC)

delete

WP:CRUFT|crufty |neologism

Deletion of Omgsplosion

WP:NEO

Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fame Fashion and Creative Excellence (FFACE)

User:Bearian

20:27, 9 April 2014 (UTC)

delete

based on what I've seen since my comment, this is mere |spam being pushed by |advocates

Deletion of Fame Fashion and Creative Excellence (FFACE)

WP:SPAM||WP:SOAP

Wikipedia:Spam

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of education articles by country

User:Themfromspace

04:21, 29 September 2009 (UTC)

delete

as a list trying to imitate the function of a category. The |self-reference makes the topic impossible to discuss from an encyclopedic perspective

Deletion of List of education articles by country

WP:SELFREF

Wikipedia:Manual of Style

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zodiac Records

User:Jasynnash2

10:56, 22 July 2008 (UTC)

delete

none of the companies mentioned seem to pass . The article with its current external links seems to function more as a sneaky advert for the swiss company (though I'm guessing that is probably unintentional

Deletion of Zodiac Records

WP:CORP

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Name Is Kay

[[User talk:TenPoundHammer|What did I screw up now?]])

03:41, 12 May 2012 (UTC)

keep

charting at http://www.allmusic.com/album/my-name-is-kay-ep-r2229161/charts-awards #63 on the Canadian Hot 100, a major chart, is sufficient to meet . '''Ten Pound Hammer

Deletion of My Name Is Kay

WP:BAND

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hermit Thrush (band)

User:jonny

06:40, 31 January 2008 (UTC)

merge

"with Dispatch (band). states that band which contain ""at least one member who was once a part of or later joined a band that is otherwise notable"" are notable, but goes on to note that ""it is often most appropriate to use redirects in place of articles on side projects, early bands and such."" Given that this band seems to be a temporary gig and is only significant in light of the fact that both members went on to play in Dispatch, the information should be included there unless it outgrows the article. The stylistic differences between the bands, while objectively interesting, does not mean that information on both can't be included in one place--I would actually argue that it adds ''more'' to the target article by illustrating Dispatch's influences"

Deletion of Hermit Thrush (band)

WP:MUSIC

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loys of Gruuthuse

User:Stifle

00:35, 11 April 2006 (UTC)

delete

per

Deletion of Loys of Gruuthuse

WP:V

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Whittet

User:Eggishorn

15:46, 9 December 2013 (UTC)

keep

while does not meet notability guidelines as a filmmaker, he meets as a doctor from the articles SisterTwister found

Deletion of David Whittet

WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lune Zoldark

User:Gavin

22:54, 3 January 2008 (UTC)

delete

as article fails , and and #PLOT; there are no sober arguments for keeping this fancruft

Deletion of Lune Zoldark

WP:V||WP:FICT||WP:WAF||WP:NOT

Wikipedia:Verifiability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexz Johnson (album)

User:Astronaut

05:58, 5 June 2009 (UTC)

delete

No release date, no title, undecided track listing, poor sources = easily fails

Deletion of Alexz Johnson (album)

WP:MUSIC

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Tysons, Virginia

User:7

11:16, 30 June 2019 (UTC)

keep

Well sourced article. reserve, ot paper, , EXIST, igcov. And no compliance with efore {{mdash}} nominator has ignored the article as it is and as it may become. No policy based or factually based reason for deletion proposed. Wikipedia:I just don't like it is not a reason to delete

Deletion of List of tallest buildings in Tysons, Virginia

WP:P||WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:NEXIST||WP:S||WP:B

Wikipedia:Portal

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goosefoot (Chicago restaurant)

user:Andrew

11:55, 17 November 2020 (UTC)

keep

"There is extensive coverage of this place such as https://www.papercitymag.com/culture/goosefoot-chicago-restaurant-byob-husband-wife-team/ The Small BYOB Restaurant That’s Worth Flying to Chicago For. See and : ""''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page"

Deletion of Goosefoot (Chicago restaurant)

WP:NEXIST||WP:ATD

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liu Haocun

User:TheGreatWikiLord

17:10, 24 March 2019 (UTC)

delete

Agree with{{u|Timmyshin}}'s explanation and it is

Deletion of Liu Haocun

WP:TOOSOON

Wikipedia:Too soon

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shirleene Robinson

User:AlanS

11:12, 20 August 2014 (UTC)

delete

Most of the material I could find when searching for her were books she was involved in writing or journal articles she had written. Fails and

Deletion of Shirleene Robinson

WP:PROF||WP:GNG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esoh Omogba

User:Joseph2302

11:25, 11 November 2017 (UTC)

delete

fails and

Deletion of Esoh Omogba

WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ukrainian Internet Exchange

User:Cunard

04:48, 17 March 2010 (UTC)

delete

per the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-press+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Ukrainian+Internet+Exchange%22 lack of |reliable sources. This topic fails Wikipedia:Notability

Deletion of Ukrainian Internet Exchange

WP:RS

Wikipedia:Reliable sources

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K.V.Dominic

User:Ragib

14:04, 8 October 2010 (UTC)

delete

Fails ,

Deletion of K.V.Dominic

WP:N||WP:PROF

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jana Sanchez (2nd nomination)

User:KidAd

02:13, 4 May 2021 (UTC)

delete

Twice-unsuccessful congressional candidate fails . If there is no clear consensus to delete, '''Redirect''' to either of the main election pages

Deletion of Jana Sanchez (2nd nomination)

WP:NPOL

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashworth Harold McGee

User:DARTH

18:28, 2 February 2011 (UTC)

delete

per , as non-notable

Deletion of Ashworth Harold McGee

WP:BIO

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omega Theta Alpha

User:TerriersFan

18:26, 25 November 2009 (UTC)

delete

lacks the sources to meet . Purely local fraternity. Being a part of the SFUO means nothing significant

Deletion of Omega Theta Alpha

WP:ORG

Wikipedia:Notability

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Body core

User:Lankiveil

07:33, 12 January 2008 (UTC)

delete

I'm not sure that they meet

Deletion of Body core

WP:MUSIC

Wikipedia:Notability